The Enzymes VOLUME IV
HYDR OLYSIS Other C-N Bonds Phosphate Esters Third Edition
CONTRIBUTORS CHRISTIAN B. ANFINSEN ...
177 downloads
2187 Views
12MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
The Enzymes VOLUME IV
HYDR OLYSIS Other C-N Bonds Phosphate Esters Third Edition
CONTRIBUTORS CHRISTIAN B. ANFINSEN ALBERT0 BERNARDI
I. R. LEHMAN ALTON MEISTER
GIORGIO BERNARDI LARRY G. BUTLER NATHAN CITRI
ROBERT C. NORDLIE MARIAN ORLOWSKI S. PONTREMOLI
F. ALBERT COTTON
TED W. REID F. J. REITHEL
PEDRO CUATRECASAS GEORGE I. DRUMMOND FUJI0 EGAMI H. 9.FERNLEY STANDISH C. HARTMAY EDWARD E. HAZEN, J R . VISCENT P. HOLLANDER B. L. HORECKER JOHN JOSSE M. LASKOWSKI, SR.
FREDERIC M. RICHARDS C. H. SWELTER HIROSHI TANIUCHI TSUNEKO UCHIDA IRWIN B. WILSON SIMON C. K. WONG JOHN C. WRISTON, JR. HAROLD W. WYCKOFF MASANOBU YAMAMOTO
c. I. ZIELKE ADVISORY BOARD C. B. ANFINSEN I. R. LEHMAN
ALTON MEISTER STANFORD MOORE
THE ENZYMES Edited by PAUL D . BOYER Molecular Biology Institute and Department of Chemistry University of California Los Angeles, California
Volume IV HYDROLYSIS Other C-jV Bonds Phosphate Esters
T H I R D EDITION
A C A D E M I C P R E S S New York and London
1971
COPYRIGHT 0 1971, BY ACADEMIC PRESS, INC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED NO PART OF THIS BOOK MAY BE REPRODUCED IN ANY FORM, BY PHOTOSTAT, MICROFILM, RETRIEVAL SYSTEM, OR ANY OTHER MEANS, WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHERS.
ACADEMIC PRESS,
M C . 1 1 1 Fifth Avenue, New York, New York 10003
United Kingdom Edition published by ACADEMIC PRESS, INC. (LONDON) Berkeley Square House, London WlX 6BA
LIBRARY OF
CONGRESS CATALOG CARD
LTD.
NUMBER: 75 - 1 1 7107
PRINTED IN THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
Contents xi xv
Lisl oj Contributors
P rejuce Contents of Other Volumes 1.
xvii
Ureaser
F. J. REITHEL I. Introduction 11. Isolation and Purification of Jack Bean Urease 111. Molecular Properties IV. Ureases from Other Sources V. Catalytic Properties VI. Summary
2.
1 2
5 13 15 20
Penicillinase and Other p-lactarnares NAT'IAN
CITRI
23 27
I. Introduction 11. Molecular Properties 111. Catalytic Properties IV. Conformation and Function V. Immunological Studies
35
44 46
3. Purine, Purine Nucleoside, and Purine Nucleotide Aminohydrolases C. L. ZIELKE AND C. H. SVELTER I. Introduction 11. Adenine Arninohydrolase 111. Adenosine Aminohydrolasc. IV. 5'-Adenylic Acid Aminohydrolase V. Adenine Nucleoside and Nucleotide Aminohydrolase (Nonspecific) VI. Guanine Aminohydrolase VII. Guanosine Aminohydrolase V
47 51 54
64 73 76 77
vi
CONTENTS
4. Glutaminase and y-Glutamyltransferawr
STANDISH C. HARTMAN I. Introduction 11. Glutaminase of Escherichia coli 111. Other Glutaminases and Glutamyltransferase IV. Concluding Remarks
5.
79
80 93 98
L-Asparaginase
JOHN C. WRISTON,JR. I. Introduction 11. Occurrence 111. Guinea Pig Serum Asparaginase IV. Escherichin coli Asparaginase V. Other Asparaginases VI. Physiological Properties
6.
101 102 105 107 116 117
Enzymology of Pyrrolidone Carboxylic Acid
MARIANORLOWSKIAND ALTON,MEISTER I. Introduction 11. Detection and Determination of Pyrrolidone Carboxylic Acid 111. Natural Occurrence of Pyrrolidone Carboxylic Acid IV. Nonenzymic Formation of Pyrrolidone Carboxylic Acid from Glutamic Acid, Glutamine, and Other Compounds V. Enzymic Formation of Pyrrolidone Carboxylic Acid from Glutamic Acid VI. Enzymic Formation of Pyrrolidone Carboxylic Acid from Glutamine and Glutaminyl Peptides VII. Enzymic Formation of Pyrroline Carboxylic Acid froni y-Glutamyl Amino Acids VIII. Enzymic Formation of Derivatives of Pyrrolidone Carboxylic Acid IX. Pyrrolidone Carboxylyl Peptidase X. Pyrrolidone Carboxylate Metabolism
7.
124 125 127 130 133 139 142 146 147 149
Staphylococcal Nuclease X-Ray Structure
F. ALBERTCOTTON A N D EDWARDE. HAZEN,JR. I. Introduction 11. The Conformation of the Peptide Chain 111. The Binding of Thyniidine-3’,5-Diphosphate and Calcium Ion IV. Some Correlation Studies in Solution V. Some Tentative Comments on Mechanism and Plans for Future Studies
153 159 163 172 174
CONTENTS
8.
vii
Staphylococcal Nuclease, Chemical Properties and Catalysis
CHRISTIAN B. ANFINSEN,PEDROCUATRECASAS, AND HIROSHI TANIUCHI I. Introduction 11. Isolation 111. Covalent Structurc IV. Behavior in Solution V. Substrate Specificity and Catalytic Mechanisms VI. Stereochemical Probes of the Active Site VII. Coniplementation of Fragments VIII. Synthetic Analogs
9.
177 178 180 183 185 195 196 199
Microbial Ribonucleaser with Special Reference to RNarer TI, T2, N,, and U,
TSUNEKO UCHIDA AND FUJIOEGAMI I. Introduction 11. Fungal RNases TI, T,,N1, U,, and U, 111. Other Microbial RNases of Special Interest IV. List of Microbial RNases
10.
205 208 239 248
Bacterial Deoxyribonuclearer
I. R. LEHMAN I. Introduction 11. Exonucleases 111. Endonucleases 1 1.
25 1 252 259
Spleen Acid Deoxyribonucleare
GIORGIO BERNARDI I. Introduction 11. Physical and Chemical Properties 111. Catalytic Properties IV. Distribution, Intracellular Localization, and Biological Role
12.
27 1 272 276 285
Deoxyribonuclease I
>I LASKOWSKI, . SR. I. Introduction 11. Chemical Nature 111. Active Center IV. Inhibitor
289 292 297 299
CONTENTS
viii V. Ions
VI. Kinetica VII. Specificity VIII. Physiological Role
302 303 30% 310
13. Venom Exonuclease
M. LASKOWSKI, SR. I. Introduction 11. Chemical Nature of the Enryme 111. Structural Characteristics of Substrates AIfecting Susceptibility IV. Venom Exonuclease as a Tool for Structural Determination V. Other Venom Enzymes That Hydrolyze Phosphate Esters
14.
313 317 319 324 328
Spleen Acid Exonuclease
ALBERTO BERNARDI AND GIORGIO BERNARDI I. Introduction 11. Isolation, Purity, and Physical Properties 111. Catalytic Properties IV. Distribution and Intracellular Localization
15.
329 330 331 336
Nucleotide Phorphomonoesterases
GEORGE I. DRUMMOND AND MASANOBU YAMAMOTO I. 5’-Nucleotidase 11. 3’-Nucleotidase
16.
337 352
Nucleoside Cyclic Phosphate Diesterases
GEORGE I. DRUMMOND AND MASANOBU YAMAMOTO I. Introduction 11. Ribonucleoside 2’,3’-Cyclic Phosphate Diesterase with 3’-Nucleotidase Activity from Microorganisms 111. Ribonucleoside 2’,3‘-Cyclic Phosphate Diesterase from Vertebrate Nerve IV. Nucleoside 3’,5’-Cyclic Phosphate Diesterase 17.
355
356 363 365
E. coli Alkaline Phorphatase
TEDW. REIDAND IRWINB. WILSON I. Introduction 11. Molecular Properties 111. Catalytic Properties
373 377 392
CONTENTS
18.
ix
Mammalian Alkaline Phosphaturer
H. N. FERNLEY I. Introduction 11. Molecular Properties 111. Catalytic Properties IV. Mechanism of Enzymic Action 19.
417 422 428 443
Acid Phorphataser
VINCENTP. HOLLANDER I. Introduction 11. Prostatic Acid Phosphatase 111. Red Cell Acid Phosphatase IV. Liver Acid Phosphatase V. Spleen Acid Phosphatase VI. Acid Phosphatase in Serum VII. Miscellaneous Sources
20.
450 455 477
484 493 495 496
Inorganic Pyrophosphatase of Elcherichia coli
JOHN JOSSEAND SIMONC. K. WONG I. Introduction 11. Molecular Properties 111. Catalytic Properties IV. Conclusions
21.
499 501 518 528
Yeast and Other Inorganic Pyrophosphataser
LARRY G. BUTLER I. Introduction 11. Yeast Inorganic Pyrophosphatase 111. Other Inorganic Pyrophosphatases
22.
529 530 539
Glucose-6-Phosphatase, Hydrolytic and Synthetic Activities
ROBERTC. NORDLIE I. Introduction 11. Molecular Properties 111. Catalytic Properties IV. Metabolic Roles and Regulation, in V i m .4ppendix
543 553 565 596
800
CONTENTS
X
23.
F~ctose-1 ,bDiphosphatases
S. PONTREMOLI AND B. L. HORECKER I. Introduction 11. Liver FDPase 111. Kidney FDPase IV. Muscle FDPase V. Fructosediphosphatase of Candida utilis VI. FDPases in Other Microorganisms VII. FDPases in Higher Plants and Blue-Green Algae VIII. Summary and Conclusions
24.
612 616 629 632 635 638 640 644
Bovine Pancreatic Ribonuclease
FREDERIC M. RICHARDS AND HAROLD W. WYCKOFF I. Introduction 11. Isolation and Chromatography 111. Structure IV. Modification of Covalent Structure V. Molecular Properties VI. Catalytic Properties
647 649 653 669 705 746
Author Indez
807
Subject Indez
853
List
of Contributors
Numbers in parentheses indicate the pages on which the authors’ contributions begin.
CHRISTIAN B. ANFINSEN (177) , Laboratory of Chemical Biology, National Institute of Arthritis and Metabolic Diseases, National Institutes of Health, Bethesda, Maryland ALBERT0 BERNARDI (329), Section on Molecular Genetics, National Institute of Child Health and Human Development, National Institutes of Health, Bethesda, Maryland GIORGIO BERNARDI (271, 329), Laboratoire de GhQtique MolCculaire, Institut de Biologie MolQculaire, Facult6 des Sciences, Paris, France LARRY G . BUTLER (5291, Department of Biochemistry, Purdue University, Lafayette, Indiana NATHAN CITRI (23), Institute of Microbiology, The Hebrew University, Hadassah Medical School, Jerusalem, Israel F. ALBERT COTTON (153), Department of Chemistry, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, Massachusetts PEDRO CUATRECASAS (177), Laboratory of Chemical Biology, National Institute of Arthritis and Metabolic Diseases, National Institutes of Health, Bethesda, Maryland GEORGE I. DRUMMOND (337, 355), Department of Pharmacology, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, Canada F U J I 0 EGAMI (205), Department of Biophysics and Biochemistry, Faculty of Science, The University of Tokyo, Hongo, Tokyo, Japan
H. N. FERNLEY (4171, Department of Biochemistry, Institute of Orthopaedics, Stanmore, Middlesex, United Kingdom xi
xii
LIST OF CONTRIBUTORS
STANDISH C. HARTMAN (79), Department of Chemistry, Boston University, Boston, Massachusetts EDWARD E. HAZEN, J R . (153), Department of Chemistry, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, Massachusetts VINCENT P. HOLLANDER (449), Research Institute for Skeletomuscular Diseases, Hospital for Joint Diseases and Medical Center, New York, New York B. L. HORECKER (611), Department of Molecular Biology, Division of Biological Sciences, Albert Einstein College of Medicine, Bronx, New York JOHN JOSSE (499), Syntex Institute of Molecular Biology, Palo Alto, California
M. LASKOWSKI, SR. (289, 313), The Laboratory of Enzymology, Roswell Park Memorial Institute, Buffalo, New York I. R. LEHMAN (251), Department of Biochemistry, Stanford University School of Medicine, Stanford, California ALTON MEISTER (123), Department of Biochemistry, Cornell University Medical College, New York, New York ROBERT C. NORDLIE (543), Guy and Bertha Ireland Laboratory, Department of Biochemistry, University of North Dakota Medical School, Grand Forks, North Dakota MARIAN ORLOWSKI (123), Department of Biochemistry, Cornell University Medical College, New York, New York
S. PONTREMOLI (611), Institute of Biological Chemistry, University of Ferrara, Ferrara, Italy
TED W. REID* (373), Department of Chemistry, University of Colorado, Boulder, Colorado F. J . REITHEL ( l ) , Department of Chemistry, University of Oregon, Eugene, Oregon FREDERIC M. RICHARDS (647), Department of Molecular Biophysics and Biochemistry, Yale University, New Haven, Connecticut
* Present address : Departments of Ophthalmology, Molecular Biophysics, and Biochemistry, Yale University School of Medicine, New Haven, Connecticut.
LIST O F CONTRIBUTORS
xiii
C. H. SUELTER (47), Department of Biochemistry, Michigan State University, East Lansing, Michigan HIROSHI TANIUCHI (177), Laboratory of Chemical Biology, National Institute of Arthritis and Metabolic Diseases, National Institutes of Health, Bethesda, Maryland TSUNEKO UCHIDA (205), Department of Biophysics and Biochemistry, Faculty of Science, The University of Toyko, Hongo, Tokyo, Japan lRWIN B. WILSON (373), Department of Chemistry, University of Colorado, Boulder, Colorado SIMON C. K. WONG (499), Department of Biological Chemistry, Harvard Medical School, Boston, Massachusetts JOHN C. WRISTON, J R . (101), Department of Chemistry, University of Delaware, Newark, Delaware HAROLD W. WYCKOFF (647), Department of Molecular Biophysics and Biochemistry, Yale University, New Haven, Connecticut MASANOBU YAMAMOTO (337, 355), Fisheries Research Board of Canada, Vancouver Laboratory, Vancouver, Canada. C. L. ZIELKE (47), Department of Biochemistry, Michigan State University, East Lansing, Michigan
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Preface This volume, the fourth of the treatise, continues the coverage of enzymes catalyzing hydrolyses. More is known about the hydrolases than any other group of enzymes. They thus command a major space allotment. Volume I11 was devoted entirely to enzymes catalyzing hydrolysis of peptide bonds. This volume deals principally with enzymes catalyzing hydrolysis of phosphate ester bonds. Also included is a shorter portion on the hydrolysis of other C-N bonds. Coverage of hydrolysis will be completed with Volume V, which includes cleavage of sulfate and carboxylate esters and both hydrolysis and phosphorolysis of glycosidic bonds. I n these volumes an attempt is made to present an authoritative compilation for those enzymes about which considerable information is now available. Hence, a number of lesser studied enzymes are not included, although often information is given about them in chapters covering their better studied relatives. Authors have responded well to the guideline limiting coverage to molecular aspects of the enzyme or of the reaction catalyzed. As a result some chapters are short. In some instances, however, the amount of information is striking. For two of the phosphodiesterases, pancreatic ribonuclease and staphylococcal nuclease, this volume includes the latest structural information from X-ray analysis. Pancreatic ribonuclease is indeed one of the best understood of all enzymes; information contained in the chapter dealing with this enzyme has broad implications. With this volume we are approaching midstream in planning the treatise. Occasionally I have pondered my wisdom, or lack thereof, in assuming the editorial responsibility. But the completion of each volume is a gratifying experience, and the quality of the product an addicting reward. For planning this volume, as well as Volume 111, thanks are due to xv
xvi
PREFACE
the Advisory Board members C. B. Anfinsen, I. R. Lehman, Alton Meister, and Stanford Moore. For the quality of the volume, much appreciation is extended to the staff of Academic Press, as well as to Lyda Boyer for her editorial assistance. Their interest, enthusiasm, and encouragement were invaluable assets. PAULD. BOYER
Contents of Other Volumes Volume I: Structure and Control
X-Ray Crystallography and Enzyme Structure David Eisenberg Chemical Modification by Active-Site-Directed Reagents Elliott Shuw Chemical Modification as a Probe of Structure and Function Louis A . Cohen Multienzyme Complexes Lester J . Reed and David J . Cox Genetic Probes of Enzyme Structure Milton J . Schlesinger Evolution of Enzymes Emil L . Smith The Molecular Basis for Enzyme Regulation D . E . Koshland, Jr. Mechanisms of Enzyme Regulation in Metabolism E . R . Stadtman Enzymes as Control Elements in Metabolic Regulation Daniel E . Atkinson Author Index-Subject
Index xvii
xviii
CONTENTS OF OTHER VOLUMES
Volume II: Kinetics and Mechanism
Steady State Kinetics W . W . Cleland Rapid Reactions and Transient States Gordon B. Hammes and Paul R. Schimmel Stereospecificity of Enzymic Reactions G . PopjcEk Proximity Effects and Enzyme Catalysis Thomas C . Bruice Enzymology of Proton Abstraction and Transfer Reactions Irwin A . Rose Kinetic Isotope Effects in Enzymic Reactions J . H . Richards Schiff Base Intermediates in Enzyme Catalysis Esmond E. Snell and Samuel J . Di Mari Some Physical Probes of Enzyme Structure in Solution Serge N . Timasheff Metals in Enzyme Catalysis Albert S. Mildvan Author Index-Subject Index
Volume 111: Hydrolysis: Peptide Bonds
Carboxypeptidase A Jean A. Hartsuclc and William AT. Lipscomb Carboxypeptidase B J . E . Folk Leucine Aminopeptidase and Other N-Terminal Exopeptidases Robert J . DeLange and Emil L. Smith Pepsin Joseph S. Fruton
CONTENTS OF OTHER VOLUMES
Chymotrypsinogen : X-Ray Structure J . Kraut The Structure of Chymotrypsin D . M . Blow Chymotrypsin-Chemical George P . Hess
Properties and Catalysis
Trypsin B . Keil Thrombin and Prothrombin Staffan Magnusson Pancreatic Elastase B. S. Hartley and D . iM.Shotton Protein Proteinase Inhibitors-Molecular Aspects Michael Laskozcski, Jr. and Robert W . Sealock Cathepsins and Kinin-Forming and -Destroying Enzymes Lowell M . Greenbaum Papain, X-Ray Structure J . Drenth, J . iV. Jansonius, R. Koekoek, and B. G. Wolthers Papain and Other Plant Sulfhydryl Proteolytic Enzymes A . N . Glazer and Emil L. Smith Subtilisin : X-Ray Structure J. Kraut Subt,ilisins: Primary Structure, Chemical and Physical Properties Francis S. Marleland, Jr. and Emil L. Smith Streptococcal Proteinase Teh-Yung Liu and S. D . Elliott The Collagenases Sam Seifter and Elvin Harper Clostripain William M . iMitchel1 and William F . Harrington
XiX
xx
CONTENTS OF OTHER VOLUMES
Other Bacterial, Mold, and Yeast Proteases Hiroshi Matsubara and Joseph Feder Author Index-Subject
Index
Volume V (Tentative): Hydrolysis (Sulfate Esters, Carbowyl Esters, Glycoside Bonds) , Phosphorolysis, and Hydration
Plant and Animal Amylases John A . Thoma, Joseph E . Spradlin, and Stephen Dygert Neuraminidases Alfred Gottschalk and A . S . Bhargava Cellulases
D. R . Whitaker The Hydrolysis of Sulfate Esters A . B. Roy Arylsulfatases R. G. Nicholls and A . B. R o y Phage Lysozymes and Other Lytic Enzymes Akira Tsugita Bacterial and Mold Amylases Toshio Takagi, Hiroko Toda, and Toshizo Isemura Carboxylic Ester Hydrolases Klaus Krisch Hyaluronidases Karl Meyer Phospholipases Donald J . Hanahan Glycogen and Starch Debranching Enzymes E . Y . C . Lee and W . J. Whelan Yeast and Neurospora Invertases J . Oliver Lampen
CONTENTS OF OTHER VOLUMES
xxi
L-Glucan Phosphorylases-Chemical and Physical Basis of Catalysis and Regulation Donald J . Graves and Jerry H . Wang Acetylcholinesterase Harry C . Froede and Irwin B. Wilson Dehydrations Requiring Vitamin H,z-Coenzyme Robert H . Abeles Dehydration in Nucleotide Linked Deoxysugar Synthesis L. Glaser and H . Zarkowsky Aconitase Jenny Pickworth Glusker P-Hydroxydecanoyl Thioester Dehydrase Konrad Bloch Purine Nucleoside Phosphorylase R . E . Parks, Jr. and R . P . Agarwal Enolase Finn Wold Fumarase and Crotonase Robert I,. Hill and John W . Teipel 6-Phosphogluconic and Related Dehydrases W . A . Wood Carbonic Anhydrase S . Lindskog, L . E . Henderson, K . K . Kannan, A . Liljas, P . 0 . Nyman. and B . Strandberg Author Index-Subject
Index
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
The Enzymes VOLUME IV
H Y D R O L YSlS Other C-N Bonds Phosphate Esters Third Edition
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Ureases F. J . REITHEL I . Introduction . . . . . . . . I1. Isolation and Purification of Jack Bean Urease Enzymic Activity Measurement . . . I11. Molecular Properties . . . . . . A . Molecular Weight Determinations . B . Other Physical Properties . . . C . Chemical Composition and Behavior . D . Urease Derivatives . . . . . E . Immunological Behavior . . . . IV . Ureases from Other Sources . . . . V . Catalytic Properties . . . . . . . A . Mechanism . . . . . . . B . Substrate Specificity . . . . . C . Kinetic Studies . . . . . . D. Active Site Studies . . . . . VI . Summary . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. .
. .
. .
. .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
. . .
.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . .
.
. . .
. .
. . . . . .
1 2 4 5 8 10 11 12 13 13 15
15 16 18 20 21
.
1 Introduction
The title retains the trivial name for enzymes with the systematic name of urea amidohydrolase and the Enzyme Commission code number of EC 3.5.1.5. Ureases are hydrolases acting on C.-N bonds (nonpeptide) in linear amides and thus belong to a group that includes glutaminase, formamidase, and formyltetrahydrofolate deformylase . The title is plural to emphasize that urease activity may be exhibited by several protein species. Urease, singular. has come to mean by common usage. that particular enzymic protein first crystallized by Sumner from jack bean 1
2
F. J. REITHEL
meal. An excellent account of the earlier work was provided by Sumner in the first edition of this compendium (I), and in a well-known book ( 2 ); a more recent review was assembled by Varner (3). Although the present review recognizes the multiplicity of ureases, the bulk of our knowledge derives from the crystalline protein isolated from the jack bean Canavalia ensiformis. This seed has little utility for other purposes, and it is not known what function is served by urease in the economy of the plant. Since both urea and urease occur widely in the plant kingdom there have been numerous studies of variations in the concentrations of both components ( 4 ) .There seems to be no obvious correlation. A recent ontogenetic study on the jack bean ( 5 ) has not revealed conclusive evidence of an important function for urease. To date no one has demonstrated urease to be an enzyme to engage the enthusiasm of the investigator on the basis of its biological function. As a hydrolase it has been notable for specificity. This, together with an outstanding catalytic efficiency, has justified a search for the details of the hydrolytic mechanism and has potentiated numerous investigations of urease activity in a wide spectrum of biological material. I n the recent past urease has stimulated interest as a model in the study of subunit interactions. The preparative molecular weight of 489,000 ( 6 ) appears to be the result of a systematic arrangement of single polypeptide chain subunits of 30,000 daltons ( 7 ) .
II. Isolation and Purification of Jack Bean Urease
I n view of the isolation of the crystalline enzyme from this source (chosen because of the high concentration) 45 years ago, it might be supposed that a discussion of preparative procedures would be unnecessary. On the contrary, vigorous contentions concerning the purity and activity of crystalline urease have been a hallmark of its literature right to the present. Several factors contribute to this situation. The urease content of jack bean meal varies according to the origin and 1. J. B. Sumner, “The Enzymes,” 1st ed., Vol. 1, Part 2, p. 886, 1951. 2. J. B. Sumner and G. F. Somers, “Chemistry and Methods of Enzymes,” 3rd rev. ed. Academic Press, New York, 1953. 3. J. E . Varner, “The Enzymes,” 2nd ed., Vol. 4, p. 247, 1959. 4. E. G.Bollard, S y m p . SOC.E z p . Bid. 13, 304 (1959). 5. P.P. Sehgal and A. W. Naylor, Botan. Gaz. 127, 27 (1966). 6. F.J. Reithel and J. E. Robbins, ABB 120, 158 (1967). 7. C. C. Contaxis, Ph.D. Thesis, University of Oregon, 1970.
1. URENSES
3
age of the seed and the method used in preparing the meal ( 8 , 9 ) . The acetone extraction must be performed precisely as directed or some other extraction procedure adopted. The enzymic activities of various preparations may be difficult to compare because assay conditions have not been uniform and because the activity is sensitive to minute concentrations of heavy metals. The propensity of the enzyme to dissociate, and to form oligomers, compounds the difficulty of assigning a specific activity. Finally, there are anomalies (10) noted during assay that suggest variations in activity with conformational change and this further adumbrates specific activity as a criterion. As Mamiya and Gorin (11) note, Sumner occasionally had difficulty in preparing crystalline urease from some jack bean meals and this is a technical problem that has received attention in each recent improved method of preparation (11-15). Modification of Sumner’s extraction procedure by including p-mercaptoethanol (11, 14) t o diminish aggregation and ethylenediaminetetraacetate (EDTA) (15,15) to maintain a low concentration of metal ions has been helpful. The procedure used in this laboratory with consistent success over a period of 4 years, and involving several students, is essentially that of Mamiya and Gorin (11) but with EDTA included in the buffers. [There is an error in Mamiya and Gorin (11). The concentration of acetone used was 32%, not 360/0.] A method for the isolation of urease from hydrated jack beans developed by Sehgal and Naylor (15) employs DEAE-cellulose as a final purification step. A method intended for purification of urease from mammalian sources (16) was developed using jack bean meal as a standard source. It employed no acetone but is a combination of (NH,) &30, precipitation and Sephadex column separations. [Note Fish8. The prime supplier of jack beans for many years was Mr. Ernest Nelson, Waldron, Arkansas. His business is being continued by his son, Winton R. Nelson. Companies offering jack beans and jack bean meal at. the present time include Sigma Chemical Co., St. Louis, Mo.; General Biochemicals Co., Chagrin Falls, Ohio; and Worthington Biochemical Co., Freehold, N. J. 9. W. N . Fishbein, Ann. N . Y . Acad. Sci. 147, 857 (1969). 10. Workers in several laboratories have noted that the activity of urease uppears to Increase upon standing a t room temperature. Until this is understood assay prowdures cannot be assumed to yield precise values. 11. G. Mamiya and G. Gorin, BBA 105, 382 (1965). 12. K. K. Lynn, BBA 146, 205 (1967). 13. R. I,. B1:ikeley. E . C. Webb, and 13. Zerner, Biochemishy 8, 1984 (1969). 14. F. J. Itpithel, J. E. Robbins, and G . Gorin, ABB 108, 409 (1964). 15. P. P. 8ehg:il a d A . W. Naylor, Plant Physiol. 41, 567 (1966). 16. E. J. Conway, 0. Fitzgerald, and I<. McGceney, Irish J . Med. Sci. 491, 502 (1966).
4
F. J . REITHEL
bein (9) with respect to the use of Sephadex.] The procedure of Lynn (12) also employed molecular sieves (17 ) . The jack beans grown in Japan, Canavalia ensiformis var. gladiata, present special problems in the isolation procedure. Hanabusa (18) has proposed a modified procedure for extraction without the use of acetone.
ENZYMIC ACTIVITY MEASUREMENT Sumner (1) defined the unit of activity as the amount of enzyme that liberates 1 mg of ammonia nitrogen from urea a t 20" in 5 min. Despite the fact that the phosphate buffer (used to maintain a pH near 7) is slightly inhibitory, as is ammonia, the assay has been widely used with reasonable satisfaction. Chin and Gorin (19) have studied this assay in detail and have shown that the liberation of ammonia is not linear and that the p H changes appreciably during the 5-min incubation. They reported that 1 Sumner unit = 14.28U;O where the latter is defined in accordance with IUB recommendations: a unit catalyzing the decomposition of 1 microequivalent of the bond involved in 1 min (20°,p H 7). Because of the shortcomings of the Sumner assay, Gorin and Chin (20) have proposed a more precise assay employing a trisEDTA buffer a t pH 9 (25"). This unit is symbolized as U r and 1 Sumner unit = 11.0 U:6. Comparing activities a t three different temperatures, Uz6 = 1.22 Uio and Ui6 = 0.79 Uzo. I n this assay the product is mostly ammonium carbamate, explicitly shown in the following equations: Ha-CO-NH2
+ 2H10
4
S
+ + +
+
NH4+ NHzC02H20 2NH4+ c0:NH4+ NH3 HCOI-
+
After a 2.0-min reaction time (two bonds broken per molecule urea), addition of excess HC1 stops the reaction and converts the carbamate to ammonium ion. Back titration with NaOH estimates the unreacted acid. A somewhat more elaborate assay has been proposed by Blakeley et al. (13) employing a recording p H stat. In this assay no buffer is used, but dithiothreitol ( D T T ) is present during the titration (that maintains the pH a t 7.0). The unit, IU, is defined as the amount that causes the decomposition of 1 pmole of urea per minute (38", pH 7.0, 0.05M urea, 2 pM DTT). One Sumner unit = 17.6 IU/mg = 11 UiK/mg.Specific 17. Personal correspondence with K. R. Lynn. Throughout this paper there are stated activities that are at least one order of magnitude too high. 18. K. Hanabusa, Nature 189, 551 (1961); 193, 1078 (1962). 19. C. C. Chin and G. Gorin, Anal. Biochem. 17, 60 (1966). 20. G. Gorin and C. C. Chin, Anal. Biochem. 17, 49 (1966).
1.
URWEB
5
activity is defined as I U per ml/A2,, where the denominator is 0.589. Other types of assay procedures proposed are based on diffusion (16, d l ) , potentiometry (22),and estimation with Nessler’s reagent (23). A brief review of procedures has recently appeared (24). The calculation of specific activity requires a reliable method for determining the weight of urease used. The most convenient method is measurement of the ultraviolet absorption but this is not highly accurate. 0.771 (6)for the absorption of 1 mg/ml Values of 0.589 (IS),0.754 (20), at 280 nm have been reported as well as 0.77 a t 277 nm (26).Urease isolated in the presence of P-mercaptoethanol yielded a value of 0.640 (20) and a t p H 2, 0.597 (6). Until far more data are a t hand, obtained in systematic studies to establish the relation of activity to concentrations of protein and the effects of ions, there seems little justification for attaching undue weight to specific activity determinations as an indication of purity. I n the author’s laboratory urease that appears homogeneous by electrophoretic and ultracentrifuge criteria has an activity of 160 Sumner units (at 20”) per milligram based on A,,, = 0.762 in turn based on dry weight measurements (26). The catalytic action of urease has a large temperature coefficient,and it would be highly desirable if a single standard temperature could be agreed upon, particularly that recommended by the IUB, 30”. It is convenient to have a method for the detection and rough estimation of urease activity in gels. A simple staining procedure using cresol red has been described (27),but a more elaborate procedure (28) employing p-nitro blue tetrazolium results in sharper definition.
111. Molecular Properties
Physicochemical studies on jack bean urease during the past 10 years undoubtedly were stimulated by the 1960 paper of Creeth and Nichol 21. J. A. Blain and M . Caskie, Chem. & Znd. (London) p. 17 (1965). 22. S. A . Katz. Anal. Chem. 36, 2500 (1964). 23. E. Bernt and H. U. Bergmeyer, in “Methods of Enzymatic Analysis” (H. U. Bergmcyer, ed.), p. 401. Academic Press, New York, 1963. 24. A . Kaplan, Methods Biochem. Anal. 17, 320 (1969). 25. C. J. Bailey and D. Boulter, BJ 113, 669 (1969). 26. R. Goodrich and F. J. Reithel, Anal. Biochem. 34, 538 (1970). 27. D. P. Blattler, C. C. Contaxis, and F. J. Reithel, Nature 216, 274 (1967) ; C. C. Contaxis and F. J. Reithel, JBC (in press). 28. W. N. Fishbein, Proc. Int. Symp. Chromatog. Electrophoresis, 6th, Brussels, 1968, p. 238. Presses Acad. Eur., 1969.
6
F. J. REITHEL
(29). I n this, the evidence strongly suggested that the persistent “impurities” with sedimentation constants greater than 20 were oligomers of the main component of urease preparations. The main component had an extrapolated s;,~ value of 20 k 0.5, the most prevalent “impurities,” 28 S and 36 S, suggesting a In, 2n, 3n relationship. It was noted that a 4-6 S, and occasionally a 12 S, peak could also be discerned. I n the presence of sulfite such preparations yielded only 19-20s values during ultracentrifugation and showed an increase in activity. The latter observation has been cited repeatedly as evidence that the 28 S and 36 S forms possessed lower specific activities than the 20 S form, but this has not been demonstrated with isolated oligomers. The action of sulfite on the 2 0 s form, isolated as such, has not been demonstrated. The ultracentrifuge evidence strongly indicated that the above forms were not in rapid equilibrium. This conclusion was strengthened by the experimental results of Siegel and Monty (SO) who chromatographed a commercial preparation of jack bean urease (of unspecified age) on Sephadex G-200. They obtained an elution pattern with four peaks, and from the elution volumes they calculated Stokes radii of 61, 79, 92, and 122A. If the first three components were assumed to have S values of 19, 28, and 36, then the molecular weights could be calculated. They were found to be in the ratio 1.0, 1.9, and 2.9. It was noted that only 10% of the sample used was soluble. Hill and co-workers (31,32) chromatographed freshly prepared urease on carboxymethyl cellulose in acetate-phosphate buffer, with and without sulfite. They succeeded in obtaining fractionation with respect to activity, but the fractions were heterogeneous with respect to the sedimentation values obtained. Sedimentation coefficients of 3, 3.9, 19, 28, and 32 were noted and there was no correlation that permitted an assignment of specific activity to each component. More recently (IS), it was found t h a t the activity of urease could be maximal even when 3Q% of the urease had sedimentation coefficients greater than 1 8 s . I n another laboratory (9) it was found that specific activity did not correlate with monodispersity. Several investigators have presented evidence for low molecular weight forms exhibiting urease activity. Hand (33), in 1939, obtained diffusion data indicating particles of 17,000 daltons or less that retained enzymic activity. More recently, sucrose density gradient ultracentrifugation (34) 29. J. M. Creeth and L. W. Nichol, BJ 77, 230 (1960). 30. L. M. Siegel and K . J. Monty, BBRC 19, 494 (1965). 31. M. Shadaksharaswamy and R. M. Hill, ABB 97, 607 (1962). 32. R. M. Hill and A. Elliot, ABB 113, 405 (1966). 33. D. B. Hand, JACS 61, 3180 (1939). 34. P. P. Sehgal, R. J. Tanis, and A. W. Naylor, BBRC 20, 550 (1965).
1. UREASES
7
has been used to demonstrate an active 1 2 s form of urease in a commercial preparation, in jack bean meal, and in extracts of soaked jack bean seeds. Less than 5% of the total activity was in this form. Urease preparations extracted with water and precipitated with NaCl and polyethylene glycol-4000 yielded (35) a form of urease with a s&, = 8.5. Urease exposed to 0.1 M acetate buffer, p H 3.5, has been reported (36) to be converted to a metastable, transiently enzymically active, species with szo,,, = 9.8. Using quantitative gel electrophoresis (37) and a simple activity stain (27), Blattler examined urease preparations showing evidences of “aging” changes (38,38,). When urease, initially electrophoretically homogeneous, was allowed to age in buffer or 50% diol, enzymically active species appeared that had electrophoretic mobilities between the usual bands. These intermediate bands corresponded to a variety of species that differed by approximately 60,000 molecular weight between 240,000 and 480,000, and between 480,000 and 960,000. Fishbein and co-workers (9,39) have examined a variety of urease preparations by gel electrophoresis. The use of an improved staining technique (98) allowed the visualization of activity in bands corresponding to n, 2n,3n, 4n, 5n, 6n (where n = 480,000 daltons) . These bands were designated as polymeric isozymes. Other bands of activity corresponding to molecular weights of 240,000, 600,000, and 800,000 were observed and termed epiisozymes assumed to consist of multiple active assemblies of a single active subunit. Filtration of preparations (containing only n species) through columns of Sephadex G-150 or G-200 resulted in the appearance of 2n-6n species and a very minor amount of a form estimated to have a molecular weight of 17,000. Finally, the existence of conformeric isozymes was postulated on the basis of variations in electrophoretic mobility observed. The mechanism involved in the production of urease oligomers on gel columns has not been clarified and seems anomalous because all of the species were excluded from the gel. Moreover, as Creeth and Nichol observed (as), if an equilibrium exists, the kinetic constants are small. The demonstration of so many enzymically active forms of urease 35. K. K. Stewart and L. C. Craig, Federation Proc. 25, 590 (1966). 36. G. Gorin and C. C. Chin, Federation Proc. 26, 605 (1967). 37. D. P. Blattler and F. J. Reithel, J . Chromatog. 46, 286 (1970). 38. D. P. Blattler, Ph.D. Thesis, University of Oregon, 1967; Dissertation Abstr. B29, No. 1, 38 (1968). 38a. D. P. Blattler and F. J. Reithel, Enzymologia 39, 193 (1970). 39. W. N. Fishbein, C. L. Spears, and W. Scurai, Nature 223, 191 (1969).
8
F. J. REITHEL
with such disparate mobilities point to a complex association-dissociation process. However, until these several forms have been isolated and characterized, particularly with respect to specific activity, unequivocal interpretations of the data are not possible. Moreover, specific activity values per se are not measurements of precision unless they are related to a mass of a characterized conformer. And, finally, it must be shown that the enzyme retains the same character during the enzyme assay that it has in isolation conditions.
A. MOLECULAR WEIGHTDETERMINATIONS The molecular weight of recrystallized urease was carefully determined in Svedberg's laboratory by combining sedimentation velocity and diffusion data (40). The value reported ( 4 1 ) , 483,000, is substantially the same as that of a more recent study ( 6 ) reporting the value 489,000, obtained by sedimentation equilibrium. These values pertain to the most prevalent molecular species in freshly prepared urease. If the single polypeptide chain weight (n) in urease is 30,000, then Sumner's urease can be considered as (16n). This type of symbolism prevents misunderstanding in the discussion of polymorphic proteins with the proviso that (n) is defined. There is another active molecular species (8n) obtainable by treatment with propanediol, glycerol (27), or 1,2-ethanediol (4.Z))having a molecular weight of 236,000. Urease activity persists unaltered when the enzyme is dissolved in 8 M urea although the ultracentrifuge data indicate a molecular weight of about 90,000 ( 7 ) . This form of urease has not been sufficiently characterized but does indicate that neither enzymic activity nor specific activity is dependent upon very high molecular weight aggregates. Dissociation and Association The foregoing discussion provides numerous references to observations of the dissociation-association behavior of urease. It is common knowledge among those using this enzyme that association occurs but during storage. Disulfide bonding is not required for association (7,427) 40. J. B. Sumner, N. Gralen, and I.-B. Eriksson-Quensel, JBC 125, 37 (1938). 41. The value of 483,000 is in the original publication but was misquoted by both Sumner ( 1 ) and Varner (3) as 473,000. Moreover, the diffusion constant was determined in the presence of sodium sulfite but the sedimentation constant was not. The main component in phosphate buffer was found to have a sedimentation constant of 18.65 a t 20". 42. G. Gorin, D. P. Blattler, and D. E. Thain, BBRC 36, 1045 (1969).
1. UREASES
9
may occur if not prevented as suggested by the findings of Creeth and Nichol (29). Evidence of dissociation under various conditions has been noted ( 29, 3 2 4 6 ). The effects of “dissociating agents” have been described. In 6 M guanidine hydrochloride a value of 83,300 was found ( I d ) , but this value was probably the result of partial reassociation ( 4 3 ) . Urease dissociates even in 3 M guanidine hydrochloride to (2n) subunits of 60,000 daltons (71, but it reaggregates upon standing. Ultracentrifuge studies (44) as well as gel electrophoresis studies (46) of urease in sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) suggest dissociation to a molecular weight of 6O,OOO, with total loss of activity. Another gel electrophoresis study (26) in SDS and p-mercaptoethanol yielded a mobility corresponding to a molecular weight of 75,000. Dissociation of urease in 0.1% SDS in 45% thioglycerol, followed by dialysis against tris-EDTA, p H 9.2, yielded a 120,000 molecular weight species (4n) as judged from ultracentrifuge data ( 7 ) . Urease is remarkably resistant to unfolding in urea. No change in optical rotatory dispersion or specific activity of the enzyme occurs in concentrations of urea up to 8 M ( 7 ) . Between 8 and 9 M , unfolding occurs and the molecular weight becomes 60,000, but some activity persists. Solution in 0.1 M acetate buffer, p H 3.5, resulted in an enzymically active species (8n) of 240,000 daltons (46). Tanis and Naylor (4’7) have reported that a t low concentration of protein the 18s form predominated above pH 5.3 and the 1 2 s form below pH 4.8. Between these p H values a rapid equilibrium of the 12 S and 18 S species was observed The dissociation behavior of urease a t low pH depends on the buffer used. I n 0.1 M potassium phosphate buffer, adjusted to p H 2.0 with HC1, a heterogeneous mixture of dissociated forms was obtained ( 6 ) with an Mw of about 150,000. I n acetate buffer a t pH 3.5 dissociation into a 120,000 molecular weight species (4n) was observed (48). I n 34% acetic acid a t p H 2.2 there is effected a dissociation to subunits (n) of 30,000 daltons (7). This same value was obtained for urertse ultracentrifuged in 8 M urea 0.5 M thiol and in performic acid oxidized urease (48).
+
A. Andrews and F. J. Reithel, ABB 141, 538 (1970). G. Gorin, G. Mamiya, and C. C. Chin, Experieiitiu 23, 443 (1967). D. P. Blattler and G. Gorin, Can. J . Biochem. 47, 989 (1969). G. Gorin, C. C. Chin, and S. F. Wang, E x p e r i e n t k 24, 685 (1968). R. J. Tanis and A. W. Naylor, BJ 108, 771 (1968). F. J. Reithel and J. E. Robbins, Proc. 7th Intern. Congr. Biochem., Tokyo, 1967 Abstracts IV, p. 585. Sci. Council Japan, Tokyo, 1968. 43. 44. 45. 46. 47. 48.
10
F. J. REITHEL
At this time there is no definitive evidence concerning either the identity of the subunits or the groups involved in their interaction. Since it is possible to observe the dissociation of urease in four discrete steps to (8n), (4a), (2n), and ( a ) subunits, it seems likely that a t least four types of binding arrangements are present. Since the dissociations are symmetrical it seems likely that the subunits are identical a t least down t o 60,000 daltons. At least two groups (1S,2.5) have evidence for a subunit weight of 75,000-80,000 daltons. This is supported by other evidence (14,445). It is likely that these data are artifactual and do not relate to a structural subunit weight.
B. OTHER PHYSICAL PROPERTIES The diffusion constant a t 20" determined many years ago (400) in cm2 sec-l remains unchallenged. The partial sodium sulfite as 3.46 X specific volume value of 0.73 reported (40) has been verified by recent measurements using other techniques (6). At p H 7 and 25", 0.733 was found; a t pH 2 and 25", 0.734; a t p H 7 and 5",0.722. The wavelength of maximum absorbance is 278.5 nm (13,20).The absorbance values reported show wide divergences: A2,8.G(1mg/ml) = 0.601, A280 0.589 (IS) ; A 2 7 8 = 0.771, A 2 7 8 (PH 2) = 0.597, A 2 7 8 (6 M GCl) = 0.671 (6, 14) ; At78 (PH 7) = 0.754 (20); A 2 7 8 = 0.64 (4.2, 45) ; A 2 7 8 = 0.80 (49). Since protein concentration is often estimated by measuring the absorbance, it is evident that the spectrum of activities to be found in the literature very likely reflects the spectrum of values given above. The AZ80/&60 ratio has been reported as 1.8-1.9 ( 1 3 ) . The isoelectric point, determined by Sumner and Hand (50) to have a value of 5.0-5.1, has been redetermined by the electrofocusing technique (43). The value obtained was 4.8. The solubility is extremely small a t this pH, but the urease can be located by its enzymic action. It is a point of interest that the solubility of the isoelectric species increases spectacularly if the sulfhydryl groups are substituted with N-ethylmaleimide (NEM) (4.9). Evidence for conformers of urease has been presented by two groups of investigators. Chernitskii et a2. (51) noted fluorescence maxima a t pH 3 4 , 5.5-6.5, 7.5-9, and >10.5 when urease solutions were irradiated with 280 or 296 nm radiation. Addition of urea increased the fluorescence 49. I. Matsuo and G. Mamiya, Keio J . M e d . 17, 189 (1968). 50. J. B. Sumner and D. B. Hand, JACS 31, 1255 (1929).
51. E. A. Chernitskii, V. M. Mazhul, and S. V. Konev, Biofizika 13, 581 (1968).
11
.. UREASES
md addition of guanidine-HC1 abolished the maxima. Fishbein et al. :9,39,56)interpreted changes in mobility in gel electrophoresis, followng repeated recrystallizations, as the formation of conformer isoenzymes. The ultrasonic absorption coefficient of urease has been measured (53) md found to increase in the presence of urea.
>. CHEMICALCOMPOSITIONAND
BEHAVIOR
The amino acid composition (6,54) of urease has no unique features but does provide a guide for molecular weight considerations. The two itations are not in agreement and hence further work is in order. Of )articular interest are the values of 82 (6,43) and 64 (54) half-cystines ier 485,000 MW. This is unexpectedly less than the value of 29 cystine dus 47 cysteine per 473,000 reported by Gorin et al. ( 5 5 ) . However, uch values necessarily reflect the technique used to estimate the protein oncentration. In view of the wide discrepancies in absorbance one night expect a corresponding scatter in sulfhydryl content. In a later nvestigation Gorin and Chin (56) found, titrating with N-ethylmalimide, 21 sulfhydryl groups that reacted rapidly with no loss of enymic activity, 7-8 groups that reacted more slowly with the loss of 0% of the activity, and 16-20 groups that reacted slowly. Andrews (43) ound that estimation either with N-ethylmaleimide or 5,5'-dithiobis2-nitrobenzoic acid) indicated the following numbers of sulfhydryl roups per (16n) : 26-28 rapidly react without loss of activity, 7-9 titrate :ss rapidly with loss of activity, and 45-50 more become available fol)wing unfolding. Twenty years ago. Desnuelle and Rovery (57) prolosed that the loss of activity during such titrations was not a result of 'locking groups and modifying their chemical behavior but rather that he loss of activity reflected a change in structure. The use of "S$beled tetraethylthiuram disulfide (58) has indicated 19 readily titratble sulfhydryl groups per mole of protein and a total of 53 groups itratable when the protein was dissolved in 0.25% SDS. The protein sed was a commercial sample of indeterminate age and submaximal ctivity. There is no compelling evidence for the existence of interchain 52. W.N.Fishbein, C. L. Spears, and W. Scurzi, Federation Proc. 28, 468 (1969). 53. M.Pancholy and T. K. Saksena, J . Acoust. Soc. Am. 44, 639 (1968). 54. J. M.Milton and I. E. P. Taylor, BJ 113, 678 (1969). 55. G. Gorin, E. Fuchs, L. G. Butler, S. I,. Chopra, and R. T. Hersh, Biochemistry , 911 (1962). 56. G. Gorin and C. C. Chin, BBA 99, 418 (1965). 57. P. Desnuelle and M. Rovery, BBA 3, 26 (1949). 58. A. H.Neims, D. S.Coffey, and L. Hellerman, JBC 241, 3036 (1966).
12
F. J . REITHEL
disulfide bonds in the (16n) species, and there is no evidence for intrachain disulfide bonds. Without doubt disulfide bonds do form in (32n) and (4%) forms and similar oligomers, but there is no evidence that such formation is mandatory. When 40% of the groups are blocked in unfolded preparations reassociation (43) is strongly inhibited. I n a recent paper ( 2 5 ) , Bailey and Boulter have presented evidence for a single N-terminal rnethionine residue per (a suggested subunit of) 75,000 daltons. A single C-terminal sequence, -Tyr-Leu-Phe, was found using carboxypeptidases A and B and hydrazinolysis. Asparagine has also been reported as the N-terminal amino acid (59).
D. UREASE DERIVATIVES As noted above, Sumncr and co-workers were unable t o determinc the diffusion coefficient of urease unless thcy added Na2S0, and NaHSO, to the phosphate buffer (40) used. Nichol and Creeth, employing identical concentrations (GO),measured both the sedimentation coefficient and the electrophoretic mobility of sulfite-modified urease. They concluded that sulfite contributed to the formation of -S-SO,- groups attached to the (16n) species. Some of these groups they ascribed to the scission of intermolecular disulfide bonds of aggregated forms; others, they suggested, arose from the 22 reactive sulfhydryl groups that react with 0, (air) to form transitory disulfides that can, in turn, react with sulfite. An unusual type of derivative is the complex that forms between urease and bentonite in acid medium (61). The adsorbed form was found catalytically active. Similarly, urease immobilized in a polyacrylamide gel matrix has been used to prepare a urea-specific enzyme electrode (62). Yet another active water-insoluble derivative has been prepared (63) by allowing p-chloromercuribenzoate-treated urease to react with a diazotized copolymer of p-amino-D,L-Phe and L-Leu. Urease has been found to retain about 20% of its original activity when encapsulated in 100 p microcapsules of benzalkonium-heparin in collodion (64). Both carboxymethyl and aminoethyl urease have been prepared (251, 59. R. L. Blakeley, J. A . Hinds, H . E. Kunze, E. C. Webb. and B. Zerner. Biochemitry 8, 1991 (1969). 60. I,. W. Nichol and J. M. Creeth. BBA 71, 509 (1963). 61. G. Surand, Ann. Znst. Pasteur Suppl. 3. 121 (1965). 62. G . G. Guilbault and J. G. Montalvo, Jr., JACS 91, 2164 (1969). 63. E. Ricsel and E. Katchalski, JBC 239, 1521 (1964). 61. T. M. S. Chang, L. J. Johnson, and 0. J . Ransome, Can. J. Physiol. Plinrmacol. 45, 705 (1967).
1.
UREASES
13
the latter being used to prepare tryptic peptide “maps” of urease. Reduced carboxymethylated urease was reported (65) to have a molecular weight of 16,000 on the basis of tryptophan (Trp) content.
E. IMMUNOLOGICAL BEHAVIOR
It was noted in previous reviews (1,s) that injection of urease into rabbits elicited an antibody and that the precipitate formed between urease and its antibody still possessed catalytic activity. This indicates that the antigenic and catalytic regions are not identical. A more recent study employing horse and rat antisera (66)revealed only one major antigenic component in urease preparations and confirmed the lack of complete enzyme inhibition by the precipitin reaction. Urease-immunized laboratory animals have been observed (67) to suffer a depression in the in vivo hydrolysis of 14C urea. This has received close scrutiny since there is evidence (68) that passively immunized animals (injected with anti-urease) show increased survival after whole-body y radiation. IV. Ureases from Other Sources
Ureases occur in a large number of microorganisms. A listing has appeared in a paper (69) calling attention t o the existence of urease even in organisms that do not hydrolyze urea in the culture medium. Particularly designed for the assay of urease in bacterial extracts is a coupled enzyme assay ( 7 0 ) . This procedure is based on the high K , value of glutamic acid dehydrogenase for ammonia. Thus, in the presence of a-ketoglutarate, the oxidation of NADH was found to be proportional to the ammonia resulting from urease action. It has been noted that the various strains of Enterobacteriaceae contain either urease or P-galactosidase (71). The urease of the genus Proteus has continued to receive attention. 65. K. Sekita and G. Mamiya, Proc. 7 t h Intern. Congr. Biochem., T o k y o , 1967 Abstracts IV, p. 761. Sci. Council Japan, Tokyo, 1968. 66. W. J. Visek, M. E. Iwert, N. S. Nelson, and J. H. Rust, A B B 122,95 (1967). 67. H. C. Dang and W. J. Visek, Proc. SOC.Ezpptl. B i d . M e d . 105, 164 (1960). 68. W. J. Visek and H. C. Dang, Ezcerpta M e d . Monogr. Nucl. Med. B i d . No. 1, 292 (1966). 69. H. Seneca, P. Peer, and R. Nally, Nature 193, 1106 (1962). 70. H. Kaltwasser and H. G. Schlegel, Anal. Biochem. 16, 132 (1966). 71. M. Catsaras, Ann. Znst. Pasteur Lille 16, 175 (1965).
14
F. J. REITHEL
A partially purified enzyme from P . mirabilis (72) was found to have a molecular weight of 151,000. The urease of P . rettgeri is an inducible enzyme that appears only when urea, but not its analogs, are present in the media ( 7 3 ) .Proteus vulgaris urease was found to be inhibited in vitro by thiourea and two derivatives ( 7 4 ) ,and by hydroxamic acids (93). I n Azotobacter vinelandii, urease appears to be synthesized only when urea or thiourea is present ( 7 5 ) . A study of the urease constitutive in Corynebacterium renale (76) did not reveal features remarkably different from the plant enzyme. A similar conclusion was reached in the characterization of a highly purified enzyme from B . pasteurii ( 7 7 ) . Stewart (78) has devised a medium for the detection of urease activity in pseudomonads and has resolved uncertainties that have developed in the literature. It has been reported that Sarcina ureae produces urease as an exoenzyme (79). Bacteria-free cultures of blue-green algae yielded extracts in which urease could be demonstrated (80,81). Again, in algae as in bacteria (69) the function of urease is conjectural (82). The addition of urea to tissue cultures of human amnion cells has been found to induce urease formation (83).Urease from the seed of the legume Glyciridia maculata has been purified (84) and found to be advantageous for commercial purposes. This enzyme was reported to have no activity a t 30" and below but to be active at 50"-60"! Ureases from several sources have been examined for enzymically active low molecular weight forms ( 4 7 ) .It was noted that the 12 S forms from jack bean did not hybridize with that from B . pasteurii. It now seems probable that gastric urease is bacterial in origin (85). The OC72. J. A. Andersen, F. Kopko, A. J. Siedler, and E. G. Nohle, Federation Proc. 28, 764 (1969). 73. I. Magana-Plaza and J. Ruiz-Herrera, J . Bacteriol. 93, 1294 (1967). 74. R. S. Pianotti, R. R. Mohan, and B. S. Schwartz, Proc. SOC.Exptl. Biol. Med. 122, 506 (1966). 75. S. I,. Mehta, M. S. Naik, and N. B. Das, Indian J . Biochem. 4, 194 (1967). 76. A. J. Lister, J . Gen. Microbiol. 14, 478 (1956). 77. A. D. Larson and R. E. Kallio, J . Bacteriol. 88, 67 (1954). 78. D. J. Stewart, J . Gen. Microbwl. 41, 169 (1965). 79. A. S. Pel'ttser, Izv. Timiryazev. Selskokhoz. Akad. No. 3, p. 230 (1969). 80. D. S. Berns, P. Holohan, and E. Scott, Science 152, 1077 (1966). 81. D. S. Berns, E. Scott, K. T. O'Reilly, and P. D. Holohan, N . Y . Stale Depl. Health, Ann. Rept. Div. Lab. Res. p. 82 (1964). 82. It should be noted that urease-negative extracts of Candida utilis and Chlorella catalyze an ATPdependent cleavage of urea to CO, and NH3. See R. J. Roon and B. Levenberg, JBC 243, 5213 (1968). 83. F. Lieben and K. Springer, Enzymologia 27, 47 (1964). 84. K. Valmikinathan, V. N. V. Rao, and N. Verghese, Enzymologin 34, 257 (1968). 85. A. M. Delluva, K . Markley, and R. E. Davies, BBA 151, 646 (1968).
1. UREASES
15
currence of urease in the gastric mucosa of man and several animals has been observed repeatedly for 40 years. Attempts to use antibiotics such as oxytetracycline (867,chloramphenicol, penicillin, and neomycin led to results of poor reproducibility. However, it is rather clear that gastric tissue from germfree animals (85) contains no urease. Urease activity in soils has been found to reflect the bacterial count and content of organic matter. The urease isolated from an Australian forest soil (87) was crystallized and found to have a specific activity of 75 Sumner units (S.U.) per mg. The molecular weight species were estimated (sedimentation velocity) to be 42, 131, and 217 x lo3. T h a t urease activity persists in soils is shown by the finding that enzymic activities, including urease, could be demonstrated in soil samples over 8000 years old (88).
V. Catalytic Properties
The Enzyme Commission catalog (EC 3.5.1.5) lists the urease reac2 NH,. Since two C-N bonds are broken tion as urea 2 HzO = CO, it is evident that the stoichiometric relation above is the result of two component reactions. Any conjecture concerning the mechanisms of these reactions and the nature of the intermediates must encompass the action of inhibitors and the spectrum of substrates. Some of the organic inhibitors that have been reported are shown in Table I. The substrates that have been shown to be hydrolyzed are listed in Table 11.
+
+
A. MECHANISM The work of Gorin (89) and of Blakeley et al. (59) has provided convincing evidence that carbamate is the intermediate in a two-step reaction.
o=c,,OH
NH,
-H,CO,
+
,ONH O=C\
NH,
+
NH,
]
:
2 NH,
86. M. E. Belding and F. Kern, Jr., J. Lab. C h a . M e d . 61, 560 (1963). 87. M. H. Briggs and L. Segal, Life Sci. 1, 69 (1963). 88. J. J. Skujins and A . D. McLaren, Enzymologia 34, 213 (1968). 89. G. Gorin, BBA 34, 268 (1959).
4-
HOH
16
F. J . REITHEL
Presumably urease forms a carbamoyl complex HtN-C-enz
II
0 as one of the ES complexes and presumably water is the acceptor in a carbamoyl transfer reaction. Carbamate thus becomes the obligatory substrate for thc second step. Since the evidence derives from kinetic data there is, as yet, no direct evidence for the mechanism presented. However, Sumner had long since shown that ammonium carbonate was formed. The present explanation accounts for thc observations and rules out CO, as an initial product. There are two reports that hydroxamic acid inhibition is reversible (59,90)and one that inhibition is irreversible (91). The inhibition appears to be competitive. The rather extensive screening of 36 hydroxamic acids was accomplished with sword bean urease (N),but Proteus urease (92) and jack bean urease (59) also have been found to be inhibited by these specific inhibitors. Using tritium-labeled caprylohydroxamic acid and sword bean urease, Kobashi et al. (94) have shown the formation of an inactive complex containing two moles of inhibitor per mole of enzyme. B. SUBSTRATE SPECIFICITY Hydroxyurea is a substrate ( 9 5 ) , but the rate a t which it is hydrolyzed decreases during the progress of the reaction. The concomitant inhibition disappears as the hydroxyurea is depleted. There is no satisfactory explanation of the events described, and there has been no adequate description of the active site. It has been demonstrated (96) that hydroxyurea added to urease solutions inhibited the hydrolysis of urea and that the extent of inhibition depcnded both on the order of addition and the time of exposure of the enzyme to the inhibitor. Dihydroxyurea is a substrate at high concentration (97) ; K , = 1.25 X 1k2.The products are hydroxylamine and CO,. Like hydroxyurea, hydroxylamine and (in some cases) hydroxamic acids, dihydroxyurea is a 90. 91. 92. 93. 94. 95. 96. 97.
K. Kobashi, J. Hase, and K. Uehara, BBA 65, 380 (1962). W. N. Fishbein and P. P. Carbonc, JBC 240, 2407 (1965). G. R. Gale, J . Bacten’ol. 91, 499 (1966). J. Hnse and K. Kobashi, J . Biochem. ( T o k y o ) 62, 293 (1967). K. Kobaslii, J. Haw, and T. Komai, BBRC 23, 34 (1966). W. N. Fishbein, JBC 240, 2402 (1965). G. R. Galc, Biochem. Phnrmacol. 14, 693 (1965). W. N. Fishbein, JBC 244, 1188 (1969).
1.
17
UREASES
noncompetitive inhibitor. Whether ureasc binds these compounds at, or near, the catalytic site for urea is not known. Unlike hydroxyurea, the extent of inhibition by dihydroxyurea does not increase with time after TABLE I ORGANIC INHIBITORS OF UI{EASI: Compound Hydroxamic acids
Formula
lief.
13-C-NHOH
C hlorttmphenicol
Pheny lurea
I,-Phe Chlormerodrin (neohydrin)
CI-Hg-CH-CH-CH2--S
Hy droxyurea
HgN-C-NHOH
Hydroxylamine Dihydroxyurea
0 HzN-OH HOHN-C-NHOH
OCHs I
H-C-N
K
Hz
I1
Thiourea
Oxytet racycline
Dimethyl sulfoxide
98. E. Mueller, Nnturwissenschaften 54, 226 (1967). 99. E:. Gerhards and H. Gibian, Ann. 'V. Y . Acntl. Sci. 141, 65 (1967). 100. K. Kleczkowski and M. Dabrowska, Bull. Acad. Polon. Sci., Ser. Sci. Biol. 16, 267 (1968).
18
F. J. REITHEL
TABLE I1 UREASE SCJBSTR.4TES OTHER
Compound
Forniiila
THANUREA lief.
Hydroxyurea
HZN-C--N
HOH
(95)
Dihydroxyiirea
0 HOHN-C-NHOH
(97)
II
II
0
an equilibrating preincubation. The inhibition is kinetically reversible and less than that of hydroxyurea. The relation between catalytic activity and pH as measured in 0.1 M tris-maleate buffers is substantially the same for each of the thrce substrates (97) when percent of maximal activity is plotted as the ordinate. C. KINETICSTUDIES The earlier documentation of iirease kinetics by Kistiakowaky and co-workers has been extended more recently by Lynn ant1 Yankwich (101,102). Both overall rcaction rates and 13C kinetic istope effects were determined under conditions where the following variables wero altered: temperature, pH, extent of rcaction, ionic strciigth, conceiitration of reactants, type of buffer, arid age of preparation. I t was concluded that each preparatioii of urcasc was unique, respon(letl uniquely to the medium, and changed throughout the course of tlic reaction. In view of the handling of tlic enzyme, its exposure to glycerol, and grcat dilution and aging changes, the variations found in kinetic data also not surprising. Table I11 gives representative literature values of I<,,, and V,,,:,,for several ureases. The activation energy of urea hydrolysis catalyzed hy ureasc h a s been reported as 8.0 kcal/mole (103) and 9.8-12.2 kcal/mole (101). Ti1 one report no temperature anomalies were evident (103) although, again, it is difficult to know what ureaw species was being invcstigated sincc. glycerol was being used (27). In contrast, another invrstigatioii (104) revealed anomalous temperature tlrpendencc of hydrolysis rates as did an earlier one ( 7 7 ) . A prcparation of soybean urcase in sulfitc buffer was used. Activation energies similar to those ahovc were reported. 101. I<. R. 1,ynn and P. E. Ymkwiclr. BBA 56, 512 (1962). 102. K. R . Lynn :ind P. E. Ynnkwic.11. BBA 81, 533 (1964). 103. R . J. Millcr. C . Pinkllnm. .I. H . Orermnn, and S. W. Dumfortl BBA 167, 607 (1968). 104. G . Talsky and G . K1unkc.r. 2. Physiol. (‘hem. 348, 1372 (1967).
1.
19
UREAELEG
K,
AND
TABLE 111 V,,,,, VALUESFOR UREASEFROM VARIOUSSOURCES
T Buffer
Sources
pH
("C)
K , X 1W (mole/ liter)
V,.. (mole/ li ter/sec)
Ref.
~~
Phosphate Phosphate Phosphate Sulfite Thiosulfate Tris-HC1
S S C B S S
J J
7 7 7 5.7 6.7 7.7 7 7 7.4 7.0
25 25 37 20 20 20 25 25 25 38
20 19 30 100 130 40 4 76 66 4 3.28
15.4 X 10.5 X
37 17.2
x x
10-8
(Arbitrary units) Maleate
J
TrieHtSOI
J
J
5.0 7.0 7.0 9.0 8.0
21
20.8
4.0 4.9 5.1 2.7 4
2.5 x 6.7 x 8.4 x 1.7 x 15.5 x
10-3 10-3 10-3 10-3
a Abbreviations: S, soybean; C, Corynebacterium renale; B, Bacillus pasleurii; and J, jack bean.
The relative reaction rates of urease at low water activities have been measured (105). Mixtures of lyophilized urease and 14C-urea were exposed to various relative humidities at 20". The rates observed ranged from negligible activity below 60% huiiiidity to full activity at 100% relative humidity. It was estimated that hydrolysis could occur only after the water content exceeded onc molecule per polar group. There is an extensive older literature describing effects of various ions on urease activity. A recent study employing potentiometry (106) indicated inhibition by copper and zinc, questionable inhibition by nitrate, and slight activation by phosphate. Use of the same technique (107) has provided data showing 50% inhibition is produced by Hg". Cu'*, ZnL+,Cd"', Co2+,and Ni'+ arraiigeil in decreasing effectiveness (increasing coiiccntration required) . Tho data were held to provide support for the ol)inion that inhibition results from metal substitution of the sulfhydryl group. The pH of maximal catalytic activity in maleate buffer was found to be 6.5 compared to 7.5 in tris buffer [cited in Lynn ( 1 2 )I . The 105. J . J . Skujins :ind .4. L). McI,arrn, Science 158, 1569 (1967). 106. S. A . Kntz and J . A. Cowans, HBA 107, 605 (1965). 107 R . B. Hughes. S. A Katz, nnd S. E. Stuhbins. Enzymologia 36, 332 (1969).
20
F. J. REITHEL
rate of hydrolysis a t p H 6.9 has been reported higher in potassium phosphate buffers than in sodium phosphate buffer (108).
D. ACTIVESITESTUDIES Three types of evidence provide a basis for speculation concerning the nature of the catalytic site. First, kinetic studies have provided data for plots of R,,‘and V,,,;,,vs. pH (12). From such plots molecular ionization constants can be deduced. Lynn’s interpretations (12) suggest a histidine group with a pK,, valuc of 5.8, an a-ammonium group with a pK, value of 7, and a sulfhydryl group with a pK, value of 8.3. It was suggested that the ammonium and sulfhydryl groups are involved in the formation of the ES complex, the binding, and that the histidine group is involved in the reaction of the complex, the catalysis. Second, the correlation of change in enzymic activity with the titration of “essential” sulfhydryl groups has led to a postulation of eight active sites per 480,000 ( 5 6 ) . Unfortunately, the possibility of structural changes during such titrations makes interpretation of such data equivocal. However, the observation that urease retained its activity in 8 M urea, where the molecular weight has been reduced a t least to 90,OOO ( 7 ) , supports the conclusion above. Third, inhibitor binding studies have led to the conclusion that only two active sites are present in a (16n) structure (94). This conclusion is based on the characterization of a complex containing only 2 moles of hydroxamic acid per (16n) urease and the demonstration that this complex has no catalytic activity. Again, the possibility of structural changes cannot be excluded. Obviously the number of active centers postulated until now are fewer than the number of protomer?, but there is fair evidence for a t least eight active regions per molecule of crystalline enzyme or one catalytic region in a (2n) unit.
VI. Summary
Until our knoweldge of the iireases discloses biological significance the research on these enzymes will continue to be restricted. Inquiries into the mechanism of the urease catalysis are clearly appropriate 108. D. Watson, Clirt. C’hirn. Aclo 14, 571 (1966). 109. M. C. Wall and K. J. Laidler. A B B 43, 299 (1953).
1.
UREASES
21
since both specificity and efficiency are remarkable. I n the past such inquiries have suffered because the urease preparations used were not demonstrated to contain a single species. The seeming arbitrariness of the kinetic data reflect the lack of discrimination and control in securing a catalyst of known and reproducible properties. Similarly, studies of the molecular structure of urease have suffered because care in preparation did not match the concern for precision in physical measurements. It is now possible to prepare and characterize ureases in a suitable state of homogeneity. The literature may soon reflect this opportunity to carry out investigations, both chemical and physical, of more enduring value.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Penicillinase and Other P-Lactamases NATHAN CITRI I . Introduction . . . . . . . . . A . Background . . . . . . . B. Definitions and Specificity . . . . C . Occurrence . . . . . . . . D . The Catalytic Reaction . . . . . I1. Molecular Properties . . . . . . . A . Purification and Physical Properties . . B. Composition and Sequence Analyses . . I11. Catalytic Properties . . . . . . . . A . Methods of Assay . . . . . . B . Kinetics and Substrate Specificity . . . C . Structural Modifications in Substrates . D . Structural Modifications in the Enzyme . E . Other Factors Affecting Activity . . . IV . Conformation and Function . . . . . . A . Nonspecific Conformational Transitions . B . Specific Transitions: Conformative Response V . Immunological Studies . . . . . . .
. .
. .
. .
. .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
. . . . .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
. .
. .
. .
. .
.
.
.
.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
.
.
.
.
23 23 25 26 27 27 27 31 35
35 39 40 41 42 44 44 45 46
.
1 Introduction
A . BACKGROUND In 1940 Abraham and Chain ( 1 ) reported that an extract of Escherichia C O Z ~ destroys the antibacterial activity of benzylpenicillin . The authors presented evidence indicating that the extract (and possibly several 1. E . P. Abraham and E . Chain, Nature 146. 837 (1940).
23
24
NATHAN CITRI
other bacterial preparations) contained a penicillin-inactivating enzyme which they named penicillinase. Subsequently, many other bacteria were found to contain or secrete similar enzymes for which the inore general term, p-lactnmnse, Iins I ) c c i i suggesttxl. Tlicrc is 110 autliciiticntcd evidence that organisms other than bacteria produce p-lactamase ( 2 ) . The apparently exclusive and wide distribution of p-lactamascs anioiig diverse bacterial species suggests that this family of enzymes may have cvolvctl in connection with a uniquely bacterial function such as bacterial crll wall formation ( 2 6 ). The role of 1wnicillinasc and other ,8-luctnmascs i n conferring resistance to penicillins a i d the closcly relatctl cephalosporiiis has been amply demonstrated (6-8),niitl rcpcatcdly coiifirmctl in tlic numerous reports tlealing with the clinical aspects of p-lactmiase activity (reviewed in references 6, 7 , 9, 10).At a more fundaincntal lcvc~l,penicillinase has been studied most c.stcnsivcly from the point of view of enzyme induction ( 2 , 11, 1 2 ) , enzyme secretion (13-16), and transfer of genetic elements (17, 18). Earlier investigations a t the niolecular level, which have beeii reviewed in previous editions of this book (.19,20) , have been recently cbspanded to cover additional p-lactamase preparations. The picture which emerges indicates an unexpected diversity of size, structure, and molecular properties. Even more surprising is the variety of catalytic activities, which became increasingly evident as more p-lactamase preparations were iso2. N. Citri and M . R . Pollock. A ~ U U IEnzymol. I. 28, 237 (1966). 3. M. R. Pollock. Brit. M e d . J. IV, 71 (1967). 4. H. G. Boman. K. G. Eriksson-Grennberg, J . Foldes, and E. B. Lindstrom, in “Regulation of Nil[-lric A4cid and Protein Biosynthcsis” (V. V. Koningaherper and I,. 13osch. eds.). Vol. 10. 11. 366. B. B. A . Library, Elsevier Publ. Co., Amstcrdam. 1967. 5. I,. G. Burman, K. Nordstrom. and H. G . Bomnn, J. Bacteriol. 96, 438 (1968). 6. M. Barber, in “The Scientific Basis of Medicine,” Annual Review, 1964, p. 169. Univ. of London, (Athlone), London, 1964. 7. W. M. M. Kirby :ind R. J. Bulger. Ann. 12ee. M e d . 15, 393 (1964). 8. H. C. Neu, BBRC 32, 258 (1968). ‘3. E. Rauenbusch, Antibiot. Cliemolhercipia 14, 95 (1968). 10. J . T. Smith, J . M . T. Hamilton-Miller, nnd It. Knox, J . Phurm. Phurmtrcol. 21, 337 (1969). 11. M. R. Pollock, “The Enzyrncs,” 2nd ed., Vol. 1, p. 619. 1959. 12. M. H. Richmond. Essays Biocliem. 4 , 105 (1968). 13. J . 0. Lxnipen. J . Gen. Microbiol. 48, 249 and 261 (1967). 14. M. R. Pollock. J . Gcn. Microbiol. 26, 239 :ind 267 (1961). 15. D. J . Kushner and M. R . Pollock, J. Gett. Micl-obiol. 26, 255 (1961). 16. D. J . Kushner, J. Gen. Microbiol. 23, 381 (1960). 17. R. P. Novick, Bucteriol. Rev. 33, 210 (1969). 18. M. H. Richmond. A d v n n . Microbiol. Fhysiol. 2, 43 (1968). 19. E. P . Abraham. “The Enzymes,” Vol. 1, Pnrt 2, 1’. 1170, 1951. 20. M . R. Pollock, “The Enzymes,” Vol. 4, p. 269, 1959.
2.
PENICILLINASE AND OTHER
P-LACTAMASES
25
lated and studied against the larger number of scmisyiithetic penicillins and cephalosporins which became available in recent years.
B. DEFINITIONS A N D SPECIFICITY The term p-lactaubase denotes an enzymc which catalyzed thc hydrolysis of the amide bond in the p-lactam ring of 6-amino-penicillanic acid (6-APA) or 7-amino-cephalosporanic acid (7-ACA) and of their iV-acyl derivatives ( 2 ) .Such derivatives arc commonly referred to as penicillins [Fig. 1 (I) 1 and cephalosporins IFig. I (III), (V), and ( V I I ) ] , respectively. There is no evidence that any bond other than thc ainide bond in the intact nucleus of penicillin or cephalosporin is broken by the
(V11)
(VIII)
FIG.1. General structure of substrates tind products of the p-lactamase reaction, Substrates: (I) penicillins; (111). ( V ) , and ( V I I ) rephalosporins. Products: (11) penicilloic acids; ( I V ) , (VI), and (VIII) cephalosporoic acids.
26
NATHAN CITRI
enzyme ( 2 1 ) . Thus the catalytic specificity of p-lactamases appehrs at present to be confined to these two closely related families of antibiotics. The term penicillinuse has been retained in common usage to denote p-lactamase preparations which predominantly catalyze the hydrolysis of penicillins. Conversely, preparations which are more active against cephalosporins have been frequently referred to as cephulosporinases. It is expected that this distinction will disappear as more p-lactamases are found to show a continuous spectrum of activity against penicillins and cephalosporins.
C. OCCURRENCE Although @-lactamaseis widespread among the various bacterial species ( 2 , 9 ) ,the levels of p-lactamase activity within each species are extremely variable. The range (22) and significance of such variations have been the subject of a recent discussion by Pollock ( 2 3 ) . Indeed, studies prompted by variations in the penicillinase-forming ability of bacteria led to important advances in our understanding of the transfer and control of genetic information. In the present context the following observations may be relevant: (1) The gene for p-lactamase is readily lost (or acquired) in strains of bacteria (e.g., staphylococci and enteric bacteria) (24) where it is carried by an extrachromosomal particle (18,2 6 ) . (2) The gene expression (i.e., rate of p-lactamase formation) is often controlled by the mechanism of induction ( 2 , 1 1 , 2 7 ) . (3) A single mutational event, resulting presumably in the replacement of a single amino acid residue, may cause a large decrease in activity (3, 23). 21. The suggestion has been made that certain peptides which have been studied as inducers of p-lactamase in Bacillus cereus and in S. atireus may serve as substrates for the enzyme [A. K. Saz and D. L. Lowery, BBRC 15, 525 (1964); 19, 102 (1965)l. However, there is no evidence that such peptides are in fact hydrolyzed by plactamase. 22. J. M . T . Hamilton-Miller, FEBS Letters 1, 86 (196S). 23. M. R . Pollock, Ann. N . 1’. Acncl. Sci. 151, 502 (1968). 24. In enteric bacteria the p-lactamase gene may be acquired by infection with an R factor (cf. Table IV). This led to the pertinent observation (25) that no plactamase should be regarded as “species-specific” until its gene is shown to bc rhromosomal. 25. N. Datta and M. H. Richmond, BJ 98, 204 (1966). 26. R . P. Novick, Ann. N . Y . Acad. Sci. 128, 165 (1965). 27. M . H . Richmond, Nature 216, 1191 (1967).
2.
PENICILLINASE AND OTHER
P-LACTAMASES
27
D. THECATALYTIC REACIYON By definition, p-lactamase catalyzes the hydrolysis of the P-lactam ring in penicillins or cephalosporins as shown in Fig. 1. The product of the reaction with a penicillin has been identified by Abraham et al. (28) as the corresponding penicilloic acid. Although few other cases have been as rigorously investigated, it is generally accepted that the action of a p-lactamase on a penicillin results in the formation of a relatively stable, single product, penicilloic acid [Fig. 1 (11) 1. An analogous reaction has been postulated for cephalosporins (29,30), but it soon became apparent that the presumed primary product is highly unstable (31, 32) except in the case of cephalosporin y-lactones [Fig. 1 (VII) and (VIII)]. In other cephalosporins the nature of the primary product appears to depend on the substituent R [Fig. 1 (III)] (33).When R’ = H, an unstable “cephttloeporoic acid” is formed [Fig. 1 (V) and ( V I ) ] which is a product analogous to the penicilloic acid. In contrast, when R’ is an acetoxy or pyridinium group, the reaction involves the loss of R’ with the formation of an exocyclic double bond and a rearrangement as shown in Fig. 1 (IV). The resulting compound (Amax = 230 nm) is unstable and undergoes fragmentation (33).
II. Molecular Properties
A. PURIFICATION AND PHYSICAL PROPERTIES The numerous reports of p-lactamase activity in various bacterial strains reflect the widespread occurrence and the clinical importance 28. E. P. Abraham, W. Baker, W. R. Boon, C. T. Calam. H. C. Carrington, E. Chain, H. W. Florey, G. G. Freeman, R. Robinson, and H. G. Saunders, in “The Chemistry of Penicillin” (H. T. Clarke, J. R. Johnson, and R. Robinson, eds.). Chaptrr 2. p . 10. Princeton Univ. Press, Princeton, New Jersey, 1949. 29. B. Crompton. M. Jago, K. Crawford, G . G. F. Newton, and E. P. Abraham. BJ 83, 52 (1962). 30. G. G. F. Newton and E. P. Abraham, Nature 175, 548 (1955). 31. L. D. Sabath, M . Jago, and E. P. Abraham, BJ 96, 739 (1965). 32. G. G. F. Newton, E. P. Abraham. and S. Kuwabara, Antimicrobinl Agents
Chemothempy p. 449 (1968). 33. J. M. T. Hamilton-Miller, G . G . F. Newton, and E. P. Abrahani, BJ 116, 371 (1970). 34. Similarly, two distinct p-lactamasee have been observed in pure cultures of Enlerobncter ( 3 6 ) . 35. T. D. Hennessey, J . Gen. Mksobiol. 49, 277 (1967).
TABLE I PURIFIED ~LACTAMASE PREPARATIONS Source of enzyme 1. Bacillus cereus 569/H
extracellular (8-lactamase I) 2. Bacillus cereus 569/H extracellular (8-lactamase 11) 3. Bacillus crrrus 569/H cell bound (8-lactamase 7 )
4. Bacillus cereus 5/B
ex tracellular
5. Bacillus licheniformis 749/C eutracellular 6. Bacillus licheniformis 749/C cell bound
7. Bacillus lirheniformis 6346/C extracellular and cell bound
Main purification steps 1. Selective adsorption on glass 2. Ammonium sulfate fractionation 1. Ammonium sulfate fractionation 2. Ethanol precipitation 1. Sonic disintegration 2. Selective adsorption on cellulose phosphate 3. 1. CJI-cellulose chromatography Acetone precipitation 2. Ammonium srilfate fractionation 3. 1. Ethanol precipitation Selective adsorption on cellulose phosphate 2. Ammonium sulfate fractionation 1. Lyxozyme and trypsin digestion 2. Ammonium srilfate fractionation 3. DEAIGcelliilose chromatography 1. Ammonium sillfate fractionation
Criteria of homogeneity
Ref.
Electrophoretic and sedimentation patterns Crystallized
36
ChZ-cellulose rechromatography
38
Electrophoretic and sedimentation patterns
39
Sedimentation pattern
40
DEAEcellulose rechromatography
40
Electrophoretic and sediment,ation pat terns
40
37
8. Staphylococcus aurcus (types A, B, and C) extracellular
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
a
1. Selective adsorption on
cellulose phosphate 2. CM-cellulose chromatography 3. Centrifugation on sucrose gradient 4. Electrophoresis on sucrose gradient 1. Ultrasonic disintegration Escherichia coli TEM (R-TEM)o cell bound 2. DEAEcellulose chromatography 3. Gel filtration Escherichia coli K-12 (Glla1)b 1. Release by spheroplasting 2. SE-cellulose chromatography cell bound 3. Chromatography on hydroxylapatite 1. Osmotic release Escherichia coli DB103 (ATSm)a 2. DEAE-cellulose chromatography cell bound 3. Selective adsorption on hydroxylapatite Escherichia coli W3630 ( R G N Z ~ ~ ) ~1. Ultrasonic disintegration 2. DEAE-cellulose chromatography cell bound 3. CM-cellulose chromatography 1. Ultrasonic disintegration Eschwichia coli W3630 (RGN14). 2. Streptomycin precipitation cell bound 3. DEAE-cellulose chromatography Enterobacter cloacae 214 1. Ultrasonic disintegration cell bound 2. Chromatography on CM-Sephadex G-50 3. Gel filtration
CM-cellulose rechromatography ; sedimentation patterns
DEAE-cellulose rechroma tography
41
25,42
Electrophoretic and sedimentation patterns; immunodiff usion Single band on gel electrophoresis
43
Electrophoretic and sedimentation patterns
44
Electrophoretic and sedimentation patterns
44
Electrophoretic pattern and CM-cellulose rechromatography
45
The 8-lactamase gene was acquired by infection with the R factor shown in parentheses. The 8-lactamase gene is chromosomal.
8
30
NATHAN CITRI
of this group of enzymes. However, in most cases no attempts were made t o isolate the enzyme and the available information is too fragmentary to permit characterization a t the molecular level. Table I lists p-lactamase preparations which have been purified and shown to be homogenous. The different purification procedures, summarized in Table I (25,34-45),reflect to some extent differences in the cellular location and in the physical properties of the various preparations. Of particular interest is the isolation of distinct p-lactamases from a single source such as Bacillus cereus strain 569/H, which yields the three P-lactamase preparations listed in Table I (34).This strain is a constitutive mutant of the inducible strain 569 of B. cereus which produces similar levels of all three variants of p-lactamase upon induction (46-49). The relationship between the cell-bound (7-penicillinase) variant and p-lactamase I (a-penicillinase) has been extensively investigated (38, 46, 50-54) but not clarified. Much less is known about the more recently discovered p-lactamase I1 in relation to the two other varieties. One fascinating question which remains open is the interconvertibility of the three varieties (2,.25,37,38). According to a recent report ( 5 5 ) , p-lactamase I of strain 569 can be further resolved by P-cellulose chromatography. The three fractions thus obtained appear to retain their identity on gel electrophoresis, even in the presence of urea, and yield distinctive tryptic digest maps.
36. M. Kogut, M. R . Pollock, and E. J. Tridgell, BJ 62, 391 (1956). 37. S. Kuwabara, and E. P. Abraham, BJ 103, 27C (1967). 38. N. Citri and A. Kalkstein, ABB 121, 720 (1967). 39. M. R. Pollock, A-M. Torriani, and E. J. Tridgell, BJ 62, 387 (1956). 40. M. R. Pollock, BJ 94, 666 (1965). 41. M. H. Richmond, BJ 94, 584 (1965). 42. N. Datta and P. Kontomichalou, Nature 208, 239 (1965). 43. E. B. Lindstrom, H. G. Boman, and B. B. Steele, J. Bucteriol. 101, 218 (1970). 44. S. Yamagishi, K. O’Hara, T. Sawai, and S. Mitsuhashi, J. Biochem. (Tokvo) 66, 11 (1969). 45. T. D. Hennessey and M. H. Richmond, BJ 109, 469 (1968). 46. M. R. Pollock, J . Gen. Microbid 15, 154 (1956). 47. L. D. Sabath and E. P. Abraham, BJ 98, 11C (1966). 48. R. Sheinin, J. Gen. Microbial. 21, 124 (1959). 49. J. D. Duerksen, BBA 87, 123 (1964). 50. J. D. Duerksen and M. L. O’Connor, BBRC 10, 34 (1963). 51. M. R. Pollock and M. Kramer, BJ 70, 665 (1958). 52. N. Citri, BBA 27, 277 (1958). 53. N. Citri, Bull. Res. Council Israel A9, 28 (1960). 54. E. Ron-Zensiper and N. Citri, Nature 198, 887 (1963). 55. J. Imsande, F. D. Gillin, R . J. Tanis, and A. G. Atherly, JBC 245, 2205 (1970).
2.
PENICILLINASE AND OTHER
p-LACTAMASES
31
Several molecular properties of purified P-lactamase preparations are 56-58).I n most cases reported listed in Table I1 (2,25,36,39,40,41,@, the molecular weight is within the range of 28,000-30,000, which seems to be typical for the gram-positive p-lactamases. Similar values have been reported for some but not all, gram-negative p-lactamases. Thus, the values for the enzymes from several strains of E . coli and Salmonella typhinzurium are in the range of 22,00032,000 (43,44, 59,60).In contrast, lower values (14,00C)-17,000) have been reported for other J3-lactamase preparations isolated from E . coli (Table 11, 26, 4 )and from a strain of Enterobacter cloacae (45). The interesting suggestion has been made (61) that the unusually high molecular activity of extracellular p-lactamases (Table 11) may possibly compensate for the dilution of the secreted enzyme in the growth medium. Partial data on the optical rotation (57)and optical rotatory dispersion (55)of native, denatured, and renatured /3-lactamases of B. cereus suggest fairly strong hydrophobic interactions and compact folding. An a-helix content of 30% has been proposed for the native and renatured enzyme of B. cereus 569 (66).
B. COMPOSITION AND SEQUENCE ANALYSES The amino acid composition of the p-lactamases listed in Table I11 (2, 40,41, 43, 45,54, 55, 58, 62-64) underlines the similarities between
preparations derived from closely related strains of bacteria, especially if the combined basic and acidic amino acid content is compared ( 2 3 ) . The staphylococcal enzymes are remarkably rich in lysine, and the lysine-arginine content of the other gram-positive p-lactamases is almost as high. Complete absence of cysteine appears to be characteristic (2,55), although J3-lactamases which contain a t least one cysteine residue have been reported (37,65,66). 56. J. R. Hall and A. G. Ogston, BJ 62, 401 (1956). 57. N. Citri, N. Garber, and M. Sela, JBC 235, 3454 (1960). 58. M. H. Richmond, BJ 88, 452 (1963). 59. C. Lindqvist and K. Nordstrom, J. Bacterial. 101, 232 (1970). 60. H. C. Neu and E. B. Winshell, ABB, 139, 278 (1970). 61. M. R. Pollock, in “The Bacteria” (I. C. Gunsalus and R. Y . Stanier, eds.), Vol. 4,p. 121. Academic Press, New York, 1962. 62. S.Jacobs, Res. Commun. 16th Congr. Quim. Anal., Lisbon, 1966 p . 212 (1956). 62a.M.H.Richmond, personal communication (1966). 63. R. P.Ambler and R. J. Meadway, Nature 222, 24 (1969). 64. R. J. Meadway, BJ 115, 12P (1969). 65. J. T.Smith, Nature 197, 900 (1963). 66. L. D.Sabath and M. Finland, J. Bacterial. 95, 1513 (1968).
TABLE I1 MOLECULAR PROPERTIES OF PURIFIED &LACTAMASES
Source of enzyme"
B. cereus 569 B. cereus 569/H (1) B. cereus 5/B (4) B. lichenifomis 6346 (7) B. Zicheniformis 749/C (6) B. Zicheniformis 749/C (5) S.nureus A ( 8 ) S. aureus B (8) S . aureus C (8) E. wli TEM (9) E. coli G l h l (10)
Molecular weight 31,500 30,800 35,200 28,000 28,000 28,100 29,600 29,600 29,600 16,700
29,OOO
Molecular activityb 1.60 X 1.53 X 1.48 X 2.10 X 1.18 x 1.08 x 2.0 x 2.8 X 1.9 X 2.0 X 2.08 X
106 1W 106 lW 106 106 104 lo3 l(r 10'
1Oa
Sedimentation coefficient (10'8 X ~ 2 0 2.68e 2.5-2.65" 2.82~ 2.63 2.70 2.66 2.62 2.5 2.5 1.85 3.4
EE , ~ )
(nm/mg N) 6.0 6.35 7.35 5.65 5.45 4.75 7.38
Electrophoretic mobility0
(cm*/sec/VX
Asc., 1.68; Desc., 1.70d Asc., 1.73; Desc., 1.65d
Desc., 3.4@ Asc., 4.95; Desc., 4.50/ Asc., 4.33; Desc., 3.65/ -
-
13.1
-
~
Numbers in parentheses are the serial numbers of the preparations in Table I. Moles benzylpenicillin hydrolyzed per mole enzyme per minute at 30". The diffusion coefficients determined (66) for preparations 569, 569/H and 5/B are 8.28, 8.38, and 7.80 (107 x D m J . In glycine buffer, p = 0.2, pH 8.4. e In glycine buffer, p = 0.2, pH 8.15. In veronal buffer, p = 0.1, pH 8.15. u Aw., ascending; l)esc., descending. a
b
Ref.
10-6)
36, 66 36, 66, 67 36, 39, 66 2, 40 2, 40 40 68
41 41 26
43
TABLE I11 AMINOACID COMPOSITION OF B-LACTAMASES E. coli
B. cereus
B. lichenijormis
S. a u r m
E. cloacae Amino acids Lysine Histidine Arginine Aspartic acid Threonine Serine Glutamic Proline Glycine Alanine Valine Methionine Isoleucine Leucine Tyrosine Phenylalanine Cysteine WPhPhan N-term AA Total ammonia amide
214 G l l a l D3lo (Ref. 43) (Ref. 46) 9 2 5
10 8
7 12 9 10 15 10 5 6 10 5 3 ? ?
17 4 10 25 18 16
33 19 23 28 17 4 15 23 10 8 0
-
17 4 9 23 18 14 32 20 22 29 17 5 17 24 12 7 0 6 Ala (22)
5/B
569 569/H (Ref. 2, 62)
31 23 6 6 13 11 33 25 9 12 2 4 25 22 6 10 19 21 30 29 17 15 5 1 22 20 17 19 5 7 7 8 0 0 Aspb Lysc
6346/C (Ref. 40)
749/c (Ref. 63, 64)
21 5 10 31 13 5 22 10 19 33 17 1 22 18 4 6 0
19 1 12 28 18 10 24 9 12 19 10 5 9 21 5
24 1 15 37 21 11 27 11 15 26 15
5
-
0 -
-
LYS
7 3 Lysd (20)
5 14 27 6
TypeA TypeB (Ref. 64,68) (Ref. 4 1 ) 43 2 4 39 13 19 18 9 12 18 16 3 19 22 13 7 0 2 LYS (29)
43 2 5
42 12 17 22 11 16 21 11 2 15 22 9 7 0 -
(28)
TypeC (Ref. 4 1 ) 45 3 4 39 11 17 18 10 15 19 11 2 18 23 14 7 0 -
LYS (32)
The &Iactamase gene was received from G l l a l and both eneymes were purified by identical procedures (Serial No. 11 in Table I). Richmond (@a). c Imsande et al. (66). d See, however, text and Ambler and Meadway (63). a
TABLE IV OF VARIOUSSUBSTRATES (RATEOF HYDROLYSIS OF BENZYLPENICILLIN = 100) RELATIVE RATESOF HYDROLYSIS ~~
w
I@
~
Substrates
Source of enzyme"
Phenoxymethyl- Ampipencillin d i n
Bacillus licheniformis Strain 749/C (3 isozymes) [5] (mutant 77) Strain 6346/C [7] Bacillus cereus Strain 569/H 8-lactamase I [I] plactamase I1 [2] 8-lactamase y [3] Strain 5/B [4] Staphylowccus aureua Types A and B [8] Type C I81 Escherichia w l i Strain TEM (R-TEM) [9] Strain K-12 (Gllal) [lo] Strain W3630 ( h N Z 3 8 ) [I21 Strain W3630 ( h14) ~ [I31 Enlerobacler cloacae 214 [14] a
-
153
64-74
-
-
Cloxacillin
0.45-0.50 4.0 1.0
-
-
-
-
4.6-5.0 5.0 13
0.7 89 <0.1 -
40 9
-
3.5 1.0
10 -
0.5 1.2
5 89 5 4
6-APA
-
100 100
-
1.5 0.6
4.5 1.0
50 -
1 -
-
-
110 4 450
-
-
27 292
-
140
-
-
-
130
86
11
-
-
-
-
171 96
120 64 55
Benzylcephalosporin
Oxacillin
3.0 89 26 1.8
-
Cephalosporin C
Methicillin
-
Numbers in brackets are the serial number of the preparation in Table I.
85 1.2 263
0.3-0.4 0.9.5-1.06 11.0 15 42
17.5-19.8 275 -
Ref.
23 23 40
3 41 17 -
38, 75 37 38 29, 76
-
-
41,58
0.8 920 -
16 -
65 72 3.6
44
-
-
69
44
1830
8200
45
80
7200
<0.1 -
Cephaloridine
-
41 25 43
f
ael
E
2.
PENICILLINASE AND OTHER
p-LACTAMASES
35
The data on terminal amino acids (Table 111) support the accepted notion that every p-lactamase consists of a single polypeptide chain. There are no indications to the contrary, although firm evidence is lacking in most cases. Further observations pertaining to the chemical composition of plactamases and comments on the significance of the reported variations can be found in recent reviews ( d , S , 23). Ambler and Meadway have very recently reported on their studies of the amino acid sequence of p-lactamases from representative strains of S. aureus and B. lichenijormis (63, 6 4 ) . The complete sequence of the p-lactamase protein of S. aureus PCI (type A) was determined by the characterization of the peptides produced by digestion with trypsin, chymotrypsin, or pepsin. The sequence analysis of the p-lactamase protein of B . licheniformis 749/C was performed on both the extracellular and the cell-bound enzyme (cf. serial Nos. 5 and 6, Table I ) . The slight differences between the two forms were confined to the N-terminus and attributed to the difference in the release mechanism. Peptides corresponding to about 90% of the molecule have been characterized and their sequences combined to form five larger fragments. The results of these studies are summarized in Fig. 2, which presents the S. aureus sequence and the B. lichenijormis fragments arranged in such a way as to give the best possible match with that sequence. This arrangement implies that the B . licheniformis molecule is several residues longer a t each end (see also Table 111).The authors estimated that the complete sequence of the B. lichenijormis protein will show about 40% identity with that of S. aureus. This estimate has been most recently confirmed (64), and the homology proposed in Fig. 2 is now firmly established. There can be little doubt that both proteins share a common origin and that their divergent evolution accounts for the differences in the catalytic properties listed in Tables IV and V.
111. Catalytic Properties
A. METHODSOF ASSAY The methods most commonly used for the quantitative assay of plactamase are based on one of the following principles: (1) Manometric or alkalimetric titration of the new carboxyl group formed by hydrolysis of the p-lactam ring; (2) iodometric titration of the product, and (3)
1
8
Lys-
Thr-
26 27 -THR- Lss-Thr-
3
4
5
Glu- Met- Lys28
6 7 Lys- Glu-
Asp- Asp-
8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 Leu- Asn- Asp- LEV- GLU- Lys- Lys- TyrPhe-
Lys-
LD Leu-
Glu-
Glu-
Glu- Phe-
Ser-
29 Gly-
30 Lys-
Glu-
32 VAL-
Gly-
Thr-
Asn- Arg-
Thr-
Val-
Ah-
Tyr-
Arg-
LC Pro- Asp-
Glu-
51 -Ser-
5’2 Ala-
53 Ile-
54 55 56 Leu- Leu- Glu-
5i Gln-
58 Val-
59 Pro-
60 Tyr-
61 62 Asn- Lys-
63 64 65 Leu- Asn- Lys-
Ser-
Ile
(Glx,
GIx,
Asx.
76 -Ala-
79 80 81 87 83 84 85 86 TYI:- Ser- PRO- ILE- Leu- GLT- LYS- Tyr- VAL- GlyLE Tyr- Asn- Pro- IleThr- Glu- Lys- His- Val- Asp-
87
38 89 Asp- Ile-
31
33 34 35 LD- Phe- Am-
Lys-
8
Ah-
-Val-
??
36
Ser-
id
16 17 18 Asn- ALA- His-
19 He-
20 21 GLT- Val-
Ah-
Leu-
Gly-
Asp-
57 38 39 40 41 42 ASP- Lys- ARG- PHE- ALA- Tyr-
Lys-
Arg-
Asx,
Phe- Ala66 Lys-
L e u ) Arg-
-Tyr-
Jer
126
127 -Oh- Leu-Lys-
Ile-
(Asp.
Asti) Ala-
128
199 130 G L P - ASP- Lys-
106
LCJ- Ile-
112 113 LPS- GluLB Leu- Lys- Gln-
131 13‘7 13) VAL- Thr- Asn-
134 Pro-
135 Val-
136 137 AKG- Tyr-
(Thr.
Gln-
Asn-
Gly-
Asp-
0111- Val
Asx,
Pro,
Glx)
Arg-
Phe-
151 132 153 .Asp- TIIR- Ser-
154 Thr-
155 Pro-
15G Ala-
157 158 ALA- I’he-
159 Gly-
160 Lys-
161 TI r-
162
Srr)
Ala-
Are
Ala-
Val-
Thr-
Scr-
Asx)
Thr
(Tlir,
Leu-
44 45 46 43 ALA-, S E R - T H R - Ser-
Phe
Ah-
Leu- Asp
48 49 47 LTS- ALA- IleAla-
50 Am-
Leu
Ser-
Thr-
Ilc-
Lp-
68 His-
69 Ile-
70 Asn-
71 Lys-
73 74 ASP- ASP- Ile-
75 Val-
Thr-
Tyr-
Thr-
Arg-
Asp-
Asp-
Leu-
9.5 96 Ile- Glu-
07 Ala-
08
Ser-
99 100 Met- Thr-
67 ValLE Ile-
91 92 93 THR-LEU- LTS- Ala90
94 LEr-
7‘7
Asn-
Thr- Gly- Met- Thr- Leu- Lys
107 10rl 109 110 111 ALA- Asn- A S S - L ~ s - I L E - IleAh-
Ile-
23 24 !25 AbA- LEU- ASP-
Phe- Ala-
Ile-
163
Ser!
Leu- Arg.
103 Arg-
124 125 LEV- Lya-
Pro)
Lru-
Glu-
Leu- Arg-
144
145 Ser-
146 Pro-
147 L?s-
148 Stx-
149 Lys-
150 Lys-
(GI?,
Pro,
Thr.
1;1x, Asx,
Asr.
Leu- Ala
119 Val-
(Ser,
140 141 142 143 GLU- LEU- Asn- Tyr-
114 115 116 117 ILE- GLP- GLT- Ile-
138 139 GLU- IleLB Glu- Pro-
Ah,
120 121 122 LJ-s- LTS- Gin-
Glu-
118 Lys-
Lys-
102 103 104 105 -TYR- S E R - Asp- Asn- Thr101
Lys-
Pi! Tyr-
Gly-
Glu-
GI?-
Leu-
1G4 165 166 LEU- A m - Lys- Leu- IleLB Leu- A r e 41a- Phe- A h -
Glu
Tyr-
Gln-
Glu-
Val
16T Ah-
168 Asn-
160
Leu-
Glu-
(Asp.
Lys- Lys-
17‘3
174
GI!--
1TO 171 179 LTS- LEU- Ser-
L?-S.
4:
Asp-
LXS- Leo-
Ser-
Glu-
Pro-
175
1.1.- ASU
Lys-
176 - L p
IT7
178
Lys- Plie-
179 180 LEV- Leu-
181 182 ASP- Leu-
NET- Leu- Asn- Asn- Lys- Ser-
183
Leo-
Asp- Trp-
Met-
184
185
186
187
188
1R9 Gly-
190 Asp-
191 Tlir-
192 193 194 LEV- ILE- Lyr-
195 Asp-
196 197 GLT- Val-
Pro-
193
199 Lys-
200 Asp-
Asn)
Leu- Ile-
Arg-
-4Ia-
Gly
(Asp,
Glu,
Pro.
Trp.
217 .4sn-
919 Val-
220 Ma-
5'11 Phc-
222 Val-
223 224 Tyr- Pro-
225 Lyn-
249
250
LB
Lys- Arg- Asp (Thr. Thr,
Leu-
201 202 -Tyr- Lys-
203 204 Val- Ala-
205 206 207 208 209 ASP- LTS- Ser- CLY- Gln-
Gly,
Ala.
Val,
Val)
Asp-
226
227
228
Gln-
Ser-
229 (;hi-
230 231 Pro- Ile-
-lily.
252 ILE- Ser2.51
-1lew
Ile-
-Are Glu-
Ala-
253 254 GLU- Thr-
Glu-
Ah-
255 Ah-
Thr-
Lys- Thr232 Val-
210 211 ALA- IleLB
Ala-
Gly,
212 213 Thr- Tyr-
214 Ala-
215 216 Ser- Arg-
Thr-
(ily-
Ala-
Ala-
Ber-
Tyr-
Cly-
Arg- Asn- Asp- Ilc-
Aln
233 Leu-
234 Val-
235 Ile-
236 Phe-
237 Thr-
238
239 Asn- Lys-
240 241 ASP- Asn-
242 Lys-
244 Asp-
Ala-
Val-
Leu-
Ser-
Ser-
Arg-
Asp
(Ma,
Lys,
256 257 LYR- Srr-
258 259 260 961 VAL- MET- LYS- Glo-
252
263
264
265
266
967
Phc
Lys-
LA Val-
Leu- Asn-
Met- Asn-
Gly-
Val-
218 Asp-
Met-
Lys- Ala-
243 SerLA Asp,
245 246 LTS- Pro-
L?-s) 1 ~ s - Tyr-
247
248
b s n - A>I'- LYS- LEUAsp-
ASP- Lys-
Leu-
Lys
FIG.2. Amino acid sequences of P-lactamases of Staphylococcus aureus PCI (upper line) and of Bacillw licheniformis 749/C (fragments LA to LE, lower line). Matching residues are shown in block letters (upper line). (From Ambler and Meadway, 63.)
TABLE V APPARENTDISSOCIATION CONSTANT^
(pM)
Substrates Source of enzyme" Bacillus licheniformis Strain 749/C (5) Strain 6346/C (7) Bacillus cereus Strain 569 p-lactamase I* Strain 569/H 8-lactamase I (1) p-lactamase I1 (2) Strain 5/B (4) Staphylococcus aureus Type A (8) Type 80/81b Escherichia coli Strain 214 Tb Strain TEM (9) Strain W3630 ( F ~ 238) N (12) Strain W3630 (&N 14) (13) Aerobacter cloacaeb Pseudomanas pyocyanea
Benzylpenicillin
49 9.5
Ampicillin -
-
Methicillin 0.93 0.23
Oxacillin
Cloxacillin
-
-
b
16.6 16.7
Cephalosporin C
50 50
Cephaloridine
Ref.
-
48
110
410
550
-
-
-
-
60 3300 43
1300 3300
570 1600 330
2300 -
3000 -
-
1100 -
3300
-
460 1600 230
-
77, 79, 80 37 20, 77
5 12
170
16000 5000
5000 -
-
120
100 -
-
41, 58, 81
22 5.1 27.8 8 13
35oc 2.3 15.9 34.0 541 -
>46& 22 26.3 222
-
-
-
1000
600 111 400 69 130
44= 3.2
-
-
-
0.lP
-
1.lC
0.g 13.0 16.5c 0.026
Numbers in parentheses are the serial numbers of the preparations in Table I. For purification procedure see original references. c Based on KI with benzylpenicillin as substrate. a
6-APA
-
-
46, 77, 78
78 82, 83
25
44 44 83 31
2.
PENICILLINASE AND OTHER
P-LACTAMASES
39
colorimetric determination of the hydroxaniate formed by residual substrate. The various applications of these and several other principles have been reviewed elsewhere (67, 6‘8).The assay methods, primarily designed for benzylpenicillin, the standard substrate, are generally suitable for other substrates, although in some cases the procedure has to be modified. Specific problems involved in the replacement of benzylpenicillin with other substrates, especially cephalosporins (69) have been recently discussed ( 2 , 31, 32, 7 0 ) . )
B. KINETICSAND SUBSTRATE SPECIFICITY
It is generally agreed that the &I-lactamase reaction is of zero order in the presence of saturating substrate concentration (71) and that the enzyme displays typical Michaelis-Menten kinetics over a wide rangc of concentrations (72). The slight deviations, which have been observed with crude enzyme preparations only (59, 73) deserve further investigation ( 4 ) . Anomalously high dissociation constants recorded with certain substrate combinations (74) have been correlated with the effect of such substrates on the conformation of p-lactamase (see Section IV,B) . Individual “substrate profiles” of variously related p-lactamases and apparent dissociation constants for several substrates are listed in Tables IV (2.9)25, 29,37, 38,40, 41, 43-45, 58, 75, 76) and V (20, 25, 31, 37, 40) 41, &,46,58,76,77--83), respectively. An interesting attempt to correlate )
67. J. M. T. Hamilton-Miller, J. T. Smith, and R. Knox, J. Pharm. Pharmacol. 15,81 (1963). 68. N. Citri, Methods M e d . Res. 10, 221 (1964). 69. E. P. Abraham, Phamtacol. R e v . 14, 473 (1962). 70. M. R. Pollock, J. Fleming, and S. Petrie, Proc. 2nd Meeting Federation Euro-
pean Biochem. SOC.,1966 p. 139. Pergamon Press, Oxford, 1967. 71. R. J. Henry and R. D. Housewright, JBC 167, 559 (1947). 72. J. E. Banfield, Experientia 13, 403 (1957). 73. W.Rothe, Pharmazie 5, 25 (1950). 74. N. Zyk and N. Citri, BBA 151, 306 (1968). 75. N. Citri and N. Zyk, BBA 99, 427 (1965). 76. S. M. Chaikovskaya and T. G. Venkina, Antibiotiki 9, 329 (1964). 77. N. Citri, N. Garber, and A. Kalkstein, BBA 92, 572 (1964). 78. R. H. Depue, A. G. Moat, and A. Bondi, ABB 107, 347 (1964). 79. F. R. Batchelor, J. Cameron-Wood, E. B. Chain, and G. N. Rolinson, Proc. R o y . SOC.B154, 514 (1961). 80. S. Kuwabara and E. P. Abraham, BJ 115, 859 (1969). 81. M. H. Richmond, Brit. M e d . Bull. 21, 260 (1965). 82. J. M. T. Hamilton-Miller and J. T. Smith, Nature 201, 999 (1964). 83. J. M. T. Hamilton-Miller, J. T. Smith, and R.Knox, Nature 208, 235 (1965).
40
NATHAN CITRI
these values in a physiologically meaningful way has been made by Pollock (40), who pointed out that under typical ecological conditions the enzyme functions at unsaturating substrate concentrations. Thus the “physiological efficiency” of a p-lactamase depends on both the V,,,,, and the K , value and may be conveniently expressed as the ratio VlnaJKm. There can be little doubt that this ratio is an important parameter in comparing 8-lactamases in any context dealing with the ecology, evolution, and physiological significance of the enzyme (2,25,40,84).
C. STRUCTURAL MODIFICATIONS IN SUBSTRATES The effect of replacement of the APA nucleus with an ACA nucleus on the susceptibility of the substrate to enzymic hydrolysis depends on the nature of the p-lactamase ( 2 ) . It has been richly illustrated in the case of the p-lactamase of Pseudomonas pyocganea (31)and analyzed in terms of conformative response (see Section IV,B) in a study of a B . cereus p-lactamase (75).I n that study the role of the nucleus was examined in both catalytic and noncatalytic enzyme-substrate interactions. Little has been published on the effect of modifications within each nucleus, presumably because such modifications lead, as a rule, to the loss of antibiotic activity. Conversion of the carboxyl groups in penicillins confers partial resistance to p-lactamase (85-87).I n cephalosporins, replacement of the acetyl group in position 3 of the dihydrothiazine ring [ R in Fig. 1, (111)] by pyridine causes increased susceptibility to hydrolysis by p-lactamases of Pseudomonas pyocyanea (31,88),Enterobacter cloacae (45),E . coli (42,88),and both the extracellular and cell-bound enzymes of B . cereus (38)* The most common modification is the replacement of the N-acyl substituent (“side chain” R in Fig. 1 ) , especially in penicillins. Indeed, the differences in K , and relative V,,, values among the penicillins listed in Tables IV and V all result from the differences in the nature of the side chain. Analysis of such data (Table VI) (25,@, 4,70,76,77-79, 81, 89,901 84. M. R. Pollock, Antimicrobial Agents Chemotherapy p. 292 (1965). 85. D. E. Cooper and S.B. Brinkely, JACS 70, 3966 (1948). 86. N . J. Huang, T. A. Seto, J. M. Weaver, A. R. English, T. J. McBride, and G. M. Schull, Antimicrobial Agents Chemotherapy p. 493 (1964). 87. E. Grunberg and G . Beskid, Antimicrobial Agents Chemotherapy p. 619 (1968). 88. L. D. Ssbath and M. Finland, Ann. N. Y. Acad. Sci. 145, 237 (1967). 89. R. P. Novick, BJ 83, 229 (1962). 90. J. M. T. Hamilton-Miller, BJ 87, 209 (1963).
2.
41
PENICILLINASE AND OTHEB ~-LACTAMASES
TABLE VI EFFECTOF SIDE CHAINON CATALYTIC CONSTANTS OF PENICILLINS Side chain Phenylacetyl-
V,..:: V,..P 5.3 16.7 2.6 20.0 10.0
Phenylglycyl-
Dimethoxybenzoyl-
K,r: K,P 0.003 0.10 0.02 3.0 20.8
7.7
0.57
1.37
1. o
90.0 0.38 0.77 1.3 1.5 25.0 3.6 1.71 1.07 0.08
0.17 0.67
0.014 0.19 0.13 0.105 0.054 1.40 0.007 0.61 0.15 0.15 37.2 41.5
Source of enzyme
Ref.
S . aureua 524 SC S . aureua 147 B. cereua 569/H B. lichenifomis 749/C (wild type) B. lichenifomis 749/C (mutant 19) B. lichenifomis 6346/C (wild type) B. l i c h e n i f m i s 6346/C (mutant 3) E. coli G l l a l E. wli GN 238 E. coli GN 14 E . euli TEM K . aerogenes 418 S . aurew 147 B. coli G l l a l E . coli GN 238 E. coli GN 14 B. cereua 569/H S . auras 524 SC 8.aureus 147
89 78 79 70
70
70
ro 43
44 44 86
90 81
43
44 44
76, 77, m 89 78
~~
V,..I and K,I are the respective constants for the unsubstituted 6-APA; V,,, K,t are the corresponding constants for the indicated 6-APA derivatives. 0
and
brings out the striking differences in the response of the various p-lactamases to a given side chain. Such differences are clearly evident even in closely related enzyme preparations and in some instances (e.g., the mutants of B . Zicheniformis) may result from the replacement of a single amino acid. The role of the side chain in both catalytic and noncatalytic (76) enzyme-substrate interactions has been investigated in considerable detail (reviewed in reference a ) , and a mechanism has been suggested which may explain the rate-controlling effect of side chains on the catalytic activity of p-lactamase (see Section IV,B).
D. STRUCTURAL MODIFICATIONS IN
THE
ENZYME
No data are available on the effect of defined structural modifications on the properties of p-lactamases. Indirect evidence bearing on the
42
NATHAN CITRI
role of the primary structure in catalytic activity comes from the studies of Pollock (23) on the effect of mutations on the properties of the plactamase of B. licheniformis 749/C. It appears that structural mutations, presumably involving a single amino acid replacement in the enzyme molecule, frequently cause a considerable decrease in thermostability (70) along with a decrease in the catalytic activity ( 2 3 ) . The substrate profile is altered as in the case of the mutant strain 749/C/77 (Table IV) with preferential loss of “penicillinase” activity. The change in thermostability and in response to antibodies (see also Section V) implies an altered conformation in such mutant enzymes (23,7 0 ) . A comparison of spontaneously and experimentally released p-lactamase preparations of B . lichenifomis (40) indicates that the ends of the polypeptide chain can vary without affecting the properties of the enzyme. Although such preparations differ in the C- and N-terminus, they are serologically and catalytically indistinguishable (40,63). Similarly, B. lichenifomis 749/C isozymes, separable by starch gel electrophoresis or DEAEchromatography and believed to differ a t the C- or N-terminus C40),have identical substrate specificities (Table V) . Other indirect (genotypic or phenotypic) modifications of the primary structure (70, 91, 92) as well as reversible conformational transitions (52, 67, 93) have been reviewed by Citri and Pollock ( 2 ) and more recently by Pollock ( 4 0 ) .
E. OTHERFACTORS AFFECTING ACTIVITY 1. Effect of pH and Temperature
Typical pH-activity curves obtained with gram-positive p-lactamases and benzylpenicillin show maxima in the range of p H 6.0-7.0 with a rather sharp decline in the alkaline range ( 2 ) . Recent data on gramnegative p-lactamases (25,31,43,44,59,65,90,94-96)show optimal values scattered over the range of pH 5.0-8.5. A shift in the pH-activity curve has been observed when benzylpenicillin was replaced with 6-APA (78,79) or methicillin (54) but not with cephalosporin C ( 3 1 ) . Few data are available on the temperature dependence of p-lactamase activity ( 2 ) . With benzylpenicillin as the substrate, the optimal tem91. 92. 93. 94. 95. 96.
D. A. Dubnau and M. R. Pollock, J . Gen. Microbiol. 41, 7 (1965). M. H. Richmond, BJ 77, 112 (1960). N. Citri and N. Garber, BBA 30, 664 (1958). J. T. Smith and J. M. T. Hamilton-Miller, Nature 197, 976 (1963). J. M. T. Hamilton-Miller, BBRC 13, 43 (1963). G. A . J. Ayliffe, J. Gen. Microbiol. 30, 339 (1!963).
2.
PENICILLINASE AND OTHER
p-LACTAMASES
43
peratures reported range from 30" (44,97)through 35'40" for B. cereus p-lactamases (71,98)to 45"-55" for several enzyme preparations (&,89,98,99).Optimal temperatures for other substrates have not been reported. It has been pointed out (100) that the activation energy of the catalytic reaction (with benzylpenicillin) is generally higher in the gram-positive p-lactamases (7.2-8.8 x 103 cal/mole) (71,100,101) than in gramnegative enzymes (3.3-5.2 X lo3cal/mole) (31,94,95,100). Replacement of benzylpenicillin with cephalosporin C (31) caused considerable increase in the activation energy. 2. Activators and Inhibitors
As a rule p-lactamase activity does not depend on specific activators or cofactors. The only exception so far is p-lactamase I1 which requires Znz+for stability and activity (37).The metal binding characteristics of this enzyme have been described in a recent study (66).In other cases where the ion content of the assay medium may affect the activity (@,44), no absolute requirements were demonstrated. The search for selective means of inactivation, prompted by clinical considerations, has not been successful, although many substrate analogs act as powerful competitive inhibitors ( 2 ) . On the other hand, irreversible inhibition may result from interaction with substrate analogs which oause labilization of the enzyme (see Section IV,B) . Specific stimulation and inhibition by homologous antibodies is reviewed in Section V. Inhibition of a staphylococcal p-lactamase by certain dipeptides has but it is not clear whether the active site was directly been reported (102), involved. Other remotely related and unrelated compounds as well as metals have been implicated, but the results are largely inconclusive (8,9,20,&). Of the nonspecific inhibitors, the thiol reagents have been most extensively tested and usually found ineffective. This is not surprising in view of the available data on the amino acid composition of p-lactamases (Table 111) which show total absence of cysteine. However, interesting exceptions have been reported. Thiol reagents inhibit the Zn2+-dependent p-lactamase I1 of B . cereus (37, 66) and the &lac97. M. Goldner and R. J. Wilson, Can. J. Microbiol. 7, 45 (1981). 98. E. E. D. Manson, M. R. Pollock, and E. J. Tridgell, J. Gen. Microbiol. 11, 493 (1954). 99. A. Royce, C. Bowler, and G. Sykes, J. Pharm. Pharmacol. 4, 904 (1952). 100. J. T. Smith and J. M . T. Hamilton-Miller, Nature 197, 769 (1963). 101. N. Zyk and N. Citri, BBA 159, 317 (1968). 102. A. K. Saz, D. L. Lowry, and L. J. Jackson, J . Bacten'ol. 82, 298 (1961).
44
NATHAN CITRI
tamases of K . aerogenes and of A . cloacae (65,lOS).I n the case of /3-lactamase I of B. cereus, where the absence of cysteine is reportedly established (Table 111) (lO4),inhibition by PCMB (75)and by Hgz+ ( K , = 1.4 X lo-' M ) (105)has been demonstrated. The former depends on conformative response to substrate analogs (75).The inhibition by Hg2+, which is accompanied by a slight shift in the CD signal in the region of 205-240 nm, is partly reversed by EDTA (105). Inhibition by chelating agents has been reported only in the case of the Zn2+-dependentp-lactamase I1 (47,106). Alcohols may inhibit (107), or stimulate (102).The inhibitory effect of alkyl sulfates (108,109)depends on the length of the alkyl chain (109,110). Thermal inactivation has been studied mainly in the B . cereus enzymes (S8,98,111,llb). The protective effect of certain macromolecules (e.g., gelatin) is observed at loo", but paradoxically not a t 70" (113,114). The effect of various substrates on the thermostability of several has been studied in the context of conp-lactamases (38,77,112,115) formative response (see Section IV,B) .
IV. Conformation and Function
A. NONSPECIFIC CONFORMATIONAL TRANSITIONS The absence of disulfide bridges appears to be one of the few characteristics common to all p-lactamases. There are indications that in one case a t least (the cell-bound 7-type p-lactamase of B. cereus) the tertiary 103. J. T. Smith, BJ 87, 40P (1963). 104. M. R. Pollock and M. H. Richmond, Nature 194, 446 (1962). 105. L. D'Souza and R. A. Day, Abstr., 168th A m , Chem. SOC.Meeting, New York p. 60 (1969). 106. L. D. Sabath and E. P. Abraham, Antimicrobial Agents Chemotherapy p. 392 (1966). 107. E. B. McQuarrie and A. J. Lubmann, A B B 5, 307 (1944). 108. R. Brunner, A. Kraushaar, and E. Prohaska, Antibiot. Ann. p. 169 (1960). 109. Z. C . Kaminski, J. Bacteriol. 85, 1182 (1963). 110. E. Rauenbusch, M e d . Chem., Abhandl. Med.-Chem. Forschungsataetterr Farbenfabriken Bayer A . G . 7 , 466 (1963). 111. E. E. D. Manson and M. R . Pollock, J. Gen. Macrobiol. 8, 163 (1953). 112. N. Citri and N. Garber, BBA 67, 64 (1963). 113. D. H. Williams, 111, A. Bondi, A. G . Moat, and F. Ahmad, J. Bacteriol. 91, 257 (1966). 114. For an interpretation of this and related observations, the original report (11.9) should be consulted.
115. N. Zyk and N. Citri, BBA 159, 327 (1968).
2.
PENICILLINASE AND OTHER
P-LACTAMASES
45
structure of the enzyme is nevertheless stabilized by firm, possibly coI n more typical cases, valent, attachment to the cell membrane (38,48). and certainly in all extracellular P-lactamases analyzed so far, the conformation of the enzyme is not constrained by covalent bonds. A likely consequence is the marked flexibility of the conformation of the extracellular p-lactamases of several bacilli (67,77). Reversible transitions in the conformation (and antigenic structure) have been demonstrated in extracellular p-lactamases of B. cereus 569/H (69,67,93) and of B. cereus (52).Thus, a mild treatment with alkali, urea, or guanidine .HCl resulted in a markedly increased levorotation and in exposure of iodine-sensitive regions. Similar changes, including almost total loss of antigenic identity, were observed when the enzyme was adsorbed to charged surfaces. Surprisingly, the adsorbed enzyme was fully active (68)and this led to an inquiry into the possibility that the substrate may restore the conformation of the active site (93,116).
B. SPECIFIC TRANSITIONS : CONFORMATIVE RESPONSE I n a series of papers on the interaction of several purified p-lactamase preparations with various substrates (75,77,101,118,116,117-120), evidence was presented which indicates a possibly meaningful correlation between the structure of the substrate, its effect on the conformation of the enzyme, and the catalytic activity. Much of the evidence (partly reviewed in reference 8) is based on interactions with penicillins differing in the structure of the side chain (substituent R in Fig. 1). As pointed out above (Section 111) the side chain controls the rate of the catalytic reaction. It was subsequently observed that it also controls the conformative response, i.e., the effect of the substrate on the conformation of the enzyme (76).Significantly, the nature of the conformative response could be correlated with the effect on the catalytic activity. Thus, the conformative response to benzylpenicillin and other penicillins with side chains promoting the rate of catalysis is characterized by increased stability of the enzyme molecule. Conversely, penicillins which carry side chains interfering with the catalytic activity labilize the enzyme and facilitate inactivation by heat, urea, proteolysis, iodination, or photooxidation. Such penicillins act as competitive inhibi116. 117. 118. 119. 120.
N. Citri and N. Garber, BBA 38, 50 (1960). N. Garber and N. Citri, BBA 62, 385 (1962). N. Citri and N. Garber, BBRC 4, 143 (1961). N. Citri and N. Garber, J . Pharm. Pharmctcol. 14, 784 (1962) N. Zyk and N. Citri, BBA 146, 219 (1967).
46
NATHAN CITRI
tors of the hydrolysis of benzylpenicillin. The competitive relationship at the catalytic level is reflected in a corresponding shift in the conformative response. These observations led to the conclusion that the side chain of penicillin affects the rate of the reaction by modifying the conformative response of the enzyme. Subsequent studies led to the suggestion that the modified conformative response is strongly reflected in the binding properties of the enzyme (120).Although lacking direct support, this suggestion provides a single explanation for two sets of discrepancies observed when a comparison is made of enzyme-substrate dissociation constants based on the catalytic activity with those based on the conformative response ( 7 4 ) .
V. Immunological Studies
The immunology of p-lactamases has been studied fairly extensively (16,23,41,4.3,70,115,121-124) and reviewed elsewhere (70,125).At the molecular level, differences in antigenicity could be usually correlated with differences in composition and physical properties ( 7 0 ) . On the other hand, reversible changes in antigenicity-without apparent loss of activity-could be correlated with reversible conformational transitions ( 5 2 ) . The effect of specific antibodies on the catalytic activity of p-lactamase is usually inhibitory, as expected (125).I n some cases, however, it may be stimulatory ( 7 0 , 1 2 2 ) .This surprising effect depends on the structure of the substrate (101, 122) or on structural mutations in the enzyme ( 7 0 ) . It has been suggested (70,101,115) that the stimulation results from the effect of the antibody on the conformation of the enzyme. Indeed, the effect of antibodies on the conformation of p-lactamase shows a quantitative correlation with their effect on the catalytic activity (101). Specifically, homologous antibodies suppress the conformative response and virtually eliminate the effect of the side chain of the substrate on the rate of catalytic activity (116). These results (cf. Section IV,B) imply a plausible mechanism (115) which may account for both the stimulating and inhibitory effect of antibodies on the activity of p-lactamase. 121. 122. 123. 124. 125.
M. R. Pollock, J. Gen. Microbial. 14, 90 (1956). M. R. Pollock, Immunology 7, 707 (1964). H. K. Rhodes, M. Goldner, and R. J. Wilson, Can. J. Microbiol. 7 , 355 (1961). N. Citri and G. Strejan. Nnture 190, 1010 (1961). M. R. Pollock, Ann. N . Y . Acad. Sci. 103, 989 (1963).
Purine. Purine Nucleoside. and Purine Nucleotide Aminohydrolases C . L. ZIELKE
C. H . SUELTER
I . Introduction . . . . . . . . . . A . Historical Background . . . . . . B . Distribution . . . . . . . . . C . Methods of Assay . . . . . . . 11. Adenine Aminohydrolase . . . . . . . I11. Adenosine Aminohydrolase . . . . . . . A . Molecular Properties . . . . . . . B . Catalytic Properties . . . . . . . C . Considerations of Physiological Function . . IV . 5'-Adenylic Acid Aminohydrolase . . . . . A. Molecular Characteristics . . . . . . B . Catalytic Properties . . . . . . . V . Adenine Nucleoside and Nucleotide Aminohydrolast. (Nonspecific) . . . . . . . . . A . Adenosine Aminohydrolase (Nonspecific) . . B . Adenine Nucleotide Aminohydrolase . . . VI . Guanine Aminohydrolase . . . . . . . VII . Guanosine Aminohydrolase . . . . . . .
. . . .
. . . . . . .
.
.
.
.
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
47 48 49 51 51
54 54 56
63 64 64 66
73 73 75 76 77
.
I Introduction
The purine bases. adenine and guanine. participate in nature by providing structural elements of nucleic acids and numerous cofactors . Tlie deaminated products of adenine and guanine do not participate i n these coenzymic functions except in a relatively few instances . For example. the relative ineffectiveness of inosinc monophosphate (IMP) vs . 47
48
C. L. ZIELKE AND C. H. SUELTER
adenosine monophosphate (AMP) a3 an effeclor of teveral enzymes such as muscle phosphorylase ( I , d ) , heart phosphofructokinase (S),fructose-1,6-diphosphatase ( 4 ) ,and threonine dehydraTe ( 5 ) has been widely documented. Inosine is found in certain restricted positions of several tRNA ( 6 , 7 ) . Other aspects of guanine and adenine nucleotide distribution and their involvement as substrates and regulators of many enzymecatalyzed reactions are discussed elsewhere (8-10).
A. HISTORICAL BACKGROUND The existence of two separate enzymes in animal tissues responsible for the liberation of ammonia from each of the two aminopurines, adenine and guanine, the latter specific for the free purine and the former for the nucleosides, was initially presented by .Jones and his colleagues (11, 12). I n 1928, Schmidt (13-15) demonstrated that AMP aminohydrolase was responsible for the appearance of inosinic acid in muscle and for a t least a portion of ammonia liberated during contraction. He showed not only a marked specificity for deamination of 5’-AMP but also provided the first clue that muscle adenylic acid (5’-AMP) and yeast adenylic acid (3’-AMP) were different compounds. Initial evidence for guanine and adenosine aminohydrolase including aspects of the specificity were also described by Schmidt (16‘). Additional details regarding development of interest in purine aminohydrolases are available in several excellent reviews (17-20). E. G. Krebs, BBA 15, 508 (1954). N. B. Madsen and C. F. Cori, BBA 15, 516 (1954). T. E. Mansour, JBC 238, 2285 (1963). K. Taketa and B. M. Pogell, BBRC 12, 229 (1963). K . W. Rabinowitz, J. D. Shada, and W. A. Wood, JBC 243, 3214 (1968). R. W. Holley, J . Apgar, G. A. Everett, J. T. Madison, M. Marquisee, S. H. Merrill, J. H . Penswick, and A. Zarnir, Science 147, 1462 (1965). 7. J. T. Madison, Ann. R e v . Bwchem. 37, 131 (1968). 8. M. F. Utter, “The Enzymes,” 2nd ed., Vol. 2, Part A, p. 75, 1960. 9. D. E. Atkinson, Ann. R e v . Biochem. 35, 85 (1966). 10. R. M. Bock, “The Enzymes,” 2nd ed., Vol. 2, Part A, p. 3, 1960. 11. W. Jones and C. R. Austrian, Z . Physwl. Chem. 48, 110 (1906). 12. S . Amberg and W. Jones, Z . Physiol. Chem. 73, 407 (1911). 13. G. Schmidt, Z. Physiol. Chefm. 179, 243 (1928). 14. G. Schmidt, Z. Physwl. Chem. 179, 261 (1928). 15. G. Schmidt, in “Biological Phosphorylation” (H. M. Kalckar, cd.), p. 45. Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey, 1969 [English translation of excerpts of Schmidt (IS,1411. 16. G. Schmidt, 2. Physwl. Chem. 208, 185 (1932). 17. P. P. Cohen and G. W. Brown, Jr.. Comp. Biochem. 2, 177 (1960). 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6.
3.
PURINE AMINOHYDROLASES
49
B. DISTRIBUTION The virtual lack of adenine aminohydrolase in animal tissues has been confirmed in several laboratories (81-25). The reported presence of this enzyme in milk (21) has not been confirmed (26). Evidence for adenine aminohydrolase i n Saccharom y c e s rerevisine and Candida utilis based on enhanced growth on adenine (27) has been supported by Rousch and his colleagues (28, 29). The direct deamination of adenine by extracts of E . coli (30-32) has not been verified (33). Adenosine aminohydrolase occurs in tissues of both vertebrates and invertebrates. The enzyme has been observed i n the larvae of Drosophila melanogaster ( S 4 ) , the blowfly (35), sea urchin eggs (36),the hapatopancreas of both crayfish and lobster (3‘7), and a variety of animal tissues (38-4lb). Brady and O’Donovan (4%’)examined the distribution 18. M. P. Schulman, in “Metabolic Pathways” (D. M. Greenberg, ed.), Vol. 11. p. 418. .4cademic Press. Xew York, 1961. 19. Q . Schmidt, in “The Nucleic Acids” (E. Chargaff and J. N. Davidson. cds.). Vol. 1. 11. 595. Academic Press, New York, 1955. 20. T.-P. Lee, “The Enzymes,” 2nd ed., Vol. 4, p. 279, 1960; A. Raggi, S. RoncuTestoni. and G. Ronca, BBA 178, 619 (1969). 21. E. J. Morgan, C. P. Stewart, and F. G. Hopkins, Proc. Roy. SOC.B94, 109 (1922-1923). 22. Q. Duchateau, M. Florkin, and G. Frappez, C o m p t . Rend. SOC.B i d . 133, 274 (1940). 23. M. B. Blauch, F. C. Koch, and M. E. Hanke, JBC 130,471 (1939). 24. J. P. Greenstein, Federation Proc. 6, 488 (1947). 25. Y. Wakabayasi, J . Biochem. (Tokyo) 29, 247 (1939). 26. W. F. Williams and C. W. Turner, Proc. SOC.Exptl. Biol. M e d . 94, 196 (1957). 27. F. J. DiCarlo, A. S. Schultz, and D. K.McManus. JBC 189, 151 (1951). 28. A. H. Rousch, A B B 50, 510 (1954). 29. A . H. Rouscli and M. A. Saeed, BBRC 2, 43 (1960). 30. C. Lutwak-Mmn, BJ 30, 1405 (1936). 31. M. Stephenson and A. R. Trim, BJ 32, 1740 (1938). 32. S. Friedman and J. S. Cots, JBC 201, 125 (1953). 33. A . L. Koch and G. Vallee, JBC 234, 1213 (1959). 34. I<. P. Wagner and H. K. Mitchell, A B 17, 87 (1948). 35. F. G. T,cnnox, Australian Council Sci. I d . Res.. Pnmphl. 109, 37 (1941). 36. T. Gustafson and I. Hasselberg. E z p t l . Cell Res. 2, 642 (1951). 37. A. H. Rousch and R. F. Betz, BBA 19, 579 (1956). 38.E. J . Conway and R. Cooke, BJ 33, 479 (1939). 39. D. A . Clark. J. Dnvoll, F. S. Philips, and G. B. Brown, J. Pharmacol. Exptl. ‘1’Aemp. 106, 291 (1952). 40. J . Purzycka, Acta Biochim. Polow. 9, 83 (1962). 41. W. Mak:ircwicz and M. Zydowo. C o n t p . Biocliem. Pliysiol. 6, 269 (1962). 41a. S. J . Mustafn and C. P. Tewari, Eiizymologiu 38, 177 (1970). 41b. S. J. Mustafa and C. P. Tewari, BBA 198, 93 (1970). 42. T. G. Brady and C. I. O’Donovan, P o m p . Biochem. Physwl. 14, 101 (1965).
50
C. L. ZIELKE AND C. H. SUELTER
of this enzyme in 20-23 tissues of rat, guinea pig, mouse, cat, rabbit, and dog, and 10 tissues of the calf. Activity in heart and skeletal muscle was generally low; activity was always high in the spleen. Although activity in the small intestine was consistently high, in other parts of the alimentary tract i t was generally low. Of all tissues examined, the cat placenta, calf intestinal mucosa, cat lung, and cat spleen exhibited the highest activity. Unequivocal proof for existence of adenosine aminohydrolase in any type of higher plant is still lacking (43). AMP aminohydrolase, an enzyme relatively specific for AMP, has been observed in reptiles ( 4 4 ) ,erythrocytes (%), snail (45), unfertilized fish eggs (46), invertebrates (47), a variety of mammalian tissues ( 2 0 ) , and a particulate fraction of pea seeds (48).Evidence suggests that the frog muscle AMP aminohydrolase is located within or just beneath the sarcolemma (49). The rabbit skeletal and heart muscle enzymes were found in the cytoplasm and mitochondria (20, 40, 50, 51), while the enzyme of kidneys and gills of freshwater fish was located in the cytoplasmic fraction (6.2).The enzyme occurs in most areas of the rat (53) and rabbit brain (54). The nonspecific enzyme from several microbial sources deaminates adenosine triphosphate ( ATP) and adenosine diphosphate (ADP) as well as AMP (see Section V ) . Guanine aminohydrolase is present in a variety of animal tissues (55-58), in lobster hepatopancreas (37), in certain bacteria (59), and 43. T. G . Brady :ind V. J. Hrgurty, Nature 209, 1027 (1966). 44. J. 13. Balinsky. G. I,. Murison, A. R. Conradie, and R. E. Santo. S. African J. Med. Sci. 29, 61 (1964). 45. T. Fujiwara and 13. Spencer, BJ 85, 19P (1962). 46. N. M. Abrosimova and R. I. Tatarskaya, Biokhimiya 28, 128 (1963); C A 58, 12895b (1963). 47. J. Uniiastowski. Acta Biochim. Polon. 11, 459 (1964). 48. D. H. Turner and J. F. Turner, BJ 79, 143 (1961). 49. C. R. Dunkley, J. F. Manery, and E. E. Dryden, J. Cellular Physiol. 68, 241 (1966). 50. 1). C. Park and R. J. Pennington, Clin. Chim. Acta 13, 694 (1966). 51. Z. Yu. Nechiporenko and 0. P. Goloborod’ko, Ukr. Biokhim. Zh. 39, 322 (1967) ; C A 67, 105156s (1967). 52. W. Makarewicz, Acta Biochim. Polon. 10, 363 (1963). 53. H. Kluge and V. Wieczorck, Acla Bwl. Metl. Gel. 21, 271 (1968); C A 70, 26875j (1969). 54. M. K . Malyslievu and N. M. Polyukova, U k r . Biokhim. Z h . 37, 360 (1965); C A 63, 12063b (1965). 55. J. P. Greenstcin, C. E. Curter. H . W. Chalkley, and F. M. Leuthardt, J. Natl. Cancer Inst. 7, 9 (1946). 56. W. D. Block and D. V. Johnson, JBC 217, 43 (1955). 57. T. C. Hall, R. Levine, and C. A. Harris, Biochem. Pharmacol. 8, 71 (1961). 58. J. E. Roy, Can. J. Biochem. 44, 1093 (1966). 59. J . Rakosky, Jr. and J. V. Beck, J. Bacterial. 69, 563 (1955).
3.
PURINE AMINOHYDROLASES
51
in yeast Torula utilis (28). The enzyme from rat kidney or spleen but not the brain and liver was localized almost exclusively in the 15,000-g supernatant fraction of isoosmotic sucrose homogenates. The rat cerebellum was devoid of guanine aminohydrolase activity. However, the enzyme from cerebral hemispheres appeared in two isozymic forms: one present a t birth was associated with the 5000-g supernatant while the second, located in the nuclear and mitochondria1 fractions, did not occur until 15-20 days after birth (60).
C. METHODSOF ASSAY Purine aminohydrolases may be assayed by measuring release of ammonia (IS, 14) or directly by the much more convenient spectrophotometric method developed by Kalckar ( 6 1 ) and Rousch and Norris (62).Absorbancy changes resulting from enzymic hydrolysis of the purines or purine derivatives are summarized in Table I (62-75).
II. Adenine Aminohydrolare
The partially purified adenine aminohydrolase (EC 3.5.4.2) from Azotobacter vinelandii catalyzes the anaerobic conversion of adenine to 60. S. Kurnar, V. Josan, K. C. S. Sanger, K. K. Tewari, and P. S. Krishnan, BJ 102, 691 (1967); S. Kumar, ABB 130, 693 (1969). 61. H. M. Kalckar, JBC 167, 445 and 461 (1947). 62. A. H. Rousch and E. R. Norris, AB 29, 124 (1950). 63. Y. Ishida, H. Shirafuji, M. Kida, and M. Yoneda, Agr. Biol. Chem. 33, 384 (1969). M. R. Wolfenden, JACS 88, 3157 (1966). 65. L. N. Simon, R. J. Bauer, R. L. Tolman, and R. K. Robins, Biochemistry 9, 573 (1970). 65a. H. P. Baer, G . I. Drummond, and J. Gillis. ABB 123, 172 (1968). 66. A. Coddington, BBA 99, 442 (1965). 67. R. Wolfenden, J. Kaufman, and J. B. Macon. Biochemistry 8, 2412 (1969). 68. K. L. Smiley, Jr., A. J. Berry, and C. H. Sueltrr, JBC 242, 2502 (1967). 69. R. Wolfenden, T. K. Sharpless, I. S. Ragade, and N. J. Leonard, JACS 88, 185 (1966). 70. B. M. Chassy and R. J. Suhadolnik, JBC 242, 3655 (1967). 71. S. Frederiksen, ABB 113, 383 (1966). 72. J. G. Cory and R. J. Suhadolnik, Bioche'mistry 4, 1733 (1965). 73. S. F. Mason, Ciba Found. Symp. Chem. Biol. Pteridines p. 74 (1954). 74. S. Frederiksen, BBA 87, 574 (1964). 75. S. Minato, T. Tagnwa. M. Miyaki, B. Shimiau, and K. Nakanishi, J . Biochem. (Tokyo) 59, 265 (1966).
52
C. L. Z I E L R E AND C. H. SUELTER
TABLE I ABSORBANCYCHANGES RESULTING FROM ENZYMIC HYDROLYSIS OF ~-SUBSTITLIENT OF PURINE DERIVATIVES
Ae X 1W'M PH A
Substrate Adenine Adenosine N1-Methyladenosine 2'-Deoxyadenosine
AMP 3-(8-~-Ribofuranosyl) adenine 8-hinoadenosine 8-Azaadenosine 8-Hydroxyadenosine 2,6-Diaminopurine ribonucleoside
(nm)
6
7
265 260 265 265 260 265 265 265 285 290 285
-7.8"
-5.2
262 267 6-Hydroxylaminopurine 250 ribonucleoside 269
6-Bromopurine ribonucleoside 6-Iodopurine ri bonucleoside 2-Amino-6-methoxypurine ribonucleoside 2-Amino-6-chloropurine ribonucleoside
270 246 250 250 265 264
9
-
-
+4.16
+2.74
-
-8.33 -8.6b
-8.2"
-
-7.33' +0.300 +o. 120 -7.94
272 280 272 256 284
Na-Methyladenosine
6-Methoxypurine ribonucleoside 6-Chloropurine ribonucleoside
-
8
-8.6* -5.1 -8.86"
-5.37 -7.17 -4.55 +3.90 4-3. llb -11.00 -11.ooo
-
-11.2
-
-
-10.7
-
-
-9.7 -
-
-8.41
$3.65 -8.22
-7.90
-7.00
+3.76
4-3.90
+4.90
+7.02
+5.06
+5.26 -
-
-4.54
+6.3d +5.32 +5.66 -4.0
-
250
4-6.24
250
+6.44
257
+6.35
+6.35
+6.75
256 264
+9.91
+7.28 +9.86
+lO.lO
-
+11.4
Ref.
3.
53
PURINE AMINOHYDROLASEB
TABLE I (Continued)
PH
x Substrate
(nm)
2-Amino-6-iodopurine 255 ribonucleoside 340 7-Amino[l,2,5]oxy diazolo[3,4d] pyrimidine 7-AminoI 1,2,5] 340 thiadiazolo[3,4d] pyrimidine ~ ’ - D I X X ~ I ~ ~ O S ~ M -275 aminopyrazolo[3,4d] pyrimidine 2’-Deoxyribosyl-& 280 azaadenine 2’-Deoxyribosyl-&amino 278 adenine 9-Allyladenine 265 265 Q-(y,y-Dimethylsllyl) adenine 9-Benayladenine 265 4p-~-Glucopyranosyl 265 adenine 245 Guanine 250 255 260 Guanosine 240 8-Azaguanine 245 265
6
7
8
9
Ref.
+7.68 -6.1“
(67,73)
-7.80
(67,73) -8.63d -6.gd
(74)
-8.1
-7.33’ -7.54c -7.69’ -7.05’
-5.85
-7.05 -
-5.85 -5.3
-5.33
-
-3.9 -2.96 -2.22
-3.45 -
4-3.1 +3.1
Determined at pH 6.5.
* Determined at pH 7.4.
Determined at pH 5.6. Determined a t pH 7.2.
hypoxanthine without addition of dialyzable cofactors ( 7 6 ) .The kinetic behavior of enzyme from Candida utilis (77, 78) and Saccharomyces cerevisiae (79) was similar to the A . vinelandii preparation. Of the 76. L. A. Heppel, J. Hurwitz, and B. L. Horecker, JACS 79, 630 (1957). 77. W. D. McElroy, “Methods in Enzymology,” Vol. 6, p. 203, 1963. 78. R. C. Hartenstein and I. Fridovich, JBC 242, 740 (1967). 79. P. Medhat, Dissertation, Microfilm No. 68-71. University Microfilm, Inc., Ann Arbor, Michigan, 1965.
54
C. L. ZIELKE AND C. H. SUELTER
SUBBTRATEB FOR
TABLE I1 ADENINE AYINOHYDROLABE AND Azotobacter vinelandii
OF
Awtobaeter vinelandii
Candidu utilis Compound
K,
Adenine 7-Aminothiazolo[5,4d] pyrimidine 2,bDiaminopurine 6-Hydrazinopurine 6-Iodopurine 2-Amino-6-chloropurine 6-Chloropurine
x
104M
Candida I d d i S
Vrela
K,
x
lWM
VIei4
0.3 3
1.o 1.27
0.1 1.5
1.0 2.51
3.7 9.0
0.06 0.19 2.11 0.29
2.1 3.0 6.0 10 5
0.12 0.29 0.19 3.0 0.62
13 25
a Specific activity of enzyme from C. utilis,0.25 pmole/min/mg and from A , vinelandii 3.6 pmoles/min/mg, 0.01 M potassium phosphate, pH 7.0, 25’.
purine analogs which were substrates, the lowest K , was observed for adenine (Table 11) ; dehalogenation of 2-amino-6-chloropurine was 2-3 times more rapid than deamination of adenine. Guanine, cytosine, guanosine, cytidine, adenosine, 2’-AMP, 3’-AMP, 2’,3’-AMP, 5’-AMP, ADP, ATP, and G M P were deaminated a t less than one-two hundredth the rate for adenine (76). Adenine aminohydrolase of A. vinelandii does not catalyze the back incorporation of products, hypoxanthine or chloride, into 6-chloropurine during the course of hydrolysis when examined over a wide range of pH in contrast to the back incorporation of oxygen-18 into hypoxanthine catalyzed by adenosine aminohydrolase (80) (see Section 111). These results are consistent with a direct displacement of the 6 substituent by water rather than the intermediate formation of purinyl enzyme or chloroenzyme during catalysis. No information is available regarding the physiological function of this nonmammalian enzyme.
111. Adenosine Aminohydrolase
A. MOLECULAR PROPERTIES 1 . Purification
Homogeneous preparations of adenosine aminohydrolase (EC 3.5.4.4) have been obtained from mucosa of calf duodena (81, 82), chicken
3.
PURINE AMINOHYDROLASES
55
duodena (83),calf serum (84),and calf spleen (85).I n addition to the extensively purified preparation from ox heart (86), partially purified preparations fr m brain (87), bovine thyroid (88), Yoshida ascites cells (66), Escheric!t ia coli (33), Mycobacterium tuberculosis (89), Bacillus cereus (M), and cat lung (91)have been reported.
2. Chemical and Physical Properties The overall amino acid compositions of calf duodenal (92,92a) and calf spleen (85) enzyme showing an excess of acidic over basic amino acids are consistent with the isoelectric point of 4.85-5.0 previously reported for the calf and chicken duodenal enzyme (81,83). The N-terminal amino acid of the calf enzyme was not available for reaction with l-fluoro-2,4-dinitrobenzene in 8 M urea (92a).Calf spleen enzyme reportedly contained galactosamine and glucosamine (86) ; other preparations apparently have not been examined for carbohydrate. The molecular weight of the calf duodenal adenosine aminohydrolase determined from sedimentation and diffusion data (91) and by comparative elution from Sephadex gels (93,94) ranges from 31,000-35,OOO (84,91,93,95). A molecular weight of 52,000 from sedimentation velocity and sedimentation equilibrium data has not been confirmed (92). Molecular weight data for other preparations are consistent with additional forms of the enzyme; for example, chromatography of hepatic extracts of amphibia on Sephadex G-200 gave three peaks of adenosine aminohydrolase activity labeled type A, B, and C (96).Types corre~~
~
80. L. G. Howell and P. F'ridovich, JBC 242, 4930 (1967). 81. T. G. Brady and W. O'Connell, BBA 62, 216 (1962). 82. P. M. Murphy, M. Noonan, P. Collins, E. Tully, and T. G. Brady, BBA 171, 157 (1969). 83. V. D. Hoagland, Jr. and J. R. Fisher, JBC 242, 4341 (1967). 84. J. G. Cory, G. Weinbaum, and R. J. Suhadolnik, ABB 118, 428 (1967). 85. N. Pfrogner, ABB 119, 141 (1967); N. Pfrogner, ibid. 119, 147 (1967). 86. M. Rockwell and M. H. Maguire, Mol. Pharmacol. 2, 574 (1966). 87. M. K. Malysheva, U k r . Biokhim. Zh. 35, 764 (1963); C A 60, 4388e (1964). 88. W. Dierick, P. Olislaegers, and J. Stockx, Arch. Intern. Physiol. Bwchim. 75, 623 (1967); C A 68, 38095~(1968). 89. S. R. Guha, R . P. Saxena, and K. L. Arora, J. Sci. Ind. Res. (India) 21C, 66 (1962). 90.J . F. Powell and J. R. Hunter, BJ 62, 381 (1956). 91. P. M. Murphy, T. G. Brady, and W. A. Boggust, BBA 188, 341 (1969). 92. R. Wolfenden, Y. Tomozawa, and B. Bamman, Biochesmktry 7, 3965 (1968). 92a. J. Phelan, F. McEvoy, S. Rooney, and T. G. Brady, BBA 200, 370 (1970). 93. P. Andrews, BJ 96, 595 (1965). 94. J . R. Whitaker, Anal. Chem. 35, 1950 (1963). 95. T. G. Brady and M. O'Sullivan, BBA 132, 127 (1967). 96. P. F. Ma and J. R. Fisher, Comp. Biochem. Physwl. 27, 687 (1968).
56
C. L. ZIELKE AND C. H. SUELTER
sponding to B and C were also identified in chicken liver and rabbit duodena while only type C was found in cat lung and eight other animal duodena (83,91). Approximate molecular weights of the three types determined by comparative elution of standard proteins from Sephadex were: (A) 200,000, (B) lOO,OOO, and (C) 30,000 (96). Calf duodenal enzyme denatured with 8 M urea or 2 M guanidineeHC1, oxidized with performic acid, reduced with sulfite to cleave disulfide bonds and urea denatured carboxymethylated enzyme migrated on Sephadex G-75 as a single peak with a molecular weight near 35,000 consistent with a single polypeptide structure (82). Yet the calf duodenal enzyme (82,8,9,92) as well as the calf serum (84) and the human spleen, liver, heart, lung, and kidney enzyme (97') migrated as more than one band during electrophoresis. Chromatography of the calf duodenal enzyme on cellulose separated the enzyme into five somewhat overlapping peaks with similar kinetic and molecular properties. However, since only two isozymes were present in the mucosa of a single animal when examined immediately after death and also since the calf serum deaminase migrated in two major bands and two ininor bands (84), Murphy et al. (82) suggested that two isozymes of adenosine aminohydrolase are normally present in calf duodena; the additional bands were relegated to artifacts of preparation. No information is available regarding molecular weight differences. All adenosine aminohydrolase preparations have typical absorption spectra consistent with the absence of tightly bound prosthetic groups. No dissociable cofactors are necessary for catalysis since extensive dialysis of enzyme or addition of the metal chelator ethylenediaminetetraacetate (EDTA) did not cause significant inhibition.
B. CATALYTIC PROPERTIES 1. Reaction Parameters
The kinetic parameters K,, VIIIUX, pH optima, and energy of activation (Eact)for deamination of adenosine catalyzed by homogeneous preparations of adenosine aminohydrolase are summarized in Table I11 (8286, 98). Except for the unusually low specific activities observed for both the chicken duodenal and calf serum enzymes, and the significantly higher energy of activation reported for the former, the reaction param97. N. Ressler, Clin. Chim. Acla 24, 247 (1969). 98. 0.P. Chilson and J. R. Fisher, ABB 102, 77 (1963).
3.
57
PURINE AMINOHYDROLASES
TABLE I11 PREPARATIONS* KINETIC PROPERTIES" OF HOMOGENEOUS OF ADENOSINE AMINOHYDROLASE Enzyme preparation
VIW (pmolel (M X 106) min/mg)
K,
E.Ct
Temp. ("C)
pH optima
(kcal/ mole)
Ref.
~
Calf duodenal Isozyme mixture Isozyme 2 3 4 5 6 Calf spleen Ox heartb Calf serum Chicken duodenal
3-5 1.7 1.5 1.5 2.8 44 4.1 3.3 1.3
7.0-8.5 436 330 550
37 37 37
300 374 240 292 1.1 26
37 37
-
-
25 38 38
6.3 6.8-7.2 6.5-8.5 6.5-8.0
7.2
5.6 17.2 [Ref. (98)l
(98) (82)
(86)
(86) (84)
(83)
Kinetic data obtained from linear Lineweaver-Burk plots.
* Kinetic data for the ox heart preparation are included even though definitive data regarding homogeneity are not available.
eters are similar. The lower activities may reflect real tissue or species differences or some other as yet unknown property. I n contrast to the similar ratios of activity with adenosine compared to deoxyadenosine observed for mammalian tissue enzymes (42), lower ratios and higher activation energies were noted for the chicken liver and duodenal adenosine aminohydrolase (99). To define this more concisely Ma and Fisher (100) examined the adenosine-deoxyadenosine activity ratios, activation energies, and K , values of adenosine for the liver and duodenal enzyme from 6 orders of mammals, 5 orders of birds, 3 orders of reptiles, 2 orders of amphibia, 6 orders of bony fish, and 2 orders of cartilaginous fish. This extensive study showed that activation energies ranging from 4-10 kcal/mole, K , from to 6 X M , and adenosine-deoxyadenosine activity ratios from 0.6 to 1.5 are characteristic of vertebrates in general. In confirmation of the previous report (98) and in contrast to vertebrates in general, bird liver and bird duodenal adenosine aminohydrolase have activation energies in the range of 10-17 kcal/mole and lower adenosine-deoxyadenosine activity ratios. 99.J . R. Fisher, P. F. Ma, and 0. P. Chilson. Comp. Bwchem. Physiol. 16, 198 (1965). 100. P. F. Ma and J . R. Fisher, Comp. Biochem. Physiol. 19, 799 (1966).
C.
L. ZIFLKE AND C.
€3. SUFLTER
2. Nature of Active Site Graphical treatment of pKm vs. pH showed a relatively constant K , for adenosine between pH 5.5 and 8.5 for both the calf (65a) and chicken duodenal (98) adenosine aminohydrolase. This plot for the calf enzyme also exhibited inflection points a t pH 5.7-6.3 and pH 9.5-10.2 suggesting dissociable groups in the enzyme substrate complex with analogous pK values. Complete inactivation of the enzyme by equimolar concentrations of p-mercuribenzoate and phenylmercuriacetate and the -protection by 2,6-diaminopurine and 8-azaguanine (101), competitive and uncompetitive inhibitors, respectively, and lack of protection against inactivation by dinitrophenylation of 2-lysine €-amino groups by these same inhibitors (102) suggest but do not prove the involvement of sulfhydryl group(s) in the enzyme-substrate complex. On the other hand, mercuration of one sulfhydryl group of the chicken duodenal enzyme with p-mercuribenzoate produces a stable derivative with 2.5-fold greater activity than the native enzyme ; excess mercurating reagent always resulted in inactivation. Iodoacetamide does not appear to react with the enzyme but N-ethylmaleimide reacts to produce a 1.7-fold activation ( 8 3 ) . Schaeffer et al. (103) have synthesized and also demonstrated enzyme inactivation with two active-site-directed irreversible inhibitors, 9- (p-bromoacetamidobenzyl) adenine and 9- (0-bromoacetamidobenzyl)adenine. Inactivation proceeded by a first-order reaction following formation of an initial reversible inhibitor complex. Inhibition constants M , respectively, for the reversible enzyme M and 43 x of 1.4 X inhibitor complex evaluated from kinetics of inactivation agree with constants obtained by the usual double reciprocal plot of initial velocities. The first-order rate constants for alkylation in the reversible EI complex are 1.1 x min-I and 7.7 x lo-? min-l, respectively. The functional group undergoing alkylation has not been defined. The reversible and competitive inhibition of calf duodenal adenosine aminohydrolase by relatively low concentrations of urea, methyl urea, and 1,3-dimethyl urea is similar to the urea (104) inhibition of several other enzymes (105). The inhibition appears to involve 1-2 molecules of inhibitor in the inhibition complex (106)determined from log[ ( V d v i ) 101. G.Ronca, C.Bauer, and C. A. Rossi, European J. Biochem. 1, 434 (1967). 102. G. Ronca, P. L. Ipata, and C. Bauer, BBA 122, 379 (1966). 103. H.J. Schaeffer, M. A. Schwarts, and E. Odin, J. M e d . Chem. 10, 686 (1967). 104. T.G. Brady and M . O’Sullivan, BJ 80, 17P (1961). 105. K.V. Rajagopolan, I. Fridovich, and P. Handler, JBC 236, 1059 (1961). 106. G. Ronca and S. Ronca-Testoni, BBA 178, 577 (1969).
3.
PURINE AMINOHYDROLASES
59
11 vs. log I plots (107).Mixed inhibition studies (108)with several urea and amidine derivatives coupled with their mutually competitive interaction with 2,6-diaminopurine1 a substrate analog, are consistent with two independent but adjacent binding sites for these compounds (106). I n addition, the similar relationship between the inhibition and basicity of several amidine and purine derivatives (108, 109) suggests an interaction of the amidine derivatives with the purine binding site. The N-alkyl urea derivatives may bind a t a second presumably more apolar site consistent with a previous suggestion of Schaeffer and his colleagues (110).After examination of more than 40 9-substituted alkyl adenine derivatives as inhibitors of calf duodenal adenosine aminohydrolase, particularly the marked inhibition by 9- (1-hydroxymethyldecanyl)adenine, they suggested an active site composed of a purine binding region, an apolar region, and a hydrophillic region (110).In a similar vein, Bloch et a2. (111) concluded after comparison of 43 analogs of adenosine and 2’-deoxyadenosine as substrates or inhibitors of adenosine aminohydrolase that the 1’ and 5’ positions of adenosine were particularly important for substrate activity. The absence of substrate activity of the compounds lacking the 5’-hydroxyl suggests an important role for this group in binding. 3. Mechanism
Calf duodenal adenosine aminohydrolase affects enzymic hydrolysis of a wide variety of 6-substituted purine derivatives as well as analogs of adenosine with alteration in the purine ring and sugar moiety (Table IV) (65,65a,67,70,71,112). Although not noted in Table IV, AMP, ADP, and ATP are not substrates. The hydrolysis of the 6-methoxypurine derivative in H2180 occurs between C-6 and oxygen (113) consistent with the observed back incorporation of 180 from H2l80 into inosine as catalyzed by both calf duodenal and Takadiastase non107. F. H.Johnson, H. Eyring, and R. W. Williams, J. Cellular Comp. Physiol. 20, 247 (1942). 108. I. Fridovich, JBC 239, 3519 (1964). 109. G.Ronca and G. Zucchelli, BBA 159, 203 (1968). 110. H. J. Schaeffer and P. S. Bhargava, Biochemistry 4, 71 (1965); H. J. Schaeffer, D. Vogel, and R. Vince, J. Med. Chern. 8, 502 (1965); H.J. Schaeffer and D. Vogel, ibid. p. 507; H.J. Schaeffer, C. F. Schwender, and R. N. Johnson, J . Pharm. Sci. 54, 978 (1965); H.J. Schaeffer and C. F. Schwender, ibid. 57, 1070 (1968).
111. A. Bloch, M. J. Robins, and J. R. McCarthy, Jr., J. Med. Chem. 10, 908 (1967). 112. J. L. York and G. A. LePage, Can. J. Biochem. 44, 331 (1966). 113. R. Wolfenden and J. F. Kirsch, JACS 90, 6849 (1968).
60
C. L. ZIELKE AND C. H. SUELTER
TABLE IV
KINETICCONSTANTS FOR SUBSTRATES OF CALFDUODENAL ADENOSINE AMIINOHYDROLASE Substrate
Adenosine
(a) Derivatives of Purine Moiety 6.5-7.5 3.5 100
3-(B-D-Ribofuranosyl) adenine (isoadenosine) Adenine N1-Methyladenosine No-Meth yladenosine No-Ethyladenosine 6Hydroxyaminopurine ribonucleoside 6-Methoxypurine ribonucleoside 6-Chloroadenosine 6-Bromoadenosine 6-Iodoadenosine 2-Aminoadenosine 2-Amino-6-chloropurine ribonucleoside 2-Amino-6-iodopurine ribonucleoside 2-Amino-6-methoxypurine ribonucleoside 4-Aminopteridine 7-Amino[1,2,5]oxydiarolo [3,4d]pyrimidine 7-Amino[l,2,5]thiadiszolo 13,4d]pyrimidine &hinoadenosine 8-Oxoadenosine 8-Azaadenosine
6.5
7.7
0.52
6.5 6.5-8.9 7.0 6.8-7.0 7.0 6.8-7.0
15 9.6-10.1 9.6 0.6-1.1 12 7.14.5
6.8 6.8-7.2 7.0 7.0 6.8 7.0 6.8 7.0
3.2 25-70 9.8 30 3.4 6.7 30.5 41
127 59
6.8
5.0
12
6.5 6.5
10.5 38
6.5 7.0 7.0 7.0
333
0.0014 0.17 0.0014 0.16 0.14 23-38 0.45 2140 11 5 25
73
0.58 0.79 7.4
3.7 13.7 10.0 6.27 217 9.6 (b) 9-Substituted Adenine Derivatives 2’-Deoxyadenosine 7.2 2.2 93 3’-Deoxyadenosine 7.2-7.5 2.5-5.2 52 2’,3’-Dideoxyadenosine 7.2-7.5 8.7-7.7 3‘-Amino-2’,3’-dideoxyadenosine 7.2 8.3 3 2’-Amino-2’,3’-dideoxyadenosine 7.2 40 223 3’-Amino-3’-deoxyadenosine 7.2 16.7 103 2‘-O-Methyladenosine 7.0 2.2 53 2’-3’-Isopropylideneadenosine 7.0 4.8 49 4’-Thioadenosine 7.2 3.3 37
3. PURINE AMINOHYDROLASES
61
TABLE IV (Continued) Substrate 9-X ylosy ladenine 9-Arabinosyladenine 9-(3’-Deoxyarabinosyl) adenine 9-Lyxosyladenine 9-(5‘-Deoxylyxosy1)adenine 2’,(3)-O-(N-Benzyloxycarbonyl) glycyladenosine 9(c~-~2’-Deoxyribofuranosyl) adenine 9(@-~-5’-Deoxyxylofuranosyl) adenine
pH
7.5 7.2 7.2-7.5 7.5 7.5 7.5 7.0
K, ( M X I@)
VW
10
57 17 18-25 1.6 1.5 6.5 47
1.9 7.7-14 12 17.1 8 3.5
(rel)
7.0
6.1
8
7.0
6.7
5
Ref.
(c) Other Analogs
2’-Deoxyribosyl-8-azaadenine 2’-Deoxyribosyl-4-aminopyraaolo[3,4d]pyrimidine 2’-Deoxyribosyl-8-amino adenine
7.2 7.2 7.0
12.5 10.7 6.39
460 4.3 2.0
specific enzymes (115). While no rates were given for the very slow nonenzymic exchange into free inosine, the enzymic exchange rates were lower by approximately five orders of magnitude than the limiting rate constants for adenosine deamination by both the calf and Takadiastase enzymes (113). The reverse reaction, i.e., the direct conversion of inosiiie to adenosine catalyzed by both the calf duodenal and the Takadiastase nonspecific adenosine aminohydrolase (Section V) and rncasured as a function of pH with the calf enzyme, was defined by a theoretical curve for the equilibrium, Kc,= ( [inosine] [ NH,] ) / ( [adenosine][ H20]) = 38, with water concentration taken as one and pK, values of 8.8 and 9.2 for inosine and ammonium ion, respectively. The calculated AF = -5400 cal/mole a t pH 7.0 was in reasonable agreement with -6000 cal/mole estimated from the summation of a series of partial reactions (114). Because of the wide specificity of catalysis, Bar and Drummond (115) argued that the basic mechanism of action involves a nucleophilic displacement by hydroxyl at the 6 position of the purine system. Structural 114. R. Wolfenden, JBC 242, 4711 (1967). 115. H. P. Biir and G. I. Drummond. BBRC 24, 584 (1966).
62
C. L. ZIELEE AND C. H. SUELTER
considerations of the substrates suggested an analogy to some esterases and proteolytic enzymes. This comparison appears valid if one considers the amino tautomer of adenosine as the imido form of a carboxylic acid; thus, the 6-chloro, 6-methoxy, and 6-amino derivatives resemble an acid chloride, a methyl ester, and an amide, respectively. Enzymic deamination might also be facilitated by enzyme stabilization of the rare imino tautomer, as contrasted to the 6-amino tautomer which predominates by a factor of more than lo‘ (116). Enzymic activity on 1-methyladenosine (the neutral species of which is already in the imirio form) and on 3- (P-D-ribofuranosyl) adenine are consistent with the formation of the imino tautorner preceding hydrolysis (69). In an extension of the ideas of Bar and Drummond ( 1 1 5 ) ,Wolfenden (116) suggested the rate limiting formation of a tetrahedral intermediate a t the 6 position of purine involving enzyme or enzyme bound water and substrate similar to the type of intermediates generally encountered in nucleophilic aromatic substitution as indicated in ( I ) .
Several lines of evidence are consistent with this mcchanism. First, all known ring-modified substrates can form the tetrahedral intermediate ( 6 7 ) . Second, as previously detailed, both the calf duodenal and the nonspecific Takadiastase enzyme catalyze back incorporation of lSO into inosine. Third, the nearly identical I’,,,:,, for hydrolysis of 6-amino, -1iydrazin0, -chloro, -rnetliylamirio, and -methoxy purine riboside catalyzed by the Takadiastase enzyme when the apparcnt affinity varied by a factor of approximately 600 is indicative of the rate limiting hydrolysis of an intermediate common to all five reactions, one in which the original 6 substituent has been completely displaced (66).However, rates of hydrolysis catalyzed by the calf enzyme were not so similar (see Table I V ) . Furthermore, if a nucleophilic attack by the enzyme (or water bound to the enzyme) on the substrate were rate limiting, then the absence of a primary deuterium isotope effect observed with both enzymes suggests that cleavage of the leaving group before the transition state would be unlikely (117).T h a t is, the rate limiting hydrolysis 116. R. Wolfenden, J M B 40, 307 (1969). 117. R. Wolfenden, Biochemistry 8, 2409 (1969).
3.
63
PURINE AMINOHYDROLASES
of a common purinyl enzyme intermediate would be expected to involve a partial cleavage of water in the transition state. Also, electron withdrawing groups in the ring, for instance, the substitution of an oxygen or sulfur atom for the 8 carbon, enhance the V,,,,, as would be expected if nucleophilic attack constituted a part of the rate-limiting step (67). Deamination of both adenosine and deoxyadenosine is also enhanced by substitution of nitrogen for the 8 carbon (6'5, 74) and substitution of ribose at the 3 or 9 position results in very large rate enhancement as compared to adenine (67). However, Simon et al. (65) could establish no correlation between enhancement of activity and substitution of electron withdrawing groups a t the 8 position of adenosine. However, it was concluded that steric factors were important since those 8-substituted derivatives devoid of activity exhibited greater steric requirements than those which were substrates. Furthermore, Bar and Drummond (115) observed that the order of reactivity of 2-substituted adenosine was H>>NH, >F >OH>>Cl which suggests that electron withdrawing groups decrease the reactivity. Perhaps altered positioning of the various substrate analogs in the catalytic site accounts for the most significant effect on the altered rates of deamination in these cases. In any event the data are consistent with a subtle balance between the bond-breaking and bond-forming steps (118) in the development of the transition state. The isolation of the proposed covalently linked enzyme intermediate would aid materially in the elucidation of this mechanism.
c. CONSIDERATIONS O F PHYSIOLOGICAL
FUNCTION
The suggestion of Berne (118) that adenosine may play an important part in regulating coronary blood flow has provided considerable inieptus to the study of adenosine deaminases. The auriculoventricular block of mammalian heart caused by adenosine is transient, probably because of rapid deamination to the inactive inosine (119). 2-Chloroadenosine1 which has long-lasting effects and 10 times the potency of adenosine in causing heart block in the guinea pig (119), was not deaminated by the ox heart enzyme (86). A number of 2-substituted adenosine analogs with a free 6-amino group which inhibit ox heart adenosine aminohydrolase have also been found to cause prolonged vasodilation in a number of mammalian species ; however, comparison of the relative potencies of these analogs with their inhibitor constants shows no correlation between the inhibitory effects of the analogs on ox heart aden118. R. N . Berne, Physiol. Rev. 44, 1 (1964). 119. R. H. Thorp and L. B. Cobbin, Arch. Interrt. Pharmacodyn. 118, 95 (1959).
64
C. L. ZIJCLKE AND
C. H.
SUELTER
osine aminohydrolase and their effect as vasodilatory agents (86). The inhibition constant for ouabain also shows no correlation with biological effects (86). Thus the role of adenosine in the regulation of coronary blood flow requires additional study. I n addition to the general catabolic role of adenosine aminohydrolase in purine metabolism first suggested by Brady (120) and in the detoxification of the pharmacologically active adenosine, other results (121) imply a role in cellular deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) metabolism. I n the liver where catabolic enzymes are mostly known to increase with age of the animal, the level of adenosine aminohydrolase does not show any variation. On the other hand, in tissues showing high DNA synthesis and intense mitotic activity, as observed during normal tissue regeneration and normal or neoplastic cell proliferation, the levels of catabolic enzymes are low but adenosine aminohydrolase is surprisingly high.
IV. 5'-Adenylic Acid Aminohydrolase
A. MOLECULAR CHARACTERISTICS 1 . Purification and Homogeneity
Several preparations for 5'-AMP aminohydrolase (EC 3.5.4.6) have been described which yield homogeneous enzyme (68, 122, 123). Of these the method utilizing the direct absorption of AMP aminohydrolase from a crude rabbit muscle extract with cellulose phosphate and its consequent elution provides a one-step purification of ultracentrifugal and electrophoretically homogeneous enzyme in high yields (68). This method has been adapted with slight modifications for preparations from rat ( l 2 4 ) , chicken breast (123), and carp muscle (125).The scheme for purification of enzyme from elasmobranch fish (Raia clavata) involved calcium phosphate gel and DEAE-cellulose chromatography (126). While the enzyme from chicken breast muscle was homogeneous by 120. T . Brady, BJ 36, 478 (1942). 121. M. Galy-Fajou. C . E. Stripati, and Y. Khouvine, Bull. Soc. Claim. Biol. 51, 52 (1969). 122. Y.-P. Lee, JBC 227, 987 (1957). 123. H. Henry and 0. P. Chilson. Co'mp. Biochem. Physiol. 29, 301 (1969). 124. A. W. Murray and M. R. Atkinson, Biochemitry 7 , 4023 (1968). 125. J. Purzycka-Preis and M. Zydowo, Actn Biochim. Polon. 16, 235 (1969). 126. W. Makarewicz. C o m p . Biochem. Physiol. 29, 1 (1969).
3.
PURINE AMINOHYDROLASES
65
clectrophorctic, ultr~iccutrifugal,itiitl im~iii~noclcctrophoreticcriteria, 110 data were given for the rat and fish muscle preparations. A previous preparation of rat and rabbit musclc enzyme (127) and enzyme purified from rat liver (128) was not homogeneous. No criteria were published for the 200-fold purified calf brain cnzymc (129). 2. Chemical and Physical Properties Whereas the rabbit muscle (68)and brain preparations (129) required 1-10mM mercaptoethanol and KCl or LiCl for stability over extended time periods, the preparation described by Lee was not affected by reducing or oxidizing agents (130). Multivalent anions, such as tripolyphosphate, 3-iso-AMP, ATP, and GTP, but not substrate, stabilized the calf brain enzyme against heat inactivation (129, 131). The molecular weight of 320,000 obtained for the muscle enzyme from sedimentation-diffusion data a t 2-6 mg/ml and 8 = 0.75 (132) is to be compared with 270,000 obtained by Wolfenden et al. from s ~ =~11.1, S ~ and D,,,, = 3.75 X lo-‘ cm2 sec-I, and V = 0.731 calculated from the amino acid content (92). The rabbit muscle enzyme has a normal amino acid content, that is, no unusually low or large amount of a particular amino acid was found. Of the 32 cysteine/half-cystine residues per mole based on a molecular weight of 270,000, 6.2 were rapidly titrated with p-mercuribenzoate (92). Typical protein absorption spectra were reported for elasmobranch fish (126), carp (125), rat (127), and rabbit muscle enzyme (68). An Ettm a t 280 nm = 9.13 has been reported for the rabbit muscle enzyme (133). The atypical absorption spectrum with a maximum a t 275-276 nm observed by Lee (132) is indicative of contaminating bound nucleotides. Inhibition of the chicken breast enzyme by rabbit antisera for chicken breast enzyme; the lack of effect on the chicken brain, heart, or erythrocyte enzyme ; and the differences in substrate specificity exhibited by the brain and breast muscle enzyme are consistent with at least two isozymes of chicken 5’-AMP aminohydrolase (123). Isozymic patterns, while perhaps implied by differences in certain kinetic pa127. R. D. Curric and H. L. Webster, BBA 64, 30 (1962) ; G. Nikiforuk and S. P. Colowick, “Methods in Enzymology,” Vol. 2, p. 469, 1955. 128. L. D. Smith and D. E . Kiaer, BBA 191, 415 (1969). 129. B. Setlow and J. M . Lowenstein, JBC 242, 607 (1967). 130. Y.-P. Lee, JBC 227, 999 (1957). 131. B. Setlow and J. M. Lowenstein, JBC 243, 3409 (1968). 132. Y.-P. Lee, JBC 227, 993 (1957). 133. C. L. Zielke and C. H. Suelter, Federation Proc. 28, 728 (1969).
66
C. L. ZIELKE AND C. H. SUELTER
rameters of the calf brain (129) and rabbit muscle enzyme (68),have not been clearly delineated for other preparations.
B. CATALYTIC PROPERTIES 1. Specificity I n general, AMP aminohydrolase specificities have not been thoroughly defined perhaps because of difficulties until recently in obtaining pure enzyme. I n addition to AMP and dAMP, the muscle enzyme catalyzes the deamination of N6-methyl AMP, N”-ethyl AMP, formycin-5’-monophosphate, adenosine-5’-monosulfate, adenosine-!Y-phosphoramidate, adenosine, ADP (133), adenosine-5’-phosphorothioate, and 6-chloropurine 5’-ribonucleotide (124) ; ATP, GMP, CMP, 2’-AMP, 3’-AMP, 3’, 5’-cyclic AMP, 3-iso-AMP, N1-methyl AMP, toyocamycin5’-monophosphate, tubercidin-5’-monophosphate, and 6-mercaptopurine5’-ribonucleotide are not deaminated (133). The elasmobranch fish muscle, carp muscle, and avian brain enzymes appear to be specific for AMP and dAMP (123, 125, 126). Extracts from pea seed and erythrocytes and the purified calf brain enzyme are specific for AMP (48,131, 134). 2. Kine tics
The kinetic parameters of various muscle AMP aminohydrolases presented in Table V (51, 68,12.2, 124-127) are similar except for the lower specific activities exhibited by the fish enzymes for which no criteria of homogeneity are presently available. Specific activities reported for brain enzymes not shown in Table V are 1 5 pmoles/min/mg for calf (129) and 30 pmoles/min/mg for chicken (123).Although the pH optimum for AMP deamination varies depending upon the source, it normally occurs in a range from pH 5.9 to 7.1 (48, 125, 126, 129, 150, 135-137).
a. Activation. Most preparations of AMP aminohydrolase are activated by monovalent cations and nucleoside di- or triphosphates (Table VI) (48,54,68,123, 126, 126, 128, 129,131,137-148). Potassium is gen134. A . Askuri, Science 141, 44 (1963). 135. G. Nikiforuk and S. P. Colowick, JBC 219, 119 (1956). 136. S. Naril, Seikagaku 32, 204 (1960); C A 60, 5815 (1964). 137. A . Askari and J. E. Franklin, Jr., BBA 110, 162 (1965). 138. B. Setlow and J. M. Lowcnstein, JBC 243, 6216 (1968). 139. J. Mendicino and J. A. Munts, JBC 233, 178 (1958). 140. A . Askuri, Nature 202, 185 (1964). 141. B. Setlow, R. Burger, and J. M. Lowenstein, JBC 241, 1244 (1966). 142. S. N. Rao, L. Ham, and A. Askuri, BBA 151, 651 (1968).
3.
67
PURINEI AMINOHYDROLASES
TABLE V KINETICCONSTANTS FOR AMP DEAMINATION BY SEVERAL PREPARATIONS OF AMINOHYDROLASE V mar
Source (Ref .)
K,
(#mole/ min/mg.)
Conditions
Rabbit muscle (199)
1.4
1660
(61, 68)
0.4
12006
Rat muscle (187)
1.4
1140
(184)
0.95
13306
0.1 M Na+ succinate, pH 6.4, 30" 0.05 M Tris-cacodylate, pH 6.3, 0.15 M KCl, 30" 0.1 M succinate, pH 6.4, 0.5 M KCl, 30" 0.02 M K + cacodylate, pH 6.5, 1 mM mercapto-
ethanol Fish-elasmobranch (196)
1.52
350
0.1 M K + succinate, pH 6.6, 30"
Carp muscle (1956)
0.4
180
0.5 M K + succinate, pH 6.4, 30"
Vmaxwas calculated from the Michaelis-Menten equation where K , is the value reported in this table and v the specific activity of the purest fraction a t the concentration of AMP used for the standard assay. Ir,,, values were obtained from double reciprocal plots.
erally th most effective monovalent cation activator although Lit, Na+, Rb', and NH,+ can often substitute. Monovalent cations are not required for the brain, muscle, and rat liver enzyme since the same v,, was observed a t high concentrations of AMP in either the presence or absence of cations. However, the enzyme associated with a brain particulate fraction (54),Ehrlich ascites tumor cells (148), and the human erythrocyte membrane (142) is reported to absolutely require K+ for activity. The soluble human erythrocyte enzyme, which constitutes 85% 143. A. R u i n and J. Mager, Israel J. M e d . Scz. 2, 614 (1966). 144. S. Nara, Seikagaku 34, 654 (1962) ; C A 58, 10456g (1963). 145. K. L. Smiley, Jr. and C. H. Suelter, JBC 242, 1980 (1967). 145a. K. L. Smiley, Jr. and C. I,. Lohrnan, Federation Proc. 26, 560 (1967). 146. M. N. Lyubimova and E. Sh. Matlina, Dokl. Akad. Nauk SSSR 94, 927 (1954) ; C A 48, 7084g (1954). 147. G. Ronca, A. Raggi, and S. Ronca-Testoni, BBA 167, 626 (1968). 148. M. R. Atkinson and A. W. Murray, BJ 104, 1Oc (1967).
TABLE VI MONOVALENT CATIONAND N~JCLEOTIDE ACTIVATORSOF AMP AMINOHYDROLASE Source
Activator
Comments
Ref.
Brain Calf
Chicken Dog Rabbit Particulate Soluble Rat
Li+ > Na+ > K+ > Rb+
> CS+ > NHI+ = (CHI)IN+ ATP > dATP > ITP > CTP = UTP Li+ > Na+ > NH4+ K+, Rb+, Cs+ no effect ATP ATP ATP ATP Na+ Na+ or Kf Na+ or K+
+
(189)
(131)
Inhibitor GTP present
(138) (183s) (139) (140)
Synergistic effect Required Activate, not required
ATP
(64) (64)
(141)
Erythrocyte Human Soluble
K+, NHI+ ATP >> ITP, GTP, UTP Na+, Li+, Rb+
Membrane bound Cat and dog
K+, Na+ ATP no effect ATP
Rabbit
ATP=ADP>GTP
Rat
Liver Na+, K+, Li+, ATP, ADP
Carp
ATP
Required No effect in absence of K+ or Na+ Activation only in presence of ATP Required
(137)
Monovalent cationsno effect
(137)
(148
(143)
Muscle
Elasmobranch fish Rabbit
K+ > Cs+ > Na+ > NH4+ > Rb+ K+ > Rb+ > N&+ Li+ > Na+ >> (CH&N+ ATP > 2'-AMP K+ = Na+ > Li+ > Rb+ NH4+ >> CS ATP, ADP N
N
Rat Chicken
K+, ADP ATP
Ehrlich ascites tumor cells Pea seed
ATP
Other
NH4
> Li' > Na+
(48)
3.
69
PUBINB AMINOHYDWLASES
of the total AMP aminohydrolase content of the cell (I,@), was activated only by K+ and NH4+ (137); activation by Na+, Li+, and Rb+ required the presence of ATP. Adenosine triphosphate alone did not activate the soluble enzyme but did lower the effective concentration for K+ activation. I n contrast the cat and dog erythrocyte enzyme were activated by A T P but not by monovalent cations either in the presence or absence of ATP (137). I n the absence of activators AMP aminohydrolase from brain (149), erythrocytes (143, 1501, muscle (145), and liver (128) gave sigmoid curves for velocity vs. AMP concentration which were hyperbolic after the addition of monovalent cations, adenine nucleotides, or a combination of monovalent cations and adenine nucleotides. For the rabbit muscle enzyme (I&), addition of K', ADP, or ATP produced normal hyperbolic saturation curves for AMP as represented by a change in the Hill slope nH from 2.2 to 1.1; V,,, remained the same. The soluble erythrocyte enzyme and the calf brain enzyme required the presence of both monovalent cations and ATP before saturation curves became hyperbolic. I n contrast, the bound human erythrocyte membrane enzyme did not exhibit sigmoid saturation curves and K activation was not affected by ATP (142).
b . Inhibition. A variety of anions such as inorganic phosphate (123, 126, 130, 143, 151-153)) sulfate (153), nitrate (153)) pyrophosphate (130, 131), tripolyphosphate (131), 2,3-diphosphoglycerate (150), creatine phosphate (153n), as well as several phosphate esters (153b), carboxylate (133, 147), F- (48, 126, 130, 136, 151, 152), #-AMP (126, 131, 1 3 S ) , G T P (128, 141, 145), G D P (145), and 3-iso-AMP (131) have been shown to inhibit AMP aminohydrolase. G T P inhibited the ATP activation of the enzyme from rat brain, heart, and liver, calf brain ( 1 4 1 ) ) and rabbit muscle (145) but had no effect on the elasmobranch fish muscle enzyme (126). G T P inhibition of calf brain enzyme was competitive with respect to ATP, apparent Ki = 10 3-ISO-AMP was not a substrate but was an effective inhibitor for the brain (apparent K i = 60 &) (131) and muscle enzyme (133). A recent study ( 1 5 3 ~ )of the effect of purine nucleotides on the K+-activated enzyme from muscle of several species showed that while
a.
149. B. Cunningham and J . M. Lowenstein, BBA 96, 535 (1965). 150. A. Askari and S. N. Rao, BBA 151, 198 (1968). 151. D.E.Kizer, B. Cox, C. A. Lovig, and S. F. DeEstrugo, JBC 238, 3048 (1963). 152. Y.-P. Lee and M. H. Wang, JBC 243, 2260 (1968). 153. A. Askari, Mol. Pharmncol. 2, 518 (1966). 153a. S. Ronca-Testoni, A. Raggi, and G . Ronca, BBA 198, 101 (1970). 153b. D.W.Sammons, H. Henry, and 0. P. Chilson, JBC 245, 2109 (1970).
70
C.
L. ZIELKE AND
C. H. SUELTER
a t low K+ concentrations ATP was an activator, a t KCl concentrations greater than 100 mM ATP as well as G T P and ITP were inhibitors. The conflict between these data and those previously reported (145,1 4 5 ~ ) may reflect the general sensitivity of this enzyme to differences in assay conditions. Carboxylic acids have been reported either to have no effect (129, 130), to activate (135),or to inhibit (133)AMP aminohydrolase. While the activation of the rabbit muscle enzyme was not thoroughly examined (135),the reported inhibition of this enzyme by citrate, succinate, and maleate was most effective in the absence of activators or in the presence of ADP (153).Enzymic activity in intact myofibrils was activated by ATP, ADP, and ITP in succinate buffer but not in citrate buffer (154). With the rat enzyme citrate, succinate, cacodylate, acetate, and lactate increased both the apparent K , and Hill slope for AMP; V,,, decreased only slightly (14'7). The inhibition by carboxylic acids, o-phenanthroline and dithioerythritol led to the finding of 2.8 g-atoms Zn2+/300,000g of rabbit muscle AMP aminohydrolase (135); 2 g-atoms Zn2+/290,000g of rat muscle The mechanism for AMP aminohydrolase has also been reported (154~). the reported inhibitions by Zn2+ (130,I % ) , Cu2+ (129,130, 155),Fe3+ (130),Ag+ (130,155),Cd2+and Ni2+ (129,155),and Hgz+ (135,136) is not understood but may involve interaction with a sulfhydryl group(s) necessary for catalysis or displacement of the presumably required zinc. Iodoacetate had no effect on the rabbit muscle enzyme (130,135) but did inhibit the carp muscle and pea seed enzyme (48,136).Organic mercurials are also reported to inhibit the enzyme from several sources (48, 125, 126, 130, 156). Except for the preliminary report by Wolfenden et al. (92) that mercurials desensitized the rabbit muscle enzyme to allosteric inhibition by GTP, the role of sulfhydryl residues in AMP aminohydrolase is not understood. 3. Mechanism
A detailed discussion of the mechanism for 5'-AMP deamination is a t present premature. The sigmoid relationship for substrate saturation and activation by monovalent cations and adenine nucleotides is consistent with mechanisms involving active site-effector site interaction. However, the activation brought about by this site-site interaction is a relatively 154. G. Kaldor, Proc. SOC.E z p t l . Biol. Mecl. 110, 21 (1962). 154a. A. Raggi, M. Ranieri, G. Taponeco, S. Ronca-Testoni, G. Ronca, and C. A . Rossi, FEBS Letters 10, 101 (1970). 155. H. Kluge and V. Wieczorek, Acta B i d . M e d . Ger. 22, 205 (1969).
3.
PURINEI AMINOHYDROLASES
71
slow first-order process independent of protein concentration (156)comparable to observations reported for yeast glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate dehydrogenase (157) and homoserine dehydrogenase (158).The activation was discussed in terms of a simple scheme similar to those proposed by Rabin (159) and Weber (160)which provides a plausible explanation for the sigmoid curve for initial velocities vs. substrate concentration without involving additional phenomena such as cooperative interactions between catalytic sites. The hydrolytic deaminstion catalyzed by rabbit and rat muscle AMP aminohydrolase may be facilitated by Zn2+(133,1 5 4 ~ )in contrast to the mediation of a common purinyl enzyme intermediate for adenosine aminohydrolase catalysis (see Section 111). 4. Considerations oj Physiological Function
As with many enzymes the role of AMP aminohydrolase in the hierarchy of metabolic catalysts is not clearly understood. Enzymic activity in muscle is markedly reduced in the dystrophic mouse (161,16?2), in humans suffering from Duchanne type muscular dystrophy (163),in hypokaliemic periodic paralysis (164), and upon denervation of normal and dystrophic mouse gastronemii (165).Activity is reported to increase in both transplanted and primary hepatomas (151) and in precancerous livers prior to the onset of neoplasia induced by feeding or by intraabdominal injections of the potent carcinogen 3’-methyl-4-dimethylaminoazobenzene (166). The weak carcinogen, 4’-methyl-4-dimethylaminoazobenzene was not effective (166).Increases in enzyme activity concomitant with altered nuclear-nucleolar morphology, nuclear RNA content, and nuclear RNA biosynthesis were also observed after injections of thioacetamide, a hepatocarcinogen (167,168). 156. C. H. Suelter, A. L. Kovacs, and E. Antonini, FEBS Letters 2, 65 (1968). 157. K. Kirschner, M. Eigen, R. Bittman, and B. Voigt, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U . S. 56, 1661, (1S66). 158. E. D. Barber and H. J. Bright, Proc. Natl. Acacl. Sci. U . S. 80, 63 (1968). 159. B. R. Rabin, BJ 102, 22c (1967). 160. G. Weber, i71 “Molecular Biophysics” (B. Pullman and M. Weissbluth, eds.), p. 369. Academic Press, New York, 1965. 161. R. J. Pennington, Nature 192, 884 (1961). 162. R. J. Pennington, BJ 88, 64 (1963). 163. R. J. Pennington, Proc. Nutr. Soc. (Engl. Scot.) 21, 206 (1962). 164. A. C. Engel, C. S. Potter, and J. W. Rosevear, Nature 202, 670 (1964). 165. M. W. McCaman and R. E. McCaman, Am. J. P h y s d . 209, 495 (1965). 166. D. E. Kizer, B. A. Howell, B. C. Shirley, J. A. Clouse, and B. Cox, Cancer Res. 2 6 4 822 (1966).
72
C. L. ZIELKE AND C. H. SUELTER
A M P aminohydrolase activity was low but distinguishable in the leg, diaphragm, and heart muscle of a 20-24-day-old rabbit fetus (169). The activity in the heart remained low in both neonatal and adult life, whereas a rapid increase occurred in the activity of the enzyme in the diaphragm during the 4 or 5 days before parturition reaching a maximum activity immediately after birth. In contrast the enzymic activity of the mixed leg muscles remained relatively constant until 8-9 days after birth when it began to rise steadily with increased physical activity reaching an adult value of 7-8 times that of the fetal muscle within 14 days. Similar but qualitatively different effects were observed with guinea pig and rat leg muscle and chicken leg and pectoral muscle. Increases in aldolase, myokinase, and creatine phosphokinase activity were roughly parallel to increases in AMP aminohydrolase activity. Although it has been reported that increased AMP aminohydrolase activity occurred during prolonged stimulation of muscle bundles (170l 7 2 ) , the participation of this enzyme in the contractile process seems unlikely in light of the lack of significant changes in the levels of AMP and I M P during a single contraction of frog abdominal muscle (173). This is corroborated by the absence of AMP aminohydrolase activity in muscle of some invertebrates (174-176) and in human uterine muscle (177). It is tempting to consider regulation of the concentration of AMP, a known effector of several glycolytic enzymes, by the antagonistic action of adenine and guanine nucleotides on AMP deamination as a control factor in glycolysis and gluconeogenesis (178). Setlow et al. ( 1 4 1 ) suggested the participation of AMP aminohydrolase in a self-regulating system for purine nucleotide interconversion as presented in Fig. 1. As the G T P concentration decreases, AMP aminohydrolase inhibition is re167. D. E. Kizer, B. C. Shirley, B. Cox, and B. A. Howell, Cancer Res. 25, 596 (1965). 168. D. E. Kizer, B. A. Howell, J. A. Clouse, and B. C. Shirley, Cancer Res. 26, 1376 (1966). 169. J. Kendrick-Jones and S. V. Perry, BJ 103, 207 (1967). 170. J. Wajzer. R. Weber, J. Lerique, and J. Nekhorocheff. Nature 178, 1287 (1956). 171. E. M. Szentkiralyi. ABB 67, 298 (1957). 172. N. Moldoveanu, R e v . Roiimaine Biochim. 2, 327 (1965). 173. D. F. Cain, M. J. Kushmerick, and R . E. Davies. BBA 74, 735 (1963). 174. S. Kitagawa and Y. Tononiura. J . Biochem. ( T o k y o ) 44, 317 (1957). 175. D. Gilmour and J. H. Calaby. Enzynzologia 16, 23 (1953). 176. D. C. Cochran, BBA 52, 218 (1961). 177. T. T. Hayashi and P. S. Olmstcad, Anal. Biochem. 10, 354 (1965). 178. M. C. Scrutton and M. F. Utter, Ann, R e v . Biochem. 37, 249 (1968).
3.
PURINE AMINOHYDROLASES
1 3
73
Fumarote
ATP-----
I ----
+
Aden ylosuccinate
GDP Aspartate t P, t GTP
I I
I I
I I
I
I
“k ATP t Glutamtne AMP
+ Pyrophosphate + glutamate
I I I I I L------GTP
FIG.1. Purine nucleotide interconversions
leased with a concomitant increase in hypoxanthine and G T P which completes the self-regulating system by inhibiting the AMP aminohydrolase. I n the case of the rat and calf brain enzymes, the ATP activation and G T P inhibition were observed a t the normal i n vivo concentrations of these nucleotides and AMP (131, 155). However, such a control mechanism based upon kinetically observed changes with an in vitro system is subject to presently undefined effects by other factors i n vivo. At present only preliminary data exist as to (1) the effects of divalent metals such as Mg2+and Ca2+upon the activation and inhibition by nucleotides (138, 147, 153a) and (2) the effects of anions other than nucleotides (133, 147, 15%). Consequently, the control and function of AMP aminohydrolase remain interesting questions.
V. Adenine Nucleoside and Nucleotide Aminohydrolase (Nonspecific)
A. ADENOSINE AMINOHYDROLASE (NONSPECIFIC) Of the two homogeneous preparations of a nonspecific adenosine aminohydrolase from Aspergillus oryzae (Takadiastase) (92,179) that described by Wolfenden et al. (92) appears to be more facile and concise. Both procedures yield enzyme with turnover numbers near lo5 moles adenosine deaminated per minute and molecular weights near 215,000. The mo)
74
C. L. ZIFLKE AND C. H. SUFLTEIt
lecular weight in 8 M urea is reduced to 103,000 ( 9 2 ) ; Minato (179) observed additional dissociation in 3 M guanidine-HC1 to a 29,000 molecular weight unit or 7-8 subunits. The two preparations from A . oryzae reportedly differ in amino acid and carbohydrate composition. The enzyme prepared by Minato contained 25% carbohydrate; no cysteine was detected either by titration with p-mercuribenzoate in 6 M urea or by cysteic acid analysis after performic acid oxidation (179). In contrast, Wolfenden et al. ( 9 2 ) reported 14 cysteine residues per mole of enzyme which reacted instantaneously with p-mercuribenzoate in the absence of urea. No explanation is available for this apparent discrepancy. The enzyme catalyzes the deamination of a wide spectrum of naturally occurring adenosine derivatives including, in addition to the majority of compounds noted in Table VII, many other phosphorylated derivatives (75, 179). The I<,,&values for adenosine, 5'-AMP, 3'-AMP, 3',5'-cyclic AMP, and 2'-dAMP ranged from 0.1 to 0.5 mM. Except for 2'-dAMP, the relative rates of deaniination for these compounds were similar. The 2'-monophosphate ester was not deaminated (75, 180). Oligomers of AMP such as ApA, ApAp, ApApA, and ApApApA (181) were also substrates; deamination of the first residue of ApAp was more rapid than the second. Deamination of polyadenylic, polydeoxyadenylic, and the terminal residue of E . coli soluble RNA was not observed. TABLE VII SUBSTRATE SPECIFICITY OF ADENINE NUCLEOTIDE AMINOHYDROLASES
D. desulfuricansa
M . audouinic
P . crispatab
Substrate
Vm, (prnolel K, X (d) min/mg) pHopt 106 M
Vmax Km X (rel) pHopt 106 M
ATP ADP AMP Adenosine NAD
0.285 0.30 0.25 0.69 59
0.69 0.72 1.0 0.28 0.49
K,
13.8 12.6 14.2 0.98 30
6.0 6.0 6.8 7.1 5.6
6.6 4.7 4.7 56.0 7.2
5.0 5.0 5.0 5.0
3.3 4.7 8.3 52
Vmax
(re11 1 0.84 0.20
Conditions: 0.05 M sodium phosphate pH 5.8-6.0, temperature not given. Deaminations observed in 0.05 M phosphate buffer, 22";K , and Vmaxwere obtained from Lineweaver-Burk plots. Conditions 0.1 M acetate 25". a
179. S. Minato, J . Biochem. ( T o k y o ) 64, 815 (1968). 180. T. P. Wang, L. Shuster, and N. 0. Kaplan, JBC 206, 299 (1954). 181. R. Wolfenden, T. K . Sharpless, and R. Allan. JBC 242, 977 (1967).
3. PURINEAMINOHYDROLASES
75
Aspects of the mechanism of deamination catalyzed by the nonspecific Takadiastase enzyme are discussed in conjunction with calf duodenal adenosine aminohydrolase (see Section 111).
B. ADENINENUCLWTIDE AMINOHYDROLASE Three highly purified preparations catalyzing the deamination of ATP, ADP, and AMP have been isolated from Porphyra crispata (red marine alga) (182), Microsporum audouini (183), and Desulfovibrio desulfuric a m (grown anaerobically) (184). The enzyme from the red marine alga seaweed, purified 950-fold catalyzes the deamination of compounds noted in Table VII; 2’-AMP, 3’-AMP, NADP, and adenine were not substrates. Although no evidence regarding homogeneity was presented the constant ratios of activity for AMP: ADP: ATP: NAD :adenosine throughout the purification and heat inactivation data are consistent with a single enzyme. The reaction was activated by divalent cations Caz+,Mg2+,and Baz+; Ca2+was twice as effective as Mg2+ and Ba2+.The percent activation by Ca2+ of NAD, ATP, ADP, 5’-AMP, and adenosine deamination was 81, 260, 200, 116, and 0, respectively (182). The enzyme from M . audouini cultured on wheat bran, initially called AMP deaminase (185), has been extensively purified (4000-fold) (183) and renamed ATP aminohydrolase because of greater activity on that substrate. The ultracentrifugal sedimentation pattern exhibited a large and small peak, but no evidence was presented regarding the identity of either. Requirements for catalytic cofactors were negative. In addition to substrates noted in Table VII, 3’-AMP, 3’,5‘-cyclic AMP, dATP, dADP, dAMP, ADPribose, ADPglucose, 5‘-adenosine monosulfate, $-adenosine acetate, 5’-adenosine propionate, NAD, FAD, CoA, and nucleosidin were deaminated at appreciable rates. Deamination of ATP was inhibited by orthophosphate, pyrophosphate, triphosphate, and Fe3+;with adenosine none of these substances were effective inhibitors. Effects of other divalent cations were not reported. In contrast to the cation activation observed with the P . crispata enzyme, the preparation from D. desulfuricans 800-fold purified (184) way not activated by cations nor inhibited by EDTA, cysteine, and Na,S. Substrates other than those noted in Table VII were dATP, dADP, 182. 183. 184. 185.
J. C. Su, C. C. Li, and C. C. Ting, Biochemistry 5, 536 (1966). S. T. Chung and K. Aida, J . Biochem. (Tokyo) 61, 1 (1967). M. G. Yates, BBA 171, 299 (1969). K. Aida, S. Chung, I. Suzuki, and T. Yagi. Agr. B i d . Chem. 29, 508 (1965).
76
C.
L. ZIELKE AND
C.
H.STJELTEB
dAMP, deoxyadenosine, and ADPribose. The enzyme was inhibited by several anions ( K i ): cacodylate (134 mM), phosphate (83 mM), maleate (22 mM), succinate (18 mM) , citrate (6 mM), and &&dimethyl glutarate (3.2
a).
VI. Guanine hinohydrolase
Partially purified preparations of guanine aminohydrolase (EC 3.5.4.3) have been reported from rabbit liver (68,186), rat liver (61), Cbstridium acidurici (187),rat brain (60, 188, 189), and lingcod muscle (IN). The rat brain enzyme (60) occurs in both the mitochondria1 and supernatant fraction; the latter fraction yielded two forms, A and B from DEAEcellulose, which were subsequently purified 70- and 600-fold, respectively. Form B had a specific activity of 290 pmoles/min/mg. Kinetic, immunochemical, and electrophoretic studies revealed that the mitochondrial enriyme was distinct from supernatant enzyme B. A distinction between the supernatant A and B forms was less certain (60). Little is known of the physical properties of guanine aminohydrolase. Elution of rabbit liver enzyme from Sephadex gave a skewed activity peak; the estimated molecular weight of the main component was 170,000, a minor shoulder component, 525,000 (60). Substrates susceptible to enzymic hydrolysis by the lingcod muscle enzyme including K,,, and relative (V,,,,,J are: guanine, 0.033 mM, (1) ; 2-chloro-6-hydroxypurine,0.15 mM, (0.31) ; 2-hydrazino-6-hydroxypurine, 0.04 mM, (0.07); 1-methylguanine, 0.19 mM, (0.8); and 8azaguanine, 1 mM, (8.1) (191). Like adenosine aminohydrolase (see Section 111) guanine aminohydrolase requires no known cofactors and catalyzes both a dechlorination and hydrolysis of a hydrazino group. Likewise the 8-aza derivative of guanine was more rapidly deaminated than the natural substrates. Rat brain mitochondrial enzyme, however, did not affect deamination of 8-azaguanine (60). The enzyme was inhibited by NaCN (0.1 M, 45%), K F (lo-*M ,75%), and p-mercuribenzoate ( lcr4M, 100%); iodoacetate and CuSO,, l W 5 M, did not inhibit (68). The rat and sheep brain preparations exhibited a double pH optima, pH 4-6.5 and 8.0-9.0, with guanine as substrate (188, 186. G. H. Hitchings and E. A. Falco, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S . 30, 294 (1444). 187. J. Rakosky, L. N. Zimmerman, and J. V. Beck, J . Bacterial. 69, 566 (1955). 188. M. Mansoor, G. D. Kalyankar, and G. P. Talwar, BBA 77, 307 (1963). 189. S. Kumar, K. K. Tewari, and P. S. Krishnan, J . Neurochem. 13, 1550 (1968). 190. R. Currie, F. Bergel, and R. C. Bray, BJ 104, 634 (1967). 191. J. E. Roy and K. L. Roy, Can. J . Biocbm. 45, 1263 (1967).
3. PUBINE A l U I N O H Y D W W ~
77
189);the rat brain particulate preparation exhibited a single pH 8.0 optimum after solubilization by Triton. The purified supernatant and mitochondria1 enzyme also had single pH optima in the range of pH 7-8 (60).Crude enzyme from lingcod muscle had double peaks of activity at pH 5.6 and 8.5, but after heat treatment during purification it had a single optimum of pH 6.0. While not understood, these double pH optima may reflect pH-dependent mitochondria1 membrane-enzyme associations or other enzyme-protein interactions which are destroyed during purification. A naturally occurring noncompetitive, proteinlike, heat labile inhibitor of guanine aminohydrolase isolated from rat eye lens (192),rat liver (60),or heavy mitochondrial fractions of rat cerebellum (60) may also be responsible. Since guanine aminohydrolase catalyzes the deamination of thioguanine and 8-azaguanine thereby destroying their anti-neoplastic effects, Baker and his colleagues have prepared a series of active site directed irreversible inhibitors to block the enzyme in tumor tissue (193).The most effective inhibitor, 9- (4-methoxy phenyl) guanine, effected a 50% inhibition at 0.38 pill in the presence of 13.3 pill substrate (194). The physiological role of guanine aminohydrolase is uncertain. The catabolic role in uric acid and allantoin production might be emphasized especially with respect to the deficiency of this enzyme in pig liver and spleen which is believed to be responsible for a form of gout observed in pigs in which crystals of guanine are deposited in joints (196).A lack of or deficiency of this enzyme may also account for the interesting distribution of guanine in nature (195). Evaluation of serum guanine aminohydrolase activities has been suggested as a quantitative indication of liver cell damage (196).
VII. Guanosine Aminohydrolase
A guanosine aminohydrolase preparation from Pseudomonas convexa No. 149 free from guanine, adenine and adenosine aminohydrolase and nucleoside phosphorylase activities has been described (63). Of the 22 192. S. Kumar, A B B 126, 964 (1968). 193. B. R. Baker, J . Chem. Educ. 44, 610 (1967). 194. B. R. Baker and W. F. Wood, J . Med. Chem. 10, 1106 (1967). 195. A. Bendich, in “The Nucleic Acids” (E. Chargaff and J. N. Davidson, eds.), Vol. 1, p. 95. Academic Press, New York, 1955. 196. S. McLeod, Can, J . Med. Technol. 29, 60 (1967); E. M. Knights, Jr., Progr. Clin. Pathol. 1, 318 (1966); E. BowkiewicrSurma and J. Krawcznski, Clin. Chim. Acta 16, 26 (1967).
78
C.
L. ZIELKE AND
C. H. SUELTER
purine compounds examined as substrates, guanosine, deoxyguanosine, M, and 8-aaaguanosine were deaminated with K,,, values of 3.6 X 6.2 X M , and 1.22 X lo-' M , respectively. No cofactors were required and optimal activity for guanosine was observed between pH 6 and 6.5. The molecular weight obtained by Sephadex G-100chromatography was 1-2 x 105.
Glutaminases and y.Glutamy1transferases STANDISH C. HARTMAN I . Introduction
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Occurrence . . . . . . . . . . . . .
I1. Glutaminase of Escherichia coli .
B . Assay . . . . . . . . . . . . C . Purification . . . . . . . . . . . D. Specificity . . . . . . . . . . . E . Acyl Transfer Reactions . . . . . . . . F. Reactions of Glutaminase with 6-Diarod-oxonorleucine G . Other Inhibitors . . . . . . . . . . H . Effects of pH upon Kinetic Parameters . . . . I . Effect of Temperature . . . . . . . . J . Effect of Deuterium Oxide . . . . . . . K . Relationship to Other Acylases . . . . . . L . Mechanism of Action . . . . . . . . . 111. Other Glutaminases and Glutamyltransferases . . . . . A . Survey . . . . . . . . . . . . B . y-Glutamyltransferase from Agaricaceae . . . . C . y-Glutamyl Transpeptidases from Kidney . . . . D . Glutaminase from Azotobacter agilis . . . . . IV . Concluding Remarks . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . .
. .
79 80 81 81 82 82 84 85 87
88
.
88
. . .
90 90 90 93 93
. . . . .
.
95
96 97 98
.
I Introduction
Enzymes which catalyze cleavage of the 7-acyl bond in glutamine are classified either as glutamine amidohydrolases (EC 3.5.1.2) (glutamin79
80
STANDISH C. HARTMAN
ases) or as glutamine glutamyltransferases (EC 2.3.2.1), depending upon whether the acyl acceptor is water or some other substance. I n a number of cases, categorization is necessarily somewhat arbitrary since the enzymes involved effect both hydrolysis and transfer to amines. The distinction also tends to obscure the probable mechanistic similarities of these processes. It may be useful therefore to review comparatively enzymes which, in common, transfer the acyl constituents of glutamine and related compounds. The major part of this article will be concerned with the acid glutaminase of Escherichia coli. Representative glutaminases and glutamyl transferases from bacterial, plant, and animal sources will be discussed more briefly. Considerable information on the phosphate-activated glutaminase of animal tissues is given in the previous edition of “The Enzymes” ( 1 ) . Glutamyl transferases, which act exclusively on glutaminyl residues in peptides and proteins such as the calcium-activated enzyme from guinea pig liver ( 2 ) , will be omitted from this discussion as will the class of biosynthetic enzymes which transfer the NH, group of glutamine to various activated acceptors (3).Glutamyltransferase activity dependent upon adenosine nucleotides and phosphate or arsenate, which is apparently associated with glutamine synthetase (4,5), also is not included in this coverage.
II. Glutaminase of Escherichia coli
I n 1955, Meister et al. (6) described the partial purification of an enzyme from E . coli which catalyzed the hydrolysis of L-glutamine to glutamic acid and ammonia and which was maximally active in the acidic region of pH. The enzyme showed a relatively high specificity for Lglutamine since it would not hydrolyze a large number of related amides. I n addition to hydrolysis, the enzyme catalyzed the formation of yglutamyl hydroxamic acid when hydroxylamine was present. More recently the study of this system was undertaken in the author’s laboratory with the expectation that information concerning the enzymic hydrolysis 1. E. Roberts, “The Enzymes,” 2nd ed., Vol. 4, p. 285, 1960. 2. D. D. Clarke, M. J. Mycek, A. Neidle, and H. Waelsch, ABB 79, 338 (1959); J. H. Pincus and H. Waelsch, ibid. 126,34 and 44 (1968) ; J. E. Folk and P. W. Cole, JBC 240, 2951 (1965) ; J. E. Folk and P. W. Cole, ibid. 241, 5518 (1966). 3. A. Meister, “The Enzymes,” 2nd ed., Vol. 6, p. 247, 1962. 4. A. Meister, “The Enzymes,” 2nd ed., Vol. 6, p. 443, 1962. 5. P. K. Stumpf, “Methods in Enzymology,” Vol. 2, p. 263, 1955. 6. A. Meister, L. Levintow, R. E. Greenfield, and P. A. Abendschein, JBC 215, 441 (1955); A. Meister, “Methods in Enzymology,” Vol. 2, p. 380, 1955.
4.
GLCTAMISASES AND 7-GLUTAMYLTRANSFERASES
81
of glutamine would be of value in understanding more complex biosynthetic reactions in which transfer of the NH, group occurs from this substrate to an organic acceptor (7-9).
A. OCCURRENCE Cells of E . coli B are found to produce significant amounts of this enzyme only after the stage of rapid exponential growth has ceased. All attempts to enhance or to repress its synthesis by altering the composition of the growth medium or conditions of culture have been unsuccessful. Glutaminase is not released when the cells are converted to protoplasts in isotonic sucrose, but the enzyme is solubilized upon lysis of the protoplasts. Strain W also possesses the enzyme, but no extensive screening of related species has been done.
B. ASSAY In crude enzyme systems the most sensitive assay depends upon detecting ammonia produced in the reaction: Glutamine -I-HZO -+ glutamate
+ NH,'
(1)
This product can be observed in the presence of glutamine with the use of a modified Nessler's reagent (10). More conveniently, a pH-stat assay may be employed which takes advantage of the fact that in the p H range of enzymic activity protons are taken up during the hydrolysis owing to partial protonation of the glutamate formed ( 7 ) . From the observed pK,' of glutamic acid (4.31 at 25", ionic strength 0.2), the relationship between rate of proton uptake required to maintain any constant pH and the rate of glutamine hydrolysis can be directly obtained. The hydrolysis of other glutamic acid derivatives catalyzed by the enzyme can also be followed by this method, except that ester substrates consume alkali during their hydrolysis. Also, when amides which release partially protonated amines (such as hydroxylamine and O-methylhydroxylamine) are hydrolyzed, a correction must be applied to obtain the proper relationship between titrant addition and net reaction. 7. S. C. Hartman, JBC 243, 853 (1968). 8. R. A. Hammer and S. C. Hartman, JBC 243, 864 (1968). 9. S. C. Hartman, JBC 243, 870 (1968). 10. A. P. Vanselow, Ind. Eng. Chem.. Anal. Ed. 12, 516 (1940).
82
STANDISH
C.
HARTMAN
C. PURIFICATION Purification of the glutaminase involves precipitation of impurities a t low pH, chromatography upon DEAE-cellulose, ammonium sulfate fractionation, gel filtration upon Sephadex G-100, and a heat treatment ( 7 ) . I n more recent preparations the gel filtration step has been omitted. After the heating step, the solution is thoroughly dialyzed against 0.02 M sodium acetate, p H 5.0, clarified by centrifugation, and then passed through a small column of carboxymethyl cellulose previously equilibrated with the same buffer. The enzyme, which passes directly through this column, is concentrated by ultrafiltration. The specific activity at this stage is about 50% of the maximal value observed with samples subjected to zone electrophoresis. The latter preparations appear to be better than 90% pure as judged by analytical gel electrophoresis. A net purification of about 3000-fold is achieved based upon the total soluble protein of the bacterial extracts. The enzyme preparation prior to the electrophoresis step may be stored for many months a t 2" with little loss in activity.
D . SPECIFICITY Kinetic parameters for the known substrates of glutaminase are reported in Table I ( 7 ) , the k, values (turnover numbers per active site) being given by V,,,,,/Eo. Values for active site concentration (E,) were determined from the amount of 14C-6-diazo-5-oxonorleucine(DON), which reacts covalently with the enzyme (see below), with the assumption that the number of molecules of this substrate analog bound is equivalent to the number of substrate-reactive sites. Kagan et al. (If) reported that the enzyme acts on a-methyl-L-glutamine, but rate data comparable to those of Table I are not available. Substances not hydrolyzed at a measurable rate (koless than 0.1 sec-') include L-glutamic 7-ethylamide, D,L-glutamic y-dimethylamide, L-glutamic y-anilide, Lglutamic y-p-nitroanilide, L-glutamic y-2-hydroxyethy tmide, L-glutamic y-2-chloroethylamide, D,L-glutamic y-n-butylamide, L-glutamic diamide, glutaramic acid, N-acetyl-L-glutamine, D-glutamine, D- or L-asparsgine, L-2-amino-4-cyanobutyric acid, ~-2,2,2,-trifluoroethylL-glutamate, L-pyroglutamic acid, S-carbamoyl-L-cysteine, O-acetyl-L-serine and Lisoglutamine. Meister e t al. previously reported negative results with L-homoglutamine as well as with some of the above substances (6). 11. H. M. Kagan, L. R. Manning, and A. Meister, Biochemistry 4, 1063 (1965)
4. GLUTAMINASES
83
AND 7-GLUTAMYLTRANSFERASES
TABLE I KINETICPROPERTIES OF SUBSTRATES Substraten
hb
KC
(sec-l)
(mM)
1265 8.0 14 212 296 5O8Od 645 36 1260 300
0.42 3.3 12 5.1
~~
Glutamine 7-Glutamyl methylamide 7-Glutamyl hydraside 7-Glutamyl hydroxamic acid r-Glutamyl methoxyamide Glutamic acid 7-Methyl glutamate 7-Ethyl glutamate 7-Thio methyl glutamate 7-Thio ethyl glutamate
configuration. numbers per 6-diaeo-5-oxo-~-norleucinebinding site at 25" and pH 5.0. Estimated error in /GO, f 5%. Estimated error in K,, f 20%. The values for glutamic acid are determined from the rates of exchange of 1 6 0 between HZl80and the 7-carboxyl oxygens of this substrate (8);the kinetics of hydroxamate formation yields K , = 2.0 mM. 0
All materials were of the
5.0 2.gd 64 50 10 23
* ko values are the turnover
L
While not hydrolyzed by the enzyme, the following compounds act as competitive inhibitors: L-glutamic y-ethylamide ( K , = 2.8 mM) , L-glutamic y-2-hydroxyethylamide ( K , = 52 mM) , and 2,2,2-trifluoroethyl glutamate ( K , = 67 mill). Other substances related to glutamine which are neither substrates nor inhibitors are L-glutamic diamide, N-acetyl-L-glutamine, glutaramic acid, L-glutamic y-anilide, L-2-amino4-cyanobutyric acid, S-carbamoyl-L-cysteine, 0-acetyl-L-serine, D,L-methionine sulfoxide, D,L-methionine sulfone, D,L-methionine sulfoximine, D,L-allylglycine, and ~,~-2-amino-4-iodobutyric acid. The structural requirements for a substance to be a substrate for the glutaminase are relatively stringent: the L- configuration and a free amino and a-carboxyl group are necessary; also, a carbonyl group on the C-5 atom is apparently essential. I n general, the rate of hydrolysis within a given class of compounds is inversely related to the size of the substituent in the y position (NH, > NHCH, > NHCH,CH,; OH > OCH, > OCH,CH,, etc.), In comparing substituents of similar size, the sulfur and oxygen compounds are cleaved more rapidly than amides (OH > NH,; SCH, > OCH, > NHCH,; etc.). The K , (or K , values are most obviously affected by the chemical nature of the group; the esters and the amides each have a characteristic range of substration parameters. This generalization does not hold in the case of the very (Y-
84
STANDIGH C. EABTMAN
small substituents NH, and OH, which have significantly lower K,,, values than other N or 0 compounds. As the size of the group increases, the hydrolytic rate constant first drops to zero, without a correspondingly large change in K , or K , but after a critical size is reached (e.g., dimethylamide or 2-chloroethylamide) the compound is totally rejected by the enzyme. The contrasting substituent effects upon K,,, and k, indicate that the events of substrate binding and catalysis are governed by largely independent factors. At least for the poorer substrates, the K , values probably approximate dissociation constants of the Michaelis complexes.
E. A c n
TRANSFER
REACTIONS
I n the presence of hydroxylamine, glutaminase catalyzes the synthesis of y-glutamyl hydroxamic acid from all of the substrates in Table I. The rate of this reaction with either glutamine or glutamic acid is linearly related to the concentration of the free base of hydroxylamine over a range of p H values (7).At substrate saturation, a catalytic rate constant for reaction of any substrate with hydroxylamine can therefore be defined as kN = VN/(NH*OH) ( E , ) , where V , is the zero-order rate of hydroxamic acid formation. The relative rates of hydroxylaminolysis and hydrolysis have been determined for a number of substrates (glutamine, glutamic acid, y-methyl glutamate, and 7-thio methyl glutamate), and the ratio kN/k, is observed to be the same for all within experimental error (2.&2.2 M-l) (9). The apparent superiority of hydroxylamine compared to water is even more evident if the rates of hydrolysis are expressed for water in the standard state of moles per liter (i.e., k0/55.5).On a molar basis, hydroxylamine reacts about two orders of magnitude more rapidly than water. Under conditions of experimental measurement, however, when the concentration of NH,OH is on the order of 0.02 M (at pH 5 ) , observed velocities of hydrolysis are much larger than those of hydroxylaminolysis, as noted by Meister et al. ( 6 ) . The equilibrium constant of the reaction RCOOH
+ NHRH
RCONHOH
+ H R ( R = - CH&H.&H(NHs+) COO-)
(2)
as catalyzed by the enzyme is observed to be
when the activity of water is taken as 1, or 1.1 X 10' when it is expressed as 55.5 M.This is a pH-independent constant when the concentrations of the species are given in the ionic forms shown. This value agrees within
4.
85
GLUTAMIMASES AND y-GLUTAMYLTRANSFERASES
a factor of two with that calculated by Ehrenfeld et al. for the similar process catalyzed by an enzyme from Azotobacter agilis (12) or with that found by Jencks et al. for related equilibria of homogeneous phase reactions of carboxylic acids with hydroxylamine (IS). At equilibrium, therefore, partitioning of the acyl group between hydroxylamine and water favors the former by about lo4. I n the reaction catalyzed by E. coli glutaminase, the kinetic partitioning ratio [ kN(HzO)/k,] was seen to be only lo2. Glutaminase also catalyzes acyl transfer from glutamic acid to methanol by the reverse of the reaction of methyl glutamate hydrolysis (7) : Glutamic acid
+ methanol
methyl glutamate
+H a
(4)
The rate constant k, = V,/(CH,OH) ( E o ) is 0.47 M-' sec-' a t 25" and p H 5.0, a value which may be compared to that for the virtual hydrolysis of glutamic acid Ic,/(H,O) of 91.5M-' sec-'. Thus, from the ratio k, (H,O)/lc,, it is seen that the rate with methanol is some 194 times slower on a molar basis than that with water even though methanol is generally observed to be a somewhat better nucleophile than water in similar nonenzymic substitution reactions ( 1 4 ) . These results indicate that the enzyme shows a large preference kinetically for water over hydroxylamine or methanol compared to what would be expected on the basis of the intrinsic reactivities of these substances.
F. REACTIONS OF GLUTAMINASE WITH
6-DIAZO-5-OXONORLEUCINE
In the presence of an excess of the glutamine analog, DON, the enzyme is readily inactivated irreversibly ('7). This substance behaves as an active-site-directed alkylating agent in a number of enzymes which utilize glutamine as substrate ( 3 ) . With the use of 6-14C-DON, the amount of inhibitor covalently bound to protein can be directly measured; and, as shown in Fig. 1, this amount is linearly correlated with the extent of inhibition of catalytic activity. The simplest explanatioii of this behavior is that irreversible reaction of one molecule of DON with the enzyme inactivates one catalytic site, probably by combination with an essential group a t that site. With this assumption the concentration of active sites in an enzyme preparation may be calculated for the 12. E. Ehrenfeld, S. J. Marble, and A. Meister, JBC 238, 3711 (1963). 13. W. P. Jencks. M . Caplow, M. Gilchrist, and R. G. Kallen, Biochemistry 2, 1313 (1963). 14. M. L. Bender, G . E. Clement, C. R. Gunter, and F. J. KBsdy, JACS 66, 3697 (1964).
86
STANDISH C. HARTMAN
4
c
0 3 x
-e0
E i
:2 = n 0 z
x I
I
I
5
10
’
15
11.0
DON added, prnoles X I O ~
FIG.1. Titration of glutaminase with “C-DON. The amount of labeled DON bound to 20.7 p g of enzyme protein is shown. (0) DON bound; (0) enzymic activity.
purpose of expressing kinetic values on an absolute basis. In studies with the essentially pure enzyme it is found that one mole of DON binds to 50,000 g of protein. Comparison with an approximate molecular weight for the protein of 100,000, estimated by gel filtration on a calibrated column, indicates that two identical catalytic subunits comprise the molecule. It may be seen from the proportional region of Fig. 1 that only a small fraction, about 1/70, of the DON added to the enzyme becomes covalently bound. Further analysis of this phenomenon has shown that glutaminase catalyzes the hydrolytic cleavage of the ketone and that the rate of this reaction is 70 times that of the irreversible inactivation of the enzyme. Once alkylation of all reactive sites is complete, the further catalytic hydrolysis of DON is totally blocked. After reaction of 6-14C-DONwith glutaminase, glutamic acid ( 1 equivalent) and I4C-methanol (0.75 equivalent) were isolated from the reaction mixture. The initial product formed from the C-6 atom appears to be diazomethane ( 1 4 ~ )If. relatively high concentrations of a benaoic acidbenzoate buffer are included in the reaction mixture, labeled methyl benzoate is formed in addition to the methanol. Further, the relative 14a. S. C . Hartman and T. McGrath, unpublished observations (1969).
4.
87
GLUTAMINASES AND y-GLUTAMYLTRANSFERASES
amounts of methyl benzoate and methanol formed are identical to those observed when 14C-diazomethane itself is added to the benzoate buffer system a t the same p H and concentration. The reactions are viewed as occurring as follows:
+
+
Enzymic: RCOCHNz HzO + RCOOH CHZNZ Nonenzymic: CHZNZ HzO -+ CH,OH Nz CHZNZ beiizoic acid + methyl benzoate
+ +
+
(5)
+ Iyz
(6)
(7)
The C-C bond cleavage catalyzed by the enzyme appears to be very similar to the reactions of all other derivatives of glutamic acid. A precedent for this C-C bond cleavage exists in the action of chymotrypsin upon ethyl 5- (p-hydroxyphenyl)-3-oxovalerate (15).Which of the two modes of reaction occurs between DON and glutaminase may depend upon whether a catalytic group on the enzyme attacks C-5 of the analog, leading to hydrolysis, or C-6, leading to irreversible alkylation. The fact that l’C-DON labeled in positions 1-5 gives rise to labeled enzyme and, after cleavage with trypsin, to peptides identical to those derived with the use of 6-14C-DON indicates that the diazomethane released is not the primary inhibitor. The site of covalent attachment of the inhibitor moiety has not yet been defined. G. OTHERINHIBITORS Glutaminase is sensitive to inhibition by heavy metal ions and their derivatives. Mercuric ion and p-mercuribenzoate inhibit completely a t 0.1 mM; silver, lead, and cupric ions are effective a t somewhat higher concentrations. The presence of glutamine prevents inhibition by p-mercuribenzoate. Other divalent metal ions, including magnesium, manganese, zinc, cadmium, cobalt, ferrous, and calcium, neither inhibit nor activate a t 1 mM. The metal chelating agents ethylenediaminetetraacetate (EDTA) , o-phenanthroline, and dithiothreitol do not inhibit but instead result in slight activation. Despite the inhibition by heavy metals, iodoacetate, iodoacetamide, and N-ethylmaleimide, which generally react with sulfhydryl groups, are not inhibitory when the enzyme is exposed to them a t either pH 5 or 7. Glutaminase is similarly insensitive to diisopropylphosphorofluoridate (DFP). Phthalein dyes, such as bromocresol green, strongly inhibit glutaminases from kidney (1) and from Clostn’dia (16),but they do not affect the E . coli enzyme. 15. D. G. Doherty, JACS 77, 4887 (1955). 16. D. E. Hughes and D. H. Williamson, BJ 51, 45 (1952).
88 H. EFFECTS OF pH
STANDISH C. HARTMAN
UPON
KINETICPARAMETERS
The E . coli glutaminase functions effectively only in the acidic pH region. Values of K , and k , have been evaluated over the whole pH range of interest for a good ester substrate (methyl glutamate) and for a poor amide substrate (glutamyl methylamide), as well as over a more restricted ranges for glutamic acid and glutamine (9). I n all cases the maximum velocity for any substrate is essentially independent of pH over the entire accessible range. The K , values are also constant from below pH 4 to about 5.3. (The fact that the K,,, for glutamic acid is also constant in this range indicates that the protonated form of glutamic acid rather than glutamate ion is the true substrate.) Above about pH 5.3, K , values rise as a very steep function of pH as shown in Table 11; thus, when a pH above 5.8 is reached, substrates virtually cease to be bound by the enzyme. As Peller and Alberty have shown, the dependence of IC,/K, upon p H indicates the dissociation of essential acidic groups on the free enzyme (17).I n the present case this ratio changes with pH four to five times more steeply than would be expected if a single acidic group were required in the free enzyme. The results are consistent with the view that the state of the enzyme capable of binding substrate is stabilized by the cooperative action of several acidic groups. Dissociation of any one of these groups transforms the enzyme into the inactive form as the cooperative stabilization is lost. Since there is no additional effect of p H upon k,, it appears that all catalytic groups are in their proper state of dissociation in the ES complex and are not permitted to change while the complex exists.
I. EFFECT OF TEMPERATURE The variations of velocity with temperature over the range 5 " 3 5 " were measured for several substrates (9). Linear Arrhenius plots of these data were obtained which allowed calculation of the empirical activation energy and AH^. A F ~values a t 25" were calculated from the first-order rate constants ko expressed in units of sec-'. These values and the entropies of activation are given in Table 111. The K , values for glutamine have also been determined over this temperature range and found not to vary from the value a t 25" (4.32 mM) by an experimentally significant amount. 17. L. Peller and R. A. Alberty, JACS 81, 5907 (1959).
4.
89
GLCTAMINASES AND y-CLUTAMTLTRANSFERASES
TABLE I1 KINETIC PARAMETERSO
EFFECTOF pH
UPON
~
K, (mM)
Substrate and pH
4.00 4.50 5.00 5.30 5.40 5.50 5.60 5.70
Methyl glutamate 58 64 60 70 122 270 555 >2000
3.50 4.00 4.50 5.00 5.30 5.40 5.50 5.60
Glutamyl methylamide 3.35 3.20 3.41 3.30 3.70 4.65 5.50 14.3
4.00 4.50 5.00 5.40
Glutamine 0.53 0.48 0.42 0.92 Glutamic acid 2.0
5.00 4.30 a
b
ko (sec-l)
537 615 645 603 670 683 634 b 7.4 8.1 8.0 8.0 8.7 8.4 9.2 9.0 1250 1220 1265 1190
5080 4830
All values are at 25" and ionic strength 0.2 M. Indeterminate. TABLE I11 ACTIVATION PAR.4METERSa
~
~~
ko
AF:
AH:
Substrate
(sec-l)
(kcal mole-')
(kcal mole-l)
AS: (eu)
Glutamic acid Glutamine ?-Methyl glutamate 7-Ethyl glutamate 7-Glutamyl methylamide
5080 1265 645 36 8.0
12.4 13.2 13.6 15.4 16.2
8.2 7.9 8.1 10.2 14.2
-14.1 -17.8 -18.4 -17.4 -6.7
a
Values were determined at 25",ionic strength 0.2M . Estimated error in AH:, f 0.5
kcsl mole-'; in AS:, f 2 eu.
STANDISH C. HARTMAN
J. EFFECT OF DEUTERIUM OXIDE Rates of hydrolysis of several substrates in water and in D,O have been compared (9). Average values of VH20/VD,0were, for glutamine, 1.16; for methyl glutamate, 1.38; for glutamyl methylamide, 1.10; and for glutamic acid, 1.50.
K. RELATIONSHIP TO OTHERACYLASES A majority of the known enzymes capable of hydrolyzing carboxylic derivatives (acylases) can be placed into four categories according to their mode of action or key functional groups (18): (1) serine esterases, typified by chymotrypsin and subtilisin; (2) thiol acylases such as papain ; (3) metal dependent enzymes, including carboxypeptidase and various aminoacylases; and (4) acid proteases such as pepsin. Glutaminase catalyzes reactions similar to those of the above enzymes, including the ability to act on various types of carboxylic derivatives and to transfer the acyl groups to water and other acceptors. A more detailed comparison, however, strongly indicates that the glutaminase does not fall into these previously recognized categories. Table IV summarizes certain characteristics of representative enzymes from these classes and those of glutaminase (19-96). The distinctions between glutaminase and these enzymes are clear enough, it is felt, to warrant the conclusion that primary differences must exist in the fundamental aspects of the catalytic process. The strong possibility that glutaminase acts upon carboxylic derivatives by a novel mechanism and with a catalytic efficiency substantially greater than that of other acylases make it an intriguing system for further study.
L. MECHANISM OF ACTION Hydrolytic enzymes may be regarded as catalysts of group transfer processes. It is often the case in such processes that the group being 18. B. S. Hartley, Ann Rev. Biochem. 29, 45 (1960). 19. G. P. Hess, “The Enzymes,” 3rd ed., Vol. 111, p. 213, 1971. 20. E. L. Smith, “The Enzymes,” 3rd ed., Vol. 111, p. 501, 1971. 21. W. Lipscomb and J. A. Hartsuck, “The Enzymes,” 3rd ed., Vol. 111, p. 1, 1971. 22. J. S. Fruton, “The Enzymes,” 3rd ed., Vol. 111, p. 119, 1971. 23. B. Zerner, R. P. M. Bond, and M. L. Bender, JACS 86, 3674 (1964). 24. J. R. Whitaker and M. 2, Bender, JACS 87, 2728 (1965). 25. W. 0. McClure, A. Neurath, and K. A. Walsh, Biochemistry 3, 1897 (1964). 26. K. Inouye and J. S. Fruton, JACS 89, 187 (1967).
P 0
TABLE IV COMPARISON O F E. COli GLUTAMINASE WlTH Chymotrypsina Principal functional groups pH optimum Selective inhibitors
Serine, histidine >7 DFP
ko (see-l) for good substrates Esters Amides
63* 0.039"
P
OTHER
ACYLASES
Papainb
Carboxypeptidasec
Pepsind
Cysteine, histidine
Aspartic acid 2 4
Heavy metals iodoacetate
Zinc, glutamic acid tyrosine >7 Metal chelating agents
15.7, 8.5,
4669 1829
0.77h 0.29
5-8
Glutaminase ?
3.5-5.5 Heavy metals, DON (iodoacetate, DFP, chelating agents not inhibitory)
645 1265
~~
See Hess (19). b See Smith (20). 6 See Lipscomb and Hartauck (bf ) . d See Fruton (2.2). 0
N-Acetyl-lrphenylalanine derivatives, 25" (23). N-Benaoyl-karginine derivatives, 25" (2.4). Hippuryl derivatives of phenyllacta& and phenylalanine, 25" (26). h CBZ-histidyl-p-nitrophenylaianyl derivatives of phenyllactic methyl ester and phenyldanyl methyl ester, 37" (96).
6
f
3 B%
D
92
STANDISH C. HARTMAN
transferred forms an intermediate compound with a component of the enzyme. I n the case of acylases, the group transferred is the acyl moiety, and i t is well documented that a t least certain members of this class proceed through the intermediate formation of an acyl-enzyme derivative in a two-step acylation-deacylation sequence. Although the importance of this mode of action is established, in principle, an alternative path exists in the direct reaction between the ultimate nucleophilic agent (e.g., water) and the enzyme-bound substrate. There can be very little doubt about the existence of an acyl-enzyme intermediate in cases where the derivative has been isolated or otherwise directly observed. However, the implication of such an intermediate strictly by indirect kinetic means almost invariably is open to uncertainty. As mentioned above, chemically different substrates of glutaminase, including glutamic acid, the amide, the methyl ester, and the thiomethyl ester, all react in the presence of hydroxylamine to produce glutamyl hydroxamic acid. At a fixed concentration of hydroxylamine, all of these substrates show the same ratio of initial reaction rates with the amine and water. The nucleophilic agents must therefore react with a common intermediate, regardless of the substrate, since one would expect the partitioning ratio between hydroxylamine and water to vary over several orders of magnitude if a direct reaction between nucleophilea and substrates governed the kinetics (9). Despite the fact that a distinct intermediate appears to occur in the pathway, i t is unlikely that this component could be observed directly since its expected rate of reaction should exceed its rate of formation (except possibly for the best substrate, glutamic acid). This conclusion follows from the observation that the rate of the slow step in the overall hydrolytic reaction, i.e., that which controls k,, depends upon the nature of the substrate and therefore precedes the formation of the common intermediate. It is reasonable to identify the intermediate indicated by the abovementioned experiments as a 7-glutamyl-enzyme compound, an interpretation not excluded by any of the experimental results. There is, however, another plausible explanation for the observations, which does not necessarily involve a covalent enzyme-substrate compound of this kind. In this alternative proposal the rate determining steps in the catalytic reaction are not involved with the covalent bond processes but are conformational changes in the enzyme-substrate and enzyme-product complexes. If product is not released from the enzyme until a large number of rapid covalent reactions with the available nucleophiles has occurred, then any substrate will be converted to the same equilibrium mixture of bound products (e.g., glutamic acid and glutamyl hydroxamic
4.
GLUTAMINASES AND y-GLUTAMYLTRANSFERASES
93
acid) and the formation of free products observed in the steady state will be independent of substrate structure. The postulation that enzyme isomerization is rate controlling is not inconsistent with the lack of observable effect of p H upon k,, with the small solvent deuterium isotope effects and with the rather low values for enthalpies of activation. A scheme representing this type of mechanism is summarized in Eqs. ( 8 ) (12) :
(8) (9) + + + (10) + (11) (12) where E*S and E"P indicate conformational states different from the Michaelis complexes and N, and N, represent water and some other nucleophilic reactant. The fast covalent steps of Eq. (10) could in principle occur either through nucleophilic participation of a group on the enzyme or through direct displacement by the terminal acyl acceptors N, and N,. It is not possible to distinguish between these paths with present information. It is tempting to consider the (unidentified) residue which reacts with DON as a nucleophilic catalyst in the hydrolytic reactions. On the other hand, its function as an acidic or basic catalyst in a direct displacement reaction is also easily envisaged. E+SGES ES E'S E'S N1 E'P N) E'P EP EPeE+P
(slow, rate determining) (fast) (slow)
111. Other Glutaminases and Glutamyltransferases
A. SURVEY The glutamine transforming enzymes treated in this chapter may be arbitrarily placed into four categories based upon the nature of the acyl group acceptor: (1) Strictly hydrolytic. The anion-stimulated glutaminase I of animal tissues apparently is unable to utilize acceptors other than water and ammonia. Ammonia, the product of the normal hydrolytic reaction, is observed to exchange with the NH, group of glutamine in the absence of a concurrent exchange of the acyl portion of the molecule (27').Glutamyl hydroxamic acid is not a substrate, nor will hydroxylamine serve to accept the glutamyl group of glutamine ( 6 , 28). 27. J. D. Klingman and P. Handler, JBC 232, 369 (1958) 28. C. Lamar, Jr.. BBA 151, 188 (1968).
94
STANDISH C. HARTMAN
(2) Reaction with water preferred. The glutaminase of E. coli preferentially catalyzes hydrolysis of glutamyl derivatives but will also utilize acceptors such as hydroxylamine and methanol. Larger amine acceptors are excluded. The glutaminases from Pseudomonas (29, 30) and from Azotobacter agilis (12) are probably of this sort. The latter enzymes act upon D- as well as L-glutamine, and upon asparagine. (3) Reaction with amine acceptors preferred. Hydrolysis of glutamyl compounds occurs with the transferase from mushrooms (31) and with one type of transpeptidase isolated from kidney ( 3 2 ) . However, when suitable amine acceptors are present the hydrolytic reaction is largely suppressed in favor of transfer to the amine. (4) Totally nonhydrolytic. The glutarnyl transferase from Proteus vulgaris acts upon glutamine as substrate and utilizes hydroxylarnine, hydrazine, and ammonia as acceptors, but it is apparently devoid of any glutaminase activity ( 3 3 ) . Glutamyl units derived from L- or Dglutamine are polymerized into a y-linked polymer by an enzyme from Bacillus subtilis ( S 4 ) , a function which is similar to that of the kidney transpeptidase except that the bacterial enzyme does not appear to catalyze hydrolytic reactions. An enzyme from pig kidney, distinct from the hydrolase-transpeptidase mentioned in category (3) catalyzes the transfer of glutamyl units from glutathione (but not glutamine) to certain peptides such as glycylglycine without formation of glutamic acid under any condition ( 3 5 ) . The “7-glutamyl cyclotransferase” found in animal tissues, including liver and brain, might be considered a special member of this group (36).This enzyme effects an intramolecular acyl transfer by converting certain y-glutamyl peptides to the cyclic pyrrolidone carboxylic acid (see Orlowski and Meister, Chapter 6, this volume). Glutamine is not a substrate, and glutathione is acted upon very slowly. A cyclotransferase with somewhat different properties has been obtained from papaya latex (37). L-Glutamine and N-terminal a-glutaminyl peptides lacking substituents on the y-NHz group are cyclized to the corresponding pyrrolidone carboxylic acid derivatives. Several other enzymes which catalyze y-glutamyl transfer reactions 29. M. A. Ramadan and D. M. Greenberg, Anal. Biochem. 6, 144 (1963). 30. K. Soda, K. Uchiyama, and K. Ogata, Agr. Biol. Chem. (Tokyo) 30, 547 (1966). 31. H. J. Gigliotti and B. Levenberg, JBC 329, 2274 (1964). 32. M. Orlowski and A. Meister, JBC 240, 338 (1965). 33. H. Waclsch, “Methods in Enzymology,” Vol. 2, p. 267, 1955. 34. W. J. Williams and C. B. Thornc, JBC 210, 203 (1954). 35. F. H. Leibach and F. Rinkley, A R B 127, 292 (1968). 36. M. Orlowski, P. G. Richman, and A . Mrister, Biochemislry 8, 1048 (1969). 37. M. Messer and M . Ottesen, BBA 92, 409 (1964); Compt. Rend. Tmv. Lob. Cnrlsbcig 35, 1 (1965).
4.
GLUTAMINASES AND 7-GLUTAMYLTRANSFERASES
95
have been described, but insufficient information is available to allow their classification in the above scheme. These would include the glutaminase from Clostridium welchii (16),an anion-activated enzyme derived from the microsomal fraction of rat kidney which hydrolyzes glutamine and glutamyl hydroxamic acid and which is distinct from and a hydrolase from pig kidney which cleaves “glutaminase I” (,%I), glutamyl naphthylamide but will not transfer the glutamyl unit to peptide acceptors (35). Some of the above-mentioned enzymes about which significant enzymological information is availatde are singled out for further description in the following sections.
B. ~GLUTAMYLTRANSFERASE FROM AGARICACEAE Gigliotti and Levenberg (31) have described an enzyme isolated from certain species of mushrooms of the genus Agaricus which is associated with the occurrence of agaritine (y-L-glutamyl-p-hydroxymethyl-phenylhydrazide) and y-L-glutamyl-p-hydroxyanilide. Partial purification (20fold) yielded a preparation capable of hydrolyzing a number of y-acyl derivatives of L-glutamic acid in a narrow region of pH, with optimum about 7. When rates of hydrolysis a t a fixed concentration of substrate (1 mM) were determined, the phenylhydrazide, p-hydroxyphenylhydraaide, p-hydroxyanilide, cyclohexylamide, ethylamide, and benzyl ester were rapidly cleaved, while glutamine, glutamyl hydrazide, and glutamyl 1-naphthylhydrazide were acted upon somewhat more slowly. Glutathione and other y-glutamyl peptides were not substrates. Apparently, a bulky hydrophobic substituent is preferred in contrast to the situation with the E. coli glutaminase. In the presence of hydroxylamine, ammonia, phenylhydrazine, or p-hydroxyaniline, transfer of the glutamyl unit from substrates to these amines is observed. The rate of hydrolysis and transfer to hydroxylamine (at 0 . 2 5 M ) for a given substrate are approximately equal. I n this respect, the behavior of the Agaricus and E. coli enzymes are rather similar. When an acceptor amine containing an aromatic group is present (e.g., phenylhydrazine) , hydrolysis is almost completely suppressed in favor of transfer to the aromatic amine, and in this sense the mushroom enzyme is best considered a transferase. These results are consistent with the view that the enzyme has a hydrophobic site which can be occupied either by the substituent group of the substrate or by the acceptor amine. Water or other small amine acceptor can react with a bound derivative of glutamic acid if this site is not occupied, but a t a slower rate than that which occurs with the hydrophobic amine. The possibility that the enzyme may depend upon sulfhydryl groups
96
STANDISH C. HARTMAN
for activity is indicated by its sensitivity to inhibition by mercuric, cupric, and zinc ions, mercuribenzoate, and iodoacetate.
C. Y-GLUTAMYL TRANSPEPTIDASES FROM KIDNEY The ability of enzyme preparations from various animal tissues to catalyze transfer of the glutamyl unit from glutamine or glutathione to certain a-amino acids and peptides, first observed by Hanes et al. (38),has been examined in several laboratories (32,35,39-41). Enzymes of this type have been studied recently by Orlowski and Meister (in hog kidney) (32)and by Szewczuk and Baranowski (in beef kidney) (41). Results with the hog kidney enzyme will be reviewed here; the beef enzyme is quite similar in many respects, but it is not identical in physical properties. After solubilization from a particulate fraction of hog kidney cortex, the transpeptidase has been obtained in highly purified, but not yet homogeneous, form. The enzyme is active in the alkaline p H region with a maximum at about p H 8.8. Although appreciable magnesium is present in the enzyme preparation and added Mg2+ partially stimulates the catalytic action, it is not certain whether this metal is essential for activity since EDTA exerts an enhancement rather than an inhibition. The transpeptidase catalyzes y-glutamyl transfer from a number of compounds in addition to glutathione and glutamine, including glutamyl p-nitroanilide, glutamyl naphthylamide, y-benzyl glutamate, y-ethyl glutamate, and y-glutamyl peptides. Derivatives of D-glutamic acid are also substrates, although they react a t only about 10% the rate of the L-isomers. Asparagine and homoglutamine are not utilized. When the enzyme acts upon one of the above substrates some glutamic acid is produced in addition to products formed by transfer of the y-glutamyl moiety from one molecule of substrate either to the a-amino group of the product, glutamic acid, or to that of another molecule of substrate, to form a y-linked peptide. Subsequent addition of glutamyl units to the dipeptides can build up oligopeptides of glutamic acid. Eventually, since the reactions are reversible, the thermodynamically favored hydrolytic process overrides the kinetically favored transpeptidation reaction and glutamate ion results as the predominant product. If one of a large number of a-amino acids or peptides is present, it 38. 39. 40. 41.
C. S. Hanes, F. J. R. Hird, and F. A. Isherwood, BJ 51, 25 (1952) P. J. Fodor, A. Miller, and H. Waelsch, JBC 202, 551 (1953). E. G. Ball, J. P. Revel, and 0. Cooper, JBC 221, 895 (1956). A. Szewczuk and T. Baranowski, Biochem. Z. 338, 317 (1963).
4.
GLUTAMINASES AND y-GLUTAMYLTRANSFERASES
97
will serve as acceptor of the glutamyl unit to form the corresponding y-glutamyl peptide. Hydroxylamine will also accept the acyl group. It is evident that the hog kidney transpeptidase exhibits relatively little specificity with respect to substituent groups on the substrate (or acyl acceptor). I n contrast to the transferase from mushrooms, the transpeptidase is particularly reactive with amines containing polar substituents such as amino acids and peptides. Another type of glutamyl transpeptidase (or transferase) is obtainable from hog kidney, as shown by Leibach and Binkley (35). The enzyme is obtained in soluble form by treating renal microsomes with ficin, after which it has been purified 2000-fold to apparent homogeneity. Differences between this enzyme and the one described by Orlowski and Meister are striking, even though a detailed examination of the specificity of the microsomal enzyme has not been reported. The latter system catalyzes glutamyltransfer from either reduced or oxidized glutathione to certain peptide acceptors such as glycylglycine: Glutathione
+ glycylglycine S cysteinylglycine + -pglutamylglycylglycine
(13)
Neither glutamine nor glutamyl naphthylamide are substrates. The specificity requirements for the acceptor are considerably more demanding in that acyl transfer to water (hydrolysis) or to hydroxylamine is not observed under any conditions. The transferase was separated chromatographically from an enzyme capable of hydrolyzing glutamyl naphthylamide which conceivably is related to the previously described t ranspeptidase.
D. GLUTAMINASE FROM Azotobacter agilis Ehrenfeld et al. have described the purification of a glutaminaseglutamyltransferase from this soil bacterium ( l a ) . Although not completely pure, the enzyme was observed to have a sedimentation coefficient of about 4.4-4.8 S. It not only catalyzes hydrolysis of L-glutamine (relative rate, 1) but also that of D-glutamine (0.57), L-asparagine (0.7), Dasparagine (0.24), succinamic acid (0.15), and glutamyl hydroxamic acid. A number of other amino acid amides, as well as glutamyl y-ethylamide and y-ethyl glutamate, are not substrates. The enzyme exhibits a remarkably broad pH optimum, the V,,, for L-glutamine being constant between pH 4.5 and 9. Glutamyl hydroxamic acid is produced by action of the enzyme on substrates in the presence of hydroxylamine. Hydroxylaminolysis and hydrolysis are about equal in rate a t p H 7.2 when the hydroxylamine concentration is 0.5 M. The rate of formation of hydrox-
98
STANDISH C. HARTMAN
amic acid a t fixed total hydroxylamine concentration is not constant with pH, but rather it increases between pH 4.5 and 6.5 in the manner expected if the basic form of hydroxylamine were the reactant. When expressed in terms of the basic form of the amine, the relative rates of transfer to water and hydroxylamine for this enzyme are almost identical to those observed with E . coli glutaminase. Glutamic acid is also a substrate of the Azotobacter enzyme since it reacts readily with hydroxylamine to form the hydroxamic acid, the reverse of which process is the hydrolysis of the latter substance. The equilibrium constant for the formation of the hydroxamic acid from glutamic acid and hydroxylamine has been determined with the aid of this enzyme. I n the absence of glutamine the diazo analogs, DON and azaserine, strongly and irreversibly inhibit the enzyme. Unlike the E . coli enzyme, this one is insensitive to mercuribenzoate. Ethylenediaminetetraacetate is not inhibitory. Evidence is presented that glutamic acid binds to the enzyme in a form that dissociates to free glutamic acid more slowly than it reacts with hydroxylamine. When the enzyme is briefly exposed to 14C-glutamic acid, then hydroxylamine and a large amount of unlabeled glutamic acid are added, the initial molecules of glutamyl hydroxamic acid formed have an excess of radioactivity over that expected from the average specific activity of the glutamic acid in the mixture. The authors suggest that the formation of a covalent glutamyl-enzyme intermediate could account for these results. The alternative possibility advanced in the discussion of the E . coli glutaminase could be offered here as well: the bound form of substrate is not covalently linked to enzyme but is separated kinetically from free substrate by slow conformatianal changes.
IV. Concluding Remarks
That formal similarities occur among the reactions discussed above raises the question of whether the enzymes responsible might be related structurally, mechanistically, and perhaps, evolutionarily. Insofar as the limited information available allows comparison there would seem to be no obvious basis for supposing that a common derivation or mode of action of these enzymes exists. While data on structure are scanty, variability in functional groups is evidenced by the disparate pH-activity profiles and spectra of sensitivity toward inhibitors, for example. AS a first approximation, such criteria set the limits for the kinds of groups which are essential for catalytic action.
4.
GLUTAMINASES AND 7-GLUTAMYLTRANSFERASES
99
The most evident phenomenological differences among these enzymes reside in their abilities to utilize diverse acceptors for the glutamyl moiety transferred by each. Specificities with respect to acceptor are a consequence of the specificities shown toward substrates, both in principle and experimentally. The acceptor is mechanistically equivalent to the 7-substituent group of a substrate since the process in which the C-N bond is formed is microscopically the reverse of the C-N bond cleavage. Those and only those substituent groups which are tolerated by the enzyme in the direction of bond cleavage will be inserted in the “acyl transfer’:. reaction. Thus, for example, an enzyme capable of transferring th y-glutamyl group to hydroxylamine must necessarily utilize the hydr amic acid as a substrate, and vice versa, otherwise the enzyme would bk a one-way catalyst. It may sometimes be difficult to observe transfer .reactions with certain substrates and acceptors which themselves are normal reaction products (e.g., glutamic acid or ammonia). In these cases the difficulty is undoubtedly an experimental one of not being able to achieve significant concentrations of the proper ionic forms of the reactant in the pH range where the enzyme is active. The observation that acyl groups (including those derived from glutamic acid) are transferred to amines, especially hydroxylamine, is often regarded as evidence for the formation of an “activated” intermediate, in analogy to the reactions by which acyl phosphates or acyl thiols may be trapped. However, the view that such an intermediate is a compound of large free energy of hydrolysis is objectionable on the ground that it would seem to require an unnecessarily large energy barrier in the reaction pathway. Any reasonable mechanism for the hydrolysis of amide or hydroxamic acid, whether or not it involves an intermediate activated in this sense, provides a path, in its reverse, for the synthesis of the amide. In discussing possible mechanisms for the reactions catalyzed by E . coli glutaminase in Section I, it was concluded that either a two-step acylation-deacylation pathway or a one-step route, displacement by the ultimate nucleophile, could be accommodated by the results. It may be noted that any single displacement mechanism for a group transfer reaction requires that both incoming and outgoing substituent groups associate with the enzyme a t the same time
i
0
II
x1-c-xp I R
in contrast to the case with a double displacement mechanism in which only one X need be present (the other one is a component of the enzyme).
100
STANDISH C. HABTMAN
At least thii is the case for enzymes which show a selectivity with respect to the substituent or acceptor, a situation indicating that the agent does not react from the solution phase. The single displacement mechanisms, then, require the existence of two distinct and specific sites for recognition and reaction of XIand X,, capable of carrying out the mechanistically symmetrical events of catalysis. It is not too difficult to imagine a hydrolytic reaction occurring in this way, in which one group is H,O (or OH-). However, in the acyltransferase reactions in which water is not a reactant, two often bulky and structurally complex groups would need to be accommodated at once. If the principle of simplicity in nature carries any force, one would be inclined to favor the two-step displacement pathway to describe these reactions. In this event the enzyme would need to possess only one site for interaction with any acyl donor or acceptor. The simplification would not extend to the reaction mechanism however, since the same type of acyl transfer must be catalyced in either case; uiz., transfer to the dissociable acceptor or transfer to an interim carrier which is part of the enzyme.
JOHN C. WRISTON, JR. I. Introduction . . . . 11. Occurrence . . . . 111. Guinea Pig Serum Asparaginase A. Isolation . . . B. Properties . . . IV. EscheTichia coZi Asparaginase A. Isolation . . . B.Pmperties . . . V. Other Asparaginases . . . VI. Physiological Properties . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
101
102 105 105 106 107 107 109 116 117
1. Introduction
L-Asparaginase (L-asparagine amidohydrolase, EC 3.5.1.1.) that catalyzes the hydrolysis of L-asparagine to L-aspartic acid and ammonia is widely distributed. In addition, there is at least one other enzyme system capable of catalyzing the hydrolysis of asparagine. Meister has demonstrated (1,2)that rat liver, for example, contains an asparaginase activity which is a-keto acid dependent, and which actually results from the presence of an w-amidase (a-amidodicarboxylate amidohydrolase, EC 3.5.1.3) that catalyzes the hydrolysis of the a-keto succinamate formed from asparagine by transamination. Rat liver extracts also appear to contain a true L-asparaginase, but one which is phosphate dependent 1. A. Meister, H. A. Sober, 8.V. Tice, and P. E. Fraser, J . BWZ. Chem. 197, 319 (1952). 2. A. Meister, L. Levintow, R. E. Greenfield, and P. A. Abendschein, J . Biol. Chem. 215, 441 (1955).
101
102
JOHN C. WRISTON, JR.
and relatively heat labile, properties which tend to differentiate it from other asparaginases that have been more thoroughly studied. Asparagine deamidation can also be accomplished by o-replacement reactions (S) . Little new information has been reported concerning either the a-keto acid-dependent asparaginase or the phosphate-dependent asparaginase, and this article will focus almost entirely on the so-called true asparaginases.
II. Occurrence
Asparagine hydrolyzing activity is widely distributed [for earlier reviews, see references ( 4 4 1 , but in many of the earlier reports describing the formation of ammonia from added asparagine by cell suspensions or crude cell extracts over a period of hours or even days, it is not possible to ascribe the activity to a true asparaginase. For this reason, a historical survey will be avoided here, and the examples that will be noted are those where there is reasonable assurance that the enzyme being considered is kasparagine amidohydrolase. I n 1953, Kidd reported (7‘) that whole guinea pig serum could bring about the regression of certain transplanted lymphosarcomas in inbred mice. His experiments indicated that the substance responsible for the antilymphoma activity was a protein, and in 1961 Broome (8) presented evidence linking this activity to the presence of the enzyme L-asparaginase in the guinea pig serum. These observations, together with the discovery that an E . wli asparaginase also had antilymphoma activity (9),have been reponsible for a marked increase in interest in asparaginase since 1961. The presence of asparaginase in guinea pig serum was first reported by Clementi (10), who also noted the absence of this enzyme in the sera of a number of other common mammals including the rat, cat, dog, monkey, and human. The list of animal sera from which asparaginase H. Waelsch, Aduan. Enzymol. 13, 237 (1952). J. E. Varner, “The Enzymes,” 2nd ed., Vol. 4, p. 243, 1960. C. A. Zittle, “The Enzymes,” 1st ed., Vol. 1, Part 2, p. 922, 1951. A. Meister, “Biochemistry of the Amino Acids,’’2nd ed., Vol. 2, p. 606, Academic Press, New York, 1965. 7. J. G. Kidd, J . Exptl. Med. 98, 565 and 582 (1953). 8. J. D. Broome, Nature 191, 1114 (1961). 9. L. T. Mashburn and J. C. Wriston, Jr., Arch. Biochem. Biophys. 105,451 (19&1). 10. A. Clementi, Arch. Intern. Physiol. 19, 369 (1922). 3. 4. 5. 6.
5.
L-ASPARAGINASB
103
is absent has subsequently been extended to include the chicken, pig, sheep, cow, horse, and nutria (11-13), although rabbit serum has been reported to contain traces of activity (11).Clementi also reported that asparaginase was present in the liver and kidney of certain birds. The enzyme has also been found in fish liver, but not in the liver of frogs ( 1 4 ) , in guinea pig liver (16-I?),in chicken liver (18), and in the serum of several animals closely related to the guinea pig (12, 19). Serum from all members of the superfamily Cavioidea, to which the guinea pig belongs, contain asparaginase. Agouti serum, in particular, was found to contain several times as many units of activity per milliliter as guinea pig serum, and this fact, coupled with the larger size of the animal, would appear to make it a more practical source of mammalian enzyme than the guinea pig. Members of three other hystricomorph families related to the Cavioidea do not contain serum asparaginase. It has also been found that the serum of newborn guinea pigs contains very little asperaginase (8,11,20) and that the levels do not appear to be affected by strain, sex, or dietary intake of asparagine ( 1 1 ) . Asparaginase is present in the serum of two species of new world monkeys, but not in three old world species ( 2 1 ) . The guinea pig serum enzyme has been purified to apparent homogeneity and is discussed in more detail in a later section. Several asparaginases from microorganisms were described prior to 1961. Asparaginase has been found in Aspergillus niger (22, 23), and is also present in yeasts (24-27). Extracts of Mycobacterium smegmatis, 11. D. B. Tower, E. L. Peters, and W. C. Curtis, J . Bwl. Chem. 238, 983 (1963). 12. N. D. Holmquist, Proc. SOC.Exptl. BWZ. M e d . 113, 444 (1963). 13. M. B. Lee and J. M. Bridges, Nature 217, 758 (1968). 14. G. Steensholt, Acta Physiol. Scand. 8, 342 (1944). 15. H. A. Krebs, BWchem. J . 47, 605 (1950). 16. N. DeGroot and N . Lichtenstein, Biochim. Biophys. Acta 40, 92 (1960). 17. H. M. Suld and P. A. Herbut, J . Biol. Chem. 240, 2234 (1965). 18. T. Ohnuma, F. Bergel, and R. C. Bray, Biochem. J . 103, 238 (1967). 19. L. J. Old, E. A. Boyse, H. A. Campbell, and G . M. Dana. Nature 198, 801 (1963). 20. H. Ainis, H. M. Kurtr, P. I. Kramer, H. E. Weimer, R. M . Ryan, and E. Jameson, Cancer Res. 18, 1309 (1958). 21. R. Arrison, personal communication, cited in J. D. Broome, Trans. N . Y . Acnd. Sci. [21 30, 690 (1968). 22. D. Bach, Compt. Rend. 187, 955 (1928). 23. K. Schmalfuss and K. Mothes, Biochem. Z . 221, 134 (1930). 24. W. Grassman and 0. Mayr, Z . Physiol. Chem. 214, 185 (1933). 25. G. Gorr and J. Wagner, Biochem. Z . 254, 1 (1932). 26. J. D. Broome, J . NatZ. Cancer Znst. 35, 967 (1965). 27. A. K. Abdumalikov and A. Y. Nikolaev, Bwkhimiya 32, 4 (1967).
104
J O H N C. WRISTON, J R .
M . phlei, and several strains of M . tuberculosis (2830)contain a true asparaginase, as do extracts of Bacillus coagulans and Bacillus stearothemnophilus (31).Brucella abortus contains two asparaginases, one specific for L-asparagine and the other for the opposite enantiomorph (3.2). An asparaginase is also present in Pseudomonas fluorescens ( 3 3 ) .Also, Tsuji, in 1957, had reported the presence of asparaginase in extracts of acetone powders of E . coli, Staphylococcus, M . avium, and Aspergillus oryzae (34). Since 1961, several of the previously reported asparaginases have been reexamined for antilymphoma activity, and a number of additional asparaginases have been found. Mashburn and Wriston (9) reported that an L-asparaginase from E . coli B had antilymphoma activity but that the B . coagulans enzyme did not. The discovery of a bacterial source of the enzyme with antilymphoma activity made it possible to prepare large amounts of enzyme and carry out extensive clinical studies, which are still under way. Several purification schemes have been reported, and the E . coli asparaginase is also discussed in detail in a later section. Asparaginases with antilymphoma activity have also been found in extracts o f Serratia marcescens (36-57), Erwinia carotovora (58), and Proteus vulgaris ( 3 6 ) . Escherichia w l i extracts contain a second asparaginase that is devoid of antilymphoma activity (39),and a similarly inactive enzyme has been found in a fungus, Fusarium tricinctum (40). An enzyme from Streptomyces griseus has L-asparaginase activity when assayed in tris-Cl (pH 8.6) but little or no activity in sodium borate (pH 28. W. F. Kirchheimer and C. K . Whittaker, Am. Rev. Tuberc. 70, 920 (1954). 29. Y. S. Halpern and N. Grossowicz, Biochem. J . 65, 716 (1957). 30. H. N. Jayaram, T. Ramakrishnan, and C. S. Vaidyanathan, Arch. Biochem. Biophys. 126, 165 (1968). 31. G. B . Manning and L. L. Campbell, Jr., Can. J . Mimobiol. 3, 1001 (1957). 32. R. A. Altenbern and R. D. Housewright, Arch. Biochem. Biophys. 49, 130 (1954). 33. N. DeGroot and N. Lichtenstein, Biochim. Biophys. Acta 40, 99 (1980). 34. Y. Tsuji, Naika Hokan 4, 222 (1957); CA 53, 10350 (1957). 35. B. Rowley and J. C. Wriston, Jr., Bwchem. Biophys. Res. Comm. 28, 160 (1967). 36. J. W. Boyd, M.S. Thesis, University of Delaware, 1965. 37. R . E. Peterson and A. Ciegler, Appl. Microbiol. 18, 64 (1969).
38. H. E . Wade, R. Elsworth, D. Herbert, J. Keppie, and K . Sargeant, Lancet i, 776 (1968). 39. H. A. Campbell, L. T. Mashburn, E . A. Boyse, and I,. J. Old, Biochemistry 6, 721 (1967). 40. R . W. Scheetz, Ph.D. Thesis, University of Delaware, 1969.
5.
L-ASPABAGINASE
105
8.5) (41). Peterson and Ciegler have recently surveyed 123 species of bacteria for L-asparaginase activity and found the highest yields in an Erwinia aroideae strain (42). It is interesting to note that some of the E . coli strains they examined contain no asparaginase. Roberts et al. (43) have listed several additional asparaginase-containing microorganisms but found no asparaginase activity in several molds or yeast that they examined. An amidase, apparently a single enzyme, that catalyzes the hydrolysis of both asparagine and glutamine and that appears to have only limited antilymphoma activity, has been reported in extracts of Pseudomonas (44-46). Lee and Bridges (13) have confirmed the absence of asparaginase in the serum of a variety of animal species and in 25 human sera but have observed that human and sheep sera, themselves devoid of detectable asparaginase activity, enhanced the activity of guinea pig serum (GPS). Other sera did not show this effect with the GPS enzyme, but all the sera enhanced E . coli asparaginase activity. Further work by these authors (47) and by Ho and Jones (48) indicates that the effect results from a nonspecific stabilization by plasma proteins. The presence of asparaginase has also been reported in certain plant tissues (49, 5 0 ) , but a recent study by Lees et al. ( 5 1 ) , in which they used U-14C-asparagine to provide a sensitive assay system for asparagine conversion to aspartic acid, failed to show any asparaginase activity in extracts of wheat or lupin seedlings. 111. Guinea Pig Serum Asparaginase
A. ISOLATION Several partial purifications of guinea pig serum asparaginase have been reported, beginning with a sevenfold purification by Meister in H. A. Campbell and L. T. Mashburn, Biochemistry 8, 3768 (1969). R. E. Peterson and A. Ciegler, A p p l . Microbiol. 17, 929 (1969). J. Roberts, G. Burson, and J. M. Hill, J. Bacteriol. 95, 2117 (1968). M. E. A. Ramadan, F. El Asmar, and D. M. Greenberg, Arch. Biochem. Biophys. 108, 143 and 150 (1964). 45. F. A. El Asmar, and D. M. Greenberg, Cancer Res. 26, 116 (1966). 46. L. P. Evseev, A. Y. Nikolaev, V. V. Eremenko, and S. R. Mardashev, Biokhimiya 32, 873 (1967). 47. M. B. Lee and J. M. Bridges, personal communication (1969). 48. P. P. K. Ho and L. Jones, Bwchim. Biophys. Acta 177, 172 (1969). 49. C. E. Grover and A. C. Chibnall, Biochem. J. 21, 857 (1927). 41. 42. 43. 44.
106
JOHN C. WRISTON, JR.
1955 (11, 17, 69-55). Purification to apparent homogeneity was reported by Yellin and Wriston in 1966 ( 5 6 ) . Their procedure, described in detail elsewhere ( 5 7 ) , involves salt fractionation with Na2S0,, gel filtration on G-200 Sephadex, chromatography on DEAE-cellulose, followed by chromatography on calcium hydroxylapatite. A 900-fold purification was achieved with an overall recovery of about 10%. Asparaginase accounts for about 0.1% of the total protein of guinea pig serum, and the amount recovered corresponds to less than 1 mg of homogeneous enzyme from 100 ml of GPS, with a specific activity of about 470 I U mg (57a). The enzyme was judged to be homogeneous on the basis of immunoelectrophoresis, analytical ultracentrifugation studies, and polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. The homogeneous enzyme was found (58) to have antilymphoma activity toward the Gardner lymphosarcoma in C3H mice comparable to that of the guinea pig serum itself, thus confirming Broome’s original suggestion.
B. PROPEF~TIES Guinea pig serum asparaginase has a molecular weight of approximately 138,000 (equilibrium sedimentation) and- an s;,~ of 6.55 S ( 5 6 ) . The purified enzyme is stable for at least 6 months at -20”, to repeated freezing and thawing, and to heating at 55” for 10 min (11,56).It is also stable to dialysis in the cold but is labile under conditions which promote surface denaturation. Whole guinea pig serum can be stored for several weeks a t 4” without appreciable loss of asparaginase activity. It has also been reported (15) that a dry powder obtained from whole guinea pig serum by precipitation with two volumes of cold ethanol can be stored in a desiccator for a year or more with no appreciable loss of 50. W. L. Kretovich, Advan. Enzymol. 20, 319 (1958). 51. E. M. Lees, K. J. F. Farnden, and W. H. Elliott, Arch. Biochem. Biophys. 126, 539 (1988). 52. A. Meister, “Methods in Enzymology,” Vol. 2, p. 383, 1955. 53. S. R. Mardashev and V. Shao-Khua, Dokl. Akad. Nauk SSSR 142, 709 (1962). 54. L. T. Mashburn and J. C. Wriston, Jr., Biochem. Biophys. Reg. Commun. 12, 50 (1963). 55. J. D. Broome, J . Exptl. Med. 118, 99 and 121 (1963). 56. T. 0. Yellin and J. C. Wriston, Jr., Biochemitry 5, 1605 (1966). 57. J. C. Wriston, Jr., “Methods in Enzymology,” 1971 (in press). 57a. The international unit (IU) is defined as that amount of enzyme which will catalyze the release of 1 pmole of ammonia per minute under standard assay
conditions. 58. T. 0. Yellin and J. C. Wriston, Jr., Science 151, 998 (1966).
5. L-ASPAEAGINASE
107
activity. The enzyme has the electrophoretic mobility in starch of an a-2-globulin ( 8 ) . The optimal pH range (in 0.1 M sodium borate buffer) is from 7.5 to 8.5 (52),although Tower et al. reported (11) a pH optimum of 9.6 for 100-fold purified enzyme in buffers of lower ionic strength than those used by Meister (r/2 = 0.2 instead of 0.4). The K , value has been reported as 2.2 X lo-’ M (11) and 7.2 X M (18). Broome has also shown (59)that the apparent K , for agouti serum asparaginase is 4.1 X M. The enzyme is inhibited by p-mercuribenzoate and HgCl, (40 and 83% inhibition, respectively, at 0.1 mM) but not by L-glutamic acid or Lglutamine, 10 mM; L-aspartic acid, 20 mM; NH,CI, 50 mM; alanine, oxaloacetate, a-ketoglutarate and pyruvate, 5 mM; FOB,-, 50 mM; SO:-, 5 mM; MgZ+,Ca2+,and MnZ+,5 mM; iodoacetate, fluoride, and cyanide, 1OmM; and N-ethylmaleimide and pyridoxal phosphate, 1 mM (11). Of a large number of amides examined, only L-asparagine (loo%),D-asparagine (3%), L-leucine amide (5.3%), L-phenylalanine amide, (8.2%), and L-tyrosine amide (8.5%) were hydrolyzed (2, 11). L-Glutamine is among those amides not hydrolyzed. The enzyme will not hydrolyze N-acetyl-Lasparagine or N-L-glutaminyl-L-asparagine (11). Guinea pig serum asparaginase also catalyzes hydrolysis of L-p-aspartyl hydroxylamine and synthesis of the hydroxamate from asparagine and hydroxylamine, but these reactions proceed more slowly than the hydrolysis of L-asparagine ( 2 ) . The amino acid composition has been determined (56).Guinea pig serum asparaginase has been used occasionally for the quantitative determination of asparagine (11, 16, 60).
IV. Escherichia coli Asparaginase
A. ISOLATION Tsuji (34) was the first to report the presence of L-asparaginase in
E . coli extracts. In 1964, Mashburn and Wriston (9)described a partial purification of the enzyme from E . coli B, and found that this bacterial asparaginase possessed antilymphoma activity. Purification to apparent homogeneity was reported in 1968 (61). Roberts et al. (43) in that same year also described an extensive purification in high yield of E . coli 59. J. D. Broome, Bn’t. J . Cancer 22, 595 (1968). 60. B. F. Sansom and J. M. Barry, Biochem. J . 68, 487 (1958). 61. H. A. Whelan and J. C . Wriston, Jr., Biochemistly 8, 2386 (1969); Federation Proc. 27, 586 (1968).
108
JOHN C. WRISTON, JR.
L-asparaginase. Several pharmaceutical firms have developed greatly simplified purification schemes making it feasible to produce large amounts of highly purified enzyme for clinical trials (62-65). The steps used in the first purification to homogeneity are shown in Table I [for details, see Wriston (57)l. In the procedure developed by Roberts et al. (43) there is an alcohol fractionation, DEAE-cellulose chromatography, an isoelectric precipitation with alcohol, chromatography on carboxymethyl Sephadex, and a final prep disc electrophoresis step. Ho et al. (6%) obtained crystalline L-asparaginase from E. coli B by a procedure involving essentially ammonium sulfate and ethanol fractionation, and they reported an h’ig of 7.1 for the dry crystalline enzyme. The Bayer group (63-65) have also crystallized E . coli asparaginase recently. I n one case this was done by using 50% aqueous polyethylene glycol (average molecular weight 1500) with resuspended acetone powders of E. coli cells; and in another it was done by a combination of heat denaturation, acetone and 2-methylpentane-2,4-diol fractionation, and Sephadex G-200 gel chromatography. TABLE I PURIFICATION OF E. coli B ASPARAGINASE~
Step
Sample vol. (ml)
Total protein (mg)
Total units
Specific activity (units/mg)
Crude extract MnCls, heat P-150 Bio-Gel D EAE-cellulose Calcium hydroxylapatite Prep disc electrophoresis
140 90-100 8-10 40-50 25 4
12-14 1800 1200 500-800 3-6 1.5-2
3500 2400 2200 1600 800 600
0.2-0.25 1.3 1.8 20-32 150-250 300-400
Stepwise recovery
(%) 65 90 70 50 90
From 20 g of lyophilized cells. Experimental details are given in the text. Recoveries in ultrafiltration and dialysis were essentially quantitative, and these steps are omitted in the table. Overall purification of approximately 2000-fold with 15% recovery. 62. P. P. K. Ho, B. H. Frank, and P. J. Burch, Science 165, 510 (1969); P. P. K. Ho, E. B. Milikin, J. L. Bobbitt, E. L. Grinnan, P. J. Burck, B. H. Frank, L. D. Hoeck, and R. W. Squirrs, J . Bid. Chem. 245, 3708 (1970). 63. K. Bauer, A. Arens, E. Rauenbusch. E. Irion, 0. Wagner. W. Kaufmann, W. Scholtan, and S. Y. Lie, Abslr. 6th. FEBS Meeting, Madrid, 1969 p. 93. Academic Press, New York, 1970. 64. 0. Wagner, K. Bauer, E. Irion, E. Rauenbusch. W. Kaufmann, and A. Awns Angew. Chem. Intern. Ed. 8, 885 (1969). 65. A. Arens, E. Rauenbusch, E. Irion, 0. Wagner, K. Bauer, and W. Kaufrnuiiii. 2.Phy8M1. Chem. 351, 197 (1970).
5.
L-ASPARAGINASE
109
B. PROPERTIES 1. General
The content of asparaginase varies widely in different strains of E . coli (39,4.2, 4.9) and there are certain differences in properties as well. There are two quite different asparaginases in E. coli B cells, designated EC-1 and EC-2 by Campbell et al. (391,which can be separated by DEAEchromatography or by differential heat inactivation. Only EC-2, the relatively heat-stable asparaginase, has antilymphoma activity, and only this enzyme has been purified and studied in detail. The two enzymes differ in several other respects and can be distinguished by taking advantage of marked differences in their pH-activity profiles. A broad pHactivity profile is shown by EC-2 with a maximum a t about 8, while EC-1 shows a rapid decrease in activity below pH 8.4. This has served as the basis for a differential assay a t pH 5 and 8.5 (39).Two asparaginases have also been detected in E. coli K-12 (66) and here a differential assay has been based on the fact that asparaginase 11, the enzyme with antilymphoma activity, has a higher substrate affinity than asparaginase I. Both enzymes are saturated at 10 mM asparagine; but a t 0.1 mM asparagine, asparaginase I1 is almost entirely responsible for the observed hydrolysis. The EC-2 asparaginase of E. coli B also has a higher substrate affinity than EC-1 and presumably corresponds to asparaginase I1 of E. coli K-12. In E. coli K-12, asparaginase I1 appears to be located in the periplasmic space between the bacterial plasma membrane and cell envelope (67). Little information is available as yet on optimal conditions for enzyme production. Roberts et a2. (43) compared several media but did not determine how much of the total activity resulted from the EC-2 asparaginase. Schwartz et al. (66) reported that maximal yields of asparaginase I1 are produced under “highly anaerobic” conditions. I n the most thorough study to date of growth conditions, Bilimoria (68) found that gentle aeration (shake cultures) are most suitable for good cell growth and high enzyme content. The situation with respect to the number of different E. coli asparaginases is complicated in one sense, but clarified in another, by the recent report of the Bayer group (65) that homogeneous crystalline 66. J. H. Schwartz, J. Y. Reeves, and J. D. Broome, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. 56, 1516 (1966). 67. H. Cedar and J. H. Schwarts. J. Bid. Chem. 242, 3753 (1967). 68. M. H. Bilirnoria. Appl. Microbial. 18, 1025 (1969).
U. S.
110
JOHN C. WRISTON,
JR.
asparaginases from two different strains of E . coli, while being apparently identical in a number of ways, differ with respect to isoelectric point and with respect to the half-life in the circulation. Asparaginase A, in the terminology of the Bayer group, isolated from E . coli ATCC 9637, has an isoelectric point of 5.0, while asparaginase B, from E . coli ATCC 11303, has a value of 4.8. This observation, attributed to different proportions of isoenzymes in the two asparaginases, helps to explain certain apparent discrepancies in reports of the properties of asparaginase from different laboratories. The subunit structure of asparaginase is discussed in a later section. 2. Substrate Specificity and Effect of Inhibitors
Escherichia coli B asparaginase consistently shows about 2-4% of the activity toward L-glutamine that it does toward L-asparagine (39,69) and has about 5% as much activity toward D-asparagine ( 4 1 ) . This is in contrast to GPS asparaginase, which has no effect on L-glutamine but does hydrolyze D-asparagine to a limited extent ( 2 ) .Campbell and Mashburn (41) have presented evidence strongly suggesting that the hydrolysis of all three compounds occurs a t the same active site in E . coli asparaginase. Product inhibition occurs with ammonia a t pH 8.5, although not a t pH 7.4 or 5.0, but neither hydrolysis nor inhibition is found with L-aspartic acid, D-aspartic acid, L-glutamic acid, or D-glutamic acid ( 4 1 ) .Escherichia coli asparaginase will not catalyze the cleavage of p-aspartyl glucosylamine compounds and has not been observed to release ammonia from several proteins known to contain asparaginyl residues (70). Escherichia coli B asparaginase has no free sulfhydryl groups and is not sensitive to such reagents as p-mercuribenzoate, N-ethylmaleimide, M (71) 1. It is inhibited specifically by 5and iodoacetic acid [ 1 x diazo-4-oxo-~-norvaline (DONV) (41, 72, 73) as is guinea pig serum asparaginase, but not by the corresponding glutamine analog, DON, which inhibits glutaminase ( 7 4 ) . Handschumacher has shown (72,73) that DONV acts both as an alternate substrate and as an inhibitor. 69. J. H. Kim, E. A . Boyse, L. J. Old, and H . A . Campbell, Biochim. B i o p h y ~ . Acta 158, 476 (1968). 70. L. T. Mashburn, personal communication (1969). 71. H. A . Whelan and J. C. Wriston, Jr., unpublished results (1969). 72. R. E. Handschumacher, C. J. Bates, P. K. Chang, A . T. Andrew. and (;. A . Fischer, Science 161, 62 (1968). 73. R. C. Jackson, D. A. Cooney, and R. E. Handschumacher, Fedemtion P w c . . 28, 601 (1969); R. C. Jackson and R. E. Handschumacher, Biochemistry 9, 3585 (1970). 74. B. Levenberg, I . Melnick. and J. M. Buchanan,
J. Biol. Chem. 225,
163 (1957).
5.
L-ASPARAGINASE
111
In experiments with a relatively high ratio of asparaginase to substrate, DONV is catalytically decomposed, with the evolution of nitrogen and the formation of 5-hydroxy-4-keto-~-norvaline. This reaction can be blocked by L-asparagine but not by L-glutamine. I n experiments with saturating amounts of DONV, however, a slower, irreversible reaction also occurs involving the binding of the analog to the enzyme. Covalent binding has been demonstrated by using 5-14C-DONV, and since the modified enzyme is no longer active toward asparagine, binding may well have occurred at the active site of asparaginase. The hydrolysis of asparagine is strongly inhibited by dimethylsulfoxide (DMSO) in concentrations higher than 5 M , but activity can be regained by rapid dilution. Catalytic decomposition of DONV is also inhibited in 5 M DMSO, but covalent binding appears to proceed at an undiminished rate. The D-isomer of DONV is inactive both as substrate and inactivator of the enzyme. Asparaginase also catalyzes the slow hydrolysis of another asparagine analog, P-cyanoalanine, to L-aspartic acid, and since pcyanoalanine can competitively inhibit the decomposition of DONV it would appear that the nitrilase activity occurs at the same active site. 3. Amino Acid Composition
The amino acid compositions of several E. coli asparaginase preparations are presented in Table 11. The first such report (61) assumed a subunit molecular weight of approximately 22,000, based partly on the apparent molecular weight of subunits in dissociating solvents, and partly on the necessity of achieving integral values for the number of residues of certain amino acids such as cystine, present to only a limited extent in asparaginase. The amino acid composition data in Table 11, however, are presented as residues per subunit of molecular weight of approximately 33,000 because of the growing body of evidence indicating that there are 4 subunits, not 6, per mole of enzyme. Four subunits a t 33,000 each are as -compatible with the generally agreed upon monomer molecular weight of about 130,000 as are 6 a t 22,000. The evidence for the $-subunit model is discussed in a later section. I t may be seen from Table I1 that there is good agreement in general between the reports from the various laboratories. It is worth noting, as Arens et al. (65) have done, that about 50% of the molecule is composed of only five amino acids: aspartic acid, threonine, alanine, valine, and glycine. Whether the differences that are reported result from experimental variation in the analyses, real differences between strains, or different proportions of isoenzymes in the enzymes examined remains to be seen. As mentioned in another section, the Bayer group (65) found
112
J O H N C. WRISTON, J R .
TABLE I1 AMINO ACID COMPOSIT~ON OF E . coli ASPARAGINASES~ AmLiiio acid
Squibb [Ref. (GI)]
ASP Thr Ser Glu Pro GlY Ala Val CYS Met Ile Leu TYr Phe LYS His -4% T rP NH,
45 30 15 20 11 27 29 30 2 6 11 22 10 8 20 3 S 1 -
50 31 13 19 11 29 34 33 1 3 12 23 10 8 22 3 S 1 50
46 30 15 19 12 26 30 31 2 5 12 21 10 S 20 3 7 2 27
29s
311
299
Total residues a
Lilly [Ref. (SO)]
Bayer [Ref. (SS)]
As residues, per 33,000 molecular-weight subunit.
no differences in amino acid composition between their asparaginases A and B. One explanation that has been offered for the fact that the Bayer asparaginases A and B differ with respect to isoelectric point without showing any differences in amino acid composition is that there are differences in the number of amide groups in the two enzymes. Arens et al. (65) have reported an experimental value of approximately 27 moles of ammonia per 33,000 molecular weight subunit for asparaginase A but have not reported the corresponding figure for asparaginase B. This is in good agreement with a value obtained by Greenquist and Wriston (75) for the amide content of asparaginase from E. coli B by the carboxyl modification method of Hoare and Koshland (76). It is difficult to draw an accurate comparison with GPS asparaginase, the only other asparaginase whose amino acid composition has been 75. A. C. Greenquist and J. C. Wriston, Jr., Federation Proc. 29, 882 (1970). 76. D. G. Hoare and D. E. Koshland, Jr., J . Biol. Chem. 242, 2447 (1967).
5.
L-ASPARAGINASE
113
reported, because its molecular weight appears to be a little higher than the E. coli enzyme and because there is as yet no evidence on subunit structure. On the assumption that the 138,000 molecular weight GPS asparaginase molecule consists of 4 subunits of about 35,000 molecular weight each, however, there appear to be inajor differences in composition between the two enzymes. The GPS enzyme has only about half as much aspartic acid, for example, but twice as much proline, and it is also strikingly low in tyrosine. 4. Structure
Analytical ultracentrifugation at 0.1% enzyme concentration in 0.2 M potassium phosphate and 1% sucrose at pH 7.25 gave an apparent molecular weight of approximately 139,000. I n a slightly different solvent system, 0.02 M sodium phosphate and 0.2 M NaCl at pH 6.85, a value of 125,000 was obtained (61, 77). At 1% asparaginase, however, a value about twice as high was obtained, and a t low protein concentrations (0.02%) the apparent molecular weight was 64,000. Frank and Veros (78) also obtained a molecular weight value of 130,000 by sedimentation equilibrium, but they did not confirm the apparent dissociation upon simple dilution seen by Kirschbaum et al. (77). The Bayer group (65) obtained a value of 127,000 for the molecular weight of the monomer. They also note a second species with a molecular weight of about 240,000 in higher protein concentrations and observed partial dissociation in aqueous solution by dilution to below 0.1%. Evidence for the existence of subunits has also been obtained by dedetermining the Jdimeritation coefficiciits i n several solvent systems (77). The s , O , , ~ value at 10 mg/ml is 8 . 6 s (molecular weight 255,000). At a concentration of 1 mg/ml, however, a second species of sedimenting material appears with an s&,, value of 5 . 6 s (molecular weight 125,000). When the enzyme concentration is lowered to about 0.4 mg/ml, only a trace of the 8 . 6 s peak remains, and a third species appears with an s,",,, value of 4.0s (molecular weight of 65,000). Increasing the NaCl concentration from 0.1 M to 3 M with protein concentrations in the ra!igc of 5-10 mg/ml also causes similar changes in sedimentation coefficients, and although the Sedimentation coefficient of E. coli asparaginase remains constant at 8.6 S from pH 4 to 10.6, below pH 4 the 77. J . Kirschbaum. J. C. Wriston, Jr.. and 0. T. Ratych, Bzochim. Biophys. Actn 194, 161 (1969). 78. B. H. Frank and A. J . Veros, Federntion Proc. 28, 728 (1969); B. H. Frank, A . H. Pekar. A. J. Veros. :inti P. P. K. Ho. J. Biol. Chem. 245, 3716 (1970).
114
JOHN C. WRISTON, JR.
enzyme again begins to dissociate. I n all these cases, only the 8.6s form of asparaginase is observed several hours later. Rich e t al. (79) have carried out a temperature jump relaxation study of E . coli asparaginase and reported that the finding of multiple relaxation times is qualitatively consistent with the suggested subunit structure. The apparent molecular weight of asparaginase in 8 M urea, 5 ill guanidinium chloride, or 9 M formamide was first reported as being 19,000-24,OOO, with an s , ~ ,of~ 1.5 to 1.8 S (77), demonstrating the presence of subunits. Arens et al. (65) and Frank and Veros (78) have confirmed the value of the sedimentation coefficient of the subunits obtainctl in 8 M urea, but the latter authors reported an apparent molecular weight of approximately 32,500 instead of 19,000-24,000, and their value is almost certainly the correct one. Asparaginase preparations thought to be homogeneous or nearly so usually show one or more faint bands in addition to the principal one when subjected to disc electrophoresis. Gel slicing experiments show asparaginase activity in both the major and minor peaks in such experiments, and it appears that the minor peaks result from aggregates of the 130,000 molecular weight monomer species. Ho and Milikin (80) have shown that the multiple forms seen on disc electrophoresis represent a size isomer family of proteins by plotting the log of protein mobility vs. acrylamide gel concentration. Size isomeric proteins give a family of nonparallel lines extrapolating to a common point in the vicinity of 2% gel concentration, whereas charge isomers would give a family of parallel lines (81). The former kind of plot was obtained with the crystalline Lilly E . coli asparaginase. Whelan and Wriston (61) reported a value of 4.85 for the isoelectric point of their preparation of E . coli B, and a value of 4.95 was reported by Campbell and Mashburn (41). Roberts et al. (43) found a completely different value of 4.35. Arens et al. (65) noted that the electrophoretic mobilities of asparaginases A and B (from E. coli strains ATCC 9637 and 11303) were different, the isolectric points being 5.0 and 4.8 for A and B, respectively. They noted in addition, however, that the single proteill band obtained in these cellulose acetate electrophoresis experiments was asymmetric when examined in a densitometer. When they carried out prolonged electrophoresis, the apparently single band separated into several equally spaced bands in each case. The principal zones of the asparaginases were labelcd A, and B,, with the remaining bands being numbered consecutively in order of increasing electronegativity. A r m 79. L. D. Rich, E. M. Eyring, and J. Roberts, personal communication (1969). 80. P. P. K. Ho :ind E. 13. Milikin. B i t ~ l i i mR. i o p k y s . Acln 206, 196 (1970). 81. J. L. Hedrick and A. Smith, Arch. Biochem. Biophys. 126, 155 (1968).
5.
L-ASPARAGINASE
115
et al. showed that the zones A, and B, carry the same net charge by performing electrophoresis with a mixture of asparaginases A and B. However, if the mixture was incubated briefly in the presence of 6 M urea and then subjected t o electrophoresis, a completely different pattern was obtained with a Gaussian distribution of isoenzymes. Both asparaginases A and B have the same specific activity, the same broad pH-activity profile with a maximum a t pH 7.2, the same tendency to hydrolyze L-glutamine, and the same apparent amino acid composition. They have the same apparent molecular weight, and the N-terminal amino acid sequences of asparaginases A and B are identical for the first 14 residues. Aside from the differences i n electrophoretic mobility, the only other difference yet established is the longer half-life time of asparaginase B, the more acidic of the two enzymes. Arens et al. (65) have concluded that both enzyme preparations consist of a series of isoenzymes with different isoelectric points though with the same specific activities, with asparaginase B containing more of the acidic isoenzymes than asparaginase A. Although not yet established, it would appear reasonable to assume that other E . coli asparaginases will be constructed on the same principle. It was first suggested tentatively (61) that there were 6 subunits in asparaginase from E . coli B, primarily because of the apparent molecular weight values (19,00&24,000) of the species obtained in 8 M urea or 5 M guanidine. However, it is now becoming reasonably certain, as a result of work from several laboratories, that there are in fact 4 subunits per mole of asparaginase. The preliminary results obtained by Greenquist and Wriston (75) (working with E . coli B asparaginase provided by Squibb) provide support for the 4-subunit model and also suggest that the subunits are identical; but one cannot, of course, have isoenzymes unless there are a t least two kinds of subunits. If the finding of isoeiizymes by Arens et al. (65) in asparaginases A and B proves to be characteristic of all the E . coli asparaginases, only further work will be able to resolve the question of the apparent similarity of the E . coli B subunits. The structure work of the Delaware group (75) may be summarized as follows. Treatment with Sanger’s reagent yields only DNP-Leu, approximately 4 moles per mole of enzyme. Tyrosine is the only free aniino acid liberated in significant quantity upon hydrazinolysis, to the extent of 3.3 moles per mole of enzyme. In studies with carboxypeptidase A , Tyr is released very rapidly from S-aminoethylated enzyme (approximately 4 moles per unit of enzyme) followed by Gln, Ile, Phe, and Asn. The order of these 4 aniino acids is not yet established unequivocally, but there are approximately 4 moles of each per mole of asparaginase. Finally, fingerprints of tryptic digests of S-aminoethylated asparaginase
116
JOHN C. WRISTON, J R .
show 32-36 ninhydrin-positive spots, 10 of which are also Sakaguchi positive. On the basis of 20 Lys, 8 Arg, and 2 Cys residues per minimum molecular weight unit of about 33,000, these results are about what would be expected if the subunits were identical. It is true, however, that there appear to be a few more pepticle spots on the fingerprint map than would theoretically be formed, allowing for the possibility of a small number of differences between the subunits. Arens et a2. (65) also reported finding only N-terminal Leu in both asparaginases A and B. In addition, using the Edman procedure, they have established the sequence of the first 14 amino acids from the Nterminal end (shown below) still without encountering a difference between the two H-Leu~Pro~Asn~Ile.Thr~Ile~Leu~Ala~Thr~Gly. (Gly.Val.Ile.Ala)1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11 1 2 1 3 1 4
asparaginases, or without finding any position that appears to be occupied by more than one amino acid, as might he the case with subunits of different structure. Wagner et al. (82) have used nitrous acid to prepare a partially deaminated asparaginase in which the a-amino group of the N-terminal Leu and one of the c-amino groups of Lys are removed. This modified asparaginase can be crystallized and retain full activity. It is more acidic than the native enzyme and has a longer half-life time.
V. Other Asparaginares
The propertieb of several other asparaginases are coniparcd with those of the better known GPS and E . coli cnzymes in Table 111. Three of these enzymes (from Sermtia mnrcesceiis, Erwinin cnrotovorn, and Erwinia aroideae) have antilymphoma activity, while the labt two ~~1~ do not. Thc Ser(from Bacillus coagulans and F i ~ t l i . 1 tricinctzm) ratia enzyme has bceii purified extensively [ apl)roxiinntcly 600-foltl (35)] but not to homogeneity. Hcinemaiin and Howard (85) have recently studied fermentation conditions for thc production of thc Serratia enzyme. The Eminin ctrrotovora asparagin:i>e has I)eeii crystallized by the Portori group (38,84) and has becn found to have an isoelectric point that is strikingly higher than those of the other known 82. 0. W:igncr, E. Irion. A . ;\rcsns. nntl K. B:iric~.Hioclietn. Hiripliya. 11'c.s. C o n t ~ t r / r . 37, 383 (1969). 83. 13. Heincmann and A . J. H o ~ w r d A , / ~ p lMicrobial. . 18, 550 (106'3). 84. A. C. T. North. H. E. Wxlc. and K . A . Cnmmack. Nolitre 224, 59.4 (I%!)).
5.
L-ASPARAGINASE
117
asparaginases (85). Extracts of Erwinia carotovora also have specific enzymic activities several times higher than either E . coli or Serratia extracts, and the specific activity of the crystalline enzyme appears to be about twice as high as that of E . coli asparaginase (700 IU/mg as compared to 280-400 IU/mg). Partial purification of an asparaginase from Erwinia aroideae (37) has also been described. No reports of clinical trials with any of these three enzymes have yet appeared. The asparaginase from Bacillus coagulnns, first described by Manning and Campbell (311 , has been purified about 300-fold but not to homogeneity (86). It does not have antilymphoma activity and differs from those asparaginases that do in sever:il ways. Its pH optimum is a good deal higher, for example; it has a lower molecular weight, and is very rapidly removed from the circulation of thc mouse, in which respect it resembles yeast aaparaginase. I t is also rapidly and irreversibly denatured by 8 M urea and is inhibited (reversibly) by p-mercuribenzoate ((38% inhibition at 1 X lO-'iM). The enzyme appears to bear a closer resemblance to one of the M . tuberculosis asparaginases described by Jayaram et al. (SO) than it does to any of the asparaginases possessing antilymphoma activity. I t has proved difficult to purify because of the small amounts present in cell extracts. The asparaginase from the mold Fusariuuz tricinctum, also without ailtilymphoma activity, has been purified to apparent homogeneity, although its amino acid composition has not yet been established (40). It is perhaps worth noting that it has been found to contain both galactosamine and glucosamine. VI. Physiological Properties
The mechanism by which L-asparaginase exerts an antitumor activity is not yet clear. The cells of susceptible tumors require asparagine, while normal cells and the cells of resistant tumors appear to be independent of an external source of this amino acid (18, 39, 56, 87-90). Scveral groups of workers have established a correlation between S5. 1.. T. M : i s I i l ~ i i ~:~i nnc I I.. M. 1,:incIin. i,c "licvvnt Rrsults in C:inc.rr Rrsenrc,li" (;riintlin:inn ; i n ( l H . I;. Orttgrn. rcls.). Vol. 33. 1). 48. Sliringcr-Vrrlag. Hcilin :ind Scs\v Toil;. 1070. 86. A . 8. I,nw, PIi.L). l'lit&. TJnivc,rsityof L)rl:iwiiic~. 1969. S7. 1'. A . Boysc, I,. J . Old, H. -4. C:iniph~ll,and I,. T. M:isliburn. J . E x p t l . A l e ( / . 125, 17 (1967). 88. I,. J. Old. E. A . lloysr. H . A . C~inilibrll. It. S.Ikodey, J . Fidler, and J. D. Ti~llc~i. ('(ltirer 20, 1066 (1967). 59. LV. C. Doloivy. D. Henson. J. Cornet. and H . Sellin, Cn/rcer 19, 1813 (1966). 90. R. A . Keriman and T. A . McCoy. Sczenre 124, 114 (1956). (11;.
118
JOHN C. WRISTON, JR.
TABLE I11
Property Molecular wt
Guinea pig serum [Ref. (6611
E. coli B (Squibb) [Ref. (6l)l
138,O0Oa 133, OOob
125,000139, OOW 106, OOob
Nessler GLDHd pH stat Isoelectric point
7 . 2 X 1W6 3.6-4.5e
1.25 X 1 W 5.25 X 6 . 0 X 1W6 4.85,; 4.979
pH optimum
7.5-8.5
No
8 (broad maximum) 4%
+
+
Kill
Hydrolyzes glutamine Antitumor activity Urea denaturation Half-life time
?
11-19 hrh
E. coli B (Lilly) [Ref. (6.211
E. coli (Bayer) [Ref. (66)]
130,000”
127, OOW 120, ooob
-
-
5.39, 5.5n
1%
Bayer A, 5 .Of Bayer B, 4.81 Bayer A, 5 . 3 , 5.59 Bayer X, 4.639 7 . 2 (broad maximum) 34%
+
+
-
Iteversi ble
Reversible
Reversible
4 . 0 hri
2 . 9 hr‘
Bayer A, 2 . 8 hr; Bayer X, 7 . 3 hri
Analytical ultracentrifuge. Gel filtration. c Sucrose density gradient. d Coupled assay with glutamic dehydrogenase, E. D. Mooz and J. C. Wriston, unpublished data (1970).
resistance to asparaginase and the presence of the asparagine synthetase, on the one hand, and asparaginase sensitivity and an absence of the capacity to synthesize asparagine, on the other. The low levels of asparagine synthetase in several normal tissues are puzzling in this connection, however (91-98). 91. 92. 93. 94.
J. D. Uroonie, J . E z p t l . M e d . 127, 1036 (1968). J. D. Broome and J. H. Schwartz, Biochim. Biophys. Acta 138, 637 (1967). M. K.Piitterson and G. Orr, Biochem. Biophys. Res. Cornmiin. 26, 228 (1967). M. D. Prager and N. Bachynsky. Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 31, 43
(196s).
95. M. D. Prager and N. Bachynsky, Arch. Biochem. Biophys. 127, 645 (1968). 96. 13. Horowitz, B. K. Madras, A. Meister, L. J. Old. E. A. Boyse, and E. Stockert, Scieltce 160, 533 (1968). 97. M. D. Prager, P. C. Peters, J. 0. Jones, and I. Derr, Notitre 221, 1064 (1969).
5.
119
L-ASPARAGINASE
PROPERTIES OF SEVERAL ASPARAGINASES
E. coli (Kyowa Hakko)
E. E. S . marcescens carolovora aroidcae [Ref. (%)I [Ref. (S8,84)] [Ref. (4.213
141 ,OOOa
150,OOOE
-
1 x 10-4 1 . 2 x 10-6
-
7.2 X 4.7
5.029
8.0 1
5.11 5.85,
6.9 (broad maximum) 4%
+
+
Reversible
lteversi ble
4 . 2 hr'
?
-
128,000145,000 3
x
10-3
B . coagutans F. lricinctum [Ref. (86)j [Ref. (40,] 85,OOOE
4.7 x 10-8
5.2 x 10-4 4 . 2 x 10-4 5.181
8.79,8.9"
-
-
7.5
8.5-9.5
7.5-8.7
2
No
No
No
No
15%'
-
160,000171 ,OO@
+
+
2
2
Irreversible
Reversible
4.1 hr'
>
<30 min
Very short
a-2-Globulin behavior. Cellulose acetate strip electrophoresis. 0 Isoelectric focusing, Mashburn and Landin (86). Broome (26). ' Mashburn and Landin (86). J
Protein synthesis is the only known major role for asparagine in mammalian systems. Both Sobin and Kidd (99) and Broome (91) have shown that the capacity of asparagine-dependent tumors to synthesize protein is impaired in the absence of this amino acid. Nevertheless, the question is not yet resolved as to whether the dramatic effect of asparaginase on leukemic cells can bc ascribed solely to interference with this process or whether other metabolic functions are affected indirectly. Ryan and Sornson (100)have shown recently that the administration of asparaginase depressed the level of tumor glycine specifically in 98. J. D.Broome, Trans. N . Y . Acad. Sci. [21 30, 690 (1968). 99. L. H.Sobin and J. G . Kidd, Proc. SOC.Ezpll. Bid. M e d . 119, 325 (1965). 100. W.L. Ryan and H. L. Sornson, Science 167, 1512 (1970).
120
J O H N C. WRISTON, J R .
mice, and they suggested that the loss of cellular glycine may be more important than loss of asparaginc because of the rcquiremeiit for glycine in purine synthesis. A decrcase in glycine in animals treated with asparaginase might arise if tlic tumor synthesizes it from glyoxylic acid and asparagine, a route to glycinc which has been sho~vnI)y RIcister to occur in liver (1). Several factors arc involved in thc widc variation in tumor inhibitory activity of asparaginases from different sources (98). One obvious possibility is the rate of clearance of tlic enzyme from the circulation of the host animal, a i d Broonie (26) was tlie first to obtain cvidence iniplicating half-life as a factor iii antitumor effectiveness. Guinea pig serum asparaginasc, for example, has a half-life time of 11-19 hr, while a partially purified yeast asparaginase preparation without antilyniphoma activity is almost completely cleared within 30 min. Differences in half-life alonc cannot explain the differences in antitumor activity in all cases, however; and the question still remains as to what structural features are responsible for rapid or slow clearance. Mashburn and Landin (85) have suggested that differences i n half-life time may be related to the isoclectric point of the enzyme, and evidence also exists to hupport the itlen that t l i o tumor inliibitory activity of sonic asparaginases is related to their K,,, values (59, 6 7 ) . An additional factor has recently been shown to affect the clearance time of the E . coli asparaginase and its pattern of tumor inliibitory activity. Mashburn et al. (101) and Boyse et al. (873 observed that E. coli asparaginase was far less effective than the GPS enzyme when atlministered a t the same time that mice were inoculated with tumor cells but was more effective than the GPS enzyme against established tumors. An explanation for this apparently paradoxical finding was provided by the work of Riley et al. (102) and of Notkins and Scheele (103),who had shown earlier that a “lactic dehydrogenase elevating virus” ( L D H virus) is carried by 6C3HED lymphosarcoma cells and leads to a decrease in the rate a t which certain enzymes are removed from the blood. The virus does not affect the half-life of all enzymes (I&), but it has been shown (41, 59, 105) that the L D H virus does have a pronounced 101. I,. T.Mashburn, E. A. Boyse, H. A . Campbell, and L. J. Old. I’roc. Soc. E x p l l . Biol. M e t / . 124, 568 (1967). 102. V. Rilry. J. L. Lovelcss, M . A . Fitzmuwice. and W. M . Siler, Lije Sci. 4, 487, 1965; V. Riley, Methods Cancer Res. 4, 493 (1968). 103. A. L. Notkins and C. Srheele, J. Nntl. Cnncer Inst. 33, 741 (1964). 104. B. W. J. Mahv. K . E. K . Bowsrn, and C. W. Pam, J . E z p t / . M e d . 125, 277 (1967). 105. V . Riley, Nulure 220, 1245 (1968).
5.
L-ASPARAGINASE
121
effect on the half-life time of E . coli asparaginase, increasing it in one set of experiments, for example, from the control value of 2.6 hr in normal mice to 19.7 hr (59). The status of the extensive clinical trials of L-asparaginase against a number of forms of cancer, especially acute lymphatic leukemia, has been thoroughly treated in several recent reviews (106-109) and will not be dealt with here.
106. R. H. Adumson and S. Fabro, Crrncer Chemotherapy R e p . 52, 617 (1968). 107. R. E. Handschumacher, Ann. R e v . M e d . 21, 433 (1970) ; Ann. R e v . Pharmacol. 10, 421 (1970). 108. P. Laboureur, Pathol. Biol. Semaiiie H o p . 17, 885 (1969). 109. H. Marquardt, ArzneimitteZ-Forsch. 18, 1380 (1968).
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Enzymology of Pyrrolidone Carboxvlic Acid MARIAN ORLOWSKI
ALTON MEISTER
I. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11. Detection and Determination of Pyrrolidone Carboxylic Acid . 111. Natural Occurrence of Pyrrolidone Carboxylic Acid . . . . IV. Nonenzymic Formation of Pyrrolidone Carboxylic Acid from Glutamic Acid, Glutamine, and Other Compounds . . . . V. Enzymic Formation of Pyrrolidone Carboxylic Acid from Glutamic Acid . . . . . . . . . . , . A. D-Glutamic Acid Cyclotransferase . . . . . . B. Glutamine Syntbetase and y-Glutamylcysteine Synthetase C. L-Glutamic Acid Cyclotransferase (L-Glutamic Acid . . . . . . . . . . . Dehydrase) D. Conversion of L-Glutamate to Pyrrolidone Carboxylate by Rat Liver Nuclear Preparations . . . . . . VI. Enzymic Formation of Pyrrolidone Carboxylic Acid from Glutamine and Glutaminyl Peptides . . . . . . A. L-Glutamine Cyclotransferase . . . . . . . B. y-Glutamyl Transpeptidase and . . . . . . . y-Glutamyl Cyclotransferase VII. Enzymic Formation of Pyrrolidone Carboxylic Acid from y-Glutamyl Amino Acids . . . . . . . . A. y-L-Glutamyl Cyclotransferase (y-Glutamyl Lactamase) . VIII. Enzymic Formation of Derivatives of Pyrrolidone Carboxylic Acid . . . . . . . . . . . . IX. Pyrrolidone Carboxylyl Peptidase . . . . . . . . X. Pyrrolidone Carboxylate Metabolism . . . . . . .
123
124 125 127 130 133 133 136 138 138 139 139 141 142 142 146 147 149
124
M. ORLOWSKI AND A. MEISTER
1. Introduction
Haitinger ( I ) , who seems to have been the first to describe pyrrolidone carboxylic acid (2-pyrrolidone-5-carboxylic acid ; pyroglutamic acid) , reported in 1882 that when he heated glutamic acid a t 180-190" it was converted to a new compound which differed from glutamic acid in having lost a molecule of water; Haitinger named this compound pyroglutamic acid. A decade later, Menozzi and Appiani ( 2 , 5 ) reported similar but more detailed studies and gave the correct structure. Thus, pyrrolidone carboxylic acid has been known for about 90 years as a cyclic compound derived from glutamic acid. It has been found in the free state in many plark and animal tissues and also in peptide linkage as the N-terminal group of a number of peptides and proteins. Its role in metabolism is as yet undefined, and it is not yet certain in a number of instances whether its presence in proteins and peptides can be ascribed to nonenzymic modification of an N-terminal glutamine or glutamate residue during isolation or whether it is present as such in the native molecule. Pyrrolidone carboxylic acid was reported as a product of glutathione metabolism in kidney extracts in 1942 ( 4 ) ; however, the first clearly defined enzymic reaction in which pyrrolidone carboxylic acid is a product was described as recently as 1956 by Connell and Hanes ( 5 ) . These workers described an enzymic activity (y-glutamyl lactamase ; 7-glutamyl cyclotransferase) in liver that catalyzes the conversion of 7-glutamyl amino acids to pyrrolidone carboxylic acid and the corresponding amino acid. Subsequently, the formation of L- and D-pyrrolidone carboxylic acid from the corresponding isomers of glutamic acid was found to be catalyzed by glutamine synthetase in the absence of ammonia (6, 7 ) . Other enzymes that catalyze pyrrolidone carboxylate formation include (1) an activity found in the kidney and liver of a number of animals which catalyzes the conversion of D-glutamate to Dpyrrolidone carboxylate (8),(2)a bacterial enzyme that forms L-pyrrolidone carboxylate from L-glutamate ( 9 ) , and (3) an enzyme found in 1. L. Haitinger, Monatsh. Chem. 3, 228 (1882). 2. A. Menozzi and G. Appiani, Gazz. Chim. Ital. 22, 14 (1892). 3. A. Menozzi and G. Appiani, Gazz. Chim. Ital. 24, 370 (1894). 4. G.E.Woodward and F. E. Reinhart. JBC 145, 471 (1942). 5. G.E. Connell and C. S. Hanes, Nature 177, 377 (1956). 6. P. R. Krishnaswamy, V. Pamiljans, and A. Meister, JBC 235, PC39, (1960). 7. P.R. Krishnaswamy, V. Pamiljans, and A. Meister, JBC 237, 2932 (1962). 8. A. Meister and M . W. Bukenberger, Nature 194, 557 (1962). 9. S. Akita, K. Tanaka, and S. Kinoshita, BBRC 1, 179 (1959).
6.
ENZYMOLOGY OF PYRRQLIDONE CARBOXYLIC ACID
125
papaya latex that forms pyrrolidone carboxylate from free glutamine and glutaminyl peptides (10).The formation of pyrrolidone carboxylate from glutathione in kidney extracts ( 4 ) may now be ascribed to the cornbined action of two enzymes: ( 1 ) y-glutamyl transpeptidase and (2) y-glutamyl cyclotransferase (11-13). Preparations and extracts of nuclei have been reported to catalyze the conversion of L-glutamate to L-pyrrolidone carboxylate, and it appears that this reaction is linked to an energyyielding oxidation reaction (14-16). I n this chapter the enzymic reactions mentioned above will be reviewed. I n addition, consideration will be given to the detection, determination, and natural occurrence of pyrrolidone carboxylic acid, the noneneymic formation of pyrrolidone carboxylic acid, and to other information now available about the metabolism of this compound.
II. Detection and Determination of Pyrrolidone Carboxylic Acid
Ellfolk and Synge (17) have reviewed methods that have been used for the identification and isolation of pyrrolidone carboxylic acid. A number of workers have used extraction with ethyl acetate, chloroform, methanol, or ethanol. A typical procedure is extraction of an aqueous solution (pH 2.4-2.6) with ethyl acetate (4, 18-22) ; after removal of the solvent, the extracted pyrrolidone carboxylic acid is hydrolyzed with hydrochloric acid and quantitatively determined as glutamic acid. This method suffers from the disadvantage that other conjugated forms of glutamic acid and indeed other conjugated amino acids may be extracted into the solvent (17); furthermore, pyrrolidone carboxylic acid may be formed from glutamine during extraction ( 2 1 , 23). The separation of pyrrolidone carboxylic acid from other organic 10. M. Messer, Nature 197, 1299 (1963). 11. E. E. Cliffe and S. G. Waley, BJ 69, 649 (1958). 12. E. E. Cliffe and S. G. Waley, BJ 79, 118 (1961). 13. M. Orlowski, P. G. Richman, and A. Meister, Biochemistry 8, 1048 (1969). 14. T. Niwaguchi, N. Motohashi, and H. J. Strecker, Biochem. 2. 342, 469 (1965). 15. T. Niwaguchi, N. Motohashi, and H. J. Strecker, BBA 82, 635 (1964). 16. T. Niwaguchi and H. J. Strecker, BBRC 16, 535 (1964). 17. N. Ellfolk and R. L. M. Synge, BJ 59, 523 (1955). 18. H. Wilson and R. K. Cannan, JBC 119, 309 (1937). 19. H. G. Bray, S. P. James, I. M. Raffan, and W. V. Thorpe, BP 44, 625 (1949). 20. G. W. Pucher and H. B. Vickery, I n d . Eng. Chem., Anal. Ed. 12, 27 (1940). 21. F. Leuthardt, 2. Physiol. Chem . 265, 1 (1940). 22. P. J. Fodor, A. Miller, and H. Waelsch, JBC 202, 551 (1953). 23. S. Ratner, JBC 152, 559 (1944).
126
M. ORLOWSKI AND A. MEISTER
acids (including glutamic acid) can be achieved by paper chromatography in a variety of solvent mixtures (5-7, 64-27). High voltage paper electrophoresis has also been used for the separation of pyrrolidone carboxylic acid from amino acids (6, 7 , 28, 2 9 ) . The use of “C-labeled substrates (e.g., glutamate, glutamine, y-glutamyl amino acids) facilitates the quantitative study of enzymic reactions. Pyrrolidone carboxylic acid does not give a positive ninhydrin reaction but may be detected on paper chromatograms by application of indicators such as bromcresol green or bromphenol blue. A more sensitive procedure was introduced by Ellfolk and Synge ( l 7 ) ,who used the chlorine-starch-iodide reaction of Rydon and Smith (30)to render pyrrolidone carboxylic acid visible on paper chromatograms. This procedure or one of its modifications (3134a) is very useful for detection of pyrrolidone carboxylic acid on papers after chromatography or electrophoresis. Pyrrolidone carboxylic acid may be quantitatively determined as the methyl ester by gas-liquid chromatography (35); this procedure distinguishes pyrrolidone carboxylic acid, from pyrrolidone, a-methylpyrrolidone carboxylic acid, and piperidone carboxylic acid. The gas chromatographic procedure has been used for determination of D-glutamic acid cyclotransferase activity (35) and for identification of pyrrolidone carboxylic acid in human urine ( 3 6 ) .Zamir and Lichtenstein (37) determined pyrrolidone carboxylic acid colorimetrically after heating samples with hydroxylamine followed by treatment with the ferric chloride reagent of Lipmann and Tuttle (38). Ramakrishna and Krishnaswamy (39)used this reaction to render pyrrolidone carboxylic acid visible on paper chromatograms ; they cut out 24. L. Levintow, A. Meister, G. H. Hogeboorn, and E. L. Kuff, JACS 77, 5304 (1955). 25. W. J. Le Quesne and G. T. Young, J. Chem. Soc. p. 594 (1952). 26. J . B. Stark, A. E. Goodban, and H. S. Owens, Anal. Chem. 23, 413 (1951). 27. A. Meister, M. W. Bukenberger, and M. Strassburger, Biochem. 2. 338, 217 (1963). 28. D. Gross, Nature 178, 29 (1956). 29. G. E. Connell and A . Szewczuk, Clin. Chim. Acla 17, 423 (1967). 30. H. N. Rydon and P. W. G. Smith, Nature 169, 922 (1952). 31. F. Reindel and W. Hoppe, Naturwissenschajtsn 40, 221 (1953); Chem. Ber. 87, 1103 (1954). 32. A. Meister, I,. Levintow, R. E. Greenfield, and P. A. Abendschein, JBC 215, 441 (1955). 33. S. C. Pan and J. D. Dutcher, Anal. Chem. 28, 836 (1956). 34. D. P. Schwartz and M. J. Pallansch, Anal. Chem. 30, 219 (1958). 34ii. It. H. Mazur, B. W. Ellis. and P. S. Cammarata, JBC 237, 1619 (1962). 35. P. Polgar and A. Meister, AM^. Biochem. 12, 338 (1965). 36. R. Tham, L. Nystrom, and B. Holmstedt, Biochem. Pharmacol. 17, 1735 (1968). 37. A. Zarnir and N. Lichtenstein, A n d . Chim. Acta 12, 577 (1955). 38. F. Lipmann and L. C. Tuttle, JBC 159, 21 (1945). 39. M. Rarnakrishna and P. R. Krishnaswamy, Anal. Biochem 19, 338 (1967).
6.
ENZYMOLOGY OF PYRROLIDONE CARBOXYLIC ACID
127
the spots containing y-glutamyl hydroxamate and after elution with ethanol estimated the hydroxamate colorimetrically. The procedure suffers from the disadvantage that it also yields color with glutamine, asparagine, and glutathione; furthermore, the low sensitivity of this test restricts its usefulness. It is known that peptides and proteins exhibit a higher absorbance a t wavelengths below 240 nm than the component amino acids (40, 41) and that the absorbance a t 205 nm of peptides and proteins is approximately proportional to the number of peptide bonds. Pyrrolidone carboxylic acid, which has an internal peptide bond, exhibits this type of absorbance, which may be used under appropriate conditions for its quantitative determination. Thus, Orlowski et al. (13) followed the activity of y-glutamyl cyclotransferase by this procedure; after incubation of the enzyme with 7-glutamyl amino acids, the reaction mixture was passed through a small column of Dowex 50 (H’) in order to remove interfering substances, and the absorbance of the eluate a t 205 nm was then determined. A number of attempts have been made to determine pyrrolidone carboxylic acid after reduction with sodium in alcohol, zinc and HCl, Na2S204,and other reducing agents; in general, these were not successful (42). Recently, the reduction of an N-terminal pyrrolidone carboxylic acid residue of proteins with diborane in tetrahydrofuran or tetramethyl urea was attempted with some success; the N-terminal pyrrolidone carboxylic acid residue may thus be identified by its conversion to proline ( 4 3 ) . Special procedures (44) are required for the demonstration of Nterminal pyrrolidone carboxylic acid residues in peptides and proteins; frequently, pyrrolidone carboxylyl-peptides can be detected by the procedure of Rydon and Smith (SO). Discovery of enzymes capable of cleaving pyrrolidone carboxylic acid from the N-terminus of peptide chains should facilitate studies of this type (45, 46) (see below).
111. Natural Occurrence of Pyrrolidone Carboxylic Acid
Pyrrolidone carboxylic acid has been found in the free state in a wide variety of vegetables, fruits, and grasses. Thus, it has been found in 40. 41. 42. 43. 44. 45. 46.
J. S. Ham and J. R. Platt, J . Chem. Phys. 20, 335 (1952). L. J. Saidel, ABB 54, 184 (1955). G. 0. Schlutz, Biochem. 2. 324, 295 (1953). S. Takahashi and L. A . Cohen, Biochemistry 8, 864 (1969). B. Blomback, “Methods in Enzymology,” Vol. 11, p. 398, 1967. R. F. Doolittle and R. W. Armentrout, Biochemistry 7, 516 (1968). R. U‘.Armentrout, BBA 191, 756 (1969).
128
M. ORLOWSKI AND A. MEISTER
TABLE I N-TERMINAL PYRROLIDONE CARBOXYLYL (PYR-)RESIDUES OF PEPTIDES AND PROTEINS No. 1 2 3 4 5
6
7 8 9
10 11 12
Peptide or protein
Sequence
Eisenine Fastigiatine Eledoisin Physalaemin Thyrotropin releasing hormone? Fibrinopeptides B Man Bovine Reindeer Elk Muntjak Mule deer Cape buffalo Water buffalo Gastrin Peptides from snake venoms Heavy chain of human immunoglobin (Eu) Heavy chain of pathological human immunoglobin IgG Heavy chains of .abbit IgG
Pyr-Glu-AlaOH Pyr-Glu-GlnOH Pyr-Pro-SerPyr-Ala-AspPyr-His-Pro-NH2
A-Type Bence Jones proteins Type BO Type Ha Mouse A chains a,acid glycoprotein of human plasma a2chain of rat collagen &Galactosidase from E. wli
Reference
Pyr-G1y-ValPyr-Phe-ProPyr-Leu-AlaPyr-His-SerPyr-His-SerPyr-His-LeuPyr-Phe-ProPyr-Phe-ProPyr-Gly-ProPyr-Gln-Try-OH Pyr-Asn-Try -OH Pyr-Val-GlnPyr-Val-ThrSeveral Pyrpeptides Pyr-Ser-AlaPyr-Ser-ValPyr-Ala-ValPyr-Pro-LeuRyr-TVr-SerPyr-?
Italian rye grass that has been stored a t -20" ( 1 7 ) . However, it seems to be absent in extracts of fresh grass but appears after drying and in silage (17, 4 7 ) . It is of interest that while fresh tomato juice does not contain appreciab 'e quantities of pyrrolidone carboxylic acid, this compound represents about 30% of the total organic acid in stored tomato juices (48). These and other reports which have appeared in the literature 47. H. T. Macphenon and J. S. Slater, BJ 71, 654 (1959). 48. A. C. Rice and C. S. Pederson, Food Res. 19, 106 (1954).
6.
ENZYMOLOGY OF PYRROLIWNE CARBOXYLIC ACID
129
suggest that most plant materials contain little if any free pyrrolidone carboxylic acid ; however, the amount increases, often considerably, during processing or storage probably a t the expense of glutamine, 7glutamyl amino acids, or y-glutamyl peptides. Pyrrolidone carboxylic acid is formed nonenzymically from glutamine during prolonged incubation of proteins with proteolytic enzymes, and in proteins in which the N-terminal amino acid is glutamine, cyclization may precede cleavage of the residue leading to the formation of a pyrrolidone carboxylic-peptide. Sanger et al. (4.9) were able to demonstrate that a pyrrolidone carboxylic acid residue was formed from a glutamine residue in positions 5 and 15 of the A chain of insulin; thus, they obtained two peptides having the same amino acid sequence but differing only in the N-terminal component; one peptide had a pyrrolidone carboxylic acid residue and the other a glutamine residue. Similar observations were made in studies on ribonuclease (50).Pyrrolidone carboxylic acid formation has also been observed during enzymic hydrolysis of enolase, albumin, casein, egg albumin, and other proteins (51-53).In a number of instances it has been difficult to determine whether the Nterminal pyrrolidone carboxylic acid residue formed during isolation or whether it is present in the native peptide or protein. The subject has been extensively reviewed recently (44).A list of some of the peptides and proteins which have been found to contain N-terminal pyrrolidone carboxylic acid residues is given in Table I (54-73).The methods 49. F. Sanger, E. 0. P. Thompson, and R. Kitai, BJ 59, 509 (1955). 50. D. G. Smyth, W. H. Stein and S. Moore, JBC 237, 1845 (1962). 51. J. A. Winstead and F. Wold, Biochemistry 3, 791 (1964). 52. K. Narita and J. Ishii, J. Biochem. ( T o k y o ) 52, 367 (1962). 53. S. Aqvist and A. Wretlind, Acta Physiol. Scand. 39, 147 (1957). 54. B. Blomback, M. Blomback, P. Edman, and B. Hessel B B A 115, 371 (1966). 55. E. M. Press, P. J. Piggot, and R. R. Porter, BJ 99, 356 (1966). 56. C. A. Dekker, D. Stone, and J. S. Fruton, JBC 181, 719 (1949). 57. A. Anastasi and V. Erspamer, ABB 101, 56 (1963). 58. V. Erspamer, A. Anastasi, G. Bertaccini, and J. M. Cei, Ezperientiu 20, 489 (1964). 59. J. Boler, F. Ensmann, K. Folken, C. Y. Bowers, and A. V. Schally, BBRC 37, 705 (1969). 60. B. Blomback, M. Blomback, and P. Edman, Acta Chem. Scand. 17, 1184 (1963). 61. B. Blomback and R . F. Doolittle, Acta Chem. Scand. 17, 1816 (1963). 62. B. Blomback and R. F. Doolittle, Acla Chem. Scand. 17, 1819 (1963). 63. G. A. Mross and R. F. Doolittle, ABB 122, 674 (1967). 64. H. Gregory, P. M. Hardy, D. S. Jones, G. W. Kenner, and R. C. Sheppard, Nature 204, 931 (1964). 65. H. Kato, S. Iwanaga, and T. Suzuki, Ezperientia 22, 49 (1966). 66. G. M. Edelman, B. A. Cunningham, W. E. Gall, P. D. Gottlieb, U. Rutishauser, and M. J. Waxdal, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U . S. 63, 78 (1960).
130
M. ORLOWSKI AND A. MEISTEH
employed for the isolation of some of these peptides (e.g., eisenine, fastigiatine, and gastrin) involve extraction with hot or boiling water or water-alcohol mixtures, procedures that might be expected to lead to cyclization of N-terminal glutamine residues. On the other hand, the isolation of fibrinogen (54) and immunoglobin (55) were carried out a t neutral pH and low temperature; it seems unlikely that under these conditions appreciable cyclization of glutaminyl residues occurred and thus that the native protein probably contains N-terminal pyrrolidone carboxylic acid. It remains to be determined whether pyrrolidone carboxylic acid can be incorporated directly into protein or whether this residue is formed by cyclization of a glutaminyl residue on the tRNA, growing peptide, or completed peptide. Some experimental efforts have been made in this direction (74, 7 4 a ) . It is of interest in this connection that the enzyme from papaya latex ( 7 6 ) ,which catalyzes the cyclization of glutamine and glutaminyl peptides also catalyzes the formation of pyrrolidone carboxylyl-tRNA from E. coli glutaminyl-tRNA ( 7 6 ) . It would be of interest to determine whether glutamine cyclotransferase or a similar enzyme with activity toward glutaminyl-tRNA and glutaminyl peptides is present in animal tissues.
IV. Nonenzymic Formation of Pyrrolidone Carboxylic Acid from Glutamic Acid, Glutamine, and Other Compounds
Abderhalden and Kautzch (77) reported that the heating of dry glutamic acid to 180"-200" led to the formation of essentially optically inactive pyrrolidone carboxylic acid. They obtained optically active Lpyrrolidone carboxylic acid by heating L-glutamic acid a t 150"-160" followed by fractional crystallization of the product. These workers also observed that treatment of optically active pyrrolidone carboxylic acid with strong mineral acid led to its conversion to optically active glutamic 67. J. M. Wilkinson, E. M. Press, and R. R. Porter, BJ 100, 303 (1966). 68. F. W. Putnam, T. Shinoda, K. Titani and M. Wikler, Science 157, 1050 (1967). 69. L. Hood, W. R. Gray, and W. J. Dreyer, JMB 22, 179 (1968). 70. E. Appella and R. N. Perham, JMB 33, 963 (1968). 71. T. Ikenaka and K. Schmid, Proc. Soc. EzptZ. Biol. M e d . 120, 749 (1965). 72. A. H. Kang, P. Bornstein. and K . A. Piez, Biochemistry 6, 788 (1967). 73. R. P. Erickson and E. Steers, Jr., BBRC 37, 736 (1969). 74. B. Moav and T. N. Harris. BBRC 29, 773 (1967). 74a. C. Baglioni, BBRC 38, 212 (1970). 75. M. Messer and M. Ottesen, BBA 92, 409 (1964). 76. M. R. Bernfield and L.Nestor, BBRC 33, 843 (1968). 77. E. Abderhalden and K. Kautzch, 2. PhysioZ. Chem. 68, 487 (1910).
6. ENZYMOLOGY OF PYRROLIDONE CARBOXYLIC ACID
131
acid. The marked difference between the melting points of L-pyrrolidone carboxylic acid (160"-161") and D,L-pyrrolidone carboxylic acid (180"183") (78) led to the erroneous identification of the former compound as 3,6-diketopiperazine-2,5-dipropionicacid (79). Wilson and Cannan (18) reported detailed observations on the equilibrium and velocity constants in the glutamic acid-pyrrolidone carboxylic acid system in dilute aqueous solution. They found that the conversion of glutamic acid to pyrrolidone carboxylic acid follows the equation for a reversible first-order reaction. The equilibrium constant and the rate a t which the equilibrium is achieved depend on the pH of the solution and the temperature. I n neutral solutions, the equilibrium favors almost complete conversion of glutamic acid to pyrrolidone carboxylic acid; however, the rate of the reaction is very slow and thus only 1% conversion occurs after 2-3 hr a t 100".I n weakly acid (pH 4) and alkaline (pH 10) solutions, the conversion of glutamic acid to pyrrolidone carboxylic acid is much faster and about 98% conversion occurs in less than 50 hr. In strong acid (2 N HCl) and base (0.5 N NaOH) the conversion of pyrrolidone carboxylic acid to glutamic acid proceeds rapidly and virtually to completion. Other studies have shown that the conversion of glutamic acid to pyrrolidone carboxylic acid can be carried out within 2 hr a t 142" with little alteration of optical rotation (80). Using the data of Wilson and Cannan (It?), Cleaves (81) was able to show that the rate of formation of pyrrolidone carboxylic acid from glutamic acid in aqueous solution depends directly on the concentration of the ionic species of glutamic acid in solution. Thus, the reactive species are (I), (11),and (IV), while (111) is relatively unreactive. Protonation of the amino group and dissociation of the 7-carboxyl group thus makes these groups less reactive ; carboxylate ion resonance apparently hinders nucleophilic attack by the amino nitrogen. The stabilizing effect of the carboxylate ion resonance is also evident YOOH
78. 79. SO. 81.
y
2
y
2
COOH
yOO-
yo-
7Hz
y i 2
7%
I
C HNH:
7% C HNH:
COOH
COO-
COO-
coo-
(1)
(11)
(UI)
(IV)
I
7% CHNH:
A . F. Beecham, JACS 76, 4613 (1954). J. A . King and F. H. McMillan, JACS 74, 2859 (1952). A. C. Kibrick. JBC 174, 845 (1948). D. W. Cleaves, JBC 186, 163 (1950).
7% CHNH,
132
M. ORLOWSKI AND A. MEISTER
from the rapid cyclization of glutamic acid y-derivatives in which this effect is weakened or abolished. For example, glutamine, 7-esters of glutamic acid, and y-glutamyl peptides are known to cyclize much more rapidly than glutamic acid. Chibnall and Westall (82) found that when glutamine was boiled in solution (p H 3-10) substantial amounts of ammonia form while a t the same time the amount of amino nitrogen decreases. Thus, the main product of "hydrolysis" of glutamine under these conditions is pyrrolidone carboxylic acid (83).Archibald (84) has called attention to the fact that when glutamine was heated at 186" for 30 sec it is quantitatively converted to ammonium pyrrolidone carboxylate. When solutions of glutamine in phosphate buffer (pH 6.5) are placed a t loo", there is 99% conversion to pyrrolidone carboxylate in 90 min; in contrast, cyclization of glutamate under these conditions is very slow. Hamilton was the first to observe that phosphate exerted an accelerating effect on the cyclization of glutamine ( 8 5 ) . These studies were confirmed and extended by Gilbert et a2. (86) who showed that arsenate and carbonate exhibit a similar effect. The nonenzymic cyclization of glutamine is substantial even a t 37",10% being converted to pyrrolidone carboxylic acid after 24 hr (87). Melville has shown that peptides containing glutamine in the N-terminal position exhibit a lability similar to that of glutamine (88). When the amino group is substituted, considerable stabilization is observed ; thus, C-terminal glutamine and glutamine residues within the peptide chain are much more stable than is free glutamine (82, 89). 7-Glutamyl hydroxamate is much more labile than glutamine ; thus, it is virtually completely converted to pyrrolidone carboxylic acid a t pH 7 after heating a t 100" for 7.5 min; less than 10% of glutamine is cyclized under these conditions ( 2 4 ) . a,y-Diesters of glutamic acid (90) are also susceptible to rapid cyclization while a-esters are much more stable (91). Attempts to prepare glutamine from y-methylglutamate or 7-ethylglutamate by ammonolysis fail because cyclization proceeds very rapidly, so rapidly indeed that ammonolysis is not effective. Thus, treat82. A. C. Chibnall and R. G. Westall, BJ 28, 122 (1932). 83. H. B. Vickery, G. W. Pucher, H. E. Clark, A. C. Chibnall, and R. G. Westall, BJ 29, 2710 (1935). 84. R . M. Archibald, Chem. R e v . 37, 161 (1945). 85. P. B. Hamilton, JBC 158, 375 (1945). 86. J. B. Gilbert, V. E. Price, and J. P. Greenstein, JBC 180, 209 (1949). 87. G. L. Tritsch and G. E. Moore, Exptl. Cell Res. 28, 360 (1962). 88. J. Melville, BJ 29, 179 (1935). 89. H. Thierfelder and E. von Cramm, 2. Physiol. Chem. 105, 58 (1919). 90. E. Abderhalden and A. Weil, 2. Physiol. Chem. 74, 445 (1911). 91. A. Neuberger, BJ 30, 2085 (1936).
6.
ENZYMOLOGY OF PYRROLIWNE CARBOXYLIC ACID
133
ment of y-ethylglutamate with aqueous ammonia leads to almost quantitative conversion to pyrrolidone carboxylate (92-94). y-Thioesters of glutamic acid decompose rapidly a t neutral or slightly acid p H to yield pyrrolidone carboxylic acid (95), and it is of interest that phosphate enhances this reaction. Hopkins (96) found that heating of aqueous solutions of glutathione led to formation of pyrrolidone carboxylic acid; cleavage is complete in 120 hr a t 62" (97). Other y-glutamyl peptides exhibit similar behavior (25). However, the nonenzymic cyclization of y-glutamyl amino acids and related compounds proceeds more slowly than that of glutamine; thus, 7-glutamylmethyl amide, y-glutamyldimethylamide, y-glutamylethylamide, and y-glutamylglycine were not significantly affected by incubation in 0.5 M potassium phosphate buffer a t p H 7.8 after 3 days, while under the same conditions the deamidation of glutamine, a-methylglutamine, homoglutamine, and y-methylglutamine had gone virtually to completion (98). It is of interest that the deamidation of glutamine and of a-methylglutamine occur a t approximately the same rates while y-methylglutamine is deamidated considerably more rapidly than glutamine (98). Similarly, y-methyleneglutamine cyclizes more rapidly than glutamine (99). The same product was obtained in the cyclization of 7-methyleneglutamic acid ; this reaction occurs more rapidly than that of glutamic acid. The cyclization of y-hydroxy-ymethylglutamic acid (99) and of p-hydroxyglutamic acid (100) has also been described.
V. Enzymic Formation of Pyrrolidone Carboxylic Acid from Glutamic Acid A.
D-GLUTAMIC ACID CYCLOTRANSFERASE
The discovery of D-glutamic acid cyclotransferase was foreshadowed by the observations of Ratner (23) who fed rats D,L-glutamate labeled with I5N in the amino group and deuterium attached to the a- and pM. Bergman and L. Zervas, 2.Physiol. Chem. 221, 51 (1933). D. Coleman, J. Chem. SOC.p. 2294 (1951). A. F. Beecham, JACS 76, 4615 (1954). H. Sachs and H. Waelsch, ABB 69, 422 (1957). F. G. Hopkins, JBC 84, 269 (1929). E. C. Kendall, H. L. Mason, and B. F. McKenzie, JBC 88, 409 (1930). 98. A. Meister, JBC 210, 17 (1954). 99. J. Blake and L. Fowden, BJ 92, 136 (1964). 100. C. R. Harington and S. S. Randall, BJ 25, 1917 (1931).
92. 93. 94. 95. 96. 97.
134
M. ORLOWSKI AND A. MEISTER
carbon atoms. The animals excreted more 15N in the urine than could be accounted for by urea and ammonia; the extra 15N was found in the form of D-pyrrolidone carboxylic acid, which contained the same concentrations of isotopes as that of the glutamic acid fed. Ratner recovered 73% of the administered D-glutamic acid as urinary D-pyrrolidone carboxylic acid, and since the concentration of deuterium was unchanged she concluded that no reaction involving the a- and phydrogen atoms of D-glutamic acid had occurred. These findings were subsequently confirmed by Wilson and Koeppe (101) who found that injection of l'C-~-glutamate to rats led to the excretion of more than 50% of the radioactivity as D-pyrrolidone carboxylic acid. These authors also found that incubation of D-glutamate with slices of rat liver and kidney led to the formation of D-pyrrolidone carboxylate. The enzyme responsible for the conversion of D-glutamic acid to D-pyrrolidone carboxylic acid was subsequently demonstrated in homogenates of kidney and liver of the mouse, rat, and man (8). Somewhat lower levels of activity were subsequently found in the kidney and liver of the guinea pig and rabbit and in rat spleen, skeletal muscle, brain, pancreas, and testes (102). The enzyme was purified approximately 50-fold from mouse kidney, which appears to be the richest source of this enzyme. Studies on rat and mouse liver and kidney indicated that about two-thirds of the initial activity remained in the supernatant solution when homogenates of these tissues were centrifuged a t 100,000 g for 2 hr. Purification was accomplished by centrifugation of the homogenates followed by ammonium sulfate precipitation (3&60% of saturation) ; the enzyme was then passed through a column of Sephadex G-50and lyophilized. A moderate increase in specific activity was achieved by absorption of impurities on alumina C-y gel. The enzyme requires either manganese or magnesium ions for activity, but no other cofactor requirements were found. With 0.033 M concentrations of metal ions, the activity was more than three times higher with manganese than with magnesium ions. Dialysis of the enzyme against tris-HC1 buffer (pH 7.5) or water a t 0" led to inactivation and attempts a t reactivation were unsuccessful. Optimal activity was observed in the pH range 7.8-8.3 (tris-HC1 buffers). The apparent K , value for Dglutamate is 1.5 x 1CP M . The reaction is reversible and the equilibrium was approached from both directions in the presence of magnesium ions; an equilibrium value of 94% of D-glutamate was converted to D-pyrrolidone carboxylate a t (pH 8.3). The equilibrium constant, K,,= pyrrolidone carboxylate/glutamate = 16. 101. W. E. Wilson and R. E. Koeppe, JBC 236, 365 (1961). 102. A . Meister, M. W. Bukenberger, and M . Strassburger, Baochem. 2. 338, 217 (1963).
6.
135
ENZYMOLOGY OF PYRROLIDONE CARBOXYLIC ACID
The product of the enzymic reaction was isolated in crystalline form and identified as D-pyrrolidone carboxylic acid. The enzyme does not act on L-glutamic acid nor does it catalyze the synthesis of L- or Dglutamine or of the corresponding 7-glutamyl hydroxamates. Studies on the specificity of the enzyme indicated that a number of racemic glutamic acid derivatives are substrates. Thus, as indicated in Table 11, various methyl and hydroxy derivatives of glutamic acid are attacked; with the racemic substrates 50% was utilized. It is of interest that although D-e-aminoadipic acid is not a substrate, both diastereoisomers of D,L-a-aminotricarballylate are attacked. The ability of D-glutamic acid cyclotransferase to act on a-aminotricarballylate has made it possible to obtain enzymic evidence for the configuration of the D-isocitric acid of the Krebs tricarboxylic acid cycle (103). The available data suggest that the amount of D-glutamic acid cyclotransferase in mammalian kidney and liver is sufficient to explain the appearance of D-pyrrolidone carboxylate in the urine of animals that TABLE I1 SPECIFICITY OF D-GLUTAMIC ACID CYCMTRANSFERASEO
Amino acid D-Glutamatd D,LGlutamatee L-Glutamate
,
D b y -Hy droxygluta-
mate (isomer A)" D,ty-Hydroxyglutamate (isomer B) D,tp-Hydroxyglutamate (isomer B) D, bfl-MethylglutaD,ba-Methylglutamate Da-Methylglutamate
Disappearance of amino acid (pmole/hr)
3.8 3.8 0 2.6
0.80
Amino acid D-y-Methylglu tamatd D,ty-Methylglutamatec D,tAllo-a-aminotricarballylatdvc D,bcu-Aminotncarballylate**C tGlutamine
Disappearance of amino acid (pmolelhr)
3.0 2.9 3.6 1.8
0 0
1.8 3.2
D- Aspartate
0
0.80 0.80
D-a-Aminadipate D-Homoglutamine
0 0
a The reaction mixtures contained initially mouse kidney enzyme (0.5 mg), b o r D-amino acids (5 pmoles), D,tamino acids (10 pmoles), MgC12 (4 pmoles), and 2-amino-2-(hydroxymethyl)-1,3-propanediol-HCl buffer (33 rmoles; pH 8.3) in a final volume of 0.2 ml; 37";analysis by procedure C. * The product was identified by paper chromatography [from Meister et al. (IOS)]. c On prolonged incubation (2-6 hr) disappearance of amino acid was close to but did not exceed 5070 of the total amino acid added.
103. A. Meister and M. Strassburger, Nature 200, 259 (1963).
136
M. ORLOWSKI AND
A.
MEISTER
have been fed D-glutamic acid. Substantial amounts of D-pyrrolidone carboxylic acid have been found in human urine (10%);it is not known whether this arises from D-glutamic acid of dietary origin or whether it is produced by bacterial metabolism in the intestine. It might conceivably arise from dietary D-pyrrolidone carboxylic acid (104). The finding of D-pyrrolidone carboxylic acid and D-glutamic acid in the urine after feeding of human tumors to dogs and rats (105,1 0 6 ) was cited as evidence that tumors contain D-glutamic acid; this subject has been reviewed by Miller (107).The physiological role of D-glutamic acid cyclotransferase may be to detoxify D-glutamate formed by the intestinal flora or present in the diet. D-Glutamic acid is one of the most abundant bacterial D-amino acids and it is a very poor substrate for D-amino acid oxidase. The enzymic cyclization of D-glutamate may be considered as a special case of an intramolecular acylation reaction, similar to the physiological acylation of benzoate (as hippuric acid) and phenylacetate (as phenylaceturic acid and phenylacetylglutamine) .
B. GLUTAMINE SYNTHETASE AND 7-GLUTAMYLCYSTEINE SYNTHETASE The enzymic synthesis of glutamine takes place according to the following reaction: ena. M g * +
Glutamate
+ ATP + NH, 7’ glutamine + ADP + Pi
Glutamine synthetase (from brain and peas) catalyzes the synthesis of L-glutamine and D-glutamine from the respective optical isomers of glutamic acid [for reviews, see Meister (108-1IO)].When glutamine synthetase is incubated with ATP, magnesium ions, and either L- or Dglutamate (in the absence of ammonia) the corresponding isomer of pyrrolidone carboxylic acid is formed : Glutamate
+ ATP
en5, Mg’+ A
pyrrolidone carboxylate
+ ADP + Pi
The formation of pyrrolidone carboxylic acid under these conditions has been interpreted to indicate the enzymic formation of an activated glutamate intermediate. The available evidence supports the view that glutamate and ATP interact on the active site of the enzyme to yield en104. E. Abderhalden and R. Hanslian, 2.Physiol. Chem. 81, 228 (1912). 105. F. Kogl, T. J. Barendregt, and A. J. Klein, Nature 162, 732 (1948). 106. G. Hillman, A. Hillman-Elies, and F. Methfessel, 2. Naturforsch, (1954). 107. J. A. Miller, Cancer Res. 10, 65 (1950). 10s. A. Meister, “The Enzymes,” Vol 6, p. 443, 1962. 109. A. Meister, Harvey Lectures 63, 139 (1969). 110: A. Meister, Advan. Enzymol. 31, 183 (1968).
Qb,
660
6.
ENZYMOLOGY OF PYRROLIDONE CARBOXYLIC ACID
137
zyme-bound 7-glutamyl phosphate. In the absence of ammonia, the enzyme-bound acyl phosphate is released from the enzyme as pyrrolidone carboxylic acid. Whether cyclization occurs on the enzyme or after dissociation of the acyl phosphate from the enzyme is not yet certain. It is of interest that the rate of enzymic formation of pyrrolidone carboxylic acid from L-glutamate is approximately the same as that of D-glutamate; however, the cyclization reactions occur much more slowly than that of the synthesis of glutamine catalyzed by the same enzyme. Similar cyclization reactions take place with the optical isomers of a-aminoadipic acid. I n this reaction, piperidone carboxylic acid is formed (6, 7, 111). Although the cyclization reactions catalyzed by glutamine synthetase are of interest in relation to the mechanism of action of this enzyme, it seems unlikely that this relatively slow reaction can be of physiological significance. Purified preparations of y-glutamylcysteine synthetase can also catalyze the formation of pyrrolidone carboxylic acid ( I l l a , b ). This enzyme catalyzes the synthesis of y-glutamylcysteine according to the following reaction: L-Glutamate
+ A T P + L-cysteine enz, Mgz, ---+
L-y-glutamyl-L-cysteine
+ A D P + Pi
When L-cysteine is replaced by L-a-aminobutyrate, L-y-glutamyl-L-aaminobutyrate is formed. The enzyme does not catalyze the synthesis of glutamine nor does glutamine synthetase catalyze the formation of y-glutamyl amino acids. Nevertheless, the reactions catalyzed by these enzymes are analogous and appear to involve activation of the y-carboxyl group of glutamate. When y-glutamylcysteine synthetase purified from rat kidney was incubated with L-glutamate, ATP, and magnesium ions in the absence of an amino acid acceptor pyrrolidone carboxylic acid was formed. The formation of pyrrolidone carboxylate requires magnesium ions and ATP and is associated with the cleavage of ATP to stoichiometric quantities of ADP and inorganic phosphate. The enzyme also catalyzes the formation of D-y-glutamyl-L-a-aminobutyrate; however, even in the presence of L-0-aminobutyrate, cyclization of D-glutamate takes place. It is of interest that r-glutamylcysteine synthetase catalyzes the cyclization of D-glutamate about five times more rapidly than Lglutamate. Presumably the cyclization of D-glutamate and L-glutamate catalyzed by this enzyme reflects, as in the case of the analogous reactions catalyzed by glutamine synthetase, activation of the y-carboxyl group of glutamate, i.e., formation of 7-glutamyl phosphate. 111. V. P. Wellner, M. Zoukis, and A. Meister, Biochemistry 5, 3509 (1966). l l l a . M.Orlowski and A. Meister, Biochemistry 10, 372 (1971). l l l b . M.Orlowski and A. Meister, unpublished data (1970).
M. ORLOWSKI AND A. MEISTER
C. L-GLUTAMIC ACID CYCLOTRANSFERASE (L-GLUTAMIC ACID DEHYDRASE) Akita e t al. (9,112) found L-glutamic acid cyclotransferase in a variant of Pseudomonas cruciviae (var. ovalis). This organism utilizes peptone, L-glutamate, L-pyrrolidone carboxylate, and intermediates of the tricarboxylic acid cycle ; while C1-carboxylic acids are good carbon sources, glucose, sucrose, acetate, and ribose are not utilized for growth. The enzyme was purified from lyophilized cells by a procedure which involved sonication of the cells in 0.066 M potassium phosphate buffer (pH 8) followed by centrifugation. After differential heat denaturation of impurities, the enzyme was fractionated with ammonium sulfate and then further purified by acetone fractionation a t -20" and lyophilized. This procedure gave about a 20-fold increase in specific activity. The purified enzyme was reported to exhibit a single component on electrophoresis in phosphate buffer a t pH 8. The enzyme is not active with D-glutamate. At p H 8 and 50") 98.2% of the added L-glutamate was converted to pyrrolidone carboxylic acid a t equilib-rium. The reaction was found to be reversible. The maximal rate of reaction occurred a t 50". The enzyme exhibited a pH optimum a t 8.0 in potassium phosphate buffers. No cofactor requirements were reported. Activity was inhibited by ethylenediaminetetraacetate (EDTA) , sodium sulfide, and L-cysteine. The apparent K , value for L-glutamate was 1.5-1.6 x 10-1 M . It is of interest that the K , value for D-glutamate with D-glutamic acid cyclotransferase (see above) is also relatively high. L-Glutamic acid cyclotransferase was reported to be inactive toward N-acetyl-L-glutamate, L-glutamine, L-glutamic acid y-ethyl ester, D,L-aspartic acid, 7-aminobutyric acid, L-ornithine, L-lysine, glycylglycine, a-aminoadipic acid, diaminopimelic acid, and glutathione.
D. CONVERSION OF L-GLUTAMATE TO PYRROLIDONE CAREOXYLATE BY RAT LIVERNUCLEAR PREPARATIONS Niwaguchi et al. (14-16) reported that when rat liver homogenates were incubated in a system containing '*C-~-glutarnate,glucose, D P N , adenosine triphosphate (ATP), magnesium ions, cytochrome c, and fumarate, an acidic compound was formed which could be identified as pyrrolidone carboxylic acid by infrared spectroscopy, electrophoresis, 112. S. Akita. K. Tanaka, and S. Kinoshita, Koso Kagaku Shimpoziumu 15, 130 (1961).
6.
139
ENZYMOLOGY OF PYRROLIDONE CARBOXYLIC ACID
paper chromatography, and melting point determination. About 70% of the initial activity of the homogenate was found to reside in the nuclear fraction while the supernatant fractions were essentially devoid of activity. It was subsequently found that pyruvate or intermediates of the tricarboxylic acid cycle plus ATP and magnesium ions were able to substitute for the multicomponent system described above. Furthermore, a soluble extract of the nuclear fraction was capable of catalyzing the reaction. The formation of pyrrolidone carboxylic acid required oxygen and was inhibited by compounds that inhibit A” synthesis, e.g., cyanide, areenate, 2,4-dinitrophenol, aside, Antimycin A, dicumarol, fluoroacetate, and Amytal. The observation that ATP plus an ATP-regenerating system did not substitute for a carbohydrate subtrate suggested that formation of pyrrolidone carboxylic acid is coupled to an energy-yielding oxidation reaction. The mechanism of pyrrolidone carboxylic acid formation in this system is not yet clear. The possibility that the reaction involves the synthesis of a y-glutamyl amino acid catalyzed by y-glutamyl cysteine synthetase followed by cyclization catalyzed by 7-glutamyl cyclotransferase (although not excluded) seems unlikely since 7-glutamyl cyclotransferase has been found almost exclusively in the supernatant fractions of cells. Furthermore, the nuclear preparations studied did not catalyze the synthesis of glutathione or of 7-glutamyl cysteine. Niwaguchi et al. (14) considered the possibility that a “high energy” intermediate derived from glutamate is formed. Further work is necessary to elucidate the mechanism and physiological significance of this interesting reaction. VI. Enzymic Formation of Pyrrolidone Carboxylic Acid from Glutamine and Glutaminyl Peptides
A. L-GLUTAMINE CYCLOTRANSFERASE This enzyme, which was discovered in papaya latex by Messer ( l o ) , catalyzes the conversion of glutamine and glutaminyl peptides to pyrrolidone carboxylic acid or pyrrolidone carboxylyl peptides, respectively : CON& I
f: H*
7%
KC-CH, 1
C-NHCHCONH.. I
6
1
O&,N,CHCNHCHCONH.
CHNH,
R
.
H
II O
I R
-- +
NH,
140
M. ORLOWSKI AND A. MEISTER
Damodaran and Ananta-Narayanan (113) observed that the rate of formation of ammonia from protein amide groups during hydrolysis by crude preparations of papain was considerably higher than when other proteolytic enzymes were used for hydrolysis. This observation was explained by the discovery (10, 75) that crude papain contains L-glutamine cyclotransferase. Neither chymopapain nor papain catalyzes this cyclization reaction ; indeed, neither of these enzymes liberates ammonia when incubated with wheat gluten. It is known that treatment of wheat gluten with crude papain abolishes the toxic effects of the gluten for patients with celiac disease (114, 115). It has been suggested that the toxicity of gluten is related to the presence of a peptide possessing an N-terminal glutaminyl residue ; presumably this is cleaved by an intestinal peptidase which is lacking in patients with celiac disease. The purification of glutamine cyclotransferase from papaya latex has been carried out by Messer and Ottesen (116). A batch procedure was used for the removal of impurities by passage of a papaya latex extract through a thin layer of carboxymethyl-Sephadex ; the active protein was separated by selective elution. Additional purification was achieved by chromatography on a column of carboxymethyl-Sephadex and by gel filtration on Sephadex G-100. The purified enzyme was homogeneous by the criteria of paper electrophoresis, ultracentrifugation, and gel filtration on Sephadex G-100 columns and chromatography on carboxymethyi- or DEAE-Sephadex. The electrophoretic behavior of the enzyme indicates that it is a basic protein with an isoelectric point near 9.0. The sedimentation coefficient is 3.0 S. The approximate molecular weight of the enzyme was determined by gel filtration (117)to be about 25,000. The amino acid composition of the enzyme was determined. Enzymic activity has been conveniently determined using L-glutaminyl-L-asparagine as the substrate by following the formation of ammonia. The pH optimum was 8.4 (Verona1 buffer) ; with L-glutamine as substrate, optimal activity was observed a t pH 9.4. The apparent K , value (with L-glutaminyl-L-asparagine) is 0.2 mM. The enzyme was found to be inactive toward D-glutamine, L-glutamic acid, glycyl-L-glutamine, L-asparagine, L-yglutamylhydrazide, glutathione, and y-L-glu113. M. Damodaran and P. Ananta-Narayanan. BJ 32, 1877 (1938). 114. M. Messer, C. M. Anderson, and L. Hubbard, Gut 5, 295 (1964). 115. H. G. Krainick, G. Mohn, and H. H. Fischer, Helv. Paediat. Acla 2, 124 (1959). 116. M. Messer and M. Ottesen, Compt. Rend. Truv. Lab. Carlsberg 35, 1 (1965). 117. P. Andrews, BJ 91, 222 (1964).
6.
141
ENZYMOLOGY OF PYRROLIDONE CARBOXYLIC ACID
tamylglycine. L-Glutamine methyl ester is a substrate and is converted to pyrrolidone carboxylate methyl ester. The relative activity of the enzyme toward several substrates is given in Table 111. The enzyme also catalyzes the conversion of glutaminyl-tRNA to pyrrolidone carboxylyltRNA (76).
B. 7-GLUTAMYL TRANSPEPTIDASE AND 7- GLUTA MYL CYCLOTRAN SFERASE An enzyme possessing the properties of L-glutamine cyclotransferase has not as yet been found in animal tissue. However, the conversion of glutamine to pyrrolidone caboxylic acid by a two-step enzyme-catalyzed pathway has been observed (IS). Thus, glutamine may be converted to y-glutamyl glutamine by y-glutamyl transpeptidase: 2-~-Glutamine
y-glutarnyl
* 7-L-glutamyl-L-glutamine
transpeptidase
+ NHs
7-L-Glutamyl-L-glutamine is a substrate for 7-glutamyl cyclotransferase (see below), which converts it to pyrrolidone carboxylic acid and glutamine.
TABLE I11 SUBSTRATE SPECIFICITY OF GLUTAMINE CYCLOTRANSFERASE~ Substrate LGlutamine D-Glutamine L-Glutamic acid diamide LGlutaminyl-L-asparagine LGlu taminyl-cleucine L-Glutaminyl-Lasparaginyl-8-benzyl-lrcys teinyl-Lprolyl-bleucylgly cinamide L-Glutaminyl-lrasparaginyl-8-benzyl-bcys teinyl-b prolyl-N-tosyl-blysyl-glycinamide Glycyl-bglutamine L-Asparagine
Relative activity 0.02 0 0.7 1.0 1.0 1.4 1.5 0 0
The experiments were done in Conway dishes witahfraction 5 and 2.5 mM substrate in 0.1 M Verona1 buffer, pH 8.4. For other details, see Messer and Ottesen (116).
142
M. ORLOWSKI A N D A. MEISTER
VII. Enzymic Formation of Pyrrolidone Carboxylic Acid from 7-Glutamyl Amino Acids
A. Y-L-GLUTAMYL CYCLOTRANSFERASE (y-GLUTAMYL LACTAMASE) I n the course of studiea on the hydrolysis of glutathione by kidney extracts, \l'oodwarcl :ind Rcinliart 4 I rioted that 1)yrrolidone carboxylic acid was formed. Pyrrolidone carboxylic acid was the predominant product a t relatively alkaline yalucb:, of pH, while at pH values lower than 6.6, free glutamic acid was tlie major product. The formation of pyrrolidone carboxylic acid from glutathione in the presence of a more purified sheep kidney enzyme preparation waa later reported by Fodor et al. (22).The formation of pyrrolidone carboxylic acid in these systems may be ascribed to thc action of two enzymes, i.e., y-glutaniyl transpeptidase and 7-glutamyl cyclotransferaae. Hanes et al. (1181 were the first to demonstrate enzymic tranbfer of the y-glutamyl moiety of y-glutamyl peptides (or y-glutamyl amino acids ) to acceptor peptides and amino acids with the formation of a new 7-glutamyl linkage. Subsequent studies with purified preparations of y-glutamyl transpeptidase (119, 120) clearly demonstrated that this enzyme does not produce pyrrolidone carboxylic acid wlic~n inculxited with 7-glutarnyl amino acid3 or y-glutamyl peptides. The (libcowry by Connell and Hanes ( 5 1 of an enzyme that catalyzes the forinatioii of pyrrolidone carhoxylic acid from y-glutamylglycine, y-glutamylglutamate, and (more slowly) from y-glutamyl phenylalanine and glutathione thub seems to explain a number of earlier observations on the formation of pyrrolidone carboxylic acid in systems containing glutathione. Connell and Hancs (5) did not detect forination of free glutainic acid and revereibility of the reaction could iiot be demonstrated. 7-Glutamyl cyclotransferase activity wab later observed by Cliffe and Waley (1 1 ) in preparations of calf lens and rabbit liver. Extracts of these tissues catalyzed the cleavage of y-Lglutamyl-L-a-aminobutyrate and 7-L-glutamylglycine to pyrrolidone carboxylic acid and the corre+onding amino acids. The supernatant fraction of rat liver hornogenateb also catalyzed the conversion of ophthalmic acid (7-glutamyl-a-aminobutyrylglycine) to pyrrolidone carboxylic acid, but glutathione wab only slightly attacked. On the other hand, prcyarations from lens did not exhibit detectable action on the tripeptides. Studies 118. C. S. Hance. I;. J. R. Hid. :ind I;. A. Isherwood, BJ 51, 25 (1952) 119. F. J. H. H i d :ind P. H. Springell, BJ 56, 417 (1954). 120. M. Orlowski und A. Mcister. JBC' 240, 338 (1965).
6.
143
ENZYMOLOGY OF PYRROLIDONE CARBOXYLIC ACID
on the specificity of highly purified y-glutamyl cyclotransferase (IS) indicates that this enzyme differs considerably from that of 7-glutamyl transpeptidase (120).While y-glutamyl transpeptidase attacks virtually all y-glutamyl peptides and 7-glutamyl amino acids, the specificity of y-glutamyl cyclotransferase is much narrower. Thus, purified 7-glutamyl cyclotransferase does not attack glutamine, oxidized glutathione, or reduced glutathione. However, when both y-glutamyl transpeptidase and 7-glutamyl cyclotransferase are present, pyrrolidone carboxylic acid is formed from glutathione. These findings suggest that the actual substrate of y-glutamyl cyclotransferase is the corresponding y-glutamyl amino acid and that the formation of pyrrolidone carboxylic acid from glutathione proceeds in two steps as follows: 7-glutamyl
2-Glutathione
7-glutamyl glutathione
transpeptidase y-glutamyl
7-Glutamyl glutathione
+ cysteinylglycine
’ pyrrolidone carboxylic acid
cyclotransferase
+ glutathione
The formation of pyrrolidone carboxylic acid from glutamine (in the presence of both enzymes) probably takes place in an analogous fashion. In contrast to y-glutamyl transpeptidase, which is almost entirely bound to particulates, y-glutamyl cyclotransferase is present in the supernatant fractions of liver and other tissues. Studies on the distribution of the enzyme shows that it is present in most animal tissues but that there are some species differences (Table I V ) . Relatively high enzymic activity is found in kidney, liver, brain, and skin. In man, the highest activity is found in the brain. The unusually high activity in TABLE IV 7-GLUTAMYL CYCLOTRANSFERASE ACTIVITY OF SEVERAL ANIMALTISSUEP Tissue
Mouse
Guinea Pig
Rat
Skin Testes Kidney Brain Heart Liver Spleen Skeletal muscle Intestine Lung
185 141 83 79 63 52 57 23 14 14
426 60 133 66 30 101 86 29 64 54
157 39 286 12 11 77 17 5 89 17
Man 76 63 150 27 45 28 27 38
4 Mean values (units/mg protein) of several determinations (unpublished data obtained in the authors’ laboratory, 1969-1970).
144
M. ORLOWSKI A N D A. MEISTEK
skin is of interest and may be related to the observation that skin contains a rather high concentration of pyrrolidone carboxylic acid (121123) . Connell and Hanes ( 5 ) achieved a 20-fold purification of y-glutamyl cyclotransferase from pig liver by a procedure involving ammonium sulfate fractionation; the active protein precipitated in the fraction between 70 and 85% of ammonium sulfate saturation. A 14-fold purification of a similar enzyme from rat liver was reported by Kakimoto et al. (124).This enzyme was named y-glutamyl glutamine lactamase and was thought to be different from that isolated by Connell and Hanes ( 5 ) because i t was found to be inactive toward y-glutamylglycine and glutathione. However, since both the preparations obtained by Connell and Hanes (5)and Kakimoto e t al. (124)were of relatively low purity, it is difficult to be certain as to whether the reported differences in specificity reflect different enzymes; the presence of additional enzymes in these preparations which might catalyze interfering reactions might possibly account for the observed differences. The most highly purified preparations of y-glutamyl cyclotransferase that have thus far been obtained have been isolated from sheep and human brain (13).The method of isolation involves preparation of an acetone powder of brain followed by extraction and precipitation of inactive proteins at pH 4.2. Further purification is carried out by ammonium sulfate fractionation, heat denaturation of impurities, gel filtration on Sephadex G-75 columns, and chromatography on carboxymethyl cellulose and DEAE-cellulose columns. Several active protein fractions differing in isoelectric point have been found in the course of purification of sheep brain acetone powder extracts. The enzyme from human brain has been purified more than 2000-fold; the preparation obtained catalyzed the formation of about 250 pmoles of pyrrolidone carboxylic acid per milligram of protein per minute using the model substrate L-y-glutamyl-L-7-glutamyl-p-nitroanilide. At least three catalytically active proteins were obtained from human brain. During purification on Sephadex G-75 columns, the activity separated into two different distinct fractions. The lower molecular weight component comprised approximately 75% of the overall activity; after isolation it was shown by DEAEcellulose chromatography and by electrofocusing in a pH gradient (125, 126) to consist of two components differing somewhat in isoelectric 121. G. Pascher, Arch. Klin. Exptl. Dermatol. 203, 234 (1956). 122. G. Leonhardi, I. V. Glasenapp, and G. Bruhl, 2. Physiol. Chem. 292, 89 (1953). 123. K. Laden and R.Spitzer, J. SOC. Cosmetic Chemists 18, 351 (1967). 124. Y. Kakimoto, A. Kanazawa, and I. Sano, BBA 132, 472 (1967). 125. H. Svensson, Acta Chem. Scand. 15, 325 (1961) ; 16, 456 (1962). 126. H. Svensson, ABB 1, Suppl. 132 (1962).
6.
145
ENZYMOLOGY OF PYRROLIDONE CARBOXYLIC ACID
point (PI 4.06 and 4.25). The isolated enzyme was found to be stable a t 0" for a t least one month, and it was also stable in the lyophilieed state when stored a t -20". The pH optimum lies in the range 7.8-8.2 (borate buffer). The apparent K,,, value for L-y-glutamyl-L-y-glutamyl p-nitroanilide is 4 X lo-* M . Table V gives data on the specificity of the purified 7-glutamyl cyclotransferases obtained from human and sheep brain; the two enzymes exhibited similar specificity. The model substrate, L-7-glutamyl-L-7-glutamyl-p-nitroanilide was the most active substrate ; the corresponding L,D-, D,L-, and Dpisomers were inactive. The enzyme preparations also TABLE V SPECIFICITY OF
THE
7-GLUTAMYL CYCLOTRANSFERASES ISOLATED FROM HUMANAND SHEEPBRAIN" Formation of pyrrolidone carboxylate (pmole/mg/min)
Substrate
Human brain ~
y-~-Glutamyl-y-Lglutamyl-p-ni troanilide y-tGlutamyl-rcglu tamine 7-tGlutamy1-L-a-alanine y-rcGlutamylgly cine y-bGlutamy1-Lcu-aminobutyric acid 7-rcGlutamy1-S-met hyl-I,-cysteine y-rcGlu tamyl-Lvaline 7-rcGlutamyl-rcleucine y-rcGlutamy 1-rctyrosine 7-rcGlutamy1-Lp henylalanine 7-LGlutamylglycine ethyl ester 7-L-Glutamyl-8-aminoisobutyric acid Glutathione (reduced) Glutathione (oxidized) y-LGlutamyl-palanine LGlutamine 7-rcGlutamy1-p-nitroanilide y-~-Glutamyl-p-nitroanilide y-D-Glu tamyl-y-D-glutamyl-p-nitroanilide 7-D-Glutamyl-7-Lglu tamyl-p-ni troanilide y-bGlutamyl-y-D-glu tamyl-p-ni troanilide
150 (156)* 6 4 . 5 (68.8) 84.7 (77.6) 2 1 . 6 (22.5) 16.9 (18.5) 7 . 3 (15.3) 1.32 (9.7) 1 . 2 8 (7.95) 1.41 (13.5) 0.75 (8.95) 0 . 4 8 (6.75) 0.00 (0.31) 0 . 5 3 (18.5) 0 (7.1) 0 (0.79) 0 (2.96) 0 (59.2) 0 (0) 0 (0) 0 (0) 0 (4.85)
Sheep brain ~
~
100 (102)b 7 6 . 5 (81.3) 2 7 . 7 (38.8) 9 . 4 5 (15.9) 6 . 2 (9.45) 0 . 6 8 (7.15) 0 . 1 7 (7.15) 0 . 1 1 (4.10) 0.08 (3.10) 0 . 3 1 (5.95) 0 . 0 5 (0.11) 0 . 2 8 (17.8) 0 (10.5) 0 (0.71) 0 (2.01) 0 (22.6) 0 (0) 0 (0) 0 (0) 0 (1.97)
a The reaction mixtures contained substrate (4 pmoles; 2 rmoles for y-Lglutamyl-pnitroanilide), tris-HCl buffer (pH 8.0, 10 rmoles), and y-glutamyl cyclotransferase (0.1 unit; human brain enzyme specific activity 150 units/mg; sheep brain enzyme specific activity 100 units/mg) in a final volume of 0.25 ml. The mixtures were incubated a t 37" for 10-120 min, after which the formation of pyrrolidone carboxylate was determined as described in the text. * The values given in parentheses were obtained in experiments in which 1 unit of y-glutamyl transpeptidase was added to the reaction mixture [from Orlowski et al. (IS)].
146
M. ORLOWSKI AND A. MEISTER
exhibited activity toward L-y-glutamyl-L-glutamine, L-7-glutamyl-L-aalanine, L-y-glutamyl-L-a-aminobutyric acid, L-y-glutamylglycine, and L-7-glutamyl-S-methyl-L-cysteine. Although a number of other closely related compounds were not active or only slightly active, when 7-glutamyl transpeptidase was added, substantial formation of pyrrolidone carboxylic acid was observed with almost all of the y-glutamyl compounds. I n many cases activity was significantly increased ; notable are the values obtained with glutathione, L-y-glutamyl-p-nitroanilide, L-glutamine, L-y-glutamyl-L-phenylalanine, and L-y-glutamyl-L-valine. The enzyme did not act on L-a-y-glutamyl diglycine, L-a-glutamyl-Lalanine, L-y-glutamyl-P-alanine, L-y-glutamyl-P-aminoisobutyric acid. y-Glutamyl cyclotransferase activity is widely distributed and this observation suggests that the enzyme is of metabolic significance in many mammalian tissues. However, the function of this enzyme as well as that of a variety of y-glutamyl amino acids that have been found in nature remain to be elucidated. (See Section X.)
Vlll. Enzymic Formation of Derivatives of Pyrrolidone Carboxylic Acid
Studies on the transamination of glutamine with a-ketoacids (127132’) have shown that a-ketoglutaramic acid is formed as a product. a-Ketoglutaramic acid has been found to exist in solution in equilibrium with the cyclic ketolactam form: CONH,
At pH 7.5 less than 1% of the compound exists in the open-chain a-ketoacid form while a t pH 9 approximately 3% is in a form that reacts as a typical a-keto acid. Glutamine transaminase also catalyzes the transamination of glutamic acid y-A‘-methylamide ; the expected transamination product, a-keto-N-methylglutaramic acid has not yet been isolated from a transamination reaction mixture. However, this compound was 127. A . Meister and S. V . Tim, JBC 187, 173 (1950). 128. A. Meister, JBC 197, 309 (1952). 129. A . Meister, JBC 200, 571 (1953). 130. T. T. Otani and A. Meister, JBC 224, 137 (1957). 131. A . Meister, “The Enzymes,” Vol. 6, p. 193, 1962. 132. A. Meister, Science 120, 43 (1954).
6.
147
ENZYMOLOGY OF PYRROLIDONE CARBOXYLIC ACID
prepared by enzymic oxidation of glutamic acid y-N-methylamide; the product isolated exhibited the properties of 5-hydroxy-N-methylpyrrolidone carboxylic acid; it was not possible to obtain the a-keto analog of glutamic acid-y-N-methylamide in a form possessing a reactive keto group (129).The observation that glutamic acid-7-N-methylamide is a substrate for glutamine transaminase (127) and that methylamine is apparently formed (in the presence of both glutamine transaminase and a-ketoglutaramic acid amidase) suggests that the open-chain form (i.e., a-keto-N-methylglutaramic acid) is demethylamidated rapidly under these conditions, probably more rapidly than its rate of cyclization to 5-hydroxy-N-methylpyrrolidone carboxylic acid. The formation of a-keto-y-methylglutaramic acid by an analogous transmination reaction with y-methylglutamine has also been demonstrated. The a-ketoglutaramic acid amidase present in liver (and other tissues), which catalyzes the deamidation of the open-chain form of a-ketoglutaramic acid, and apparently a-keto-A'-methylglutaramic acid, has no activity toward aketo-y-methylglutaramic acid. Hersh et al. (133) have studied an enzymic reaction between methylamine and a-ketoglutarate which is catalyzed by cellfree extracts of a Pseudomonas; the product of this reaction was shown to be 5-hydroxyN-methylpyrrolidone carboxylic acid. Although the mechanism of this reaction is not as yet understood, it was suggested that the synthesis of 5-hydroxy-N-methylpyrrolidonecarboxylic acid involves two steps. The first of these is presumably enzymic and leads to the formation of the y-N-methylamide of a-ketoglutaric acid: (Y-
In the second postulated step, the product spontaneously cyclizes to yield 5-hydroxy-N-methylpyrrolidone carboxylic acid.
IX. Pyrrolidone Carboxylyl Peptidase
Doolittle and Armentrout (46) recently described an enzyme that selectively cleaves pyrrolidone carboxylyl residues from polypeptide chains. The enzyme was obtained from a strain of Pseudomonas fluores133. L. B. Hersh, L. Tsai, and E.
R. Stadtman, JBC 224, 4677
(1969).
148
M. ORLOWSKI AND A. MEISTER
cens which was isolated from soil. The organism is capable of growing on free pyrrolidone carboxylic acid as the sole source of carbon and nitrogen [see also Maruyama and Nomura ( 1 3 4 ) l . Although the physiological function of this enzyme is not clear, it is clearly of value in the characterization of many proteins and peptides which possess N-terminal pyrrolidone carboxylyl residues. This peptidase has also been found in Bacillus subtilis and in other bacteria ( 1 3 5 ) , and a similar activity (cleavage of the amide linkage of pyrrolidone carboxylic acid amide) has been found in Vibrio dunbar preparations (136). Pyrrolidone carboxylyl peptidase activity has been followed using pyrrolidone carboxylyl L-alanine (or other pyrrolidone carboxylyl-amino acids) as substrate by following the amount of amino acid released as determined by the ninhydrin method (13'7).I n another assay procedure the release of p-naphthylamine from L-pyrrolidone carboxylic-pnaphthylamide (135) is determined by the diazotization procedure of Bratton and Marshall (138) as modified by Goldberg and Rutenberg (139). Armentrout and Doolittle (140) purified the enzyme from a sonicate of Pseudomonas fluorescens by a procedure involving high speed centrifugation of the sonicate, precipitation of impurities by protamine sulfate, ammonium sulfate fractionation, Sephadex G-200 gel filtration, chromatography on DEAE-Sephadex, and preparative gel electrophoresis. A 200-fold increase in specific activity was obtained. These authors stabilized the enzyme during purification by addition of a relatively high concentration (0.1 M ) of 2-pyrrolidone. The enzyme was completely inhibited by brief exposure to sulfhydryl reagents, e.g., iodoacetamide and p-mercuriphenylsulfonate. The most purified preparation was reported to exhibit two components on gel electrophoresis. Studies on the specificity of the enzyme (141) showed that pyrrolidone carboxylyl-L-alanine (Pyr-Ala) was the best substrate. The influence of the penultimate amino acid on the rate of hydrolysis of Lpyrrolidone carboxylyl-L-amino acid dipeptides is considerable. The order of the relative hydrolysis rates varied in the sequence: Pyr-Ala, Pyr-Ile, Pyr-Val, Pyr-Leu, Pyr-Phe, Pyr-Tyr. L-Pyrrolidone carboxylyl 134. Y. Maruyama and M. Nomura, J. Biochem. (Tok y o) 43, 327 (1956). 135. A. Seewczuk and M. Mulceyk, European J. Biochem. 8, 63 (1969). 136. U. Senji, 0. Hiwatashi, and 0. Kimio, Tohoku J. ExpZ. M e d . 42, 46 (1942). Chem. Abstr. 42, 5067 (1948). 137. C. H. W. Him, S. Moore, and W. a.Stein, JBC 219, 623 (1956). 138. A. C. Bratton and E. K. Marshall, Jr., JBC 128, 537 (1939). 139. J. A. Goldbarg and A. M. Rutenburg, Cancer 11, 283 (1958). 140. R. W. Armentrout and R. F. Doolittle, ABB 132, 80 (1969). 141. J. A. Uliana and R. F. Doolittle, P B B 131, 561 (1969).
6. ENZYMOLOGY
OF PYRROLIDONE CARBOXYLIC ACID
149
L-proline is not detectably hydrolyzed. The enzyme exhibits considerable optical specificity ; thus, D-pyrrolidone carboxylyl L-alanine is not hydrolyzed while L-pyrrolidone carboxylyl D-alanine is hydrolyzed about 30 times more slowly than the corresponding L-L isomer. Pyrrolidone carboxylyl peptidase from B. sirbtilis (135)exhibits properties similar to the enzyme obtained from Pseudomonas. It is of interest that the enzyme is inactivated by shaking with air a t room temperature for 5 min and that reactivation is readily achieved by brief incubation with 2-mercaptoethanol and EDTA. Studies on pyrrolidone carboxylyl peptidase have shown that the enzyme can catalyze the removal of the terminal pyrrolidone carboxylyl residue from fibrinopeptides, fibrinogen (135,l4O), and human seromucoid (136). A recent report describes the presence of pyrrolidone carboxylyl peptidase in rat liver (46).A partial purification of the enzyme has been obtained by ammonium sulfate fractionation and gel filtration on Sephadex G-200. The rat liver eiizyme is similar to that obtained from Pseudomonas; thus, it is protected against inactivation by 2-pyrrolidone and exhibits similar substrate specificity.
X. Pyrrolidone Carboxylate Metabolism
There is relatively little definitive information in the literature about the metabolism of pyrrolidone carboxylic acid; although several reports indicate that pyrrolidone carboxylic acid can be utilized by mammals (104,142-1467, and certain microorganism (45,134, 147-1521, information relating to the enzyme-catalyzed utilization of pyrrolidone carboxylic 142. R . Muraclii, Acta Schol. Med. Univ. Kioto 7 , 445 (1925). 143. R. M . Rctlikr and H. Strcnback, JBC 58, 105 (1923). 144. S. Prdrrscn and H. B. L(.wis. JBC 154, 705 (1944). 145. L. D. Greenberg and C. L. A . Schmidt, Univ. Calif. Berkeley Publ. Physiol. 8, 129 (1936) ; Chem. Abstr. 30, 8388 (1936). 146. J. S. Butts. H. Hlunden, and M. S. Diinn. JBC 119, 247 (1937). 147. P. Sirrionnrt and K. Y. Chow. Antonze vrcu Leeuwenhoek 1. Microbiol. Serol. 19, 34 (1953) ; Chem. Abstr. 47, 8173 (1953). 148. M. Forbes and M. G. Sevag, ABB 31, 406 (1961). 149. T. Toss : i n t i I. Chibuta, J. Btrcteriol. 89, 919 (1965). 150. Y. Ihwai, Y. Kawai, and T. Urrnurn, Agr. Biol. Chem. ( T o k y o ) 29, 395 (1'365). 151. Y. Kanai and T. Yrmura, Agr. Uiol. ('hem. ( T o k y o ) 30, 438 (1966). 152. Y. Kawai, K. Aida, and T. Ucinura, Agr. Biol. Chem. ( T o k y o ) 33, 212 (1'369).
150
M . ORLOWSKI AND A. MEISTER
acid has been slow in accumulating. Recently, Ramakrishna et al. (153) reported that when l4C-~-pyrro1idonecarboxylic acid was injected intraperitoneally into rats more than half of the radioactivity appeared in the expired carbon dioxide within 30 min; these workers also found that liver and kidney slices converted 14C-pyrrolidone carboxylic acid to 14C0, and to 14C-glutamate.I n independent studies in the author's laboratory it was found that slices of rat kidney, liver, heart, muscle, skeletal muscle, and brain oxidized "C-pyrrolidone rarboxylate to "Co, ; analysis of the intracellular amino acid pool in the experiments with kidney slices revealed that 70% of the initial radioactivity was present in glutamate and glutamine (154). Rush and Starr (155) observed in the course of studies on the incorporation of pyrrolidone carboxylic acid into tRNA that a soluble rat liver preparation catalyzed the conversion of 14C-pyrrolidone carboxylate to "C-glutamate and "C-glutamine in the presence of ATP. Recent studies conducted by the authors have shown that when rat kidney extracts were incubated with "C-L-pyrrolidone carboxylate in the presence of ATP, magnesium ions, and an ATP-generating system, more than 80% of the radioactivity was converted to 14C-glutamine; the remainder was present as '*C-glutamate. When such incubations were carried out in the presence of L-methionine sulfoximirie [an irreversible inhibitor of glutamine synthetase (156)1, all of the radio-
FIG. 1. The y-glutamyl cycle. I, y-Glutamylcysteine synthetase ; 11, glutathione synthetnse ; 111, y-glutamyl transpeptidase; IV, y-glutnrnyl cyc1otr:tnsferase; V. peptidase. PCA = pyrrolidone carboxylic acid ; AA = amino acid. 153. M. Ramakrishna, P. R. Krishnaswamy, and Rajagopal D. Rao, BJ 118, 895 (1970). 154. P. Van Der Werf. M . Orlowski. and A . Meister. unpublished data (1970). 155. E. .4. Rush and J. I,. Stnrr, BBA 199, 41 (1970). 156. R. .\. Ronzio :ind A . Mrialrr. Ploc. S o t l . Acntl. Sci. I ' . S. 59, 164 (1968).
6.
151
ENZYMOLOGY OF PYRROLIDONECARBOXYLIC ACID
activity was found in glutamate (154). It thus appears that rat kidney (and probably other animal tissues) contains an enzyme that converts pyrrolidone carboxylic acid to glutamate in a reaction that requires ATP and magnesium ions. Evidence has been presented that rat kidney contains enzymes that catalyze the utilization and synthesis of glutathione, i.e., y-glutamyltranspeptidasc, y-glutamyl-cyclotransferase, y-glutamylcysteine synthetase, and glutathione synthetasc. The reactions catalyzed by these and two other enzymes, which involvc the uptake and release of amino acids from y-glutamyl linkage and the formation and utilization of pyrrolidone carboxylic acid, constitute a cyclical process (Fig. 1) which has been termed the “7-glutamyl cycle” (157).It has been suggested that the y-glutamyl cycle may function in the transport of amino acids.
157. M. Orlowski and A . Meister, Proc. iVatl. Acnd. Scz.
U. S . 67,
1248 (1970).
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Stabhv lococcal Nuclease X-Ray Structure F. ALBERT COTTON
EDWARD E. HAZEN, JR.
I . Introduction . . . . . . A. Why Staphylococcal Nuclease?
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
. B. Introduction to thc Crystnllographic Stiidics . 11. The Conformation of the Peptidc Chain . . . .
. . .
. . .
. . .
111. The Binding of Thymidinc-3’,5’-Diphosphate and Calcium Ion . . . . . . . . . . . IV. Some Correlations with Stirdics in Solution . . . . V. Some Tentative Comments on Mechanism and Plnns for Future Studies . . . . . . . . . . A . A Warning . . . . . . . . . . B. Mechanism . . . . . . . . . . C. Proposed Future Studies . . . . . . .
.
.
.
.
. . . .
. .
. .
153 153 156 159 163 172 174 174 174 175
I. Introduction
A. WHYSTAPHYLOCOCCAL NUCLEASE? I n the second edition of this work t h e subject of the extracellular nuclease of Staphylococcus a w e u s , ribonucleate (deoxyribonucleate) 3’nucleotidohydrolase, EC 3.1.4.7,was quite adequately covered in some six-hundred words ( 1 ) . I n this edition there are two chapters jointly containing more than a n order of magnitude more words about this forinerly obscure, nonspecific riuclease with its high pH optimum (pH 9-10) and 1. M. Laskowski, Sr.. “The Enzymes,” 2nd ed., Vol. 5, p. 142. 1963 153
154
F. A. COTTON A N D E. E. H A Z E N , J R .
requirement for relatively high (0.01 41) calcium ion concciitration for full activity ( 2 ) . Earlier work on this cnzymc has been well rcvicwetl (1, 3-5). I n recent ycars work on the cnzymc in solution has been reported from only four 1al)oratorics. Von Hippel and Fclscnfelrl (6)and Wingert and voii Hippel (7) have examined some parameters influencing the mode and rate of hydrolysis of deosyribonucleic acid (IINA) by the enzyme. 1,askows;ki :ind his collaborators havc rontinuetl thcir intcrcst in the nuclease as a tool in nuclcic acid rcsearch with further studies of its purification, specificity, and mode of action (8-12). ,Jardetzky and hie colleagues are in the process of publishing their cxtcnsive nuclear magnetic resonance studies of native as well as specifically dcuteratcd derivatives of the enzymc (13-18). The most intcnsivc and comprehensive studies of the nuclease arc being executed in C. B. Anfinsen’s laboratory, with particular recent emphasis on factors influencing chain folding. Tliese may be considered as a natural extension of earlier work on conformtitional aspects of bovine pancreatic ribonucleasc (19, 2 0 ) . In the present case, the system is free of complications arising from the prcscncc of disulfide cross-links for, in its single chain of 149 amino acid residues, the nuclease has no covalent intrachain cross-linking nor, for that matter, any sulfhydryl groups (21-23). A description of iiivestigations on the 2. P. Cuatrctcasns. S. Fuchs, and C. B. Anfinsen, JBC 242, 1541 (1967). 3. M. Laskowski. Sr.. Atlvtrn. Enzymol. 29, 166 (1967). 4. M. Privat dc Garilhr, “Enzymes in Nucleic Acid Research.” p. 170. H(miann. Paris, 1967. 5. P. Cuatrecasas, H. Taniuchi, and C. B. Anfinsen. Brookhaven Symp. B i ~ l 21, . 172 (1968). 6. P. H. von Hipprl and G . Fclsenfcld. Biocheniis/ry 3, 27 (1964). 7. I,. MTingrrt :ind P. H. von Hipprl. U B A 157, 114 (1968). 8. E. Sulkowski and M. Laskowski, Sr., JBC 241, 4386 (1966). 9. E. Sulkowski and M. 1,askowski. Sr.. JBC 243, 651 (1968). 10. E. Sulkowski and M. Laskowski, Sr., JBC 243, 4917 (1968). 11. E. Sulkowski and M. Idaskowski, Sr., JBC 244, 3818 (1969). 12. A. J. Mikulski, E. Sulkowski, L. Stasiuk, and M. Laskowski, Sr., JBC 244, 6559 (1969). 13. D. H. Meadows, J. L. Markley, J. S. Cohen, and 0. Jardetzky, l’roc. Nnll. Acad. Sci. U . S. 58, 1307 (1967). 14. J. L. Markley, I. Putter, and 0. Jmdetzky, Z. Anal. Chem. 243, 367 (1968). 15. J. L. Markley, I . Putter, and 0. Jardetzky. Scieme 161, 1249 (1968). 16. I. Putter, A . Barreto, J. L. Markley, and 0. Jardetzky, Proc. N a t l . Acnd. Sci. U.S. 64, 1396 (1969). 17. I. Putter, J. L. Markley, and 0. Jardetzky. Proc. N n l l . Acad. Sci. U. S. 65, 395 (1970). 18. J. I,. Markley, M. W. Williams. and 0. Jardetzky, Proc. Natl. Actcd. Sci. C.. S. 65, 645 (1970). 19. C. B. Anfinsen. Harvey Lectures 61, 95 (1967). 20. C. 13. Anfinsen, Develop. Biol. S u p p l . 2, 1 (1968).
7. STAPHYLOCOCCAL
KCCLEASE X-RAY STRI‘CTURE
155
structure, function, and synthesis of staphylococcal nuclease is given in earlier reviem ( 5 , 241 and i i i Chapter 8 by Anfinmi et al. in this volume ( 2 5 ). One observation liab 1)ecn particularly critical in the X-ray crystallographic investigation of the enzyme. It was found that thymidine-3’,5’-diphospliate ( pdTp) i n the presence of calcium ions is a potent in1iil)itor of the nucleasc ( 2 6 ) .The obligate ternary complex (27) of nuclea~e-ldTI)-Ca’+ha. hoiiie Iwopcrtic. nhicli differ markedly from those of the uninhibited nucleabc ; the differenceb are probahly only in part the result of ~ n i a l conformational l change* (5.18,30,3 1 ) .T h e inhibited nuclease is more rehi&iiit to urea ( 5 ) and heat ( 5 ,9, 3 2 ) denaturation, has a distinctly altered pattern of reactivity of its tyrosine residues toward chemical inodification (32,3 3 ) , has ahout 34 fewer easily exchangeable protonb (34, 3 5 ) , and is inore rebistant t o liydrolybis by the proteolytic enzyme, trypsin, which now cleaves it specifically in only two places (between residues 5 and 6 and I)etneen 48 and 4 9 ) . The combination of 6 4 8 and 49-149 fragiiients has bigiiificant (about 10% 1 enzymic activity (36-38). X-ray crybtallographic study was undertaken to supply a structural 21. H. Taniuclii. C. U. Anfinsen. and il. Sod.i:i, JBP 242, 4752 (1967). 22. C . I.. Ciisuniano. H. T:iniuclii, :ind C. B. ilnfinsen, JBC 243, 4769 (1968). 23. H. Tnniuchi. C. L. Cusumano. C. b. Anfinsen, and J. L. Cone, JBC 243, 4775 (1968). 24. C. B. Anfinsen, Pure Appl. Chem. 17, 461 (1968). 25. C. B. Anfinsen. P. Cuatreciisns. and H. Taniuchi, “The Enzyrnrs.” 3rd ed., Vol. IV, p. 177, 1971. 26. P. Cuntrec:isas, S. Fuchs. and C. B. Anfinsen, JBC 242, 1541 (1967). 27. Although gel filtration ( 2 s ) and sl~t~ctroscol)ic (29) ni(~asurmientsof riuclcotidc binding indirate nn nbsolut,e rcclriirement for cnlciurii ion and virc vc’rsa. the N M R studies (13-15, 1 s ) cuggcst thnt both C‘a” and nuchotides c:in indrlwndently bind to the nucleasr but that further rh;ingrs takr pl:icr in the NMR spcctruni when all three (Ca”, pdTp. and nuclease) are present,. As Markley et al. pointed out (15) this aliliarent discrrpancy is probably only a mattcr of rnethodological sensitivity and tightness of binding. 28. P. Cuntrcrasas. S. Fuchs, and C. 13. Anfinscn. JBC 242, 3063 (1967). 29. P. Cuatrecasas. S. Furhs, and C. B. rlnfinsrn, JBP 242, 4759 (1967). 30. P. Cuatrecasas, H. Edelhoch, and C. B. ilnfinscn, Proc. Nntl. Acad. Sci. 7,’. S . 58, 2013 (1967). 31. A. Arnone. C. J. Birr, F. A . Cotton, E. E. Hazen, Jr., 11. C . Richardson, and J. S. Richardson, Proc. N n t l . Acnd. Scz. G. S. 64, 420 (1969). 32. 1’. Cuatrecasas, S. Fuclis, :ind C. 13. Anfinsen. HUA 159, 417 (1968). 33. 1’. Cuatrrcasas, S. F L I C ~and S . C. B. Anfinsen. JBC 243, 4787 (1968). 34. A . N. Schechter, L. Moravek, and C. €3. Anfinsen. Proc. N n f l . Acrrd. Sci. U . S . 61, 1478 (1968). 35. A . N. Schcchter, L. Moravek. and C. B. Anfinsen, JBC 244, 4981 (1969). 36. H. Taniuchi, C. B. Anfinsen. and A. Sodja, Proc. Nutl. Acrtd. Sci. U . S. 58, 1235 (1967). 37. H. Taniuchi and C. B. Anfinsen, JBC 243, 4778 (1968). 38. H . Taniuchi, L. Moravek. and C. B. Anfinsen, JBC 244, 4600 (1969).
156
F. A. COTTON AND
E. E. HAZEN,
JR.
basis for understanding these and other properties of the nuclease as well as to help elucidate the mechanism of its action.
B. INTRODUCTION TO THE CRYSTALLOGRAPHIC STUDIES We began our investigation (39) of the crystal structure of the staphylococcal nuclease with attempts to crystallize the enzyme in the spring of 1963. At approximately the same time that Sulkowski and Laskowski crystallized the nuclease from ammonium sulfate (8J, we obtained suitable crystals for X-ray diffraction purposes (40) and began active crystallographic work about the beginning of 1966. All our work has been done on the nuclease from the Foggi strain of Staphylococcus aureus ( 2 2 ) . All crystals have been grown from low ionic strength buffers ( p N 0.01) with 2-methyl-2,4-pentanediol as the precipitant ( 4 1 ) . The detailed conditions for the growing of crystals, the preparation of heavy-atom derivatives, the collection of data, and the production of electron density maps are given elsewhere (31, 40, 4 2 ) . Anomalous dispersion measurements were made on all heavy-atom derivatives ; this allows an electron density map to be calculated with the data obtained from a single heavy-atom derivative ( 4 3 ) . We have studied crystals of both the uninhibited nuclease and the nuclease-pdTp-Ca’+ complex and treated them as independent structures. The crystals of uninhibited nuclease, hereafter referred to as Type I, have unit cell parameters a = b = 47.75 A, c = 63.5 A ; the ternary complex (inhibited nuclease) crystals, hereafter called Type I I , have unit cell parameters a = b = 48.3 A, c = 63.3 A ; the space group of both is P4, (31). We shall show views of the structure of the nuclease a t three ‘‘levels of resolution”; these structures were determined as follows : (1) At 6 A resolution, Type I crystals phased from derivatives prepared by soaking in PtCli-, p-chloromercuribenzenesulfonic acid (PCMBS) and p-acetoxymercurianiline (PAMA) and using all the data within a 6 A sphere in reciprocal space. 39. The others n.ho have been associated with this project, in order of appenrance, nre D. C. Richardson, J. S. Richardson, A. Amone, C. J. Bier, V. W. Day, A . Yonath, and S. Lnrsen. 40. F. A. Cotton, E . E. Hasen, Jr., and D. C. Richardson, JBC 241, 4389 (1966). 41. M. V. King. BBA 79, 388 (1964). 42. A. Arnonc, C. J. Bier, F. A. Cotton, E. E. Hazen, Jr., D. C. Richardson, J. S. Richardson, V. W. Day, and A. Yonath, JBC (1971) (in preparation). Some additional details will be found in the P1i.D. thesis of A. Amone, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, 1970. 43. A. C. T. North, Acta Cryst. 18, 212 (1965).
7.
STAPHYLOCOCCAL NUCLEASE X-RAY STRUCTURE
157
(2) At 4 A resolution, again using all the data. (a) Type I crystals phased with the same heavy-atom derivatives. (b) Type I1 crystals phased with the single substitution of an iodine atom for a methyl group. (3) At high resolution, Type I1 crystals phased with iodine for methyl and barium for calcium ion substitutions using all the data t o 4 A but only that 35% of the reflections from 4 to 2 A with the highest intensities. I n the Type I1 crystal the iodine atom was introduced by substituting 5-iododeoxyuridine-3,5’-diphosphate for pdTp when growing the crystals. For the other derivative the bound calcium ion was replaced by a barium ion by soaking, since it proved difficult to grow large well-formed bariumcontaining crystals de novo. Our results indicate that the iodine atom replaces the methyl group, and the Ba’+ the Cazf with full occupancy and high isomorphicity. There is an indication that the Ba‘+ position is somewhat displaced from that of the Ca‘+ (4.2). Although the determination of protein structures by X-ray crystallography has had immense impact on the field and although these crystal structures appear to be excellent approximations of the structures in solutions ( 4 4 ) ,the unsophisticated use of this information is not without its dangers. If it has not already happened, it is almost inevitable that a protein-crystallographic group will someday make a gross error-minor errors or uncertainties are commonplace-in the interpretation of their electron density map. Indeed, our private attempts to fit our 4-A resolution maps located the path of much of the peptide chain correctly but were completely out of register with the sequence. I n the determination of the structure of small molecules by X-ray crystallography, the resolution is sufficient to reveal individual atoms, thus allowing, for one thing, the application of prior knowledge of reasonable values for bond lengths and angles. I n addition it is possible, with the aid of the computer, to apply reasonably rigorous tests to the correctness of the structure. Although the ability to test the fitting and correctness of a protein electron density map is growing (45-48), we believe these maps, not because we can be sure they are correct but because they satisfy our notions of what a protein should look like, were obtained with valid 44. J. A . Rupley. in “Structure and Stability of Biological Macromolerules” (S.N . Timashcff and G. D. Fasman, eds.). p. 291. Marccl Dckker, New York, 1969. 45. F. M. Richards, J M B 37, 225 (1968). 46. R. Diamond, Actn Cryst. 21, 253 (1966). 47. R . Diamond, Acta Cryst. A25, 5189 (1968) (Abstr. 81h Intern. Congr. I n t s i n . Union Crystallog.). 48. M. Levitt and S. Lifson, J M B 46, 269 (1969).
158
F. A. COTTON AND E.
E. HAZES,
JR.
techniques by competent people and are, after all, the only electron density maps we have of proteins. The recent dispute over the interpretation of the structure of DNA (49-53) is not without relevance to protein structures, even though the isomorphous replacement method allows the independent determination of magnitudes and phases. Indeed, Donohue's comments on resolution, disorder, and the R value would appear most apt (49). To come to our point, it may be very worthwhile for students to build Kendrew models of enzymes from lists of coordinates, but for the investigator whose work depends critically on the knowledge of an enzyme structure, complete reliance on such a model is risky; the electron density map itself should also be consulted where crucial questions of
FIQ.la. 49. J. Donohue, Science 165, 1091 (1969). 50. M. H. F. Wilkins, D. A. Marvin, and L. D . Hamilton. Science 167, 1693 (1970) 51. F. H. C. Crick, Science 167, 1694 (1970). 52. S. Amott, Science 167, 1694 (1970). 53. J. Donohue, Science 167, 1700 (1970).
7.
STAPHYLOCOCCAL NUCLEASE X-RAY STRUCTURE
159
atomic configurations arise. In the first place, a set of coordinates is a secondary source of data involving someone else’s partially subjective interpretation of the primary data; in the second place, there is considerably more information in the electron density map than t.here is in a model. The lack of coordinates in this chapter should, however, not be taken as implying that we disapprove of their publication but only that we have not yet measured a set with sufficient precision to justify inclusion here.
II. The Conformation of the Peptide Chain
Figure l a is the front view of a Styrofoam model of the nuclease made from the 6-A electron density map of Type I crystals. As we speak, subsequently, of the front, back, top, bottom, etc., of the molecule, we are
Fic:. 1 . (a) Front virw of the 6-A Styrofoam model of the uninhibited nuclease (Typca I crystals); (b) view of thr samr Styrofoam model from the left side.
160
P. A. COTTON A N D E. E. HAZEN, J R .
FIG.2a.
viewing it as it is shown here with right and left meaning the viewer’s right and left. Figure l b is the same model viewed from the left-hand side. Figures 2a and 2b show the front and right views, respectively, of the conformation of the peptide backbone of the nuclease, based on the high resolution structure of the Type I1 crystals. The latter photographs, which are black and white reproductions of the original color slides, are taken with UV illumination of fluorescent dye-filled, transparent tubing tied to each a-carbon of a Kendrew model of the nuclease (54).Figure 3 is a drawing of the peptide chain showing the approximate positions of the a-carbon atoms. Figure 4 is the amino acid sequence of the Foggi strain of Staphylococcus aureus ( 2 2 ) . As one views the nuclease from the front, the N-terminal residue is a t the upper left rear. From this point the chain goes diagonally down 54. These photographs were made by C. B. Anfinsen, D. C. Richardson, and J. S. Richardson. This technique is particularly effective when the flow of dye through the tubing is vicwed as a function of time in a motion picture.
7.
STAPHYLOCOCCAL NUCLEASE X-RAY STRUCTURE
161
FIG.2. (a) Front view of the conformation of the peptide chain of the inhibited nudeme at high resolution (Type I1 crystals). ( b ) Right side view of the chain conformation a t high resolution. The curlicue at the upper left center represents the inhibitor pdTp.
across the back of the molecule until at residue 12 there begins a nearly vertical, inwardly curving section of antiparallel /?-pleated sheet made up of three strands which run approximately front to back. This sheet, consisting of some 24 residues, forms the upper right flank of the nuclease molecule. Between residues 37 and 44 the chain loops through the center of the molecule and then between residues 44 and 53 forms the loop which can be seen extending out into solution in the side view of the chain. Residues 54 through 67 form some three and one-half turns of helix which runs from front to back. From the end of the helix the chain rises up the back of the molecule, comes to the front a t the top right, at T y r 85 turns again toward the back and then drops down the back to the start of another helical section (residues 99-107) of two and one-half turns that comes toward the front bottom of the molecule, slanting down a t an angle of about 20" from the horizontal. From
162
FIG.3. Drawing of
F. A. COTTON AND E. E. HAZEN, JR.
:I
front view of the chain conformation showing the locations
of the a-carbon atoms along the chain. The positions of the 3’- and 5’-phosphatr groups of pdTp are indicated by X and the Caz+by 0 .
10
20
FIG.4. The amino acid sequence of the staphylococcal nucleuse, Foggi strain.
7.
STAPHYLOCOCCAL NUCLEASE X-RAY STRUCTURE
163
this point, the chain rises directly up forming the left front of the molecule, loops toward the rear with Pro 117 a t the peak of the loop, and drops down to the start of another helical section a t residue 122. At a n angle of 40” with the horizontal, this helical section runs down and forward to residue 134 near the bottom left front of the molecule. The chain ends in a complex loop near the bottom left of the molecule. Despite the fact that the phases for the high resolution map were obtained from only two heavy-atom derivatives ( 5 5 ) ,the electron density map was quite interpretable with the aid of the sequence along most of the peptide chain. This is illustrated in Fig. 5a which shows the high resolution map of the bottom right helix, one of the best resolved sections. Figure 5b shows the same section phased only with the high resolution iodine data; Fig. 5c, the Type I1 crystals phased with iodine and barium at 4 A ; and Fig. 5d, the Type I crystals phased with the three heavy-atom derivatives a t 6 A resolution. The five N-terminal residues and the six or seven C-terminal residues cannot be seen in the high resolution electron density map, and the loop referred to above, formed by residues 44 to 53, appears a t only one-third to one-half the amplitude of the well-resolved parts of the map. The lack of clarity in theae three regions might possibly result from poor phasing or some other crystallographic factor, but we consider it more likely that these predominantly hydrophilic sections of the peptide project in a disordered way into the solvent. In this connection, it is interesting that in the presence of Ca’+ and pdTp trypsin cleaves inhibited nuclease a t only two points: between residues 5 and 6 and between residues 48 and 49 (36-38) which are a t the very extremity of the loop. It also seems relevant that ribonuclease S also shows lack of clarity a t the ends of the peptide chains and in the region of a relatively exposed loop (66)* 111. The Binding of Thymidine-3’,5’-Diphosphate and Calcium Ion
In the front view of the Styrofoam model (Fig. l a ) a distinct pocket is seen in the upper left quadrant of the model. Figure6a shows a view from directly above this pocket in the 4-A electron density map of the 55. I n addition, not only are iodine and barium relatively light “heavy” atoms. but they are replacing a carbon atom (the 5-methyl of thymine) and a calcium ion. respectively, giving net changes of 47 and 36 electrons, respectively. 56. H. W. Wyckoff. D. Tsernoglou, A. W. Hanson, J. R. Knox, B. Lee, and F. M. Richards, JBC 245, 305 (1970).
164
F. A. COTTON AND E. E. HAZEN, JR.
(b)
FIG.5a and b. Type I (uninhibited) crystals. I n a rather marked contrast, Fig. 6b shows the same view of the 4-A electron density map of the Type I1 (inhibited) crystals. A mass of electron density now appears in the pocket, and there also appears to be some added density a t the left side of the perimeter of the pocket itself. It should perhaps be reemphasized here that these structures of the Type I and Type I1 crystals were determined completely independently using one set of heavy atoms and unsubstituted data for the uninhibited nuclease and another entirely different combination for the nuclease-inhibitor complex. However, the fact that heavy-atom positions appear very distinctly when intensities from Type I crystals are combined with Type I1 phases (and vice versa) indicates that the nuclease undergoes no gross conformational changes with pdTp and Caz+binding (31) ; thus, the kind of comparison presented
7.
STAPHYLOCOCCAL NUCLEASE X-RAY STRUCTURE
165
FIQ.5. (a) The helical section a t the lower right of the nuclcase as seen from dircctly above. This section is from the high resolution map phased with both Ba" and I in the Type I1 crystal. The heaviest lines are meant to indicate the groups closest to the viewer. (b) The samc helical section a t high resolution but phased only with I in Type I1 crystals. (c) The same helical section a t 4 A resolution phased with both Ba2+and I in Type I1 crystals. (d) The same helical section a t 6 A resolution in Type I crystals phascd with three heavy-atom derivatives.
in Fig. 6 is justified. From its dimensions and amplitude distribution, the electron density seen in the pocket in Fig. 6b may be attributed to the pdTp molecule with the pyrimidine ring seen approximately edge-on in the upper part and the two phosphate groups nearly superposed in the lower part. This interpretation is strikingly and unequivocally confirmed by
166
F. A. COTTON AND E. E. HAZEN, JR.
FIG.6a.
the electron density contours shown in Fig. 7a ( 5 7 ) . These are in planes which are vertical and are viewed from the right side (directions relative to the canonical orientation of the molecule as defined earlier). According to the interpretation suggested for Fig. 6b, we should now be viewing the pdTp molecule approximately perpendicular to its mean plane. Figure 7b shows a space-filling model of pdTp, to the same scale as the electron density sections of Fig. 7a. It is clear that the pyrimidine ring of the pdTp lies within the pocket formed by the enzyme with the phosphate groups exposed to solution at the enzyme surface, the 3‘-phosphate toward the top, the 5’-phosphate toward the bottom, and very close to dead front-center of the model in Fig. l a . It does not appear to be possible to fit the inhibitor to the electron density maps with any significantly different orientation or configuration of the pdTp. The high resolution map has revealed the qualitative character of the binding of the pdTp and Ca2+,but the accurate fitting of map to model has, unfortunately, not proceeded quite far enough a t this writing to permit a quantitative discussion. The calcium ion is almost directly below the $-phosphate and is complexed by the carboxylate side chains of 57. The map in this figure was calculated with phases from both the Ba” and I substitutions. We show a very similar map in Fig. 6 of Arnone et al. (SO),but that one-the original view-was phased with a single I, indicating that useful inform:ition can be obtained from maps calculated with the aid of a single derivative.
7.
STAPHYLOCOCCAL NUCLEASE X-RAY STRUCTURE
167
FIQ.6. (a) Top view of the area of the pocket from the 4-A electron density map of the Type I crystals; X marks the position of the 5-methyl of pdTp in the Type I1 crystals. (b) Same view of the pocket area. but now the 4-A electron density map of the Type I1 (inhibitor complex) crystals. The phasing is based on a single I.
Asp 21, Asp 40, and Glu 43. However, it appears almost certain that the Ca‘+ is too far from the phosphate for even a weak electrostatic bonding, nor have we found any indication of a bridging water molecule in the electron density map. The 5’-phosphate interacts with the guanidinium terminus of Arg 35, which in turn also appears to interact with the peptide carbonyl group of Leu 36 and perhaps with the peptide carhonyl of Val 39. The guanidinium group of Arg 87 also interacts on one side with the 5’-phosphate and on the other side with the carboxylate side chain of Asp 83, which in turn may form a bond to the peptide nitrogen of Gly 86. There may also he interaction between the guanidinium group and the oxygen atom of the furanose ring of the deoxyribose. The T y r 113 ring plane is parallcl to thc pyrimidine ring of pdTp but probably too distant to warrant a postulate of any significant ring-ring interaction. However, it does appear that its phenolic hydroxyl group is in position to interact with the oxygen of the 5’-phosphate ester bond. The %-phosphate group appears definitely to interact with the phenolic hydroxyl group of T y r 85 and possibly, but less clearly, with the c-amino group of Lys 84. The lining of the pocket is formed by a complex intertwining of the
(b)
FIG.7. (a) View of the electron density map shown in Fig. 6b as if looking from the right side of the Styrofoam model of Fig. la, but looking only at the added electron density in the pocket region and on the left side of the pocket. I, determined position of the iodine atom in the crystals containing 5-iododeoxyuridine diphosphate analog of pdTp; B and R, the pyrimidine ring and deoxyribose moiety of pdTp, respectively. The positions of the 3’- and 5’-phosphates and the Ca2+ are also shown. T, a group thought a t the time to be the benzene ring of a tyrosine residue, later identified as Tyr 113. Again the heaviest lines are meant to show the nearest groups (67). (b) A space-filling model of pdTp.
7.
STAPHYLOCOCCAL NUCLEASE X-RAY STRUCTURE
(01
(b)
Fro. 8a and b.
169
170
F. A . COTTON A N D E. E. HAZEN, JR.
FIG.8c and d.
7.
STAPHYLOCOCCAL NCCLEASE X-RAY STRUCTURE
171
side chains of hydrophobic and neutral residues with the main peptide chain. The exception to this is Asp 83 lying on the upper right side, but this residue is tightly folded back along the main chain and probably has its charge partially neutralized by Arg 87. We must not fail to mention that the c-amino of Lys 71 from a neighboring nuclease molecule in the unit cell appears to interact with the 5’-phosphate. There is no wholly adequate substitute for a detailed study of the three-dimensional electron density map, but Figs. 8a-e show two-dimensional projections of interactions discussed above.
FIG.8. (a) The side view of the pdTp from the high resolution map, this time with the density associated with Tyr 113 omitted. R, deoxyribose; B, the pyrimidine ring. The labels indicate approximate position of the side chains of the indicated residues. (b) View of the pocket from the top in the plane of the calcium ion with the positions of some side chains indicated. Again the dark lines are densities nearest the eye. The depth of the section is 5.1 A. (c) View of the pocket from the top in the plane of the %-phosphate. The depth of the section is 5.1 A. (d) View of pocket from the top cut off just above the deoxyribose and below the 3’-phosphate. The depth of the section is 3.2 if. R, deoxyribose; B, the pyrimidine ring. (e) View of the pocket from the top running from just below the 3’-phosphate to the top of the enzyme molecule. The depth of the section is 3 8 A. B, top of the pyrimidine ring.
172
F. A. COTTON AND E. E. HAZEN, JR.
IV. Some Correlations with Studies in Solution
From differences between the spectral (29) and fluorescence (30)properties of the inhibited and uninhibited nuclease and from differences in the number of groups susceptible to acetylation (32) in the two forms of the enzyme, Cuatrecasas et al. (33) concluded that tyrosyl residues were involved in binding pdTp. This led them to some very interesting studies of the specific modification of certain tyrosyl residues with tetranitromethane and of the properties of these modified forms of the nuclease which we will discuss below in the context of this paper. Briefly, the pattern of relative reactivity was found to be Uninhibited nuclease: Tyr 85 >> 54 2 113 > 27 >> 115 Inhibited nuclease: Tyr 115 >> 54 2 113 >> 85 ‘v-27
Tyrosine 91 and 93 are not nitrated even a t high molar excess of reagent unless the enzyme is denatured. Tyrosine 85 and 115 are so highly reactive that it proved possible to isolate nuclease derivatives in which only Tyr 85 was nitrated (NT,,Nuc) or only T y r 115 was nitrated (NT,,,Nuc) and, by reduction, the corresponding aminotyrosine derivatives (AT,,Nuc and ATlISNuc). First of all let us deal with the question of the high reactivity of Tyr 85 in the uninhibited nuclease and of Tyr 115 in the inhibited. One of the characteristics of electron density maps of protein structures (and information that is not available in models) is that the clarity with which amino acid side chains can be seen varies considerably. Typically the poorly resolved side chains are charged and extend out from the molecular surface. In the high resolution structure (inhibited molecule) the side chains of Tyr 27, 91, 93, 85, and 113 are very well resolved, that of Tyr 54 is only slightly less clear, but that of Tyr 115 is very diffuse and apparently highly exposed, lying above and to the rear of Tyr 113 (see Figs. 8d and 8e for the positions of Tyr 113 and 115). Although we do not yet have a high resolution map of the uninhibited nuclease, it is plausible to suggest that here, with no 3’-phosphate group to which a hydrogen bond can be formed, Tyr 85 may be similarly highly exposed, lying as it does a t the tip of an exposed loop on the extreme top right front of the nuclease. Thus, the high reactivity of T y r 85 and 115 may be ascribed to their being very highly exposed. This view agrees well with the spectral and titration behavior observed in the above-cited paper. It is easy to see why Tyr 85 is unreactive in the inhibited nuclease; it is tightly hydrogen bonded to the 3’-phosphate of the pdTp. I n harmony
7. STAPHYLOCOCCAL NUCLEASE X-RAY
STRUCTURE
173
with this, it is found that NT8,Nuc has lost its enzymic activity and also binds 5’-AMP more weakly. Since 3-nitrotyrosine has a pK of 6.8 (58) and Tyr 85 can thus no longer form a good hydrogen bond to the 3‘phosphate a t p H values substantially above 6.8, the substrate can probably not be positioned in the active site correctly; consequently, the enzyme is no longer active ( 5 9 ) .I n ATg5Nucsome of the enzymic activity is restored which is consistent with a pK of the phenolic hydroxyl of 10 in 3-aminotyrosine (61). Incomplete restoration of activity in AT,,Nuc (and perhaps part of the loss of NT,,Nuc) can probably be ascribed to some sort of steric factor. The reduction of 5’-AMP binding is more difficult to explain, but since in NTlISNuc Tyr 85 is no longer easily nitratable, it is possible to postulate a hydrogen bond between T y r 115 and 85 when one or the other is nitrated, thus blocking access to the pocket. If our inference based on the 4-A maps of the Type I and Type I1 crystals (31) that in the uninhibited nuclease the side chains of T y r 113 and 115 are folded into the pocket is correct, it is possible to explain the resistance of T y r 115 to nitration. Indeed, if the peptide chain in this region pivots as we have surmised it does, then in the uninhibited nuclease the side chain of Tyr 115 should lie fairly deep within the pocket, conceivably in a position to bond to the carboxylate of Gln 80 or possibly that of Asp 83; Tyr 113 would be toward the front of the pocket and more accessible. NT,,,Nuc retains full activity toward DNA but loses about 50% of its activity toward RNA. The 2’-hydroxyl of ribonucleotides, if bound in the same stereochemistry (62) as pdTp, would be favorably situated for interaction with the side chain of T y r 115, such an interaction being enhanced by the low pK of a nitrotyrosyl 115 residue. In the high resolution structure, Tyr 91 and 93 are indeed “buried” deep in the hydrophobic area between the back wall of the pocket and the rear edge of the nuclease molecule. Tyrosine 27, which is more resistant to nitration in the inhibited nuclease, is probably hydrogen bonded to the carboxylate of Glu 10, partially shielded by the methylene chain of Lys 28, and, most importantly, at the rear upper right 58. J. F. Riordan, M. Sokolovsky, and B. L. Vallee, Biochemistry 6, 358 (1967).
59. The basic structural unit nerded for activity is R-pdT-R. R may be a free 3’-OH but a phosphate here markedly increases substrate binding. R may bc a p nitrophenyl group. The bond that is broken is the P-0 of the 5’-C-0-P ester linkage (60). 60. P. Cuatrecasas, M. Wilchek, and C. B. Anfinsen, Biochemistry 8, 2277 (1969). 61. M. Sokolovsky. J. F. Riordan, and B. L. Vallee, BBRC 27, 20 (1967). 62. Preliminary results with crystals containing 5’-AMP indicate that the binding positions are very similar.
174
F. A. COTTON AND E. E. HAZEN, JR.
corner of the molecule far from the binding site. 1t7e are looking forward to finding out whether this reactivity change results from a conformational change transmitted from the pocket through a mass of protein or whether T y r 27 is close to one of the other binding subsites that the work of Cuatrecasas et al. indicated are present (63). As recently discussed by Cuatrecasas, some of the work with affinity labels, which are based on modification of pdTp, supports the subsite hypothesis ( 6 4 ) . The hydrolysis of dinucleotides by the staphylococcal iiuclease hab been recently studied in Laskowski's laboratory ( 1 2 ) .In 12 dinucleotides of the type d-NapNflp the susceptibility to hydrolysis varied about 100fold and appeared t o depend primarily on the type of base in the /3 position. In addition, the corresponding d-NpN dinucleosidemonophosphates were more resistant to hydrolysis, and the pNpN 5'-phosphodinucleotides were most resistant of all. This work would appear to be consistent with our view of the pdTp binding site of the nuclease a t high resolution.
V. Some Tentative Comments on Mechanism and Plans for Future Studies
A. A WARNING I n our high resolution structure of the nuclease-pdTp-CaZt complex, we find but a single calcium ion. The gel filtration studies of pdTp and CaZt binding and of calcium binding to the nuclease in the presence of nucleic acid indicate that there are probably a t least two sites of binding (28). These findings are not necessarily inconsistent. They may merely reflect the fact that the crystals prefer t o grow under conditions different from those used for the binding studies. Further studies on this point are in order.
B. MECHANISM It would be attractive to speculate that as part of the enzymic reaction T y r 113 donated a proton to the 5'-phosphate ester bond (59). Since the enzyme is active when T y r 113 is nitrated (33) and thus almost certainly present as a phenolate ion a t the optimum pH, this idea 63. P. Cuatrecasas, M. Wilchek, and C. B. Anfinsen, Science 162, 1491 (19668) 64. P. Cuatrecasas, JBC 245, 574 (1970).
7.
STAPHYLOCOCCAL NUCLEASE X-RAY STRUCTURE
175
is doubtful. However, it is not unreasonable to think then in terms of a nuclcophilic attack or a stabilization of a transition state by this ionized tyrosine. Again, further discussion had best await further work.
C. PROPOSED FUTURE STUDIES Work is well under way on the high resolutioii structure of the uninhibited nuclease as are attempts to prepare crystals with other nioiio-, di-, and trinucleotidcs of various types so that more insight may be gained into the actual workings of the nucleasc. As described clscwhere in this volume ( 2 5 ) , some of the most exciting prospects for the future arc thc correlations to hc made t)ctn.cen the crystallographic studies of the threc-dimensional structure and the properties of the fragmented and synthetic versions of this nuclease.
Note: Viewer for color stereo figures can be found in back pocket. Green lens, right eye; red lens, left eye.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Staphylococcal Nuclease, Chemical Properties and Catalysis CHRISTIAN B. ANFINSEN HIROSHI TANIUCHI
PEDRO CUATRECASAS
I. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . 11. Isolation . . . . . . . . . . . . 111. Covalent Structure . . , . . . . . . IV. Behavior in Solution . . . . . . . . . V. Substrate Specificity and Catalytic Mechanisms . . . A. Polynucleotide Substrates . . . . . . B. Synthetic Substrates and Inhibitors . . . . C. Recapitulation-Size and Specificity of the Active Site VI. Stereochemical Probes of the Active Site . . . . VII. Complementation of Fragments . . . . . . VIII. Synthetic Analogs . . . . . , . .
.
.
.
. .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
177 178 180 183 185 185 187 191 195 196 199
1. Introduction
Staphylococcal nuclease was discovered by Cunningham and his colleagues in cultures of pathogenic strains of Staphylococcus aureus (1,8). It was the first nuclease to be found that yielded 3’-nucleotides upon hydrolysis of polynucleotide chains (3-16). Historically, this feature of 1. 2. 3. 4. 5.
L. Cunningham, B. W. Catlin, and M. Privat de Garilhe, JACS 78, 4642 (1956). L. Cunningham, Ann. N . Y . Acad. Sci. 81, 788 (1959). P. Cuatrecasas, S.Fuchs, and C. B. Anfinsen, JBC 242, 1541 (1967). K . K . Reddi, Nature 187, 74 (1960). K . K . Reddi, Nature 182, 1308 (1958). 177
178
C. B. ANFINSEN, P. CUATRECASAS, AND H. TANIUCHI
its catalytic action was of considerable use in the classic studies of Kornberg and his collaborators in the determination of nearest neighbor base frequencies in synthetic deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) ( 1 7 ) . A radioactive phosphorus atom esterified to the 5‘-OH group of deoxyATP, for example, would be located, after staphylococcal nuclcase digestion of the newly synthesized DNA, on the 3‘-mononucleotide, dXp, derived from the sequence dXpdA-. The enzyme has also h e n used extensively in studies on the elucidation of sequences of polynucleotidc chains (18). In addition to interest in this enzyme because of its catalytic characteristics, a considerable body of information has accumulated on staphylococcal nuclease as a protein molecule. I t s relatively small size, the absence of covalent cross-linkages, and its behavior upon binding a variety of ligands have made it an ideal model substance for the study of various aspects of protein chemistry including X-ray crystallography. These investigations are reviewed in the present chapter and in Chapter 7 by Cotton and Hazcn, this volume, on the thrce-dimcnsional structure (19). II. Isolation
Early studies on the purification of staphylococcal nuclease led to conflicting reports on whether the enzyme could hydrolyze both DNA ~~~
~
~
6. M. Privat de Garilhe, G. Fassina, F. Pochon, and J. Pillet, Bull. Sac. Chim. Biol. 40, 1905 (1958). 7. F. Pochon and M. Privat de Garilhe, Bull. Sac. Chim. B i d . 42, 795 (1960). 8. K. K. Reddi, BBA 36, 132 (1959). 9. K. K. Reddi, BBA 47, 47 (1961). 10. A. Ohsaka, J.-I. Mukai, and M. Laskowski, Sr., JBC 239, 3498 (1964). 11. M. Alexander, L. A . Heppel, and J. Hurwits, JBC 236, 3014 (1961). 12. G. W. Rushizky, C. A. Knight, W. K . Roberts, and C. A. Dekker, BBRC 2, 153 (1960). 13. E. Sulkowski and M. Laskowski, Sr., JBC 237, 2620 (1962). 14. W. K . Roberts, C. A. Dekker, G. W. Rushizky, and C. A. Knight, BBA 55, 664 (1962). 15. G. W. Rushizky, C. A. Knight, W. K. Roberts, and C. A . Dekker, BBA 55, 674 (1962). 16. R. Hacha and E. Frederico, BBA 123, 493 (1966). 17. J. Josse, A. D. Kaiser, and A. Kornberg, JBC 236, 864 (1961). 18. G. von Ehrenstein, in “Aspects of Protein Biosynthesis” (C. B. Anfinsen, ed.), p. 139. Academic Press, New York, 1970. 19. F. A. Cotton and E. E. Hazen, Chapter 7, this volume.
8.
STAPHYLOCOCCAL NUCLEASE
179
and ribonucleic acid (RNA). I t is now clear, however, that the cleavage of polynucleotides by nuclease is only quantitatively affected by the nature of the sugar moiety in the substrates ( 3 , 2 0 ) . The isolation of highly purified nuclease has also received special attention because of the desirability of having availahle, for polynucleotide sequence studies, enclonucleases free of phosphatase activity. When the enzyme is prepared from a crude ammonium sulfate fraetion by gradient elution from CM-cellulose columns, considerable levels of both acid and alkaline phosphatnse activities remain in the final product ( 2 1 ) . These activities may be removed by chromatography on phosphocellulose, on which the phosphatases are more highly retarded during elution with a salt and pH gradient ( 2 1 ) . The relative activities against RNA and DNA remain constant across the elution profile from both CM-cellulose and phosphocellulose, and this, together with other evidence described below, indicate that both activities result from a single species of enzyme molecule. Mikulski et 01. ( 2 2 ) have employed a combination of phosphocellulose chromatography and gel filtration in the final stages of an alternative preparation of phosphatase-free nuclease. The extremely high affinity of phosphocellulose for nuclease at pH values below 6.5 has formed the basis of a convenient method for the isolation of large amounts of enzyme from cultures of Staphylococcus aureus without the need for direct handling of this potentially dangerous pathogen ( 2 3 ) . The entire culture, in a 300-liter fermenter, is stirred with the cation exchanger a t pH 5.5-6.5 and, after the phosphocellulose with the attached nuclease has settled to the bottom and the supernatant fluid has been siphoned off, remaining bacterial cells may be removed by repeated suspension in distilled water. Subsequent purification to a state of homogeneity may then be carried out by gel filtration on Sephadex G-75 followed by phosphocellulose chromatography of an ammonium sulfate fraction of the total adsorbed protein, or on a smaller scale by the application of the principle of affinity chromatography using Sepharose-inhibitor columns ( 2 4 ) . 20. C. B. Anfinsen, M. K. Rumley, and H . Taniuchi, Acta Chem. Scand. 17, 270 (1963). 21. S. Fuchs, P. Cuatrecasas, and C. B. Anfinsen, JBC 242, 4768 (1967). 22. A . J. Mikulski, E. Sulkowski. L. Stasiuk, and M. Laskowski, Sr., JBC 244, 6559 (1969). 23. L. Morkvek, C. B. Anfinsen, J. L. Cone, and H. Taniuchi, JBC 249, 497 (1969). 24. P. Cuatrecasas, M. Wilchek. and C. B. Anfinsen, Proc. Nntl. Acad. S C ~u. . 61, 636 (1968).
s.
180
C. B. ANFINSEN, P. CUATRECASAS, AND H. TANIUCHI
111. Covalent Structure
Nuclease is composed of 149 amino acid residues, and contains neither sulfhydryl groups nor disulfide bonds (20, 25, 267. Figure 1 shows the amino acid sequence of nuclease isolated from Staphylococcus aureus, strain V8 (20, 25-27). Physical measurements of the molecular weight of nuclease from strain V8 as well as from strain “Foggi” are consistent with this sequence (28). The determination of the amino acid sequence of nuclease was approached by preparing large fragments by BrCN cleavage (29) and arranging the fragments in linear order (25). Nuclease contains four methionine residues and essentially quantitative cleavage of the methionine bonds by BrCN yields five fragments; [l-261, [27-321, [33-651, [66-981, and [99-1491 (the numbers in the brackets indicate the residues contained in the fragment). The COOH-termini of the first four 1
10
10
FIG.1. The amino acid sequence of nuclease V8 (25-2’7). Residue 43 is revised as glutamic acid (H. Taniuchi and C. B. Anfinsen, unpublished results; see also text). 25. H. Taniuchi and C . B. Anfinsen, JBC 241, 4366 (1966). 26. H. Taniuchi, C. B. Anfinsen, and A. Sodja, JBC 242, 4736 and 4752 (1967). 27. H. Taniuchi, C. L. Cusumano, C. B. Anfinsen, and J. L. Cone, JBC 243, 4775 (1968).
28. F. A. Cotton, E. E. Hazen, Jr., and D. C. Richardson, JBC 241, 4389 (1966). 29. E. Gross and B. Witkop, JBC 237, 1856 (1962).
8.
STAPHYLOCOCCAL NUCLEASE
181
peptides are, of course, homoserine or the lactone form of this amino acid. Separation of the BrCN fragments was best achieved by gel filtration on a long column of Sephadex G-50 (25) with further separation of [ 1-26] and [ 33-65] by continuous flow electrophoresis. Each cyanogen bromide fragment was digested with trypsin and the tryptic peptides were fractionated by ion exchange chromatography on a Dowex 50 column, using gradient elution with pyridinium acetate buffer (30). Further purification of these tryptic peptides was performed by paper chromatography, paper electrophoresis, or the combination of these two methods (two-dimensional peptide mapping) (31). Four tryptic peptides containing intact methionine residue were obtained from the tryptic digest of intact nuclease. Amino acid analysis (32) and NH?-terminus determination by the dinitrofluorobenzene method of the BrCN fragments, the tryptic peptides obtained from the BrCN fragments and the four from native nuclease provided the information required to deduce the linear arrangement of the BrCN fragments ( 2 5 ) . The tryptic peptides of the BrCN fragments were sequenced by Edman degradation using the subtractive method (33) together with identification of the phenyl thiohydantoins (PTH) of the amino acids (34, 3 5 ) . Amide groups were determined by examining the electrophoretic mobility, a t pH 6.5, of peptides on paper or by digesting peptides with leucine aminopeptidase followed by amino acid analysis. Ascending paper chromatography with 80% pyridine as solvent was sometimes used to separate glutamine or asparagine released by leucine aminopeptidase. The collidine-ninhydrin reagent stains glutamine and asparagine differentially (36). Arrangement in order of tryptic peptides derived from the BrCN fragments was based on the structures of overlapping chymotryptic peptides, which were separated and partially sequenced in a manner similar to that described above (26). Residues 30 and 31, glutamine and proline, respectively (27), were originally assigned in the reversed order on the basis of partial removal of residue (homoserine) from cyanogen bromide fragment [ 27-32] by carboxypeptidase A ( 2 6 ) . The action of the latter is generally as30. R. E. Canfield and C. B. Anfinsen, JBC 238, 2684 (1963). 31. A. Katz, W. J. Dreyer, and C. B. Anfinsen, JBC 234, 2897 (1959). 32. D. H. Spackman, S. Moore, and W. H. Stein, Anal. Chem. 30, 1190 (1958). 33. C. H. W. Hirs, S. Moore, and W. H. Stein, JBC 235, 633 (1960). 34. P. Edrnan and J. Sjoquist, Acta Chem. Scand. 10, 1507 (1956). 35. H. 0. Van Orden and F. H. Carpenter, BBRC 14, 399 (1964). 36. R. E. Canfield and C. B. Anfinsen, in “The Proteins” (H. Neurath. ed.), Vol. 1, p. 311. Academic Press, New York, 1963.
182
C. B. A N F I N S E N , P. CUATRECASAS, AND H. T A N I U C H I
sumed to be effectively blocked by a proline residue, though the ahsumption is not always valid (37). Glutamic acid (see the legend to Fig. 1) was originally proposed as glutamine on the basis of apparent ncutrality during electrophoresis a t pH 6.5 of tryptic peptide 136-45 I (26). The unusual array of four hydrophobic residues (leucincs 36, 37, and 38 and valine 39) caused serious tailing of the spot on paper during paper electrophoresis, giving an ambiguous mobility. Removal of the four hydrophobic residues by leucine aminopeptidase from peptide [ 36-45 yielded peptide [40-45] with an unequivocal acidic mobility (38). The amino acid sequence of nuclease Foggi was also studied because this strain, Staphylococcus aui-eus, yields much more nuclease in culture (23, 3 9 ) . The close similarity of the covalent structures of nuclease V8 and Foggi was early indicated by immunological studies (%‘I), physicochemical characterization (40), amino acid analysis, and the two-dimensional peptide map of tryptic digests ( 4 1 ) . The availability of substantial quantity of nuclease Foggi was fundamental in the carcful reexamination of ambiguous points of amino acid sequcncc as described above and for the structural and functional studies of nuclease, including X-ray crystallography. Elucidation of the amino acid sequence of nuclcase Foggi was approached in the same manner as that of nuelease V8. Two fragmcnts (residues 6-48 and 49-149) obtained by the limited trypsiii digestion (see below) of nuclease were also used to make cyanogen bromide fragments. The sequential Edman-dansyl chloride method (42) was mainly employed for rapid sequencing of tryptic peptides (41) instead of the subtractive Edman method or PTH-amino acid identification. The amino acid sequences of nuclease V8 (Fig. 1) and Foggi (41, 43) arc the same with the exception of residue 124, which is leucine in V8 (26) and histidine in Foggi nuclease (41). Replacement of leucine 124 by a histidine residue appears to have no effect on the structure and function of the enzyme (27, 28, 40). A methionine auxotroph (M-) of Staphylococcus aureus also appears to yield nuclease with a covalent structure similar to that of nuclease 37. J. I. Harris and C. H. Li, JBC 213, 499 (1955). 38. H. Taniuchi and C. B. Anfinsen (see reference 4 3 ) . 39. J. N. Heins. H. Taniuchi, and C. B. Anfinsen, in “Methods in Nucleic Acid Rcsearch” (J. Cantoni and D. Davies, eds.), p. 79. Harper, New York, 1966. 40. J. N. Heins, J. R. Suriano, H . Taniuchi, and C. B. ilnfinsen, JBC‘ 242, 1016
(1967). 41. C. I,. Cusumano. H. Taniuchi, and C. R. Anfinsen, JBC 243, 4769 (1968). 42. W. R. Gray, “Methods in Enzymology,” Vol. 11, p. 139, 1967. 43. J. L. Cone, C. L. Cusumano, H. Taniuchi, and C. B. Anfinsen, JBC (it1 prcsd (1971).
8.
STAPHYLOCOCCAL NUCLEASE
183
V8, as indicated by two-dimensional peptide maps of tryptic digests (44). It appears, therefore, that various strains of S. aureus produce a major extracellular nuclease with covalent structures extremely similar to that of nuclease V8. Staphylococcus aureus has been reported, however, to produce several minor extracellular nucleases with different isoionic points and heat stabilities ( 4 5 ) . The covalent structures of these materials have not been studied.
IV. Behavior in Solution
Nuclease behaves like a typical globular protein in aqueous solution when examined by classic hydrodynamic methods (40) or by measurements of rotational relaxation times for the dimethylaminonaphthalene sulfonyl derivative ( 4 6 ) . Its intrinsic viscosity, approximately 0.025 dl/g is also consistent with such a conformation. Measurements of its optical rotatory properties, either by estimation of the Moffitt parameter O,,,or the mean residue rotation at 233 nm, indicate that approximately 1518% of the polypeptide backbone is in the a-helical conformation (47, 4 8 ) . A similar value is calculated from circular dichroism measurements (48). These estimations agree very closely with the amount of helix actually observed in the electron density map of nuclease, which is discussed in Chapter 7 by Cotton and Hazen, this volume, and Arnone et al. ( 4 9 ) . One can state with some assurance, therefore, that the structure of the average molecule of nuclease in neutral, aqueous solution is a t least grossly similar to that in the crystalline state. As will be discussed below, this similarity extends to the unique sensitivity to tryptic digestion of a region of the sequence in the presence of ligands (47, 48), which can easily be seen in the solid state as a rather anomalous protrusion from the body of the molecule (19,4 9 ) . When the protein is exposed to pH values below 3.5-3.7, temperatures 44. C. B. Anfinsen and L. G . Corley, JBC 244, 5139 (1969). 45. T. Wadstrom. B B A 147, 441 (1967). 46. P. Cuatrecasas, H. Edelhoch. and C. 13. Anfinsen, Proc. N u l l . Acntl. Sca. U . S. 58, 2043 (1967). 47. H. Taniuchi, C. 13. Anfinsen. and A. Sodja, PTOC.&'all. Acod. Sci. c'. S. 58, 1235 (1967). 48. H. Taniuchi and C. B. Anfinsen, JBC 243, 4778 (1968). 49. A. Arnone, C. J. Bier, F. A . Cotton. E. E. Hmen. D. C. Richardson, nnd J . S. Richardson, Proc. Nntl. Acad. Sci. U . S.69, 420 (1969) ; see also Chapter 7, this volume.
184
C. B. ANFINSEN, P. CUATRECASAS, AND H. TANIUCHI
in the range of 55”-65”, high concentrations of urea, guanidinium chloride, and certain organic solvents, it rapidly unfolds. This denaturation is completely reversible. Measurements of the rate of refolding of nuclease by stopflow measurements of the enhancement of tryptophan fluorescence after changing the pH from 3.4 to 6.5 indicate that most of the refolding process takes place with a half-time of about 45 msec, with a somewhat slower secondary “readjustment” process having a halftime of about 200 msec (50). Hydrodynamic, spectroscopic, and optical rotatory methods can “see” only the average molecule and a fraction of the population as large as 5 or 10% that differs significantly in shape might not be detected. On the other hand, measurements of hydrogen exchange, or of susceptibility to proteolysis of proteins in a relatively infrequent, transient state of partial denaturation, would detect such deviant molecules. Although native nuclease, like most proteins in solution, behaves, on the average, as though all the molecules were globular, this phenomenon of motility becomes apparent when the protein is examined by such “historical” methods. The exchangeable hydrogen atoms of nuclease can be shown to be completely susceptible a t room temperature to equilibrium with the hydrogen atoms of the aqueous solvent in one hour or less (51, 5 6 ) . Variations in the structure of the protein must therefore permit the rapid entrance and exit of bulk solvent during the extremely brief deviations from the rather tightly packed geometry indicated by the crystallographic studies. This interpretation is supported by the ligand-induced resistance to hydrogen exchange. When pdTp and calcium ions are present, approximately 35 hydrogen atoms become inaccessible to solvent for many hours in spite of the fact that only a slight and localized change in structure can be detected crystallographically (see Chapter 7 by Cotton and Hazen, this volume) in the nuclease-pdTp-Ca2+ complex. The results indicate that infrequent unfolding and refolding must be occurring in the native protein in solution and that only when the structure is “rigidified” by ligand addition is this motility suppressed. Similar conclusions may be reached from the study of the ligandinduced resistance to proteolysis (47, 5 3 ) , a phenomenon that has been employed in the production of large complementing fragments of nuclease (see below). 50. A. N. Schcchter, R. F. Chen, and C. B. Anfinsen, Science 167, 886 (1970). 51. A. N. Schechter, L. MorBvek, and C. B. Anfinsen, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. u. s. 61, 1478 (1968). 52. A. N. Srhechter, L. Morivek, and C. B. Anfinsen, JBC 244, 4981 (1969). 53. H. Taniuchi, L. Morivek, and C. B. Anfinsen, JBC 244, 4600 (1969).
8.
STAPHYLOCOCCAL
NUCLEASE
185
V. Substrate Specificity and Catalytic Mechanisms
A. POLYNUCLEOTIDE SUBSTRATES 1. Specificity
Staphylococcal nuclease is a phosphodiesterase which can cleave either DNA or RNA to produce 3’-phosphomononucleosides (3-16, 2 0 , 2 5 ) . The rates of hydrolysis of these substrates are dependent on the conformation of the substrate, Ca2+concentration, and the ionic strength and the pH of the buffer ( 3 , 5 4 ) . Denatured D N A is hydrolzed more rapidly than native DNA ( 3 , 12, 64-56), which reflects the important effect of substrate conformation on catalysis. I n native DNA the X p d T p and X p d A p bonds are preferentially attached (7, 12, 14, 15, 5 5 ) . With denatured D N A the order of cleavage appears to be nearly random (14, 15, 56, 57‘).The Xp-dCp and Xp-dGp linkages in the helical regions of DNA, which are more cxtensively stabilized, are more resistant to hydrolysis. The specific order of release of various mononucleotides from native compared to denatured DNA suggests that in the hydrolysis of D N A specificity toward the constitutent bases is less important than the substrate conformation (64-57). The mechanism of catalysis of macromolecular substrates is relatively complicated. The initial phases of digestion arc predominantly ( 4 , 8, 13, 58, 69),but not exclusively ( 1 1 , 58, 5 9 ) , endonucleolytic. These initial cleavages are probably followed by exonucleolytic cleavages of the same strand ( 5 9 ) . Subsequent scission of the exposed single-stranded region occurs, followed by unwinding of the region proximal to the scission. These interpretations are consistent with the marked changes in hyperchromicity, and the low di- to mononucleotide ratio, in the initial phases of digestion when the principal products are mononucleotides and long fragments (59). The cleavage pattern becomes progressively exonucleolytic as the reaction progresses, becoming principally exonucleolytic on the hexanucleotide level ( 1 1 , 13, 6 0 ) . Exhaustive digestion of deoxyribopolynucleotide substrates results in the release of 3’-mono54. E. Sulkowski and M. Laskowski, Sr., JBC 243, 4917 (1968). 55. M. I,. Dirksen and C. A. Dekker, BBRC 2, 147 (1960). 56. P. H. von Hippel and G . Felsenfeld, Biochemistry 3, 27 (1964). 57. L. Wingert and P. H. von Hippel, BBA 157, 114 (1968). 58. E. J. Williams, S. C. Sung, and M. Laskowski, Sr., JBC 236, 1130 (1961). 59. E. Sulkowski and M. Laskowski, Sr., JBC 244, 3818 (1969). 60. M. de Meuron-Landolt and M . Privat de Garilhe, BBA 91, 433 (1964).
186
C. B. ANFINSEN, P . CUATRECASAS, AND H . TANIUCHI
nucleotides, dinucleotides, and a 3,5’-nucleosidediphospliatc (the left tcrminus) (10, 11, 2 2 ) . Contrary to early reports (11, 13, 59),dinucleotides can be hydrolyzed by micrococcal nuclense (22, 61). No hydrolysis of 2’,3’-cyclic phosphate esters has been observed (11), and no evidence exist$ to suggest that the mechanism of hydrolysis proceeds through cyclic phosphate intermediates. Enzymic activity is inhibited by oligonucleotides or ~ i ~ o ~ i o ~ i ~ ~ c l e o t i c l e ~ bearing 5’-phosphate end groups (3, 11). The presence of a 3’-phosphate end group enhances hydrolysis of the adj accnt internucleotide bond in oligonucleotides (11, 22) and synthetic substrates (61). The enzyme shows preference for adenine and thymine over cytosine and guanine, as judged by (1) the rate of inononuclcotide release from I)NA, polynucleotidcs, and oligonucleotides (1, 10, 11, 13); ( 2 ) the pattern of hydrolytic susceptibility of oligo- and dinucleotides (11, 13, 22) ; and (3) the binding affinities of 5’-mononucleotides (61). 2. Kinetic Measurements The rate of hydrolysis of DNA, RNA, and polynucleotides can be measured by a sensitive spectrophotometric assay which is based on the hyperchromicity that occurs upon hydrolysis of these substrates (3). The enzyme has a 7-fold greater affinity for denatured D N A than for RNA (3).No inhibitory products accumulate during the course of the reaction. The p H optimum for RNase and DNase activities is between 9 and 10, depending on the Caz+concentration. At higher pH values less Ca2+is required. The inhibitory effect of high Ca2+observed consistently by many investigators is more pronounced a t higher pH values ( 3 ) . Enzymic activity appears to be completely dependent on the presence of Caz+ (1, 3, 4, 6, 11). There are no significant changes i n Ca‘+ requirements when the amounts of DNA or RNA are varied, suggesting that Ca2+is not primarily involved in producing conformational changes in the substrate. This is consistent with the observation that Ca2+ is required for the binding of nucleotide inhibitors to the enzyme active site. This has been confirmed by direct physical measurements (62) and by changes in the ultraviolet spectra (6S), fluorescence emission spectra (46), circular dichroic spectra ( 6 4 ) , and antigenic reactivity (6‘6) 61. P. Cuatrecasas, M . Wilchek, and C. B. Anfinsen, Biochemistry 8, 2277 (1969). 62. P. Cuatrecasas, S. Fuchs, and C. B. Anfinsen, JBC 242, 3063 (1967). 63. P. Cuatrecasas, S. Fuchs, and C. B. Anfinsen, JBC 242, 4759 (1967). 64. G. S. Omenn, P. Cuatrecasas, and C. B. Anfinsen, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. 64, 923 (1969). 65. S. Fuchs, P. Cuatrecasas, D. A. Ontjes, and C. B. Anfinsen, JBC 244, 943
(1969).
8.
STAPHYLOCOCCAL NUCLEASE
187
which occur upon binding of thesc inhibitors to the cnzyinically activr site. The location of a tightly bound Ca"+ (or Ba'+) i i i crystallinr nucleasr has also been detcrmined hy crystallographic methods ( 1 9 , 4 9 ) . Considerable DNase but no RNasc activity rcsults if CaS+is replaced by S f + , while Fe"+ and Cu"+ causc minimal activation ( 3 , 4 0 ) . A number of heavy metal cations inhibit DKase and RNasc activities competitivcly with Ca"; Hg", Zn2+,and Cd" are the most potent of thesc (3). Studies with synthetic substrates, to be discussed below, indicatc that Ca'+ is not only required for the proper lincliiig of substrates but also that it is required for thc sul)scqucnt independent hydrolytic process. Although several divalent cations can substitute for Ca2+ in the binding function, as evidenced hy their competitive inhibition of enzymic activity ( 3 ) and their ability to promote nuclcotitle binding ( 6 2 ) , the catalytic role of Ca'+ appears to be unique.
B. SYNTHETIC SUBSTRATES AND INHIBITORS 1. Specificity Studies of the cleavage patterns ant1 kinetic constants of a number of synthetic, low molecular weight substrates intlicatc that the basic structural element required for recognition a s substrate (R-pdN-R') (65a) need not be part of a polynucleotide chain ( T a b l e I ) (61). Cleavage of compounds of the general class R-pdTp-R' result in the release of R phosphate and dTp-R' (61). Hydrolysis occurs irrespective of the size of the substrate since it appears that the nature of the R group is unimportant as long as a dicster bond is present and since substitution of the 3'-OH is not required to achieve the maximal rate of catalysis (61). Cleavage occurs rapidly with compounds having as the R group a p aminophenyl, p-nitrophenyl, or methyl substituent. Although it is not known whether the base is an essential feature of a substrate, the nucleoside moiety is necessary since bis- and tris-pnitrophenyl phosphate esters are not hydrolyzed (61). The nature of the R' substitution on the 3'-OH clearly affects the affinity of the substrate or inhibitor for the enzyme, even though it does not affect the maximal catalytic rate constant (Table I). The importance of the 5'- and 3'phosphate groups in determining the affinity of inhibitors (3, 66) is consistent with the contribution of these groups to substrate affinity ( 6 1 ) . These effects result from the phosphoryl groups themselves rather than 65a. Here N stands for nuclcoside.
66. 1'. Cuatrecasas, H. Taniuchi, and C. B. Anfinsen, Brookhaven S y m p . B i d . 21, 172 (1969).
188
C. B . ANFINSEN, P . CUATRECASAS, AND H . TANIUCHI
TABLE I SYNTHKTIC SUI3STRATI~:S A N D INHInITORS O F STAPHYLOCOCCAL NUCLEASIP Kcat
Compound Ni tropheiiyl-pdl’ 3‘-0Acetyliii trophenyl-pd‘l’ Ni trophenyl-pdTp Ni trophenyl-pdTpnitrophenyl Nitrophenyl-pdTpdT Nitrophenyl-pdTpdTpnitrophenyl Ni trophenylpdTpmet hyl Aminopheny 1-pdT Met,hyl-pdTpni trophenyl Fluoro-pdT dTp-Nitrophenyl 5’-Sulfate-dTpni trophenyl 5'-O- Acetyl-dTpnitrophenyl 5’-Chloromethyl-pdTpnitrophenyl dTp-Fluoro PdT PdTP Sulfate-dT-sulfate pdTp-N itrophenyl pdTp-Aminophenyl PdTpdT
K,,,,, (M) (min-’) 2 . 2 x 10-3 2 . 1 x 10-3
9.1 9.2
1.0 x 4 . 2 x 10-3 6 . 4 x 10-3 1.7 X 9 . 6 X lo-‘ 4.6 x 5 . 9 x 10-5
10.6 10.5 0.1 9.3 10.2 0.03 10.9
Kib ( M )
Groiip released
Nitrophenyl phosphate Nitrophenyl phosphate Nitrophenyl Nitrophenyl Ni trophenol Nitrophenyl Nitropherryl Ni trophenol Nitrophenyl
phosphate phosphate phosphate phosphat,e phosphate
1.3 X
0.08
2 . 2 x 10-2 5.9 x 10-3
0.7 1.9
Aminophenyl phosphate Methyl phosphate Ni trophen ol Fluorophosphate Ni trophenol Nitrophenol
x
0.7
Ni trophenol
0.4
Nitrophenol
2.1
1 .7 X
10-3
10-
x 2.0 x 1.9
1.1 x 1.0 x 6.3 x
lo-‘ lo-’ 10-3 10-6 10-6 10-7
a All the values were determined in 0.05 M borate buffer (pH 8.8) and 10 mM Ca2+as described by Cuatrecasas et al. (61). Inhibition was competitive in all cases. Data from Cuatrecasas et al. (61).
from alteration or elimination of the free hydroxyl groups, since 0-acetyl substitution does not substantially affect the kinetic constants obtained with the substituted derivatives (Table I) (61). Apart from important similarities in the endo- and exonucleolytic properties of staphylococcal nuclease and other well-studied phosphodiesterases ( 6 7 ) ,those from snake venom and spleen, the basic structural substrate elements for these enzymes appear to be quite different 67. H. G. Khorana, “The Enzymes,” Vol. 5, p. 79, 1961.
8.
189
STAPHYLOCOCCAL NUCLEASE
(Fig.2). The staphylococcal enzyme may appear to be more akin in its mode of action to the spleen enzyme because they both hydrolyze DNA and RNA to 3’-nucleotides, whereas the venom enzyme releases 5’-nucleotides. However, their mode of action and specificity are quite different, and the structural requirements of the staphylococcal enzyme substrates are perhaps more nearly similar to those of the venom enzyme. The principal difference is that the staphylococcal enzyme cleaves the diester bond between the phosphate and the 5’-carbon of the sugar, whereas the venom enzyme cleaves on the other side of the phosphate, that is, between the phosphate and the nonspecific hydroxylic component of the diester bond. In contrast to both spleen and venom diesterases, the primary product released by staphylococcal nuclease hydrolysis is a derivative bearing a hydroxyl group (on the 5’ position) rather than a phosphoryl group. Therefore, the 3’-phosphoryl product formed from polynucleotide hydrolysis is a secondary consequence of such cleavage.
1
j
I
I R ’ O $ Y - O - c O
I I
I I
! 0I I I I
I OH
I
I I
I
i
1
0
I
o=~-o’
I I I I
.-.-.-<-.-.-.-.-. (C)
FIG.2. Proposed structural requirements for substrates of phosphodiesterases that hydrolyze DNA and RNA, those from (a) snake venom, (b) spleen. and (c) staphylococcus (R = thymine and R = p-nitrophenyl). The studies indicated for the venom and spleen enzymes are those suggested by Khorana (67) [data from Cuatrecasas et al. (61)l.
190
C. B. ANFINSEN, P. CUATRECASAS, AND H. TANIUCHI
2. Kinetic Measurements
Above pH 6 the release of p-nitrophenyl phosphate from synthetic substrates (Table I) results in a shift in the ultraviolet spectrum of the chromophore which may be followed spectrophotometrically (Fig. 3 ) . This forms the basis for a sensitive and convenient assay of this enzyme (61). Perhaps the substrate best suited for routine assay of enzymic activity is nitrophenyl-pdTp, since it has highly favorable kinetic constants. The dependence of the kinetic constants (Table I) upon the concentration of Ca2+,pH, and ionic strength is not the same for all the synthetic substrates shown on Table I. In general, however, with all these substrates the maximal velocities are achieved between pH 9 and 11, maximal affinity for substrate occurs between pH 7.5 and 8.5 (Fig. 4 ) , and inhibition of enzymic activity is observed with NaCl concentrations greater than 0.1 N . Similar dependence upon these parameters is seen when activities are measured with DNA and RNA (3). Various kinetic studies indicate that the K , values measured with the synthetic substrates are true dissociation constants Ks. Furthermore, the Ki constants of these substrates, obtained from their inhibition of DNase
240
260
280
300
320
340
360
380
400
X (mp)
FIG.3. Ultraviolet spectral changes resulting from hydrolysis of nitrophenylpdTp-nitrophenyl (32 p M ) by staphylococcal nuclease (14 p M ) . Thc spectrum a t zero time is that of the mixture of enzyme and substrate before addition of Ca". The reaction is started by addition of Ca'+ (10 mM) ; by 3 min the reaction is cornplete. Data from Cuatrecasas et al. (61).
8.
191
STAPHYLOCOCCAL NUCLEASE I
I
I
I
I
I
Molecular ionization Constants
5 -
2a 4 3 -
I
~ K E ,
7.0
PKE~
8.6
Km
I
1
I
I
I
I
6
7
8
9
10
II
PH
FIG.4. Dependenw of K , , , , and K,* on pH for the clcavagc of thr synthetic substrate nitrophenyl-pdTp by staphylococcal nuclcasc. Assays wcre prrforincd in 0.05 M borate buffer, 0.015 M C a C L
activity, are identical with the K,,,,,,, values derived from their hydrolysis. This suggests that these substrates are specifically bound to the same region of the enzyme which binds and hydrolyzes DNA. As with DNA and RNA (S), substrate affinity depends upon the Ca"+ concentration. The lowest li,,,, for nitrophenyl-pdTp-nitrophenyl occurs a t mM Ca'+, but for nitrophenyl-pdTp it is 2.5 iriM Ca2+.Apart directly (Fig. 4) ; maxitnal from its effect on K,", Ca2+increases the effects are observed with about 0.1 ill Ca"+. Again in analogy with studies using DNA and RNA (S), all the synthetic substrates show an apparent inhibition of activity when the conccntration of Ca'+ is raised above 0.05 M . This effect is solely the result of an increase in li, (Fig. 5 ) .
C. RECAPITULATION-SIZE ASD SPECIFICITY OF T H E ACTIVESITE The data available from studies of the actioii of nucleabe on synthetic substrates, oligonucleotidcs, and natural polynucleotidcs are consistent with the following generalizations and simplifications. I t appcars that
192
C. B. ANF INS E N, P. CUATRECASAS, AND H. TA N I U C H I
LOQ
[ca'']
I'Ic. 5 . Dcl)endrncc of kinetic constants on Ca'+ conccntratlon for t hr c1cnr:igi~ of p-nitroplienyl-pTpT by staphylococcal nuclrnse. Data from Cuatrccisas et ol.
(GI).
the basic structural clement of substrate specificity is R-pN, with relcasc of Rp upon hydrolysis. Thc nature of R is cssentially unimportant with regard to specificity. The affinity for substrates and inhibitors is affected by the size, charge, and nature of the substituent on the 3'-OH. Study TABLE I1 BINHING CONSTAHTS OF OI,IGON~:CI.~~OTII,IC-NUCLIEAS~~ COMPLEXES Dissociation constant"
AFob
(M1
(cal/mole)
1 . 9 x 10-4 6 . 3 x 10-7 9 . 3 x 10-8
-4,400 -8,500 -10,000 -9,500
Nucleotide
1.I 1.4 G.o 2.0 1.1 1.7
x x x x x x
10-7
10-7
-9,400
10-7
-8 ,,500
10-7
-9,000 -8,100 -6,500
10-6 10-5
K , obtaiiied by Dixon plots (Fig. 1 ) ; the value for N1'-pdTp-NP is Kn,(approximately), obtained from Liiicweaver-Burk plots under identical experimental conditions. AF" = ky' 111 K,. c p-Nitropheiiyl phosphate (NI') esters. Data from Cuatrecasas t l ul. (68). 68. P. Cuatrrcasns, M. Wilchek, and C. B. Anfinscn. Science 162, 1491 (1969)
8.
193
STAPHYLOCOCCAL NUCLEASE
.
of the dissociation constants of a progressively longer series of 5’phosphoryl oligothymidyl inhibitors (pdT) indicate that the optimal stability of the enzyme-nucleotide complex occurs with approximately a trinucleotide sequence (Table 11) (68).It can be postulated that three unequal phosphate binding “subsites,” principally electrostatic in nature, exist in the substrate binding region of the enzyme (Fig. 6) (68). The most important site is thought to coincide with the hydrolytic site, and the other two are presumed to exist to the “right” of this hydrolytic site. I n the case of inhibitors, the free 5’-phosphoryl group, owing to its strong anionic charge and properly placed adjacent nucleoside, is recognized by the hydrolytic region. I n this case [ (pdT).], nucleotide units other than that bearing the 5’-phosphoryl group are considered to be to the “right” of the hydrolytic site and would be expected to contribute principally to the affinity constant. The rationalization can then be made in the case of substrates so that R-pdTp-R’ derivatives, unlike the inhibitors, possess a cleavable phosphodiester bond on the 5’ position and will thus release Rp upon hydrolysis. The R’ group, as in the case of the 5’-phosphoryl group of inhibitors, should contribute solely in terms of affinity. As with the K , values of inhibitors, the K , values of substrates are very sensitive to the addition of ionic phosphate groups to the “right” of the hydrolyzable bond. Furthermore, in contrast to the K,,, constants, the Kcatconstants of the various deoxythymidyl 5’-phosphate ester substrates are essentially identical. These considerations are consistent with the observation that 5’phosphoryl oligo- and mononucleotides are inhibitory (3, 1 1 ) , that the presence of a 3’-phosphate end group enhances cleavage of the adjacent bond of dinucleotides and oligonucleotides (11, 2 2 ) , and that endonucleolytic cleavage will readily occur in relatively random fashion in large oligonucleotides and polynucleotides. Although the contribution of the purine and pyrimidine bases is considered to be relatively minor compared to the electrostatic effects of the phosphates, the enzymic subsites must clearly be able to preferentially distinguish and discriminate the various bases. For example, Mikulski et al. have shown that the nature of the base in the /3 position exerts a dominant role in the susceptibility of hydrolysis of dinucleotides; a clear preference is demonstrated for A and T ( 2 2 ) . Also consistent with this are the observations that 5‘-mononucleotide binding shows a clear preference for A and T (3,6 S ) , that poly A is more rapidly hydrolyzed than poly C or poly U (S), and that T p are preferentially released during the early phases of RNA and DNA hydrolysis. For simplification, the scheme shown in Fig. 5 does not take into account the essential role of Ca2+in binding and hydrolysis of substrates and inhibitors. Complex formation with possibly several side chain car-
194
C. B. ANFINSEN, P . CUATRECASAS, AND H. TANIUCHI
35%
4
-20
r--
0
-
Nuclease 30 A x 3 0 i x 4 0 i
T
B
*
A
T
T
B
(C)
FIG.6. Schematic: representation of (a) complex formation brtwrrn stalh,~.loc~occal nucleasc and polynucleotide substrates ; ( b ) inhibitory oligonuclrotid(ss h i r i n g 5’-phosphoryl termini ; and (c) a slowly hydrolyzrd 3 ’ - ~ ~ h o s ~ 1 l i o r ~ l o l i g o n ~ i ~ ~ l ~ ~ o t i d r . XpYpZp. The major substrate binding rrgions of the enzyme, or “phosphatr subsites,” are indicated as P1, P2,and P3. The hydrolytic site (H) consists of a rcgion closely related to P1 which recognizes the phospliodirster bond ( A ) :inti a rrgion which recognizes the sugar-base moiety whose 5’-OH is linked to the phosphatc group (B).
8.
STAPHYLOCOCCAL NUCLEASE
195
boxyl groups, and possibly phosphate groups, are strongly suggested by the three-dimensional structure (see section below on synthetic analogs).
VI. Stereochemical Probes of the Active Site
Some information concerning the stereochemical orientation of active site residues in the solution state has been obtained by affinity labeling studies using broinoacetarnidophenyl ( 6 9 ) and diazoniuin (70) derivainhibitors. tives of p-aniiiio~~liciiylnuclcotide The tyrosyl residue a t position 115, which can be specifically modified with tetranitromethane in the presence of pdTp and Ca'+ ( 7 l ) ,is labeled selectively with affinity labeling reagents derived from pdTp-aminophenyl (6'9). The bromoacetyl reagent derived from this inhibitor also reacts specifically with lysines 48 and 49 and with histidine 46. These results suggest that there may be some flexibility in the 46-49 region of the protein, and that this region as well as that of tyrosine 115 must be near the active site. The selective cleavage of the 4%49 region by trypsin in the presence of pdTp and Ca2+ (48) is also consistent with these observations. X-Ray crystallographic analysis of this protein indicates that the three-dimensional structure of the active site permits precise attachment of the alkylating and diazonium reagents to the hydroxyl and ortho carbons, respectively, of tyrosine 115 ( 4 9 ) .Furthermore, a peptide loop containing residues 46 through 49 lies near the binding site. The catalytically essential nature of tyrosine 85 and its proximity to the substrate binding site and to tyrosine 115 were demonstrated from studies of modification with tetranitromethane (7f) and from studies of intramolecular cross-linking of aminotyrosyl residues ( 7 2 ) . The bromoacetamidophenyl (69) and diazonium (70) reagents obtained from aminophenyl-pdT both react selectively and exclusively with tyrosine 85. This residue is situated, stereochemically, such that its hydroxyl group can interact with the 3'-phosphate of pdTp. The regions of residues 46-49 and of tyrosine 115 must be located in the section of the binding site which intcracts with that part of the substrates or inhibitors extending to the 3'-carbon side of the basic structural element, R-dpT. This region is probably of importance in the binding function of the enzyme. More exact correlation of affinity labeling 69. 70. 71. 72.
P. Cuatrerasas, P. Cuatrecasas, P. Cuatrecasas, P. Cuatrecasas,
M . Wilchek, and C. B. Anfinsen, JBC 244, 4316 (1969) JBC 245, 574 (1970). S.Fuchs, and C. B. Anfinsen, JBC 243, 4787 (1968). S. Fuchs, and C. B. Anfinsen, JBC 244, 406 (1969).
196
C. B. ANF INS E N, P. CUATRECASAS, AND H. TA N I U C H I
studies and catalytic mechanism with structure must await the further refinement of the crystallographic data that is now in progress.
VII. Complementation of Fragments
One approach to the understanding of the relationship between the amino acid sequence of a protein and its three-dimensional structure consists of preparing fragments which reconstitute a functional nativelike structure by noncovalent association. Richards first demonstrated that the two fragments of hovine pancreatic ribonuclease, RNase-S-peptide (residues 1-20) and RNase-S-protein (residues 21-124), the latter with four intact disulfide bonds, bind noncovalently t o form the original functional structure, RNase-S’ (73, 7 4 ) . The elucidation of the three-dimensional structure of RNase-S by X-ray crystallographic study confirmed these observations (‘75).The RNase-S-protein-RNase-S-peptide system also provided a way by which chemically synthesized fragments could be used to test the role of individual residues in the formation of the functional structure of the protein (76-79). Nuclease is a second case in which fragments could be obtained which yield productive complementation (47, 48, 80, 81) (Fig. 7). Observations on such complementations have contributed to the understanding of protein folding and, as with ribonuclease, have provided convenient systems for the synthetic approach t o the study of the structure-function relationship in nuclease. Binding of thymidine-3’,5’-diphosphate (pdTp) and Ca’+ to nuclease induces resistance t o proteolysis by a number of proteases (47, 5 3 ) . Trypsin rapidly cleaves the peptide bond between residues 5 and 6 of the liganded nuclease. The fragment thus formed, nuclease- (6-149), possesses enzymic activity and structure similar t o nuclease ( 4 8 ) . Further cleavage of nuclease-(&149) in the presence of the ligands takes place 73. F. M. Richards. Proc. Natl. Acod. Sci. U.S. 44, 162 (1958). 74. F. M. Richards and P. J . Vithayathil, JBC 234, 1459 (1959). 75. H. W. Wyckoff, K. D. Hardman, N. M. Allewell. T. Inagarni, L. N. Johnson, and F. M. Richards, JBC 242, 3984 (1967). 76. F. M. Finn and K. Hofmann, JACS 87, 645 (1965). 77. B. Gutte and It. B. Merrifield, JACS 91, 501 (1969). 78. R. Hirchmann, R. F. Nutt, D. F. Vcber, R. A. Vitali, S. L. Valgn, T. A . Jacob, F. W. Holly, and R. A . Denkewalter, JACS 91, 508 (1969). 79. I. Kato and C. B. Anfinsen, JBC 244, 5849 (1969). 80. H. Taniuchi and C. B. Anfinsen, JBC 244, 3864 (1969). 81. H. Taniuchi, Federation Proc. 29, No. 2, 335 (1970).
8. STAPHYLOCOCCAL NUCLEASE I49
I
Nuclease
I49
6
Nuclease- (6-149) Nuclease-T-(6-48)
197
48
I -?
Nuclease-T-(49- 149)
49
149
Nuclease-T-(50-149)
50
149
Nuclease-(l-126)
!
126
Nuclease-(99-149)
99
149
,
149
ILI
Nwlease-(Ill-I49)
1 2 7 4 9
Nuclease-(127-149)
FIG.7. Fragments of nuclease. The residues of the fragments are indicated by the numbers in the parentheses. Unfilled lines represent inactive and disordered fragments.
a t the bonds between residues 48 and 49 and between residues 49 and 50 a t approximately equal rate. The two derivatives formed each consist of two noncovalently bonded fragments: [nuclease-T- (6-48) ; nucleaseT- (49-149) ] and [ nuc1ease-T- (6-49) ; nuc1ease-T- (50-149) 1. Trypsin removes lysine 49 from the latter. The final product, “nuclease-T,” is a mixture of the two complexes [nuclease-T- (6-48) nuc1ease-T- (49149) ] and [nuclease-T- ( 6 4 8 ) nuc1ease-T- (50-149) ] (48).Nuclease-T has an enzymic activity approximately 8% that of nuclease and appears to have ordered structure similar to nuclease (47, 48, 5 3 ) . Both nuc1ease-T- (4S149) and nuc1ease-T- (50-149) are enzymically inactive and disordered but bind to the inactive fragment nuc1ease-T- (6-48) to form nuclease-T‘ which is functionally and structurally like nuclease-T (48, 53). Thus nuclease-T (or T’) represents complementation involving a discontinuity of the polypeptide chain in the region of residues 48-50. Nuclease-T (or T’) also exhibits the ligand-induced resistance to proteolysis observed with native nuclease ( 5 3 ) . Another large fragment of 126 residues, including the NH,-terminus nuclease-(1-126) can be obtained (80) from nuclease that has been trifluoroacetylated (82). Trypsin cleaves the bond involving the carboxyl group of arginine 126 in this trifluoroacetylated derivative more rapidly than those of the other arginine residues. Limited incubation of trifluoroacetylated nuclease with trypsin produces the fragment containing
+
82.
R. F. Goldberger and C . B. Anfinsen, Biochemistry
+
1, 401 (1962).
198
C. B. ANFINSEN, P. CUATRECASAS, AND H . TANIUCHI
residues 1-126, together with the residual sequence, residues 127-149, in fairly good yields. Nuclease- (1-126) and nuclease- (127-149) were isolated from the incubation mixture after removal of the trifluoroacetyl groups. Nuclease-(1-126) is inactive and appears to be disordered as judged by measurements of optical rotation, circular dichroism, and intrinsic viscosity (80). Nuclease- (127-149) is also inactive and does not bind to nuclease-(l-126) (80). Thus, the cleavage of the peptide bond between residues 126 and 127 destroys the functional structure of nuclease in contrast to the cleavage of bonds in the region of residues 48-50, which leaves the structure of nuclease essentially unchanged. However, nuclease- (1-126) complements with a BrCN fragment nuclease-(99-149) (see above) to form an enzymically active (at the level of nuclease-T) and ordered complex (81). The structure of this complex is less resistant to trypsin digestion in the presence of pdTp and Caz+than that of nuclease-T although such resistance is still observed (47, 81). Trypsin very rapidly removes residues 99-110 from the complex in the presence of the ligands. The derived complex, composed of nuclease- (1-126) and nuclease- (111-149), possesses an enzymic activity similar to that of the original complex. Isolated nuclease- (1-126) and nuclease- (111-149) combine to regenerate the enzymic activity (81). Accordingly, residues 99-110 of nuclease- (99-149) appear not to participate in the ordered structure formed by nuclease- (1-126) and nuclease- (99-149) and probably extends flexibly from the ordered structure. Further removal of residues 111-113 and 125-126 with exoproteases also appears not to affect the complementation. When nuclease- (1-126) is mixed with nuc1ease-T- (49,50-149) [the mixture of nuc1ease-T- (49-149), and nuclease-T- (50-149) 1 , enzymic activity is generated a t the level of nuclease-T and the formation of ordered structure is also indicated (80). After incubation of the enzymically active mixture in the presence of pdTp and Ca'+ with trypsin for a fairly long time, approximately 50% of the original enzymic activity remains. The enzymically active complex thus formed is the same as nuclcase-T' and is composed of the two fragments nuclease-T-(6-48) and nucleaseT- (49-149) [or nuc1ease-T- (50-149) 3 (80). Therefore, nuc1ease-T- (49, 50-149) binds to the nuc1ease-T- (6-48) portion of nuclease- (1-126) forming an enzymically active structure like nuclease-T', and the redundant residues 49-126 of nuclease- (1-126) extend in a disordered manner from the ordered structure. When the mixture of nuclease- (1-126) and nuclease-T- (49, 50-149) are incubated in the presence of the ligarids with trypsin for a short time, the fragments composing the undigested cornplexes are nuclease-T- (49,
8.
199
STAPHYLOCOCCAL NUCLEASE
n
II FIG.8. Sdwmatic illustration of the simultnnvous formation of two types of complrmentations from nuclease-(l-l26) nnd nuclease-T-(49-149). The polypeptide chains hypotlirtically participating in the ordercd structtires are circlrd.
50-149), nuclease- (1-48), nuclease- (1-126), and nuclcase- ( 1 11-149) (81). Therefore the complex composed of the nuclease- (1-126) and nuclease(111-149) as well as nucleasc-T were formed in the mixture (Fig. 8 ) . The latter type of complex appears to predominate (81). These observations on the co~nplementationof fragments of nuclcasc are consistent with the concclpt that almost the entire arnino acid sequence of nucleasc is required for the minimum information necessary to determine a stable, functional nuclcasc structure. Furthermore, the native conformation of nuclease cannot be forrned during assembly from the NH,-terminus until the polypeptide chain has been extended beyond residue 126 (80). Finally, i t appears that stable and functioiial structures can he formed in several ways when the minimum requirement for information is fulfilled (81).
VIII. Synthetic Analogs
T h e solid phase method (83)for the synthesis of peptides and proteins has been used in the synthesis of a large number of analogs of nuclease. 83. R . B. Mcrrifirld. JACS 85, 2148 (1863) ; Scieme 150, 178 (1965).
200
C. B. ANFINSEN, P. CUATRECASAS, AND H. TANIUCHI
The solid phase method possess certain inherent sources of inaccuracy resulting for the most part from the slight incompleteness of coupling that may occur a t each step of amino acid addition to the growing chain and from certain side reactions during the final deprotection steps. However, careful purification of synthetic products has been carried out (84, 85) , and synthetic variations in sequence have been restricted to those that yield essentially all-or-none answers about questions of enzymic function and structure. The synthetic studies have been made possible by the availability of complementing fragments of nuclease that contain approximately 50 amino acid residues or less (48, 81, 86). These fragments, nuclease-T- (& 48) or nuclease-T-(&47) and nuclease-(99-149) (48, 81, 86), have been discussed above in connection with the limited proteolysis of nuclease and the study of principles involved in the folding of the chain. Following synthesis and purification, the fragments can be assayed for their capacity to generate enzymic activity when combined, noncovalently in solution, with the proper complementing peptide. The ability of the various analog peptides to yield nativelike conformations upon such combination can also be estimated by spectroscopic, fluorimetric, and other methods. For example, the measurement of the intensification of tryptophan fluorescence, and the blue shift in the wavelength of maximum emission, have been of particular convenience in such studies (80, 85, 87) (see Fig. 9 ) . Several classes of analogs of the two sequence regions 6-47 and 99-149 have now been prepared, including analogs varying in the extent of deletion at the amino terminus of the protein (87, 8 8 ) , those concerned with changes in the nature of the amino acids associated (from a study of the three-dimensional crystallographic data) with the active site (87-89) and analogs that were designed t o give information about the side chain requirements for binding of the carboxyl-terminal helical region to the rest of the molecule to yield an cnzymically active recombinant (90). I n the case of the fragments containing residues 6 4 7 , which can combine with nuclease-T- (49, 50-149) to yield an active complex (see above), omission of residues 6 , 7, and 8 yields a derivative which still binds to the larger fragment and shows undiminished activity (87). Deletion of residue 9, however, reduces activity to about 2070 of the normal level, and further deletion of residue 10 produces an entirely inactive semisyn84. D. A. Ontjrs and C . B. Anfinsen, Proc. Nntl. Acnd. Sci. U . S. 64, 428 (1969). 85. I. M. Chaikrn and C. B. Anfinsen. JBC 245, 2337 (1970). 86. H . Taniuchi and C . B. Anfinsen. JBC (in prrss) (1971). 87. D. A. Ontjcs and C. B. Anfinscn. JBC 244, 6316 (1969). 88. I. M . Cliaiken and C. B. Anfinscn, JBC 245, 4718 (1970). 89. I. M. Chaiken a n d C . n. Anfinsrn, JBC (in press) (1971). 90. I. Parikh and C. B. Anfinsen, manuscript in preparation.
8.
201
STAPHYLOCOCCAL NUCLEASE
60
50
-2 -
A
2,
._
40
0
5 0
c
30
e 3 -
LL
20
10
Emission wavelength, nm
FIG.9. Fluorescence emission spectra of mixtures of nuclease-T-(49,50-149) with nuclease-T-(6-48) or synthetic pcptides upon excitation a t 295 nrn. Samples containing 2 X 10.' M nuclease-T-(49,50-149) and 4 X 10' M nuclease-T-(648) or synthetic peptide were in 0.05M tris, pH 8, with 0.01 M CaCL and O.OOO1 M pdTp. The spectrum for nuclease-T-(49,50-149) alone was corrected for the small measured emission exhibited by the buffer solution containing pdTp and Ca*+. The spectra for mixtures of synthetic peptide or nuclease-T-(6-48) with nuclease-T(49,50-149) were corrected for the meoswed emission exhibited by the appropriate synthetic peptide [or nuclease-T-(6-48) 1 alone in buffer containing pdTp and Ca'+. ( 0 )Nuclcase-T-(&48), (0) synthetic ( 6 4 7 ) , (A)synthetic (%47), ( A ) synthetic (18-47), (0) synthetic ( 3347) , and (m) nuclease-T-(49, 50-149) alone. Taken from Ontjes and Anfinsen (87).
thetic complex (88).These effects may be rationalized on the basis of the three-dimensional structure in which lysine (9) and glutamic acid 10 appear to contribute to the stabilization of a portion of the structure containing a number of hydrophobic amino acid side chains (19). Even shorter fragments retain some capacity for combination with nuc1ease-T(49, 50-149), as evidenced by their ability both to enhance the binding of 4251-[nuclease-T-(49,50-149) ] to antinuclease (87, 91) and to bind to Sepharose t o which nuclease-T- (49-149) is covalently bound (87). 91. G . S. Ornenn, D. A. Ontjcs, and C. B. Anfinsen, Biochemistry 9, 313 (1970).
202
C. B. ANFINSEN, P. CUATRECASAS, AND H. TANIUCHI
A number of residues may be replaced with other amino acids without apparent change in enzymic activity. These replacements include norleucine for methionine a t positions 26 and 32 (87), phenylalanine for tyrosine 27 ( 9 2 ) , and glycine for histitline 46 (85).As mentioned above, deletion of histidine 8 is without deleterious effect. The two remaining residues of histidine at positions 121 and 124 may also be ruled out as components of the active site since the former is, stereochemically, far on the other side of the molecule and the latter is replaced by leucine in nuclease from the Foggi strain of Staphylococcus aureus. Changes in residues that are implicated in the active center of the
I GLU
A S N 8, A
f
FIG.10. Correlation of active site synthetic analog results for nuclease-T (takrn from Table 111) with the X-ray crystallographic model for the binding site region for nuclease [taken from Cotton and Hazen (IS)]. B indirates binding of a synthetic ( 6 4 7 ) analog, with noted change, to nucleuse-T-(49,50-149) ; NB, ineffectivc binding; A , the ability of the synthetic ( 6 4 7 ) analog to generate a t least partial enzymic activity upon addition to nuclease-T-(49, 50-149) ; I, little or no ability t o generate such activity. 92. C. B. Anfinsen, D. A . Ontjes, and I. M. Chaiken, Proc. 10th Europecin Peptide Symp., 1969 (in press).
8.
203
STAPHYLOCOCCAL NUCLEASE
enzyme lead to results that are essentially as one would predict from the structure (19). Thus, as shown schcrnatically in Fig. 10 and summarized in Table 111, glutamic acid 43, aspartic acid residues 21 and 40, and arginine residue 35 play important and, indeed, except for aspartic acid 40, essential roles in the binding of the calcium atom and the inhibitor molecule pdTp. The presence of a charged carboxylate group on aspartic acid 40 is apparently not obligatory for activity (asparagine may be introduced for aspartic acid) although replacement with the bulkier glutamic acid leads to an inactive, semisynthetic nuc1ease-T complex. Both the capacity to bind to, and to induce activity with, nuc1ease-T(49, 50-149) are lost when arginine 35 is replaced with the neutral residue citrulline. The same occurs upon replacement of aspartic acid 21 with
PROPERTIES
Residue position
OF
TABLE I11 COMPLIGMENTATION OF SYNTHETIC ( 6 4 7 ) ACTIVESITE ANALOG PEPTIDIB WITH NUCLEASE-T-(4Q,50-149)'
Binding to Normal Replacement nuclease T- (49, 50-149)
21
ASP
35
-k%
40
ASP
43
Glu
(I
Glu Asn LYS Cit Glu Asn ASP Gln
+++ + + +
Enzymic activity upon addition to nuclease-T-(49, 50-149) 0 0
0 0 0
Partial 0 0
From Chaiken and Anfinsen (89).
asparagine. Both the stereochemistry and charge of the side chain on glutamic acid 43 appear to be critical for activity since replacement with either glutamine or aspartic acid causes complete inactivation, although both analogs form complexes with nuclease-T- (49, 5C149) as indicated by fluorescence measurements. As discussed earlier in relation to the complementation of fragments of nuclease to yield enzymically active, structured complexes, a fragment consisting of the first 126 residues is able to interact through noncovalent bonds with a fragment containing residues 99-149 which results from BrCN cleavage of the native protein (81, 86). This latter polypeptide, itself structureless in solution as is the 126 residue fragment, has been synthesized in several analog forms (go), and these derivatives have been tested for their ability to yield active complexes. The fragment
204
C. B. ANFINSEN, P. CUATRECASAS, AND H. TANIUCHI
may be shortened a t both ends (deleting residues 99-114 and 142-149), and the tryptophan residue a t position 140 may be replaced with phenylalanine, apparently without significant loss of activity and structureproducing capacity.
Microbial Ribonucleases with Special ReJerence to RNases TI. T2.JV;. and U2 TSUNEKO UCHIDA
F U J I 0 EGAMI
I . Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . I1. Fungal RNases TI. T.. N.. U.. and Ug . . . . . . . . A . General Survey . . . . . . . . . . . B . RNase TI . . . . . . . . . . . . C . RNase T. . . . . . . . . . . . . D . RNase N. . . . . . . . . . . . . E . RNase U. . . . . . . . . . . . . I11. Other Microbial RNases of Special Interest . . . . . . A . Extracellular RNases of B . subtilis Strain H . . . . . B . Intracellular RNase of B . subtilis . . . . . . . C . RNase PP, of Physarumpolycephalum . . . . . D. RNases 11. 111, IV. and V of E . coli . . . . . . IV . List of Microbial RNases . . . . . . . . . .
205
208 208 212 223 230 234 239 239 240 241 241 243
.
1 Introduction
Ribonucleases (RNases) may be defined as phosphodiesterases that attack the internucleotide bonds in ribonucleic acid (RNA) and its products but not those in deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) or simple phosphodiesters such as bis-p-nitrophenyl phosphate . Ribonucleases may be classified conventionally by their mode of 205
206
T. UCHIDA A N D F. EGAMI
TABLE I CLASSIFICATION O F RIBONUCLEASES A. Classification by the mode of action 1. Degradation by nucleotidyl transfer 2. Degradation by hydrolysis 1. Endonucleolytic 2. Exonucleolytic (a) From 3‘ terminal (b) From 5’ terminal B. Classification by the reaction products 1. Enzymes producing 5’-nucleotides 2. Enzymes producing nucleoside 2’,3’-cyclic phosphates (a) Enzymes producing nucleoside 2’,3’-cyclic phosphates as final products (b) Enzymes producing 3’-nucleotides as final products 3. Enzymes directly producing 3‘-nucleotides C. Classification by the substrate specificity 1. Classification by the base specificity (a) Nonbase specific (b) Pyrimidine specific (c) Guanine specific (d) Purine specific 2. Classification by the conformation specificity (a) Preferential to single-stranded RNA (b) Practically inactive to double-stranded RNA (c) Specific for double-stranded RNA
action, by their reaction products, and by their substrate specificity as shown in Table I. Most typical RNases such as pancreatic RNase (RNase A ) , described in the chapter by Richards and Wyckoff, and RNases TI, T,, N,, and U,, which will be described in this chapter, are characterized as follows: Degradation by nucleotidyl transfer Endonucleolytic Producing nucleoside 2’,3‘-cyclic phosphates which are more or less slowly hydrolyzed to produce 3’-nucleotides Practically inactive to double-stranded RNA Fairly heat stable
As for the base specificity, it is generally recognized that RNase T, is nonbase-specific, but RNases A, T, , and U, are base-specific for pyrimidine, guanine, and purine, respectively. However, generally speaking, the base specificity is not absolute but relative. For example, RNase A splits poly A a t a high concentration of the enzyme.
9.
207
MICROBIAL RIBONUCLEASES
This chapter deals with microbial RNases ( 1 ) of interest because of their enzymology or their use in nucleic acid research, with special reference to fungal RNases. Details of experimental methods are not included. Original papers or appropriate books (2, 3) should be consulted for methods of enzyme preparation and for assays of enzymic activity. For earlier surveys the chapters by G. Schmidt and M. Laskowski, by H. G. Khorana, and by C. F. Anfinsen and T. H. White, *Jr., in the second edition of “The Enzymes,” Vol. 5 , and specialized monographs (1, 4 ) should be consulted. I
I
O=P-O-
I
o=p-o-
0
0
I
0
I
o=p-o-
I
I
I
?
o=p-oI
OH
FIG. 1. Reaction catalyzed by typical RNases. 1. F. Egami and K. Nakamura, “Microbial Ribonucleases.” Springer, Berlin, 1969. 2. G . L. Cantoni and D. R. Davies, cds., “Procedures in Nucleic Acid Research.”
Harper, New York, 1966. 3. 6 . P. Colowick and S . 0. Knplan. ds.. “Methotis in Enzymology.” Vol. 12. Part A , 1967. 4. M. Privat de Garilhe, “Enzymes in Nuclric Acid Research.” Hermmn. Paris. 1967.
208
T. UCHIDA AND F. EGAMI
II. Fungal RNases, T,, T,, N,, U,, and U,
A. GENERAL SURVEY All fungal RNases (TI, T,, N,, U,, and U,) treated in this section catalyze the reaction shown in Fig. 1. The first step (phosphate transfer) is the cleavage of the phosphodiester bond between the 3' and 5' positions of the ribose moities in the RNA chain with the formation of nucleoside 2',3'-cyclic phosphates and oligonucleotides with 2',3'-cyclic phosphate a t 3' terminal. The nature of the phosphodiester bonds to be cleaved depends on the base specificity of the enzyme. This phosphoryl transfer step is reversible. In the second step (hydrolysis), these terminal cyclic phosphate groups are hydrolyzed with the formation of corresponding %-phosphates. Because the first-step is usually faster than the second step, more or less accumulation of the cyclic phosphate may be observed. TABLE I1 MAIN PROPERTIES OF FUNGAL RNasesovb RNases
Source pH optimum for RNA digestion Base specificity Specific activity (units/mg) for RNA digestion Molecular weight (amino acid analysis) Absorption max (nm) Absorption min (nm) 0Dmx/ODm1.
Ul (Ref. 7)
uz
TI
(Ref. 7)
(Ref. 6)
Ti (Ref. 6)
NI (Ref. 6 )
Aspergillus oryzae
Neurospora crassa
7.5
7.0
8.0
4.5
4.5
Guanine
Guanine
Guanine
Purine
1.6 X lo"
4.0 X lo4
1.7 X 10'
-
Nonbasespecific 1.4 x 103
11,085
11,000
11,000
10,000
36,200
278
279
278.5
277.5
281
251.5
252
251.5
251
252
3.68
3.15
Ustilago Ustilago sphaerogena sphaerogena
4.16
2.6
Aspergillus oryzae
2.52
One unit; the amounts of enzyme causing an increase in absorbance a t 260 nm of 1.0 by the assay described by Uchida and Egami (3, see p. 228) is defined as one unit of enzyme. * Some unpublished data are included.
9.
209
MICROBIAL RIBONUCLEASES
Main properties of these enzymes are summarized in Table I1 (5-7). The amino acid compositions of these enzymes are shown in Table I11 in comparison with each other and with RNase A. Base-specific RNases TI, N,, U,, and U, are of similar molecular size, unlike nonbase-specific RNase T,, which is much larger. The amino acid composition of RNases T,, N,, and U,, which are classified as guanyloribonucleases, are similar to each other, as shown in Table 111. It is remarkable that all three RNases have four residues of half-cystine. From this finding, it may be expected that these three enTABLE I11 AMINOACID COMPOSITION OF RNases Amino acid
Ti (Ref. 6)
Tz Nia
UP
A
(Ref. 6)
3 1 15 6 15 9 4 12 7 4 8 0 2 3 9 4 1
3 3 3 14 4 14 4 5 13 10 4 4 2 5 4 9 5 1
3 2 2 16 8 13 6 4 15 5 4 6 0 2 1 12
0
10 4 4 15 10 15 12 4 3 12 8 9 4 3 2 6 3 0
23 6 4 39 25 32 39 23 28 19 11 7 1 19 18 14 10 7
Total
104
107
103
124
325
N-terminal
Ala
Ala
-
Lys
C-terminal
Thr
-
TYr
Val
Glu (or Gln) -
LYS His -4% ASP Thr Ser Glu Pro GlY Ala +cys Val Met Ile Leu TYr Phe TrP
a
1
4
Unpublished data.
5. F. Egami, K. Takahashi, and T. Uchida, Prog. Nucleic Acid Res. Mole. Biol. 3, 59 (1964). 6. N. Takai, T. Uchida, and F. Egami, BBA 128, 218 (1966). 7. T. Arima, T. Uchida, and F. Egami, B J 106, 601 (1968).
210
T. UCHIDA AND F. EGAMI
zymes may have a similar architecture maintained by two disulfide bonds. Two or three residues of histidine, which has been regarded to be essential for active site in RNase A and also RNase T,, are found in each RNase. Two methionine residues are found only in RNase N,, and no tryptophan residue is found in RNase U,. Thus, neither absence of methionine nor presence of tryptophan is considered to be characteristic in guanyloribonucleases. At least the presence of tryptophan is not essential for the activity of guanyloribonuclease. The contents of aromatic amino acid residues are also similar to each other, as indicated by the similarities of the UV absorption spectrum shown in Tahle 11. However, the UV absorption spectrum of RNase U, is different from the others in that it has no shoulder a t 285 nm. This may reflect the difference in contents of tyrosine and tryptophan. The content of acidic amino acid residues increases in an order of N, < U, < T,, whereas that of basic amino acid residues decreases in the same order. This shows a good agreement with the order of the acidities of these enzyme proteins as observed in their behaviors on DEAE-cellulose column chromatography. The effects of inhibitors and activators on RNases T,, N,, U,, U,, and T, are summarized in Table IV (5, 7, 8 ) , showing the characteristics of each RNase. Ribonuclease T, is strongly inhibited by 10-3M Zn2+; RNases U, and T, are inhibited about half; but RNases N, and U2 are not inhibited. Ribonuclease T, is also strongly inhibited by 10-3M Ag+, while all other RNases are inhibited about half. But M Cu2+strongly inhibits RNase T,and only about half inhibits the other RNases. All five RNases are not inhibited by IO-, M ethylenediaminetetraacetate (EDTA) M ICH,COOH. No metallic cofactor is required for their action. and An immunochemical study on RNase T, with its immunological relation to other RNases has been carried out by Uchida (9). Antisera to RNase T, can be prepared in rabbits. The content of antibody in the antisera thus obtained is about one-tenth that in the antisera to RNase A prepared by the same method, suggesting that the immunogenicity of RNase T, may be very weak. Enzymic activity of RNase T, assayed with RNA is completely inhibited by binding with the antibody in the region of antibody excess, However, about 20% of the enzymic activity of the RNase T, used is found in the washed immune precipitate when assayed with guanosine 2',3'-cyclic phosphate. Therefore, the inhibition of the enzymic activity by binding with the antibody is considered t o result not from the specific masking of the active site but from the 8. N. Takai, T. Uchida, and F. Egami, Seikagaku 39, 473 (1967). 9. T. Uchida, J. Biochem. ( T o k y o ) 68, 255 (1970).
9.
21 1
MICROBIAL RIBONUCLEASES
TABLE I V ~ ~ : ~ ' F I ~ ;OcYT sINHIIIITOBS ANI)
ACTIVATORS O N FUNGAL IlNasea
Activity remaining (7;) Final COIlC.
Ileagents NaCl NaF NaN3 Na2S MgC1,
CaC12 AgNOa HgCh MIISO~ ZnSO,
cuso, FeSOl ICH&OOH BrCHICOOH DFP His
EDTA PCMB (I
-log ill
TI
(Ref. 6 )
N, (Ilef. 8)
U, (Ilef. 7)
9 66 81 100 100
-
-
-
-
33a 96O 56 60
79" 1100 94 60
0 1 3 1 2 2 1 2
75 100-1 15
-
19 67
3 2 3 3 2 3 3 3 2 3 2 3 4 6 2 3 2 4
-
-
70-75 0 10 45
114 51 20 103 62 108 47 245 160 190 115
Y3-100 95-100 10 60
-
0 20-50 20
-
100
-
-
100 100 82 150 120-150
10b
-
-
110
83
-
-
lJ2 (Ref. 7) 71
-
-
24b 104b 41" 61
72b 15gb 102c 53
109 117 108
112 55 103
-
-
115 101
91 95
-
-
-
T p (Ref. 5 ) 40-50 90
104 92 36 78
-
90 50 40 66
50 0 58
-
120
-
100 100 100 100 110
-
MgSO, is used instead of MgCL MnClz is used instead of MnSO1. ZnAc is used instead of ZilSO,.
steric hindrance of accessibility of substrate molecule to the enzymic site by binding with the large antibody molecules. Both RNases T, and U,, with quite different base specificities from that of RNase T,, are immunologically unrelated to RNase T,. Among the guanyloribonucleases, RNase N, has no immunological relation to RNase T, but RNase U, is found to be immunologically somewhat correlated to RNase T,. It remains to be determined if this observation is related to the difference of their enzymic activity: RNase N, is distinguishable from RNases T, and U, by its lower hydrolase activity.
T. UCHIDA AND F. EGAMl
B. RNase T, In 1957, RNasc T, ( 5 , 10, 11) was isolated from Takadiastase, a commercial product of Aspergillus oryzae ( 1 2 ) .It is now a familiar enzyme used as an essential tool for the structural analysis of RNA. 1. Preparation
Since the partial purification of RNase T, was carried out by Sat0 and Egami ( l a ) , several purification procedures have been reported. Takahashi (13) first obtained the purified RlSase T, as a homogeneous protein in the form of fine spherular crystals by the following procedure: heat treatment in acidic pH of crude extract, fractionation by ammonium sulfate (0.61.0 saturation), absorption of impurities by acid clay, two separations on DEAE-cellulose, reabsorption of impurities by acid clay, and crystallization by dialysis against the solution of 0.6 ammonium sulfate saturation. Soon after, Rushizky and Sober (14) also succeeded in the purification of this enzyme by a different procedure: After the simplified extraction in pH 2.6 and then concentration by 66% acetone, they mainly used four systems of DEAE-cellulose column chromatography. Judging from the ratio of the absorbance a t 280nm to that a t 260nm, the resulting preparation of RNase T, appears to be somewhat less pure than that prepared by Takahashi's procedure. Uchida (16) simplified a purification procedure with increase in both yield and purity. First an RNase T, fraction was obtained from the crude extract of Takadiastase Y powder by a batchwise treatment with DEAEcellulose, and then other enzymic activities in the RNasc T, fraction were inactivated by heating in pH 1.5 at €302 2" for 2 min. Ribonuclease T, in the heat-treated fraction was absorbed on the acid clay with other proteins a t acidic pH and specifically eluted at neutrality. This step serves effectively for the isolation and concentration of the enzyme preparation. After the eluate was fractionated by ammonium sulfate (70-100% saturation), the dialyzed RNase T, was subjected to DEAEcellulose column chromatography, in which RNase T, of specific ac10. F. Egami, J. Sn'. Ind. 12e.s. (India) 25, 1 (1966). 11. K. Takahashi, F. Egami. and T. Uchida, Advan. Biophys. (Japan) 1, 53 (1970). 12. K. Sat0 and F. Egami, J . Biochem. ( T o k y o ) 44, 753 (1957). 13. K. Takahashi, J. Biochem. (Tokuo) 51, 95 (1962). 14. G. W. Rushizky and H. A. Sober, JBC 237, 834 (1962). 15. T. Uchida, J. Biochem. ( T o k y o ) 57, 547 (1965).
9.
MICROBIAL RIBONUCLEASES
213
tivity approximately 500-800 could be prepared in a yield of approximately 29487%.Whenever further purification is desired, the crystallization as described in Takahashi's method for the removal of color contaminants, or gel filtration by Sephadex G-75 for the exhaustive removal of RNase T,, may be added to the above procedure. Minato e t al. of Sankyo Co. Ltd. (Tokyo, Japan) (16, i7) developed independently a large-scale purification procedure for the commercial preparation of RNase T1. Recently, R. Fields, H. B. F. Dixon, and C. Yui (unpublished) have developed a chromatographic system for the isolation of RNase TI. This procedure uses only a column of DEAE-cellulose equilibrated with a buffer of 0.0844 NaH2P0, and 0.1244 Na,HPO, after the water extraction of Takadiastase Y powder. 2. Properties Most of the properties of RNase TIare summarized in Tables I1 and IV. It is a very acidic protein, active between pH 4 and 8.5; it is most active at pH 7.5 for RNA digestion (12) and a t pH 7.2 for the hydrolysis of guanosine 2',3'-cyclic phosphate (18). The purified enzyme possesses a specific activity of about 1.6 x lo4 units/mg of protein. The molecular activity (standard units/pmole enzyme) has not been determined for the cleavage of a definite dinucleoside monophosphate such as GpC or for the hydrolysis of guanosine 2',3'-cyclic phosphate. Ribonuclease T1 is a stable enzyme. It is fairly resistant to heat (100' for 10 min a t pH 6) and acid but somewhat unstable in alkaline solution ( > p H 9 ) ( 5 , 19). It should be noted that the catalytic reaction by the enzyme cannot be stopped by simply heating the reaction mixture to loo", and even a t 100" an abnormal reaction might occur (K. Satoh, Y. Inoue, and F. Egami, unpublished). Heparin, which inhibits RNase A, does not inhibit RNase TI, nor does a natural RNase A inhibitor from rat liver (do), or Aspergillus oryzae nuclease inhibitor ( 2 1 ) . 16. S. Minato, T . Tagawa, and K. Nakanishi, Ann. Sankyo Res. Lab. 15, 122 (1963). 17. S. Minato. T. Tagawa, and K. Nakanishi, J . Biochem. ( T o k y o ) 59, 443 (1966). 18. S. Irie, T. Itoh, T. Ueda, and F. Egami, J . Biochem. ( T o k y o ) 68, 163 (1970). 19. S.Iida and T. Ooi, Biochemistry 8, 3897 (1969). 20. K. Shortman, BBA 55, 88 (1962). 21. T. Uozumi, G. Tamura, and K. Arima, Agr. Bid. Chem. ( T o k y o ) 33, 636 (1969).
214
T. UCHIDA AND F. EGAMI
TABLE V BASESPECIFICITY OF RNase TI
R
R
SIC( 1 (Refs. I X , 2 7 )
A (-)
(Ref. 23)
H G l y o x a l G (t) (Refs. 26.31
R
N - 1 M e t h y l G (*) (Refs. 2 8 , 2 9 )
I
R
R
CMC-G ( 1 (Ref. 30)
9.
215
MICROBIAL RIBONUCLEASES
3. Specificity and Mode of Action Ribonuclease TImay be regarded as a guanyloribonuclease [EC 2. 7.7.26, ribonucleate guaninenucleotido-2’-transferase (cyclizing) ] (22, 23). It splits the internucleotide bonds between 3’-guanylic acid groups and the 5’-hydroxyl groups of the adjacent nucleotides with the intermediary formation of guanosine 2’,3’-cyclic phosphate. The first step, transphosphorylation, is reversible. The second step, hydrolysis of the cyclic phosphate to produce 3’-guanylate, is practically irreversible. The base specificity has been extensively investigated by the 3‘-terminal analysis of digestion products of RNA and polyribonucleotides and by the studies on the susceptibility of dinucleoside monophosphates or nucleoside 2’,3’-cyclic phosphates to the enzyme. The results are summarized in Table V ( 2 4 3 7 ) . From the base specificity study, the esTABLE V (Continued)
I
I R
N-2 Dimethyl G
(*)
(Refs. ? 8 , 2 3 , 3 3 )
I N P - G (-) (Ref. 3 G )
R
P -Sulfophenylazo G (T. Ito, T. Uchida, and F. Egami, unpublished) ( 6 )
8 - A m G (+ +)
(Ref. 37)
22. K. Sat0 and F. Egami, C o m p t . Rend. Soc. B w l . 151, 1792 (1957). 23. K. Sato-Asano, J. Biochem. (Tokyo) 46, 31 (1959). 24. P. R. Whitfield and H. Witzel, BBA 72, 338 (1963). 25. K. Sato-Asano and Y. Fujii, J. Biochem. (Tokyo) 47, 608 (1960). 26. T. Uchida and F. Egami, J . Biochem. (Tokyo) 57, 742 (1965). 27. S. Irie. T. Uchida, and F. Egami, BBA 209, 289 (1970). 28. M. Staehelin, BBA 87, 493 (1964). 29. R. W. Holley, J. Apgar, G. A. Everett, J. T. Madison, M. Marquisee, S. H. Merrill, J. R. Penswick, and A. Zamir, Science 147, 1462 (1965). 30. T. Uchida, T. Arima, and F. Egami, J . Biochem. (Tokyo) 67, 91 (1970).
216
T. UCHIDA AND F. EGAMI
sential requirements for the preferred substrates of RNase T, are the keto group a t the 6 position and the trivalent nitrogen a t the 7 position of purine base (11). The presence of a proton a t N-1, as in guanine, further increases the susceptibility. Thus, these groups may be regarded as the specific binding sites of the purine base with the enzyme. This consideration may explain the apparent resistance of doublestranded RNA, such as RNA from cytoplasmic polyhedrosis virus (38, S9), and of polyribonucleotides highly rich in guanylyl residues, such as RNase A resistant core of RNA (40),since these sites participate in the formation of double-stranded structure and in the association of guanylyl residues. The optimum pH values of RNase TI for the hydrolysis of guanosine cyclic phosphate and xanthosine cyclic phosphate are pH 7.2 and 4.5, respectively. The xanthosine cyclic phosphate may have the lactam form (-NH-CO-) susceptible to the enzyme only in the acidic medium (18). (1) ( 6 ) The resistance of S-substituted analogs, such as 6-thioguanylylcytidine, may result from the lower electronegativity of sulfur atom than that of oxygen and/or the longer atomic distance of C=S than that of C=O (27). The resistance of N-2 p-sulfophenylazoguanylyl bonds (T. Ito, T. Uchida, and F. Egami, unpublished) may result from the steric hindrance by the large substituent. A considerable effect by the neighboring nucleoside on the splitting rate of 3’-guanylyl phosphodiester bonds was observed by Whitfeld and Witzel (Z4),and Irie ( 4 1 ) , as shown in Table VI and VII. The K , values for GpA, GpC, GpG, and GpU are of similar magnitude, but the V,,, values decrease in the order GpC > GpG > GpA > GpU (15.1 : 3.5:3.3:1) (41). This is the reverse order of the reaction rate catalyzed by OH- and is a promising observation for the analysis of the reaction
31. N. W. Y. Ho and P. T. Gilham, Biochemistw 6, 3632 (1967). 32. M. Hiramaru, J. Sokawa, T. Uchida, and F. Egami, Seikagaku 38, 662 (1966). 33. U. L. RajBhandary, A. Stuart, and S. H. Chang, JBC 243, 584 (1968). 34. C. B. Reese and J. E. Sulston, BBA 149, 293 (1967). 35. J. Hashimoto, T. Uchida. and F. Egami, BBA 199, 535 (1970). 36. M. Azegami and K. Iwai, J . Biochem. ( T o k y o ) 55, 346 (1964). 37. D. H . Levin, BBA 61, 75 (1962). 38. K. Miura, I. Fujii, T. Sakaki, S. Kawase, and J. Fuke, Proc. 7 t h Intern. Congr. Biochem., T o k y o , 1967, Abst. IV, p. 618, B-5.Sci. Council Japan, Tokyo, 1968. 39. M. A. Billeter, C. Weissmann, and R. C. Warner, J M B 17, 145 (1966). 40. K. Itagaki, Y. Kuriyama, Y. Shiobara, H. Hayashi, T. Yamagata, and F. Egami, Seikagaku, 37, 217 (1965). 41. M. Irie, J . Biochem. ( T o k y o ) 63, 649 (1968).
9.
217
MICROBIAL RIBONUCLEASES
TABLE VI RELATIVE RATESOF SPLITTING BY RNase Tp
4
Substrates
Relative rate
GPCP GPC GPA GPG GPU IPC XPC GlyoxalGpC G cyclic-p
1100 800 550 450 250 150 10 5 2
From Whitfeld and Witzel (94).
mechanism catalyzed by the enzyme and by OH- (T. Koike and Y. Inoue, unpublished). As mentioned in the beginning of this chapter, the base specificity of RNases is, in general, not absolute, but relative. Ribonuclease TI is not exceptional in this sense. In a longer incubation with higher concentrations of the enzyme (substrate-enzyme ratio: 40/1 w/w or less) compared with the usual experimental condition (substrate-enzyme ratio : 100/1 or more), nonbase-specific cleavage may occur even with an enzyme preparation of guaranteed purity. The order of the susceptibility to the enzyme is G>> A > U > C (T. Uchida and F. Egami, unpublished). The observation by Irie (42) of cleavage of poly A, poly C, and poly U and by Michelson and Money of poly 7-methylguanosine digestion (43) may be nonbase-specific cleavages, although a slight contamination by TABLE VII Km AND Vmax VALUESAT pH 7.5
OF
RNase TIo VmEZ
Substrate GPC GPG GPA GPU
(mole/min/O.27 unit enzyme)
Km 0.445 X 0.291 X 0.268 x 0.238X
lo-' lo-' lo-' lo-'
6.65 x 1.54x 1.47 x 0.44 x
10-4 10-4
10-4 10-4
From Irie (41).
42. M.h i e , J. Biochem. ( T o k u o ) 58, 599 (1965). 43. A. M. Michelson and C. Money, BBA 166, 294 (1968).
218
T. UCHIDA AND F. EGAMI
other RNases such as RNase T, in their enzyme preparations could not be excluded. The phosphodiester bond has been thought to be specific to the internucleotide 3’,5’-phosphodiester bonds (44-46). However, convincing evidence has been presented quite recently (Y. Inoue, unpublished) that Gp (3‘,5’) -N, but not Gp (2’,5’)-N, is split. A curious observation by Podder and Tinoco (47) that G-(2’,5’)-G bond was synthesized by RNase T, from G-cyclic-p led Egami and Inoue (unpublished) to reinvestigate the phosphotransferase activity a t various temperatures. At loo”, unlike at 36”, G- (2’,5’)-G,,-, is split to produce G,,,, and G-(3’,5’)-G3,-, is attacked in quite a different way a t 100” than it is a t 36”. This may result from the altered action of partly heat-denatured RNase T,. Native RNase TIis specific, however, to the internucleotide 3‘,5‘-phosphodiester bonds a t normal temperature. Unlike guanosine 2’,3’-cyclic phosphate, guanosine 3’,5’-cyclic phosphate is quite resistant to the enzyme (S. Sato, T. Uchida, and F. Egami, unpublished). The sugar specificity of RNase T, appears to require a 2‘-hydroxyl group for the substrate because DNA is not attacked by RNase TI. This is consistent with the intermediary formation of 2‘,3’-cyclic phosphate and also with the finding that a’-O-methylated guanylyl bonds in tRNA is resistant to the enzyme ( 4 8 ) . Holy and Sorm (49) found that RNase T, did not attack L-guanosine 2’,3’-cyclic phosphate and L-inosine 2‘,3‘cyclic phosphate. They found further that RNase T, split 9- (a-L-lyxofuranosyl) -hypoxanthine 2’,3’-cyclic phosphate but not the D-lyxofuranose derivative, and they concluded that the substrate molecule was fixed a t least to three regions of RNase TI( 5 0 ) . 4. Structure and Function
The amino acid sequence of RNase T, has been elucidated by K. Takahashi. It consists of a single polypeptide chain of 104 amino acid residues cross-linked by two disulfide bonds, essential for the maintenance of the enzymically active structure, as shown in Fig. 2 (51). The reductive cleavage of the bonds destroys the enzyme’s activity, but 44. Y. Kuriyama, J. Koyama, and F. Egami, Seikagaku 36, 135 (1964).
45. M. N. Lipsett, JBC 239, 1250 (1964). 46. H. Nishimura, T. Sekiya, and T. Ukita, BBA 174, 653 (1969). 47. S. K. Podder and I. Tinoco, BBRC 34,569 (1969). 48. H. G . Zachau, D. Dutting, and H. Feldmann, 2. Physiol. Chem. 347,212 (1966). 49. A. Holf and F. Sorm, Collection Czech. Chem. Commun. 34, 3383 (1969). 50. A. Holg and F. Sorm, Collection Czech. Chem. Commun. 34, 3523 (1969). 51. K. Takahashi, JBC 240, PC4117 (1965).
9. I
tl
219
MICROBIAL RI BON U CLEASES
Ald
(‘ys I
=
I0 15 3, 25 .I0 CY, Tyr Scr Srr Ser A * p Val Scr Tlir A h (;In A h AIL (;ly Tyr <;In L e u 111s (;lu A l p G l y GluwThr
I
Asp
I
Asn
I Ser
lyr I
45 A * p Phv l i l y (;lu T y r A l n A m Tyr I.y\
50 Sl‘r Scr Val Scr I’hc I
b I Thr ( ‘ y , C l y II HO l h r C y i
411 11th
Pro
35
VJI
I
r y r Srr A w Srr (;ly
P w S5 I
l y r Tyr (;lu
I
(;I” I 100 VJI Phc h m A m (;ly
70 75 l y r Srr l i l y Pro <;ly Srr Gly A l a A t p I A rg 90 RS 80 I h r llir Thr l k Val (;ly A h Leu (;In A w A * n G l u A m Phe Val V a l
1311 hS T q l 1’ro I I U Lru Sl‘r Srr (;ly A l p V r l
95 Sl‘r Ala G l y
FIG.2. Thc :imino iicid srqucncc of RNasc TI.
air-oxidation regenerates 110th the activity and the native structure (52, 53). Analyzing the data of UV absorption, circular dichroism (CD), and optical rotatory dispersion (ORD), Yamamoto and Tanaka suggested that RNase TIhad ahout 33% of a-helix structure, 24% of p structure, and 43% of random coil (54).Spectrochemical analysis suggests that most of the tyrosine residues and the only tryptophan residue in the enzyme are embedded in the hydrophobic region in the interior of the three-dimensional structure. This is consistent with the results on the potentiometric titration of the enzyme (19). From the data, pK values of dissociable groups were calculated and tentatively assigned to the dissociable groups of the molecule as shown in Table VIII. Most of the carboxyl groups TABLE VIII pK
VALUES OF
IhssocImLE GROUPSI N RNase Tp
Intrinsic PKb values
No. of groups/ molecule
Tentative assignment to dissociable groups
3.85 5.0 6.6 7.2 7.4 8.6 9.7
10 3 2 1 1 1 2
Carboxyl Carboxyl Imidazole Imidazole Cy-Amino rAmino Phenolic
From Iida and Ooi (19). Reprinted from Biochemistry 8 , 3897 (1969). Copyright 1969 by the American Chemical Society. Iieprinted by permission of the copyright owner. Potentiometric titration was performed i l l 0.1 M NaCl a t 25”. Seven of the phenolic groups and a guanidyl group were not titrated. 52. 8. Yamagata. K. Taknhashi, and I;. Eganii, J. Biochem. (Tokyo) 52, 272 (l(362). 53. K. Kasai. J. Biochem. (Tokyo) 57, 273 (1965). 54. Y. Yamamoto and J . Tnnaku. BBA 207, 522 (1970).
220
T. UCHIDA A N D F. EGAMI
are not in direct contact with the solvent but interact with other groups in the molecule. Riiterjans et al. (55) carried out proton magnetic resonance studies of RNase T, and, based upon the chemical shifts of the C-2 proton of the histidine residues of the enzyme, suggested that histidine residues interact with carboxylate anions of amino acid residues. By gel filtration experiments and by the difference spectrum of the mixture of RNase T, and 2’-guanylate, a strong competitive inhibitor, it was found that one molecule of RNase T, binds one molecule of the inhibitor. Thus, the enzyme molecule may be regarded to have one active center for the specific binding with the substrate ( 5 6 ) . This was confirmed by the analysis of the influence of pH and substrate analogs on the fluorescence of the enzyme (57). From the pH dependence of kinetic parameters (K,,, for guanylyl nucleosides and K , for 2’-gu:inylatesJ, Iric concluded ( 4 1 , 58) that RNase T, had at least three dissociable groups with pK, values 3.5, 5.7, and 7.5 a t its active center. The 3.5 group is very likely the carboxyl group of Glu 58, essential for the enzymic activity. At least one of others may be assigned to an imidazole group of histidine residues, which has been considered an active site of the enzyme. Riiterjans et al. also reported the presence of histidines i n the active center of the enzyme from the changes of the C-2 proton magnetic resonance caused by the addition of guanosine 2’-phosphate to RNase T1( 5 5 ) . The search for active sites of the enzyme, by chemical and enzymic modifications has been extensively carried out since 1959 and was recently reviewed in detail (11).Only a short summary will be presented here. Inactivated by carboxymethylatiori with iodoacetatc ( 5 6 ) , Glu 58 is the carboxymethylated residue and is an essential residue for the catalytic activity ( 5 9 ) . Inactivated by photooxidation in the presence of methylene blue ( G O ) , riboflavine ( G O ) , or Rose Bengal (61).Together with the inactivation the concomitant loss of histidine residues is observed. Onc (probably His 92) or more histidine residues might participate in the enzyme activity. 55. H. Ruterjana, H. Witzrl, and 0. Pongs, BBRC 37, 247 (1969). 56. S. Sato and F. Egami, Biochem. 2.342, 437 (1965). 57. 0. Pongs, B i o c h e k t r y 9, 2316 (1970). 58. M. Iric, J. Biochem. ( T o k y o ) 61, 550 (1967). 59. K. Takahashi. W. H. Stein, and S. Moor, JBC 242, 4682 (1968). 60. S. Yamagata, K. Takahashi, and F. Egarni. J . Biochem. ( T o k y o ) 52, 261 (1962). 61. K. Takahashi, J. Biochem. ( T o k y o ) 67, 833 (1970).
9.
MICROBIAL RIBONUCLEASES
221
Deamination (62) or trinitrophenylation (63) of two amino groups (a-amino group of N-terminal alanine and c-amino group of a lysine rcsidue) retains the activity. Amino groups have nothing to do with the activity. Modification with phenylglyoxal and glyoxal, arginine-modifying reagents, causes inactivation and concomitant loss of the only arginine residue. The single arginine residue might be a part of the active center (64)*
The single trytophan residue in the native RNase T, seems to be embedded in the interior of the molecule and cannot be modified by specific reagents. The modification of the residue in 8 M urea was carried out with 2-hydroxyl-5-nitrobenzyl bromide by Takahashi (64a) and with N-bromosuccinimide by Kawashima and Ando ( 6 5 ) . In both cases complete inactivation occurred when the tryptophan residue was completely modified. However, RNase TI modified with 2-hydroxyl-5-nitrobenzyl bromide in 4 M urea retained about 30% of the original activity (66). Thus, it may be concluded that the tryptophan residue does not participate directly in the catalytic process, since i t is situated quite close to the essential Glu 58, it may indirectly participate in the building up of the active conformation (11). Various experimental evidence suggests that only 2 or 3 of the 9 tyrosine residues are on the surface of the enzyme (19, 5 6 ) . Indeed only a part of the tyrosine residues can be easily modified by acetylimidazole at pH 7.5 or by tetranitromethane at pH 8.0 (H. Kasai, K. Takahashi, and T . Ando, unpublished). As enzymes thus modified have catalytic activity, the tyrosine residues that are probably located at the surface of the enzyme do not seem to be essential for activity. Consistent results were also obtained from the modification by fluorodinitrobenzene or by diaao1H-tetrazole (H. Kasai, K. Takahashi, and T. Ando, unpublished). Especially noteworthy is the derivative, in which one to two tyrosine residues, amino terminal alaninc, and one lysine residue were modified with diazo-lH-tetrazole. The derivative was deprived of most of its activity toward RNA but retained about 5Q% of its activity toward guanosine 2’,3’-cyclic phosphate. This may be explained by some steric hindrance owing to the modification of a tyrosine residue near the active center. 62. Y. Shiobara, K. Takahashi, and F. Egarni, J . Biochem. (Tokyo) 52, 267 (1962). 63. H. Kasai, K. Takahashi, and T. Ando, J . Biochem. (Tokyo) 56, 591 (1969). 64. K. Takahashi, J . Biochem. (Tokyo) 67, 541 (1970). 64a. K. Takahashi. J . Biochem. (Tokyo) 68, 659 (1970). 65. H. Kawashima and T. Ando, Intern. J . Protein Res. 1, 185 (1969). 66. T . Terao and T. Ukita, BBA 181, 347 (1969).
222
T. UCHIDA A N D F. EGAMI
Ribonuclease TI is fairly resistant to proteases. The threonine residue a t the carboxyl terminal of the enzyme can be removed by carboxypeptidase A without loss of activity (67). Leucine aminopeptidase does not release amino acids from the amino terminal (68). Ribonuclease T, is not inactivated by trypsin or chymotrypsin in the presence of 0.2 M phosphate (69), which probably binds the enzyme and protects it from inactivation (67). Treatment of the enzyme with trypsin in the absence of phosphate inactivates it (67). Ribonuclease T, is hydrolyzed by pepsin with progressive loss of activity (6‘9). It is not yet possible to coordinate all the information about RNase T, to elucidate the nature of the active center of the enzyme and to explain the mechanism of specific reactions catalyzed by the enzyme. Further studies, including X-ray crystallographic analysis are required. However, if it is assumed that there is a base-specific binding site and a catalytic site in the active center, the former may be essentially different from that of RNase A and the latter may somewhat resemble that of RNase A. It is believed that the residues Glu 58, Arg 77, and His are probably essential to the activity, and that at least one of the histidine residues participates in the catalytic site.
5. Applications Soon after the discovery of RNase T,, it was suggested (70, 71) that it would become an important tool for the elucidation of nucleotide sequence in RNA. Indeed, since 1962 several workers have tried to use the enzyme for the nucleotide sequence analysis of RNA, especially in highly purified specific tRNA’s. Finally, the brilliant research of Holley and his associates in 1965 resulted in the first elucidation of the complete nucleotide sequence of an RNA, alanine specific yeast tRNA, using RNase T, as a main tool (29). Since then many successful elucidations of nucleotide sequence of various RNA’s, using RNase T, as a main tool, followed, and now the enzyme is well-known as an essential tool for the structural analysis of RNA. Ribonuclease TI has been used by several workers to synthesize guanylylnucleosides, oligoguanylate, and other guanosine-containing oligonucleotides with (3’-5’)-phosphodiester bonds (72-79). 67. 68. 69. 70. 71. 72.
C. Shiozawa, J. Biochem. (Tokyo) 66, 733 (1969). K. Takahashi, J. Biochem. (Tokyo) 52, 72 (1962). K . Takahashi, J. Bwchem. (Tokyo) 60, 239 (1966). F. Egami, Kagaku No Ryoiki 12, 9 (1958). K. Sato-Asano and F. Egami. Nature 185, 462 (1960). K . Sato-Asano and F. Egami, BBA 29, 655 (1958).
9.
MICROBIAL RIBONUCLEASES
223
Since recently isolated RNase N, has been shown to be a more suitable enzyme for the same synthetic reactions, the synthetic reactions will be described in the section on RNase N,. However, it should be pointed out that Podder and Tinoco recently demonstrated that the synthetic reactions by RNase TI can lead to the formation of unnatural (2’-5’)phosphodiester bonds ( 4 8 ) . This curious phenomenon occurs when the enzyme and the products are kept a t a higher temperature (100’) (K. Satoh, Y. Inoue, and F. Egami, unpublished). A t normal temperature, (3’4’) -phosphodiester bonds are formed exclusively by the enzyme (79)*
C. RNase Tz Ribonuclease T, ( 5 ) was found in 1957 by Sat0 and Egami in Takadiastase (12). Since the partially purified RNase T, was found to preferentially attack phosphodiester bonds of adenosine-3’-phosphate in RNA ( 8 0 ) ,this enzyme had long been expected to be specific for adenylic acid phosphodiester bond if it could be completely purified. However, sufficiently purified RNase T, showed no absolute base specificity (81, 82) and was found rather to split all phosphodiester bonds in RNA with a preference for adenylic acid bonds. Thus, RNase T, is effective in the analysis of the base composition of RNA. 1. Preparation
The partial purification of RNase T, was carried out by Naoi-Tada et al. (80). Uchida and E’gami (81, 83),and Rushizky and Sober (82) 73. K. Sato-Asano, J . Biochem. (Tokyo) 48, 284 (1960). 74. H. Hayashi and F. Egami, J. Biochem. (Tokyo) 53, 176 (1963). 75. K. H. Sheit and F. Cramer, Tetmhedron Letters 11. 2765 (1964). 76. T. Sekiya, Y. Furuichi, N. Yoshida, and T . Ukita, J . Biochem. (Tokyo) 63, 514 (1968). 77. D. Griinberger, A. Holj., and F. Sorm, Collection Czech. Chem. Commun. 33, 286 (1968). 78. S. C. Mohr and R. T. Thach, JBC 244, 6566 (1969). 79. H. J. Rowe and M. A. Smith, BBRC 38, 393 (1970). 80. M. Naoi-Tada, K. Sato-Asano, and F. Egami, J . Biochem. (Tokyo) 46, 757 (1959). 81. T. Uchida, J . Biochem. (Tokyo) 60, 115 (1966). 82. G. W. Rushizky and H. A. Sober, JBC 238, 371 (1963). 83. T. Uchida and F. Egami, Procedures Nzicleic Acid Res. p. 46 (1966).
224
T. UCHIDA AND F. EGAMI
independently obtained the purified RNase T, as a homogeneous protein. Ribonuclease T, is more stable in acidic pH and heating than other proteins in Takadiastase and has higher isoelectric point and molecular weight than RNase TI.The purification of RNase T, was based upon these properties: Heat treatment in acidic p H or acid extraction was effective for the inactivation and removal of other enzymic activities in Takadiastase, batchwise treatment by DEAE-cellulose or fractionation with ammonium sulfate (40-100% saturation), ethanol (4052%), or acetone (<66%) for the removal of other proteins and concentration of RNase T, activity, and column chromatography by DEAEcellulose or CM-cellulose or gel filtration by Sephadex G-75 for the separation from RNase TI. Ribonuclease T, was purified (900-1 100-fold with a yield of about 10%) from the water extract of Takadiastase A powder by the suitable combinations of several methods described above (81). By the process of DEAE-cellulose column chromatography, RNase T, was separated into two fractions, RNase T2-A and T,-B. However, the only difference is in the nature of their sugar components. 2. Properties Most of the basic properties of RNase T, are summarized in Tables I1 and IV. It is a neutral protein. It is most active at pH 4.5 for RNA or homopolymer digestion and a t pH 6.0-6.3 for the hydrolysis of various nucleoside 2’,3’-cyclic phosphates and for the degradation of 3’-nucleotide beneyl ester (84). Considering that the value was obtained for the first step of RNase T2 action, the degradation of the benzyl esters, the difference of optimum pH may result not from the difference of transphosphorylation and hydrolysis but probably from the difference of molecular size. Indeed this consideration is also confirmed by the finding that the curve of pH dependence of the RNase T, action on commercial RNA does not strictly coincide with the curve of that on the high molecular weight yeast RNA but expands larger than the latter in the region of pH 6-5 (81). The purified enzyme possesses a specific activity of about 1.4 x 103 units/mg of protein. The molecular activity determined for the cleavage of uridine ‘2‘,3’-cyclic phosphate is 15 x lo3 standard units per micromole of protein (83).Onc unit, determined using RNA as substrate, corresponds to about 0.30 standard unit (83). Ribonuclease T2 is most stable a t pH 6.0, 80” for 5 min. At room temperature it is more stalde in alkaline medium and less stable in acidic medium than RNase TI. Ribonuclease T, contains 12-15% carbohydrates, in addition to amino 84. S. Sato,
T.Uchidn, and I?. Egami, A B B 115,
48 (1966).
9.
MICROBIAL RIBONUCLEASES
225
acids. Ribonuclease T,-A can be distinguished from RNase T,-B by the nature of sugar components: RNase T,-A contains mannose and glucose and RNase T,-B contains mannose and galactose as the main sugar components (81). 3. Specificity and Mode of Action Ribonuclease T, is regarded as a nonspecific endoribonuclease [EC 2.7.7.17, ribonucleate nucleotido-2’-transferase (cyclizing) 1. It preferentially splits the internucleotide bonds between the 3’-adenylic acid group and the 5’-hydroxyl group of adjacent nucleotides in RNA, with the intermediary formation of adenosine 2’,3’-cyclic phosphate and splits consequently all secondary phosphate ester bonds of other nucleotides in RNA via the nucleotides 2’,3’-cyclic phopshates. The mode of action on various RNA’s and synthetic homopolymers has been investigated by the 3’-terminal analysis of digestion products (85).I n the exhaustive digestion with RNase T,, RNA is quantitatively digested to produce all nucleoside-3’-phosphates. I n the partial digestion of RNA or tRNA mixture, the mode of action of RNase T, is as follows: (1) Some adenylyl bonds (about 20%) in RNA are preferentially split to produce the large fragments terminating with adenylyl residue in the very early stage of digestion, in which no increase in the optical density of acid-soluble products is observed. (2) Whereas adenylic acid appears rapidly in the initial stage, other mononucleotides appear after a short lag time. The rates of appearance of mononucleotide are in the order of A >> U > G > C . (3) No small oligonucleotides such as di- or trinucleotides with 3’terminal Ap are produced throughout the process of digestion, but those with 3’-terminal Gp or Up are produced in the course of digestion. (4) Adenosine 2‘,3‘-cyclic phosphate is scarcely accumulated, though other nucleoside 2’,3’-cyclic phosphates are accumulated as intermediates. This result suggests that the action of RNase TIon RNA is owing to the cooperation of an adenylic acid specific endonuclease activity and a nonspecific exonuclease activity releasing mononucleotides from the 3‘ terminal. The mode of action on poly U is similar to that on RNA. A remarkable increase of 3’ terminus a t an initial stage (about 25% of total residues), subsequent accumulation of UpUp or U > p, and rapid appearance of Up after a short lag time are observed. This shows that RNase T, clearly behaves as an endonuclease for poly U as for RNA. Therefore, it should be interpreted that the apparent initial endo85. T. Uchida and F. Egami, J . Bbchem. (Tokyo) 61,44 (1987).
226
T. UCHIDA AND F. EGAMI
nuclease activity on the digestion of RNA with RNase T, is not specific but preferential for adenylic acid. The susceptibility to RNase T, depends on the nature of various RNA's and homopolymers (85).Poly A is fairly resistant to RNase T, in spite of the preferential cleavage of adenylic acid linkages in RNA, whereas, unexpectedly, poly U is the most sensitive to RNase T, of the various homopolymers tested. Poly C is also resistant to digestion by RNase T,. I n the digestion of poly A or poly C, only 3'-mononucleotide is detected as a digestion product and a small increase of 3' terminus in the initial stage (about 4% of total residues) is observed; the initial endonuclease activity appears to be markedly reduced. The reason may be that poly A forms a rigid double-stranded helical structure in acidic medium, because poly U, which has no secondary structure a t 37", is easily digested. I n 40% methanol solution, where a part of its rigid double-stranded structure is destroyed, poly A is more sensitive to RNase T, than it is in water; and the mode of action of RNase T, on poly A in 40% methanol solution is very similar to that on RNA or poly U. Furthermore, the susceptibilities to RNase T, among various RNA's are in the order of commercial yeast RNA (low molecular weight) > high molecular weight yeast RNA > tRNA mixture containing more double-stranded structure than the other RNA's ( 8 5 ) .These observations also confirm the resistance of higher structure in substrate molecule to RNase T,. Ribonuclease T, has no absolute specificity, but 8-methyl ribofuranoside 2',3'-cyclic phosphate is not cleaved by RNase T, ( 8 5 ) , indicating that a t least a part of the base Structure is of significance for the action of RNase T,. The order of preference of RNase T, for various bonds in RNA is ApN > UpN > GpN > CpN ( 8 5 ) , so no general rule can be stated for the preference for purine or pyrimidine, or for keto or amino substituent. Recently, it was found that RNase T, gave complete cleavage of the phosphodiester bonds of 4-thiouridylate in tRNA (86) and of 6-thioguanylyl- (3'-5') -cytidine (27). This shows that the substitution of sulfur a t the 4 position of pyrimidine base or a t the 6 position of purine base does not effect the action of RNase T,. Furthermore, the phosphodiester bonds of the nucleotides with a large substituent a t the 6 position of purine base such as N6-isopentenyladenosine (87), 2-methyl thi0-W- (Az86. M. Saneyoshi, F. Harada, and S. Nishimura, BBA 190, 264 (1969). 87. S. Hashimoto, M. Miyazaki, and S. Takemura, J . Biochem. ( T o k y o ) 65, 659 (1969).
9.
MICROBIAL RIBONUCLEASES
227
isopentenyl) adenosine (88),or N-9- (P-~-ribofuranosyl) purin-6-ylcarbamoyl threonine (89, 90) were also split completely by RNase T, to produce the corresponding 2’,3’-cyclic phosphates. The effect of the substituent a t N-7 in purine base on the susceptibility to RNase T,has been also studied, in comparison with a purine specific ribonuclease, such as RNase TI or U,, for which the importance of N-7 has been recognized. Ribonucleic acid methylated with dimethyl sulfate was completely digested with RNase T, to the acid-soluble products, in which mononucleotide (66%) and dinucleotide were detected on a paper chromatography ( 3 2 ) . From this result, the good susceptibility of 7methyl guanine residue to RNase T,, unlike its susceptibility to RNase TI, was expected and it has been clearly proved by the studies (86,91,92) on the primary structure of tRNA containing 7-methyl guanine residue. Recently, 7-dcazaadenylyl- (3’4’) -uridine (tubercidyl uridine) was found to be easily cleaved by RNase T,. Also, 7-deazaadenosine-2’,3’-cyclic phosphate was completely hydrolyzed by RNase T, as fast as adenosine 2’,3‘-cyclic phosphate, which is the most susceptible substrate to RNase T, (35). Therefore, it is concluded that N-7 in purine base has nothing to do with the susceptibility to RNase T,. The substituents a t the 5 or 6 position of the pyrimidine base have no relation to the susceptibility to RNase T,. Madison and Holley (93) have shown that RNase T, is able to split the phosphodiester bonds of pseudouridylic acid and 5,6-dihydrouridylic acid. Recently, Saneyoshi et al. (86) have found a new minor constituent, Vp, with 5-methyl cytidine 3’-phosphate and other mononucleotides on the two-dimensional paper chromatogram of RNase T, exhaustive digest of E . coli tRNAVa’; later the structure of V was proved to be uridine-5-oxyacetic acid (94). It has been reported that RNase T, is able to split easily the phosphodiester bond of I-methyl adenylic acid in mctliylated RNA ($2) and 1methyl adenylyl- (3’-5’)-uridine (30).However, the Ap-N-oxide phosphodiester bonds in RNA-N-oxide, prepared by the action of perphthalate on RNA, were found to be quite resistant to RNase T a ( 8 5 ) .The phos88. F. Harada, H. J. Gross, F. Kimura, S. H. Chang, S. Nishimura, and U. L. H:ijBhandary, BBRC 33, 299 (1968). 89. H. Ishikura, Y. Yamada, K. Murao, M. Saneyoshi, and S. Nishimura, BBRC 37,990 (1969). 90. S. Takemura, M. Murakami, and M. Miyazaki, J. Biochem. (Tokyo) 65, 553 ( 1969). 91. T. Seno, M. Kobayashi, and S. Nishimura, BBA 169, 80 (1968). 92. S. Cory and K. A. Marcker, European J. Biochem. 12, 177 (1970). 93. J. T. Madison and R. W. Holley, BBRC 18, 153 (1965). 94. K. Murao, M. Saneyoshi, F. Harada, and S. Nishimura, BBRC 38, 657 (1970).
228
T. UCHIDA AND F. EGAMI
phodiester bonds of glyoxal guanylic acid, blocked with glyoxal to link between N-1 and 2-amino group of guanylyl residues, was also found to be fairly resistant to RNase T, and to remain mostly in the 2’,3’-cyclic phosphate form after the digestion of glyoxalated RNA (SO).According to Tada, the phosphodiester bonds of dimethyl guanylic acid and 1-methyl guanylic acid are fairly resistant to RNase T, ( 9 5 ) . Accordingly, these observations show that blocking a t N-1 of the base with a substituent group results in the increase of the resistance to RNase T2, and that N-1 in the base is of significance for the action of RNase T,. Hol? and Sorm (49, 50) observed that RNase Tz, like RNase TI, attacks 9- (/?-D-ribofuranosyl) and 9- (a-L-lyxofuranosyl) derivatives but not 9- (p-L-ribofuranosyl) and 9- (a-D-lyxofuranosyl) derivatives. Also, RNase T, is quite inactive on the phosphodiester bonds like RNase TI, of the nucleotide with 2’-O-methyl ribose, such as 2’-O-methyl guanylic acid (96) or 2’-O-methyl cytidylic acid (86). Thus, the action of RNase T, is in good accord with that of RNase T, and RNase A on sugar specificity, which may be a common property throughout all RNases, producing 3’-phosphate via 2’,3’-cyclic phosphate. Sat0 et al. (84) studied the action of RNase Tz on various nucleoside 2’,3’-cyclic phosphates and determined the K,,, and V,,, a t the optimum pH, as shown in Table IX. Although the K , value for A cyclic-p was TABLE IX MICHAELIS CONSTANTS, INHIBITOR CONSTANTS, AND MAXIMUM VELOCITY OF RNase TP Substrates and inhibitors
Km
A cyclic-p C cyclic-p G cyclic-p CJ cyclic-p
2.3 x 4.0 x 6.5 x 6.1 x
(M)
Ki (MI
V, (pmole/min/ pmole protein)
Cyclic Nucleotides
2’-AMP 2’-CMP 2’-GMP 3’-AMP 0
13.0 X 12.6 X 9.0 x 15.1 X
10-4 10-4 10-4 10-4
10s lo3 10s 1@
2’- or 3‘-Nucleotides 1 . 1 x 10-6 1 . 2 x 10-4 3 . 4 x 10-4 3 . 8 X 10-6
From Sato et al. (84).
95. M. Tada, Seikagaku 38, 662 (1966). 96. U. L. RajBhandary, R. D. Faulkner, and A. Stuart, JBC 243, 575 (1968).
9. MICROBIAL
229
RIBONUCLEASES
a little smaller than that for others, no remarkable difference was observed between the Km and V,,,,, values with adenosine 2',3'-cyclic phosphate and those with others. This result may reflect lack of base specificity of RNase T,. The apparent preference for adenylic acid bonds observed in RNA digestion might result from the base-specific affinity of RNase T, to adenylate. The findings that the Ki values for 2'- or 3'adenylate toward the hydrolysis of uridine 2',3'-cyclic phosphate are much smaller than those for other nucleotides (Table I X ) , and that the adenylates protect most strongly from bromoacetate inactivation of RNase T,, support this consideration. Imaaawa et al. (97) also measured the Km and V,,,,, values a t pH 6.0 with various dinucleoside monophosphates, XpY (Table X) ; K m values increased in the order of A C < G < U for both X and Y, while the V,,,,, values decreased in the order of U > G > C > A for X and of C > G > U > A for Y. When either X or Y in XpY was adenylyl residue, their K, values were smaller than those of others. This finding also supports the consideration mentioned above.
<
4. Applications
Rushiaky and Sober ( 8 2 ) first described the use of RNase T, for the base analysis of RNA as it hydrolyzes RNA practically completely to 3'-nucleotides. Ribonuclease T, digestion is certainly more advantageous for the base analysis of RNA than alkaline hydrolysis which gives TABLE X
K,
AND
Substrates
V,
VALUESOF RNase Tf
K , (MI
(pmole/min/ pmole protein)
~
UPU UPA GPU GPA CPU CPA APU APG APC APA 4
1.2 x 0.47 X 1.1 x 0.63 x 0.72 X 0.41 x 0.82 X 0.75 x 0.67 x 0.39 x
10-4 lO-' 10-4 10-4 lW4 10-4 lO-' 10-4 10-4 10-4
26 X 23 X 12.0 x 12.7 X 20 x 11.3 X 10.3 X 7.2 x 15.3 X 3.6 X
lo8 lo" 10s 10s 10s 10s 10s 103 lo"
lo"
From Imaaaws et al. (97).
97. M. Imazawa, M . hie, and T. Ukita, J. Biochem. ( T o k y o ) 84, 595 (1968).
230
T. UCHIDA AND F. EGAMI
rise to the mixture of 2’- and 3‘-nucleotides to complicate the analyzing procedure, and which may be accompanied by a slight degradation of nucleotide bases, especially of certain minor components unstable in the alkaline region. Nirenberg et al. (98) applied it to the analysis of certain oligoribonucleotides. A map of the complete digestion products of tRNA showed that all the products were localized in the area of mononucleotides and no oligonucleotide was detected (85). Recently, RNase T, has also played an important role in the discovery and identification of new minor constituents in tRNA: 5,6 dihydrouridylic acid (93), uridine-5-oxyacetic acid (Vp) (86, 94), “;-methyl adenosine (86), and N-9- (P-D-ribofuranosyl) purin-6-ylcarbamoyl threonine (89, 90). Two-dimensional paper chromatography of RNase T, digest was presented by Saneyoshi et al. (86) as the most effective and general method for detection of minor nucleotides in tRNA. Besides these applications, RNase T, has been used for the syntheses of certain nucleoside-3’-phosphates such as coenzyme A (99).
D. RNase N, Although Neurospora crassa had been extensively studied from a genetic point of view, the RNases received little attention until recently. A short report by Suskind and Bonner (100) was the only one before our finding of RNase N, (6). Soon after our finding, genetic studies were reported by Ishikawa et al. (101). Takai et al. (102) studied the formation of ribonuclease, phosphodiesterase, and phosphomonoesterase in cultures of three different strains of N . cl’assa, wild strain 74A and two adenine-requiring strains, in various culture media. They found an extracellular RNase, designated RNase N,, in the culture broth of all strains tested, during the stationary phase. Ribonuclease N, has properties similar to those of RNase TI in regard to base specificity and molecular size (6). However, it has a higher phosphotransferase activity and far less hydrolase activity than RNase T,. As suggested from this finding, RNase N, is more advantageous than RNase T, for the synthesis of oligonucleotides with 5’-terminal 98. M. Nirenberg, P. Leder, J. Trupin, F. Rottman, and C. O’Neal, Proc. Nall. Acad. Sci. U . S . 53, 1161 (1965). 99. A. M. Michelson, BBA 93, 71 (1964). 100. S. R. Suskind and D. M. Bonner, BBA 43, 173 (1960). 101. T. Ishikawa, A. Toh-e, I. Uno, and K.Hasunuma, Genetics 63, 75 (1969). 102. N. Takai, T. Uchida, and F. Egami, Seikagaku 39, 285 (1967).
9.
MICROBIAL RIBONUCLEASES
231
guanylate and those with a definite nucleotide sequence containing guanylyl or inosinyl residue (103, 104). 1 . Preparation The partial purification of RNase N, was carried out by Takai et al. (6,8)from the culture broth (5.5 liters) of Neurospora crassa, adenine-requiring strain 74A-T32-M12. The specific activity of their enzyme preparation was increased to about 5000 times that of the culture filtrate, but their preparation was not yet homogeneous as a protein. It is remarkable that although it was only partially purified, RNase N, had a higher activity than homogenous RNase T,. Kasai et aZ. (105) succeeded in the purification and the crystallization of RNase N,. The culture filtrate of N . crassa was first concentrated by lyophilization. The solution of the lyophilieed powder was fractionated with ethanol (5066%) followed by precipitation with 90% ammonium sulfate saturation. After the resulting precipitate was dissolved in buffer and then dialyzed against 0.005 M Na,HP04, the dialyzed solution was subjected successively to DEAK-cellulose column chromatography, gel filtration by Sephadex G-75, and CM-cellulose column chromatography. This procedure was further simplified a t the Research Institute, Seikagaku-kogyo Co. Their procedure consists of only three steps: the salting-out with ammonium sulfate, DEAE-cellulose column chromatography, and gel filtration by Sephadex G-75. For crystallization, the RNase N, fraction eluted from the CM-cellulose column or Sephadex G-75 column was concentrated by lyophilization and then dialyzed against distilled water at 4". During dialysis, fine needle-shaped crystals were formed. The specific activity of the crystals was about 2200. The solubility of the crystals is small around neutrality and increases below pH 4.0. Thus, the crystals are usually dissolved in dilute acetic acid. 2. Properties
Most of the basic properties of RNase N, (6, 8) are summarized in Tables I1 and IV. It is a neutral protein. It is most active a t pH 7.0 for 103. F.Egami, T.Uchida, T. Arima, and T. Koike, 6th Intern. Symp. Chem. N a t . Prod., London, 1968 Abstr. E-20, p. 266. International Union of Pure and Applied Chemistry, Oxford, England. 104. T. Koike, T. Uchida, and F. Egami, BBA 190, 257 (1969). 105. K. Kasai, T. Uchida, F. Egami, K. Yoshida, and M. Nomoto, J . Biochem. (Tokyo) 68, 389 (1969).
232
T. UCHIDA AND F. EGAMI
RNA and the activity decreases steeply in alkaline medium. The pH dependence of hydrolase activity for guanosine 2’,3’-cyclic phosphate is not yet determined. The crystals of RNase N, possess a specific activity of about 4.0 x lo4 units/mg of protein, about 2.5 times that of purified RNase T,. Ribonuclease N, is most stable in neutral or acid media at 37”. It is resistant even to heating a t 80” for 2 min in acidic media of pH 2 4 , and is fairly unstable in alkaline medium like RNase T,. It is not as stable as RNase T, in higher salt concentrations and exhaustive dilution with water makes the enzyme unstable. This enzyme needs a protective protein such as gelatin or bovine serum albumin for assay. 3. Specificity
Ribonuclease N, is regarded as a guanyloribonuclease [ EC 2.7.7.26, ribonucleate guaninenucleotide-2’-transferase (cyclizing) , Neurospora crassa]. Like RNase T,, it splits specifically the internucleotide bonds between 3’-guanylic acid group and the 5’-hydroxyl groups of adjacent nucleotides in RNA, with the intermediate formation of guanosine 2’,3‘cyclic phosphate The base specificity has been investigated by the 3’-terminal analysis of digestion products of RNA. In the partial digestion of high molecular weight RNA, RNase N, produced almost exclusively guanosine 2’,3’cyclic phosphate and oligonucleotides with guanylyl residues as 3’ terminus (6, 8). Since 3’-guanylic acid was scarcely detected in the RNA digestion products, the hydrolase activity of RNase N, for guanosine 2’,3’-cyclic phosphate was much lower than that of RNase T,. Ten units of RNase T, hydrolyzed 45% of the guanosine 2’,3‘cyclic phosphate (1.4 pmoles/O.5 ml) to 3’-guanylic acid in 6 hr a t pH 7.5, while comparable hydrolysis by RNase N, was produced only with about 150 units of the enzyme in 6 hr a t pH 7.0.
4. Applications Recently, Koike et al. (104) have proved that RNase N, is a more useful tool than RNase TI for the synthesis of oligonucleotides such as guanylyl- (3’,5’)-nucleoside, oligoguanylic acid, and the oligonucleotides of defined sequence containing guanylyl or inosinylyl residue. When guanosine 2’,3’-cyclic phosphate is incubated with about %fold nucleoside a t a low temperature in the presence of RNase N,, guanylyl(3’,5’)-nucleoside can be obtained as a synthetic product. For example, using uridine as a phosphate acceptor, GpU was obtained with a high yield of 27% calculated upon guanosine 2’,3‘-cyclic phosphate added. This
9.
MICROBIAL RIBONUCLEASES
233
yield of GpU synthesized by RNase N, is about twice as much as that of GpU by RNase T, under similar conditions. Furthermore, more than 50% of guanosine 2’,3’-cyclic phosphate remained unchanged, unlike the synthesis by RNase T,, showing the poor hydrolase activity of RNase N, a t lower temperature. The high yield of synthetic product and the possibility of recovering reactants might thus be more advantageous for the practical use of the enzymic synthesis by RNase N,. Ribonuclease N, can also synthesize inosinyl- (3’-5’) -nucleoside from inosine 2’,3’-cyclic phosphate and the nucleoside as phosphate acceptor a t low temperature, like the synthesis of guanylyl- (3’-5’) -nucleoside. Generally, the yield of synthetic products by ribonuclease depends on temperature, pH, incubation time, enzyme concentration, substrate concentration, the ratio of acceptor to phosphate donor, and the nature of acceptor (73, 78, 103, 104). Among these variables, temperature is most important. A low temperature gives a larger amount of the product because it reduces the competing hydrolytic activity; both the rate and extent of synthetic reaction increase when the initial concentrations of the phosphate donor and the ratio of acceptor to phosphate donor are increased (73, 78). Especially when the ratio of acceptor to phosphate donor is large, the production of by-products such as GpGp or GpGpU in the case of GpU synthesis is greatly reduced (104). The optimum p H of synthetic reaction is usually near that of RNA digestion by the ribonuclease (pH 7.0 in the case of RNase Nl). As expected, the rate of the synthetic reaction parallels the enzyme concentration, but the latter does not affect the extent of the reaction (78, 104). The effect of the nature of the nucleoside as a phosphate acceptor on the yield of dinucleoside monophosphates is in the following order: cytosine > uridine > inosine > adenosine. This order has been shown from the results with RNase TI, N,, and U, to be common to all the ribonuclease tested and suggests that the affinity of the dinucleoside monophosphate to enzyme has no relation to the yield of synthetic products in the reaction. The 2’ (3’)-mononucleotides are less effective as acceptors than the nucleosides because of the inhibitory effect of phosphate (78, 104). When RNase N, was incubated only with guanosine 2’,3’-cyclic phosphate (0.1 mmole/O.l ml) in the absence of phosphate acceptor, about 57% of polymerized products consisting of 2-6 guanylyl residues such as GpG cyclic-p (9.1%), GpGp (13.3%), GpGpG cyclic-p (10.20/0), GpGpGp (7.4%), and tetramer (6.5%) were obtained (104). It is characteristic of RNase N, that the oligonucleotides terminating with 2’,3’-cyclic phosphate is produced in higher yield than those with 3’phosphate, unlike RNase T,. The synthetic reaction can be extended to acceptors containing
234
T. UCHIDA AND F. EGAMl
more than one nucleoside residue (T. Koike, T. Uchida, and F. Egami, unpublished), for example G cyclic-p I cyclic-p
-
+ ApG RNaae NI GpApG (7.5% for 46 hr)
+ ApCpC RNaae NI IpApCpC (7.6% for 20 hr)
Furthermore, when ApG cyclic-p was incubated with about 14-fold cytidine at a low temperature in the presence of RNase N,, trinucleoside diphosphate, ApGpC could be obtained with the yield of about 38% after 1 hr of incubation. When ApG cyclic-p alone was incubated with RNase N,, the polymerized products with the definite repeating sequence (ApGp), could be produced. The yield of tetramer (n = 2 ) , ApGpApG cyclic-p ApGpApGp, amounted to 34% and that of hexamer (n = 3), to 7%. But larger polymers were scarcely detected (T. Koike, T. Uchida, and F. Egami, unpublished).
+
E. RNase U, Ribonuclease U, is a novel enzyme found in the culture broth of Ustilago sphaerogena (7, 106). Ribonuclease U, splits, practically specifically, the phosphodiester bonds of purine nucleotides in RNA with the intermediary formation of purine nucleoside 2',3'-cyclic phosphates, indicating the specificity is complementary to that of pancreatic RNase A (106). Like RNase N,, RNase U, very slowly hydrolyzes the intermediate, nucleoside 2',3'-cyclic phosphate, to 3'-nucleotides (SO, 1 0 6 ) . Thus, RNase U, is a useful tool, not only for the analysis of nucleotide sequences of RNA (90,92, 10'7, 108) but also for the synthesis of various oligonucleotides containing adenylyl or guanylyl residue (30) (T. Koike, T. Uchida, and F. Egami, unpublished). 1. Preparation
Arima et a2. (7) have partially purified RNase U, with RNases U, and U, from the culture broth (25 liters) of a strain of Ustilago sphaerogena, from which Glitz and Dekker had isolated a guanyloribonuclease (109, 110). 106. T. Arima, T. Uchida, and F. Egami, BJ 108, 609 (1968). 107. J. M. Adams, P. G. N . Jeppessen, F. Sanger. and B. G. Barrell, Nature 223, 1009 (1969). 10s. N. W.Y. Ho, T. Uchida, F. Egami, and P. T. Gilham, Cold Spring Harbor Symp. Quunt. Biol. 34, 647 (1969). 109. D. G. Glitz and C. A. Dekker, Biochemistry 3, 1391 (1964). 110. D. G. Glitz and C. A. Dekker, Biochemistry 3, 1399 (1964).
9.
MICROBIAL RIBONUCLEASES
235
Ustilago sphaerogena was cultured in a medium containing glucose, glycine, and mineral salts a t 30" for 60 hr. After the cells were removed, the RNase U, fraction was roughly separated from the RNase U, fraction by batchwise treatment of the supernatant with DEAE-cellulose. Other contaminating proteins in the RNase U2 fraction were removed by batchwise treatment with CM-cellulose a t pH 4.0. The resulting RNase U, fraction, after dialysis, was subjected to DEAE-cellulose column chromatography, in which three peaks of RNase activity corresponding to RNases U,, U,, and U:], respectively, were eluted successively. The RNase U, was further purified by rechromatography with DEAE-cellulose and then gel filtration with Sephadex G-75. The RNase U, preparation obtained by this procedure was purified about 3700-fold with a yield of 2.6% from the culture broth of U . sphaerogena. Attempts to develop a simplified procedure are in progress in our laboratory. A large-scale purification procedure has recently been accomplished by Sankyo Co. for the commercial preparation of RNase U,. This procedure mainly consists of repeating the DEAE-Sephadex A-25 column chromatography several times and then using a Sephadex C-50 column chromatography. An RNase U, preparation with the specific activity of 138 could be obtained by this method with a high yield of 22% of the activity of the culture broth. 2. Properties Most of the basic properties of RNase U, are summarized in Tables I1 and IV. It is an acidic protein, most active a t pH 4.5 for RNA digestion (7 ) . It has far less hydrolase activity than phosphotransferase activity (SO). The enzyme preparation obtained possesses a specific activity of about 1.4 x lo3units per OD,,, unit, corresponding to about one-fifth that of RNase T, and twice of that of RNase T,. Ribonuclease U, is as stable as RNase T,. It is fairly resistant to heating a t 80" for 4 min in sodium phosphate buffer, p H 6.9 ( 7 ) . 3. Specificity Ribonuclease U, may be regarded as a purine specific endoribonuclease [ ribonucleate purinenucleotido-2'-transferase (cyclizing) 3 , but the specificity is not absolute. Its mode of action on high molecular weight yeast RNA has been investigated by the 3-terminal analysis of digestion products (SO). As shown in Table XI, RNase U, preferentially splits the phosphodiester bonds of purine nucleotides in RNA. Low concentrations of enzyme (less than 0.5 units/mg of RNA in 0.2 ml) can be used as a nearly purine specific ribonuclease (106'). With about 10-fold larger amounts some phosphodiester bonds of pyrimidine nucle-
236
T. UCHIDA AND F. EGAMI
TABLE XI OF PRODUCTS B Y RNase uz DIGESTION OF 3’-TERMINAL ANALYSIS HIGHMOLECULAR WEIGHT YEASTRNAo RNase UP 0.01 0.107 0.428 1.07 4.28 21.4
53.5 a
(3’-Terminal A/ Total A) X 100
(3’-Termiiial G/ Total G) X 100
(3’-Terminal C/ Total C) X 100
(%I
(%)
(%I
70
46 89 92 96 100 101 95
0 0 0
93 96 100 99 99 100
a 27 57 64
(3’-Terminal U/ Total U) x 100
(%I 0 0 0 0.2 6 20 30
From Uchida et al. (SO). Unit for 1 mg RNA.
otides in RNA are also split. The phosphodiester bond of cytidylic acid is split more readily than that of uridylic acid by RNase Up. According to F. Harada, F. Kimura, and s. Nishimura (unpublished), the phosphodiester bond of uridine-5-oxyacetic acid 3’-phosphate in tRNA can be split by RNase U,. The susceptibility of four nucleotide rcsiducs to RNase U, decreases in the order of A > G >> C > U. Deaminated RNA is more resistant to RNase U, than unmodified RNA. Thus, the presence of the amino group a t the 6 position of purine base (or a t the 4 position of pyrimidine base) seems to be favorable for susceptibility to RNase U,. This suggestion is compatible with the findings that the phosphodiester bond of N - [9- (P-D-ribofuranosyl) -purin-6-ylcarbamoyl] threonine, blocked at the 6 position of adenylyl residue with a large substituent, is resistant to RNase U? (90) and that thioguanosine 2’,3’-cyclic phosphate (240 pg/lOO 1.1) is scarcely hydrolyzed by a large amount of RNase U, (3 units) (S. Irie, T . Uchida, and F. Egami, unpublished). Recently, Hashimoto et al. (35) reported that 7-deazaApU (tubercidylyl- (3’-5’) -uridine) was quite resistant to RNase U2, suggesting that a nitrogen atom a t N-7 of purine base might participate in the preference of substrate to RNase U?. This suggestion was supported by the findings that RNase U2 prefers purine base to pyrimidine base and that methylated RNA including 7-methyl guanylyl residues is also more resistant to RNase Uz than yeast RNA. Both l-methylApU and glyoxalGpU are more resistant to RNase U, than ApU and GpU (SO).Furthermore, it was found that RNase U, does not attack the dinucleoside monophosphates in which N-1 of gua-
9.
MICROBIAL RIBONUCLEASES
237
nylyl residue is blocked with N-cyclohexyl-N'-p- (4-methylmorpholinium) ethylcarbodiimide p-toluene-sulfonate (CMCT) such as CMCGpA and CMC-GpC (108). Considering these results, blocking purine residue a t N-1 appears to decrease its susceptibility to RNase U,. The phosphodiester bonds of xanthylic acid in deaminated RNA were scarcely split by RNase U2 (SO). The susceptibility of purine nucleotide residues to RNase U, decreases in the order of A > G > I >> X, indicating that the phosphodiester bonds of adenylic acid and inosinic acid without a keto group a t the position of purine base are more sensitive to RNase U, than those of guanylic acid and xanthylic acid. The resistance of TNP-RNA to RNase U, may be also attributed to the steric hindrance by a larger substituent at 2-amino groups of guanylyl residues, as with RNase T, (SO). Accordingly, no blocking a t N-1, an amino group a t the 6 position, and a nitrogen atom a t N-7 of the purine base are considered to play an important role in the affinity of the nucleotidyl residue to RNase Uz. Ribonuclease U, digestion of ApU has revealed reduced hydrolase activity in the second step of RNaee U, action (SO). When 87.4% of ApU was readily degraded to produce uridine and adenosine 2',3'-cyclic phosphate, no 3'-adenylic acid was detected. After exhaustive degradation of ApU, hydrolysis of adenosine 2',3'-cyclic phosphate occurred and 3'-adenylic acid gradually appeared. Double-stranded cytoplasmic-polyhedrosis-virusRNA obtained from silkworm was scarcely split by RNase U, (106). 4. Applications Many applications of RNase U, for sequence analysis have been reported. (1) Sequence analysis of longer oligonucleotides in RNase T, digest (90, 9.2, 107): Oligonucleotides produced by RNase T, digestion have no guanylyl residues in the nucleotide chain except 3'-terminal guanylic acid. Thus, as a limited amount of RNase U, specifically splits the phosphodiester bonds of adenylic acid in the nucleotide chain, information on localization of adenylyl residues can be obtained. The nucleotide sequence of oligonucleotide in RNase T, digest can be generally determined by using RNase U, digestion together with pancreatic RNase A digestion; for example, fragment No. 16 obtained from RNase TI digest of tRNAXIeproduced Ap, U-N"-Ap, and C-Gp by RNase U, digestion and A-Up, N"-A-Cp, and Gp by RNase A digestion. Consequently, a unique sequence of fragment No. 16 could be determined to be A-U-N"-A-C-G (90). However, the nucleotide sequence of longer
238
T. UCHIDA AND F. EGAMI
oligonucleotides involving more adenylyl residues in the chain, such as oligonucleotide A obtained from RNase TI digest of R17 RNA, can be determined by combining the results obtained with RNase U, and RNase A and with a new method developed by Gilham (111). After treatment with CMCT reagents reacting with uridylyl and guanylyl residues in RNA, the modified RNA can be split only after cytidylyl residues are split by RNase A. Although oligonucleotide A consists of 21 nucleotide units and contains 7 residues of adenylic acid, a unique sequence can be constructed for it as follows: AAUUAACUAUUCCAAUUUUCG (107) This experiment indicates that adenylate tracts in a nucleotide chain increase its resistance to attack by RNase U,. (2) Specific cleavage of adenylate linkages i n RNA by RNase U,: It is expected that if all guanylyl residues in RNA could be completely modified to any form resistant to RNase U,, RNase U, would split specifically adenylate linkages i n RNA ( 3 0 ) .Based on this consideration, the behavior of RNase U, to the modified RNA with CMCT reagents was investigated (108). It was found that the presence of a blocking group on either side of the phosphodiester linkage was sufficient to confer resistance to RNase U, action. Thus, the action of RNase U, on CMC-modified RNA was restricted to the cleavages of -ApA- and -ApC-. The phosphodiester bond of glyoxalguanylic acid in glyoxalGpU was more resistant to RNase Uy than other bonds (SO). Therefore, if all guanylyl residues in RNA could be modified completely with glyoxal, the fragments having the adenylic acid in 3’ termini would be obtained specifically by RNase U, digestion. However, glyoxalRNA modified completely has not yet been obtained. At present, RNase U, is a unique tool for the synthesis of oligonucleotides through adenosine 2’,3’-cyclic phobphate. The synthesis of adenylyl- (3’-5’)-nuclcoside and oligoadenylic acid by RNase U, has been investigated (T. Koike, T . Uchida, and F. Egami, unpuhlislicd). When adenosine 2’,3’-cyclic phosphate was incubated with about %fold uridine a t a low temperature in the presence of RNase U,, a synthetic product ApU was obtained with a high yield of 37% in regard to the initial adenosine 2’,3’-cyclic phosphate. Other by-products were scarcely detected and 58% of adenosine 2‘,3‘-cyclic phosphate remained unchanged, showing a low hydrolase activity of RNase U,. An optimum condition for the synthesis of ndcnylyl- (3’-5’)-nucleoside by RNaw ITTL. 111. P. T.Gilham. JACS 84, 687 (1962).
9.
239
MICROBIAL RIBONUCLEASES
is the same as that for the synthesis of guanylyl- (3’-5’) -nucleoside by RNase N, (see Section II,D, 4 ) . A large-scale preparation of ApU with RNase U, was also described, suggesting that enzymic synthesis of ApU by RNase U, is an excellent method because of the specific formation of 3‘,5‘-phosphodiester linkage, good yield, simplicity of technique, and economy of time (SO). When adenosine 2‘,3’-cyclic phosphate was incubated with RNase U, for 10 days a t 4” to produce oligo Ap, small oligomers such as ApA cyclic-p (14.1724, ApAp (2.7%), and trimer (5.4%) were obtained, suggesting that RNase U, is somewhat suitable for the synthesis of relatively small oligomers. Ribonuclease U, may bc used for the synthesis of guanylyl-(3’-5’)nucleoside and for the addition of adenylyl residue to 5‘ terminal of oligonucleotides including no guanylyl residue. By the fractionation of RNase U,digests of RNA, oligonucleotides of defined sequence with 3’terminal adenylic acid can be prepared.
111. Other Microbial RNases of Special Interest
Other microbial RNases of special interest from points of view of enzymology or of nucleic acid chemistry are briefly mentioned below. RNase A. EXTRACELLULAR
OF
B. subtilis STRAIN H
An extracellular RNase of Bacillus subtilis strain H was isolated in crystalline state and its chemical nature studied by Nishimura and coworkers (112).I t has a very complicated base specificity (113, 114). However, with a few exceptions, the phosphodiester bonds of 3’-purine nucleotides are cleaved faster than those of 3’-pyrimidine nucleotides, and those of 3’-nucleotides with 6(4)-keto group are cleaved faster than those of 3‘-nucleotides with a 6(4) -amino group. Thus, when adjacent bonds are the same, the following results: -GpXp-
>
-ApNp- u p s p-
> -CpNp-
112. S. Nishimura, P w c e d u r e s Nitcleic Acid Res. p . 56 (1966). 113. P. R . Whitfeld and H. Witzel, BBA 72, 262 (1963). 114. G. W. Hushizky, A . E. Greco, R . R. Hartley, Jr., and H. A. Sober, Bioclirmistry 2, 787 (1963).
240
T. UCHIDA AND F. EGAMI
Although, because of its complicated specificity, it is not easy to use the enzyme with a probable expectation for the nucleotide sequence analysis of RNA, sometimes it has been used with success (115,116). It may be useful especially to digest the large fragments produced by RNase TI. I n this case, it usually splits 3’-adenylyl and 3’-uridylyl bonds but not 3’-cytidylyl bonds. The enzyme has also been used to produce large fragments from tRNA in the presence of Mg2+ (116, 117).
B. INTRACELLULAR RNase OF R. subtilis Nishimura and Maruo (118) extracted and RNase from cells of Bacillus subtilis strain H, which is quite different from the extracellular RNases of the same strain. It is remarkable that the digestion products of RNA by the enzyme are exclusively four nucleoside 2’,3’-cyclic phosphates. The same enzyme has been highly purified from another strain (strain K) of Bacillus subtilis, and their properties have been fully investigated by Yamasaki and Arima (119, 120).They have confirmed the findings by Nishimura and Maruo and have found, moreover, that ATP and dATP strongly inhibit the enzyme. Yamasaki and Arima suggested that ATP might participate in the regulation of intracellular RNase activity. The observation that the final digestion products of RNA by the enzyme are four nucleoside 2’,3’-cyclic phosphates led Ukita and coworkers (121) to utilize the enzyme for the synthesis of various dinucleoside monophosphates. Indeed they have successfully synthesized UpU, CpU, ApU, GpU, UpC, CpC, ApC, and GpC in good yields (from 20 to 75% based on initial nucleoside 2’,3’-cyclic phosphates) by the reaction Ncyclic-p + IV’ NpN’ Other similar enzymes such as intracellular RNase of Azotobacter agilis (122) (strain C) may be used for the same object. --t
115. G . C. Brownlee. F. Sangcr, and B. G. Bnrrell. J M B 34, 379 (1968). 116, F. Haradn, F. Kimura. and S. Nishimura, BBA 195, 590 (1969). 117. K. Oda. F. Kirnura, F. Harada, and S. Nishimura. BBA 179, 97 (1969). 118. S. Nishirnura and B. Maruo, BBA 40, 355 (1960). 119. M. Yamasaki and K . Arirna, BBA 139, 202 (1967). 120. M. Ynrnasaki and K. Arima, BBRC 37, 430 (1969). 121. M . Saito, Y. Furuichi, K. Takeishi. M. Yoshida, M. Ynrnasaki. K. Arima, H. Hayntsu. and T . Ukita. BBA 195, 299 (1969). 122. I. Shiio. K. Ishii. and S. Shirnizu. J. Biochem. ( T o k y o ) 59, 363 (1966).
9. MICROBIAL
241
RIBONUCLEASES
C. RNase PP,
OF
Physarum polycephalum
Hiramaru et al. (123, 124) isolated four RNases and two nucleases from a slime mold, Physarum polycephalum. One (RNase PP,) of the RNases was found to be a novel enzyme. It hydrolyzes RNA in an endonucleolytic way, producing PA, pG, and oligonucleotides bearing 5'-phosphates group with a high preference for purine with regard to 3'-terminal nucleotides. Although the specific cleavage of RNA has to be further confirmed in different conditions, it is suggested that the enzyme will hydrolyze polyribonucleotides as shown below in appropriate experimental conditions. This degradation has the advantage that 3' and 5' terminals in the digests may be easily distinguished by alkaline hydrolysis as nucleosides and nucleoside diphosphates, respectively. pG pA plT pC pC pG pA pA pG pG pC pU pU pG pA pC pU
I
RNase P A
pG/pA/pU PC PC PG/PA/PA/PG/PG/PC PU PU PG/PA/PCPU
D. RNases 11, 111, IV, AND V
OF
E . coli
Among RNases of E . coli so far reported, RNase I is a typical nonbase-specific RNase and is listed in Table XI1 of Section IV. Ribonucleases 11, 111, IV, and V are very characteristic enzymes. The RNase designated RNase I1 of E . coli by Spahr (125) has been purified and extensively studied by Singer and co-workers (126, 127). Ribonuclease I1 of E. coli requires the presence of both a monovalent cation (K') and a divalent cation (Mg*+) for its activity. It has no base specificity but is specific for single-stranded polyribonucleotides. It is an exonuclease, attacking polyribonucleotides from the end of the chain bearing a 3'-OH group to produce 5'-mononucleotides. It hydrolyzes short chain oligoribonucleotides (chain length less than eight) with difficulty. The enzyme may be useful for the sequence analysis near 3' terminal and for obtaining a cluster near 5' terminal. Ribonuclease I11 (128, 129) of E . coli was discovered in 30s extracts 123. M. Hirnmaiu, T. Uchida, and F. Egnnii, J . Biochem. ( T o k y o ) 65, 697 (1969). 124. M. Hiramnru. T. Uchida. and F. Egami, J . Biochem. ( T o k y o ) 65, 701 (1969). 125. P. F. Spnlir, JBC 239, 3716 (1964). 126. M. F. Singer and G . Tolbert, Biochemistry 4, 1319 (1965). 127. N. G. Xossal and M. F. Singer, JBC 243, 915 (1968). 128. H. D. Robertson, H . E. Webster, and N. D. Zinder, Virology 32, 718 (1967). 129. H. D. Robertson, R . E. Webstcr, and S . D. Zinder, JBC 243, 82 (1968).
242
T. UCHIDA AND F. EGAMI
of E. coli. When RNA from q-/3 phage was added to 30s extracts of E. coli to direct protein synthesis, it was found that only the RNase A resistant double-stranded fraction of the RNA was digested completely. This observation led to the discovery of RNase I11 of E . coli. The enzyme remains within osmotically shocked cells ( E . coli 526) attached to the ribosomes. It sediments with the ribosomes in less than 0.20M NH,Cl but is detached a t higher concentrations; thus, it can be liberated from the ribosome fraction with higher NH,Cl concentrations. The free enzyme shows an absolute specificity for polymers containing double helical polyribonucleotide regions. Other polymers (single- and double-stranded DNA’s, single-stranded RNA’s) are not digested, nor do they inhibit the digestion of double-stranded RNA’s when present in excess. Thus the enzyme digests reovirus RNA, polyAU, (poly G) * (poly C ) , but not f, RNA, poly C, f, DNA, E. coli DNA, poly (A-T). I n the case of RNA from phage q-8, only the double-stranded region can be digested by the enzyme. Ribonuclease I11 shows an absolute requirement for divalent cations (Mg2+and Mn2+), and for monovalent cations (K+, NH,+, and Na”); Ca2+ cannot replace Mg2+ or Mn2+.No definite pH optimum is found; however, since it is much more active in alkaline medium (pH 7.6<) than in acidic medium (pH 7 > ) , it is recommended that experiments be carried out a t pH 7.6. The mode of action of the enzyme has not been fully studied. It appears to be endonucleolytic, and the internucleotide cleavage appears to yield a 3’-phosphate and a 5’-hydroxyl group without intermediary formation of 2’,3’-cyclic phosphates. According to Libonati ( I S U ) , Mg2+is required, but K+ is an activator. The lower activity of the enzyme a t lower salt concentration might be partly attributed to the conformational change of RNA. The enzyme is somewhat heat stable a t acidic medium. As the discoverers of the enzyme suggest (129), RNase I11 of E. coli will be an important tool in studies of the function and structure of RNA : “Particularly relevant are studies on the replication of RNA-containing viruses, all of which have a double-stranded stage in their life cycles. Additionally, it may yield specific limited cleavages of such single-stranded RNA molecules as tRNA, ribosomal RNA, and phage RNA. Finally its ability to digest the RNA of DNA-RNA hybrids should provide a further measure of specificity in DNA-RNA hybridization experiments.” Ribonucleases IV and V of E. coli are extremely interesting enzymes, 130. M. Libonati, Boll. SOC.Ital. Biol. Sper. 44, 786 and 789 (1968).
9.
MICROBIAL RIBONUCLEASES
243
but because this nature is quite different from that of typical RNases, they can not be treated adequately here. Ribonuclease IV purified from an RNase I minus strain of E. coli (MRE-600) specifically cleaves R17 RNA into two large fragments, one sedimenting a t about 15s carrying the 5’ terminal of the original molecule, and the other sedimenting a t about 21 S (131). The nature of the bonds cleaved by the enzyme is not known. A new RNase activity, tentatively named RNase V , was found in cell-free extracts of E . coli. Ribonuclease V is an exoribonuclease attacking mRNA from 5‘ to 3‘ terminal producing 5’-mononucleotides. It is characterized by the requirements of ribosomes, G and T factors, tRNA, K+ or NH,’, Mg2+,GTP and a sulfhydryl compound; by its specificity; and by the fact that it degrades poly U, poly A, T, phage mRNA or E . coli mRNA, but not ribosomal RNA (132). It should be mentioned here that a quite different RNase was designated “RNase V of E. coli” in France (133).It hydrolyzes ribosomal RNA, BSRNA, poly U, poly A, poly C , and R17 RNA, but not tRNA.
IV. List of Microbial RNases
Studies on microbial RNases began in 1924 when Noguchi found ribonucleic acid degrading enzymes in Takadiastase (134). Since then extensive studies have been carried out on RNA degrading enzymes. It is rather surprising that guanyloribonuclease so widely distributed in microorganisms was found only in 1957. This is because earlier studies did not consider base specificity. Even quite recently studies on nucleases or ribonucleases do not consider base specificity or do not separate nuclease mixtures from each other; thus, information available on microbial RNases is still scant. Microbial RNases with known substrate specificity are listed in Table XII. Nucleases with DNase activity are not included. It should be noted here that the lists of RNases in both animal and plant kingdoms are presented in the monograph by Privat de Garilhe ( 4 ) and in a chapter by E. A. Barnard in Annual Review of Biochemistry (1969) (135). 131. P.F.Spahr and R. F. Gesteland, Proc. N n l l . Acad. Sci. U . S. 59, 876 (1968). 132. M. Kuwano, C. Ning Kwan, D. Apirion,D. Schlessinger, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.64,693 (1968). 133. F. Ben Hamida and F. R. William, Bull. SOC.Chim. Biol. 51, 1545 (1969). 134. J. Noguchi, Biochem. 2. 147, 255 (1924). 135. E.A. Barnard. Ann. R e v . Biochem. 38, 677 (1969).
TABLE XI1 LIST OF MICROBIAL RNasesa Individual name or source
PH optima
Heat stability
Awtobacter agilis
7.5
Yes in acid
Bacillus cereus
7.9
30,000-40,OOO +Np Non-s
Bacillus pumilus
7.9
10,OOO-15,000
Bacillus subtilis H ( B . amyloliquejacias)
7.5-8.5 Yes
B. subtilis Marburg
5.0
B . subtilis (intracellular)
5.8
Clostridium acetobutylicum RNase I1 E. coli RNase I
4.5
RNase I1
8.1
7-8
MW
-+
N
Other information
>p
- + N p G-s Tra, endo, -+N Np, Non-s
>p+
Intracellular RNase: solnbilization and purification ; effectors; activation by Ca*+ Purification; inactivation by EDTA Purification; no inactivation by EDTA Crystallization; relative specificity, amino acid composition; see text Partial purification
Tra, endo, --* N > p Np, Non-s, hydrolysis very slow Tra, endo, -+N > p Inhibition by EDTA; Non-s effects of nucleotides; see text Endo, -+Np Enzyme formation; purification; effectors
No
-+
Tra, endo, -+N Np, Non-s
Yes in acid
NO
Specificityb Bacteria Tra, endo, Non-s
10,700
E
65,000
>p
-+
Hyd, exo, +pN, Non-s
Purification; basic protein; relative specificity; intracellular localization; activation by Mgz+; compare with related enzymes See text
Ref.
(122)
(140) (140)
(112-114)
(1.41) (118-121)
Y (142)
d
d
X
E
(143-146)
&!
9 q H
2
(125-127)
5
RNase I11 RNase IV and V Lactobacillus casei
7.6-9.7 8.1-8.2 (7.4)
L. plantarum RNase I1
8.6
YeS
M ymbaeterium avium
7.5
Proteus mirabilis RNase I1
7.0
Salmonella typhimurium
7.0
Not so stable
Thwbacillua thwpam IIA IIB IA-2
7.0 9.5 5.5
YeS Yes Yes
Actinomyces
Endo, doublmtrsnded Requirement for M%+and (128-1SO) K+ or N&+; see text specific +Np and pN see text (131-133) Endo, exo, +pN Purification; activation (146) by K+ Hyd, exo, - + p N Purification; monovalent (147) and divalent cations required; single-stranded preferred Purine specific or Purification (148) preferential Tra, +N > p, Non-s Purification (14.99) CpN bonds are fairly resistant (150) Tra, endo, +N > p -+ Intracellular enzyme; Np, Non-s, hydrolysis purification; Na+, K+, and Mgz+ have no effect; very slow. poly I resistant tRNA fairly resistant Endo, +Np, pyr-s
aureoventieillatus
s. albogriseolus
7 . W 3 . 5 Yes in acid
S. erythreus
7.3-7.4
Yes
(151, 162)
Purification; specificity for methylated guanylates; splitting rate of GpNp: GPUP > GPCP Purification; effectors
(137, 138)
8
La 0
E! P F La
CI
8
Z
2
ED
m
Endo, +Np, pyr-s Streptomyces 13,000 Tra, endo, +N NP, G-s
7.6-7.8
Purification
9
> p -+
Tra, endo, -+N > p ---t NP, G-s Tra, endo, + N > p -+ Purification; relative specificity for methylated NP,G-s guanylates
(153)
(136)
2
01
2
TABLE XI1 (Continued) Individual name or source
PH optima
Heat stability
MW
Specificity6
Other information
Ref.
Yeast Endomyces Rhdorula glutinis I
I1
4.5
-+NP
7 4
+pN, Non-s +Np, Non-s
7 7.5
No
Acrocylindrium sp.
8.0
YeS
Aspergillus niger Aspergillus oryzae RNase TI
3.0-3.5
I11 Saccharomyes cerevisiae (Bakers' yeast)
RNase Tt Aspergillus saitoi RNase M
Chalaropsis sp. RNase Ch
+Np, Non-s Hyd, exo, -Np,
Fungi (including a slime mold) Tra, endo, -+N G-s s ~ = .2.59 ~ S +Np, Non-s
7.4-7.5 Yes
11,000
4.5
YeS
36,000
4.0
YeS
30,000
Tra, endo, -+N Np, G-s Tra, endo, +N Np, Non-s Tra, endo, -+N Np, Non-s
(164)
Relation between enzyme formation and culture conditions Non-s
(166-167)
Intracellular enzyme; purification; effectors; activated by phosphate and inhibited by Zn'+
> p, Purification; inhibitors
>p+
See text
(160-169)
See text
> p + See text
>p+
Tra, endo, - + N> p NP, G-s
-+
Purification; inhibition by Zn'+, Cuf+; other effeo tors; kinetic data; photooxidation; inhibition by nucleotides
166)
tiU 1 H
(167)
cl 2-
5
Lenzites tenuis Monasczls pilotus Mucor genevensis
7.9 4.5 7.9
Neurospora craasa RNase NI
7.0
30,000-40,OOO +Np, Non-s 30,000-40,OOO -Np, Non-s 12,000 +Np, G-s Yes
11,000
RNase NZ
8.0
36,000
R N m NI
6-7
A little larger than RNase
Inhibited by EDTA Not inhibited by EDTA Scarcely inhibited by EDTA
Tra, endo, +N > p -+ Formation, see text NP, G-s Tra, endo, I ~ N> p + Formation Np, Non-s Tra, endo, + N > p + Intracellular enzyme; formation Np, G-s
N1 Genetics; inhibited by EDTA
Neurospora crassa
7.5
YeS
Physarum polycepholum RNase PPl
6.7
Yes
40,000
RNase PPt
4.5
YeS
40,000
RNase PPa
5.5
YeS
10,000
RNase PPI
4.0
No
Plmspora
7.5
Rhizopzls RNase
5.0
T r i e o d e m koningi I, I1
4.5
Tra, endo, - + N > p + Np, G-s Tra, endo, -+N > p + Np, Non-s Tka, endo, -+N > p -+ Np, Non-s Hyd, endo, +pN Tra, endo, +N Np, Pur-s
Fairly stable
am,w = 2.42 S
25,000
I
>p+
Endo, -+Np, Non-s, purine preferential
Tra, endo, +N Np, Non-s
>p +
(140) (140) (140)
lo
@,8, 102, 106) (8,102)
r
(8,102)
(loo, 101)
Inhibitors; purification
(1.w
Inhibitors; purification, see text Induced formation; inhibition by phosphate; Michaelis constant Crystallization; inhibited by Znz+,Cu2+;no inhibition by EDTA
(124)
Similar to RNase TZ
(168-170)
(171)
(179)
H
BP
? i c:
TABLE XI1 (Continued) c4
Individual name or source 111
Ustilug0 sphaerogena RNase UI
A
Heat stability
PH optima
00
MW
4.5
Specificityb
Tra, endo, -+N Np, purine preferential
Tra, endo, -+N > p + Np, C-s Tra, endo, +N > p -+ Np, Pw-s Tra, endo, +N > p + Np, Pur-s Hyd, exo, +Xp, Non-s
8.0-8..5
Yes
11 ,OOO
RNase UZ
4.5
Yes
10,oOO
RNase US
4.5
Yes
10,OOO
RNase Ud
8.0-8.5
No
Much larger than U,, Uz
Ustilago me
8.9
No
Euglena gracis Paramecium aurelio
4.5
No
6.5
Yes (I, I1 mixture)
I I1 Teirahymena pyriformis I, 11, I11
>p +
10,oOO
Tra, endo, -tN Np, G-s
> p -+
Other information
Ref.
Activated by Mg"
Induced formation; see text See text
Induced formation Induced formation
Protozoa Non-s Non-s
Inhibitors; inhibited by H$+; resistant to other metal ions
Tra, endo, +N > p -+ Np, I, 11, 111, relative specificity different
4 M urea increases the
5.5 5.0
~~~~
activity
~
With the collaboration of Dr. E. Ohmura. * Abbreviations: tra, transphosphorylation; hyd, direct hydrolysis; >p, 2',3'-cyclic phosphate; endo, endonucleolytic; exo, exonucleolytic; Non-s, nonspecific; G-s, guanine specific; Pur-s, purine specific; Pyr-s, pyrimidine specific. 0
1
s
E
9.
MICROBIAL RIBONUCLEASES
249
Since the information is still scant, it is probably premature t o draw general conclusions on the distribution of different RNases in animals, higher plants, and microorganisms. However, it may be pointed out that to date, RNases found in higher plants are nonbase-specific, that both nonbase-specific and pyrimidine-specific RNases are found in animals, and that guanine-specific and purine-specific RNases are found only in microorganisms. Guanyloribonueleases are, as shown in Table XII, widely distributed in microorganisms, especially in fungi and streptomyces. These guanyloribonucleases may exhibit different fine relative specificity. Indeed the action of RNase TI and guanyloribonucleases of streptomyces or actinomyces on minor components in tRNA such as methylated guanylyl bonds or on chemically modified guanylyl bonds has been reported to be different (136‘-139).Further studies on such fine relative specificity are required. 136. K. Tanaka, Procedures Nucleic Aczd Res. p. 14 (1966). 137. N. H. Abrosimova-Amelyanchik, R. I. Tatarskaya, T. V. Venkstern, V. D. hksel’rod, and A. A. Bayev, Biokhimiyu 30, 1269 (1965); Biochemistry (USSR) (English Transl.) 30, 1 W (1965). 138. It. I. Tatarskaya, N. H. Abrosimova-Amelyanchik, and V. D. Aksel’rod, Biokhimiyu 31, 1017 (1966); Biochemistry (USSR) (English Trunsl.) 31, 882 (1966). 139. N. K. Konchetkov, E. I. Budowsky, N. E. Broude, and L. M. Klebanova, BBA 134, 492 (1967). 140. G. W. Rushizky, A. E. Greco, R. W. Hartley, Jr., and H. A. Sober, JBC 239, 2165 (1964). 141. M. Nikai, I. Minami, T. Yamasaki, and A. Tsugita, JBC 57, 96 (1965). 142. M. Tomoyeda, H. Horitsu, and K. Kumagai, Res. Bull. Fac. Agr., Gifu Univ. 28, 153 (1969). 143. P. F. Spahr and B. R. Hollingworth, JBC 236, 823 (1961). 144. Y.Anraku and D. Mizuno, BBRC 18, 462 (1965). 145. Y. Anraku and D. Mizuno, J . Biochem. (Tokyo) 61, 70 (1967). 146. H.M. Keir, R. H. Mathog, and C. E. Carter, Biochemistry 3, 1188 (1964). 147. D.M. Logan and M. F. Singer, JBC 243, 6161 (1968). 148. A. Tsugita and K. Matsui, Seikagaku 41, 588 (1969). 149. M. S. Center and F. J. Behal, BBA 151, 698 (1968). 150. K. Chakraburtty and D. I?. Burma, JBC 243, 1133 (1968). 151. W. Ostrowski and Z. Walczak, Actu Biochim. Polon. 8, 345 (1961). 152. Z. Walczak and W. Ostrowski, Actu Biochim. Polon. 11, 241 (1964). 153. M. Yoneda, J. Biochem. (Tokyo) 55, 469 (1964). 154. T. Hattori and S. Nakamura, Seikaguku ( T o k y o ) 38, 563 (1966). 155. Y.Nakao and K. Ogata, Agr. B i d . Chem. (Toyko) 27, 116 (1963). 156. Y. Nakao and K. Ogata, Agr. Biol. Chem. (Toyko) 27, 499 (1963). 157. Y. Nakao and K. Ogata, Agr. B i d . Chem. (Tokyo) 27, 507 (1963). 158. Y.Ohtaka, K.Uchida, and T. Sakai, J . Biochem. ( T o k y o ) 54, 322 (1963). 159. I. Suhara, F. Kusaka, and E. Ohmura, Koso Kagaku Shimpoziumu 16, 115 (1964).
250
T. UCHIDA AND F. EGAMI
160. Y. Eto, Y. Goto, and M. Tomoyeda, Nippon Nogei Kagaku Taikai Abstr., p. 30 (1969).
161. Y. Azuma, H. Horitsu, and M. Tomoyeda, Nippon Nogei Kagaku Taikai Abstr., p. 30 (1969). 162. H. Horitsu, K. Okamoto, Y. Azuma, and M. Tomoyeda, Nippon Nogei Kagaku Taikai Abstr., p. 30 (1969). 163. M. Irie, J. Biochem. ( T o k y o ) 62, 509 (1967). 164. M. h i e , J. Biochem. ( T o k y o ) 65, 133 (1969). 165. M. Irie, J. Biochem. ( T o k y o ) 66, 569 (1969). 166. M. Irie, J. Biochem. ( T o k y o ) 66, 907 (1969). 167. J. H. Hash and E. Elsevier, Science 162, 681 (1968). 168. C. M. Cuchillo, J. M. Ventura, E. Concustell, and V. Villar-Palasi, R e v . Espan. Fisiol. 23, 81 (1967). 169. C. M. Cuchillo, J. M. Ventura, E. Concustell, and V. Villar-Palasi, R e v . Espan. Fkiol. 23, 87 (1967). 170. C. M. Cuchillo, J. M. Ventura, E. Concustell, and V. Villar-Palasi. R e v . Espan. Fkiol. 23, 93 (1967). 171. M. Tomoyeda, Y. Eto, and T. Yoshino, ABB 131, 191 (1969). 172. M. Hamada and M. I r k , Seikagaku 41, 587 (1969). 173. M. Yanagida, T . Uchida, and F. Egami, Nippon Nogei Kagaku Kaishi 38, 531 (1964). 174. J. Fellig and C. E. Wiley, Science 132, 1835 (1960). 175. G. Gross, B. Skoczylas, and W. Tunski, Acta Protozoal. 4, 59 (1966). 176. L. H. Lazarus and 0. H. Scherbaum, BBA 142, 368 (1967).
Bacterial Deoxvribonucleases I. R. LEHMAN I. Introduction
.
.
.
.
.
.
11. Exonucleases . . . . . . -1.E . coli Exonucleases I :uid 111
.
. . B. Phage A-Induced Exonuclcmc~ . C. E . coli Exonurleasr IV . . .
.
. . . .
.
. . . . D. Pltitge T2- and T4-Intluced ISxonuc1r:iscs .
.
. . . . .
.
. . . . .
.
. . . . .
E. Exonucleases Associated with E . coli DNA Polymerase F. B . subtilis Phage SP-3 Induced Exonuclease . . . G . E . coli ATP-Dependent DNase . . . . . . 111. Endonucleases . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Nonspecific Endonucleases . . . . . . . B. Specific Endonucleases . . . . . . . .
.
251
.
255 258 259 259 259 262
. 252 . 253 . 253 . 254 . 255 .
. . . .
I. Introduction
Deoxyribonucleases, enzymes which hydrolyze specifically the internucleotide bonds of polydeoxynucleotides, have been described in many bacteria. A useful general classification first introduced by Laskowski ( 1 ) divides these enzymes into exonucleases and endonucleases depending upon their mode of attack. Endonucleases attack polynucleotides at many points within the chain, generally producing only a small proportion of mononucleotides ; cxo~iucleases catalyze a stepwise attack a t either the 3’ or 5’ terminus of a polynucleotide, producing predominantly mononucleotides. Recent detailed investigation of several of the purified bacterial deoxyribonucleases has indicated that this categorization is overly 1. M . Laskowski, Ann. N . Y . Acad. Scz. 81, 776 (1959). 251
252
I. R. LEHMAN
simplified and in fact a single physically homogeneous protein may have the capacity to catalyze both the exo- and endonucleolytic cleavage of diester bonds depending upon the structure of its macromolecular substrate. All of the bacterial deoxyribonucleases that have been examined in detail possess a specificity directed in varying degrees toward the secondary structure of the polydeoxynucleotide. With one recent exception, none of the deoxyriboriucleases shows a simple base specificity whereby they attack phosphodiester bonds adjacent to a single base. However, it is now clear that several of the endonucleases may possess an extremely high order of specificity and have the capacity to recognize and attack one or a few phosphodiester bonds in polydeoxynucleotide chains composed of many thousands of internucleotide linkages. In this review, the bacterial deoxyribonucleases to be considered will be divided into exonucleases and endonucleases. The latter category will be further subdivided into “nonspecific” endonucleases ; that is, enzymes which do not show a high level of specificity for the internucleotide bond split and are, as a result, capable of degrading polynucleotides to a mixture of relatively small oligonucleotides and “specific” endonucleases, which display a high level of specificity for a given sequence within the polynucleotide chain, and as a consequence, introduce only a very few cleavages into a high molecular weight polynucleotide. As noted above, the enzymes to be discussed are those which attack polydeoxynucleotides exclusively. Thus, nucleases from, for example, Bacillus subtilis (2-4), Serratia marcescens ( 5 ) , and Staphylococcus aureus (6),which attack both RNA and D N A will not be considered. Such an enzyme from S. aureus is, however, the subject of Chapter 7 by Cotton and Hazen and Chapter 8 by Anfinsen et al. in this volume.
It. Exonucleases
The bacterial D N A exonucleases which have been purified and examined in detail are with two exceptions derived from E . coli and E . coli infected with bacteriophages; all show a strong specificity for the secondary structure of their polydeoxynucleotide substrate.
2. 3. 4. 5. 6.
I. M. Berr. J. R. Chien. iintl I. R. Lehniun, JBC 242, 2700 (1967). R. Okazaki, T. Okazaki, and K. Sakabe, BBRC 22, 611 (1966). H. C. Birnboim, J . Bacterial. 91, 1004 (1966). M. Nestle and W. K. Roberts, JBC 244, 5213 and 5219 (1969). L. Cunningham. B. W. Catlin. and M. Privut De Garilhe. JACS 78, 4642 (1956).
10.
BACTERIAL DEOXYRIBONUCLEASES
253
A. E. coli EXONUCLEASES I AND IIL Both E. coli exonucleases I and I11 have been considered in a recent review (7) and will not be discussed in detail here. It is, however, worth noting again that they are prototypes of nucleases with an extreme specificity for the secondary structure of their substrate. Thus, exonuclease I attacks only single-stranded polynucleotides and exonuclease I11 has an equally strong preference for double-stranded structures. In both instances, once the structural requirements have been met, the enzymes initiate their attack a t the 3'-hydroxyl termini sequentially liberating 5'-mononucleotides. In the case of exonuclease 111, hydrolysis ceases once the bihelical structure is lost as a result of sustained exonucleolytic attack. Exonuclease I is unable to cleave dinucleotides ; hence, the terminal and penultimate residues situated at the 5' end of the polynucleotide substrate remain as a residual dinucleotide. Recent experiments by Masamune and Richardson (8) have demonstrated that exonuclease I11 is able to initiate its attack a t an internally located 3'hydroxyl group in a DNA duplex (i.e., a t a single-stranded interruption) as well as a t the 3'-hydroxyl group at the end of the chain. Finally, it should be noted that exonuclease I11 possesses an intrinsic DNA-phosphatase activity which specifically removes 3'-phosphoryl groups from double-stranded polynucleotides. This enzyme when acting on a 3'-phosphoryl-terminated DNA, first removes the 3'-phosphoryl group as inorganic phosphate, then proceeds as an exonuclease with the stepwise release of deoxynucleoside 5'-monophosphates (9). Lacks and Greenberg (10) have purified an exonuclease from Diplococcus pneumoniae with properties very similar to E. coli exonuclease 111. The pneumococcal enzyme acts preferentially on native DNA producing 5'-mononucleotides and single strands which are not susceptible to further attack. Like exonuclease I11 it shows an intrinsic 3'-phosphoryl-DNA phosphatase activity. A DNA phosphatase-exonuclease activity has also been reported in B. subtilis (11).
B. PHAGEA-INDUCEDE'XONUCLEASE The exonuclease synthesized after induction of h lysogens or after infection with virulent mutants of this phage has received a great deal 7. I . R . Leliman, Ann. Rev. Biochem. 36, 645 (1967). 8. Y. Masamune and C. C. Hichardson, Biophys. Soc. Abstr. p. 18a (1970) 9. C . C. Richardson and A . Kornberg, JBC 239, 242 (1964). 10. S. Lacks and B. Greenberg, JBC 242, 3108 (1967). 11. T. Okazaki and A . Kornberg, JBC 239, 259 (1964).
254
I. R. LEHMAN
of attention because of its involvement in h-recombination. The h exonuclease has been obtained in physically homogeneous, crystalline form and is the only one of the bactcrial DNases available a t this level of purity (12). Phage h possesses its own recombination system, the “red” system (13, 14) which permits its DNA to undergo recombination in recombination deficient (rec-) hosts ( 1 5 ) . Thc rctl systcm is composed of three complementation groups, two of which define the structural gene for the A exonuclease (16). The h exonuclease is antipodal to exonuclease I11 in its polarity of attack ; thus, it specifically degrades double-stranded DNA, starting a t the 5’-phosphoryl terminus, sequentially liberating 5’-mononucleotides. As in the case of exonuclease 111, single strands are generated which are then not susceptible to further hydrolysis (17). The h-exonuclease shows a very strong preference for termini bearing 5’-phosphoryl groups. Unlike exonuclease 111, the h-induced nuclease is unable t o attack a t single-stranded breaks within a DNA duplex (8). Clearly, both exonuclease I11 and h exonuclease could be responsible for the production of the single-stranded regions in recombining DNA molecules postulated in most current models of genetic recombination (18).
C. E. coli EXONUCLEASE IV Exonuclease IV is distinguished from the other DNA exonucleases of E. coli by its strong preference for relatively short chain oligonucleotide substrates (19). Native and denatured DNA are degraded a t rates less than one-twentieth those observed with oligonucleotide mixtures derived from pancreatic DNase digests of DNA. At present it is not clear whether this reflects an inability of the enzyme to bind to macromolecular DNA or the relatively low concentration of DNA molecules compared to oligonucleotide chains present in the usual assay mixtures. Exonuclease IV requires magnesium ion and is optimally active a t alkaline p H (pH 8-9). It produces 5’-mononucleotides exclusively, presumably by an exonucleolytic attack starting a t the 3’terminus, although this latter point 12. J. W. Little. I. R. Lehmnn. and A. D. Kaiser, JBC 242, 672 (1967). 13. H. Echols, R. Gingery, and L. Moore, J M B 34, 251 (1968). 14. E. R. Signer and J. Weil, J M B 34, 261 (1968). 15. A. J. Clark, J . Cellular Physiol. 70, Part 11, Suppl. 1, 165 (1967). 16. C. M. Radding, J. Szpirer, and R. Thomas, Proc. N a l l . Acad. Sci. U . S. 57, 277 (1967). 17. J. W. Little, JBC 242, 679 (1967). 18. C. C. Richardson, Ann. Rev. Biorhem. 38, 795 (1969). 19. A. E. Oleson and J. F. Koerner, JBC 239, 2935 (1964).
10.
BACTERIAL DEOXYRIBONUCLEASES
255
has not been established definitively. Koerner and his colleagues have found that exonuclease I V separates into two subfractions, termed IVa and IVb, upon gradient chromatography on columns of DEAE-cellulose (20). Though chromatographically distinct, exonucleases IVa and IVb have identical pH optima, divalent cation requirement, substrate specificity, and thermolability. The origin and significance of the two fractions are unknown.
D.
PHAGE
T2-
AND
T4-INDUCED EXONUCLEASES
An exonuclease catalytically very similar to exonuclease IV appears after infection of E. coli with phages T2 and T4 (19).Yet another catalytically indistinguibhable cxonuclease activity is synthesized after T2 and T 4 phage infection and is closely associated with the T2- and T4induced DNA polymerases (21, 2 2 ) . An amber mutant which maps in the structural gene for the T4 DNA polymerase has been found by Nossal to induce the polymerase-associated exonuclease but not the polymerase ( 2 3 ) .Both of the phage-induced exonucleases act optimally on mixtures of small oligonucleotides producing 5’-mononucleotides. Recent experiments by Richardson et al. (8) and by Kornberg and his colleagues (24) have demonstrated a 3’+5‘ polarity of attack by the polymerase-associated exonuclease. E. EXONUCLEASES ASSOCIATED WITH E . coli DNA POLYMERASE The hydrolytic activity of E . coli DNA polymerase has until recently been termed exonticlease 11 primarily because of the uncertainty as to whether the polymerizing and hydrolytic functions of the purified enzyme were part of a single unit ( 2 5 ) .I t is now apparent as a result of studies in Kornberg’s laboratory that DNA polymerase is a homogeneous protein composed of a single polypeptide chain with a single binding site for a DNA terminus and that the polymerizing and hydrolytic activities both involve a common active site ( 2 6 ) . A detailed investigation of the 20. S. E. Jorgensen and J. F. Koerner. JBC 241, 3090 (1966). 21. E. C. Short and J. F. Koerner. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S. 54, 595 (1965). 22. M. Goulian, Z. J. Lucas, and A. Kornberg. JBC 243, 627 (1968). 23. N . G. Nossal, JBC 244, 218 (1969). 24. N. R. Cozzarelli, R . B. Kelly, and A. Komberg, J M B 45, 513 (1969). 25. I. R. Lehman and C . C.Richardson. JBC 239, 233 (1964). 26. A . Kornberg, Science 163, 1410 (1969).
256
I. R. LEHMAN
exonucleolytic activity by Deutscher and Kornberg (27) and independently by Klett et al. (28) has in fact shown that there are two exonucleolytic activities of opposite polarity intrinsic to the polymerase. One catalyzes an attack starting at 3’-hydroxyl terminus (3’ + 5’) ; the second attacks a t the 5’-phosphoryl terminus (5’- 3’). 1. 3‘ + 5’ Exonuclease
Early studies of the nuclease activity associated with purified preparations of E . coli DNA polymerase indicated that it catalyzed an exonucleolytic attack on both double- and single-stranded polydeoxynucleotides beginning a t the 3’-hydroxyl end, liberating deoxynucleoside 5’-monophosphates. Upon prolonged incubation, hydrolysis to mononucleotides was complete ( 2 5 ) . It is now clear that hydrolysis of single-stranded polymers results exclusively from the 3‘ + 5’ exonuclease component of the polymerase. This activity is optimal in tris buffer a t p H 8.6 and in glycine buffer a t p H 9.2. It has an absolute requirement for a free 3‘hydroxyl group ; 3’-phosphoryl-terminated polynucleotides are resistant ( 2 7 ) .It therefore resembles very closely the exonuclease activity associated with the T4-induced D N A polymerase ( 2 2 ) .Like the phage-induced enzyme, the 3’ + 5‘ exonuclease activity of the E . coli DNA polymerase is almost completely abolished under conditions of DNA synthesis (22, 2 9 ) . Presumably a single 3‘-hydroxyl terminus site serves for either polymerization or 3’ + 5’ hydrolysis. Since the 3’ 3 5’ exonuclease activity removes nucleotide residues a t the same site in the polynucleotide chain (3’-hydroxyl) a t which the polymerizing activity adds nucleotides it has been suggested that this exonuclease activity represents an errorcorrecting mechanism whereby improperly paired nucleotides are removed in the course of synthesis (26). 2. 5’ + 3’ Exonuclease
Studies by Klett et al. (28) with a synthetic d (A-T) copolymer in which diamino purine replaced adenine a t the 3’ end and by Deutscher and Kornberg (27) with 3’-phosphoryl-terminated polynucleotides led to the finding that purified preparations of E . coli D N A polymerase possess a 5‘ += 3‘ exonucleolytic activity. In the latter studies DNA preparations with 3‘-phosphoryl termini introduced by the action of staphylococcal nuclease (6) and therefore inscnsitiw to 3’+ 5’ exonuclease action were 27. M. P. Deutscher and A. Kornberg, IBC 244, 3029 (1969). 28. R. P. Klett, A. Ccrarni, and E. Reich, Proc. Natl. Acnrl. Sci. ”. 8. 60, 943 (1968). 29. D. Brutlag, M. R. Atkinson, P. Setlow. and .4.Kornberg, BBRC 37, 982 (1969).
10.
BACTERIAL DEOXY RIBONUCLEASES
257
found to be extensively degraded by purified DNA polymerase preparations yielding 5’-mononucleotides and oligonucleotides terminating in a 3’-phosphoryl group. Detailed investigation of this phenomenon showed that the 5’+ 3’ exonuclease activity occupies a site on the enzyme distinct from the 3’+ 5’ exonuclease. Unlike the latter i t has a strong preference for double-stranded polynucleotide substrates and displays a broad pH optimum ranging from p H 7.4 to 9.2 (a7). The products of 5‘+ 3‘ exonuclease action consist of dinucleotides in addition to 5‘mononucleotides. This was demonstrated in an experiment in which hydrolysis of d (pT) 300 was compared with d (pT)3oo annealed to d (PA) 4&oo and d(pT)joo blocked at the 3’ terminus by a dideoxythymidine residue also annealed to d (PA) 4ooo. The dinucleotide d (pT), was observed among the products of hydrolysis only in the latter two cases; it was not found when single-stranded d (pT)3oo was degraded, i.e., in the absence of 5’- 3‘ exonuclease action. Kinetic studies showed that the rate of appearance of dinucleotides relative to mononucleotides during 5’ 3’ hydrolysis was not altered as a function of time ( 2 4 ) . In further contrast to the 3’ 4 5’ exonuclease, the 5’ + 3’ exonuclease activity was strongly stimulated (as much as 40-fold) by simultaneous synthesis ; moreover, an increased frequency of oligonucleotides was observed among the products of 5 ‘ 4 3’ hydrolysis during synthesis, and oligonucleotides in lengths ranging up to the hexanucleotide appeared (SO). The increase in 5‘ 3’ exonuclease activity accompanying polymerization of nucleotides a t the 3’ termini of the primer strands has been explained by postulating that the DNA polymerase binds a nicked region of a DNA duplex in its active center, thus bringing the 3‘-hydroxyland 5‘-phosphoryl-terminated chains in close alignment. The synthetic activity, by advancing the 3‘-hydroxyl terminus keeps the latter adjacent to or near the 5’ end and increases the rate of release of 5’-mononucleotides at this terminus. The release of oligonucleotides may be the result of the failure of the DNA polymerase to cleave terminal bonds, thereby resulting in exposure of the second or subsequent phosphodiester linkages to hydrolysis a t the 5’+ 3‘ exonuclease site (24).In the case of d(pT)300 with a tetradeoxycytidylate region a t the 5’ terminus annealed to d the deoxycytidylate residues which do not hydrogen bond to the d (PA)4ooo were found to be excised as oligonucleotides ( 3 1 ) .Hence, the 5’- 3‘ exonuclease is able to hydrolyze double-stranded DNA in the duplex region beyond a set of non-hydrogen-bonded residues, removing
-
-
30. R. B. Kelly, N . R. Cozzarelli. M. P. Deutscher. I. R. Lehman, and A. Kornberg, JBC 245, 39 (1970). 31. R. B. Kelly, M. R. Atkinson, J. A . Huberman, and A. Kornberg, Nature 224,
495 (1969).
258
I. R. LEHMAN
oligonucleotides containing these residues. This property of the 5' + 3' exonuclease may play a general role in the removal of mismatched regions, for example, pyrimidine dimers. Kelly et al. (31) have, in fact, found that the 5' + 3' exonuclease can excise oligonucleotides containing thymine dimers from ultraviolet-irradiated d (pT) annealed to d(pA),," as well as from irradiated DNA. I n contrast, the 3'+ 5' exonuclease like E . coli exonuclease I and snake venom phosphodiesterase (31, 3 2 ) is blocked at the point in the (pT):joo a t which it encounters a thymine dimer. Studies by Jovin et al. (33) had shown that acylation of the enzyme with N-carboxymethylisatoic anhydride resulted in a total destruction of polymerase activity with a concomitant 9-fold enhancement of exonuclease activity as measured a t pH 7.4. More recently, Brutlag e t al. (29) and Klenow and Henningsen (34) independently discovered that the 5'+ 3' exonuclease activity could be dissociated from the remainder of the DNA polymerase molecule by limited proteolysis with subtilisin or trypsin. Thus, treatnicnt of the polymerase, a single polypeptide chain of molecular weight 109,000, with these proteases led to the generation of two fragments of 76,000 and 34,000 molecular weight. The larger fragment retained the polymerizing activity and the 3' + 5' exonuclease activity ; the small fragment contained the 5' + 3' exonuclease. The 76,000 molecular weight fragment derived from the E . coli DNA polymerase is therefore similar to the T4-induced polymerase in that both enzymes, contain only the 3'+ 5' exonuclease in addition to the polymerizing activity. The phage-induced enzyme, despite the lack of 5' 3 3'-exonuclease, has a molecular weight of approximately 110,000 (22).
F. B. subtilis PHAGE SP-3-INDUCED EXONUCLEASE Trilling and Aposhian have partially purified a DNase from extracts of B. subtilis infected with phage SP-3 ( 3 5 ) .This enzyme requires magnesium ion and shows optimal activity between pH 7.8 and 8.9 in Tris buffers. It is highly specific for denatured DNA and appears to catalyze a unique type of exonucleolytic attack beginning a t the 5' end of the chain which sequentially releases dinucleotides. Neither mono32. L. Grossman, J. C . Kaplan, s. R. Kushner. and I. Mahler, Cold Spriltg Harbor Symp. Quant. Biol. 38, 229 (1968). 33. T. M. Jovin, P. T. Englund, and A . Kornberg, JBC 244, 3009 (1969). 34. H. Klenow and I. Henningsen, Proc. Nutl. Acad. Sci. U.S. 65, 168 (1970). 35. D. M. Trilling and H. V. Aposhian, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci U. S . 60, 214 (1968).
10. BACTERIAL
DEOXYRIBONUCLEASES
259
nucleotides nor oligonucleotides of intermediate size between dinucleotides and the polymeric DNA substrate (with the exception of a few percent trinucleotides) is observed at any time during hydrolysis.
G. E. coli ATP-DEPENDENT DNASE An ATP-dependent DNase has been partially purified from extracts of E . coli by Oishi (36) and Barbour and Clark (37). It shows an absolute requirement for magnesium or manganese ion and has a broad pH optimum ranging from pH 7.5 to 9.5. The partially purified enzyme preferentially degrades native DNA (including glucosylated T4 DNA) and has an almost absolute requirement for ATP or dATP. Current preparations of the enzyme are also active on denatured DNA; however, there is only a slight stimulation of hydrolysis by added ATP. This latter activity may therefore represent some contamination with exonuclease I. The mode of attack is stated to be exonucleolytic. A particularly interesting feature of the ATP-dependent DNase is its possible involvement in genetic recombination. Thus, certain recombination deficient strains of E . coli with the recB- and r e d - phenotypes (16) appear to lack this enzyme.
111. Endonucleases
A. NONSPECIFIC ENDONUCLEASES
1. E . coli Endonuclease I The existence of a deoxyribonuclease in E . coli bound to an inhibitory RNA was first suggested by Kozloff (38) who found that the DNase activity of freshly prepared extracts could be markedly enhanced by pretreatment with ribonuclease. The enzyme was subsequently purified and freed of inhibitor (39). The purified enzyme termed endonuclease I could, in turn, be competitively inhibited by a variety of RNA's inM (nucleotide) cluding transfer RXA, and K , values as low as have been observed (40). Examination of various purified RNA species and synthetic polyribonucleotides for their inhibitory activity has led M. Oislii, Proc. N a t l . Acud. Sci. U . S. 64, 1292 (1969). S. D. Barbour and A . J. Clark, I'roc. N o t / . Acad. Sci. U . S. 65, 955 (1970). L. M . Kozloff. Cold Spritig Harbor Sump. Qiront. Bid. 18, 209 (1953). I. H . Lehman, G. G . Roussos, und E. A. Pratt. JBC 237, 819 (1962). 40. I . R. Lehman, G. G. Roussos, and E. A . Pratt, JBC 237, 829 (1962).
36. 37. 38. 39.
260
I. R. LEHMAN
to the suggestion that some ordered conformation is required for a polynucleotide to be an effective inhibitor ( 7 ) . Endonuclease I has a pH optimum ranging from pH 7.5 to 8.5 and absolutely requires magnesium or manganese ion for activity. It degrades native DNA a t a rate sevenfold greater than denatured DNA. Attack is purely endonucleolytic yielding oligonucleotides terminated by 5’-phosphoryl groups. The enzyme shows little, if any, base specificity and limit digests produced after exhaustive digestion of DNA contain a mixture of oligonucleotides with an average chain length of 7 residucs. Analysis of the oligonucleotides has shown an almost random distribution of nucleotides a t the 3’ and 5‘ termini. Studier (41) and independently Bernardi and Cordonnier ( 4 2 ) have found that endonuclease I cleaves both strands of a DNA double helix a t or near the same level. Paoletti et al. (43) have examined this question in greater detail employing a fluorometric method based on the increase in the amount of ethidium bromide bound to closed circular duplex DNA upon the introduction of a single-stranded break ( 4 4 ) . In contrast to pancreatic DNase in which there was a linear increase in fluorescence, nonlinear kinetics were observed with endonuclease I. Further investigation of this phenomenon led to the suggestion that endonuclease I possesses a significant exonucleolytic component with the result that approximately 400 nucleotides are removed at each endonucleolytic scisson introduced by the enzyme. Consequently, endonuclease I does not promote a clean double-stranded break but rather causes a “shattering” a t the point of cleavage, leading to the liberation of small oligonucleotides, presumably by an exonucleolytic mode of attack. 2. Streptococcal and Pneumococcal Endonucleases
A deoxyribonuclease termed streptodornase, optimally active a t pH 7.0 in the presence of magnesium ion, has been partially purified from culture fluids of Streptococcus pyogenes (45). This enzyme yields a distribution of products from DNA very similar to that seen with E . coli endonuclease I: Only traces of mono- and dinucleotides are found, the majority of products being rather large oligonucleotides terminated by 41. F. W . Studier, J M B 11, 373 (1965). 42. G. Bernardi and C. Cordonnier, J M B 11, 141 (1965). 43. C. Paoletti. J. B. LePccq. and I. R. Leliman. J M B (1971) (in press). 44. R. Radloff. W. Baucr, and J. Vinograd, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U . S . 57, 1514 (1967). 45. M. Laskowski, “The Enzymes,” 2nd ed.. Vol. 5. p. 123. 1961.
10.
BACTERIAL DEOXYRIBONUCLEASES
26 1
5‘-phosphate groups. Like E. coli endonuclease I, streptococcal endonuclease is inhibited by RNA. A careful study of various strains of Streptococcus by Wannamaker has demonstrated that group A streptococci produce three different DNases (A, B, and C) which can be distinguished by their electrophoretic and immunological properties and by their pH optima ( 4 6 ) . The relative amount of each enzyme produced appears to be a function of strain variation. Streptodornase has been identified with DNase A. Lacks and Greenberg havc partially purified an endonuclease from Diplococcus pneumoniae in conjunction with the exonuclease cited in Section II,A (10). This enzyme is active on both native and denatured DNA and produces 5’-phosphoryl-terminated olingonucleotides. 3. Phage TS-Induced DNase
A deoxyribonuclease not normally present in E . coli is rapidly synthesized after infection with phage T5 (4‘7‘). This DNase appears at approximately the same time as the other “early” phage-specific enzymes (DNA polymerase and deoxynucleotide kinase, etc.) induced following infection with this bacteriophage. The T5-induced DNase has been purified nearly to the point of physical homogeneity. It has a pH optimum of pH 9.3 in glycine buffer and absolutely requires a divalent cation (magnesium or manganese) for activity. The mode of attack by the enzyme appears to be both endonucleolytic and exonucleolytic, yielding ultimately a mixture of 5’phosphoryl-terminated mononucleotides and oligonucleotides of average chain length 6 5 . Although the enzyme attacks both native and denatured DNA a t approximately the same rate, the proportion of mononucleotides produced from denatured DNA at the limit of digestion is only about one-fourth that found with native DNA. 4. M . luteus ATP-Dependent Endonuclease
In 1964, Tsuda and Strauss discovered a DNase activity in crude extracts of Micrococcus lysodeikticus (later renamed Micrococcus luteus) which required a nucleoside di- or triphosphate for activity ( 4 8 ) . This enzyme has recently been purified extensively (2400-fold) and examined in detail by Takagi and his colleagues (49). It has an alkaline pH L. W. Wannamaker, J . Exptl. M e d . 107, 797 (1958). A. V . Paul and I. R. Lehman. JBC 241, 3441 (1966). Y. Tsuda and B. S. Strauss, Biocl~emistry3, 1678 (1964). M . Anai. T. Hirahashi, and Y. Tukagi, JBC 245, 767 (1970); M. Anai, T. Hirahashi, M. Yamanaka, and Y. Tnkagi, ibid. p. 775. 46. 47. 48. 49.
262
I. R. LEHMAN
optimum (pH 9.4) and requires a divalent cation, preferably magnesium ion for activity. Double-stranded DNA is degraded a t a rate 40-fold greater than denatured DNA. The mode of attack is endonucleolytic yielding 5’-phosphoryl-terminated oligonucleotides with an average chain length of 5.5 residues a t the limit of digestion. A kinetic analysis of DNA degradation by the M . luteus endonuclease by means of sucrose density gradient centrifugation of the products as hydrolysis proceeded showed that the DNA added initially disappeared and was replaced by very slowly sedimenting material. Products of intermediate size were not detectable. Takagi and his colleagues interpreted these findings in terms of a one-by-one type of degradation in which the products of the initial hydrolysis possess a higher affinity for the enzyme than the undegraded DNA substrate, with the result that a DNA molecule initially attacked is degraded to completion before attack of a second molecule is begun. The role of the nucleoside triphosphate in the hydrolysis of DNA has not yet been clarified. ATP and dATP are the most effective nucleotides and only slight activity (10% or less) is observed with the other triphosphates ; nucleoside diphosphates are inactive. The rate of DNA hydrolysis is proportional to the ATP concentration and the ATP is converted to ADP and inorganic phosphate in the course of the reaction. Three moles of ATP are consumed for each phosphodiester bond cleaved, indicating a complex mechanism of participation of ATP in the endonucleolytic reaction. Preliminary experiments by Takagi and his colleagues indicate that the purified enzyme catalyzes an exchange of ADP with ATP in the absence of DNA, suggesting that a phospho enzyme may be an intermediate.
B. SPECIFIC ENDONUCLEASES During the past three years endonucleases have been discovered which possess a specificity which is considerably more refined than that shown by the nucleases considered thus far. Typically, these enzymes catalyze the cleavage of one or, a t most, a few phosphodiester bonds in a DNA molecule composed of many thousands of nucleotide residues. In no instance has the basis for this remarkable specificity been established. However, in the case of the E . coli “restriction” enzymes the presence or absence of a methyl group on a specific deoxyadenylate or deoxycytidylate residue may be involved. The limited attack catalyzed by the specific endonucleases obviously poses formidable assay problems which have in several cases been re-
10. BACTERIAL
DEOXYRIBONUCLEASES
263
solved by novel and ingenious methods. These are indicated where applicable. 1. E . coli Restriction Endonucleases
The E . coli restriction endonucleases are involved in the phenomenon of host-controlled modification and restriction whereby bacterial cells of one strain are able to destroy DNA from cells of foreign strains (50). As noted above, the current working hypothesis is that resistance to a given restriction endonuclease is conferred by specific methylation a t nucleotide sequences that would otherwise be vulnerable to that enzyme. The restriction enzymes have been assayed either by measuring the decrease in sedimentation coefficient of a homogeneous DNA preparation (usually phage A) (51) or more simply by measuring the inactivation of infectious DNA (phage h or fd) ( 5 2 ) ,both of which are sensitive to the introduction of one or a few phosphodiester bond scissions. One of the restriction endonucleases, called endonuclease R -K, has been purified approximately 5000-fold from E . coli strain K by Yuan and Meselson (61). This enzyme cleaves double-stranded DNA synthesized in other E . coli strains but is totally without effect on DNA synthesized in strain K itself. I n addition to magnesium ion the enzyme specifically requires ATP and S-adenosylmethionine; its pH optimum lies in the range pH 7.5-8.0. Several very similar nucleases with different specificities but with the same unusual cofactor requirements have also been described. An enzyme partially purified from E . coli lysogenic for phage P1 attacks DNA from E . coli lacking P1 ( 5 1 ) , and another enzyme from E . coli strain B attacks DNA from strains other than B ( 5 2 ) . There has also been a brief report of a restriction endonuclease in Hemophilus influenzae (53). Meselson and Yuan have carried out a detailed examination of the mode of attack of X.C DNA (i.e., DNA from phage h grown on E . coli strain C and therefore lacking the K enzyme modification) by purified endonuclease R - K ( 5 1 ) . Sucrose density gradient analysis of the products formed after treatment of h. C DNA with the endonuclease has shown that they consist of duplexes containing little or no single-stranded DNA and no single chain breaks. The products sediment in sucrose gradients a t or near the position at which quarter molecules of A-DNA would sediment. Thus, the h .C DNA appears to undergo double-stranded 50. W. Arber and S. Linn, Ann. Rev. Biochem. 38, 467 (1969). 51. R . Yuan and M. Meselson, Nature 217, 1110 (1968). 52. S. Linn and W. Arber, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U . S. 59, 1300 (1968). 53. T. J. Kelly, Jr. and H. 0. Smith, Federation Proc. 29, 405 (1970).
264
I. R. LEHMAN
cleavage at fixed sites along its length. By examining the action of the enzyme on the twisted circular form of X.C DNA (54),Meselson and Yuan have also been able to demonstrate that single-stranded scission precedes cleavage of the duplex. The occurrence of single chain scissions early in the reaction taken together with the paucity of single chain breaks in the limit product indicate that the enzyme first cleaves only one chain and then a few seconds later breaks the complementary chain a t a point directly or nearly opposite to the initial break. A similar result was obtained by Linn and Arbor with the restriction endonucleases partially purified from E . coli and E . coli lysogenic for P1 (62).It has not been determined whether a given enzyme molecule remains bound to the DNA, catalyzing breaks in both chains, or whether the two chains are attacked independently. I n the case of endonuclease R - K acting on phage X DNA it has been established that duplexes in which only one of the two chains is modified (presumably by the appropriate methylation) are not attacked at all. Thus, heteroduplexes are resistant even to single chain scissions and are therefore modified a t every site of potential attack. The role of ATP and S-adenosylmethionine in the reaction remains an intriguing but as yet unresolved question. Recently Yuan and Meselson have reported that in the presence of magnesium ion, ATP and S-adenosylmethionine the Re K endonuclease forms a specific complex with its DNA substrate ( 5 5 ) . Complex formation is, however, observed M ) a t which nucleolytic activity is a t ATP concentrations (4 x not detectable. This result suggests that ATP may be involved in a t least two steps: (1) formation of a nonhydrolytic complex a t low ATP levels and (2) formation of more stable (or more numerous) complexes and nucleolytic action a t higher concentrations of ATP. The S-adenosylmethionine requirement for complex formation is in the same concentration range as observed for restriction. 2. E . coli Endonuclease I1
Endonuclease I1 of E . coli was first recognized by Friedberg and Goldthwait as an activity in extracts of E . coli mutants lacking endonuclease I, that specifically attacked double-stranded DNA alkylated with the monofunctional alkylating agent methyl methane sulfonate ( 5 6 ) . It was subsequently found that the partially purified enzyme could in fact 54. V. C. Bode and A . D. Kaiser, J M B 14, 399 (1965). 55. R. Yuan and M. Meselson, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U . S. 65, 357 (1970). 56. E. C. Friedberg and D. A. Goldthwait, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. I J . S . 62, 934
(1969); E. C. Friedberg. S. M. Hadi, and D. A . Goldthwait, JBC 244, 5879 (1969).
10.
BACTERIAL DEOXYRIBONUCLEASES
265
introduce a limited number of single-stranded breaks in nonalkylated duplex DNA, approximately 3-4 per single strand. The activities on the alkylated and nonalkylated DNA appear to be associated with the same protein; however, this point has not yet been definitely settled. Endonuclease I1 has a broad pH optimum ranging from pH 8.0 to 9.0. It has no absolute requirement for a divalent cation but is stimulated by added magnesium or manganese ion. Unlike endonuclease I, i t is not inhibited by RNA. Goldthwait and his co-workers have assayed endonuclease I1 by measuring the release of 3H-thymidine-labeled fragments from a suspension of polyacrylamide gel containing alkylated T4 DNA ( 5 7 ) . Most (>90%) of the radioactivity released from the gel is acidprecipitable, hence, still macromolecular. With lightly alkylated DNA, endonuclease I1 makes predominantly single-stranded breaks suggesting that the enzyme can hydrolyze a phosphodiester bond a t or near an alkylated base in a native DNA molecule with no single-stranded breaks in this region. With more extensively alkylated DNA, double-stranded breaks predominate. Friedberg et al. (56) pointed out that since alkylation of DNA occurs principally a t the N-7 position of guanine and the N-3 position of adenine (58) these chemical modifications might be expected to result in electron rearrangements in the purine rings that may affect hydrogen bonding, base-stacking, or both. Thus, alkylation might produce a distortion in the secondary structure of DNA, and it is this distorted structure which is the substrate for endonuclease 11. Since the enzyme makes a limited number of single-stranded breaks in native DNA, it is possible that a similar type of conformational distortion exists in nonalkylated DNA. The role of endonuclease I1 in vivo is not known. Assay of recombination defective mutants of E . coli and mutants abnormally sensitive to ultraviolet irradiation and to treatment with methyl methane sulfonate showed them all to possess normal levels of the enzyme (56).
3. Phage T7-Induced Endonuclease Center e t al. (59) have purified extensively (1000-fold) an endonuclease induced after infection of E. coli with phage T7. This enzyme attacks native DNA to yield products with a molecular weight of approximately 2 X lo4 and denatured DNA to produce fragments having 57. E. Melgur and D. A. Goldthwait, JBC 243, 4401 (1968). 58. P. D. Lawley, Prog. Nucleic Acid Res. Mol. Biol. 5, 89 (1966). 59. M. S. Center, F. W. Studier, and C. C. Richardson., Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S. 65, 242 (1970).
266
I. R. LEHMAN
a molecular weight of lo4 or less. The fragments have not been further characterized. The endonuclease activity on native DNA was assayed by measuring the conversion of 3H-labeled 4X-174 RF I (60)to a form which could be trapped on nitrocellulose membrane filters after heating at 100". Thus, covalently closed duplex DNA is not retained on these filters, whereas the single strands produced by heating the circular duplexes that have suffered a single-stranded break are retained. The action of the enzyme on single-stranded DNA was followed by measuring the conversion of single-stranded circular +X 174 DNA (61) to a form susceptible to E. coli exonuclease I (62). Studies with conditional lethal mutants of phage T 7 have shown that gene 3 is the structural gene for the DNase (T7 contains at least 19 distinct complementation groups) (63).In the restrictive host, gene 3 mutants synthesize only limited amounts of phage DNA ( 6 4 ) . Inasmuch as they are also defective in carrying out the degradation of host DNA, the gene 3 endonuclease may be the enzyme required for this function. The purified endonuclease produces little acid-soluble material ; thus, an additional activity is presumably required for the complete degradation of host DNA. Center et al. suggested that gene 6 specifies an exonuclease which acts a t the breaks produced by the gene 3 endonuclease (69). As noted above amber mutants in gene 3 produce only limited amounts of DNA under restrictive conditions. It is therefore clear that degradation of host DNA is required for normal T7 DNA synthesis and phage production, a result which is to be anticipated in light of the finding that T7 derives most of its nucleotides from host nucleic acids ( 6 5 ) . Center et al. have observed that the purified T 7 endonuclease can hydrolyze T 7 DNA in in vitro (59). Hence, it is not known how T 7 infection results in the selective degradation of E . coli DNA in vivo. 4. Phage T4-Induced Endonucleases
II and IV
Sadowski and Hurwitz have described two endonucleases synthesized in T 4 phage-infected E . coli which they have named T4 endonucleases II and ZV (66). 60. A. Burton and R. L. Sinsheimer, JMB 11, 327 (1965). 61. W. Fiers and R. L. Sinsheimer, J M B 5, 424 (1962). 62. I. R. Lehman and A. L. Nussbaum, JBC 239, 2628 (1964). 63. F. W. Studier and J. V. Maisel, Virology 39, 575 (1969). 64. F. W. Studier, Virology 39, 562 (1969). 65. F. W. Putnam, D. Miller, L. Palm, and E. A. Evans, Jr., JBC 199, 177 (1952). 66. P. D. Sadowski and J. Hurwitz, JBC 244, 6182 and 6192 (1969).
10.
BACTERIAL DEOXYRIBONUCLEASES
267
a. T4 Endonuclease II. T4 endonuclease I1 has been purified approximately 300-fold (6‘6‘). The partially purified enzyme has a broad alkaline p H optimum (pH 8.4-10.1) and shows an absolute requirement for magnesium ion. Two methods have been used for the assay of the enzyme. One measures the discharge of 3H-AMP from the E . coli DNA ligase-AMP complex on reaction of the complex with DNA pretreated with endonuclease 11. Since ligase-AMP repairs single-stranded breaks in duplex DNA that have apposing 3’-hydroxyl and 5’-phosphoryl termini (67), the discharge of AMP is a direct measure of the number of breaks introduced into the DNA by T4 endonuclease 11. The second assay estimates the number of 3’-hydroxyl termini formed by measuring the increase in I4C-labeled h DNA which beconies susceptible to E . coli exonuclease I after thermal denaturation of the nicked DNA. Since exonuclease I acts exonucleolytically from the 3’-hydroxyl terminus of denatured DNA ( 6 2 ) ,the amount of acid-soluble 14C formed is an estimate of the number of 3’-hydroxyl termini generated by T4 endonuclease I1 action. The enzyme introduces predominantly single-stranded breaks into native DNA, although at high enzyme concentrations some doublestranded breakage occurs. Purified preparations of the endonuclease do, however, show some activity on denatured DNA, possibly resulting from contamination with T4 endonuclease I V (see below). As noted above, the single-stranded breaks produced by T4 endonuclease 11 bear 3’-hydroxyl and 5’-phosphoryl termini. The enzyme makes a limited number of breaks in duplex DNA and the average length of the limit product from phage h DNA, as determined by sucrose density gradient centrifugation, is about 1000 residues. As in the case of E. coli endonuclease 11, the basis for the very limited extent of hydrolysis of DNA is not known. Sadowski and Hurwitz have examined the nucleotide residues a t the 5’-phosphoryl termini by means of the polynucleotide kinase reaction and found all four deoxynucleotides to be present. There did, however, appear to be a significantly higher proportion of deoxyguanylate and deoxycytidylate residues a t these termini. A limited base specificity of this kind cannot, however, account for the apparent high degree of specificity actually observed. T4 endonuclease I1 appears to differ from E . coli endonuclease I1 in several respects, the most striking difference being the inability of the phage-induced enzyme to attack either glucosylated or nonglucosylated T4 DNA. Friedberg et al. have also found that whereas the activity of 67. J. R. Little, S. B. Zimmerman, C. K. Osliinsky, and M. Gellert, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U . S. 58, 2004 (1967).
268
I. R. LEHMAN
extracts of infected and uninfected cells showed similar activities when tested with alkylated DNA, there was a marked increase in relative endonucleolytic activity on unalkylated DNA in the infected cell extract, suggesting that the phage-induced enzyme either has no activity or very little activity on alkylated DNA (56). Recently, two groups have independently isolated non-lethal mutants of T4 that are incapable of degrading the host E. coli DNA and may therefore be defective in T4 endonuclease I1 (68, 69).
b. T4 Endonuclease I V . T4 endonuclease IV has been purified approximately 150-fold (66). It has a p H optimum which ranges from pH 8.4 to 9.2 and an absolute requirement for magnesium or cobalt ion. Endonuclease IV was assayed by measuring the conversion of singlestranded circular fd DNA ( 7 0 ) , labelcd with 14C to an exonuclease Isensitive form. The partially purified enzyme has a strong preference for denatured DNA; however, it does attack native X DNA a t a significant rate (one-tenth that of fd). Like T4 endonuclease 11, endonuclease IV shows only limited activity, producing oligonucleotides 150 residues long; it does not form measurable amounts of acid-soluble material. The oligonucleotide products contain 3’-hydroxyl and 5’-phosphoryl termini; the latter bear deoxycytidylate residues exclusively. T 4 endonuclease IV therefore has an absolute base specificity and is unique among the DNA endonucleases which have thus far been described. Some other, as yet undetermined feature of its mechanism must, however, be responsible for the limited extent of attack observed. Again, like T4 endonuclease I1 it does not hydrolyze T 4 DNA, whether glucosylated or not. The combined action of T 4 endonucleases I1 and IV and an exonuclease which Sadowski and Hurwitz have identified in extracts of T4-infected cells can result in the double-stranded breakage of duplex DNA. Presumably, endonuclease I1 introduces a single-stranded break in native DNA and the exonuclease removes mononucleotides from the internal 3’-hydroxyl termini exposing a region of single-stranded DNA on the opposite strand. This region is then cleaved by endonuclease IV to yield double-stranded fragments of DNA. Because of the inability of T4 endonucleases I1 and IV to attack T 4 DNA, it is possible that these enzymes together with the “T4 exonuclease” promote the initial stages 68. K . Hercules, J. L. Munro, S. Mendelsohn, and J. S. Wiberg, Federation Proc. 29, 465 (1970). 69. S . E. Jorgensen, J. F. Koerner, D. P. Snustad, and H. R. Warner, Federalion Proc. 29, 465 (1970). 70. H. Schaller, JMB 28, 435 (1969).
10.
BACTERIAL DEOXYRIBONUCLEASES
269
of breakdown of host DNA following T4 infection. Warren and Bose have, in fact, reported that in the initial phase of host DNA breakdown, E . coli DNA is degraded to fragments of molecular weight approximately 1 X lo6 in a process in which single-stranded breaks occur first, followed by double-stranded cleavage ( 7 1 ) . The double-stranded DNA fragments are then presumably degraded to acid-soluble oligonucleotides and ultimately mononucleotides, which can then be used in the synthesis of T4 DNA. 5. M . luteus “UV Repair Enzymes” I n 1962, Strauss described an activity in extracts of Micrococcus lysodeikticus ( M . luteus) which preferentially inactivated UV-irradiated B . subtilis transforming DNA ( 7 2 ) .It was subsequently shown by Carrier and Setlow that such extracts were able specifically to excise thyminethymine and thymine-cytosine dimers from the irradiated DNA ( 7 3 ) . Fractionation of the M . luteus extracts by Nakayama et al. demonstrated that two chromatographically separable protein fractions were required for pyrimidine dimer excision, one of which they suggested was an endonuclease that introduced a phosphodiester bond cleavage a t or near the pyrimidine dimer and the second of which released the dimer as part of an acid-soluble oligonucleotide ( 7 4 ) . The two activities have been purified and examined in detail by Takagi et al. (75) and independently by Grossman and his colleagues (32, 7 6 ) .The purified enzymes acting together do in fact have the capacity to excise quantitatively thymine dimers from UV-irradiated DNA. The first enzyme in the sequence has been purified approximately 5000-fold; it is of relatively low molecular weight (14,0W15,OOo based on Sephadex gel filtration). The pH optimum of the enzyme is pH 6.5-7.5 and it is stimulated by, but it is not dependent upon, added magnesium ion. The purified enzyme is entirely specific for UV-irradiated, double-stranded DNA and is free of the ATP-dependent endonuclease of M . luteus. The UV endonuclease introduces a single-stranded break in close proximity t o a 71. R. J. Warren and S. K. Bose, J . Viral. 2, 327 (1968). 72. B. S. Strauss, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U . S. 48, 1670 (1962). 73. W. L. Carrier and R. B. Setlow, B B A 129, 318 (1966). 74. H. S. Nakayama, M. Okubo, M. Sekiguchi, and Y. Takagi, BBRC 27, 217 (1967). 75. Y. Takagi, M. Sekiguchi, S. Okubo, H. Nakayama, K. Shimada, S. Yasuda, T. Nishimoto, and H. Yoshihara, Cold Sprlng Harbor Symp. Quant. Biol. 38, 219 (1968). 76. J . C. Kaplan, S. R. Kushner, and L. Grossman, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U . S. 63, 144 (1969).
270
I. B. LEHMAN
thymine dimer leaving a 3’-phosphoryl terminus. Nucleotides are not released during this incision step. The subsequent thymine dimer excision is carried out by the second enzyme, an exonuclease also purified extensively (15OO-fold) by Grossman et a2. This enzyme, whose activity is dependent upon added magnesium ion, acts on unirradiated denatured DNA releasing 5’-mononucleotides by an exonucleolytic mechanism starting a t either the 3’ or 5’ terminus. Native DNA is resistant to the action of the exonuclease; however, the enzyme will attack irradiated native DNA that has been pretreated with the endonuclease in the 5’+ 3’ direction liberating an average of 6 nucleotides per endonucleolytic break. The digestion products consist of mono-, di-, and trinucleotides ; and the thymine dimers are contained in the trinucleotide fragments. Purified preparations of the exonuclease are devoid of DNA polymerase activity, suggesting that the UV exonuclease is not a 5’ + 3’ exonuclease component of the M . luteus DNA polymerase. It would appear from these studies that the excision of thymine, and more generally pyrimidine dimers may be a two-step process. The initial single-stranded incision is probably dependent upon the presence of a distorted area in the DNA duplex resulting from the formation of a thymine dimer. Once the initial break has been introduced, a short single-stranded region containing the photoproduct results which is then susceptible to the action of the exonuclease. Grossman et al. have isolated a mutant of M . luteus by nitrosoguanidine mutagenesis which is abnormally sensitive to UV and X-irradiation and also shows a reduced capacity to support the replication of UVirradiated phages (the hcr- phenotype). Extracts of this mutant have a correspondingly low level of UV endonuclease activity (76).Takagi et al. have transformed the mutant with DNA derived from UV-resistant cells and found that the UV-resistant transformants displayed the same level of sensitivity to UV irradiation as the wild type; however, the W endonuclease activity in the extract remained a t the same low level observed in the original mutant strain ( 7 5 ) . All attempts to isolate a revertant have thus far been unsuccessful, suggesting that the mutant bacterium may harbor a double mutation. Thus, while it appears that the UV endonuclease may be involved in the repair of UV damage in V ~ V O , this point has not been firmly established.
Sfi1een A cid Deoxyribonuclease GIORGIO BERNARD1 I. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . 11. Physical and Chemical Properties . . . . . . . A. Isolation . . . . . . . . . . . B. Physical and Chemical Properties . . . . . . C. A and B Components . . . . . . . . D. Dimcric Structure . . . . . . . . . 111. Catalytic Properties . . . . . . . . , . . A. General Features of DNA Dcgradation . . . . B. Methods of Investigation and Activity Units . . . C. Mechanism of the Initial Degradation of Native D S A . D. General Catalytic Properties . . . . . . . E. Specificity . . . . . . . . . . . 1V. Distribution, Intracellular Localization, and Biological Hole .
.
. . .
. . . . . . . . .
271 272 272 273 275 275 276 276 278 278 280 283 285
1. Introduction
Acid deoxyribonuclease (DNase) is an enzyme which splits the phosphodiester bonds of native DNA by both a diplotomic and a haplotomic mechanism (see Section II1,C) leaving the terminal phosphate in a 3’ position. The enzyme is very widely distributed in animal cells and appears to be localized in the lysosomes. The best known acid DNase is that from hog spleen; this explains why most of the data presented here refer to this enzyme. I t should be stressed, however, that the properties of acid DNases obtained from the tissues of other vertebrates appear to be extremely similar to those of the hog spleen enzyme; 271
272
GIORGIO BERNARD1
therefore, the results obtained with hog spleen acid DNase may be of a more general validity. The present article will review the progress made in our knowledge of acid DNase during the past 10 years, therefore after the second edition of “The Enzymes” (1). No attempt has been made to cover exhaustively the literature on this subject since several reviews dealing with acid DNase have been published in the meantime ( 2 4 ) . The DNase activity having a pH optimum comprised between 4.5 and 5.5, first observed in animal tissues in the late 1940’s, was referred to by the early investigators as acid DNase. Later the name DNase 11, intended to mean the second type of animal DNase was suggested for the acid DNase activity (7) to contrast it with pancreatic DNase, which was called DNase I. Subsequently, DNases have been classified as 5’-monoester formers and 3’-monoester formers (I), a division which is not identical with that of DNases I and 11, even if frequently it is assumed to be so. More recently, it has been suggested to abandon the distinction between DNase I and DNase I1 altogether ( 6 ) . Here the original terminology will be used since it is the least inconsistent among those proposed so far.
II. Physical and Chemical Properties
A. ISOLATION Methods leading to homogeneous acid DNase preparations from hog spleen have been described (8-11). The following is a very brief outline of the method of Bernardi et al. (10) as presently used in the author’s laboratory. Hog spleens are trimmed, ground, and homogenized with 0.05M H,SO,; the homogenate is acidified to pH 2.5 with 0.1M H,SO, and centrifuged; the supernatant so obtained is fractionated be1. M. Laskowski, “The Enzymes,” 2nd ed., Vol. 5, p. 123, 1961. 2. M. Privat de Garilhe, “Les nucl6ases.” Hermann, Paris, 1964. 3. I. R. Lehman, Ann. R e v . Biochem. 36, 645 (1967). 4. W. E. Razzell, Experientia 23, 321 (1967). 5. M. Laskowski, Advan. Enzymol. 29, 165 (1967). 6. G. Bernardi, Advan. EnzymoZ. 31, 1 (1968). 7. L. Cunningham and M. Laskowski, BBA 11, 590 (1953). 8. G. Bernardi, M. Griff6, and E. Appella, Nature 198, 186 (1963). 9. G. Bernardi, and M. Griff6, Biochemistry 3, 1419 (1964). 10. G. Bernardi, A. Bernardi, and A. Chersi, BBA 129, 1 (1966). 11. G . Bernardi, Procedures Nucleic Acid Res. p. 102 (1966).
11.
273
SPLEEN ACID DEOXYRIBONUCLEASE
tween 40 and 80% saturation of (NH,),SO,; the final precipitate is dialyzed against 0.05M phosphate buffer, p H 6.8, and clarified by centrifugation. The crude enzyme solution so obtained is purified using three chromatographic steps involving DEAE-Sephadex, hydroxyapatite, and CM-Sephadex, respectively. The enzyme is eluted from the last column in two activity peaks, the first component representing less than 20% of the total activity. The two components, called A and B, respectively, are rechromatographed separately on CM-Sephadex columns, dialyzed against 0.001 M acetate buffer, pH 5.0, concentrated by freezedrying to about 1% concentration, then frozen and stored a t -15". Hog spleen acid DNase, as obtained by the above procedure, is completely free of contaminating phosphatase, exonuclease, and adenosine deaminase activities. The enzyme has a weak intrinsic hydrolytic activity on bis (p-nitrophenyl) phosphate and the p-nitrophenyl derivatives of deoxyribonucleoside 3'-phosphates (see Section III,D,3).
B. PHYSICAL AND CHEMICAL PROPERTIES The physical properties and the amino acid analysis of hog-spleen acid DNase B (main component) are given in Tables I and 11, respectively. The high ammonia level of the acid hydrolyzate and the high amide level seen in Pronase digests suggest that a very large percentage of t,he dicarboxylic acids may be present in the protein as the corresponding amides. Glucosamine ( l a ) and mannose (R. G . Winzler, personal TABLE I ACID DEOXYRIBONUCLEASE" PHYSICAL PROPERTIES OF HOQ SPLEEN (Svedbergs) (analytical centrifugation) (sucrose gradient centrifugation) D20,w(lo-' cmz/sec)b P (ml/g)c Molecular weight (from s and D ) (from sedimentation equi1ibrium)d ~ 2 0 , ~
fEiZ if0 ip
3.4 3.3 0.1 7.8
*
0.72 3.8 x 104 4.1 X 10' 1.34 12.1
From Bernardi el al. (12).
* This value was obtained a t concentrations of 0.5Yo and about 0.1%. c
d
Value calculated from amino acid composition. Townend and Bernardi (2s).
12. G. Bernardi, E. Appella, and R. Zito, Biochemistry 4, 1725 (1965). 13. R. Townend and G. Bernardi, ABB, submitted for publication.
274
GIORGIO BERNARD1
TABLE I1 AMINOACID ANALYSISOF HOG SPLEENDEOXYRIBONUCLEASE~ Grams of amino acid residues per 100 g of protein* in hydrolysis time of Amino acid
22 hr
48 hr
72 hr
Coriected values"
LYS His (NHs) -4% ASP Thr Ser Glu PI.0 GlY Ma +-cys Val Met Ileu Leu TYr Phe Try Glucosamine
6.94 2.13 (23.05) 5.04 10.19 5.44 8.30 11.03 7.09 3.88 4.84 1.77 2.62 1.63 2.08 10.47 5.23 6.30 6.30 3.07
6.80 2.17 (23.65) 5.55 10.14 5.20 8.10 11.09 7.14 3.97 4.72 1.79 3.33 1.65 2.49 11.13 5.17 6.56
6.95 2.31 (24.06) 5.37 9.36 4.80 7.18 10.66 6.51 3.87 4.33 1.79 3.35 1.30 2.52 10.49 4.83 6.07
6.89 2.20 (22.5) 5.46 9.89 5.63 8.46 10.93 6.91 3.90 4.63 1.79 3.35 1.53 2.52 10.67 5.28 6.31
3.32
3.06
3.15
98.05 98.9
100.32 98.7
94.75 97.4
99.50
Total
N recovery (%)
Moles of amino acid/ mole of protein MW 38,000
Nearest integral No. of residues/ mole of proteind
20.44 6.08 (49.4) 13.30 32.68 21.16 36.93 32.19 27.05 25.99 24.77 6.65" 12.84 4.45 8.47 35.87 12.31 16.30 6.3' 7.45
20 6 (49) 13 33 21 37 32 27 26 25 8 13 4 8 36 12 16 6 (8) 343
From Bernardi et al. (fa). Total N is 17.2%; total S is 1.0%. c In calculating the corrected values, the criteria given by Tristram and Smith (14) have been followed. dThe selection of the integral numbers of residues has been done also taking into account results from other analyses. After performic acid oxidation, cysteic acid 8.2 residues. From N-bromosuccinimide titration.
communication, 1967) are present in the protein; in the tryptic digests, the glucosamine and neutral sugar residues are found on a single peptide spot. No free sulfhydryl groups can be detected in acid DNase, both native and denatured (G. Bernardi, unpublished observations) ; therefore, the eight half-cystine residues must form four disulfide bridges. Optical rotatory dispersion, circular dichroism, and infrared spectra of
11.
SPLEEN ACID DEOXYRIBONUCLEASE
275
acid DNase have shown that the enzyme contains little a-helix; antiparallel pleated sheet p-structure is probably present in the molecule (13a). C. A
AND
B COMPONENTS
A comparison of the properties of the two acid DNase components A and B showed no differences in the sedimentation velocities, elution volumes from Sephadex G-100 columns, ultraviolet spectra, orcinol reaction, and enzymological properties (DNase and phosphodiesterase activities). Two differences (besides their different behavior on CMSephadex columns, which indicates that component A is likely to be slightly less basic than component B) have been found so far between the two components: (1) the level of both glucosamine and mannose are definitely lower in component A compared to component B (R. G. Winzler, personal communication, 1967) ; (2) one particular single tryptic peptide spot of component A is resolved into two spots in the otherwise identical peptide map of component B. Since the amount of component A may be reduced to zero by avoiding acidification, the latter finding may tentatively be explained (10) by assuming that the difference between A and B results from the deamidation of an asparagine (or a glutamine) residue adjacent to a lysine (or an arginine) by the acid treatment involved during the preparation of the enzyme, leading to a peptide bond resistant to trypsin. Alternatively, it may be thought that during acidification a peptide bond has been split by cathepsins present in the homogenate. The loss of sugars might also be due to acid hydrolysis or to an enzyme attack. It is possible that the two chromatographic components of spleen acid DNase seen by Koszalka et al. (16) on Amberlite IRC-W had an origin similar to components A and B, since 5 N H,SO, was used by these authors to adjust the tissue extract to p H 4.0.
D. DIMERIC STRUCTURE Some chemical and physical results seem to suggest that acid DNase may have a dimeric structure (6, 16). When the enzyme is reduced, carboxymethylated, digested with crystalline trypsin (treated with 1,l13a. S. N . ‘rirnasheff and G. Bernardi. ABB 141, 53 (1970).
14. G. R. Tristram and R. H. Smith, Advan. Protein Chem. 18, 227 (1967). 15. T . R. Kosaalka, R. Falkenheim, and K. I. Altman, BBA 33, 647 (1957) 16. G. Bernardi. J M B 13, 603 (1965).
276
GIORGIO BERNARD1
tosylamido-2-phenethyl-chloromethylketone to inactivate contaminating chymotrypsin), and mapped, 17-19 peptides are found as opposed to 32-34 arginine lysine residues present in each enzyme molecule of MW = 38,000. Arginine, tryptophan, and histidine peptides are found in half, or less than half, the number of the respective amino acids in the supposedly dimeric protein. Other results also suggesting a dimeric Structure come from sedimentation studies. At a 1% concentration, the sedimentation coefficient of the enzyme, which is 2 . 8 s in acetate or phosphate buffers, drops to 1.75 and 2.1 S in 6 M guanidine a t pH 5.6 and 8.6, respectively; in the presence of P-mercaptoethanol, the sedimentation coefficient is still lower, as expected: 1.5 S in 6 M guanidine and only 0.8s in 8 M urea; in 4 M u r e a 4 0 5 M P-mercaptoethanol, pH 5.0, two boundaries, having sedimentation coefficients equal to 2.6 and 0.8 S, respectively, can be seen. Cooperative binding of the synthetic substrate bis (p-nitrophenyl) phosphate and of a protein inhibitor (see Sections III,D,2 and 3) might also be considered as an indirect indication of a dimeric structure. Recent equilibrium sedimentation studies (13) show, however, that the molecular weight of acid DNase in 6 M guanidine (with or without 0.1 M P-mercaptoethanol) is close to 40,000. Clearly, further investigations on acid DNase are needed for a better understanding of the relationships between structure and mechanism of action of this enzyme.
+
111. Catalytic Properties
A. GENERAL FEATURES OF DNA DEGRADATION Three different phases can be distinguished in the degradation of native DNA by acid DNase as follows (see Fig. 1) : (1) The initial phase, in which the macromolecular and biological properties of DNA are dramatically modified, whereas no change can be detected in its spectral properties and no acid-soluble fragments are formed. I n terms of molecular weight this phase extends from the initial molecular weight to about 1 0 daltons [weight average molecular weight, M,, of double-stranded fragments (17,18)1. (2) The middle phase, which is characterized by a hyperchromic shift and the formation of acid-soluble oligonucleotides ; monoesterified phosphate can be detected. In this phase, the increase of ultraviolet absorption and of acid-soluble oligonucleotides is linear with the reciprocal 17. G. Bernard, Nature 206, 779 (1965). 18. G. Bernardi, BBA 174, 423 (1969).
11.
277
SPLEEN ACID DWXYRIBONUCLEASE
i
1.35
-0.1I
10-0.10
-0.09 -0.08 -0.07
Time (minutes)
FIG.1. Hyperchromic shifts (0; left-hand outer scale), acid solubility ( A ; lefthand inner scale; values corrected for dilution), reciprocal average size (0 ; righthand outer scale) of oligonucleotides from calf thymus DNA during acid DNase digestion. The DNA sample ( A m 0 = 8.0) was digested at 23" in 0.05 M ammonium acetate401 M EDTA, pH 5.5. The horizontal broken line indicates the limit between the middle phase and the terminal phase of the digestion. I n this experiment the initial lag time of both hyperchromic shift and acid solubility is not apparent because of the high enzyme concentration used ( 1 9 ) .
number average molecular weight of oligonucleotides, l/Mn, that is the relative number of terminal nucleotides. Under the experimental conditions of Fig. 1, the average chain length in this phase is comprised between 100 and 14 nucleotides (19). It is important to stress that the limits of the middle phase may be shifted by changes in the experimental conditions of the digestion (temperature, pH, and ionic strength of the solvent). (3) The terminal phase, which shows an increasingly slower, further increase in the hyperchromic shift and acid-soluble oligonucleotide formation. Both phenomena, however, are no more linear with number of 19. C . Soave, J. P. Thiery, S. D. Ehrlich, and G . Bernardi, in preparation.
278
GIORGIO BERNARD1
end groups liberated. Under the experimental conditions of Fig. 1 this phase extends from a chain length of 14 to a chain length of 6 .
B. METHODS OF INVESTIGATION AND ACTIVITY UNITS The degradation of native DNA by acid DNase may be investigated, by physical, biological, and chemical methods. It should be pointed out that none of these methods can be used to follow the entire course of the enzymic degradation and also that all methods, with the only exception of the terminal phosphate determination, are indirect methods. The routine use of indirect assay procedures (most commonly the formation of acid-soluble oligonucleotides, the hyperchromic shift, or the viscosity drop) has made it very difficult to define a satisfactory activity unit. Since a linear relationship exists between the formation of terminal phosphate groups and both hyperchromic shift and the liberation of acid-soluble oligonucleotides (Fig. l ) , the indirect methods can be standardized against the direct method. It is possible, therefore, to define acid DNase activity according to the recommendations of the Commission on Enzymes of the International Union of Biochemistry: One unit of DNase is defined as the amount of enzyme which catalyzes the formation of 1 pmole of terminal phosphate per minute a t 25” under optimal conditions. One such unit is equivalent to about 325 units defined ( S l l ) as the amount of enzyme catalyzing the liberation of oligonucleotides having a corrected A,,, equal to 1, a t 37”, in 0.15 M acetate buffer, 0.01 M ethylenediaminetetraacetate (EDTA), p H 5.0, the DNA concentration being 400 pg/ ml.
C. MECHANISM OF
THE
INITIAL DEGRADATION OF NATIVEDNA
Acid DNase initially degrades native, double-stranded DNA according to two mechanisms (see Fig. 2) : (1) a diplotomic mechanism (8, 20)-
FIG.2. Scheme of the mixed haplotomic and diplotomic mechanism of degradation of native DNA by acid DNase. 20. The introduction of this terminology (6) is justified by the fact that a mechanism of DNA degradation involving the simultaneous breakage of both strands a t the same level shows a “single hit” kinetics whereas that caused by single breaks shows a “double hit” kinetics; this is, of course, a source of ambiguity.
11. SPLEEN
ACID DEDXYRIBONUCLEASE
279
from the Greek diplo's, double, and tome', break-by which both strands are simultaneously split at the same level, and (2) a haplotomic mechanism (6)-from the Greek hapZo's, single-causing scissions on one or another of the two strands. Both mechanisms are operational from the very beginning of the digestion. The diplotomic mechanism, first suggested on the basis of qualitative evidence ( d l ) ,has been rigorously established by kinetic work (22-25) and later confirmed using different experimental approaches (26, 2 7 ) . This mechanism is responsible for the absence of a time lag in the molecular weight decrease and for the linearity of plots of l J M , vs. digestion time, which characterize the acid DNase digestion. A diplotomic degradation of native DNA has subsequently been demonstrated to take place also with other DNases, e.g., E . coli endonuclease I (28, 29) and D.pneumoniae DNase ( S O ) . In spite of the fact that kinetically these enzymes degrade native DNA like acid DNase, i t is conceivable that their mechanism of action at the molecular level is different. Among other differences, the two bacterial enzymes have molecular weights close to half the molecular weight of acid DNase and form 3'-OH-ended oligonucleotides. The haplotomic mechanism is similar to that already known to occur with pancreatic DNase (31, 32) and contributes to the molecular weight decrease only after a time lag, during which single breaks accumulate on the DNA strands. The ratio of total bonds broken to bonds broken by the diplotomic mechanism has been estimated, in different ways, to lie a t least initially between 1.5 and 3 ( 3 3 ) . As can be expected, the initial degradation of DNA by acid DNase not only causes a drastic change in the macromolecular properties of the substrate, but also strongly affects its biological activity. Young and Sinsheimer (26') have been able to show that close to one diplotomic 21. A. Oth, E. Fredericq, and R. Hacha, B B A 29, 287 (1958). 22. G. Bernardi and C. Sadron, Nature 191, 809 (1961). 23. G. Bernardi and C . Sadron, A . Baselli Conference on Nucleic Acids and Their Role in Biol., Milan, 1964 p. 62. 24. G. Bernardi and C . Sadron, Biochemistry 3, 1411 (1964). 25. L. A. MacHattie, G. Bernardi, and C . A. Thomas, Jr., Science 141, 59 (1963). 26. E. T. Young, I1 and R. L. Sinsheimer, JBC 240, (1965). 27. E. Melgar and D. A. Goldthwait, JBC 243, 4401 (1968). 28. G. Bernardi and C. Cordonnicr, J M B 11, 141 (1965). 29. F. W. Studier, JBM 11, 373 (1965). 30. H. Kopecka and G. Bernardi, 6th Meeting Fed. European Biochem. Sac., Mndrid, 1969 (abstracts). 31. C. A. Thomas, JAPS 78, 1861 (1956). 32. V. N . Schumaker, E. G. Richards, and H. K. Schachnian, JACS 78, 4320 (1960). 33. G. Bernardi and M. L. Bach, J M B 37, 87 (1968).
280
GIORGIO BERNARD1
break per A-DNA molecule is sufficient to destroy its infectivity, whereas, on the average, four phosphodiester bonds can be hydrolyzed by pancreatic DNase in a A-DNA molecule before its infectivity is lost. Bernardi and Bach (33) have found no feature in the inactivation of transforming H. influenzae DNA that could specifically be related to the diplotomic mechanism of action, in agreement with the fact that transformation occurs by integration of single-stranded and not of doublestranded DNA into the host genome. An interesting finding was that a t comparable levels of bond breakage acid DNase is much more inactivating than pancreatic DNase, E . coli, endonuclease I, or sonication; for example, a Poisson average of one inactivating event per cathomycin marker (37% survival) requires more than 50 breaks per molecule of 12 X lo6 daltons by pancreatic DNase but less than 2-4 breaks by acid DNase.
CATALYTIC PROPERTIES D. GENERAL These have generally been investigated by hyperchromic shift or acid solubility assays and therefore bear on the middle phase of the DNA degradation. 1. Effect of Substrate Concentration, p H , and Ions
When acid DNase activity is assayed by the acid-solubility method the optimal DNA concentration is 0.4 mg/ml (9) and higher substrate concentrations appear to be inhibitory (16, 21, 3 4 ) . It has been shown, however, that this inhibition is because increasing substrate concentration decreases the efficiency of acid-soluble oligonucleotide release since the number of breaks per unit length of DNA is lower. If a direct method of estimating enzymic activity is used, such as the determination of phosphatase-sensitive phosphate, it can be shown that the inhibition by high substrate seen by the acid solubility method is only apparent (34). The effect of pH and ions on acid DNase activity has been investigated in several laboratories, and rather different results have been reported. It appears now that many discrepancies result from a rather poor understanding of the complexity of pH and ion effects. In fact, it has been shown (34) that electrolytes and pH modify the acid DNase activity not only by affecting the enzyme itself but also by stabilizing or destabilizing the secondary structure of native DNA. Since the enzyme has a quite different affinity for the native vs. the denatured structure 34. R. Rosenbluth and S.-C. Sung, C u n . J . Biochem. 47, 1081 (1969)
11. SPLEEN
ACID DEOXYRIBONUCLEASE
28 1
of DNA (9),any change in the secondary structure of the substrate will indirectly affect the enzymic activity. Another complicating factor is the presence or absence of contaminating proteins. The effects of Mg2+ and SO:- are quite different a t different levels of enzyme purity (36). Using very highly purified hog spleen acid DNase a t p = 0.15 (9) the pH optimum is close to 4.8. At a 0.01 M level, Mg2+is slightly inhibitory above pH 4.5, whereas EDTA is an activator. Above pH 5.0, HPOf is slightly inhibitory and 5024- is very strongly inhibitory, particularly above pH 4.5. In succinate buffer, p = 0.15, pH 6.7, the activity is less than 3% of that in acetate buffer, pH 5.0, p = 0.15. At low ionic strength, acid DNase is active a t neutral pH (24,33, 36). Activation of acid DNase by cysteine was reported by Maver and Greco (37'), but was not found by Brown et al. (38).Bernardi and Griff6 (9) found an activating effect only on rather highly purified enzyme preparations. This effect was no longer apparent when protecting proteins were added to the enzyme solutions. Since acid DNase has no free sulfhydryl groups (see Section II,B), it is possible that cysteine protects the enzyme against traces of heavy metals. It should be mentioned that cytochrome c is particularly effective as a protecting protein. 2. Inhibitors
The occurrence of a dialyzable, heat-stable inhibitor in human urine has been reported (39, 40). Inhibition results from urinary sulfate (41) as well as from other salts ( 4 2 ) . Iodoacetic acid, N-bromosuccinimide, and H20, were found to be strongly inhibitory, whereas iodoacetamide was only slightly inhibitory and diisopropylfluorophosphate was not inhibitory. These results suggest that tryptophan, methionine, and/or histidine, but not serine, are involved in the enzymic activity ( 4 3 ) . Acid DNase is strongly inhibited by actinomycin D. In contrast with the claim (44) that actinomycin causes the same extent of inhibition of 35. C. Cordonnier and G. Bernardi, Can. J . Biochem. 46, 989 (1968). 36. J. Shack, JBC 226, 573 (1957). 37. M. E. Maver and A. Greco, JBC 181, 853 (1949). 38. K. D. Brorm, G. Jacobs, and M. Laskowski, JBC 194, 445 (1952). 39. T. R. Koszalka, K. Schreier, and K. I. Altman, BBA 15, 194 (1954). 40. 0. D. Kowlessar, S. Okada, J. 1,. Potter, and K. I. Altman, ABB 68, 231 (1957). 41. E. C. Rauenbusch and K. I. Altman, Proc. Soc. Exptl. Biol. M e d . 104, 385 (1960). 42. P. O w , 0. E. Brown, and J. Laszlo, ABB 131, 652 (1969). 43. M. S. Melzer, Can. J . Biochem. 47, 987 (1969). 44. N. R. Sarkar, BBA 145, 174 (1967).
282
GIORGIO BERNARD1
both pancreatic and acid DNase, the inhibition on acid DNase is much stronger than that on either pancreatic or E. coli DNase (6). The type of inhibition of actinomycin upon acid DNase is that expected for the case of inhibition by coupling of the inhibitor with the substrate but not with the enzyme (6).This is not surprising in view of the strong binding of actinomycin by guanylic acid residues in DNA and of the high guanylic acid level in the sequence split by acid DNase (see below). A protein inhibitor has been extracted and partially purified from mouse liver by Lesca and Paoletti ( 4 5 ) .This protein inhibits acid DNases from different tissues and species but not pancreatic or E . coli DNases. Very interestingly, V vs. substrate concentration plots become sigmoid in the presence of the inhibitor provided that pH is lower than 5.6. The existence of a DNase-inhibitor complex is suggested by sucrose-gradient results. An unusual feature of the inhibitor is its ability to reactivate acid DNase preparations treated with 8 M urea. A weak competitive inhibitory effect of bases, nucleosides, and nucleoside mono- and polyphosphates has been reported ( 4 6 ) . 3’P-oligonucleotides are very weakly inhibitory. Inhibition by natural and biosynthetic polyribonucleotides of the type previously found for some bacterial DNases (47-50) has been demonstrated to occur in the case of spleen acid DNase (51, 5 2 ) . The inhibition is, as in the case of E . coli DNase ( 5 0 ) , of the competitive type. With the remarkable exceptions of poly A and poly C, which did not show any effect on the DNase activity, all synthetic polyribonucleotides tested, transfer RNA and ribosomal RNA exhibited an inhibitory activity. This was very weak with the single-stranded polymer poly U. The finding that polyribonucleotides having single-stranded structures, like poly U, have very weak inhibitory properties and that single-stranded DNA is a poorer substrate than double-stranded DNA underlines the weaker binding of the enzyme by single-stranded structures. It should be stressed that the competitive inhibition by polyribonucleotides is specific and does not simply represent the binding of a polyanion by a basic protein; in fact, some polyribonucleotides are ineffective as inhibitors, and an
45. P. Lesca and C. Paoletti, Proc. Nntl. Acad. Sci. 46. H. Slor, Ph.D. Thesis, Indiana University, 1966.
c’, S. 64,
913 (1969).
A. W. Bernheimer and N. K. Ruffier, J . E x p t l . M e d . 93, 399 (1951). A . W. Bernheimer, BJ 53, 53 (1953). L. Kozloff, Cold Spring Harbor S y m p . Quant. Bid. 18, 209 (1953). I. R. Lehman, G. G. Roussos, and E. A. Pratt, JBC 237, 819 (1962). G. Bernardi, B B R C 17, 573 (1964). A. Jacquemin-Sablon, J. Laval, J.-Y. Le Talaer, J.-B. Le Pecq. and C. Paoletti, C o m p t . R e n d . 259, 2551 (1964). 47. 48. 49. 50. 51. 52.
11.
SPLEEN ACID DEOXYRIBONUCLEASE
283
excess of cytochrome c, a strongly basic protein, in the incubation mixture does not interfere with inhibition.
3. “Phosphodiesterase” Activity Acid DNase from hog spleen catalyzes the slow hydrolysis of p-nitrophenol from bis (p-nitrophenyl) phosphate and the p-nitrophenyl esters of deoxyribonucleoside 3‘-phosphates, but not from those of deoxyribonucleoside 5’-phosphates (9). Using bis (p-nitrophenyl) phosphate as the substrate, the pH optimum was found to be between 5.6 and 5.9. The activity in acetate is about twice as large as in succinate buffer. In acetate buffer, no significant changes occur upon addition of Mg2+ or EDTA. I n the 4-7 pH range, 0.01 A1 S O P and 0.01 M HPOi- g‘ive a very strong inhibition. Interestingly, plots of the initial velocity of hydrolysis of bis (p-nitrophenyl) phosphate vs. substrate concentration have an initial upward curvature, whereas they are hyperbolic when native D N A is used as the substrate. The conclusion of Bernardi and Griff6 (9) that the “phosphodiesterase” activity of acid DNase is an intrinsic property of the enzyme molecule has been recently challenged by Slor (46, 5 3 ) , Swensoii and Hodes ( 5 4 ) ,and Slor and Hodes ( 5 5 ) , who claimed to have obtained a separation of the two activities. I n fact, none of the reported results proves an actual separation of the two activities and constitutes an acceptable evidence against the two activities being carried by the same protein molecule. Some data suggest, however, that the “phosphodiesterase” activity may be inactivated prcferentially by some treatments. I n connection with the phosphodiesterase activity of acid DNase, see also Tables I and I1 in reference (56‘) and the related discussion (56‘a).
E. SPECIFICITY Determining the specificity of a DNase is a problem of great complexity since not only the enzyme itself must be extremely pure but also the other enzymes (exonucleases and phosphatases) used in chain length and terminal nucleotide determinations must be extremely pure ; in addition, extremely accurate anrtlytical methods are needed. I n retrospect, it appears that these requirements were only partially met in some 53. H. Slor, BBRC 38, 1084 (1970). 54. M. R. Swenson and M . E. Hodw. JBC 244, 1803 (1969). 55. H. Slor and M. E. Hodes, A B B 139, 172 (1970). 56. A . Bernardi and G. Bernurdi, this volume. 1’. 329. 56a. P. J. Sicsard. A . Obrenovitch, and G . Aubel-S;idron. FEBS Letters 12, 41 (1970) could not confirm the claim of Hodes el ctl. (54, 5 5 ) .
284
GIORGIO BERNARD1
investigations (5740) devoted to the specificity of acid DNase (61).
A series of investigations in some crucial areas such as the purification of ancillary enzymes (62-65), base analysis (66, 6 7 ) , and kinetics of the middle and terminal phases of acid DNase digestion (19, 65) were therefore made in the author's laboratory. As a result of this work, a new picture of the acid DNase specificity is emerging. The events characterizing the middle and terminal phase may be briefly described as follows. During the middle phase the composition of the 3'-P terminal and of the 5'-OH terminal and penultimate nucleotides of oligonucleotides obtained from calf thymus DNA by acid DNase digestion, in the incubation conditions of Fig. 1, is practically constant. Some results obtained in this phase are given in Table 111. Purine nucleotides form about 75% of the 3'terminals and of the 5'-OH penultimates with a predominance of G in
TABLE I11 SPECIFICITY OF SPLEEN ACID DNase ON CALFTHYMUS DNA 3'-Phosphate terminal nucleotide" A
G T C Purines Pyrimidines Average size (1
28 44 20 8 72 28 14-20
5'-OH 5'-OH terminal penultimate nucleotideb nucleotide* 22 34 13 31 56 44 9.6
52 23 16 9 75 25 9.6
From Soave et al. (19). From Ehrlich et al. (66).
57. S. Vanecko and M. Laskowski, JBC 236, 1135 (1961). 58. S. Vanecko and M. Laskowski, BBA 61, 547 (1962). 59. J. Doskocil and F. Sorm, Collection Czech. Chem. Commun. 26, 2739 (1961). 60. J. Doskocil and F. Sorm, Collection Czech. Chorn. Commun. 27, 1476 (1962). 61. M. Carrara and G. Bernardi, Biochemistry 7 , 1121 (1968). 62. A. Chersi, A. Bernardi, and G. Bernardi, BBA 129, 11 (1966). 63. A. Bernardi and G. Bernardi, BBA 155, 360 (1968). 64. A. Chersi, A. Bernardi, and G. Bernardi, BBA, submitted for publication. 65. S. Ehrlich, G. Torti, and G. Bernardi, Biochemistry (in press). 66. M. Carrara and G. Bernardi, BBA 155, 1 (1968). 67. G. Piperno and G. Bernardi, BBA (in press).
11. SPLEEN
ACID DEOXYRIBONUCLEASE
285
the first case and of A in the second one. This indicates not only that enzyme splittings are very far from random, but also that the enzyme is able to recognize a sequence of a t least three nucleotides in DNA. It is possible, therefore, that acid DNase may be used to assess the relative concentrations of recognized sequences in different DNA's. During the terminal phase a drift in the composition of terminal nucleotides takes place, leading to a more random distribution of terminals.
IV. Distribution, lntracellular localization, and Biological Role
An acid DNase activity has been found in the cells of a number of animal tissues and species (see references 1-6 for reviews of the literature). An interesting problem is whether this activity is carried by similar protein molecules. An unequivocal answer could be obtained by comparing the chemical, physical, and enzymic properties of highly purified preparations obtained from different sources. This being a very long and difficult task, Cordonnier and Bernardi (35) compared the chromatographic and enzymic properties, the sedimentation coefficients, and the mechanism of action on native DNA exhibited by partially purified acid DNase preparations obtained from 15 different animal sources : (a) epithelial tissues-hog liver, hog kidney, and hog pancreas; (b) lymphatic tissues-hog spleen, calf spleen, and calf thymus; (c) tumor tissues-a fibroblastic sarcoma from AKR mice and a mammary epithelioma from C,H mice; (d) nonmultiplying cells-chicken erythrocytes, hog erythrocytes, and mackerel sperms ; (e) biological fluids-hog serum, bull seminal plasma, and human urine; and ( f ) an invertebrate, the clam Mercenuriu mercenariu. The results obtained strongly indicated that the enzymic activity is associated with protein molecules endowed with very similar properties. The enzyme levels in the different tissues examined by Cordonnier and Bernardi (5.5) were found to vary by as much as three orders of magnitude. The highest acid DNase levels were found in lymphatic and tumoral tissues; the lowest were found in cells (sperms and erythrocytes) that do not reproduce themselves anymore. This relationship between levels of acid DNase activity and capacity for proliferation or regeneration of a given tissue had already been observed by Allfrey and Mirsky (68). As far as the intracellular localization of acid DNase is concerned, 68. V. G. Allfrey and A. E. Mirsky, J. Gen. Physiol. 36, 227 (1952).
286
GIORGIO BERNARD1
such an activity was found to be associated with lysosomes by several authors (69). On the other hand, it has been recognized very early that acid DNase activity is latent and that tissue autolysis or acidic treatintent is necessary to release it. J. M. Van Dyck and G. Bernardi (unpublished experiments) found that the enzyme from rat liver tritosomes has the same sedimentation coefficient as spleen acid DNase. It may be interesting to recall that acid DNase has been the first lysosomal enzyme obtained as a homogeneous protein. Concerning the biological role of acid DNase, it has been suggested by several authors that this enzyme might be involved in some essential biological mechanism, like DNA replication, where it might play some accessory role, and DNA recombination. If, however, one considers that lysosomes appear to contain all enzymes needed to degrade nucleic acids to nucleosides (Table IV) , it seems more likely that, a t least under TABLE IV DEQRADATION OF NUCLEIC ACIDSBY LYSOSOMAL HYDROLASES DNA (Acid DNase)
RNA (Acid RNase)
oligonucleotides 3 ’ P
Mononucleotides 3 ’ P (Acid phosphatase)
Nucleosides ‘Hypothetical.
69. J. T. Dingle and H. B. Fell, eds., “Lysosome in Biology and Pathology.” North-Holland Publ., Amsterdam, 1969.
11,
SPLEEN ACID DEOXYRIBONUCLEASE
287
normal conditions, the biological role of acid DNase is a degradative one. Its diplotomic mechanism of action might be an extremely effective way of degrading foreign DNA. From the information gathered so far on acid DNase and other lysosomal hydrolases, it appears that these enzymes share some properties, like the basic character and the absence of SH groups, of digestive enzymes which are excreted from pancreatic cells into the intestinal tract. In this connection, it may be pertinent to mention here that a set of hydrolases of nucleic acids, recalling those of lysosomes, are found in bacterial cells such as E . coli and that they are localized between cell wall and cell membrane (7'0).
70. C. Cordonnier and G. Bernardi, BBRC 20, 555 (1965).
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Deoxyribonuclease I M. LASKOWSKI, SR. I. Introduction . 11. Chemical Nature 111. Active Center . IV. Inhibitor . . V.Ions . . . VI. Kinetics . . VII. Specificity . . VIII. Physiological Role
. . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
.
.
. .
. .
. .
.
. .
.
. .
.
. .
.
. .
.
. .
.
. .
.
. .
.
. .
.
. .
.
289 292
297 299 302 303 308 310
I. Introduction
During the past decade a previously accepted notion that the deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA)-deoxyribonuclease (DNase I) reaction runs a uniform course with a uniform specificity began to be seriously doubted. It is now realized that striking differences exist between the early and terminal stages of the same reaction. The observed differences are not limited solely to the rate of the reaction but include variations in endoor exonucleolytic character, in the effect of the divalent cation, and, finally, in the specificity toward the bases adjacent to the bond that is cleaved. Several reviews and books devoted exclusively t o methodology for following the action of DNase I exist (1-5). For the purpose of this 1. “Methods in Enzymology,” Vol. 2, Sect. 2, 1955. 2. “Methods in Enzymology,” Vol. 6, Sects. 1 and 2, 1963. 3. “Methods in Enzymology,” Vol. 12, Parts A and B, 1967, 1968. 4. G. L. Cantoni and D. R. Davies, Procedures Nucleic Acid Res. Sect. A (1966). 5. N. Kurnick, Methods Biochem. Anal. 9, 1 (1962). 289
290
M. LASKOWSKI, SR.
review it suffices to say that it is possible by the use of the p H stat to measure the number of internucleotide bonds cleaved. This method is independent of the stage of the reaction or of the location of the bond within the molecule. Methods measuring changes in molecular weight reflect the number of double-strand scissions. Finally, with the use of two other enzymes, polynucleotide kinase and DNA ligase (see below), it is possible to evaluate the number of “nicks” inflicted on one of the strands without causing a scission. Methods based on spectrophotometry reflect the collapse of ordered structure. Finally, methods measuring the appearance of mononucleotides reflect exonucleolytic activity. Among endonucleases which hydrolyze DNA one seldom finds an enzyme that attacks double-stranded and single-stranded substrates with equal ease. If the enzyme shows preference for double-stranded substrates (as DNase I does) autoretardation is observed. This decrease in the reaction rate is caused by the gradual disappearance of the preferred, double-stranded substrate and an increase in the concentration of less susceptible, single-stranded substrate. Differences in rates between the early and terminal phases of the reaction of the order of 1OOOfold have been described ( 6 ) . The opposite case, autoacceleration, is seen with those enzymes that show preference for the single-stranded structure, e.g., micrococcal nuclease ( 7 ) . I n the original meaning (8,9)endonucleases and exonucleases were conceived as retaining their character throughout the whole course of the reaction. It is now established that at least some typical endonucleases acquire exonucleolytic character toward the end of the reaction (10). Proximity of the newly created monophosphoryl or hydroxyl group is responsible for this change. Many DNases are known to be activated by a divalent cation. However, only from the work of Bollum (11) did it become clear that the nature of the cation may qualitatively change the specificity of the enzyme toward adjacent bases. Quantitative changes in the requirements for the divalent cation (10) have been observed during different stages of the same reaction, e.g., micrococcal nuclease (7) where the increased Ca2+concentration causes a decrease in the average size of the terminal product. Finally, it was shown with a number of DNases that during the 6. S. Vanecko and M. Laskowski, Sr., JBC 236, 3312 (1961).
7. E.Sulkowski and M. Laskowski, Sr., JBC 243, 4917 (1968). 8. M.Privat de Garilhe and M. Laskowski, Sr., JBC 223, 661 (1956). 9. M.Laskowski, Sr., G. Hagerty, and U.-R. Laurila, Nature 180, 1181 (1957) 10. M. Laskowski, Sr., Advan. Enzymol. 29, 165 (1967). 11. F.J. Bollum, JBC 240, 2599 (1965).
12. DEOXYRIBONUCLEASE
I
291
course of the reaction cleavages become less specific (10). By extrapolation, the first few cleavages must be very specific. The direct proof for this statement is delayed by technical difficulties in determining terminal nucleotides in fragments of 1000 or more monomers. I n spite of this, it seems safe to predict that in the near future the DNases previously considered to be nonspecific will be used to inflict a very limited number of very specific cleavages. Regulation of ionic medium, pH, temperature, and exposure time can be expected to significantly improve specificity in the early stages of the reaction. On the other hand, it becomes equally evident that in the terminal stages of the reaction, in addition to the base specificity the effect of the monophosphoryl group determines the end point of the reaction (1.2). The reasons for selecting pancreatic DNase I as one of the two representative of mammalian DNases are to a large extent historical. Deoxyribonuclease I was the first enzyme to be recognized as specific for DNA (13-16),the first DNase to produce 5’-monoesterified products (16, lY), the first DNase to be crystallized (It?), the first DNase to have a specific protein inhibitor (19-23),the first DNase shown to produce “nicks” on one strand in preference to scission of both strands ( 2 4 , 2 6 ) .A new first has been added recently (25a) ; DNase I was covalently coupled to porous glass, thus supplying an insoluble DNase. The articles on DNases in previous editions of “The Enzymes” (26,xT) discussed several of these issues in historical perspective. The historical discussion will not be repeated in the present edition except when new information requires an introduction. 12. A. J. Mikulski, E. Sulkowski, L. Stasiuk, and M. Laskowski, Sr., JBC 244, 6559 (1969). 13. J. P. Greenstein and W. V. Jenrette, J . Natl. Cancer Inst. 1, 845 (1941). 14. M. Laskowski, Sr. and M. K. Seidel, A B B 7, 465 (1945). 15. M. McCarty, J . Gen. Physiol. 29, 123 (1946). 16. J. L. Potter, K. D. Brown, and M. Laskowski, Sr., BBA 9, 150 (1952). 17. R. L. Sinsheimer and J. F. Koerner, JACS 74, 283 (1952). 18. M. Kunitz, J . Gen. Physiol. 33, 349 (1950). 19. W. Dabrowska, E. J. Cooper, and M. Laskowski, Sr., JBC 177, 991 (1945). 20. E. J. Cooper, M. L. Trautman, and M. Laskowski, Sr., Proc. SOC. Exptl. B i d . M e d . 73, 219 (1950). 21. L. Cunningham and M. Laskowski, Sr., BBA 11, 590 (1953). 22. U. Lindberg, Biochemistry 6, 323 (1967). 23. U. Lindberg, Biochemistry 6, 343 (1967). 24. S. Zamenhof, G. Griboff, and N. Marullo, BBA 13, 459 (1954). 25. E. T. Young, I1 and R. L. Sinsheimer, JBC 240, 1274 (1965). 25a. A. R. Neurath and H. H. Weetall, FEBS Letters 8, 253 (1970). 26. M. Laskowski, Sr., “The Enzymes,” 1st ed., Val. 1, p. 956, 1951. 27. M. Laskowski, Sr., “The Enzymes,” 2nd ed., Val. 5, p. 123, 1961.
M. LASKOWSKI, SR.
II. Chemical Nature
Almost as soon as bovine pancreatic crystalline DNase I was obtained, doubts concerning its homogeneity arose. Even before crystallization (18) it was shown (28,282sa) that DNase I cocrystallizes with chymotrypsinogen B. The chronologically first crystalline product contained about two-thirds chymotrypsinogen B and about one-third DNase I (28, 28a). It would, therefore, be expected that the reverse also occurs. I n fact, Potter (29) showed that a commercial sample of crystalline DNase can be separated into five protein-containing bands on cellulose acetate strips. One of these bands was identified as chymotrypsinogen B. With a sensitive method of detection (31) the presence of one part of RNase per 100,000 parts of DNase I was found in the crystals. This activity could be further reduced by continuous flow electrophoresis (S2), or more efficiently by chromatography on DEAE-cellulose (33). Lindberg (34) passed the solution of commercial crystalline DNase I through a column of Sephadex G-100, removed contaminants of smaller molecular weight, and obtained a preparation of high purity. A series of beautiful papers from the laboratory of Moore and Stein ( 3 5 3 9 a ) recently appeared, confirming that crystalline DNase I is contaminated with about one-third chymotrypsinogen B and chymotrypsin B. It was first established (35) that commercial DP grade ( 3 2 ) DNase I is composed of a t least two, enzymically active glycoproteins. Figure 1, reproduced from the work of Price et al. ( S 5 ) , shows the separation on SE-Sephadex into two equally active components B and A. A modified procedure (39) of chromatography on phosphocellulose (Fig. 2) led to three peaks, C, B, and A (in order of their appearance from the column). A further refinement of technique (39a) allowed visualization of a small additional 28. M. Laskowski, Sr., JBC 166, 555 (1946). 28a. M. Laskowski, Sr. and A. Kazenko, JBC 167, 617 (1947). 29. J. L. Potter, personal communication, quoted by Laskowski (SO). 30. M. Laskowski, Sr., Procedures Nucleic Acid Res. p. 83 (1966). 31. J. Polatnick and H. L. Bachrach, Anal. Biochem. 2, 161 (1961). 32. Worthington, catalog (1965). 33. S. B. Zimmerman and G. Sandeen, Anal. Bioehem. 14, 269 (1966). 34. U. Lindberg, Biochemistry 6, 335 (1967). 35. P. A. Price, T.-Y. Liu, W. H. Stein, and S. Moore, JBC 244, 917 (1969). 36. P. A. Price, S. Moore, and W. H. Stein, JBC 244, 924 (1969). 37. P. A. Price, W. H. Stein, and S. Moore, JBC 244, 929 (1969). 38. B. J. Catley, S. Moore, and W. H. Stein, JBC 244, 933 (1969). 39. J. Salnikow, W. H. Stein, and S. Moore, Federation Proc. 28, 344 (1969). 398. J. Salnikow, S. Moore, and W. H. Stein, JBC 245, 5685 (1970).
12.
DEOXYRIBONUCLEASE I
293
peak D. Each component had comparable specific activity. Peaks A:B:C were present in a constant ratio of 4:l:l. The major peak A corresponded to peak A of the previous separation (35). Figure 2 shows a portion of the chromatographic pattern obtained on phosphocellulose. Peak A has been studied further. Table I, reproduced from the paper of Price et al. (35),compares amino acid content of peak A with that obtained by Lindberg (34) for the purified DNase I. The composition reported from the two laboratories for preparations obtained by two different methods is surprisingly similar. The linear sequence is being determined in the laboratory of Moore and Stein (39b). The possibility that the three fractions are artifacts caused by the exposure to a strong acid during the preparation procedure has been ruled out by the experiment with a freshly collected pancreatic juice. The juice was first chromatographed on DEAE-cellulose according to Keller et al. (40) and the fraction containing DNase was then rechromatographed on phosphocellulose (39) and gave three identical peaks as were seen with crystalline DNase. To elucidate the mode of attachment of the carbohydrate moiety to the protein of DNase I, Catley et al. (38)digested the peak A DNase with Pronase and subjected the digest to gel filtration on Sephadex G-25. All of the carbohydrate was recovered in a mixture of the dipeptide SerAsp and the tetrapeptide Ser-Asp-Ala-Thr. Removal of serine by an Edman degradation demonstrated that all of the carbohydrate was in association with aspartic acid. Analysis of the carbohydrate moiety demonstrated two residues of glucosamine, five residues of mannose, and one residue of ammonia, leading to the conclusion that the saccharide moiety is attached at a single position on the enzyme through an aspartamidohexose linkage. An analysis of the peak B DNase identified the same sugars in the same proportions except that sialic acid was present in fractional quantities. Since sialic acid in the intact peak B DNase analyzed for 0.2 residue and in a tetrapeptide fraction for 0.06 residue, it was considered to be part of an impurity not associated with the heptasaccharide moiety. If the presence of fractional quantities of sialic acid is accidental, the most probable reason for the separation of peaks C, B, and A appears to be the number of amides since the gross amino acid composition is not different. Some minor corrections of the values shown in Table I are required. The latest work (39a) shows that peaks A and B have identical amino acid composition. Peak A contains two residues of N-acetylglucosamine 39b. S. Moore and W. H. Stein, personal communication (1970). 40. P. J. Keller, E. Cohen, and H. Neurath, JBC 233, 344 (1958).
M. LASKOWSKI, SR.
oo
0
- 100 >
0
o o o
c
V
<-
'c
x c 0 c
C 0 V
120
60
Effluent ml
Effluent ml
FIG.1A and B.
I80
12.
295
DEOXYRIBONUCLEASE I
0.2
E c 0 aD N L
0
w 0.I U
0
e
n 5:
a
Effluent ml
FIG.1. Chromatography of various samples of DNase on SE-Sephadex column, 0.9 by 55 cm; temperature, 25" ; initial eluent 0.2 M sodium acetate buffer, p H 4.70; linear gradient with 150 ml each of the initial and limit buffer, 1.OM sodium Enzymic activity. (A) Worthington D P grade DNase acetate buffer, pH 4.70. (0) (amorphous), load 30 mg, linear gradient begun a t 30 ml. (B) Worthington oncecrystallized DNase, load 45 mg, linear gradient begun a t 21 ml. (C) Worthington electrophoretically purified DNase, load 5 mg, linear gradient begun a t 20 ml. From Price et al. (36). Authentic sample of chymotrypsinogen B tested in the same system was eluted between 10 and 35 effluent ml. Chymotrypsin B gave several peaks in the range 15-65 ml.
1.2-
A
A280
0.6 -
mL
100
FIG. 2. Chromatography of DNase I (Worthington D P grade) on phosphocellulose (Whatman P-11, column 0.9 by 70 cm) linear gradient of sodium acetate buffer pH 4.7, 0.38-0.7 M (with respect to acetate), 200 ml of each. From Salnikow et al. (39).
296
M. LASKOWSKI, SR.
TABLE I AMINOACID COMPOSITION OF PANCREATIC DEOXYRIBONUCLEASE PEAKA a - b ~~
~
Nearest integral number of residues per molecule
Residue
Residues per 100 g of protein
Residues Per molecule
Price et al. (Ref. 56)
3.78 2.65 6.08 12.08 4.88 8.41 8.37 2.93 1.75 5.13 8.55 4.33 8.49 8.30 5.47 1.71 1.31 2.34 0.97 0.95
9.14 5.99 12.07 32.81 14.96 29.92 20.00 9.35 9.51 22.37 26.72 11.86 23.26 15.77 11.52 4.05 3.95 3.90 1.82 1.81
9 6 12 33 15 30 20 9 10 22 27 12 23 16 12 4 4 4 2 2
~
Lysine Histidine Arginine Aspartic acid Threoninec SerineC Glutamic acid Proline Glycine Alanine Valined Isoleucined Leucine Tyrosinec Phenylalanine Methioninea Half-cystinee Tryptophan/ Mannose Glucosamine Amide-NH3 Total
Lindherg (Ref. 34) ~~
9 6 12
34 15 30 20 9 9 23 27 12 24 16 12 4 4 4
22 98.589
272
From Price et al. (36). Duplicate analyses by ion exchange chromatography were performed on 24-, 48-, and 72-hr hydrolyzates. Unless indicated otherwise, the average of all of these values was used to compute the values in the second column. Replicate analyses agreed to *2.5y0. A molecular weight of 31,000 was used to calculate the residues per molecule. The average 24-, 48-, and 72-hr values for threonine, serine, and tyrosine have been extrapolated to zero time to correct for destruction during hydrolysis. The average 72-hr values were taken for isoleucine and valine. Methionine and half-cystine were determined in duplicate as methionine sulfone and cysteic acid on the performic acid-oxidized protein [S. Moore, JBC 238, 235 (1963)l. A molecular ratio of 3.80 was determined for tyrosine to tryptophan by the method of T. W. Goodwin and R. A. Morton [BJ 40, 628 (1946)l. g This recovery figure is based on the weight of the samples analyzed after correction for moisture and ash content.
12.
DWXYRIBONUCLEASE I
297
and six residues of mannose. Peak B contains one residue of sialic acid, three residues of N-acetylglucosamine and five residues of mannose. Peak C contains the same carbohydrate as peak A, but one residue less of histidine and one residue more of proline. All three forms have NH, terminal leucine, COOH-terminal threonine. Other changes from the values of Table I are in tryptophan, three rather than four residues, aspartic acid 34 rather than 33, and valine 25 rather than 27. The amino acid analysis (Table I) strongly supports the value of 31,000 for the molecular weight of DNase I. This value has been accepted in Stockholm (34) and in New York (35), making all previously reported values obsolete [see reviews (10, 26, 27, SO)1. The values obtained (Table 11) by ultracentrifugation methods sedimentation diffusion and approach to equilibrium closely agree with the value of 31,000 based on N-terminal determination. New information is also available (35) on stabilization of the DNase I molecule. The presence of 5 mM Caz+fully stabilizes the molecule against proteolytic digestion. For many years it has been known that pancreatic proteases, trypsin and both chymotrypsins, are protected from autolysis by 10mM Ca2+.The protection of DNase I is achieved by a lower Ca2+ concentration. Calcium also exerts a pronounced effect on the reduction of S-S bonds in DNase I. This protein is unusually susceptible to reduction: Both S-S bonds may be reduced within minutes by mercaptoethanol or similar reagents a t pH 7.2 without any denaturing agent (37). The reduced enzyme is inactive and remains inactive even after exposure for 24 hr to oxygen in the presence of ethylenediaminetetraacetate (EDTA) . The situation changes upon addition of 4 m M Ca2+.Activity is regained in minutes. If the Ca2+is present during reduction, only one S-S bond is reduced and activity remains unchanged. If Ca2+is added to a completely reduced protein even in the presence of a reducing agent one S-S bond is re-formed. In spite of exerting a strong stabilizing effect on the enzyme, Ca2+is not strongly bound to the protein. Simple gel filtration a t neutral pH removed .l6Ca2+completely from both the native and the partially reduced forms of the enzyme (37).
111. Active Center
Neither the three-dimensional structure nor the complete primary structure of DNase I has yet been announced. However, a histidine residue has been identified in the active center of DNase I fraction A by
298
M. LASKOWSK1, SR.
SUMMARY OF
THE
TABLE I1 PHYSICAL AND CHEMICAL CHARACTERISTICS OF DNase 1.
Characteristic analyzed
Ei:m a t 280 nm Experimental From amino acid composition Refractive index increment (ml/g)' szO,a ( X 10-13 sec) D20,w( X 10+ cm2/sec) Partial specific volume (from amino acid composition)
Results obtained 12.3b 13.9" 15.3d 0.196 f 0.007f 2.78 8.7 0.733
Molecular weight Approach to equilibrium Sedimentation diffusion N-Terminal determination Isoelectric point Experimental Total nitrogen (%) Experimental From amino acid composition Total sulfur (yo) Experimental From amino acid composition ~~
30 ,900 30,700 29 ,400 31,300 4.79 16.7 f 0.4f 16.2 0.75 f 0.02f 0.81
~
Reprinted from Lindberg (34) by permission of the copyright owner. Copyright 1967 by the American Chemical Society. b In 0.01 M KzHP04-KH2P04buffer, pH 7.6. I n 0.1 N NaOH, pH 13. d This value was calculated using the molar extinction coefficients for the aromatic amino acids tyrosine and tryptophan given by T. W. Goodwin and R. A. Morton [BJ 40, 628 (1946)). 8 Here dn/dc was determined at 20", using the ultracentrifuge as a differential refractometer. f The average deviation about the mean is given based on four determinations. 0 Determined by M. Kunitz [ J . Cen. Physiol. 33, 349 (1950)] and by A. Polson [BBA 22, 61 (1956)j. 0
Price et al. (36).The evidence is based on experiments in which DNase I was reacted with iodoacetate a t pH 7.2 in the presence of 0.1 M Mn2+. Under these conditions the enzyme is gradually inactivated and the loss of activity parallels the formation of one residue of 3-carboxymethyl histidine per molecule. The rate of the alkylation reaction is dependent on Mnz+concentration. Substitution of Mn2+by Cuz+in the presence of tris buffer greatly increases the rate of alkylation. A 29-residue peptide con-
12.
DEOXYRIBONUCLEASE I
299
taining the modified histidine residue has been isolated in 90% yield after tryptic hydrolysis of carboxymethylated DNase I. One structural requirement in the active center can be deduced from a study of specificity with small substrates (see Section VII). Oligonucleotides bearing a 3'-monophosphoryl group are easily cleaved to form d-pNwp (41), whereas neither N u nor pN@is formed. This suggests that a positively charged group (either from lysine or arginine) is placed in the vicinity of an active histidine and immobilizes the negative charge of 3'-monophosphoryl group. One can further speculate that the resistance of d-N"pN0 and d-pN"pN@to the action of DNase I is caused by the lack of such an anchor. However the resistance of a t least some compounds of the type d-pN"pN@cannot be explained without postulating the repulsive effect of the 5'-monophosphoryl group. The long-established preference for the Pu-pPy bond is presumably of lesser structural importance than the phosphoryl group because d-ApApTp can be cleaved to liberate d-pTp (@), whereas d-CpApC is resistant (43).
IV. Inhibitor
A naturally occurring inhibitor of DNase I was originally observed in hypertrophic epithelium of the crop gland of a pigeon (19) and later in several normal and neoplastic mammalian tissues (20, 2 1 ) . The early work has been reviewed (10). For several years, except for sporadic confirmation, the problem remained dormant until Lindberg (22, 23, 4.4, 45) resumed the work and purified two different proteins with inhibitory properties from calf spleen. The spleen inhibitor I1 was crystallized. It forms a uni-uni molecular complex with DNase I under conditions in which either the inhibitor or DNase I is in excess. Figure 3, reproduced from Lindberg's paper (23), illustrates this point. The complex can be irreversibly dissociated (with the loss of inhibitory activity) into its component parts a t pH 7.6 in the presence of 3 M urea. It can also be dissociated a t pH 11.3 and a t pH 3.5 again with loss of inhibitor activity, the activity of DNase I remaining intact. Recently, Lindberg and Skoog (45a) purified DNase I inhibitor from thymus. A 15-fold purification led to a homogeneous preparation. The thymus inhibitor has many properties identical with spleen inhibitor I1 but differs in molecular weight 41. S. Vanecko and M. Laskowski, Sr.,JBC 236, 1135 (1961). 42. J. L. Potter, U.-R. Laurila, and M. Laskowski, Sr.,JBC 233, 915 (1958). 43. H. G. Khorana, J . Cellular C o m p . Physiol. 54, Suppl. 1, 5 (1959). 44. U. Lindberg, BJ 92, 27p (1964). 45a. U. Lindberg and L. Skoog, European J . Biochetn. 13, 326 (1970).
300
M. LASKOWSKI, SR.
0.4
I("
1 ' " A,1
DNase I
p..'
0.2/
,
,
0
,q
1
lo
0
420 I
-0 - 60 -40
0 -20
E
;
>._ c
'"
-,o
N
+
3
0
0)
c
e
n P
a
10 0
10 0 Effluent(ml)
40
60
80
FIG.3. Sephadex G-100 chromatography on DNase I, inhibitor 11, and mixture containing the two proteins. (A) DNase I only, (B) inhibitor I1 only, (C) and (D) both components with different molar excess of inhibitor, (E) equimolar amounts of inhibitor and enzyme, (F) and ( G ) both components with a different excess of enzyme. Absorbance a t 215 nm (solid line) was measured after 20-fold dilution with water using a similarly diluted blank of the elution buffer (0.5 M potassium phosphate, p H 7.6). Each chromatogram was analyzed for DNase activity (01, inhibitor activity ( O ) , and for the presence of DNase-inhibitor complex, in this figure represented as DNase I activity which was measured on samples of the fractions after adjustment of the pH to 3.5 with HCl ( 0 ) .[From Lindberg (3 4 ). Copyright 1967 by the American Chemical Society. Reprinted by permission of the copyright owner.]
12. DEOXYRIBONUCLEASE I
30 1
(49,000 instead of 59,000 for spleen inhibitor 11) and in the maximum stability which is a t pH 6 for thymus and pH 7 for spleen. One of the most exciting aspects of the problem is the exact mechanism of the union of the two proteins. Striking progress in understanding of the mechanism of the union between trypsin and trypsin inhibitor has been made in the laboratory of Laskowski, Jr. (46, 4 7 ) . The trypsin inhibitor-trypsin complex is essentially a Michaelis-Menten complex. During the union one trypsin-sensitive bond in the inhibitor (reactive site) is cleaved without affecting the inhibitory power of the protein, thus creating “the modified form” of the inhibitor. If one makes an analogy to enzyme other than trypsin, it would be expected that the inhibitor for DNase I should be a specifically resistant DNA. However, the protein nature of both partners, DNase I and spleen inhibitor 11, is well established. Obviously, not all protein-protein interactions must be of the trypsin inhibitor-trypsin type, but it may be worthwhile to check the DNase inhibitor for possible proteolytic activity. One is tempted to speculate that in this case the inhibitor I1 may be a protease specific for a peptide linkage involving histidine. To prove it experimentally, it would be necessary to trap the “modified form of DNase I” before the bond is re-formed. Several years ago the question of whether DNase I is a strictly digestive enzyme was argued. On the basis of experiments in which DNase I type of activity was found in the minced tissue only after the previous exposure to an acid pH, known to destroy the inhibitor, it was concluded (21) that the DNase I type of enzyme is intracellular and ubiquitous. Recently, Lee and Zbarsky (48) used pigeon crop gland inhibitor to identily a DNase I type of activity in the intestional mucosa of the rat. The crop gland inhibitor and presumably the spleen inhibitor I1 react with DNase I of many species. It appears that no species specificity exists in the reaction of complex formation. The above considerations could bring us to the discussion of the occurrence of DNase I in different tissues and in different organelles of the same cell. A fairly extensive literature exists, particularly in reference to different pathological conditions. It will not be considered in this review. In many papers only two criteria are used to classify an enzyme as DNase I : (1) It requires Mg”, and (2) it has an optimum a t pH 7. 46. M. Laskowski, Jr., S y m p . , Structure-Pri?iction Relationship of Proteolytic En(P. Desnuelle, H. Neurath, and M. Ottessn, eds.) p. 89. Munksgaard, Copmliagen, and Academic Press, New York. 1970. 47. M. Laskowski, Jr. and R . W. Senlock, “The Enzymes,” 3rd ed., Vol. 111, p. 376, 1971. 18. C. Y. Lee and S. 11. Zbarsky, Can. J . Biochem. 45, 39 (1967). zymes, 1968
302
M. LASKOWSICI, SR.
Historically, these criteria are justified, but they are no longer sufficient. Additional information characterizing the enzyme as a 5'-monoester former would be desirable, but the ability to react with the specific DNase I inhibitor appears to be the most important criterion. Without having tested for it the enzyme should not be called DNase I.
V. Ions
Many years ago it was observed that the presence of either Mg2+or MnZ+increased the rate of hydrolysis of DNA by DNase I whereas high concentrations of NaCl decreased it [see review (10)1. The revolutionary finding comes from the work of Bollum (11) who showed that the nature of activating cation qualitatively affects specificity. Deoxyribonuclease I was presented with (dI),.(dC), as substrate. Only (dI), but no (dC), was hydrolyzed when 1 0 m M Mg2+ was the sole activating divalent cation. If, in addition to Mg2+,2 mM Ca2+was introduced, both strands were hydrolyzed. The same result (both strands digested) was obtained when 10 m M Mn2+ alone was present instead of the mixture of Mg2+and Ca2+.A recent paper (48a) describes the elegant separation and identification of di- and trinucleotides in the DNase I digest. The composition of digests obtained in the presence of Mn2+is different from that obtained in the presence of MgZ+. This result strongly supports Bollurn's (11) conclusion. This discovery of Bollum (11) makes obsolete a number of previous excellent studies including those on mutual interdependence between concentrations of divalent metal, monovalent metal, hydrogen ion, and substrate. Unless the bond affected by the metal in question is specified, an overall rate represents a number with little value. The problem is further complicated by the suspected (by analogy to other nucleases) quantitative changes in requirements for metal ions a t different stages of the reaction. So far no such data are available for DNase I. One is tempted to add, luckily, because in view of the uncertainty of qualitative effects such data would hardly be expected to have a long survival time. Melgar and Goldthwait (49, 50) used a method in which isotopically labeled DNA was incorporated into acrylamide gel. The suspension of the gel containing DNA was used as substrate. The average molecular 48a. E. Juchnowicz and J. H. Spencer, Biochemistry 9, 3640 (1970). 49. E. Melgar and D. A . Goldthwait, JBC 243, 4401 (1968). 50. E. Melgar and D. A. Goldthwait, JBC 243, 4409 (1968).
12.
DEQXYRIBONUCLEASE I
303
weight of fragments released from the gel was approximately 400,000. In the presence of Mg2+ alone the rate of release of these fragments with DNase I showed a lag period. No such lag period was observed with either DNase I1 or E . coli endonuclease I, known to make doublestrand scissions. The lag was eliminated when Mn2+,Caz+, or Co2+,or Mg2+plus Ca*+was used. Sodium added to Mn2+,to Ca2+,or to Ca2+plus Mg2+reestablished the lag. The results are interpreted as indicating that only single-strand cleavages occur during the lag period, whereas double-strand scissions release the fragments from the gel. This interpretation was confirmed by viscometry and ultracentrifugation. Eichhorn et al. (51) concluded that Co*+is a better activator of DNase I than any of the previously used metals. As a criterion of activity the authors used the formation of acid-soluble products, corresponding to terminal stages of the reaction. I n neither of these papers (49, 51) was the attempt made to characterize the split bond.
VI. Kinetics
As mentioned in the Introduction, a characteristic aspect of the kinetics of DNase I acting on native DNA is autoretardation (10). Autoretardation is caused by the continuous formation of products which are poorer substrates than those from which they are derived. Three types of experiments were performed to prove this (6). Experiments of the first type were performed in a p H stat. The reaction was allowed to run until the originally fast rate reached a plateau. At this time a 100-fold excess of enzyme was added. The initial rate of the reaction was restored, then slowed down, and reached a second plateau. Further addition of a fourfold amount of enzyme (the total enzyme concentration was now 500-fold that of the original) resulted in a new burst of activity, but the rate was slower than the original. A second type of experiment was performed by isolating the reaction products a t different stages of the degradation and using them as substrate for a fresh sample of DNase I. The reaction again was followed in a p H stat. The rate was highest with native DNA. To obtain comparable rates the amount of enzyme needed was 15-fold with the “I-min digest,” 500-fold with the “10-min digest,” and 2500-fold with “oligonucleotides” obtained from the reaction in which the first plateau was reached. 51. G. L. Eichhorn, P. Clark, and E. Tarien, JBC 244, 937 (1969).
304
M. LASKOWSKI, SR.
The third type of experiment was performed to show that inhibition by the products is insufficient to account for the observed difference in rate. The substrate consisted of a 50:50 mixture (in terms of optical density) of native DNA and “oligonucleotides.” With this mixture the rate of hydrolysis decreased to about one-half of that for native DNA. This result agrees with the previously established (52) competitive-type inhibition by the products. It also shows that the inhibition by products accounts for changes in rate within one order of magnitude, whereas the decreasing affinity toward the newly formed substrates accounts for more than three orders of magnitude. With so pronounced a difference in susceptibility of substrate in the very early and in the very late phases of the reaction, the two phases must be considered independently. Kinetics of the early phases of the reaction have been studied by Dekker and Schachman (53),Schumaker et al. (54),Thomas ( 5 5 ) , and Young and Sinsheimer ( 2 5 ) . All the results demonstrate that DNase I hits a t random and that several hits on a single strand occur before one double-strand scission is detected. The estimates of numbers, however, vary; Thomas considered that an average of 200 single hits occur before the average molecular weight has decreased by a factor of 2. Young and Sinsheimer (25) estimated that an average of 4 hits occur before h-phage DNA is inactivated, possibly as a result of a doublestrand scission. The ability of DNase I to inflict a number of a single-strand breaks (or nicks) before producing a detectable decrease in molecular weight has been utilized by Richardson and his colleagues to create a detecting system in their studies of polynucleotide kinase and DNA ligase (56, 5 t h ) . The scheme of sequential reactions involved in nicking and labeling the nicked ends is reproduced in Fig. 4. Figure 5 shows the dependence between the number of single-strand breaks and concentration of DNase I. In view of the impact of this work on several lines of nucleic acid research some of the experimental details are given in the legends. Figure 6 shows the scheme of a procedure by which the labeled nicks are first closed with the aid of DNA ligase. Deoxyribonucleic acid is then degraded enzymically in such a manner that allows the identification of the nucleosides adjacent to the labeled internucleotide linkage. Table I11 shows the composition of nucleotides adjacent to the nick 52. L. F. Cavalieri and B. Hatch, JACS 75, 1110 (1953). 53. C. A. Dekker and H. K. Schachman, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U . S. 40,894 (1954). 54. V. N. Schumaker, E. G. Richards, and H. K. Schachman, JACS 78,4230 (1956). 55. C. A. Thomas, Jr., JACS 78, 1861 (1956). 56. B. Weiss, T. R. Live, and C. C. Richardson, JBC 243, 4530 (1968). 56a. B. Weiss, A. JaqueminSablon, T. R. Live, G. C. Fareed, and C. C. Richardson, JBC 243, 4543 (1968).
32PJ-
L-
-P -"J
1
Polynucleotide Kinase APP+p3'
P32
.-I
PY
FIG.4. Scheme of the preparation containing =P-labeled phosphomonoesters a t single-strand breaks, The two strands of TT DNA duplex are schematically represented by two parallel lines and only the 5' termini are designated. After the introduction of single-strand breaks into DNA by incubation with pancreatic DNase, the phosphomonoesters formed are removed by phosphatase a t 65". The 5' termini are then labeled by incubation with polynucleotide kinase. From Weiss et al. (66).
DNase concentralion,units /ml
1 k . 5. Production of single-strand breaks by pancreatic DNase. T, DNA w m incubated with varying amounts of pancreatic DNase. After each reaction, the number of single-strand breaks (internal phosphomonoesters per 4.0 X 10' nucleotides) was measured by end group labeling (see Fig. 4 ) . Crystalline pancreatic DNase I (11 mg. 1 vial Worthington) was dissolved in a 1-ml solution containing 10 m M sodium acetate buffer, pH 5.5,5 mM MgCl,, 0.2M NaC1, and 0.5 mg/ml of bovine plasma albumin. The mixture was stored at 0" for up to 1 month during which time it gradually lost 10-25% of its activity. Immediately before use it was diluted with the same solution and assayed spectrophotometrically by the method of Kunitz. One unit of enzymic activity was defined as the amount of enzyme causing an increase in Az, of 0.001/min/ml of assay solution at 25". Deoxyribonucleic acid was incubated in 5 ml volume containing 1.3 mM DNA, 67 mM tris-HC1 buffer (pH 8.0), 5 m M MgCl,, and 0.5-5 units of DNase I at 20" for 30 min. To stop the reaction EDTA (0.5M,pH 7.5) was added to attain 16 mM concentration. The niixture was dialyzed for 8 hr at 4" against 20 n d 1 NaCl-10 mM tris-HC1 buffer (pH 8.0) and stored up to 6 months at 0".From Weisa et al. (66).
306
M. LASKOWSKI, SR. X
Y
Z
A B C
- -- p l p J p .bz i p l
p
1,-- -
I
Ligose system
X Y Z A B C
- - -pJ P
1 k 1 1,- - P
diesterase sple~/
PJ P
k g a s e
2 HOJps 3-Mononwleotides
32p
4
OH
5'-Mononmleotides
FIG.6. Scheme for nearest neighbor analysis of phosphodiesters formed in the ligase reaction. From Weiss et al. (66a).
TABLE I11 NEARESTNEIGHBORANALYSISOF NUCLEOTIDES JOINED IN LIGASE REACTION"^^ DNA (Fig. 6) prior to the action of ligase 3'-Nucleotides 5'-Nucleotides 5'-Nucleotides DNA (Fig. 6) after the action of ligase
Nucleotide
(%I
(%I
(%)
dAMP d T MP dGMP dCMP
31
22 59
22
44 11
14
8 11
57 9 12
From W e i s et al. (664. A T? DNA preparation (300 mpmoles) containing 90% (the other sePwas terminal) of its a*Pin internal phosphomonoesters was incubated in the standard ligase reaction mixture for 30 min with 0.01 unit of DNA ligase. An aliquot of the reaction mixture was subjected to the standard assay procedure; 90% of 3 2 P in the DNA became insusceptible to phosphatase. The incubation mixture was dialyzed, incubated with phosphatase for 30 min a t 65" to remove any remaining phosphomonoesters. The protein was extracted with phenol, and the DNA was dialyzed against four changes of 0.01 M tris-HC1 buffer (pH 7.6)-0.05 M NaC1. One aliquot of DNA was hydrolyzed completely to 5'-mononucleotides (see Fig. 6) by the consecutive action of pancreatic DNase I and venom o-exonuclease. Another aliquot was hydrolyzed to 3'-mononucleotides by the action of micrococcal nuclease and spleen a-exonuclease. The only labeled nucleotides were those adjacent to the original DNase I cleavage (Fig. 4).
12.
DEOXYRIBONUCLEASE I
307
which was originally inflicted by DNase I (Figs. 4 and 6). The data of Table I11 show that all four bases are present, but A and T are significantly favored. Little can be said concerning the location of nicks relative to the center of the molecule. Present evidence suggests th a t central locations are strongly favored (49, 5 3 ) . This is supported by inability to detect any sign of exonucleolytic character in the early phases of the DNase I reaction (67).A surprising and as-yet unexplained result of the latter work was the finding that in comparison to other nucleases DNase I showed an exceptionally high hyperchromic shift per cleavage during the early phase. As the reaction progressed a plateau was reached, even though titrimetry indicated a continuation of the reaction. One is tempted to speculate that the early nicks occur in such regions where the unwinding of an extended portion of the helix is possible (e.g., A,Trich regions). On the other hand, the cessation of optical changes prior to titrimetric changes suggests that a considerable portion of the oligonucleotides remains double stranded. An elegant study of the kinetics has been performed on single-stranded biosynthetic polymers (68),prepared by the method of Bollum et al. (69). Three polymers were used : (1) d ( [ 3H]PA) (PA)lzl (2) d ( ['HI PA) (PA)llii ( [ 2-14C]PA) 4 ~ ;7 and (31 d ( [3HI PT) (PA) i ~ The . digestion was carried out in the presence of Mg2+ and allowed to proceed in a pH stat until 10% of internucleotide bonds were hydrolyzed. The reaction was stopped by heating on a steam bath. The size of the products in the digestion mixture was determined by means of chromatography on a column of Bio-Gel P-60 previously calibrated with oligomers. The overall conclusion (58) is that the rate of attack on diester bonds within 10 nucleotides of an end is much smaller than on bonds in the central region, if the substrate molecule is several multiples of 10 nucleotides or less in length, but that this discrimination disappears as the substrate length increases. In connection with autoretardation it is interesting to note that with a single-stranded homopolymer, there is a greater probability of producing fragments larger than 10 than of producing shorter fragments. Fragments of about 15 are attacked slower than the larger ones. All these findings confirm autoretardation and extend it into a phase of the reaction, in which little or no double-stranded substrate remains. The observation that short fragments (less than 10) 57. E. J. Williams, S.-C. Sung, and M. Laskowski, Sr., JRC 236, 1130 (1961). 58. D. E. Hoard and W. Goad, J M B 31, 595 (1968). 59. F. J. Bollum, E. Goreniger, and M. Yoneda, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S. 51, 853 (1963).
308
M. LASKOWSKI, SR.
are formed faster in the earlier than in the latter stages of the reaction implies that DNase I either recognizes structure up to 100 A long (3 x 10 oligomers) or recognizes such aspects of the tertiary structure of homopolymers that exist in the long, but not in short, fragments. As in the experiment of Bollum (11), Hoard and Goad ( 5 8 ) , observed that the thymidylic acid fragment was deiraded faster than the corresponding fragment containing adenylic acid. This was in contrast to the report of Ralph et al. (60). Since Bollum and Hoard and Goad used Mg2+whereas Ralph et a2. used Mn2+as activating cation, it seems possible that the observed differences were caused by the nature of the metal (see Section V ) . Entirely different kinetics characterize the terminal phase of the reaction. At this phase, the remaining substrates are quite resistant. Presumably, the end point of the reaction is primarily affected by the concentration of the activation ion.
VII. Speciflcity
The previous characterization of specificity of DNase I (26, H )was arrived a t from the analysis of digestion products at the time of termination of the reaction. Three tacit assumptions were made, all of which are probably false: (1) the specificity does not change during the whole course of the reaction, (2) the nature of the activating ion does not influence specificity, and (3)the end point of the reaction is characteristic for the enzyme and is independent of the medium (ions, pH, type of substrate, etc.) Although the earlier data are valid for the conditions under which they were collected their generality needs to be reexamined. A long time ago, the work in the Sinsheimer’s laboratory (61-63)and in ours (64) established that among the products present a t the so-called termination of the reaction, dinucleotides of the type pPu-pPy were either rare or absent. This was interpreted as evidence that the Pu-pPy bond is the most susceptible to DNase I [for details, see reviews (10, 27, 30)1. This conclusion rests on the validity of the first assumption (see above). The recent work of Scheffler et al. (65) is the only work that supR. K. Ralph, R. A. Smith, and H. G. Khorana, Biochemistry 1, 131 (1962). R. L. Sinsheimer and J. F. Koerner, JACS 74, 283 (1952). R. L. Sinsheimer, JBC 208, 445 (1954). R. L. Sinsheimer, JBC 215, 579 (1955). M. Privat de Garilhe, L. Cunningham, U.-R. Laurila, and M. Laskowski, Sr., JBC 224, 751 (1957). 65. I. E. Scheffler, E. L. Elson, and R. L. Baldwin, J M B 36, 291 (1968). 60. 61. 62. 63. 64.
12.
DEOXYRIBONUCLEASE I
309
ports this premise. The authors digested biosynthetic d (A-T) polymer with DNase I in the presence of Mg” and found only the products of the type d(pTpA),, where n was any integral number. No fragments starting with A, and no odd numbered fragments were detected. These findings show that only the cleavages between A and p?” were occurring throughout the whole course of the reaction, and no other cleavage. This agrees with the postulated specificity Pu-pPy. However, in many respects d (A-T) polymer behaves differently from a representative natural DNA with its four bases. The most obvious difference is its complementarity, which allows it to retain double-stranded conformation essentially throughout the reaction. To accomlish the double-strand scission the hydrolysis of an identical A-pT bond is required. The work on d(A-T), suggests that synthetic polymers may be most useful in elucidating some aspects of base specificity. The conclusion, however, that specificity remains unchanged throughout the whole course of the reaction is not directly transferable to DNA, where early cleavages appear to be considerably more specific than the later ones. I n Section VI the comparison of the rate of hydrolysis of (dA), and (dT), was discussed. The only way to account for the contradictory findings in different laboratories is to ascribe the differences to the activating ion used. The evidence exists that during the late phase of the reaction factors other than the Pu-pPy specificity determine the lability of the internucleotide bond. Thus, Potter et al. (42) easily digested d-ApApTp to d-ApA and d-pTp, whereas Khorana (43) observed that d-CpApT was resistant to DNase I. Both compounds had Pu-pPy sequence in the p - y positions, but differed with respect to 3’-terminal phosphate, which exerts a labilizing influence on the proximal internucleotide bond (see below). Doubts concerning the validity of the second and third premise stem from two sources: studies of the effects of metals on kinetics of DNase I, and from a comparison with other nucleases. Hurst and Becking (66-68) and Hacha and Fredericq (69) showed that whereas Mgz+ and Mn2+ both accelerated the action of DNase I, each led to a different mixture of products. Both groups suggested that DNase I may be a mixture of a DNase and an oligonucleotidase. I n view of Bollum’s findings (11) the probable explanation for these phenomena is that Mn2+ and Mg2+ affected susceptibility of different bonds in the substrate. The experiments in which a direct effect of concentration of a divalent 66. G. C. Becking and R. 0. Hurst, Can. J . Biochem. Physiol. 40, 166 (1962). 67. R. 0. Hurst and G. C. Becking, Can. J . Biochem. Physwl. 41, 469 (1963). 68. G. C. Becking and R. 0. Hurst, Can. J . Bwchem. P h y h l . 41, 1433 (1963). 69. R. Hacha and E. Fredericq, Bull. SOC. Chim. Belges 72, 580 (1963).
310
M. LASKOWSKI, SR.
cation on the end point of the reaction was demonstrated have been performed so far only with micrococcal nuclease (7). It seems likely, however, that with all DNases requiring a divalent cation, the requirement increases as the reaction proceeds. One issue was so far avoided, namely, the origin of mononucleotides. I n a digest stopped a t end point of the fast reaction the digestion mixture contains about 1% of mononucleotides. The maximum amount of mononucleotides ever observed after an exhaustive digestion was 5% ( 6 ) . All four mononucleotides are present but in different amounts. Ralph et al. (60) concluded that the smallest unit from which mononucleotides can be derived is a tetranucleotide, because in agreement with others (6) they found di- and trinucleotides resistant to large doses of DNase I . There is only indirect evidence suggesting that mononucleotides may originate from the o terminus (41). Summarizing the present status of our knowledge of the specificity of DNase I it is necessary to reemphasize the difference between the early and the terminal phase of the reaction. The only exception is biosynthetic d(A-T), (66). With DNA as substrate the early cleavages are directed toward the center of the molecule and are predominantly singlestrand nicks. By analogy to other nucleases one should expect that they are specific also with respect t o the adjacent bases. I n the latter part of the reaction the Pu-pPy bond is preferentially cleaved. The reaction can be carried to the stage when products are essentially a mixture of dinucleotides and trinucleotides. At this stage the term preferentially cleaved linkage is obviously nonapplicable.
VIII. Physiological Role
As yet no definite physiological role can be assigned to DNase I. The role of such an enzyme in digestion is testified by its presence in the pancreatic juice. However, the presence of DNase I activity in practically all other tissues casts doubt that the digestive function is its major role. The prevailing opinion assigns the major function of DNase I t o inflicting nicks during the early stages of hydrolytic attack on DNA. Thus participation in repair phenomena rather than complete digestion appears to be its major function. ACKNOWLEDOMENTS The experimental work referred to in this article and performed in our laboratory was generously supported by the American Cancer Society PRP-30 and E-157, by
12.
DEOXYRIBONUCLEASE I
311
the U. S. Atomic Energy Commission AT(30-1)3630, and the National Science Foundation GB-6058. The author is indebted to Dn. Bollum, Moore, Richardson, Sinsheimer, and Weinfeld for the critical reading of the manuscript, and to Drs. Lindberg, Moore, and Richardson for permission to reproduce their data.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
13 Venonz Exonuclease M.LASKOWSKI, SR.
.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . .
I. Introduction . . . . . . 11. Chemical Nature of the Enzyme . , . 111. Structural Characteristics of Substrates Affecting Susceptibility A. Conformation . . . . B. The Nature of Sugar . . . . . . C. The Nature of Bases . . . . . . . D.Effect of Monophosphoryl Group . . . . IV. Venom Exonuclease as a Tool for Structural Determination . A. Sequence in Ribooligonucleotides . . . . B. Identification of a and o Terminals . . . . . V. Other Venom Enzymes That Hydrolyze Phosphate Esters . .
.
.
. . .
. . . . . . .
313 317 319 319 320 320 322 324 324 326 328
I. Introduction
Venom has long been known to be a good source of several enzymes that hydrolyze esters of phosphoric acid. I t is not possible to discuss venom exonuclease without mentioning other enzymes of this group. An effort will be made, however, to limit the discussion of other phosphatases to the bare essentials and key references. The surveys of different species of snake with respect to these enzymes are fairly numerous (1-9) and allow several conclusions to be drawn. 1. C . 4 . Chen and C.-C. Su, Yamaguchi Med. Coll. J . 8, 570 (1959). 2. C.-C. Yang, C. Iwanoga, and S. Kawashi, J . Formosan Med. Assoc. 57, 525 (1963). 3. S. K . Vasilenko, Biokhimiya 28, 602 (1963). 4. G.T.Babkina and S. K. Vasilenko, Biokhimiya 29, 268, (1964). 5. F.E. Russell, F. W. Buess, and M. V. Woo, Tozicon 1, 99 (1963). 6.B.D. McLennan and B. G. Lane, Federation Proc. 24, 602 (1965). 7. B. D. McLennan and B. G. Lane, Can. J . Biochem. 46, 81 (1968). 8. G.M. Richards, G. du Vair, and M. Laskowski, Sr., Biochemktry 4,501 (1965). 9. D.Mebs, Z. Physiol. Chem. 349, 1115 (1968). 313
314
M. LASKOWSKI, SR.
First, exonuclease (phosphodiesterase) , endonuclease (8, 10-12), 5’nucleotidase (13),and nonspecific phosphatase (13) are present in all venoms that have been analyzed. Therefore, nature did not provide these materials as sources of any one of these enzymes free from undesirable contaminants which may be represented by the others. Second, a new ribonuclease has been reported (3, 4, 6 , 7, 14) in three different species of snake which are widely separated geographically. I n addition, a monophosphatase that specifically or preferentially (7) attacks pNp is strongly suspected. Third, the quantitative differences in concentration of the four enzymes vary appreciably therefore making several venoms an undesirable source of exonuclease (8). All partially purified preparations of venom exonuclease exhibit adenosine triphosphate-pyrophosphatase activity (cleavage of the a-p linkage). Pfleiderer and Ortanderl (14a) studied this issue and showed that during purification the ratio of the two activities remains constant, concluding that both activities are intrinsic properties of the same enzyme. The terms venom exonuclease and venom phosphodiesterase are a t present used interchangeably to designate the same enzyme. The reviewer prefers the first, because he would like to see phosphodiesterase restored to it original meaning as the general name for all enzymes attacking diesterified phosphate. During the recent past, venom exonuclease has been reviewed several times (15-21). Three books (ZZ-24) devoted to nucleases discuss venom exonuclease. The distinction between exonucleases and endonuclease was first formulated in our laboratory (11, 25). The originally erroneous designation of the terminus has been corrected (26-29). 10. H. A. Haessler and L. Cunningham, Exptl. Cell Res. 13, 304 (1957). 11. M. Laskowski, Sr., G. Hagerty, and U.-R. Laurila, Nature 180, 1181 (1957). 12. J. G. Georgatsos and M. Laskowski, Sr., Biochemistry 1, 288 (1962). 13. E. Sulkowski, W. Bjork, and M. Laskowski, Sr., JBC 238, 2477 (1963). 14. L. Brisbois, N. Rabinovitch-Mahler, P. Delori, and L. Grillo, J . Chromatog. 37, 463 (1968). 14a. G. Pfleiderer and F. Ortanderl, Biochem. 2.337, 431 (1963). 15. G. C. Butler, “Methods in Enzymology,” Vol. 2, p. 561, 1965. 16. M. Laskowski, Sr., Ann. N . Y . Acad. Sci. 81, 776 (1959). 17. H. G. Khorana, “The Enzymes,” 2nd ed., Vol. 5, p. 79, 1961. 18. W. E. Razzell, “Methods in Enzymology,” Vol. 6, 236, 1963. 19. M. Laskowski, Sr., Procedures Nucleic Acid Res. p. 154 (1966). 20. M. Laskowski, Sr., Advan. Enzynol. 29, 165 (1967). 21. W. Bjork, Acta Univ. Upsaliensis, Abstr. Uppsala Dissertations Sci. 106 (1967). 22. M. Privat de Garilhe, “Les Nuclkases.” Hermann, Paris, 1964 (in French). 23. M. Privat de Garilhe, “Enzymes in Nucleic Acid Research.” Hermann, Paris, 1967 (in English). 24. V. S. Shapot, “Nukleazy.” Meditzina, Moskva, 1968 (in Russian).
13. VENOM EXONUCLEASE
315
It is now clear that venom exonuclease attacks all polynucleotide chains from the w terminus regardless of the location of the monophosphoryl group (see below). During the past few years, a t the suggestion of Dr. Waldo E. Cohn we have used a to designate the 5' terminus and w for the 3' terminus. The Greek letter has an advantage over the symbol 5', when the terminal nucleotide is to be isolated either as N u or pN'p (a-nucleoside or (~-3~~5'nucleosidediphosphate instead of the alternative description as 5'terminal nucleoside or $-terminal 3',5'-nucleosidediphosphate, which is more cumbersome). I n this connection the reviewer would like to suggest the name of o-exonucleases for the type of enzyme exemplified by venom exonuclease and a-exonucleases for the type of enzyme exemplified by spleen exonuclease, as substitutes for types I and I1 of Razzell (18). This nomenclature is particularly useful in case of nucleases with mixed endo-, exonucleolytic properties as well as mixed mono-, diesterase properties. For example, mung bean nuclease I which was purified as an endonuclease, and thus diesterase, is inseparable from the w-monophosphatase activity (5052); both activities are probably intrinsic properties of the same molecule. An enzyme with similar properties (53) has been previously observed among exonucleases of E . coli (see Chapter 10 by Lehman, this volume). Presumably many more enzymes of this type will be found. Among the presently known nucleases only a few exhibit the W-monophosphatase activity. Venom exonuclease which belongs to the group of W-exonucleases does not have this property (see Section IV,B) . It has been known for some time (16)that venom exonuclease produces only 5'-mononucleotides and that it attacks both deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) and ribonucleic acid (RNA). Recently, however, it was shown that it also attacks derivatives of arabinose (30,34, 36) and
25. 26. 27. 28. 29.
M. Privat de Garilhe and M. Laskowski, Sr., JBC 223, 661 (1955). M. F. Singer, R. J. Hilmoe, and L. A. Heppel, Federation Proc. 17, 312 (1958). W. E. Razzell and H. G. Khorana, JACS 80, 17770 (1958). W. E. Razzell and H. G. Khorana, JBC 234, 2114 (1959). G. M. Richards and M. Laskowski, Sr., Biochemistry 8, 1786 (1969).
30. W. J. Wechter, A. J. Mikulski, and M. Laskowski, Sr., BBRC 30, 318 (1968). 31. P. H. Johnson and M. Laskowski, Sr., JBC 245, 891 (1970). 32. A. J. Mikulski, P. H. Johnson, and M. Laskowski, Sr., Federation Proc. 25, 906 (1970). 33. C. C. Richardson, I. R. Lehman, and A. Kornberg, JBC 239, 251 (1964). 34. W. J. Wechter, J . M e d . Chem. 10, 762 (1967). 35. G. M. Richards, D. J. Tutas, W. J. Wechter, and M. Laskowski, Sr., Biochemistry 6, 2908 (1967).
316
M. LASKOWSKI, SR.
thus appears to be “totally blind” to sugar. Historically, venom exonuclease was considered to have a strong preference for short monostranded oligonucleotides. I n spite of claims to the contrary (%), it is capable of attacking native DNA (11, 37-40). The most important and as yet unanswered question with regard to venom exonuclease is concerned with its endonucleolytic activity. Is this activity a result of contamination with the known venom endonuclease (8, 10-12) or contamination with an as yet unidentified endonuclease, or is it an intrinsic property of the enzyme molecule? Traces of contaminating venom endonuclease, which is a #-monoester former (12) can undoubtedly be identified in all presently available preparations. There are, however, some facts suggesting the presence of an endonucleolytic activity that is distinct from the known venom endonuclease. Tener et al. (41) and Razzell and Khorana (28) found that cyclo-pTpT, cyclo-pTpTpT, and cyclo-pTpTpTpT were all hydrolyzed at an identical, very slow rate, and the only product was pT. No linear oligonucleotide was detected as an intermediate. Should the known endonuclease as a contaminant have been responsible for the opening of the ring, a compound having a 3’-monophosphoryl group would have been detected. Bjork (42) subjected phage T2 DNA to the action of deoxyribonuclease (DNaseI) and obtained a mixture of fragments containing glucosylated hydroxymethyl cytosine. This mixture was then used as substrate for repeated and exhaustive digestion with venom exonuclease. Products containing oligonucleotides were analyzed for glucose to phosphate ratio. It was assumed that glucosylated hydroxymethyl cytosine completely blocks the exonucleolytic action of exonuclease. From the composition of the oligonucleotides obtained after repeated exhaustive digestion, it was concluded that the endonucleolytic action of venom exonuclease requires a sequence of a minimum of three glucose-free nucleotides interposed between the glucose-containing units. Unquestionably the activity observed by Khorana et al. (28, 41) and by Bjork (42) must be ascribed to an enzyme that is a 5’-monoester former. The question as to whether or not this activity is an intrinsic 36. I. I. Nikolskaya, N. M. Shalina, and T. I. Tikhonenko, BBA 91, 354 (1964). 37. H. G. Boman and U. Kaletta, Nature 178, 1394 (1956). 38. H. G. Boman and U. Kaletta, BBA 24, 619 (1957). 39. J. Adler, I. R. Lehman, M. D. Bessman, E. S. Sims, and A. Kornberg, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S. 44, 641 (1958). 40. E. J. Williams, S.-C. Sung, and M. Laskowski, Sr., JBC 236, 1130 (1961). 41. G. M. Tener, H. G. Khorana, R. Markham, and E. H. Pol, JACS 80, 6223 (1958). 42. W. Bjork, Arkiv Kemi 27, 515 (1967).
13.
VENOM EXONUCLEASE
317
catalytic property of pure exonuclease cannot be answered a t present. An interesting substance poly (adenosine diphosphate) in which two 5‘monophosphoryl groups are linked through a pyrophosphate bond to form a chain of not more than 25 oligomers has been recently used as substrate. The enzyme was commercial venom exonuclease that was further purified by passage through a column of Dowex 50W-X8. Matsubara e t al. (@a) concluded that in this system venom exonuclease had endonucleolytic type of action.
II. Chemical Nature of the Enzyme
Very little is known about the chemical nature and physical properties of venom exonuclease; we simply do not have a preparation pure enough to warrant such studies. This regrettable state of affairs is caused in part by the high price of the starting material. No laboratory can afford a macroscale purification procedure. Therefore, the major aim up to the present time has been to obtain a preparation free from the contaminants that interfere with a specific use of the enzyme. This approach resulted in a number of preparations that varied not only in specific activity of exonuclease but also in the nature, and quantity of contaminants. The criteria used to describe these remaining contaminating activities vary. Such statements as “below the level of detection” are helpful only if the level is specified. Unfortunately, this is not always the case. Several methods for preparation of purified venom exonuclease have been described [see the reviews on methods (15,18, 19, 21) and books (22-24) 1. The major effort of purification was directed toward removing the contaminating monophosphatases. A successful and widely used step was introduced by Sinsheimer and Koerner ( 4 3 ) . At p H 4, monophosphatases are precipitated with a lower concentration of acetone; the remaining exonuclease is precipitated by a higher acetone concentration. Several modifications of this principle have been proposed (concentration of acetone, temperature during precipitation, etc.) , Commercially available preparations represent essentially this stage and contain per unit of 5’-nucleotidase, unit of nonspecific unit of exonuclease: phosphatase, and about the same amount of endonuclease. The last figure is only an approximation because of the difficulty of accurate determination. The more elaborate preparations have these contaminants 42a. H. Matsubara, S. Hasegawa, S. Fujimura, T. Shima, T. SugimurtL and M. Futai, JBC 245, 3606 (1970). 43. R. L. Sinsheimer and J. F. Koerner, JBC 198, 293 (1952).
318
M. LASKOWSKI, SR.
reduced by about two orders of magnitude. Recently significant progress was made (43a). Monophosphatases may be selectively inactivated by thermal denaturation below pH 4. Since the acetone precipitation step is not applicable to all venoms, the decision of which method to use depends on the availability of the starting venom: Crotalus adamanteus (35), Bothrops atrox ( 4 4 ), Hemachatus haemachates (45’), and Vipera lebetina ( 4 5 ) . The best that can be done a t present to characterize venom exonuclease is to state that it is a colorless protein, presumably having no prosthetic group. However, the absence of carbohydrate has not been definitely established. The enzyme is heat labile, and it is not significantly retarded on Sephadex G-100 (4.4), suggesting a comparatively large molecular weight. Either exonuclease itself (or a protein t o which it is strongly bound) behaves as a basic protein because it is readily absorbed on CM-cellulose and only slightly on DEAE-cellulose (4,46). Exonuclease activity peaked a t pH 8.7 when the whole venom of cobra (Naja naja atra) was subjected to electrofocusing ( 4 7 ) . Although virtually nothing is known concerning the detailed structure of the exonuclease molecule, speculations about its active center have been made (48, 49). Brown and Bowles (48) concluded that venom exonuclease requires the following for activity: intact tryptophan and tyrosine residues, SH groups, and S-S bridges. Wigler ( 4 9 ) ,on the basis of kinetic data, concluded that the active center contains two closely located acidic groups. The presence of acidic groups in the vicinity of the active center serves to explain the recent results of Richards and Laskowski (30, 5 0 ) , who found that a double negative charge on the 3’-monophosphoryl group confers an unusual resistance on this type of compound to exonuclease. Suggestions concerning the structural element to which the enzyme binds vary. Razzell and Khorana ( 5 1 ) , on the basis of minimal requirements for activity, considered the binding site identical with the hydrolytic site, which is limited to one doubly esterified 5’-nucleotide. Bjork (42) believed that besides a hydrolytic site additional binding sites exist. I n this connection it should be mentioned that whereas a #-mono43a. E. Sulkowski and M. Laskowski, Sr., Federation Pi-oc. (in press). 44. W.Bjork, JBC 238, 2487 (1963). 45. I. I. Nikolskaya, N. M. Shalina, and E. I. Budowski, BBA 64, 197 (1962). 46. F. Felix, J. L. Potter, and M. Laskowski, Sr., JBC 235, 1150 (1960). 47. J. Simon, L. Brisbois, and L. Grillo, J . Chromatog. 44, 209 (1969). 48. J. H.Brown and M. E. Bowles, U.S. A m g Med. Res. Lab., Fort Knox, Ky., R e p t . 627, 11 (1965); CA 15178b (1965). 49. P. W.Wigler, JBC 238, 1767 (1963). 50. G. M. Richards and M. Laskowski, Sr., Bbchemistm 8, 4858 (1969). 51. W. E.Razzell and H. G . Khorana, JBC 234, 2106 (1959).
13. VENOM
319
EXONUCLEASE
nucleotide is a minimal requirement for a good substrate, it is not an absolute requirement since di-p-dinitrophenyl phosphate is slowly hydrolyzed. Several years ago, Razzell and Khorana ( 5 1 ) ,using dinucleosidemonophosphates of deoxythymidylic acid, showed that the 5‘+5‘ linkage was hydrolyzed slightly faster than the normal 3 ’ 4 ’ linkage. With nucleosides heterogeneous with respect to sugar, both 2‘+5’ and 5‘+5‘ linkages were shown to be hydrolyzed slightly slower than the normal 3‘+5’ linkages (35). In Khorana’s and in our laboratories the differences were comparatively small. I n the case of the 5’+5’-linked nucleosides with different sugars, the cleavage occurred in such a manner that phosphate remained on a nucleoside containing sugar other than arabinose (34, 36) ’ 111. Structural Characteristics of Substrates Affecting Susceptibility
A. CONFORMATION In spite of some claims to the contrary, venom exonuclease is capable of attacking double-stranded high molecular DNA. I n fact, doublestranded DNA is a better substrate than denatured DNA. Bjork (@) studied the rates of degradation of native and heat-denatured DNA using a pH stat. Denatured DNA was degraded a t a steady rate, which was dependent on the ionic strength of the medium. An increase in NaCl concentration from 1 to 100 m M decreased the rate of hydrolysis by a factor of two. With native DNA a two-phase reaction was observed. The initial, very rapid, rate was independent of NaCl concentration. After about one-third of the linkages had been hydrolyzed, the rate slowed down to that of denatured DNA and became salt dependent. Similar biphasic kinetics was observed previously with DNA that was denatured by an exhaustive dialysis (40). With RNA as substrate the results are conflicting. Cousin (52) observed that poly I, poly U, and poly C were rapidly and completely hydrolyzed, whereas under identical conditions poly I poly C was hydrolyzed slowly and incompletely. Native rRNA and tRNA were resistant to 60 pg/ml of commercial exonuclease, but after heat denaturation rRNA was readily and tRNA partly digested (52). Nihei and Cantoni (53) digested tRNA to completion, as did Keller (64) who observed a two-phase reaction. In agreement with the last two authors (53, 54) but contrary to the results of Cousin ( 6 2 ) , Hadjiolov et al.
+
52. M. Cousin, Bull. SOC.Chim. Bwl. 45, 1363 (1963). 53. T. Nihei and G. L. Cantoni, JBC 238, 3991 (1963). 54. E. B. Keller, BBRC 17, 412 (1986).
320
M. LASKOWSKI, SR.
(65) found that poly U was hydrolyzed faster than poly A, whereas an equimolar mixture of poly A and poly U forming a double-stranded structure was hydrolyzed a t a rate that was halfway between the previous two. Heat denaturation did not affect the rate of hydrolysis of rRNA. It would appear, therefore, that with RNA as substrate, conformation exerts no effect on the rate of hydrolysis.
B. THENATUREOF SUGAR I t has been known for many years (15-24) that venom exonuclease is capable of hydrolyzing both DNA and RNA. Gray and Lane (56) showed that naturally occurring 2'-O-methyl-substituted ribose derivatives are also hydrolyzed, even though the rate of hydrolysis is slower than with the unsubstituted ribose. Interestingly, the 2'-O-methylated derivatives are totally resistant to 5'-nucleotidase (57, 5 8 ) . Wechter (34) and Richards et al. (35) showed that venom exonuclease is capable of hydrolyzing dinucleoside monophosphates with one or both nucleosides containing arabinose. Even though only four different sugars have been tested, it would appear that venom exonuclease is totally blind to sugar, a t least in the qualitative sense. Other enzymes capable of hydrolyzing DNA and RNA are incapable of hydrolyzing derivatives of arabinose, e.g., micrococcal nuclease (30). Quantitative differences between susceptibility of compounds containing different sugars exist. Richards et al. (35) made a systematic study of a number of dinucleosidemonophosphates (N"pN0) in which either the CY- or P-nucleoside contained arabinose, while the other nucleoside contained ribose or deoxyribose. All compounds were found susceptible to venom exonuclease. The surprising finding was that the extremes of differences in the values of V , and K,,, lay in a comparatively narrow range of 20-fold.
C. THENATUREOF BASES Venom exonuclease has no pronounced preference (or discrimination) toward any of the four common bases of DNA or RNA. The discrimina55. A. A. Hadjiolov, P. V. Venkov, L. B. Dolapchiev, and D. D. Genchev, BBA 142, 111 (1967). 56. M. W.Gray and B. G. Lane, BBA 134, 243 (1967). 57. M. Honjo, Y. Kanai, Y. Furukawa, Y. Mizuno, and Y. Sanno, BBA 87, 696 (1964). 58. B. G . Lane, Biochemistry 4, 212 (1965).
13.
VENOM EXONUCLEASE
321
tion against glucosylated hydroxymethyl cytosine has been suspected for a long time because these compounds were resistant to the combined action of DNase I and venom exonuclease (59, 60). Recent work of Nikolskaya et al. ( G I ) and Bjork (41) established that glucosylated bases blocked the action of venom exonuclease. A good source of uncommon bases is tRNA. It provides substrates for studying the effect of base on the rate of hydrolysis. Baev e t al. (82) showed that N2-dimethylguanylyl- (3'-5') -cytidine-3' phosphate (GZ"pCp) was hydrolyzed much slower than the usual GpCp. Venkstern (63) reported that Tpq was hydrolyzed very slowly. Naylor et al. (64) found that Cpq was hydrolyzed with half the rate of CpU. The same group of workers introduced (64, 6 5 ) a chemical block on uridine and pseudo-uridine residues by reacting RNA with 1-cyclohexyl-3- (2morpho-linyl- (4)-ethyl) -carbodiimide metho-p-toluene sulfonate. The modification of the uridine residues completely blocked the action of venom exonuclease and also blocked the action of pancreatic RNase. The action of venom exonuclease is also blocked by thymine dimers produced as a result of UV irradiation of DNA a t 280 nm. Setlow et al. (G6) subjected irradiated DNA to exhaustive digestion by venom exonuclease. They isolated and identified the products of the reaction, which were composed of large amounts of all four 5'-mononucleotides and of small amounts of trinucleotides of the type d-pNpTTT where N was any of four common nucleosides and TpT was the irradiation-induced dimer of thymidine. These trinucleotides were totally resistant to further digestion with venom exonuclease but became partially susceptible after UV irradiation at 240 nm, known to reverse dimerization. The authors picture the action of venom exonuclease as proceeding linearly from the 0 terminus until the block is encountered. At this point the enzyme (or an impurity) acts very slowly by splitting the internal bond one base beyond the dimer. From there on conventional hydrolysis is resumed until the next block. This experiment touches upon one of the most pressing problems connected with venom exonuclease. Is the endonucleolytic activity an intrinsic property of the enzyme? 59. R. L. Sinsheimer, Science 120, 551 (1954). 60. E. J. Vokin, JACS 76, 5892 (1954). 61. I. I. Nikolskaya, D. S. Kislina, N. M. Shalina, and T. I. Tikhonenko, Biokhimiya 30, 1236 (1965). 62. A. A. Baev, T. V. Venkstern, A. D. Mirzabekova, and R. I. Tatarskaya, Biokhimiya 28, 931 (1963). 63. T. V. Venkstern, Dokl. Akad. Nauk SSSR 170, 718 (1966). 64. R. Naylor, N. W. Y. Ho, and P. T. Gilham, JACS 87, 4209 (1965). 65. J . C. Lee, N. W. Y. Ho, and P. T. Gilham, BBA 95, 503 (1955). 66. R. B. Setlow, W. L. Carrier, and F. J. Bollum, B B A 91, 446 (1964).
322
M. LASKOWSKI, SR.
D. EFFECT OF MONOPHOSPHORYL GROUP The effect of the proximity of the 5’-monophosphoryl group on susceptibility of a dinucleotide to venom exonuclease was recognized quite early (25, 2 8 ) . The removal of the 5’-monophosphoryl group decreased the rate of hydrolysis about 10-fold. The reported extreme values varied from 5- to 20-fold. The influence of the 5‘-monophosphoryl group (or of the lack of this group) is most pronounced with dinucleotides and is easily demonstrable with tri- and tetranucleotides. Intuitively one expects the effect to diminish with increasing chain length; indeed, with a homologous series of dephosphorylated compounds U (pU) Dolapchiev (67) showed that the longer the chain the more susceptible it becomes t o exonuclease. This finding indirectly supports Bj ork’s hypothesis regarding the existence of multiple sites of attachment of substrate to enzyme. The absence of the 5’-monophosphoryl group is felt by the enzyme even though the hydrolytic site is removed from the ry terminus by several monomers. Derivatives bearing a 3‘-monophosphoryl group were originally classified as totally resistant to venom exonuclease. As the quality of the enzyme preparation improved, these compounds were found susceptible but required 1000-fold more enzyme than was needed to hydrolyze 5’-monophosphate-bearing compounds. This unusual resistance led to another erroneous conclusion, that the polarity of exonuclease ehanges ( 2 Q ) .The basis for this belief were the experiments in which a mixture of tri-, tetra-, and pentanucleotides of the type d-NapN@pN7pNJpwere used as substrates. The early products were nucleosides and nucleotides, whereas 3’, 5’-mononucleoside diphosphates appeared considerably later. It is clear now that the mixture was contaminated with a small amount of dephosphorylated chains which were rapidly hydrolyzed to completion. The accompanying tabulation represents an approximation of several semiquantitative determination from different laboratories. These data %,
Compound
Relative amount of enzymes required for hydrolysis
d-pNupN@ d-N‘pN@ d-NapNap
1 10 1000 ~~
67. L. B. Dolapchiev, FEBS Letters 2, 185 (1969)
13.
323
VENOM EXONUCLEASE
were obtained a t pH 9, which is known to be an optimum for venom exonuclease attacking chains bearing 5'-monophosphate. Under the conditions in which the determinations were made these values are still essentially valid. However, it was recently found (29) that decreasing pH (and thus the negative charge on 3'-monophosphate) decreases the resistance of these compounds to venom exonuclease. Figure 1 shows the dependence of the rate of hydrolysis on pH. A change from pH 9 to 6 produces an increase in the rate of hydrolysis to 125% with ribonucleotides and a 500% increase with deoxyribonucleotides. This also means that the quantity of enzyme required to accomplish a complete hydrolysis of deoxyribodinucleotides is reduced by a factor of 5 (from lo00 to 200 relative units ; see the accompanying tabulation). In Fig. 2 the ratio of the rates of hydrolysis of phosphorylated to that of dephosphorylated dinucleotides is plotted vs. pH. The ordinate is on the logarithmic scale. The ratio changes from about 40 a t pH 5 to about 1700 at pH 9. [The previous estimate of the latter value (as 1000/10 = 100 in the tabulation) was an underestimate.] The lower curve of Fig. 2 compares the analogous ratio except that a ribodinucleotide terminated in 2',3'-cyclic phosphate serves as substrate. In this case the ratio decreases slightly when the pH is changed
0
E
z
25
-
20
-
t5-
.c 40 2
5 -
I
I
I
I
I
I
1
4
5
6
7
8
9
PH
FIG.1. Effect of pH on the hydrolysis of mixed-base 3'-phosphorylated ribodinucleotides ( 0 )and deoxyribodinucleotides (A). For ribonucleotides reaction mixtures (total volume 0.063 ml) were incubated for 1 hr a t 37" in sealed capillary tubes. Substrate Ant = 65, [enzyme] = 4.2 units/ml, [buffer] = 0.1 M (tris succinate), [MgCl,] = 1.0 mM. After electrophoresis on paper for 0.5 hr, 23 V/cm, pH 7.0, amounts of N were determined as percent of total material ( A n ] )recovered from the paper. With deoxyribodinucleotides [substrate] = 83 A,?,, [enzyme] = 5.1 units/ml; [buffer] and [MgCl,] as above. Reprinted from Richards and Laskowski (60). Copyright (1969) by the American Chemical Society. Reprinted by permission of the copyright owner.
324
M. LASHOWSKI, SR.
u)
2
e
.I -
4000300 -
>,
P R r
I00
-
30
-
v-
._ o c
B
I0 -
0
3 I '
4
I
I
1
I
L
5
9
7
0
9
PH
FIQ.2. Effect of removing negatively charged groups from the w end of a dinucleotide at several values of pH. The data were compiled from large number of experiments. ( 0 ) Calculated from the rate of appearance of nucleosides (d-Nu) ; ( A ) calculated from the rate of appearance of the &terminal unit, be it d-pNe (from d-NapN8) or d-pN@p (from d-NepNPp). The same system is used for A'pA8 and AapAR > p. Reprinted from Richards and Laskowski ($9).Copyright (1969) by the American Chemical Society. Reprinted by permission of the copyright owner.
from 6 to 9. It must be borne in mind that with both ApA > p and ApA the optimal rate of hydrolysis is a t pH 9. On the basis of these findings the experiments with deoxyribosetrinucleotides were performed (Fig. 3). The results clearly show that throughout the whole range of pH values an intermediate d-NapNP accumulated as d-pNyp was liberated. The experiment convincingly shows that no change in polarity in the action of venom exonuclease occurs with substrates bearing 3'-monophosphoryl group. The same W+(Y sequence of attacks occurs with all substrates regardless of termination.
IV. Venom Exonuclease as a Tool for Structural Determination
A.
SEQUENCE IN
RIBOOLIGONUCLEOTIDES
An elegant method of determination of sequence using monophosphatase, exonuclease, and alkaline hydrolysis has been proposed by
13.
325
VENOM EXONUCLEASE
d-NpN
5-
b a -
4-
-6
3 -
0 + +
r-
8 2 -
d-N
I X
4
5
6
7
8
9
PH
FIG.3. Effect of pH on the hydrolysis of purified mixed deoxyribotrinucleotides (dd-pN@,and ( 0 ) NnpN@pN'p)by venom exonuclease. ( A ) d-pNnp, ( X ) d-NapN8/2, (0) d-Na. Unhydrolyzed d-NapNBpNTp is not shown but is included in the total Am. Substrate = 83 A 27 1 , [enzyme] = 0.525 unit/ml for pH 4.0, 0.210 unit/ml for pH 5.0 and 9, and 0.105 unit/ml for pH 6-8. Electrophoresis for 2 hr, pH 6. Observed values for (percent of total A271) of the separated products were divided by 5.2 or 1 to compensate for the different amounts of enzyme used. Dashed line shows values for mononucleotides without such correction. Values of percent of total A m for d-NnpN@were divided by 2 to facilitate comparison with other products on a molar basis. Reprinted from Richards and Laskowski (29). Copyright (1969) by the American Chemical Society. Reprinted by permission of the copyright owner.
Holley et al. (68). A ribooligonucleotide is first dephosphorylated with rnonophosphatase. Its composition is established by a complete hydrolysis with KOH, which also defines the m-terminal nucleoside. The rest of the dcphosphorylated compound is subjected to a mild, incomplete hydrolysis with venom exonuclease. The mixture is then chromatographed on DEAE-cellulose according to the method of Tomlinson and Tener (69), giving a series of homologs each longer by one monomer than the preceding compound. The material of each peak is collected separately and hydrolyzed completely with KOH, giving a mixture of mononucleotides and one nucleoside representing the o terminus. The nucleoside in each peak is identified and this establishes the sequence. The method could be extended to deoxyribose derivatives by substi68. R. W. Holley, J. T. Madison, and A. Zamir, BBRC 17, 3846 (1964). 69. R. V. Tomlinson and G. M. Tener, Biochemktq/ 2, 697 (1963).
326
M. LASKOWSKI, SR.
tuting an enzyme for KOH to accomplish the complete degradation in order to obtain the W-deoxynucleoside. Until now this could have been done either with the aid of spleen a-exonuclease or Lactobacillus acidophilus a-exonuclease (70). Since the first enzyme is known to contain some monophosphatase, the risk of obtaining a false nucleoside existed, particularly with the longer oligonucleotides. The second enzyme also has limitation, it attacks only short oligonucleotides. Recently ( 7 I ) , it was found that micrococcal nuclease in extremely high concentration is capable of degrading oligomers to 3’-mononucleotides. Thus, an alternative enzymic degradation may be tried. I n the case of micrococcal nuclease the contamination with monophosphatase is insignificant.
B. IDENTIFICATION OF a A N D w TERMINALS Venom exonuclease has been widely used for the determination of the CY terminus in oligonucleotides. The normal procedure was to divide the dephosphorylated sample into two parts and digest one part with venom exonuclease. The terminus appeared as a nucleoside; the rest of the chain was degraded to 5’-mononucleotides. The other part of the dephosphorylated chain was degraded with spleen a-exonuclease. In this case the w terminus appeared as a nucleoside, the rest of the chain as 3’-mononucleotides. As the quality of venom exonuclease improved, more difficult tasks were tackled. The LY terminus was identified in tobacco mosaic virus (72). It required finding one nucleoside among 6400 nucleotides. Venom cxonuclease was also used for identification of both terminals in chains bearing 3’-monophosphate (IS,73). The CY terminus appears as a nucleoside, the w terminus as a nucleoside-3’,5’-diphosphate.The method did not gain a wide application because it required large amounts of highly purified enzyme. The recent finding that 3’-monophosphates are better substrates a t pH 6 than 9 (29) is likely to increase the use of this method. Roblin (74) used venom exonuclease to identify the a terminus in RNA isolated from bacteriophage R-17. The RNA was degraded with alkali and the mixture chromatographed according to Tomlinson and Tener ( 6 9 ) . The terminal appeared at the place in the pattern that corre(Y
70. W. Fiera and H. G . Khorana, JBC 238, 2789 (1963). 71. A. J. Mikulski, E. Sulkowski, L. Stasiuk, and M. Laskowski, Sr., JBC 244, 6559 (1969). 72. T. Sugiyama and H. Fraenkel-Conrat, Biochemistry 2, 332 (1963). 73. S. Venecko and M. Laskowski, Sr., BBA 61, 547 (1962). 74. R. Roblin, J M B 31, 51 (1968).
13. VENOM
327
EXONUCLEASE
sponded to tetranucleotides and had a spectrum of G. The amount of venom exonuclease required to produce a complete hydrolysis of G T P was established in a control experiment.
-
exonuclease
PPPG
faat
PG
+ PP
A fivefold amount of exonuclease was then used on the isolated derivative, and only three-fourths of it was hydrolyzed. The slow hydrolysis was expected because of the presence of 3‘-monophosphate. The product of this reaction, pGp, was identified by comparison with an authentic sample. Both reactions were run a t p H 9.0. Should a p H of 6 be used
-
exonucleaae
PPPGP
slow
PGP
+ PP
in the second reaction the hydrolysis would have been complete. In conjunction with other enzymes DNase I, phosphatase, polynucleotide kinase, DNA ligase, and another nuclease, venom exonuclease, have been used for identification of nicks inflicted by DNase I. Essentially the same method identifies the (Y terminus in a very long polynucleotide. The schematic representation of events preceding venom exonuclease is shown in Figs. 4 and 6 in Chapter 12, by Laskowski, Sr., this volume. From the schemes it is obvious that the simplified problem of determining only the terminus requires phosphatase and polynucleotide kinase, but no ligase. Upon a complete digestion to 5’-mononucleotides (venom exonuclease) the only radioactive nucleotide is the a! terminal. The contamination by venom endonuclease has no effect on identification. However, the contamination with 5’-nucleotidase leads to partial dephosphorylation and a false estimate of the chain length. Venom exonuclease was also used to determine the o terminus and its adjacent four nucleotides in tobacco mosaic virus ( 7 6 ) .The sequence was determined from the rate of appearance of monomers. In passing, it may be mentioned that o-exonuclease activity presumably simiIar to venom exonuclease has been studied histochemically in a variety of tissues. Several substrates have been developed specifically for this purpose (76-79). The newest addition to the family of substrates (Y
75. B. Singer and H. Fraenkel-Conrat, BBA 72, 534 (1963). 76. H. Sierakowska, H. Szemplinska, and D. Shugar, Acta Biochim. Polon. 10, 399 (1963).
77. H. Sierakowska and D. Shugar, BBRC 11, 70 (1963). 78. J. P. Horwitz, C. V. Easwaran, P. L. Wolf, and L. S. Kowalczyk, BBA 185, 143 (1969).
79. M. Erecinska, H. Sierakowska, and D. Shugar, European J . Biochem. 11, 465 (1969).
328
M. LASKOWSKI, SR.
useful for distinguishing a- from o-exonuclease are 2,Cdinitrophenyl esters of 3‘- and 5’-phosphates of thymidine (80). A comprehensive review (81) on histochemical aspects has been published.
V. Other Venom Enzymes That Hydrolyze Phosphate Esters
Two monophosphatases of venom are known (31). Both have pH optima of about 9 and thus represent dangerous contaminants when exonuclease is used to identify a nucleoside among a large number of mononucleotides. One of the monophosphatases, 5’-nucleotidase, is quite specific and attacks only 5’-rnononucleotides. This enzyme has been used to determine the amount of mononucleotides in a mixture of 5’-monophosphates of various chain length. It was also used to distinguish between 3‘- and 5’-mononucleotides in a mixture of both. Venom endonuclease is ’#-monoester former with a preference for the Gp-G bond and an optimal pH of 5 (1%’).It represents the most dangerous contaminant of exonuclease in experiments designed for the identification of terminals in long chains bearing 3‘-monophosphates because it leads to false terminals. More details concerning the properties of these contaminating enzymes may be found in reviews (17-21)and books (22-24) devoted to nucleases. ACHNOWLEDQMENTS The experimental work referred to in this article and performed in our laboratory was generously supported by the American Cancer Society, PRP-30 and E157; by the U. S. Atomic Energy Commission, AT(30-1)3630; and by the National Science Foundation, GB-6058. The author is indebted to Drs. Barnard, Heppel, Holley, Lehman, Tener, and Weinfeld for the critical reading of the manuscript.
80. R. G.von Tigerstrom and M. Smith, Bwchemtstry 8, 3067 (1969). 81. D.Shugar and H. Sierakowska, Prog. Nucleic Acid Res. 7, 369 (1967).
Spleen A cid Exonuclease ALBERT0 BERNARDI
GIORGIO BERNARDI
I. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . 11. Isolation, Purity, and Physical Properties . . . 111. Catalytic Properties . . . . . . . . A. Activity on Natural Substrates . . . . B. Activity on Artificial Substrates . . . . C. pH-Activity Curves-Activators and Inhibitors IV. Distribution and Intracellular Localization . . .
. . . .
.
.
.
.
.
. . .
. . . .
.
.
.
.
.
329 330 331 331 333 334 336
I. Introduction
Spleen acid exonuclease is an enzyme particularly useful in sequence studies of oligonucleotides, derived from both ribonucleic acid and deoxyribonucleic acid, since it splits off, in a sequential way, nucleoside3’-phosphates starting from the 5’OH end. The enzyme has also been called spleen phosphodiesterase (I, 2 ) and phosphodiesterase I1 ( 3 ) .We prefer to use the term phosphodiesteruse as a general name for the broad group of enzymes hydrolyzing phosphodiester bonds whether between nucleosides or not ( 4 ) . Table I gives a few examples of such enzymes. The term phosphodiesterase II (S), intended to mean an enzyme releasing nucleoside-3’-phosphates, seems to be an unhappy one, like that of deoxyribonuclease I1 (6) from 1. L. A. Heppel, R. Markham, and R. J. Hilmoe, Nature 171, 1152 (1953). 2. D. M. Brown, L. A. Heppel, and R. J. Hilmoe, J . Chem. SOC.p. 40 (1954). 3. W. E. Razzell, Experientia 23, 321 (1967). 4. G. Schmidt and M. Laskowski, “The Enzymes,” 2nd ed., Vol. 5, p. 1, 1961. 5. G. Bernardi, “The Enzymes,” 3rd ed., Vol. IV, p. 271, 1971.
329
330
A. BERNARDI AND G. BERNARDI
which i t is derived. I n fact, to mention just one of several criticisms which can be raised, roman numerals are more and more used to indicate new enzymes both of bacterial (6) and animal ( 7 ) origin and have little bearing on the position of phosphate in the products of digestion. An alternative, shorter, nomenclature for the enzyme is spleen exonuclease. After the initial and fundamental work of Heppel and Hilmoe, and Razzell and Khorana, already reviewed in the previous edition of “The Enzymes” (8) and in two other articles (3,9 ) , the major advances have been the preparation of spleen exonuclease in a very highly purified form (10, 11), and the recognition that the enzyme has no endonucleolytic activity and that it can attack oligonucleotides carrying a terminal phosphate in the 5’ position (12) ; this represents, however, a strong ratelimiting step.
It. Isolation, Purity, and Physical Properties
A method for the partial purification of spleen exonuclease was described by Heppel and Hilmoe in 1955 (IS) and by Hilmoe in 1960 (14) ; this was later improved by Razzell and Khorana (15) and Richardson and Kornberg (16). I n 1966, we described a novel purification procedure (10) leading to an enzyme preparation with a specific activity comparable to that of the best preparation of Razzell and Khorana (15). Enzyme yields were, however, low; the method was therefore modified and satisfactory results were obtained (11). The new method involves the preparation of a crude enzyme obtained essentially as in the case of acid deoxyribonuclease (6, 1 7 ) . The main differences are that acidification to pH 2.5 is avoided and (NH,),SO, fractionation is done between 35 and 60% saturation. The crude enzyme is then purified by chroma6. I. R. Lehman, Procedures Nucleic Acid Res. 2, 84 (1963). 7. T. Lindahl, J. A. Gally, and G. Edelman, Proc. Natl. Acad. X c i . U. S. 62, 597 (1969). 8. H. G. Khorana, ‘The Enzymes,” 2nd ed., Vol. 5, p. 79, 1961. 9. W.E. Razzell, “Methods in Enzymology,” Vol. 6, p. 230, 1963. 10. G. Bernardi and A. Bernardi, Procedures Nuclek Acid Res. p. 144 (1966). 11. A. Bernardi and G . Bernardi, BBA 155, 360 (1%). 12. A. Bernardi and G. L. Cantoni, JBC 244, 1468 (1969). 13. L. A. Heppel and R. J. Hilmoe, “Methods in Enzymology,” Vol. 2, p. 565, 1955. 14. R.J. Hilmoe, JBC 235, 2117 (1960). 15. W.E.Razzell and H. G . Khorana, JBC 236, 1144 (1961). 16. C. C. Richardson and A. Kornberg, JBC 239, 242 (1964). 17. G. Bernardi, A. Bernardi, and A. Chersi, BBA 120, 1 (1966).
14.
SPLEEN ACID EXONUCLEASE
331
tography on CM-Sephadex, hydroxyapatite, Sephadex G-75, and rechromatography on hydroxyapatite. The final product may be freezedried with only a small loss in activity. The enzyme is usually stored as a frozen solution or in 50% glycerol a t -15". The enzyme obtained by this purification procedure (11), when tested for contaminants under very stringent conditions, was found to be completely free from phosphatase, DNase, ribonuclease, and adenosine deaminase activities. The sedimentation coefficient of spleen exonuclease, measured by centrifugation in a sucrose density gradient, using cytochrome c as the reference protein, was 4.6 S (11). The enzyme is eluted from Sephadex G-100 between acid phosphomonoesterase (s = 5.6 S) and acid DNase (s = 3.4 S ) . The thermal inactivation curve of the enzyme in 0.15 M acetate buffer0.01 M ethylenediaminetetraacetate (EDTA) , pH 5.0, showed that a 50% inactivation was obtained by heating for 20 min a t 56" (11).
111. Catalytic Properties
A. ACTIVITYON NATURAL SUBSTRATES 1. Mechanism of Action
Spleen exonuclease is active on the 5'-OH oligonucleotides of both the rib0 and the deoxyribo series. These are sequentially split from the 5'-OH end with formation of 3'-mononucleotides. It has been suggested that an enzyme-product intermediate may exist in the form of nucleoside-3'phosphoryl-enzyme complex (3)since transfer of nucleoside-3'-phosphate to available 5'-hydroxyl functions (or other alcoholic functions) occurs a t high substrate (or acceptor) concentrations (15,18). Bernardi and Cantoni (12) have investigated in detail the mechanism of action of spleen exonuclease on tRNA. They showed that a t pH 4.8 the enzyme is practically unable to digest phosphorylated tRNA, whereas it can digest dephosphorylated tRNA perfectly well. I n contrast, at p H 6.2 the enzyme attacks phosphorylated tRNA though a t a slower rate than dephosphorylated tRNA. Since no inorganic phosphate is liberated in the degradation of phosphorylated tRNA, it is likely that in this case the enzyme begins its attack by releasing the terminal nucleotide as a diphosphate. Following the release of labeled serine at the opposite end of 18. L. A. Heppel and P. R. Whitfield, BJ 80, 1, (19%).
332
A. BERNARDI AND G . BERNARDI
the initial enzyme attack permitted to see that exonuclease degrades tRNA molecules “jumping” from one substrate molecule to another; in fact practically no serine is liberated up to 50% digestion, indicating that the enzyme digestion is progressing a t the same rate in all molecules. I n the case of phosphorylated tRNA, clearly the splitting of the terminal nucleotide represents a strong rate-limiting step since, once this obstacle is overcome, the resulting dephosphorylated substrate molecules are rapidly digested to the end and therefore the liberation of labeled serine takes place early in the digestion course. The mechanism of action of spleen exonuclease is similar to that seen for venom exonuclease (19-21)but different from the processive type of attack exhibited by E . coli RNase 11, sheep kidney exonuclease, and polynucleotide phosphorylase (22,23), in which cases each polynucleotide molecule is completely degraded before the enzymes attack a new molecule. The results of Bernardi and Cantoni (12)contradict the previous beliefs that the enzyme has an intrinsic, though weak, endonucleolytic activity (8) and that a phosphate group in a terminal 5’ position makes a polynucleotide chain completely resistant to the enzyme (16, 94, 26). 2. Eflect of Secondary Structure
The enzyme is very sensitive to the secondary structure of the substrate. Native calf thymus DNA is quite resistant to enzymic attack by spleen exonuclease, being split a t less than 4% the rate a t which alkalidenatured DNA is split (11). Long deoxyribonucleotides (average chain length 20-50), which still have complementary double-stranded structure, are rather resistant to the enzyme (26). Some limited results obtained with synthetic polyribonucleotides (11) are rather puzzling since poly C was found to be completely resistant, whereas poly A, poly I, and poly U were degraded a t comparable rates. I n the solvent used (0.15 M acetate buffer401 M EDTA, p H 5.0), poly A and poly C are believed to have 19. J. Preiss, P. Berg, E. J. Ofengand, F. H. Bergmann, and M. Dieckmann, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sn‘. U.S. 45, 319, (1959). 20. W. E. Razzell and H. G. Khorane, JBC 234, 2114 (1959). 21. T. Nihei and G. L. Cantoni, JBC 238, 3991 (1963). 22. G. W. Nossal and M. F. Singer, JBC 243, 913 (1968). 23. C. B. Klee and M. F. Singer, JBC 243, 923 (1968). 24. D. R. Harkness and R. J. Hilmoe, BBRC 0, 293 (1967). 25. L. A. Heppel and J. C. Rabinowitz, Ann. Rev. Bwchem. 27, 613 (1968). 26. C. h a v e , J.-P. Thiery, S. D. Ehrlich, and G. Bernardi, Biochemistry (submitted for publication).
14.
SPLEEN ACID EXONUCLEASE
333
a similar double-helical structure with co-parallel strands, whereas poly U is in a disordered configuration (27). 3. Effect of Glucosylation and Other Chemical Modifications
Glucosylated oligonucleotides obtained from T4 phage DNA by acid DNase digestion are resistant to spleen exonuclease (28). It has been reported that acetylation of the 2'-OH groups of tRNA completely inhibits the action of the enzyme, whereas venom exonuclease is not affected (29). The naturally occurring methylation of sugars and bases in tRNA does not seem to hinder the action of spleen exonuclease.
B. ACTIVITY ON ARTIFICIAL SUBSTRATE~ Other substrates for spleen exonuclease are the p-nitrophenyl esters of nucleoside-3'-phosphates and bis (p-nitrophenyl) phosphate, which is split only very slowly. These substrates are also split by enzymes having quite different natural substrates (Table I) (30-37). I n fact, not only phosphodiesterases, in a broad sense, such as acid DNase, micrococcal nuclease, spleen and venom exonucleases, and cyclic phosphodiesterase but also enzymes such as nucleoside phosphoacyl hydrolase and nucleoside polyphosphatase split these substrates. As pointed out by Spahr and Gesteland (367,this may be explained by the fact that these substrates are not true diesters but rather mixed phosphoanhydrides because of the acidic character of the phenolic OH. It is evident that the use of the synthetic substrates, advocated by Razzell (3) as specific substrates for exonucleases, may be very misleading. Table I1 shows the distinctive characters of three spleen enzymes active on bis (p-nitrophenyl) phosphate which are present in the crude extracts from which acid exonuclease is prepared. 27. A. M. Michelson, J. Massoulie, and W. Guschlbauer, Pro,. Nucleic Acid Res. 6, 84 (1967). 28. C. Soave and G. Bernardi, unpublished experiments (1968). 29. D. G. Knorre, N. M. Pustoshilova, and N. M. Teplova, Bwkhimiya 31, 666 (1986). 30. G. Bernardi and M. GriffB, Biochemistry 3, 1419 (1964). 31. P. Cuatrecasas, M. Wilcher, and C. B. Anfinsen, Bwchemwtry 8, 2277 (1969). 32. M. Laskowski, Procedures Nucleic Acid Res. p. 154 (1966). 33. Y. Anraku, Procedures Nucleic Acid Res. p. 130 (1966). 34. M. Laskowski and B. Filipowicz, Bull. SOC.Chim. Bwl. 4 4 1885 (1958). 35. A. Bernardi and G. Bernardi, BBA 155, 371 (1968). 36. P. F. Spahr and R. F. Gesteland, European J . Bwchem. 12, 270 (1970). 37. T. Term and T. Ukita, J . Biochem. (Tokyo) 58, 163 (1986).
334
A. BERNABDI AND G. BERNARD1
TABLE I SOME ENZYMES ACTIVE ON ~NITROPHENYL PHOSPHODIESTERS p-Ni trophenyl derivatives of Enzyme
Ref.
Natural substrate
Acid D N w Micrococcal nuclease Spleen exonuclease
(30) (31)
DNA DNA, RNA
Bis(p-nitrophenyl) 3'5'phosphate Nucleotides Nucleotides
+ + +
5'-OH oligonucleotides Snake venom (3s) 3'-OH oligoexonuclease nucleotides Cyclic (33) Nucleosidef phosphodiesterase 21, 3'-cycli c phosphates Nucleoside (34, 36) ATP, ADP polyphosphatase Nucleoside (36) Aminoacyl Competitive phosphoacyl adenylate inhibition hydrolase Pancreatic (37) ?b phosphodiesterase (16)
+
+ + +
+"
-
+
+
-
+
-
-
+ +
Split with liberation of p-nitrophenyl phosphate.
* Nucleic acids and oligonucleotides are resistant.
It should be pointed out that the successful purification of spleen exonuclease ( 1 1 ) was greatly helped by use of a DNA hydrolyzate produced by spleen acid DNase as the substrate, since the synthetic substrates are nonspecific, and RNA "core" (the water-undialyzable ribooligonucleotides obtained by exhaustive digestion of RNA with pancreatic RNase) is also hydrolyzed by both acid and basic spleen ribonucleases (38,39). Spleen exonuclease is unable t o hydrolyze cyclic phosphates (14).
C. pH-ACTIVITYCURVES-ACTIVATORS AND INHIBITORS Using an acid DNase hydrolyzate as the substrate and 0.1 M succinate and phosphate buffers as the solvents, the pH optimum was found to be close to 5.5; a higher value, between pH 6 and 7, was found in 0.1 M acetate. The addition of 0.02 M Mg2+did not affect very sensibly the pHactivity curves, although a shift to lower values could be detected. These 38. A. Bernardi and G. Bernardi, BBA 129, 23 (1966). 39. M. E. Maver and A. E. Greco, JBC 237, 736 (1962).
14.
336
SPLEEN ACID EXONUCLEASE
TABLE I1 PROPERTIES OF SPLENIC ENZYMES ACTIVE ON BIS(~NITROPHENYL) PHOSPHATE’
Properties
1. Sedimentation coefficientb 2. pH optimum”
3. Substrates Bis(p-nitrophenyl) phosphate p-Nitrophenyl eaters of thymidine5’-phosphate thymidine3’-phosphate Native DNA ATP, ADP, etc. 3’-Phosphate oligonucleotides 4. Inhibitors’ HPOP
sod*-
Polyribonucleotides 5. Thermal inactivation (50%)
6. Chromatographic properties DEAE-Sephadex (pH 6.8) Hydroxyapatite (pH 6.8) CM-Sephadex 7. Kinetica (V vs. S)
Nucleoside polyphosphatase
Acid DNase
Exonuclease
3.4 5.6-5.9
5.8
3.2 6.8
+
+
+
4.6
-
+ +-
+ + + 60” 0.05 M KP.
0.3 M K P pH 6.8; 0.2 M K P Sigmoid
0.05-0.1M 0.12 M K P pH 6.3; 0 . 2 M KCl Hyperbolic
0.05MKP 0.12 M K P pH 5.7; 0.11 M K P Hyperbolic
From Bernardi and Bernardi (36). As determined by sedimentation in sucrose gradient, using cytochrome c as a reference protein; enzymic assays were done on both bis(p-nitrophenyl) phosphate and the natural substrates; the results were the same. c Using bis(p-nitrophenyl) phosphate in 0.25 M succinate buffer as the substrate. The enzyme degrades polyribonucleotides to 3‘P mononucleosides; these are inhibitory. Eluting molarity; K P is potassium phosphate buffer. 0
results (11) are in general agreement with those of Hilmoe (14), which were obtained on RNA core using lower salt concentrations. The pH-activity curve using bis (p-nitrophenyl) phosphate as a substrate showed an optimum a t pH 5.8, but considerable activity could be detected between pH 6 and 7 (11). Using RNA “core” as the substrate, EDTA and sulfhydryl reagents are activators; MgZ+,MnZ+,and, more effectively, CuZ+,Hg”, and Zn2+ are inhibitors; arsenite and fluoride are weak inhibitors (14 ) . Deoxyribonucleoside-3’-phosphates are competitive inhibitors of the activity on acid DNase digests.
336
A. BERNARD1 AND G. BERNARDI
IV. Distribution and lntracellular localization
It has been claimed that spleen acid exonuclease has its counterpart in other tissues (3, 40). It is very likely that this claim is correct, in spite of the fact that it was based on the wrong assumption that a hydrolytic activity a t pH 6.0 on p-nitrophenyl thymidine-3’-phosphate could be equated with acid exonuclease activity (see Tables I and 11).In fact, an acid exonuclease activity has been shown in fish muscle (41, 42) and, using as a substrate an acid DNase digest, in rat liver ( 4 3 ) . In this latter case, it was checked that the activity on p-nitrophenyl thymidine-3’phosphate was not inhibited by S04z- and that it was lower than on thymidylyl (3’ + 5’) thymidine ( 4 4 ) . As far as the intracellular localization of the acid exonuclease activity is concerned, Razzell (40), using the synthetic substrate, found it in both the mitochondrial-lysosomal fraction and in the supernatant. Van Dyck and Bernardi (46) found that an enzymic activity on acid DNase hydrolyzates could be extracted from rat liver lysosomes and that the sedimentation coefficient of this activity, as determined by sucrose density gradient centrifugation, was the same as for spleen acid exonuclease. Subsequent work (43, 44) confirmed the idea that acid exonuclease is a lysosomal enzyme like other acid hydrolases of nucleic acids [see Table IV and related discussion in Bernardi ( 6 )1. For a recent review on the problem of intracellular localization of exonucleases, the reader is referred to Shugar and Sierakowska (46‘).
40. W. E. Razzell, JBC 236, 3028 (1961). 41. N. Tomlinson, Can. J . Biochem. Physiol. 36, 633 (1958). 42. N. Tomlinson, Can. J . Biochem. Physiol. 47, 945 (1959). 43. J. M. Van Dyck and R. Wattiaux, European J . Biochem. 7 , 15 (1968). 44. M. Erecinska, H. Sierakowska, and D. Shugar, European J . Biochem. 11, 465 (1969). 45. J. M . Van Dyck and G. Bernardi, unpublished experiments (1968). 46, D. Shugar and H. Sierakowska, in “Progress in Nucleic Acid Research” (J. N. Davidson and W. E. Cohn, eds.), Vol. VII, p 369. Academic Press, New York, 1967.
Nucleotid e Phosphomonoesterases GEORGE I. DRUMMOND
MASANOBU YAMAMOTO
I . 5'-Nucleotidase . . . . . . . . . . . . . A . Bacterial 5'-Nucleotidase . . . . . . . . . B . Yeast iY-Nucleotidase . . . . . . . . . . C . Snake Venom 5'-Nucleotidase . . . . . . . . D. Bull Seminal Plasma 5'-Nucleotidase . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . E . Liver 5'-Nucleotidase F. Intestinal 5'-Nucleotidase . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . G . 5'-Nucleotidase from Pituitary H . 5'-Nucleotidase from Nerve Tissue . . . . . . I . 5'-Nucleotidase from Cardiac Tissue . . . . . . J . 5'-Nucleotidase from Other Vertebrate Tissues . . . K . 5'-Nucleotidase from Ehrlich Ascites Tumor Cells . . . L. 5'-Nucleotidase from Potatoes . . . . . . . M . Comparison of the Enzymes . . . . . . . . 11. 3'-Nucleotida~e . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Rye Grass 3'-Nucleotidase B. M u g Bean 3'-Nucleotidase . . . . . . . . C . 3'-Nucleotidase from Wheat Seedlings . . . . . . D . 3'-Nucleotidase from Microorganisms . . . . . .
337 338 341 342 342 343 345 346 346 347 348 348 349 349 352 353 353 353 354
.
I S'-Nucleotidase
5'-Nucleotidase (5'-ribonucleotide phosphohydrolase. EC 3.1.3.5) is widely distributed in nature and a voluminous literature has appeared in the past decade on the enzyme from vertebrate tissues. seminal fluid. snake venoms. yeasts. and bacteria . Studies regarding the discovery and early investigations of the enzyme have been reviewed by Heppel ( 1 ) and
.
1 . L . A . Heppel. "The Enzymes. " 2nd ed., Vol . 5. p 49. 1961.
337
338
G. I. DRUMMOND AND M. YAMAMOTO
more recently by Bodansky and Schwartz ( 2 ) . The enzymes from these various sources have some properties in common ; however, numerous differences exist with respect to substrates and physical and chemical properties. Because of the diversity of studies each enzyme will be reviewed according to its source; this will be followed by a synopsis of the main similarities and contrasting features. A. BACTERIAL 5'-NUCLEOTIDASE In 1963, Kohn and Reis (3) first drew attention to the fact that extracts from many species of bacteria-Proteus, Hemophilus, Staphylococcus, Escherichia, and Clostridium-were capable of hydrolyzing both ribonucleoside 3'- and 5'-monophosphates. From their studies on relative activities with the two substrates, pH optima, and the effects of metal ions, they concluded that bacterial 3'- and 5'-nucleotidases were distinct and separate enzymes. Since that time both activities have been examined closely. Neu and Heppel ( 4 ) found that the 5'-nucleotidase of E . wltwas released into solution when spheroplasts were prepared with ethylenediaminetetraacetate (EDTA)-1ysozyme (6). The enzyme is also released from E. coli cells by osmotic shock. In this procedure, cells, preferably in the exponential growth phase suspended in hypertonic sucrose, are centrifuged and rapidly dispersed in a medium of low ionic strength (6). A number of degradative enzymes including 5'-nucleotidase, alkaline phosphatase, and cyclic phosphate diesterase are released into solution (7, 8) (see also Chapter 16 by Drummond and Yamamoto, this volume). Using the osmotic shock technique, Neu (9) has achieved a 5000-fold purification of 5'-nucleotidase from E. coli. The enzyme was pure as judged by molecular sieve chromatography, gel electrophoresis, and ultracentrifugation. A molecular weight of 52,000 was determined. The purified preparation hydrolyzes all 5'-ribo- and 5'-deoxyribonucleotides with preference for 5'-AMP. It does not attack 2'-AMP, 3'-AMP, cyclic 2',3'-AMP, or inorganic pyrophosphate. It appears unusual in that in addition to 5'nucleotides, adenosine triphosphate (ATP) , uridine diphosphate glucose, and bis (p-nitrophenyl) phosphate are hydrolyzed. The ratio of activities 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9.
0. Bodansky and M. K. Schwartz, Advan. Clin. Chem. 11, 277 (1968). J. Kohn and J. L. Reis, J Bacterial. 86, 713 (1963). H. C. Neu and L. A. Heppel, BBRC 17, 215 (1964). R. Repaske, BBA 30, 225 (1958). L. A. Heppel, Science 156, 1451 (1967). H. C. Neu and L. A. Heppel, JBC 240, 3685 (1965). N. G. Nossal and L. A. Heppel, JBC 241, 3055 (1968). H. C. Neu, JBC 242, 3896 (1967).
15.
339
NUCLEOTIDE PHOSPHOMONOEGTERASES
for these unrelated substrates remained constant during purification to apparent homogeneity; heat inactivation curves with respect to each substrate were parallel. These facts suggested that the various hydrolytic activities were associated with a single protein (9). This would seem to be a rather unusual enzyme since the substrates are quite unrelated and hydrolysis of bis (p-nitrophenyl) phosphate is usually indicative of diesterase activity. The 5’-AMP hydrolytic activity is stimulated 100-fold by 0.5 mM Co2+;it is inhibited by Zn2+and chelating agents. For stimulation of 5’-AMP and ATP hydrolysis, MnZ+can replace Co2+but Coz+is not needed for UDPG hydrolysis. Glaser et al. ( 9 a ) have studied extensively the nucleoside diphosphosugar hydrolase activity of E. coli and have also concluded that this activity and 5’-nucleotidase are associated with the same protein. Thus, the ratio of 5’-nucleotidase to UDP-sugar hydrolase activity remained constant over a 1000-fold range of purification and both were inactivated equally by heat treatment. These investigators showed that 14C-uridine-labeled UDP-D-glucose was hydrolyzed to uridine and inorganic phosphate without extensive mixing with a pool of nonlabeled 5’-UMP. This suggested an enzyme-bound complex of 5‘UMP as intermediate. Based on these findings they concluded that UDPG is hydrolyzed by the following sequence: a-glucose-1-P
UDP-D-glucose
+E
UDP-D-glucose-E
+
E-UMP
-+
It E + 5’-UMP
E
+ uridine + Pi
The enzyme also cleaves UDP-D-galactose and UDP-N-acetyl-D-galactosamine; other nucleosidediphosphate sugars containing adenine, guanine, and cytosine as the base are hydrolyzed at less than 5% of the rate of uridine nucleotides. The authors suggested (9a) that the enzyme is likely concerned with intracellular (rather than extracellular) UDPG, acting to maintain suitable levels of nucleotides in the cell. With such a wide range of specificity, the name 5’-nucleotidase for this bacterial enzyme seems inappropriate. When E. coli were grown in the presence of low concentrations of EDTA, a striking reduction in the activity of 5’-nucleotidase (also alkaline phosphatase and cyclic phosphate diesterase) occurred (10) and the data suggest that EDTA acts by binding a trace metal essential for activity. To investigate this further, E . coli were grown in the presence of s5Zn2+and subjected to osmotic shock (11).5’-Nucleotidase was purified from the shock fluid to apparent homogeneity. The purification was ac9a. L. Glaser, A. Melo, and R. Paul, JBC 242, 1944 (1967). 10. H. F. Dvorak, JBC 243, 2640 (1968). 11. H. F. Dvorak and L. A. Heppel, JBC 243, 2647 (1968).
340
G. I. DRUMMOND AND M. YAMAMOTO
companied by an enrichment with respect to 65Zn which could not be removed by dialysis. This and other evidence suggest that 5’-nucleotidase (and nucleoside cyclic phosphate diesterase) are metalloproteins, possibly zinc metalloproteins. The fact that 5’-nucleotidase is released into solution during spheroplast formation and during osmotic shock suggests a surface localization of the enzyme. Other evidence as to surface localization has also been provided. Thus, when an E . coli mutant (U-7a) which lacks alkaline phosphatase was grown on 2’-AMP as a carbon and phosphate source a severe lag in growth occurred (12). I n the presence of 5’-AMP growth took place rapidly. The inference was that 5‘-nucleotidase, being a surface enzyme, was capable of cleaving 5’-AMP to provide a carbon and phosphorus source for the cell. The possible location of these enzymes between the cell wall and cell membrane in the “periplasmic” space has been considered by Heppel ( 6 ) and is also discussed in Chapter 16 by Drummond and Yamamoto, this volume. Osmotic shock has also been used to release the enzyme from various Enterobacteriaceae: Shigella sonnei, Salmonella heidelberg, and Proteus vulgaris (13, 14). The enzyme from all these organisms exhibit properties similar to the E . coli enzyme with regard to the p H optimum, ion stimulation, substrate specificity, and physical properties. Mauck and Glaser (15) have recently purified a periplasmic enzyme from Bacillus subtilis which catalyzes the hydrolysis of several nucleosidediphosphate sugars ( ADP-glucose, GDP-glucose, GDP-mannose, CDP-glucose, etc.) to the corresponding nucleoside, inorganic phosphate and sugar phosphate. The enzyme shows 5’-nucleotidase activity and both activities seem to be catalyzed by the same protein. Unlike the E . coli enzyme, no divalent cations are required and it does not hydrolyze ATP. A specific protein inhibitor for 5’-nucleotidase has been purified from E. coli cell cytoplasm (10, 16). It prevents the action of the enzyme on 5’-AMP, ATP, and UDPG. It also inhibits the hydrolysis of 5’-AMP by the 5‘-nucleotidases from A . aerogenes, S. sonnei, and S. typhimurium (10). Other Enterobacteriaceae also possess similar intracellular protein inhibitors (13) which inhibit all hydrolytic activities of the 5’-nucleotidase of these organisms. The relevance of this inhibitor protein to the action of the enzyme in vivo is not known. 12. H.C.Neu, JBC 242, 3905 (1967). 13. H.C.Neu, Biochemistry 7, 3766 (1968). 14. H.C.Neu, J . Bacterbl. 95, 1732 (1968). 15. J. Mauck and L. Glaser, BiochemGtry 9, 1140 (1970). 16. H.F.Dvorak, Y. Anraku, and L. A. Heppel, BBRC 24,628 (1966).
15.
NUCLWTIDE
PHOSPHOMONOESTERASES
341
B. YEAST 5’-NUCLEOTIDASE A 5’-nucleotidase from yeast (Saccharomyces oviformis) has been purified to electrophoretic homogeneity and studied kinetically in detail by Takei (17-21). The enzyme hydrolyzes all ribo- and deoxyribonucleoside 5’-phosphates. It does not hydrolyze nicotinamide mononucleotide, 3‘- or 2’-AMP, sugar phosphates, or P-glycerol phosphate. Like the bacterial enzyme, yeast 5’-nucleotidase is markedly activated by Co2+and Ni2+ (18) and inhibited by EDTA. It was found that purified preparations of the enzyme possessed nucleotide pyrophosphatase (EC 3.6.1.9) activity. Substrates for the nucleotide pyrophosphatase are NAD, NADH2, FAD, ATP, and to a lesser degree, NADP and inorganic pyrophosphate (21). This activity could not be eliminated during purification of the 5’-nucleotidase to electrophoretic homogeneity (19). The pH profile of both activities were the same (pH 6.3-6.5) ; both activities were equally labile on heating a t temperatures between 40” and 60” for 5 min; their stabilities to UV irradiation and urea treatments were identical ; and both were similarly inhibited by N-bromosuccinimide, iodine, Zn2+, Ag+, and Cu2+ ( 2 1 ) . These data indicate that both 5’-nucleotidase and nucleotide pyrophosphatase reside in the same enzyme protein in S . oviformis. The enzyme seems to catalyze the catabolism of NAD in this organism as follows:
+ + adenosine + Pi + NhlN
(1) NAD -+ 5’-AMP NMS (2) 5’-AMP -+ adenosine I’,
(3) NAD
-+
The K , values for 5’-nucleotides are in the range of 0.2 mM for purine ribonucleotides and higher (2 mM range) for pyrimidine ribonucleotides (20). The enzyme is inhibited competitively by purine and pyrimidine bases, nucleosides, 2’- and 3’-mononucleotides, and NMN; NAD and NADP display a mixed type of inhibition against 5’-AMP hydrolysis ( K i values of 1 and 7 mM, respectively). Takei has concluded that the active sites for the two activities although residing in the same protein are not identical. It seems possible that the enzyme may be composed of two protein subunits each with a separate activity and with active centers 17. 9. Takei, Agr. Bwl. Chem. ( T o k ~ o 29, ) 372 (1965). 18. S.Takei, Agr. Bwl. Chem. ( T o k y o ) 30, 1215 (1966). 19. S.Takei, Agr. Biol. Chem. ( T o k y o ) 31, 917 (1967). 20. S.Takei, Agr. Bwl. Chem. (Tokyo) 31, 1251 (1967). 21. S. Takei, J. Totsu, and K . Nakanishi, Agr. BWZ. Chem. (Tokyo) 33, 1251 (1969).
342
G. I. DRUMMOND AND M. YAMAMOTO
in part common to each other. In general, this enzyme seems remarkably similar to the bacterial 5’-nucleotidase.
c. SNAKE VENOM
5’-NUCLEOTIDASE
That various snake venoms contain potent 5’-nucleotidase activity has been known for over 30 years. Until fairly recently only relatively crude preparations have been available ( 2 2 ) .Sulkowski et al. have purified the enzyme 1000-fold from Bothrops atroz venom ( 2 3 ) .The preparation was free of alkaline phosphatase and phosphodiesterase activities which are rich in venom of several species (24). The enzyme hydrolyzes all riboand deoxyribo-5’-nucleotideswith greatest reactivity for 5’-AMP. It does not attack 3’-nucleotides, ATP, ribose-5-phosphate1 inorganic pyrophosphate, p-nitrophenyl phosphate, nor dinucleotides of the type d-pXpY or pXpYp ( 2 3 ) .Specificity studies indicate a requirement that C-1 of ribose must contain a nitrogenous base and that the hydroxyl group on C-3 must be free. The enzyme is strongly inhibited by EDTA (0.1-1 mM) and this inhibition is reversed by CW+, Mg2+,and Ni2+.A similar enzyme has been purified from venoms of Crotalus adamanteus, Hemachatus haemachates, and Vipera m s e l l i (26, 2 6 ) . The H . haemachates enzyme is activated by 2’- and 3‘-mononucleotides and by 0-amino acids (26) which seem to do so by increasing the dissociation of enzyme and product. This enzyme is activated by Co2+and Mg2+,and activation is increased in the presence of 3’-AMP (26). 5‘-Nucleotidase has been purified to electrophoretic homogeneity from cobra (Naja naja atra) venom ($7). Properties of this enzyme are again similar to the B . atroz venom enzyme with regard to substrate specificity, activation by Mg2+ and Mn2+, and inhibition by Zn2+and Ni2+.It differs in that the pH optimum is 6.5-7.0.
D. BULL SEMINALPLASMA B’-NUCLEOTIDASE Some of the properties of the enzyme from this source were reviewed by Heppel ( 1 ) . More recently, attention has been focused on certain kinetic properties of the enzyme, especially its double pH optimum. Using 22. 23. 24. 25. 26. 27.
W. Bjork, BBA 49, 195 (1961). E. Sulkowski, W. Bjork, and M. Laskowski, JBC 238,2477 (1903). G. M. Richards, G. du Vair, and M. Laskowski, Sr.,Biochemiatry 4, 501 (1965). W. Bjork, BBA 89, 483 (1964). W. Bjork, Arkiv Kemi 27, 555 (1967). Y. Chen and T. Lo, J . Chinese Chem. SOC.(Taiwan) 15,M (1988).
15.
NUCLEOTIDE PHOSPHOMONOEST~ASES
343
a partially purified enzyme, Bodansky and Schwartz (68)found that in the presence of MgZ+,L-histidine inhibited the enzyme below pH 7.5 but activated i t above this pH value, shifting the optimum from 7.5 to 9.3. In the absence of MgZ+,L-histidine produced inhibition below p H 9. The second pH optimum was independent of buffer, but was Mg2+ and temperature dependent (29). It was also dependent upon the nature of the substrate since the phenomena was exhibited only with 5’-AMP, 5’-GMP, and 5’-IMP. From these studies, Levin and Bodansky (29) have proposed a model to explain the role of Mg2+ in producing a second optimum a t pH 9. The model involves four binding sites: one for the C-2 hydroxyl of ribose, one for water, another for phosphate, and one for Mg2+.The model proposed is contingent upon the absence of isozymes, and none was detected by starch gel electrophoresis. Pilcher and Scott (SO), however, have resolved bull seminal plasma 5’-nucleotidase into three active components by electrophoresis on polyacrylamide gels. It is thus possible that the double pH optimum is a reflection of heterogeneity.
E. LIVER5’-NUCLEOTIDASE 5’-Nucleotidases have been studied in liver from various species and activity has been identified in lysosomes, cytoplasmic supernatants and plasma membrane preparations. Arsenis and Touster (31) have purified a 5’-nucleotidase from rat liver lysosomes to apparent homogeneity. The enzyme is unusual in that it hydrolyzes 2’-, 3’-, and 5’-mononucleotides equally well with preference for 5‘-dAMP. It also hydrolyzes FMN, p nitrophenyl phosphate, and ,&glycerol phosphate, but not inorganic pyrophosphate or bis (p-nitrophenyl) phosphate. Unlike the 5’-nucleotidases described thus far, divalent cations such as Co2+,Mn2+,and Mg2+have no activating effect, but EDTA is inhibitory. In spite of the broad substrate specificity kinetic experiments indicate that a single enzyme is involved. Because of its broad substrate specificity it has been suggested (31) that it may play a key role in lysosomal catabolism of nucleic acids. An apparently different 5’-nucleotidase has been partially purified (50-fold) from acetone powder preparations of chicken liver (32): 5’-IMP and 5’-GMP are hydrolyzed by this preparation more rapidly than other 5‘-nucleotides ; 5‘-AMP, 5’-UMP, and 5’-CMP are hydro28. 0. Bodansky and M. K. Schwartz, JBC 238, 3420 (1963). 29. S. J. Levin and 0. Bodansky, JBC 241, 51 (1966). 30. C. W. Pilcher and T. G. Scott, BJ 104, 41c (1967). 31. C. Arsenis and 0. Touster, JBC 243, 5702 (1968). 32. R. Itoh, A. Mitsui, and K. Tsushima, BBA 146, 151 (1967).
344
G. I. DRUMMOND AND M. YAMAMOTO
lyzed a t rates only 510% that of 5‘-IMP. The enzyme is inactive in the absence of divalent metal and is maximally active in the presence of 10 mM Mgz+or Co2+;MnZ+is less effective. It is competitively inhibited by nucleosides, inosine being the most potent. A similar enzyme preparation has been obtained from acetone powder preparations of rat, frog, and pig liver (33). Again 5’-IMP and 5’-GMP are the preferred substrates; the enzyme requires divalent cations and is inhibited by nucleosides. From a study of the dephosphorylation of pyrimidine nucleotides in the soluble fraction of rat liver, Fritzon (34, 35) has provided evidence that two 5’nucleotidases exist. One of the enzymes had a broader specificity for 5’-nucleotides than the other, which acted mainly on dTMP and dUMP. The former enzyme was partially purified from the 100,000 x g supernatant fraction of rat liver (36) essentially free of nonspecific phosphatases. This enzyme is activated by divalent metals, the pH optimum is 6.3 and 5’-IMP is the preferred substrate. The general properties indicate that it is identical to the one isolated from liver acetone powder preparations by Itoh et al. (33).It is entirely reasonable that the cytoplasmic enzyme alone would be extracted into solution from acetone powders. I n spite of the presence of lysosomal and cytoplasmic 5’-nucleotidases in liver, much evidence exists that most of the enzyme in this tissue is membrane bound. Using procedures for isolating subcellular structural components, Song and Bodansky have reported (37) that activity resides in membrane fragments that constitute a part of the microsomal membranes. The distribution of the enzyme between the subfractions of microsomal preparations subjected t o density gradient centrifugation suggested that most of the activity was in the heavier fraction, i.e., in those membranes with attached ribosomes (38) and therefore deriving from the endoplasmic reticulum rather than the plasma membrane. However, liver plasma membrane preparations isolated by sucrose density gradient procedures (39, .lo) show enrichment with respect to 5’-nucleotidase (41-43), and a recent modification employing CaC12 as a mem33. R. Itoh, A. Mitsui, m d K. Tsushima, J . Biochem. (Tokyo) 63, 165 (1968). 34. P. Fritzon, European J . Biochem. 1, 12 (1967). 35. P. Fritzon, BBA 151, 716 (1968). 36. P. Fritzon, BBA 178, 534 (1969). 37. C. S.Song and 0. Bodansky, JBC 242, 694 (1967). 38. C. S. Song and A. Kappas, Ann. N . Y. Acad. Sci. 166, 585 (1969). 39. P. Emmelot, C. J. Bos, E. L. Benedetti, and P. H. Rumke, BBA SO, 126 (1964). 40. D. M. Neville, Jr., BBA 154, 540 (1968). 41. R. Coleman and J. B. Finean, BBA 125, 197 (1966). 42. J. M. Graham, J. A. Higgins, and C. Green, BBA 150, 303 (1968). 43. P. Emmelot and C. J. Bos, BBA 120, 369 (1966).
15.
NUCLEOTIDE PHOSPHOMONOESTERASES
345
brane stabilizer gives especially high specific activities with respect to 5’-nucleotidase (44). The membrane-bound enzyme from both rat liver and human liver (45) has been solubilized using deoxycholate (46) and sonic oscillation ( 4 7 ) . On precipitation to remove deoxycholate, the enzyme reassociates with phospholipids and other membrane proteins to regenerate vesicular membranes ( 4 6 ) . Widnell and Unkeless (48) have obtained a highly purified 5‘-nucleotidase from rat liver microsomes and plasma membranes using classic fractionation procedures in the presence of detergent. The enzyme has been shown to be a lipoprotein containing only one phospholipid, sphingomyelin. The enzyme hydrolyzes 5’-AMP and 5’-UMP more rapidly than other 5’-nucleotides. The substrate specificity differs considerably from that of the enzyme isolated from acetone powder extracts (33) and is probably identical with the one identified in plasma membrane preparations by Song and Bodansky (37). Thus, there is likely as many as three enzymes with 5’-nucleotidase activity in liver, one lysosomal, one cytoplasmic, and one membrane bound. Their specificities and kinetic properties appear to be distinctly different. This would suggest specialized physiological functions not yet understood.
F.
INTESTINAL
5’-NUCLEOTIDASE
Center and Behal (49) have resolved 5’-nucleotidase from calf intestinal mucosa into three fractions using DEAE-cellulose chromatography. One of these was obtained free of nonspecific phosphatase. It had a pH optimum of 6-6.5, MnZ+,Mg2+,and Co’+ (1-10 mM) all enhanced activity and complete inactivation was produced with 1 mM EDTA. This enzyme hydrolyzes all 5’-ribonucleotides a t similar rates and hydrolyzes 5’deoxribonucleotides more slowly. These properties indicate that it is strikingly similar to the one obtained from acetone powder preparations of chicken and rat liver (32, 33) and from soluble supernatants of rat liver ( 3 6 ) .The other two activities (which were not fully characterized) (49) could possibly have originated from particulate material or membranes because the authors employed deoxycholate in the early phase of purification. T. K. Ray, BBA 196, 1 (1970). C. S.Song and 0. Bodansky, BJ 101, 5 C (1966). C. S. Song, B. Tandler, and 0. Bodansky, Biochem. Med. 1, 100 (1967). C. S. Song, J. 8. Nisselbaum, B. Tandler, and 0. Bodansky, BBA 150, 300 (1968). 48. C. C. Widnell and J. C. Unkeless, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S. 61, 1050 (1968). 49. M. S.Center and F. J. Behal, ABB 114, 414 (1966). 44. 45. 46. 47.
346 G. 6’-NUCLEOTIDASE
G. I. DRUMMOND AND M. YAMAMOTO
FROM PITUITARY
Some of the kinetic properties of a partially purified (60-fold) 5’nucleotidase from bovine pituitary gland have been described (50-54). The specificity of this enzyme seems different from that of other tissue in that 5’-GMP and 5’-UMP are the preferred substrates (61, 5 4 ) . The enzyme is strongly inhibited by EDTA and this is reversed by Mgz+ but not MnZ+ ( 5 0 ) .It is inhibited by Zn2+and competitively inhibited by 2’- and 3’-mononucleotides and nucleosides, particularly adenosine ( 5 4 ) .The approximate molecular weight was determined to be 237,000. It cannot be determined for certain whether this is a cytoplasmic enzyme. Pituitary glands were homogenized in 0.1 M ammonium sulfate and centrifuged at low gravitational force so that membranous material could have been present in the early stages of purificatian.
H. 5’-NUCLMYTIDASE
FROM
NERVE TISSUE
The enzyme has been partially purified (70-fold) from 38,000 X g supernatant fluid from sheep brain homogenates by Ipata (55-58).The, enzyme (MW 140,000) is reported to be specific for 5’-AMP and 5’-IMP although the substrate specificity does not appear to have been examined closely. 2‘- and 3’-AMP are not hydrolyzed ( 5 6 ) . Unlike the enzyme from many sources the brain enzyme does not require divalent cations and indeed Co2+, which stimulates several other 5’-nucleotidases, was inhibitory a t 5 mM. The enzyme is strongly inhibited by very low concentrations of ATP, UTP, and CTP (50% inhibition by 0.3 & ATP) but not by GTP. 2’-AMP, 3’-AMP, and a variety of other nucleoside monophosphates, nucleosides, and sugar phosphates do not inhibit. A kinetic examination of ATP, UTP, and CTP inhibition (56-58) revealed that inhibition curves were sigmoidal, indicating cooperativity between inhibitor molecules and an allosteric type of interaction between inhibitor and protein. The metabolic significance of ATP inhibition is 50. J. Lisowski, Arch. Immunol. Therap. Exptl. 12, 542 (1964). 51. J. Lisowski, Arch. Immunol. Therap. Ezptl. 14, 195 (1966). 52. J. Lisowski, Arch. Immunol. Therap. Exptl. 14, 209 (1966). 53. J. Lisowski, Arch. Irnmunol. Therap. Exptl. 14, 217 (1966). 54. J. Lisowski, BBA 113, 321 (1966). 55. P. L.Ipata, Nature 214, 618 (1967). 56. P. L. Ipata, BBRC 27, 337 (1967). 57. P. L. Ipata, Biochemistry 7, 507 (1968). 58. P. L. Ipata, Frog. Brain Res. 29, 527 (1968).
15.
NUCLEOTIDE PHOSPHOMONOESTERASES
347
not established. Again it is not entirely clear whether this enzyme is cytoplasmic, being recovered from homogenates centrifuged a t 38,000 X g. 5’-Nucleotidase activity has been examined histochemically (6941) in brain tissue and such studies indicate that more than one 5‘-nucleotidase is present or that the enzyme exists as isozymes (62). It is certainly possible that multiple activities exist in a tissue such as brain with such a diversity of cell types. Activity is present in both white and gray matter (63, 64) and is greatest in cortical tissue, cerebellum, and spinal cord (66). 5‘-Nucleotidase activity has been reported to be greatly diminished in demyelinated areas of the brain in patients with multiple sclerosis (66).
I. 5’-NUCLEOTIDASE FROM CARDIAC TISSUE The enzyme in the myocardium has recently attracted attention because of the possibility that adenosine is a physiological regulator of coronary blood flow (67) (adenosine is a potent coronary dilator). Most of the 5’-nucleotidase activity in rat heart is membrane bound, and a partially purified preparation has been obtained by extracting acetone powder preparations with deoxycholate (68). All 5’-nucleotides are hydrolyzed. The enzyme is strongly inhibited competitively by ATP (Ki 1.8 &). Whether this provides a regulatory mechanism for adenosine formation in the heart is not known. Histochemical evidence has indicated that the enzyme resides in the sarcoplasmic reticulum and transverse tubular system of rat myocardium (69). However, other evidence indicates that enzymic activity is also localized within the walls of the coronary blood vessels (70-72). Recent histochemical studies (73) have shown that the enzyme resides not 59. T. G. Scott, J . Comp. Neurol. 122, 1 (1964). 60. T. G. Scott, J . Comp. Neuro2. 129, 97 (1967). 61. D. Naidoo, J . Histochem. Cytochem. 10, 421 (1962). 62. T. G. Scott, J . Histochem. Cytochem. 13,657 (1965). 63. H. B. Tewari and G. H. Bourne, J . Anat. 97, 65 (1963). 64. K. Nandy and G. H. Bourne, Arch. Neurol. 11, 547 (1964). 65. N. Robinson and B. M. Phillips, Clin. Chim. Acta 10, 414 (1964). 66. K. D. Barron and J. Bernsohn, Ann. ‘N. Y . Acad. Sci. 122, 369 (1965). 67. R. M. Berne, Am. J. Physwl. 204, 317 (1963). 68. H. P. Baer, G. I. Drummond, and L. Duncan, Mol. Pharmacol. 2, 67 (1966). 69. J. Rostgaard and 0. Behnke, J . Ultrastruc. Res. 12, 579 (1965). 70. J. R. Williamson and D. L. Dipietro, BJ 95, 226 (1965). 71. H. P. Baer and G. I. Drummond, Proc. Soc. Ezptl. Bwl. Med. 127, 33 (1968). 72. E. Bajusz and G. Jasmin, Acta Histochem. 18, 222 (1964). 73. K. Nakatsu, H. Clarke, and G. I. Drummond, Federation Proc. 29, 351 (1970).
348
G. I. DRUMMOND AND M. YAMAMOTO
within the cardiac cell but exists almost exclusively in the capillary endothelial cells and small blood vessels of the coronary vasculature. Location of the enzyme a t these sites could have considerable significance with regard to the role of adenosine as an autoregulator of blood flow to the heart. .J. 5’-NUCLEOTIDASE FROM OTHERVERTEBRATE TISSUES 5’-Nucleotidase present in 48,000 x g supernatant fractions of rat and guinea pig skeletal muscle extracts has been examined briefly (74).5‘UMP seems to be the preferred substrate. The enzyme from fish skeletal muscle has also been studied (75).This enzyme hydrolyzes all riboand deoxyribonucleoside 5’-phosphates (except dCMP and dTMP) with preference for 5’-IMP and 5’-UMP. The enzyme is strongly activated by Mn2+; Mg2+is a less powerful activator, and Zn2+ and EDTA are inhibitors. This enzyme thus appears similar to the soluble activity from mammalian liver (33,36). 5’-Nucleotidase in mammary gland hydrolyzes all 5’-ribonucleotides and shows a decrease from pregnancy to early lactation (76).Rats injected with glucagon show increased 5‘nucleotidase in pancreatic islet tissue (77).The enzyme in mouse kidney has been examined histochemically and electrophoretically and found to exist as isoaymes (78).Electrophoretic techniques have also provided evidence that the enzyme exists as isozymes in many other tissues of the mouse such as liver, spleen, intestine, testes, and heart (79).
K. 5‘-NUCLEOTIDASE FROM EHRLICH ASCITES TUMOR CELLS Murray and Friedrichs (80) have obtained a 5‘-nucleotidase from a particulate fraction of Ehrlich ascites tumor cells using deoxycholate. The relative rates of hydrolysis of 5’-UMP, 5’-AMP, 5’-CMP, 5’-GMP, and 5‘-IMP are 129, 100, 93, 83, and 79, respectively. Adenosine and thymidine triphosphate are competitive inhibitors of 5’-AMP hydrolysis 74. I. Cozzani, P. L. Ipata, and M.Ranieri, FEBS Letters 2, 189 (1969). 75. H. L. A. Tarr, L. J. Gardner, and P. Ingram, J. Food Sci. 34, 637 (1969). 76. D. Y. Wang, BJ 83, 633 (1962). 77. S. Johanason and I. B. Toljedal, Endocrinology 82, 173 (1968). 78. M. J. Hardonk and 6. Koudstaal. Hitochemie 15, 290 (1968). 79. M. J. Hardonk and H. G. A. de Boer, Histochemie 12,!29 (1968). 80. A. W. Murray and B. Friedrichs, BJ 111, 83 (1989).
15.
NUCLEOTIDE PHOSPHOMONOESTERASEE
349
a,
(Ki 0.4 and 4.8 respectively). The enzyme is strongly inhibited by Znz+.5’-Nucleotidase in these cells has also been examined by Paterson and Hori (81) who found the enzyme located primarily in nuclei. Nuclei prepared from a 6-mercaptopurine-resistant subline were markedly deficient in enzymic activity. L. 5’-NUCLEOTIDASE
FROM POTATOES
The presence of an enzyme with 5’-nucleotidase activity in extracts of potato were referred to by Heppel (1).The enzyme has been purified 200-fold by Klein (8B) and studied kinetically (83). All major 5’nucleotides are hydrolyzed a t similar rates. The preparation also hydrolyzed 3’-nucleotides a t a substantial rate (2040% that of 5’-AMP). However, kinetic data (83)suggested that the purified preparation was perhaps a mixture of specific 5’- and 3’-nucleotidases.
M. COMPARISON OF
THE
ENZYMES
It seems clear that the 5‘-nucleotidases are a somewhat heterogeneous group of enzymes with many differences and yet having certain properties in common. It must be emphasized that most of the enzyme preparations do not represent pure proteins, and there can be many variations in experimental procedures which might account for some of the differences. Table I presents a summary of some of the similarities and contrasting features of the enzyme from several sources. It can be seen that the relative rates of hydrolysis of the major 5’-nucleotides differ in a seemingly random manner. The E . coli and S. sonnei enzymes differ from those of other sources in that they possess nucleoside diphosphosugar hydrolase activity and also hydrolyze ATP. The B. subtilis enzyme is different from that of the two above organisms in that it does not hydrolyze ATP and converts UDPG to nucleoside and sugar phosphate (16) whereas the E . coli and S. sonnei enzymes degrade this compound to base, sugar, and inorganic phosphate (9,13). The yeast enzyme is unique in that it possesses nucleotide pyrophosphatase activity, converting NAD to NMN, adenosine and inorganic phosphate. The liver lysosomal enzyme appears to have yet a different substrate profile, hydrolyzing both nucleoside 2‘- and 3’-phosphates in addition to 5‘-phosphates. 81. A. R. P. Paterson and A. Hori, Can. J . Biochem. Physwl. 41, 1339 (1963). 82. W. Klein, 2. Physwl. Chem. 307, 247 (1957). 83. W. Klein, 2. Physwl. Chem. 307, 254 (1957).
W
cn
0
TABLE I SUMMARY OF PROPERTIES OF VARIOUS 5!-NUCLEOTIDASES
Apparent Enzyme murce
E. wli
Cellular localisstion
K, Other eubstrah
5'-AMP (mM)
PH optimum
Activators
Deoxyribo0.03(0.12 6.0for5'Cd+.Mn'+, nucleotidea for ATP) AMP; 6.8 Ca*+ ATP. UTP, for ATP GTP. UDPglucose E . sonnei Surface A > U > G > C > I Deoxyribo0.012 (0.13 5.8 for 5'Cd+. Mn*+ periphic nucleotidea for ATP) AMP: 7-8 for UDPG ATP, ADP. (0.11 for UDP-glucoee UDPG) 8 UDPG. CDPG, 0.0018 for B. uubtilis A >G >U >C ADPG UDPG 5.57 C d + , Ni'+ A>>G = I > U > C NAD. NADH, 0.2 Yesst FAD, ATP S.wiformis
Snake venom B. droz
Surface periplaamic
Relative rate of hydrolyaia of 5'ribonucleotideaa A > G > C > U > I
A > C > I > G > U
Deoxyribonucleotidea NMN
9
W+.Mg'+ and Ni'+ reveme EDTA inhibition
Inhibitor8
MW
EDTA citrate 52,000
D%grS?% of purity
Ref.
5000-fold ( 9 )
urea
EDTA citrate 44,000-
3000-fold
(13)
p
(16)
P
(17$1 )
1OOO-fold
(83)
53 ,000
137,000
Zn*+, Cu'+. EDTA nucleosidea. particularly adenoeine En'+, EDTA
Rat liver
Rat liver
Rat liver Calf intestinal mucw Bovine pituitary
Lyemornea
>U
=G
>I
I =G >U >A I00.OOO X u supernatant U = A > C > G > I " P b membrane" U >C =G >A
Membrane bound
F i h skeletal muscle Ascitea Nuclear tumor cells membrane a
A
6.5-7 7 . 8 and 9 . 2
C > A > I > G
Sheep brain
Rat heart
0.13
A > C = U > C
Snake venom N. naja olra BuU seminal P b
2'-, 3'-Mononucleotides. 5'-deo4nucleotidea CDeoxyribonucleotidea
3.7-5.5
Mn'+. Mg'+
NP+, Znz+
Cd+.Ni'+
Znt+. Cu'+ nucleonidea nucleotidea Zn*+. NP+
Cd+,Mn*+.
6.8
6.3
Nucle&dea
P P
Cd+. MIL¶+, ME¶+
EDTA nucleosidea
G > U = C > I >A
0.06
9
ME'+ r e v e m EDTA
EDTA Zn'+ nucleonidea
A = I
0.007
7.3
C > U = A > I >G
0.018
9
U > A > C > G > I
P
P
6.04.5
>C >G
P
ME'+
0.05
U =I
Hihly
and Niz+ do n d activate
0.012 5'-Deoryribcnuoleotiden
1O.OOO
8
5'-Deoxyrib* nucleotidea 0.067
inhibition None required
Mnt+, ME'+
237 ,OOO
ATP. UTP. Cot+. En:+ ATP (Ri 1.8 r M ) EDTA. ZnZ+ ATP, Zn'+
P
P
D P
120,OOO
Nuclec&de-5'-monophospha~are represented only by the baee letter. Degree of purity designated nu p representa partial purification.
P
352
Q. I. DRUMMOND AND M. YAMAMOTO
The most notable similarities relate to activation and inactivation by metal ions and other materials. I n most instances (Table I) each is activated by one or more of the cations Co2+,Mn2+,NiZ+,Mg2+,or Ca2+ of which the former three are usually most effective. Here again, however, there are differences. Thus, the B. atrox enzyme is not activated by ions, but they serve to reverse EDTA inhibition (23). The rat liver lysosomal enzyme is also not activated by divalent metals (31) ; the sheep brain enzyme does not seem to require divalent cation and in fact it is inhibited by Co2+ (67). In most cases EDTA has been reported to be an effective inhibitor; Znz+and Cu2+are frequently inhibitory. Whereas ATP is a substrate for the bacterial enzyme, it and other nucleosidetriphosphates are powerful inhibitors of the enzyme from several mammalian sources (a7, 67,68). The enzymes differ markedly in molecular weight, varying from 10,OOO for the snake venom (Naja atra) enzyme (27) to 237,000 for the enzyme from bovine pituitary (64). It appears certain that there is more than one 5‘-nucleotidase present in most mammalian tissues. This is best established for liver. In other cases it has not been possible to determine the exact intracellular origin because of the nonselective extraction procedures used. However, those enzymes isolated from acetone powder preparations of chicken liver and rat liver appear to have properties essentially identical to the enzyme present in 100,000 x g supernatant fraction of rat liver and therefore may be cytoplasmic in origin. This could also be the case for the intestinal mucosa enzyme. Very little can be said about the physiological function of the enzyme except that it is obviously involved in normal cellular catabolism of nucleosidemonophosphates. Its surface localization in microorganisms must have metabolic relevance; its presence in membrane structures in mammalian tissues also points to specialized functions. Perhaps, even the nucleoside product has physiological functions yet to be discovered.
II. 3’-Nucleotidase
In contrast to 5‘-nucleotidases, enzymes which hydrolyze nucleoside3‘-phosphates have attracted comparatively little attention. Enzymes possessing some specificity for 3’-nucleotides seem to occur predominantly in the plant kingdom and several have been only partially purified and characterized.
15.
NUCLEOTIDE PHOSPHOMONOESTERASES
353
A. RYE GRASS3’-NUCLEOTIDASE An enzyme purified from rye grass capable of specifically hydrolyzing 3‘-nucleotides has been available for some years (84). The enzyme has also been purified (50-fold) from germinating rye seedlings (85) and seems quite specific for 3’-nucleotides. 3’-Deoxymononucleotides are not attacked (86) nor is arabinonucleoside 3’, 5’-diphosphate (87) . Enzymic activity increases 10-fold during germination (85).
B. MUNGBEAN3’-NUCLEOTIDASE Walters and Loring (88) have purified a 3’-nucleotidase about 50-fold from mung bean sprouts (Phaseolus aureus Roxb.). The enzyme hydrolyzes 3’-AMP, 3’-GMP, 3’-CMP in decreasing order and also hydrolyzes the 3I-phosphate group of coenzyme A. (89), but it has no significant activity for 2’- or 5’-ribonucleotides. For 3’-GMP, 3’-AMP, 3’-UMP, and 3’-CMP, K , values are 0.67, 1.1, 7.7, and 15 mM, respectively. The enzyme preparation also contained acid stable ribonuclease activity (89). Both 3’-nucleotidase and acid ribonuclease were inactivated reversibly at pH 5.0 and by dialysis and this inactivation could be prevented by Zn2+.The two activities were similarly inactivated by heat at pH 5 and 7.5. Such data indicate that the two are metalloproteinsprobably zinc metalloproteins. These similarities and other kinetic data provide evidence that the 3’-nucleotidase and ribonuclease activities reside in the same protein.
c. 3’-NUCLEOTIDASE FROM
WHEAT
SEEDLENGS
An enzyme similar to the 3‘-nucleotidase of mung bean has been isolated from germinating wheat seedlings and purified 800-fold (90). The preparation possessed DNase, RNase, and 3’-nucleotidase activities. These three activities were similar in p H optima, requirements for Znz+ and sulfhydryl compounds, stability to storage, temperature inactivation L. Shuster and N. 0. Kaplan, “Methods in Enzymology,” Vol. 2, p. 551, 1955. L. Shuster, JBC 229, 289 (1967). L. Cunningham, JACS 80, 2546 (1958). G. R. Barker and G. Lund, BBA 55, 987 (1962). T. L. Walters and H. S. Loring, JBC 241, 2870 (1966). H. S. Loring, J. E. McLennan, and T. L. Walters, JBC 241, 2876 (1966). 90. D. M. Hanson and F. L. Fairley, JBC 244, 2440 (1969).
84. 85. 86. 87. 88. 89.
354
G. I. DRUMMOND AND M. YAMAMOTO
and reactivation and inhibition by metal ions and EDTA. The three activities also co-chromatographed on DEAE-cellulose and phosphocellulose and migrated identically on gel filtration. The three activities thus seem to reside in a single protein. The activity in wheat seedlings increases over 80-fold during germination (91). D. 3’-NUCLEOTIDASE
FROM
MICROORGANISMS
Numerous microorganisms possess a cyclic 2’, 3’-ribonucleoside phosphate diesterase which has 3‘-nucleotidase activity. This “double headed” enzyme has been vigorously studied and is described in the chapter on nucleoside cyclic phosphate diesterases (Chapter 16 by Drummond and Yamamoto, this volume). Suffice it to say that the ability of microorganisms producing this enzyme to catabolize 3’-nucleotides is well established. An enzyme from Bacillus subtilis, which hydrolyzes a variety of nucleoside 3’-phosphates, has been briefly described (92). The enzyme was found to be present in culture filtrates after removing the cells by centrifugation. Whether or not this enzyme is identical to the nucleoside cyclic phosphate diesterase in this organism is unclear. Because of its specificity for 3‘-nucleotides it has been proposed (93) as a specific method for preparing 2’-nucleotides. Becker and Hurwitz (94) have found that after infection of E . coli B with T-even bacteriophages a novel 3‘-deoxynucleotidase activity appears. They purified the enzyme 2000-fold. In addition to its attack on 3’-deoxymononucleotides, the enzyme selectively removes the 3’-phosphoryl groups from DNA. It does not attack 3‘-ribonucleotides, 3’phosphoryl groups of RNA, or 5’-phosphate esters. Like bacterial 5‘nucleotidases, this enzyme is markedly activated by Mg2+and Co2+and is inhibited by EDTA. The enzyme appears to be a phage-induced enzyme; the activity rises early after injection with T-even phages and formation of the enzyme is blocked with chloramphenicol.
91. L. Shuster and R. H. Gifford, Arch. Biochem. Biophys. 96, 534 (1962). 92. S. Igarashi and A. Kakinuma, Agr. Biol. Chem. ( T o k y o ) 26, 218 (1962). 93. A. Kakinuma and S. Igarashi, Agr. Biol. Chem. ( T o k y o ) 28, 131 (1964). 94. A. Becker and J. Hurwitz, JBC 242, 936 (1967).
Nucleoside Cyclic Phosphate Diesterases GEORGE I . DRUMMOND
MASANOBU YAMAMOTO
I . Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . I1. Ribonucleoside Y.3'-Cyclic Phosphate Diesterase with 3'-Nucleotidase Activity from Microorganisms . . . . . A . Properties of the Enzyme . . . . . . . . B . Cellular Localization . . . . . . . . . . C . Cyclic Phosphate Diesterase-A Metalloenzyme . . . D . Physiological Function . . . . . . . . . I11. Ribonucleoside Y.3 '-Cyclic Phosphate Diesterase from Vertebrate Nerve . . . . . . . . . . . . A . Properties and Substrate Specificity . . . . . . B . Intracellular Localization in Myelin . . . . . . C . Physiological Role of the Y.3 '-Cyclic Phosphate Diesterase IV . Nucleoside 3'.5 '-Cyclic Phosphate Diesterase . . . . . . A. Distribution of the Enzyme in Nature . . . . . B . Substrate Specificity . . . . . . . . . . C . Intracellular Localization . . . . . . . . . D . Metal Ion Requirement. pH Optimum and Substrate Affinity . . . . . . . . . . . . . E . Inhibitors and Activators . . . . . . . . . F. Possibility of Other Nucleoside Cyclic 3'.5 '-Phosphate Diesterases . . . . . . . . . . . . G . Physiological Function of Nucleoside 3'.5 '-Cyclic Phosphate Diesterase . . . . . . . . .
355 356 357 361 362 363 363 364 364 365 365 366 366 367 368 368
370 370
.
I Introduction
Enzymes are available from a variety of sources which split the phosphodiester bond of nucleoside 2'.3 '. and 3'.5 '.cyclic phosphates . The ability of the ribonucleases to hydrolyze ribonucleoside 2'.3 '.cyclic phosphates to the corresponding 3'-phosphates is well known . During 355
356
G. I. DRUMMOND AND M. YAMAMOTO
the past decade a number of enzymes have been discovered which appear to be specific for nucleoside cyclic phosphates and which do not possess nuclease action, i.e., they do not split internucleotide bonds. Early studies in this area were reviewed in the second edition of “The Enzymes” by Khorana ( 1 ) . Since that time three enzymes in particular have been reasonably well characterized, the cyclic phosphate diesterase from bacteria which possesses 3‘-nucleotidase activity, the nucleoside 2‘,3’cyclic phosphate diesterase from nerve tissue, and a nucleoside 3’, 5’-cyclic phosphate diesterase which is widely distributed in nature.
II. Ribonucleoride 2’,3’-Cyclic Phosphate Diesterare with 3’-Nucleotidase Activity from Microorganisms
In 1964, Anraku (2, 3) reported the isolation of an enzyme from Escherichia coli B which hydrolyzed ribonucleoside 2’,3’-cyclic phosphates. Enzyme fractions representing a 900-fold purification also possessed 3’-nucleotidase activity. Similar activities have subsequently been purified from Proteus mirabilis (4, 6),halophilic Vibrio alginolyticus (6, 7) , Bacillus subtilis (8),and various Enterobacteriaceae, specifically, Shigella sonnei, Salmonella heidelberg, Serratia marcescens, Proteus vulguris ( 9 ), and others (10).The enzyme from each organism is strikingly similar, but some differences are apparent. Although in no case has the enzyme been purified to homogeneity, much evidence exists that the ribonucleoside 2’,3’-cyclic phosphate diesterase activity and the 3’-nucleotidase activity reside in the same protein. Thus, in all cases the ratio of the two activities remained constant throughout purification which has varied from 130-fold for the P . mirabilis enzyme ( 4 ) to 2000-fold for the enzyme from V . alginolyticus ( 6 ) .Anraku (3) found that both activities from E . coli B had the same optimal pH, both showed the same behavior to activators such as Co2+, and to inhibitors [Zn2+, Cuz+, ethylenediaminetetraacetate (EDTA) 3 , both were activated simultaneously by heating at 55” for 5 min and 1. H. G. Khorana, “The Enzymes,” 2nd ed., Vol. 6, p. 79, 1961. 2. Y . Anraku, JBC 239, 3412 (1984). 3. Y . Anraku, JBC 239, 3420 (1964). 4. M. S. Center and F . J. Behal, JBC 243, 138 (1968). 5. M. S. Center and F. J. Behal, ABB 127, 391 (1988). 6. T. Unemoto and M. Hayashi, BBA 171, 89 (1969). 7. T. Unemoto, F. Takahashi, and M. Hayashi, BBA 185, 134 (1969). 8. K. Shimada and Y. Sugino, BBA 185, 367 (1969). 9. H . C. Neu, Biochemistry 7, 3774 (1968). 10. H. C. Neu and J . Chou, J . Bacteriol. 94, 1934 (1967).
16.
357
NUCLEOSIDE CYCLIC PHOSPHATE DIESTERASES
were lost at temperatures above 70”. Center and Behal ( 4 ) were unable to separate the two activities from P . mirabilis by starch gel electrophoresis or by density gradient centrifugation. Like the E . coli enzyme both activities in P . mirabilis were similarly affected by metal ions, both possessed identical heat stabilities, and treatment with trypsin and chymotrypsin inactivated each to the same extent. Similar studies with the enzyme from B . subtilis (8) and the Enterobacteriaceae (9) support the conclusion that the diesterase and 3’-nucleotidase represent a single protein.
A. PROPERTIES OF THE ENZYME 1 . Substrate Specificity
The activity of the enzyme from the various organisms for a variety of phosphate esters is given in Table I. The enzyme is highly specific TABLE I RELATIVE RATESOF HYDROLYSIS OF VARIOUSPHOSPHATE ESTERSBY NUCLEOSIDE DIE ST CYCLIC PHOSPHATE DIESTERASE
Compound 3’-UMP 3’-AMP 3’-CMP 3’-GMP Cyclic 2‘,3’-UMP Cyclic 2’,3’-AMP Cyclic 2‘,3’-CMP Cyclic 2’,3’-GMP 5’-UMP 5’-AMP 5’-CMP 5’-GMP bis(p-Nitrophenyl) phosphate p-Ni tropheny1 phosphate 2’-AMP Cyclic 3’,5’-AMP 4
E. coli B (Refs. 8,3 ) O 100 90 78 95 90 87 75 70 0.9 3.3 4.6 0.9 33
P. mirabilis (Ref. 4 P
6, 7)
100 100 88 138 65
100 100 106 153 350
51
117
71 0.005 0 0.005 0 151
0.01 0
V. alginolyticus (Refs.
0.0002 0
168
B. S. sublilzs sonnei (Ref. 8)b (Ref. 9)
P. vulgaris (Ref. 9)
100 100 86 100
100 111 98 105 76 55 58
100 100 90 103 65 55 60
0.01 0.01
0
0
0.86
36
48
0.0001
31
22
0.01
Mixed 3’(2’) isomers were actually used as substrates.
* The B. sublilis enzyme also hydrolyzes 3’-deoxynucleotides.
0.001 0
0.001 0
358
G . I. DRUMMOND AND M . YAMAMOTO
for ribonucleoside 3’-phosphates and ribonucleoside 2’,3’-cyclic phosphates ; bis (p-nitrophenyl) phosphate is also hydrolyzed. p-Nitrophenyl phosphate is hydrolyzed, but a t a rate much slower than 3’-AMP except with the enzyme from Enterobacteriaceae. The B. subtilis enzyme is unique in that 3’-deoxyribonucleotides are attacked. Ribonucleoside 2‘and 5‘-phosphates, adenosine 3’,5’-cyclic phosphate, ribonucleoside diand triphosphates, hexosephosphates and pentose phosphates, and pglycerol phosphate are not attacked. I n addition most preparations are free of DNase and RNase activities, and the enzyme clearly does not split internucleotide bonds. Its ability to split the cyclic diester group of cyclic-ended oligonucleotides does not seem to have been clearly delineated. It can open the cyclic phosphodiester linkage of short cyclicended oligonucleotides such as ApA-cyclic-p and ApApA-cyclic-p but a t rates much slower than for cyclic 2’,3’-AMP (11). It has also been reported capable of opening the cyclic phosphate ends in TMV-RNA but is unable to release the resulting monoesterified phosphate ( l a ) . 2. Physical and Chemical Properties Several characteristic properties of the enzyme from the various microorganisms are given in Table 11. In general, there are similarities with regard to pH optima, heat sensitivity, activation and inhibition by metal ions, and molecular weight. Differences, however, are apparent, namely, the lower pH optimum of the enzyme from E. coli B and B. subtilis, the marked activation of the E. coli enzyme a t 55”, and the marked activation of the enzyme from this organism and other Enterobacteriaceae by Co2+.I n addition the enzyme from slightly halophilic V . alginolyticus is unique in that the 3’-nucleotidase is activated by C1- while the cyclic diesterase activity is inhibited by this anion. Some of these differences of ,course may be experimental rather than real, resulting perhaps from slight variations in assay procedures and from the presence of nonenzyme impurities in the different preparations. 3. Kinetics and Mechanism of Action
Some kinetic constants for several substrates are given in Table 111; K , values for each substrate are roughly comparable for the enzyme from each organism, and V,,, values indicate the degree of reactivity for each substrate. Several kinetic studies have provided evidence that 11. Y. Anraku and D. Mieuno, J . Biochem. ( T o k y o ) 61, 81 (1967). 12. N. Pfrogner, A. Bradley, and H. Frankel-Conrat, BBA 142, 105 (1967).
SOME Organism
E. coli B P . mirabilis
PROPERTIES OF THE
Ref.
PH Optimum
(4 3)
6.4
(4)
7.5-8
(6,7)
7.68.3
B. subtilis
(8)
6.5
Enterobacteriaceae
(3)
7.2-8.0
V . alginolyticus
TABLE I1 2',3'-cYCLIC PHOSPHATE DIESTERASE FROM &IICROORG.4NISMS Heat sensitivity
Effect of metal ions
&fold activation a t 55"; inactivated a t 70" Partial inactivation at 55" and 65"
Activated 3- to 5-fold by Co2+(0.1 to 1 d). Inhibited by Zn2+and Cuz+ (1 mM) and by EDTA (0.1 mM) No activation by Co*+and slight inhibition a t 1 mM. Inhibited by Zn2+(0.1 and 1 mM) and by EDTA (1 mM) No activation by Cot+. Inhibited by Zn2+, Hg2+, and Cuz+ (0.2 mM) and by EDTA (0.2 mM). 3'-Nucleotidase markedly activated by C1(200 mM) but cyclic diesterase inhibited by ClNot activated by Co2+ and inhibited above 1 mM. Inhibited by Zn2+ (1 mM) Stimulated 2- to 3-fold by Coz+and Mn2+(10 mM). Inhibited by Zn2+ (10 mM)
Partial inact,ivation a t 55"
Stable a t 70" for 5 min Partial inactivation at 55"
Molecular weight 68,000
65 t o 0 0
50,000
57,400
360
G. I. DRUMMOND AND M. YAMAMOTO
TABLE I11 KINETICCONSTANTS FOR
THE
CYCLIC
3‘-AMPa
3’-UMPo
Organism
K m
Vmax
Km
E. wli P . mirabilis v.algionolyticvsb B. 8ubtdh S . aonnei P . VUlgaTis
0.50 0.22 0.80 0.40 0.45 0.50
900
0.53 1610
660
0.50
a
0.22 0.70
PHOSPHATE DIESTERASE
Cyclic 2‘,3’UMPo Km
Vmax
Vmsx
bi5 @Nitrophw-1) phosphate Km
Vmax
2 . 8 1000 5000 0.94 0.75 360 3 . 6 9 . 3 X 106 4 . 5 1020 7.0 77 C 0.2 6.7
K, values are those given X lo-‘ M, and Vmaxvalues are pmolelmg protein/hr.
* Values listed are for those assays without C1-. Value for cyclic 2’,3’-AMP is 2.7 X 106.
cyclic phosphate diesterase and 3’-nucleotidase activities represent different active sites on the enzyme protein. To examine this Anraku (3) measured the velocity constants (k, and k,) of both reactions involving hydrolysis of cyclic 2’,3’-UMP. ki
kt
cyclic 2’,3‘-UMP -+ 3’-UMP -+ U
+ Pi
These were differently affected by different procedures. For example, when the enzyme was activated at 55”, the increment in k , was slight, but k, increased 3.5-fold. Similarly, in the presence of EDTA, k , and k , values decreased independently, suggesting that the sites for both activities were different. Center and Behal ( 6 ) found that with the P . mirabilis enzyme, cyclic 2’,3’-UMP competitively inhibited the hydrolysis of bis(p-nitrophenyl) phosphate. The K i was 40 pl! very close to the K , for the cyclic nucleotide (Kml75 pl!) which indicated that the two compounds could serve as alternate substrates being hydrolyzed at the same active site. In contrast, 3‘-AMP was a mixed inhibitor of cyclic 2’,3’-UMP and bis (p-nitrophenyl) phosphate hydrolysis. Adenosine was a mixed inhibitor of bis (p-nitrophenyl) phosphate hydrolysis but a competitive inhibitor of 3’-AMP hydrolysis. From such kinetic studies Center and Behal ( 6 ) suggested that two separate and adjacent sites A and B are involved in the hydrolysis of the diester and phosphomonoester substrates. Site A serves as a binding site for hydrolysis of ribonucleoside 2’,3’-cyclic phosphates and together with site B catalyzes the hydrolysis of the diester bond. During this reaction 3‘-
16.
NUCLEOSIDE CYCLIC PHOSPHATE DIESTERASES
361
UMP becomes bound to site B which catalyzes the hydrolysis of the phosphomonoester bond. Adenosine and 3’-AMP by binding at site B could interfere with the breakdown of cyclic 2’,3’-UMP. Similarly, binding of bis (p-nitrophenyl) phosphate at site A could interfere with the breakdown of 3’-AMP. Cyclic 2’,3’-UMP and bis (p-nitrophenyl) phosphate compete for site A while adenosine competes with 3’-AMP for site B. Unemoto et al. ( 7 ) have examined the mutual inhibition of substrates and substrate analogs for the enzyme from halophilic V . alginolyticus. They also concluded that 3‘-ribonucleotides and ribonucleoside 2’,3’-cyclic phosphates are hydrolyzed a t difierent sites. However, because of the nature of the mutual inhibition between 3’-AMP and bis(p-nitrophenyl) phosphate, they suggested that part of the site for the latter substrate overlaps with the 3’-nucleotidase site. At this time the precise mechanism of action of the enzyme is not settled, but clearly there are two active sites, one a 3’-nucleotidase site and a cyclic phosphate diesterase site. Anraku (13) has described this protein as a “double-headed” enzyme.
B . CELLULAR LOCALIZATION The cyclic phosphate diesterase is found in the cell sap upon fractionation of bacterial extracts, and when such extracts are centrifuged a t 100,OOO x g i t is present in the supernatant fluid. Neu and Heppel (14) found the enzyme was released into solution when EDTA-lysozyme spheroplasts (16) were prepared from E . coli. This pointed to a surface localization of the enzyme as had been suggested for alkaline phosphatase, another enzyme known to be released during spheroplast formation ( 1 6 ) . Neu and Heppel (14) have also shown that the diesterase is released from E. coli cells by a process of osmotic shock. I n this procedure (17) cells preferably in the exponential growth phase are suspended in hypertonic sucrose, sedimented, and rapidly subjected to dispersal in solution of low ionic strength. About 4% of the cellular protein is released and most of the cells remain viable ( 1 7 ) . Cyclic phosphate diesterase is one of a family of degradative enzymes (17-19) including alkaline phosphatase, ribonuclease I, 5’-nucleotidase (see Chap13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19.
Y. Anraku, Procedures Nucleic Acid Res. p. 130 (1966). H. C. Neu and L. A. Heppel, BBRC 17, 215 (1964). R. Repaske, BBA 30, 225 (1958). M. H. Malamy and B. L. Horecker, Biochemistry 3, 1889 (1964). L. A. Heppel, Science 156, 1451 (1967). H . C. Neu and L. A. Heppel, JBC 240, 3685 (1965). N. G. Noasal and L. A. Heppel, JBC 241, 3055 (1966).
362
Q.
I. DRUMMOND AND M. YAMAMOTO
ter 15 by Drummond and Yamamoto, this volume) and others that are released into solution. The diesterase is also released during osmotic shock from other members of the Enterobacteriaceae such as Shigella, Enterobacter, Citrobacter, Serratia, and Salmonella (9, 10) ; this technique has provided an effective alternate procedure for purification (9, IS).The nature of this process suggests that these enzymes exist external to the cytoplasmia membrane and within the cell wall. Brockman and Heppel (20) have provided further evidence that the enzyme is located near the surface of E . coli external to the protoplasmic membrane. Thus, uridine 2’,3’-cyclic phosphate was hydrolyzed by intact cells suggesting the enzyme lay outside the permeability barrier for phosphate esters. Enzymic activity with intact cells, however, was less than that observed with equivalent amounts of cell extract. This suggested a partial barrier to penetration; the enzyme may be located between the cell wall and the cytoplasmic membrane in the “periplasmic space” (17’). Histochemical evidence (21) supports such a localization. The suggestion has also been made (10)that these enzymes are probably loosely bound to cytoplasmic membrane through the mediation of divalent cations. Whatever the precise location it seems probable that such degradQtive enzymes are confined in a compartment separate from those regions of the cell where synthetic reactions are taking place. Such compartmentation may be analogous to the localization of certain degradative enzymes in mammalian lysosomes. C. CYCLICPHOSPHATE DIESTERASE-AMETALLOENZYME When E . coli are grown in the presence of low concentrations of EDTA, a selective depression of cyclic phosphate diesterase (as well as 5’-nucleotidase and alkaline phosphatase) occurs. Dvorak (28) suggested that EDTA may act by binding a trace metal ion essential for the activity of the enzymes. To investigate this, E . coli cells were grown in the presence of radioactive s5Zn and cyclic phosphate diesterase and 5‘-nucleotidase were purified from shock fluid (23).The purification was accompanied by enrichment of 66Zn which could not be removed by dialysis. On chromatography and disc gel electrophoresis a superimposable peak of en2yrni.c activity and 66Zn were observed for both enzymes. Both enzymes were inactivated by prolonged exposure to EDTA and partial reactivation occurred upon the addition of Zn2+. The pos-
R.W. Brockman and L. A. Heppel, Biochemistry 7, 2554 (1968). 21. S. 5.Spicer, B. K. Wetzel, and L. A. Heppel, Federation Proc. 25, 539 (1966). 22. H. F. Dvorak, JBC 243, 2640 (1968). 23. H. F. Dvorak and L. A. Heppel, JBC 243, 2647 (1968). 20.
16. NUCLWIDE
363
CYCLIC PHOSPHATE] DIE ST ERAS^
sibility is thus considered (93)that the diesterase and 5’-nucleotidase of E . coli are zinc metalloenzymes.
D. PHYSIOLOGICAL FUNCTION Since ribonucleoside 2‘,3’-cyclic phosphates are formed from degradation of RNA by ribonuclease, Anraku (3) has suggested that the cyclic phosphate diesterase acting together with ribonuclease may be involved in the reutilization of nucleotides. Some evidence for this exists. Purified cyclic diesterase hydrolyzes ribonucleoside 2’,3’-cyclic phosphates about lo00 times more rapidly than purified rRNase (11). Furthermore, the ratio of their activities in vivo is about 600:l indicating that cyclic phosphate diesterase is the major enzyme concerned with the digestion of nucleoside cyclic phosphates. I n support of this, it has been shown that the diesterase is capable of opening the cyclic diester linkage of short cyclic-ended oligonucleotides such as ApA-cyclic-p and ApApAcyclic-p (11). Based on these facts Anraku and Mizuno (11) have proposed an RNase-cyclic phosphate diesterase system in which the diesterase acts on oligonucleotides with 2’,3’-cyclic phosphate end groups and catalyzes the rapid reutilization of cyclic phosphates by converting them to the corresponding nucleosides as shown in the scheme: RNA
___t
Xpyp
f
RNase
RNA
x p y p ----------- z p
/*
1
..--------. Z-cyc1ic-p _ _ _ t
- -
cyclic phosphate diesterase
X-cyclic-p
3’-nucleotidase
t/
I(
3’-XMP
nucleosides
+ Pi
A suggestion that such a system functions in the breakdown of ribosomal RNA in vivo has been provided by Maruyama and Mizuno (93a).They showed that the degradation of ribosomal RNA induced by phosphorus starvation was catalyzed by the primary attack of RNase on ribosomes followed by the accumulation of oligonucleotides with 2‘,3‘-cyclic phosphate end groups and these were subsequently converted to nucleosides and inorganic phosphate presumably by cyclic phosphate diesterase.
111. Ribonucleoside 2’,3‘-Cyclic from Vertebrate Nerve
Phosphate Diestemre
Prior to 1961, ribonucleoside 2’,3’-cyclic phosphate diesterase activity had been reported from two vertebrate tissues, calf spleen (94)and beef 23a. H. Maruyama and D. Mizuno, BBA 108, 593 (1965). 24. P. R. Whitfield, L. A. Heppel, and R. Markham, BJ 80, 16 (1956).
364
Q. I. DRUMMOND AND M. YAMAMOTO
pancreas (26) [see Khorana ( I ) ] . More recently, Drummond et al. (26) have described an extremely active diesterase from nerve tissue. A. PROPERTIES AND SUBSTRATE SPECIFICITY This enzyme converts ribonucleoside 2',3'-cyclic phosphates exclusively to the corresponding 2'-phosphates. The enzyme has greater specificity for 2',3'-cyclic phosphates bearing purine bases than those with pyrimidine bases. Activities in crude extracts of brain may be as high as 5-10 pmoles/min/mg of protein at 30". The K,,, for cyclic 2',3'-AMP is 1.9 d. The enzyme does not hydrolyze simple nucleoside phosphate esters and does not split internucleotide bonds of dinucleotides, oligonucleotides, or RNA. It does not hydrolyze ribonucleoside 3',5'-cyclic phosphates. The enzyme opens the cyclic diester linkage of 2',3'-cyclicended dinucleotides such as GpC-cyclic-p and ApC-cyclic-p with formation of the corresponding 2'-ended dinucleotide (26). The 2',3'-cyclic diester bond of longer cyclic-ended oligonucleotides, for example, Ap (Ap),A-cyclic-p, is also cleaved without rupture of internucleotide bonds. The enzyme possesses a pH optimum between p H 6 and 7; it is strongly inhibited by Zn2+and Hg2+and activated slightly by EDTA and citrate. Tissue from the central nervous system is the richest source of the enzyme; it is also present in peripheral nerve. White matter contains much more activity than gray matter. Relatively insignificant activity resides in tissues other than nerve.
B. INTRACELLULAR LOCALIZATION IN MYELIN The enzyme was originally found to be membrane bound and resisted solubiliaation and purification (26).Lundblad and Moore (27') , however, have reported solubilizing it using dilute (5 mM) sodium borate buffer at pH 9 after 16 hr a t 37". Studies on regional and subcellular distribution using density gradient techniques have revealed that the 2',3'-cyclic phosphate diesterase concentrates in those fractions containing myelin (28, 2 9 ) , and the conclusion has been reached that the enzyme is localized in the myelin sheath or intimately associated structures. Kurihara and 25. F. F. Davis and F. W. Allen, BBA 21, 14 (1956). 26. G. I. Drummond, N. T. Iyer, and J. Keith, JBC 237, 3535 (1962). 27. R.L. Lundblad and S. Moore, Brain Res. 12, 227 (1969). 28. T. Kurihara and Y . Tsukada, J . Neurochem. 14, 1167 (1967). 29. R. W. Olafson, G. I. Drummond, and J. F. Lee, Can. J . Biochem. 47, 961 (1969).
16.
NUCLEOSIDE CYCLIC PHOSPHATE DIESTERASES
365
Tsukada (30) have examined developmental changes of the enzyme in chick brain and spinal cord. Enzymic activity appears a t about the eighteenth day of incubation and increases rapidly until 3 days after hatching in the brain and between 18 and 21 days of incubation in the spinal cord. These are precisely the periods of active myelination in the brain and spinal cord of the chick, respectively. Similarly, brain tissue of the newborn rat is devoid of cyclic phosphate diesterase activity; it appears at about 8 days after birth and increases dramatically between the tenth and thirty-fifth day of life (29). This coincides precisely with the development of myelin in this species. The diesterase is essentially absent in the brain of the “jimpy” mouse (SI),a lethal mutant devoid of myelin in the central nervous system. It is also absent from the spinal cord of this mutant. The enzyme is about 50% deficient in brain tissue of the “quaking” mouse (29), a mutant with partial deficiency of myelin. There is no activity in nerve fibers and ganglia from a variety of invertebrates such as squid, octopus, crab, shrimp, and starfish. Nerve tissue in these organisms is nonmyelinated. All these observations point to an intimate association of the enzyme with myelin in vivo.
C. PHYSIOLOGICAL ROLEOF
THE
CYCLIC PHOSPHATE DIESTERASE
Nothing is known of the physiological function of this enzyme. No biological function is known for ribonucleoside 2’,3’-cyclic phosphates or cyclic-ended oligonucleotides, and if they occur in nerve tissue they are surely below the sensitivity of the usual methods of detection. Moreover, myelin is a tissue which has been considered essentially devoid of metabolic activity. The presence of such a highly active enzyme raises interesting possibilities regarding a role of nucleoside 2’,3’-cyclic phosphates in nerve function. The possibility should even be considered that the physiological substrate is something other than a nucleoside cyclic phosphate. The association of the enzyme with myelin is of interest with regard to its possible involvement in demyelinating diseases.
IV. Nucleoride 3’,5’-Cyclic Phosphate Diesterase
Following the discovery of adenosine 3’,5’-cyclic phosphate, an activity present in various animal tissues capable of destroying the compound 30. T. Kurihara and Y. Tsukada, J . Neurochena. 15, 827 (1968). 31. T. Kurihara, J. L. Nussbaum, and P. Mandel, Brain Re8. 13, 401 (1969).
366
Q. I. DRUMMOND AND M. YAMAMOW
was reported by Sutherland and Rall in 1958 (38).The activity was shown to be a Mg2+-dependent diesterase which catalyzed the hydrolysis of cyclic 3’,5’-AMP at the 3’ position forming 5‘-AMP. Since that time knowledge of the physiological role played by cyclic 3’,5’-AMP as a mediator of hormone action and modulator of enzymic activity has expanded rapidly [for reviews, see Sutherland et al.’ ( 3 6 )]. The 3’,5’cyclic phosphate diesterase has attracted considerable attention because of its important role (along with adenyl cyclase) in regulating intracellular levels of cyclic 3’,5’-AMP. A. DISTBIBUTION OF
THE
ENZYME EN NATUBE
Early studies revealed that the 3’,5’-cyclic phosphate diesterase is present in all mammalian tissues (39, 33, 3 6 ) , being most active in cerebral cortex (36, 37). It has also been identified in extracts of liver fluke (FascioZa hepatica), the common earthworm ( L u m b r h terresth) , and fly larvae (36) ; and it has been studied in marine organisms (38), the cellular slime mold Dictyostelium discoideum (39, 40), and in E. coli (41). The enzyme has been partially purified from beef heart (369,dog heart, (42) and bovine brain (37,@) . No highly purified preparations have yet been obtained and most studies have been performed with relatively crude preparations.
B. SUBSTRATE SPECIFICITY The enzyme from brain hydrolyzes cyclic 3’,5‘-monophosphates bearing purine bases more readily than those bearing pyrimidines (37,&). 32. E. W. Sutherland and T. W. Rall, JBC 232, 1077 (1958). 33. E. W. Sutherland and T. W. Rall, Phamnacol. Rev. 12, 265 (1960). 34. E. W. Sutherland, G. A. Robison, and R. W. Butcher, Circulation 37, 279 (1968).
35. G. A. Robison, R. W. Butcher, and E. W. Sutherland, Ann. Rev. Biochm. 37, 149 (1908).
36. R. W. Butcher and E. W. Sutherland, JBC 237, 1244 (1962). 37. G. I. Drummond and S. Perrot-Yee, JBC 236, 1128 (1961). 38. M. Yamamoto and K. L. Massey, Comp. Biochem. PhvWZ. 30, 941 (1969). 39. Y. Y. Chang, Science 161, 57 (1968). 40. J. T. Bonner, D. S. Barkley, E. M. Hall, T. M. Konijn, T. W. Mason, G. O’Keefe, 111, and P. B. Wolfe, DeveZop. BWZ. 20, 72 (1969). 41. H. Bra& and F. Chytil, F o l k Mkrobiol. (Prague) 11, 43 (1965). 42. K. G. Nair, Biochemistry 5, 150 (1960). 43. W. Y. Cheung, BBA 101, 303 (1969). 44. G. I. Drummond, M. W. Gllgan, E. J. Reiner, and M. Smith, JACS 86, 1026 (1964).
16.
NUCLEOSIDE CYCLIC PHOSPHATE DIESTERASES
367
Cyclic 3‘,5‘-CMP is not attacked. Deoxyribonucleoside 3’,5’-cyclic phosphates are hydrolyzed a t rates slightly less than the corresponding ribonucleoside derivatives ( 4 4 ) . Similar specificity is shown by the dog heart (42) and rat liver enzyme (45).Tubercidin 3’,5’-cyclic phosphate (tubercidin is 7-deaza adenosine) is hydrolyzed about three times more rapidly than cyclic 3’,5’-AMP by the rabbit brain enzyme (46). I n all cases that have been examined, the product of hydrolysis is exclusively the 5’-phosphate (39, 36, 37, 4.4). These limited studies indicate a rather low degree of substrate specificity with regard to the base moiety. There seems to be a much more rigid requirement for an intact phosphate and sugar moiety. Thus, substitution of a butyryl group on C-2 of ribose greatly reduces reactivity (47) and N8,2’-O-dibutyryl cyclic 3‘,5’-AMP is completely resistant to hydrolysis (4.6, 46). Moreover, adenosine 3’,5’cyclic phosphorothioate and a 3’-methylene cyclic phosphonate analog (the 5’-cyclic ester of 9- [3’-deoxy-3’-dihydroxyphosphinylmethyl-~-~ribofuranosyl] -adenine) are neither substrates nor effective inhibitors (46). I n addition, the 5’-methylene cyclic phosphonate compound and adenine xylofuranosyl 3’,5’-cyclic phosphate are extremely poor substrates. Precise understanding of the mechanism of action of the enzyme must await the availability of highly purified preparations and systematic kinetic studies,
C. INTRACELLULAR LOCALIZATION Some investigators have found the enzyme primarily in the 100,000 x g supernatant fluid of extracts of rabbit brain (37), dog heart (&), rat liver (46), rat brain, and beef pineal gland (48). I n contrast, other
investigators have reported that the enzyme from beef heart (36)and rat brain (49, 50) is mostly particulate being present in all the primary fractions nuclear, mitochondrial, microsomal, and 100,000 x g supernatant. The reasons for these discrepancies are not entirely clear but m