Bird Families of the World A series of authoritative, illustrated handbooks of which this is the 15th volume to be publ...
382 downloads
4188 Views
7MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Bird Families of the World A series of authoritative, illustrated handbooks of which this is the 15th volume to be published
Series editors ROBERT B. PAYNE Chief editor MICHAEL D. SORENSON KAREN KLITZ JOHN MEGAHAN Robert Payne is an ornithologist at the University of Michigan, where he is Professor of Zoology in the Department of Ecology and Evolutionary Biology, and Curator of Birds in the Museum of Zoology. Earlier ornithological positions include two years postdoc experience at the Fitzpatrick Institute of Ornithology at the University of Cape Town, in a study of African brood-parasitic cuckoos and finches, and three years teaching at the University of Oklahoma in the Great Plains. He is interested in parental care and brood parasitism of birds, evolution of the brood-parasitic finches and cuckoos and their hosts, nestling mimicry of the parental hosts by the brood parasites, behavioral imprinting and how this may lead to the origin of new species of brood-parasitic birds, and the biology of bird song. Over time his interests have developed through a mix of travel to watch birds in the field, experimental studies to ask questions about behavior development, and systematics using the museum collections. He has about 190 publications on birds, many on brood parasitism and population biology. He works with others who work well with the molecular systematics of birds. In field research he has studied the variation of the broodparasitic finches and their host species associations in Africa, and after this book is completed he plans to travel with his wife Laura to observe cuckoos and record their songs in the field. Karen Klitz began painting birds in Africa in 1965. She has been a staff illustrator in the Museums of Zoology and Paleontology at the University of Michigan and is currently Principal Illustrator for the Museum of Vertebrate Zoology at the University of California, Berkeley.
Bird Families of the World 1. The Hornbills Alan Kemp 2. The Penguins Tony D.Williams 3. The Megapodes Darryl N. Jones, René W. R. J. Dekker, and Cees S. Roselaar 4. Fairy-wrens and Grasswrens Ian Rowley and Eleanor Russell 5. The Auks Anthony J. Gaston and Ian L. Jones 6. The Birds of Paradise Clifford B. Frith and Bruce Beehler 7. The Nightjars and their Allies D.T. Holyoak 8. Toucans, Barbets and Honeyguides Lester L. Short and Jennifer F. M. Horne 9. Ratites and Tinamous S. J. J. F. Davies 10. The Bowerbirds Clifford B. Frith and Dawn W. Frith 11. Albatrosses and Petrels across the World Michael Brooke 12. The Grebes Jon Fjeldså 13. The Hawaiian Honeycreepers H. Douglas Pratt 14. Herons James A. Kushlan and James A. Hancock 15. The Cuckoos Robert B. Payne 16. Ducks, Geese and Swans Edited by Janet Kear
Bird Families of the World
The Cuckoos Robert B. Payne with a molecular genetic analysis of cuckoo phylogeny by
Michael D. Sorenson and Robert B. Payne Color plates by
Karen Klitz Black and white illustrations by
John Megahan
Great Clarendon Street, Oxford OX2 6DP Oxford University Press is a department of the University of Oxford. It furthers the University’s objective of excellence in research, scholarship, and education by publishing worldwide in Oxford New York Auckland Cape Town Dar es Salaam Hong Kong Karachi Kuala Lumpur Madrid Melbourne Mexico City Nairobi New Delhi Taipei Toronto Shanghai With offices in Argentina Austria Brazil Chile Czech Republic France Greece Guatemala Hungary Italy Japan South Korea Poland Portugal Singapore Switzerland Thailand Turkey Ukraine Vietnam Oxford is a registered trade mark of Oxford University Press in the UK and in certain other countries Published in the United States by Oxford University Press Inc., New York Illustrations © Oxford University Press, 2005 Text © Robert B. Payne except Text of Molecular Systematics Chapter © Michael D. Sorenson and Robert D. Payne, 2005 The moral rights of the authors have been asserted Database right Oxford University Press (maker) First published 2005 All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, without the prior permission in writing of Oxford University Press, or as expressly permitted by law, or under terms agreed with the appropriate reprographics rights organization. Enquiries concerning reproduction outside the scope of the above should be sent to the Rights Department, Oxford University Press, at the address above You must not circulate this book in any other binding or cover and you must impose this same condition on any acquirer A catalogue record for this title is available from the British Library British Library Cataloging in Publication Data Data available ISBN 0 19 850213 3 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 Typeset by Macmillan India Limited Printed in China
Acknowledgments
My father Russell Payne and Sao Saimong Mongrai introduced me to cuckoos in the Shan States in Burma in 1951, where I watched cuckoos at Taunggyi, a site of classic cuckoo studies in the 1930s. Undergraduate work at the University of Michigan Museum of Zoology and a talk by Herbert Friedmann on brood-parasitic birds at Cranbrook Institute of Science were important in turning attention toward the cuckoos. Graduate work at the Museum of Vertebrate Zoology, University of California, Berkeley, supported a field study of broodparasitic cowbirds. A National Science Foundation postdoctoral research fellowship in 1965 allowed two years in the field with brood-parasitic cuckoos in Africa, with the help of Herbert Friedmann and the Percy FitzPatrick Institute of African Ornithology at the University of Cape Town, with fieldwork in South Africa, Botswana, Rhodesia, Zambia, Malawi and Kenya. In southern and east Africa, Karen Klitz and I worked with cuckoos in the 1960s, guided by Jack Winterbottom, Richard Liversidge, Jack Skead and Gordon Ranger in South Africa, Michael Irwin in Zimbabwe, and John Williams in Kenya. My wife Laura Payne and I watched Neotropical cuckoos in Gayana and Curaçao, we next shared fieldwork with cuckoos and fairy-wrens in the 1980s in Western Australia with the CSIRO research team of Ian Rowley, Eleanor Russell, Michael Brooker and Graeme Chapman on Gooseberry Hill, and with Ian and Eleanor and Dick and Molly Brown in the Manjimup forests. Later we worked with Nedra Klein in Cameroon, Mike Sorenson in Zimbabwe and Guinea, Pierre Reynaud in Senegal, Clive Barlow in Guinea, Senegal, Gambia and Mali, Ben King in India, Phil Round in Thailand,Wang Luan Keng
and Lim Kim Keang in Malaysia, Ir Darjono in Java, and Kathy Groschupf in Arizona. In other field studies I worked with Geoffrey Field in Sierra Leone, Chris Risley in Ghana, Kathy Groschupf in Cameroon, and Roger Wilkinson, Neville Skinner and Mark Hopkins in Nigeria. In North America the University of Michigan Biological Station, the Matthai Botanical Gardens, and the E. S. George Reserve of the University of Michigan provided field support, as did the Oklahoma University Biological Station at Willis, Oklahoma. The second phase of work was examining the specimens in natural history museums.This gave a closer look at cuckoos than the birds themselves ever allowed in the field. The curators of these valuable collections allowed me to examine specimens during research visits or through loans. For permission to examine specimens and information from their collections, I thank the curators and staff of the following museums and live bird collections: Brian Gill (AM,Auckland); Dean Amadon, George Barrowclough, Joel Cracraft, Wesley Lanyon, Mary LeCroy, Pamela Beresford, Peter Capainolo, Shannon Kenney, Chris Milensky, Chris Vogel and Paul Sweet (AMNH, New York); David Agro and Leo Joseph (ANSP, Philadelphia); Robert PrysJones, Michael Walters, Frank Steinbrenner and Mark Adams (BMNH,Tring); Carla Kishinami (B. P. Bishop Museum, Honolulu); Kit Hustler and Michael Irwin (BWYO, Bulawayo); Phil Bruner (BYU, Laie, Hawaii); Lei Fu-min (CAS, Beijing); Ken Parkes, Brad Livezey and Robin Panza (CM, Pittsburgh); Robert S. Kennedy (CMNH, Cincinnati); Michael Brooke (Cambridge University Museum); Kevin McGowan and Charles Dardia
vi Acknowledgments (CU, Ithaca); Mike Brooke (CUM, Cambridge); David Allan and Philip Clancey (DM, Durban); Gene Hess and Jean Woods (DMNH, Wilmington); Dave Willard, John Bates, Shannon Hackett, Melvin Traylor, Peter Lowther and Amy Driskell (FMNH, Chicago); Dave Steadman and Tom Webber (FLMNH, Gainesville); René Verheyen (IRSNB, Brussels), Bob Zink, Scott Lanyon and John Klicka ( JFBM, Minneapolis); C. J. Skead (Kaffrarian Museum, King William’s Town); H. Schouteden, Anton De Roo and Michel Louette (KMMA, Tervuren); Rick Prum and Mark Robbins (KU, Lawrence); Donna Dittmann, Steve Cardiff, Rob Moyle, Van Remsen and Fred Sheldon (LSU, Baton Rouge); Karl Schuchmann, Renate van den Elzen and Hans Wolters (ZFMK, Bonn); Eulàlia Garcia Franquesa (MCNB, Barcelona); Doug Causey, Ray Paynter and Alison Pirie (MCZ, Cambridge); Robin Restall (MHNLS); Pavel Tomkovich (MMZ, Moscow); Christian Erard and C. Voisin (MNHN, Paris); Martin Nhlane (MNM, Blantyre); Giuliano Doria, Roberto Poggi and Enrico Borgo (MSNG, Genoa); Giorgio Chiozzi and Carlo Violani (MSNM, Milan); Laura Abraczinskas, Barb Lundrigan and Pamela Rasmussen (MSU, East Lansing); Ned Johnson, Carla Cicero and Karen Klitz (MVZ, Berkeley); S. Somadikarta and Ir Darjono (MZB Cibinong); Marta Poggesi (MZUS, Firenze); Tony Parker (NMGL, Liverpool); Chum Cunningham-van Someren (NMK, Nairobi); Rodolfo A. Caberoy (NMP, Manila); Ernst Baurenfeind and Herbert Schifter (NMW, Wien); Jarunjin Nabhitabhata (NSM, Bangkok); Gary Schnell (OU); Robin Restall (POC); Steve van Dyke (QM, Brisbane); René Dekker, Gerlof Mees and Peter Van Dam (RMNH, Leiden); Jon Barlow and Jim Dick (ROM, Toronto); John M. Winterbottom (South African Museum, Cape Town); Gerald Mayr (SMF, Frankfurt); Siegfried Eck (SMTD, Dresden), Maklarin Bin Lakim (SP, Kinabalu); James Mueller (SRSU); Keith Arnold (TCWC, College Station, Texas); Lakkana Pakkarnseree (TISTR, Bangkok); Fritz Hertel (UCLA, Los Angeles); Bob Dickerman (UNM, Albuquerque); Gary Voelcker (UNLV, Las Vegas); Mike Braun, Phil Angle, James Dean, Gary Graves, Helen James, Storrs Olson, Pamela Rasmussen and
Dick Zusi (USNM,Washington, D.C.); Scott Cutler (UTEP); Scott Edwards, Sievert Rohwer,Wang Luan Keng, Chris Wood, Gary Voelcker, Robert Faucett, Sharon Birks and Sergei Drovetski (UWBM, Seattle); Dieter Rinke (VW, Walsrode); Glen Storr (WAM, Perth); René Corrado (WFVZ, Camarillo); Jacques Gautier, Paul Whitfield and Kristof Zyskowski (YPM, New Haven); Juergen Fiebig (ZMB, Berlin); Jon Fjeldså (ZMUC, Copenhagen); Yang Chang Man, Darren C. J. Yeo and Lua Hui Keng (ZRC, Singapore); Josef Reichholf (ZSM, München); Kees Roselaar (ZMA,Amsterdam); and Pavel Tomkovich (ZMM, Moscow). Tom Huels hand-reared young roadrunners for developmental studies. Michael Walters measured eggs at BMNH. Dan Gaebel, Karen Kevelighan, Jeff Rebitzke, Sharon Reske and Angie Steffen, undergraduate students at the University of Michigan, examined skeletal specimens with me. George Kulesza made available the measurements of brain size in cuckoos from his comparative brain measurements from skeletons in UMMZ. Carlo Violani was helpful in arranging visits to natural history museums in Italy and in locating specimens and publications. Godfrey Symons gave access to photograph bird eggs in his collection; the collection is now in the Cathcart Museum, South Africa, and Jean Woods at DMNH loaned bird eggs to use in calibrating egg colors in the photographs. For photographs of museum specimens, I thank Patricia Escalante Pliego and Adolfo G. Navarro S. (Colección Nacional de Aves, Dept. Zoología, Instituto de Biología, UNAM, Mexico City), Leslie Jessop (NEWHM), Michel Louette (KMMA), Maklarin Bin Lakim (Sabah Parks), Ir Darjono (MZB) and Lei Fu-min (CAS), and for photographs of live cuckoos I thank Graeme Chapman, Carla Fontana, Johannes Foufopoulos, Karen Klitz, Mary LeCroy, Dale Lewis, Regina Macedo, Richard Peek, Cheong Weng Chuan and Kit Hustler, Ron Orenstein, Ole Post, Ong Kiem Sian, Trevor Price, Carol Ralph, Cheong Wan Chun, Pamela Rasmussen, Phil Round, Joe Strauch, Bob Thornton, Sandra Vehrencamp, Wang Luan Keng, Jongmin Yoon and Moo-Boo Yoon. Rob Moyle and Carl Vernon provided their photographs of forest habitat which we adapted into the background of the color plates.The British Library National Sound Archive (NSA, Richard
Acknowledgments vii Ranft), Cornell Library of Natural Sounds (LNS), Sandra Gaunt (OSU), Per Alström, Clive Barlow, Graeme Chapman, Jared Diamond, Chris Filardi, Lei Fumin, Paul Holt, Bob Kennedy, Ben King, Lindy McBride, Barry Morgan, Pamela Rasmussen, Phil Round, Pratap Singh, Deepal Warakagoda and Martha Whitson gave descriptions of songs and copies of their tape and digital recordings of cuckoo songs. Colleagues at the University of Michigan, including Lei Fumin, Janet Hinshaw, George Kulesza, David Mindell, John Mitani, Phil Myers, Robert Storer, Jean Woods and Tamaki Yuri, were helpful throughout the study. Material for molecular genetics analysis was provided by several museums and collections (AMNH, ANSP, BMNH, CM, CMNH, FMNH, LSU, QM, AM, DM, DMNH, MCZ, MNM, MVZ, RMNH, SMNS, UMMZ, UMMZ, USNM, UWBM, VW, WFVZ, YPM and ZMUC), and by Dinesh Bhatt (Gurukul Kangri University, Haridwar), Steve Latta (University of Missouri), Terry Root (Ann Arbor), Steve Schneider (Palo Alto) and Lei Fu-min (CAS, Beijing). Preliminary genetic analyses were conducted in David Mindell’s laboratory at the University of Michigan Museum of Zoology, for which the University of Michigan supported funding for DNA sequencing. Suzanne Ambs, Marina Ramon, Tracy Heath, Kristina Sefc and Elen Oneal assisted with the processing of DNA sequencing reactions at Boston University. Funding for DNA sequencing and a computer cluster used for the phylogenetic analyses were provided by Boston University. For bibliographic help I thank Joann Constantinides, Janet Hinshaw, Charlene Stachnick and Dorothy Riemenschneider (University of Michigan, Ann Arbor), Linda Birch (Alexander Library, EGI, Oxford University), Effie Wahr (BMNH, Tring), Mary Petersen (ZMUC, Copenhagen), Renate van den Elzen (ZFMK, Bonn) and the librarians of ZSM (Munich). David Seel of Bangor guided me to Pound Green Common, Worcestershire, where Edgar Chance observed cuckoos in the 1920s. Carla Fontana, Lydia Skrynnikova and Tamaki Yuri translated works in Portuguese, Russian and Japanese; and Ir Darjono, James Dean, Antonia Gorog and Paul Taylor interpreted the museum specimen labels of birds taken in Indonesia. David Allan, Wayne Arendt, Walter Boles, Mariana
Cariello, Mario Cohn-Haft, Nigel Collar, Jack Cox, Carla Fontana, Larry Heaney, Regina Macedo, Sergio Posso, Pamela Rasmussen, Danny Rogers, Burkhard Stephan and Robert L. Sutton kindly sent original data, observations and copies of their papers, and Burkhard Stephan allowed us to use his drawings of cuckoo wings. Clive Barlow, Pamela Beresford, Andy Berger, Bonnie Bowen, Michael Brooker, John Colebrook-Robjent, Richard Dean, Edward Dickinson, Jon Fjeldså, Steve Goodman, Kathy Groschupf, Bill Hamilton, Hiroyoshi Higuchi, Tom Huels, Kit Hustler, Klaus Immelmann, Bob Kennedy, Jiro Kikkawa, J. M. (Martjan) Lammetink, Mary LeCroy, Regina Macedo, Gerald Mauersberger, Ernst Mayr, Sergio Posso, Pamela Rasmussen, Manolo Soler, Richard Thorington, Carl Vernon, Carlo Violani, Michael Walters and Amotz Zahavi offered discussion during the study. For comments on the manuscript I thank Bonnie Bowen, Richard Dean, Edward Dickinson, Kathy Groschupf, Ben King, Karen Klitz, George Kulesza, David Lahti, Regina Macedo, Laura Payne, Rick Prum, Pamela Rasmussen, Robin Restall, Charlie Rosa, Mike Sorenson and J.Van Remsen. Karen Klitz painted the color plates of cuckoos. John Megahan drew the black and white illustrations of birds and bones and digitized the maps, the eggs and nestling photographs. Janet Hinshaw, Alec Lindsay, David Lahti, John Megahan, Laura Payne, Jean Woods and Tamaki Yuri helped prepare the illustrations. The National Science Foundation supported fieldwork on cuckoos and laboratory work on molecular genetics. Additional support was provided for field studies by the National Geographic Research Committee and the University of Michigan, and for molecular studies by the University of Michigan Museum of Zoology and Boston University. I thanks the series editors Professors Christopher Perrins,Walter Bock, and Jiro Kikkawa for their support, Judith May, formerly Senior Editor, for inviting the contribution, and the staff of Oxford University Press and Macmillan India, especially Stephen Benaim and Laura O’Neill, all for providing the freedom and encouragement to develop the book. I thank OUP for publishing this wonderful series on birds.
A brood parasite destroys its host and family—speaks the Fool, as Goneril evicts Lear: “For you know, nuncle, The hedge-sparrow fed the Cuckoo so long That it’s had its head bit off by its young. (King Lear, I, 4, 203–205),
“. . . the Cuckoos. In these the confusion is tremendous, and I don’t know if [I] will be able to make them out satisfactorily. I am afraid that I shall have not the time to go through them in a proper way.”— Tommaso Salvadori, 1875, letter to R. B. Sharpe, 12 Oct 1877 (Violani et al. 1997: 40–41).
Laying behavior of Little Bronze-cuckoo Chrysococcyx minutillus in Putrajaya Wetland, near Kuala Lumpur, Malay Peninsula. a, female cuckoo perches and peers at a pocket-shaped nest of a flyeater, Golden-bellied Gerygone Gerygone sulphurea. The cuckoo then perched closer to the nest, then moved to the nest. b, cuckoo laying in nest, perched on nest pocket rim, the head and cloacal region inserted into the nest entrance, the back feathers raised, the wings and tail spread outside the nest, wings grasping the nest and the tail supporting the bird (obscured by vegetation). The cuckoo remained in this posture for 3–4 seconds. After the cuckoo's visit, an unspotted greenish egg appeared in the nest — Little Bronze-cuckoos lay greenish eggs; the flyeaters lay spotted whitish eggs. Drawn from photos by Cheong Weng Chun. The laying behavior of this cuckoo is similar to that described in other bronze-cuckoo species in Australia (Brooker et al. 1988).
Contents
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11
List of color plates List of abbreviations Plan of the book
xiv xv xix
PART I General chapters Introduction to the cuckoos Distribution, habitats and conservation status Behavior Morphology A molecular genetic analysis of cuckoo phylogeny Species Fossil and comparative evidence of cuckoo relationships Breeding biology and life histories Cooperative breeding Brood parasitism The evolution of brood parasitism in cuckoos
3 9 15 27 68 95 109 114 132 137 154
PART II Species accounts Crotophaginae Genus Guira Guira Cuckoo Genus Crotophaga Greater Ani Smooth-billed Ani Groove-billed Ani
169 169 169 172 172 174 178
Neomorphinae Genus Tapera American Striped Cuckoo Genus Dromococcyx Pheasant Cuckoo Pavonine Cuckoo Genus Morococcyx Lesser Ground-cuckoo Genus Geococcyx Greater Roadrunner Lesser Roadrunner
Guira guira Crotophaga major Crotophaga ani Crotophaga sulcirostris
Tapera naevia Dromococcyx phasianellus Dromococcyx pavoninus Morococcyx erythropygus Geococcyx californianus Geococcyx velox
183 183 183 187 187 189 191 191 193 193 198
x Contents Genus Neomorphus Banded Ground-cuckoo Rufous-winged Ground-cuckoo Red-billed Ground-cuckoo Rufous-vented Ground-cuckoo Centropodinae Genus Centropus Buff-headed Coucal Pied Coucal Greater Black Coucal Biak Coucal Rufous Coucal Green-billed Coucal Black-faced Coucal Black-hooded Coucal Short-toed Coucal Bay Coucal Gabon Coucal Black-throated Coucal Senegal Coucal Blue-headed Coucal Coppery-tailed Coucal White-browed Coucal Javan Coucal Greater Coucal Goliath Coucal Madagascar Coucal African Black Coucal Philippine Coucal Lesser Coucal Violaceous Coucal Lesser Black Coucal Pheasant Coucal Couinae Genus Carpococcyx Sumatran Ground-cuckoo Bornean Ground-cuckoo Coral-billed Ground-cuckoo Genus Coua Crested Coua Verreaux’s Coua Blue Coua Red-capped Coua Red-fronted Coua Coquerel’s Coua
radiolosus rufipennis pucheranii geoffroyi
200 200 202 203 204
milo ateralbus menbeki chalybeus unirufus chlororhynchos melanops steerii rectunguis celebensis anselli leucogaster senegalensis monachus cupreicaudus superciliosus nigrorufus sinensis goliath toulou grillii viridis bengalensis violaceus bernsteini phasianinus
208 208 208 210 211 213 214 215 216 218 219 221 222 224 226 228 231 233 236 238 242 244 246 248 250 254 255 257
Neomorphus Neomorphus Neomorphus Neomorphus
Centropus Centropus Centropus Centropus Centropus Centropus Centropus Centropus Centropus Centropus Centropus Centropus Centropus Centropus Centropus Centropus Centropus Centropus Centropus Centropus Centropus Centropus Centropus Centropus Centropus Centropus
Carpococcyx viridis Carpococcyx radiatus Carpococcyx renauldi Coua Coua Coua Coua Coua Coua
cristata verreauxi caerulea ruficeps reynaudii coquereli
262 262 262 264 266 268 268 270 271 273 274 276
Contents xi Running Coua Giant Coua Snail-eating Coua Red-breasted Coua
Cuculinae Genus Rhinortha Raffles’s Malkoha Genus Ceuthmochares Whistling Yellowbill Chattering Yellowbill Genus Taccocua Sirkeer Malkoha Genus Zanclostomus Red-billed Malkoha Genus Phaenicophaeus Chestnut-breasted Malkoha Chestnut-bellied Malkoha Red-faced Malkoha Blue-faced Malkoha Black-bellied Malkoha Green-billed Malkoha Genus Rhamphococcyx Yellow-billed Malkoha Genus Dasylophus Rough-crested Cuckoo Scale-feathered Malkoha Genus Clamator Chestnut-winged Cuckoo Great Spotted Cuckoo Levaillant’s Cuckoo Jacobin Cuckoo Genus Coccycua Little Cuckoo Dwarf Cuckoo Ash-colored Cuckoo Genus Piaya Squirrel Cuckoo Black-bellied Cuckoo Genus Coccyzus Dark-billed Cuckoo Yellow-billed Cuckoo Pearly-breasted Cuckoo Mangrove Cuckoo Cocos Cuckoo Black-billed Cuckoo Gray-capped Cuckoo
Coua Coua Coua Coua
cursor gigas delalandei serriana
277 279 280 281
283 283 Rhinortha chlorophaea 283 285 Ceuthmochares australis 285 Ceuthmochares aereus 287 291 Taccocua leschenaultii 291 293 Zanclostomus javanicus 293 294 Phaenicophaeus curvirostris 294 Phaenicophaeus sumatranus 298 Phaenicophaeus pyrrhocephalus 299 Phaenicophaeus viridirostris 301 Phaenicophaeus diardi 302 Phaenicophaeus tristis 304 306 Rhamphococcyx calyorhynchus 306 308 Dasylophus superciliosus 308 Dasylophus cumingi 309 311 Clamator coromandus 311 Clamator glandarius 313 Clamator levaillantii 318 Clamator jacobinus 320 325 Coccycua minuta 325 Coccycua pumila 328 Coccycua cinerea 330 331 Piaya cayana 331 Piaya melanogaster 335 336 Coccyzus melacoryphus 336 Coccyzus americanus 339 Coccyzus euleri 345 Coccyzus minor 347 Coccyzus ferrugineus 350 Coccyzus erythropthalmus 351 Coccyzus lansbergi 354
xii Contents Chestnut-bellied Cuckoo Rufous-breasted Cuckoo Jamaican Lizard-cuckoo Puerto Rican Lizard-cuckoo Cuban Lizard-cuckoo Hispaniolan Lizard-cuckoo Genus Pachycoccyx Thick-billed Cuckoo Genus Microdynamis Dwarf Koel Genus Eudynamys Common Koel Genus Urodynamis Long-tailed Cuckoo Genus Scythrops Channel-billed Cuckoo Genus Chrysococcyx Asian Emerald Cuckoo Violet Cuckoo Diederik Cuckoo Klaas’s Cuckoo Yellow-throated Cuckoo African Emerald Cuckoo Long-billed Cuckoo Horsfield’s Bronze-cuckoo Black-eared Cuckoo Rufous-throated Bronze-cuckoo Shining Bronze-cuckoo White-eared Bronze-cuckoo Little Bronze-cuckoo Genus Cacomantis Pallid Cuckoo White-crowned Cuckoo Chestnut-breasted Cuckoo Fan-tailed Cuckoo Banded Bay Cuckoo Plaintive Cuckoo Gray-bellied Cuckoo Brush Cuckoo Genus Cercococcyx Dusky Long-tailed Cuckoo Olive Long-tailed Cuckoo Barred Long-tailed Cuckoo Genus Surniculus Fork-tailed Drongo-cuckoo Philippine Drongo-cuckoo Square-tailed Drongo-cuckoo
Coccyzus Coccyzus Coccyzus Coccyzus Coccyzus Coccyzus
pluvialis rufigularis vetula vieilloti merlini longirostris
Pachycoccyx audeberti Microdynamis parva Eudynamys scolopacea Urodynamis taitensis Scythrops novaehollandiae Chrysococcyx Chrysococcyx Chrysococcyx Chrysococcyx Chrysococcyx Chrysococcyx Chrysococcyx Chrysococcyx Chrysococcyx Chrysococcyx Chrysococcyx Chrysococcyx Chrysococcyx Cacomantis Cacomantis Cacomantis Cacomantis Cacomantis Cacomantis Cacomantis Cacomantis
maculatus xanthorhynchus caprius klaas flavigularis cupreus megarhynchus basalis osculans ruficollis lucidus meyeri minutillus
pallidus leucolophus castaneiventris flabelliformis sonneratii merulinus passerinus variolosus
Cercococcyx mechowi Cercococcyx olivinus Cercococcyx montanus Surniculus dicruroides Surniculus velutinus Surniculus lugubris
356 357 358 360 361 362 364 364 367 367 368 369 378 378 380 381 385 385 388 391 395 399 400 403 405 407 409 410 413 415 421 422 424 426 427 430 433 437 439 447 447 449 451 453 454 458 460
Contents xiii Moluccan Drongo-cuckoo Genus Hierococcyx Mustached Hawk-cuckoo Dark Hawk-cuckoo Large Hawk-cuckoo Common Hawk-cuckoo Rufous Hawk-cuckoo Philippine Hawk-cuckoo Javan Hawk-cuckoo Whistling Hawk-cuckoo Genus Cuculus Black Cuckoo Red-chested Cuckoo Asian Lesser Cuckoo Sulawesi Cuckoo Indian Cuckoo Madagascar Lesser Cuckoo African Cuckoo Oriental Cuckoo Himalayan Cuckoo Sunda Lesser Cuckoo Common Cuckoo
Surniculus musschenbroeki Hierococcyx Hierococcyx Hierococcyx Hierococcyx Hierococcyx Hierococcyx Hierococcyx Hierococcyx Cuculus Cuculus Cuculus Cuculus Cuculus Cuculus Cuculus Cuculus Cuculus Cuculus Cuculus
vagans bocki sparverioides varius hyperythrus pectoralis fugax nisicolor
clamosus solitarius poliocephalus crassirostris micropterus rochii gularis optatus saturatus lepidus canorus
463 464 465 466 468 471 473 475 477 479 481 481 485 488 491 492 496 498 500 505 508 510
Glossary
519
Bibliography
526
Index
607
Color plates Color plates fall between pages 166–167. Plate 1 Plate 2 Plate 3 Plate 4 Plate 5 Plate 6 Plate 7 Plate 8 Plate 9 Plate 10 Plate Plate Plate Plate Plate Plate Plate
11 12 13 14 15 16 17
Plate 18 Plate 19 Plate 20
New World cuckoos Crotophaga, Guira,Tapera, Dromococcyx and Morococcyx New World Geococcyx and Neomorphus Coucals Centropus milo, ateralbus, menbeki, chalybeus, unirufus, celebensis, melanops, steerii and rectunguis Coucals Centropus nigrorufus, sinensis, chlororhynchos, phasianinus (including nigricans and spilopterus) and bernsteini Coucals Centropus toulou, violaceus, goliath, bengalensis, viridis, grillii African coucals Centropus leucogaster, anselli, monachus, cupreicaudus, senegalensis and superciliosus Old World ground-cuckoos Carpococcyx and couas Coua Old World malkohas Ceuthmochares, Rhinortha, Taccocua, Zanclostomus, Rhamphococcyx, Dasylophus and Phaenicophaeus New World cuckoos Coccycua, Piaya and Coccyzus (including Saurothera and Hyetornis) Old World brood-parasitic genera Pachycoccyx, Microdynamis, Eudynamys, Urodynamis and Scythrops Glossy cuckoos in Africa and Asia, genus Chrysococcyx Glossy cuckoos in Australasia, genus Chrysococcyx Brush cuckoos Cacomantis Drongo-cuckoos Surniculus, long-tailed cuckoos Cercococcyx Crested cuckoos Clamator, hawk-cuckoos Hierococcyx Cuckoos Cuculus Eggs of brood-parasitic cuckoos and their hosts in Australia and southern Africa. Brood parasitism in cuckoos. Eggs of Village Weaver Ploceus cucullatus Mouth patterns of young cuckoos
Abbreviations AM AMNH ANSP BMNH BPBM BWYO BYU CAS CM CMNH CU CUM DM DMNH FLMNH FMNH IRSNB JFBM KMMA KU LNS LSU MCNB MCZ MHNLS MMZ MNHN MNM MSNG MSNM MSU MVZ MZB MZUS NMGL NMK NMP NMW NSA
Auckland Museum, Auckland, New Zealand American Museum of Natural History, New York Academy of Natural Sciences, Philadelphia British Museum of Natural History (Natural History Museum),Tring, UK Bernice P. Bishop Museum, Honolulu National Museums of Zimbabwe, Bulawayo Museum of Natural History, Brigham Young University, Hawaii Campus, Laie, Hawaii Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing Carnegie Museum, Pittsburgh Cincinnati Museum of Natural History, Cincinnati Cornell University, Ithaca Cambridge University Museum, Cambridge Durban Museum, Durban Delaware Museum of Natural History, Greenville Florida State Museum of Natural History, Gainesville Field Museum of Natural History, Chicago Institut Royal des Sciences Naturales de Belgique, Brussels James Ford Bell Museum of Natural History, University of Minnesota Koninklijk Museum voor Midden Afrika,Tervuren University of Kansas Museum of Natural History, Lawrence Library of Natural Sounds, Cornell University, Ithaca, New York Museum of Zoology, Louisiana State University, Baton Rouge Museu de Cièncias Naturals de la Ciutadella, Barcelona Museum of Comparative Zoology, Cambridge, MA Sociedad de Ciencias Naturales La Salle (Fondacion La Salle), Caracas Moscow Museum of Zoology, Moscow Muséum National d’Histoire Naturelle, Paris Malawi National Museum, Blantyre Museo Civico di Storia Naturale “Giacomo Doria”, Genoa Museo Civico di Storia Naturale, Società Italiana di Scienze Naturale, Milan Michigan State University Museum, East Lansing Museum of Vertebrate Zoology, University of California, Berkeley Museum Zoologicum Bogoriense, Cibinong nr Bogor Museo Zoologico Universitario “La Specola”, Florence National Museums and Galleries (Merseyside Museums), Liverpool National Museum of Kenya, Nairobi National Museum of the Philippines, Manila Naturhistorisches Museum Wien,Vienna British Library National Sound Archive, London
xvi Abbreviations NSM OU OSU POC QM RMNH ROM SMF SMNS SMTD SP SRSU TCWC TISTR UCLA UMMZ UNLV UNM USNM UTEP UWBM WAM WFVZ YIO YPM VW ZFMK ZMA ZMB ZMM ZMUC ZRC ZSM F I, Is M NP NSW NT P PN S
National Science Museum,Technopolis, Bangkok University of Oklahoma, Norman Borror Laboratory of Bioacoustics, Ohio State University, Columbus Phelps Ornithological Collection, Caracas,Venezuela Queensland Museum, Brisbane Nationaal Natuurhistorisch Museum, Leiden Royal Ontario Museum,Toronto Forschungsinstitut Senckenberg, Frankfurt Staatliches Museum für Naturkunde in Stuttgart, Stuttgart Staatliches Museum für Tierkunde, Dresden Sabah Parks, Kota Kinabalu Scudday Vertebrate Collection, Sul Ross State University, Alpine,Texas Texas Cooperative Wildlife Collection, College Station Thailand Institute of Scientific and Technical Research, Bangkok Dickey Collection, University of California, Los Angeles University of Michigan Museum of Zoology, Ann Arbor University of Nevada at Las Vegas, Las Vegas (MBM) University of New Mexico Museum of Southwestern Biology, Albuquerque National Museum of Natural History,Washington, D.C. University of Texas at El Paso, El Paso Burke Museum, University of Washington, Seattle Western Australian Museum, Perth Western Foundation of Vertebrate Zoology, Camarillo, California Yamashina Institute of Ornithology, Abiko, Japan Yale Peabody Museum, New Haven Vogelpark Walsrode,Walsrode, Germany Museum Alexander Koenig, Bonn Universiteit van Amsterdam Museum, Amsterdam Zoologische Museum, Humboldt-Universitat, Berlin Zoological Museum of Moscow, Moscow Universitets Zoologiske Museum, Copenhagen National Museum of Singapore (Zoological Reference Collection, National University of Singapore), Singapore Zoologische Staatssammlung München, Munich female island(s) male National Park New South Wales, Australia Northern Territory, Australia wing feather, primary (numbered from innermost outward, P1 the inner primary, P10 the outer primary) Parc National wing feather, secondary (numbered from outermost inward)
Abbreviations xvii T TA TB U WA
tail feather, rectrix (numbered from the inner pair outward,T1 the inner rectrix,T5 the outer rectrix) ambient temperature, air temperature body temperature unsexed Western Australia
This page intentionally left blank
Plan of the book
The book is a comprehensive survey of the biology of cuckoos, with descriptions of the life history and systematic status of the 141 cuckoo species. Part I gives general accounts of cuckoo biology, behavior, cooperative breeding and brood parasitism, and it develops ideas about the relationships among the species and major lineages of cuckoos, based on song, morphology and molecular genetics. In the general chapters the cuckoos are mentioned by common name or scientific name, and sometimes by both names. In part I the text, tables and graphs summarize the details of life history and comparative morphology of the cuckoos. Part II consists of species accounts of each cuckoo species, with details about plumage, size, geographic variation, behavior and breeding biology, depending on the information available.The details and references for the general chapters in Part I are in the species accounts in Part II. Recent field observations on the behavior of these birds and phylogenetic studies on cuckoo evolution, allow a synthesis of ideas about the evolution of parental behavior and adaptations for competition, cooperation and brood parasitism in these remarkable birds. The species were determined by the morphological distinctiveness of regional populations and by their songs when these were available on tape recordings. Each cuckoo species that has been studied and is well known has a characteristic song.The songs provide an objective criterion to assess the status of species: if cuckoos have the same song they are conspecific, and if the songs differ, the cuckoos are not of the same species. Female birds choose their mates on the basis of song. Females are attracted to songs of their own species and not to songs of other
species. For these reasons bird songs are a major clue to the nature and limits of biological species (Payne 1986, Alström and Ranft 2003). Another criterion used to determine species status is the fact that birds living in the same area and not interbreeding are distinct species. So song is used mainly to compare birds living in different areas, such as in continental Asia and on islands. In a few cases the results of molecular genetics were used to refine ideas about the nature and limits of cuckoo species. The scientific and common names of most birds in the text are the names in Sibley and Monroe (1990), a comprehensive recent and referenced systematic revision of birds on a worldwide scale.Where the names in that source differ from those in standard regional works, as in Japan, the regional names are also included. For cuckoos the names in Sibley and Monroe’s book are used, except where recent evidence of song or molecular genetics, or both, indicates that the species are not the ones those authors suggested. For example, in the hawk-cuckoos Hierococcyx fugax and the geographic forms nisicolor, hyperythrus and pectoralis, there now appear to be four species rather than one ‘Hodgson’s Hawkcuckoo’. In Part 1 the common and scientific names are given together at their first occurrence in the text. Subsequently the common names are used, except in the tables and chapters that discuss systematic details, where the scientific names are used again. For most cuckoo species and subspecies, 20 or more specimens were measured if the series were available in UMMZ, otherwise specimens in other museums were sampled. When possible, the sex of the specimens used was determined when the
xx Plan of the book gonads were examined, and male or female indicated on the label. In a few specimen series it became obvious that the birds had been mis-sexed. Some species are now known to differ in male and female plumage, which was not known when the collector obtained the birds, for instance with Raffles’s Malkoha Rhinortha chlorophaea (Swainson 1838, Shelley 1891). In other species such as coucals Centropus the sexes differ in size. I avoided museum series where mis-sexing of birds was apparent. In some cases the sex had been added after the field label was written. In such cases I usually did not use the specimen, although some may have been labeled appropriately from the collector’s field notes after the field label was written. The publications where each species was first described are listed in the species accounts. Citations of publications where subspecies were described are available elsewhere (Peters 1940, Payne 1997b), and for recently described forms the source is indicated in the species account. Measurements were taken on museum specimens. Wing length was measured with a stop-end mm rule and the wing flattened on the rule. Tail length was taken with a rule from the point of insertion of the central rectrices (tail feathers) on the body to the tip of the central tail feather. The tail could not be measured on some specimens of which the collector had pushed the base of the tail well into the body cavity, as far as 100 mm in the large coucals and malkohas that were collected and prepared by G. Heinrich, as described by Eck (1978). The tail feathers are numbered in the text, T1 being the innermost rectrix,T2 the next, and T5 the outermost rectrix. Bill length was measured with calipers from the skull to the tip of the bill. Tarsus length was measured from the proximal end of the tarsometatarsus to the distal margin of the most distal tarsal scute that was not divided between toes 2, 3 and 4. Specimens were measured for all species and nearly all subspecies known to vary in size, and in others that vary in plumage color or pattern. For cuckoos that I did not measure, I used the measurements given by E. Mayr, E. Stresemann, D. Rogers in Higgins (1999), where these coincided with the measurements of specimens, done by other ornithologists. Bird skins
shrink as they dry, and the wing length of museum specimens is less than that of live birds measured in the field, with a difference of about 2 mm in the Yellow-billed Cuckoo Coccyzus americanus. Measurements are given in terms of maximum, minimum, mean, and ⫾ standard deviation (sd) where sample sizes are larger (n ⫽ 6 or more).Where data are cited from another author, sd is included only when the author included this index of variation. Body weight is the main index of body size in birds. Body weight can change as much as 40% in resident cuckoos from summer to winter (Greater Roadrunner Geococcyx californianus), more than 20% above average for breeding females with a large yolking ovary and oviduct, 70% above average for birds that had large stores of fat before migration, and 40% below average after a long over-water migration (Yellow-billed Cuckoos Coccyzus americanus). Individual birds that are caught and weighed through the year even in a tropical region change their body weight by as much as 16% (Mustached Hawk-cuckoo Hierococcyx vagans).Where specimen labels noted a large amount of premigratory fat, or laying females with enlarged ovaries and oviducts and sometimes an egg in the oviduct, the body weights of these specimens were noted separately. Body weights do not vary in a statistically normal frequency distribution and for this reason sd’s are not included for weights. The wing formula captures some of the diversity in wing shape. Counting the primaries from the innermost outward, the rank of feather length from the bend of the wing to the tip of the folded wing was determined, with the longest primary listed first, followed by the next, and so on. For example, P7 ⬎ 6 ⬎5 indicates that the seventh primary (P7) is longest, then P6 and then P5. Cuckoos with the longest primary number 8 and 9 have pointed wings, and cuckoos with the longest primary number 4 and 5 have rounded wings.The details of the wing formula vary within cuckoo species, but this variation is much less than between groups of closely related species of cuckoos (Stephan 2001a). Plumage colors of specimens in different museums were compared with reference to a standard color guide (Kornerup and Wanscher 1967). Also useful were color photographs, taken with a standard
Plan of the book xxi gray reflectance card placed under the specimens. A Nikon-F3 camera was attached to a ring flash at 0.7 or 1.0 m from the specimen. Photographs taken under these conditions were compared, for birds in different museums. Photographs of birds such as the Little Bronze-cuckoo Chrysococcyx minutillus species complex show the glossy color to be the same across the visual field, except in the center of the body plumage where it appears dark. Glossy cuckoos with bronze gloss are more greenish than in their photographs, and these specimens were either compared directly with each other, or their photographs were compared with other photographs taken in the same conditions. ‘Sources’ indicates the museum collections that were used for species descriptions and, in some cases, the publications used for the appearance of nestlings. Colors of the bare skin on the face, the eye-ring, the iris, the bill and the feet were recorded from photographs and the labels on museum specimens. Where the colors of plumage and the bare parts differed between the sexes and ages, these are described. Subspecies are recognized when populations are nearly exclusive in size, color or other morphological characteristics, in different parts of their geographic range. Geographic variation in birds involves average size differences between birds in different areas, or a continuous variation between over areas. For example, Yellow-billed Cuckoos in western North America are larger on average than birds in eastern North America, but most birds are in the size range that overlaps between the eastern and western birds, and no subspecies are recognized in this case. Banders and collectors who see these birds in migration or in their winter range in South America, cannot know for certain the breeding areas where the birds originated in North America. Although early work with cuckoos involved collecting birds in the field and studying them in the museum, recent work in the field has involved conservation of their populations in nature. Wilson (1993) cites Baba Dioum:“In the end, we will conserve only what we love, we will love only what we understand . . .”. Conservationists are concerned about the birds whose numbers are low, and whose continued existence is threatened by human activity. This concern is expressed through the protection of
their habitats, to preserve the wild birds alive in natural conditions. Even though these biologists favor an agenda for conservation, we make our best estimates of the distinctiveness of bird species, on the basis of their biology rather than their conservation status. Conservationists have sometimes argued that if each population is given the special taxonomic status of a species, this will increase the legal and social protection of the population. There is, however, no evidence that systematic biologists have had a compelling impact on our own population growth, economics, migration, commercial logging or agricultural techniques. It is questionable whether biologists ought to set their scientific standards for a perceived social gain (Slobodkin 2001), such as in naming every population as a species or a subspecies, which practice becomes a political statement rather than a biological description. Even though we look for arguments and means by which to preserve wild birds and their habitats, the long-term outlook for these birds, and for tropical forests in general over the years to come, is not encouraging (Struhsaker 1997, Heaney and Regalado 1998, Oates 1999, Holmes 2000). Morphological descriptions are used to identify birds in the field or in a museum, and these descriptions are presented in the book. In earlier days a systematic revision provided a diagnosis, that is, a summary of characters that differentiate a taxon from related or similar taxa, and genera were recognized and diagnosed when an authority perceived “really trenchant external characters” (Peters 1940:45). In practice, the description of a species became the standard for the diagnosis of a genus (e.g., Cabanis and Heine 1863). Because similar body forms have evolved in different lineages of birds, as molecular genetic studies have shown (e.g., Sibley and Ahlquist 1990, Cibois et al. 1999, 2001, Sorenson and Payne 2001), the book emphasizes description rather than diagnosis. The book takes a new look at the relationships among the cuckoos, using phylogenetic analysis of discrete molecular genetic characters. The genetic characters (that is, the sequences of nucleotide bases in the DNA) determined in the study, can be accessed by computer in Genbank, the international register for comparative genetic data. These
xxii Plan of the book sequences were used to determine the groupings of cuckoo species into clades (lineages or branches of common ancestry) (Hillis et al. 1996). Molecular genetic analysis uses a large number of characters (the four nucleotide bases and their sequences at thousands of sites in the mitochondrial gene).These genetic characters provide a much larger data set than distinct morphological characters have ever allowed. Molecular genetic profiles were determined for each cuckoo species. The evolutionary relationships among cuckoos were estimated from the molecular genetic sequences and computer programs (PAUP*: Swofford 2001; POY, Gladstein and Wheeler 1996) which use parsimony, a principle of the smallest number of evolutionary changes that are necessary to derive the relationships from a common ancestor in a phylogeny. The phylogenetic estimates of relationships among the cuckoos in the molecular genetic results, were similar to the traditional sets of genera and subfamilies of cuckoos as recognized by morphologists and other museum systematists. Where they differed, the genetic phylogeny was taken as the best estimate of common ancestry, and these results are used throughout the book. I examined nearly all specimens from which the genetic samples were taken. A few re-identifications of these cuckoo specimens was a result (Payne and Sorenson 2003). The evolution of social behavior, such as cooperative breeding and brood parasitism, is a question of general significance. Phylogeny is used not only to clarify the evolutionary relationships among cuckoo species, but also to determine which behaviors evolved once or more than once, and the circumstances in the most closely related lineages that may have led to the evolution of these behaviors (Brooks and McLennan 1991, Edwards and Naeem 1993, Ligon 1993, Sorenson and Payne 2001, 2002). That is, cuckoos are a case study of evolutionary history and adaptation to behavioral ecology. Determining their phylogeny is a way to test the course of evolution of brood parasitism from a non-parasitic ancestor. These questions have been
addressed before (Poiani and Elgar 1994, Poiani 1998) using the estimate of cuckoo relationships in Sibley and Ahlquist (1990), yet that estimate was based on a genetic technique that did not use discrete characters, and it did not include all the major groups of cuckoos. The phylogenetic analysis of molecular genetic characters in the present study was designed not only to get a best estimate of relationships among the cuckoos, but also to determine processes in the evolution of social behavior and breeding biology. The arrangement of subfamilies, genera and species follows the phylogenetic convention of listing the basal taxa first, and the recent radiations or “crown” taxa last, in the order of their branching in the evolutionary tree (Wiley et al. 1991). This convention has long been used in some avian groups such as waterfowl, in contrast to recent reviews of cuckoos which first list the familiar cuckoos of Europe.Where the first convention did not apply, as in symmetric branches of the tree, other conventions were used. First, species with little or no geographic variation between populations (subspecies) were listed, before species with greater geographic variation. Second, where no subspecies were involved, the species with the more northern extent of distribution was listed first. Application of the “basal group first” norm caused the New World Cuckoos to be listed before the Old World cuckoos, and within the New World clade, the group-living crotophagine cuckoos are listed first. The order in which birds appear in the list does not necessarily mean that ancestral cuckoos were cooperative-group living birds. Within a species the geographic forms are listed from north to south and from east to west, with no necessary phylogenetic interpretation. Geographic names in the book are mainly those in the Times Atlas of 1993. In Indonesia the historical names of the Moluccas, now Maluku, and the Lesser Sunda islands, now Nusa Tenggara, have been retained, as they are widely used in current regional works on birds (White and Bruce 1986, Coates and Bishop 1997).
PART I General chapters
This page intentionally left blank
1 Introduction to the cuckoos
The parasitic breeding behavior of cuckoos has fascinated people for centuries. The brood-parasitic cuckoos lay their eggs in the nests of other kinds of birds, and never rear their own young ( Johnsgard 1997, Rothstein and Robinson 1998, Davies 2000). The natural history of the Common Cuckoo Cuculus canorus and the Great Spotted Cuckoo Clamator glandarius, the two species that live in Europe where they have been observed for many years, is well known. In Classic times,Aristotle studied the brood-parasitic behavior of Common Cuckoos (Friedmann 1964b,Aristotle 1991), and in Britain Shakespeare referred to cuckoos in his plays. The term “cuckoldry” was often used in the sense of an adulterous affair, and the implications of immorality in a later period led to a censored version of Shakespeare that eliminated the term “cuckold” (Bowdler 1861, Hamilton 1996). Many other species of brood-parasitic cuckoos live in Africa, Asia and Australia and in Central and South America where they have been watched by resident naturalists. Brood-parasitic cuckoos are diverse with 56 species in the Old World and three in the New World. Nevertheless, brood parasitism is only one of several breeding behaviors in this family of birds. A few cuckoos, the anis and the Guira Cuckoo of the New World, are sociable, with several pairs sharing a nest where they lay their eggs and care for the young; these are the cooperative breeders. Their cooperation is balanced by competition, as a female may remove the eggs of other females when she lays her own. In contrast to these birds which have gone to extremes of parental care and social behavior, most species of cuckoos live in solitary pairs and regularly build a nest and raise their own young.
Even these cuckoos occasionally lay their eggs in the nests of others, either a nest one of their own species or a nest of another kind of cuckoo. One cuckoo species is extinct, and eight cuckoo species are threatened or endangered at the global level. The distribution of cuckoos is cosmopolitan, and most species live in the Old World tropics.The variation in social behavior and parental care of cuckoos may be unmatched among the bird families of the world. The cuckoos are the most successful broodparasitic birds. They have the largest number of species, the largest number of host species that rear their young, and worldwide distribution.The cuckoos are one of the five families of birds in which brood parasitism is the only life style for one or more species—the others are two families of songbirds (the Old World finches and the New World cowbirds), the honeyguides, and the ducks. One duck is a dedicated brood parasite; indeed other waterfowl sometimes lay their eggs in the nests of other ducks of the same species or a different species. In each of these other families, an obligatory breeding style of brood parasitism has evolved only once (Sorenson and Payne 2001, 2002). Brood parasitism has originated more than once in cuckoos. Results of molecular analysis in this study indicate that the parasitic lineages of cuckoos are not all each others’ closest relatives. Because brood parasitism has evolved more than once, the cuckoos provide a replicate test of the behavioral context of the course of evolutionary changes when parental care was transformed into brood parasitism. Young cuckoos are altricial. They remain in the nest where they depend on their parents or foster
4 The Cuckoos parents to provide food, and they grow rapidly.The young of nesting cuckoos leave the nest days before they are able to fly, while the young of broodparasitic cuckoos take longer to fledge and are welldeveloped when they leave the nest. Nesting cuckoos in the New World have the shortest incubation periods and the shortest nestling periods of any birds. Even the Old World coucals have a short nestling life, unusual for such large birds.The variable period in which the cuckoos depend upon parental care is closely associated with the life style of nesting and brood parasitism. The mating systems and social organization of cuckoos range from monogamous pairs that stay together in a social bond, to the cooperatively breeding anis and Guira Cuckoo where incubation and nestling care are shared by group members that use a single communal nest to rear their young. Among these birds there is genetic evidence of polygyny and polyandry as well as social monogamy. Cuckoos have a long evolutionary history. Studies in molecular genetics have estimated that cuckoos occurred as a distinct lineage more than 60 million years ago, a lineage as ancient as that of any modern bird (Sibley and Ahlquist 1990). Fossil cuckoos have been known for only a part of this time. These fossil birds are as varied as modern cuckoos, and some appear to have been flightless. Cuckoos occur throughout the world on all habitable continents and on the island areas of southern Asia, and they are an important part of the biological diversity of tropical birds. Much of what is known about cuckoos came from birds collected in the 1800s when they were first discovered by western Europeans. A few cuckoos were described by their collector and discoverer, Stamford Raffles (1781–1826), natural historian, ethnologist, Governor of Java and founder of the trading station that became Singapore (Raffles 1817, 1830). He began his work as a clerk in London and read widely, mastered languages, cultivated friends and gained a position in Penang. Based on his interests and his rewarding discussions with the Viceroy of India, he was able to study the area’s history, culture and wildlife (Raffles 1830, Mearns and Mearns 1998). Raffles was unusual among early collectors for his access to the publishing world. Later collec-
tors visited the same areas and prepared specimens that made their way back to natural history museums, and in some regions resident naturalists were able to observe the details of their behavior and breeding biology. These collectors were employed by governments and private collectors, and most of their specimens were sent to natural history museums in Europe where the species were described and named (e.g. Blyth 1842, Gould 1845b, Cabanis and Heine 1863, Salvadori 1881, Shelley 1891). Linnaeus described more kinds of cuckoos than any other taxonomist, and half of the 22 species that he described are currently recognized as distinct kinds of birds (some others included a second sex), although the specimens from which they were described are no longer in existence. Tommaso Salvadori appears to hold the record for the number of new cuckoos described by a post-Linnaean ornithologist. Museum patrons employed bird collectors who visited Borneo, the Moluccas and New Guinea, and from specimens that made it safely back to Europe, Salvadori described 11 kinds of cuckoos which are now recognized as species and subspecies (Salvadori 1874, 1875, 1876, 1878a,b, 1879, 1881, 1889). He was based at the museum in Turin (Elter 1986,Violani et al. 1997), and his many type specimens in Turin, Genoa, Leiden and other museums rank him highest among his ornithological generation (Payne 1997b). He usually did not designate a single specimen as the holotype of a species, but rather syntypes of a type series, many of which went to other museums as “duplicates”, with some still being discovered in these collections. Salvadori worked with other families of birds as well. He worked for two years at the National Museum in London where he wrote monographs on parrots and pigeons, and he lived in Leiden where many of his type series are located (van den Hoek Ostende et al. 1997). In other museums in Germany, Cabanis and Heine (1863) described nine cuckoos which are now recognized as species and subspecies, and they described several cuckoo genera as well. A few species of cuckoos are known only from museum collections. The nests of several cuckoos have never been found, and the life histories of these and many other cuckoos are unknown. Many cuckoos live in the Old World tropics where few
Introduction to the cuckoos 5 observations of their life histories have been made in the forests, where these birds are hard to see as the nests are well hidden. Once a nest is found a predator is also likely to find it. Little collecting of anatomical and genetic materials for scientific research has been done in recent years, and the careful field studies that were the fieldmark of resident ornithologists have waned with changes in land ownership. Current research efforts have been limited by nationalistic zeal, and by the difficulty of productive research by unacclimated field biologists in the malarial tropics.The museum specimens that have been collected over the past two centuries are a valuable and unreplaceable resource and are our primary record of biological diversity.We continue to learn new details from these museum specimens, such as geographic variation and the plumages and molts of birds, and we can now retrieve genetic information from feathers or skins of these specimens. Field studies on behavior and recordings of the songs of cuckoos are much needed to understand these birds in natural conditions, and great opportunities remain to discover the life styles and the changing distribution of birds such as the cuckoos.
What are the cuckoos? Cuckoos are zygodactyl birds with the inner and outer toes directed backward and the other two toes directed forward. The bill is usually slender and slightly arched.The plumage of most cuckoos is soft and lax. The body form varies among species with their systematic relationships, body size and life style. Most arboreal cuckoos have a slender body and long tail, whereas terrestrial cuckoos are heavybodied and have long tarsi for their size (weight). The nostrils are round in many cuckoos, but slit-like in the coucals, in the crested cuckoos Clamator and Thick-billed Cuckoo Pachycoccyx audeberti, and to a lesser extent in Long-tailed Cuckoo Urodynamis taitensis, Common Koel Eudynamys scolopacea and Dwarf Koel Microdynamis parva, and slit-like in some malkohas also. Many cuckoos have long eye-lashes. The bill has no cere; the tarsi are scutellate and often unfeathered. The base of the tail has a naked and bilobed oil gland.
Cuckoos have a wing with 10 primaries and 9 to 13 secondaries (9 in several malkohas, in the large Caribbean species of Coccyzus (“Hyetornis”and “Saurothera” ), and in some squirrel cuckoos Piaya; 9 or 10 in Cuculus cuckoos; 10 in hawk-cuckoos Hierococcyx,Thick-billed Cuckoo Pachycoccyx,African Crested Cuckoo Clamator levaillantii and in some coucals; 11 in koels Microdynamis and Eudynamys, in some couas and coucals and in the Great Spotted Cuckoo Clamator glandarius); 12 in some other coucals, and 12 or 13 in the Channel-billed Cuckoo Scythrops novaehollandiae (Stephan 2001a).The alula is small in most cuckoos but large in the New World ground-cuckoos Neomorphus and Carpococcyx, and in the brood-parasitic American Striped Cuckoo Tapera naevia. In the last two cuckoos the large alulae are extended when the wings are spread in display.The wing is eutaxic.The pattern of wing molt is peculiar to cuckoos, where a wave of molt jumps over the neighboring old feathers. The odd-numbered primaries first drop and grow, followed by the evennumbered primaries. Cuckoos are capable of flight, varying from the swift and direct flight of the longwinged, long-distance migrant Common Cuckoo Cuculus canorus and Black-billed Cuckoo Coccyzus erythropthalmus of northern temperate regions, to the gliding flight of short-winged tropical forest-living malkohas and the slow awkward flight of anis, couas and coucals. The tail usually has 10 rectrices, though only 8 in anis Crotophaga and Guira Cuckoo Guira guira. The tail of some cuckoos is shorter than the wing, particularly that of the glossy cuckoos Chrysococcyx. The tail of other cuckoos is one and a half times the length of the wing, as in the arboreal squirrel cuckoos Piaya cayana and P. melanogaster, the yellowbills Ceuthmochares and several Asian malkohas, and the terrestrial ground-cuckoos Geococcyx and Neomorphus (Stephan 2001b). In North and Central America where all cuckoos have long tails, the area of the tail is larger in cuckoos than in any other family of bird of comparable body size (Hartman 1961). In many cuckoos the tail is strongly graduated, with the central feathers longest and the outer feathers short, and the steps marked by the conspicuous white tips of the tail feathers. In others the tail is rounded, square, or even forked, with the central
6 The Cuckoos feathers shorter than the outer feathers, especially in the Fork-tailed Drongo-cuckoo Surniculus dicruroides and Moluccan Drongo-cuckoo S. musschenbroeki. Cuckoos span a wide range in body size, with most species 16–70 cm in overall length.They vary in mass from 17 g with the smallest, Little Bronzecuckoo of Australasia, to 400 g with Giant Coua Coua gigas of Madagascar, and 700 g with the largest broodparasitic bird, Channel-billed Cuckoo Scythrops novaehollandiae of Australia (the next largest brood parasite is Black-headed Duck Heteronetta atricapilla at 513–565 g, Carboneras 1992). The largest nesting cuckoos are coucals in the New Guinea region, where Greater Black Coucal Centropus menbeki and Violaceous Coucal C. violaceus are more than 500 g, Goliath Coucal C. goliath are over 600 g, and Buffheaded Coucal C. milo are as large as 770 g.
The major groups of cuckoos The major groups of cuckoos include two groups with a common ancestry in the New World, two groups in the Old World, and one group that occurs in both regions. In the past, some of these groups have been called families, and others have only recently been recognized as lineages with a common evolutionary history, especially the Cuculinae, which include both New World and Old World cuckoos, and both nesting species and brood-parasitic species.
1. Crotophaginae The crotophagines are groupliving cuckoos and all cuckoos with this life style live in the New World.They have robust legs and a long tail, streaked brown plumage in the South American Guira Cuckoo Guira guira and black plumage and a deep compressed bill in the three ani species Crotophaga. Living in aggressive and noisy social groups, several pairs defend a common territory and share a joint communal nest where two or more females lay their eggs (in anis, some nests may be of single females) and the adults all rear their common young together as cooperative breeders. The nest is flat or a shallow bowl, built in a tree.The nestling mouth is pink with white marks on the palate and tongue. Anis often have a pungent odor, noticed when birds are held in the hand or when they are at their night roost. The social or adaptive
significance of the smell is unknown. The crotophagines have large and unique anal glands, but whether these produce chemical deterrents to predators or chemical signals to social partners or are accessory reproductive structures is unknown (Quay 1967).The ridge on the bill is shaped by an underlying ridge in the nasomaxillary skeleton, especially in Greater Ani Crotophaga major.Awkward in movements with the wings and tail seemingly disconnected from the body, anis are unlike the graceful arboreal cuculine cuckoos.Anis are slow and clumsy as they flutter and clamber through low bushes and weeds, where their flopping wings and waving tails flush out insects in dense vegetation; Guira Cuckoos fly like kites in the wind.
2. Neomorphinae Ground-cuckoos of the New World have short wings, long legs and a long tail. They include a dry scrub-forest terrestrial cuckoo of Central America (Lesser Ground-cuckoo Morococcyx erythropygus), lizard-catching roadrunners (Geococcyx) of the semi-arid regions of North America, and large South American ground-cuckoos Neomorphus that follow ant swarms in the tropical forests and eat the insects that escape the marauding ants. Roadrunners run across the ground at speeds of up to 30 km/hr in chase of their lizard and grasshopper prey, the birds holding their heads and tails level with the ground and swinging their tails like rudders. They often course along roads, paths and dry stream beds, and walk and run on their daily rounds for food and to patrol their territories. These ground-cuckoos can fly, though when they survey their area from an elevated perch they stay within a hop and a flap of the ground. The nesting ground-cuckoos build a nest and rear their own young nestlings which have conspicuous colored spots inside their mouths. The ground-cuckoos also include three species that are brood-parasitic (two species of Dromococcyx, both shy and secretive, and the American Striped Cuckoo Tapera naevia), and are forest dwellers.They parasitize several species of passerine hosts that breed in covered or domed nests, and occasional other hosts that breed in open nests. 3. Centropodinae Coucals are large groundforaging birds with long stout feet, a long straight
Introduction to the cuckoos 7 claw on the inner hind toe in most species (the claw is the “foot spur” of the genus Centropus), short rounded wings and a long broad tail. The plumage is black, rufous brown, or white, or a combination of these colors; the plumage is shaggy and in many species the neck and breast have spiny hackles. Coucals live in the Old World, mainly in the tropics from Africa and Asia to Australia, New Guinea and the Solomon Islands, and on many islands in Wallacea and the Papuan region. Coucals live in forest, swamp and marsh habitat, and spend most of their time on the ground, and in dense marshes they are most often seen in their slow and awkward flight. Most coucals build large globular or domed nests of grass and leaves with a side entrance. Most make deep resonant cooing calls, some species in a “water-bubbling” pattern which recalls the gurgling sound of water as it rushes from a narrow-necked bottle, and some species call in duets. Nestling coucals have an odd set of stiff natal down (trichoptiles) and as the body feathers grow these hair-like structures are attached to the tips of growing feathers, then fall off when the birds fledge; and they have conspicuous raised colored spots on the palate.Adult coucals have a pheasant-like body form with long, robust legs and a long tail, coarse plumage with stiff hackles, and a bronchial syrinx. Males of some coucals have a single testis while others have two testes; the number can vary between one and two within a species and a local population (Mayr 1937, Mayr and Rand 1937, Rand 1942a).
4. Couinae These are large colorful groundcuckoos of Madagascar and southeast Asia and have long tarsi. Ground-cuckoos Carpococcyx of tropical forests in Asia have plumages of dove-like greens and blues, bright bare skin around the face and long eye lashes, and they build flat platform nests. Couas Coua are large cuckoos in Madagascar. They have soft and lax plumage with dove-like colors of pastel pinks, purples and peach (blue in the Blue Coua Coua caerulea), a long tail and large feet, colorful bare areas of skin around the eye, and long eye-lashes. Most are terrestrial. The arboreal Blue Coua has long legs like the terrestrial couas and like them it walks, but in the trees.The Red-capped Coua Coua ruficeps is mainly terrestrial and walks on the ground,
and along branches when it is in a tree (Berger 1960). One species of coua, a snail-eating specialist on Ile Sainte Marie northeast of Madagascar, was last seen around 1835. This is the only cuckoo species known to have become extinct in the past two centuries. Nestling couas and Asian groundcuckoos lack natal down, and the palate and tongue have conspicuous patterns of raised white or blue spots that contrast with the red mouth lining and may be a signal to their parents during parental care.
5. Cuculinae These include the long-tailed arboreal nesting cuckoos of the Old World and New World.The Old World nesting birds in this group are known as the malkohas and are now grouped into six genera in Asia: Rhinortha, Taccocua, Zanclostomus, Phaenicophaeus, Dasylophus and Rhamphococcyx, and a seventh, Ceuthmochares, is found in Africa.“Malkoha” is a Sinhalese name in Sri Lanka (Ceylon) for the Red-faced Malkoha Phaenicophaeus pyrrhocephalus. It has been widely used for other species in the Oriental Region (Levaillant 1806, Raffles 1822, Jerdon 1862) and as a generic name Malcoha Schinz 1821. Malkohas have strong, unfeathered tarsi, short rounded wings, and long graduated tails tipped with bold spots and bars. Malkohas are skulking arboreal cuckoos of forests and thickets. Many have brightly colored bare skin around the eye and face, and the bill is large, often arched and brightly colored. The German term for the birds, “Buntschnabelkuckucken,” translates as the descriptive “colorfulbilled cuckoos.” The wing feathers often have wide vanes and the body feathers have stiff, shiny shafts in a color that contrasts with the rest of the feather. Malkohas build shallow nests, lay chalky white eggs and rear their own young. The malkohas are brightly-colored in plumage, with swollen and brightly colored bills, short wings and long tails. All are arboreal except for Sirkeer Malkoha Taccocua leschenaultii which is terrestrial. A cultural awareness of cuckoos as brood parasites in Europe caused some ornithologists to guess that the other cuckoos were also brood parasites, and Newton (1896) suggested that malkohas were brood-parasitic, but field ornithologists in India and the Malay Peninsula, Borneo and Sulawesi had by that time observed adult malkohas at their own nests. Little is known
8 The Cuckoos about the details of nesting such as the incubation period, nestling period and parental behavior in these birds. The brood-parasitic Old World crested cuckoos Clamator appear to be closely related to the malkohas. Several cuckoos of the New World are the ecological counterparts of malkohas and are closely related to them. Most are arboreal insect-eaters and have long tails. The coccyzine cuckoos including Coccyzus have long wings, and several species are long-distance migrants between continental North and South America, or between temperate South America where they breed and tropical South America where they winter. Others are large-bodied cuckoos that live on islands in the Caribbean and feed on lizards. The New World cuckoos build saucer-shaped nests, lay white or blue eggs, and rear their own young. The young have raised papillae inside the mouth; the color of the papillae contrasts with the palate. Cuculines also include the brood-parasitic cuckoos of the Old World, the tribe Cuculini. Many are migratory with long, narrow, pointed wings, long tails, and short legs with the tarsus feathered at the base. The tail is often graduated with the central feathers longer than the others. As noted by Aristotle, Common Cuckoos Cuculus canorus look like hawks (notably Merlin Falco
columbarius) in plumage, shape and flight; and now we know the hawk-cuckoos Hierococcyx have rounded wings like bird-hawks (Accipiter). Most brood-parasitic cuckoos are dull in plumage, and their cryptic appearance may help them to avoid detection by their hosts (Payne 1967). The parasitic glossy cuckoos Chrysococcyx of Africa and Australasia, however, are conspicuous in their colorful plumage. They are small and at first glance could pass for insect-eating songbirds, and sometimes they even feed in mixed-species flocks with songbirds. Old World brood-parasitic cuckoos lay their eggs in the nests of many passerine host species. Their eggs vary from blue and green to chocolate brown to white, spotted or unspotted, and some species of Old World brood-parasitic cuckoos have more than one kind of egg marked by different colors and patterns. The nestlings are naked when they hatch (young Shining Bronzecuckoos Chrysococcyx lucidus and Little Bronzecuckoos have sparse natal down). Inside the mouth the young lacks visual effects except for a healthy color of red, orange or yellow.The young of one brood-parasite, African Thick-billed Cuckoo, however, have a bright orange palate with contrasting pale spots, and nestling Rufous Hawk-cuckoo Heirococcyx hyperythrus have a palate of yellow and pink.
2 Distribution, habitats and conservation status
Distribution Cuckoos occur around the world in tropical and temperate regions. More species live in the Old World (n ⫽ 109) than in the New World (n ⫽ 32). The northernmost cuckoos (Common Cuckoo Cuculus canorus, Oriental Cuckoo C. optatus, Indian Cuckoo C. micropterus,Asian Lesser Cuckoo C. poliocephalus) occur in northern Europe and Russia in summer.They are migrant brood-parasites that lay in the nests of migrant Palearctic songbirds and then winter in the tropics, sometimes crossing the equator and even passing over the Indian Ocean from Asia to Africa. In the New World the two species (Yellowbilled Cuckoo, Black-billed Cuckoo Coccyzus erythropthalmus) that breed in the United States and Canada are mainly warm-weather birds that spend most of the year in the New World tropics. No cuckoo species occurs regularly and breeds in both the Old World and the New World, although vagrants from northeastern Asia (Common Cuckoo and Oriental Cuckoo) turn up in the Alaskan archipelago and northern Alaska in migration season, and vagrant Black-billed Cuckoos and Yellow-billed Cuckoos from northeastern North America show up in many years in Europe from Iceland to Italy. Cuckoos are widespread as breeding birds on islands, especially in the Indonesian archipelago and the New Guinea region. Migrant cuckoos occur on these islands in winter, mainly species from the northern hemisphere; Australian cuckoos also live on the islands during the austral winter. Cuckoos are not as likely to turn up on oceanic islands as are fruit-eating pigeons and doves, nectar-feeding white-eyes or the rails, yet migrant Oriental
Cuckoos from northern Asia occur as far from their breeding grounds as Palau in the western Pacific and Australia in the Southern Ocean. Perhaps the most widely-traveled species is Long-tailed Cuckoo Urodynamis taitensis which migrates from its breeding area in New Zealand to winter on islands in Melanesia, Micronesia and Polynesia across a wide area of the tropical Pacific. Three species (Common Cuckoo, Asian Lesser Cuckoo, Jacobin Cuckoo Clamator jacobinus) migrate from Asia to Africa for the non-breeding season, and some birds appear during migration season on islands in the Indian Ocean. Cuckoos are unusual birds in this India-Africa migration pattern. All major clades of cuckoos occur in South America, Africa, and southern Asia through to Australia.The biogeography of cuckoos suggests an ancient origin and radiation of cuckoos in the southern region of the world. Geologically this area was the ancient tectonic plate Gondwanaland. Cuckoos in the northern region are all closely related to cuckoos in the southern region and appear to have derived from the southern cuckoos. The ancient diversity of cuckoos that is suggested by the genetic differences between major groups (Sibley and Ahlquist 1990) point to an early origin of the major clades, perhaps before the Eocene and at the time of the breakup of the Gondwana plate; yet there is no independent calibration of this date from dated fossils. The North American Coccyzus (including the large lizard-cuckoos “Saurothera” and “Hyetornis” of the West Indies) is closely related to the Old World malkohas and appears to have been derived from them, perhaps following the dispersal of ancestral nesting cuculine cuckoos by way of
10 The Cuckoos South America.Within the Old World the distributions of certain cuckoo groups suggested to some workers, an initial separation traced to plate tectonic events. Marchant (1972) suggested this origin for the biogeographic separation of Chrysococcyx glossycuckoos of Australasia and Africa, and Cracraft (1988) suggested the same for the Carpococcyx groundcuckoo species in southeast Asia, Borneo and Sumatra. So far there is no evidence that the genetic distances observed between the clades and species of cuckoos correspond with the genetic distances expected from these tectonic events, based on mutation rates and the length of time since the events. The goal of biogeographic models should be to test whether the geological and the genetic times of divergence coincide (Zink et al. 2000).
Habitats Cuckoos are mainly arboreal birds of forest and woodland. Their habitats are varied but include many primary, more or less undisturbed tropical rain forests. Other cuckoos live in secondary forest and some of these have adapted to life in tree plantations, particularly that of cocoa where larger trees provide shade for the cocoa plants.The forests they inhabit range from primary evergreen forests to semi-arid scrub in Madagascar. Cuckoos often occur in the canopy and on dense vines and rattan in Asia, and the ground cuckoos are mainly forest birds. A few cuckoos live in coastal mangroves (Mangrove Cuckoo Coccyzus minor, some malkohas and coucals in southern Asia, and some broodparasitic cuckoos in Australasia). Cuckoos also live in open brushy country in Australia and the plateau country of Africa, in the southwestern United States, Mexico and the drier parts of Central America, and in southern South America. The diversity of cuckoo behavior is highest in the New World tropics. Here, many cuckoo species nest as pairs and rear their own young, others are cooperative breeders that care for the young of others in their social group, and three are brood parasites which do not rear their own young. Cuckoos are especially numerous and diverse in Amazonian Brazil. Near Manaus there are seven species of cuckoos, only one a brood parasite, one a cooperative breeder, and
others solitary birds, or ones that join mixed-feeding flocks but nest in pairs away from other birds (CohnHaft et al. 1997). In one of the largest forest reserves in the world,Tapajós National Park, with 448 species of birds, seven are cuckoos (Oren and Parker 1997); in Jaú NP, with 445 species, nine are cuckoos (Borges et al. 2001); on the Middle Rio Jiparaná, Rondônia, with 459 species, 12 are cuckoos; and in the Alta Floresta region in extreme northern Mato Grosso, with 474 species, nine are cuckoos including a nonbreeding austral migrant (Zimmer et al. 1997). In all these areas most cuckoos are of the solitary nesting species. The Atlantic coastal forests in Brazil have as many as ten cuckoos, although one, a subspecies of ground-cuckoo, may now be extinct in that region (Parker and Goerck 1997). The number of cuckoo species is highest in forests of the Old World tropics. In southern Asia at a local scale of a 2 km2 area in the Malay Peninsula, Khaso Nor Chuchi has 247 breeding bird species with 29 resident cuckoos (Round and Treesucon 1997), the Pasoh Forest Reserve has 188 species of birds and the Kerau Wildlife Reserve at Kuala Lompat has 195 species, each site within the geographic range of 21 cuckoo species (Wells 1999).The Tekam Forest Reserve has 225 species with 12 resident cuckoo species, ( Johns 1989). In the Vu Quang Nature Reserve,Vietnam, there are 220 resident bird species with 9 cuckoos, and in 14 other sites in Vietnam there are 16 cuckoo species (Eames et al. 2001). On a larger scale, the Malay Peninsula has 686 species with 22 cuckoos that are unlikely to breed there (Wells 1999) and Sabah has 339 resident species with 21 cuckoos (Sheldon et al. 2001). Island areas are less species-rich both in birds on the whole, and in cuckoos. In the Lesser Sunda Islands, 251 species are known on Flores, nine of them cuckoos (Verhoeye and Holmes 1998); and 182 species on Sumba, six being cuckoos (Linsley et al. 1998). In Central Africa, as many as 16 resident species of cuckoos live together in forests and on forest edges. Four are coucals Centropus species, one is a malkoha, Chattering Yellowbill Ceuthmochares aereus, and the others are brood parasites that lay in nests of forest passerines. In Cameroon in Lobéké FR where 305 species of birds are known there are 13 cuckoos, 10 of them in forest habitat; and Mt. Kupe has 324 resident
Distribution, habitats and conservation status 11 species with 10 cuckoos in Congo-Brazzaville Nouabalé-Ndoki has 273 species with 12 cuckoos, Odzala NP has 435 species with 17 cuckoos, and the Kouilou basin has 425 species with 16 cuckoos (Dowsett and Dowsett-Lemaire 1997, DowsettLemaire and Dowsett 2000, Bowden 2001), in the Central African Republic Dzanga-Sangha has 360 species with 11 cuckoos (Green and Carroll 1991, P. Beresford in litt., AMNH) and in Uganda Kibale Forest has 410 species with 13 cuckoos (Struhsaker 1997). In each of these Old World areas, more than half the cuckoo species are brood-parasitic. The difference in the number of cuckoo species between the New World and Old World lies mainly in the greater number of brood parasites in the Old World, and this is a result of different evolutionary histories, rather than any obvious ecological difference between the two regions. Cuckoos live not only in the warm tropics but in cool and wet conditions as well, in forests and in more open habitats. When their plumage becomes wet, the cuckoos use the sun to dry and these birds are best seen when they expose themselves high on a perch in the early morning or after a shower, spreading their wings and tail and lifting their back feathers, exposing the skin to the sun. Sunning behavior is well known in coucals and glossy parasitic cuckoos in the Old World, and in Coccyzus cuckoos, roadrunners Geococcyx californianus and anis Crotophaga and Guira in the New World. Ani plumage becomes soaked as the birds forage in wet grass and herbaceous vegetation. Guira Cuckoos Guira guira have heavily pigmented black skin between the dorsal feather tracts, and in the morning on cold days the birds droop their wings, turn their back and expose the black skin toward the sun to dry the plumage and warm the body. Anis adapt to cool weather and to poor food conditions by becoming semi-torpid; they drop their body temperature a few degrees at night, and when their body temperature drops the anis can still fly after two days of fasting (Warren 1960). A few cuckoos live in seasonally hot, arid and semi-arid habitats. These include roadrunners in the New World, a few couas Coua in Madagascar, and several brood parasitic cuckoos in Australia.
While the dry-country brood parasites escape the extreme conditions when they migrate, the nesting cuckoos typically live in the deserts as residents. Cuckoos have adapted well to human changes in habitats in some areas. In the New World tropics, anis Crotophaga have spread with forest clearings. In southeast Asia the koels Eudynamys scolopacea have spread to new areas and new host species that do well in towns and cities. In Australia the extensive plantings of gardens and flowering trees have attracted nectar-feeding birds. In southeastern Australia, Common Koels and Channel-billed Cuckoos have increased in numbers in the past ten to twenty years along with their host species, and in southwestern Western Australia Pallid Cuckoo Cacomantis pallidus are common where the large honeyeaters especially Red Wattlebird Anthochaera carunculata live in parks and gardens. Certain ground-living cuckoos including Gabon Coucal Centropus anselli, Red-billed Ground-cuckoo Carpococcyx renauldi and Red-capped Coua Coua ruficeps are often seen when they visit human areas and feed on camp refuse such as rice and noodles and on the rich insect life downstream from camp latrines.
Conservation status Although cuckoos are at some risk wherever their habitat is shared with humans, most cuckoos are not at immediate risk of extinction for at least another generation of humans. Unless otherwise indicated in the species accounts, the cuckoos are not considered threatened, when judged by the criteria in Collar et al. (1994) and BirdLife International (2001). The cuckoos most at risk are forest cuckoos. Tropical evergreen forests, the unique achievement of millions of years of nature, are being destroyed by logging for widescale economic consumption, and human populations are large and growing and are removing forest to cultivate open lands. As their forests are logged, many cuckoos are unable to adapt to any remaining scrub and secondary forest that might survive. Furthermore, forests once logged are open and vulnerable to fires and encroachment. In the past two decades, fires have burned millions of
12 The Cuckoos hectares of logged forests in Borneo and Sumatra (MacKinnon et al. 1996, Curran et al. 1999, Francis 2001). Global-imaging satellite records of change in humid forests of tropical regions between 1990 and 1997 have determined an annual deforestation rate of 1–4% in southeast Asia, 1–5% in Africa and Madagascar, and 3–4% in the upper Amazon (Achard et al. 2002). In the Old World the cuckoos at risk include the Red-faced Malkoha Phaenicophaeus pyrrhocephalus, Sumatran Ground-Cuckoo Carpococcyx viridis, Black-hooded Coucal Centropus steerii, Javan Coucal C. nigrorufus and Green-billed Coucal C. chlororhynchos. In the New World there are questions about the continued existence of Cocos Cuckoo Coccyzus ferrugineus, Rufous-breasted Cuckoo C. rufigularis and Banded Ground-cuckoo Neomorphus radiolosus (Collar et al. 1994, BirdLife International 2001). Several other species and subspecies are considered near-threatened (Collar et al. 1994), especially birds whose distributional range is small and limited to islands (Coral-billed Ground-cuckoo Carpococcyx renauldi,Verreaux’s Coua Coua verreauxi, Kai Islands race of Pheasant-coucal Centropus phasianinus spilopterus, Biak Coucal C. chalybeus, Short-toed Coucal C. rectunguis, Rufous Coucal C. unirufus and Scaled Ground-cuckoo Neomorphus geoffroyi squamiger. Although no brood-parasitic cuckoos appear on the lists of threatened and endangered birds, the loss of forests will have an impact on these birds, as well as on their host species. Most critically, the lowland and montane forests in the Malesian tropics of Malaysia, Indonesia and the Philippines are at risk, and with loss of forests these areas and the world are in danger of losing their cuckoos and the rest of their birds (Whitten et al. 1987, 1996, Collins et al. 1991, Sayer et al. 1992, Heaney and Regalado 1998, Kennedy et al. 2000, BirdLife International 2001). At least one brood-parasitic cuckoo should be added to the list of species at risk, Philippine Drongo-cuckoo Surniculus velutinus. Formerly regarded as a subspecies of a single species of drongo-cuckoo, the drongo-cuckoos are now known as four distinct species on the basis of differences in songs and in their plumage. More than 90% of forest habitat in the Philippines has been lost in recent years.
Preservation of their forest habitats is the only way to maintain the numbers and diversity of birds: necessary but perhaps not sufficient if hunting and trapping of birds continue. In addition to forest cuckoos, the cuckoos of open woodlands have seriously decreased in numbers. In Brazil, in the interior part of São Paulo State the number of species reported by earlier observers but no longer seen, is much greater than the number of species that have disappeared in the humid coastal areas, where the remaining forests are protected by law. Even there, birds are hunted and captured for the cage bird trade, and habitats of bamboo and coastal flats are developed for human housing. In the mesic and drier inland region of São Paulo, the open woodland savannas (“cerrado”) have been destroyed for large ranches, replaced by sugar cane for alcohol production, and coffee and oranges for export crops, and now the small dry forest and savanna fragments cover less than 1% of their original area. In inland regions of Brazil, Pearl-breasted Cuckoo Coccyzus euleri have little remnant habitat and their numbers are much reduced (Willis and Oniki 1992). In North America, Greater Roadrunners were controlled with a federal or state bounty on their heads as predators of quail, early in the twentieth century. In fact, these cuckoos hardly ever take quail, whereas they often take crop and household pests. Even though roadrunners have a traditional cultural status in the North American southwest (Dobie 1939), they are often shot as targets and trophies. Large ground-cuckoos undergo local extinction when their small forest patches support only a few birds, and the destruction of nearby habitats results in the loss of opportunity for birds in neighboring areas to disperse into the remnant forests. Local extinction has been documented on Barro Colorado Island, Panama, a forested hilltop that between 1912 and 1914 was isolated from the mainland forest when the Chagres River was dammed to form the Panama Canal.The area of the island is 1564 hectares, or six square miles.The site was designated a biological reserve in 1923 and has been the focus of long-term behavioral and ecological studies of birds and other tropical life (Eisenmann 1952, Willis 1979, Leigh 1999). When
Distribution, habitats and conservation status 13 the nearest populations of resident sedentary birds were lost, as forest habitats were cut around Gatun Lake, no source populations remained to repopulate the island. Rufous-Vented Ground-cuckoo Neomorphus geoffroyi was the first bird to become extinct on the island; it was last seen in 1935. The brood-parasitic Pheasant Cuckoo Dromococcyx phasianellus, was the second cuckoo lost; it was last seen on the island in 1971 as its shrub habitat was overgrown by forest (Willis and Eisenmann 1979). Of special interest and concern is Sumatran Ground-cuckoo Carpococcyx viridis, a fruit-eating bird that had not been seen by western ornithologists since 1916, but was rediscovered when one was captured in a live trap, photographed and released in 1997; another one was seen at another site in 2000 (Zetra et al. 2002). Sumatran Ground-cuckoo may persist in dipterocarp forests, where vulnerability to snaring and hunting, the widespread failure of these forests to fruit in certain years ( Janzen 1974, Whitten et al. 1987), and the loss and fragmentation of forests in response to logging and burning which restrict the dispersal of large vertebrates (Curran et al. 1999, Curran and Leighton 2000), all threaten the survival of large forest animals including the Sumatran Ground-cuckoo. The only cuckoo that is known to have become extinct as a species in historical times is Delalande’s or Snail-eating Coua Coua delalandei, which disappeared from Madagascar around 1835 during a time of deforestation. Hunting may have been involved in its extinction, along with the introduction of rats which depleted the terrestrial snails that were the coucals’ food. In regions where forest habitats have been destroyed, the species that do well in disturbed habitats have become more common and the forest species have become rare.This has led to some concern that replacement of the rare species is a result of competitive exclusion by the more common species. For example, the rare Black-hooded Coucal Centropus steerii and the more widespread Philippine Coucal C. viridis live in cut-over former forested lands in Mindanao. Elsewhere in southeast Asia and the Sunda Archipelago the uncommon forest-living Short-toed Coucal C. rectunguis, Javan Coucal C. nigrorufus and Green-billed Coucal
C. chlororhynchos are decreasing and their place taken by the widespread Greater Coucal C. sinensis. Disappearance of these rare coucals results from destruction of their habitat. It is unlikely the rare coucals would recover their numbers if the more common coucals were controlled. Conservation efforts are better applied to the protection of a diversity of habitats that are suitable for these rare coucals (BirdLife International 2001). Humans have used cuckoos for food and traditional medicine, (Payne 1997b). The cultural practice of folk medicine has declined and appears to be disappearing in rural areas, as in the use of the rare Green-billed Coucal in Sri Lanka (Wijesinghe 1999) and anis in the West Indies. Host species populations which the broodparasitic cuckoos parasitize are not a risk to cuckoos and their brood parasitism is not a conservation concern.When their hosts are thin on the ground, their nesting birds may be too few to support the cuckoos, because a population of brood parasites needs a large number of nesting hosts in order to maintain their own numbers from one generation to the next. Certain cuckoo species concentrate on only one or a few host species, and the population numbers of cuckoos are likely to be lower than the numbers of their hosts. Deteriorating habitat conditions for cuckoo hosts would drive the cuckoos into local extinction well before the hosts become threatened or endangered owing to cuckoo parasitism. In this sense the brood-parasitic cuckoos may be indicators of the environmental health of an Old World forest. Cuckoos depend on a healthy insect population for food and survival, and the brood-parasitic cuckoos depend on their hosts finding enough food to rear the cuckoo young. Environmental disturbances that lead to the reduction of hosts also lead to the loss of brood-parasitic cuckoos, and disturbances that reduce the area of wooded habitats and their insects lead to the decrease of other cuckoos as well. Cuckoos are among the first birds to disappear when a habitat is polluted by industrial and chemical waste. Their caterpillar prey accumulate toxins from chemical pollution. In North America, migratory cuckoos that flew into television transmitting towers in the early 1970s had tissues with significant amounts of chlorinated hydrocarbons. Concentrations of pesticide
14 The Cuckoos metabolites in Yellow-billed Cuckoos were higher in autumn than in spring, and were higher in autumn adults than in juveniles, so the time and context suggest that pesticides were acquired on the breeding grounds (Grocki and Johnston 1974). Finally, Greater Roadrunners in North America have disappeared from urban areas and highways as a result of human impact, as well as disturbance and predation from feral and domestic dogs and cats (Emlen 1974). Roadrunners need extensive areas of undisturbed open shrub and grassy habitats with abundant populations of reptile and insect prey, and these are destroyed with the development of agriculture, urban areas, and the fragmentation of expansive tracts of grassland and shrub lands. Few cuckoos are kept in zoos and none have bred in captivity on a large scale that could provide enough birds to reintroduce cuckoos into areas where they have been lost in the wild and where the habitat remains. Cuckoos that have been maintained in captivity where the bright bare colors of their heads and their bright plumage can be well seen by visiting people, include Red-billed Malkoha Zanclostomus javanicus and Chestnut-breasted Malkoha Phaenicophaeus curvirostris. Cuckoos are difficult to breed in captivity
(Pagel 1992), although a few cuckoos, (Great Spotted Cuckoo Clamator glandarius, Common Cuckoo, Guira Cuckoo, Greater Roadrunner and Coral-billed Ground-cuckoo) have bred at zoos, including the National Zoo in Washington, D.C. (Muller 1971) and Vogelpark Walsrode in Germany (Marcodes and Rinke 2000). Captive breeding has been useful for behavioral observations, especially in the Old World ground-cuckoos: behavior and breeding biology are better known through avicultural studies than on the field, where these birds are seldom seen and are nearly unknown (Robiller et al. 1992). Most cuckoos are shy and skulking with humans. The most easily watched in the field are the roadrunners of the southwestern United States and the social group-living Guira Cuckoos and anis in the New World tropics, where these birds are often tame and allow a close approach. Cuckoos are not agricultural pests, and the brood-parasitic cuckoos are not threats to the breeding populations of their hosts. Cuckoos are most interesting to naturalists and biologists who are fascinated with their variety of behavior, the evolution of their sociality, their mating systems and breeding styles which include monogamy, cooperative breeding and brood parasitism.
3 Behavior
Social and parental behavior Cuckoos are solitary, skulking birds, more often heard than seen. Their calls in forests and woodlands are among the most conspicuous and compelling sounds of the tropics. As a group the cuckoos are arboreal and spend their time in trees, although several couas of Madagascar, most coucals in the tropics and some cuckoos in semidesert areas are terrestrial. Many cuckoos live by themselves and call only in the breeding season, while a few kinds of cuckoos live in social groups, leaving their group perhaps only once throughout their lives, when they disperse and join another social group. Cuckoos are mainly diurnal, but both the nesting cuckoos and the brood-parasitic cuckoos call at night along with the nocturnal owls and nightjars. It is in their social and parental behaviors that cuckoos are particularly variable, with monogamous pairs that rear their own young, cooperative breeding birds that rear each others’ young, and brood-parasitic cuckoos that leave their young to be reared in the nests of other species of birds. Many cuckoos rear their own young. Some cuckoos are highly social, living together in permanent social groups where they feed and breed together. Several pairs build a nest and rear their young together in a common nest.These cooperatively breeding cuckoos, the anis and the Guira Cuckoo, live in the New World. The broodparasitic cuckoos, however, have no obvious longterm pair bond. Male and female live apart from each other and come together only to copulate. There is also no family bond between offspring
and their own parents. Females lay their eggs in the nest of another species, the host, and the hosts are foster parents to the young cuckoos. Female cuckoos also remove a host egg to make room for the nestling cuckoo which then removes the others by evicting them from the nest, pushing its own naked body under the eggs and lifting them over the rim of the nest. This behavior ensures that all the parental care of the foster parents will be delivered to the nestling cuckoo.To the host pair the nestling cuckoo means the loss of their own nesting effort. Many cuckoo hosts remove an egg from their nest if it looks unlike their own eggs, and this rejection behavior is the main line of defense against cuckoo parasitism.When the young cuckoo hatches, however, the foster parents accept the cuckoo and rear it at the cost of their own young.This host-parasite association has led to evolutionary battles which each member of the association has won in turn. First the hosts evolve a sensitivity to the cuckoo’s egg in their nest and remove it. Then the cuckoos evolve the ability to match the color and pattern of the host egg (Davies 2000). The nestling cuckoo takes the theme of sibling rivalry to its infanticidal extreme by killing its nestmates. In these broodparasites the rivals, the offspring of the foster parents, are not kin but are competitors for parental care. Cuckoos affect the breeding success of their hosts, both when the female cuckoo removes a host egg from the nest, and when the nestling cuckoo removes the rest of the hosts’ genetic interest by evicting the eggs and nestlings from the nest. Much of our interest in cuckoos and their eggs and behaviors is focused on this brood-parasitic behavior.
16 The Cuckoos
Food and feeding Cuckoos are generalist predators and mainly take large insects. The diet of many cuckoos consists of noxious, brightly colored and hairy forms of caterpillar. These include urticating caterpillars, whose hairs pierce the skin and histamines causing itching and burning, at least when they contact human skin. Cuckoos also take grasshoppers and locusts, many with distasteful “tobacco” juice; other kinds with hard legs and shields. Other cuckoo foods include large non-insect arthropods like millipedes, centipedes, spiders and phalangids, and terrestrial snails and small vertebrates such as tree-frogs.A few cuckoos concentrate on lizards. Roadrunners take many reptiles, and the lizard-cuckoos on Caribbean islands where there are no lizard hawks, feed on lizards. In addition, the brood-parasitic cuckoos take eggs and nestlings from the nests of their hosts, and the coucals take nestling birds when they find them. Old World malkohas and the arboreal New World cuckoos forage by moving through the vines and branches of tropical forests and thickets with hops, twisting the tail for balance like a squirrel, then turning and seizing an insect spotted on a leaf or axil. Most Old World brood-parasitic cuckoos feed in much the same manner, perching and peering in a characteristic posture (Figure 3.1). Cuckoos hunt by ambush as they perch motionless for many minutes and peer about from a perch, then dash or fly to a caterpillar when they sight it on the underside of a leaf or on a tree trunk, grab the insect, and return to their perch to eat it.Their feeding behavior is one of “peer and pounce.” Caterpillars have guts full of indigestible and toxic leaf products, and the cuckoos clean the caterpillars and remove these products. The cuckoo bites off the end and wipes the caterpillar back and forth on a branch until the guts are pressed out, or passes it back and forth through the bill to clean the insides, then swallows the insect. Or else it beats hairy caterpillars against a branch, removing their gut contents and toxins before eating them. These gut removal techniques do not remove the caterpillar hairs. The cuckoo swallows the hairs, which form a felted mat lining in the stomach, and the hairs are regurgitated as a pellet.
Figure 3.1. Fledgling Klaas’s Cuckoo Chrysococcyx klaas, Hans Merensky Nature Reserve,Transvaal.
North American Black-billed and Yellow-billed Cuckoos forage on the tent caterpillars Malacosoma spp. The cuckoos, along with orioles and other birds (60 species are known to feed on these insects, Witter and Kulman 1972), are attracted to wooded areas where the caterpillar tents hang on hawthorns, wild cherries and other rosaceous trees and shrubs.The caterpillars build a communal tent of silk where they retreat between foraging bouts in the tree (Fitzgerald 1995). Although their tent protects the caterpillars, many insectivorous birds pierce the tent and remove the caterpillars. Birds also feed on them as they move along marked foraging tracks. Cuckoos often nest in sites with an abundance of tent caterpillars, M. americanum in spring and M. disstria in autumn. Outbreaks of tent caterpillar in the northern states can defoliate trees each year for up to six years; in the southern states the forests can be defoliated annually for 20 to 30 years (Fitzgerald 1975). The clutch size of Blackbilled Cuckoos varies with the abundance of caterpillars, with large numbers of eggs laid when the
Behavior 17 number of caterpillars is high (Forbush 1927, Sealy 1978). The variation in tent caterpillar abundance may affect the numbers of breeding cuckoos. It is unlikely, however, that cuckoos control the populations of pest caterpillars, although over a few days a cuckoo can take hundreds of caterpillars and clean out a tree of all its caterpillars. Other large insects that appear in outbreaks are also taken, including larvae of gypsy moths Lymantria dyspar ( Jauvin 1996). Caterpillars on economically important trees are more often controlled with the application of chemical pesticides, and bacteria and viruses as biological control agents. The chemical pesticides appear in cuckoo tissues, and from the cuckoo’s point of view it is not a good idea to spray these pesticides in the woods. Coucals take large insects and small vertebrates including snakes, lizards, tree frogs, mice and rats, and small birds.These large cuckoos feed mainly on the ground, often in thick scrub and less commonly in tangles of vines and on the branches of trees. They are generally slow and clumsy in movement but move rapidly when they locate their prey. When hunting grasshoppers and lizards on the ground, they move forward with a slow stalking walk. Then when close, they change to a hop and run, and ambush or chase the prey. Their feeding behavior is one of “flush and rush.” At other times, they tear open bird nests to get the eggs and young, and rip bark from trees to get the lizards and large insects that are concealed underneath the bark. Small birds recognize coucals as predators and they mob the larger coucals. In marshes and swamps, coucals feed partly in the water, where they take frogs, crabs, and aquatic insects, and occasionally they scavenge for dead fish. In seasonally dry habitats, coucals respond to opportunity when fires burn the grass during the dry season. Like foraging Cattle Egrets Egretta ibis, White-browed Coucals Centropus superciliosus approach the smoke and feed at the edge of grass fires, where they take large insects and small mammals that attempt to escape the flames as the fire advances. Other foods include snails, which are rich in protein and in calcium. Senegal Coucals C. senegalensis take large, brightly colored, apparently aposematic bush locusts that give warning displays. They attack and
subdue the locust, then soften it with the bill, working the abdomen and thorax. They then hold the insect underfoot and remove the head and digestive tract and eat the remainder (Goodwin 2001). Anis and Guira Cuckoos are mainly ground feeders. Groove-billed Anis and Guira Cuckoos live in meadows and pastures in dry open habitats, Smooth-billed Anis in denser herbs in wetter habitats, and Greater Anis in wet forest edges. Ani species that live in habitats with larger and wetter leaves have the largest bill: The anis use the bill as a wedge to move through leaves and feed (Willis 1983b), to open the soft wet earth and grab burrowing insects, and to plow through cow dung to get insects (Gosse 1847). The name of the ani genus Crotophaga means tick-eater, a behavior that was more common in the days before chemical pesticides were used in management of livestock.An old German term for anis is “Madenfresser”, eater of ticks (Leverkühn 1894). Groove-billed Anis take grasshoppers and follow cattle much like the icterid cowbirds. Anis also take tuks from the backs of cattle. Anis bite hard-bodied insects repeatedly before they swallow or feed the insects to their young. Smooth-billed Anis sometimes feed on butterflies. In a rapid approach the bird runs to a group of butterflies, lunges, captures one, swallows it, then tries to capture and swallow another, as long as the butterflies remain: Or the bird walks slowly in a crouch towards a single butterfly, then lunges and grabs it. Adult anis are more successful at capturing a large butterfly than are the young birds. Members of an ani group forage near each other, and when they are out of sight of each other in the grass they stay in contact with loud calls. Anis feeding with a cow or horse hop near the front of the mammal and seize insects stirred up in the grass.They catch more insects per minute when they feed with cattle than when they hunt alone, especially in the dry season. Anis in the forest use ant swarms as beaters, catching roaches and other insects as they are driven from the litter by the ants (Sutton 1951, Rand 1953, Smith 1971, Skutch 1983, Willis 1983b, Burger and Gochfeld 2001). Roadrunners feed on the ground. They flush prey as the birds walk with the head low and brush
18 The Cuckoos the grass: The disturbance startles the insects, and when they jump, the roadrunner grabs them. They also flush out insects when they jump up and flap their wings slowly over the ground, then catch the insect in flight or watch it land and pick it from the vegetation.They dart into clumps of vegetation for large insects such as grasshoppers and crickets, spiders as large as tarantulas, and scorpions, and they take vertebrates such as small snakes, mice, small birds and the contents of bird nests.They run down lizards in fast pursuit. Roadrunners leap at flying insects and birds such as swifts that swoop over a dry stream, and they ambush hummingbirds at nectar sites where these visit and feed. They take young bats that fall from the ceilings of caves. In winter they take beetles and grasshoppers, finding insects around the base of rocks.They also take fruits, seeds and scattered grain when insects and reptiles are scarce. Roadrunners eat the sweet seedy fruit of the prickly pear cactus Opuntia, knocking it to the ground and tumbling it to remove the spiny cover: These fruits can make up 10% of a bird’s diet in fruiting season. Following a hand-reared free-living roadrunner through the Texas brush, Sutton (1913, 1915) recorded the food it took in a day: 263 hopping grasshoppers and 73 flying grasshoppers, 17 scorpions, 28 sowbugs, 7 caterpillars, 3 chrysalids, 14 angleworms, 39 moths, 1 butterfly, 14 centipedes, 16 spiders, 2 tarantulas, 3 walking-sticks, 3 small toads, 3 horned lizards, 14 other lizards and a mouse. When roadrunners encounter a rattlesnake, they crouch and circle it, then dart in to grab it behind the head, which they hold in their bill. Then they whip and pound the snake against the ground or stones until it no longer moves. After it is dead they pull the snake into the shade of a shrub and eat it. They also toss and batter other snakes and lizards in this way to kill their prey. Birds are killed and plucked, small mammals are killed by a blow to the base of the skull, and larger prey such as lizards, snakes and ground squirrels are held in the bill, then swung and hit repeatedly against a rock, stick or the ground. The beating kills the prey, separates and crushes the skeleton, compacts the meal and allows the bird to swallow its prey whole. Food processing may take up to 15 minutes. Roadrunners kill scorpions by biting at the tail where the poison gland
and sting are located; this procedure removes the stinger. They swallow lizards and snakes headfirst, avoiding the backwards-pointing spines and scales. They take these reptiles especially in the breeding season when there are young roadrunners to be fed: The pair sometimes cooperates in attacking a snake, circling it and alternating their attacks (Figure 3.2). In the forests of tropical America, groundcuckoos feed at ant swarms, using the ants as beaters to flushout insect prey. Ground-cuckoos are the largest birds in attendance at army-ant swarms and are regular at the swarms along with other forest birds. The cuckoo waits until an ant swarm enters its territory, then follows as the ants pass through the territory and flush out insects with their advance.The cuckoo stands on the ground or perches on a low branch, then runs along the edge of the swarm, snaps up an insect or other forest floor arthropod and runs away, active as it bounds, changes direction or spins: Occasionally it flaps over a vine or gains a higher perch, but extended flight is uncommon. One cuckoo feeds at a time at an ant swarm. When two appear near the swarm the birds either go their separate ways, or they rush at each other with rapid bill-pops, or lower the primaries and spread the tail in aggressive behavior till one bird leaves the site. At other times the ground-cuckoo wanders through the forest, and when it comes to an ant trail it follow the trail until it comes upon the ant swarm. Like a roadrunner, a hand-reared or habituated ground-cuckoo becomes tame enough for an observer to follow on its foraging rounds (Oniki and Willis 1972, Willis and Oniki 1978).
Figure 3.2. Greater Roadrunner pair killing a rattlesnake (after Meinzer 1993).
Behavior 19 A few other cuckoos form a feeding association with ant swarms, or primates and other large mammals, or mixed-species bird flocks. New World ground-cuckoos Neomorphus and Old World ground-cuckoos Carpococcyx follow foraging groups of peccaries and wild pigs, to the extent that these large ground-feeding birds in South America and in Borneo are locally known as “pig birds”. This behavior may have been more common in earlier days when large herds of pigs moved through the forests. Old World coucals sometimes feed in mixedspecies bird flocks. In Madagascar the Blue Coua Coua caerulea follow troops of lemurs as they forage on the forest floor.African yellowbills Ceuthmochares accompany other birds and squirrels, which use each other as beaters.A bird grabs the insects disturbed by the others (Brosset and Erard 1986). Bates (1930: 190) described this behavior: “In its hunt after insects it does not go alone, but follows the squirrels which live in these creepers, or joins itself to other birds, of many kinds, that seek insects, and catches those that flee from the rest; for all insect-catching birds of the trees of the forest find it to their advantage to feed in company.” Yellowbills are seen in 10% of mixed-species flocks in lowland Cameroon (Thomas 1991).Yellow-billed Malkohas Rhamphococcyx calyorhynchus follow Bay Coucals Centropus celebensis through the rattan creepers in Sulawesi, and they also follow troops of primates, Sulawesi macaque Macaca nigra and booted macaque M. ochreata. Redfaced Malkohas Phaenicophaeus pyrrhocephalus sometimes associate with hornbills and other species. Other malkohas that feed in mixed-species flocks include Raffles’s Malkoha Rhinortha chlorophaea. Black-bellied Malkoha P. diardi, Chestnut-bellied Malkoha P. sumatranus and Chestnut-breasted Malkoha P. curvirostris. New World cuculines usually feed alone but some feed in mixed-species flocks of birds. Squirrel Cuckoos Piaya cayana follow army ants in Brazil, and Squirrel Cuckoos and Blackbellied Cuckoos Piaya melanogaster in the Neotropical mainland forests and lizard-cuckoos Coccyzus longirostris in the Caribbean occur in mixed-species flocks, as do wintering Black-billed Cuckoos and Yellow-billed Cuckoos in South America. Greater Anis follow ants and squirrel monkey troops. Other anis live in flocks where they associate with cattle
and take insects when they are stirred up by the cattle, while in less disturbed habitats the anis follow native American mammals. Brood-parasitic cuckoos appear in mixed-species flocks in the non-breeding season. Several insectivorous cuckoos in New Guinea do this, as do wintering Oriental Cuckoos in Australia. Birds in mixed-species flocks benefit from the foraging activities of other birds, and they may also benefit from protection against predators (Thiollay and Jullien 1998). Fruits (especially figs, also berries, tamarinds and palm oil fruits) are the main food of the broodparasitic Dwarf Koel, Common Koel and Channelbilled Cuckoo, and fruit is important in breeding behavior in the Dwarf Koel and Common Koel when the male feeds his mate in courtship. Figs are especially important as they are high in calcium and the fruits are often present in all seasons. Koels have a wide mouth gape (⬎ 2 cm) and can eat as many as 68 intact figs before they regurgitate a pellet that contains the seeds. The young of these broodparasitic cuckoos are often fed insects, although nestling Common Koels reared by Figbirds Sphecotheres viridis get fruit as well as insects, and young Channel-billed Cuckoos Scythrops novaehollandiae are fed fruit by Pied Currawongs Strepera graculina. African Emerald Cuckoo Chrysococcyx cupreus parasitize the fruit-eating Yellow-whiskered Bulbul Andropadus latirostris, as well as insectivorous host species.The bulbuls feed insects to the nestlings during the first four days after their brood has hatched, then feed a mix of insects, regurgitated fruit pulp and whole fruits during the last week of nestling life. Fruit is also fed to young nestling Jacobin Cuckoos when they are reared by fruit-eating bulbuls (Liversidge 1971). Fruit is important to several nesting cuckoos as well. Some malkohas, couas, coucals and Old World ground-cuckoos (Carpococcyx “fruitcuckoos”) take fruit (Shanahan et al. 2001). The ground-cuckoos in Sumatra and Borneo live in dipterocarp forests which produce huge crops of fruit in some years, but in most years do not produce any fruit ( Janzen 1974, Appanah 1985). The fruiteating animals such as bearded pigs Sus barbatus that take these masting fruits have to move long distances to find food or switch to alternative foods such as figs (Whitten et al. 1987, MacKinnon et al. 1996).
20 The Cuckoos Ground-cuckoos often feed with large mammals nearby. Dipterocarp forests are heavily logged and burned and during El Niño years the trees fail to fruit (Curran et al. 1999, Curran and Leighton 2000). Dependence on the fruit of these masting trees may be responsible in part for the decline of groundcuckoos in the Greater Sundas. In Madagascar, two couas are vegetarians that take mainly fruit; couas also take the gum that exudes from acacia trees. In the New World, roadrunners, Squirrel Cuckoos and Yellow-billed Cuckoos occasionally take fruit along with a mainly insectivorous diet. Koels and other fruit-eating birds are ecologically important in the dispersal of forest fruits (Lambert 1989, 1991, Lambert and Marshall 1991, Compton et al. 1996, Kinnaird et al. 1999, Shanahan et al. 2001). Smooth-billed Anis take hot peppers Capsicum, the “Madame Jeanette” chili peppers of the Caribbean and Suriname.The capsaicin chemical in the ripe fleshy fruit is distasteful to mammals but not to birds. The function of capsaicin is to deter mammal seed predators (small rodents are fruit consumers which crush the seeds and do not allow them to germinate) and not to deter birds, which are attracted to the bright fleshy fruits and disperse the seeds in their feces. Consumption of non-pungent peppers by fruit-eating mammals results in zero germination. In contrast, consumption of both non-pungent and hot peppers by fruiteating birds results in germination rates similar to those of control seeds planted from the fruit, which proves that consumption by birds results in successful dispersal of the seeds (Tewksbury and Nabham 2001).Anis disperse gumbo-limbo fruits when they remove the fruit skin, swallow the flesh and regurgitate the seeds.
Cuckoos and their predators Larger predators such as raptors and large primates take adult cuckoos, and cuckoo nestlings and eggs are taken by a variety of predators including birds, mammals and snakes. Both young and adult broodparasitic cuckoos are eaten by mammals such as monkeys in Africa.Young roadrunners are eaten by dogs, cats and raccoons, and these mammals also catch adult roadrunners on the nest. Black-billed
Cuckoos in North America are eaten by hawks and other predatory birds (Hughes 2001), Cuculus cuckoos in the Philippines are plucked and eaten by raptors (Curio et al. 2001), anis in Central America are taken by carnivorous bats (Vehrencamp et al. 1977), and coucals in Central Africa are eaten by chimpanzees Pan troglodytes (Nishida and Uehara 1983), all observations suggesting that cuckoos are not toxic to predatory birds and mammals. In addition, rural peoples eat cuckoos for medicinal purposes as well as for food, including anis in the Caribbean, Common Koels in India and coucals in New Guinea (Walden 1869, Payne 1997b). Most cuckoos avoid predators by stealth. The arboreal New World Black-billed and Yellow-billed Cuckoos avoid predators by their watchful behavior and are easily overlooked by predators, as well as by their visually-oriented prey. Other cuckoos actively avoid predators.When they see a predator, group-living anis call and fly together to a higher perch, so their group behavior is related not only to food but also to mutual protection from predators. Adult Greater Roadrunners avoid an aerial predator by running, dodging, flashing their wings and spreading their tails, behaviors that may distract, confuse or intimidate a predator (Rand 1941b). Roadrunners often run rather than fly when a predator approaches. When I taught a field ornithology course with field trips in the Black Mesa country of western Oklahoma, we watched where the bird ran—it hid in a clump of cholla cactus.The students circled the cactus, one reached in and grabbed the roadrunner. Then we took a few photos, released the bird and watched it run again. Nestlings of many nesting cuckoos (Black-billed and Yellow-billed Cuckoos, roadrunners, coucals) void a foul black liquid from the cloaca when they are disturbed in the nest, and this may repel a predator. Nestling Guira Cuckoos of any age sometimes leap from the nest or branches and escape a predator when they land safely on a lower branch and hide; leapers sometimes die from the fall (R. Macedo, in litt.).The young cuckoos are at risk: more than half of all roadrunner nests are lost to predators (Folse 1974).Young nestling roadrunners produce a fecal sac that is removed and eaten by the parent cuckoos; older nestlings when about to
Behavior 21 leave the nest produce the foul liquid when a predator disturbs them. Brood-parasitic young cuckoos do not produce the black liquid, but like their passerine host young they encapsulate their feces and urine in a gelatinous fecal sac which is removed by the foster parent.Although nesting cuckoos take an active role in mobbing predators, the broodparasitic cuckoos do not join these mobs; they leave the defense of the young to the foster parents.
Breeding seasons In temperate latitudes the gonads of many kinds of birds develop in response to the photoperiod. Seasonal daylength changes are reliable predictors of environmental conditions such as food and temperature, which affect the ability of birds to rear their young (Murton and Westwood 1977). In the northern temperate New World, brood-parasitic Brownheaded Cowbirds Molothrus ater breed at the same time as their host species. In experiments, the cowbirds respond to seasonal changes in daylength in the same way as their hosts, and in the same way as nesting icterids in the same region (Payne 1969b, 1973b). It is likely that brood-parasitic cuckoos respond to the same environmental cues as their hosts in the initial stages of hormonal activity and gonad growth. The final stages of ovarian growth of the brood-parasitic birds depends on hearing the songs and seeing the nesting activity of their hosts (Immelmann and Immelmann 1967, Payne 1973b, 1983, Löhrl 1979). No experimental work on this has been carried out with cuckoos, but it is likely that they respond to changing conditions in much the same way as these other brood-parasitic birds do. North American Black-billed and Yellow-billed Cuckoos breed along with the earliest songbirds in April and May, and if insects are still abundant they continue to breed into August and early September. These early, long and late seasons occur notably in areas with outbreaks of tent caterpillars, which feed in huge numbers on many wild rosaceous trees and shrubs. For Greater Roadrunners, breeding varies with temperature and rainfall. In southern California they breed from late February in low elevations of the Lower Sonoran Life Zone,
and a month later in the upland deserts of the Upper Sonoran Life Zone. A pair can nest again when the male takes over the care of the fledged brood while the female lays a second set of eggs.The cooperative behavior of a pair may let them rear more than one brood when insect food is abundant during the short desert season. In southern Arizona, breeding tends to be bimodal with nesting from mid-April to mid-June and late July to midSeptember with a pause in the hot dry summer, and nesting again after the summer rains, with the breeding peaks varying with the rains of the year. In Texas they breed from March to October, and in Oklahoma from April to July or August. In the tropics, cuckoos breed in the rains; many cuckoos in anglophone regions of the world are known as “rain birds”. They begin to sing shortly before the first good rains begin, and their calls are taken as cues to local farmers to prepare their land for cultivation. Birds may begin their physiological change into breeding condition well before the rains begin (Immelmann 1971). Although their breeding seasons are indirectly timed with the season of rains, some tropical birds respond directly to changing daylength much as in northern temperate regions. A seasonal change of less than an hour, that is, the daylength change at 15° from the equator, is enough to affect the cycles (Hau et al. 1998). Outside the forest where the rains fall through fewer than six months, breeding is seasonal with changes in the vegetation and insects (Levings and Windsor 1982, Wright and Cornejo 1990). In tropical forests many birds are seasonal, nesting in all but the rainiest or driest season (Chapin 1939, Moreau 1950, Skutch 1950, Fogden 1972, Bell 1982a,b,Wikelski et al. 2000). The breeding season for brood-parasitic cuckoos corresponds with the breeding season of their host species. In tropical and subtropical regions, the cuckoos breed early in the rains when their host species begin to nest.These seasons vary within Africa. (1) In equatorial East Africa the breeding season corresponds to the local rains, where seasons differ by a few months in areas only 200 km apart (Brown and Brown 1980). These differences are associated with altitude, distance from the coast, and the presence of mountains that intercept monsoon rains from the Atlantic. East of the eastern rift (region D)
22 The Cuckoos there are two rains in a year, with long rains in April and May and shorter rains around November: January to March is a hot dry season and June to October is cooler and overcast.West of the rift and south of Lake Victoria (region C) there is only one season with rains between October and April or May, and a dry season in the middle of the year, although temperatures are cooler than in the dry season of D owing to the elevation and to the sun not being overhead at that time. In western Kenya, the Lake Victoria basin and Uganda (region B), rains come from March to November with two peaks corresponding with those east of the rift. In the dry region of northern Uganda and northern Kenya (region A) the rains come between March and October, with little rain in June and July. In coastal Kenya the rains come from April to June during the southeast monsoon. Insectivorous songbirds breed during the rains in these areas, and their brood-parasitic cuckoos breed in the same season as their hosts. Klaas’s Cuckoo Chrysococcyx klaas breed mainly in the rains as do their sunbird hosts, with most recorded from February to April in region D, December to April in region C, April in region B and September in region A. Diederik Cuckoo C. caprius breed for a longer season from March to June when most ploceids breed in region D. Finally, Red-chested Cuckoos Cuculus solitarius breed mainly from April to June in region D, and February to September in region B. (2) In West Africa, seasonal rains from the Atlantic are controlled by the inter-tropical convergence (ITCZ), which is the atmosphere’s equator.The zone moves a month or two behind the overhead movement of the sun.The vernal equinox in March is followed by rains in West Africa in May and these rains continue until October. The zone forms by movement into, or convergence of, the northeast trade winds of the northern hemisphere and the southeast tradewinds of the southern hemisphere in the equatorial belt.The inflowing air rises and clouds form in convective cells that often drift westward bringing frequent rains and thunderstorms. Dry northeasterly winds, the harmattan, blow off the Sahara desert from November to March, signaling the end of the rains in the north.The wet westerly or southwestern monsoon is more extensive and marked in summer
from May to September when thermal heating over the continent supports the northerly displacement of the equatorial trough. Rains on the coast of Ghana at Accra and Cape Coast peak in May and June, as the monsoon is intercepted along the coast west of Cape Coast. Further east in Togo the rains are affected by a low north-south mountain range (Grimes 1987, Cheke and Walsh 1996). Only 200 km inland from the coast in Ghana at Kumasi are there two rainy peaks, one in May and June and the other in September and October (Elgood et al. 1994). Further north the winds bring less rain. In coastal Togo, Lomé gets nearly 100 mm during April, while in northern Togo rains this intense arrive a month later and the growing season begins later (Cheke and Walsh 1996). Likewise northern Senegal gets less rain and the season of effective rain is from June to October (Morel and Morel 1990). In Nigeria a monthly rainfall of at least 100 mm comes a month earlier on the coast (March) than at Ibadan (April), and a month later in northern Nigeria (May) (Elgood 1994). Different breeding seasons are known for African Black Coucal Centropus grillii—in coastal Ghana from April to July, in northern Ghana in July and August.The birds also apparently migrate between north and south (Grimes 1987), much as they do in Togo. (3) Even at high latitudes the breeding seasons are strongly influenced by seasonal rains. Klaas’s Cuckoos in the Cape Region of South Africa, an area of winter rainfall at 34–35° N, breed in winter from July to September along with their sunbird hosts, and in the Eastern Cape at 33–34° N they breed mainly from October to December. Further north (c. 15° S) where rains come later the cuckoos breed in the later months, as in Zambia where they breed mainly from December to February. Great Spotted Cuckoos breed two or three months later in western Namibia, than in Natal and the Eastern Cape of South Africa, again in relation to the rains of the region. In India the breeding seasons of brood-parasitic cuckoos are similar to those of nesting cuckoos. Their breeding seasons are related to altitude in India (Baker 1934, 1942), where cuckoos and their hosts breed earlier in the plains than in the higher foothills and mountains.The rains and green growth that follow come earlier at the lower altitudes.
Behavior 23 In Africa the breeding season for the broodparasitic cuckoos varies with the ecology of the nesting cuckoos as well as with the ecology of the host species. In Malawi, nesting resident Whitebrowed Coucals breed right through the year except from July to September, while migratory African Black Coucals breed from January to May when the marshes are flooded (Benson and Benson 1977). Many insect-eating songbirds begin to breed before the first rains, and in northern Zambia like the miombo trees in Brachystegia woodland which grow and unfold their new leaves before the rains, these songbirds anticipate the rains weeks before they begin. In this pre-rain period, Black Cuckoos Cuculus clamosus and Klaas’s Cuckoos begin to sing. The nesting cuckoos tend to have a longer breeding season than the brood parasites, depending on their status as migrants or as residents (Table 3.1). In the parasite species with the largest number of records, the season is five months. In Zambia, the cuckoos with the long breeding season are resident coucals. In Zimbabwe, the brood-parasitic cuckoos with the longest season are Levaillant’s Cuckoos Clamator levaillantii, whose main host,
Table 3.1 Breeding seasons (number of months) in south-central Africa.
nesting cuckoos Centropus grillii Centropus cupreicaudus Centropus senegalensis Centropus superciliosus Ceuthmochares australis brood parasites Clamator jacobinus Clamator levaillantii Pachycoccyx audeberti Cuculus clamosus Cuculus solitarius Cuculus gularis Chrysococcyx caprius Chrysococcyx klaas Chrysococcyx cupreus
Malawi
Zambia
Zimbabwe
5 na 1 9 1
3 6 7 3 -
4 4 6 6 1
7 2 1 3 1 7 5 3
5 3 4 3 5 5 -
6 8 5 4 4 4 6 8 -
Arrow-marked Babbler Turdoides jardinei, is a cooperatively-breeding bird that nests in all months; and the partly resident Klaas’s Cuckoos whose hosts are warblers and sunbirds, some breeding in the rains and others in the dry season. The resident coucals breed over a longer period than the migratory African Black Coucals (Irwin 1981, Hustler 1997a). In Australia, the time when cuckoos breed depends on the rains. In two regions matched for latitude but with different months of rain, Horsfield’s Bronze-cuckoo Chrysococcyx basalis begins to lay in the early austral spring in July in the southeast, and in early October in the southwest. A common host in the west, Splendid Fairy-wren Malurus splendens have a longer breeding season than their cuckoos, and the latest nests escape the cuckoo parasite (Rowley et al. 1991, Rowley and Russell 1997). Further north where rains fall in austral summer, cuckoos and their hosts breed in the Kimberley Division from January to March, and from March to May and August to September in the Pilbara Region: In arid inland Australia breeding is bimodal, with rains in spring and autumn (Storr 1984a, Brooker and Brooker 1989a,b, Ambrose and Murphy 1994, Pizzey and Knight 1998, Higgins 1999).
Migration Cuckoos undertake long-distance migrations between their temperate breeding areas and their wintering grounds.With cuckoos that breed in the higher latitudes, migration is known from their alternating seasonal occurrence in the breeding region and on the winter grounds. North American Black-billed and Yellow-billed Cuckoos migrate to South America, and winter south of the equator. Another North American cuckoo is at least partly migratory: northern populations of Mangrove Cuckoos appear seasonally in Florida and the Bahamas, and are absent in winter. Migration is just as remarkable although the detail is less well known with the South American cuckoos. Austral migration occurs with other birds that breed in temperate South America while the cuckoos are nonbreeding wintering birds in the tropics (Chesser 1994, 1997). At least three cuckoos have
24 The Cuckoos this seasonal movement and tend to live in scrub woodland both in their breeding grounds and in the austral winter: Ash-colored Cuckoo and southern populations of Pearly-breasted Cuckoos Coccyzus euleri and Dark-billed Cuckoos C. melacoryphus. Ash-colored Cuckoos Coccycua cinerea breed only in the southern temperate region, but the other two cuckoos have a wide breeding range. Other cuckoos perhaps migrate from the southern extremity of their range (Greater Ani, American Striped Cuckoo: Chesser 1994), yet the odd birds that appear in the tropics in localities where they are not regular in occurrence may be local dispersers rather than austral migrants. In the absence of known morphological differences between northern and southern breeders it has not been possible to determine whether the southern cuckoos move into the northern region while northern birds are breeding, or whether both populations spend a non-breeding period in the Amazon basin. Four cuckoos in the northern temperate region of the Old World complete long-distance migrations when they move across the equator (Great Spotted Cuckoo, Common, Oriental and Asian Lesser Cuckoos). European Great Spotted Cuckoos and Common Cuckoos migrate to Africa, flying nonstop over the Mediterranean and the Sahara, a distance of more than 3000 km. Other cuckoos migrate from continental Asia to the Malay Peninsula, the Greater Sunda Islands and the Philippines (hawk-cuckoos Hierococcyx and drongocuckoos Surniculus), or over the Indian Ocean to Africa (Indian populations of Jacobin, Common and Asian Lesser Cuckoo) and appear in migration on islands in the Indian Ocean between their breeding and wintering grounds. Some cuckoos that appear on the coast in Kenya have flown over 3000 km from their nearest breeding grounds to winter in Africa. Madagascar Lesser Cuckoos Cuculus rochii migrate from their breeding grounds to live the rest of the year in continental Africa. Migration of the Common Cuckoo is known both by seasonal changes in where the birds live, and by recoveries (n ⫽ 2) of birds marked in Europe and found thousands of kilometers away in Africa in the winter. Less well known are the wintering grounds of the Common Cuckoo that breeds in eastern Asia.
Migration of brood-parasitic cuckoos that move between breeding and nonbreeding areas is timed to coincide with the season when the hosts breed, and when caterpillars emerge and become abundant with the onset of warmer weather in spring in the high latitudes, and with rains in the subtropics and tropics. Cuckoos regularly migrate within Africa, moving from their breeding grounds in South Africa to equatorial Africa (black phase Jacobin Cuckoo, Black Cuckoo). Cuckoos move with the rains in West Africa where they normally live near the humid coast in the dry season, and move northward into the savanna in the rains ( Jacobin Cuckoo, Levaillant’s Cuckoo, Black Cuckoo, African Emerald Cuckoo, Klaas’s Cuckoo, Diederik Cuckoo, African Black Coucal), while some may remain as residents of coastal areas throughout the year. In the Australo-Pacific region, certain cuckoos migrate from their southern breeding grounds in the temperate regions of Australia and New Zealand, to winter in the tropics (Horsfield’s Bronze-cuckoo, Shining Bronze-cuckoo, Channelbilled Cuckoo, Long-tailed Cuckoo). Migrating cuckoos are often very fat, and their stores of fat may persist into winter (“summer” in their nonbreeding grounds), as in a Common Cuckoo from the Palearctic measured in December in South Africa (Payne 1968, Moreau 1972). Shining Bronzecuckoo and Long-tailed Cuckoo breed in New Zealand in summer but are absent there in the winter months; and they occur on tropical Pacific islands in winter but not in summer. Few banded cuckoos in the region have been recovered to show longdistance migration, In one case, Common Koel banded in New South Wales, Australia, was recovered in New Guinea, 2950 km from its banding site (Higgins 1999). The only form of Little Bronzecuckoo known to migrate from Australia to New Guinea is Chrysococcyx m. barnardi, with a few winter records in New Guinea. Other Australian bronzecuckoos move within Australia but it is unknown whether the green-glossed C. m. minutillus migrate to New Guinea. Rufous birds that breed in Australia look like rufous breeding birds in New Guinea (C. m. poecilurus), so there is no compelling evidence of long-distance migration in these cuckoos.
Behavior 25 Migration of cuckoos that breed in tropical areas is less well known, and cuckoos seen only in one season, may be resident but inconspicuous at other times when they are silent. In Africa, Jacobin Cuckoos and Levaillant’s Cuckoos are seen seasonally in Zambia within 15° of the equator and they migrate to more equatorial regions. Klaas’s Cuckoo is conspicuous in the breeding season in southern Africa and nearly disappears in the non-breeding season. Nevertheless a few birds remain all year, but are inconspicuous during the season when they do not sing. Movements of cuckoos within Africa are not well understood, partly because several species have populations that do not differ morphologically between regions and lack distinctive subspecies, and in these birds there is no easy way to distinguish between local residents and nonbreeding visitors. The black-phase Black Cuckoos in West Africa probably come from populations further south (that is, south of the Congolese equatorial forests), if only because these black-phase birds are not known to sing or to breed in West Africa. On the other hand, there are remarkably few records of the resident forms of this species actually breeding in West Africa.These migratory forms are mainly non-forest birds. In Togo, five species of non-passerines in forest habitats show seasonal changes in their numbers, that suggest a seasonal arrival of birds from further south: three of these are cuckoos, Black Cuckoo, Red-chested Cuckoo and African Emerald Cuckoo. Among savanna cuckoos several species appear to have resident populations in the south, but these birds are present only during the rains in the northern savannas and they may undertake more local migrations. These include Diederik Cuckoo, Klaas’s Cuckoo and African Black Coucal, and the coastal swamp grasslands may also receive visiting African Black Coucals from further south (Cheke and Walsh 1996). In East Africa, Barred Long-tailed Cuckoos Cercococcyx montanus appear seasonally near the east coast where they do not breed, and these birds make local migrations. In southeast Asia, the migration of cuckoos at night has been recorded in the Malay Peninsula. On Fraser’s Hill, the records of cuckoos netted at night include more than 10 individuals each of Chestnut-
winged Cuckoo Clamator coromandus,Violet Cuckoo Chrysococcyx xanthorhynchus, (Fork-tailed) Drongocuckoo Surniculus (dicruroides) (the most abundant, with 57 records),Whistling Hawk-cuckoo Hierococcyx nisicolor and Indian Cuckoo Cuculus micropterus (Medway and Wells 1976). The seasonal appearance of small glossy-cuckoos Chrysococcyx in the Indonesian archipelago may result from the inconspicuous behavior of non-breeding birds, and there are no substantiated records of migration of the distinctive forms of Little Bronze-cuckoo C. minutillus. Brush Cuckoos Cacomantis variolosus may migrate from the central highlands to the lowlands in New Guinea: the evidence is the occasional appearance near the coast of long-billed birds, that are more often found in the mountains (Diamond 1972). Long-distance migrants sometimes appear on the wrong side of the ocean. North American Black-billed and Yellow-billed Cuckoos appear as vagrants on the North Atlantic islands and in northern Europe, and as far east as Italy and Sicily, while Palearctic Common Cuckoos turn up in northern North America in Alaska and on the Atlantic coast, and Oriental Cuckoos appear in Alaska.The dangers of migration over the ocean are illustrated by the remains of a Yellow-billed Cuckoo in the stomach of a shark (Saunders 1962). Black-billed and Yellow-billed Cuckoos migrate at night.They make an over-water flight in autumn of 2000–3000 km from their breeding grounds in North America to the West Indies, then continue onwards to South America. Or they fly as far as 4000 km from the north directly to the mainland of South America, then continue well inland to winter south of the equator. Yellow-billed Cuckoos appear through May to August on islands off the Florida coast where they do not occur as breeding birds, and their appearance suggests that spring migration continues as late as June, and the southbound return begins by July (Stevenson and Anderson 1994).These cuckoos orient by patterns of the stars: when tested in a planetarium (Marler and Hamilton 1966) they became active at night and directed their movements in the seasonally correct direction of the planetarium sky. These cuckoos appear as casualties below TV transmitting towers which attract nocturnal migrants by their lights,
26 The Cuckoos and they fly into brightly lit walls as well (Sick 1993). Cuckoos that breed in New Zealand, the Shining Bronze-cuckoo and Long-tailed Cuckoo, are nocturnal migrants that winter on remote islands in the Pacific Ocean more than a thousand kilometers from their breeding range. The large Channel-billed Cuckoos migrate during the daytime as they pass between Australia and the tropics where they winter in New Guinea and the Moluccas. Cuckoos like other nocturnal migrants can orient even without the experience of learning from their parents. When they are socially isolated and hand-reared apart from the adults, young Yellowbilled Cuckoos become active at night in the migration season and orient their restless behavior toward the stars (Marler and Hamilton 1966). A “natural experiment” demonstrated that the young brood-parasitic cuckoos have no opportunity to learn the migration time or route from the adults, as the older birds do not live with their offspring, and would have left from their northern breeding
grounds several weeks before the juveniles leave the area. Some resident cuckoos disperse after the breeding season and range far from their natal and breeding areas. Individual Greater Anis appear outside their breeding range in Brazil away from their breeding sites. Smooth-billed Anis and Groovebilled Anis occasionally show up at the end of summer in North America more than 1000 km north of their breeding grounds, usually alone and not in a group. A South American Guira Cuckoo once appeared in the Netherlands Antilles. “All three [ani] species have shown a remarkable tendency towards extralimital vagrancy, given their seemingly ineffective flight and short rounded wings. The wide distribution of Smooth-billed [Ani] in the West Indies with no phenotypic differentiation attests to its powers of dispersal” ( J.V. Remsen, in McLean 1995). Most tropical cuckoos are resident, including the ground-cuckoos of the Old World and New World, the Madagascar couas, the malkohas and many coucals.
4 Morphology
Cuckoos have a zygodactyl foot with two toes of each foot (numbers 1—the inner toe or hallux of most birds—and 4, the outermost toe) directed backward, and the other two toes (numbers 2 and 3) directed forward. Most cuckoos have a long tail. Cuckoos have 10 primaries and 10 rectrices (eight in the anis); the plumage has no aftershaft; the oil gland is naked, and in most species the nestlings have no downy feathers (Nitzsch 1867). Several other morphological features occur in cuckoos that are generally not present in other birds, and a few of these features occur only in the cuckoos.The most distinctive charactereristics are in the skeleton in details of the tarsometatarsal bone (two enclosed canals side by side in the hypotarsus, and a characteristic shape of the accessory process or sehnenhalter on trochlea IV of the distal tarsometatarsus), and in the shape of the humerus and its deltoid crest. Relationships within the cuckoos have been estimated from their anatomy, geographic distribution and breeding biology, and more recently from their molecular genetics. Earlier studies were based on morphology, primarily from museum skins. Shelley (1891) recognized one family of cuckoos with six subfamilies: typical cuckoos Cuculinae, coucals Centropodinae, malkohas Phaenicophaeinae, New World ground cuckoos Neomorphinae, New World brood parasites (the group: the birds were not yet known to be brood parasites) Diplopterinae, and anis Crotophaginae. Peters (1940) recognized the cuckoo family, also with six subfamilies (Cuculinae, Phaenicophaeinae, Crotophaginae, Neomorphinae, Couinae and Centropodinae); he included Carpococcyx with Neomorphus in Neomorphinae. Wolters (1975–1982) recognized nine families of cuckoos
(Crotophagidae, Centropodidae, Neomorphidae (including Dromococcyx), Taperidae, Coccyzidae, Clamatoridae (including Pachycoccyx), Cuculidae, Eudynamidae (including Caliechthrus, Urodynamis, Microdynamis, Rhamphomantis and Scythrops), and Phoenicophaeidae. He included Coua and Carpococcyx with Centropus in a family Centropodidae; Mason (1997a) listed characters that these groundliving birds had in common.
Comparative and adaptive features of cuckoo morphology A few general trends in morphology are related to the life style of cuckoos. In some cases we can distinguish between adaptations and features that are explained by the evolutionary relationships among lineages. Body weight was taken as the main standard of body size to allow broad comparisons across cuckoos: body weight is correlated with other aspects of size, and many life history variables are associated with body weight in birds in general, as in a sampler of behavior, breeding biology, lifespan and metabolic rates (Calder 1984). Body size was then compared with brain size in cuckoos with different breeding behavior (brood parasites, nesting pairs and cooperatively-breeding group-living birds), and also with length of the leg bones in relation to the arboreal and terrestrial feeding behavior of the cuckoos.Where body weight is not known, wing length or even tarsus length can be used as an estimate of body size, at least within a group of birds based on the same body plan such as the coucals, but where the proportions of birds differ
28 The Cuckoos among groups, body weight is the standard of comparison for body size. Species differences in brain size may be related to both phylogeny and adaptive behavioral ecology. There have been few comparative studies of birds (Pearson 1972, Mlíkovsky 1989), and those have shown few ecological correlates of brain size, except that altricial birds tend to have larger brains than precocial birds (Bennett and Harvey 1985, Iwaniuk and Nelson 2001, 2002). In cuckoos, the brain size is similar to that of other altricial birds of the same body size, although the brain is smaller than in parrots.The relationship of brain size with body size in birds varies with the systematic level of analysis, a so-called “taxon-level effect” ( Jerison 1973, Aboitiz 1996, Nealen and Ricklefs 2001). To test the variation in brain size with behavior, skeletal specimens of 76 cuckoo species were examined by George Kulesza. The orbital foramina were closed with masking tape, then the braincase was
filled through the foramen magnum. Spherical lead shots of uniform size were introduced into the braincase with the help of a flexible cylinder.The volume of shot in the braincase was compressed by shaking and tapping the skull until the shot was level with the foramen magnum. The procedure was repeated for each skull to determine repeatability (within 2%) and the two measurements were averaged. The amount of shot was determined with the use of a graduated pipette. Volumetric measurements showed that 0.17 ml of shot was equal to 1 ml or about 1 g of brain. The mean mass of a pellet (0.013 g) agreed closely with the mass µ calculated for a sphere of the measured diameter 0.136 cm (µ ⫽ ρ (4/3)πr3), where radius r ⫽ 0.068 cm, and density of lead ρ ⫽ 10.5 g (cm3)⫺1.Where several skeletal specimens of a species were available, 2–4 skulls were measured and the mean brain size was calculated. Brain size (g) was then compared with body size (g) in the corresponding sex and subspecies.
Figure 4.1. Brain size in relation to body size and behavioral ecology in cuckoos. Closed symbols indicate nesting species (N), open symbols indicate brood parasites (P).
Table 4.1 Leg length, femur, tibiotarsus and tarsometatarsus (mm), brain (g), body weight (g) and behavior (a ⫽ arboreal, t ⫽ terrestrial). Species
breeding (c, n, p)2
specimen3
41.0 43.6 38.3 36.3
t t t t
c c c c
UMMZ UMMZ UMMZ UMMZ
49.8 86.5 70.8 95.1 40.2 46.6 40.5
38.0 63.7 51.2 74.6 30.5 36.2 32.3
t t t t t t t
n n n n p p p
UMMZ 159111; 133738, 159111 UMMZ 227057; 227059, 234551 UMMZ 159112; 156461, 159112 UMMZ 200592 UMMZ 222217; 218370, 218946 MVZ 85638 LSU 101257
37.9 48.4 60.6 52.3 63.5 73.8 54.4 48.8 60.5 41.7 45.1 39.9
55.1 71.7 87.9 79.9 95.3 112.3 74.9 67.5 90.6 59.3 63.5 62.3
41.4 45.6 57.5 50.1 63.4 71.6 51.1 48.4 63.5 41.2 43.1 43.8
t t,a t t t t t t t t t t
n n n n n n n n n n n n
UMMZ 143041 USNM 226188 USNM 557171 USNM 318594 AMNH 7333 UWBM 63149 UMMZ 224761 UMMZ 207709 BMNH S/1969.1.462, USNM 562052 UMMZ 208305 UMMZ 208402 UMMZ 228027; 228025, ⫺26, ⫺27 (s)
64.4 66.3 42.4
112.3 112.4 74.4
87.4 91.7 57.9
t t t
n n n
UMMZ 219851, 236029; ⫺26 and 219043 (s) USNM 223970 USNM 432195; FMNH 356640 (s)
brain (g)
femur
tibiotarsotarsus metatarsus
142 153 105 75
1.85 2.69 1.71 1.53
37.2 41.9 38.3 34.8
58.8 64.6 56.8 53.6
62 305 178 345 52 85 48
1.33 3.59 2.77 4.39 1.25 1.11 0.86
31.4 54.5 50.0 60.8 27.9 30.3 24.3
88 – – 336 503 769 280 170 417 170 177 123
2.25 4.38 5.33 – 7.45 9.69 3.90 3.34 4.66 3.11 3.36 2.75
– – 190
5.96 – 2.63
202015; 157046, 200661, 202013, ⫺14 (s) 139988; 139989, 219553 (s) 218940; 118151, 218943 (s) 219189; 133737, 219189, 219557 (s) (s) (s) (s) (s)
Morphology 29
Crotophaginae Guira guira Crotophaga major Crotophaga ani Crotophaga sulcirostris Neomorphinae Morococcyx erythropygus Geococcyx californianus Geococcyx velox Neomorphus geoffroyi Tapera naevia Dromococcyx phasianellus Dromococcyx pavoninus Centropodinae Centropus bengalensis Centropus celebensis Centropus goliath Centropus leucogaster Centropus menbeki Centropus milo Centropus phasianinus Centropus senegalensis Centropus sinensis bubutus Centropus superciliosus Centropus toulou Centropus viridis Couinae Carpococcyx renauldi Carpococcyx radiatus Coua ruficeps
behavior (a,t)1
body (g)
Species Coua caerulea Coua cristata Coua reynaudii Coua gigas Coua serriana Cuculinae Rhinortha chlorophaea Ceuthmochares australis Clamator coromandus Clamator glandarius Clamator jacobinus Clamator levaillantii Dasylophus superciliosus Dasylophus cumingi Zanclostomas javanicus Phaenicophaeus diardi Phaenicophaeus tristis Phaenicophaeus curvirostris Rhamphococcyx calyorhynchus Coccycua minuta Piaya cayana Piaya melanogaster Coccyzus americanus Coccyzus minor Coccyzus melacoryphus Coccyzus erythropthalmus Coccyzus lansbergi Coccyzus merlini Coccyzus longirostris Coccyzus pluvialis Coccyzus rufigularis
body (g)
brain (g)
femur
235 136 140 420 298
3.48 2.38 3.47 4.75 4.15
50.0 34.7 43.5 57.8 52.5
tibiotarsotarsus metatarsus 83.8 55.4 55.5 39.3 66.4 46.3 98.1 72.0 80.1 61.0
59 66 77 124 72 124 118 174 98 61 115 189 – 40 98 102 63 64 50 51 55 154 98 176 130
1.34 1.53 1.49 1.85 1.31 1.89 2.62 3.27 2.46 – 2.39 2.98 – 1.06 2.07 1.89 1.20 1.53 1.15 0.99 1.12 2.50 1.96 2.79 2.62
28.1 31.0 32.1 35.6 31.7 36.9 40.1 46.1 37.6 34.4 40.6 45.8 49.6 25.6 42.0 38.2 29.2 29.9 27.9 26.2 28.6 42.3 37.4 47.6 48.2
41.3 44.2 45.4 49.6 44.5 51.2 57.3 67.2 51.2 47.2 59.5 65.1 67.1 36.1 61.4 53.7 39.7 43.5 39.0 37.1 41.5 61.6 51.9 68.8 –
27.1 29.9 27.8 32.5 29.0 32.5 38.7 44.0 35.6 33.5 40.5 43.2 45.7 25.4 42.4 37.4 27.4 29.7 26.3 24.6 27.0 41.9 35.1 45.1 –
specimen3
behavior (a,t)1 a a t t t
breeding (c, n, p)2 n n n n n
UMMZ 209201 UMMZ 157526; 157526, FMNH 384680 (s) UMMZ 219043; 208403, FMNH 352797 (s) FMNH 360040 UMMZ 209202; FMNH 356638, ⫺39 (s)
a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a
n n p p p p p n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n
MCZ 342734 UMMZ 209209; 158185–86 (s) USNM 343999 UMMZ 212911; ⫺11, ⫺14 (s) UMMZ 212899; 212890, ⫺94, ⫺96 (s) UMMZ 212906 UMMZ 228068; ⫺22, ⫺23, ⫺24 (s) UMMZ 233062; ⫺63 (s) UMMZ 236439 BMNH S/1969.1.10 USNM 344002 UMMZ 236028 USNM 226196 UMMZ 139991; ⫺90, ⫺92 (s) UMMZ 222216; 133732, ⫺33 (s) UMMZ 209478; LSU 64990, 89701 (s) UMMZ 203320; 154465, 201937, 207641 (s) UMMZ 208492; 152623, 208492 (s) UMMZ 208493 UMMZ 205253; 200574, 201813 (s) LSU 114314 UMMZ 158527 USNM 554614 USNM 559182 USNM 226541
30 The Cuckoos
Table 4.1 contd.
1
40.9 36.7 58.7 19.6 16.5 16.8 17.2 20.6 18.3 23.0 25.8 20.6 19.2 19.0 22.1 19.1 33.7 29.1
57.1 51.9 80.2 29.7 25.5 24.4 25.7 28.5 25.3 31.1 36.8 28.8 28.2 27.0 30.9 27.1 46.2 39.3
34.2 34.5 44.5 20.7 17.8 16.3 18.0 18.1 15.9 18.8 22.7 18.5 18.6 18.2 20.3 16.1 28.3 23.3
25.9 26.8
36.8 35.2 34.2 43.2 32.1 31.5 36.6 34.9 37.1
21.2 19.9
32.0 22.5 22.5 37.0 36.2 28.4
27.1 19.0 17.3 21.4 19.4 20.7
a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a
p p p p p p p p p p p p p p p p p p p p p p p p p p p p p
UMMZ 210347 USNM 559589 KU 85378; KU 85378, MCZ 340296 (s) UMMZ 214229; 214229, ⫺30 (s) KU 85213; UMMZ 214232 (s) KU 43514; KU 41018 (s) UMMZ 214231; 214231, 231601 (s) UMMZ 212919; 217503 (s) UMMZ 158083; 158083, 209198 (s) UMMZ 218545; 209197, 218545 (s) UMMZ 206513; 214226 (s) UMMZ 223664 UMMZ 210982; 207451 (s) UMMZ 228020; 233059, ⫺60 (s) UMMZ 214227; 214227, ⫺28 (s) UMMZ 233061 UMMZ 233058 USNM 557504
FMNH 357420 UMMZ 212917; 212918, 217502 (s) UMMZ 212916 USNM 318240 UMMZ 234936 FMNH 384675 UMMZ 207052; 119430, 151115, 207051 (s) USNM 560668 UMMZ 207450
Behavior, a⫽arboreal; t⫽terrestrial. Breeding behavior, c⫽cooperative; n⫽nesting; p⫽brood-parasitic. 3 First specimen indicates leg measurements, second specimen(s) indicates brain measurements where a specimen other than the first was used, repeated number indicates that brains of all specimens were used. 2
Morphology 31
Eudynamys scolopacea 222 2.59 Urodynamis taitensis 120 2.08 Scythrops novaehollandiae 684 5.55 Chrysococcyx osculans 30 0.77 Chrysococcyx basalis 24 0.56 Chrysococcyx minutillus 18 0.58 Chrysococcyx lucidus 23 0.58 Chrysococcyx caprius 32 0.88 Chrysococcyx klaas 26 0.61 Chrysococcyx cupreus 38 0.94 Cacomantis pallidus 82 1.52 Cacomantis sonneratii 37 0.94 Cacomantis merulinus 24 0.99 Cacomantis variolosus 34 0.93 Cacomantis flabelliformis 44 1.05 Surniculus velutinus 36 0.99 Hierococcyx sparverioides 150 2.19 Hierococcyx hyperythrus 115 1.82 Hierococcyx nisicolor 75 Hierococcyx fugax 80 Hierococcyx pectoralis 76 1.62 Cuculus clamosus 85 1.54 Cuculus solitarius 74 1.59 Cuculus micropterus 119 – Cuculus poliocephalus 52 – Cuculus rochii 59 1.01 Cuculus canorus 106 1.67 Cuculus optatus 117 1.52 Cuculus saturatus 91 – Body weights are from the species accounts.
32 The Cuckoos Brood-parasitic cuckoos have smaller brains for their body size than nesting cuckoos (Table 4.1, Figure 4.1). The variation in brain size is in part explained by a taxon level effect with less scatter around a genus than between genera. Nevertheless, the trend for brood parasites to have smaller brains appears in all three clades of brood-parasitic cuckoos. Cuculus and related brood-parasitic cuckoos have smaller brains than the malkohas, Clamator have smaller brains than the nesting malkohas of the same body size, and the New World brood-parasitic Tapera and Dromococcyx have smaller brains than the nesting Lesser Ground-cuckoo Morococcyx erythropus and Lesser Roadrunner Geococcyx velox. It is unknown whether certain parts in the brain of brood-parasitic cuckoos are small and associated with breeding behavior. In the other brood-parasitic birds that have been examined, cowbirds have larger hippocampus volumes than do the non-parasitic icterids, and females cowbirds that search for host nests have larger hippocampus volumes than males that do not; total brain volume was not determined (Sherry et al. 1993, Reboreda et al. 1996). In birds, the hippocampus is associated with spatial experience and memory (Clayton et al. 1997, Clayton 1998). No other comparative studies on brains of parasitic and non-parasitic birds have been reported. The cooperatively-breeding crotophagine cuckoos do not have large brains for their body size; neither do cooperatively-breeding songbirds have larger brains than other songbirds of the same body size (Iwaniuk and Arnold 2004). In contrast, primate species with the cognitive demands of sociality in complex societies have large brains (Harvey and Krebs 1990, Dunbar 1995, Barton 1996, Kudo and Dunbar 2001). Arboreal cuckoos have smaller brains than terrestrial cuckoos Coua, Carpococcyx and Centropus, in contrast to mammals, where arboreal squirrels have larger brains than terrestrial rodents, as might be expected with the arboreal squirrels’ use of a threedimensional habitat (Eisenberg 1981). Cuckoo brains do not have unusually large olfactory lobes when compared with those of other birds, although the brains of only four cuckoo species have been examined (Bang and Wenzel 1985). The presence of large anal glands in anis (Quay 1967), and
their possible function ( perhaps as in the Hoatzin Opisthocomus hoazin or “Stink-bird” (Newton 1896) which have large olfactory lobes) suggests a direction for further study of olfactory behavior and brain structure in cuckoos. Second, the appearance of the head and bill differs among cuckoos. In the anis the head shape is determined by the bill, which is compressed laterally and expanded into a lateral shield. Bill size and shape may be important in social displays (males have a more prominent profile than females, and adults have a more prominent arc than juveniles), and bills also vary with feeding behavior, with larger bills in species that forage in wet, dense foliage. Bill size and shape vary in the malkohas where bright colors suggest their importance as social signals, and in the lizard-cuckoos where the bill is long and slender. Bills of fruit-eating cuckoos are particularly gross. The nostril shape differs among cuckoos and in early systematic treatments the nostril shape was used to characterize the genera of malkohas (Sharpe 1873).The nostril is circular in many brood-parasitic cuckoos and in the New World cuculines, and slitlike in other brood-parasitic cuckoos. The nostril shape even varies between geographic vicariants within a single species in the Chestnut-breasted Malkoha Phaenicophaeus curvirostris, where the colors of the face and brightly-colored bill with light green, red and black are in different patterns across the range of the species, and the nostril shape varies from a horizontal oval to a vertical slit, with or without a groove extending from the nostril to the cutting edge of the bill. In these birds the nostrils are as variable as the color patterns on the bill, and they may be behavioral signals within a mated pair. In other cuckoos, nostril shape is consistent across species that are closely related in the phylogenetic analyses. Colors of the bill and bare facial skin range from indistinct blackish to bright red, yellow, blue and green. The yellow banana-like bills of some Asian malkohas suggest toucans to a New World ornithologist, and the bicolor huge banana-like bill of Australian Channel-billed Cuckoo led to their original descriptions as “Anomalous Hornbill” and “Psittaceous Hornbill”.A bright blue face is striking both in real life and in photographs of Raffles’s
Morphology 33 Malkoha Rhinortha chlorophaea, Blue-faced Malkoha Phaenicophaeus viridirostris, and several couas Coua, as well as in roadrunners Geococcyx, large forest-living New World ground-cuckoos Neomorphus and Lesser Ground-cuckoo. In some cuckoos the blue contrasts with the neighboring bare skin of orange, red or purple, and in others especially couas the blue is outlined with black. In earlier work on birds, blue skin has often been attributed to the incoherent scattering of light by small particles, the bright violets, blues and greens on the bare faces of these cuckoos may be due to constructive reflection from ordered arrays of collagen arrays, as in other birds with bright blue bare skin. The red facial skin of Red-faced Malkoha is covered with rough papillae, the color disappears when the birds are dead; the source of the color is unknown. Brightly-colored bare skin occurs in many cuckoos, in both the Old World and the New World, especially in the tropical
forests. Bare skin that ranges from violet, blue and green to yellow which reflects certain colors due to constructive interference has evolved at least twice in the cuckoos, once in the Old World and once in the New World. These colors may be associated with colors of the ambient light in forests (Endler 1993, Prum and Torres 2003). Third, the length and proportion of the leg bones vary with arboreal or terrestrial behavior. The legs are longer in proportion to body size in terrestrial cuckoos than in arboreal cuckoos. This morphological adaptation across clades may not have been noted before in birds, perhaps because the mechanics of movement differ between birds and mammals, a group where functional comparisons have been made in more detail (Hildebrand 1974). Engels (1938) and Berger (1952) described the lengths of leg bones in four species of North American cuckoos, but their motive was description
Figure 4.2. Body weight vs total leg length in arboreal and terrestrial cuckoos.
34 The Cuckoos and classification, and not a comparative test of behavior over different clades. In the present study, for cuckoo species that were available as skeletons, the femur, tibiotarsus, and tarsometatarsus were measured and the percentage of the total length of these leg elements was compared with body size (weight) and with terrestrial or arboreal behavior. Across a wide range of body size (23 g to 769 g) the ratios vary with the femur 25–33% of total length, the tibiotarsus 40–44%, and the tarsometatarsus 22–31%.The distal bones do not increase in length disproportionately to the femur with increasing body size, a trend that occurs when birds are compared over a wider range of size (Calder 1984). Terrestrial cuckoos have longer legs and a longer tarsometatarsus than climbing arboreal cuckoos of the same body size (Table 4.1, Figures 4.2, 4.3). Arboreal cuckoos may have short legs to balance and keep a low center of gravity as they move along branches in the canopy. Terrestrial cuckoos with
long legs and a long tarsometatarsus move rapidly without the mechanical problem of high distal mass: angular momentum and the energy to move the legs is an exponential function of the mass of the distal elements, and speed is a function of stride with long legs. Greater Roadrunners on the desert floor for example run very fast with a long stride in pursuit of their lizard prey. The ratios of lengths of leg bones vary less in cuckoos than among other families of birds (Gatesy and Middleton 1997) and large mammals (Scott 1985). Much as in birds, in cursorial ungulates the distal leg bones are longer than the femur.Very large mammals have short distal elements of the leg and a long femur; giants support much weight on their legs, whereas cuckoos are built on a smaller scale. In contrast to the cuckoos, terrestrial squirrels are shorter-legged than arboreal squirrels; the terrestrial squirrels burrow with short legs while arboreal squirrels use their limbs to bound about on branches (Bryant 1945,
Figure 4.3. Body weight vs % tarsometatarsus: leg length in arboreal and terrestrial cuckoos.
Morphology 35 Emry and Thorington 1982, Thorington and Thorington 1989). Cuckoos with rounded wings tend to have a short tarsus or a long digit 3, and there may be other variation in toe length with life style. In all cuckoos, toe 1 is shortest, then toes 2, 4 and 3 (Stephan 2002). In the terrestrial cuckoo that is best known, the Greater Roadrunner, the pelvic muscles originate further anteriorly and laterally than in arboreal
cuckoos. These muscles may support stability and balance in a runner that places its weight alternately on one leg and then the other. Roadrunners have slender leg bones especially the tarsometatarsus, and the toes are mobile and flexible allowing the bird to vary the shape of its foot as it moves on a flat surface (Berger 1952, 1953a, Hughes 1996b). Among the couas Coua of Madagascar, the behavioral differences between species do not appear to co-vary with the dimensions of the tarsus (Milne-Edwards
Table 4.2 Comparative data on the biology of cuckoos, from the species accounts. Species Cuculinae (brood-parasitic) Clamator jacobinus, Jacobin Cuckoo Clamator levaillantii, Levaillant’s Cuckoo Clamator coromandus, Chestnut-winged Cuckoo Clamator glandarius, Great Spotted Cuckoo Pachycoccyx audeberti,Thick-billed Cuckoo Cuculus sparverioides, Large Hawk-cuckoo Cuculus varius, Common Hawk-cuckoo Cuculus vagans, Mustached Hawk-cuckoo Cuculus hyperythrus, Hodgson’s Hawk-cuckoo Cuculus nisicolor,Whistling Hawk-cuckoo Cuculus fugax, Javan Hawk-cuckoo Cuculus pectoralis, Philippine Hawk-cuckoo Cuculus solitarius, Red-chested Cuckoo Cuculus clamosus, Black Cuckoo Cuculus micropterus, Indian Cuckoo Cuculus canorus, Common Cuckoo Cuculus gularis, African Cuckoo Cuculus saturatus, Himalayan Cuckoo Cuculus optatus, Oriental cuckoo Cuculus poliocephalus, Asian Lesser Cuckoo Cuculus rochii, Madagascar Lesser Cuckoo Cuculus mechowi, Dusky Long-tailed Cuckoo Cuculus olivinus, Olive Long-tailed Cuckoo Cuculus montanus, Barred Long-tailed Cuckoo Cacomantis pallidus, Pallid Cuckoo Cacomantis leucolophus,White-crowned Cuckoo Cacomantis sonneratii, Banded Bay Cuckoo Cacomantis merulinus querulus, Plaintive Cuckoo
m wl f wl m wt f wt egg l 154 174 161 199 223 236 201 146 199 178 173 175 172 174 195 221 215 183 206 150 161 138 146 149 193 172 121 110
153 174 160 193 221 227 191 143 196 181 175 174 169 178 194 210 205 175 196 146 160 135 143 143 192 169 124 110
79 90 129 121 77 139 129 92 111 151 101 105 58 62 115 78 76 76 79 78 70 90 87 119 119 117 106 97 110 79 73 99 89 54 54 65 54 58 66 56 59 58 90 86 115 (99) 35 27 25
egg w
egg g
inc da
nestl da
27 26 27 33 24 27 31
22 21 23 24 17 19 20
7.2 6.3 7.9 10.5 3.8 5.4 6.9
12 12
18 13
12.8 13
24 28
28 24
20 16
6.1 3.4
19–20
22 26 25 23 25 21 22 22 18
18 19 19 17 18 16 16 16 14
3.9 12–14 5.2 14 5.0 12 3.6 12 4.5 3.0 3.1 3.1 2.0
17–21 20–21 21 17–20 20–23
23 21 25
16 15 16
3.3 2.6 3.5 12–14
18 20
14 14
2.0 2.2
18–20
36 The Cuckoos Table 4.2 contd. Species Cacomantis variolosus sepulcralis, Brush Cuckoo Cacomantis castaneiventris, Chestnut-breasted Cuckoo Cacomantis flabelliformis, Fan-tailed Cuckoo Chrysococcyx osculans, Black-eared Cuckoo Chrysococcyx basalis, Horsfield’s Bronze-cuckoo Chrysococcyx m. minutillus, Little Bronze-cuckoo Chrysococcyx lucidus plagosus, Shining Bronze-cuckoo Chrysococcyx ruficollis, Rufous-throated Bronze-cuckoo Chrysococcyx meyeri,White-eared Bronze-cuckoo Chrysococcyx maculatus, Asian Emerald Cuckoo Chrysococcyx xanthorhynchus,Violet Cuckoo Chrysococcyx klaas, Klaas’s Cuckoo Chrysococcyx cupreus, African Emerald Cuckoo Chrysococcyx caprius, Diederik Cuckoo Surniculus dicruroides, Fork-tailed Drongo-cuckoo Surniculus velutinus, Philippine Drongo-cuckoo Surniculus lugubris, Square-tailed Drongo-cuckoo Microdynamis parva, Dwarf Koel Eudynamys s. scolopacea, Common Koel Eudynamys s. cyanocephala, Common Koel Urodynamis taitensis, Long-tailed Cuckoo Scythrops novaehollandiae, Channel-billed Cuckoo Cuculinae (Old World), nesting Ceuthmochares australis,Whistling Yellowbill Phaenicophaeus curvirostris, Chestnut-breasted Malkoha Phaenicophaeus pyrrhocephalus, Red-faced Malkoha Phaenicophaeus diardi, Black-bellied Malkoha Phaenicophaeus sumatranus, Chestnut-bellied Malkoha Phaenicophaeus tristis, Green-billed Malkoha Phaenicophaeus viridirostris, Blue-faced Malkoha Taccocua leschenaultii, Sirkeer Malkoha Rhinortha chlorophaea, Raffles’s Malkoha Zanclostomus javanicus, Red-billed Malkoha Rhamphococcyx calyorhynchus,Yellow-billed Malkoha Dasylophus superciliosus, Rough-crested Malkoha Dasylophus cumingi, Scale-feathered Malkoha Cuculinae (New World), nesting Coccycua pumilus, Dwarf Cuckoo Coccycua cinerea, Ash-colored Cuckoo Coccyzus erythropthalmus, Black-billed Cuckoo Coccyzus americanus,Yellow-billed Cuckoo
m wl 116 110 144 118 103 94 106 95 89 109 100 96 104 117 136 117 126 105 195 217 189 354
f wl m wt f wt egg l 115 33 32 20 113 30 32 21 141 50 50 21 117 29 32 20 101 22 24 18 92 19 19 19 106 23 25 18 95 21 24 89 18 21 109 25 30 17 100 20 26 16 95 26 29 19 102 38 37 20 121 34 41 21 135 38 22.5 117 33 38 124 30 31 21 102 43 51 189 229 31 215 262 257 34 186 110 124 24 347 708 660 41
egg w 15 15 15 14 12 13 12
egg g inc da 2.5 12–13 2.6 2.6 2.2 1.4 11–13 1.8 1.4 13–14
12 12 13 15 15 17
1.4 1.3 1.8 11–12 2.5 13–14 2.6 12 3.6
16
3.0
124 169 155 130 139 163 135 158 115 144 177 151 157
124 172 157 131 139 161 131 154 116 145 180 157 159
68 64 30 152 144 39.7 36 66 57 30 114 28.5 116 114 34 84 29 219 140 36 56 62 28 98 97 29 36 115 120 174 167
23 28.4 27 24.5 23.5 26 25 26 24 23 31
102 107 135 139
102 110 139 144
36* 37 47 58
19.6 19 21 23
24.9 45 25.5 54 27 65 30
23 24 17 29
9.1 13–14 10.8 14–17 3.8 16 19.1 8.7 17.7 14.5 10.0 8.7 13.5 10.0 13.5 8.9 8.5 19.1
nestl da 17–19
18 17–19 18–21
19–21 18–20 20–22
19–28 19–28 21–29 17–24
13
5.3 12 5.1 6.6 10–11 8.8 10–11
12 8–9 8–9
Morphology 37 Table 4.2 contd. Coccyzus euleri, Pearly-breasted Cuckoo Coccyzus minor, Mangrove Cuckoo Coccyzus melacoryphus, Dark-billed Cuckoo Coccyzus lansbergi, Gray-capped Cuckoo Coccyzus merlini, Cuban Lizard-cuckoo Coccyzus vieilloti, Puerto Rican Lizard-cuckoo Coccyzus longirostris, Hispaniolan Lizard-cuckoo Coccyzus vetula, Jamaican Lizard-cuckoo Coccyzus pluvialis, Chestnut-bellied Cuckoo Coccyzus rufigularis, Rufous-breasted Cuckoo Piaya cayana, Squirrel Cuckoo Piaya melanogaster, Black-bellied Cuckoo Coccycua minuta, Little Cuckoo Couinae, nesting Carpococcyx radiatus, Bornean Ground-cuckoo Carpococcyx renauldi, Coral-billed Ground-cuckoo Coua gigas, Giant Coua Coua coquereli, Coquerel’s Coua Coua serriana, Red-breasted Coua Coua reynaudii, Red-fronted Coua Coua cursor, Running Coua Coua ruficeps, Red-capped Coua Coua cristata, Crested Coua Coua verreauxi,Verreaux’s Coua Coua caerulea, Blue Coua Centropodinae, nesting Centropus celebensis, Bay Coucal Centropus unirufus, Rufous Coucal Centropus melanops, Black-faced Coucal Centropus nigrorufus, Sunda Coucal Centropus milo, Buff-headed Coucal Centropus goliath, Goliath Coucal Centropus violaceus,Violaceous Coucal Centropus menbeki, Greater Black Coucal Centropus chalybeus, Biak Coucal Centropus ateralbus, Pied Coucal Centropus p. phasianinus, Pheasant Coucal Centropus p. spilopterus, Kai Coucal Centropus bernsteini, Lesser Black Coucal Centropus rectunguis, Short-toed Coucal Centropus steerii, Black-hooded Coucal Centropus s. sinensis, Greater Coucal
128 137 115 114 174 129 134 124 177 171 171 136 105
133 132 116 114 180 130 137 126 194 184 184 135 105
49 64 46 50 134 80 92 95 130 128 104 99 41
57 67 54
31 29 26 40 34 37 32.5 40 38 35 30 24
23 22 20 30 25 25 24 31 25 26 23 19
9.1 7.8 11–12 5.8 27.1 11.8 12.8 10.4 21.3 13.1 13.1 18 8.8 4.8
259 278 221 144 165 137 130 168 139 134 195
253 455(540) 47 278 (400) 44 214 413 420 43.5 148 33.5 168 298 139 240 163 36 133 118 34 168 190 34 146 144 145 35 131 200 236 254 37
35 34 32 25
35.6 28.1 18–19 25.7 11.6
173 156 162 208 272 263 311 225 203 202 226 228 174 164 159 203
182 162 168 201 162 211 238 224 267 769* 271 401 622 261 (500) 221 503 529 203 214 330 342 249 302 445 252 180 146 180 197 238* 164 179 163 215 255 370
155 92 105 189 100 93 40
28 23 28 26.5
15.6 9.9 14.7 13.6
28.5
16.6
31 39
26 31
11.6 21.3
43 37
34 30
27.5 18.4
41 38 36 32 37
33 29 27 25.5 30
24.7 17.7 14.5 11.5 18.4
36
28
7–9 8–13
8⫹
18–24
15
17–21
15.6 15–16
18–22
38 The Cuckoos Table 4.2 contd. Species m wl f wl m wt f wt egg l egg w egg g inc da nestl da Centropus s. andamanensis, Brown Coucal 180 183 234 35 28 15.2 Centropus toulou, Madagascar Coucal 148 168 173 180 33 26 12.3 14–16 19 Centropus grillii, African black Coucal 152 169 100 151 31 24 9.9 18–20 Centropus bengalensis, Lesser Coucal 134 159 86 148 28 24 8.9 Centropus v. viridis, Philippine Coucal 148 160 112 134 30 25 10.4 14 Centropus chlororhynchus, Green-billed Coucal 167 175 35 27 14.1 Centropus leucogaster, Black-throated Coucal 189 198 293 336 Centropus anselli, Gabon Coucal 186 195 210 Centropus monachus, Blue-headed Coucal 187 186 171 237 35 27 14.1 Centropus cupreicaudus, Coppery-tailed Coucal 214 224 272 299 38 28 16.5 17⫹ Centropus senegalensis, Senegal Coucal 160 164 169 169 34 26 12.7 17–19 18–20 Centropus superciliosus,White-browed Coucal 146 154 124 136 33 25 11.4 14–15 18–20 Crotophaginae, nesting (cooperative breeder) Crotophaga major, Greater Ani 203 201 171 152 45 38 35.9 13–14 8–10 Crotophaga ani, Smooth-billed Ani 149 149 111 92 35 27 14.1 13–14 13–17 Crotophaga sulcirostris, Groove-billed Ani 135 131 80 67 31 24 9.9 12–14 10 Guira guira, Guira Cuckoo 179 174 139 145 43 32 2.46 12–13 12–15 Neomorphinae (nesting or brood parasite) Tapera naevia, American Striped Cuckoo (brood parasite) 119 113 49.4 51.1 22 17 3.5 15–16 18 Dromococcyx phasianellus, Pheasant Cuckoo “ 166 163 85 98 25 14.5 2.9 Dromococcyx pavoninus, Pavonine Cuckoo “ 134 137 50 45 21 15 2.6 Morococcyx erythropygus, Lesser Ground-cuckoo 101 102 63 68 27 21 6.6 Geococcyx californianus, Greater Roadrunner 178 171 344 309 39 30 19.4 17–18 17–19 Geococcyx velox, Lesser Roadrunner 146 141 186 174 35 26 13.1 Neomorphus geoffroyi, Rufous-vented Ground-cuckoo 169 164 350 386 43 32 24.3 Neomorphus rufipennis, Rufous-winged Ground-cuckoo 170 164 435 328 40 31 21.3 Neomorphus pucheranii, Red-billed Ground-cuckoo 172 166 330 Data are from the species accounts: m wl ⫽ male wing (mm), f wl ⫽ female wing (mm), m wt ⫽ male weight (g), f wt ⫽ female weight (g), egg l ⫽ egg length (mm), egg w ⫽ egg width (mm), egg g ⫽ egg weight (g), inc da ⫽ incubation period (days), nestl da ⫽ nestling period (days). In Graph 1, for Carpococcyx, brain size is for Carpococcyx renauldi and body size is for C. radiatus; the ground-cuckoos are about the same in other body measurements. Figures in parens were based on single individuals of atypical body condition, as described in the species accounts, and these are not included in all graphs. * indicates unsexed birds.
and Grandidier 1879, Berger 1960); tarsi are long in the arboreal Coua caerulea and the terrestrial C. gigas and C. ruficeps, and short in the climber C. reynaudii and the terrestrial C. cursor. The main difference between couas is in the longer tendons and the site of their attachment in the long-legged forms
(Berger 1960). Fourth, wing shape in cuckoos varies with the longest primary ranging from the 9th (the most pointed wing) to the 2nd (the most rounded and broad wing).The wing length and shape vary with migratory behavior. Pointed wings are seen in the
Morphology 39
Figure 4.4. Wing length and body mass in cuckoos.
migratory Cuculus species and rounded wings in the ground-cuckoos and in coucals Centropus, where the longest primary is P7, P6 or P5 in Lesser Coucal C. bengalensis and P4, P3 or P2 in the large Greater Black Coucal C. menbeki. The migratory northern hawk-cuckoos have more pointed wings than the more tropical species (Rufous Hawkcuckoo Hierococcyx hyperythrus and Whistling Hawk-cuckoo H. nisicolor, compared with Javan Hawk-cuckoo H. fugax and Philippine Hawkcuckoo H. pectoralis). The long wings of broodparasitic cuckoos in the Old World are related to their migratory behavior and not to brood parasitism, insofar as the New World brood-parasitic cuckoos are residents and have short wings (Table 4.2, Figure 4.4). Many nesting cuckoos are shortwinged, especially resident tropical birds, and so are a few forest brood parasites especially the African long-tailed cuckoos Cercococcyx, which have a
rounded wing with the inner primaries P4-7 longer than the outer primaries P8-9. Wing shape in cuckoos has been described in detail from the lengths of the wing feathers in relation to ulna length (Stephan 2001a, Figure 4.5). In Figure 4.5, the primaries are numbered from the proximal end of the carpometacarpus, the secondaries S1 from the distal end of the ulna, S6 and the more inner secondaries from the proximal end of the ulna, and S2-5 from their corresponding points of attachment along the ulna. In another comparison, the length of “free” primaries relative to “free” secondaries captures the shape of the wing, the term indicating the length of feathers that extend beyond the wing coverts (Stephan 2001a, Figure 4.6). All cuckoos can fly and have a keeled sternum, even in the terrestrial roadrunners which more often walk and run than fly. The shape of the
Figure 4.5. Wing shape in cuckoos, with relative lengths of the primaries and secondaries (after Stephan 2001a). Lengths of the wing feathers are plotted from their positions of attachment along the ulna, which is represented by the two small circles on each wing: a, Scythrops novaehollandiae; b, Cuculus canorus; c, Eudynamys scolopacea malayana; d, Clamator levaillantii; e, Rhamphococcyx calyorhynchus; f, Piaya cayana; g, Centropus celebensis; h, Coua ruficeps; i, Tapera naevia; j, Geococcyx californianus.
Morphology 41
Figure 4.6. Wing shape in cuckoos, with extent of “free” primaries and secondaries: a, rounded wing, Geococcyx californianus; b, pointed wing, migratory Cuculus canorus (after Stephan 2001a).
sternum varies with life habits among Coua species, the more arboreal couas with a more convex and strongly keeled sternum than the terrestrial couas (Milne Edwards and Grandidier 1879). Finally, much variation in wing morphology of cuckoos can be explained by their phylogenetic associations, such as coucals being short-winged owing to being related to other short-winged coucals, and secondarily owing to their terrestrial and non-migratory behavior. Coucals have short wing bones as well (Milne-Edwards and Grandidier 1879, Berger 1952, 1953a); and the New World terrestrial roadrunners Geococcyx and to a lesser extent the anis Crotophaga have shorter wing bones relative to leg bones than the Coccyzus cuckoos (Larson 1930, Engels 1938, Berger 1952).
Sexual size dimorphism Among most cuckoos the sexes are nearly the same in size (Table 4.2, Figures 4.7, 4.8). Sexual dimorphism in body size does not vary among cuckoos as
much in relation to their breeding biology as to their systematic status. Among the coucals, females are larger than males in the monogamous species such as Pheasant Coucal, where the female is half again the mass of the male and both sexes care for the young, and in the sometimes-polyandrous African Black Coucal where the male looks after the young. The degree of sexual size dimorphism is consistent across subspecies in the coucal species that vary geographically in size (as in Greater Coucal and Philippine Coucal). The largest degree of sexual size dimorphism occurs in the smaller coucals, unlike birds such as grouse where sexual size dimorphism is greater in the larger species (Rensch 1950, Payne 1984, Abouheif and Fairbairn 1997). Among the smaller coucals the females are larger than the males, with larger coucals the sexes are the same size, and with the largest coucals the males are larger than the females. With other kinds of birds, reversed sexual size dimorphism where females are the larger sex is sometimes associated with polyandry, as in buttonquail, tinamous Tinamidae, painted snipe Rostratulidae, jacanas Jacanidae and some other shorebirds (Payne 1984, Andersson 1994, 1995). Insofar as reversed sexual size dimorphism occurs both in some monogamous birds and in polyandrous birds, the large size of female coucals does not necessarily indicate a polyandrous mating system among coucals. Other explanations of sexual size dimorphism include the ability of large females to lay more or larger eggs, or to defend the young where the small and agile males forage for the females and leave them at the nest, as with many monogamous hawks and owls. Reduced competition for food between mates among some birds is also a correlate of sexual size dimorphism, though the use of prey of different sizes may follow sexual size dimorphism that evolved for other reasons (Andersson 1994). Coucals have a long hallux claw, much as do some other terrestrial birds such as larks and pipits, while other birds have long claws on all the toes (longclaws Macronyx spp., jacanas Jacanidae, Longtoed Lapwing Vanellus crassirostris, Purple Heron Ardea purpurea), birds that live in grassland and on weak-stemmed and floating aquatic vegetation. In coucals the hallux claw ranges from 32–35% of tarsus length (in the large Buff-headed Coucal
42 The Cuckoos
Figure 4.7. Sexual size dimorphism in body size in cuckoos: body mass.
Centropus milo and Violaceous Coucal C. violaceus), to 68–76% of tarsus length (in the small marshliving African Black Coucal C. grillii and Lesser Coucal C. bengalensis). An exception is Short-toed Coucal C. rectunguis in which the hallux claw is only 23% of tarsus length. A test of whether the hallux claw is a sexually selected trait in coucals is whether the claw is proportionally larger in one sex. The diagonal line in Figure 4.9 indicates the position where male and female claws are equally long in relation to tarsus length. About the same number of coucal species have males with relatively longer claws on average than females. When claw length is compared with body size, there is no trend for species with a large size to have proportionally larger claws in females than in males. Also there is no increase in relative size of the claw of the sex with larger body size, as there is with measurements in other polygamous birds (Payne 1984).The lack of sexual
dimorphism in this prominent feature of coucals does not support the idea that the reversed sexual size dimorphism of coucals has been driven by polyandry. Sexual differences in size of cuckoos might be related to female aggressive behavior. In some hawks, falcons and owls, the female takes the lead in social dominance or territorial behavior of the pair (Pleasants and Pleasants 1989, Mueller 1990). Field observations on mating among cuckoos do not suggest female social dominance over males. In the cooperatively breeding anis, females are about the same size as males. Females compete for the position of their eggs in a communal nest and they remove each others’ eggs, yet within a group the body size is not larger in the socially dominant females at a nest (Vehrencamp et al. 1986). Large female size may also be related to egg size in anis, where large eggs provide nestlings a head start for growth in the competition for parental care in a brood.
Morphology 43
Figure 4.8. Sexual size dimorphism in body size in cuckoos: wing length.
Plumage The body plumage of ground-cuckoos, couas and malkohas is soft and lax.The plumage becomes wet in the rain, and the birds often sun themselves to dry after a shower and even on a warm morning (Forbush 1927, Cracraft 1964). The anis have smooth, dense glossy plumage, a texture that appears to be related to foraging in wet foliage. Their feathers still become soaked, and in cool wet weather the anis spread their wings in the sun’s rays to dry (Skutch 1983), like a vulture or a cormorant. Coucals that forage in wet habitats do the same. None of these plumage traits are exclusive to cuckoos, as some gruiform birds and doves have the same kind of lax plumage and soft pastel colors of purples and pinks like the plumage of couas and malkohas. Cuckoos also have bristles, specialized contour feathers with a stiff rachis, and barbs are unfused and restricted to the feather base (Stettenheim 1973).
Specialized feathers are found on the face of many nesting cuckoos. The eyelashes are small and inconspicuous in several cuckoos but are conspicuous, stiff and curved without vanes or barbs in some malkohas (Yellow-billed Malkoha Rhamphococcyx calyorhynchus, Green-billed Malkoha Phaenicophaeus tristis, Black-bellied Malkoha P. diardi, short and thin in Blue-faced Malkoha P. viridirostris, Rough-crested Malkoha Dasylophus superciliosus and Scale-feathered Malkoha D. cumingi), and they are particularly long and stout in Sirkeer Malkoha Taccocua leschenaultii which live in semi-arid sandy habitats.The eyelashes are short in Red-faced Malkoha P. pyrrhocephalus and in the African yellowbills Ceuthmochares; they are absent in the small Raffles’s Malkoha Rhinortha chlorophaea. The eyelashes are conspicuous in New World squirrel-cuckoos Piaya; they are short in Coccycua and Coccyzus. Eyelashes are also found in anis and in large terrestrial cuckoos including Coua, Carpococcyx, Centropus, Geococcyx and Neomorphus. Eyelashes are short in Clamator and are absent or
44 The Cuckoos
Figure 4.9. Size and sexual size dimorphism in hallux claw in coucals Centropus. Measurements are in the species accounts.
not noticeable in other Old World brood-parasitic cuckoos. The face and head have some feathers with long delicate projections of the rachis or shaft from the loose-webbed base of vaned feathers in the malkohas. In Sirkeer Malkoha these shafts are stiff and only a small length of the feather base has a vane. In Chestnut-bellied Malkoha P. sumatranus the feathers are recurved forward especially around the base of the bill. In Blue-faced Malkoha P. viridirostris the lower head, neck and breast feathers are forked. In these unique feathers, the bifurcation is formed by stiff terminal barbs that cling together on each side of the central feather shaft, which protrudes as a fine free black hair-like bristle. Delicate hair-like shafts occur in some other cuckoos including Great Spotted Cuckoo, although these structures are not evident in most Old World brood-parasitic cuckoos
(Cuculus, Chrysococcyx, Eudynamys, Scythrops). In the New World, the Guira Cuckoo and roadrunners have long delicate feathers around the face (Figure 4.10). The feathers on the face and head occur in an extreme form with a thickening and fusion of barbs in two Philippine malkohas. Rough-crested Malkoha Dasylophus superciliosus has superciliary crests formed by stiff reddish barbs; at the base a few more basal barbs form a loose-webbed vane on each side of the shaft. Perhaps the most bizarre head feathers are in Scale-feathered Malkoha D. cumingi whose terminal barbs are fused at the tip into a single shiny metallic flat blue-black shield that contrasts with the white vane near the base of the feather.The tips are formed of fused barbs that are densely packed with melanin, while the surfaces are thick layers of keratin with little melanin (Brush
Morphology 45
Figure 4.10. Facial feathers of cuckoos: Greater Roadrunner Geococcyx californianus and Guira Cuckoo Guira guira.
1965). The tips of the crest feathers are twisted to reveal the same iridescent color on each side of the head. Some coucals have hackles, robust elaborate feathers on the neck, with conspicuous stiff feather shafts, the shaft color often in contrast to the feather vane. In Greater Roadrunner the head has stout, bare, black terminal shafts that project outward and backward over the eyes, barbed bristles around the base of the bill, and short recurved feather shafts all around the head, while Rufousvented Ground-cuckoo has dark bare eyelash bristles above and below the eye, and semibristles in front of the eye. Many cuckoos have long tails that function as rudders in slow flight in the arboreal species, and as steering devices and balancers in the cursorial ground-living species. Cuckoo tails are also conspicuous in courtship behavior.The tails often have
contrasting colors, with broad or narrow white tips in many malkohas and New World arboreal cuckoos, and red tips on green tails in Chestnut-breasted Malkoha P. curvirostris. Raffles’s Malkohas Rhinortha chlorophaea are sexually dimorphic, the males with the tail finely barred black and gray in a washboard pattern and broadly tipped white; the females with the tail rufous and a black subterminal band and white tip. In several cuckoos (Common Cuckoo, Sirkeer Malkoha,Yellow-billed Cuckoo) the tail is spread and held above the back, exposing the color pattern on the dorsal surface in frontal display to the mate. In some cuckoos the edges of the tail feathers are “notched” with a V-shaped area of contrasting color, the apex toward the feather shaft; in others the notches are extended well towards the shaft and almost form a bar. The notches are distinctive of certain species especially of the brush cuckoos Cacomantis. Tails are most elaborate in the small ground cuckoos Dromococcyx of the New World tropics, with the long rectrices arrayed in a fan and the upper tail coverts cascading nearly the full length of the tail, each pointed covert feather with a black band and a delicate white spot at the tip. In display the bird arches the tail coverts over the body.
Natal down and naked nestlings Natal down of cuckoos is hair-like, a single keratinized shaft called a “trichoptile” (hair-feather), rather than an array of non-interlocking barbs as is the fluffy natal down of many kinds of birds.These trichoptiles are not down-like in structure but are down-like in being the first set of feathers on a young bird.They are present at hatching or within a day or two in most cuckoos, and are developmentally homologous with the natal down of other birds. The trichoptile grows from the same follicle as the juvenile contoured feather, and when the pinfeather bursts open, the hair-like natal down remains attached to the tip for a day or two in the same position on the tip of the feather as the fluffy down of songbirds. The down is often worn away by the time the nestling fledges. This down is white in many cuckoos; it differs in color between certain closely-related species (gray in
46 The Cuckoos Yellow-billed Cuckoo, white in Black-billed Cuckoo).A few nesting cuckoos have not been studied as hatchlings but have soft body feathers as feathered nestlings (Scale-feathered Malkoha); these may be loose-webbed juvenile contoured feathers rather than natal down. Malkohas, of which the nestling has been studied and described, have hair-like natal down. In young cuckoo nestlings with dark skin, such as Black-billed Cuckoo and Greater Roadrunner, the white hair-like down forms a strong pattern of contrast with the skin. In the nesting cuckoos, these feathers appear to be continuous with the sheath that covers the growing first generation of contoured feathers. Hair-like down is prominent in the coucals Centropus, where the feathers are white, stiff and sometimes as long as 20 mm and the nestlings look like spiny hedgehogs; less typical of young coucals is Lesser Black Coucal C. bernsteini which has only short white tips attached to the growing contoured feathers on the head. Natal down is absent in the nesting Old World ground-cuckoos Carpococcyx and Madagascar couas Coua, both as hatchlings and when they fledge. In adult cuckoos, fluffy down-like feathers are limited to the apteria. Natal down is absent in the brood-parasitic cuckoos, and this may be explained by the fact that the naked skin of nestlings is sensitive to the touch of host eggs which they evict, and natal down would interfere with this close contact. An exception is Shining Bronze-cuckoo, which has a few small hairlike feathers in New Zealand and New Caledonia, and few or none in southern and Western Australia where the young are naked; Little Bronze-cuckoo also has some natal down. Nestling brood-parasitic cuckoos evict the host egg from the nest; natal down in those bronze cuckoos is mainly on the head, thigh and side, rather than on the back where the egg is balanced in eviction behavior. Nestling crested cuckoos Clamator, like other Old World brood-parasitic cuckoos, lack natal down, and nestling brood-parasitic American Striped Cuckoos in the New World also hatch naked without down.
Plumage change with age Juvenile plumages are variable in a few broodparasitic cuckoos. Jacobin Cuckoo and Levaillant’s
Cuckoo juveniles occur that are dull versions of the adult plumage phases, and in East-Central Africa a rufous color phase occurs in Levaillant’s Cuckoo. Juvenile Diederik Cuckoos vary in plumage in some regions, with rufous juveniles in areas where the cuckoos parasitize bishop finches, Euplectes species. It is unknown whether the color variants of cuckoos are genetically different (diederiks have egg races in these areas, and the plumage may correspond with egg races), or the rufous plumage is a result of bishop foster parents rearing the young on seeds rather than entirely on insects as in the greenplumaged juveniles that are reared by the more insectivorous weavers Ploceus. Juvenile plumage in most cuckoos is similar to adult plumage, especially so in the nesting cuckoos. The transition from juvenile to adult appearance occurs early in life. The main difference in plumage is the shape of the rectrices (narrow and pointed in juvenile plumage, more broad and rounded or truncate in the adult) and the presence and extent of white tips on the rectrices (less in juveniles), or the presence of barred rectrices (barred in juvenile coucals, not barred in adult coucals). Juveniles are quick to assume adult head plumage. Philippine Red-crested Malkoha and Scale-feathered Malkoha with their elaborate head plumage grow these feathers within a few weeks of leaving the nest and have their showy adult head plumage by the time the tail is fully grown. A few flight feathers in wing and tail are often retained into the first breeding plumage of the coucals Centropus spp. The cuckoos with the most strongly age-graded plumage, where juvenile plumage differs from adult plumage, are certain brood-parasites. None of these cuckoos mimic the plumages of their host species. Juvenile Common Koels Eudynamys scolopacea have black plumage like their crow hosts in much of their range, yet this is characteristic only of male juveniles; female koels have a spotted brown juvenile plumage that is intermediate between that of juvenile males and adult females. Behavioral associations with the host species may nevertheless have some effect on juvenile plumage. In koels the plumage somewhat resembles that of their host species, dark like crows in India where
Morphology 47 koels parasitize crows, and streaked brown in Australia where they parasitize brown honeyeaters. The juvenile plumage of Philippine Drongocuckoo Surniculus velutinus is similar to that of a paradise flycatcher Terpsiphone cinnamomea, but the host of this cuckoo is unknown and the similarity of juvenile plumages in these birds is no more than a teasing clue to the mystery of their breeding behavior. A distinctive subadult plumage that is retained for a year after the molt from juvenile plumage occurs in the Asian hawk-cuckoos, as described for some of these birds by Mayr (1938b); previously these had been confused as a female plumage (Siebers 1930). Species with a distinct subadult plumage are Large Hawk-cuckoo Hierococcyx sparverioides, Dark Hawk-cuckoo H. bocki, Rufous Hawk-cuckoo H. hyperythrus, Whistling Hawkcuckoo H. nisicolor, Javan Hawk-cuckoo H. fugax, and Philippine Hawk-cuckoo H. pectoralis. At least one hawk-cuckoo breeds in subadult plumage, Philippine Hawk-cuckoo females laying in this plumage as well as in the definitive unstreaked adult plumage. In the Sulawesi Cuckoo Cuculus crassirostris also a distinct subadult plumage occurs and specimens with this plumage are more common in museum collections than are the juveniles, which have a white head much as that of the closely related Indian Cuckoo C. micropterus, but nothing is known of their breeding. Burchell’s Coucal Centropus superciliosus burchellii breed in subadult plumage as well as in the definitive plumage that lacks the white eye-stripe. Another coucal with subadult plumage is a subspecies of Blue-headed Coucal C. monachus heuglini in the southern Sudan, where its breeding has not been studied. In known cases, the development of sexual maturity is completed well before the development of adult plumage. Among these cuckoos the sexes are alike in plumage and both sexes have the full set of plumages. In both Centropus superciliosus and C. monachus, the other subspecies lack the extra plumage and breed in the plumage that looks like the “subadult” plumage of these two subspecies. The lack of a subadult plumage is probably related to the rapid development of sexual maturity of cuckoos in general.
Cuckoos sometimes retain a few juvenile feathers through their first year, particularly in the wing (e.g., Great Spotted Cuckoo, Diederik Cuckoo Chrysococcyx caprius and Klaas’s Cuckoo Chrysococcyx klaas).The retained juvenile feathers show that these cuckoos breed in their first year, as these birds with mixed plumage have been taken with eggs in the oviduct. Earlier studies misinterpreted the great variation in adult plumage of some cuckoos (e.g., Black Cuckoo, Bannerman 1921) to be due to the number of years it takes a bird to develop an adult plumage. The larger number of specimens now available for examination in museums shows that each adult plumage form follows a single molt from the all-black plumage of the juvenile, in which the tail tip is black and not white as in the adult. Insofar as cuckoos usually breed in their first year, there is no reason to expect a series of subadult plumages. If birds that attempt to breed in their first year are less successful in reproduction over their lifetimes than those that do not attempt to breed at that time, then a delay in sexual activity in the first year may be the more productive life history strategy, and we should see sexual inactivity in birds with a lessthan-definitive plumage. The idea of a “delayed plumage maturation” is derived from the more general concept of “delayed maturation”, which proposes that few first-year birds are competent to breed, and that early reproduction negatively affects their later success (Lack 1954, Selander 1965,Williams 1966).A logical consequence of this life history theory is that individuals with plumages unlike the older adults are sexually inactive. If this is true, we predict that these birds do not breed, or when they do breed they have a lower survival and lifetime reproduction. However in many cuckoos the birds with odd plumages are sexually active. Female cuckoos with a few juvenile feathers in their plumage have been taken with eggs in the oviduct so they were actively breeding, as described in the species accounts of Plaintive Cuckoo C. merulinus, Brush Cuckoo and black-billed Common Koel Eudynamys scolopacea melanorhyncha. There is no indication that brood-parasitic birds have a long life (Payne 1977b).They are expected to breed in their first year: if they deferred breeding in the first year, they would have a high chance of dying before the next year. In some cooperatively-living species of
48 The Cuckoos songbirds the definitive adult plumage may not occur while the young are living in a group with older, socially and sexually dominant individuals (Rowley and Russell 1997). These long-lived cooperatively breeding birds are one group where “delayed maturation” might occur, although with removal of older birds in the group, the younger birds become breeders themselves. However, in the cooperativelybreeding anis Crotophaga and Guira Cuckoo Guira guira which compete for social status at communal nests, where increased maturity might give the birds some benefit in competing with their group members, the species do not have distinct subadult plumages, and these birds do not have a long life span. A few coucals molt into a winter non-breeding plumage before they molt into the adult breeding plumage (African Black Coucal Centropus grillii, Lesser Coucal C. bengalensis, Australian Pheasant Coucal C. p. phasianinus, and some other coucals). These birds are known to molt from breeding plumage back to a nonbreeding plumage, at least in forms where specimens are available from all seasons; a second- and later-year non-breeding plumage is not known for the New Guinea races of Pheasant Coucal. In Blue-headed Coucal Centropus monachus fischeri and in White-browed Coucal C. superciliosus burchellii and C. s. fasciipygialis, a distinctive subadult plumage is retained for a year after the molt from juvenile plumage and before the molt to definitive adult plumage. In addition, Stresemann (1913a) thought Greater Coucal C. sinensis had a series of subadult plumages based on the variation in the retained juvenile feathers in birds in partial adult plumage. He also noted the absence of museum specimens of Lesser Coucal in molt from adult breeding plumage to nonbreeding plumage.The lack of molting specimens may be due to the secretive behavior of birds after the breeding season, rather than to a lack of a post-breeding molt. It would be useful to keep these birds in captivity and observe their sequence of molts and plumages. Some coucals also have a distinct adult nonbreeding plumage, at least in their first year. They molt from juvenile plumage into this alternate nonbreeding plumage and maintain the plumage for a season before they molt into an adult breeding plumage. The nonbreeding plumage has sometimes been
overlooked owing to its similarity with the juvenile plumage. Although there is no evidence of an adult nonbreeding plumage for most coucals, distinct nonbreeding plumages are known for a few species including Lesser Coucal C. bengalensis throughout its range and the Pheasant Coucals C. phasianinus nigricans, C. p. thierfeldi and C. p. spilopterus in New Guinea and the Kai Islands. The question remains whether birds with a distinct subadult or nonbreeding plumage maintain the adult breeding plumage all year into later years, or assume a distinct non-breeding plumage as in birds in molt from black to pale plumage in Pheasant Coucals of Australia, Lesser Coucal, African Black Coucal and Madagascar Coucal C. toulou. Again, it would be informative to watch the plumage change through the seasons within an individual bird species.
Sexual dimorphism in plumage A few cuckoos are sexually dimorphic in plumage color, perhaps more among the Old World parasitic cuckoos where males are conspicuous and glossy and females are cryptic and not so glossy like the African and Asian Chrysococcyx, and the Common Koel where males are black and females are brown. The eye-ring and iris color and pattern (a ring in the iris) also differ between the sexes in some cuckoos, both in glossy cuckoos where sex is apparent from eye color like the Little Bronze-cuckoo and Shining Bronze-cuckoo, and in several malkohas. Conspicuous plumage dimorphism is not known in nesting cuckoos except in Raffles’s Malkoha Rhinortha chlorophaea.
Plumage phases and color morphs Adult plumage is typically cryptically colored in the brood-parasitic cuckoos. In several brood-parasitic cuckoos more than one adult plumage phase occurs within a population and these color phases are limited to the females. In several Cuculus species the females occur in either a gray phase like the adult male or a barred rufous (or “hepatic”) color phase. The proportion of female Common Cuckoos with gray or rufous plumage varies in Europe, where rufous females are most common in Central Europe,
Morphology 49 and the proportion of color phases parallels that of Accipiter hawks and Falco falcons (Voipio 1953).The variation in plumage may be density-dependent, where a bird in the rarer plumage phase has an advantage in not being recognized by naive songbirds, while the more common form is recognized and the cuckoo is chased away from the nest before it can lay (Payne 1967). Distinct plumage color phases (gray without bars, rufous with bars) also occur in breeding female Plaintive Cuckoo and Brush Cuckoo (not in all subspecies). Plumage variation in the Pallid Cuckoo Cacomantis pallidus of Australia appears to the number of rufous feathers grown after the postjuvenile molt (not retained juvenile feathers, which are white and black) and after adult molt in later years in breeding females. Finally, female Common Koels Eudynamys scolopacea melanocephala in Sulawesi have three plumage phases, and females in each of these plumages are known to lay as they have each been collected with an egg in the oviduct (Stresemann 1940). Two species of brood-parasitic crested cuckoos Clamator, Jacobin Cuckoo and Levaillant’s Cuckoo, have color phases in both sexes: a pied phase that is white or whitish below, and a black phase where white is limited to a wing patch (and in Levaillant’s Cuckoo to the tip of the tail). In both cuckoos the black phase is limited to a small part of the distributional range of the species in Africa. Color morphs and locally distinct subspecies that differ in plumage color occur among several nesting cuckoos, particularly the coucals. In some the plumage is partly albinistic. In the Andaman Islands, Greater Coucal Centropus sinensis andamanensis has a pale body (buffy white or dusky gray) rather than a black body as in most other subspecies, and on Kangean I south of Borneo the form C. s. kangeangensis likewise has a pale body (buffy white or dusky gray). On Timor the only specimen collected of Pheasant Coucal C. phasianinus has been described as a subspecies (C. p. mui) and has a white breast, in contrast to other populations of Pheasant Coucal which have black underparts in breeding plumage and buff with paler streaks in nonbreeding plumage. Goliath Coucal C. goliath in the northern Moluccas has a whitish morph in Halmahera. Melanistic or black plumages occur in certain coucal populations on
islands, especially in Philippine Coucal C. viridis with two subspecies having black wings (C. v. mindoroensis, C. v. carpenteri) unlike the rufous wings of coucals elsewhere in the Philippines, and on Luzon an uncommon white phase occurs in a population where most birds are black and rufous. Pied Coucal C. ateralbus in the Bismarck Archipelago have four distinct color phases in the amount of white in the adult plumage; birds with intermediate plumage are also known. Senegal Coucal C. senegalensis have a dark rufous color phase “epomidis” in humid areas of coastal West Africa; other birds in these populations are white below.
Other comments on plumage The cuckoo wing is eutaxic, with eutaxy the number of secondaries equal to the number of upper greater secondary coverts (Stephan 1970). The alternative condition in birds is diastataxy, where the wing has a missing secondary S5 (or an extra secondary covert between S4 and S5). The condition varies among orders of birds and within some families such as the megapodes Megapodiidae, kingfishers Alcedinidae, rails Rallidae and waders Scolopacidae, and it varies among the birds suggested as relatives of cuckoos (diastataxic in turacos Musophagidae, parrots Psittacidae, doves Columbidae and nightjars Caprimulgidae; and eutaxic in trogons Trogonidae, woodpeckers Picidae and the perching birds Passeriformes). Because the covert varies in no apparent regular manner among orders, and it varies within some families (the kingfishers, the waders Scolopacidae), the eutaxic wing gives us no clue to the relationship of cuckoos with other orders of birds (Sibley and Ahlquist 1990). Total plumage mass of Smooth-billed Anis has been measured. Males have an average plumage mass of 4.6 g, and a feathered body of 129.1 g; plumage is 3.6% of the total body weight. Females have an average plumage of 3.9 g and a feathered body of 120.0 g, and plumage is 3.3% of total body mass (Mitsch 1974).This proportion is about average among birds of their body size.
Glossy plumage The glossy- and bronze-cuckoos Chrysococcyx have a glossy plumage, with considerable variation
50 The Cuckoos among the species in color and brilliance. Two species are named for their brilliant greens, Asian Emerald Cuckoo C. maculatus and African Emerald Cuckoo C. cupreus; other cuckoos are named for a coppery or subtle bronze copper such as the Australian Horsfield’s Bronze-cuckoo. The glossy plumage of Asian Violet Cuckoo C. xanthorhynchus is violet purple in mainland Asia and the Sundas, and blue in the Philippines subspecies. Plumage gloss is more intense in the sexually dimorphic African glossy cuckoos and less intense in the sexually monochromatic Australian glossy cuckoos, where only the colors of the bare eye-ring and iris give visual cues to the sex of a bird. There may be an evolutionary conflict in the plumage appearance of these brood-parasites, between sexual selection within the species and avoiding detection by the host (Payne 1967, Andersson 1994). Structural features of feathers affect plumage color, including the wavelength λ of reflected light, the proportion of light that is reflected and the brightness of plumage, and the consistent color of reflected light viewed from different angles. The shape and curvature of the barbules, the changing dimension of barbules along the feather shaft and the orientation of barbules all combine to maintain a constant λ over a wide range of angles of incident light (Durrer and Villiger 1970, Dyck 1987). The constancy of reflected color in plumage when seen at different angles to the incident light in the emerald cuckoos C. maculatus and C. cupreus may result from the rounded shape of the reflectors and the angle of barbules, with the proximal and distal barbules nearly at right angles to each other (Dyck 1987). The structure of body feathers of African Emerald Cuckoo has been examined by light microscopy (Dorst 1951) and scanning and transmission electron microscopy (TEM) (Durrer and Villiger 1970, Durrer 1986). Feather barbules originate on each side of the barb shaft.The barbules are broad and nearly flat along their length, with haemuli (small hooks) on the medial side of the vane, and the barbules are elongated, narrow and lack haemuli on the outer side, the feather structure giving the plumage a frosted appearance. The frosted plumage of this cuckoo contrasts with the more
glossy Diederik Cuckoo and Klaas’s Cuckoo which have only the elongated, unflattened barbules (van Someren 1925, Dorst 1951), so the appearance of texture is due to the microstructure which exposes the color-producing portions of the barbules. Internally the barbule has layers of melanin granules, rod-like, arrayed side by side with the long axis parallel to the long axis of the barbule. The convex upper surface of the barbules has 10–14 of these melanin layers and the inner surface has 5–6 layers separated by keratin, the upper and lower stacks arranged around a keratin core.The number of these layers is related to plumage brightness (Rütschke 1966); glossy cuckoo feathers are more brilliant on the outer surface which reflects light to other birds than on the inner surface which faces the bird’s body, and the Scale-feathered Malkoha has equal brilliance on both sides. Multiple layers of melanin and keratin in the feather barbule are reflectors that determine the constructive interference of light waves. Some light is reflected from the first layer, some from the second, and so on.The color observed is a summation of light waves reflected off each layer. The light reflected from each layer travels a different distance to any point in the feather, and the most reflected waves pass out of phase with one another and cancel each other out. But those waves that travel an entire wavelength in the added distance traveled, are in phase with each other. These waves sum to produce the more brilliant color of a restricted wavelength. In the plumage of other green birds that have been studied in more detail, the structural determinants of reflected color include the number of melanin granule layers (the more layers, the more total light is reflected and the more brilliant the color), and the thickness and number of layers of melanin and keratin (Dyck 1987). Insofar as reflected light waves interfere with light waves reflected from other surfaces and the interference depends on their phase relationships, the wave lengths amplified in constructive interference can be calculated from a physical model of reflected light (Durrer 1986). The model predicts that the optical thickness (actual thickness⫻ refractive index) of each layer is equal to a quarter of the wavelength λ of maximum reflectance. This is the difference in
Morphology 51 light paths (2 ⫻ sine of the angle of incidence ⫻ the distance between reflecting layers) and the refractive indices of melanin and keratin. Reflected color varies with the angle of incidence and observation of light. At the larger critical angle the melanin layers absorb nearly all light, and at an angle of 0o no light would undergo constructive interference and the reflected colors would be less intense than when light is reflected at an angle, but the bigger effect is on hue. Differences between path length of waves become larger as incident light is more direct, and the hue will vary from a shorter wavelength (more blue) to a longer wavelength (more red). In this model of constructive interference, the wavelength λ amplified in an ideal regular multilayer reflector is four times the thickness of the semitransparent layers, times the refractive index. For an African Emerald Cuckoo feather, the λ observed is close to the λ value calculated from the thickness of keratin layers in the feather (Durrer and Villiger 1970). The exact color that is most strongly amplified depends on how the keratin layers are measured in relation to the rounded melanin rods (Prum et al. 1999b). In addition to this ideal model of multiple reflectors, the arrangement of keratin and melanin may affect the reflected colors through “chirping” series of layers where the peripheral reflectors are thick and the interior layers are progressively thinner. Parker et al. (1998) found these chirping multiple reflectors in the glossy gold wings of beetles. Feather barbs of African Emerald Cuckoo have thicker peripheral layers than internal layers of keratin, and TEM figures show a 20–30% shift in keratin thickness between layers (Durrer and Villiger 1970), much as in beetle wings, and this ordered structure may affect plumage color. The layers of different thicknesses may reinforce different components of the spectrum, producing complex and broad spectrum colors, metallic hues with coppery or golden highlights. In addition to the constructive interference of colors that is produced by multiple reflecting layers, coherently scattering threedimensional nanostructures occur in feathers (Prum et al. 1998, 1999a). In other birds with glossy green feathers, the colorful green Malachite Sunbird Nectarinia famosa has
more layers of melanin and keratin in the feather than does the Black Sunbird N. amethystina, while the non-glossy Gray Sunbird N. veroxi has unordered melanin granules that are not in regular layers as in the glossy species (Farquhar et al. 1996). In African starlings there is a similar difference between the dull and modestly glossy birds, but the most glossy birds have oblong melanin granules that are filled with a refractive material, especially the Emerald Starling Coccycolius iris with multiple layers on the dorsal feather surface and a single layer on the ventral surface.The color and gloss of plumage varies with the size and shape of these granules (Craig and Hartley 1985, Durrer 1986). These structural features may determine differences in plumage color among the glossy cuckoo species. The iridescent color of plumage has been said to change with wear, as in Greater Black Coucal Centropus menbeki becoming less blue and more green (Rand 1942a). The mechanism of color reflectance described for the internal layers of melanin and keratin within the feather barb make this kind of change unlikely, and the observation of variation in color probably refers to natural variation in plumage color among birds within a population.
Molt Most cuckoos molt their plumage once a year. Exceptions are coucals which molt their body plumage twice a year, and anis which have a complete molt and an incomplete molt within a year. The bird keeps a long tail through the period of molt. Tail feathers are replaced with one of the three long rectrices T1-2-3 which are retained until another long feather on each side is completely replaced. In some coucals (best known in Pheasant Coucal Centropus phasianinus in Australia) the central rectrices T1 are replaced twice and the others once a year (Higgins 1999). Smooth-billed Anis Crotophaga ani have a complete post-juvenile body and tail molt and a partial wing molt that is similar in pattern and extent to the adult molt. In March and April the young birds undergo a partial molt, but they attain the wide adult tail feathers only after the second autumn molt (Dickey and Van Rossem
52 The Cuckoos 1938). Adult anis undergo a complete postbreeding molt and a partial prebreeding body molt, with the molt slow and lasting through much of the year, and birds sometimes breed while they are still in molt (Davis 1940a, Snow and Snow 1964, Foster 1975, Pyle 1997). Molt is generally seasonal and occurs when birds are not breeding or in migration. Molt is not a reliable guide to the seasonality of breeding in cuckoos, and some cuckoos molt while they are breeding. In addition to the anis, Lesser Ground-cuckoo Morococcyx erythropygus and Dwarf Cuckoo Coccycua pumila sometimes molt while they are in breeding condition (Foster 1975, Ralph 1975), breeding adult Yellow-billed Cuckoos sometimes begin postbreeding molt while they are still caring for their nestlings (Potter 1980), and a few brood-parasitic females in Africa begin to molt while still laying (Payne 1969a). Molt in cuckoos is a prolonged affair. Migratory cuckoos such as Common Cuckoo begin and complete their post-juvenile and post-breeding molts on their wintering grounds. In northern temperate-region cuckoos that migrate, the molt is sometimes incomplete or is delayed for months. Common Cuckoos replace their plumage in about 100 days (Seel 1984b). For the Diederik Cuckoo and Klaas’s Cuckoo, the juvenile primary molt begins at 4 months and is completed in about 80 days (Hanmer 1995). In several species including the Common Koel, Diederik Cuckoo and Klaas’s Cuckoo, juvenile molt is often interrupted with birds in their first year ending the molt with their wing primaries, secondaries and coverts a mix of juvenile and adult feathers. Most remarkable in cuckoos is the molt pattern in which the flight feathers are replaced. The wing feathers are replaced not from the innermost outward, but from separate centers within the wing, beginning with an outer primary (Stresemann and Stresemann 1961, 1966, 1969, Piechocki 1971, Stephan 1991). Molt proceeds in leaps forwards or backwards across one or more adjacent primaries, in a “transilient” pattern. As with other birds, the primaries are numbered from the innermost feather outward; the terms “ascending” and “descending” trace back to an earlier time when the feathers were
numbered from the outermost feather inward. The Old World parasitic cuckoos shed the primaries in a predictable sequence. In the simple form of transilient molt, the odd-numbered feathers are replaced first from outer to inner position, then the evennumbered feathers are replaced, again starting from the outer position. Several variations occur on this theme: in Cuculus, Cacomantis and Chrysococcyx the molt sequence is P9 - 7 - 5 - 8 - 6, with P 4 - 1 2 - 3 beginning between the old primaries P5 and P3. Long-tailed Cuckoo Urodynamis taitensis has a unique molt, first the odd-numbered primaries then the even-numbered primaries, with the molt sequence P9 - 7 - 5 - 3 - 10 - 8 - 6 - 4. Certain cuckoos have other patterns, with Common Koel Eudynamys scolopacea quite different from other parasitic cuckoos with the outer primaries in transilient ascending molt (P9 - 7 - 5 - 10 - 8 - 6) and the inner primaries in stepwise descending molt (1 - 2 - 3 - 4) (Stresemann and Stresemann 1961). Another pattern is a semi-transilient ascending molt where some adjacent feathers are molted (Scythrops,Tapera). The crested cuckoos Clamator and lizard-cuckoos Coccyzus (Saurothera) are unique as their wing molt progresses in a regular pattern to skip two feathers, with a sequence P6 - 9 - pause - 7 - 10 - pause - 8 - 5 (or - 5 - 8) (Stresemann and Stresemann 1969, Piechocki 1971). In the Great Spotted Cuckoo these feathers are of different colors in juvenile and adult plumage, and first-year birds can be identified by their primaries, the new odd-numbered adult primaries being gray-brown and the evennumbered primaries the old rufous juvenile feathers. Non-parasitic cuckoos have a variable pattern of transilient ascending molt where adjacent feathers are sometimes replaced in series (Coccyzus, Ceuthmochares, Centropus) but the same pattern of alternating juvenile and adult feathers is sometimes seen in the flight feathers of first-year birds (Pyle 1997). Molt sequences sometimes vary within a species (Stresemann and Stresemann 1961) and the number of museum specimens in active molt is limited, so it is not possible at this time to use molt patterns as characters in a phylogenetic analysis for all cuckoos. This unique transilient pattern of molt nevertheless supports the monophyly of cuckoos.
Morphology 53
Skeleton Avian anatomists and paleontologists identify birds from the details of their bones (Huxley 1867, Fürbinger 1888, Pycraft 1901, 1903, Howard 1929, Berger 1960, Olson 1985, 1990, Olson and James 1991, Feduccia 1996). Certain bones have characteristic shapes that differ among avian families and orders, and skeletons may be useful in discovering the evolutionary relationships among birds of the world. It is only since the application of cladistic reasoning or phylogenetic systematics (Hennig 1966) that ornithologists have distinguished between characters that are shared because they are primitive (inherited from a remote ancestor, and shared only because other lineages from the same ancestor have evolved different characters, and not because they are shared by a strictly monophyletic lineage), or because they are derived (synapomorphic, inherited from a unique and recent common ancestor), and that skeletal characters have been used in the logic of phylogenetic systematics (e.g. Cracraft 1974, Payne and Risley 1976, Livezey 1993, 1997, 1998, Mayr 1998a,b). Despite the accumulation of a vast amount of descriptive detail on skeletal features, systematists have only recently begun to organize the accumulated data in a phylogenetic research program to determine the evolutionary relationships among birds (Livezey and Zusi 2001). In practice, bird skeletons are identified by comparison with a reference collection where bones are matched for identification to samples without a detailed description, and the published descriptions of bones are usually limited to certain groups or to a geographic region. While these resources are helpful, they often do not include all variations found within a family, and identification is sometimes based on a process of elimination (“not as above”) (e.g. Gilbert et al. 1981). Cuckoos have a desmognathous palate, no vomer, no basipterygoid process, a holorhinal nasal septum, deep temporal fossae and short mandibular processes.The postcranial skeleton has 13 or 14 cervical vertebrae.The pectoral girdle has a large coracoid and the sternum has an internal spine.The pubis has a pectineal or preacetabular process.The leg has two bony canals arranged side by side in the hypotarsus (the crest complex on the proximal end of the
tarsometatarsus), and the foot is zygodactyl, with two toes forward and the inner and outer toe directed backward, and with an accessory process on trochlea IV of the distal end of the tarsometatarsus to support the backwards orientation of the outer toe. These characters of cuckoos have been pointed out in earlier studies as reviewed by Sibley and Ahlquist (1990), and they were observed in skeletons in the present study. These skeletal features taken one at a time are not unique to cuckoos. For example, a desmognathous palate (a palate with a medial bridge across the maxillopalatinos: Huxley 1867, Pycraft 1901) also occurs in ducks, falcons, turacos, parrots and rollers and a few other avian groups, so this palate structure has evolved more than once in birds (Huxley 1867, Pycraft 1901). Other skeletal features vary among the cuckoos, such as the pectineal process of the synsacrum, a process which is prominent only in the terrestrial cuckoos (Verheyen 1956).There has been little consideration of whether the skeletal features of cuckoos are uniquely derived (synapomorphies) within the group, or are shared with other avian groups with a common ancestry, or are independently derived in the cuckoos and in other groups (homoplasies). Characters of cuckoos that may have been independently derived in bird lineages include the zygodactyl foot, a foot structure that also occurs in parrots, owls and woodpeckers. Although these birds may not form a monophyletic lineage, they are related in one phylogenetic hypothesis (Sibley and Ahlquist 1990), and if that model is true, then zygodactyly was ancestral to the original land-bird radiation and was subsequently lost three times (in Coraciiformes; in nightjars Caprimulgiformes, some swifts and hummingbirds Apodiformes; and in the lineage leading to pigeons, rails, the wading birds Ciconiiformes and the perching birds Passeriformes). The details of the zygodactyl foot in cuckoos differ from those in other zygodactyl birds and other birds that have two toes directed forwards and two backwards (trogons, mousebirds, some swifts, osprey, parrots, owls, cuckoo-roller, piciforms and the jacamars and puffbirds) (Figure 4.11). In zygodactyl birds the outer and inner toes (digits I and IV) are directed backwards; in fact the outer toe of
54 The Cuckoos
Figure 4.11. Distal end of the tarsometatarsus of cuckoos, hoatzin, turaco and other zygodactyl birds: a, cuckoo Geococcyx californianus; b, hoatzin Opisthocomus hoazin; c, turaco Tauraco hartlaubi; d, parrot Amazona amazonica; e, owl Otus asio; f, woodpecker Colaptes auratus. ii ⫽ trochlea II; iii ⫽ trochlea III; iv ⫽ trochlea IV; Se ⫽ sehnenhalter. Each pair of figures shows the end view (above) and ventral view (below), left tarsometatarsus; scale mark is 3 mm.
climbing woodpeckers is also often directed laterally (Bock and Miller 1959). The distal end of the tarsometatarsus in these zygodactyl birds with digit IV permanently reversed (cuckoos, parrots, owls, piciforms, jacamars and puffbirds) has an accessory articulating process for digit IV, a large inflected collateral flange, the sehnenhalter or sinew holder (Steinbacher 1935, Simpson and Cracraft 1981, Olson 1983, Houde and Olson 1992), and in mousebirds the simple outer flange of trochlea IV is enlarged and birds can reverse the outer toe even
though the toe is not permanently reversed (Raikow 1985).This sehnenhalter process in zygodactyl birds is enlarged and rotated posteriomedially. In cuckoos the process is less distinct than in other zygodactyl birds. It extends posteriomedially from trochlea IV but not as far distally as trochlea IV (it extends further distally in parrots), its lateral length is less than half the width of the distal shaft of the tarsometatarsus (it is about half the width in jacamars and puffbirds (not shown), and is longer in woodpeckers), and it projects on the perpendicular
Morphology 55 only slightly from the shaft of the tarsometatarsus (it projects radially a distance more than the width of the tarsometatarsus in woodpeckers and other piciforms, in which it also extends along the shaft further than its radial projection). The structure is similar for all cuckoos though it is slightly longer in the terrestrial cuckoos such as roadrunner. In hoatzin, trochlea IV bears a posteriolateral process which is not however an extra process (not a sehnenhalter), and it is similar to the expansion of the lateral ridge of trochlea IV in the trumpeter (Psophia crepitans UMMZ 152877, Psophiidae) which has an even weaker sulcus for the trochlear IV tendon; the hoatzin is not zygodactyl and the outer three toes are directed forwards.Turacos have a semi-zygodactyl foot in which the outer toe can go forwards, it is usually directed outwards, and it can rotate backwards within 70o of the hallux (Moreau 1938); this flexibility of the outer toe does not involve a sehnenhalter (Fig. 6). In the heterodactyl trogons digits I and II are sometimes directed backwards, not digits I and IV as in the zygodactyl birds; actually trogons usually hold all four toes forwards. The arrangement of foot tendons co-varies with the tarsometatarsal trochleae in zygodactyl birds (Gadow 1892, Steinbacher 1935, Olson 1983), except that muscle attachments are similar in jacamars and puffbirds and in the typical piciform birds (Swierczewski and Raikow 1981, Raikow and Cracraft 1983). The mechanical function of this process is to articulate with the basal phalanx of digit IV in the reversed position and to reverse the direction of force of the long flexor tendons of digit IV (Scharnke 1930, Steinbacher 1935). The foot of the cuckoo is also distinctive at the proximal end of the tarsometatarsus, where tendons from the leg to the toes pass through two bony canals in the hypotarsus.The two canals are arranged side by side in cuckoos. Other zygodactyl birds have a differently structured hypotarsus. In woodpeckers two bony canals are arranged radially, owls have no bony canals, and in parrots the hypotarsus varies with a single canal in Aratinga and Ara, a single canal with a partial division into two radial canals in lories Lorius garrulus and two canals side by side with incomplete division of one of them in the cockatoo
Cacatua moluccensis. In addition a few other birds including a grebe Podiceps grisegena and some herons Botaurus (Payne and Risley 1976) have two bony canals side by side, and songbirds have a hypotarsus with two canals side by side and also have other canals arranged radially to these (Figure 4.12). Although the foot skeleton of cuckoos is distinctive, the presence of two bony canals that are arranged side by side in the hypotarsus is not unique. Cuckoos have 13 or 14 cervical vertebrae and the number has figured prominently in earlier systematic arrangements of cuckoos. Fürbinger (1888) reported 13 in Crotophaga and 14 in Cuculus, Zanclostomus javanicus and Centropus; Shufeldt (1886a,b, 1901) and Berger (1952, 1960) reported 13 in Clamator, Coccyzus (including Saurothera) and Piaya, and 14 in most other cuckoos; Hughes (2000) reported 13 only in Clamator and Coccyzus. Pycraft (1903) recognized only 11 or 12 but he also recognized 2 or 3 cervico-thoracic vertebrae; Newton (1896) and Gadow and Selenka (1893) recognized 14 or 15 cervical vertebrae in cuckoos. The number of cervical vertebrae depends on the criteria used to define them. As Beddard (1899a) noted, the last three neck vertebrae bear ribs that progressively increase in size, with the anteriormost ones being very small.The ribs articulate anteriorly with the head, and a facet on the short knob on the anteriolateral surface of the vertebral centrum, and posteriorly with the tubercle and a larger process of the neural arch. Fürbinger (1888) and Baumel (1993), distinguished cervical vertebrae from thoracic vertebrae in that they do not articulate with a complete rib, where a “complete rib” has both vertebral and sternal segments, and the sternal segment connects directly or indirectly with the sternum. Vertebrae at the root of the neck which bear moveable ribs that do not reach the sternum are transitional between cervical and thoracic vertebrae. Newton (1896) and Berger (1960) considered only vertebrae with a rib that have a direct connection with the sternum to be thoracic vertebrae, yet they found different numbers of cervical vertebrae. Pycraft (1903) was more restrictive. He considered the vertebrae behind the cervicals to be cervicothoracic vertebrae, recognized by their ventral catapophyses in addition to the median hypapophysis,
56 The Cuckoos
Figure 4.12. Proximal end of the tarsometatarsus, showing the canals in the hypotarsus: a, cuckoo Geococcyx californianus; b, hoatzin Opisthocomus hoazin; c, turaco Tauraco hartlaubi; d, songbird Corvus brachyrhynchos; e, grebe Podiceps grisegena; f, woodpecker Colaptes auratus; g, owl Otus asio. c ⫽ canals; h ⫽ hypotarsus. Each pair of figures shows the end view (above) and ventral view (below), left tarsometatarsus; scale mark is 3 mm.
the second and third cervico-thoracics having ribs and the third having a rib with an uncinate process. He also noted that the fifth or posteriormost thoracic rib did not reach the sternum.Another feature that has been used to differentiate the cervical and thoracic vertebrae is the shape of the dorsal spine, which is short in the axial plane in the cervical vertebrae and has a high longitudinal crest in the dorsal vertebrae (Newton 1896), whereas Pycraft (1903) noted that the dorsal spine of the first thoracic vertebra in Coua is barely visible and is like that of the posterior cervical vertebrae. Using Fürbinger’s definition, in skeletal specimens where the articulation of ribs from the vertebrae to the sternum is intact I recognize 13 cervical vertebrae in Surniculus and Cuculus as well as in Clamator, Zanclostomus javanicus and Carpococcyx renauldi. Inasmuch as (a) some studies did not describe the criteria to recognize the cervical vertebrae, (b) the
transitional series of these vertebrae are associated with the transitional series of the ribs, (c) the attachment of the rib to the sternum is not obvious in disarticulated specimens, and (d) the number of cervical vertebrae sometimes varies among specimens of a single species both in cuckoos and in other birds (Fürbinger 1888, Berger 1952, 1960), the definitions and homologies of avian cervical vertebrae need to be re-evaluated. The sternum varies in the depth of the keel, where the flight muscles attach. The sternum also varies in the shape of the posterior edge (notched, windowed or intact).The keel is short and shallow in terrestrial ground cuckoos such as the couas and coucals (Pycraft 1903). These cuckoos can fly. The flight muscles attach not only to the keel but also to a stout coraco-clavicular membrane that extends from the coracoid to the furcula, as in Pheasant Coucal (Feduccia 1996, p. 136).
Morphology 57
Figure 4.13. Humerus of cuckoos and other birds: a, Geococcyx californianus; b, Eudynamys scolopacea; c, Opisthocomus hoazin; d, Tauraco hartlaubi; e, Trogon citreolus; f, Colaptes auratus; g, Indicator indicator; h, Corvus brachyrhynchos. aet ⫽ anterior external tuberosity; de ⫽ deltoid crest; ect ⫽ ectepicondyle; ent ⫽ entepicondyle; head ⫽ head; rt ⫽ round tuberosity; s ⫽ shaft. Anconal view, right humerus; scale mark is 5 mm.
In cuckoos the humerus is concave along the medial edge; it has a strongly developed median crest, and it lacks the distinct round tuberosity proximal to the entepicondyle that characterizes the perching birds Passeriformes. The humerus is distinct in the shape of the deltoid crest.The crest projects in a ridge with two peaks, a minor peak located proximally at the anterior external tuberosity and a larger peak located distally on the crest with a shallow concave area between the peaks (Figure 4.13). The crest is short and does not extend far along the shaft, has a simple low ridge and often a more extensive distal projection along the shaft.The distal peak is more prominent in Eudynamys and less
prominent in the ground-cuckoos Carpococcyx and Neomorphus. In other groups of birds, the deltoid crest is a straight ridge with a single peak (songbird), or it has a single peak without the extensive ridge ( parrot, pigeon), or a single rounded ridge (mousebird, not shown in Figure 4.13), while other details in the humerus also differ between cuckoos and other birds.
Skeletons and cuckoo monophyly Seibel (1988) and Hughes (2000) described several features of cuckoo skeletons that they interpreted as unique to the cuckoos, and other features that
58 The Cuckoos characterized certain lineages, including terrestrial vs arboreal cuckoos, and the brood parasites. These features involved the shape and combination of skeletal elements, and not the presence or absence of a simple element. Hughes used the more inclusive set: 14 characters. Because these skeletal characters were used to estimate the evolutionary history of cuckoos, and the conclusions of these studies differed from conclusions of studies in molecular genetics, it is of interest to compare these characters. The skeletons of cuckoos and other avian taxa were compared, in the present study, to test whether the characters reported to support monophyly of cuckoos were in fact unique to cuckoos. One or two representatives from each major cuckoo clade were selected. The other taxa were selected from specimens in orders that were within three branches of the cuckoos in the phylogenetic estimate of Sibley and Ahlquist (1990): mousebirds Coliiformes, kingfishers Coraciiformes, puffbirds Bucconidae, buttonquail Turniciformes, woodpeckers and honeyguides Piciformes, parrots Psittaciformes, turacos Musophagiformes, owls Strigiformes, doves Columbiformes, plovers Charadriiformes, falcons Falconiformes and herons Ciconiiformes (these last three all classed as Ciconiiformes in Sibley and Ahlquist 1990) and songbirds Passeriformes. The sample was selected to include at least one taxon from all third-order branches (clades within three branching points) of the cuckoos in Sibley and Ahlquist (1990), and from each order that has been suggested elsewhere as being closely related to the cuckoos.The sample also included hoatzin, which was regarded by Sibley and Ahlquist as a cuckoo.When a bone was missing or damaged, another specimen was examined. Taxa and specimens examined are listed in Table 4.3, and the characters of cuckoo monophyly in Seibel (1988) and Hughes (2000) are described in Table 4.4. The examination of skeletons does not support the claim (Hughes 1990) that all 14 characters are unique to cuckoos (Table 4.4). Depending on the character, the structures vary among the cuckoos, or they are not unique to cuckoos, or they vary both among cuckoos and among other taxa, although a few characters are unique. Cuckoos and the other
taxa differed in (8): the occurrence and position of two hypotarsal canals side by side.A few other birds also have two hypotarsal canals arranged side by side, so this characteristic is not unique to cuckoos. The sehnenhalter or accessory trochlea IV differs between cuckoos and other zygodactyl birds, but the description of character (9) does not make this distinction. The shape of the maxillary bone is distinctive, as is the form of the humerus. The other characters are variable among cuckoos or also occur in other taxa.
Skeletons and evolutionary relationships between cuckoo species Comparison of cuckoo skeletons has led to estimates of cuckoo relationships that affect the interpretation of important questions in evolution, including the origin of brood parasitism, the adaptations of arboreal and ground cuckoos, and the interchange between or isolation of the Old and New World cuckoos (Seibel 1988, Hughes 1997d, 2000). This phylogenetic inference is based on the assumption that truth is revealed in bones, and skeletal characters are true guides to the evolutionary relationships within the cuckoos.
Single origin of arboreal and terrestrial behavior? In an analysis of the postcranial skeleton of cuckoos, Seibel (1988) concluded that ground-cuckoos of the Old World were closely related to groundcuckoos of the New World, and neither were closely related to the arboreal cuckoos in their regions. The characters that linked these groundcuckoos were features of the synsacrum and tarsometatarsus, and these may have independently derived their structure in relation to the terrestrial mode of locomotion. Seibel reported three traits as shared derived characters for the recognition of a clade of coucals, couas and the Old World and New World ground-cuckoos: the relative length of the ilioischiatic synsacrum (long in these cuckoos), and the contour and orientation of the anterior edge of the posteriodorsal iliac crest (straight and more
Morphology 59 Table 4.3 Skeletal specimens examined to test statements that cuckoos are diagnostically distinct. Cuckoos Carpococcyx renauldi Centropus senegalensis Centropus toulou Clamator glandarius Coccyzus americanus Coua caerulea Crotophaga ani Cuculus canorus Dasylophus superciliosus Eudynamys scolopacea Geococcyx californianus Neomorphus geoffroyi Zanclostomus javanicus Surniculus velutinus Other taxa Amazona amazonica (parrot) Ardea herodias (heron) Ceryle alcyon (kingfisher) Charadrius vociferus (plover) Colaptes auratus (woodpecker) Colius striatus (mousebird) Columba livia (pigeon) Corvus brachyrhynchos (songbird) Falco sparverius (falcon) Indicator indicator (honeyguide) Notharchus macrorhynchos (puffbird) Opisthocomus hoazin (hoatzin) Otus asio (owl) Tauraco hartlaubi (turaco) Trogon citreolus (trogon) Turnix suscitator (buttonquail)
laterally directed in these cuckoos). This first character is problematic, as most cuckoos had an intermediate form (Seibel 1988). Second, the couas, Old World ground-cuckoos and New World groundcuckoos were uniquely linked only by the inflection of the acrocoracoidial furcular facet of the coracoid, although the definition of character states of the facet is problematic (Seibel 1988). Third,
specimen number UMMZ 219851, 236029 UMMZ 207709 UMMZ 208402 UMMZ 212907 UMMZ 152712 UMMZ 209201, 208404 UMMZ 218940 UMMZ 151115 UMMZ 228022 UMMZ 210347 UMMZ 71909 UMMZ 200592 UMMZ 236439, 236440 UMMZ 233061 UMMZ 203942, 203944 UMMZ 107419, 224551 UMMZ 206751 UMMZ 74184, 198342, 220113 UMMZ 235110, 207776 UMMZ 234219 UMMZ 224018 UMMZ 232727 UMMZ 223964 UMMZ 212931 UMMZ 219195 LSU 62741 UMMZ 224665 UMMZ 234273 UMMZ 209256 UMMZ 205093
within this last set of cuckoos, the Old World ground-cuckoos and New World ground-cuckoos including roadrunners were linked by two tarsometatarsal traits: the size and position of a tubercle, and the position of the distal edge of the proximal foramen. Insofar as the characters are in the synsacrum and legs (or are problematic), and these birds share a common pattern of locomotion,
60 The Cuckoos Table 4.4 Skeletal characters in a statement of cuckoo monophyly (after Hughes 2000). 1. “Os quadratum. Condylus medialis, caudalis, and lateralis prominent, well-rounded, and separated by a broad notch; condylus caudalis tapered to a rounded point, deflected and extending well beyond caudal margins of quadrate in lateral aspect; processus orbitalis quadrati truncated and somewhat anvil-shaped.” (Character 21 of Hughes 2000). Comments:The description is appropriate for cuckoos, although the shape of the condyles vary considerably in detail, particularly the shape of the orbital process, and the condylus medialis is not demarcate by a distinct notch in relation to the other quadrate condyles. In the other taxa, the same description appears to match the bones in part, if not in entirety: (1a) the condyles are prominent and well rounded in the parrot, kingfisher, trogon, heron and songbird; (1b) the broad notch is present in the buttonquail, trogon, kingfisher, mousebird, hoatzin, owl, turaco and songbird, and the heron has a prominent but narrow notch; (1c) the condylus caudalis is tapered to a rounded point and deflected in the kingfisher, plover, songbird, owl and turaco; (1d) the condylus caudalis extends as in cuckoos, in the honeyguide, kingfisher, trogon, turaco, owl, plover and songbird; (1e) the processus orbitalis quadrati is truncated in the buttonquail, hoatzin, turaco, parrot, plover, falcon and songbird; and (1f ) the processus orbitalis is anvil- or cone-shaped in the hoatzin, parrot, plover, dove and falcon. Because these characters are variable within the cuckoo species, and none are unique to cuckoos, the form of the quadrate is not diagnostic in cuckoos, i.e. it does not clearly distinguish them. 2. “Os pterygoideum. Mesially deflecting spur-like processus dorsalis located caudally on facies dorsalis near, but not articulating with, os quadratum.” (Character 44 of Hughes 2000). Comments: Not all cuckoos have such a process, and in Centropus, Clamator and Eudynamys the process articulates with the quadrate. 3. “Os ectethmoidale. Large, quadrilateral in form, marginis lateralis and ventralis slightly to moderately excised.” (Character 15 of Hughes 2000). Comments:The character has three components: in cuckoos (3a) all have a quadrilateral ectethmoid; (3b) a lateral excision is apparent only in Clamator, Coccyzus, Eudynamys, Geococcyx and Neomorphus; and (3c) a ventral excision is apparent in all but Carpococcyx, Centropus, Coua and Dasylophus. In other taxa, seven have a quadrilateral ectethmoid, five have a lateral excision, and six have a ventral excision; the hoatzin is deeply excised (not slightly to moderately excised), the puffbird is similar to Centropus, although the ectethmoid is extended further laterally, the mousebird is nearly identical to Coccyzus, and the buttonquail is nearly identical to Coua. 4. “Os palatinum. Marginis medialis meeting in midline below, fully or nearly concealing, rostrum parasphenoidale; lamella caudolateralis being widest midway between processus pterygoideus and margo distalis of pars choanalis, tapering towards rostrum; processus interpalatinus extending nearly to margo caudalis of processus maxillopalatinus; in lateral aspect, cristae lateralis are deflected ventrally.” (Character 47 of Hughes 2000). Comments:The description defines the desmognathous palate and elaborates on the shape of the palatines. In cuckoos the description is appropriate, except that (4b) the parasphenoid is exposed throughout its length in Carpococcyx; and (4d) the palatines do not taper anteriorly in Clamator.The description excludes the other taxa, as most of these including hoatzin are schizognathous, although in all (4d) the palatines taper to the rostrum and (4f) the lateral crests are deflected ventrally in all but kingfisher. 5. “Os maxillare. In ventral aspect, processus palatinus bilobed, extending caudally nearly to marginis distalis of crista ventralis; margo medialis of processus palatinus not fused caudally to margo distalis of os maxillare.” (Character 48 of Hughes 2000). Comments: The description applies to cuckoos. In the other taxa, it also applies to plover, songbird and buttonquail, although the shape of the maxilla differs in other aspects from that of cuckoos. 6. “Os articulare, crista intercotylaris. Prominent, half-disk shaped with radius aligned approximately 45° to planum medianum.” (Character 54 of Hughes 2000). Comments:The description of the base of the lower mandible applies to cuckoos. In other taxa, the description does not universally apply as the articular surface is more complex (more robust in parrot) and the radius is closer to the median plane in turaco, owl, falcon and buttonquail, but the description applies well to the hoatzin, puffbird and trogon which are nearly identical to cuckoos. 7. “Tibiotarsus, incisura intercondylaris. Deep, rounded pit extending caudally at least half the length of extremitas distalis; trochlea cartilaginis tibialis poorly developed.” (Character 57 of Hughes 2000).
Morphology 61 Table 4.4 contd. Comments: This character has two components: (7a) the extent of the pit; and (7b) the development of the trochlea. The description of the distal end of the tibiotarsus applies to cuckoos. In the other taxa both 7a and 7b apply to the mousebird, turaco and owl. 8. “Tarsometatarsus, hypotarsi. Two oblong canales hypotarsi, completely enclosed in bone, positioned side by side in planum medianum both almost entirely caudal to cotylae medialis and lateralis, and corpus tarsometatarsi.” (Character 58 of Hughes 2000). Comments:This character is present in the cuckoos, while in the other taxa examined it is absent. Some have a single canal, e.g. hoatzin. However certain other birds have two enclosed hypotarsal canals, either side by side (some grebes) or in another arrangement (not side by side: woodpeckers, some herons, Payne and Risley 1976), or have two canals in the same position as the cuckoos, but have additional canals peripheral to those in a radially expanded hypotarsus (songbird) (Fig. 5). 9. “Tarsometatarsus, trochlea metatarsi quarti. Margo distalis proximal to incisura intertrochlearis medialis; caudal trochlea accessoria prominent and strongly inflected medially.” (Character 75 of Hughes 2000). Comments:This character has two components: (9a) the shape of the distal margin; and (9b) the sehnenhalter (accessory caudal trochlea). All cuckoos have the character, while in the other taxa, (9b) the sehnenhalter is inflected inwards in the owl, woodpecker and honeyguide, as in cuckoos (in owl the outer trochlea IV flange forms the base of the structure, and in woodpecker and honeyguide the inner trochlea IV flange forms this structure as in cuckoos; in parrots trochlea IV is shorter—it does not extend very far distally along the shaft—than the sehnenhalter). In hoatzin the outer trochlear flange is prominent, but less so than in cuckoos (in hoatzin, trochlea IV extends as far distally as trochlea II, the flange is about 60% as long as the metatarsal articular surface of trochlea IV, and the flange not inflected inwards (Fig. 4). 10. “Coradoiceum, facies articularis sternalis. Crista ventralis prominent, centred, rounded, and facing sternally.” (Character 99 of Hughes 2000). Comments: Gilbert et al. (1981) describe this condition as “ventral sternal facet rounded, centered and facing sternally”. Although the figures in Gilbert et al. (1981) and Hughes (2000) do not show the feature well, the coracoid has a ridge or crest on the ventral surface, perpendicular to the shaft and centered with respect to the shaft, with the curved ridge parallel to that of the margin of the sternal articulatory facet. All cuckoos have a coracoid as in this description, while in the other taxa, trogon and plover have the crest as in cuckoos, the woodpecker is similar (though the crest is more distal to the coracoid shaft), and the pigeon has a prominent ventral crest not centered but expanded on the procoracoideal side of the coracoid. The ventral crest is also present in certain other birds including herons and cormorants (Phalacrocorax auritus) although it is not always centered on the shaft in these birds (Payne and Risley 1976). It is also known in other birds including early fossil charadriiform, trogon and other Eocene fossils (Mayr 1998a, 1999, 2000). In hoatzin the coracoid is fused with the sternum and no articular surface is visible. Seibel (1988) recognized fusion of the bones and assumed that hoatzin lacked a ventral crest (his character state CO19a); Hughes (2000) did not describe hoatzin though she coded the crest as absent in hoatzin. 11. “Scapula. Facies articularis humeralis directed dorsally; facies articularis clavicularis prominent, knob-like, and directed dorsally; extremitas cranialis scapulae, delineated by acromion and tuberculum coracoideum, truncated and flattened cranially.” (Character 107 of Hughes 2000). Comments:The description fits the cuckoos, and also the other taxa, except that (11a) the facies articularis humeralis is directed ventrally in the kingfisher; (11b) the facies articularis clavicularis is not prominent in the songbird, and (11c) the facies articularis clavicularis is not directed dorsally in the plover, while in the woodpecker the caudal end of the scapula is greatly enlarged, flattened and recurved to meet the rib cage. 12. “Humerus, condylus ventralis. Rounded, not flattened or oblong, in axis proximodistalis and both plana transversialia and dorsalia.” (Character 114 of Hughes 2000). Comments: In cuckoos the description matches the specimens, while in the other taxa it matches for all except woodpecker, honeyguide and trogon. 13. “Synsacrum, extremitas caudalis synsacri. Crista dorsalis reduced and fused to form a single low ridge; marginis lateralis of processus transversus widened in axis rostrocaudalis, facies lateralis projecting cranially.” (Character 130 of Hughes 2000).
62 The Cuckoos Table 4.4 contd. Comments: In cuckoos, (13a) the crista is not prominent in Crotophaga; and (13d) there is no wide lateral margin of the transverse process in Clamator and the lateral margin does not project cranially in Neomorphus, while in the other taxa, (13a) the crista dorsalis is reduced in the kingfisher, songbird, owl, turaco and buttonquail; (13b) the crista dorsalis is unfused in all but the plover; (13c) a single low ridge is present in all but the songbird and hoatzin; (13d) there is a wide lateral margin of the transverse process in the mousebird and honeyguide; and (13e) the lateral face projects cranially in the plover and turaco. 14. “Vertebrae caudales, primus. Processes transversus tapered, not widened, paddle-shaped in ventral aspect; projecting strongly caudally.” (Character 131 of Hughes 2000). Comments: The description is appropriate for most cuckoos, although (14a) the transverse process is not tapered in Carpococcyx, Coua, Dasylophus or Eudynamys; (14b) it is not paddle-shaped in Coua; and (14c) it does not project strongly caudally in Carpococcyx, Coua or Eudynamys, while in the other taxa, (14a) the process is tapered in the kingfisher, trogon, songbird, falcon and turaco; (14b) it is paddle shaped in the woodpecker, mousebird and hoatzin; and (14c) it projects strongly caudally in the parrot, mousebird and owl.
the skeletal characters are likely to be adaptations for running on the ground, and evolved independently in these cuckoos (Payne 1997b). Only one character was found to link the arboreal cuckoos: the posterior extent of the medial angle of the posterior dorsal iliac crest, relative to the width of the vertebral centra (the main body of the vertebra).The cuckoos that share the character are the New World anis, New World broodparasitic cuckoos, New World coccyzine cuckoos and the Old World malkohas and brood-parasitic cuckoos. Seibel’s conclusion that a synsacral character is a derived synapomorphy may follow from the assumption of turaco as the outgroup (Payne 1997b). These long-legged birds have synsacra that are used in bounding locomotion, so it is questionable whether this trait is a good standard by which to estimate the evolutionary polarity of characters in cuckoos. The shape of the iliac crest in these cuckoos may be a primitive rather than a derived character. Also, it is uncertain that turacos are closely related to cuckoos.With only a single skeletal character to link these cuckoos with each other, there is no corroboration of the hypothesis that arboreal cuckoos form a single lineage.
Single origin of brood parasitism? Skeletal characters were used by Seibel (1988) and Hughes (2000) to infer a single origin of broodparasitic cuckoos.These characters were re-examined
in the present study, using some of the same specimens and others that were not available to the earlier studies. Seibel (1988) listed four characters that defined the brood-parasitic cuckoos of the Old World and New World as a single derived group, together with the New World Coccyzus cuckoos, and two additional characters that defined this group except for the parasitic genera Urodynamis and Eudynamys. Hughes (2000) used a larger set of 135 skeletal characters, including 56 cranial as well as 79 postcranial characters, and she modified several characters of Seibel (1988). In addition some taxa were different (Dasylophus cumingi in Hughes 2000, Zanclostomus javanicus in Seibel 1988). The phylogenetic estimates of the two studies were similar, with a few exceptions. In Hughes’ estimate, (1) Carpococcyx was basal to all cuckoos, (2) Coua and Centropus formed the next basal clade, and (3) the New World Morococcyx, Geococcyx and Neomorphus formed the next basal level (rather than a sister clade to Old World Carpococcyx).The differences in (1), (2) and (3) may result from rooting the outgroup next to Carpococcyx rather than between the ground cuckoos and arboreal cuckoos. Other differences in estimates were that in Hughes (2000), (4) the mostly Old World Phaenicophaeinae and Cuculinae formed separate clades, and (5) New World brood-parasitic Tapera and Dromococcyx were basal to the Old World brood-parasites with both in Cuculinae. Hughes’ estimate was similar to Seibel’s in (1) the association of New World Coccyzus with
Morphology 63 the Old World brood-parasitic cuckoos rather than with New World nesting Piaya, and (Coccyzus sub-genera) Saurothera and Hyetornis, and (2) the association of Morococcyx, Geococcyx and Neomorphus in the New World ground cuckoos. Hughes (2000) included a data matrix, and this matrix and a character analysis were presented elsewhere as an appendix (Hughes 1997d ). Both Seibel (1988) and Hughes (2000) concluded that brood parasitism evolved only once in the cuckoos. Hughes’ presumptive clade of “Cuculinae” (Old World and New World brood parasites together with the genus Coccyzus) was distinguished in Hughes (1997d, 2000) by nine skeletal characters that changed state from node #63 to node #64, and defined her “Cuculinae” parasitic cuckoos. To evaluate this estimation of a single origin of brood-parasitic cuckoos, I examined skeletons of cuckoos for the six characters that were said to define the brood-parasitic clade in Seibel (1988), and the nine characters said to define the clade in Hughes (1997d, 2000), a total of 12 characters, with some overlap between the two studies. The terminology and examples refer to the illustrations and descriptions in standard anatomical works (Howard 1929, Baumel 1993).
Cuckoo skeletons were examined to test their conformity with coding of the characters that Seibel and Hughes reported, to support their conclusion of a single origin of brood-parasitic cuckoos. Specimens used for the examination were: Clamator glandarius 212909, Cuculus canorus 2020512, 119430, Eudynamys scolopacea UMMZ 210347, Urodynamis taitensis USNM 559589, Tapera naevia UMMZ 214005, Dromococcyx pavoninus UMMZ 209207, Crotophaga major UMMZ 219553, Geococcyx californianus 227057, Morococcyx erythropygus UMMZ 133738, Ceuthmochares australis UMMZ 158186, Zanclostomus javanicus UMMZ 209478, Dasylophus superciliosus UMMZ 228024, Coccyzus americanus UMMZ 154465, Saurothera merlini UMMZ 158527, Coccycua minuta UMMZ 139991, 139990, Piaya cayana UMMZ 200591, Piaya melanogaster UMMZ 209478, Coua caerulea 209201, Coua cristata UMMZ 157526, and Centropus senegalensis UMMZ 205896. Where skeletal elements were missing, a second specimen was examined. In most cases there was no consistent or discrete difference in the skeletal trait for nesting cuckoos and brood-parasitic cuckoos, as in Table 4.5. Where the CI is less than 1.0, the character transition occurred more than once in
Table 4.5 Skeletal characters in a statement of monophyly of brood parasitism (“Cu”) in cuckoos (Hughes 1997d (node 66), 2000). Characters are numbered as in Hughes (1997d ), where the character transitions are described. Character number, transition, and description #24 (1–2). “Os quadratum, angle of proc. oticus and proc. orbitalis in lateral aspect (ordered): 0 large, 1 moderate, 2 small. CI ⫽ 0.67.” Comments: No difference in size of either orbital or otic process of quadrate between “Cu” and other cuckoos is apparent: proc. oticus and proc. orbitus in parasitic cuckoos Cuculus, Clamator and Urodynamis were as large as in nesting cuckoos of similar body size or larger (Ceuthmochares, Piaya melanogaster, Morococcyx, Centropus). Quadrate processes were larger in brood-parasitic Tapera than in the larger Morococcyx. There was a trend for larger cuckoos to have larger processes than smaller cuckoos, although this did not consistently distinguish groups, and quadrate processes varied in a gradual transitional series and not in a step function. #37 (0–1). “Os exoccipitale, shape (ordered): 0, flat or slightly raised; 1, produced into bulbous expansion raised above contour of os occipitale; 2, as in 1 but greatly expanded. CI ⫽ 1.00.” Comments:The bulbous projection from the skull base was not very large (2) in any cuckoos, and the birds in which it was relatively large included both parasitic cuckoos (Tapera, Dromococcyx, Clamator, Cuculus, Eudynamys, Urodynamis) and nesting cuckoos (Geococcyx, Zanclostomus, Dasylophus, Morococcyx, Coccyzus, “Saurothera” and both Coua). #80 (0–1). “Pelvis, relative widths of facies dorsalis (ordered): 0, narrowest point less than half the width between processes antitrochantericus; 1, approximately half; 2, more than half. CI ⫽ 0.67.” Comments: Seibel listed this as a synapomorphy for Cuculinae, less Eudynamys and Urodynamis. Hughes (1997) listed 0–1 as a synapomorphy for “Cu”, 1–2 as a synapomorphy for most “Cu” and 1–0 as a reversal from other “Cu” to Eudynamys and Urodynamis. I find all forms to be “0”, except “1” for brood-parasitic Tapera and Dromococcyx, and a nesting cuckoo Coccycua minuta.
64 The Cuckoos Table 4.5 contd. #87 (0–1). “Ilium, cross-section of margo medialis (Fig. 15) of crista iliaca dorsolateralis in axis dorsoventralis: 0, broad, forming smooth arc; 1, compressed into thin, blade-like shelf. CI ⫽ 1.00.” Comments:This character ⫽ PE10 in Seibel 1988, I find that all cuckoos are “0” except for the brood-parasitic Tapera and Clamator and the nesting Crotophaga which are “1”. #92 (0–2). (p) “Ilium, relative length of sync. ilioischiadica from crista caudalis fossa renalis to proc. marginis caudalis in axis rostrocaudalis, with reference to depth of recessus caudalis fossae: 0, intermediate between state 1 and 2; 1, sync. ilioischiadica long, recessus caudalis fossae present and deep; 2, sync. ilioischiadica short, recessus caudalis fossae shallow. CI ⫽ 0.67.” Comments: Seibel (1988) defined the character in terms of vertebral centrum width; Hughes defined it in terms of depth of the fossa renalis. Seibel found three transitions, none corresponding to those of Hughes. Seibel (1988: 64) described the character as problematic and nearly impossible to code within the Phaenicophaeinae, that is, the group related to Cu. In general aspect, birds with a longer pelvis have a longer ilioishiadic fusion H93. The character varies with the life style of cuckoos, a shorter ilioishiadic fusion in the arboreal cuculines; the structure is nearly identical in the parasitic Tapera and the nesting Morococcyx, while it is shorter in the small, terrestrial parasitic Dromococcyx. I find character 92 to have state 2 in the brood-parasitic Dromococcyx and in the nesting cuckoos Coccyzus, Coccycua minuta and Piaya melanogaster. #94 (1–2). “Sternum, cranial extent of apex carinae (ordered): 0, cranial tip of apex caudal to labrum externum of sulcus articularis coracoideus; 1, apex at same cranio-caudal level as sulcus; 2, apex cranial to sulcus. CI ⫽ 0.50.” Comments: I find no difference among cuckoos. #111 (0–1). “Humerus, extremitas proximalis humeri,“bulbous convexity” on facies cranialis just lateral to midpoint: 0, absent, 1, present. CI ⫽ 1.00.” Comments: I find no difference among cuckoos. #112 (0–2). “Humerus, position of fossa m. brachialis in cranial aspect: 0, mesial to center of corpus humeri; 1, far mesial; 2, at or lateral to meso-lateral center of corpus humeri. CI ⫽ 0.67.” Comments: Seibel found the transition from primitive cuckoos to occur in two places, one leading to the New World terrestrial cuckoos Geococcyx, Morococcyx and Neomorphus, the other to Coua. Seibel’s transitions and Hughes’s transitions occurred at different points on their phylogeny; Seibel’s transitions did not occur to define a clade “Cu”. Examination of UMMZ specimens supports Seibel’s transitions, except that the form of the fossa varies within Coua. I find all cuckoos to be similar except for Crotophaga, Geococcyx, and Coua caerulea, all with a lateral position. #124 (1–2). “Os carpi ulnare, shape of distal end: 0, blunt, expanded, or bulbous; 1, pointed, margo distalis 45⫿ to crus longum; 2, strongly pointed, approximately 30°. CI ⫽ 0.67.” Comments: Seibel defined three characters of the ulnare—his “cuneiform”—that appeared to be synapomorphies of all cuckoos; Hughes used these to define cuckoos and also recognized a new character, the shape of the distal end, a modification of Seibel’s character CU3. In parasitic cuckoos the ulnare has a more slender shape, but not in all; it is blunt in Eudynamys and especially in Tapera, whereas in nesting cuckoos it is narrow and pointed in Saurothera and somewhat narrow in Ceuthmochares and Dasylophus. The form seems to vary with behavior, blunt in terrestrial forms, and narrow and pointed in the more arboreal birds and the intercontinental migrants. In addition, Seibel (1988) reported the following characters to distinguish the clade Cuculinae (except Urodynamis, which fell outside the clade): S#57, PE5: (pectineal process, ⫽ tuberculum preacetabulare of Hughes 2000). I find no discrete variation in this process between the parasitic and non-parasitic cuckoos, although it is large in the terrestrial forms, as noted by Verheyen (1956). S#55 , UL1:0–2, ulna distal shape: Seibel had 6 states for the ulna; I find no distinct differences in ulna shape. S#52 , PE17, iliac crest shape and its anterior position relative to antitrochanter) Seibel (p. 63) found PE17 problematic and nearly impossible to code in Coccyzus, and PE17 individualistic and nearly impossible to code in Rhinortha. In Seibel (1988), PE17 character state B was coded “not as in A” with no independent description. I find the antitrochanter indistinct in cuckoos, whereas it is distinct in the goose and turkey (Howard 1929, Baumel 1993).
Morphology 65 the phylogenetic hypothesis of Hughes (2000), and the character is not unique to brood-parasitic cuckoos. The models of Seibel (1988) and Hughes (2000) of phylogeny among the cuckoo species and a single origin of brood parasitism depended on certain characters. Deconstruction of these characters reveals unquestioned assumptions and inconsistencies and leaves no reason to think that broodparasitic behavior evolved only once in the cuckoos. Also, several characters that supported their conclusion of a single origin of brood parasitism changed more than once in the skeletal phylogeny of cuckoos. The characters with a low consistency index are 24, 80, 95, and 124 (Hughes 2000). In addition, certain of these reported character states are not discrete, but rather they intergrade between extremes: these intergrading characters are 24, 37, 87, 93, 95, 110, 112, and 124 (Hughes 2000). Posso (2003) found the skulls of cuckoos to differ from the descriptions of Hughes, and his phylogenetic estimate of cuckoo relationships also differed from that of Hughes. There is no confidence in conclusions that are based on unrepeatable characters. The conclusion that brood parasitism evolved once rather than twice in the Old World cuckoos i