This page intentionally left blank
The Civil Partnership Act 2004 This authoritative guide to the Civil Partnership A...
9 downloads
788 Views
1MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
This page intentionally left blank
The Civil Partnership Act 2004 This authoritative guide to the Civil Partnership Act 2004 is written by two family law barristers with a combined practice experience of over fifty years. The Civil Partnership Act 2004: A Practical Guide provides clear, concise explanations of the new legislation. The book covers the lifetime of a relationship, from entering into the civil partnership, its consequences in terms of financial and family arrangements, to practical guidance on how the partnership is dissolved and the consequences of breakdown and death. paul mallender is a specialist in family work in the High Court and all other jurisdictions, at 2 Pump Court. His work includes Children Act and child support cases, ancillary relief, judicial separation, nullity, wardship and child abuse. jane rayson is head of chambers at 2 Gray’s Inn Square. She practises exclusively in family law and her work is (broadly) divided equally between children and ancillary relief.
The Civil Partnership Act 2004 A Practical Guide
P A U L M A L L E N D E R , L L B , Barrister J A N E R A Y S O N , L L B , Barrister
cambridge university press Cambridge, New York, Melbourne, Madrid, Cape Town, Singapore, São Paulo Cambridge University Press The Edinburgh Building, Cambridge cb2 2ru, UK Published in the United States of America by Cambridge University Press, New York www.cambridge.org Information on this title: www.cambridge.org/9780521617925 © Cambridge University Press 2005 This publication is in copyright. Subject to statutory exception and to the provision of relevant collective licensing agreements, no reproduction of any part may take place without the written permission of Cambridge University Press. First published in print format 2005 isbn-13 isbn-10
978-0-511-13210-0 eBook (EBL) 0-511-13210-7 eBook (EBL)
isbn-13 isbn-10
978-0-521-61792-5 paperback 0-521-61792-8 paperback
Cambridge University Press has no responsibility for the persistence or accuracy of urls for external or third-party internet websites referred to in this publication, and does not guarantee that any content on such websites is, or will remain, accurate or appropriate.
Contents
Foreword vii Acknowledgements viii Table of cases ix Table of statutes xi
1 Introduction to the Act
1
2 What is a civil partnership? Formation by registration in England and Wales: eligibility
5
3 Pre-registration procedure: standard procedure; house-bound and detained partners; certain non-residents and other special cases
9
4 Registration in England and Wales – the standard procedure; the special procedure
23
5 Registration outside the UK by Order in Council
28
6 Overseas relationships treated as civil partnerships
32
7 Financial and property implications of civil partnership
36
8 Children
45
9 Relationship between the Civil Partnership Act and the Gender Recognition Act
49
10 The ending of the partnership: orders for dissolution
54
11 Nullity and other proceedings
64
12 Offences
74
13 Domestic violence and occupation of the home
77
v
Contents
14 Financial consequences on breakdown 15 Financial relief in England and Wales after an overseas dissolution
106
16 Miscellaneous
111
Appendix Civil Partnership Act 2004 – extracts Index
vi
85
337
114
Foreword
It is difficult to overestimate the significance and importance of the Civil Partnership Act 2004 in terms of the changes it makes to the treatment in law of same-sex relationships. I am proud to have been a member of the governing party which introduced such ground-breaking legislation and to have had the opportunity as a member of the House of Lords to have championed its cause in that chamber. This book is an erudite, but highly practical, guide to the legislation. It represents for the authors – both highly experienced and well-regarded practitioners – a continuation of their contribution to the understanding of major pieces of family law legislation. I am confident that this book will enjoy the wide critical acclaim their other publications have attracted. Its clear and detailed explanation of the steps that intending couples need to take to enter into the partnership, its consequences not only in terms of their financial and other mutual obligations including their property rights, but also the impact the partnership will have on their relationship with government agencies will be of immense assistance to a wide range of readers. Although the primary audience of the book will be solicitors and barristers called upon to advise clients on the impact of the legislation, judges and their support staff will also benefit from this guide. It should also be of considerable assistance to lecturers and others who are called upon to explain the nature and workings of what is without question a major piece of social legislation. Many agencies and organisations such as social workers and government departments will need to have a general understanding of the legislation and this work should provide an easy route to that. It is aptly titled and I am delighted to commend it. Lord Alli House of Lords June 2005
vii
Acknowledgements
The authors would like to express their sincere thanks to Steve Beaver, Costas Paraskeva and John Parker for their technical support and to Cecilia Barrett for her assistance by proofreading. The responsibility for errors and omissions is, of course, our own. Paul Mallender Jane Rayson
viii
Table of cases
A (A Minor), Re (1980) 10 Fam Law 184 A v A (Maintenance Pending Suit: Provision for Legal Fees) [2001] 1 WLR 605 Barrett v Barrett [1988] 2 FLR 516 Bellinger v Bellinger [2001] 3 FCR 1, [2003] UKHL 21, [2003] FCR 1 Bergin v Bergin [1983] 1 All ER 905, [1983] 1 WLR 279 Bernstein v O’Neill [1989] 2 FLR 1 Birch v Birch [1992] 1 FLR 564, [1992] Fam Law 290 Bown v Bown and Weston [1949] P 91 Chalmers v Johns [1999] 1 FLR 392 Clarkson v Clarkson (1930) 143 LT 775, 46 LTR 623 Corbett v Corbett (otherwise Ashley) [1971] P 83, [1970] 2 All ER 33, 49 Cossey v UK [1991] 2 FLR 492 De Reneville v De Reneville [1948] 1 All ER 56 Dinch v Dinch [1987] 1 WLR 252, [1987] 2 FLR 162 G (A Minor) (Parental Responsibility Order), Re [1994] 1 FLR 504 Ghaidan v Mendoza [2004] UKHL 30 Gillick v West Norfolk and Wisbech Area Health Authority and the DHSS [1986] 1 AC 112, [1986] 1 FLR 224 Goodwin v UK [2002] 2 FCR 577 GW v GW [2003] EWHC 611; [2003] 2 FCR 298, [2003] 2 FLR 108 Hale v Hale [1975] 1 WLR 931 Hamlin v Hamlin [1986] Fam 11, [1985] 3 WLR 629 I v UK [2002] 2 FCR 613 Jordan v Jordan [1999] 2 FLR 1069 Kaur v Secretary of State for Social Services [1981] 3 FLR 237 Lilford v Glynn [1979] 1 WLR 78, [1979] 1 All ER 441 Livingstone-Stallard v Livingstone-Stallard [1974] Fam 47, [1974] 2 All ER 766 M v M (Child of the Family) (1980) 2 FLR 39 M v M (Financial Provision) [1987] 2 FLR 1 M v M (Financial Relief: Substantial Earning Capacity) [2004] 2 FLR 236 Mawson v Mawson [1994] 2 FLR 895
46 95 93 50 56 98 57 42 80 55 50 50 64 89 46 38 45 50 86 89 99 50 107 43 88 56 46 93 86 96
ix
Table of cases
McG (formerly R) v R [1972] 1 All ER 362, [1972] 1 WLR 237 Mouncer v Mouncer [1972] 1 All ER 289, [1972] 1 WLR 321 N v N (Foreign Divorce: Financial Relief) [1997] 1 FLR 900 Newlon Housing Trust v Alsulaimen [1999] AC 313, [1998] 2 FLR 690 Nicholson (deceased), Re [1974] 1 WLR 476 O’Neill v O’Neill [1975] 3 All ER 289, [1975] 1 WLR 1118 Passee v Passee [1988] 1 FLR 263 Pavlou, a bankrupt, Re [1993] 3 All ER 955 Pearce v Pearce [2003] EWCA Civ 1054 [2003] 2 FLR 1144 Pettitt v Pettitt [1970] AC 777, 36 R v Registrar General, ex p P and G [1996] 2 FCR 588 R v Tan [1983] QB 1053 Rees v UK [1987] FLR 111 S-T v J (Transsexual: void marriage) [1997] 1 FCR 349 Sheffield and Horsham v UK [1998] 2 2FLR 928 Tavoulareas v Tavoulareas [1998] 2 FLR 418 Thomas v Fuller-Brown [1988] 1 FLR 237 White v White [2001] AC 596, [2000] 2 FLR 981 Wicks v Wicks [1998] 1 FLR 470
x
58 57 106 89 37 56 37 37 97 37 49 49 50 50 50 88 36 92 88
Table of statutes
1774 1837 1860 1882 1892 1925 1925 1945 1947 1949 1952 1954 1954 1955 1957
1958
1962 1967 1968 1970 1971 1972
Life Assurance Act 112 Wills Act 39 Matrimonial Causes Act 61 Married Women’s Property Act 37, 41 Foreign Marriage Act 28, 29 Administration of Estates Act 40 Law of Property Act 38 Statutory Orders (Special Procedure) Act 65 Naval Forces (Enforcement of Maintenance Liabilities) Act 44 Marriage Act 24 Prison Act 14 Landlord and Tenant Act 38 Pharmacy Act 113 Army Act 30, 44 Registration of Births, Deaths and Marriages (Special Provisions) Act 30 Matrimonial Causes (Property and Maintenance) Act 37 Law Reform (Husband and Wife) Act 42 Leasehold Reform Act 38 Caravan Sites Act 38 Matrimonial Proceedings and Property Act 36 Immigration Act 21, 22 Social Security Contributions and Benefits Act 43
1973 1974 1975
1975 1976 1976 1977 1977 1980 1980 1981 1983 1984 1984
1985 1986 1987
1988 1989 1989 1991
Matrimonial Causes Act 46, 50, 51, 53, 86–7 Slaughterhouses Act 113 Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 40–1 Sex Discrimination Act 112 Fatal Accidents Act 42 Rent (Agricultural) Act 38, 84 National Health Service Act 14–15 Rent Act 38, 84, 109 Domestic Proceedings and Magistrates’ Courts Act 99 Housing Act 39 British Nationality Act 29 Mental Health Act 66 Dentists Act 113 Matrimonial and Family Proceedings Act 85, 106, 110, 111–12 Housing Act 38, 84, 109 Agricultural Holdings Act 38 Domestic Proceedings and Magistrates’ Courts Act 85, 100, 101, 103 Housing Act 38, 109 Children Act 45–8, 81–2, 86, 103–4, 113 Local Government and Housing Act 38 Child Support Act 42–3, 48, 86, 104–5
xi
Table of statutes
1992 1992 1995 1996 1996 1999
xii
Social Security Administration Act 43 Social Security Contributions and Benefits Act 44 Jobseekers Act 43 Family Law Act 59, 60, 77, 78–9, 84, 109 Housing Act 84 Welfare Reform and Pensions Act 90, 91
2002 2002 2003 2004 2005
Adoption and Children Act 46, 48 Tax Credits Act 43 Sexual Offences Act 113 Gender Recognition Act 3, 6, 22, 34, 49–53, 66–70 Tax Credits Nonlocation of Changes of Circumstances (Civil Partnership) (Transitional Provisions) Order 43
1 Introduction to the Act
1.1
Background The Civil Partnership Act 2004 received the Royal Assent on 18 November 2004. Section 263 of the Act provides for the coming into force of its provisions. All the substantive provisions of the Act are to come into force by commencement orders. At the date of publication of this book at least one commencement order has been made, namely the Civil Partnership Act 2004 (Commencement Order No.1) Order 2005 (S.I. 112) and the indication from the Department of Constitutional Affairs is that because of the large volume of rules to be made in the wake of the Act, it will not to be brought fully into force until 5 December 2005. The Act was heralded by a document originating in the Women and Equality Unit of the Department of Trade and Industry in June 2003 entitled ‘Civil Partnership – A framework for the legal recognition of same-sex couples’ with a foreword by Jacqui Smith M.P., the then Minister of State for Industry and the Regions and Deputy Minister for Women and Equality. Her words are an attempt to summarise or encapsulate what the government perceived as the unfairness and injustice that the Act seeks to remedy. In that foreword the Minister stated: Today there are thousands of same-sex couples living in stable and committed partnership. These relationships span many years with couples looking after each other, caring for their loved ones and actively participating in society; in fact living in exactly the same way as any other family. They are our families, our friends, our colleagues and our neighbours. Yet the law rarely recognises their relationship.
Many have been refused a hospital visit to see their seriously ill partners, or have been refused their rightful place at their partner’s funeral. Others find themselves unable to access employment benefits reserved only for married partners. Couples who have supported each other financially throughout their working lives often have no way of gaining pension rights. Grieving partners can find themselves unable to stay in their shared home or to inherit the possessions they have shared for years when one partner dies suddenly without leaving a will. 1
1.2
Civil Partnership Act 2004 – a practical guide
In so many areas, as far as the law is concerned, same-sex relationships simply do not exist. This is not acceptable. After a consultation period of three months a report summarising the consultation findings was published. An intention to bring forward a Civil Partnership Bill was announced in the Queen’s Speech on 26 November 2003 and the Civil Partnership Bill was introduced into the House of Lords on 30 March 2004. The press was largely supportive of the Bill. In April 2004 The Times in an editorial comment entitled ‘Commitment Rewarded’ opined that . . . far from undermining marriage the Bill encourages the long term commitment and mutual support that make marriage such a benefit to society. Gay couples will not enter lightly into civil partnerships, for their dissolution will be as complicated and painful as divorce. In order to avail themselves of the tax and legal advantages of a civil partnership they will also have to take on the responsibility to care for each other and live together as a loving and supportive couple.
The fact that all the three leading parliamentary parties decided that there was to be a free vote on the Bill and that Michael Howard, as leader of the Conservative Opposition, signalled at an early stage that he intended to support it was an indication of how political thinking has changed in relation to the way society perceives same-sex relations in Britain today. However, the passage of the Bill through its parliamentary stages was not without its difficulties, particularly in the House of Lords, when, in its final stages, an attempt was made to amend it in such a way that the whole rationale and intent of the legislation would have been undermined. The House of Commons rejected the amendment and the Lords finally yielded to the will of the lower House.
1.2
Summary The purpose of the legislation is to enable same-sex couples to obtain legal recognition of their relationship by forming a civil partnership, which they may do by registering as civil partners of each other provided: • • • •
they are of the same sex, they are not already in an existing civil partnership or lawfully married, they are both over the age of sixteen, they are not within the prohibited degrees of relationship.
Forming a civil partnership will have legal consequences. The civil partners will assume legal rights and responsibilities with regard to each other and to third parties, including the state. Some foreign jurisdictions have amended their domestic law to make available to same-sex couples the institution of marriage. For example in Belgium it is possible for a same-sex couple to get married in the same way as a heterosexual couple and more recently Canada has taken this step. However, most European countries, now including ours, have shrunk 2
Introduction to the Act
1.3
from going that far and have opted for a civil partnership or something very close to it. Although it is not marriage, civil partnership is in truth very close to that institution and many of the provisions of the Act will sound familiar to the family practitioner. Many of its provisions are taken directly, word for word, from the statutes that regulate heterosexual married life and many of the amendments to existing legislation are achieved by inserting after ‘spouse’ the words ‘or civil partner’. The vast array of amendments to existing legislation ensure that partners who are in a civil partnership are put on a similar footing to a couple who have married heterosexually with the result that, although the proponents of the legislation assiduously avoided the phrase, something very like ‘gay marriage’ has been created by this Act.
1.3
Scotland and Northern Ireland Somewhat unusually for legislation of this nature, the Act contains not only provisions relating to the jurisdiction of England and Wales, but also provisions that relate to both Scotland and Northern Ireland. The reason for that is that both the Scottish Parliament and the Northern Ireland Office Ministers agreed to the inclusion in the Westminster Civil Partnership Bill of the provisions necessary to make the scheme available to those resident within their own borders. This makes for a somewhat bulky, if not intimidating, document. In one sense it is three Acts of Parliament rolled into one, but only one of which is material to those who practise exclusively in the jurisdiction of England and Wales. Helpfully, the Act is divided in such a way that it is abundantly clear which of the 264 sections contained within its 8 Parts and which of the 30 Schedules (alone comprising some 300 pages) relate to which of the three jurisdictions. It is beyond the ambition of this book to serve as a practical guide for Scottish lawyers, or for those who practise in Northern Ireland, who will no doubt have the benefit, or burden, of similar publications to address the substantive law and procedures peculiar to their respective jurisdictions. It is necessary, however, to have some understanding of the provisions in the Act that relate to nullity in Scotland and in Northern Ireland as those provisions contribute to a full knowledge of the grounds upon which a civil partnership is regarded by the law of this jurisdiction as either void or voidable (as to nullity, see chapter 11). Where two people register as civil partners of each other in Scotland, the civil partnership is void for the purposes of the law of England and Wales only if it would be void under the Scottish provisions in section 123 of the Act. The partnership will also be voidable if an interim gender certificate is subsequently issued to either party under the Gender Recognition Act 2004 (s.54(1) of the Act). Similarly, in relation to Northern Ireland where two people register as civil partners of each other in that jurisdiction, the civil partnership is void for the purposes of the law of England and Wales only if it would be void under the Northern Ireland provisions in section 173 of the Act. The partnership 3
1.3
Civil Partnership Act 2004 – a practical guide
will also be voidable if the circumstances are as described in paragraph 50(1) of the Act. Gretna Green
It has always been possible for young lovers (i.e. those over sixteen, but under eighteen years) to elope to Scotland, specifically to Gretna Green near Dumfries, in order to marry where the consent of their parents or guardian is not forthcoming, and for that marriage to be recognised as valid in England and Wales. It appears that the same facility will be available to prospective civil partners. Under the provisions that relate to England and Wales (see chapter 2) where one of the proposed civil partners is over sixteen years, but under eighteen years of age, parental consent is required under section 4 of the Act. Without such consent (or the consent of the court where parental consent is either withheld or unobtainable) any subsequent civil partnership is effectively void in this jurisdiction under section 49(c). In Scotland, however, although both civil partners must be at least sixteen years of age (one of the same eligibility requirements as in England and Wales), if a prospective civil partner is over sixteen, but under eighteen years of age, there is no requirement for parental consent. In determining whether the civil partnership of two people, one or both of whom are under eighteen years of age and who register as civil partners of each other in Scotland, is valid in England and Wales, section 54 of the Act provides that such a civil partnership is void if, and only if, it would be void in Scotland under section 123. In fact any civil partnership formed or created without parental consent is perfectly lawful in Scotland and an absence of parental consent is not a ground for holding that the civil partnership is void (see section 123 of the Act).
4
2 What is a civil partnership? Formation by registration in England and Wales: eligibility
2.1
Introduction In essence, a civil partnership is a legal relationship between two people of the same sex, which can be created, or formed, in either of two ways. The first method is by registration of the civil partnership either in the United Kingdom, or under what is termed an Order in Council, which allows for registration at British Consulates or by armed forces personnel. The second method is where the couple register an ‘overseas relationship’ (as defined in the Act) which is treated under the Act as a civil partnership. Once formed, the civil partnership, however created, subsists until it is ended by death, dissolution or annulment (s.1(3)). In England and Wales the chief method whereby a civil partnership will be formed or created, namely by registration, is achieved by the prospective civil partners signing a document issued to them by an authority created under the Act called the registration authority. The signing has to be attended by certain formalities, and before it is issued the partners have to comply with the pre-registration procedure, the steps of which differ according to the particular circumstances of the prospective partners. This chapter will deal chiefly with eligibility. In the next chapter we will deal with the pre-registration procedure in relation to the method that most English and Welsh practitioners are likely to encounter, namely by registration of the civil partnership in the United Kingdom, and specifically in England and Wales. In later chapters we examine in detail the other pre-registration procedures, the signing ceremony or registration itself, and how a civil partnership can be created abroad either by registration under Order in Council, or where the couple register an overseas relationship which is treated as a civil partnership under Chapter 2 of Part 5 of the Act. Before a detailed consideration of the procedural stages is undertaken it is necessary to establish eligibility.
5
2.2
Civil Partnership Act 2004 – a practical guide
2.2
Eligibility Section 3(1) of the Act provides that two people are not eligible to register as civil partners of each other if: (a) (b) (c) (d)
2.2.1
they are not of the same sex; either of them is already a civil partner or lawfully married; either of them is under sixteen; they are within prohibited degrees of relationship.
Not of the same sex One of the elements that render a couple ineligible to marry each other is an essential constituent of the eligibility test for a civil partnership. In most cases this element of eligibility will not cause a problem. However, the provisions of the Gender Recognition Act 2004 may bring about complications, and it must be remembered that gender is no longer determined simply by the entry on a birth certificate. It is now possible for an individual to acquire a gender different from the one they were born with. The Gender Recognition Act has a significant impact on the Civil Partnership Act and is the subject of a separate chapter (chapter 9), which examines the correlation between the two Acts.
2.2.2
Already a civil partner or lawfully married Under the Act the court is given powers to dissolve a civil partnership or to annul such a partnership or even to make an order which dissolves a civil partnership on the ground that one of the civil partners is presumed to be dead. Clearly, therefore, the Act only renders ineligible someone who is in a subsisting civil partnership and not a party who has previously been in such a partnership, which has been the subject of any of the dissolving orders under the Act. The section also prohibits a person who is in a subsisting marriage from registering as the civil partner of another.
2.2.3
Either is under the age of sixteen The section renders wholly ineligible any person who is under sixteen. Moreover, where one of the prospective civil partners is under eighteen the consent of an appropriate person is generally required.
2.2.4
Prohibited degrees of relationship Part 1 of Schedule 1 of the Act contains provisions for determining when two people are within prohibited degrees of relationship for the purposes of section 3 of the Act (s.3(2)). What follows is a summary of those provisions, but it is essential that, in any given case, careful reference is made to the detailed provisions contained in Schedule 1.
6
What is a civil partnership?
2.2
Absolute prohibitions Paragraph 1(1) of Part 1 of Schedule 1 lists the people who are absolutely prohibited from forming a civil partnership with each other. Broadly speaking, they are blood relationships and there are no circumstances in which a civil partnership is permitted between them. Two people are within absolutely prohibited degrees of relationship if one falls within the list below in relation to the other. • • • • • • • • • •
Adoptive child Adoptive parent Child Former adoptive child Grandparent Grandchild Parent Parent’s sibling Sibling Sibling’s child
‘Sibling’ in this context means a brother, sister, half-brother or half-sister (paragraph 1(2)). Qualified prohibitions Paragraphs 2 and 3 of Part 1 list the people who are prohibited from forming a civil partnership with each other unless certain conditions are met. Broadly speaking, they are ‘in-laws’. Two people are within prohibited degrees of relationship if one of them falls within the list below in relation to the other: • • • • • • • •
Child of former civil partner Child of former spouse Former civil partner of grandparent Former civil partner of parent Former spouse of grandparent Former spouse of parent Grandchild of former civil partner Grandchild of former spouse
(paragraph 2(1)). In this context ‘child of the family’, in relation to another person, means a person who has lived in the same household as that other person and has been treated by that other person as a child of his family (paragraph 2(2)). However, if both persons in the qualified prohibitions list have reached twenty-one at the time when they register as civil partners of each other and the younger has not at any time before reaching eighteen been a child of the family in relation to the other, the partnership is permissible although the Act imposes additional procedural safeguards to ensure that the requirements of the legislation are complied with. 7
2.2
Civil Partnership Act 2004 – a practical guide
Death removes certain prohibitions Two people are within prohibited degrees of relationship if one falls within column 1 of the table below in relation to the other unless: (a) both of them have reached twenty-one at the time when they register as civil partners of each other, and (b) the persons who fall within column 2 are dead.
8
Relationship
Relevant deaths
Former civil partner of child
The child The child’s other parent
Former spouse of child
The child The child’s other parent
Parent of former civil partner
The former civil partner The former civil partner’s other parent
Parent of former spouse
The former spouse The former spouse’s other parent
3 Pre-registration procedure: standard procedure; house-bound and detained partners; certain non-residents and other special cases 3.1
Introduction The pre-registration procedure followed by prospective civil partners will depend on their particular circumstances. Most will follow what the Act describes as the standard procedure, but the Act also caters for persons who are housebound, for detained persons and there is also a special procedure for cases where one or both of the prospective civil partners is seriously ill and not expected to recover. Moreover, all the procedures (except for the special procedure) are subject to modification where one of the partners is a non-resident (see 3.5 for who is regarded as a non-resident) or is a former spouse who has changed sex. The procedure will also be different in those cases where there are issues of prohibited degrees of relationship and where one of the proposed civil partners is under eighteen. Finally, there are special procedural considerations in the case of a prospective civil partner who is subject to immigration control.
3.2
Standard pre-registration procedure
3.2.1
Giving notice Each of the would-be civil partners must give notice of the proposed civil partnership to a registration authority and must also have resided in England and Wales for at least seven days immediately before giving the notice (s.8(1)). Registration authority In relation to England ‘registration authority’ means a county council, the council of any district comprised in an area for which there is no county council, a London borough council, the Common Council of the City of London or the Council of the Isles of Scilly (s.28(a)) and in relation to Wales, a county council or county borough council (s.28(b)). Notice The notice must contain such information as may be prescribed by the regulations (s.8(2)). At the time of writing, the prescribed information has not yet been the subject of regulation, but section 8(3) already provides that the 9
3.2
Civil Partnership Act 2004 – a practical guide
notice must include a solemn declaration in writing by the person giving notice that he or she believes that there are no lawful impediments to the formation of the civil partnership and that each of the civil partners has had a usual place of residence in England and Wales for at least seven days immediately before giving the notice (s.8(4)(a) and (b)). The declaration must be signed by the person giving the notice at the time when the notice is given and in the presence of an authorised person (s.8(3)(a) and (b)). The authorised person must then attest the declaration by adding his name, description and place of residence (s.8(3)). Authorised person Section 8(6) defines an authorised person as an employee or officer or other person provided by a registration authority who is authorised by that authority to attest notices of proposed civil partnership.
3.2.2
Duty of the registration authority When the registration authority is given notice of a proposed civil partnership, it must record in the register as soon as possible the fact that the notice has been given, together with the information in it and that the authorised person has attested the declaration (s.8(5)). The register Section 30(2) of the Act imposes a duty on the Registrar General for England and Wales to provide a system for keeping any records that relate to civil partnership required by the Act, and the register is defined as the system for keeping those records (s.30(4)). Registrar General Section 30 of the Act defines the Registrar General as the Registrar General for England and Wales.
3.2.3
Evidence The registration authority need not take at face value the information provided by each of the civil partners. Section 9 of the Act empowers a registration authority to request a person giving notice to provide evidence to verify certain information. Such requests may be made any time before the registration authority issues the civil partnership schedule, and the evidence can relate to a person’s name and surname, age, as to whether the person has previously formed a civil partnership or a marriage, and, if so, as to the ending of the civil partnership or marriage. Evidence may also be requested of a person’s nationality and about their residence in England and Wales during the relevant seven days (s.9(3)).
3.2.4
Publicity Civil partnership is not for the publicity shy. Reminiscent of the concept of ‘banns’ in the context of marriage, there is a requirement imposed by section 10(1) on potentially several different registration authorities, as well as the Registrar General (as to which see 3.2.2) to publicise during ‘the waiting period’ information (referred to as ‘relevant information’) in relation to the proposed
10
Pre-registration procedure
3.2
civil partnership, namely the name of the person giving the notice, the name of that person’s proposed civil partner and possibly other information. We say possibly other information because the section states that ‘ relevant information’ includes ‘such other information as may be prescribed by regulations’, so we have to see what information in due course the regulations might provide for. It is a reasonable assumption that this publicity requirement may deter some partners from becoming civil partners under the Act. This was foreshadowed in the DTI consultation document entitled ‘Civil Partnership – A framework for the legal recognition of same-sex couples’ (referred to in chapter 1), which recognised that same-sex couples might want the fact of their registration to remain private for all sorts of reasons, not least of which could be homophobic attack. However, balanced against that understandable wish for privacy is the recognition that partnership registration carries with it a very significant commitment and confers such a wide range of rights and responsibilities not only between the state and the couple, but also between the partners and third parties, that it should be a matter of public record. It was also felt that public knowledge might strengthen the legitimacy of civil partnership registration in the wider culture. Added to that is the practical consideration that anyone who knows of an impediment to the forthcoming civil partnership registration should have the same opportunity to raise an objection (see 3.2.6) as he or she would have in relation to other formal changes of legal status.
3.2.5
Waiting period Ordinarily the waiting period, prescribed by section 10, begins on the day after the notice of the proposed civil partnership has been recorded in accordance with section 8(5) of the Act and ends fifteen days later (s.11). However, if the Registrar General is satisfied, because of exceptional circumstances, that there are compelling reasons to do so, he is empowered by section 12(1) to reduce the usual waiting period by as much as he considers appropriate, if he receives an application to do so. The wording of the section suggests that the Registrar General cannot of his own motion shorten the waiting period. Section 12(2) and (3) give the Registrar General power to make procedural regulations in relation to such applications and to make regulations delegating the power to shorten the waiting period to a registration authority in prescribed cases, and making provision for appeals to the Registrar General against any decision taken by a registration authority where this power has been delegated.
3.2.6
Objections Unsurprisingly the Act provides a mechanism for any person to object to the issue of a civil partnership schedule. By section 13 the objector must give the registration authority notice of his objection. Although not explicit, it is plain 11
3.2
Civil Partnership Act 2004 – a practical guide
that the notice of objection cannot be made verbally because section 13(2) provides that the notice of objection must state the objector’s place of residence and the ground of objection and it must be signed by the objector or on his behalf. Once an objection is received, the registration authority must record in the register the fact that the objection has been made and the information it contains as soon as possible (s.13(3)).
3.2.7
Civil partnership schedule As soon as the fifteen-day waiting period has expired, it is open to one or both of the proposed civil partners to request the registration authority, in whose area it is proposed that the registration is to take place, to issue a document to be known as a civil partnership schedule. The contents of the schedule will be prescribed by regulations to be made under section 14(2). Provided that the registration authority is satisfied that no lawful impediment to the formation of the civil partnership exists, and that (if applicable) any objections to the proposed civil partnership have been satisfactorily investigated by the relevant registration authority, or have been withdrawn (s.14(4)), it must issue the civil partnership schedule (s.14(1)). The ‘relevant registration authority’ means the authority which first records that a notice of proposed civil partnership has been given (s.14(5)).
3.2.8
Appeal against refusal to issue If a registration authority refuses to issue a civil partnership schedule (whether on account of an objection under section 13 or because the authority is not satisfied that there is no lawful impediment to the proposed partnership), either of the proposed civil partners may appeal to the Registrar General whereupon he must either confirm the refusal or direct that a civil partnership schedule be issued (s.15).
3.2.9
Frivolous objections If a person objects to the issue of a civil partnership schedule and the Registrar General declares that the objection is frivolous and ought not to obstruct the issue of the civil partnership schedule, the frivolous objector is liable to pay the costs of the proceedings before the Registrar General and to pay damages to the proposed civil partner to whom the objection relates (s.16(1) and (3)). The same liability arises if someone makes a representation to the registration authority alleging that there is a lawful impediment to the formation of the partnership, and that representation is declared to be frivolous and not capable of obstructing the issue of the civil partnership schedule (s.16(2) and (3)). In proceedings for the recovery of such costs and damages, a sealed copy of the Registrar’s declaration is sufficient evidence that the declaration was made (s.16(4)).
12
Pre-registration procedure
3.2.10
3.3
Time limit for registration Section 17(1) provides that the proposed civil partners may not register as civil partners of each other until the waiting period (see above) in relation to each notice of the proposed civil partnership has expired. On the face of it this is a somewhat surprising provision, as the duty to issue the civil partnership schedule is not imposed on the registration authority until after the expiration of the specified waiting period (see s.14(1)) and so ordinarily the registration authority is unlikely to issue the schedule until after the expiration of the waiting period, and without the civil partnership schedule registration of the civil partnership would not be possible in any event. However, in the event that the civil partnership schedule came to be issued before the expiration of the waiting period, section 17(1) forbids the proposed civil partners from deploying it before the waiting period has expired. Once they are entitled to do so, ordinarily the partners may register their civil partnership at any time during a period of twelve months beginning with the day on which the notices of the proposed civil partnership were recorded under section 8(5). If the notices are not recorded on the same day, the twelve months runs from the earlier of those days (s.17(4)).
3.2.11
Failure to register Section 17(3) provides that if the partners fail to register within the twelvemonth period, both the notices and the civil partnership schedule become void, and the partners would have to start all over again.
3.3
House-bound persons The pre-registration procedure for house-bound persons is not markedly different from the standard procedure.
3.3.1
‘House-bound’ This modified procedure applies to a person who, in the opinion of a registered medical practitioner (to be given by way of a statement referred to as ‘a medical statement’ in such manner as may be prescribed by regulations), ought not, because of illness or disability, to move or be moved from the place where he is at the time when the statement is made, and that this is likely to be the case for at least the next three months (s.18(2)).
3.3.2
How procedure differs The procedure is the same but with the additional requirements as follows: (1) A medical statement, as described above, must accompany each notice of proposed civil partnership. Any such statement must not be more 13
3.4
Civil Partnership Act 2004 – a practical guide
than fourteen days old in relation to the day on which the notice is recorded. (2) Receipt of the medical statement must be recorded in the register. (3) The period within which the civil partnership schedule must be signed (ordinarily twelve months – see above) is shortened to three months (s.18(3)). Section 18(6) provides that for the purposes of forming a civil partnership, a house-bound person is treated as being resident and usually resident at the place where he or she is for the time being, even if this would not otherwise be the case.
3.4
Detained persons
3.4.1
Generally Again, the only divergence from the standard procedure is that each notice of proposed civil partnership must be accompanied by a statement, made by the responsible authority not more than twenty-one days before the day on which the notice is recorded, which identifies the establishment where the person is detained and states that the responsible authority has no objection to that establishment being specified in a notice of proposed civil partnership as the place where the detained person is to register as a civil partner. Receipt of the statement must be recorded in the register, and, as with house-bound persons, the period within which the civil partnership schedule must be signed is shortened to three months (s.19).
3.4.2
‘Detained’ For the purposes of section 19, ‘detained’ means detained as a patient in a hospital (other than a short term detainee under the Mental Health Act 1983) or in a prison or other place to which the Prison Act 1952 applies (s.19(2)). ‘Patient’, ‘Hospital’ etc.
Both have the same meaning as in Part 2 of the Mental Health Act 1983 (s.19(7)): ‘Hospital’ means – (a) any health service hospital within the meaning of the National Health Service Act 1977; and (b) any accommodation provided by a local authority and used as a hospital by or on behalf of the Secretary of State under that Act. ‘Patient’ means a person suffering or appearing to be suffering from mental disorder; ‘Managers’ has the same meaning as in section 145(1) of the 1983 Act which provides: 14
Pre-registration procedure
3.5
(a) in relation to a hospital vested in the Secretary of State for the purposes of his functions under the National Health Service Act 1977, and in relation to any accommodation provided by a local authority and used as a hospital by or on behalf of the Secretary of State under that Act, the [Primary Care Trust,] [Strategic Health Authority,] [Health Authority or Special Health Authority] responsible for the administration of the hospital; (b) in relation to a special hospital, the Secretary of State; [(bb) in relation to a hospital vested in [a Primary Care Trust or] a National Health Service trust, . . . the trust;] [(bc) in relation to a hospital vested in an NHS foundation trust, the trust;] [(c) in relation to a registered establishment, the person or persons registered in respect of the establishment;] ‘Responsible authority ’
If a person is detained in a hospital, the managers of the hospital constitute the responsible authority; if in prison, the governor or officer for the time being in charge (s.19(6)). Again, for the purpose of forming a civil partnership, section 19(8) treats a detained person as being resident and usually resident at the place where he is for the time being, even if it would not otherwise be the case.
3.5
Certain non-residents Where two people wish to register as civil partners of each other in England and Wales in circumstances where one is resident in England and Wales and the other is a non-resident by virtue of being resident either in Scotland or in Northern Ireland or because he is a member of Her Majesty’s forces serving outside the UK, section 20 of the Act imposes certain modifications to the preregistration standard procedure, to the procedure applicable to house-bound persons, and to that applicable to detained persons.
3.5.1
How procedure differs Section 20(5) sets out the modifications: (1) The resident partner is still required to give notice in the usual way, but the non-resident partner is not required to give notice of proposed civil partnership. Ordinarily both partners have to give notice under section 8(1). (2) The notice given by the resident partner need not contain the declaration ordinarily required under section 8(4) that each of the proposed partners has resided in England and Wales for at least seven days before giving the notice. (3) The waiting period is calculated by reference to the day on which the resident’s notice of proposed civil partnership is recorded. That must follow because only the notice of the resident partner is required to be given. 15
3.6
Civil Partnership Act 2004 – a practical guide
(4) Although he or she is not required to give notice, the non-resident partner must nonetheless have been issued with a certificate of no impediment. In the case of a partner who is a non-resident by virtue of being resident in Scotland, the certificate of no impediment is issued under section 97 of the Act; if a non-resident by reason of living in Northern Ireland, the relevant certificate will be issued under section 150 of the Act; and, in the case of a member of Her Majesty’s forces who is serving outside the UK, the no impediment certificate must be issued under section 239 of the Act. If neither partner produces the certificate of no impediment, a registration authority must not issue a civil partnership schedule (s.20(5)(d)). (5) In the case of the standard procedure, where one of the proposed civil partners resides in Scotland or Northern Ireland (but not where the non-resident is a member of the forces serving outside the UK), the civil partnership schedule must be signed within three months (that reduction from twelve months is always applicable for house-bound and detained persons – see 3.3.2 and 3.4.1).
3.6
Additional safeguards where the proposed partners are within prohibited degrees of relationship and/or where a proposed civil partner is under eighteen
3.6.1
Prohibited degrees of relationship; paragraph 2 There can be no legal civil partnership where the proposed civil partners are within certain degrees of relationship (broadly speaking these are blood relationships), in respect of which there is an absolute prohibition. However, the proposed civil partners may be within other degrees of relationship where the prohibition on the formation of a civil partnership is of a qualified nature. These relationships of ‘qualified prohibition’ are set out in paragraphs 2 and 3 of Part 1 of Schedule 1 to the Act and for convenience they are listed at 2.2.4. In relation to the degrees of relationship that are listed in paragraph 2, the civil partnership may nonetheless take place provided that both persons have reached twenty-one at the time when they register as civil partners of each other and the younger has not at any time before reaching eighteen been a child of the family in relation to the other. However, where two people are subject to paragraph 2, but intend to register as civil partners of each other by signing a civil partnership schedule, paragraph 5 of Part 2 of the Schedule provides that a registration authority must not record the fact that a notice of proposed civil partnership has been given unless it is satisfied by the production of evidence of age that both parties have reached twenty-one, and that it has received a declaration (‘a 5(1)(b) declaration’) made by each of the proposed civil partners specifying their affinal relationship and declaring that the younger of them has not at any time before reaching eighteen been a child of the family in relation to the other. The content and the manner of signing
16
Pre-registration procedure
3.7
and attesting a declaration made under paragraph 5(1)(b) will be prescribed by regulations.
3.6.2
Duty of the registration authority The registration authority must record in the register the fact that it has received a 5(1)(b) declaration and must file and keep it.
3.6.3
High Court declaration As an alternative to a 5(1)(b) declaration, it is open to either of the proposed civil partners to apply under paragraph 7 to the High Court for a declaration as to the matters contained in paragraph 5(1)(b), and that in those circumstances there is no impediment of affinity to the formation of the civil partnership.
3.6.4
False declaration If a registration authority in whose area it is proposed the registration takes place receives from a person other than one of the proposed civil partners a signed written statement alleging that a 5(1)(b) declaration, as shown in the register, is false, the authority must not issue a civil partnership schedule unless a High Court declaration (as described above) is received.
3.6.5
Provisions relating to paragraph 3 qualified prohibitions In certain circumstances those who are within the degrees of relationship that are listed in paragraph 3 may still form a lawful civil partnership provided that certain conditions are fulfilled. In order to be satisfied that the conditions are fulfilled, evidence of age and relevant deaths must be produced before the fact that a notice of proposed civil partnership has been given can be recorded in the register by the registration authority. It is curious that paragraph 9(2) of Part 2 which imposes this requirement does not also include a requirement of a declaration from the parties nor does it provide the alternative of a declaration from the court.
3.7
Persons under eighteen in England and Wales There can of course be no lawful civil partnership between two proposed civil partners if one of them is under sixteen (s.3(c) of the Act). However, if one proposed civil partner is over sixteen, but under eighteen, there are procedural safeguards in recognition of the fact that the proposed civil partner, though over sixteen and capable in law of forming a civil partnership, is still a minor. The starting point in the event that one of the proposed civil partners is under eighteen is section 4 of the Act, which sets out the provisions requiring consent. Section 4(1) provides that the consent of the appropriate persons is required 17
3.7
Civil Partnership Act 2004 – a practical guide
before a ‘child’ (a person under eighteen according to s.4(5)) may register as the civil partner of another.
3.7.1
Appropriate persons In order to establish who are the appropriate persons in any given case, it is necessary to consult Part 1 of Schedule 2 to the Act, paragraph 1 of which sets out in table form the appropriate persons or bodies required to give consent to the civil partnership of a child. It is self-explanatory and deals comprehensively with the range of circumstances in which such a child might find himself, from being in the ordinary care of his parents to being placed for adoption with adoptive parents and all the possible placements in between.
3.7.2
If child is surviving civil partner Section 4(3) excepts a child who is a surviving civil partner from the basic requirement of consent under section 4.
3.7.3
Ward of court The consent of the High Court will still be required if one of the proposed civil partners is a ward of court (s.4(4)).
3.7.4
Consent unobtainable Where a child and another person intend to register as civil partners under any procedure other than the special procedure (as to which see 4.3), and consent of the appropriate person is unobtainable because the person whose consent is required is absent, inaccessible or under a disability, paragraph 3 of Part 2 provides a remedy, namely for the registration authority to dispense with that consent if there is another person whose consent is also required. If only the consent of the missing, inaccessible or disabled person is required, the Registrar General may dispense with the need for any consent, or, in those circumstances, the court (as defined in paragraph 15 of Schedule 2) may, on application, consent to the child registering as the civil partner of the other, and that consent has the same effect as if the consent had come from the ‘appropriate person’.
3.7.5
Refusal of consent of appropriate person Paragraph 4 enables a court to give its consent if the appropriate person refuses to do so.
3.7.6
Declaration Under section 8(3) of the Act every notice of proposed civil partnership must include a solemn declaration in writing by the person giving notice that he
18
Pre-registration procedure
3.7
or she believes that there are no lawful impediments to the formation of the civil partnership and that each of the civil partners has had a usual place of residence in England and Wales for at least seven days immediately before giving the notice (s.8(4)(a) and (b)). The declaration must be signed by the person giving the notice at the time when the notice is given and in the presence of an authorised person (s.8(3)(a) and (b)). The authorised person must then attest the declaration by adding his name, description and place of residence (s.8(3)). By virtue of paragraph 5 of Schedule 2, if one of the proposed civil partners is a child, the declaration must also include a statement that the consent of each appropriate person has been obtained, or that such consent has either been dispensed with or given by the court, or that there is nobody whose consent is required.
3.7.7
Forbidding proposed civil partnership In the event that notice of proposed civil partnership between a child and another person has been recorded in the register, paragraph 6 of Schedule 2 enables a person whose consent is required to the registration of such a partnership to forbid the issue of a civil partnership schedule. The method to be adopted is for the person whose consent is required to give any registration authority written notice that he forbids it. Any written notice must specify the name of the person giving it together with his place of residence and the capacity, in relation to either of the proposed civil partners, in which he forbids the issue of the civil partnership schedule.
3.7.8
Duty of the registration authority The registration authority must, as soon as is practicable after receiving the notice forbidding the issue of the civil partnership schedule, record in the register the fact that it has been received (paragraph 6(4) of Schedule 2).
3.7.9
Effect of forbidding proposed civil partnership If the issue of the civil partnership has been forbidden under paragraph 6, the notice of proposed civil partnership and all proceedings on it are void (paragraph 6(5)). However, that is not the case if the court has given its consent under paragraphs 3 or 4 (paragraph 6(6)). Indeed, if the court’s consent has been obtained, no person can forbid the issue of a civil partnership schedule.
3.7.10
Evidence If, for the purpose of obtaining a civil partnership schedule, a person declares that the consent of any person whose consent is required under section 4 of the Act has been obtained, the registration authority is entitled under paragraph 7(2) to refuse to issue the schedule unless written evidence is produced that consent has in fact been given. 19
3.8
Civil Partnership Act 2004 – a practical guide
3.7.11
Issue of civil partnership schedule Ordinarily, provided that the registration authority is satisfied that no lawful impediment to the formation of the civil partnership exists, and that (if applicable) any objections to the proposed civil partnership have been satisfactorily investigated by the relevant registration authority, or have been withdrawn, it must issue the civil partnership schedule (s.14(1)). However, by virtue of paragraph 8, that duty does not arise if its issue has been forbidden under paragraph 6. As though to emphasise that this element of the process is kept in the forefront of the registration authority’s consideration in cases where a child is involved, in the event that a civil partnership schedule is issued, it must contain a statement that the issue of the civil partnership schedule has not been forbidden under paragraph 6 of the Schedule (paragraph 9).
3.7.12
Obtaining consent: special procedure Where the special procedure is being invoked in the case where one of the proposed civil partners is a child, provisions which broadly correspond to the provisions examined above are put in place by paragraphs 10 to 14 of Schedule 2.
3.7.13
The court For the purposes of Parts 2 and 3 of Schedule 2 the ‘court’ is defined in paragraph 15 as the High Court, the county court of the district in which any applicant or respondent resides, or a magistrates’ court acting in the local justice area in which the applicant or respondent resides. This paragraph also provides for the making of rules of court in relation to applications made under the provisions of Schedule 2, including rules to ensure that if the application is made in the High Court it will be heard in chambers, and if made in the county court it will be heard in the first instance by the district judge with a right of appeal to the circuit judge (paragraph 15(2)). Rules of court may also provide that if the application is to be heard in the magistrates’ court it shall be heard other than in open court, and may also make provision to ensure that any person involved in a hearing dealing with refusal of consent is given proper notice of the hearing.
3.8
Immigration control and the formation of civil partnerships Section 5(4) of the Act contains special provisions relating to the formation of civil partnerships in the United Kingdom by persons one of whom is subject to immigration control. Section 249 introduces Schedule 23 to the Act which sets out the procedure to be followed in such circumstances.
20
Pre-registration procedure
3.8.1
3.8
‘Subject to immigration control’ Paragraph 1(2) provides that a person is subject to immigration control if he is not an EEA national (a national of a State which is a contracting party to the Agreement on the European Economic Area signed at Oporto on 2 May 1992) and under the Immigration Act 1971 he requires leave to enter or remain in the UK whether or not leave has been given. The procedure considered below applies if the proposed civil partnership is to be formed in England and Wales by signing a civil partnership schedule.
3.8.2
Giving notice of proposed civil partnership By paragraph 4 of Schedule 23 to the Act each notice of proposed civil partnership must be given to a specified registration authority (specified, that is, by the Secretary of State under regulations made by him) and delivered to ‘the relevant individual’ in person by the two proposed civil partners. The relevant individual means such employee or officer or other person provided by the specified registration authority as is determined in accordance with regulations (paragraph 4(2)).
3.8.3
Declaration under section 8 Again, under section 8(3) of the Act every notice of proposed civil partnership must include a solemn declaration in writing by the person giving notice that he or she believes that there are no lawful impediments to the formation of the civil partnership and that each of the civil partners has had a usual place of residence in England and Wales for at least seven days immediately before giving the notice (s.8(4)(a) and (b)). The declaration must be signed by the person giving the notice at the time when the notice is given and in the presence of an authorised person (s.8(3)(a) and (b)). The authorised person must then attest the declaration by adding his name, description and place of residence (s.8(3)). By virtue of paragraph 5 of Schedule 23, if one of the proposed civil partners is subject to immigration control, the declaration must also include a statement that that person fulfils the qualifying condition (and the reason why).
3.8.4
The qualifying condition Paragraph 2 provides that the qualifying condition is that the person – (a) has an entry clearance granted expressly for the purpose of enabling him to form a civil partnership in the UK, (b) has the written permission of the Secretary of State to form a civil partnership in the UK, or (c) falls within a class specified by regulations by the Secretary of State. 21
3.9
Civil Partnership Act 2004 – a practical guide
3.8.5
Entry clearance This phrase has the meaning given by section 33(1) of the Immigration Act 1971.
3.8.6
Duty of registration authority Paragraph 6 imposes a duty on the registration authority not to record in the register the fact that a notice of proposed civil partnership has been given unless the authority is satisfied by the production of specified evidence that the qualifying condition is fulfilled. Specified evidence means such evidence as may be specified in guidance issued by the Registrar General.
3.9
Former spouse who has changed sex Before leaving pre-registration procedures it is necessary to say a few words about the procedure to be followed in certain very specific and rare circumstances, namely where one of the proposed civil partners is a former spouse of the other and has changed sex. Schedule 3 caters for the situation where two parties to a marriage, who want to stay together notwithstanding that one of them is changing gender, wish to have their marriage annulled and to register under the Act as civil partners of each other, all on the same day if they wish. This is dealt with in detail in chapter 9 which is devoted to the interrelation between the Civil Partnership Act and the Gender Recognition Act 2004.
22
4 Registration in England and Wales – the standard procedure; the special procedure
4.1
Introduction In the vast majority of cases a civil partnership will be formed, or created, at the point of registration, and that occurs once each of the civil partners has signed a document known as the civil partnership document (s.2(1)), which in most cases will be the civil partnership schedule. The signing of the civil partnership document must be attended by certain formalities. It is now time to consider in detail those formal requirements.
4.2
Registration We are all familiar with the concept of marriage and the traditional way in which a heterosexual couple marry in a church, synagogue or chapel with a priest or other religious person officiating as the couple solemnly exchange vows. Those anticipating that civil partners will be permitted under this Act to tie the knot in a similar fashion will be disappointed. The process is one much more akin to a register office ceremony. The Act requires no exchange of vows and civil partnership is formed, or created, at the point of registration. That occurs once each of the civil partners has signed a document with the less than romantic title of the civil partnership schedule (s.2(1)) in front of an official called the civil partnership registrar. The schedule is best thought of as a licence or permission to marry and is given, or issued, by a body created under the Act called the registration authority which must be satisfied of certain matters before it issues the document. It is highly likely that the existing body of registrars, who perform civil weddings on a daily basis up and down the country, will be pressed into service to undertake the functions and duties required to be discharged under the Act. In acknowledgement of the legal significance and consequences of the creation of a civil partnership, the signing of the civil partnership document must be attended by certain formalities, which will be examined in detail, and the Act carefully prescribes the steps that must be taken both before the registration and at the registration itself. To that extent the formation of a civil partnership is 23
4.2
Civil Partnership Act 2004 – a practical guide
not dissimilar to marriage, which, by the provisions of the Marriage Act 1949, has to be preceded, and attended, by a number of legal formalities.
4.2.1
No religious service Although this is the nearest the civil partners get to a ‘wedding ceremony’, section 2(5) of the Act specifically prohibits the use of any religious service while the civil partnership registrar is officiating at the signing of a civil partnership document. Curiously, the Act does not contain any sanction against that prohibition. There appears to be nothing in the Act to prohibit the use of a religious service at a time close to the signing of the civil partnership document, but the prohibition of any religious element at the time of signing underlines the civil, rather than the religious, nature of the registration.
4.2.2
Not in religious premises The civil, or temporal, nature of the registration is further underscored by the fact that the place at which two people may be registered as civil partners of each other must not be religious premises (s.6(1)(b)). The phrase ‘religious premises’ receives a wide definition in the Act as meaning any premises which are used solely or mainly for religious purposes or have been so used and have not subsequently been used solely or mainly for other purposes (s.6(2)(a)(b)). There is nothing in the Act, however, forbidding a religious ceremony at a time and place separate from the signing, nor the use of religious premises for the purpose of such a ceremony. The recent wedding between the Prince of Wales and Camilla Parker-Bowles is an illustration of how this might work: the couple were legally married in a civil ceremony at the Guildhall at Windsor, followed by a religious ceremony of blessing very shortly afterwards in St George’s Chapel ending with a reception in Windsor Castle itself.
4.2.3
Civil partnership registrar A civil partnership registrar is defined as an individual who is designated by a registration authority as a civil partnership registrar for its area (s.29(1)).
4.2.4
The signing The prospective civil partners must sign the document at the invitation of, and in the presence of, the civil partnership registrar (s.2(1)(a)). That signing must also take place in the presence of each other and in the presence of two witnesses (s.2(1)(b)). The two witnesses and the civil partnership registrar must then each sign the document in the presence of the civil partners and in the presence of each other (s.2(3)(a) and (b)).
24
Registration in England and Wales
4.2.5
4.3
After the signing Once the civil partnership document has been signed, the relevant registration authority is then charged with the duty of ensuring that the fact that the two partners have registered as civil partners of each other, together with any other information prescribed in the regulations, is recorded in the register as soon as possible (s.2(4)).
4.2.6
Place of registration The place at which two people may register as civil partners of each other must be in England and Wales (s.6(1)(a)) and must not be in religious premises (s.6(1)(b)). It must also be a place that is specified in the notice, or notices, of proposed civil partnership (s.6(1)(c)) and one which is open to any person wishing to attend the registration and agreed with the registration authority in whose area it is located before being specified in the notice of proposed civil partnership (s.6(3)). The sanction for failing to agree the place of registration before it is specified in the notice is that the notice itself is void (s.6(4)).
4.3
Special procedure In certain circumstances it may be desirable for a civil partnership registration to take place very quickly. The most likely circumstances are where one of the proposed civil partners is gravely ill and not expected to recover. It is for such circumstances that the Act lays down a special procedure. Essentially, this procedure enables a civil partnership registration to take place much more expeditiously than is usually the case by deploying the Registrar General’s licence. The licence is the equivalent of a civil partnership schedule, and can be issued only on the authority of the Registrar General, and it is the document that the couple signs to form the civil partnership. The standard requirements are relaxed from the outset so that instead of both the proposed civil partners giving notice of proposed civil partnership, it is sufficient if only one does so (s.21(1)). That is to allow for the fact that the other civil partner may be too unwell to give the usual notice. The single notice must comply with the usual requirements set out in section 8(3) to (6) inclusive, save that the requirement as to residence, in section 8(4)(b), is not applied (s.21(3)). The notice must be given to the registration authority for the area in which it is proposed that the registration take place, and at the same time the partner giving the notice must, under section 22, produce such evidence as the Registrar General may require in order to be satisfied that: (1) there is no lawful impediment to the formation of the civil partnership, (2) one of the proposed civil partners is seriously ill and not expected to recover, and he understands the nature and implications of signing a Registrar General’s licence. 25
4.3
Civil Partnership Act 2004 – a practical guide
A medical certificate is sufficient evidence of any or all of the matters mentioned in (2) above. As soon as the registration authority receives notice of the proposed civil partnership together with the evidence required to be produced under section 22 of the Act, section 23 requires the registration authority to inform the Registrar General and to comply with any directions he may give in order to verify the evidence given.
4.3.1
Objections Section 24 sets out the procedure for any person to object to the issue of the Registrar General’s licence. The objector must give notice to any registration authority or to the Registrar General himself. Any such notice must, in the usual way, state where the objector lives and the grounds of his/her objection, and he/she, or someone on his/her behalf, must sign it (s.24(2)). Any registration authority that receives a notice of objection must record in the register as soon as possible the fact that the notice has been given and the information it contains (s.24(3)). If the Registrar General receives any objection to the issue of his licence, he must not give his authority for the issue of the licence until he has investigated the objection and has decided whether it ought to obstruct the issue of the licence or the objection has been withdrawn (s.25(6)). His decision is final (s.25(7)).
4.3.2
Frivolous objections Echoing the usual provision about frivolous objections (see 3.2.9), a frivolous objector to the issue of the Registrar General’s licence exposes himself to liability for costs and damages (s.26).
4.3.3
Issue of Registrar General’s licence The issue of such a licence is tightly controlled. The registration authority may issue such a licence if, and only if, the Registrar General authorises them to do so (s.25(2)). He may not give such authority unless he is satisfied that one of the proposed civil partners is seriously ill and not expected to recover (s.25(3)(a)). However, once the Registrar General is satisfied on this issue he must give his authority unless he is also satisfied that there is a lawful impediment to the issue of his licence (s.25(3)(b)). Any licence issued under section 25 must state that it is issued on the authority of the Registrar General (s.25(4)).
4.3.4
Period within which registration may take place The proposed partners usually have a period of twelve months in which to register the civil partnership, and that period shortens to three months in certain other cases (as to which see 3.3.2 and 3.4.1). However, consonant with the exceptional circumstances of the Registrar General’s licence, the period within
26
Registration in England and Wales
4.4
which the proposed civil partners must register as civil partners shrinks to one month beginning with the day on which the notice of proposed civil partnership was given (s.27(1)). Failure to register within the prescribed period will render both the notice and the licence void, and no civil partnership registrar may officiate at the signing of the licence by the proposed partners (s.27(2)).
4.4
Offences The Act creates a number of offences that may be committed in connection with the procedure relating to the formation of a civil partnership. These are dealt with separately in chapter 12.
27
5 Registration outside the UK by Order in Council
5.1
Introduction The vast majority of civil partnerships encountered by practitioners to whom this work is chiefly addressed will be those formed or created by registration in England and Wales. However, the Act also permits couples not living in the UK to form a civil partnership outside the UK. Formation of a civil partnership outside the UK is either by registration of the civil partnership under an Order in Council or where the couple register an ‘overseas relationship’, which is treated as a civil partnership under Chapter 2 of Part 5 of the Act. We deal with registration of an overseas relationship in chapter 6. Subordinate legislation is made by a person or body other than the Sovereign in Parliament by virtue of powers conferred either by statute or by legislation which is itself made under statutory powers. When made by virtue of powers conferred by statute it is frequently referred to as delegated legislation. The great majority of powers conferred on the Crown are required to be made by Orders in Council which are orders expressed to be made by and with the advice of the Privy Council.
5.2
Registration at British consulates etc. Section 210 of the Act confers power to make subordinate legislation by Order in Council to enable two people to register as civil partners of each other in prescribed countries or territories outside the United Kingdom in the presence of a prescribed officer of Her Majesty’s Diplomatic Service. This will only be permitted, however, where the officer is satisfied that certain conditions are met. At the time of writing, the countries or territories where it will be possible to form a civil partnership in this way had not been identified nor had the grade, or status, of the diplomatic service officers who will be involved. Section 244(5) defines ‘prescribed’ as ‘prescribed by Order in Council’ and so this information will be set out in the relevant Order in Council. Under the Foreign Marriage Act 1892 it is possible for UK nationals to marry in accordance with UK law at a diplomatic post overseas in certain circumstances. The power conferred by
28
Registration outside the UK
5.3
section 210 will be used to enable civil partnerships to be formed at diplomatic posts overseas in a similar way.
5.2.1
The conditions Section 210(2) sets out four conditions that must be met to the satisfaction of the relevant diplomatic service officer. Firstly, at least one of the proposed civil partners must be a UK national. Secondly, the civil partners must have been eligible to register as civil partners of each other in the relevant part of the UK (as determined according to the provisions of the Order in Council) so that the conditions of eligibility already considered in chapter 2 will have to be satisfied. The third condition that must be met is that the authorities of the country or territory do not object to the registration, and, finally, the facilities for the proposed civil partners to enter into an overseas relationship under the law of that country or territory (see chapter 6) are insufficient. It should be noted, however, that an officer is not required to allow two people to register as civil partners of each other if in his opinion to do so would be inconsistent with international law or with the comity of nations (s.210(3)) which means the courtesy and friendship between nations that is marked by a recognition of each other’s laws. The Order in Council may include provision for an appeal against any such refusal.
5.2.2
United Kingdom national Section 245 of the Act defines a ‘United Kingdom national’ as a person who is: (1) a British citizen, a British overseas territories citizen, a British Overseas citizen or a British National (Overseas), (2) a British subject under the British Nationality Act 1981, or (3) a British protected person within the meaning of that Act.
5.2.3
Effect It is envisaged that an Order in Council will provide that two people who register as civil partners of each other pursuant to section 210 will be treated for the purpose of bringing proceedings for an order for dissolution, separation or nullity, for the purpose of proceedings for a presumption of death order, and, in relation to applications for declarations as to validity, as if they had registered their civil partnership in the part of the United Kingdom relevant to them. There is a similar provision for those who register under section 211.
5.3
Registration by armed forces personnel Under section 22 of the Foreign Marriage Act 1892 members of the armed forces, and certain civilians accompanying them, can be married outside the UK by a forces chaplain or by an officer authorised by the commanding officer. 29
5.3
Civil Partnership Act 2004 – a practical guide
Section 211 of the Act enables similar provision to be made, again by Order in Council, for people who wish to enter a civil partnership by enabling two people to register as civil partners of each other in prescribed countries or territories outside the UK in the presence of an officer appointed by virtue of the Registration of Births, Deaths and Marriages (Special Provisions) Act 1957. This will only be permitted, however, provided that the officer is satisfied that certain conditions are met.
5.3.1
The conditions Section 211(2) sets out the conditions, all of which must be met: (1) At least one of the proposed civil partners – (a) is a member of a part of Her Majesty’s forces serving in the country or territory (b) is employed in the country or territory in such other capacity as may be prescribed, or (c) is a child of a person falling within (a) or (b) and has his home with that person in that country or territory, (2) The proposed civil partners would have been eligible to register as civil partners of each other in such part of the UK as is determined in accordance with the Order, and (3) Such other requirements as may be prescribed are complied with.
5.3.2
‘Prescribed countries or territories’ At the time of writing, the countries or territories where it will be possible to form a civil partnership in this way had not been identified.
5.3.3
Her Majesty’s forces Section 245(2) of the Act provides that this expression has the same meaning as in the Army Act 1955.
5.3.4
‘Child of a person’ In determining whether for the purposes of the section one person is the child of another, a person who is or was treated by another as a child of the family in relation to – (a) a marriage to which the other is or was a party, or (b) a civil partnership in which the other is or was a civil partner, is to be regarded as the other’s child (s.211(3)).
30
Registration outside the UK
5.3.5
5.3
Ships are included By section 211(5) any reference to a country or territory outside the UK, to forces serving in such country or territory and to persons employed in such a country or territory includes references to ships which are for the time being in the waters of a country or territory outside the UK, to forces serving on any such ship and to persons employed on any such ship.
31
6 Overseas relationships treated as civil partnerships
6.1
Introduction We deal in this part of the book with the circumstances where two people register an ‘overseas relationship’ (as defined in the Act) which is entitled to be treated as a civil partnership.
6.2
Meaning of ‘overseas relationship’ Section 212 of the Act defines an ‘overseas relationship’ as a relationship which is either a specified relationship or a relationship which meets what are described under the Act as the ‘general conditions’. In addition, in order to qualify as an overseas relationship for the purposes of the Act, it must have been registered with a responsible authority in a country or territory outside the UK by two people who are of the same sex under the relevant law, and (according to UK law) are not already in a civil relationship or lawfully married. The same-sex qualification is also a requirement of UK law – see section 216.
6.2.1
‘Relevant law’ Section 212(2) defines this as the law of the country or territory where the relationship is registered, including its rules of private international law.
6.2.2
‘Specified relationship’ To ascertain whether the couple is in a specified relationship it is necessary to refer to Schedule 20 to the Act. This Schedule is more readily understood when it is appreciated that the United Kingdom has been relatively tardy in giving same-sex relations the legal status conferred by the Act when compared to other (mostly) European jurisdictions and at least one state of America. Accordingly, the Schedule lists various types of relationship which exist in other countries such as ‘registered partnership’ in Norway, ‘confirmed cohabitation’ in Iceland,
32
Overseas relationships
6.3
‘civil union’ in Vermont, USA, and so forth. In Belgium and the Netherlands marriage itself is available to same-sex partners. It is important to remember that for a specified relationship to qualify as an overseas relationship, and be treated as a civil partnership in the UK, it must meet the other requirements laid down in section 212, namely that the partners must be of the same sex and not already in a civil partnership or lawfully married. Section 213(2) empowers the Secretary of State to amend by order Schedule 20. The amendment can take various forms, from adding a relationship to the list of specified relationships, to amending the description of one of the listed relationships or omitting a relationship from the list.
6.2.3
‘The general conditions’ Even if a relationship is not a ‘specified relationship’ as listed in Schedule 20, it will still be an ‘overseas relationship’ within the meaning of section 212 if it meets the ‘general conditions’ specified in section 214. Unsurprisingly, key to the general conditions is the exclusivity of the relationship and its duration. The first requirement of the relationship is that it must not be one that may be entered into if either of the parties is already a party to a relationship of that kind or is already married (s.214(a)). The second requirement is that the relationship must be of indeterminate duration, thus excluding arrangements where the parties have agreed to live together for a fixed period of time (s.214(b)). Lastly, the relationship has to be such that the effect of entering into it must be that the couple is treated (either generally or for specified purposes) either as a couple under the relevant law (as already defined) or as married (s.214(c)). A relationship registered under a local or municipal scheme within a particular city or town, which is entirely limited or parochial in its impact, having no legal effect or status under the law of the country or territory as a whole, would be insufficient to meet this condition.
6.3
Overseas relationships treated as civil partnerships: the general rule Section 215 of the Act sets out the general rule in relation to an ‘overseas relationship’, namely that two people are to be treated (in the UK) as having formed a civil partnership as a result of having registered (outside the UK) an overseas relationship, provided that under the relevant law (as defined in s.212(2)) they had the capacity to enter into the relationship and they met all the requirements necessary to ensure the formal validity of the relationship. Subject to satisfying these requirements, the civil partnership is treated as having been formed at the time when the overseas relationship is registered (under the relevant law) as having been entered into (s.215(2)). However, if the overseas relationship was registered before this section comes into force, section 215(3) provides that the civil partnership is treated as having been formed only at the 33
6.6
Civil Partnership Act 2004 – a practical guide
date when this section comes into force. This is, of course, subject to any prior dissolution or annulment of the overseas relationship.
6.4
Prior overseas dissolution or annulment of overseas relationship Section 215(4) and (5) deal with the situation where an overseas relationship was dissolved or annulled outside the UK before this section comes into force. If the dissolution or annulment meets the requirements for recognition under Chapter 3 of Part 5 of the Act, the parties will be treated for certain purposes only as former civil partners who have dissolved or annulled their relationship, namely for the purposes of Schedules 7, 11 and 17 of the Act, all of which deal with financial relief in different parts of the UK after dissolution or annulment obtained outside the UK, and for the purpose of any other provisions specified by an order made under section 259. Save for those specific purposes the parties are not to be treated as having been civil partners for any other purposes (s.215(5)).
6.5
The same-sex requirement An important thread running through this part of the Act dealing with overseas relationships is an emphasis on the fact that the parties to such a relationship must be of the same sex, if the relationship is to be treated as a civil partnership for the purposes of UK law. Section 216 puts this requirement beyond doubt as it provides in terms that two people are not to be treated as having formed a civil partnership as a result of having registered an overseas relationship if, at the critical time, they were not of the same gender under UK law. The concept of the critical time is introduced to take account of when the overseas relationship was entered into in relation to the commencement of section 215 of the Act. Ordinarily the time when the parties are to be treated as having formed the civil partnership as a consequence of registering their overseas relationship would be when their overseas relationship is registered as having been entered into, and that time is the critical time for the purposes of section 216(1). However, where an overseas relationship is registered (under the relevant law) as having been entered into before section 215 comes into force, the critical time (for the purposes of s.216(1)) is the time when section 215 comes into force.
6.6
Exception to the same-sex requirement This is dealt with more fully in chapter 9 which deals with the interrelation of the Civil Partnership Act and the Gender Recognition Act 2004. However, in essence the provisions contained in section 216(2), (3) and (4) are analogous to provisions contained in the Gender Recognition Act in relation to overseas marriages.
34
Overseas relationships
6.7
6.9
Persons domiciled in a part of the United Kingdom The intent behind section 217 of the Act is to ensure that, where an overseas relationship is registered by a person who is domiciled in England and Wales, Scotland or Northern Ireland, it cannot be treated as a civil partnership unless the couple would have been eligible to register as civil partners of each other in that part of the UK. By the operation of section 3(1) of the Act, two people are not eligible to register as civil partners of each other if – (a) (b) (c) (d)
they are not of the same sex, either of them is already a civil partner or lawfully married, either of them is under sixteen, they are within prohibited degrees of relationship.
Accordingly, section 217(2) specifically provides that the overseas relationship will not be treated as a civil partnership if, at the time of registration, either party was under sixteen at the time or they are within the prohibited degrees of relationship applicable in the relevant part of the UK.
6.8
The public policy exception Section 218 of the Act provides that two people are not to be treated as having formed a civil partnership as a result of their overseas relationship if it would be manifestly contrary to public policy to recognise the capacity of either of them to enter into the relationship under the relevant law.
6.9
Dissolution etc. The jurisdiction of the court in the UK to make orders in relation to the termination of civil partnerships formed by registration outside the UK by Order in Council and in the case of overseas relationships treated as civil partnerships is dealt with in chapter 10.
35
7 Financial and property implications of civil partnership
7.1
Introduction The Act includes many small, but significant, legislative changes, designed to ensure that civil partners enjoy broadly the same rights as married persons. The areas covered are wide ranging – from wills and intestacy, pensions and tax credits to insurance policies, via secure tenancies and fatal accident compensation. A new solution to a long-standing problem for those partners who are home sharers is contained in section 65, which provides that if a civil partner contributes to the improvement of property in which one or both partners are beneficially interested, the contributing partner will acquire a share, or an enhanced share, in the property. The section reflects the legal position which already applies to married and engaged couples by virtue of section 37 of the Matrimonial Proceedings and Property Act 1970. Amendments to tax legislation so that civil partners are taxed in the same way as spouses (of particular importance in the case of inheritance tax, where same-sex partners have not hitherto benefited from the spouse exemption on assets which exceed the nil rate band) are not specifically included in the Civil Partnership Act but will form part of the next Finance Bill.
7.2
Property: contributions to improvement The state of the law as it affects unmarried cohabitants who carry out improvements to property has been unsatisfactory for many years. With no statutory provision akin to section 37 of the Matrimonial Proceedings and Property Act 1970, they have been left to struggle with the unyielding common law principle that in the absence of an agreement (either an express agreement or a common intention which is inferred by the court from the conduct of the parties) or any argument based on estoppel, the mere fact that partner A spends money or physically labours on partner B’s property does not entitle partner A to an interest in the property (see, for example, Pettitt v. Pettitt [1970] AC 777 or, more recently, Thomas v. Fuller Brown [1988] 1 FLR 237).
36
Financial and property implications
7.3
Section 65 of the Act, however, provides that if a civil partner contributes towards the improvement of property in which either or both partners has or have a beneficial interest, the contributing partner will be treated as having acquired a share, or an enlarged share, in the beneficial interest. The section applies to both real and personal property. The contribution can be in money or money’s worth (s.65(1)(a)), but it must be of a ‘substantial’ nature (s.65(1)(b)). The extent of the share (or enlarged share) will be as agreed between the partners. If there is no agreement, it will be such share as the court considers in all the circumstances just (s.65(2)). Section 65(2) takes effect subject to any agreement between the parties to the contrary, whether that agreement is express or implied. The body of decided cases relating to the efforts of one spouse to establish a beneficial interest on the basis of improvements carried out to the matrimonial home should assist in the interpretation of the phrase ‘substantial’. In Pettitt, Lord Reid did not consider that ‘do it yourself’ jobs were sufficient, nor redecoration, which he described as ‘ephemeral’. See also Re Nicholson, deceased [1974] 1 WLR 476. Examples of improvements to real property which are likely to acquire a share or enhanced share for the contributing partner would be undertaking or paying for a loft conversion, an extension, or the replacement of the roof. A contribution of a substantial nature to the improvement of personal property might be represented by one partner’s spending significant sums on the renovation of a classic car owned by the other partner or carrying out lengthy restoration work on a jointly owned valuable painting. For useful guidance about how the court should approach the task of valuing the share or enlarged share acquired by the contribution, see Passee v. Passee [1988] 1 FLR 263 and Re Pavlou, a bankrupt [1993] 3 All ER 955.
7.3
Property: dispute about title or possession If there is a dispute between civil partners about the title to or possession of property, either partner may apply to a prescribed county court or the High Court under section 66 and the court is empowered to make ‘such order as it thinks fit’ regarding the property, including an order for its sale. A partner may wish to apply, for example, for a declaration as to the respective beneficial interests of each partner, or for an order conferring the right on one partner to occupy the property to the exclusion of the other partner, with or without the payment of a compensating occupation rent. If partner B has, or has had, in his control or possession money or property in which partner A had a beneficial interest, section 67 allows A to apply under section 66 even if partner B no longer has the money or property, or A does not know whether B still has it. This provision is similar to that available to spouses under section 17 of the Married Women’s Property Act 1882, as extended by section 7 of the Matrimonial Causes (Property and Maintenance) Act 1958. If A can satisfy the court both that B has had the relevant money or property in his 37
7.4
Civil Partnership Act 2004 – a practical guide
or her possession or under his or her control and that B has not made to A such payment or disposition as would have been appropriate, the court is empowered to make section 66 orders. Those include orders for B to pay to A such sum in respect of money, or the value of the property, as the court considers appropriate (s.67(4) and (5)).
7.3.1
Time limit Section 66 applications must be made within three years of the dissolution or annulment of a partnership (s.68).
7.4
Housing and tenancies Introduced by section 81 of the Act, Schedule 8 contains the necessary legislative amendments to achieve the same treatment for civil partners as that given to spouses in respect of certain tenancies, leases and licences to occupy. In addition, wherever a relevant statute refers to two persons living together as husband and wife, it now refers also to two persons living together as civil partners, reflecting Ghaidan v. Mendoza [2004] UKHL 30. In particular, the amendments provide security of tenure for a civil partner who would otherwise have faced eviction from his or her home following the death of a partner who had been the tenant. Surviving partners will now be entitled to succeed to tenancies under the Rent Act 1977; to secure tenancies under the Housing Act 1985; to relevant licences or tenancies under the Rent (Agricultural) Act 1976; and to assured periodic tenancies and assured agricultural occupancy under the Housing Act 1988. They are also eligible to apply for new tenancies under the Agricultural Holdings Act 1986 and to protection from eviction under residential contracts granted pursuant to the Caravan Sites Act 1968. Under both the amended Rent Act 1977 and the amended Housing Act 1988, a person who was living with the original tenant as if they were civil partners will be treated as the civil partner of the original tenant for the purpose of succession, so that he or she will become a statutory tenant. A partner will also now benefit from the redefined category of members of a family who are able to succeed to a tenancy under the Leasehold Reform Act 1967. Where grounds for possession of a dwelling-house include the fact that the property is required as a residence for a landlord or family member (for example, under Schedule 3 to the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954, the Rent Act 1977 or the Local Government and Housing Act 1989), a partner is now included within the list of family members. A similarly extended definition provides that civil partners are family members with whom secure tenants can exercise their ‘right to buy’ under the Housing Act 1985. Leases falling within section 149(6) of the Law of Property Act 1925 now include leases determinable on the formation of a civil partnership between the lessee and another person and so taking effect as a lease for 90 years
38
Financial and property implications
7.5
determinable by notice after the formation of the civil partnership (paragraph 1 of Schedule 8). The Schedule also includes the legislative amendments necessary to give effect to transfers of those tenancies which are otherwise non-assignable (for example, a protected shorthold tenancy under the Housing Act 1980), provided the transfer is directed pursuant to a property adjustment order made in connection with civil partnership proceedings, or after an overseas dissolution of a civil partnership. It is impossible in a book of this nature to mention every statutory amendment relating to housing and tenancies. Schedule 8 is comprehensive and should be consulted for any specific question.
7.5
Wills and administration of estates A marriage and any subsequent divorce both impact significantly upon wills. By virtue of the Wills Act 1837, except in certain cases, a will is revoked by the testator’s marriage. If a marriage is dissolved or annulled, property bequeathed to a former spouse takes effect as if the former spouse had died on the date on which the marriage was formally ended. The same applies in the case of an appointment of a former spouse as executor or trustee. Section 71 of the Civil Partnership Act introduces amendments to the law relating to wills and the administration of estates, set out in detail in Schedule 4 to the Act. As a general rule, a will is revoked by the testator’s formation of a civil partnership (new s.18B of the Wills Act, inserted by Part 1 of Schedule 4 to the Act). However, section 18(B)(2) to (6) comes to the rescue if it appears from a will that at the time it was made, the testator was expecting to form a civil partnership with a particular person and he or she intended the will should not be revoked by the formation of the partnership (s.18(B)(3)). Similar provisions apply to a disposition in the will. Any other disposition takes effect unless it appears from the will that the testator intended the disposition to be revoked by the formation of the partnership (s.18(B)(6)). A disposition under a power of appointment will take effect despite a subsequent partnership unless the property would in default of appointment pass to the testator’s personal representatives (s.18(B)(2)).
7.5.1
Dissolution of partnership If a partnership is dissolved or annulled, new section 18(C) of the Wills Act applies. It provides that, except where a contrary intention appears in a will, any provisions appointing the former partner as an executor or trustee or conferring on the former partner a power of appointment, take effect as if the former partner had died on the date the partnership was dissolved. Property devised or bequeathed to the former partner passes as if the former partner had died on the dissolution date, but, again, this is subject to any contrary intention appearing in the will. 39
7.6
Civil Partnership Act 2004 – a practical guide
7.5.2
Intestacy So far as intestacy is concerned, a partner is, by virtue of amendments to the Administration of Estates Act 1925 brought about by Part 2 of Schedule 4, put on the same footing as a spouse and will therefore benefit from the real and personal estate of the deceased partner in accordance with sections 46 and 47 of the Administration of Estates Act. The surviving partner will currently be entitled, if there are children, to the first £125,000 of the deceased’s estate plus personal chattels and a life interest (income only) in half the remainder. The remaining half will be divided equally between any children when they reach eighteen. If either partner dies intestate while a separation order is in force and the separation is continuing, section 57 of the Act provides that the property devolves as if the other civil partner had then been dead.
7.6
Inheritance Act The Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975 allows an applicant to apply to a court for financial provision from an estate on the ground that the way in which the deceased left his or her estate by will, or the operation of the intestacy rules (or both), did not make ‘reasonable financial provision’ for the applicant. Amendments made to the Inheritance Act by Schedule 4 enlarge the class of potential applicants. A civil partner of the deceased can apply for financial provision as can a former civil partner of the deceased, provided he or she has not formed a subsequent partnership. So, too, may any person who, in the case of any partnership to which the deceased was at any time a party, was treated as a child of the family in relation to that partnership (s.1(a) and (b) of the amended 1975 Act). Section 1(1B) of the amended Inheritance Act also allows an application to be made by a person who throughout the whole two years immediately before the death of the deceased, was living in the same household as the deceased and as his or her civil partner. A civil partner of the deceased is entitled to reasonable financial provision on the more generous basis under section 1(2)(a) of the Inheritance Act, that is such financial provision as it would be reasonable in all the circumstances of the case for a civil partner to receive, whether or not it is required for his or her maintenance. For all other applicants, reasonable financial provision is defined as such financial provision as it would be reasonable for the applicant to receive for his or her maintenance. The factors to be taken into account by the court are set out in section 3 of the 1975 Act. They include the current and future financial resources and financial needs of any applicant or beneficiary; any obligations and responsibilities which the deceased had towards any applicant or beneficiary; the size and nature of the net estate; any physical or mental disability of any applicant or beneficiary; and anything else (including the conduct of the applicant) the court considers
40
Financial and property implications
7.7
relevant. Where an applicant is a partner or former partner, or the parties had been living together in the same household as civil partners, the court will also take into account the age of the applicant, the duration of the partnership or the period of cohabitation and the contribution made by the applicant to the welfare of the deceased’s family (including any contribution by looking after the home or caring for the family). In assessing what the provision should be for a civil partner, section 3(2) of the Inheritance Act requires the court to take into account the provision the applicant might reasonably have expected to receive had the partnership been ended by a dissolution order rather than by death (see chapter 11). The court can make various orders to be met from the deceased’s net estate under section 2 of the Inheritance Act, including periodical payments and lump sum orders and orders for the transfer, settlement or acquisition of property. The court can also vary any settlement made during a partnership formed by the deceased or in anticipation of the deceased’s forming a partnership. There are specific provisions inserted to deal with the situation where a dissolution, nullity or separation order or presumption of death order has been made in respect of a civil partnership and one partner dies within twelve months of the date on which the order was made but no application for financial provision has been made or it has been made, but not determined. Section 14A of the Inheritance Act gives the court power, if it thinks just to do so, to treat the surviving partner as if the order terminating the partnership had never been made. New section 15ZA of the Inheritance Act, inserted by paragraph 21 of Schedule 4, allows the court, on making a dissolution, nullity, separation or presumption of death order or at any time thereafter, to direct, if it considers just to do so, that a civil partner should not be entitled, on the death of the other, to apply for an order under section 2 of the Act and there is a similar power for such an order to be made in proceedings for financial relief following an overseas dissolution (s.15B of the Inheritance Act). Finally, section 18A of the Inheritance Act permits the court to direct that applications made under paragraph 60 (where the partner paying secured periodical payments has died and the surviving partner applies to vary the order) and paragraph 73 (where the partner paying payments under a written agreement has died but the payments are to continue after his or her death and an application is made to alter the agreement) of Schedule 5 to the Civil Partnership Act shall be deemed to have been accompanied by an application for an order under section 2.
7.7
Life policies Under the Married Women’s Property Act 1882, money paid under a life policy does not form part of the insured’s estate in the case of a married person’s policy for the benefit of his spouse or children. Section 70 of the Civil Partnership Act applies section 11 of the 1882 Act to assurance policies effected by a civil 41
7.10
Civil Partnership Act 2004 – a practical guide
partner on his or her own life and expressed to be for the benefit of his or her partner, or of his or her children, or of his or her partner and children, or any of them. It is worth noting here that a life policy taken out by the husband after marriage to benefit the wife has been held to be a post-nuptial settlement and thus susceptible to variation by the court: Bown v. Bown and Weston [1949] P 91.
7.8
Torts Section 69 of the Act provides that while a civil partnership subsists, if an action in tort is brought by one partner against the other, the court may stay the proceedings if it is satisfied either that no ‘substantial benefit’ would accrue to either partner or that the questions arising could more conveniently be disposed of under section 66 (see above). This replicates the provisions relating to actions in tort between husband and wife contained in the Law Reform (Husband and Wife) Act 1962. An example of an action brought by one partner against the other in tort but more appropriately dealt with under section 66 is a claim brought in trespass arising from one partner’s eviction of the other from their jointly owned home.
7.9
Fatal accident compensation The meaning of ‘dependant’ under the Fatal Accidents Act 1976 is extended by section 83 of the Act so that a civil partner or former civil partner of the deceased may claim damages where the death was caused by the wrongful act, neglect or default of another person. So, too, may any person (not being a child of the deceased) who, in the case of any civil partnership in which the deceased was at any time a party, was treated by the deceased as a child of the family in relation to that partnership. A civil partner may also claim bereavement damages under section 1A(2) of the Fatal Accidents Act.
7.10
Social security benefits Schedule 24 to the Act (introduced by s.254) contains amendments dealing with social security, child support and tax credits. Substantial subordinate legislation will be required to implement all the changes. Essentially, the word ‘couple’ is re-defined in all the major relevant Acts to include two people of the same sex who are civil partners of each other and are members of the same household, or two people of the same sex who are not civil partners of each other but are living together as if they were civil partners. For the purpose of the definition, two people of the same sex are to be regarded as living together as if they were civil partners if, but only if, they would be regarded as living together as husband and wife were they instead two people of the opposite sex (see, for example, amended paragraph 10C of Schedule 1 to Child Support Act 1991,
42
Financial and property implications
7.11
amended s.137(1) of the Social Security Contributions and Benefits Act 1972 and amended s.3(5A) of the Tax Credits Act 2002). The Explanatory Notes to the Act state that the definition is to ensure that the body of case law applicable to those living together as husband and wife will also apply to those living together as civil partners (page 105). So, the factors to be taken into account in determining whether persons are living together as civil partners are likely to be: membership of the same household; stability; financial support; sexual relationship; children and public acknowledgement (see, for example, Kaur v. Secretary of State for Social Services (1981) 3 FLR 237). A detailed examination of social security provisions is outside the scope of this book but, in summary, for the purpose of child support payable under the Child Support Act 1991, a parent living with a same-sex partner as if they were civil partners will be treated in the same way as a parent living with an opposite sex partner. Under the Social Security Contributions and Benefits Act 1972, surviving partners are now eligible for bereavement payments, bereavement allowance and widowed parent’s allowance on the basis of the National Insurance contributions of their deceased partner. The definition of ‘relative’ is amended, for the purpose of determining whether a carer is entitled to claim carer’s allowance, to include a person related by civil partnership. Only one partner can claim income support, housing and council tax benefits, but the needs and resources of the other partner will be taken into account. Conditions under which mortgage interest payments are made within income support and jobseeker’s allowance are extended under the Social Security Administration Act 1992 and partners may be required to make a claim for jobseeker’s allowance as a ‘joint-claim couple’ (Jobseekers Act 1995). A working tax credit award may include an element for being a member of a couple or for being a lone parent who is not a member of a couple. In certain circumstances, one member of a couple will be treated as acting on behalf of the other when making a joint claim (Tax Credits Act 2002). At the date of writing, one statutory instrument has so far been made, namely the Tax Credits Notification of Changes of Circumstances (Civil Partnership) (Transitional Provisions) Order 2005, which modifies section 6 of the Tax Credits Act 2002 by providing that a change of circumstances shall be treated as having occurred where by virtue of the coming into force of Part 14 of Schedule 24 to the Act, two people of the same sex are treated as a couple.
7.11
Pensions Paragraphs 23 to 33 and 51 of Schedule 24 to the Act amend the Social Security Contributions and Benefits Act 1972 so that basic state pension rights are available to civil partners. A civil partner will qualify for a pension when the other partner who was born on or after 6 April 1950 reaches state pension age. (So, female civil partners will qualify from 2010 but male civil partners will not qualify until 2015, because of the difference in state pension ages.) 43
7.12
Civil Partnership Act 2004 – a practical guide
A civil partner is brought into line with a widow, who currently qualifies after reaching state pension age for a ‘Category B pension’, i.e. a pension calculated as if her husband was entitled to it when he died. The pension consists of the basic pension plus additional pension (made up of a percentage of SERPS and of any state second pension). Partners will only be eligible if both partners are over state pension age when the first one dies, but as from 6 April 2010, partners who reach pensionable age will qualify regardless of the age at which their partner dies. Where a civil partnership has ended, the contributions of the former partner may be substituted for the period of the civil partnership to allow a person to qualify for the basic state pension (amended s.48 of the Social Security Contributions and Benefits Act 1992).
7.12
The armed forces Schedule 26 of the Act contains amendments of a number of statutes relating to the armed forces and associated charities such as the Greenwich Hospital. They provide for surviving civil partners to be treated in the same way as widows for the purpose of rights to certain pensions or similar gratuities; financial compensation for service by members of the reserve and auxiliary forces; and the disposal of the deceased’s estate. The provisions of the Naval Forces (Enforcement of Maintenance Liabilities) Act 1947 and the Army Act 1955, whereby deductions can be made from the pay of members of the armed forces to meet maintenance orders in favour of a wife or children, are extended to include orders made in favour of a civil partner.
44
8 Children
8.1
Introduction While not particularly complex or lengthy, the legislative changes in respect of the children of civil partners are critical to any statutory scheme which is intended to give the fullest possible recognition to every aspect of a civil partnership. Most importantly, the Act provides for a civil partner to acquire parental responsibility for a child, either by agreement or by court order. It also extends the statutory definition of ‘child of the family’ to include the children of a civil partnership. Civil partners are added to the class of persons who are entitled as of right to apply under the Children Act for residence and contact orders, and, as part of the significant changes brought about by the Adoption and Children Act 2002, civil partners may apply jointly for an adoption order.
8.2
Parental responsibility Parental responsibility is defined by section 3(1) of the Children Act 1989 as ‘all the rights, duties, powers, responsibilities and authority which by law a parent of a child has in relation to the child and his property’. Although there is no more detailed definition contained in the Children Act or preceding statutes, a substantial body of case law demonstrates that parental responsibility embraces many and varied aspects of a child’s life, ranging from the power to appoint a guardian for the child by will, consenting to, or refusing, medical treatment for the child or choosing the child’s school to determining the child’s religious upbringing and naming the child. See, for example, Gillick v. West Norfolk and Wisbech Area Health Authority [1986] AC 112. While all mothers, and fathers who were married to the mother when the child was born, automatically have parental responsibility, unmarried fathers can only acquire it by executing a parental responsibility agreement or by registering as the father on the child’s birth certificate or by obtaining a parental responsibility order from the court. Before the Act, a same-sex partner was unable to share parental responsibility for his or her partner’s child without 45
8.3
Civil Partnership Act 2004 – a practical guide
obtaining a residence order, which by virtue of section 12(2) of the Children Act carries with it parental responsibility while the residence order remains in force. A civil partner is now able to acquire parental responsibility for a child in three ways. Firstly, he or she can enter into a parental responsibility agreement with the parents who have parental responsibility for the child. Secondly, he or she may acquire parental responsibility by an order of the court (s.4A(1) of the Children Act, inserted by s.112 of the Adoption and Children Act 2002 and extended by s.75(2) of the Civil Partnership Act). Thirdly, as before, he or she will automatically acquire parental responsibility in the event that a residence order is made in his or her favour. A parental responsibility agreement or order can only be brought to an end by an order of the court (s.4A(3) of the Children Act). When the court considers an application for a parental responsibility order, under the Children Act the child’s welfare will always be the court’s paramount consideration (s.1(1)) and the court will also apply the general principle that delay in determining a question with respect to the upbringing of a child is likely to prejudice the welfare of the child (s.1(2) of the Children Act). Under section 1(5), the court will not make an order unless it considers that doing so would be better for the child than making no order at all. The ‘welfare checklist’ set out in section 1(3) of the Children Act does not apply to an application for parental responsibility (s.1(4)). In the case of applications by unmarried fathers for a parental responsibility order, the court has taken into account, in particular, the degree of commitment shown by the father to the child, the degree of attachment between him and the child and his reasons for applying for the order (see, for example, Re G (A Minor) (Parental Responsibility Order) [1994] 1 FLR 504). There seems no good reason for the court’s departing from that approach when dealing with an application by a civil partner.
8.3
‘Child of the family’ ‘Child of the family’ in relation to two people who are civil partners means not only a child of both of them but any other child who has been treated by both of them as a child of their family (s.105(1) of the Children Act, substituted by s.75(3) of the Civil Partnership Act). Children placed with partners as foster carers are excluded from the definition. Cases decided under section 41 of the Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 will assist the court in determining whether a child has been treated as a child of the family. The test is two-fold: there must be a ‘family’ and there must be ‘treatment’ as a child of that family: Re A (A Minor) (1980) 10 Fam Law 184, CA and M v. M (child of the family) (1980) 2 FLR 39, CA. There are two situations in which the existence of a child of the family will be significant. Firstly, the court must assure itself that in the aftermath of the breakdown of a civil partnership, the parties have not lost sight of the needs of
46
Children
8.5
any child of the family under sixteen. Section 63(1) of the Civil Partnership Act requires the court to consider whether it should exercise any of its Children Act powers in the light of arrangements which either have been, or are proposed to be, made for the upbringing and welfare of any children of the family. In line with the court’s power to refuse to make absolute a decree nisi of divorce in similar circumstances, under section 63(2) the court may direct that a dissolution or nullity order is not to be made final (or, in the case of a separation order, is not to be made at all) if it appears that the court is required, or is likely to be required, to exercise its Children Act powers, but cannot do so without giving further consideration to the case. There must be exceptional circumstances making it desirable, in the interests of the child, that the court should give such a direction. Section 63 also applies to a child who has reached sixteen, if the court directs the section should apply to him or her. Such a direction might be made, for example, where a child has significant special needs and the partners have been unable to agree on important decisions in the child’s life. The second relevant area is that of financial relief. Periodical payments orders, lump sum and property adjustment orders and sale of property orders may all be made against a civil partner to or for the benefit of a child of the family (see Part 1 of Schedule 5 to the Civil Partnership Act). In deciding whether to exercise its powers to award financial relief orders, the court’s first consideration is the welfare while a minor of any child of the family who has not yet attained the age of eighteen (Schedule 5, paragraph 20).
8.4
Extended definition of ‘relative’ The Children Act definition of ‘relative’ (s.105(1)) in relation to a child is amended so that it now means a grandparent, brother, sister, uncle or aunt (whether of the full blood or half blood or by marriage or civil partnership) or a step-parent. The status of relative is relevant in a number of ways under the Children Act, such as the duty imposed by section 23 on a local authority which is looking after a child to make arrangements to enable him or her to live with a parent, a person who has parental responsibility or a relative, friend or other person connected with the child (subject to welfare considerations and practicality).
8.5
Guardianship The ability of a parent to appoint, pursuant to section 5(3) of the Children Act, a guardian for a child in the event of the parent’s death is a valuable part of parental responsibility. If, however, a civil partnership is dissolved or annulled, section 6(3A) of the Children Act (inserted by s.76 of the Civil Partnership Act) provides that the appointment of a guardian is revoked unless the appointment shows the contrary intention. The same applies to the guardian’s own appointment, pursuant to section 5(4), of another individual to take his place should he or she die. 47
8.8
Civil Partnership Act 2004 – a practical guide
8.6
Residence and contact orders Section 10(5) of the Children Act defines the class of persons entitled as of right to apply to the court for residence or contact orders. It includes any party to a marriage in relation to whom the child is a child of the family, any person with whom the child has lived for a period of at least three years and a person who has the consent of all persons in whose favour a residence order has been made or of all those with parental responsibility for the child. The class is extended by section 77 of the Act to include any civil partner in a partnership (whether or not the partnership is subsisting) in relation to whom the child is a child of the family.
8.7
Adoption Once the Adoption and Children Act 2002 is fully in force, the meaning of ‘a couple’ (see s.144(4) of the Adoption and Children Act) is extended by section 79(12) of the Civil Partnership Act to include two people who are civil partners of each other, thus enabling partners to apply jointly for an adoption order. As in the case of married couples, an adoption order will only be made on the application of one civil partner if the court is satisfied that the other partner cannot be found, or the partners have separated and the separation is likely to be permanent, or the other partner is, by reason of ill-health, incapable of making an application (s.53(1A) of the Adoption and Children Act, inserted by s.79(5)).
8.8
Financial provision for children Schedule 1 to the Children Act 1989 enables the courts to make financial provision for children, subject to the restraints imposed by the Child Support Act 1991. Section 78 of the Civil Partnership Act amends the definition of ‘parent’ contained in paragraph 16(2) of Schedule 1 by extending it to include any partner in a civil relationship in relation to whom the child concerned is a child of the family. It matters not whether the relationship subsists.
48
9 Relationship between the Civil Partnership Act and the Gender Recognition Act
9.1
Introduction By section 1 of the Civil Partnership Act, a civil partnership is, in essence, a legal relationship between two people of the same sex, and that being so, such a partnership cannot take place unless each of the proposed civil partners is of the same sex (see s.3(1)(a)). The issue of the gender of the prospective partners will for the most part be straightforward. However, the Act recognises the modifications in the law relating to gender change as set out in the Gender Recognition Act 2004, and in different parts of the Civil Partnership Act provision is made to accommodate these changes. Rather than deal in each of the separate chapters with the modifications brought about by the Gender Recognition Act 2004 to, for example, the procedure to be adopted for registration where one of the prospective civil partners is a former spouse who has changed gender, or the effect of a change of gender on nullity proceedings, it was thought more sensible to devote a separate chapter to the interrelation between the two Acts. The practical advantage is that once the practitioner becomes aware that there may be an issue in relation to gender this discrete chapter will be a convenient starting point.
9.2
Before the Gender Recognition Act 2004 At common law, the criteria which governed whether a person was likely to be male or female were purely biological, and were first laid down in 1970 by Ormrod J in Corbett v. Corbett (otherwise Ashley) [1971] P 83, [1970] 2 All ER 33. Essentially, the three biological criteria were chromosomal, gonadal and genital. Where all three were present together this was regarded as determinative of the gender irrespective of any psychological or social factors, and in particular what, if any, steps had been taken by any individual to have their gender reassigned. The Divisional Court confirmed Corbett in R v. Registrar General, ex p. P and G [1996] 2 FCR 588, and the Court of Appeal did so in R v. Tan 49
9.3
Civil Partnership Act 2004 – a practical guide
[1983] QB 1053, and S-T v. J (transsexual: void marriage) [1997] 1 FCR 349, and, more recently, albeit most reluctantly, in Bellinger v. Bellinger [2001] 3 FCR 1. In a series of cases (see Rees v. UK [1987] FLR 111, Cossey v. UK [1991] 2 FLR 492, Sheffield and Horsham v. United Kingdom [1998] 2 FLR 928) the European Court of Human Rights initially accepted the ruling in Corbett as representing English law and being consistent with the right under Articles 8 and 12 of the European Convention on Human Rights to marry and found a family, although it noted that the position needed to be kept under review in the light of scientific and legal developments. In the Sheffield and Bellinger cases the unsuccessful applicants had even undergone gender reassignment surgery and treatment. More recently, however, the European Court in Goodwin v. United Kingdom [2002] 2 FCR 577, and I v. United Kingdom [2002] 2 FCR 613 ruled that in the case of post-operative transsexuals the denial of the right to change the birth registration so as to record the reassigned sex, and the denial of the right to marry a person of the opposite sex to that reassigned, constituted breaches of Articles 8 and 12 of the European Convention. The United Kingdom could not claim that these refusals fell within the margin of appreciation. In April 2003 Bellinger went to the House of Lords [2003] UKHL 21, [2003] 2 FCR 1. The House declined to declare the marriage valid, holding that the words ‘male’ and ‘female’ in section 11(c) of the Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 could not be taken to include post-operative transsexual persons. The House, however, noted that the government had announced its intention to introduce legislation which would allow transsexual people who can demonstrate that they have taken decisive steps towards living fully and permanently in the acquired gender to marry in that gender, and issued a declaration that section 11(c) was incompatible with Articles 8 and 12 of the European Convention. That announcement foreshadowed the enactment of the Gender Recognition Act 2004 which provides the mechanism for the recognition of the reassigned sex.
9.3
After the Gender Recognition Act 2004 The main provision of the Gender Recognition Act is that a person of either gender who is aged at least eighteen may make an application for a gender recognition certificate on the basis of – (a) living in the other gender, or (b) having changed gender under the law of a country or territory outside the United Kingdom. An application for a gender recognition certificate must be made to a Gender Recognition Panel (‘the Panel’) who must be satisfied of certain requirements
50
Civil Partnership Act and Gender Recognition Act
9.3
before granting such a certificate. It is unnecessary for our purposes to examine those requirements, or indeed the means whereby the Panel can be satisfied those requirements have been fulfilled. What is important to note, however, is that the term for the gender that the applicant seeks to have confirmed by the granting of the certificate is ‘the acquired gender’. If an applicant is successful the Panel will grant a full gender recognition certificate unless the applicant is married, in which case he or she will be granted an interim gender recognition certificate. One of the most significant consequences of the grant of an interim gender recognition certificate is that it is now one of the grounds on which the marriage is voidable. That is brought about by Schedule 4 to the Gender Recognition Act which amends section 12 of the Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 by adding to the list of grounds on which a marriage celebrated after 31 July 1971 is voidable the ground ‘that an interim gender recognition certificate under the Gender Recognition Act 2004 has, after the time of the marriage, been issued to either party to the marriage’. If, instead of being married, the successful applicant to the Panel is in a subsisting civil partnership, he or she will again be granted only an interim gender recognition certificate (see the amendment to s.4 of the Gender Recognition Act by s.250 of the Civil Partnership Act). Moreover, mirroring the provision in nullity in marriage, the grant of an interim gender recognition certificate to a civil partner in a subsisting civil partnership is now one of the grounds on which a civil partnership is voidable (see s.50(1)(d) and generally chapter 11). It is also important to note that a court which makes absolute a decree of nullity granted on the ground that an interim gender recognition certificate has been issued to a party to the marriage must, on doing so, issue a full gender recognition certificate to that party (s.5 of the Gender Recognition Act). The same is true for a civil partner in that, by the operation of section 250(4), section 5 of the Gender Recognition Act is amended in such a way that a court which makes final a nullity order on the ground that an interim gender recognition certificate has been issued to a civil partner must, on doing so, issue a full gender recognition certificate to that civil partner. Section 9 of the Gender Recognition Act provides that where a full gender recognition certificate is issued to a person, the person’s gender becomes for all purposes the acquired gender (so that, if the acquired gender is the male gender, the person’s sex becomes that of a man and, if it is the female gender, the person’s sex becomes that of a woman). However, this does not affect things done, or events occurring, before the certificate is issued, and section 12 of the Gender Recognition Act 2004 specifically provides that the fact that a person’s gender has become the acquired gender under this Act does not affect the status of the person as the father or mother of a child. With the main provisions of the Gender Recognition Act 2004 in mind it will be convenient to consider their impact on the workings of the Civil Partnership Act. 51
9.5
Civil Partnership Act 2004 – a practical guide
9.4
Formation of the civil partnership by registration in the UK Detailed consideration of the law relating to the formation of a civil partnership in the UK by registration can be found in chapters 2, 3 and 4 of this book. This section, however, deals solely with the relatively unusual situation where a civil partnership is to take place by way of registration in England and Wales where the gender of one of the proposed civil partners is an acquired gender under the Gender Recognition Act 2004. The pre-registration procedure is modified in such a case as is explained below. The starting point is section 5(2) of the Act which states that all the different types of pre-registration procedure (with the exception of the special procedure) are subject to modification (as set out in Schedule 3 to the Act) where the proposed civil partners are former spouses, one of whom has changed sex. Essentially, the provisions set out in Schedule 3 make it possible for two parties to a marriage, who wish to stay together notwithstanding that one of them is changing gender, to have their marriage annulled and to register under the Act as civil partners of each other, all on the same day if they wish. The modifications apply where a court makes absolute a decree of nullity granted on the ground that an interim gender recognition certificate has been issued to a party to a marriage, and on doing so issues a full gender recognition certificate (in accordance with the provisions summarised above) to that party, and the parties wish to register in England and Wales as civil partners of each other without being delayed by the waiting period (normally fifteen days – see s.11 of the Act). In order to achieve this result each of the parties must give notice of proposed civil partnership during the ‘relevant period’ which is the period beginning with the issue of the full gender recognition certificate and ending at the end of one month from the day on which it is issued, so if they wish the notices could be given on the very day the full gender recognition certificate is issued. At the same time each must make an election under paragraph 3 of the Schedule. If that is done, the standard procedure is modified in such a way that the requirement for publicity (under s.10 of the Act) is disapplied, as is the usual requirement for a waiting period (under s.11). Following on from the disapplying of the waiting period, section 14(1) of the Act is modified in such a way that as soon as the notices of proposed civil partnership have been given the registration authority must at the request of one or both of the partners issue the civil partnership schedule (paragraph 4(2)). The period during which registration must take place (usually twelve months) is shortened to one month.
9.5
Effect on nullity The passing into law of the Gender Recognition Act has necessitated changes to the law of nullity in relation to marriage so that the issue of an interim gender recognition certificate is one of the grounds on which a marriage is now
52
Civil Partnership Act and Gender Recognition Act
9.5
voidable. Similarly the issue of such a certificate is, under section 50(1)(d), one of the grounds on which a civil partnership is voidable. Moreover, section 12 of the Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 is amended so that included in the grounds on which a marriage celebrated after 31 July 1971 is voidable is that ‘the respondent is a person whose gender at the time of the marriage had become the acquired gender under the Gender Recognition Act 2004’ (see Schedule 4 to the Gender Recognition Act). Similarly, under section 50(1)(e) a civil partnership is voidable on the ground that the respondent is a person whose gender at the time of the formation of the partnership had become the acquired gender under the Gender Recognition Act 2004.
53
10 The ending of the partnership: orders for dissolution
10.1
Introduction The intention behind the Act is that civil partnerships should be long-term stable relationships. Hence the fact that the creation of the partnership has to be attended by formalities which underscore the commitment involved and the fact that the partnership confers a wide range of rights and responsibilities not only between the state and the couple, but also between the partners and third parties. Consistent with this notion is the belief, embodied in the legislation, that an appropriate degree of formality should be required to bring a registered partnership to an end. This chapter deals with what is likely to be the most frequently used order the court can make to bring a civil partnership to an end. The orders that the court can make are very similar to those made by the court on the breakdown of a marriage, and divorce practitioners will readily recognise the language and concepts discussed below. Essentially, there are four different orders that can be made by the court on the breakdown of a civil partnership. In this chapter we concentrate on the order called a dissolution order which (when made final) will bring a civil partnership to an end. It is the one most likely to be deployed after the breakdown of the civil partnership. It is very similar in concept to divorce. To put the order in context, the three other orders that can be made by the court (all of which receive separate treatment in chapter 11) are a nullity order the effect of which, as with divorce, will (again when made final) annul a civil partnership which is either void or voidable; a presumption of death order, the effect of which will be to dissolve the civil partnership on the ground that one of the civil partners is presumed to be dead; and a separation order which provides for the separation of the civil partners, but will not allow either civil partner to marry or to form another civil partnership. Each of the above orders (with the exception of the separation order) will in the first instance be a conditional order which will not be made final until the end of a period prescribed in section 38 of the Act. These notions will resonate with divorce practitioners who are very familiar with the granting of a decree nisi of divorce in the first instance which,
54
Ending of the partnership
10.3
after a prescribed period of time, is made absolute. The language is different, but the concepts are the same.
10.2
One ground The sole ground on which either party to a marriage may present a petition for divorce to the court is that the marriage has broken down irretrievably (s.1(2) of the Matrimonial Causes Act 1973). The court hearing a petition for divorce must not hold that the marriage has broken down irretrievably unless the petitioner satisfies the court of one or more of a number of facts: that the respondent has committed adultery and the petitioner finds it intolerable to live with the respondent; that the respondent has behaved in such a way that the petitioner cannot reasonably be expected to live with the respondent; that the respondent has deserted the petitioner for a continuous period of at least two years immediately preceding the presentation of the petition; that the parties to the marriage have lived apart for a continuous period of at least two years immediately preceding the presentation of the petition and the respondent consents to a decree being granted; and, finally, that the parties to the marriage have lived apart for a continuous period of at least five years immediately preceding the presentation of the petition. These facts themselves (unreasonable behaviour, adultery, desertion etc.) are by the layman often understandably, though mistakenly, referred to, or regarded as, the grounds for divorce. Save for the provision relating to adultery, which is discussed below, this aspect of the law of divorce has been imported almost wholesale into the statutory provisions governing the dissolution of a civil partnership. Accordingly, there is only one ground on which an application for dissolution of a civil partnership may be made and that is that the partnership has broken down irretrievably (s.44(1)). The civil partner who makes the application for an order for dissolution of the partnership is referred to as the applicant, and the other civil partner is the respondent.
10.3
Adultery Adultery is the voluntary sexual intercourse between a man and a woman who are not married to each other but one of whom at least is a married person (Clarkson v. Clarkson (1930) 143 LT 775, 46 TLR 623). In the light of that definition it was thought inappropriate to import it as a fact to evidence the irretrievable breakdown of the civil partnership. However, as Dr Stephen Cretney emphasised in his excellent ‘Comment’ entitled ‘Sex is Important’ in the November 2004 issue of Family Law, it has to be acknowledged that at the core of the Act is the recognition that ‘it is sexual relationships and only sexual relationships which are of themselves capable of creating legal rights and duties’. 55
10.5
Civil Partnership Act 2004 – a practical guide
It might have been possible to draft a form of words to isolate a mode or modes of sexual behaviour that of itself or of themselves would have constituted a fact sufficient (together with the element of intolerability) to evidence the irretrievable breakdown of the civil partnership. However, the failure of imagination of the draftsman (or his disinclination) ought not to create any real difficulty, as it is highly likely that sexual intercourse, or even acts falling short of that, with someone, whether of the same or of different gender, will persuade a court that the respondent has thereby behaved in such a way that the applicant cannot reasonably be expected to live with the respondent.
10.4
The court The courts which can make the orders described above are the High Court or a county court with jurisdiction to hear civil partnership proceedings (s.37(4)). Subsection (5) makes it clear that the powers of the court are subject to the court having jurisdiction under sections 219 to 224 of the Act. These sections found the courts’ jurisdiction to hear proceedings for the orders described above broadly based on domicile, habitual residence and the fact that the civil partners registered their partnership in England and Wales.
10.5
‘Behaviour’ Section 44(5) sets out the facts upon which an applicant may rely to evidence the irretrievable breakdown of the partnership. The first of such facts is that the respondent has behaved in such a way that the applicant cannot reasonably be expected to live with the respondent (s.44 (5)(a)). There is a significant body of case law dealing with the concept of unreasonable behaviour and it is safe to assume that the authorities on this issue will be relevant to the concept of unreasonable behaviour in the context of the breakdown of a civil partnership. The court will have to consider the effect of the respondent’s behaviour (whether such behaviour is voluntary or involuntary) on the particular applicant. This will involve a consideration not only of the behaviour of the respondent, but of the personality, character, behaviour and disposition of the applicant. Just as a mere disinclination to continue with a marriage, or boredom with it, does not entitle a court to dissolve it, a similar attitude towards a civil partnership will not be a sufficient basis for the court to end it. In divorce the matter has been approached by assessing whether any right-thinking person would come to the conclusion that the respondent has behaved in such a way that the petitioner cannot reasonably be expected to live with him taking into account the whole of the circumstances and the characters and personalities of the parties (see Dunn J in Livingstone-Stallard v. Livingstone-Stallard [1974] Fam 47, [1974] 2 All ER 766 and approved by the Court of Appeal: see O’Neill v. O’Neill [1975] 3 All ER 289, [1975] 1 WLR 1118, CA, Bergin v. Bergin [1983] 1
56
Ending of the partnership
10.6
All ER 905, [1983] 1 WLR 279 and Birch v. Birch [1992] 1 FLR 564, [1992] Fam Law 290, CA). A similar approach will be taken in judging whether the applicant has raised conduct of sufficient gravity to justify a court ending the partnership. Echoing a similar provision in the context of divorce, if, following the final incident of conduct on which an applicant seeks to rely, the applicant and the respondent continue to cohabit for a period or periods not exceeding six months in total, such period of cohabitation must be disregarded in determining, for the purposes of section 44(5)(a), whether the applicant cannot reasonably be expected to live with the respondent (s.45(2)).
10.6
‘2 years’ separation’ The second fact on which an applicant can rely to satisfy the court that the civil partnership has irretrievably broken down is that the applicant and the respondent have lived apart for a continuous period of two years immediately preceding the making of the application and the respondent consents to a dissolution order being made. This is, of course, precisely the same as the more familiar ‘2 years’ separation with consent’ in the context of divorce. Moreover, civil partners are to be treated as living apart unless they are ‘living with each other in the same household’ (s.45(8)), and the case law on the meaning of this critical phrase in the context of divorce will be applicable. This effectively means that they must not be sharing a common life together (see Mouncer v. Mouncer [1972] 1 All ER 289, [1972] 1 WLR 321) as will be the case if they share their meals or preserve other usual incidents of cohabitation. Section 45(6) also makes plain that in considering whether the period for which the civil partners have lived apart has been continuous, no account is to be taken of any one period not exceeding six months or any two or more periods not exceeding six months in all. So, for example, an applicant will be able to prove separation for two years even if the civil partners lived together for, say, two months during the relevant period as long as the total period of separation adds up to two years (excluding, however, those two months, because section 45(7) provides that no period during which the civil partners have lived with each other counts as part of the period during which the civil partners have lived apart). Understanding consequences Where a civil partner allegedly consents to the making of a dissolution order under the ‘2 years’ separation’ head, rules of court must make provision to ensure that he or she is given information which will enable him or her to understand the consequences of consenting to the order, and the steps which must be taken to indicate consent (s.45(4)). At the time of writing, the rules are yet to be made, but they will be similar to those which apply to divorce where the consent of the respondent will normally be given to the court in the acknowledgement of service of the petition (Form 6) and if so 57
10.8
Civil Partnership Act 2004 – a practical guide
it must be signed by him personally and, if he is represented by a solicitor, his solicitor (Family Proceedings Rules 1991 r 2.10(1)). In cases where this is not done there must be clear evidence that express consent to the grant of a decree has been given: consent will not be implied (see McG ( formerly R) v. R [1972] 1 All ER 362, [1972] 1 WLR 237).
10.7
‘5 years’ separation’ An applicant can rely on the fact that he and the respondent have lived apart for a continuous period of at least five years immediately preceding the making of the application (s.44(5)), referred to in the section as ‘5 years’ separation’ and thus precisely mirroring the fact on which a petitioner can rely in the context of divorce. Section 45(6), (7) and (8) are equally applicable to ‘5 years’ separation’ as they are to ‘2 years’ separation’. Refusal on ground of grave hardship In the case of divorce, section 10 of the Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 confers special protection on a respondent to a petition where the petitioner relies on ‘separation’ (whether two years or five years) to evidence the irretrievable breakdown of the marriage. Similar protection is afforded to a respondent to an application for a dissolution order in which the applicant alleges five years’ separation. Section 47(1) of the Act provides that such a respondent may oppose the making of an order on the ground that the dissolution of the civil partnership will result in grave financial or other hardship to him and it would in all the circumstances be wrong to dissolve the partnership. Section 47(4) provides that ‘hardship’ includes the loss of the chance of acquiring any benefit which the respondent might acquire if the civil partnership were not dissolved. The court’s duty in this context is to consider all the circumstances, including the conduct of the civil partners and the interests of the civil partners and of any children or other persons concerned, and if having done so it is of the opinion that the respondent has made out the ground set out in subsection (1), the court must (so it is mandatory) dismiss the application for a dissolution order (s.47(3)). It should be noted, however, that the court’s duty only arises under subsection (3) if – (a) the making of the dissolution order is opposed under section 47, (b) the court finds that the applicant is entitled to rely in support of his application on the fact of five years’ separation and the court makes no such finding as to any other section 44(5) fact, and (c) apart from section 47, the court would make a dissolution order (s.47(2)).
10.8
Desertion Section 44(5)(d) permits an applicant to rely on the fact that the respondent has deserted the applicant for a continuous period of at least two years preceding the making of the application as evidence that the civil partnership has irretrievably
58
Ending of the partnership
10.8
broken down. Again it is without the scope of this book to examine in detail the body of case law that has grown up around the meaning of desertion in divorce, and judges have tended to avoid a definition of desertion, but it is generally accepted that it requires a withdrawal from cohabitation without reasonable cause with the intention of bringing cohabitation permanently to an end without the consent of the other spouse. As in the case of ‘separation’ no account is to be taken of any one period not exceeding six months or any two or more periods not exceeding six months in all during which the civil partners resumed living with each other for the purposes of considering whether the period for which the respondent has deserted the applicant has been continuous (s.45(6)), but equally no period during which the civil partners have lived with each other counts as part of the period of desertion (s.45(7)). Presumed intention Section 45(5) of the Act allows the court to consider a period of desertion as continuing even when the civil partner concerned was incapable of continuing the necessary intention, provided that the court would on the evidence have inferred that the period of desertion would have continued if the civil partner had been able to continue the intention. The most obvious example of the application of this provision is where one civil partner deserts his or her civil partner, but is involved in an accident at some time over the two years which leads to a temporary loss of consciousness. This break in the ‘intention to desert’ would not stop the two years from accruing. Impact of period of exclusion The court may treat as a period of desertion to support an application for a dissolution order a period during which the respondent was subject to an injunction excluding him or her from the civil partnership home (for example, one civil partner may have obtained an injunction in the High Court under the inherent jurisdiction of that court), or when an order under section 33 or 37 of the Family Law Act 1996 was in force prohibiting the civil partner from occupying a dwelling-house used (then or previously) as the civil partnership home (s.46(5)). Effect of earlier period of desertion followed by separation order Section 46(4) provides that if an application is made for a dissolution order following a separation order or any order requiring the civil partners to live apart, and there was a period of desertion immediately preceding the application for a separation order, the period of desertion is to be treated for the purposes of the application for a dissolution order as if it had immediately preceded the making of the application provided that the civil partners have not resumed living together and the separation order has been continuously in force since it was made. It will be remembered that for an applicant to be able to rely on the fact of desertion as evidence of the irretrievable breakdown of the civil partnership, the two-year period of desertion must ordinarily immediately precede the making of the application for an order of dissolution. Were it not for section 46(4), an earlier period of desertion would not count. 59
10.12
Civil Partnership Act 2004 – a practical guide
10.9
Duty of the court On an application for a dissolution order it is the duty of the court to inquire, so far as it reasonably can, into the facts alleged by the applicant and any facts alleged by the respondent (s.44(2)). The court must not hold that the civil partnership has broken down irretrievably unless the applicant satisfies the court of one or more of the facts described above (s.44(3)). However, if after conducting its inquiry, the court is satisfied of any of those facts it must make a dissolution order unless it is satisfied on all the evidence that the civil partnership has not broken down irretrievably (s.44(4)). If in any proceedings for a dissolution order the respondent alleges and proves any such fact as is mentioned in section 44(5) (a), (b), (c), or (d), the court may give to the respondent the relief to which he would have been entitled if he had made an application seeking that relief (s.62(1)). If the court does so, it may, by virtue of section 62(2), treat the respondent as the applicant and the applicant as the respondent for the purposes of section 44(5).
10.10
Dissolution order not precluded by previous separation order etc. Section 46 of the Act provides that where a separation order, an order for financial relief in the magistrates’ court or an order under section 33 or 37 of the Family Law Act 1996 has been made, this does not prevent either civil partner from applying to the court for a dissolution order on the basis of the same facts that were relied on when granting the previous order. Indeed, the court may treat the previous order as sufficient proof of the facts by reference to which it was made, but the court must not make the dissolution order without receiving evidence from the applicant (s.46(3)).
10.11
Restrictions on presenting an application for dissolution No application to dissolve the civil partnership can be made until at least one year has passed since its formation. However, matters which occurred within the one-year period may be used in support of the application for dissolution (s.41).
10.12
Attempts at reconciliation of civil partners Section 42 provides that if at any stage of an application for an order for dissolution or separation it appears to the court that there is a reasonable possibility of a reconciliation between the civil partners, the court may adjourn the proceedings for such period as it thinks fit to enable attempts to be made to effect a reconciliation between them. Rules of court must make provision requiring the applicant’s solicitors to certify whether they have discussed with their client the possibility of reconciliation and to certify whether they have given the applicant details of persons qualified to help with reconciliation (s.42(2)).
60
Ending of the partnership
10.15
This section mirrors the statutory provision in divorce whereby the court may adjourn divorce proceedings at any stage and for such period as it thinks fit for the purpose of enabling attempts to be made to effect a reconciliation between the parties where it appears to the court that there is a reasonable possibility of a reconciliation (s.6(2) of the Matrimonial Causes Act 1973). It should be noted that this statutory power of the court has been considerably developed and extended by Practice Direction to all matrimonial litigation, and the High Court or county court may in any case in which it considers that there is a reasonable possibility of a reconciliation or that there are ancillary proceedings in which conciliation might serve a useful purpose, refer the case or any particular matter or matters in dispute therein to Children and Family Court Advisory and Support Services (CAFCASS).
10.13
Consideration by the court of certain agreements or arrangements Section 43 of the Act provides that rules of court may make provision for civil partners to refer to the court an agreement or arrangement between them in connection with the dissolution of their partnership or their separation. The rules (not yet made) may allow the court to express an opinion about whether the agreement is reasonable or to give directions. This provision reflects section 7 of the Matrimonial Causes Act 1973.
10.14
Period before conditional orders may be made final Each of the orders under discussion (with the exception of the separation order) will in the first instance be a conditional order. Section 38(1) of the Act provides that a period of six weeks must elapse from the making of the conditional order before it can be made final, subject to a slight modification if this day ends on a day when the court office or registry is closed. Section 38(2) gives the Lord Chancellor power to make an order substituting a different period not exceeding six months. By section 38(4) the court may in particular cases reduce the period. Such a case might be where there is a deathbed dissolution and formation of a new civil partnership.
10.15
Intervention of the Queen’s Proctor The office of H M Procurator General or Queen’s Proctor is an ancient office of the Crown and it is beyond the ambit of this work to consider the nature of that office in detail. However, since the passing of the Matrimonial Causes Act 1860 the Queen’s Proctor has been vested with special functions in matrimonial causes. In the case of divorce or nullity, the court may, if it thinks fit, under section 8 of the Matrimonial Causes Act 1973, direct all necessary papers in the matter to be sent to the Queen’s Proctor, who shall under the directions of the Attorney 61
10.17
Civil Partnership Act 2004 – a practical guide
General instruct counsel to argue before the court any question in relation to the matter which the court considers it necessary or expedient to have fully argued. Moreover, any person may, at any time during the progress of the divorce or nullity proceedings, or before the decree nisi is made absolute, give information to the Queen’s Proctor on any matter material to the due decision of the case, and the Queen’s Proctor may thereupon take such steps as the Attorney General considers necessary or expedient. Section 39 of the Act provides for precisely the same intervention by the Queen’s Proctor in proceedings where an application has been made for a dissolution, nullity or presumption of death order. Section 39(4) and (5) contain provisions as to the payment of costs in the event of intervention by the Queen’s Proctor.
10.16
Proceedings before order has been made final Section 40(1) of the Act provides an opportunity, between the making of a conditional order and a final order, for the Queen’s Proctor, or any person who has not been a party to the proceedings in which the order was made, to show cause (good reason) why the order should not be made final on the ground that material facts have not been brought before the court. When this happens the court may make the order final, rescind the order, direct that further enquiries be made, or deal with the case in such other manner as it thinks fit (s.40(3)). The court’s power to make the order final applies even if the prescribed period under section 38 has not yet expired (see 10.14). It is, however, subject to the restrictions imposed in section 48(4) (relating to financial provision in separation cases – as to which see 10.17.2) and section 63 (restrictions on the court’s powers to make orders affecting children – as to which see chapter 8). By subsection (2) where the civil partner who applied for the conditional order has not taken steps to have the order made final within three months from the earliest date when such an application could have been made, the other civil partner may apply to the court under this section whereupon the court has power either to make the order final, to rescind the order, require further enquiry, or otherwise deal with the case as it thinks fit.
10.17
Proceedings before order made final: protection for respondent in separation cases In addition to the safeguard already considered (Refusal on ground of grave hardship – see 10.7), there is further protection provided for respondents in separation cases under the Act similar to that which is afforded to respondents facing divorce proceedings where the fact relied on to evidence the irretrievable breakdown of the marriage is either two years’ or five years’ separation. Section 48(1) of the Act gives a court power to rescind a conditional dissolution order which has not yet been made final where the application was based on two years’
62
Ending of the partnership
10.18
separation if it is satisfied that the applicant misled the respondent about any matter which the respondent took into account in deciding to give his consent. It does not matter whether the applicant misled the respondent intentionally or unintentionally (s.48(1)(c)). Further, a respondent to an application for a dissolution order based on either two or five years’ separation may, after the court has made a conditional dissolution order, apply to the court for consideration of his financial position after the dissolution of the civil partnership (s.48(2)).
10.17.1
Matters to be taken into account The court must consider all the circumstances including the age, health, conduct, earning capacity, financial resources and financial obligations of each of the parties, and the financial position of the respondent on the death of the applicant, assuming the applicant died first (s.48(3)).
10.17.2
Court’s powers to make order final The court must not make the order final unless it is satisfied either that the applicant should not be required to make any financial provision for the respondent or that the provision made for the respondent is reasonable and fair, or the best that can be made in the circumstances (s.48(4)). However, the court may make the dissolution order final if the circumstances make it desirable to do so without delay, provided that it has received an undertaking from the applicant to make such financial provision for the respondent as the court may approve. The court may, for example, require an applicant to provide an undertaking that he will irrevocably nominate the respondent as the person to receive the lump sum, or a percentage thereof, payable in the event of his death under the terms of his pension scheme in return for making the conditional order of dissolution final.
10.18
Public funding The Act makes no mention of public funding. However, in the DTI document ‘Civil Partnership – A framework for the legal recognition of same-sex couples’ it was acknowledged that when civil partners are dissolving a partnership they may need legal advice or assistance. The authors anticipated that dissolution proceedings would come within the definition of ‘family proceedings’ for which public funding is available, and that the Government may need to make changes to the Funding Code which sets out the way public funding operates. The document also points out that generally speaking public funding is means-tested and when assessing an applicant’s means, just as the means of a new partner or spouse are taken into account, in the context of proceedings relating to a civil partnership the means of the civil partner would also be taken into account. The detailed provisions were at the date of publication not yet available. 63
11 Nullity and other proceedings
11.1
Introduction This chapter deals with the orders, other than the order for dissolution (see chapter 10) the court can make to bring a civil partnership to an end or to provide for the separation of the parties. The orders that the court can make in civil partnership are very similar to those made by the court on the breakdown of a marriage, and divorce practitioners will readily recognise the language and concepts discussed below.
11.2
Nullity The Act preserves in relation to civil partnerships the distinction which is made in marriage between unions that are void and those which are voidable. A void marriage is said to be ‘one that will be regarded by every court in any case in which the existence of the marriage is in issue as never having taken place and can be so treated by both parties to it without the necessity of any decree annulling it; a voidable marriage is one that will be regarded by every court as a valid subsisting marriage until a decree annulling it has been pronounced by a court of competent jurisdiction’ ( per Lord Greene in De Reneville v. De Reneville [1948] 1 All ER 56 at 60, CA).
11.2.1
Grounds on which a civil partnership is void Section 49 of the Act provides that where two people register as civil partners of each other in England and Wales, the civil partnership is void if – (1) At the time they register as civil partners they are not eligible to do so under section 3 of the Act (for eligibility, see chapter 2). (2) They are in breach of certain formal requirements if both civil partners were aware of the breach at the time of registration. The breaches are: (a) failure to give the required notice of the proposed civil partnership, (b) the civil partnership document not being duly issued,
64
Nullity and other proceedings
11.2
(c) the civil partnership document having expired, (d) the place of registration not being the place specified in the notice(s) of proposed civil partnership and the civil partnership document, (e) the civil partnership registrar not being present at the registration. (3) The civil partnership document is void under paragraph 6(5) of Schedule 2 to the Act because one of the intended civil partners is a child (under the age of eighteen) and the issue of the civil partnership document has been forbidden by a person whose consent is required for the child to form a civil partnership and the consent of the court has not been obtained following an application under paragraph 3 or 4 of Schedule 2 to the Act. This requirement is dealt with in depth in chapter 3.
11.2.2
Power to validate civil partnership Section 53 of the Act makes provision for the Lord Chancellor to validate a civil partnership where two people have registered as civil partners but it appears to him that the partnership may be void under section 49(b) (see 11.2.1 – breach of certain formal requirements). An order made under section 53(1) may include provisions for relieving a person from any liability under sections 31(2), 32(2) or 33(5) or (7) of the Act (offences relating to civil partnership schedule, Registrar General’s licence and recording of civil partnerships – see chapter 12). If the Lord Chancellor is minded to validate the civil partnership, notwithstanding the breaches under section 49(b), he must advertise a draft of the proposed validating order at least one month before the order is made. The manner of advertisement is a matter for the Lord Chancellor. Section 53(4) of the Act, however, imposes a duty on him to consider all the objections sent to him in writing during that month and, if it appears necessary to him, to direct a local inquiry into the validity of any such objections. An order under section 53(1) is subject to special parliamentary procedure, laid down in the Statutory Orders (Special Procedure) Act 1945.
11.2.3
Grounds on which a civil partnership is voidable The grounds on which a civil partnership is voidable are set out in section 50 of the Act, which provides that where two people register as civil partners of each other in England and Wales, the civil partnership is voidable if – (1) Either of the civil partners did not validly consent to the formation of the civil partnership whether through a mistake, or through being put under duress or due to unsoundness of mind or otherwise. (2) At the time of the formation of the civil partnership either of the civil partners, although able to consent to the registration, was suffering from a mental disorder which made him or her unfitted for civil partnership. 65
11.2
Civil Partnership Act 2004 – a practical guide
(3) At the time of the formation of the civil partnership, the respondent was pregnant by some person other than the applicant. (4) An interim gender recognition certificate under the Gender Recognition Act 2004 has been issued to either civil partner after the time of the formation of the civil partnership. An example will aid an understanding of the intention and rationale of this subsection (but the reader’s attention is invited to chapter 9 of the book which examines in detail the correlation of the Gender Recognition Act and the Civil Partnership Act): Kevin and John register as civil partners of each other. At the time of the formation of the partnership they satisfy the eligibility test set out in section 3(1)(a) of the Act, being of the same sex or gender. After the formation of the partnership Kevin aspires to change sex and to become Katie and successfully applies to a Gender Recognition Panel who grant her (as Katie) an interim gender recognition certificate. By the operation of section 50(1)(d) of the Act, the grant of that certificate will render the civil partnership voidable on the basis that John may well be unhappy to continue in his civil partnership with Katie and may wish to avoid the partnership. However, as we shall see below, there is a time limit within which John must bring his application, namely six months from the date of issue of the interim gender recognition certificate (s.51(5)). (5) The respondent is a person whose gender at the time of the formation of the civil partnership had become the acquired gender under the Gender Recognition Act 2004. Again, an example will help: Kevin was born as a male, and that was the gender recorded on his birth certificate. However, he aspires to change gender and, having done so, successfully applies to the Panel who grant her a full gender recognition certificate as Karen. Karen meets Susie and they decide to form a civil partnership. They satisfy the eligibility test, as they are both of the female gender. However, Karen’s gender is the acquired gender under the Gender Recognition Act. Were Susie to find out that fact, she might not wish to continue the civil partnership with Karen. By virtue of section 50(1)(e), the civil partnership is voidable and so Susie, subject to certain bars to do with her state of knowledge at the time of the formation of the civil partnership, which are discussed below, can apply for an order of nullity.
Mental disorder For the purposes of section 50(1)(b) and section 51 ‘mental disorder’ has the same meaning as in the Mental Health Act 1983, namely ‘mental illness, arrested or incomplete development of mind, psychopathic disorder and any other disorder or disability of mind and “mentally disordered” shall be construed accordingly’ (s.1(2) of the Mental Health Act 1983). 66
Nullity and other proceedings
11.2.4
11.3
Bars to relief where civil partnership is voidable Even where any of the grounds of a voidable civil partnership is established, the court must refuse an order for nullity if the respondent satisfies the court that the applicant, knowing that it was open to him or her to obtain a nullity order, acted towards the respondent in such a way as to indicate that he or she would not apply for a nullity order, and that it would be unjust to the respondent to make the order (s.51(1)). In most cases an application for a nullity order on the grounds that a civil partnership is voidable must be made within three years from the date that the civil partnership was formed (s.51(2)). However, the court may allow a later application where it is just to do so on the basis that the applicant has suffered from mental disorder at some time during the three-year period. Where the application is made on the ground that an interim gender recognition certificate has been issued under the Gender Recognition Act 2004 after the formation of the civil partnership (s.50(1)(d)), proceedings for an order of nullity must be instituted within six months from the date of the issue of the certificate (s.51(5)).
11.2.5
Lack of knowledge is essential in gender and pregnancy cases Section 51(6) provides that, where the application is made on the grounds of pregnancy at the time of formation of the civil partnership, or a change of gender previous to that date, a nullity order must not be made unless the court is satisfied that the applicant did not know of the relevant facts at the time of formation of the civil partnership.
11.2.6
Proof of certain matters not necessary to validity of partnership By virtue of section 52 of the Act where two people have registered as civil partners of each other it is not necessary in support of the civil partnership to give any proof that any consent required under section 4 (consent by parents etc. where one of the intended civil partners is under eighteen: see chapter 2) was actually given, or that the person who officiated at the signing of the civil partnership schedule was a designated civil partnership registrar for the area in which registration took place. In fact no evidence may be given in any nullity proceedings to disprove either of these facts. However, the issue of consent is subject to the provisions of section 49(c) which provides that a civil partnership involving a person under eighteen will be void if the issue of the civil partnership document was forbidden by a person whose consent was required and the consent of the court was not obtained.
11.3
Validity of civil partnership registered outside England and Wales The vast majority of civil partnerships encountered by practitioners will be those civil partnerships that are registered in England and Wales. However, it 67
11.3
Civil Partnership Act 2004 – a practical guide
is also possible under the Act for couples resident in Scotland and in Northern Ireland to form their civil partnership in their own jurisdictions under the provisions (peculiar to their respective jurisdictions) set out in the Act. The Act also makes provision for civil partnerships to be formed or created under Order in Council, and for overseas relationships, in very prescribed circumstances, to be treated as civil partnerships. Save for the procedure for the formation of civil partnerships in Scotland and Northern Ireland, the provisions relating to the formation or creation of a civil partnership outside the UK are examined in chapter 5. Subject to satisfying a court in England and Wales that it has jurisdiction to deal with the proceedings, section 54 sets out the rules to be applied when determining whether, under the law of England and Wales, a civil partnership is void or voidable where the parties did not register as civil partners in England and Wales. If the civil partnership is void or voidable, a court in England and Wales which has jurisdiction under sections 219 to 221 may make a nullity order in respect of the civil partnership under section 37.
11.3.1
Scotland Where two people register as civil partners of each other in Scotland, the civil partnership is void for the purposes of the law of England and Wales only if it would be void under the Scottish provisions in section 123 of the Act. The partnership will also be voidable if an interim gender certificate is subsequently issued to either party under the Gender Recognition Act 2004 (s.54(1) of the Act).
11.3.2
Northern Ireland Where two people register as civil partners of each other in Northern Ireland, the civil partnership is void for the purposes of the law of England and Wales only if it would be void under the Northern Ireland provisions in section 173 of the Act. The partnership will also be voidable if the circumstances are as described in section 50(1) of the Act.
11.3.3
Registration under Order in Council Void
Registration by Order in Council will be pursuant to either section 210 (registration by British consulates) or section 211 (registration by armed forces personnel). In the case of registration under section 210, the civil partnership will be void if it turns out that neither of the proposed civil partners was a United Kingdom national (as defined in s.245 of the Act) or if it transpires that the proposed civil partners would not have been eligible to register as civil partners of each other in such part of the UK as is determined in accordance with the Order (s.54(4)(a)(i)). 68
Nullity and other proceedings
11.3
Similarly, in the case of registration under section 211 certain conditions must be met including the following, namely that at least one of the proposed civil partners – (a) is a member of a part of Her Majesty’s forces serving in the country or territory, (b) is employed in the country or territory in such other capacity as may be prescribed, or (c) is a child of a person falling within (a) or (b) and has his home with that person in that country or territory. Moreover, the section imposes the requirement that the proposed civil partners would have been eligible to register as civil partners of each other in such part of the UK as is determined in accordance with the Order. If it transpires that any of the above conditions was not fulfilled then the civil partnership is void (s.54(4)(a)(i)). The partnership will also be void in both cases where any requirement prescribed for the purposes of this paragraph by an Order in Council under the relevant section (i.e. under section 210 or 211) is not complied with (s.54(4)(a)(ii)). Voidable
A civil partnership formed by registration by Order in Council will, in the case of partners who would have been eligible to register in England and Wales or Northern Ireland, be voidable if any of the circumstances set out in section 50(1) of the Act apply (the usual grounds on which a civil partnership registered in England and Wales is voidable) (s.54(4)(b)(i)). In the case of partners who would have been eligible to register in Scotland, the purported civil partnership is voidable if the circumstances set out in section 50(1)(d) of the Act apply, namely that an interim gender recognition certificate under the Gender Recognition Act 2004 has, after the time of the formation of the civil partnership, been issued to either civil partner (s.54(4)(b)(ii)).
11.3.4
Registration of overseas relationship This section deals with the situation where two people have registered an apparent or alleged overseas relationship. Void
Section 54(7) of the Act provides that the civil partnership created by that method is void in English law if the relationship turns out not to be an overseas relationship as defined, or if, even though the overseas relationship meets the definition laid down in the Act, one or more of the requirements for the overseas relationship to be treated as a civil partnership is not met. Sections 215 to 218 of the Act set out the requirements that the relationship must fulfil in this context. 69
11.5
Civil Partnership Act 2004 – a practical guide
By way of example, section 215(1) provides that two people are to be treated as having formed a civil partnership, as a result of having registered an overseas relationship, if, under the relevant law (i.e. under the law of the country or territory where the overseas relationship was registered, including its rules of private international law), the couple had the capacity to enter the relationship. If it transpires that at the time of entering the relationship the would-be partners did not have the required capacity, the ensuing registered civil partnership (which depends for its existence on the validity of the overseas relationship) would be void. Voidable
A civil partnership formed or created as a consequence of the registration of an overseas relationship is voidable if the relationship is voidable under the relevant law (see above). Such a partnership will also be voidable if an interim gender recognition certificate under the Gender Recognition Act 2004 has, after the time of its formation, been issued to either civil partner (for a more detailed analysis of the correlation between the Civil Partnership Act and the Gender Recognition Act, see chapter 9). Finally, the civil partnership will be voidable where either of the parties was domiciled in England and Wales or Northern Ireland at the time when the overseas relationship was registered and the circumstances set out in section 50(1)(a), (b), (c) or (e) are present.
11.4
Presumption of death orders Section 55 of the Act gives the court power to make a presumption of death order, on the application of a civil partner, if it is satisfied that there are reasonable grounds for believing that the other civil partner is dead. A continuous absence of seven years coupled with an absence of belief in the applicant that the other civil partner has been living during that period will be sufficient evidence of the death of the partner unless and until the contrary is proved (s.55(2)). This relief mirrors the power conferred on the court in the context of divorce by section 19 of the Matrimonial Causes Act 1973, subsection (3) of which provides for the same presumption.
11.5
Separation orders A situation may arise within the civil partnership whereby the partners feel that they need to separate and that the separation requires the support of a formal order, but that they are not yet at the point where the breakdown of the relationship is irretrievable. In such circumstances, an application for a separation order is more appropriate than an application for a dissolution order. Section 56 of the Act allows an application for a separation order to be made on the basis of the same facts as are required for an order for dissolution, but the court does not need to be satisfied before granting a separation order that
70
Nullity and other proceedings
11.6
the civil partnership has broken down irretrievably. Accordingly, the applicant for such an order must establish either that the other civil partner (again referred to as the respondent for these purposes) has behaved in such a way that the applicant cannot reasonably be expected to live with him/her, or that they have lived apart for a continuous period of at least two years immediately preceding the making of the application and the respondent consents to a separation order being made, or that they have lived apart for a continuous period of at least five years immediately preceding the making of the application or, finally, that the respondent has deserted the applicant for a continuous period of at least two years immediately preceding the making of the application.
11.5.1
Duty of the court Section 56(2) requires the court to inquire, so far as it reasonably can, into the facts alleged by the applicant and any facts alleged by the respondent, but whether the civil partnership has broken down irretrievably is irrelevant. If, however, the court is satisfied of the facts alleged it must make a separation order subject to the provisions of section 63 of the Act. It will be recalled that section 63 imposes restrictions on the making of orders in proceedings for a dissolution or nullity order as well as in proceedings for a separation order. This section requires the court in such proceedings to consider whether, in the light of arrangements which have been, or are proposed to be, made for the upbringing and welfare of the child, it should exercise any of its powers under the Children Act 1989. In the case of a separation order, the court may direct that the order is not to be made if it may need to exercise its powers under the Children Act 1989 but cannot do so without giving further consideration to the case and there are exceptional circumstances making it desirable in the interests of the child that the court should give such a direction. (This section has been examined further in chapter 8.)
11.5.2
Effect of separation order If a civil partner dies without making a will at a time when a separation order is in force and the separation is continuing, the rules that order the disposition of the deceased partner’s estate shall be applied as if the surviving civil partner were also dead (s.57). It must also be remembered that a separation order does not entitle a civil partner to form another civil partnership.
11.6
Declarations In divorce, courts have long had the power to make a declaration concerning the validity of marriage, although the exercise of this power is relatively rare. Section 58 of the Act extends this power to civil partnerships. Accordingly, any person (but see below) may apply to the High Court or to a county court 71
11.6
Civil Partnership Act 2004 – a practical guide
for various declarations regarding the status of a civil partnership. In broad terms, the potential declarations cover its validity, its existence or otherwise on a specified date, and whether a dissolution, annulment or legal separation obtained outside England and Wales is or is not entitled to recognition in England and Wales. Although, as stated above, any person may make an application for a declaration, where the applicant is not one of the civil partners concerned, the court must refuse to hear the application if it considers that the applicant has insufficient interest in the outcome (s.58(2)).
11.6.1
Hearing in private Section 61(4) of the Act enables the court to direct that the hearing of an application for a declaration under section 58 should be heard in private and section 61(5) provides that an application for such a direction must be heard in private unless the court otherwise directs.
11.6.2
General provisions as to making and effect of declarations Where an application for a declaration is made under section 58, and the truth of the proposition to be declared is proved to the satisfaction of the court, the court must make the declaration unless to do so would be manifestly contrary to public policy (s.59(1)). If the court dismisses the application, it must not make any other declaration which has not been applied for (s.59(3)), and the court is expressly precluded by section 59(5) from making a declaration, whether under section 58 or otherwise, that a civil partnership was void at its inception. However, nothing in section 58 is to prevent the court from being able to make a nullity order in respect of the civil partnership (s.59(6)).
11.6.3
The Attorney General and proceedings for declarations At any stage in the course of an application for a declaration under section 58 the court may, either of its own motion, or on the application of any party to the proceedings, direct that all papers in the case be sent to the Attorney General (s.60(1)). The Attorney General may intervene in the proceedings for such a declaration under section 58 as he thinks necessary or expedient, and may argue any question which the court thinks should be fully argued (s.60(2)).
11.6.4
Costs By virtue of section 60(3) the court may make such order as it thinks just about the payment by parties to the proceedings as to any costs incurred by the Attorney General in connection with any application for a declaration under section 58.
72
Nullity and other proceedings
11.6.5
11.7
Supplementary provisions as to declarations Rules of court will determine the form of any application under section 58 and the form of any declaration made under that section (s.61(1)). The rules will also make provision for the information that the applicant needs to supply, and for notice of the application to be served on the Attorney General and on persons who may be affected by the declaration (s.61(2)). Section 61(3) provides that no proceedings under section 58 will affect any final order or judgment already given.
11.7
Joinder and dismissal of parties Section 64 of the Act provides for the making of rules of court to allow for parties to be joined to proceedings for dissolution, nullity or separation if they are involved in allegations of improper conduct made in the proceedings. Rules will also make provision for their dismissal from the proceedings and for the appropriate parties to an application for a declaration. Section 64(3) permits the court to allow any person it thinks fit to intervene in any proceedings if it thinks that he or she should be made a party, if necessary on such terms as the court thinks just.
73
12 Offences
12.1
Introduction The Act creates a number of offences in connection with the formation of a civil partnership. These offences are examined in detail in this chapter, but practitioners will have also to consult standard works of criminal law and practice in the event that they are called upon to advise in connection with these offences. The offences created relate to the issue of the civil partnership schedule, to the issue of the Registrar General’s licence (under the special procedure) and to the recording of civil partnerships.
12.2
Offences relating to the civil partnership schedule The procedure to be followed under the Act in order to create or form a civil partnership by registration in England and Wales is examined in detail in earlier chapters and the reader is invited to recall that procedure in order to understand the context of the offences discussed below. As part of the standard procedure of registration, section 14 of the Act imposes a duty on the registration authority to issue, at the request of one or both of the civil partners, a document known as the civil partnership schedule. That duty ordinarily arises as soon as ‘the waiting period’ (as defined in the Act) has expired. The waiting period can be shortened in special circumstances under section 12, but in the usual case it begins on the day after notice of proposed civil partnership has been given to the registration authority and recorded by the authority, and ends fifteen days thereafter (see s.11). Once the civil partnership schedule has been issued the proposed civil partners have a period of time, known as ‘the applicable period’, within which they must sign the schedule. Again, that period may be shortened in special cases, but it is normally no more than twelve months. However, whatever the length of the applicable period may be in any given case, failure to sign within it will render void both the notice of proposed civil partnership and the civil partnership schedule. Where one of the proposed civil partners is a child (meaning a person under eighteen for these purposes), as an additional safeguard, the consent of an
74
Offences
12.3
appropriate person must be obtained. Any person whose consent is required may, by giving the registration authority written notice, forbid the issue of a civil partnership schedule. These procedural provisions give rise to a number of potential offences: section 31 provides that a person who issues a civil partnership in the knowledge that the waiting period has not yet expired commits an offence (s.31(1)(a)). An offence is also committed by a person who knowingly issues a civil partnership schedule after the applicable period (whatever it might be in any given case) has ended (s.31(1)(b)). Section 31(1)(c) also makes it illegal for a person to issue a civil partnership schedule knowing at the time of issue that its issue has been forbidden by a person entitled to do so. By virtue of section 31(2) a person who, in his actual or purported capacity as a civil partnership registrar, officiates at the signing of a civil partnership schedule knowing that he does so at a place other than the place specified in the notices of proposed civil partnership and in the civil partnership schedule, commits an offence. So, too, does such a person who officiates either in the absence of a civil partnership registrar, or before the waiting period has expired, even though the civil partnership is void under section 49(b) or (c) of the Act.
12.2.1
Punishment A person found guilty of any of the above offences is liable on conviction on indictment to go to prison for a term not exceeding five years or to a fine or both (s.31(3)).
12.2.2
Time limit No one can be prosecuted more than three years after the commission of any such offence (s.31(4)).
12.3
Offences relating to Registrar General’s licence The issue of such a licence is strictly controlled and the procedure governing its issue is considered in detail in chapter 4. A person who wishes to take advantage of this special procedure must give notice to the registration authority for the area in which it is proposed that the registration take place, and at the same time the person giving the notice must, under section 22, produce such evidence as the Registrar General may require in order to be satisfied that: (1) there is no lawful impediment to the formation of the civil partnership, (2) one of the proposed civil partners is seriously ill and not expected to recover, and he understands the nature and implications of signing a Registrar General’s licence. 75
12.4
Civil Partnership Act 2004 – a practical guide
A medical certificate is sufficient evidence of any or all of the matters mentioned in (2) above (s.22(3)). Section 32(1) makes it an offence for any person to give such information or to give such a certificate licence knowing that either the information or the certificate is false. Echoing the offences created under section 31(2) above, a person who, in his actual or purported capacity as a civil partnership registrar, officiates at the signing of a Registrar General’s licence knowing that he does so at a place other than the place specified in the licence, commits an offence. So, too, does such a person who officiates either in the absence of a civil partnership registrar, or after the end of one month from the day on which the notice of proposed civil partnership was given, even though the civil partnership is void under section 49(b) or (c) of the Act (as to which see 11.2.1).
12.3.1
Punishment A person found guilty of any of the above offences is liable on conviction on indictment to go to prison for a term not exceeding three years or to a fine or both (s.32(3)(a)) or on summary conviction to a fine not exceeding the statutory maximum (s.32(3)(b)).
12.3.2
Time limit No one can be prosecuted more than three years after the commission of any such offence (s.32(4)).
12.4
Offences relating to recording of civil partnerships Section 33 creates a number of offences relating chiefly to the failure or refusal by a civil partnership registrar to comply with the provisions laid down in the Act or regulations made thereunder, and the reader’s attention is invited to study the details set out therein.
76
13 Domestic violence and occupation of the home
13.1
Introduction The breakdown of a civil partnership may cause one or both partners to seek relief from the courts in the short and the longer term. If a partner finds herself or himself the victim of domestic violence, or a dispute arises about one partner’s entitlement to occupy the partners’ home, remedies and rights are now available under the Family Law Act 1996. The intention behind the amendments to the 1996 Act, effected by Schedule 9 to the Civil Partnership Act (introduced by s.82), is for civil partners to be entitled to the same protection as that available to spouses and opposite sex couples. So, a civil partner or former partner can apply for non-molestation orders under section 42 of the Family Law Act and occupation orders under section 33, 35, 36, 37 or 38 of that Act. ‘Home rights’ replace ‘matrimonial home rights’ in section 30, so that a civil partner’s entitlement to occupy the home for so long as the partnership subsists is recognised, investing civil partners with the same rights to occupy their home as married persons. The Act also introduces the concept of the ‘civil partnership home’. As with divorce, the breakdown of a civil partnership will inevitably involve a consideration of what, if any, financial provision ought to be made in favour of a partner, or children, or both. In addition, amended Schedule 7 to the Family Law Act enables the court, when it has the power to make a property adjustment order under Part 2 of Schedule 5 to the Civil Partnership Act, or when civil partners cease to live together as partners, to transfer certain tenancies.
13.2
Domestic violence: ‘cohabitants’ and ‘associated persons’ Section 62 of the Family Law Act 1996 defines ‘cohabitants’ and ‘associated persons’ for the purpose of applications under Part IV of the 1996 Act. The definitions are an important first step in ascertaining the nature of the relief that can be applied for. A partner’s status as a cohabitant will dictate the section of the amended Family Law Act under which an application for an occupation order must be made. 77
13.5
Civil Partnership Act 2004 – a practical guide
Amended section 62(1)(a) redefines cohabitants to include two persons who are not civil partners of each other but are living together as if they were civil partners. ‘Former cohabitants’ is, by virtue of section 62(1)(b), to be interpreted accordingly, but does not include cohabitants who have subsequently become civil partners of each other (amended s.62(1)(b)). An applicant for a non-molestation order must be ‘associated’ with the respondent within the meaning of section 62(3). The class of associated persons is enlarged by the new section 62(3) (amended by paragraph 13 of Schedule 9) to include persons who are or have been civil partners of each other and those who have entered into a civil partnership agreement, whether or not that agreement has been terminated. Already included are cohabitants and former cohabitants (see above for the amended definition).
13.3
Non-molestation orders: time restriction on applications An application under section 42 of the Family Law Act for a non-molestation order can only be made by a person who is associated with the respondent (s.42(2)(a)). If a civil partnership agreement (see s.73 of the Civil Partnership Act) is terminated, an application for a non-molestation order which relies on that agreement for associated person status cannot be made more than three years after the date of its dissolution (s.42(4ZA) of the Family Law Act, inserted by paragraph 9 of Schedule 9 to the Civil Partnership Act). Section 42(4) of the Family Law Act contains a similar provision, which prevents a party from relying on an agreement to marry more than three years after the engagement has ended.
13.4
Occupation orders Occupation orders are designed to govern the occupation of the partners’ home. An order can enforce one civil partner’s right to enter or remain in the home, require one partner to leave, regulate the occupation of the home by either or both partners and exclude one from a defined area in which the home is included. The choice of which of the five sections of the Family Law Act under which to make an application, and the menu of orders available, depend upon the status of the applicant and the respondent in terms of whether one or both is or are entitled to occupy the civil partnership home. The entitlement to occupy may arise in the partner’s own right or because he or she has home rights in relation to the house.
13.5
‘Home rights’ Home rights are of great importance, giving a civil partner rights to occupy the home during the civil partnership until the death of the other partner or
78
Domestic violence and occupation of the home
13.7
the termination of the partnership (and sometimes beyond its end if the rights are extended by the court under s.33(5)) – rights to which he or she would not otherwise be entitled. Further protection is afforded by the fact that a partner’s home rights can be registered as a charge against the property (amended s.31 of the Family Law Act). Section 30(2) of the Family Law Act (as amended by paragraph 1 of Schedule 9) defines home rights. If one civil partner is entitled to occupy the home (because of a beneficial estate or interest or contract, or any enactment) and the other partner is not so entitled, the second partner has the right not to be evicted or excluded from the home except with the court’s permission, given by a section 33 order. If the non-entitled partner is not in occupation, he or she has the right, with the permission of the court, to enter and occupy the home.
13.6
‘Civil partnership home’ Home rights do not arise if a house has never been and was never intended by the partners to be their civil partnership home (amended s.30(7)). As with ‘matrimonial home’ in the unamended Family Law Act, there is no definition in the Act of this phrase. The term ‘dwelling house’ which is used throughout the Act is defined as including any building or part of a building which is occupied as a dwelling and any yard, garden, garage or outhouse belonging to the dwelling and occupied with it (s.63(1)).
13.7
Entitled applicant: section 33 application An application should be made under section 33 where the applicant partner is entitled in his or her own right to occupy a house by virtue of a beneficial estate or contract or any enactment, or has home rights. The house must be, or have been, the home of the partner entitled and of any person with whom he or she is associated or it must at some time have been intended by them to be their home (s.33(1)(b)). All orders made under section 33 are discretionary. Of all the five sections under which occupation orders can be made, section 33 gives the court the widest powers. Under section 33(3) an order may: • enforce the applicant’s entitlement to remain in the home, • require the respondent to allow the applicant to enter and remain in the home, • regulate the occupation of the home by either or both partners, • prohibit, suspend or restrict any rights the respondent has to occupy the home, • terminate the respondent’s home rights (but only if the applicant is the other civil partner), • require the respondent to leave the home or part of it, • exclude the respondent from a defined area in which the home is included. 79
13.8
Civil Partnership Act 2004 – a practical guide
Orders may also be made under section 33(4) to declare that the applicant is entitled to occupy the home, or has home rights and, under section 33(5), to provide that a civil partner’s home rights are not brought to an end by the death of the other partner or the termination other than by death of the partnership (this latter application must be made during the subsistence of the partnership). The court is entitled to exercise its powers under section 33(5) in any case where it considers that in all the circumstances it is just and reasonable to do so (s.33(8)). When dealing with applications under section 33, the court must take into account all the circumstances, including the housing needs and housing resources of the partners and any relevant child; their financial resources; the likely effect of an order, or of the court’s deciding not to make an order, on the health, safety or well-being of the partners and of any relevant child; and the partners’ conduct, in relation to each other and otherwise (s.33(6)).
13.7.1
Balance of harm test The court must also apply the balance of harm test set out in section 33(7). If it appears that the applicant or any relevant child is likely to suffer significant harm attributable to conduct of the respondent if a section 33(3) order is not made, the court must make the order unless: • it appears that the respondent or any relevant child is likely to suffer significant harm if the order is made; and • the harm likely to be suffered by the respondent or the child in that event is as great as, or greater than, the harm attributable to conduct of the respondent which is likely to be suffered by the applicant or child if the order is not made. The balance of harm test should be considered by the court before it moves on to the section 33(6) criteria: Chalmers v. Johns [1999] 1 FLR 392.
13.8
One non-entitled former partner: section 35 Where one former partner has rights to occupy a house because of a beneficial estate, interest, contract or enactment and the other partner does not, if the house was ever their civil partnership home or was ever intended to be their partnership home, the non-entitled former partner may apply for orders under section 35. If the court decides to make an order under section 35, it has to make one of the following mandatory orders: If the applicant is in occupation, an order: • giving the applicant the right not to be evicted or excluded from the partnership home or any part of it by the respondent for a specified period, and • prohibiting the respondent from evicting or excluding the applicant from the partnership home during that period (s.35(3)).
80
Domestic violence and occupation of the home
13.9
If the applicant is not in occupation, the court must make an order: • giving the applicant the right to enter into and occupy the home for a specified period, and • requiring the respondent to permit the exercise of that right (s.35(4)). In addition to the mandatory orders, the court may make discretionary orders under s.35(5): • • • •
regulating the occupation of the home by either or both partners, prohibiting, suspending or restricting the respondent’s rights to occupy, requiring the respondent to leave the home or part of it, excluding the respondent from a defined area in which the home is included.
In deciding whether to make a mandatory order, the court will take into account, under section 35(6), the housing needs and resources of the parties and any relevant child; their financial resources; the likely effect of any order, or of any decision not to make an order, on the health, safety or well-being of the partners and any relevant child; the partners’ conduct in relation to each other and otherwise; and the length of time since the partners ceased to live together. These are also the factors to be considered by the court when it is deciding whether to make mandatory orders (s.35(7)). In determining whether or not to make a discretionary order, the court must additionally consider the length of time since the civil partnership was dissolved or annulled and the existence of any proceedings between the parties for a property adjustment order under Schedule 5 to the Act or under Schedule 1 to the Children Act. A balance of harm test will also be applied, but not in identical terms to that set out in section 33. Before section 35(8) applies, the court must first decide to make an order and it should then include section 35(5) discretionary provision if a failure to do so would cause greater harm attributable to conduct of the respondent than doing so.
13.9
One non-entitled cohabitant or former cohabitant: section 36 Where one cohabitant or former cohabitant (see 13.2 for the full definition) has rights to occupy a house because of a beneficial estate, interest, contract or enactment and the other does not, if the house was at any time their civil partnership home or was at any time intended to be, the non-entitled party may apply under section 36. When making an order under section 36, the court must make one of the following mandatory orders: If the applicant is in occupation, an order: • giving the applicant the right not to be evicted or excluded from the home or any part of it by the respondent for a specified period, and 81
13.10
Civil Partnership Act 2004 – a practical guide
• prohibiting the respondent from evicting or excluding the applicant during that period (s.36(3)). If the applicant is not in occupation, an order must be made: • giving the applicant the right to enter into and occupy the home for a specified period, and • requiring the respondent to permit the exercise of that right (s.36(4)). Section 36(5) empowers the court also to make discretionary regulatory orders in identical terms to those which may be made under section 35(5). The criteria for making a mandatory (s.36(4)) order are set out in section 36(6), namely the housing needs and housing resources of each party and of any relevant child; their financial resources; the likely effect of any order, or any decision not to make an order, on the health, safety or well-being of the parties and any relevant child; and the conduct of the parties in relation to each other and otherwise. These are also the criteria to be applied by the court in deciding whether or not to make a discretionary order. In determining whether or not to make a mandatory order, the court must also have regard to the nature of the parties’ relationship and, in particular, the level of commitment involved in it, the length of time during which they have lived together as civil partners, whether there are or have been children who are children of both of them or for whom both have parental responsibility, the length of time that has elapsed since the parties ceased to live together and the existence of any proceedings between the parties for an order under Schedule 1 to the Children Act or relating to the legal estate or beneficial ownership of the house (s.36(6)). A ‘balance of harm test’ (s.36(7) and (8)) applies, but the terms of the test are not identical to those contained in section 33 or 35. No obligation is imposed on the court to make an order; instead the court is simply required by section 36(7)(b) to have regard to the balance of harm questions.
13.10
Neither partner nor former partner entitled to occupy: section 37 Where neither partner nor former partner has the right to occupy a house which is or was their civil partnership home (for example, because they are squatters), either may apply under section 37. The court may make discretionary orders under section 37(3): • • • •
requiring the respondent to permit the applicant to enter and remain, regulating the occupation of the home by either or both parties, requiring the respondent to leave the home or part of it, or excluding the respondent from a defined area in which the home is included.
The section 33(6) criteria apply, as does the ‘balance of harm’ test. 82
Domestic violence and occupation of the home
13.12
An order under section 37 cannot initially last for more then six months, but it may be extended on one or more occasions for a further specified period not exceeding six months (s.37(5)).
13.11
Neither cohabitant nor former cohabitant entitled to occupy: section 38 Where neither cohabitant nor former cohabitant has the right to occupy a house which is or was the home in which they lived together as civil partners, either may apply under section 38. The court may make discretionary orders under section 38(3): • requiring the respondent to permit the applicant to enter and remain in the home, • regulating the occupation of the home by either or both parties, • requiring the respondent to leave the home or part of it, or • excluding the respondent from a defined area in which the home is included. The criteria applicable are identical to those set out in section 33(6), and the balance of harm test set out in section 38(5) again requires the court merely to consider the questions whether the applicant or any relevant child is likely to suffer significant harm attributable to conduct of the applicant if an order containing provision under section 38(3) is not made and whether the harm likely to be suffered by the respondent or child is as great as or greater than the harm attributable to conduct of the respondent which is likely to be suffered by the applicant or the child if the section 38(3) provision is not included, rather than imposing a duty to make an order. An order under section 38 cannot exceed six months but may be extended on one or more occasions for a further specified period not exceeding six months (s.38(6)).
13.12
Additional and supplementary provision On, or after making, an occupation order, section 40 allows the court to impose on either partner obligations relating to the repair or maintenance of the home or the discharge of rent, mortgage repayments or other outgoings. The court may also require the occupying partner to pay periodical payments to an entitled but excluded partner, grant either party possession or use of furniture and order either party to take reasonable care of furniture or other contents or to take reasonable steps to keep the house and any contents secure (s.40). Under section 40(2) the court is obliged, when deciding whether to make a section 40 order, to consider all the circumstances of the case, including the parties’ financial needs, resources and obligations to each other and to any relevant child. 83
13.13
Civil Partnership Act 2004 – a practical guide
13.13
Transfer of tenancies The tenancies which may be the subject of the transfer provisions set out in Schedule 7 to the Family Law Act (known as ‘relevant tenancies’) are protected or statutory tenancies within the meaning of the Rent Act 1977; statutory tenancies under the Rent (Agriculture) Act 1976; secure tenancies under section 79 of the Housing Act 1985; assured tenancies or assured agricultural occupancy under Part I of the Housing Act 1988; and introductory tenancies within the meaning of Chapter 1, Part V of the Housing Act 1996. The court can only make a transfer of tenancy order under Part II of Schedule 7 to the Family Law Act if the dwelling house is or was a civil partnership home. Where one civil partner is entitled (in his or her own right or jointly with the other partner) to occupy the home by virtue of a relevant tenancy, the court may order a transfer at any time when it has the power to make a property adjustment order. Where one cohabitant is entitled to occupy the home and the cohabitants cease to live together as civil partners, the court may make a Part II order. In deciding whether to exercise its discretionary powers and, if so, in what way, the court must take into account all the circumstances of the case, including the circumstances in which the tenancy was granted to one or both partners; the housing needs and housing resources of each partner and any relevant child; the financial resources of the partners; the likely effect of any order, or of a decision not to make an order, on the health, safety or well-being of the parties and of any relevant child; and the suitability of the partners as tenants (paragraph 5 of Schedule 7 to the Family Law Act). In the case of an application by a cohabitant, the court must also consider the nature of the parties’ relationship; the length of time during which they have lived together as civil partners; whether there are or have been any children who are children of both parties or for whom both parties have or have had parental responsibility; and the length of time that has elapsed since the parties ceased to live together.
84
14 Financial consequences on breakdown
14.1
Introduction As at the end of a marriage, the breakdown of a civil partnership will often necessitate a consideration of whether financial arrangements should be made for the benefit of a partner, or children, or both. The other relief that may be required, usually on a more immediate basis, relates to protection from domestic violence and occupation of the home and is the subject of a separate chapter (chapter 13). The various types of financial orders which the court may make under the Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 on the formal termination of a marriage are now available, under Schedule 5 to the Civil Partnership Act, on the breakdown of a civil partnership. Ancillary relief practitioners will immediately recognise the list of factors to be taken into account by the court when deciding how to exercise its powers and the court’s duty to consider whether to dispose finally of the parties’ financial claims by imposing a ‘clean break’. The ability of the court to make financial relief orders if one civil partner has failed to provide reasonable maintenance for the other, or has failed to contribute properly towards reasonable maintenance for a child (corresponding with s.27 of the Matrimonial Causes Act), is also included in Schedule 5. The availability of financial relief orders in the magistrates’ court under the Domestic Proceedings and Magistrates’ Courts Act 1987 is extended to civil partners, who may apply, under Schedule 6 to the Civil Partnership Act, for maintenance and for lump sums of less than £1,000. If a civil partnership is dissolved or annulled or the partners have separated overseas, Schedule 7 allows civil partners to make applications for financial relief to the High Court in this country, provided that the overseas dissolution, annulment or separation is entitled to be recognised as valid. The provisions of Schedule 7 correspond with those of Part III of the Matrimonial and Family Proceedings Act 1984, which empower the High Court to make financial orders here following an overseas divorce. This is the subject of a separate chapter (chapter 15).
85
14.2
Civil Partnership Act 2004 – a practical guide
Finally by way of introduction, Schedule 1 to the Children Act 1989 is amended by section 78 of the Civil Partnership Act. Schedule 1 enables the court to make a range of orders for financial relief for the benefit of children and also entitles a child who is eighteen or over to apply to court in his or her own right for periodical payments or a lump sum order. The amendments add to the extended meaning of ‘parent’ in paragraph 16(2) of Schedule 1 any civil partner in a civil partnership in relation to whom the child concerned is a child of the family, and allow financial orders to be made against a civil partner. Of course, all court powers to make financial orders in respect of children are restricted by the Child Support Act 1991, as to which see 14.30.
14.2
Prenuptials/cohabitation It is likely that pre-nuptial agreements (which might more accurately be referred to as pre-registration agreements in this context) may gain more prominence and enforceability in the realm of civil partnerships than they have so far in divorce. In ancillary proceedings in divorce, pre-nuptial agreements are as a class not specifically enforceable in English law. However, the existence of such an agreement and the weight to be given to it are factors to be taken into account in the discretionary exercise under section 25 of the Matrimonial Causes Act 1973. Precisely the same factors are to be taken into account by the court when determining what if any financial orders should be made by the court on the ending by legal process of the civil partnership. It remains to be seen whether a pre-registration agreement will remain merely one of the factors to be taken into account or, given the fact that contained within the Act is not only the means of creating the relationship, but also the mechanism for ending it in law, and in the majority of cases children will not be a consideration, whether the courts will be prepared to give such agreements more teeth. One of the factors to be taken into account when the court exercises its discretion in relation to financial orders on the ending of the partnership is of course the duration of the relationship. Recent cases in divorce have made plain that in today’s society in certain circumstances a period of cohabitation will count towards this factor. In GW v. GW [2003] 2 FCR 298 Nicholas Mostyn Q.C. (sitting as a deputy High Court judge) held that where a relationship had moved seamlessly from cohabitation to marriage without any major alteration in the way the couple lived, it was unreal and artificial to treat the periods differently. He also held that it was equally unreal to characterise a period of estrangement, where there had been a formal separation, as part of the duration of a marriage. More recently in M v. M (Financial Relief: Substantial earning capacity) [2004] 2 FLR 236 Baron J held that no distinction was to be drawn between the years of cohabitation and marriage in a case where the period of cohabitation was four years followed by a marriage some twelve years in duration. Bearing in mind that many people who decide to enter into a civil partnership will not have had the opportunity to formalise their
86
Financial consequences on breakdown
14.4
relationship in this way before, and may well have been in their relationship for years, the period in which they have lived together may well be of considerable significance. These matters of principle will no doubt be the focus of case law that will as the years go on form the jurisprudence in this new area of law.
14.3
Financial relief on dissolution, nullity or separation The financial relief orders which may be made under Schedule 5 to the Act (introduced by s.72(1)) by the High Court and county courts coincide in nearly every respect with the ancillary relief orders which may already be made in connection with divorce, nullity or judicial separation. Schedule 5 includes the expected and familiar provisions dealing with when orders may take effect, the termination of partners’ financial obligations, pension sharing orders and, equivalent to maintenance pending suit, maintenance pending the outcome of proceedings for the termination of the partnership. The matters to which the court is to have regard when exercising its powers are set out in paragraphs 21 and 22 of Schedule 5, while Part 6 of the Schedule, corresponding with section 25B to D of the Matrimonial Causes Act 1973, deals in detail with pensions. Part 7 relates to Pension Protection Fund compensation and the assumption by the PPF Board of responsibility for administering pension sharing orders in specified circumstances.
14.4
Periodical payments: Part 1 of Schedule 5 Paragraph 2(1)(a) of Schedule 5 allows the court to order either civil partner to make to the other periodical payments for such term as may be specified in the order. It may also require one partner to secure to the other, to the satisfaction of the court, such periodical payments for such term as may be specified (paragraph 2(1)(b)). Periodical payments and secured periodical payments orders may be made in favour of a specified person for the benefit of a child of the family or directly to a child of the family (paragraph 2(1)(d) and (e)), although paragraph 49(1) and (5) contain restrictions on making orders in favour of children who have reached the age of eighteen, dealt with in more detail below. Obviously, as in divorce, a nominal order for periodical payments might be made, keeping open the receiving partner’s rights to apply for substantive payments if circumstances warrant it. Provisions regarding the timing of Part 1 orders are set out in paragraph 1 of Schedule 5. All types of periodical payments order may be made on making a dissolution, nullity or separation order or at any time thereafter. Additionally, paragraph 1(2) allows a periodical payments or secured periodical payments order to or for the benefit of a child to be made before the dissolution, nullity or separation order is actually made and, if proceedings for termination are dismissed, either straightaway or within a reasonable period of the dismissal. 87
14.5
Civil Partnership Act 2004 – a practical guide
The latter corresponds with the court’s power under section 23(2) of the Matrimonial Causes Act. There is no limitation of the number of applications which can be made for income provision.
14.5
Lump sum orders: Part 1 of Schedule 5 The basic lump sum provisions appear in paragraph 2(1). Pursuant to paragraph 2(1)(c), the court may order either partner to pay to the other such lump sum or sums as may be specified. One partner may also be ordered to pay a lump sum to a specified person for the benefit of a child of the family or directly to a child (paragraph 2(1)(f)(i) and (ii)). Paragraph 3 of Schedule 5 contains further provisions about lump sum orders. Paragraph 3(1) permits the court to make a lump sum order for the purpose of enabling a partner to meet any liability or expenses reasonably incurred in maintaining himself or herself or a child of the family before applying for a Part 1 order. Paragraph 3(2) similarly provides that a lump sum order to or for the benefit of a child may be made to meet liabilities or expenses incurred by or for the child before an application is made. Paragraphs 3(1) to (3) are expressly stated not to restrict the court’s powers under paragraph 2 to make lump sum orders. Despite the existence of these provisions, the court does not actually have the power to make interim lump sum orders, as authorities decided under section 23(3) of the Matrimonial Causes Act make clear: see, for example, Wicks v. Wicks [1998] 1 FLR 470. Practical arrangements for the payment of lump sums appear in paragraph 3(3) and 3(5). Payment can be ordered by instalments (paragraph 3(3)(a)), with or without security for the payments (paragraph 3(3)(b)). If payment of all or part of a lump sum is to be deferred or to be made by instalments, provision is made by paragraph 3(5) for outstanding amounts to carry interest. The circumstances in which the court may make lump sum orders are set out in paragraph 1 of Schedule 5. Both types of order may be made on making a dissolution, nullity or separation order or at any time thereafter. Additionally, paragraph 1(2) allows a lump sum order to or for the benefit of a child to be made before the dissolution, nullity or separation order is actually made. The same is true if the proceedings for termination of the partnership are dismissed, either straightaway or within a reasonable period of the dismissal. If a lump sum order is made on or after a dissolution or nullity order, it does not take effect until the dissolution or nullity order has been made final (paragraph 4(1)). Only one lump sum order can be made in favour of a partner, but the power to make lump sum orders in favour of a child is, by virtue of paragraph 1(3), exercisable from time to time. There is ample authority for the proposition that lump sums should not as a general principle be awarded to children, ranging from Lilford v. Glynn [1979] 1 WLR 78 to Tavoulareas v. Tavoulareas [1998] 2 FLR 657. Exceptional circumstances, such as the disability of the child, will be required to justify an order.
88
Financial consequences on breakdown
14.6
14.7
Property adjustment orders: Part 2 of Schedule 5 Paragraph 6 permits the court to make one or more property adjustment orders on making a dissolution, nullity or separation order or at any time thereafter. Property adjustment orders are defined by paragraph 7 as – • an order that one partner should transfer specified property to which he or she is entitled to the other partner, to a child of the family or to a specified person for the benefit of a child (paragraph 7(1)(a)), • an order that one partner should settle specified property for the benefit of the other partner and the children of the family or either or any of them (paragraph 7(1)(b)). Orders can also be made varying, for the benefit of the partners and the children of the family or either or any of them, a relevant settlement, or extinguishing or reducing either partner’s interest under a settlement. Cases decided under section 24 of the Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 have established that ‘property’ includes a council tenancy (Newlon Housing Trust v. Alsulaimen [1998] 2 FLR 690) and a contractual, weekly tenancy (Hale v. Hale [1975] 1 WLR 931). A ‘relevant settlement’ means a settlement made, during the partnership or in anticipation of its formation, on the civil partners (paragraph 7(3)). The definition includes a settlement made by will or codicil but excludes one in the form of a pension arrangement. If a property adjustment order is made, it will not take effect until the dissolution or nullity order is made final (paragraph 8(1)). In common with section 24 of the Matrimonial Causes Act 1973, nothing in paragraph 7 precludes a second application being made under a different sub-paragraph, provided that any earlier order was not intended to be a full and final settlement. If the earlier order related only to one property, a subsequent application in respect of a second property may be made: Dinch v. Dinch [1987] 2 FLR 162.
14.7
Sale of property orders: Part 3 of Schedule 5 The court can make a sale of property order when it makes a secured periodical payments order or a lump sum order under Part 1, or when it makes a property adjustment order under Part 2, or at any time afterwards (paragraph 10(1)). A sale of property order is defined by paragraph 11(1) as an order for the sale of specified property in which (or in the proceeds of sale of which) either or both civil partners have an interest. The interest may be either in possession or reversion. Paragraph 11 corresponds with the provisions of section 24A of the Matrimonial Causes Act 1973. A sale of property order may include any consequential or supplementary provisions the court thinks fit (paragraph 11(2)), including a requirement that a payment should be made out of the proceeds of sale or that 89
14.8
Civil Partnership Act 2004 – a practical guide
property should be offered for sale to a specified person or class of persons (paragraph 11(3)). In order to protect third parties, paragraph 14 provides that any person who is not a civil partner, but who has a beneficial interest in the relevant property or in its sale proceeds, must be given an opportunity to make representations to the court about any proposed sale of property order and the court will take such representations into account under paragraph 20. Paragraph 12(1) provides that a sale of property order will not take effect unless the dissolution or nullity order has been made final. The order may contain a direction that the order, or a specified provision contained in it, should not take effect until a specified event occurs, or at the expiry of a specified period (paragraph 12(2)). If a sale of property order provides for the sale proceeds of a property to be used to secure periodical payments to a partner, the order will cease to have effect on the partner’s death or in the event that he or she forms a subsequent partnership or marriage (paragraph 13).
14.8
Pension sharing orders: Part 4 of Schedule 5 The provisions for pension sharing are, again, virtually identical to those available on divorce. Paragraph 15 (corresponding broadly with s.21A and s.24B of the Matrimonial Causes Act) allows the court to make a pension sharing order on making a dissolution or nullity order or at any time thereafter. This power is not available in the case of separation proceedings. A number of married couples prefer to commence judicial separation proceedings rather than file a divorce petition because, in the absence of a decree absolute, they remain married for the purpose of benefits from each other’s pensions. This fact may influence a civil partner to seek a separation order rather than the dissolution of the partnership. A pension sharing order is defined by paragraph 16(1) as an order which provides that one civil partner’s shareable rights under a specified pension arrangement (see below) or that partner’s shareable state scheme rights (see below) are to be subject to pension sharing for the benefit of the other partner. Such an order must specify the percentage value to be transferred (paragraph 16(1)(b)).
14.8.1
Pension arrangement ‘Pension arrangement’ is defined by paragraph 16(4) and includes an occupational pension scheme, a personal pension scheme, a retirement annuity contract, an annuity or insurance policy purchased or transferred for the purpose of giving effect to rights under an occupational or personal pension scheme and an annuity purchased or entered into to discharge liability in respect of a pension credit under section 29(1)(b) of the Welfare Reform and Pensions Act 1999.
14.8.2
Shareable state scheme rights ‘Shareable state scheme rights’ are defined by paragraph 16(3) as rights in relation to which pension sharing is available under Chapter 2 of Part 4 of the
90
Financial consequences on breakdown
14.9
Welfare Reform and Pensions Act 1999. Those were originally defined by the 1999 Act as the earnings related additional pension (SERPS) but are now the Additional State Pension (ASP) and any rights derived from an ASP pension sharing order made in previous proceedings.
14.8.3
Pension sharing orders: charges Charges for pension sharing may be apportioned between the partners by any court order (see paragraph 17).
14.8.4
Restrictions on making pension sharing orders No order can be made in respect of a pension arrangement which is already or has been the subject of a pension sharing order in relation to the civil partnership, or in respect of shareable state scheme rights that have already been shared between the partners (paragraph 18). An order will not take effect until the dissolution or nullity order has been made final (paragraph 19(1)).
14.9
Factors to be taken into account by the court: Part 5 Paragraph 20 requires the court, in deciding whether to exercise its powers and if so, in what way, to have regard to all the circumstances of the case. Its first consideration must be the welfare while a minor of any child of the family who has not yet attained the age of eighteen. In exercising its powers in favour of a partner to make orders under Part 1, 2, 3 or 4, the court must then have regard to: • the income, earning capacity, property and other financial resources which each partner has or is likely to have in the foreseeable future (in common with section 25(2) of the Matrimonial Causes Act, in the case of earning capacity, the court must consider any increase in that capacity which the court thinks it reasonable to expect a partner to take steps to acquire), • the financial needs, obligations and responsibilities of each partner, now and in the foreseeable future, • the standard of living enjoyed by the family before the breakdown of the civil partnership, • the age of each partner and the duration of the civil partnership, • any physical or mental disability of either partner, • the contributions which each partner has made or is likely in the foreseeable future to make to the welfare of the family, including any contribution by looking after the home or caring for the family, • the conduct of each partner if that conduct is such that it would in the opinion of the court be inequitable to disregard it, and 91
14.10
Civil Partnership Act 2004 – a practical guide
• in proceedings for a dissolution or nullity order, the value to each partner of any benefit which, because of the dissolution or annulment, that partner will lose the chance of acquiring (paragraph 21(2)(a –h)). Following the decision of the House of Lords in White v. White [2001] AC 596, it appears that the implicit objective of section 25 of the Matrimonial Causes Act is to achieve a fair outcome. The propositions advanced by Lord Nicholls have just as much relevance to civil partners as to spouses. There can be no discrimination between the parties in their respective roles, so no bias in favour of the money earner and against the child-carer and home-maker. While there is no presumption of equality, fairness generally implies an equal division and any judge should arrive at his tentative view after carrying out the section 25 exercise and then check that view against the ‘yardstick of equality’. In White, where assets exceeded the financial needs of both parties, the wife’s claims were not limited to her ‘reasonable requirements’, as had previously been the practice in cases involving substantial wealth. It was also accepted that the wish of one party to leave property to the next generation is a relevant consideration under section 25.
14.10
Children: factors to be taken into account Paragraph 22(2) requires the court, when making orders in relation to a child of the family under paragraphs 1, 2 or 3, to have regard to: • the financial needs of the child, • the child’s income, earning capacity (if any), property and other financial resources, • any physical or mental disability of the child, and • the way in which the child was being, and in which the civil partners expected the child to be, educated or trained. The court is also obliged to consider the partners’ income, earning capacity, property and other financial resources, now and in the foreseeable future; their financial needs, obligations and responsibilities, now and in the foreseeable future; the standard of living enjoyed before the breakdown of the civil partnership; and any mental or physical disability of either partner (paragraph 22(2)(e)). If an order is made against a civil partner in respect of a child of the family who is not that partner’s child, paragraph 22(3) requires the court to consider whether the partner has assumed any responsibility for the child’s maintenance; the extent to which, and the basis on which, he assumed such responsibility and for how long; whether he did so knowing the child was not his; and the liability of any other person to maintain the child.
92
Financial consequences on breakdown
14.11
14.12
The termination of financial obligations If the court does decide to make financial orders under Part 1, 2, 3 or 4 in favour of one partner, in pursuit of the ‘clean break’ objective it must consider whether it would be appropriate so to exercise its powers that the financial obligations of each partner toward the other are terminated as soon after the making of the dissolution or nullity order as the court considers just and reasonable (paragraph 23(2)). This paragraph is the equivalent of section 25A(1) of the Matrimonial Causes Act. The court’s duty does not arise in the case of proceedings for separation.
14.11.1
Term orders If the court makes a periodical payments order or a secured periodical payments order in favour of a civil partner, it must consider whether it would be appropriate to require payments to be made or secured only for such term as would in the opinion of the court be sufficient to enable the recipient to adjust without undue financial hardship to the termination of his or her financial dependence on the other partner (paragraph 23(3), reflecting s.25A(2) of the Matrimonial Causes Act).
14.11.2
Clean break Paragraph 23(4) allows the court, if it considers that no continuing obligation should be imposed on either partner to make income provision for the other, to dismiss an application for income provision and to direct that the applicant is not entitled to make any further application in relation to that civil partnership for a periodical payments or secured periodical payments order. This corresponds with section 25A(3) of the Matrimonial Causes Act.
14.11.3
Principles to be applied in maintenance cases It has been emphasised by the Court of Appeal that the equivalent Matrimonial Causes Act provision gives the court a discretion; there is no presumption in favour of a dismissal: Barrett v. Barrett [1988] 2 FLR 516. The court has, in applying section 25A, been reluctant to cut off maintenance for a wife with dependent children, and the same is true in the case of a spouse who has not worked for many years before the breakdown of the marriage (in M v. M (Financial Provision) [1987] 2 FLR, the idea of a term order for a wife of forty-seven was rejected).
14.12
Pension benefits: Part 6: pension attachment (formerly earmarking) orders Part 6 of the Act makes it clear both that the financial resources to which the court is to have regard under paragraph 21 on an application for financial relief 93
14.13
Civil Partnership Act 2004 – a practical guide
include pension benefits under a pension arrangement or by way of a pension which a civil partner has or is likely to have, and that loss of benefits under paragraph 21 includes any pension benefit which, because of the dissolution or nullity order, a civil partner will lose the chance of acquiring (paragraph 24). If pension benefits are taken into account when the court decides to make a Part 1 order, the provisions of paragraphs 25 to 27 apply. The person responsible for one partner’s pension arrangement may be ordered to make a payment for the benefit of the other partner (paragraph 25(2)). So, a financial provision order takes effect against all forms of members’ benefits under the scheme (income and lump sum). The pension attachment order must specify the amount to be paid as a percentage of the payment due to the partner with pension rights. The partner with pension rights may, by virtue of paragraph 25(5), be ordered to exercise rights of commutation. No pension attachment order may be made in respect of a pension arrangement which is already subject to pension sharing (paragraph 25(8)). Paragraph 26 deals with lump sums payable in the event of the death of a partner who has pension rights. If the person responsible for the pension arrangement has the power to determine who should receive a lump sum on the death of the partner with pension rights, the court may order that person to pay all or part of the death benefits to the other partner (paragraph 26(3)). If the partner with pension rights has the power to nominate the recipient of all or part of his or her death benefits, the court may, pursuant to paragraph 26(4), require that partner to nominate the other partner to receive the whole or part of the benefit. It is worth noting that Pension Protection Fund compensation to which a partner is or is likely to be entitled will be treated as a financial resource under paragraph 21 (without the words ‘in the foreseeable future’). Part 7 of Schedule 5 sets out practical arrangements affecting pension sharing orders where the Pension Protection Fund Compensation Board has assumed responsibility for an occupational pension scheme. Pension attachment orders (formerly earmarking orders) under the Matrimonial Causes Act have been unpopular and rarely used, not least because they are susceptible to subsequent variation and continue as a link between the parties. In contrast, pension sharing orders mean the recipient becomes a member of the pension scheme in his or her own right and they permit a clean break to be implemented.
14.13
Maintenance pending outcome of proceedings: Part 8 As in the case of maintenance pending suit in divorce, once an application for a dissolution or nullity order has been made paragraph 38 allows the court to order either partner to pay periodical payments for such term as the court thinks reasonable. The term cannot begin earlier than the date on which the application was made and it will end on the date on which the proceedings are determined (paragraph 38(a) and (b)).
94
Financial consequences on breakdown
14.14
In the context of protracted proceedings, it is worth remembering, too, the power of the court to include in such orders a financial element to discharge ongoing legal costs (see, for example, A v. A (Maintenance Pending Suit: Provision for Legal Fees) [2001] 1 FLR 377).
14.14
Failure to maintain: Part 9 orders If a civil partner has failed to provide reasonable maintenance for the other partner, or has failed to provide, or to make a reasonable contribution to, reasonable maintenance for any child of the family, the court may make an order under Part 9 of the Act (corresponding with s.27 of the Matrimonial Causes Act).
14.14.1
Jurisdiction An application will not be entertained by the court unless one party is domiciled in England and Wales on the date of the application, or the applicant partner has been habitually resident here throughout the period of one year ending with that date, or the respondent partner was resident in England and Wales on that date (paragraph 39(2)).
14.14.2 Interim orders An interim order can be made by the court, defined by paragraph 40 as an order requiring the respondent partner to make to the applicant, until the application is determined, such periodical payments as the court thinks reasonable.
14.14.3 Final orders Once a failure to maintain has been established, the court may make one or more of the orders set out in paragraph 41, namely an order for periodical payments, secured payments or a lump sum to be paid to the applicant, or to a specified person for the benefit of the child to whom the application relates, or directly to the child. As in the case of financial relief orders upon dissolution, a lump sum order may be made to meet liabilities or expenses reasonably incurred before an application is made in maintaining the applicant partner or a child of the family (paragraph 42). Payment of lump sum orders may be ordered to be made by instalments and the court may order security to be provided for the payment of the instalments (paragraph 42(2)).
14.14.4 Factors to be taken into account In the case of an application by a partner, paragraph 43 requires the court, when deciding whether the respondent has failed to provide reasonable maintenance and what, if any, order to make, to take into account all the circumstances of the case, including the paragraph 21(2) matters. Where an application is made in 95
14.16
Civil Partnership Act 2004 – a practical guide
respect of maintenance for a child, paragraph 44 requires that the factors to be taken into account by the court are the matters mentioned in paragraph 22(2)(a) to (e): see 14.10. As usual, if an application is also made under paragraph 39 in respect of a child who is not yet eighteen, the court will give first consideration to the welfare while under eighteen of that child (paragraph 43(3)).
14.15
Commencement and duration of orders: partners Applications for a Part 1 order, a property adjustment order or for maintenance pending the outcome of proceedings may be begun at any time after the presentation of the application for dissolution, nullity or separation (paragraph 46(2)). Rules of court will provide for an application for financial relief to be made in the application for dissolution etc. or the response thereto, otherwise only with the leave of the court (paragraph 46(3)). The term of a periodical payments order in favour of a civil partner will be such term as the court thinks fit (paragraph 47(1)), but, in common with periodical payments orders on divorce, the term must not extend beyond the death of either partner (in the case of secured periodical payments, the death of the recipient partner) or the formation of a subsequent civil partnership or marriage by the partner in whose favour the order is made (paragraph 47(2) and (3)). A direction may be made by the court that a partner is not entitled to apply for the extension of any term specified in the order (paragraph 47(5), which is in terms identical to those contained in section 28(1A) of the Matrimonial Causes Act 1973). The cases concerning the imposition of a section 28(1A) bar will obviously be relevant. It will rarely be appropriate where there are young children (Mawson v. Mawson [1994] 2 FLR 895). If a periodical payments or secured periodical payments order is made otherwise than on or after the making of a dissolution, nullity or separation order, but the partnership is subsequently dissolved or annulled, the order will, by virtue of paragraph 47(6), come to an end if the recipient partner forms a subsequent partnership or marriage.
14.16
Duration of orders: children Generally, no Part 1 order, order requiring the transfer of property or order based on a failure to maintain can be made in favour of a child who is already eighteen or older (paragraph 49(1)). The term of a periodical payments or secured periodical payments order cannot in the first instance extend beyond the date of the child’s birthday immediately after the upper limit of compulsory school age (i.e. the child’s seventeenth birthday) unless the welfare of the child requires the court to extend the term further, and must not in any event extend beyond the child’s eighteenth birthday (paragraph 49(3)). However, paragraph 49(5) provides that those restrictions do not apply if a child is, or will be if an order
96
Financial consequences on breakdown
14.18
is made, being instructed at an educational establishment or being trained for a trade, profession or vocation, or there are special circumstances justifying the making of an order (for example, if a child has a disability affecting his or her capacity to live independently).
14.17
Variation of orders: Part 11 Paragraph 51 of Schedule 5 to the Act (compare s.31 of the Matrimonial Causes Act) permits the court to vary, discharge, suspend, or revive the operation of any suspended provision of, certain orders. The orders are listed in paragraph 50(1) and are for income provision (both interim and final), a lump sum order insofar as it relates to instalment provisions, a deferred lump sum, an order for settlement or variation of settlement, a sale of property order and a pension sharing order made before the final dissolution order. The court is also empowered by paragraph 52 to remit arrears arising under income provision orders.
14.18
Additional powers on discharge or variation of periodical payments If an existing periodical payments order in favour of a civil partner is discharged, or varied so that payments are required only for a term, paragraph 53 enables the court to make supplemental provision by way of lump sum, property adjustment and pension sharing orders in favour of the receiving partner. This is similar to section 31(7A-7G) of the Matrimonial Causes Act. In Pearce v. Pearce [2003] EWCA Civ 1054, Thorpe LJ held that the function of the court was not to give the wife a second bite of the cherry so far as an award of capital was concerned. He considered that the court should decide what variation to make to the maintenance, decide when the variation should commence and apply a Duxbury calculation to arrive at the appropriate lump sum to capitalise the claim. Periodical payments in favour of a child in the case of failure to maintain may be varied on the application of the child himself once he has attained the age of sixteen. If such an order ceases when the child reaches sixteen or at any time before he or she is eighteen, the court may revive the order if the child is attending an educational establishment or undergoing training for a trade or profession (paragraph 55). In considering a variation application, the court must give first consideration to the welfare while a minor of any child who has not attained the age of eighteen and then take into account any change in the matters it had to take into account when making the order (paragraph 59). In the case of a periodical payments or secured periodical payments order, the court must consider whether payments should be made or secured only for such period as would in the opinion of the court be sufficient to enable the party in whose favour the order was made to adjust without undue financial hardship to the termination of the payments (paragraph 59(4)). 97
14.21
Civil Partnership Act 2004 – a practical guide
14.19
Arrears and repayments: Part 12 No maintenance arrears more than twelve months old can be enforced without the leave of the court (paragraph 63). Any such leave may have conditions attached to it. In Bernstein v. O’Neill [1989] 2 FLR 1, Ewbank J suggested that the general rule about the enforceability of arrears implies that earlier arrears should be remitted. If the circumstances of a recipient of income provision or the paying partner have changed since the order was made, and the recipient has received more than the payer should have been required to pay, the court may, under paragraph 64, order repayment of all or part of the excess sum. Payments may also be recovered if they continue after the recipient has entered into a subsequent civil partnership (paragraph 65).
14.20
Consent orders and maintenance agreements: Part 13 The court may approve a consent order on the basis only of such information supplied to it as is required by rules of court, unless it has reason to think that there are other circumstances into which it ought to inquire (paragraph 66(1)). The prescribed information will probably be that which is required in the case of consent orders under section 33A of the Matrimonial Causes Act by Family Proceedings Rules 1991, r 2.61. A maintenance agreement is defined by paragraph 67 as an agreement in writing between the partners in a civil partnership which falls into one of two categories, either made during the partnership or after its dissolution or annulment and containing financial arrangements, or a separation agreement containing no financial arrangements but made where there is no written agreement between the partners containing financial arrangements. A subsisting maintenance agreement may be altered by the court, pursuant to paragraph 69, if it is satisfied that because of a change in circumstances different financial arrangements should be made or that the agreement does not contain proper financial provision for any child of the family. If an agreement contains a provision which purports to restrict any rights to apply to the court for an order containing financial arrangements (defined by paragraph 67(2) as provisions governing the rights and liabilities towards one another when living separately of the civil partners in respect of payments or the disposition or use of property), that provision is, by virtue of paragraph 68, void.
14.21
Avoidance of transactions Paragraph 74 of Schedule 5 extends to civil partners the financial protection given to married persons under section 37 of the Matrimonial Causes Act in three particular situations. So, if one partner has brought proceedings for financial
98
Financial consequences on breakdown
14.22
relief, the court can under paragraph 74(2) restrain the other partner from making any disposition, or transferring out of the jurisdiction or otherwise dealing with any property, if the court is satisfied that the other partner is, with the intention of defeating the first partner’s financial relief claims, about to do so. If the court is satisfied that one partner has already, with the intention of defeating the other’s claims for financial relief, made a reviewable disposition and, if the disposition were set aside, financial relief or different financial relief would be awarded, paragraph 74(3) empowers the court to set aside the disposition. Thirdly, under paragraph 74(4), where a partner has already obtained a financial relief order against the other and the court is satisfied that the second partner has, with the intention of defeating the first partner’s claims for financial relief, made a reviewable disposition, it may set aside the disposition. Paragraph 75 explains the reference to defeating a claim for financial relief. It includes preventing financial relief from being granted, reducing the amount of financial relief otherwise available and frustrating or impeding the enforcement of any order.
14.21.1 Reviewable disposition Any disposition is a reviewable disposition unless it was made for valuable consideration and to a person who acted in good faith and without notice of any intention to defeat the financial relief claim (paragraph 75(3)). If the disposition took place less than three years before the financial relief application, or is about to take place, and the court is satisfied that the disposition would have the consequence of defeating the financial claim or that it has had that effect, the paragraph 74(4) presumption applies so that, unless the contrary is shown, it is presumed that the person carried out such actions with the intention of defeating the claim for financial relief. Although ‘property’ is not defined for the purpose of the paragraph, in Hamlin v. Hamlin [1986] 1 FLR 61, it was held that section 37 of the Matrimonial Causes Act included real and personal property situated abroad.
14.22
Financial relief in the magistrates’ court: grounds of application under Schedule 6, Part 1 Under Schedule 6 to the Act, the court may make financial orders if satisfied that the other civil partner has failed to provide reasonable maintenance for the applicant, has failed to provide or make a proper contribution towards reasonable maintenance for any child of the family, has behaved in such a way that the applicant cannot reasonably be expected to live with the respondent, or has deserted the applicant (paragraph 1(a) to (d)). These grounds reflect those contained in section 1 of the Domestic Proceedings and Magistrates’ Courts Act 1980. 99
14.23
Civil Partnership Act 2004 – a practical guide
14.23
Magistrates’ courts: the orders available Paragraph 2 of Schedule 6 enables the magistrates’ court to make periodical payments, secured periodical payments and lump sum orders to the applicant or to the applicant for the benefit of a child of the family or to the child himself. Lump sums awarded by the magistrates’ court cannot, however, exceed £1,000. In common with Part 1 of Schedule 5, a lump sum may be made to meet any liability or expenses reasonably incurred in maintaining the applicant or a child of the family before an order is made (paragraph 3(1)).
14.23.1 Matters to be taken into account: civil partners The first consideration is the welfare while a minor of any child of the family who has not yet attained the age of eighteen (paragraph 4). Otherwise, matters to be taken into account under paragraph 5(2) are those already familiar to practitioners from section 25(2) of the Matrimonial Causes Act and section 3 of the Domestic Proceedings and Magistrates’ Courts Act, namely: • the income, earning capacity, property and other financial resources which each partner has or is likely in the foreseeable future to have (including any increase in earning capacity which it would be reasonable to expect a partner to take steps to acquire), • the financial needs, obligations and responsibilities of each partner, now and in the foreseeable future, • the standard of living enjoyed by the partners before the occurrence of the conduct alleged as the ground of the application, • the age of each partner and the duration of the partnership, • any physical or mental disability of either partner, • the contributions which each partner has made or is likely in the foreseeable future to make to the welfare of the family, including any contribution by looking after the home or caring for the family, • the conduct of each partner if that conduct is such that it would in the opinion of the court be inequitable to disregard it. It will be noted that loss of benefits is not included in the list because the magistrates’ court does not have power to make pension orders of any description.
14.23.2 Matters to be taken into account: children In the case of children, pursuant to paragraph 6 the court must also consider the child’s financial needs, his income, earning capacity, property and other financial resources, any physical or mental disability, the standard of living enjoyed by the family before the occurrence of the conduct which occasioned the application and, finally, the way in which the child was being, and the civil partners expected the child to be, educated or trained. 100
Financial consequences on breakdown
14.25
14.23.3 Conciliation If an application is made to court for a Part 1 order, the court must, before deciding whether to exercise its powers, consider whether there is any possibility of reconciliation between the partners (paragraph 7). If there is at any stage of proceedings a reasonable possibility of such a reconciliation, paragraph 7(1)(b) allows the court to adjourn the proceedings for such period as it thinks fit.
14.23.4 Refusal by magistrates’ court to make an order The court may, under paragraph 8, refuse to make an order if it considers that any of the matters in issue between the partners would be more conveniently dealt with in the High Court. Although there is no appeal from such a decision, if the High Court subsequently conducts proceedings relating to the same matter, it may, under paragraph 8(3), order the application to be reheard and determined by the magistrates’ court.
14.24
Agreed orders: Part 2 of Schedule 6 Applications for agreed orders may be granted pursuant to paragraph 9 if the court is satisfied that the applicant or the respondent has agreed to make the financial provision specified in the order and the court has no reason to think it would be contrary to the interests of justice to make the order. Agreement between the partners cannot confer power on the court to make property adjustment orders, sale of property orders or pension sharing orders. The list of orders in paragraph 10 is confined to income provision and lump sum orders. If the respondent is not present or represented, no order can be made unless evidence is produced to the court of his or her consent to the order and of his or her financial resources (paragraph 11). Where the agreement includes financial provision for children, paragraph 12 forbids the court from making the agreed order unless it is satisfied that the proposed order provides for or makes a reasonable contribution to the financial needs of the child. The court does have the power to make alternative orders if it decides it would be contrary to justice to make the order sought or that agreed financial provision in respect of a child is insufficient (paragraph 13), but only if the partners agree that the alternative order should be made.
14.25
Orders where partners are living apart by agreement: Part 3 of Schedule 6 Part 3 of Schedule 6 (see the equivalent in s.7 of the Domestic Proceedings and Magistrates’ Courts Act) allows the court, if civil partners have been living apart for a continuous period exceeding three months, and one partner has been paying periodical payments for the benefit of the other or a child of the family, to order that the respondent should pay periodical payments to the applicant, 101
14.27
Civil Partnership Act 2004 – a practical guide
or to the applicant for the benefit of a child or to the child, for such term or terms as may be specified (paragraph 16). The total amount the respondent is required to pay cannot during any period of three months exceed that which he or she has paid during the three months immediately preceding the application (paragraph 17). The matters to be taken into account on such an application are those set out in paragraphs 5 and 6, except that the standard of living enjoyed by the partners is taken into account until they started to live apart (substituted by paragraph 19 for the occurrence of the conduct which is the ground of the application).
14.26
Interim orders: Part 4 of Schedule 6 Paragraph 20 allows the magistrates’ court at any time before making a final order to make an interim order. Paragraph 21 defines an interim order as an order requiring the respondent to make such periodical payments as the court thinks reasonable to the applicant or to or for the benefit of a child of the family who is not yet eighteen. An interim order cannot start before the date of the application (paragraph 22) and it ceases to have effect on the date specified in the interim order, on the expiry of three months from the making of the order or when the court makes a final order, whichever event occurs earliest (paragraph 24(1)). Save in the case of a final order having been made, the court may, under paragraph 24(2), order the interim order to continue in force for a further period.
14.27
Commencement and duration of orders: Part 5 of Schedule 6 A periodical payments order cannot begin before the date of the making of the application for an order, and the term of a periodical payments order must not extend beyond the death of either partner (paragraph 26(1)). The order will cease to have effect on the formation of a subsequent civil partnership or marriage by the civil partner to whom the payments are made (paragraph 26). Orders in favour of children must not extend in the first instance beyond their seventeenth birthday and in any event beyond their eighteenth, unless they are or would be still at school or college or being trained for a vocation or profession (paragraph 27(3)).
14.27.1 Resumption of cohabitation Periodical payments to a partner will cease if the partners resume cohabitation for a continuous period exceeding six months (paragraph 29).
14.27.2 Variation: Part 6 of Schedule 6 The magistrates’ court may vary, revoke, suspend all or part of an order and revive any provision it has suspended (paragraph 30). It has power under 102
Financial consequences on breakdown
14.29
paragraph 31 to award a lump sum on variation of a periodical payments order (but it will be recalled that lump sums are limited to £1,000). Paragraph 34 sets out the factors to be taken into account by the court when exercising its powers to vary. As usual, the first consideration is the welfare while a minor of any child who has not attained the age of eighteen. The court must then consider any change in any of the matters it was originally required to take into account when making the order (paragraph 34).
14.28
Arrears and repayment: Part 7 of Schedule 6 An order for the payment of money made by the magistrates’ court under Schedule 6 is enforceable as a magistrates’ court maintenance order (s.32 of the Domestic Proceedings and Magistrates’ Courts Act, as applied by paragraph 43). Section 32(4) of the Act provides that a person cannot enforce through the High Court or county court the payment of arrears due under a magistrates’ court order without the leave of the court if arrears are more than twelve months old. Sums overpaid after the cessation of an order because of the formation of a subsequent civil partnership or marriage may be ordered to be repaid (paragraph 44), either fully or in part. Under paragraph 44(5), repayment may be directed to be made by instalments.
14.29
Financial provision for children: Schedule 1 to the Children Act Section 78 of the Act amends Schedule 1 to the Children Act. The extended meaning of ‘parent’ in section 16(2) is amended to include any civil partner in a civil partnership (whether or not it subsists) in relation to whom the child is a child of the family. In the case of an application by a parent or a guardian of a child to the High Court or a county court, paragraph 1(1) and (2) of Schedule 1 allows the court to make a periodical payments order, a secured periodical payments order, a lump sum order, a settlement of property order or a property transfer order, in each case directly to the child or to the applicant for the benefit of the child. The magistrates’ court is restricted to making periodical payments, secured periodical payments, together with lump sum orders not exceeding £1,000 (paragraph 1(1)(b)). The court is entitled to make a financial order under Schedule 1 without any application being made if it is making, varying or discharging a residence order (paragraph 1(6)). The powers under paragraph 1 can be exercised at any time. Orders for financial relief can only last until a child is eighteen, but paragraph 3 allows payments to continue if a child remains in education or is undergoing training. Paragraph 2 also enables an adult child in those circumstances to make an application in his or her own right for orders requiring either or both parents to pay periodical payments or a lump sum. 103
14.30
Civil Partnership Act 2004 – a practical guide
The matters to be taken into account by the court are listed in paragraph 4 and include the income, earning capacity, property and other financial resources each person mentioned in paragraph 4(4) has or is likely to have in the foreseeable future; their financial needs, obligations and responsibilities, now and in the foreseeable future; the financial needs of the child; the income, earning capacity (if any), property and other financial resources of the child, any physical or mental disability of the child and the manner in which the child was being, or was expected to be, trained. The persons mentioned in paragraph 4(4) are in a paragraph 1 application any parent of the child, and in a paragraph 2 application the mother and father of the child, the applicant for the order and any other person in whose favour the court proposes to make the order. The court will, in exercising its powers under paragraph 1 against a person who is not the mother or father of the child, have regard also to the extent to which that person assumed responsibility for the child and for how long, whether he did so knowing the child was not his and the liability of any other person to maintain the child. Lump sums can be ordered under paragraph 5(1) to meet expenses reasonably incurred before the making of the order in connection with the birth of the child or in maintaining the child. They may be ordered to be paid by instalments (paragraph 5(5)). The provisions for the variation of orders appear in paragraph 6. The court is obliged to consider all the circumstances of the case, including any change in any of the matters which it originally took into account. Paragraph 6(4) enables an application to vary to be made by the child if he or she has reached the age of sixteen. The court is permitted to suspend any provision of an order and to revive any suspended order. Interim orders may be made under paragraph 9.
14.30
Financial provision for children: the Child Support Act Section 8 of the Child Support Act 1991 limits the role of the courts with respect to maintenance for children in any case where jurisdiction exists for a maintenance calculation to be made by the CSA. Except in limited circumstances, no court is permitted to exercise any power it would otherwise have to make, vary or revive a maintenance order in respect of a child. The exceptions are where there is a written agreement between parents or there is an application for a ‘top up’ order (on the ground that there has been a maintenance calculation but the absent parent’s net income exceeds the upper limit for net income – currently £2,000 a week), or payments are sought to meet school fees or other expenses incurred by a child’s receiving training or expenses attributable to a child’s disability. By virtue of paragraph 49(7) of Schedule 5, paragraph 62 of Schedule 5 and paragraph 27 of Schedule 6, where a maintenance calculation within the meaning of section 54 of the Child Support Act 1991 is in force with respect
104
Financial consequences on breakdown
14.30
to a child, and an application is made for a periodical payments or secured periodical payments order in accordance with section 8 of the Child Support Act, and the application is made before the end of six months beginning with the date of the current maintenance calculation, the term of the periodical payments order may be backdated to whichever is the later of the date six months before the application is made or the date on which the current calculation took effect.
105
15 Financial relief in England and Wales after an overseas dissolution
15.1
Introduction An application may be made here for financial relief where a civil partnership has been dissolved or annulled, or the civil partners have been legally separated, by judicial or other proceedings in an overseas country and the dissolution, annulment or legal separation is entitled to be recognised in England and Wales (Schedule 7, paragraph 1(1)). The provisions of Schedule 7 correspond to a great extent with Part III of the Matrimonial and Family Proceedings Act 1984.
15.2
Overseas country Overseas country is defined by paragraph 1(3) as a country or territory outside the British Islands.
15.3
The applicant Either partner may apply, provided the leave of the court has been obtained to do so (see below) and he or she has not, following the dissolution or annulment of the partnership, formed a subsequent civil partnership or marriage (paragraph 2).
15.4
Leave of the court The permission of the court is required for an application and it will not be granted unless the court considers there is ‘substantial ground’ for the application (paragraph 4(2)). The existence of an order for financial relief made by an overseas court does not prevent leave being granted and paragraph 4(4) enables leave to be given subject to such conditions as the court thinks fit. On an application for leave under the Matrimonial and Family Proceedings Act, the court will have regard to the factors set out in section 16 of that Act, and several reported cases give helpful examples of the court’s exercising its discretion in this regard: see, for example, N v. N (Foreign Divorce: Financial
106
Financial relief after overseas dissolution
15.7
Relief) [1997] 1 FLR 900 and Jordan v. Jordan [1999] 2 FLR 1069. It might, therefore, have been expected that the factors set out in paragraph 8(2) would be taken into account on an application under paragraph 4 for leave, but somewhat surprisingly, paragraph 6 states that paragraphs 7 (jurisdiction of the court) and 8 (duty of the court to consider whether England and Wales is the appropriate venue for the application) apply where one partner has been granted leave under paragraph 4 and, acting on that leave, applies for a financial order.
15.5
Interim maintenance orders: Schedule 7 Where leave to apply has been granted, if the court considers the applicant, or any child of the family, is in immediate need of financial assistance, an interim maintenance order may be made under paragraph 5. This order is not, however, available if the only jurisdictional requirement satisfied by the applicant (see below) is the fact that either or both partners had, when the application for permission was made, a beneficial interest in possession in a house in England and Wales which was at some time their civil partnership home (paragraph 5(4)).
15.6
Jurisdictional requirements: Schedule 7 The applicant must satisfy the court of one or more of the three following jurisdictional requirements, set out in paragraph 7, before it will entertain an application: • either partner was domiciled in England and Wales on the date leave was applied for or on the date when the overseas dissolution, annulment or separation took place, • either partner was habitually resident in England and Wales for one year ending with the date when the leave was applied for, or was habitually resident for one year ending with the date on which the dissolution took effect in the overseas country, • at the date of the application for leave, either partner had a beneficial interest in possession in a house in England and Wales which was at some time the partners’ civil partnership home. Even if a jurisdictional requirement under paragraph 7 is satisfied, the court is still obliged by paragraph 8(1) to consider whether in all the circumstances of the case it would be appropriate for a court in England and Wales to make an order of the kind applied for.
15.7
Matters to be taken into account in considering whether England is the appropriate venue for application The court will take into account all the matters set out in paragraph 8(3), namely the partners’ connection with England, the partners’ connection with the country 107
15.10
Civil Partnership Act 2004 – a practical guide
in which the partnership was ended, the partners’ connection with any other country outside England and Wales and any financial benefit which the applicant or a child of the family is likely to receive by virtue of an agreement or the operation of the law of any other country. Where a financial order has been made by an overseas country, the court must consider the financial relief given by the order and the extent to which the order has been complied with or is likely to be complied with. Any right which the applicant has or has had to apply for financial relief under the law of any country outside England and, if the applicant has omitted to exercise that right, the reason for the omission will be taken into account as will the availability of any property here in respect of which an order could be made, the extent to which any order under this Schedule is likely to be enforceable and the length of time that has elapsed since the date of the dissolution, annulment or separation.
15.8
Orders that can be made: paragraphs 9 and 13 of Schedule 7 The court may make orders under paragraphs 9 and 13. Paragraph 9 enables the court to make any of the orders it could make on dissolution or annulment of the partnership under Part 1, 2 and 4 of Schedule 5, that is financial provision, property adjustment and pension sharing orders. Paragraph 13 relates to the transfers of tenancies and is dealt with at 15.11.
15.9
Matters to be taken into account The welfare while a minor of any child of the family who has not yet attained the age of eighteen will be the court’s first consideration (paragraph 10(2)). Otherwise, in the case of an order in favour of a partner, the court will have regard to the Schedule 5, paragraph 21 (2) considerations (paragraph 10(3)) and the duties of the court to consider the termination of financial obligations are as set out in Schedule 5, paragraph 23 (see 14.11). Included within the financial resources to be taken into account are any benefits under a pension arrangement which either partner has or is likely to have and any Pension Protection Fund compensation to which they are likely to be entitled (paragraph 10(4)). The same two factors are also to be included as benefits which cease to be acquirable. In relation to a child of the family, the court must have regard to the matters set out in paragraph 22(2) of Schedule 5.
15.10
Powers if only jurisdictional requirement is home here If jurisdiction relies solely on the existence of a civil partnership home in England and Wales, the court’s powers are limited by paragraph 11 to making only lump sum orders, property adjustment orders (in either case, in favour of the applicant and children or either or both of them) or an order for the sale of one partner’s interest. A lump sum cannot exceed the amount prescribed by
108
Financial relief after overseas dissolution
15.12
paragraph 11(5) as the value of the paying partner’s interest in the home or the net sale proceeds of that interest.
15.11
Transfer of tenancies: paragraph 13 If one partner is entitled (in his own right or jointly with the other) to occupy a house by virtue of a tenancy which falls within Schedule 7 to the Family Law Act 1996, the court can make, by virtue of paragraph 13, any order which it could make under Part 2 of the Schedule, so the tenancy may be transferred to the applicant or the status of statutory tenant switched from one partner to the other. The Family Law Act tenancies are Rent Act 1977 protected tenancies, Housing Act 1985 secure tenancies, assured tenancies or assured agricultural occupancies within the meaning of Part I of the Housing Act 1988 and Chapter I, Part V Housing Act 1988 introductory tenancies.
15.12
Avoidance of transactions: Schedule 7 Paragraph 15 allows the court to make orders to avoid transactions designed to defeat claims under paragraphs 5 and 9. An application may be made in three sets of circumstances, namely: • Where a partner has been granted leave to apply for an order, if the court is satisfied that the other partner is, with the intention of defeating the claim, about to make any disposition or transfer out of the jurisdiction, or otherwise deal with, property. The court may make such order as it thinks fit to restrain the transaction or generally for protecting the claim (paragraph 15(2)). • Where a partner has been granted leave, if the court is satisfied that the other partner has, with the intention of defeating the claim, made a reviewable disposition and that if the order were set aside, the applicant would be granted financial relief or different financial relief. The court may set aside the disposition (paragraph 15(3)). • If an order for financial relief has already been made under paragraph 5 or 9 and the court is satisfied that the respondent partner has, with the intention of defeating the applicant’s claim, made a ‘reviewable disposition’. The court may set aside the disposition (paragraph 15(4)). Paragraph 15(9) provides that a reference to defeating a partner’s claim means preventing financial relief from being granted, or reducing the amount of relief which might be granted or frustrating or impeding the enforcement of any order.
15.12.1 Reviewable disposition A disposition is reviewable unless it was made for valuable consideration (other than the formation of a civil partnership) to a person who, at the time of the 109
15.13
Civil Partnership Act 2004 – a practical guide
disposition, acted in relation to it in good faith and without notice of any intention on the part of the respondent partner to defeat the claim (paragraph 15(8)). Paragraph 16 contains certain presumptions. In the case of a disposition which took place less than three years before the date of the application, or a proposed disposition, if the court is satisfied that the disposition would effectively defeat the applicant’s claim (by preventing an order being granted or by reducing the amount of relief), there is a presumption that the transaction was made with the intention of defeating the applicant’s claim.
15.12.2 Avoidance of transactions before application for leave Paragraph 17 contains similar provisions to deal with the need to prevent avoidance before an application for leave has been made. Orders can be made to restrain dispositions or set them aside if the court is satisfied that the civil partnership has been validly terminated overseas and that the applicant partner intends to apply for leave as soon as he or she has been habitually resident here for one year (paragraph 17(1)).
15.13
‘The court’: Schedule 7 The court means, for the purposes of Schedule 7, the High Court or, where a county court has jurisdiction by Part 5 of the Matrimonial and Family Proceedings Act 1984, a county court.
110
16 Miscellaneous
16.1
Civil partnership agreements A civil partnership agreement is defined by section 73(3) of the Act as an agreement between two people to register as civil partners or to enter into an overseas relationship. In common with the law relating to engagements, an agreement does not take effect as a contract (s.73(1)) and no action can be taken for breach of an agreement (s.73(2)). If a civil partnership agreement is terminated, a partner may still take advantage of the provisions of sections 65, 66 and 67 to claim a share, or enhanced share, in property they have improved or to apply to court for the resolution of disputes between them about property, provided that any application is made within three years of the termination of the partnership agreement (s.74).
16.2
Jurisdiction The basic rules are set out in amendments to the Matrimonial and Family Proceedings Act 1984 brought about by Schedule 27 to the Act. They are subject to the creation of rules of court and the introduction of statutory instruments. Any county court may be designated by the Lord Chancellor as a civil partnership proceedings county court and any such court may then be designated as a court of trial (s.36A of the Matrimonial and Family Proceedings Act). Section 36A(4) provides that only a court of trial can determine a ‘civil partnership cause’ (defined by s.32 as an action for the dissolution or annulment of a civil partnership or for the legal separation of civil partners). Every civil partnership cause must be commenced in a civil partnership proceedings county court. It must be heard or determined there unless transferred to the High Court (s.36A(6) and (7)). These provisions do not affect the powers of magistrates’ courts under Schedule 6. Proceedings may be commenced in the Principal Registry of the Family Division, unless rules provide otherwise, and rules will make provision for treating the proceedings for specified purposes as if they were pending in a civil partnership proceedings county court (s.42). 111
16.5
Civil Partnership Act 2004 – a practical guide
The jurisdiction of civil partnership proceedings county courts in respect of financial relief and the protection of children is set out in section 36B of the 1984 Act. In summary, they may exercise powers under: • section 63 of the Act (requirements for arrangements for children to be considered before a dissolution or nullity order is made final), • Schedule 5 to the Act (orders for financial relief on dissolution or nullity), save for Part 12 (arrears and repayment) and paragraph 73 (alteration of maintenance agreements after the death of one partner), in each case, in connection with any application or order pending in or made by a civil partnership proceedings court (s.36B(1)), • Part 9 of Schedule 5 (failure to maintain), • Paragraphs 69 to 71 of Schedule 5 (alteration of maintenance agreements during the lives of the partners), • Schedule 7 (financial relief after an overseas dissolution) if the court is designated for that purpose. Jurisdiction under section 43 (the consideration by the courts of agreements or arrangements where proceedings for a dissolution or nullity order are contemplated or have begun) will be conferred on the civil partnership proceedings court (s.36C)). Under section 36D, circuit judges are assigned to deal with civil partnership proceedings.
16.3
Employment It is worth making the point that section 251 of the Act amends the Sex Discrimination Act 1975 in order to prevent discrimination against civil partners in the employment field. A partner will be discriminated against if he or she is treated by someone less favourably on the ground that he or she is a civil partner (s.3 of the Sex Discrimination Act).
16.4
Insurable interest For the purpose of the Life Assurance Act 1774, each civil partner is presumed to have an interest in the life of the other and there is no limit on the amount of the value of the interest (s.253).
16.5
Evidence Section 84 of the Act provides that statutes or rules of law relating to a spouse giving evidence shall apply in relation to a civil partner, but not to a former civil partner.
112
Miscellaneous
16.6
16.6
Minor amendments Schedule 27 contains a host of minor and consequential amendments to more than 80 statutes, all of which amendments are intended to put civil partners in the same position as spouses for purposes ranging from the ability to carry on a deceased dentist’s business for three years (Dentists Act 1984) to eligibility for benefits from a benevolent fund under the Pharmacy Act 1954 and the right to a temporary continuance of a slaughterhouse licence on the death of the licence holder (Slaughterhouses Act 1974). The following is a summary of the minor amendments with which the practitioner is more likely to come into contact.
16.6.1
Amendments of the Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 The grounds on which a marriage is void under section 11 now include that at the time of the marriage, either party was already a civil partner. Similarly, amended section 14 provides that a marriage governed by foreign law or celebrated abroad will not be treated as valid by the English court if at the time when it purports to have been celebrated, either party was already a civil partner. If the proceeds of sale of a property are ordered to be used, pursuant to section 24A(5), to secure periodical payments, the order will cease to have effect if the receiving spouse forms a civil partnership. The formation of a partnership will automatically bring to an end a continuing financial provision order in favour of a party to the marriage (amended s.28).
16.6.2
Amendments of Sexual Offences Act 2003 The marriage exceptions by which, under sections 23, 28 and 43, conduct by a person which would otherwise be an offence is not an offence if at the time they were lawfully married are redefined to include persons who were civil partners of each other.
16.6.3
Amendments of the Children Act 1989 ‘Family proceedings’ are redefined by amended section 8(4) to include Schedules 5 and 6 to the Civil Partnership Act. No one is excused from providing information under section 48(2) (powers of the court when making an emergency protection order to require disclosure of the child’s whereabouts) or under section 50(11) (powers of the court when making a recovery order to require disclosure of a child’s whereabouts) on the ground that complying with the request will incriminate him/her or his/her civil partner.
113
Appendix Civil Partnership Act 2004 – extracts 2004 Chapter 33 C Crown Copyright 2004 www.hmso.gov.uk/acts/acts2004/20040033.htm
CONTENTS
Pa r t 1 Introduction Section 1 Civil partnership
Pa r t 2 C i v i l pa r t n e r s h i p : E n g l a n d a n d W a l e s Chapter 1 R e g i s t r at i o n Formation, eligibility and parental etc. consent 2 3 4
Formation of civil partnership by registration Eligibility Parental etc. consent where proposed civil partner under 18
5 6 7
Types of pre-registration procedure Place of registration The civil partnership document
Registration procedure: general
The standard procedure 8 Notice of proposed civil partnership and declaration 9 Power to require evidence of name etc. 10 Proposed civil partnership to be publicised 11 Meaning of “the waiting period” 12 Power to shorten the waiting period 13 Objection to proposed civil partnership 14 Issue of civil partnership schedule 15 Appeal against refusal to issue civil partnership schedule
114
Appendix Civil Partnership Act 2004 – extracts
16 17
Frivolous objections and representations: liability for costs etc. Period during which registration may take place
18 19
House-bound persons Detained persons
20
Modified procedures for certain non-residents
21 22 23 24 25 26 27
Notice of proposed civil partnership Evidence to be produced Application to be reported to Registrar General Objection to issue of Registrar General’s licence Issue of Registrar General’s licence Frivolous objections: liability for costs Period during which registration may take place
The procedures for house-bound and detained persons
Modified procedures for certain non-residents The special procedure
Supplementary 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36
Registration authorities Civil partnership registrars The Registrar General and the register Offences relating to civil partnership schedule Offences relating to Registrar General’s licence Offences relating to the recording of civil partnerships Fees Power to assimilate provisions relating to civil registration Regulations and orders
Chapter 2 D i s s o l u t i o n, n u l l i t y a n d o t h e r p r o c e e d i n g s Introduction 37 38 39 40 41 42 43
Powers to make orders and effect of orders The period before conditional orders may be made final Intervention of the Queen’s Proctor Proceedings before order has been made final Time bar on applications for dissolution orders Attempts at reconciliation of civil partners Consideration by the court of certain agreements or arrangements
44 45 46 47 48
Dissolution of civil partnership which has broken down irretrievably Supplemental provisions as to facts raising presumption of breakdown Dissolution order not precluded by previous separation order etc. Refusal of dissolution in 5 year separation cases on ground of grave hardship Proceedings before order made final: protection for respondent in separation cases
Dissolution of civil partnership
115
Appendix Civil Partnership Act 2004 – extracts
Nullity 49 50 51 52 53 54
Grounds on which civil partnership is void Grounds on which civil partnership is voidable Bars to relief where civil partnership is voidable Proof of certain matters not necessary to validity of civil partnership Power to validate civil partnership Validity of civil partnerships registered outside England and Wales
Presumption of death orders 55
Presumption of death orders
Separation orders 56 57
Separation orders Effect of separation order
58 59 60 61
Declarations General provisions as to making and effect of declarations The Attorney General and proceedings for declarations Supplementary provisions as to declarations
62 63 64
Relief for respondent in dissolution proceedings Restrictions on making of orders affecting children Parties to proceedings under this Chapter
Declarations
General provisions
Chapter 3 P r o p e r t y a n d fi na n c i a l a r r a n g e m e n t s 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72
Contribution by civil partner to property improvement Disputes between civil partners about property Applications under section 66 where property not in possession etc. Applications under section 66 by former civil partners Actions in tort between civil partners Assurance policy by civil partner for benefit of other civil partner etc. Wills, administration of estates and family provision Financial relief for civil partners and children of family
Chapter 4 C i v i l pa r t n e r s h i p ag r e e m e n t s 73 74
Civil partnership agreements unenforceable Property where civil partnership agreement is terminated
Chapter 5 Children 75 76
116
Parental responsibility, children of the family and relatives Guardianship
Appendix Civil Partnership Act 2004 – extracts
77 78 79
Entitlement to apply for residence or contact order Financial provision for children Adoption
Chapter 6 Miscellaneous 80 81 82 83 84
False statements etc. with reference to civil partnerships Housing and tenancies Family homes and domestic violence Fatal accidents claims Evidence
Pa r t 5 C i v i l pa r t n e r s h i p f o r m e d o r d i s s o lv e d a b r o a d e t c . Chapter 1 R e g i s t r at i o n o u t s i d e U K u n d e r O r d e r i n C o u n c i l 210 211
Registration at British consulates etc. Registration by armed forces personnel
Chapter 2 O v e r s e a s r e l at i o n s h i p s t r e at e d a s c i v i l pa r t n e r s h i p s 212 213 214 215 216 217 218
Meaning of “overseas relationship” Specified relationships The general conditions Overseas relationships treated as civil partnerships: the general rule The same-sex requirement Person domiciled in a part of the United Kingdom The public policy exception
Chapter 3 Dissolution etc.: jurisdiction and recognition Introduction 219
Power to make provision corresponding to EC Regulation 2201/2003
Jurisdiction of courts in England and Wales 220 221 222 223 224
Meaning of “the court” Proceedings for dissolution, separation or nullity order Proceedings for presumption of death order Proceedings for dissolution, nullity or separation order: supplementary Applications for declarations as to validity etc.
Recognition of dissolution, annulment and separation 233 234
Effect of dissolution, annulment or separation obtained in the UK Recognition in the UK of overseas dissolution, annulment or separation
117
Appendix Civil Partnership Act 2004 – extracts
235 236 237 238
Grounds for recognition Refusal of recognition Supplementary provisions relating to recognition of dissolution etc. Non-recognition elsewhere of dissolution or annulment
Chapter 4 M i s c e l l a n e o u s a n d s u p p l e m e n ta r y 239 240 241 242 243 244 245
Commanding officers’ certificates for Part 2 purposes Certificates of no impediment to overseas relationships Transmission of certificates of registration of overseas relationships Power to make provision relating to certain Commonwealth forces Fees Orders in Council: supplementary Interpretation
Pa r t 6 R e l at i o n s h i p s a r i s i n g t h r o u g h c i v i l pa r t n e r s h i p 246 247
Interpretation of statutory references to stepchildren etc. Provisions to which section 246 applies: Acts of Parliament etc.
Pa r t 7 Miscellaneous 249 Immigration control and formation of civil partnerships 250 Gender recognition where applicant a civil partner 251 Discrimination against civil partners in employment field 253 Civil partners to have unlimited insurable interest in each other 254 Social security, child support and tax credits 255 Power to amend enactments relating to pensions 256 Amendment of certain enactments relating to pensions 257 Amendment of certain enactments relating to the armed forces
Pa r t 8 S u p p l e m e n ta r y 258 Regulations and orders 259 Power to make further provision in connection with civil partnership 260 Community obligations and civil partners 261 Minor and consequential amendments, repeals and revocations 262 Extent 263 Commencement 264 Short title
SCHEDULES Schedule 1 Prohibited degrees of relationship: England and Wales Part 1 The prohibitions Part 2 Special provisions relating to qualified prohibitions
118
Appendix Civil Partnership Act 2004 – extracts
Schedule 2 Part 1 Part 2 Part 3 Part 4 Schedule 3 Schedule 4 Part 1 Part 2 Schedule 5 Part 1 Part 2 Part 3 Part 4 Part 5 Part 6 Part 7 Part 8 Part 9 Part 10 Part 11 Part 12 Part 13 Part 14 Schedule 6 Part 1 Part 2 Part 3 Part 4 Part 5 Part 6 Part 7 Part 8 Schedule 7 Part 1 Part 2 Part 3 Schedule 8 Schedule 9 Part 1 Part 2 Part 3 Schedule 20
Civil partnerships of persons under 18: England and Wales Appropriate persons Obtaining consent: general Obtaining consent: special procedure Provisions relating to the court Registration by former spouses one of whom has changed sex Wills, administration of estates and family provision Wills Administration of estates and family provision Financial relief in the High Court or a county court etc. Financial provision in connection with dissolution, nullity or separation Property adjustment on or after dissolution, nullity or separation Sale of property orders Pension sharing orders on or after dissolution or nullity order Matters to which court is to have regard under Parts 1 to 4 Making of Part 1 orders having regard to pension benefits Pension protection fund compensation etc. Maintenance pending outcome of dissolution, nullity or separation proceedings Failure to maintain: financial provision (and interim orders) Commencement of certain proceedings and duration of certain orders Variation, discharge etc. of certain orders for financial relief Arrears and repayments Consent orders and maintenance agreements Miscellaneous and supplementary Financial relief in magistrates’ courts etc. Failure to maintain etc.: financial provision Orders for agreed financial provision Orders of court where civil partners living apart by agreement Interim orders Commencement and duration of orders under Parts 1, 2 and 3 Variation etc. of orders Arrears and repayments Supplementary Financial relief in England and Wales after overseas dissolution etc. of a civil partnership Financial relief Steps to prevent avoidance prior to application for leave under paragraph 4 Supplementary Housing and tenancies Family homes and domestic violence Amendments of the Family Law Act 1996 (c. 27) Consequential amendments Transitional provision Meaning of overseas relationship: specified relationships
119
Appendix Civil Partnership Act 2004 – extracts
Schedule 21 References to stepchildren etc. in existing Acts Schedule 23 Immigration control and formation of civil partnerships Part 1 Introduction Part 2 England and Wales Part 3 Scotland Part 4 Northern Ireland Part 5 Regulations Schedule 24 Social security, child support and tax credits Part 1 Amendments of the Child Support Act 1991 (c. 48) Part 2 Amendments of the Child Support (Northern Ireland) Order 1991 (S.I. 1991/2628 (N.I. 23)) Part 3 Amendments of the Social Security Contributions and Benefits Act 1992 (c. 4) Part 4 Amendments of the Social Security Administration Act 1992 (c. 5) Part 5 Amendments of the Social Security Contributions and Benefits (Northern Ireland) Act 1992 (c. 7) Part 6 Amendments of the Social Security Administration (Northern Ireland) Act 1992 (c. 8) Part 7 Amendments of the Jobseekers Act 1995 (c. 18) Part 8 Amendments of the Child Support Act 1995 (c. 34) Part 9 Amendments of the Child Support (Northern Ireland) Order 1995 (S.I. 1995/2702 (N.I. 13)) Part 10 Amendments of the Jobseekers (Northern Ireland) Order 1995 (S.I. 1995/2705 (N.I. 15)) Part 11 Amendments of the Social Security Act 1998 (c. 14) Part 12 Amendments of the Social Security (Northern Ireland) Order 1998 (S.I. 1998/1506 (N.I. 10)) Part 13 Amendments of the State Pension Credit Act 2002 (c. 16) Part 14 Amendments of the Tax Credits Act 2002 (c. 21) Part 15 Amendments of the State Pension Credit Act (Northern Ireland) 2002 (c. 14 (N.I.)) Schedule 25 Amendment of certain enactments relating to pensions Schedule 26 Amendment of certain enactments relating to the armed forces Schedule 27 Minor and consequential amendments: general Schedule 30 Repeals and revocations
120
Appendix Civil Partnership Act 2004 – extracts
pa r t 1 introduction 1
Civil partnership
(1) A civil partnership is a relationship between two people of the same sex (“civil partners”)(a) which is formed when they register as civil partners of each other(i) in England or Wales (under Part 2), (ii) in Scotland (under Part 3), (iii) in Northern Ireland (under Part 4), or (iv) outside the United Kingdom under an Order in Council made under Chapter 1 of Part 5 (registration at British consulates etc. or by armed forces personnel), or (b) which they are treated under Chapter 2 of Part 5 as having formed (at the time determined under that Chapter) by virtue of having registered an overseas relationship. (2) Subsection (1) is subject to the provisions of this Act under or by virtue of which a civil partnership is void. (3) A civil partnership ends only on death, dissolution or annulment. (4) The references in subsection (3) to dissolution and annulment are to dissolution and annulment having effect under or recognised in accordance with this Act. (5) References in this Act to an overseas relationship are to be read in accordance with Chapter 2 of Part 5.
pa r t 2 c i v i l pa r t n e r s h i p : E n g l a n d a n d W a l e s Chapter 1 R e g i s t r at i o n Formation, eligibility and parental etc. consent 2
Formation of civil partnership by registration
(1) For the purposes of section 1, two people are to be regarded as having registered as civil partners of each other once each of them has signed the civil partnership document(a) at the invitation of, and in the presence of, a civil partnership registrar, and (b) in the presence of each other and two witnesses. (2) Subsection (1) applies regardless of whether subsections (3) and (4) are complied with. (3) After the civil partnership document has been signed under subsection (1), it must also be signed, in the presence of the civil partners and each other, by(a) each of the two witnesses, and (b) the civil partnership registrar.
121
Appendix Civil Partnership Act 2004 – extracts
(4) After the witnesses and the civil partnership registrar have signed the civil partnership document, the relevant registration authority must ensure that(a) the fact that the two people have registered as civil partners of each other, and (b) any other information prescribed by regulations, is recorded in the register as soon as is practicable. (5) No religious service is to be used while the civil partnership registrar is officiating at the signing of a civil partnership document. (6) “The civil partnership document” has the meaning given by section 7(1). (7) “The relevant registration authority” means the registration authority in whose area the registration takes place. 3
Eligibility
(1) Two people are not eligible to register as civil partners of each other if(a) they are not of the same sex, (b) either of them is already a civil partner or lawfully married, (c) either of them is under 16, or (d) they are within prohibited degrees of relationship. (2) Part 1 of Schedule 1 contains provisions for determining when two people are within prohibited degrees of relationship. 4
Parental etc. consent where proposed civil partner under 18
(1) The consent of the appropriate persons is required before a child and another person may register as civil partners of each other. (2) Part 1 of Schedule 2 contains provisions for determining who are the appropriate persons for the purposes of this section. (3) The requirement of consent under subsection (1) does not apply if the child is a surviving civil partner. (4) Nothing in this section affects any need to obtain the consent of the High Court before a ward of court and another person may register as civil partners of each other. (5) In this Part “child”, except where used to express a relationship, means a person who is under 18.
Registration procedure: general 5
Types of pre-registration procedure
(1) Two people may register as civil partners of each other under(a) the standard procedure; (b) the procedure for house-bound persons; (c) the procedure for detained persons; (d) the special procedure (which is for cases where a person is seriously ill and not expected to recover). (2) The procedures referred to in subsection (1)(a) to (c) are subject to(a) section 20 (modified procedures for certain non-residents); (b) Schedule 3 (former spouses one of whom has changed sex). (3) The procedures referred to in subsection (1) (including the procedures as modified by section 20 and Schedule 3) are subject to-
122
Appendix Civil Partnership Act 2004 – extracts
(a) Part 2 of Schedule 1 (provisions applicable in connection with prohibited degrees of relationship), and (b) Parts 2 and 3 of Schedule 2 (provisions applicable where proposed civil partner is under 18). (4) This section is also subject to section 249 and Schedule 23 (immigration control and formation of civil partnerships). 6
Place of registration
(1) The place at which two people may register as civil partners of each other(a) must be in England or Wales, (b) must not be in religious premises, and (c) must be specified in the notices, or notice, of proposed civil partnership required by this Chapter. (2) “Religious premises” means premises which(a) are used solely or mainly for religious purposes, or (b) have been so used and have not subsequently been used solely or mainly for other purposes. (3) In the case of registration under the standard procedure (including that procedure modified as mentioned in section 5), the place(a) must be one which is open to any person wishing to attend the registration, and (b) before being specified in a notice of proposed civil partnership, must be agreed with the registration authority in whose area that place is located. (4) If the place specified in a notice is not so agreed, the notice is void. (5) A registration authority may provide a place in its area for the registration of civil partnerships. 7
The civil partnership document (1) In this Part “the civil partnership document” means(a) in relation to the special procedure, a Registrar General’s licence, and (b) in relation to any other procedure, a civil partnership schedule. (2) Before two people are entitled to register as civil partners of each other(a) the civil partnership document must be delivered to the civil partnership registrar, and (b) the civil partnership registrar may then ask them for any information required (under section 2(4)) to be recorded in the register.
The standard procedure 8
Notice of proposed civil partnership and declaration
(1) For two people to register as civil partners of each other under the standard procedure, each of them must(a) give a notice of proposed civil partnership to a registration authority, and (b) have resided in England or Wales for at least 7 days immediately before giving the notice.
123
Appendix Civil Partnership Act 2004 – extracts
(2) A notice of proposed civil partnership must contain such information as may be prescribed by regulations. (3) A notice of proposed civil partnership must also include the necessary declaration, made and signed by the person giving the notice(a) at the time when the notice is given, and (b) in the presence of an authorised person; and the authorised person must attest the declaration by adding his name, description and place of residence. (4) The necessary declaration is a solemn declaration in writing(a) that the proposed civil partner believes that there is no impediment of kindred or affinity or other lawful hindrance to the formation of the civil partnership; (b) that each of the proposed civil partners has had a usual place of residence in England or Wales for at least 7 days immediately before giving the notice. (5) Where a notice of proposed civil partnership is given to a registration authority in accordance with this section, the registration authority must ensure that the following information is recorded in the register as soon as possible(a) the fact that the notice has been given and the information in it; (b) the fact that the authorised person has attested the declaration. (6) “Authorised person” means an employee or officer or other person provided by a registration authority who is authorised by that authority to attest notices of proposed civil partnership. (7) For the purposes of this Chapter, a notice of proposed civil partnership is recorded when subsection (5) is complied with. 9
Power to require evidence of name etc.
(1) The registration authority to which a notice of proposed civil partnership is given may require the person giving the notice to provide it with specified evidence(a) relating to that person, or (b) if the registration authority considers that the circumstances are exceptional, relating not only to that person but also to that person’s proposed civil partner. (2) Such a requirement may be imposed at any time before the registration authority issues the civil partnership schedule under section 14. (3) “Specified evidence”, in relation to a person, means such evidence as may be specified in guidance issued by the Registrar General(a) of the person’s name and surname, (b) of the person’s age, (c) as to whether the person has previously formed a civil partnership or a marriage and, if so, as to the ending of the civil partnership or marriage, (d) of the person’s nationality, and (e) as to the person’s residence in England or Wales during the period of 7 days preceding the giving of a notice of proposed civil partnership by that person.
124
Appendix Civil Partnership Act 2004 – extracts
10
Proposed civil partnership to be publicised
(1) Where a notice of proposed civil partnership has been given to a registration authority, the relevant information must be publicised during the waiting period(a) by that registration authority, (b) by any registration authority in whose area the person giving the notice has resided during the period of 7 days preceding the giving of the notice, (c) by any registration authority in whose area the proposed civil partner of the person giving the notice has resided during the period of 7 days preceding the giving of that notice, (d) by the registration authority in whose area the place specified in the notice as the place of proposed registration is located, and (e) by the Registrar General. (2) “The relevant information” means(a) the name of the person giving the notice, (b) the name of that person’s proposed civil partner, and (c) such other information as may be prescribed by regulations. 11
Meaning of “the waiting period”
In this Chapter “the waiting period”, in relation to a notice of proposed civil partnership, means the period(a) beginning the day after the notice is recorded, and (b) subject to section 12, ending at the end of the period of 15 days beginning with that day. 12
Power to shorten the waiting period
(1) If the Registrar General, on an application being made to him, is satisfied that there are compelling reasons because of the exceptional circumstances of the case for shortening the period of 15 days mentioned in section 11(b), he may shorten it to such period as he considers appropriate. (2) Regulations may make provision with respect to the making, and granting, of applications under subsection (1). (3) Regulations under subsection (2) may provide for(a) the power conferred by subsection (1) to be exercised by a registration authority on behalf of the Registrar General in such classes of case as are prescribed by the regulations; (b) the making of an appeal to the Registrar General against a decision taken by a registration authority in accordance with regulations made by virtue of paragraph (a). 13
Objection to proposed civil partnership
(1) Any person may object to the issue of a civil partnership schedule under section 14 by giving any registration authority notice of his objection. (2) A notice of objection must(a) state the objector’s place of residence and the ground of objection, and (b) be signed by or on behalf of the objector.
125
Appendix Civil Partnership Act 2004 – extracts
(3) If a notice of objection is given to a registration authority, it must ensure that the fact that it has been given and the information in it are recorded in the register as soon as possible. 14
Issue of civil partnership schedule
(1) As soon as the waiting period in relation to each notice of proposed civil partnership has expired, the registration authority in whose area it is proposed that the registration take place is under a duty, at the request of one or both of the proposed civil partners, to issue a document to be known as a “civil partnership schedule”. (2) Regulations may make provision as to the contents of a civil partnership schedule. (3) The duty in subsection (1) does not apply if the registration authority is not satisfied that there is no lawful impediment to the formation of the civil partnership. (4) If an objection to the issue of the civil partnership schedule has been recorded in the register, no civil partnership schedule is to be issued until(a) the relevant registration authority has investigated the objection and is satisfied that the objection ought not to obstruct the issue of the civil partnership schedule, or (b) the objection has been withdrawn by the person who made it. (5) “The relevant registration authority” means the authority which first records that a notice of proposed civil partnership has been given by one of the proposed civil partners. 15
Appeal against refusal to issue civil partnership schedule
(1) If the registration authority refuses to issue a civil partnership schedule(a) because an objection to its issue has been made under section 13, or (b) in reliance on section 14(3), either of the proposed civil partners may appeal to the Registrar General. (2) On an appeal under this section the Registrar General must either confirm the refusal or direct that a civil partnership schedule be issued. 16
Frivolous objections and representations: liability for costs etc. (1) Subsection (3) applies if(a) a person objects to the issue of a civil partnership schedule, but (b) the Registrar General declares that the grounds on which the objection is made are frivolous and ought not to obstruct the issue of the civil partnership schedule. (2) Subsection (3) also applies if(a) in reliance on section 14(3), the registration authority refuses to issue a civil partnership schedule as a result of a representation made to it, and (b) on an appeal under section 15 against the refusal, the Registrar General declares that the representation is frivolous and ought not to obstruct the issue of the civil partnership schedule. (3) The person who made the objection or representation is liable for(a) the costs of the proceedings before the Registrar General, and (b) damages recoverable by the proposed civil partner to whom the objection or representation relates.
126
Appendix Civil Partnership Act 2004 – extracts
(4) For the purpose of enabling any person to recover any such costs and damages, a copy of a declaration of the Registrar General purporting to be sealed with the seal of the General Register Office is evidence that the Registrar General has made the declaration. 17
Period during which registration may take place
(1) The proposed civil partners may not register as civil partners of each other on the production of the civil partnership schedule until the waiting period in relation to each notice of proposed civil partnership has expired. (2) Subject to subsection (1), under the standard procedure, they may register as civil partners by signing the civil partnership schedule at any time during the applicable period. (3) If they do not register as civil partners by signing the civil partnership schedule before the end of the applicable period(a) the notices of proposed civil partnership and the civil partnership schedule are void, and (b) no civil partnership registrar may officiate at the signing of the civil partnership schedule by them. (4) The applicable period, in relation to two people registering as civil partners of each other, is the period of 12 months beginning with(a) the day on which the notices of proposed civil partnership are recorded, or (b) if the notices are not recorded on the same day, the earlier of those days.
The procedures for house-bound and detained persons 18
House-bound persons
(1) This section applies if two people wish to register as civil partners of each other at the place where one of them is house-bound. (2) A person is house-bound at any place if, in relation to that person, a statement is made by a registered medical practitioner that, in his opinion(a) because of illness or disability, that person ought not to move or be moved from the place where he is at the time when the statement is made, and (b) it is likely to be the case for at least the following 3 months that because of the illness or disability that person ought not to move or be moved from that place. (3) The procedure under which the two people concerned may register as civil partners of each other is the same as the standard procedure, except that(a) each notice of proposed civil partnership must be accompanied by a statement under subsection (2) (“a medical statement”), which must have been made not more than 14 days before the day on which the notice is recorded, (b) the fact that the registration authority to whom the notice is given has received the medical statement must be recorded in the register, and (c) the applicable period (for the purposes of section 17) is the period of 3 months beginning with-
127
Appendix Civil Partnership Act 2004 – extracts
(i) the day on which the notices of proposed civil partnership are recorded, or (ii) if the notices are not recorded on the same day, the earlier of those days. (4) A medical statement must contain such information and must be made in such manner as may be prescribed by regulations. (5) A medical statement may not be made in relation to a person who is detained as described in section 19(2). (6) For the purposes of this Chapter, a person in relation to whom a medical statement is made is to be treated, if he would not otherwise be so treated, as resident and usually resident at the place where he is for the time being. 19
Detained persons
(1) This section applies if two people wish to register as civil partners of each other at the place where one of them is detained. (2) “Detained” means detained(a) as a patient in a hospital (but otherwise than by virtue of section 2, 4, 5, 35, 36 or 136 of the Mental Health Act 1983 (c. 20) (short term detentions)), or (b) in a prison or other place to which the Prison Act 1952 (c. 52) applies. (3) The procedure under which the two people concerned may register as civil partners of each other is the same as the standard procedure, except that(a) each notice of proposed civil partnership must be accompanied by a supporting statement, which must have been made not more than 21 days before the day on which the notice is recorded, (b) the fact that the registration authority to whom the notice is given has received the supporting statement must be recorded in the register, and (c) the applicable period (for the purposes of section 17) is the period of 3 months beginning with(i) the day on which the notices of proposed civil partnership are recorded, or (ii) if the notices are not recorded on the same day, the earlier of those days. (4) A supporting statement, in relation to a detained person, is a statement made by the responsible authority which(a) identifies the establishment where the person is detained, and (b) states that the responsible authority has no objection to that establishment being specified in a notice of proposed civil partnership as the place at which the person is to register as a civil partner. (5) A supporting statement must contain such information and must be made in such manner as may be prescribed by regulations. (6) “The responsible authority” means(a) if the person is detained in a hospital, the hospital’s managers; (b) if the person is detained in a prison or other place to which the 1952 Act applies, the governor or other officer for the time being in charge of that prison or other place.
128
Appendix Civil Partnership Act 2004 – extracts
(7) “Patient” and “hospital” have the same meaning as in Part 2 of the 1983 Act and “managers”, in relation to a hospital, has the same meaning as in section 145(1) of the 1983 Act. (8) For the purposes of this Chapter, a detained person is to be treated, if he would not otherwise be so treated, as resident and usually resident at the place where he is for the time being.
Modified procedures for certain non-residents 20
Modified procedures for certain non-residents
(1) Subsection (5) applies in the following three cases. (2) The first is where(a) two people wish to register as civil partners of each other in England and Wales, and (b) one of them (“A”) resides in Scotland and the other (“B”) resides in England or Wales. (3) The second is where(a) two people wish to register as civil partners of each other in England and Wales, and (b) one of them (“A”) resides in Northern Ireland and the other (“B”) resides in England or Wales. (4) The third is where(a) two people wish to register as civil partners of each other in England and Wales, and (b) one of them (“A”) is a member of Her Majesty’s forces who is serving outside the United Kingdom and the other (“B”) resides in England or Wales. (5) For the purposes of the standard procedure, the procedure for house-bound persons and the procedure for detained persons(a) A is not required to give a notice of proposed civil partnership under this Chapter; (b) B may give a notice of proposed civil partnership and make the necessary declaration without regard to the requirement that would otherwise apply that A must reside in England or Wales; (c) the waiting period is calculated by reference to the day on which B’s notice is recorded; (d) the civil partnership schedule is not to be issued by a registration authority unless A or B produces to that registration authority a certificate of no impediment issued to A under the relevant provision; (e) the applicable period is calculated by reference to the day on which B’s notice is recorded and, where the standard procedure is used in the first and second cases, is the period of 3 months beginning with that day; (f) section 31 applies as if in subsections (1)(a) and (2)(c) for “each notice” there were substituted “B’s notice”. (6) “The relevant provision” means(a) if A resides in Scotland, section 97; (b) if A resides in Northern Ireland, section 150;
129
Appendix Civil Partnership Act 2004 – extracts
(c) if A is a member of Her Majesty’s forces who is serving outside the United Kingdom, section 239. (7) “Her Majesty’s forces” has the same meaning as in the Army Act 1955 (3 & 4 Eliz. 2 c. 18).
The special procedure 21
Notice of proposed civil partnership
(1) For two people to register as civil partners of each other under the special procedure, one of them must(a) give a notice of proposed civil partnership to the registration authority for the area in which it is proposed that the registration take place, and (b) comply with any requirement made under section 22. (2) The notice must contain such information as may be prescribed by regulations. (3) Subsections (3) to (6) of section 8 (necessary declaration etc.), apart from paragraph (b) of subsection (4), apply for the purposes of this section as they apply for the purposes of that section. 22
Evidence to be produced
(1) The person giving a notice of proposed civil partnership to a registration authority under the special procedure must produce to the authority such evidence as the Registrar General may require to satisfy him(a) that there is no lawful impediment to the formation of the civil partnership, (b) that the conditions in subsection (2) are met, and (c) that there is sufficient reason why a licence should be granted. (2) The conditions are that one of the proposed civil partners(a) is seriously ill and not expected to recover, and (b) understands the nature and purport of signing a Registrar General’s licence. (3) The certificate of a registered medical practitioner is sufficient evidence of any or all of the matters referred to in subsection (2). 23
Application to be reported to Registrar General
On receiving a notice of proposed civil partnership under section 21 and any evidence under section 22, the registration authority must(a) inform the Registrar General, and (b) comply with any directions the Registrar General may give for verifying the evidence given. 24
Objection to issue of Registrar General’s licence
(1) Any person may object to the Registrar General giving authority for the issue of his licence by giving the Registrar General or any registration authority notice of his objection. (2) A notice of objection must(a) state the objector’s place of residence and the ground of objection, and (b) be signed by or on behalf of the objector.
130
Appendix Civil Partnership Act 2004 – extracts
(3) If a notice of objection is given to a registration authority, it must ensure that the fact that it has been given and the information in it are recorded in the register as soon as possible. 25
Issue of Registrar General’s licence
(1) This section applies where a notice of proposed civil partnership is given to a registration authority under section 21. (2) The registration authority may issue a Registrar General’s licence if, and only if, given authority to do so by the Registrar General. (3) The Registrar General(a) may not give his authority unless he is satisfied that one of the proposed civil partners is seriously ill and not expected to recover, but (b) if so satisfied, must give his authority unless a lawful impediment to the issue of his licence has been shown to his satisfaction to exist. (4) A licence under this section must state that it is issued on the authority of the Registrar General. (5) Regulations may (subject to subsection (4)) make provision as to the contents of a licence under this section. (6) If an objection has been made to the Registrar General giving authority for the issue of his licence, he is not to give that authority until(a) he has investigated the objection and decided whether it ought to obstruct the issue of his licence, or (b) the objection has been withdrawn by the person who made it. (7) Any decision of the Registrar General under subsection (6)(a) is final. 26
Frivolous objections: liability for costs
(1) This section applies if(a) a person objects to the Registrar General giving authority for the issue of his licence, but (b) the Registrar General declares that the grounds on which the objection is made are frivolous and ought not to obstruct the issue of his licence. (2) The person who made the objection is liable for(a) the costs of the proceedings before the Registrar General, and (b) damages recoverable by the proposed civil partner to whom the objection relates. (3) For the purpose of enabling any person to recover any such costs and damages, a copy of a declaration of the Registrar General purporting to be sealed with the seal of the General Register Office is evidence that the Registrar General has made the declaration. 27
Period during which registration may take place
(1) If a Registrar General’s licence has been issued under section 25, the proposed civil partners may register as civil partners by signing it at any time within 1 month from the day on which the notice of proposed civil partnership was given. (2) If they do not register as civil partners by signing the licence within the 1 month period-
131
Appendix Civil Partnership Act 2004 – extracts
(a) the notice of proposed civil partnership and the licence are void, and (b) no civil partnership registrar may officiate at the signing of the licence by them.
Supplementary 28
Registration authorities
In this Chapter “registration authority” means(a) in relation to England, a county council, the council of any district comprised in an area for which there is no county council, a London borough council, the Common Council of the City of London or the Council of the Isles of Scilly; (b) in relation to Wales, a county council or a county borough council. 29
Civil partnership registrars
(1) A civil partnership registrar is an individual who is designated by a registration authority as a civil partnership registrar for its area. (2) It is the duty of each registration authority to ensure that there is a sufficient number of civil partnership registrars for its area to carry out in that area the functions of civil partnership registrars. (3) Each registration authority must inform the Registrar General as soon as is practicable(a) of any designation it has made of a person as a civil partnership registrar, and (b) of the ending of any such designation. (4) The Registrar General must make available to the public a list(a) of civil partnership registrars, and (b) of the registration authorities for which they are designated to act. 30
The Registrar General and the register
(1) In this Chapter “the Registrar General” means the Registrar General for England and Wales. (2) The Registrar General must provide a system for keeping any records that relate to civil partnerships and are required by this Chapter to be made. (3) The system may, in particular, enable those records to be kept together with other records kept by the Registrar General. (4) In this Chapter “the register” means the system for keeping records provided under subsection (2). 31
Offences relating to civil partnership schedule
(1) A person commits an offence if he issues a civil partnership schedule knowing that he does so(a) before the waiting period in relation to each notice of proposed civil partnership has expired, (b) after the end of the applicable period, or (c) at a time when its issue has been forbidden under Schedule 2 by a person entitled to forbid its issue. (2) A person commits an offence if, in his actual or purported capacity as a civil partnership registrar, he officiates at the signing of a civil partnership schedule by proposed civil partners knowing that he does so-
132
Appendix Civil Partnership Act 2004 – extracts
(a) at a place other than the place specified in the notices of proposed civil partnership and the civil partnership schedule, (b) in the absence of a civil partnership registrar, (c) before the waiting period in relation to each notice of proposed civil partnership has expired, or (d) even though the civil partnership is void under section 49(b) or (c). (3) A person guilty of an offence under subsection (1) or (2) is liable on conviction on indictment to imprisonment for a term not exceeding 5 years or to a fine (or both). (4) A prosecution under this section may not be commenced more than 3 years after the commission of the offence. 32
Offences relating to Registrar General’s licence
(1) A person commits an offence if(a) he gives information by way of evidence in response to a requirement under section 22(1), knowing that the information is false; (b) he gives a certificate as provided for by section 22(3), knowing that the certificate is false. (2) A person commits an offence if, in his actual or purported capacity as a civil partnership registrar, he officiates at the signing of a Registrar General’s licence by proposed civil partners knowing that he does so(a) at a place other than the place specified in the licence, (b) in the absence of a civil partnership registrar, (c) after the end of 1 month from the day on which the notice of proposed civil partnership was given, or (d) even though the civil partnership is void under section 49(b) or (c). (3) A person guilty of an offence under subsection (1) or (2) is liable(a) on conviction on indictment, to imprisonment not exceeding 3 years or to a fine (or both); (b) on summary conviction, to a fine not exceeding the statutory maximum. (4) A prosecution under this section may not be commenced more than 3 years after the commission of the offence. 33
Offences relating to the recording of civil partnerships
(1) A civil partnership registrar commits an offence if he refuses or fails to comply with the provisions of this Chapter or of any regulations made under section 36. (2) A civil partnership registrar guilty of an offence under subsection (1) is liable(a) on conviction on indictment, to imprisonment for a term not exceeding 2 years or to a fine (or both); (b) on summary conviction, to a fine not exceeding the statutory maximum; and on conviction shall cease to be a civil partnership registrar. (3) A person commits an offence if(a) under arrangements made by a registration authority for the purposes
133
Appendix Civil Partnership Act 2004 – extracts
of section 2(4), he is under a duty to record information required to be recorded under section 2(4), but (b) he refuses or without reasonable cause omits to do so. (4) A person guilty of an offence under subsection (3) is liable on summary conviction to a fine not exceeding level 3 on the standard scale. (5) A person commits an offence if he records in the register information relating to the formation of a civil partnership by the signing of a civil partnership schedule, knowing that the civil partnership is void under section 49(b) or (c). (6) A person guilty of an offence under subsection (5) is liable on conviction on indictment, to imprisonment for a term not exceeding 5 years or to a fine (or both). (7) A person commits an offence if he records in the register information relating to the formation of a civil partnership by the signing of a Registrar General’s licence, knowing that the civil partnership is void under section 49(b) or (c). (8) A person guilty of an offence under subsection (7) is liable(a) on conviction on indictment, to imprisonment for a term not exceeding 3 years or to a fine (or both); (b) on summary conviction, to a fine not exceeding the statutory maximum. (9) A prosecution under subsection (5) or (7) may not be commenced more than 3 years after the commission of the offence. 34
Fees
(1) The Chancellor of the Exchequer may by order provide for fees, of such amounts as may be specified in the order, to be payable to such persons as may be prescribed by the order in respect of(a) the giving of a notice of proposed civil partnership and the attestation of the necessary declaration; (b) the making of an application under section 12(1) (application to reduce waiting period); (c) the issue of a Registrar General’s licence; (d) the attendance of the civil partnership registrar when two people sign the civil partnership document; (e) such other services provided in connection with civil partnerships either by registration authorities or by or on behalf of the Registrar General as may be prescribed by the order. (2) The Registrar General may remit the fee for the issue of his licence in whole or in part in any case where it appears to him that the payment of the fee would cause hardship to the proposed civil partners. 35
Power to assimilate provisions relating to civil registration (1) The Chancellor of the Exchequer may by order make(a) such amendments of this Act as appear to him appropriate for the purpose of assimilating any provision connected with the formation or recording of civil partnerships in England and Wales to any provision made (whether or not under an order under section 1 of the Regulatory Reform Act 2001 (c. 6)) in relation to civil marriage in England and Wales, and
134
Appendix Civil Partnership Act 2004 – extracts
(b) such amendments of other enactments and of subordinate legislation as appear to him appropriate in consequence of any amendments made under paragraph (a). (2) “Civil marriage” means marriage solemnised otherwise than according to the rites of the Church of England or any other religious usages. (3) “Amendment” includes repeal or revocation. (4) “Subordinate legislation” has the same meaning as in the Interpretation Act 1978 (c. 30). 36
Regulations and orders
(1) Regulations may make provision supplementing the provisions of this Chapter. (2) Regulations may in particular make provision(a) relating to the use of Welsh in documents and records relating to civil partnerships; (b) with respect to the retention of documents relating to civil partnerships; (c) prescribing the duties of civil partnership registrars; (d) prescribing the duties of persons in whose presence any declaration is made for the purposes of this Chapter; (e) for the issue by the Registrar General of guidance supplementing any provision made by the regulations. (f) for the issue by registration authorities or the Registrar General of certified copies of entries in the register and for such copies to be received in evidence. (3) In this Chapter “regulations” means regulations made by the Registrar General with the approval of the Chancellor of the Exchequer. (4) Any power to make regulations or an order under this Chapter is exercisable by statutory instrument. (5) A statutory instrument containing an order under section 34 is subject to annulment in pursuance of a resolution of either House of Parliament. (6) No order may be made under section 35 unless a draft of the statutory instrument containing the order has been laid before, and approved by a resolution of, each House of Parliament.
chapter 2 d i s s o l u t i o n, n u l l i t y a n d o t h e r p r o c e e d i n g s Introduction 37
Powers to make orders and effect of orders (1) The court may, in accordance with this Chapter(a) make an order (a “dissolution order”) which dissolves a civil partnership on the ground that it has broken down irretrievably; (b) make an order (a “nullity order”) which annuls a civil partnership which is void or voidable; (c) make an order (a “presumption of death order”) which dissolves a civil partnership on the ground that one of the civil partners is presumed to be dead;
135
Appendix Civil Partnership Act 2004 – extracts
(d) make an order (a “separation order”) which provides for the separation of the civil partners. (2) Every dissolution, nullity or presumption of death order(a) is, in the first instance, a conditional order, and (b) may not be made final before the end of the prescribed period (see section 38); and any reference in this Chapter to a conditional order is to be read accordingly. (3) A nullity order made where a civil partnership is voidable annuls the civil partnership only as respects any time after the order has been made final, and the civil partnership is to be treated (despite the order) as if it had existed up to that time. (4) In this Chapter, other than in sections 58 to 61, “the court” means(a) the High Court, or (b) if a county court has jurisdiction by virtue of Part 5 of the Matrimonial and Family Proceedings Act 1984 (c. 42), a county court. (5) This Chapter is subject to sections 219 to 224 (jurisdiction of the court). 38
The period before conditional orders may be made final
(1) Subject to subsections (2) to (4), the prescribed period for the purposes of section 37(2)(b) is(a) 6 weeks from the making of the conditional order, or (b) if the 6 week period would end on a day on which the office or registry of the court dealing with the case is closed, the period of 6 weeks extended to the end of the first day on which the office or registry is next open. (2) The Lord Chancellor may by order amend this section so as to substitute a different definition of the prescribed period for the purposes of section 37(2)(b). (3) But the Lord Chancellor may not under subsection (2) provide for a period longer than 6 months to be the prescribed period. (4) In a particular case the court dealing with the case may by order shorten the prescribed period. (5) The power to make an order under subsection (2) is exercisable by statutory instrument. (6) An instrument containing such an order is subject to annulment in pursuance of a resolution of either House of Parliament. 39
Intervention of the Queen’s Proctor
(1) This section applies if an application has been made for a dissolution, nullity or presumption of death order. (2) The court may, if it thinks fit, direct that all necessary papers in the matter are to be sent to the Queen’s Proctor who must under the directions of the Attorney General instruct counsel to argue before the court any question in relation to the matter which the court considers it necessary or expedient to have fully argued. (3) If any person at any time-
136
Appendix Civil Partnership Act 2004 – extracts
(a) during the progress of the proceedings, or (b) before the conditional order is made final, gives information to the Queen’s Proctor on any matter material to the due decision of the case, the Queen’s Proctor may take such steps as the Attorney General considers necessary or expedient. (4) If the Queen’s Proctor intervenes or shows cause against the making of the conditional order in any proceedings relating to its making, the court may make such order as may be just as to(a) the payment by other parties to the proceedings of the costs incurred by him in doing so, or (b) the payment by the Queen’s Proctor of any costs incurred by any of those parties because of his doing so. (5) The Queen’s Proctor is entitled to charge as part of the expenses of his office(a) the costs of any proceedings under subsection (2); (b) if his reasonable costs of intervening or showing cause as mentioned in subsection (4) are not fully satisfied by an order under subsection (4)(a), the amount of the difference; (c) if the Treasury so directs, any costs which he pays to any parties under an order made under subsection (4)(b). 40
Proceedings before order has been made final (1) This section applies if(a) a conditional order has been made, and (b) the Queen’s Proctor, or any person who has not been a party to proceedings in which the order was made, shows cause why the order should not be made final on the ground that material facts have not been brought before the court. (2) This section also applies if(a) a conditional order has been made, (b) 3 months have elapsed since the earliest date on which an application could have been made for the order to be made final, (c) no such application has been made by the civil partner who applied for the conditional order, and (d) the other civil partner makes an application to the court under this subsection. (3) The court may(a) make the order final, (b) rescind the order, (c) require further inquiry, or (d) otherwise deal with the case as it thinks fit. (4) Subsection (3)(a)(a) applies despite section 37(2) (period before conditional orders may be made final), but (b) is subject to section 48(4) (protection for respondent in separation cases) and section 63 (restrictions on making of orders affecting children).
137
Appendix Civil Partnership Act 2004 – extracts
41
Time bar on applications for dissolution orders
(1) No application for a dissolution order may be made to the court before the end of the period of 1 year from the date of the formation of the civil partnership. (2) Nothing in this section prevents the making of an application based on matters which occurred before the end of the 1 year period. 42
Attempts at reconciliation of civil partners
(1) This section applies in relation to cases where an application is made for a dissolution or separation order. (2) Rules of court must make provision for requiring the solicitor acting for the applicant to certify whether he has(a) discussed with the applicant the possibility of a reconciliation with the other civil partner, and (b) given the applicant the names and addresses of persons qualified to help effect a reconciliation between civil partners who have become estranged. (3) If at any stage of proceedings for the order it appears to the court that there is a reasonable possibility of a reconciliation between the civil partners, the court may adjourn the proceedings for such period as it thinks fit to enable attempts to be made to effect a reconciliation between them. (4) The power to adjourn under subsection (3) is additional to any other power of adjournment. 43
Consideration by the court of certain agreements or arrangements (1) This section applies in relation to cases where(a) proceedings for a dissolution or separation order are contemplated or have begun, and (b) an agreement or arrangement is made or proposed to be made between the civil partners which relates to, arises out of, or is connected with, the proceedings. (2) Rules of court may make provision for enabling(a) the civil partners, or either of them, to refer the agreement or arrangement to the court, and (b) the court(i) to express an opinion, if it thinks it desirable to do so, as to the reasonableness of the agreement or arrangement, and (ii) to give such directions, if any, in the matter as it thinks fit.
Dissolution of civil partnership 44
Dissolution of civil partnership which has broken down irretrievably
(1) Subject to section 41, an application for a dissolution order may be made to the court by either civil partner on the ground that the civil partnership has broken down irretrievably. (2) On an application for a dissolution order the court must inquire, so far as it reasonably can, into(a) the facts alleged by the applicant, and (b) any facts alleged by the respondent.
138
Appendix Civil Partnership Act 2004 – extracts
(3) The court hearing an application for a dissolution order must not hold that the civil partnership has broken down irretrievably unless the applicant satisfies the court of one or more of the facts described in subsection (5)(a), (b), (c) or (d). (4) But if the court is satisfied of any of those facts, it must make a dissolution order unless it is satisfied on all the evidence that the civil partnership has not broken down irretrievably. (5) The facts referred to in subsections (3) and (4) are(a) that the respondent has behaved in such a way that the applicant cannot reasonably be expected to live with the respondent; (b) that(i) the applicant and the respondent have lived apart for a continuous period of a