THE CAMBRIDGE HISTORY OF RUSSIAN LITERATURE REVISED EDITION
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 20...
74 downloads
2554 Views
35MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
THE CAMBRIDGE HISTORY OF RUSSIAN LITERATURE REVISED EDITION
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
THE CAMBRIDGE HISTORY OF RUSSIAN LITERATURE REVISED EDITION
edited by
CHARLES A. MOSER
CAMBRIDGE UNIVERSITY PRESS
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
Published by the Press Syndicate of the University of Cambridge The Pitt Building, Trumpington Street, Cambridge CB2 1RP 40 West 20th Street, New York, NY 10011-4211 USA 10 Stamford Road, Oakleigh, Melbourne 3166, Australia © Cambridge University Press 1989, 1992 First published 1989 Revised edition 1992 Reprinted 1992,1995,1996 Printed in Great Britain by Athenaeum Press Ltd, Gateshead, Tyne & Wear British Library cataloguing in publication data The Cambridge history of Russian literature. 1. Russian literature, to 1979—Critical studies I. Moser, Charles A. 891.709 Library of Congress cataloguing in publication data The Cambridge history of Russian literature / edited by Charles A. Moser.—Rev. ed. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 0 521 41554-3 ISBN 0 521 42567-0 (paperback) 1. Russian literature—History and criticism. I. Moser, Charles A. PG2951.C36 1992 891.709-DC20 91-38275 CIP ISBN 0 521 41554 3 hardback ISBN 0 521 42567 0 paperback
Transferred to Digital Reprinting 1999 Printed in the United States of America
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
CONTENTS
Preface
page
Preface to the revised edition 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11
The literature of old Russia, 988-1730 by Jostein Bertnes The eighteenth century: neoclassicism and the Enlightenment, 1730-90 by Ilya Serman The transition to the modern age: sentimentalism and preromanticism, 1790-1820 by Mark Altshuller The nineteenth century: romanticism, 1820-40 by John Mersereaujr. The nineteenth century: the natural school and its aftermath, 1840-55 by Richard Peace The nineteenth century: the age of realism, 1855-80 by Richard Freebom The nineteenth century: between realism and modernism, 1880-95 by Julian Connolly Turn of a century: modernism, 1895-1925 by Evelyn Bristol The twentieth century: the era of socialist realism, 1925-53 by Victor Terras The twentieth century: in search of new ways, 1953-80 by Geoffrey Hosking Afterword: Russian literature in the 1980s by Efim Etkind
vii x 1 45 92 136 189 248 333 387 458 520 595
Bibliography by Charles Moser
615
Index
653
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
PREFACE
This history presents in narrative form a survey of Russian literature from the beginnings to this decade, in sufficient but not overwhelming detail. Those who wish to pursue particular points in more depth will find guidance in the bibliography appended to the volume, which is also in effect an outline of the historiography of Russian literature for approximately the last century, though with emphasis upon studies in western European languages, and especially in English. In 1986, indeed, we marked the centenary of the publication of the first truly influential work on Russian literature in a western language: Eugene Marie Melchior de Vogue's Le Roman russe, which initiated what has turned out to be a sturdy tradition of criticism and scholarship in western languages. In addition, we are approximately at a century's remove from the time when the great pioneer translators of Russian literature into English - Isabel Hapgood in the United States, whose first translations appeared in 1886, and Constance Garnett in England, who started publishing her translations in 1894 - began the careers which would do so much to bring Russian writers to the attention of the English-speaking world. The beginning date of this study is a traditional and a political one: 988, the year of the official christianization of Kievan Rus, now a millennium in the past. The concluding date of 1980 has been chosen more or less as a matter of convenience and contributors have not been forbidden to speak of works published since then if it seemed appropriate. As general editor I have divided the history into ten chapters and chosen what seemed to me appropriate division points. All such division points are necessarily arbitrary to a degree, but I have sought to select years which were
vii Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
PREFACE primarily of literary-historical significance. Of course one cannot altogether ignore politics in literary history, and one division point - the year of Stalin's death, 1953 - has been chosen for reasons both political and literary, in token of the unprecedented literary importance which politics assumed during the Stalinist era. Each of this book's ten chapters has been written by a different hand, that of a specialist in the period for which he or she is responsible. Of the ten, one is a western European, two are former Soviet scholars now in emigration in the west (the general editor is responsible for the English translations of their chapters), three are British, three are American, one a long-term resident of the United States, and the general editor is American. The bibliography emphasizes scholarship in Russian and in western European languages. Thus the general editor has sought to bring an international perspective to this volume. Though each chapter in this book has been composed by a different person, and thus invariably exhibits a different approach, the general editor has made some adjustments to ensure coverage of the material, and in addition has himself written brief introductions to each chapter outlining the nature of literary development during the period described in that chapter. The general editor has stipulated that contributors dealing with Russian literature of the twentieth century should treat works written or published outside the Soviet Union on an equal footing with literature written or published within the Soviet Union since 1917. One of this volume's objectives is to promote the healing of the division between those two branches of Russian literature, a healing which has begun in recent years of a breach which - at least in western scholarship - never should have occurred in the first place. Finally, a word about the always vexing problem of transliteration. Though the bibliography consistently employs the Library of Congress system for Russian transliteration, the body uses a slightly different system easier for those who know no Russian. First names are anglicized when they correspond to widely recognized forms in English, though when an individual of Russian origin is well known in the west under a name in a particular form, that form is used. In chapter one, dealing with the old Russian period, however, most Christian names have been Hellenized
viii Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
PREFACE because of the close links prevailing at that time between Byzantine Greek and Russian culture. The editor would like to express his gratitude to all the contributors to this volume for their cooperation in writing the chapters requested of them and their willingness to adjust portions of their contributions; to Terence Moore, literature editor of the Cambridge University Press; and to the staffs of the Library of Congress and the Gelman Library of George Washington University for their assistance in providing information needed for the editing of the manuscript and the compilation of the bibliography.
IX Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
PREFACE TO THE REVISED EDITION
The revised edition of this history is in its essentials simply a corrected version of the original edition. The chief difference between it and the first edition is an essay on Russian literature in the 1980s, added to the original ten chapters. I thank the author of that essay, Efim Etkind, for writing it so expeditiously, the authors of the original chapters who brought errors to my attention or made additions at my request, and the reviewers of the first edition who had corrections or suggestions to offer. I have also revised the bibliography to include scholarly publications through 1990.
X
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
I
THE LITERATURE OF OLD RUSSIA, 988-1730
The story of Russian literature begins with a date of great significance for Russian political and cultural history: the year 988, when the ruler of Kievan Rus officially accepted Christianity as the new faith of the principality. At that point there was no written literature in Rus, but by his action Prince Vladimir laid the foundations of what we now call medieval Russian literature, even though it would not come into real being — so far as we know from what has reached us after the destruction wrought by the Mongol invasion - for some years thereafter. But the eastern Slavs received an alphabet designed by SS. ConstantineCyril and Methodius, and also fell heir to the rich Byzantine cultural heritage which had been and would be translated from the Greek. When we speak of "literature" in the old Russian period, however, we must understand it as something quite different from our notions of "literature" in the twentieth century. In the first place, most old Russian literature was not what we would consider fictional, or at least it presented itself as dealing with fact and reality. In the earliest period one of the leading literary genres was the chronicle (exemplified by the Primary Chronicle) which built upon the achievements of the Byzantine historians. This genre by its very nature claimed to be factual even though it contained some clearly fictional (or at least non-factual) elements. Another leading genre was hagiography, which dealt with biographical accounts of the lives of Russia's holy men and women: if a saint's life contained fantastic elements, they were meant to be taken seriously, and not regarded as fiction. Even works such as the epic Igor Tale purported to deal with historical matters, though the author obviously took literary liberties with his materials. To be sure, there were semi-fictional or fictional works in old Russian literature from very early on (the Supplication of Daniel the Exile, for example), and their importance increased as the old Russian period approached its end. But this does not alter the fact that "literature" in old Russia dealt primarily with the real world as medieval men saw it, and not with fictionalized accounts of it. In the second place, old Russian literature was highly ideological.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
JOSTEIN B0RTNES From the beginning it was closely linked to the church, and indeed in its first few centuries hardly existed outside it. Among the leading literary genres of Kievan Rus were prayers and sermons, specifically ecclesiastical in nature, as well as hagiography; and the oldest dated manuscript in our possession is the Ostromir Gospel of the mid eleventh century, a work designed as a lectionary. Since the church nurtured literature so carefully during the old Russian period, it was difficult for more secular works to be copied and to survive. This also meant that originality was suspect. Indeed, originality was even dangerous, for it could easily lead to heresy: the writer's chief task was to quote skilfully from those who had gone before him, or to express old and well-tested truths in a novel way. He was ill-advised to offer his readers anything startlingly original. Since the church and the state were closely intertwined in medieval Russia, and since most literature was linked to the church, literature naturally supported the purposes of the state. Far from regarding themselves as antagonists of the state or the ruler, writers for the most part were at one with the objectives of their society and state. There were exceptions to this, of course, as with Prince Kurbsky and his polemic with Ivan the Terrible: but even here the fact that Ivan himself was a leading writer of the sixteenth century points to the closest possible connection between the state and literature. Indeed, in the broad sweep of the history of Russian literature it is only during the nineteenth century and down to the October revolution of 1917 that writers viewed themselves as fundamentally opposed to the state, or as social critics. Both before and after that interlude they have by and large supported the objectives of their society and the state in which they lived. To this it may be added that in the medieval period there was little in the way of literary culture. Many works of the earliest period are anonymous - among them the greatest work of that time, the Igor Tale - or merely attributed to certain individuals, with greater or lesser certainty, on the basis of internal or external evidence. Most writers evidently worked in near isolation, deriving intellectual sustenance from the writings that had gone before them but not from any "literary community" in the modern sense of the word. Indeed there was scarcely anything resembling a professional writer in the medieval period: there were people who wrote, and sometimes very well, but they were really something else: priests or monks or government officials or even tsars. Toward the end of the seventeenth century this situation began to change, so that we may speak of two or three or four identifiable writers who lived at the same time and place and knew one another. Thus Feofan Prokopovich, one of the best writers of the early eighteenth century though he was in fact a high ecclesiastical functionary, could regard the government official and diplomat Antiokh Kantemir as a literary disciple of his. At this time not only did there begin
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
THE LITERATURE OF OLD RUSSIA, 9 8 8 - I 7 3 O to appear something resembling a community of literary men, there also emerged literary works in the modern sense (Kantemir's verse satires, for example), and at times which are important for literary history as distinct from political history. The year 1730 is more important in Russian literary history than it is in Russian political history, for it is a key year for the transition from the rich traditions of an ecclesiastically oriented medieval literature to a secular modern literature. Indeed, as a date in literary history proper it may be the most important one in the entire thousand-year sweep of Russian literature.
O L D R U S S I A N LITERATURE takes its origins from the work of the two Thessalonian brothers Constantine-Cyril (826-69) and Methodius (815-85), the Greek apostles to the Slavs. During their mission to Great Moravia, where they arrived as envoys of the East Roman Emperor in 863, they created a liturgical language enabling them to preach the Christian gospel in the vernacular of the Slavs. This language, today known as Old Church Slavonic, was based on the dialect spoken by the Slav population of the brothers' native Thessaloniki, but it was strongly influenced by Greek models in vocabulary, phraseology, syntax, and style. At the end of the first millennium, linguistic differences among the Slavs were still negligible, and Old Church Slavonic became the common literary idiom of all the Orthodox Slavs. After the death of Methodius, the Moravian church came under Frankish hegemony, and his disciples were exiled. The Cyrillo-Methodian tradition was preserved by Boris of Bulgaria and his son Simeon, whose reign (893-927) is still remembered as the golden age of Bulgarian literature. Ohrid and Preslav emerged as the new centers of Old Church Slavonic where the work of the two preceptors of the Slavs was preserved and a wide range of early patristic and Byzantine writings were translated or adapted from the Greek. From Bulgaria the corpus of Old Church Slavonic literature spread to Kievan Rus, and when Prince Vladimir in 988 finally decided to accept Byzantine Christianity, the Eastern Slavs soon developed a literature of their own on the foundation of the Cyrillo-Methodian and Bulgarian heritage. The corpus of Greek texts translated into Old Church Slavonic by the brothers and their disciples was not arbitrarily chosen, but a hierarchically ordered group of writings, the most important
3 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
JOSTEIN B0RTNES being the books required for liturgical purposes. These included the Leitourgikon (Sluzhebnik) and the Horologion (Chasoslou), containing the prayers and hymns for the fixed yearly cycle; the Triod katanyktion (Triodpostnaya), the Pentekostarion (Triod tsvetnaya), and the Oktoechos (Oktoikh), with prayers and hymns for the moveable cycle; the Lectionaries, drawn from the Gospels, from the Acts and Epistles of the Apostles, and from the Old Testament; the Psalter (Psaltyr); and the Synaxarion (Prolog), a collection of short exegetical sermons and saints' Lives. The oldest dated manuscript to have come down to us from old Russian literature, the Ostromir Gospel (Ostromirovo evangelie), belongs to this set of liturgical texts. It is a Gospel Lectionary copied from a Bulgarian translation for the Novgorod alderman Ostromir in 1056-7. Second in the hierarchy of translated literature came the extended Lives of the saints and the writings of the Church Fathers, in particular the •works of John Chrysostom, Basil the Great, his brother Gregory of Nyssa, and Gregory Nazianzen, the classics of Greek patristic literature. Their writings were either translated separately, or gathered in miscellanies with excerpts from various authors. From early Kievan literature two such miscellanies (Izborniki) have been preserved, copied in 1073 and 1076 for Prince Svyatoslav of Kiev, the former from manuscripts that had belonged to Tsar Simeon of Bulgaria. It also contains a treatise on figures of speech by the Greek rhetorician George Choeroboscus, and a list of twenty-five "secret" books on the Church's index, with a commentary that clearly shows that Church Slavonic literature could attract the reader for many reasons, even in Kievan times: If you want great stories, you may read the Books of Kings. If you crave exciting and edifying reading, you have the Prophets, the Book ofjob, or Jesus Sirach. But if, finally, your demand is for song books, you may read the Psalter. Next to the canon of liturgical, hagiographical, and patristic texts, the Russians received from their western and southern neighbors works belonging to such popular, "lowbrow" genres of Byzantine literature as the apocrypha, stories about the lives of the desert fathers, and chronicles. Among the Old Church Slavonic translations imported from Bulgaria by the beginning of the twelfth century were the Chronicle of John Malalas, a Syrian
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
THE LITERATURE OF OLD RUSSIA, 9 8 8 - I 7 3 O rhetorician of the sixth century, and the Chronicle of George the Monk, called the Sinner (Hamartolos), written in the middle of the ninth century. Both go from the creation of Adam down to their authors' own time. They relate the history of the Jewish people, the Oriental empires, Rome, and the Hellenistic world, culminating in an account of the Byzantine Empire and its role in the history of man's salvation. These chronicles contained a wealth of curious information culled from a variety of sources. Malalas is particularly interesting in this respect: his rambling narrative is interlarded with stories about pagan gods and ancient Greek heroes, sensational miracles and cruel disasters, so that it becomes a kind of Byzantine Trivialliteratur, in contrast to the Chronicle of Hamartolos, in which the monastic ideology is more evident. Byzantine chronicles had a decisive influence on the form and ideological content of old Russian historical writing. The body of translated literature accumulated in Kievan Rus during the first century after Vladimir's conversion corresponds fairly accurately to the selection of books found in monastic libraries throughout the Orthodox world. In this selection there was no place for the classics of ancient Greek literature, still read and studied by educated "humanists" in Byzantium, or for "highbrow" historians like Procopius, Psellus, and Anna Comnena. Even such pseudo-historical works as the Tale of Troy {Skazanie 0 Troe) and the Romance of Alexander (Khronograficheskaya Aleksan-
driya) which might be seen as belonging, however marginally, to the classical tradition, were received in Rus in the context of the chronicles, and interpreted in terms of their Christian world view. Similarly, the sophisticated casuistry of Flavius Josephus' History of the Jewish War, translated by the beginning of the twelfth century, found no response with old Russian readers, whose interest focused on its account of events of biblical history, and on the striking imagery of its battle scenes, which provided original old Russian literature with a whole arsenal of military terms and martial metaphors. The literary corpus received by the Eastern Slavs in Old Church Slavonic translations included the medieval artes dictandi, both in their metrical and in their non-metrical forms. Metrical discourse was first transposed into Old Church Slavonic by ConstantineCyril, whose verse compositions in the new literary idiom closely
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
JOSTEIN B0RTNES follow the patterns of Greek verse. His "Prologue to the Gospels" goes back to the Byzantine dodecasyllable, whereas the meter of his "Eulogy to Gregory Nazianzen" may have been based on Byzantine hexameters. The writing of verbal poetry seems, however, to have been confined to the Cyrillo-Methodian tradition in Moravia and Bulgaria, while in Russia the musical variant was taken up and developed into a national school of Church Slavonic hymnody. This musical poetry has been sadly neglected by historians of old Russian literature, and we are still waiting for the manuscripts to be properly edited and examined. Apart from the hymns of the liturgy, the forms of discourse found in old Russian literature are all versions of the non-metrical ars dicendi, ranging from the highly elaborate rhetoric inherited from the Greek logos epideiktikos, regulated by rhythm as well as by rhyme, to the simple, unadorned style, oscillating between artistic prose and ordinary speech. From Vladimir's conversion until the Tatar invasions in the first half of the thirteenth century, Kiev was the cultural and political center of Rus, the capital, and seat of the metropolitan of the new Russian church. Here, Prince Yaroslav Vladimirovich (ruled 1019-54) strove to emulate the splendor of Byzantine art in its manifold manifestations: architecture, icon painting, music, and literature. This imitation of Byzantine models was not mechanical but active. The artists and writers of old Russia showed their creative skills by taking the models apart into single motifs and elements, selecting certain ones, and recombining them into new configurations. The literary masterpiece of this early Kievan court art is the Sermon on the Law and Grace (Slovo 0 zakone i blagodati), a work
attributed to Metropolitan Hilarion, the first Russian to hold this office, appointed by Prince Yaroslav in 1051. The sermon is written in the form of logos epideiktikos and addressed, as the author explicitly declares in the proem (preamble), "Not to the ignorant, but to those who have feasted most abundantly on the sweetness of books." In accordance with encomiastic rhetoric, its prose is regulated by isocola (couplings of period-members of equal length) and by homoioteleuta (like endings.) The compositional theme of the sermon is the triumph of the grace of Christ over the Law of Moses. In the first part, this
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
THE LITERATURE OF OLD RUSSIA, 9 8 8 - I 7 3 O theme is developed in a series of allegorical antitheses, in which events and characters from the Old Testament are seen as foreshadowings and images of the truth revealed in the Gospels, beginning with the contrast between Hagar and Sarah, borrowed from Saint Paul (Gal. 4:2iff). The central part of the sermon represents the triumph of divine Grace in a sequence of Christological antitheses, seventeen in all (five referring to the birth of Christ, five to His public life, and seven to His Passion). The third and last part, with its final eulogy to Prince Vladimir, celebrates the entry of Rus into Christendom. What was prefigured in the first, allegorical part of the sermon has been fulfilled in the third through the Incarnation of Christ, the event around which the whole sermon is centered. Allegory and fulfillment here correspond to each other zsjigura veritatis and veritas in the conception of history that underlies the rhetorical technique of the sermon. In this conception, taken from the Church Fathers and from Byzantine theology, the Old Testament was seen as a series of prefigurations of Christ and the salvation of future nations, led into the promised land of the Heavenly Kingdom, not by the Law of Moses, but by the Grace of the Lord. History understood in this way does not seek to discover the causal links between events and characters, but rather to interpret them as images of a timeless, archetypal pattern designed by God before the foundation of the world. This conception of history also underlies the representation of Vladimir as the imitator of Constantine the Great. What the latter achieved among Greeks and Romans in subjecting his empire to God, the former has achieved among the people of Rus, and their heavenly glory is the same. Whereas the encomiastic rhetoric of the Sermon on the Law and Grace is a mode of expression typical of the logos epideiktikos, its figural interpretation is not confined to the genre of the encomium. Figural interpretation is more than a rhetorical technique. It is a way of thinking characteristic of early Kievan literature as a whole. The ornate discourse of the encomium was not unanimously accepted in old Russia. There were those who, like the anonymous author of the twelfth-century Sermon to a Brother Stylite (Slovo k bratu stolpniku), refused to write "in artfully interwoven words or in a covert style," preferring the unadorned mode of expression
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
JOSTEIN B0RTNES found in the homilies of Abbot Theodosius of the Kiev Caves Monastery and those of Archbishop Luka Zhidyata of Novgorod, written in the same period as the Sermon on the Law and Grace. The only extant work of Clement Smolyatich, the second Russian to become Metropolitan in Kiev (1147-55), the Epistle Written to Thomas the Presbyter (Poslanie napisano Klimentom
metropolitom
ruskym Fome prozviteru), is a defense of allegorical exegesis. The finest examples of the rhetorical sermon in twelfth-century Russian literature are the works of Cyril, Bishop of Turov (died about 1182). Cyril wrote epistles, parables, prayers, hymns, and sermons. A number of his sermons were included in the old Russian anthologies of Greek homiletics, the Chrysostom (Zlatoust) and the Panegyrikon (Torzhestvennik), a sure sign of their popularity. Most widely admired were his eight Easter sermons. Their compilatory character and lack of originality have been heavily criticized by modern scholars, but Cyril's use of the texts of others does not preclude originality. Cyril would select a verse from the Bible, a passage from John Chrysostom, another from Cyril of Alexandria, a third from Simeon Metaphrastes, and bring them together in a collage of quotations, allusions, and paraphrases. Among Cyril's favorite rhetorical devices are isocolic antitheses and parallelisms, comparisons, and prosopopeia, i.e. fictitious recreations of the speeches and gestures of his personages, as when, for example, in the Sermon on the Deposition, the Mother of God bursts into a long lament while gazing upon her crucified Son. Like the Sermon on the Law and Grace, Cyril's sermons are Christocentric and inspired by an awareness of Christ's presence. But his allegories are less dogmatic and more intuitive, his rhetoric often verges on poetry. The Sermon on the Law and Grace and Cyril's Easter homilies follow a common compositional scheme inherited from Greek epideictic oratory. According to this scheme, a logos may be divided into three main parts: a proem, a "narrative" or exposition of the subject matter, and an epilogue in the form of a eulogy ending in a prayer. In the epideictic oration, the narrative is shortened and concentrated on the elements that enable the author to extol the acts and personal traits of his heroes above their real dimensions by means of rhetorical amplification. But in other variants of the logos epideiktikos the narrative is also amplified in the
8 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
THE LITERATURE OF OLD RUSSIA, 98 8 - 1 73 0 linear dimension, with the result that the eulogy is transformed into an entire account of the life and deeds of the central hero. Both types of amplification are found in hagiography, the most popular of all the literary forms that prospered in Kievan Rus. The models were derived from works translated from the Greek, and by saints' Lives and legends written by the disciples of Constantine and Methodius, whose vitae are among the earliest examples of original Church Slavonic hagiography. The first notable hagiographer in old Russian literature is Nestor, a monk from the Caves Monastery, the monastic center of Kievan Rus. Nestor wrote the Reading on the Life and Slaying of the Blessed Martyrs Boris and Cleb (Chtenie 0 zhitii i 0 pogublenii blazhennuyu strastoterptsu Borisa i Gleba), and the Life of Our Holy Father Theodosius, Abbot of the Caves Monastery (Zhitie prepodobnogo ottsa nashego Feodosiya, igumena pecherskogo), the former belonging to the
abridged type, the latter to the type with expanded narrative. Both works were probably written between 1079 and 1085. In the Life of Saint Theodosius Nestor refers to himself as the author of the Reading, which he had already completed before embarking upon the larger vita. Nestor's Reading is one of three different, but textually interrelated, versions of the same story: the killing of Vladimir's youngest sons by their brother Svyatopolk in the power struggle that ensued upon Vladimir's death in 1015. The throne was first seized by Svyatopolk, but he was later ousted by another brother, Prince Yaroslav Vladimirovich of Novgorod, and died in exile in 1019. The other versions of these events are the chronicle account and the anonymous Narrative and Passion and Eulogy of the Blessed Martyrs Boris and Gleb (Skazanie i strast i pokhvala svyatuyu muche-
niku Borisa i Gleba). The basic story is identical in the various versions, but they differ in the rhetorical treatment of the material. Common to them all is a combination of two distinct modes of expression, one simple and artless, the other containing all the devices of panegyrical oratory. The former mode is used in relating the historical facts, the latter to amplify and interpret the historical narrative. The contrast between the two modes is most pronounced in the chronicle account and in the Narrative, whereas Nestor's style is more balanced. In the Narrative in particular, the martyrs' fictitious soliloquies are composed in the form of highly
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
JOSTEIN B0RTNES
emotionalized laments, with strings of anaphoric isocola, scriptural quotations, and figural juxtapositions. Nestor views the misdeed within the context of universal history, in much the same way as the conversion in the Sermon on the Law and Grace is seen. Vladimir is the new Constantine, Boris and Gleb are compared to Joseph and Benjamin, Svyatopolk to Cain. In spite of such divergences, the religious interpretation of the assassinations is fundamentally similar in all three versions. The brothers' acceptance of a violent death without resistance is represented as an imitatio Christi (imitation of Christ), by which they become partakers in the divine nature of Christ, exercising their powers of intercession in the Kingdom of Heaven as the celestial patrons of their brother Yaroslav and the Christian people ofRus. This celestial aspect of their sainthood is symbolized in the mystical light that surrounds their earthly remains and their posthumous miracles. The light symbolism, less evident in the Reading and in the chronicle account, is a predominant feature of Nestor's miracle stories, in which their exhumed bodies "shone white like snow, and their faces were radiant like those of angels." The use of light symbolism in order to bring out the anagogical dimension of the saints as images of the divine figure of Christ is characteristic of Nestor's hagiographical art, where this anagogical aspect is complementary to the representation of the saints' imitation of Christ's humbled, earthly figure. This complementarity of the human and the divine in the saint's imitatio Christi also determines the structure of Nestor's Life of Saint Theodosius. Nestor never knew Theodosius personally: he entered the Caves Monastery only after the saint's death in 1074. The events forming the story line of his vita represent a selection from what others had told him about the life of his hero. A characteristic feature of the Life of Saint Theodosius is the strong emphasis on the abasement and sufferings of the saint in his childhood. We are repeatedly told that his mother, who objects to his becoming a monk, torments him, beats him to the ground, puts him in chains, and throws him into a dark dungeon. Although the account of the conduct of the saint's mother may seem strikingly realistic, this effect is only of secondary importance in the vita, where the primary function of the saint's humiliations is 10 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
THE LITERATURE OF OLD RUSSIA, 9 8 8 - 1 7 3 O disclosed in his own interpretation of them in imitation of the suffering of Christ: Listen mother, I pray you, listen! The Lord Jesus Christ has abased and humbled himself and given us an example, so that we too should humble ourselves for his sake. Also, he was scorned, spat upon and beaten. And all this he suffered for our salvation. Must we not then with even greater cause suffer in patience, so that we shall gain Christ! In inverse correlation to this imitation of Christ's suffering, the second part of Nestor's narrative is amplified by a series of mystical light visions, transfiguring the life of the saint as abbot of the Caves Monastery into an anagogical prefiguration of his celestial glory, anticipated by his illumination in the light of Christ, the Sun of Justice, in the vision that accompanies Nestor's account of the saint's baptism. Figural interpretation thus provided Nestor with the pattern underlying his rhetorical transformation of Theodosius into an image of Christ in both his human and in his divine aspects. In his Life of Saint Theodosius Nestor recalls that Theodosius in his youth had wanted to join a group of pilgrims to the Holy Land, "where Our Lord had walked in the flesh." But God would not let him leave his own country, according to Nestor, and the pilgrims departed without him. Russian pilgrimages to the holy places of Palestine began soon after the conversion, but the earliest account of such a journey extant in old Russian literature is the Life and Pilgrimage of Abbot Daniel from the Land ofRus (Zhitie i khozhdenie Danila ruskyya zemli
igumena). We know little about the author, who was probably the abbot of a monastery in the principality of Chernigov. He spent sixteen months in the Holy Land in 1106-8, travelling with a large retinue and employing professional guides everywhere. In Jerusalem he was received by Baldwin I, King of Jerusalem, under whose protection he was able to go to places normally inaccessible to visitors. During the Easter Service at the Holy Sepulchre, the king placed Daniel next to himself. The Pilgrimage is first and foremost a description of the holy places associated with the life story of Jesus Christ. Daniel sees these places both in their biblical context and in their natural environment, endeavoring to convey to his Russian readers the emotional effect they had on him. He walks along the banks of the river Jordan "with love," comparing it to the river Snov back in II Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
JOSTEIN B0RTNES Rus, kisses the place of Christ's Transfiguration "with love and tears," and exclaims at the first sight ofJerusalem that "no one can hold back his tears at the sight of this much longed-for land of these holy places, where Christ Our Lord endured sufferings for the sake of us sinners." The pilgrimage culminates in the celebration of the Easter Service, when Daniel kindles a light by the sacred fire "on behalf of the whole Russian land." From the point of view of genre, Daniel's Pilgrimage represents a rather free version of the Greek proskynetarion, a form that emerged in the tenth century in imitation of the Latin itinerarium. As with the Latin variant, Daniel's itinerary displays a personal tone, in contrast to the proskynetaria, which provide impersonal descriptions of various places of worship in and around Jerusalem, meant as guides for pilgrims to the services arranged especially for them. Whether Nestor the hagiographer also wrote the Primary Chronicle (Povest vremennykh let), we shall probably never know. Arguments have been advanced both for and against this attribution, based on a reference to "Nestor, the monk of Theodosius' Caves Monastery" in a sixteenth-century copy of the Primary Chronicle and on references in the oldest, twelfth-century part of the Paterikon of the Caves Monastery (Kievo-pechersky paterik) to Nestor "who
wrote the Chronicle." Current scholarship commonly sees Nestor as the author of the first comprehensive redaction of the Primary Chronicle, compiled about 1113 on the basis of at least two earlier texts. This redaction was revised about 1117 by Abbot Silvester of the Kievan Monastery of Saint Michael, while another version was prepared for Prince Mstislav Vladimirovich in the Caves Monastery in 1118. Silvester's redaction is believed to have been preserved in the Laurentian codex of 1377, and the redaction of 1118 in the Hypatian codex, dating from the 1420s. These are the oldest surviving manuscripts of the old Russian chronicles. The Laurentian codex contains under 1096 the Instruction (Pouchenie) of Prince
Vladimir Monomakh on Christian virtues and Christian behavior, addressed to his children. Modelled on Byzantine sources, the work draws heavily on Scripture, and was obviously meant as a practical manual for ruling princes in a newly converted Christian society. In its basic outline this reconstruction of the development of the Primary Chronicle goes back to the investigations of Alexey Shakh12 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
THE LITERATURE OF OLD RUSSIA, 9 8 8 - I 7 3 O matov at the beginning of this century. With slight modifications, his hypothetical reconstruction is generally accepted in current scholarship. From a literary point of view, the Primary Chronicle is an unusual work, an accumulation of very heterogeneous texts strung together according to a simple chronological principle. This form was probably taken over from the Paschal calendars, tables showing the dates of Easter for a number of years in succession with columns for the recording of important events under each year. This simple cumulative structure still shows through in places where the text is reduced to the mere enumeration of years, with no subsequent entry. However, all the events listed in this way are unique: they stand out against the background of the ordinary, that which is not worth recording. Expanded into narratives, these records retain their anecdotal, legendary form. This annalistic cumulation of extraordinary events is theoretically unlimited: it has no beginning, and could go on forever. Only by inserting into his own annalistic recordings excerpts from translated Byzantine chronicles can the author of the Primary Chronicle provide his own work with a beginning, a middle, and an end. The Primary Chronicle opens with a story about the division of the earth among the sons of Noah after the flood, when the northern and western lands, among them the land of Rus, went to Japheth, and of the building of the Tower of Babel, when God scattered His people over the face of the earth and the linguistic and ethnic unity of mankind gave way to a multiplicity of nations and languages. This story, known in Kievan Rus from works such as the Chronicle of George Hamartolos, is further combined with passages from an unidentified story about the migrations and early history of the Slavs, leading up to the legendary description of the foundation of Kiev and the emergence of Rus. The technique used by the author of the Primary Chronicle is identical with that employed in the Sermon on the Law and Grace. By bringing his domestic records together with passages quoted from other texts, the author of the Primary Chronicle likewise integrates the history of Rus into the context of world history, interpreted teleologically, as an eschatological process, beginning with the fall of Adam and the expulsion from Paradise, and moving towards the final Day of 13 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
JOSTEIN B0RTNES
Judgement, when history will come to an end. Furthermore, this linear conception of history is complemented by a spatial dimension, in which historical events and characters are transformed into a network of prefigurations and fulfillments centered around the Incarnation and expiatory Passion of Christ. In the Primary Chronicle this figural interpretation emerges in the "philosopher's speech," inserted into the chronicle under 986 in the form of a didactic dialogue between an anonymous philosopher "sent by the Greeks" and Prince Vladimir, on the eve of the baptism of Rus. Its sources have not been identified, but there can be no doubt of its Greek origin. The philosopher's speech interprets events in the Old Testament as anticipations of the coming of Christ and the spreading of the Gospel to the "new nations." Similarly, the imminent conversion of Vladimir and his people is seen as a fulfilment of Old Testament prophecies. In his allegorical exegesis of the story of Gideon (Judges VI), the philosopher employs the very terms "prefiguration" (preobrazhenie) and "prefigured" (preobrazi) in order to bring out its hidden meaning: dew (on the fleece) prefigures the baptism of the new nations. This figuration enables the chronicler to carry the method over into his own description of the Russians. With the help of biblical quotations he interprets the baptism of his own people as an imitatio Christi: Praised be our Lord Jesus Christ, who loved His new people, the kingdom of Rus, and illuminated it with holy baptism . . . Saint Paul says: "Brothers! All of us who have been baptized into Jesus Christ were baptized into His death." We were buried therefore with him by baptism into death, so that as Christ was raised from the dead by the glory of the Father, we too might walk in newness of life. The "philosopher's speech" and the eulogy to Vladimir that follows belong to a group of texts that together represent the ecclesiastical strain in the early redactions of the Primary Chronicle. This group includes episodes such as the baptism and death of Olga, the martyrdom of the first Varangian Christians, the slaying of Boris, and Gleb, and the eulogy to Prince Yaroslav under the year 1037. To this group may be added the introduction on the origins and history of the Eastern Slavs. Stylistically, these passages are characterized by a combination of crisp and simple 14 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
THE LITERATURE OF OLD RUSSIA, 9 8 8 - I 7 3 O narrative, verging on the vernacular, with rhetorical elements typical of the Church Slavonic encomium. A very different style prevails in the episodes dealing with the coming of the Varangians and the history of the Varangian rulers in pre-Christian Rus. Told in the form of short, pointed independent anecdotes, often culminating in dramatic dialogues, these episodes reflect an oral epic tradition, and have been associated with the Varangian element in the retinue of the Kievan princes. Some of them are clearly based on motifs also found in old Norse literature. Well known examples are the combat tale of Mstislav and Rededya under the year 1022, the description of Olga's (Scand. Helga) murder of her suitors to avenge her dead husband Igor (Scand. Ingvarr) under 945 (which has its counterpart in the story about Sigrid Storrada in the Olaf Tryggvasson Saga), or the death of Oleg (Scand. Helgi), bitten by a snake which suddenly emerges from the skull of his favorite horse. In this part of the chronicle Prince Vladimir is no longer the Christian ruler but a Varangian warrior who ravishes Rogned (Scand. Ragnheidr), the daughter of the Varangian Prince Rogvolod (Scand. Ragnvaldr) of Polotsk. The story of her unsuccessful revenge occurs in another variant in the story of Gudrun, Ironbeard's daughter, in the Olaf Tryggvasson Saga.
Correspondences such as these have given rise to the theory that the Varangians brought their own oral epic tradition with them from Scandinavia to Rus. More plausible, however, is the explanation put forward by Adolf Stender-Petersen, who suggests that both the old Russian and the old Norse material reflect a GreekByzantine tradition passed on to Varangian merchants and mercenaries in Byzantium and carried back to Kiev and Scandinavia. From this perspective, the tales about Gudrun, Rogned and Sigrid appear as echoes of ancient Greek heroic tales. One of the most enigmatic heroes of the Primary Chronicle is Prince Vseslav of Polotsk, whose birth is recorded under 1044. Conceived by magic, he was born with a caul which his mother was told by magicians to bind upon the child that he might bear it for the rest of his life. This he did, and so was "merciless in bloodshed," according to the chronicler. The figure of Vseslav is surrounded by ominous signs: a large star appeared "as if it were made of blood," the sun was "like the moon," and these signs 15 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
JOSTEIN B0RTNES "portended bloodshed." By combining the account of Vseslav given in the Primary Chronicle with the description of him in the Igor Tale and with the figure of Volkh (i.e. wolf) Vseslavevich of the byliny, it is possible to reconstruct an old Russian Vseslav epic about the prince-werewolf, based on an ancient werewolf myth also reflected in Serbo-Croatian epic poetry and deeply rooted in the Indo-European tradition common to both Slavs and Scandinavians (Roman Jakobson and Marc Szeftel). Vseslav of Polotsk is the hero of an extensive digression in the Igor Tale (Slovo o polku Igoreve), in which the description alternates between his diurnal life as prince and warrior, and his nocturnal adventures as a werewolf: Vseslav the prince sat in judgement over men, as prince he ruled over cities; but at night he coursed as a wolf; running from Kiev to the ramparts of Tmutorokan, as a wolf he crossed the path of Great Hors. For him the bells rang early for matins in Polotsk at St. Sophia, but he heard the ringing in Kiev. The folkloric character of this passage is reinforced by the reference to the Great Hors, an Iranian borrowing designating the radiant sun, another name for Dazhbog ("giver of wealth"), the sun god of the pagan Slavs. In the Igor Tale the old pagan deities have lost their cultic value. Like the werewolf myth, they seem to belong to an oral epic tradition exploited by the author of the Tale for purely poetic purposes. When the Igor Tale was published in 1800, nine years after it had been acquired by Prince Alexey Musin-Pushkin, it was immediately regarded as an oral epic and even compared to the poems of Ossian. The correspondences between the Tale and James Macpherson's forgeries were subsequently used as an argument against the authenticity of the old Russian manuscript, which perished in the Moscow fire of 1812, so that the text only survives in the first edition and in a copy made for Catherine II in 1795-6. The authenticity of the Tale has been challenged by a number of scholars, but the philological evidence supporting its genuineness is now overwhelming. It would not have been possible to reconstruct the old Russian and Turkic forms found in the Tale in 16 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
THE LITERATURE OF OLD RUSSIA, 9 8 8 - I 7 3 O Catherine H's Russia, or in the sixteenth century, a date that has also been suggested for its composition. Furthermore, the Igor Tale no longer appears as an isolated work in pre-Tatar Rus. Parallels to its style and imagery have been found in Cyril of Turov's sermons and in the Sermon on the Resurrection of Lazarus (Slovo 0 Lazarevom voskresenii), an anonymous homily dating from the same period. Words and phrases once regarded as unique in the Tale have been identified with expressions found in texts such as the chronicles, Flavius Josephus' History of the Jewish War, and the old Russian Digenis Akritas romance. The Igor Tale must have been composed in the years between 1185, when the events that form its subject matter took place, and 1 October 1187, the death date of Igor's father-in-law, Prince Yaroslav Osmomysl of Galich, referred to as still living in the Tale. The Igor Tale describes a campaign against the Polovtsians, Turkic nomads who had appeared in the southeastern steppes in the middle of the eleventh century. The campaign, led by Igor Svyatoslavich, Prince of Novgorod-Seversk, was only an episode in the wars against this people but is recorded both in the Laurentian and in the Hypatian copies of the chronicle. On 23 April 1185, Igor set off with his son Vladimir and his nephew Svyatoslav Olgovich. In spite of a bad omen - a total eclipse of the sun - the Russians decided to cross the Donets river and attack the Polovtsians. At first they were successful, and the enemy fled. But when they decided to spend the night in the abandoned Polovtsian camp instead of retreating with their spoils, they were taken by surprise, and defeated. Igor was taken prisoner and spent about five weeks in Polovtsian captivity, from which he escaped in June 1185. The basic sequence of events is roughly the same in the Kievan chronicle (the Hypatian codex) and in the Tale. The difference between them lies in the rhetorical treatment of the material. On the one hand, the anonymous author of the Tale has condensed his subject matter so greatly as to make it well-nigh incomprehensible to an audience unfamiliar with its historical context. On the other hand, he has amplified his condensed narrative by a series of digressions, creating a network of similarities and contrasts between the princes of his own troubled present, fighting each other in ruinous wars, and the heroes of a legendary, united past, 17 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
JOSTEIN B0RTNES between his own style and the devices of Boyan, the "vatic singer" of old. Lyrical exclamations and emotional appeals, laments and eulogies interrupt the story. The poetic imagery transforms men and animals, plants and trees into a complex pattern of metaphoric and metonymic equivalences. The author has translated his troubled premonitions of the ruin of Rus into a poetic vision of tragic portent. The intricate imagery of the Igor Tale has been compared to similar instances of enigmatic speech and ornament in other twelfth-century European literature, to scaldic poetry, and to Wolfram's epic. The corresponding old Russian mode of expression is the parabolic-figurative style inherited from Byzantine epideictic rhetoric. It is from the Byzanto-Slavonic logos epideiktikos that the Tale derives its encomiastic composition: first a proem in which the author addresses his audience and introduces his theme, followed by the central part of the narrative, with digressions and interruptions characteristic of encomiastic glorification, and concluded by an epilogue in the form of afinalhymn of praise celebrating the happy return of Igor, his son, and his brother. The Supplication and Address of Daniel the Exile (Molenie i Slovo Daniila Zatochnika) is known in two versions, the Supplication and
the Address, surviving in copies from the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries, both going back to an original believed to date from the last decades before the Tatar invasions. Neither the author of the petition, Daniel, nor its addressee, a certain Prince Yaroslav, has been identified, and it may well be that the work is pure fiction. Daniel has for unknown reasons fallen into poverty and been abandoned by his friends and family. He turns to the prince for material support, hoping that his wit will be rewarded. He begins his appeal to the prince with a sycophantic eulogy, which gradually changes into facetious satire centered around the two traditional motifs of evil wives and self-indulgent monks. The text is a patchwork of quotations from biblical and secular sources, aphorisms, and quasi-popular proverbs, ranging from a description of the prince in words taken from the Song of Solomon "sweet is thy voice, thy lips drop as the honeycomb, . . . thy cheeks are like a bed of spices . . . thy countenance is as Lebanon, excellent as the cedars . .. thy belly is like an heap of wheat..." to misogynous adages ("I should rather take a fiery bull into my 18 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
THE LITERATURE OF OLD RUSSIA, 9 8 8 - I 7 3 O house than an evil wife") and sarcastic ribaldry ("I have never seen a dead man riding on a swine, nor the devil on a woman"). Though he boasts of his own wisdom, Daniel does not flinch from selfmockery: "I am not wise, but have only donned the robes of those who are, and put on their boots." His pompous onset - "Let us trumpet forth, o brethren, as on a trumpet of gold, on the wisdom of our wit" - sounds like a parody of an epic invocation. The whole petition is, in fact, a kind of parody, and it has been suggested that it belongs to the jocular folklore of the skomorokhi, the wandering minstrels of old Russia who were persecuted by the church and could only survive on the fringes of old Russian culture. The difficulty with this explanation is that the Supplication is not folkloric, but a written composition. Its generic origin is more likely to be found in Byzantine literature, in particular in satires such as the demotic verse supplications of the twelfth-century writer Theodore Prodromos, a nephew of the Metropolitan John of Kiev, and his contemporary, Michael Glykas. Addressed to the Emperor and other high-ranking persons, these poems combine coarse realism and a macabre sense of humor with malicious satire, flattery and shameless begging. Recurrent motifs in these supplications include the plight of a husband married to a cantankerous wife, an innocent suffering in jail, the scholar's wretched existence as opposed to the comfort enjoyed by ignorant artisans, and the contrast between simple monks, living in utter misery, and the meanness of wealthy abbots. Daniel's Supplication appears to be a unique example of this particular genre in Kievan Rus. In 1223 a large army suddenly invaded the land of Rus from the south and dealt a crushing defeat to a coalition of Russian and Polovtsian armies on the Kalka River, before disappearing as quickly as they had come, leaving the Russians totally bewildered. This was their first reaction to the Mongols, or Tatars, as they were always called in Russia. In 1237-41 they returned to central Russia, ravaging towns and villages, massacring all who dared to resist them, but leaving the country's political institutions intact. The city of Ryazan was devastated in 1237, Vladimir in 1238, and in 1240 Kiev was sacked. The whole of northeast Russia and Novgorod became tributary lands of the Golden Horde, a branch of the Mongols' vast Asian empire controlled by Khan Batu, a grandson of Chingis Khan. The administrative center of the Horde 19 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
JOSTEIN B0RTNES
was the city of Sarai on the lower Volga, where the Russian princes now had to go for their investiture, in order to pledge allegiance to the khan. Some of them even undertook the long journey to Karakorum in central Mongolia, the capital of the empire. The Tatars established a rule in Russia based on tribute, which the local princes were obliged to pay under the threat of new reprisals, with only the Russian Church granted exemption from Tatar taxation: according to the Laurentian Chronicle, "abbots, monks, priests, members of the clergy and those who vow loyalty to the Holy Mother of God and the bishop" went free. Throughout the years of Tatar rule the Russian metropolitanate thus continued to exercise jurisdiction over the whole of Russia, and the Church remained the center of Russian civilization, the guardian of the religious and cultural values of the country. Metropolitan Cyril, who had first supported Daniel of Galicia's contacts with the papacy and the Catholic kingdoms of central Europe, eventually decided to transfer his allegiance to the khans at Sarai, and in 1250 travelled to Vladimir, where he established close ties with Alexander Nevsky, prince of Novgorod (r. 1240-52) and grand prince of Vladimir (r. 1252-63). Alexander, who in 1240 had defeated the Swedes on the Neva river and in 1242 won the battle against the Teutonic Knights on the ice of Lake Peipus, was confirmed by Khan Batu as a grand prince. In his anti-western, pro-Mongol policy, Alexander acted with the support of both the Russian metropolitan and the Byzantine patriarch, who saw in the Mongol ruler a safeguard against western expansionism while, they believed, the religious tolerance of the Tatars would guarantee the independence of the Orthodox Church. In 1299 the metropolitanate was moved from the southwest to the city of Vladimir, the capital of the northern grand princes. The result of all this was that Russian civilization now survived and continued to develop in the north and east, in Novgorod and the principalities on the upper Volga, Moscow, Vladimir, Kostroma, Yaroslavl and Tver. Towards the end of the Tatar yoke, Moscow emerged as the new political and cultural center of Russia. Hagiography remained a predominant genre in this period of old Russian literature, and a number of Lives were written to commemorate the monastery builders of the north, such as Saint 20
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
THE LITERATURE OF OLD RUSSIA, 9 8 8 - I 7 3 O Leonty Rostovsky, Saint Nikita of Pereyaslavl-Zalessky, Saint Varlaam of Khutyn, and others. More interesting from the point of view of literary history, however, is the development of princely Lives and martyr passions in this period. The cult of the ruler and the martyred prince was a characteristic feature of Kievan Rus. In the eleventh century this cult had found its literary expression in eulogies to Olga and Vladimir and their descendants, and in passion stories about Boris and Gleb. In subsequent centuries both forms found their way into the chronicles. The appanage princes of Novgorod and Vladimir, for example, were glorified according to the hagiographical schemes developed in Kievan literature. One of the most moving princely martyr passions is the story of Igor Olgovich, recorded in the Kievan Chronicle under 1147. The central motif is the prince's imitatio Christi through suffering, and like Boris and Gleb, Igor is killed by his brothers in the struggle for power. With the Tatar invasions, the princely Lives and passions acquired new significance. The martyrologion was chosen to represent the steadfastness of Russian princes tortured and killed by the henchmen of the khans, whereas the Life was used to glorify Alexander Nevsky, the secular hero embodying the policy of the Orthodox Church. The new historical context engenders a marked change in the selection of motifs. The imitatio Christi motif disappears and the motif of fratricide is often suppressed, as the rivalry of the Russian princes for the khan's favor is played down. A typical princely passion from this period is the Story of the Murder of Prince Michael of Chernigov and his Boyar Feodor in the Horde (Skazanie ob ubienii v orde knyazya Mikhaila Chernigovskogo i
ego boyarina Feodora). The murder took place in 1246, when the prince had gone to Sarai, probably in order to receive his decree from the khan, even though the story gives as the reason for his journey his desire to expose the khan's deceit. As in the early martyr passions, the khan - or tsar, as he is called here, and was always officially called in Russia - represents the power of this world, whereas the two Russians stand for a higher, divine authority. In accordance with church teachings, the two Christians are prepared to accept the khan's superiority in secular matters, but they firmly refuse to take part in a pagan fire-ritual and to bow to 21 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
JOSTEIN B0RTNES the sun and the idols of the Tatars: "I bow to you, O tsar, for God has given you the tsardom and the glory of this world." Rather than betray their Christian faith, they suffer torture and a terrible death at the hands of the khan's people. The story thus has an ideological message, reflecting the Realpolitik of the Russian Church under Tatar rule. A similar combination of political realism and hagiographical ideals appears in the Tale of the Life and Valor of the Faithful and Grand Prince Alexander (Povest o zhitii i o khrabrosti blagovernogo i
velikogo knyazya Aleksandra), written shortly after his death in 1263 by an author who had known him personally. The Life makes no attempt to describe Alexander Nevsky's biography in detail, but rather concentrates on the main events of his political career, his victories over the Swedes, the Livonians, and the Teutonic Knights. His humiliating relationship with the khan, on the other hand, is glossed over. The style of the Life is a mixture of hagiographical and martial rhetoric. Alexander is compared to Joseph the Beautiful in appearance, to Samson in strength, to Solomon in wisdom, and in military prowess to the Emperor Vespasian, known from Flavius Josephus. Before the battle against the Swedes, a vision foreshadows the invisible assistance of Boris and Gleb heading a heavenly host of warriors. In the battle on Lake Peipus against the Teutonic Knights, Alexander's army is likened to the warriors of King David, and in his prayers the prince remembers the victories of Moses and Yaroslav. Heavenly hosts appear in the sky, and with their help Alexander conquers the German invaders. These hagiographical elements create an otherworldly framework for the battle scenes, described with the precision of the military tales of the chronicles: "And when the sun rose, the enemies met. And there was a cruel fight. And a cracking of snapping spears. And a clanging of clashing swords. And it was as if the frozen lake was moving. And the ice could not be seen, covered as it was with blood." The combination of two different stylistic registers within it has given rise to the theory that the Life was originally written in the form of a secular biography. As long as this notion is not corroborated by textological studies, however, there is no reason to assume that the hagiographical element is secondary. On the 22 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
THE LITERATURE OF OLD RUSSIA, 9 8 8 - I 7 3 O contrary, these elements give the Life of Alexander Nevsky its deeper significance, transforming its hero into a vehicle of God's will. The traumatic effect of the Mongol invasions is reflected in the military tales, a group of texts composed in the second half of the thirteenth century and the early fourteenth. None of them survives as an individual work: they have been incorporated in larger compilations like the chronicles. The Tale of the Battle on the River Kalka (Povest 0 bitve na Kalke) interprets the first Tatar incursion as God's punishment for the sins of the Russian people, and sees in their sudden departure a sign that the end of the world is near. The style is simple and prosaic, as in so many of the military chronicle tales. In contrast to the unsophisticated narrative of the battle on the Kalka, the Tale of Batu's Sacking of Ryazan (Povest 0 razorenii
Ryazani Batyem) is a complex epic work of great poetic beauty. Using a lyrical mode of expression, the author recalls how the city was destroyed, and how its princes, the Ingvarevichi, were savagely killed, "all together emptying the same chalice of death." Passages cast in the martial style alternate with hagiographical rhetoric. In their laments, the dramatis personae give voice to their despair at the misfortune that has befallen the country. The author bewails the martyrdom of the young and beautiful princes Oleg and Feodor, of Eupraxia, who jumped from a tower to escape the khan's embraces, and Agrippina with all her daughters and daughters-in-law, killed in the church where they had sought refuge. In the central part, the boyar Evpaty Kolovrat, a true epic hero, gathers around him a small host of men "whom God had preserved" and sets out against the enemy. Echoing the folk epic, the tale describes how Evpaty kills one of the Tatar chiefs in single combat, and how the khan, when the Russians finally bring their dead hero before him, sends for his "mirzas, and his princes, and his snachuk-beys, and all were amazed at the courage, fortitude, and bravery of the Ryazan warriors." The tale ends with the burial of the dead princes, whose earthly remains have been collected and brought back to Ryazan by Prince Ingvar Ingorevich. Order has been restored, and Ingvar's lament for his dead brothers concludes with an invocation of Boris and Gleb for help against the enemy. On 8 September 1380, a Russian army led by the Grand Prince 23 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
JOSTEIN B0RTNES
Dmitry Ivanovich of Moscow (Donskoy) defeated Khan Mamai and his army on the Kulikovo field on the upper Don, less than 200 miles south of Moscow. This was the first time the Russians had bested the Mongols, and the victory was undoubtedly of great psychological importance both to the Russians and to the Mongols: though the Tatar yoke would last for another century and more, it showed that the invaders were vulnerable. By 1393, the account of the victory had been turned into an epic composition by Sofoniya of Ryazan, of whom nothing is known but his name. His work is today called the Zadonshchina (The Battle Beyond the Don), a title it received in the earliest of its six extant copies, dating from the 1470s. The Zadonshchina was composed in conscious imitation of the Igor Tale: the epic movement from initial disaster to final success for the Russians on the Don in 1380 mirrors the movement from triumphant victory to total surrender on the Kayala in 1185. According to Roman Jakobson's ingenious conjecture, this mirror symmetry is a deliberate device employed by the author in order to bring together in a diptych his own original Lament and Encomium and an old Lament "copied from books", i.e. the Igor Tale. Or, to quote from Sofoniya's proem: "First I wrote down the Lament of the Russian land and so forth, citing from books. After that I composed the Lament and Praise to Grand Prince Dmitry [.. .] let us adjoin Tale to Tale." Like the author of the Igor Tale, Sofoniya refers back to the "vatic Boyan." But the archaic imagery associated with this legendary figure in the Tale is no longer understood by the author of the Zadonshchina. He reduces the nature symbolism of the older work to much simpler figures. The wolf-symbolism of the Tale, for instance, reappears in the Zadonshchina as a negative parallelism: "And the grey wolves [...] want to advance against the Russian land. Those were not grey wolves, but the pagan Tatars [...]" Moreover, Sofoniya's discourse is multistyled, with elements borrowed from the chronicles and the military tales, such as the contrast between pagans and Christians, the topos "God has punished the Russian land for its sins," the princes' prayers before the battle, etc. In spite of all these differences, however, the esthetic significance of the Zadonshchina depends on its relationship to the Igor Tale. The tragic vision of the ruin of Rus in the Tale is 24 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
THE LITERATURE OF OLD RUSSIA, 9 8 8 - 1 7 3 O counterbalanced in Sofoniya's work by a new vision of "the glorious town of Moscow." The rise of Moscow as the new center of Russian culture is due most of all to the influence of Metropolitan Cyprian. Little is known about Cyprian's early years. He probably spent some time as a monk on Mount Athos, where he was trained in the hesychast tradition of contemplative prayer. At the beginning of the 1370s, he was taken into the service of the pro-hesychast Patriarch Philotheos, and soon became one of his trusted men. In 1375 he was appointed metropolitan of Kiev and Lithuania, and in 1390 finally moved to Moscow, after a brief and unsuccessful stay there in 1381-2. An accomplished diplomat, theologian and man of letters, Cyprian was a typical representative of "political hesychasm," advanced by a group of ecclesiastical princes who, in the second half of the fourteenth century, worked together to restore and preserve the unity of the Orthodox Church under the patriarchate of Constantinople. To this group also belonged Patriarch Euthymius of Trnovo and his pupil Gregory Tsamblak, both friends and colleagues of Cyprian's, and in Russia such distinguished church leaders as Sergius of Radonezh and his nephew Theodore, Abbot of the Simonov Monastery and Grand Prince Dmitry Donskoy's confessor, later bishop of Rostov. Cyprian contributed actively to the spread of hesychast theology in Russia. He translated texts promoting hesychast doctrine from Greek into Church Slavonic, among them the Ladder of John Climacus and certain writings of Dionysius the Areopagite. Furthermore, he revised the Russian ritual in order to bring it more in accordance with Byzantine practice. In the years before his death in 1406, he was involved in the compilation of the first comprehensive Moscow chronicle, completed in 1408. His major works as a man of letters are his two versions of the Life of Metropolitan Peter (Zhitie metropolita Petra, ruled 1308-26), based on an earlier Life of Peter commissioned by Ivan Kalita in 1327 to commemorate Peter's translation of the metropolitanate from Vladimir to Moscow. Cyprian's first and shorter version may have been written in 1381-2, during his initial incumbency in Moscow, whereas the longer version was written after 1385, probably after Cyprian's return to Moscow in 1390. In Cyprian's Life, Peter is depicted as the incarnation of 25 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
JOSTEIN B0RTNES fourteenth-century hesychasm in both its aspects, the mystical and the political. During his years of monastic apprenticeship the saint spent his days in meditation, setting up a ladder of ascent in his heart [...] according to the instruction and teaching of Saint John Climacus [...] soon he had learnt the painting of Holy Icons [...] and through this all his spirit and mind were carried away from earthly things, and in spirit he was wholly deified [...] lifting his mind from these painted images to their archetypes. The saint's mystical theosis and the Orthodox theology of the Holy Icons are here described with a precision which itself testifies to Cyprian's hesychast background. By the same token, his account of Peter's career as a church leader is accompanied by a vision of the saint as the servant of the Holy Mother of God and her Son and Lord, the heavenly archetype of the hesychast bishop. This relationship between Christ and his servant is extended to Cyprian himself, who in his concluding eulogy to Peter projects the main events of his own life onto the life story of his protagonist, emphasizing the correspondences between them. The eulogy ends with a depiction of "our glorious Orthodox princes" venerating the saint's relics. Receiving blessings with all the Orthodox, praising the Lifegiving Trinity, the secular princes are represented humbly kneeling before Metropolitan Cyprian, the image of the divine prototype of Christ. Cyprian's expanded Life of Peter is commonly regarded as the first example in old Russian hagiography of a new hagiographical style, captivating the audience more by rhetorical embellishment than by reliable and sober narration. Cyprian's style is thus intermediate between the neo-Slavic rhetoric of fourteenth-century Bulgarian and Serbian hagiography, and its Russian counterpart, known as "word-weaving" (pletenie sloves), a Greek caique. In early Muscovite literature, "word-weaving" is usually associated with the hagiographical writings of Epiphanius the Wise and Pachomius the Serb. The Life of Saint Stephen, Bishop of Perm (Zhitie svyatogo Stefana, episkopa Permskogo), written by the monk Epiphanius the Wise soon after Stephen's death in 1396, is known in an early sixteenthcentury copy, believed to be identical with Epiphanius' original composition. 26 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
THE LITERATURE OF OLD RUSSIA, 9 8 8 - I 7 3 O Saint Stephen brought the Gospel to the Finnish Zyrians (the Permians of the Life) and translated the Christian Scriptures into their language. The hagiographical significance of this is brought out in a comparison with the missionary work of the Apostles and with Constantine-Cyril. By these parallels, the conversion of the Permians is integrated into the history of salvation, seen as a linear progress beginning with the Fall and moving towards the Day of Judgement, a temporal process that has its spatial correlative in the expansion of the Russian Church to the land of Perm. A similar chronotope determines the representation of Stephen's ascent in the hierarchy of the Church in the form of a movement in time and geographical space. From his home town of Ustyug he moves to Rostov, where he is shorn a monk, ordained as deacon, and receives his priesthood, before proceeding to Moscow and to Perm, returning back to Moscow to become bishop. This idea* of sanctification as an ascent in the ecclesiastical hierarchy is one of the two ways to divine knowledge described by Dionysius the Areopagite, the other being the way of spiritual ascent in contemplation of the divine mysteries. In the writings of the Areopagite the two ways are equal, one belonging to the personal sphere, the other to the sphere of the Church as a social institution. What is remarkable in the Life of Saint Stephen is the one-sided emphasis on social and political themes. Ideologically, the Life of Saint Stephen is a document of political hesychasm; its mystical, contemplative aspect has been suppressed. By his own admission Epiphanius wrote the Life of Saint Stephen "to praise the preacher of faith, Perm's teacher, and the Apostles' successor." Thus the Life was conceived as an encomium. In a series of rhetorical amplifications, culminating in three final laments in commemoration of the saint, Epiphanius exploits the whole register of Church Slavonic devices, following the exemplars of Kievan oratory and of the neo-Slavonic logos epideiktikos of Serbian hagiography developed in the thirteenth and fourteenth centuries. This ornamental style of "word-weaving," with its paronomastic repetitions, synonyms, isocola and homoioteleuta, is brought to a flamboyant apex in Epiphanius' tirades. Before his death about 1420, Epiphanius wrote the Life of Saint Sergius of Radonezh (Zhitie svyatogo Sergiya Radonezhskogo,
1314-92), the founder of the Monastery of the Holy Trinity north 27 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
JOSTEIN B0RTNES of Moscow, and one of the leaders of monastic hesy chasm in early Muscovite Russia. This Life was rewritten by Pachomius the Serb soon after his arrival in Russia about 1440, and has only been preserved in this revised version. Pachomius had received his education on Mount Athos, and was fully familiar with the ornate style of Serbian literature. For the next forty years Pachomius was active in both Novgorod and Moscow, revising old saints' Lives and writing new ones. Besides this, Pachomius composed a number of canons with which he laid the foundations of an original Muscovite hymnography. In the Life of Saint Sergius, the devices of "wordweaving" are used less conspicuously than in the Life of Saint Stephen, and there is more emphasis on narrative. At the same time, Pachomius introduces into his glorification of the saint a number of light visions, a motif not found in Epiphanius' eulogy to Stephen of Perm. The light visions reflect the inner ascent and mystical illumination of Sergius, creating a link between his figure and the illuminated figure of Nestor's Saint Theodosius. The correspondences between the two saints are hardly accidental. They are both depicted as imitatores Christi, though Theodosius' imitatio takes the form of a mystical re-enactment of Christ's suffering and an anagogical prefiguration of His celestial glory, whereas the prototype of Sergius' imitatio Christi is the| Transfigured Christ on Mount Tabor, the central image of mystical hesychasm. With the fall of Constantinople in 1453, Moscow emerged as the new center of the Orthodox Church and heir to the imperial legacy of East Rome. In 1459 the Russian Church was declared autocephalous, and the marriage in 1472 of Ivan III to Princess Zoe, niece of the last Byzantine emperor, seemed to confirm Russia's new status. During the next century the Russian Church turned inward and developed the ideology of Moscow as the third and last Rome. The idea that the grand princes of Moscow - the tsars, as they were now called - were the legitimate heirs of the Roman emperors was developed in several pseudo-historical works dating from the reigns of Ivan III (1462-1505) and Vasily III (1505-33). One of the most popular was the Tale of Constantinople (Povest 0 Tsargrade), included in the Russian Chronograph (Russky Khrono28 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
THE LITERATURE OF OLD RUSSIA, 9 8 8 - I 7 3 O graf) of 1512, and ascribed in one copy to a certain Nestor Iskander. In the final part, the tale describes the sultan's triumphant entry into the fallen city, concluding with a prophecy of Byzantium's liberation by a "fair people" (rusy rod), soon taken to mean that the Russians (russky rod) had been chosen by Providence to free Constantinople. A related idea is expressed in Spiridon Sava's Epistle on the Crown of Monomakh (Poslanie 0 Monomakhovom ventse), which traces the genealogy of the reigning Russian grand princes back to Caesar Augustus. In the Tale of the Princes of Vladimir (Skazanie 0 knyazyakh Vladimirskikh), Spiridon's genealogy, originally designed to glorify the princes of Tver, has been transferred to Grand Prince Yury Danilovich of Moscow and his descendants, as part of the new ideology. From the literature of this period a number of tales have reached us, either in translations or in original Russian versions belonging to the international repertoire of medieval story telling. Among the translated works are the so-called Serbian Romance of Alexander (Serbskaya Aleksandriya) and Guido de Colomna's Latin Tales of Troy (Troyanskie skazaniya), originally completed in 1287, and translated from a printed late fourteenth-century German edition. Closer to the folkloric tradition are Stefanit and Ikhnilat, based on a tale from the Indian Panchatantra, and the Tale of Solomon and Kitovras {Skazanie 0 Solomone i Kitovrase). The Dispute between Life and Death (Prenie zhivota i smerti) was translated from Nicholas Mercator's German version, published in Liibeck in 1484, whereas the Tale ofDracula (Povest 0 Drakule) appears to have been written by a Russian familiar with the Dracula legend. These texts signalled a new trend in old Russian literature. A work apart is the Journey beyond the Three Seas (Khozhdenie za tri morya) by the Tver merchant Afanasy Nikitin. Hardly intended for publication, these travel impressions of Islamic India recorded by an Orthodox Russian in 1466-72 have more appeal to a modern reader than most of the period's official literature. The end of the fifteenth century and the beginning of the sixteenth was a period of great religious unrest in Russia, in Novgorod and Moscow in particular. Critics of the official church could be found among both the laity and the clergy. Their most serious complaints had to do with the institutional hierarchy of the church, which they attacked in its foundations through a 29 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
JOSTEIN B0RTNES
scrutiny of canon law. One of their most prominent leaders, Ivan Volk Kuritsyn, developed his ideas of "free will" and of the "spiritual church" of the early Christians from reading the official Nomocanon (Kormchaya kniga).
Ivan's brother Fyodor wrote that "the soul has a free will and is defended by faith [...] wholly blessed in knowledge, whereby we arrive at the fear of God, the beginning of virtue." The reform movement reached the court of Ivan III, who initially supported it as part of his plans to confiscate the landed estates owned by the Russian Church and her monasteries. But when the reformers proved too dangerous, the Church launched a counterattack under the leadership of Abbot Joseph of Volokolamsk (1439-1515), a staunch defender of monastic property and head of the Possessors (styazhateli) in their struggle with the non-Possessors (nestyazhateli). The latter were headed by Nil Sorsky (1433-1508), a great mystic who insisted on monastic poverty and withdrew to the remote forests beyond the Volga in order to devote himself to solitary contemplation. However, the two antagonists joined forces in opposition to the reformers, and Joseph's main antiheretical work, The Enlightener (Prosuetitel), was written with Nil's assistance. The religious unrest in early Muscovite Russia ended with the victory of the Josephites over the "heretics" as well as the nonPossessors. Prince Vassian Patrikeev, a disciple of Nil Sorsky, fought in vain against them, chastizing the property-owning monasteries for desecrating the tradition of the saints and describing the acquisition of property as the "new heresy." In 1531 he was arrested and imprisoned in Joseph's monastery at Volokolamsk, where he died about 1545. A similar fate befell his friend Maxim the Greek. Known in the world as Michael Trivolis, Maxim had in his youth been close to the Italian humanists, but under the influence of Savonarola's antihumanist sermons he became a monk on Mount Athos and later went to Russia. He died in 1556 after spending thirty-one years in prison for his opposition to the church and the secular establishment. After 1547, when Ivan IV the Terrible proclaimed himself "Tsar," official Russian literature was characterized by an encyclopedic activity which paralleled the political centralization and unification of the country under its autocratic ruler. The chronicles 30 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
THE LITERATURE OF OLD RUSSIA, 9 8 8 - I 7 3 O were codified and brought up to date, the Church Council of 1551 affirmed the established ritual of the Russian Church and issued its decrees in a Book of a Hundred Chapters (Stoglav). Under the leader-
ship of Metropolitan Macarius (in office 1542-63), the hagiographical and patristic legacy of old Russia, as well as more recent polemical writings, were collected in a vast compilation entitled the Great Reading Menaia (Velikie cheti minei). In Household Manage-
ment (Domostroy), the rules of family life and everyday behavior were laid down once and for all. Among the original tales of this period is the Tale of Peter and Fevroniya (Povest 0 Petre i Fevronii)
composed by the monk Ermolay-Erazm in mid-century. The legend is based on international fairy-tale motifs, such as the slaying of a dragon, and the "wise maiden." These folklore motifs are combined with hagiographical topoi and contemporary political themes in a work expressing the social ethos of the author, a reformer in the tradition of the trans-Volga elders. The cult of the tsar was codified in the Book of Ranks of the Tsars' Genealogy (Stepennaya kniga tsarskogo rodosloviya), perpetuating the
mythical link between Caesar Augustus and the Russian princes, now said to have been "tsars" even in Kievan times, and glorifying the house of Kalita, rulers by divine appointment and support. According to Ivan Peresvetov, an adventurer from Lithuania who became the mouthpiece of the new Russian service nobility, the tsar, in order to exert his "terrible power," should combine "Christian faith" with "Turkish order." The terrible tsar and his policies are glorified in the History of Kazan (Kazanskaya istoriya), written in 1564-5, and in the Tale of Stefan Batory's Attack on Pskov {Povest 0 prikhozhdenii Stefana Bato-
riya na Pskov), written only after the death of the tsar. There is little doubt that Ivan the Terrible was a cruel and mentally deranged tyrant. But he was also the author of some of the most original works of sixteenth-century Russian literature. Educated in the stern spirit of Josephite monasticism, Ivan mastered to perfection the rules of Muscovite rhetoric, at the same time demonstrating his despotic omnipotence by bringing into his rhetorical discourse elements of blasphemy and scorn associated with the buffoonery of the skomorokhi and court jesters, whose company he cherished, although their pranks had been banned by the Hundred Chapters. Ivan's hybrid style was a forceful instrument 31 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
JOSTEIN B0RTNES
in his polemics against political opponents, but it proved a doubleedged sword once the enemy discovered its unholy combination of apparent Christian piety and personal arrogance, of Scriptural quotations and foul-mouthed ribaldry. The weaknesses of Ivan's style were probed mercilessly by his principal adversary, Prince Andrey Kurbsky (1528-83). A descendant of old princely families of Yaroslavl and Smolensk, Kurbsky had distinguished himself in Ivan's military campaigns as well as in administration, when, in 1564, during a war with Lithuania, he deserted to the enemy. From Lithuania he responded to the tsar's accusatory letters, and in 1573, during the Polish interregnum, compiled the History of the Grand Prince of Muscovy (Istoriya 0 Velikom knyaze moskovskom), produced for the explicit
purpose of preventing the election of Ivan IV to the Polish throne. The correspondence between Ivan and Kurbsky has been preserved only in seventeenth-century copies, and its authenticity has recently been questioned. The ideological positions of the two correspondents, however, coincide with views put forward in their other writings. Ivan defends his autocratic idea of tsardom, whereas Kurbsky favors limited princely power and shared governmental responsibility, a position he further developed in his History. Kurbsky is the first Russian writer to regard European civilization and secular knowledge as superior to the theological learning of the Orthodox Church and the traditions of old Russia. To Kurbsky Ivan represents cultural barbarism, whereas Ivan uses the same word to characterize Kurbsky's apostasy from Muscovite Christianity. After the death in 1598 of Fyodor Ivanovich, the last tsar of the old dynasty, and of his successor Boris Godunov in 1606, the Muscovite state was thrown into a crisis that lasted until 1613, when Mikhail Fyodorovich, the first Romanov tsar, ascended the throne. The interregnum, known as the Time of Troubles, had shaken the foundations of the state. The country had been ravaged by civil unrest and by wars of succession in which Poles and Swedes had intervened in support of their respective candidates. The Time of Troubles was a turning point in old Russian literature. During this period church and state lost control over the written word, Polish verse composition was imitated in Moscow, and oral poetry was transposed into writing. The country was 32 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
THE LITERATURE OF OLD RUSSIA, 9 8 8 - I 7 3 O swamped with the "alluring leaflets" of the false pretenders' Catholic supporters, and Church Slavonic rhetoric acquired a new role in the verbal battle with the enemy. Political pamphleteering was no longer the preserve of the tsar, as it had been under Ivan IV. In the ideological struggle of the interregnum, the authority of the written word had ceased to be absolute. It now depended on the individual author's ideological stance. The new situation is clearly reflected in the memoirs written during or shortly after the Time of Troubles, such as Avraamy Palitsyn's Narrative (Skazanie, 1612-20), Ivan Timofeev's Discourses (Slovesa dney i tsarey i svyatiteley moskovskikh, 1616-24), Ivan
Khvorostinin's Chronicle (Vremennik, 1616-19), and Semyon Shakhovskoy's True Account in Memory of the Martyred and Faithful Tsarevich Dimitry, and of His Slaying (Povest izvestnoskazuema na pamyat uelikomuchenika, blagovernogo tsarevicha Dimitriya i 0 ubienii
ego), probably composed in the 1620s. In these works the old rhetoric is skilfully employed to express, and at times to camouflage, the authors' personal assessments of the events and characters of the period. In trying to understand the behavior of Ivan the Terrible and Boris Godunov, these authors went beyond the traditional character-drawing of old Russian literature, with its clear distinction between sinners and righteous men, between good and evil, and developed a literary technique for the representation of complex, or "strong" characters (Dmitry Likhachov). Whereas Kurbsky had explained the contradictory nature of Ivan the Terrible's personality diachronically, seeing the death of the Tsarina Anastasia as the watershed between the wise and brave ruler and the cruel tyrant who finally murdered his own son, the chroniclers of the interregnum try to depict the rulers of the period as products of an internalized struggle between good and evil in a contrastive technique where good and bad qualities are no longer mutually exclusive, but form a syndrome, modifying each other and creating a dramatic inner conflict. Boris Godunov's character, which to his contemporaries seemed so enigmatic, is explained as an interplay of many factors: human "nature," "free will," striving after fame, the influence of other men. The original contribution of these authors to old Russian literature lies in their invention of a rhetoric of complex characterization. After the accession of Alexey Mikhailovich in 1645, Moscow
33 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
JOSTEIN B0RTNES became the center of a spiritual revival, led by Stephen Vonifatev, the tsar's teacher and father confessor. Inspired by the Hundred Chapters of 1551, Stephen dreamed of a "lay monasticism" of small penitential communities headed by a priest or archpriest. Among the members of Stephen's "circle of zealots" were both Nikon, the future patriarch, and Avvakum, who was to become his most intransigent opponent when, upon his appointment in 1652, Nikon decided to bring "Russian Gallicanism" to an end and work for a closer relationship with the Ukrainian Church. After the union between Russia and the Ukraine in 1654 this became a matter of urgent concern, and the zealots' dream of reviving Muscovite religiosity was a lost cause. The schism following Nikon's liturgical reforms of 1653 split the whole Russian Church into two camps: the Old Believers, representing the ideals of the Hundred Chapters, and the Graecophiles, who accepted the necessity of putting an end to the cultural isolationism of Muscovite, society. At their initiative, Ukrainian bookmen educated at the Kiev Academy were called to Moscow, bringing with them a culture strongly influenced by the educational system of the Polish Jesuits, on which the Kievan Metropolitan Petro Mohyla had modelled the curriculum of the Academy. The decisive step toward a westernization of Russian literature was taken with the invitation of Simeon Polotsky (1629-80) to Moscow in 1663. Born in Polotsk in White Russia, Simeon was educated at the Kiev Academy, and he probably also studied at the Jesuit College at Wilno, where he learned Polish and Latin. In 1656 he became a monk and teacher at the Orthodox Brotherhood's School in his home town, where in the same year he twice attracted attention with verses he wrote on the occasion of Tsar Alexey's visits to the city. On his arrival in Moscow he opened a school for government officials where he taught grammar, Latin, poetics and rhetoric. In 1667 he was appointed tutor to Tsarevich Alexey, and later to Fyodor, Sofia, and Peter I. He was court preacher and one of the organizers of the Council of 1666-7, which officially deposed Nikon and condemned the Old Believers, whom he attacked in his Scepter of Government (Zhezl pravleniya). His sermons were published posthumously in two volumes: the Spiritual Midday Meal (Obed dushevny, 1681) and the Spiritual Supper (Vecherya dushevnaya,
1683). He wrote the first plays for the new court theater, Comedy 34 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
THE LITERATURE OF OLD RUSSIA, 9 8 8 - I 7 3 O on the Parable of the Prodigal Son (Komediya pritchi 0 bludnom syne) and the tragedy On Nebuchadnezzar the King (O Navkhodonosore tsare),
both cast in the style ofjesuit school drama, the tragedy based on an old Byzanto-Russian liturgical play about the "three youths in the fiery furnace." Simeon's large collections of poems, The Garden of Many Flowers (Vertograd mnogotsuetny), and the Rifmologion,
remained unpublished. The former contains satirical, panegyrical, narrative and didactic verse, the latter panegyric odes and occasional poems written to the tsar and his family. Simeon's verse translation of the Psalter (Psaltyr rifmotvornayd), printed in Moscow in 1680, was set to music at the end of the century. In his panegyrical verse Simeon created an "imperial style" for the glorification of the new absolutist empire and its ruler. This style combines old Russian rhetoric and Byzanto-Russian imperial ideology with tropes and figures taken over from ancient and contemporary western European literature in the form ofjesuit school Baroque. With Simeon, a whole museum of ancient gods, muses, heroes, authors and philosophers entered Russian literature. But they had been lifted from their historical context and given a purely ornamental function in his tirades of syllabic lines. Verbal poetry - verse composition regulated by meter - was unknown in Kievan and Muscovite literature. Verse composition was known in old Russia only in the musical poetry of the Church Slavonic hymns and in the spoken verse of brief oral genres, proverbs, riddles, incantations, etc. recited by the skomorokhi. Examples of skazovy stikh are to be found in Daniel's Supplication. From the beginning of the sixteenth century, the musical poetry of the liturgy was imitated outside its liturgical context in compositions known as "penitential verse" (stikhi pokayannye). Syllabic poetry came to Russia from the west, through the Ukraine, Belorussia, and Poland. The first virshi (from Latin versus) were written in Russia in the early seventeenth century. Following Ukrainian and Belorussian patterns, they were either written in the form of isosyllabic couplets, or as couplets of lines with a varying number of syllables (relative isosyllabism). The latter variant found, for instance, in the writings of Prince Khvorostinin coincided with the old skazovy stikh, but they were soon differentiated functionally: "relative isosyllabism" was associated with serious poetry, skazovy stikh with popular, "low" rhymes. 35 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
JOSTEIN B0RTNES According to Alexander Panchenko, the new art of verse writing was further developed by a group of Moscow government officials whose activity seems to have ended with the schism, when they sided with the Old Believers. Nikon favored the new art too, and at his patriarchal court hymns were written on the Polish model. But it was Simeon Polotsky who finally transferred the whole system of syllabic poetry to Russia. His work was continued by his favorite pupil, Silvestr Medvedev (1641-92), beheaded by Peter I for his support of the tsar's sister, the Tsarina Sofia, and Silvestr's friend, Karion Istomin (mid-i7th centuryafter 1720), after 1698 head of the printing office. From the end of the sixteenth century and throughout the seventeenth, a number of medieval adventure novels were translated into Russian, not from the originals but from the chapbook versions in which these works survived in German and Polish literature. The Tale about Prince Bova (Povest 0 Bove Koroleviche),
which goes back to the Italian romance of Buovo d'Antona, Peter of the Golden Keys and Queen Magilena (Povest 0 Petre zlatykh klyuchey), derived from Pierre de Provence et la belle Maguelonne, the
Tale of Bruntsvik, a chapbook version of an old Czech poem, the Tale of the Golden Haired Czech Prince Vastly (Povest 0 Vasilii Zlatovlasnom, koroleviche Cheshskoy zemli), and others.
Equally popular were the Russian counterparts of the German Schwdnke and French fabliaux, sometimes translated from Polish facetiae, sometimes developed into original Russian versions of well-known international motifs. Among the most popular were the Tale about Karp Sutulov (Povest 0 Karpe Sutulove), the Story of a Life in Luxury and Fun (Skazanie 0 roskoshnom zhitii i veselii), the Tale of Ersh Ershovich (Povest 0 Ershe Ersheviche), and Shemyaka's
Trial (Shemyakin sud), which project traditional denunciations of bureaucracy and corrupt judges onto the reality of seventeenth century Russian life. The original Tale of Frol Skobeev has been called both a Russian "picaresque novel" and the "masterpiece of Muscovite fabliaux." This rather cynical tale describes the devices by which the roguish hero seduces a nobleman's daughter, clandestinely marries her, is finally reconciled with her parents, and ends "in great fame, and rich." Both its tone and plot suggest that this story already belongs to the Petrine period. Another group of seventeenth-century satires deals with the
36 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
THE LITERATURE OF OLD RUSSIA, 9 8 8 - I 7 3 O clergy and monastic life. In stories like the Tale about Sava the Priest (Povest 0 pope Save) and the Petition of the Monks from Kalyazin (Kalyazinskaya chelobitnaya), the solemn world of monks and
priests is turned upside down and parodied. The particular variant of spoken verse employed in these satires points to their oral origin. The existence of similar forms in Byzantine literature is an indication that this is an old oral tradition fixed in writing in the seventeenth century, the century when Russian folklore took permanent form for the first time. Somewhat different from the merry, recreational parody of these tales are the satires in which laughter mingles with tears. Among them are such texts as the Mass of the Tavern (Sluzhba kabaku), and the Abecedary of the Naked and Poor Man (Azbuka 0 golom i nebogatom cheloveke), the former a parody of the vespers, concluding with the life story of a drunkard in the form of a mock-vita, the latter of a devotional abecedary, a genre common in Byzanto-Slavonic literature. In both works the comic inversion of official genres is combined with social satire. Like the prodigal son, so popular in Jesuit literature of the period, the heroes, or anti-heroes, of these works are described as social outcasts who act against the will of their parents and waste their patrimony in the company of the dregs of society. They are set in the inns and taverns of the slums. But there is a characteristic element of redeeming irony in them too. The first-person narrator of the Abecedary depicts his own abasement with an element of irony, as if in his humiliation he has broken away from the values of this world. A central text in this group is the Tale of Woe-Misfortune (Povest 0 Gore i Zlochastii). Composed in the unrhymed lines of the folk epic, with four stressed syllables in each line, the work is clearly a literary transcription of an oral composition close to the genre of the "penitential songs," with a strong admixture of elements from popular apocrypha about the figure of Khmel, or Humulus, as the embodiment of the demon of drunkenness. The Tale of WoeMisfortune is thus a hybrid work in which a nameless youth leaves his parents, strays from the right path, loses his possessions, and is pursued by Woe-Misfortune, his evil spirit and the incarnation of death, until he is saved at the monastery gates, where he is spiritually reborn and becomes a monk. 37 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
JOSTEIN B0RTNES Underlying the Tale of Woe-Misfortune is a vision of life as tragic farce in which demons play tricks on men in a godforsaken world ruled by the forces of evil, by Satan and the Anti-Christ, or their henchmen. This same vision undergirds the autobiographical Life (Zhitie) of Archpriest Avvakum, the last great hagiographical work in old Russian literature. The Hundred Chapters Council had envisioned a Russian Church encompassing the whole of society, extending church discipline to all spheres of human life. The center of this "lay monasticism" was to have been the "household church" under the supervision of a priest or archpriest. This idea found expression in the regulation of everyday life prescribed in the Domostroy, and it was revived by the circle of religious reformers around Tsar Alexey Mikhailovich in the 1640s. One of the few literary expressions of this ideal is the Life of the Holy and Pious Mother Juliana Lazarevskaya (Povest 0 svyatoy i pravednoy materi Yulianii Lazarevskoy), written about 1625 by her
son. The Life is composed on the traditional pattern, but now projected onto a secular life story, with the result that some of the well-known topoi have been distorted, or even turned upside down. Juliana did not go to church regularly, as a traditional saint would have done. She was more concerned with her duties towards the hungry, the poor, and the sick, than with ritual matters. Also, she obeyed her husband when he forbade her to enter a convent, and spent the rest of her days as a lay ascetic in constant "spiritual prayer." The schism of 1653 wrecked hopes for a revival of household religiosity. The leaders of the reformist movement went over into opposition to the tsar and the patriarch, continuing their work as religious dissidents, persecuted by church and state, tortured, and finally burnt at the stake. The vitae et passiones of these martyrs are the most significant seventeenth-century contribution to old Russian hagiography. These works include the anonymous Life of Boyarina Morozova, Princess Urusova, and Maria Danilova (Zhitie boyariny Morozovoy, knyagini Urusovoy, i Mari Danilovoy), and the autobiographical
Lives of Archpriest Avvakum and his fellow sufferer, the monk Epiphanius. Archpriest Avvakum (1621-82) wrote his Life at Pustozersk on 38 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
THE LITERATURE OF OLD RUSSIA, 9 8 8 - I 7 3 O the White Sea, where he spent his last fifteen years as a prisoner. The Life went through several revisions, with the hagiographical element becoming more pronounced in each new version. Written in the form of an intimate "talk" (beseda) addressed to Epiphanius, the Life has a markedly dialogic structure. The author conducts a dialogue with his own past, trying to discover meaning in his suffering, be it in the patriarchal torture chambers or during the years of his Siberian exile. The memories of his suffering become meaningful only when he regards his own life as a reenactment of Christ's Passion. Avvakum's theological thought is permeated by the symbolism of the Areopagite (Konrad Onasch): in his Life, people and events, even the flora and fauna of eastern Siberia, are "signs and miracles" of divine prototypes, revealing themselves in the immediate reality of his suffering. The interference of this supernatural world of prototypes transforms his humiliations into a series of symbols of the world to come, of his triumph over the arch-enemy, that Anti-Christ incarnate, Patriarch Nikon. Avvakum's combination of ecclesiastical and colloquial language transposed into writing the pathos of his oral rhetoric, and has remained a source of inspiration to modern Russian literature ever since the Life was first published in 1861. Ukrainian influence in Moscow, which had steadily increased during the reign of Alexey Mikhailovich, became all-pervasive during the reign of his son, Peter the Great. The UkrainianOrthodox imitation of Polish-Jesuit school Baroque, introduced into Russian literature by Simeon Polotsky, continued to flourish in the writing of his successors, the Metropolitan Dimitry of Rostov (1651—1709), Stefan Yavorsky (1658—1722), locum tenens of the patriarchal chair, and Feofan Prokopovich (1681-1736). All three were educated at the Kiev Academy, after which Yavorsky and Prokopovich temporarily converted to Catholicism and continued their studies abroad, the former at Polish and Lithuanian universities, the latter in Rome, where he became acquainted with Jesuit scholasticism. This he later rejected, together with the divinity of the Greeks, trying to revitalize Russian theology in confrontation with Protestantism, whose doctrines he also refused to accept. As distinguished men of letters, these ecclesiastics caught the attention of the tsar, whose reforms they regarded with various 39 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
JOSTEIN B0RTNES feelings, from Yavorsky's open resistance and Dimitry Rostovsky's silent disapproval to the enthusiastic support of Prokopovich, who saw Peter as the embodiment of his own ideal of enlightened despotism. All three men were professional writers, trained according to the rules of Jesuit school rhetoric, which Yavorsky summarized in his Rhetorical Handbook (Ruka retoricheskaya), while Prokopovich
wrote his own Latin courses in both poetics and rhetoric. Dimitry Tuptalo, later canonized as Saint Dimitry Rostovsky, is known mainly for his Reading Menaia (Minei-Cheti, 1689-1705). Written under the influence of the Jesuit Peter Skarga's Polish Lives and the acta sanctorum of the Bollandists, the work replaced Macarius's old Menaia, and became the hagiographical thesaurus for generations and generations of Russian readers and writers, right up to our own century. The highly ornate discourse of his ecclesiastical oratory shows how well Baroque rhetoric and Byzanto-Slavonic "word-weaving" could function together. His plays A Comedy for the Day of Christ's Birth (Komediya na Rozhdenie Khristovo), A Comedy for the Dormition of the Virgin (Komediya na
Uspenie Bogomateri), and others, are written in the tradition of Jesuit school drama, while his poems, epigraphs and hymns reveal a predilection for Baroque conceptism. In Rostov, Dimitry established the first Russian theological seminary using Greek and Latin. To his contemporaries, Stefan Yavorsky was known first and foremost as the author of the anti-Protestant treatises Vineyard of Christ (Vinograd Khristov, 1698) and Rock of Faith (Kamen very,
1718). His sermons, written in the Baroque mannerist style, were aimed at impressing the audience with exclamations such as "O Noah, glorious admiral!" "O celestial pharmacist, how miraculous is Thine alchemy, how marvellous Thy pharmacy [. . . ] . " Stefan's arguments against the Protestants were borrowed from Catholic works. Like Feofan Prokopovich, Stefan was tri-lingual, and wrote his poems in Latin, Polish and Church Slavonic. His most accomplished verse composition is a Latin valedictory elegy to his library, written in the tradition of the humanists. Of all the Ukrainians active in Moscow under Peter the Great, Feofan Prokopovich was the most prominent. He it was who carried out Peter's church reforms, abolishing the old Byzanto40 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
THE LITERATURE OF OLD RUSSIA, 9 8 8 - I 7 3 O Russian idea of a diarchy between church and state and subjecting the ecclesiastical hierarchy to the authority of the secular ruler as "high priest" and "supreme shepherd". In his literary work Feofan glorified the tsar and the new absolutism in panegyrical logoi, such as the Discourse on the Power and Dignity of the Tsar (Slovo 0 vlasti i chesti tsarskoy, 1718), and the Panegyrical Discourse on the Russian Fleet (Slovo pokhvalnoe 0 flote
rossiyskom, 1720). His tragicomedy Vladimir (1705), written in syllabic verse, is regarded by some historians as an allegorical satire on the opponents of Peter's reforms though on the surface it deals with Vladimir's Christianization of Rus. His Epinikion (1709), celebrating Peter's victory over the Swedes at Poltava, was written in Latin, Polish and Church Slavonic. The Slavonic version is composed according to the traditional scheme of thirteen-syllable lines, with the caesura after the seventh syllable, a fixed stress on the sixth and twelfth, and regular rhyme. After Peter's death Feofan's poetry became more experimental and varied, with imitations of the Italian ottava rima (a/b a/b a/b c/c), epodic couplets in which a long line is followed by a shorter one, more frequent use of non-grammatical rhymes, and a poetic diction closer to everyday speech. During these years he was surrounded by a "learned retinue," a circle of intimate friends, among whom were the historian Vasily Tatishchev (1686-1750) and the young Prince Antiokh Kantemir, whose first and most famous satire, "Against the Enemies of Education" ("Na khulyashchikh uchenie"), was directed against Feofan's enemies. In this work, the reign of Peter the Great is already viewed as a "golden age" of the past, nostalgically referred to by one of the harbingers of a new age in Russian literature. According to the Primary Chronicle, in 980, only eight years before his official conversion to Christianity, Prince Vladimir set up a group of pagan idols on a hill near his castle at Kiev. The gods represented were Perun, Khors, Dazhbog, Stribog, Simarigl, and Mokosh. Perun is further mentioned in the Graeco-Russian treaties reproduced in the chronicle (907, 945, 971), where it is said that the non-Christian Russians swore by Perun and by Veles, the god of cattle. Comparative studies have shown that the pagan deities of the 41 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
JOSTEIN B0RTNES
eastern Slavs have their counterparts in the mythology of other Slavs, and that ultimately they are derivations of an IndoEuropean pantheon. A notable feature of Slav paganism is the strong Iranian influence still to be found in terms like bog ("god"), meaning "giver of wealth"; vera ("faith"), coinciding with the Iranian word denoting choice between good and evil; and svyat ("holy"). The Russian word mir, meaning both "peace" and "peaceful community," is connected with the Iranian god Mithra. With the acceptance of Christianity, the old pagan beliefs were relegated to the periphery of old Russian culture, and the church began an endless struggle to eradicate the remnants of paganism. In spite of this, the old traditions survived in popular peasant cults, in folklore and decorative folk art, right up to the twentieth century. In popular tradition, pagan and Christian elements often eoalesced in hybrid forms, known by the church as "ditheism" (dvoeverie). Perun, for instance, the old thunder-god, whom the Varangians of the princely retinue identified with the old Norse Thor, found a Christian equivalent in Elijah, and Veles, the god of wealth and cattle, was transformed into Saint Blasius. But in the popularjuxtaposition of Elijah and Blasius/Veles, modern scholars have detected traces of an archaic antagonism between the IndoEuropean thunder-god and a dragon-shaped cattle god, hiding from his opponent in trees, cliffs, animals, human beings, etc. Folkloric transformations of this deity are such epic heroes as the Serbian Zmaj Ognjeni Vuk (Dragon Fiery Wolf), Volkh Vselavevich in the Russian folk epic, and the magician Prince Vseslav of Polotsk in the Primary Chronicle and the Igor Tale. In the old Slavonic version of the Romance of Alexander, Zeus is identified with Perun. Hephaistos and Helios are translated as Svarog and Dazhbog in the Chronicle of Malalas, and the two are described in the Hypatian Chronicle under 1114 as father and son. Khors is another name for the sun god, borrowed from the Iranian. Stribog, who comes next to Dazhbog in Vladimir's ensemble of idols, has been translated as "the apportioner of wealth" (Roman Jakobson), and Dazhbog and Stribog form a divine pair corresponding to the Greek Aisa and Poros, "Portion" and "Allotment," Vedic Amsa and Bhaga, all pointing to a common Indo-European prototype. In the Igor Tale, the Russians 42 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
THE LITERATURE OF OLD RUSSIA, 9 8 8 - I 7 3 O are called, "Dazhbog's grandsons," and the winds are the "grandsons of Stribog," blowing from the sea with arrows against Igor's valiant hosts. The genuine folkloric tradition of old Russia was transmitted by the skomorokhi, the Russian minstrels. Persecuted by the church and finally outlawed by Tsar Alexey Mikhailovich in the middle of the seventeenth century, they receded into the remote regions of northern Russia, where their art was taken over by peasant singers and tellers of tales. It was in the seventeenth century as well that the first Russian folk tales and ballads were recorded, the tales by an Oxford doctor of medicine, Samuel Collins, the ballads by another Oxford man, Richard James, at the beginning of the century chaplain to the English diplomatic mission in Moscow. He returned to England in 1620, bringing with him the first transcriptions of Russian secular folk songs. An important event in the study of Russian folklore was the publication of Kirsha Danilov's Drevnie rossiyskie stikhotvoreniya (1804), a collection of epic songs, or byliny. The classical collection of Russian folk tales is the one published by Alexander Afanasev in 1855-64, containing about 600 texts. In the Middle Ages the byliny were sung to the accompaniment of the gusli, a harp-like instrument. The line is the compositional unit: each line has a fixed number of stressed syllables, usually three, with the last stress falling on the antepenultimate syllable to give the line a dactylic ending. There is no end rhyme, and the lines are grouped into larger sections by means of repetitions and parallelisms. A single bylina usually consists of between 200 and 300 lines. The byliny are divided into a Kievan and a Novgorod cycle. The central hero of the latter is the poor gusli player Sadko, who becomes a rich merchant with the help of the tsar of the underwater realm of Lake Ilmen. The Kievan cycle is centered around the legendary figure of Prince Vladimir and the banquets he arranges for his retinue; its heroes are the valiant knights Vladimir sends out to fight foreign invaders and internal foes. The most popular are Ilya Muromets, Dobrynya Nikitich, and Alyosha Popovich. They are all bogatyri, a Persian word meaning "athlete." Ilya, a hero of superhuman strength granted him by Jesus and two Apostles, first uses his power to clear the land on his parents' farm, 43 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
JOSTEIN B0RTNES
and later in Vladimir's service. He destroys the Tatar Kalin Tsar and his army before descending into a Kievan cave, where he is turned into stone. Dobrynya and Alyosha Popovich are dragon slayers. The historical prototype of the latter may have been Alexander Popovich, mentioned in the chronicle under 1223 as one of the warriors killed by the Tatars. In the bylina historical elements are fused with mythological motifs. Thus Alyosha kills the dragon Tugarin, a poetic transformation of the Polovtsian chief Tugor Khan. The heroes of the byliny moved easily into the fairy tales, a genre closely related to the epic songs in subject matter, but following different poetic patterns. Whereas the bylina glorifies the heroes of a distant historical past, the fairy tales conjure up a social Utopia, a vision of the "other world." The bylina heroes belong to a golden age, while the folk-tale hero sets out in search of a "better place," "three years by a crooked way, or three hours by the straight only there is no thoroughfare." When finally he finds it, the other world is very much like the one he has left: "The bed is wide and the pillows are of down." Much of the charm of the Russian folk tales is due to their verbal artistry, in particular their use of dialogue and their incorporation of other, smaller folkloric genres: proverbs, riddles, and incantations. According to a traditional narrator, the talk of the tale is the most difficult: "If a single word is wrong, nothing will work out right."
44 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
THE EIGHTEENTH CENTURY: NEOCLASSICISM AND THE ENLIGHTENMENT, 1730-90 Although those who came first chronologically in the history of eighteenth-century Russian literature - Antiokh Kantemir and Vasily Trediakovsky - initially wished to effect a radical break with their medieval tradition, much as Peter the Great had done in the political sphere, they could not manage it immediately. They initiated the transition to a modern literature, but it would take some time to accomplish, for the greatest literary figure of mid-century, Mikhail Lomonosov, was not so anxious as they to jettison native ways, and indeed eventually Trediakovsky too reverted to a greater sense of his roots than he had displayed in his youth, when under strong western European influence. Although the church ceased to nurture literature directly in those years, it still continued to do so indirectly - through its schools, for example, which Lomonosov attended - and took an active hand in developing culture generally. Although literature was evidently much more secular in the eighteenth century than it had been earlier, there was still a serious religious component to it, one which emerged, for example, in Lomonosov's "Morning meditation" and "Evening Meditation," in Trediakovsky's Feoptiya, and in Derzhavin's ode "God," promptly translated into many languages. Nor did it prove a simple matter to implant an understanding of literature as fiction: Kantemir had to explain carefully to the readers of his satires that his characters were but literary creations. There was also a continuing emphasis on history in the eighteenth century, both in the strict sense (even in the nineteenth century Karamzin's History of the Russian State would be seen as a great literary achievement), and in the literary sense: the ode, the leading literary genre of mid-century, dealt primarily with great historical events, though often contemporary ones, while the tragedy, another principal literary genre, for the most part described crucial moments of Russian history. On the other hand, the leading forms in the years immediately after 1730 (the year in which Kantemir's verse satires began to circulate widely) were poetic ones, which
45 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
ILYA SERMAN had not been the case for most of the old Russian period. In the minds of most readers, a work written in verse is clearly literary, whereas a literary work in prose may be confused with a piece of documentary writing. Thus the supremacy of poetry for several decades after 1730 may be regarded as an implicit affirmation that Russia indeed now had a modern literature. After largely rejecting the legacy of medieval Russia, the creators of eighteenth-century Russian literature went back to classical models, and shaped a literature based upon its precepts. However, this approach represented no very radical departure from previously prevalent literary doctrine. Neoclassicism in literature dealt with that which was common to all peoples in all places at all times. Thus there was a serious internationalist component to neoclassicism, which went well with the internationalist - or, more precisely, universalist — perspective of the Christian culture which had preceded it: nationalism had not yet become a major element of the Russian cultural outlook. In addition, literature of the neoclassical period raised serious moral and social issues, problems affecting the society as a whole or in which the state was involved. The writer did not consider it appropriate to speak of himself or his own personal experiences: his gaze was fixed upon higher things. Several writers of the eighteenth century had quite pungent personalities, but they did not express them directly through their writing. To be sure, they were not so self-effacing as their medieval predecessors, but they were very far from their nineteenthcentury successors, who tended to concentrate upon their own emotions and opinions. Literature in the eighteenth century thus tried to offer serious guidance to society as a whole on important questions. There is yet another literary parallel with the medieval period to be detected in the eighteenth century: the close connection between literature and the objectives of the state, as well as between writers and the state. Most of the outstanding writers of the eighteenth century were also important government officials: Kantemir was a leading diplomat; Trediakovsky, though less successful in finding employment, still derived much of his livelihood from the state, as did Lomonosov, who in his numerous odes on official occasions such as coronations set out his ideals for Russian society; Fonvizin was a government bureaucrat close to the man responsible for Russian foreign policy in the 1770s; Derzhavin gave unsolicited advice to Catherine; Radishchev was employed in the St. Petersburg customs house; and Catherine herself had literary ambitions. Such examples could be multiplied to show that even during the eighteenth century there were almost no professional literary men. Rather, most writers derived their primary livelihood from the state (though not the church anymore), and tended therefore to feel considerable responsibility for its policies. In creating the foundations of a modern literature, Russian writers after 1730 adapted the theories of western European neoclassicism to
46 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
THE EIGHTEENTH CENTURY: I 7 3 O - 9 O Russian conditions. Trediakovsky and Sumarokov worked out detailed descriptions of an intricate system of literary genres which was rather different from that which had gone before, and promulgated rules which the serious writer was virtually obliged to follow. Trediakovsky and Lomonosov elaborated a new system of versification which replaced the classical scheme of syllables containing long or short vowels with syllables containing stressed or unstressed vowels (syllabo-tonic versification), rejecting the scheme of syllabic versification - when only the number of syllables in a line was regulated which Kantemir had perfected in practice on the basis of Polish models, and which he also defended in theory before his death. Lomonosov adapted a variant of the classical system of three styles (high, middle and low) to the Russian literary language, in so doing providing it with a theoretical structure of great importance even if it was frequently honored in the breach. And all the writers of the decades following 1730 were much concerned with the problem of developing a modern Russian literary language, laying the foundations of a synthesis which would be brought to perfection by Pushkin and those who came immediately after him in the early nineteenth century. During the eighteenth century the number of writers increased, and the rudiments of a literary society began to appear. In the first decades after 1730 the number of writers was small, and there were many antagonisms among the leading ones - Trediakovsky, Lomonosov and Sumarokov - but still they knew one another, and even antagonistic competition could be stimulating. In 1755 literary journals began to be founded, and with them literary groupings of an informal sort, so that writers could lend one another support and advice. Later on Derzhavin in particular seems to have had a powerful sense of the importance of literary society, and even at the beginning of his career gathered about him writers like Khemnitser and Lvov. Thus literature gathered momentum, and it is appropriate that the concluding date of this chapter- 1790- should be the date of the appearance of a political book by a man who worked for the government, cast in an eclectic neoclassical literary form but with infusions of the new sentimentalism then coming to the fore, and yet one which clearly looked to the future, when the writer would regard himself as antagonist to the state: Radishchev's Journey from St. Petersburg to Moscow. The publication of
the Journey would also establish a sad precedent for modern Russian literature: the persecution and jailing of a writer for an implicit and explicit political critique expressed in literary form. But at least this showed that Russian rulers regarded literature as a serious enterprise.
IN 1730, in both capitals, but especially in Moscow, where the Court and the Guards regiments were situated at the time - that is, 47 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
ILYA SERMAN a large part of the nobility which had by that point become Europeanized - the verse satires of Antiokh Kantemir which had first appeared in 1729 continued to circulate in manuscript. In that same year of 1730, in St. Petersburg there appeared an allegorical novel in prose by Paul Tallemant entitled A Voyage to the Isle of Love (Ezda vo ostrov Lyubvi) in a translation by Vasily Trediakovsky, who had just returned from Paris. Thus two themes entered Russian literature which had had no place in it before: laughter and love. To be sure, Russian folklore had already developed the lyrical lovesong and various humorous genres, but all this existed on a level of everyday life and ordinary holiday amusement and did not reach the basic literary genres: the chronicles, the lives of the saints, and also polemical essays, which developed especially rapidly in the seventeenth century because of the schism within the Russian Orthodox Church leading to the departure of significant numbers of clergy and laypeople, the Old Believers. The appearance in Russia of literature of the new, Europeanized type became possible only after a whole series of political and administrative reforms and cultural and educational legislation put through in the first quarter of the eighteenth century by Emperor Peter I. Peter's reforms were primarily subordinated to the requirements of politics. In order to create a state technologically equal to the most powerful states of Europe, Peter needed industry and trained specialists; and in order to create the latter he required appropriate institutions of learning. All this came into being in the course of unceasing wars which shaped the entire life of the state. Consequently Peter had little interest in the development of the humanities or the creation of a Europeanized artistic literature. The culture which Peter as political leader required was a secularized one liberated from the control of the Orthodox Church. By subjecting the church to the state and depriving it of its role as the nation's ideological guide, Peter did a great deal to implant within the social consciousness of the ruling stratum, the Russian aristocracy, the ideas of European political thought in that variant which viewed enlightened absolutism as the most effective instrument of cultural and social progress. When they made their debuts in literature - or more precisely, in their consciously and carefully calculated initial literary enterprises - neither Kantemir nor Trediakovsky drew upon any sort of
48 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
THE EIGHTEENTH CENTURY: I73O-9O Russian literary tradition. With Kantemir and Trediakovsky the Russian literary consciousness acquired the conviction that the new literature of the European type could derive no benefit at all from the Russian literary experience of the eleventh to seventeenth centuries. As Alexander Sumarokov, one of the most prolific of modern Russian authors, later phrased it in his "Eulogy to Emperor Peter the Great" ("Slovo pokhvalnoe o gosudare imperatore Petre Velikom," 1759): Until the time of Peter the Great Russia was not enlightened by any clear conception of the nature of things, by any useful knowledge or by any profound doctrine: our reason was submerged in the darkness of ignorance, sparks of intellect would be extinguished, because they lacked the strength to burst intoflame[...] But when Peter became a man the sun arose; and the darkness of ignorance was dissipated. Antiokh Kantemir (1708-44) was the son of Prince Dmitry Kantemir, a Moldavian ruler who went over to Peter's side during the Russo-Turkish war in 1711. Dmitry Kantemir was not only a statesman, but a writer as well, the author of satirical works and also of a History of the Ottoman Empire, later translated into major European languages. Since Antiokh was clearly the outstanding one among Dmitry's four sons, his father saw to his education with special care. Italian and Modern Greek were spoken at home, and Antiokh was taught Russian and Church Slavic by the poet and translator Ivan Ilinsky. In St. Petersburg Antiokh attended lectures by Academician Christian-Friedrich Gross, who was conducting a course on Cartesian Naturphilosophie. It was very likely Gross who stimulated his interest in French culture, which at that point still had not penetrated the Russian mind. Kantemir began his investigations of the spirit and forms of French poetry with translations of Nicolas Boileau's satires in 1726 and 1727. Since Kantemir wrote in syllabic verse (he was one of the last Russian writers to do so), the translations came out with equivalent numbers of lines. Boileau's satires attracted Kantemir primarily because they contained elements not to be found in the Russian poetic tradition of the Simeon Polotsky school, which he knew quite well: their concern with literature itself, their support for a good and proper national literature and their opposition to literature that was not
49 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
ILYA SERMAN
good and proper. Boileau's satires combined in literary form a typology of contemporary society with literary polemics and argumentation in favor of the literary principles which Boileau defended. Kantemir was equally influenced in his intellectual development by Jean de la Bruyere's satirical prose and Justus Van Effen's French journals published in Holland. From these Western authors he could learn methods of transforming characterological satire into an instrument of political combat. Kantemir's first original satire appeared in manuscript in 1729, at a time when the debates between the supporters and the opponents of the Petrine reforms were becoming more spirited. In 1730 he actively participated in attempts to gain influence with the new Empress Anna: he it was who wrote the first proposal in Russian history for a gentry constitution which would have established-a parliament of the nobility and limited the monarch's authority. With the support of the gentry Anna rejected the attempts of the high aristocracy to gain power with their own oligarchical proposal, and would have no part of Kantemir's either. She reverted to the traditional system of unlimited autocratic authority. Kantemir was removed from the center of political life and dispatched as ambassador to London in late 1731. By that time he had already written five satires. The first task with which the founders of modern Russian literature grappled was that of selecting a literary orientation. In view of his aspirations to make Russian poetry an active participant in the effort to educate the Russian intelligentsia in the spirit of the ideas of Peter's reign, Kantemir settled upon the verse satire - partly in its classical examples by Juvenal and Horace, but primarily on the model of the satires of Boileau, who had subsequently renewed the genre - as the most suitable genre for his purposes. Following Boileau's example, in his satires Kantemir combined the energy of current ideological debate with a precise depiction of Russian ways and Russian mores. Contemporary reality was poetically reflected within them; it became the object of conscious literary depiction. Kantemir as well as those, like Trediakovsky, who started out with him, not to mention such writers as Lomonosov who came along later, faced the necessity of defining themselves in literary 50 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
THE EIGHTEENTH CENTURY: I73O-9O terms, that is, of comprehending their place in the literary context, both within Russian culture and on the stage of European culture. When he addressed his readers in the satirical form, although his satires were read with interest, Kantemir discovered that in themselves his verse texts were difficult to understand. Consequently he felt compelled to equip them with prose commentaries, sometimes quite substantial ones. Kantemir turned to his readers directly to deal with that which was most complicated for them: his satires' literary form and devices connected with that form. In order to elucidate these devices, in many of his footnotes Kantemir would engage in vigorous arguments with his own characters. In Kantemir's first satire (first version) the "envious man" ridicules and condemns the sciences: We lived, he says, without knowing Latin, Before a great deal better than now, though ignorant; In our ignorance we reaped much better harvests; After we adopted a foreign tongue, our harvests have gone down. Kantemir adds the following note to these lines: In our ignorance we reaped much better harvests. One hears such things
from many people quite frequently, that after we started to adopt foreign languages and customs we began to suffer from famine, as though that were the reason for it; but people do not want to see the truth, which is that this is caused by the idleness of our agriculturalists and the bad weather, signs of God's displeasure with us for our severe offenses against Him and our insults to our neighbors, the sorts of things we have no need to borrow from other nations because we have plenty of them at home. This note informed the satire's readers that the satirist did not think the same way as his character, that he disagreed with his character, and that his character's opinions were precisely those convictions and ideas which the satirist opposed. In this way readers comprehended both the structure of the verse satire, a new poetic genre for Russian literature, as well as the basic principle of the new literature: it acted not through direct didacticism but rather by juxtaposing various conflicting viewpoints, inviting the reader to select those which seemed to him rational and correct. 51 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
ILYA SERMAN The novelty of Kantemir's satirical approach within Russian literature lay in the fact that for the most part he based it on the self-exposure of his negative characters. In speeches of ignoramuses, hypocrites and obscurantists which expose their motivations the reader can discern as it were through the text the images of positive heroes, honorable and virtuous people, enthusiastic supporters of science and enlightenment. In the name of a common and universal human morality Kantemir derides everything which cannot withstand the criticism of reason and feeling. But if Kantemir's negative personages incorporate living elements of contemporary mores within themselves, to such an extent that we can sometimes guess at their actual prototypes, then his positive figures are created through contrast with his negative ones and emerge as ideal schemes without any genuine living content. This does not mean that in itself Kantemir's ideal as a satirist was concocted solely in his own imagination: that ideal was founded on his profound conviction of the absolute superiority of the new view of the world created during Peter's reign over the old, traditionally religious approach. In London, where he spent six years, and then in Paris, where he was sent as ambassador in 1738, Kantemir continued to work on his satires, although the lack of any direct and living contact with a literary milieu made things difficult for him. As far as possible he compensated for that lack by making new acquaintances. In London he did not associate with the English particularly, but rather with Italian literary men and diplomats representing those north Italian states in which reforms along Enlightenment lines were being actively introduced in the 1730s (Parma, Lucca, and others). In Paris Kantemir drew close to Montesquieu, whose Persian Letters he translated (although the translation has not survived), and to those around him; he became a familiar figure in Paris literary salons. In these years as well Kantemir reworked his first five satires, evidently planning to publish them in Russia. He also wrote new satires, which set forth his Enlightenment viewpoint, though they had no specific connection with the situation in Russia. Kantemir died before his satires ever saw print, and in this sense the first modern Russian writer established a Russian tradition. His 52 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
THE EIGHTEENTH CENTURY: I73O-9O satires appeared initially in a French translation of 1749, next in a German version of 1752, and only then, finally, were they printed in Russia, in 1762. Various literary impressions of the years 1727-30 found places in Vasily Trediakovsky's basic literary project implemented abroad: his translation of Tallemant's book. The dispute within French literature over the advantages of poetry in prose or in verse was not yet decided, and Trediakovsky, not adhering definitively to either side in the dispute, chose to translate a work written in both verse and prose, that is, he tested his readers' reactions to both possible resolutions of the debate. In Paris Trediakovsky (1703-68) must have been even more greatly influenced by the arguments over the novel than he was by the disputes over verse and prose. In Russia there was no such thing as the novel as cultural phenomenon, the novel as a component part of the cultural surroundings of all levels of the population. It would acquire such popularity only in the nineteenth century. French scholars call the years Trediakovsky spent in Paris the "golden age" of the French novel. Between 1725 and 1730 fiftyone new novels were published, and in the subsequent five-year period 129 appeared. The novel became the most popular genre, supplanting the tragedy and the comedy. French novels of the late 1720s spoke of love as a law unto itself, a thing above all else in human existence. Novels undermined the official system of morality and were considered dangerous to religion. The version of Tallemant's novel which Trediakovsky offered to the Russian reading public contains essentially two conceptions of love. Tallemant's novel is an allegorical one, and its prose text tells of romantic adventures and mishaps which conclude with a taking leave of love and a turning to Glory at the advice of Reason. Even the most adamant critics of the novel of the late 1720s could accept such a love story as that. But the book by TrediakovskyTallemant contains verse as well as prose. In his verse translations Trediakovsky abandons any sort of trivial literalness: he alters the structure of strophes, utilizes lines of varying lengths, and so forth. But the most essential alterations he introduces have to do with the treatment of love and romantic relationships. He systematically 53 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
ILYA SERMAN
modifies Tallemant's verse descriptions of love relationships. He replaces abstract and periphrastic expressions in the original with concrete images and erotic situations. Trediakovsky made such serious modifications of Tallemant's verse because he was attracted by the French school of free-thinker libertine poets, whose work at the time was not published but only circulated in manuscript (it gradually began to appear in print only after Louis XIV's death). Precisely that sort of philosophy of love and life made Trediakovsky the most popular poet and songwriter in Russian society of the 1730s. In 1732 Trediakovsky became official translator for the Academy of Sciences in St. Petersburg. This position offered him new opportunities to influence literary life, but at the same time he was required to work in conformity with the demands of the Court, which regarded Academicians in the humanities as suppliers of solemn odes and eulogies for appropriate occasions, as planners of illuminations and firework displays, and as translators of texts for theatrical presentations by touring foreign troupes. Trediakovsky's position as an Academy poet-bureaucrat was made more difficult by the fact that the new Empress Anna, Peter I's niece, had formed her tastes and outlook in Mittau, capital of the duchy of Courland, a vassal state of Russia's, which had been governed first by her husband and then by her. Anna's German sympathies and those of her favorite, Ernst Johann Biron, a stableman whom she had created a Duke, were reflected in the preferential treatment the Court accorded to Academy poets who wrote in German. Gottlob Friedrich Wilhelm Junker (1703-46) received special encouragement from the Court: invited to the St. Petersburg Academy in 1731, in 1734 he was made professor of poetry over Trediakovsky's head. Junker and Jakov von Stahlin (1709-85), who replaced him in 1735, produced eulogistic odes and verse inscriptions for firework displays published in the German original and in Russian translation. That was the way Trediakovsky's "Solemn ode on the surrender of the city of Danzig" ("Oda torzhestvennaya o sdache goroda Gdanska," 1734) was printed: Junker did the German translation. By 1734 Trediakovsky, in addition to Latin and French versification, had become fairly well acquainted with German verse (since he translated the odes of the German court poets); with
54 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
THE EIGHTEENTH CENTURY: I73O-9O Italian poetry from the originals of comedies which he translated; with the poem "Tears of the Prodigal Son," written in trochaic meter, by the Croatian poet Ivan Gundulic. And then he was familiar with Russian folksongs as well. After comparing these different versification systems Trediakovsky came to the conclusion that Russian verse should be regulated in conformity with the nature of the Russian language, and that a versification reform was necessary. On 14 May 1735 Trediakovsky gave an address at the "Russian Convocation" of the Academy of Sciences in which he presented a proposal for a species of "Petrine reform" of all contemporary literature. Among the various projects he urged one had already been carried out: a "science of versification." Trediakovsky wished to replicate in literature that rupture with pre-Petrine Rus which the adherents of the Russian Enlightenment saw Peter as having effected on the level of the state. It was then that people became persuaded that the syllabic system as exemplified in "Polish verse" should be replaced by a system of versification which was more national and closer to the character of the Russian language. To be sure, Russian syllabic verse - by virtue of the very fact that it made use of another language than did Polish syllabic verse - had become Russian and not Polish, and could not really resemble its model. But the adherents of the Russian Enlightenment believed that if their campaign for a new poetry were to be successful they must declare syllabic verse "foreign," and not even poetry either, but rather prose. Trediakovsky elaborated on both these points in his New and Brief Methodfor Composing Russian Verse (Novy i kratky sposob k slozheniyu rossiyskikh stikhov, 1735)-
Along with the "Ode on the surrender of the city of Danzig," which had appeared a year earlier and to which was appended a "Treatise on the Ode" ("Rassuzhdenie ob ode"), the New and Brief Method offered a complete exposition of a system of poetic genres, a new model done in verse. For the first time in the history of Russian poetry a unified principle had been established for constructing a hierarchy of poetic genres corresponding to the relationship of each to the general idea of the new poetry. Moreover, the system of Russian poetic genres was laid out synchronically, with appropriate French examples for comparison 55 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
ILYA SERMAN
and contrast. As a man of the Enlightenment and a rationalist, Trediakovsky held that the poetry of any nation should express the great truths of the new science which were obligatory for all enlightened countries, and that Russian poetry was fully capable of carrying out this historical task once it had grasped the "rules" and adopted a new versification system more appropriate to its nature and consequently more "correct." Trediakovsky's book did not contain merely a practical "poetics": it was essentially an exposition of a new esthetic system, a programmatic statement for Russian classicism for half a century to come. Later attempts to elaborate this program in more detail added nothing substantial to Trediakovsky's ideas. The notion of the generality and universality of ideas which are identical for all nations and peoples, the conviction that poetic perfection could be achieved by imitating recognized models both ancient and modern, and that imitation could be successful only if the rules of each poetic genre were strictly observed: such were the basic ideas of the new esthetics, at the basis of which lay the notion of human nature as a good and rational product of rational upbringing shaped by the combined powers of science and art. Since Trediakovsky failed to find a wealthy patron among influential men at court, by the end of the 1730s his position had become not simply difficult, but unbearable. In early 1740 he was beaten up at the instance of Minister Artemy Volynsky; he received moral satisfaction and material compensation only after Volynsky was executed later that year. During the 1740s Trediakovsky abandoned poetry in the proper sense to busy himself with stylistic problems and questions of Russian grammar. In the 1750s he saw several quite extensive literary projects through to fruition. In addition to a prose translation of 1751 of John Barclay's (1582-1621) Latin novel Argenis (1621) - an apologia for powerful and enlightened monarchical authority - in the early 1750s Trediakovsky also did a verse translation of the Psalms, and the poem Feoptiya, a poetic version of Fenelon's popular treatise Demonstration de I'existence de Dieu (1713). Neither of these poetic works of Trediakovsky's was published during his lifetime, nor for a very long time after his death: Feoptiyafirstcame out in 1963, and the Psalms have even now been published only in very small part. In 1730, like Kantemir, Trediakovsky declined to employ what
56 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
THE EIGHTEENTH CENTURY: I73O-9O he considered the obsolete Church Slavic language in which all literary works in the Muscovite state had been written down to the period of the Petrine reforms; but in the 1750s he began composing verse in extraordinarily archaic, slavonicized, and deliberately syntactically convoluted language. His final and perhaps most significant poetic work - Telemakhida (1765), a verse translation of Fenelon's prose novel Les Auentures de Telemaque (1699) - became for contemporaries a laughing stock and symbol of artistic incompetence. Later generations of literary men - Radishchev, Gnedich and Pushkin among them - looked on Telemakhida differently: they admired Trediakovsky's innovation in employing a dactylotrochaic meter in his poem as a substitute and analogue for the ancient Greek hexameter, considering this an important contribution to the development of Russian verse. Mikhail Lomonosov (1711-65) studied at the Slavic-GreekLatin Academy in Moscow a few years after Trediakovsky matriculated there, and later was sent to Germany to study mining engineering. After spending five years in Germany, he returned in 1741 to Russia, where he quickly garnered renown as a poet. The experience of the first decade of Russian poetry's problematic existence (if we calculate from 1729, the year Kantemir's first satires appeared) had not produced a satisfactory solution to the problem of poetic style as a whole. Basing it solely upon the bookish Church Slavic tradition meant Russian poets would be mere epigones of the Simeon Polotsky school. But the exclusive use of the colloquial language might have submerged the new poetry and its ideas, quite novel for Russian culture, in a sea of unregulated linguistic currents with its great variety of social and regional dialects. A national literature required a unified, common, normalized literary language. Lomonosov founded his program, not on the notion of a break with the past, as Kantemir and Trediakovsky had advocated in the 1730s, but rather on the idea of incorporating within poetry everything genuinely poetic and genuinely artistic which Russian literature from the eleventh to the seventeenth centuries had to offer. "Russian verse should be written in conformity with the natural character of our language," wrote Lomonosov in his "Letter on the rules of Russian versification" ("Pismo o pravilakh ros-
57 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
ILYA SERMAN
siyskogo stikhotvorstva," 1739). It followed from this fundamental principle that Russian versification should draw upon the actual Russian accentual system, "as our natural pronunciation shows us quite easily." As Boris Tomashevsky has brilliantly noted, the essence of Trediakovsky's reform lay in his making the actual alternation of stressed and unstressed syllables, or the genuine rhythms of the language which had been totally ignored by the syllabic poets, into the metrics of the verse. But Trediakovsky was reluctant to extend his understanding of the nature of verse to all its categories. Lomonosov, having absorbed the experience of purely tonic German verse, boldly declared all of Russian verse to be tonic. Lomonosov then buttressed the theoretical correctness of his solution of the problem with his own poetic works, his odes of tjie 1740s, through which the Russian ode in fact defined its own essence. The ode did not develop so variously or become such an important poetic genre in any European literature of the ones with which the creators of modern Russian literature competed and compared themselves as it did in Russian literature. The ode was usually written on the occasion of some official event (a birthday, an anniversary of the coronation of a monarch) and was presented in the name of the Academy of Sciences. This accounts for its complimentary tone, its inevitable and obligatory praise of whoever was in power at the moment. The presence of such obligatory, ritual praise later caused some to accuse Lomonosov of flattery and unjustified exaltation of the ignorant, trivial and indolent Elizabeth, during whose reign from 1741 to 1761 most of his poetic works were produced. Those who castigated Lomonosov for his "unjustified praises" of the monarch - Radishchev, among others - did not realize that Lomonosov's eulogies as a rule display a rather conventional character and relate not so much to the present as to the future. Fundamentally, each of Lomonosov's odes is not so much a eulogy as a program elaborating those political and cultural initiatives which he thinks the Russian government should undertake if it genuinely has the nation's good at heart. All the way down to Alexander Pushkin's "Liberty" ("Volnost," 1817) and Kondraty Ryleev's "To Ermolov" ("K Ermolovu," 1822) the Russian ode 58 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
THE EIGHTEENTH CENTURY: I73O-9O preserved that peculiar character with which Lomonosov had endowed it: it always set forth a political program and was oriented toward the future. The thematic and linguistic structure of the Lomonosovian ode provides a special and original form to embody its content. Lomonosov does not limit himself to a simple, systematic exposition of his ideas or of any specific political program. He wants the reader to respond emotionally, and not just logically, to his feelings and ideas. He seeks to stir up his reader's emotions, not merely to make an impact upon his intellect. It is precisely for that reason that he develops the ode's poetic idea through conflict, through a clash of two polarities, two opposing concepts. Most frequently this is a clash between tranquility and destruction, war and peace, ending with the ultimate victory of the powers of reason and good. The author's attitude toward the universe he depicts in the ode is expressed not only, and not so much, through his own direct evaluation as through his clearly expressed view of the conflicting forces within the ode. The poet as ode writer appears before us as the sole personage within the poetic drama whose task it is not only to express his opinions of the conflicting forces, but also to provide an objective picture of the scale and intensity of the conflict itself. The basic contradiction within Lomonosov's view of things stemmed from the fact that he saw the world as divided, which meant that it could not be reduced to a single, all-embracing principle. Thus, while he discovered harmony and beauty in nature deriving from the movement of atoms, within society he found only conflict and contradictory interests. This pessimistic view of man in society emerged with particular force in Lomonosov's poetry in the theme of enemies and the theme of a destructive environment hostile to man. The spiritual odes which make up the first subdivision of Lomonosov's Collection of Various Works (Sobranie raznykh sochine-
niy, 1751) are arranged in the following order. First come translations of the first, fourteenth, twenty-sixth, thirty-fourth, seventieth, hundred forty-third, and hundred forty-fifth psalms, each of which is a monologue with complaints and petitions addressed by man to God. The complaints have to do with the imperfections of 59 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
ILYA SERMAN this world, the intrigues and slanders of one's enemies, while the petitions are for the punishment of those enemies, vengeance upon them for all their crimes and evil deeds. Next comes the "Ode selected from Job" ("Oda, vybrannaya iz Iova"), cast as a monologue addressed by God to man. This subdivision is capped by the "Morning" and "Evening meditations" ("Utrennee razmyshlenie," "Vechernee razmyshlenie"), in which nature's perfection and complexity are praised in the name of man. That same idea though now advanced in God's name - constitutes the basic content of the "Ode selected from Job." There is an obvious demarcation line between the translations of the Psalms and the three subsequent spiritual odes (the "Ode selected from Job" and the two "Meditations"). The psalms depict man in society; they contain a passionate and furious denunciation of the imperfections of human life as life in society. Although the themes running through the translations of the Psalms have a certain autobiographical character, they nevertheless remain a poetic treatment of the fate of man in general, of man in his loneliness foundering in a hostile world of human passions, of man with a burning desire to eradicate evil in the world. Lomonosov sees this evil as afflicting everything, even the throne, where the ruler stands at the head of the social order. Over against society he counterposes not only his ideal of man and citizen, but also the world of nature, the limitless variety and magnificence of the cosmos in which all is subject to unified and rational laws, in which the harmony of the world order in general is not threatened by the selfish or treacherous plots of man, of a cosmos through the study and contemplation of which man recovers confidence in his own powers and (as Lomonosov as deist was persuaded) belief in God the Creator, in the original impulse given Creation by its Great Master. Although during the 1740s Lomonosov wrote only odes, both eulogistic and spiritual, in the 1750s he took up other poetic genres. At the command of the Court he wrote two verse tragedies: Tamira and Selim (1750) and Demofont (1752). Of these only the former was ever staged, and it had no success with the public. In 1752, on his own initiative, Lomonosov composed a didactic poem entitled Letter on the Use of Glass (Pismo 0 poize stekla),
addressed to Ivan Shuvalov. In it he mounted a strong defense of 60 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
THE EIGHTEENTH CENTURY: I73O-9O contemporary scientific thought and, most especially, of the heliocentric view of the solar system, in opposition to the Holy Synod, which at the time sought to suppress any references to Copernicus and his discoveries. A few years later Lomonosov entered into an open conflict with the Synod in coming to the defense of his student Nikolay Popovsky, who by that time had become a professor at the newly founded Moscow University. A talented poet, Popovsky had done a verse rendering from a French translation of Alexander Pope's Essay on Man. The Synod refused to permit the translation to be published, and so in 1756 Lomonosov composed a satirical poem entitled "Hymn to the beard" ("Gimn borode") in which he attacked obscurantist church officials quite mercilessly and without mincing words. The "Hymn to the beard" circulated widely in manuscript, infuriating Lomonosov's enemies. The Synod submitted an official complaint against Lomonosov to the Empress (although no name was attached to the "Hymn") and requested that he be given over for trial to an ecclesiastical court. But Shuvalov was a favorite of the Empress, and his protection rescued Lomonosov from any further persecution. The translation of Essay on Man was published as well, although the most "harmful" lines within it were replaced by others composed by a censor appointed by the Synod. Lomonosov's largest poetic project was the epic poem Peter the Great (Petr veliky, 1760-1), which remained unfinished. Taking Voltaire's Henriade as his model, Lomonosov planned to depict Peter I's entire life, including his struggle against the opponents of his reforms and the difficult wars which he brought to successful conclusions. Lomonosov managed to write only two cantos of the poem, but even in that state it served for many years as a model for Russian poets interested in the epic genre. During his own lifetime Lomonosov was recognized as a classic, as the creator of modern Russian literature. Even his literary enemies - headed by Sumarokov during the 1750s - admitted that the Russian ode was Lomonosov's creation. And he remained the most widely recognized authority in Russian literature down to Pushkin's day, although in the late eighteenth century Radishchev condemned him for flattering the tsars and Karamzin criticized his prose as outdated. Even Pushkin could not avoid drawing upon the Lomonosovian 6l Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
ILYA SERMAN
legacy in his artistic quest. For example, in his poem Poltava he consciously employed the stylistic devices of the Lomonosovian eulogistic ode. And the Russian romantics of the 1820s and 1830s were attracted both by his philosophical positions and by his life, which they admired for its heroic quality. After Pushkin's day interest in Lomonosov's poetry subsided, although, as Yury Tynyanov has put it, "Lomonosov flared up here and there in the poetic currents of the nineteenth century." These "flare-ups" occurred most often when Russia undertook a war and stood in need of Lomonosov's odic verses for the glorification of military heroism. That was the case, for example, during the years of the Crimean War (1853-6), when odes began to be written once more, and also in 1904-5, during the Russo-Japanese War, when such well-known poets as Valery Bryusov and Vyacheslav Ivanov produced odes. The October revolution of 1917 and the period of totalitarian stabilization initiated in the mid-i92os saw no diminution of interest in the Lomonosovian ode in modern Russian poetry. On the contrary, reality in its official forms and official interpretations reproduced the basic historical situation of Lomonosov's day: the Poet in the presence of Authority, in the presence of the Leader and Master. Alexander Sumarokov (1717-77), unlike Trediakovsky and Lomonosov, came from the hereditary gentry and studied from 1732 to 1740 at the Cadet School for the Nobility, an elite training ground which prepared young aristocrats to enter government service, and principally military service. While still at the Cadet School Sumarokov began writing verses, initially imitating Trediakovsky; later he became a disciple of Lomonosov's. Along with his literary ally, he went up against Trediakovsky in a competition involving the translation of the hundred-forty-third psalm (1743). Trediakovsky did his translation in trochaic meter, while Sumarokov and Lomonosov used iambs for theirs. All three versions were published anonymously in a single booklet, and readers were invited to decide which version was best. Sumarokov acquired notoriety within Russian society of the 1740s for his love songs, which his youthful admirers set to music and sang in private gatherings. These lyrics not only brought 62 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
THE EIGHTEENTH CENTURY: I73O-9O Sumarokov an audience: through them he came to head an entire group of poets who specialized in songs. Intended for a popular audience, and not designed as great literature, Sumarokov's songs offered the public a novel conception of love as a genuine, profound, and unconquerable passion, and not as some sort of drawing-room flirtation, as it was presented in Trediakovsky's songs and in his translation of Journey to the Isle of Love. In Sumarokov's hands the song as it were goes beyond the limitations of the genre to become an original sort of dramatic concentrate which foreshadows his verse tragedies. The first of these tragedies, Khorev, appeared in 1747, a crucial year for Sumarokov. In that same year he published his "Epistle on poetry" ("Epistola o stikhotvorstve"), the first Russian verse treatise on poetics based on the model provided by Boileau for modern European literature in his L'Art poetique. For all its resemblances to European treatises on poetics, the "Epistle on poetry" took proper account of the Russian literary situation and of Russian literature's future requirements as Sumarokov understood them. For example, aside from the verse tragedy, the "Epistle on poetry" treats the song and its stylistics in some detail, and emphasizes the importance of the verse fable as well. With the appearance of this treatise on poetics modern Russian literature declared, essentially and formally, its adherence to the dominant literary trend of the times, i.e. classicism, although this term came to be used only later, during the romantic war against eighteenth century literary traditions. Sumarokov took from classical literary theory its insistence upon norms, its system of rules and taboos, a particularly strict view of genres, and a painstaking distinction among stylistic devices corresponding to the genre hierarchy, from the highest (the epic poem) to the lowest (the fable). At the same time Sumarokov advocated the principle of stylistic simplicity for the majority of poetic genres as well as for literature in general. On this basic point Sumarokov parted company with Lomonosov both in theory and in practice. Their formerly friendly relationship became quite hostile, and a vicious literary polemic sprang up between them in which Sumarokov and the young poets who followed him were on the attack. In this literary controversy Sumarokov drew sustenance from his increasing popularity, for which his verse tragedies were pri63 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
ILYA SERMAN marily responsible. Sumarokov wrote nine tragedies in all: Khorev (1747), Hamlet (1748; he was acquainted with the Shakespearean tragedy in Laplace's French translation), Sinav and Truuor (1750), Artistona (1750), Semira (1751), Yaropolk and Dimiza (1758), Vysheslav (1768), Dmitry The Impostor {Dmitry Samozuanets, 1771), and
Mstislav (1774). The playwright sets six of his tragedies in Kievan times, i.e. from the tenth to the twelfth centuries, while the action of Dmitry the Impostor occurs in the early seventeenth century, and thus is considerably closer in time. The structure of Sumarokov's tragedies, their plots, the fact that their heroes are chosen only from among rulers and great nobles, the absence of realistic details of everyday life, and the obvious distance of the events described from the time of writing - all these things link them to the well-established general European tradition of the classical tragedy from Racine to Voltaire and Gottsched. Sumarokov's tragedies had an immense esthetic and ethical impact upon Russian society. What was new and astounding for the viewers of these tragedies was his system of ethical precepts, that world of moral principles in which his heroes lived, principles for which they were willing to fight and to die. The system of ethical precepts set out in Sumarokov's tragedies was strictly defined by the time of the action, by the epoch in which they took place as Sumarokov understood it. In all Sumarokov's tragedies on old Russian topics the action takes place in the pre-Christian pagan era. The characters in his tragedy speak only of the gods, of fate and its influence on human destiny. However, the gods do not interfere in human affairs in any specific way in Sumarokov's tragedies. When his heroes address the gods in monologues or dialogues, they do so merely for emotional reasons: the gods take no part at all in the "plot." Rather the principal determinant of the heroes' actions is ethics and morality, condensed in the concept of honor. The fundamental source of the conflict in Sumarokov's tragedies is the struggle between love and honor in the consciousness and behavior of the heroes. The playwright depicts this struggle as the chief motivation behind their behavior. This notion of purely ethical motivations for the ideas and actions of the Russians before the Mongol invasions to which Sumarokov gave such artistic expression became established in-
64 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
THE EIGHTEENTH CENTURY: I73O-9O Russian tragedy and survived there until the mid 1820s. In this sense Sumarokov regarded the time of Kievan Rus as a special and heroic era of the nation's history. Sumarokov and his followers by no means set out deliberately to modernize the past. On the contrary, they knew very well that Kievan Rus was fundamentally different from the Muscovite state of the early seventeenth century and from the Russian Empire of the mid eighteenth century. But their conception of the moral consciousness of the Russian nobility in the pre-Mongol period made that epoch seem especially attractive to them in the esthetic sense; they found in it especially appropriate material for their tragic art. Although he confirms his hero's unvarying obligation to heed the requirements of honor rather than the summons of passion, Sumarokov nevertheless views and depicts passion as a force just as powerful as honor. In fact, if there were no passions there would be no tragedy either. For that reason Sumarokov's contemporaries spoke of him as "tender," that is, as a poet most interested in depicting love and not honor. And it was precisely that "tenderness" - the depiction of love - which contemporaries valued most of all in Sumarokov. Sumarokov's early tragedies made such an impression on Russian society that Elizabeth's government decided to create a Russian theater in Russia: it was founded in 1756, and Sumarokov became its first director. But his prose comedies had no great influence. One finds in them neither complex personalities nor an especially complete depiction of contemporary society. Sumarokov wrote a series of pamphlet comedies in whose characters contemporaries could easily recognize the author's personal or literary enemies. Sumarokov's admiring contemporaries bestowed the title of "The Northern Racine" upon him for his tragedies. His fables brought him no less notoriety, as well as the title of "The Russian La Fontaine." In the dispute over various types of fables which engrossed European theoreticians of this genre in the middle of the eighteenth century, Sumarokov consciously sided with La Fontaine, the advocate of situational and linguistic humor within the genre, and not moralism. Sumarokov went even further than La Fontaine by eliminating in his fables the distinction between the poet and the reader. The 65 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
ILYA SERMAN
fable-writer no longer looks down on ordinary mortals from the Parnassian heights, but is rather alongside them, nearby; he does not instruct and berate his readers, but rather shares with them his thoughts, ideas, and life-experience. The narrator in his fables is in the very thick of things, alongside his characters. This proximity to the world of the fable is a special and important fundamental innovation of Sumarokov's, a manifestation of his artistic originality in developing an approach to the fable which led to an entirely independent variant of the fable as La Fontaine created it. At the same time, as a fable-writer Sumarokov does not hesitate to evaluate the actions of his fictional characters, even though he formulates his evaluations through a comic exposure of his heroes in a manner analogous to that employed by Kantemir in his verse satires. In both Sumarokov's fables and Kantemir's satires there emerges a clear opposition quite typical for the psychology of the eighteenth-century Enlightenment, an opposition on the one Hand between the author as the proponent of a scientifically rational approach to the world, as a "philosopher" in the sense in which that word was generally used during the Enlightenment, and on the other hand an "irrational," confused world of social and human relationships lacking any sort of natural, rational, moral criterion of human behavior. The peculiarity of this sort of consciousness - which the literature of Russian classicism counterposed to that universal fair of worldly vanity - lay in the fact that this consciousness was a poetic one, one which produced its impact not merely by the power of "rational thought," as Sumarokov had said of Kantemir, but rather through the energies of art, through laughter and the comic exposure of literary characters in the satirical genres. As Grigory Gukovsky, that remarkable investigator and specialist on Sumarokov's art, has pointed out, Sumarokov's contemporaries, who used to extol his fables to the heavens and who considered his tragedies among the finest achievements of European literature, have almost nothing to say about his personal, intimate and primarily love lyrics [...] and [...] about that extensive segment of his poetry which he called "spiritual" verse. It was precisely in his lyric verse that Sumarokov exploited the possibilities of Russian syllabotonic verse which had escaped Lomonosov's and Trediakovsky's notice. He wrote in every sort of
66 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
THE EIGHTEENTH CENTURY: I73O-O.O meter, reproduced classical strophic forms, wrote free verse and utilized dolniki (accentual verse), to which Russian poets reverted only in the twentieth century. In the area of versification Sumarokov was far ahead not only of his own time, but of the nineteenth century as well. At mid-century it became clear that the efforts of the few enthusiasts who had labored in the 1730s and 1740s had made Russian literature a notable feature of Russian cultural life. The founding of the Russian theater in 1756 also had an impact on literary development. The fledgling theater faced an immediate problem requiring immediate resolution: it had to stage plays without waiting for new Russian playwrights to appear in Sumarokov's wake. There was only one solution: translate those items from the popular European repertoire suitable for the Russian theater-goer of the 1750s and 1760s. We know exactly what sort of things St. Petersburg theater-goers wanted from contemporary memoirs. One memoirist wrote in 1765: "One segment of the audience, a very small one, likes plays dealing with characters, sentimental and filled with noble thoughts, while the larger segment prefers merry comedies." This means that most theater-goers wished to be entertained, they wanted to laugh and be amused, and not especially to be instructed. These demands upon the Russian theater determined its history for half a century, if we confine ourselves solely to the eighteenth century. The chief questions which the founders of Russian comedy had to answer were first formulated in the mid 1760s in a circle of theatrical people and playwrights gathered around Ivan Elagin (1725—94), who took over the directorship of the St. Petersburg theater from Sumarokov. This group advanced the idea of adapting foreign comedies to Russian tastes. The approach developed by the Elagin circle was the first step toward the creation of a national comedy repertoire as opposed to a translated repertoire designed solely for entertainment. These playwrights gathered their theoretical ideas and their practical examples from the achievements of west European literature, and especially the French stage. In the early 1760s Denis Diderot's views on theatrical reform were very popular with Russian translator-playwrights, who accepted his doctrine of the comedy as a "serious genre."
67 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
ILYA SERMAN Vladimir Lukin's (1737-94) programmatic work A Wastrel Reformed by Love (Mot, lyubovyu ispravlenny, 1765), written and
staged with Elagin's enthusiastic approval, was a first attempt in the genre of the serious comedy, then quite novel for Russian literature. Lukin's basic dramatic device was self-narration, a character's account of himself, his self-analysis, his conclusions about himself, which were supposed to serve both as an authorial evaluation and also to let the viewer know quite definitely and entirely unhesitatingly what attitude he should adopt toward a particular character in the play, depending on whether the latter's behavior has been moral or immoral. So far as dramatic characterization is concerned, in principle there is no difference between positive and negative personages in Lukin's serious comedy; they are all equally dedicated to selfanalysis and to providing information on their actions, intentions and feelings to the audience. Lukin's efforts at creating a serious comedy yielded no significant artistic results because in rejecting Sumarokov's proposals for the creation of social satire he also ceased to employ humor as a special form for expressing the author's attitude toward his depiction, toward the object of his satirical exposure. Along with the theater, another new departure for Russian literature was prose in its various forms, since for the preceding quarter-century poetry had been dominant, and all the founders of modern Russian literature had been poets first of all. Sumarokov was not only the editor and almost the sole author of the first Russian literary journal, The Industrious Bee (Trudolyubivaya pchela,
1759), he also wrote for its pages satirical prose which built upon the varied accomplishments of French and German satirical journalism of the eighteenth century. Following Sumarokov's example, in 1760 a group of teachers at the Cadet School began issuing a literary and didactic journal entitled Spare Time Put to Use (Prazdnoe vremya v polzu upotreblen-
noe). This same group of writers also set about the systematic translation of English and French novels. For example, Lukin and Elagin translated Antoine Prevost's Adventures of Marquis G., Or, The Life of a Nobleman Who Abandoned the World (1756-61), and
Semyon Poroshin translated the same author's English Philosopher (1761-7). The novels of Henry Fielding, Rene Lesage, Pierre
68 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
THE EIGHTEENTH CENTURY: I73O-9O Marivaux, and Daniel Defoe's Robinson Crusoe were also translated. These translated novels provided the Russian public with entertaining reading in addition to acquainting it with those works which had already become part of the culture of every literate person in western Europe. The first Russian novelist, Fyodor Emin (1735-70), also began publishing in the early 1760s. He was a man of astonishing background and of quite varied literary abilities. His most popular works were the adventure novels Inconstant Fortune, or Miramond's Adventures (Nepostoyannaya fortuna Hi pokhozhdeniya Miramonda) and Themistocles's Adventures (Priklyucheniya Femistokla), both
published in 1763. The action of the novels takes place in various European countries as their heroes undergo most unexpected experiences before their creator brings everything to a happy ending. Emin's later novel, Letters of Ernest and Doravra (Pisma
Emesta i Doravry, 1766), was the first attempt at a Russian epistolary novel and an open imitation of Jean-Jacques Rousseau's La Nouvelle Heloise (1761), which had caused a stir in Europe at that time. Following Rousseau's lead, Emin acquainted his readers with the preromantic devices of psychologism which were new to them. Mikhail Chulkov (1734-92) was an actor and then a servant at court before he finally became a literary man; but his financial circumstances compelled him to seek government employment, in which he rose to a sufficiently high bureaucratic rank to obtain personal nobility. In cooperation with Mikhail Popov, Chulkov in 1767 compiled a Brief Mythological Dictionary (Kratky mifologichesky slovar), which
offered the Russian reader, in addition to information on the gods of antiquity, a pagan Slavic pantheon of divinities drawn up on the basis of rather unreliable sources and partially simply concocted by the compilers. But Chulkov's and Popov's Slavic gods continued to figure in Russian literature down to the middle of the nineteenth century. In 1770-4, again in cooperation with Popov, Chulkov published the first printed collection of Russian songs, the Collection of Various Songs (Sobranie raznykh pesen), containing some 800
literary and folk songs. But Chulkov's most important literary work was the unfinished
69 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
ILYA SERMAN novel The Comely Cook, or The Adventures of a Debauched Woman (Prigozhaya povarikha Hi Pokhozhdeniya razvratnoy zhenshchiny,
1770), a remarkable instance of a Russian rogue-novel. The book's heroine, Martona, fights a desperate battle against all obstacles in an effort to achieve worldly success without taking account either of the law or of religious morality (it should be added that the entire world as Chulkov sees it has no use for morality either). Stylistically Chulkov employs living colloquial Russian with a generous smattering of proverbs and folk sayings. In this regard Chulkov's prose is immeasurably better than the prose of Emin, whom Chulkov attacked unsparingly in his journals at the time. The invigoration of literary life was not confined to St. Petersburg. In Moscow the first Russian university, founded in 1755, became the center of the city's literary life. In 1760 Mikhail Kheraskov - one of the university's curators and himself a poet of the Sumarokovian school - followed the example of the Industrious Bee and began publishing a literaryjournal entitled Useful Entertainment (Poleznoe uveselenie, 1760-2). This was followed by Free Time (Svobodnye chasy, 1763), Innocent Exercise (Nevinnoe uprazhnenie, 1763), and Good Intentions (Dobroe namerenie, 1764). For the most
part these journals published poetry, although they offered philosophical and moralistic prose as well. These were the journals in which those poets who considered themselves Sumarokov's followers made their debuts; in subsequent years those poets defined the course of Russian literature. In addition to Kheraskov the contributors included Ippolit Bogdanovich, Vasily Maykov and others who have left less noticeable traces in the literature of that time. The new literary vigor of the early 1760s was not only the result of the fact that the new Empress Catherine II considered herself obliged in the eyes of her subjects and of all Europe to nurture enlightenment and literature, but also of the fact that she wished to function as an author herself. Catherine compiled a treatise, mostly on the basis of the writings of Montesquieu and Beccaria, in which she expounded the general principles of Enlightenment thought. She published the treatise anonymously in major European languages under the title Instruction to the Commission for the Compilation of a New Code of Laws (Nakaz dlya komissii po sochineniyu
novogo ulozheniya). This publication was supposed to demonstrate 70 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
THE EIGHTEENTH CENTURY: I73O-9O to the whole of Europe that in Russia, reputed to be a despotic state, a body of legislation could be passed which would be founded on the basic principles of western political thought. The Commission for the Compilation of a New Code of Laws, created in 1767, which had elected representatives from all segments of the population except the enserfed peasantry, seemed to many at the time to resemble a Parliament. As a means of distracting public opinion, in early 1769 Catherine began the publication of a satirical weekly entitled All Sorts and Sundries (Vsyakaya vsyachina). In this connection she not only urged Russian writers to follow her example, but for a certain period freed editors from preliminary censorship. And several literary figures did follow the example of All Sorts and Sundries, which was under the direction of Catherine herself with her State Secretary G. Kositsky as its editor. Mikhail Chulkov began publishing a weekly, This and That (I to i syo), a title which duplicated the title of Catherine's journal in a different form; Emin began publishing the weekly Miscellany (Smes) and the monthly Hell's Post (Adskaya pochta); Nikolay Novikov brought out the weekly Drone (Truten). The prose works appearing in the satirical journals of 1769 were simultaneously a new literary phenomenon for Russian culture and a new form for the expression of public opinion. Nikolay Novikov (1744-1818) had the task of establishing satirical journalism's right to treat such social phenomena as had formerly been within the sole jurisdiction of the bureaucracy in Tsarist Russia, which could be considered only in secret and then only with the knowledge and approval of the authorities. The appearance of the Instruction, however, made it possible for journalists to discuss questions of political life which had earlier been forbidden. The Deputies to the Commission of 1767, for all their sharp differences on other matters, were agreed on the necessity of basing social relations as they had developed by the 1760s on the firm foundation of legality. The majority of the speeches by the deputies display a consistent desire for its establishment. The situation of the peasantry was not examined in and of itself, but rather as part and parcel of the general problem of arbitrariness and illegality from which all social classes, including the nobility, suffered to some degree. 71 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
ILYA SERMAN
The chief object of satirical treatment in Novikov's Drone was the Russian nobility, which refused to adopt the ideas of the Enlightenment or yield even a fraction of its privileges. This approach of Drone's generated a critical response in the pages of Catherine's All Sorts and Sundries. Catherine was evidently quite displeased at this dispute, for in any case the Drone was compelled to cease its polemics with her journal, and in general Novikov could renew his journalistic activity only in 1772, by which time Catherine had already made her debut as a playwright with the anonymously published comedy Oh Time! (O vremya!). The very fact that the ruler should be participating directly in Jiterary life was an astounding novelty in Russia. In dedicating his new satirical journal The Painter (Zhivopisets) to the author o£Oh Time!, Novikov asserted that his struggle against the moral barbarism of the aristocracy coincided with the aims of the Empress as comedy writer. When public opinion shifted as a consequence of the Pugachov rebellion of 1773-4, Novikov ceased to publish any further satirical journals, confining himself instead to collecting the best articles from Drone and The Painter for reissue in 1775. At this point Novikov's purely literary activity ceased. In 1775 he became a Freemason and an adherent of Rosicrucianism. In Moscow, with the assistance of his ideological allies, he organized a publishing house called the "Typographical Company," an immense enterprise for the time. Translations for it were supplied by the so-called "Friendly Society," which he also organized. At this stage Novikov published journals of masonic content such as Morning Light (Utrenny svet) and Evening Light (Vechernyaya zarya). He also leased the newspaper Moscow News (Moskovskie vedomosti)
from 1779 to 1789, transforming its Supplement (Pribavleniya) into a serious political and general publication which paid considerable attention to the American revolutionary war. Novikov's activity as a book publisher through the Typographical Company reached a scale unheard of at that point in the history of Russian culture. He published textbooks, books on agriculture, medicine, pedagogy, philosophy and theology as well as books for children, including the first Russian children's magazine Reading for Children (Detskoe chtenie), which became a literary training ground for Nikolay Karamzin, that outstanding writer and reformer of Russian prose 72 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
THE EIGHTEENTH CENTURY: I73O-9O in the 1790s. As he expanded his publishing activity Novikov also created a book trade within Russia on a European scale in every province of the enormous country by making arrangements with local merchants to sell his books on a commission basis. The scale of the educational enterprise upon which Novikov and his associates had embarked aroused Catherine's displeasure from the very first. In 1792, having come to suspect him and the other Moscow Freemasons of political connections with the heir to the throne, the future Emperor Paul I, Catherine destroyed everything Novikov had created. He was himself arrested and sentenced to fifteen years imprisonment in the Shlusselburg Fortress. When Paul came to the throne in 1796 he freed Novikov, but by that time he was both ill and completely ruined financially. Denis Fonvizin (1745-91), who emerged from the Elagin-Lukin circle, concentrated his energies on developing methods for the comic depiction of contemporary mores, in which sense he became a literary ally of Novikov and his Drone. His first successful play was the comedy The Brigadier (Brigadir, 1769), in which "right-thinking" characters - i.e. reasonable and virtuous personages - are not the exception but rather the norm. Fonvizin compensates for the small numbers of these adherents of intellect and virtue in The Brigadier by giving them a powerful ally - laughter. It is precisely laughter which overcomes and conquers the forces of unreason presented in such variety within the comedy. Sofya and Dobrolyubov, the virtuous heroes, adopt a neutral attitude toward the other characters. They are concerned primarily with their own affairs, and the most they permit themselves are cautious mockery and contempt. There is absolutely no link between them and the other characters in the play, not even a
conflict. In The Brigadier Fonvizin utilized a great deal from the theory and practice of the serious comedy, but that did not cause him to reject laughter or to cease searching for comic depictions of various types of human behavior. The special circumstances under which the characters in The Brigadier are placed - the intertwining of family and romantic relationships - gave the author the opportunity to display various personages in one and the same comic situation, to make them participants in a common dispute. For example, the humor in one of these disputes (over the limitations
73 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
ILYA SERMAN of God's omnipotence) derives from a collision between the phraseology of high literary style and its interpretation in everyday terms, from a reinterpretation of formulas translated from the Biblical world of images and concepts into the world of contemporary Russian life, into an everyday context, into the sphere of military and bureaucratic discourse and notions of life in which the official "Table of Ranks" is viewed as something unchangeably established by divine sanction. In such fashion the author's relationship to his comedy is not "eliminated," but does acquire a considerable internal complexity. It is not only the comic characters who fall within its field of gravity, but also in many instances that "serious" world which they parody. In The Brigadier the social problem concerns solely the social elite: there are no servants in the play, and all its heroes are members of the nobility. This gives Fonvizin an opportunity to analyze the moral condition of the governing class, whose internal
situation led him to conclude that social morality should be based upon a system of values outside the individual. In The Brigadier the conflict between intellect and stupidity is realized theatrically in the form of a dispute among idiots. "Our" morals - that is, the morals which existed at the time among the Russian nobility and the necessity of providing some sort of national definition for them are displayed through the grotesque depiction of the Gallomania of Ivanushka and the Councillor's Wife. Gallomania and the Helvetian morality of the young taken to idiotic extremes are shown as inevitable consequences of the absence of any moral standards at all among the older generation. Fonvizin's skepticism and pessimism in The Brigadier are balanced by his comic treatment of all the characters, for the author's laughter provides the viewer with the support he needs in the conflict between intellect and stupidity transpiring on the stage. Fonvizin's philosophical development in the period between The Brigadier and The Minor (Nedorosl, 1783) bears the imprint of
the intellectual battles and the diplomatic activity in which he was engaged at the time along with Count Nikita Panin. The internal struggles within the court gave him the opportunity to study at first hand the structure and mainsprings of the absolutist system in the variant which Catherine developed to preserve her own power and to strengthen her social base. 74 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
THE EIGHTEENTH CENTURY: I73O-9O To absolutism and its practical morality of "luck" and success Fonvizin sought to counterpose the independent intellect of the nobility and a morality of social service based upon a concept of the social necessity of religion as a basis for such morality. Fonvizin's viewpoint on the role of religion as a force for socialization, in which are to be found "all the power and security of human law," was first set forth in his "Discourse on the recovery of the Crown Prince Paul" ("Slovo na vyzdorovlenie velikogo kriyazya Pavla Petrovicha," 1771). Fonvizin conceives of education as the basic instrument for the formation of the socially engaged personality grounded in religion, which he assembles as a system in the form of a particular variant of deistic stoicism ultimately stemming from the masonic idea of the soul as a concentration point of moral concepts and habits of behavior which meet the criteria of social reasonableness. His return to a recognition of religion's social utility and even its necessity brought Fonvizin into conflict with the Encyclopedists and caused him to seek support from such moderate representatives of the French Enlightenment as Antoine-Leonard Thomas and even from Fenelon's humanitarian religious views, resurrected during the French ideological battles of the 1770s. On the basis of a visit to France soon after the failure of Anne Robert Jacques Turgot's reforms, Fonvizin decided that the Encyclopedists were just as responsible as the reactionary clergy for the profound social and moral crisis which afflicted the country then. A comparison of Fonvizin's letters to Panin of 1777-8 with his "Discourse on permanent laws of state" ("Rassuzhdenie o nepremennykh zakonakh"), written in 1783, makes it possible to comprehend Fonvizin's social and historical conception, constructed on the basis of a comparative analysis of the contemporary cultures of Russia and the west, in this case represented by France. In the "Letters to Panin" and the "Discourse on permanent laws" Fonvizin examined the social structure of France from the viewpoint of the elite class: for him the determining element in evaluating the state of the nation was the moral condition of the nobility, which he regarded as the "nation's representatives," the only ones who expressed its consciousness. If we used the 75 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
ILYA SERMAN terminology of Russian thinkers of the 1840s, we might say that in the thinking portion of the nobility Fonvizin saw a "selfconsciousness" raised above "substance," a group counterposed to the benighted, uneducated masses, the body of the nation, which was incapable of absorbing ideology and thought. Far from weakening that belief, the Pugachov rebellion simply confirmed Fonvizin's conviction that "substance" was incapable of playing a conscious historical role, of acting in a rational social sense. As Fonvizin depicted her in his letters to Panin, France was in an at least unhappy, if not actually catastrophic, situation as a consequence of the moral paralysis of the French nobility, which had lost any sense of its obligations to the nation and was selfishly interested merely in exercising its own rights. Absolutism had been transformed into despotism, and the nobility transformed into the pillars of that despotism, into its obedient servants. As a consequence, in The Minor, whose action occurs in a distant province far from the capital, the "court" theme - references to the highest authorities and their malignant influence on morality receives no less attention than the play's basic action: the conflict between the Prostakovs on the one hand and Starodum and his associates on the other. The "court" with its named and unnamed personages, Prostakova's father and Starodum's father, is represented offstage. The offstage characters create within The Minor the historical and social perspective necessary for the development of the comedy's basic ideological conflict. What Nikolay Gogol once called the Prostakov family's "coarse bestiality" is contrasted within the comedy with the high level of gentry self-consciousness and morality displayed by Starodum and his friends. Starodum's behavior and that of his friends is always ideologically motivated; all their actions, feelings and thoughts are permeated by their sense of moral obligation. Their consciousness has an ethical quality, and their code of ethics is quite conscious. The opposing party in The Minor- Mrs. Prostakova, her family and relatives - live and act independently of any ideology: in their minds custom and habit substitute for it. Prostakova espouses no theories, no ideological systems, no religion or morality. Her behavior on stage is determined by her emotional assessment of any given situation, not a rational one. Her behavior is not guided by the logic of self-consciousness but by a logic of instinct.
76 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
THE EIGHTEENTH CENTURY: I73O-9O In The Minor the opposing sides in the conflict are both intellectually and morally so unequal that there really can be no quarrel between them. No more can there be a quarrel among Starodum's friends, for they are all united in their outlook, "sympathizers," and therefore their stage conversations are make-believe dialogues in which they elaborate but a single thought which they all take for granted. The actual dispute which Starodum conducts on stage and over the heads of his friends is a quarrel with the universe of false conceptions. He defends social and ethical truths from the distortions to which they are subjected by contemporary aristocratic society. Starodum steps forward as judge and prosecutor of this universe of distorted conceptions, and his associates support him in that struggle. As Fonvizin sees it, in the area of thought and ideology Starodum can make contact only with his associates and with the theater audience, at least if we assume that it shares the viewpoint of the author of The Minor. By their ironic rejoinders and questions Starodum and his friends provoke Mrs. Prostakova, Mitrofan and Skotinin to make comic statements which have consistently evoked laughter from the Russian theatergoer to this day. As Fonvizin saw it, this was the form the victory of Starodum and his friends should take, the victory of the world of high ideas and moral truths over the world of ignorance and dark instincts, the victory of culture over ignorance, of reason over the unbridled forces of empirical existence, of conscious service to the cause of the nation's social progress over the world of selfishness and animal instincts. The comic elements in The Minor appear only in the words and actions of Mrs. Prostakova and her relatives. The words and behavior of Starodum and his friends are serious. The most they permit themselves beyond the boundaries of absolute seriousness is to ironize at Prostakova's expense. The Minor displays with special force one of the most acute internal contradictions to afflict the Russian Enlightenment of the second half of the eighteenth century: the contradiction between abstraction, the idealization of certain concepts, and the real world of concrete phenomena, between a static notion of a deductively defined system of the rational and the obligatory, and a dynamic idea of empirical reality which develops of its own accord. In The Minor laughter and 77 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
ILYA SERMAN comedy are always with Mrs. Prostakova and Mitrofan, and are never to be found in Starodum. The wild, unchannelled displays of blind vital energy in Prostakova turn out to be immeasurably more significant than the elitist system of values to which Starodum wants to subject history and life. The conflict between thought and life in The Minor- the conflict between beautiful, rational thought and monstrous, ridiculous life - is resolved ideologically by the victory of thought; but theatrically, artistically, it is Mrs. Prostakova, and not Starodum, who gains the victory. Life with its brute force and particularity emerges the victor, and not thought with its rationality and abstraction. It is the lines of Mrs. Prostakova and Mitrofan, their sayings, that people now remember, and not Starodum's noble arguments. They remember Mrs. Prostakova's sayings because "nature" speaks in them, not a role which the author has assigned the character to play. When Mrs. Prostakova, enraged at the news that her servant girl Palashka is ill, shrieks: "She's delirious, the beast! As if she were a noblewoman!" - her words are humorous because they combine absurd stupidity (as if only a nobleman, a member of the gentry, could be delirious) with Prostakova's own straightforward conviction that she is quite correct. Prostakova is not playing on a stage: she lives in the world of her own understanding, and never emerges from it. She is always serious. That is precisely what makes her humorous. Perhaps without realizing it himself, Fonvizin perceived in Prostakova's "undirected force" some sort of constant within the national character. Starodum's beautiful and noble ideas are excessively burdened by the Utopian optimism of the period immediately preceding the French revolution. The system of values they contain is excessively elitist. The wild and directionless outbursts of blind vital energy from Mrs. Prostakova have not become outmoded either in their essence or in their form. Such is the irony of history, and that Fonvizin could not have foreseen. In the 1760s and 1770s certain writers who had been disciples and followers of Sumarokov's in their youth continued to develop those same genres in which Sumarokov had gained general recognition (the tragedy and the fable) as well as others to which he had paid no attention - which latter included the epic poem. Vasily 78
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
THE EIGHTEENTH CENTURY: I73O-9O Maykov and Ippolit Bogdanovich boast the greatest achievements in this genre. Vasily Maykov's (1728-78) poem Elisey, or Bacchus Enraged (Elisey, Hi razdrazhenny Vakkh) was, after Sumarokov's fables, the most important example of Russian satirical poetry, conjoining as it did the force of satirical exposure with a vivid depiction of the mores of the urban underclass in the Russian capital. In addition to specifically poetic traditions (Sumarokov's depiction of the "life of the common people" in his fables and Kantemir's descriptions of popular entertainments), Maykov also made use of the accomplishments of Russian satirical journalism of 1769-70, which had worked out methods of depicting social vices and disorders. As Maykov first conceived of the poem - the adventures of the cabdriver Elisey and his wife, who finally ends up in a prison for streetwalkers - were to have reflected a development in Russian life which many journalists and economists of the mid 1760s had written about and which was typical of the increasing complexity of economic relations in a system based on serfdom, when economic growth was limited by the amount of labor available and the labor market had to be supplemented by peasants temporarily permitted to work in the cities for wages. Maykov depicts this movement from the country to the capitals as an unavoidable shift from healthful, productive labor to a slough of drunkenness, vice and crime. That is the chiefjournalistic line promoted in Elisey. The work's plot is constructed on another economic topic, one no less important at the time: criticism of the system of farming out the sale of alcoholic beverages which was introduced in Russia in 1767 and which proved quite ruinous for the basic mass of the population. The struggle against these tax-farmers is the plot center of the poem's "fabulous," fantastic portion, which takes place among the gods of Olympus. Bacchus dispatches the cabdriver Elisey to wreak vengeance upon the tax-farmers for raising the prices of vodka and beer. In his poem Maykov defends the interests of the peasantry to the extent that they coincide with the interests of the landowners who manage their estates rationally, but no further. Consequently, although he derives condescending enjoyment from the feats of the valiant cabdriver in the taverns, winecellars, and other dens of
79
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
ILYA SERMAN
iniquity in the big city, he remains of the opinion that only agricultural labor under the reasonable supervision of the landowner can keep the peasant within the bounds of healthy morality and social discipline. Along with Maykov's hero we are introduced to a St. Petersburg of a sort no one had ever written about in eighteenth-century Russian poetry before him. This was not the St. Petersburg of palaces, churches, and parks, but rather the city of lower-class suburbs, of taverns and of lock-ups. The poem described what later came to be called urban lowlife. The city's entire geography in the poem is defined by the location of one point or another in relation to popular drinking establishments. Aside from its purely journalistic aims, Maykov's poem was composed for a particular literary purpose. It was the first attempt at an original "heroic-comic" poem of the sort Sumarokov had described in such detail and with such taste in his "Epistle on poetry." In it the adventures of drunken hotheads or a fight between the peasants of Zimogorets and those of Valday is described in the high style of the epic poem, made even more humorous by the fact that it is Elisey who is recounting all this. Maykov preserves the distinctions between the high and low style, and the poem's humor derives partially from the collision between the two, but it was not only that which made his poem so popular in literature as late as the 1820s. Maykov's humor often derives from the narrator's attitude toward his narration, and not only from the contrast between elements from differing stylistic spheres. Pushkin esteemed Vasily Maykov precisely for his unconstrained authorial attitude, for his natural and ironic approach to his heroes and their adventures. In the 1770s new literary trends, new esthetic notions, new poetic worlds revealed to the European literary consciousness by sentimentalism and preromanticism, evoked a double response from the representatives of Russian classicism. Some of them simply unequivocally rejected everything new: genres, themes, and especially the new understanding of the principle of feeling which sentimentalism advanced. Sumarokov adhered to this position to the end of his life, as did Maykov; nor was Novikov as author of satires inclined to make any concessions to the new trends. But others thought it possible to absorb certain elements of 80 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
THE EIGHTEENTH CENTURY: I73O-9O "foreign" literary programs, to assimilate them, to subordinate them to the esthetic system they had already worked out for themselves. This position was adopted in the 1770s by Kheraskov, Bogdanovich, Ivan Khemnitser, and - at the end of the decade Derzhavin. This ability to assimilate and digest new ideas demonstrated the enormous vitality of Russian classicism, the extent of its powers and resources still in reserve. As preromantic tendencies penetrated the poetry of Russian classicism, there appeared as early as the 1770s a more definite interest than earlier in the national character, the national history, and folklore. At this time there emerged the first poetic attempts at reproducing historic events and folklore images. As far as contemporaries were concerned, the most remarkable poetic work of the 1770s was Mikhail Kheraskov's poem Rossiada (1779), which astounded them by the grandiosity of its conception and the resolve with which it was pursued. Before it appeared Russian poetry had not known an epic poem so monumental in its national and historical scope. Mikhail Kheraskov (1733-1807) took as his poem's subject the destruction of the Kazan Khanate by Ivan the Terrible in the sixteenth century, an event which contemporaries rightly perceived as the first step toward Russia's transformation into a powerful and independent state of the east European plain. The struggle between Russia and Kazan in Kheraskov's poem is the struggle between east and west, between Christianity and Islam. Moreover, in the poem Islam is presented not so much as a thing in itself as it is as a collection of all possible pagan superstitions and prejudices, as a creature of the forces of darkness and evil generally. These forces of evil assist the Kazanians in their struggle against the Russian forces, summoning first unbearable heat (seventh-ninth cantos) and then sudden winter frosts in the middle of summer (twelfth canto). Over against the enchantments, wizardry and demonic forces aiding Kazan there are counterposed the Orthodox Russian troops, Christian saints and martyrs who conquer the evil powers of pagan Islam. Thus events in the poem develop as it were within two spheres: the human and the superhuman. But the forces of good and evil intervene quite directly in human affairs as well, assisting their favorites or suggesting that they take particular actions. Kheraskov followed Tasso's example 81 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
ILYA SERMAN in linking political decisions and military undertakings of the warring camps with the actions of "unearthly" forces. But what interested contemporaries most of all in Rossiada was neither religion nor politics. Kheraskov was the first Russian poet to offer extensive landscape descriptions in his work. Thus Kheraskov paints nocturnal landscapes before presenting the moon, quite an obligatory element in Young's or Ossian's night scenes. However, in his concept of "feeling" Kheraskov adheres, generally speaking, to classical positions, continuing to regard individual psychology as the sum of certain traits of character which can be rationalistically defined and comprehended. The influence of Kheraskov's poetic portraits on poetry of the late 1770s and early 1780s is particularly noticeable in Derzhavin's work. Ippolit Bogdanovich (1743-1803) became one of the most popular Russian poets in the final decades of the eighteenth century thanks to his long poem Dushenka (1783, first published in 1778 as Dushenka's Adventures). Using as his plot the story of Cupid and Psyche, one of the most poetic myths in classical Greek literature, Bogdanovich sensed the popular, folktale basis of the stylized ancient narration found in Apuleius and in La Fontaine's reworking of it, and therefore made an attempt, quite bold for his time, to insert some motifs from Russian folktales into his poem. Bogdanovich transferred the story of Dushenka, with its ancient origin, onto Russian soil; it took firm root there. This is not merely a matter of folktale motifs and personages: as Maykov had done before him, Bogdanovich boldly introduced everyday life into his poem. Thus, as Dushenka sets off on her journey to be wed, her servants bear after her, in addition to her "crystal bed," all the objects which a noblewoman of that period would require: Sixteen men, placing them on cushions, Bore along the Empress's embroidery and bobbins, Which the Empress-mother had herself placed there, Toilet articles for the journey, combs and pins, And all sorts of other items of necessity. All these scattered details of everyday Russian gentry surroundings link the poem with life to some degree. What happens within it ceases to be a folktale; the abstract personages of idylls and 82 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
THE EIGHTEENTH CENTURY: I73O-9O eclogues give way to Dushenka's captivatingly human image. Bogdanovich succeeded in breathing life into the conventional figure of La Fontaine's Psyche by presenting her as a living, modern girl from a gentry family of the middling sort. By her naturalness of behavior and liveliness of character Dushenka surpassed everything created in Russian literature before Zhukovsky's "Svetlana" and Pushkin's Ruslan and Lyudmila. In his poem Bogdanovich adopts a characteristically ironic attitude toward his subject, toward the events he describes. He does not cease to be ironic even when his heroine is in peril or finds herself in difficult situations. The smile always on his lips as he recounts Dushenka's joys and sorrows, his jocular attitude, all create in the reader's mind a special "literary" image of the author, who becomes a character within the work: indeed that image may replace the real figure of the poet in the consciousness of later generations of readers. In Dushenka the poet Bogdanovich presented himself as the bard of the beautiful and the harmonious, but he did not endow the image of the poet (his own image) with any particular specificity or a historical perspective. The author of Dushenka lives solely in the world of beauty and poetry. Bogdanovich's poem was one of the fullest embodiments of Russian classicism's aspirations at the "esthetic" stage of its development. The best-known playwrights of the Sumarokov school - Yakov Knyazhnin (1742-93) and Nikolay Nikolev (1758-1815) - made certain essential changes in the artistic structure of the tragedy and endowed it with a directly social resonance which had been missing earlier. If Knyazhnin in Vladimir and Yaropolk of 1772 had worked out the problem of honor entirely in the spirit of early Sumarokovian tragedy, then in Rosslav (1783) he broke with his mentor's approach and took as the basic source of dramatic conflict the idea of the common good embodied within patriotic forms. That conscious civic patriotism which the "great soul" of the chief hero of Knyazhnin's tragedy exhibits is contrasted not only to various sorts of egotism and selfishness as embodied in Khristiern and Kedar, but even to such wholly positive heroes as Lyubomir, the Russian ambassador to Sweden, and the Russian prince who is prepared to sacrifice the territory he has taken from the Swedes in order to save Rosslav. Rosslav's firmness in all the trials to which
83 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
ILYA SERMAN
fate subjects him may be explained by the special concept of honor by which he is guided. His notion of honor is quite different from that which inspired the heroes of Sumarokov's tragedies: as Rosslav sees it, patriotism consists of unconditional and absolute dedication to the fatherland, that is Russia as the fatherland, and not to a prince or to the authorities. The philosophy of heroism which permeates Knyazhnin's entire tragedy is not founded on any well-defined historical conception, as in Sumarokov, but rather on an emotional and psychological image of the Russian citizen-patriot. As a consequence, the Russian political system which Rosslav represents so brilliantly is depicted rather fuzzily in the tragedy. It is indicated that Russia has already cast off the Mongol yoke, but no more precise definitions than that are given. The basic content of the dispute which continues for the entire course of the tragedy between Rosslav and all the other characters, whether positive or negative, is an emotional and psychological conception of the essence of the national character. Rosslav wishes to die for his fatherland and thus demonstrate his right to be called a citizen of Russia. The other characters in the play - for various reasons and from different points of view seek to deflect him from his intention. Consequently the dispute is always over the same thing, although the negative heroes (the tyrant Khristiern and the traitor Kedar) fail to comprehend Rosslav's aspirations, while the positive heroes understand them but think one need not always be so morally rigid. The tragedy's transformation from an internal to an external dispute, the displacement of interest in the hero's self-analysis by the depiction of a struggle which occurs outside him, led to a revision of the tragic style. Dialogue among characters was transformed into a dialogue between the hero and the audience over the heads of those to whom the hero seemed to be speaking directly. Knyazhnin's eighth and last tragedy, Vadim of Novgorod (Vadim Novgorodsky, 1789), had a peculiar history. Knyazhnin took as his subject a rather vague legendary account - but quite a popular one in the eighteenth century - about a ninth-century conflict between the Scandinavian Prince Rurik and the Novgorodians under the leadership of Vadim, who fought in defense of his city's ancient liberties. In Knyazhnin's tragedy Rurik overcomes Vadim because the people are weary of the anarchy into which the aristocrats have 84 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
THE EIGHTEENTH CENTURY: I73O-9O plunged free Novgorod, and opt for peace and order under a tsar's firm authority. In view of the political tension which gripped Russia after the outbreak of the French revolution, Knyazhnin declined to have Vadim of Novgorod staged. It was first published only in 1793, after his death. However, terrified by the Jacobin dictatorship in France, Catherine regarded Knyazhnin's play as quite dangerous, and so the entire edition was destroyed ("burned at the executioner's hand"). It was reprinted only in 1871. Nikolev also sought methods of reviving tragedy, but they did not coincide with the ones Knyazhnin adopted. Instead of Rosslav the heroic patriot, Nikolev depicted contemporary man as the victim of spiritual division. Nikolev is interested in the philosophical and political content of the conflicts of his day; he felt under no obligation to seek any historical explanation for them, and was satisfied with the same sort of communication with his audience and the same sort of system of declarative aphorisms with which we are familiar from Knyazhnin's plays. Gavriil Derzhavin (1743-1816), the major Russian poet of the eighteenth century, began to follow the basic lines of poetic currents of his day only toward the end of the 1770s: it took him more than fifteen years to discover his own personal poetic approach. During the years when his younger contemporaries were publishing book after book, occupying prominent places on the Russian Parnassus, and being rewarded with detailed and approving estimates in Novikov's Preliminary Historical Dictionary of Russian Writers (Opyt istoricheskogo slovarya rossiyskikh pisateley,
1772), the first survey of Russian literature, Derzhavin had to be content with a rather dubious description of him as the author of satirical poems directed against the Guards regiments. Derzhavin did not absorb the theory and practice of Russian poetry through personal study with an older poet or recognized teacher; rather he had to make his own way among the complexities of contemporary literary currents, to test his powers in various genres and approaches, imitating Lomonosov at some times, at others Sumarokov. He sought answers to the questions which concerned him in the writings of Lomonosov and Trediakovsky which were available to him as well as in the works of popular classical theoreticians of the eighteenth century. Derzhavin's attitude toward the published works of contempo-
85 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
ILYA SERMAN
rary Russian poetry was molded by his theoretically developed view of poetry as a collection of exemplary works in all genres. The beginning poet needed only to study these models diligently and then imitate them. The careful study of various exemplary works in the lesser genres did not prevent Derzhavin at the same time from writing odes and epistles in which he willy-nilly followed Lomonosov's lead, without concealing his dependence on the "Russian Pindar." But despite all his stubborn attempts to grasp its secret, Derzhavin never mastered the Lomonosovian "high style." On occasion Derzhavin seemed to feel that essentially there was no secret to it at all, and that one could write an ode in the high style even without using its Lomonosovian form. At the end of the 1770s Derzhavin found himself as a poet, and selected another path in poetry, not the one Lomonosov had blazed. His new poet friends Nikolay Lvov, Vasily Kapnist, and Ivan Khemnitser contributed considerably to Derzhavin's poetic self-definition. They kept up with all the latest happenings in European literary and artistic life, and were brimful of the most daring literary enterprises. After Sumarokov, Khemnitser (1745-84) was the most prominent fable-writer in Russian literature of the 1770s: he published his first collection of fables in the same year of 1779 which marked the beginning of Derzhavin's own independent literary career. Fables and Tales by N.N. (Basni i skazki N.N.), as Khemnitser entitled his collection, was innovative within the confines of the genre. In their fables Sumarokov and his followers mocked particular cases of the violation of rational and moral norms. The characters in Sumarokov's fables are sinful and stupid, although the laws which govern the world are rational and correct. In Sumarokov's world humor stems from a collision of the ridiculous, irrational and unnatural with the ideal of the rational and correct which exists in the writer's consciousness. The world of Khemnitser's fables is quite different, with different interrelationships between ideas and things. Khemnitser does not attack particular cases of stupidity and unreason, but rather the general absurdity of things and the impropriety of life's structure overall. Khemnitser's fables are not so humorous as Sumarokov's, since their satirical targets are mostly widespread human traits,
86 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
THE EIGHTEENTH CENTURY: I73O-9O shortcomings and habits common to all peoples and to all humanity. Consequently, Khemnitser's plots are a great deal less russified, and their social aspects less specific. His characters are often "rich men" and "poor men," without any clearer definition of their social origins. The satirical aim of Khemnitser's fables is to expose the absurdities of human society as a whole from the viewpoint of the progressive philosophical thought of the age. He seeks to point out to his readers their "delusions" and errors, to put across the truth in place of false conceptions of life: this is the task which Khemnitser as fable-writer sets himself, and to which he subordinates both the thematics and the stylistics of his works. Khemnitser has no interest either in individualizing the speech of his characters or in endowing them with any sort of individual characteristics. All his characters speak one and the same fully literary language. The authorial text in Khemnitser's fables stylistically is quite similar to the speeches of his characters. It is just that the author is better informed than his heroes, a good deal is obvious to him about which his characters cannot even guess. Khemnitser very scrupulously avoids humorous incongruities and unnatural combinations of human and animal traits. The animals in the world of his fables in all their actions do not go beyond general human limitations, and indeed there is very little of the animal in them. In the late 1770s Derzhavin destroyed the solemn ode's taboo on the personal and the biographical. He appears in his odes addressed to tsars not only as a poet, a singer of grandeur and beauty, but also as a person, as a government bureaucrat, a family man, a victim of the persecutions of high officials who dislike him, a fighter for truth and justice both social and individual. As Derzhavin sees it, poetry has a double countenance. The poet "sings" "spiritual praises to the Creator" and "sings of" "good [...] tsars," i.e. acts just as Lomonosov and all the other odewriters who followed in his footsteps had acted: he praises Catherine just as Lomonosov had praised Elizabeth. After developing his own stylistic approach at the end of the 1770s, Derzhavin constructed his religious and philosophical odes on quite different bases than had Lomonosov. He found no inspiration in the vast horizons offered by natural science in the eighteenth century which Lomonosov had helped to create. The 87 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
ILYA SERMAN basic question for which Derzhavin sought answers under the guidance of his religious convictions was that of man's fate in the universe and the degree to which it was predetermined. In his ode of 1779 "On the death of Prince Meshchersky" ("Na smert knyazya Meshcherskogo") - ordinarily considered by Russian critics his finest poetic work - Derzhavin meditates on the relationship between time and eternity, on the irreversibility of time's flow and the dependence of individual existence upon it. Although Derzhavin was not a Mason, he included in this ode several motifs from Night Thoughts by Young, an author much esteemed by the'Russian Masons of the Novikov circle. By means of this ode Derzhavin initiated a new theme in Russian poetry, becoming the teacher and forebear of Zhukovsky and Tyutchev. In his ode "God" ("Bog," 1784) Derzhavin gave a poetic depiction of the idea of the Great Chain of Being, one common to all of religious and philosophical thought in the eighteenth century. Derzhavin believes that man as an individual, that man in general outside his historical and social context, is spiritually capable of overcoming his physical insignificance and drawing near to the Godhead, or even possibly coming to resemble the Divinity. In these odes Derzhavin's poetic intuition took him beyond the limits of dogmatic Orthodox theology, but the criticisms of the theologians had no effect upon their enthusiastic reception by readers, either during the poet's lifetime or afterwards. The poet as Derzhavin conceives of him expresses the living feeling of the nation - the "echo of the Russian people," as Pushkin would put it later - but he speaks not only in the name of the people or the nation but in his own name as well. The world of the exalted as it were diminished to create space in Derzhavin's work for the poet's private life, for his personal and professional relationships. Thus in Derzhavin's poetry we find, on an equal footing with the traditional ideal of moral stoicism and dedication to virtue, the Horatian and epicurean ideal of the golden mean and of moderation in one's demands upon fate; in short, all the atmosphere of personal life with its domestic joys and consolations. Of course "domestic," "everyday" themes could not expel the grand themes of citizenship, politics and the state from Derzhavin's poetry: they developed in his writing in complicated ways,
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
THE EIGHTEENTH CENTURY: I73O-9O now prevailing, now retreating to peripheral verse of an incidental character. The prevalence of personal motifs over general political and moral ones, observable in Derzhavin's poetry between the 1770s and the 1780s, beginning in the early 1780s and down to the mid 1790s yields to a new predominance of the solemn ode and the themes of historic events and political questions associated with it. After the mid 1790s personal and domestic subjects again come to the fore in Derzhavin's poetry: they are reflected in a particular collection, the Anacreontic Songs (Anakreonticheskie pesni) of 1804,
although Derzhavin still considers it his definite duty to react to the course of contemporary political and military events. Derzhavin received governmental recognition - i.e. Catherine's personal favor - upon the publication of his "Ode to Felitsa" ("Oda Felitse," 1782), which was dedicated to the Empress. In this ode Derzhavin violated all the canons of the genre by having* Felitsa - or Catherine - behave like an ordinary mortal: she walks "on foot," eats, reads, writes, treats people nicely, and enjoys jokes. The significance of the Empress's simplicity and businesslike behavior is emphasized by the contrast between the modesty of this great states woman who cares only for the "happiness of humankind," and the emptyheaded, egotistical behavior of her high aristocrats, their feasts and entertainments and the luxury of their dress, as well as by the contrast between the most ordinary amusements of the common people (boxing matches) and woodwind music, the most refined fancies of musical art in the eighteenth century. However, despite the variety of aristocratic tastes, all the "murzas" (high officials) in "Felitsa" lack any serious civic interests and ideas: even those lines in which Derzhavin speaks of Potyomkin's political plans are ironic and present them more as the amusements of an idle mind than the thought of a statesman. Against the background of Felitsa's modest way of life and businesslike activity, the idealized image of the Empress which Derzhavin creates is strengthened even further by an account of her everyday cares, which encompass the entire gamut of statesmanship, all the nation's needs. As Derzhavin depicts her, Felitsa does not demand civic heroism of her subjects, or any stoic negation of one's personal interests. The Derzhavinian formula "be a human being on the throne" in "Felitsa" turns out to mean
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
ILYA SERMAN
that Catherine should condescend to human weaknesses and shortcomings and not be a rigorous moralist. The boundary between a "hero" in Lomonosov's poetic vocabulary, between a great man as bearer of the idea of enlightened absolutism and an ordinary mortal or common man, ceases to be eternal and unchangeable in Derzhavin. It vanishes because Derzhavin demands of the tsar, the ruler and lord, that before all else he recognize the legitimacy of not only the nation's interests as a whole, but of each individual in particular (what we would now call human rights). Since he shared what was then a widespread faith in the Empress's talents and abilities, Derzhavin tried to show that her purely human traits provided the base for Catherine's positive qualities as a ruler. His Felitsa copes so successfully with her governmental obligations because she is herself a human being and comprehends every human necessity and weakness. It was precisely Derzhavin who created the poetic legend of Catherine, a legend which sustained itself in the Russian cultural consciousness for nearly a century. In "Felitsa" and other odes linked to it ("The Murza's vision" ["Videnie murzy"], "To Reshemysl" ["Reshemyslu"]) Derzhavin discovered a new vantage point from which to view the high aristocrats around the Empress. Its novelty consisted of a combination of abstracting people and events (the fairytale world of the east) and concretizing the immediacy of hints and details of the everyday world. Contemporaries had no difficulty in recognizing which individuals the poet was writing about. Derzhavin's odes on the high nobility incorporated a system of hints and allegories brilliantly developed by Russian journalism of 1769-72, and especially in Novikov's journals. In Derzhavin's long odes such as "The Image of Felitsa" ("Izobrazhenie Felitsy," 580 lines), "The Waterfall" ("Vodopad," 444 lines), "On the Capture of Izmail" ("Na vzyatie Izmaila," 380 lines), or "On Perfidy" ("Na kovarstvo," 320 lines), one can clearly perceive Derzhavin's break with the Lomonosovian idea of the high style: Derzhavin defined his stylistic principle as one of "equal choice of words." In "Felitsa" and the cycle of odes connected with it Derzhavin allocated a definite but rather strictly defined place to the low or colloquial style. The poet who is supposed to be 90 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
THE EIGHTEENTH CENTURY: I73O-9O
the narrator in "Felitsa" is a "murza" who uses words and expressions which until then could have been encountered only in humorous poetry or in such genres as the fable and the heroiccomic poem. And yet the system of "three styles" (high, medium, and low) which Lomonosov had created and which had become the basic stylistic rule of Russian classicism is still intact in Derzhavin, even within the bounds of a single genre. The hierarchical ranking of poetic subjects - from high to low, from God to worm - remains unquestioned even in Derzhavin. Only the poet's approach to reality has changed. The further Derzhavin's art develops, the more esthetic considerations determine both his choice of subjects and his stylistic treatment of them. With Derzhavin's poetry Russian classicism enters the highest phase of its development - the point at which esthetic principles become decisive, whereas earlier everything had been subordinate to politics and ethics. In his odes of the 1780s and 1790s Derzhavin evaluated people and events from a viewpoint which seemed to him to express the general opinion of the nation: among the leaders of Russian society he sought those dedicated to duty and enthusiasts for the "common good." After the mid 1790s Derzhavin withdrew more and more into the poetry of personal life. He became increasingly terrified at the gap between his ethical ideals and contemporary political battles.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
3
THE TRANSITION TO THE MODERN AGE: SENTIMENTALISM AND PREROMANTICISM, 1790-1820 From 1790 to 1820 the Russian Empire underwent tumultuous years beginning with the immediate aftermath of the French revolution, continuing through the rise of Napoleon and the Napoleonic wars which saw the French invasion of Russia in 1812 and the allied occupation of Paris, and ending with the intellectual ferment of the movement which would culminate in the abortive Decembrist uprising of 1825. No great fraction of the nation's energies at this time could be directed toward literature. In literary terms this period begins with a work which faithfully reflects the political tensions of the time of the French revolution Radish«hev's Journey from St. Petersburg to Moscow - and ends with a
narrative poem, Pushkin's Ruslan and Lyudmila, which expresses well the romantic sensibility then on the verge of a short-lived cultural triumph. In the intervening thirty years, a culturally chaotic period, a major alteration occurred in literature's approach to the world. As Arthur Lovejoy has so aptly put it, during the years of neoclassicism and the Enlightenment intellectuals looked to a single standard, "conceived as universal, uncomplicated, immutable, uniform for every rational being." But then a "momentous" shift in outlook occurred, and was completed by the time of the romantic period, "when it came to be believed not only that in many, or in all, phases of human life there are diverse excellences, but that diversity itself is of the essence of excellence." In short, the change in emphasis was from a unitary human standard to a belief in diversity for its own sake. Where the classical mind had excluded individual experience and personal emotion from literature, writers of the sentimental era made a fetish of individual sensibility; where the classical eye had seen only events important to society as a whole, the sentimental author tended to concentrate on personal idiosyncrasies and even individual aberrations. The individual rather than society came to be at the center of
92 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
TRANSITION TO THE MODERN AGE: I 7 9 O - 1 8 2 O literary perception: if in the classical period in the standard conflict between love and duty the latter must prevail, in the sentimentalist epoch love must win through if the entire conflict were not reduced to meaninglessness or shown to have been illusory in the first place. Thus, though Derzhavin was firmly grounded in the neoclassical tradition, his poetry of the turn of the nineteenth century required extensive notes for its comprehension, for he wrote of very personal experiences of which others could not be expected to know except by being told. Amid such change there were also constants. One of them was the primacy of poetry: the reigning poetic genres altered, as the ode faded from view to be replaced by such shorter and less specific genres as the elegy, but poetry maintained its positions fairly well against the competition of prose, and would continue to do so until the end of the romantic period. A second constant was the linkage between writers and the state. Karamzin, for example, after a brilliant early career as poet and prosewriter, was appointed official historiographer, a position which enabled him to produce his classic History of the Russian State and also provided him access to the sovereign as an advisor. In the early part of the century Derzhavin was appointed Minister of Justice for a time; later on, during the Napoleonic invasion, Alexander Shishkov turned from his literary and linguistic activities to compose patriotic manifestoes to rally the Russian people against the invader. Zhukovsky was close to the royal family as tutor and advisor. Even Radishchev, jailed as a radical at the beginning of this period, was released after Paul I came to the throne and later for a while held a position of some governmental responsibility. Along with this, however, there appeared signs of political disaffection among writers, a disaffection which would bear fruit in the succeeding romantic period. A phenomenon peculiarly characteristic of this period was the existence of extensive formal and informal literary circles, which sprang from Russian writers' sense that they were engaged in a common cultural enterprise. The most prominent such circle was the "Colloquy of Lovers of the Russian Word," which met at Derzhavin's home under Shishkov's leadership for some years. It was countered by the "Arzamas" literary society, which, though very informal, included many writers whose names are now writ large in the history of Russian literature. Authors were well acquainted personally with one another; they engaged in polemics which helped them to sharpen their own intellectual positions; they could be reasonably certain that whatever they wrote would have a resonance in cultured Russian society, even though that society was not very extensive. These personal contacts were important in preparing the ground for the flowering of nineteenth-century Russian literature which would begin with the work of Alexander Pushkin.
93 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
MARK ALTSHULLER IN THE MIDDLE of the eighteenth century, approximately, new literary trends began to contest the place of classicism. This literary movement which had once been so powerful and influential began to abandon its former positions not only within writers' artistic consciousness, but also in the minds of readers. It was natural that literary trends should arise in opposition to classicism, trends which viewed life in a different way in a country in which drama had never surrendered to the classical system and in which the traditions of the novel, a genre which classical theoreticians rejected, had long been well developed: in England, in the land of Shakespeare and Marlowe, of Ben Jonson and Smollett. English literature nurtured a concept of personality quite alien to the one predominant under classicism. Classicism viewed man not so much as a personality, but as the bearer of a particular idea or feeling; it regarded the individual as a molecule within a particular hierarchically constructed social system (a hero in a tragedy, a gentle shepherd in an idyll, a military commander or ruler in the ode, and so forth). The pioneer in the new depiction of man was Samuel Richardson, whose famous epistolary novels Pamela, or Virtue Rewarded (1740) and Clarissa, or The History of a Young Lady (1747-8) offered detailed depictions of the inner worlds of their heroes, ordinary people concerned with romantic experiences. Laurence Sterne published two interconnected novels - The Life and Opinions of Tristram Shandy, Gentleman (1760-7) and A Sentimental Journey Through France and Italy (1768) - in which he undertook a painstaking investigation of the slightest spiritual experiences, feelings and sensations of his characters. He brought his analysis to perfection. Sterne's second book indeed bestowed its name upon an entire literary movement: sentimentalism. Needless to say, in actuality the formation of sentimentalism was quite complex, and involved many works of world literature, including such masterpieces as Rousseau's Nouvelle Heloise (1761) and Goethe's Die Leiden desjungen Werthers (1774).
In the literature of sentimentalism man is viewed and depicted as an individual, as an independent personality of value in and of itself (and not acting under the influence of duty or its surroundings), defining its own fate and behavior (thus Sterne's heroes pay little
94 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
TRANSITION TO THE MODERN AGE: I79O-182O attention to the rules of society but live according to their whims, their moods, attending to their various hobbies). Such an individual often turns out to be lonely and feeble in the threatening world around him: the reverse side of the coin of constant attention to man's inner life is man's fear of the world about him. A sense of horror at the thought of inevitable destruction, a feeling that the world was doomed, and fear of death were embodied very adequately in Edward Young's The Complaint, or Night Thoughts on Life, Death, and Immortality (1742-5). Gloomy depictions of the harsh northern landscape with its mists, rain and storms as well as melancholy descriptions of bloody battles, death and despair are to be found in the well-known Poems of Ossian (1762) by James Macpherson. The Poems of Ossian reflected a heightened interest in all national cultures (and not just in ancient Greek and Roman culture, as under classicism) which was characteristic of romanticism's early stages. For the romantics the culture of each nation within the context of other world cultures was just as particular and individual as was each human personality. As a consequence the romantics were consistently interested in the folklore and the history of their own people and also in the art of all other peoples and tribes, including primitive and undeveloped ones. If sentimentalism treated the peaceful and slightly idyllic existence of the individual, preromanticism is generally seen as dealing with the exploration of man's tragic sense of the world. Thus preromanticism finds its expression in the description of death, natural catastrophes and other such things. Naturally enough, these two currents often intertwine in the work of a single author and coalesce with each other. These developments in European literary life which we havejust described so briefly and schematically began to have an impact on Russian cultural life toward the end of the eighteenth century. Richardson's novels were translated into Russian in 1790, and Sterne was translated at the same time. Young's Complaint was widely read as early as the 1780s, at which time there also appeared the first complete translation of that book done by Alexey Kutuzov, Radishchev's friend and a well-known Freemason. The Russian reader had become familiar with Ossian's works by the very end of the 1780s and the early 1790s, and in 1792 there
95 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
MARK ALTSHULLER
appeared a complete two-volume prose translation of Ossian from the French. The translator was the talented poet Ermil Kostrov, who followed the latest literary trends very closely. The publication of his translation was a literary event at the time, and all later interpreters of Ossian drew upon it, including the young Alexander Pushkin. We should also note that many Russian readers (writers and poets among them) became acquainted with contemporary preromantic literature in the original language - although not many people knew English in Russia at that point - and in French translation. Thus it is not surprising that preromantic and sentimentalist trends had acquired considerable resonance in Russian literature by the end of the 1780s and the 1790s. An outstanding figure in the development of Russian sentimentalism and preromanticism as well as the history of Russian literature as a whole was N. M. Karamzin. Nikolay Karamzin (1766-1826) was born on his father's estate in the Simbirsk province on the middle Volga. He received a modest education at home before entering Professor Johann Schaden's boarding school in Moscow in 1778-81, where courses were given on the university level. During the last year of his studies Karamzin attended lectures at the university. Upon completing his boarding school course he was a well educated young man, with a knowledge of French and German. Being in no position to continue his education, Karamzin was compelled to enter military service with a Guards regiment, although his military service was not very lengthy and was interrupted by frequent leaves. In 1783, upon his father's death, Karamzin left military service and returned to Simbirsk, where he began to write in the free time remaining to him after an active social life of balls and cardplaying. The eighteen-year-old Karamzin was strongly influenced at the time by a meeting with Ivan P. Turgenev, a prominent Freemason and director of Moscow University, who encouraged the talented young man to dedicate himself to serious intellectual work and received him at the "Golden Crown" masonic lodge. In 1785 Karamzin moved to Moscow and joined the Friendly Literary Society, headed by the famous Freemason and promoter of Enlightenment ideals Nikolay Novikov. At this point Karamzin
96 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
TRANSITION TO THE MODERN AGE: I 7 9 O - 1 8 2 O began a serious literary career, translating Gessner, Haller, Shakespeare, and Lessing, editing the journal Reading for Children along with his friend Alexander Petrov, corresponding with Lavater, and in 1789 setting out on an extensive trip abroad. His journey was apparently undertaken with the approval of his masonic friends, for they drew up a plan for it and may well have supplied him with a certain amount of money, even though Karamzin's masonic interests were never very profound and he parted company with them after his return. Karamzin traveled through Germany, Switzerland, France and England for fourteen months. Upon his return to Russia he published an account of his journey under the title Letters of a Russian Traveler (Pisma russkogo puteshestvennika, 1792), a book
which immediately made his reputation. The epistolary form provided a framework for his spiritual effusions and a detailed analysis of his inner world, even though that form was fictional, for he wrote no letters to his friends and probably compiled the book upon his return to Moscow on the basis of brief travel notes no longer extant. The writer was clearly under Sterne's influence, for he never missed an opportunity to emphasize his links to his great predecessor: for example, in the first letter he bewails his separation from his beloved friends in the best sentimentalist style, and in the 130th he hastens to visit those places where Yorick had stayed. However, as a matter of fact Karamzin does not imitate Sterne so much as derive his orientation from another type of travel literature, that which communicated new information to the reader and stimulated him to political and historical ruminations, like Charles Dupaty's Lettres sur I'ltalie en 1785, Voltaire's Lettres philosophiques, or Jean Jacques Barthelemy's Voyage du jeune Anacharsis en Grece. The young traveler - he is not yet twenty-four visits famous scholars and thinkers, including Johann Kasper Lavater and Christophe Martin Wieland, wanders about Paris during the days of the French revolution (it is even possible that he knew Robespierre at the time), praises the British political system, and provides sharp, interesting, vivid and entertaining descriptions of everything he sees. In the Letters one can already detect that moderately liberal to conservative political position of Karamzin's which with some further development formed the basis for the philosophical and historical conception underlying his History of
97 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
MARK ALTSHULLER the Russian State (Istoriya gosudarstva rossiyskogo). Karamzin always
opposed despotism and tyranny of whatever origin, whether they stemmed from a monarch or from the rebellious people. An established legal system, he felt, was always preferable to anarchy or sudden political shifts. Letters of a Russian Traveler appeared in the Moscow Journal
(Moskovsky zhurnal), which Karamzin began to publish immediately upon his return from abroad and which came out in 1791-2. It was quite a successful publication, with 300 subscribers, more than any other such publication enjoyed in the eighteenth century. The fact that it was reprinted in 1801-2 is another indication of its popularity. On the pages of Moscow Journal also appeared some of the short stories which brought Karamzin fame as a Russian writer. The most important among them was "Poor Liza" ("Bednaya Liza," 1792). Liza, a peasant girl, lost her father when she was very young. She falls in love with Erast, a handsome young aristocrat, who loves her tenderly in return. However, once Liza has given herself to her beloved the passion for a young peasant cools down within the inconstant young man. When she discovers her beloved has been unfaithful to her, Liza drowns herself in a pond near the Simonov Monastery. Afterwards Erast repents bitterly of his behavior and can find no solace for the rest of his life. Karamzin offers a skillful depiction of the genesis and development of feeling within the lovers' souls, of the young girl's sufferings and her mother's blindness. Readers were captivated by the expressively romantic depictions of nature and by the endearing tenderness of the heroes' emotions transmitted through a sentimental vocabulary which up until that point had been little used either in life or in literature. As Karamzin sees it, love places people on an equal footing: he wrote the famous formula "even peasant women are capable of loving" in the course of describing the grief of Liza's mother at her husband's death. The author sympathizes immensely with Liza, who falls in love to such a degree as to surrender her honor, but he understands Erast as well, seeing him as a good person but also inconstant and not very serious. The tale ends with a reconciling resolution: in Heaven Liza and Erast are no doubt joined once again.
98 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
TRANSITION TO THE MODERN AGE: I 7 9 O - 1 8 2 O At this time Karamzin is much concerned with the depiction of romantic experience and the inner life of women. Indeed he directs his writing toward his female readers. It is precisely women who, in his view, having finally begun to read and speak Russian rather than French, should help writers to create a Russian literary language, a subject on which Karamzin expounded in his article "Why is there so little writing talent in Russia?" ("Otchego v Rossii malo avtorskikh talantov?"). The short story "Julia" (1796), a high society variant of "Poor Liza," was no less successful with readers. The beautiful Julia (her name was intended to remind readers of Rousseau's Nouvelle Heloise) falls in love with the intelligent, honest and good young Aris, but then the brilliant Prince N. appears and steals her affections. Unlike her predecessor, the peasant girl Liza, as well as the heroine of Rousseau's novel, Julia does not yield to the blandishments of her brilliant suitor and preserves her chastity. The Prince, lacking Erast's goodness, sincerity, and weakness, abandons the intransigent beauty, who returns to Aris and marries him. A short time later, however, she again becomes infatuated with Prince N. On discovering this Aris departs, leaving Julia to retire to the country to bring up her son and lead a lonely, virtuous life. A few years later Aris returns to her, and they find happiness together. In both tales the reader was attracted by the depiction of the heroes' inner life and by the presentation of ordinary people who aroused sympathy by their very ordinariness and their excusable weaknesses, a characteristic of the sentimentalist movement as a whole. Karamzin demonstrates once again that he recognizes no social inequalities: all people are equal, and equally interesting. Along with sentimental short stories Karamzin also produced typically preromantic tales, in the tradition of the "Gothic novel" of Ann Radcliffe, Matthew Lewis, Charles Maturin and others. The best of them is the famous "Island of Bornholm" ("Ostrov Borngolm," 1793), in which we find all the attributes of preromanticism: a gloomy island lost in the North Sea; an ancient castle; a beautiful young woman confined in a dungeon for an unknown crime (probably incest); and a plot line which suddenly breaks off, although it is not difficult for the reader to imagine how the story might end. All this makes the "Island of Bornholm" a masterpiece of Russian preromantic literature.
99 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
MARK ALTSHULLER
Karamzin also experimented with historical tales. "Natalya the Boyar's Daughter" ("Natalya, boyarskaya doch," 1792) transports the reader to the times of Tsar Alexey Mikhailovich. Natalya, daughter of an aristocratic boyar named Matvey, falls in love with a young stranger who turns out to be the son of a boyar currently in disfavor. The two escape to a forest retreat until they finally return to her father's roof after a victorious battle against the Lithuanians in which Natalya, disguised as a man, and her husband have both participated. Except for the names, there is nothing historical in the tale. A Russian boyar of the seventeenth century kisses a girl's hand, falls seriously ill and nearly perishes of love, sketches landscapes while his young wife does embroidery: in short acts exactly like a sentimental hero of the late eighteenth century. Still, this story bears witness to that interest in Russian history which a few years later would lead Karamzin to become a professional historian. In 1792 Novikov was arrested and the Freemasons suppressed. By that time Karamzin had not only parted company with the Masons, but had also quarrelled with Novikov, whom he never liked. But that did not prevent him, with that profound decency which always characterized him, from publicly defending the victims of such persecution. In the Moscow Journal he published an ode entitled "To forgiveness" ("K milosti"), in which it is not difficult to detect a defense of the Freemasons then the object of governmental repression: Karamzin maintains that governmental stability is assured by the preservation of the rights of the people as a whole and of each individual in particular. The concepts of the Rousseauian "social contract" emerged here with unexpected force and emphasis. No doubt Karamzin realized that the general intellectual situation in Russia in the 1790s was not conducive to the development of journalism and literature, so he gradually reoriented his publishing activities. Despite its popularity, the Moscow Journal ceased to appear in 1792. In 1794-5 Karamzin brought out two issues of a literary almanac, Aglaya, whose pages were filled primarily with his own works. Here Karamzin published a sketch in the form of letters ("Melodor to Filalet" and "Filalet to Melodor") describing the tragic bankruptcy of the ideology of the Enlightenment: the flower 100 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
TRANSITION TO THE MODERN AGE: I79O-182O of Enlightenment ideas has been destroyed in the "blood and flame" of the French revolution. To the melancholy present Karamzin counterposes merely an idyllic dream of the past, as he does in the sketch "Athenian life" ("Afinskaya zhizn") describing a typical day in ancient Athens in the manner of the young Anaharsis in Barthelemy's novel. The author describes Plato instructing his disciples, attends a performance of Sophocles's Oedipus, and goes to an evening feast, or symposium. It should be noted, though, that even this ancient Greek idyll is done in melancholy tints. Emperor Paul I was assassinated on 1 March 1801. After his death and the beginning of liberalization under Alexander I, Karamzin intensified his literary activity. He started publishing the Herald of Europe (Vestnik Evropy), which soon became the
finest periodical of its day. Here he printed the historical short story "Martha the Mayoress" ("Marfa Posadnitsa," 1803), an incomparably better work than its predecessor "Natalya the Boyar's Daughter." "Martha the Mayoress" deals with the conquest of the Republic of Novgorod by Grand Duke Ivan III. In this tale Karamzin's view of history emerges in full panoply. He obviously sympathizes with the Novgorodians in their struggle for liberty, and he sketches the portrait of the heroic republican leader Martha with understanding and affection. Martha organizes the defense of her native state, summons her compatriots to the love of liberty, appoints the young Miroslav commander-in-chief, giving him her daughter Xenia to wife, and herself meets death on the scaffold courageously after the Novgorodians have been defeated and subjected to the power of the autocrat of all the Russias. At the same time, however, Karamzin regards Ivan Ill's victory as historically justified and necessary for Russia's growth. Every nation has its own historical destiny. A republican system or a constitutional monarchy is appropriate for very small states like Switzerland or relatively small countries like England, but in France, say, the overthrow of the legal monarch led to senseless bloodshed. For Russia the monarchy is the most suitable form of state organization. Ivan makes an appearance at the place of execution where Martha gave her life and promises the Novgorodians order, justice and security. At first the people remain silent, but IOI Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
MARK ALTSHULLER after an interval they cry: "Glory to the Russian tsar!" as they bid farewell to their liberties and accept a new form of governance. Before much longer Karamzin abandoned literature altogether. By order of Alexander I, on 31 October 1803 he was appointed court historian at a modest salary of 2,000 rubles per year. Residing in Moscow, working in the archives, studying the chronicles, he became entirely absorbed in writing his history of Russia. Still, his scholarly commitments did not keep him from following current events attentively, and paying special attention to the rather rapid transformations which the young tsar had already effected or was preparing to effect: Alexander wished to alter the bureaucratic system, introduce constitutional limitations on the monarchy, and abolish serfdom. In view of the tragic course of the French revolution, Karamzin considered such radical transformations at the least premature and inappropriate to the established state structure. In 1811 Karamzin addressed to the tsar a "Memoir on Ancient and Modern Russia" ("Zapiska o drevney i novoy Rossii"), one of the most remarkable political documents of the nineteenth century. The "Memoir" dealt with basic problems of Russian history and current affairs with such honesty that it was published only once in pre-revolutionary Russia (in 1914) and has never appeared in the Soviet Union. Karamzin's fundamental assumptions in the "Memoir" are consistently monarchist: he considers an enlightened monarchy the best form of government for Russia. Karamzin traces the genesis and development of the monarchy over the course of time, as the Russian state was gradually created. The people had peaceably given up their liberties and adored their rulers. In Karamzin's view any popular uprisings against the monarchy (the assassination of the False Dmitry, the Time of Troubles) were much more damaging to the state than the sins and deficiencies of rulers. But this does not justify rulers in anything they may wish to do, for they must meet, or seek to meet, the ideal of the enlightened monarch. With the scope and skill of a brilliant journalist Karamzin describes the cruelty and arbitrariness of Peter I as well as his hatred for his own people and his native culture, the sensuality and vice of Catherine II, and the extravagant behavior of Paul I. Then, taking up contemporary issues, Karamzin condemns the reforms which the present monarch has instituted or is considering introducing. He 102 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
TRANSITION TO THE MODERN AGE: I 7 9 O - 1 8 2 O opposes rapid and showy transformations. The sudden abolition of serfdom would be a greater evil than was its introduction in the first place, and limitations upon the monarchy would lead to a new Time of Troubles: "Any innovation in the structure of the state is an evil [. . .] time alone provides the necessary stability to the laws." Alexander I did not care for such fundamental criticism; it offended him. However, he managed to suppress his resentment, and personal relations between the historian and the tsar continued to be friendly until the latter's death. Along with many other factors, Karamzin's arguments played a role in the tsar's decision to abandon his reforms, and that in turn had a tragic impact on the entire subsequent course of Russian history even down to our day. In the meantime Karamzin continued with his major work, the History of the Russian State. When the first eight volumes appeared in 1818 in an unprecedented printing of 3,000 copies, they sold out in twenty-five days. Karamzin kept working on the History to the end of his life. When he died in 1826, the last words he had written for volume thirteen were: "Oreshek would not surrender..." Karamzin rendered his judgements on moral grounds, attempting to comprehend the inner motivations behind the behavior and actions of tsars. Thus he condemned the cruelty of Ivan the Terrible in words worthy of Tacitus. At the same time Karamzin adhered consistently to his conception of the state and the monarchy, and he relied honestly on his sources: half of each volume consists of references to the sources and extensive quotations therefrom. The History is written in beautiful and expressive Russian. Karamzin succeeded in overcoming the excessive emotionalism and sentimentality of his early works. The History, then, was a worthy culmination to the career of Nikolay Karamzin, reformer of the literary language, poet, prosewriter, journalist and historian, a man whose fiction is read to this day and whose historical contributions still retain their value. Karamzin gave rise to an entire pleiad of sentimentalist writers who imitated his themes, his plots and his language, overburdened with epithets, periphrases, detailed "sentimental" descriptions, and so forth. There was born a new genre of the sentimental tale, desciibing unhappy lovers, tragic deaths, the joys of country life, 103 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
MARK ALTSHULLER and so forth. Their titles speak for themselves: "Unhappy Maslov" ("Neschastny Maslov," 1793), by Alexander Klushin; "The Dark Grove, or A Monument to Tenderness" ("Temnaya roshcha, ili Pamyatnik nezhnosti," 1819), by Peter Shalikov; "A Russian Werther" ("Rossiysky Verter," 1801), by Mikhail Sushkov; "The Tale of Poor Marya" ("Istoriya bednoy Mari," 1805), by N. Milonov; "Poor Masha" ("Bednaya Masha," 1801), by Alexander Izmaylov; and the anonymous "Unhappy Liza" ("Neschastnaya Liza," 1810). Also, Karamzin's Letters of a Russian Traveler engendered an entire literature of sentimental travelogues, whose authors generally did not even go beyond Russia's borders and who busied themselves not so much with recalling places they had visited as with exaggeratedly detailed descriptions of their own experiences and impressions. Such works include "My Journey, or the Adventures of a Single Day" ("Moe' puteshestvie, ili Priklyuchenie odnogo dnya," 1803), by Nikolay Brusilov; "A Journey to Little Russia" ("Puteshestvie v Malorossiyu," 1804) and "Another Journey to Little Russia" ("Drugoe puteshestvie v Malorossiyu," 1817) by Peter Shalikov; "Journey to the South of Russia" ("Puteshestvie v poludennuyu Rossiyu," 1800-2) by Vladimir Izmaylov; and others. The work of Alexander Radishchev (1749-1802), who wrote independently of Karamzin and a little earlier than he, belongs to another category of sentimentalism. Radishchev knew European literature at least as well as Karamzin, perhaps even better. Born in 1749, he studied initially at the St. Petersburg School for Pages, then at the University of Leipzig in 1766-71, where Catherine sent him along with twelve other students to obtain a legal education. Upon his return he worked in the Senate, then was a military procurator, and finally found employment at the St. Petersburg custom house, whose director he became in 1790. Radishchev began his literary career with stylized "letters" and "diaries." It is likely that his "Diary of a week" ("Dnevnik odnoy nedeli"), a sentimental account of a separation from friends done in a Sternian mode, dates from the 1770s. The language of this brief work is a strange amalgam of sentimental, archaic Church Slavic with civic-journalistic vocabulary. This stylistic approach (with a considerable buttressing of archaisms) remained characteristic of 104 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
TRANSITION TO THE MODERN AGE: I 7 9 O - 1 8 2 O Radishchev's writing, setting him clearly apart from the Karamzinian school. In 1782 Radishchev wrote a "Letter to a friend resident in Tobolsk" ("Pismo drugu, zhitelstvuyushchemu v Tobolske") describing the unveiling of the famous "Bronze Horseman," the monument to Peter I, and thoughts on the power of the monarch, who never abandons his authority voluntarily. Afterwards Radishchev composed the "Life of Fyodor Vasilevich Ushakov" ("Zhitie Fedora Vasilevicha Ushakova," published in 1789). With typical stylistic insensitivity, Radishchev inappropriately selected the word zhitie, ordinarily employed only for saints' lives, for a biography of his friend and fellow student at Leipzig University. Ushakov was no doubt a capable and talented young man, but he was no saint, since he died while still a student as a consequence of excessive sexual indulgence. The "Life" is filled with journalistic essays drawing upon the relationships between the students and their instructor, about the nature of state power, the links between the tsar and his subjects, etc. As Radishchev sees it, the absence of specific legislation to define (as in Rousseau's "social contract") the rights and duties of social groupings leads to rebellion and destruction, and ordinarily rulers who have exceeded their powers are to blame for this. In the course of the 1780s Radishchev worked over his principal book, A Journey from St. Petersburg to Moscow (Puteshestvie iz Peter-
burga v Moskvu). The title, the basic plot line, and even the style (description of the experiences and feelings of the author-narrator) were suggested to Radishchev by Sterne's Sentimental Journey. However, in the realm of ideas and content Radishchev most emphatically parted company with his predecessor. Radishchev wrote his book slowly and with great difficulty: he was not only devoid of any great artistic gift, but also had a feeble grasp of the rules of composition. He was obviously incapable of writing an extensive work, and so his book divides into various fragments, episodes, inserted verses, sketches, and meditations. The Journey consists of chapters bearing the names of towns and posting stations located between St. Petersburg and Moscow: Sofia, Lyubani, Torzhok, Tver, and others. These place names mark the author-traveler's progress between one capital and the other, but have no connection with the content of the sketches, 105 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
MARK ALTSHULLER
each of which stands by itself, is dedicated to a particular social problem and, as a rule, consists of facts and authorial commentary combined with a detailed analysis of the traveler's feelings and experiences. The major topics to which Radishchev dedicates his descriptions and essays are state power, the situation of the serfs, governmental reform, and literary problems. Radishchev is extremely critical of state authority. In the chapter "Spasskaya Polest" he depicts a ruler blinded by his own magnificence and theflatteryof those around him. The ruler issues orders which are not carried out; his top officials deceive him while his unhappy subjects live in poverty and are unjustly persecuted. However, the author, raised as he is in the spirit of Enlightenment philosophy and enlightened absolutism, immediately offers a cure. The Holy Wanderer Pryamovzora (i.e. Truth) removes the cataracts from the tsar's eyes, and deceit is vanquished. Thus, from the author's point of view, if the tsar will seek truth, then proper order can be established within the state. In this depiction of the tsar it is not difficult to detect traits of Catherine II, and in her courtiers certain outstanding high officials, including the famous Count Grigory Potyomkin. The depiction of the tsar was as far as Radishchev could go in exposing iniquity, but he also depicts local officials who abuse their authority: for example the governor who spends official funds on the purchase and delivery of oysters in "Spasskaya Polest," the officer who does not care about saving those who are perishing in "Chudovo," corrupt judges in "Spasskaya Polest," and others. It should be added that in eighteenth-century Russia such criticism was not at all unusual. Novikov had engaged in open polemics with Catherine in his Drone in 1769, and in 1783 Denis Fonvizin had exasperated the Empress with sharply probing questions on the pages of her very own journal Collocutor of Lovers of the Russian Word (Sobesednik lyubiteley rossiyskogo slova).
Radishchev paid particular attention to describing the difficult situation of the serfs. A peasant might have to labor six days a week on the land of a cruel landowner. In order to keep himself and his family alive he would work for himself at night and on Sundays ("Sofia"). A cruel and libertine serfowner deprives his peasants of all their property, demands the right of first night for himself, and is ultimately assassinated by his peasants ("Zay106 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
TRANSITION TO THE MODERN AGE: I 7 9 O - 1 8 2 O tsevo"). An intelligent young peasant who has received a good education but has subsequently been humiliated by his young masters is overjoyed at being dispatched as an army recruit ("Gorodnya"). A poor peasant woman lives in a hut with no chimney, eats bread made of chaff, and has never tasted sugar in her life ("Peshki"). But let us again note that there was nothing unusual in this condemnation of the cruelty and monstrosity of the system of serfdom in eighteenth-century literature. Fonvizin had written about all this in The Minor, Novikov in his satirical journals, Krylov in his Spirit Post (Pochta dukhou).
However, unlike his immediate predecessors and contemporaries, Radishchev pays a great deal of attention to the likely consequences of cruel exploitation. He speaks directly to cruel serfowners, threatening them with the wrath of the peasantry ("Lyubani," "Peshki") and predicting a rebellion during which the slaves will smash their masters' heads with their chains ("Gorodnya"). And from Radishchev's point of view they would be justified in so doing, since cruel slavery violates the law, the peasant is not entitled to legal protection ("he is dead to the law"), and therefore has the right to violate a law which protects only the masters. On this basis Radishchev welcomed the American revolution which liberated the country from its subjection to the British crown, and was prepared to justify Cromwell, who, by executing Charles I, affirmed the right of vengeance for a people deprived of liberty (the ode "Liberty" included in the chapter "Tver"). From all this it does not follow, though, that Radishchev considered a popular revolution the best possible resolution of political problems. It could occur only as a result of illegitimate and excessively cruel exploitation. Thus Radishchev makes various proposals for the improvement of the existing system. First of all, a ruler must know the truth ("Spasskaya Polest"), for then his governance will be useful and will make his subjects happy; in "Vydropusk" he proposes abolishing the system of Court ranks on the grounds that courtiers are parasites, and it is wrong to equate their servile accomplishments with genuine service to the fatherland. Unnecessary luxury merely offends the ordinary people in our enlightened and rational age. In this age of reason, when the fatherland is flourishing (a 107 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
MARK ALTSHULLER
compliment to Catherine on Radishchev's part), it is shameful to keep one's countrymen in the chains of bondage ("Khotilov"). Serfdom is harmful to the state from all points of view: it is dangerous (i.e. it may lead to political rebellion), it sets a bad moral example, and it hinders economic progress, since only free men work diligently. All these shortcomings afflict Russia, and a serf uprising may destroy her, as nearly happened during the Pugachov rebellion of 1773-4. So Radishchev urgently summons his compatriots to liberate "our brothers from the bonds of slavery," to undertake a selflessly humanitarian act: embrace the former serfs and "love one another sincerely." At the conclusion of the chapter Radishchev elaborates a gradual plan for the complete abolition of serfdom. Literary questions, dealt with in "Tver," are kept somewhat separate from the social and political problems predominant in the Journey. In "Tver" Radishchev argues primarily that various different meters besides the customary iambs (spondees, dactyls, hexameters) should be used in poetic texts, and that poetic rhyme is not at all necessary: its constant usage is merely the result of blind imitation of French models. The most interesting aspect of Radishchev's literary theories had to do with the notion of "difficult" verse, that is, poetic lines full of consonants, difficult to pronounce, rough and cacophonic. As Radishchev saw it, poetry ought to be "stiff and difficult to pronounce" if its poetic aims so required, as, for example, in his ode "Liberty," which depicts the difficult transition from slavery to freedom; or if the complex thought contained in the verse demands careful, slow reading and complicated, slow deciphering ("The eighteenth century" ["Osmnadtsatoe stoletie"], "Ode to my friend" ["Oda drugu moemu"]). In such cases harmony must be subordinated to the expressiveness of the verse. Later on, in the last portion of his life, Radishchev developed his ideas on the hexameter as a complex and expressive meter in a treatise on Vasily Trediakovsky entitled "Monument to the dactylo-trochaic champion" ("Pamyatnik daktilo-khoreicheskomu vityazyu," 1801). Nikolay Gnedich's translation of the Iliad done in the 1810s and 1820s, still the best rendering in Russian, was produced under the influence of Trediakovsky's experiments and Radishchev's theories. 108 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
TRANSITION TO THE MODERN AGE: I 7 9 O - 1 8 2 O Radishchev's ideas had a certain influence later on in the campaign of the so-called "archaists" against the Karamzinists: Radishchev's language, replete with archaisms, provided an excellent model for the struggle against the high-society frivolity of the Karamzin school's language. Literary men of the 1800s and 1810s were much more interested in Radishchev's literary views than they were in his political ideas, so that, paradoxically, his followers turned out to be political conservatives, the early Slavophiles and members of the "Colloquy of Lovers of the Russian Word." When Catherine II came to power she issued several liberal ukases, one of which permitted citizens to establish "free printing presses" for the publication of anything their owners wished under only nominal censorship. In 1789 Radishchev established just such a printing press in his home, and there, in 1790, he printed his Journey from St. Petersburg to Moscow in 650 copies, an ordinary
press-run for that time. As we have seen, the book did not contain any especially subversive ideas, except for some clumsy remarks about the cruelties of peasant rebellions and the execution of the English king and even these could easily have been regarded as mere lack of political tact. But this journalistic treatise on social and political questions came out at precisely the wrong time. Catherine was getting along in years, and as a result was becoming ever less tolerant and ever more persuaded of her own infallibility. Since she had usurped the throne in 1762, she feared her own son Paul, the legitimate heir to the throne. But the Empress was frightened most of all by events in France, where the revolution had broken out, a Constituent Assembly had been formed, and Louis XVI had abdicated his throne. All this caused the Empress to keep very close track of public opinion in Russia. Upon a careful reading of Radishchev's book Catherine found it exceedingly dangerous, discovering in it "dissemination of the French infection," a call to rebellion and threats to rulers: she termed the author a "rebel worse than Pugachov." At Catherine's order Radishchev was arrested, tried, and condemned to death. But the Empress, as was her custom, lightened the sentence considerably and ordered the writer to be sent to Siberia for ten years. Thanks to the assistance of his superior and consistent protector Alexander Vorontsov, Radishchev arrived safely at the distant 109 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
MARK ALTSHULLER Siberian town of Ilimsk, where he purchased a home and lived with his family until the Empress died in 1796. The new Emperor Paul I, who had released Novikov from jail, permitted Radishchev to return from Siberia as well and settle on his ancestral estate at Nemtsovo near Moscow. Here Radishchev devoted the years of Paul's reign to literary endeavor. He wrote the beginning of a comic poem in the folk tradition entitled "Bova," several other poems, the beginning of a narrative poem entitled "Songs performed at competitions in honor of the ancient Slavic divinities" ("Pesni, petye na sostyazaniyakh v chest drevnim slavyanskim bozhestvam"), the treatise on Trediakovsky mentioned above, and so forth. When Alexander I came to the throne in 1801, Radishchev was not only permitted to return to St. Petersburg, he was even invited to participate in the work of a Commission on the Laws. But imprisonment and exile had deepened the melancholy pessimism so characteristic of Radishchev in any case. As Alexander Pushkin tells it, the chairman of the Commission made some half-jocular reference to Radishchev's past political sins. The sensitive Radishchev was frightened by this, returned home, and took his own life. The date was 12 September 1802. In addition to prose, Russian sentimentalist writers also produced poetic works. Karamzin and Radishchev, Shalikov and Izmaylov and many others wrote poetry. Karamzin was a superlative poet: his poetry isfilledwith profound meditations and often attains formal perfection. It also analyzes subtle facets of human emotions, which is quite characteristic of sentimentalism. Other sentimentalist poets of the time include Mikhail Muravyov (17571807), Vasily Kapnist (1738-1823), Nikolay Lvov (1751-1803), and Yury Neledinsky-Meletsky (1752-1818). One of the most outstanding Russian sentimentalist poets was Ivan Dmitriev (1760-1837). A high government official (Minister of Justice), Dmitriev was a close friend of Karamzin's and a convinced adherent of Karamzin's poetic practice: thus he called his collection of verse of 1795 My Trifles Too (I moi bezdelki) in a demonstrative echo of Karamzin's My Trifles (Moi bezdelki, 1794). In his writing Dmitriev broke with the traditions of classicism. In his famous satirical poem "What others say" ("Chuzhoy tolk," 1794), he mounted a witty attack on the solemn ode, the most 110 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
TRANSITION TO THE MODERN AGE: I 7 9 O - 1 8 2 O important classical genre. He also reformed the classical fable. Instead of an undeviatingly didactic narration in a coarsely popular tone, Dmitriev created an elegant miniature done in the style of La Fontaine and written in light, refined language (later on Krylov would return to the traditions of the classical fable). Dmitriev's sentimentalism emerges most clearly in his songs, many of which have become popular songs since. Dmitriev's songs are ordinarily melancholy romantic effusions in which he speaks of the happiness of life with his beloved, of the sorrows of parting, and so forth: "Without my loving friend I wander o'er the meadows..." ("Bez druga i bez miloy brozhu ya po lugam..."), "The consolations of love are measured in minutes..." ("Lyubovny uteshenya minutami letyat..."), "Friends, time is so short..." ("Drugi, vremya skorotechno..."), etc. Dmitriev's best-known song was "The grey dove moans" ("Stonet sizy golubochek," 1792). Russian writers in the eighteenth century were not very numerous; as a rule they felt isolated, as though they were eccentrics involved in strange occupations quite incomprehensible to those around them. They tried to assure their few readers, the public generally, and themselves that literary work was a pleasant, entertaining, interesting and useful enterprise: so many journals were given names in that spirit, such as Pleasant and Useful Pastime, or Pleasant, Interesting and Entertaining Reading.
By the end of the eighteenth century that situation had changed. Writers by then regarded themselves as representatives of public opinion which, in the course of its development, became subdivided into different currents. That led to ideological conflict, and to the necessity of bringing ideological allies together in small circles on the basis of linkages of family and friendship, and later on in official and semi-official literary societies (for example, in St. Petersburg in the late 1770s there was a circle which included four poets - Derzhavin, Lvov, Kapnist, and Khemnitser; the first three of them were married to three sisters, all great beauties of the day). In the early nineteenth century the director of the Public Library and the President of the Academy of Arts, Alexey Olenin, organized a brilliant literary salon at his home which was attended by Derzhavin, Batyushkov, Zhukovsky, Vyazemsky, and many III Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
MARK ALTSHULLER
others. The most faithful members of the circle, and those closest to Olenin, included Gnedich, Krylov and Batyushkov. The introduction of Masonic ideas in Russia and the founding of numerous Masonic lodges provided ready-made organizational structures for more formal literary associations. So when such talented young people as Andrey Turgenev, Andrey Kaysarov, Alexey Merzlyakov, Alexander Voeykov, and Zhukovsky decided to meet for discussion of literary and social questions, they organized a "Friendly Literary Society" with a President, records of meetings, an archive, and so forth. Despite that the Society, which came into being in January 1801, had disintegrated by November. The "Free Society of Lovers of Literature, Science and Art" existed for a considerably longer period, from 1801 to 1825 with some interruptions. It brought together primarily lesser known writers not of gentry origin: Ivan Born, Ivan Pnin, Vasily Popugaev, Alexander Vostokov, Nikolay Radishchev (Alexander Radishchev's son), and others. This society, which took up a middle position in the disputes between the Karamzinists and their opponents, the archaists, had no serious role in the history of Russian literature. Still, one should mention two members of the society, poets who played a certain part in the development of Russian preromanticism: Semyon Bobrov (1763-1810), author of overweighty and tense philosophical odes and gloomily romantic nature descriptions; and Gavriil Kamenev (1771-1803), author of what might be considered the first Russian romantic ballad, "Gromval" (1802). One of the Society's most important and influential members was Alexander Vostokov, not only a gifted poet but also an outstanding scholarly philologist, author of the classic Essay in Russian Versification (Opyt 0 russkom stikhoslozhenii, 1812). He did
a great deal for the development of Russian versification, expanding its metrical potential by the use of classical meters and folk rhythms. The major literary grouping of the early nineteenth century was the "Colloquy of Lovers of the Russian Word" (Beseda lyubiteley russkogo slova, 1811-16), which had begun to meet unofficially as early as 1807. In March of 1811 the "Colloquy" inaugurated its regular monthly meetings in a beautiful and luxuriously appointed 112 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
TRANSITION TO THE MODERN AGE: I 7 9 O - 1 8 2 O hall in Derzhavin's large home on the banks of the Fontanka in St. Petersburg. As many as 500 people - in a word, nearly all of educated St. Petersburg - might attend the meetings. The Society published its own journal, Readings at the Colloquy of Lovers of the Russian Word (Chteniya v Besede lyubiteley russkogo slova), which
printed for the most part materials presented at the meetings. Nineteen issues of the publication appeared. The Colloquy was controlled by conservatively inclined literary men opposed to Alexander I's liberal reforms. In literary matters the members of the Colloquy were against the Karamzinists. They looked to the Church Slavic language, folklore and national cultural traditions in an effort to create a cultural and historical Utopia rooted in the past. Interest in national history and culture and in popular folklore is quite typical of romanticism, which began to appear at the turn of the century and sooner or later permeated all the Western literatures: Herder, Brentano and the Brothers Grimm in Germany, Ossian and Walter Scott in England, James Fenimore Cooper in the United States, and so forth. In this sense the activities of the Colloquy may be linked to the early history of Russian romanticism. The Colloquy of Lovers of the Russian Word was organized by Admiral Alexander Shishkov (1754-1841). He began his literary career as a poet: in his poem "Old and new" ("Staroe i novoe vremya," 1784) he contrasted an idealized pre-Petrine past with the present state of affairs in Russia. His book of 1803 Essay on the Old and New Styles of the Russian Language (Rassuzhdenie 0 starom i
novom sloge rossiyskogo yazyka) sparked a great controversy, since in it Shishkov criticized the mannered style of sentimentalist Karamzinian prose. Shishkov argued that literature should take its direction from Church Slavic, which he termed the "root and foundation of the Russian language." Displaying the concern with medieval national history so characteristic of the romantics, he also composed an enormous commentary on the Igor Tale and produced a translation of the text which was rife with archaisms and Church Slavic elements. In an "Address upon the inauguration of the Colloquy" ("Rech pri otkrytii 'Besedy'," 1811) Shishkov emphasized the importance of ancient church books and folklore for the development of the 113 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
MARK ALTSHULLER
national culture, contrasting these helpful sources with malignant western influences. Shishkov developed these ideas in two more specialized works of the same year. One was a brochure entitled "On the eloquence of the Scriptures" ("O krasnorechii Svyashchennogo pisaniya"), in which he sought to demonstrate his favorite argument: that Church Slavic and Russian are one and the same language, and that familiarity with church books was a prerequisite for literary creativity in Russian. In his second book, Conversations on Literature (Razgovory o slovesnosti), Shishkov for
the first time painstakingly worked out a poetics of Russian folklore. In short order Shishkov received the opportunity to address his linguistic and literary ideas to as large an audience as any writer could ever hope for. In 1812 he was appointed State Secretary to Alexander I, and given the task of drafting all the official manifestoes, orders and rescripts issued during the war of 1812—13. Shishkov used these documents to elaborate his ideological and political program: he rejected the ideas of the Enlightenment and the French revolution, affirmed the principles of monarchism and Russian Orthodoxy (which he considered an integral part of Russian nationality from time immemorial), praised Russia's historic past, and so forth. In his manifestoes Shishkov employed solemn, lofty, and ponderously archaic language of the sort to which the Russians had long been accustomed from the liturgy and the Holy Scriptures. These manifestoes were very popular among the common people: as they listened to them people "wept and gnashed their teeth." After the war they were published in a separate book, and contemporaries - including Shishkov's literary opponents - recognized their indisputable positive qualities. After the war, having aroused the Emperor's displeasure by his conservatism and his consistent defense of serfdom, Shishkov withdrew from government service and at his own request was appointed president of the Russian Academy. Later on, from 1826 to 1828, after Alexander's death, he served as Minister of Education. He died at an advanced age. Another founder of the Colloquy was Gavriil Derzhavin; Derzhavin retired in 1803 and dedicated himself wholly to literature. In Derzhavin's work of thefinalperiod (1803-16) one can easily detect 114
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
TRANSITION TO THE MODERN AGE: I 7 9 O - 1 8 2 O Shishkov's influence: Derzhavin wrote more frequently on Biblical subjects, and in a complicated and archaic style. Shishkov and Derzhavin were quite close politically, for Derzhavin was also a consistent monarchist and foe of all liberal reforms. It is not surprising that the Colloquy should have ceased to exist after Derzhavin's death. The Colloquy opposed sentimental poetry with its interest in the trivialities of the inner lives of private individuals, holding that literature was a serious social matter. Consequently its adherents gave their primary attention to lofty and serious genres which had pretensions to influencing public opinion. The Colloquy was particularly interested in the heroic poem, a genre which, though well developed in the classical period, had become totally obsolete and considerably transformed in the romantic period, when the best example of the heroic poem was thought to be, not Virgil's Aeneid, composed according to all the rules, but Homer's Iliad, viewed as a spontaneous expression of Greek national culture and character. Homer newly interpreted in this sense could serve as a model for the creation of Russian national heroic works as well. At the beginning of the nineteenth century there was no Iliad in Russian. The best translation extant, by Ermil Kostrov - done in six-foot iambic lines with paired rhymes, called Alexandrines broke off at the ninth canto and was never completed. In 1807 the young poet Nikolay Gnedich (1784-1833) set out to translate the Iliad. At first he used Alexandrines to complete Kostrov's translation but later on, taking Trediakovsky's efforts and Radishchev's theories into account, he shifted to Russian hexameter (dactylotrochaic meter), which from that time to the present has been the Russian poetic equivalent of the ancient hexameter and the instrument for the embodiment of ancient culture in the Russian tongue. Gnedich worked at his translation for more than twenty years, completing it only in 1829. His version is still one of the finest renderings of Homer not only in Russian, but in any modern European language. The members of the Colloquy (Gnedich did not formally belong, but he worked closely with it) were interested in Gnedich's efforts at creating a "Russian Homer," and sympathized with them. The young poet's translations were discussed enthu115
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
MARK ALTSHULLER
siastically at its meetings; there were polemics over Homeric metrics, and the Readings brought out a portion of the hexametric translation of the Iliad in its first publication. However, even the most superlative translation of Homer could not take the place of a heroic epic created on a national foundation as the romantics understood it. Sergey Shirinsky-Shikhmatov (1783-1837), one of Shishkov's most dedicated disciples, accepted that task. He sought to extend the lofty, solemn style of the Lomonosovian ode to all literary genres, making consistent use of archaisms and Church Slavicisms, expelling foreign words from the literary language, and making syntactic constructions ever more complex. In 1807, in compliance with his principles, Shirinsky-Shikhmatov wrote a narrative poem entitled Pozharsky, Minin, Germogen, or Russia Saved (Pozharsky, Minin, Germogen, Hi spasennaya Rossiya)
which depicts the Time of Troubles and the heroic efforts of Russia's best people to save their country from ruin. The author, however, has little interest in narrating the events of that time, as the classical narrative poem usually did. Instead ShirinskyShikhmatov's extensive work is an agitated monologue describing the author's own feelings and emotional experiences in connection with these great and dramatic events. The genre distinctions so obligatory under the classical system vanish here: the ode coalesces with the narrative poem to form a lyrical monologue more typical of the romantic narrative poem than anything else. These same traits characterize Shikhmatov's second poem as well, his Lyric Oratorio Peter the Great (Liricheskoe pesnopenie Petr
Veliky, 1810): here again it is the lyric rather than the epic element which predominates in the ecstatic enthusiasm for Peter's accomplishments. Both poems are composed in expressive and energetic verse completely free of verbal rhymes. However, Shikhmatov's attempts at creating a new type of narrative poem on the basis of archaic language and a reformed classical esthetic system were doomed to failure, for the future belonged to the romantic poem of the Byronic type which Pushkin would create. Contemporaries wrote numerous epigrams criticizing his poems, and he himself was dubbed "verbless Shikhmatov." Within the Colloquy another classical genre was also developed
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
TRANSITION TO THE MODERN AGE: I 7 9 O - 1 8 2 O and modernized: the fable. We have already mentioned Ivan Dmitriev's reform of the fable along La Fontainean lines. The Colloquy sought to return the fable to its ancient sources, Aesop and Phaedrus, and to their successor Lessing. Thus Dmitry Khvostov (1757-1835) rejected the La Fontainean approach of vividly literary narration in favor of emphasizing the fable's allegorical qualities and traditionally primitive moralizing. For the sake of this allegorical quality he eliminated the most important element of classical poetics, verisimilitude, as understood within a strictly defined genre system. Khvostov created a strange world containing doves with teeth and donkeys with claws and heels, where carp shriek from pain and ravens have mouths and lips. Contemporaries did not understand what Khvostov was trying to do and mocked his efforts, so that he has gone down in the history of Russian literature as a comic and pitiful graphomaniac. The Russian fable reached its zenith at the hands of Ivan Krylov (1768-1844), whose literary achievements exceed the bounds of the Colloquy and also the chronological limits of the nineteenth century, and deserve especially careful consideration. The son of an impoverished army officer, after his father's death Krylov, at the age often, began working in an office in a provincial city. Though he lacked formal education, he taught himself languages (in his old age he even learned ancient Greek so that he could read Homer in the original); in general he was an educated man, well acquainted with Russian and European literatures. In 1782 Krylov made his way to St. Petersburg, where he wrote several dramatic pieces even as he continued his bureaucratic employment: these included the comic opera The Fortune Teller (Kofeynitsa) and the tragedies Cleopatra and Philomela. Distin-
guished as a young man by his boldness and independent judgment, Krylov used his comedies to mount sharp attacks upon contemporary mores, and that without stopping short at direct hints at particular individuals: for example in his comedy The Pranksters (Prokazniki) he made fun of the playwright Yakov Knyazhnin and his entire family. His comedies A Frenzied Family (Beshenaya semya) and A Writer in the Anteroom (Sochinitel v prikho-
zhey) contained sharp critiques of the morality of contemporary literary life. A quarrel with a theater director, who had at first 117 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
MARK ALTSHULLER
assisted the young writer, made it impossible for his plays to be staged. Krylov then turned to journalism, continuing on the one hand the Novikovian tradition of satirical journalism while on the other drawing upon the achievements of English satirical journalism (Addison and Steele) and French satirical epistolary novels (Montesquieu). In 1789 he published a monthly entitled Spirit Post in which spirits - undines, gnomes, sylphs, etc. - correspond with Malikulmulk the wizard, discuss philosophical problems, describe various everyday scenes, and laugh at people's weaknesses and failings (it has only recently been discovered that twenty-three out of forty-eight letters in the Spirit Post were translated from two novels by the Marquis Jean-Baptiste d'Argens, Lettres cabalistiques and Lettres juives). Thereafter Krylov and his friends in 1792 published the journal Spectator (Zritel), whose title was no doubt borrowed from Addison and Steele's English publication of the same name. In 1793 he published the journal St. Petersburg Mercury (Sankt-Petersburgsky Merkury).
All during these years Krylov worked within the traditions of late classicism and of eighteenth-century French philosophical prose connected with them. The tale "Kaib" (1792), describing the journey of a young eastern monarch traveling incognito, recalls Voltaire's so-called "eastern tales" - "The Princess of Babylon," "The White Bull" - and makes fun of pastoral idylls written in a sentimentalist spirit. In "Nights" ("Nochi," 1792), a narrative describing several of the hero's nocturnal adventures in a certain city, one can detect the influence of eighteenth-century French prose (Jean-Baptiste Louvet de Couvray, Antoine Prevost, Louis Sebastien Mercier). As we have already seen, advancing age and the French revolution impelled Catherine II to intensify governmental supervision of literature and to persecute Radishchev and Novikov. Krylov suffered certain difficulties as well. In 1792 his printing house was searched, and he himself was placed under police surveillance. In 1794 Krylov left St. Petersburg to wander about the country until 1804. During that time he wrote nothing at all except for a burlesque comedy entitled The Nibbler (Podshchipa), in which he attacked Paul I and German influence at court. Here one can discern that shift toward Russophile ideas which later brought him
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
TRANSITION TO THE MODERN AGE: I 7 9 O - 1 8 2 O to membership in the Colloquy. The comedy was of course not published, and circulated only in manuscript. After Alexander I's accession to the throne, Krylov returned to literature, coming back to St. Petersburg in 1806. His comedies of 1807 The Fashion Shop (Modnaya lavka) and A Lesson for Daughters
(Urok dochkam) (the latter falls somewhere between an imitation and an adaptation of Moliere's Les precieuses ridicules) won Krylov great notoriety, and had long runs in St. Petersburg and Moscow. His comedies attacked Gallomania and cosmopolitanism while praising Russian mores and the foundations of the national life. In 1806 Krylov began writing fables. In his first published fables he entered upon a literary competition with Dmitriev by selecting some of the same subjects that the latter had borrowed from La Fontaine: the proud oak uprooted by a storm and the reed which bends but survives; the old man who plants a tree and outlives some young people who laugh at his supposedly pointless efforts. Dmitriev's elegant and nationally neutral narration becomes a living picture under Krylov's pen, a picture of Russian life not merely with its local color but even with its social system and its national consciousness. Krylov's fables deal with broad philosophical and ideological problems as well as the most immediate details of social and political life. In the early part of the century Krylov was consistently reinforced in his conservative, monarchist, anti-western and antiEnlightenment views. From his viewpoint, the French revolution had demonstrated the destructive nature of Enlightenment ideas. The poet does not reject the Enlightenment altogether, as Rousseau did, but demonstrates that a dedication to the ideas of the Enlightenment leads to the moral corruption of particular individuals and of entire states, just as an evil smell of wine remains forever in a barrel which has been filled even once with it ("The barrel" ["Bochka"]). The fable "The writer and the bandit" ("Sochinitel i razboynik") describes a France which has perished thanks to the spread of Enlightenment doctrine and Voltairianism along with the ideas of the Encyclopedists. Krylov also opposed Alexander I's liberal reforms. In his fable "The lion's education" ("Vospitanie lva") he mocked the Emperor's French tutors who had trained the King of Beasts to "build nests," i.e. had alienated him from the needs and interests of his 119 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
MARK ALTSHULLER country by filling his head with worthless liberal ideas. Krylov also opposed the tsar's constitutional projects. In the fable "Horse and Rider" ("Kon i vsadnik") both characters perish because the Rider (the tsar) releases the reins and permits the Horse (the people) to gallop off wherever he wishes without caring where he is going. In "Leaves and Roots" ("Listy i korni") the Leaves fail to understand the Roots because they do not recognize their dependence upon the soil, the national sources of their being. It is understandable that a man of such anti-western, anti-liberal and Russophile views as Krylov should have become a pillar of the Colloquy and a regular participant in all its activities. He also joined the Olenin circle, which resembled the Colloquy in its political, cultural and ideological viewpoints. With Olenin's assistance Krylov obtained a post at the Public Library, where he remained, with regular promotions, until he retired with the rank of general. Krylov's fables are distinguished by their supreme artistic perfection. They contain astoundingly precise descriptions of the ordinary peasant's way of life along with witty characterizations of various human - but simultaneously Russian - types: the lazy miller, cardplayers, the hard worker, the braggart, the wastrel, and so on. Krylov's fables became incredibly popular within all classes of society, and especially among the common people. During the author's lifetime they appeared in eighteen editions; the pages of his books were read to shreds. In bringing the Russian fable to such perfection, Krylov exhausted all the genre's comparatively modest resources. Thereafter the fable ceased to claim a serious place in the history of Russian literature. Since they were drawn to social activism and sought to establish and expand their influence on public opinion by propagandizing their ideas extensively, the Colloquy naturally took a great interest in the theater. They promoted Krylov and his patriotic comedies A Lesson for Daughters and The Fashion Shop. Another member of the
Colloquy was the playwright Alexander Shakhovskoy (17771846), who as early as 1805 wrote a very successful play, A New Sterne (Novy Stern), in which he made viciously wicked fun of Karamzin and his followers. Still, the archaist circle was not the source of genuine innovation 120 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
TRANSITION TO THE MODERN AGE: 179O-182O
in the Russian theater. Vladislav Ozerov (1769-1816), the creator of the sentimental tragedy, did transform the Russian stage, and for a very short time became its leading figure. He first acquired fame through his Oedipus in Athens (Edip v Afinakh, 1804), a play
on a subject drawn from antiquity. In it Ozerov exalted the liberal and constitutional policies of the young Alexander I, through the image of the Athenian king Theseus. In the sympathetic depiction of Oedipus, who unintentionally kills his father, one might detect a certain moral justification of the tsar, who had been indirectly responsible for the murder of his father Paul I. The play's most important theme, however, is Antigone's love for her blinded father, and not any political allusions. This love makes up the play's central content, transforming it into a sentimental tragedy emphasizing the depiction of the most refined elements of the heroes' emotions. The play was magnificently produced with Olenin as designer; the classical local color was retained, and the details of everyday life in antiquity were preserved to the greatest possible extent. Ozerov's next play, Fingal (1805), based on Ossianic motifs, was no less successful. This time Scottish local color was depicted on the stage: the sets were steeped in the northern romanticism associated with the Scottish bard's songs; the play's monologues consisted of elegiac meditations on love and death while reproducing images of the gloomy natural settings of the north. The tragedy lacked action and genuine dramatic tension, but it did have a great many beautiful lines. These same shortcomings were observable in Ozerov's next tragedy, Dmitry Donskoy (1806). Here the playwright once again resorted to a political topic and direct political allusions; in the viewers' minds Alexander I's struggle against Napolean was the subtext of Dmitry Donskoy's contest with the Mongols. As in Oedipus, so in this tragedy the author supported the tsar's liberal projects for the limitation of the monarchy. At the same time Ozerov introduced a love theme: Dmitry Donskoy is in love with Princess Xenia, and the playwright complicates the struggle against the common enemy with a rivalry between princes. The public was ecstatic about the play, but it was Ozerov's last success. Ozerov's final play, and very possibly his best, was Polyxena (1808), which describes the ritual sacrifice of Hecuba's daughter 121 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
MARK ALTSHULLER
Polyxena at the grave of Achilles, who has been killed under the walls of Troy. Polyxena indeed desires her own death, for she hopes to be reunited with her beloved beyond the grave. Her passionate monologues contain some of Ozerov's finest poetry, but the public was completely indifferent to them. In the course of a few years the sentimental tragedy had reached its apogee and then embarked on its downward course. Ozerov's own fate was tragic. He was dismissed from his employment without the pension he should have received and fell into obvious disfavor. No matter what the reason for this may have been, the playwright suddenly found himself living in a distant village under very difficult financial circumstances. The failure of Polyxena completely shook his mental stability: Ozerov went insane, burned all his papers, and died after six years of mental illness. The archaists, Karamzin's enemies, bore a considerable responsibility for Ozerov's sudden failure as a playwright. Derzhavin, Shishkov and other future members of the Colloquy had done detailed and sharp critiques even of Oedipus, attacking the play's sentimental vocabulary and its liberal author's political views. Shishkov and his allies found Dmitry Donskoy especially unacceptable. The Shishkov circle produced a nasty parody of it entitled Mityukha Valdaysky (1810), and Derzhavin sneered at the tragedy's hero for being in love like some adolescent and at the Princess, who on the eve of the bloody battle goes visiting the tents of various princes to tell them all about her unhappy love. Shishkov was also indignant over these same historical inaccuracies in the play. Taking Ozerov's plays as a point of departure, Derzhavin tried to create his own historical plays, writing several on Russian topics: Pozharsky (1806), Vasily the Blind (Temny, 1808), Eupraxia
(1809). These plays were clumsy and overwrought, replete with excessively direct hints at contemporary reality, and so never saw the stage. But there was a certain logic to them, an undoubted expressiveness of their heavy, archaic language, and they exerted some influence on the development of the Russian theater. Thus Shakhovskoy clearly took Derzhavin as his guide in writing his tragedy Deborah (1809), done on a biblical topic but with contemporary allusions, as for instance to Napoleon's attempt at 122 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
TRANSITION TO THE MODERN AGE: I79O-182O marrying the Grand Duchess, the tsar's sister. The play was staged quite successfully. One must note, however, that the Russian tragedy on lofty political themes turned out on the whole to have no future. As we have seen, the Ozerovian tradition soon came to an end, and without any consequences to speak of; the Derzhavinian tradition had some influence on the play writing of the Decembrists (Fyodor Glinka, Paul Katenin, Wilhelm Kuchelbecker), but their plays were almost never staged. With considerable mediation the overall tradition did re-emerge in Pushkin's Boris Godunov. To some degree that play may be regarded as the apex of the tradition of political tragedy in Russian literature. By the early nineteenth century sentimentalism was on a downward trajectory. Its founder, Karamzin, abandoned literature. His overenthusiastic imitators, with the assistance of sharp and in many ways justified criticism from the Shishkovites, were gradually nudged to the periphery of literary life. A new generation of gifted, energetic and well educated writers arose to take their places. Since they were closely linked to Karamzin both personally and professionally, they blazed new trails in the history of Russian literature by developing their mentor's literary and linguistic ideas. These trails led to romanticism, which reached its apogee in the poems of Pushkin and Lermontov and Gogol's colorful, grotesque prose. But the poets of the first part of the century, treading their own paths, created works of very great esthetic value, so that it would be fair to term them early Russian romantics. First place among them belongs to Vasily Zhukovsky (17831852), whose romantic life constitutes an astonishing parallel to his poetic work. Zhukovsky is Russian literature's Petrarch, a man who remained hopelessly and forever in love with his Laura. Zhukovsky was the illegitimate son of a wealthy landowner named Bunin and a young Turkish woman, apparently from a pasha's harem, given to Bunin by a friend of his. He obtained his name from his godfather, a poor neighbor of Bunin's called Andrey Zhukhovsky. Zhukovsky's literary interests and talents developed quite early. As a youth he was already an educated man and a fine teacher, a tutor to his nieces Masha and Alexandra, daughters of his step-sister Catherine Protasova. Soon Masha, ten years his junior, and Zhukovsky fell in love. Masha, who had 123 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
MARK ALTSHULLER
grown up under Zhukovsky's care and guidance, was a gentle, tender girl with a poetic nature. Zhukovsky rightly saw in her the happiness of his entire life, but her mother set herself resolutely against a marriage on grounds of their blood relationship (although the church permitted marriages of this type). Protasova was a firm-willed woman of rare stubbornness, and all attempts to change her mind failed. Zhukovsky's religious and moral principles, as well as Masha's, would not permit them to go against her mother's will. In 1817, at her mother's insistence and with Zhukovsky's assent, Masha married a professor. In 1823 she died in the Estonian city of Tartu, then Dorpat. Zhukovsky cherished her memory as long as he lived. In the meantime Zhukovsky's literary and poetic fame was spreading. During the campaign of 1812 he composed a patriotic poem, "A bard in the camp of Russian warriors" ("Pevets vo stane russkikh voinov"), which every literate Russian soon knew by heart. In 1817 Zhukovsky was appointed Russian language tutor to the fiancee of the future tsar Nicholas I (she was German, as were most of the wives of Russian tsars). In 1823 he was appointed instructor to the heir to the throne, the future Alexander II. It was that pupil of Zhukovsky's who in 1861 abolished serfdom in Russia and introduced many other liberal reforms. A year after his retirement in 1840, Zhukovsky married the daughter of a German artist friend of his and settled in Germany for the remainder of his life. It was there he died in 1852, in Baden-Baden. Zhukovsky made his literary debut with a translation of Thomas Gray's famous poem "Elegy written in a country churchyard" (1751), published in 1802 in Karamzin's Herald of Europe. This poem brought Zhukovsky some little renown, and also in large measure determined the course of his subsequent literary development: Zhukovsky's poetry is almost invariably linked to western originals. The poet himself used to say: "Everything I have done is foreign or a propos of something foreign, and yet it is all still mine." Thus Zhukovsky's lyric poetry, despite its foreign sources, is vividly autobiographical in nature. It is usually melancholy and elegiac. At Zhukovsky's hands the individual word in Russian poetry for the first time becomes multivalent, and its shades of meaning often turn out to be more essential than its basic sense. The author 124 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
TRANSITION TO THE MODERN AGE: I79O-182O seeks to describe not so much his physical environment as the world of his feelings and experiences, his subjective sensations. Consequently the basic components of Zhukovsky's lyrics are meditations on the passing of youth, regrets over an unhappy love or the death of a beloved (Zhukovsky was especially fond of this topic), or melancholy appreciations of natural beauty: he usually describes the evening, mists, the moon, and so forth. By his pioneering experiments in thefieldof multivalency of the Russian poetic word, Zhukovsky paved the way for Russian symbolists such as Alexander Blok and Valery Bryusov, whose poetry dissolved the reality of everyday existence and summoned readers to the ideal worlds of Plato or of Vladimir Solovyov. Ballads - that is, narrative verse commonly of fantastic content and sunk in a gloomy fairytale atmosphere - occupied an important place in Zhukovsky's art. Almost all Zhukovsky's ballads and he wrote thirty-nine of them - are either translations or else, though more rarely, comprised of motifs taken from German and English ballads. Among the writers upon whom Zhukovsky drew were Schiller, Goethe, Gottfried Burger, Walter Scott, and Robert Southey. Zhukovsky became famous with his first translation of a German ballad, a rendering of Burger's "Lenore" which he titled "Lyudmila." This ballad describes a dead man who rises from the grave to claim his bride and carries her off to the cemetery, straight into the tomb. The Russian author significantly softened the sharp expressiveness of the original and a certain coarseness found in it: Lyudmila's melancholy plaints are not at all like Lenore's curses and blasphemies. Later on Zhukovsky used motifs from this same ballad of Burger's to assemble an entirely russified ballad entitled "Svetlana" (1812), which includes poetic descriptions of fortunetelling on the eve of Epiphany and other Russian customs. This ballad was one of his best literary creations. In other ballads Zhukovsky depicts the ancient world as the preromantics understood it ("Cassandra," "Triumph of the conquerors" ["Torzhestvo pobediteley"], "The Eleusinian festival" ["Elevzinsky prazdnik"], all taken from Friedrich Schiller) or the romantic Middle Ages (Walter Scott's "The Eve of St. John" ["Zamok Smalgolm, ili Ivanov vecher"], "A ballad showing how an old woman rode double on a black horse and who rode before 125 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
MARK ALTSHULLER
her" ["Ballada, v kotoroy opisyvaetsya, kak odna starushka ekhala na chernom kone vdvoem i kto sidel vperedi"] based on Southey's poem). Russian culture is deeply indebted to Zhukovsky as a translator. He translated Byron and Schiller, acquainted Russian readers with the Sanskrit epic by rendering the story of "Nala and Damayanti" from the Mahabharata, and put the charming prose tale "Undine" by Friedrich de la Motte-Fouque into elegant Russian hexameters. Zhukovsky also produced the finest extant Russian translation of Homer's Odyssey. The other major poet of the early nineteenth century was Zhukovsky's contemporary Konstantin Batyushkov (1787-1855). Though his health was always frail, he was a fearless soldier who participated in three military campaigns. Though a pessimist by nature, he wrote energetic satirical epistles in which he defamed the Karamzinists' literary enemies. Victim of a cruel heredity, in 1822 Batyushkov went insane and thereafter spent half his life in a condition of mental incompetence. He died of cholera in the provincial city of Vologda. The contradictions within Batyushkov's personality were reflected in his art. On the one hand there is the painful premonition of death with which the poet must deal against the background of a gloomy northern landscape. The ghost of a dead friend appears to him in the Ossianic setting of the North Sea ("Ghost of a friend" ["Ten druga"], 1814), or he meditates on bards and skalds long dead, on Ossian's heroes, in "On the ruins of a castle in Sweden" ("Na razvalinakh zamka v Shvetsii," 1813). Batyushkov also speaks of the horrors of war in his epistle "To Dashkov" ("Dashkovu," 1813), saying: "I have seen a sea of evil." At the same time, the poet describes the joys of a calm and peacefully sybaritic existence in an isolated cottage with a beloved woman, a glass of wine, and a stack of books by his favorite poets. That is the message of the famous "My Penates" ("Moi penaty," 1812), which had a great impact on Zhukovsky, Pushkin, Vyazemsky, and Denis Davydov. Anacreontic motifs are also quite important in Batyushkov's work. He makes no attempt at re-creating antiquity as it really was, as his friend Gnedich had sought to do in his translations of Homer. Batyushkov finds his antiquity not so much in original 126 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
TRANSITION TO THE MODERN AGE: I 7 9 O - 1 8 2 O Greek texts as in the verse of Evariste Parny, Jean-Baptiste Gresset, Giovanni Casti, French translations of the Greek Anthology, and so forth. The antiquity which Batyushkov depicts most conventionally in his love lyrics is a fragile, elegant world of conventional eroticism whose vivid colors temporarily banish tragic thoughts of the inevitable end; it is useless to hope that one's experiences of love will continue after death in Elysium ("Elysium," 1810). In one of his last and finest poems Batyushkov laments the beauty of the ancient world now vanished forever as he views the porphyry columns of an ancient city inundated by the sea, a city destined never to appear to men's eyes again ("You awake, oh Baia, from the tomb . . . " ["Ty probuzhdaeshsya, o Bayya, iz grobnitsy . . ."], 1819).
Batyushkov's poetry had a great and fruitful influence upon the subsequent development of the anthological trend in Russian poetry in the verse of Pushkin, Fet, Apollon Maykov, Nikolay Shcherbina, Leo Mey, and many others. Batyushkov's poetic language is remarkably melodic, flowing and euphonic; it is unique in Russian poetry. Possibly this is due to the influence of Italian poetry, of which Batyushkov was a connoisseur. Zhukovsky, we recall, extended the semantic boundaries of the poetic word by endowing it with numerous supplementary shades of meaning. Batyushkov, to the contrary, made the word astoundingly precise by bestowing upon it within the poetic context the only possible objectified clear and definite meaning. Possibly it is for that reason that Batyushkov is so drawn to painterly color epithets: purple grape, yellow hops, lilac hands, leaden waves, and so forth. If Zhukovsky is a predecessor of Russian symbolism, then Batyushkov might be considered a forerunner of the acmeists, who rejected symbolism's polysemantics and strove for the precision of the poetic word with a single meaning. It is indicative that Batyushkov was one of Osip Mandelshtam's favorite poets: Mandelshtam spoke of the "grapeflesh" of Batyushkov's verses. Prince Peter Vyazemsky (1792-1878), Zhukovsky's and Batyushkov's younger contemporary, belonged to the Karamzin entourage: he was the younger brother of Karamzin's second wife, and Karamzin treated him as though he were his own son. Vyazemsky reciprocated with respect and intense love. 127 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
MARK ALTSHULLER Vyazemsky had no great poetic gift, although his best poetry displays the casual quality of good conversation and offers vivid portrayals of Russian life. Such, for example, is the poem "First snow" ("Pervy sneg," 1819), which Pushkin liked immensely and which later engendered numerous echoes in Pushkin's own work. Vyazemsky made up for his lack of poetic expressiveness with his wit and aggressive temperament. He wrote political poetry in which he fought for the liberation of the serfs and attacked serfowners, bureaucrats and others: see his "Indignation" ("Negodovanie," 1820), "St. Petersburg" (1824), and "The Russian God" ("Russky Bog," 1828). Vyazemsky acquired special renown as a polemicist during the literary conflict which burst out between the Karamzinists and the archaists around 1815. He wrote malicious epigrams against the Shishkovites - including an entire "poetic bouquet" of them against Shakhovskoy - as well as parodies of Count Khvostov's fables and dashing epistles to his friends. His gift for polemics made Vyazemsky a leading literary critic of the 1820s. Although his critical pieces were not distinguished by either precision or intellectual profundity, he played a major role in formulating the theoretical foundations of Russian romanticism through his articles on Pushkin's poems The Prisoner of the Caucasus (1822), The Fountain of Bakhchisarai (1824), and The Gypsies (1827).
One should also mention Vyazemsky's contributions to the field of literary history: he was the author of a fine monograph on Fonvizin (1848) as well as articles on Ozerov (1817), Dmitriev (1821), Sumarokov (1830) and others. Denis Davydov (1784-1839) occupies a special niche in the glittering pleiad of early romantics: he was a spectacular soldier, a bully of a hussar, a participant in guerrilla warfare and a hero of 1812. That was the way he depicted himself in his verse and in his autobiography ("Some events from the life of Denis Vasilevich Davydov"); he designed his own life to fit his poetry. The hero in Davydov's verse occupies the military world of the bivouac. He uses his Hussar sword for a mirror, instead of sofas a bag of oats, instead of marble vases - glasses full of punch. He is always first to the table, first to raise his glass, with his pipe ever gripped between his teeth, but he is also first in bloody battle as well. Davydov remains a Hussar in his love poetry. He is consumed 128 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
TRANSITION TO THE MODERN AGE: I 7 9 O - 1 8 2 O by the impatience of passion, insists on immediate answers to his demands from his beloved, does not fear ambiguity and sometimes even a certain frivolity, and cures his disappointments in love by drink. Of course the correspondence between the writer and his poetic image could not have been complete. This was all a literary mask which the poet sought to wear in real life. But he provided an example - unique even for romantic poetry - of the combination of reality and literature. The appearance on the scene around 1815 of some gifted followers of Karamzin's caused literary debates to become much sharper. They began when Shakhovskoy derided Karamzin and his followers in the narrative poem Stolen Overcoats (Raskhishchennye shuby, 1811-5). And in 1815 he staged one of his best comedies, Lipetsk Spa (Lipetskie vody). This play contains an episodic character, the poet Fialkin, who was a maliciously witty caricature of Zhukovsky. Fialkin composes lengthy ballads on topics from medieval and ancient cultures in which contemporary theatergoers easily caught hints at Zhukovsky's ballads "Lyudmila" and "Achilles." That caused a scandal. Zhukovsky's friends Dmitry Dashkov, Dmitry Bludov and Vyazemsky came to the defense of the offended poet with polemical letters, sketches, epigrams, and even cantatas. Bludov wrote a satire entitled "A Vision at the inn at Arzamas, published by the society of scholars" ("Videnie v arzamasskom traktire, izdannoe obshchestvom uchenykh lyudey"), which depicted a group of modest provincial writers who overhear some delirious ravings from Shakhovskoy, who is asleep on the other side of a partition. This satire led to the founding of a friendly literary society of "Unfamous Arzamas Writers," which has gone down in literary history under the name of Arzamas. The Arzamas members consisted of gifted literary men, Karamzin's supporters and people close to his circle: Zhukovsky, Batyushkov, Davydov, Alexander Voeykov, Dashkov, Filipp Vigel, Alexander Turgenev, Vasily Pushkin, Alexander Pushkin, and others. The Arzamassians emphasized their group's informal character, which they contrasted with that of the primly official Colloquy. They held their meetings in various places: one even occurred in a carriage on the way from St. Petersburg to Tsarskoe Selo. The society's permanent secretary, Zhukovsky, kept humorously solemn minutes 129 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
MARK ALTSHULLER of these meetings in hexameter. The members of Arzamas adopted nicknames taken from Zhukovsky's ballads. Zhukovsky himself was called Svetlana, Batyushkov - Achilles, Vyazemsky Asmodeus, and so on. The main content of the Arzamas group's humorous works consisted of attacks on the Colloquy. The Arzamassians delivered funeral eulogies of their opponents, the "living dead," and made fun of the solemn rituals they observed at their sessions. To be sure, the Arzamassians also read and discussed their own serious works, but that did not constitute the group's center of gravity: they concentrated on pranks and literary polemics. One of the best polemicists in the circle was Vasily Pushkin (1770-1830), Alexander Pushkin's uncle. He had begun mounting attacks on the archaists and Slavophiles from the Colloquy's very beginnings in 1810-11 (and on his deathbed he inveighed against the critical articles of the most junior archaist, Paul Katenin). In his epistle "To Zhukovsky" ("K Zhukovskomu," 1810) Pushkin attacked the "illiterate Slavs" who were trampling underfoot that true enlightenment which was oriented toward Europe. In his epistle "To Dashkov" ("K D. V. Dashkovu") he defended himself vigorously against Shishkov's attacks and scolded bad writers. But the poem "A dangerous neighbor" ("Opasny sosed," 1811) was Vasily Pushkin's genuine polemical masterpiece. The work is set in a brothel whose inhabitants are ecstatic over the Slavophiles' writings, and especially those of Pushkin's old enemy Shakhovskoy. After he joined Arzamas, where he was received with a great many humorous and complicated ceremonies, Pushkin wrote an epistle to Vyazemsky, an epistle to the Arzamassians and several epigrams, but he could never again attain the level of his polemic verse of 1810-11. The Arzamas group included writers who were too individualistic and too talented for it ever to become such a serious and established union of literary allies as was the Colloquy. In 1816-17 Arzamas attracted several men who would become Decembrists in the future: Nikolay Turgenev, Mikhail Orlov and Nikita Muravyov. They sought to deflect the group's activity into more serious, primarily political, channels; and they insisted that Arzamas publish a literary and political journal, for which they had already begun to prepare and collect material. These reform efforts 130 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
TRANSITION TO THE MODERN AGE: I 7 9 O - 1 8 2 O led to bitter arguments within the group and to its rapid disintegration by the fall of 1817. The last meeting of Arzamas occurred in April 1818. It did not outlive the Colloquy by much, since its main reason for existence had after all been its polemics with the Colloquy. Thus Arzamas was not so influential in the history of Russian literature as is sometimes thought. The individuals who made it up were much more significant - both in their gifts and in their role in the history of Russian culture- than was an ephemeral and humorous group brought into existence for a short time. Much as Karamzin was succeeded by a younger generation of early romantics, so the Slavophiles and members of the Colloquy gave way to a younger generation of archaists: Paul Katenin, Wilhelm Kuchelbecker, Fyodor Glinka, Alexander Griboedov and a few others. In a paradox of literary history, while the older archaists were conservatives who found themselves in opposition to the government, the majority of the young archaists, though they shared the Shishkovites' Slavophile and anti-western aspirations, were more or less closely connected to the anti-government Decembrist movement, a revolutionary liberal effort. The most important figure among the young archaists was undoubtedly Alexander Griboedov (1795-1829). Ties of friendship linked him to Kuchelbecker and Katenin, as well as to Shakhovskoy from the older generation of the archaists. Griboedov's life was brief and intense. A person of outstanding ability, he entered Moscow University at the age of eleven; by sixteen he had successfully completed the literary, law, and natural science and mathematical faculties, learned French, German, English and Italian, and was preparing to take his doctorate. The Napoleonic invasion of 1812 interrupted these peaceful scholarly endeavors, and Griboedov never returned to them. From 1812 to 1816 he was in the military service, although he never had occasion to participate directly in battle. From 1817 on Griboedov worked for the Foreign Ministry. But then a duel terminated his pleasant St. Petersburg life, with his initial literary successes, drinking bouts with his young friends, and romantic adventures. Anxious to leave St. Petersburg, Griboedov accepted appointment as first secretary of the Russian embassy in Persia, and thus commenced his diplomatic career in
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
MARK ALTSHULLER 1818. The young diplomat quickly learned Arabic and Persian and acquired remarkable erudition in the area of Middle Eastern cultures. After the uprising of 14 December 1825 Griboedov came under official suspicion, since he was linked both in personal and literary ways with several of the Decembrists, and his comedy Woe from Wit promoted many clearly liberal ideas. Griboedov was arrested, but since his connections with the secret revolutionary societies could not be demonstrated he was released after a few months with a promotion and a monetary reward. In 1828, under Griboedov's guidance, Russia signed the peace of Turkmanchay with Persia, a quite favorable treaty for Russia. Griboedov received a medal, a monetary award, and the high rank of State Councillor; in addition he was soon appointed the Resident Minister (Ambassador) to Persia. On the way to his assignment he delayed for some time in the Georgian capital of Tiflis (now Tbilisi) to marry the daughter of an old friend of his, the famous Georgian poet and social activist Alexander Chavchavadze. The beautiful young Nina - she had not yet turned sixteen had been in love for some time with Griboedov, who had tutored her in music and kept close track of her education and upbringing. Griboedov did not take his wife with him to Teheran, for he realized how dangerous his mission was. Being well informed on eastern questions, he knew how much the Persians hated the Russians, since they were burdened with large financial obligations to pay the restitution which the victors had imposed on the defeated country. In accordance with the provisions of the Treaty of Turkmanchay, the Russian ambassador demanded the return of Russian prisoners (including women in harems) as well as military deserters and runaway serfs, many of whom had long since settled down in Persia, converted to Islam, served in the army (often in high ranks), and had not the slightest desire to return to Russia. On 30 January 1829 an enraged mob, urged on by fanatic mullahs and with the tacit encouragement of the government, invaded the Russian embassy and slaughtered all the Russian representatives (only one survived by chance). Griboedov perished in that bloody episode as he bravely and calmly fought to the end. "His death was instantaneous and magnificent," Alexander Pushkin wrote of him. Since he was constantly absorbed by his official duties, Griboe132 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
TRANSITION TO THE MODERN AGE: I 7 9 O - 1 8 2 O dov managed to write very little in the course of his life. His literary work consisted primarily of dramatic works, a few articles and some poems. From the start of his literary career Griboedov always adhered to the Karamzinists' opponents: in his comedy The Student (Student, 1817), co-authored with Katenin, he mocked and parodied the poetry of Karamzin, Zhukovsky, Batyushkov, and the two Pushkins. Griboedov's protector and mentor was Alexander Shakhovskoy, member of the Colloquy, consistent anti-Karamzinist and critic of sentimentalism. We have already mentioned his comedies The New Sterne (1805) and Lipetsk Spa (1815). Shakhovskoy was the creator of the so-called noble, high-society comedy, distinguished by its lively, free language and its light, entertaining plots. The action in such plays usually takes place in the high society salons of Moscow or St. Petersburg, and their heroes, worldly and well educated people, are often notable for their lofty spiritual aspirations. Another popular author of high society comedies at the time was Nikolay Khmelnitsky (1789-1845), whose plays The Indecisive Man (Nereshitelny), The Chatterbox (Govorun), Castles in the Air (Vozdushnye zamki) and others were invariably successful. The comedy Your Own Family, or The Married Fiancee (Suoya semya, Hi zamuzhnyaya nevesta, 1817) was written collectively by Shakhovskoy, Khmelnitsky and Griboedov. From the soil of the high-society comedy of the early nineteenth century sprang a masterpiece of the Russian theater, Woe from Wit (Gore ot uma, 1822-4). In the Russian mind Griboedov remains the author of this one work: everything else he wrote is of interest only because it came from the pen of the creator of Woe from Wit. The plot of the comedy is briefly as follows. After an absence of three years the young Alexander Chatsky returns to the home of a wealthy Moscow aristocrat, Paul Famusov, where he had spent his childhood and early adolescence, and where he had fallen in love with Famusov's daughter Sofya. The intelligent and exceedingly well educated Chatsky still loves Sofya ardently, just as before, but she has changed: she now loves her father's secretary, the cowardly scoundrel Molchalin, and has come to hate the man she once loved. When Chatsky tries to discover what has happened to her and with whom she is in love, Sofya declares.he has gone mad. 133 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
MARK ALTSHULLER Chatsky suffers and tortures himself as his conflict with those around him gradually intensifies. In the last act, in despair upon learning of Sofya's love for the nonentity Molchalin, Chatsky leaves Moscow forever. A very important trait of Griboedov's comedy is the combination of romantic and social drama within it. Chatsky suffers from unrequited love, and in his impatience and irritation comes into more and more severe conflict with the nonentities who surround him. The women around him think only of clothes, the men of their careers, everyone seeks his own pleasure and no one has any spiritual interests. In his passionate monologues Chatsky defends science, art and creative work against the attacks of careerists and rogues. He criticizes the system of serfdom, or more precisely, the abuses and cruelties of that system: the selling of serfs separately from their families, serf theaters and so forth. The struggle against Gallomania also occupies an important place in Chatsky's monologues: in this area Griboedov shares the views of the Shishkovites and the young archaists entirely. His Chatsky defends the purity of the Russian language against pollution by French borrowings, he sorely regrets the abandonment of the comfortable traditional Russian dress which has been replaced in high society by ridiculous frock coats and bizarre women's fashions. Only the common people have preserved the dress, morals and customs of their ancestors, and Chatsky's speeches contain comments on the tragic gulf between the simple people and educated aristocrats whom those simple people, "intelligent and energetic," look upon as another nation quite foreign to themselves. All these ruminations of Chatsky's correspond in considerable degree to the views and ideas of the Decembrists, who were naturally quite enthusiastic about the comedy and spoke of it frequently while they were under police investigation and in their subsequent memoirs. Still, although he mostly shared the social and political ideas of the Decembrists, Griboedov was also a sceptic who looked with a jaundiced eye upon conspiracies, plots, revolutions and the other romantic schemes of his Decembrist friends. Thus in the fourth act of his play he introduces the episodic character of Repetilov, a chatterbox, drunkard and fool who 134 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
TRANSITION TO THE MODERN AGE: I 7 9 O - 1 8 2 O claims to belong to a "most secret union" of "decisive men." This was an obvious caricature on secrecy and conspiracies. Griboedov's comedy is linked structurally to the traditions of classicism. The classical unities of time, place, and action are strictly observed (one day, the Famusov home, Chatsky's unrequited love). The comedy's precise and aphoristic language remains to this day the finest anthological example of living colloquial Russian. This prevalence of the well-formed aphorism also connects Griboedov's comedy with the finest models of the classical comedy, and primarily with Moliere, whose Misanthrope undoubtedly influenced Griboedov's conception of Chatsky. At the same time certain romantic traits are detectible within the main hero's character, in his lyrical monologues, in his solitude, in that juxtaposition of the hero with the banal and worthless world surrounding him that we find in Schiller's plays, for example. The play's central conflict also remains unresolved, in the romantic tradition: the hero departs, but without our knowing why, where he is going, or what he will do in the future. For many decades down to the present day writers such as Dostoevsky, Saltykov and Goncharov, as well as theatrical directors like Konstantin Stanislavsky and Georgy Tovstonogov have sought to interpret, elucidate and elaborate Griboedov's thoughts about Chatsky as a hero of his time and about the channels of Russia's historical development.
135 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
4
THE NINETEENTH CENTURY: ROMANTICISM, 1820-40
The decades between 1820 and 1840 witnessed simultaneously the zenith of Russian romanticism and the first stages of Russian literature's greatest period, which extended from approximately 1820 to the time of the First World War. In terms of genres, Russian romanticism began with a strong emphasis on poetry (it is appropriate that Ruslan and Lyudmila of 1820 should be a narrative poem), but in the course of its development shifted toward prose. Thus Pushkin, though he never abandoned poetry by any means, turned definitely toward prose in 1830 with the composition of his Tales of Belkin, a cycle of works which laid the foundations of the Russian short story yet to come; Gogol began his literary career with a poetic failure but soon found his place as a writer of elaborate prose; and Lermontov, in numerous ways the most characteristic figure of the romantic period, remained not only a fine poet - many think him second only to Pushkin among nineteenth-century poets - but became an excellent prose-writer as well, and it is proper that his novel, or cycle of short stories, A Hero of Our Time (1840), should mark the end of Russian romanticism, and rather decisively at that. The transition from Ruslan and Lyudmila to A Hero of Our Time marks not only a shift from an early romanticism based upon national folklore to a romanticism oriented toward the extraordinary individual, the "superfluous man," in a social context, but also a shift from poetry to prose. And yet both works are plainly romantic in their thrust. By around 1820, and certainly by 1825, neoclassicism had receded into the past: though Pushkin's literary approach retained many classical elements, few were to be found in Gogol or in Lermontov. The new literature emphasized the individual spirit, generally the extraordinary man who stood in some way above society, who had something peculiarly his own to offer. Ivan Turgenev, who lived through the height of Russian romanticism in the 1830s as a very young man, in 1870 deftly outlined what he called the "Marlinsky type" of that time:
136 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
THE NINETEENTH CENTURY: 1 8 2 O - 4 O What was lacking in that type? There were Byronism and romanticism; reminiscences of the French revolution and of the Decembrists — and adoration of Napoleon; a belief in fate, in one's lucky star, in one's strength of character; a pose and a phrase - and the anguish of emptiness; the trembling anxieties of a shallow self-love - as well as genuine power and courage; noble aspirations along with ignorance and poor upbringing [...] There was, in short, something admirable about the romantic hero with his exotic dreams, even though he could be comic too. A romantic like the Gogol of the 1830s could overdo things considerably, with his tales of wizards, incestuous fathers, great sinners; Lermontov loved the exotic settings of the Caucasus, although he was considerably more sober than Gogol in his approach. But no doubt the Marlinsky type as Turgenev describes him was most characteristic of the romantic mind. It was also during the romantic period that the Russian writer began to view himself as normally an adversary of the existing order. This frame of mind came into being especially after the suppression of the Decembrist uprising of 1825 and the execution or exile of many of its participants. Nicholas I, who came to the throne then, found little sympathy from intellectuals and writers, and in turn entrusted them with little authority. Where only a few years before writers like Karamzin and Derzhavin had been influential in high government circles or held lofty official positions, now writers rarely obtained anything more than modest government positions, and certainly had little to do with the formulation of high government policy. The writer thus adopted a posture of hostility to the government, and viewed himself as primarily a critic of his society. During the romantic period another important change occurred in the writer's status. Earlier authors did not expect to gain a living from their writing, or even to receive much in the way of income from it, but now literature became more commercialized. In order to support himself the writer had to produce things the reading public would accept and therefore pay for, but this meant that he was more than ever dependent upon the tastes of his audience. During the eighteenth century writers had been members of the landowning aristocracy or else supported by the government in some fashion, but as the nineteenth century wore on they became more and more dependent Upon the reading public. In an effort to reach that public the so-called "thick journals" were created. The first important such journal was Osip Senkovsky's Library for Reading, founded in 1834; it was followed in short order by Pushkin's The Contemporary in 1836 and Fatherland Notes in 1839. All of these lasted at least until into the 1860s. Such journals published writing of various sorts: poetry, prose, history, commentary, in a 137
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
JOHN MERSEREAU JR. volume the size of a book which appeared monthly and provided general intellectual fare for the reader. Among the writing included in the "thick journals" was literary criticism, which developed quickly now that there was some original literature to write about. Vissarion Belinsky, the most outstanding critic of the century, began his career in the 1830s, and in the subsequent decade would exercise a profound influence upon Russian literature. Before Belinsky Russian criticism was a feeble reed; after him it laid just claim to an important place in the history of Russian culture. The "thick journals" also had another significant function. With the virtual disappearance of the literary societies which had been so vital at the beginning of the century, they supplied focal points for literary life: now writers might run into one another at the editorial offices of the journals in which they published rather than at evening gatherings at Derzhavin's home, for example. But the journals also reinforced the spirit of faction in literature, for each journal generally espoused a certain approach and gathered to itself writers who agreed with that approach. Thus they sowed division as well as unity among writers. OUR TENDENCY to think in terms of schools and movements suggests that literature consists of discrete blocs of artistically homogeneous works. Of course, that is not the case, since literature is constantly evolving, and every period, in addition to its exemplary figures, has its epigones from past movements and precursors of things to come. Thus, it is difficult to place even approximate limits on a movement or a school. Given this caveat, we may say that Russian romanticism begins to emerge from sentimentalism around 1815, that it gains the high ground in the 1820s and 1830s, and by the early 1840s is on the verge of displacement by realism, whose harbingers have appeared over the previous decade. Works in verse formed the centerpiece of Russian romantic literature: so brilliant and rich was the product of that period that by general acceptance it has been termed "The Golden Age" of Russian poetry. The poetry of Baratynsky, Tyutchev, Delvig, Yazykov, along with that of some less well-known talents, would justify that appellation even were one to exclude all of Pushkin's contribution, as unthinkable as that might be. With some justification literary historians extend the final limit of the Golden Age until the death of Lermontov in 1841. Be that as it may, poetry as the dominant literary form began to be displaced
138 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
THE NINETEENTH CENTURY: 182O-4O by prose at the end of the 1820s, quite probably because the reading public had simply become sated with an abundance of good verse. By 1830 prose was preeminent, and even poets par excellence such as Pushkin increasingly turned to fiction. Some social considerations must be taken into account in any survey of romanticism, for to a degree they affected prevailing literary themes and their treatment. Almost without exception, the romantic poets belonged to the gentry class. Accordingly, most of them had some formal education, which put them in touch with the more important examples of ancient poetry and of classicism, foreign and domestic. Most knew French at least as well as Russian, and used French in conversation, in correspondence, and sometimes in their compositions. The new generation of romantics devoted considerable effort to Anacreontic and fugitive verse celebrating the pleasures of friendship and the good life. If a change of mood seemed appropriate, the elegy was a favorite form. When protest motivated them, they inveighed against restrictions on personal freedom, rather than seeking equality for the masses. Most of them accepted serfdom: however liberal or democratic their political orientation, they were not vocal proponents of emancipation. Since personal freedom was at issue, it was natural that Byron enjoyed a vogue in the early 1820s. But the banner of protest which the Englishman had raised and which seemed destined to be grasped by eager Russian hands after his death in 1824 was dropped summarily after the suppression of the Decembrist uprising of 1825. A number of writers were exiled, including Kuchelbecker and Alexander Bestuzhev-Marlinsky; the poet Kondraty Ryleev was hanged; and everyone else, including Pushkin, came under suspicion. From then on poets sought to keep away from the gaze of officialdom. Meanwhile, men of a new social class were entering the literary arena, not only as writers but as journalists, publishers, and critics. Although not exactly from the lower strata of society, they were hardly prepared to join the so-called St. Petersburg "mandarins," for whom literary activity was an endeavor for which remuneration had seldom been expected or provided. This new group of litterateurs were professionals who sought - often with pathetic results - to gain a livelihood from their efforts, and that injected a 139 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
JOHN MERSEREAU JR. new note of economic necessity into the general literary scene. At this point we begin to see literary criticism, never noted for its gentility, acquiring acrimonious tones and slanderous overtones. Literary piracy became common as publishers and booksellers sought to outsmart and outsell their competition. With political protest strictly proscribed, and certainly unappealing in view of the fate of the Decembrists, social protest was nonetheless implicit in some of the poetry and prose of the late 1820s. This was particularly true of prose after it began to dominate literature in the early 1830s. This protest was made on behalf of painters, musicians, and other persons of artistic talent, who because of their plebeian, or even serf, origins were scorned or unappreciated by a vacuous society. But again, the protest was most often voiced on behalf of their unrecognized talent, not on behalf of the class from which they had emerged. The dominant figure of this period -was the poet Alexander Pushkin (1799-1837), who even as a student at the lyceum for gentry youth at Tsarskoe Selo had displayed uncommon poetic ability. In fact, when Derzhavin visited the school in 1815 and heard him declaim his own verses, he had announced: "This is he who will replace Derzhavin." His prediction quickly proved correct, for within four years Pushkin's Ruslan and Lyudmila (Ruslan i Lyudmila) appeared. Ruslan and Lyudmila is conventionally called a "mock epic," but it has many more prototypes than merely, for example, Voltaire's La Pucelle. One may find in it stylistic features of diverse European and Russian origins, such as medieval fabliaux, the Orlando Furioso, the Russian bylina, or modern efforts to imitate folklore, such as Zhukovsky's "Twelve sleeping maidens." High adventure, magic, spells, and a giant disembodied head which speaks are involved as three champions seek to recover Lyudmila, kidnapped by the hideous dwarf-magician Chernomor. There is considerable erotic suggestiveness in this comedy, which in the end ingeniously unites Lyudmila with her rightful beloved, Ruslan. Conservatives were (at least publicly) disturbed by the eroticism and other "low" features of Ruslan and Lyudmila, and faulted Pushkin for failing to provide a bona fide epic, a feat beyond their own powers. Others were perplexed by the eclectic nature of the work and the heterogeneity of its language, which ranged from 140 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
THE NINETEENTH CENTURY: 182O-4O Church Slavic to vernacular Russian. Discerning critics saw it as a demonstration of the triumph of innovations begun by Karamzin, and Zhukovsky sent Pushkin a portrait of himself generously inscribed "To the victorious student from his vanquished mentor." Pushkin had no use for Alexander I, whom he considered a usurper, and upon graduation from the Tsarskoe Selo lyceum he wrote several poems with political implications, including "Liberty" ("Volnost," 1817), an ode calling for the lawful punishment of tyrants, and "To Chaadaev" ("Chaadaevu," 1818), in which he pledges himself to the cause of freedom. These and other poems, as well as an incendiary epigram directed at the tsar's favorite, Count Alexey Arakcheev, came to the attention of the authorities, and Pushkin was exiled to the south of Russia. En route he fell ill and was aided by the Raevsky family, with whom he traveled across the Crimea. Alexander Raevsky, somewhat older than Pushkin and a hardened cynic, seems to have influenced the young poet, at least if one interprets "My demon" ("Moy demon," 1823) as alluding to their relationship. Less ambivalent were Pushkin's feelings about Maria Raevskaya, the seventeenyear-old daughter of the family, who seems to have become a muse for Pushkin, or at least the addressee of several lyrics. Three narrative poems form the so-called southern cycle, The Prisoner of the Caucasus (Kaukazsky plennik), The Fountain of Bakhchisarai (Bakhchisarayskyfontan), and The Gypsies {Tsygany). All
show Byron's influence in setting, theme, and character types. They exploit the exoticism of the remote Circassian aul, the Crimean palace of the Tatar khans, and the gypsy camp; unrequited love and violence are common to all three. The prisoner is a disaffected Russian officer whose devoted Circassian lover frees him from his captors and drowns herself. In The Fountain of Bakhchisarai a jealous odalisque slays her rival. By the time Pushkin finished The Gypsies, he presumably had overcome the Byronic influence, for the protagonist, Aleko, is depicted as inherently selfish and desirous of freedom only for himself: when his gypsy lover leaves him for another, he murders her. He is then banished by the tribe. While still in the south, Bessarabia, Pushkin began his most famous work, the "novel in verse" Eugene Onegin (Evgeny Onegiri). Completed seven years later, in 1830, the work combines features of the mock epic with those of the free poem or Byronic poem. 141 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
JOHN MERSEREAU JR. Pushkin remarked that it was "in the manner of Don Juan," although it more closely resembles Beppo. There are eight chapters or cantos, each containing around fifty stanzas of sonnet-like "Onegin stanzas": fourteen lines of iambic tetrameter ending in a couplet. The humorous and effervescent verse of the early cantos later gives way to a more serious tone, a development that reflects the growing maturity of Pushkin's "lyric I." Interwoven with the story of Eugene, a jaded member of the St. Petersburg jeunesse doree, and Tatyana Larina, a naive provincial miss, are extensive digressions, some of many stanzas, containing the author's ars poetica, ars amatoria, autobiography, literary criticism and parody, and social commentary. Over one hundred persons are mentioned by name, including authors, literary characters, and acquaintances. Settings range from provincial Russia to Moscow and St. Petersburg, the seasons are described, social customs are depicted, and food, dress, education, and current events are discussed. The characters are presented in an unusual manner, for while Onegin and Tatyana are represented in ways that later became standard for realist literature, and their portraits are in fact psychological ones, the secondary characters - Tatyana's fickle sister Olga and her poet-fiance Lensky - are purely satirical. Pushkin tells us the girl is a typical blonde, and urges us to complete her portrait for ourselves; Lensky, imbued with German romantic philosophy, is as foggy as his elegies. At first encounter Onegin appears a bored fop, though goodhearted and intelligent, who hopes to overcome his ennui when he inherits his uncle's country estate. Among his neighbors is Tatyana, a solitary dreamer under the spell of European preromantic literature, who instantly identifies Onegin as her fated lover. Defying convention, she writes him a poignant letter declaring her love, to which Onegin responds with a stern lecture on the dangers of imprudent behavior. After a senseless duel in which he kills Lensky, Onegin leaves the provinces. Tatyana, happening upon his estate and its library, seeks clues to his enigmatic personality among his books and their marginal notes, but remains uncertain whether he is heaven-sent, a demon, or simply a Byronic poseur. At the end of the seventh canto she is packed off to Moscow to be married, and we are left to guess, when we encounter her again in the final canto, how this simple country girl became the wife of a 142 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
THE NINETEENTH CENTURY: 182O-4O prince and a leading figure of the St. Petersburg beau monde. Onegin, just returned from aimless travels, encounters her at a ball, is instantly enthralled, and importunes her with his advances and letters of devotion. Ultimately they meet alone, and he beseeches her to respond to his love. She remains aloof, though admitting she is unhappy and would gladly give up everything to return to the modest surroundings where first they met, but "I have married. . . . I love you, why dissemble, but I have been given to another. I will be faithful to him forever." As the story unfolds we sense a diminution of the author's sympathy for Onegin, but there is no doubt about his sustained attachment to Tatyana, who embodies an ideal Russian ethos. From her peasant nurse she has assimilated a rich heritage of native folklore, and she has an abiding love for the serene beauty of her rural surroundings. Eschewing social frivolity, she is withdrawn and wistful, impulsive and instinctive, and morally unfaltering. In his History of Russian Literature D. S. Mirsky noted that
"Onegin and Tatyana are the forefathers of a whole race of characters in Russian fiction." Indeed, the opposition of the morally strong woman and the "superfluous man" - an individual who can find no productive role in society despite intellect, education, and even wealth - became typical for the Russian novel of psychological realism. Throughout the 1820s an often acrimonious debate raged over the meaning of romanticism and its companion term narodnost, roughly translatable as "national identity" or "national culture." Indicative of the confusion was Alexander Voeykov's identification of Pushkin's Ruslan and Lyudmila as "romantic" owing to its mixture of comic and epic. Pushkin himself held that verse forms known to the ancients were "classical," while those new on the literary scene were "romantic," a simple but scarcely helpful distinction. Some light was cast on the subject by Orest Somov's three-part essay of 1823 entitled "About romantic poetry" ("O romanticheskoy poezii"), which appeared in The Emulator (Sorevnovatet), the widely-read journal of the Free Society of Russian Letters. The first two parts paraphrased (with credit) Madame de StaeTs De I'Allemagne (1813), while in the final part Somov exhorted his countrymen to find sources for an original Russian romanticism in their chronicles, history, landscape, ethnic types,
H3 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
JOHN MERSEREAU JR. and language. Somov's essay was not a definition, but it did isolate ingredients which might contribute to a romanticism based upon narodnost and incorporating mestnost, or national locale. Baron Anton Delvig (1798-1831) is remembered almost as much for his friendship with Pushkin and his publishing ventures as for his poetry. He attended the Tsarskoe Selo lyceum with Pushkin, where he, along with Kiichelbecker, shared that poetic ambiance. After leaving school, Delvig lived in St. Petersburg, for a time sharing an apartment with Baratynsky. His talent and good relations with gentry poets made him one of the "literary mandarins" of St. Petersburg, and in 1824 he had no difficulty in mobilizing his friends to contribute to the almanac Northern Flowers for 1825 (Seuernye tsvety na 1825 god). His house became a gathering place for St. Petersburg literati and ultimately a center of opposition to the "literary shopkeepers" Nikolay Grech and Faddey Bulgarin. Delvig's poems are largely of the kind termed "occasional," such as epistles to his poet friends or elegies. Many pieces are entitled simply. "A romance," and deal with personal circumstances and intimate thoughts. A number of poems display an original combination of meters, evidence of the experimentation typical of romantics, but Delvig's constant allusions to classical mythology in much of his verse (except the popular songs) reveal an orientation toward the Greek Anthology not typical of his contemporaries. His use of hexameters in much of his mature poetry was also unusual. Delvig's mature poetry includes a number of idylls and sonnets, not ordinary for Russian romantics, and imitations of popular songs, some so "authentic" as to have been accepted as the real thing. Many of these are titled "A Russian song" ("Russkaya pesnya"), and share the features of this folklore genre: an abundance of diminutives, repetition, apostrophe, particles with no meaning inserted for emphasis or the meter, and parallel constructions: Ach thou, night thou, Nightlet! Ach thou, night thou Stormy!
Akh ty, noch li, Nochenka! Akh ty, noch li Burnaya!
A number of these songs have been set to music, along with many other poems by Delvig, which testifies to their general appeal. Delvig was not inclined toward politics, and seems to have had 144 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
THE NINETEENTH CENTURY: 182O-4O
no relations with the Decembrists other than those based on personal friendship. There is a story that on 14 December 1825, he blithely crossed Senate Square oblivious of what was going on. In 1826 Delvig enlisted the aid of Orest Somov as managing editor for Northern Flowers, and from that point on Somov became a fixture of the almanac's editorial staff. With the support of the finest contemporary writers, in 1830 Delvig launched The Literary Gazette (Literaturnaya gazeta), an eight-page newspaper which appeared every five days. Several of Delvig's idylls have become anthology pieces, among them "The bathing women" ("Kupalnitsy," 1825), which D. S. Mirsky called "the highest achievement in Russian poetry in the more purely sensuous vision of classical antiquity." Also noteworthy are "The end of the golden age" ("Konets zolotogo veka," 1829) and "The retired soldier" ("Otstavnoy soldat," 1829), wh'ich employs the idyll as a vehicle for the tale of a wounded veteran of the war with Napoleon. Eugene Baratynsky (1800-44) is in the good company of poets second only to Pushkin. Although he is indisputably a romantic, his poetry is highly intellectual, and he has been called "the poet of thought." Baratynsky's life was marred by an incident in his youth which prevented him from enjoying the privileged status to which his gentry descent entitled him. At the age of sixteen he was dismissed from the Corps of Pages for involvement in a prank which aroused the ire of Alexander I. Three years later he was permitted to enroll as a common soldier with private quarters. Then followed four years of not too arduous service in Finland. In 1825 he became an officer, and that December he was in Moscow on extended furlough. Despite his many friends among the Decembrists, he seems not to have had any connection with the conspiracy, nor any deep political convictions. Baratynsky is known for his narrative poetry and for his lyrics, all permeated by a pervasive pessimism. Eda (1825) is the tale of a naive Finnish girl who is abandoned by her Russian officer lover. Except for some excellent descriptions of the Finnish landscape and a touching portrait of the heroine, the work is not unusual, and critics have not unjustly seen it as a Finnish variant of Karamzin's "Poor Liza" or Pushkin's Prisoner of the Caucasus. Two later narra145 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
JOHN MERSEREAU JR. tive poems - The Ball {Bal, 1828) and The Concubine (Nalozhnitsa,
1831) - concern contemporary society and are closer in concept to Eugene Onegin: that is, they present psychological portraits of the central characters and satirical depictions of society. In The Ball Princess Nina, abandoned by her Byronic lover Arseny, takes poison. In The Concubine (in later editions retitled The Gypsy Woman [Tsyganka]), the title character, a prostitute, finds her lover Eletsky is devoted to another woman. Hoping to regain his affections, she gives him a love potion which turns out to be a fatal poison. While it would be wrong to ignore Baratynsky's narrative poems, his lyric poetry is much more original and distinctive. His early mastery of the elegy caught the attention of Pushkin, who wrote Vyazemsky in 1822 that "he will outdo both Parny and Batyushkov if he keeps on advancing as he has until now." Pushkin's comment identifies two important influences upon Baratynsky, to whom must be added Millevoye, a number of whose poems he translated. Pessimism about poetry, the poet's lot, love, culture, and the future is a common denominator of these lyrics. In "A complaint" ("Ropot," 1820) the poet expresses his inability to respond to joy; in "An admission" ("Priznanie," 1823) the lyric "I" declares itself unable to love again. Even the epistles to friends strike a somber note, as "To Delvig" ("Delvigu," 1821), which begins: In vain, Delvig, we dream of finding Happiness here in this life; The gods of heaven will not share it With Prometheus' mundane children. All of Baratynsky's poetry has a forcefulness of expression which elevates it above the usual trite words about jaundiced emotions and premature disillusionment typical of much other occasional verse of the period. After 1826 Baratynsky left the service, married, and moved to Moscow, where he associated with members of the disbanded Lovers of Wisdom Society. Though he was never a disciple of Schelling, who was, after all, an optimist, Baratynsky's poetry now acquires a philosophical quality which reflects careful thought about art, the poet's role, the fate of civilization. Death becomes an 146 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
THE NINETEENTH CENTURY: 182O-4.O overt theme, as in "The last death" ("Poslednyaya smert," 1827), a vision of a world devoid of life; "The last poet" ("Posledny poet," 1834-5), which casts the poet in the role of a superfluous and ridiculous member of society; and "Autumn" ("Osen," 1837), an ode of 160 lines finished just after Baratynsky learned of Pushkin's death: autumn is the time of harvest, and winter effaces all, but for you [Pushkin] there is no future harvest. The last two of these poems appeared in Baratynsky's final collection, Twilights (Sumerki), which contained poems written between 1834 and 1841. Baratynsky parted company with most of his Moscow literary friends at the end of the 1830s, unable to share their Slavophile enthusiasms. In the fall of 1843 he began a tour of Europe during which he met a number of famous French writers. In the spring of 1844 he left Paris for Italy, and died unexpectedly in Naples in June of that year. Today Baratynsky's reputation is secure, but during his lifetime he did not enjoy the fame he deserved. His poetry of ideas, psychological and philosophical, was too serious for a public accustomed to album verse, and although he enjoyed the respect of his fellow poets he found the critics rather severe. Many viewed the subject matter of his narrative poems as uncouth and even Belinsky, while recognizing Baratynsky's talent, criticized his relentless pessimism (in the 1830s Belinsky was an optimistic disciple of German romantic idealism). Nikolay Yazykov (1803-46) is the third charter member of the Pushkin Pleiad. While most of the writers of the romantic period improved as they grew older, Yazykov was an exception, for the verses of the first decade of his creative life are generally recognized as superior to those of the final two decades. Commenting upon his move from Dorpat (now Tartu) to Moscow at the end of the 1820s, Yazykov said that he had "gone straight from the tavern to the church": he had also gone from being a university student majoring in revelry and a writer of excellent occasional poetry to a militant Russian-Orthodox-Slavophile and author of excessively tendentious verse. Yazykov's surname was fully appropriate, since yazyk means "tongue" in Russian, and no poet surpassed him in verbal felicity. The inspiration for the poetry of his Dorpat period came mostly from wine, women, and song, which he celebrated enthusiastically 147 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
JOHN MERSEREAU JR. and incessantly. In endless epistles and works he called elegies (though their subject matter was atypical of the genre) he lauded friendship, drinking, feasting, and amorous adventures (in explicit language). These verses, many of which could circulate only in hand-written copies, reveal unusual craftsmanship, but their beauty is superficial, for there is nothing conceptually new about them and they display no particular intellectual content. Yazykov is more serious in his verse devoted to freedom, which, of course, he enjoyed fully at Dorpat, far removed from the center of autocracy and the pale of serfdom. At that time the poet was an outspoken enemy of the tsar and his minions, and like contemporary "civic" poets, he turned to Russia's heroic past for examples of patriotic virtue. "Boyan to the Russian warrior during the time of Dimitry Donskoy" ("Bayan k russkomu voinu pri Dimitrii donskom") presumably is the exhortation of a patriotic bard to the troops combatting the Tatars, but it might also be relevant to contemporary circumstances: An end to tyrants' reign: The Tatar khan was fearsome, But the Russian sword killed him! In poems such as this we find a reflection of the romantic ideal of the poet as seer or prophet, the bearer of truth, the leader of the people. During the summer months of 1826 Yazykov had the good fortune to stay at Trigorskoe, an estate adjacent to Mikhaylovskoe, where Pushkin resided at the time, and the two poets became fast friends. For Yazykov Pushkin was a "free-thinking poet, an heir to Voltaire's wisdom." The cycle of poems connected with this summer (usually referred to as the Pushkin cycle) represents the best of Yazykov, who was perhaps on his mettle. These verses include epistles to Pushkin and to other friends, and a tribute to Pushkin's nurse, Arina Rodionovna, who provided the young poets with food and drink and entertained them with folk tales. Also among them is "Trigorskoe," one of the most highly regarded of his works, a long reminiscence of his visit to that estate which ranges widely from allusions to the freedom of the past to a vivid description of a summer storm, the latter rather unusual in the work of a poet not noted for his attachment to nature.
148 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
THE NINETEENTH CENTURY: 182O-4O Yazykov's association with the Slavophiles was not accompanied by any intellectual maturation on his part. In fact, some of his verses attacking the westernizers Peter Chaadaev and Alexander Herzen were so abusive as to offend even those of his own persuasion. He spent his final years traveling about Europe in the vain hope of finding a cure for his progressively poorer health. After his death he was largely forgotten until rediscovered by the symbolists, who saw in him the ability to express the inexpressible. The Pushkin Pleiad may be expanded to include many poets of talent and accomplishment. Some must be mentioned, because they were important in their own right and because they contributed to the heritage of the Golden Age. Dmitry Venevitinov (1805-27) during his brief career was recognized by his fellow literati as a poet of considerable potential and was a leading figure in the Lovers of Wisdom in the early 1820s. His entire work consists of less than fifty poems. The last ones, dealing with unrequited love and hinting at suicide, strengthened the aura of romantic fatalism which surrounded his untimely death (due, however, to a most unromantic case of pneumonia). Ivan Kozlov (1779-1840) is remembered for his accomplishments as a translator, which rivaled those of Zhukovsky. By the age of forty he was blind and paralyzed, but he learned English and German (he already knew French and Italian) and began translating Scott, Byron, and Moore. His Byronic narrative poem The Monk (Chernets, 1825) produced a large number of imitations. His original lyrics are marked by a feeling of religious resignation and are notable for their vivid nature descriptions. Alexander Polezhaev (1805-38) achieved notoriety in 1825 for Sashka, a parody of the first cantos of Eugene Onegin. Tsar Nicholas was outraged by its salacious content and sent Polezhaev to the Caucasus as a common soldier, where he continued writing. He is remembered today for his protest verses and his narrative poems which seek to deromanticize the Caucasus. Fyodor Tyutchev (1803-73) is often ranked next to Pushkin and sometimes even higher than Lermontov. While Lermontov was clearly a disciple of Pushkin and Byron, Tyutchev was oriented toward Derzhavin, Goethe and Schiller. His early association with the Lovers of Wisdom Society while a student at the University of 149 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
JOHN MERSEREAU JR. Moscow and his reading of Schelling permanently influenced his world view. During the period of romantic dominance he spent most of his time in Germany and Italy as a diplomat, and did not return permanently to Russia until the mid 1840s. While abroad he attended Schelling's lectures in Munich, where he was also close to Heine. Since he remained active as a poet for many decades after the end of romanticism's supremacy, much of his later poetry was out of touch with prevailing tastes. Tyutchev never took himself seriously as a poet, and because of his own indifference many of his compositions simply disappeared. His typical form is the short poem, a casual effort to assuage boredom, jotted down on whatever was available. The romantic concept of the poet-prophet did not infect him, and, although he was consistently didactic, he apparently was unconcerned about seeing his poems in print. When Pushkin "discovered" him in 1836 and printed several of his poems in The Contemporary (Sovremennik), they were signed only with his initials. Tyutchev's thoughtful content, his rhetorical quality, and his somewhat archaic diction make him seem much more formal than any of his romantic contemporaries. But he was typically a romantic in his attraction to nature: the sea, the sky, night, stars, the seasons, brooks and streams, and other natural features are constant elements in his poetry. In Tyutchev nature is always anthropomorphized, living, providing clues to the meaning of a perplexing universe. The appellation "metaphysical poet" has been applied to Tyutchev because his constant theme is the dilemma of man caught between Cosmos and Chaos, good and evil, day and night, in his personal vision of Manichean dualism. But this philosophical content is not categoric, and his system, if such it be, is susceptible to multiple interpretations. Accordingly, his poems more often provoke questions than answer them. Perhaps Tyutchev's most quoted line is from "Silentium" (1830), "A thought once spoken is a lie," an idea which appealed to the symbolists, who recast it as: "Only that is true which one heart can say to another in mute greeting." "Silentium" - three stanzas of six lines each - exhorts us to live within ourselves, for in our souls is a whole world of secret magical thoughts. We are advised 150 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
THE NINETEENTH CENTURY: 182O-4O to attend to their song - and be silent! This poem offers several examples of Tyutchev's innovative metrics, with amphibrachs injected into the iambic patterns. Later editors saw fit to correct these illicit lines and force them into the conventional mold. An unusual figure on the Russian romantic Parnassus was Alexey Koltsov (1809-1842), often called the Russian Robert Burns, though not by those familiar with both authors. He was the son of a domineering cattle merchant, who frustrated his son's endeavors to acquire an education. Koltsov's discovery by the Stankevich-Belinsky circle in Moscow in the early 1830s led to ten years of recognition by the literary community, though Koltsov did not enjoy happiness in his personal life, which was marred by his father's autocratic control and destruction of the poet's marital intentions. There is little point in winnowing the wheat from the chaff in Koltsov's occasional verse, and even less in his efforts to poeticize his philosophical musings, which, although earnest, reveal his absence of a formal education. Of importance are his Russian songs, themselves imitations of folk forms, though, owing to his direct contact with peasants as drover and cattle dealer, less artificial than Delvig's. Lyric songs come in many forms: dance, harvest, marriage, love, recruitment and others linked to pagan or Orthodox celebrations. Many of these are laments at a personal loss, such as the death of a lover, the departure of a bride from her father's house, the recruit's farewell. Koltsov's songs are those of individuals who face the reality of their hard lot with fortitude, as, for example, the rejected fiance in "The betrothed's betrayal" ("Izmena suzhenoy," 1838). Something new in Russian literature at that time was Koltsov's depiction of peasant life as a not unsatisfying combination of toil and fulfillment, and there is quiet optimism in his "Song of the plowman" ("Pesnya pakharya," 1831), in which the peasant cheerfully delivers to his horse a monologue extolling labor and the cooperation of beneficent nature. "The harvest" ("Urozhay", 1835) recounts the labors leading to the harvest and voices the peasants' confidence in God's grace. These poems convey a feeling of the wholeness of a life which submerges the individual identity in an integration of nature, the peasant, and toil. Koltsov's songs are not strictly canonical, for he uses stanza
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
JOHN MERSEREAU JR. divisions and sometimes employs a thrice accented unrhymed line rather than the traditional folksong line of two accents. However, they do reproduce the effect of the popular song and provided new perspectives on a world little known to the educated public. Paul Katenin (1792-1853) was an important figure on the literary scene during the 1810s and 1820s. Of the well-to-do gentry, he took part in the Napoleonic wars and reached the rank of colonel, but in 1822 he was summarily exiled to his family estates. Later he resumed his military career, and ultimately retired with the rank of general. The critic Yury Tynyanov classifies Katenin, along with Griboedov and Kiichelbecker, as a "young archaist," a literary nationalist who inveighed against slavish imitation of foreign models and style and who advocated classical traditions with their roots in Lomonosov and Derzhavin. His first efforts were in the field of drama, with translations from Corneille and Racine, original comedies (he collaborated with Griboedov on The Student), and a classical verse tragedy entitled Andromache (1828). One of his most popular works was "An old tale" ("Staraya byl," 1828), a ballad set in Kiev during the time of Prince Vladimir. The setting and content reflect contemporary romantic interests, but the language has a sinewy quality absent from the ballads of the Zhukovsky school. Katenin's Princess Milusha {Knyazhna Milusha), a verse fairy tale,
was finished in 1833. Again set in Vladimir's time, its action prompts comparison with Ruslan and Lyudmila. The hero, Vseslav, a knight of martial and erotic prowess, must prove his suitability to marry Vladimir's daughter Milusha by remaining chaste for an entire year. The work describes the traps laid for him by the witch Proveda, Milusha's guardian, who assumes various disguises in her attempt to cause the libidinous Vseslav to fail the test. The tale is withal rather amusing, with its tongue in cheek attitude toward romantic cliches associated with folklore, the good old days of Vladimir, and its well meaning but weak protagonist. The verses are marked by archaic diction and syntax, but Katenin achieved a tour deforce by incorporating a multitude of Russian proverbs and sayings into his work appropriately and seemingly without effort. Although many of the poets commonly associated with the Pleiad shared liberal ideals, for the most part they were not directly 152 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
THE NINETEENTH CENTURY: 182O-4O engaged in what might be called revolutionary activities. Such was not the case, however, with Alexander Bestuzhev, Kondraty Ryleev, Wilhelm Kiichelbecker, and Alexander Odoevsky, who used their pens to advance their political ideas overtly and covertly. Wilhelm Kuchelbecker (1797-1846) is remembered today for his literary theory and criticism, a small corpus of poems, and for his attractive eccentricity. From a Russified German family he was educated at the Tsarskoe Selo lyceum along with his close friends Pushkin and Delvig. His unusual name (Kuchelbecker means "cupcake baker"), odd appearance, and animated, Quixotic behavior drove his coevals to tease him, but they also admired him for his lofty aspirations, his enthusiasm, and his intelligence. After graduation from the lyceum, he took a post in the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, when he apparently established contact with the future Decembrists. From 1820 to 1822 he served first in Paris and then Tiflis. On his return to Russia, he gravitated towards the Lovers of Wisdom society (Lyubomudry), with whom he shared an enthusiasm for the romantic idealism of Schelling; he and Vladimir Odoevsky became co-editors of Mnemosyne (Mnemosyna), the group's unofficial almanac. There Kuchelbecker published "On the direction of our poetry, especially lyrical, in the last decade" ("O napravlenii nashey poezii, osobenno liricheskoy, v poslednee desyatiletie"), in which he criticized his friends Zhukovsky, Baratynsky, and Pushkin for imitativeness and repetitiousness in their poetry, which he felt was typified by indefiniteness, standardized imagery, bogus landscapes, tasteless personification of such abstract concepts as Peace, Joy, Sadness, and Labor, and inevitable fog, "fog over the pine copse, fog over the fields, and fog in the writer's head." Kiichelbecker's literary position was idiosyncratic: he called himself "a romantic in classicism." Kuchelbecker found his model in Derzhavin: in an age when the elegy had triumphed he called for a revival of the ode, which he considered the loftiest of genres. For him the poet was the bearer of truth, the eloquent citizen-patriot who scorned the crowd, a frivolous mob of pleasure seekers without vital concerns of the spirit, such as a thirst for freedom. Kuchelbecker's poetry occasionally suffers from exaggerated emotionalism and declamatory pomposity, although he was no doubt quite sincere in his manner of expression. 153 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
JOHN MERSEREAU JR. The Argives (Argivyane), an unfinished dramatic tragedy in verse, was a typical effort in a "civic" vein which encouraged the quest for freedom from tyranny. Ado, published in Mnemosyne in 1824, is a prose tale of the tribulations of Ado, a pagan Livonian priest who leads a resistance movement against the Teutonic Knights, who are subjugating his people. Ultimately he and his followers are saved by Prince Yaroslav, and Ado becomes a Christian. The characters are puppets, the plot banal, and the ethnographic material largely the author's invention. Kiichelbecker was on the Senate Square on 14 December 1825, where he attacked two high officials. On both occasions his pistol misfired. He escaped to Warsaw, was captured, and spent the final two decades of his life in Siberia. He continued to write, and some of his work done in exile - for example his reminiscences of Griboedov and Ryleev and a poem on Pushkin's death - have an affective power. Polar Star (Polyarnaya zvezda), a literary annual published by Ryleev and Bestuzhev, appeared in 1823, 1824, and 1825. Its contributors represented the best of Russia's writers, including those from the Pleiad and those of an earlier generation such as Zhukovsky, Gnedich, Fyodor Glinka, and Batyushkov. Also included were works by Faddey Bulgarin, Osip Senkovsky (1800-58) and Nikolay Grech (1787-1867), the group which later attained almost monopolistic control over St. Petersburg periodical publications. Since Ryleev and Bestuzhev were both involved in secret political activities, it was natural that their publication should to the greatest possible extent serve their liberal ideals and disseminate their concepts of civic virtue. In this respect their almanac followed the pattern set by The Emulator, the monthly publication of the Free Society of Lovers of Russian Letters (1818-25), which sought to inculcate ideals of civic responsibility and self-sacrifice in a gentry largely concerned with self-gratification and status. The success of Polar Star led to a proliferation of literary almanacs, of which the most prestigious and the best was Delvig's Northern Flowers. It was so successful that the editors of Polar Star decided to withdraw and conclude their venture with a final issue, smaller than the previous three and thus to be called Little Star (Zvezdochka). However, before it could appear the events of 14 December took place, and it never came out. 154 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
THE NINETEENTH CENTURY: 182O-4O Kondraty Ryleev (1795-1826) was educated in the Corps of Pages, took part in the final campaign against Napoleon, and accompanied the army occupying Paris. His subsequent service on the Don River engendered a deep affection for the Ukrainian land and its culture within him, and a large part of his mature poetry is patterned on Ukrainian historical songs, or dumy. In 1818 he retired from the army and settled in St. Petersburg, serving first in the judiciary and subsequently as a director of the Russian-American Company. In 1820 he published "To the favorite" ("K vremenshchiku"), a denunciation, though not by name, of the tsar's advisor Count Arakcheev so scathing that officialdom was powerless to punish its author, because that would have required acknowledging that Arakcheev was the addressee. Ryleev worked on his historical songs in 1821-3, completing almost a score of them. From Karamzin's History of the Russian State Ryleev chose figures notable for their patriotism, love of freedom, steadfastness in adversity, and courage, such as Oleg, Svyatoslav, Dmitry Donskoy, Ermak, Ivan Susanin, and Bogdan Khmelnitsky. These heroic types speak the language of romantic heroes: his patriot Artemy Volynsky, executed by the Empress Anna at the instigation of Count Biron, goes to his death proclaiming that he has served "sacred truth, and my execution will be my triumph." Those were prophetic words from the pen of one soon to be hanged for his role in the Decembrist conspiracy. Ryleev's Voynarovsky (1824) is a long narrative poem in which the title figure, the nephew of Mazeppa, describes the anguish of his uncle after he has betrayed Peter the Great and joined forces with Charles I of Sweden, only to suffer defeat and bring retribution upon his beloved Ukraine. The work resembles the author's historical songs by its inflated rhetorical style and the adaptation of history to suit its moralistic purposes. Ryleev presents extensive descriptions of the harsh Siberian landscape, the site of Voynarovsky's exile, to intensify the emotional content. In the early 1820s Ryleev became deeply involved in clandestine political activities, and soon acquired a prominent position in the Decembrist organization. His part in recruiting conspirators, planning the revolt, and inciting the troops to rebel, along with 155 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
JOHN MERSEREAU JR. his presence on Senate Square on that fateful 14 December, made it clear he was a central figure in the uprising. For that he was executed. Northern Flowers was not designed to serve any cause other than that of literature per se. In general, the Pushkin-Delvig circle in St. Petersburg was committed to art for art's sake: Pushkin declared that "the aim of poetry is poetry." Orest Somov's annual surveys of Russian literature, which appeared from 1827 to 1831, stressed the importance of developing high literary standards and, most particularly, a literary language purged of foreign borrowings and rude vernacular and adequate for fiction, essays, and technical exposition. He also called for "verisimilitude" in fiction, by which he seems to have meant a concern for description in accordance with reality. Somov's critical essays reflected the confused circumstances in which prose found itself during the 1820s. While poetry had a long tradition and established (even cliched) means of expression, prose was still in a developmental state. Many authors, including Pushkin, complained that prose expression was incondite, imprecise, unsuited for the conveyance of ideas. Others noted that there was no tradition for the representation of conversation in Russian, since conversations in society were usually conducted in French. So one of the main tasks of Russian authors in the 1820s and even in the 1830s was the forging of a viable prose language. The genre pool available to prose writers at the beginning of the 1820s included travel notes, the intensified anecdote of adventure, the military memoir, the historical tale, the "psychological novel," the supernatural tale, and the eastern tale. These categories were not mutually exclusive, and so one finds combinations of them, such as an adventure anecdote interpolated in travel notes. Travel notes, in fact, were a favorite choice, for their flexible format permitted "adaptations" of real experience to exploit suspense or add pathos which bridged autobiography and fiction. Thus The Inn Stairs (Traktirnaya lestnitsa) by Nikolay Bestuzhev, the sea-
faring brother of Alexander, employs travel notes to frame a "psychological" novelette, the fatuous confession of a soul gone astray. Alexander Bestuzhev (1797-1837) is known also by his pseudonym Marlinsky, a name derived from the village of Marli near 156 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
THE NINETEENTH CENTURY: 182O-4O
Peterhof, where he served as an officer of Dragoons in 1817. His first prose was a travel sketch, "A Journey to Revel" ("Poezdka v Revel"), which appeared in The Emulator in 1821, signed Marlinsky. This long sketch filled with all manner of historical, anthropological, and geographical information about Estonia and Revel also included poetry and anecdotes. Bestuzhev then published a number of historical tales, the longest and most important of which was "Roman and Olga" ("Roman i Olga"), which came out in the first issue of Polar Star in 1823. This didactic tale focuses upon the civic virtues and heroism of Roman, a citizensoldier of old Novgorod, who sacrifices his personal happiness to undertake a dangerous mission on behalf of that city-state when its independence is threatened by Muscovy. Ultimately he leads Novgorod to victory and is reunited with his Olga. This tale displays stylistic qualities widely associated with this author (hyperbole, metaphorical saturation, sentimental rhetoric), features which came to be known as "Marlinisms." At the same time, the author advanced the art of fiction by his obvious employment of (some) dialogue as a means of characterization. Bestuzhev wrote three historical tales with castles in their titles: "Wenden Castle" ("Zamok Venden," 1823), "Neuhausen Castle" ("Zamok Neygauzen," 1824), and "Eisen Castle" ("Zamok Eyzen," published in 1826 anonymously under the title Blood for Blood). These stories of villainy in Baltic climes feature bloody acts worthy of I'ecole frenetique. "The Tournament at Revel" ("Revelsky turnir," 1825) is a comic work attacking the prejudices of the Estonian knights, who stubbornly refuse to adapt to new economic circumstances or to recognize the importance of a developing merchant class. The work features witty dialogue, like much of Bestuzhev's work. Following his arrest and exile, Bestuzhev did not appear again until 1830, when his society tale "The Test" ("Ispytanie") was published in The Son of the Fatherland (Syn Otechestva) over the
initials "A. M." As a convicted Decembrist then serving as a common soldier in the Caucasus, he could not use his own name, so his works appeared either anonymously or over the Marlinsky pseudonym. The year 1829 saw the publication of the first Russian historical novel in the manner of Walter Scott. The Scots bard had enjoyed a 157 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
JOHN MERSEREAU JR. fantastic popularity in France, and the Russian reading public was well aware of the Waverley series through French translations or the scores of French imitations. Mikhail Zagoskin (1789-1852) was the first to provide his audience with a Russian historical novel, Yury Miloslavsky, or the Russians in 1612 (Yury Miloslavsky, Hi Russkie v 1612 godu). This was a lively tale of the Russo-Polish conflict from the Time of Troubles, employing the usual Scottian formula of lovers separated by the fortunes of war against a colorful canvas of past events and historical figures. Yury himself was rather on the lines of Marlinsky's Roman ("Roman and Olga"), but, coming as he did just four years after the Decembrist catastrophe, he must have seemed a welcome paragon of courage, devotion, patriotism, and self-sacrifice. Pushkin congratulated Zagoskin on his triumph, saying: "Everyone is reading it. The ladies are in ecstasies. Zhukovsky spent an entire night with it." In conclusion, Pushkin wished Zagoskin a long life so that he might produce many more novels. Zagoskin's initial success encouraged him to produce a whole series of historical novels. Roslavlev, or the Russians in 1812 (Roslavlev, Hi Russkie v 1812 godu) appeared in 1830, and he was still writing in this genre by the end of the 1840s. Meanwhile Yury Miloslavsky had set a pattern for his compatriots, and some quite respectable Russian historical novels shortly appeared. One of the best story tellers was Ivan Kalashnikov (17971863), the scion of a merchant family from Irkutsk. His The Daughter of the Merchant Zholobov. A Novel Drawn from Irkutsk Legends (Doch kuptsa Zholobova. Roman izvlechenny iz irkutskikh predaniy), published in 1831, had the attraction not only of an exotic Siberian setting but an involved plot with separated lovers. It has no participating historical figures, but boasts all the other ingredients of the novel a la Scott. There are also numerous ethnographic details connected with the pagan Buryats, sociological information on the life of the merchant class, and geographical descriptions of the region around Lake Baikal. The characters are flat and simply serve to act out the complicated plot. Kalashnikov's The Kamchatka Girl (Kamchadalka) came out in 1833. Set in the previous century, it offers an interesting picture of Eskimo life and customs, and again employs the separated-lovers formula. 158 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
THE NINETEENTH CENTURY: 1 8 2 O - 4 O Probably the best of these works, excluding Pushkin's The Captain's Daughter, were the novels of Ivan Lazhechnikov (17921869), who styled himself "the grandson of Walter Scott." Known originally for a military memoir of the campaign of 1812, he published his first historical novel, The Last Novik (Posledny Nouik), in 1831-3. It deals with Peter the Great's conflict with Sweden. The Ice Palace (Ledyanoy dom, 1835) details intrigues at the court of Empress Anna (reigned 1730-40) and features horrors derived from I'ecole frenetique. Lazhechnikov's The Infidel (Basurman), set in the time of Grand Prince Ivan III, and The Bodyguard of Ivan the Terrible (Oprichnik) continued the tradition. Bulgarin catered to the fad with Dmitry the Impostor (Dmitry samozvanets) and Mazeppa, in 1830 and 1833 respectively, while Nikolay Polevoy's The Oath at the Lord's Tomb (Klyatva pri grobe gospodnem) came out in 1832. Other popular authors were Konstantin Masalsky and Rafail Zotov, who each produced several historical novels in the late 1830s. It is difficult today to explain the extraordinary popularity of Faddey Bulgarin's (1789-1859) Ivan Vyzhigin, which in 1829 became Russia's first best-seller, with over 6,000 copies sold. Bulgarin was not unknown to the public as an author, for a number of his military anecdotes, eastern tales, and historical tales had been published in The Polar Star and Northern Flowers. Parts of Vyzhigin began appearing as early as 1825, when the book was titled Ivan Vyzhigin, or a Russian Gil Bias, and fanciers of these selections were doubtless moved to purchase the complete work when it appeared in four volumes. The absence of the name of Lesage's hero from the final version of the title is significant, because in his foreword Bulgarin insisted that "this is the first original Russian novel of its kind. I dare to assert that / imitated no one, copied no one, and wrote that which was conceived in my mind alone" (italics in the original). This puffery is the more amusing if one knows that Bulgarin had also borrowed significant episodes from Bishop Ignacy Krasicki's Pan Podstoli, a picaresque work of 1778. Vyzhigin is an amorphous work with a vast setting both inside and outside Russia. Bulgarin's stated intention was to reform society through satire (to those who know the man, this was hilarious!), and thus he sought to forestall criticism of his hero, whose transgressions the author graciously pardons because the 159 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
JOHN MERSEREAU JR. lad is well-meaning but has a weak spirit. Vyzhigin undergoes all manner of adventures as he moves from childhood as a despised gooseherd to manhood as the scion of an illustrious father. Occasionally his escapades are entertaining. Orest Somov damned the work with faint praise but criticized the author for several scenes which revealed his lack of knowledge of St. Petersburg and Moscow high society. This criticism must have galled Bulgarin, who suffered from an inferiority complex in his relations with the literary mandarins of St. Petersburg. The literary mandarins were enthusiastic about a novel of manners written by one of their own, Alexey Perovsky (17871836), whose pseudonym was Antony Pogorelsky, entitled The Smolny Institute Graduate (Monastyrka [sometimes translated The Convent Girl]). The 17 May 1830 issue of The Literary Gazette
referred to this work as "probably the first real novel of manners in Russia," doubtless an allusion to Bulgarin's self-serving assessment of his Vyzhigin as "the first original Russian novel." Perovsky's novel is set in the provincial Ukraine, to which the heroine, Anyuta, newly graduated from the Smolny convent in St. Petersburg, returns. In a lightly ironic tone the narrator describes her efforts to adjust to the rustic manners of her home area after she has received a refined education. The first volume, which consists of Anyuta's letters to a cousin and the omniscient narration of a relative, a certain Antony Pogorelsky, promises some psychological development in the depiction of the heroine, but the hero, the officer Blistovsky, a model of rectitude, is quite flat and rather tedious. This is not true of the secondary figures, especially Anyuta's outspoken aunt, the girl's sanctimoniously perfidious guardian Klim Dyundik and his terrifying wife, a shrew of epic proportions. (This work is a precursor to Gogol's Dead Souls, for Dyundik and his wife are stylized in a Gogolian manner and Dyundik equals Chichikov as a schemer and purveyor of banality.) Unfortunately, the second volume of this work, albeit engaging, focused primarily upon Anyuta's attempts to escape from her guardian, and the delineation of her psychology is scanted. The Literary Gazette was conceived by the Pushkin-Delvig camp as a means of competing with the influence of Grech and Bulgarin, which they considered deleterious to literature and culture. Earlier efforts to foster rival periodicals, such as Prince Vyazemsky's 160 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
THE NINETEENTH CENTURY: 182O-4.O support of Nikolay Polevoy's bi-weekly The Moscow Telegraph (Moskovsky telegraf) or Pushkin's collaboration with Mikhail Pogodin's The Moscow Herald {Moskovsky vestnik), had proved
disappointing. Polevoy showed poor judgment in permitting criticism of Karamzin's History of the Russian State to appear in his periodical; even worse, his polemical History of the Russian People (Istoriya russkogo naroda) was seen as an inept insult to Karamzin. The Moscow Herald, inaugurated in 1827, fared somewhat better, and it enjoyed contributions from the St. Petersburg literary mandarins. However, its Moscow contributors' interest in German romanticism was not shared by the Pushkin circle, and when the poet Venevitinov and Vladimir Odoevsky, who had been closely involved with it, moved to St. Petersburg, Pogodin's scholarly interests increasingly dominated the periodical. Possibly the unprecedented success in 1829 of Ivan Vyzhigin emphasized the urgency of finding ways to curb the expanding influence of Bulgarin and his cohorts. The Literary Gazette began publication on 1 January 1830. Delvig was editor-in-chief, Orest Somov filled a post analagous to that he held on Northern Flowers, and Vladimir Shchastny, a poet of limited range, was secretary. The Gazette appeared every five days in eight pages for its eighteen months of publication. Each of the pages was in two columns. The first four pages were devoted to prose, with poetry generally confined to one or two short pieces. The "Bibliography" section announced new works, some of which were reviewed. "Miscellany" occupied the last pages with a hodge-podge of anecdotes and brief notes on literary matters. Even as word of the venture spread through literary circles, doubts arose as to its feasibility. Vyazemsky wrote to Pushkin that it was unlikely that the paper would succeed: "There is little hope for The Literary Gazette. Delvig is lazy and writes nothing, and he relies exclusively sur sa bete de somme ou de Somoff." In a letter to Pogodin, Yazykov rephrased Vyazemsky's doubts and also alluded to the competition the paper would face from Grech and Bulgarin: "Delvig is excessively lazy and Somov is enthusiastic but incapable. It is not likely they will succeed against those names who have somehow already entrenched themselves on our Parnassus." Yazykov was correct in anticipating opposition from 161 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
JOHN MERSEREAU JR. Bulgarin's The Northern Bee (Severnaya pchela), for even before the
first issue of The Gazette appeared, Bulgarin was attacking it in his paper. The Gazette opened as scheduled, with prose by PerovskyPogorelsky, literary history by Paul Katenin, and contributions by Pushkin and the extended Pleiad. Matters proceeded smoothly until March, when Delvig printed a very negative review of Bulgarin's Dmitry the Impostor. The paranoid Bulgarin attributed the review to Pushkin, and in retaliation published a scathing commentary on Canto VII of Eugene Onegin. The tone of this review so offended the tsar that he told the chief of his Third Section, Count Benckendorff, to forbid Bulgarin to publish literary criticism, and threatened to prohibit criticism in general. The 28 October edition of The Literary Gazette contained a brief poem by Casimir Delavigne which alluded to the heroes of thejuly revolution. Benckendorff then threatened Delvig with exile to Siberia along with Pushkin and Vyazemsky, a reprimand so insulting to Delvig that he totally lost interest in all his literary activities, including Northern Flowers. He was not allowed to continue as editor of The Gazette, but the paper itself was not banned in order not to disappoint the prepaid subscribers. Somov assumed the editorship, and served in that capacity until the periodical closed in the summer of 1831. Perhaps the most popular form of fiction in the 1830s was the society tale, short novels describing the lives and loves of the haut monde. A taste for this type of literature had been created by Balzac's many stories about French provincials and Parisiennes which had appeared in Russia in the original or in excerpts and translations. An early attempt in this genre was Orest Somov's "The Fool in Christ" ("Yurodivy", 1827), which combined a physiological sketch of a typical mendicant holy fool with a plot involving features which were to become standard for the society tale: a ball, arrogant officers, an insult, a challenge, a duel, an innocent victim. Bestuzhev-Marlinsky is usually credited with the first society tale, but his "The Test" ("Ispytanie"), published in 1830, followed not only Somov but also an interesting epistolary society tale entitled "Coquetry and Love" ("Koketstvo i lyubov"), the work of a certain Peter Sumarokov which appeared in The Moscow Telegraph in 1829. One of the most prolific practitioners of 162 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
THE NINETEENTH CENTURY:182O-4O the genre was Ivan Panaev (1812-62), whose "The Boudoir of a fashionable lady. An episode from the life of a poet in society" ("Spalnya svetskoy zhenshchiny. Epizod iz zhizni poeta v obshchestve," 1824) introduces an element of social protest in the person of the poet scorned by an insensate society. In general, the society tale in its canonical form satirized high society, exposing its frivolity, false values, and moral vacuity. The typical plot involved an illicit affair between someone from outside the haut monde and a countess or princess, unhappily married to an older, stupid, and rich husband. A common variant genre took as its protagonist a young man of unusual sensitivity and ability, often a poet, painter, or musician, always poor. Here the society tale merged with the so-called Kuenstlernovelle, which had as its hero an artist or would-be artist scorned by the unfeeling upper classes. A well-known example is "The Name Day Party" ("Imeniny," 1835) of Nikolay Pavlov (1805-64), which chronicles the unhappy love of a serf musician for the daughter of a gentry family. This story is marred by sentimentalism, a mistake not repeated in Pavlov's "Yataghan" ("Yatagan") (both works were collected in the volume Three Tales [Tripovesti, 1835], a suspenseful and psychologically engaging tale of violent revenge stemming from a false sense of honor and class prejudice. Several women writers published society tales. The best-known of them was Countess Evdokia Rostopchina, nee Sushkova (1811-58), who entered the lists in 1838 with two works, "Rank and Money" ("Chiny i dengi") and "The Duel" ("Poedinok"), both of which feature self-sacrificing heroines who are victims of rigid rules of behavior and lack any power to alter their social circumstances. Rostopchina's championing of the rights of women earned for her the title of "the Russian George Sand," with whom she also shared a propensity for hyperbole and prolixity. Elena Gan, nee Fadeeva (1814-42), also concerned herself with the plight of the intelligent woman in circumstances which stifle her interests and instincts. "The Ideal" ("Ideal") is unusual in its depiction of the oppressive atmosphere and stultifying routine of life in a provincial garrison town from which its heroine seeks to escape, but otherwise the story is improbable and the style sententious. Gan travelled widely, and some of her other works are set in remote regions with plots involving love affairs between Russians 163 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
JOHN MERSEREAU JR. and natives, such as Kalmyks and Tatars. She has been called "the female Lermontov," but except for their nearly coincident dates of birth and death, their extensive travels, and their choice of exotic settings, they have little in common. Nadezhda Durova (1783-1866) is in a class by herself owing to her unusual biography. Outraged at the submissive behavior which her domineering mother and society required of her, she fled her home. She entered the army disguised as a man, and after training as a cavalryman took part in several battles during the campaign of 1807, for which she received a medal from Tsar Alexander. Later she saw action at Borodino, was wounded, and subsequently served as orderly to General Kutuzov. She retired from the cavalry in 1816 with the rank of junior captain and returned to her home in a remote province east of Kazan. Some years later Pushkin became acquainted with her brother, learned of her exceptional experience, and encouraged her to write her memoirs. She brought them to him in St. Petersburg in 1836, and he published excerpts in The Contemporary under the title Notes of a Cavalry Maiden (Zapiski kaualerist-devitsy). They occasioned con-
siderable comment, as did their author, who wore male attire and spoke of herself using masculine forms. However, despite their renown, the Notes did not sell well. Durova then turned to fiction, over the next four years producing a number of society tales and a novel, none of them very noteworthy. In 1840 she abruptly ceased publishing. Soon after its advent the society tale acquired what might be called formulaic characteristics, and it was not long before parodies on it began to appear, Pushkin's "The Queen of Spades" ("Pikovaya dama," 1834) being the most famous. One of the most amusing - and far fetched - is from the pen of the prolific Alexander Veltman (1800-60). His "Erotida" (1835) describes a vain and unfaithful officer, a certain G., who forgets his first love Erotida, seeks an affair with her several years later when she appears at Carlsbad disguised as Emilia, a widow, and then kills her in a duel when she, further disguised as a young man, appears to be G.'s rival for Emilia's affections. Although many a society tale concludes with sentimental effusions, in this case the narrator informs us that G. simply threw his victim's body into the river 164
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
THE NINETEENTH CENTURY: 182O-4O (there were no seconds at the duel) and returned to town to continue his pursuit of yet another young lady. One author whom we may categorically label a romantic is Prince Vladimir Odoevsky (1804-69), co-founder of The Lovers of Wisdom Society and one of the principal figures behind its publication, Mnemosyne. Odoevsky is often linked to E. T. A. Hoffmann, with whom he shared an almost obsessive curiosity about the supernatural, an affinity for music and musicians, and pessimism as to the artistic spirit's ability to flourish in the philistine atmosphere of modern life. He created his own unique Kuenstlemovellen in which, with intentional disregard for biographical accuracy, he mobilized Beethoven, Bach, and the Venetian architect and engraver Piranesi to exemplify his own ideas on creativity, the lonely mission of the artist, the effect of music on the human spirit. Odoevsky's Beethoven is a frenetic, deranged, and decrepit ancient who hammers out his last quartet on a stringless harpsichord, oblivious to the world around him. "Beethoven's Last Quartet" ("Posledny kvartet Betkhovena," 1831) concludes with a scene in which society indifferently notes the musician's death. The story of Piranesi ("Opere del Cavaliere Giambatista Piranesi," 1832) combines the supernatural with the sublime in describing the madness of the Venetian's scheme to build an arch joining Mt. Vesuvius and Mt. Etna and his jealous effort to destroy his rival's work (to topple the tower of Pisa by hanging on to it). The Hoffmannesque combination of genius and insanity is absent from "Sebastian Bach" ("Sebastyan Bakh," 1835), an overtly didactic work which emphasizes the spiritual nature of Bach's creation as opposed to the destructive sensuality of Italian music. Motley Fairy Tales (Pestrye skazki, 1833), a cycle ostensibly
presented by the impecunious philosopher Ireney Modestovich Gomozeyko, contains several didactic pieces with engaging titles, such as "The Fairy Tale About the Corpse Which Belonged to Who Knows Whom" ("Skazka o mertvom tele, neizvestno komu prinadlezhashchem") or "The Fairy Tale About Why It Is Dangerous for Young Ladies to Walk in a Crowd Along Nevsky Prospect" ("Skazka o torn, kak opasno devushkam khodit tolpoyu po Nevskomu prospektu"). In the latter a young girl is detained by the evil owner of a dress shop, turned into a fashionable doll, and 165
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
JOHN MERSEREAU JR.
sold to a young man. Later he discovers that she is alive, but her modish existence has rendered her unfit to be the companion of a thinking individual. "The Sylph" ("Silfida," 1837) suggests that retreat to an ideal world of insanity is preferable to a conventional life. Odoevsky's typical didacticism is represented in less fantastic settings by his two society tales, "Princess Mimi" ("Knyazhna Mimi," 1834) and "Princess Zizi" ("Knyazhna Zizi," 1839). The former chronicles the human suffering caused by the vicious gossip of the spinster Mimi, who dominates her circle by her slander. The work follows the standard pattern of the genre, except that the preface suddenly appears in the middle of the story - so we will pay attention to it, as the author explains. Russian Nights (Russkie nochi, 1844) is a collection often tales, nine of which had already been published, arranged within the frame of a dialogue among four friends. Functioning as a chorus, the friends discuss the philosophical content of the stories, with the principal commentator, Faust, serving as the author's porte parole. The discussions range far and wide in an effort to find some principles unifying science and art, while at the same time maintaining credence in the world beyond the five senses. The general criticism of western thought and behavior and hints at the superiority of Russian moral nature reflect Odoevsky's Slavophile beliefs, which became more pronounced as he grew older. However, Odoevsky never adopted the chauvinistic postures typical of the more conservative Slavophiles, like Yazykov. Nikolay Gogol (1809-52) is one of the "big three" of Russian romantic writers. Born into a Ukrainian family of the petty gentry, he began his career inauspiciously with the idyll Ganz Kuechelgarten (1829), derived from Voss's Louise. A chapter of an unfinished historical novel, The Hetman (Getman), an effort combining Scott and I'ecolefrenetique, appeared in Northern Flowers for 1831. He achieved success with Evenings on a Farm Near Dikanka (Vechera na khutore bliz Dikanki, 1831-2), a collection of stories
introduced by a folksy Ukrainian beekeeper, Rudy Panko. Derived from the puppet theatre and folklore, the eight tales range from somber treatments of demonic entrapment to ribald slapstick. Devils, witches, river spirits, boisterous villagers combine with elements of popular superstition, including huts on hens' legs and fires marking buried treasure, to produce improbable but 166 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
THE NINETEENTH CENTURY: 182O-4.O entertaining tales, narrated in a style ranging from effusive descriptions of nature to uncouth dialogue. One might suppose that these stories reflected Gogol's romantic interest in the folklore of his native region, but more probably he was merely responding to the literary market: Somov had already published several tales derived from Ukrainian folklore. One of these eight tales, "Ivan Fyodorovich Shponka and His Aunt" ("Ivan Fedorovich Shponka i ego tetushka"), presages the classic Gogol, the unmasker of poshlost, a term peculiar to Russian suggesting, among other things, banality, self-satisfied mediocrity, phony sentiment, and vegetative existence. Gogol believed in the devil, and saw his hand behind any human behavior which seemed unworthy of man's high mission, with poshlost as his instrument. In "Shponka," poshlost manifests itself in Shponka's total passivity, his lack of any passion or drive, his mental vacuity. The method of characterization used here becomes typical for Gogol's later prose: he stylizes all aspects of the hero to conform to an essential quality, in this case the total lack of any significant physical or mental activity. Shponka, a military officer, spends his life lying on his bed, setting mouse traps and polishing his buttons. In like manner the hallmark of the mature Gogol would be the depiction of life as it should not be.
Gogol later enlivened the romantic prose scene with another collection, Mirgorod (1835). "Viy" is a horror story featuring a folklore monster of Gogol's invention with eyelids falling to its feet. Less fanciful but still imaginative is the pseudo-historical novel Taras Bulba, an exotic pageant uniting features of the Scottian novel, the Ukrainian historical song, and I'ecolefrenetique. Set in an indeterminate century, the work glorifies the good old days on the Russian frontier when Cossacks from the republic of SechBeyond-the-Falls (on the Dnepr River) used to slaughter infidel Jews, Tatars and heretical Poles as much for the sport of it as to punish the enemies of Orthodoxy. Though morally unappealing, the work is colorful and has an exciting plot. Mirgorod also included "Old World Landowners" ("Starosvetskie pomeshchiki"), which externally is a nostalgic reminiscence of the quiet pleasures of rural gentry life but in fact attacks the poshlost of a spiritless existence devoted to gourmandizing and self-gratification. The same irony pervades "The Tale of How 167 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
JOHN MERSEREAU JR. Ivan Ivanovich Quarreled with Ivan Nikiforovich" ("Povest o torn, kak possorilsya Ivan Ivanovich s Ivanom Nikiforovichem"), which recounts how the two estimable gentlemen of the title ruin themselves through an extended and nonsensical lawsuit. Gogol here depends in part upon Vasily Narezhny's work of 1825, The Two Ivans (Dva Ivana), a didactic satire on Ukrainians' devotion to self-destructive litigation. The year 1835 also saw the appearance of Arabesques (Arabeski), a collection which included, among some thematically related essays, stories forming part of Gogol's St. Petersburg cycle: "Nevsky Prospect" ("Nevsky Prospekt"), "Diary of a Madman" ("Zapiski sumasshedshego"), and "The Portrait" ("Portret"). To this cycle we must add "The Nose" ("Nos"), published in Pushkin's Contemporary in 1836, and "The Overcoat" (1842). All of these stories raise problems for the reader, who may find himself deceived should he accept the narrator's implied sentiment or empathize too quickly with the protagonists. "Nevsky Prospect" chronicles the dire fate of a naive painter, Piskaryov, who believes he has discovered his ideal woman only to learn that she is a vulgar prostitute. Emotionally destroyed, he seeks refuge in opium and ultimately commits suicide. This pathetic version of the Kuenstlemovelle, which seems to reflect Hoffmann's philanthropic treatment of the sensitive artist defeated by the mundane world, is contrasted in the same story with an account of the adventures of an officer, Pirogov, whose attempt to seduce the wife of a drunken tinsmith (whose name is Hoffmann and whose cobbler friend is named Schiller) results in his being beaten, vowing revenge, and then forgetting the whole thing by dancing the mazurka at a banal soiree. The officer's easy acceptance of a mortal insult at the hands of the drunken artisans contrasts sharply with Piskaryov's essentially pompous idealizations and his suicide. The plot of "The Nose" involves the snobbish affectations of the eponymous organ after its separation from the face of a Major Kovalyov, a social climber who needs that appendage to find a wife with a large dowry. In this story we find both the Doppelgdnger theme from Hoffmann and the nose from Tristram Shandy's Slawkenburgius, yet further indications of Gogol's familiarity with western European themes and his readiness to appropriate them for his own purposes. 168 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
THE NINETEENTH CENTURY: l82O—40 "The Portrait" caused Gogol difficulties - later to be shared by his commentators - and he considerably altered the initial version of 1835 for publication in 1842. The tale chronicles the disintegration of Chartkov, a poor but promising painter, whose downfall begins when he purchases the forbidding portrait of an Asiatic money-lender and later finds a considerable sum of money hidden in its frame. Now able to dress fashionably, Chartkov becomes an enormously successful society painter, but pandering to his clients erodes his talent, and he becomes incapable of creating anything of value. In jealous despair he buys up works of true artists and slashes them to ribbons, ultimately to die destitute and insane. In the second part of the story the reader learns of the malevolent portrait's origin and how the artist overcame its pernicious effects by retreating to a monastery. Presumably the reader is to understand that talent may be destroyed if an artist seeks easy success, although in fact Chartkov seems to be a victim of some supernatural force associated with the subject of the portrait. The reworked version, considerably longer, places excessive emphasis upon the story's didactic and moralistic content. In 1836 appeared Gogol's play The Inspector General (Revizor),
usually categorized as a satire upon corrupt officials. The "hero," a brainless young clerk named Khlestakov, is mistaken for a government inspector travelling incognito by the worthies of a provincial town, who give him bribes to overlook their many transgressions. The insouciant clerk is initially oblivious to their error and assumes that their toadying is the natural result of his charm and his hyperbolically mendacious account of his position in St. Petersburg. In the end Khlestakov's servant suggests they take French leave while they can. The officials then learn to their chagrin of their self-deception, and the play concludes with the stunning news that a real inspector has arrived. In The Inspector General Gogol seems deliberately to have violated the conventions of classical comedy: his "hero" arrives in Act Two and leaves in Act Four, he proposes almost simultaneously to the mayor's wife and daughter, and the play has no positive characters. Reportedly the tsar himself was amused by the play, which he saw as a satire against corruption; others interpreted it as an indictment of the governmental system. Its real value, how ever, lies in its grotesque characters, the creative lies of Khlestakov, the incomprehensible "reasoning" which afflicts the towns169 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
JOHN MERSEREAU JR. people, and the agglomeration of nonsense which motivates their actions. Despite the tsar's approbation, political conservatives attacked the play, and the hypersensitive author sought refuge abroad. For much of the next twelve years he lived principally in Rome, and it was there he composed his masterpiece, Dead Souls, a primary work of the 1840s. While still in exile at Mikhaylovskoe, Pushkin had expanded his creative horizon to include drama, a move prompted by a growing general interest in Shakespeare. Boris Godunov, which Pushkin called "a romantic tragedy," was the fruit of an effort which extended over the better part of 1825. Informed by Karamzin's account of the reign of the "usurper" Boris and inspired by Shakespeare's freedom of composition, Pushkin combined blank verse, prose, lofty rhetoric and vernacular, the somber and the comic, in chronicling the inevitable disaster facing Boris and his family. In Pushkin's treatment of the conflict between Tsar Boris and the pretender to the throne, the false Dmitry, the former proves incapable of mastering his own destiny, while the usurper succeeds almost without effort. Boris's psychological disintegration contrasts sharply with the naive confidence of the pretender and provides the reader - the play is seldom staged - with a depth not found in Karamzin's account. In 1826, when Pushkin favored his literary friends with readings of his drama, they were astonished at its apparent innovations and gave it the highest praise, but after it was published in 1830 the critics and public reacted otherwise: they complained about its violation of the classical unities and preferred the more traditional treatment of historical subjects found in the contemporary novel in the manner of Walter Scott. Pushkin remained at Mikhaylovskoe following the Decembrist uprising until the following September, when he was summoned to Moscow by Nicholas. The tsar apparently persuaded Pushkin of his good will and proposed to serve as his personal censor. In fact, however, the poet was still regarded with suspicion and remained under police surveillance. Still, his exile was over. He was now famous, free to enjoy the accolades of the public, and able to renew the bachelor pursuits denied him at Mikhaylovskoe. His somewhat irregular life (wine, women, and gambling) did not keep him 170 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
THE NINETEENTH CENTURY:182O-4O
from writing, but now he moved toward prose. The Moor of Peter the Great (Arap Petra velikogo), begun in 1828, was a fictionalized account of the youth of the poet's great grandfather, Abraham Hannibal, an Abyssinian who became a favorite of Peter the Great. The effort consisted of seven chapters, the last unfinished, and was only published completely in The Contemporary in 1837. In 1829, among other prose efforts, Pushkin tried his hand at an epistolary novel, A Novel in Letters (Roman v pismakh), now also unfinished but nevertheless a rich source on the author's ideas on the obligations of the gentry, particularly as regards their serfs. It also reveals a strong interest in the psychology of the protagonists, and had it been completed and published it doubtless would have contributed much to the emerging genre of the society tale. Pushkin's developing interest in history, and in particular in Peter the Great, was further manifested in the long narrative poem Poltava, completed in 1828. The work's originality caused difficulties for the critics: it combined features of the Byronic poem, though without a subjective authorial voice, and the epic, though without a central heroic figure, and lacked the traditional intervention by supernatural powers. The poem is in three parts, with the first a family drama in which Maria, daughter of the nobleman Kochubey, declares her love for the aged Mazeppa, Hetman of the Ukraine, who is also her godfather and thus forbidden by church law from marrying her. She flees to him, so angering her father that he reveals to Tsar Peter Mazeppa's plan to betray Russia. In part two, Kochubey has been imprisoned and tortured by Mazeppa, who hides from Maria his intention to execute her father. She learns of his plan and seeks to intercede, but is too late. She flees, and the distraught Mazeppa cannot find her. The historical implications are broadened in the third and final part describing the battle of Poltava (1709), in which Peter defeated the Swedish king Charles XII and his turncoat ally Mazeppa. Charles and the distraught Hetman flee thefieldof battle, and in a remote village Mazeppa encounters Maria, who has gone insane. In general the historical details of Poltava are correct, although the final encounter between the crazed Maria and her treacherous husband was doubtless poetic license. Oddly, although the hero of the piece is Peter, until the battle itself the poem focuses upon Kochubey, Maria, and in particular upon Mazeppa, depicted as a 171 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008