THE CAMBRIDGE HISTORY OF CHINA General editors DENIS TWITCHETT and JOHN K. FAIRBANK
Volume I I Late Ch'ing, 1800-1911, ...
317 downloads
1353 Views
46MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
THE CAMBRIDGE HISTORY OF CHINA General editors DENIS TWITCHETT and JOHN K. FAIRBANK
Volume I I Late Ch'ing, 1800-1911, Part 2
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
THE CAMBRIDGE H I S T O R Y OF CHINA Volume II Late Ch'ing, 1800-1911, Part 2 edited by JOHN K. F A I R B A N K and K W A N G - C H I N G LIU
CAMBRIDGE
UNIVERSITY
PRESS
CAMBRIDGE LONDON
•
NEW
YORK
MELBOURNE
• NEW •
ROCHELLE
SYDNEY
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
CAMBRIDGE UNIVERSITY PRESS
Cambridge, New York, Melbourne, Madrid, Cape Town, Singapore, Sao Paulo Cambridge University Press 32 Avenue of the Americas, New York, NY 10013-2473, USA www.cambridge.org Information on this title: www.cambridge.org/9780521220293 © Cambridge University Press 1980 This publication is in copyright. Subject to statutory exception and to the provisions of relevant collective licensing agreements, no reproduction of any part may take place without the written permission of Cambridge University Press. First published 1980 Reprinted 1999, 2005, 2006 Printed in the United States of America A catalog record for this publication is available from the British Library. Library of Congress Cataloging in Publication Data
Main entry under title: The Cambridge History of China. Vol. 11 edited by J. K. Fairbank and K. C. Liu. Bibliography: p. Includes index. CONTENTS : v. 10. Late Ch'ing, 1800-1911. pt. 1. v. 11. Late Ch'ing, 1800-1911. pt. 2. 1. China History. I. Twitchett, Denis Crispin. II. Fairbank, John King, 1907- III. Liu, Kwang-Ching, 1921DS735.C3145 95i'°3 76-29851 ISBN O 521 22O29 7 (V. Il) ISBN-13 978-0-521-22029-3 hardback ISBN-IO 0-521-22029-7 hardback
Cambridge University Press has no responsibility for the persistence or accuracy of URLS for external or third-party Internet Web sites referred to in this publication and does not guarantee that any content on such Web sites is, or will remain, accurate or appropriate.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
GENERAL EDITORS' PREFACE
In the English-speaking world, the Cambridge histories have since the beginning of the century set the pattern for multi-volume works of history, with chapters written by experts of a particular topic, and unified by the guiding hand of volume editors of senior standing. The Cambridge Modern History, planned by Lord Acton, appeared in sixteen volumes between 1902 and 1912. It was followed by The Cambridge Ancient History, The Cambridge Medieval History, The Cambridge History of English Literature, and
Cambridge Histories of India, of Poland, and of the British Empire. The original Modern History has now been replaced by The New Cambridge Modern History in twelve volumes, and The Cambridge Economic History of
Europe is now being completed. Other Cambridge Histories recently undertaken include a history of Islam, of Arabic literature, of the Bible treated as a central document of and influence on Western civilization, and of Iran and China. In the case of China, Western historians face a special problem. The history of Chinese civilization is more extensive and complex than that of any single Western nation, and only slightly less ramified than the history of European civilization as a whole. The Chinese historical record is immensely detailed and extensive, and Chinese historical scholarship has been highly developed and sophisticated for many centuries. Yet until recent decades the study of China in the West, despite the important pioneer work of European sinologists, had hardly progressed beyond the translation of some few classical historical texts, and the outline history of the major dynasties and their institutions. Recently Western scholars have drawn more fully upon the rich traditions of historical scholarship in China and also in Japan, and greatly advanced both our detailed knowledge of past events and institutions, and also our critical understanding of traditional historiography. In addition, the present generation of Western historians of China can also draw upon the new outlooks and techniques of modern Western historical scholarship, and upon recent developments in the social sciences, while continuing to build upon the solid foundations of rapidly proCambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
vi
G E N E R A L EDITORS* PREFACE
gressing European, Japanese and Chinese sinological studies. Recent historical events, too, have given prominence to new problems, while throwing into question many older conceptions. Under these multiple impacts the Western revolution in Chinese studies is steadily gathering momentum. When The Cambridge History of China was first planned in 1966, the aim was to provide a substantial account of the history of China as a bench mark for the Western history-reading public: an account of the current state of knowledge in six volumes. Since then the out-pouring of current research, the application of new methods, and the extension of scholarship into new fields, have further stimulated Chinese historical studies. This growth is indicated by the fact that the History has now become a planned sixteen volumes, including the earliest pre-dynastic period, but which still leave out such topics as the history of art and of literature, many aspects of economics and technology, and all the riches of local history. The striking advances in our knowledge of China's past over the last decade will continue and accelerate. Western historians of this great and complex subject are justified in their efforts by the needs of their own peoples for greater and deeper understanding of China. Chinese history belongs to the world, not only as a right and necessity, but also as a subject of compelling interest. JOHN K. FAIRBANK DENIS TWITCHETT
June 1976
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
CONTENTS
General editors' preface
page v
Ust of maps
xi
List of tables
xiv
Preface to volume 11 1 Economic trends in the late Ch'ing empire, 1870-1911 by ALBERT FEUERWERKER, Professor of History, University of Michigan Agriculture Handicraft industry Modern industry Domestic and foreign commerce Government and the economy 2 Late Ch'ing foreign relations, 1866-1905 by IMMANUEL C. Y. H S U , Professor of History, University of California, Santa Barbara
The changing context Foreign, relations, 1866-75 Acceleration of imperialism in frontier areas and tributary states Japanese aggression in Korea The threatened 'partition of China' The Boxer Uprising The effects of the Anglo-Japanese Alliance and the Russo-Japanese War 3 Changing Chinese views of Western relations, 1840-95 by Y E N - P ' I N G and E R H - M I N Hong Kong
xv 1
2 15 28 40 58 70
70 71 84 101 109 115 130 142
Professor of History, University of Tennessee W A N G , Senior Lecturer, Chinese University of HAO,
Introduction: traditional views of foreign relations Initial response and inertia, 1840-60 Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
142 145
VU1
CONTENTS
The impact of Western power and wealth, 1860-95 page 156 The ambivalence of foreign policy views, 1860-95 172 Continuity and change in Chinese views of Western relations 199 4 The military challenge: the north-west and the coast by KWANG-CHING LIU, Professor of History, University of California, Davis and RICHARD J. SMITH, Associate Professor of History, Rice University Ch'ing armies of the post-Taiping era The Muslim revolts and their international implications Ch'ing victories in Shensi and Kansu The reconquest of Sinkiang Li Hung-chang and coastal defence The Sino-French War and its aftermath The disaster of the Sino-Japanese War 5 Intellectual change and the reform movement, 1890-8 by H A O CHANG, Professor of History, Ohio State University Background - aspects of the Western impact K'ang Yu-wei and the emerging intellectual ferment The reform movement Reform in Hunan The debacle of 1898 Legacies of the reform era 6 Japan and the Chinese Revolution o f i 9 i i by MARIUS JANSEN, Professor of History, Princeton University The opening of China as a warning to Japan Meiji Japan in Chinese thinking Chinese students in Japan Nationalism and its repercussions Influence through translation Japan and the Chinese revolutionaries 7 Political and institutional reform, 1901-11 by CHUZO ICHIKO, Professor of History, Center for Modern Chinese Studies, Tqyo Bunko, Tokyo The reform edict of the Kuang-hsu Emperor Reforms in education Reforms in the military system Preparations for constitutionalism Financial reorganization and centralization Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
202
202 211 225 235 243 251 269 274 274 283 291 300 318 329 339 340 343 348 353 361 363 375
375 376 383 388 403
CONTENTS
Other reform programmes Characteristics of the late-Ch'ing reforms
IX
page 408 411
8 Government, merchants and industry t o i 9 i i
416
by W E L L I N G T O N K . K . C H A N , Associate Professor of History,
Occidental College Merchants and modern enterprise: a reassessment Official sponsorship of modern industry Campaigns for private enterprise Peking and the provinces: the conflict over leadership The emergence of entrepreneurial officials 9 The republican revolutionary movement by M I C H A E L G A S S T E R , Professor of History, Rutgers University Early coalitions: the revolutionary m o v e m e n t before 1905 T h e revolutionary alliance, 1905—8 T h e fall of the Ch'ing dynasty, 1908-12 T h e emerging coalition T h e birth of the republic
416 421 437 447 454 463 465 484 506 507 515
10 Currents of social change by M A R I A N N E B A S T I D - B R U G U I E R E , Maitre de recherche au Centre national de la recherche scientifique, Paris T h e privileged classes T h e c o m m o n people T h e g r o w t h of a sub-proletariat Dynamics of social change
535
Bibliographical essays
603
Bibliography
627
Glossary-index
683
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
536 571 586 5 89
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
MAPS
i 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 io 11
Ch'ing empire - physical features Major crop areas Trade routes Railway building Central Asia French Indo-China Imperialism Peking International relations of Manchuria and Korea Muslim Rebellion Ch'ing reconquest of Sinkiang
12
Taiwan
page xu 4 42
55 89 98 114 120
216
236 259
13 Sino-Japanese War 14 Revolution of 191.1
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
271
523
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
MAP I. Ch'ing empire - physical features 0 0
libo miles
" - " Trade Route Grand Canal Great Wall Pass Region of wind-borne foess
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
TABLES
i z 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22
Estimated gross national product page z Changes in rural population and area of farm land 5 Changes in the size of farms $ Chou and hsien reporting of harvests 7 Trends in crop acreages 8 Estimated production of major crops 11 Cotton yarn and cloth imports 20 Capital, looms and workers in handicraft workshops 23 Estimated yarn and cloth consumption 2$ Number and capitalization of foreign-owned industries 29 Foreign and Sino-foreign manufacturing and mining 30-1 Nature of Chinese-owned manufacturing and mining 35 Location of Chinese-owned manufacturing and mining 36 Initial capitalization of Chinese-owned manufacturing and mining 37 Number and initial capitalization of treaty-port and inland Chinese-owned manufacturing firms 38 China's foreign trade 46-7 Distribution of principal imports 49 Distribution of principal exports 49 Foreign trade and principal trading partners, 1871-1911 JI Foreign trade and principal trading partners, 1899-1905 52 Estimated revenue and expenditure of the central government 63 Military and indemnity loans 67
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
j
,
j
PREFACE TO VOLUME 11
While generating is required in all thinking about history, it becomes a special problem in the case of China's history. 'China' is in fact one of the largest generalities used in modern speech. The term represents the largest body of people in one of the biggest land areas over the longest recorded time - a four-dimensional non-pareil. Just to think about 'China' or 'the Chinese' is to rise to a level of generality (measured in persons or years or acres) that in other fields of history would seem almost infeasibly high. Europe since the Minoan age is a smaller entity. To say, with our greater knowledge of Europe and comparative ignorance of China, that European history is more complex would be presumptuous. Until modern times the Chinese record was more extensive. Perhaps China's greater sense of unity produced more homogeneity than in Europe, or perhaps this is partly an illusion created by the traditional Chinese historians' primary concern for social order, the state and its ruling class. In any case, China's historical record with its already high level of generality is now being studied in search of syntheses and unifying concepts to give peoples of today some image of China's past. This is urgently needed, but the difficulties are great: the public need for a generalized picture often coincides with a popular seeking for predetermined conclusions, in order to allocate blame and identify villains, or to acknowledge guilt and regret it, or to justify doctrines and reaffirm them, as the case may be. This means that what the historian of China contributes to his history must be scrutinized with even greater care than usual, especially in a history of China written by outside observers. For example, modern Chinese history in the West has been in large part a history of foreign relations with China, the aspect of modern China most easily studied by foreigners. Of course the multiplicity of foreign influences on China since 1840 (or since 1514) is plain to see. It has even become customary to date modern times from the Opium War, a foreign invasion. But all such impacts from abroad formed only a small part of the Chinese people's day-to-day environment, in which the surrounding landscape and inherited ways remained Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
XVI
PREFACE TO VOLUME II
dominant and changed only slowly. Is it not likely that foreign influences will in time bulk less large in the landscape of nineteenth-century China ? Not because they will shrink in size or significance but simply because they will be overshadowed by the accumulated new knowledge about China's indigenous experience. Volume 10 of this series begins not with the foreign commercial invasion and Opium War but with the view from Peking - the institutional structure of the Ch'ing empire in China and Inner Asia early in the nineteenth century. This is followed by Peking's growing domestic problems of administrative control and social order in the first half of the century. Similar signs of internal malaise as well as signs of rejuvenation appear in the accounts of the Taiping and the Nien rebellions and of the tortured success of the Ch'ing restoration. China's economy, and even her military institutions, shows the inner dynamics of an ancient yet far from stagnant society. In the face of unprecedented strains, millions of men and women knew how to survive. It is evident that by the end of the dynasty the eighteenth-century triumph of Ch'ing arms and governance in the Manchus' Inner Asian empire had actually set the stage for the expansion of the Han Chinese from China proper into the spacious borderlands of Manchuria, Mongolia, Sinkiang and eastern Tibet - a great secular migration consequent upon China's phenomenal population growth that began even before the eighteenth century. The rise of the Canton trade - a two-way street - is only the best-known part of this great Han expansion in numbers, migration, trade and even investment. Part of this Chinese expansion had indeed already taken place overseas, parallel with the expansion of Europe. It occurred beyond the Ch'ing frontiers in that realm of maritime China which forms a minor tradition roughly half as old as the great tradition of the continental, agrarian-bureaucratic empire that dominated the official histories. Seafaring enterprise in the form of the junk trade from Amoy and Canton to South-East Asia (Nanyang, 'the southern seas') long antedated the arrival of the European colonial powers in that region. One has only to think of the Southern Sung navy taken over by the Mongols, of their expedition to Java in 1292, and of the early Ming expeditions across the Indian Ocean in the period 1405-33. Granted that the emperor's leadership of maritime China was foreclosed by the resurgence of Mongol power in the 1440s which pre-empted Ming attention, and by the eventual succession of the Ch'ing as another Inner Asian, anti-seafaring dynasty, the fact remains that in the South-East Asian colonies of the Spanish, Portuguese, Dutch, British and French the European rulers increasingly relied upon Chinese merchants and middlemen to handle retail trade and perform the tasks of
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
PREFACE TO VOLUME II
XVU
licensed monopolists and petty tax collectors. These overseas Chinese (Hua-ch'iao, 'Chinese sojourners') became a special middle class in the European colonies, just as they became indispensable also to the rulers of Siam, where one of them indeed founded the Chakri dynasty that still reigns at Bangkok. Though unappreciated and sometimes denounced by Peking, the seafarers and entrepreneurs of maritime China thus participated in the commercial revolution of early modern times and the colonialism to which it gave rise in South-East Asia. When this accelerating growth of international trade at length forced its way into China through the Tiger's Mouth (Hu-men, Bocca Tigris) below Canton, merchants of Canton, Swatow and Amoy both in legal trade and in the opium trade were among the prime movers in the subsequent growth of international contact. Despite the plethora of foreign commercial records and the present paucity of Chinese, we know that the foreign trade of China was a distinctly Sino-foreign enterprise - in fact, once the treaty ports were opened, the foreign firms' compradors handled most of the trade both into China from the ports and out of China through the ports. Hong Kong, Shanghai and the other places of trade became Chinese cities no matter what the foreign residents may have thought about their sovereignty, their treaty rights or the fire-power of their gunboats. It is almost equally true to say that Chinese participated in the foreigners' opening of China as to say that foreigners participated in China's commercial opening of herself. In the rapid growth of the East India Company's great staple trade in tea at Canton c. 1784-1834, the tea, after all, came from China. Taken together with the Chinese farmers or traders in far-off Sinkiang or Manchuria, the seafarers and entrepreneurs of maritime China bespeak the vitality of the Chinese people, especially since they received scant help from their own government. If foreign trade was a two-sided process in which both Chinese and foreigners actively participated, there is also another consideration with which to appraise the foreign influence in late Ch'ing history: during the nineteenth century, foreign contact bulked larger and larger in the experience of almost every people. The great migration from Europe to the New World had long preceded the more modest movement of Chinese overseas in foreign vessels after mid-century. For the British public the Opium War was of less strategic relevance than the First Afghan War, the Boxer Uprising was only a spectacular incident during the long grind of the Boer War. For most peoples industrialization came from abroad; the centre of gravity in many aspects of change was seen to lie outside the country. International science and technology, like international trade and politics, increasingly contributed to the global life of a world society. In this perCambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
XV111
P R E F A C E TO VOLUME I I
spective it seems only natural that outside influences should have played an unprecedentedly larger role in late Ch'ing history. China's entrance into world society has now laid the basis for historical interpretations that are themselves an ultimate form of foreign influence. These interpretations align the Chinese experience with that of other peoples. This is done first with 'imperialism' and secondly with 'modernization'. These approaches are by way of analogy, seeking to find in China phenomena found universally elsewhere. Both imperialism and modernization are terms of almost meta-historical scope that require precise definition and concrete illustration if they are to be of use to historians. In a general way imperialism implies foreign initiatives while modernization suggests domestic processes. In its economic aspect, imperialism in the case of China stopped short of colonialism. No plantation economy was developed by foreigners solely for an export market. Even the classic Marxist agent of disaster, the import of factory-made cotton textiles, did not destroy China's handicraft production of cloth; it was sustained into the second quarter of the twentieth century by the supply of cheaper machine-made cotton yarn that could be used by otherwise unemployed members of farming families whose weaving could not have fed them by itself but could nevertheless add a tiny bit to their mea"gre family incomes. The fact that in the 1930s perhaps 70 per cent of China's cotton cloth still came from handlooms indicates how strongly Chinese families felt compelled to make use of their unemployed labour power. Handweaving indexed their poverty. In thwarting the domination of factory-made cloth, it also suggests how China's people on the whole escaped becoming a mass market for foreign goods (with the exception of cigarettes and kerosene for illumination) simply by being too poor. This example may suggest how much more we need to know about the internal aspects of China's relations with the outside imperialists in the late Ch'ing. The psychological impact of imperialism, though slow to accumulate, was less uncertain. As time goes on, imperialism as a theme in modern China's history may become more substantial in the realm of thought and psychology, conducive to the rise of nationalism, while it may stand up less well in the quantified field of economics. Chinese ideas of foreign exploitation are already more broadly and easily documented than such exploitation itself. The aggressive assertion of foreign privilege is the major fact in the record, and on this level the missionary vied with the merchant. The imperialism of warfare and gunboat diplomacy, treaty rights and the foreign presence, became very plain to all at the time and is clearly remembered in the national heritage today. A more recent outsiders' view, the concept of modernization, as applied Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
P R E F A C E TO VOLUME I I
XIX
to China suffers from being a catch-all for the concepts of the social sciences developed mainly in the modern West. The effort of the social sciences to be objectively value-free may sometimes be contaminated by their being a culture-bound product of the West. If so, this should be a temporary problem that will be obviated by the growth of a world culture. More serious is the high level of generality inherent in the term modernization. We take it to be a prehension into unity of the ideas of progressive development exemplified in all the social sciences including history. Modern times see widespread growth which brings complexity, change and development in the analytic realms of the economy, the polity, the society and the culture. But the modernization process in each of these realms is defined in the terms of the discipline concerned. To posit a single principle at work in every realm across the board is a further act of faith. This may be a logical satisfaction and yet difficult to apply to the confused data of history. Do we really gain in understanding by promoting the adjective 'modern' to the status of an abstract entity, 'modernization' ? The term may become a useful basket, like 'life', in which to carry a load of things largely unknown, messages undeciphered, mysteries unresolved. Like any term, once reified as a thing in itself, it may become a substitute for thought. As the corpus of modern historical research and writing on China grows and develops, we should expect less demand for the over-arching generalizations that give preliminary structure to a new field of learning. The concrete experience and conscious concerns of the late Ch'ing era should receive major attention, as they do in many parts of this volume. While literature and the arts remain regrettably beyond our scope here, the history of philosophical and political thought gives us major insights into what happened and how. In brief, the late Ch'ing response to the West now begins to seem like only a minor motif; the major process was China's continued response to the Chinese past in the light of new conditions including the West. Stimulus, in short, is where you find it, and stimulus without response is no stimulus at all. For example, the deterioration of the Grand Canal transport system to feed Peking roused an effort in the 1820s to revive the sea transport of government rice around Shantung, an institutional arrangement within the tradition of the statecraft (ching-shih) school of practical administrators. Only in the 1870s were steamships adopted to meet the problem. Again, the doctrinal basis for the self-strengthening movement, to defend China by borrowing Western technology, may be viewed as an application of traditional statecraft in a new context. Only in the 1890s, after many disasters, were ideas of evolutionary progress and social Darwinism
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
XX
PREFACE TO VOLUME II
smuggled into Confucianism as a necessary platform for the reform movement. And in the end, the principal struggle of the reformers was not against imperialism directly but against those Chinese traditions that had made imperialism possible. Late Ch'ing reformers and revolutionaries both accepted the ancient Confucian adage, 'If you can keep your own house in order, who will dare to insult you ?' China's strength must come from within. For scholars trained in the classics, the chief source of inspiration for China's future was still her past. For today's historians of the late Ch'ing, this puts a premium on understanding China's great tradition as well as the nineteenth century. There is no substitute for our knowing what the generations before Sun Yat-sen actually had in mind. Mary Clabaugh Wright (1917-70) left her mark on the history of late imperial China through her students and friends and in two books dealing respectively with the 1860s and the 1900s - the initial and final periods of the present volume. The last stand of Chinese conservatism: the T'ung-chih
Restoration, 1862-1874, which developed from her Harvard dissertation of 1952, analysed the problems and policies of the Ch'ing regime comprehensively as few have done before or since. China in revolution: thefirstphase, 1900-1913, edited from a conference she organized and presided over in 1965, is the first all-embracing study of the subject that embodies the results of modern scholarship from half-a-dozen countries. From 1945 to 1959 Mary Wright built up the Chinese library of the Hoover Institution on War, Revolution and Peace at Stanford and then from 1959 until her untimely death was Professor of History at Yale University. Since this volume of the Cambridge History of China is so indebted to her pioneering work, we dedicate it to her. JKF October 1977
KCL
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
CHAPTER 1
ECONOMIC TRENDS IN THE LATE CH'ING EMPIRE, 1870-1911
There was little of the Chinese economy prior to the twentieth century that was not included within the agricultural sector or quite intimately connected with it.' The bulk of the following essay ought properly to be devoted to an analysis of the structure and development of Chinese agriculture in the nineteenth century and its implications for the rest of the economy. I have, however, while discussing agriculture first, given roughly equal attention to handicrafts, modern industry, trade and commerce, and the fiscal system. If these divisions are so obviously the customary ones, I can only plead my own limitations and the possible extenuation that - with honourable and increasing exceptions - the studies of China's modern economic history upon which I have had to rely for this survey are themselves conventionally descriptive works. The treatment of material in all of the following sections is unavoidably selective. I have in each case focused on what was new or changing in the last five decades of the Manchu dynasty against a background which, until 1911 and long afterwards, remained a basically unaltered mix of the factors of production operating within a largely constant social context. This is not to imply that nothing of importance changed in the last century of imperial China. On the contrary, ideological and political storms uprooted the Confucian empire. Fundamental economic change and modern economic growth, however, did not come of their own momentum out of the late-Ch'ing economic system. They were pre-eminently the by-products of a new and possibly still tenuous political integration which itself was achieved only after decades of political strife, foreign invasion and civil war. One must begin by reluctantly accepting that precise quantitative information of a global kind - as opposed to a fair amount of suggestive local and partial data - is not available and probably cannot be satisfactorily derived for pre-republican China. Nowhere is this more apparent 1
The author gratefully acknowledges the support of the Committee on the Chinese Economy of the Social Science Research Council, and of the Center for Chinese Studies at the University of Michigan in the preparation of this essay.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
2
ECONOMIC TRENDS, 1 8 7 0 - 1 9 1 1
than in the case of so fundamental a measure as national income. Table 1 reproduces, with modifications, the only attempt, of which I am aware, to estimate China's gross national product in the nineteenth century. The individual components were often arbitrarily arrived at, but it is doubtful whether substantial amounts of more reliable information can be assembled. These estimates roughly indicate the relative sizes in the 1880s of the several sectors of the economy. TABLE 1
Estimated gross national product of China in the 1880s Amount (1,000 taels)
Sector
2,229,941
Agriculture Nonagriculture mining manufacturing* construction transportation trade finance residential housing government services professional, gentry and other services net income from abroad
66.79
1,108,816
33.21
47,800 128,000 30,000 30,000 220,000 74,645 164,000 164,000
1.43 3-77 0.90 0.90 6.59 2.24 4.91 4.91
241,313 11,258
7-23 0.34
Total
3.338,757
100.00
* almost entirely handicraft. Source: Chung-li Chang, The income of the Chinese gentry (1962), 296. The principal shortcomings of this estimate, apart from the admittedly critical data question, are Chang's probable overstatement of the share of gentry services, and the much more serious reliance on 1887 official data for the area of cultivated land. As I suggest in the next section, these data and thus the share of agriculture should be adjusted upward by at least one-third. This I have done and, leaving Chang's other components unchanged, I have accordingly recalculated the percentages. AGRICULTURE
While there were changes in detail and alterations in the size or quality of certain components, the technology and organization of Chinese agriculture differed little in 1911 from what it had been in 1870. (Even into the 1930s it remained largely unchanged.) The principal changes were: a slow but perceptible population increase unaccompanied by an equivalent extension of cultivated land; a resulting decrease - particularly in North China - in the size of the average farm; changes in the pattern of crops grown, partly in response to the increasingly adverse man-land ratio and partly in response to new external market opportunities; the absolute and
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
AGRICULTURE
3
relative decline of cotton spinning as a peasant handicraft and a partial restructuring of the sources of rural non-agricultural income in response to this decline; some differentiation of land-holding patterns in the immediate hinterlands of the growing treaty ports from those of the bulk of the rural interior of China; and a completion of the process already long under way by which the distinction between various legal forms of land tenure was dissipated. No useful demographic data for the last half of the nineteenth century are of course available. The official estimates for the 1840s put China's population at a little more than 400 million persons; these, it has been argued, while not accurate in detail are relatively good data.2 The Taiping Rebellion and the other great mid-century uprisings not only resulted in substantial population losses, especially in central China, but also produced a breakdown of the refurbished pao-chia system which had collected the reasonably reliable population data for the period 1776-1850. 'The century between 1851 and 1949, despite the availability of various figures, is practically a demographer's vacuum.'3 There are, nevertheless, sufficient qualitative indications from which to assert, if not to measure, a slowly increasing population from the 1870s until the end of the dynasty. Migrations of population from provinces to the west and north which had not been so severely afflicted gradually repopulated the Yangtze valley provinces that the civil wars had ravaged. The last four decades of the Manchu dynasty were internally relatively peaceful and, compared to mid-century, prosperous. While the wars with France in 1884-5 and with Japan in 1894-5 were politically and diplomatically of great significance, they had no major demographic effect. The great famine of 1877-8 in North-West China and lesser but still serious famines in 1892-4 and 1900 unquestionably resulted in temporary population losses. Such crises, caused by drought and floods, had been endemic in the past and were experienced again in the twentieth century, for example in 1920-1, 1928, 1931 and 193 5. They are inherent components of the demographic pattern characteristic of many 'underdeveloped' countries which combines a high but widely fluctuating death-rate and a high but relatively stable birth-rate to produce slow but substantial population increments. But, how large an increment ? C. M. Chiao and J. L. Buck have estimated from birth- and death-rates observed in 4,216 farm families from four provinces in 1924-5 that the rural population of China might possibly have grown at an average rate of 1.4 per cent per annum between the 1860s and 2
Ping-ti Ho, Studies on tbe population of China, t)SS-i9J3, 47-64.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
J
Ibid. 97.
ECONOMIC TRENDS, 1 8 7 0 - I 9 I I
MAP. 2 Major crop areas the 1920s.4 Such a rate of increase, if uninterrupted, would have resulted in a doubling of the population during these seven decades, and on the face of it appears too high as an actual long-term average although it might have been valid in some areas for shorter periods. In 1934, the National Agricultural Research Bureau of the Ministry of Industry produced, from retrospective and thus tenuous data assembled by its crop reporters, an estimate of changes in the rural population and the area of farm land between 1873 and 1933 which I reproduce in table 2. A population increase of 17 per cent for the forty years 1873-1913, or an annual average of slightly less than 0.5 per cent, is suggested. Assuming a total population of between 350 and 400 million in 187 3, by 1913 this total would have increased to between 410 and 468 million. Bearing in mind that the mid-century population was somewhat more than 400 million, that the Taiping and other civil wars resulted in severe population losses, and that the population of China in 1953, after many years of war and civil war, was enumerated at 5 83 million in the closest thing to a real census that China has ever 4
C. M. Chiao and J. L. Buck, 'The composition and growth of rural population groups in China', Chinese Economic Journal, 2.2 (March 1928) 219-55.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
AGRICULTURE TABLE 2
Index numbers of changes in China's rural population and area of farm land,
= I0°)
1873 1893 1913 1933
Population
Farm land
100
100
108
101 101 101
"7 '3«
Source: Department of Agricultural Economics, National Agricultural Research Bureau, Ministry of Industries, Crop reporting in China, '934. 48-53-
experienced, these estimates for 1873 and 1913 are at least not unreasonable. The National Agricultural Research Bureau's respondents, as table 2 indicates, reported that the farm area in their several localities showed no increase comparable to the slow but continuing population growth which occurred. The resultant worsening of the man-land ratio is reflected in the historical data on average farm size shown in table 3, collected by J. L. Buck'sfieldinvestigators for his monumental land utilization study. Buck's respondents overwhelmingly attributed the reported decreases in average TABLE 3
Changes in the si%e of farms, 1870—1930
Regions, areas and locations China wheat region rice region Wheat Region Areas spring wheat (Kansu, Tsinghai) winter wheat-millet (Honan, Shansi, Shensi) winter wheat-kaoliang (Anhwei, Honan, Hopei*, Kiangsu, Shantung) Rice region areas Yangtze rice-wheat (Anhwei, Chekiang, Honan, Hupei, Kiangsi, Kiangsu) rice-tea (Hunan, Kiangsi) Szechwan rice (Shensi, Szechwan) double-crop rice (Fukien) south-western rice (Kweichow)
Number of locations reporting
Average crop area per farm (hectares)
iSfo
1S/0 '•37 '•75 0.67
'•35 1-77 0.81
ifro 1.06 1.32 o-77
0.92 1.10 0.72
8
0.48 1.14
0.51 1.28
0.66 0.97
0.71 0.81
'9
2.19
2.18
'•53
1.26
15
°-77
0.99
0.84
0.79
6
0.42 0.82 0.58
0.42
2 1 2
—
0.52
0.76 0.64 0.55 0.48
0.74 0.55 °-53 0.36
55 29 26 2
0.76 0.54
* Hopei province was, of course, called Chihli in the late Ch'ing period. Source: John Lossing Buck, Land utilisation in China. Statistics, 288.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
'9)»
6
ECONOMIC TRENDS, 1 8 7 O - I 9 I I
farm size to increases in the population of their areas. In North China (Buck's winter wheat-kaoliang areas) the decline in average farm size was more striking than in central China (the rice-wheat and rice-tea areas). The difference is attributable to the much greater demographic losses from the Taiping Rebellion in the provinces south of the Yangtze River and the consequent temporary fall in the man-land ratio in Central and South China. As population migrated to these then relatively less-crowded provinces from more crowded areas, the man-land ratio rose and average farm size after 1900 slowly declined. While it is certain that rural living standards between 1870 and 1911 did not improve, there is no conclusive evidence that population growth and declining average farm size were accompanied by a drastic secular fall in the peasant standard of living. The semi-annual official reports from the provinces to Peking on the quality of the summer and autumn harvests do indicate a definite downward trend in the course of the nineteenth century. It is reasonable to expect that some deterioration occurred during the catastrophic rebellions of the 1850s and 1860s as table 4 suggests. A continued decline after 1870, however, is not convincingly confirmed by the numerous reports of local crop conditions which appear annually in the Reports and returns on trade by the Imperial Maritime Customs. My suspicion is that the higher proportion of poorer harvests reported in the last decades of the dynasty in part reflects the efforts of the provinces to resist Peking's importunate demands for increased tax remittances, which are described below in the discussion of government and the economy. The depopulation attributable to the rebellions, moreover, could be called a Malthusian safety valve which temporarily reduced the inexorable pressure of population on land. Conditions of individual farmers and of spatially separate localities of course differed widely, with the difference between survival and misery often depending upon uncertain weather, the rapacity of the local officials and the presence or absence of civil war and banditry in the locality. Overall, however, total crop production between 1870 and 1911 probably increased adequately to support the larger population. This increment was not due to any major changes in farm technology or organization. No important new crops or seed varieties (like corn and early-ripening rice earlier in the dynasty) were introduced in the second half of the nineteenth century. The middle decades of civil war, moreover, had seen a substantial destruction of capital stock which was only gradually replaced. Irrigation, water storage and control, and grain storage facilities were not extended or improved beyond their eighteenth-century levels. The increase in crop production was apparently die result mainly of a shift by farmers to crops Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
AGRICULTURE
f
which yielded a larger amount of food or income per unit of land and at the same time required more labour for their cultivation. Crop shifts of this kind in the early twentieth century, as the man-land ratio continued to TABLE 4
Percentage of chou and hsien in nine provinces reporting above normal, normal and below normal harvests, 1821-1910 Number of reports* 1821 182; 1830 1835
1840 1845 1850 1855 i860 1865 1870 1875 1880 1885
1890 1895
1900 1905 1910
,114 .'92 .321 .229 ,3O4 ,306
,019 979 752
i ,087 >*55
1 .308 l .309 1 .246 1 .3°9 1 . 2 43 i ,190 ] ,198 1 ,126
Above normal 42.99 46.47 39.64 20.17 25.07 29.24 22.27 14.09 20.21 5-79 4.86 6.19 7-79 6.26 5-27 3-94 4.28 4.00 4.61
Normal
54-3°
51.67 61.54 65.58 67.02 63.93 72.32 65.67 59.04 53.81 45.01 53.66 52-94 49-51
45-37 45-29 42.85 43-*4 37-74
Below normal 2.69 1.84 1.51 14.23
7.89 6.81 J-39 20.22 24-73 40.38 50.11 40.13 39.26 44-22 49-35 50.76 52.85 52-7J 57-63
* For eight of the nine provinces both summer and autumn reports are included; the number of tbou and hsien reporting is thus about half the number of annual reports Source: Calculated from data in Li Wen-chih, comp. Cbung-kuo cbin-tai nung-yeb sbib t^u-Hao ti-i-cbi, 1840-1911 (Source materials on the history of agriculture in modern China, 1st collection, 1840-1911), 761-9, which are based on reports submitted in response to the following edict: 'An edict to the Hu-pu. Hereafter, in reporting the harvest results of the several provinces, use the following categories; eight Jen [i.e., 80 per cent of a theoretical maximum] is to be taken as a rich harvest, six to seven ftn as a normal harvest, and Eve fen or less as a poor harvest.' Ta-Cb'ing Kao-tmng sbun-buang-ti sbih-lu (Veritable records of the Ch'ien-lung Emperor of the Ch'ing dynasty), 339. 4ia-b, 14 June 1749 (vol. 22, p. 5151 of Taipei reprint, 1964).
worsen, are shown in the data on trends in crop acreage between 1904-9 and 1924-9 collected by J. L. Buck's investigators and summarized in table 5. These indicate a progressive substitution of corn, sweet potatoes and sesame for barley, kaoliang and millet as food crops, and also an increase in such cash crops as cotton to supply the expanding mills of Shanghai and Tientsin. For the period 1870-1911, unfortunately, not even such imperfect although suggestive data are available; but if changes of this kind could occur amidst the political instability and civil war of the
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
8
ECONOMIC TRENDS, 1 8 7 O - I 9 I I
early Republic, they are not implausible in the relative stability of the lateCh'ing decades. Some partial clues are provided by an examination of trends in the exportation of agricultural products between 1870 and 1911. TABLE 5
Trends in crop acreages between 1904-9 and 19}0-} Number of localities reporting
Estimated percentage of total crop area* 1904-9
1914-19
1924-9
1930-5
Crops whose acreage increased or was unchanged
broad beans corn cotton opium peanuts rapeseed rice sesame soy-beans sweet potatoes wheat
7
9
9
9
8
22
11
16 18
17 20 20
*9
11
14 14
13 18
14
3
11
9
8
11
11
5
21
27
17
15 40
37
7 7
4 8
41 8
28 40
10 10
9 8
18 29
IO
11
12
26
27
17
13 27
*4
23
to 26
7
20 2 20
16
17
17
5
6
9
Crops whose acreage decreased
barley indigo kaoliang millet sugar cane
10 12
14 15
22
2J 18
10
7
6
19
* in the reporting localities Source: Buck, Land utilization,217.
In value terms, tea was China's most important single export until 1887 when it was overtaken by silk. The proportion of tea to total exports fell steadily from 54 per cent in 1871 to 18 per cent in 1898 and 11 per cent in 1906. While the decline in the absolute quantity of tea exported was far less precipitous, it does suggest that tea acreage did not increase during the four decades under consideration. The exportation of raw and manufactured silk as measured by both quantities and values increased throughout the four decades. This suggests the likelihood that additional land was devoted to growing mulberry and oak trees. In North China and Manchuria the leaves of oak trees fed the worms from whose silk 'pongee', an increasingly important export fabric, was woven. From 1888 to 1919, with the single exception of 1899, China exported more raw cotton than it imported. This completely reversed the import surplus shown between 1870 and 1887 (except 1874). At first glance it Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
AGRICULTURE
9
might appear that the growing exportation of raw cotton is a strong indication that the total cotton crop increased significantly in the last two decades of the Ch'ing. But matters were not in fact so simple. The increase in cotton exports was accompanied by a steady rise in raw cotton prices and by a simultaneous growing inflow of relatively inexpensive machinespun yarn from India and Japan. The conjunction of these three trends suggests that cotton production did not expand or did not expand sufficiently to meet both domestic and export demand, that the resulting higher domestic prices of cotton and yarn induced weavers to purchase the cheaper imported commodity, and that in turn a reduced domestic demand diminished the inducement to increase raw cotton production. One crop which definitely expanded in acreage during the last decades of the nineteenth century was opium. In value terms opium was China's largest single import until the mid-i88os. Opium and cotton goods together made up about two-thirds of China's imports in the 1870s and early 1880s; by 1898 the share of the two had fallen to about 50 per cent. This decline was entirely due to a decrease in the quantity (although not the value, which continued to rise) of opium imported, while cotton goods imports increased rapidly. The principal reason for the fall in the quantity of opium imports was the steady spread of domestic opium cultivation. Unfortunately no data are available with which to measure even roughly the area of land newly planted with poppy to replace the imported article. The significant price rises per unit at the very end of the Ch'ing and in the first years of the Republic were caused by market speculation in reduced quantity of the drug as the first step towards its de jure if not de facto suppression. The legal import trade was abolished at the end of 1917, while efforts to suppress domestic cultivation subsequently varied in success with the morals and financial needs of the local warlords in whose territories the poppy was grown. Again, judging from data on the quantity and value of exports between 1879 and 1915, it appears possible that there was a substantial increase in crop acreage of soy-beans, rapeseed, sesame and peanuts. Before the 1890s the trade in these commodities was negligible. From the turn of the century, the value of bean products and vegetable oils exported shot quickly upward, the oils going largely to Europe where they were used chiefly in soap manufacture, and the beans and bean cake as well as oil to Japan. The chief producing and exporting area was Manchuria; the flow of population from North China to Manchuria after the Russo-Japanese War was possibly related to an important expansion of soy-bean cultivation. Moreover, efforts to suppress the opium crop in North China led farmers to increase their planting of beans, sesame and peanuts as a substitute cash
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
IO
ECONOMIC TRENDS,
1870-I9II
crop. On the other hand, important changes in domestic consumption patterns were taking place simultaneously which may suggest that the new bean and oil exports represented not so much an increased crop as a diversion to export of products hitherto consumed at home. From the 1890s there was a rapid increase in imports of kerosene, which replaced the more expensive vegetable oils used to make candles for illumination and other purposes. The remarkable growth in bean and oil exports, then, probably overstates the extent to which cultivation patterns were altered before 1900, although Buck's data give a strong indication, as we have seen, that the acreage of these and other cash crops did increase from the early twentieth century. Only a very crude estimate of the production of major crops in a typical year at the end of the nineteenth century is possible. Data in the Kuang-hsu edition (1899) of the Collected statutes (Ta-Ci)''ing hui-tieri) on the area of land under cultivation - with some adjustments the official figure for 1887 is 847,760, j 54 mou - are imperfect in detail and in any case represent a substantial understatement of the actual cultivated area. The underlying unit of measurement in many localities was a 'fiscal' mou used to convert different grades of land to a single standard; some land reclaimed after 1712 had remained unregistered; and the property of the more powerful local elite was not always fully reflected in the tax rolls. The precise degree of under-registration is not known, but judging from J. L. Buck's 1929-33 agricultural survey findings, an upward adjustment by one-third would be quite conservative. Cultivated land (which I take as equivalent to the crop area) in the late-nineteenth century was then perhaps 1,130,344,579 mou. No comprehensive nineteenth-century data are available for the proportions of the total crop area planted in individual crops. If, however, the averages of Buck's 1929-33 percentages and those for 1931-7 by the National Agricultural Research Bureau are adjusted for the changes between 1904-9 and 1930-3 shown in table 5, an approximation of the situation in the last decades of the dynasty is possible. Based on these estimates, table 6 presents at least a plausible guess as to the output of major crops in the late-nineteenth century. The fate of cotton spinning, the most important single rural handicraft in the nineteenth century, is discussed in the following section. In the relatively 'developed' lower Yangtze area (and possibly in Kwangtung as well), where commerce and manufacture were most advanced and where the impact of foreign trade was most substantial, the post-Taiping decades saw an increase in absentee landownership, representing the investment of commercial profits by successful merchants, brokers and compradors. Absenteeism in this sense is to be distinguished from the fact that the great
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
AGRICULTURE
II
majority of the rural elite did not of course reside in the peasant villages in which they owned land; their normal habitat was the rural town, at the level of the hsien city or lower. One form which this development took was the growth of the landlord bursary {tsu-chari) by means of which individual owners, primarily urban businessmen, entrusted their lands and tenants to the management of the bursary owner and received a proportionate share of the profits after taxes and other expenses were met. It is TABLE 6
Estimated annual production of major crops, c. ipoo Typical yield per
Percentage
Rice, unhusked Wheat Kaoliang Millet Barley Soy-bean Corn Cotton, lint
of
Crop acreage
mou
crop ares
(mou)
(piculs)
Output (piculs)
30.2 26.3 12.5 11.6 10.2 6.7
341,364,190 297,280,735 I4i,293."5 131,120,020 115,295,190
j.89 '•39 '•73 ..64 '•47 [.39 [.87 (D.27
1,327,906,699 413,220,222 244.437.'°<> 215,036,83} 169,483,929 105,269,030 88,777,296 7,3 2 4,44i
4-2 2.4
75.733.H5 47.474,49° 27,127,500
Sources: Buck, Land Utilisation, 217; Ta-chung Liu and Kung-chia Yeh, The economy of the Chinese mainland: national income and economic development, I93)-'919, table 30, p . 130,
table A-9, p. 300.
impossible to estimate the extent of this phenomenon, but enough cases have been found by Muramatsu Yuji to suggest that in Kiangsu at least it was more than incidental.5 The bursary owners tended to be well-placed members of the rural elite (gentry) who were able to call upon official assistance (even to the extent of the arrest and imprisonment of delinquents) to collect tenant rents. While rural class relations were never the proper subject for a pastoral idyll even under the best Confucian landlord, absenteeism in the late nineteenth century introduced an increasing element of harshness which became intolerable in the twentieth. The official Ch'ing land records of 1887 still record the existence, in addition to private land (min-t'ien), of substantial acreages especially in North China and Manchuria of banner land (ch'i-ti), military land (t'unt'ieri), imperial manors (chuang) and the like. These reflect the intention of the early Manchu rulers to superimpose a land system corresponding to 5
See Muramatsu Yuji, 'A documentary study of Chinese landlordism in the late Ch'ing and the early republican Kiangnan', BSOAS, 29.3 (1966) 566-99, and Professor Muramatsu's numerous studies of the tsu-cban cited therein.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
12
ECONOMIC TRENDS, 1 8 7 O - I 9 I I
the Manchu political and social structure upon that of conquered China. In reality, by the late nineteenth century little remained, apart from differential rates of land tax, of these earlier distinctions. The combined effects of population growth, inadequate official stipends, and the preponderant influence of the underlying Chinese system of private landownership had in practice almost entirely homogenized the various legal forms of land tenure. Banner land as well as private land was farmed by Chinese tenants in small, scattered plots which by one or another subterfuge were freely rented, mortgaged, bought or sold. The land held under some form of official tenure, bursary land and private land in general were not normally farmed as contiguous estates with hired agricultural labour. The continued rarity of 'capitalist' commercial farming is the first of several aspects of late-Ch'ing agriculture which remained constant alongside the several changes that I have recounted. Examples can be cited of large landholdings by officials, wealthy gentry and monopoly merchants in excess of 10,000 mou throughout the nineteenth century; holdings of this size, however, were quite unusual. Ownership of land in late-Ch'ing China was skewed, but there were few large agricultural holdings comparable to the great estates of Europe and other parts of Asia or the giant ranches and commercial farms of the United States. The landowner normally ranged from the owner-farmer cultivating perhaps 20-30 mou in North China and 12-15 mou in the south, to some two million local elite families whose median holdings were perhaps 100-50 mou, most of which was normally rented to tenants.6 Tenancy, as in the twentieth century, was much more common in the south (the 'rice region') than in the north (the 'wheat region'); perhaps, again as in later decades, 50 per cent of farming families could be classified as tenants or part-owners. Some signs of increasing numbers of tenancies can be observed in districts which had suffered prolonged famine and in areas near the major commercial centres, but there is little evidence that land tenure patterns changed radically in the last four decades of the dynasty. Rents were paid either in money or in kind; if the latter, they were commonly 50 per cent of the major crop. Reported cash rents in the 1880s vary from 0.6 taels to 2.66 taels per mou, approximately 5 to 10 per cent of the value of land in these localities. (Compare the National Agricultural Research Bureau's estimate of average cash rents as 11 per cent of land 6
There are no survey data describing nineteenth-century land tenure or utilization patterns comparable even to the admittedly inadequate twentieth-century reports. My comments are based in part on the results of an 1888 questionnaire to local informants compiled by George Jamieson for the Royal Asiatic Society: 'Tenure of land in China and the condition of the rural population', Journal of the North China Branch of the Royal Asiatic Satiety, NS, 23 (1889)
59-117.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
AGRICULTURE
13
values in the 1930s.) This suggests that, after deductions for taxes and other costs, the return on investments in land, while relatively secure so long as political stability was maintained, was only one-half as large as the 10 to 20 per cent which could be realized from commerce or moneylending. The comparatively low rate of return probably limited any tendency to increasing concentration of landownership. The real burden of tenancy depended upon other stipulations of the landlord-tenant contract in addition to rent. Individual examples of better and worse terms are available for the nineteenth century - labour service, short-term leases, rent deposits and the like - but we lack systematic evidence from which to conclude that the late-nineteenth-century situation was a progressively worsening one, rather than a perpetuation of the same wretched existence, for the numberless poor. One piece of evidence - Professor Muramatsu's discovery that landlord bursary income from rents increased sharply between i c ^ a n d i t j i y - does suggest that the local elite were able to pass on to their tenants much of the burden of the increased taxation of the dynasty's last decade. These additional levies, which are discussed later in this essay, were assessed on the provinces in order to obtain funds for the Boxer indemnity payments. Given the historical ability of influential landowners to evade their proportionate shares of the ordinary tax burden (most commonly by paying none or only part of the 'extras' which had over time become attached to nominal land tax quotas), it is not unlikely that owner-farmers as well as the tenants of larger landlords ultimately paid a disproportionate part of the added taxation. It is the overall stability of the agricultural system rather than any significant departures up or down from the traditional norms that is most remarkable. The equilibrium was satisfied at a very low level of subsistence for the great majority of the millions of farming families who constituted 80 per cent of China's population. The hazards of flood, famine and epidemic were compounded by the absence of inexpensive means of bulk transportation and of an effective central government which could channel funds and food from surplus to deficit areas. Few peasants could realistically expect ever to be better off than their fathers or grandfathers had been. Yet after the great Taiping and Nien uprisings no major peasant revolts threatened the Ch'ing government or the elite-dominated rural society. One might suggest that the absence of a substantial peasant-based revolutionary movement (the role of the omnipresent secret society was ambiguous - as often as not it was controlled by or in cooperation with the local elite) may be taken as an indication that 'restoration' and 'selfstrengthening' were remarkably effective in suppressing traditional forms
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
14
ECONOMIC TRENDS, 1 8 7 0 - I 9 I I
of domestic discontent - if not anti-dynastic nationalism and foreign political and economic incursions. The stability, in a narrower sense, of patterns of agricultural organization and land utilization was the consequence less of political conservatism than of the constraints of the available technology and of the social values which motivated the population. Very large estates, as I have noted, were not common. Moreover, the average land actually cultivated by an individual farming family, owner or tenant, was very small; beyond a certain point larger owners found it preferable to let their excess land rather than farm it with hired labour. Twentieth-century data show a high correlation between the size of the farm household and farm size, an indication that the unit of cultivation was close to the minimum subsistence level. Miniature cultivation was aggravated by the fact that farms tended to be broken up into several nonadjacent parcels usually of different qualities or types of land. Considerable land was wasted in boundary strips, excessive labour time was used to travel from parcel to parcel, and rational irrigation practices were impeded. The rarity of latifundia, the tiny family farm, and parcelization of the typical holding, were all in part the consequence of traditional inheritance practices - in particular of the absence of primogeniture. For elite and peasant alike, the death of the head of the family was usually followed by the equal division of its holdings among all surviving sons who commonly established themselves as separate households. Fen-cbia ('dividing the family'), as the process was called, might be resisted for a generation or more, but the elite ideal of the large extended family did. not often survive the inevitable tensions. Hence, as in the forest primeval, individual oaks sprang up, matured, aged and decayed while the forest itself continued magnificently to dominate the countryside. Parcelization was obviously the outcome of successive efforts to provide each heir with roughly equivalent amounts of the several types of land (paddy, upland, orchard and so on) which had constituted the patrimonial farm. Ownership of a substantial acreage, before or zitetfen-cbia, did not imply management of that land as a unit. Local elite families would farm with hired labour only a portion of their holdings. In addition to the inadequacies of rural credit facilities, to the poverty of management techniques themselves, and to the unstable market for cash crops, there were limits on the quantity of land which would yield greater profits from direct cultivation than from tenant rents. These limits were set by the immense but uneven labour requirements of the existing farm technology. The potential employer of large quantities of farm labour was faced with high supervisory costs and diminishing returns from non-family labour which was used intensively but only at peak seasonal periods. Only improved seeds, more Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
AGRICULTURE
15
and better fertilizers and expanded irrigation - that is, significant technological'changes which did not occur - would have fully justified large-scale farming to supply a distant market. The agricultural sector of the Chinese economy in the last decades of the Ch'ing dynasty was thus characterized by a factor mix in which land and capital were in short supply and the superabundance of labour was subject to some diminishing returns. It was, however, if not for the long run at least for the purposes of any middle-term prediction, in a stable equilibrium with no endogenous economic reason why it should not continue to reproduce itself. It is a tribute to the traditional technology that so vast a population and so high a culture in its upper strata could be supported — even if for the majority the level of subsistence was low indeed. The many centuries of basic investment of immense quantities of human labour in altering the land - by terracing, irrigation, flood control and drainage - had made possible perhaps from as early as the seventeenth century an output of 2.3 metric tons of rice per crop hectare. This is an important benchmark which represents the theoretical maximum yield of pre-modern agricultural technology (that is, without major current inputs of improved seeds, fertilizers, pesticides and so on). China's average rice yield per crop hectare reached only 2.47 metric tons in the 1930s and 2.54 metric tons in the years 1955/6-1960/1. In the latter period India's yield was no more than 1.36 metric tons.7 But the gap between stability and stagnation is narrow. The equilibrium of traditional agriculture had been reached at a very low level of per capita output of which a very high proportion was consumed by the agricultural producers. Only a small quantity of marketable surplus was available either as industrial raw material or to feed the non-farm sector. Conversely, the effective demand for urban manufactured products was limited. Thus the immediate possibilities either of extensive industrialization or of agricultural development were narrowly constrained by the disabilities of the agricultural sector.
HANDICRAFT INDUSTRY
The simplistic indictment of 'foreign capitalism' by some contemporary Chinese historians for having progressively 'crushed' and 'exploited' domestic handicraft industry from the mid nineteenth century onward is belied by the actual state of the Chinese economy as late as the 1930s. In the middle of that decade, even in the cotton textile industry which allegedly suffered most severely from the 'incursion of foreign capitalism', 61 per cent of the cotton cloth produced in China (in square yards; if the unit of 7
See Shigeru Ishikawa, Economic development in Asian perspective, 69-77.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
l6
ECONOMIC TRENDS, 187O-I9II
measurement were yards the proportion would be 73 per cent) was woven by handicraft methods.8 Anyone who would claim that the Hunan or Szechwan peasant in the 1930s dressed in Naigaiwata cottons, smoked BAT cigarettes, and used Meiji sugar has a big case to prove. In 1933, the output of handicrafts accounted for an estimated 68 per cent of the total value of industrial output. Of course the relative share of handicrafts was greater in 1870 or 1911, prior to or in the early stages of the development of the small modern industrial sector which began in the 1890s, than it was in the 1930s. And in some important handicraft industries, notably cotton spinning, a sharp decline occurred from the nineteenth century to the twentieth. On both theoretical and empirical grounds, however, there is reason to believe that the total domestic and export demand for handicrafts did not decline in the twentieth century, and a fortiori that handicraft industry as a whole was not seriously undermined between 1870 and 1911. But to reject the crudest formulations is not to deny either that significant structural changes in the handicraft industrial sector took place in these four decades or that the strain and dislocation occasioned by these developments adversely affected substantial parts of the population. Handicraft industry in mid-nineteenth-century China was carried on either in handicraft workshops, predominantly urban in location but present also in rural areas, or in individual households both in urban and rural locations. The distinction between these two forms of handicraft is sometimes quite arbitrary as peasant weavers, for example, in addition to the weaving performed by household labour, might accumulate sufficient funds to purchase several looms which were operated with hired labour; or urban craftsmen might similarly employ non-kin workers to supplement the labour of family members in milling rice or ginning cotton. 'Handicraft workshops' or 'manufactories' (shou-kung-yeh kung-ch'ang) were relatively large-scale shops as yet unequipped with power machinery. These enterprises, essentially removed from the household nexus and using the labour of several households, included such undertakings as salt wells and refineries in Szechwan, copper mines in Yunnan, pottery kilns like that at Ching-te-chen in Kiangsi, rice and wheat milling in cities throughout China, and the calendering and dyeing of cotton cloth in Kiangsu. No measure is or ever will be possible of the absolute extent of this extrahousehold manufacturing.9 There can be no doubt, however, that it was 8
Yen Chung-p'ing, Cbung-kuo miin-fang-cbib sbib-kao, 1289—19)7 (Draft history of the Chinese cotton industry, 1289-1937), J I I . « P'eng Tse-i, comp. Cbung-kuo cbin-tai shou-kung-yeb shib t^u-liao, 1X40-1949 (Source materials
on the history of handicraft industry in modern China, 1840-1949), 2. 382-90, lists 132 references in eighteenth- and early nineteenth-century writings to handicraft workshops; this is, of course, neither a controlled sample nor an exhaustive count. Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
HANDICRAFT INDUSTRY
17
vastly overshadowed both in employment and in output by the handicraft production of individual households, either ancillary to farming in rural China or performed by full-time urban and semi-urban craftsmen. The most important household handicraft in rural China was the spinning and weaving of cotton. Because of its significance in the economy of the late-Ch'ing period, I shall first discuss developments in the handicraft cotton textile industry in some detail. The history of handicraft production in general during this period can then be assessed in the light of the fate of cotton textiles. From the Yuan dynasty onward cotton culture and manufacture had spread rapidly, cotton cloth becoming the principal daily article of clothing for all except the very wealthy. While cotton cultivation was fairly widely distributed, the principal producing areas were in the Yangtze valley provinces. It was in this region that cotton handicrafts were most concentrated and highly developed. Large areas in the Yangtze delta were better suited to growing cotton than food crops, and in the relatively humid climate of Kiangsu yarn of greater tensile strength and evenness could be spun. From Kiangnan (the area south of the lower reaches of the Yangtze River) and the districts around Shasi in Hupei, for example, large quantities of baled raw cotton and woven piece goods were carried by water and on the backs of porters to Manchuria and North China, to Szechwan via the Yangtze, to Yunnan and Kweichow in the south-west, and to the southern coastal provinces. It was more profitable for Kiangnan peasants to concentrate their productive resources on growing cotton and on weaving (and on spinning only what was required by that weaving) rather than to spin themselves all the cotton that they grew. Thus spinning by rural households for their own consumption with supplies from the Yangtze valley provinces and with local raw cotton was carried on to varying degrees throughout China. And locally woven cloth supplemented that which came from Hupei and Kiangnan. But only in the leading cotton-producing areas had the handicraft production of cotton textiles developed into a major industry serving other than an immediate local market. From the weaving districts in southern Hupei, for example, cloth was brought by peasant weavers or petty merchants to the daily piece-goods market in Shasi. The wholesale merchants who purchased in this market graded the cloth by quality and stamped each grade with a well-known 'chop' (trademark) which was accepted as a guarantee of quality in the markets of Yunnan and Kweichow to which the goods were sent. Cloth from Hupei reached northern Yunnan via Szechwan, first by water on the Yangtze and its tributaries, then on the backs of porters who carried loads as large as 117 pieces of cloth weighing 220 pounds, and then by pack animal on the Yunnan mountain roads. Kweichow
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
18
ECONOMIC TRENDS, 1 8 7 0 - I 9 I I
was reached mainly via Hunan employing the Tungting Lake and the Yuan River which flows into it. This was not, by contemporary standards, a petty trade either in size or in the distances traversed. As late as 1895, by which time there had already been radical changes in the structure of the handicraft cotton industry, more than 200,000 bales of raw cotton and 300,000 bales of piece goods were being imported annually into Szechwan largely from Hupei. And some 3,200,000 pieces of cloth were reaching northern Yunnan each year from Shasi. Similarly, China south of Amoy, North China and Manchuria were supplied mainly from Kiangnan. Moreover, substantial quantities of hand-woven cotton cloth were exported from Canton to England and the United States. Until 1831 England purchased more 'nankeens' (cloth manufactured in Nanking and other places in the lower Yangtze region) each year than she sold British-manufactured cloth to China. Spinning and weaving in the cotton regions for the most part were carried on by individual rural households, to a small extent on a nearly full-time basis but more often in addition to the production of food crops upon which the family was chiefly dependent. Yarn was either spun in the household, or obtained in exchange from the merchants who purchased the cloth which the peasants wove. The income from textile handicrafts formed a larger part of the total income of poorer farmers with the smallest farms than it did of the more affluent. Preparation of the warp prior to weaving, for example, was commonly undertaken in small peasant households to supplement meagre agricultural incomes. For the cotton regions as a whole, however, maintenance of the minimum living standards of the dense rural population was critically dependent upon the market for raw cotton and cloth. The calendering and dyeing of cotton cloth tended to be concentrated in market towns and cities which also were the distributing centres for the finished product. These finishing processes were often controlled by the larger cloth merchants and carried out by hired labour, usually paid on a piece-work basis, in 'handicraft workshops' owned by these merchants or, as in Soochow, by intermediary 'contracting agents' (J>ao-t'ou) to whom the workers paid a monthly fee from, their piece-work earnings for the use of the plant and equipment. In general, before the last quarter of the nineteenth century the cloth merchants exercised no similar direct control over the weaving of the cloth which was, as I have stated, usually executed on their own account by peasant households. In the urban areas handicraft manufacture was still under relatively strict guild supervision; the individual master craftsman and not the handicraft workshop was the dominant form of industrial organization. The very unusual comprador Cheng Kuan-ying offered one version of Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
HANDICRAFT INDUSTRY
19
the changes which occurred in the cotton textile handicraft industry in the second half of the nineteenth century: Cotton is grown in the coastal regions, and spun into yarn and woven into cloth. In addition to supplying local needs, the cloth and yarn were shipped in considerable quantities to the western and northern provinces. But when foreign yarn and cloth began to be imported, the population responded to their lower price and high quality and one after another bought and used them. Thus half of the profits of spinning and weaving in the southern provinces was usurped. Now, in the treaty ports and the cities and towns of the interior, only twenty or thirty per cent of the people wear native cloth while seventy or eighty per cent wear foreign doth.10 Foreign merchants and consular officials in late nineteenth-century China would have been amused to read Cheng's warnings to his countrymen; their reports in contrast were full of repeated complaints about the difficulty of penetrating the Chinese market, especially in the interior provinces. The mercantile community pointed particularly to restrictions on foreign residence in the interior and to the burden of the likin (li-chin) transit tax. The more perceptive of the consuls, however, recognized that the strength of the handicraft weaving industry was the principal obstacle to clothing every Chinese in Lancashire cottons. Cheng Kuan-ying and the foreigners in the treaty ports, in fact, shared the truth between them. Foreign imports of cotton yarn and cloth began to increase significantly after the 1858-60 treaties opened additional treaty ports, including three on the Yangtze. This growth was facilitated by the newly gained right to inland steam navigation in China, by the transit pass system which permitted an additional one-half of the import duty to be paid on foreign goods in lieu of likin, and by the opening of the Suez Canal in 1869 which lowered shipping costs from Europe. Table 7 shows the annual quantity and value of cotton goods imports for the period 1871-1910. Cotton yarn and piece goods in 1871 made up about one-third of China's imports by value. While in succeeding years they fluctuated around that proportion of total imports, from the 1880s until 1920 (the peak year) imported cotton manufactures grew by leaps and bounds. The quantity of yarn imports increased twenty-four times - from 97,451 to 2,363,000 piculs (tari) — if the average annual amounts for the two decades 1871-80 and 1901—10 are compared. After 1913 a decline began as domestic machine-spun yarn progressively replaced imported yarn. While the imports of cotton piece goods exceeded yarn in value in every year except 1898, 1899 and 1903, their growth - a twofold increase between 1871-80 and 1901-10, from 11,463,010 to 21,442,000 pieces - was not nearly so 10
Cheng Kuan-ying, Shtng-shib ati-ytn (Warnings to a prosperous age), 7.2oa-b.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
2O
ECONOMIC TRENDS, 1 8 7 O - 1 9 I I TABLE 7
Quantity and value of cotton yarn and cloth imports, 1871-1910 Yarn
Cloth l.OOO
I.OOO
piculs* 1871
7° 5°
haikwan taelsf
152 172
1,877 1.372 3.130? 1.969 2,747 2,839 2,841 2,521 3,191 3.648 4,228
2
185
4,5O5
3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1890
228
5.242 5,584 7,871 7,869 12,591 13,496 13.019 19.392 20,984 22,153 17.86} 21.597 21,209 32,010 34,43° 39.295 54,941 30,187 49,012 54,794 67.736 59.5*6 67,209 65,141 57.5«5 46,173 62,464 62,831
2
3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1880 1
1 2
3 4 5
6 7 8 9 1900 1 2
3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1910
68 69 91 113 116 108
138
261
}88
383 593 685 679 1,081 1,211 I.3O4 982
1,160 1,152 1,621 1.571 1.959 2.745 1,488 2,273 2,448 2.738 2,281 2,554 2,54' 2,273 1,82} 2,406 2,282
Average value per picul (haikwan taels) 26.81 27.44 46.03 ? 28.54 30.19 25.12
24.49 23-34 23.12 24.00 24.58 24-35 2299
21.39 20.20 20.55 21.23 19.76 19.17 17.94 17.25 16.99 18.19 18.45 18.74 1975 21.92 20.06 20.01 20.29 21.56 22.38 24.74 26.09 26.32 25-64 25.50 25-33 25.96 27-53
1,000 pieces^
1,000 haikwan taelsf
Average value per piece (haikwan taels)
14,439 12,241 8,989 9,763 10,720 11,870 11,117 9.158 12,772 13.561 14,931 12,159 11,500 11,229 15,706 14,041 15.267 18,664 H,275 16,561 17.601 i6,359 12,498 13.343 13.457 18,919 16,914 15.524 19,419 15.964 16,688 22,958 19.272 18,704 55,76o 28,754 18,195 16,906 21,196 17,013
24,877 21,435 16,202 16,301 17.3*5 17.377 15.959 13.509 19,409 19.735 21,818 18,201 16,805 i6,557 23,623 21,181 24,457 5O,942 25,116 25,629 32,307 30.555 27,275 30,708 51,865 47.255 44.255 58,524 48,524 45,419 50,640 72,752 60,884 64,568 114,244 87,587 61,401 64,725 74,827 67,852
1.72 i-75 1.80 1.67 1.62 1.46 1.44 1.48 1.52 1.46 1.46 1.50 1.46 1.47 1.50 1.51
t.6o 1.66 1.62 i-55 1.84 1.87 2.18 2.30 2-37 2.50 2.62 2.47 2.50 2.85 5.05 5-J7 3.16 3-45
3-19 3.05 5-37 5.83 5-53 3-99
* piculs or /«» of 155.55 'b s j- the haikwan tael was first used in 1874; 1871-3 values are the estimated equivalents in haikwan taels of values given in local taels in the customs returns % of varying sizes, but commonly 40 yards long and 56 inches wide; cotton items measured in dozens or yards — perhaps 1 or 2 per cent of the total in square yards - rather than pieces are not included here Source: Yang Tuan-liu and Hou Hou-pei, 'Liu-sbib-ou-nitn lai Cbtmg-kuo kuo-ibi mao-i fung-xbi (Statistics of China's foreign trade during the last sixty-five years) tables 4, 9; China. Inspectorate-General of Customs, Decennial reports . . ., 1922-19}!, 1.113, 182. Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
HANDICRAFT INDUSTRY
21
spectacular. The importation of piece goods did, however, continue to grow until the 1920s and was cut sharply only when the Nanking government regained tariff autonomy. Paradoxically, the very success of yarn imports in the last four decades of the Manchu dynasty indirectly came to be the major obstacle to the equally rapid development of cloth imports. Yarn imports had a critical effect upon the structure of China's cotton textile handicrafts. The average values per picul of imported yarn and per piece of imported cloth given in table 7 indicate a falling trend in yarn prices from the mid1870s until almost the end of the century. Cloth prices also declined in the 1870s but began to rise again in the late 1880s and more sharply than the later increase in yarn prices. The major factor behind the appearance of cheaper yarn was the entry into the Chinese market on a large scale of the products of Bombay spinning mills which replaced the more expensive English yarn. From the 1890s Indian yarn was supplemented by increasing inflows of machine-spun yarn from Japan. The decline in the price of yarn was gradual; it extended over some two decades. It is all the more significant in that over the whole period 1871-1910 the gold value of the haikwan tael was itself steadily falling. While imported machine-spun yarn was becoming cheaper, the price of Chinese raw cotton was rising. This price increase was a consequence of large exports of raw cotton to Japanese mills from the early 1890s onward, while the cotton crop increased little if at all before the spectacular growth of the modern textile industry in China during and after World War I. Together with the limited capacity of a fragmented and technologically backward agricultural sector to respond quickly to export demand, the importation of cheaper foreign yarn itself, which weakened the demand for native handspun, reduced the farmer's incentive to increase his raw cotton acreage. "The most curious feature in connection with the native cotton industry', reported an English mission to China from Blackburn, Lancashire in 1896-7, 'is the high price of the raw material in comparison with other agricultural produce.'" Increasingly the handicraft weaver turned to imported machine-spun yarn, at least for his warp and sometimes for the weft as well. In the 1870s and 1880s South China, Kwangtung in particular, was the main market for imported yarn, absorbing over half of the total. This proportion, however, fell steadily to about a fifth of total yarn imports. By the 1890s two regions, (1) North China and Manchuria and (2) the middle and upper Yangtze valley provinces of Anhwei, Kiangsi, Hupei, Hunan 11
Blackburn Chamber of Commerce, Report of the mission to China of the Blackburn Chamber of Commerce, 1S96-7, Neville and Bell's section, 212.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
22
ECONOMIC TRENDS,
187O-I9H
and Szechwan, together with Yunnan and Kweichow, were each receiving about 30 per cent of the total and thus constituted the major markets for imported yarn. The Kiangnan area, where cotton handicrafts were concentrated, absorbed annually about 10 per cent of yarn imports with large fluctuations from year to year. It is evident that the principal markets for imported machine-spun yarn were those regions where cotton growing and handicrafts were least developed. Cheap imported yarn made possible the economical development of handicraft weaving in districts which previously had purchased cloth or relatively expensive raw cotton from Kiangnan or Hupei. Marginal handicraft spinning declined and cloth, woven locally with warps of imported yarn and wefts of domestic handspun, competed with pure handspun cloth and foreign piece goods in such areas as Szechwan, for example, where it was reported that 'Indian cotton yarn is killing what little local cultivation of cotton there was, and, when woven, is encroaching on home-spun cloths and to a much less degree on imported grey shirtings.'12 The most obvious consequences of the increasing inflow of foreign yarn was thus a geographical dispersion of the handicraft weaving industry which in the first half of the nineteenth century had been concentrated in the major cotton-growing provinces. While the older weaving centres were hurt at first, in order to compete in their former markets they too had to adopt machine-made yarn. From the late 1890s Japanese yarn began to be used in large quantities for warp threads in the Shasi and Hankow areas. Although imported yarn did not win a large market there, Kiangnan handicraft weavers in the early twentieth century became the major purchasers of the output of the growing cotton mills of Shanghai. The adoption of machine-made yarn, moreover, strengthened the handicraft weaving industry as a whole. Cloth produced with a mixture of imported and handspun yarn was particularly suited in price and durability to the contemporary Chinese market. Spinning and weaving for household consumption with domestic raw cotton continued to be important in many areas of rural China, but a significant part of spinning for the market was displaced first by imported yarn and then by machine-made yarn from Chinese- and foreign-owned mills in the treaty ports. While weaving continued to be primarily an individual household handicraft, in some areas by the turn of the century other forms of industrial organization had appeared. These changes were facilitated by the supply of cheaper machine-made yarn and also by improved foot-treadle wood looms and iron-gear looms introduced from Japan which increased the weaver's daily output. One estimate records the establishment of 142 " Blackburn report, F. S. A. Bourne's section, j - 6 .
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
HANDICRAFT INDUSTRY
Z}
handicraft weaving workshops in the period 1899-1913, 69 of these in Kiangsu where they were supplied with Shanghai-made yarn, 15 in Shantung, 14 in Chihli (Hopei), 9 in Szechwan, 7 each in Shansi, Fukien and Kwangtung, 6 in Hupei, 4 in Manchuria, 3 in Chekiang and 1 in Kweichow. Table 8 indicates the size and equipment of these establishments. TABLE 8
Capital, looms and workers in 142 handicraft weaving workshops, established Number of workshops for which data given Capital (Ch. $) 67 Number of looms 37 Number of workers 96
Total
Average
Largest
Smallest
660,220 3.3°7 14.97*
9,854 89 156
70,000 360 1,264
200 12 5
Source: P'eng Tse-i, comp. Chung-kuo cbin-tai sbou-kung-yeb Mb t^u-liao, 1840-1)4) (Source materials on the history of handicraft industry in modern China, 1840-1949), 2. 369-76.
A verlag type of weaving, in which cloth merchants put-out yarn to rural weavers some of whom had abandoned their farming and wove for a piece-work wage the patterns stipulated by their merchant employer, also developed in a number of places alongside rural weavers who wove on their own account. No data are available to indicate the actual extent of this putting-out system, some notable examples of which were in Kao-yang and Pao-ti in Chihli (Hopei), Wei-hsien in Shantung and Hsia-shih in Chekiang. In the first three of these four examples, putting-out developed fairly rapidly from the first decade of the twentieth century until the mid-i92os. It flourished especially during and immediately after World War I, but declined sharply thereafter. For those people who could no longer rely on agricultural income as a cushion against fluctuating demand, rural weaving of this type was an inherently precarious occupation. It was an industry which produced for a non-local market but lacked the modern organization and financial facilities to respond to inevitable change. The main reason for the much slower growth of cloth than of yarn imports was the extent and strength of the handicraft weaving industry which, as I have stated, was increased by the adoption of machine-made yarn. Relatively little imported cloth was used in rural areas; its principal sale was to the wealthier craftsmen and merchants in the cities and towns. The British consul in Amoy reported in 1886: It is well known already that the many millions of lower-class Chinese toiling and moiling throughout the 18 provinces, and in huge territories beyond them. Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
24
ECONOMIC TRENDS, 1 8 7 O - I 9 I I
do not wear foreign-made cloths, but homespun. Ask a Chinaman why this is, and he tells you that the poor wear suits of native cotton, because such clothing lasts three, four, or five times as long as foreign cloth, because it wears less easily, and because it is much warmer in winter. Why is it warmer? Because, he says, the yarn of which the native fabric is made is quite different from the foreign, and warmer by nature. While, therefore, the well-to-do merchant is wearing out three or four suits of handsomelyfinished_y<**g-/>»,the mechanic, the field-hand, the porter, and the boatman are and must be content with one suit of coarser but, in fact, better material.13 And the combination of a machine-made warp with a handspun weft made an even better cloth to compete with foreign piece goods. l No doubt the common shirtings are being superseded by native cloth woven by hand from imported yarn', the Blackburn mission acknowledged, 'and for this there seems no help.' 14 On the assumption that the average annual raw cotton crop in the decade 1871-80 was 7 million piculs and that it was approximately the same size in 1901-10,1 have attempted to estimate the sources of the yarn and cloth consumed in an average year in these two decades. Table 9 summarizes this estimate. It will be seen immediately that the total consumption of cotton yarn increased with the population growth from the first period to the second. The handicraft spinning of yarn, however, which had a near monopoly in the first period, declined drastically both in absolute terms and as a proportion of the total yarn supply. Output fell by 2.4 million piculs, so that only half as much handspun yarn was produced in an average year in 1901-10 as in 1871-80. From 98 per cent of the total yarn consumed, handspun fell to 42 per cent. Handspun yarn was replaced by both domestic and imported machine-spun products. While in the first period there were as yet no modern spinning mills established in China, by 1901-10 Chinese- and foreign-owned mills in and near the treaty ports produced nearly 18 per cent of the total yarn consumed, in absolute terms an output approximately equal to the entire increase in total yarn consumption from 1871-80 to 1901-10. But far more important was the growth of imported yarn which by 1901-10 was nearly equal in quantity to the handicraft output. From 2 per cent of the total in 1871-80 it had increased to 40 per cent in 1901-10; in absolute terms, it was twenty-four times larger in the later period than in the earlier. Total consumption of cloth, whether measured in yards or in square yards, also increased as the population grew. The output of domestic weaving mills, non-existent in 1871-80, was still barely noticeable in 11
Report on the native cloth in use in the Amqy consular district (Foreign Office, miscellaneous series, 1886, no. 19), 4. '* Blackburn report, F. S. A. Bourne's section, 36.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
HANDICRAFT INDUSTRY
25
1901-10; the great expansion was to come only from the early 1920s. Imported cotton piece goods, while they increased from the first period to the second, did so only to a moderate degree as compared with imported yarn. From n per cent (yards) and 19 per cent (square yards) of the total consumption in an average year in 1871-80 cloth imports grew to 16 and 26 per cent in an average year in 1901-10. The contrast with the quite remarkable increase in yarn imports is entirely due to the fact that the handicraft weaving industry held its own very well in the face of foreign competition from the earlier decade to the later. TABLE 9
Sources of estimated yarn and cloth consumption, I8JI-8O 1. Cotton yarn 1871-80 Domestic mills Imports Handicraft Total
tan —
% 97,451 4,882,381 4,979.83*
1.96 98.04 100.00
and 1901-10
1901-10 tan 1,055,040 2,363,000 2 ,449,7 I 5 5,867,755
%
17-98 40.27 41-75 100.00
2. Cotton cloth 1871-80 0/
/o
sq. yds
0/
—
—
—
11.40 88.60 100.00
376,165,000 1,612,480,220 1,988,645,220
18.92 81.08 100.00
yds
/o
o-57 16.23 83.20 100.00
sq. yds 24,494,4°° 654,200,000 1,849,945,217 2,528,639,617
%
25,200,000 721,400,000 3,699,890,434 4,446,490,434
yds Domestic mills Imports Handicraft Total
414,805,000 3,224,960,440 3>6}9>765,44°
/o
1901-10 Domestic mills Imports Handicraft Total
0.97 25.87 73.16 IOO.OO
Source: Albert Feuerwerker, 'Handicraft and manufactured cotton textiles in China, 1871-1911', Journal of Economic History, 30.2 (June 1970), 338-78.
The relative position of handicraft cloth declined slightly, but the absolute amount of cloth woven increased from 3.2 US billion yards in an average year in 1871-80 to 3.7 US billion yards in an average year in 1901-10. This was a creditable growth which shows the strength of this sector but which would certainly have been larger in the absence of foreign cloth imports. Some of those many peasants who had once engaged in spinning as an ancillary occupation undoubtedly turned to weaving as a replacement for their lost employment, but the most generous comparison of the labour lost by the 2.4 million picul decline in handspun yarn with Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
l6
ECONOMIC TRENDS, 1 8 7 O - 1 9 H
that which could be absorbed by the increment of 600 or 700 million yards of hand woven cloth indicates that only 10 to 20 per cent of the total could have been accommodated. One cannot but conclude that among the peasant households in the regions where cotton spinning had been important, many were unable either to find urban employment for some of their family members or to increase their production and marketing of cash crops. For them the always precarious equilibrium between income and necessary expenditure was profoundly shaken. This certainly is one source of the indictment of the 'incursion of foreign capitalism' to which I referred at the beginning of this section. No other handicraft industry was as important a supplement to rural incomes as cotton spinning and weaving. Although many other handicrafts maintained themselves or expanded in the last half of the nineteenth century, from the undoubted disruption of handicraft spinning the broader and unjustified claim has been advanced that the whole of the traditional handicraft sector was undermined by foreign imports and domestic factory products. There is also a second source which helps to account for the sometimes vitriolic tone of the indictment. Foreign capitalism, it is argued, not only crushed and exploited native handicrafts; it was even more culpable because it short-circuited the normative progression that should have taken place, according to the Chinese reading of Marx on European capitalism, from commodity production by individual households through handicraft workshops to modern factory industry. In China, handicraft workshops and the putting-out system were prevented by foreign capitalism from playing the role they had allegedly played in Europe as the critical intermediary stage to the full-scale development of capitalism. In China the evidence supports the fact although not necessarily the interpretation handicraft workshops appeared in substantial numbers only after modern industries had been brought forth directly or indirectly by foreign investment, and then only as ancillaries to the mechanized factories. Thus both handicraft and modern industry in late nineteenth- and early twentiethcentury China were subservient to foreign capitalism.15 Certain handicraft industries unable to compete with imported products, for example native iron and steel production in Hunan and Kiangsi, had nearly disappeared by the end of the nineteenth century. Others expanded in response to export demand during all or part of the four decades from 1870 to 1911. Raw silk from 1887, when it replaced tea, was China's most important single export. While the proportion of silk to total exports 15
See, for example, Fan Pai-ch'uan, 'Chung-kuo shou-kung-yeh tsai wai-kuo tzu-pen-chu-i ch'in-ju hou ti tsao-yii ho ming-yun' (The fate of Chinese handicraft industry after the incursion of foreign capitalism), LJ-sbib yen-cbiu, 1962. 3, pp. K8-115.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
HANDICRAFT INDUSTRY
27
declined, the actual quantity of silk exported increased throughout the period. Some of the raw silk was reeled in steam filatures, accounting for 40 per cent of the total exported in 1899. This was a relatively late development which became dominant only in the twentieth century, and in any case the steam filatures were hardly one step removed from handicraft workshops. The Commissioner of Customs at Chefoo, Shantung, reported in 1912: The reeling of wild silk for export from the Manchurian cocoon is a comparatively modern industry, introduced in the seventies, since when it has developed considerably. Steam filatures, of which there are now three in existence, have, so far, not proved a success; but the foot-reel of foreign pattern has long been generally adopted, in place of the native hand-reel, with excellent results. There were 40filaturesat work during 1911; they employ over 14,000 hands, and their annual output is 14,000 piculs. No improvement in processes can be recorded." A preliminary reconnaissance of the contemporary literature records at least 415 handicraft reeling filatures, mainly in Kwangtung, Szechwan and Shantung, in the period 1892-1913.17 Silk weaving was performed entirely on handlooms and was a major industry in South and Central China. The exportation of silk piece goods increased fairly steadily from the 1870s until the early 1920s when the competition of rayon fabrics began to be felt. Handicraft tea processing, on the other hand, probably reached its maximum in the mid-1880s, after which Chinese exports of tea which had increased steadily from the opening of the treaty ports declined sharply. This fall resulted largely from the competition of Indian and Ceylon teas produced in colonial circumstances in which, in contrast to China, the exporters had sufficient control over production to maintain quality standards. In the case of tea, and of silk as well, the only overall data available are for exports. There is, however, no indication in contemporary writings that domestic demand declined in the late Ch'ing period, and with the population growth already postulated earlier in this chapter this is unlikely to have been the case. Thus the relative export success of silk and the growth and then decline of tea exports taken together, while they do not suggest a new flourishing of handicraft industry, contradict with equal force any assumption that handicraft was in mortal crisis at the end of the Manchu dynasty. Oil pressing, rice milling, mining by native methods, together with silk weaving among the larger handicrafts, were little affected by imported or domestic manufactured goods in the nineteenth century. Oil pressing in 16 17
China. Inspectorate-General of Customs, Decennial reports ..., 1902-1911, 2.229-50. P'eng Tse-i, Cbung-hio cbin-tai sbou-hmg-ych sbib t^u-Hao, 2.356-66.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
28
ECONOMIC TRENDS, 1 8 7 O - I 9 I I
handicraft workshops in fact expanded rapidly from the 1890s in response to the demand for soy-bean oil by European soap manufacturers and for bean, bean cake and oil in Japan. The use of vegetable oils for lighting was, however, steadily supplanted by kerosene imports from the 1890s. Such minor handicrafts as the production of firecrackers, fans, bamboo furniture, Chinese medicines and agricultural tools - commodities for which there were no import substitutes - were not affected at all. The ginning of cotton for export in handicraft workshops with imported Japanese foot-treadle gins expanded in the port cities. Moreover, several new industries developed, for example, cotton knitting and the production of matches in handicraft workshops. Much of this growth of handicrafts at the turn of the century occurred in the form of handicraft workshops established in urban areas. There were apparently no comparable new developments in the rural areas apart from the putting-out organization of weaving already discussed. A slowly growing rural population, deprived in the course of the nineteenth century of a significant part of its income from cotton spinning, thus, perhaps increasingly, saw the departure of one or more family members for temporary or permanent employment in the workshops, factories and shops of the cities and towns. In 1911, however, this was still a minor trend. MODERN INDUSTRY
Even for the small modern industrial sector which gradually appeared in the last part of the nineteenth century, the quantitative data that can be assembled are at best only gross approximations; information on output before 1912 is, for example, almost completely lacking. This is surprising since these enterprises were located primarily in the treaty ports, were recorded in the English-language press either because of their foreign sponsorship or because of their novelty if the entrepreneurs were Chinese, and are reflected in the documents of the Ch'ing officials who promoted many of them. The most recent and probably the best estimates that have been made suggest that prior to 1895 approximately 103 foreign-owned industrial enterprises, most of them small firms, were inaugurated in China. They and the Chinese-owned firms to be discussed below were often differentiated from handicraft industries only by the fact that they employed some power-driven machinery. In a strict sense manufacturing by foreigners was illegal under the treaties; but it existed nevertheless, for the most part in the Shanghai foreign concessions with a smaller number at other treaty ports. Prior to the 18 80s the Chinese government did not interfere with the establishment of these petty foreign factories. When, however, Li HungCambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
MODERN INDUSTRY
29
chang and other officials began to promote their own manufacturing enterprises, they were able until 1895 to secure Peking's support to prevent foreigners from undertaking such major ventures as cotton textile mills. The estimated number and capital in 1894 of these foreign industrial firms are shown in table 10.18 TABLE
10
Estimated number and capitalisation of foreign-owned industries in China in 1894* Type of
firm
Number
Capital (Ch.J)
Shipyards: construction and repairs Tea processing Machine silk reeling Processing of exports and imports (other than tea and machine silk) Other light manufacturing Electric power and waterworks
12
39 4
3,793,000 1,523,000
Total
88
19,724,000
7 7 '9
4,945.°°°
4,ooo,ooo J.972.2" 1,493,000
* Includes a small number of firms based in Hong Kong Source: Sun Yu-t'ang, comp. Cbung-kuo chin-tai kung-yeh sbib t^u-liao, ti-i-cbi, 1840—189J nien (Source materials on the history of modem industry in China, 1st collection, 1840-1895), 1. 242-7. Admittedly based on incomplete data.
From 1895 to 1913, following the legalization of foreign industry in the treaty ports by the Treaty of Shimonoseki, at least 136 additional foreignowned manufacturing and mining enterprises were set up, with initial capital investments in excess of Ch.$ 100,000. These included 40 joint Sinoforeign firms which for all practical purposes were under foreign control. (All foreign-owned mines regardless of the size of their capitalization have been included in the above figure.) The total initial capitalization of these firms was Ch.$io3,ij3,ooo, and some of their characteristics are shown in table 11. While the establishment of the English, French, German and Russian firms was fairly evenly distributed over the two decades, all but two of the Japanese enterprises were begun in 1904 and later - evidence of Japan's increasing economic penetration of Manchuria after the Russo-Japanese War. Coal mining was the biggest field of investment, and Britain the largest investor. The high proportion of Sino-foreign mining enterprises reflects the influence of the Ch'ing government's mining regulations 18
The currency unit given as Ch. $ in this section is thcyang-juan or 'foreign dollar', commonly the Mexican silver dollar which had considerable currency in the treaty ports. These were gradually supplemented by Chinese silver dollars. Until 1933, b° t r l t n c dollar and the tael were used as units of account. One dollar was valued at approximately 0.72 tads.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
TABLE II
Nationality, industry, location, si%e of initial capitalisation of foreign and Sino-foreign manufacturing and mining firms established in China, Initial capitalization (Ch.$ 1,000)
Number of firms i
2
Foreign
Sino-foreign 1 + 2
Percentage of total
1
2
Foreign
Sino-foreign 1 + 2
Percentage of total
25.465 2,986 6,534 19,829 3,866 2,551 3,028 64,259
24.216 1,609 1.147 6,501 2,782 689 i,95o 38,894
48.16 4.38 7-45 25-53 6-44 3.14 4.83 100.00
Nationality
England France Germany
Japan Russia United States other Total Industry mining engineering and shipyards electric power and water works spinning and weaving foodstuffs other Total
28
9
4 9 35 9
2
37 6
3
12
14
6
2
5 96
2
49 17 8 7
40
136
8
27.21 4.41 8.82 36.03 12.50 5.88 5-15
100.00
49,681 4,515 7,681 26,330 6,648 3,240 4,978 103,153
W O O 2
s
0
t_l
P8 W
Z
\J M >
>-*
00
O I
10
22
32
23-53
18.533
31.436
49,969
48.44
1 M
NO
7
0
7
5-15
2,895
0
2,895
2.81
16
3
19
13-97
10.772
742
11,514
11.16
12
4 5
16
11.76 28.68 16.91 100.00
10,325 15,126 6,608 64.259
2,190 2,022 2.504 38,894
12,515 17,148 9,112 103,153
12.13 16.62 8.83 100.00
34 17 96
6 40
39 23 136
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
•H M
Location Kiangsu Chihli Hupei Shantung Manchuria other Total
33 7 8 5 37 6 96
Size of initial capitalization 2 less than 100,000 32 100,000-249,999 250,000-499,999 30 500,000-999,999 17 1,000,000-4,999,999 14 1 more than 5,000,000 Total 96
11
6 2 1 16
44 13 10
6 53
4
10
40
136
5 15
7 6 5 2 40
7 47 37 23 19
3 .36
32-35 9.56 7-35 4.41 38.97 7-35 100.00
515 34.56 27.21 16.91 '3-97 2.21 100.00
18,501 4.645 3.576 3.5O3 18,680 15.354 64.259
120
5,021 11,623 12,887 20,622 13,986 64.259 .
5,121 1,609 92 5,332 2.431 38,894
23,622 28,954 $,185 3.595 24,012 17.785 103,153
288
408
2,213 3,132 4,088 7,54i 21,632 38,894
7,234 '4,755 16,975 28,163 55,618 103,153
22.90 28.07
5°3 3-49 23.28 17.24 100.00
0.40 7.01 14.30 16.46 27.30 34-53 100.00
Source: Calculated from Wang Ching-yu, comp. Cbung-kuo cbin-tai kung-yeb sbib t%u-liao, ti-erb-cbi, iS)j-ifi4 materials on the history of modern industry in China, 2nd collection, 1895-1914), 1. 2-13.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
Average capital (Ch. $1,000) 58
g
154
O
399 738 1,482 ".873 . 758
a
nien (Source
z 0
32
ECONOMIC TRENDS, 1 8 7 0 - 1 9 1 1
which, prior to 1902, required 30 to 50 per cent of the capital in any mining venture to be provided by Chinese investors. Of the 32 mining enterprises, 9 were British, representing a capital of 01.537,930,000 out of a total in this sector of Ch. $49,969,000 and representing a similar proportion of the total direct British investment in industry. Britain and Japan accounted for all of the firms under 'Engineering and shipyards', and for a very high proportion under each of the other categories, giving them together 86 out of 136 firms and Ch.$76,000,000 out of the Ch.$ 103,000,000 total initial capital. These foreign and Sino-foreign firms were, apart from the coal mines which were located primarily in Chihli and Manchuria, concentrated in Shanghai, the northern treaty ports and Manchuria. From 1906 to 1913, 53 firms including mines were inaugurated in Manchuria, largely by Japanese investors. The average size of the initial capital of the 136 enterprises was Ch.$758,ooo. The data are even less satisfactory about Chinese-owned manufacturing and mining enterprises at the end of the Ch'ing dynasty (other than the joint Sino-foreign firms included above). There were, first, about 19 government-owned arsenals and shipyards, the largest of which were located in Shanghai (established by Tseng Kuo-fan and Li Hung-chang in 1865), Nanking (Li Hung-chang, 1865) and Hanyang (Chang Chih-tung, 1890). In addition to manufacturing munitions and a small number of steamships, the government arsenals were generally equipped with machine shops for the production and repair of tools and parts. A number of them operated training programmes for technicians and, as at the translation bureau of the Shanghai Arsenal, produced compilations and translations which served as textbooks for late-nineteenth-century Chinese students of science and engineering. Secondly, a number of official and semi-official mining, smelting and textile enterprises had been undertaken from as early as 1872. Of these pioneering ventures, the largest and best-known, such as the Kaiping Coal Mines, the Hanyang Ironworks and its coal and iron mines (Hanyehping), Chang Chih-tung's Hupei Textile Mill and Li Hung-chang's Shanghai Cotton Cloth Mill, gradually passed out of the purview of the officials who had sponsored them and into the hands of private Chinese investors, or under foreign control in the case of Kaiping. No satisfactory estimate has been made of the size of the investment represented by the arsenals; and the data concerning the hum-pan (official-managed), kuan-tu sbang-pan (official-supervised and merchant-managed) and kuan-shang ho-pan (official and merchant jointly managed) varieties of official and semi-official firms are not always clearly distinguished from those purporting to describe manufacturing and mining enterprises established by private Chinese Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
MODERN INDUSTRY
33
entrepreneurs {shang-pan, merchant-managed). The distinctions between semi-official and private undertakings of this type were in any case largely formal ones and perhaps of secondary significance as I shall indicate below. A recent search of the contemporary literature has yielded information about 75 manufacturing firms other than the arsenals referred to above (for example, silk reeling, cotton ginning, cotton spinning, flour milling, matches, paper mills) and 33 coal and metal mines established between 1872 and 1894 in which private investment played a greater or lesser role. Many of these were short-lived and often they were small, being distinguished from handicraft workshops only by their employment of some steam or electric power.19 From 1895 Chinese-owned manufacturing enterprises, like the foreignowned, increased in number. But the total growth of the industrial sector in this period of China's early industrialization was minute in absolute terms and modest when compared to the relatively large spurt of new enterprises which began production in the period 1918-22. Ch'ing government efforts, after the disasters of the Sino-Japanese War and the Boxer Uprising, to promote industry by such measures as the creation of a Ministry of Commerce (later reorganized as Agriculture, Industry and Commerce) in 1903 and the promulgation of a 'Company Law' in 1904 may have contributed to this limited expansion. Certainly the burgeoning anti-imperialist nationalism of provincial merchants and gentry was a factor. The principal force behind the establishment of new firms, however, was the manifest profitability of the first few enterprises undertaken in most industrial sectors and especially in the manufacture of consumers' goods to be marketed in the treaty-port areas. Successful foreign- and Chinese-owned firms were earning annual returns on the initial market value of their capital investments of 10 per cent or more in the first decade of the twentieth century. The total market, however, was severely limited by the low level of effective demand in the bulk of rural China. Consequently successive firms entering any particular industry, after the first few pioneers, faced a situation of increasing risk and uncertainty. This risk was reinforced by the fact that many of the pioneer firms had been established on the initiative of important provincial officials, or with the aid of official funds, or with official support in such forms as partial tax exemptions or the monopoly of certain markets. Thus the Shanghai Cotton Cloth Mill (began production 1890, reorganized 1894) and the Hanyehping Coal and Iron Co. (began production 1894, reorganized 1896) were under Sheng Hsuan-huai's 19
Sun Yu-t'ang, comp. Cbimg-kuo cbin-tai kung-yeb sbib t^u-liao, li-i-cbi, 1S40-189/ nien (Source materials on the history of modern industry in China, 1st collection, 1840-1895), 2.1166-9, 1170-3.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
34
ECONOMIC TRENDS,
1870-I9II
direction as kuan-tu shang-pan enterprises and were dependent on the backing of the provincial leaders, Li Hung-chang and Chang Chih-tung respectively. But even such nominally private (shang-pan) enterprises as Chang Chien's Ta-sheng Cotton Mill (began production 1899) and the Chou Hsiieh-hsi's premier Chee Hsin Cement Co. (began production 1907) owed their initial success to the official support which their sponsors, because of their own official ties, were able to obtain - from Chang Chihtung and Liu K'un-i in the former case and from Yuan Shih-k'ai for Chee Hsin. Given a limited market, the lack of a modern banking system which could systematically channel savings into industrial investment, a central government whose financial resources were severely limited, and competition from imported goods and foreign-owned factories in China, it is perhaps not surprising that some regional officials and the entrepreneurs who were associated with them attempted to establish limited but protected industrial empires for their mutual profit. Few purely private ventures could expect success. The link between economic success and political power, which had characterized such monopolies as that of the Cohong or the salt merchants of an earlier period and was manifest again in Kuomintang China in the 1930s and 1940s, was not broken during the era of China's early industrialization. Between 1895 and 1913, according to a recent estimate, at least 549 Chinese-owned private and semi-official manufacturing and mining enterprises using mechanical power were inaugurated. Their total initial capitalization was Ch.$i2o,288,ooo. This estimate excludes arsenals, mints and also apparently a relatively small number of purely official undertakings. Some of the characteristics of these 549 firms, which include all with an initial capital of Ch.$ 10,000 or more for which data could be found and about which there is more information than for the enterprises started before 1895, are given in tables 12-14. The peak years for the establishment of modern industry during the two decades surveyed were 1905-8. In this four-year period, 238 firms with a total initial capitalization of Ch. $61,219,000 began operation. Much of the machinery installed came from abroad, which is reflected in the fact that annual imports of tools and machinery in 1905-8 were more than double the annual value in 1895-1904. Machinery imports continued to grow after 1908, but the number of new enterprises opened fell sharply until the much larger industrialization spurt of 1918-22. These trends perhaps suggest increased capital investment in the privileged establishedfirmscombined with an increasing difficulty in entering the limited market for new firms. They may also reflect a shift of venture capital to provincial railway Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
MODERN
35
INDUSTRY
projects inspired by the nationalist 'rights recovery' activities of the last years of the dynasty. TABLE 12
Number and initial capital of Chinese-owned manufacturing and mining enterprises inaugurated i8pj-ipij, by industry Initial Average Number of Percentage capital Percentage capital enterprises of total (Ch.J 1,000) of total (Ch.J 1,000)
Industry Coal mining Metal mining and smelting Metal working Public utilities (water and electricity) Cement Bricks, tiles Pottery Glass Matches Candles, soap Cotton ginning Cotton spinning Cotton weaving and dyeing Silk reeling Wool weaving Hemp weaving Other weaving Rice milling Flour milling Oil pressing Cigarettes, tobacco Other foodstuffs Paper Printing Leather tanning Other Total
12.06 6.29 2.32
345
21,600 2,620
17.96
470
2.18
651
O.54
772 3.429 3.444 805 280
O.64 2.85
873 543 no 343
2.86
132
0.67
45 93
14,508
42
7-65.
39
7.10
7.565
15
2-73
2,787
46
8.38 0.55 2.19 1.28 1.82
3 12
7 10
26 18
4-74
3
0.55
19 27
4.92
97 7
17.67 1.28
4
°-73
6 9 53
1.09 1.64 9.65
3.28
3.46
28
5.10
20
3.64
15 14
6
2-73 2-55 1.09
11 12
2.00 2.19
549
100.00
0.23
194 186
5.215
8.69 1.05 9.63 4-34
1,000 732 1,012
0.83 0.61 0.84
8,622
7-17
"3 163
4.752 1.378
3-95
170
I.IJ
69
3,111
2.59
207
5.929 1,160 4,608 1,009 120,288
4-93
424 193 419
io.454 1,261 11,584
0.97
3.83
55° 47 119
745 250 122
0.84
84
100.00
219
Source: Calculated from Wang Ching-yu, Chung-kuo cbin-tai kung-yeh tbih l^u-liao, 2. 869-920.
In both numbers and initial capital the bulk of these new industries was concentrated in such light manufacturing fields as textiles (160 firms or 29.14 per cent of the total, with a capitalization of Ch.$ 3 0,246,000 or 25.14 per cent of the total) and the processing of foodstuffs (125 firms or 22.76 per cent; Qi.$ 18,875,000 o r 15-69 per cent). Mines accounted for 14.75 per cent of the firms and 18.3 5 per cent of the initial capitalization. Their relative importance reflects again the considerable success of the lateCh'ing 'rights recovery movement' which accomplished the cancellation of a substantial number of foreign mining concessions during the first decade of the twentieth century, although sometimes at the price of clearly
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
}6
ECONOMIC TRENDS, 1 8 7 0 - I 9 I I
excessive compensation payments. The 46 electric power plants or waterworks were established in the larger cities in all the provinces of China proper with the exception of Shensi, Kwangsi and Kweichow. They varied greatly in size and were most often to be found in the treaty port cities of the Yangtze valley and south-east coastal provinces. TABLE 15
Number and initial capital of Chinese-owned manufacturing and mining enterprises inaugurated X89J-1913, by location Percentage Number of enterprises
Location Anhwei Chekiang Chihli (other than Tientsin) Tientsin Fukien Honan Hunan Hupei (other than Wuhan) Wuhan Kiangsi Kiangsu (other than Shanghai) Shanghai Kwangsi Kwangtung (other than Canton) Canton Kweichow Manchuria Shansi Shantung Shensi Szechwan Yunnan Other Total
18 29
34 17
'9 12 24
9 28
'3
7° 83 5 68 16 1
44 10 20 I
19
5 4 549
of total 3.28 5.28 6.19 3.10 3.46 2.19 4-37 1.64 5.10 i-37 12.75 15.12 0.91 12.39 2.91 0.18 8.01 1.82 3.64 0.18 3.46 0.91 0.73 100.00
Initial capital (Ch.Ji.ooo) 1,868 4.346 ".951
4."9
1,461 1,890 3,968 1.937 17,240 2.383 13.51° 23.879 1.424 5.038 5.791 79 4.922 3.038 4,614 405
2,248 1,671 2,406 120,288
Percentage of total '•55 3.61 9-94 3-5i
1.21 1-57 3-3» 1.61 14-33 1.98 11.23 19.85 1.18
4.19 4.81 0.07 4.09 2-53 3.84 0.34 1.87 1.39 2.00 100.00
Source: Same as table 12.
With the exceptions of silk reeling, which after 1900 was increasingly performed in steam filatures, iron mining at Ta-yeh for export to Japan, and to a lesser extent oil pressing, these Chinese-owned modern industries were not engaged in processing raw materials for export. Only three modern cotton ginning plants, for example, are recorded. Much export processing continued to be primarily a handicraft industry, although supplemented by the output of foreign-owned processing plants. Cotton weaving and dyeing, even in the urban areas, remained also at the handiCambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
MODERN INDUSTRY
37
craft stage or were performed in small plants with minimal powermachinery in the vicinity of the new cotton spinning mills. Many of these new manufacturing enterprises were, in fact, small. Of the 160 firms in the textile line, 97 were steam silk filatures of which 54 were very small plants located in Kwangtung. The 21 filatures located in Shanghai were each several times larger than those in the south, but the average initial investment for all 97 was only Ch.$ 119,000. Of the 549 enterprises, 303 had initial capitals of less than Ch.$ioo,ooo. The average capitalization of the remaining 246 Chinese-owned firms (capitalized at Ch.$ 100,000 and over) was Ch. $43 2,000 compared with an average investment of Ch.$7j8,ooo for the 136 foreign and Sino-foreign enterprises in table 11. TABLE 14
Initial capitalisation of Chinese-owned manufacturing and mining enterprises, inaugurated 189J-1913 Size of initia 1 capitalization (Ch.$)
Percentage Initial Percentage Average Number of of capital of capital enterprises total (Ch.Ji.ooo) total (Ch.$i,ooo)
10,000- 49,999 50,000- 99,999 100,000-249,999 250,000-499,999 500,000-999,999 1,000,000 and over Total
214
89 104
85 40 17
549
38.98 16.21 18.94 15.48 7-29 3.10 100.00
5.899 7.OJ2
I7.73I 29,901 27,980 3 1 .7 2 5 120,288
4.90 5.86 14.74 24.86 23.26 26.37 100.00
28
79 170
35* 700
1,866 219
Source: Wang Ching-yii, Modern industry, 2. 1041.
Chinese-owned enterprises could of course locate in the interior, if they wished, as well as in Shanghai and other treaty ports. Of 468 non-mining enterprises, 239 were located in treaty-port cities and 229 in places other than treaty ports. As the foreign-owned non-mining firms were all located in the treaty ports, and marketed their products primarily in these places, the existence of Chinese firms in inland locations suggests that there was some degree of complementary as well as competition between the markets served by foreign industries in China and Chinese-owned enterprises. However, Chinese-owned modern manufacturing firms in the treaty ports had much larger initial capitalization and average size than the inland firms, as table 15 indicates. The four cities of Shanghai, Wuhan, Tientsin and Canton, as may be seen from tables 13 and 15, were the most important manufacturing centres. Shanghai, for example, led in at least the following Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
38
ECONOMIC TRENDS,
187O-I9II
industries: metal working, cotton textiles, silk reeling, flour milling, oil pressing, printing, candles and soap. The foregoing data are of value only in suggesting gross trends. It is likely that some firms were either omitted or counted more than once, that a proportion of those undertaken failed during the period under consideration, and that the initial capital may have been overestimated in some cases (or quickly increased in others). It would therefore be misleading to take a simple sum of the number of firms and the magnitude of their capitals under the several categories discussed above as the absolute magnitude of China's nineteenth-century industrialization. The best that can be said is that by the end of the Ch'ing dynasty there were perhaps 500-600 foreign and Chinese mining and manufacturing enterprises employing mechanical power, and that the total capitalization of these firms was in the vicinity of Ch. $200,000,000. TABLE 15
Number and initial capitalisation of treaty-port and inland Chineseowned manufacturing firms, Number
Inland enterprises Treaty-port enterprises Shanghai, Wuhan, Tientsin, Canton Other treaty ports Total
48.93 51.07
229 2
39 144
95 468
Percentage Initial Percentage Average of capital of capital total (Ch.Ji.ooo) total (Ch.Ji.ooo)
3°-77 20.30 100.00
33.158 65.057 51,129 13,928 98,215
33-76 66.24 52.06 14.18 100.00
145 272
355 147 210
Source: Same as table 12.
Among these firms, it is estimated that 116 Chinese-owned enterprises and 40 foreign-owned employed 500 or more workers each, with a total of 130,985 in the former and 109,410 in the latter. The 500 employee cut-off point is arbitrary, of course, but if it is adopted these 240,395 workers may be considered the extent of the 'modern' labour force in China in the period 1900-10. Some part of the investment in the nineteenth-century foreign factories was held by Chinese shareholders resident in the treaty ports, principally compradors of foreign trading firms or merchants dealing in silk, tea and imported yarn and doth. This was especially true of the foreign-owned coastal and riverine steamship lines and of banks, insurance companies and goods warehouses which are not included in the data on manufacturing firms in table 10. But it was also the case in silk reeling, electric light and Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
MODERN INDUSTRY
39
power utilities and, after 1895, in the newly established cotton textile mills. One recent study has identified 130 large Chinese shareholders who had invested in 44 foreign firms between i860 and 1900.20 Another sample, for 1896-1910, lists 78 Chinese investors, individuals and firms, in 17 foreignowned factories mainly in Shanghai. Of these firms, 6 were cotton mills and 2 flour mills.21 The total size of the investment by Chinese in foreign enterprises reflected in these two samples cannot be estimated. But such investment does testify to the availability of funds (often the profits of participation in foreign trade) in the treaty ports if there were prospects of substantial profits. The special status of foreigners and their concessions in the treaty ports provided the needed assurance. When Chinese entrepreneurs could give similar guarantees of potential profit, some of those who had invested in foreign firms also put their 'comprador capital' into Chinese-owned ventures. The special privileges of the kuan-tu shang-pan enterprises, and of others formally in the private sector but dependent in varying degrees on official favours, were intended to provide precisely this assurance. But, as I have already stated, the overall prospects for modern manufacturing industry in late-Ch'ing China were limited. The institutions - a modern banking system in particular - for channelling non-treaty-port savings into industry did not exist. The central government was ideologically and politically incapable of establishing and guaranteeing the framework of legal, commercial and educational institutions without which modern enterprise could not thrive. Nor was it able, in the absence of tariff autonomy and in view of the special privileges foreigners had exacted, to provide protection for 'infant' Chinese-owned firms against competition from imports and the products of foreign firms in China. And, above all, it would have required a basic reorganization of the agricultural sector to provide the raw materials for industrial growth, food for an expanded urban population, and a sufficient market for increased output. The latenineteenth-century Chinese economy was admittedly poor: the technology of Europe's industrial revolution was just beginning to appear in the coastal cities, and the rural population lived with an increasingly adverse man-land ratio and an agricultural technology which over the centuries had been exploited to the limits of its potential. But it was not an absolute shortage of capital which constrained China's early industrial development. 20
21
Wang Ching-yii, 'Shih-chiu shih-chi wai-kuo ch'in Hua ch'i-yeh chung ti Hua-shang fu-ku h u o t u n g ' (Investment by Chinese merchants in the foreign firms which invaded China in the nineteenth century), U-sbibycn-cbiu, 1965. 4, pp. 39-74. Wang Ching-yii, comp. Chung-kuo cbin-tai kung-yeb ibib l^u-liao, ti-erb chi, 189J-1914 men (Source materials on the history of modern industry in China, 2nd collection, 1895-1914), 2.1065.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
40
ECONOMIC TRENDS, 1 8 7 0 - I 9 I I
As of 1912, manufacturing firms registered with the Ministry of Agriculture and Commerce reported a total capitalization of Ch.$ 5 4,804,000. In the same year, traditional banks {ch'ien-chuang, 'money shops') and pawnshops registered with the ministry were capitalized at a total of Ch. $164,854,000." The resources of the economy, limited as they were, remained sterilized in traditional vessels which only fundamental political change could shatter. DOMESTIC AND FOREIGN COMMERCE
The economy of late-Ch'ing China was, at its given level of technology, characterized by a high degree of commercial development. Goods and traders moved extensively throughout the country and, to a limited extent, the domestic economy had developed links with the world market. At the most basic level, the peasants of every rural area bought and sold regularly at the periodic markets of the standard market towns which served their groups of villages. Here such agricultural surplus as they produced and the products of handicraft manufacture were exchanged for other local commodities or for goods manufactured in the treaty-port cities or imported from abroad which, in small quantities, had flowed down through successive levels of the marketing system to the final consumer. These thousands of basic markets, of which Skinner estimates there were 63,000 early in the twentieth century,23 were linked in turn to two higher level markets intermediate and central - and ultimately to the great trading cities of the coast such as Tientsin, Shanghai and Canton. At each level the markets were populated by itinerant pedlars, local merchants and agents offirmsfrom all markets except the basic ones. At its upper levels - the central markets and above - the marketing system interpenetrated with the administrative hierarchy of the Ch'ing government. The rural central markets and the urban city and regional markets were the loci of the officially regulated merchant middlemen and the merchant guilds {ya-hang) through whom the bureaucratic elite regulated and taxed the commerce of the empire. Also in these upper markets were found the exchange banks (often operated by families from Shansi province and hence known as 'Shansi banks') through whose drafts large sums were transferred from one upper level market to another. Other types of 'native banks', such as the money shops {ch'ien-chuang) which advanced funds to local merchants - usually on personal security and occasionally on the security of designated goods - and also changed money from one local "Ibid. 2.1017. " G. William Skinner, 'Marketing and social structure in rural China, part 11', JAS, 24.2 (February 1965) 227.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
DOMESTIC AND FOREIGN COMMERCE
41
currency standard to another, were also located in the upper level markets. In the basic markets, barter was not unknown and the financial institutions were limited to the local moneylender and the petty 'shroff' or moneychanger. The discreteness of the 63,000 rural basic markets and the structure of the marketing hierarchy as a whole were closely related to the degree of development of the means of transportation. The upper level markets were located on or at the termini of the principal water and, in North China, overland routes by which goods and persons were transported, while the basic markets were situated on the progressively less accessible feeder trails and waterways. The intricate and highly developed periodic marketing structure continued to nourish not only in late nineteenth-century China but well into the twentieth century as well, as a result of the relative absence of two critical changes: (1) improved transportation at the local level, which would make intermediate and higher level markets as easily available to the peasant as his traditional basic market; and (2) a linking of the higher level markets to industrial centres within and outside China by superior steamship and railway communications with a consequent increase in the inflow and outflow of commodities, which in turn would decrease the self-sufficiency of the households which traded at the basic markets. Certainly the bulk, perhaps as much as three-quarters, of all the trade in nineteenth-century China consisted of small-scale local trade. This was confined to the basic and intermediate market levels by high transport costs, by the profits of multitudinous middlemen at each successive level of the marketing system, and to some extent too by the relative self-sufficiency in basic grains of much of rural China. 'For the most part, trade takes to the water when it can', the Commissioner of Customs at Lungchow noted in 1892.2* This observation was applicable both to short-haul grain shipments within major producing regions (for example, from the Hunan districts bordering the Tungting Lake to the major markets of Hsiang-t'an or Changsha) and to the thousandmile trip from the rice surplus province of Hunan to the deficit regions in the Yangtze Delta. Nevertheless the total amount of long-distance shipping of such a bulky, low-priced commodity as grain was very small. Even in the early twentieth century, the total freight and marketing cost of bringing rice by junk from Anhwei to Shanghai was almost double the original price of the rice in the Anhwei village where it was produced.25 The long24 15
China. Inspectorate-General of Customs, Decennial reports ..., 1882-1891, 661. Amano Motonosuke, Cbugoku nog/5 no sbo mondai (Problems of Chinese agriculture), 2.241-7, gives a meticulously detailed account of each item of cost from Anhwei to Shanghai.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
ECONOMIC TRENDS,
1870-I9II
« = Major land routes — — Waterways Coastal junk traffic *=; Porterage over pass •
.
,
• 5°01"" 300 miles
MAP. 3 Trade routes
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
DOMESTIC AND FOREIGN COMMERCE
43
distance trade - between higher level markets, but of course originating or terminating ultimately at the basic level - consisted for the most part of commodities with a relatively high value per ton whose production was favoured by the resources or climate of a particular region: raw cotton and cotton textiles from Kiangnan; salt from the brine wells of Szechwan or the coastal evaporating pans of Kiangsu; opium from Yunnan, Kweichow and Szechwan; sugar from Kwangtung and Fukien; copper and lead from Yunnan;'teas from the middle and lower Yangtze valley; and silk from Chekiang, Kiangsu, Kwangtung and Szechwan. These products could bear the high freight and handling markup because of their higher values in relation to weight - in the case of tea for example, which was worth perhaps ten times as much per picul as an equivalent weight of rice, this might be 15 or 20 per cent between Anhwei and Shanghai. There were no alternative sources of supply, and they were consumed in disproportionate amounts by the wealthier residents (the gentry) of the towns and cities for whom the question of price was relatively less important. In Central and South China in particular the major rivers and their branches and tributaries were the arteries and capillaries of commerce. A twentieth-century estimate, which appears applicable to the late Ch'ing as well, suggests that there were at least 4,000 miles of waterways suitable to steamer traffic, 15,000 miles more which could be navigated by steam launches, and an additional 27,000 miles open to 'native craft' of all kinds. Perhaps 25,000 miles of Yangtze waterways were ultimately navigable from Shanghai - by ocean steamer to Hankow, then by light-draft steamer to Ichang where goods were repacked and loaded on to junks, thence through the Yangtze rapids with the aid of trackers to Chungking;26 from Chungking on progressively smaller junks via the upper Yangtze and its tributaries to northern Szechwan and to Kweichow, and by stream and porter into Yunnan. In the smallest streams the vessels may have been no more than bamboo rafts turned up at the bows; or maybe they were flatbottomed skiffs, drawing perhaps nine inches of water fully loaded, whose crewmen were often in the water lifting and shoving. While the West River from Canton was navigable by steamer only to Wuchow on the Kwangsi border, thousands of junks on that stream and its tributaries carried goods further into and out of Kwangsi, Kweichow and Yunnan. A third major trade route (by which teas and silks were brought to Canton before the opening of Shanghai) proceeded via the North River from Canton, by porter over the Cheling or Meiling passes in the Nan-ling Mountains to the headwaters of the Hsiang and Kan rivers in Hunan and 16
Chungking was first reached by small steamship in 1898. Regular steamer service began in 1908.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
44
ECONOMIC TRENDS, 1 8 7 O - I 9 I I
Kiangsi respectively, and then through the Tungting and Poyang lakes to the Yangtze. The necessity for overland porterage over the Nan-ling Mountains and the limited hinterlands of Ningpo, Foochow and Amoy favoured the development of Shanghai as the major foreign trade port, and the Yangtze as the principal route into the interior of China. From Hankow, junks could proceed north-westward on the Han River into Shensi. To some extent also the Grand Canal continued to link the lower Yangtze valley with the North China plain. But North China was much less served with navigable waterways than the south. Here the largewheeled North China carts and pack animals moved over dust and mud tracks, which constant traffic in the loess regions of Honan, Shansi and Shensi had sometimes cut down ten or more feet below the surface of the surrounding countryside. The major traditional trade routes from Peking followed a difficult course overland to Shansi, and via Kalgan across Mongolia to Kiakhta on the Russian border, with branches westward to Shensi and Kansu. Where water routes were not available, as in much of North China, the movement of goods was slow and expensive.27 Overland freight costs by cart, wheelbarrow, pack animal or on the backs of porters are estimated to have been two to five times higher per ton mile than freight charges by junk. The nineteenth-century commercial system, in spite of its high level of traditional development, was of course not yet a 'modern' market economy. While a few high-value commodities, as I have indicated, might have been carried by water throughout the empire, it would be incorrect to speak of a national market even for these. Commerce tended to be contained within a large number of hierarchically arranged cells, as a result of friction created by certain factors. These were a bimetallic silver-copper standard with multiple local currencies, high-cost transportation (in money and time), the comparative rarity of credit advances against commodities, the absence of a commercial banking system for the mutual clearing of indebtedness, and the omnipresence of numerous petty middlemen with vested interests in the traditional structure of trade. Each cell bustled with petty commerce and, to use Sol Tax's phrase, 'penny capitalism', but they were connected only by a traffic of semi-luxury goods and the outflow of silver and some grains in the form of taxes to the administrative hierarchy above. " The distribution of stations on official routes suggests that most official travel was by horse overland. For the travel of government officials the Ch'ing statutes provided for the maintenance of 1,634 land stations, 92 water stations and 54 land and water stations throughout the empire. At each stage in the journey these stations provided horses, carts, sedan chairs or boats as needed, as well as lodging and food. Official documents were carried overland among some 15,000 postal stations. See Kono Michihiro, 'Shindai Santosho no kansei rikujo kotsuro' (Official overland communication routes in Shantung in the Ch'ing dynasty), Sbirin, 33.3 (May 1950) 317-36.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
DOMESTIC AND FOREIGN COMMERCE
45
Foreign observers in the second half of the nineteenth century, after the establishment of the likin tax in 1853 to finance the suppression of the Taiping rebels, were wont to see this levy on internal trade (which admittedly was sometimes capriciously administered) as the principal obstacle to their own trade and to the commercial integration of China.28 But compared with freight and handling markups of 15 to 100 per cent, it appears unlikely that the common likin rate of 2 per cent at each tax station had more than a small effect on the total amount and direction of internal trade. The British, as I have stated earlier, found it difficult to sell Lancashire cloth in the interior of China because domestic handicraft weaving offered effective competition. The marketing structure and size of China's domestic commerce were constrained not primarily by burdensome official exactions, but by the limitations of pre-modern transportation and communications. By the end of the Manchu dynasty in 1911, there was a small but noticeable change in the commercial system at its outer fringes. While, as I shall argue, it remained essentially intact, it is, after all, common sense that the late-Ch'ing economy was influenced by the progressive opening of treaty ports and the expansion of foreign trade. The trade data compiled by the foreign-administered maritime customs are almost the only substantial long-term historical statistics for modern China. But even these generally excellent data have shortcomings. To 1887, imports from Hong Kong were not included, and free on board and cost, insurance and freight values were not used so that export values were understated while imports were overstated. Moreover, the trade was measured in silver haikwan (maritime customs) taels in an era when silver was steadily declining in terms of gold with the result that the recorded value of the trade was inflated as compared with its gold value or its actual quantity. Table 16 presents values in current haikwan taels and index numbers of China's foreign trade for the period 1870-1911.
In current haikwan taels the total volume of trade increased more than sevenfold from 1870 to 1911. As already indicated, silver values inflate the actual growth of trade: in terms of quantity, imports increased 312 per cent and exports 307 per cent during these four decades. The growth of total trade measured in current values was relatively slow until the 1890s, with the most rapid increase coming in the first decade of the twentieth century. The quantity indices indicate that the growth of imports was fairly steady 18
The Chinese, of course, were irritated by the fact that foreign goods could, to a degree, escape the likin if covered by 'transit passes' obtained by payment of half of the regular import duty. It should be remembered, however, that these passes were valid only so long as the goods remained in their original packaging and were transported to the destination stated on the pass. In effect, it was possible that the tax on goods under pass was only delayed until they reached the final consumer.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
ON
TABLE l6
Values and index numbers of China's foreign trade, {All indices: 191} = 106) Value in current haikwan taels (i.ooo) Net imports 1870 1871 1872 1873 1874 1875 1876 1877 1878 1879 1880 1881 1882 1883 1884 1885 1886 1887 1888
63.693 70,103 67.317 66,637 64,361 67,803 70,270 70,804 82,227
79.293 91,911 77.715 73.568 72,76l 88,200 87,479 102,264 124,783
Exports
Imports
Trade balance
Current values
118,988
-
12.2 14.1 14.6 14.0 13-5 14.0 15-5 14.5 14.2 15.9 16.1 16.8 14.9 14.8 14.4 15-7 16.9 19-3 22.3
136,956
80,851 64,445 67,172 72,281
151,121 140,679 139.976 154,508
70,198 67,148 65,006 77.2O7 85,860 92,401
Indices of quantity
Total
66,853 75.288 69.451 66,713 68,913
77,884 71,453 67,337
Indices of value of total trade
142,605 136,088
i3l»°74 136,716
157.177 163,364 145,052 143,766 139.909 153,206 164,686 188,124 217,184
8,398
+ 7,97i + 2,814 + 2,352
+ i,no + -
10,581 5,789 3.632 9.946 1,409 20,458 10,378 3.370 5.6i3 23,194 10,272
-
16,404 32,382
'Real' values* — — —
20.7 21.0 21.6 21.9 20.5 22.0 23-7 21-3 22.0 21.1 23.I 24.2 28.4 34-3
25.9 28.1 27-9 27-3 3i-5 33.8 36.3 36.1 34-9 40.8 36.2 40.8 36.4 35-o 34-5 40.5 55-3 41.6 50.3
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
Exports 33-3 39-4 43-3 39-i 40.1 42.2 42.8 40.8 41.4 47-2 43-5 45-9 47.2 50.6 47.6 54-2 41.2 43.6
Net barter terms of trade (import prices/ export prices) 76.5 75-9 71.1 70.8 62.8 65.3 54-4 65.2 66.3 63.9 69.7 72.8 76.7 75-i 83.6 83.3 91.4 62.4 62.7
W D O
z o g o
w z
00
-4
o I tH
1889 1890 1891 1892 l8
93
1894 1895 1896 1897 1898 1899 1900 1901 1902 1903 1904 1905 1906 1907 1908 1909 1910 1911
110,884 127,093 134,004 I35,ioi 151,363 162,103
96,948
207,832
»3,936
87.144 100,948
214,237 234.952 237,685
39,949 33.056
21-3 22.0 24.1
32,517
24.4
267,995 290,208
34,73' 33,998
27-5 29.8
102,584 116,632 128,105
171.697 202,590 202,829
143.293 131,081
314,990
28,404
32.4
333,67'
163,501
366,330
7i,5O9 39.328
209,579
i59.o}7 195.785
368,616
5O.542
264,748
68,963
211,070
158,997
460,533 370,067
34-3 37.6 37-9 47-3
52,073
38.0
169.657 214,182
437,96o
98,646
45-o
529,546
101,182
54-5
326,739 344,061 447,101
214,352
541,091
112,387
239.487 227,888
IO4,574 219,213
410,270
236,457
583,548 674,989 646,727
416,401
264,381 276,660
680,782
338,993
757,i5i
380,833
843,798
"7,845 79,i65 82,132
55.6 59-9 69.3 66.4 69.9 68.9 77.8 86.7
377.338
848,842
94,166
87.2
268,303 315.364
394.505 418,158 462,965 471.504
671,165
173,813 152,020
31.4 32.4 35-5 34-9 38.8 40.3 45.6 47.6 47.6 45-' 50.9 43-7 55-5 56.1 54-o 60.6 62.5 66.4 67.2 62.7 70.1 85.0 82.3
44.0 54.8 60.8 59-9 59-4 45-3 45.8 53-2 49-7 5'-3 69.2 49-5 62.5 70.9 65.1 69.2 96.6 95-3 88.7 72-7 77-' 79.2 80.9
45.2 42.0 47-9 49-8 57-2 60.1 66.3 56.4 61.6 63-4 62.5 54-9 59.8 65.1 59.8 64.0 62.5 64.6 67.1 73.0 92.9 102.9 102.1
63.0 59.8 56.1 58.8 67.0 91.1 96.4 91.0 85-7 91.2 68.5 82.3
85.4 82.6 85.5 94.1 89.8 83.2 84.3
101.4 105.1 111.7 111.7
* Total trade in current values divided by index of wholesale prices Sources: Yang Tuan-liu, Statistics of China's foreign trade, tables 1-3; Nankai Institute of Economics, Nankai index numbers, $) 37-8; and Chi-ming Hou, Foreign investment and economic development in China, 1840—1937, 194-8, for pre-1904 terms of trade.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
a w H
n z o
o z o o s s w n w
48
ECONOMIC TRENDS, 1 8 7 0 - I 9 I I
(the great spurt in 1905-6 was a direct consequence of the Russo-Japanese War and should be discounted) while exports, which were relatively stationary in the 1890s, increased rapidly in the last few years of the dynasty. Bean and bean product shipments, primarily from Manchuria, account for much of this export spurt. If the pre-1888 trade data are adjusted to measure imports at cost, insurance and freight values and exports at free on board values, and an allowance is made for opium and others 'smuggled' from Hong Kong, China's foreign trade probably showed an export surplus from 1870 to 1887. From 1888 to 1900, imports moderately exceeded exports by an annual average of 40,876,000 haikwan taels. After 1900, the import excess became substantially larger, the average annual excess for 1901-11 growing to 121,377,000 haikwan taels. Part of this adverse trade balance was offset by remittances homeward by overseas Chinese, and up to 1900 by a small net export of gold and silver. The remainder was financed by an inflow of capital - including investment in industry after 1895 as described above, and loans to the Ch'ing government which I shall discuss later. Opium, mainly from India, ranked as the most important single Chinese import until 1890 when it was surpassed by cotton piece goods. Cotton cloth and yarn together after 1890 accounted for about one-third of China's imports by value. The cotton trade and its effect on the Chinese economy have already been discussed in connection with the handicraft industry. Cereals and other foodstuffs were imported largely to supply the large coastal cities in quantities which appear to have fluctuated with localized harvest supply conditions rather than the general quality of the harvest; this trade reflects both the growth of these cities and the heavy transportation and marketing costs for domestic grains grown outside their immediate hinterlands. The percentage distribution of China's principal imports is given in table 17, and exports are shown in table 18. Silk and tea, which had been China's most important exports before the Treaty of Nanking, continued to occupy this position until the end of the Ch'ing dynasty. Their combined relative position in the export trade was, however, a diminishing one. Tea exports fell largely because of the inability of exporters in China to enforce quality standards among producers and middlemen in the face of growing Indian and Japanese competition. While the large absolute quantities of silk piece goods exported suggest the continued strength of a major rural handicraft industry, the new importance of bean oil, leather, flour, egg and egg products, and to a lesser extent ginned cotton exports, reflects the establishment from the turn of the century of numerous small handicraft workshops in the larger and medium-sized urban centres. Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
TABLE 17
Percentage distribution of China's principal imports, 18J0-1910 Cotton piece Total value Total Opium goods (HK taels 1,000]I % % % 1870 i88o 1890 1900 1910
63.693 79.293 "7.093 211,070 462,965
100 100 100 100 100
43.0$ 39.3 19.J 14.8 12.0
28.0 24.9 20.2 21.5 14.7
Metals Cotton yarn % 3.0 4.6 15.3 14.3 13.6
Cereals, Sugar flour 0/ % /o O.J 0.04
and Tobacco /o
Coal
Kerosene minerals
0/
/o
/o
0.09
7.0
0.4 0.9 3.0
— — — 0.5
7-7
4.8
2.0
O.I
9.6
1.2
1.6 3.1 1.8
/o
— — 3-2 6.6 4-7
5-8 5-5 5-7 4.7 4-3
Railwayf materials,, All other Machinery* vehicles 0/ /o % %
— — 0.3 0.7 i-5
— — — — 3.8
1997* 24.0 23-7 23.8 29.1
Total Total value (HK taels 1,000) % 1870 1880 1890 1900 1910
55.295 77,884 87.144 158.997 380,833
100 100 100 100 100
Tea % 49.9 45.9 30.6 16.0 9.4
38.8 38.0 33.9 30.4 25.4
Seeds, /o
Beans %
1.2
1.2
O.I
0.2
O.6 2-5
0.4
8.4
5.6
oil
1-9
Hides, leather, skins %
Raw cotton 0/ /o
Coal 0/ /o
Z Eggs, egg products 0/ /o
O-5 0.5 1.4
0.2
4-3 5-3
6.2
3-4 7-4
0.4 1.6 1.9 2.5
— — —
— — —
I.J
1.1
Sources: Yang Tuan-liu and Hou Hou-p'ei et at., Statistics of China's foreign trade, table 4, pp. 4-14, table 8, pp. 32-42; Yu-kwei Cheng, Foreign trade, 19.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
>
pa W
i8jo-iyio
Wool 0/ /o
H
a0•a
TABLE l 8
Silk, silk goods %
s
M
z
% Estimated t Not recorded separately before 1903 * Not recorded separately before 1886 Sources: Yang Tuan-liu, Statistics of China'sforeign trade, , table 5, PP- 15-25. table 9, pp. 43-8; Yu-kwei Cheng, Foreign trade and industrial development of China, 19.
Percentage distribution of China's principal exports,
0 0
O
All Flour 0/ /o
other 0/ /o
0.3
8.1
0.2
14.J 27.8 36.0 32.0
0.3 0.8 1.4
w 0
a
JO
ECONOMIC T R E N D S ,
187O-I9II
Hong Kong's large nominal share in China's foreign trade, combined with the lack of data before 1932 on goods shipped from and to Hong Kong, prevent an accurate statement of the proportions of trade with each foreign country. Table 19 presents an unadjusted percentage distribution of China's foreign trade for selected years, 1871-1911, while table 20 represents H. B. Morse's estimate for the Imperial Maritime Customs of the distribution of trade, which treats Hong Kong as a Chinese port and apportions its imports and exports among the several major trading countries. The United Kingdom was China's most important trading partner until the end of the nineteenth century - and on into the twentieth century if the entire British empire is considered. British predominance in the import trade is most notable, and as already indicated is accounted for by cotton piece goods from Lancashire and yarn and opium from India. The total British share, while it remained the largest, was a declining one. From the 1890s Japanese trade, spurred on by the provisions of the Shimonoseki Treaty and by Japan's post-190 j role in Manchuria, grew rapidly. The American and Russian shares in China's trade were also in general increasing ones. Two general observations about the foreign trade which has just been described are pertinent here. First, although it was a growing commerce, as late as 1913 China's world trade per head of population (in US dollars: imports, $0.94; exports, $0.67; total, $1.61) was the lowest of eighty-three countries for which League of Nations data were compiled. It is possible that the 1913 population of China was overstated in these estimates; but even in the unlikely case that per capita foreign trade was double the figures given above, China would still be near the very bottom of the list of eighty-three. Professor Kuznets' studies have indicated that a negative correlation is to be expected between a country's size and its foreign trade as a proportion of national income. In the case of China this size factor was reinforced by an economic system with substantially autarchic economic cells, sustained by a relatively unchanging transport system. The second observation is that, by and large, the inland distribution of foreign goods and, to a somewhat lesser extent, the assembly of exports were dominated by Chinese merchants and operated through the traditional channels of trade. "There is at present not a single Western merchant engaged in the cotton-goods import trade in the whole Yang-tze Valley, except in Shanghai: English capital has been withdrawn from ports like Hankow, and has never been invested in the new ports like Ch'ung-king', reported the Lancashire mission to China of 1896-7.z9 Eleven large Chinese dealers in Hankow regularly bought imported cloth and yarn in Shanghai 19
Blackburn report, F. S. A. Bourne's section, 70-1.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
TABLE 19
O O
Percentage distribution of China's foreign trade with principal trading partners, 1S71-1911 Imports from
s w
Exports to
1871-3
1881-3
1891-3
1901-3
3^-5 34-7 3-7
36.2 23.8 4.9 3-7
51.2 20.4 4-7 4-5
41.6 15.9 12.5 8.5
0.2
0.6
0.8
1871-3
1881-3
1891-3
1901-3
33-9 16.5
14.7 52-9
25.4 33-3
39-3 11.3
15-5 7-1
i-7
2.4
7-2
14.1
3-5
3-3
12.4 7-3 — — 19.2 100.0
9.8 8.6
40.8 4.8 12.5 10.2 5-5 — — 26.2 100.0
1909-11
1909-11
n >• 25
Hong Kong Great Britain Japan*
United States Russia Germanyf Francef Others Total
°-5 0.2
—
— —
— —
31.2 100.0
18.6 100.0
20.7 100.0
—
—
—
28.4 100.0
* includes Taiwan from 1895
4.2 0.6 18.7
100.0
'3-3 100.0
— — 23.8 100.0
28.2 5-i
M-9 9.0
12.5 3-1
10.7 15-5 100.0
f included in 'Others' before 1909-11
Source: Yen Chung-p'ing et al., comps. Cbung-kuo cbin-tai cbing-cbi sbib t'ung-cbi t^u-liao bsuan-cbi (Selected statistics on China's
modern economic history), tables 7-8, pp. 65-6.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
D *n o w M
o z n o
s w
po
n w
52
ECONOMIC TRENDS, 1 8 7 O - 1 9 H
through their agents. They then resold the goods to Hankow retailers and to merchants from lower level markets in Hunan and Honan who came to Hankow for their supplies. In 1896, there were five European firms in Chungking; only one of these dealt in imported cotton goods, China's most important import, and that was in a small way. The cotton trade in Chungking was in the hands of twenty-seven Chinese firms who, together with three firms in Chengtu and one in Chia-ting, each August sent their TABLE
2O
Percentage distribution of China's foreign trade {including Hong Kong) with principal trading partners, rfyp-ipoj Imports from
Exports to
average
1904
1903
1904
1905
average 18991903
20.13 28.33 (48.46) 18.26 10.95
0.80 13.32
23.92 26.54 (50.46) 18.06 9.20 4-31 5.90 0.56 11.51
2353 23.81 (47-34) 16.13 18.11 3-49 5.08 0.46 9.40
8.60 13.98 (22.58) 12.70 12.92 '3-59 3-39 19-35 15-47
7-72 12.49 (20.21) 15.51 16.09 13.24 4.05 16.97 '3-93
100.00
100.00
100.00
100.00
100.00
1899-
Great Britain British Dominions, etc. (total British empire) Japan* United States Russia Germany France Others Total
2.54 5-5O
1905 6.97 12.44 14.03 J5-47 14.83 4.41 16.52 15-33
100.00
* includes Taiwan Source: Calculations by H. B. Morse in China, Inspectorate-General of Customs, Returns of trade and trade reports, 1906, pt 1, p. 46.
agents (often partners of the several firms) to Shanghai where they resided until May while they purchased and shipped cloth and yarn to Chungking. Lower level markets in Szechwan were supplied by local merchants who bought on credit from the Chungking dealers. In South China, agents or partners of firms in such relatively small centres as Linanfu in Yunnan bought directly from British importers in Hong Kong, the goods being shipped via Haiphong and entering China at Mengtze. While in the 1860s and into the 1870s branches of foreign firms, especially British, handled much of the importation of cotton goods into such ports as Hankow, these branches in the smaller treaty ports - which were the urban markets for large regional trading areas — were unable to develop permanent direct ties with rural Chinese distributors even at the central market level, not to
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
DOMESTIC AND FOREIGN COMMERCE
53
speak of intermediate or basic markets. The Chinese firms with whom they dealt in Chinkiang or Hankow were located at the apex of the traditional marketing structure and had the advantage of local know-how and longstanding connections with lower level markets. Increasingly firms like those in Chungking mentioned above preferred to buy directly in Shanghai or Hong Kong where the selection of goods was larger and where they might benefit from competition among importers and frequent auction sales. Chinese and foreign steamship companies on the Yangtze were highly.competitive and offered as favourable terms to Chinese merchants as to foreign. And, moreover, the Chefoo Convention of 1876 formalized the right of Chinese shippers transporting imported goods to obtain transit passes and thus nominal equality of taxation with the foreigner. It is perhaps only a small exaggeration, regarding the importation and distribution of the major staples of commerce, to describe the foreign trading firms in China as having been gradually transformed into Shanghai and Hong Kong commission agents serving the established Chinese commercial network. For some proprietary goods or those representing an advanced technology, networks of Chinese agents under direct foreign supervision were established from about the turn of the century. Some of the increasing Japanese trade after the Sino-Japanese War was also distributed by direct methods. But the bulk of the distribution of imports remained in Chinese hands. The Chinese demand for imported goods was thus a limited one, and beyond the treaty ports this demand was supplied almost entirely through the traditional Chinese marketing system. On the export side the situation was similar, but there are indications of a somewhat greater foreign participation. The inability of foreign exporters in the treaty ports to exercise any quality control in the assembly of the annual tea crop was a major factor in the relative decline of China teas in foreign markets in the face of Indian, Ceylonese and Japanese competition. On the other hand, foreigners played a direct role at least in the earlief development of the supply of such new exports as hog bristles, hides and leather, and eggs and egg products. The stability of the traditional marketing system was, as I have stated, directly related to the technology and cost of transportation. By 1911 steamships and steam launches and the railroad had penetrated the interior of China only to a very limited extent. In 1865, the Ch'ing government prohibited the traffic of foreign steam launches in inland waters which had been tolerated during the Taiping Rebellion. But foreign- and Chineseowned steam shipping among the treaty ports including those on the Yangtze, which was permitted by the treaties, expanded from the 1870s. In 1874,17 American, 11 British and 6 Chinese steamers were carrying freight
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
54
ECONOMIC TRENDS, 1 8 7 0 - I 9 I I
on the Yangtze River and between Shanghai and other treaty ports. By 1894, 26 vessels owned by the China Merchants' Steam Navigation Co. and at least 51 owned by two British companies were in service on these routes. Smaller Chinese-owned steam launches were also beginning to ply between the treaty ports and inland cities not open to foreign traffic. The spread of the steam launch is apparent from the falling average tonnage of Chineseowned steam vessels registered with the Imperial Maritime Customs: 1882, 737 tons; 1892, 247 tons; 1900, 35 tons. In 1898, in 'compensation' for China's refusal to accept Great Britain's offer of a loan, the British government forced Peking to permit foreign-flag steamers to trade at the inland ports from which they had been excluded since 1865. By 1903, 614 Chinese and foreign steamers had registered for inland trade, a number which increased to 977 in 1909, 1,030 in 1910 and 1,130 (936 Chinese and 194 foreign) in 1913. These small river steamers brought cheaper and more rapid transportation to the traditional trade routes on the tributaries of the Yangtze and West rivers (360 of the total in 1909 were registered at Shanghai, 72 at Hankow and 277 at Canton), but they remained vastly overshadowed in numbers and total tonnage by the thousands of junks and rafts of all sizes which continued to carry the bulk of the inland trade.30 Similarly, although 9,244 kilometres of trunk and branch railway lines had been completed by 1912 (including 288 kilometres before 1895), the railway had only a limited impact upon the late-Ch'ing economy and commercial system - as opposed to its very considerable political consequences for the ultimate fate of the Manchu dynasty. China's pre-1912 railways affected the economy and marketing system little not only because their total mileage was, after all, extremely small, but also because the bulk of this track was opened only in the last few years of the dynasty. Moreover, such consequences as the railway did have in the first years of the Republic were seriously distorted by endemic civil war which commandeered railway lines for troop transport, diverted revenues to the maintenance of warlord armies, and neglected repairs to the roadbed and rolling stock. With minor exceptions such as the 199 kilometres from Peking to Kalgan which were built by Chinese engineers largely with the profits of the Peking-Mukden line, China's pre-republican railways were financed 30
Even in the very unlikely case that the average tonnage of the 1,130 inland steamers of 1913 was as high as 100 tons (the 1900 average for Chinese-owned steamers was 35 tons), the total tonnage would be only 113,000. In September 1941, in the three provinces of Kiangsu, Chekiang and Anhwei, 118,29a junks and sampans of all sizes {min-cb'uan), totalling 850,704 tons and with crews of 459,178 persons, had registered with the boatmen's associations established by the Wang Ching-wei government. I have no data on the number and tonnage of junks in the late-Ch'ing period, but it is improbable that they could have been smaller than the 1941 figures for three provinces alone. See Mantetsu Chdsabu, Cbu-Sbi no minsengyo (The junk trade of Central China), 134-5.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
DOMESTIC AND FOREIGN COMMERCE
M
\
/Soft Chita i ^_vt\
55
-?\
/
' ~'v / V._
^•-*
f
/
>'N. r '^.,
"V«i
J^Harbin ¥>*>^. Vfss
.if J^. r
Vladivostok
rv s
$£
•»..__
./
^/ Ral?£J?'
j
^ *5airer
Jffensin
^ \
—v^^
^_
fit \
f KOREA \
\
)
\J"
4-8
S S ^ ^ Shanghai
^tyankow/
Of
/
\
\
^
J
u n g
1 : Tsm9t£ ° I /# ^7 /Chiao-tsoK-/ < f e / j .^^^TKaifenSft, - — - ^ Loyang 4 Che ngchovig
/«^v Singpo
1
f
f
,.„, y / /
Yunnanfu \
Canton 'S07-U
f
I
l^KoX^on ^ ^
\ Hanoi^* / (
^
^ongKong
(Haiphong
L
(
0
MAP.
'
r^—
1
MSkden"9>"
C
1
"^Jyv Tsitsihar
m
>
;t •f
Manchouli^-—>-~*^*N-^
500km 3 0 0 miles
4 Railway building, late Ch'ing
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
56
ECONOMIC TRENDS, 1 8 7 O - I 9 I I
mainly by foreign loans and constructed by foreign concessionaires. The Chinese Eastern Railway in Manchuria (1,481 kilometres) and the South Manchurian Railway mainline from Harbin to Dairen (944 kilometres) were completely Russian undertakings with only a thin veneer of Chinese participation; and the Shantung railway from Kiaochow to Tsinan (394 kilometres) was a German financed and operated line. Slightly more than one-third of the total railway mileage in 1912 was in Manchuria, and unquestionably the railway was important for increasing the export of Manchurian soy-beans and for the steady growth of cotton goods imports in the first decade of the twentieth century. Harbin was in effect created by the Chinese Eastern Railway, and such ports as Newchwang and Chinwangtao which lacked navigable waterways in their hinterlands were dependent on the railway. The major trunk lines within China proper - the Peking-Hankow railway (1,215 kilometres) and the Tientsin-Pukow railway (1,009 kilometres) - ran from north to south and provided links between the North China plain and the Yangtze valley where only the inadequate Grand Canal had served before. While these two parallel lines were possibly to some degree an uneconomical duplication, in general the routes of the lines completed in this first spurt of railway construction were well located to open new territories as in Manchuria, and to compensate for the absence of navigable waterways in North China. A radial network, centring perhaps at Hankow, would have been theoretically more desirable, but in 1906 when the Peking-Hankow line was completed it was not possible to foresee the duplication of lines for political reasons as in Manchuria in the 1920s, the delay of several decades before Hankow was connected with Canton, and the failure to build westward to Szechwan before 1949. At the end of the Ch'ing dynasty the comment of the customs commissioner at Shasi in Hupei applied to all except the few major centres in North China and Manchuria which were connected by rail: 'Shasi has no railway communication, and, being the centre of a most extensive system of natural and artificial waterways, can dispense with any for many years.'* • Though it may be contrary to the more common view, it does appear that the foreign merchant in late-Ch'ing China increasingly served rather than controlled the Chinese commercial system. The actual process of importing and exporting, however, which was conducted primarily at Shanghai and Hong Kong, remained almost completely in foreign hands until the 1920s. The principal link between the foreign merchant who spoke no Chinese and his customer or supplier from Chungking or Hankow who spoke no English was the comprador. While nominally employees of " Decennial reports. ..,
1902-1 f 11, 1.292-j.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
DOMESTIC AND FOREIGN COMMERCE
57
foreign firms, many compradors were traders on their own account in the goods handled by their employers. Their role in purchasing from Chinese dealers in exports and in arranging credit for buyers of imports provided unique opportunities to influence the flow of trade inward and outward and to profit therefrom. Many of the original investors in Chinese-owned shipping, financial and manufacturing enterprises were men who had grown wealthy as compradors of the leading foreign firms in Shanghai. The increase in the number of Chinese- and Japanese-owned exportimport houses after 1911 (the Japanese apparently made greater efforts than the British or Americans to acquire some competence with the Chinese language) reduced the overall significance of the compradors as the link between foreign trade and the Chinese marketing system. In a somewhat truncated form, however, the institution lingered on. Continued foreign dominance of the export-import process in the treaty ports was sustained by the role of foreign banks in China in financing foreign trade. From 1848, when the Oriental Banking Corporation established an office in Shanghai, the British enjoyed for forty years a virtual monopoly of modern-style banking in China. The two most important British-controlled firms were the Chartered Bank of India, Australia and China, whose first Chinese branch was opened in 18 5 7, and the Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation, which was established in 1865. German, Japanese, Russian, French and American competitors began to appear in the 1890s. Most of the advances of the foreign banks for financing imports and exports were made to foreign firms; direct loans to Chinese merchants were limited. Short-term credits were, however, allowed to 'native banks' which in turn loaned funds to Chinese merchants. In effect, the foreign banks by virtue of their monopoly of the financing of foreign trade also controlled the foreign exchange market. They were the channel through which the flow of silver to and from China took place, and they determined the fluctuating gold price of silver. Until 1935 the official exchange rate in the Shanghai market was based on the daily quotations of the Hongkong and Shanghai Bank. The first Chinese modern bank, the Chung-kuo t'ung-shang yin-hang (known before 1911 as the Imperial Bank of China), was established by Sheng Hsuan-huai in 1896, but no Chinese bank played a significant role in the financing of foreign trade until the Hu Pu Bank established in 1904 had evolved into the Bank of China in the Republican period. Between 1896 and 1911 sixteen modern-style Chinese banks were opened (of which only seven survived up to the 1930s). All their main offices and branches were located in the larger cities; and they maintained only small and indirect connections with the trade of the interior in the form of short-term
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
j8
ECONOMIC T R E N D S ,
187O-I9II
advances to inland 'native banks'. Modern commercial banking did not begin to penetrate the traditional marketing system until the 1920s and 1930s, while its total influence was meagre at best even after World War JI. The bulk of local commerce in late-Ch'ing China, to the degree that it depended upon external credit at all, continued to be financed by old-style banks - one further indication that, other than in the major treaty ports, the structure of trade and the institutions which facilitated it had not changed greatly by 1911 from what they had been half a century before.32 GOVERNMENT AND THE ECONOMY
The consequences of the Ch'ing political system for the Chinese economy have often been stated in terms of excessive and capricious taxation, omnipresent corruption, and a general disdain for commerce and the merchant. These are not matters simply to be disregarded - the ideological posture of 'exalting agriculture and disparaging commerce' in particular requires examination that I cannot give it here (see chapter 8). The fact is, however, that within the constraints of the traditional technology, as earlier sections of this chapter have demonstrated, late-Ch'ing China was possessed of a complex, commercialized, 'developed' economy. Over the span of two centuries it had been able to support a growing population, had facilitated the 'pacification' of immense territories beyond the boundaries of China proper, and until the late eighteenth century (with the exception of the Rebellion of the Three Feudatories in 1673-81) had seen an unusually lengthy era of internal peace, relative prosperity and effective rule. In modern terms the tax burden on the population, while sometimes capriciously administered, was light. Depravity found its place in China as in other societies, but much of what appeared to the treaty-port observer as 'corrupt' represented the foreigner's inability to understand the informal but institutionalized lou-kuei ('customary exactions') which interpenetrated the highly rationalized fiscal system set forth in the official statutes of the dynasty. If the merchant was devalued in the official ideology and sometimes inordinately pressed for 'contributions' to the government, this does not negate the fact that he might be rich. The average annual profit of the Liang-Huai salt transport monopoly in the eighteenth century was perhaps 5 million taels, which was shared by thirty principal transport merchants and some two hundred lesser dealers; an additional profit of 2 million taels was divided annually among some thirty factory merchants. The merchant 12
A substantial decline in the position of the Shansi banks from about 1900 is, however, to be noted. The semi-official modern banks established after 1896 absorbed much of their transfer business and the deposits of public funds upon which they had depended.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
GOVERNMENT AND THE ECONOMY
59
might also be powerful, in particular within the rural marketing structure where the local elite in and out of office invested in commerce or usury through the merchant's auspices. In addition a merchant might be fortunate. His sons and grandsons, with ample leisure and strict instruction and perhaps a purchased initial degree - might themselves enter the political elite. In short, for the maintenance, extension and prosperity of the traditional economy at a relatively constant level of per capita output, the ideology and administration of the state were at least neutral factors and almost never, except in recurrent periods of dynastic decay, major obstacles. If, however, one's point of reference is economic development - either in the sense of increasing per capita national product or in the sense of industrialization (that is, the rapid growth of a modern manufacturing sector with or without an immediate increment in per capita product), then undoubtedly the late-nineteenth-century Chinese government was incapable of supplying positive assistance. Ideology, traditional fiscal practices, and the patterns of revenue and expenditure, were all obstacles to suitable action. In the first spurt of industrialization in the more 'backward' countries of Europe, Russia in the 1890s for example, as Professor Gerschenkron has shown," the state budget substituted for deficient market demand and capital supply, which were sharply limited by the poverty of the agricultural sector. A similar role was played by the credit-creating operations of the industrial banks in less 'backward' countries such as Germany and France. Neither alternative was available in late-Ch'ing China. As we have seen, apart from the important role of modern foreign banks in financing international trade, the pre-1911 banking system of China was almost entirely limited to transfer banks of the Shansi bank type and to local 'native banks'. The directors of China's first modern bank, the semi-official Imperial Bank of China, were primarily concerned with gaining control of the lucrative transfer of government funds between the provinces and Peking. When this project failed, they turned completely to conventional commercial banking. Neither of the two relatively small government banks established later (the Bank of Communications founded in 1908; and the Hu Pu Bank founded in 1904 and reorganized as the Ta-Ch'ing Bank in 1908) was intended to make industrial loans. The failure of the Ch'ing government to promote a modern banking system which could foster industrial investment ultimately stemmed from the same causes which made it unable to invest in economic development from its own budget. In brief, the fiscal system of the central government like other aspects of its administration was quite superficial. Even in 13
Alexander Gerschenkron, Economic backwardness in historical perspective.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
60
ECONOMIC TRENDS, 1 8 7 O - I 9 I I
normal times the imperial bureaucracy, although highly centralized in its formal organization, did not penetrate very deeply into Chinese society, including those aspects of society which constituted the economy. The central government normally confined its economic role to claiming its share of a relatively fixed economic product and to providing the internal order and external defences which would permit that product to be reproduced from one year to the next. This was of course in accordance with the main stream of the Confucian political ideology. But at various times in the two millennia of empire the more activist Legalist strain in the Confucian-Legalist ideological amalgam which supported the imperial system had been drawn upon for departures from economic passivity, notably in the 'reforms' of Wang Mang and Wang An-shih. Such departures, however, were perhaps particularly difficult for the ultra-conservative Manchu dynasty, always conscious of its foreign origin and determined to demonstrate its mandate by upholding Confucian orthodoxy. Thus as land under cultivation increased (until about 1800) and as the population grew slowly and unevenly (except for probable losses during the mid-nineteenthcentury rebellions), the total economic product of course grew in size. But for the central government, economic growth by the accretion of more units of roughly the same mix of factors of production was not an opportunity to increase its revenues and its participation in the economy. In 1712 the official rates for the most important imperial revenue, the land tax, were fixed in perpetuity by the K'ang-hsi Emperor; the provincial quotas due to Peking were to be raised only as new land was opened to cultivation and added to the tax rolls, increments which the provinces rarely recorded in their reports to the capital. However, as we shall see, it is evident that provincial and local tax collections retained their flexibility andflourishedwith the increasing size of the national product. Yet from the point of view of possible economic development as opposed to maintenance of an economic equilibrium, these new resources were completely neutralized. It remained an ideological possibility, even though remote, within the central government bureaucracy that Legalist raison d'etat might be revived and motivate programmes for economic development. To a limited extent this was done by the 'selfstrengtheners' of the late nineteenth century, such as Li Hung-chang, Chang Chih-tung and Sheng Hsuan-huai, by the 'reformers' of 1898, and by the late-Ch'ing reform movement after 1901. But local administration was pre-eminently the home of the Confucian 'general will' until nearly the end of the dynasty. This was broader and more diffuse than the interests of the bureaucratic state per se, and reflected the preoccupation of the local elite with maintaining unchanged a society that was truly theirs. These Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
GOVERNMENT AND THE ECONOMY
6l
people had been educated in and sustained by the Confucian ideal of rule by moral example. Although the 'general will' was increasingly penetrated by anti-imperialist nationalism after 1900, this did not extend to an acceptance of the fiscal burdens of economic development. No effective initiatives for economic change could be expected here. Hence my attention in what follows to the disabilities of the central government - a weak branch to be sure, but none other offered even a foothold. The statutory receipts recorded by the Peking government did not change significantly between 1712 and the third quarter of the nineteenth century. (For selected years the total central government receipts were: 1725, 36,106,483 taels; 1753, 39,767,292 taels; 1812,43,343,978 taels; 1841, 38,600,750 taels. Land tax supplied 75 to 80 per cent of the total. Provincial and local collections, however, continued to increase notwithstanding the freezing of land tax rates by the K'ang-hsi Emperor. Three principal devices were utilized to enlarge actual collections beyond the nominal quotas due to the central government. The first was a 'meltage' fee {hao-hsieri), in theory assessed to compensate for remittances in silver of less than the required purity and for losses in melting and casting silver ingots. In practice these losses were minimal; the meltage fee was in fact a tax increase beyond the rates sanctioned by K'ang-hsi. In 1724, this surtax received formal imperial recognition and in part was remitted to Peking for payment to officials as an annual bonus to 'foster their honesty' (jang-lien), that is to compensate for inadequate salaries. The bulk of the collection, however, remained outside Peking's control. Secondly, local officials added a conventional sum for expenses of collection to the bill submitted to taxpayers. The third device was the relative freedom with which local magistrates set the exchange rates between nominal assessments in grain or silver and the number of copper cash per picul of grain or tael of silver which they would accept in full payment of the tax due. In the mid-nineteenth century two major sources of revenue were added to the traditional land tax, salt gabelle and customs duty. The establishment of the foreign-operated Imperial Maritime Customs after 1854 regularized the collection of duties on foreign trade and channelled these receipts to the Peking government rather than to the provinces. The second new impost, in contrast, was almost entirely outside Peking's control. This was the likin (Ji-chin) which was originally instituted by provincial officials to finance their campaigns against the Taipings. It was first levied in 18 5 3 in Kiangsu as an internal transit tax on grain passing through the Grand Canal. By 1862 it had been applied to nearly all commodities and had been adopted by nearly every province. In some cases likin was collected not only along the route of transit but also as a production tax at the point of origin or as a
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
6l
ECONOMIC T R E N D S ,
187O-I9II
sales tax at the destination. The rate varied widely, from i to io per cent ad valorem, with the most common rate about z per cent at each tax barrier. Of the likin collections on merchandise reported annually by the provinces to the Hu Pu (Board of Revenue), only about 20 per cent was disposed of by the central government, the balance remaining under the de facto control of the provinces. The unreported collection, of unknown size, was also of course retained locally. In addition some small and temporary increases in receipts from the salt gabelle and miscellaneous taxes were realized as a result of constant prodding by the Hu Pu in the 1870s and 1880s to meet the costs of a continuing series of crises: rebellion in Central Asia, the Hi dispute with Russia, the Sino-French War, floods and famines. The nearly doubled imperial revenue of the 1880s and 1890s as compared with mid-century receipts was, however, almost entirely accounted for by maritime customs duties and likin. For the immediate financing of such emergencies as Tso Tsung-t'ang's military expeditions and 'pacification' of the north-west, to which the traditional fiscal system was incapable of responding rapidly, the government was forced to turn to foreign loans (see chapter 4). Before 1894 nine loans totalling 40 million taels were concluded, mostly for military expenses. These funds were advanced by foreign firms in the treaty ports, not by foreign governments. By the outbreak of the Sino-Japanese War 33? million taels in principal and interest had been repaid, largely from maritime customs revenue. Table 21 shows estimates of Peking's revenue from all sources and of the major items of expenditure in a typical year in the early 1890s. The revenue figures do not represent actual remittance of tax receipts to the capital; they are the amounts reported to the Hu Pu yearly (in two instalments). They were then stored in money or in kind in the several provincial treasuries to await allocation by the Hu Pu. No composite budget of income and expenditure was prepared by the central treasury. (One of the unrealized projects of the reformers was the establishment of a regular national budget.) Rather, items of recurring expenditure had gradually come to be charged piecemeal against the yields of specific taxes in particular provinces. Eventually one part of the reported total was retained by the provinces to cover local civil and military expenses for the ensuing period, a second portion was remitted to Peking (or elsewhere at the direction of the Hu Pu), and in some cases a third part was transferred as grants-in-aid to other provinces. The fiscal system was oriented to shortrange operations and the weight of traditional practices made it incapable of responding rapidly to emergency needs. As a result of the Taiping and other mid-century rebellions Peking's control of the revenue sources of the Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
GOVERNMENT A N D THE ECONOMY
63
empire had been weakened and the fiscal system was severely strained. In contrast to the last seventeen years of the dynasty, however, with the assistance of new revenues the government's civil and military expenditures until 1894 were met without major borrowing from abroad, and the normal income was stretched to amortize the costs of the relatively modest foreign loans that were made. Little, of course, was realized from the substantial investment in a modernized navy and foreign-style armies, as the meagre results of the pre-1895 jang-wu (foreign matters) military and industrial projects testify. TABLE
21
Estimated annual revenue and expenditure of the central government in the early 1890s (K'u-p'ing or treasury taels) Revenue
land tax grain tribute salt gabelle (including salt likin) likin on merchandise maritime customs (1893) native customs duty and likin on domestic opium miscellaneous taxes, sale of degrees, 'contribution', etc.
25,088,000 6,562,000 13,659,000 12,952,000 21,989,000 1,000,000 2,229,000 5,500,000
Total Expenditure central government administration, imperial household, stipends to Manchu garrisons maritime customs administration public works modernized armies, coastal defence defence of Manchuria civil and military administration of Kansu and Central Asia Northern Fleet Southern Fleet railway construction grants-in-aid to Kwangsi, Kweichow and Yunnan Provincial administration, provincial troops Principal and interest payments on foreign loans
19,478,000 2,478,000 1,500,000 8,000,000 1,848,000 4,800,000 5,000,000 5,000,000 500,000 1,655,000 36,220,000 2,500,000
Total
88,979,000
88,979,000
Source: George Jamieson, Report on tbe revenue and expenditure of the Cbinete empire.
As already noted, the revenue reported annually to Peking represented only a portion of the total tax collection of the empire. The share of the potential fiscal resources of the country which the central government could control was largely inelastic. It had no chance to increase revenue from the growth of foreign trade, because tariff rates could not be changed without the unanimous consent of the treaty powers, and it had only a Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
64
ECONOMIC TRENDS, 187O-I9II
limited ability to manipulate the salt gabelle and various minor taxes. Several estimates of total national tax revenues have been made; while none is more than an intelligent guess so far as the absolute total is concerned, collectively they are strong evidence that the total annual tax collection at all levels in the last decade of the Manchu dynasty was more than twice the amount reported to Peking. A recent examination of the provincial 1V'ai-cheng shuo-ming-shu (Descriptions of financial administration), which are the reports of the Financial Reorganization Bureaux set up by imperial decree in each of the provinces in 1909, suggests that the total tax revenue for 1908 was 292 million taels.34 H. B. Morse in his account of revenue and expenditure in The trade and administration of the Chinese empire offers a minimum total of 284,1 j^ooo taels for the early 1900s apportioned as follows: imperial administration, 99,062,000 taels; provincial administration, 142,374,000 taels; local administration, 42,718,000 taels. Finally, the imperial 'budget' for 1911 prepared by the Tzu-cheng yuan (Consultative Assembly) estimated total central and provincial income at 501,910,297 taels (including, it may be noted, likin collections of 44,176,541 taels which should be compared with the 12-15 million taels reported annually by the provinces, and non-tax revenues of 92 million taels). In contrast to Meiji Japan, where the land-tax revision of 1873 brought the major revenue sources of the country under the direct control of the new central government, the late-Ch'ing government was ideologically and politically incapable of extending its control of the revenue. If we assume that total collections in the latter part of the dynasty were about 250 million taels and that Peking's share came to 100 million taels, what part of the national income was available for government expenditure ? Only the crudest estimate is of course possible in the absence of reliable national income data. If Chang Chung-li's 'rough estimate of the annual gross national product in the 1880s' is adjusted for its understatement of the agricultural product, GNP in the late-nineteenth century may have been about 3,338,757,000 taels (see table 1 above). Total government revenue would then come to 7.5 per cent of GNP and the Peking govern-ment's share to 3 per cent.35 These proportions are, as I have acknowledged, subject to a very wide margin of error. With this caveat in mind, it is instructive to note that proportions of this general order of magnitude for the share of government consumption in GNP are also to be found in several Western European countries and in the United States in the midnineteenth century. 36 Economic development in these less 'backward' J4 Yeh-chien Wang, Land taxation in imperial China, i/jo-iyrr, 73-83. J> Government revenue or expenditure in my estimate includes some part of the share which Chang attributes to gentry services. >* Simon Kuznets, Modern economic growth: rate, structure, spread, 236-9.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
GOVERNMENT AND THE ECONOMY
65
countries was set in motion without any major direct assistance from the government budget. The contrast with China of course lies in the greater quantity and quality, within the Western governments' total consumption, of expenditures for health and education and for general administrative, legislative and adjudicative services (including commercial and marketing services) which fostered a climate in which the private sector could profitably invest in new enterprises. China's problem was thus not only that a manifestly small proportion of GNP was subject to government control, and that only 40 per cent of even that total was available to the central authorities. Of equal and perhaps greater consequence was the fact that almost all of the increase in central government expenditure was for military purposes, mainly to suppress internal rebellion but also in response to a number of minor external crises. This was so even though this expenditure doubled in the course of the nineteenth century - compare table 21 with the examples cited of annual receipts for selected earlier years. Government services, such as they were, were not significantly augmented; nor was there any important departure from their traditional limitation, which was the maintenance of order and the collection of taxation with which to support the emperor and his bureaucracy. Perhaps the Ch'ing government - aroused now by antiimperialist nationalism — after 1900 was ideologically prepared to do more. But both political weakness andfiscalstringency kept actual expenditures on such items as the new school system and industrial promotion to a low level. After 1895 the triple demands of indemnity payments, servicing large foreign loans, and military expenditure wrecked the rough balance between income and outlay which Peking had precariously maintained until that time. Even as the prevalent ideological note was changing from 'exalt agriculture and disparage commerce' to 'enrich the nation and strengthen its military power', the imperial government was without the facilities to reverse the largely passive economic role it had hitherto assumed, even if it had wanted to do so. And despite the rise of nationalism, conservative resistance to change including modern economic growth remained strong until the end of the dynasty. Between 1894 and 1911 the Ch'ing government contracted for loans from foreign lenders amounting to 746,220,453 k'u-p'ing taels. Of this total 330,587,160 taels was accounted for by loans for railway construction which were to be repaid from the revenue of the lines themselves. While the several contracts granted the foreign mortgagees de facto operating privileges and handsome commissions on the purchase of material, repayment of principal and interest on the railway loans did not represent a direct Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
66
ECONOMIC TRENDS, 1 8 7 O - I 9 I I
burden on the ordinary budget of the central government. Relatively small amounts were borrowed for industrial purposes (25,517,349 taels), to finance telegraph lines and equipment (5,452,783 taels), and for miscellaneous uses (647,812 taels). The industrial loans consisted mainly of advances by Japanese creditors to the semi-oflficial Hanyehping Coal and Iron Co. Hanyehping was unable to repay these loans and fell deeper and deeper into debt to the lenders, thus providing the pretext for the inclusion of formal recognition of Japanese control over the company in the Twenty-one Demands of 1915. Apart from the large sums for railway construction, the funds were borrowed principally for the military costs of the Sino-Japanese War (119,838,648 taels) and to finance the large war indemnity which China was required to pay to the victor (263,176,701 taels). These totals include several short-term advances; the seven major long-term military and indemnity loans are shown in table 22. Payment of principal and interest on these loans required an annual outlay of some 20 million taels in addition to the normal annual expenditure summarized in table 21. From where did these funds come ? All but two of the loans in table 22 were entirely secured on the maritime customs revenue. The Arnhold Karberg loan of 1895 was secured as a first charge on the salt likin of Kiangsu and as a second charge on the customs revenue. The 1898 Anglo-German loan was secured on the unencumbered portion of the customs revenue (which in view of the earlier loans was small in 1898) and on the revenue of seven salt and likin collectorates in the Yangtze basin which were placed under the supervision of the Inspector-General of Customs. This, however, is only the beginning of the matter. Customs revenue between 1890 and 1900 remained fairly stable at about 22—3 million taels per annum. Its allocation to service the foreign debt left the Hu Pu with a substantial deficit in its regular accounts - at least 16,700,000 taels in 1900 according to the Board's estimate. Ultimately the loan payments were made by increasing salt prices several times, reducing some salaries and emoluments, raising the tax on domestic opium, increasing market taxes and other miscellaneous levies, enlarging slightly the likin remitted to Peking, and so on - all traditional measures, and each the result of a protracted negotiation with the provincial authorities. The payments were made as scheduled, but until 1902 thefiscalsystem was in chaos. Of some interest is an attempt to float a public domestic loan - China's first - in 1898: 100 million taels of 'Sincerity Bonds' paying 5 per cent and redeemable in twenty years were offered. Perhaps as much as 10 million taels' worth of bonds were sold before cries of extortion by the local elite and merchants brought the experiment to a close. There was little public confidence in the 'full faith and credit' of the Ch'ing govern-
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
G O V E R N M E N T A N D T H E ECONOMY
67
ment and no banking system to absorb government bonds at a huge discount as was so often done in the Republican era. TABLE 22
Military and indemnity loans, 1894-8 Face amount (in k'u-p'ing tael equivalent:} 7% Silver Loan of 1894 6% Sterling Loan
10,000,000 18,653,961
of 1895
6% Gold Loan of 1895
6,217,987
6% Gold Loan of 1895 4% Gold Loan (Franco-Russian) of 1895 5% Sterling Loan (Anglo-German) of 1896 4i% Gold Loan (Anglo-German) of 1898
6,217,987
Total
Underwriter
Security
Hongkong and Shanghai Bank Hongkong and Shanghai Bank Arnhold, Karberg & Co. (for National Bank fur Deutschland) Cassel Bank
maritime customs maritime customs Kiangsu salt likin/ maritime customs maritime customs
98,968,370
Syndicate of Paris and St Petersburg banks
maritime customs
97,622,400
Hongkong and Shanghai Bank Deutsch-Asiatische Bank Hongkong and Shanghai Bank/Deutsch-Asiatische Bank
maritime customs
112,776,780
likin/salt likin/ maritime customs
35O.457.485
Source: Hsu I-sheng, Chung-kuo chin-tai wai-chai shih t'ung-cbi t^u-liao, materials on the history of China's foreign loans, 1853-1927), 28-31.
(Statistical
On top of the annual requirements for the service of the loans listed in table 22, from 1902 at least an equal amount had to be found to meet the annual Boxer indemnity payments. In the last years of the dynasty, loan service and Boxer payments together came to 46-7 million taels per annum. Part of the added outlay was obtained from increased customs revenue collections after the 1902 tariff revision and from the receipts of native customs stations placed under the Inspectorate of Customs by the Boxer protocol. It is instructive, however, that three-quarters of the Boxer payments until the fall of the dynasty were met by regular annual remittances by the provinces of land tax, salt and likin funds above the quotas shown in table 21. The extraction by Peking from the provinces - in spite of strong protests and without the inconclusive bargaining of 1895-1901 of more than 18 million taels annually which had previously been outside its control was of course only possible in the extraordinary circumstances of a de facto occupation of North China by foreign armies. But this and the
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
68
ECONOMIC TRENDS, 1 8 7 O - I 9 I I
other funds raised more fitfully are evidence that the late-Ch'ing economy was not without some potential for savings. The missing factors were both the ideological sanction and the political power to mobilize this potential for productive investment. A total of 476,982,000 taels in principal and interest was paid between 1895 and 1911 to foreign creditors on account of the Boxer indemnity and the three loans (Russo-French, two Anglo-German) from which the war indemnity to Japan was met. This represented a large net drain on China's available resources. (If the four military loans were included, payments would rise to 547,5 52,066 taels, but let us allow that military expenditure is an essential service and does not represent a net loss of resources in the sense that an indemnity does.) The sum of 476,982,000 taels is one-and-ahalf times as much as the total amount borrowed from foreign lenders for railway construction before 1912. It is more than twice the size of the total initial capitalization of all the foreign, Sino-foreign and Chinese-owned manufacturing enterprises established between 1895 and 1913. Apart from the growth of maritime customs revenue in the dynasty's last decade, this enormous outflow of funds from the Chinese economy came ultimately from increased taxes on the population levied by local collectors and remitted to the central government for payment to foreign creditors. The Ch'ing did not fall, however, primarily because the populace rose up against excessive taxation. Quite the contrary. By 1911 both its political and its fiscal resources were equally superficial and superfluous. When the Peking government after 1900 slowly began to break through the ideological resistance to engaging in 'national development' in its various aspects, it not only lacked the political control required (though it set out to get it); it was also saddled with foreign debts which pre-empted the fiscal resources with which it might have got started. But the process of acquiring these debts had been the blunt, educative instrument which had led the government to begin to broaden its objectives. So there is, perhaps, in all of this an element of tragic inevitability. Slowly and on a very small scale, the 'traditional' Chinese economy had begun to change in the second half of the nineteenth century. The changes were not, however, of the kind to encourage the expectation either that the economic system would be radically restructured ('modernized', 'industrialized') with the mere passage of a few decades, or that the basically unaltered economy had a capacity to continue the growth along traditional lines which it had displayed until about 1800. The plain facts are that by the mid-nineteenth century, if not earlier, China's economy had reached the limits of development possible with the technology (mechanical and Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
G O V E R N M E N T A N D THE ECONOMY
69
organizational) at its disposal, and that by 1911 very little new ('advanced', 'modern') technology had been imported and adopted or generated internally. Neither the state nor the private sector, moreover, was ideologically and fiscally competent to promote 'economic development' as a priority policy. On the other hand, in spite of sectoral and local strains, by the end of the Ch'ing dynasty there was little to suggest that this economic system was in mortal agony, ripe to be overthrown and discarded. Much of the population lived close to - but still at a distance from, it is important to state - a minimum level of subsistence. Social disorder and class conflict were endemic. But rather than being symptoms of fundamental systemic malignancies, this turbulence seemsto have oscillated in scope and intensity with the occurrence of temporary and largely random crises exogenous to the economic system itself: flood and drought, seasonal crop failures, banditry and civil war, foreign incursions, official corruption. Eventually, in the absence of technological advancements, the inexorable pressure of population on land could be expected to threaten the viability of the whole economy. A confrontation of this magnitude was, however, not yet on the agenda at the beginning of the twentieth century. In 'normal' years the population, rural and urban, could be provided for, however poorly. As it happened the ideological and political components of the ancien rigime collapsed and were discarded earlier than those that may be properly described as economic. When new political forces turned consciously to the task of economic development, they perhaps overconfidently assumed that the traditional economy too had been substantially undermined in the revolutionary century before 1949. They thought there was nothing inherent in the basic values or structure of the Chinese economy which would prevent rapid economic growth once the onerous fetters on the people's strength had been removed. That hope continues to haunt Peking.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
CHAPTER 2
LATE CH'ING FOREIGN RELATIONS, 1866-1905
THE CHANGING CONTEXT
A new era dawned in Chinese foreign relations after 1861. Western belligerence had given way to moderation, and Chinese resistance to accommodation. Defeat in the two wars and the Anglo-French occupation of Peking climaxed by the burning of the Summer Palace in 1860 had shocked the more pragmatic Ch'ing officials into a realization that a new international situation had set in and that the contemporary Westerners were basically different from the barbarians who had disturbed China in earlier times. There was a growing feeling that 'the West wind is blowing East', and that it could not be stopped. It was therefore imperative that China accept this reality, however unpleasant. The more progressive scholars and statesmen resolved to honour China's treaty obligations, to modernize her diplomatic practice, to create Western-style industry and enterprises, and to employ foreigners to help manage the new situation. As a result, a proto-foreign office was established in 1861, a text on international law was translated in 1864, an imperial audience was granted to foreign diplomats without the kotow in 1873, and diplomatic missions were established abroad after 1876. By 1880 China had taken her place in the family of nations and learned to struggle for survival in a world of social Darwinism just like any other state. In form, the Confucian universal empire (t'ien-hsia) had been metamorphosed into a nation-state (kuo-chia), but in spirit the old Middle Kingdom world view still lingered. Torn between tradition and modernity, China went to war to defend Vietnam and Korea in the 1880s and 1890s, partly to fulfil her tributary obligations and partly to exert her suzerainty in the manner of Western colonial powers. When the wars were lost, the tribute system was shattered in theory as well as in practice, marking the total disintegration of the imperial tradition of foreign intercourse. On the Western side, there was also a change of attitude, policy and power relationships among the leading states. Foreign governments and traders in the early 1860s were on the whole satisfied with the concessions of the recent treaties. Britain in particular had decided to curb her Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
THE CHANGING CONTEXT
Jl
nationals' adventurous, expansionist tendencies lest she be drawn into administering a tottering Ch'ing empire. The Mutiny of 1857 in India, which demonstrated the extreme difficulty of governing Hindus and Muslims, was a sufficient lesson to London that Britain should not seek additional territorial possessions in the East. The new emphasis was to obtain political influence, economic privileges and strategic security without the burden and expense of a colony.1 Hence British policy after 1861 was to support Chinese political stability and maintain British commercial pre-eminence by peaceful means - a marked departure from the forceful approach that had characterized the earlier confrontation. This policy of moderation, along with the rising assertiveness of other powers and the growing independence of other foreign diplomats in Peking, signalled the beginning, however imperceptible at the time, of the gradual decline of British domination of Western relations with China. While Britain continued to be paramount until the end of the century, she was slowly losing the indisputable position of leadership she had once commanded. During the generation after 1870, British interests were in fact threatened by Japan's extension of influence to Formosa (Taiwan) and acquisition of the Liu-ch'iu (Ryukyu) and Bonin Islands, by Russian activities in Sinkiang, by the French annexation of Indo-China, and finally by the Japanese detachment of Korea which opened the door to the 1898 'Scramble for Concessions' in China.2 Late Ch'ing foreign relations must be examined both in the global context of intensified imperialism and shifting power configurations among the leading Western states and Japan, and also against the background of the progressive decline of Manchu rule and the disintegration of the imperial tradition of foreign intercourse. FOREIGN RELATIONS, I 866—7 J
As China began a diplomatic modernization, Robert Hart, the young Inspector-General of Customs, and Thomas Wade, charge" d'affaires of the British legation, promoted the idea of 'progress', and under their influence the first Chinese mission was sent abroad. The Pin-ch'un Mission, 1866
On 6 November 1865 Robert Hart submitted a memorandum to the Tsungli Yamen entitled 'Observations by an outsider' ('Chii-wai p'ang1
Ronald Robinson, John Gallagher and Alice Denny, Africa and the Victoriant: the climax of imperialism, 6, 8, I O - I I , 471.
3
L. K. Young, British policy in China, iSfj-iyoi,
5, 7-13.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
72
FOREIGN RELATIONS, 1866-19OJ
kuan lun'), in which he stressed the advantages of railways, steamships, telegraphs, mining and Western diplomatic practices. Tactfully he implied that acceptance of his advice would make China strong while rejection might turn her towards international servitude. 'The view of an outside observer is neither unconsidered nor coercive. What the foreign nations will demand in the future does not aim at hurting China; they merely hope that peace and friendship with her may be maintained.' Diplomatic representation abroad was considered by Hart as of 'paramount importance', because it would enable China to bypass the headstrong diplomats in Peking and make direct representations to foreign governments which were more fair-minded. This move would help China to preserve her independence and also 'constitute a tie which should bind her to the West so firmly and commit her to a career of improvement so certainly as to make retrogression impossible'.3 Prince Kung found Hart 'quite capable of making vigilant examination of Chinese and foreign situations', but felt that his views could not be implemented for the moment.* Following the Hart memorandum, Thomas Wade also presented to the Tsungli Yamen in 1866 a communication called 'A brief exposition of new ideas' ('Hsin-i lueh-lun'), expounding the usefulness of railways, telegraphs, mining, schooling, Westernized army training, and diplomatic representation. Wade warned that foreigners today were different from the barbarians of the past such as the Hsiung-nu, and unless China recognized this fact and sought progress along Western lines her fate would be sealed. In particular, diplomatic representation abroad would bring great benefits, for mutual communication would create a warm feeling between governments and forestall troubles. 'Even if [China] should be embroiled in a quarrel with a certain country, if she was in the right, other nations would of course come forward to assist her with good offices, if not with armed assistance.' Wade urged that China should not look to the past for guidance but to the future.s As a consequence of these promptings, the Tsungli Yamen decided to send an informal exploratory mission to Europe under the guidance of Hart during his furlough in 1866. The mission was headed by Pin-ch'un, a 63-year-old ex-prefect and Hart's secretary for Chinese correspondence. Though Pin-ch'un was given a temporary third class civil service rank to 1
Chinese text in Cb'ing-tai cb'ou-pan i-au tbib-mo (Complete record of the management of barbarian affairs). T'ung-chih period (hereafter IWSM-TC), 40.14-22. See also Robert Hart, 'Notes on Chinese matters', in Frederick W. Williams, Amon Bwrlingame and thefirstChinese mission to foreign powers, 285.
• WSM-TC, 40.10b. » Chinese text in IWSM-TC, 40.22b-} ib. The original English text is lost, but H. E. Wodehouse made a free translation from the Chinese text; see his 'Mr. Wade on China', The China Weview, 1.1 (July-Aug. 1872) $8-44, and i.2(Sept.-Oct. 187a) 118-24.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
FOREIGN RELATIONS, I 8 6 6 - 7 J
73
add dignity to his mission, Prince Kung made it clear that it was not a formal diplomatic mission, but only an information-gathering junket to the West. Being unofficial, it would obviate touchy questions of protocol and avoid the high cost of a regular embassy. The mission visited London, Copenhagen, Stockholm, St Petersburg, Berlin, Brussels and Paris, and its novelty insured it a gracious welcome everywhere. Upon their return, members of the mission recorded detailed descriptions of what they had seen. Unfortunately, their observations were mainly limited to Western social customs, tall buildings, gaslights, elevators and machines; only in passing did they touch upon political institutions. The mission nevertheless signified China's first effort towards dispatching embassies abroad, but establishment of regular legations had to wait until 1877. The Burlingame Mission and the Alcock Convention
While Western governments followed a 'Cooperative Policy' at Peking in the 1860s, foreign traders and Old China Hands in the treaty ports increasingly clamoured for a more aggressive policy - to lay open all of China to Western commerce and promote 'progress' through adoption of railways, telegraphs, mining and other modern enterprises. Their pronouncements and the memoranda of Hart and Wade aroused fear in the Tsungli Yamen that the British were about to make new demands during the forthcoming treaty revision scheduled for 1868. The Yamen anxiously polled the powerful provincial authorities for their views on issues that were likely to arise. Tseng Kuo-fan, the leading statesman and governor-general at Nanking, suggested that China temperately but resolutely rejects all foreign demands regarding railways, telegraphs, inland navigation, transportation of salt in Chinese waters, and opening of warehouses, as these activities would harm the livelihood of the Chinese people. Mining, however, was potentially profitable and China might avail herself of foreign tools in the initial phase of operations. He believed that China should open diplomatic missions abroad when suitable men and funds were available, but he showed no concern about missionary activities, believing that their alternating periods of success and decline - according to the funds available - made them relatively ineffective and harmless.6 Similar views were expressed by Li Hung-chang, governor-general of Hunan and Hupei, who was in touch with Tseng. Li attempted to calm the court's anxiety by pointing out the difference between treaty revision and peace negotiations: the former implied mutual discussion without the forcible imposition of one nation's demands upon the other; failure to reach an agreement would not bring 1
1WSM-TC, 54.1-4, 18 Dec. 1867.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
74
FOREIGN RELATIONS, 1 8 6 6 - 1 9 0 5
hostilities, whereas failure in the latter might. Hence in the forthcoming treaty revision there would be room for a dispassionate exchange of views without the risk of war.7 The Tsungli Yamen's fears were, in reality, unfounded as London looked without favour upon the Old China Hands' push for hasty 'progress' in China. In August 1867, Lord Stanley, the foreign secretary, assured Minister Rutherford Alcock in Peking that 'We must not expect the Chinese, either the Government or the people, at once to see things in the same light that we see them; . . . we must lead and not force the Chinese to the adoption of a better system.'8 The Tsungli Yamen, not having diplomatic agents in London, had no inkling of the British policy, but common sense suggested the application of the old principle of playing off the barbarians against one another. Prince Kung and Wen-hsiang invited the retiring American minister, Anson Burlingame, who had offered to act as if he were China's envoy if needed, to join a roving diplomatic mission to dissuade European and American governments from forcing the pace of Westernization in China. Burlingame readily accepted: 'When the oldest nation in the world, containing one-third of the human race, seeks, for the first time, to come into relations with the West, and requests the youngest nation through its representative, to act as the medium of such change, the mission is one not to be solicited or rejected.'9 Accompanied by a Manchu and a Chinese co-envoy,10 Burlingame led the mission to the United States in May 1868. His eloquence and charm captivated the Americans and, after a flattering interview with President Andrew Johnson, he signed a treaty with Secretary of State Seward on 28 July 1868. It committed the United States to a policy of noninterference in the development of China, and stipulated the sending of Chinese consuls and labourers to the United States and reciprocal rights of residence, religion, travel and access to schools. Though Burlingame acted on his own authority, without the prior approval of the Chinese government, Peking was too grateful to disown the treaty. In London, the mission was received by Queen Victoria. Lord Clarendon, foreign secretary, assured Burlingame on 28 December 1868 that provided China observed her treaty obligations faithfully, she was 'entitled to count upon the forebearance of foreign nations' and that Britain had 'neither a desire nor intention to apply unfriendly pressure to China to induce her Government to advance more rapidly in her intercourse with foreign 7
Ibid. 55.6-10, 31 Dec. 1867. China correspondence, no. 5 (1871), document 1, p. 8. • Foreign relation! of the United States, 1868, 1.494. 10 Chih-kang and Sun Chia-ku. 8
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
FOREIGN RELATIONS, 1 8 6 6 - 7 5
75
nations than was consistently with safety, and with due and reasonable regards for the feelings of her subjects.'" Alcock was informed of this assurance and was instructed to act accordingly in his forthcoming negotiations for treaty revision.'2 Having secured the British promise, Burlingame moved on to Berlin, where he obtained from Bismarck a pledge that the North German Confederation would deal with China in whatever manner Peking considered in its best interest. After all these successes, Burlingame contracted pneumonia at St Petersburg and died on 23 February 1869. The mission, however, continued on to Brussels and Rome and returned to China in October 1870. Burlingame's mission was successful in its immediate objective for it did commit Western powers to a policy of restraint in the forthcoming treaty revision, yet, in the long run, it encouraged the growth of conservatism in China. The mandarins, who spent 160,000 taels on the mission, came to believe that foreigners could be managed at a price and became more complacent and less responsive to outside stimuli. During the prolonged discussion of treaty revision, the British mercantile community vigorously promoted the opening of all China and demanded new concessions on telegraphs, railways, mining, inland navigation and residence. Alcock firmly resisted their pressure and conducted the negotiations in a spirit of moderation and conciliation. In this he was strongly supported by Clarendon and by the influential under-secretary of the Board of Trade, Louis Mallet, who, in a lengthy position paper on 19 May 1869, favoured a 'safe course' in China to consolidate the position already gained, and the use of moral influence, moderation and patience to achieve future developments.13 On 4 June 1869 Clarendon practically authorized Alcock to accept any arrangement satisfactory to the Chinese and 'wait for a more favourable and complete revision of Treaties' in the future: 'Her Majesty's Government are content that you should agree to accept what you can obtain at once.'14 The actual negotiations were conducted as between equals, without military threats, for the first time since the Opium War. The resultant Alcock Convention of 23 October 1869 allowed China to establish a consulate at Hong Kong; to increase the import duty on opium by 2.5 per cent ad valorem and the export duty on silk by a fraction over 1 per cent; and to " China correspondence, no. i (1869). Correspondence respecting the relations between Great Britain and China, document 1, The Earl of Clarendon to Mr Burlingame, 28 Dec. 1868. 11 Ibid, document 2, Clarendon to Alcock, 30 Dec. 1868. 13 China correspondence, no. 5 (1871), Correspondence respecting the revision of the Treaty of Tientsin, document 107, p. 355. 14 Ibid, document 117, Clarendon to Alcock, 4 June 1869.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
•j6
FOREIGN RELATIONS, 1 8 6 6 - 1 9 0 5
qualify the most-favoured-nation arrangement so that the British must accept the conditions under which certain rights were granted other powers, if they wished to claim the benefits of those rights. Other provisions included the opening of Wenchow and Wuhu and the closing of Kiungchow on Hainan which was useless; an additional 2.5 per cent transit duty on British textile imports at the port of entry; foreign navigation on inland waterways in traditional Chinese boats owned by foreigners; steam navigation on Poyang Lake; a conditional and qualified right of foreign temporary residence in the interior; and Chinese assent to adopt a written code of commercial law. All in all, the terms of the convention demonstrated mutual concessions. The Tsungli Yamen was of course proud of this first equal agreement and considered it final when both sides signed it. Ratification by London was regarded as a formality, since no previous treaties with foreign powers were unratified. Therefore, the Yamen urged the court to approve the convention quickly, especially in view of the growing British mercantile hostility towards the agreement.15 Alcock himself was highly satisfied with the results of his work. To Clarendon he proudly stated: 'I believe it [the Convention] will be found to secure advantages far in advance of the objects contemplated in the XXVII [or revision] Article of the Treaty.' That he could have achieved these results, Alcock acknowledged, was due in no small part to the mediatory service of Robert Hart: 'I believe it was mainly through his active intervention that they [the Yamen ministers] were at last led to see the expediency, if not advantage, of ceding many points previously insisted upon, and offering me terms I felt justified in accepting.'16 With pride Alcock proclaimed that 'We are no longer dictating conditions of peace, but negotiating for reciprocal advantages upon an equal footing'." However, the British mercantile communities, both at home and in China and Hong Kong, scorned Alcock's diplomacy and scoffed at the idea of treating China 'as a country entitled to the same rights and privileges as civilized nations'. l8 They strenuously opposed the terms of the convention, especially the Chinese consul at Hong Kong, whom they saw as a revenue officer and a spy. Numerous memorials were sent to Parliament arguing against the ratification of the agreement." Reinforcing the mercantile " IWSM-TC, 68.14-14IJ, 23 Oct. 1869. China correspondence, no. 1 (1869), Alcock to Clarendon, 18 Oct. 1869. " China correspondence, no. 5 (i 8 7')> P- 360, Alcock to Mcdhurst, 1 April 1869. 18 Stanley F. Wright, Hart and the Chinese customs, 382. •• Texts of these memorials may be found in China correspondence, no. 4 (1870), no. 6 (1870). They were presented by merchants and others in London interested in trade with China, and Chambers of Commerce from Glasgow, Leith, Edinburgh, Dundee, Manchester, Macclesficld, Shanghai, Foochow and Hong Kong. 16
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
FOREIGN RELATIONS, I 8 6 6 - 7 5
77
opposition were unfavourable foreign attitudes. Except for the American charge d'affaires, Dr S. Wells Williams, who praised the convention as 'a victory of peace', most other diplomats were cool and non-committal. In the face of such adverse reactions, Alcock defended the agreement forcefully, pointing out that 'no country or Western government has ever before made such liberal concessions to foreign trade' and that China had granted greater religious toleration and a more moderate tariff than most European states.20 Yet these arguments could not outweigh the combined force of strong mercantile opposition and lukewarm foreign attitudes. Lord Granville, foreign secretary after Clarendon, decided that ratification of the convention would increase rather than decrease misunderstanding and friction, and accordingly rejected it on 25 July 1870. This was an act undoubtedly detrimental to both Chinese and foreign interests. The Tsungli Yamen felt betrayed in its trust in foreign goodwill and friendly international relations. The feeling was common among its negotiators that foreigners only took but never gave and that the minute a treaty slightly unfavourable to them was negotiated they disowned it. According to Thomas Wade who succeeded Alcock as minister, Wenhsiang was 'thirsting for revenge because of the discredit and inconvenience our rejection of the Convention has occasioned, . . . the difficulties of the legation are infinitely multiplied by the rejection of the Convention of 1869'.21 Yet in its report to the court on the British rejection of the agreement, the Yamen was surprisingly mild and devoid of bitterness: It is true that in foreign political systems, the government's authority is weak while the merchants' influence is strong. . . . We have told him [Wade] in sharp, reproving language that if the new agreement is not implemented, Chinese and foreign traders and people will have no faith in future transactions, etc.. . . We [the Yamen] suspect that the large items wanted most by foreigners such as telegraph lines, railways, transportation of salt, and mining have been rejected by China, and even those items agreed to [made them feel] that their gains cannot compensate for their losses. Hence their dilatory tactic.22 The restraint exhibited by the Yamen was obviously part of a doublebarrelled tactic. To the Chinese it played down the importance of the rejection of the convention,23 but to the foreigner it played up the dire consequences of British bad faith. Clearly, there was no point in the Yamen 10
21
21
China correspondence, no. 10 (1870), Memorandum by Sir R. Alcock on 'Further memorials respecting the China Treaty Convention", 3 May 1870, p. 9. Nathan A. Pelcovits, Old China bands and the Foreign Office, 104, citing FO, 17/654, 16 May 1873. « IWSM-TC, 79.40-40^ 21 Jan. 1871. Apart from the Yamen report just cited, there was a conspicuous absence of reference to the British rejection of the Alcock Convention in court documents such as the Veritable records (Sbib-lu) and the Tung-bua lu, and works of leading statesmen such as Tseng, Tso, Li, Wenhsiang, Wo-jen, Shen Pao-chen, Feng Kuei-fen and Wang Chih-ch'un.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
78
FOREIGN RELATIONS, 1 8 6 6 - I 9 0 5
publicizing the failure of its policy of international conciliation, but demonstration of disappointment to. foreigners served the purpose of putting them on the defensive. It would be an overstatement to suggest that the rejection of the Alcock Convention ended a decade of goodwill between China and foreign powers, and gave rise to a wave of anti-foreignism in the 1870s. Antiforeign riots had occurred before 1869, while Chinese disappointment following the British rejection was limited to a small circle of officials without much public awareness. Pragmatic officials such as Tseng Kuo-fan and Li Hung-chang continued to behave responsibly in their foreign dealings. Anti-foreign riots were mostly instigated by gentry who knew little about the British rejection. Hence it is hard to establish a direct link between the rejection and anti-foreignism; but it is certain that the British action confirmed the Chinese view that foreigners were greedy in nature andficklein behaviour. If the Burlingame Mission heightened Chinese complacency, the rejection of the Alcock Convention reaffirmed Chinese suspicion of foreign trustworthiness. Both events had an adverse effect on Sino-Western relations.24 The Tientsin Massacre, 1870
Even as Burlingame was touring the United States, inviting missionaries to 'plant the shining cross on every hill' in China, anti-Christian activities broke out across the country. Christianity, as a heterodox faith, was antithetical to Confucianism, and its practice of mixed congregations ran counter to Chinese custom and aroused rumours of immoral and perverted behaviour (see volume 10, chapter 11). Missionary protection of Chinese converts and the construction of churches in disregard of time-honoured concepts of geomancy (feng-shui) irritated Chinese sensibilities.25 AntiChristian tracts appeared frequently and eruption of anti-missionary activities under gentry instigation was common. These activities elicited a ready reprisal from foreign representatives who felt, as did Rutherford Alcock, that failure to act would result in a 'serious loss of prestige and influence, on which everything depends in the East'. Thus in August 1868, when a mob in Yangchow plundered and set fire to the new missionary station of the China Inland Mission, Alcock sent Consul W. H. Medhurst ** Mary C. Wright, The last stand of Chinese conservatism; the Tung-chib restoration, 1862-1874, 299: 'As the recapture of Anking and the founding of the Tsungli-yamen had symbolized the beginning of the Restoration, so the rejection of the Alcock Convention and the Tientsin Massacre symbolized its end.' " For an excellent study of the missionary problem, see Paul A. Cohen, China and Christianity: the missionary movement and the growth of Chinese antiforeignism, 1860—1870, chs. 3—7.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
FOREIGN RELATIONS, I 8 6 6 - 7 5
79
and four ships to Nanking to force Governor-general Tseng Kuo-fan to cashier the Yangchow officials and pay compensation. Again, in November 1868, when a mob in Taiwan attacked foreign merchants in an effort to break the camphor monopoly, British interpreter John Gibson and Lieutenant T. P. Gurdon blew up the Chinese military installations at Anping and exacted 40,000 taels. Such actions produced quick results but invariably inflamed public feeling and aroused xenophobia. Even London found the Alcock-Medhurst action contrary to British policy and condemned the Gibson-Gurdon move as 'reprehensible' and 'rash and inexcusable'.26 In 1870, Tientsin was the site of a major anti-Christian riot. It is not by chance that Tientsin was the scene of the outburst, for it had twice been occupied by foreign troops - during the negotiations of the Treaties of Tientsin in 1858, and the Conventions of Peking in i860. Even after the peace settlement, portions of the Anglo-French forces remained in Taku until 1865. The presence of foreign troops was always a cause of irritation, and additional fuel came from the French seizure of the imperial villa27 in Tientsin in i860 for use as a consulate. In 1869, the church and orphanage of Notre Dame des Victoires was constructed on the site of a razed Buddhist temple. As few Chinese would send orphans to the foreign establishment, the nuns offered a premium for each child, thereby encouraging rascals, known as 'child brokers', to kidnap children. The offer of a premium and the high mortality rate - the nuns were particularly interested in baptizing sick and dying children - inevitably aroused suspicion. Rumour spread that behind their high walls and closed gates, the foreigners bewitched the children, mutilated their bodies, and extracted their hearts and eyes to make medicines. In 1870, Ch'ung-hou, superintendent of trade for the northern ports, inspected the orphanage and found no truth in the wild charges. Then the truculent French consul, Henri Fontanier, and his chancellor suddenly appeared armed with pistols and demanding justice for the nuns. Angry at the sight of the mob which the magistrate had been unable to disperse, Fontanier fired a shot which missed the magistrate but killed his servant. In retaliation the mob killed Fontanier and his assistant, and burned the church and orphanage. Ten nuns, two priests, two French officials and three Russian traders were killed, and four British and American churches were destroyed. This crisis summarily dispelled a decade of goodwill and cooperation. Foreign gunboats quickly anchored off Tientsin, and strong 26
John K. Fairbank, 'Patterns behind the Tientsin massacre', HJAS, 20.3-4 (Dec. 1957) 482-3, 488, 501. " Known as the 'Sea-viewing Pavilion', or 'Wang-hai lou'.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
80
FOREIGN RELATIONS, 1 8 6 6 - I 9 O 5
protests from seven foreign ministers were lodged with the Tsungli Yamen, demanding redress and punishment of the rioters. The court appointed its most venerable servant, Tseng Kuo-fan, now governor-general of Chihli, to investigate the case. Ill and aged, Tseng accepted the strenuous assignment only to find the situation far knottier than he had anticipated. The French charge d'affaires demanded the lives of the vigorously anti-foreign General Ch'en Kuo-jui and the Tientsin prefect and magistrate, while conservative Chinese officials and literati clamoured against any concession or appeasement. In this precarious situation, Tseng showed great integrity and courage. Rather than cater safely to public sentiment he risked his political future with the candid recommendation that the absolute truth of the case be established. He advised the court that Britain, the United States and Russia be indemnified first to dissociate them from the French cause. Tseng then visited the orphanage and learned firsthand from the children there that they were not kidnapped but had been sent by their families voluntarily. He asked the court to restore the reputation of the nuns by issuing a proclamation denying the rumours of cruel treatment of the children. For the settlement of the case, Tseng recommended dismissal of the taotai, the Tientsin prefect and the district magistrate; capital punishment for fifteen chief instigators and banishment for twenty-one others. If this did not satisfy the French, Tseng stated, greater punishment might be imposed. The conservatives immediately condemned Tseng as a traitor. The Hunan Association in Peking burned his calligraphy which had adorned its wall, and Grand Secretary Wo-jen ridiculed the idea of bargaining with the French about the penalty. The court, too, found Tseng's recommendations hard to accept. At this juncture, Li Hung-chang, governor-general at Wuchang, submitted a more palatable solution, suggesting capital punishment of eight and exile of twenty. Li was transferred to Tientsin to take over the investigation and Tseng was sent to Nanking as governorgeneral. Overwhelmed by a sense of personal inadequacy and hounded by the conservatives' accusations, Tseng lapsed into despondency. He wrote to friends, 'I fear public criticism without, and am conscience stricken within.' French bellicosity in China was providentially tempered by the outbreak of the Franco-Prussian War in Europe. Li Hung-chang speedily settled the case, agreeing to pay a compensation of 400,000 taels, to send a mission of apology, to banish the Tientsin prefect and magistrate, and to sentence eighteen rioters to capital punishment and twenty-five to hard labour on the frontier. The apology mission, led by Ch'ung-hou, reached Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
FOREIGN RELATIONS, I 8 6 6 — 7 5
8l
France only to find the French government too involved in the Prussian War to receive it. The Tsungli Yamen then ordered Ch'ung-hou to return home. When he had reached New York, however, Ch'ung-hou was summoned back to France, where the provisional president, M. Thiers, received him at Versailles on 23 November 1871 and announced that France was not interested in decapitating the Chinese wrongdoers, but in securing lasting peace and order. The case was officially closed with Thiers' acceptance of the letter of apology from the Chinese emperor.28 The Audience Question,
Even though foreign diplomats took up residence in Peking in 1861, they were continuously denied audience with the boy emperor. Prince Kung received them in his capacity as semi-regent and explained that an audience was inadvisable during the emperor's minority. Though they agreed that there was little point in demanding a meeting with a five-year-old emperor, the foreign representatives argued that repeated delay of the audience was an act of unfriendliness. Chinese postponement was due, of course, to the knowledge that foreigners would not perform the kotow, thus denying the myth of China's universal overlordship and the.ancient tributary practice. The Tsungli Yamen's tactics put off but did not solve the question of audience. Therefore, during the secret discussion of treaty revision in 1867, the Yamen solicited views on the question from leading provincial authorities. The majority were content to sidestep the issue until the emperor's majority. Li Hung-chang declared that contact with Prince Kung was sufficient access to the throne and that foreign representatives could gain nothing through personal audience with the emperor. As to the ceremonies for audiences following the emperor's majority, he suggested foreign ministers should be allowed to perform such rituals as they would before their own rulers. Tseng Kuo-fan asserted that just as the K'ang-hsi Emperor (1662-1722) had treated Russia as an enemy state on an equal footing rather than as an inferior, dependent state, the court should also regard foreign ministers as envoys from enemy states of equal status exempt from Chinese customs. A number of conservative officials, however, argued that China should not change her institutions and practices to suit the convenience of foreigners. In 1872 the emperor reached his majority and was married, but no foreign diplomats were invited to the celebration; this avoided protocol problems. In February 1873, he inaugurated his personal rule and foreign a8
Knight Biggcrstaff, 'The Ch'ung-hou mission to France, 1870-71', Nankai SocialandEconomic Quarterly, 8.3 (Oct. 1935) 633-47.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
82
FOREIGN RELATIONS, 1 8 6 6 - I 9 0 5
representatives renewed their demand for an audience. Unable to defer the issue longer, the Tsungli Yamen conducted protracted discussions with the diplomats as to the proper rituals and finally agreed that foreign representatives should simply bow instead of kotow during the audience. On Sunday 29 June 1873, the foreign diplomats convened at 5.30 a.m. but were not received by the T'ung-chih Emperor at the Pavilion of Violet Light until 9.00 a.m. The Japanese foreign minister, Soejima Taneomi, who was in Peking to exchange ratifications of a treaty of 1871, took this opportunity to demonstrate his mastery of Western diplomacy and assert Japanese equality with the Western powers by insisting that his ambassadorial rank entitled him to precede the Western ministers. He was therefore received first, followed in order of seniority by the Russian, American, British, French and Dutch ministers and the German interpreter. They laid their credentials on a table before the emperor, who expressed, through Prince Kung, his amicable feelings towards the foreign sovereigns represented there. The audience, for which Western diplomats had waited twelve years, took no more than half an hour. 2» It was an anticlimax, the more so when the foreign representatives later learned that the pavilion in which they had been received was also used for the reception of tributary envoys.30 The Margary Affair,
187;
The great depression in Europe in the early 1870s, brought on partly by the tariff war there, adversely affected the China trade, which declined steadily after 1872. To brighten trade prospects, the British revived a scheme to open a back door to interior China by constructing a railway and trade route from Burma to Yunnan and the upper Yangtze. Captain Richard Sprye, a retired Indian army officer, had first proposed the idea in 18 5 8 as a means to counter the Russian advance from the northwest and the American move across the Pacific. London was unimpressed but Sprye, undaunted, repeated the proposal to each new foreign secretary. Lord John Russell, foreign minister in 1859, remarked, 'Captain Sprye is a visionary who indulges in the wildest notions . . . there is a certain degree of interest attaching to his schemes but they are impracticable.'31 The foreign office believed that such a back-door thrust would create troubles without a compensating commercial benefit. In 1874, the idea was revived *• British parliamentary papers, China, no. 1 (1874): Correspondence respecting the audience granted to Her Majesty's minister and the other foreign representatives at Peking by the emperor of China. 10 Such as in 1839-43, 1845-8 and 1864. See John K. Fairbank, ed. The Chinese world order: traditional China'sforeign relation! (hereafter CWO), 262. 31 Pelcovits, Old China bands, 115, citing FO 17/470, 22 Nov. 1859.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
FOREIGN RELATIONS, I 8 6 6 - 7 5
8
5
as Lord Salisbury, the only high official to fancy the project, became head of the India office in the Disraeli ministry. He ordered the Indian government to survey the proposed route and requested the foreign office to instruct the minister in Peking to seek Chinese permission for the entry of an exploratory mission from Burma. Though sceptical of the commercial possibilities of such a route, Thomas Wade found the Chinese government readily assented to his request and agreed to let a British vice-consul, 28-year-old Raymond Augustus Margary, travel up the Yangtze River to meet the mission. Aware of the hostility to foreigners of guerrilla bands in the Chinese-Burmese border area, and despite warnings from local Chinese officials, Margary ventured on to Bhamo on the frontier to await the mission from Burma. There, on 21 February 1875, Margary was ambushed and killed. Though international law relieves the host country of responsibility when a foreigner exposes himself to danger at his own risk, the British government obdurately held the Chinese government responsible and instructed Wade to obtain redress. The ambitious Wade demanded an investigation of the murder, an indemnity for the bereaved family, another expedition, and trial of the acting governor-general of Yunnan and Kweichow in whose jurisdiction the incident took place. He also raised the extraneous issues of audience procedure, transit dues, better etiquette in the treatment of foreign diplomats, and an apology mission to Britain. Peking agreed to an investigation and an indemnity but frowned on the other questions. Wade then impetuously withdrew his legation to Shanghai and, amidst rumours that he had entered into a pact with the Russian minister engaging a British army from India and a Russian force from Hi, he threatened to break off relations. To avoid a rupture, on 29 August 1875 the court authorized the dispatch of an apology mission to Britain headed by Kuo Sung-tao, and sent Robert Hart to Shanghai to persuade Wade to resume discussions. When Hart tactfully intimated that Kuo might initiate settlement proceedings in London, excluding Wade from all claims to credit, the British minister agreed to meet with Li Hung-chang at the summer resort of Chefoo. On 1} September 1876, the Chefoo Convention was concluded to settle the Margary case. Part I dealt with the dispatch of an apology mission to Britain and the payment of 200,000 taels to the bereaved family. Part II provided for the preparation of an etiquette code for the Chinese government and foreign diplomats. Part III dealt with the opening of four new ports and the limitation of likin-free areas to treaty ports. However, the British government failed to ratify this convention until 1885 due to opposition from: (1) the United States, Germany, France and Russia, who
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
84
FOREIGN RELATIONS, 1 8 6 6 - 1 9 0 5
criticized Britain's unilateral action; (2) the British mercantile community, which sought complete abolition of the likin; and (3) the Indian government, which protested against the increase in the opium tax. The most significant outcome of the Margary incident was the dispatch of the mission of apology, which became the first resident Chinese legation abroad. Kuo Sung-tao, a progressive sixty-year-old friend of Li Hungchang, was given the title of vice-president of the Board of War prior to his departure for Britain. After the presentation of the emperor's letter of apology to Queen Victoria on 8 February 1877, he set up the Chinese legation in London. In the next two years, other legations were established in Paris, Berlin, Spain, Washington, Tokyo and St Petersburg. By 1880 China had belatedly taken her place in the family of nations. China's slowness in reciprocating the Western practice of diplomatic representation may be attributed to several causes." Institutionally, she had never dispatched permanent, resident embassies abroad but only ad hoc missions, which were sent out either in times of strength and prosperity to spread the prestige of the Son of Heaven and to bring outlying states into the tributary system, or in times of weakness and disorder to beg for peace or alliance with barbarian tribes. Psychologically, the majority of mandarins eschewed foreign affairs as beneath their dignity, and foreign assignment as a form of banishment. Burlingame's two associates had fared badly after their return: one was sent to an obscure post in western China, and the other to the Mongolian frontier, as if they had been contaminated by their foreign trip. To the question 'Who among men of rectitude today excels in foreign affairs?' a grand secretary replied: 'Do men of rectitude care to engage in foreign affairs?'32 The censors, the Hanlin scholars and the conservative gentry and officials repeatedly proclaimed that historically barbarians were transformed by Chinese ways, not the Chinese by barbarian ways. They promoted conservatism against modernization and condemned foreign association as disgraceful. So powerful was the conservative atmosphere and the psychological inertia that it had taken China more than fifteen years to overcome this barrier and reciprocate the Western practice of diplomatic representation.
ACCELERATION OF IMPERIALISM IN FRONTIER AREAS AND TRIBUTARY STATES
The last three decades of the nineteenth century were a period of accelerated foreign imperialism in China. Europe, experiencing 'a generation of « Inunanuel C. Y. Hsu, China's intranet into the family of nations: the diplomatic phase
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
ACCELERATION OF IMPERIALISM
85
materialism', was propelled by the forces of nationalism, evangelism and capitalism into heightened activity in Asia, Africa and the Middle East. Industrialization created a need for raw materials and overseas markets, and Social Darwinism sanctioned expansion as a struggle for survival among nations. Religious fervour fired devotees with the sense of a divine mission to evangelize the heathen. And to all this was added the proud, self-righteous feeling of racial superiority, expressed as the 'White Man's Burden'. 3 3 Epochal events of the 1860s - the end of the Civil War in the United States, the Meiji Restoration in Japan, the rise of the Third Republic in France, and the unifications of Italy and Germany - liberated energies for action abroad. The completion of the Suez Canal in 1869 further facilitated European expansion, and newly modernized nations - notably Japan and Germany - joined the imperialist ranks. In contrast, China under the Empress Dowager Tz'u-hsi made little headway in self-improvement and regeneration; after a brief upsurge during the T'ung-chih period (1862-74), dynastic strength steadily declined. Taking advantage of China's weakness, foreign powers nibbled away the frontier areas and tributary states. Formosa ({Taiwan) and L.iu-ch'iu (RyuJkyu)
Japan had been a tributary state of China for a time during the Ming period (1368-1643), when the shogun Ashikaga Yoshimitsu accepted tributary status in order to enrich his coffers from trade. After the middle of the sixteenth century, however, nationalistic Japanese statesmen found such relations humiliating and discontinued official contact with China. After the establishment of the Ch'ing dynasty in 1644, official relations were still not resumed; the Manchu rulers, unlike the Ming emperors, never attempted to bring Japan into the tribute system. With the opening of China and Japan in the mid-nineteenth century, Japanese traders began to arrive in Shanghai on British and Dutch ships. By 1870, the Meiji government had decided to establish official relations with the Ch'ing dynasty and sent Yanagiwara Sakimitsu to Peking to seek a treaty. The Tsungli Yamen, though inclined to permit trade, was reluctant to sign a formal treaty. Conservative officials opposed treaty relations with a former tributary state because it might set a precedent for other tributaries such as Korea and Annam (the Chinese name for Vietnam). They cited further the past records of Japanese piracy along the China coast and the Japanese arrival at the time of the Tientsin Massacre as proof 11
Carlton J. H. Hayes, A generation of materialism, 1871-1900. William L. Langcr, Tbe diplomacy ofimperialism, iSf 0-1902.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
86
FOREIGN RELATIONS, 1 8 6 6 - 1 9 0 5
of their desire to take advantage of China. On the other hand, progressive officials like Li Hung-chang and Tseng Kuo-fan favoured treaty relations. Li said that Japan, though a tributary state of the Ming, was never a Ch'ing tributary; thus her status was basically different from that of Korea and Annam. That Japan sought official relations without an introduction by, or the aid of, a Western power, showed her independence and goodwill, and China should not begrudge her the request. Furthermore, the existence of large Chinese communities in Japan, China's importation of a considerable quantity of copper from Japan annually, and Japan's very proximity, led Li to recommend the establishment of equal treaty relations. Tseng concurred in these views and stressed, in addition, the reciprocal nature of Sino-Japanese trade as opposed to the largely one-sided Sino-Western trade. He approved of treaty relations but recommended withholding mostfavoured-nation treatment. On the strength of these recommendations, the court authorized the conclusion of a commercial treaty with Japan on 24 July 1871, which provided, among other things, for (1) nonaggression towards the other's territorial possessions; (2) a mutual offer of good offices in case of conflict with a third power; (3) mutual consular jurisdiction; (4) trade under a tariff in treaty ports only; and (5) no appointment of Japanese merchant consuls in China. In 1873, the Japanese foreign minister Soejima Taneomi came to Peking, ostensibly to exchange ratifications, but actually to participate in the T'ung-chih audience and to determine China's position on the Formosa incident. By capitalizing on this incident, which concerned the killing of fifty-four shipwrecked Ryukyuan sailors by Formosan aborigines late in 1871, Japan attempted to assert her exclusive right to speak for the RyukyGans. The question of Ryukyu's status, which had been ambivalent for two-and-a-half centuries, was thus thrust to the fore. Ryukyu (Liu-ch'iu in Chinese) had been a regular tributary of China since 1372. During the Ch'ing it paid tribute every other year and, with Korea and Annam, was one of the three most important tributary states. In 1609, unknown to China, the Satsuma ban (feudatory) of Japan subjugated Liuch'iu, putting the northern part under its direct administration and leaving the southern part to the Liu-ch'iu king. As a vassal, Liu-ch'iu paid tribute annually to Satsuma and periodically to the shogunal court at Edo (Tokyo). Eager to reap the benefits of the mainland trade, however, Satsuma directed Liu-ch'iu to continue its tributary relations with China. Satsuma determined Liu-ch'iu's royal succession but allowed Chinese investiture missions to confirm the legitimacy of a new king's rule. During the Ch'ing period a total of eight such missions visited Liu-ch'iu, the last in Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
ACCELERATION OF IMPERIALISM
87
1866, and during their stays Satsuma took great care to remove evidence of the Japanese presence. Although members of the Chinese missions could not fail to note traces of Japanese influence, the Ch'ing court officially knew nothing of Liu-ch'iu's double status and treated it as an exclusively Chinese tributary state. *• Thus, when Soejima asserted the right to speak for Liu-ch'iu in 1873, the Tsungli Yamen pointedly told him that as the islands were a Chinese tributary and Formosa part of China, the killing of sailors of one by aborigines of the other was no business of Japan. Moreover, as China had never interfered in the internal affairs of the aborigines, she could not be held responsible for their behaviour. Soejima argued that sovereignty over a territory was evidenced by effective control; since China did not control the Formosan aborigines, they were beyond her jurisdiction and any action by Japan to chastise them would not violate Chinese jurisdiction. The Japanese government then decided to send an expedition, and in April 1874 the Office of the Formosan Expedition was formed, with Okuma Shigenobu as director and Saigo Tsugumichi as commander of the expeditionary force. This move was in keeping with the Meiji foreign policy of expansion along Western imperialist lines, and served to divert domestic demands for representative assemblies and satisfy the clamour of ex-samurai for an expedition to Korea. Faced with the Japanese invasion, Peking ordered Shen Pao-chen, director of the Foochow Dockyard, to defend Formosa. Shen found effective defence impossible - for example, the guns cast by the Nanking Arsenal could only fire salutes and would burst when real explosive shells were used. An early attempt at settlement failed when Saigo refused to honour the agreement and on 10 September 1874 the home minister, Okubo Toshimichi, arrived in Peking to direct negotiations. Okubo repeated the argument that absence of effective Chinese administration on Formosa proved that China lacked sovereignty, and the Japanese landing, consequently, could not be construed as an invasion of Chinese territory. Prince Kung insisted that Sino-Japanese relations be governed, not by the general principles of international law, but by the treaty of 1871, which specifically stipulated nonaggression against each other's territorial possessions. Okubo retorted that the treaty concerned only Chinese-Japanese relations, not the Formosan aborigines who were beyond Chinese jurisdiction. A diplomatic impasse ensued and the British minister, Thomas Wade, offered to mediate. The case was finally settled when China agreed to pay half a million taels ($US7jo,ooo) of which " Robert K. Sakai, 'The Ryukyu (Liu-ch'iu) Islands as fief of Satsuma', and Ta-tuan Ch'en, 'Investiture of Liu-ch'iu kings in the Ch'ing period', in CWO, 112-34, 13J-64.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
88
FOREIGN RELATIONS, 1 8 6 6 - I 9 0 5
100,000 taels was for the Ryukyuan victims and 400,000 taels for the purchase of Japanese barracks constructed on Formosa. In addition, China agreed not to condemn the Japanese action - a concession which implied recognition of Japan's claim to sovereignty over Ryukyu. China's willingness to pay for being invaded - as the British minister in Japan, Sir Harry Parkes, sarcastically described it - was a blatant revelation of her weakness and an invitation to further foreign encroachment. In 1879 Japan annexed Liu-ch'iu and renamed it Okinawa Prefecture. The Hi Crisis, 1871-81 Hi, or Kulja in Russian, was a Chinese prefecture (/») governing nine cities in northern Sinkiang near the border of Russian Turkestan (see volume 10, chapter 2). The Hi valley was not only agriculturally and minerally rich but also strategically important - its Muzart Pass controlled communication with southern Sinkiang. Possession of Hi facilitated control of all Sinkiang, and Western military experts described Hi as the fortress of Chinese Turkestan. A place of such importance naturally attracted the attention of strong neighbours. In 1851 the Russians had secured the Treaty of Kulja which allowed them to establish consulates and conduct duty-free trade at Hi and Chuguchak (Tarbagatai) on the Mongolian border. The Hi trade grew rapidly and the continuous expansion of the Russians in Central Asia brought them ever closer to Hi. Taking advantage of a Muslim rebellion in Sinkiang in the 1860s, the Russians were ready to move into this important area. The Muslim Rebellion in Sinkiang had its roots in the corrupt local Ch'ing administration (see chapter 4). Since its conquest under the Ch'ienlung Emperor in 1759, Sinkiang had been governed as a military colony under the direction of a military governor at Hi, aided by a number of assistant military governors, imperial agents and some 21,760 troops at various key points. The high officials and officers were nearly all Manchus and bannermen, who ruled the populace - mostly Turki-speaking, turbanwearing Uighur Muslims - through local chieftains known as begs. The Manchu conquerors treated the subject Muslims as uncivilized aborigines, levying heavy taxes and exacting forced contributions to support their own unbridled extravagance. Muslim discontent inspired revolt, and the former hereditary and saintly rulers, or khojas, banished by the Ch'ing to Khokand, were ever anxious to re-establish themselves. The khojas of the Afaql line of the Makhdumzada family had once ruled Kashgaria (southern Sinkiang) before the Ch'ing conquest. They encouraged their co-religionists in Sinkiang to revolt, while they themselves organized Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
" ^
1
N
E S
E
'Turfan
J
M A P . 5 Central Asia Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
'HOT.,
0
I l l dovcr 1500m (4920ftl | L | 500 fcm
0
300miles
90
FOREIGN RELATIONS, 1 8 6 6 - I 9 0 5
invasions. During the century following the Ch'ing conquest, no less than a dozen uprisings and invasions took place. In 1864, amid the dynastic decline and a Muslim rebellion in North-West China, the Muslims in Sinkiang struck again. The local Ch'ing administration was too weak to suppress them, while the central government in Peking was too preoccupied with the Taiping, the Nien and other rebellions to undertake punitive measures (see volume 10, pages 74ff, and below, chapter 4).3S During the disorder, Ya'qub (Yakub) Beg (1820-77), a Khokandian general, entered Sinkiang in 1865, and through a series of military and political manipulations established himself by 1870 as the ruler of Kashgaria and part of the northern Sinkiang. The British in India, with a view to blocking the extension of Russian influence, encouraged his empirebuilding and sent missions to cultivate friendship and supply arms. The Russians viewed these developments with concern. They considered Ya'qQb's empire to be an extension of British influence, which when viewed in the larger context of Anglo-Russian rivalry in the Near East and Central Asia, took on added political significance. Moreover, the turmoil in Sinkiang had adversely affected the Russian trade and created unrest among the Kazakhs and the Kirgiz and other minorities in Russia. The Russian army, the bureaucrats and the bourgeois press all clamoured for a permanent occupation of Hi, but the government decided to occupy it only until Chinese authority was re-established in Sinkiang and then return it in exchange for new trade routes to Western China and certain 'rectifications of the border'.^6 In July 1871 General K. P. von Kaufman, the first governor-general of Russian Turkestan, sent troops to occupy Ili. St Petersburg tried to create the impression that the Russian stewardship of Ili was an act of kindness to China during a period of disorder, but it was obvious that Russia believed the effete Ch'ing could never recover Sinkiang. To perpetuate disorder and prolong their occupation of Ili, the Russians signed a commercial treaty with Ya'qub in 1872; the British followed suit a year later. Both countries granted him recognition in exchange for trade privileges. Before they could reach Ya'qub, the Ch'ing had to suppress the Muslim Rebellion in Shensi and Kansu. In 1866 the court appointed Tso Tsungt'ang governor-general of Shensi and Kansu with the specific assignment of suppressing the rebels there. However, before he assumed command, he was transferred to fight the Nien. After pacifying the Nien Rebellion in 1868, Tso assumed his earlier assignment, and by efficient leadership, good « Immanuel C. Y. Hsu, The Hi crisis: a study of Sino-Rutsian diplomacy, 1871-1881, 18-22. J* A. L. Narochnitskii, Kolomal'naia politika kapitalisticbeskikb der^bay na dal'ntm vostoke, 1860189/(Che colonial policies of the capitalist powers in the Far East, 1860-189$), 207, 210-13.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
ACCELERATION OF IMPERIALISM
91
strategy and hard campaigning, crushed the rebellion in these two provinces in 1873. Just as Tso's army was poised to strike into Sinkiang, the Formosan crisis with Japan arose as noted earlier, and China's weakness as revealed in the settlement pointed to the urgent need for coastal defence. The nation faced the vexing problem of whether it could support a bold naval programme simultaneously with a costly Sinkiang campaign. A grand debate ensued. Maritime defence versus frontier defence
Prince Kung and Wen-hsiang were the first to express alarm at the inadequacy of the coastal defence after a decade of self-strengthening. They warned: 'If we continue to drift along passively and do not eagerly seek to improve ourselves and forge ahead, trouble in the future will be even more difficult to meet.' High officials on the coast proposed the creation of a navy consisting of forty-eight ships, divided into three squadrons and stationed on the North, Central and South China coasts. The threat of Japan, they felt, was more immediate than that of Russia. Li Hung-chang, leading spirit of this group, boldly asked the court to cancel the Sinkiang campaign and shift its funds to naval defence. The advocates of maritime defence advanced five arguments: (i) frontier defence was not as important and urgent as maritime defence because of Peking's proximity to the coast and Sinkiang's distance from the capital; (2)financialexigency and the uncertainty of victory in Sinkiang compelled re-examination of the advisability of that campaign; (3) the barren land of Sinkiang was not worth the high cost of recovering it; (4) surrounded by strong neighbours, Sinkiang could not be effectively defended for long; and (5) to postpone its recovery was not renunciation of territory conquered by former emperors, but simply a sensible way of preserving strength for the future. Many other officials, however, while not disputing the importance of naval defence, argued that it should not be undertaken at the expense of frontier defence. If China failed to suppress the Sinkiang rebels, the Russians would continue their advance, and the Western powers might attack along the coast in response. Russia was a greater threat than Japan or the Western powers because of her common frontier with China Russia could reach China by land as well as by sea, whereas Japan and the Western countries could reach her only by sea. They compared the Russian trouble to a sickness of the heart, and the Western threat to that of the limbs. Tso Tsung-t'ang, leader of this group, stressed that Western powers usually fought only for commercial privileges, whereas Russia sought both commercial and territorial concessions.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
92
FOREIGN RELATIONS, 1 8 6 6 - I 9 0 5
The advocates of frontier defence also presented five arguments: (i) Sinkiang was the first line of defence in the north-west: it protected Mongolia, which in turn shielded Peking; (2) the Western powers posed no immediate danger of invasion, but the Russian advance in Sinkiang was a prevailing threat; (3) the funds for frontier defence should not be shifted to coastal defence, since the latter had already been allocated its own standing fund; (4) the land conquered by the dynastic forefathers should not be given up; and (5) strategic spots such as Urumchi and Aksu should be recovered first. Tso warned that to halt the campaign now was to invite foreign domination of Sinkiang.'7 The arguments of both groups were cogent and well reasoned. But there was no immediate trouble along the coast, while there was a rebellion in Sinkiang and a Russian occupation of Hi. Thus, though not giving up the naval programme, on 23 April 1875 the court appointed Tso imperial commissioner to conduct the Sinkiang campaign. Tso absorbed himself in an elaborate preparation for the campaign and decided on the strategy of 'proceeding slowly but fighting quickly'. By early 1876 he was ready to strike, and in March moved his headquarters to the advanced post of Su-chou. General Liu Chin-t'ang struck hard and fast into Sinkiang, and by November had conquered its northern half. Ya'qub, still established in southern Sinkiang, grew apprehensive and sent an emissary to London in late spring 1877 to seek British mediation, indicating his willingness to accept the status of a tributary to China. But Tso's army moved faster than discussions in London. Ya'qub was soundly defeated and driven to suicide on 29 May 1877. His sons carried on thefight,but internecine strife precluded any effective resistance. By the end of 1877 all of Sinkiang had been recovered except for the small enclave of Ili, still under Russian occupation. Having re-established the imperial authority in Sinkiang, China had fulfilled the Russian condition for the return of Ili. But as the Russian minister in Peking repeatedly postponed discussion of the issue, the Tsungli Yamen charged its recently established legation in Russia to negotiate for the return of Ili. The mission head, Ch'ung-hou, was given the title of imperial commissioner first class, which meant an ambassador authorized to act as he saw fit. Ch'ung-hou and the Treaty ofUvadia The Russians were determined to make the most of the Ili situation. The government had been under pressure from the industrialists and business<7 Immanuel C. Y. Hsu, 'The great policy debate in China, 1874: maritime defense vs. frontier defense', HJAS, 2$ (1965) 212-28.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
ACCELERATION OF IMPERIALISM
93
men in the central provinces and the Urals to secure new trade routes to Mongolia, Kansu and Shensi, where British and American goods and competition were nonexistent. Such trading possibilities and mining rights in Western China where precious metals abounded were said to be enough to relieve the economic crisis in Russia, which was evident during 1873-6. Under the direction of the minister of war, a special committee was called to formulate her policy in China. It decided to demand, as the price for the return of Hi, the right of Russian caravans to enter the interior of China, cession of the Tekes valley and the Muzart Pass, amnesty for the population of Kulja, and several other conditions. However, General Kaufman's proposal to ask for a large indemnity to pay for the construction of the Central Asian railway was rejected.38 Ch'ung-hou (1826-93), a compliant Manchu noble of no great ability, was totally unprepared for his mission. Ignorant of the intricacies of international diplomacy and Hi's geography, he arrived in St Petersburg where Russian flattery apparently overwhelmed him and disarmed his vigilance. Moreover, he seemingly feared the awesome Russians and was eager to return home to tend to urgent family affairs. Ch'ung-hou hastily negotiated the Treaty of Livadia, which returned Hi to China in name but ceded seven-tenths of the area to Russia, including the strategic Tekes valley and the Muzart Pass. It awarded to Russia an indemnity of 5 million roubles, the right to consulates in seven key places, and navigation on the Sungari River to Petuna in Manchuria. When these terms were telegraphed to Peking, the astonished Tsungli Yamen cabled Ch'ung-hou not to sign the treaty. His curious reply was that the treaty had already been negotiated and the texts copied out; no change or renegotiation was possible. On 2 October 1879, on his own authority, he signed the treaty and returned home without imperial authorization. Chinese officialdom received the news with consternation. The Tsungli Yamen insisted that this way of restoring Hi to China was worse than none. Tso Tsung-t'ang feared that the fruits of his arduous Sinkiang campaign were about to be snatched away by Ch'ung-hou's stupidity. He urged the court: 'We shall first confront them [the Russians] with arguments . . . and then settle it on the battlefields.'" On the other hand, Li Hung-chang, never sympathetic to the Sinkiang campaign or the policy of pressing Russia for the return of Hi, was only superficially critical of the treaty and did not advocate its rejection: 'The present mission of Ch'ung-hou had its origin in an imperial edict endowing him with full powers to act as he saw J
* Narochnitskii, Kolonial'naia politika, 217, 231-j. Tso Tsung-t'ang, Tso Wen-briang kung cb'uan-cbi (Complete collection of Tso Tsung-t'ang's papers), Ttou-kao (Memorials), 55.38.
19
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
94
FOREIGN RELATIONS, 1 8 6 6 - I 9 0 5
fit. We cannot say that he had no power to negotiate a treaty settlement. If we give assent first and then repudiate it later, we are at fault.'40 Li was in the unpopular minority. The prevailing sentiment among scholars and officials was for war to avenge the humiliation, regardless of whether or not the country was ready for it. Countless memorials poured into the court demanding severe punishment of the signatory and rejection of the treaty. The most eloquent of these came from a young librarian of the Supervisorate of Imperial Instruction, Chang Chih-tung (1837-1909), who announced: 'The Russians must be considered extremely covetous and truculent in making the demands and Ch'ung-hou extremely stupid and absurd in accepting them . . . . If we insist on changing the treaty, there may not be trouble; if we do not, we are unworthy to be called a state.' He demanded that Ch'ung-hou be decapitated to show China's determination to reject the treaty, even at the price of war. Because he spoke the mind of the literati and officials, Chang gained immediate fame.41 The court appointed Marquis Tseng Chi-tse, minister to Britain and France and son of Tseng Kuo-fan, as head of a second mission to Russia to renegotiate the treaty. Meanwhile, Ch'ung-hou's death sentence met with strong protests from the representatives of Britain, France, Germany and the United States, who could not remain indifferent to the inhumane treatment of a brother diplomat. When Queen Victoria sent a personal plea to the empress dowager, Ch'ung-hou was given a reprieve on 26 June 1880, but kept in prison to await the outcome of the second mission. Dissatisfied with this partial concession, Russia refused to deal with Tseng until Ch'ung-hou was granted a full pardon. Irritated by China's actions, Russia sent twenty-three warships to China as a naval demonstration. War seemed imminent; there was great fear of a Russian naval attack along the coast in concert with an army thrust from Siberia through Manchuria to Peking. The court did not intend to precipitate a clash, but was pushed by literati-official sentiment into taking a stronger position than it wanted. To prepare for the eventuality of war, it installed several Hunan army officers of Taiping fame in key positions, and through Robert Hart invited Charles Gordon to China to help with defence. Gordon, former leader of the Ever Victorious Army, had been secretary to the viceroy of India since the spring of 1880; but finding the life of a desk officer 'a living crucifixion', he resigned, and two days later received the telegraphic invitation from Hart. Gordon seized the opportunity, and •»» Cb'ing-cbi wai-cbiao Mb-liao (Historical materials concerning foreign relations in the late Ch'ing period, 1875-1911), 17.16-19 (hereafter WCSL.). *' WCSL, i8.i8-22b, 16 Jan. 1880. For a study of the life of Chang Chih-tung, see William Ayers, Cbang Cbib-lung, and Daniel H. Bays, China enters the twentieth century.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
ACCELERATION OF IMPERIALISM
95
after meeting with Li at Tientsin agreed that China should not drift irresponsibly into war. He warned that as long as Peking was the seat of government China could not afford to fight any first-rate power, for the Taku forts could easily be taken, rendering Peking indefensible. If China must fight, he said, the court should be moved to the interior and be prepared for a long war of attrition. Such blunt counsels were unwelcome in the belligerent atmosphere of Peking, but Gordon made a powerful case for the inadvisability of war. Li used him both to discourage the war party from a disastrous venture and to show Russia that China did not lack friends in her hour of need.42 Marquis Tseng and the Treaty of St Petersburg, 1881
As Gordon was counselling for peace in China, Marquis Tseng was preparing himself for the mission to St Petersburg. To avoid his predecessor's mistakes, he thoroughly planned his diplomatic strategy and studied the maps of Hi. Determined to hold firm on the boundary issue, bargain on the question of trade, and be conciliatory on monetary compensation, Tseng set out for Russia with assurance from the British foreign office of unofficial assistance, and the British ambassador at St Petersburg was instructed by London to offer him advice. The Russians, who secretly feared war at this point, ostensibly refused to open negotiations at St Petersburg, insisting on moving the site to Peking as punishment for China's bellicose attitude. The Ch'ing court urged Tseng to use all means to keep the negotiations in Russia. The Russians finally acquiesced but negotiations progressed slowly. The Russians were in no position to wage a distant war, due to their depressed economy following the Turkish War of 1876-7 and their international isolation after the Congress of Berlin in 1878. The St Petersburg government was further restrained by fear of revolution at home, and concern that the adverse effect of war on trade might goad Europe and America into taking sides with China. Moreover, the liberal and the conservative press as well as a group of sinologists also urged a peaceful course of action.41 The government wanted peace but could not find a graceful exit from the predicament. After nearly half a year of fruitless arguments, the tsar finally decided to end the dispute by agreeing to return all of Hi, including the Tekes valley and the Mu2art Pass, except for a few villages in the western part for the settlement of those Muslim refugees who refused to return to China. The number of Russian consulates was reduced to two (Turfan and 41
41
Immanuel C. Y. Hsu, 'Gordon in China, 1880', Pacific Historical Review, 23.2 (May 1964) 147-66. Narochnitskii, KoloniaVnaia politika, 235-6. The sinologists included V. Vasil'ev, M. I. Veniukov and V. Radlov.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
96
FOREIGN RELATIONS, 1 8 6 6 - 1 9 0 5
Su-chou), and the indemnity, dignified under the name of 'military compensation', was increased to 9 million roubles (about j million taels). These terms were incorporated in a new agreement, the Treaty of St Petersburg, on 24 February 1881. The peace settlement, generally considered a Chinese diplomatic victory, left behind two important consequences. First, the thought of having won a round from a powerful Western state stimulated Chinese self-confidence and conservatism, in spite of Tseng's warnings against pride, optimism and arrogance. The literati, who irresponsibly expressed their chauvinistic views (ch'ing-i), were encouraged to believe that the victory resulted from their war cries, and became overconfident of their ability to untangle China's problems in foreign relations. The second significant outcome was the new status of Sinkiang. Traditionally known as the Western Region (Hsi-yii), Sinkiang had never been an integral part of China but had remained a frontier area held by her when she was strong, lost when she was weak. After the Treaty of St Petersburg, the court accepted the recommendation of Tso Tsung-t'ang and turned Sinkiang into a regular province in 1884, with Liu Chin-t'ang, the brilliant young general who contributed much to its reconquest, as itsfirstgovernor. This institutional innovation constituted a milestone in Chinese frontier history.*4 The Sino-French War over Annam {Vietnam),
IS&J-J
Following the settlement of the Hi crisis, there arose the problem of French encroachment in the tributary state of Annam. Known in ancient times as Vietnam, Annam first came under Chinese influence in the third century BC, and its northern part was conquered during the reign of Han Wu-ti (140-87 BC) in i n BC. Its Chinese name was derived from the An-nan ('south-pacifying') protectorate established during the T'ang dynasty (AD 618-907) to govern the area. Though independent after the fall of the T'ang, Vietnam remained under strong Chinese cultural and political influence, and was an important tributary state during the Ming and Ch'ing periods. Western influence reached Vietnam with the Jesuits in 1615, but church work progressed slowly in this predominantly Confucian state. The French East India Company made an unsuccessful attempt to trade, but French influence began to rise by the end of the eighteenth century, when Nguyen Phiic Anh, the lone survivor of the ancien regime overthrown in 1788, regained control of the country with the aid of French officers. He was ** Hsu, The Hi crisis, 189-96.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
ACCELERATION OF IMPERIALISM
97
installed as Emperor Gia-Long of the Nguyen dynasty, which lasted from 1802 until 1945.
Gia-Long and his successors were conservative Confucianists, who countenanced xenophobic riots against missionaries and converts. Louis Napoleon, eager to build a French Indo-Chinese empire and pose as a champion of Catholicism abroad, sent troops to Saigon in 1859 to punish anti-missionary aggressors. A treaty, imposed on Vietnam in 1862, secured for the French an indemnity of $US4 million and the rights to trade, to propagate religion and to control Vietnamese foreign relations, as well as cession of three provinces in the south known as Cochin China. In 1874 a new treaty was signed which confirmed French possession of Cochin China and direction of Vietnamese (now called by the French Annamese) foreign relations, and authorized French navigation on the Red River in Tongking in the north. This document reduced Annam to a French protectorate, though nominally recognizing her independence. China, preoccupied with the Formosan crisis and the Margary murder case, took no positive action to stop the French advance but refused to honour the treaty of 1874 on the grounds that Annam was a Chinese dependency.** The French intensified their activities in Annam, and by 1880 had stationed troops in Hanoi and its port Haiphong and established fortresses along the Red River. The Annamese government, to counter the French advance, strengthened its ties with China by sending tribute and by seeking the aid of the irregular Chinese Black Flag Army, which was established along the Sino-Annamese border. By 18 8 2, the Black Flag Army had begun engaging French troops, and in the following year the Ch'ing court also quietly dispatched regular troops into Tongking. Li Hung-chang, governor-general at Tientsin, warned against challenging France before the completion of the Chinese naval and coastal defence programme. He argued that China should fight only if attacked, but, as even this could prove disastrous, he favoured a quick settlement through negotiations. Prince Kung, head of the Tsungli Yamen and still the leading member of the Grand Council, agreed that China should not prematurely challenge a first-rate Western power. The rise of the Ch'ing-i Party
The cautious attitude of Li and Prince Kung was attacked and ridiculed by a coterie of young officials who were brilliant scholars but who had little practical experience in or genuine knowledge of foreign and military affairs. By fervid memorials championing a belligerent course of action, *' For details of French activities see John F. Cady, The roots of French imperialism in Eastern Asia, ch. 16.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
98
FOREIGN RELATIONS, 1866-I9OJ
"JR.
CHINA
SEA
_Pulo CCondore Is.
200 miles
MAP. 6 French Indo-China
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
ACCELERATION OF IMPERIALISM
99
they won public acclaim and imperial attention. Calling themselves the party of the purists (Ch'ing-liu tang), they belittled France as a 'spent arrow', and condemned appeasement as encouraging greater demands from the insatiable enemy. War was won, they insisted, more by the human qualities of courage and virtue than by weapons, and Li Hung-chang was contemptuously compared to the notorious Sung traitor Ch'in Kuei (AD 1090-1155).46
Just as the Ch'ing-liu Party emphasized China's moral strength, so did Li stress her material weakness. But Marquis Tseng demonstrated a balanced grasp of the situation. Based on his understanding of France's domestic politics and international position, Tseng concluded that France could not afford a far-flung war. He warned Li against timidity in dealing with the French because: (i) they despised the weak and respected the strong. The more determined China was to fight, the greater the likelihood of peace. Indecision, procrastination and compromise could only lead to French gains, which would be difficult for China to recover later; (2) the French aspired after the coal mines in Kwangtung and the gold deposits in Yunnan; ceding Annam would not satisfy their appetite but would weaken China's southern defensive frontier; (3) the loss of Tongking would encourage Britain and Russia to covet Tibet and Korea; (4) the political instability in France and her isolated position in European politics would not permit her to wage a foreign war. For these reasons, Tseng warned against too much caution and urged a strong stance.47 The Ch'ing court vacillated between war and peace. Honour demanded the defence of a tributary, yet fear argued against fighting a leading Western power. A report from Robert Hart's agent in London, J. D. Campbell, led the court to believe that the French troops in Annam would not precipitate a full-scale war, and th°t the opening of Hanoi and the Red River to trade and navigation would remove the basic cause of contention. The court therefore instructed Li Hung-chang to open negotiations with the French minister. The first agreement, which would have made Annam a joint protectorate of China and France, was rejected by Paris, which then dispatched an expedition to Annam. Defeat of the Chinese troops in Tongking and fear of a French attack on China proper caused the empress dowager angrily to dismiss Prince Kung and four other members of the Grand Council and to order Li again to seek a settlement. The subsequent arrangement between Li and the French naval captain, F. E. Fournier, in 1884 called for Chinese recognition of all French treaties with Annam, 46
47
Lloyd E . Eastman, 'Ch'ing-i and Chinese policy formation during the nineteenth century', JAS, 14.4 ( A u g . 1965) 6 0 4 - 5 . Hsiao I-shan, Cb'ing-tai t'tmg-tbib ( A general history o f the Ch'ing period), 3. 1 0 7 0 - 1 .
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
IOO
FOREIGN RELATIONS,
1866-I905
withdrawal of Chinese troops from Tongking, and a French promise of no demand for indemnity, no invasion of China, and no undignified reference to China in any future treaties with Annam. The agreement so inflamed the Ch'ing-liu Party that forty-seven memorials reached the court demanding Li's impeachment. Thus harassed, Li failed to report to the court the date stipulated by the Li-Fournier agreement for the withdrawal of Chinese troops from Annam. 48 Having received no orders to withdraw, the Chinese troops in Tongking rejected French demands that they evacuate, and hostilities were renewed. Paris accused China of bad faith and sent an ultimatum on 12 July 1884 demanding a large indemnity and the immediate execution of the LiFournier agreement. Fearful of a French attack, the court at Peking transferred two leaders of the Ch'ing-liu Party to key defence positions: Chang Chih-tung became governor-general at Canton, and Chang P'ei-lun was put in charge of the Fukien fleet. On 23 August French ships under Admiral Courbet launched an attack at Foochow and, within an hour, sank or damaged eleven Chinese warships and destroyed the Foochow Navy Yard, built with French aid after 1866. Chang P'ei-lun was among the first toflee.His report to the court was so distorted with florid language that Peking thought that China had won a naval battle, but when the truth was learned, Chang was exiled to the frontier and the court declared war on France. The peace settlement
The empress dowager supported war for three months, from August to November 1884, but in December she vacillated again as a result of her distress over the indecisive military outcome in Tongking, the French blockade of Taiwan, and the effort to stop tribute grain shipments from South China. The expected aid from Britain and Germany did not materialize; and there was also the threat of renewed Russian activities on the northern frontier and a Japanese advance in Korea. The desire for peace was reciprocated in France, where unstable political conditions and the difficulty of supporting a distant war began to weigh on the government. Peace arrangements were made secretly in Paris by Hart's London agent J. D. Campbell, and a major defeat suffered by French troops at Langson provided Peking with a face-saving opportunity to pursue peace and further dampened the war spirit in France. In June 1885, Li Hungchang and the French minister in China concluded a formal agreement: China recognized all the French treaties with Annam, and France evacuated 4t
Lloyd E. Eastman, Throne and mandarins: China't search for a policy during the Sino-Frencb controversy, ISSO-ISSJ,
chs. 4-5.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
ACCELERATION OF IMPERIALISM
IOI
her troops from Taiwan and the Pescadores. No indemnity was paid, but China had expended in excess of ioo million taels and incurred debts of some 20 million taels.49 The indecision and vacillation of the court had proved disastrous. A firm war policy might have deterred French aggression and a persistent policy of peace might have spared the Fukien fleet and the Foochow Navy Yard. But ineffective leadership resulted in the destruction of both and the loss of the tributary status of Annam. The Ch'ing-liu Party must be held largely responsible by their emotional espousal of an unrealistic position. The loss of Annam signalled the failure of the twenty-year-old selfstrengthening movement. The limited diplomatic, military and technological modernization had not strengthened the country to a point where it could resist foreign imperialism. China's weakness prompted the British to emulate the French and detach Burma by invasion in 188 5. A treaty secured from China in 1886 reduced Burma to a British protectorate but permitted her to continue to pay tribute to Peking once every ten years. With the loss of these tributary states in the south, the fate of the leading tributary in the north-east, Korea, now hung in a delicate balance. JAPANESE AGGRESSION IN KOREA
Korea, regarded by the Chinese as a valuable 'outer fence' of North China, was a leading tributary state during Ming and Ch'ing times. The Yi dynasty (1392-1910) annually sent three regular tribute missions to the Ming and four to the Ch'ing, and numerous smaller embassies. From 1637 to 1894, 507 Korean missions visited Peking and 169 Chinese missions travelled to Korea.' 0 Living under the political and cultural shadow of China, Koreans modelled their institutions and way of life on the Chinese and described relations with China as 'serving the great' (sadae), as distinguished from their more equal 'neighbourly relations' (kyoriri) with Japan. Since 1637 Korea had maintained virtually no foreign intercourse other than tributary relations with China and occasional exchanges of delegations with Japan; she was known to Westerners as the Hermit Kingdom. The opening of Korea
With the opening of China and Japan, Korea came under increasing Western pressure for trade, religious propagation and diplomatic relations. *• Shao Hsun-cheng, Chung-Fa Yueh-nan kuan-bsi shih-mo (A complete account of Sino-French relations concerning Vietnam [until 1885]). 50 Hae-jong Chun, 'Sino-Korean tributary relations in the Ch'ing period', in CWO, 90-111.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
IO2
FOREIGN RELATIONS, 1 8 6 6 - 1 9 0 5
But the Korean court had proscribed Christianity as a heterodox faith in 1786 and, apart from caring for the shipwrecked, refused any contact with the West. This intransigence intensified after the TaewSn'gun (Grand Prince), father of the minor king Kojong, became regent in 1864. In February 1866, he renewed the persecution of Christians, which resulted in a massacre of foreign priests. In October, the French minister in China, without authorization from Paris, sent a punitive mission to Korea. The French forces captured Kanghwa at the river entrance below Seoul, but suffered a defeat outside the city and withdrew. In August of the same year, an American merchant ship, the General Sherman, arrived at P'yong'yang to demand trade with threats and gunfire. Behaving like a pirate, the ship was finally burned and its crew killed after it ran aground during low tide. In 1871 the state department authorized Frederick F. Low, minister in China, to investigate the case. He was accompanied by five naval ships. Refused negotiations off Kanghwa Island, the American expedition forced its way up the Han River leading to Seoul. When Korean shore batteries opened fire, the Americans retaliated, bombarding Kanghwa in full force. They then withdrew for lack of authorization to fight. The Koreans concluded they had won battles with both the French and the Americans. The Tsungli Yamen, aware of China's inability to defend Korea, began in 1867 to advise Korea to reach an accommodation with the West. By 1879-80 the Chinese were urging Korea to enter treaty relations with the West in order to counter the rising influence of Japan.51 Japanese relations with Korea, handled by the feudal lords of Tsushima during the Tokugawa period (1603-1867), came under the direct control of Tokyo after the Meiji Restoration in 1868. Missions dispatched to Korea to announce these political changes and revise relations were rejected by the Taewon'gun, who scorned Japanese modernization and viewed the assumption of the title 'Imperial Highness' by the Japanese emperor as improper. In response to this insult, Japanese leaders decided to dispatch a punitive mission in 1875. This move would: (1) provide an outlet for disgruntled samurai and shift attention from domestic problems; (2) win for Japan a leading position in Asia by successfully challenging China's supremacy in Korea; (}) forestall British and Russian advances; and (4) revenge the failure of Hideyoshi's invasions of Korea in 1592 and 1597. However, Japanese leaders returning from the West reversed this decision on the grounds that the country's backward domestic conditions did not allow for a foreign venture. Nevertheless, a surveying team, accompanied by gunboats, was dis" For a study of changing Chinese attitudes, see Mary C Wright, 'The adaptability of Ch'ing diplomacy: the case of China's involvement in Korea', JAS, 17.3 (May 1958) 363-81.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
JAPANESE AGGRESSION IN KOREA
103
patched in 1875. When attacked at Kanghwa Bay, the Japanese returned fire and destroyed the Korean forts. Following this victory, Tokyo sent six more ships to Korea and an emissary to PekingS2 to determine the Chinese response. The Tsungli Yamen, then involved in the Margary affair, timidly responded that Korea was tributary to China but had always been allowed complete freedom in her domestic and foreign affairs. Thus encouraged, Japan pressed for the opening of Korea, and the Ch'ing court, anxious to avoid a clash, instructed Korea to enter into negotiations. On 24 February 1876, the Japanese-Korean Treaty of Kanghwa was signed, stipulating: (1) recognition of Korea as an independent state on an equal footing with Japan; (2) exchange of envoys 5(3) opening of three ports; and (4) Japanese consular jurisdiction in these ports. By not protesting Korean independence, China defaulted her claim to suzerainty. Japan's action in Korea, followed by her annexation of the Liu-ch'iu (Ryukyu) Islands in 1879, led to the Chinese decision that Korea should be opened to the West to check Japanese influence. Peking put Li Hungchang in charge of Korean affairs to begin the opening of Korea to Western commerce and diplomacy. In 1882 he sent Ma Chien-chung and Admiral Ting Ju-ch'ang to Korea to introduce Commodore R. W. Shufeldt of the United States for treaty negotiations. On 22 May 1882, an American-Korean treaty was signed; the two countries agreed to exchange diplomats, to establish consuls at trading ports, and to treat each other as equals. The United States recognized Korean independence, but Korea issued a separate statement declaring her position as a dependency of China.53 In subsequent years Korea signed agreements with Britain, France and Germany and, albeit tardily, began some modernization after the Chinese fashion. Domestic insurrections and international politics™
After King Kojong began his personal rule in 1873, his queen of the influential Min family (and so called 'Queen Min') gained increasing power, which she exercised to support reform and to employ Japanese officers to train the Korean army. The Taewon'gun, determined to curtail her influence, capitalized on the discontent of dismissed soldiers and, in 1882, incited them to attack the palace and the Japanese legation. Queen Min narrowly escaped, while the legation was burned, seven Japanese officers 51 Mori Arinori. " Had this statement been included in the treaty, the US Senate would have refused ratification. 34 For China's involvement in Korea during this period, see Wang Hsin-chung, Cbung-]ib ebia-wu cban-tbtng cbib aai-cbiao pei-ching (The diplomatic background of the Sino-Japanese War).
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
104
FOREIGN RELATIONS, 1 8 6 6 - 1 9 0 5
were killed and the ministerfledhome; the Taew6n'gun returned to power. Admiral Ting and Ma Chien-chung, arriving to investigate the situation, quickly took steps to prevent Japanese punitive action by arresting the Taewon'gun and sending him to China for detention. Acting on Ma's advice, the Korean king reached a settlement with Japan, agreeing to pay an indemnity of $US 5 50,000, to send an apology mission, and to allow Japan to station troops and construct barracks at the legation. The establishment of Japan's right to send troops to Korea marked a significant victory for Japanese diplomacy. After the insurrection of 1882, Li Hung-chang initiated positive efforts to strengthen China's position in Korea. China and Korea signed a commercial treaty, giving China extraterritoriality, and the Chinese granted loans and gifts of foreign-style guns to the Korean government. Li appointed a Chinese commercial agent to supervise Korean trade and assigned Yuan Shih-k'ai to train the Korean army. Paul George von Mollendorf, formerly in the Chinese customs service and then German consul at Tientsin, became customs commissioner and foreign affairs adviser in Korea. Six Chinese battalions were stationed in Korea to maintain order and guard against Japanese aggression. Following 1882 the struggle mounted between pro-Chinese and proJapanese Koreans. The government was dominated by Yuan Shih-k'ai and the pro-Chinese groups, but the Japanese minister Takezoe Shin'ichiro sought to promote friendship and guide the pro-Japanese group led by Kim Ok-kyun. In 1884, when China, at war with France, withdrew three battalions from Korea, the pro-Japanese group attempted a coup on 4 December. Their troops broke into the palace, captured the king, and killed pro-Chinese officials. Yuan Shih-k'ai's forces soon overwhelmed the rebels and rescued the king, but Kim, the chief instigator, escaped to Japan. Tokyo immediately dispatched an expedition and a high emissary (Inoue Kaoru) to Korea, demanding an indemnity, an apology and funds to reconstruct the legation. Another envoy, Ito Hirobumi, was sent to confer with Li Hung-chang who, preoccupied with the French war, compromised readily and agreed to a Sino-Japanese Tientsin Convention on 18 April 1885, which stipulated: (1) China and Japan would withdraw their troops from Korea within four months; (2) neither would train Korean troops, but would urge Korea to engage instructors of a third nationality; and (3) each would notify the other before dispatching troops to Korea, and upon the restoration of order would withdraw the troops at once. This agreement virtually reduced Korea to a co-protectorate of China and Japan, eliminated China's claim to exclusive suzerainty, and confirmed Japan's right to send troops to Korea. Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
JAPANESE AGGRESSION IN KOREA
IOJ
Meanwhile, international rivalry intensified as Russia took Port Lazareff on the north-eastern coast of Korea and Britain seized Port Hamilton, an island in the south. Japan, recognizing the Western threat to her interests in Korea, adopted the policy of encouraging China to strengthen her control, thus curtailing other influences and ensuring that Japan would have only China to deal with in future Korean affairs. Unaware of this scheme, Li Hung-chang proceeded to strengthen China's grip by appointing Yuan Shih-k'ai Chinese Resident in Korea to direct all commercial and diplomatic affairs and supervise the domestic administration. Yuan quickly dominated the court, the customs, the trade and the telegraphic service, and became the most powerful man in Korea from 1885 to 1893. This period of Chinese supremacy in Korea coincided with rapid economic and military growth in Japan, and by 1894 Japan had modernized sufficiently to challenge China. The already tense situation was exacerbated by the assassination in Shanghai of the pro-Japanese Korean leader, Kim Ok-kyun, in March 1894 by another Korean; his corpse was transported to Korea for mutilation as a warning to traitors. The Japanese considered the incident a direct affront, and though the foreign minister Mutsu Munemitsu argued that the killing of one Korean by another in China did not legally concern Japan, feelings ran high and secret societies such as the Genyosha agitated for war. These groups encouraged the Tonghak Insurrection as an excuse for sending troops to Korea. The Tonghak Insurrection, 1894
The Tonghak movement, originally religious in nature, became political as a result of official persecution. Its founder, Ch'oe Che-u (1824-64), a frustrated scholar distressed by official oppression and the progress of Christianity, established a cult of 'Eastern Learning' (Tonghak) which purported to be a mixture of the quintessence of Buddhism, Confucianism and Taoism. The Korean government banned it as heterodox and in 1864 Ch'oe was arrested, tried and decapitated. Forced to go underground, the sect gradually attracted men with political ambitions. In 1892, the Tonghaks petitioned for the lifting of the ban, but this was refused and their organization was ordered to be dissolved. Shortly afterwards, the Tonghaks, aided by Japanese of the Genyosha society, capitalized on a mass protest against official corruption to stage a rebellion. When the court requested Chinese aid, the Japanese minister encouraged Yuan to take positive action and implied that Japan had no intention of intervening. Li Hung-chang was lured into believing that Japan would not wage war, whereas Tokyo was fully prepared to act, and no sooner had the Chinese helped to crush the Tonghaks than 8,000
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
IO6
FOREIGN RELATIONS, 1 8 6 6 - 1 9 0 5
Japanese troops appeared. The Japanese demanded reform of the Korean internal administration, but, under instruction from Li, the Korean government responded that reform would be carried out after the withdrawal of Japanese troops. The outbreak of war
Determined to find a diplomatic solution, Li hoped to win Western sympathies and force Japan into a peace settlement. When Russia failed to honour an understanding to intervene on China's behalf, Li turned to Britain for mediation. London had not anticipated this rapid turn of events and was caught without a suitable policy. Lord Rosebery, who took over the government after Gladstone in March, 'did not want an active situation in the Far East'. 55 What finally emerged was a mild innocuous proposal which called for a simultaneous withdrawal of Chinese and Japanese troops and the creation of a neutral zone around the Korean capital. The Japanese rejected the proposal as they also ignored an American plea for peace. Li's diplomatic efforts delayed China's military preparations; only when all hope of a settlement had faded did he authorize the dispatch of reinforcements to Korea. The Japanese learned of the convoy of reinforcements and on 25 July 1894 sank the British chartered steamer Kowshing, drowning 950 Chinese soldiers.56 On 1 August China and Japan both declared war. The war was, in effect, a contest between the two after a generation of modernization. On land, the Japanese defeated Li's Anhwei Army at P'ySng'yang, set up a puppet government under the Taewon'gun, and declared Korea independent. At sea, although China boasted the larger fleet, not all of her ships were mobilized. Only Li's Peiyang fleet fought the Japanese; the Nanyang fleet and the two other provincial squadrons at Canton and Foochow remained 'neutral' for self-preservation. Furthermore, the Chinese ships, larger in tonnage than the Japanese, were older and slower and no match for the new and fast Japanese fleet. The two navies met on 17 September 1894 off the Yalu River in the Yellow Sea. Confusion plagued the Chinese forces from the first as the captain of the flagship countermanded the orders of his superior, Admiral Ting, regarding the fighting formation. When the first salvo from the flagship caused the bridge to collapse, wounding Admiral Ting and his British adviser, the flotilla was leaderless. A German adviser who was an army officer, assumed command but was ineffectual. After five hours of exchange, the Chinese » Young, British policy, 16. 56 The Koatbing was a British steamer chartered by the Chinese. Its sinking aroused some feeling in Britain but it was soon mollified by Japanese promise of reparation for the ship and assurance of the safety of British interests in China'. Sec Young, British policy, 16.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
JAPANESE AGGRESSION IN KOREA
IO7
had lost four ships and suffered casualties in excess of a thousand men. The Japanese lost but one ship. The surviving Chinese ships retreated to Port Arthur and then to the naval base at Weihaiwei. In November the Japanese occupied Dairen (Ta-lien) and Port Arthur from the landward side, rendering the cannon in the forts ineffectual. In February 1895, the defeat was completed when the Japanese took Weihaiwei from the rear and turned the guns in the forts on the Chinese ships in the harbour. Admiral Ting committed suicide and his subordinates surrendered (see chapter 4). This humiliating defeat after thirty years of self-strengthening exposed Li to severe criticism. His defence, that victory was impossible when only the Peiyang fleet and the Anhwei (Huai) Army opposed the might of the entire Japanese nation, was unable to save him from dismissal and disgrace. The peace settlement
In November 1894, Prince Kung, reappointed head of the Tsungli Yamen, initiated a peace move by requesting the American minister to mediate, indicating that China was willing to pay an indemnity and recognize the independence of Korea. The Japanese, who by now had taken Port Arthur and Dairen and were threatening Manchuria and Liaotung, considered these concessions insufficient but intimated their willingness to negotiate. The Ch'ing court sent Chang Yin-huan, a minister of the Tsungli Yamen and vice-president of the Board of Revenue, to Hiroshima in February 1895 for a meeting with Ito and Mutsu but the Japanese refused to accept him, insisting that his powers were insufficient to negotiate a settlement. After the defeat of the Peiyang fleet, the court, desperate for peace, appointed Li Hung-chang as envoy first class to Japan. The Japanese proposal for the peace settlement was a synthesis of the demands of various elements in the country. The army insisted on cession of the Liaotung peninsula; the navy demanded Taiwan (Formosa) as a base for operations in South Asia. The Progressive Party suggested Japanese control of Shantung, Kiangsu, Fukien and Kwangtung and the Liberals urged cession of Manchuria. The treasury proposed a large indemnity. The formula that ultimately emerged emphasized the independence of Korea, an indemnity, the cession of territory, and commercial and navigational privileges. At the negotiations at Shimonoseki, Li stressed that China and Japan should recognize their common cultural and racial backgrounds, as well as their similar interests as Asians in an age of Western imperialism, and not exploit each other. Li attempted to use his age - seventy-three sui - to gain
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
IO8
FOREIGN RELATIONS, 1 8 6 6 - 1 9 0 5
a psychological advantage over his younger opponents but to no avail.57 At this critical point, Li was shot by a Japanese fanatic. Though the wound was not fatal, the incident proved very embarrassing to the Japanese government, which feared that it might provoke the Western powers to intervene on China's behalf. The Japanese emperor sent his personal doctor to treat Li and the government voluntarily declared an armistice and reduced the indemnity sought from 300 to 200 million taels. The foreign minister, Mutsu, noted that 'the misfortune of Li is also the fortune of the Great Ch'ing Empire. From now on peace terms will be more easily arranged, and the Sino-Japanese war will be terminated.'58 On 17 April 1895, the Treaty of Shimonoseki was signed. It provided for: (1) recognition of Korean independence and termination of tribute to China; (2) an indemnity of 200 million taels; (3) cession of Taiwan, the Pescadores and the Liaotung peninsula; (4) the opening of Chungking, Soochow, Hangchow and Shaci to trade; and (5) the right of Japanese nationals to open factories and engage in industries and manufacturing in China. Chinese reaction was severely critical. Li was accused of selling out the country. Chang Chih-tung, governor-general at Nanking, opposed ratification of the treaty and, on several occasions, provincial graduates who were gathered in Peking for the metropolitan examinations petitioned the court to reject the treaty and continue the fighting (see chapter 5).5» But despite this opposition, the court exchanged ratifications on 8 May 1895. Chinese leaders on Taiwan offered strong resistance to the cession of their island which, made a province after the French war, had made considerable progress in modernization under its first governor (see chapter 4).60 Declaring their independence on 2 5 May they proclaimed Taiwan a republic and offered the presidency to the incumbent governor. Pressure from the Ch'ing representative, Li Ching-fang, son of Li Hung-chang, and the efforts of Japanese troops finally overcame the local movement in October 1895 and Taiwan was transferred to Japanese control. In any reappraisal of the war, China's defeat appears inevitable. In the first place, the war pitted Japan, which had become a modern state in which nationalism bound the government and people together in a common purpose, against China, where government and people by and large formed separate entities. The Japanese war effort mobilized the consolidated might " Li's tactics are revealed in the minutes of his conversations at the peace talks at Shimonoseki: 'Ma-kuan i-ho Chung-Jih t'an-hua lu', in Cheng Yen-sheng, Chtmg-kuo nti-luan n/ai-buo li-tbib ts'un-shu (A historical series on China's internal disorder and external trouble), vol. 5. 58 Li Shou-k'ung, Chung-kuo chin-tai shih (China's modern history), 464-5. s » The petition on 30 April 189$ contained 1,200 to 1,300 signatures. 40 Liu Ming-ch'uan.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
JAPANESE AGGRESSION IN KOREA
109
of the entire nation while the Chinese people were hardly affected by the conflict and the government relied almost entirely upon the Peiyang fleet and Anhwei Army of Li Hung-chang. Secondly, China had no clear demarcation of authority, no unity of command, and no nationwide mobilization. Conflicting advice from the Tsungli Yamen, provincial authorities, and irresponsible Ch'ing-liu officials rendered the court indecisive. Li, in charge of diplomatic and military affairs in Korea, had no authority to decide policy matters or to control ships and troops outside his area (see chapter 4). Thirdly, corruption at court and in the Peiyang command doomed the Chinese effort from the start. The dowager's use of many million taels from naval funds to construct the Summer Palace (I-ho yuan), her trust in the eunuchs, and the general degeneration of public morality contributed to the defeat. Irregularities were rampant in the Peiyang command where Li chose his subordinates for their personal loyalty and willingness to work rather than for their uprightness. Many officers curried favour with the chief eunuch, Li Lien-ying, and embezzled public funds to make presents to him, who then protected their irregularities. For all its outward show the Peiyang fleet was weak. Knowing its weakness, Li had wanted to exhaust diplomatic means before deciding to fight. Fourthly, Li's diplomacy was limited by his lack of understanding of international politics, his overconfidence in his personal powers of persuasion, and his reliance on the antiquated policy of playing off the barbarians against one another. When Russia failed to intervene on China's behalf, Li turned to Britain and the United States, but neither could effectively check Japan.
THE THREATENED
PARTITION OF CHINA'
The triple intervention
On 23 April 1895, Russia, France and Germany sent a joint note to Tokyo warning that Japanese possession of the Liaotung peninsula would menace Peking, render illusory the independence of Korea, and threaten the general peace in East Asia. Russia, fearful of the Japanese presence on the Asiatic mainland, and herself interested in the ice-free ports of Dairen and Port Arthur, had instigated the intervention. Count Witte, minister of finance, stated that 'it was imperative not to allow Japan to penetrate into the very heart of China and secure a footing in the Liaotung peninsula'.61 61
Sergei Iul'evich Wittc, The memoirs of Count Witte, trans, and ed. by Abraham Yarmolinsky, 8
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
IIO
FOREIGN RELATIONS, 1 8 6 6 - I 9 0 5
Russia therefore decided to seek preservation of the status quo ante bellum in Liaotung and to take whatever action might be necessary, including bombardment of Japanese ports, to secure Japanese acquiescence. Russia was joined by France, her partner in the Dual Alliance, and Germany, who was anxious that Russia remain occupied in the East so as to reduce her pressure on Europe. To give teeth to the admonition, Russia recalled her warships from Chinese and Japanese harbours, declared Vladivostok a war zone and gathered troops there. Britain followed a policy of noninvolvement, primarily because Liaotung was not an area of direct British concern and the prime minister, Rosebery, feared the use of force against Japan.62 Before the conclusion of the peace treaty, ltd and Mutsu had recognized the possibility of a European intervention and urged that Japan refrain from territorial acquisitions on the mainland. But the military had insisted on the cession of land as essential to the victory. Now faced with the triple intervention, Japan had three alternatives: (1) to reject the warning at the risk of war; (2) to call an international conference on the Liaotung question; or (3) to accept the position of the three powers. On 24 April 1895, the imperial conference favoured the second course of action, but the foreign minister, Mutsu, demurred for fear that the Western powers would use the conference as an occasion to alter the other peace terms. The Japanese government finally decided to return Liaotung to China for 50 million taels. The powers reduced the sum to 30 million taels, and on 4 November 189 5, Li Hung-chang and Hayashi Tadasu, the Japanese minister in China, signed a formal agreement retroceding Liaotung. The Russians won the gratitude of the Chinese by their intervention, and by their offer of loans to pay to the Japanese an indemnity amounting to 100 million taels in the first year of payment. With an annual revenue of 89 million taels, the Ch'ing court was hardly in a position to pay such an indemnity. In 1895 Peking borrowed 400 million francs from a FrancoRussian banking consortium at 4 per cent interest. Later in 1896 and 1898, China twice borrowed £16 million at 5 per cent and 4.5 per cent respectively from a British-German consortium. The Sino-Kussian Secret Alliance
Impressed by Russian offers of friendship, leading Chinese officials advocated an alliance with Russia as a safeguard against future Japanese and Western aggression. Li Hung-chang, who had shown pro-Russian leanings in the debate of 1874 and the Hi crisis of 1878-81, was disappointed at Britain's failure to help China during the war. It prompted him to seek a 61
Young, British policy, 17-18.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
THREATENED 'PARTITION OF CHINA*
III
Russian alliance as the cardinal principle of future Chinese diplomacy. Eventually, the empress dowager, too, sanctioned the alliance. On Russia's part, Count Witte welcomed the alliance in the hope of winning a concession to extend the Trans-Siberian Railway across Manchuria to Vladivostok. The Manchurian route would save 350 miles, much time and money, and would further Witte's policy of peaceful penetration of China. Witte met with opposition from the Asiatic department of the foreign office, and from the governor of Amur province who felt the project would arouse opposition from other powers and possibly precipitate a partition of China. But Witte won the tsar's support and Cassini, Russian minister to China, was instructed to explain to Li Hung-chang that such a railway would facilitate Russian troop movement for the defence of China. Though some discussion took place, no formal agreement was reached, despite the report in the British North China Daily News of a 'Cassini Convention'. Negotiations for the railway concession and a Sino-Russian alliance finally materialized at the coronation of Nicholas II in 1896. When a middleranking official was authorized to attend the coronation, Cassini quietly protested that someone of Li Hung-chang's rank might be more appropriate to the occasion. The tsar himself is said to have telegraphed the empress dowager that Li's appointment would be more agreeable to him. So Li, at seventy-four sui and who had been in disgrace, was appointed imperial commissioner first class and set out on his first trip to the West to attend the coronation of the tsar and to visit the rulers of Britain, France, Germany and the United States. Witte related in his Memoirs, ' I . . . desired to prevent him [Li] from visiting any other European country before his arrival in Russia, for it was clear to me that while in Europe Li Hungchang was bound to become the object of various intrigues on the part of the European statesmen.'6* Therefore the tsar dispatched his confidant, Prince Ukhtomski, to 'intercept' Li at Suez and escort him to Odessa. At St Petersburg, Witte impressed upon Li that to render to China armed assistance in an emergency, Russia needed the shortest possible railway route from her European section to Vladivostok. Such a route, through northern Mongolia and Manchuria, would increase the productivity of the land it traversed and would not arouse Japanese opposition because it would link Japan with Europe. Li secretly welcomed the project and reported to Peking that it would benefit China and Russia alike by blocking future British and Japanese advances. Witte and Li agreed on three principles: (1) China would grant to Russia permission to construct a railway from «J Witte, Memoirs, 87.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
112
FOREIGN RELATIONS, 1 8 6 6 - I 9 O J
Chita to Vladivostok, which would be operated by a private firm - the Chinese Eastern Railway Corporation. (2) China would cede a strip of land sufficient for the building and operation of the railway, within which the corporation would have complete authority, including the right to maintain police. The railway might be redeemed by China after thirty-six years at 700 million roubles, but would pass free to her after eighty years. (3) China and Russia agreed to defend each other against any Japanese attack on China, Korea or Russian possessions in East Asia. It was rumoured that Li accepted a Russian bribe of HJS1.5 million and at least a first payment to him seems to have been made. Witte denied it, but even if a fact, the bribery was not decisive in Li's thinking for he had come to Russia for the explicit purpose of concluding an alliance. Li, committed to the policy of playing off the barbarians - using Russia against Japan in this case - proudly announced that the treaty would give China peace for twenty years. But the peace lasted less than two years. The scramble for concessions
After the triple intervention, Germany sought a naval base in China as her reward, citing the fact that all other major powers had bases in East Asia: Britain in Hong Kong, France in Tongking, and Russia in Vladivostok. The Chinese refused. But in 1897, the kaiser visited Russia and obtained a somewhat vague consent from the tsar to the German occupation of Kiaochow in Shantung. The Germans then capitalized on the murder of two German missionaries in Shantung (in November 1897) to seize Kiaochow and compel the Chinese to sign a ninety-nine-year lease and a concession for two railways in Shantung. Encouraged by this, the Russian foreign minister Muraviev won the tsar's support (over the protest of Witte) for a plan to occupy Port Arthur or Dairen. In December 1897, the Russians seized the two ports on the pretext of protecting China from the Germans, and in the following March compelled China to grant them the right to lease Port Arthur and Dairen for twenty-five years and to construct a South Manchurian Railway from the Chinese Eastern Railway to the ports and then west to Ying-k'ou (Newchwang) and east to the Yalu River. Witte later admitted having bribed the Chinese negotiators, Li Hungchang and Chang Yin-huan, for their collusion. The Russians now held the Liaotung peninsula which China had reacquired from Japan three years earlier at the cost of 30 million taelsl The scramble for concessions now began in earnest. The British secured the lease of Weihaiwei for twenty-five years and the Hong Kong New
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
THREATENED 'PARTITION OF CHINA*
113
Territories for ninety-nine years,64 and a promise that China would not transfer the Yangt2e valley to any other power, thus making it a British sphere of interest.6* Japan obtained a similar nonalienation commitment for Fukien province. The French leased Kwangchow Bay for ninety-nine years and established a sphere of influence in Kwangtung-KwangsiYunnan. Only Italy, whose demand was rejected, failed to obtain a concession, while the United States was too preoccupied with the Spanish War and the Philippine Revolution to take any action. The threatened partition of China precipitated the reform movement of 1898 domestically (which is a large subject in itself; see chapter 5) and it also led to the declaration of the Open Door policy by the United States. The Open Door policy
Although Britain claimed a sphere of special interest in China, she sought to promote the policy of an open door for trade wherever other powers had special influence. As a party to the scramble for concessions, Britain could hardly promote the idea alone and turned to the United States, the only major power with a 'clean' record, for support. In 1898 and again in 1899 the British minister in Washington approached the state department to suggest a joint sponsorship of a movement for equal commercial opportunity in China. The Americans, however, showed little interest until after the end of the Spanish War and the annexation of the Philippines. Then, A. E. Hippisley, a British commissioner of Chinese maritime customs, convinced his American friend, W. W. Rockhill, of the soundness of the proposal. Rockhill, a former minister in China, was adviser on Far Eastern affairs to the secretary of state, John Hay. The latter delivered to Britain, Germany, Russia, France, Italy and Japan in September 1899, a note prepared by Rockhill presenting the idea of equal commercial opportunity in China. It contained three main points, all of which added up to the preservation of the treaty system: (1) Within its sphere of interest or leasehold, a power would not interfere with any treaty port or with the vested interest of any other power. (2) Within its sphere of influence, no power would discriminate against nationals of other countries in matters of harbour dues or railway rates. (3) Within each sphere of influence, the Chinese treaty tariff should apply and the Chinese government be allowed to collect customs duties. No power committed itself to the note, each making its acceptance con*4 Young, British policy, 70-1. Five long cabinet meetings were held before the decision was made. 65 Ibid. 91. The British readily admitted to having a sphere of interest in China but not a sphere of influence.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
FOREIGN RELATIONS, 1 8 6 6 - I 9 0 5
114
The Treaty Ports • Canton Original Sports opened 1842-4 O Tientsin 9 ports opened in the 1860s • A/gun Ports opened by 1911 (names of some omitted from this map)
EMPIRE
SS3 Foreign Leased Areas. 1898 Port Arthur and Liaotung Peninsula (Kwantung) (Russian) Weihaiwei (British) Kiaochow (German) Kowloon New Territories (British) Kwang-chow-wan (French) <[ ': Neutral zones
-*-t-»-Railways
'..... Spheres of influence 9 500 km
Ichang Yochow Chungking Changsha
(tojapan
Tamsui /Jaiwan-fu TAIWAN \\W f 7\ TAIWAI (ceded to t, N
\
u
Japan 1895) 1
Pescadores Is. (ceded to Japan 1895)
M A P . 7 Imperialism in the 1890s
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
THREATENED 'PARTITION OF CHINA*
II5
tingent upon that of the others, but Hay nevertheless announced on 20 March 1900, that their assent was 'final and definitive'. Only Japan challenged this statement. On 3 July 1900, during the Boxer Uprising when the Open Door principle appeared threatened, the United States issued a second note, expanding the provisions to include the preservation of Chinese territorial and administrative integrity. A mere statement of intention, it did not solicit a response from the other powers. The Open Door was a declaration of principles, not a formal policy of the United States government, which had neither the will nor the power to enforce it. However, the partition of China did subside after the declaration, not in response to the American call, but because the imperialists feared rivalry and conflict among themselves. The resultant equilibrium saved the Ch'ing empire from immediate collapse. THE BOXER UPRISING
At the end of the Hundred Days reform (see chapter 5) the coup d'etat of September 1898 restored the reactionary Manchus to power at the expense of both radical and moderate Chinese. Jung-lu and other conservatives such as Yii-lu and Ch'i-hsiu entered the Grand Council, and the grand secretary Kang-i gained increasing favour with the empress dowager. These men advocated a policy of hard resistance and, under their influence, the empress dowager resolved to grant no more concessions to foreign powers. When the Italians demanded cession of Sanmen Bay, Fukien, in February 1899, she ordered that the demand be resisted and saw the new policy vindicated when the Italians backed down in October. On 21 November 1899, she instructed the provincial authorities to entertain no more illusions of peace: 'It behooves our governors and governors-general throughout the country to unite forces and act in unison. . . With a country such as ours . . . what indeed is there to fear from any strong invader ? Let us not think of making peace, nor rely solely upon diplomatic manoeuvres.'66 The flight of the court to Jehol in i860 in the face of an Anglo-French invasion, defeat at the hands of the French and then the Japanese, and the foreign scramble for concessions in 1897-8 gave the dowager ample reasons for her resentment of foreigners. Foreign sympathy for the reform effort of 1898, foreign meddling which facilitated the escape of the reformers K'ang Yu-wei and Liang Ch'i-ch'ao, and the activities of these fugitives in Japan to continue the cause of reform compounded her antipathy. Now the foreign ministers in Peking openly disapproved of her plan to depose " Chester C. T'an, The Boxer catastrophe, 3 2, with minor changes.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
Il6
FOREIGN RELATIONS, 1866-1905
the Kuang-hsii Emperor and name the son of Prince Tuan as heir apparent. Humiliated and frustrated by their inability to resist this foreign interference with their plans, the empress dowager and Prince Tuan transferred their support to a major anti-foreign uprising, the Boxer movement. Background of the Boxer movement
Anti-foreign sentiment permeated not only the court but also the scholars, the officials, the gentry and the people at large. Half a century of foreign humiliation had deeply wounded their pride and self-respect. The presence of haughty foreign ministers and consuls, and aggressive missionaries and traders, reminded them constantly of China's misfortune. A growing sense of injustice combined with larger social, economic, political and religious factors brought about a vast anti-foreign movement. The Treaties in Tientsin in 1858 and the Conventions of Peking in i860 had allowed foreign missionaries to propagate Christianity freely in the Chinese interior. But they had great difficulty in winning converts among the Chinese, who resented the invasion of Christianity under the protection of gunboats. Some missionaries adopted the practice of offering monetary subsidies or other amenities to their converts, and interceding with the magistrates on behalf of their converts in legal disputes. The Tsungli Yamen summed up the protective power of the missionaries in a report to the court: 'During the several decades since we have handled church cases, never once have we come across an instance in which the missionaries reprimanded or punished the converts.' The gentry were particularly anti-foreign and regarded Christianity as a socially disruptive, heterodox sect. As self-appointed guardians of Confucian propriety, they resented the inroads of any foreign religion or philosophy and were particularly offended by the Christian converts' failure to perform traditional rituals and participate in local festivals. The gentry were not infrequently secret instigators of anti-mission riots. Folklore and rumour portraying the atrocities perpetrated by foreigners behind high church and convent walls inflamed Chinese antipathy, and Christianity became a basic cause of anti-foreignism (see volume 10, chapter 11). The scramble for concessions in 1897-8 precipitated a sense of imminent national extinction on the part of patriotic Chinese. K'ang Yu-wei warned of the danger of becoming a second Burma, Annam, India or Poland, and the progressives proposed national salvation through radical institutional reforms. The reactionary and the ignorant, however, advocated the extermination of the foreigners. An estimated one thousand incidents occurring in Shantung after the German occupation of Kiaochow and countless Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
BOXER UPRISING
117
incidents erupting in other parts of the country, all testify to the tremendous public anger over foreign encroachment. The influx of foreign imports and the fixed customs tariff seem to have depressed the Chinese economy. The difficulty of life had increased during the mid-century rebellions as famine drove many to banditry. Many of the destitute who had at first blamed their misfortunes on the Taipings ultimately shifted their hatred to foreigners for having inspired the rebels with Christian ideology. In the post-Taiping era foreign products appeared increasingly in Chinese urban markets, and during the self-strengthening period (1861—94) foreign-style enterprises and industries as well as foreign capital were introduced. Foreign railways also threatened the traditional transport systems. The Grand Canal and the Hankow-Peking land route could not compete with the railways now being built, and thousands dependent upon these transportation systems for their livelihood feared unemployment. By the end of the nineteenth century, China seemed beset by village poverty, rising unemployment and general hardship in popular livelihood. Many Chinese attributed all this to foreign influence and economic domination and, not surprisingly, deep hostility developed towards foreigners. Economic hardships were compounded by natural disasters in 1898 when the Yellow River burst its banks inundating hundreds of villages in Shantung, and similar floods occurred in Szechwan, Kiangsi, Kiangsu and Anhwei. These disastrous floods were followed by a severe drought in North China in 1900. Victims of the natural calamities, and superstitious scholars and officials blamed the foreigners, who, they insisted, had offended the spirits by propagating a heterodox religion. Foreigners were accused of damaging the 'dragon's vein' (lung-mat) in the land by constructing railways, letting out the 'precious breath' (pao-cb'i) of the mountains by opening mines, and generally interfering with the natural (though mysterious) functioning of the topography, thus adversely affecting the harmony between men and nature. In this atmosphere of superstition, extreme economic hardship, and public resentment of the foreign presence, a major anti-foreign movement erupted in 1900. The origin of the Boxers
'Boxers' was the English name for a Chinese secret society called the I-ho ch'iian, or the 'Righteous and Harmonious Fists' after the old-style calisthenics practised by its members. The I-ho ch'iian was an offshoot of the Eight-trigram sect (Pa-kua chiao), which was associated with the White Lotus sect, an anti-Ch'ing secret cult which had fomented the rebellion Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
Il8
FOREIGN RELATIONS, 1 8 6 6 - I 9 O J
of 1796-1804. The I-ho ch'tian first received official notice in an edict of 1808 and, despite official prohibition, continued to carry on its activities in Shantung, Honan, Kiangsu, Anhwei and Chihli provinces. In the 1890s this traditionally anti-dynastic organization also took on an anti-foreign cast, vowing to kill foreigners and their Chinese collaborators. The Boxers consisted of several uncoordinated groups, such as the Ch'ien Fists, the K'an Fists and the K'un Fists, each under its own leaders. The groups were usually organized into units of twenty-five, each under a leader with complete authority. The method of instruction differed with each group, but on the whole it was short and simple, completed within a day. The Boxers called their head 'Old Teacher' and lesser leaders 'First' and 'Second Elder Brothers'. Foreigners were 'Primary Hairy Men' (ta mao-t^ti), Chinese Christians and those engaged in 'foreign matters' were 'Secondary Hairy Men' (erh mao-t^u), and those who used foreign goods were 'Tertiary Hairy Men' {san mao-t^ti). All 'Hairy Men' were to be exterminated.67 The Boxer pantheon included both legendary and historical figures. Central to the Boxer programme, and of primary appeal to the superstitious populace, was the practice of magic arts. Through charms, incantations and rituals they invoked supernatural powers which they claimed granted them immunity to bullets, the power tofly,and the aid of divine generals and soldiers in battle. Being anti-foreign they shunned the use of guns and preferred old-style swords and lances. Though some leading Boxers became pro-dynastic in the autumn of 1899, not all the groups shared this spirit with equal conviction. One band continued to hold to the 'anti-Ch'ing, revive-Ming' objective while other groups, being largely bandits, held no views on the matter. When the Boxers were summoned by the court to Peking in the summer of 1900, the pro-Ming band attacked the foreign legations but also secretly gathered forces in a futile attempt to overthrow the Manchu court.68 The various Boxer groups were united, however, in their determination to destroy the foreigners and their Chinese collaborators. Court patronage of the Boxers
In the 1890s a group of Boxers known as the Big Sword Society (Ta-tao hui) became particularly active in Shantung where it was secretly encouraged by Governor Li Ping-heng. Li held the Christians responsible for the " This account of the Boxers is based on Lao Nai-hsuan, I-bo cb'iian cbiao-men yuan-liu k'ao. (Inquiry into the origins of the Boxer sect; I cbuan, 1899), in Chien Po-tsan et a/, eds. I-bo t'uan (The Boxers), 4.433-9. Cf. Immanuel C. Y. Hsu, The rite of modern China, 465-7. 68 Li Shou-k'ung, Chung-kuo cbin-tai sbib, 589. Victor Purcell, The Boxer uprising, chs. 9 and 10.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
BOXER UPRISING
II9
riots that were being stirred up by the Boxers. He maintained that the Christians, 'with the support and protection of the missionaries, bullied and oppressed the common people'. He recommended that the Boxers be pacified rather than suppressed. When two German missionaries were killed in 1897, providing the excuse for the German occupation of Kiaochow, I i was dismissed under foreign pressure. Yii-hsien was then appointed in March 1899 as governor and he, too, patronized the Boxers and the Big Sword Society, ordering his subordinates to ignore the petitions and complaints of the missionaries and their converts. Under his aegis, the Boxers raised the banner of 'support for the Ch'ing and extermination of the foreigners' (Ju-Ch'ing mieh-jang). The governor subsidized the Boxers, invited them to train his own soldiers and renamed them the I-ho t'uan as a form of officially sanctioned militia (/''nan-lien). Emboldened by official support, the Boxers increased their attacks on missionaries and converts while Yii-hsien continued to report to the court that 'there is absolutely no such thing as maltreatment of the Christians'. The court accepted this position and its pronouncements assumed a more antiforeign tone. 6 ' When in December 1899 foreign pressure forced the court to remove Yii-hsien, he came to Peking where he convinced Prince Tuan, Prince Chuang and Grand Secretary Kang-i of the wisdom of supporting the Boxer forces. These reactionaries recommended the idea to the empress dowager, who in her frustration readily embraced it. Yii-hsien was named governor of Shansi and his successor in Shantung, Yuan Shih-k'ai, was admonished to refrain from punishing the Boxers. But Yuan refused to comply and succeeded in suppressing the Boxer movement in Shantung. The court continued to favour the Boxers and on 12 January 1900, decreed that people drilling themselves for self-defence should not be considered as bandits. 'When peaceful and law-abiding people practise skill and calisthenics for the purpose of defending themselves and their families, or when they combine in village communities for the mutual protection of the rural population, this is only a matter of mutual help and collective defence.'70 This edict and a similar one in April further encouraged Boxer activities, and in May the Boxers led a major uprising in Kao-lo village, Chihli. The governor-general, Yii-lu, aware of the dowager's secret patronage of the Boxers, proffered no chastisement and the court undertook no punitive measures. The Boxers became more daring, destroying railways and telegraph lines as symbols of the foreign enslavement of China. In May 1900 the court considered organizing the Boxers into a militia *• T'an, The Boxer catastrophe, 46, 59.
70
Ibid. 60-1, with minor changes.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
FOREIGN RELATIONS, 1 8 6 6 - 1 9 0 5
I2O
sian Ecclesiastical Mission
NorthCathedral (Pei-t'ang)
IMPERIAL CITY
T'ien-an-men (Gateof Heavenly Peace)
J
C
n-
-ta- men|| C
H
TEMPLE
I
N
E
S
E
81
1 .Canal \Tung-pien-men
'I—-
C I T ' Y
Imile
TEMPLE OF HEAVE! ~
[
'/AGRICULTUREL
- - - - Lineof defence to 21 June - ^ ^ Line of defence to 16 July and thereafter
^Imperial Palace
Belgian I Legation
Jfci. Austrian. Legation JRanlm Academy English Legation
Palace of
Customs
1
Post Office
Italian legation
Ufliflui Bridui!
German Legation Wall Burncadu on wall
/
'
I
Portion o( wall held by . Americans and Russians
..Water Mate
^Barricade on wall
Wall Chinese City
MAP. 8 Peking in 1900
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
BOXER UPRISING
121
but the plan was blocked by Yii-lu and Yuan Shih-k'ai. Impressed by reports of the Boxers' spiritual powers, however, the dowager summoned them to Peking. She commended their leaders and ordered all court attendants, including the women, to learn their art. Princes and nobles now engaged Boxers to guard their residences and some of the regular army joined the Boxers. The rising tide of anti-foreignism prompted the foreign diplomats to call up troops from the ships off Taku on 28 May. Though the Tsungli Yamen attempted to limit the number of guards to thirty for each legation, the first detachment, arriving in Peking on 1 and 3 June, consisted of seventy-five each Russians, British and French, fifty Americans, forty Italians and twenty-five Japanese. Encouraged by yet another favourable court decree of 29 May, the Boxers cut the railway line between Peking and Tientsin on 3 June. Chang Chih-tung, governor-general at Wuchang, and Sheng Hsuan-huai, director of railway and telegraphs, pleaded unsuccessfully with the court to suppress such activities. As the court was completely dominated by the reactionaries, foreign diplomats began to fear for the safety of foreigners in Peking. The British minister requested help from Admiral Seymour at Tientsin, and on 10 June an international force of 2,100 men left Tientsin by train. Half-way between Tientsin and Peking, the Boxers attacked the foreign expedition and blocked its progress to Peking. Telegraph lines between the two cities were cut, isolating the foreign community of Peking. On the same day, Boxers burned the British summer legation in the Western Hills, and on 11 June the chancellor of the Japanese legation was killed by troops of the reactionary Muslim general Tung Fu-hsiang. On 13 June the court announced that the embassies were adequately protected and there was no need for more foreign troops in Peking. Governor-general Yu-lu and General Nieh Shih-ch'eng were ordered to resist the advance of Admiral Seymour, and the commander of the Taku Forts was alerted against a surprise attack. Beginning on 13 June large groups of Boxers swarmed into Peking, burning churches and foreign residences, killing Chinese converts, and dragging officials into the streets for public humiliation. They exhumed the bodies of missionaries, including the early Jesuits, made attacks on the legation guards, and on 20 June killed the German minister, Clemens von Ketteler. At Tientsin, the Boxers rampaged all over the city and, facing such disorder, the foreign forces occupied the Taku Forts on 17 June. Meanwhile, the Seymour expedition fought its way back to Tientsin. Prince Tuan, Kang-i and the empress dowager now agreed that an allout attack on the legations was necessary to expunge the humiliations of
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
122
FOREIGN RELATIONS, 1 8 6 6 - I 9 0 5
half a century. On 16 June, at the first of four imperial councils called to deliberate on the question, Yuan Ch'ang, a director of the Court of Sacrificial Worship, opposed the plan to attack, pointing out the falsity of the Boxer claim of immunity to firearms. The dowager retorted: 'If we cannot rely upon the supernatural formulae, can we not rely upon the hearts of the people? China has been extremely weak; the only thing we can rely upon is the hearts of the people.' The meeting was indecisive, but a decree was issued to recruit the 'young and strong' Boxers into the army. At the second imperial council of 17 June, the dowager revealed an alleged four-point demand from the foreign powers: designate a special place of residence for the emperor; allow foreign ministers to collect provincial revenues; and permit them to direct Chinese military affairs. The fourth point, which she did not disclose, was said to be 'restore the emperor to power'. This four-point demand, actually fabricated by Prince Tuan, goaded the dowager into declaring that China should 'fight to the death' against any foreign action. The third council of 18 June was again indecisive, but on 19 June word arrived that the foreigners had demanded the surrender of the Taku Forts. The dowager called the fourth imperial council on 19 June to announce the break-off of diplomatic relations. She was determined to fight the powers with the help of the Boxers and overruled attempts by the Kuang-hsu Emperor to postpone the decision. On 21 June, an ambiguous but rather favourable report on the fighting at Taku and Tientsin arrived and the court confidently declared war on the foreign powers. 71 The court now formally ordered the provincial authorities to organize the Boxers to oppose the foreign invasion. At Peking, the Boxers were officially subsidized and Prince Chuang, Kang-i and Prince Tuan assumed official command of Boxer bands. These bands, together with the government troops under General Tung Fu-hsiang, launched attacks on the legations and the Northern (Roman Catholic) Cathedral. Prince Chuang offered rewards for the taking of foreign captives while Kang-i declared: 'When the legations are taken, the barbarians will have no more roots. The country will then have peace.' By the attacks, made with the full approval of the dowager, the reactionaries sought to vent their wrath on the barbarians, rid the capital of the foreign menace, destroy evidence of court support for the Boxers, and stimulate support among the people. Within the legations the 450 guards, 475 civilians (including 12 diplomatic ministers), and 2,300 Chinese Christians, offered stiff resistance to the Boxers who, wearing wild, loose-hanging hair, carrying 'magic weapons', and moving in prescribed 71
Hsiao I-shan, Cb'ing-tai t'ung-sbih, 4.2196-8.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
BOXER UPRISING
I23
steps, resembled legendary witches. Peking was gripped in the pandemonium of a witches' sabbath. Alarmed by these developments, the foreign powers resolved to dispatch troops to China. Britain in particular was concerned with the future of the Yangtze valley as her sphere of interest. The foreign office received in early July a number of suggestions as to the proper course of action. H. B. Morse, who later became a historian, proposed 'throwing a screen of British and German troops between the valley and the rebellion'. Byron Brenan, consul-general at Shanghai then on leave in London, recommended that Duke K'ung, a lineal descendant of Confucius, be considered as a possible candidate for the throne should the allied military intervention drive the court out of Peking, leaving behind a state of anarchy.72 Independent action of South and East China
Even before the formal declaration of war, it was clear that the court was following a disastrous course of action. Li Hung-chang, now governorgeneral at Canton and probably the only man capable of reversing the tide, refused to act, declaring that Jung-lu, with his numerous troops, should act to remove the reactionaries from control.73 The provincial authorities, unable to change court policy, were yet anxious to protect their jurisdiction from the Boxer disruption and foreign punitive action. When the court issued the declaration of war on 21 June, the leading provincial authorities - Li Hung-chang at Canton, Liu K'un-i at Nanking, Chang Chih-tung at Wuchang and Yuan Shih-k'ai in Shantung - collectively refused to recognize it, insisting that it was a luan-ming, an illegitimate order issued without proper authorization of the throne. They suppressed the declaration and, together with the governor-general of Fukien and Chekiang, entered into an informal pact with the foreign consuls at Shanghai, stating that they would protect foreign lives and property and suppress the Boxers within their jurisdiction, and the foreign powers would refrain from sending troops into their regions. Hence, the whole of South-East China was exempt from the Boxer catastrophe and foreign invasion. The provincial leaders justified their actions on the grounds that the Boxers and reactionaries had seized control of the court and issued illegitimate orders; that war with several foreign powers was insanity; and that the lives of foreigners in the legations must be saved. They urged the court to assign well-disciplined troops to protect the legations, and to continue 72 73
Y o u n g , 'British policy, 171. Hsiao I-shan, Cb'ing-tai t'img-sbib, 4.2203.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
124
FOREIGN RELATIONS, 1 8 6 6 - 1 9 0 5
to honour the foreign debts. They appealed to Jung-lu but he refused to cooperate. Sheng Hsuan-huai suggested that Yuan Shih-k'ai march his troops from Shantung to Peking to rescue the dowager and the emperor from the clutches of the undesirable elements. Yuan declined, stating: 'Without authorization, if I should lead my troops northward to save the foreign ministers, I am afraid that I would be defeated first on the way. It is really difficult for me to comply.' Liu K'un-i, attempting to absolve the dowager of guilt, notified foreign consuls that the hostilities were 'beyond the expectations of the imperial court'. Meanwhile, the court decreed on 3 July that provincial authorities should purge the word 'peace' from their mouths. On 14 July, foreign troops took Tientsin and threatened to march on Peking and, on the same day, thirteen south-eastern provincial authorities urged the court to suppress the Boxers, protect foreigners, compensate them for losses sustained in the disturbances, and send a letter of apology to Germany for the death of von Ketteler. Under these pressures, the court became somewhat conciliatory for a short time. The Tsungli Yamen invited foreign diplomats and their families to move to the Yamen for safety, pending arrangements for their return home. Li Hung-chang was ordered to instruct Chinese diplomats abroad to inform their respective governments that their representatives in Peking were safe. On 19 July, the Yamen again offered to send the foreign ministers to Tientsin under military escort but the foreigners, feeling the Yamen could not ensure adequate protection, preferred to remain in the legations to await relief. During this brief conciliatory period (14-26 July), the Yamen sent supplies to the legations and the attacks were suspended. The policy of war and extermination was reaffirmed, however, with the arrival of the reactionary Li Ping-heng in Peking on 26 July. Five high officials who dared to counsel peace were executed and Yuan Shih-k'ai was moved to describe the situation as 'hopeless'. Foreign reinforcements reached Taku in late July but mutual jealousy and dissension delayed their departure for Peking until 4 August. This international force of 8,000 Japanese, 4,800 Russians, 3,000 British, 2,100 Americans, 800 French, 58 Austrians and 53 Italians decisively defeated the Boxers and government forces, and on 14 August, arrived in Peking to relieve the besieged legations. The legations had held out for nearly two months, thanks in large part to Jung-lu, commander-in-chief of thePeiyang forces, who, afraid to oppose the dowager, had launched a noisy but only half-hearted attack on the quarter. As the allies advanced the dowager, the emperor and a small entourage fled Peking. The emperor had wanted to remain to negotiate a settlement Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
BOXER UPRISING
125
but the dowager forced him to accompany her. After a long and arduous flight, the court was re-established in Sian on 23 October. The Boxer catastrophe which had swept North China, Inner Mongolia and Manchuria, killing 231 foreigners and many thousands of Chinese Christians, was over at last. The peace settlement
In the aftermath of the Boxer Uprising, Li Hung-chang was called upon to negotiate a peace settlement. He had earlier been summoned by the court to Peking on 18 June 1900, but, alarmed by the dowager's patronage of the Boxers, he delayed his departure from Canton. On 8 July, he was appointed governor-general of Chihli and superintendent of trade for the northern ports, posts which he had held previously from 1870 to 189 5, and only then did he sail for Shanghai.74 Arriving there on 21 July, he was thoroughly discouraged by the situation in Peking and refused to go north. On 7 August, the court appointed him plenipotentiary to negotiate with the foreign powers but still Li hesitated to go to Peking for he believed that the court would not agree to the measures that he saw as necessary to attain peace - namely, suppression of the Boxers and protection of the foreigners in Peking. Li was somewhat consoled when the powers did not declare war on China but sent an expeditionary force merely to suppress the rebels. And, when Russia offered to withdraw her troops and civilians to Tientsin in preparation for negotiations, and to set a tone of moderation at the conferences to forestall excessive demands by the other powers, Li agreed to go north. He requested that Prince Ch'ing and Jung-lu be assigned to join him in the negotiations, and when the court complied, he went north under Russian protection, arriving in Tientsin on 18 September. When the powers declared Jung-lu unacceptable as a negotiator because of his part in the legation attacks, Li petitioned that he be allowed to go to Sian. Li hoped that Jung-lu, who joined the Grand Council on n November, would check the still strong influence of Prince Tuan and Kang-i. Meanwhile the allied representatives in Peking refused to open negotiations before 'the return of the court', by which they meant 'the return of the emperor to power'. They hoped to use this demand as leverage to gain satisfaction of their other demands. The dowager refused, however, stating that she feared unacceptable terms would be imposed on her, and indicated that the court would return only after the peace settlement. The south-eastern provincial leaders now attempted to shift allied attention to 74
He did so against British advice which urged him to stay in Canton. Young, British policy, 175.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
126
FOREIGN RELATIONS, 1 8 6 6 - I 9 O J
the issue of punishment for guilty ministers. They put pressure on the court to accept the demand for punishment of nine pro-Boxer ministers, Governor Yii-hsien and General Tung Fu-hsiang. The court reluctantly agreed to punish the ministers but reserved judgment on General Tung. The powers insisted that Tung be punished, and Liu K'un-i and Yuan Shih-k'ai pressed Jung-lu for action, stressing that no wise statesman 'would love a single man against the public opinion of the nation, let alone against the interests of the people'.75 On 3 December 1900, the court finally relented. In attributing guilt, no mention was made of the two chief culprits: the empress dowager and Jung-lu. At Peking the allied negotiators had difficulty agreeing on terms. Germany demanded severe punishment, and the kaiser spoke of even the destruction of Peking. He sought to ensure that 'no Chinese will ever again even dare to look askance at a German'.76 Because of von Ketteler's murder, the German field marshal, Count von Waldersee, was named commander-in-chief of the allied forces in China. Britain supported Germany in an attempt to check Russia while the Russians ingratiated themselves with the Chinese in the hope of gaining concessions in Manchuria, which they had occupied during the turmoil. The Japanese competed with the Russians in an attempt to win Chinese goodwill; France declared she had no designs on China and the United States announced the second Open Door note supporting 'Chinese territorial and administrative entity'. After prolonged debate, a joint note of twelve articles was announced on 24 December 1900, and reluctantly accepted by the Chinese court on 16 January 1901. The final settlement consisted of the following main features. (1) Punishment of the guilty. The allies had originally demanded the death penalty for twelve officials, including Princes Chuang and Tuan, Kang-i, Yii-hsien, Li Ping-heng, Hsu T'ung and General Tung Fu-hsiang. In the final settlement, Prince Chuang was ordered to commit suicide, Prince Tuan to be banished to Sinkiang for life imprisonment, and Yiihsien to be executed. General Tung was stripped of appointment. Kang-i, Hsu T'ung and Li Ping-heng, already dead, received posthumous degradation. In the provinces, a total of 119 officials received penalties ranging from capital punishment to mere reprimand. (2) Indemnity. An indemnity of £67.5 million, or 450 million taels was levied with payment to be completed in thirty-nine years at 4 per cent annual interest, and with the maritime customs, likin, native customs and salt gabelle as security. To help meet the payment, the existing tariff was to 75 76
T a n , The Boxer catastrophe, 139, 141. H. B. Morse, The international relations of the Chinese empire, 3.309.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
BOXER UPRISING
127
be increased and hitherto duty-free merchandise to be taxed. The breakdown of the indemnity was as follows:77 Country Russia Germany France Britain Japan United States Italy Belgium Austria Others
taels 130,371,120 90,070,515 70,878,240 50,620,545 34,793.100 3*.939.°55 26,617,005 8,484,345 4,003,920 1,222,155
percentage of total 29.00 20.00 15-75 11.25
7.70 7.30 5.90 1.90 0.90 0.30
(3) Other important stipulations. (a) Apology missions to Germany and Japan. (b) Establishment of a permanent legation guard. (c) Destruction of the Taku and other forts between Peking and the sea. (d) Prohibition of the importation of arms for two years. (e) Stationing of foreign troops in key points from Peking to the sea. (f) Suspension of official examinations for five years in some fortyfive cities where the Boxers had been active. These items were formalized in The Boxer Protocol of twelve articles and nineteen annexes, and signed by Li Hung-chang, Prince Ch'ing, and the representatives of eleven powers on 7 September 1901. The allied troops evacuated Peking on 17 September, but the court did not return until 7 January 1902. Russia in Manchuria
The peace settlement did not resolve the question of the Russian occupation of Manchuria. Under the pretext of suppressing the 'rioters' and restoring order, 200,000 Russian troops had swept into Manchuria, taking Aigun on 23 July 1900, Tsitsihar on 30 August, and Mukden (Shen-yang, the subsidiary Ch'ing capital) on 1 October. On 30 November, Admiral Alexeiev, Russian governor-general of the Liaotung peninsula, coerced the 77
Actually, the indemnity far exceeded the losses sustained by the allies. The actual American private claims were only $2 million, which had been paid by 1905. In 1908 the United States government returned to China $10,785,286, while retaining $2 million for possible future adjustments, and in 1924 the rest of the indemnity was waived. The refund was specified by Washington to be used for educating Chinese students in the United States. To prepare these students for schooling in America, Tsing Hua College (later Tsing Hua University) was established in Peking, where many American teachers were employed. Remissions of the indemnity funds by other countries followed suit: Britain, 1922; Russia, 1924; France, 1925; Italy, 1925, 1933; Belgium, 1928; the Netherlands, 1933. Many writers in China have viewed the Boxer refunds as a form of cultural imperialism — a subject clearly in need of re-examination.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
128
FOREIGN RELATIONS, 1 8 6 6 - 1 9 0 5
Manchu military governor of Mukden, Tseng-ch'i, into signing a 'provisional agreement' which virtually pre-empted Chinese rule in Manchuria. The Ch'ing court refused to recognize the agreement, which they insisted Tseng-ch'i had no authority to sign. Negotiations then opened in St Petersburg, and on 16 February 1901 the Russians proposed a twelvearticle treaty (to replace the Alexeiev-Tseng agreement), which returned Manchuria to China in name, but, in effect, legalized the occupation of Manchuria by Russian troops disguised as 'railway guards'. The agreement prohibited China from sending arms to Manchuria or granting anyone railway and mining privileges there without Russian consent. It stipulated that China pay for the occupation and for damages to the Chinese Eastern Railway and granted Russia the right to construct a railway from the said line to the Great Wall. The Russian action aroused the apprehension of the other powers. The Japanese minister in Peking warned Prince Ch'ing that any concession on the Russian occupation of Manchuria would lead to the partition of China. Britain and Germany admonished the court not to sign a separate treaty with Russia before the conclusion of a general agreement with the allies in Peking, and the United States, Austria and Italy urged China to resist the Russian demands. Count Witte, meanwhile, threatened that rejection of the proposal would lead to Russian incorporation of Manchuria. The dilemma of the court was intensified by the conflicting advice of leading officials. Li Hung-chang, his pro-Russian leanings now evident, advised signing the treaty to avoid a perilous break with Russia, while Chang Chih-tung and Liu K'un-i vigorously opposed the treaty. Caught between conflicting advice and diverse international pressures, the court was incapable of reaching a decision. But after repeated admonitions against signing from the Chinese ministers in London and Berlin, and particularly from the minister in Tokyo, who stressed that Russia would not dare take action in Manchuria in face of the combined opposition of Britain and Japan, the court finally rejected the Russian treaty on 23 March. Facing international opposition, the Russians took no direct action but merely issued a statement that, as much as they would like to evacuate Manchuria, the realities of international politics did not permit them to do so at the moment. Li continued to support a separate settlement through direct negotiation and attempted to offer concessions in Manchuria to Russia in exchange for troop evacuation, but Count Witte refused his proposals. Thus rejected, old, weak and ashamed, Li Hung-chang died suddenly on 7 November 1901, at the age of seventy-eight. Li's work was carried on by Prince Ch'ing and Grand Councillor Wang Wen-shao. As the international situation was unfavourable to Russia, she Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
BOXER UPRISING
I29
ultimately signed an agreement with China on 4 April 1902 promising to evacuate Manchuria in three stages at six-monthly intervals. On her part, China agreed to protect the Russian-dominated Chinese Eastern Railway. The first evacuation took place on schedule, but when the second stage was due in April 1903, the Russians did not leave but resorted to the subterfuge of disguising their troops as 'railway guards'. In addition, they demanded new monopolistic rights and re-occupied the evacuated cities of Mukden and Newchwang, sowing the seeds of war with Japan. Repercussions of the Boxer Uprising
The Boxer movement developed out of the combined forces of the reactionary Manchu court, the conservative officials and gentry, and the ignorant and superstitious people. It was an unreasoned outburst of emotion and anger against foreign imperialism, possessing an inherent patriotic element. Marxist and other historians today consider it a primitive form of patriotic peasant uprising, with the right motive but the wrong methods. The Boxer Uprising and its final settlement had many significant consequences: (1) The allied occupation of Peking and the Russian advance into Manchuria sharpened international rivalry and caused the powers to fear conflict among themselves and the subsequent end of equal economic opportunity in China. There developed a general international desire to reduce tension and maintain the status quo in China. The United States issued the second Open Door note on 3 July 1900, in an effort to 'preserve Chinese territorial and administrative entity and safeguard for the world the principle of equal and impartial trade with all parts of the Chinese Empire.' And on 16 October, Britain and Germany signed an agreement (to which other powers were invited to adhere) stipulating that the signatories would refrain from seizing Chinese territory. This stalemate on imperialistic activities prevented an immediate break-up of the Ch'ing empire, but its international position fell to an unprecedentedly low point. (2) The Boxer Protocol infringed severely upon Chinese sovereignty. The prohibition on arms importation, the destruction of the Taku and other forts, the stationing of foreign troops in the legation quarter, and the right of foreign powers to deploy troops from Peking to the sea, all compromised China's powers of self-defence. The suspension of government examinations in many parts of the country was a blatant interference with the internal administration of China. (3) The indemnity of 450 million taels together with its accrued interest Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
I30
FOREIGN RELATIONS, 1 8 6 6 - I 9 0 5
would have amounted, if fully paid, to 982,283,150 taels, more than twice the original sum. As the payments had to be made in foreign currencies, China suffered additional losses in the exchange, especially during the years when the value of silver sharply declined. The outflow of such a large amount of capital inhibited, if not incapacitated, China's economic growth. (4) Foreign ministers in Peking thenceforth constituted a powerful diplomatic corps that sometimes functioned above the Manchu court as a super-government. (5) The barbarous Boxer conduct made China appear uncivilized to the world, while the brutal demonstration of foreign power created an image of invincibility and superiority that shattered Chinese self-confidence and self-respect. The Chinese attitude of disdain and hostility towards the foreigner often became one of fear and toadying. (6) Although the Manchu court attempted some half-hearted reforms towards a constitutional government in an effort to survive, many Chinese, viewing the Manchu leadership as bankrupt, turned to revolution. Dr Sun Yat-sen's advocacy of a forceful overthrow of the Ch'ing received increasing sympathy and support. His image changed from that of a disloyal rebel to that of a patriotic revolutionary as the pulse of revolution quickened, precipitating the ultimate fall of the Manchu dynasty in 1911.
THE EFFECTS OF THE ANGLO-JAPANESE ALLIANCE AND THE RUSSO-JAPANESE WAR
Origins of the Alliance
The Russian occupation of Manchuria, with all its serious international ramifications, must be viewed in the larger context of European power politics. At the turn of the century, Europe was caught in a precarious balance of power between the Triple Alliance (Germany, Austria-Hungary and Italy) and the Dual Alliance (France and Russia), with Britain maintaining her 'splendid isolation'. The tension generated by the rivalry between the two camps and the fear that the two, being defensive alliances, might join in a continental league against Britain, resulted in a stalemate among the powers, prompting them to direct their attention towards Asia and Africa. From this perspective, the Russian encroachment in Manchuria was not merely an isolated case of violation of Chinese sovereignty, but a serious disruption of the existing international order. Japan, in particular, was concerned with her position in Korea and Manchuria, and the United States feared for the future of the Open Door in China. Britain felt threatened about her influence in Peking and her position south of the Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
ANGLO-JAPANESE ALLIANCE AND RUSSO-JAPANESE WAR 131
Great Wall. On the other hand, France supported the Russian advance and Germany secretly encouraged Russia's eastward expansion to divert her focus from Europe. Clearly, a new era of international relations was unfolding, leading to an unprecedented East-West alignment. Britain was at the crossroads. Her policy of 'splendid isolation' had left her no friends, and the Boer War, absorbing 250,000 British soldiers for two-and-a-half years (October 1899-May 1902), exposed the weaknesses in her imperial defences and the dangers of her isolation policy. In order to protect her empire and preserve her pre-eminence in world leadership, Britain was forced to emerge from isolation and search desperately for an ally. The first choice was Germany. London had hoped that the AngloGerman Agreement of October 1900, which pledged the maintenance of the status quo in China, would check the Russian advance in Manchuria, but Germany later excluded Manchuria from the pact in an apparent move to avoid antagonizing Russia. Repeated British attempts to seek an alliance with Germany met with no success, obliging London to look for other alternatives. France was out of the question because of her role in the Dual Alliance, while the United States adhered to her traditional policy of 'no entangling alliances', and having recently fought the Spanish War, was in no mood for an overseas venture to defend the Open Door. Japan thus became the only possibility, the more attractive because of her naval power and well-known antipathy towards Russia. In 1901 the British Admiralty reckoned that the combined RussianFrench naval forces in the 'China seas' outnumbered those of Britain by nine to four in battleships, but alignment with Japan would give Britain a superior ratio of eleven to nine in battleships and a preponderance of cruisers, obviating the need to draw ships from her European fleets. Apart from military considerations, Britain was concerned with possible Russian domination of Peking through their control of Manchuria, and the penetration of Russian economic influence (through Belgian capital in building the Peking-Hankow Railway) into the Yangtze valley - a traditional British sphere of interest. Also disturbing was the intensification of Russian activities in Tibet leading to the dispatch by the Dalai Lama of two missions to Russia in 1901-2.78 If unchecked, the Russian southward thrust might threaten the security of India. With traditional fears thus revived, Britain found it imperative to ally with Japan in order to block the Russian advance and maintain her pre-eminence in Asia. With a farflung empire, being isolated in European politics, and facing new Russian threats, Britain could hardly do otherwise. Negotiations with the Japanese 78
Liu Yen, Cbung-kuo wai-chiao shib (Chinese diplomatic history), enlarged by Li Fang-ch'en, 268-9.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
FOREIGN RELATIONS, 1 8 6 6 - 1 9 0 5 / SIBERIA
/
\
]
Aigun^
•AjAianchouli
S I B E R I A
.X
^»-*^--*--t—*v
j
OUTER MONGOLIA
yS
N<
S
HEILUNGKIANG
/Tsitsihar
/
V>~>
S
>
rbin
c
/ V E
^ v
H /O
L
Vladivostok/
^
vf /
'Anshan //Ying-kouT/ •^(Newchwangj//
Shan-hai-kuanV*^
> f (•—» i ^Vf w * / I
o
DTUN
-/|LIA(
k
J??'
L f
K
R EA y
°
g
^ / \
Kinanlungff / Peninsula^A/y (i-?Dairen Port Arthur
fWonsan
Chinnampo Vp-y8ng'yang V .
J r^^~u Weihaiwei \^v^Chefoo~-^v-j
Inchon' iTSeoul (Chemulpo)
y f t t o w KiaochowV\^l j J Tsingtao
M
ChangchunyC^^,
/ >"*"n / '
7
•
7 1\
->
{ J
#
'^
''^
\
\ 1
X
S EA
f
\
Ta^5\ 1
(^
Pusan\j
I f
/^y
Shimonosekij^
(
\
?
300 km 200milos
\
rushi,a^
.-.'.?
'
M A P . 9 International relations of Manchuria and Korea
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
V
£t»Sasebo
A N G L O - J A P A N E S E A L L I A N C E A N D R U S S O - J A P A N E S E WAR 133
minister in London proceeded swiftly in order to block any possible Japanese agreement with Russia, which would seriously jeopardize British interests in Asia. For Japan, antagonism with Russia had been prevalent ever since the Triple Intervention of 1895. Alliance with Britain, the foremost Western power, was a dream beyond expectation, for it would elevate Japan's international status instantly, signify her coming of age as a great power, and serve as an effective shield against Russia. A powerful group led by the prime minister Katsura Taro (a protege" of Yamagata Aritomo), the foreign minister Kato Takaaki, his successor Komura Jutaro, and minister to Britain Hayashi Tadasu, strongly favoured such a course of action, and they had the support of the elder statesmen Yamagata, Saigo Tsugumichi and Matsukata Masayoshi. But the influential former premier and elder statesman Ito Hirobumi, doubted British sincerity in abandoning the traditional policy of isolation and feared that the alliance would make Japan bear the brunt of fighting Russia, a task which he thought too onerous for his country. He preferred, instead, a rapprochement with Russia since the questions of Korea and Manchuria concerned mainly Japan and Russia, not Britain. His arguments evoked a sympathetic response from the other elder statesman, Inoue Kaoru, but Yamagata and his military group believed that any rapprochement with Russia could only be temporary and ultimately Japan would have to fight Russia for supremacy in Korea and Manchuria. Needless to say, the conflicting views in foreign affairs among the Japanese leadership were related to rivalry in domestic politics: Ito wanted to prevent the military from dominating the affairs of state, while the military wanted to deny Ito the chance of returning to political power. In opposing the cabinet's stand, Ito had become something of a nuisance to Katsura. Katsura was anxious to rid himself of a political rival and an opportunity presented itself in October 1901 when Ito was invited by Yale University to receive an honorary doctor-of-law degree during its bicentennial celebration. After the event, Ito, with the encouragement of Inoue, went to Europe with the intention of visiting Russia in a private capacity to initiate negotiations. With Ito out of the country, Katsura ordered Hayashi to proceed with the alliance negotiations in London as fast as possible. When Ito reached Paris, Hayashi appeared with a draft treaty of the alliance. Ito was so discouraged that he thought of returning home, but in the end decided to proceed to Russia as planned. He asked Hayashi to temporize in London for a while. In Berlin he received word from Tokyo that negotiations for the alliance had gone too far for Japan to withdraw. Still undaunted, Ito continued his trip to Russia, where he proposed: (1) a mutual guarantee of Korea's independence; (2) a mutual promise not to
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
134
FOREIGN RELATIONS,
1866-I905
use its territory for strategic purposes against each other; and (3) Russian recognition of Japan's freedom of action in Korea, in exchange for Japanese acknowledgment of Russia's paramount interests in Manchuria. The Russian government would not accept these conditions. It refused to give Japan a free hand in Korea and it insisted on freedom of action for Russia in Manchuria as well as in the rest of China.79 Ito left Russia without reaching an agreement, but he still did not give up the idea of rapprochement. On the way home, in Berlin, he cabled Tokyo to warn again of the unreliability of Britain and proposed a postponement of the signing of the alliance pending further negotiations with Russia. The cabinet, however, was in no mood to risk losing a sure alliance with Britain for a dubious chance of reconciliation with Russia. On the recommendation of the privy council the emperor approved the Anglo-Japanese Alliance in December 1901. Ito accepted the decision with grace but urged that the alliance be used, not to confront Russia but to put pressure on her to reach an agreement based on the principle of Man-Kan kokan: a quid pro quo of Japanese acceptance of Russian dominance of Manchuria for Russian recognition of Japanese dominance of Korea, in short, a 'Manchuria-Korea exchange'. The Anglo-Japanese Alliance was formally concluded on 30 January 1902. In the preamble the contracting parties called for the maintenance of the status quo and general peace in East Asia through the preservation of the independence and territorial integrity of China and Korea, and equal opportunity for all nations in these two countries. The signatories declared that they would take necessary measures to safeguard their interests in these two countries if threatened by foreign aggression or domestic disturbances. They pledged neutrality if either became involved in a war with another power, and agreed to use their influence to prevent other powers from joining the war; but if another power joined the war against one of the signatories, the other signatory would come to its aid. Thus, Japan was given a free hand to fight Russia; if France should intervene on the side of Russia, Britain would come to Japan's rescue. Impact of the Alliance
The immediate reaction of Russia and France was to extend the applicability of the Dual Alliance to East Asia, but it was merely a symbolic move. American sympathy was with Japan. President Theodore Roosevelt considered her a defender of the Open Door and China's territorial integrity, and even saw Japan's complete control of Korea as in the best interests of 79
Ch'en Fu-kuang, Yu-Cb'ing i-lai Mb Cbung-O kuan-hsi (Sino-Russian relations during the Ch'ing dynasty), 531.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
ANGLO-JAPANESE ALLIANCE AND RUSSO-JAPANESE WAR 135
peace in East Asia.80 To him the Chinese were weak, befuddled and easy prey of the strong, while the Japanese signified a rising power in the East. 'What nonsense to speak of the Chinese and the Japanese as of the same race!'81 The president looked to Japan to block the Russian advance in Manchuria and was pleased to see her position strengthened through the British connection. China reacted with a mixture of relief, shame and fear. Initially, there was a feeling of relief because the alliance was directed against Russia in favour of the preservation of China and Korea. A sense of shame followed because the foreign pledge for China's independence and territorial integrity put her into the same category as Korea and emphasized the fact that China's fate was not in her own hands but in those of her would-be protectors. Finally, there was fear that Japan would ultimately replace Russia as the chief imperialist in Manchuria. The joint memorial of the elder statesmen Chang Chih-tung, governor-general of Hu-Kwang, and Liu K'un-i, governor-general of Liang-Kiang, dated 16 February 1902, expressed these feelings of relief and anxiety when they informed the court that it was the activities of Russia in Manchuria that had aroused the resentment of Japan and Britain, and prompted them to form the alliance 'with the primary purpose of dealing with Manchuria'. However, they warned: 'If we can follow them [Britain and Japan] and hold firm, it will be good for Manchuria, but if we fall into the Russian trap and cause Japan and Britain to lose their rights, they would undoubtedly seek compensations from us.' 82 Two days later, in a telegram to Liu K'un-i and Yuan Shih-k'ai, now governor-general of Chihli, Chang expressed great concern over the implications of the alliance. Referring to the first article on the British and Japanese declaration to intervene in Chinese and Korean domestic disturbances, he questioned the meaning of 'disturbances'. Did it mean that they could send troops to China at will just as Japan did in Korea during the Tonghak Insurrection? Painfully he proclaimed: 'To rely on others for preservation and to be placed along with Korea is most disheartening. Our country has fallen to such a state of weakness that I have nothing more to say!'8* Yuan Shih-k'ai was even more emphatic in his analysis of the alliance. No country in the East, he informed the court, had a better army than Japan and no country in the West had a better navy than Britain. The com*° Marius B. Jansen, Japan and China: from mar to peace, 1894-1972, 79-80. 81 Michael H. Hunt, Frontier defense and the open door: Manchuria in Chinese-American relations, itfj~ifii, 78, 81. »» U7CSL, I52.iob-i2a. •' Chang Chih-tung, Chang Wen-bsiann kmg, cb'uan-cbi (Complete collection of Chang Chihtung's papers), 178.1J.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
136
FOREIGN RELATIONS,
1866-I905
bination of the two created a new power bloc affecting not only the balance in East Asia but the entire world, and they did so to protect their own national interests without any real intention ofpreserving China and Korea. Yuan asked, why should Britain and Japan exert themselves at great expense for the benefit of China ? Therefore, the Chinese should expect no benefits from the alliance. On the contrary, the alliance forebode trouble for China should she ever relax her vigilance. Soberly he warned, 'There is no greater shame for China than to rely on the alliance of other countries for the preservation of her territory I' In the face of such humiliation, Yuan urged the court to strengthen the country through an immediate institutional reform, rapid army training, development of resources, and promotion of modern education.8* Despair prevailed among Chinese officialdom because of the country's total inability to do anything about the situation. It was clear that if the Anglo-Japanese Alliance led to a Russo-Japanese understanding, China would be the loser, and if it led to a war, Chinese territory would be the battleground, and China would be at the mercy of the victor. There was also a growing fear of the rise of Japan as the chief menace to China.8s Chang Chih-tung found the Japanese becoming increasingly overbearing, employing the tactics of 'sweet talk but vicious action'.86 He saw through the hollowness of the reference to the Open Door in the Anglo-Japanese Alliance and was very concerned about the ultimate Japanese designs. Yet he continued to regard Japan as a lesser evil than Russia on the grounds that it was preferable for China 'to seek the aid of a nearby state in order to ward off aggression by a distant foe'.87 Britain had hoped that the alliance would have a steadying effect on Japan, making her neither too belligerent nor too conciliatory towards Russia, thus lessening the chances of war. She saw no objection to an agreement between Japan and Russia provided she was kept informed of the negotiations and it did not violate the stipulations of the alliance. The Japanese government believed that an agreement with Russia was preferable to war, but the military doubted that any enduring agreement was possible and feared that Russian military power in the East would steadily increase after the completion of the Trans-Siberian and Chinese Eastern railways. In Russia a series of conferences were held between November 1902 and *• Wang Yen-hsi and Wang Shu-min, comps., Huang-cb'ao Tao-Hsien-T'ung-Kuang tsou-i (Memorials of the Tao-kuang, Hsien-feng, T'ung-chih, and Kuang-hsu periods of the Ch'ing dynasty), reprinted in Taipei, 1968, 16.18. 85 L i K u o - c h ' i , Cbang Cbib-lung It wai-cbiao cbeng-ti'e ( C h a n g C h i h - t u n g ' s foreign policy p r o posals), $23-6. 86 Chang Chih-tung, Cbang Wen-bsiang kung cb'iian-cbi, 180.35b. " Ibid. 85.21b.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
ANGLO-JAPANESE ALLIANCE AND RUSSO-JAPANESE WAR 137
April 1903 to deliberate on East Asian policy. The finance minister, Witte, was attacked by an influential group led by the tsarist confidant, Bezobrazov, for involving Russia in the expensive work of railway building in Manchuria without providing adequate security against Chinese hostility or foreign intervention. This group controlled a timber-cutting concession in North Korea which they proposed should be exploited for profit and strategic purposes — using the concession as a military shield against Japanese penetration of southern Manchuria. Witte was rapidly losing influence with the tsar and his policy of peaceful penetration of Manchuria was discarded. The tsar decided that Russia should exploit the timber concession and halt the military evacuation of Manchuria until China accepted new conditions. In an attempt to turn Manchuria into a 'Yellow Russia',88 St Petersburg decided to demand that China should agree not to cede or lease territory in Manchuria to any other power, nor, without consulting Russia, open any new areas to foreign trade or consular residence. No foreigners, other than Russians, were to be employed in any administrative capacity in Manchuria; the Russo-Chinese Bank was to continue to collect customs dues at Newchwang; and all rights secured by the Russian subjects in Manchuria were to be preserved by them. On 18 April 1903 these demands were presented to the Chinese government which promptly communicated them to the interested foreign powers. Encouraged by Britain, Japan and the United States to reject the demands, the Chinese government informed St Petersburg that no new conditions could be discussed until the evacuation of Manchuria was completed in accordance with the convention of April 1902. A set of modified conditions proposed by Russia in September was also rejected, and on 8 October 1903, the date set for the final withdrawal of Russian troops' from Manchuria, China concluded revised commercial treaties with the United States and Japan, opening Mukden, Antung and Tatungkow to foreign trade and residence. In retaliation for this direct challenge to their demands, the Russians re-occupied Mukden. Earlier, in August 1903, the tsar had created a viceroyalty of the Far East, vested with independent powers of war and diplomacy after the fashion of the viceroyalty of the Caucasus created in 1845, treating Manchuria as if it were a territory to be absorbed like the Caucasus.89 Meanwhile, Japan had entered into negotiations with Russia. The general terms proposed were: (1) preservation of the independence and territorial integrity of China and Korea; (2) maintenance of equal com88 8
Ch'en Fu-kuang, Yu-Ch'ing i-lai chib Cbung-O kuan-bti, 3 3 8-9. ' Wu Hsiang-hsiang, O-li cb'in-lueb Chung-kuo Mb (A history of the Russian imperialist aggression in China), 220.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
138
FOREIGN RELATIONS,
1866-1905
mercial opportunity in those two countries; (3) mutual recognition of the existing legal rights of Russia and Japan in Manchuria and Korea, and of the right to send forces to protect these interests and deal with internal disturbances; and (4) recognition of the exclusive right of Japan to advise and assist Korea in carrying out internal reforms. It was clear that Japan now assumed an interventionist position in Manchuria. On 28 July 1903 the Russian government agreed to open discussions and the Japanese proposals were delivered on 12 August. In their counterproposals, delivered on 3 October, the Russians insisted that Manchuria was outside the scope of discussion. As far as Korea was concerned, while recognizing Japan's paramount interests there, they demanded mutual respect for Korea's independence and territorial integrity, a neutral zone north of the thirty-ninth parallel, and no fortification of the south coast. In short, Russia denied Japan's right to intervene in Manchuria while granting her a less than complete control of Korea. Although Russia later abandoned the neutral zone demand, the differences between the two sides were too vast to be bridged. The Japanese concluded that war was inevitable. The Russo-Japanese War
The decision for war was made in Tokyo after very sober assessments of the differences in the size, military preparation and financial resources of the two countries. It was felt that Japan could win early battles to achieve a position of strength from which to launch a peace settlement. General Kodama Gentaro, chief of staff, informed the throne: 'There is a good chance that Japan will win six out of ten victories on the battlefield. If that is the case, we can expect some country to step forward to offer its good offices to negotiate peace.'90 The country in question was the United States, for President Roosevelt was sympathetic with Japan's role in bearing the brunt of fighting Russia and defending the Open Door in Manchuria, since the Chinese themselves could not do it and the United States would not do it due to public apathy.91 To exploit fully the president's goodwill, Japan sent his former Harvard classmate, Kaneko Kentaro, to Washington. On 6 February 1904 Japan broke off negotiations with Russia and started hostilities a day later. On 10 February Russia and Japan declared war against each other. The Ch'ing court was in a dilemma as to China's status in the war, which was fought in Manchuria. Even before the diplomatic impasse, Yuan Shih-k'ai advised the court on 27 December 1903 that 'if we make common cause with Russia, the Japanese navy would attack our Southeast; 80
Jansen, Japan and China, 81.
*' H u n t , Frontier defense and the open door, 78—81.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
ANGLO-JAPANESE ALLIANCE AND RUSSO-JAPANESE WAR 139
if we make common cause with Japan, the Russian army would invade our Northwest. Not only would China be placed in a dangerous position but the entire globe could be endangered. In case of a breakdown in RussoJapanese negotiations, we should proclaim neutrality.'92 On 7 January 1904 the Japanese minister in China informed Peking that his government desired that China remain strictly neutral in the event of a Russo-Japanese War. On 22 January Yuan again impressed upon the court the importance of neutrality, since China lacked the capacity to prevent the war from taking place in her territory. The defence of Manchuria, he pointed out, would require hundreds of thousands of men and even the defence of key points would take sixty to a hundred thousand, when China at best could mobilize only twenty to thirty thousand soldiers, whose munitions were in short supply because of the prohibition of arms importation by the Boxer Protocol.93 Other officials such as Ts'en Ch'un-hsuan, governorgeneral of Liang-Kwang, however, advocated joining with Japan against Russia in an attempt to recover Manchuria.94 But this was clearly an impractical suggestion. At the outbreak of the war, Yuan again urged the court to proclaim neutrality 'to settle people's minds'.95 Only then did the court make the announcement, at the same time appealing to the belligerents to respect the imperial tombs at Mukden and Hsingking and not usurp the sovereignty of China in Manchuria: 'The territorial right of Manchuria must remain Chinese regardless of who wins and who loses; neither country should occupy (the area).' Japan agreed to honour China's neutrality and disclaimed any postwar territorial ambitions, but Russia refused to regard Manchuria as a neutral territory or discuss its future status.'6 Chinese public opinion became deeply resentful of the Russian arrogance and also critical of the timid Ch'ing attitude. Earlier, on 6 February, the German ambassador in Washington suggested to Roosevelt that the United States propose to the various powers that they cooperate to maintain the neutrality of Chinese territory south of the Great Wall. Roosevelt objected that such a proposal would leave Russia free to operate in Mongolia and Sinkiang and that the dispatch of an international force for the purpose of protecting North China might provoke Chinese hostility. But Washington did send notes to the powers asking them to urge Japan and Russia to 'respect the neutrality of China and in all practicable ways her administrative entity'. The neutral powers as well as Japan and Russia agreed to this on the understanding that Manchuria be excluded. The war itself hardly needs recounting here. Suffice it to say that by « [PCSL, 179.4b. « IbM. 181.18.
»i Ibid. 181.3-j. «•/*/
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
I40
FOREIGN RELATIONS,
1866-1905
spring 1905 the Japanese had taken Port Arthur, driven the Russians from southern Manchuria, landed in the Sakhalin Islands, and completely defeated the Russian navy, including the near-total destruction of the Baltic Fleet in the Straits of Tsushima. Militarily and financially exhausted, Japan asked Roosevelt to use his good offices to bring about a peace conference, which was held at Portsmouth, New Hampshire. The Chinese were deeply concerned about the peace terms and how they would affect the future of their country. Sun Pao-ch'i, minister in Berlin, recommended that China take the initiative in opening Manchuria, Mongolia and Sinkiang to foreign commerce, as a means of preserving her sovereignty and forestalling future Russian designs.97 The court asked for suggestions from the provinces and Chang Chih-tung's response of 24 July 1905 represented the consensus of most officials: 'It is utterly impossible that Japan would return to China all the special privileges she has seized in Manchuria. But if she takes too much she would violate her earlier pledge and incur the jealousy of European powers. This she would not do. [In saying] she is for China, Japan is in fact for herself, for a strong Japan needs the preservation of China. Russia only wants to deceive China and swallow her up; it is purely a case of hurting us and benefiting themselves . . . . Hence, regardless of the final peace terms, whatever rights Japan obtains in the East are far preferable to Russian [gains].'98 Clearly, Chinese attitudes had changed from 'anti-Japanese, pro-Russian' after the Sino-Japanese War to 'pro-Japanese, anti-Russian' after the RussoJapanese War. Chang Chih-tung also recommended the complete opening of Manchuria to foreign commerce and residence, introducing British and American influence to counter the Japanese, and the employment of foreign advisers, including the Japanese, to govern the area. With the presence of these foreigners, he concluded, Manchuria could no longer be governed in the old way and her special status should be ended.' 9 The peace treaty, signed on 5 September 1905, provided for: Russian recognition of Japan's political, economic and military pre-eminence in Korea; the mutual withdrawal of troops from Manchuria within eighteen months; and the return of Manchuria to China except for the leased territory of Liaotung and the southern section of the Manchurian railway, which Russia agreed to transfer to Japan subject to China's approval. Russia agreed to cede to Japan the southern half of Sakhalin and the adjacent islands. Both Japan and Russia had the right to station troops in « Ch'ing Kuang-ksu cb'ao Chung-Jib ehiao-sbe shib-liao (Historical materials on Sino-Japanese negotiations during the Kuang-hsu period), 68.25, 24 June 1904. •• WCSL, I9o.i2b-i5b. •• Chang Chih-tung, Chang Wen-bsiang kung cb'uan-cbi, 8j.2j-b.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
ANGLO-JAPANESE ALLIANCE AND RUSSO-JAPANESE WAR 141
Manchuria to protect their respective railways, but not more than fifteen soldiers per kilometre. On 23 December 1905 China and Japan signed a 'Secret Protocol of 16 Articles' in Peking, which ratified the transfer of the Liaotung leasehold and the South Manchurian Railway to Japan. In addition it opened sixteen ports and agreed on a joint Sino-Japanese exploitation of the forest on the southern side of the Yalu River. Japan gained far more than was specified in the Portsmouth treaty, as a compensation for the 'generous' terms for Russia. She had in fact replaced Russia as the chief imperialist in Manchuria. Japan's emergence as a great power and her renewal of a closer alliance with Britain in 1905 ushered in a new chapter in the international relations of East Asia. It did not end the rivalries of the powers in China but it did remove the fear of territorial partition which had threatened the moribund Ch'ing empire since 1895. Had Russia been victorious, she would most likely have annexed Manchuria and perhaps Mongolia, provoking the other powers to demand territorial compensation. But in defeat, Russia turned her attention to the Balkans where she collided with AustriaHungary and Germany, setting the stage for World War I. Japan, now firmly established in southern Manchuria, was in a position eventually to threaten the independence and territorial integrity of China. But, in 1905, the return of Chinese administration in Manchuria, even though circumscribed by the special privileges of Japan and Russia, ensured that Manchuria would remain Chinese. On 20 April 1907 the Ch'ing court took measures to end the special political status of Manchuria as a frontier homeland of the Manchus and instituted the regular provincial system there, with Hsu Shih-ch'ang as governor-general and concurrently imperial commissioner, assisted by three civil governors who replaced the military governors in the provinces of Fengtien, Kirin and Heilungkiang.It>0 Equally notable was the rise of a constitutional movement in China under the impact of the Russo-Japanese War. The famous scholar-turnedindustrialist, Chang Chien, proclaimed that 'the victory of Japan and the defeat of Russia are the victory of constitutionalism and the defeat of monarchism'. On 1 September 1906 the Ch'ing court was obliged to announce its intention of establishing a constitutional government, but its insincerity alienated it further from the people and gave new impetus to the revolutionary movement. China's unhappy vicissitudes in her foreign relations since the 1860s had paralleled the decline of the Ch'ing dynasty. 100
For details of the status of Manchuria and its reorganization, see Robert H. G. Lee, Tbe Manchurian frontier in Cb'ing history, 1 5 2 * / teq.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
CHAPTER 3
CHANGING CHINESE VIEWS OF WESTERN RELATIONS, 1840-95*
INTRODUCTION:
T R A D I T I O N A L VIEWS O F F O R E I G N
RELATIONS
China's invaders in the nineteenth century left a more extensive record than anything we are as yet aware of from the Chinese side. After all, success makes a good story. Exploits and impressions on the expanding frontier of the international trading world were variously recorded by travellers, diplomats, missionaries, journalists and others in a flood of correspondence, articles and books now available in Western libraries and archives. The Chinese who suffered invasion, on the other hand, had little but oddities, fears and disasters to record. The story of the foreign intrusion on the whole was unpleasant and humiliating. Moreover, it was known directly to only a few of the ruling class, literati and officials, while the commoners, especially those who worked with foreigners, were not accustomed to writing down their views and experiences for posterity. Consequently in examining Chinese views of the West we are obliged to rely primarily on upper-class writings by scholars who were thoroughly indoctrinated in the Chinese classical teachings and therefore least likely to depart from traditional attitudes towards foreigners. In addition, China's perception of Western relations during the Ch'ing period was influenced by certain considerations peculiar to the ruling Manchus, who came from an area that differed significantly from China proper. The economy of Manchuria, for example, was semi-nomadic, based originally on a mixture of hunting, fishing and animal husbandry that was fundamentally different from the sedentary and agricultural economy of China. The Manchus therefore paid particular attention strategically to the nomadic societies of Mongolia, Sinkiang and Tibet, which shared certain basic characteristics with Manchuria. Although the Western impact from the coast would have constituted a severe challenge to any Chinese dynasty, the Manchu preoccupation with the northern nomadic region handicapped their efforts to deal with the Westerners who came to China from the south* The authors wish to acknowledge a heavy debt to Professor Kwang-Ching Liu who has supplied much helpful information, not all of which is specifically noted. They also wish to thank Professors Hao Chang and Richard B. Rice for helpful suggestions.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
TRADITIONAL VIEWS
143
east. In addition, culturally the Manchus were a non-Sinic people. That they clearly recognized a difference between themselves and the Chinese was abundantly evident throughout their dominion in China. Being aliens themselves, the Manchus were not in a comfortable position to advocate nationalism when China faced the Western invasion in the mid-nineteenth century. Instead, they had their own dynastic interests at heart. However, as the nineteenth century progressed, these Manchu elements became increasingly insignificant because of the gradual sinicization of the Manchus. They had adopted traditional Sino-Confucian institutions increasingly in the seventeenth century, and their sinicization accelerated after the Yung-cheng reign began in 1722. This trend was evident in the Ch'ien-lung Emperor's celebrated 1793 edict to the king of England, in which he forbade the residence of a Western representative inside China, and told the English that 'there is nothing we lack'.r It is not surprising, then, to find that in coping with the problem of Western incursion during the nineteenth century the Manchus relied heavily on Chinese culturalism. By 1800 the Manchus had firmly adopted the Chinese world view. This Chinese world order was a set of ideas and practices elaborated and perpetuated by the ruling elite of China over many centuries.2 At the heart of this order was the universal pre-eminence of the Son of Heaven -(i'ten-t^ti) who presided over t'ien-hsia 'all under heaven', a term that was often used to embrace the whole world including everything outside of China. For the Chinese, China was not viewed as a part of Asia, much less of the 'Far East'; it was Chung-kuo, or the Middle Kingdom, that embodied civilization itself. These Sinocentric ideas originated from the fact that China's superior size, power, history and resources all made her the natural centre of the East Asian world. The relations of the Chinese with non-Chinese peoples were coloured by this concept of Sinocentrism and an assumption of Chinese superiority. The Chinese tended to think of their foreign relations as an extension of the principles of social and political order that were manifested internally within China. Accordingly, China's foreign relations were hierarchic and nonegalitarian, like the Chinese society and state. In theory, the Chinese world order should have been hierarchic in several respects - China was internal, large and high, while the non-Chinese 'barbarians' were external, small and low. At the same time, the ideas of inclusiveness and impartiality were also important. On his part the universal ruler should give largesse and hospitality to all in order to 'show nothing left out'. In doing so, a 1 2
Ssu-yii Teng and John K. Fairbank, China's response to the West, 19. For this topic we draw heavily on John K. Fairbank, ed. The Chinese world order (hereafter CWO). For a perceptive analysis of transition of this world view in modern China, sec Joseph R. Levenson, Confucian China and its modern fate: the problem of monarchical decay.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
144
CHINESE VIEWS OF WESTERN RELATIONS, 1 8 4 0 - 9 5
policy of impartiality should be adopted. All foreigners, near or far, were to be treated equally. The non-Chinese peoples were expected in theory to participate in the Chinese world order by observing the appropriate procedures and ceremonies in their contact with the Son of Heaven. These practices constituted what foreigners called the tribute system. There were of course discrepancies between theory and practice concerning the Chinese world order. When the non-Chinese peoples refused to conform to this scheme, coercion might be used. Indeed, militarism can easily be found in the classical Confucian tradition. An old saying quoted in the Tso-chuan says, 'It is virtue by which the people of the Middle Kingdom are cherished; it is by severity that the wild tribes around are awed'. 3 This militant attitude continued in the later dynasties, as evidenced by the Ming emperor Yung-lo's aggressive determination to bring the whole known world into the framework of the Chinese system. At times when there was no war it was felt important to collect intelligence, analyse it, and test the results of the analysis so as to ascertain the other party's strength and intention. This was in keeping with the ancient classic on the art of war, the Sun T%u: 'If you know yourself and know your adversary, a hundred battles will be a hundred victories.' But the Sun T%u hastens to add that to be victorious in all one's battles is not supreme excellence; supreme excellence consists in breaking the enemy's resistance without fighting. Actually, in the long history of China's relations with non-Chinese ethnic groups, pacifism generally prevailed, for lack of regard for physical coercion was deeply imbedded in the Confucian tradition. Confucius says, 'By indulgent treatment of men from a distance, they are brought to resort to him [the king] from all quarters.'4 Mencius went further by declaring that 'those who are skilful in fighting should suffer the highest punishment'.s From the former passage a Chinese term for appeasement, huai-joujuan-jen ('to cherish men from afar') was formed, and along with this a cbi-mi or 'loose rein' policy (as when a rider controls a horse) was frequently used in dealing with stronger 'barbarians'. (The early decades of the mid-nineteenth century treaty system could be viewed in this perspective.) Often in the Han and T'ang dynasties, Confucian literati had warned that the strength of the government and of the people would be exhausted by a policy of military expansion. This pacific foreign policy was a reflection of the established order in China that from Han times onwards esteemed the triumph of literate culture (wen) over brute force (wu). Yet while the Confucian tradition tends, on balance, to be more 3
James Legge, trans. The Chinese classics. The Cb'tm Ts'ew with the Tso Cbuen, 196. • James Legge, trans. The Chinese classics. The doctrine of the mean, 409. s James Legge, trans. The Chinese classics. The works of Mencius, $05.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
TRADITIONAL VIEWS
145
pacific than militant concerning foreign policy, it was by no means onesided. This ambivalent attitude was manifest in China's views of Western relations from 1840 to 1895.
INITIAL RESPONSE AND INERTIA, 1 8 4 0 - 6 0
Traditional statecraft and the new strategy proposals
The early nineteenth century saw the emergence of revived interest in the school of statecraft or 'learning of practical use to society' (ching-shih chih jung). This school of thought, stressing the importance of social participation and this-worldly activism, reflected the ideal of Confucian humanism. On the one hand, it rejected the Neo-Confucian trend towards metaphysical speculation as being 'empty', and, on the other hand, it despised the practice of textual criticism as being pedantic and useless. It had flourished in the seventeenth century but, mainly due to the repressive policy of the Ch'ien-lung Emperor towards the literati class, was overshadowed by the school of scholasticism in the eighteenth century.6 The re-emergence of the statecraft school in the nineteenth century was evidenced by the revi taxation of the Modern Text School of classical learning, which laid stress on one's emotional need for moral commitment to bring peace and prosperity to state and society in a practical way. An important scholar in this intellectual revival was Chuang Ts'un-yii of Wuchin, Kiangsu (1719-88). Through his grandson Liu Feng-lu (1776-1829), who studied the classics under him, the ching-shib school gained momentum, for Liu exerted both direct and indirect influence on a group of young scholars during the early nineteenth century. They included the prolific writers Kung Tzu-chen and Pao Shih-ch'en, and the frontier experts Yao Ying and Hsiao Ling-yii. This group also included Lin Tse-hsu and Huang Chueh-tzu, who were to play important roles in the Opium War, and Wei Yuan and Feng Kuei-fen, who later were noted as reformers primarily interested in the problems arising from China's relations with the West. Of these men Wei Yuan and Kung Tzu-chen had especially close ties with Liu Feng-lu. In the preface to Haang-ch'ao ching-shih wen-pien (Collection of Ch'ing dynasty writings on statecraft), Wei Yuan set forth two basic approaches of the statecraft school: emphasis on the present, and stress on the importance of practical application. What were the pressing problems of China during this time? In the first decades of the nineteenth century, a major 6
For a brief account of the intellectual trends in early Ch'ing, see Liang Ch'i-ch'ao, Intellectual trends in tie Cb''ingperiod(Cb'ing-lai hsueb-shu kai-lun), trans, by Immanuel C. Y. Hsu, i and 11.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
146
CHINESE VIEWS OF WESTERN RELATIONS, 1840-95
concern of the ching-shih literati was the problem of domestic administration, resulting from the slow process of dynastic decline in general and the White Lotus Rebellion in particular (see volume 10, chapter 3). These problems involved rebel-suppression techniques and general reform of grain transport and the salt gabelle. As the rebellion drew to a close, the ching-shih scholars paid increasing attention to frontier problems, especially those concerning Inner Asia. A case in point was Wei Yuan (1794-18 5 7), who began his frontier interests when he was in his twenties. In 1830 his plan to make a personal tour of Sinkiang with General Yang Fang aborted, a missed opportunity he regretted for the rest of his life. However, he continued his investigation of the northern frontier, completing at least eight studies.7 Other statecraft scholars continued such investigations, as evidenced by Chang Mu and Ho Ch'iu-t'ao in the fifties and Tseng Chi-tse and Chang Chih-tung in the seventies and eighties. The maritime frontiers, to be sure, had sometimes caused concern. The coastal harassments of the Sino-Japanese pirates in the sixteenth century and the threats of Koxinga's forces from Taiwan during the seventeenth century were worrying, yet before the mid-nineteenth century China's overriding concern had been the Inner Asian frontier. With the mounting Western incursion from the south-east coast, however, the second quarter of the nineteenth century saw a significant reorientation in the focus of Chinese statecraft - from Inner Asia to the maritime world, whence came 'barbarians' with a new technology. The statecraft writer Pao Shih-ch'en declared as early as 1826 that the British would soon pose a serious threat to China from the coast, but his view in this respect remained ambivalent; he wrote later that the relief of people's sufferings was far more important than maritime defence. The early writings on maritime defence naturally focused on the Kwangtung coast. Kuan T'ien-p'ei, who was to be killed during the Opium War, compiled the Ch'ou-hai ch'u-chi (First collection of papers relating to preparation for maritime defence) around 1836, and similar studies were completed by Liang T'ing-nan, Yii Ch'ang-hui and Li Fu-hsiang after the war.8 The overriding concern of some statecraft literati-officials was to understand the maritime West. But how? For Commissioner Lin Tse-hsu, an effective way was through translation. When he was in Canton in 1839, he ordered the translation of foreign newspapers from Canton, Macao, Singapore and India. Wei Yuan later suggested the establishment of an official translation institute. Kuo Sung-tao's 1859 memorial proposed the ? Wang Chia-chien, Wei Yuan tui hsi-fang ti jen-sbih tbi cb'i bai-fang ssu-hsiang (Wei Yuan's 8
knowledge of the West and his ideas regarding maritime defence), 6. Ch'i Ssu-ho it al. eds. Ya-p'ien cban a&«;.g(The Opium War), 4.461; 6.491, 535.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
INITIAL RESPONSE, 1 8 4 0 - 6 0
147
creation of an official school for the teaching of foreign languages.9 (This approach was to be used during the fifties by some pragmatic officials on the coast, such as Ho Kuei-ch'ing, Lao Ch'ung-kuang and Hsueh Huan.) Besides newspapers, information was gathered on Western history, geography, law and political conditions. Under Commissioner Lin's sponsorship, passages of international law from Vattel were translated. Later, Liang T'ing-nan wrote a book, Ho-chung-kuo sbuo (On the United States), which spoke highly of the American political system. Impressive as these works might be, it was the study of world geography that was to have the most considerable influence. The interest in world geography appeared on the surface to be directed towards obtaining knowledge of the unknown Western world, and indeed of the entire globe. But when we consider the urgent needs of the times, it can be seen as a movement to strengthen China's own knowledge and ability. In other words, a segment of Chinese officials and literati of the period, after a war with a barbarian state of Western Europe, urgently sought to understand the enemy and discover what kind of place Europe was. It was necessary to seek correct answers. Under this pressure, there was a surge of interest in world geography. The data on Europe in Chinese gazetteers and historical works were extremely scanty. This was especially true of materials concerning the powerful countries of nineteenth-century Europe, since earlier knowledge of world geography had all come from the pens of Catholic missionaries, and even among these works there were only three illustrated geographies. Before the 1840s Chinese authors had produced three fairly reliable reference works: Ch'en Lun-chiung's Hai-kuo wen-cbien lu (Heard and seen in maritime countries; published in 1730), Wang Ta-hai's Hai-tao i chih (Little-known account of the seas and islands; 1760) and Hsieh Ch'ingkao's Hai-lu (Records of the seas; 1820). Lin Tse-hsu consulted the Hai-lu to get an understanding of the situation in Britain.10 After 1840 Chinese literati began gradually to pay more attention to the subject of world geography, and by 1861 more than twenty-two books had been written.'' Commissioner Lin Tse-hsu championed such study. Under his auspices, passages from Murray's Cyclopaedia of Geography were translated into Chinese in 1841 under the title of Ssu-chou chih (A gazetteer of * Kuo T'ing-i el al. Kuo Stmg-tao biien-sbtng nien-p'u (A chronological biography of Kuo Sungtao), 1.13 2-4. 10 Chung-yang ycn-chiu-yuan chin-tai-shih yen-chiu-so, comp. Cbin-Iai Cbung-kuo tui Hsi-fang cbi lieh-ch'iang jm-sbih l^u-liao bui-pien (Compendium of materials on modern Chinese understanding of the West and of the various powers; hereafter HFJS), 145. 1 ' Some of these twenty-two works were collected in the geographical series Hsiao-fang-bu cbai yu-li It'ung-cb'ao (Geographical series of Hsiao-fang-hu studio, preface 1894). Some were published separately. Seven are now lost except for their titles.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
I48
CHINESE VIEWS OF WESTERN RELATIONS, 1 8 4 0 - 9 5
four continents). A pioneer and comprehensive work was Wei Yuan's Hai-kuo fu chib (Illustrated treatise on the maritime kingdoms) which had its origins in Lin. The materials on foreign countries gathered by Lin were turned over to Wei in 1841, who compiled them into a large work of fifty chiian in 1842 and published it in the following year. This was the first significant Chinese work on the West. •2 Yao Ying was similarly interested in world geography. Unlike Commissioner Lin Tse-hsu and Wei Yuan, Yao acquired his knowledge of foreign countries from the British prisoners of war whom he captured while serving as a taotai on Taiwan during the Opium War. Another noted study on this subject entitled Ying huan chihlueh (A brief survey of the maritime circuit) was compiled by Hsu Chi-yii, governor of Fukien, and was published in 1848. With regard to their motives for writing, these men expressed the intention of making a rigorous pursuit of knowledge and of guiding the efforts of their fellow countrymen. Wei Yuan stated that his most important motive was to understand completely the situation of foreigners. Whether concerning the making of war or the conduct of peace negotiations, his central idea was to study the advantages the foreigners enjoyed and then to see how these advantages might be turned to use in subduing them. Because of this the Hai-kuo fu-chih contains not only the geography of the various countries but, at the same time, as complete a treatment as possible of the techniques of shipbuilding and weapons production in foreign countries. Wei held that all his fellow countrymen should study the geography of foreign countries. Hsu Chi-yu's Ying huan chih-lueh was more systematic. Because Hsu was in charge of commercial affairs at Foochow, he could combine his official duties with his writing. He thus compiled the book from foreign sources by working daily over a five-year period. Yao Ying avowed that his motive in writing came from his anger over the treatment of China at the hands of foreigners. His hope was that he could bring Chinese, both young and old, to a true knowledge of other countries. Finally, he wanted to save China from disgrace, and by emphasizing maritime and frontier defence avoid China's conquest by a foreign nation.'3 These scholars, especially Wei and Hsu, were thus instrumental in changing the Chinese geographical picture of the outside world. In so doing, they played a significant role, for they not only introduced new knowledge of the West, but also began to dissolve the Sinocentric view by showing that China was in reality not the 'Middle Kingdom'. 11
For Lin Tse-hsu, see Ch'i Ssu-ho et al. Ya-p'ien chan-cbeng, 6.506. For Wei Yuan, see articles by Jane K. Leonard and Peter M. Mitchell in MAS, 6.2 (1972) 151—204. •i Yao Ying, Tung-ming wen hou-cbi(Supplement to Yao Ying's collected essays), 8.iob-n. Hsu Chi-yii, Ying huan chih-lueh (A brief survey of the maritime circuit), preface. Wei Yuan, Hai-kuo t'u Mb (Illustrated treatise on the maritime kingdoms), preface. Also Fred W. Drake,
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
INITIAL RESPONSE, 1840-60
149
Impressed with British military power, some were interested in the superior Western weaponry and the need for China to emulate it. This new interest was epitomized in the popular saying ch'uan-cbien p'ao-Ii (strong ships, powerful cannon). In the years 1821-61 at least sixty-six men supported the view that China must procure such warships and guns, and these included the Tao-kuang Emperor, high government officials and eminent scholars.14 All of them advocated shipbuilding and arms research. Lin Tse-hsu also championed this programme. He purchased two hundred foreign guns to strengthen the Canton defences and ordered the translation of manuals on Western gun-making. For political reasons, however, he stopped short of advocating publicly the emulation of Western armament. Wei Yuan, on the other hand, was more straightforward. In January 1843, he finished thefirstdraft of his Hai-kuo t'u chih, in which he advocated the building of a shipyard and an arsenal at Canton, and the hiring of French and American engineers to carry out construction and to teach ship navigation and the operation of weapons. He also suggested adding a section to the imperial military examinations for naval officers so that those able to construct ships and weapons could enter public service, and those in the ranks who could pilot ships and operate weapons could gain promotion. He suggested that all naval officers be required to advance by these routes. These were pioneer ideas in the military history of modern China.1S Excluding the reprints of traditional works on weapons and munitions, the period produced twenty-two new works on Western arms - seven about the production of guns and cannon, and six on mines and bombs. Two works dealt with gun emplacements, and another two, the production of gunpowder. The remaining five works were on offensive and defensive artillery tactics. Most of these twenty-two works were finished between 1840 and 1850, with the latest appearing before i860.16 The relative values China chart 1 the world: Hsu Chi-yu and his geography of 1848.
'* The names of forty-five are listed in Wang Erh-min, Ch'ing-cbi ping-kungyeh ti hsing-eb'i (The rise of the armaments industry in the late Ch'ing period), 35. The others are: the Tao-kuang Emperor, Lu K'un (governor-general of Kwangtung and Kwangsi), I-liang (governorgeneral of Liang-Kiang), Chi-erh-hang-a (governor of Kiangsu), Ho Kuei-ch'ing (governorgeneral of Liang-Kiang), Chou T'ien-chueh (governor-general of grain transport), Kueiliang (grand secretary), Hua-sha-na (president of the Board of Civil Appointments), Shen Chao-lin (president of the Board of War), Chin Ying-lin (sub-director of the Court of Judicature and Revision), Hsueh Shu-t'ang (junior metropolitan censor), Liu Ch'eng-chung (provincial censor), Yin Keng-yun (provincial censor), and the following gentry: T'ang I, Fang Hsiung-fei, Hsiao Ling-yu, Hsia Hsieh, Liang T'ing-nan, Wu Min-shu, Hsu Nai and Feng Kuei-fen. '* Wei Yuan, Hai-kuo, 2.2a-b. 16 Ting Kung-ch'en, Kung Chen-lin (two works), Wang Chung-yang, Liang Chang-chu (two) and Hsi-la-pen wrote about guns and cannon; Huang Mien (two), Ting Shou-ts'un, P'an Shih-ch'eng, Lin Tse-hsu and Kao Pang-che about mines and bombs; Huang Mien and Yeh Shih-huai about gun emplacements; and Ting Shou-ts'un and Ch'en Chieh-p'ing about gunpowder. The remaining five authors were Chin Ying-lin, Chang Huan-yuan, Yii Ch'anghui, Hsu Nai-chi and Ch'i Yuan-fu. For a fuller account of these works, see Wang Erh-min,
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
IJO
CHINESE VIEWS OF WESTERN RELATIONS, 1 8 4 0 - 9 5
of these writings varied, but they all demonstrate the intention of the Chinese literati to make an intensive effort to study Western military technology. In addition, more than ten authors investigated or wrote about Western warships in this period. The most detailed explanation was the Huo-lun-cb'uan t'u-shuo (Illustrated treatise on the steamship) by Cheng Fu-kuang. 17 All of these reactions were directly stimulated by Western contact, which resulted in the Chinese making real demands upon themselves. Collectively, these studies were for the purpose of, as Wei put it, 'learning the superior techniques of the barbarians in order to control the barbarians'. Meanwhile, until China was able to use its own military strength, various temporary methods for controlling barbarians were suggested. One policy was the use olttzdzfj/ungshangchibi). Under the tribute system China as the host country customarily looked upon foreign relations and trade as one and the same thing. In fact, China did not even recognize the existence of foreign relations with the Western countries but only of 'barbarian affairs', in essence another name for trade. Some literati of the period, therefore, naturally thought of using trade to meet the necessities of foreign relations. In their treatment of traders from far-off countries, the Chinese had very early used the method of opening or closing markets in order to control them. It was not the intention of China to refuse trade absolutely, and this ultimate recourse was, therefore, not often used, although stoppages of trade had been used with increasing frequency to put pressure on the East India Company at Canton. In the 1840s Chinese officials tended to underestimate the true strength of the Western powers, and therefore used this policy too often. Failing at the same time to make a reasonable estimate of their own strength and state of preparedness, they invited the disaster of warfare. Trade stoppage was mainly used by Hsu Kuang-chin and by Yeh Ming-ch'en, successive governors-general at Canton, who were the most important advocates of the policy.18 The basic hypothesis of Sino-foreign trade, as the Chinese understood it, was that the foreigners could not give up their trade and so it could be used Cb'ing-chiping-kungyeh tibsing-ch'i, 206-8; Wei Yuan, Hai-kuo, 87.2; HFJS, 229, 301-2,418-19, 4}2, 435, 439, 875-904. 17 Wei Yuan, Hai-kuo, 84.ib-6; 85 (this chiian is Cheng Fu-kuang's Huo-lun-cb'uan t'u-ibuo or Illustrated treatise on the steamship). Hsieh Ch'ing-kao and Yang Ping-nan, Hai-lu (Records of the seas), 1.75. HFJS, 248-9, 860. Shib-liao bsun-k'an (Historical materials published thricemonthly), 38.398b. Ch'ing-tai ch'ou-pan i-wu shib-mo (Complete record of the management of barbarian affairs), Tao-kuang (hereafter IWSM-TK) 59.48b; 63.3815-39. Wang Wen-t'ai, Hung-mao-fan Ying-cbi-li k'ao-lueh (Short account of the red-haired English barbarians), in Wang Ch'ao-tsung, comp. Hai-aai fan-i lu, 6b. Wang Ta-hai, Hai-tao i chih (Little-known account of the seas and islands), in Hai-wai fan-i la, 7a-b. Hsu Chi-yii, Ying buan cbib-lueb,. 7.48IJ-49. '• IWSM-TK, 80.25.
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
INITIAL RESPONSE, 1 8 4 0 - 6 0
I JI
to make them surrender." What was the value of this policy in fact? Modern sovereign states have used it continually, and it seems to be a necessary part of national sovereignty. But in the ancient tradition of trade with China under the tribute system, a trade boycott was only one device for manipulating the barbarian. The basic strategy was to use the lure of trade and profit to meet the foreigner's desires and thus to appease him and avoid military conflict. After the Opium War and the opening of the treaty ports, Chinese officials still thought in this way. Ch'i-ying's idea of extending equal trade opportunities to all the powers was the best evidence of this use of trade as a positive inducement to peaceful behaviour. Trade expansion, then, would have some positive value for the policy of using trade to control foreigners.20 As this time-honoured policy did not work as effectively as expected during the mid-nineteenth century, the strategy of using the people to control the barbarians (jung min chih i) was also advocated. This concept harks back to the ancient idea that 'Heaven sees as the people see', that the sanction for government is the tacit acquiescence of the populace. Popular opposition that can overthrow government can also be used to oppose invaders. This policy was most clearly suggested by Hsu Kuang-chin as governor-general of Liang-Kuang, and by Sheng-pao, an imperial commissioner,21 but the number of those who discussed the policy was rather large, and its influence was widespread. The real aim was to use the public sentiment of the masses to oppose foreigners entering China, and it was first used to oppose the arrival of foreign merchants in the treaty ports. Later it was gradually applied in the interior to oppose the propagation of Christianity, frequently resulting in serious diplomatic complications. This policy reflected two of the literati's basic beliefs: thefirstwas that foreigners feared the common people, whenever they were aroused against them (they often were by Chinese officials), and so it was possible to use popular sentiment to control the barbarians.22 The second belief was that the people were loyal, given to group action, impetuous and easily incited, and thus could be used to oppose the foreigners.23 By the same token, the foreigners could be manoeuvred into opposing one another. This was the policy of using barbarians to control barbarians (/ / chih i). As early as the sixth century BC, the Chinese had already deve" Sbib-liao bsun-k'an, 56.340. IU7SM-TK, 8o.4a-b. Hsu Chi-yii, Sung-k'an bsicn-sheng cb'iian-chi
(Complete works of Hsu Chi-yii), 1.56b. Hsiao Ling-yu, Yueb-ttmg tbib-po lun (On foreign trade and shipping in Kwangtung), 2b, in Htiao-fang-hu chaiyii-ti ts'ung-cb'ao (hereafter HFHC), 2nd supplementary series, pt 9. 11 Sbib-liao btun-k'an, 36.}40.1WSM, Hsicn-feng (hereafter IWSM-HF), 34.22. 11 Hsu Chi-yii, Sung-k'an, 1.31^32. 21 Wang Erh-min, 'Ch'i-ying wai-chiao' (The diplomacy of Ch'i-ying), Ta-lu tta-cbib, 30.10 (1965) 330-3. 10
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008
152
CHINESE VIEWS OF WESTERN RELATIONS, 1 8 4 0 - 9 5
loped the concept that the 'security of the Son of Heaven lay in [using] the surrounding barbarian states' (t'ien-t%u shou tsai ssu-i). This concept easily led to the idea of using foreigners to control foreigners.24 Begin