London Mathematical Society Lecture Note Series 418
The Bloch–Kato Conjecture for the Riemann Zeta Function Edited by John Coates, A. Raghuram, Anupam Saikia, and R. Sujatha
LONDON MATHEMATICAL SOCIETY LECTURE NOTE SERIES Managing Editor: Professor M. Reid, Mathematics Institute, University of Warwick, Coventry CV4 7AL, United Kingdom The titles below are available from booksellers, or from Cambridge University Press at http://www.cambridge.org/mathematics
295 296 297 298 299 300 301 302 303 304 305 306 307 308 309 310 311 312 313 314 315 316 317 318 319 320 321 322 323 324 325 326 327 328 329 330 331 332 333 334 335 336 337 338 339 340 341 342 343 344 345 346 347 348 349 350 351 352 353 354
Geometry and integrability, L. MASON & Y. NUTKU (eds) Lectures on invariant theory, I. DOLGACHEV The homotopy category of simply connected 4-manifolds, H.-J. BAUES Higher operads, higher categories, T. LEINSTER (ed) Kleinian groups and hyperbolic 3-manifolds, Y. KOMORI, V. MARKOVIC & C. SERIES (eds) Introduction to Möbius differential geometry, U. HERTRICH-JEROMIN Stable modules and the D(2)-problem, F.E.A. JOHNSON Discrete and continuous nonlinear Schrödinger systems, M.J. ABLOWITZ, B. PRINARI & A.D. TRUBATCH Number theory and algebraic geometry, M. REID & A. SKOROBOGATOV (eds) Groups St Andrews 2001 in Oxford I, C.M. CAMPBELL, E.F. ROBERTSON & G.C. SMITH (eds) Groups St Andrews 2001 in Oxford II, C.M. CAMPBELL, E.F. ROBERTSON & G.C. SMITH (eds) Geometric mechanics and symmetry, J. MONTALDI & T. RATIU (eds) Surveys in combinatorics 2003, C.D. WENSLEY (ed.) Topology, geometry and quantum field theory, U.L. TILLMANN (ed) Corings and comodules, T. BRZEZINSKI & R. WISBAUER Topics in dynamics and ergodic theory, S. BEZUGLYI & S. KOLYADA (eds) Groups: topological, combinatorial and arithmetic aspects, T.W. MÜLLER (ed) Foundations of computational mathematics, Minneapolis 2002, F. CUCKER et al. (eds) Transcendental aspects of algebraic cycles, S. MÜLLER-STACH & C. PETERS (eds) ´ P. ROWLINSON & S. SIMIC´ Spectral generalizations of line graphs, D. CVETKOVIC, Structured ring spectra, A. BAKER & B. RICHTER (eds) Linear logic in computer science, T. EHRHARD, P. RUET, J.-Y. GIRARD & P. SCOTT (eds) Advances in elliptic curve cryptography, I.F. BLAKE, G. SEROUSSI & N.P. SMART (eds) Perturbation of the boundary in boundary-value problems of partial differential equations, D. HENRY Double affine Hecke algebras, I. CHEREDNIK ˇ (eds) L-functions and Galois representations, D. BURNS, K. BUZZARD & J. NEKOVÁR Surveys in modern mathematics, V. PRASOLOV & Y. ILYASHENKO (eds) Recent perspectives in random matrix theory and number theory, F. MEZZADRI & N.C. SNAITH (eds) Poisson geometry, deformation quantisation and group representations, S. GUTT et al (eds) Singularities and computer algebra, C. LOSSEN & G. PFISTER (eds) Lectures on the Ricci flow, P. TOPPING Modular representations of finite groups of Lie type, J.E. HUMPHREYS Surveys in combinatorics 2005, B.S. WEBB (ed) Fundamentals of hyperbolic manifolds, R. CANARY, D. EPSTEIN & A. MARDEN (eds) Spaces of Kleinian groups, Y. MINSKY, M. SAKUMA & C. SERIES (eds) Noncommutative localization in algebra and topology, A. RANICKI (ed) Foundations of computational mathematics, Santander 2005, L.M PARDO, A. PINKUS, E. SÜLI & M.J. TODD (eds) Handbook of tilting theory, L. ANGELERI HÜGEL, D. HAPPEL & H. KRAUSE (eds) Synthetic differential geometry (2nd Edition), A. KOCK The Navier–Stokes equations, N. RILEY & P. DRAZIN Lectures on the combinatorics of free probability, A. NICA & R. SPEICHER Integral closure of ideals, rings, and modules, I. SWANSON & C. HUNEKE Methods in Banach space theory, J.M.F. CASTILLO & W.B. JOHNSON (eds) Surveys in geometry and number theory, N. YOUNG (ed) Groups St Andrews 2005 I, C.M. CAMPBELL, M.R. QUICK, E.F. ROBERTSON & G.C. SMITH (eds) Groups St Andrews 2005 II, C.M. CAMPBELL, M.R. QUICK, E.F. ROBERTSON & G.C. SMITH (eds) Ranks of elliptic curves and random matrix theory, J.B. CONREY, D.W. FARMER, F. MEZZADRI & N.C. SNAITH (eds) Elliptic cohomology, H.R. MILLER & D.C. RAVENEL (eds) Algebraic cycles and motives I, J. NAGEL & C. PETERS (eds) Algebraic cycles and motives II, J. NAGEL & C. PETERS (eds) Algebraic and analytic geometry, A. NEEMAN Surveys in combinatorics 2007, A. HILTON & J. TALBOT (eds) Surveys in contemporary mathematics, N. YOUNG & Y. CHOI (eds) Transcendental dynamics and complex analysis, P.J. RIPPON & G.M. STALLARD (eds) Model theory with applications to algebra and analysis I, Z. CHATZIDAKIS, D. MACPHERSON, A. PILLAY & A. WILKIE (eds) Model theory with applications to algebra and analysis II, Z. CHATZIDAKIS, D. MACPHERSON, A. PILLAY & A. WILKIE (eds) Finite von Neumann algebras and masas, A.M. SINCLAIR & R.R. SMITH Number theory and polynomials, J. MCKEE & C. SMYTH (eds) Trends in stochastic analysis, J. BLATH, P. MÖRTERS & M. SCHEUTZOW (eds) Groups and analysis, K. TENT (ed)
355 356 357 358 359 360 361 362 363 364 365 366 367 368 369 370 371 372 373 374 375 376 377 378 379 380 381 382 383 384 385 386 387 388 389 390 391 392 393 394 395 396 397 398 399 400 401 402 403 404 405 406 407 408 409 410 411 412 413 414 415 416 417 418 419 420 421
Non-equilibrium statistical mechanics and turbulence, J. CARDY, G. FALKOVICH & K. GAWEDZKI Elliptic curves and big Galois representations, D. DELBOURGO Algebraic theory of differential equations, M.A.H. MACCALLUM & A.V. MIKHAILOV (eds) Geometric and cohomological methods in group theory, M.R. BRIDSON, P.H. KROPHOLLER & I.J. LEARY (eds) Moduli spaces and vector bundles, L. BRAMBILA-PAZ, S.B. BRADLOW, O. GARCÍA-PRADA & S. RAMANAN (eds) Zariski geometries, B. ZILBER Words: Notes on verbal width in groups, D. SEGAL Differential tensor algebras and their module categories, R. BAUTISTA, L. SALMERÓN & R. ZUAZUA Foundations of computational mathematics, Hong Kong 2008, F. CUCKER, A. PINKUS & M.J. TODD (eds) Partial differential equations and fluid mechanics, J.C. ROBINSON & J.L. RODRIGO (eds) Surveys in combinatorics 2009, S. HUCZYNSKA, J.D. MITCHELL & C.M. RONEY-DOUGAL (eds) Highly oscillatory problems, B. ENGQUIST, A. FOKAS, E. HAIRER & A. ISERLES (eds) Random matrices: High dimensional phenomena, G. BLOWER Geometry of Riemann surfaces, F.P. GARDINER, G. GONZÁLEZ-DIEZ & C. KOUROUNIOTIS (eds) Epidemics and rumours in complex networks, M. DRAIEF & L. MASSOULIÉ Theory of p-adic distributions, S. ALBEVERIO, A.YU. KHRENNIKOV & V.M. SHELKOVICH Conformal fractals, F. PRZYTYCKI & M. URBANSKI Moonshine: The first quarter century and beyond, J. LEPOWSKY, J. MCKAY & M.P. TUITE (eds) Smoothness, regularity and complete intersection, J. MAJADAS & A. G. RODICIO Geometric analysis of hyperbolic differential equations: An introduction, S. ALINHAC Triangulated categories, T. HOLM, P. JØRGENSEN & R. ROUQUIER (eds) Permutation patterns, S. LINTON, N. RUŠKUC & V. VATTER (eds) An introduction to Galois cohomology and its applications, G. BERHUY Probability and mathematical genetics, N. H. BINGHAM & C. M. GOLDIE (eds) Finite and algorithmic model theory, J. ESPARZA, C. MICHAUX & C. STEINHORN (eds) Real and complex singularities, M. MANOEL, M.C. ROMERO FUSTER & C.T.C WALL (eds) Symmetries and integrability of difference equations, D. LEVI, P. OLVER, Z. THOMOVA & P. WINTERNITZ (eds) ˇ Forcing with random variables and proof complexity, J. KRAJÍCEK Motivic integration and its interactions with model theory and non-Archimedean geometry I, R. CLUCKERS, J. NICAISE & J. SEBAG (eds) Motivic integration and its interactions with model theory and non-Archimedean geometry II, R. CLUCKERS, J. NICAISE & J. SEBAG (eds) Entropy of hidden Markov processes and connections to dynamical systems, B. MARCUS, K. PETERSEN & T. WEISSMAN (eds) Independence-friendly logic, A.L. MANN, G. SANDU & M. SEVENSTER Groups St Andrews 2009 in Bath I, C.M. CAMPBELL et al. (eds) Groups St Andrews 2009 in Bath II, C.M. CAMPBELL et al. (eds) Random fields on the sphere, D. MARINUCCI & G. PECCATI Localization in periodic potentials, D.E. PELINOVSKY Fusion systems in algebra and topology, M. ASCHBACHER, R. KESSAR & B. OLIVER Surveys in combinatorics 2011, R. CHAPMAN (ed) Non-abelian fundamental groups and Iwasawa theory, J. COATES et al. (eds) Variational problems in differential geometry, R. BIELAWSKI, K. HOUSTON & M. SPEIGHT (eds) How groups grow, A. MANN Arithmetic dfferential operators over the p-adic integers, C.C. RALPH & S.R. SIMANCA Hyperbolic geometry and applications in quantum chaos and cosmology, J. BOLTE & F. STEINER (eds) Mathematical models in contact mechanics, M. SOFONEA & A. MATEI Circuit double cover of graphs, C.-Q. ZHANG Dense sphere packings: a blueprint for formal proofs, T. HALES A double Hall algebra approach to affine quantum Schur–Weyl theory, B. DENG, J. DU & Q. FU Mathematical aspects of fluid mechanics, J.C. ROBINSON, J.L. RODRIGO & W. SADOWSKI (eds) Foundations of computational mathematics, Budapest 2011, F. CUCKER, T. KRICK, A. PINKUS & A. SZANTO (eds) Operator methods for boundary value problems, S. HASSI, H.S.V. DE SNOO & F.H. SZAFRANIEC (eds) Torsors, étale homotopy and applications to rational points, A.N. SKOROBOGATOV (ed) Appalachian set theory, J. CUMMINGS & E. SCHIMMERLING (eds) The maximal subgroups of the low-dimensional finite classical groups, J.N. BRAY, D.F. HOLT & C.M. RONEY-DOUGAL Complexity science: the Warwick master’s course, R. BALL, V. KOLOKOLTSOV & R.S. MACKAY (eds) Surveys in combinatorics 2013, S. BLACKBURN, S. GERKE & M. WILDON (eds) Representation theory and harmonic analysis of wreath products of finite groups, T. CECCHERINI-SILBERSTEIN, F. SCARABOTTI & F. TOLLI Moduli spaces, L. BRAMBILA-PAZ, O. GARCÍA-PRADA, P. NEWSTEAD & R.P. THOMAS (eds) Automorphisms and equivalence relations in topological dynamics, D.B. ELLIS & R. ELLIS Optimal transportation, Y. OLLIVIER, H. PAJOT & C. VILLANI (eds) Automorphic forms and Galois representations I, F. DIAMOND, P.L. KASSAEI & M. KIM (eds) Automorphic forms and Galois representations II, F. DIAMOND, P.L. KASSAEI & M. KIM (eds) Reversibility in dynamics and group theory, A.G. O’FARRELL & I. SHORT Recent advances in algebraic geometry, C.D. HACON, M. MUSTATA & M. POPA (eds) The Bloch–Kato conjecture for the Riemann zeta function, J. COATES, A. RAGHURAM, A. SAIKIA & R. SUJATHA (eds) The Cauchy problem for non-Lipschitz semi-linear parabolic partial differential equations, J.C. MEYER & D.J. NEEDHAM Arithmetic and geometry, L. DIEULEFAIT et al (eds) O-minimality and Diophantine geometry, A.J. WILKIE & G.O. JONES (eds)
London Mathematical Society Lecture Note Series: 418
The Bloch–Kato Conjecture for the Riemann Zeta Function Edited by
JOHN COATES University of Cambridge A. RAGHURAM Indian Institute of Science Education and Research, Pune, India ANUPAM SAIKIA Indian Institute of Technology Guwahati, India R. SUJATHA University of British Columbia, Vancouver, Canada
University Printing House, Cambridge CB2 8BS, United Kingdom Cambridge University Press is part of the University of Cambridge. It furthers the University’s mission by disseminating knowledge in the pursuit of education, learning and research at the highest international levels of excellence. www.cambridge.org Information on this title: www.cambridge.org/9781107492967 c Cambridge University Press 2015 This publication is in copyright. Subject to statutory exception and to the provisions of relevant collective licensing agreements, no reproduction of any part may take place without the written permission of Cambridge University Press. First published 2015 Printed in the United Kingdom by Clays, St lves plc A catalogue record for this publication is available from the British Library ISBN 978-1-107-49296-7 Hardback Cambridge University Press has no responsibility for the persistence or accuracy of URLs for external or third-party internet websites referred to in this publication, and does not guarantee that any content on such websites is, or will remain, accurate or appropriate.
Contents
List of contributors Preface 1
2 3
4
5
6 7 8 9
Special Values of the Riemann Zeta Function: Some Results and Conjectures A. Raghuram
page vii viii
1
K-theoretic Background R. Sujatha
22
Values of the Riemann Zeta Function at the Odd Positive Integers and Iwasawa Theory John Coates
45
Explicit Reciprocity Law of Bloch–Kato and Exponential Maps Anupam Saikia
65
The Norm Residue Theorem and the Quillen-Lichtenbaum Conjecture Manfred Kolster
97
Regulators and Zeta-functions Stephen Lichtenbaum
121
Soul´ e’s Theorem Stephen Lichtenbaum
130
Soul´ e’s Regulator Map Ralph Greenberg
140
On the Determinantal Approach to the Tamagawa Number Conjecture T. Nguyen Quang Do
154
vi
Contents
10 Motivic Polylogarithm and Related Classes Don Blasius
193
11 The Comparison Theorem for the Soul´ e–Deligne Classes Annette Huber
210
12 Eisenstein Classes, Elliptic Soul´ e Elements and the ` -Adic Elliptic Polylogarithm Guido Kings
239
13 Postscript R. Sujatha
297
Contributors
Don Blasius University of California at Los Angeles, USA. John Coates University of Cambridge, UK. Ralph Greenberg University of Washington, Seattle, USA. Annette Huber Albert-Ludwigs-Universit¨ at Freiburg, Germany. Guido Kings University of Regensburg, Germany. Manfred Kolster McMaster University, Hamilton, Canada. Stephen Lichtenbaum Brown University, Providence, USA. T. Nguyen Quang Do University of Franche-Comt´e, France. A. Raghuram Indian Institute of Science Education and Research, Pune, India. Anupam Saikia Indian Institute of Technology Guwahati, India. R. Sujatha University of British Columbia, Vancouver, Canada.
Preface
These are the proceedings of a week-long workshop entitled ‘The Bloch– Kato conjectures for the Riemann zeta function at the odd positive integers’, which was held at the Indian Institute of Science Education and Research (IISER), Pune, India, in July 2012. This workshop was immediately followed by the 2012 Pan Asian Number Theory (PANT) conference, and there was a considerable overlap between the participants of the two events. The workshop was organized by J. Coates, S. Maity, A. Raghuram, A. Saikia and R. Sujatha, and had a total of 18 lectures given by D. Blasius, J. Coates, R. Greenberg, G. Kings, S. Lichtenbaum, A. Raghuram, A. Saikia and R. Sujatha. These proceedings contain not only expanded versions of all the lectures given at the workshop, but also several invited articles on related material. The Riemann zeta function ζ(s) is the oldest L-function, and it remains one of the most important functions in modern number theory. The values of ζ(s) at even positive integers and odd negative integers have been known since the time of Euler. However, its values at odd positive integers remain mysterious to this day. The Bloch–Kato conjectures, also known as the Tamagawa number conjectures, provide a conjectural framework to understand the special values of all motivic L-functions. The principal aim of the workshop was to prove the Bloch– Kato conjecture in the simplest non-critical example of the values of ζ(s) at odd positive integers s > 1. On behalf of all the organizers, it gives me great pleasure to thank Dr Soumen Maity and Ms Suvarna Gharat, who went far beyond the call
Preface
ix
of duty in handling all the local logistics for both the workshop and the conference. As a co-editor of this volume, I am grateful to Ms Ayesha Fatima and Mr Jeeten Patel, both of whom are IISER alumni, for providing critical help with LaTeX, and for putting together different tex files into one coherent volume. I also thank Professor K.N. Ganesh, Director of IISER Pune, and Dr V.S. Rao, the then Registrar of IISER Pune, for their generous and untiring support. Indeed, the Bloch–Kato workshop and the PANT conference went a long way towards establishing IISER Pune as an important centre for mathematics in India. Finally, on behalf of all the lecturers and participants, I express my gratitude to the International Center for Theoretical Sciences for its financial support for the workshop and the conference. A. Raghuram Coordinator for Mathematics Indian Institute of Science Education and Research Pune, February 6th, 2014.
1 Special Values of the Riemann Zeta Function: Some Results and Conjectures A. Raghuram
Abstract These notes are based on two lectures given at the instructional workshop on the Bloch–Kato conjecture for the values of the Riemann ζfunction at odd positive integers. The workshop was held at IISER, Pune, in July 2012. The aim of these notes is to give a brief introduction to (i) Borel’s results and Lichtenbaum’s conjectures on the special values of the Riemann ζ-function, and (ii) Deligne’s conjecture and the Tamagawa number conjecture of Bloch and Kato on the special values of motivic L-functions as applied to Tate motives.
1.1 Values of the Riemann ζ-function and K-groups of Z 1.1.1 Definition and basic analytic properties of ζ(s) Definition of ζ(s) The Riemann zeta function is defined by the series ζ(s) =
∞ X 1 , ns n=1
σ > 1,
where s = σ + it is a complex variable with σ = <(s) and t = =(s). The series converges absolutely for σ > 1, Rwhich may be seen using the ∞ integral test by comparing the series with 1 1/xσ dx. Indian Institute of Science Education and Research (IISER), Pune, Maharashtra 411021, India. e-mail :
[email protected]
2
A. Raghuram
Euler product, analytic continuation and functional equation Theorem 1.1.1 (Basic Analytic Properties) The Riemann zeta function has the following properties: 1. (Euler Product) For σ > 1 we have −1 Y 1 ζ(s) = 1− s , p p where the product runs over all primes p. 2. (Analytic continuation) The function ζ(s), which is defined for σ > 1, extends to a meromorphic function to all of C with only one pole which is located at s = 1 and is a simple pole with residue 1. Around s = 1, we have ∞ X 1 ζ(s) = +γ + γk (s − 1)k s−1 k=1
where γ is Euler’s constant. 3. (Functional equation) s 1−s π −s/2 Γ ζ(s) = π (1−s)/2 Γ ζ(1 − s), 2 2 where Γ(s) is the usual Γ-function. See, for example, Ivic [Iv85, Chapter 1]. s −s/2 Let ζ∞ (s) = π Γ 2 , and define the completed zeta function by s Λ(s) := ζ∞ (s)ζ(s) = π −s/2 Γ ζ(s). (1.1) 2 Then Λ(s) has a meromorphic continuation to all of C with simple poles at s = 0, 1 and is holomorphic elsewhere. The functional equation looks like Λ(s) = Λ(1 − s). In analytic number theory, one also completes ζ(s) as Λ∗ (s) = s(1 − s)Λ(s). We still have the same functional equation Λ∗ (s) = Λ∗ (1 − s), but Λ∗ (s) has the virtue of being an entire function. However, from the motivic or automorphic perspective, the completed zeta function is always taken to be Λ(s) and not Λ∗ (s). An easy consequence of the functional equation is: 1 ζ(0) = − . 2
(1.2)
(For the interested reader, here is a quote from Ramanujan’s Notebooks: The constant of a series has some mysterious connection with the given infinite series and it is like the centre of gravity of a body. Mysterious
ζ-values
3
because we can substitute it for the divergent infinite series. Now the constant of the series 1 + 1 + 1 + &c is − 12 . See p.79 of ‘Notebooks of Srinivasa Ramanujan’, Volume 1, Published by TIFR, Mumbai 2012.)
1.1.2 Euler’s Theorem Critical points Definition 1.1.2 An integer n is said to be critical for ζ(s) if both ζ∞ (s) and ζ∞ (1 − s) are regular (i.e., no poles) at s = n. The set of all critical integers is called the critical set. Observe that, by definition, the critical set is symmetric, i.e., invariant under s 7→ 1 − s. Proposition 1.1.3 The critical set for ζ(s) consists of all even positive integers and all odd negative integers, i.e., critical set for ζ(s) = {. . . , 1 − 2m, . . . , −5, −3, −1} ∪ {2, 4, 6, . . . , 2m, . . . } . Proof
Let n be critical for ζ(s). This means two conditions on n:
1. ζ∞ (s) = π −s/2 Γ(s/2) does not have a pole at s = n; exponentials are entire and non-vanishing and so this means Γ(s/2) has no pole at n, i.e., n/2 ∈ / {. . . , −3, −2, −1, 0}, which means that n is not a non-positive even integer; and 2. ζ∞ (1 − s) = π −(1−s)/2 Γ((1 − s)/2) does not have a pole at s = n; this translates to Γ((1 − s)/2) having no pole at n, i.e., (1 − n)/2 ∈ / {. . . , −3, −2, −1, 0}, or n ∈ / {1, 3, 5, . . . }, which means that n is not an odd positive integer.
The critical values of ζ(s) The Bernoulli numbers are defined by the formal power series expansion of z/(ez − 1): ∞ X z zk = B . (1.3) k ez − 1 k! k=0
Some easy values are: B0 = 1, B1 = −1/2, B2 = 1/6, B3 = 0, B4 = −1/30, B5 = 0, . . . . Indeed, we have B2k+1 = 0 for k ≥ 1.
4
A. Raghuram
Theorem 1.1.4
The critical values for ζ(s) are given by:
1. The critical values to the right of the centre of symmetry: ζ(2m) =
(−1)m+1 (2π)2m B2m . 2(2m)!
2. The critical values to the left of the centre of symmetry: B2m . 2m See Neukirch [Ne99, Chapter VII, Section 1] for a detailed proof. ζ(1 − 2m) = −
Remark 1.1.4.1 Let us note the special case ζ(−1) = −1/12 was ‘proved’ by Euler (and later rediscovered by Ramanujan) via the following intriguing calculation: S = 1 + 2 + 3 + 4 + 5 + 6 + ··· 4S = 4 + 8 + 12 + · · · −3S = 1 − 2 + 3 − 4 + 5 − 6 · · · =
1 = 1/4 (1 + 1)2
=⇒ S = −1/12.
The non-critical values of ζ(s) The non-critical values of ζ(s) are its values at non-critical integers, i.e., the values {ζ(2m + 1) : m ≥ 1} and {ζ(−2m) : m ≥ 1}. The values at the odd positive integers are mysterious and the purpose of this workshop is to understand these values via the Bloch–Kato conjectures. However, the values at the negative even integers are trivial: Lemma 1.1.5 (Trivial zeros) zero at s = −2m. Proof
For any integer m ≥ 1, ζ(s) has a simple
Put s = −2m into the functional equation to get: 1 + 2m π m Γ(−m) ζ(−2m) = π (1+2m)/2 Γ ζ(1 + 2m). 2
The right hand side is finite and non-zero, therefore so is the left hand side; but Γ(−m) is a simple pole, hence ζ(−2m) is a simple zero. What is mysterious about ζ(s) at s = −2m is not so much the value, but rather the leading term: ζ ∗ (−2m) :=
lim ζ(s)(s + 2m).
s→−2m
The mystery about ζ(2m+1) is equivalent, via the functional equation, to the mystery about ζ ∗ (−2m). We mention the following transcendental statements only for the sake of completeness:
ζ-values
5
1. ζ(3) is irrational. (See Ap´ery [Ap79].) 2. The Q-span of {ζ(2m+1) : m ≥ 1} is an infinite-dimensional subspace of R, i.e., infinitely many of the zeta values at odd positive integers are Q-linearly independent. (See Ball and Rivoal [BR01].)
1.1.3 Borel’s Theorem Tamagawa number of SLn /Q and ζ-values Let n ≥ 2. Fix an isomorphism Top exterior : (sln )/Z → Z. This induces the Tamagawa measure on SLn (A) as follows: The meaQ sure dg on SLn (A) is the product of local measures dg = v dgv and locally everywhere dgv is the Haar measure determined by the above isomorphism. By definition, the Tamagawa number of SLn /Q is: τ (SLn /Q) := vol (SLn (Q)\SLn (A)) . Theorem 1.1.6 The Tamagawa number of SLn /Q is 1, i.e., τ (SLn /Q) = 1. See, for example, Weil [We58]. Corollary 1.1.7 n Y
ζ(m) = vol (SLn (Z)\SLn (R)) .
m=2
Proof
The strong approximation theorem gives:
vol (SLn (Q)\SLn (A)) = vol (SLn (Z)\SLn (R))
Y
vol(SLn (Zp ));
p
the left hand side is 1 by the above theorem, and for the right hand side we have n Y vol(SLn (Zp )) = (1 − p−m ), m=2
where all the volumes are with respect to the Tamagawa measures. It is rather piquant to note that ζ(3)π 2 /6 = vol (SL3 (Z)\SL3 (R)) .
6
A. Raghuram
Statement of Borel’s results In this section we give a very brief sketch of some results of Borel [Bo77]. The serious reader should consult Borel for all details. Consider the following diagram of cohomology groups: µ•
H • (SU(n); C) c
α•
/ H • (SLn (R)/Γn ; C) :
β•
H • (sln (C); C) where Γn is an arithmetic torsion-free subgroup of SLn (Z). The morphisms α• and β • are defined in terms of invariant forms and α• is an isomorphism; now define µ• := β • ◦ α• −1 . All the cohomology groups in sight are exterior algebras and we can talk of indecomposable elements. (Let A be an algebra over a field which is graded by subspaces {Ap }p∈N . The space of indecomposable elements of A of degree p, denoted I p (A), is defined to be the quotient of Ap by the subspace of decomposable elements, i.e., subspace generated by products of elements of degree less than p.) We can also work with rational cohomology, and let us record the following results of Borel: For an even positive integer m, the spaces I 2m+1 (sln (Q); Q) and I 2m+1 (SU(n); Q) are 1-dimensional Q-subspaces of the ambient complex spaces. (For brevity, we have let I 2m+1 (sln (Q); Q) to stand for I 2m+1 (H • (sln (Q); Q)), etc.) Borel studied the effect of the maps α• and β • on these one-dimensional lines, and proved α• (I 2m+1 (sln (Q); Q)) = (πi)m+1 I 2m+1 (SU(n); Q).
(1.4)
See [Bo77, Proposition 5.4]. Similarly, one has β • (I 2m+1 (sln (Q); Q)) = ζ(m+1) I 2m+1 (SLn (R)/Γn ; Q), (n > 8m+5). (1.5) This involves a calculation of integrating a top-degree rational form on a ‘modular symbol’ H/(Γ ∩ H) ,→ G/Γ where H is a suitable SL1 (D) inside G = SLn ; this is a Tamagawa number calculation, the simplest case of which is briefly described in 1.1.3. For more details, see Borel’s [Bo77, Th´eor`eme 5.5] and its proof. The heart of Borel’s paper is to construct and analyze a certain canonical morphism in a relative context (i.e., mod-maximal-compact) for real
ζ-values
7
cohomology: jΓ• : H • (SU(n)/SO(n); R) −→ H • (SLn (Z)\SLn (R)/SO(n); R). (1.6) Observe that the right hand side is also group cohomology: H • (SLn (Z)\SLn (R)/SO(n); R) ' H • (SLn (Z); R). The main result of Borel, stemming from (1.4), (1.5) and (1.6), is the following: Theorem 1.1.8 8m + 5. Then
Let m = 2r be an even positive integer and let n >
jΓ• (I 4r+1 (SU(n)/SO(n); Q)) =
ζ(2r + 1) 4r+1 I (SLn (Z); Q). π 2r+1
See [Bo77, Th´eor`eme 6.2]. This result has an interpretation in terms of K-groups, which we discuss in the next subsection after introducing K-groups.
1.1.4 K-groups of Z For us, Km is a functor from the category of commutative rings to the category of abelian groups; Sujatha’s lectures in this workshop go more deeply into algebraic K-theory that is necessary to study the Riemann ζ-function. One calls K0 (R) the projective module group and it is defined to be the quotient of the free abelian group on [P ] where P runs over isomorphism classes of a finitely generated projective module by the normal subgroup generated by the relations [P ⊕Q]−[P ]−[Q]. Since Z is a PID, and every finitely generated projective module is free, we get K0 (Z) = Z. The group K1 (R) is called the Whitehead group and it is defined to be the quotient GL(R)/E(R) where GL(R) := limn GLn (R), the limit taken −→ over the maps GLn (R) → GLn+1 (R) given by g 7→ diag(g, 1); and E(R) is the subgroup generated by all elementary matrices. Since we have taken R to be commutative, the determinant homomorphism is defined and one has K1 (R) ∼ = R× ⊕ (SL(R)/E(R)). The group SL(R)/E(R) is often denoted SK1 (R) and is called the reduced Whitehead group. If R is a Euclidean domain, one knows that SK1 (R) = {1}. Hence K1 (Z) = Z× ∼ = Z/2. (See, for example, Milnor [Mi71].) For a ring R, one defines Km (R) := πm (BGL(R)+ ),
(1.7)
8
A. Raghuram
i.e., the m-th homotopy group of Quillen’s plus construction applied to the classifying space of the limit GL(R) of general linear groups. Computing K-groups is a highly non-trivial problem, and even for K-groups of Z not everything is known. In the next subsection we give a summary of some more precise results on Km (Z). What is known about Km (Z)? The following brief summary on Km (Z) is taken from Weibel [We05]. We begin with two general finiteness results: 1. Km (Z) is a finitely generated abelian group. (Quillen [Qu73].) 2. Rank of Km (Z) is 1 if m ≥ 5 is 1 mod 4; in all other cases Km (Z) is a finite group, i.e., has rank 0. (Borel [Bo74].)
K0 (Z) K1 (Z) K2 (Z) K3 (Z) K4 (Z) K5 (Z) K6 (Z) K7 (Z)
= = = = = = = =
Z Z/2 Z/2 Z/48 0 Z 0 Z/240
K8a (Z) = 0? K8a+1 (Z) = Z ⊕ Z/2 K8a+2 (Z) = Z/2c2a+1 K8a+3 (Z) = Z/2w4a+2 K8a+4 (Z) = 0? K8a+5 (Z) = Z K8a+6 (Z) = Z/c2a+2 K8a+7 (Z) = Z/w4a+4
(1.8)
The question marks mean that it is expected K4a (Z) = 0. This is proven for a = 1 and is open as yet for a ≥ 2. The numbers cm and wm are defined as follows: cm = numerator of (−1)m+1 B2m /4m.
(1.9)
(It is understood that if we talk of the numerator a of a rational number a/b then one has taken the rational to be in its lowest form, i.e., a and b are relatively prime.) Let W be the group of all roots of unity in Q. Then W is naturally a GQ = Gal(Q/Q)-module, since if w ∈ W and g ∈ GQ then g(w) ∈ W. For any integer m ≥ 1 we let W(m) stand for the GQ module where g ∈ GQ acts on w ∈ W(m) = W via g ·m w := g m (w). One says W(m) is the Galois module W with a Tate twist by m. Now define wm := |{w ∈ W : g m (w) = w, ∀g ∈ GQ }|,
(1.10)
i.e., it is the cardinality of the set of those roots of unity which are fixed by GQ under the m-twisted action.
ζ-values
9
Borel regulators and non-critical values Let us go back to Theorem 1.1.8: recall that m = 2r is an even positive integer and n m, then jΓ• (I 2m+1 (SU(n)/SO(n); Q)) =
ζ(m + 1) 2m+1 I (SLn (Z); Q). π m+1
Now pass to the limit over n. Define Xu := limn SU(n)/SO(n) and −→ SL(Z) := limn SLn (Z). Then it is known that we have a duality: −→ I 2m+1 (Xu ; Q) × (π2m+1 (Xu ) ⊗Z Q) −→ Q, and similarly, I 2m+1 (SL(Z); Q) × (K2m+1 (Z) ⊗Z Q) −→ Q. (Recall that m = 2r is even, and so K2m+1 (Z) ⊗Z Q is a one-dimensional ∗ Q-vector space.) Fix a basis x∗m for π2m+1 (Xu ), and ym for K2m+1 (Z). Let xm and ym be the dual basis. Definition 1.1.9 (Borel Regulators) jΓ• (xm ) = Rm (Q) ym . From Theorem 1.1.8 and Definition 1.1.9 we get the following beautiful result of Borel on the non-critical values of Riemann zeta function: Theorem 1.1.10 (Borel)
Let r ≥ 1. Then
ζ(2r + 1) ∼ R2r (Q), π 2r+1 where ∼ means up to a non-zero rational number.
1.1.5 Lichtenbaum’s conjecture Critical values and K-groups Reference: Lichtenbaum [Li73, Conjecture 2.4]. Theorem 1.1.11 (Critical values on the left) Up to 2-torsion for any odd integer m ≥ 1 |K2m (Z)| |ζ(−m)| = . |K2m+1 (Z)| Proof
Follows from Theorem 1.1.4 and (1.8).
10
A. Raghuram
The caveat ‘up to 2-torsion’ is necessary as can already be seen from the case m = 1: B2 1 ζ(−1) = − = − , 2 12 whereas |K2 (Z)| = 2 and |K3 (Z)| = 48 giving |K2 (Z)| 1 = . |K3 (Z)| 24 K-theoretic Lichtenbaum’s conjecture In [Li73, Question 4.2] Lichtenbaum formulated a conjecture for ζ-values at any negative integer −m in terms of certain higher regulators R0m (Q) which are essentially the same as Borel’s regulators Rm (Q). For Licht0 enbaum’s definition of Rm (Q) see [Li73, p.498–499]. Conjecture 1.1.12 (Any special value on the left) m ≥ 1, possibly up to 2-torsion, we have ζ ∗ (−m) = ±
For any integer
|K2m (Z)| 0 · Rm (Q). |K2m+1 (Z)tors |
A slightly modified version of Conjecture 1.1.12 was proved for any abelian number field by Kolster, Nguyen Quang Do and Fleckinger [KNF96, Theorem 6.4]; some errors on Euler factors in [KNF96] have been corrected in [BN02]. For a result character by character, see [HK03]. The reader is also referred to the survey article by Flach [Fl04] for a historic introduction. Cohomological Lichtenbaum’s conjecture The K-theoretic Lichtenbaum’s conjecture can be restated in the language of Galois cohomology. The connection is provided by the Quillen– Lichtenbaum conjecture which relates K-groups to Galois cohomology. (The reader should look at Lichtenbaum [Li73, Conjecture 2.5] and Huber–Kings [HK03, p.410].) Indeed, the formulas in (1.8) cited from [We05] use this connection between K-groups and Galois cohomology. Give Spec(Q) the ´etale topology. Then the category of discrete GQ modules is equivalent to the category of sheaves of abelian groups over Spec(Q), and Galois cohomology is the same as sheaf cohomology which in this case is called ´etale cohomology. For any m ≥ 1, the GQ -module W(m) gives a sheaf on Spec(Q). Denote this sheaf also by W(m). Fix a prime `. Let X` := Spec(Z[1/`]), and let j : Spec(Q) ,→ X`
ζ-values
11
be the canonical inclusion. Now consider the cohomology of X` with coefficients in the direct image j∗ W(m) sheaf on X` . Conjecture 1.1.13 (Critical values on the left) m ≥ 1, we have `-part of |ζ(−m)| =
For any odd integer
|H 1 (X` , j∗ W(m + 1)| . |H 0 (X` , j∗ W(m + 1)|
For m = 1 this was conjectured by Birch and Tate. See [Li73, Conjecture 1.5]. More generally, for any special value ζ ∗ (−m) with m ≥ 1, the cohomological Lichtenbaum’s ‘conjecture’ (now a theorem; see below) states: Conjecture 1.1.14 (Any special value on the left) Let m ≥ 1. Let 00 Rm (Q) be the m-th Beilinson regulator of Q. Then, up to powers of 2, and up to sign, we have 00 ζ(−m)∗ = Rm (Q)
Y |H 2 (X` , j∗ Z` (m + 1)| . |H 1 (X` , j∗ Z` (m + 1)tors | `
The reader is referred to the excellent monograph by Burgos Gil [Bu02] 00 for a precise relation between the Beilinson regulator Rm (Q) and the Borel regulator Rm (Q); the main theorem therein says that a renormal00 ized version of Rm (Q) is twice Rm (Q). For m > 1, Conjecture 1.1.14 above is equivalent to the Bloch–Kato conjecture for the Tate motive Z(1 − m) (see next section), which is in turn equivalent, via the calculation of the Tamagawa numbers performed in the proof of [BK90, Theorem 6.1], to the Bloch–Kato conjecture for Z(m) which is the focus of the workshop.
1.2 The Bloch–Kato conjecture for the Riemann ζ-function A motive is a piece in the cohomology of a smooth projective variety, although we will deal exclusively at the level of realizations (Betti, de Rham and `-adic) of the motive. A motivic L-function is the Artin Lfunction of the Galois representation on the `-adic realization of the motive. An integer is critical for a motivic L-function if the Γ-factors at infinity on both sides of the functional equation are regular at that integer. Deligne’s conjecture says that a motivic critical L-value is rational
12
A. Raghuram
up to a period/regulator. Beilinson’s conjecture looks roughly the same as Deligne except for any L-value, critical or not. Bloch and Kato give a recipe for that rational number in terms of Tamagawa numbers.
1.2.1 The Riemann zeta function as a motivic L-function Axiomatic definition of a motive and Deligne’s conjecture References: Deligne [De79] and Blasius [Bl87]. (Under the assumption that the motive has coefficients in Q which will be the case for the motives for the Riemann zeta function.) A motive over Q with coefficients also in Q is a five tuple of data M = (MB , MdR , Mf , I∞ , If ) where MB and MdR are finite-dimensional Q-vector spaces both of dimension d, and Mf is an Af -module of rank d. The maps I∞ and If are comparison isomorphisms: I∞ : MB ⊗Q C −→ MdR ⊗Q C, If : MB ⊗Q Af −→ Mf . Hodge Decomposition and Complex Conjugation: Under the assumption that the motive M is pure and has a purity weight w, one has a Hodge decomposition M MB ⊗ C = M p,q , p+q=w
where the action of complex conjugation ρ on the second factor in MB ⊗C interchanges M p,q with M q,p . Recall that a motive is supposed to be a piece in the cohomology H • (X) of an algebraic variety X, and so MB is • a piece in HBetti (X(C), Z). This gives an action of complex conjugation on MB , denoted F∞ , arising via functoriality from the action of complex conjugation on the ‘real’ variety X(C). Let MB± := Ker(F∞ ∓ 1MB ) be the ±1-eigenspace for the action of F∞ . Let d± := dimQ (MB± ). Assume that F∞ acts on M w/2,w/2 via the scalar (= ±1) whenever M w/2,w/2 6= 0. (When the middle Hodge piece M w/2,w/2 is non-trivial, this assumption is necessary for the existence of critical points for the L-function.)
ζ-values
13
Hodge filtration: For all p, there exists a Q-subspace F p MdR ⊂ MdR such that M p0 ,q −1 I∞ (F p MdR ⊗ C) = MB . p0 ≥p
Using the Hodge filtration, we identify the analogues of MB± for MdR as follows: 1. If w ∈ 2Z, = 1 then let F + MdR := F w/2 MdR and F − MdR := F 1+w/2 MdR . 2. If w ∈ 2Z, = −1 then let F + MdR := F 1+w/2 MdR and F − MdR := F w/2 MdR . 3. If w is odd then let F + MdR = F − MdR := F (w+1)/2,(w+1)/2 MdR . Now define ± MdR := MdR /F ∓ MdR .
The comparison isomorphism I∞ induces isomorphisms I ± as: MB O ⊗ C ? MB± ⊗ C
I∞
I±
/ MdR ⊗ C O ? / M± ⊗ C dR
Deligne’s periods attached to the motive M are defined as: c± (M ) := det(I ± ),
δ(M ) := det(I)
(1.11)
where the determinants are computed relative to rational bases for MB , ± MdR , MB± and MdR . The finite part of the motivic L-function is an Euler product: Lf (s, M ) Q := p Lp (s, M ), where we fix a prime `, and the Euler factor at p 6= ` is: Lp (s, M ) := det(I − ϕp |M Ip p−s )−1 ; here M` = M ⊗ Q` which con` jecturally carries a strictly compatible system of `-adic representations, Ip is the inertia subgroup of GQ at p, ϕp is the (arithmetic) Frobenius at p which is a coset of Ip that has a well-defined action on the inertia I invariants M` p , and det(I − ϕp |M Ip p−s ) is, a priori, a polynomial with ` Q` -coefficients but, conjecturally, it is `-independent. For more details the reader is referred to Deligne [De79, §1.1, 1.2]. The product of Γ-factors at infinity, denoted L∞ (s, M ), is defined by a recipe of Serre [Se69, 3.2], which in our simplified situation goes as follows: define the Hodge numbers hp,q := dim(M p,q ). And when M w/2,w/2 6= 0, recall our assumption that the complex conjugation acts
14
A. Raghuram w/2,w/2
on M w/2,w/2 as . If = ±(−1)w/2 then put M± = M w/2,w/2 and w/2,w/2 w/2,w/2 ± M∓ = 0. Then we put hw/2 := dim(M± ). Now define: Y h+ h− L∞ (s, M ) := ΓR (s−w/2) w/2 ΓR (s−w/2+1) w/2 ΓC (s−p)hp,w−p , p<w/2
(1.12) −s/2
−s
where ΓR (s) = π Γ(s/2) and ΓC (s) = 2(2π) Γ(s). The completed motivic L-function is defined as L(s, M ) := L∞ (s, M ) Lf (s, M ). Even though it is defined a priori only in a half-plane, one expects that it has a meromorphic continuation to all of C, and that it satisfies a functional equation of the form L(s, M ) = ε(s, M )L(1 − s, M v ), 1
where ε(s, M ) is the epsilon-factor (usually written as W (M )N (M ) 2 −s ; here W (M ), called the root number of M , is a complex number of absolute value 1; and N (M ) may be called the conductor of M ), and M v is the dual motive. Conjecture 1.2.1 (Deligne) Suppose s = 0 is critical for L(s, M ) then L(0, M ) ∼ c+ (M ), where ∼ means up to an element of Q. More generally, if m ∈ Z is a critical integer for L(s, M ) then ±
Lf (m, M ) ∼ (2πi)md c± (M ),
± = (−1)m .
Motives for ζ(s) The following description is taken from certain informal lecture notes of G¨ unter Harder. For n ≥ 1 define the motive Q(−n) := H 2n (Pn ).
(1.13)
We will work through the previous subsection for this motive: . Betti realization: Q(−n)B = HB2n (Pn (C), Q) = Q · 1B , (−1)n 1B .
F∞ (1B ) =
. Purity: Q(−n) is pure of weight w = 2n. . Hodge numbers: hn,n = 1 and all other hp,q = 0. − n . Middle Hodge numbers: h+ n = 1 and hn = 0, since = (−1) . 2n . de Rham realization: Q(−n)dR = HdR (Pn /Q) = Q · 1dR .
ζ-values
15
. Comparison: I∞ (1B ) = (2πi)−n 1dR . . Hodge filtration: F n Q(−n)dR = Q · 1dR , F n+1 Q(−n)dR = 0. . The ±-spaces: . When n is even: − . Q(−n)+ B = Q · 1B and Q(−n)B = 0. + . Q(−n)dR = Q · 1dR and Q(−n)− dR = 0.
. When n is odd: − . Q(−n)+ B = 0 and Q(−n)B = Q · 1B . − . Q(−n)+ dR = 0 and Q(−n)dR = Q · 1dR .
. The periods: . When n is even: c+ (Q(−n)) = δ(Q(−n)) = (2πi)−n , c− (Q(−n)) = 1. . When n is odd: c− (Q(−n)) = δ(Q(−n)) = (2πi)−n , c+ (Q(−n)) = 1. . `-adic realization: H 2n (Pn (Q), Q` ) = Q` (−n). . Galois action: the arithmetic Frobenius ϕp at p acts on Q` (−n) as: ϕp · x = pn x. Q . Finite part of the L-function: Lf (s, Q(−n)) = p (1 − pn p−s )−1 = ζ(s − n). . Gamma factors at infinity: L∞ (s, Q(−n)) = π −(s−n)/2 Γ s−n . 2 . Q(−n) is critical: if and only if n is odd. (Recall that n ≥ 1.) . Deligne: If n is odd then L(0, Q(−n)) ∼ c+ (Q(−n)) translates to ζ(−n) ∼ 1, i.e., ζ(odd negative integer) ∈ Q. . Euler: Use the functional equation to get ζ(even positive integer 2m) ∈ π 2m Q. The Tate motive Q(1) Reference: Deligne [De79, Section 3.1]. One may say that Q(1) is the motive that is dual (in the category of Grothendieck motives) to Q(−1) = H 2 (P1 ). Or, the simplest way is to define it directly as Q(1) := H1 (Gm ). Here are some details about this motive:
16
A. Raghuram
. Betti realization: Q(1)B = H1 (C∗ , Q) = Q·1B , F∞ (1B ) = −1B , d+ = 0, d− = 1. . Purity: Q(1) is pure of weight w = −2. . Hodge numbers: h−1,−1 = 1 and all other hp,q = 0. − . Middle Hodge numbers: h+ −1 = 1 and h−1 = 0, since = −1. 1 . de Rham realization: Q(1)dR = Q · 1dR which is dual to HdR (Gm ) ' ∗ ∗ ∗ Q · 1dR where 1dR is the differential form dz/z on C .
. Comparison: I∞ (1B ) = (2πi)1dR . − . The ±-spaces: Q(1)+ B = 0 and Q(1)B = Q · 1B .
. The periods: c− (Q(1)) = δ(Q(1)) = (2πi), c+ (Q(1)) = 1. . `-adic realization: Q(1)` = Q` (1). . Galois action: the arithmetic Frobenius ϕp at p acts on Q` (1) as: ϕp · x = p−1 x. Q . Finite part of the L-function: Lf (s, Q(1)) = p (1 − p−1 p−s )−1 = ζ(s + 1). . Deligne: For example, s = 1 is critical for Lf (s, Q(1)). Conjecture 1.2.1 would give: −
ζ(2) = Lf (1, Q(1)) ∼ (2πi)d c− (Q(1)) = (2πi)2 ∼ π 2 , which is Euler’s classic ζ(2) = π 2 /6 up to rational multiplies.
The Tate motives Q(n) For n = 0, define Q(0) := H • (Point). For n ≥ 1, the motive Q(n) may be defined in one of these two ways: 1. Q(n) is the motive that is dual to Q(−n). 2. Q(n) = ⊗n Q(1), i.e., it is the n-fold tensor product of the Tate motive Q(1).
1.2.2 Tamagawa number conjecture of Bloch and Kato In this section, I only hope to convey a very general feeling for the Bloch–Kato conjecture. This is partly because defining all notation, and writing everything down, would be tantamount to repeating everything in their paper. I have followed the notation of Bloch and Kato [BK90] as much as possible.
ζ-values
17
Given a motive, for example Q(n), a crucial ingredient in the Bloch– Kato conjecture is a Galois stable lattice M. (It is notationally unfortunate that Bloch and Kato used the letter M for a lattice, unlike in Deligne [De79] where M is always a motive; Bloch–Kato do not really need to talk about the motive per se, but they only need their data to come from a motive.) This lattice M will be used to define certain groups A(Qp ) and A(Q) in terms of Galois cohomology; these groups are to behave like the Qp -points and the Q-points of the intermediate Jacobian of a cohomology group. The A in the A(Q) or A(Qp ) is merely a symbolic notation. For a suitable Tamagawa measure, the volume of A(Qp ) is the local L-value The Tamagawa num Q at 0 almost everywhere. ber Tam(M) := Vol ( p A(Qp ))/A(Q) is conjectured to be a rational number which is interpreted in terms of a Tate–Shaferevic group for M . This is the essence of the Bloch–Kato conjecture. Motivic pairs A motivic pair (see [BK90, Definition 5.5]) is a pair (V, D) of finitedimensional Q-vector spaces with extra structure: 1. (Galois representation) V ⊗Af has an Af -linear continuous GQ -action such that V ⊂ V ⊗ Af is Galois stable. 2. (Hodge filtration) D has a decreasing filtration (Di )i∈Z of Q-subspaces such that D i = D for i 0 and Di = 0 for i 0. 3. (Comparison isomorphisms) For finite p, there is an isomorphism of Qp -vector spaces ∼
θp : Dp −→ DR(Vp ) := H 0 (Qp , BdR ⊗ Vp ), where BdR is the field constructed by Fontaine; see [BK90, Section 1]. Similarly, one has a comparison map ∼
θ∞ : D∞ −→ (V∞ ⊗R C)+ . For the right hand side, σ ∈ Aut(C/R) acts as σ ⊗ σ on V∞ ⊗R C and the + means we have taken invariants under Aut(C/R). A motivic pair is assumed to satisfy the following axioms: 1. For almost all p, V` is unramified at p if ` 6= p and Vp is crystalline. 2. There exist Z-lattices M ,→ V and L ,→ D with several properties; an important one being that M ⊗ Zp is Galois stable in Vp and corresponds to L ⊗ Zp across the isomorphism θp .
18
A. Raghuram
3. The local Artin factors are `-independent. 4. There is a Galois stable lattice T in V ⊗ Af such that the invariants under inertia subgroup at p in T ⊗ Q` /Z` are divisible for all `. One should mention that the isomorphism θ∞ , which is essentially the same as I∞ , comes from classical de Rham theorem that de Rham cohomology is isomorphic to singular cohomology. Its p-adic counterpart, namely the existence of θp for a motive of the form H • (X) was conjectured by Fontaine and proved by Faltings. L-functions and weights Given a motivic pair (V, D) as above one defines the partial motivic L-function as an Euler product Y LS (s, V ) := Lp (s, V ) p∈S /
where Lp (s, V ) := det(I − ϕp |V Ip p−s )−1 as in 1.2.1, while keeping the `
axiom 3 above in mind. Suppose that the polynomial det(I − ϕp |V Ip X) ` Qdim(V ) looks like i=1 (1 − αi X). We say that (V, D) has weights ≤ w if i + |αi | ≤ pw/2 for all p (including p ∈ S), and D∞ ∩ V∞ = 0. The Euler product converges for <(s) ≥ w/2 + 1. Hence, to talk about LS (0, V ), we need to assume w < −2. The Tamagawa number conjecture Define certain abelian groups: A(Qp ) :=
ˆ Hf1 (Qp , M ⊗ Z),
A(R) := (D∞ ⊗R C)/(D∞ ⊗R C + M )+ . Here Hf1 (Qp , N ) := Ker H 1 (Qp , N ) → H 1 (Qp , Bcrys ⊗ N ) is called the finite part of the Galois cohomology group for the Galois module N = ˆ and Bcrys is a ring defined and studied by Fontaine. M ⊗Z ˆ as a finitely Now define the ‘global’ group A(Q) ⊂ Hf1 (Q, M ⊗ Z) ˆ = H 1 (Q, M ⊗ Z) ˆ and A(Q)⊗ generated abelian group such that A(Q)⊗ Z f 0 1 Q is a suitable Q-structure Φ on H (Q, V ⊗ Af ). Definition 1.2.2 (Tamagawa number of M ) Q p A(Qp ) Tam(M) := Vol , A(Q)
ζ-values
19
where the volume is with respect to the Tamagawa measure as in [BK90, Definition 5.9].
Definition 1.2.3 (Tate–Shafarevich group of M ) 1 M H 1 (Qp , M ⊗ Q/Z) H (Q, M ⊗ Q/Z) . X(M ) := Ker −→ A(Q) ⊗ Q/Z A(Qp ) ⊗ Q/Z p≤∞
We can now state the Tamagawa number conjecture of Bloch–Kato (see [BK90, Conjecture 5.15]). Conjecture 1.2.4 Assume that the motivic pair (V, D) indeed comes from a motive, and that we are given a suitable Q-structure as in the ˆ ⊂ V ⊗ Af definition of A(Q). Let M be a Z-lattice in V such that M ⊗ Z is Galois stable. Then X(M ) is finite and the Tamagawa number is given by |H 0 (Q, M ∗ ⊗ Q/Z(1))| , |X(M )|
Tam(M ) =
where M ∗ = Hom(M, Z) is the dual lattice. The local Tamagawa number Vol(A(Qp )) is L(0, Vp )−1 for almost all primes p; hence we may also write LS (0, V ) =
|X(M )| · Vol(A(R)/A(Q)) ⊗ Q/Z(1))|
|H 0 (Q, M ∗ Y
Vol(A(Qp )).
p∈S−{∞}
1.2.3 Results on the Tamagawa number conjecture for the motive Q(n) The purpose of these proceedings is to give a detailed proof of the Tamagawa number conjecture for the motive Q(n).
If n ≥ 2 is an even integer then the Tamagawa number conjecture is true up to powers of 2 for Q(n). This was proved by Bloch and Kato; see [BK90, Theorem 6.1, (i)].
20
A. Raghuram
If n ≥ 2 is an odd integer then the Tamagawa number conjecture up to powers of 2 is true for Q(n) provided another conjecture holds. See Bloch–Kato [BK90, Theorem 6.1, (ii)]. This other conjecture (see [BK90, Conjecture 6.2]) concerns the equality of certain Deligne–Soul´e cyclotomic elements in a Galois cohomology group. The lectures by Blasius and Kings in this workshop will be devoted to proving [BK90, Conjecture 6.2].
References [Ap79] Ap´ery, R. 1979. Irrationalit´e de ζ(2) et ζ(3). Ast´erisque, 61, 11–13. [BR01] Ball, K., and Rivoal, T. 2001. Irrationalit´e d’une infinit´e de valeurs de la fonction zeta aux entiers impairs. (French) [Irrationality of infinitely many values of the zeta function at odd integers]. Invent. Math., 146, no. 1, 193–207. [BN02] Benois, D., and Nguyen Quang Do, T. 2002. Les nombres de Tamagawa locaux et la conjecture de Bloch et Kato pour les motifs Q(m) sur un corps ab´elien. (French) [Local Tamagawa numbers and the Bloch– Kato conjecture for the motives Q(m) over an abelian field]. Ann. Sci. ´ Ecole Norm. Sup., 35, no. 5, 641–672. [Bl87] Blasius, D. 1987. Appendix to Orloff Critical values of certain tensor product L-functions. Invent. Math., (4) 90, no. 1, 181–188. [Bo74] Borel, A. 1974. Stable real cohomology of arithmetic groups. Ann. Sci. ´ Ecole Norm. Sup., (4) 7, 235–272. [Bo77] Borel, A. 1977. Cohomologie de SLn et valeurs de fonctions zeta aux points entiers (French). Ann. Scuola Norm. Sup. Pisa Cl. Sci., (4) 4, no. 4, 613–636. (Errata: “Cohomologie de SLn et valeurs de fonctions zeta aux points entiers”. Ann. Scuola Norm. Sup. Pisa Cl. Sci., (4) 7 (1980), no. 2, 373.) [BK90] Bloch, S., and Kato, K. 1990. L-functions and Tamagawa numbers of motives, The Grothendieck Festschrift, Vol. I. Progr. Math., 86, 333–400. Birkh¨ auser Boston, Boston, MA. [Bu02] Burgos Gil, Jos´e I. 2002. The regulators of Beilinson and Borel. CRM Monograph Series, 15. American Mathematical Society, Providence, RI. [De79] Deligne, P. 1979. Valeurs de fonctions L et p´eriodes d’int´egrales (French). With an appendix by N. Koblitz and A. Ogus. Proc. Sympos. Pure Math., XXXIII, Automorphic forms, representations and Lfunctions (Proc. Sympos. Pure Math., Oregon State Univ., Corvallis, Ore., 1977), Part 2, 313–346, Amer. Math. Soc., Providence, R. I. [Fl04] Flach, M. 2004. The equivariant Tamagawa number conjecture: a survey. With an appendix by C. Greither. Contemp. Math., 358, 79–125. Stark’s conjectures: recent work and new directions, Amer. Math. Soc., Providence, RI.
ζ-values
21
[Fo82] Fontaine, J.-M. 1982. Sur Certains Types de Representations p-Adiques du Groupe de Galois d’un Corps Local; Construction d’un Anneau de Barsotti-Tate. Ann. of Maths., 2nd Series, 115, no. 3, 529–577. [Fo92] Fontaine, J.-M. 1992. Valeurs sp´eciales des fonctions L des motifs, Ast´erisque, 206, no. 4, 205–249, S´eminaire Bourbaki, Vol. 1991/92, exp. 751. [HK03] Huber, A., and Kings, G. 2003. Bloch–Kato conjecture and Main Conjecture of Iwasawa theory for Dirichlet characters. Duke Math. J., 119, no. 3, 393–464. [Iv85] Ivi´c, A. 1985. The Riemann zeta-function. The theory of the Riemann zeta-function with applications. A Wiley-Interscience Publication. John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York. [KNF96] Kolster, M., Nguyen Quang Do, T., and Fleckinger, V. 1996. Twisted S-units, p-adic class number formulas, and the Lichtenbaum conjectures. Duke Math. J., 84, no. 3, 679–717. [Li73] Lichtenbaum, S. 1973. Values of zeta-functions, ´etale cohomology, and algebraic K-theory. Algebraic K-theory, II: “Classical” algebraic K-theory and connections with arithmetic (Proc. Conf., Battelle Memorial Inst., Seattle, Wash., 1972), Lect. Notes in Math., 342, 489–501. Springer, Berlin. [Mi71] Milnor, J. 1971. Introduction to algebraic K-theory. Annals of Mathematics Studies, no. 72. Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ; University of Tokyo Press, Tokyo. [Ne99] Neukirch, J. 1999. Algebraic number theory. Grundlehren der Mathematischen Wissenschaften [Fundamental Principles of Mathematical Sciences], 322, xviii-571. Springer-Verlag, Berlin. [Qu73] Quillen, D. 1973. Finite generation of the groups Ki of rings of algebraic integers. Lecture Notes in Math., 341, Springer-Verlag, 179–198. [Se69] Serre, J.-P. 1969–1970. Facteurs locaux des fonctions zeta des vari´et´es alg´ebriques (d´efinitions et conjectures). S´eminaire Delange-Pisot-Poitou. Th´eorie des nombres, 11, no. 2, exp. no. 19, 1–15. [We05] Weibel, C. 2005. Algebraic K-theory of rings of integers in local and global fields. Handbook of K-theory. 1-2, 139–190, Springer, Berlin. [We58] Weil, A. 1958–1960. Ad`eles et groupes alg´ebriques. (French) [Ad`eles and algebraic groups] S´eminaire Bourbaki. 5, exp. no. 186, 249–257.
2 K-theoretic Background R. Sujatha
Abstract The aim of these lectures is to cover the requisite background from Algebraic K-theory needed to prove the main result of Soul´e [So79, Th´eor`eme 5], which is dealt with in detail in [Li15]. This result of Soul´e which, along with an observation of Schneider, proves the vanishing of the ´etale cohomology group He´2t (Spec Z[1/l], Ql /Zl (m)), m ≥ 2, is equivalent to the finiteness of He´2t (Spec Z[1/l], Zl (m)) and plays a crucial role in the proof of the Tamagawa number conjecture due to [BK90]. In this article, l will denote an odd prime, all the rings considered will be commutative, associative, unital rings, unless otherwise mentioned, and all categories are small. We shall mainly consider Quillen’s K-theory referring the reader to [Q73a] for details. We would like to thank the referee for the comments which helped improve the exposition.
2.1 Quillen’s K-theory Let G be a topological group. Recall that the classifying space BG of G is the quotient of a weakly contractible space (i.e., all of whose homotopy groups are trivial) EG by a free action of G. This gives a principal Gbundle p : EG −→ BG which is universal in the sense that if X is of the homotopy type of a CW-complex, and P → X is a principal G-bundle, then there is a University of British Columbia, Vancouver, Canada. e-mail:
[email protected]
K-theoretic Background
23
continuous map f : X → BG (defined up to homotopy) such that P occurs as the pullback f ∗ EG. The spaces BG and EG are defined up to homotopy equivalence, and are connected. The topology of G is crucial when considering the classifying space. If G is discrete, then BG is a K(π, 1)-space, so that π1 (BG) = G, πn (BG) = 0 for n ≥ 2, where πn (X) denotes the n-th homotopy group of a topological space X. Similarly, Hn (X, ∗) denotes the n-th homology group of the space X with coefficients ∗. Quillen defines the higher K-groups of a ring R using the ‘plus construction’ [Q71], whose main properties are encapsulated in the following theorem. Theorem 2.1.1 (Quillen) Let (X, x) be a path connected space, N a perfect normal subgroup of π1 (X, x). Then there exists a continuous map of pairs φ : (X, x) → (X + , x+ ) such that the following hold: a) There exists an exact sequence φ∗
0 → N → π1 (X, x) −→ π1 (X + , x+ ) → 0. b) For any local coefficient system L on X + , the induced homomorphism φ∗ : Hn (X, φ∗ L) → Hn (X + , L) is an isomorphism for any n ≥ 0. c) If g : (X, x) → (Y, y) is a continuous map such that N ⊂ Ker (g∗ : π1 (X, x) → π1 (Y, y)), then there exists a continuous map h : (X + , x+ ) → (Y, y), unique up to homotopy, such that the diagram (X, x) g
φ
/ (X + , x+ )
h
y (Y, y) commutes. Let R be a ring and let GLn (R) denote the group of (n × n) matrices over R that are invertible. Each such matrix g is naturally viewed as an
24
R. Sujatha g 0 (n + 1) × (n + 1) matrix given by and thus gives an embedding 0 1 of GLn (R) into GLn+1 (R). The group GL(R) is defined as the union [ GLn (R), n
and is called the infinite linear group over R. Consider it as a topological group with the discrete topology. Take X = BGL(R), the classifying space of GL(R). Then BGL(R) is a connected space with π1 (BGL(R)) ' GL(R), πi (BGL(R)) = 0 for i ≥ 2. These properties characterize BGL(R) up to homotopy equivalence. Let En (R) be the subgroup of (n × n) elementary matrices, and put E(R) = lim En (R). Then E(R) is a perfect −→ n
normal subgroup of GL(R) and the space X + as in Theorem 2.1.1 is denoted by BGL(R)+ . Definition 2.1.2 For i ≥ 1, the i-th Quillen K-group of R, denoted Ki (R), is defined as Ki (R) = πi (BGL(R)+ ). For i ≥ 1, these groups are clearly abelian, since higher homotopy groups are. That they are abelian for i = 0, 1 follows from the discussion below (see Defn. 2.2.5). The groups K0 (R) and K1 (R) are dealt with below in greater detail. We now discuss some of the features of Quillen K-theory. For i ≥ 0, it comes equipped with a product structure Ki (R) ⊗ Kj (R) → Ki+j (R), so that we in fact have a ring K∗ (R). Further, we have Ki (R) ⊗Z Q ⊆ Hi (BGL(R), Q).
2.2 Ki (R) for small i Let C be an abelian category. Recall that a non-empty full subcategory D of C is a Serre subcategory if given an exact sequence f
g
A0 → A → A00 in C, we have that A0 and A00 are objects in D if and only if A is an object in D. The group K0 (C) is the abelian group generated by isomorphism classes [A], where A runs over the objects of C, and subject to the relation [A] = [A0 ] + [A00 ],
K-theoretic Background
25
for each short exact sequence 0 → A0 → A → A00 → 0 in C. The group K0 (C) is universal with respect to this property in the following sense. Suppose we are given an abelian group G and a map f : Ob(C) → G, such that for each short exact sequence 0 → A0 → A → A00 → 0 in C, we have f (A) = f (A0 ) + f (A00 ) in G. Then there exists a unique homomorphism φ : K0 (C) → G making the diagram Ob(C)
φ
/ K0 (C)
φ
f
z G
commutative. More generally, the group K0 can be defined analogously for any exact category, which we will not define rigorously (see [Q73a, §2]); intuitively, it is an additive category in which exact sequences are well defined. Then the map C → K0 (C) is a covariant functor from the category of exact categories and exact functors to the category of abelian groups. If, instead of exact sequences, we declare the relation [A] = [A0 ] ⊕ [A00 ] for any split, short exact sequence 0 → A0 → A → A00 → 0, then the corresponding group is denoted by K0 (C, +). The following proposition is well known [Sw68, II, 1.10], see also [We13, IV(1.1)]. Proposition 2.2.1 Let A, B be objects of C. If [A] = [B] in K0 (C, +), then there is an object C ∈ C such that A ⊕ C ' B ⊕ C.
Let R be a ring and CR be the abelian category of finitely generated (left) R-modules and let PR be the full subcategory of CR consisting of finitely generated projective left R-modules. The category PR is an exact
26
R. Sujatha
category, and the natural inclusion PR ⊂ CR induces a homomorphism K0 (PR ) → K0 (CR ). Definition 2.2.2 Let R be a ring. The group K0 (R) is defined to be the group K0 (PR ). Proposition 2.2.3 (see [Sw68, II.1]) Let R be a ring. Then the following assertions hold: i) The group K0 (PR ) is generated by [P ], where P is a finitely generated projective R-module with the relations [P ] = [Q] if P ' Q and [P ⊕ Q] = [P ] + [Q]. ii) Any element of K0 (R) can be written as [P ] − [Q] for finitely generated projective R-modules P and Q. Further, [P ] − [Q] = [P 0 ] − [Q0 ] in K0 (R) if and only if there is a finitely generated projective R-module M such that P ⊕ Q0 ⊕ M = P 0 ⊕ Q ⊕ M. A ring homomorphism η : R → R0 , along with the base change map P 7→ R0 ⊗R P, induces a group homomorphism K0 (R) → K0 (R0 ) as η induces an exact functor from the category PR to PR0 . Definition 2.2.4 Let f : R → R0 be a ring homomorphism. The category Cf consists of triplets (P, a, Q) as objects, where P and Q are finitely generated projective R-modules, and a is an isomorphism a
a : R0 ⊗R P −→ R0 ⊗R Q. Morphisms between two objects (P, a, Q) and (P 0 , a0 , Q0 ) consist of a pair of R-morphisms g : P → P 0 and h : Q → Q0 such that a0 ◦ (1R0 ⊗ g) = (1R0 ⊗ h) ◦ a. It is an isomorphism if both g and h are isomorphisms. A sequence of morphisms in Cf (see [Sw68, II.13], [We13, II(2.10)]) 0 → (P 0 , a0 , Q0 ) → (P, a, Q) → (P 00 , a00 , Q00 ) → 0
(2.1)
is a short exact sequence if the underlying sequences 0 → P 0 → P → P 00 → 0,
0 → Q0 → Q → Q00 → 0
are short exact. The group K0 (f ) (also called the relative K0 ) is an abelian group defined by generators [(P, a, Q)] with (P, a, Q) an object in the category Cf subject to the following relations:
K-theoretic Background
27
• [(P, a, Q)] = [(P 0 , a0 , Q0 )] + [(P 00 , a00 , Q00 )] for every short exact sequence as in (2.1). • [(P1 , b ◦ a, P3 )] = [(P1 , a, P2 )] + [(P2 , b, P3 )]. We now discuss the group K1 (R) for a ring R. There are various (equivalent) definitions though checking the equivalence involves several technicalities and is hence beyond the scope of these lectures. Recall the commutator subgroup [G, G] of a group G, which is always a normal subgroup of G and is universal with respect to the quotient group being abelian. The first definition of K1 (R) (also called the Whitehead group of R) is as the quotient of GL(R) by its commutator subgroup. Definition 2.2.5
K1 (R) is the abelian group GL(R)/[GL(R), GL(R)].
The abelian group K1 (R) thus has the universal property that every homomorphism from GL(R) to an abelian group must factor through K1 (R). A ring homomorphism R → R0 induces a homomorphism from K1 (R) to K1 (R0 ) and K1 is thus a covariant functor from the category of rings to Ab. Example: Since R is commutative, the determinant homomorphism is a group homomorphism from GL(R) onto the (abelian) group R× of units in R, and we denote the induced surjective map from K1 (R) by det, det : K1 (R) → R× .
The classical Whitehead’s lemma asserts that the group generated by elementary matrices E(R) is the commutator subgroup of GL(R) and there is an isomorphism K1 (R) ' GL(R)/E(R). The group K1 (R) measures the obstruction to taking an arbitrary invertible matrix over R and reducing it to the identity via a series of elementary operations. Let us now turn to an alternative definition of K1 (R) using projective modules. Let P be a finitely generated projective R-module. Choosing an isomorphism P ⊕ Q ' Rn gives a group homomorphism from Aut(P ) to GLn (R), by sending α to α ⊕ 1Q . This homomorphism is well
28
R. Sujatha
defined when viewed as a homomorphism into GL(R), up to inner automorphisms of GL(R), and thus there is a well-defined homomorphism Aut(P ) → K1 (R). Definition 2.2.6 For a ring R, the group K1 (R) is an abelian group which consists of generators [P, a] where P is a finitely generated projective R-module and a is in Aut(P ), subject to the relations • [P, a] = [Q, b] for f : P ' Q such that bf = f a. • [P, a ◦ b] = [P, a][P, b]. • [P ⊕ Q, a ⊕ b] = [P, a][Q, b]. The equivalence of this definition with the earlier one is seen using the well-defined homomorphism from Aut(P ) to K1 (R) as discussed above. There is a homological interpretation of K1 (R) given by K1 (R) = H1 (GL(R), Z),
(2.2)
the first group homology of GL(R) with Z-coefficients. A further topological interpretation elucidates K1 (R) as π1 (K(R)) where K(R) is a certain topological space built using the category PR .
2.3 K-theory of exact categories More generally, Quillen defines the K-groups for a (small) exact category C. We give a brief outline of this definition and refer the reader to [Q73a] for more details. One first defines a new (small) category QC, having the same objects as C but with morphisms between objects defined using the notion of admissibility (see [Q73a, §2]). There is also the important notion of the classifying space BC of C, which is a pointed topological space. These together enable one to define the classifying space BQC of the category QC. We also need the double Q construction Q2 C := QQC of Waldhausen, and the pairing BQC ∧BQC → BQ2 C, which is technical, and is given in [Wa78, IV(6.6)]. Definition 2.3.1 The K-groups Ki (C), for i ≥ 0, are defined as Ki (C) = πi+1 (BQC). We are being sloppy here by neglecting the base point, see [Sr93, Chap. 4] for details. When R is a ring, then, working with the category PR , it can be proved that the earlier definition of Ki (R) coincides with the definition above, viz., πi+1 (BQPR ) (see [Sr93, Chap. 7]. We shall simply
K-theoretic Background
29
write BQR for BQPR . A deep theorem of Quillen proves that there are natural isomorphisms for i ≥ 1, πi+1 (BQR) ' πi (BGL(R)+ ),
(2.3)
and hence we have isomorphisms for i ≥ 0 Ki (R) ' πi+1 (BQR) ' πi (BGL(R)+ ). We shall also need the important localization sequence in K-theory (see [Q73a, Theorem 5], [We13, Chap. V], [Gr68, §7]). Let B be a Serre subcategory of an abelian category A and consider the canonical functors i : B → A and η : A → A/B, where A/B is the quotient category. Then there is a long exact sequence η∗
δ
i
∗ · · · → Ki (A/B) → Ki−1 (B) → Ki−1 (A) → Ki−1 (A/B) → · · · .
(2.4)
As a special case of this, consider a commutative ring R and let S be a multiplicatively closed set whose elements are non-zero divisors of R. S Consider the abelian subcategory CR of CR , which consists of finitely generated R-modules that are S-torsion. This is a Serre subcategory and the quotient category is equivalent to CS −1 R , the category of finitely generated modules over the ring S −1 R. The category PR acts on the above categories compatibly and this makes the corresponding long exact sequence in K-theory an exact sequence of K∗ (R)-modules (see [We13, V (2.6.3)]); the full details of such an action require products in Quillen’s K-theory, (see [Gr68, §7]). A special example is that of a discrete valuation ring R with quotient field F and finite residue field k. In this case, the long exact localization sequence actually breaks up into short exact S sequences by ‘devissage’, we have isomorphisms Kn (k) ' Kn (CR ) (see [Ge73], [We13, V (6.9.2)]) 0 → Kn (R) → Kn (F ) → Kn−1 (k) → 0.
(2.5)
Another interesting example is when R = k[t], the polynomial ring over a field k. In this case we get short exact sequences that are split [We13, V (6.7.1)] 0 → Kn (k) → Kn (k(t)) → ⊕Kn−1 (kv ) → 0,
(2.6)
v
where the last direct sum is taken over the residue fields corresponding to the discrete valuations given by the closed points of the affine line Spec(k[t]). For a general Dedekind domain with quotient field F a global
30
R. Sujatha
field, we get short exact sequences (due to Soul´e)[We13, V(6.8)] 0 → Kn (R) → Kn (F ) → ⊕Kn−1 (kv ) → 0
(2.7)
v
where the direct sum is taken over height one prime ideals Pv of R and kv is the residue field R/Pv . The conjectural existence of such exact sequences for functors goes under the rubric of Gersten’s conjecture. We shall also need the norm or transfer maps defined in K-theory, which we recall below. Definition 2.3.2 Let R be a ring and R0 a ring containing R such that R0 is finitely generated and projective as an R-module. Let PR0 and PR denote the categories of finitely generated projective modules over R0 and R respectively. Then the natural forgetful functor PR0 → PR induces a homomorphism Kn (R0 ) → Kn (R), which is called the norm or transfer homomorphism.
2.4 K-theory with finite coefficients Let q be a positive integer. In this section, for a ring R (not necessarily commutative), we define the K-groups Ki (R; Z/q) with finite coefficients and relate them to the K-groups K∗ (R). These K-groups were first introduced by Browder (see [Br78]) and Karoubi. We first recall some notions from homotopy theory. A good reference for this is [Sel97]. Let π : E → B be a continuous map between topological spaces, and I be the unit interval [0, 1]. The map π is said to have the homotopy lifting property with respect to a space Y if given a homotopy H : Y × I → B and a lift f 0 : Y → E of H0 = H|Y ×0 , there 0 exists a lift H 0 : Y × I → E of H such that H00 = f 0 , where H00 = H|Y ×0 . A surjective map π : E → B is called a (Hurewicz) fibration if it has the homotopy lifting property with respect to Y for all spaces Y . The space B is called the base space of the fibration, E the total space and the inverse image π −1 (b) of a point b ∈ B is called the fibre of π over b. When we are dealing with pointed spaces and maps, the fibre over the base point of B is called the fibre of π. Given a fibration π : E → B π of pointed spaces with fibre F , we shall use the phrase ‘F → E → B is a fibration sequence’. The usual projection map F × B → B is called the ‘trivial fibration’. A sequence W → X → Y will be called a homotopy fibration if it is equivalent to a fibration sequence up to homotopy.
K-theoretic Background
31
Explicitly, this means that there is a commutative diagram W −−−−→ y
X −−−−→ y
Y y
F −−−−→ E −−−−→ B in which the vertical maps are homotopy equivalences with the bottom row being a fibration sequence. Given a fibration sequence as above, there is a long exact sequence · · · → πk+1 (B, b) → πk (F, x) → πk (E, x) → πk (B, b) → · · · .
(2.8)
The dual notion is that of a cofibration. An inclusion i : A ,→ X is said to have the homotopy extension property with respect to a space Y if given a homotopy H : A × I → Y and an extension f 0 : X → Y of H0 , there exists an extension H 0 : X × I → Y of H such that H00 = f 0 . An inclusion i : A ,→ X is called a cofibration if it has the homotopy extension property with respect to Y for all Y . If A is a subspace of X, we write X/A for the quotient space X/ ∼, where a ∼ a0 for all a, a0 ∈ A. If i : A ,→ X is a cofibration, then X/A is called the cofibre i of i and we write ‘A → X → C is a cofibration’, to indicate that C is the cofibre of i. Similar to (2.8), a cofibration sequence A → X → C of pointed spaces gives rise to a long exact sequence · · · → [S n C, V ] → [S n X, V ] → [S n A, V ] → [S n−1 C, V ] → · · · ,
(2.9)
where for a space X, S n X denotes the n-fold suspension of X and [X, Y ] denotes the set of based homotopy classes of based maps from the pointed space X to the pointed space Y . Note that [X, Y ] has no canonical group structure but the set [S n X, Y ] does have a group structure for n > 0. For any integer n ≥ 2, define Yqn by Yqn = S n−1
[
en ,
(2.10)
×q
where S n−1 is the unit (n−1)-sphere, en is the n-unit disc and the glueing is done by the map of degree q on the sphere. We shall abbreviate Yqn to Y n in what follows. There is a homotopic cofibration (see [Br78]) ×q
S n−1 −→ S n−1 → Y n .
(2.11)
32
R. Sujatha
Definition 2.4.1 The homotopy groups of a pointed space X with coefficients in Z/q are defined by πn (X; Z/q) = [Y n , X], n ≥ 2 where we remark that the set [Y n , X] has a canonical group structure. Definition 2.4.2 The K-groups of a ring R with coefficients in Z/q, denoted Ki (R; Z/q), for i ≥ 2 are defined as Ki (R; Z/q) = πi (BGL(R)+ ; Z/q) = [Y i , BGL(R)+ ]. For i = 0, define K0 (R, Z/q) = K0 (R)/qK0 (R), and for i = 1, K1 (R; Z/q) = π2 (BQR; Z/q). Note that, in analogy with (2.3), we have πi+1 (BQR; Z/q) = πi (BGL(R)+ ; Z/q) = Ki (R; Z/q) if i ≥ 2. Further, the cofibration sequence (2.11) clearly gives a long exact sequence ×q
×q
· · · → Ki (R) −→ Ki (R) → Ki (R; Z/q) → Ki−1 (R) −→ · · · K0 (R; Z/q) → 0. In particular, if K0 (R) is without torsion, then we recover K1 (R; Z/q) = K1 (R)/qK1 (R). Recall that if (X, x) and (Y, y) are pointed topological spaces, then the wedge product and smash product denoted respectively by X ∨ Y and X ∧ Y are defined by X ∨Y X ∧Y
= X ×y∪x×Y ⊆X ×Y = X × Y /X ∨ Y.
There is a natural pairing BQR∧BQR → BQ2 PR , see [We13, IV (6.6.2)], that induces a Z/q-algebra structure on K∗ (R; Z/q) which is a graded anti-commutative structure for odd integers q. The product structure can also be deduced via a pairing BGL(R)+ ∧ BGL(R)+ → BGL(R)+ which is defined up to weak homotopy equivalence. We refer the reader to [Br78, §1], [Lo76] for more details. Let B be an abelian category, A be a Serre subcategory and A/B be the corresponding quotient category. There is also a long exact sequence
K-theoretic Background
33
for the K-theory groups with coefficients (see [We13, V (5.2)]) analogous to the localization sequence in K-theory (2.4), → Kn (A; Z/q) → Kn (B; Z/q) → Kn (A/B; Z/q) → Kn−1 (A; Z/q) → · · · . If R is a regular Noetherian ring and H(R) is the (abelian, since R is regular) category of finitely generated R-modules with finite projective dimension, and S is a central, multiplicatively closed set of non-zero divisors in R, we may take A = H(R) and B to be the Serre subcategory HS (R) of S-torsion modules in H(R). The quotient category A/B is identified with finitely generated S −1 R-modules with finite projective dimension. The natural action of the category PR then gives a long exact sequence of K∗ R-modules (cf. [We13, Chap. V, §6]) → Kn (HS (R); Z/q) → Kn (H(R); Z/q) → Kn (H(S −1 R); Z/q) → Kn−1 (HS (R); Z/q) · · · . There are also analogues of (2.5) and (2.6) for the K-theory groups with Z/q-coefficients. For a field F with a discrete valuation v, with completion Fv and residue field kv , there are naturally defined residue maps δ¯ : Kn (F ; Z/q) → Kn−1 (kv ; Z/q), ∂v : H n (F, Z/q) → H n−1 (kv , Z/q).
2.5 Hurewicz homomorphisms Let (X, x) be a pointed topological space. The exact sequence q
0 → Z → Z → Z/q → 0 gives a long exact (Bockstein) sequence ×q
×q
· · · → πn (X) −→ πn (X) → πn (X; Z/q) → πn−1 (X) −→ of homotopy groups and ×q
×q
· · · → Hn (X) −→ Hn (X) → Hn (X, Z/q) → Hn−1 (X) −→ of homology groups, where Hi (X) denotes the i-th homology group of X with Z-coefficients. For every element α in πn (X; Z/q) = [Y n , X] (see (2.4.1)) let α∗ denote the induced maps on the homology groups Hi (Y n ) → Hi (X). Recall the classical Hurewicz homomorphisms hn :
34
R. Sujatha
πn (X; Z/q) → Hn (X, Z/q) (n ≥ 2, and q odd) are defined by hn (f ) = f∗ (n ) where n is a chosen generator of the homology group Hn (S n ). There is a natural commutative diagram (for n ≥ 2), ×q
−−−−→ πn (X) −−−−→ πn (X) −−−−→ πn (X; Z/q) −−−−→ πn−1 (X) q yh yh yh yh ×q
−−−−→ Hn (X) −−−−→ Hn (X) −−−−→ Hn (X, Z/q) −−−−→ Hn−1 (X). It is easily seen that for Y n , the cohomology groups Hi (Y n , Z/q) equal Z/q if i = 0, n − 1, n and is zero otherwise. Let nq be the generator of Hn (Y n , Z/q) whose image in Hn−1 (Y n , Z) under the Bockstein homomorphism is the class of Sn−1 ⊂ Y n . Definition 2.5.1
The Hurewicz map with Z/q-coefficients, hq : πn (X; Z/q) → Hn (X, Z/q),
is defined by the formula hq (α) = α∗ (nq ). It is a homomorphism except when n = q = 2. If q is odd, then (see [So79, Lemme 2]) any pairing X ∧Y → Z induces a commutative diagram πm (X; Z/q) ⊗ πn (Y ; Z/q) −−−−→ πm+n (Z; Z/q) hq ×hq y hq y Hm (X, Z/q) ⊗ Hn (Y, Z/q) −−−−→ Hm+n (Z, Z/q). If ∆ : X → X ∧ X is the diagonal morphism, with ∆∗ : Hn (X, Z/q) → Hn (X ∧ X, Z/q) the induced morphism on homology, and if n ≥ 2, then ∆∗ ◦ hq = 0 (see [So79, Lemme 3]).
´ 2.6 Etale cohomology and equivariant cohomology For details on ´etale sheaves and ´etale cohomology groups on a scheme X, the reader is referred to [Mi80]. We shall briefly summarize some of the results that will be needed. Let A be a commutative domain in which the prime number l is invertible. We shall consider two important ´etale sheaves, viz. Gm , the ´etale multiplicative group sheaf and the sheaf µl of l-th roots of unity. Given an ´etale sheaf F on Spec A, the ´etale
K-theoretic Background
35
cohomology groups H n (Spec A, F) (n ≥ 0) will be denoted simply by H n (A, F ). If A is a field F , an ´etale sheaf is a continuous GF -module for the Galois group GF = Gal(Fs /F ), where Fs denotes a separable closure of F and the ´etale cohomology groups are simply the Galois cohomology groups. For the sheaf Gm on Spec F , the corresponding Galois module is Gm = Fs× and we have H 0 (F, Gm ) ' F × , H 1 (F, Gm ) = 0 and H 2 (F, Gm ) ' Br(F ),
(2.12)
where for a commutative ring A, Br(A) is the Brauer group of A consisting of equivalence classes of central simple algebras. Let q = ln be invertible on A. The ´etale sheaf µ⊗i q denotes the i-th Tate twist of the ´etale sheaf µq ; the underlying object is the same as µq but the Galois group acts via the i-th cyclotomic character. The long exact sequence in ´etale cohomology associated to the Kummer exact sequence of ´etale sheaves ×q
1 → µq → Gm −→ Gm → 1,
(2.13)
along with (2.12), gives isomorphisms H 0 (F, µq ) ' µq (F ), q H 1 (F, µq ) ' F × /F ×
(the q th roots of unity in F ) and H 2 (F, µq ) ' q Br(F )
(2.14)
where q Br(F ) denotes the q-torsion subgroup of the Brauer group of F . If the group of units A× in A contains a non-zero element of order q, then the sheaf µ⊗i q is isomorphic to the constant sheaf Z/q. There is a cup-product j ⊗n i+j H i (A, µ⊗m (A, µ⊗m+n ) q ) ⊗ H (A, µq ) → H q
which is an isomorphism for i = 0 if µq ⊂ A× . If A is a Dedekind domain with quotient field F and j : A ,→ F is the canonical inclusion, then the natural morphism of ´etale sheaves ⊗i (µ⊗i q )A → j∗ ((µq )F )
is an isomorphism. For a field F with a discrete valuation v, with completion Fv and residue field kv , there are naturally defined residue maps (see [So79, III.3]), k−1 ∂v : H k (F, µ⊗i (kv , µ⊗(i−1) ). q )→ H q
If A is a Dedekind domain with quotient field F , then we have a long
36
R. Sujatha
exact localization sequence in ´etale cohomology [So79, Proposition 1] δ
⊗(i−1)
1 ⊗i 0 0 → H 1 (A, µ⊗i q ) → H (F, µq ) → ⊕H (kv , µq v
) → H 2 (A, µ⊗i q )···
⊗(i−1)
k ⊗i k−1 → H k (A, µ⊗i (kv , µq q ) → H (F, µq ) → ⊕H v
) → H k+1 (A, µ⊗i q )
··· , where the direct sum is taken over the discrete valuations v of F associated to height one prime ideals of A, kv denotes the residue field at v, and the connecting maps are obtained from the residue maps. It is well known that the residue map lands in the direct sum; this follows from an analysis of the definition of the residue map and the fact that given a non-zero element x in F , there are only finitely many valuations v such that v(x) is non-zero. Let B be a finite ´etale extension of a ring A [Mi80] and f be the injection of A into B. There is an induced morphism k ⊗i f ∗ : H k (Spec A, µ⊗i q ) → H (Spec B, µq )
and also an associated transfer morphism (see [So79, III.1.5]) k ⊗i f∗ : H k (Spec B, µ⊗i q ) → H (Spec A, µq )
which satisfies the projection formula f∗ (x ∪ f ∗ (y)) = f∗ (x) ∪ y. A − → y
B − → A/B y y
A0 − → B0 − → A0 /B0 induces the following commutative diagrams of the corresponding localization sequences in K-theory and ´etale cohomology:
δ
−−−→ Kn (B; Z/q) −−−→ Kn (L; Z/q) −−−→ ⊕Kn−1 (lw ; Z/q) −−−→ w y y y δ
−−−→ Kn (A; Z/q) −−−→ Kn (F ; Z/q) −−−→ ⊕Kn−1 (kv ; Z/q) −−−→ , v
and
K-theoretic Background
37
∂
⊗(i−1)
k ⊗i k−1 −−−−→ H k (B, µ⊗i (lw , µq q ) −−−−→ H (L, µq ) −−−−→ ⊕H w y y y ∂
⊗(i−1)
k ⊗i k−1 −−−−→ H k (A, µ⊗i (kv , µq q ) −−−−→ H (F, µq ) −−−−→ ⊕H
)
)
w
Here w varies over the discrete valuations of L (as before, associated to height one prime ideals of the corresponding Dedekind domains) and the vertical arrows are given by the transfer maps. In particular, for a number field F with ring of integers A, and for a field k with characteristic different from l, we obtain exact sequences (see [So79, III.2]) ∂
k ⊗i k−1 → H k (A, µ⊗i (kv , µ⊗i−1 ) q ) → H (F, µq ) → ⊕ H q w
∂
n ⊗i n−1 0 → H n (k, µ⊗i (kw , µ⊗i−1 ) → 0, q ) → H (k(T ), µq ) → ⊕ H q w
where the maps ∂ are given by the sum of the residue maps defined earlier. The surjectivity of the residue map in the first sequence is known to be true in certain cases (see [So79, III.2, III.3]). Note that if k > 2, the groups H k−1 (kv , µ⊗i−1 ) are zero for finite fields. Finally we mention q that the morphisms of sheaves µ⊗j → µ⊗j ln , n ≥ 1, ln+1 allow us to define H k (A, Zl (j)) := lim H k (A, µ⊗j ln ). n ←−
We now briefly recall the equivariant cohomology groups. Let X be a topological space and G a sheaf of groups on X. Denote by BG the classifying topos of G, which is identified with the category of sheaves of sets on X with an action of G (see [Gr68, Defn. 1.9]). The category of abelian group objects in BG is equivalent to the category of Z[G]-modules where Z[G] is the sheaf of integral group rings associated to Z[G]. If F is an abelian object of BG , then the G-equivariant cohomology groups of F are defined as H i (X, G, F ) = Ri (Γ(X, F G )) ' Ext iZ[G] (Z, F ), where Z is the constant sheaf with trivial G-action associated to Z. These cohomology groups can be computed using Z[G]-injective resolutions of F. Equivariant cohomology groups will play a key role in the theory of Chern classes to be discussed below.
38
R. Sujatha
2.7 K-groups of rings of integers in number fields The K-theory of the rings of integers of number fields is an important topic which has deep connections with arithmetic. We refer the reader to [Ko04] for a broad survey of this topic. Let F be a number field and denote the ring of integers in F by OF . We have K0 (OF ) ' Z ⊕ Cl(F ), K1 (OF ) ' OF× , where Cl(F ) is the Class group of F . Quillen proved that the higher K-groups are finitely generated [Q73b] and Borel [Bo77] showed that for n ≥ 2, the K-groups K2n−1 (OF ) are of the form K2n−1 (OF ) ' Zkn ⊕ H where H is a finite group and r1 + r2 − 1 if n = 1 k n = r1 + r2 if n ≥ 3 is odd r if n ≥ 2 is even. 2 We remark that kn is precisely the order of vanishing of the Riemann zeta function ζF (s) at s = 1 − n, n ≥ 2. Borel defined higher regulator maps kn ρB n (F ) : K2n−1 (OF ) → R
and showed that the kernel is finite and the image is a lattice of rank kn . The covolume of this lattice is the Borel regulator which is related to special zeta values. Soul´e showed that the inclusion map OF ,→ F in fact induces isomorphisms K2n−1 (OF ) ' K2n−1 (F ) for all integers n ≥ 2. This follows from (2.7) and the vanishing of K2n (kv ). In the simplest case when F = Q, it is also known that K4k+1 (Z) is Z for odd k, and is isomorphic to Z ⊕ Z/2 for positive even k. Let He´∗t (Z[1/l], Zl (n)) denote the ´etale cohomology groups of the ring Z[1/l]. The exact localization sequence gives a long exact sequence ⊗n ⊗n−1 1 0 0 → He´1t (Z[1/l], µ⊗n ) lm ) → He´t (Q, µlm ) → ⊕ He´t (Fp , µlm p6=l
→
He´2t (Z[1/l], µ⊗n lm )
→ ··· .
K-theoretic Background
39
Passing to the projective limit and using the fact that He´0t (Fp , Zl (n − 1)) = 0 for n 6= 1, we obtain isomorphisms He´1t (Z[1/l], Zl (n)) ' He´1t (Q, Zl (n)), n 6= 1.
(2.15)
2.8 Chern classes ´ a la Grothendieck In this section, we shall briefly discuss the theory of equivariant l-adic Chern classes as developed by Grothendieck in [Gr58], [Gr68]. We shall largely follow Soul´e’s exposition in [So79], see also [Gr68]. The basic property that we shall need of the Chern class maps are that they connect K-theory to ´etale cohomology and further commute with the relevant boundary maps as well as the residue maps of the localization sequences in K-theory and ´etale cohomology. Let l be an odd prime number and P be a projective module of finite type over A of bounded rank r over every residue field of A. Suppose that we are given a representation ρ : G → Aut(P ). This defines a locally free sheaf on Spec A with a G-action. Grothendieck associates Chern classes to such a fibre bundle, which are denoted ci (ρ) ∈ H 2i (Spec A, G; µ⊗i lv ), 0 ≤ i, v ≥ 1. They are zero for i ≥ r, and the groups are the ´etale equivariant cohomology groups where G acts trivially on Spec A. We have c0 (ρ) = 1 and, under the canonical projections µ⊗i → lv+1 ⊗i µlv , the Chern classes form a projective system. The total Chern class, denoted c(ρ), is defined by c(ρ) = 1 + c1 (ρ) + c2 (ρ) + · · · + cr (ρ). It has the following properties: 1. (Functoriality): If f : A → A0 , G → G0 and P → P 0 are compatible morphisms, then ci (f ∗ (ρ)) = f ∗ (ci (ρ)). 2. (Normalisation): Let det(ρ) be the determinant bundle of rank one viewed as an element in H 1 (Spec A, G; Gm ). Then c1 (ρ) = βv (det(ρ)), where βv is the connecting Bockstein map H 1 (Spec A, G; Gm ) → H 2 (Spec A, G; µlv )) associated to the Kummer sequence (2.13). 3. (Additivity): If 0 → P 0 → P → P 00 → 0 is an exact sequence of G-modules which are projective as A-modules and ρ0 , ρ , ρ00 are the corresponding representations, then c(ρ) = c(ρ0 ) ∪ c(ρ00 )
40
R. Sujatha where ∪ denotes the cup-product in equivariant cohomology.
4. (Multiplicativity): Let Qi be the universal polynomial with integral coefficients associated to the Chern classes. If ρ and ρ0 are two representations as above, then we have ci (ρ ⊗ ρ0 ) = Qi (c1 (ρ), c2 (ρ), · · · ; c1 (ρ0 ), c2 (ρ0 ), · · · ). 5. Identity: If idn denotes the natural representation of GLn (A) on An , m we get classes ci (idn ) ∈ H 2i (Spec A, GLn (A); µ⊗i q ), with q = l , l a prime. These classes stabilize in the sense that under the natural inclusion in of GLn (A) (resp. An ) into GLn+1 (A) (resp. An+1 ), we have i∗n (c(idn+1 )) = c(i∗n (idn+1 )) = c(idn ⊕ 1) = c(idn ) ∪ c(1) = c(idn ), (2.16) where 1 denotes the trivial representation of GLn (A) on A. These Chern classes can be used to obtain maps on the homology groups of G. More precisely, if G is a group that operates trivially on Spec A, then there exists a natural morphism [So79, Lemma 1] Φ
2i
k ⊗i H 2i (SpecA, G; µ⊗i ln ) −→ ⊕ Hom (H2i−k (G; Z/q), H (SpecA; µq )). k=0
Thus to the Chern classes ci (ρ), one may associate homomorphisms ci,k (ρ) : H2i−k (G; Z/q) → H k (SpecA; µ⊗i q ) defined by t 7→ Φ(ci (ρ)(t)). In particular, for the natural representation of GLn (A) above, taking limits over n, which is possible by the stability property (2.16). One obtains the morphism ci,k (id) : H2i−k (GL(A); Z/q) −→ H k (Spec A, µ⊗i q ), 0 ≤ k ≤ 2i. (2.17) These maps are used to construct Chern class maps on the K-theory groups which take values in the ´etale cohomology groups. Fix the ring A and integers i , k ≥ 0, q = lv . We define morphisms c¯i,k : K2i−k (A; Z/q) → H k (SpecA; µ⊗i q ),
(2.18)
as follows: c¯i,k
• ci,k is the composite K2i−k (A) → K2i−k (A; Z/q) −→ H k (SpecA, µ⊗i q ).
K-theoretic Background
41
• If 2i − k ≥ 2, then c¯i,k = ci,k (id) ◦ hq , where ci,k (id) is as in (2.17) and hq is the Hurewicz homomorphism. hq
K2i−k (A; Z/q) = π2i−k (BGL(A)+ ; Z/q) −→ H2i−k (GL(A); Z/q) ci,k (id)
−→ H k (Spec A, µ⊗i q ).
• If 2i = k, then ci,2i is given by the Chern classes of the trivial group, and it factors through K0 (A; Z/q) = K0 (A)/qK0 (A). • If 2i − k = 1, then the definition is rather ad hoc and we only consider the special case of c¯1,1 when A is a Dedekind domain. In this case, if F is the quotient field, we then have a commutative diagram where the exact rows are consequences of the localization sequences, K1 (A; Z/q) c¯ y 1,1
−−−−→ K1 (F ; Z/q) −−−−→ ⊕Z/q v ' y y
0 −−−−→ H 1 (SpecA, µq ) −−−−→ H 1 (F, µq ) −−−−→ ⊕Z/q. v
The centre vertical map c¯1,1 is an isomorphism on Spec F , both groups q being isomorphic to F × /F × . The first vertical arrow is then defined to be the obvious map arising from this commutative diagram. We mention that in all cases, ci,k is always defined on K1 (A) using ci,k (id) and the morphisms (2.2) K1 (A) = H1 (GL(A); Z) → H1 (GL(A); Z/q). When K0 (A) has no q-torsion, this permits us to define c¯i,k by reduction modulo q. • The Chern class maps commute with transfers and the residue maps in K-theory and Galois cohomology. The following theorem [So79, Th´eor`eme 1] tells us how we can bootstrap the Chern classes. Theorem 2.8.1 i) Let a ∈ Km (A; Z/q) and b ∈ Kn (A; Z/q), with m ≥ 2 (resp. n ≥ 2) where a ∈ K1 (A)/qK1 (A) when m = 1 (resp. b ∈ K1 (A)/qK1 (A)), when n = 1). Let a.b ∈ Km+n (A; Z/q) be the product of a and b. Then we have c¯i,k (a.b) = Σ
−(i − 1)! c¯i0 ,k0 (a) ∪ c¯i00 ,k00 (b). (i0 − 1)!(i00 − 1)!
In this formula, the sum is taken over all integers i0 , i00 , k 0 , k 00 verifying
42
R. Sujatha
i = i0 + i00 , k = k 0 + k 00 , 2i0 − k 0 = m, 2i00 − k 00 = n. The element ci0 ,k0 (a) ∪ ci00 ,k00 (b) is obtained by the cup-product 0
0
00
00
k H k (Spec A, µ⊗i (Spec A, µ⊗i ) → H k (SpecA, µ⊗i q )×H q q ).
ii) If a ∈ K0 (A; Z/q) and b ∈ Km (A; Z/q), with m ≥ 2, or b ∈ K1 (A)/qK1 (A), under the condition that ci,2i (a) = 0 for i ≥ 2, X 00 −(i − 1)! c¯i,k (a.b) = (ci1,2 )(a) ∪ c¯i0 ,k0 (b), 0 − 1)!(i00 − 1)! (i 0 00 0 i ,i ,k
00
00
00
with i0 + i00 = i, and k 0 + 2k 00 = k, and ci1,2 (a) ∈ H 2i (Spec A, µ⊗i ) q being the i00 -th power of c1,2 (a). Soul´e proved [So79, Th´eor`eme 4] that the Chern class map c¯i,k : K2i−k (A; Z/q) → H k (Spec A[1/l], µq ) is surjective for i < l and k ≤ 2, and under certain (mild) additional hypotheses, which certainly hold if A is the ring of integers of a number field, except possibly for k = 1. By [DF85], it is also an isomorphism for k = 1. In particular, it can be deduced that the map c¯1,0 : K2 (A; Z/q) → H 0 (Spec A, µq ) is surjective for Spec A, when A is the ring of integers of a number field.
References [Ba68] Bass, H. 1968. Algebraic K-theory, W.A. Benjamin Inc., New YorkAmsterdam. [BK90] Bloch, S., and Kato, K. 1990. L-functions and Tamagawa numbers of motives, in The Grothendieck Festschrift, vol. 1. Progress in Math., 86, 333-400. Birkh¨ auser, Boston, MA. [Bo77] Borel, A. 1977. Stable real cohomology of arithmetic groups. Ann. Sci. ´ Ecole Norm. Sup., 7, 613–636. [Br78] Browder, W. 1978. Algebraic K-theory with coefficients Z/p, in “Geometric applications of Homotopy theory I”. Lecture Notes in Math., 657, 40–84. Berlin-Heidelberg-New York. [Co15] Coates, J. 2015. Values of the Riemann zeta function at the odd positive integers and Iwasawa theory, in The Bloch-Kato Conjecture for the Riemann Zeta Function, LMS Lecture Note Series 418. Cambridge University Press. 45–64. [DF85] Dwyer, W. G., and Friedlander, E. M. 1985. Algebraic and ´etale Ktheory. Trans. AMS., 292, 247–280.
K-theoretic Background
43
[Ge73] Gersten, S. M. 1973. Some exact sequences in the higher K-theory of rings, in Higher K-theories. Lecture Notes in Math., 341, 211–243. [Gi81] Gillet, H. 1981. Riemann-Roch Theorems for Higher Algebraic Ktheory. Advances in Math. 40, 203–281. [Gr76] Grayson, D. 1976. Higher Algebraic K-theory II (After Daniel Quillen), in Algebraic K-theory (Proc. Conf. Northwestern Univ., Evanston III). Lecture Notes in Math., 551, 217–240. [Gr58] Grothendieck, A. 1958. La th´eorie des classes de Chern. Bull. Soc. Math. France, 86, 137–154. [Gr68] Grothendieck, A. 1968. Classes de Chern et r´epresentations lineaires des groupes discrets, (French), in Dix Expos´es sur la Cohomologies des Sch´emas, North-Holland, Amsterdam; Masson, Paris, 215–305. [Ka93] Kahn, B. 1993. On the Lichtenbaum-Quillen conjecture, Algebraic Ktheory and algebraic topology (Lake Louise, AB, 1991). NATO Adv. Sci. Inst. Ser. C Math.Phys.Sci., 407, 147–166. Kluwer Acad Pub., Dordrecht. [Ko04] Kolster, M. 2004. K-theory and arithmetic. Contemporary developments in algebraic K-theory, ICTP Lecture Notes XV, Trieste, 191–258. [Ko15] Kolster, M. 2015. The Norm residue homomorphism and the QuillenLichtenbaum conjecture, in The Bloch-Kato Conjecture for the Riemann Zeta Function, LMS Lecture Note Series 418. Cambridge University Press. 97–120. [Li15] Lichtenbaum, S. 2015. Soul´e’s theorem, in The Bloch-Kato Conjecture for the Riemann Zeta Function, LMS Lecture Note Series 418. Cambridge University Press. 130–139. [Lo76] Loday, J.-L. 1976. K-th´eorie et repr´esentations de groupes. Ann. Sci´ Norm. Sup. , 4 i´eme s´erie, 9, 309–377. ent. Ec. ´ [Mi80] Milne, J. S. 1980. Etale cohomology. Princeton Math. Series, 33, Princeton University Press, Princeton, New Jersey. [Ng15] Nguyen Quang Do, T. 2015. On the determinantal approach to the Tamagawa Number Conjecture, in The Bloch-Kato Conjecture for the Riemann Zeta Function, LMS Lecture Note Series 418. Cambridge University Press. 154–193. [Q71] Quillen, D. 1971. Cohomology of Groups. ICM Proceedings, Nice 1970, Gauthier Villars, Vol. II, 47-51. [Q73a] Quillen, D. 1973. Higher Algebraic K-theory I, in Higher K-theories, Proc. Conf. Battelle Memorial Inst., Seattle, Was., (1972), Lecture Notes in Math., 341, 85–147. Springer-Verlag, Berlin-New York. [Q73b] Quillen, D. 1973. Finite generation of the groups Ki of rings of algebraic integers, in Higher K-theories. Proc. Conf. Battelle Memorial Inst., Seattle, Was. (1972), Lecture Notes in Math., 341, 179–198, SpringerVerlag, Berlin-New York. [Ra15] Raghuram, A. 2015. Special values of the Riemann zeta function: some results and conjectures, in The Bloch-Kato Conjecture for the Riemann Zeta Function, LMS Lecture Note Series 418. Cambridge University Press. 1–21. [Sel97] Selick, P. 1997. Introduction to Homotopy theory. Field Institute Monographs, 9, American Mathematical Society, Providence, RI.
44
R. Sujatha
[So79] Soul´e, C. 1979. K-th´eorie des anneaux d’entiers de corps de nombres et cohomogie ´etale. Invent. Math., 55, 251–295. [Sr93] Srinivas, V. 1993 Algberaic K-theory, 2nd. Ed. Progress in Math. vol. 90, Birkh¨ auser. [Sw68] Swan, R. G. 1968. Algebraic K-theory. Lecture Notes in Math., 76, Springer-Verlag, Berlin-New York. [Wa78] Waldhausen, F. 1978. Algebraic K-theory of generalized free products I, II. Ann. of Math., (2), 108, no.2, 135–204, 205–256. [We13] Weibel, C. 2013. The K-book: An introduction to Algebraic K-theory. Graduate Studies in Math., 145, AMS.
3 Values of the Riemann Zeta Function at the Odd Positive Integers and Iwasawa Theory John Coates
3.1 Introduction The modest aim of the present paper is to give a detailed account of the intriguing p-adic argument, which, when combined with the motivic argument presented in [Hu15] and [Ki15], enables one to complete the proof of the original Bloch–Kato conjecture for the values of the Riemann zeta function at the odd integers > 1, at least up to an unknown power of 2. This p-adic argument is based on deep results from the Iwasawa theory of cyclotomic fields (we use both the main conjecture and Iwasawa’s theorem, in the simplest case when the Galois extension of Q given by the maximal real subfield of the field obtained by all p-power roots of unity to Q; see, for example, [CS06] for an account of this classical material), as well as important theorems of Borel and Soul´e on the K-theory of Z, and its relation to Galois cohomology. We stress that it is unknown at present how to carry out this p-adic argument using Iwasawa theory alone. We follow the original arguments of [BK90], section 6, but in addition make use of the deep motivic results of [Hu15] and [Ki15] included in this volume, which establish, in a form suitable for our needs, Conjecture 6.2 of [BK90], namely Theorem 3.6.2 of this paper. This Conjecture 6.2 was unproven at the time when Bloch and Kato wrote their original paper [BK90]. For an account of much further related work on all of these questions, see the article [Ng15] in the present volume.
University of Cambridge, UK. e-mail :
[email protected]
46
John Coates
3.2 Notation The following notation will be used throughout this paper. Always, p will denote an odd prime number. We write Zp and Qp for the ring of p-adic integers, and the field of p-adic numbers, respectively, and define Dp = Qp /Zp , S = {p, ∞}. Write QS for the maximal extension of Q which is unramified outside S. If K is any intermediate field between Q and QS , GS (K) will denote the Galois group of QS over K. Let µp∞ denote the group of all p-power roots of unity, and write χ : GS (Q) → Z× p for the character giving the action of GS (Q) on µp∞ . For each integer m, let Zp (m) be the free Zp module of rank 1 on which GS (Q) acts via χm . More generally, if M is any Zp -module on which GS (Q) acts, M (m) will, as usual, denote the Zp -module M ⊗Zp Zp (m), endowed with the diagonal action of GS (Q). If A is a discrete or compact Zp -module, we write A∗ = Homcont (A, Dp ) for its Pontrjagin dual, which again we endow with the natural action of GS (Q) when A is itself a GS (Q)-module. As usual, we endow GS (Q) with the profinite topology. If M is a topological GS (Q)-module, H i (GS (Q), M )(i ≥ 0) will denote the cohomology groups of M formed with continuous cochains. Similarly, if M is a topological module for the absolute Galois group G(Q¯p /Qp ) of the field Qp of p-adic numbers, we write H i (Qp , M )(i ≥ 0) for the cohomology groups of M formed with continuous cochains. If M is a finitely generated Zp -module, rZp (M ) will denote the Zp -rank of M modulo its torsion submodule.
3.3 The Poitou–Tate sequence We begin by using the Poitou–Tate sequence to establish the following result. For brevity, we put GS = GS (Q). Theorem 3.3.1
For each integer m 6= 0, we have the exact sequence
0 → H 2 (GS , Zp (m))∗ → H 1 (GS , Dp (1 − m)) → H 1 (Qp , Dp (1 − m)) → → H 1 (GS , Zp (m))∗ → H 2 (GS , Dp (1 − m) → 0. Proof Let M be any finite GS -module, and define M D = Hom(M, µp∞ ). Then, since p is odd, by the theorem of Poitou and Tate, we have the exact sequence
Zeta Values at the Odd Positive Integers and Iwasawa theory
47
0 → H 0 (GS , M ) → H 0 (Qp , M ) → H 2 (GS , M D )∗ → H 1 (GS , M ) → H 1 (Qp , M ) → H 1 (GS , M D )∗ → H 2 (GS , M ) → H 2 (Qp , M ) → H 0 (GS , M D )∗ → 0. We apply this sequence with M = Z/pr Z(1 − m), and r any integer ≥ 1 (so that M D = Z/pr Z(m)). Note that H 0 (GS , M ) = H 0 (Qp , M ) because p is totally ramified in the field obtained by adjoining all ppower roots of unity to Q. Also, since the H j (GS , M D ) are finite for all j ≥ 0, it is well known (see [Ta76]) that, for each j ≥ 0, H j (GS , Zp (m)) = lim H j (GS , Z/pr Z(m)), ←
where the projective limit is taken over all r ≥ 0. It is clear that H 0 (GS , Zp (m)) = 0 because m 6= 0. Thus, taking the inductive limit of the above sequences over all r ≥ 1, we obtain the exact sequence 0 → H 2 (GS , Zp (m))∗ → H 1 (GS , Dp (1 − m)) → H 1 (Qp , Dp (1 − m)) → → H 1 (GS , Zp (m))∗ → H 2 (GS , Dp (1 − m) → H 2 (Qp , Dp (1 − m)) → 0. It follows from Tate local duality that H 2 (Qp , Z/pr Z(1 − m)) is dual to H 0 (Qp , Z/pr Z(m)). Hence, passing to the inductive limit, it follows that H 2 (Qp , Dp (1 − m)) is dual to H 0 (Qp , Zp (m)) = lim H 0 (GS , Z/pr Z(m)), ←
and this latter group is equal to 0 because m 6= 0. This completes the proof. We next relate the H i (GS , Dp (1−m)) to the relevant Iwasawa module, and now it is vital that we assume that m is an odd integer. Definition 3.3.2 F∞ is the maximal real subfield of the field Q(µp∞ ), and G = Gal(F∞ /Q). We further define K∞ to be the maximal abelian p-extension of F∞ , which is unramified outside p (note that K∞ /F∞ is automatically unramified outside the infinite places because it is pro-p and we have assumed that p is odd), and put X∞ = Gal(K∞ /F∞ ).
(3.1)
Since K∞ is clearly Galois over Q, the group G acts continuously on
48
John Coates
X∞ via inner automorphisms in the usual fashion. As X∞ is also a Zp module, this action extends to an action of the whole Iwasawa algebra of G, which we will always denote by Λ(G) in what follows. Theorem 3.3.3 morphisms
For each odd integer m 6= 1, we have canonical iso-
H 1 (GS , Dp (1−m))∗ = X∞ (m−1)G , H 2 (GS , Dp (1−m))∗ = X∞ (m−1)G , where, as above, GS = GS (Q). Proof Recall that GS (F∞ ) denotes the subgroup of GS fixing F∞ . Now, since m is odd, both G and GS (F∞ ) act on Dp (1 − m). Also G has pcohomological dimension equal to 1. Hence the Hochschild–Serre spectral sequence E2i,j = H i (G, H j (GS (F∞ ), Dp (1 − m))) =⇒ H i+j (GS , Dp (1 − m)) degenerates into the two short exact sequences 0 → H 1 (G, H i−1 (GS (F∞ ), Dp (1 − m))) → H i (GS , Dp (1 − m)) → H i (GS (F∞ ), Dp (1 − m))G → 0 with i = 1, 2. As m is odd, GS (F∞ ) acts trivially on Dp (1 − m), and so we have H 1 (GS (F∞ ), Dp (1 − m)) = Hom(X∞ , Dp (1 − m)) = (X∞ (m − 1))∗ . Moreover, since m 6= 1, we have H 1 (G, Dp (1 − m)) = 0 (indeed, G is topologically generated by one element, say g, and multiplication by g−1 is an automorphism of Qp (1 − m) since m 6= 1, whence it follows that multiplication by g − 1 on Dp (1 − m) must be surjective). Finally, the weak Leopoldt conjecture, proven by Iwasawa, is the assertion that H 2 (GS (F∞ ), Dp (1 − m)) = H 2 (GS (F∞ ), Dp )(1 − m) = 0. The assertions of the theorem now follow from these remarks and the above two exact sequences. This completes the proof. We next give the entirely analogous local argument at the prime p. Let [ Φr = Qp (µpr+1 )+ , Φ∞ = Φr . r≥0
Of course, the Galois group of Φ∞ over Qp can be identified with the
Zeta Values at the Odd Positive Integers and Iwasawa theory
49
global Galois group G. Define Ω∞ to be the Galois group over Φ∞ of the maximal abelian p-extension of Φ∞ . Again, there is a natural action of G on Ω∞ by inner automorphisms. Local class field theory then yields a G-isomorphism ¯ × , with Φ ¯ × = lim Φ× /(Φ× )pt , Ω∞ ' lim Φ r r ←− r ←− r where the first projective limit is taken with respect to the norm maps as r varies, and the second with respect to the natural maps as t varies. Proposition 3.3.4
H 1 (Qp , Dp (1 − m))∗ ' (Ω∞ (m − 1))G = Zp .
Proof For the first isomorphism, the proof is entirely analogous to the global case given above, but using the Hochschild–Serre spectral sequence for the extension Φ∞ /Qp . For the second equality, one uses the theorem of Iwasawa (see [Iw73], Theorem 25) that Ω∞ ' Λ(G). This completes the proof. Combining Theorems 10.1.1, 10.1.2, and Proposition 3.3.4, we immediately obtain, for each odd integer m 6= 1, the first fundamental exact sequence 0 → X∞ (m − 1)G → H 1 (GS , Zp (m)) → Ω∞ (m − 1)G → → X∞ (m − 1)G → H 2 (GS , Zp (m)) → 0.
(3.2)
By a fundamental theorem of Iwasawa [Iw73], X∞ is a finitely generated torsion Λ(G)-module (which means that it has a non-zero annihilator which is not a divisor of zero in the Iwasawa algebra Λ(G)). Hence, by a well-known algebraic argument, for all odd integers m, we have rZp (X∞ (m − 1)G ) = rZp (X∞ (m − 1)G ).
(3.3)
We remark that the H i (GS , Zp (m)) are all easily seen to be finitely generated Zp -modules, and they vanish for i > 2 because GS has pcohomological dimension equal to 2 since p is odd. Combining (3.3) with the exact sequence (3.2), and Proposition 3.3.4, we immediately obtain: Corollary 3.3.5
For all odd integers m 6= 1, we have
rZp (H 1 (GS , Zp (m))) − rZp (H 2 (GS , Zp (m))) = 1.
(3.4)
We also note the following lemma. Lemma 3.3.6 For all odd integers m 6= 1, the following assertions are equivalent: (i) H 2 (GS , Zp (m)) is finite, (ii) rZp (H 1 (GS , Zp (m))) = 1 and (iii) H 2 (GS , Dp (m)) = 0.
50
John Coates
Proof The equivalence of (i) and (ii) is immediate from (3.4). Taking GS -cohomology of the exact sequence 0 → Zp (m) → Qp (m) → Dp (m) → 0,
(3.5)
we obtain the exact sequence H 1 (GS , Dp (m)) → H 2 (GS , Zp (m)) → H 2 (GS , Qp (m)) → H 2 (GS , Dp (m)) → 0. Since Qp (m) is a vector space over Qp , so is H 2 (GS , Qp (m)), and hence it contains no non-zero Zp -torsion; in particular, the image of the torsion subgroup of H 2 (GS , Zp (m)) in it is zero. On the other hand, we know that H i (GS , Dp (m)) is a torsion abelian group for i = 1, 2. Thus, if we assume that, H 2 (GS , Zp (m)) is finite, it would follow from the above exact sequence that H 2 (GS , Qp (m)) must be torsion, and hence 0, whence also H 2 (GS , Dp (m)) = 0. Conversely, if H 2 (GS , Dp (m)) vanishes then H 2 (GS , Zp (m)) would have to map to onto H 2 (GS , Qp (m)), hence this latter group would have to be zero because no non-zero divisible group can be a finitely generated Zp -module. Hence the torsion group H 1 (GS , Dp (M )) would map onto H 2 (GS , Zp (m)), and so this latter group would have to be finite because it is a finitely generated Zp module. This completes the proof. Before proceeding further, we make a brief digression to discuss the relationship of the exact sequence (3.2) to the values of the p-adic analogue of the Riemann zeta function, using the so-called main conjecture of Iwasawa theory (which is not a conjecture at all, but a proven theorem in this case – for a full discussion of this theorem, and a more detailed explanation of the notions in what follows, see, for example, [CS06]). Let us denote the common value of the two Zp -ranks appearing in (3.3) by α(m − 1). When m = 1 it is easy to see that α(0) = 0. In fact, it is one of the standard conjectures on cyclotomic fields that α(m − 1) = 0 for all odd integers m, and, as we shall now explain, this is proven for odd m < 0, but unknown for odd m > 1. Indeed, since X∞ is a finitely generated torsion Λ(G)-module, the structure theorem for such modules enables us to define its characteristic ideal C(X∞ ) in Λ(G), which is a principal ideal. Let us write η for any generator of the ideal C(X∞ ). Recall that χ denotes the character giving the action of the absolute Galois group of Q on µp∞ , so that even powers of χ can be viewed as characters of G, and therefore define Zp -algebra homomorphism from
Zeta Values at the Odd Positive Integers and Iwasawa theory
51
Λ(G) to Zp . It is then not difficult to see that, for all odd integers m, α(m − 1) = 0 if and only if χ1−m (η) 6= 0.
(3.6)
On the other hand, the main conjecture gives an analytic version of this last statement. Let us write ρ for the p-adic analogue of the Riemann zeta function. Then ρ belongs to the fraction field of Λ(G), and has the property that (σ − 1)ρ belongs to Λ(G) for all σ in G. It is uniquely determined by the property that, for all odd integers m < 0, we have χ1−m (ρ) = (1 − p−m )ζ(m),
(3.7)
where ζ(s) denotes the classical complex Riemann zeta function. Let I(G) denote the kernel of the augmentation map from Λ(G) to Zp . Then the classical main conjecture is the assertion that C(X∞ ) = ρI(G).
(3.8)
Now ζ(m) 6= 0 for all odd integers m < 0. Hence, combining (3.6), (3.7) and (3.8), we have established: Proposition 3.3.7 Let m be any odd integer. Then α(m − 1) = 0 when m ≤ 1, and, when m > 1, we have α(m − 1) = 0 if and only if χ1−m (ρ) 6= 0. It is a folklore conjecture that χ1−m (ρ) 6= 0 for all odd integers m > 1, but no proof is known at present. Note also that, for any fixed odd integer m < 0, (3.3.7) shows that χ1−m (ρ) is a p-adic unit provided p is sufficiently large compared to |m|. It seems very reasonable to similarly conjecture that, for any fixed odd integer m > 1, χ1−m (ρ) is a p-adic unit provided p is sufficiently large compared to m. Again, nothing has been proven in this direction at present. However, the question of the possible truth of such a conjecture was first posed to me by Frank Adams many years ago, and more recently by Lars Hesselholt.
3.4 The comparison diagram We now compare (3.2) with a second fundamental exact sequence, arising from the Λ(G)-module which originally led Iwasawa to the main conjecp ture. Let ζr be a primitive pr+1 -th root of unity, such that ζr+1 = ζr −1 for all r ≥ 0. Then the elements cr = (1 − ζr )(1 − ζr ) in Φr are norm compatible, and so give rise to an element c∞ = (cr ) ∈ Ω∞ .
52
John Coates
We then define C∞ to be the ideal C∞ = Λ(G)c∞ in Ω∞ ' Λ(G), and introduce the Λ(G)-module Y∞ = Ω∞ /C∞ . In particular, for each odd integer m, we have the exact sequence of Λ(G)-modules 0 → C∞ (m − 1) → Ω∞ (m − 1) → Y∞ (m − 1) → 0. Since Ω∞ ' Λ(G), we have Ω∞ (m − 1)G = 0. Thus, as G has phomological dimension equal to 1, on taking G-homology we obtain the exact sequence 0 → Y∞ (m − 1)G → C∞ (m − 1)G → Ω∞ (m − 1)G → Y∞ (m − 1)G → 0. (3.9) By global class field theory, there is a Λ(G)-homomorphism δ ∞ : Y∞ → X ∞ ,
(3.10)
whose cokernel is Gal(L∞ /F∞ ), where L∞ denotes the maximal abelian p-extension of F∞ , which is everywhere unramified. Twisting m−1 times, where m is any odd integer, we obtain a homomorphism φ∞ : Y∞ (m − 1) → X∞ (m − 1),
(3.11)
which, in turn, gives rise to two Zp -homomorphisms G G φG ∞ : Y∞ (m − 1) → X∞ (m − 1) , φ∞,G : Y∞ (m − 1)G → X∞ (m − 1)G . (3.12) We can then compare the exact sequences (3.2) and (3.9), thanks to the following proposition.
Proposition 3.4.1 homomorphism
For each odd integer m 6= 1, there exists a Zp -
ψm : C∞ (m − 1)G → H 1 (GS , Zp (m))
(3.13)
such that we have the commutative diagram with exact rows 0 − → Y∞ (m − 1)G − → G φ∞ y
C∞ (m − 1)G ψm y
− → Ω∞ (m − 1)G − → =y
Y∞ (m − 1)G φ∞,G y
− → 0
λ
0 − → X∞ (m − 1)G − → H 1 (GS , Zp (m)) − → Ω∞ (m − 1)G − → X∞ (m − 1)G ,
where λ is the map appearing in the exact sequence (3.2). Proof For each integer r ≥ 0, let Fr = Q(µpr+1 )+ , and write Jr for the group of S-units of Fr . Put t J¯r = lim Jr /Jrp , J¯∞ = lim J¯r ,
←
←
Zeta Values at the Odd Positive Integers and Iwasawa theory
53
where the latter projective limit is taken with respect to the norm maps. Now Kummer theory gives a canonical isomorphism jr : J¯r → H 1 (GS , Zp (1)).
(3.14)
Define Z∞ = lim H 1 (GS (Fr ), Zp (1)), ←
where the projective limit is taken with respect to the co-restriction maps. Passing to the projective limit over r for the maps (3.14), we then obtain a canonical Λ(G)-isomorphism j∞ : J¯∞ → Z∞ .
(3.15)
Now, as the Galois group GS (F∞ ) acts trivially on Zp (m − 1), it is well known that there is a canonical Λ(G)-isomorphism Z∞ (m − 1) ' R∞ = lim H 1 (GS (Fr ), Zp (m)). ←
Thus, twisting the map (3.15) by the Tate module Zp (m − 1), we obtain a Λ(G)-isomorphism l∞ : J¯∞ (m − 1) → R∞ . The map ψ is derived from l∞ as follows. The natural injective map from C∞ (m − 1) to J¯∞ (m − 1) gives rise, on taking G-coinvariants, to a Zp -homomorphism (C∞ (m − 1))G → (J¯∞ (m − 1))G .
(3.16)
There is also the natural map (J¯∞ (m − 1))G → (R∞ )G → H 1 (GS , Zp (m)),
(3.17)
which is given by the composition of the map on G-coinvariants derived from l∞ with the map induced from the projection map from R∞ onto H 1 (GS , Zp (m)). Then ψm is given by composing the two maps (3.16) and (3.17). It can then be verified that this definition leads to the commutative diagram given in the proposition. This completes the proof. Corollary 3.4.2 H 2 (GS , Zp (m)).
For all odd integers m 6= 1, we have Coker(φ∞,G ) =
Proof This is immediate from the above diagram, and the fact that Coker(λ) = H 2 (GS , Zp (m)) by the exact sequence (3.2).
54
John Coates
We now invoke the main conjecture for the field F∞ to prove the following proposition. As above, let L∞ be the maximal unramified abelian p-extension of F∞ , and define W∞ = Gal(L∞ /F∞ ).
(3.18)
It is a finitely generated torsion Λ(G)-module, and so by the structure theory of such modules, it has a characteristic ideal, which is principal. We define θ to be any generator of the characteristic ideal of W∞ . Proposition 3.4.3 For all odd integers m 6= 1, the following assertions are equivalent: (i) H 2 (GS , Dp (m)) = 0, (ii) H 2 (GS , Zp (m)) is finite, (iii) 1−m Coker(φ∞,G ) is finite, (iv) Ker(φG (θ) 6= 0. ∞ ) = 0 and (v) χ Proof The equivalence of (i) and (ii) and (iii) is given by Lemma 3.3.6 and Corollary 3.4.2. Note also that G Ker(φG ∞ ) = (Ker(φ∞ )) , Coker(φ∞,G )
= (Coker(φ∞ ))G = W∞ (m − 1)G .
(3.19) (3.20)
Also, by Iwasawa’s explicit determination of the Λ(G)-module Y∞ (see [CS06]), it is clear that Y∞ has no non-zero finite Λ(G)-submodule, whence the same is also true for Y∞ (m−1) and its submodule Ker(φ∞ ). Hence we conclude that Ker(φG ∞ ) is zero if and only if it is finite. Now, by the main conjecture on cyclotomic fields, Y∞ and X∞ have the same characteristic ideal, which is given by (3.8), whence it follows by the multiplicativity of characteristic ideals in exact sequences that Ker(φ∞ ) and Coker(φ∞ ) = W∞ (m − 1) also have the same characteristic ideals. As both Ker(φ∞ ) and Coker(φ∞ ) are finitely generated torsion Λ(G)modules, their G-invariants and G-coinvariants have the same Zp -rank, and so it now follows easily that assertions (iii), (iv) and (v) are equivalent. Corollary 3.4.4 For all odd integers m < 0, the equivalent assertions of Proposition 3.4.3 are valid. This is immediate from the equation (3.7), and the fact that the characteristic element θ of the Λ(G)-module W∞ must divide the characteristic ρ of X∞ , again by the multiplicativity of characteristic ideals in exact sequences.
Zeta Values at the Odd Positive Integers and Iwasawa theory
55
3.5 Theorem of Soul´ e As has been explained in the article [Li15], Soul´e [So79] has deduced the following result from Borel’s theorem on the ranks of the higher Kgroups of Z, by proving that, for all odd integers m > 1, there is an isomorphism K2m−2 (Z) ⊗ Qp ' H 2 (GS , Zp (m)) ⊗ Qp . Theorem 3.5.1 is finite.
(Soul´ e) For all odd integers m > 1, H 2 (GS , Zp (m))
This result, together with Corollary 3.4.4, shows that the equivalent assertions of Proposition 3.4.3 hold for all odd integers m 6= 1. However, we stress that, in our present state of knowledge, no proof of Soul´e’s theorem has ever been found which uses only the Iwasawa theory of cyclotomic fields. At the same time, it should be pointed out that, in all known numerical examples to date, it has always been found that L∞ = F∞ , so that we can take θ = 1, and thus the equivalent assertions of Proposition 3.4.3 are certainly true. We assume for the remainder of this section that m 6= 1 is an odd integer, and we now establish the following basic result. Theorem 3.5.2
For all odd integers m 6= 1, the map ψm : C∞ (m − 1)G → H 1 (GS , Zp (m))
is injective, and has finite cokernel of the same order as H 2 (GS , Zp (m)). Proof Thanks to Soul´e’s theorem (when m > 1), and the main conjecture (when m < 0), we know that the equivalent assertions of Proposition 3.4.3 are valid for m. The injectivity of ψm then follows immediately from the comparison diagram in Proposition 3.4.1, on noting that φG ∞ is injective. Since ψm is injective, and H 1 (GS , Zp (m)) has Zp -rank 1, it is easy to see that the cokernel of ψm must be finite. However, as we shall now explain, it is more delicate to compute the exact order of this cokernel. We can break up the commutative diagram appearing in Proposition 3.4.1 into two separate commutative diagrams with exact rows 0 −−−−→ Y∞ (m − 1)G −−−−→ φG ∞y
C∞ (m − 1)G ψm y
−−−−→ A −−−−→ 0 βy
0 −−−−→ X∞ (m − 1)G −−−−→ H 1 (GS , Zp (m)) −−−−→ B −−−−→ 0 ,
56
John Coates
and 0 −−−−→ A −−−−→ Ω∞ (m − 1)G −−−−→ Y∞ (m − 1)G −−−−→ 0 =y τy βy 0 −−−−→ B −−−−→ Ω∞ (m − 1)G −−−−→
D
−−−−→ 0 .
Moreover, from the diagram in Proposition 3.4.1, it is clear that Ker(τ ) = Ker(φ∞,G ). Note that (Coker(φ∞ ))G is finite, since (Coker(φ∞ ))G is finite, whence we deduce easily that Coker(φG ∞ ) is also finite. Similarly, the finiteness of both (Ker(φ∞ ))G and (Coker(φ∞ ))G imply the finiteness of Ker(φ∞,G ). Hence we conclude from the above diagrams that #(Coker(ψm )) = #(Coker(φG ∞ ))#(Ker(φ∞,G )).
(3.21)
Recall that G = ∆ × Γ, where ∆ is a cyclic group of order (p − 1)/2, and Γ is isomorphic to the additive group of Zp . Moreover, the action of ∆ on a Zp -module is semisimple because it has order prime to p. Thus, as the main conjecture and Iwasawa’s theorem together show that Y∞ and X∞ have the same characteristic ideals as Λ(G)-modules, we can apply the purely algebraic Lemma 3.5.5 proven below to the Γ-homomorphism ∆ ∆ φ∆ ∞ : Y∞ (m − 1) → X∞ (m − 1) .
It follows that G #(Ker(φG ∞ ))/#(Coker(φ∞ )) = #(Ker(φ∞,G ))/#(Coker(φ∞,G )).
Hence the formula (3.21) can be rewritten as #(Coker(ψm )) = #(Coker(φ∞,G ))#(Ker(φG ∞ )).
(3.22)
But we have shown earlier (see Corollary 3.4.2 and Proposition 3.4.3) that 2 Ker(φG ∞ ) = 0, Coker(φ∞,G ) = H (GS , Zp (m)),
and so the proof of the theorem is complete. We now deduce an interesting corollary of this theorem. Let ω denote the Teichmuller character modulo p. For an even integer i, and a Zp [∆] i module U , we write U (ω ) for the eigenspace of U on which ∆ acts via ω i , where, as earlier, ∆ denotes the Galois group of the maximal real subfield of Q(µp ) over Q.
Zeta Values at the Odd Positive Integers and Iwasawa theory
57
Corollary 3.5.3 For all odd integers m 6= 1, the cokernel of the map ψm has the same order as the G-coinvariants of Gal(L∞ /F∞ )(m − 1), where L∞ denotes the maximal unramified abelian p-extension of F∞ . In particular, if p is an odd prime number such that H 2 (GS , Zp (m)) = 0 for some odd integer m 6= 1, then the ω1−m -component of the p-primary subgroup of the ideal class group of the maximal real subfield of Q(µp ) is zero. Proof We have shown above that H 2 (GS , Zp (m)) and Coker(φ∞,G ) have the same order. But Coker(φ∞,G ) = (W∞ (m − 1))G = (W∞ (ω
1−m
)
(m − 1))Γ ,
where, as before, W∞ = Gal(L∞ /F∞ ). Now a compact Λ(Γ) module is zero if and only if its Γ-coinvariants vanish. Hence the remaining assertion of the corollary follows from the well-known fact that (W∞ (ω
1−m
)
)Γ = A(ω
1−m
)
,
where A denotes the p-primary subgroup of the ideal class group of the maximal real subfield of Q(µp ). This completes the proof. For all odd integers m > 1, it is shown in [DF85] that there is a surjective homomorphism from K2m−2 (Z) ⊗ Zp onto H 2 (GS , Zp (m)). But by Borel’s generalization of Garland’s theorem, K2m−2 (Z) is a finite abelian group. Hence the above corollary implies the following result. Corollary 3.5.4 Let m be a fixed odd integer > 1. Then, for all sufficiently large prime numbers p, the ω 1−m -component of the p-primary subgroup of the ideal class group of the maximal real subfield of Q(µp ) is zero. Results of this kind are well known (see, for example [So99], where a very large lower bound in terms of m for such primes p is established). We remark that, in all known numerical examples, the class number of the maximal real subfield Q(µp )+ of Q(µp ) is prime to p, and this in turn implies that Gal(L∞ /F∞ ) = 0 for such primes p. Thus, at present, we do not know a single numerical example of an odd prime number p, and an odd integer m 6= 1, for which H 2 (GS , Zp (m)) 6= 0. We also remark that, if it is indeed true (see the question raised by Adams and Hesselholt discussed at the end of Section 3) that, for fixed
58
John Coates
odd m > 1, χ1−m (ρ) is a p-adic unit for all sufficiently large primes p (here, as earlier, ρ denotes the p-adic analogue of the Riemann-zeta function), then it would follow that the ω 1−m -component of the Galois group of the maximal abelian p-extension of Q(µp )+ unramified outside p is zero for all sufficiently large primes p. Finally, we establish the following purely algebraic lemma (see also [KNF96]), which was used in the proof of the last theorem. Let Γ = Zp , and, as usual, we identify the Iwasawa algebra of Γ with the ring of formal power series R = Zp [[T ]] by mapping some fixed topological generator of Γ to 1 +T . Let π : A → B be any R-homomorphism of finitely generated torsion R-modules. Write π Γ : AΓ → B Γ and πΓ : AΓ → BΓ for the maps induced by π. Note that, if A and B have the same characteristic ideals as R-modules, so also do Ker(π) and Coker(π), by the multiplicativity of characteristic ideals in exact sequences. Lemma 3.5.5 Assume that A and B are finitely generated torsion Rmodules, which have the same characteristic ideals. Suppose that we are given a homomorphism π : A → B such that a characteristic element of Ker(π), or equivalently a characteristic element of Coker(π), does not vanish at T = 0. Then both of the maps π Γ and πΓ have finite kernels and cokernels, and we have #(Ker(π Γ ))/#(Coker(π Γ )) = #(Ker(πΓ ))/#(Coker(πΓ )).
(3.23)
Proof Put D = Ker(π), and E = Coker(π). Since, by our hypotheses, D and E both have the same characteristic element which does not vanish at T = 0, a very well-known lemma asserts that #(DΓ )/#(DΓ ) = #(E Γ )/#(EΓ ),
(3.24)
where all the groups appearing in this formula are finite. Moreover, it is clear that Ker(π Γ ) = DΓ , Coker(πΓ ) = EΓ . Hence, in view of (3.24), we must show that Coker(π Γ ) and Ker(πΓ ) are both finite, and that #(DΓ )#(E Γ ) = #(Coker(π Γ ))#(Ker(πΓ )).
(3.25)
To establish this, we recall that, quite generally, if δ = β ◦ α is the composition of any two homomorphisms α and β of Zp -modules, then
Zeta Values at the Odd Positive Integers and Iwasawa theory
59
we always have the exact sequence 0 → Ker(α) → Ker(δ) → Ker(β) → Coker(α) → Coker(δ) → Coker(β) → 0.
(3.26)
Put I = Im(π), so that we clearly have π Γ = β1 ◦ α1 , πΓ = β2 ◦ α2 ,
(3.27)
where α1 : AΓ → I Γ , β1 : I Γ → B Γ , α2 : AΓ → IΓ , β2 : IΓ → BΓ are the natural maps. These fit into the exact sequences of Γ-homology given by α1 α2 AΓ −−−− → I Γ −−−−→ DΓ −−−−→ AΓ −−−− → IΓ −−−−→ 0, (3.28)
and β1 β2 0 −−−−→ I Γ −−−−→ B Γ −−−−→ EΓ −−−−→ IΓ −−−−→ BΓ . (3.29)
Since β1 is injective, we obtain from (3.26) the exact sequence 0 → Coker(α1 ) → Coker(π Γ ) → Coker(β1 ) → 0,
(3.30)
and since α2 is surjective, (3.26) gives the exact sequence 0 → Ker(α2 ) → Ker(πΓ ) → Ker(β2 ) → 0.
(3.31)
The desired finiteness of Coker(π Γ ) and Ker(πΓ ) follows immediately from (3.28), (3.29), (3.30) and (3.31), as also does (3.25) on computing orders using these exact sequences. This completes the proof.
3.6 The Bloch–Kato conjecture We assume from now on that m is always an odd integer such that m > 1. We begin by giving a slightly more explicit description of the cokernel of the map ψm defined by (3.13). We know that H 1 (GS , Zp (m)) has rank 1 as a Zp -module, but in fact it is a free Zp -module of rank 1. Indeed, taking GS -cohomology of the exact sequence (3.5), we see immediately that the torsion subgroup of H 1 (GS , Zp (m)) is equal to H 0 (GS , Dp (m)), and this latter group is zero because m is odd and p is odd. Recall that C∞ is the free Λ(G)-module of rank 1, which is generated
60
John Coates
by the element c∞ = (cr ), where cr = (1 − ζr )(1 − ζr−1 ); here ζr denotes p a primitive pr+1 -th root of unity satisfying ζr+1 = ζr for all r ≥ 0. For each r ≥ 0, let Cr be the group of cyclotomic units in Fr generated by ⊗(m−1) cr and its conjugates over Q. We write µpr+1 for the (m − 1)-th fold tensor product of µpr+1 with itself, endowed with the diagonal action of G (of course, G acts on it because m − 1 is even). We can then define the element c∞ (m − 1) = (cr ⊗ ζr ⊗ . . . ⊗ ζr )r , which belongs to ⊗(m−1)
C∞ (m − 1) = lim (Cr ⊗ µpr+1 ←
),
with the projective limit being taken with respect to the norm maps. It is easily seen that, in fact, we have C∞ (m − 1) = Λ(G)c∞ (m − 1). Let c∞^ (m − 1) denote the image of c∞ (m − 1) in (C∞ (m − 1))G , and define the Soul´e element sm,p by sm,p = ψm (c∞^ (m − 1)).
(3.32)
Since (C∞ (m − 1))G is a free Zp -module of rank 1, we see that Theorem 3.5.2 can be rewritten in the following equivalent form: Theorem 3.6.1 For each odd integer m > 1, let sm,p be the Soul´e element defined by (3.32). Then sm,p 6= 0, and the index of Zp sm,p in the free Zp -module of rank 1 given by H 1 (GS , Zp (m)) is equal to the order of H 2 (GS , Zp (m)). To proceed further, we need Conjecture 6.2 of [BK90], which is proven in the articles [Hu15], [Ki15] in this volume. By Borel’s theorem, K2m−1 (Z) is a finitely generated abelian group of rank 1. For each odd integer m > 1, and for each odd prime number p, let λm,p : K2m−1 (Z) ⊗ Qp → H 1 (GS , Qp (m))
(3.33)
be Soul´e’s Chern class isomorphism. Note that the natural map from H 1 (GS , Zp (m)) to H 1 (GS , Qp (m)) is injective because m is odd and p is odd, and so we can view the Soul´e elements sm,p as lying in H 1 (GS , Qp (m)). Let r∞ : K2m−1 (Z) ⊗ Q → R
(3.34)
be Beilinson’s regulator map defined in [Hu15]. The following result,
Zeta Values at the Odd Positive Integers and Iwasawa theory
61
which is absolutely crucial for the rest of our argument, is then proven in [Hu15] (see Corollary 11.7.2 of [Hu15]). Theorem 3.6.2 For each odd integer m > 1, there exists bm ∈ K2m−1 (Z) ⊗ Q, such that λm,p (bm ⊗ 1) = −(1 − pm−1 )−1 sm,p , and r∞ (bm ) = (m − 1)!ζ(m), (3.35) where ζ(s) denotes the Riemann zeta function. Now we know that K2m−1 (Z) is a finitely generated abelian group, which has rank 1 by Borel’s theorem because m > 1 is odd. Write K2m−1 (Z)tor for its torsion subgroup. Proposition 3.6.3
Let m > 1 be an odd integer. Then we have
r∞ (K2m−1 (Z)/K2m−1 (Z)tor ) = ((m − 1)!ζ(m)/θ(m))Z,
(3.36)
where θ(m) = 2a
Y
#(H 2 (GS , Zp (m))),
(3.37)
p>2
for some (unknown) integer a. Proof Let zm denote any generator of K2m−1 (Z)/K2m−1 (Z)tor . Then we know that there exist relatively prime integers u, v such that ubm = vzm . It follows immediately from the second equality in (3.35) that r∞ (K2m−1 (Z)/K2m−1 (Z)tor ) = ((m − 1)!ζ(m)u/v)Z. On the other hand, it is shown in [Li15] that the Chern class map from K2m−1 (Z) ⊗ Zp to H 1 (GS , Zp (m)) is surjective, and thus λm,p (zm ⊗ 1) must be a Zp -generator of H 1 (GS , Zp (m)), which is free of rank 1 over Zp . But λm,p (zm ⊗ 1) = λm,p (bm ⊗ 1)uv −1 = −(1 − pm−1 )−1 uv−1 sm,p . Note that (1−pm−1 )−1 is a p-adic unit since m > 1. We conclude immediately from Theorem 3.6.1 that the exact power of p occurring in the nonzero rational number v/u must be precisely the order of H 2 (GS , Zp (m)). In particular, it follows firstly that H 2 (GS , Zp (m)) is zero for all but a finite number of p, and secondly that v/u must be equal to θ(m) up to sign. This completes the proof. Q ˆ For an odd integer m > 1, put Z(m) = p≥2 Zp (m), and, following
62
John Coates
Bloch–Kato [BK90], define the Tamagawa measure of the motive Z(m) by the convergent infinite product T am(Z(m)) = µ∞ (R/r∞ (K2m−1 (Z)/K2m−1 (Z)tor )) Y ˆ µp (H 1 (Qp , Z(m)), p≥2
where the measures µp are defined in [BK90] section 4, and µ∞ arises from the usual measure on the real line. It is shown in ([BK90], Theorem 4.2), using the explicit reciprocity law of Bloch–Kato (see [Sa15] in this volume), that ˆ µp (H 1 (Qp , Z(m)) = (1 − p−m )|(m − 1)!|p #(H 0 (Qp , Qp /Zp (1 − m)). Note that, since the prime p is totally ramified in the fields obtained by adjoining p-power roots of unity to Q, we have Y #H 0 (Q, Q/Z(1 − m)) = #(H 0 (Qp , Qp /Zp (1 − m)). p≥2
Combining these results with Theorem (3.6.2), we immediately deduce the following result: Proposition 3.6.4
For every odd integer m > 1, we have Y T am(Z(m)) = #H 0 (Q, Q/Z(1 − m))/(2a #(H 2 (GS , Zp (m))), p>2
for some integer a. To complete the proof of the Bloch–Kato conjecture for Z(m), we only have to relate the group H 2 (GS , Zp (m)) to the analogue of the Tate– Shafarevich group for Z(m), as defined in section 5 of [BK90]. We write X(m) for this Tate-Shafarevich group of Z(m). Lemma 3.6.5 For every odd integer m > 1, and every odd prime p, the p-primary subgroup of the Tate–Shafarevich group X(m) of Z(m) is finite, and its order is equal to the order of H 2 (GS , Zp (m)). Proof We only sketch the argument. The essential point is that Theorem 10.1.1 shows that the p-primary part of the Tate–Shafarevich group of the motive Z(1 − m) is equal to the dual of the finite group H 2 (GS , Zp (m)). We then invoke a Theorem of Flach [Fo82], which proves that there is a dual pairing between the p-primary subgroups of the Tate–Shafarevich group of the motives Z(m) and Z(1 − m).
Zeta Values at the Odd Positive Integers and Iwasawa theory
63
We also remark that, while for simplicity we have always assumed that p is an odd prime, a similar argument to the above, but involving only Galois cohomology and Iwasawa theory, also enables one to show that, for all odd integers m > 1, the 2-primary subgroup of the Tate– Shafarevich group of X(m) is finite. Hence, combining the last lemma and proposition, we finally obtain the following result, which is the original Bloch–Kato conjecture for the values of the Riemann zeta function at the odd positive integers > 1. Theorem 3.6.6 For every odd integer m > 1, the Tate–Shafarevich group of the motive Z(m) is finite, and T am(Z(m)) = #(H 0 (Q, Q/Z(1 − m))2b /#(X(m)), for some (unknown) integer b.
References [BK90] Bloch, S., and Kato, K. 1990. Tamagawa numbers of motives. The Grothendieck Festschrift Volume 1. Progress in Mathematics, 86, 333– 400. [CS06] Coates, J., and Sujatha, R. 2006. Cyclotomic fields and zeta values. Monographs in Mathematics, Springer. [DF85] Dwyer, W., and Friedlander, E. 1982. Etale K-theory and arithmetic. Bulletin Amer. Math. Soc., 6 (1982), 453–455. [Fo82] Flach, M. 1990. A generalisation of the Cassels-Tate pairing. J. Reine Angew. Math., 412, 113–127. [Hu15] Huber, A. 2015. The comparison theorem for the Soule-Deligne classes, in The Bloch-Kato Conjecture for the Riemann Zeta Function, LMS Lecture Note Series 418. Cambridge University Press. 210–238. [Iw73] Iwasawa, K. 1973. On Zl -extensions of algebraic number fields. Annals Math., 98, 246–326. [Ki15] Kings, G. 2015. The l-adic realisation of the elliptic polylogarithm and the evaluation of Eisenstein classes, in The Bloch-Kato Conjecture for the Riemann Zeta Function, LMS Lecture Note Series 418. Cambridge University Press. 239–296. [KNF96] Kolster, M., Nguyen Quang Do, T., and Fleckinger, V. 1996. Twisted S-units, p-adic class number formulas, and the Lichtenbaum conjectures. Duke Math. J., 84, 679–717. [Li15] Lichtenbaum, S. 2015. Soule’s theorem, in The Bloch-Kato Conjecture for the Riemann Zeta Function, LMS Lecture Note Series 418. Cambridge University Press. 130–139.
64
John Coates
[Ng15] Nguyen Quang Do, T. 2015. On the determinental approach to the Tamagawa number conjecture, in The Bloch-Kato Conjecture for the Riemann Zeta Function, LMS Lecture Note Series 418. Cambridge University Press. 154–192. [Sa15] Saikia, A. 2015. Explicit reciprocity law of Bloch-Kato and exponential maps, in The Bloch-Kato Conjecture for the Riemann Zeta Function, LMS Lecture Note Series 418. Cambridge University Press. 65–96. [So79] Soul´ e, C. 1979. K-theorie des anneaux d’entiers de corps de nombres et cohomologie etale. Inventiones Math., 55, 251–295. [So99] Soul´ e, C. 1999. Perfect forms and the Vandiver conjecture. J. Reine Angew. Math., 517, 209–221. [Ta76] Tate, J. 1976. Relations between K2 and Galois cohomology. Inventiones Math., 36, 257–274.
4 Explicit Reciprocity Law of Bloch–Kato and Exponential Maps Anupam Saikia
Abstract The first goal of this expository article is to give a detailed proof of Bloch–Kato’s reciprocity law in (theorem 2.1 in [BK90]) in the simplest case, where it follows from the classical reciprocity law. The second goal is to explain Bloch–Kato’s exponential and dual exponential maps, providing the background material of Fontaine’s theory of p-adic representations. Thirdly, we show how we can compute the image of the Soul´e– Deligne cyclotomic elements under the dual exponential map (theorem 3.2.6 in [HK03]). The purpose of this article is to provide a self-contained and transparent account of some of the key ingredients required in the proof of the Bloch–Kato conjecture for the Riemann zeta function.
4.1 Introduction Bloch–Kato’s explicit reciprocity law is a crucial ingredient in their work on Tamagawa number of motives ([BK90]). Their reciprocity law can be viewed as an extension of the classical explicit reciprocity law. In the second section of this article we are going to review the classical explicit reciprocity law due to Iwasawa. In the third section we introduce Fontaine’s theory of p-adic representations, which is essential for understanding Bloch–Kato’s explicit reciprocity law as well as the exponential maps of Kato. In the fourth section, we explain how Bloch–Kato’s reciIndian Institute of Technology Guwahati, India. e-mail :
[email protected]
66
Anupam Saikia
procity law in the simplest case can be proved from the classical explicit reciprocity law. In the final section, we discuss Bloch–Kato’s exponential and dual exponential maps. In particular we look into the image of Soul´e–Deligne cyclotomic elements under the dual exponential map (cf. theorem 3.2.6 of [HK03]). In order to make the material accessible to beginners, we provide the explicit details throughout the article.
4.2 The classical explicit reciprocity law Let p be an odd prime and µpn be the group of all pn -th roots of unity. Let L be a finite extension of Qp containing µpn and L denote an algebraic closure of L and GL denote the Galois group Gal(L/L). The surjective n × × map x 7→ xp from L to L results in the Kummer sequence × pn
×
0 −→ µpn −→ L −→ L −→ 0. From the Galois cohomology sequence of the above, we obtain n
κ
×
0 −→ L× /(L× )p −→ H 1 (GL , µpn ) −→ H 1 (GL , L ) = 0, where κ is the Kummer map sending given by 1 σ−1 a 7−→ κ(a) : σ 7→ a pn . Let Lab denote the maximal abelian extension of L in its algebraic closure L. The Kummer map gives rise to a pairing known as the Kummer pairing given by pn 1 σ−1 < , >n : L× / L× × Gal(Lab /L) −→ µpn , < α, σ >n = α pn . On the other hand, we have the reciprocity map of local class field theory (see chapter VI, [CF67]) given by b7→σb =(b,Lab /L)
L× −−−−−−−−−−−−−−−→ Gal(Lab /L). It is well known that Lab is the composite of the maximal unramfied extension Lur of L and the totally ramified Lubin Tate division tower S L∞ = L(Wπn ), where Wπn denotes all the [π]n -torsion points of the n
Lubin–Tate formal group associated with the local parameter π of L. For any b = uπ n ∈ L× , σb acts as the n-th power of the Frobenius on Lur and as the automorphism [u]−1 π associated with the Lubin–Tate group
Explicit Reciprocity Law of Bloch–Kato and Exponential Maps 67 on Wπn (loc. cit.). We refer to σb as the Artin symbol. The Kummer pairing can be interpreted as a pairing h , in :
L× / L×
pn
× L× −→ µpn ,
hα, βin =
1
α pn
σβ −1
.
The Kummer pairing behaves well in the cyclotomic tower of Qp , and the classical explicit reciprocity law describes it analytically. Before stating this law, let us fix certain notation. For each n ≥ 1, let ε(n) = ζpn denote a primitive pn -th root of unity such that ζppn+1 = ζpn . Let Kn = Qp (ζpn ),
B∞ := lim Kn× , ←−
K∞ =
[
n
Kn ,
U∞ := lim U , ←− n n
n
(4.1) where Un denotes the principal units in Kn . Let α ∈ Un ,
β = (βn ) ∈ B∞
NKn+1 /Kn βn+1 = βn ∀n ≥ 1 .
Let us define [α, β]n ∈ Zp /pn Zp by [α,β]n
ζpn
= hα, βin =
1
α pn
σβ −1
.
(4.2)
The classical explicit reciprocity law due to Iwasawa (see [Iw86] or chapter I of [Sh87]) can be stated as [α, β]n = p−n T rKn /Qp log(α) gβ0 /gβ (ζpn − 1) mod pn .
(4.3)
Here, gβ denotes the Coleman power series in T v(β) Zp [[T ]]× associated with β such that gβ (ζpn − 1) = βn ∀n ≥ 1. (v(β) denotes the normalized p-adic valuation of β.) We discuss Bloch and Kato’s generalization to crystalline and De Rham representations. Starting with the ‘fundamental exact sequence’ in Fontaine’s ring of + periods Bcris , one can construct a canonical class in H 1 (Qp , Qp (r)), and Bloch–Kato’s reciprocity law identifies this class essentially as the r-th Coates–Wiles homomorphism. Their work has been vastly generalized by Kato, Tsuji and others.
68
Anupam Saikia
4.3 Fontaine’s rings: Bcris and BdR In this section, we will cover the basic tools that we need from the theory of p-adic representations. For an elegant and comprehensive account, see [FO] or [BC09]. Let K be a finite extension of Qp , GK = Gal(K/K) and V be a p-adic representation, i.e., a finite dimensional Qp vector space with a continuous linear action . of GK . Let χ denote the cyclotomic character given by χ : GK −→ Z× p,
χ(σ)
σ(ζpn ) = ζpn .
For a p-adic representation and r ∈ Z, V (r) will denote the p-adic representation with the same underlying space V with the Galois action ? given by g ? v = χr (g)g.v
∀v ∈ V.
We will be mostly interested in V = Qp (r) in this article. Fontaine’s idea of studying p-adic representations was to construct rings of periods, which are topological Qp -algebras B, with a continuous linear action of GK such that B GK is a field, with some additional structures (e.g., a Frobenius φ, a filtration Fil etc) such that the B GK -module DB (V ) = B ⊗Qp V
GK
,
which inherits the additional structures, is a useful invariant of V . One can show that (theorem 5.2.1, [BC09]) dimBK G DB (V ) ≤ d = dimQ (V ). p
(4.4)
Definition 4.3.1 The p-adic representation V is called B-admissible if equality holds in (4.4). Equivalently, V is B-admissible if we have an isomorphism of GK -modules B ⊗Qp V ∼ = Bd. The canonical B-linear GK -equivariant map αV : B ⊗B GK DB (V ) −→ B ⊗BGK (B ⊗BGK V ) = (B ⊗B GK B) ⊗Qp V −→ B ⊗Qp V can be shown to be an isomorphism if and only if V is B-admissible (loc. cit.).
Explicit Reciprocity Law of Bloch–Kato and Exponential Maps 69 The coefficients of a matrix of the above isomorphism αV in two bases of DB (V ) and V are called the periods of V . Two natural choices for B c in p-adic are the algebraic closure K = Q and its completion C = Q p
p
p
topology. But V is K admissible if and only if the action of GK on V factors through a finite quotient, and V is Cp -admissible if and only if the action of inertia subgroup IK on V factors through a finite quotient (§I.2.3 in [Be04]). For example, Qp (r) is not Cp -admissible: DCp (Qp (r)) = Cp ⊗Qp Qp (r)
GK
= H 0 (GK , Cp (r)) = 0
∀r 6= 0,
by a result of Sen–Tate (theorem 4.5.1). Two of the most useful rings of periods are Bcris and BdR . For construction of these rings, we need the theory of Witt vectors.
4.3.1 Witt vectors For this subsection, an ideal reference is chapter II of [Se79]. Let R be a perfect ring of characteristic p, i.e., the Frobenius ring-endomorphism φ : x 7→ xp is bijective. Then there exists a unique (up to isomorphism) ring W (R) in which p is not nilpotent, which is separated and complete for the topology defined by pn W (R) with R as residue ring. W (R) is called the ring of Witt vectors over R. There is a unique system of representatives [ ] : R → W (R),
−n
n
[y] = lim yˆnp where yˆn ≡ y p n→∞
modulo p
satisfying [yz] = [y][z]. The representative [y] of y ∈ R is called the Teichmuller representative. Any element x of W (R) can be uniquely written as ∞ X x= pn [xn ], xn ∈ R. n=0
There exist polynomials Sn and Zn in variables x0 , y0 , . . . , xn , yn with integral coefficients such that ∞ X
pn [xn ]+
n=0
∞ X
pn [yn ] =
n=0
∞ X
pn [sn ],
n=0
∞ X n=0
pn [xn ].
∞ X
pn [yn ] =
n=0
∞ X
pn [zn ],
n=0
with 1 n
1 n
sn = Sn (x0p , y0p , . . . , xn , yn ),
1 n
1 n
zn = Zn (x0p , y0p , . . . , xn , yn ),
70
Anupam Saikia
and Sn , Zn are given by wpn (S0 , . . . , Sn ) = wpn (X0 , . . . , Xn ) + wpn (Y0 , . . . , Yn ), wpn (Z0 , . . . , Zn ) = wpn (X0 , . . . , Xn ) . wpn (Y0 , . . . , Yn ), where n
wpn ((X0 , . . . , Xn ) = X0p + . . . + pn Xn .
For example, if R = Fp , then W (R) = Zp . If R = k = Fq is the finite field of q = pf elements, then W (R) is the ring of integers of the unique unramified extension of degree f over Qp . If R = Fp , then W (R) = OQd nr . p
The construction of W (R) is functorial, thus any homomorphism f : R −→ R0 of perfect rings of characteristic p can be lifted to a homomorphism W (f ) : W (R) −→ W (R0 ) so that W (f )
∞ X
pn [xn ]
n=0
=
∞ X
pn [f (xn )].
n=0
In particular, one can lift the Frobenius automorphism φ : R → R, x 7→ xp to an automorphism (also denoted by) φ : W (R) −→ W (R). Proposition 4.3.2 The elements of W (R) satisfying φ(α) = αp are precisely the Teichmuller representatives [a], a ∈ R. P∞ Proof: Let us consider any element α = n=0 pn [an ] in W (R). We will show that a1 = a2 = · · · = 0: φ(α) = αp =⇒
∞ X
pn [apn ] = [a0 ]p + p2 [a0 ][a1 ] + · · ·
n=0
=⇒ [ap0 ] + p[ap1 ] ≡ [a0 ]p modulo p2 , =⇒ ap1 = 0 =⇒ a1 = 0. Similarly, we can show that a2 = a3 = · · · are all 0.
4.3.2 Witt vectors over perfection of OQp /pOQp The ring OQp /pOQp is not perfect as the Frobenius endomorphism is not an automorphism. But we can construct a perfect ring out of it as
Explicit Reciprocity Law of Bloch–Kato and Exponential Maps 71 follows. Consider xpi = xi−1 .
R = lim OQp /pOQp = (x0 , x1 , · · · ) | xi ∈ OQp /pOQp , ←− x7→xp
The Frobenius endomorphism R −→ R, x 7→ xp is clearly bijective: x = (x0 , x1 , · · · , xn , xn+1 , · · · ) = (x1 , · · · , xn , xn+1 , · · · )p , xp = 0 =⇒ (xp0 , x0 , x1 , · · · ) = (0, 0, · · · ) =⇒ x = 0. Hence R is a perfect ring of characteristic p. We have another useful description of R. Let x ˆi be any representative of xi in OQp , and define n
x(i) = lim x ˆp ∈ OCp . −→ i+n n
n
The above limit exists in OCp as it is easily seen that the sequence (ˆ xpi+n ) is Cauchy: k
k
n+k
n
x ˆpi+n+k ≡ xpn+i+k ≡ xi+n ≡ x ˆi+n mod p =⇒ x ˆpi+n+k ≡ x ˆpi+n mod pn+1 The association x = (x0 , x1 , . . .) 7→ (x(0) , x(1) , . . .) identifies R as a subp set of all infinite sequences in OCp such that x(i) = x(i−1) . Thus, we can also write R = lim OCp . ←− x7→xp
Observe that k
k
x ˆpi+k ≡ xpi+k ≡ xi ≡ x ˆi mod p =⇒ x(i) ≡ x ˆi ≡ xi mod p. We can define addition and multiplication in R in the new representation as follows. For x = (x(i) ) and y = (y (i) ), we must have pn
n
n
= lim x ˆp . lim yˆp = x(i) .y (i) , n→∞ i+n n→∞ i+n pn \ = lim xi+n + yi+n . n→∞ pn = lim x ˆi+n + yˆi+n .
(x.y)(i) = lim xi+n \ .yi+n n→∞
(x + y)(i)
n→∞
Note that x ˆi+n + yˆi+n ≡ x(i+n) + y (i+n) mod p pn pn =⇒ x ˆi+n + yˆi+n ≡ x(i+n) + y (i+n) mod pn+1 n p pn =⇒ lim x ˆi+n + yˆi+n = lim x(i+n) + y (i+n) n→∞ n→∞ pn (i) =⇒ (x + y) = lim x(i+n) + y (i+n) . n→∞
72
Anupam Saikia
We can define a valuation on R by setting vR (x) = vp (x(0) ), where vp is the p-adic valuation normalized by vp (p) = 1. Then R is a complete valuation ring, whose residue field is Fp . There is a canonical element ε = (ε(0) = 1, ε(1) = ζp , ε(2) = ζp2 , · · · ) ∈ R. The canonical surjective map x(i) → 7 x(0) mod p
θ : R → OCp /pOCp ,
is a homomorphism. By functoriality of Witt construction, we have a (homomorphism) lift θ : W (R) OCp ,
∞ X
pn [xn ] 7→
n=0
∞ X
pn x(0) n .
n=0
Let us denote the kernel of θ by J. Then it can be shown that J is P∞ principal ideal of W (R), generated by any α = n=0 pn [an ] for which (0) θ(α) = 0 and vp (a0 ) = 1 (proposition 2.4 in [Fo82]). In particular, we can take ω = [˜ p] − p
where
1
1
p˜ = (p, p p , p p2 , · · · ) ∈ R
(4.5)
as a generator of J. Observe that [ε] − 1 ∈ J as θ([ε] − 1) = ε(0) − 1 = 0. The Frobenius of W (R) preserves J + pW (R) but not J: φ(β) ≡ β p mod pW (R),
θ(β p ) = θ(β)p = 0 ∀β ∈ J, 1
φ(ω) = φ([˜ p] − p) = [˜ pp ] − p = [(pp , p, p p , · · · )] − p =⇒ θ(φ(ω)) = pp − p 6= 0. The Galois group acts by functoriality on R and W (R) and commutes with φ and θ. Proposition 4.3.3 θφ−n ([ε]) = ζpn .
For a ∈ R, θφ−n ([a]) = a(n) . In particular,
Proof: Observe that for x ∈ R, φ−n (x)(m) = x(n+m) . + 4.3.3 The rings BdR and BdR
Consider W (R)
h1i p
=
n X k>>−∞
o pk [xk ] | xk ∈ R .
Explicit Reciprocity Law of Bloch–Kato and Exponential Maps 73 The homomorphism θ : W (R) OCp can be extended to a homomorphism h1i X X (0) θQ : W (R) −→ Cp , pk [xk ] 7−→ pk xk . p k>>−∞
k>>−∞
+ The ring BdR is defined as + BdR = lim W (R) ←− n
h1i /(ker(θQ ))n . p
It is a complete discrete valuation ring with residue field Cp , and any gen+ erator of ker(θQ ) is a uniformizer in BdR (proposition h4.4.6 i in [BC09]). T + One can show that (ker(θQ ))j = {0}, hence W (R) 1p ⊂ BdR (loc. cit.). As ker(θQ ) = (ω), we can write + BdR
=
∞ nX
h 1 io yn ωn | yn ∈ W (R) . p n=0
Period t for the cyclotomic character: We now construct a + very useful element in the ring BdR which not only acts as a period for the cyclotomic character but also gives a filtration. Note that as θQ ([ε] − 1) = 0, the series ∞ X (−1)n−1 ([ε] − 1)n n n=1 + converges in BdR . We denote the sum of this convergent series by t. We can think of t as log([ε]). If σ ∈ GK , we now have
σ(t) = σ(log([ε])) = log([σ(1, ε(1) , · · · )]) = log([ε]χ(σ) ) = χ(σ) log([ε]) = χ(σ)t so t is a period for the cyclotomic character (see [BC09] p.61). It is the + p-adic analogue of 2πi ∈ C. Though exp(t) = [ε] 6= 1 ∈ BdR , θ([ε]) = 1 ∈ Cp . One can show that t is in fact a generator of the maximal ideal + in BdR . All we need is to check that [ε] − 1 ∈ W (R)ω − W (R)ω2 . But vp ([ε] − 1) = vp (ε − 1) = vp lim (ε(j) − 1)
pj
j→∞
pj = vp lim (ζpj − 1) = j→∞
p < 2. p−1
74
Anupam Saikia
Definition 4.3.4
We define the ring BdR as h i + 1 BdR = BdR . t
BdR is clearly a field endowed with a decreasing filtration defined by + i Fili BdR = BdR = ti BdR
∀i ∈ Z.
+ 0 In this notation, Fil0 BdR = BdR = BdR .
We also have i+1 i BdR /BdR = Cp (i). GK + GK It can be deduced from theorem 4.5.2 that BdR = (BdR ) = K, so that
DdR (V ) = (BdR ⊗Qp V )GK is a natural filtered K-vector space, with filtration given by i i DdR (V ) = Fili (DdR V ) = H 0 (GK , BdR ⊗Qp V )
∀i ∈ Z.
Definition 4.3.5 We say V is de Rham if V is BdR -admissible, i.e., the dimension of V as a Qp -vector space equals the dimension of DdR (V ) as a K-vector space. In other words, V is called a de Rham representation if ∼
BdR ⊗Qp V → BdR ⊗K DdR (V ). For example, Qp (r) is a de Rham representation for any integer r. Sub-quotients, duals and tensor products of de Rham representations are also de Rham (see §II.6 in [BC09]).
+ 4.3.4 The rings Acris and Bcris + One shortcoming of BdR is that the Frobenius automorphism of W (R)[ 1p ] does not preserve ker(θQ ), so there is no natural extension of φ on BdR : 1
1
1
1
+ ∈ BdR [˜ p ]−p 1 1 + =⇒ φ = ∈ BdR , 1 [˜ p ] − p p [˜ p ]−p
θQ ([˜ p p ] − p) = p p − p 6= 0 =⇒ [˜ pp ] − p ∈ / JQ =⇒
But θQ ([˜ p] − p) = 0 =⇒
1 + ∈ / BdR . [˜ p] − p
1 p
Explicit Reciprocity Law of Bloch–Kato and Exponential Maps 75 + Therefore, we introduce an auxiliary subring A0cris ⊂ BdR that is φstable and gives rise to a large subring Bcris of BdR on which there is a natural φ-action. Define N nX
o ωn | N < ∞, an ∈ W (R) n! n=0 h ωm i h1i = W (R) ⊂ W (R) . m! m≥1 p
A0cris =
an
Observe that A0cris is closed under multiplication: ωm ωm (m + n)! ωm+n = ∈ A0cris . m! m! m!n! (m + n)! The subring A0cris is stable under the action of the Frobenius of W (R)
h i 1 p :
ωp φ(ω) = ω p + pη = p η + (p − 1)! p! p m ω ⇒ φ(ω m ) = pm η + (p − 1)! p! ω m pm h ωp i ω p m pm ⇒φ = η + (p − 1)! ∈ W (R) ⊂ A0cris as ∈ Z. m! m! p! p! m! Definition 4.3.6 i.e.,
We define Acris to be the p-adic completion of A0cris , Acris = lim A0 /pn A0cris . ←− cris n
Acris is p-adically separated and complete, and A0cris embeds in Acris . The Frobenius φ on A0cris extends by continuity to Acris . One can show + that Acris is a subring of BdR given by ∞ n X ωn + Acris = x ∈ BdR |x= xn , n! n=0
o xn → 0 in the p-adic topology of W (R) . We define + Bcris := Acris
∞ n X ωn + = x ∈ BdR |x= xn , p n! n=0
h1i
xn → 0 in the p-adic topology of W (R)
h 1 io p
.
76
Anupam Saikia
Observe that t = log([ε]) =
∞ ∞ X X (−1)n−1 ([ε] − 1)n ωn = (−1)n−1 (n − 1)!ξ n , n n! n=1 n=1
for some ξ ∈ W (R) with [ε] − 1 = ωξ ∈ ker(θ). In other words, the + cyclotomic period t ∈ BdR belongs to Acris . Definition 4.3.7 The crystalline period ring Bcris for K is defined as + 1 + 1 the GK -stable W (R)[ p1 ]-subalgebra Bcris [ t ] = Acris [ 1t ] inside BdR [t] = BdR . One can show (proposition 9.1.3 in [BC09]) that tp−1 ∈ pAcris , so inverting t makes p a unit, and hence the equality. The filtration on Bcris is i Fili Bcris = Bcris ∩ BdR = Bcris ∩ ti BdR ,
i ∈ Z.
+ The Frobenius φ extends to Bcris as well as Bcris , and
φ(t) = p.t.
(4.6)
The Galois action also carries over to Acris , and θ also extends to Acris . If K0 is the maximal totally unramified subfield of K, then h 1 iGK GK + GK + GK W (R) = K0 ⊂ (Bcris ) = K0 = Bcris ⊂ (BdR ) p GK = BdR = K. GK GK In particular, if K/Qp is unramified, then Bcris = BdR = K.
4.3.5 Ideals of Acris We noted that θ : W (R) → OCp can be extended to A0cris , and by continuity to Acris . Let Jcris denote the kernel of θ in Acris . The ideal Jcris is not principal, it is not even finitely generated. Its divided powers are the ideals ωr ωr+1 [r] Jcris = Acris , , ··· r ≥ 1. r! (r + 1)! We also define [r]
Jcris = {α ∈ Jcris | φ(α) ∈ pr Acris }.
Explicit Reciprocity Law of Bloch–Kato and Exponential Maps 77 For any β ∈ 1 + J, we can use the power series expansion of log(1 + x) to obtain log(β) =
∞ X
(−1)n−1 (n − 1)!
n=1
(β − 1)n [1] ∈ Jcris . n!
<1> Observe that log(β) is an element of Jcris as
φ(log(β)) = log(φ(β)) ≡ log(β p ) ≡ p log(β) mod pAcris =⇒ φ(log(β)) ∈ pAcris . Therefore we have the logarithm map log
<1> <1> log : 1 + J → Jcris , 1 + J ⊃ [ε]Zp −−−−−→ Zp .t = Zp (1) ⊂ Jcris . (4.7)
4.3.6 The fundamental commutative diagram The following commutative diagram will be crucial in our proof of the explicit reciprocity law:
p−φ
0 −−−−→ [ε]Zp −−−−→ 1 + J −−−−→ 1 + pW (R) −−−−→ 0 −1 logy logy yp log 1−p−1 φ
<1> 0 −−−−→ Zp (1) −−−−→ Jcris −−−−−→
Acris
−−−−→ 0
We will prove the exactness of the top row only; for the exactness of the bottom row, see theorem 6.24 of [FO]. Also note that the third vertical arrow maps 1 + pW (R) onto W (R). Let us first show the surjectivity of p − φ. If β ∈ W (R)× , then clearly β ∈ 1 + pW (R). Consider any element α = 1 + p[a1 ] + p2 [a2 ] + · · · in 1 + pW (R). We show that by successive approximation using the Teichmuller representation, we can find b1 , b2 , · · · ∈ R such that β = 1 + p[b1 ] + p2 [b2 ] + · · · ∈ 1 + pW (R) satisfies β p−φ = α. For the first p−φ
78
Anupam Saikia
approximation, (1 + p[b1 ] + p2 [b2 ] + · · · )p = (1 + p[b1 ] + p2 [b2 ] + · · · )φ (1 + p[a1 ] + p2 [a2 ] + · · · ) =⇒ 1 ≡ 1 + p[bp1 ] + p[a1 ] mod p2 W (R) =⇒ [bp1 ] = −[a1 ] mod pW (R) 1
=⇒ b1 = (−a1 ) p in R
(R is perfect).
Having chosen b1 , we can proceed to b2 , b3 etc. and obtain a preimage β of α in 1 + pW (R). To have a pre-image of α inside 1 + J, we pick a ∈ R such that θ(β) = a(0) , and then replace the preimage β ∈ 1 + pW (R) by β/[a]. Then θ(β/[a]) = 1 and β/[a] ∈ 1 + J. But (β/[a])p−φ = β p−φ = α. Let us now show the exactness at the middle term. If β ∈ 1 + J such that β p−φ = 1, then β = [b] for some b ∈ R by proposition 4.3.2. Now, θ(β) = 1 = b(0) , hence we must have b = [ε]y for some y ∈ Zp . There is a generalization of the bottom row for r ≥ 1 [(2.5.1) in [BK90])]. There exists an integer c(r) such that the following sequence is exact: 1−p−r φ
0 −→ p−c(r) Zp (r) −→ Jcris −−−−−→ Acris −→ 0.
By tensoring the above sequence with Qp , we obtain an exact sequence [(1.13) of [BK90]] 1−p−r φ
+ + 0 −→ Qp (r) −→ Jcris ⊗ Q = Filr Bcris −−−−−→ Bcris −→ 0. (4.8)
4.4 Explicit reciprocity law of Bloch and Kato Let K be a finite unramified extension of Qp . We now consider the connecting homomorphism ∂ r of GK -comohomology of the exact sequence (4.8) + ∂ r : K = H 0 (K, Bcris ) −→ H 1 (K, Qp (r)).
Bloch–Kato’s explicit reciprocity law gives a concrete description of the cohomology class ∂ r (a) in H 1 (K, Qp (r)) for a ∈ K. We first identify the cohomology group H 1 (K, Qp (r)) with a readily recognizable homomorphism group.
Explicit Reciprocity Law of Bloch–Kato and Exponential Maps 79
4.4.1 Description of H 1 (K, Qp (r)) Rather than just working with Qp , let us consider a finite unramified extension K of Qp and denote [ Kn = K(ζpn ), K∞ = Kn , Γ = Gal(K∞ /K), ∼
ab B∞ := lim Kn× −→ Gal(K∞ /K∞ ) = P∞ , U∞ = lim U , ←− ←− n n
n
where Un denotes the principal units of Kn . The notation in (4.1) is the special case of above with K = Qp . By local class field theory we can identify U∞ with the inertia subgroup of P∞ , and observe that ˆ with the trivial action of Γ. Then, P∞ /U∞ ∼ =Z H 1 (K∞ , Qp (r)) = Hom(P∞ , Qp (r)), ∼ Hom(Z, ˆ Qp (r)) = ∼ Qp (r). Hom(P∞ /U∞ , Qp (r)) = Moreover, 0 −→ U∞ −→ P∞ −→ P∞ /U∞ −→ 0 =⇒ 0 −→ Hom(P∞ /U∞ , Qp (r)) ∼ = Qp (r) −→ Hom(P∞ , Qp (r)) −→ Hom(U∞ , Qp (r)) → 0 res
=⇒ 0 −→ H 0 (Γ, Qp (r)) −→ HomΓ (P∞ , Qp (r)) −→ HomΓ (U∞ , Qp (r)) −→ H 1 (Γ, Qp (r)). We also have the inflation-restriction sequence of cohomology res
0 −→ H 1 (Γ, Qp (r)) −→ H 1 (K, Qp (r)) −→ H 1 (K∞ , Qp (r))Γ −→ H 2 (Γ, Qp (r)) = 0. Combining all these, we obtain res
H 1 (K, Qp (r)) −→ H 1 (K∞ , Qp (r))Γ ∼ = HomΓ (P∞ , Qp (r)) res
−→ HomΓ (U∞ , Qp (r)).
(4.9)
We further have H q (Γ, Qp (r)) = 0 for q ≥ 1 and r 6= 0, and both the restriction maps in (4.9) become isomorphisms. Therefore, ∼
H 1 (K, Qp (r)) −→ HomΓ (U∞ , Qp (r))
r 6= 0.
Next, we will show that the latter module has a canonical element coming from the Coates–Wiles homomorphism.
80
Anupam Saikia
4.4.2 The Coates–Wiles homomorphism φrCW for a positive integer r We have mentioned that for any β ∈ B∞ , there is a uniquely associated Coleman power series gβ (T ) ∈ T −v(β) OK [[T ]]× such that (see theorem 2.2 in [Sh87]) (φ−n gβ )(ζpn − 1) = βn ∀n ≥ 1. For u ∈ U∞ and a positive integer r, the r-th Coates–Wiles homomorphism is defined as (see §2 of [BK90]) φrCW : U∞ −→ K(r) = K ⊗ Q(r), d r u 7−→ (1 + T ) log gu (T ) |T =0 ⊗tr ∈ K ⊗ Q(r). dT It is often convenient to use the variable d d z = log(1 + T ) so that (1 + T ) = . (4.10) dT dz Then we can express d r g0 φrCW (u) = log gu (ez −1) |z=0 ⊗tr ∈ K⊗Q(r) = Res z −r u ⊗tr . dz gu Observe that guσ (T ) = gu ((1 + T )χ(σ) − 1) =⇒ φrCW (uσ ) = χr (σ)φrCW (u), and hence φrCW is a Γ-homomorphism from U∞ to K(r). By composing with the trace map T rK/Qp , we obtain a canonical element in HomΓ (U∞ , Qp (r)) = H 1 (K, Qp (r)).
4.4.3 The explicit reciprocity law The explicit reciprocity law of Bloch and Kato can be expressed as follows (cf. theorem 2.1 in [BK90] and §6 in [Sh95]): Theorem 4.4.1 Let K be a finite unramified extension of Qp for an odd prime p. Then the connecting homomorphism of the exact sequence (4.8) + ∂ r : K = H 0 (K, Bcris ) → H 1 (K, Qp (r)) = HomΓ (U∞ , Qp (r))
is given by ∂ r (a) = −
1 T rK/Qp (a.φrCW ) (r − 1))!
r ≥ 1.
Explicit Reciprocity Law of Bloch–Kato and Exponential Maps 81 In particular, if K = Qp , we have ∂ r (1) = −
1 φr . (r − 1))! CW
In the rest of this section, we will show that the above reciprocity law for r = 1 and K = Qp follows from the classical explicit reciprocity law. The proof for r ≥ 2 can be reduced to the case r = 1, but the reduction steps are quite technical, and will not be discussed in this article (see §8, 9 in [Sh95]). In the following, we will present a detailed proof of the above theorem (cf. [Sh95]). We will first show that it is enough to work with cohomology over K∞ , and then descend to Qp by taking the Γ-invariants in the following commutative diagram:
p−φ
0 −−−−→ [ε]Zp −−−−→ 1 + J −−−−→ 1 + pW (R) −−−−→ 0 −1 logy logy yp log 1−p−1 φ
<1> 0 −−−−→ Zp (1) −−−−→ Jcris −−−−−→
Acris
−−−−→ 0
Commutative Diagram: 1 Let T = [ε] − 1, and observe that Zp [[T]] ⊂ H 0 (K∞ , Acris ). As explained at the beginning of this section, we have H 1 (K∞ , Zp (1)) Hom(U∞ , Zp (1)). Restricting the connecting homomorphism of GK∞ cohomology of the bottom row to Zp [[T]], we obtain a continuous pairing of Γ-modules ∂ 1 : Zp [[T]] × U∞ → Zp (1),
∂ 1 (f (T)), u) = ∂ 1 (f (T))(u).
Proposition 4.4.2 ∂ 1 (f (T), u) = −Res
1 g 0 (T ) f (T ) u ⊗ t. log(1 + T ) gu (T )
The above proposition can be regarded as key to the reciprocity law of Bloch and Kato. We have ∂1
+ (H 0 (K∞ , Bcris ))Γ −−−−→ H 1 (K∞ , Qp (1))Γ
+ H 0 (Qp , Bcris )
∂1
−−−−→ H 1 (Qp , Qp (1)),
82
Anupam Saikia
where the second equality comes from the inflation-restriction sequence 0 −→ H 1 (K∞ /Qp , Qp (1)) = 0 −→ H 1 (Qp , Qp (1)) −→ H 1 (K∞ , Qp (1))Γ −→ H 2 (K∞ /Qp , Qp (1)) = 0. By taking α(T) = 1, we can deduce from the proposition that 1 d ∂ 1 (1)(u) = ∂ 1 (1, u) = −Res log gu (T ) ⊗ t = −φ1CW (u). log(1 + T ) dT
4.4.4 Proof of the key proposition 4.4.2 For u ∈ U∞ , consider the local Artin symbol σu ∈ GK∞ ab /K . We want ∞ to determine how the cocycle corresponding to the image of an element α ∈ H 0 (K∞ , 1 + pW (R)) under the connecting homomorphism of the top row of the commutative diagram 1 acts on σu . Pick β ∈ 1 + J such that β p−φ = α in the top row. As (β σu −1 )p−φ = ασu −1 = 1, we must have β σu −1 = [a] for some a ∈ R by proposition (4.3.2). But θ(β) = 1 implies that a(0) = 1, and hence β σu −1 = [ε](α,u)
for some (α, u) ∈ Zp .
(4.11)
Then, the connecting homomorphism of the GK∞ -cohomology of the top row sends α to the cocycle σu 7→ β σu −1 = [ε](α,u) . Thus, we have α7→(σu 7→β σu −1 =[ε](α,u) )
H 0 (K∞ , 1 + pW (R)) −−−−−−−−−−−−−−−−→ H 1 (K∞ , [ε]Zp ) p−1 logy [ε](α,u) 7→log([ε](α,u) )=(α,u)⊗tylog H 0 (K∞ , Acris )
∂1
−−−−→
H 1 (K∞ , Zp (1)),
and ∂ 1 (p−1 log(α), u)) = ∂ 1 (p−1 log(α))(u) = log([ε](α,u) ) = (α, u) ⊗ t.
(4.12)
We will now relate (α, u) to the logarithmic derivative of the Coleman power series of u using the classical explicit reciprocity law. Lemma 4.4.3 (α, u) = p−n T rKn /Qp log(α(n) )(gu0 /gu ) (ζpn − 1) mod pn . Proof: Applying θφ−n in the definition (4.11) of (α, u), we obtain (α,u)
θφ−n (β σu −1 ) = θφ−n [ε](α,u) = ζpn
[see lemma 4.3.3].
(4.13)
Explicit Reciprocity Law of Bloch–Kato and Exponential Maps 83 Next, we compute θφ−n (β σu −1 ) using Kummer theory. As β p−φ = α we have βp
n
−φn
n−1
= αp
+pn−2 φ+···+φn−1
. n
Now apply θφ−n on both sides and observe that θφ−n (β φ ) = θ(β) = 1 as β ∈ 1 + J. Therefore, n
n−1
θφ−n (β)p = θφ−n (α)p
n−2
. · · · . θφ−1 (α).
. θφ1−n (α)p
Now take α = α(T) ∈ 1 + pZp [[T]]. As θφ−n ([ε] − 1) = ζpn − 1, we have θφ−n α(T) = α(ζpn − 1). Therefore, n
θφ−n (β)p
n−1
n−2
= α(ζpn − 1)p
. α(ζpn −1 − 1)p
. · · · . α(ζp − 1) n−1
= α(ζpn − 1)α((1 + ζpn − 1)p − 1) . · · · α((1 + ζpn − 1)p
− 1).
Let us denote α(n) (T) = α(T)p
n−1
n−2
. α((1 + T)p − 1)p
n−1
. · · · . α((1 + T)p
− 1). (4.14)
Then, 1n θφ−n (β) = α(n) (ζpn − 1) p .
(4.15)
Therefore, θφ−n (β σu −1 ) = θφ−n (β)σu −1 1n σu −1 = α(n) (ζpn − 1) p [α(n) (ζpn −1),u]n
= ζpn (α,u)
=⇒ ζpn
−n
p
= ζpn
T rKn /Qp log(α
(n)
[by (4.15)]
[by (4.2)]
0 )(gu /gu ) (ζpn −1)
[by (4.13) and (4.3)].
Hence the lemma follows. We now simplify the right hand side of the above equality. Lemma 4.4.4
For n ≥ 1, we have
0 T rKn /Qp (log α(n) )(gu /gu ) (ζpn −1)=pn−1
P
0
0 (log α)(gu /gu ) (ζpi n −1)
Proof: For the Coleman power series gu (T ) of a norm compatible unit u, we have (§2.1 in [Sh87]) Y gu ((1 + T )p − 1) = gu ((1 + T )η − 1). η∈µp
84
Anupam Saikia
d We now take logarithm on both sides and apply the operator (1+T ) dT = d [see (4.10)] to obtain dz
p(gu0 /gu )(ζpm − 1) =
X
(gu0 /gu )(ζpm η − 1)
η∈µp
=
X
(gu0 /gu )(ξ − 1).
(4.16)
ξ p =ζpm
Now, computing the trace down one step at a time, we find that T rKn /Kn−1 (log(α(n) (ζpn −1 )(gu0 /gu )(ζpn − 1) X h = (pn−1 log α(ξ − 1) + (pn−2 log α(ξ p − 1) + · · · ξ p =ζpn−1
i − 1) (gu0 /gu )(ξ − 1) [by (4.14)] pn−1 (log α)(gu0 /gu ) (ξ − 1) + (pn−2 log α(ζpn−1 − 1)
n−1
=
+ log(ξ p X ξ p =ζpn−1
+ · · · + log(ζp − 1)
X
(gu0 /gu )(ξ − 1)
ξ p =ζpn−1
X
=
pn−1 (log α)(gu0 /gu ) (ξ − 1) + (pn−1 log α(ζpn−1 − 1)
ξ p =ζpn−1
+ · · · + p log α(ζp − 1) (gu0 /gu )(ζpn−1 − 1) [by (4.16)]. Next, we take trace down to Kn−2 and obtain 0 T rKn /Kn−2 log(α(n) (ζpn −1)(gu /gu )(ζpn −1))
h = T rKn−1 /Kn−2
P ξp =ζ n−1 p
0 pn−1 (log α)(gu /gu ) (ξ−1)
0 + (pn−1 log α(ζpn−1 −1)+···+p log α(ζp −1) (gu /gu )(ζpn−1 −1)
P
=
2 ξp =ζ n−2 p
0 pn−1 (log α)(gu /gu ) (ξ−1)+
η p =ζ n−2 p
+ pn−2 log α)(ζn−2 −1)+···+p log α(ζp −1) P
=
2 ξp =ζ n−2 p
P
0 (pn−1 (log α)(gu /gu ) (ξ−1)+
i
P η p =ζ n−2 p
P
ξp =ζ n−2 p
0 pn−1 (log α)(gu /gu ) (η−1)
0 (gu /gu )(η−1)
0 pn−1 (log α)(gu /gu ) (ξ−1)+
0 pn−1 log α(ζpn−2 −1)+···+p2 log(ζp −1) (gu /gu )(ζpn−2 −1).
Continuing in this fashion, we obtain the lemma.
Explicit Reciprocity Law of Bloch–Kato and Exponential Maps 85 In view of lemmas 4.4.3 and 4.4.4, we have p−n T rKn /Qp log(α(n) )(gu0 /gu )(ζpn − 1) mod pn X = (p−1 log(α)(gu0 /gu )(ζpi n − 1) mod pn . (4.17)
(α, u) =
0
For any h(T ) ∈ Zp [[T ]] and n ≥ 1, X 1 h(ζpi n − 1) = −Res h(T ) mod pn . log(1 + T ) 0
Lemma 4.4.5
Proof: It is enough to check the above for h(T ) = (1 + T )m , m ≥ 0, as it will then hold for Zp [T ] and, by continuity, for Zp [[T ]] as well. For h(T ) = (1 + T )m , the left hand side is clearly pn − 1 if pn | m. If pn - m, then the left hand side is −1. The right hand side can be computed as −Res(T −1 (1 + T /2 − · · · )(1 + T )m ) = −1.
By combining the previous lemma with (4.17), we find that X (α, u) = (p−1 log(α)(gu0 /gu ) (ζpi n − 1) mod pn ∀n 0
=
Res
1 p−1 log(α)(gu0 /gu ) mod pn log(1 + T )
(4.18) ∀n
By (4.12) and (4.18), we have ∂ 1 (p−1 log(α))(u) = (α, u) ⊗ t = Res
1 p−1 log(α)(gu0 /gu ) ⊗ t. log(1 + T )
As α = α(T) ∈ 1 + Zp [[T]] was arbitrary, so is p−1 log(α) ∈ Zp [[T]], the proof of proposition 4.4.2 is complete. The key proposition 4.4.2 generalizes for any β ∈ B∞ , and not just for u ∈ U∞ . For β ∈ B∞ with vp (β) = d, we have gβ0 /gβ ∈ T −1 Zp [[T ]], and the proof still works with minor modifications.
4.5 The exponential and the dual exponential maps For this section, we refer the readers to chapter II of [Kt93a]. Let V be a de Rham representation. We are interested in the cohomology groups H q (GK , BdR ⊗Qp V ). We have a BdR -linear GK -equivariant isomorphism
86
Anupam Saikia
between BdR ⊗Qp V and BdR ⊗K DdR (V ). It follows that H 1 (GK , BdR ⊗Qp V ) = H 1 (GK , BdR ⊗K DdR (V )) ∼ = H 1 (GK , BdR ) ⊗K DdR (V ). Therefore, it is enough to look into the cohomology of BdR which we do next.
4.5.1 Galois cohomology of BdR We have the following well-known theorem (theorem 5.2.4 of [FO]). Theorem 4.5.1
Let K be a finite extension of Qp . Then
1. H q (GK , Cp (r)) = 0 unless q = 0, 1 and r = 0. 2. H 0 (GK , Cp ) = K. 3. H 1 (GK , Cp ) = K. log χ where χ is the cyclotomic character, and the ∼ cup-product x 7→ x ∪ log χ gives an isomorphism H 0 (GK , Cp ) −→ H 1 (GK , Cp ). Theorem 4.5.2
Suppose i < j ∈ Z ∪ {±∞}.
j i 1. If i ≥ 1 we have H q (GK , BdR /BdR )=0 ∀j ∀q ≥ 0. j i 2. If j ≤ 0 we have H q (GK , BdR /BdR )=0 ∀i ∀q ≥ 0. 3. If i ≤ 0 and j > 0, then x 7−→ x ∪ log χ gives an isomorphism ∼ j j i i H 0 (GK , BdR /BdR )(∼ /BdR ). = K) −→ H 1 (GK , BdR i+1 i Proof: 1. When i ≥ 1, H q (GK , BdR /BdR ) = H q (GK , Cp (i)) = 0 by part 1 of the theorem above. If the result holds for j, then it also holds for j + 1 by the long exact sequence of GK -cohomology j j+1 j+1 j i i 0 −→ BdR /BdR −→ BdR /BdR −→ BdR /BdR −→ 0,
noting that j j+1 ∼ H q (GK , BdR /BdR ) = H q (GK , Cp (j)) = 0 for j > 0.
2. When 0 ≥ j(> i), then the result holds for i = j − 1, as j−1 j H q (GK , BdR /BdR ) = H q (GK , Cp (j − 1)) = 0 for j − 1 < 0.
If the result holds for i, then it also holds for i − 1 by the long exact sequence of GK -cohomology j j i−1 i−1 i i 0 −→ BdR /BdR −→ BdR /BdR −→ BdR /BdR −→ 0,
Explicit Reciprocity Law of Bloch–Kato and Exponential Maps 87 i−1 i noting that H q (GK , BdR /BdR ) = H q (GK , Cp (i − 1)) = 0 for i < 0.
3. When i ≤ 0 < j, we combine the long exact sequences of GK cohomology from j j 0 i i 0 0 −→ BdR /BdR −→ BdR /BdR −→ BdR /BdR −→ 0, j j 1 0 0 1 0 −→ BdR /BdR −→ BdR /BdR −→ BdR /BdR −→ 0
and use the previous two parts to deduce that j j i 0 0 1 H q (GK , BdR /BdR ) = H q (GK , BdR /BdR ) = H q (GK , BdR /BdR )
= H q (GK , Cp ). The rest follows from the previous theorem. When i or j is infinite, we can prove it by taking limits. In particular, it follows that + H q (GK , BdR /BdR ) = 0,
+ H q (GK , BdR ) = H q (GK , BdR )
∀q. (4.19)
4.5.2 The dual exponential By virtue of theorem 4.5.2 we obtain an isomorphism induced by cupproduct ∼
K = H 0 (GK , BdR ) −→ H 1 (GK , BdR ),
x 7−→ x ∪ log χ.
(4.20)
By (4.19) and (4.20), we obtain an isomorphism ∼ DdR (V ) −→ H 1 (GK , BdR ) ⊗K DdR (V ) ∼ = H 1 (GK , BdR ⊗Qp V ),
x 7−→ x ∪ log χ. The dual exponential map exp∗ is defined as the composite ∼
H 1 (GK , V ) −→ H 1 (GK , BdR ⊗Qp V ) −→ DdR (V ), where the second map is the inverse of the isomorphism given by ∪ log χ. Proposition 4.5.3
0 The image of exp∗ lies in DdR (V ).
Proof: It is clear from the previous section that the image of any element + c of H 1 (GK , V ) in H 1 (GK , BdR /BdR ⊗Qp V ) is 0. But we have injective maps x7→x∪log χ
+ 0 DdR (V )/DdR (V ),−→H 0 (GK ,BdR /BdR ⊗Qp V )
,−→
+ H 1 (GK ,BdR /BdR ⊗Qp V )
88
Anupam Saikia
where the first injection comes from the cohomology of the exact sequence + + 0 −→ BdR ⊗Qp V −→ BdR ⊗Qp V −→ BdR /BdR ⊗Qp V −→ 0. 0 Hence, exp∗ (c) ∈ DdR (V ).
The dual exponential indeed turns out to be the dual of a natural map (to be called the exponential map) associated with the cohomology of the representation V .
4.5.3 The exponential map The fundamental exact sequence of Bloch and Kato [(1.17.1) of [BK90]] is given by α
β
φ=1 + 0 −→ Qp −→ Bcris ⊕ BdR −→ BdR −→ 0
α(x) = (x, x),
(4.21)
β(x, y) = x − y.
By tensoring with a p-adic representation V of GK , and taking the long exact sequence of cohomology, we obtain δ
0 0 −→ H 0 (GK , V ) −→ Dcris (V )φ=1 ⊕DdR (V ) −→ DdR (V ) −→ H 1 (K, V ).
The connecting homomorphism above induces the exponential map to be denoted by exp. From the exactness of the above sequence, it is clear 0 that δ factors through DdR (V ) and the resulting map is known as the exponential map. In other words, 0 exp : DdR (V )/DdR (V ) −→ H 1 (K, V ),
0 exp(x mod DdR (V )) = δ(x).
Our immediate goal is to show that the maps exp and exp∗ are related via Tate duality.
4.5.4 Tate duality Let V ∗ = HomQp (V, Qp ) be the dual representation of V , with GK action given by h 7→ h.σ −1 . The cup-product gives a perfect pairing (corollary 2.3 of [Mi86]) H q (GK , V ) × H 2−q (GK , V ∗ (1)) −→ H 2 (GK , Qp (1)) ∼ = Qp ,
q = 0, 1, 2.
Explicit Reciprocity Law of Bloch–Kato and Exponential Maps 89 We also have a canonical perfect K-bilinear pairing given by cup-product (theorem 5.2.1 of [BC09]) ∪
h , i : DdR (V ) × DdR (V ∗ (1)) −→ H 0+0 (GK , BdR ⊗Qp V ⊗Qp V ∗ (1)) ∼ DdR (Qp (1)) ∼ (4.22) = = K. Proposition 4.5.4 The above paring h , i followed by the trace map T rK/Qp : K −→ Qp induces an isomorphism between DdR (V ) and HomQp (DdR (V ∗ (1)), Qp ). Proof: Consider the Qp -linear map f : DdR (V ) −→ HomQp DdR (V ∗ (1)), Qp , x 7−→ fx : y 7→ T rK/Qp (hx, yi)
∀y ∈ DdR (V ∗ (1)).
The map f must be injective as follows. If x belongs to the kernel of f , then T rK/Qp (hx, kyi) = T rK/Qp (khx, yi) = 0 ∀ k ∈ K. If x 6= 0 then there exists y such that hx, yi = β 6= 0 as h, i is nondegenerate. Then, T rK/Qp (kβ) must be 0 for all k. Taking k = β −1 , we would obtain T rK/Qp (β −1 β) = [K : Qp ] = 0, which is absurd. Hence x = 0 and f must be injective. But the vector spaces DdR (V ) and HomQp DdR (V ∗ (1)), Qp have the same dimension over Qp as DdR (V ) and DdR (V ∗ (1)) have the same dimension over K. So f gives an isomorphism which identifies DdR (V ) with HomQp DdR (V ∗ (1)), Qp .
4.5.5 The relation between exp and exp∗ The following theorem establishes a relation between the exponential map and its dual. Theorem 4.5.5 tial map
(cf. theorem 1.4.1 (4) in [Kt93a]) The dual exponen-
exp∗V ∗ (1) : H 1 (GK , V ∗ (1)) −→ DdR (V ∗ (1)) coincides with the composite map ∼
∼
H 1 (GK ,V ∗ (1))→HomQp (H 1 (GK ,V ),Qp )→HomQp DdR (V ),Qp →DdR (V ∗ (1)).
where the first map is by Tate duality, and the second one by the Qp -dual of the exponential map of V , and the third is induced by the canonical pairing mentioned above. In other words, for a ∈ DdR (V ) and
90
Anupam Saikia
b ∈ H 1 (GK , V ∗ (1)) we have expV (a) ∪ b = −T rK/Qp (ha, exp∗V ∗ (1) (b)i). In order to prove the theorem, we need the lemma below. + 1 Lemma 4.5.6 (Lemma 1.4.3 in [Kt93a]) Let ψ : H 1 (GK , BdR /BdR )→ 2 H (GK , Qp (1)) be the connecting homomorphism of the exact sequence φ=p + + 1 0 −→ Qp (1) −→ Bcris ∩ BdR −→ BdR /BdR −→ 0.
Then for any de Rham representation V of GK , a ∈ DdR (V ) and b ∈ H 1 (GK , V ∗ (1)), we have expV (a) ∪ b = ψ(ha, exp∗V ∗ (1) (b)i log χ) ∈ H 2 (GK , Qp (1)), where h , i : DdR (V ) × DdR (V ∗ (1)) → K, is the pairing considered in (4.22). Proof: It is well known that the connecting homomorphism of cohomology is compatible with cup-product (proposition 1.4.3 in [NSW08]). Hence we have the following commutative diagram H 1 (GK ,V )
×
x a7→exp (a) V H 0 (GK ,BdR ⊗Q V ) p
×
H 1 (GK ,V ∗ (1))
∪
− −−−− →
b7→exp∗ ∗ (b)∪log χ y V (1) H 1 (GK ,BdR ⊗Q V ∗ (1)) p
− −−−− →
H 2 (GK ,Qp (1))∼ =Qp
x ψ + 1 1 H 1 (GK ,BdR )∼ =H (GK ,BdR /BdR ),
where the middle arrow comes from the very definition of exp∗ . By associativity and compatibility of cup-product with connecting homomorphism of cohomology, we have expV (a) ∪ b = ψ(a ∪ (exp∗V ∗ (1) b ∪ log χ)) = ψ(ha, exp∗V ∗ (1) (b)i log χ). Proof of theorem 4.5.5: In view of the previous lemma, it is enough to show that the map + 1 ψ : H 1 (GK , BdR /BdR ) = H 1 (GK , Cp ) = K log χ → H 2 (GK , Qp (1)) = Qp
sends c log χ to −T rK/Qp (c). First assume that K = Qp and take V = Qp (1) in the commutative diagram above. Then by local class field theory of Qp , the pairing H 1 (GQp , Qp (1)) × H 1 (GQp , Qp ) → H 2 (GQp , Qp (1)) ∼ = Qp
Explicit Reciprocity Law of Bloch–Kato and Exponential Maps 91 sends (exp(c), log χ) to −c (lemma I.4.5 in [Kt93a]). Now for any finite extension K of Qp we use compatibility of the corestriction map with the connecting homomorphism ψ (proposition 1.5.2 in [NSW08]) as well as cup-product (proposition 1.5.3 in [NSW08]) in the following commutative diagram. ψ
∪
H 0 (GK , BdR ) × H 1 (GK , BdR ) − → H 1 (GK , BdR ) − → H 2 (GK , Qp (1)) (∼ (∼ = K) = K log χ) x res cory=T rK/Qp
(∼ = K log χ) cor y
(. ∼ = Qp )
ψ
∪
H 0 (GQp , BdR )×H 1 (GQp , BdR ) − → H 1 (GQp , BdR ) − → H 2 (GQp , Qp (1)) (∼ = Qp )
(∼ = Qp log χ)
(∼ = Qp log χ)
(∼ = Qp )
4.5.6 Relation between exp and Coates–Wiles homomorphism Let K be a finite unramified extension of Qp . By tensoring the fundamental sequence (4.21) with Qp (r) = Qp .tr , we obtain α
r
βr
r φ=p r 0 −→ Qp (r) −→ Bcris ⊕ BdR −→ BdR −→ 0
αr (x) = (x, x),
(4.23)
βr (x, y) = x − y.
From the Galois cohomology sequence with respect to GK , we obtain a connecting homomorphism expr : K = DdR (Qp (r)) −→ H 1 (GK , Qp (r)) = HomΓ (U∞ , Qp (r)). On the other hand, the exact sequence 1−p−r φ
+ + 0 −→ Qp (r) −→ Jcris ⊗ Q = Filr Bcris −−−−−→ Bcris −→ 0 (4.24)
gives another connecting homomorphism + ∂ r : K = H 0 (GK , Bcris ) −→ H 1 (GK , Qp (r)) = HomΓ (U∞ , Qp (r)).
In this subsection we establish a relation between these two connecting homomorphisms. As a consequence, we will be able to express the exponential map in terms of the Coates–Wiles homomorphism in view of theorem 4.4.1. We have the following result. Theorem 4.5.7 expr (a)(g) = −∂ r (1 − p−r ap )(g),
a ∈ K, g ∈ GK .
92
Anupam Saikia r
φ=p r Proof: Let (x, y) ∈ Bcris ⊕ BdR be a pre-image of an element a ∈ K = 0 H (GK , BdR ) under βr in (4.23), i.e., x − y = a. By definition,
expr (a)(g) = c, where (c, c) = (x, y)g − (x, y) = (xg − x, y g − y). Note that βr ((xg − x, y g − y)) = (x − y)g − (x − y) = ag − a = 0. Thus, we can take expr (a)(g) = y g − y for g ∈ GK . + It is now enough to show that y ∈ Filr (Bcris ), as the connecting homor morphism ∂ of the exact sequence (4.24) will then send (1 − p−r φ)(y) to g 7→ y g − g, and
expr (a)(g) = y g − g = ∂ r ((1 − p−r φ)(y))(g) = ∂ r (x − a) − p−r (φ(x) − φ(a))(g) = −∂ r (1 − p−r φ)(a)(g)
r
φ=p as x ∈ Bcris .
r Now, y = x − a ∈ BdR ∩ Bcris = Filr (Bcris ). It is enough to show that S + + + y ∈ Bcris . Observe that Bcris = s≥0 t−s Bcris , hence ts y ∈ Bcris for some s ≥ 0. If s = 0, we are done. Suppose s ≥ 1. Then, m
m
m
y φ = (x − a)φ = pmr x − aφ = pmr (y + a) − aφ
m
∈ Filr Bcris + Fil0 (Bcris ) ⊂ Fil0 Bcris . As φ(t) = pt (see (4.6)), we have m
m
(ts y)φ = psm ts y φ ∈ Fils Bcris ⊂ Fil1 Bcris . By a result of Fontaine (Prop 4.14 in [Fo82]), it now follows that + + ts y ∈ tBcris =⇒ ts−1 y ∈ Bcris . + By repeating the process, we arrive at y ∈ Bcris .
4.5.7 The image of Soul´ e–Deligne elements under the dual exponential The reference for this section is §3 of [HK03] (cf. §6 in [BK90]). The Soul´e–Deligne cyclotomic elements form an Euler system and hence are related to p-adic L-functions. Let r be a positive integer as in sections
Explicit Reciprocity Law of Bloch–Kato and Exponential Maps 93 3.2 and 3.3. Let N be an integer coprime to p, and K = Qp (ζN ). Let cp ≡ 1 modulo N , so that n
c φ−n (ζN ) = ζN .
Consider the tower of fields Kn = Qp (ζN , ζpn ) = K(ζpn ), where ζpn is a primitive pn -th power of unity such that ζppn = ζpn−1 for all n ∈ N. Let B∞ = lim Kn× . ←− n
The Soul´e–Deligne cyclotomic element c1−r (ζN ) ∈ H 1 (GK , Zp (1 − r)) is obtained from the norm-compatible element u in B∞ given by 1 − ζ N c c2 cn n, · · · 2, · · · , 1 − ζ u= , 1 − ζ ζ , 1 − ζ ζ ζ N 6= 1, p p p N N N c 1 − ζN u = p, 1 − ζp , 1 − ζp2 , · · · , 1 − ζpn , · · · N = 1, K = Qp ,
as follows (cf §2.1.5 in [Kt93a]): ⊗(−r)
⊗ζpn
Kummer
n
c u = (1 − ζN ζpn ) ∈ lim←− Kn× −−→ lim H 1 (GKn , Zp (1)) −−→ ← n
lim←− H 1 GKn , n
Zp (1 pn Zp
n
cores
Zp 1 − r) −−→ lim H G , (1 − r) K n ←− p Zp n ∼
→ H 1 (GK , Zp (1 − r)). We have the following commutative diagram:
DdR (Qp (r)) exp y r
T rK/Qp
×DdR (Qp (1 − r)) → K −−−−−→ x exp∗ 1−r
H 1 (GK , Qp (r)) × y Hom(U∞ , Qp (r))×
Qp
∪ H 1 (GK , Qp (1 − r)) − → H 2 (GK , Qp (1)) ∼ = Qp x x ⊗(−r) n u=(1−ζNc ζpn )7→c1−r (ζN ) ⊗t
U∞
→ −
Qp (r).
The commutativity of the upper-half follows from theorem 4.5.5. In order to examine the commutativity of the lower-half, let us view it at the finite level n. It is well known that restriction, co-restriction and connecting homomorphisms of cohomology behave well with respect to cup-product
94
Anupam Saikia
(propositions 1.4.3 and 1.5.3 in [NSW08]). Hence we have the following commutative diagram:
H1
GK ,(Zp /pn Zp )(r)
×
H1
GK ,(Zp /pn Zp )(1−r)
∪
− →
H2
GK ,(Zp /pn Zp )(1)
n (∼ =Zp /p Zp )
resy H1
GK
n
x cores
,(Zp /pn Zp )(r)
×
H1
GK
n
x cores
,(Zp /pn Zp )(1−r)
∪
− →
H2
GK ,(Zp /pn Zp )(1) n
n (∼ =Zp /p Zp )
Hom
GK
n
,(Zp /pn Zp )(r)
× H1
⊗(−r) GK ,(Zp /pn Zp )(1) ⊗ζ n n p
Hom
n Gab Kn ,(Zp /p Zp )(r)
×
H1
GK
n
,(Zp /pn Zp )(1)
× ,(Z /pn Z )(r) Kn p p
×
H0
GK
n
,Kn ×
× =Kn
∪
− →
×
Un
⊗(r) Zp /pn Zp ⊗ζ n p
x − →
x
Un ,(Zp /pn Zp )(r)
Zp /pn Zp
x ⊗ζ⊗(−r) pn
x Kummer
resy Hom
∪
− →
x ⊗ζ⊗(−r) pn
Hom
(Zp /pn Zp )(r)
x − →
(Zp /pn Zp )(r).
For a ∈ K = DdR (Qp (r)), we can compute exp∗1−r (c1−r (ζN )) as −T rK/Qp (a exp∗1−r (c1−r (ζN ))) = expr (a) ∪ (c1−r (ζN )) r
= −∂ (1 − p
−r φ
a )(u) ⊗ t
(by theorem 4.5.5) ⊗(−r)
(by theorem 4.5.7 and the previous commutative diagram) i 1 h = T rK/Qp aφrCW (u) − p−r T rK/Qp aφ φrCW (u) ⊗ t⊗(−r) (r − 1)! (by theorem 3.1) i −1 1 h = T rK/Qp aφrCW (u) − p−r T rK/Qp aφrCW (u)φ ⊗ t⊗(−r) (r − 1)! i 1 h d r = T rK/Qp a(1 − p−r φ−1 ) (1 + T ) log gu (T ) |T =0 , (r − 1)! dT
Explicit Reciprocity Law of Bloch–Kato and Exponential Maps 95 where gu (T ) is the Coleman power series of u given by gu (T ) = 1 − ζN (1 + T ). Using the modified Soul´e–Deligne cyclotomic element c˜1−r (ζN ) = −
∞ X
i
p ) (pr )i c1−r (ζN
i=1
=−
∞ X
(pr φ)i c1−r (ζN ),
i=1
we can removes the Euler factor (1 − p−r φ−1 ) and obtain T rK/Qp (a exp∗1−r (˜ c1−r (ζN ))) h i −1 d r = log gu (T ) |T =0 . T rK/Qp a (1 + T ) (r − 1)! dT The above result allows us to relate the cyclotomic elements c˜1−r (ζN ) to zeta values. It further shows that these cyclotomic elements are nontorsion as cohomology classes (§3.2 in [HK03]). As a consequence, the Bloch–Kato conjecture for the Riemann zeta function up to powers of 2 can be reduced to a statement about the Soul´e–Deligne cyclotomic elements (loc. cit.).
References [Be04] Berger, L. 2004. An introduction to the theory of p-adic representations. Geometric aspects of Dwork theory, Vol. I, II, 255292, Walter de Gruyter GmbH Co. KG, Berlin. [BO78] Berthelot, P., and Ogus, A. 1978. Notes on Crystalline Cohomology. Princeton University Press. [BK90] Bloch, S., and Kato, K. 1990. L-functions and Tamagawa numbers of motives. The Grothendieck Festschrift, Vol. I. Progr. Math., 86, 333400. Birkh¨ auser Boston, Boston, MA. [BC09] Brinon, O., and Conrad, B. 2009. Notes on p-adic Hodge Theory. CMI Summer School, available online at www.math.stanford.edu/conrad/papers/notes.pdf [CF67] Cassels, J. W. S., and Frohlich, A. 1967. Algebraic Number Fields. Academic Press. [Co] Colmez, P. Fontaine’s rings and p-adic L-functions. Course given at Tsinghua University (www.math.jussieu.fr/∼colmez/tsinghua.pdf). [Fo82] Fontaine, J. M. 1982. Sur certains types de repr´esentations p-adiques du groupe de Galois d’un corps local; construction d’un anneau de Barsotti-Tate. Ann. of Math. (2) 115, no. 3, 529–577.
96
Anupam Saikia
[FO] Fontaine, J. M., and Ouyang, Y. Theory of p-adic Galois Representations. Book in preparation (www.math.upsud.fr/∼fontaine/galoisrep.pdf). [Gu99] Guo, L. 1999. Hecke characters and formal group characters. Topics in number theory (University Park, PA, 1997). Math. Appl., 467, 181192. Kluwer Acad. Publ., Dordrecht. [HK03] Huber, A., and Kings, G. 2003. Bloch-Kato conjecture and Main Conjecture of Iwasawa theory for Dirichlet characters. Duke Math. J., 119, no. 3, 393464. [Iw86] Iwasawa, K. 1986. Local Class Field Theory. Oxford Science Publications. [Kt93a] Kato, K. 1993. Lectures on the approach to Iwasawa theory for HasseWeil L-functions via BdR. I. Arithmetic algebraic geometry (Trento, 1991). Lecture Notes in Math., 1553, 50163, Springer, Berlin. [Kt93b] Kato, K. 1993. Iwasawa theory and p-adic Hodge theory. Kodai Math. J., 16, no. 1, 131. [Mi86] Milne, J. S. 1986. Arithmetic Duality Theorems. Academic Press. [NSW08] Neukirch, J., Schmidt, A., and Wingberg, K. 2008. Cohomology of Number Fields. Springer. [Se79] Serre, J. P. 1979. Local fields. Graduate Texts in Mathematics, 67. Springer-Verlag, New York-Berlin. [Sh87] Shalit, E. 1987. Iwasawa theory of elliptic curves with complex multiplication. Perspectives in Mathematics, 3. Academic Press, Inc., Boston, MA. [Sh95] Shalit, E. 1995. The explicit reciprocity law of Bloch-Kato. Columbia University Number Theory Seminar (New York, 1992). Astrisque no. 228, 4, 197221.
5 The Norm Residue Theorem and the Quillen-Lichtenbaum Conjecture Manfred Kolster
5.1 Introduction The ‘other’ Bloch–Kato Conjecture, also referred to as the ‘Norm Residue Theorem’ (Theorem 5.5.6), relates Milnor K-theory to Galois cohomology, and has been proven now by Voevodsky [Vo11] with major contributions from Rost, Suslin and Weibel. This article attempts to describe the historic development of the conjecture and some of the major achievements that led to the final proof. We try to describe some of the key ideas behind the proof and some consequences of the result, in particular on the relationship between algebraic K-theory, motivic cohomology and ´etale cohomology for rings of integers in number fields in the framework of the Quillen–Lichtenbaum Conjecture.
The final part of the proof of the theorem has appeared in [Vo11], but the method had already been outlined in [Vo03], where Voevodsky proved the Milnor Conjecture (the special case that l = 2). A good introduction to the sophisticated and deep methods developed by Voevodsky for motivic cohomology, which are used in the proof and which are beyond the scope of this article, can be found in the books [VSF00] and [MVW06], the last one being based on lectures given by Voevodsky in 1999/2000. The book [HW12], which is supposed to appear soon, provides a comprehensive treatment of the whole material surrounding the proof.
McMaster University, Hamilton, Canada. e-mail : [email protected]
98
Manfred Kolster
5.2 Background L∞ We recall that for a field F the Milnor ring K∗M (F ) = n=0 KnM (F ) of F was defined by Milnor in [Mi70] as follows: K0M (F ) = K0 (F ) = Z and K1M (F ) = K1 (F ) = F ∗ , the elements in K1M (F ) being written additively as symbols l(a), a ∈ F ∗ , satisfying l(ab) = l(a) + l(b). Let T (F ∗ ) denote the tensor algebra over Z generated by K1M (F ), and let I denote the two-sided ideal generated by tensors of the form l(a)⊗l(1−a), a 6= 0, 1. Then the Milnor ring is defined as K∗M (F ) = T (F ∗ )/I. The graded piece KnM (F ) is then the quotient of F ∗ ⊗· · ·⊗F ∗ (n factors) by the subgroup generated by those symbols l(a1 )⊗l(a2 )⊗· · ·⊗l(an ) satisfying ai + ai+1 = 0 for some i, 1 ≤ i ≤ n − 1. The generators of KnM (F ) are called symbols of length n and denoted by a = {a1 , · · ·, an }. In the special case n = 2 the group K2M (F ) is isomorphic to the Kgroup K2 (F ), which had been previously defined by Milnor for arbitrary rings, as a consequence of Matsumoto’s presentation of K2 (F ) for a field F in terms of generators and relations [Mi71]. The relation between the Milnor ring and the graded Galois cohomoL∞ logy ring n=0 H n (F, µ⊗n l ), l a prime number 6= char F , is based on the following Kummer isomorphism: We apply Galois cohomology to the Kummer sequence ·l
∗ ∗ 0 → µl → Fsep → Fsep → 0,
where Fsep denotes a separable closure of F and µl denotes the group of ∗ l-th roots of unity, and use the fact that H 1 (F, Fsep ) = 0, which is the cohomological version of Hilbert’s Theorem 90, to obtain the Kummer isomorphism ∼ H 1 (F, µl ). F ∗ /F ∗l = This isomorphism extends now to a homomorphism from the Milnor ring to the graded Galois cohomology ring, by sending a symbol {a1 , · · ·, an } to the cup-product a1 ∪ a2 · · · ∪ an ∈ H n (F, µ⊗n l ), where we identify the elements ai ∈ F ∗ with their images in H 1 (F, µl ). This homomorphism is well defined, since Tate observed that for n = 2 the cup-product a ∪1 −a vanishes in H 2 (F, µ⊗2 l ). The resulting homomorphism KnM (F )/l → H n (F, µ⊗n l )
Norm Residue and the Quillen–Lichtenbaum Conjecture
99
is called Norm Residue Homomorphism or Galois symbol. This homomorphism is clearly an isomorphism for n = 0, since both groups are isomorphic to Z/l, and is equal to the Kummer isomorphism for n = 1. For n = 2 and µl ⊂ F the cohomology group H 2 (F, µ⊗2 l ) is isomorphic to µl ⊗ l Br(F ), where for any abelian group A we denote by l A the subgroup of elements of exponent l in A. The map K2 (F )/l → µl ⊗ l Br(F ) sends {a, b} to ζ ⊗ [Aζ (a, b)], where ζ is a primitive l-th root of unity and [Aζ (a, b)] is the Brauer class of the central simple algebra Aζ (a, b), which is generated by two elements x and y, subject to the relations xl = a, y l = b and yx = ζxy. The class [Aζ (a, b)] is called norm residue symbol, because its value is 1 if and only if b is a norm from the field √ F ( n a) (for details see [Mi71, section 15]). For local or global fields the norm residue homomorphisms are isomorphisms for all integers n ≥ 0 and all primes l. For n = 2 and all primes l this was shown by Tate in [Ta76, Theorem 5.1] and for n ≥ 3 this follows – as Milnor observed – from the computations of the groups KnM (F ) for n ≥ 3 by Bass and Tate [BT73], which showed that for n ≥ 3 and a global field F one has KnM (F ) ∼ = (Z/2Z)r1 (F ) , where r1 (F ) is the number of real embeddings of F . In [Mi70] Milnor focussed on the Milnor ring k∗ (F ) := K∗M (F )/2 modulo 2 and its relationship both to the graded Galois cohomology L∞ ring n=0 H n (F, Z/2) and to the graded Witt ring gr W (F ) of a field F of odd characteristic. The latter is obtained as follows: Let W (F ) denote the Witt ring of F and let I(F ) denote the fundamental ideal in W (F ) consisting of all classes of bilinear forms of even rank. Then the graded Witt ring gr W (F ) is defined as gr W (F )) = ⊕n≥0 I n (F )/I n+1 (F ), where I 0 (F ) = W (F ). Given a1 , · · ·, an ∈ F ∗ /F ∗2 we denote by < a1 , · · ·, an > the quadratic Pn form i=1 ai x2i , and define the so-called Pfister form << a1 , · · ·, an >> via
100
Manfred Kolster
<< a1 , · · ·, an >>:=< 1, −a1 > ⊗ · · · ⊗ < 1, −an > . Milnor showed [Mi70, Theorem 4.1] that there is a unique homomorphism sn (F ) : kn (F ) → I n (F )/I n+1 (F ) for each n ≥ 0, which sends a symbol {a1 , a2 , · · ·, an } to the class of the Pfister form << a1 , · · ·, an >> mod I n+1 (F ), and that these homomorphisms are isomorphisms for n = 0, 1, 2 and surjective for all n. In the introduction to his paper [Mi70] Milnor conjectured not only that the sn are isomorphisms for all n, but also that the norm residue homomorphisms for l = 2 are isomorphisms: ‘Section 4 studies the conjecture that the associated graded ring (W/I, I/I 2 , I 2 /I 3 , · · · ) is canonically isomorphic to K∗ F/2K∗ F ’, and a few lines later he writes: ‘Section 6 describes the conjecture that K∗ F/2K∗ F is canonically isomorphic to the cohomology ring H ∗ (GF ; Z/2Z) · · · ’ . The second conjecture is now known as the Milnor Conjecture. It was proven by Voevodsky in [Vo03], and with the use of methods from [Vo03] it was then shown by Orlov, Vishik and Voevodsky [OVV07] that the Milnor Conjecture implies the first conjecture, namely that all homomorphisms sn are isomorphisms. These results answered some fundamental open questions in the algebraic theory of quadratic forms. In particular one obtains isomorphisms I n (F )/I n+1 (F ) ∼ = H n (F, Z/2Z), which define new cohomological invariants for bilinear forms. We refer to [OVV07] for more applications of the Milnor Conjecture to quadratic forms.
It seems that the general conjecture on the norm residue homomorphisms for arbitrary primes l was first explicitly formulated by Kato in the 1980 paper [Kt80, p.608]: ‘Concerning this homomorphism [the norm residue homomorphism] the experts perhaps have the following Conjecture [the Norm Residue Isomorphism Conjecture] in mind: · · · ’
Norm Residue and the Quillen–Lichtenbaum Conjecture
101
Bloch [Bl10, p.xvii] reflects about his contribution to the conjecture in the preface to the second edition (‘30 Years later’) of the reprint of his book ‘Lectures on Algebraic Cycles’ [Bl80] as follows: ‘My own contribution to this, which is explained in Lecture 5, is a proof that KnM (F )/l → H n (F, µ⊗n l ) is surjective when F has cohomological dimension n.’ In 1986 the conjecture was mentioned again in their joint paper [BK90, p.118], and since then has been referred to as the Bloch–Kato Conjecture. To avoid confusing this conjecture with the other Bloch–Kato Conjecture (the Tamagawa Number Conjecture) it is also referred to as The Norm Residue Isomorphism Conjecture.
5.3 Merkurjev–Suslin The first general result (for arbitrary fields) was obtained by Merkurjev [Me82] in 1981. He proved the Milnor conjecture for n = 2: Theorem 5.3.1 (Merkurjev) norm residue homomorphism
For a field F of odd characteristic the
K2 (F )/2 → H 2 (F, Z/2) is an isomorphism. This result gives a presentation of the subgroup 2 Br(F ) of Br(F ) of elements of exponent 2 in terms of generators and relations, and shows – in particular – that every element of exponent two in the Brauer group is similar to a tensor product of quaternion algebras. This answered an open question in the theory of algebras. Shortly afterwards the result was generalized to all primes l ([MS83]): Theorem 5.3.2 (Merkurjev–Suslin) For a field F and a prime l 6= char F , the norm residue homomorphism K2 (F )/l → H 2 (F, µ⊗2 l ) is an isomorphism. ∼ If F contains µl we have a (non-canonical) isomorphism H 2 (F, µ⊗2 l )= l Br(F ) by choosing a primitive l-th root of unity. Theorem 5.3.2 then
102
Manfred Kolster
implies again that elements of order l in the Brauer group are similar to tensor products of cyclic algebras of order l. The novelty of the ideas of Merkurjev and Suslin behind the proofs of Theorem 5.3.1 and Theorem 5.3.2 – in particular the use of Severi– Brauer varieties associated to central simple algebras, and Hilbert’s Theorem 90 for K2 for cyclic extensions – had a major influence on all the subsequent work on the Bloch–Kato Conjecture, and we will explain some of the ideas in more detail, once we have discussed some preliminary issues. We first note that both the Galois cohomology groups and the Milnor K-theory groups have natural restriction and corestriction maps for finite extensions E/F of fields, which we denote in both cases by iE/F resp. NE/F . For Milnor K-theory the corestriction is usually called transfer and has been – under certain assumptions – constructed in [BT73, section 5]. The full construction was done by Kato [Kt80]. Both homomorphisms commute with the norm residue homomorphisms, and the compositum NE/F ◦ iE/F is multiplication by the degree [E : F ]. This immediately implies: Lemma 5.3.3 If the norm residue homomorphism is an isomorphism for a prime l and a field F , then this is true also for any finite extension E of F of degree prime to l. We see that in order to prove the Bloch–Kato Conjecture we can assume without loss of generality that F contains the l-th roots of unity, and – if necessary – we can even assume that F does not have finite extensions of degree prime to l, in particular we can assume that F is perfect. Fields that do not have finite extensions of degree prime to l are called l-special [SJ06]. We note that for an l-special field all extensions of degree l are cyclic. The following result is due to Voevodsky ([Vo96, Lemma 5.2], [HW12, Lemma 1.1]) and shows that we can even restrict attention to fields of characteristic 0, if necessary, to prove the Bloch–Kato Conjecture. Lemma 5.3.4 If the norm residue homomorphism is an isomorphism for all fields of characteristic 0, then this is true for all fields in positive characteristic as well. Proof We sketch a proof, since the source [Vo96] will probably not be published and the other source [HW12] is still only available as a preprint.
Norm Residue and the Quillen–Lichtenbaum Conjecture
103
Let k be a field of positive characteristic 6= l, which we may assume to be perfect. Then the ring R of Witt vectors over k is a complete discrete valuation ring, and the natural homomorphism KnM (R)/l → KnM (k)/l is an isomorphism, since R is henselian. Let K denote the field of fractions of R. Then KnM (K) is generated by symbols of the form {π m1 a1 , π m2 a2 , · · ·, πmn an }, where π is a uniformizer in K and the ai ’s are units in R. The specialization map sπ : KnM (K) → KnM (k), which depends on the choice of π, maps the symbol {π m1 a1 , π m2 a2 , · · ·, π mn an } to {¯ a1 , a ¯2 , · · ·, a ¯n )}. This map induces a corresponding map sπ : KnM (K)/l → KnM (k)/l, ∼ K M (k)/l. The same works which is split surjective, since KnM (R)/l = n for the Galois cohomology groups and these split surjections commute with the norm residue homomorphisms. Since K has characteristic 0, we can assume the conjecture for K, and the result follows. After these preliminaries let us turn now to some of the main ideas behind the proof of Theorem 5.3.2: For a given central simple F -algebra A of degree m the associated Severi–Brauer variety X is a projective F -variety of dimension m − 1, which has a rational point in F if and only if A splits. Moreover, if F (X) denotes the function field of X, then the kernel of the map Br(F ) → Br(F (X)) is cyclic and generated by the class of A (for details see [GS06, Chapter 5], [Se79]). In dimension 1 the Severi–Brauer varieties are conics corresponding to quaternion algebras. The symbol a = {a, b} ∈ K2 (F )/2 maps to the class of the quaternion algebra (a, b), which in turn corresponds to the conic with equation ax2 + by 2 = z 2 . In general, if a = {a, b} ∈ K2 (F )/l is a symbol, then we denote by Xa the Severi–Brauer variety associated to a and by Fa the function field F (Xa ) of Xa . One of the fundamental ideas of Merkurjev and Suslin was to study the norm residue homomorphism on the level of function fields of Severi– Brauer varieties, which allowed a geometric approach, for which several K-theoretic tools were available: Quillen’s computation of the K-theory
104
Manfred Kolster
of Severi–Brauer varieties [Q73] and the Brown–Gersten–Quillen spectral sequence (also referred to as co-niveau spectral sequence). For details we refer to the survey article by Suslin [Su85, Sections 7–10] and the book of Srinivas [Sr91, section 8]. Using these techniques Merkurjev and Suslin were able to prove the following result [MS83, Prop. 13.5], which – as we will see – turned out to be fundamental for the general case of the Bloch–Kato Conjecture as well: Theorem 5.3.5 (Hilbert 90 for K2 ) Let E/F be a cyclic extension of degree l and let Gal(E/F ) = < σ > . Then the sequence σ−1
NE/F
K2 (E) → K2 (E) → K2 (F ) is exact. ‘Proof ’ of Theorem 5.3.2: To simplify the notation we denote again the quotient K2M (F )/l by k2 (F ). We also assume without loss of generality that F contains the ∼ l-th roots of unity, so that H 2 (F, µ⊗2 l ) = l Br(F ), and the norm residue homomorphism can be viewed to take values in l Br(F ). Any element x in the kernel of the norm residue homomorphism is Qm of the form x = i=1 {ai , bi }. If m = 1, say x = {a, b}, then it is well known that x must be trivial: The algebra Aζ (a, b) splits if and only if b √ is a norm from E = F ( l a). We therefore have in our case b = NE/F (c) for some c ∈ F ∗ . Hence √ x = {a, b} = {a, NE/F (c)} = NE/F {a, c} = (NE/F { l a, c})l = 1. We proceed now by induction on the number m of factors for all fields of characteristic 6= l. We can assume that the algebra Aζ (am , bm ) is not split, and we denote by X the corresponding Severi–Brauer variety. Then {am , bm } = 0 in k2 (F (X)), hence by induction x = 0 in k2 (F (X)). One of the non-trivial results [MS83, Corollary (9.3)] of Merkurjev– Suslin is that the kernel of the map k2 (F ) → k2 (F (X)) is cyclic and generated by {am , bm }. Under the norm residue homomorphism this kernel, which contains x, is mapped isomorphically to the cyclic group generated by [Aζ (am , bm )]. Hence x = 0.
Norm Residue and the Quillen–Lichtenbaum Conjecture
105
This proves the injectivity of the norm residue homomorphism. We now want to show that the cokernel V (F ) of the norm residue homomorphism k2 (F ) → l Br(F ) is trivial. The idea is to construct a large field extension F˜ of F , for which l Br(F˜ ) = 0 and V (F ) injects into V (F˜ ). The first property implies that V (F˜ ) vanishes, and the second property shows that the same holds for V (F ). This will finish the proof of Theorem 5.3.2. Here is the construction of F˜ : For each symbol a = {a, b} the map V (F ) → V (Fa ) is injective ([MS83, Corollary 11.3]) – this is a key result and again highly non-trivial. Let F 0 denote the compositum of all fields Fa , where a runs through the generators of k2 (F ). Let F1 be the maximal algebraic prime-to-l-extension of F 0 . Repeating the procedure with F1 instead of F etc., we obtain an increasing tower of fields Fi . Let F˜ = ∪Fi . Then by construction we get an injective map V (F ) ,→ V (F˜ ) and clearly k2 (F˜ ) = 0. This implies that l Br(F˜ ) has no non-trivial elements represented by cyclic algebras. We have to show that l Br(F˜ ) is trivial. We first show that in general the vanishing of k2 (K) implies the vanishing of k2 (L) for a cyclic extension of degree l: Hilbert’s Theorem 90 σ−1 implies that in this situation the map k2 (L) → k2 (L) is surjective, since k2 (K) = 0. However the l-th power (σ − 1)l of σ − 1 is trivial, hence k2 (L) is trivial as well. Since F˜ is l-special, this shows that every finite extension E of F˜ has trivial k2 (E). Assume now that there is a non-trivial central simple algebra A over F˜ , which is split by an extension L/F˜ of minimal degree. Since F˜ is l-special, the degree [L : F˜ ] is a power of l. Therefore, there exists a subfield E of L with [L : E] = l, so that A does split over L, but not over E. Let AE denote the extension of A to E. The algebra AE is cyclic, because L/E is a cyclic extension, and non-trivial, but this is impossible, because k2 (E) is trivial. Therefore l Br(F˜ ) is trivial.
Merkurjev and Suslin succeeded to use the same set of ideas to prove
106
Manfred Kolster
that the norm residue homomorphism K3M (F )/2 → H 3 (F, Z/2) is an isomorphism ([MS91]) by proving Hilbert’s Theorem 90 for K3M (F ) and using a result of Swan’s, who computed the K-groups of quadric hypersurfaces [Sw85]. The difficult part of the approach was to describe the deviation between Milnor’s K3M and Quillen’s K3 [MS91]. It became clear that for higher K-groups the methods based on Kcohomology groups could not succeed, since the deviation between Quillen K-theory groups and Milnor K-theory groups becomes extremely complicated for n ≥ 4. What was needed was a new ‘cohomology theory’, which was more closely related to Milnor’s K-theory groups for fields, and allowed to calculate these groups for function fields of certain algebraic varieties. This turned out to be ‘motivic cohomology’.
5.4 Motivic cohomology Motivic cohomology was envisioned by Beilinson and Lichtenbaum in the early 1980s ([Li83, section 3], [Be87, 5.10.D]): They conjectured the existence of a complex of sheaves Z(n) – called motivic complexes and n is called the weight – in the ´etale cohomology (Lichtenbaum) or the Zariski topology (Beilinson), so that the hypercohomology groups of a scheme X over a field F with coefficients in Z(n) – called motivic cohomology groups – satisfy a list of desired properties. We will denote i these motivic cohomology groups by HM (X, Z(n)) and HLi (X, Z(n)), respectively, depending on whether we consider the Zariski site or the ´etale site. In the case X = spec (F ) we replace spec F simply by F in the cohomological notation. Here is a selection of the properties conjectured by Beilinson and Lichtenbaum (F is a field and l a prime 6= charF ): (0) Z(0) = Z;
Z(1) = Gm [−1]
n (1) HM (F, Z/l(n)) ∼ = KnM (F )/l
(2) Beilinson–Lichtenbaum Conjecture:
The natural map
i HM (F, Z/l(n)) → HLi (F, Z/l(n))
Norm Residue and the Quillen–Lichtenbaum Conjecture
107
is an isomorphism for i ≤ n. (3) HLi (F, Z/l(n)) ∼ = H i (F, µ⊗n l ). (4) Hilbert 90:
HLn+1 (F, Z(n)) = 0
for all n ≥ 0.
Remark: Conjecture (3) has actually been formulated more generally for smooth varieties X over F . Conjecture (4) had been christened by Lichtenbaum as ‘Hilbert’s Theorem 90’, since for n = 1 one has HL2 (F, Gm [−1]) = HL1 (F, Gm ), and the vanishing of HL1 (F, Gm ) is exactly the cohomological version of Hilbert’s Theorem 90. We will use two definitions of motivic cohomology: The first one is due to Bloch [Bl86] (see also the survey article [Ge05]): Bloch introduced cycle complexes for quite general schemes X and defined higher Chow groups CH q (X, p) as the cohomology groups of the associated complex. The motivic cohomology groups are then obtained by re-indexing the Chow groups: i HM (X, Z(n)) := CH n (X, 2n − i).
These groups behave like a cohomology theory only for smooth schemes X over a field F . If X is smooth (and equi-dimensional), then we have the i important fact that HM (X, Z(n)) vanishes for i > min(2n, n + dim X) ([Ge05, section 1.2.1]). In particular Lemma 5.4.1
i HM (F, Z(n)) = 0,
if i > n.
We will use Bloch’s definition in the last section, where the base ring is a Dedekind ring. Another definition of motivic cohomology with good properties even for non-smooth schemes over a field was – according to Voevodsky ([MVW06, page viii]) – first envisioned by Suslin in 1985, and then has been formalized by Suslin and Voevodsky ([SV00]): They define for any scheme of finite type X over F a motivic complex of sheaves in the Zariski or Nisnevic or ´etale topology. The motivic cohomology groups are then defined to be the Nisnevic hypercohomology groups of this complex of sheaves. They show ([SV00, Corollary 1.1.1])
108
Manfred Kolster
that in the case of smooth schemes these groups are isomorphic to the ones obtained using Zariski hypercohomology instead (see also [Vo00a, Theorem 5.7], [Vo00b] and [Ge05, section 1.2.4]). For more details we refer to the survey article by Kahn [Ka05]. Both definitions – using Bloch’s higher Chow groups or the complexes of Suslin–Voevodsky – of motivic cohomology coincide [Vo02] for smooth varieties over a field. To establish some functorial properties the Suslin– Voevodsky approach has to assume resolution of singularities, and hence these properties are only conjecturally true in characteristic p. In these cases the Chow group approach is often used, e.g., in the work of Levine [Le01] and Geisser–Levine ([GL01], [GL00]). The relation between motivic cohomology and Milnor K-theory for a field F is given by the following fundamental result, which is due independently to Totaro [To92] and Nesterenko–Suslin [NS90] (see also [MVW06, Theorem 5.1]): Theorem 5.4.2 isomorphisms
For any field F and any integer n ≥ 0 there are n KnM (F ) ∼ (F, Z(n). = HM
Using Lemma 5.4.1 we immediately obtain the conjectural property (1) in the list of Beilinson and Lichtenbaum: Corollary 5.4.3 an isomorphism
For all fields F and all primes l 6= char F there is n HM (F, Z/l(n)) ∼ = KnM (F )/l.
The conjectural property (3) in the list of Beilinson and Lichtenbaum was proved by Voevodsky in [Vo03, Theorem 6.1] – for a more ‘elementary’ proof see [MVW06, 10.2]: Theorem 5.4.4 then
If m is relatively prime to the characteristic of F , HLi (F, Z/m(n)) ∼ = H i (F, µ⊗n m ).
Combining this result with Theorem 5.4.2 shows that the Bloch–Kato Conjecture is a consequence of the Beilinson–Lichtenbaum Conjecture. One of the main results of Suslin and Voevodsky [SV00, Theorem 7.4] implies that the two conjectures are in fact equivalent:
Norm Residue and the Quillen–Lichtenbaum Conjecture
109
Theorem 5.4.5 If the Bloch–Kato Conjecture holds for the prime l, then the same is true for the Beilinson–Lichtenbaum Conjecture. The proof used resolution of singularities, but this assumption was later removed by Geisser and Levine in [GL01]. Another proof is given in [HW12, section 2.5]. Remark: It is worth noting that Suslin and Voevodsky only assumed the surjectivity of the norm residue homomorphisms.
5.5 Voevodsky We now try to present some of the structural ingredients in Voevodsky’s proof of the Norm Residue Theorem. We first look more closely at the homomorphism i HM (F, Z(n)) → HLi (F, Z(n))
induced from the change of sites. The kernel and cokernel of this map are torsion, since i HM (F, Q(n)) ∼ = HLi (F, Q(n)) n+1 [MVW06, Proposition 14.23]. Lemma 5.4.1 shows that HM (F, Z(n)) n+1 vanishes, and therefore HL (F, Z(n)) is a torsion group, and the ltorsion is then given by HLn+1 (F, Z(l) (n)).
We see that the 4th property in our list of conjectures of Beilinson and Lichtenbaum, Hilbert 90, is true for a field F if and only if HLn+1 (F, Z(l) (n)) vanishes for all primes l and all weights n. The only additional result needed here is due to Geisser and Levine [GL00, Theorem 8.6], who showed that for a field of characteristic l > 0, the group HLn+1 (F, Z(l) (n)) vanishes. Voevodsky’s idea was to show that the Bloch–Kato (and the Beilinson– Lichtenbaum) Conjecture is in fact equivalent to Hilbert 90, and therefore can be formulated in terms of the vanishing of a cohomology group. To make the relationship more precise for a fixed prime l and a fixed weight n, we introduce the following abbreviations (due to Voevodsky): We write H90(l, n) for the statement that for all fields F of characteristic other than l and for all weights k ≤ n the cohomology groups
110
Manfred Kolster
HLk+1 (F, Z(l) (k)) vanish. Similarly, we write BK(l, n) for the statement that for all fields F of characteristic 6= l and all k ≤ n the norm residue homomorphisms KkM (F )/l → H k (F, µ⊗k l ) are isomorphisms. We want to compare H90(l, n) and BK(l, n). The easy implication is: Proposition 5.5.1
BK(l, n) =⇒ H90(l, n).
Proof Multiplication by l and BK(l, n) produce the following commutative diagram for all k ≤ n: ·l
→ KkM (F ) → KkM (F ) → KkM (F )/l → 0 ∼ y y y= ·l
→ HLk (F, Z(k))→HLk (F, Z(k))→ HLk (F, Z/l(k)) → l HLk+1 (F, Z(k)) → 0 This implies that HLk+1 (F, Z(k)) has no l-torsion. The result follows, since HLk+1 (F, Z(l) (k)) is the l-torsion subgroup of HLk+1 (F, Z(k)). The final implication, which yielded that all three conjectures are equivalent, was proven by Voevodsky in [Vo11, section 6]: Theorem 5.5.2
H90(l, n) =⇒ BL(l, n).
The following result, which again is due to Voevodsky [Vo03, Lemma 6.11], explains why the central role played by the cohomological version of Hilbert 90 in proving the Bloch–Kato Conjecture is similar to the role played by the K-theoretic version of Hilbert 90 in the work of Merkurjev– Suslin: Proposition 5.5.3 If H90(l, n) holds, then Hilbert 90 holds for the Milnor K-groups KkM for all cyclic extensions E/F of degree l and all k ≤ n.
Voevodsky’s approach to prove H90(l, n) was to use induction on the weight n. A crucial step is the following result ([Vo03, Theorem 5.9]): Theorem 5.5.4 Assume that F is l-special and that KnM (F )/l = 0. If H90(l, n − 1) holds, then HLn+1 (F, Z(l) (n)) = 0.
Norm Residue and the Quillen–Lichtenbaum Conjecture
111
It is obvious that we can imitate now the method of Merkurjev–Suslin, which we sketched above to prove Theorem 5.3.2, to finish the proof of Hilbert 90, provided the following key problem can be solved: Given a symbol a ∈ KnM (F ) there exists a smooth projective variety Xa , so that the function field Fa := F (Xa ) has the following properties: a) a vanishes in KnM (Fa )/l. b) The map HLn+1 (F, Z(l) (n)) → HLn+1 (Fa , Z(l) (n)) is injective. For l = 2 good candidates for these varieties are the so-called Pfister quadrics, which generalize the Severi–Brauer varieties (the case n = 2): Given a1 , · · ·, an ∈ F ∗ /F ∗2 the associated Pfister quadric is given by the equation << a1 , · · ·, an−1 >>= an · t2 . It has dimension 2n−1 − 1. The main result in [Vo03] showed that the Pfister quadrics satisfy the two properties above. Voevodsky combined some unpublished work of Rost on properties of Pfister quadrics with motivic techniques he had developed earlier. This finished the proof of the Milnor Conjecture ([Vo03]). Theorem 5.5.5 (The Milnor Conjecture) For any field F of odd characteristic and any n ≥ 0 the norm residue homomorphism KnM (F )/2 → H 2 (F, Z/2) is an isomorphism. The construction of analogous varieties for odd primes l satisfying properties a) and b) above was again based on work of Rost ([Ro98], [HW09]) and extended by Suslin and Joukhovitski [SJ06] and Weibel [We09]. These varieties are now called Rost varieties. The last key part of Voevodsky’s proof [Vo11]) of the ‘other’ Bloch-Kato Conjecture was to verify that the Rost varieties indeed have the right properties: Theorem 5.5.6 (The Norm Residue Theorem) For any field F , any prime l 6= char F and any n ≥ 0 the norm residue homomorphism KnM (F )/l → H n (F, µ⊗n l ) is an isomorphism.
112
Manfred Kolster
5.6 Quillen–Lichtenbaum Let X be a smooth scheme over a field F . Another conjectural property in the list of Beilinson and Lichtenbaum was the existence of a natural spectral sequence of the form p−q E2p,q = HM (X, Z(−q)) =⇒ K−p−q (X),
which relates motivic cohomology to Quillen K-theory. This was proven by Bloch and Lichtenbaum [BL95] for fields and generalized to smooth schemes of finite type over a field by Friedlander and Suslin [FS02]. It seems that there was a gap in the construction of the spectral sequence in [BL95], however in the meantime other constructions of this motivic spectral sequence have been done by Grayson [Gr95] and Levine [Le01] and shown to be equivalent to those of Bloch and Lichtenbaum. Details about the various constructions of the motivic spectral sequence can be found in Grayson’s article [Gr05]. It was well known to the experts that the Bloch–Kato Conjecture in combination with the motivic spectral sequence implies the QuillenLichtenbaum Conjecture (formulated in Theorem 5.6.8 below). By the end of the 1990s Kahn [Ka97] and independently Rognes–Weibel [RW00] studied the much harder case of the prime 2, where they used the Milnor Conjecture, which had just been proven by Voevodsky, and the motivic spectral sequence to obtain the relation between the K-theory of the ring of integers oF in a number field F (tensored by Z2 ) and the ´etale cohomology groups of spec oF [1/2]. Their techniques combined with the Norm Residue Isomorphism can also be used to give a proof of the Quillen–Lichtenbaum Conjecture. In [Le01], [Le99] Levine generalized the motivic spectral sequence to smooth schemes of finite type over a commutative 1-dimensional base ring. This made it possible to compare K-theory, motivic cohomology and ´etale cohomology directly on the level of rings of integers in a number field without analyzing the motivic spectral sequence for number fields and then descend to rings of integers, and simplified the proof of the Quillen–Lichtenbaum Conjecture. Levine followed this approach in his (unpublished) paper [Le99, section 14]. We combine ideas of Levine and of Kahn from his (unpublished) paper [Ka97] to sketch a proof of the Quillen–Lichtenbaum Conjecture. Let F be a number field, and let oF denote the ring of integers of F . We fix an arbitrary prime l and want to show first that an analogue of the
Norm Residue and the Quillen–Lichtenbaum Conjecture
113
∗ Beilinson–Lichtenbaum Conjecture holds for oF . We write HM (oF , •) ∗ instead of HM (spec oF , •) and similarly for ´etale cohomology. We also write o0F for oF [1/l].
Lemma 5.6.1
There are isomorphisms i HM (oF , Z/l(n)) → H´eit (o0F , µ⊗n l )
for all i ≤ n, and there is an isomorphism n+1 ⊗n n+1 ⊗n 0 HM (oF , Z/l(n)) ∼ = ker (H´en+1 t (oF , µl ) → H´ et (F, µl )).
Proof This follows from the commutative diagram of localization sequences for motivic cohomology – due to Geisser [Ge04] – and for ´etale cohomology – due to Soul´e [So79] – using the Beilinson–Lichtenbaum n+1 Conjecture for fields for n ≤ i and the fact that HM (F, Z(n)) = 0: i−2 i i · · · ⊕v H M (kv , Z/l(n − 1))→HM (oF , Z/l(n))→HM (F, Z/l(n)) → · · · ∼ ∼ =y =y y i i · · · ⊕v H´ei−2 et (oF , Z/l(n)) → H´ et (F, Z/l(n)) → · · · t (kv , Z/l(n − 1))→ H´
We now look at Levine’s spectral sequence for spec oF : p−q E2p,q = HM (oF , Z(−q)) =⇒ K−p−q (oF ).
In [Le99, Theorem 9.7] Levine shows that this integral motivic spectral sequence has properties similar to the field case with respect to the action of the Adams operations ψ k , k > 0, which are due to Soul´e ([So95], [GS99, Theorem 7]). The action of ψ k on the spectral sequence converges to the action of ψ on K−p−q (oF ), and ψ k acts on Erp,q , r ≥ 2, by multiplication by k −q . k
As usual this implies that the differentials of the spectral sequence are torsion, hence n−2i Kn (oF ) ⊗ Q ∼ (oF , Q(n − i)). = ⊕i∈Z HM
However – as Kahn observed ([Ka97, Corollary 2.2], [Ka05, section 4.3.2]) – there is a stronger implication:
114
Manfred Kolster
Proposition 5.6.2 Up to groups of finite exponent the K-group Kn (oF ) is a direct sum of motivic cohomology groups M n−2i Kn (oF ) = HM (oF , Z(n − i)). i∈Z
A fundamental result of Borel [Bo77] states that the K-groups Kn (oF ) are finite for even n ≥ 2 and finitely generated for odd n ≥ 1. Combining this with Proposition 5.6.2 we obtain in particular: n−2i Corollary 5.6.3 The motivic cohomology groups HM (oF , Z(n − i)) have no non-trivial divisible subgroups.
We combine this now with Lemma 5.6.1 to obtain the first main result comparing motivic cohomology groups of rings of integers to ´etale cohomology groups: Theorem 5.6.4 Let oF denote the ring of integers in a number field F , and let n ≥ 2. For each prime l and for all k ≤ n there are isomorphisms k HM (oF , Z(n)) ⊗ Zl ∼ = H´ekt (o0F , Zl (n)).
Proof Given a prime l we compare the long exact sequences in motivic cohomology (tensored with Zl ) and ´etale cohomology, associated to the short exact sequence of complexes ·l
0 → Z(n) → Z(n)→Z/l(n) → 0. We obtain the following commutative diagram, where the sequences end at k = n ≥ 2: ·l
·l
k+1 k k · · · →HM (oF , Z(n)) ⊗ Zl →HM (oF , Z/l(n))→HM (oF , Z(n)) ⊗ Zl → · · · ∼ fk+1 y fk y =y ·l
··· →
H´ekt (o0F , Zl (n))
·l
0 → H´ekt (o0F , Z/l(n)) → H´ek+1 t (oF , Zl (n)) → · · ·
The following Lemma, which is easily proved, provides information about the kernels and cokernels of the maps fk : Lemma 5.6.5
Let ·r
C −−−−→ A −−−−→ A −−−−→ o fy fy y ·r
B o y
C 0 −−−−→ A0 −−−−→ A0 −−−−→ B 0
Norm Residue and the Quillen–Lichtenbaum Conjecture
115
be a commutative diagram of abelian groups, such that the first and the last vertical arrows are isomorphisms and the map f is given by multiplication by a positive integer r. Then multiplication by r is surjective on ker f and injective on coker f . Returning now to the maps fk we immediately see that all maps fk are injective, since the motivic cohomology groups do not contain any nontrivial divisible subgroups, and the kernel of fk is l-divisible. Moreover, there is an isomorphism ∼
coker fk−1 /l → l ker fk , so that the vanishing of ker fk implies that coker fk−1 is l-divisible, hence trivial. This finishes the proof. As a consequence we obtain the following results about the structure k of the motivic cohomology groups HM (oF , Z(n)) for n ≥ 2: Theorem 5.6.6 Let F be a number field with ring of integers oF . Let r1 (F ) (resp. r2 (F )) denote the number of real (resp. pairs of conjugate complex) embeddings of F . For any n ≥ 2 we have: k 1. HM (oF , Z(n)) = 0 if k ≤ 0 or k > n.
2. For 3 ≤ k ≤ n:
k HM (oF , Z(n))
∼ =
( (Z/2Z)r1 0
if k + n is even if k + n is odd.
2 3. HM (oF , Z(n)) is torsion. 1 4. The rank of HM (oF , Z(n)) is equal to
1 rkZ HM (oF , Z(n))
=
( r1 (F ) + r2 (F ) r2 (F )
if n is odd if n is even
and the torsion subgroup is isomorphic to H 0 (F, Q/Z(n)). Proof The results of Theorem 5.6.4 allow us to use the corresponding results for ´etale cohomology groups (see e.g., [Ko04, section 2] for details about the structure of the ´etale cohomology groups of rings of integers).
116
Manfred Kolster
This proves items 1., 2. and 3. except if k = n + 1. But the localization sequence in ´etale cohomology shows that H´eit (o0F , Zl (n)) ∼ = H´eit (F, Zl (n)) n+1 for i ≥ 3, so that HM (oF , Z(n)) = 0 as claimed. k We see in particular that all motivic cohomology groups HM (oF , Z(n)) are torsion for k 6= 1, and therefore the motivic spectral sequence im1 plies that the rank of HM (oF , Z(n)) is equal to the rank of the K-group K2n−1 (oF ), which has been determined by Borel [Bo77] for n ≥ 2 to be equal to r1 (F ) + r2 (F ), if n is odd, and to r2 (F ), if n is even. 1 Again we get from Theorem 5.6.4 that the l-torsion in HM (oF , Z(n)) 1 0 is equal to the torsion subgroup of H´et (oF , Zl (n)), which in turn is isomorphic to H 0 (F, Ql /Zl (n)), hence we obtain the statement about the 1 torsion in HM (oF , Z(n)) as well.
Let us now consider an odd prime number l. We tensor Levine’s integral motivic spectral sequence by Zl . From Theorem 5.6.6 we obtain that the E2 -terms E2p,q ⊗ Zl vanish except possibly for k := p − q = 1, 2. Therefore after tensoring by Zl the motivic cohomology sequence degenerates and we obtain: Theorem 5.6.7
For odd primes l we have
k K2n−k (oF ) ⊗ Zl ∼ (oF , Z(n)) ⊗ Zl = HM
for k = 1, 2.
Remark: An important consequence is the fact that the motivic coho2 mology group HM (oF , Z(n)) is finitely generated as an abelian group, a result that improves Theorem 5.6.6. Combining the results of Theorem 5.6.7 and Theorem 5.6.4 we finally obtain: Theorem 5.6.8 (Quillen–Lichtenbaum Conjecture) natural isomorphisms for any odd prime l and n ≥ 2: K2n−k (oF ) ⊗ Zl ∼ = H´ekt (o0F , Zl (n))
There are
for k = 1, 2.
We note that the surjectivity of the maps in Theorem 5.6.8 was proven by Soul´e for n even [So79, Theorem 6 (iii)] and – using ´etale K-theory – by Dwyer–Friedlander for all n [DF85]. The Quillen–Lichtenbaum Conjecture was explicitly formulated by
Norm Residue and the Quillen–Lichtenbaum Conjecture
117
Quillen in 1974 [Q74, section 9, p.175], although he must have talked about it at least 2 years earlier, because Lichtenbaum [Li73, Conjecture 2.5] stated the conjecture in 1972 and attributed it to Quillen.
References [Be87] Beilinson, A. A. 1987. Height pairing between algebraic cycles. Ktheory, arithmetic and geometry (Moscow, 1984–1986). Lecture Notes in Math., 1289, 1–25. Berlin: Springer. [Bl80] Bloch, S. 1980. Lectures on Algebraic Cycles. Duke University Mathematics Series IV. Duke University. [Bl86] Bloch, S. 1986. Algebraic cycles and higher K-theory. Adv. Math., 61, 267–304. [Bl10] Bloch, S. 2010. Lectures on Algebraic Cycles, Second Edition. New Mathematical Monographs, 16. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press. [BL95] Bloch, S., and Lichtenbaum, S. 1995. A spectral sequence for motivic cohomology. Unpublished. [BK90] Bloch, S., and Kato, K. 1986. p-adic cohomology. Publ.Math.de ´ l’I.H.E.S., 63, 107–152. [Bo77] Borel, A. 1977. Stable real cohomology of arithmetic groups. Ann. ´ Sci. Ecole Norm. Sup., 7, 613–636. [BT73] Bass, H., and Tate, J. 1973. The Milnor ring of a global field (with an appendix on euclidean quadratic imaginary fields, by J. Tate). Algebraic K-theory, II: “Classical” algebraic K-theory and connections with arithmetic (Proc. Conf., Battelle Memorial Inst., Seattle, Wash., 1972). Lecture Notes in Math., 342, 349–446. Berlin: Springer. [DF85] Dwyer, W, and Friedlander, E. 1985. Algebraic and ´etale K-theory. Trans. Amer. Math. Soc., 292 (1), 247–280. [FS02] Friedlander, E., and Suslin, A. 2002. The spectral sequence relating ´ algebraic K-theory to motivic cohomology. Ann. Sci. Ecole Norm. Sup. (4), 35 (6), 773–875. [Ge04] Geisser, Th. 2004. Motivic cohomology over Dedekind rings. Math. Z., 248 (4), 773–794. [Ge05] Geisser, Th. 2005. Motivic Cohomology, K-Theory and Topological Cyclic Homology. Handbook of K-Theory, 193–234. Berlin, New York: Springer. [GL00] Geisser, Th., and Levine, M. 2000. The p-part of K-theory of fields in characteristic p. Invent. Math., 139, 459–494. [GL01] Geisser, Th., and Levine, M. 2001. The Bloch-Kato conjecture and a theorem of Suslin-Voevodsky. J. Reine Angew. Math., 530, 55–103. [GS06] Gille, Ph., and Szamuely, T. 2006. Central Simple Algebras and Galois Cohomolog. Cambridge Studies in Advanced Mathematics, 101. Cambridge UK: Cambridge University Press.
118
Manfred Kolster
[GS99] Gillet, H., and Soul´e, C. 1999. Filtrations on higher algebraic Ktheory. Algebraic K-theory (Seattle, WA, 1997). Proc. Sympos. Pure Math., 67, 89–148. Providence, RI: Amer. Math. Soc. [Gr95] Grayson, D. 1995. Weight filtrations via commuting automorphisms. K-Theory, 9 (2), 139–172. [Gr05] Grayson, D. 2005. The Motivic Spectral Sequence. Handbook of KTheory, 39–70. Berlin, New York: Springer. [HW12] Haesemeyer, C., and Weibel, Ch. The Norm Residue Theorem in Motivic Cohomology. Preprint 2012. [HW09] Haesemeyer, C., and Weibel, Ch. 2009. Norm varieties and the chain lemma (after Markus Rost). Abel Symposium, 95–130. Berlin: Springer. [Ka97] Kahn, B. 1997. The Quillen-Lichtenbaum Conjecture at the prime 2. Unpublished. [Ka05] Kahn, B. 2005. Algebraic K-Theory, Algebraic Cycles and Arithmetic Geometry. Handbook of K-Theory, 351–428. Berlin, New York: Springer. [Kt80] Kato, K. 1980. A generalization of local class field theory by using K-groups. II. J. Fac. Sci. Univ. Tokyo Sect. IA Math., 27 (3), 603–683. [Ko04] Kolster, M. 2004. K-theory and arithmetic. Pages 191–258 (electronic) of: Contemporary developments in algebraic K-theory. ICTP Lect. Notes, XV. Trieste. [Le99] Levine, M. 1999. K-theory and motivic cohomology of schemes. Unpublished. [Le01] Levine, M. 2001. Techniques of localization in the theory of algebraic cycles. J. Alg. Geom, 10, 299–363. [Li73] Lichtenbaum, S. 1973. Values of zeta-functions, ´etale cohomology, and algebraic K-theory. Algebraic K-theory, II: “Classical” algebraic Ktheory and connections with arithmetic (Proc. Conf., Battelle Memorial Inst., Seattle, Wash., 1972). Lecture Notes in Math., 342, 489–501. Berlin: Springer. [Li83] Lichtenbaum, S. 1983. Values of zeta-functions at negative integers. Number Theory. Lecture Notes in Math., 1068, 127–138. Berlin: Springer. [MVW06] Mazza, C., Voevodsky, V., and Weibel, Ch. 2006. Lecture notes on motivic cohomology. Clay Mathematics Monographs, 2. Providence, RI: American Mathematical Society. [Me82] Merkurjev, A. S. 1982. On the norm residue symbol of degree 2. Soviet Math. Dokl., 1546–1551. [MS83] Merkurjev, A. S., and Suslin, A. A. 1983. K-cohomology of SeveriBrauer varieties and the norm residue homomorphism (in Russian). English trans.: Math. USSR Izv., 21, 307–340. [MS91] Merkurjev, A. S., and Suslin, A. A. 1991. The norm residue homomorphism of degree 3 (in Russian). English trans.: Math. USSR Izv., 36, 349–367. [Mi70] Milnor, J. 1970. Algebraic K-theory and quadratic forms. Invent. math., 9, 318–344. [Mi71] Milnor, J. 1971. Introduction to algebraic K-theory. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press. Annals of Mathematics Studies, no. 72.
Norm Residue and the Quillen–Lichtenbaum Conjecture
119
[NS90] Nesterenko, Yu., and Suslin, A. A. 1990. Homology of the general linear group over a local ring, and Milnor’s K-theory (in Russian). English trans.: Math. USSR Izv., 34, 121–146. [OVV07] Orlov, D., Vishik, A., and Voevodsky, V. 2007. An exact sequence for K∗M /2 with applications to quadratic forms. Ann. of Math., 165 (1), 1–13. [Q73] Quillen, D. 1973. Higher algebraic K-theory I. Algebraic K-theory, I: Higher K-Theories, (Proc. Conf., Battelle Memorial Inst., Seattle, Wash., 1972). Lecture Notes in Math., 341, 81–147. Berlin: Springer. [Q74] Quillen, D. 1974. Higher Algebraic K-theory. Proc. of the International Congress of Mathematicians, 1, 171–176. Vancouver, BC. [RW00] Rognes, J., and Weibel, C. 2000. Two-primary algebraic K-theory of rings of integers in number fields. J. Amer. Math. Soc., 13 (1), 1–54. Appendix A by M. Kolster. [Ro98] Rost, M. 1998. Chain lemma for splitting fields of symbols. Unpublished. [Se79] Serre, J.-P. 1979. Local fields. Graduate Texts in Mathematics, 67. New York: Springer. [So79] Soul´e, C. 1979. K-th´eorie des anneaux d’entiers de corps de nombres et cohomologie ´etale. Invent. Math., 55 (3), 251–295. [So95] Soul´e, C. Feb. 8, 1995. Letter to Bloch and Lichtenbaum. [Sr91] Srinivas, V. 1991. Algebraic K-Theory. Progress in Mathematics, 90. Boston: Birkh¨ auser. [SV00] Suslin, A., and Voevodsky, V. 2000. Bloch-Kato conjecture and motivic cohomology with finite coefficients. The arithmetic and geometry of algebraic cycles (Banff, AB, 1998). NATO Sci. Ser. C Math. Phys. Sci., 548, 117–189. Dordrecht: Kluwer Acad. Publ. [Su85] Suslin, A. A. 1985. Algebraic K-theory and the norm residue homomorphism. J. of Math. Sciences, 30 (6), 2556–2611. [SJ06] Suslin, A. A., and Joukhovitski, S. 2006. Norm varieties. J. Pure Appl. Algebra, 206 (1–2), 245–276. [Sw85] Swan, R. 1985. K-Theory of Quadric Hypersurfaces. Ann. of Math., 122 (1), 113–153. [Ta76] Tate, John. 1976. Relations between K2 and Galois cohomology. Invent. Math., 36, 257–274. [To92] Totaro, B. 1992. Milnor’s K-theory is the simplest part of algebraic K-theory. K-theory, 6, 177–189. [Vo96] Voevodsky, V. 1996. The Milnor Conjecture. Unpublished. [Vo00a] Voevodsky, V. 2000a. Cohomological theory of presheaves with transfers. Cycles, transfers and motivic homology theories. Annals of Mathematics Studies, 143, 87–137. Princeton: Princeton University Press. [Vo00b] Voevodsky, V. 2000b. Triangulated categories of motives over a field. Cycles, transfers, and motivic homology theories. Annals of Mathematical Studies, 143, 87–137. Princeton: Princeton University Press. [Vo02] Voevodsky, V. 2002. Motivic cohomology groups are isomorphic to higher Chow groups in any characteristic. Int. Mat. Res. Notices, 7, 331–355.
120
Manfred Kolster
[Vo03] Voevodsky, V. 2003. Motivic cohomology with Z/2-coefficients. Publ. ´ Math. de l’I.H.E.S., 98, 59–104. [Vo11] Voevodsky, V. 2011. On motivic cohomology with Z/l-coefficients. Ann. of Math., 174, 401–438. [VSF00] Voevodsky, V., Suslin, A., and Friedlander, E. M. 2000. Cycles, transfers, and motivic homology theories. Annals of Mathematics Studies, 143. Princeton: Princeton University Press. [We09] Weibel, Ch. 2009. The norm residue isomorphism theorem. J. Topology, 2, 346–372.
6 Regulators and Zeta-functions Stephen Lichtenbaum
6.1 Introduction This is just a short note recalling the different definitions of higher Ktheory regulators, what the relations are between them, and various formulas in the literature relating them to special values of Dedekind zeta-functions. We will explain the relationships among these formulas, and correct several inaccurate statements in the literature. Let F be a number field, OF the ring of integers in F , ζ(F, s) the Dedekind zeta function of F , and dF the discriminant of F . Let ζ ∗ (F, u) be the limit as s goes to u of ζ(F, u)(s−u)−cu , where cu is the order of the zero of ζ(F, s) at s = u. Let n = [F : Q] = r1 + 2r2 .. Let m be an integer ≥ 2. Let am = r2 if m is even and r1 +r2 if m is odd, and let bm = n−am . Note that Borel [Bo77] proved that the rank of K2m−1 (OF ) is equal to am . Recall that the natural map from K2m−1 (OF ) to K2m−1 (F ) is an isomorphism. Let x and y be in C∗ . Define x ∼ y if and only if x/y is a non-zero rational number. If V is a finite-dimensional vector space, let Λ(V ) denote the highest exterior power of V . We recall the functional equation of the zeta-function from [La70], p.254: Let φ(F, s) = Γ(s/2)r1 Γ(s)r2 (2−r2 |dF |1/2 π −n/2 )s ζ(F, s). Then we have the functional equation φ(F, s) = φ(F, 1 − s). It is an immediate consequence of the functional equation that ζ(F, m) ∼ π nm−am Brown University, Providence, USA. e-mail : [email protected]
p
|dF |
−1 ∗
ζ (F, 1 − m).
(6.1)
122
Stephen Lichtenbaum
6.2 Regulators We start by discussing the general regulator framework. On the one hand we have groups K2m−1 (OF ), which have rank am by Borel’s theorem. Let x1 , . . . xam be a basis of K2m−1 (OF ) modulo torsion. Let σi run through the embeddings of F into C, but choose only one from each pair of conjugate embeddings, as usual. The σ’s induce natural maps from K2m−1 (OF ) to K2m−1 (C). We should have ‘higher logarithm’ maps Tm (sometimes called ‘regulator maps’, but we would like to reserve the word ‘regulator’ for the determinant, as in the classical case) from K2m−1 (C) to C. (These maps should be in some sense polylogarithms, but since the actual relation is unknown we will call them ‘higher logarithms’ to avoid confusion). If m is even, combining the map Tm with the r2 non-real embeddings σj induces a map Tm,F from K2m−1 (OF ) ⊗ C to Cr2 = Cam . If m is odd, we take all the am = r1 + r2 embeddings to again get a map into Cam . We will consider three different ways of defining such higher logarithm maps. The first one is Beilinson’s Chern class map. We will define it in general, and then specialize to the number field setting. To define this map we need to consider Deligne cohomology. Let Y be a smooth and projective scheme of finite type over R, and let YC = Y ×R C. There exists a natural period isomorphism β from the Betti cohomology HB (YC , C) to the de Rham cohomology HDR (YC ). The involution F∞ of YC induced by complex conjugation on C induces involutions F∞,B on HB (YC ) and F∞,DR on HDR (YC ). We may identify HDR (Y ) with HDR (YC )F∞,DR , and this is identified by β with the subspace of elements c of HB (YC , C) such that c = F∞,B (¯ c) ([De79], Proposition 1.4). Let M be the motive H i (YC , (Z(m)), and assume that the weight i − 2m ≤ −3. In this case we can define the motivic cohomology group i+1 H(M ) to be Hmot (YC , Q(m)), which we may take as grm (K2m−i−1 (YC )⊗ Q). (Here grm refers to Adams weight.) We next have the Betti cohomoli ogy HB (M ) = HB (YC , Z), and the tangent space tM , which is defined to be the hypercohomology H i (YC , OYC → ΩYC → Λ2 ΩYC . . . → Λm−1 ΩYC → 0) (ΩY = Ω1 (Y /Q)). We map HB (M ) to tM by composing the natural map from HB (YC , Z) to tM with multiplication by (2πi)m , and define the integral (resp. real) Deligne cohomology HD (M, Z) (resp. HD (M, R)) to be the cokernel tM /HB (M ) (resp. tM /HB (M ) ⊗ R)). As described in [RSS88] Chapter 1, Beilinson defines Chern class maps
Regulators and Zeta-functions
123
from H(M ) to HD (M, Z), and hence to HD (M, R). Beilinson shows that + the image of the Chern class maps lies in HD (M, R), which is defined to + F∞,DR F∞,B be (tM ) /(HB (Y ), R) . Let αM be the map from HB (M, C) to tM . We may identify HD (M, R) with a subspace of Coker αM such that (HD (M, R)) ⊗R C naturally identifies with Coker αM . Now let X be a projective and smooth scheme over Spec F , and ˜ for X which is regular and projective assume that there exists a model X over Spec OF . Let σ run through the embeddings of F into C. Let Xσ be X ×F C, where σ : F → C and Y = X ×Q R, so X ×Q C = YC . Let MX be the motive over Q given by H i (X, Z(m)). We define the motivic ˜ ⊗ Q in cohomology group H(MX ) to be the image of grm K2m−i−1 (X) ˜ grm K2m−i−1 (X) ⊗ Q. This is independent of the choice of X. Then Beilinson conjectures that the Chern class maps on H(Xσ ) induce an isomorphism from the motivic cohomology group H(MX ) ⊗ R to HD (Y, R), and hence from H(MX ) ⊗ C to Coker αM,X , where αM,X L + maps HB (MX ) to σ tMσ , where Mσ is the motive H i (Xσ , Z(m)). Now, let i = 0, and let X be a point, where we have the integral Deligne complex Z(m) : (2πi)m Z → C, and the real Deligne complex R(m) : (2πi)m R → C. Taking the first cohomology groups of these 1 complexes we obtain the integral Deligne cohomology HD (C, Z(m)) = m 1 C/(2πi) Z and the real Deligne cohomology HD (C, R(m)) = C/(2πi)m R. Then Beilinson Chern class maps go from K2m−1 (C) to C/(2πi)m Z, and hence to C/(2πi)m R, which we identify with im+1 R ⊆ C. We denote this Be map from K2m−1 (C) to C by Tm . Bo Borel also defines a higher logarithm map Tm , which ([Bu02], p.95) Bo Be satisfies Tm = 2Tm . We next look at the higher logarithm maps considered by Zagier [Za91] (which in this case are actually polylogarithm maps). We first consider the case m = 2, and let F be any field. In this case, by a theorem of Suslin [Su87], the indecomposable part of K3 (F ) maps with finite kernel onto a group B(F ) known as the Bloch group. The Bloch group is obtained by dividing the free abelian group on F ∗ by an infinite collection of relations coming from the functional equation for the dilogarithm, and then taking a certain subgroup of this. Consequently the single-valued version P2 of the dilogarithm (which has values in iR) induces a map from B(C) to iR and hence also from K3 (C) to iR, which as above we view as contained in C. We would like to be able to play this game in general, but we don’t know enough. We do, however, have a conjecture of Zagier ([Za91]). He first considers a single-valued version Pm of the m-th polylogarithm,
124
Stephen Lichtenbaum
which maps C to R. It is more natural to modify the definition by setting Qm equal to Pm if m is odd and iPm if m is even. In both cases we will view Qm as having values in C. Zagier defines analogous groups Bm (F ), (B2 (F ) = B(F )), which are subquotients of the free abelian group Z[F ∗ ] and such that Pm is well defined on Bm (C). Zagier then conjectures that we can identify Bm (F ) ⊗ Q with K2m−1 (F ) ⊗ Q, so that Qm induces a Z map Tm from K2m−1 (C) to C. Zagier also conjectures (Conjecture Z1) that his polylogarithm map is, up to a rational number, the one defined by Borel and Beilinson. In order to define a regulator, we need, in addition to the polylogarithm map T , a rational basis for Cam or, more precisely, a rational basis b for the exterior power Λ(Cam ). The map Tm,F induces a map ΛTm,F from Λ(K2m−1 (OF ) ⊗ C) to Λ(Cam ). If we let a be the basis of Λ(K2m−1 (OF ) ⊗ C) coming from K2m−1 (OF ), then the corresponding regulator is T (a)/b, well defined up to a non-zero rational number. Z The Zagier regulator Rm (F ) is obtained by choosing the standard basis for Cam . Based on considerable numerical evidence ([Gr81] and [Za91]), Zagier conjectures (Conjecture Z2) that we have the formula Z ζ(F, m) ∼ (2πi)mbm Rm
p
dF
−1
.
(6.2)
(Actually Zagier’s conjecture involves Pm rather than Qm , but it is easily seen to be equivalent to our statement above.) By the functional equation, Zagier’s conjecture is equivalent to: ζ ∗ (F, 1 − m) ∼ (2πi)am (1−m) RZ m.
(6.3)
Bo As renormalized by Burgos-Gil ([Bu02]), Borel’s regulator Rm is m−1 obtained by multiplying the standard basis by (2πi) , which implies, assuming Zagier’s conjecture on the equality of polylogarithms, am (1−m) Z RBo Rm , so Borel’s theorem: m = (2πi) Bo ζ ∗ (F, 1 − m) ∼ Rm
(6.4)
together with Conjecture Z1, implies Conjecture Z2. Borel’s theorem implies, using the functional equation, that Bo ζ(F, m) ∼ (2πi)mn−am Rm .
(6.5)
Remark: In [Za91], p.393, Zagier misapplies the functional equation,
Regulators and Zeta-functions
125
stating that 6.2 is equivalent to: p ζ(F, m) ∼ π mbm ( |dF |)−1 RBo m ,
(6.6)
which is not correct. Zagier thinks this should be true because he thinks his regulator is the same as Borel’s, but in fact a renormalization as indicated above is necessary. Note: In Borel’s original paper, the basis in effect is chosen to be (2πi)m (rather than (2πi)m−1 ) times the standard basis. We leave it to the reader to compute Borel’s original regulator formulas. We now go back to Beilinson’s regulator and Beilinson’s conjectures on special values of L-functions. We will give our version of Fontaine’s presentation ([Fo92]) of Beilinson’s conjecture and generalizations thereof. Let X be a regular scheme, projective over Spec F , and as above we ˜ projective over Spec OF . Let assume that X has a regular model X XC = X ×Q C. We will examine the conjectures for the motive M = H i (X, Z(m)). We will assume that the weight i − 2m is either ≤ −3 or ≥ 1, and we will give conjectures up to a non-zero rational number. We first consider the case when the weight is ≤ −3. In this case recall that i+1 we defined the motivic cohomology group H(M ) to be Hmot (X, Q(m)), ˜ which is the image of grm (K2m−i−1 (X) ⊗ Q) in grm (K2m−i−1 (X) ⊗ i Q). We next have the Betti cohomology HB (M ) = HB (XC , Q), and the tangent space tM.X , which is defined to be the hypercohomology H i (X, OX → ΩX → Λ2 ΩX . . . → Λm−1 ΩX → 0) (ΩX = Ω1 (X/Q)). We next recall the period map from HB (M ) ⊗ C to HDR (M ) ⊗ C, which induces a map which we call αM,X from (HB (M ) ⊗ C)+ to tM ⊗ C, where (HB (M ) ⊗ C)+ is the subgroup of HB (M ) left fixed by the automorphism induced by complex conjugation on the scheme XC and complex conjugation acting on the coefficients. As we have seen, Beilinson defines a Chern class map from H(M ) to + the integral Deligne cohomology H(D,Z) (M ), and hence also to the real + Deligne cohomology H(D,R) (M ). This is naturally a real subspace of + Coker αM , such that HD (M ) ⊗ C is naturally isomorphic to Coker αM . Beilinson’s conjecture implies that the induced map θM from H(M )⊗R C to Coker αM is an isomorphism of complex vector spaces. We would like to go one step further. We have the cohomology sequence arising from integral Deligne cohomology, as described on page 8 of [RSS88]. 0 → HB (M ) → tM ⊗ C → H(D,Z) (M ) → 0.
(6.7)
126
Stephen Lichtenbaum
Recall that the map from HB (M ) to tM ⊗ C is given by the usual period map multiplied by (2πi)m . The involution given by complex conjugation on the scheme on Betti cohomology and complex conjugation on the coefficients is compatible with the involution on the coefficients of de Rham cohomology. Applying this we have the exact sequence: + + 0 → HB (M ) → tM ⊗ R → H(D,Z) (M ) → 0.
(6.8)
Taking the pull-back of this exact sequence by means of the Beilinson + Chern class map from H(M ) to H(D,Z) (M ), we obtain + 0 → HB (M ) → Hζ1 (M ) → H(M ) → 0,
(6.9)
where this sequence serves to define Hζ1 (M ). This immediately defines a map from Hζ1 (M )⊗R to tM ⊗R, and hence a map θM from Hζ1 (M ) ⊗ C to tM ⊗ C. The above Beilinson conjecture + implies that this map is also an isomorphism. Since HB (M ) and H(M ) are finite dimensional Q-spaces, so is Hζ1 (M ), so both of the C-spaces Hζ1 (M ) ⊗ C and tM ⊗ C have natural Q-structures. Conjecture 6.2.1 The determinant of θM taken with respect to the bases coming from the natural Q-structures is, up to a non-zero rational number, L∗ (M ). In the number field case, let M = H 0 (X, Z(m)) with m ≥ 2 and o we will call RF m (F ) the Fontaine regulator, i.e., the determinant of the map induced by the Chern class map from Λ(H(M ) ⊗ C) to Λ(HD (M )), where we use the rational basis of H(M ) ⊗ Q, and we identify HD (M ) with Cam and choose the standard basis of Cam . (The rational basis of (HB (M ) ⊗ C)+ is given by multiplying a rational basis of HB (X)+ by (2πi)m .) It is an easy computation from Conjecture 6.2.1 that p (−1) Fo ζ(F, m) ∼ (2πi)bm Rm (F ) dF . (6.10) L Note that tM ⊗C is isomorphic to σ tMσ , but the natural Q-structures L are different. In the number field case, tM is OF ⊗ Q, and σ tMσ is L L Q-structure σ Q. The difference between σ C, which has the natural √ these two Q-structures is dF . Note also that for these weights Beilinson does not give a conjecture about the special values of L-functions. Bloch and Kato do in [BK90], and Fontaine does also in [Fo92]; this conjecture should be compatible with both of these. Both of these conjectures are meant to be valid up
Regulators and Zeta-functions
127
to sign, not just up to rational numbers, but we will discuss the more precise compatibility in a later paper. Finally, we consider the special value conjectures if the weight is ≥ 1. Here there is no Bloch–Kato conjecture, so we will make a conjecture and discuss its relation to those of Fontaine and Beilinson. In the previous weight range, we had Ker αM = 0 and in this dual weight range we have Coker αM = 0. Let N = M ∗ (1) be the dual motive to M , so that as in [Fo92] Ker αM is the dual complex vector space to Coker αN . We define the motivic cohomology Q-space Hc (M ) to be Hom (H(N ), Q). The dual of Beilinson’s higher logarithm map for N is now a map γM from Ker αM to Hc (M ) ⊗ C. In order to extend our conjecture, we need something like a Q-structure on Ker αM . This time we start with the exact sequence + 0 → Ker αM → HB (M ) → tM ⊗ C → 0,
(6.11)
and we take the push-out coming from the map γM . This produces an exact sequence 0 → Hc (M ) ⊗ C → Hζ2 (M ) → tM ⊗ C → 0,
(6.12)
and this sequence serves to define Hζ2 (M ). We have natural Q-structures on Hc (M ) ⊗ C and tM ⊗ C, but these do not combine to produce a Q-structure on Hζ2 (M ). However, they do give rise to Q-structures on the determinants Λ(Hc (M ) ⊗ C) and 2 Λ(tM ⊗ C), which gives rise to a Q-structure on Λ(Hζ(M ) ). Coming from our push-out diagram, we get a natural map, which we again call θM + 2 from HB (M ) ⊗ C to Hζ(M ) . Using this Q-structure, we again have: Conjecture 6.2.2 The determinant of Λ(θM ) taken with respect to 2 the bases coming from the natural Q-structures on Λ(Hζ(M ) ) and on + ∗ Λ(HB (M )) is, up to a non-zero rational number, L (M ). This conjecture in principle agrees with that of Fontaine, although Fontaine does not give enough details in this case for us to be absolutely sure that this is what he is saying. Fontaine also claims that his conjecture here is consistent with that of Bloch–Kato, so ours should be also. Fontaine says that his conjecture agrees with Beilinson’s, but misquotes Beilinson’s to have it say that L∗ (N) is equal to the determinant of Λ(θN ).
128
Stephen Lichtenbaum
Fontaine, in a footnote, restates Beilinson’s description of how to obtain a rational basis of Deligne cohomology, but this is not compatible with his own formalism (which we have explained above). As for Beilinson, his conjecture ([RSS88], p.31, conjecture II), would at first glance seem to say that L∗ (M ) is equal to the determinant of Λ(θN ), which is obviously false. However, Beilinson puts a different Qstructure on the Deligne cohomology, coming from the relation + i Λ(F m (HDR (XR ) ⊗R ΛHD (X, R(n) ' Λ(H i (X(C), R(n − 1)−1)
n−1
. (6.13) Jannsen shows in [Ja88] 4.9 that this conjecture is consistent with Conjecture 6.2.1, but the more natural way to view the picture is via Fontaine’s analysis as reflected in our conjecture 6.2.2. Even though Beilinson’s conjecture is in fact correct (or at least equivalent to that of Fontaine, which should be correct), it involves making, as Jannsen says, an ‘ad hoc’ choice of basis for Deligne cohomology. In the number field case, with M = H 0 (X, Z(1 − m)), m ≥ 2. we have + tM = 0, so we may identify Hζ2 (M ) with HB (M ) ⊗ C. This may in turn am be identified with C but with the basis equal to the standard basis for Cam multiplied by (2πi)1−m . Conjecture 6.2.2 then says that for m ≥ 2 we have Fo ζ(F, 1 − m) ∼ (2πi)am (1−m) Rm ,
(6.14)
which is compatible with the hypothesis that the Fontaine regulator is the Zagier regulator, and of course with Conjecture 6.2.1 in the number field case and the functional equation.
References [BK90] Bloch, S., and Kato, K. 1990. L-functions and Tamagawa numbers of motives in The Grothendieck Festschrift. vol. 1. Prog. in Math., 86. 333–400. Birkh¨ auser, Boston. [Bo77] Borel, A. 1977. Cohomologie de SLn et valeurs de fonctions zeta aux points entiers. Ann. Scuola Normale Superiore (4), 613–636. [Bu02] Burgos Gil, J. I. 2002. The Regulators of Beilinson and Borel. American Math. Society, Providence, RI. [De79] Deligne, P. 1979. Valeurs de fonctions L, in Automorphic Forms, Representations, and L-functions, II (Oregon State Univ. Corvallis, OR,
Regulators and Zeta-functions
129
1977). Proc. Sympos. Pure Math. 33, 313–346, Amer. Math. Soc., Providence, RI. [Fo92] Fontaine, J.-M. 1992. Valeurs speciales des fonctions L des motifs. Seminaire Bourbaki, 1991/92, Asterisque no. 206, Exp. no. 751, 4, 205–249. [Gr81] Grayson, D. 1981. Dilogarithm computations for K3, Algebraic Ktheory, Evanston 1980 (Proc. Conf., Northwestern Univ., Evanston, Ill., 1980). Lecture Notes in Math., 854, 168–178, Springer, Berlin. [Ja88] Jannsen, U. 1988. Deligne Homology, Hodge D-conjecture, and Motives in Beilinson’s Conjectures on Special Values of L-functions (edited by M. Rapoport, N. Schappacher, and P. Schneider), Academic Press. [La70] Lang, S. 1970. Algebraic Number Theory. Addison-Wesley, Reading, Mass. [Li75] Lichtenbaum, S. 1975. Values of zeta-functions, `etale cohomology, and algebraic K-theory. Algebraic K-theory II Springer Lecturer Notes in Mathematics, 342, 489-501. [RSS88] Rapoport, M., Schappacher, N., and Schneider, P. 1988. Beilinson’s Conjectures on Special Values of L-functions (edited by M. Rapoport, N. Schappacher, and P. Schneider), Academic Press. [Su87] Suslin, A.-A. 1987. Algebraic K-theory of fields. Proceedings of the International Congress of Mathematicians, 1–2, 222–244 (Berkeley, Calif., 1986). Amer. Math. Soc., Providence, RI. [Za91] Zagier, D. 1991. Polylogarithms, Dedekind zeta-functions, and algebraic K-theory of fields, in Arithmetic Algebraic Geometry, Prog. in Math. 89. Birkh¨ auser, Boston, p.3
7 Soul´e’s Theorem Stephen Lichtenbaum
7.1 Introduction Notation: Let p be an odd prime number, F be a number field and OF be the ring of integers in F . Let S be the set of primes of OF lying over p and A = (OF )S = OF [1/p]. Let j be the natural inclusion of Spec F in X = Spec A. Let kv be the residue field of OF at the discrete valuation v, let FS be the maximal extension of F unramified outside of S, and let GS be the Galois group of FS over F . Let Wp (n) denote the GF -module consisting of all p-power roots of unity, with GF acting by σ ∗ (ζ) = σ n (ζ), this latter action being the usual one. Note that the p-power roots of unity Wp in this notation are Wp (1). In this chapter, we are going to sketch the proofs of two important theorems which will be needed later in this volume. Theorem A: H 2 (GS , Wp (n)) = 0 for all n ≥ 2. Theorem B: The natural map from K-theory to ´etale K-theory induces et a surjective map from K2n−1 (A)⊗Zp to K2n−1 (A, Zp ) ∼ = H 1 (Xet , Zp (n)). The proof of Theorem A is taken from [So79], with an emendation from [So84], while the proof of Theorem B follows [DF85], with the deep topological parts omitted. We refer to [Su15] for the definitions of the various Chern class maps used in Lemma 7.2.1 and for her Theorem 2.8.1. Note that k below only has the values 1 and 2. Let OF be a discrete valuation ring with fraction field F and residue field kv . Brown University, Providence, USA. e-mail: [email protected]
Soul´e’s Theorem
131
7.2 Proof of Theorem A Lemma 7.2.1
The following diagram commutes: ∂¯
K2n−1 (OF , Z/pm ) −−−−→ K2n−1 (F, Z/pm ) −−−v−→ K2n−2 (kv , Z/pm ) c¯ c¯ (1−n)¯ cn−1,k−1 y y n,k y n.k H ! (OF , Wp (n))
−−−−→
H 1 (F, Wp (n))
∂
−−−v−→ H 0 (kv , Wp (n − 1)).
Proof: It is clear that the left hand square commutes, and consequently that the right hand square commutes for any element in the kernel of ∂¯v . We may assume that F is complete for v. Let q = pm . Let π be a uniformizing parameter for F . Let π˙ be the image of π in K1 (F, Z/q). Let rv denote reduction modulo v. Let s denote a section of rv in either K-theory or ´etale cohomology. (The existence of such a section follows from [HS75] p.27.) Let sπ (x) = π.s(x), ˙ for x in K2n−2 (kv , Z/q), so sπ (x) is in K2n−1 (F, Z/q). We first observe that ∂(sπ (x)) = ∂(π.r ˙ v (s(x))) = ∂(π.x) ˙ = x. Since we know the commutativity of the right hand square for elements in the kernel of ∂v , it suffices to prove it for elements in the image of sπ . a) c¯n,k (sπ (x)) = c¯n.k (π.s(x)) ˙ = (n − 1)π˙ ∪ c¯n−1,k−1 s(x)), by b) c¯n−1.k−1 (s(x) = rv−1 (rv c¯n−1.k−1 (s(x) = rv−1 (¯ cn−1,k−1 x)). (Note that rv is an isomorphism on ´etale cohomology, so rv−1 is well defined, and also that the Chern classes commute with rv .) This implies c) c¯n,k (sπ (x) = (n − 1)sπ (¯ cn−1,k−1 (x)), which immediately implies the commutativity of the right hand square for elements in the image of sπ . Theorem 7.2.2 The long exact localization sequence for the algebraic K-theory of a Dedekind domain A breaks up, if A is the ring of integers in a number field, into short exact sequences 0 → K2n (A) → K2n (F ) → ` v K2n−1 (kv ) → 0 and isomorphisms K2n−1 (A) ' K2n−1 (F ). Proof: This is now well known. However, the original proof given in [So79] is incomplete, as was pointed out by Soul´e himself, who filled the gap in [So84]. Lemma 7.2.3 Let E be a finite field, ` an odd prime number different from the characteristic of E, q = `m a power of ` and k = 0 or 1. Then
132
Stephen Lichtenbaum
the Chern class maps c¯i,k : K2i−k (E, Z/q) → H k (E, µ⊗i q ) have kernel and cokernel killed by i!. Proof: By using the surjectivity of the norm map on the multiplicative groups of finite fields, we may assume that E contains a q-th root of unity. In this case the cup-product map on ´etale cohomology is easily seen to be surjective, so Soul´e’s Chern class product formula ([Su15], Theorem 2.8.1) and induction give the required result. Let P∞ be the unique Zp -extension of Q, and let F∞ = F P∞ . Let G∞ = GF∞ . Let Γ = Gal(F∞ /F ). Lemma 7.2.4 and n 6= 0.
(Tate’s Lemma) H 1 (Γ, Wp (n) ⊗ N ) = 0 for N discrete
Proof: Let γ be a topological generator of Γ. We can write N as the direct limit of Nα where each Nα is finitely generated, and so fixed by m m γ p for some m. So we may assume N is fixed by γ p . Let T be the Tate module of W = Wp (n), and let V = T ⊗Zp Qp . Then W ⊗ N is the quotient of the finite-dimensional Qp -vector space V ⊗ N . The eigenvalues of γ on Qp ⊗ N are pm -th roots of unity, so if n 6= 0 the eigenvalues of γ on V ⊗ N are not roots of unity, so the image of Γ in the automorphism group Aut(V ) is not finite, which implies that γ − 1 acts bijectively on V ⊗ N , hence surjectively on W ⊗ N . If A is a torsion Γ-module, H 1 (Γ, A) is the cokernel of γ − 1, so we are done. Proposition 7.2.5
H 2 (GF , Wp (n)) = 0 if n ≥ 2.
Proof: Let Mp = Q(µp ). Since [F Mp : F ] is prime to p, we have; H 2 (GF , Wp (n)) = H 2 (GF Mp , Wp (n))G(F Mp /F ) so we may assume that Mp ⊆ F . The cohomological dimension of Γ is equal to 1, so the spectral sequence H i (Γ, H j (G∞ , Wp (n))) ⇒ H i+j (GF , Wp (n)) yields the short exact sequence 0→H 1 (Γ,H 1 (G∞ ,Wp (n)))→H 2 (GF ,Wp (n))→H 2 (G∞ ,Wp (n))Γ →0. ∗ ∗ Now H 1 (G∞ , µpm ) = F∞ ⊗ Z/pm , so H 1 (G∞ , Wp (1)) = F∞ ⊗ Qp /Zp , 1 ∗ which in turn implies H (G∞ , Wp (n)) = F∞ ⊗ Wp (n − 1). Lemma 7.2.4
Soul´e’s Theorem
133
∗ implies that H 1 (Γ, F∞ ⊗ Wp (n − 1)) = 0 for n ≥ 2. It remains only to 2 show that H (G∞ , Wp (n)) = 0. Since Wp ⊆ F∞ , we may assume n = 1. But H 2 (G∞ , Wp ) = Br(F∞ )(p) = 0. (See, for example, [Se74] Prop. II.9.)
Theorem 7.2.6 The group H 2 (X, j∗ Wp (n)) is annihilated by (n−1)n!. Proof: Starting with the exact sequence of relative K-theory for pm and taking the direct limit over m, we obtain the exact sequence: 0 → Kr (A) ⊗ Qp /Zp → Kr (A, Qp /Zp ) → Kr−1 (A)(p) → 0, where Kr (A, Qp ./Zp ) is the direct limit of the relative K-groups Kr (A, Z/pm ). Lemma 7.2.1 implies that the following diagram commutes: ¯ ∂
K2n−1 (F, Qp /Zp ) −→ cn,1 y H 1 (F, Wp (n))
β
−→
`
K2n−2 (kv , Qp /Zp ) (n−1)c y n−1,0
`
H 0 (kv , Wp (n − 1)) −→ H 2 (X, Wp (n)) −→ H 2 (F, Wp (n))
v
v
Of course, H 2 (F, Wp (n)) = 0 if n ≥ 2, by Proposition 7.2.5. We have the following diagram which commutes up to sign, and where the vertical maps are given by the Bockstein maps for K-theory with coefficients: ∂¯
K2n−1 (F, Qp /Zp ) −−−−→ γ y K2n−2 (F )(p)
∂
−−−−→
`
K2n−2 (kv , Qp /Zp ) α y ` v K2n−3 (kv )(p)
v
We know that K2n−2 (F ) is torsion by Borel ([Bo74]) and the localization sequence for K-theory. Since ∂ would be surjective by Theorem 7.2.2 if we replaced K2n−2 (F )(p) by K2n−2 (F ), it follows that ∂ is surjective. Since α is an isomorphism by Quillen’s computation of the K-theory of a finite field [Q72], and γ is surjective, it follows that ∂¯ is also surjective. We know by Lemma 7.2.3 that the image of cn,0 contains the image of multiplication by n!. Hence the first commutative diagram shows that the image of β contains the image of multiplication by (n − 1)n! and hence that (n − 1)n! kills H 2 (X, j∗ Wp (n)), which completes the proof of Theorem 7.2.6. Corollary 7.2.7
H 2 (X, j∗ Wp (n)) = 0 if n ≥ 2.
134
Stephen Lichtenbaum
Proof: Since H 3 (X, µ⊗n pm ) = 0 by Artin–Verdier duality ([M04] p.177), it follows that H 2 (X, Wp (n)) is divisible, hence zero by Theorem 7.2.6. H 2 (GS , Wp (n)) = 0 for n ≥ 2.
Theorem 7.2.8
Proof : This follows immediately from the fact ([M04] p.170) that if E is a locally constant sheaf on X corresponding to the finite GS -module M , and the order of M is invertible on X, then H i (X, E) ' H i (GS , M ).
7.3 Proof of a lemma of Soul´ e Let p be an odd prime, and let q = pm . Let A be a Dedekind ring whose field of fractions is a number field F . Assume that p is invertible in A. Let X = Spec A. Let K(n, m, A) be the statement that the Chern class map from Kn (A)/m to H n (X, µm ⊗n ) is an isomorphism. (Here n will be 1 or 2.) Lemma 7.3.1
K(1.p, A) is true if P ic(A)(p) = 0.
Proof: Standard. Lemma 7.3.2 Let B be a Galois extension of A of degree r. If m is prime to the characteristic of A and to r, then K(2, m, B) implies K(2, m, A). Proof: This is immediate from the existence of the norm map. Lemma 7.3.3
K(2, p, A) is true.
Proof: Lemma 7.3.2 shows that we may reduce to the case where A contains a primitive p-th root of unity. Let α be an element of K2 (A, Z/p) whose image in K1 (A) = A∗ is of exact order p. If a runs through the entire class group Pic(A) ⊆ K0 (A) the products α.a run through a subgroup of K2 (A, Z/p) which we call Ω. Let i be the injection of A in F , and i∗ the morphism induced by i. We have i∗ (α.a) = i∗ (α) ∪ i∗ (a) = 0 because Pic(F ) = 0. Hence i∗ (βp (α.a)) = βp (i∗ (α.a)) = 0 (where βp is the Bockstein morphism, and as i∗ : K1 (A) → K1 (F ) is injective, the group Ω is in the kernel K2 (A)/pK2 (A) of βp : K2 (A, Z/p) → K1 (A). It is therefore a subgroup of the kernel of i∗ : K2 (A)/pK2 (A) → K2 (F )/pK2 (F ) ⊆ K1 (F, Z/p). In addition, Soul´e’s multiplication formula ([Su15], Theorem 2.8.1), shows that c¯2,2 (α.a) = c¯1,0 (α) ∪ c1,2 (a). We have seen in [Su15] that c¯1,0 (α) is a generator of H 0 (X, µ⊗2 p ), and that c1,2 (a) runs through the
Soul´e’s Theorem
135
subgroup Pic(A)/pPic(A) of H 2 (SpecA, µp )). Hence c¯2,2 (Ω) is the subgroup βp (H 1 (X, Gm )) ∪ H 0 (X, µp ) ' P ic(A) ⊗ µp of H 2 (X, µ⊗ p 2). Tate has shown in [T76] that the kernel of the map from K2 (A)/pK2 (A) to K2 (F )/pK2 (F ) is isomorphic to Pic(A) ⊗ µp . As the class group is finite, if follows that this kernel is equal to Ω. We finish by observing that the exact sequence a 0 → Ω → K2 (A)/p → K2 (F )/p → kv∗ /(kv∗ )p , v
where the last three terms come from the localization sequence in Ktheory, maps to the sequence a 2 ⊗2 0 → P ic(A) ⊗ µp → H 2 (X, µ⊗2 H 1 (kv , µp ), p ) → H (F, µp ) → v
where the last three terms come from the localization sequence in ´etale cohomology. Since four of the five maps (counting the zero map!) between the sequences are isomorphisms, the five lemma completes the proof. Lemma 7.3.4
K(1, p, A) + K(2, p, A) implies K(2, pm , A).
Proof: We have the following commutative diagram: K1 (A)/p − → K2 (A)/pm − → K2 (A)/pm+1 − → γ1 γ2 γ3 y y y
K2 (A)/p γ4 y
− → 0
β
H 1 (A, µp ) − → H 2 (A, µ⊗2 → H 2 (A, µ⊗2 ) − → H 2 (A, µ⊗2 pm ) − p ) pm+1 The lower sequence is exact and the upper sequence is exact except at K2 (A)/pm . Diagram-chasing shows that γ1 surjective, γ2 and γ4 injective implies γ3 is injective. So by induction the map γ on K2 (A)/pm is injective for all m. Another induction now shows that γ is also surjective. So we have proved K(2, pm , A) for all m if Pic(A)(p) = 0. Lemma 7.3.5 Let OF be the ring of integers in a number field F , and let A = OF [1/p]. Let B be a ring obtained from A by inverting a finite number of primes. Then K(2, pm , B) for all m implies K(2, pm , A) for all m. Proof: Let X = Spec A and Y = Spec B. We remark that we have shown K(2, p, A) for all such A, and consequently that the map from
136
Stephen Lichtenbaum
K2 (A)/pm to H 2 (X, µ⊗2 pm ) is surjective for all A and an isomorphism for those A containing a primitive p-th root of unity. ⊗2 m 2 By taking inverse limits, we have lim lim ←−K2 (B)/p ' ←−H (Y, µpm ) m and, since K2 (A) is finite, K2 (A)(p) ' limK2 (A)/p , which surjects ←− onto limH 2 (X, µ⊗2 pm ). ←− Now the localization sequence and the vanishing of even K-groups of finite fields implies that K2 (A)(p) injects into K2 (B)(p), and hence limK2 (A)/pm maps isomorphically to limH 2 (X, µ⊗2 pm ). ←− ←− Finally we have the two exact sequences: K2 (A)/ps → K2 (A)/pm+s → K2 (A)/pm → 0 ⊗2 2 2 ⊗2 H 2 (X, µ⊗2 ps ) → H (X, µpm+s ) → H (X, µpm ) → 0.
Take inverse limits of these with respect to s and map the first to the second to finish the proof of the lemma. Since we can find a localization B of A such that P ic(B)(p) = 0, the preceding lemmas provide a proof of Theorem 7.3.6
K(2, pm , A) is true.
(This is Lemma 10 in [So79], but his proof there is incomplete. I thank R. Sujatha and B. Kahn for helping to fill the gap.)
7.4 The theorem of Dwyer and Friedlander We give a sketch of the proof in [DF85] that the Dwyer–Friedlander map from K2n−1 (A) to H 1 (Xet , Zp (n)) is surjective, leaving out the deep topological arguments and confining ourselves to the algebraic and arithmetic side. Let R be Z[1/p]. We begin with the secondary transfer: Let g : Y → X be a map of noetherian schemes with Y a finite Galois extension of X with Galois group Γ. (Note that g is ´etale.) We recall that there exists usual transfer, or norm maps, which Dwyer and Friedlander call g!et (resp. g! ) mapping Knet (Y ) → Knet (X) (resp. Kn (Y ) → Kn (X), and also the analogous maps with coefficients. They construct a ‘secondary transfer’ mapping et g!! : (Ki−1 (Y, Z/pm ))Γ → Kiet (X, Z/pm )/Imageg!et ,
and prove
Soul´e’s Theorem
137
Lemma 7.4.1 Let X be a scheme over R of finite mod p ´etale cohomological dimension. Suppose that X ← X1 ← X2 ← · · · ← Xn . . . is an infinite sequence of maps such that each Xn is Galois over X, each group Γn = Gal(Xn /X) is cyclic and the p-adic valuation of the order of Γn goes to ∞. Let Y = X1 and g be the map from Y to X. Then the secondary transfer maps defined above are surjective for all i ≥ 1. (In the application we choose Xn to be the Spec of the ring of integers in the pn -th cyclotomic extension of X, where X = Spec OF .) We next consider the following spectral sequence. Theorem 7.4.2 Let X be a connected scheme over R of finite Z/p cohomological dimension. Then there exists a strongly convergent fourthquadrant spectral sequence et E2i,−j = H i (Xet , Z/pm (j/2)) ⇒ Kj−i (X, Z/pm ).
(Here the convention is that H i (X, Z/n(j/2)) = 0 if j is odd.) Corollary 7.4.3 If H i (Xet , Z/pm (r)) = 0 for i > 2, then et K2r+1 (X, Z/pm ) is naturally isomorphic to H 1 (Xet , Z/pm (r + 1)). From now on, as in the introduction, let F be a number field, OF the ring of integers in F . Let p be a rational odd prime, A = OF [1/p], and X = Spec A. Lemma 7.4.4 The natural map from Kn (A, Z/pm ) to Knet (A, Z/pm ) is an isomorphism for n = 1, 2. The proof is a not very difficult consequence of Theorem 7.3.6 and Theorem 13.3.2. Lemma 7.4.5 If A contains a primitive pm -th root of unity ζ then taking cup-product with the class corresponding to ζ in K2et (A, Z/pm ) et induces an isomorphism from Knet (A, Z/pm ) to Kn+2 (A, Z/pm ). Proof: This is Theorem 5.6 of [DF85]. Lemma 7.4.6 If A contains a primitive pm -th root of unity, the map γn from Kn (A, Z/pm ) to Knet (A, Z/pm ) is naturally split surjective and remains so after taking invariants by a group of automorphisms of A.
138
Stephen Lichtenbaum
Proof: This follows easily from Lemmas 7.4.4 and 7.4.5 and the multiplicative properties of γn . Theorem 7.4.7 The natural maps from Kn (X, Z/pm ) to Knet (X, Z/pn ) are surjective for all n > 0, even if A does not contain a primitive p-th root of unity. Theorem 7.4.8 The natural map from K-theory to ´etale K-theory et induces a surjective map from K2n−1 (A) ⊗ Zp to K2n−1 (A, Zp ) 1 ∼ = H (Xet , Zp (n)). Proof This follows easily from Lemmas 7.4.1 and 7.4.6, by using the cyclotomic Zp -extension of A. 1. The natural map from Kn (A) ⊗ Zp to limKn (A, Z/pm ) is an isomor←− phism. This follows from the long exact sequence for relative K-theory and Quillen’s theorem that Kn (A) is finitely generated. 2. The natural map from limKn (A, Z/pm ) to limKnet (A, Z/pm ) is sur←− ←− jective. This follows immediately from Theorem 7.4.7. 3. If n = 2r + 1 is odd then we have limKnet (A, Z/pm ) ' limH 1 (Xet , Z/pm (r + 1)) = H 1 (Xet , Zp (r + 1)). ←− ←− This is an immediate consequence of Corollary 7.4.3, and the three statements above together yield the result we wanted to prove.
References [Bo74] Borel, A. 1974. Stable real cohomology of arithmetic groups. Ann. Scient. Ec. Norm. Sup. 4e s´erie, 7, 235–272. [DF85] Dwyer, W. and Friedlander E. 1985. Algebraic and Etale K-Theory. TAMS, 292, 247–280. [HS75] Harris, B. and Segal, G. 1975. Ki of rings of algebraic integers. Ann. of Math., 101, 20–33. [Ka93] Kahn, B. 1993. Descente galoisienne et K2 des corps de nombres. KTheory, 7, 55–100. [L72] Lichtenbaum, S. 1972. On the values of zeta and L-functions. Ann. of Math., 96, 338–360. [M04] Milne, J. 2004. Arithmetic Duality Theorems (2nd Edition). Booksurge, LLC. [Q72] Quillen, D. 1972. On the cohomology and K-theory of the general linear group over a finite field. Ann. of Math., 96, 552–586.
Soul´e’s Theorem
139
[Se74] Serre, J.-P. 1974. Cohomologie Galoisienne SLN, 5, Springer. [So79] Soul´e, C. 1979. K-th´eorie des anneaux d’entiers de corps de nombres et cohomologie ´etale. Inventiones Math., 55, 251–295. [So84] Soul´e, C. 1984. Groupes de Chow et K-thorie de varits sur un corps fini. Math. Annal., 268, 317–345. [Su15] Sujatha, R. 2015. K-theoretic Background, in The Bloch-Kato Conjecture for the Riemann Zeta Function, LMS Lecture Note Series 418. Cambridge University Press. 22–44. [T76] Tate, J. 1976. Relations between K2 and Galois cohomology. Inventiones Math., 36, 257–274.
8 Soul´e’s Regulator Map Ralph Greenberg
8.1 Introduction This article is an exposition of part of Soul´e’s paper On higher p-adic regulators. We will describe the proof of one of his main results, but only over Q. This assumption makes the argument simpler, but the idea for the general proof is quite similar. The result concerns the Chern class maps ci,k : K2i−k (A, Zp ) −→ Hk (Spec(A), Zp (i)) for an odd prime p, where A = Z[ p1 ], k ∈ {1, 2} and 2i − k > 1. A conjecture of Quillen asserts that the map ci,k is an isomorphism. The surjectivity of these maps has been proven by Dwyer and Friedlander in [DF85]. Soul´e’s result is that the map is an isomorphism after tensoring with Qp . First of all, we recall the definitions of the above objects. For any n ≥ 1, let µpn denote the group of pn -th roots of unity and let µp∞ denote ∪n≥1 µpn . The action of GQ on µp∞ is given by a continuous homomorphism χ : GQ → Z× p . For any i ≥ 1, we can define the GQ module Zp (i) by Zp (i) = lim µ⊗i . ←− pn n≥1
It is a free Zp -module of rank 1 and GQ acts by χi . Let S = {p, ∞} and let QS be the maximal extension of Q which is unramified at all primes q 6∈ S. The action of GQ on Zp (i) factors through Gal(QS /Q). The ´etale cohomology group Hk (Spec(A), Zp (i)) is actually the Galois University of Washington, Seattle, USA. e-mail: [email protected]
Soul´e’s Regulator Map
141
cohomology group Hk (QS /Q, Zp (i)), which can be defined by Hk (QS /Q, Zp (i)) = lim H k (QS /Q, µ⊗i pn ) . ←− n≥1
In [So79], Soul´e defines maps ci,k,n : K2i−k (A, Z/pn Z) −→ Hk (Spec(A), µ⊗i pn ) for all n ≥ 1. Taking inverse limits, one obtains the Chern class map ci,k , where one defines K2i−k (A, Zp ) = lim K2i−k (A, Z/pn Z) . ←− n≥1
Now a well-known theorem of Borel gives the dimension of the Q-vector space Km (F ) ⊗ Q for any number field F and any m ≥ 2. (Of course, K1 (F ) ∼ = F × and tensoring with Q gives an infinite dimensional vector space.) For F = Q, this dimension is 1 if m ≡ 1 (mod 4) and m ≥ 5, and is otherwise 0 for m ≥ 2. The rank of Km (A) is the same. For i > 1, it follows from this that the Zp -rank of K2i−k (A, Zp ) is 1 precisely when k = 1 and i is odd. Apart from that case, K2i−k (A, Zp ) is finite. The article of Lichtenbaum [Li15] proves the same statement about the Zp rank of Hk (QS /Q, Zp (i)), as we point out in section 2. Soul´ e’s Theorem. The map ci,k has finite kernel and cokernel. We need only consider the case where the Zp -rank of K2i−k (A, Zp ) is 1. The proof, which we describe in section 4, is based on Iwasawa theory.
8.2 The Zp -ranks of H 1 (QS /Q, Zp (i)) and H 2 (QS /Q, Zp (i)) Soul´e proof that H2 (QS /Q, Zp (i)) is finite for all i ≥ 2 is given in [Li15]. Here we explain how this gives the results about the Zp -rank of H1 (QS /Q, Zp (i)) mentioned in the introduction. This is based on the formula for the Euler–Poincar´e characteristic for the Gal(QS /Q)-module Zp (i)-module, which is defined to be the alternating sum of the Zp -ranks of Ht QS /Q, Zp (i) for 0 ≤ t ≤ 2. It depends only on the parity of i, and is equal to −1 if i is odd, 0 if i is even. Since both H0 QS /Q, Zp (i) and H2 QS /Q, Zp (i) have Zp -rank 0, it follows that H1 QS /Q, Zp (i) has Zp -rank 1 if i is odd and Zp -rank 0 if i is even.
142
Ralph Greenberg
We also consider the discrete Galois module Qp /Zp (i). This is defined to be Qp /Zp as a group on which Gal(QS /Q) acts by χi . Thus, Qp /Zp (i) is the direct limit of the finite Galois modules µ⊗i pn . The corresponding cohomology groups are also discrete Zp -modules. One has an exact sequence 0 −→ Zp (i) −→ Qp (i) −→ Qp /Zp (i) −→ 0 of Gal(QS /Q)-modules, where Qp (i) = Zp (i) ⊗Zp Qp , a 1-dimensional Qp -vector space on which the Galois action is given by χi . One deduces easily that, for any t, the Qp -dimension of Ht QS /Q, Qp (i) is the same t as the Zp -rank of H QS /Q, Zp (i) . If r is that rank, then it also follows that Ht QS /Q, Qp /Zp (i) contains a subgroup of finite index isomorphic to (Qp /Zp )r , namely its maximal divisible subgroup. Thus, we refer to r as the ‘Zp -corank’ of Ht QS /Q, Qp /Zp (i) . Since H2 QS /Q, Zp (i) is finite for any i ≥ 2, it follows easily that H2 QS /Q, Qp /Zp (i) is also finite. However, if we assume that p is odd, then it is known that H3 QS /Q, Zp (i) vanishes for any i. This is so because the p-cohomological dimension of Gal(QS /Q) is 2. The long exact cohomology sequence derived from the above exact sequence then 2 shows that H QS /Q, Qp /Zp (i) is divisible and therefore vanishes for all i ≥ 2. Although it won’t have any bearing on the topic of this article, we want to point out that the finite group H2 QS /Q, Zp (i) can be nontrivial when i is odd. To explain this, we use the local and global duality theorems of Tate and Poitou. First of all, the local Galois cohomology group H 2 (Qp , Zp (i)) is dual to H 0 (Qp , Qp /Zp (1 − i)) and that group vanishes unless i ≡ 1 (mod p − 1). Thus, for any i 6≡ 1 (mod p − 1), we have H 2 (QS /Q, Zp (i)) = ker H 2 (QS /Q, Zp (i)) −→ H2 (Qp , Zp (i)) . That kernel is often denoted by
X2 (QS /Q, Zp (i)) and is dual to
X1 (QS /Q, Qp /Zp (1 − i)), which is the subgroup of H 1 (QS /Q, Qp /Zp (1 − i)) defined in a similar way. Furthermore, still assuming that i 6≡ 1 (mod p − 1), the maps H 1 (QS /Q, µ⊗(1−i) ) −→ H 1 (QS /Q, Qp /Zp (1 − i))[p] , p H 1 (Qp , µ⊗(1−i) ) −→ H 1 (Qp , Qp /Zp (1 − i))[p] p
Soul´e’s Regulator Map
143
are both isomorphisms. As a consequence, it follows that 1 X1 (QS /Q, µ⊗(1−i) )∼ = X (QS /Q, Qp /Zp (1 − i))[p] , p
the subgroup of elements of order dividing p. Therefore, for i 6≡ 1 (mod p − 1), the vanishing of H 2 (QS /Q, Zp (i)) is equivalent to the van1 ⊗(1−i) ishing of X (QS /Q, µp ). Let L be the p-Hilbert class field of F = Q(µp ). The restriction map
X1 (QS /Q, µ⊗(1−i) ) −→ Hom∆ (Gal(L/F ), µ⊗(1−i) ) p p is also easily verified to be an isomorphism. It follows that the vanish1 ⊗(1−i) ing of X (QS /Q, µp ) is equivalent to the vanishing of the ω(1−i) component of the Zp [∆]-module Gal(L/F ), or equivalently, the vanishing (1−i) ) of Cl(F )[p](ω , where Cl(F ) denotes the ideal class group of F . Note 1−i p−i that ω =ω . 1−i
If i is even, then Cl(F )[p](ω ) can be nontrivial. Assuming that i is positive, this happens precisely when p divides the numerator of the rational number ζ(1 − i). If p is an irregular prime, this will indeed occur when i is in certain congruence classes modulo p − 1. Thus, for such i, H 2 (QS /Q, Zp (i)) will be nontrivial, and hence so will K2i−2 (Z). Here is one specific example. Suppose p = 37. In that case, p divides the numerator of the rational number ζ(1 − i) whenever i ≡ 32 (mod 36). 1−i Correspondingly, it is known that Cl(F )[p](ω ) is nontrivial, and hence so is H 2 (QS /Q, Zp (i)). In contrast, when i is odd, then a conjecture of Vandiver asserts that 1−i Cl(F )[p](ω ) is trivial, and hence that H 2 (QS /Q, Zp (i)) is also trivial. It is interesting to note that if we assume that Quillen’s conjecture is true, then, for any odd prime p and odd integer i ≥ 3, H 2 (QS /Q, Zp (i)) is trivial if and only if K2i−2 (A, Zp ) is trivial. A theorem of Lee and Szczarba [LS78] states that the order of the finite group K4 (Z) is a power of 2. Hence K4 (A, Zp ) is trivial for all odd primes p. As a consequence of the surjectivity of ci,2 , which is proved in p−3 [DF85], it follows that Cl(F )[p](ω ) is trivial, a result which is pointed out in [Ku92]. One interesting application concerns the Jacobian variety Ja,p of the curve y p = xa (1− x) , where a is an integer not divisible by p. This curve has genus (p −1)/2. It is proved in [Gr81] that |J(K)[p]| ≥ p3 p−3 and that the triviality of Cl(F )[p](ω ) implies that |J(K)[p]| = p3 . As this illustrates, the behavior of the K-groups has a close connection with various arithmetic questions.
144
Ralph Greenberg
8.3 Some results from Iwasawa theory Let Fn = Q(µpn ) and Gn = Gal(Fn /Q) for n ≥ 1. Let [ F∞ = Fn = Q(µp∞ ), n≥1
a subfield of QS . Let G∞ = Gal(F∞ /Q). For any i ∈ Z, let Qp /Zp (i) be the corresponding Tate twist, as in section 2. The inflation-restriction sequence defines an isomorphism G∞ H1 QS /Q, Qp /Zp (i) −→ H 1 QS /F∞ , Qp /Zp (i) . Furthermore, let X∞ be the maximal, abelian, pro-p quotient of the Galois group Gal(QS /F∞ ). In fact, X∞ = Gal(M∞ /F∞ ), where M∞ is the maximal, abelian, pro-p extension of F∞ unramified outside S. We then have H 1 QS /F∞ , Qp /Zp (i) = Hom X∞ , Qp /Zp (i) . Thus, the restriction map defines a canonical isomorphism H1 QS /Q, Qp /Zp (i) −→ HomG∞ X∞ , Qp /Zp (i) .
(8.1)
+ + Let F∞ denote the maximal real subfield of F∞ and let E∞ be the p ∞ p + + group of p-units in F∞ . Let N∞ = F∞ ( E∞ ), the field generated by + all p-power roots of the elements in E∞ . It is clear that N∞ ⊆ M∞ . Let Y∞ = Gal(N∞ /F∞ ). Note that G∞ acts on X∞ and Y∞ by conjugation.
If we let Q∞ be the cyclotomic Zp -extension of Q, then Q∞ ⊂ F∞ and ∆ = Gal(F∞ /Q∞ ) is cyclic of order p − 1. Let ω = χ|∆ . One can identify ∆ with Gal(F1 /Q) and ω gives the action of ∆ on µp . Furthermore, one can identify G∞ with ∆ × Γ, where Γ = Gal(F∞ /F1 ). One has a decomposition M (ω i ) Y∞ = Y∞ (8.2) 0≤i≤p−2 i
(ω )
where Y∞ is the subgroup of Y∞ on which ∆ acts by ω i . We call (8.2) the ∆-decomposition of Y∞ . However, the definition of N∞ and (ωi )
Y∞ shows that Y∞ = 0 when i is even. This follows from the following isomorphism which is defined by Kummer theory: + Y∞ ∼ ⊗ (Qp /Zp ), µp∞ ) = Hom(E∞
Soul´e’s Regulator Map
145
which is equivariant for the action of G∞ , and hence of ∆. The action + + of ∆ on E∞ ⊗ (Qp /Zp ) factors through the quotient Gal(F∞ /Q∞ ). Let Λ = Zp [[Γ]], the completed group ring for Γ over Zp . The action of Γ on Y∞ commutes with the action of ∆ and so Γ acts on each (ω i ) component in the ∆-decomposition of Y∞ . Then, for each i, Y∞ is a Λ-module. It is finitely generated. It vanishes for even i, but when i is odd, the following theorem of Iwasawa [Iw73] tells us something more precise about its structure. (ω i )
Iwasawa’s Theorem. For odd i, Y∞ of Λ of finite index.
is isomorphic to a submodule
If p does not divide the class number of the maximal real subfield of (ω i ) Q(µp ), then Y∞ is itself a free Λ-module of rank 1 for odd values of (ω i )
(ω i )
(ω i )
i. Actually, in that case, we also have X∞ = Y∞ and so X∞ is also free of rank 1. We still