THE ATTALID KINGDOM A Constitutional Historv
R. E. ALLEN
C L A R E N D O N P R E S S. O X F O R D
THE ATTALID KINGDO...
22 downloads
1021 Views
15MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
THE ATTALID KINGDOM A Constitutional Historv
R. E. ALLEN
C L A R E N D O N P R E S S. O X F O R D
THE ATTALID KINGDOM A Constitutional Historv
R. E. ALLEN
C L A R E N D O N P R E S S. O X F O R D
Oxford University Press,Walton Street' Oxford OX2 6DP London Glasgow New York Toronto Delhi Bombay Calcutta Madras Karachi Kuala Lumpur Singapore Hong Kong Tokyo
*' ^ Dares,i:, Nairobi ;inf":r,,
and associsted comPanies in Beirut Berlin lbadon Mexico City Nicosio Published in the United States by Oxford IJniversity Press, New York O R. E. Allen 1983 Atl rights reserved. No parr of this publication may be reproduced' m,eans' -stored ia retrieval system, or tansmitted, in anyform or by any without ilectronic, ' mechanical, photocopying, ryc9rding, or otherwise' rhe prior peimission'of Oxford University Press
BritishLibrary Cataloguingin PublicationData Allen' R.E. TheAttalid Kingdom. I. Pergamon- History L Title 939'.21 DSt56.P4 ISBN 0-t9a14845-3 Typesetby Fotron SA., Athens, Greece Printed in Hong Kong
P R EF A C E There hasbeen a long-feltneedfor a new constitutionalhistory of the Attalid Kingdom, that can embrace the extensiveresearch done and reassessments made since Cardinali'sI/ Regno di pergamo, still the basic work on the subject,was publishedin 1906. The presentwork is an attempt to meet that need. I was further aware in the courseof my researchthat a great deal of important specialist work, above all that of Ohlemutz (1940)and Kähler (1948),had not been adequatelyabsorbedinto the more recent works on the Attalids now available,and I hope that my debt to theseand to otherswho have studiedthe Attalid Kingdom will be obvious.. This book beganits life as a doctoral thesisof the University of London, presentedin 1972.Since then I have benefitedgreatly from the advice of teachersand examiners,as well as from work publishedin the meantime.I owe a great debt of gratitudeto Mr P. M. Fraser,who first suggesteda study of the Attalids to me and has advisedand helpedme most generouslyin achievingit. I am glad to have this opportunity at last of thanking him. I am also indebted to ProfessorA. D. Momigliano, without whose initial support my researchcould not have been contemplated,and to ProfessorH. Bengtson,under whosedirectionI studiedfor a year as a guestof the Seminar(now Institut) für Alte Geschichteof the University of Munich in 1972-3;I greatly appreciatehis kindness and hospitality, as also the stimulating discussionafforded by membersof the Seminar,especiallyDr WolfgangOrth. Finally I must thank the managingcommittee of the British Schoolat Athens for admittingme as a Studentof the Schoolfrom 1968to 1970;the British Institute of Archaeologyat Ankara for facilitatingmy researchin Turkey, especiallyat Pergamonitself; Mme D. PeppaDelmousoufor enablingme to study the epigraphical materialrelatingto the Attalids in the EpigraphicalMuseumin Athens; and Miss E. Rohdefor admittingme to the archivesof the PergamonMuseum in Berlin in 1969.To all these I am most grateful. Oxford, 1979
R. E. ALLEN
C O N T EN T S ABBREVIATIONS
vlll
M APS
l. Western Asia Minor 2. Lycia and Pamphylia
x xi
I. THE NATURE OF THE EVIDENCE
I
2. PERGAMON UNDER PHILETAIROS AND EUMENES I
9
3. THE REIGN OF ATTALOS I (i) Attalos and Asia Minor, 241-216 (ii) Attalos and the Aegean, 215-197
27 28 65
4. THE ATTALID KINGDOM AFTER THE TREATY OF APAMEIA (i) The New Provinces (ü) The Greek Cities (iii) Festivalsof Athena (iv) Officials of the Royal Administration
85 98 l2l t29
5. THE GALATIANS
136
6. ROYAL CULTS
145
7. THE CITY OF PERGAMON
159
76
APPENDICES I.THE GENEALOGY OF THE ATTALIDS
l8l
II, THE GALATIAN WARS OF ATTALOS I AND HIS ASSUMPTION OF THE ROYAL TITLE
195
I I I .Q U E E N S T R A T O N I K E
2N
IV.SELECTED INSCRIPTIONS
207
S E L E C TB I B L I O G R A P H Y
228
INDEXOF INSCRIPTIONS
233
G E N E R A LI N D E X
240
Abbreviations
lx
OGIS
A B B R EV I A T I O N S
W. Dittenberger, Orientis Graect Inscriptiones Selectae (Leipzig, 1903) Ohlemttz, Kulte E. Ohlemutz,Die Kulte und Heiligtümerder Götter in Pergamon (194O)
ötn The following abbreviationsand short titles are used of works cited frequently.Others generallyfollow those listed in The Oxford Classical Dictionary (ed. 2, 1970).In somecasesfurther informationis given in the bibliography. Abhandlungender PreussischenAkademie der WisAbh. Berlin senschaften,Phil.-Hist. Kl.
Abh Münche'
mieder wis' hen Akade !:::,"r':i;f: ?f;: t!#.' ;li.c
AM
Mitteilungen des Deutschen archöologischen Instit' uts : Athenische Abteilung
AvP
Altertümer von Pergamon
Bengtson, Strar.
H. Bengtson, Die Strategie in der hellenistischen Zeit, l-lll
J. and L. Robert, Bulletin öpigraphique(annuallyin REG) G. Cardinali,Il Regno di Pergamo (1906) Cardinali,AP Comptesrendues de l'Acadömie des inscriptionset CRAI belles-lettres Fouilles de Delphes F. Delphes F. Jacoby, Fragmente der griechischenHistoriker FGrHist (t923-) E. V. Hansen,TheAttalids of Pergamon(ed'2, 1972) Attalids Hansen, Holleaux, Etudes M. Holleaux,Etudes d'öpigraphieet d'histoire grecques, i-vi L. Moretti, Iscrizioni storiche ellenistiche (2 vols., ISE Florence. 1965and 1976) O. Kern, Die Inschriften von Magnesiaam Meander IvM (Berlin, 1900) Inschriften von Pergamon IvP F. Hiller von Gaertringen, Inschriften von Priene IvPr (Berlin, 1906) Kähler, Gr. Fries H. Kähler, Der grosseFries von Pergamon(Berlin, 1948) Magie, D. Magie,Roman Rule in Asia Minor (1950\ Roman Rule F. von Fritze, Die Münzen von Pergamon(1910) MvP
RE REA REG Robert,Et. anat. Robert, Yil/es Rostovtzeff, SEHHW SB München SB Wien
Bull.
Schmitt, Untersuchungen
Jahresheftedes Österreichischenarchäologische n Instituts Real-Encyclopädieder klassischenAltertumswissenschaft,ed. A. Pauly,G. Wissowa,W. Kroll (1893-) Rövue des ötudesanciennes Rövuedes ötudesgrecques L. Robert, Etudes anatoliennes(1937) L. Robert, Villes d'Asie Mineure (ed.2, 1962) M. Rostovtzeff,TheSocial and EconomicHistory of the Hellenistic World (Oxford, l94l) Sitzungsberichteder BayerischenAkademieder Wissenschaften,Phil.-Hist. Kl. Akademie in Sitzungsberichteder Österueichischen Wien, Phil.-Hist. Kl.
H. H. Schmitt, Untersuchungenzur GeschichteAntiochos'desGrossenund SeinerZeit StV Die Staatsvertrögedes Altertums (ed. H. Bengtson): äi. Die Verträge der griechisch-römischenWelt von 338bis200vor Chr. (ed.H. H. Schmitt,Munich, 1969) W. Dittenberger,Sylloge Inscriptionum Graecarum Sy//.3 (ed. 3, Leipzig, 19l5) Walbank,Comm. F. W. Walbank,AHistorical Commentaryon Polybius (3 vols., Oxford, 1957,1967, and 1979) Welles.RC in the Hellenistic C. B. Welles,Royal Correspondence Period (New Haven. 1934)
2. Lycia and Pamphylia
l WesternAsia Minor
1 THE NATURE OF THE EVIDENCE The history of the Attalid dynasty falls in the third and second centuriesBC,the periodof Hellenistichistoryfor which the paucity of good literary source-materialis most acutelyfelt, and the modern historian's complaint with regard to evidenceabout the Attalids coincidesto someextent with that which may be expressed of the eventsand institutionsof the Hellenistickingdomsgenerally in theseyears.l There are, however, specialproblemsarisingin a study of the Attalids, as we shall see,and the inadequaciesof the literary sources in providing information that will contribute to their solution is only partly redeemedby the admittedly copious epigraphicalevidencethat is now at the disposalof the historianof the Attalids. When the literary tradition is fullest and most reliable - for the reignsof Attalos I and EumenesII - our understanding of the men and their reignsis correspondinglypenetrating;when it fails they become obscure and ambiguous.This state of affairs is strikingly illustrated by the contrast between our knowledgeof Attalos I and EumenesI[, who are figuresof substanceand true historical significance,and our knowledge of Attalos III, who continuesto elude a historicalperspectiveand understandingappropriate to his importance, althougha growing body of epigraphical and other evidence has thrown valuable new light on his character and achievementsas a corrective to the largely anecdotal literary tradition.2 We may begin by reviewing the literary evidenceon which we may hope to rely in this study of the Attalid dynasty. The only extant historical narrative written at a time more or less contemporary to the events is that provided by Polybios for the reigns of Eumenesll (197-159BC) and Attalos II (159-138Bc); it is not I See now C. Pr6aux, Monde hell. i. 88-9. 2 See the recent discussionofJ. Hopp, Untersuchungen, 107-20.
3
The Nature of the Evidence
The Nature of the Evidence
completely preserved and it becomes increasingly fragmentary and episodicin the courseof the later of thesereigns.The early booksof Polybios'Histories dealwith eventsthat occurredbefore his own lifetime and fall from our point of view in the reign of Attalos | (241-197 nc); becausethis part of his work is more completelypreservedthan the later parts we obtain a rblatively fuller narrative for these years than we would expect from the generallycontemporarytheme of Polybios' work as a whole. In providingsuchgood evidencefor theseimportantearly years,and despitethe shortcomingsof incompleteness,Polybios' Histories constitutean importantelementin the studyof Attalid Asia Minor. Comparablein importanceto the narrative evidenceof Polybios is that of a differentkind to be derivedfrom Strabo'sGeographia. Writing in the age of Augustus, Strabo refers to the Attalids at severalpoints in the part of his work that dealswith westernAsia Minor, and shows a precise knowledge and authority that are all the more impressivefor the support they often receive from independentevidence,chiefly epigraphical;a greatdealof importance will be attachedthroughoutthis book to the testimonyhe provides. It is evident that Strabo had a sound and detailed knowledge both of the history of Asia Minor in generaland of the Attalid dynasty in particular. Of specialimportance for our purposesis the summary account which Strabo inserts by way of historical background in his treatment of the city of Pergamon and its environs (xiii. 4. 6234); this account explores family relationships and individual dynasticachievements,as well as someof the more important eventsof eachreign: as will be seenin the next chapter,our knowledgeand understandingof the reignsof the dynasts Philetairos and EumenesI owes much to thesebrief but astuteremarks. and the value ofthe epigraphicalevidenceis greatly enhancedby the possibilityof interpretingit in the contextsthat they provide. The nature and scope of Strabo's remarks about the Attalids indicate that the sources at his disposal were sound, and it is probablethat they were in many casescontemporary to the events described. The account is based largely on biographical information: lengths of rule and other chronological details are given with great precision and accuracy; there is much personal detail and anecdotal material concerning individual dynasts, especially
Philetairos,and their individual plansand achievementsare stressed.It is very likely that the authority for all this informationrests at least partly with the biographies of the Attalids that were compiled during the course of the dynasty, works' such as those of Lysimachos, a contemporary and admirer of a King Attalos; Neanthesof Kyzikos, a city with which the Attalids established early connections;and Leschides,a contemporaryof Eumenes II.3 We may alsoadducethe many scholarswho were attractedto Pergamon during its royal prosperity under Attalos I and more particularly at the invitation of EumenesII, whose enlightened aspirationsenvisagedPergamonas a famous centre of culture and learningin the Greekworld.a Someof thesescholarsare known to have researchedand written about local history and antiquities, nepqyqrriE,whoseactivity is notably Polemonof llion, ö xAry9eiE dated firmly to the reign of EumenesII, and who is known to have been concerned in his travels with antiquities and monuments rather than with considerations of geography in the usual sense. Demetriosof Skepsis,a contemporaryof Polemonwho explored and wrote at length on the antiquities of the Troad, is named by Straboas his sourceon a numberof occasions.sThesetwo names adequately represent the antiquarian research that was encouraged at Pergamonunder Attalid rule and which constitutesthe sound authority with which much of the evidence transmitted by Strabo may be associated. Before passing to consider the secondary literary evidence we should pauseto reflect on a danger that is inherent in the tradition so far discussed. and which arises from the fact that all the elements of this tradition are favourable to the Attalids and sympathetic to their aims and achievements.Polybioswas generally very well disposedto the dynasty and to the order it represented and was invariably hostile to its enemies,especially PrusiasI and II of Bithynia and Pharnakesof Pontos, these being also the
2
3FGrHist IIB, 170-2. h6aux, Monde hell. i. 86, laments the loss of these biographiesbut does not consider their status as sourcesof Strabo's information. a On what follows see R. Pfeiffer, History of Classical Scholarship (Oxford,
t%8),zß-sr.
5 See for example the referencesin book xiii (which will mainly concern us) at 1.27,594; 1.43,602: 1.44,603(where an unnamedwork by Attalos I of Pergamonis cited, probably a geographicaltreatise).
4
The Nature of the Evidence
The Nature of the Evidence
enemiesof Rome as long as the SenatesupportedAttalid interests in Asia Minor.6 Even when the Senatebecamesuspicious,sometimes with apparent justification, of Eumenes II's ambitions, Polybioscontinuedto defendhim.7Thus the picture of Attalid rule we derive from Polybios is an entirely favourable one, and very little hostile opinion of the kind that we have, for example, pertaining to Rhodian rule in the subject Peraia has reached our literary sources.sWe must discountfrom this context the so-called RhodianpropagandadirectedagainstEumenesII at the time of the Roman settlement of 188Bc as urmountingto nothing more than a disagreementwith Eumenesover the future of the Greek cities of Asia Minor in that year.eOf greatersubstanceis the propaganda recordedby Polybios (especiallyat xxxii.lT) as beingdirected at EumenesII personally by a large part of the Roman Senatein the l60s with the intention of encouraginghis brother Attalos (later Attalos II) to usurp power in his place. Then there is the largely successfulattemptof Perseusof Macedonto discreditEumenesat Rome,evidenceof which can be discernedin survivingextractsof Appian's Makedonika (notably xviii.l). None of this however, interestingthough it is, has influencedthe literary tradition as we know it or constitutedany part of it; it is largely confinedto the reignof EumenesII and is simply the reportingof elementshostile to him, and as suchit comesfrom predictablequartersand causes no surprise. Of reasonedopposition to Attalid rule we find no traces in the literary sourceseven when opportunities may be thought to arise for its inclusion. This tendencyis sharedby the epigraphicalevidence,to be reviewedbelow, sincethis also ema-
natesfrom pro-Attalid sources,either pergamonitself or cities and regionsthat were well disposedto the kings. A second caveat needs to be entered with regard to the kind of evidenceso far discussed.We have already seenthat much of it lacks context and substance,especiallywhere eventsofthe later years ofthe dynasty are concerned.Thus, apart from the sketch of Attalid history that hasbeenmentioned,much of Strabo'sinformation is given in passing and with no attempt to offer a full backgroundto the statementsmade.StrabointheGeographiawas not writing history and cannot be expectedto answerthe kinds of historical questionsthat we are inclined to pose. In the caseof Polybiosthe trouble lies with the transmissionof the text. which is increasingly fragmentary from book vii onwards. There is also in this connectiona qualitativepoint to be made, that theseliterary sourcesdo not alwaysadequatelymeetour demandfor knowledge of constitutionalmachineryand procedure,which are a primary concern of this study. Polybios is notoriously confusingon the occasionswhen he pausesto describeadministrativeor constitutional organization,even when he is thoroughly familiar with them: we can thereforehardly expect him to transmit a clear and consistentpictureofthe institutionsof Attalid rule, which he knew less well and about which he was probably less concernedto inform his readers.Thesereaderscould be expectedfurthermore to be mostly Greeks, and therefore sufücientlyfamiliar with the connotationsof his terminologyas not to requirecarefulprecision or elaboration.r0These factors increaseour diffrcultiesin interpretingthe significanceof official titles and regionaldesignations, and (evenmore noticeably)of institutionsof taxationand financial administration. Despite these reservationsPolybios and Strabo stand as the most importantliterary sourcesat our disposal,and they arejoined by Livy when he is following lost or fragmentary sections of Polybios' account. When Livy is not following polybios we are faced with the usual problem of decidingwhat his sourceis at a particular point in the narrativeand what its worth is; we will be
6 Seethe comment on Pharnakesof Pontos(xxvii. 17, on which seealso Walbank, Comm. iii. 318), and, above all, the hostile assessmentof husias II of Bithynia (xxxvi. 15;Walbank,Comm. äi. 46). ; Polyb.xxxi. 6. 6; Holleaux,Etudes,ü. 170. EP. M. Fraserand G. E. Bean,TheRhodianPeraeaand Islands(Oxford, 1954), n8-22. eC. G. Starr, C. Phil. xxxiii (1938),63-8, arguesthat mutual hostility is a continuous factor in Rhodian-Pergamenerelations from early in the reign of Attalos I; but it was the issue of the Greek cities in 189 that first divided them, accordingto Polyb. xxi. 22.6. We shallseein chapter3 that Rhodesand pergamon were brought together during the reign of Attalos I by the common needto defend the south-eastAegeanagainstPhilip V of Macedon.
5
r0 F. W. Walbank, Polybius (Sather ClassicalLectures, 42, 197D. l-6. The institutions that Polybios explains are generally those that would be unfamiliar to Creek readers:see Walbank,loc. cit.. 4. n.19.
The Nature of the Evidence
The Nature of the Evidence
particularly aware of this problem for instance when we come to consider Livy's evidence for the institution of the cistophoric coinage in the Attalid Kingdom. Also to be gonsideredas an element of the extant literary tradition is the anecdotal material about the Attatid kings, usually fanciful stories that represent a kind of elaboration or variation of known historical circumstances and must be regardedas sensationaland untrustworthy. These have survivedin the accountsof later historians(includingJustin) and in works such as the Deipnosophistai of Athenaios and the Moralia of Plutarch, whose nature and purpose provided suitable contextsfor the retailingand preservationof suchmaterial.tn this categorybelongsmuch ofthe evidenceon the parentageand reign of Attalos [II:11 since in a number of significant instancesthis evidencewill be seento be contradictedby sounderelementsin the tradition its value is correspondinglydiminished;it needsto be carefully distinguished from the more reliable biographical material preservedin Strabo's writing and certainly to be treated with a greater degree of caution than is often the case in modern ac-
which is probably the most important and certainly the most discussed single item of evidence relating to Attalid procedures of regionaladministrationafter 188nc. Another significantgenreof documentsthat may be mentioned here is that of the royal letters written to cities of varying status;theseare particularly valuablein that they are more usually datedthan are other kinds of inscription, and by their nature frequently include referencesto and explanations of royal policy such as we would not expectto find in other sources. Of equal importance in other ways are the texts from cities and regionsnot subjectto the Attalids but enjoyingfriendly relations with them. Most notableare the recordsof Attalid benefactions, beginningat an early stagein the history of the dynasty,at Athens, at Delphi, and in Boiotia. Suchevidencedocumentsthe history of the Attalids' external relations and in somecasesfurther illustrates constitutional procedures and institutions, since ambassadors, members of the royal family, and other officials and representatives are occasionallydesignatedand described.Even more important is the evidencerelating to the institution of royal cults in citieswhich were the objectofthe Attalids'beneficence;worthy of special mention in this regard is the material now accumulated from Teos and Miletos. Numismatic evidence is of less importance to constitutional mattersin the caseof the Attalids, but it contributessignificantlyto our knowledgeof the dynasty's standing,both before 188nc (the dynasticcoinage)r2and after that date,when (aswill be argued)the cistophoriccoinagebecamean institution of Attalid fiscal control throughout the newly acquiredkingdom. Finally we must considerwhat may be termed the monumental evidence.Of all the Hellenisticroyal capitalsPergamonhas provided the richest yield of monumentaland architecturalremains, enablingus to reconstructwith a high degreeof precisionnot only the growth and developmentof the city in materialterms, but also the nature and purpose of many royal and religious buildings, and the relative importance of the institutions and cults (whether royal
6
counts. Enough hasbeen saidto familiarize the readerwith the problems to be expectedof the literary evidencethat will be adducedin this study. We turn now to considerbriefly the natureof the evidence provided by inscriptions. What we know of the institutions of Attalid rule, as distinct from the historical background of their implementation, is derived very largely from epigraphical evidence, both the copious body of texts from Pergamonitself, augmented over the years since the original publications of Inschriften von Pergamon, and that from other parts of the Greek world in Asia Minor and on the Greek mainland. Of great importance is the material, consistingchiefly of honorary decreesin favour of membersof the royal family or their ofücials, from cities that were in some way subject or tributary to the Attalids, since these frequently record the names and titles of offrcials and at times attest,explicitly or otherwise,proceduresand evenpolicies of the royal administration; in this category should be mentioneda decree from Bursa honouring the Attalid strategos Korrhagos, rr SeeAppendix i; Hopp, IJntersuchungen,16-26' esp' lE-19'
7
12See in general the remarks of Rostovtzefr, SEHHW ii. 1288-96; h,6aux, Monde hell. i. 106-10,and the referencesgiven below, 24n. 51.
8
The Nature of the Evidence
or divine) that they represent.Although it will not be a part of our purpose to consider the material and artistic developmentof Pergamon, certain features of it will be noticed as they attest or contribute to our knowledgeof the Attalids' power and standingin the Greek world. Thus the early years of the reign of Attalos I, and in particular the significance of his numerous military victories over Galatiansand other enemiesin westernAsia Minor, can only be fully comprehendedin relation to the seriesof monumentsthat he dedicatedto Athena on the citadel of Pergamon;and the value of theseas historical evidenceis in many casesfurther enhanced by the presenceof dedicatory inscriptions which attest both the purposefor which they were erectedand the eventswhich they were intendedto celebrate.This kind of evidenceis lessprominent for the early years of the dynasty, but is of great importance to an of the reignsand achievementsof Attalos' successors, assessment especiallyEumenesII, for whom the Pergamenemonumentsare a true mirror of the expansionand strengtheningof royal authority in Asia Minor after the Roman settlementof 188sc.r3 13An excellent historical account of the monumentsof Pergamonis given by Kähler, Gr. Fries, 131-49(with detailednotes)'
2 P E R G A M O NU N D E R P H I L E T A I R O SA N D E U M E N E S I Under Philetairos and Eumenes I the Attalids achieved the statusof a dynasty; it is the purposeof this chapterto examinethe process.lPhiletairos'position at Pergamondatesfrom about 302, or shortly before the battle at Ipsos,2but for the twenty years' period of his allegianceto Lysimachos we have only a few literary notices, usually in late writers, and no certainly pertinent documentaryevidence.3We do not even know the exact title or nature of the office entrusted to Philetairosby Lysimachos, althoughit was almost certainlya purely financialone.aThe offrcial foundationof the Attalid dynasty, however,was put sometwenty yearslater in 283,when Philetairosplacedhimself,and the wealth he administered,at the disposalof Seleukos,whom he correctly assessedas the more likely winner in the imminent conflict with Lysimachos.This date, 283,can be reachedwith someprecision from the chronologyof the reignsof the Attalids given by Strabo I For the early growth of Pergamon,see Cardinali, Rp 4-16; Rostovtzeff, SEHHW i. 553-66;Bengtson,Srrar. ii. 195-8;Magie,RomanRale i. l-33, with the well-documented notes,ii. 725-81.The secondeditionof Hansen'sÄtra/idsshows only superficialrevisionand is as uncriticalasthe first, which waswell reviewedby A. Aymard,REÄ xlix (1947),33945. The thesisof R.B. Mcshane,Foreignpolicy (Illinois, 1964),that the Attalids worked from a panhellenicideal and on a legalistic federalbasisin their relationswith Greekcities,doesonly occasionaljusticito the evidence,and is hardly realistic. 2 According to Diodoros xx. 107. .t-5, Dokimos, strategos of Antigonos at synnada,took up the causeof Lysimachosin 302,and philetairoswas frobably given the chargeof the strongholdat pergamonat the sametime. cf. cardinali, Ri 6-7; Bengtson,Stat. i.199-201. I For the relevance to this period of the pergamene treaty of ioono).neia with Temnos(Sry iii. 555),seebelow, l6-17. a He wasprobably simplyTc(o gülal, thatis,keeper ofthe treasuryat pergamon (cf. Bengtson,Strat. ä. 195),but there is no direct evidenceto this effec1.His positionwas certainly not a military one; cf. Cardinali,Rp 7, n. 2.
l0
Pergamon under Philetairos and EumenesI
(xiii. 4. l-2, 6234), supplementedby other information. Strabo gives the length of each reign in yearsas follows: Philetairos,20; EumenesI,22; Attzlos I, 43; Eumenesll, 49:.Attalos II, 2l; and Attalos III, 5. This chronologyis mistakenat two points, but each mistake is fortunately easy to account for. Firstly, the 49 years assignedto EumenesII is evidently a slip for 39; this lower figure then fits with the rest of Strabo's dates,and an error of l0 is not difficult to explain in simple arithmeticalterms.s Strabo meant, then, to say 39, but eventhis figure is not quite accurate:the death of Attalos I can be placedfrom the narrative of Livy (xxxiii. 2. l-3:. 2l.l) in the late summer or autumn of 197,6and we know from Delphian documents recording Pergamenedonations of the year 160/59,that EumenesII died in the autumnof 159.7Thus Eumenes II ruled for a little over 38 years,which were evidentlyrounded upwards in Strabo's source to 39. Now Polybios, followed by Livy, assigns44yearsto Attalos I, and not 43;8it is therefore clear what happened to the chronology followed by Strabo: Attalos I ruled for 43llzyears(: 43 in Strabo,44in Polybios),and 5 K. Meischke,Symbolae,l2-13; Magie,RomanRule, ü.771-2, n.75. 5The account of Attalos' death is missingfrom the fragmentsof Polyb. xviii. All we have is Polybios'own eulogy(xviii. 4l). Livy's narrative,at this point drawn from Polybios, enables us to date the event to late summer or autumn 191; cf . Holleaux,Etudes, v. I 14,n. l . An inscriptionfrom Delphi (Appendixiv, no. 4), records the presenceat Delphi, in connection with a manumission,of Dameas,d napä toü 6aoü,6aE'Atrdlou ö Eni töv Epyav rritv 6aotlmöv, in August-Sep tember 197.On this evidenceMeischke concluded(Symäolae, 2l)that Attaloswas still alive in September 197,but since Dameas' titulature will probably not have changedimmediately after Attalos' death, such an exact chronologicalinferenceis hardly valid. ?The chronology of the death of EumenesII was establishedby G. Daux, BCH lix (1935),220-30;seealso hisDe/phes, 502-9,on the basisofDelphian documents (Syll.3671,now to be consultedin the edition inF. Delphes,iii. 3. 238-9,with the additional corrections and suggestions of Ad. Wilhelm, Griech. Inschriften rechtlichenInhalts, 5l-5; Sy/t.3672, : Daux, Delphes,ß2-98, C), which record donationsof EumenesII in the ninth month of the archonshipof Amphistratos (160 / 59),andof AttalosII, calledKing, in the sixth monthof the sameyear.Thesetexts show, as Daux demonstrated,that Eumeneswas alive in March-April 159,and that Attalos lI was associatedin the kingship some months before Eumenes' death, which must be placed towards the end of the year 159. The establishingof the co-regencyis probably referred to in an Athenian decree,also of 160/59(Appendix iv. no.lE). 8 Polyb.xviii. 41. 8; Livy xxxiii. 21. l.
Pergamon under Philetairos and EumenesI
11
EumenesII ruled for 38t/z years (: 39 in Strabo).eIn absolute terms,then, the accessionof Attalos I shouldbe dated241,and not 240,which means,in turn, that the official beginningof Philetairos' rule was in 283,and not 282,althoughit remainsa possibility,but an unlikely one, that the 20 yearsassignedto Philetairosby Strabo was a round figure, and that the beginningof Philetairos'rule was not exactly dated.ro It seems safer, however, to leave the chronology of the reignsof the Attalids as follows: PHILETAIROS 283_263 EUMENESII EUMENESI 263_24I ATTALOSII ATTALOSI 241_197 ATTALOSIII
197_159 I59_I38 I38_I33.
This chronology leavesus with the year 283 as most probably that of the foundation of the Attalid dynasty. Unfortunately no chronologicalprecision,corroborativeor otherwise,canbe gained from the available accounts of the events leading to the battle fought between the armies of Lysimachos and Seleukos at Corupedion,sincetheseaccountsappearin the highly dramatized narrativesof later writers, but they do havesomevaluein throwing light on the position taken by Philetairos.The two principal accounts,those of Justin and Pausanias,deal with the eventswhich made up the final downfall of the houseof Lysimachos:the conspiracy against,and murder of, his son Agathokles,widespread revolt from Lysimachos (including Philetairos' change of allegiance),and the battle at Corupedion.t t [n the narrativeof Justin (xvii. l) thesedisastersare relatedto the portent ofan earthquake which hit Lysimacheiain 28716;rzthus chronologicalprecisionis sacrificed to the making of a dramatic point: Per idem fermetempusHellespontiet Chersonesi regionibus terrae motusfuit, maximetamenLysimachiaurbs,anteduoset XX annosa Lysimachoregecondita,eversaest. Quodportentumdira Lysimacho stirpiqueeiusac regniruinamcum cladevexatarumregionumportendeCf. Cardinali,RP 8, n. 3. rolt was K. J. Beloch's view (Gr. Gesch. iv.2 2.207) that the twenty years assignedto Philetairosis a round number, but the exact figuresgiven for the other reigns count against it. ftFor these events, see B. Niese, Geschichteder griechischenund MakedonischenStaaten, i. 4024; Beloch,Gr. Gesch. iv.2 l. 242-5. t2 Beloch,Gr. Gesch.iv.2 l. 243,n. l.
12
Pergamon under Philetairos and EumenesI
ebat. Nec ostentisfides defuit, nam brevi post temporeAgathoclem, per quemmulta regniordinaverat, filium suum,quemin successionem bella prosperegesserat,non solum ultra patrium, verum etiam ultra humanummoremperosusministraArsinoönovercavenenointerfecit. ruinaefuit. Nam Haec illi prima mali labes,hoc initium inpendentis parricidiumprincipumsecutae caedessuntluentiumsupplicia,quodocet ii, qui superfuerant, cisumiuvenemdolebant.Itaqueet ii, qui caedibus exercitibuspraeerant,certatimad Seleucumdeficiunteumquepronum gloriaebellumLysimachoinferreconpellunt. iam ex aemulatione The chronology is also certainly compressedpost eventum by Pausanias,who errs further in making Lysimachosthe aggressor againstSeleukos(i. 10. 3-5): xai @ü'&aqoE äpa, fi d Tpqpara 'Aya0oil.6oug rc).ewr1yaAendtg öneürpanro Auoqtäyou, rfi re xara).apcptpanxai rd. nagä tfiE'Apowöqg ünonra fyyoüpevoE 66ver. Il1pyalrov rfiv önbp Katxou, nöptpaE öi xrjpuxa rd re yprjpara xai aöröv ööiöouZü"eüxE. The battleat Corupedionwas fought early in 281,most probablyin February,r3but the deathof Agathoklescannot be dated exactly betweenthe years 28716and 283,andthe implicationin the highly dramatizedlatetradition,that Lysimachos and Seleukoscame to blows immediatelyafter the desertionsfrom Lysimachos,is not a cogentobjectionto the (at the most) two years interval requiredby the chronologyarguedhere. ThesepassagesofJustin and Pausanias,iftheir relation ofcauses and effects can be trusted, imply that Philetairos distrusted Lysimachosand took the first opportunity to betray him. This is probably again a highly dramatizedand personalizedaccount of more soberrealities;namely,that Philetairossaw Seleukosas the strongerman in the coming struggle.According to Justin, Philetairos was not alone in this opinion: ii, qui exercitibuspraeerant is doubtlessterminologicallyinexactor may be an interpretation of the term strategoi; it was probably intendedto include Philetairos,who is not specificallymentionedin the narrative. It is then importantto rememberthat Philetairoswasnot alonein desertingLysimachos, and that the dynasty he founded was in origin only one of a number of such dynastiesin Asia Minor, althoughnone of the others sharedthe Attalids' spectacularsuc1 3B e n g t s o n ,/ / l s t o r i a , i v ( 1 9 5 3 ) , I l 3 ; H . H e i n e n , I J n t e r s u c h .z u r h e l l e n i s t i s c h e n Geschichte des 3. Jhdt. v. Chr. (Historia, Einzelschr. 20, 1972),2O4.
Pergamon under Philetairos and EumenesI
13
cess. They owed their positions later to the partially tentative natureof Seleukidrule in Asia Minor,ra and soughtindependence and an increase of authority when this power began its slow but continuousdeclineafter the deathof SeleukosI. An exampleis the dynasty of Lysias and Philomelos, whose position we will be examining later in this chapter.r5 Similarly, it is likely that Philetairos' own brother Eumenes was dynast for a time at the Paphlagoniancity of Amastris, although his tenure was evidently brief, and he did not establisha dynasty there.l6It is likely that theseother dynasts played an important part in the issuebetween Seleukosand Lysimachos,whereasPhiletairosheld an especially important position in view of the great wealth he controlled at Pergamon. How Philetairos' position was changedby his transferenceof allegianceto Seleukosin 283 is not cleat, since the nature of his rule in the service of Lysimachosis, as we have seen,so poorly attested.We may safely reckon, however, that he becamesomething more than the simple treasurer or finance-officer he had been.It is almostcertain,moreover,that he gaineda goodmeasure of freedom, althoughnot completeindependence.Strabo,whose ta On theöuvdorcr as an elementin the SeleukidKingdom, in Asia Minor as well as in the East, see,in additionto the studiesof Wilhelmand Holleaux,citedbelow, n. 39, Bengtson,Stat. ii. 3-8; A. H, M. Jones,Cities of the Eastern Roman Provinces(ed.2, Oxford, l97l),4f-9. yote especiallythe decreeofSmyrna (treaty of oupnd'neta with Magnesia ad Sipylum), passed probably in 243 or shortly thereafter (OGIS 229, = SrV iii. 492: on the date, W. Otto, Beitr. z Seleukidengesch. des3. Jahrhundertsv. Chr. (Abh. München, !4, l92B),70;Chr. Habicht,Gottmenschentum, 100:'wohlvom Frühjahr242'),lines l0-ll: ö6e6aiooty titt öriptttt d1v aöltovopi,au xai ö1poxpatlav, öyparpu öö xai npöE rcüg 6aoü"cig xai rcüg öuvdotaE xai rdg nüteq xai td. E0v4d.fulboaEd.noötfao\ar ü re iegöv rfiE ZtgatovrxtöoE,'Aqpoöit4Edoulov elvar xü,. tr Cf. below, n. 39. t6 We know from a passageof Memnon (FGrHist 434,ch.9) that a dynast named Eumenes held Amastris in 279 (roü xaüTovrog aötlv Eöp6voug), and that he surrenderedthe city to the rulers of Pontos in this year. The identification of this Eumenes with the brother of Philetairos (on whom see below, Appendix i), first proposedby Droysen (Geich. des Hellenismus(ed. 2, 1877)iii. 255),but with a preferencefor an identificationwith the son ofthis Eumenes,i.e. the futuredynast (cf. Niese, ii. 75, n. 7; Cardinali,RP 10, n. 4), is strengthenedby the fact that Philetairos'native city of Tios took part in the synoikismof Amastrisin c.300sc althoughit later withdrew (Straboxii. 3.10, 544; cf. Ernst Meyer, Die Grenzen 109-10;L. Robert,Et. anat.262-3\.
14
Pergamon under Philetairos and EumenesI
source was in all probability ultimately a biography of Philetairos, whetheror not usedat first hand,rTrefersto his positionand to his policy;hecallshim (xii. 3. 8,543)ddqyrly&1Etoütöv'Arra)'möv 6aoü.6av y|vouE, and of his administrationsays (xiii 4- 1,623) örcr|Leoe yoüv örq e\xoot xtigtoE öv roü Epoupiou xai röv 4pr1pätotv.Thus he was not simply an ofücial in the service of the Seleukids,as he had been in the serviceof Lysimachos: he was xüpnE of Pergamonand of its wealth, althoughevidently of no more.rEThe measureof his independenceis shownalsoby the fact that his coinagebore his own name,but continuedto bearthe head of Seleukosevenafter the accessionof AntiochosI, indicatingthat he owed a nominal allegianceto Seleukospersonally,and not a continuingone to the Seleukiddynastyasa whole. His returningto Antiochosof the ashesof Seleukos,attestedby Appian, is a further indicationin this direction; it need not signify, as is usually inferred, a recognitionin turn of the overlordshipof Antiochos.le In saying that Philetairoswas xüpng of Pergamonand of its wealth, Strabo clearly implies a good measureof financial independence,and this positionis confirmedby other evidence. Strabo himselfadds (xiii. 4. l, 623):örcy|veroptvotv Enircü öpiparcg ö eövoüyoE xai noAneuöpwog ör"önooyQoeovxai u75 üJ'r1E IepaneiaE d.ü npög röv iogüovra xai ByyüEnapövra. This befriending of neighbourson the part of Philetairos most often took the form of financial generosity, as is amply attestedby epigraphical evidence. Kyzikos, a city whose friendship the Attalids retainedandtreasuredthroughouttheir history, receivedthis kind of from Philetairosduringthe troubledyearsof the 270s'to assistance alleviate the difficulties it faced during the war of Antiochos I with r?Seeabove, 2-3. tt Cardinali.RP 10.n. 5. I q F. Imhoof-Blumer,Die M ünzen ; cf . U. Westermark,Das Bildnis 20-1' For the return of Seleukos'ashes,see Appian, Syr. 63. I cannot agree with the view, expressedfor example by Cardinali, RP 9-10, and P. Zancan,Il Monarcato ellenisticonei suoi elementifederalivi(Padua,l9t4),95, that this act was n€cessarily meant as a token of recognition of Antiochos' suzerainty; it was surely in essencea gestureof respectto Philetairos'deceasedpatron. Thus the positionis perhapsbetter expressedby Meyer, Die Grenzen,97: 'wie Philetairosim Anfang sich den Seleukiden gegenüber sehr loyal verhielt.' McShane wites (Foreign Policy, 3!) 'Philetaerusc{rried favour with Antiochus', which is fantasy.
Pergamon under Philetairos and EumenesI
15
NikomedesI of Bithynia and the so-calledNorthern League,during the Galatiancrisis which followed this war, and later.2oIn the decreeof Kyzikos from which this informationcomes,Philetairos is honoured as an independentbenefactor.2tSimilarly independent were his benefactionsat Delphi, where Philetairosand his family were honouredasnpol6vor.;22and at Thespiaiinscriptions attest his dedicationof land to the Helikonian Muses.23 Of equal interest is Philetairos'activity in areascloseto Pergamon which remainedunder Seleukidauthority. Again Philetairos usedhis wealth to befriend,and perhapsinfluence,his neighbours, but here it emergesmore clearly that, in spite of his considerable financial independence,he was concedednothing in terms of direct authority, beyond his position at Pergamon,by his Seleukid suzerain, Antiochos L There are, however, two aspectsto be consideredin relation to Philetairos'policy in this area. One, as alreadysuggested,is his relationshipto Seleukidcitiesarisingfrom his own relationshipto the Seleukids,that is, at the time, Antiochos I; to this aspectwe will return later. A secondconsideration, however, stemsfrom the fact that Philetairos'activity can alsobe relatedto an alreadyexistingesteemenjoyedby the city of Pergamon. Although the history of the city before the Attalid period is, in terms of literary evidence,almost unknown,2aarchaeologicaland other evidencemakesit clearthat the city was then far from insignificant. One item of evidence is especially noteworthy. The temple erected for the worship of Meter at 20OGIS 748.The recordeddonationsdatefrom 280/79to27615, accordingto the chronology convincingly establishedby Dittenberger(ad loc., n. 7), and confirmed by M. Launey,REÄ xlvi (1944),217-36;seefurther below, ch. 5. The fact that in 27918Philetairosconcededto Kyzikos (lines 8-12) dt4Tenv tiE l"cias lxai töv l"omöv 6w d.neoxujaoav lxai6oot 6t äyopdoavteElix qE aittoü Ey4ytiyovto isa furtherindicationof his financialindependence.The.b*etalqeamentionedin a list of names from the gymnasium at Kyzikos (ClG 3660)are most probably to be associatedwith Philetairos'donations:cf. L. Robert,Et. anat. 199-201. 2r Lines l-2: niöe töanev
16
Pergamon under Philetairos and EumenesI
Mamurt-Kaleh, thirty kilometresfrom Pergamon,which is mentioned as an important cult-centreby Strabo,2swas, accordingto its excavators, a refoundation, and not an original foundation, of Philetairos,and the altar built by him was, like the structureas a A bronzecoinwhole, an enlargementof an existingfoundation.26 from Adramyttion, with examples age associatedwith this cult, Gambreion,Pitane,Aigai, Elaia, Sardis,Thyateira,and Kyzikos, nearlyall of which are known to havehad strongconnectionswith Pergamonin the Attalid period, extendsfrom the fourth century Bc to the fifth centuryafterChrist.27[t wasin this area,aswill be seen, that Philetairos exercised a strong influence as dynast of Pergamon; striking too is the appearancein thö list of Kyzikos, a firm friend of the Attalids during the entire period of their rule at Pergamon.We seethat the areain which Pergamonwas influential early in the Attalid period already had contactswith this city, as subscribersto the cult of Meter, in an earlier period of its history. This fact underlinesthe importance of Philetairos' work in rebuildingthe cult centre,now in his control, on a largerscale;andto this work he could add his personaldedicationto the goddess: This was clearly one aspectof @A&aqog'Arrä).ou trtr1rpi1erbv.2E xüprcg roü cppoupiouxai rCov of Philetairos: Strabo'sdescription ypr1pätav. It has already been indicated, however, that this influence, considerablethough it may have been, did not extend to direct authority. On the contrary, his influence seems to have owed somethingto the at leastnominalsuzeraintyof Antiochoswhich he had to acknowledge; this is indicated by the appearahceof Seleukid cities among those which Philetairosbefriended.The area in which the cities of Aigai and Temnos were situatedprovides the most striking evidence of this situation. A treaty of ioono)'rcetaconcludedbetween Pergamonand Temnos is to be dated,accordingto the letters,to the beginningof the third century sc, and it is unlikely that the stone was inscribed later than the 'Aonoqvvfi5. 2s xäi. 2.6, 619: rö iepöv rö twaü9a tqE,pqQöq, töv 9eöv 26A. Conze and P. Schazmann,Mamurt-Kaleh,43; Ohlemutz, Kulte, l74ff 21Mamurt-Kaleh, 42-3. 2 8M a m u r t - K a l e h , 1 0 . I
Pergamon under Philetairos and EumenesI
17
period in which Philetairos paid allegiance to Lysimachos, althoughit may have beenearlier.2eIn any event, it points to early, and possibly pre-Attalid contacts betweenthe two cities. In the samearea, two dedications of land to Apollo made by Philetairos further attest these early contacts; both are from the temple of Apollo situated between Kyme and Myrina, and belonging to Aigai. Onereads'A n iluAavt X pqoq p iott |
18
Pergamon under Philetairos and EumenesI
The text is a reply to a decree of Smyrna which Pergamon.32 honouredthree Temnitansfor rescuingsomecitizens of Smyrna from brigands. The decreereflects a more than casualconnection betweenthe two cities, a fact of significancein that Smyrna was at that time a Seleukidcity .33The evidencefor Aigai is morepositive, andwe seethat this city remainedSeleukidat leastuntil the time of EumenesI of Pergamon,and probablylater. This is clearly shown by its coinage, which was Seleukid under Antiochos II (i.e. 261-246),34and by a group of stonesfixing the boundary between Aigai and Myrina; two from the mountain country north-west of Manisa, inscribed öpot Aiya6an,3s and a third, more recently discovered, recording the actual settlement:36ouwd$avltog 'Ane)'6aoü.60ryI'Avröpu öqor.lrrlEAiyatöoE loi re06vregü[nö )"6ouElrcü Mryqoööllpoul. The lettering indicatesa date in the middle of the third century nc, and the king is therefore most probably Antiochos [I; and sincethe formula used in the inscription denotesa settlementimposed by a suzerainrather than an arbitration,3T Seleukidauthority over this city is clearly indicated. It is possiblethat EumenesI acquiredsuzeraintyover Aigai and Temnos later in his reign, as he did earlier over Pitane (to be discussedbelow),but the first tangibleevidenceof a morepositive Pergamenecontrol in this areadatesfrom the reignof Attalos I, as we will see in the next chapter. In any event, when Philetairos dedicated land to Apollo, the city of Aigai was firmly under Seleukidcontrol, and Philetairos'contact in this areais thus seen 32L. Robert,Et. anat. XJ-6. 33L. Robert,REÄ xxxviii ( I 936), 2!-E; Et. anat. 92.On the Antiocheiain honour ofAntiochos II, and other Seleukidcults at Smyrna,seeHabicht,Gottmenschentum, 99-102: W. Orth, Königlicher Machtanspruch und städtischeFreiheit (MünchenerBeiträgezur Papyrusforschung undantikenRechtsgeschichte, Tl, Munich, 1977),163-4.StV äi. 492(cf. above,n. 14)recordsthe confirmationby SeleukosII of the city's adrcvopia xo,iöqpoxpatia, which were therefore alreadyguaranteed by AntiochosII. We alsoknow that the city's coinagewasindependentin the third century:J. G. Milne, Num. Chron. iii (1923),I ff.; A. Heuss,^Sradt und Herrscher des Hellenismus(KIio, Beiheft xxxix (1937)),t97. 3aE. T. Newell, TheCoinageof the WesternSeleucidMints (AmericanNumismatic Society,Numismatic Studies,iv, l94l), 306 ff. 35J. Keil and A. von Premerstein, BerichtübereineReisein Lydien, nos.204-5. 16P. Herrmann,Denkschr.Wien.Akad. lxxvii I (1959;,4-6, no. 2. 37As noted by J. and L. Robert,Bull. 1960,no. 340.
Pergamon under Philetairos and EumenesI
19
to exlude any kind of direct authority. The same is true of his relationswith Pitane,a city on the coast of the Elaitic Gulf to the documentof south-westof Pergamon,as is shownby a Pergamene a laterdate,which recordsthe settlementof a land disputebetween Pitane and Mytilene.3s This document refers to donations of Philetairos to Pitane, which enabled the city to purchase an amount of land (the land later in dispute)from Antiochos I; the amount of the donationhas not survivedin the text (lines 135-6): ööwoE [eiElaüra llrcavaioegxai QÄeraipou r[d).avra - - - - - ]l xovra. It is clear, once more, that Antiochos was the city's suzerain,and Philetairosits benefactor.We have then another exampleof Philetairosextendinghis influence, by financialmeans, in the directionof citieswhich remainedunder Seleukidauthority, and this evidencefits well with Strabo'sdescriptionof Philetairos' . . . xüprcE öv to6 authority and its implied limits: öLer6).eoe yqrlpdtatv. gqouqiou xs.i rritv Philetairos,then, basedhis influenceon threefactors:the influence alreadyenjoyedby the city of Pergamonin connectionwith the nearbycult of Meter; his Seleukidpatronage,wherebyhe was ableto enjoy closercontactswith Seleukidcities; and his financial independence , which enabledhim to exploit theseadvantages.It is worth noting that in respectof Philetairos'generosityto independentcities and cult centres,the samepolicy can be ascribed,as far asthe limited evidenceallows, to the PhrygianPhilomeliddynasty mentioned earlier. This dynasty, which evidently retained the semi-independentand undefined position in relation to the Seleukidsthat we can reasonablyattributeto Philetairos,without, however, achieving the status of a kingdom, is known to have developedthe friendship of important religiouscentres,such as Delphi and Didyma. The Philomeliddynastycan,like the Attalid, be traced back to the early third century sc, although we have no
3E/GxiiSuppl.p.48,no.l42(IvP245,OGIS335)incorporatingsuggestionsofL' Rob€rt,tCH xlix (1925),219-21;BCH l(1926),469,n. | (SEGiv. 680);REÄxxxvi (1934),58; Et. anat. ll4, n. l. A new editionof this text is promisedby Robertin Villes, 413, n. l. On the topographyinvolved in the dispute, see Meyer, Die Grenzen, lO6-7.
20
Pergamon under Philetairos and EumenesI
Pergamon under Philetairos and EumenesI
direct record of its foundation.3e If we knew more about such dynasties in Asia Minor, we would probably find other features reminiscentof the policies of the early Attalids. Philetairos was, as Strabo says, master of Pergamonand its wealth, but he acquiredno further measureof direct authority from his Seleukid suzerains.We therefore cannot expect to define an area of Pergameneauthority under his rule, since such a concept would be meaningless.The position changesentirely in this respect,however,under his successor,EumenesI. Eumenes,as we know from Strabo(xiii. 4. 2,624), met and defeatedAntiochosI in a battle near Sardis:aoöoneq xai örcö4f,arcrö ll6pyapov, xo.i fiv ijö4 öuvdorrlg röv xüxLE yogiav, öme xo.inegi 2dpöe6 övixqoe pdyrl oup6a)'öv 'Avrioyov röv Ze)'eüxou.Several points emerge clearly from this statement:firstly, Eumenesis called'dynast of the surrounding country' whereas Philetairos had been simply 'masterof Pergamonand its wealth'; secondly,this position was achievedbefore the battle, since Strabo statesclearly that it was a factor which led to the battle: rt, iiöq öuväoqE. . . ritorc. . . . On the other hand, Strabo does not allude to or imply an increasein territory achievedby Eumenes;this is consistentwith the picture we have drawn of the nature of Philetairos' position at Pergamon. It is not to the extent of Eumenes' authority, as comparedwith Philetairos',that Straborefersin this passage,but to the natureof this authority. Where Philetairos had exercised an influence, Eumenesclaimeda definitedynasteia.Sincethe battlewas fought between263,the year of Eumenes'accession,and 261,theyear of
the death of his opponent,4rthis claim must have been madeat the very beginning of Eumenes' reign, which is also the natural place to put it. Some indications of the significanceand implications of this changeofauthority can be deducedfrom other evidence. Of first importance in this regard is the inscription already mentioned, relating to the land dispute between Pitane and Mytilene Here, as we have seen,Philetairos is shown to be an independent benefactor to Pitane, while the city remained under Seleukid authority; under Eumenes,however,this authorityin itself passedto the dynast, as is clear from the statementin the text (lines l4l-21:az fx]ai ög Eöp4vryEnapd"a6dv rd nqäy[pata napäEefi,eüxou löyntpöS I lltlta.vaiouE xrA. This assumption of Qdqev ölnntollv direct authority by Eumenesis to be dated most plausibly early in his reign,beforethe accessionof AntiochosII, to whom thereis no referencein the documentamongthe line of successivesuzerains at Pitane; the suzerainty therefore passed directly to Eumenes. This evidence adds meaning to the statement of Strabo, that Eumeneswas 'dynast of the surroundingcountry'; he was in this respect suzerainof Pitane. In view of the chronological indications already argued, it is most probable that Eumenesacquired, or more probably usurped authority over Pitane before the battle at Sardis,as one aspectof his aspirationtodynasteia. Anacquisition of new territory would perhaps be more understandableafter the defeat of Antiochos, but such acquisition does not come into question here;a3a declaration of independentauthority, with
3eThe chronologyandgenealogyofthe Philomeliddynastywereclarifiedby Ad. Wilhelm,NeaeBeiträgezurgriech. Inschriftenkunde(SBWien clxvi(l9ll), I. ll, 48-63). See also the important additionalconclusionsof Holleaux, Etudes, üi, 357-63(fromREA l9l5\; Robert,Villes, 156,n. 2; Bengtson,Strat. ä.5-6, and his remarksinDie Inschr. von Labranda (SBMünchen, 1971,3),14-16.Donationsat Didyma:A. Rehm,Didyma,ä.272,no.458(second Delphi:SGD.I2716(242sc);at centuryrc). At Ddyma, a Philomelosgavetenpairsof mulesandfive driversto the temple.This remindsus of a gift of Attalos (probablyII) to the templeof Athenain Ilion (L. Robert,BCH liv (1930),348-51;Welles,RC 62). aoIvP 15is possiblyan epigramcelebratingthis victory: Beloch,Gr. Gesch.iv.2 l . 5 9 3 ,n . 4 ; M a g i e R , o m a nR u l e ,ü . 7 3 3 , n . 1 6 .
2l
at The deathof AntiochosI is datedin the BabylonianKingJist publishedby A. J. Sachsand D. J. Wiseman,Iraq, xvi (1954),206,to year 5l (Seleukidera),(month) II, (day) f 6, namelyJune lst or 2nd,26l nc. Cf. R. A. Parkerand W. H. Dubberstein,BabylonianChronology626B. C. - A. D.75, Brown UniversityStudies,vol. xix (hovidence,R.I., 1956),21. a2I give the restorationsofL. Robert,as followedin/G xii Suppl.p. 48,no. 142 (seeabove, n. 38). a3The attempt has too often beenmadeto seean increasein Pergameneterritory, implying an existing Pergameneauthority under Philetairos,as a result ofthe battle at Sardis;e.g. Meyer, Die Grenzen,98,speaksof 'diesergrossel-andgewinn'.It wasa'Landgewinn',in my view, only in the sensethat Philetairoshadhadno direct authorityin the area.It was,as I havestressed,the natureandnot the extentofthe authoritythat changedwith EumenesI. This doesnot meanthat Eumenes'claim was necessarily implemented fully and immediately: we see Myrina, which lay within the area embracedby Philetaireia and Attaleia and the öpot [Iepyap4vöv, remainingunder Seleukidauthority until later. On Gryneion,seebelow, n: 52.
22
Pergamon under Philetairos and EumenesI
which we are concerned, is a tangible motive for the battle. A few words need to be said at this point on the position of Eumenes in relation to Antiochos' opponents, especially Ptolemy II of Egypt, in the so-calledSecondSyrian War.aaIt is not known whether Eumenes had any contact with these other enemiesof Antiochos. It has been supposed(one can hardly say argued) that in opposing Antiochos Eumeneswas acting in collusion with, or even in alliance with Ptolemy, enabling the latter to pursuemoreeasilythe warat sea,and to makea numberof specific gains, including Ephesos,which was evidently under Ptolemaic For this suppositionthereis not a control for a while in the 250s.as shred of evidence. direct or otherwise. The fact that Eumenes establishedcontactswith Delos doesnot meanthat he was bound to follow Ptolemaicpolicy, and still less that he was Rolemy's formal ally.a6It is possiblethat Eumeneswas shrewd enoughto take accountof the threat to Antiochos in Koile Syria in making his own attack,andthat his successat Sardisin turn providedRolemy with an opportunity for more vigorous action against Antiochos' successor,Antiochos II, but more specific co-operationis not attested. It is more likely, as we have seen, that Eumenes took the opportunity affordedby his own accession,that is, the changeof rule he represented at Pergamon, to press more strongly than Philetairoshad done a claim to an independentdynasteia-This aaSee,in general,Will, Ilisl. pol. i. 208-ll. a5Beloch,Gr. Gesch. iv.2 l. 593,n. 4; Cardinali,RP I 3-14; Crampa,Labraunda, iii. l. l13-20; Magie,Roman Rule, ü.733, n. 16, rightly points out the lack of conclusiveevidence. 45It is most likely, and significant, that EumenesI was responsiblefor the first official contact of the dynasty with Delos. The first vase for a Philetaireiafestival (1917),427,n.4;IG xi.2.224A,4),and wasdedicatedin262(Ziebarth,Hermes,lii Eumenes'statue (1G xi. 4. ll07, = Durrbach, Cftoir, 33)is the earliest known ofan Attalid on the island; the base celebrating a victory of Philetairos was almost certainly inscribed during the reign of Attalos I, as I suggestbelow, 3l n. 8. The developmentofthese contacts, which naturally had a considerableprestigevalue, was probably first and foremost an expressionof Eumenes'inderyndentdynasteia, and though doubtlesscarried through with Egypt's approval, does not imply that Eumeneswas that country's vassal. For the view that the battle at Sardis was decisive to the outbreak ofthe Syrian War, see,besidesBeloch(citedin n. 45),W. W. Tarn,ÄzrrgonosGonatas(Oxford, l9l3), 314.The accessionto the Seleukidthrone ofthe young Antiochos II was perhapsa strongerreasonforftolemy's advance;cf. Will, Hist. pol. i.208.
Pergamon under Philetairos and EumenesI
23
attitude is probably reflected also in a Pergameneinscription recordinga settlementbetweenEumenesand groupsof mercenaries settled at Philetaireia and Attaleia, who had recently been in revolt.47Attaleia was situatedin Lydia, north-eastof Thyateiraand some35 kilometreseastof Pergamon;aE the positionof Philetaireia hasnot beenexactly located,but itsdesignationin the documentin question as being önö rlv "Iöryv placesit somewhat north of the AdramytteneGulf, in the south-eastof the Troad.aeIn this treaty, a7IvP 13,with addenda,IvP i. p. xix, ii. p. 507,= OGIS 266;StV iii. 4El, with bibliography, p. 149. 48G. Radet,BCH xi (1887),168;Cardinali,RP 14,n. 6; L. Robert, Rev. Arch. 1934,9O-2: Villes, l0l-2. aeThe namePhiletaireiais to be found in two other Pergameneinscriptions. One, a dedication, refers to a Eumeneion (/vP 24(),with addenda,/vp ii. p. 509, = OG/S 'Entx),6ou9,, 336):lrcynqg lxaraota9eiE npög qt tnrpü,eiar xailgü,axqr uiv iv eenv, tv tltt xataoxeuao|[fival I vaöv ),flilou] ).euxoö, eiE6v dvarc9fivat rö äyd"pa. tv fi ö' äv tlp6par. yivqtar rl xa0r,6plao6l I airyü o[taLfitlar nopdlv tx rcü nputavciou eigtö üpevoE aöto6 xil". The provision for the procession presupposesthat the temenos, and therefore the place called Philetaireia,where it was to be dedicated,were in Pergamonitself or nearby.As the first editor ofthe inscription observed, this Philetaireiacan hardly have been the one designatedönö d1t'Iö4v, sincethe latter was a good two days from Pergamon (H. Hepding,ÄM xxxii (1907),254-5;cf. L. Roberr,REÄxxxvi (1934),524;Avpix. 89-90). The procedurelaid down in the decreefor Diodoros makesit clear that the Philetaireiaconcernedwas closeto Pergamon,althoughthe conclusionthat it was a part of the city, designatingthe old city of Philetairosas distinct from the city built by Eumenesll (cf . AvP ix. 90), is unlikely, since the use of a dynastic namein this form of a part of a city is extremely rare, though not entirely unparalleled(cf. the quarter namedAl4drianosaddedto the city ofAlexandriaby Hadrian: p. M. Fraser, ./EÄ xxxvii (1951),105;PtolemaicAlexandria, (Oxford, 1972),35).Itseemsmore likely that this Philetaireia was situated in the immediate vicinity of pergamon. From this probability we may draw two conclusions:(l) that the philetaireiaof the treaty with the mercenarieswas called rizö d1t'Iö4v to distinguishit from the one closer to Pergamon (and possibly others of the name); (2) that the Eumeneion attestedis to be located in the latter place.Thus the conclusionthat EumenesI was recognizedasztior1g ofPhiletureiaünö d1v'Iö7r cannotbe maintained,and there is no reason, on this evidence, to assign the completion of the building at Philetaireiaand Attaleia to the rule of EumenesI rather than to that of philetairos.
24
Pergamon under Philetairos and EumenesI
referenceis made to a grant of immunity dated by a Seleukidyear (linesl0-l l):fi &r6).en. . . ft örrötrcrdpruxxaircooapalcooröt ötet, i.e.269l8.soSuch an exact designationby a Seleukidyear' even as a matter of convenience, is hardly accountable after the break with the Seleukidsat Sardis. This indication is confirmed by Eumenes'coinage,on which the head of Seleukosis replacedby that of Philetairos, and the legend
Pergamon under Philetairos and EumenesI
25
cannot necessarily be regarded as definite frontier fortifications, since the location of Attaleia, at least, did not lend itself to this function.s3The treaty with the mercenariesdoes,however, add a further indication of the status of Eumenes'dynasteia;it shows that he had large groups of mercenariesin his own pay, and that he personally,not the Seleukids,administeredthe territory in which they were settled. The geographicallimits of the independentrule establishedby Eumenescan only be approximatelyestablished.sa The literary evidence,that of Polybios and Strabo, refers to the kingdom of Pergamon before the Peace of Apameia as being confined to a smallareain Mysia around Pergamon.Polybios,in his admiration of the achievementof Eumenes[I, makeswhat is clearly a simple contrast between the size of the kingdom after Apameia, and that immediately before, that is, during the final years of the reign of Attalos t and the early yearsof his successor's(xxxii.8. 3): öEyt npörov pöv napa)'a6öv napd. rcü narqög i1v 6aoü"eiay ouveora).pivr1v u).6a9 üE ü"iya xai )"nd. no)rnpdtn raiE peytmatE töv xa9' aöröv öuvamuöv ögd.pt)J"ovönotqot rlv iöiau dpXür. The samedistinctionis valid at xxiii. ll.7: naqa).a6övteE o6rct (EumenesIl and Attalos Il) ptmpdvapXüv.This evidencetherefore cannot be applied to the situation prior to the reign of Attalos L The distinction made by Strabo, however, in referring to the Roman settl:ment, seemsto be of a wider application(xäi. 4. 2, 624):npörcpn ö'i1v ü. nepi ll4pyapov oö nd.).d.yapfu ptyq qE 'E).afur1v 'Aöqapun1vöv. 9aAd.nr1Erfi; xard röv xö).nortxai töv This designation is more arguably relevant also to the rule of EumenesI and Attalos I. In the caseof Eumenes.confirmationof the validity of this inferencecan be adduced.A boundaryinscription (ögor Ilqyaprlvör,) from Ketschi-Agyl, 2 kilometressoutheastof Cape Hydra at the southernextremity of the Elaitic Gulf, must be dated, according to the highly characteristic letter-forms, to the middle of the third century Bc, and it is therefore attributable to the reignof EumenesI.s5The military settlementsat Philetaireia 53L. Robert, Rev.Arch. l%4, 9o-2. saCf. Meyer, Die Grenzen,9'7-102,with the reservationsexpressedabove,nn. 43 and 52. ssD. Baltazzi,BC.FIv (1881),283;more fully publishedinAvP l. l. 95-6.
26
Pergamon under Philetairos and EumenesI
and Attaleia were also within Eumenes' teritory, although, as has been said, they probably did not mark its boundaries.It is unlikely, however, that Eumenes'territory extendedeastwardmuch further than Attaleia, since Thyateira and Nakrasa remained Seleukid until a later date.s6To the south, the area of Aigai and Temnos is not specifically attested as being under Attalid control until the reign of Attalos I, although it is just possiblethat Attalos acquired it from Eumenes. In general,however, Strabo's description of the size of the kingdom before the Peaceof Apameia can be said to apply to the rule of Eumenes I. It is probable, therefore, as Strabo indicates, that the Elaitic Gulf, and with it the port of Elaia itself, belongedto the Pergamene sphere of influence from an early date. During the reign of Antiochos I, however, Elaia seemsto have beeneither independent or at leastnot Attalid, as is shown by the evidenceof a land dispute involving the city;s7 it must therefore have been acquired for the first time by EumenesI, and we may reasonablyconclude that he did so at about the sametime as his acquisition of nearby Pitane, andin the samecircumstances,that is, aspart of the positivepolicy undertaken early in his reign. We will seein the next chapter that a Pergamenefleet is attested for the first time during the First MacedonianWar, but we have no A questionwe would very much direct evidenceas to its origins.5E like to answer, but at present cannot, is the extent to which this fleet was alreadydevelopedunder EumenesI. There can be little doubt that with the acquisitionof Elaia Eumeneswill have taken the opportunitythus providedofstrengtheningby seathe contacts with Kyzikos and the Black Seaareawhich had beenformed by his predecessor.It is highly likely, then, that the fleet was built up from this date, and was developed over the years to the point where, at the end of the third century, it played a role in Aegean warfare and is first noticed by ourliterary sources.The importance of Eumenes'acquisitionof Elaia can hardly be overstressedas an important factor in the developmentof the Attalid Kingdom. It remainedthe chief port of the Attalids at leastuntil Ephesoswas given to them in 188. 56Seebelow. 43-4. 106. s7OGIS 335,: IG xii Suppl. l42t 144.Cf. Magie,Äoman Rule, ii. 734,n. 18. 58Seebelow. 68-9.
3 THE REIGN OF ATTALOS I EumenesI died in 241, and was succeededby his cousin (once removed) and adoptedson, Attalos I.t During Attalos' reign we see a development of Pergamene authority in three important respects:Attalos' assumptionof the royal title; the emergenceof the military and diplomatic power of the king; and a corresponding attempt to expand the area of Attalid influence. We seeoverall the foundation of more concentrated administrative institutions. which remainedthe guiding principles of Attalid rule even after the transformationof the kingdom in 188.From the literary sources, and of these especiallyPolybios,2Attalos I emergesas the most able of the Attalids in nearly every respect: militarily he was the most energetic,and he was clearly responsiblefor the foundation of the military power of Pergamon,both on land and sea,a power which remaineda factor of importanceto the Attalids in addition to the support which they later hoped, not always with success,to receive from Rome; in the field of diplomacy he had not perhaps the sharpcunningand subtleduplicity to be displayedlater by his son, EumenesII, but his greatestachievementmust be reckoned to be his serviceto the alliancewith Rome, and the greatadvance of the international renown enjoyed by Pergamonas a result of this alliance.That Attalos failedultimatelyto establisha lastinghold on the greatly increasedkingdom that seemedwithin his grasp is a measurepartly of his own evidently limited intentions,and partly of the ability of his rivals to power in Asia Minor, especiallythe SeleukidAntiochos III. In contrast with the achievementof his successor,one important point needs finally to be made: that whereasEumenesacquired an empire determinedby and at the disposalof the Roman Senate,Attalos' achievementwas entirely t On thedate,seeabove,l0-l l. On the adoption,Ä M xxxv ( I 9 l0), 463-5,no. 45: Eipfv4E
28
The Reign of Attalos I
his own, and in his dealingswith Romehe consistentlymaintained the right to an independentpolicy. The reign of Attalos I is best discussedin two parts: firstly the yearsof almostcontinuouswarfarein Asia Minor, endingwith the agreementwith Antiochos III; and secondlythe final yearsof the reign when Attalos was the ally of Rome. (i) Attalos and Asia Minor, 241-216 the first part of the reignof Attalos I, we arefacedwith In assessing a numberof difficulties.The most basicof theseis the fact that our knowledge of the details, in terms of topography and chronology, of the military campaignsof the years24l-216, on which Attalos' extendedauthority was ultimatelybased,is for the most part, with a significant exception (the campaignof 218, discussedbelow) extremely sketchy, consistingof facts without the meansfully to evaluatetheir significance.This is true of the eventsof the 230sand 220s,whose chronologyis obscurein the extreme, while for the years218-202we sufferan almosttotal lack of evidencerelatingto Attalos' position in Asia Minor, in particular in relation to the Seleukid position. Secondly, the evidence that we do have is almost exclusively concernedwith the military facts, and the insight that we are afforded into the nature of Attalos' attempts at consolidation,in terms of administrativeinstitutions, is correspondinglylimited. The relevantepigraphicalevidence,consisting mainly of the inscriptions to the victory monuments set up by Attalos in the sanctuaryof Athena in Pergamon,similarly dwells on the military aspectof the situation,recordingvictories,or what Attalos regardedas victories,3and no more. This is not however I One of the small bases dating from the restoration of the precinct of Athena under EumenesII commemoratesa victory in the naval battle off Chios fought in 201 QvP 52, as restored by Holleaux, Etudes, ü. 43-9, : OGIS 2E3):lBao.leüEl 'A9qvdl Ntxfryqöptu dlnö tl1E npöE @Amnov| xai "Ar[tü,oE | | | /ü] xali Maxelöivag nepi Xtovllvaup[a1iaEl. (On the date of the inscription, see Kähler, Gr. Fries, 187,n. 43.)Polybios'accountof the battle,however,showsthat Attalos' part in it was hardly distinguished (xvi. 2-E, especially 6, Attalos' escape to Erythrai). We therefore have to reckon with a certain propa.gandaelement in at least some of the monuments erected to commemoratevictories claimed by Attalos, a considerationof importance,as we will see,in assessingthe role played by the Galatians as Attalos' opponents. The Eumenid restoration of the precinct of Athena is more fully discussedin c!. 4 (iii).
Attalos and Asia Minor
29
the place to enter into a discussion,which must necessarilybe lengthy, of the relationshipbetweenthe literary and epigraphical evidencefor the involved and much disputed chronologyof the 230sand 220s:this is done in Appendix ii; here I state only the conclusionsreached,in order to procöeddirectly to an evaluation of their significance. The successiveopponentsof Attalos I in the years24l-216were the Galatians,Antiochos Hierax (in whose army Galatiansappthestrategoiof earedasafliesor, moreprobably,asmercenaries),4 SeleukosIII Soter, and Achaios. Naturally the motives of these enemiesin opposingAttalos were various. To the GalatiansAttalosstoodin the way of their obtainingplunderfrom the rich lands in the neighbourhoodof Pergamon;he had, furthermore,refused to pay the tribute periodicallypaid to the Galatiansby the dynasts of Asia Minor to securefreedomfrom attack (seebelow), and he had perhaps encouragedthe Greek cities to do the same.sThe a It is not always clear from the evidence whether the Galatianswere fighting as allies or as mercenaries of the kings, but their appearancealongside different enemiesof Attalos suggeststhe latter. Launey's argument@,echerches, i. 505-6; cf. Cardinali. RP 32i that since Attalos names the Galatians before Antiochos Hierax in his victory monuments,they were his principal opponents,and not simplythe mercenariesof Hierax, is not convincing;thisprecedencewas probably due as much to the propagandavalue to Attalos of emphasizingthis aspectof his victories (on which his claim to the royal title was based)as to the relative strength and importance of his opponents, and this consideration applies equally to the monument set up after the death ofHierax by the soldiers who had served under EpigenesQvP 29, = OGIS 280; cf. Kähler, Gr. Fries, lE5, n. 18, and below, Appendixii). 5 A decree of Erythrai honouring its board of strategoi, probably passedin the early 270s,before the Galatian victory of Antiochos l, shows that the cities as well asthe dynastspaid tribute.directly to the Galatians(Sy//.r 410, = H. Engelmannanc R. Merkelbach,DieInschr.von Erythrai u. KlazomenaiQnschr.giech. Städteaus Kleinasien, l, 1972),no. 24. 10-15):nolT).6n öt Eöll6at xai xwöüvav ncpu ovdytav xai öanyiv4E oöo4Eapögl I eiqiqv oöx ü.iyqE iv änaor,vörcflfipqocv ü1v nö1\/w xai rlv göpav dxöpatov, tnrycl19tvlrtg pöv tfi; t6,rvgp4llyätav wvayayfig rc xai dnootlolfig rctg nepi Aeovllvögrcv 6ap66potg ö.ouveü.farc f1 nfür6l xilt. This payment seemsto have been made on a direct basis, as distinct from the l-a,lazmd attestedin the context of a remission by a Seleukid king, most probablyAntiochosI (cf. Habicht,Gottmenschentum,96-9; M. Wönle,Chiron, v (1975),70: W. Orth, Königlicher Machtanspruch,76 fr.) in a letter to Erythrai (Welles,RC 15(datedto AntiochosII by Welles): Inschr. von Erythrai etc., no. 3I ), 26-8: xai dqopolf,oylritoug civat ouyTapoüpevtöy re äAAay ändwov xai I [röv cigl td fal.atmd ovvayoptvov. It is in any event quite clear that a city's financial obligations in this respect could be extremely severe.
30
The Reign of Axalos I
Seleukid kings, SeleukosII, SeleukosIII, and for a time also Antiochos [II, were naturally opposedto Attalos' increasinghis dynasteia in Asia Minor at their expense, as were Antiochos Hierax and Achaios, nominally as officials in the service of the Seleukids,but each acting eventually in his own interest with a view to establishinga kingdom in Asia Minor independentof Pergamonand of the Seleukid king he originally served. As far as Attalos was concerned,however, all these opponentssharedan interestin limiting his authority, and we will seethat this part of his reign was entirely committed to defending this authority. His victoriesover his opponentsled, in the caseof the Galatiansto his assumptionof the royal title, and in the case of the Seleukids (including Antiochos Hierax and Achaios) to a temporary military predominancein parts of Asia Minor, especiallyin Hellespontine Phrygia,Lydia, and Caria.The most importantpoint of discussion in this connection,to be taken up in this chapter,is the extent to which, and manner in which, Attalos was able to exploit this military predominancein terms of the possibleextensionof his authority in the areasconcerned.6 A distinctionmust first be madebetweenthe independentaction of the Galatians in their plundering activities in western Asia Minor, which threatenedthe Greek cities over which Attalos claimedauthority, or to whom he offered protection,and the part they played in opposition to Attalos as mercenariesin the service of Antiochos Hierax.? We know from Polybios, through Livy (xxxviii. 16.14),that Attalos refusedto pay the Galatiansthe usual 5 Important contributions to an understandingof the chronology of the 230sand E. Bickermann' 220s are those of Beloch, Hist. Zeitschr. lx (1E88), 499-_512:. Berytus, vni (944),76-8. For a good discussionfrom the Pergamenepoint of view, s e e K ä h l e r , G r . F r i e sl 8, l , n . l l ; c f . m o r e r e c e n t l y , I . C r a m p a , L a b r a u n d a , ä i . 1 . 123-31. Of great importance is the evidence of friendship between Antiochos Hierax and SeleukosKallinikos in the spring of 236,when the two brothers madea joint dedication of land to the city of Babylon (see Bickermann' loc. cit.); thus Beloch seemsto me to have beencorrect in dating the outbreak ofthe war and the battle at Ankyra not earlier than 236 (cf. also his Gr. Gesc&. iv.2 2- 543). ? Cf. A. Ferrabino,ÄttiAccad. Torino, xlviii (1912-13),233-44;Magie,Roman Rule,ä. 7 34,n. 20.The view of Beloch(Gr. Gesch. iv.2 2. 546)andCardinali(RP 23-34) that the great Galatian victory was simply a part of Attalos' war with the Galatiansand Hierax, does not not seemto me to fit with the evidence,as I explain below, 33.
Attalos and Asia Minor
3l
tribute, and that he was the first of the dynaststo do so;Ewe know from Polybios directly, as well as from later sources,that he defeatedthe Galatiansin a greatbattle in Mysia, and that as a result of his victory he took the royal title.eThesetwo events,the refusal to pay tribute and the battle in Mysia, must clearly be associated . with one another, and the two together must further be associated with the independentmaraudingactivities of the Galatians,and not with their role as mercenariesof Hierax, since,in this latter role, payment of tribute to secure freedom of attack would not come into question.Thus Attalos' Galatianvictory is not to be regarded as simply a part of his war with Hierax, a view against which the literary tradition is also to my mind decisive (see below). This conclusion is confirmed by Attalos' dedicationto Athena for a victory won over the TolistoagianGalatiansat the sourcesof the river Kaikos. The victory was commemoratedtogetherwith Attalos' later victoriesin the seriesof dedicationswhich makeup the so-called 'longbathron' (IvP 2l-8; OGIS 273-9), and also in an entirely separatemonument, unique among the victory monuments of Attalos I and surely designedfor erection in a prominent position in the precinctof Athena in Pergamon,inscribed(vP 20, : OGIS 269)fBaoütüg"Awa)og vmfioagpdlgqt Td.rctfoayioug fdd.ralg n[egi nqydd Katx[ou nora.poü, yalp{oflrilpr,ov 'A|l4tva] This victory was the most lavishly celebratedof the successesof Attalos I, and was evidently regardedby him as the most important; it is for this reason the one most probably to be identifiedwith the victory 'in Mysia' (seen. 9) which led to Attalos' EPimus Asiam incolentium abnuit Attalus, pater regis Eumenis. An epigram inscribed on a base at Delos (IG xi. 4. I 105, = Durrbach, Choix, 3l) celebratesa victory won by a Philetairosover Galatians.Sincethe letters are clearly ofthe late third century sc (seeDurrbach, ad loc.), we may discountthe son ofAttalos I asthe victor, and are left with Philetairos the Founder. Since the inscription was almost certainly made, on this criterion, duringthe reigrrof Attalos I, it is very likely, in my view, that the base was erected on Delos by Attalos at the time of his similar resistanceto th€ Galatians.Philetairos,despitehis victory, seems,like Antiochos I, to have continued the payment oftribute, a policy which is in accordancewith the ad hoc natu'reof the tribute as argued in the text. ePolyb. xviii.4l.7-8; Straboxäi. 4.2,624. Pausanias i.25.2, referringto monuments set up by Attalos on the Athenian Acropolis, refers to one commemorating a battle 'in Mysia': xai laldrav tlv tv Muoiq g0opdv d.v604xev "Ana).og öoov rc öüo ntyöv Examov. See further, Appendix ii.
32
The Reign of Attalos I
assumptionof the royal title (Polyb. xviii. 41.7):vmfioaEyäppdyrl fal&ag. . . raüu1v dgXit, Snonioaro xo.i röre nqbrov sötöv ööe$t 6aoü.6a.toThe dateof this victory is clearly of greatimportance to the chronology of Attalos' titulature, but it cannot be preciselydetermined.It has been thought that Attalos' refusalto pay the Galatianstheir usualtribute is best understoodas a reversal of policy to be associatedwith his accession,lrbut this argument misunderstandsthe nature of the tribute in question. It is unlikely that it was paid by the kings and dynastson a regular,or annual,basis;it is more likely that the sumsinvolved were offered 'protection money' as we by them as bribes as the need arose, would call it, when the dangerfrom the Galatiansappearedto be particularlyoppressive,and could not otherwisebe averted.r2The obvious attraction of this expedientwas that it avoidedthe effort and probablyeven greaterexpenseinvolved in carrying out military resistance,and it is not surprising that the Galatianscame eventuallyto expect it as a matter of course.In refusingto pay the tribute Attalos was open to attack, and was patently preparedto meetthis attackby meansof direct military action.This decision may plausiblybe associatedwith a developmentof the Pergamene armyat Attalos'disposal.r3EumenesI seemsto havereliedlargely as we haveseenin the caseof on the employmentof mercenaries, probably was moreeconomicalfor him it and Attaleia; Philetaireia t0On these monuments see Kähler, Gr. Fries, I82, who also shows, from Livy x x x v i i i . 1 6 .l l , t h a t t h e m o v e m e n t s o f t h e T o l i s t o a g i a n s d o w n t h e w e s t c o a s t o f A s i a Minor make them the most likely of the groups of Galatians to have made contact with Attalos and thus to have demanded tribute from him. r f S e e , f r o m e x a m p l e , E . T h r a e m e r , P e r g a m o s ( L e i p z i g , 1 8 8 8 ) , 2 5 8 .W i l c k e n , RE, s.v. Analos (9), 2159-60, rightly discounted this argument, but retained an early date for Attalos' assumption of the royal title on the basis of Polybios' statement (xviii. 4l . 8\ 6aoü,eüoaE rerrapäxovra xai ttttaga (i.e. 'ruled as king' f r o m 2 4 1 t o 1 9 7 ) .I t i s c l e a r , h o w e v e r , t h a t P o l y b i o s ' t e r m i n o l o g y i n s u c h a s u m m a r y c o n t e x t c a n n o t b e p r e s s e d ,a s n o t e d b y B e l o c h , G r . G e s c h . i v . 2 2 . 5 4 6 : ' e r k o n n t e sich auch ohne arge Pedanterie gar nicht anders ausdrücken'; cf. Kähler, Gr. Frles, l8l, n. ll. Wilcken also supposed that the head of Philetairosreplaced that of Seleukos on Pergamene tetradrachms as a result ofAttalos' assumption ofthe royal title, but this coinage must be accounted an innovation ofhis predecessor Eumenes (see above, 24). t2 Cf. F. Stähelin,Gercft.derkleinasiatischenGalater(ed.2,Leipzig, 1907),and below, ch. 5. r 3 S e e , i n g e n e r a l , M . L a u n e y , R e c ' h e r c h e s ,i . 4 3 8 - 4 1 .
Attalos and Asia Minor
33
therefore to pay the occasionaltribute. A more developedPergamenearmy is attestedfor the first time duringthe First Macedonian War by the inscriptionsfrom Delphi recordingthe honours which the Phociantown of Lilaia bestowedon the membersof its noteworthyis the appearancefor Pergamenegarrison;raespecially the first time of PergamenecitizensandMuooL t5We will seelater that influencein Mysia formed an important part of the authority conceivedof by Attalos for his kingdom.The developmentof this arrny probably extendedover a numberof years,as did the building of a fleet, which also appearsfor the first time during the First MacedonianWar (see below, 68-9), but its origins may well be located in the 230s and 220s, years during which Attalos faced almost continuoushostilities from his neighbours. We seein any event that Attalos' attitudeto the Galatiansis not necessarilyto be regardedas a reversalof policy implementedat his accession,and on this criterion the time of the Galatians'attack cannot be preciselylocated. It seemsmost likely, however,for a number of reasons,that it took place before the Galatiansjoined forces with Antiochos Hierax. In the first place,the literary tradition does not connect Attalos' victory in any way with the war againstHierax.16Secondly,the victory at the sourcesof the Kaikos was won over the TolistoagianGalatiansalone,whereasin the battle fought at the AphrodisionAttalos facedthe Tektosagan Galatiansas well as the Tolistoagiansand AntiochosHierax. Thus the Tektosagansmost probablyjoined the struggleat a laterdate.17 Also to be consideredis the fact that the victory at the Aphrodision was evidently a decisiveone (seefurther, below), and a major t aF . D e l p h e s , i i i . 4 . 1 3 2 - 5 . tsF. Delphes, äi.4. 132,2: M1vööapog NtawoE MuoöE xai oi öq' aödv Mulooli. The 25 names listed in the third column of this decree have no ethnics and may reasonably be identified as Muooi (Launey, Recherches, i. 439). t6 Beloch (Gr. Gesch. iv.2 2. 544) has said the opposite: 'dass der benihmte Sieg des Attalos über die Galater aufs engste mit seinen Kämpfen gegen Antiochos zusammenhängt, war schon aus unserer literarischen Überlieferung klar . . . So heisst es bei Justin von Attalos (er nennt ihn rex Bithyniae Eumenes) victorem Antiochum Gallosque adgreditur.' This reasoning is absurd in assuming that the battle mentioned by Justin is the only one to be taken into account in this context: see further, Appendix ii. rTOn the movements of the Tolistoagians see M. Launey, REA xlvi (1944), 217-36t Kähler, Gr. Fries, 182.
34
The Reign of Attalos I
Galatianattack in the immediatelyfollowing yearsis hardly credible. In the chronologyarguedherethe battle at the Aphrodisionis datedto the late 230s,and we can accordinglymost plausiblydate the battle at the sourcesof the Kaikos to the early 230s,probably, but not necessarily,before the beginning of the war between AntiochosHierax and SeleukosII. Within this decadea preference for an earlierrather than a later date is suggestedby the decisivenessof Attalos' victory, of which there can be no doubt; a longer ratherthan a shorterintervalis to be expectedbeforethe reappearance of the TolistoagianGalatiansas Attalos' opponentsin the battle at the Aphrodision.rsTheseconsiderationssuggesta date for Attalos' Gallic victory within the period 23V235, and it is probablethat he bore the royal title for all but the initial yearsof his rule at Pergamon.re The battle fought at the Aphrodision, which must denote the PergameneAphrodision outside the city,20in which Attalos defeatedthe Tolistoagianand TektosaganGalatiansand Antiochos Hierax, is almostcetainlythe one mentionedby Trogus,Prologue xxvii, in the words Galli Pergamo victi ab Attalo, sinceTrogus' descriptioncorrespondsmorecloselywith this than with any other battle attestedfor these years. It is hardly identifiablewith the battle fought at the sourcesof the Kaikos, which was in no way located'at Pergamon'.The context of the battle in Trogus'narrative is the aftermathof the battle at Ankyra, in which Antiochos Hierax defeatedhis brother SeleukosII.21 The battle at Ankyra should most probably be dated to the year 235 (althoughothers have dated it earlier: see Appendix ii), and the battle at the Aphrodisionto the last yearsof the decade,that is, shortly before r8 An interval of some years between Attalos' Galatian victory at the sources of the Kaikos and the reappearance of the Galatians as mercenaries of Hierax was regarded by Kähler (Gr. Fries,83) as a'schwer vorstellbare Situation', but we would expect a period of inactivity on the part of the Tolistoagians if Attalos' victory was as resounding as our sources would have us believe. te For the epigraphical evidence relating to Attalos' titulature, see Appendix ii; it does not enable a closer dating than that already argued. 20The designationü 'Agpoöiorcv in a royal dedication at Pergamon must refer to the precinct outside the city; cf. Beloch, Gr. Gesch. iv.2 2.546. 2t Seleuci bellum in Syria adve rsus Ptolomaeum Tryphonem: item in Asia adve rsus fratrem suum Antiochum Hieracem, quo bello Ancurae victus est a Gallis' utque Galli Pergamo victi ab Attalo,Zielan Bithunum occiderint.
Attalos and Asia Minor
35
the battles in Lydia, Caria, and HellespontinePhrygia,of which the first two (/vP 27 and 28, from the bathron) are mentionedby Eusebios and dated respectively to 22918and 22817.22 In 227, accordingto the chronologytransmittedby Eusebios,Hierax fled to Thrace, there to meet his death, and to this year and in this context shouldmost probablybe datedthe battle in Hellespontine Phrygia which Attalos claimed as a victory (IvP 2l).zt ln 22615SeleukosII was succeededby his son SeleukosIII Soter, zawho undertookwithout successto recoverthe seriously weakenedSeleukid position in western Asia Minor. Among the dedicationswhich make up the largebathron is one for a victory over 'Lysias and the strategoi of Seleukos'(IvP 25+26, : OGIS 277): d.nö rfiE nagfd ne)öSA[u]olav I xai rcüs Zü.1eüxou mpatl4yolülE päXrt;. Another victory over a Seleukid army is celebratedin the seriesof smallerbaseswhose inscription is datable to the time of the Eumenid restoration of the precinct of Athena (on which seeAppendix ii), and which we shouldrestore (IvP 36): fBaoü.eüg"Arta).oE | /ri xai 'A}r1vaLl| älnö rrts-l I 'E[nry6vr1v'! npöE röv]|Zd,u3xou oftparryyövpdxnEl.rt This battle is too often overlooked, and is of particular importance in pointing to a probably continuous Seleukidmilitary undertaking against Attalos during the short reign of SeleukosIII. Attalos' opponent Lysias is almost certainly the AuofuE @LAoprfl,ou Maxeötitv honoured by a Delphian proxeny decree dated to 242 sc.26This allianceof the Seleukidking with adynastof Asia Minor 22Eusebiosi. 253 Sch. The chronologicaltradition derives from Porphyrius, Eusebios'sourcefor the chronologyofthe Hellenisticmonarchies.On the tradition, seeE. Schwartz,RE, s.v. Eusebios,1378-80(: Griech.Geschichtschreiber, 507-10)iR.Helm, Eranos,xxii (1924),l*40. zr Polyb. v.74.4: peral).d.fawoEtöv 6iov ini @p(x4q; Eusebiosi. 253 Sch. Eusebios'chronologyplacesHierax's flight to Thraceimmediatelyafterthe battle with Attalos in Caria, omitting the abortive attack on Seleukosin Mesopotamia which mustcomebetweenthesetwo events;that is, Hieraxfled from Seleukos,not f r o m A t t a l o sc; f . M . L a u n e yR , e c h e r c h e is. ,5 0 5 , n . 3 , a n d , o n t h e d e a t h o Hfi e r a x , Walbank.Comm. i.600. 2aBeloch,Gr. Gesch.iv.2 l. 686,2. 196. 25For the restoration'Efnry6v4tl, which is extremelylikely, seeCardinali,RP 44,n. | (a SeleukidEpigenes, rival of Hermeias,is knownfromPolyb.v.41.4:cf . Schmitt, Untersuchungen,15l-3). The restorationgiven in the text is more probable than that usually written, following unnecessarilythe dedicationfor the battle 'Efnryöv4u with Lysias: npög xai roüg ilJougl lZü.eüxou ofrpaqyoüE pdTqgl 26SGDI 2736;cf. above, 20 n. 39.
36
Attalos and Asia Minor
The Reign of Attalos I
againstthe King of Pergamonfurther indicatesthe intensityof the campaign, but whether this was a voluntary undertaking on Lysias' part or a requirementarisingfrom a subordinateposition cannot be determined.This evidencealfords no more than a dim and fleeting glimpse of the fortunes of a small dynasty whose originswere similar to thoseof the Attalids, but which, unlike the Attalids, did not achievethe statusof a kingdom. Thesetwo battles fought againstSeleukidarmies should probably be dated to the years 226-223,that is before Seleukos'advancein person,recordedby Polybios(iv. 48.7-8),which led to his death,most probablyin 223(seebelow, n.27):261euxoEyäp ö v6oEöE 0drrov napü.a6e rlu 6aot).eiav,rruvilavöpevoS"ArraTov ndoav ijör1 fiv öni räöe roü Taügou övvqoreiav öcp' aüröu npdypaow. nenotfio1at, nae@epü?q 6or10tiv roiE, ocper6poLE cp g ).o ov4 0 ei; ünö v, x ai ö o T aü o pey äpe t r öv q6 ä7rl öuv a),öv öö ön 'Anaroupbu peqL|a[e üv 6tov. toü laAärou xai NLxdvopoE, r' Although Seleukosfailed entirely to check Attalos' military predominancein western Asia Minor, his oppositionwas maintained,with more positiveresults,by his brother,AntiochosIII, Antiochos'cousin,or him in the autumnof 223.21 who succeeded position of oqarryyöE the uncle, Achaios,2swho had alreadyheld under Seleukos Kallinikos,2ewas now appointedBni täöe toü Ta(,tpou,that is to the overall commandof SeleukidAsia Minor, a post usurped previously by Antiochos Hierax.3oIt is diffrcult to assessthe implicationsfor Attalos of Achaios' success,althoughit is clear that for a time Achaioswas masterof the whole of Attalos' kingdomexceptthe capital(Polyb.iv. 48. ll):röv piv"AwaTov ei5 riav öö )"omöv nävrcttv i, öyaürö rö Il1pyapou ouv6.x),erce, xpau1E.It is likely, however,that Achaios'militarypredominance and it hasleft no wasephemeraland without lastingconsequences, 2 7O n t h e c h r o n o l o g y o f S e l e u k o s ' d e a t h a n d t h e a c c e s s i o no f A n t i o c h o s I l I , s e e S c h m i t t , U n t e r su c h u n g en , 2 - 3 . 2 8F o r t h e r e l a t i o n s h i pb e t w e e n A c h a i o s a n d A n t i o c h o s , s e e B e l o c h , G r . G e s c h . iv.2 2. 204-6: P. Meloni, Rendiconti dell'Accad. naz. dei Lincei, vüi (1949\, 543l. S c h m i t t , U n t e r s u ch u n g e n , 3 0 - 1 . 2ePolyainos iv. l7 (campaign against Hierax): orpat4yoi Zeleüxou'AyaöE xai 'AvöpöpaXoE pttä nüJ.fig öuvdpta4 Eöionov. Cf. Beloch, Gr. Gesch. iv .2 2. 205. r0 On this office see Bengtson, Strat. ü. 90-l l5l Schmitt, Untersuchungen, I 58-60.
37
trace in contemporarydocuments.We can more positively conclude that by the year 220 Attalos and Achaios had come to an understanding. In this year Achaios was proclaimed king in Laodikeia,3t and by this act he took for himselfmostof thoseparts of Asia Minor over which the Seleukidking still claimedauthority. Such an act of open rebellion is hardly credible if Achaios remainedformally at war with Attalos, no matter how successfulhe had previously been. Furthermore,when war broke out between Rhodesand Byzantion in this sameyear, 220,Byzantionappealed Polybios, who reto both Attalos and Achaios for assistance.32 cords the event, makes it clear that Attalos was in no position, beingstill confinedto Pergamon,to take an active part in the war, but it is hard to imaginethat Byzantionwould have madesuchan appealto both Attalos and Achaiosif the two were still in a stateof openwarfarewith one another.Thus we may concludethat by 220 some kind of agreementhad been reached;whatever the exact terms, it is clear from Polybios' narrative that for the time being Achaios maintainedhis military advantage. This initial advantage,however,was not maintained.In 218, while Achaios was occupied with the siegeof Selgein Pisidia,33 Attalos undertooka military expeditionwhich wasclearlyaimedat his authorityas it wasthenconstituted.Of particure-establishing lar interest is the fact that Achaios' suddendepartureleft Attalos free to leave his capitalwith a largearmy; we see, that is, that Achaios had done little to consolidatehis position, and Attalos quickly regainedhis 'lost' territory. A full accountof the expedition is given by Polybios(v.77-8\, and this accountremainsthe of the natureand extent of Attalos' rule in basisfor an assessment theseyears. This seriesof eventsends with the agreementreachedin 216 betweenAttalosand AntiochosIII, which probablydeterminedto a largeextent the final outcomein termsof Attalos' positionin the 3t Cf. Schmitt, Untersuchungen, 164-5. 3 2P o l y b . i v . 4 8 . l - 3 . I t i s t o b e n o t e d t h a t A t t a l o s e x p r e s s e dh i s s u p p o r t ' b u t c o u l d "AnaAog not implement it (48. 2): ö piv oöv fiv npö0u1to5, tip öi 6ga74tiav üre 'AlaLoü äqX1r'' ouwT4Taptvog eiE t)1v taq(tav Qonlv öE äv ün' rrPofyb. v.7'7.2: xard öi töv xaqöv xa|' öv'Ayaög itvottlto rfiv öni toüE 2tlytiE
orpattiav.
38
The Reign of Attalos I
following years, and was perhaps confirmed by a more formaL treaty a few years later. First, however, we must review the developmentof Attalos' position prior to this agreement. It is not surprisingthat during theseyearsof almostcontinuous military and political instability in the west of Asia Minor we see very little trace in any of our sourcesof an attempton Attalos' part to consolidatehis successesin terms of an expansionof direct royal authority; it seemsrather to have been a caseof his maintaining a hold on the little that he initially gained.Before 230 his military activity was entirely defensive,in the sensethat his victoriesover the TolistoagianGalatiansat the sourcesof the Kaikos, and over the combinedGalatiansand Hierax at the Aphrodision, clearly arosefrom action taken in defenceofthe kingdom he had Thus there was little opportunity inherited at his accession.34 Attalos to increasethe area of his direct auduring the 230sfor thority. During the yearsfrom 230to 223his military activity was extendedfurther afield, in areasover which he and his predecessorshad not previouslyexercisedany kind of authority, namelyin Lydia, Caria,and HellespontinePhrygia.and for a time Attalos was militarily predominantin all of them, although- a point which needsto be stressed- not in all of them at one time; they were, that is, simply successivetheatresof warfare.35Polybiossaysthat in 223 Seleukos III crossed the Tauros to attack Attalos, "Arra)"ov nAoav fiört riv öni räöe roü Taüpou nuu9anöpevoE öuvqore(av öq' aüröv nenoLfio9at(see above, 36). This statement, however,representsthe attitudeof Seleukos(asinterpreted by Polybios!), and not that of Attalos; it is chronologicallyinexact36and certainly exaggeratedwith respect to the extent to which Attalos was able to translatehis military supremacyinto a 3aThe defensive nature ofthese battles is shown by their respective positions: the 'sources of the Kaikos' were, as Kähler has indicated (Gr. Fries, 182), a natural point of entry for the Galatians into Attalos' kingdom; and at the Aphrodision Attalos was fighting under the walls of his capital. 3s For the view, which I regard as incorrect, that Attalos claimed a cumulative h e g e m o n y i n w e s t e r n A s i a M i n o r , s e e ,e . 9 . , C r a m p a , L a b r a u n d a , i i i . l . 1 2 4 ,w h o also sees Attalos' position as a motive for Doson's Carian expedition (following McShane, Foreign Policy, 97-100); this is extremely unlikely. 36Polybios compresses the chronology by saying that Seleukos crossed the Tauros röE 0dttov nap67a6e d1v 6aoÄeian, whereas he did so in 223, three years after his accession (see above, 36).
Attalos and Asia Minor
39
political one. During the years in question,the political vacuum createdin westernAsia Minor by the defeatof Antiochos Hierax was not left to Attalos alone to fill. In Caria, the interventionof AntigonosDoson in227, which we may now fortunatelyregardas a fact, effectively precludedAttalos' continuedmilitary predominance, and it is significant that the correspondencefrom Labraunda,which providesa very full picture of foreign rule in Caria, In makes no allusion to any period of Attalid administration.3T other areasAttalos continuedto face Seleukidmilitary opposition, and at leasttwo majorbattleswith Seleukidarmiesare, aswe have seen,recordedamongthe inscriptionsfrom the largebathron and elsewhere.The lack of positiveevidencemust precludecertainty, but it is extremely unlikely that Attalos found any opportunity during the 220sto establisha political hegemonyin the areas in which he was militarily successful. This negativeaspectof Attalos' ambition is complemented,on the other hand, by his developmentof relationswith Greek cities closerto Pergamon,where the evidenceshowsa distinct advance from the strictly limited position held by EumenesL38Herein, to my mind, and not in the field of military expansion, lies the achievementof Attalos I. The most important evidence is, as alreadynoted, Polybios'accountof the military expeditioncarried out by Attalos in 218,to which we now turn. Polybios'narrative(v. 3?Crampa, Labraunda, äi. l. 124. We also owe to Crampa (:Opusc.Athen. väi ( l%S), l7l-8) the elimination from the body of evidence relating to this question of a document (Welles, RC 29) once thought to have been ofthe Pergamene chancery and to relate to a supposed period of Attalid rule in Caria following the defeat there of Antiochos Hierax. Its connection with the Attalids has never been a convincing p r o p o s i t i o n ( c f . t h e d o u b t s a l r e a d y e x p r e s s e db y B e n g t s o n ,S t a t . ä . 1 0 0 ,n . 4 ) , a n d it can no longer be adduced in support ofthe conclusion, for which there is no other evidence, that Attalos treated Caria for a time as a Pergamene province. 38The best treatments of Attalos' relations with the Greek cities are still those ol P . G h i o n e , M e m . A c c a d . T o r i n o , l v ( 1 9 0 5 ) ,6 7 - 1 4 9 , a n d G . C a r d i n a l i , R P 8 l - 1 0 2 ; for further discussion see Magie, Roman Rule, ä.939, n. 36. The subject has been taken up more recently by R. B. McShane, Foreign Policy,58_9l, who sees the development of Attalos' relations with the cities as amounting to the foundation of a league modelled consciously on that of Doson's mainland league of states and cities. This view seems to me in itselfto go far beyond the scope ofthe evidence; it is presented by McShane by means of comparative arguments that are at best jar' gonistic and superficial, at worst absurd (e.g. the argument from Polyb. v.77.5-6 that Attalos held league meetingsl!), and inevitably leads to a distorted view of Attalos' activity and intentions in these years.
40
Attalos and Asia Minor
The Reign of Attalos I
77-8) is well detailedin terms of topography,and Attalos' movements can be retraced with some precision.3eThe aim of the expeditionwas clearly to recover authority over cities and communities in Aeolis and Mysia, that is, close to Pergarnon,which had previously fallen to Achaios;aothus Attalos went first to the "Amü"og Aeolian cities (v. 77. 2): öytv roüEAiyooäyaE faAdtag önenoqeüuo rdE xarä d1v Aiü,öa nö1e6 xai rdg'ouveTeiE 'Ayat(t xteooexex@Qrixenav öü. röv EötdürdeE,öoat npörcpov 6ov. After receivingenvoys from certain lonian cities, he turned northward; crossingthe AüxoE norapöE by Thyateira he visited thexaromiat t6y Muodur,the inhabitantsof Mysia,arreceivedthe surrenderof Karseai and Didyma Teiche (fortified positions in Mysia left by Achaios in chargeof a otpa.rqydg,Themistokles), crossedthe'AniaE neöfov (to be identifiedmost probablywith the valley of Balikesir)and Mount Pelekas(part of the Temnosrange), At thispointAttalos' andreachedthe river Makestos(v.77.3-91.t2 Galatianmercenaries,wearied by the long march, took the opportunity affordedby the omenof an eclipseof the moon to refuse to go any further, and they were settledby Attalos on suitableland by the Hellespont(v. 78. l-5;.+r After friendly dealingswith Qp4parioaE Eü.av)qtitnutE)three cities in the Troad which had remainedloyal to him, Lampsakos,AlexandriaTroas, and llion, Attalos returnedperä rfig öuvdtrteoqto Pergamon(v. 78. 6).aa 3eHolleaux's study inErades, ii. l7-42 (which first appeared in 1897)established the basis of our understanding of this campaign; for further topographical discussion (relative to Mysia), cf. L. Robert, Et. anat. 185-98. See also Schmitt, U ntersuchunge n, 262-4. 4 0 T h e a t t e m p t o f G . R a d e t , R e v u e d e s U n i v e r s i t ö sd u M i d i , 1 8 9 6 ,l - 1 8 , t o s h o w that Attalos' campaign involved a pursuit of Achaios as far as Pisidia, was refuted in detail by Holleaux, art. cit. (previous note), and was later renounced by the author i n t h e s a m ej o u r n a l ( 1 8 9 7 , p . 5 2 3 ) . ar Pliny, Nat. Hist. v.ll5: intus et Thyatira adluitur Lyco. Onthexatomiar rdtv Muoöv see Robert, Et. anat. l9l-4. a2The river is called Megistos by Polybios (v. 77.9,nepi dv M|yrotov norapöv), but its identification with the Makestos (Pliny, Nat. Hist. v. 142) or, more accurately, M6.xtoroE (Strabo xii. 8. l I, 576) is assured: Cf. W. Ruge, RE, s.v. Makestos, 773; Holleaux, Etudes, ii. 38; L. Robert, Et. anat. 187. a 3 O n t h e s i g n i f i c a n c eo f t h i s s e t t l e m e n ts e e c h . 5 . T h e e c l i p s e ( l S e p t . 2 l 8 ) provides one ofthe very few chronological certainties ofthe reign ofAttalos I prior to his alliance with Rome. aaIt is important to note from these words,perd tfiE öuvapettE, that the Galatians evidently constituted only a part, and probably a less significant part, ofthe forces which accompaniedAttalos in 218; see further below, ch. 5.
4l
The most important information suppliedby Polybios' account concernsthe extentof Attalos'ambition in 218,which corresponds with the conclusionswe have drawn on the basisof his activity in the 230sand 220s.Military activity was confinedto Aeolis and the Mysian communities;dealingswith the Greekcities southof Aigai and Temnosand in the Troad were, on the contrary, conductedon a diplomatic level. This fact is of considerableimportancein that the absenceof Achaios in Pisidia left Attalos with a free hand in areas further afield, and the limited nature of his activity may thereforebe regardedas representativeof his intentions.Attalos was clearly as little concerned in 218 with securinga political hegemonyin Lydia, Caria, and HellespontinePhrygiaas he seems to have been in earlier years. It is clear.then. that Attalos treatedthe Greekcitiesfurtherfrom Pergamonrather differently from those in Aeolis and Mysia. In thesetwo areas,as we seefrom Polybios' narrative, Attalos im' posedhis authority by force of arms. In Aeolis he aimedat recov'A6aLQ ötd Tueooex€X@Qrixercav ering those citiesöoat npörtpov töv qö6ov. fav al piv nLeiougö1ü.ovti1vaötQ npoo60evroxai ltetd ydqrcoE,ö\iyat ö6 rLveErqg 6taEnpoo$eqilr1oav.fioav ö' a[ t6re pera|4trnvarnpög aöröv npörov piv Küp1 xai MüqLvaxai
42
The Reign of Attalos I
affairs were in somemeasuresubjectto the dynast's supervision. We shouldevidentlyenvisage,that is, an areaof territory closeto Pergamonin which the Greek cities lost a large measureof their independenceto the dynasts.The natureof Attalos'authority over these cities cannot easily be defined, becausewe lack further evidenceof a positive kind. A clearerindicationof statusmay be seenhowever in the caseof Phokaia.During the Antiochic War this city was betrayedto Antiochos and receiveda Seleukidgarrison;a6then in 188,by the termsof the Romansettlementof Asia, it receivedback its 'ancestralconstitutionand the territory which it had before' (i.e. before the war).47Thus Phokaia, one of the Aeolian cities which returned willingly to Attalos' allegiancein 218, evidently retained its constitution and the right to the civic ownership of land in the years 218 to 195,during the years of Attalid rule. This does not necessarilymean, however, that Attalos exercisedno constitutionalcontrol over the city. In Pergamon, and (aswe will see)in other cities at a later date, the Attalids preservedthe constitutionalforms of the independentcity, the nd.rgrcvnü'fueupa, and controlledthe administrationby claiming for themselvesthe right to appoint certain officials within the administration,abovealltheorparqyoi.4sAt Pergamonthis measure is seento be in force alreadyduringthe rule of EumenesI,aebut the procedure is not certainly attested for cities of the Attalid Kingdom before the Peaceof Apameia, when the status of the Attalids' authority in Asia Minor was radically altered.It will be argued later that the office of inrctdrqg, comparablewith that attestedfor the other Hellenistic kingdomsin the context of the administrationof the Greek cities, was introduced to the PergameneKingdom by Attalos I, probablywhen he acquiredAigina in 209.s0Aigina was however a unique case; it was the personal possessionof the king, and at the time of its acquisitionit constituted his only territory outsideAsia Minor. Attalos' rule in Aigina a6Livy xxxvii. 9. l-4; I l. 5; cf. Appian, Syr. 25: önrixooE'Avrö7ou. +zPolyb. xxi. 46. 7: dn|öaxav öi xai
Attalos and Asia Minor
43
may not necessarilybe taken as a reflection of his rule in cities closer to Pergamonand acquired at an earlier date. In the caseof Phokaia,moreover,the institution of an önrcrdrqg is not compatible with the fact that the city evidently retained its ancestral constitution after 2 18. It is probable then that Attalos demandedthe loyalty of the Greek cities and communitiesin Aeolis and Mysia, and supported this demandby force of arms in 218,but that he did not interfere, beyond this requirement, in their internal administration.This conclusionwill be seento correspondwith the natureof Attalos' activity in the first twenty yearsof his reign, which was defensive and not expansive; in maintaining his authority in Aeolis and Mysia againstthe interferenceof his successiveenemies,and of these especiallyAchaios, who for a short time most effectively deprived him of his authority, it was support for his military undertakingsthat Attalos most requiredfrom the cities and communitiesconcerned.Further evidencein supportof this indication may be cited for Thyateira.This city is not mentionedin Polybios' accountof the campaignof 218,perhapsbecauseit had not allied itself with Achaios, but in crossing the ArjxoE notap6g Attalos passedthrough its territory,sr and he probably took the opportunity of confirrning its loyalty; it is unlikely, at least, that he ignoredit altogether.That Thyateiralost a measureof its independence after 218 is shown by a dedicatory inscription of Roman imperial date emanating from this city, and set up by oi d.nö 'AndTou xai EüptvouE xarolxoüvteg Mepvo{tgwa 6aot76atv 'HpaxArloaorai.s2A cistophorosof Thyateira,formerly dated to year 2 of the reign of EumenesII (BA EY B), indicatedon that chronologythat Thyateirawas Attalid in 196/5,and it was argued that the katoikoi of the dedicationwere originally settled in the territory of Thyateira, as the joint namessuggest,at the end of Attalos' reign and the beginningof Eumenes',that is, in 197.53 Now that this cistophoros,togetherwith othersof the sameseries (datedBA EY B and A), has been convincinglyredatedto a later period,s4there is no evidencethat Thyateira remainedunder At5r See above, 40. 52Keil and von Premerstein, Bericht über eine Reise in Lydien, 27, no. 51. sr Robert, Villes, 3940. 5 4E . S . G . R o b i n s o n , N u m . C h r o n . x i v ( 1 9 5 4 ) , l - 7 1 L . R o b e r t , V i l l e s , 2 5 2 - 6 0 .
44
The Reign of Attalos I
Attalos and Asia Minor
talid control continuously from 218 to the outbreak of the AntiochicWar, and the literaryevidencesuggests otherwise.In 201, when Philip V of MacedoninvadedPergamene territory, Thyateira seemsstill to havebeenunderAttalos' control,ssbut it is probable that this control was lost to AntiochosIII in 198,when he in turn invadedAttalos' kingdom;there is positiveevidencein the narrative of Livy to the effect that EumenesII no longercontrolledthe city in 190and hadprobablynot doneso for sometime (xxxvii. 8. 7): is (sc. Eumenes)cum magnampraedam agi possedixissetex hostium agro, qui circa Thyatiram esset, hortando perpulit Livium, ut quinquemillia militum secummitteret. missi ingentem praedam intra paucos dies averterunt.s6In the light of this interpretationof the evidence,we must concludethat the settlement was originally establishedby Attalos I before 198,and probably beforePhilip's invasionof 201,when Attalos becameinvolved for the secondtime in an Aegeanwar, and that it was refoundedby EumenesII after 188.The statusof Thyateirais thereforecertainly relevantto Attalos'positionafter218,andshowsthatin additionto expectingthe loyalty of the Greek cities he regardedhimself as entitled to establishcoloniesin their territory. Further evidence of the implications for the cities and communitiesof Aeolis and Mysia of their enforcedloyalty to Attalos can be inferredonly indirectly from our sources.In particular,we have no direct evidenceas to whether they were requiredto pay tribute, but the fact that the Ionian city of Teos, which was bound to Attalos by ouv9fixan,hadto pay a largeamountof tribute, as we will see,rendersit extremely likely that the sameobligationwas demandedat least in Aeolis, where Attalos' control was, as we haveseen,much tighter. It was naturallyan importantincentiveto
a Hellenistic monarch in ensuringthe loyalty of the Greek cities that he gained thereby more substantialsupport in his military undertakings.It seemsmost likely, then, that Attalos envisageda supply of money and men in the cities whoseloyalty he enforced. In Mysia, the situationwas rather different.Muooi, as hasalready been mentioned, constituted a part of the Pergamenegarrison which occupied the city of Lilaia during the First Macedonian War, a fact which indicatesthat the communitiesof Mysia supplied men rather than money;5?this is an understandableprocedurein the caseof a country which was madeup almostentirelyof village communities(xaromtat röv Muoöv).s8 We shouldtake account,finally, of a letter written by Attalos in 205to Magnesiaon the Maeanderin reply to that city's requestfor recognitionof its newly inauguratedfestival for Artemis Leukophryene.seIn agreeingto the requestAttalos speaksnot only for himself,but alsofor'the citiesunderme' (12-13:riliouv ööxaiü.E ön' öpänü.epEllänoö6[ao0aL öpoitoE;19-20:.xsi ai nö).etEöi ai fneßöpe]lvaripoi notrtoouowöpoiaE). The cities concernedcan only be thoseof Aeolis,andthe terminologyusedby Attalos shows that they remainedfirmly under his control, in a mannerand to a degreecomparablewith the control exercisedby EumenesI over the Pitane.In sum, the evidencefor the years218to 201suggests following conclusionsas to the nature of Attalos' authority in Aeolis and Mysia: it is clear that he claimed the right to their loyalty (this right extendingto substantialsupportin time of war) and. furthermore. to their subordinationto his will in matters of foreign policy, as well as the right to use their land for the settlement of military colonists;it is probable,on the other hand,that he did not appoint residentofficials in thesecitiesor interferein their constitutionalprocedure.They were, in other words, administratively independent,but in terms of external policy they were subjectto the directionsof the King of Pergamon. Turning to the citiesfurther from Pergamon,to the southin lonia and to the north in HellespontinePhrygia, we see, as already
ss Polyb. xvi. l. 7: Philip, after destroying the Pergamene Nikephorion, äppqoe tdE trrövdpTdq öni @uarcipow. It has rightly been inferred from this passage that Thyateira was at this time in Attalos' possession; cf. Holleaux, Etudes, iv.247-55: Robert, Villes, 38. It should be noted that Philip did not necessarily attack Thyateira, or even reach it; the words iz i @oariptlv indicate the direction of his march (Holleatx, Etudes, iv. 249, n. l). 56Cf. Livy xxxvii. 37, attesting further Antiochos' occupation of the city before the battle at Magnesia: regia castra circa Thyatiram erant. Schmitt (Unrersuchungen, 273, n. 3) has pointed to the unlikelihood of Eumenes' taking part in a raid on a recent possession; it is therefore more reasonable to regard Thyateira as a loss of 198, eight years earlier.
45
5 7S e e a b o v e , 3 3 . ssOn the Mysian communities, see L. Robert, Et. anat. 194: Launey. Recherches, i.4f6-'1. seIvM 22. = OGIS 282; Welles, IRC 34.
46
The Reign of Attalos I
noted,a differentrelationshipbetweenking andcity . The evidence for theseareasis fuller, althoughin somerespectsequallyconfusing. In particular, the ouv9qxanmentionedby Polybiosdo not tell us very much about the obligationsthey incurred,beyondthe fact that they were entered into voluntarily by the cities concerned: rjxov öö xai naqd Tqbv xai KoAocpavtavnp6odt6 |yyepi(ovreE öi xai rcüroug öni oqdE aüroüE xai tdE n6)"e6.npooöe$ö.peuoE raig ouv0rjxa6 atE xai rö nqörcgov, xai ).a6öv öpripouE,öy pqtrtdrrcerciE napd röv Zltupvafav npeodeuraiEqü.av9qdno4 öÄ rö pä)"rcra roütouErcrqqrlxtvacrlv nqöEaütöv niorw (v .77 . 5-6). The useof the wordöyyeqi(ew,'to entrust',is of significance in that Polybiosused it on severaloccasionsto denotea relationship between king and city, or betweenone city and another, in which the weakervoluntarily seeksthe protectionof the stronger, and three examplesare especiallynoteworthy as the phraseology is identicalwith that pertainingto Teos.60Kalynda, seekingindependencefrom Kaunos in 163,turned to Rhodes (xxxi. 5. 3): äyavtövttg öö rö pil.)"ov nqeodeüetvpöv .. . (lac.) iyyeLp((ovreg ogd.gaitroüg xai rlv nöLw.6t ln 219,during the war of the allies, the city of Phialeia,threatenedby an Aitolian attack (iv. 79. 8), aüroüE önnpeodeuodpevotngöEröv @il,mnovöveytipcoavocpd.g The expressionis used,finally,of a city's seeking xai tilv nö)"w.62 rptTant the protectionof Rome(xviii. 49.l): ödv,rö öl ).ey6pevov, i1v öoydrr1u,öni roüg'Papaioug xatacpeüfovraLxai roüroLEEyyetqrc0ot ocpd.E aörcüE xai rlv nö)"w. These parallels serve to clarify the position taken by Teos in 218,as Polybiosdescribesit. As in the other casescited, the idea impliedis not one of conquest or subjection,but ofprotection soughtby the city againsta danger, 60For other uses of tyyetpiltw by Polybios, see A. Mauersberger,PolybiosLexikon (Berlin 1956-),s.v. (65examples).The word is also usedin public documents of the 'entrusting' of civic ofTicesto a person, e.g. in /G ä.2 1O28,72: napala6öv tilv ilyllprgto9eioat äaurlritr, nilotLv önö rcü öfipou;cf.lG ix. 2. I103, l3-14; Holleaux,Etudes,ii. 186.In itself it in no way impliessurrenderor lossof independence. 6rOn thiseventseeMagie,Roman Rule, i. I l0; ii. 957,n. 7t; l39l n. 59.Rhodes subsequentlyoccupiedthe city and its possessionwas confirmedby the Senate (xxxi. 5. 5: ouv66q öö xai d1t oüyil.1rov aötoiE fedauloat rilv röv KaJ,uvölav xtfiow). This doesnot, however,affectour interpretationofthe originalintention as expressedin the word iyptpiltr.v. 62Cf. F. W. Walbank,Philip V of Macedon (Cambridge,1940),46.
\i
Attalos and Asia Minor
47
the dangerin this caseclearly beingthe return of Achaios.A single term will not adequatelydefinethis relationship,but the nearestto hand is 'protectorate' rather than 'overlordship'; words such as 'subjection',and 'dependence',which are more usuallyappliedin this context,63are inappropriateto the positionof the cities which soughtAttalos' protection. This interpretationof Polybios' evidenceis of considerableimportancein clarifying the statusof Teos in the last decadeof the third century. In the middle of this decade,most probably in204, following the exampleof a numberof citiesof westernAsia Minor, Teos instituted a festival to honour its god, Dionysos, and dispatchedthe usual envoys throughoutthe Greek world to request the doü'ia of its territory.6aAmong extant repliesto this request are those of the Aitolians, the Amphiktyons, Delphi, and a large The decreesof Delphi and of the numberof Cretancommunities.6s that of Amphiktyons are datableto one of the years 20413-20312; the Aitolians more preciselyto the Panaitolikaof February-March 203.66The replies of some of the Cretan communities,which should also be dated to one of these years,67refer to assistance affordedto the envoysof Teos by representativesof Philip V and 63Cf. Cardinali,RP l0l (Teoslisted as'Attalid' as distinctfrom 'free'); Meyer' Die Grenzen,105.Seealsobelow,n. 76. 6aSeeP. Herrmann.Anadolu, ix (1965),29-159(citedin the followingnotesby the author'snamealone). 6sTwo copieshavebeenfound ofthe Aitolian and Delphiandecrees.AlroLlANS: (a) copy from Teos: SGDI l4ll, : Syl/.3 563,IG ix.2 l. 192;(b) from Delphi:F (a) from Teos: Ad. Wilhelm,GGA clx (1898)'218' : Delphes,üi.2. 134a.DELpHI: SGDI 2675;(b) from Delphi: Syl/.r 565, = F. Delphes,iii. 2. 134c.AMPHIKTYoNS: rtNcs, Theodoros Sy//.I 564, : F. Delphes,iii. 2. I 34b. Letter of the ATHAMANIAN and Amynandros:Wilhelm, GGA clx (1898),217, = Welles'RC 35. cnrreN cotr'tSGDI 5165-80,: Inscr. Creticae,I, p. 4, no. I (Apollonia);p. 25, no. 52 MUNTTTES: (Arkades);p. 30, no. I (Biannos);p. 62, no. 8 (Knossos);p. l0l, no. I (Istron); p. ll l, no. 2 (Lato);p.292, no. I (Rhaukos);ll,p.2' no. I (Allaria);p. 63' no. l7 (Axos)p ; . l 1 8 , n o . 2 ( K y d o n i a )p; . 1 6 l , n o . 2 l ( E l e u t h e r n a ) ; p . 2 4n3o' . 3 ( P o l v r rhenia);p. 291,no. I (Sybritos);III, p. 31, no. 2 (Hierapytna). 66Thechronologicalbasisofthese decrees,includingthe fact that the repliesof the Greek communitiesshouldbe datedto the years205-201,was establishedby Cf. G. Klaffenbach,IGix.2 1.,p.5l (onno. Ad. Wilhelm,GGAclx (1898),216-20. 95): Herrmann,94. 67Cf.G.Colin,F.Delphes,iii.2.p.l36;Holleaux'Etudes, iv. 178-203;W.Ruge' RE, s.v. Teos, 541-50.The datingofthe Cretandecreesto 193,the yearofthe reply of the Roman praetor (seebelow, n. 73), though followed in spiteof Wilhelm by difil.xxxv(lX)7), l3)isunsupportable. Blass(onSGD/5165-80)andCardinali(Riv.
48
The Reign of Attalos I
Antiochos III, and it is clear from thesecircumstancesthat Teos was acting in the matter without referenceto its relationshipwith the King of Pergamon.On the contrary, it has long been recognized that the intervention of Philip was due to his status as npoord.rqgof the Cretan communities,while the part played by Antiochos showed a direct relationship between Teos and the Seleukidking.68An inscriptiondiscoveredmore recently at Teos (Sivrihissar)has confirmed and clarified this position.6eThis inscriptionrecordsa decreeof Teos honouringAntiochosIII and his queen,Laodike, aswell aspart of a letter written by the king to the city acknowledgingthe honourspaid to him. The decreerefers in detail to Antiochos' part in the negotiations,and to his own recent recognitionof the äoü"1o.of the city, and was thereforeprobably passedin 203.70Of particularinterestis the fact, now attestedfor the first time, that Antiochos appearedin person in the city, strengtheningthe impressionof a firm relationshipbetween the two (I. 17-18):napü")öv eiErilv öxü,ryotavaödE ld.vqxeri1[v] nöLry xq) rily yrbgav rjpöv ieqd.vxoi äoü.ov zrl.. Antiochos' presenceat Teos may be dated to 204,when he is known to have been in Asia Minor following the return from his easterncampaigns,Tra datewhich fits well with a declarationof äoü.fu inthe Greek mainlandin the following spring. It is clear from this evidence that by 2M Teos no longer dependedon its former relationshipwith Attalos I of Pergamon.As long as Teos is regardedas an Attalid subject, or as part of the Attalid Kingdom, in the years from 218 to 204,this sequenceof events presentsa major difficulty in that Attalos must, in these have sufferedthe'loss'of Teos as a kind of fait circumstances, accompli,T2 in spiteof the goodrelationswhich,as we will see,are 6EMagie, Roman Rule, ii.942-3, n.391'Buckler Studies, 168, n. 3; Ruge, RE s.v. Teos, 550; Walbank, Philip V, l2l, n.3. The view of Holleaux (art. cit. n. 67), that Philip was at the time master of Teos, having captured the city in 201, was extreme and failed to explain the position taken by Antiochos: it also led to chronological difficulties. 6eHerrmann, art. cit. (n. 64). 7 0S e e H e r r m a n n ' s c o m m e n t a r y , 9 3 - 7 . ItPolyb. xv. 25. 13, in an account of events in Egypt following the death of Phifopator, says that Agathokles If6lona piv äftneprpe röv I76lorog tiEtilv'Aotav npög'Avrioyov röv 6aoL\öa. On the date of this event, see Wilhelm, Wien. Anz.lvü ( 1 9 2 0 ) ,5 7 ; S c h m i t t , U n t e r s u c h u n g e n , 2 3 3 , n . 2 ; H e r r m a n n , 9 6 . 72So Herrmann, 106-18, esp. l12: 'es sieht eher danach aus, dass Attalos in diesem Falle ein fait accompli in Kauf nehmen musste' etc.
Attalos and Asia Minor
49
evident between Attalos and Antiochos for at least a part of the time before the outbreakof the SecondMacedonianWar. What is more. the action of the Roman Senatein 193,in addingits nameto the list of stateswhich recognizedthe inviolability of Teos,thereby endorsing the part played by Antiochos, would be difücult to understand if Antiochos had acquired the city forcibly from Rome'sfriend and ally.73This legalisticview of Teos' statusdoes not, however,adequatelyaccountfor its relationshipwith Attalos, and later with Antiochos; in fact such a view never coresponds with the largelyindefiniterelationsbetweena Hellenisticmonarch and a Greek city.74Polybios says that Teos placed itself under Attalos' influenceby looking to him for protection; this is not to saythat the city was thencefortha subjectcity or a part of Attalos' kingdom.It is more likely that Attalos simply retainedhis statusof defender,or protector, of Teos, Kolophon, and the other Ionian cities, up to 205,the year of the Peaceof Phoinikewhich endedthe First MacedonianWar. Attalos had played little part in this war, having had to return to defend his kingdom in 208 when it was invadedby PrusiasI of Bithynia. Of the war with Prusiaswe know little more than the fact, but it is probablethat it wasendedin 205at the sametime as the Peaceof Phoinike,bringinga short periodof tranquillity to westernAsia Minor beforethe invasionof Philip in 201.7s lt is not surprisingthat Teos,in this shortperiodof peace, no 73A letterof M. ValeriusMessalla,the praetorof 193(Sy//.3601),confirmedthe status of Teos as fcqär xa0dtg xai vüv totw xai äou).ovxai dqopd.öyqrov dnö 'Ptopaior. For the circumstances,which includedagainthe mediaro6 örjpouröv Etudes,iv.200-203,whoexplainedthe tionofenvoysofAntiochos,seeHolleaux, latedateof Teosl requestto Romein termsof his beliefthat the city remainedunder the control of Philip, Rome'senemy,until 196,when Afrtiochosgainedcontroland could act as mediator.Now that we know that Antiochos'influenceat Teosis to be dated much earlier than previouslysupposed,this explanationcannot stand; cf. Herrmann 14l-2. In the presentstate of our evidencethe questionmust remain open. 7aCf. the remarksof A. H. M. Jones,Tfte GreekCityfrom Alexanderto Justinian (Oxford, 1940),95. TsOn the war betweenPrusiasand Attalos see Habicht, RE, s.v. Prusias(l). 1092-3iHermes, lxxxiv (1956),94. Habicht rightly envisagesa separatetreaty concludedbetweenthem at aboutthe time of the Peaceof Phoinike.I seeno good reason, however, to discount the authenticity of their appearanceamong the adscriptito thePeaceof Phoinike(Livy xxix. 12.l4), sincetheirhostilitieshadhada bearingon the MacedonianWar. Most suspectamongthe namesof lhe adscripti are Athensand Ilion, but all the otherscan be defended.Forthe greatlyvariedmodern opinion on this question, ranging from complete acceptance(e.g. J. P. V. D. Balsdon,JR^l xliv (1954),32-5) to total rejection(Habicht,RE, s.v. Prusias(l), 1093),seethe bibliographyto Sty iii. 543 (Peaceof Phoinike).
50
The Reign of Attalos I
longer sought Attalos' protection, and the fact that itsouvilfixat with Attalos were renewedin 218 indicatesthat the relationship was largefyof anqd hoc nature,that is, it wasrelatedto the stateof military activity in westernAsia Minor. [n passingunder the more direct influenceof AntiochosIII on his return from the East in 204, Teos did not ceaseto be an Attalid city (which it had never been) and henceforthbecomea Seleukidcity,76terms which so far from defining statusavoid the problemsinvolved; rather, in a time of comparativepeace,it felt free to look to a new protector. This, then, is the natureof the changein Teos' status;the reasonsfor it aremoreclearly apparentfrom the decreehonouringAntiochos,to which we now return. The decreeattestsclearly for the first time the natureand extent of the obligationswhich in generalwe would expectTeos to have incurred in looking to Attalos for protection. It has long been thought, although mostly for the wrong reasons,that Teos paid someform of tribute to Attalos in 218,77and this conclusionhas been establishedas a fact by the decree,where we find specific .referencesto such payments: I. l0-20 (Antiochos) naqayevöpevog öni rcüExa?' rjpaErönouEänoxat6ornoe d ngäypara eiE oupE{povoav xard.otaow xo,i inöqp1oaE iv rfi nö).et fipdv xai 1erttpöv ilqo1uryxhaE flpag xafi] öv rciE xowoiE xai öu rcig iöiory öü rc toöE ouveXetE noT|poulgl xai ü piyüog dtv öcptpopev ouurdfeav xai 6ou7öpevoE ui rc npöE üv )eöv eüoeddtEötaxüo7at fot xa|ßpaotv flpritutilv nöAw xai d1vXtbpav(xo'i) 067ovyap(lw9at röt te örjpaLxai uitt xowöt tört nepi röu 4gövuoovrtyvtröv napeT9dsveiEd1v öxxlqoi.av aötöE ävqxe fi[v] nö),tuxai rily ybpav f1priviepäv xai äoütou xai dgopoTöy1rov xlailröv ä)J.ay fov icp4poptvouurd$eav6aoÄei'Auä\at üneö{fato &.nü.u0fioao0atfipag öt' aürcü xrL. L32-4 (Teian envoys had been sent to Antiochos, and he) BveEävoe [ört natpaAöiuxed1p nöltv eiEd.eixa\ött önqyilarc ,;t, orrrr*fflo" fueucppptov6aoÄei'And).a L. The terminology here is imprecise; we read first äy öcp6popev ouwä$tav (19), and later fov ouverd$apu cphpow (33-4), although 76SoRuge,RE, s.v.Teos,547-50: cf. Herrmann108:,tatsächlich istTeosin den Jahren205/3seleukidisch gewesen bzw.,wiewirjetzt sagenkönnen,geworden.' tt e.g.by Ghione,art.cit. (n. 38),94;Cardinali, RP 934;Meyer,DieGrenzen, 105,wholistsTeoswith'tributpflichtige Städte'as distinctfrom.freieverbündete'.
Attalos and Asia Minor
51
it is to be noted that in the secondcontext the decreerecordsthe reply of Antiochos. A distinction between the terms cpögoEand oüvtalry is clearly evident in the fourth century, including Alexander'sadministrationof the Greekcitiesof Asia Minor, but it cannot be taken for granted that the distinction was maintainedat the end of the third century.t8 In the Attalid Kingdom as it was constitutedafter the Peaceof Apameia,we meeta variety of terms to denote the payment of money by a city to a king: qöQoE, ü,)'eopa,np6ooöor,,but the exact differencesin their connotations remainobscure.TeWe cannot even be certainthat the tetmqöpoE always denotesa regular,i.e. annualtribute, althoughthis seems to be the usagein a documentdating from the reign of Attalos II and concerning a city under Pergamenecontrol.soOverall the evidence seemsto show that, as distinct from the term EöpoE, which acquired the role of a generaldesignation(asis apparent,for example,in the concept of d.qopd"oyqoia),the terms oüvta[6, rt),eopa, and so on, were used impreciselyand even indiscriminately. [t is thereforenot necessarilyvalid to arguefrom the text under discussionthat Teos paid Attalos I specificallycategorized cpdpogand oüvra$rE, since this too would presupposethat the terms are used precisely, whereasthey clearly are not. Further78For a statementof the casefor maintaininga strongdistinctionbetweenthe termsoüvta{ry and cpöpoE,see H. Francotte,Les Financesdes citös grecques (Paris,1909),77-86;on the Attalids,81, where the positionis summedup as follows:'substituerle phorosä la syntaxis,c'est substituerun 16gimede contrainte sansrdservesä un r6gimede libertd.' This conclusionis in my view too rigid for the natureof relationsbetweencity and suzerainin the Hellenisticperiod,which I have touchedon in thetext.On theotherhand,A. Heuss.StadtundHerrscher,l0ü-lll. argued too dogmaticallyagainstthe distinction at this date. There seems,for example,tobeadistinctionintheletterofAlexandertoPriene,OG/S 1.9-15:rödä - - xci Mupol- - - xai - - - - | xlai n[d.oav rilu nfu $1 Xtbpalv ylwtboxa ipilv tiva4 I rcüq,öi xaltomoövtag öv taiE xdpatg taültaq cpipttv rcüE cpöpoug.trlE | öi ouwdf,taE äqiqpt t)1pLlqqlvöap nötrn,22,1. Herrmann'spoint in this connection (seebelow),that referenceis in onecaseto a city, andin theotherto villages,seems to me to strenglhenrather than weakenthe casefor a distinction.Naturally one cannotassumethat the distinctionwas maintainedabsolutelyover a hundredyears later, but it seemslikely that chancerieswere awareof somedifferencein concept betweenthe two terms.Forfurtherdiscussion of this question,cf.Magie,Roman Rule, li.829, n.14;Herrmann,l0l-5. 7eSeebelow. ch. 4 (ii). t0 Amfada: Swoboda, Keil, and Knoll, Denkmäleraus Lykaonien, no. 74 ll: Appendix iv, no. 23; this documentis discussedbelow, 102.
52
The Reign of Attalos I
more, the fact that AntiochosdeclaredTeos feqä xo,iäou).ogxai äcpopo)r6yqtog does not mean that the city had formerly paid regularcpöeogin addition to oüwaSLq since the formula was an abstractone, usedto denotethe future statusof a city's inviolability.tt It is more likely that Teos hadpreviouslybeenrequiredto pay occasionalcontributionsto Attalos, which were sometimes calledouvrd(eq and at other times, more generally,cpdpoqthan that thesepaymentswere regularand specific.It is not until a later date in the developmentof the PergameneKingdom that we find the paymentof regulatedtribute to the sovereign. Further evidenceof theseobligationsis to be found in the terms, asreportedby Polybios,of the Romansettlementof Asia Minor in 188sc. Here we read amongthe requirementslaid down for the Greek cities (xxi. 46. 2): öoat (sc. titv aörovöpav n6).eav)ö' 'Arrd.|qt oüvra$w irt).ouv, raüra6 öntta$av röv aüröv Eöpövet öLöövatqöqov.E2This is translatable in two ways:either,'they (the Romancommissioners)requiredthosecities which hadpaidoüvra$ry to Attalos to pay the same(amountof ) tribute to Eumenes', or, 'they requiredthosecities which had paid oüvraf r.Eto Attalos to pay the sameasEöpogto Eumenes'.Of thesetwo alternatives, the first seemsto me in itself the more likely; this involvesregardingoüvralg andcpöqoE as beinginterchangeable, in the sensethat qöpoE could denote any kind of tribute payment, which, as we have seen,seemsto be the casein the third and secondcenturies sc. This preferencewith respectto Polybios'meaningis supported by his terminologyin describing,at an earlier point in the narra8t It is the conclusion of Herrmann, l0l-5, that in addition ro a regular EöeoE, Teos paid Attalos ouuttiferg, but this assumes that the declaration of dEoqoToy4oia (L l8) means that Teos had necessarily paid a regulargdgo6 up to that point, an assumption which is not justified by the confused terminology used in the decree. A declaration of äpopd.oyr1oia meant only that the city would not be required in the future to pay tribute, regardless ofprevious requirements. The term is included in the letter of Messalla (Sy//.3 601 ; see above n. 73), 19-21:.xpivoptv tlvat i1v nö7Lv xai d1v Xtblpav iqä.v xa0öE xai vüv öorp xai äoü"ov xai d.cpogol).öyqtov d.nö rcü 'Parya{aw, örjpou toü and in the letter of the Athamanian kings (see n. 65), 7-8: olulyXtttpoüptv eivat xo) i1v I nöLa, öpöv xai tily X
Attalos and Asiq Minor
53
tive, the generalprovisionsenvisagedby the Senatefor the settlement of Asia Minor (xxi. 24. 8): r6v (öö)nütav iav 'E),),7viöav 'Auä)"q öoat pöv cp6qovöner|)rouv, caütaE röy aötöv Eöp|vet 'AvuöyE, rü'eiv, öoat ö' pövov ra6ra6 d.cpeio9at röv cp6gov.The constructionof this sentencearound the antithesisöoat pöv 'ArtdAE - öoat ö' 'AvröXE, requires that the term cpöqoEbe usedofformer paymentsboth to Attalos andto Antiochos,and this usage therefore confirms the general connotation of the term cpöeog.In the case of Teos, then, the city certainly paid Attalos orjvra$tE and Eöpog, but it is most probablethat the two terms refer to the same thing, and the fact that these paymentswere evidently severeconstitutesthe most likely motive for the city's turning to Antiochos in 204. Another inscription requires mention in the context of tribute payment,althoughits relevanceis doubtful.s3This documentis a decreeof Teos recording its decisionto buy land for the Ionian Guild of Dionysian relvitar, whose seat was then at Teos (5-9): dyoqäoat öö aötoiE xai xftqllual öyyeoviv u1Lnö),eri) rfiLyritpat änö öqa (ytöv ) F X I lxail np ooayoqt6 eo1a Lr ö &yoqao?iv xrfi pa iepöv ö ävt604lxl ö öqpoE röt xow(aLuitv nepi röy lr,öttuooy r[ely]vtröv, öv d.re],iEtiv f1 nö76 änßä)").etrc).öv. Of the six thousanddrachmai required for the purchaseof the land, three thousand were to be provided iy 6aoü"moü, that is, from royal funds (15-18): rö öö ön[ollL]nöEöpafupäE)XXX öötaoav oi eioLövreErapiat ix t[öv I np]ötav öo0qoop6vatvaöroiE öy 6ao ü.moü eiEr [fiv I t rllEndAea Eörcixrlow. Thesetwo procedures, the paymentof r67q ('duties'),and the receiptof moneyfrom royal funds,have hitherto suggesteda relationshipwith an Attalid rather than a Seleukid king,8aalthough this criterion alone does not decidethe matter; all we can say is that thesepracticesare better attestedfor the Attalids. A more substantialargumentis the fact ar R. Demangel and A. Laumonier,SCH xlvi(1922),312-lg, no. 2 (SEGii. 580). Cf. L. Robert,Et. anat. 3944 (supplements2-5; commentary16-23).The text is reproducedin A. W. Pickard-Cambridge,The DramaticFestivalsof Athens(ed.2, rev. Gould and Lewis, Oxford, 1968),314, no. 9. saCf. Holleaux, Etudes,ii. 95-6 (chronology:96. n. 2); Ruge,RE, s.v. Teos,562 (datesthe inscriptionbefore225);E. Bickermann,Hermes,lxvii (1932),68; W. Hahland,Ö"/lr xxxviii (1950\,924: Herrmann. 102.n. 105.
54
The Reign of Attalos I
that the Attalids are known to have taken a great interest in the welfareand prosperityof the reyvfuatwhen Teosbecamea tributThe Ionian Guild is attestedfor the first time by an ary city in 188.8s Aitolian decreeof 235,and it is unlikely that it was foundedmuch beforethis date;s6in this casethe only alternativeroyal funds are those of the Seleukid Antiochos III, who can reasonably be excluded on the ground of his recognition of the city as nor is it likely that the city had paid taxes in 204;87 dcpopoAöyrltoE to Antiochos at an earlier date, since the decree honouringhim complainsso bitterly of the demandsmadeby Attalos. For these reasonsa connectionwith the Attalids is a sounderproposition' The documenthas commonlybeendatedto the reign of Attalos I, but a dateafter the Peaceof Apameiaseemsfar more likely.88The criterion of the letter forms is not by itself decisive,sincethey are compatible with a date in any of the three periods, 22V223' 2l&l20l, and that immediatelyfollowing the Roman settlement.8e On historical groundsthe first of theseperiodsappearsto be the least likely, while Holleauxls argumentthat the decreegives the impressionof relationsrecently establishedbetweenthe city and sincetheserelationswere the Guild of rsxvirGLis not convincing;eo never very stable, it is not necessarilyto be concludedthat the buyingof land and votingof honoursby the city impliesthe Artists' recentarrival. Furthermore,the only other evidencefor payment 85Seebelow,ch. 4 (ii). E6F. Delphes,iii. 3. 218B,6-7: ööofelroiE AiraToIE dn]?ööpevtoiE rqgvfuatE 'I[aviag xai'ELLqonölvtou xr]'' On tdlv lrt doEdAem)vxc'irdv äoü'tav totg ön' the origins of the Ionian koinon, see G. Klaffenbach,Symbolaead historiam collegiorum Artificum Bacchiorum (Berlin, l9l4), 17-21; Pickard-Cambridge' Dram. Festivals,2914. s7Holfeaux,Etudes, li. 96, n. 2. 8sCf. Bengtson Holleaux,Ruge,Hahland(see ,Strat.ä.220.Fortheearlierdate: n. 84). EeCf. Holleaux,loc. cit. (n. 8?).The lettersbearsomeresemblance to thoseof the Korrhagosdecree,but this point cannotbe pressed.In this caseI do not think that the letters can determinea dating one way or the other. e0Holleaux,Ioc. cit.;cf. Hahland,ÖJh xxxväi (1950)'92. Equallyflimsy seems to me an argumentintroducedby Herrmann( 102,n. 105)that subventionsfrom the royal treasuryare not likely to havebeenmadeat a time recentto the passingofthe decreefor Antiochos,which attestsheavyouwö.felE;this is to assumean understandingof royalfinancialpolicythatwe simplydo not have,andit is worth pointing out that the city which honouredKorrhagosreceivedroyal subventionsalthoughit had previouslybeen payingsubstantialnpooööot to the king.
rromthe.",",,."",":;':::::::'",:'::chpassed,n"o.".:: honouring Korrhagos,oqar4yöE of EumenesII in Hellespontine Phrygia,after the Romansettlementhad put Pergameneauthority over Greek cities on a much surer footing (9-12):sr(Korrhagos) fi$tatoevröv 6aoü"6aänoöo?fivat . . . rö üE ü. iepd.xai nöAeoE öLoixr1owäpyüqrcv xt)'. This parallel,and the implication,mentioned above, of the changein Teos' status in 188,when the Attalids first took a seriousinterestin the welfareof the reXvirar, strongly suggestthat the inscription in question,and the financiai procedureattestedby it, shouldbe datednot to the reign of Attalos I, but to that of EumenesII, and more exactly,to the years immediatelyfollowing the Romansettlement,namelyto the same time as the decree honouring Korrhagos. Its relevance to the periodof Attalos' relationswith Teos in 218shouldthereforein all probability be discounted. At this point we may usefully summarize the conclusions reachedfrom this evidenceasto the implicationsofTeos'relations with Attalos. In 218the city entrusteditselfto him on the basisof ouv9fixat which had been arrangedat an earlier date. From this date, and possiblyearlier, the city was requiredto pay a vaguely definedform of tribute, sometimesof a considerableamount.The position of Teos can thus be said to lie somewherebetweenfreedom and dependence;an exact definition is unattainableand was probably not meant to be attainable.It seemscertain. however, that Teos enjoyed a greater measureof freedom by virtue of its ouv9fixat than did the communitiesof Aeolis and Mysia, whose statuswas closerto full subjectionto Attalos.When hostilitiesin Asia Minor involving Attalos came to a temporary halt in 205, probably'at the time of the Peaceof Phoinike which ended the Aegean War, Teos felt free to turn to Antiochos III, who had recently returned from the East and now supportedthe causeof Teos in its requestfor the generalrecognitionof its riou,tic. This recognitionwas duly accordedin204/3by the Greekcommunities, and in 193by the RomanSenate.Teos'relationswith Attaloshad been basedentirely on military considerations,and it is not surprising that after long years of war it should turn to a different protector in a peacefulcause. er Holleaux,Etudes,ü.71-125. Seebelow,ch. 4 (i).
56
The Reign of Attalos I
This evidence leaves a clear impression that Teos became eventuallydissatisfiedwith the terms of its relationshipwith At' talos. In the case of the neighbouringcity of Kolophon, the evidenceusuallycited for its relationswith the PergameneKing must now be redated, partly on the basis of the conclusionsreached above.[n the closingyearsof the third century, Old Kolophon,the city visited by Attalos I, establisheda settlementat Notion (Colophon Nova);e2althoughindependentof the old city, the new setand its inhabitants tlement was attachedto it by oupno)"weta,e3 were called, accordingto a decreeof Magnesiaon the Maeander, A decreeof the new city records KolocpüvrcLd.nö 7aldoor1E.e4 of the v6oLandiqri6oL to celebfestival a to institute the decision the youngestof the sonsof Athenaios, rate the yuöLAnE üpieo of Attalos I.esHolleaux has shownfurther that other membersof the Attalid royal family were honouredwith Athenaiosin havingtheir eixöveg,erectedby the city in the sanctuaryof Apollo Klarios.e6 Holleaux argued, from the absenceof any specific referenceto EumenesII, that the decreewas passedbefore his accessionin 197,and thereforenecessarilyshortly before 197,sinceAthenaios cannot have been born earlier than220.e7More recently, a later date hasbeen urgedon the basisof the letter forms of the inscription,e8to which an importanthistoricalconsiderationmust now be e2Cf. Cardinali,RP 94,n. 4l Holleaux,hudes' ü. 53. er L. Robert,Ret,.Phil. x (1936),158,n. 6, 1654:Villes,62. salvM 53,75-9:Kü'orptivtol of fivllapXaiav nölltv oilxloüvregdistinguished from KoTocprivtoL Qtnö\ l9ü'äoottE. ssTh. Macriiy ,fun' iäiitsosl, lot-r, no. l, asinterpretedby loll9aux, Erades,ii-ll=60(and simultaneously.but in lessdetail, by A. Brueckner'OJh ix(lW), Beibl. 58-9);Appendixiv, no. 20. e6Holleaux.Etudes,ü. 58. e?Ibid.59: on the birthof AthenaiosseealsoMeischke,Symbolae,26' esHabicht, 1vP iii., p. 28, n. 5. Much dependson the restorationof lines 2-5; Holleauxrestored: foraqfivatöildlvcixdvallivr,tuinn4hrcrötaxr6zatL(?)roü 'A?1vallou xo'i trlg p4rpöE | [aürd)v iltpol nlqoiov | 1röv tix|vuv röv &.öelqtbv Beibl.58-9:nlqoiovl Cf. A. Brueckner,ÖJhix(1906), 6aoü,ioonE,'AroiTavlöo1E 'An91' 'Attü']ou xai rr1gpqqöE | 10nE 6aodtooqE2 ftoü narpöE \eoü 6aoü.6aE Neither restorationis completelysatisfactory,but the constructionimT0/viöolE. posed 6y Brueckner (m|oat öö rlv eixöva - ' - tT4otov roü natpög xtl') is particularlyunfortunate.It is diflicult to seein thesecircumstanceshow Attalos' ii.58,n.3): it isnot namecanhavebeenincludedatthispoint(cf. Holleaux,Erades, then so surprisingthat Eumenes'nameis alsolacking,and it shouldbe notedthat the omission of a royal name in a civic decree is often misleadingand rarely furtherin Appendixiii (203'n.l4)' decisive,a point which will be discussed
4ttalos and Asia Minor
57
added:that after 205Attalos' influencein Ionia was weakenedby the end of the military undertakingson which the ouv|fixar with Teos and Kolophon, and other cities, were based.The honours voted to Athenaioscannotbe datedbefore205,when he will have been too young, and a date betweenthe years205and 197seems extremely unlikely. Although the period from 197to 188,that is, duringthe first ten yearsof Eumenes'reign,remaina possibility,a date after the Roman settlementis by far the most convincing, since we have other evidenceof cities instituting similar cults to honour the Attalids at this time.eeIt needsto be addedthat sucha cult does not necessarilyimply a subjectstatuson the part of the city concerned (Colophon Nova was declaredfree of tribute in l881,toosince the practiceis known to have been followed by independentcities,for exampleKos and Miletos.rorThis important point will be taken up in a later chapter; at this point the redating of this decree leaves us with no additional evidenceto clarify the statusof Kolophonin the years218to 201. It remainsto considerAttalos'dealingswith the citiesin HellespontinePhrygia.The statusof thesecitiesis evenmore clearlyone of friendship rather than of allegiance.It appearsfrom polybios' narrative that Attalos visited them becausehis settlementof the Galatiansby the Hellespontbrought him into the area, rather by chancethan by design(v. 78. 6):'Awa)"oEpöv olv, d.noxaraorqoag roüE AiyooäyaE eig röv 'E)"l4onovrov xo,i yprlltatbaE cpüav0p6naEAaprpaxrlvöig,'Ak$avöpt6otv,'il"rcüot, öÄ. ü rerrlpr1x|vaLroürouErilv npög aüröv niorrv, äveyrbgryoe pud tfig öuvdpea4 eiE [I|pyapoy. On the other hand, the words z€rqgryxövatrqv ngöEaüröv niorw suggestthe existenceofa previous relationshipduring the war with Achaios, one perhapsbased on ouvQfixan,as is the case with the Ionian cities. This does not necessarilymean, however, that their terms were the same as thoseof the Ioniancities;it is extremelyunlikely,for example,that they paid Attalos tribute, sincethey were free citiesafter 188.r02 Nor did the Hellespontine cities'entrust'themselves to Attalosin e eS e e b e l o w , c h . 6 . r o oP o l y b . x x i . 4 6 . 4 ; s e e b e l o w , c h . 4 ( i i ) . roI See below, I 55. Kolophon was regarded
as a subject city by Cardinali, Rp g6, and, on the basis ofthe cult, by Holleaux, Etudes, ä.60. r02On the status of these cities after 188, see Schmitt, (Jntersuchunpen, 2g4.
58
The Reign of Attalos I
the manner of Teos and Kolophon. On the contrary, Polybios' narrative shows that Attalos' dealingswere on the basisof a free alliance,spontaneoussupportrather than contrivedco-operation. Thus Attalos' relationshipwith Lampsakos,Ilion, and Alexandria Troas may be comparedwith that pertainingto Kyzikos; in the caseof Ilion, evidencecited in the next chapterrevealsa further parallel in the form of the kind of Attalid benefactions already known for Kyzikos in the caseof Philetairos.They were all important free cities whose friendship was especiallyvaluable to Attalos because,like Kyzikos, they facilitatedthe important PerThey sympathizedwith gamenetrade with the Black Seaarea.1o3 Attalos, but owed him no allegiance. * The conclusionof the precedingdiscussionhasbeenthat Attalos' main contributionto the growth of his kingdomin the years241to 218layin his developmentof firmerdiplomaticcontactwith Greek cities further from Pergamon,enablinghim to find strongerand more substantialsupport in his wars againstsuccessivelocal opponents.In examiningthe extent to which Attalos subsequently maintainedthe positionhe gainedin 218two importanteventshave to be taken into account: the counter-attackmade by Achaios in the years 218 to 216, and the agreementreachedin 216between Attalos and Antiochos to co-operatein eliminatingAchaios. Of neither event do we possesssignificant details. The first is re'Ayaö; öä corded by Polybios as follows (v. 77. l):toa nou1odpevogöE' 6auröv d1v Mü'u6.öa xai rd. il'etota ptgq riE IlatrrcpultaEäv6leufe, xai napcyevöpevoEeiE2d.pöeq önü"Ltrtet äveteiveroöö l1gouoiq',xrdoLö' fiv cpo6eqöE ltbv'AnalE ouveXCoE, xai 6apüg roig öni rdöe roü Taüqou xaromoüot. Although the extentof Achaios' successin theseyearsis unknown,it is probable that Attalos found himself again in difficulties, for such circumstancesbest explain his willingnessto come to terms with 'AvrioyoE öi Antiochosin the late springof 216 (v. 107.!):ros r 0 3O n t h i s a s p e c to f t h e A t t a l i d s ' e c o n o m i c p o l i c y c f . M . I . R o s t o v t z e f f , R a m s a y Studies,365-6. f 04 Schmitt, Untersut'hungen, 263. r05On the xowonpayia see Schmitt, Untersuchungen, 264-7; on the date, 264. n. l.
Attalos and Asia Minor
59
peyd.Tqnapaoxufi yprlodpevoE öv r(t ptpdtvt, petd. taüra tfiE |epetaE önryevop|vqg önep66a)"eröu Taüpov, xai ouv)öpevoE "Auü"ov röv 6oot),6a xowonpaytav öviorato üv npöE npöE 'AyaÄv nö),epov.This agreement(xotvonpayia) was one of military co-operationdesignedto achievea specificpurpose,and not a formal treaty,106but there is further evidencethat the good relations between Attalos and Antiochos were maintainedafter the capture and death of Achaios in 213 had put an end to the immediateground of co-operationbetweenthe two kings. A treaty betweenthem is recorded,this time with the title ouv9fixal, in the literary evidence relating to the Roman negotiationswith Antiochos after his defeatat Magnesiain 189: Appian,Syr. xxxviii: Scipioaddresses an embassy from Antiochosand (sc. afludes to thecompensation thatwouldberequired of him:d.noöoüvat "Ana)"ov Antiochos). . . Eüptvetöoa Tomd rqE npöE üu Eöptvoug äpt. naripa ouv9qxrlg the samenegotiations as follows:clzoPolybiosxxi. 17.6 expresses xai töv öor.ivat öi xai EipivtL rerpaxöorcrd).avra(rd)npoooEuAöpeva i),7efuovraofuouxard rd.EnpöEröv naröpaouv9fixaE. It is extremely unlikely that the agreementreachedin 216constialthough tuted the kind offormal treaty attestedby thesepassages, we need not necessarilyconclude that the ouv9fixal had been concludedonly shortly before the year 189in which referenceis madeto them.r07If, as seemscorrect, we regardtheouv?fixat as a treaty of later dateand closerdefinitionthan thezolvonpayia, the most likely date for its conclusionis immediatelyor shortly after the deathof Achaios,namely in 213or 212.In the years212to 205/4Antiochoswas in the eastof his kingdom,andon his returnin 204 his activity in western Asia Minor was hardly conduciveto friendly relations with the King of Pergamon.It is also possible that in the years before the outbreak of the SecondMacedonian 1 0 6S c h m i t t , U n t e r s u c h u n g e n , 2 6 4 , n . l . ro?I find unconvincing Schmitt's argument (Untersuchungen, 265),'doch ist kaum anzunehmen. dass der Seleukide noch nach fast drei Jahrzehnten die vergleichsweise niedrige Summe schuldig geblieben wäre.' On the contrary, payments of such obligations in instalments, overa period oftime, is a well-attested procedure at this time; the treaty which ended the war between Attalos II and Prusias II, for example, was drawn up on this basis. Prusias being obliged to pay Attalos 500 tafents over a period of twenty years (Polyb. xxxiii. 13. 6: nutaxöota öi rd),avra xartvtyxtiv iv örtow tixoot).
60
The Reign of Attalos I
War, Attalos was largelyresponsiblefor propagatingthe belief in, and danger of, an alliance between Antiochos and Philip V of Macedon.This would havebeenan unconvincingattitudeto adopt if he himself had also concludeda formal alliancewith Antiochos within the last few years. Since relationsbetweenthe two kings were strongestin the years 216to 212,it is to this period, shortly after the informal xoLvonpay[a had lapsed with the defeat of Achaios,that the ouv9fixat most naturallybelong.t08 The terms of the xoLvonpayiaand the ouv|fixat are unknown, but it has usually been concluded that Attalos gained from his co-operationwith Antiochos,at leastto tfreextentthat he was able to recoverthe positionhe had achievedin 2 18.roeAs far as it goes this view is probablycorrect, sinceAntiochos cannothave hoped to gain Attalos'co-operationin 216without makingsomeform of concession;on the other hand Achaios was at the time of the 10E AntiochosandPhilip:SIV iii. 547.It seemsmostlikelythatthe'pact'between Antiochosand Philip V wasan informalagreementto co-operate,oreven simplyan understandingnot to interferewith one another's interests.Such an agreement could very easilyhavebeenunderstoodlater to haveamountedto a partitionofthe EgyptianEmpire, and it is highly probablethat Attalos and the Rhodiansusedthe rumour (which is all it can have been) in order to convince the Senateof the existenceof a danger(cf. Appian,M aked. 4. 2: xai rrivb rilv öölav, €xtapdooouoav änavtaE'Pöörctpöv'PapaioLgöpfiwoav; cf. D. Magie,JRS xxix (1939)' Rule, ü.'750,n.42); whetherthe Senatetook the threatseriouslyis 32-44:Roman anothermatter(seebelow, n. l5 | ). Magiehas perhapsgonetoo far in denyingthe existenceof any kind of agreement(althoughhe was quite right in stressingthe importanceof the rumour of its existence,which is what really matters),but Schmitt'sattempteddefenceofthe tradition (Untersuchungen'237-61)does not establishthe authenticityof a formal treaty, whoseexistenceis most unlikely. See afsoE. Badian,Gnomon,xxxviii (1966),7 15-16. Two dedicationsfrom Pergamonshouldbe mentionedin the contextof relations betweenAttalos and Antiochos.One (/vP 189,= OG/S 236)is a statuebaseof Zeuxis, oqat4yöE and ini ttiv npaypdrav of Antiochos lll (cf. Ad. Wilhelm' Inscr.de Sardis,l.9-14);thebaseis Wien.Stud. 1907.I l-13: L. Robert,Noavelles inscribedZaifo Kuvayou lö önpoE.The other (IvP 182,: OGIS 2zt0)is a baseof 'AvtioTlot the king himself:Baot).tla pdyav lfilaotltaE Z1eLe{xouKaTfulvtxouI The official natureof thesededicationsimplies vop)ocp6,tc{. lllpaltaE Mtvfintyou at leastthat Antiochoswas at the lime personagrata in Pergamon,and sincethe statueofAntiochos, wherethe restorationofthe titlepfTa6:seemsassured,cannot be datedbefore205(Holleaux,Iitudes üi. I 59-63),it appearsthat we mustenvisage a short period of good relationsbetweenAttalos and Antiochosafter Antiochos' return from the East in 204.That thesegood relationslastedfor more than a few monthsis, however, most unlikely. loeSeethe referencesgiven by Schmitt, Untersuchungen,266, n.2.
Attalos and Asia Minor
6l
conclusionof the agreementat leastas much a threat to Attalos as he was to Antiochos, perhaps more so, and it is arguablethat Attalos stood to gain more from the xowonpayfu in immediate termsthan Antiochos. It is thereforeunlikely that Attalos was able to achieve more than a return to the statusquo of 218. More important, however, is the considerationthat this is the first recordedtreaty betweenAttalid and Seleukidkings; it therefore marks a decisive point in the developmentof relations between the two dynasties.Previously, as we have seen, the Seleukidswere alwaysconcernedwith limiting the Attalid dynasteia, andit is unlikely that they evenacknowledgedits independent status. Now, however, the formal constitutionalcommitmentto ouv9fixat implies a direct recognitionby Antiochos of this independentstatus,and of Attalos as an equalking.r r0We may therefore reckonas the most importantconcessionthat Antiochosmade to Attalos the first Seleukidrecognitionof the Attalid Kingdom as a separateand sovereigndynasteia. Further specificconclusionsremaintentative.In 218the Hellespontinecities of Lampsakos, Alexandria Troas, and Ilion affirmed the loyalty to Attalos which they had shownduringthe war with Achaios. In vieryof this attitudetakenby the leadingcitiesof the area,it is unlikely that Antiochoswas ableto reassertSeleukid influencein the Troad before the two invasionsof Asia Minor in 198and 197.Pergameneinfluence in the Troad may thereforebe accounteda specificgain of the wars endingwith the agreementof 216and theouv9fixauttl The subjectstatusafter 216of the Aeoliancitiescloseto Pergamon is confirmed in the case of Thyateira by the inscription atrroAgreementsbetween kings in the Hellenistic period were obviously not always called ouv9ixatt much clearly dependedon the circumstancesof the agreement.Thus an agreementto end hostilitieswas often called, as we would (e.9.StV iii. 428(Peaceof 3l I ), 448 (ephemeralpeacebetween expect,öLalüoeLE Demetrios Poliorketesand Kassandrosin 302)).Of the terms used, however, ouv9fixat is constitutionallythe most formal, and necessarilyinvolves a mutual recognitionof status. rrr Schmitt (Untersuchungen,165)points to the possibilitythat the cities of the Troad had eventuallyfallento Achaios,and that Polybiosv. 78. 6 merelysaysthat they remainedloyal to Attalos, i.e. they resistedas long as they could. This view cannotbe discounted,but it seemsto me not lo be what Polybiosmeans,in the context of the sectionas a whole.
62
The Reignof Attalos I
testingAttalos' settlingof xcnoixot in its territory, and in general terms, as we have seen, by the reference in Attalos' reply to Magnesiaon the Maeanderto ai ön' öpön6)"e6,g[g.rt2The fact that referencewas madein the Roman settlementto taxespaid to Attalos further suggeststhat the situationapparentin 218was also in force in the following years. In these respectsthen, Attalos seemsto haverecoveredthe positionhe held in 218.On the other 'possedesse hand, Pedroli's extreme view that after 216 Attalos dell' Asia Minore i territori al nord di una linea idealeche dal mare ed immediatamentea messogiornodi Colofonesi estendefino all' alta valle del Sangario,e di qui fino all' Ellesponto; e perö all' incircatutta I'anticasatrapiadi Frigiaall' Ellesponto',r13is neither basedon specificevidencenor relatedto the realitiesof Attalos' position in earlier years, in which such aggrandizementof the kingdom does not come into question, and it was rightly diswhich countedby Cardinali.Cardinali'sown view, however,r14 by L. and was endorsedby Ernst Meyer,rt5by M. Holleaux,rro Robert,rlTthat Attalos retainedin216 all his conquestsof two yearsearlier, needsmodificationin accordancewith the differing statusof the subjectcommunitiesin Aeolis and Mysia, and the allied cities in Ionia and HellespontinePhrygia,where statusvaried from city to city. Attalos most probably recovered the authority he had exercisedin 218,but the extent of direct authority, which was confined to Aeolis and Mysia, remainedunchanged. The situationin Mysia, however, was.certainlyless stableafter 216.As alreadynoted, the natureof the country permittedonly a tentativeand partial kind of authority, and no treaty could by itself guaranteeAttalos' position there. In the yearsfollowing Attalos' expeditionof 218 its position is unclear, but the fact that Muoo( appearin Attalos' army during the First MacedonianWar shows that his control was at least partially maintained in the years following the agreementwith Antiochos. In all probability' howr 1 2S e e a b o v e , 4 5 . t t r U . P e d r o l i , l l R e g n o d i P e r g a m o ( T u r i n , 1 8 9 6 ) ,3 O - 1 . C f . C a r d i n a l i , R P 8 l - 3 . r14RP86. tts Die Grenzen, 103-4. t t 6E t u d e s , ü . 6 0 . tt7 villes. 40. n. 3.
Attalos and Asia Minor
63
ever, the status of Mysia remained vague, in the sensethat no singleruler exercisedauthority over the wholecountry; it hasbeen shown, for instance, that although Attalos continued to recruit soldiersfrom the country he was by no meansthe only ruler at the end of the third century to do so.r 18Mysia may thereforebe seen rather as a natural recruitinggroundfor Hellenisticarmiesthan as a country of sustainedpolitical importance. This conclusion concerningthe statusof Mysia may serve to clarify a vexed problem arising from a referenceto Mysia in the terms of the Romansettlementof Asia Minor in 188sc. According to Polybios (xxi. 46.10) the territories awarded to Eumenes II includedMuooriE,oüEnqöreqov aütöE napeoxeud.oaeo; accordingto Livy (xxxviii. 39.15),Mysiam, quamPrusiarexademerat.lt has been generallyrecognizedthat Polybios' text as we have it is corrupt, and that Livy transmits the correct original.rreThe identificationof Mysia, however, remainsproblematical.It is unlikely to have beenthe whole of the areaadjoiningPergamon,that is, Mysia proper, since the area is more closely defined:quam Prusia rex ademerat. It is also most unlikely that Prusiasever penetratedso closeto Pergamon.On the other hand, the idea that Attalos gained an even temporary control over an entire area further from Pergamon,such as Mysia Olympeneand the later Phrygia Epiktetos, both of which have been suggestedin this context, seemsto be ruled out by the literary evidence,which unanimouslystressesthe smallnessof the Attalid Kingdombefore I 88.r20Furthermore,Polybios' referenceto Muoo I suggestsa part and not the wholeof a country. In thesecircumstances we should think rather of territory on the bordersof Mysia, and most probably that betweenMysia and PhrygiaEpiktetos,whoseboundaries I r8On the recruitmentof Mysiansin the Hellenisticarmies,cf. Launey,Recherches,i.436-9. treCf. Cardinali,RP82, n.2; Meyer,Die Grenzen,150,n.2; Magie,Roman R u l e , ä . 7 5 8 , n . 5 6 ; H a b i c h tH , e r m e s , l x x x i v( 1 9 5 6 )9, 1 . M o m m s e nR, ö m i s c h e Forschungen,ii. 538,aloneattemptedto emendthe text of Livy (Prusialopridem). r2oMysia Olympene: Cardinali,RP 82, n. 2. Phrygia Epiktetos: Meyer, Die Grenlen, I l5; Magie,RomanRule, ii. 759(with reservations); Habicht,art. cit. (n. I l9), 92t Schmitt,Untersuchungen,266,276-8. On the evidenceforthe sizeofthe kingdombefore 188,seeabove, 25.
64
The Reign of Aualos I
were neverclearly definedin antiquity.r2rWe know, in particular, that certain communities in this border area were sometimesassignedto Mysia,122and we may reckon that Attalos' control in Mysia spilled for a time into the area known later as Phrygia Epiktetos,but this doesnot meanthat the country as a whole may be accounteda part of his kingdom.l23We are dealing,in other words, with the border territory between the kingdoms of Pergamon and Bithynia, and, given the unstablesituationin Mysia, it is not surprisingthat this territory remaineddisputeduntil the time of the Roman settlement.Prusiasis known to have been actively hostileto Attalos on at leasttwo occasions,in 208and in the years precedingthe Antiochic War.r24On the first occasion Prusias invadedAttalos' kingdom,an action which must havebroughthim into the interveningterritory in Mysia;12sas we have seen,it is by no meanscertain that Attalos was able to maintainthe hegemony in this areaas a whole to which he aspiredin 218.It is admittedly plausiblethat the loss to Prusiasat this dateof a part of Mysia will but it havebeenrectifiedby the peacewhich we may dateto 205,r26 is hardly likely that this was the only occasionon which Prusias invadedMysia. As a border land betweenthe two kingdomsthe country was naturally liable to frequent attemptson the part of each king to maintain a strongerand more widespreadinfluence there than his rival. For this same reason it would constitute territory which requiredsettlementin 188,whateverthe situation at that moment. It is not necessarilyto be concludedthat at the time of the Roman settlementthe territory concernedwas still in Prusias'possession;only that it had beendisputed,and remained in dispute.It is probablethat Prusiastook the opportunityafforded r2rCf. Habicht,art. cit., 92, with particularreferenceto Straboxü.4.4' 564: yrttpigtä Muoriv xai
Attalos and the Aegean
65
by Antiochos' invasion of Attalos' kingdom in 198to strengthen his position in the disputedarea, but that his position was maintained there for the following ten years is doubtful.t27 These considerationslead to the conclusionthat the Mysians concerned lay on the border of Mysia proper and were later included in Phrygia Epiktetos; that owing to the nature of the country neither Attalos nor Prusias was able to maintain a more than ephemeralhold there, although both made the attempt on various occasions;and that the disputed area was settled in Eumenes' favour in 188. In this respect, then, Attalid influence in Mysia under Attalos I may be compared with that pertaining at a later date in Galatia, to the extent that similar conditions rendered impossiblea settledandlastingcontrol over the wholecountry.r2s (ii) Attalos and the Aegean, 215-197 We have seen Attalos, during the first twenty-five years of his reign, in the role not of an ambitiouswould-beempirebuilder, but of a cautiousand defensiveruler, concernedwith strengtheninghis kingdomrather than with expandingit, and indeedfor most of the time preoccupied with defending its very existence from the threats presentedby successiveenemies.To strengthenhis military position Attalos formed closer relationswith Greek cities in Ionia and the Troad. but we have seenthat in terms of direct rule the situation hardly changedfrom the time of his predecessor. Finally, in the years precedingAntiochos' departurefor the eastern campaigns,the Seleukidand Attalid kings cameto an agreement, eventually constituted under the formal title ouvQfixaq which at the very least confirmed Attalos' sovereigntyin Aeolis and Mysia. Attalos' achievementin the years precedinghis alliance with Rome can be summarizedas the consolidation of authority within the kingdom left to him by EumenesI, and the foundation of strongerdiplomatic relationsoutside it. One could r2?Schmitt, Untersuchungen,276-8,arguedthat Prusiasinvadedthe areaconcernedin 198,necessarilybeforeEumenes'accession(cf. Polyb.xxxii. 8. 3); asI do not believethat either Attalos or Prusiasexercisedsuch a definitecontrol in this areaasto constituteincorporationin their respectivekingdoms,I do not think that this point can be pressed. rusOn Galatia, see further below, ch. 5.
66
The Reign of Aualos I
not do better than recall the words of M. Holleaux, written with referenceto Attalos' campaignof 218,but applicableto the reignas a whole: 'circonspectet avis€,calculantjustesesint6röts,limitant sesentreprisesä sesmoyens d'action, et se hätant d'accomplir, sitöt que s'en offre I'occasion, des besognesimm6diatement utiles.'12e A few years after the agreementwith the Seleukid king, Attalos took part in the so-calledFirst MacedonianWar as Rome's ally againstPhilip V of Macedon.The natureof Attalos' involvement, and above all the motives for his enmity to Macedon in the light of his cautious policy of earlier years, must form an important part of our discussion.Scholarshave suggestedvarious reasonsfor Attalos' alliancewith Rome. The most extreme view has been expressed,surprisingly,by the same scholarwhose more apposite words have been quoted above; written twenty-four years later, this view seesAttalos, in the secondhalf of his reign, attemptingto found an empire in the Aegean after his failure to increase his kingdomin Asia Minor; to 'escapeto the west', evento re-formthe old kingdom of Lysimachos.r30In such a scheme,Philip would appearas Attalos' naturalenemy, and in Holleaux's brilliant picture of Romanrelationswith the East,Attalos appearsasthe ready ally of Rome, concernedto persuadethe Senateof the usefulness of its intervention, but equally anxious to securesuch powerful support for the grandioseintentions he now allegedly entertained for the expansionof his kingdom. This view, needlessto say, presentsa pictureof Attalos' intentionsvery differentfrom the one argued in the preceding pages, and we would have to supposea dramaticchangeof policy; it is, however, untenableand must be refuted. Other views see Philip as the natural enemy of Attalos in the ns Etudes,ä. 42. t3oRome, la Gröceet les monarchieshellänistiquesau IIIe siöcleav. J .-C. (Paris, l92l),2M-5, especially205: 'dominer I'Aig6e, y prendre la place quitt6e par I'Egypte,y pr6venirla Mac6doineet lui enleverce qu'elley tient ddjä,occuperles Cycladeset möme l'Eubde, p€n6trerau Sudjusqu'au coeur des mers grecques, pousserauNordjusq'aux iles et aux rivagesde Thrace,puis s'dtendre,s'il sepeut, vers la Chersonöse,se saisirdes d6troits,et, chevauchantsur I'Europe et I'Asie, restaurerl'6ph6möreempirede Lysimaque.'In this list of imputedintentions,only the words 'y pr6venir la Macddoine'seemto me to be realistic.
Attalos and the Aegean
67
latter's opposition to the Seleukidsand to PrusiasI of Bithynia, Philip's ally;trt and Attalos as the natural enemy of Philip in his defence of his kingdom in Asia Minor.r32Neither of these two pointsof view is realistic;the first overlooksthe importantfact that Attalos and Antiochos were formal allies during the years preceding the outbreakof the MacedonianWar, as well as the consideration that Prusias'interventionon Philip's behalftook place some yearsafter the outbreak ofthe war, and cannot therefore havebeen a factor determiningAttalos' policy beforeit; the secondargument is equally untenable in view of the fact that Philip was at this date not a direct threat to Attalos' position in Asia Minor, even as suzerainof Caria, where Attalos did not have lastinginterestsat this date; this threat was, once again, a later developmentin Aegeanpolitics.r33 More important, however, is the considerationthat all these approachesto the problem presupposea total commitment on Attalos' part from the very beginningof the war with Philip. A closer examinationof the facts showsthat this assumptionis not justified; on the contrary, it will be seen that Attalos had little enthusiasmfor the war andtook part only when persuadedto do so by his allies and only to such an extent as would satisfy them. We must consider,firstly, the circumstancesin which Attalos became Rome's ally, and the implications of this alliance. Although these circumstancesare not entirely clear, it is certain at leastthat the initiative lay not with Attalos, but with his prospective allies,and of thesewith Aitolia more than Rome. In interpreting the literary tradition, representedin full at this point only by Livy, we have to be careful in distinguishingthe evidencederived from Polybiosfrom that which can be ascribedto one or anotherof the Roman annalists, and in assessingtheir respectivevalues. Livy's accountof the Romantreaty with Aitolia, which we should probablydate to the year 212,althoughcompressedand evidently r3rG. ne Sanctis,Storia dei Romani (Turin, 1907-64),äi.2. 416. t32U. Wilcken,Ä8, s.v. Attalos(9),2163. r33Prusias'seeHolleaux,Rome,la Gröce, 2O6,n. l. Philip and Caria: Crampa Labraunda, äi. l. 127-31. ?*
/
;i
68
The Reign of Attalos I
selective,wasalmostcertainlyderivedfrom Polybios;r3athe terms show that Attalos' co-operationwas envisagedbut not presupposed(Livy xxvi. 24.8-9): igitur conscriptaecondiciones,quibus in amicitiam societatemquepopuli Romani venirent (sc. Aetoli), (9) additumque ut, si placeret vellentque,eodem iure amicitiae Elei Lacedaemoniiqueet Attalus et Pleuratus et Scerdilaedus essent,Asiae Attalus, hi Thracum et Illyriorum reges. As is well known, Rome avoidedtotal involvementin the war even after this treaty with Aitolia, and it is probablethat Attalos' participation was suggestedin the hope that the availability of the Attalid fleet would complement the power of Aitolia by land, and thereby further reduceRome'sdirect obligations.The fleet appearsfor the first time, and then only briefly (see below) during this war, at which point it was evidentlya force of somestrength,but we have no direct evidenceas to the circumstancesof its construction.The fact that a fleet is not attestedby Polybiosin the campaignof 218 hardly providesaterminuspost quem for its construction,as has beenthought,trs rin"" Attalos' strictly military activity in that year wasconfinedto areasof Aeolis and Mysia in which navalactivity is hardly to be expected;in other areashis dealingswere political, and in one case (the Troad), not originally envisaged.So the argumentthat Attalos beganthe constructionof a fleet sometime after 218as a part of his plan to tum to the west, doesnot haveany firm basisin the evidence.It is more probablethat the fleet was built up graduallyover a number of years, and in particular after the acquisitionof the important harbour position of Elaia, probably in the reign of EumenesI, as a meansof improvedcommunicationsand especiallyof closercontact with the Greek mainland, which was always an important factor in Attalid foreign policy. There is no evidence to show that the fleet was developedin pursuit of an expansiveor aggressivepolicy. 114The most thoroughanalysisof the literary traditionis that of K.-E. Petzold, Die Eröffnung des zweiten römisch-makedonischenKrieges (Berlin, 1940),but it suffersfrom a dogn,atic attitude taken towards the value of the various elementsof the tradition. For the treaty with Aitolia, see Schmitt'scommentary,Sty iii. 536. On the date, seeespeciallyG. Klaffenbach, Der römisch-ötolischeBündnisvertrag vom Jahre 212 v. Chr. (SB Berlin, 1954);G. A. Lehmann, Untersuchungenz. historischen Glaubwürdigkeit des Polybios (Münster, 1967), 10-134. r35As argued,for example,by Holleaux,Rome, la Grice, 205-4, n.2.
Attalos and the Aegean
69
Although the availability of the fleet was an attraction to his allies, we seeclearly that Attalos' own part in the war was from the beginningof a vagueand undefinednature,and it is unlikely that a formal alliancewith Rome was concludedbefore the time of the Peaceof Phoinike which ended the war; it is more probablethat Attalos' position remainedone of informal amicitia. r36This conclusion is indicatedin particular by Polybios' referencein a later context (200 nc) to Attalos' activity as basedon a xolvontpay[a (xvi. 25. 4):|eopdtv (Attalos)ö' aörcüg (the Romancommissioners) xai üS npoyeyevqptvqg xowonqayiaE pvqpoveöovraE . . . nepqppilE riz. This term was used, as we have seen,of Attalos' co-operationwith Antiochosin the war with Achaios,and denotesa commitment to military assistancefor the time being rather than the conclusionof a formal treaty. Such military assistance seemsto have been the nature of Attalos' involvement,to which we now turn. Attalos' short and casualinvolvement hardly supportsthe notion of a schemeon his part of expansionin the Aegean. The invitation to Attalos to take part in the war was probably made in 'escapeto the 212.So far from seizingthis goldenopportunityof an West', Attalos did not appearin Aegeanwatersuntil the year 209, and then only when the Aitolians, still left to bear the brunt of the fighting and evidently desperateto secureAttalos' active participation, offered him the honorary title of Leaguefiyepbv together with the prestigiousislandof Aigina, recentlyacquiredby them, at the nominal price of thirty talents, as a base for the Pergamene flss{.t32 The following year Attalos returned to his capital on receipt of news of Prusias' invasion of his kingdom, a diversion probably engineeredby Philip, and he took no further active part in the war. Apart from Aigina, which constitutes a special case, Attalos achievedno territorial gainsasa resultof his participation. This activity, viewed objectively, suggestsinformal co-operation rather than a formal alliance, and correspondswith the conclusion reached above as to Attalos' initial relationship with Rome. It also correspondswith our view of Attalos' policy with regard to his kingdom; we see him still, that is, cautious and 116K.-E. Petzold,Die Eröffnung, l,+-18. r37Polyb. xxii. 8. l0; cf. BSA lxvi (1971)'l-2.
70
The Reign of Attalos I
reserved,hesitant to commit himself to ambitious schemes,and more concernedwith the preservationof his small kingdom, and the authority it represented,than with its aggrandizement.We have seenthat the initiative in securingAttalos'albeit ephemeral co-operationlay in a largemeasurewith the Aitolians. This fact is of importance in that it was with Aitolia that Attalos' relations were, at that time, in the,context of the Roman alliance, the strongest.It is well known that, at a date before 219,Attalos had financedthe building of the fortifications of the Aitolian stronghold of Elaos;138less frequently noticed is the equally significantap'Awü.eüE pearanceof the ethnic in Aitolian manumissionsfrom pointing to the existencein Aitolia at the end of the third century, 'Arrü,eia whose foundation,or, more that date of a city named probably, refoundation, may be dated to the time of the First MacedonianWar, or earlier.r3eWe arebound,then, to reckonwith a closer Pergamenerelationshipwith Aitolia than that suggested by the singlefortification of Elaos.This impressionis strengthened by evidence relating to Attalos' activity at Delphi, then under Aitolian control. Attalos' predecessorshad establishedcordial relationswith Delphi, but their generositywas probablylimited to direct financial support. This policy was taken a step further by Attalos, as elsewhere,by the more direct expedientof addingto the buildingsofthe sacredprecinct.This took the form ofa terrace built to the north-eastof the Temple of Apollo and including a small stoa;the scaleof the buildingwas compact,and the most interesting featureof the constructionis the choice of its site, as close as possibleto the templeand therebyin an areaso constrictedthat to allow room for the new terrace a breach had to be made in the sacredperiboloswall, for the first time sincethe reconstructionof the area in the sixth century.l4o The size and position of the buildingindicatea cult purpose- the stoawas not simply a shelter from the rain - as does the dedicationof the whole complex to tra p6fyf. iv. 65. 6-7: 'ArrdTou dp, nepi aötö xataoxtulv dvaöelap{voo toig Airaioig. trcCf. Klaffenbach on IG ix.2 1.95 (2M/3; cf. 107):'nimirum hoc oppidum 'Attü.ela denominatum est a rege Attalo I de Aetolis bene merito.' On the origins of Attalos' relations with Aitolia (which are very obscure) see also McShane, Foreign Policy, l0l, n.29. rao For a description of the site see G. Roux, BCH lxxvi (1952), 14l-96.
Attalos and the Aegean
7l
"Arr Apollo : IBa]o t],elüg al)"oE I'A n P A0)orr p l. An Amphiktyonic decreedated most probablyto 2231236tat lsgslds regulationsfor the useof the portico, and leavesthe impressionthat abusesof the precinct had arisen since its construction (lines 7-11): iv rdv 'Arnaordlöa rdv dvarc|eioav röt. 1töl I itnö rcü 6aoü.61o1g täAou pq|evi üpfev ö$ouofuvn).fiv 6aoü"6ory1läva)eivalpq9öv, p4öö oxavoüv pqöb nlüp dvdmer.vBwögfi |xröEllrdE naoü.öog xü'.lt is likely then, from this evidence,that the constructionof the terrace should be dated to the earlier years of Attalos' reign, most probably the 230s,althoughthere is no reasonto associate the construction with anv of Attalos' militarv successes,as has beendone.!42 It is to be noted,finally, that it wasAttalos'policy, in Delphi and elsewhere,not simply to finance building operationsof this kind, as his predecessorsseem to have done, but to provide skilled workers to carry out the actualoperation;we hearat Delphi in 197 'And)"ou ö öni röv öpyau of one Dameas,ö napä rcü 6aoü'öaE röv 6aoü.möv.143The implementingof this moreambitiouspolicy at Delphi may be accountedone of the factors leadingto Attalos' friendly relations with Aitolia. It can hardly be coincidence,then, that it was the Aitolians with whom Attalos had the strongestrelationsat the time of the outbreak of the First MacedonianWar; they whosetreaty with Rome envisagedAttalos' co-operation;and they at whose call Attalos finally appearedwith afleet in the Aegeanin supportof the Roman alliance.In this connectionlie the origin and motive of Attalos' at first reluctant appearancein the allianceformed againstPhilip, and any notion of personalambition on Attalos' part at this time must be discounted. It is probablethat Attalos, togetherwith PrusiasI of Bithynia, was enteredas one of theadscripti to the Peaceof Phoinikewhich [t is at any rate certain endedthe First MacedonianWar in 205.144 that Attalos' position in relation to the Roman allianceremained r4rsy//.3 523(Pomtow).Cf. Wilhelm, Öth vüi (1905),l2-13; R. Flaceliöre,zes Aitoliens d Delphes (Paris, 1937),407,no. 38b. to, e.g. by McShane,Foreign Policy, l0l:.'Attalus I built a portico at Delphi to celebratehis Gallic victories.' t4tSGDI 2001;Appendixiv, no.4; cf. Daux,Delphes,499. f44On the authenticityof the adscripti, see above,n. 75.
72
The Reign of Attalos I
informal. In the yearsfrom 205to 200,however, the situation in the Aegean changed dramatically with the emergence of Philip of Macedon as a threat to the islands and to Attalos' position in westernAsia Minor. The piratical expeditionof Dikaiarchos,the worshipper of Lawlessnessand Impiety, which we should probably date to the year after the Peaceof Phoinike,r4smust havebeen the first clear indication of the reality of this new threat. Attalos and Rhodesstood to suffer most: Attalos from Philip's now clear designson the cities of the Hellespont,!46and Rhodesfrom his support of the cretan pirates. with their commerceand prosperity equally threatened,it is not surprisingto find Attalos and Rhodes co-operatingin the following years, as the threat merged into reality, in resisting Philip's advance. So far from being an unnaturalalliance,as hasusuallybeenassumed,it was the inevitable reaction to a common danger. Of particular importanceis their of commonpolicy, now well attestedby epigraphicalevidence,r4T challengingPhilip's position in Crete (a position of great importanceto his ambitionsin the Aegean)by concludingallianceswith groupsof Cretan cities, thereby controlling the supply of Cretan mercenaries. It seemsmost likely, however,from the limited evidence,that of thesetwo powers Rhodeswas the more belligerentat the time of the outbreakof the SecondMacedonianWar, owing largelyto the vigorous policy of her admiral Theophiliskos. Polybios states explicitly that Theophiliskos was the driving force behind the alliance,being mainly responsiblefor securingAttalos' participation in the naval battle off Chios, in which the combinedAttalid and Rhodianfleetsproved to be a good matchfor Philip, although r45Polyb. xviii. 54. 8; Diodorosxxviii. L Holleaux,Etudes,iv. 12445, establishedthe dateofthe expeditionas either205or 204;ofthesethe later yearseemsby far the more likely. ra6Polybiosdesignatesas Dikaiarchos'objectivesin204,tdg KuxldöaE vfioouE 'Eil,4onöwou xai rd.göE' nö),eq (54. 8). This policy of aggressionagainstthe Hellespontine cities,'which was carried further in 202, and which directly threatened both Attalos' interests there and his contacts with the Black Seaarea, must have been a decisive factor in determiningAttalos' more positive policy as developed after 202. t47For Attalid treaties with Cretan communitiessee P. Ducrey and H. van Effenterre,Kret.Chron.xxi(1969),277-300;P.Ducrey,BCIIxciv(1970),637-59: Appendixiv, no. 3;for the Rhodiantreaties,Sty iii. 551(Hierapytna),552(Olus). Note that Hierapytna was the common ally of Rhodes and Attalos.
Attalos and the Aegean
73
both sides claimed the victory.raEIn these events we see again Attalos' reluctance to become involved in an Aegeanwar, shown also by the fact that he had not taken part in the earlier engagement betweenthe Rhodianand Macedonianfleetsat Lade.laeThe death of Theophiliskosat Chiosdoubtlessalsogoesa longway to explain the marked hiatus in the activity of Rhodes and Attalos prior to their appeal to Rome. This appeal took place in 200, after Philip's escapefrom his enemies'siegein Bargylia;for its motive we need surely look no further than the consideration that Attalos and Rhodes had after three major attempts (Lade, Chios, Bargylia) failed to contain Philip, and to keep him from plunderingAttalos' own territory,lso and the probable feeling after the death of Theophiliskosthat the alliancewas by itself not powerful enough. For the first time we see Attalos taking an energeticinitiative in Aegeanaffairs,indeedthe main advocate-or so it seems-of the renewalof the war with Macedon.This policy, so far from beinga reversalof his earlier policy, shouldbe seenas a logical development of it; no longer able to defend his kingdom by his own resources,he soughtthe helpof the powerwhich seemedmost able to supporthim.r5r r48For the narrativeofthe battle,Polyb.xvi. 2-8; Philip'sclaim to victory is at 8. 2. For Attalos' victory dedication,seeabove,n. 3. The initiativeofTheophiliskos, "AuaTov 9. 4: fivdyxaot öi töv fi1 piL).ew xr7. r4ePolyb. xvi. 10. l: röv ö' "AttaAov p4ö6natouppepryh,or.AlthoughHolleaux put forward positive argumentsfor dating the battle offChios before that ofLade (Etudes,iv.218-22), I regardas more convincingthe chronologyproposedby De Sanctis,Stor. Rom. iv. l. 10,n.27, in which the battleof Lade is followedby Philip'sinvasionof Pergamonand the battleoff Chios,in that order. Cf. Walbank, Philip v, 301-8. r50Pofyb. xvi. I , discussedby Holleaux,Etudes,iv . 247-551withthe chronological reservationexpressedin the previousnote; cf. Walbank,Philip V,308). t5rI cannot discuss fully here the political and diplomatic circumstancesof Romaninterventionin the SecondMacedonianWar; nor the variousattitudesat Rome at the time. As I have said(above,n. 108),the existenceof a formal treaty betweenAntiochosand Philip seemsextremelyunlikely,but an informal working agreementcannotbe ruled out. What matteredwas the reportingof the rumour at Rome,althoughit is not likely that sucha report playeda decisivepart in determining Romanpolicy in 200;no one in Romecan havebelievedin the possibilityof a direct threat from the East (seeH. Bengtson,Die Welt als Geschichte,v (1939), 176-7, = Kleine Schriften zur alten Geschichte(Munich, 1974),251-2).More important considerationsto the Senateat this time surely were that Philip was supportinglawlessnessin the easternAegean,and that Roman interventionto restore order there had becomefeasible with the ending of the war with Carthage (on this secondpoint, seeNiese ii. 590; Petzold24-5).
74
Attalos and the Aegean
The Reign of Attalos I
This appraisal of Attalos' policy in relation to the Roman alliance leadsto the conclusion that the main motive continued to be the defence,and not the extension,of his kingdom.[n fact, Attalos achievedtwo territorial gainsas a result of the alliance with Rome, namely the islandsof Aigina and Andros.l52Aigina remainedan island of someconsiderableprestige in the Hellenistic period, and must have appearedto Attalos as an assetof value, particularly as its possessionprovided him with a baseclose to the Greek mainland, with whosecitiesit remainedhis concernto promotefriendly relations,but its acquisitionwas not due to any substantialinitiative on Attalos' part. Andros was acquired in 199, during the SecondMacedonianWar, but the circumstances,beyondthe fact that Attalos had taken part in its capture from Philip, are unclear. We have only Livy's statement,ea ab Romanis regi Attalo concessa(xxxi. 45.7);we cannotbe surethat it had the samestatus,in the senseof being a possessionof the king, as Aigina. We see,then, that Attalos never envisagedthe Roman alliance as a meansof territorial expansion.Such ideas of Attalos as an empire-builderare the fantasiesof modern historians.With our sightsthusnarrowedwe are ableto assessmorefairly Attalos' own achievement.He did not createa new kingdom;rather he devoted his resourcesto strengtheningthe existingkingdom- modestasit was in size - and to establishinga diplomatic standingin the Greek world which it never lost. We may howeverreasonablyattributeto Attalos, in the context of his rule over Aigina, the applicationof an institutionwhich was later extendedto other cities of the enlargedkingdom.Aigina and Andros are of particularimportancein assessingthe development of institutionsof Attalid rule in that they were subjectpossessions whoseacquisitioncan be datedfirmly to the reignof Attalos [, and whoseinstitutionscan thereforebe assignedwith a high degreeof probability to him. In particular, the presenceof an Bnrcrdr1Eat Aigina, attestedby a decreeof the city dating from the reign of Attalos II, indicatesthat this was an Attalid institution beforethe r52Attalid interestsin Euboia,includingAttalos' temporarypossession of Oreos (Livy xxxi. zt6. 16: cf. 1vP 50, : OGIS 288)were shortlived;in 196Flamininus preventedthe Romancommissioners from finally cedingEretriaand Karystos'and xväi.47. l0-lI;Holleaux,Etudes,v.40'n. |). evenOreos,toEumenesIl(Polyb.
75
extension of the kingdom in 188.t53It is more likely that the Enrcrätqg had existed in Aigina from the time of its acquisition, than that the offrce was introduced suddenly in 188, since the status of Aigina was not changed in that year. It is unlikely, however, as has already been pointed out (above, 42), that the offrce was introduced by Attalos into any of the cities of Asia Minor, whosestatuswas much lesscloselydefined;but we can be reasonablysurethat Attalid rule in Aigina provided a precedentfor similar institutions that were implementedthroughout the kingdom after 188.It will be shown in a later chapterthat the development of royal cults of the Attalids also owes its origins in some measureto Attalos' rule in Aigina and Andros. Of equal importancein this connectionis the indication that a garrison was imposed in Aigina after Attalos acquiredit in 209. That this was the case is shown by a dedicationof the garrison members,which is datable to the reign of Attalos \:lsa ALi xai 'Alfivat l6nöp6aoü"6aEI'Arril"ou lZarupivog, Kal)"tpayoElxai oi ön' aötoüg flyep6veElxai oqattbrar. As I have attemptedto show elsewhere,this body was not an army in the field during the First MacedonianWar, as no Pergamenearmy was engagedin Aiginaat this time; it wasthereforea garrisonput in later.rssIn fact the presenceof a garrison is attestedby Livy during the Second MacedonianWar,tso but we have no evidence as to its permanence.It seemslikely, however,that the statusof Aigina asa naval baserenderedthe islandliable to almostcontinuousmilitary occupation by Attalos. Although this policy may be seenas an important precedentfor Attalid practice elswhere at a later date, for exampleon the frontier with Galatia,rsTit seemsto havebeen the exceptionratherthan the rule. The Attalid garrisonin a Greekcity remained,as we will see, a rarity. ' s r l G i v . l , = O G I S 3 2 9 . S e e B S A l x v i ( 1 9 7 1 ) ,4 . ts4EA l9l). L92: lSE i. 36. r 5 5 B S A l x v i ( 1 9 7 1 ) ,l - 6 . 156xxxi. 25. I (200): quia praesidium Attali ab Aegina Romanique ob Piraeo intraverant urbem. r 5 7S e e b e l o w . c h . 5 .
Attalid Kingdom after the Treaty of Apameia
4 THE ATTALID KINGDOM AFTER THE TREATY OF APAMEIA The Attalids were the greatopportunistsof the Hellenisticworld, and none more so than Eumenes II, who succeededhis father Attalos towards the end of 197.1His reign marked the height of Pergamenepower and splendour,as characterizedby the extensive rebuildingof the citadelof Pergamon,2 and it hasleft us in the Great Altar and its sculpturesone of the finest monuments of antiquity.3Eumeneswas rewardedfor his loyalty to Rome in the war with Antiochos III of Syria with an extendedkingdom which far surpassedthe previous Attalid Kingdom in terms of size and extent of authority, althoughit was, as we shall see,basedon it. The new kingdom made proportionately greater demandson the Attalid systemof administration,and at the sametime the incorporation of Teos, the seatof the Ionian Guild of Dionysiantechnitai, allowed Eumenesand his successorsnew scope in the development of royal cults. Theseaspectsof Attalid rule will demandmost of our attention in this and the following chapters. The eventsof the reign of EumenesII are well documentedby the narratives of Polybios and Livy, and a fairly dependable chronologicalframework can be established.Eumenesextended his father's policy of forming friendshipswith the statesof the Greek mainland by concluding an alliance with the Achaian Leaguewhich Polybioscalls (in 185)'theancestralalliance'.aThe t On the date, see above, l0 n. 6. 2 Strabo xäi. 4. 2, 624; the chronology and details of the building programme underEumenesllarediscussed by A. Schober,OJlr xxxii (1940),15l ff.,andmore fully by Kähler, Gr. Fries, 136ff. 3 See,in addition toAvP III, Kähler, Gr. Fries, part I. The best readily available photographsof the friezes known to me are those in E. Schmidt, TheGreat Altar of Pergamon (London, 1965),but the text is not ofthe samestandard.Carl Humann's drawings of the figures of the friezes are beautifully reproduced inDer Pergamon Altar (hrlmund, 1960). a Polyb. xxii. 7. 8.
77
Attalid fleet againservedthe purposeof the alliance,assumingan active role in two expeditionsdirected againstNabis of Spartain 195and 192,5andthe allianceis further attestedin actionduringthe war with Antiochos by a dedicationof the Leaguemadeafter the battle of Magnesiain honour of Eumenes' brother, the future Attalos II.6 It is clear that Eumenes,like his father, enjoyedclose and lasting relations with the states of central and southern Greece,Tand these relations are also illustratedby an important but not often cited passageof Polybios,which refersto widespread honourspaid to Eumenesin the Peloponnese.s By meansof large donationsat Delphi, Attalos I and EumenesII also strengthened their friendshipwith the Aitolians, their allies in the Macedonian wars, and this friendihip is reflectedin the many honourspaid to the Attalids at Delphi, more than to any other dynasty.eThese relationswere all inspiredby the now establishedAttalid policy of winning friendsby actsof generosity,a policy notedamongothers by Livy (xlii. 5.3):cum Eumenisbeneficiisnumeribusqueomnes Graeciae civitates et plerique principum obligati essent. The lavish use of their wealth remainedas much a corner-stoneof the Attalids' foreign policy after 188as it had been before. ln 216Antiochos III seemsto have recognizedAttalos I as an equalking and his kingdomas a sovereignstate,and he is the first of the Seleukids for whom such action is attested. We know nothing further of the relationsbetween the two kings until 198, when Antiochos, after returning from successful operations elsewherein his kingdom,turned his attentionagainto Asia Minor and took the opportunity of attackingthe kingdomof Attalos at a 5 Livy xxxiv. 29. 4; IvP 6O-63,= Sy//.3595, 605. 6IvP 64,: Sy/I.r 606. ? The evidence of Attalos I's interest in central Greece and the Peloponnese consistsofchancereferences,e.g. Polyb.iv. 65.6, wherewe learnthat Attaloshad financed the building of the walls of the Aitolian stronghold of Elaos. He was honouredby the Sikyoniansafter redeemingsacredland of Apollo for them; later he receivedan annualsacrificethere (Polyb.xviii. l6; seebelow, 147).For Eumenes seealso Appendix iv, no. l9 (Thebes). 8 xxvii. 18:in 170/69.when the whole of Greecewas concernedwith the imminent war with Perseus,the Achaians consideredrevoking all their honours, but a more moderate proposal, supported by Polybios himself, was adopted (xxvii. 7. 8-14). The affair characterizes dramatically the Attalids' high regard in the Peloponneseand their concern to maintain it. e Daux,Delphes.502-l l.
78
Attalid Kingdom after the Treaty of Apameia
time when the latter was particularly unable to defend it.10Antiochos' behaviour is diffrcult to understand,for no sooner was Attalos dead than he offered a marriage-allianceto Eumenes, whose refusalEumenesclaimedto his credit in his speechto the RomanSenatein l89.tt The importanceof Antiochos'actionslay in the consequencethat the Roman alliancereplacedthe needfor at least nominal co-operationwith the Seleukidsas a major requirementof Attalid foreign policy. This freedom from Seleukid influenceis reflectedin a numberof institutionsof Attalid rule after the Treaty of Apameiahad confirmedthe position: in the regional administration,which departedfrom the Seleukidsatrapalsystem; in the titles and functionsof oflicials; and in the new royal coinage, the cistophoros,first minted on a generalbasisafter the Treaty of Apameia (see part ii below). [n terms of practical politics this situation formed for a time a far more decisive and substantial support to Attalid independence.After the Roman settlementof 188sc the King of Pergamoncould dealwith the Seleukidproblem from a position of strength,and the results are startling. In Asia Minor the new kingdomawardedto EumenesII created its own problems,and Eumeneswas facedfor the rest of his reign with the enmity of Bithynia and Pontos, as well as the danger presentedby the apparentreadinessof the Galatiansto ally themselves with any enemy of Pergamon,as they had done in the previousreign. One of the most important aspectsof the external policy of the Attalids in the yearsafter Apameiawas thereforethe need to keep control over Galatia, which they did not annex formally as a provincealthoughperhapsthey could havedone (see chapter 5), and Cappadocia,which they achievedby a dynastic marriage(seeAppendix iii) and, when necessary,by direct interference. r0Livy xxxii. 8. 9-10. The authenticityofthis invasionin 198,asdistinctfrom the one in the following year, is convincingly defended by E. Badian, CI. Phil. liv (1959),82-3 (: Studiesin Roman History (Oxford, 1964),l14) and by Schmitt, Untersuchungen, 269 tr. t I Polyb. xxi. 20. E-9; Appian, Syr. 5. The most convincing date for this offer is 195,after the marriageof Antiochos'children Antiochos and Laodike at Seleukeia in 196/5 (Schmitt, Untersuchungen, lTl4), and the meeting of Antiochos and Hannibalat Ephesosin the autumnof 195(Holleaux,Etudes,v. 180-3),where it occursin Appian's narrative;see also below, Appendix iii, n.7.
Attalid Kingdom after the Treaty of Apameia
79
The immediatecausesof the war which Eumenesfought with PrusiasI of Bithynia are unknown, and we have no continuous narrative of its course, the literary evidence being confined to occasionalreferences.r2A decreeofTelmessos,datedto 184and thereforeduring Attalid rule, honoursEumenesfor a greatvictory over'Prusias, Ortiagon, and the Galatiansand their allies', and acclaimsEumenesas Soter, saviour.l3The content of the decree suggeststhe context of a war in progress, and establishesa chronology whereby the peaceis to be dated a little after 184/3. Eumenes'victory provided a suitableoccasionfor the first celebration of the reorganizedPergameneNikephoria, which we must date to l8l; it probably also earnedEumenesthe title So/er, first attestedby the decreeof Telmessosjust mentioned,and referring more probably to this war than to the earlier, Antiochic, war.r4 No sooner was peace concluded with Prusiasthan Eumenes faced another enemy, Pharnakesof Pontos. This new war was under way in 18312,when envoys of Eumenesand of Pharnakes appearedin Rome and the Senateagreedto send out legati. The most substantialpieceof evidenceon the courseand natureof this The war is Polybios'accountof the treaty concludingit in 180/79.t5 principal action evidently took place in Galatiaand Cappadocia, and this fact illustratesthe rivalry of the kingdomsof Asia Minor for control of theseimportant areas.In the settlementPharnakes was required to evacuatethe Galatians'territory and to revoke ouvilfixat previously concluded with them; Attalid interests in both Galatia and Cappadociawere firmly reasserted. As a result of the enormousincreaseof their kingdomin 188the Attalids were for the rest of their history far more concernedwith Asian affairs, and far less than before with the events of the Aegean.It was a signof the timeswhen in 17514EumenesII placed on the Seleukidthrone the new king, Antiochos IV Epiphanes, whose elevation is describedby Appian (Syr. 45), and equally 12For an account of this waf,seeNiese iii. 70ff.; Habicht, Hermes, lxxxiv (1956), 9l fr.; RE, s.v. husias (l), 1086-1107. t3 Appendix iv, no. 7; see also no. 8 (Panion,Thrace). 14Onthe chronology,see Habicht, Hermes,lxxxiv (1956),99;on the title, L. Robert, Rev. Phil. lx (1934),284-5tEt. anat. 73, n. l. ti xxiii. 9. 3; the treaty is at xxv. 2; cf. xxiv. 14.
80
Attalid Kingdom after the Treaty of Apameia
Attalid Kingdom after the Treaty of Apameia
81
remarkablethat Eumenes and his brothers, and the deceased Attalos Soter, shouldbe lavishly honouredin an Atheniandecree relatingto theseevents.r6Furthermore,we know from afragment of Diodoros (xxxi. 32a) that when Epiphanes died in 16413, Eumenes went so far as to crown at Pergamona rival to the successorDemetrios,and this pretenderwas later brought to the throne by Attalos II, after the defeat and death of Demetrios (Straboxiii. 4. 2,624). Suchinterferencein Seleukidhistory was a by-product of Roman intervention. It is not surprising that Eumenes was only vaguely interested in the Roman war with Perseus,althoughthe extentof his commitmentis unclear;on the other hand, Romecould not deal as finally with the King of Pergamon as she choseto do with Rhodes.rT The Galatiansremaineda major problemin Asia Minor, for the Greek cities as well as the monarchies.Attalid troops had taken part in the campaignof Manlius in 189(Polyb. xxi. 33-40; Livy xxxviii. 12-38),and its successfuloutcomehadbeen,accordingto Polybios(xxi. 40. 2) a causeof greaterjoyto the inhabitantsof Asia Minor than the prospectof freedom from Antiochos. Those inclined to dub Eumenesa lackey of Rome and a traitor to Hellenismrs are reminded that he now assumedresponsibility for GalatiadespiteevidentRomandisapproval,re and secureda victory comparablein its outcometo that of Manlius, and certainlyas beneficialto the safetyof the Greek cities. (The detailsof this war will be discussedin chapter5.) Polybiosis explicitthat Eumenes' popularity among the Greek cities increasedas he took a more independentline (xxxi. 6. 6): xa9' öoov öö6xouv oi 'Papaiot
flapürcqov rQ Eüptvet ngooqtpn)aL xcrrd roooüro ouv66atve "ElJ'qvaE fiQoootxeroüoeaL 9(toet uitv dvqpdtnau äü tQt roög 0)"ßopövE tilv eövomv npoovepövron. We are surely entitled to believethen that Eumenesdied in the favour of many of the Greek cities of Asia Minor.20 Eumeneswas already ill during the war with Pharnakes,when his brother Attalos assumedmuch of the burdenof the war, and by 168/7his death was expected.2lAccording to the chronological indicationsafforded by Strabo, he died in 160/59,and documentary evidencefrom Delphi allows a closer dating: Eumeneswas certainly alive until the late autumn of 159,and furthermore his brother Attalos had been co-regentduring the last months of his life.22 The personalityof Attalos II is markedly different from that of Eumenes,for althoughhe is in many ways the most likable of the Attalids, he clearly did not have the forcefulnessand diplomatic ability which his father and his brother had shown in turn. It had been,for example,the recoveryof Eumenesthat had put an endto the war with Pharnakes.Strabo informs us that Eumenesleft the kingdomto Attalos asepitopos of the youngerAttalos (thefuture Attalos III), Eumenes'son by Stratonike(xiii. 4. 2,624- seeAppendix i). The fact that Attalos called himselfking and ruled until his own death, which occurredcertainly well after the majority of his nephew,23probably reveals the intention of protecting the successionin much the sameway as Antigonos Doson had done for Philip V of Macedon.2a Under Attalos II, Attalid foreignpolicy continued,althoughon a
t6IvP 160,= OGIS 248: Holleaux.Etudes. li. 12747. r7 H. H. Schmitt,Ronr und Rhodos(MünchenerBeiträge7urPapyrusforschung und antikenRechtsgeschichte,40, 1957),157tr. r8There is no evidenceto support the generalization that Eumenes'was everywheredislikedasbeingRome'sjackal, the traitor to Hellenism'(W. W. Tarn, HellenisticCivilisation(ed. 3, London, 1952),29).It is preciselyevidenceof this kind that we most lack for Eumenes'reign; what there is is confinedmainly to which naturallydepictEumenesin an unfavourable scrapsofRhodianpropaganda, light. te Note the eventssurroundingAttalos' visit to Romein 168/7(Polyb.xxx. l-3; Livy xlv. l9). The Senate'ssuspicionswere directedat Eumenespersonallybecauseof his behaviourduring the war with Perseus.Rome's contribution to a solutionof the Galatianproblemin theseyears was preciselynil.
20Note especiallythe decreeofthe Ioniankoinonpassedin Eumenes'honourin the winter of 16?/6,immediately after he was refusedentry into ltaly by the Roman -Senate;it is quotedextensivelyin Eumenes'reply to the koinon (OGIS ü.763' 169-Tl,andbelow'partii). ii.ch.xi,esp. Appendixiv,no.l3;cf.Holleaux,Etudes, Eumeneswas particularlycommendedfor bringingpeace(lines ll-13). z t P o l y b .x x i v . 5 . 2 : x x x . 2 . 5 . 22Seeabove,l0 n. 7. 23On the chronology,seebelow, Appendix i. 2aAntigonos Doson was firsl epitropos and later basileas"seethe study of Dow l63ff.ThedistinctionbetweenguardianandEdson,flarv.Stud.xlviii(1937),esp. shipand usurpationis examinedby A. Aymard,Etudesd'histoireancienne(Pans' 196D,230ff. The careful attention Attalos II paid to the guardianshipof his nephew is now further demonstratedby a royal letter about the man who was appointedhis mentor (Appendix iv, no. 24).
82
Attalid Kingdom after the Treaty of Apameia
less independentbasis, to be concernedalmost exclusively with Asian affairs.Accordingto Polybios(xxxii. I 2) Attalos' first act on succeedingto the throne was the restorationof his personalfriend Ariarathes(V) to the throne of Cappadocia,and polybios rightly notes that this was an exampleof Attalos' generalpolicy.2sIt is probable, then, that Attalos was anxious to make sure of his friendsbeforedealingwith his enemies.26 Theseenemieswere for the most part, as in the previousreign,Galatiaand Bithynia. Royal correspondence with the friendly priest Attis at Pessinousmakesit clear that Attalid control over Galatia, barely establishedunder Eumenes II, was lost under Attalos II.27 Attalid hostility to Bithynia reacheda final climax. We have a good if brief narrative of Attalos'warwith PrusiasIlintheMithridateiosof Appian(3-7), supplementedby substantial fragments of Polybios' history (xxxii-xxxiii). Both theseaccountsare written in Attalos'favour. and the only documentaryevidence,a dedicationof Attalos himself, naturally confirms the implications of the literary sources, that Prusiaswas completely in the wrong.2E Of Prusias'initial treacherythere can be little doubt; according to Appian the SenateorderedPrusiasto make peacewith Attalos on the frontier, taking with him only a thousandmen, insteadof which he advancedwith his entire army and destroyedthe pergameneNikephorion.2eOn the other hand,Attalos resortedto the now standardAttalid practice of dealing with potential and real enemiesby removingthem from their thronesandinstallingfriends in their places;by the time Attalos was dead,this policy had been successfully applied to Syria and Cappadocia, as well as Bithyni4.ro zsxxxiii. 12. For Attalos' early friendshipwith Ariarathesat Athens, seeSy/l.3 666, ajoint dedicationto their teacherCarneades. 26Note Appian's comment(Syr. 45) on the motivesof Eumenes and Attalos in supporting Antiochos IY: ötar.p$öpevot töv dvöpa. 27Seebelow,ch. 5. 2EIvP 225, = OGIS 327. 2eMithr.3; Polyb.xxxii. 15.Accordingto both accounts,prusias' destructionof the Nikephorionconstitutedhis secondattack on Attalos. Accordingto polybios, Prusiaswent on to loot the rich country around Thyateira, as philip V of Macedon had done in 201 (xvi. l. 6-7; Holleaux,Etudes, iv. 248-51;L. Robert,Et. anat. I l2- 13; Magie,Roman Rule, ä. 1197 , n. 42). 30Appian,Mithr. 4-7; for Syria, see Hopp, L)ntersuchungen, 79-85.
Attalid Kingdom after the Treaty of Apameia
83
Attalid forcesassistedRomein the final subjugationof Macedon in 149,3rand in the sackof Corinth threeyearslater,32andwith the latter event the narrativeof Polybios(or what is left of it) comesto a close. For the rest of the reign of Attalos II, and for that of his successor,we are left, apart from the comparativelymeagreepigraphical evidence, with literary referencesthat are either fragmentary or incidental, or both. For most events we badly miss context and detail, and the loss of a good contemporarysourceis irreparable. Little more than the fact is known of Attalos II's probably important campaignagainstthe Thracianking Diegylis, son-inlaw of Attalos' former enemy, PrusiasII of Bithynia (Appian, Mithr. 6), which is dated by a dedicationto the year 145,33 and the end of Attalos' reign is shroudedin darkness. The preoccupationof Eumenes II and Attalos II with Asian affairsis further exemplifiedby their activity on the southernshore of Asia Minor, where the cities of Selgeand Amlada in Pisidia evidently tried to resist Attalid influenceafter the Galatiantroubles of the 160s.Both Eumenesand Attalos undertook military campaignsin the area,but the shortliterary noticesrecordingthem do not say much aboutthe backgroundand circumstancesofthese events.34Also of great importanceis Attalos' foundation of Attaleiain Pamphylia,3swhich, togetherwith his buildingactivity in the harbourat Ephesos(seepart ii below), indicateshis concernto promotetrade in the kingdom. Attaleia facedCyprus, the eastern Mediterranean.and the realm of the Ptolemies.and the choice of this positionconfirmsthe tendencyof the Attalids after the Treaty of Apameia to turn away from co-operationand economicintercourse with the Seleukids. The anecdotalnatureof the literary evidencefor the reignof the 3r Strabo xäi. 4.2, 624; cf. Niese iii. 334. 3' Pliny, Nat. Hist. xxxv. 24; cf. Niese iii. 352. 33OGIS 330; Hopp, Untersuchungen,96-8. ra For Selgewe havethe noticeofTrogus,Prol. xxxiv; Straboxii.7. 3, 571says that the SelgiansörepriTowo npöE rcüE 6aor)'öaEfui (by oi 6aoü'etg Strabo often meansthe Attalids). Cf. Hopp, (Jntersuchungen,70. The situation of Amlada is discussedmore fully below, 102. 35Straboxiv. 4. l, 667. Attaleia was founded more probably in the early yearsof Attalos' reign, when he was campaigningin Pisidia, than in 189in connectionwith Manlius Vulso's campaignin the area; Hopp, Untersuchungen,102-4considers both datespossible.
84
Attalid Kingdom after the Treaty of Apameia
last of the Attalids, Attalos III Philometor,has alreadybeen discussed;it tells us more about the man than aboutthe eventsof his reign.36He figureshardly at all in the final fragmentsof Polybios' history,3Tand we are left with a mainly hostiletradition about him that has excessivelycoloured modern opinion. The epigraphical material shows that Attalos III continued to defend Attalid interestsin military terms,3Eand that he was responsiblefor a significantand highly individualdevelopmentof the royal cults of the kingdom (seechapter 6). His decisionto bequeaththe kingdomto Rome3emustbe seenin the context of his own personalityand rule, and not in terms of a postulateddependenceon Romebeginningin the previousreignor even earlier, for Attalos' predecessorswere well able to defend their kingdomevenwhen the Senaterefusedordeclinedto support them. Attalos' bequestis the first instanceof the will of a Hellenistic monarchin favour of Rome being put into effect. There was a theoreticalprecedent,known from an inscriptionfrom Cyrene,in the decisionin 155of Ptolemy Physkon (the future EuergetesII, then King of Cyrene)to leavehis kingdomto Romeasa last resort, shouldhe die with no one of his choice to succeedhim; it is even possiblethat Attalos knew of Physkon'sdecisionfrom hiscontacts in Rome, althoughPhyskon'swill was not implementedand was probablynot madepublic until a later date.aoAttalos' action later 36Seeabove,ch. l. 37The testimoniaare given in Appendix i below. 38IvP 246, : OGIS 332 honours Attalos on his return from a successfulmilitary expedition,perhapsin Thrace; cf. Hopp, Untersuchungen,lll, n.25. 3eStill important is Cardinali's study 'Le morte di Attalo III e la rivolta di Aristonico', in Saggi . . . offerti a G. Beloch (1910),269-320;for an excellent moderndiscussionsee Hopp, Untersuchungen,12147. a0SEG ix. 7, : Ann. öp. 1912,80.Accordingto this text a copy of the will was to be sent to Rome. Wilcken, SB Berlin, 1932,tl7-36, arguedthat the will was not publisheduntil 96 nc, when Romefinally acquiredCyrene, but the Senatemay have known the terms in 155.and the information could therefore have reachedAttalos. An earlier origin of this practice may be seen in the decision of Nikomedes I of Bithynia(diedc.255:Beloch,Gr. Gesch.iv.22,p.213) to securethe succession for the children ofhis secondmarriageby naming specific guardiansoutside his own kingdom, namely Herakleia, Kios, Byzantion, and the Kings of Macedonia and Egypt (Memnon22,= FGrHist 434, Fl4). In the event,despitetheseprecautions, Ziaelas,half-brother ofthe designatedheirs, succeededin gaining the throne (see Magie,RomanRuIe, ä. I195,n. 35).
The New, Provinces
85
constituteda precedentfor NikomedesIV of Bithynia.al The transition to Romanrule was hinderedby the resistanceof Aristonikos. Now that Aristonikos can be seen as a dynastic aspirantto a paternum regnum, as his coinage,which calls him King Eumenes,indicates,we are sparedfurther speculationaboul social upheavalin the Attalid Kingdom and especiallyat pergamon.a2Aristonikos failed to win supportfrom the Greek cities of the kingdom, probably becausethey had already been promised their freedomin Attalos' will,a3and he resortedto the mobilization of slavesas a desperatestrategicmeasure.He failednot as a social revolutionary,but asthe lastclaimantto the throneof the Attalids. (i) The New Provinces We havenow tracedthe history of the Attalid Kingdomto the point where under Attalos I it becamean independentand sovereign kingdomableto maintainalliancesand exert influencesbeyondits own frontiersas Attalos and his predecessors choseto placethem. The origins of this expansivepolicy lay in a need to defend the kingdom againstthe Galatians44 and other enemies;they did not arise from and did not lead to thoughts of empire or even of expandingthe areaof direct royal authority. Attalos' treatieswith the important Greekcities, reviewedabove,a5servedthe interests of both parties, city and king, and enabled Attalos to collect ouvtä$e6 for the supportof his professionalizedarmies.There is no evidencewhatever within the area of direct authority which Attalos inheritedfrom EumenesI of a regionaladministrationor of a systemof direct governmentover the Greekcitiesconcerned;the coincidenceof certain institutions with those of the Pergamene constitution,as indicatedby the prescriptsofextant decrees,is not in itself necessarilyindicativeof a centralizedpolicy, sincethe city of Pergamondid not havean untypicalconstitution,but one which other cities might be expectedto sharein ordinary circumstances. arMagie,RomanRule, ä. 1200,n. 49. 42E. S. G. Robinson,Num. Chron. xiv (1954), l-7; Hopp, (Jntersuchungen, t45-7. o, Hopp, Untersuchungen,143.4. 44Seealso below, ch. 5. ai Seeabove, 39-58.
86
Attalid Kingdom after the Treaty of Apameia
We shall see later that the Attalids were able to exploit the constitutionalarrangementsin somecitiesto their own advantage,but there is no evidencethat they manipulatedor prescribedthe forms of the constitutions themselves.46Attalos' administration was noticeably gearedto the military requirementsof his reign, and apart from their commitmentto support him in this area of royal activity we have no indication in the availableevidencethat the cities in the immediateterritory of Pergamonwere not allowed to lead a full and independentcivic life. Whatever the exact nature and extent of royal rule during the reign of Attalos I, it is clear at leastthat at the end of his reign the kingdom was hardly any biggerthan it had beenat the beginning. Polybiosascribesto Philip V of Macedonthe following commenoöroLpmqdv dationof EumenesII andAttalo sII:a1napa)"a66vreE dpXitu xai i1v ruyoöoav qü[rlxaot taÜrr1v,aorc pr1fupü4 elvat xaraöeeottqal. The mostrecentlosseswerethoseof 198when, as the evidencesuggests,Antiochos III seizedlarge areasof Attalid territory, enablinghim to march throughthis territory againin the spring of 196without any apparentoppositionfrom Eumenes.as During the war in which Eumenesfought againstAntiochoson the side of Rome, many Attalid cities close to Pergamon,including PhokaiaandThyateira,aeremainedin Seleukidpossession,andthe Attalid Kingdom for a while almost ceasedto exist, but at the end of this war Eumeneswas rewardedfor his loyalty to Rome with a kingdomwhich in terms of size and securityof tenure was something the Attalids had not known before. In this chapterwe shall examinethe implicationsof this new situationin terms of the royal administrationand the precedentson which it drew. In 188 BCthe Roman settlementof Asia Minor imposed new obligationson the King of Pergamonby altering totally the constitutionalbasison which the kingdom was founded. EumenesII had not merelyforeseenbut had welcomedtheseobligationsin his speechdeliveredto the Roman Senatein 189,the year after the a6Seefurther below. 104-9. a7xxiii. I I . 7. Seealsoxxxii. E. 3: (Eumenes)ropü"a6öv napd rcö tarpög rilv 6aoütiav ouvtma).pöt4v rc).6a9eig ü.tya xai ).wä nd,rcpdtn. 48Schmitt, Untersuchungen,271-3,and especially273. aeSeeabove.42.434.
The New Provinces
87
defeatof AntiochosIII at Magnesia:s0 oüöui cpap€v ömatdrtpov üvaL naqayoptiv üpd.Etöv ix roü noltpou ytyovörav ä07av flneprjpiv. It was not simplya matterof an increaseof territory that was at issue,becausethe terms by which the increasewas made representsomethingquite different from previousAttalid experience.We shallseein particularthat the basisof Attalos' expansion of royal influence beyond his formal frontiers was swept aside together with these frontiers by the terms imposedby Rome.st Polybios' account of the settlement as it related to Eumenes specifiesboth areasand individualcitiesthat were assignedto him as gifts. These included,in Europe, Chersonesos, Lysimacheia and 'the adjoining strongholdsand chora which Antiochos had ruled', and in Asia, 'HellespontinePhrygia,GreaterPhrygia,the Mysians whom Prusiashad previously taken, Lycaonia, Milyas, Lydia, and the citiesof Tralles,Ephesos,and Telmessos'.s2 This provision suggeststhat the administrationof the areasconcerned was left in Eumenes' hands, and we look for confirmation and clarification of this situationto a number of contemporarydocuments relating to two of the areasspecifiedin the Roman settlement, namelyChersonesos and HellespontinePhrygia.In addition we now haveevidencefor a third region,centredon Ephesos.In all cases the attested names and institutions.show a departure in terminologyfrom the Seleukidsatrapalsystem,but it will be seen that the new institutionsdo not indicate,asis often maintained,the influenceof any other singleadministrativesystem. An inscription of Roman date from Sestoshonouringa benefactor refersto Straton
88
Attatid Kingdom after the Treaty of Apameia
that the name of the area as defined in theseinscriptionscorrespondsclosely with the designationgiven in the Roman settlement 'Chersonesosand Lysimacheiaand the adjoining of 188,namely strongholds and chora'. To this evidence we may now add a recently published inscription from Ephesoswhich attests one 'keeper of the seal' andmqaqyög Demetriosson of Apollonios, 'EE1oouxai rCovxar"'Ecpeoovrönon xai Kaüorpou neö[ou än( re xai rö Kü.6nvöv (sic).5r The most substantialevidencefor the Attalids' institutionsof provincial administrationis an inscription relating to Hellespontine Phrygia.saThe stonewas found at Bursa (ancientPrusa)and recordsa decreehonouringa man namedKorrhagosson of Aristomachos,but it has been firmly establishedthat the honouring city was not Prusaitself.ssHolleaux'sexhaustivestudy of the termini of c. 225and 150BC;this means letter-formsestablished that the decree must refer either to Seleukidor to Attalid rule, since during these years the territories of HellespontinePhrygia cameunder no other authority.56There is no specificreferencein the decreeto either kingdom,and the only royal designationis the anonymousö 6aot),eü;.
s
"Eöo(tv rrlt 6ou74L xai tCot öripot M*6paXoE 'Appläou einu' inti KöppayoE'Aprctoprilou Maxeötbv, rtraypfvoE orparqyöE röv xa'EM"fionovrov rönutv, önrtlet rilp naoav 0' onouöi1v xcti tiivotav nQooqtgöprvoE tiE rö otv-
5rThrace:OGIS 339,: J. Krauss,Inst'hr. r'on Sestosund der Thrakischen Chersones(lnsthr. griech. Städte aus Kleinasien' XIX, 1980)'no. I (with full commentary);oGlS 330.Comparethe title of the third-centuryRolemaicofficial 'El)lqonövrou xoJröv itti @pamqEüttatv (lG Xll. Hippomedon,or pa{qyöE iE 8. 156,= Sy'//.r502;Bengtson,Strat lii. 178).Ephesos:Appendixiv, no' 25' 5aHomolle, CRAI 1921,269ff. (editioprinceps),superseded by Holleaux,BCII xlviii (f924), l-57 {Etudes,ä.73-125),the mostthoroughanalysisand necessarily the startingpoint of any discussionof the text. On the date, which is discussed below,andotheradditionalpoints,seethe importantremarksof G. De Sanctis,Riv. (tifil. üi(1925),63-78.The text appearedassEG ii.663 (cf. iv. 716).see the useful in Bengtson,Strat. ii.2ll-26. discussion 55Holleaux,Erudes.ü. I l4-15;De Sanctis,Riv. difil.lili (1925),7V1.Holleaux arguedpersuasivelyin favour ofApollonia on the Rhyndakos,not far from ancient Prusawherethe stonewas found. Magie'sargumentsfor Abydos (RomanRule, ü. | 0l l-13) arenot acceptablein themselvessinceAbydoswasprobablynot Attalid at the argueddate (seebelow, n. 140). 56Holleaux.Etudes,ii. 75-81,85-6.
The New Provinces
r0
l5
20
25
89
aü$rc9at üv ö1pov, xai xoLvfit xai iöfut rctE iuruyXävouotv töv nd"rcitv tüXp4otov aöröv napaoxtud\e, önö rt rlv napd).rtlplv rrtE nö7eaE rj{iatoev röv 6aot7öa änoöo94vat toüg tt uöltouE xai tilv nätprcu noAne tav xai rd iepd rcp6vq xai tö eig d iepä xai nöLuog örcfuqow ägyüprcv xcti tö rotE vöoLEöLatov xai rd. ä77a änep if dpXAg ünqpXev töt örjpa4 ivöeöE rt änal).aooövrav triu noAnav öÄ röv nölepov napd tt aöto6 öyapioarc eiE räg ö4porekIE ?t,o[ag 6oüE xai iepeia, xo'i töt 6aoÄeli) pv49tiE i$enoploaro oftov tig onöppa xai önrgoEqv, xai td.E iö[aE txäorutt röv noludty xrrjoery ouv{oneuotv önpeiv[at] roiE re pl öyouotv öo94vaL ix roü 6aotttxoü, xai drelthg inmeXapqptv4E naoöv rav nqooööav tinö roü 6aoÄ{oE iröu tgtöv öoneuotv xai ä77a öüo kq önöo9qvaq 6ouT6ptvog tig tüöa4toviav xai intöoow xatamfioat roüE no),i,taE, dxö[ou9a npdooov tfit rc6 6aoÄtaE npoaqöoeL' ivct öi xai ö öqpoE Eaiv1ra(t) änoööoüg ydprcag ä{fuE rcig aiüv eütpyttoüotv, öeööy9at töt öfipat' finaLvfoat rl Köppayov röv orpat4yöv xali otecpavöoat aütövl Xpuoöt ottrpftivat. xtA.l
30 'A decree of the boule and the people, on the motion of Menemachos son of Archelaos. Considering that Korrhagos the Macedonian, son of Aristomachos, after being appointed strategos of the regions around the Hellespont, constantly shows every enthusiasm and good will for the advancement of the people and publicly and individually puts himself at the service ofthe citizens; that after the acquisitionofthe city he asked the king to restore the city's laws and ancestral constitution and its sacred precincts, as well as providing funds for the sacred and civil administration and oil for the use of the neoi and everything elseformerly availableto the people; that when the citizens were in severehardship as a result of the war he provided at his own expense oxen and other animals for the public sacrifices, and having notified the king he provided corn for sowing and for sustenance,urged that each individual should keep his own possessions and that those with nothing should be provided for out of royal funds, and also urged that immunity from all taxes granted by the king for three years should be extended for another two years, wishing to endow the citizens with prosperity and generosity in accordance with the king's policy. So that the people may be seen to show suitable gratitude to its benefactors, the people have decided as follows: to commend Korrhagos thestrategos, to crown him with a gold crown, [etc.].' The decisive
argument
in favour
of associating the decree
90
Attalid Kingdom after the Treoty of Apameia
with Attalid rule arises from the name given to the region: of 'Ellfionovrov rönol. Under Seleukid rule the area was xa9' 'Eil,r1on6urou oareaireia, and the called, more typically, fi öcp' 'ilJrqonövrou.s1 correspondingofficial was calledorqarrlyöEBcp' When Attalos I defeatedAntiochosHierax in HellespontinePhrygia, he named the area similarly in his dedication to Athena,ss
The New, Provinces
9l
ratherto a completechangeof authority.63In this casethe causeof the changecan only havebeenthe termsof the Romansettlement, and the war referredto in the decreein connectionwith the city's hardshipsis the Antiochic War, in which Antiochos III invaded Asia Minor and no doubt brought the city concernedunder his control, as he did with Phokaia.6a We may conclude,then, that the areasassignedto Eumenesin the Roman settlementwere, in the casesfor which we have evidence,renamedand placedunder the authority ofroyal strategoi. We turn now to consider another phenomenonattestedby the texts so far cited, the designationtopoi.The term is a familiar one in other Hellenistickingdoms,especiallyin the SeleukidKingdom 63See De Sanctis,loc. cit. (n. 54) 7l ff.; Rostovtzelf, SEHHW üi. 1472,n. 44. Holleaux,Etudes, ii. I 18ff., observedthat the expressionnapd,a6öv d npäypara and its variants refer to acquisition of authority rather than to military conquest,but did not makethe distinctionbetweentransferof commandwithin one authority and the transfer of that authority itself. ln caseswhere an existing authority passesto a new official or to a succeedingking, the predecessoror the personby whom the authority is delegatedis named;for the PtolemiesseeOGIS 55 (a decreeof Telmessos),7-9: IltolepatoE ö Auoryälgolu, napü"a6öa rlv nü,Lv napd 6aoÄöl@E llrld"epatou roü llto)"epaiou xr),., and Sy//.3 463 (a decree of Itanos), : I. Cret. iii. p. 83, no.7: Baoüeüg llrd.epaioE lnapü.a6öv td.v rtity 'ltaviov nöLo xo'i nd.haE I napä rcü natpög 6aoü.6o4 llro).tpaiou, xai röv I npoyövotv, xtL. OGIS 90 (the Rosetta Stone) refers to the date of Ptolemy (line 47) as the yeariy fir napil,aflevtilv 6aoü.eiavnap(d) Epiphanes'accession toü narpö;. For the Attalids seePolybios'referenceto the succession ofEumenes II at xxxii. 8. 3, quoted above, n. 47. Another instanceof the simpler formula usedof Korrhagos' appointmentin the decreefromBursaisprovidedbyPolyb.xxvii. l3(anexcerptofunknowncontext) with reference to Rolemy Makron, strategos of Cyprus under Rolemy VI: rapü.a6öt tilv vfioovörr,vqtiou rcü 6aot)"6agöttog. SeeBengtson,Strat. ä.216, n. 4; Walbank,Comm. äi. 3l l . We havealreadymet anotherrelevantexamplein theacquisitionof Pitaneby EumenesI asattestedby OG^|S335,line l4l (seeabove, 19,21):Eüpövqgnapd.a6öv tä npd.yfuatalxr,l. The inscriptionsfrom Labraunda supply a further examplecomparableto the position of Korrhagos in Olympichos' acquisition of authority over Mylasa (Labraunda, iii. 1., no. 8, line 13): napa).a6övt4 ydp fiv [üpetöqav nü"w) xil'. (on the liberation of Mylasa by SeleukosII see Crampa,op. cit., ch. 3). 6aSeeabove,42 andn.46 rhereiCf. Rostovtzeff.SEHHW ii. 635.On the dateof the decreefrom BursaseeDe Sanctis,loc. cit. (n. 54);Bengtson,Strat. ä. 213-17. Holleaux associatedthe decreewith later events, but eventually subscribedto De Sanctis'date(BCHliv (1930),248,n.2:cf.Etudes,ü. l16, n. 2).It shouldbenoted that l8E is the date of the nagä),ryE6 qg nü,euE, and not necessarilythat of the decree,which can be datedto any of the yearsimmediatelyfollowingthis event.
93
Attalid Kingdom after the Treaty of Apameia
The New Provinces
and in Egypt, but its rangeof meaningsand applicationsis wide.6s For the Attalid Kingdomit hasto be determinedwhetherit hasany consistentsignificationrelativeto the regionaladministrationas a whole, suchasthat of a collectionof smallareasor communitiesas distinct from cities, as in the SeleukidKingdom and in Egypt. It is found with an apparently similar connotationin lists of epheboi from Pergamon,in the heading 'from the places' (dnö ünov) which introducesgroupsof nameseachconsistingof the personal namefollowed by the patronymicand the formula tdtv änö or ix, 'of thosefrom' a namedplace.A full designationof this type would read, for example:'Apollonides,son of Athenaios,of those from DaskYlion.'oo An interestingfeature of these formulae is that they stand in placeof the more usualethnic. Thosewho are designatedforeignin other lists are namedwith the conventionaladjectival ers($6rtoL) ethnic, so that thosedzö rönov must be regardedas belongingto a different category.6TNor are the designationsin the lists of those riaö r6nav those of placesattachedby sympoliteia to another city, since we know that such placeswere designatedby a
formula including the name of the city concerned'68The topoi referred to in the ephebiclists formed a separatecategoryrepresentingcommunitiesthat were outsidecivic life, for exampleröz "A66ou 3S x6prtE. a number of reasons,however, it seemsunlikely that the For rcpoi mentionedin the ephebiclists have anythingdirectly to do with the terms usedin the Attalid namesfor Chersoneseand HellespontinePhrygia. In the first place, the lists are certainly confined in scopeof referenceto ephebesfrom the immediateareaof the city of Pergamonthat can be related to the direct authority exercisedby EumenesI. Furthermore,among the provisions of the Pergamenedecree passed after the death of Attalos III,6e people called Maoöurlvoi are included among the soldiers who were to receivethe citizenshipof Pergamon,and their home may be identified with the name Maoö{tq or Malt3q, which appears frequentlyin the ephebiclists in the formulaof thosednö rönov.7o Clearly then, the Maoöur1vo(constituteda military settlementin the immediatearea of the city, and they did not have Pergamene citizenshipin the royal period. They were in fact, as I haveargued generally, outside civic life in administrativeand constitutional terms. A further argumentmay be added. If the topoi of the ephebic lists are to be relatedto the regionaltopoi,we must expecta closer definition in the former than the simpled.nörönat, such as rizö röv rönotv röv iv Xepqovrjoor,or whateverthe casemay be. The fact that the designationis simply änö rönav reinforcesthe conclusion that it refers to a singlearea, which in the circumstances
92
6r SeeRostovtzeff, SEHHW i.561-2, iii. 1450,n. 327.On Seleukidusageseealso Bickermann,ln stitutionsdesSöleucides (Paris,1938),198,302;Bengtson, Strar. ii. 10-12,211.Rostovtzeffs and Bengtson'sview ofthe termtopoi as exactusagein the Attalid as well as the Seleukidkingdomsis disputedhere. oeThe headingdnörönon ispreservedonly in onelist, that publishedinÄM xxxv (1910),434,no. 19:dnö törav I'Aqö1tuv'Aoil,4ntdöou ütv änö - - - I'Aoil.d.now Me)"avinnouröv i[ - - - lMryvoytvqE'Aoil.4nnöouröv ix - - -. Regrettablyin this instancethe right-handedgeofthe stoneis not preserved.There are other lists of epheboiin which the namesare compiledin the sameway, and the headingdaö rönav may be restoredto them;ÄM xxxv (1910),426,no. 12,col. ii includesthe following completenames "A66ou 'Aoil.d.navoE xöpqlEl röv öE MlqtplööopoE 'Avöp LxöE'Aox).4nü.öou töv i[,' A nLaolovog dypoü 'AnoAlaviöqE'A9rlvaiou röv öy laoxuAtou 'ArdJ"6vLoE Mrlqoöbpou röv dnö Maoöü4[Sl 'Aro7\aviöqE lrcvuoocpd.voutöv öx T[pvov 'Aox71nLd.ö49 Mqvorpdvroutöv dtö Maoöü4[El nos.309-14,322,324,326-7,329,331?; OthersuchlistsareÄM xxxii (1907),440ff., AM xxxv (1910),422 ff., no. l l, col. i, lines l-9. 67For a list of f ivot seeAM xxxv (1910),422,no. I l.The headingalsooccursin a fragmentof anotherlist, AM xxxii (1907),435,no.297.
68Thus in the list cited in the previous note a man named Epikrates son of 'Ivötmtöiou. This designationhas Diodorosis designated.IrqatoumeöE töv dnö nothingto do with the formulaof thoseriaö törav, who haveno ethnicat all in the lists.Stratonikeiais soqualifiedto distinguishit from othercitiesof the samename, as L. Roberthasshown(Villes, 43-82),and so Epikratesappearsin the list of{ivor with what is an ordinarydesignationoforigin, as is clearfrom the form ofthe other 'Aqipov namesin his list (e.g. Tqlicpou Tmp4vöE). 6eOGIS 338, = tGR iv.269. 70Not with the Paphlagonian town of Mastya, as the similarity of namesonce wrongly suggested;see Magie,Roman Rule, ii. 1036,n. 8.
94
Attalid Kingdom after the Treaty of Apameia
must be that of the city of Pergamon.zlThe placesso designated included military settlementsof the kind specified above, and these are probably comparable to the katoikoi attested for PtolemaicEgypt,' and the'Macedonianfoundations'mentioned by Strabo,73but in generalterms we may envisagevillage communitiesoutsidecity life suchas that at Abboukomementionedin the lists. It may now be askedwhetherthis conclusionhelpsus to understand the nature of the designationtopoi in the Attalid regional administration.The first thing one noticesis that in this contextthe application is inconsistentand less exact, referring in the Korrhagosdecreeto a whole region and in the dedicationfollowing Attalos II's Thracian campaign to certain parts of a region.74 Indeed in the seconddocumentit is most unlikely that the term topoi implies any constitutional significance whatever, being sinceAttalos' camrathera genericdesignation meaning'places', paign took him, according to the literary evidence,to parts of Thrace,includingthe territory of King Diegylis,that were beyond the frontiersof his kingdom.TsIn the decreefrom Sestos,however, the term /opoi seems to have more exact connotations,being within the Attalid Kingdom and probably denotingknown rather than unknown areas.?6 This varyinguseof the term is consistentneitherwith Ptolemaic practice (the most likely parallel) nor with usageat the Attalid capital as arguedfrom the evidenceof the ephebiclists. When the term is used so inconsistently, we are bound to question the validity of the claim that in the Attalid provinces the topoi as attestedin the texts cited were an extensionof the local Pergamene usage.[t seemsunlikely, in the circumstances,that the wordtopoi as appliedto the provinceshad any preciseor consistentconstitu7t The implicationsof this conclusionfor the civil administrationwill be noticed below in chapter7. 72Bengtson,Strat. üi.73-5. 73SeeL. Robert,Et. anat. 193,n.2. 7aKorrhagos is called simply (lines 34) oqatryög töv xa9' 'E)Jrionovrov rönov. Attalos' dedication (OGIS 330)refers to oi xard. Xeqpövqoov xai @pdtx4v tönou rs For a review of the evidenceseeHopp, Untersuchungen,96-8. 76Seeabove,87.
The New, Provinces
95
tional significance,and it is more likely that it was a convenient genericformula for describingdifferent regionalphenomenanot preciselyexpressiblein other terms. It cannot be comparedwith the Seleukidtoparchiai in Syria, for which a specific official is In the Attalid Kingdom the only offtce associatedwith attested.TT thetopoi for which we have evidenceis that of thestrategor of the whole province. In 188BCEumenesII receiveda number of formerly Seleukid military settlements,katoikiai in another special sense of the word.78Although evidenceof the Attalid administrationof these communitiesis in generalterms extremelythin, a good exampleis to be found in the settlementof the territory of Telmessos,which passedinto Eumenes'handsalong with that city. A stonenow in the museumat Izmir preservesa letter written by EumenesII to his official Artemidoros, whose title is unfortunatelynot given. He was responsiblefor the katoikoi of the village of the Kardakesin the territory of Telmessos,who had petitionedhim on the grounds of a numberof severehardships,in particularthe inability to pay a oüvra$6, here a poll-tax of four Rhodian drachmasand one obol per head. In his letter Eumenespromisesconsiderableassistance to the community, includingthe sendingof an architectto advise on the reconstruction of dilapidated fortifications and - most important - a reductionof the poll-tax to one Rhodiandrachma and one obol. We seeEumeneshere as in the Korrhagosdecree concernedto safeguardthe welfare of the community which had appealedto him, and to ensureits prosperityby meansof positive measureswhich are probablytypical of Attalid policy as appliedto the inherited Seleukidkatoikiai.Te It is unlikely that thesecommunitieshaveany exactcorrelation with the topoi of the Attalid provincesdiscussedabove; for one thing we have seen that the term is used without any evident 77OGIS 752;Bengtson,Strat. ä.22-3. 78On the Seleukidxanomiat see Rostovtzeff,SEHHW i. 499-501; Bengtson, Strat.ä.68-9,bothofwhomcontesttheviewofBickermann,lzsr. Sö1.12tr.(cf.L. Robert,E?. anat. 19l-3) that the colonies were not military in character.Seenow G. M. Cohen, The Seleucid Colonies (Historia Einzelschr. 30, 1978). 7eThe text wasmentionedby L. Robert,Et. anat. 375, n. l, andwaspublishedby M. SegreinCl. Rhodos ix (1938),190ff. An improved text will be found in Maier, Mauerbauinschriften,i. 76 (: 566 xix. 867).
96
Attalid Kingdom after the Treaty of Apameia
consistency, and for another the former Seleukid katoikiai or military settlements were of a nature very different from the Mysian katoikiai, villages not specifically military in character, which we havefound reasonto relateto the local Pergamenetopoi mentionedin the ephebiclists. For this reasonand otherswe must not regardthe organizationofthe enlargedkingdomcreatedin 188 Bc as an extensionof the organizationof the Mysian communities formerly administeredby the dynastsand kings at Pergamon.On the contrary, it is probablethat the Attalids maintainedwithout changethe Seleukidsystemof administeringthe military katoikiai by meansof stategoi; such at least is the implicationof a dedication made by the membersof a colony near Lydian Apollonis in 15413:8o BalolüeülovrolE'AnäLou I houE E' W)qvlölE Eavötxolu)loli ix .)eoönöprcü leplxfuAilöourcü aöiov oqalr[4yo]u roüpatuMaxeö6lveE dperr1E tvexevxatil I eööt6Q1ou [rirö]q1a]ya?iaE fiE| äytatlvönteQ.leieTg rc | 1röu6aor.Al6[a xai] ölaluroüfs). It seemsprobable that the Attalids were anxious to promote the prosperity of these newly acquired communitiesby easing their financial burdens and by maintainingexisting administrative institutions, thereby disturbing as little as possible the relations of the colonists with their suzerain.In this respect the Attalids evidently did not depart from the methodsused by the Seleukids.The same seemsto be true, accordingto the limited evidence,of the Attalid administrationof the templesof the kingdom, whose rich lands rendered them an important source of revenue,as they had beenunderthe Seleukids.8lThe little that we know of the Attalids' treatmentof templelandsindicatesthat they subscribedto the methods used in other Hellenistic kingdoms. Their maintenanceof control over the administration,and in particular the financialadministration,of the templesis shownby the royal appointment of a neokoros to the temple of Artemis at Sardis,E2 and a tax-exemptionis attestedby an inscription from soAM xxiv (1E99),230,no.68; fuller textap. Keil and von Premerstein,Reise, 4 7 , n o . 9 5 .C f . B e n g t s o nS, t r a t .ü . 2 0 7 . srFor the continuity of temple administrationsee Jones,Greek City, 42 ff; Rostovtzeff, SEHHW ii. 648-9 (with the reservation expressedbelow, n. 84). 82Appendixiv, no. 5, lines7-1 l: ö 6aoü"eüE . . . xaröm4o* vetoxöpovtfiE0eo6.
The New Provinces
97
Soma in the upper Kaikos valley recording a letter written by Attalos II during Eumenes'reign to the katoikoi of Apollo Tarsenos.E3Most important, the Attalids maintainedthe policy known for other Hellenisticmonarchiesof assigninglandto templesin the kingdom, as I believeis shownby an inscriptionof Hadrianicdate from Aizanoi in Phrygia.Ea It may be useful at this point to summarizewhat has been said' We have evidently to assignthe institutions and proceduresof Attalid rule after 188 sc to various precedents.It seemslikely, from the disappearancein Attalid recordsof the designationsatrapeia, previouslyappliedby the Seleukidsin Asia Minor, that the Seleukid satrapal system was replaced by a different and less closely defined system. Within this framework, however, a number of detailed administrative institutions were retained from the Seleukidorganization,particularlyin areassuchasthe military settlementswhose tradition of allegianceto the Seleukidscould not be ignored,andthe temple-landswhich hadalwayspreserveda semblanceof independence,where it will have been in the Attalids'interest to renderthe changeofsuzeraintyas inconsequential as possible.Finally, it needsto be emphasizedthat the Attalid administrationafter 188 sc was not simply an extensionof the administrationappliedhitherto in the smallareaof directauthority aboutPergamon,and thereis no evidencefor supposingthat it was basedon or evengreatlyinfluencedby Rolemaic practice.Thereis no significancein the designationtopoi since this was in Attalid usagea vague and inconsistentterm appliedto provincesand to areas byond them, and it does not seem to have had for the 83Welles,RC 47. Boehringer'sattempt(AvP ix.92) to ascribethe authorshipof this letter to Attalos I before his assumptionofthe royal title has beenconvincingly refuted by Kähler, Gr. Fries lE2. On tax-exemption in the Hellenistic period see Holleaux.Etudes. ü. ll2-13. aaThe inscription(Bull.Mus. Imp. Rom. lxvi (193E),44-8,= E. M. Smallwood, Doc. Ill. Principates ofNerva, Trajan and Hadrian, 165,no.454) referstofines lovi cfrea?ftoriet civitati Aezanitarumdatos lalb Attalo et Prusia regibus.The kings are most probably Attalos I and husias l: seeT.R.S. Broughtonin Studies.. in honor of A.C. Johnson,236-5O;Habicht,Hermes, lxxxiv (1956),93 ff. Compare the Seleukid donation of land attested,by OGIS 262. This evidence cannotjustify the view of Rostovtzeff, SEHHW ii. 6,f8, that the king could seize temple land or income, or his statement,'at Aezani in Phrygia the kings, both Seleucidand Attalid, exercisedthe rightofpartial confiscation.' Seethe importantremarksof Jones,Greek City, 309-10, n. 58; Broughton,loc. cit.
Attalid Kingdom after the Treaty of Apameia
The Greek Cities
Attalids the specificconnotationswhich it had for the Ptolemies and the Seleukids.The positiveconclusionto be drawn is that the Attalids' methodsof rule as implementedafter 188Bc drew on a wide rangeof Hellenisticinstitutionsandweredetermined,aswith the Attalids generally,by expedienceand opportunism,not being basedexclusively or even predominantlyon any one system of administration.
the war is unknown, but its nameappears,not aspart of the Attalid Kingdom, but as a fully sovereigncity and entitled to compensation from Prusias,in the ouv9fizd, concludedbetweenAttalos II and Prusias II of Bithynia in 154, together with Methymna, Herakleia, and Kyme, cities certainly independentat the time.eo Other cities, subjectto the King of Pergamonand known to have been attackedby Prusias,such as Elaia, Thyateira,and Temnos, do not appear separatelyin the freaty; so we may infer that Aigai, once an Attalid subject, had its independencerestored in 188, presumably on the basis of its behaviour during the war with Antiochos.er This principlewas evidently subjectto exceptions.Magnesiaon the Maeandersurrenderedto Rome at the sametime as Ephesos and Tralles, but unlike thesetwo it was privilegedby the Scipios and remained an independentcity outside Attalid jurisdiction, evidently maintainingon its own account friendly relationswith Teos, a tributary city after 188,as we shall see.e2This caseis not likely, however, to have been an exceptionin principle, because the treatment afforded to Magnesiadependedon the personal authority of the Scipiosand not on senatorialpolicy generally. The treaty also stipulated,as we saw in the previouschapter, that cities which had paid o6vraf6 to Attalos I shouldhenceforward pay cp6eoEto Eumenes. It is clear then that the Roman settlementwas more careful in its treatmentof the Greek cities than in its apparently wholesale allocation of entire provinces. Although the Chersonesewas assignedto Eumenesand became part of an Attalid province, someof its cities remainedindepen-
98
(ii) The Greek Cities Accordingto the literary evidence,the statusof eachGreekcity in 188depended,at least as far as the paymentof tribute was concerned, on its record during the war with Antiochos, and this principlecan usuallybe seento haveappliedin individualcases.ss Miletos co-operatedwith a Romanfleet operatingin the areaof the city in 190;in 188its sovereigntywas respectedto the extent that its sacredlands, evacuatedduring the war, were restoredin full, and later Miletos concluded a private treaty with Herakleia.s6 Thus in theory Miletos, pro-Romanduring the war, was left independentafterwards.Ephesos,on the other hand,surrenderedonly after the defeatof Antiochosat Magnesia,andwasone of the'gifts' grantedto EumenesII by the Romansettlement.sT Tralles surrendered at the sametime and sufferedthe samefate.88For Telmessos, another 'gift' city, the evidence is less clear, but Seleukid sympathiesare suggested by its coinageandits useof the Seleukid era at a later date, and it seemslikely that it too assistedAntiochos in the war with Rome.Ee There is evidencemoreoverthat subjectcities of the old kingdom of EumenesI and Attalos I becameindependentif they had earnedthe right. Aigai is a casein point: this city's record during 85Polyb.xxi.46. 2-3; Livy xxxviii. 39.7-8; xxxvii. 53.2E.Seethe valuablestudy of Bickermann,REG i (1937),217-39;Schmitt, ()ntersuchungez,278-85; Walbarrk,Comm. iii ad loc; Pr€aux,Monde hell. i. 16l-3. s6Livyxxxvii. 16.2;17.3;Polyb.xxi.46.5.ThetreatywithHerakleia:Sy//.3633. Miletos and Herakleia evidently passedunder Rhodian influence for a time; the treaty they concluded establishedthe principle that neither should do anything ünevavrloy tfit npöE'Poöioug ouppayiat (line)S).ThisouppaTla is not otherwise attested (see Fraser and Bean, Rhodian Peraea, 109). s.TEphesos' surrender:Livy xxxvii.45. l. t6 Ephesosand Trallesas gift cities: Polyb. xxi. 46. 10. 8eSeeMagie,RomanRule, ä.762.
D
soPolyb. xxxiii. | 3. 8. Methymnalater enteredinto privatediplomaticrelations with Rome(Syt/.r693).Kyme wasfreedof tributeobligationsin 188(Polyb.xxi. 46. 4). We have good evidencefor the autonomyof Herakleiaafter 188:Sy//.3618 recordsa letter of Cn. Manlius Vulso (on the identificationseen. I in Syllogead loc.) to the city in 188confirmingits autonomy.As we haveseen(n. 86above),the city concluded a treaty with Miletos which attests its membershipof a Rhodian ouppayia. er For the evidenceof Aigai's coinage,seebelow, I I l. e2Tacitus,Änn. äi.62:proximi hosMagnetesL. Scipioniset L. Sullaeconstitutis nitebantur: quorum ille Antiocho hic Mithridate pulsisfidem atque virtutem Magnetum decoravere, uti Dianae Leucophrynae perfugiam inviolabile foret. The sovereigrrtyof Magnesiais reflected in documentsrelatingto the city's disputewith hiene, in which Mylasa was the arbitrator (IvM 93, = Syl/.3 679). Relationswith 'leos'. IvM 97.
100
The Greek Cities
Attalid Kingdom after the Treaty of Apameia
dent and were listed as aörovoltoup|uot in the peaceconcluded between Eumenes II and Pharnakes of Pontos in 179.e3 Lysimacheia,however,was specificallygiven to Eumenesin 188, alongwith the Chersoneseand tä. npooopoüvratoüroLgBqüpara xai yitpav, and Diodoros refers to the city as being subject to Attalos II.ea We havenow seenthat four cities were assignedto Eumenesas gifts in 188:Ephesos,Tralles,Telmessos,and Lysimacheia.To these we should perhaps add Magnesia ad Sipylum, which is similarlydesignatedby Livy.e5It shouldbe admittedimmediately that if we did not havethis specificevidenceaboutthe gift citieswe would not easily discernfrom other sourcesany major diffefence in status from other cities which passedin varying degreesof subjectionunder Attalid control, and it is unlikely that the designation as 'gifts' which Polybiosrecordshad any preciseconstitutional implications.There is no literary record of oppressionas there is in the caseof the Rhodiantreatmentof the Lycian cities, also categorizedas gifts in 188;e6even Rhodianpropagandadirected againstEumenesdid not touch on this subject. It is unlikely, then, that the Senateintendedany particularstatus by the title 'gifts', andit would be unprofitableto look for one in the epigraphicalevidence.We now know that after 188nc Ephesos wasthe centreof an administrativeregionandthe seatof a regional strqtegos.A gymnasialdedicationattestsEumenes'interestin the gymnasium,a policy applied by the Attalids to Greek cities of whateverstatus,notably Miletos.eTEumeneswas a benefactorat Ephesosand at Miletos, and we shallconsiderlater the possibility that, despiteor perhapsbecauseof their differentstatus,thesetwo sr Polyb.xxv. 2. 13. grPolyb.xxi.46.9; Diod. xxxiii. 14.2. ei Livy xxxvii. 56.3: et nominatimMagnesiamad Sipylum. e6Theambiguity of Rome's definition of the statusof Lyciaand the subsequent dispute with Rhodes on this question of course obscure the issue (seeFraser and Bean, Rhodian Peraea, lll fr.), but I am concernedhere with Polybios'ter'PoötotEyaprlöpevot minology as applied to the original ruling (xxii. 5. 4): totg öö npootwrpav tv öapeQ.rcüE Auxbug e7Appendixiv, no. 25;J. Keil,Wien. Anz. xxii (1951),331-6,no. I, = SEG xvii. 510:f'Egpeil'Hgail,ei xai flaohei Eöp4ver.For the restoration l'Eppei] seeJ. and L. Robert, BulI. lxvi (1953), 169, no. 178. See in general Pr€aux, Monde hell. i. 265-4.
101
cities competedfor royal favour. It is enoughhere to confirm that there is no evidencethat Ephesoswas treatedspeciallyin internal constitutionalterms after 188sc. Telmessosis the first city known to havecalledEumenesSoter; this was done in a decree of 184 nc passed in gratitude for Eumenes' defenceof Asia Minor againstPrusias,the Galatians, and other enemies.esClearly, however, this kind of spontaneous honouring of the saviour king is a feature of Greek civic life irrespectiveofconstitutional status,and thereforehas no special sigrrificancein the case of Telmessos.ee We pass to Tralles. There is evidence, lacking for the other cities, that Tralles was a royal residenceof the Attalids: both Vitruvius and Pliny refer to a royal palacein the city.t00A decree of Tralles honouring a judge from Phokaia refers to ltouotxoi &yöueEcelebratedat Tralles in honour of EumenesII, but such activity again is not necessarilyto be associatedwith subject StatUS.l0l
In the caseof Lysimacheiaevidenceis lacking,but that already adducedis enoughto demonstratethat an enquiry which setsout 'free' merely to determinewhich cities were 'subject' and which after 188sc will be misleadingin the way that definingstatusfor the cities under Attalos I was seento be misleading.tozThere is also the difüculty that the literary accountsof the Roman settlement, and very probably the Roman settlementitself, did not set out to explore the connotationsof a city's status.The accountsin Polybios' and Livy's narrativesare (at times on their own admis[n sion)selective,and dwell in particularon the issueof tribute.103 e8Appendix iv, no. 7. eeSeebelow, ch. 6. rooVitruvius ä. 8. 9: Trallibusdomus regibusAttalicisfacta; Pliny, Nat. ÄIisl. xxxv. 49: domum Trallibus regiam Attali. ror Seebelow,ch. 6, and Appendixiv, no. 6, lines lG-l 1. Othercities,apartfrom those discussedin this and the previous chapter, known to have been subject at sometime to the Attalids are Priapos(Straboxiii. l. 14,58E),Skepsis(Straboxiii. l. 54, ffi), Nakrasa (if OGIS 268 emanatesfrom there: see Robert, Villes, 36, n. 6), and Phrygian Apameia, where an ephebic cult of Eumenes II and Attalos II is attested (MAMAvi. 173:.J. and L. Robert, Bull. 1939,no. ulü)); the evidence of Apameia's coinage is discussedlater in this chapter. ro2Seeabove, ch. 3 (i). r03Seee.g. Livy xxxviii. 39.7: civitatium autem cognitiscausisdecemlegati aliam aliarumfecerunt condicionem. On tribute as a mark of subjectionseeJones, Greek City, 102-12; Pr€aux, Monde hell. ü. 438.
r02
Attalid Kingdom after the Treaty of Apameia
consideringall the evidence,literary, epigraphical,and numismatic, our analysismust seekto determinehow statusaffectedcivic life and prosperity, how it restrictedindependenceand freedom, and how it was regardedby the Attalids, in whose hands it was placedby the will of the Roman Senate. A high degreeof subjectionto the Attalids entailedby tributary status after 188 has been allegedon the premiss that the kings could, and did, demandadditionalpaymentswhen they required them, apart from the regular q6eoE, but on closer analysisthis premissdissolvesinto nothing.t04The Pisidiancity of Amladawas required to pay a #).eopa as well as gdqog during the major Galatianwar of EumenesII in the 160s,accordingto a letter of his brother Attalos to the city on the subject.r05The statusof Amlada in relation to the Attalids is quite unclear,but this letter seemsto dealwith conditionsimposedby the circumstancesof war (suchas the takingof hostages)ratherthan with an episodein the contextof continuousAttalid rule.r06 r04SeeRostovtzetr,SEHHW iii. 1475,n. 55. roi Appendix iv, no. 23. On telesma,see Welles, RC' p. 369. 106Information on the status of Amlada is derived from a group of documents dealing with wartime conditions (Swoboda, Keil, and Kroll, Denkmöler aus Lykaonien,nos. 74-5; Appendixiv, nos. 22-3);see now in generalHopp,Untersuchungen,70-4, and on the chronology,7 l, n.80. The documentsare: I. The enc of a letter whose authorshipis unclear; II. A letter (OGIS 751; Welles,RC 54) headed'Aud'oE'Ap].aö6ov rfir nö),et xai rctg ytparctE; III. A badly preservec "Attalog 'Ap).aö6av rlfit nü,et xai rfolg yepanlEl. Of letter, headed f6aoü"eüg these three letters, only the last can be dated firmly to a specific reign, from a referencein it to Eumenes'sonAttalos, the future Attalos III (lines'+-5)' The writer of this letter is therefore Attalos II; letter II, the most important, was written by Attalos before his accession,and the events referred to in the letter, including the remissionof Amlada's paymentsto the king, may be associatedwith the waxof this king involving the Pisidiancity of Selge,attestedby thePrologue to Trogus xxxiv: ut mortuo regeAsiae EumenesuffectusAttalus bellum cum Selegensibushabuit et cumregePrusia.The recentdeathof EumenesII, andtheproximity ofthe warwith Prusias,which broke out about 154,place the war with Selgein the l50s' not long after the accessionofAttalos ll. It is thereforeclear that Amlada was heavily taxed during this war, but it cannot be assumed that these circumstancesapplied in peacetime conditions (contra Hopp, 70). The fact that, according to letter II' Amlada paid yearly tribute, establishesthe city's subjectstatusat thattime, but this statusmay have arisenfrom the city'sbehaviourin the waras well as fromany other definite cause;there is, furthermore, no specificevidencethat the Attalids received Amlada in lE8 sc. Whatever the case, it is clear that the conditions attested for Amlada, a frontier-city necessarily involved in the continual bouts of warfare undertakenby the Attalid kings in the area (cf. Meyer, Die Grenzen, 154;Welles' RC 54 ad loc.), cannot be regardedas typical of the Attalids' treatment of other tributary cities, whose circumstanceswere different.
The Greek Cities
r03
An inscription from Sardis to be dated to the early second century Bc records remissionsof tribute and other concessions allowed to a city of whose name only the initial T has been preserved on the stone;tozit includes the provision (lines 16-19): ld lzö öä roü öyööou hou Eöö övar rqe[iE ävacpopd.g) | lix] nao 6u röv ytvoptvav npooööav na[p' Examov] | ivmuröv dpyufp]iou pvdg eixoog xo,i ä)J.lary pl övlloy).eio0at.eivfatl öä aörcüE of this document älqpouqrjclouElxü... . . The toneand language somewhat reminiscent the Attalid are of chancery,but no proof whatever is attainablein the present state of the text. The city concernedmay havebeenTemnos,asthe editorsofthe inscription suggested,and the circumstancesthe sameas thoseof the decree for Korrhagos, namely the aftermath of the Antiochic War, but many such contexts may be adducedwith no lessplausibility. In short, none of the evidenceusually cited indicatesAttalid policy with regard to taxation in general terms and in normal circumstances. The city for which we have the clearestevidenceas regards statusas a tribute-payingcity after 188sc is Teos. We know that Teos paid a considerableoüwa$6 to Attalos I, as we saw in the previouschapter,and accordingto the termsof the RomansettleA letter written by ment it should have paid qöeoE thereafter.10E EumenesII to the Ionian Guild of Dionysiantöchnitci,whoseseat was then at Teos, tells us a good deal about the relationship betweenthe king and the city.toeFragmentarythoughthe letter is, it is very probable that Teos, like the Guild, could be bound by royal prostagmata and that by this meansa settlementcould be imposed on the city concerningits dispute with the Dionysian to?Sardis vii. l, no. 2. rosBefore the discovery ofthe decreehonouringAntiochos III and Laodike (see above,ch. 3, n. 64),there was no specificevidencethat Teoswas a tributary Attalid city after 188.Its subject statuswas inferred by Cardinali (RP 94)from (i) the city's allegianceto Antiochos during the war with Rome (cf. Livy xxxvii. 27-8), and (ii) the direct treatment afrorded to Teos by Eumenes II in its dispute with the Dionysian technitai (see below). The fact that Teos interceded at Rome for its daughter-cityAbderain 167(Syl/.r656)is regardedby Magie,RomanRule, ä.959, and Walbank, Comm. äi.167-8, as evidencethat Teos was then independent,but this approach is too dogmatic; it is quite feasible that a Greek city could send an embassyto Rome while being tributary to a king, especially in the special circumstancesrelating to the question of Abdera. toelvp 163,: Welles,RC 53.
104
The Greek Cities
Attalid Kingdom after the Treaty of Apameia
technitai.tr0 The samemachineryis known to have been used in the context of Attalid rule in Aigina, a possessionof the King of Pergamon,rll and a decisionof Attalos III concerningthe important priesthoodof Dionysos Kathegemonat Pergamonwas also communicatedas a prostagma, as recorded in Attalos' letter to The word wasused,as is Kyzikoson the subject,dated13596. 112 well known, of royal decisions,and sometimesof the decisionsof subordinateofficials, in other Hellenistickingdoms.r!3It is clear from the constitutionalterms employed in the surviving correspondencethat Eumeneswas more than just an arbitrator in the dispute betweenthe city and the Guild of lechnitai, becausethe embassyof the Guild, to which referenceis made, envisageda settlementimposedby the king if it provedto be necessary:rraei öi pi1öö6lvar oürag \trtaurövönaryeiEöfuövonlv änoxaralor4oag, 6$atlöE üpiv eiEröv ).omlöy yqövov lltd eTiEeifqqvilvxai eüvo' usedofroyal decisions, ptav ouvre[vovra- - - -]. The expressions all introduced by either xpiva or ünd,ap6dva, determine the extentof royal authorityimpliedin the settlement.rr5 According to a decreeof Teos honouringa citizen of Magnesia on the Maeander,the strategoiof Teos had a constitutionalfunction similar to their counterparts at Pergamon; the prescript readsrr6 tqtptl16atv xai orpatqydtu yvtit1t4.We have already noticed a similar procedureat Pitane and Phokaia,and to these instanceswe may add from the Attalid Kingdom the cities of rroFränkel restored IvP 163. C,7-8 x[aü. tä ööypallta töp 6aoÄ6tov, but Holleaux's restoration lEtudes, iii. 205) xlard. rä. npootdypa)lta was adopted by Welles, and is followed here. ttt OGIS 329, 14_15. tt2IvP 248, : OGIS 331. III, 4l-3, = Welles, RC 66, 16-18' r f 3 S e e t h e v a l u a b l e a n a l y s i so f H o l l e a u x . E t u d e s , i i i . 2 0 5 - l l . F o r t h e R o l e m i e s see also M. - Th. Lenger,Corpus des ordonnances des Ptolömles (Brussels' 1964)' and in general, Pr6aux, Monde hell. i.272-3, ii. 599-601. rra Welles. RC 53 I.A. lines 6-9. r 1 5S e e , i n t h e t e x t , I L C , l i n e 1 5 ; I I I . B , l i n e 8 , C , l i n e 9 ; I V . C , l i n e 1 2 . C o m p a r e the case of Hierocaesar€a and Thyateira, whose dispute was settled regis [con]stitutionibus (Keil-von Premerstein, Zweite Reise, 13, no. l8). A letter written to Priene concerning a settlement between that city and Miletos UvPr 27, : Welles, RC 46) is,I believe, a document of Roman rule and not the letterof an Attalid, and in any event the text is too fragmentary to allow conclusions concerning constitutional prodecure. tt6IvM 97.3047.
105
PhrygianHierapolis,Sardis,Tralles,Magnesiaad Sipylum,and an unnamed city replying to a communicationof Magnesiaon the Maeander.rlTThis constitutionalmachineryis lessfrequently attestedoutsidethe Attalid Kingdom;1tEmore significantly,it forms a part of the constitutionof the city of Pergamonfrom the beginning of the Attalid dynasty, as Pergamenedecreesfrom the early third century onwards attest.rle We are therefore led to ask whetherthis stateof affairs entitlesus to believethat the kings of Pergamondeterminedor interferedin any way with the constitutionsoftributary and subjectcities.The frequentoccurrenceofthe constitutionalmachinery whereby the strategoi introducedmatters for considerationto the popular assembly,notably at Teos which we know was a tributary city after 188,is the soleindication that it reflects Attalid policy in general terms. The only other evidencethat canbe adducedrelatesto a singlecity. A decreefrom Bakir (ancientNakrasa),but not necessarilyof that preciseprove'Artd.),ou, nance, dated6aoü'eüowoE ngcbroulöroug, and therefore issued by a city of the Attalid Kingdom, honours a certain 'AnüJ,cbvrcE MeAeälypouönrcrdrqg.r20The term Enrcrö.rqEis well attestedin the Hellenisticperiodasa governingmagistratein a subjectcity, tzt and in the Attalid Kingdomit was usedof Kleon's office at Aigina;122in the presentcasethere can be no doubt that rr7 Hierapolis:OGIS 308;Sardis:Appendixiv, no. 5, lines 1-2; Tralles:B.SAxxix (1927-8),68-71;Magnesia: AM xxiv (1899),411;the unnamedcity: IvM 87,:
ocrs 319. tt8Notably at Priene under Lysimachos (OGIS ll), and at Smyrna under Seleukos ll @GIS 229\. ile See below, 165n. 23. t2oOGIS 268; cf. Robert,Villes, 36, n. 6. The decree is dated by Robert, followed by Bengtson, Strat. ä.248, to the reign ofAttalos II or III, on the premiss (as yet not argued in full) thatthe basileia mentioned in line 6 honoured Zeus Basileios and not the kingship of Attalos I, as Wilcken, RE, s.v. Attalos (9), 2159, and Meyer, Die Grenzen, 98, thought. The issue in my view remains open: Attalos I did not fall short ofdivine honours elsewhere (see ch. 6), and we find a parallel to the royal basileia in the Baoilcn at Alexandria (P. M. Fraser, Ptol. Alexandria, ü. 382, n. 341). f2r See Holleaux, Etudes, äi. 217-19, and his list, 253-4, supplemented by Robert, Hellenica, vü, p.22; Bengtson, Strat. passim. On the Seleukid epistates , r6aux, s e e a l s o W e l l e s , R C ,p . 1 8 7 , n . 3 , l 8 S , n . 4 , a n d o n t h e P t o l e m a i c e p i s t a t e s P Monde hell. ü. 419-20. One example of the office is knowlr from Bithynia: L. Robert, Et. anat.228-35; cf. Bengtson, Strat. ü.245; Rostovtzeff,SEHHW üi. 1 4 8 1 .n . 7 5 . F o r t h e R h o d i a n e p i s t a t a i o f t h e P e r a e a . s e e H o l l e a u x , E r u d e s , i . 409-17; Fraser and Bean, Rhodian Peraea, 86-94. t22OGIS 329,34-5, with Dittenberger's n. 19.
106
Attalid Kingdom after the Treaty of Apameia
Apollonios*as"pistotrs of the city which passedthe decreein his honour. If, as seems likely, the stone came from a city near Nakrasa,suchas Akrasosor Stratonikeia,the city concernedwas situatedin the area of direct authority establishedby EumenesI and exploitedby his successor,and we know that the areaaround Thyateira,includingNakrasaand the upper Kaikos valley, was in Attalid hands some years before the Roman settlement,in fact alreadyduringthe reignof Attalos I.123Aigina alsowas an acquisition of Attalos I, and it is therefore very likely that the office of epistateswas introducedinto subjectcitiesby this king ratherthan EumenesIL The decree also refers to another office previously held by Apollonios: x ai ng & elqot öö orp arqyöEq Enö7ea4x ar aor a0 ei E. This constitutesthe only indicationof the methodof appointment of the civicstrategoi in the Attalid Kingdom outsidethe capital;as such it is tantalizingly vague, but two parallelscan be cited in determiningthe significanceof the verb xaraora9eig used of the appointment.The sameword is usedof EumenesI's appointment of the Pergamenestrategoi,r24and in a Megarian decree of the appointmentof Hikesiosof Ephesosat Aiginaby EumenesII. t25It seemslikely, then, that Apollonios' office was a royal appointment, althoughthis is not specificallystated,aswas his later offrce of epistates.126 In the light of this evidence we have reasonablegrounds for believing that the King of Pergamonappointed epistatai and strategoiin the subjectcities; that, in other words, he interferedin and perhapsrestrictedthe constitutionalfunctionsof thesecities. This doesnot necessarilymeanhoweverthat the constitutionsasa whole were similarly determined,sincethe king could have made use of existinginstitutions, as he did perhapsat Pergamonitself, but it is possiblethat he favouredthe type of constitutionfound at Pergamon and encouragedcities within his kingdom to adopt it At this point then, we may usefullyconsidertheexactnatureofthe r23Robert, Villes, 3140. t24OGIS 267. lI, l-2: oi xataota0öweg ün' Eitptvoug oqatqyoi. t2sSyll.t 642:'ö xataota9eiE En' AiytvaE önlö rci 6aop).6o9Eipiuoug. Seemy remarksin.BSl{ lxvi (1971),34. r26SeeBengtson,Strat. ü.248-9.
The Greek Cities
10?
office of strategos in Greek cities that were subject to Attalid authority. In Attalid usagethe term strategos connotesone of two civil offices: either a regionalgovernor, suchas Korrhagosand Demetrios, or a member of a collegiateboard, as at Pergamonand the other cities already mentioned. It is never clearly attestedin a military sense.The copious body of inscriptionswhich provide informationconcerningthe organizationof the Attalid army attests no military offrcehigherthan that of f7yep6v,whetherreferringto a garrison or to an army in the field. In the decreesfrom Delphi honouringthe membersof a garrisonput into the town of Lilaiaby Attalos I, their ranks are designated as oi otqartörat xai and the sameformula is used with referenceto the fiyep6veg,t27 armiesat Philetaireiaand Attaleia under EumenesI,124and with referenceto an Attalid force at Aigina in the time of Attalos I. t zs All this is in strikingcontrastto Seleukidand Ptolemaictitulatures, in which the military strqtegos is separatelydesignated.l30 We may concludethen that in the Attalid Kingdom the ofüce of strqtegoswas civil (in two senses)and not military.13rIt may be thought significant that Livy's Corragus,praefectus Eumenis, whom we have identified with the strategos Korrhagos,fought with Manlius againstthe Galatiansin 189,but even he was subordinatein the commandof the Attalid contingentto a memberof the royal family, Athenaios,r32and the fact that Corragus(Korrhagos) r21F. Delphes, äi. 4. 132-5:part of 133 is now convenientlyreproducedin Moretti, lSE ii, no. 8l ; note there the typical formulasof orp att'tinat xai äyepöveg oi perd @paolupdToul andröv t @qaoüpalov xai tolülE perd aütoö otpatubtag xai fiyepöveg. t2EIvp 13, : OGIS 266, 19-20:IlapäpovoE xai oi f1yepövegxai oi ü9' aötoüg mparuittau t2eEph. Arch. l9l!, 90*2, = Moretti, ISE i, no. 36. I have reproduced and discussedthe text of this small round red-painted altar in B.lA l x v i ( 1 9 7 1 ) , 4 - 5 (photoSraph,pl. 2). See also fvP 29, : OGIS 280. rro SeeOGIS 217, = Welles,RC 39 (cf. Wilhelm, Wien.Anz. lvii (1920)'40-2). 13tThe application ofthe terrr,;, strategia to the mercenarybody in Philetaireiain the documentrecordingthe settlementwith EurnenesI (ch. 2, n. 47)doesnot in my view necessarilymeanthat their commander,Paramonos,wps calledsrrategos,as Bengtson,Strat. ü. 198 ff., argues.The significanceof the titulature of Philopoimen,oqat4yög xai öni qE ogpaytöoEunder Attalos II (see below, 132)is unclear(Bengtson,loc. cit.). r32Livy xlii. 67. 4.
108
Attalid Kingdom after the Treaty of Apameia
was a regional strategos does not have a direct bearing on his military office in the field. In fact this instanceis typical of Attalid practice: the largely mercenary armies were invariably commanded,at least in the more important campaignsfor which we haveevidence,by the king or a near relativeof the king, and in the caseof EumenesII, very often by one of his brothers. This analysisdeterminesthe nature of the office held by Apollonios, as attested by the decree from Bakir, orparrlyöE rqE nöAeog.The possibilitythat he wasa military governorin chargeof a garrisoncan be discounted.Sincehe is calledstrategos'of the city', the collegiatecivic magistracycommonin citiesof the Attalid Kingdom alone remains in question. We have found reason to believethat he was appointedto this office by the king, a practice likely to be repeated in other cities of the kingdom, for which evidenceis lacking. On the other hand we have found no cogent evidenceto suggestthat the office itself, let alonethe constitution as a whole, was of the king's designor imposition;sincethe office was,aswe haveseen,a civic oneanda typicalGreekoneat that,it seemsreasonableto think that the king made use of an existing institution in order to establisha personalcontrol over the constitutional features of the cities concerned,as he did at Pergamon. 133
The widespreadappointmentof royal officials in cities is attested by an excerpt from Diodoros' history which refers to the hostileattitudeof Attalos III to officialsof his father'sreign:134 uitv öö ä)")"arycpü"tttvröv ön' Efouoiq. orparruttCoufi nöTetttvr€rayptuav oüE trtiv ööd"oqövr1otv,oüE öi ouAAadöu navorubuE dveü,e.The construction of the sentencesuggestsa generaldescriptionof oflicials ratherthanthe designationof a specificoffice, ö öni nöLeutE,sincein fact Diodoros' expressionis oi ön' ö(ouoig. . . . n6).eav,anda comparisonwith the offrcecalledti öni nd)"eogat Pergamoncan carry little weight.r3sIt seemsmore plausibleto regardDiodoros' descriptionas embracingthe titles strategosand r33Seebelow, ch- 7. ß4 xxxiv. 3. t35Seebelow,l7l-2.
The Greek Cities
109
epistatesattestedby the epigraphicalevidencewe have beenconsidering. We may conclude,then, that tributary citiesof the Attalid Kingdom enjoyedfreedomin the matter of constitutionalform, but that it was a freedomlimited by the king's appointmentof strategoi and epistatai. The evidenceof the king's power to issueprostagmatq in the caseof Teos further indicatesthe statusof a tributary city, sincethe king could certainlytreat one suchcity on the sameterms as another.Theselimitationsapart, all our evidencesuggeststhat the tributary cities continuedto leadan independentcivic life, and no evidenceof the impositionof garrisonsor military governorsin normal circumstanceshas come down to us. We have seenthat the main burden imposedon thesecities was the obligationto pay tribute, and it is in theseterms that they are designatedin the accountswe haveof the Romansettlementof 188 Bc. It was doubtless this obligation more than any other that determineda city's relationshipto the king at Pergamon.With this considerationwe may associatein part the Attalids' concern to influence probouleutic functions by virtue of their personalappointment of strategoi, becauseone important aspect of these functions was the administrationof finances, at Pergamonand elsewhere.r36A further line of enquiry in this regardmay be found in the cities' coinage,which hasundergonea thoroughre-examination in recentyears.l37 It has now been establishedthat cities independentof the Attalids after 188began or continued to issue gold coins or tetrat 3 6S e e b e l o w , 1 6 7 _ 8 . rr7 The groundwork on these coins was done by F. Imhoof-Blumer,Die Münzen, 28-35. and H. von Fritze,Die Münzen von Pergamon; these studies established a stylistic sequence for the coins. Important among recent works are: E. S. G' Robinson, Nunr . Chron. xiv (1954), 1-7; U. Westermark,Das Bildnis, who argued that the old dynastic coinage bearing the head of Philetairos ended in 190; D' Kienast, Jahrb. für Numismatik und Geldgesch. xi (1961)' 159 ff.' with bibliogr a p h y , 1 6 3 - 8 6 ; R o b e r t , V i l l e s , 2 5 2 f f . ; H . S e y r i g ' R e v . N u m . v ( 1 9 6 3 ) ' 1 9f f . F o r a summary of discussion on this question see now F. S. Kleiner and S. P. Noe, T/re Early Cistophoric Coinage (American Numismatic Society, Numismatic Studies xiv. 1977); A. Giovannini, Rome et Ia circulation monetaire en Grice au IIe siöcle av. Jösus-Christ (Schv'eiz. Beitr. zur Altertumswiss. l5' 1978).
110
The Greek Cities
Attalid Kingdom after the Treaty of Apameia
drachmsin their own right,138whereasno independentcoinageis attestedfor cities known to have been tributary to the Attalids. Many of thesetributary cities issueda new coin, the cistophoros, which was mintedinitially at Pergamon,Ephesos,andTralles,on a different standardfrom that of the Attic tetradrachm,and which, as we shall see, was most probably introducedas the exclusive coinageof the kingdom in 188 Bc. This cistophoric coinagewas limited to cities known to havebeen tributary to the Attalids after 188sc, andrecentnumismaticresearchhasindicatedits statusasa royal coinage minted at Attalid cities, the chief mint being at Pergamon,which providedalso for the issuesof Synnada,Sardis, and Apameia.r3e The consistentpatternof the coinagesof the Greekcitiesof Asia Minor after the Romansettlementis clearfrom the followingtable, which lists the issuesof twenty-sevencitieswhosestatusin known from literary or epigraphicalevidence: City Alabanda AlexandriaTroas Colophon Nova Ephesos Herakleia by Latmos Ilion Kibyra Kos Kyme Kyzikos Lampsakos Magnesiaon theMaeander Magnesiaad Sipylum
Status independent independent independent gift city
Coinage independent independent independent cistophoric
independent independent independent independent independent independent independent
independent independent independent independent independent independent independent
independent independenl gift city no independent (Livy; coinage
lrt Seyrig,l9; seealsothe tablebelow. Someofthesecitiesareofspecialinterest in view of their previousrelationswith Pergamon,notably Kyzikos, l-ampsakos, Ilion, the Kolophoniansof Notion, Alexandria Troas, and Smyrna (see ch. 3 above).Note that Kyme and the Kolophoniansof Notion were specificallyfreed of the obligationto pay tribute in 188(Polyb. xxi. 46. 4). For relationsbetweenIlion and the Attalids, see Welles,RC 62 (as interpretedby Robert, BC^taliv (1930), 348-51; Op. Minora Selectai. 167-70),a royal letter written probablyby Attalos II; it refersto a purchaseof landby the king from the templeofAthena at llion, and to previous benefactionsof oxen and drivers (compare the sending of artists to Delphi by Attalos II (Syll.3 682; Datx, Delphes, 509) and of an architect to the katoikoi in the territory ofTelmessosby EumenesII (above,95). r3eSeyrig,27-2. As Seyrigshows,the singlecistopftorosof Smyrnais of a later date, and was clearly a specialissue.
Miletos Myndos Mytilene Priapos Rhodes Sardis Skepsis Smyrna Telmessos Temnos Tenedos Teos Thyateira Tralles
IlI
independent independent independent no independent coinage independent independent cistophoric tributary no indePendent tributary coinage independent independent gift city no independent coinage no independent tributary coinage independent independent no independent tributary coinage cistophoric tributary gift city cistophoric
independent independent independent tributary
It seemsfrom this evidencethat a city's coinageafter 188was directly related to its statusas fixed by the Roman settlementof that year: independentcities were free to issuetheir own coinage, whereascitiesmadetributary to the Attalids lost this right. If this is so, then cities which continuedafter 188to issuetheir own coins were evidently not Attalid subjects; the independentstatus of Aigai, arguedaboveon othergrounds,would thusbe confirmed,as would that of Parion,Abydos, Myrina, Lebedos, and Phaselis. 1a0 raoSeyrig,20. The caseofAbydos is particularlyinteresting,in that Abydoshas beenthoughtto be an Attalid subjectfrom 188,and even,by Magie(seebelow),as possiblythe city which issuedthe decreehonouringKorrhagosdiscussedabovein part i. The statusofAbydos is howeverunclear;in 196it was declaredfree (Polyb. 284),but xviii.44.4; Holleaux,Etudes,iv. 317-18,n.4; Schmitt,(Jntersuchungen, Antiochos'garrisonstill held the city in 190(Livy xxxvii. 9. I 1-12; xxxiii. 38.4). We do not know how the city wastreatedby Romein 188,but Magie'sview (Rornan Rule, ü. l0l2-13) that 'for its surrenderto Antiochusit would naturallyhavebeen awardedto Eumenes'is untenable,in view of explicit evidence,in the caseof Phokaia(Polyb. xxi. 46. 7; see above,42 n. 46), that a city betrayedto Antiochos, and then held by a garrisonand not by loyalty, was not treatedin 188as if it hadjoined the cause voluntarily. Abydos' independentcoinageprobably dates from shortlyafter the third Macedonianwar (Seyrig,20,n.2), and may havebegun with a commemorativeissue;thus a short period of Attalid rule after 188is not precluded on this criterion, and is perhapssupportedby an inscription from Ilion 'A66öou: it would be difücult to mentioning a certain Chaireas,ö tetayptvog en' assignthis clearly royal appointmentto anyone but an Attalid king (cf. Bengtson, Strat. ä.24D. An we can say with certaintyis that Abydos was independentfrom about 170;if it was subjectto Eumenesbetween188and that date,the reasonfor such a statusis not clear.
112
Attalid Kingdom after the Treaty of Apameia
The oldest coins of the cistophoriccoinage,judged on stylistic grounds, are issuesof Pergamon,Ephesos,Tralles, Sardis, and Apameia;althoughat one time dated,as individual issuesof each city, to the end of the third century Bc andevenearlier,rarit is clear from the history of these cities, from the dominanceof the Pergamenemint in the coinage,and above all from the fact that the coins werg issuedby all of them, and minted in the three major Attalid cities, in the sameperiod, that is, as a-common coinage, that the originsof the coinagemust be datedto the yearsafter 188 Bc, when the citiesconcernedwere assignedto EumenesII by the terms of the Roman settlementof Asia Minor. It is only in this period of the secondcentury that the necessarycommonpolitical circumstancescan be adducedfor all the cities in explanationof sucha coinage.t42 In the case of Pergamonit is probable that the coinagewas issuedbefore 188sc, in addition to the dynastic coinagebearing the head of Philetairos,which, it now seems,continued to be mintedafter 188BC.Livy mentionscistophoriamongthe booty of three Roman triumphs of the Antiochic War in 190and 189,and these referencescannot be dismissedas anachronisticdesignations of a number of different coinages,as is usually done.tar Livy's evidence does not necessarilyemanate from badly informed annalisticsources,sincethe exact detailshe gives suggest archivalmaterialof the kind gatheredfor the Augustanpublication of the fasti triumphales; and the objection that Glabrio, who triumphed in 190, could not have had cistophoroi in his booty becauseneither of his defeated opponents, the Aitolians and rar Kleiner and Noe, l0-18. ra2Seyrig, 22 ff.; Giovannini 15. Cistophoroi from Thyateira, Apollonis, and Stratonikeia, bearing the letters BA EY followed by B or /, have been shown by Robinson (cited above, n. 137) to be issues of Aristonikos, who called himself Eumenes III; cf. L. Robert, Villes2, 252ff . Kleiner and Noe date the introduction of the common coinage to about 166sc. after Eumenes' successful Galatian warofthe early 160s.They argue, on the basis of a coin hoard from Mektepini in Phrygia (N. Olgay and H. Seyrig, Le Trösor de Mektepini en Phrygie, Paris, 1965) that the dynastic coinage bearing the head of Philetairos continued after 188 Bc. and postulate a short overlap with the new cistophoric coinage, but a longer one is possible; moreover the historical circumstances they adduce as contextual evidence are not especially convincing. For the dominance ofthe Pergamene mint in the coinage, see Kleiner and Noe. 120-4. r a 3x x x v i i . 4 6 . 2 ( M ' . A c i l i u s G l a b r i o i n 1 9 0 ) ;x x x v i i . 5 8 . 4 ( L . A e m i l i u s R e g i l l u si n 1 8 9 ) ;x x x v i i . 5 9 . I ( L . C o r n e l i u s S c i p i o A s i a t i c u s i n 1 8 9 ) .C f . S e y r i g , 2 4 , n . l ; K l e i n e r and Noe, I 8, n. 58. For the chronology of the late dynastic coinage, see Kleiner and Noe. l4-16.
The Greek Cities
I 13
Antiochos III, ever circulated the coin, cannot stand, because Antiochos at least could easily have acquired quantities of the coins when his son seleukosraidedAttalid territory and besieged Pergamonip f !Q.ra I regardit as probable,then, thatcistophoroi were minted at Pergamonbefore,althoughnot longbefore, 188nc, as well as tetradrachmsbearingthe portrait of Philetairos,and that the cistophoric coinage was imposed on tributary cities in or shortly after 188as the soleculrency of Eumenes'newly acquired kingdom, with Pergamonas the chief mint and othersat Ephesos and Tralles. This fact attests clearly Eumenes'intention of renderinghis subjectsfinancially dependenton their suzerain,and is consistent with the Attalids' persistent concern to control the financesof their kingdom personally,another consequenceof which we sawearlierin their direct appointmentof civic strategoi' The fact that the cistophoriccoinagewas not circulatedoutside the kingdom throws light on Eumenes'economicpolicy in more generalterms.r4sSo far from co-operatingeconomicallywith the Seleukidsafter 188,as Rostovtzeffthought,ra6Bumsngswas eviraaSeyrig, 24,n. l; seleukos'invasionof 190:Livy xxxvii' l8; Appian' Syt' 26' The invasionsof 198and 197also come into consideration:seeabove,77-8' r4sOn this question,seeSeyrig,25-6; Kleinerand Noe, 124-5' | 46Anat. s t id. B uckter 277ff . ; s EH Hly ii. 654ff. Rostovtzeffargued,from the abundanceof autonomoustetradrachmsfrom westernAsia Minor found in Syrian hoardsofthe secondcenturyBc.that EumenesII inheriteda surplusofmetal in 188' andthereforeco-operatedwith the Greekcitiesandwith the Seleukidsby supplying them with this meial. This view has beendecisivelycriticizedby Seyrig,26-8; in fact, circulationofthesetetradrachmsin the SeleukidKingdomis asnotablebefore lg8 as after, and remainedalways a free circulation,as distinct from the royal Furthermore,thepolicyoffinancialmonopoly,introducedinto seleukidcurrency. his kingdomin theform of thecistophorosin l88 gc,testifiesagainstthe notionof an 'ententecordiale' with the Seleukidsafter that date. O.MÖrkholm,AntiochuslVofSyria(Copenhagen,1966),51-63,believesina politicaland economicco-operationbetweenthe Attalidsand the seleukidswhen intiochos IV came to the throne. Apart from the circumstancesof Antiochos' elevation.which seemto me to amount to little more than a typical exampleof Attalid opportunism,there is little evidenceto supportthis view, and still lessto support ihat of a'triple allianceof Pergamon,Cappadocia,and Syria' after 175 (Iridrkhotm,55).The-factthat Antiochos sharedthe samecontactsin the Greek world as Eumenesproves nothing, since many of them, especiallyDelphi and Delos, receivedthe attentionof most powerful statesand kingdomsat this time. Again,Antiochos'policy of friendshipwith Miletos,a city accordingto Mdrkholm .w-ithinthe Pergaminesphereofinfluence', simply reflectsanotheraspectofthat city's determinationto advanceits own position by courting the favour of any benefactorwilling to assistit (on this policy seefurther below);it saysnothingfor the relationsbetweenthe benefactors.Finally, as Mdrkholm admits (57-8), Antiochoswaswilling to helprivals of Pergamonaswell as friends;Rhodesis a casetn point (Livy xli.20. 7; Syll.1644-5)-
n4
Attalid Kingdom aftei the Treaty of Apameia
dently concernedto establisha rival economy,whosecoinagewas on a standard different from that of the Attic tetradrachm circulated in the Seleukid Kingdom, and whose status therefore suggestscircumstancesother than co-operationin trade with the Seleukids.Although he was no doubt awareof the exampleof this policy shownby the Ptolemies,it is hardly valid in the presentstate of the evidenceto regard Eumenes' implementingof a currency monopolyas a signof direct Rolemaic influence;ratherit suggests that samepolicy, argued above, whereby the Attalids after 188 adopted institutions of different origins as they suited the circumstancesof the new kingdom. We have seenthat the Attalids were always concernedto control personallythe institutions of financialadministrationin the various parts of their kingdom:the Greek cities, the katoikiai, the temples, and, as Cardinali has shown, the capital, where this policy was probably implemented early in the dynasty's history.trT This policy did not, however, reachthe proportionsof the highly centralizedeconomicand fiscal system developed by the Ptolemies, of which the currency monopoly was only one aspect;it would be wrong, therefore,to supposethat Eumeneswas directly influencedto any greatextent by Rolemaic practice in making provision for the financial administrationof his kingdom after the Treaty of Apameia. The status of a 'free' or non-tributary city in relation to the Attalid Kingdomis moredifficult to determine.The difficultiescan bestbe consideredby comparingthe fortunesof the two cities for which the evidenceis most informative: the gift city of Ephesos and the free city of Miletos. In the caseof Miletos the materialto hand allows us to draw a very distinct picture of the relations betweenthe city and the king. Perhapsthe most significantconclusion to be drawn from it is that at Miletos EumenesII was almost certainly called a god in his lifetime. The entire body of evidencewith which we are concerneddates from thereignof EumenesII; someof it hasbeenfamiliarforalong time, while someis more recent.r4sAs we have seen,Miletos was ra7G. Cardinali,Mem.Accad.Bologna,x (1915-16),181-93;seebelow,ch. 7. The responsibilityfor financesofthe provincialstrategos is shownby acrstophoros bearing the letters KOPPATOZ) AP(I2TOMAXOY-); Seyrig, 29-3t. ra8The texts are given in Appendix iv, nos. l3-17.
The Greek Cities
il5
given its freedom in 188as a reward for co-operationin the Antiochic War. The statusof the city beforethe war is unclear;there is certainlyno evidencethat it wasa Ptolemaiccity at the endof the third century and in all probability it was completely indepenThere is no ground in the Romansettlement,as recorded dlent.r4e by Polybios, on which Miletos could have been expectedto pay tribute to Eumenes,and its independencewas in all ways assured. The city's territory almostcertainlyincludedthat of Myus, a small town whose sacredlandswere a constantcauseof disputewith its more powerful neighbours.This was undoubtedlyso at the end of the third century, when Miletos billeted someCretanmercenaries in the territory of Myus.t50As aresult of the expeditionof Philip V in Asia Minor in 201, Miletos temporarily lost its independence, and Myus was given by the invader to Magnesiaon the Maeander,tsr but the former situation was restoredwhen Miletos concluded a separatetreaty with Magnesiain 196, which set the boundary between the two cities at the River Hybandos.ts2The territory of Myus was presumablyincluded in the sacredlands which were specificallyrestoredto Miletos in 188. The most importantof the documentswe areto consideris a long letter of Eumenes[I addressedto the Ioniankoinon (Appendixiv, no. 13),which quotes extensively(lines 5-37) the lonian decree passedin his honour to which his own letter is a reply. It is the key to the chronologicalproblems involved in attemptingto form a securesequenceofdocuments,and therebya sequenceofevents. Holleaux's thorough analysisof the contentsof the letter and its historical contentls3establishedthat the winter of 16716,when Eumenesis likely to havebeenat Delos(lines1-5)andhis Galatian war was still in progress, is the date which best suits all the implicationsof the letter, and this date has rightly been accepted since.The decree,as passedon to us by Eumenes'letter, attests honoursvoted to him both by thekoinon and by Miletosalone.The honours of the koinon are conventional:the donation of a gold raeHolleaux, Etudes, iii. 135-6; Rehm, Das Delphinion in Milet (Milet i.3, Berlin, l9l4), 267, 321. t s oM i l e t i . 3 . 3 3 8 ; M a g i e , R o m a n R u l e , ü . 8 8 3 , n . 8 1 . r5f Polyb. xvi.24.9; Holleaux, Etudes, iv. 230 ff' r52Sll/.3 588, line 30. r53Holleaux. Etudes, ii. 153-78.
116
Attalid Kingdom after the Treaty of Apameia
crown, the erectionof a gilded statueanywherein the territory of thekoinon, honoursto be announcedat the festivalsof thekoinon, Eumenesto be met and congratulatedby representativesof the koinon. The more significantpart is containedin Eumenes'reply: he offers to provide an income for the celebration of his riptqa önrbvupoEat the festival of the Panionion,ls4and to pay for the statue, which he chooses to be put up (lines 59-60) fiv rrit örpr1llErcp|vatfipiv önö Müqo[tun re]p6velt\' Oneof the Ionianenvoyswho met Eumenesat Delos(line 3)was Eirenias son of Eirenias, a prominent citizen of Miletos about whom a good deal is now known. He is also mentioned in the surviving portion of the city's decreein honour of Eumenes(Appendix iv, no. 14),in the capacityof envoy of the city to the king; -öl fov Eumenesin reply (lines l6-18)ygäpara (sic)&.n6ora)"xev HolxtL. td re önö Eiqtnllvbu öpqavrc06vra aüt6t öX06pevoE leaux's identificationof the date of this mission on behalf of the city with that of the missionon behalfof thekoinon is the weakest part of an otherwise dependablechronologicalframework, although it has been accepted,for example,by Welles.lssThis identity ofoccasions, basedsolely on the fact that on each occasionthe Milesianenvoy was Eirenias,is certainlysuspect.Thereis no other reasonto datethe decreeof Miletos to the year 16716,and a later date is also arguable. We passto the third document,a decreeof the Milesianboule which honoursEumenes'brothersAttalosand Athenaiosin addition to the king himself (Appendixiv, no. l5).tsoThe principal honoursof coursego to Eumenes,and include the celebrationof hisyevi0ArcE iptSa.As Holleauxargued,this celebrationimplies 'voted' (itprlqrcpivov) in that the temenos, still referred to as Eumenes'letter (lines59-60), had beencompleted,and we may thereforeconcludethat the decree ofthe boule is the later ofthe r5aThis celebration is not proposed in the extant part ofthe decree, and may have been Eumenes' own idea. r s s l l s l l s a u l , E t u d e s , ü . 1 7 4 - 5 ; W e l l e s , R C , p . 2 1 4' i:t a p p e a r s . . . t h a t l r e n i a s , the Milesian member of the League embassy, had carried a special message to the king.' This identification is not accepted however by Daux, BCH lix (1935),227. rs6The omission from these honours of Philetairos, the youngest ofthe sons of Attalos I, may be explained by an early death. The last record ofhim relates to the year l7l (Livy xlii. 55. 7); cf. Hoffmann, RE s.v. Philetairos (3)' 2162; Hopp, Untersuchunpen,3l-2.
The Greek Cities
ll7
two documents.Although there is no indicationthat Eumenesis AttalosII, is calledin his brotherandeventualsuccessor, dead,157 "Arra).oE this decree 6aotAeüE flines 39-40). We have already seen that Delphian decreesdated in the year of Amphistratos (160/59)establishthe fact that Attalos II was given the royal title beforethe deathof EumenesII late in l59.rs8An Atheniandecree in honour of an unknownoikeios of EumenesII, passedearlier in g3nn6[thereforerefer in its lastsurviving the sameyear, 160/59,tse line to Eumenes'death,but must refer to the act of establishingthe co-regency.When I examinedthe stone,now in the Epigraphical Museumin Athens(inv. 7526),I obtaineda numberof new readings, notably these in the important final line: ---- KAINYNwe may EYMENO. . THNAPX- - - -. FollowingDaux's suggestions, restore this line as follows: xai uüv EöptvoluEl rrlv ügyfilv 'Anä)"atl. napaööwoE (or innq&pawoE) rCotäöeAEdtL The importance of this text lies in the fact that it provides a terminuspost quem, or evenad quem, for Attalos' assumptionof the royal title, whereasDelphian chronologypresentsus with a fait accompli. For our presentpurpose,it provesthat the decreeof theboule of Miletos cannotbe much earlierthan 160/59.It may be later, becausethe possibility remainsthat Eumeneswas already him'r6oif so it will not be much deadand Attalos had succeeded r57On this point, and others concerning the chronology under discussion, see G Daux, BCH lix (1935\,226-9. r 5 8S e e a b o v e . l 0 n . 7 . t s eI G ä . 2 9 5 3 ; A p p e n d i x i v , n o . l 8 ; W . B . D i n s m o o r , T h e A t h e n i a n A r c h o n L i s t i n the Light of Recent Discoveries (New York, 1939), 190, with references. r60This possibility depends on the interpretation drawn from the words (önaE) ü dE üp 6aoü.6o lvüpq öncpuL([oorlrlar (lines 37-8), which do not necessarily mean that Eumenes was no longer alive. An Athenian decree in honour of Pharnakes I ofPontos and his recently acquired queen, Nysa, passed in the archonship of Tychandros, that is in the same year as IG ii.2 953 discussed above, 160/59, included the provision ävayy677ew öi töt 6aoüü töv xfeX]ttporovqpövov, örr ö öfipolE nleqäo€ra. . . . näwa rä neöE ööEav xai pvrjpr1v laöröL dvrjxolvta ouy: xataoxtuäoat xr7. (lnscr. Dölos, 149'7bis, lines 50 ff.). Pharnakes was most certainly alive at the time; see also Mdrkholm, Antiochus |V,54. In his letter to the Ioniankoinr.rn, Eumenes makes the offer already referred to in the words (lines 54-6) npooööoug öpiv täg ixcwdg äval1|fiolq 4q' dtv Efere d1v xa|fixouoav flpiv lävatß)ivat pvtjp4u. The expression can then refer to a living king. If Eumenes had died between the time the temenos at Miletos was voted and the time of the passing of the decree of theäoale of Miletos, we would expect a more explicit reference to his death in the later document, and I am more inclined to believe that Eumenes was still alive when the temenos had been completed and the statue had been erected.
I l8
Attalid Kingdomafter the Treatyof Apameia
later.l6rThe most important implicationof this chronologyso far as the present argumentis concernedis that the building of the temenosvoted to EumenesII in the decreequoted in the king's letter, and the erection of the statuetherein as requestedby the king in the sameletter, were almostcertainly achievedduring his lifetime.t 62 The last two documentswith which we areconcernedhavebeen publishedmore recently than the others; one was found in 1960, the other known, but not published,before' One is a decreeof Miletos honouringits prominentcitizen Eirenias(Appendixiv, no' l6). and it establishesas a fact what had previouslybeen conjectured, that Eumenesof Pergamonprovided the capital for the gymnasiumat Miletos, this being in the case of the Attalids a Previouslyit had been known only that well-attestedpractice.163 the sameEireniashad beenappointedoverseerin the construction of the gymnasium.r64It may have been at this juncture that Eumenes sent a letter to the city, and that the city passedthe decreein his honourof which the text is our no. 14.Or it may have been later still. here(Appendixiv, no. l7) is the Thelastdecreeto be considered final link in justifying the assertionexpressedabove,that Miletos called Eumenesa god in his lifetime' Found rebuilt into a wall in 1903,it was referredto by Ruge,r6sbut remainedunavailableuntil publishedby P. Herrmannalongwith the new decreeconcerning Eirenias.r66For the precisechronologicalrelationshipof this to the other Milesian documents,the reader is referredto the commentaryattachedto that publication.For our purposethe important point is that the text is certainly a Milesiandecreeratified by 16rThis point depends on Rehm's revised dating of'the second god after Menekrates' (lines 27-8); see Holleaux, Etudes, ii. 177-8. Although this chronological point is not by any means precise to the year, itjustifies the statement I have made in the text. 'il n'est pas r62See the previous two notes. Holleaux's point (Etudes, ii. 173), de bien exig6 ait par les Mil6siens croyable que la mise en 6tat dut6lttvo6 consacr6 longs d6lais', should also be taken into account. 1 6 3L . R o b e r t , E t . a n a t . 8 5 , n . 3 . E p h e s o s :S E G x v i i ' 5 1 0 ' 164Th. Wiegand, Siebenter vorlöufiger Bericht über die von den Königlichen Museen in Milet und Didyma unternommenen Ausgrabungen @bh' Berlin' Anhang, l9ll),29. r 6 5 R E ,s . v . M y u s . 1 4 3 6 . 1 6 6I s t . M i t t . x v ( 1 9 6 5 ) ,7 l - 1 1 7 .
The Greek Cities
il9
it is the peopleof Myus, at the time insympoliteiawith Miletos;167 to be dated before the erection of the statueof EumenesII in his temenosat Miletos,sincethedecreewasto be inscribedon its base (lines7-8): d.vaypacprl öi xai rööe ö rprlErcpaeig rc ü 6rlfua BE' rcü 6aoü6ag eixtitv. According to the o61l oru9fioetaL fi chronology argued above, this placesthe decree,with near certainty, in Eumenes'lifetime, and the propositionis confirmedby the evidenceofthe decreeitself. Throughout,thereis referenceto oneking,ö 6aoÄeü8,who mustof coursebe Eumenes;in particular, the king whoseeikon wasto be setup in Miletos(line 8) mustbe to whom envoysof the sameas the king, in no way distinguished, the city were to be sent(lines l0ff.). If Eumeneswere no longer him, we would expecta distincalive,and Attaloshad succeeded tion to be madebetweenthe deadking and the living, for example The decreeincludes in line 12:nagaxaAetvtöu 6aoü"6s"ArraAov. priesthood provision of Eumenes(lines 4-5): a for the sale of a Thus, acönaE ieqaofvr1nqa9lrl fi 6aoü,toEl Eüptvoug 9eoü.168 cording to our chronology,which is confirmedat every point, the priesthood and the divine title were associatedwith Eumenes during his lifetime. There was nothing new in the city of Miletos calling a royal benefactora god; it haddonethis for AntiochosII after the murder 'Avrio4oE ... öi of Timarchos,as Appianinformsus:r6eöedregoE 1eöEönövutrtovönö MAr1otav yiyverat ng6rov. The worship of Antiochos and that of Eumenesconstitutethe type of cult instituted spontaneouslyby a gratefulbut not necessarilysubjectcity, as distinct from the dynastic cult establishedas a result of royal wish.r7oIts place in the context of Attalid royal cults as a whole will be examinedin a later chapter, but at this point the political implicationsof Miletos' extravagantattitude to honouringEumenes,an attitude not paralleledto our knowledgeelsewherein the Attalid Kingdom, require some consideration. of Eumenes At both Ephesosand Miletos, one the possession accordingto the terms of the Roman settlement,the other a free 16?Herrmann, 90 ff. r6t I see no objection to the restoration of 6aoü.6utE at the end of line 4. The absence of the royal title would call for some explanation. r6eSyr. 65. See W. Orth, Königlicher Machtanspruch, 153-6. t70 Habicht, Gottmenschentum, 160 tr.
120
Attalid Kingdom after the Treaty of Apameia
non-tributary city by the same terms, the institution of the gymnasium became, by his will, the responsibility of the king. At Ephesoshe received a normal gymnasialdedicationassociating him with Hermes and Herakles, as was uSUal;tzrat Miletos the honours were extendedto amount to a regular cult of the living king. Thus Miletos, and not Eumenes'own city of Ephesos,may be regardedas a centre of his cult, in addition to the capital Pergamonand Teos. This condition would be more readily attributable to a subjectcity. It is arguable,however,that of thesetwo cities, Ephesoswas in a better position after the Romansettlementhad placedthe city in Eumenes'hands.WhereasMiletos dependedon royal favour for any benefitsshe might receive,Ephesos,as a part of the kingdom and probably its largestport, was automaticallydestinedto prosperity, and it doubtlessemergedfrom the Roman settlementas a city enjoying advancedroyal patronage.In fact we know that Ephesosranked high in the Attalids' regard,and we have specific evidenceof building activity, always a sure sign of prosperity, under Attalos II.r72The city was the centreof an Attalid administrative region; at least two Ephesians, Hikesios and Megon, reachedhigh rank in the royal administration,and a third, whose name is not known in full, was chosen to be the mentor of the young Attalos IlI.r73 Miletos, on the other hand, was in a different position, having rather to fend for itself for its economic prosperity. There are indicationsthat its harbour was beginningto silt up, and that its whereasEphesosstill enjoyedthe tradeby seawas in decline,rTa t 1 1C f . O G I S 2 3 0 ( H e r m e s , H e r a k l e s , a n d A n t i o c h o s M e g a s a t S o l i ) ; A M x x v i i i ( 1 9 0 3 ) ,3 5 8 f f . ( f t o l e m y , H e r m e s , a n d H e r a k l e s a t S a m o s ) . r 7 2S t r a b o x i v . 1 . 2 4 , 6 4 1 , m e n t i o n s A t t a l o s I I ' s p r o j e c t o f b u i l d i n g a m o l e a t t h e mouth of the harbour with the idea of deepening the entrance to accommodate larger ships; although unsuccessful, it is an indication ofthe growing volume of trade passing through the harbour. Strabo says of the city in his own day , aüf*at 'Aoiav d1v övtö; roü xa7' öxdotrlv fi1tfqarr, ipnöprcv oöoa p|ytorov töv xatd tilv Taüpou. Ephesos also enjoyed a fuller trade by land with the East. Strabo traces, on the evidence of Artemidoros, the important route from Ephesos which reached as far as the Euphrates (xiv. 2. 29, 66J). r73For Hikesios and Megon, see below, 133-5. The mentor of Attalos III: Appendix iv, no. 24. r 7 4S t r a b o x v i . 6 3 5 .
Festivals of Athena
121
advantageafforded by Lysimachos early in the third century nc of a new and better site for its harbour.rTsIt was doubtlessfor this reason that the Milesians worked so hard to attract the king's attentionand seizedevery opportunity to honour him. No wonder they were so gratefulto Eirenias,who had the king's ear.176 As a centre of Eumenes'worship the city would attain two important aspirations:the guaranteedgoodwill of the king whose cult was celebrated,and the commercialprosperitythat any importantcult brought to a Greek city.rtz It is clear that in both theserespects Ephesosheld an advantageby virtue of its status,and if Miletos was to remaincompetitiveit had to adopta positivepolicy to gain and keep the king's favour. This evidently is what it did, and with great success. Evidently,then,the terms'free'and'subject'do not adequately definethe statusof cities which enjoyedcontactswith the Attalid Kingdom. The evidencewe have discusseddoes not allow us to draw sharp distinctionsbetweena free and a tributary or subject city, apart from the issueof tribute obligation.The informationit doesconvey concernsthe king's readinessto be as well-disposed to the latter asto the former, and showsthat a city in the possession of the king in all probabilityled as independenta civic life asa free city, such as Miletos. It also enjoyedthe advantageof royal patronage,a privilege which the free city soughtby other means. (iii) Festivals of Athena So far in this chapterwe havebeenconsideringthe implicationsof the Roman settlementin mainly political terms, and we may now usefully turn to examineanother facet: the processby which the cult and festivals of Athena, the most important of Pergamon's gods, were enhancedand transformed as a means of religious propagandain line with the new standingof the King of Pergamon in the Greekworld. We shallalso seein a later chapterhow cults of Dionysos were used to advancethe statusof the royal cult. f 7 5l b i d . x i v . l . 2 l ; c f . M a g i e , R o m a n R u l e , i i . 9 2 1 , n . 1 3 . | ?6See the city's decree in his honour (Appendix iv, no. l6). These close relations between Miletos and the Attalids were maintained in the reign of Attalos II, when statues of the king and his brother Athenaios were erected in Miletos (OGI.S 320-l ). r77Habicht, Gottmenschentum, 165 ff.
t22
Attalid Kingdom after the Treaty of Apameiu
Athenawas a goddesswith many aspects,and waswell suitedto the role of a city's presidingdeity: shewas a protector,a bringerof victory, a patronof learningand art, and shehad associationswith the oldest cities of the Greek mainlandand Asia Minor. All these attributeswere exploitedby the Attalids, asthey were b1'othersin the Hellenisticperiod. A templeof Athena was built at Pergamon probablyat the beginningof the third century sc, when Philetairos still acknowledgedthe suzeraintyof Lysimachos,and it was sufficiently importantby the time of EumenesI to be the depositoryof the Pergamenecopy of his treaty with the mercenaries at Philetaireiaand Attaleia.rTsA festival called Panathenaiais attestedat aboutthe sametime by the decreeof Pergamonhonouring the city's strategoi,but nothingfurther is known of it'r7e In the reign of Attalos I the evidence for the cult of Athena becomesmore copious and more significant' correspondingto Attalos' seriesof military victories and his proclaimedkingship' An enlargementof the temple and precinct of Athena in the city predatingthe great Eumenid restorationis probably to be considered the work of Attalos I early in his reign, as a means of accommodatingthe massivemonumentshe dedicatedto Athenn.raofhs figure of Athena on the dynastic coinageundergoes somechangein Attalos' reign, greateremphasisbeinglaid on the which spearshe is holdingand lesson the shield'developments particular in activity, may plausiblybe relatedto Attalos' military his victory over the Galatiansat the river Kaikos.r8r Oneof the few piecesof literary evidencefor the cults of Athena at Pergamonrecordsthe occurrenceof äy6uegfor Athena in220' Polybioswrites (iv. 49. 3), with referenceto the outbreakof commercial war between Rhodes and Byzantion in this year' that PrusiasI of Bithynia could be expected to take the side of the Rhodians:ig60ße ö' aüröv xq.i tö öoxelv BulawiouE npöEpiv "Ana).ov tiErcüErfiE'A04vaEdyrbvaEroüEovv|üoovraEö$aneot18OGIS 266,: StV iii. 481 (discussedabove' 22-5)' Ohlemutz,Kulte, 16-23, dates the foundation of the temple to the first decade of the third century BC. On the temple of Athena as a statearchive, seeibid. 23' 55-7. t1eIvP 18, : OGIS 267 (discussedbelow, ch' 7). r80AvPii. 55-6; Ohlemutz,Kulte,28-9; Kähler,Gr' Fries, 135;themonuments are listed and consideredin Appendix ii. tlt Mvp ll. 7,9, 12, l5; III. 4; Ohlemutz,Kulte, 34-5.
Festivals of Athena
123
ralxfvaL, npöEaöröv ö' eiEräZarfign pr1ö6vanenopEtvar.This evidencehasbeeninterpretedto suggestthat Attalos' festivalwas but the emphasisof novelty lies a recent foundation in 220,182 surelyon Prusias'Soteria(aboutwhich nothingfurther is known), and the passagecannot in my view be expectedto afford precise chronologicalcluesaboutAttalos' festival.All we can sayis that in 220 Attalos was celebratingimportant gamesfor Athena, whose descriptionby Polybios suggestssomethingother than the older and which may plausiblybe associated,likethe other Panathenaia, more definite cult phenomena,with Attalos' victories and assumption of the royal title. At sometime towards the end of Attalos' reign, or more probably at the beginningof the reign of EumenesII, Athenawas given the cult name Nikephoros, 'bestower of victory'. With this phenomenonwe havealsoto associatetwo other nameswhich are known chiefly from epigraphical sources, the festival of the Nikephoria, and the site outsidethe city calledNikephorion. It is possiblethat this titulaturewas not all introducedat the sametime; that is to say,that AthenawascalledNikephorosbeforethe ideaof a Nikephorionor of Nikephoriawas conceived,but this is most unlikely, and the evidenceis best understoodas reflectinga single concept, as is usually done. Of the three names,only that of the Nikephorionoccursin literary sources,in Polybios,Strabo,and Appian, in all casesfortunately in securelydated contexts. First Polybios:his narrativeof the year 201,when Philip V of Macedon was raiding Attalid territory, refersinter alia to Philip's destruction of the Nikephorion (xvi. l. 6): inei öi rö Nmqcpöqrcv öAuprjvaro,rö trtiv ä)"oogixrtpti.tv, röv öö negi6oTovönqgtEaE, roüE re vaoüE öx 9epeltov dv9oxatpe,noM"oüExai nü.urcAeiE öndpxovtaq xrL. After his defeatin 197, Philipwas requiredto put the damageright, and he agreedto do so (xviii. 2. 2), but we do not know whether he kept his promise. Straboattributesa renovation of the site to Eumenes II, as we shall see, but this does not necessarilymean that Philip had not kept his word, since the Eumenidrestorationtook place in the 180s,by which time Pergamon had sufferedanotherinvasion,that of Seleukosin 190(Livy r82For example by Ohlemutz, Kulte, 34.
124
Attalid Kingdom after the Treaty of Apameia
xxxvii. 18;Appian, Syr. 26).Appian also refersto a later destruction of the site, that by PrusiasII of Bithynia in 155(Mithr' 3; cf . Polyb. xxxii. 27). Now this evidenceneedscarefulconsideration,becauseat first sight Polybios seemsto suggestthat the PergameneNikephorion was in existence already in the reign of Attalos [, and this is frequentlytaken to be the case,leadingnecessarilyto the conclusion that Attalos was also responsiblefor designatingAthena as Nikephorosand forthe foundationofthe Nikephoria,which are on this view to be identifiedwith the äy6veEfor Athena recordedfor 220.183But Polybios, in saying that Philip destroyed the Nikephorion in 201, may well be referringto the name current in 'many his own duy,tto and it is to be notedthat Polybiosspeaksof temples'on the site, which suggestsan extendedapplicationof the name beyond that of the original cult centre. The place may not formerly have had a name,and Philip's promiseto restorethe site related,of course,to the renovationwhich eventuallybecamethe famous Nikephorion. The evidenceof Attalos' monumentsthrows further doubt on the acceptedview, becauseall the extant dedicationsare madeto Athenawithout the cult epithetNikephoros,with the exceptionof a smallgroup which we may now consider.This group (IvP 5l-6, 58)comprisesa numberof not very substantialfragmentsof small round bases commemoratingindividual victories; in two cases they are dedicatedto Athena Nikephoros.one celebratingthe victory over the Tolistoagians,the other the victory over Philip V at Chios in 202J'8sAnother piece (IvP 55 A) has the first three letters of the nameNikephoros, but the royal name has not been preserved.This meagre.evidencefor the cult name is in striking contrast to the seriesof large monuments,none of which calls AthenaNikephoros.We cannotsimply assumethat all the dedicar s 3H o l f e a u x , E t u d e s , ü . 6 l - 2 : O h l e m u t z , K u l t e , 3 3 4 ; K l a f f e n b a c h , M D A I i l i (1950), 99 ff. The site ofthe Nikephorion has not been identified; for a discussion of the probabilities, see Ohlemutz, Kulte,36-7. r 8 4K ä h l e r , G r . F r i e s , 1 8 7 , n . 4 3 . r s 5 / v P 5 1 . : K ä h l e r . G r . F r i e s , 1 9 0 ,n . 5 6 ; I v P 5 2 , : O G I S 2 8 3 : s e e b e l o w , 196 n. 5. Segre, in his important study cited below' n' 192' thought that the Nikephoria were founded by Attalos after the battle off Chios, but this is not a good context even regardless of other considerations (see above, 28 n. 3).
Festivals of Athena
125
tions to Athena Nikephoros were placedin the Nikephorion outside the city rather than in the city temple from which the known becauseAttalos, aswe haveseen,envisaged monumentscome,1E6 the precinct in the city as the context of his grandestmonuments, and it would be diffrcultto imaginethe evengrandermonumentsto be expected of a postulated new Nikephorion. Furthermore, Eumenes placed his dedications to Athena Nikephoros in the city's temple even after the known rebuildingof the Nikephorion outside the city. There remains the question of the two small baseswhich are certainly dedications in the name of King Attalos to Athena Nikephoros. Although usually dated to the last years of Attalos' reign, the lessregularletter-formsare markedlydifferentfrom the materialassociatedwith the 230sand 220s,and alsofrom Attalos' dedicationof booty from Aigina in2l0 (IvP 47, : OGIS 281),and are closer to the inscriptionsfrom the l90s and later. Kähler has plausiblysuggestedthat thesebasesareto be datedto the Eumenid rebuildingof the precinctof Athenain the city, when,ashe shows, old blocks and bases were reused in addition to new material brought in.rE7Athena's cult nameNikephoros is at this dateto be regardedas Eumenes'addition,and in supportof this chronology is the appearanceof what must be Eumenes'name in one of the fragmentsof the group under consideration(IvP 56 B). On this chronological view, the first appearanceof Athena Nikephoros in the Pergameneinscriptions is the dedication of Eumenes II commemorating his victory in alliance with the It6 As does Ohlemutz, Kulte, i4. 181Gr. Fries, 135-6, with n. 46. An examination of the stones in the Pergamon Museum in Berlin undertaken by the author in 1969confirmed this chronology. The rather crude letters of the small bases under discussion differ markedly from the more precise work of Attalos'larger monuments, and are directly comparable with some of Eumenes'own dedications, especially/vP 63 (see Kähler, Gr. Fries, l9O, n . 5 6 ) . E u m e n e s ' r e c o n s t r u c t i o no f t h e p r e c i n c t o f A t h e n a i n v o l v e d t h e u s e o f o l d material for new inscriptions and the reinscription of a number of bases dating from Attalos' reign. The first dated example of this use of old material is the base celebrating victory in the second war against Nabis of Sparta and the ensuing campaign against Antiochos III in Greece (lvP 62, : Syll.3 605 A), and since its erection must be dated after 189, the beginning ofthe project culminating in an enlarged precinct dedicated to Athena Nikephoros most plausibly belongs to this period, along with the rebuilding of the Nikephorion outside the city, which preceded the first celebration ofthe panhellenic festival.
126
Attalid Kingdom after the Treutlt of Apomeia
This local affair Achaian Leagueover Nabis of Spartain 195.188 cannothoweverbe the reasonfor the designationNikephoros and the cult activity associatedwith it; we must go back a few more yearsto the Attalid victory in the alliancewith Romeover Philip V of Macedonin 197,on which accountPolybios,doubtlessreflecting Greek sentimentgenerally,praisedAttalos I (xviii.41. 9) as 'E)"Lrivatv il'eu9egfuE. äyavt(öpevog önöp rfiE töv It may be regardedas an understandabletribute on Eumenes' part that shortly after his accessionin 197he institutedthe cult of AthenaNikephorosandthe festival of the Nikephoriato celebrate this victory for freedomwon by his father. We know that Eumenes was concernedto advancethe status of Athena at Pergamonin other ways, by propagatinga spuriouslegendaryorigin of the cult, for instance.rseThe first coinage bearing the legend AoHNAz NIKHaoPoY should also be dated to his reign,reoand we may reasonablypostulatethat festivalscalled Nikephoria were celebrated in the 190s. A further opportunity to promote the cult of Athena camewith the victory over AntiochosIII in 189and the Romansettlementof the following year. During the years immediatelyfollowing the settlementEumenesimplementedthat grand designof rebuilding and extendingPergamonwhich occupiedthe rest of his reign and requirednew circuit walls to encompassthe much enlargedcity. Athena received much of the attention; a magnificent twostoreyed temple, whose propylon bore a dedication to Athena Nikephoros, the adjoining library housing Eumenes' precious collectionof books, and a new statueof Athena Parthenosmodelled on the Athenian original betokened her continued importance. I eI Of equalimportanceto all this activity, and arisingin part 'crowned' out of it, was the reinstitutionof the Nikephoriaas a panhellenicfestival, first celebratedon this basis in 181' and attestedby a seriesof documentsconcerningthe recognitionof the rsE/vP 60, : Sy//.3 595 A; cf' Kähler, Gr. Fries, 187' n.43. 18e/vP 156' cf. Ohlemutz, Kulte, 16. t e oM v P L 1 9 , 2 0 : O h l e m u t z , K u l t e , 3 9 . r e r S t r a b o x i i i . 4 . 2 , 6 2 4 , q u o t e d b e l o w ; s e e a l s o t h e s t u d i e s c i t e d a b o v e ' n2 ' F o r the temple of Athena Nikephoros, see lvP 149; E. Rohde, Griech. und röm. Kunst in den staatlichen Museen zu Berlin (1968), 49 and pl' 36'
Festivals of Athena
127
new festival and the d.ouAiaof the Nikephorion,to which we must now turn. The documentsare decreesof the Aitolians and the Delphic Amphiktyons recordingacceptanceof Eumenes'invitation to the 'crowned' festival,which consistedaccordingto this evidenceof games, the musical part ioonü?roE and the athletic and equine partsiooTüpnrcg(the Amphiktyonic decreeis datedto 182/l and provides the chronological key to these events); a letter of Eumenesto a Cariancity, mostprobablyIasos;anda letterto Kos, of which a secondsubstantialfragmentproviding important new information was publishedby Segrein 1948.te2A great deal of difficulty has been removed, and argumenteliminated,from our of thesetexts now that it has been convincingly understanding shown that the reorganizedcelebrationsattestedby them took placeregularlyevery five years,and at no time every three years, as was formerly taken for granted on the basis of a decree of PergamonhonouringMetris, the priestessof the ninth Nikephoria: the trieteric festival mentionedthere is not the Nikephoria,but the This conclusionconfirmsSegre'srestorationof line Dionysia.re3 l6 of Eumenes' letter to Kos, already supportedby comparison with the texts dealingwith the foundationof the Leukophryenaat Magnesiaon the Maeander,and all the ingeniousproposalsfor explainingor avoidingthe allegedinconsistencymay be dispensed with.leaEumenes'invitation is, as Segrerecognized,to a penöi tetericfestival(Appendixiv, no. 12,lines15-17):örcyvfax6rcE ouvreLeiv aöu1t nalvlqyuqiv re ötä nevltaetrlqlöoExai pouo.lxolügxai yultumoüE[xai innmoüg d.yCovaE]. In this letter Eumenestakes a personalcredit for the establishr e 2A i t o l i a n d e c r e e : S y l l . 3 6 2 9 , : D a u x , D e l p h e s , 2 9 9 - 3 0 1 , : F ' D e l p h e s ' i l i . 3 2 4 0 . A m p h i k t y o n i c d e c r e e :S y / / . r 6 3 0 , : D a u x , D e l p h e s , 2 9 3 - 5 , : F . D e l p h e s , ü i . l . 2 6 1 : c f . D a u x , E C I I l x x v i i i ( 1 9 5 4 ) ,3 7 0 - 1 . E u m e n e s ' l e t t e r s : t o a C a r i a n c i t y , probably Iasos: Welles,R C 49;cf . Segre (cited below); to Kos: Welles,^RC50; (with new fragment found in 1938)M. Segre ap. Robert, Hellenica, v (1948), 102-28; see A p p e n d i x i v , n o s . 9 - 1 2 . O n t h e c h r o n o l o g y , s e e L . R o b e r t , E C I I l i v ( 1 9 3 0 ) ,3 3 2 - 8 ; G . K l a f f e n b a c h , M D A I i i i ( 1 9 5 0 ) ,9 9 - 1 0 6 . r e r C . P . J o n e s ,C h i r o n , i v ( 1 9 7 4 ) , 1 8 3 - 9 . reaSegre envisaged two phases in the reorganization, but Klaffenbach showed conclusively that all the documents under consideration refer to the same procedure of 182/ I . Klaffenbach's restoration in line 16, öd ntv[O' i1pöpav], taken to mean'lastingforfivedays'isnotpossible:seeJ.andL.Robert,Bal/. 1952,no.127.
128
Attalid Kingdom after the Treaty of Apameia
ment of the cult, the designationNikephoros (lines 5-7, with Segre's restoration: IN txrlq öpov ] | rc np ooqyoq e6xapev, lxüJ" iou1v voltilovllreE eivat. xai oixercrfurllv tilv npooullvupiav raüqu), and two previous celebrations(lines 9-10: öigydp iiöry napaxlq9|lvteg öcp' ittöv ü.E rcl I navryyüpecgdE ürfe xarrlyye(|atrttvänoö6$ao0el I qt)"oEpövag). Even allowing for royal exaggeration,this evidenceseemsto confirm the conclusion we have already reached,that the festival of the Nikephoria socalled was an institution of EumenesII in the first years of his reign, and not of his predecessorAttalos I. We saw reasonearlier to associatethe cult epithet Nikephoros with the victory over Philip V of Macedonin 197, and we may reasonablydate the two 'earlier'celebrationsof Nikephoria referredto in Eumenes'letter to the 190s,before the outbreakof war with Antiochos III intervened.A date in the yearsafter the Antiochic War is not convincing, becauseEumeneswas then occupiedwith the restorationof the PergameneNikephorion, which Strabo describesin the context of the building programmedatableto the l80s (xiii. 4. 2,624): xareoxeüaoe ö' o6roE d1v nö)"w xai rö Nmqgdqrcv it)oet xai dva?fipata xai 6ß),rc)qxag xai tilv ini rooövöe xcrecpüreuoe xarorxiav toü Itepyd.pou rilv vüv oöoav öxelvoE xreooThe completionof the Nikephorion, and Eumenes' ecpü,oxäLqoe. defeatof the Galatiansand PrusiasI of Bithynia celebratedin the decreeof Telmessoswhich hailed Eumenesas Soter in 184/3, (Appendixiv, no. 7) doubtlessprovided the occasionfor refounding the Nikephoria as orecpaviratayöveE,as the decreesof the Aitoliansandthe Amphiktyonscall them, but the inspirationof the new Nikephoriamust be locatedin the defeatof Antiochosand the greatly increasedauthority attainedby Eumenesin the resulting just astheolderNikephoriahadbeentheresult Romansettlement, on a more modest scaleof the defeat of Philip V of Macedon. The Nikephoria remainedthe most important Pergamenefestival until after the formationof the Romanprovince,and the priestessesof Athena Nikephoros held an important position in the city's life, as inscribedbaseshonouringthreeof themattest:these are Metris, priestess of the ninth Nikephoria roü orecpavtrou dyövoE, 149reckoningon a pentetericbasis,the year of Attalos II's victory over PrusiasII of Bithynia; Biton, priestessof the
Officials of the Royal Administration
129
fourteenth Nikephoria in 129; and Asklepias, priestessof the eighteenthNikephoriain I 13.resIt was probablya regularpractice for the city to honour its priestessin a year in which Nikephoria were held; this is a further indication of the importanceof the festival both to Pergamonand to the king, as an outward signto the Greek world of his authority and influence after the Treaty of Apameia. (iv) Officials of the Royal Administration Like other Hellenistic monarchies,the Attalids evolved an administrative bureaucracy that was separatefrom the civil administrationof the capital (to be discussedin chapter7); most of our informationcomesas usualfrom epigraphicalsourcesrelating to the positions and activities of high-rankingofücials.1e6 Around the king stooda group of closeadvisers,of whom some, but not all, were his relatives.At their headwas the office of 6 öni röv npaypärav, one holder of which, Menogenes son of Menophantes,has recorded his title in a seriesof dedicatoryinscriptionsfrom Pergamonhonouringmembersof the royal family.ßz 16" peak of his careeris to be datedto the reignof Eumenes II, accordingto a decreefrom Nakrasa in which he is the honorand.les lot nqi NdlxpaoovMaxeööv4 dvrou, lMqvoyl6vr1vM qvocp louyyevqI 6aoÄ6a4 Eüptvou, [xai vo]pocp67axa, dpetfig övtxev fxai dvöqa]ya?iaE xai eüvofuE [npöE te dyt 6aoÄ6a xai öauroüE.
This dedicationshowsthat Menogeneswas concernedwith the re5Metris: /vP 167,: OGIS 299;Biron: IvP 223,: OGIS 322; Asklepias: IvP 226, : OGIS 324. For the chronology, see Jones 188-9, correcting the 'traditional' trieteric dates given by Ohlemutz, Kulte, 49-5O, and elsewhere. re6There is a valuable synthesis ofthe evolution ofthe Hellenistic bureaucracies by Rostovtzeff , SEHHW ii. 1079ff. For the Attalids, see Cardinali, RP 205 ff.; G. Conadi,Studi Hellenistici (Turin, 1929)347ff.; Hopp, Untersuchungen, 98-101. t e 7J v P 1 7 l - 6 , : O G I S 2 9 1 - 6 . T h e t i t l e s u r v i v e s i n f u l l o n l y i n l v P 1 7 4 T O G I S 294). but it can be restored in all the others. tet IvP, ä. p. 504, no. 176a, = OGIS 290, with the revisions of L. Robert, Vil/es, 75-6. Robert's restoration l"Alxpaoov is not followed, however, since the singular form NdxpaooE @r Ndxqaoou), which he rejected, is now attested: see P. H e r r m a n n , S B W i e n c l x v . l ( 1 9 6 9 ) ,7 - 3 6 : J . a n d L . R o b e r t , B u l l . 1 9 ' 1 0 ,n o . 5 1 2 .
l3l
Attqlid Kingdom after the Treaty of Apanteia
OfJicialsof the Royal Administration
affairs of an old subjectcity of the Attalids, and it is possiblethat the office he held gave him responsibilityfor the area of direct authorityinheritedfrom the rule of EumenesI, the natureof which was discussedin chapter 2. No regionalstrategosis attestedfor this area,and it is very likely that, like other partsof the kingdom' it was administeredby the officials of the royal administration. Menogeneswas most probably appointedto the office of ö ini rav npaypärav in the later part of Eumenes'long reign, sincehis nameappearsagaintogetherwith those of Athenaiosand Sosandros, relativesof Attalos II, in a letter written by Attalos to the whoseactivitieswill be reviewedin the priestAttis at Pessinous, nextchapter(Welles,RC6l). This chronologyis supportedby the evidenceof a dedicationmade by Menogenesto Attalos II (IvP 174.: OGIS 294),in which Attalos is namedwithout the royal title and was therefore not yet king:
commanderof a Pergameneforce which defendedElaia against PrusiasII of Bithynia in 15716,an event recordedby Polybios (xxxii. 25.10): (Prusias)oüööv öb npanew öuvätrtevoE öt'd.rö eioü"r1)"u9öra oüvrpocpov 26oavöpov röv roü 6aoÄtaE trterd otgattartbv eipyeLvaüroü täE inßd"dE, änfipevöni @uareipatv. We alsolearnfrom Attalos' letter to Athenaios,andfrom a letter of son-in-law AttalosIII to Kyzikos,datedto 135sc, that Sosandros' Athenaioswas appointedto the important priesthoodof Sabazios during Sosandros' lifetime, and that when Sosandros died, Athenaios succeededhim, combiningthe two priesthoods,of Dionysos Kathegemonand Sabazios,in one person.200 It is clear then from this evidencethat the king was servedin his royal administrationby familiesratherthan individuals,the son(or son-in-law)succeedingto the positionheld by his fatherevenwhen he held anotherposition already.The priesthoodof Sabazioswas of course a special matter in that Sabazioswas particularly associatedwith QueenStratonike,who brought the cult from Cappadocia,and it was naturalthat the priesthoodwould be preserved in the family of Sosandrosand Athenaios,who were relatedto the royal family: we cannotthereforereasonablyinfer a generalpolicy from this instance alone. There is however further evidence pointing to the sameconclusion. First to be consideredare two inscriptionsattestingoitvrgoEot is a populardedicationfor of Attalos II. One, from Pergamon,20r one Apollonidesson of Theophilos:
130
" An a )"ov 6 ao Ät ö IE' An d.\ou] voE ävft ou,l M1u oy 6v4E M 11 ö öni röv npaypdrov, dpletrlE övexevf xai tüvoictE rrlE eiE ö[auröv].
The king drew heavily for membersof the royal administration on a close circle of friends and relatives, as is shown by the frequentappearancein both literary and epigraphicalrecordsrelating to Pergamonof the king's oüwqocpot (companions)and ouyyevelE(relatives).Their service to the king assumedmany forms, and the family about which we know most' that of SosanThe evidros and Athenaios,providesthe clearestexamples'ree denceis derived mainly from three royal letters concerningtheir priesthoodsof Sabaziosand DionysosKathegemon,of which the first (Welles, RC 65) is addressedby Attalos II to his cousin Athenaios.He calls Sosandros,the son-in-lawof Athenaios,his oüvrpoEoE,and saysthat he hadbeenappointedpriestofDionysos Kathegemonby his brother Eumenes.He was thereforepriest at the beginningof Attalos' reign,and accordingto the sameletter he continued to hold the office until ill health preventedhim' This chronologicalpoint is of importance,becauseit showsthat he was still priest of Dionysos Kathegemonwhen he servedas military teeOGIS 331, : Welles, RC 65-7; cf. Ohlemutz' Kulte,90 ff. See also the dedication IvP 221, as interpreted by H. von Prort, AM xxvii (1902)' 161 ff'
ö örtpo[s] 'A no77avö v @eocp[).[ou ry ], s
töu oüvrpocpov toü 6aotAltaE,l äpnqE tvtxtv xai eüvotaE lr4gl npöE rt töu 6aoÄ6a xai 6aluröv).
The other is a dedication of Attalos II from the Athenian agora in
honour of another Theophilos, undoubtedlythe brother of the Apollonides attestedat Pergamon:202 2o0See, in addition to the references given in the previous note, my remarks on the cult of Sabazios at Pergamon and its political implications, inBSA lxvi (1971)' 8-9. zot IvP l7g, : oGIS 334. 2o2Hesperia, xxiii ( 1954), 252, no. f3, -- SEG xiv. 127;cf , Hesperia, xxvi (1957)' 8 6 : H a b i c h t . G n o m o n , x x x ( 1 9 5 8 ) ,3 1 7 .
132
Attalid Kingdom after the Treaty of Apameia "An oJog Qg[oÄ6o s' Art dlou] 16aoltA,eüE x ai 6 ao t).[oo [rlE "! ln ü"7av IöoE] l @ l e ö c p Ä o@ v e . .. . . . . . . l / e a ltlöv öawoö oöwpocpoltd'pet4lElEvex[a] 'A?1vatatv. IrqlE eiEöawöv xai töv öfipov üv
We turn now to another relationship. A certain Andronikos is mentioned by Polybios (xxxii. 16) as leader of a Pergamene embassy to Rome during the reign of Attalos II which pleaded the case against Prusias II of Bithynia, and in the Mithridateios of Appian (Mithr.4-5) he figures prominently in a subsequent plot to overthrow Prusias. He was evidently an important figure about whom we know all too little, and we may, with Fränkel, identify him as the honorand of a fragmentary decree which deals inter alia with the proceedings of an embassy, and calls the honorand a oüvrQoqoE of Attalos II:2o3 .loötbpou' lini nputd.ve@E
yvbprl olrparrlyCov' öyva öfipoE' Bnei_
rot 6aoL7öaEäv re rct[E ävayxctrcrdtorgro.räois;]. [. . . oüvtgo]cpoE lonouölaiaE yqe/agnapeioyqrat rd.ttte 6aoLAletxo,iratLöfipttt xt7.1 A dedication of the same reign from the Samian Heraion honours a man whom we may identi$ as Andronikos' brother: 'keeper of the Philopoimen son of Andronikos, strateSos and ggnl''20a
s
"AuaToE 6aoü'eüg 'AudTou 6aoL).6aE Q.tl o n o tPev a.' Av ö v 99 lxo1t rov orQdr1yov xcrl tltl rIE oqpaytöog dgtr4; Evexa
:;L:':",3i":;i:ä:"4' Hpat.
This Philopoimenwas commanderof the Pergameneforces present at Corinth in 146(Paus.vii. 16. 1 and 8), and accordingto an anecdoterecorded by Plutarch (Mor. 792)was the favourite adviser of Attalos Philadelphostowards the end of his life. 2o3IvP 224, = OGIS 323. The phi of oüvrpogog is discernible from a squeeze I made of the stone in Berlin in 1969. 2 o 4A M x l i v ( l 9 l 9 ) , 3 0 , n o . t 6 , : S E G i . 1 7 4 , : / G R i v . l 7 l 2 ; a p h o t o g r a p hw i l l b e found ap. Tölle, Die Antike Stadt Samos (Mainz, 1969),26. Another holder of the office of izi rtlE ocpqayi\oE was the slralegos Demetrios at Ephesos (Appendix iv, no. 25; see above, 88); see on this title Bengtson.Strot. ü.209-
Officials of the Royal Administration
133
The part played by these oüvrgoqoq collectively also called ävayxaioq was an activeand importantone, both in implementing royal policy, as did Menogenesat Nakrasa,and in helpingto form it, as we seemost clearly in the letter written by Attalos II to Attis already mentioned.Attalos had evidently met Attis at Apameia, and the two had discussedthe possibilityof military actionagainst a bandof Galatians(seebelow, chapter5); returningto Pergamon, Attalos consultedthe d.vayxaiot:il")övrav ftpö, I eiEll4pyapov 'A|qvarcv xai ouvayayövtoEltou oö pövov lxai 26oavögov xai Mr1voy6vr1v, d77ä xai htgouE il.etolvaE töv ävayxaiav xü.. It was one of these,Chloros,who urgeda policy of conciliationwith Rome, and the king himself finally subscribedto it, althoughthe decisionremainedhis.20sNo other documentof the Attalid chancery illustrates so well the factors which determinedroyal decisions and the meansby which they were reached. Apart from the office ofö öni töv npaypärav and the general designationsoüwpocpotand,ouyyeveig we do not know what titles, if any, thesecloseadvisersheld. Thereare other termsattestedby epigraphicalevidencewhich connotethoseespeciallyfavouredby the king, but theseterms are of ageneric nature, and conform to the patternestablishedin other Hellenistickingdoms,where various gradesof cptTotare attested.206 [t may be convenientto list the evidencerelating to the Attalids at this point. (I ) qil.oE IG ä.2 l+S 1Sy//.t651), lines 8-9. Decree honouringDiodoros (EumenesIl): Aööopog q{IloEl lünäpyav r6t 6aor).eiEöp6uet. This is the only Attalid exampleof the unqualifiedtitle Ei),og,and examplesof highergradesof Eü"ot are likewise rare: one such is Megon of Ephesos,who is mentionedby EumenesII in letters written to Iasos and Kos concerningthe reorganizationof the 2osAttalos uses the wordxpivttt of this final decision: txptvov oöu eiE ltiv t1i11v 'Ptitpqv dei ripner,v xr7. Cf. Cardinali, RP 205-6, and on the significance of the wordxpiva in connoting a royal decision, Welles, RC, p. 83. 206On these titles, see G. Corradi, Studi Hell.3l8 ff.; A. D. Momigliano, A t h e n a e u m , x i ( 1 9 3 3 ) , 1 3 6 4 1 ; H o l t e a u x , E t u d e s , i i i . 2 2 0 f f . ( f r o m B C H 1 9 3 3 ) .O n the Seleukid 9i,1or see also Bickermann, In st. Sö1.4l ff. It is important to note that the graded status of the g/tror (four grades according to Momigliano) were evidently common to all the Hellenistic monarchies. and the Analids were therefore following normal practice.
134
Attalid Kingdom after the Treaty of Apameia
PergameneNikephoria (seeabove, iii): Kos: Appendix iv, no. l2:2o1Mfyowa I'Eq6oLov, tav E(7av töv npo-?ll tqtaptvov nap' riplrt. t (or Iasos: Appendix iv, no. 11: M l6yon d.r e rtttv E iTav iv r tpfi t [rr1t npar 11 peytot4L) nap' fipiv övra (or övta naq' ipiv) ). Another is attested by a dedication from Attondae (MAMA vi.68):2ö7av 'Arrä[ou, cptAoEnpöroE.
These titles are more common in the Seleukid, Pontic, and, and it is perhapsnot above all, the Ptolemaicadministrations,20s surprisingthat they shouldappearlessfrequentlyin our evidence for the more closely centralizedAttalid administration' (2) napd. töL 6aoü.ei önrpi6av, xrA. IG ä.2 947, lines 15-17.DecreehonouringTheophilos(?166/5): inuöi1 @eölEÄloEllegylalprlvöEeüvo)uEönäpyav üt [öq]pl@)t npötegövre önrg[6utv [napd.rai fiaoLfteiEüp|vel xai öv rrye[I övl naq' aüröt xtA. of This is surely the man we have already met as oüvrpocpoE as honorary EumenesII; the presenttitles may then be considered rather than constitutionallyspecific. 'EnQovoE/apoxqd.teug Appendixiv, no. 26 (decreeof Kyme): 'Attd)-E. TapavrtvoE| öntgßav napä Qt 6aoüel (3) oixeiog IG ä.2953,lines6-7. Decreehonouringa manwhosenamehasnot survived on the stone (160/59): loixleioE öv rcü 6aoÄ6o4 EüptvouExrL. (4) t6v nportpa4t|van of Ad. Wilhelm'Wien' IG ä.2946(Syll.3655,with the supplements Anz. 1921,81),line 8: MövavöqoEIleqyapryvö;tlöv pd'AtoranLo' reuoptvav xai cLpalttvavl naqd rfot 6aoAel EÜptveLxrL' Although the evidenceis not copious, it seemslikely from the casesreviewedthat thesewere in the main honorarytitles with no particularconstitutionalor administrativesignificance;the caseof Theophilos bears this out, as do Menogenesand Philopoimen' 20?The restoration is that of H olleaux,Etudes. ili.222, which is preferable to that of Momigliano, art. cit. 140: 1töv nptbtav (sc' qiTav) xai npolttpupivwv 208See the studies cited above, n' 206.
Officials of the Royal Administration
135
becausethey had specifictitles in additionto the apparentlyhonorary ones. We may conclude,then, that a numberof the royal advisersdid not have official titles designatingparticularspheres of authorityor activity,but wereemployedin diversecapacities as the king chose. It is importantto point hereto the fact that at leastthreecitizens of Ephesosservedimportant roles in the royal administration. One,Megon,hasbeenmentionedabove,as acpü"oE of the highest category. A second, Hikesios, was ri xuraora9eiE in' Aiytvqg (Sy/l.3642),anda third, whosenameis not known, was appointed by Attalos II to be the mentor of his nephew,the future Attalos III (Appendix iv, no. 24). lt is probable then that when Ephesos becameAttalid in 188,it providedthe royal administrationwith a numberof officials who were able to reachhigh rank, and it is not surprisingthat the king drew on the considerableadministrative experienceof this city. This policy correspondsto the high regard for Ephesoswhich we have elsewhereattributed to the Attalid kings in other contexts,but the extent to which this policy was applied, and whether it was applied to other cities besides Ephesos,cannotin the presentstateofthe evidencebe adequately determined.It is significantin this regard,however,that Ephesos and Tralles, as we saw earlier, played an important part as royal mints after the Treaty of Apameiain additionto the principalmint at Pergamon.
The Galatians
5 THE GALATIAN S throughout An eventwhich was to havethe greatestrepercussions the Galaof the entry was Minor Asia of history the subsequent was consolidating Philetairos when time very tiansin 27817 ,t at the his position at Pergamon.Records of their activity and of their relations with the dynasts at Pergamonare naturally more complete for the reignsof Attalos I and his successors,while for the first thirty years or so of their occupationwe rely on the chance evidenceof contemporarydocumentsand traditionspreservedin the works of local historiansand transmittedto us by later writers. It is only by thesemeansthat we can examinetheir methodsand aims,as well as the reactionsof the Greekcitiesand other inhabitants of Asia Minor. The only useful referenceto the Galatians' activitiesas a whole is a curious one in Strabo (xii' 5' 1,566): xar1oyov öä rilv ybgav raürryv (i'e' Galatia) o[ fa)"drat nLavrl7|uteEnoAüvypövov xo,ixaraöqaltdweErilv ünö roig'Arra).m'oiE6aot)"eüotybpav xai roiE BßuvoiE, Eaq nag' öx6vttov il.a1ov rilv vüv faAatiav xai fa)J.oypalxtrv )'eyop6v4v'2This is the only evidenceof a generalnature to suggestthat the Attalid rulers were concernedwith the settlementof Galatians,although clearly it cannot be acceptedas it stands.There is specific evidenceof this policy in the case of Attalos I, as we shall see,but none refersto settlementof Galatianswithin Pergameneterritory. That Philetairoswon a victory over a bandof Galatiansseemsto be shownby a metrical dedicationinscribedon a baseat Delos; the Philetairosis not specified,but the letter-formspoint almost cerI Pausaniasx.73. l4datesthe entry of the Galatiansinto Asia Minor to the year See,in general,F. Stähe|in,Gesch.der of the Athenianarchon Demok|es,2781.7, i. 490 ff.; M. wörrle, Galater,T ff.; M. Launey,Recherches, kleinasiatischen 'AntiochosI, Achaiosder Altere und die Galater" inChiron' v (1975)'59-87' On below' n' 6' the chronology,seeM' Launey,REA xlvi (1944)'218' n' 2' and r Referenceito particularmethodsused by the Galatiansin their raids can be in the text foundin Livy xxxviii. |6. |2_|3,and in the decreeofPriene mentioned It'Pr 17, = OGIS 765).
r37
tainly to Philetairosthe Founder.rIf authentic,this victory occurred at about the sametime as the victory of Antiochos I, attested by Appian but undated;athe two battlesmay havebeenconnectei with the samesubsidiarymovementof the Galatiansbut thereis no reasonto believe that the celebrationof Philetairos'successwas due to participationin Antiochos' victory ratherthan to a separate victory. In addition to his own direct action against the Galatians Philetairosis known to have offered substantialassistanceto at least one independent city, Kyzikos.5 The chronology of Philetairos' donations is fairly well established;they include money, supplies, and contributions to the Eü"axfi rfig ytbpaE, notably in 21817,when a band of Galatianspassedclose to the territory of Kyzikos on its route to the interior of Asia Minor.6 In 3IG xi.4. l 105,: Durrbach,Choix, 31.This inscriptionis discussedaboveand datedto the reignof AttalosI, 3 | n. 8. a Syr. 65. Cf. Stähelin,12-14;the colourful accountin Lucian, Zeuxis 8-ll, is defendedby B. Bar-Kochva,Proc.Camb. Phil..Soc.cxcix (1973),l-8, who dares the battle to 'shortly after April 272'. Segre'sdate,278/7(Athenaeum,viii (1930), 53-6) seemsto me to be too early in view ofthe restofthe chronology;c.272,after the end of the first Syrian war, is preferable,althougha date shortly beforethe outbreakofthiswar,t.2T6/5,isalsopossible(soLauney,REA xlvi(1944),234,n.1; Magie,RomanRule li.7ll,n. 12).Seenow M. Wörrle,Chiron,v (1975'1,65-72. s OGIS 748:.see above. 15n. 20. 6 The inscriptionrecordsthe donationsof Philetairoslistedaccordingto the years of the Kyzikene eponymousmagistrates,as follows: Gorgippides money for äyaveE andcpuAaxiltqE XöpctE. Bouphantides ärü.en tfiE 7eiaE. Phoinix cpulaxl t4q X6qag Poseidon Diomedon
money eig ö)"arcv xai ouvayayilv töv ytav. supplies iv töL toLöpat tdtt tpög rcüE fald.rag yevop{uau
The first editors dated Diomedon lo 278t7 from the reference under his name to a Galatian war; this chronology however raises a difficulty in dating Gorgippides as early as 282l l. Dittenberger (OG1S ad loc. , n. 7) argued an alternative chronology, associatingthereferencedriBoucpavtiöou,nokp40t[or1grfigXöeaEwiththewars involving Antiochos I, Nikomedes of Bithynia, and Antigonos Gonatas, thus making Phoinix the magistrate of 27817, the year of the Galatians' arrival in Asia Minor. This chronology has been convincingly endorsed by Launey, inREA xlvi (1944), 2 l7 ff. , where a relief from Kyzikos showing Herakles fighting an opponent (which Launey showed to be a Galatian), and also dated 3zi (Dolvuog innapyou (cf . BCH lvi (1932), pl. xxv), was shown to have represented an appeal from the city to the god when threatened by an attack from the Galatians under Loutarios; these, according to Livy's account of their entry into Asia Minor (xxxviii. l6), had to pass near Kyzikos to rejoin the Galatians under Leonnorios. M. Segre adopted a chronology earlier than this by two years @thenaeum, väi (1930), 488 ff.), and s u b s e q u e n t l yo n e e a r l i e r b y o n e y e a r ( l t h e n a e u m , x i i ( t 9 3 4 ) , 4 3 1 , n . 2 ) .
138
The Galatians
gratitude, the city instituted a festival named Philetaireiain his honour (seebelow, chaPter6). The aimsof the Galatiansseemfrom the beginningto havebeen settlementand security.Their attackon Ilion, accordingto Strabo a 'kind of village-town' (xwp6nd'tg rtE i1v), and according to Demetriosof Skepsisas recordedby Straboin the samepassage (xiii. I .27,594), very much in declinebeforethe AntiochicWar, "'Hyqoüvan was evidentlyinspiredby their needfor a stronghold öä roüEfaldrag, ntqata\|vtaE ix r4EEüprbnrlEdvaflrlvatpiv tiE rilv nö)'w öeotrttvougtghparoE, napaygfipa ö' ixlmeiv öLd'rö äre(yrcrov. When defeatedby the dynasts of Asia Minor, they were dealt with by the assignationof settlements;after Attalos' greatvictory they were settledin the part of GreaterPhrygiawhich becameGalatia,in all probabilityby MithridatesII of Pontos,who had received this territory on the occasionof his marriagewith Laodike, the sisterof SeleukosKallinikos.?It was probablyfor similarreasonsthat the Galatiansenteredthe serviceof kings as mercenariesor as allies:8Attalos of Pergamonafter their defeat (seebelow),AntiochosHierax, the kingsof Bithyniaand, above all, the kings of Pontos.The Kaqtxd' of Apollonios,accordingto "Ayxupa,referredto the settlement Stephanosof Byzantion,s.v' by Mithridates I (died 266)and Ariobarzanes(266-256)of Galatiansin alliancewith them againstEgypt; this is goodevidencethat the Galatiansattachedthemselvesfrom the beginningto the kings of pontos,by whom they were given landsin exchangefor military service, rather than to the kings of Bithynia, from one of whom they had receivedthe initial invitation to crossinto Asia.ewe have recordsof three significantGalatianrevolts in theseyears:the first in Pontos in the reign of Ariobarzanesin which the king himself perished,the secondduring the war of the Seleukidbrothers,and the third during the expeditionundertakenby Attalos I of Pergamon in 218sc. In the lasttwo cases,wherewe haveevidence,the 7 Straboxii. 5. l, 566,quotedabove;Pausaniasi. 4' 5, 8. 2. Justinxxxviii. 5. 3 (marriage-alliance betweenMithridatesII and SeleukosKallinikos,c.245).I follow (l'eipzig, herethJconclusionsof Ed. Meyer,Geschichtedes KoenigreichsPontos other For passage' Strabo of the 1879),43-51, as offering the best explanation views,see Mzgie,RomanRule, ä' 731' n. 13. e on the statusofthe Galatiansservingin the kings' armiesseeabove,29 n. 4. 9 FGrHist740,F14.The deathof MithridatesI: Diod. xxiii. SeeEd. Meyer,op' cit. (n. 7), 43 ff.
The Galatians
r39
Galatianswere dealt with by meansof settlement.roFor this reasonit seemslikely that during the years when Philetairosand ruled at Pergamon,someGalatians,who EumenesI successively (aswe know) plunderedwesternAsia Minor and were defeatedby Philetairos,were settledin the small area of Pergameneterritory thenestablishedandformedan importantpart of its consolidation. For the reignof Attalos I the evidencebecomesclearerandmore substantial.We have alreadyfound reasonto relate the activities of the Galatiansin the early years of his reign to the individual allianceshe concludedwith numerousGreekcities and confirmed in 2 l8 (seeabove,chapter3), andthis pointcannow beelaborated. There is a body of local evidenceconcerningGalatianattackson Greekcities;in additionto theevidencefor Ilion, alreadycited,we have a number of honorary decrees voted by Greek cities in recognitionof the braveryof individualsduringGalatianattacks.A decreeof Prienehonoursa certain Sotasfor bravery and initiative in defendingthe city againsta Galatianattack,and a similardecree of Erythrai honoursthe entire board ofstrategoi for the part they played in defendingtheir city against an attack from Galatians underLeonnorios.Among Philetairos'donationsto Kyzikos,according to the decreeof that city already discussed(OGIS 748), werequantitiesof corn contributedövtöt nol{pat lrfu npögroüg laAd.raEyltvoptvol (linesl8-19). A privatededicationof a man from ThyateirathankingApollo for rescuingthe man's sonri,troüE ünö röv fa).ätav may alsobe connectedwith theseactivities.rrIn the case of Miletos, as of Ilion, a Galatian raid was recorded (according to Parthenius)by a local historian, Aristodemos of Nysa, and the city's resistanceis celebratedin an epigramattriFinally, an inscriptionfrom Denizli buted to Anyte (AP vii. 4921.r2 ro Revolt and settlement under Antiochos Hierax: Justin xxvii. 2l under Attalos I: P o l y b .v . 7 8 . 1 - 5 . rrPriene: IvPr 17,: OGIS 765. Erythrai: see above, 29 n. 5. Thyateira: K e i f - v o n P r e m e r s t e i n ,Z v ' e i t e R e i s e , n o . l 9 ; M a g i e , R o m a n ' R u l e , i i . 7 3 0 - 1 , n . I l . See in general on this evidence M. Wörrle, Chiron, v (1975),614. r2 Parthenius viii. I ff. This evidence may however relate to later events: see Rehm, Milet, i. 245; Parthenius' story of a man of Miletos who travelled to Gaul in search of his captured wife implies a Greek awareness of the Gauls and their geography that is not easily attributable to the early third centrury, before the Romans appeared on the scene: see A. D. Momigliano, Alien Wisdom (Cambridge, 1975), 57-60: A. S. F. Gow and D. L. Page, The Greek Anthology, Hellenistic Epigrams, Anyte xxiii (commentary, ii. 89 ff., 103 f.), : Page, Epigr. Graeca, Anyte xxii: the epigram relates the suicide of Milesian women captured by the Galatians.
140
The Galatians
near Izmir publishedin 1975recordsa decreeof the settlementsof Neonteichosand Kiddioukome,datedto the month Peritiosof the forty-fifth year of the joint rule of Kings Antiochos and Seleukos (:Jan. 267), honouring two offrcials of the elder Achaios' Banabelosand Lachares,for redeemingprisonerscapturedby the Galatiansin the niAepog falatrnöE.l3 Evidently then traditionsdevelopedon the themeof resistance to the Galatiansin the first half of the third century, a resistancein which the Greek cities concernedtook considerablepride. with the Greek cities Attalos I of Pergamonwas equallya victim of the Galatians;he too choseto defy them by refusingthe usual tribute they exacted,laandit is in this contextthat the alliancesconcluded by Attalos should be placed, although,as we have seen(above, chapter3), they subsequentlyservedother purposes'We now see more clearly the significanceof Attalos' great victory at the river Kaikos andhis assumptionof the royal title; assuccessfuldefender of the Greek cities of western Asia Minor he could justly call himself king. According to the literary sources the Galatiansnow moved eastwardsand were settledin territory belongingto MithridatesII of Pontos.Some,however,evidentlyremainedin Attalid territory to servein Attalos' armies,including,accordingto Polybios(v '77 ' 2), the army which accompaniedhim on his military expeditionof 218.We have found reasonto believethat this policy was a common one perhapsalready exercisedby his two predecessorsas well as by other rulers in Asia Minor. The implicationof Polybios' statementis that theseGalatianshad beensettledin Attalid territory, and we may infer from what we have seenof their intentions that this settlementwas a major incentive for enlistingwith Attalos,just as the Galatianswho servedwith the kings of Pontos were rewarded with lands in their kingdom. We may conclude then that the Galatianswho swarmedinto resortedto two chief meansof survival:their Asia Minor in 27817 periodic demandsfrom dynastsand cities alike for tribute in exchangefor freedomfrom attack, andtheir enlistmentin the service 1 3M . W ö r r l e , C h i r o n , v ( 1 9 7 5 ) ,5 9 - 8 7 . raLivy xxxviii. l6; on the nature ofthis tribute, seeabove, ch. 3. The Galatians of evidently demanded tribute from the cities as well as the dynasts, as the decree l 5 ' n ' 7 3 2 ' i i ' R u l e ' R o m a n M a g i e , C f . s h o w s . a b o v e Ervthrai mentioned
The Galatians
l4l
of the dynasts,from the invitation of Nikomedesto their partial settlementby Mithridates of Pontos. As far as the Attalids are concerned,however,they no longerservedin any significantway as mercenariesafter the reign of Attalos I; from that time they appear in our sourcesrather as their enemies.In fact, relations between the Galatiansand Attalos I also are not straightforward; we have seen that he took a band of Galatianswith him on his expeditionof 218,but his intentionmay havebeenas much to find a locationfor their settlementasto usethem asa contributionto his military power, a considerationthat is indicatedby their attitude when they revolted,and by Attalos' readinessto complywith their demandsfor settlement.l5 Attalos' great victory at the river Kaikos should be regarded, accordingto the evidenceof his monuments,as a victory over the Galatiansfighting for their own ends,and not as a part of his later war with Antiochos Hierax, with whom Galatiansservedas mercenaries,16 but there is no indication in the admittedly scant evidence of a major Galatian war fought in its own right until the hostilitiesof the l60s which we shall considervery shortly. We have in this connectionto recognizetwo aspectsof the Galatians' activities: their raids on Greek cities and on the territories of Bithynia and Pergamon,in which context shouldbe placedAttalos' victory at the river Kaikos; and their co-operationas mercenarieswith the enemiesof Pergamon,namelyAntiochosHierax, PrusiasI of Bithynia, andPharnakesI of Pontos,which becamethe principalfeatureof Galatianhostility to Pergamonin the reignsof Attalos' successors.rT We have seen that during the war with Pharnakesin particular, Pergameneinterestsin Galatiawere directly threatened,and there is someevidencethat in the years following this war Eumenesundertookto consolidatehis authority in the area,an essentialstepaslong asthe Galatianswereprepared to fight alongsidehis enemies.We may now turn to considerthe chronology and significanceof this activity. 15Polyb. v. 78. Note especially 78. 3: (Attalos) 4ptlav ptv aöröv oüöepiav ö\ooppr1 xoptl6pevoE. Up to this time the Galatians had shown themselves to be precarious allies, often proving to be as much a liability as an asset to the kings they served; see the cases cited by Launey, Recherches, i. 492 ff. 1 6M a g i e , R o m a n R u l e , ü . 7 3 4 , n . 2 0 ; s e e a b o v e , c h . 3 , a n d b e l o w , A p p e n d i x ii. 17Antiochos Hierax: see above, ch. 3. Prusias I: 79. pharnakes: 79: cf. polvb xxv.2.4.
142
The Gtlatians
Perseus' After the defeatof Perseusof Macedon,the Galatians' A Performer allies, launched a surprise attack on Eumenes' Crassus' Licinius P' and 168' in gameneembassywassentto Rome to patch ih. Rornunconsulof 171,arrivedin Asia in 167ostensibly and however' up a peace at Smyrna.l8The initiative failed' Galatia' We Eumenesresorted to direct military intervention in intervenhave only fragmentaryand incidentalreferencesto this of fragment is a these of important tion in the literary sources:most inwhich but context lacks Diodoros' history (xxxi.l4), which inot1forms us that Eumenesnctvrö fa)'ärory E|vog önoyeiqnv control in oclro.te This strongly implies an intention to retain of military conquest' Galatiabeyondthe immediateconsequences Attalid policy with in feature new and accordingly indicates a regard to the Galatians. Eumenes' Further evidence in this regard may be found in one with Attis' the priestof Kybeleat Pessinous' correspondence to this of the principal religious centres of Galatia'2oAccording correspondenceitwasthroughAttis'collaborationthattheAtpart of it talidsmaintaineda control over the country' or ratherthe rs Polyb. xxix. 22.4; cf. xxv. 6.3; xxix. 9' l3; Livy xlv' 34' l0 Cf Niese' iii' 200' Mogistrates of the Romon For p. Licinius Crassus, see T. R. S. Broughton, (envoy in 167)' ( c o s ' 4 3 5 1 7 l ) ' 4 1 6 i . l 9 5 l ) , Y o r k , Republit'(New Eumenes' brother Attalos ih. P.rgurn"ne embassy to Rome in 168 included foremost Stoic in (Polyb. xix. l-3; Livy xiv. l9), and Krates of Mallos' the (Suetonius, de gram' scholarship Pergamene in figure leading and a ir";;;." rege " ' sub ipsam Ennii m a t i c i s2 : C r a t e s ' . . r , i s s u s a t l s e n a l u m a b A t t a l o king must be a mistake-for the of name the date, the of view In (: 169) mortem ). Scholarship' 2!5'n' (History of Classical II, as R. Pfeiffer has indicated But.n.. forcb Ä ttalo we should read 2); the suggestion of Hansen,A ttatids, l2l,n' 166'that did not share the royal title this ,;^ ,qttiti, does not explain rege, since Attalos II On Krates at Pergamon' see one' correct upp.o".h is therefore the "-ivtpf.iff"t't Pfeiffer, 21546. ItisclearfromPo|ybios'accountofAttalos'missionthattheSenate'smain concernatthistrmewaswithlimitingEumenes'power'ratherthanwithsolvingthe l' 6: röv ydp nltiotav'Papatav Galatian problem; note especially Polyb' xxx' dnrl)J"otptovp|vav rfiE rcü 6aoülo4 EiptvouE eövoiag' re A probable vrctory monument of this war is /vP 165 (with an additional A Delphian decree accepting a f.agment published in ÄM xxvii (1902)' 90' no' 74)' refers to Eumenes' war as [röv festival of Sardis for Athena und King Eumenes note l2). I have xivöuvoy (OGIS 305, lines il-12, with Diuenberser's iirr"rl 'uii"uav his standing rn to victory Galatian of Eumenes' "rnpt "sized the importance gb); this importance was first realized by cardinali, RP the Greek world (above, 103 ff. 2 0O G I S 3 1 5 , = W e l l e s , R C 5 5 - 6 1 .
The Galatians
143
centredon Pessinous, andthe secondofthe lettersshowsthatthey personallysupportedAttis' positionat Pessinousin the face of rivalry from his own family, doubtlessas a quid pro quo for his co-operation(Welles,RC 56,lines3-7):öxoprcdpqvi1v nagd.oou pou negi tdtu ltle xalrd üv inrcroAfiv, I iv tlL öLeorcacprjx€q äöeAEdvoou AioL6pryayeypaplpivou.ög1öE oöv xa?' öneq6ü"lv ötlfura xü.. The positionof Attis at Pessinousis in some ways comparableto that of the priest Korris at Labraundain the third century;both seemto haveheld their positionsas of family right, and both dependedlargelyon the favour of the dynasts.2l The letters are mainly concernedwith the need for periodic military activity in Galatia,and there are severalreferencesto Pergamene armiesstationedthere.The permanence of this situation is furtherindicatedby the complaintsof PrusiasII of Bithynia to the Roman Senatein 16514that Galatiaremainedunder the occupationof Pergamenetroops,as thoughthe needfor them, that is, thedurationof Eumenes'war, wasalreadyover.22 This is not to say, however,that Galatiawas treatedas an Attalid provinceon the linesof the territoriesacquiredin 188nc. The evidencepoints ratherto a seriesof major campaignsundertakenin the early 160s, which strengthened Attalid influencein the areabut requiredcontinued military occupationand secretcollaborationwith Attis at Pessinous.It was important,as the Galatians'activitiesin recent yearshad shown, that Attalid influencein Galatiashouldbe maintained,but it is extremelyunlikelythat the Attalidseverregarded Galatiaas part of their kingdom, or controlled more than certain parts of the country at any one time. UnderAttalosII thisalreadylimitedcontrolin Galatiaevidently weakened.The last substantialitem in the correspondencewith Attis is a letter in which Attalos refers to the need for military action, but admitsthat this coursecould not be adoptedfor fear of Rome'sdisapproval.23 Thereis evidencenonethe lessthatAttalos maintainedmilitary activity in the areaon a limited scale.According to Trogus (Prol. xxxiv), mortuo regeAsiae Eumenesuffectus Attalus bellumcum Selegensibus habuit et cum regePrusia.As we 2rSee,on Korris,J. Crampa,Labraunda,iii. l. 75 ff. z: Polyb. xxx. 20. 2-3:' cf. Niese ii' 200ff. 2rOGIS 315 VI. : Welles,RC 60.
r44
The Galatians
have seen,this war is to be dated to the 150s,in the first yearsof Attalos' reign. It was clearly not a major war of the kind fought by Eumenesin the l60s; its main objectivewas evidentlyto maintain authority in the area of Galatia adjoining Selgeand Amlada, and to securethe allegianceof frontier positions such as these.2aThis evidencesupportsthe implicationsof Attalos' letter to Attis, that he wishedto avoid total commitmentin Galatia,and had no intention of attemptingto control the entire country' It is possible,furthermore,that Galatiansservedas alliesor as mercenariesin the pay of PrusiasII duringthe war with Attalos, as can be inferredfrom the words of Trogusjust quoted:bellum cum . . . et cum regePrusia.Althoughthe evidenceis too selegensibus limited to allow certainty on this point, it is clear that Attalos' control over Galatiacontinuedto be piecemealand tentative;that his wars were of a local nature not designedto support a direct administrationin the country as a whole; and that vigorousmeasures were taken to establishthe co-operationof the important strategic positions at Selge and Amlada' This evidence, then, confirms the conclusionsreachedfor Eumenes' reign as to the statusof Galatia in relation to the Attalid Kingdom as a whole. Galatia could never be regardedas a singleentity, let alone be controlledas such, but it compriseddistinct groupsof occupation suchas that centredon Pessinous.It was with one or anotherbut not with all of thesegroups that the dynastsof Asia Minor concludedalliancesand from one or anotherthat they recruitedmercenariesfrom time to time asthe needarosein the third and second centuries BC. Eumenes II and Attalos II of Pergamondid not undertakemilitary interventionin Galatiain order to increasetheir kingdom but in order to counter the influence of their enemies, who rightly saw the Galatiansas a meansof containingAttalid powerand authoritY. 2 aS e e a b o v e , 1 0 2 .
6 ROYAL CULTS Like their contemporariesin other dynasties,the Attalidsreceived a wide range of secularand religioushonours from the cities of Asia Minor and the Greek mainland,and the nature and scaleof thesehonoursis a reflection of their authority and renown in the eyesof thosewho honouredthem: againthe reignof Attalos I and the creationof the new kingdom in 188appearto mark the important stagesin their development. Certain distinctionshave to be borne in mind in any consideration of Hellenisticroyal cults, and theseareespeciallyimportantin the case of the Attalids. The first, and most important, is the difference between worship and deification.r From the reign of Attalos I onwardsAttalid kingswerethe objectsof wide andvaried cult practice,both within and beyond the limits of their kingdom, but it was not until after 188Bc that any of them was calleda god in narne,and then it was usually done after death, with the single known exceptionof Miletos, whosecircumstanceswere reviewed in a previous chapter.2A seconddistinction concernsmotive. It was one thing for the king to enforcea centralizedimperialcult of himselfor membersof his family, of the kind now well attestedfor the Seleukidsunder Antiochos III, and quite anotherfor a city to institute an individual cult on its own initiative and in circumstancesarising from its relationswith a particular king.3We t Habicht, Gottmenschentum,206 ff.; see also the remarksof köaux, Monde hell. i. 238 ff. 2 Seeabove, ll4-19. rFor the centralizedSeleukidcults, see Holleaux,Etudes,iii. 165-81 (from BCH 1930);Welles,RC 36-7; Wilcken, SB Berlin. 1938,298-321;Robert,Ilellenica,vä (1949),l-29 andCRAI 1967,281-94. For the Attalid cults, seein general Cardinali,RP139-7Z;Daux,BCII lix (1935),210-3O;AvPix. 84ff.; Habicht,Gottmenschentum,124-6; and,for cults associatedwith Dionysos,H. von Prott,AM x x v i i ( l $ 2 ) , 1 6 1 - 8 8 ( w i t h R o b e rEt ,t . a n a t . 2 5 - 6 ) l O h l e m u t z , K u l tge0, f f . ; P . M . Fraser,REÄ liv (1952),242tr.; A. W. Pickard-Canbndge,Dram.Festivals,279ff. Hansen,Attalids,453 ff. adds nothingofimportance to the discussion.
146
Royal Cults
need, finally, to rememberthat it was not the lot or prerogative only of subjectcitiesto worshipor otherwisehonourthe kingswho were their suzerains;free cities could and frequently did honour with equalor greaterextravagancethosewho were their benefactors. As a corollary to this, the presenceof a royal cult in a city is not necessarilya mark or indicationof its status,aswe shallshortly seeat Miletos, Kos, and elsewhere. We may further divide the honourspaid to the Attalids broadty into the secularand religiouskind (althoughthe distinction is not alwaysa real one),the first consistingmainly of eponymousfestivals called Attaleia, Eumeneia,or whatever name was appropriate, and the secondof worship and deificationas differentiated above. The earliest known eponymousfestivals are the Philetaireia and Eumeneia on Delos, which, unlike those to be consideredshortly, were initiated and financed by the dynasts themselvesand are an indicationof their claimsto dynasticstanding in the Greek world rather than of its recognition.a At Kyzikos we hear of a festival named Philetaireia,which is probablyto be associatedwith the supportthat Philetairosgaveto the city when it was under threat from the Galatiansin the 270s;it was the city's methodof expressinggratitudeto its benefactorand conforms with practicesthroughoutthe Hellenistic world in the third and second centuries.sComparableare the Eumeneia at Pergamonitself, which are mentionedin the city's decreehonouring its board of strategoiand are not to be associatedsimply with Eumenes' position as dynast: he is called Euergetes,and the honoursare such that any Greek city might bestowon a benefactor.o Honoursof this kind continuein the reign of Attalos I, and their extent and location are predictably more widespreadin accordancewith the extendedrange of contactshe established,especially through his alliancewith Rome' in the Aegeanand on the Greekmainland.In this contextwe may put the Attaleiaassociated with the gymnasiumat Kos; these were probably instituted on a IG xi.2. 224A.line 4; seefurtherabove,22 n. 46. s CIG 3660,linel5; seeRobert,Er' anat. 199-201;Habicht' Gottmenschentum' 124.Seealsoabove,15n' 20. 6OGIS 267,discussedbelow, 166-8.
Royal Cults
147
behalf of Attalos I and are a further sign of that king's concernto cultivate allies in the south-westAegeanas a supportagainstthe threat of Philip V of Macedon in the early years of the third century.TThe newly attestedAttaleiaat Aiolian Kyme may alsobe connected with the first Attalos, and specificallywith the diplomatic activity of 218 in which Kyme played an important part (seeabove, chapter 3 (i)), but the city's decreein which they are mentionedis probablyto be datedto the reignof Attalos II, and so this later bearerofthe namemay be the honorandof the Attaleia.8 Attalos I was the first of his dynasty to receivecult honoursin the full sense.At Sikyon, accordingto a passageof Polybioswhich has survivedout ofcontext, he receivedan annualsacrifice,and a colossal statue of him was placed beside that of Apollo in the agora,an act renderinghim effectivelyoüvvaoEwith Apollo.r An inscriptionin Athenswhich in my view recordsa decreeof Aigina, refers to Attalos as being madeoüvvaoEwith the island's hero Aiakos and also mentions the setting aside of temene (plural), althoughthe context and detailsofthe honoursare not preserved on the stone.r0This text is to be datedto the lastyearsof the third century, after Attalos had acquiredthe islandin 210,and it is also to this time that we may date the establishmentat Athens of a priesthoodof Attalos and a tribe namedafter him.rr These cult activities constitute a major advancein honours paid to the Attalids, and were later to provide precedentsfor the honours enjoyed by thelastofthe dynasty,AttalosIII Philometor.They areto be regardedas a direct resultof the greatrenownwon by Attalos in the Greek world by his defenceof Greekfreedomboth againstthe Galatiansin Asia Minor, and as Rome's ally againstPhilip V of Macedonin Asia Minor and the Aegean.r2 Thesecults institutedfor Attalos I were nonethe lessoccasional 7 Sy//.3 1028, : F. Sokolowski,Lois sacröes des citös grecques (Paris, l%9), 165, A. 8. See now S. M. Sherwin-White,Ancient Cos (Hy pomnemata,li,1978), 132-1. 8G. Petzl and H. W. Pleket,Chiron, ix (1979),73-81; Appendix iv, no.26. e xviii. 16. t o I G ä . 2 8 8 5 ; A p p e n d i x i v , n o . 2 ; I d i s c u s s e dt h i s t e x t i n 8 S Ä l x v i ( 1 9 7 l ) , l - 1 2 . tt IG li.2 5080; the priesthood is probably to be associated with the creation ofthe tribe Attalis in 200 sc (Polyb. xvi. 25. 9; Cardinali, AP 145-6). t2 See Polyb. xviii. 4l . 9, which refers to Attalos ayavrlöpevoE önip rqg röv ' E ).lfi v tttv il.t u 0 q iaE.
148
Royal Cults
andadhoc, anddespitethe greatadvancein his authorityachieved when he took the royal title, there is no evidenceof a systematic ruler-cult at Pergamonor elsewherein the kingdom during his reign.r3The evidenceusually adducedin supportof the view that Attalos was deifiedwhen he died haslittle substanceand virtually no chronologicalforce. The baseIvP 59 is dedicatedto 6aoAia - - - | \eöv Za\rr1pal, and even if Attalos' name is restoredhere, the dateof the inscriptionmay well be muchlater than his death,as the letter-formsindicate.In anotherbase(/vP l7l,: OGIS 291)' "Afrra).ov 0eöv1| xai Eöeqy6v7v,the usually restored 6aoÄ6o supplementcalledfor is surely[Zarqga] | xai Eüeqytrnv.t4 It was not until after 188 that the further step was taken of instituting regular priesthoodsof the Attalids and of calling the king0eöE;this chronologymay be further establishedby a review of the known instances.The principal cults were establishedat PergamonandTeos;when the latter becamea tributary city in 188, EumenesII was quick to exploit its position as seatof the Ionian Guild of Dionysiantechnitai.rsThe full name of this Guild, rö '87'IoviaE xai xowöv r6v nepi At6vuoov rcyvrcöv röv ön' Tqonöwou, is first attestedby an Aitolian decreeof about235,and it correspondsclosely to the nameof the regionwhich becamean Attalid provincein 188.t6The unificationof the cults of Dionysos was effectedby associatingthe activity of this Guild with that of the cult body of Dionysos Kathegemonwhich had beeninstituted at Pergamonprobably by Attalos I; the associatedGuilds were 'Iav('aE xai calledrö xowöv röv nepi/övuoov reXvr,xrövröv ön' ti The Basileiaattestedby OGIS 268are ofdoubtful relevancehere:seeabove, 1l05n. 120(contra Cardinali,RP 153,n. 3). raBoehringer,AvP ix.86, regardedthe developmentof the ruler-cultas dating from the reignof Attalos I, but the evidencehe cites relateswith the exceptionof Aigina to placesoutside the kingdom and does not attest a ruler-cult in the form in which it developed later at Pergamon and elsewhere. The altars dedicated to Attalos at Pergamon(IvP 43-5) are ofa private nature, and their date is uncertain. ri See in general Pickard-Cambridge,Dram. Festivals, 2914. t6F. Delphes,iii. 3. 2188, lines 6-7. It hasbeenthoughtthat this full title dates from IEE and relates to the Attalid acquisition of Hellespontine Phrygia (so von Prott, AM xxvii (1902),l6l ff. ; Ohlemutz,Kulte, 98-9), but the evidenceof the Aitolian decree discountsthis view. It seemslikely, on the contrary, that the Attalids' regionalnamecorrespondedto a namealready in use by the Guild. Seein generalabove, 53-4, 103-4.
Royal Cults
149
'E),Ar1onövrou, xai töv neqi vöv Ka0rlyep6vaAr,övuoorr.r7 This amalgamationof the worship of Dionysos at Pergamonand at Teos, which was to outlast the Attalid dynasty,r8provided a suitable context in which the cults of membersof the Attalid royal family could be placed,and is a further attestationof the Attalid policy of associatingtheir own honours with those of a deity or hero, of the kind which we seein practiceat Sikyon (AttalosI and Apollo), Aigina (Attalos I and Aiakos), and at Pergamonitself (EumenesI[ and the twelve gods, Attalos III and Asklepios).re The creation of the enlargedkingdom in 188 occasionedthe institution of a direct form of ruler-cult, againcentredchiefly on Pergamonand Teos. This cult arosefrom a new practiceof recognizing membersof the royal family as becominggods when they died. In a decreeof HierapolishonouringApollonis, the queenof Attalos I, it is saidthat shep€06,orr7xev The dateof this eiE0eoüg.20 decreecannot be exactly determined,but we may be sure that it was passedafter 188for reasonsthat will be mentionedshortly. At a later date, the death of Attalos III was expressedin a decreeof Pergamon in the words fue|tolrd.pevogö$ ävl0g6nav.21 This practice of deifying a royal person on death plays an important part in Attalid ruler-cults, and we will do well to establishits chronologybefore exploring its significance. Although Attalos I is posthumouslycalled)eöE,the designation and its associatedpriesthoodare not attesteduntil after 188,and we have no evidenceof a cult before this date. The first priestt7 For thejoint name,seeRobert,Er. a nat. 445-50(Michel,Äec. l0l4): /G xi. 4. ll36 + 1061,: Durrbach,Choix, 75 (Pickard-Cambridge, Dram. Festivals,314, no. l0(a)). SeealsoG. Klaffenbach,Symbolae,l7ff.;Datx,BCH lix(1935),226ff. I8 It is attestedin the sameform in a letter of Sullato Kos confirming privilegesof the lonian Guild (81-79sc): M. Segre,.Riv. di fi|. lxvi ( 1938),253ff. (Pickard-Cambridge,Dram. Festivals,3 18,no. l3). This evidencewasoverlookedby Ohlemutz, Kulte, 98; 'nach dem Erlöschender Pergamenischen Dynastieschwindetaus dem Titel der Hauptverbandes der Techniten in Teos der Zrusatzxai töv nepi töv Ka92yepövalrövuoov.' Ohlemutz's view, following von Prott, that Dionysos Kathegemon was being worshipped as the dpX1yftqg toö yövouEof the Attalid dynasty,was basedon evidencewhoserelevancewas discountedby Robert,Et. anat.254. teOGIS 332(discussedbelow);notelines26-7:lorcllqavqEopfioatmiwa Exaotov meqavqEöpov töv l6öexa 9eöv xai 6alor7öagEöptuou. 20OGIS 308, line 4. 2t OGIS 338, lines zt_5.
Royal Cults
Royal Cults
hoods we hear of are those of the living Stratonike and the deceasedApollonis at Teos, and of EumenesII during and after his lifetime at Pergamonand Teos; all thesecult phenomenalikewise fall in the period after 188,and it is a plausiblecontentionthat this year, in view of its importanceto the Attalids, marksthe beginning of royal cult activity. In the case of Eumenes, von Prott demonstratedmany yearsagothat the cults to which the priesthoods belongedwere introducedat Pergamonand Teosby Kraton sonof Zotichos, auletes and priest of the lonian Guild of Dionysian technitai.22The evidencefor this eventis providedby two decrees of the Guild honouring Kraton: the first is undated,23but the second is dated by a priesthood of Eumenes,evidently newly a ini iq6o4 Zarögou, xo,i&yovo1örou xlail I ieptaE introduced:2 6aot).6a4Eöptvou NtxortAoufEl. Since the first decreerefers to the combinedGuild of DionysiantechnitaiatTeosandof Dionysos Kathegemonat Pergamonin the form mentionedearlier,it follows that both decrees,and accordinglythe introduction of Eumenes' priesthoodat Teos,mustbe datedafter 188,when this combination occurred. At about the sametime, or at any rate after 188,when shewas betrothed to Eumenes,Stratonike also received a priesthoodat Teos, according to an honorary decreeof that city.zsAlthough neither Eumenesnor Stratonikewas called a god, the deceased Attalos I and his queenApollonis were so called, and Apollonis furthermore was to be worshipped as oüwaoE with Aphrodite (lines 4-5): röv öi |uoütv önryü'ry|fivattöv ieq6a llrts I'AqqQöftqE xo,i1ed.E'AnüJ.aviöogEöoe6oüE.At Hierapolis,as we have seen,it was saidof Apollonis that shepe06oqxev eiE0eoü9, and the chronology of this terminology may also be dated fairly securelywithin a rangeof a few years.In the decreeof Hierapolis Apollonis is calledyuvil pöv Ieoü 6aoü"6ag'Atrd)"ou,luiqlqllöö 6aoü,6aEEüptvou Zarfiqog, and since Eumenes' epithet Sorer
was bestowedin the 180sduring his war with PrusiasI of Bithynia and the Galatians,26Apollonis' death is placed in the years after about 184.In fact it was probably later still, sincePolybiosstates that she long outlived her husband,who died in 197.27 Towards the end of his life Kraton moved from Teos to Perga-
150
22AM xxvä (1902),16l-88 (seeabove, n. 3). 2r Durrbach, Choix, 75; improved text ap. Datx, BCH lix (1935)' 210 tr' 2aMichel, Äec. l016 A (O. Lüders, Die DionysischenKunstler (Berlin, 1873)' 179-80). zsRobert,Et. anat.9-20. On the betrothalof Stratonike,see Appendix iii.