Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
Related titles from Woodhead Publishing Limited: Medical textiles and biomaterials for healthcare (ISBN 1 85573 683 7) Medical textiles and biomaterials are a significant and increasingly important part of the technical textiles industry. They cover a huge range of applications from diapers and surgical gowns to substrates for electronic sensoring of vital life signs, external use as wound care, and internal use as implantables for biodegradable post-operative support systems, as well as the replacement of body parts through tissue engineering by supplying the structure for the growth of new cells. Even the humble plaster has the potential to deliver a powerful healthcare effect through its specific skincare characteristics and controlled delivery of medications. Medical textiles and biomaterials for healthcare will discuss recent developments in the main aspects of healthcare and medical textiles covering materials, manufacture, performance, applications, standards and user experience. It will serve as an essential resource for healthcare and medical textiles manufacturers, clinicians, researchers and consumers. Biomaterials, artificial organs and tissue engineering (ISBN 185573 737 X) Maintaining quality of life in an ageing population is one of the great challenges of the twenty-first century. This book and collection of illustrated CD lectures summarises how this challenge is being met by multi-disciplinary developments in specialty biomaterials, devices, artificial organs and in-vitro growth of human cells as tissue engineered constructs. Part A provides an introduction to living and man-made materials for the nonspecialist; Part B is an overview of clinical applications of various biomaterials and devices; Part C summarises the bioengineering principles, materials and designs used in artificial organs; Part D presents the concepts, cell techniques, scaffold materials and applications of tissue engineering; and Part E provides an overview of the complex socioeconomic factors involved in technology-based healthcare, including regulatory controls, technology transfer processes and ethical issues. Each chapter is supplemented with illustrated lectures and study questions in an easy to use CD to aid the reader in self-paced instruction. Hyaluronan (two-volume set: ISBN 1 85573 570 9) (Proceedings of an international meeting, September 2000, North East Wales Institute, UK.) Hyaluronan and its derivatives have developed very quickly in the last few years from a scientific novelty into an important new material for a diverse range of medical and biomaterial applications. The landmark conference on which this two-volume reference work is based focused on recent developments and applications in the use of hyaluronan in tissue repair and reconstruction, drug delivery systems, anti-cancer treatments and joint recovery and engineering. The entire range of hyaluronan progress is dealt with in depth by more than 135 individual papers presented in two volumes covering: analytical chemistry; chemical modification; physical characterisation; cell biology and medical applications. Details of these books and other Woodhead Publishing titles can be obtained by: · visiting our website at www.woodheadpublishing.com · contacting Customer Services (e-mail:
[email protected]; fax: +44 (0) 1223 893694; tel.: +44 (0) 1223 891358 ext. 30; address: Woodhead Publishing Limited, Abington Hall, Abington, Cambridge CB1 6AH, England)
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials Edited by Pankaj Vadgama
Published by Woodhead Publishing Limited Abington Hall, Abington Cambridge CB1 6AH England www.woodheadpublishing.com Published in North America by CRC Press LLC 2000 Corporate Blvd, NW Boca Raton FL 33431 USA First published 2005, Woodhead Publishing Limited and CRC Press LLC ß 2005, Woodhead Publishing Limited The authors have asserted their moral rights. Every effort has been made to trace and acknowledge ownership of copyright. The publishers will be glad to hear from the copyright holders whom it has not been possible to contact concerning the following: Figs 1.11 and 1.13. This book contains information obtained from authentic and highly regarded sources. Reprinted material is quoted with permission, and sources are indicated. Reasonable efforts have been made to publish reliable data and information, but the authors and the publishers cannot assume responsibility for the validity of all materials. Neither the authors nor the publishers, nor anyone else associated with this publication, shall be liable for any loss, damage or liability directly or indirectly caused or alleged to be caused by this book. Neither this book nor any part may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, microfilming and recording, or by any information storage or retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publishers. The consent of Woodhead Publishing Limited and CRC Press LLC does not extend to copying for general distribution, for promotion, for creating new works, or for resale. Specific permission must be obtained in writing from Woodhead Publishing Limited or CRC Press LLC for such copying. Trademark notice: product or corporate names may be trademarks or registered trademarks, and are used only for identification and explanation, without intent to infringe. British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data A catalog record for this book is available from the Library of Congress Woodhead Publishing Limited ISBN-13: 978-1-85573-930-7 Woodhead Publishing Limited ISBN-10: 1-85573-930-5 CRC Press ISBN 0-8493-3446-6 CRC Press order number: WP3446 Project managed by Macfarlane Production Services, Markyate, Hertfordshire (
[email protected]) Typeset by Godiva Publishing Services Ltd, Coventry, West Midlands Printed by TJ International Limited, Padstow, Cornwall, England
Contents
Contributor contact details
xv
Preface
xxi
Part I Forming methods 1
Fundamental properties of surfaces
P W E I G H T M A N and D S M A R T I N , The University of
3
Liverpool, UK
1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 1.6 1.7 1.8 1.9 1.10 1.11
Introduction Experimental considerations Surface characteristics Active sites and kinetics Controlling crystal growth: semiconductor technology Heterogeneous catalysis Real surfaces: theoretical advances Real surfaces: experimental approaches Insight into the biological activity of surfaces Conclusion References
3 4 14 15 17 20 23 24 25 27 27
2
Control of polymeric biomaterial surfaces
29
2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4 2.5 2.6
Introduction Preparation of polymers The solid state and structure Polymer-solvent interactions The polymeric surface and surface-bulk difference The general properties of a biomaterial surface
29 29 32 35 38 39
V H A S I R C I and N H A S I R C I , METU, Turkey
vi
Contents
2.7 2.8 2.9 2.10 2.11
Modification of polymer surfaces Surface analysis Surface properties and biomaterials applications Conclusion References
3
Organic thin film architectures: fabrication and properties M C P E T T Y , University of Durham, UK
3.1 3.2 3.3 3.4 3.5 3.6 3.7
4
4.1 4.2 4.3 4.4 4.5 4.6 4.7 4.8
5
5.1 5.2 5.3 5.4 5.5 5.6 5.7
Introduction Established deposition methods Molecular architectures Molecular organization in thin films Future trends Further information References
Membranes and permeable films
N A H O E N I C H , University of Newcastle upon Tyne, UK and D M A L I K , Loughborough University, UK
40 50 56 57 57
60 60 61 65 71 78 79 79
83
Introduction 83 Materials and applications 83 Membrane characterisation 89 Blood material contact 92 Biological events at the membrane and thin film blood interface 93 Improvement of biocompatibility 99 Conclusion 99 References 100
Stable use of biosensors at the sample interface
103
J F G A R G I U L I , University of London, UK, A G I L L and G L I L L I E , University of Manchester, UK, M S C H O E N L E B E R , University of London, UK, J P E A R S O N , University of Manchester, UK, G K Y R I A K O U and P V A D G A M A , University of London, UK
Introduction Biosensor limitations Biocompatibility Materials interfacing strategy Membrane systems used in biosensors Microflows as surrogate, renewable barrier films Microfluidics and biosensors
103 104 105 116 119 138 140
Contents 5.8 5.9 5.10
6
Conclusion Acknowledgements References
Micro- and nanoscale surface patterning techniques for localising biomolecules and cells: the essence of nanobiotechnology
Z A D E M O V I C and P K I N G S H O T T , The Danish Poymer
vii 146 147 147
150
Centre, Denmark
6.1 6.2 6.3 6.4 6.5 6.6 6.7
Introduction Lithographic patterning with photons, particles and scanning probes Soft lithographic techniques Colloidal-based fabrication techniques Template-imprinted nanostructured surfaces Conclusion References
150 152 158 168 169 169 171
Part II Measurement, monitoring and characterisation 7
Surface spectroscopies
M M E H L M A N N and G G A U G L I T Z , University of
183
Tuebingen, Germany
7.1 7.2 7.3 7.4 7.5 7.6
8
Introduction Surfaces Optical detection methods Biomolecular interaction analysis Conclusion References
Surface microscopies
C Z I E G L E R , University of Kaiserslautern, and Institut fuÈr
183 183 186 190 196 197
200
OberflaÈchen- und Schichtanalytik GmbH, Kaiserslautern, Germany
8.1 8.2 8.3 8.4 8.5 8.6 8.7
Introduction Electron microscopies Scanning probe microscopies Optical microscopies Future trends Further information References
200 208 211 218 219 220 220
viii
9
Contents
Nanoindentation
A B M A N N , The State University of New Jersey, USA
9.1 9.2 9.3 9.4 9.5 9.6 9.7 9.8 9.9
Introduction Instrumentation Data analysis Thin films and coatings Hard biological materials Soft biological materials Conclusion Further information References
10
Surface plasmon resonance
10.1 10.2 10.3 10.4 10.5 10.6 10.7
Introduction Surface plasmon resonance phenomenon Surface functionalization Applications Conclusion Acknowledgements References
11
Ellipsometry for optical surface study applications
V H P EÂ R E Z - L U N A , Illinois Institute of Technology, USA
Y M G E B R E M I C H A E L and K T V G R A T T A N , City
225 225 225 229 235 236 240 241 242 242
248 248 249 257 261 264 265 265
271
University, London
11.1 11.2 11.3 11.4 11.5 11.6 11.7
12 12.1 12.2 12.3 12.4 12.5 12.6
Introduction History of ellipsometry and polarisation control Fibre based polarisation modulated ellipsometry A high birefringence fibre polarisation modulation ellipsometry Future trends Sources of further information References
Neutron reflection
J R L U , UMIST, UK
Introduction Neutron reflection and deuterium labelling Peptide interfacial assembly Lysozyme adsorption: the effect of surface chemistry Effect of size of globular proteins on their adsorption Conclusion
271 278 282 285 292 292 294
299 299 300 303 305 314 315
Contents 12.7 12.8
13
ix
Acknowledgements References
317 317
Microgravimetry
322
S V M I K H A L O V S K Y , University of Brighton, UK, V M G U N ' K O , Institute of Surface Chemistry, Ukraine, K D P A V E Y , University of Brighton, UK, P E T O M L I N S , National Physical Laboratory, UK and S L J A M E S , University of Brighton, UK
13.1 13.2 13.3 13.4 13.5 13.6 13.7 13.8 13.9 13.10 13.11 13.12
Introduction Quartz crystal microbalance technique Analytical applications of QCM Combination of QCM with other techniques Acoustic/piezoelectric sensors Future development of piezoelectric sensors Thermal gravimetry Non-QCM adsorption methods Dynamic contact angle measurements Conclusion Acknowledgements References
322 322 332 355 357 359 360 361 362 366 366 366
Part III Surface interaction and in-vitro studies 14
Interaction between biomaterials and cell tissues
Y I W A S A K I and N N A K A B A Y A S H I , Tokyo Medical
389
and Dental University, Japan
14.1 14.2 14.3 14.4 14.5 14.6 14.7
15 15.1
Introduction Surface properties of biomedical materials Surface analyses of biomedical materials Design for non-biofouling surface How to connect tissues with biomaterials Conclusion References
389 389 393 399 405 410 411
Blood flow dynamics and surface interactions
414
Clinical application and problems of medical devices in contact with blood
414
W V A N O E V E R E N , University of Groningen, The Netherlands
x
Contents
15.2 15.3
Surface interactions of blood Role of blood cells during flow: rolling of cells, effect of concentration of erythrocytes, expression of adhesive cell receptors Biomaterial surface characteristics in relation to haemocompatibility and clinical applications Haemocompatibility of metals, ceramics and polymers Biological surface treatment to improve haemocompatibility ISO 10993 requirements for testing of medical devices: simulation of clinical application including flow, blood composition, anticoagulants Test models: static, low flow, arterial flow, pulsatile/laminar flow Conclusion References
15.4 15.5 15.6 15.7 15.8 15.9 15.10
16
Cell guidance through surface cues
A K V O G T - E I S E L E , Max-Planck Institute for Polymer Research, Germany, A O F F E N H AÈ U S S E R , Institute for Thin Films and Interfaces, Research Centre JuÈlich, Germany and W K N O L L ,
418 422 423 425 427 431 432 434 435
447
Max-Planck Institute for Polymer Research, Germany
16.1 16.2 16.3 16.4 16.5 16.6
17 17.1 17.2 17.3 17.4 17.5 17.6 17.7
Introduction Surface functionalization Patterning of chemical surface cues Synaptic connections in patterned neuronal networks: communication along predefined pathways Conclusion References
Controlled cell deposition techniques
C M A S O N , University College London, UK
Introduction In-vivo and in-vitro cell interactions Two-dimensional controlled cell deposition techniques Three-dimensional controlled cell deposition techniques Future trends Further information References
447 451 454 458 461 462
465 465 466 468 480 483 484 486
Contents
18 18.1 18.2 18.3 18.4 18.5 18.6 18.7
Biofouling in membrane separation systems
Z C U I and Y W A N , University of Oxford, UK
Introduction Membrane separation ± concepts and applications Fouling mechanisms and factors affecting fouling Biofouling Fouling control Conclusion and future trends References
xi
493 493 495 500 508 513 529 530
Part IV Surface interactions and in-vivo studies 19
Bioactive 3D scaffolds in regenerative medicine: the role of interface interactions
J R J O N E S and L L H E N C H , Imperial College London, UK 19.1 19.2 19.3 19.4 19.5 19.6 19.7 19.8 19.9 19.10
Introduction The need for biomedical materials and implants Surgical procedures for bone repair Surgical procedures in lung repair A new direction: regenerative medicine Bone regeneration Tissue engineering of the lung Conclusion Acknowledgements References
20
Intravascular drug delivery systems and devices: interactions at biointerface
K S R A O , Nebraska Medical Center, USA, A K P A N D A ,
545 545 545 547 550 551 552 561 567 568 568
573
National Institute of Immunology, India and
V L A B H A S E T W A R , Nebraska Medical Center, USA 20.1 20.2 20.3 20.4 20.5 20.6 20.7 20.8
Introduction Biomaterials and biointerface Intravascular drug delivery systems Nanoparticles as an intravascular delivery system Stents Vascular grafts and catheters Future trends References
573 573 575 575 580 581 581 582
xii
Contents
21
Surface degradation and microenvironmental outcomes C C C H U , Cornell University, USA
21.1 21.2 21.3 21.4
585 585 587 589
21.5 21.6
Introduction Chemistry of synthetic biodegradable biomaterials In-vitro degradation of synthetic biodegradable biomaterials In-vivo biodegradation of synthetic biodegradable biomaterials and cell/biomaterial surface interaction Conclusion References
22
Microbial biofilms and clinical implants
619
22.1 22.2
Introduction Epidemology and costs of infection associated with clinical implants Microbiology of clinical implant infections Molecular mechanisms underlying biofilm formation Determinants of biofilm antibiotic resistance Consequences of biofilm formation on clinical implants Clinical implant infection Prevention of biofilm formation on clinical implants Further research Information resources References
619
22.3 22.4 22.5 22.6 22.7 22.8 22.9 22.10 22.11
23
601 614 614
M M I L L A R , Barts and the London School of Medicine and Dentistry
Extracellular matrix molecules in vascular tissue engineering C M K I E L T Y , D V B A X , N H O D S O N and M J S H E R R A T T , Wellcome Trust Centre for Cell-Matrix
620 621 622 624 624 625 627 630 630 631
637
Research, UK
23.1 23.2 23.3 23.4 23.5 23.6 23.7 23.8 23.9
Introduction Natural blood vessels Vascular tissue engineering Coating ECM molecules on surfaces ± a cautionary tale Biological seeding materials ECM-regulated delivery of therapeutic growth factors Future trends Acknowledgements References
637 638 641 646 651 657 658 658 659
Contents
24
Biomineralisation processes
24.1 24.2
Introduction `Biologically-induced' and `organic matrix-mediated' mineralisation Organic macromolecules Control over crystal structure Control over crystal orientation Control over morphology Control over mechanical properties Conclusion Further information References
24.3 24.4 24.5 24.6 24.7 24.8 24.9 24.10
25
F C M E L D R U M , University of Bristol, UK
xiii
666 666 667 667 671 674 676 686 687 688 688
On the topographical characterisation of biomaterial surfaces 693 P E T O M L I N S and R L E A C H , National Physical Laboratory, UK, P V A D G A M A , University of London, UK, S M I K H A L O V S K Y and S J A M E S , University of Brighton, UK
25.1 25.2 25.3 25.4 25.5 25.6 25.7 25.8 25.9 25.10 25.11 25.12 25.13 25.14
Introduction Biomaterials, surfaces and biocompatibility What is a surface? Surface measurement Filters Quantifying surface texture Two-dimensional profile data Three-dimensional data Techniques for surface texture measurement Traceability and calibration Conclusion Further reading Acknowledgements References
693 693 694 694 695 696 696 700 703 713 713 714 715 715
Part V Appendices 26
Surface modification of polymers to enhance biocompatibility
719
Introduction Polymers in medical applications
719 720
M T A V A K O L I , TWI Limited, UK
26.1 26.2
xiv
Contents
26.3 26.4 26.5 26.6 26.7
Biocompatibility Surface modification techniques Future trends Acknowledgements References
27
Issues concerning the use of assays of cell adhesion to biomaterials
S L J A M E S and S M I K H A L O V S K Y , University of Brighton, UK, P V A D G A M A , University of London, UK and P E T O M L I N S , National Physical Laboratory, UK
722 723 740 741 741
745
27.1 27.2 27.3 27.4 27.5 27.6 27.7
Introduction Measurement objectives Issues of interpretation of adhesion measurements Sources of variability in adhesion assays Methods of assaying cell adhesion in current use Conclusion References
28
Protein adsorption to surfaces and interfaces
28.1 28.2 28.3 28.4 28.5 28.6 28.7 28.8
Introduction Classification of biomaterials surfaces and interfaces Non-specific adsorption to hard surfaces General rules of non-specific adsorption to flat surfaces Non-specific adsorption to `soft' surfaces Non-specific adsorption to penetrable surfaces and interfaces Future trends References
763 764 765 768 773 774 775 776
Index
782
B M I L T H O R P E , University of New South Wales, Australia
745 746 750 753 757 760 761
763
Contributor contact details
Introduction Professor Pankaj Vadgama Director, IRC in Biomedical Materials Queen Mary University of London Mile End Road London E1 4NS UK E-mail:
[email protected] Chapter 1 Professor Peter Weightman and Dr David S Martin Physics Department and Surface Science Research Centre The University of Liverpool Liverpool L69 3BX UK Tel: +44 (0)151 794 3871 E-mail:
[email protected] E-mail:
[email protected] Chapter 2 Professor V Hasirci Department of Biological Sciences Biotechnology Research Unit and Professor N Hasirci
Department of Chemistry METU Ankara 06531 Turkey E-mail:
[email protected] E-mail:
[email protected] Chapter 3 Professor M C Petty School of Engineering and Centre for Molecular and Nanoscale Electronics University of Durham South Road Durham DH1 3LE UK Tel: +44 (0)191 334 2419 E-mail:
[email protected] Chapter 4 Dr Nicholas A Hoenich School of Clinical Medical Sciences Medical School University of Newcastle Framlington Place Newcastle upon Tyne NE2 4HH UK Tel: +44 (0)191 222 6998 E-mail:
[email protected]
xvi
Contributor contact details
Dr Danish J Malik Department of Chemical Engineering Loughborough University Loughborough LE11 3TU UK Tel: +44 (0)1509 222507 E-mail:
[email protected] Chapter 5 Joseph Gargiuli IRC in Biomedical Materials Queen Mary, University of London Mile End Road London E1 4NS UK Tel: +44 (0)20 7882 5547/3254. E-mail:
[email protected] Andrew Gill Inverness Medical Ltd Beechwood Business Park North Inverness IV2 3ED UK Tel: +44 (0)1463 721706. E-mail:
[email protected] Monika Schoenleber IRC in Biomedical Materials Queen Mary, University of London Mile End Road London E1 4NS UK Tel: +44 (0)20 7882 3316 E-mail:
[email protected] J Pearson Department of Epidemiology University of Manchester Manchester M13 9PL UK
G Kyriakou IRC in Biomedical Materials Queen Mary, University of London Mile End Road London E1 4NS UK Tel: +44 (0)20 7882 3316 E-mail:
[email protected] Professor Pankaj Vadgama Director, IRC in Biomedical Materials Queen Mary, University of London Mile End Road London E1 4NS UK Tel: +44 (0)20 7882 3316 E-mail:
[email protected] Chapter 6 Dr P Kingshott The Danish Polymer Centre Riso National Laboratory PO Box 49 Fredericksborgvej 399 DK-4000 Roskilde Denmark E-mail:
[email protected] E-mail:
[email protected] Chapter 7 Professor G Gauglitz and M Mehlmann Institut fuÈr Physikalische und Theoretische Chemie UniversitaÈt TuÈbingen Auf der Morgenstelle 9 72076 TuÈbingen Germany
Contributor contact details E-mail:
[email protected] E-mail:
[email protected] Chapter 8 C Ziegler Department of Physics, University of Kaiserslautern and Institut fuÈr OberflaÈchen- und Schichtanalytik GmbH Erwin-SchroÈdinger-Straûe 56 67663 Kaiserslautern Germany Tel: +49 631 205 2855 E-mail:
[email protected] Chapter 9 Adrian Mann Department of Biomedical Engineering Rutgers The State University of New Jersey Piscataway NJ 08854 USA E-mail:
[email protected] Chapter 10 Professor Victor Perez Luna Room 144 Perlstein Hall Illinois Institute of Technology in Bioengineering, Chicago USA E-mail:
[email protected]
xvii
Chapter 11 Dr Y M Gebremichael and Professor K T V Grattan School of Engineering and Mathematical Sciences City University Northampton Square London EC1V 0HB UK Tel: +44 (0)20 7040 3888 Fax: +44 (0)20 7040 8568 E-mail:
[email protected] E-mail:
[email protected] Chapter 12 Professor Lu Biological Physics Group School of Physics and Astronomy The University of Manchester G13, Sackville Street Building Sackville Street Manchester M60 1QD UK Tel: +44 (0)161 2003926 E-mail:
[email protected] Chapter 13 Professor S V Mikhalovsky, Dr K D Pavey and Dr S L James School of Pharmacy and Biomolecular Sciences, University of Brighton Cockcroft Building Lewes Road Brighton BN2 4GJ UK Tel: +44 (0)1273 642034 Fax: +44 (0)1273 642115 E-mail:
[email protected]
xviii
Contributor contact details
Tel: +44 (0)1273 642042 Fax: +44 (0)1273 679333 E-mail:
[email protected] Dr V M Gun'ko Institute of Surface Chemistry 17 General Naumov Street 03164 Kiev Ukraine Tel/Fax: +38 (044) 5123095 E-mail:
[email protected] Dr P Tomlins Materials Centre, National Physical Laboratory, Queens Road, Teddington, Middlesex, TW11 0LW UK Tel: +44 (0)208 943 6778 Fax: +44 (0)208 943 6453 E-mail:
[email protected] Chapter 14 Professor N Nakabayashi Institute of Biomaterials and Bioengineering Tokyo Medical and Dental University 2-3-10 Kanda-surugadai Chiyoda-ku Tokyo 101-0062 Japan Tel: +81-47-341-9734 E-mail:
[email protected] Dr Yasuhiko Iwasaki Institute of Biomaterials and Bioengineering Tokyo Medical and Dental University
Kanda-surugadai Chiyoda-ku Tokyo 101-0026 Japan Tel: +81-3-5280-8026 E-mail:
[email protected] Chapter 15 Dr Willem van Oeveren, Dept of Biomedical Engineering, University Medical Center Groningen, Ant. Deusinglaan 1 PO Box 196, 9700AD Groningen The Netherlands Tel: +31 503633127 E-mail:
[email protected] Chapter 16 Professor W Knoll Max-Planck-Institut fuÈr Polymerforschung Postfach 3148 55021 Mainz Germany Tel: +49 06131 / 379 160 E-mail:
[email protected] Dr Angela K Vogt-Eisele Cell Physiology ND/4 Ruhr University Bochum Universitystr. 150 44 780 Bochum Germany Tel: +49 (0)234 32 26756 Fax: +49 (0)234 32 14129 E-mail:
[email protected]
Contributor contact details Professor Andreas OffenhaÈusser Institute for Thin Films and Interfaces (ISG-2) Forschungszentrum JuÈlich D-52425 JuÈlich Germany Tel: +49 (0)2461 612330 Fax: +49 (0)2461 618733 E-mail:
[email protected] Chapter 17 Mr Chris Mason FRCS Department of Biochemical Engineering University College London Torrington Place London WC1E 7JE UK Tel: +44 (0)20 7679 0140 Fax: +44 (0)20 7209 0703 E-mail:
[email protected] Chapter 18 Professor Zhanfeng Cui Department of Engineering Science Oxford University Parks Road Oxford OX1 3PJ UK Tel: +44 (0)1865 273118 E-mail:
[email protected] Dr Yinhua Wan Department of Engineering Science Oxford University Parks Road Oxford OX1 3PJ UK Tel: +44 (0)1865 273059 E-mail:
[email protected]
xix
Chapter 19 Professor Larry Hench and Dr Julian Jones Department of Materials Imperial College London South Kensington Campus London SW7 2AZ UK E-mail:
[email protected] E-mail:
[email protected] Chapter 20 Vinod Labhasetwar, Ph.D. College of Pharmacy Department of Pharmaceutical Sciences 986025 Nebraska Medical Center Omaha, NE 68198-6025 USA Tel: (402) 559-9021 E-mail:
[email protected] Chapter 21 C Chu Department of Textiles and Apparel, and Biomedical Engineering Program Martha Van Rensselaer Hall Cornell University Ithaca, New York, 14853-4401 USA Tel: 607-255-1938 E-mail:
[email protected] Chapter 22 Michael Millar Department of Microbiology Barts and the London School of Medicine and Dentistry Whitechapel
xx
Contributor contact details
London E1 2AD UK Tel: +44 (0)20 7377 7080 E-mail:
[email protected] Chapter 23 Cay M Kielty, Daniel V Bax, Nigel Hodson and Michael J Sherratt School of Biological Sciences University of Manchester Michael Smith Building Oxford Road Manchester M13 9PT UK E-mail:
[email protected] Chapter 24 Dr Fiona Meldrum School of Chemistry University of Bristol Cantock's Close Bristol BS8 1TS UK Tel: +44 (0)117 3317215 E-mail:
[email protected] Chapter 25 Dr Paul Tomlins National Physical Laboratory Queens Road Teddington Middlesex TW11 0LW UK E-mail:
[email protected] Professor Pankaj Vadgama Director, IRC in Biomedical Materials Queen Mary
University of London Mile End Road London E1 4NS UK E-mail:
[email protected] Chapter 26 Professor Mehdi Tavakoli TWI Limited Granta Park Abington Cambridgeshire CB1 6AL UK E-mail:
[email protected] Chapter 27 Dr S L James School of Pharmacy and Biomolecular Sciences University of Brighton Cockcroft Building Lewes Road Brighton BN2 4GJ UK Tel: +44 (0)1273 642042 Fax: +44 (0)1273 679333 E-mail:
[email protected] Chapter 28 Professor B Milthorpe Head of School Graduate Scool of Biomedical Engineering University of New South Wales UNSW Sydney 2052 Australia Tel: +61-2-9385-3911 Fax: +61-2-9663-2108 E-mail:
[email protected]
Preface
Biomaterials research has undergone a variety of evolutionary, one might say revolutionary, developments in recent years. The full entry of biomaterials as a credible modality in modern medicine was essentially triggered by the work of John Charnley on hip replacement. Then, as now, bulk materials properties and biomechanics took centre stage in view of the stringent mechanical and tribological demands of the implants. However, such issues cannot be the sole determinants of clinical outcome. Interest in bulk properties has inevitably shifted to the important consideration of the surface with the plethora of allied interfacial phenomena, conditioning clinical outcome. A consideration of the interface goes beyond the realms of an intellectual research exercise given that, even today, implants are better characterised by a bioincompatibility, rather than the hoped for `inertness' of biocompatibility. In mass terms, of course the surface is insignificant compared with the bulk. However, whilst the latter is a largely sequestered environment, amenable to at least some degree of engineering/physical science based prediction, the interface is the seat of some extraordinarily powerful, frontline biological responses. These variously conspire to attack the `non-self' implant firstly to try to degrade and eliminate it, and if that is not possible, to mask it off with an inert capsule; not a very promising outcome for precision engineering based therapeutics. The rules that govern the complex biological events are yet to be fully worked out, but it is a fair assumption that study of surface chemistry, organisation, topography, mechanics and physics, etc., will repay the effort. Unfortunately, the importance of surface processes in determining functional outcomes is not yet matched by the attention given in dedicated texts. The growing body of original literature also seems increasingly dissipated in analytical, chemical and biophysical journals. This book attempts to redress the information imbalance between surface and bulk descriptions or biomaterials. The series of chapters attempts to cover a spectrum from the fundamentals of surface structure and forming methods to biological and clinical outcomes. The link between experimental studies of surfaces in a controlled biomatrix and clinical results is a difficult one to make,
xxii
Preface
but at least the authoritative descriptions provided here will promote fresh thinking in this important area. Without measurement tools, understanding is restricted, so some key surface analytical techniques, both classical and developing (viz. probe microscopies, optics) are included. Ultimately, quantitative measurement is vital to understanding and so this book is in part an expression of the UK interest in metrology, represented through Department of Trade and Industry (DTI) programmes on materials metrology. I would like to express my sincere thanks to the many authors who were so patient with me and who contributed so effectively in making this book a viable exercise. My thanks also to Francis Dodds, Melanie Cotterell and their colleagues at Woodhead, whose continuous support and advice made the whole process both pleasurable and interesting and one that was so ably initiated by Gwen Jones. Finally my thanks to Catherine Jones of the IRC in Biomedical Materials for her unfailing assistance over the innumerable author interactions in modifying and adapting texts and for ensuring the project remained on track. Pankaj Vadgama IRC in Biomedical Materials University of London
Part I
Forming methods
1
Fundamental properties of surfaces P W E I G H T M A N and D S M A R T I N , The University of Liverpool, UK
1.1
Introduction
Surface scientists occasionally observe that while God created solids, the Devil created surfaces. This phrase encapsulates the fact that while surfaces often dominate the behaviour of materials they are very difficult to study. Surfaces usually lack the high symmetry and purity of the interior of a solid and are often strongly influenced by adsorbed impurities from their environment. It is hard to overstate the significance of the Devil's work since surfaces are very important. Phenomena experienced in everyday life such as corrosion, adhesion, adsorption, friction and lubrication all occur at surfaces. More intimately, the crucial role played by surfaces in biocompatibility gives them an importance in the design of materials used in dentistry, contact lenses and medical implants such as hip joints and knee replacements. Industrial processes that occur at surfaces have a great impact on our lives and include crystal growth, semiconductor device manufacture and heterogeneous catalysis. Surface properties will also have a dominant influence on the emerging field of nanotechnology. The control of surface properties is thus essential to the function of a wide variety of materials. Clearly, then, a primary aim of surface scientists is to obtain a sufficient understanding of surfaces to make it possible to control surface properties. The field of surface science concerns fundamental, nanoscale investigations of surface phenomena that are both scientifically important and technologically relevant. The subject is relatively new since the experimental study of clean surfaces was delayed for many years by the crucial limitation that in a pressure in excess of 10ÿ6 mbar a clean surface adsorbs a monolayer of impurities within a few seconds. Thus experimental work on clean surfaces could not begin until the development in the 1960s of ultra-high vacuum (UHV) techniques, which reach pressures of 10ÿ10 mbar or less. This technological advance led to a rapid increase in surface studies and a proliferation of experimental techniques of which there is space here to give only the briefest of descriptions of some of the most important.
4
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
The advances made in the understanding of surfaces in UHV conditions in the last forty years raise two questions. Firstly, to what extent are the surfaces that we now understand representative of the field in general? Secondly, does an understanding of the behaviour of surfaces in UHV provide a good guide to the behaviour of surfaces in the ambient conditions in which we find them in everyday life? The second of these questions is particularly pertinent to the role of surfaces in biomaterial applications and it will be addressed later in this chapter. The first question requires a rough estimate of how many surfaces are worthy of study since there are an infinite number of ways of terminating single crystals, to say nothing of the number of possible surfaces of amorphous materials. As a rough guide we note that Wyckoff's six volume classification1 lists ~7000 crystal structures. If we assume that each crystal structure has three important crystal faces and that it is appropriate to seek to understand the interactions that occur between each of these faces with the ten most important gases then we have a target for surface science of understanding ~200,000 surfaces. So far, the structures of ~1000 surfaces have been determined, about 1% of the target. We have a good understanding of the behaviour of the known surface structures in UHV and some understanding of the factors that are important in catalysis. In addition surface science has made major contributions to the considerable progress that has been made in the design and controlled growth of semiconductor systems. However, as will be made clear later, we are only just beginning to develop an understanding of surfaces in ambient conditions. The study of surfaces thus has a long way to go, particularly in addressing issues that are important in the real world.
1.2
Experimental considerations
We begin with a brief account of the importance of UHV and a description of single crystal surfaces. There are many experimental probes capable of detailed investigations of surfaces and interfaces, however, we have space to give only a brief overview of some of the most commonly used surface techniques. A more extensive introduction to these and many other techniques may be found in the books by Woodruff and Delchar,2 Zangwill,3 Prutton4 and Venables.5
1.2.1 Ultra-high vacuum As indicated in the introduction, the experimental investigation of the fundamental properties of surfaces have mostly taken place in UHV where the pressure is typically 10-10 mbar ± thirteen orders of magnitude lower than atmospheric pressure. A UHV environment is required to prepare a well-defined clean surface and maintain it for a sufficient time for experimental studies. In addition to surface preparation, a good vacuum is also a prerequisite for many of the experimental probes used to study surfaces since these probes are often
Fundamental properties of surfaces
5
based upon controlling the trajectories of electrons and ions. Vacuum technology has developed pumping systems capable of maintaining a UHV environment within stainless steel chambers for indefinite periods of time. Experiments are not exclusively performed on clean surfaces in UHV and the recent development of experimental probes that are capable of operating in a non-UHV environment is giving rise to an increasing trend of experimental studies of surfaces in ambient and liquid environments.
1.2.2 Crystal surfaces and surface preparation The majority of experimental surface studies have been performed on single crystals in order to simplify the atomic and electronic structure of the surface. Crystal surfaces can be prepared so as to consist of relatively large flat terraces made up of atoms of similar atomic coordination, with relatively few atoms associated with defect sites such as steps. The majority of single crystals grow in one of four basic structures: simple cubic (SC), face centred cubic (FCC), body centred cubic (BCC) or hexagonal close packed (HCP). When a single crystal is terminated by a surface, then, depending on the angle of the termination, different atomic arrangements are exposed. These different surfaces are described by the Miller indices and an introduction to this system of classification of crystal structures and surfaces can be found in ref. 6, which also explains the Wood notation that is used to describe the symmetry of surfaces. For FCC and BCC crystals, surface planes are defined by three integers. The three `low index' surfaces, (110), (111) and (100) created from the FCC and BCC structures are shown in Figs 1.1 and 1.2, respectively. The figures show that different crystal planes have different atomic densities and hence differences in free energy at the surface. The free energy of a surface is an important determinant of its behaviour as will be discussed later in considerations of crystal growth. Free energy consideration also influences the natural cleavage planes of crystalline materials and cleavage along a nonpreferred direction often results in a rough morphology composed of small areas of energetically preferred faces known as faceting. The cleavage of single crystals in UHV is one of the easiest ways of producing a clean surface. However, it can only be applied to the natural cleavage planes and these are not always the most important surfaces of a material. A variety of ways have been developed for producing clean surfaces on crystal faces that cannot be obtained by cleaving. These often involve bombarding the surface with argon ions in UHV to remove impurities followed by annealing to remove the structural damage. However, there is no cleaning procedure that works for all surfaces, and a considerable amount of effort is devoted to finding a recipe for the cleaning of a surface which is to be studied for the first time. Fundamental investigations of systems in ambient air are naturally limited to surfaces that can be prepared in air, and this draws attention to structural
6
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
1.1 Surface structures created from cleavage of the FCC structure: (a) (110), (b) (111), and (c) (100). For the surface structures, the unit cells are shown: light spheres 1st layer atoms, dark spheres 2nd layer atoms.
stability in the presence of oxygen. Surfaces like graphite and mica that are stable against oxidation and which are easily cleaved in air to yield clean surfaces have naturally attracted attention. Cleaving graphite ± a layered material ± produces a well-defined surface consisting of large atomically flat terrace planes bounded by steps (Fig. 1.3). Such a relatively simple structure is ideal for investigating adsorption of organic molecules, and graphite has been used extensively for such studies.7,8 Gold surfaces are relatively inert to the effects of the atmosphere and this element provides some of the few single
Fundamental properties of surfaces
7
1.2 Surface structures created from cleavage of the BCC structure: (a) (110), (b) (111), and (c) (100). For the surface structures, the unit cells are shown: light spheres 1st layer atoms, dark spheres 2nd layer atoms, darkest spheres 3rd layer atoms.
crystal surfaces that can be prepared by the flame annealing technique for use as electrodes in electrochemical experiments at the solid/liquid interface. The surface structures shown in Figs 1.1 and 1.2 represent perfect terminations of the bulk crystal structure. The periodicity of the surface structures facilitates their representation by two-dimensional unit cells, which
8
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
1.3 (a) Atomic structure of graphite showing layers (b) AFM image of the graphite surface showing atomically flat terraces and steps.
can be repeated to represent the extended surface structure. For a perfectly terminated crystal surface, the lengths of the surface unit cell are determined by the lengths of the unit vectors of the corresponding two-dimensional plane of the three-dimensional unit cell of the bulk crystal structure. This relationship is termed a (1 1) surface structure in the Wood terminology.6 Atoms at newly created surfaces sometimes adopt different positions from those expected from a perfect termination of the bulk crystal structure and such `reconstructed' surfaces may adopt a new symmetry with a periodicity that differs from that of the bulk crystal structure. This new periodicity can often be represented relative
Fundamental properties of surfaces
9
1.4 The FCC(110)-(1 2) reconstruction. Light spheres 1st layer atoms, dark spheres 2nd layer atoms, darkest spheres 3rd layer atoms.
to the symmetry of the unit cell of the bulk structure by a change in the ratio of the surface to bulk unit vectors. The surface periodicity is then described in terms of these ratios, n and m, as (n m) in the Wood notation. Sometimes the representation of surface structures also requires a rotation of the axes of the surface unit cell relative to those of the bulk unit cell. Surface structures often involve a relaxation of the first few atomic planes in the direction normal to the surface. One example of a common reconstruction is the (1 2) `missing row' structure of the FCC(110) surface. In this reconstruction, every other 1 1 0 row of atoms from the normal (1 1) surface is missing (Fig. 1.4) and this doubling of periodicity in one dimension is captured by the (1 2) Wood terminology. The clean (110) surfaces of Au, Pt and Ir at room temperature in UHV all adopt the (1 2) structure. There are many different surface reconstructions and surfaces often reconstruct as a result of the adsorption of foreign species. The surface reconstructions of the Si(100) and (111) surfaces are among the most important technologically and are shown in Figs 1.5 and 1.6. These reconstructions are driven by the reactivity of the unsatisfied covalent bonds of the Si surface atoms. The reconstruction of the Si(100) surface is easy to understand in that it arises from the pairing of adjacent Si surface atoms to form dimers. The dimers form rows and since the surface periodicity along the rows is the same as that of the bulk structure while the surface periodicity at right-angles to the dimer rows is twice that of the bulk structure this is termed a (1 2) reconstruction in the Wood notation. As Fig. 1.6 shows, the reconstruction that occurs on the Si(111) surface is very complex. It has a (7 7) periodicity relative to the bulk structure and its formation requires a considerable displacement and rearrangement of the atoms in the top three layers of the
10
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
1.5 The Si(100) 1 2 reconstruction (courtesy Klaus Hermann, Fritz-HaberInstitut, Berlin).
Si(111) surface. The determination of the atomic positions in this structure took a considerable amount of time and required the application of all the major surface science experimental techniques. It is one of the many triumphs of the field. Once a well-defined single crystal surface is prepared, controlled experiments can then be performed such as investigating the first stages of oxidation or the interaction of the surface with molecular adsorbates. Structural defects such as adatoms, vacancies and steps, in addition to chemical impurities, can dramatically affect surface properties. It is often possible to control the introduction of these defects to surfaces and observe their impact on the system under investigation.
1.6 The Si(111) 7 7 reconstruction (a) STM image (Omicron Nanotechnology GmbH) and (b) surface structure model (reprinted from ref. 6 with permission of Oxford University Press).
Fundamental properties of surfaces
11
1.2.3 Determination of the elemental and chemical composition of surfaces: photoelectron and Auger electron spectroscopy Photoelectron spectroscopy involves illuminating a surface with photons of fixed energy and analysing the electrons subsequently emitted from the surface region. Atomic core hole states created by the X-ray emission of photoelectrons often decay by the Auger process which results in the emission of a second electron with an energy that is characteristic of the atomic element involved. These techniques can also be used to estimate the relative concentrations of the atomic species present in surfaces and the thickness of overlayers. Chemical bonds give rise to small changes in XPS and AES spectra that can be used to obtain insight into the chemical composition of surfaces. The electronic structure of a surface can be investigated using ultra-violet (UV) photoemission spectroscopy where the lower energy and momentum of UV photons relative to high energy X-rays allows the valence levels to be measured at high resolution. Unoccupied electronic bands can be examined using inverse photoemission spectroscopy (IPES).
1.2.4 Determination of surface structures: diffraction techniques The determination of surface structures on a macroscopic scale is obtained using diffraction techniques which, by their nature, emphasise periodicity. The more commonly used of these techniques are low-energy electron diffraction (LEED) and surface X-ray diffraction (SXRD). They give information on surface crystallography and can be used to determine the atomic structure of reconstructions and the overlayer structures of adsorbates. While LEED is restricted to a UHV environment, SXRD can be used to study surfaces at solid/ liquid interfaces.
1.2.5 Determination of the nature of molecular adsorption at surfaces: vibration spectroscopies and temperature programmed desorption Vibrational spectroscopies such as Raman spectroscopy and reflection absorption infra-red spectroscopy can provide information on molecular orientations at surfaces and on molecule-surface bonding. For example, whether a planar molecule adsorbed at a surface is flat-lying or upright can be distinguished. These techniques exploit the fact that chemical bonds absorb infra-red light at characteristic vibrational frequencies. An absorption spectrum reveals the chemical species present and shifts in frequencies from those expected from the `free' molecules in solution indicate interactions with the surface or other surface species.
12
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
Temperature programmed desorption (TPD) is primarily used to determine the binding energies of molecules adsorbed at surfaces. In this technique a linearly increasing temperature gradient is applied to the sample and the molecular mass of desorbing species is recorded as a function of time. In this way, specific mass fragments can be identified and the strength of interactions and the activation energy for desorption can be determined since the least bound molecules will desorb first as the temperature is raised.
1.2.6 Techniques for the study of surfaces in ambient conditions: scanning probe and optical techniques Scanning probe techniques such as scanning tunnelling microscopy (STM) and atomic force microscopy (AFM) provide information on atomic and electronic structure on a local scale. They reveal the morphology of the surface and the degree and extent of surface roughness and they can achieve atomic resolution. The mechanism of image formation involves the surface of interest being brought into close contact with a sharp tip and exploiting the precise scanning motion that can be obtained in the plane of the surface by the use of piezoceramic crystals. The surface is then scanned underneath the tip whilst monitoring a certain property of interaction between the tip and surface. For STM, a tunnelling current, of the order of nA, between the tip and sample is monitored and maintained at a constant value by an electronic feedback loop. The measured current is extremely sensitive to tip-sample separation and increases as the separation decreases. Thus, to maintain a constant current, the sample ± due to its morphology ± is moved up or down perpendicular to the surface plane and this information is used to construct a three-dimensional image of the surface. In AFM, the tip is mounted at the free end of a flexible cantilever that is pivoted at the other end. A laser beam reflecting off the back of the cantilever monitors the deflection of the tip-cantilever arrangement by the morphology of the surface. A constant deflection is maintained by moving the surface up or down and an image sensitive to the height is recorded. The basic principles of the operation of STM and AFM are shown in Figs 1.7 and 1.8. Optical probes have the potential to study surfaces in ambient conditions but need to allow for the fact that only ~1% of the optical signal reflected from a solid arises from the surface. This dominance of the bulk contribution to the reflected signal is overcome in reflection anisotropy spectroscopy (RAS) and the related technique of reflection anisotropy microscopy (RAM) by measuring the difference in reflectance of normal incidence linearly polarised light between two orthogonal directions in the surface plane. When applied to a cubic crystal material, the contribution from the bulk cancels by symmetry and RAS becomes a surface-sensitive probe of optical anisotropy. RAS was developed to monitor semiconductor growth at high pressures9 and has developed into a probe of metal
Fundamental properties of surfaces
13
1.7 Basic schematic showing the principle of operation of an STM (courtesy Michael Schmid, Technische Universitaet, Wien).
1.8 Basic schematic showing the principle of operation of an AFM.
14
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
surfaces10 with the potential to monitor molecular assembly at surfaces.11 Nonlinear optical techniques such as second harmonic generation (SHG) and sum frequency generation (SFG) are also surface sensitive and can be used to investigate chemical reactions at surfaces in a wide range of environments.12 After this brief introduction to the practical aspects of surface science we now review some of the most important conclusions reached from the study of surfaces.
1.3
Surface characteristics
Surfaces are usually expected to be flat, rigid and inert. However, this is rarely the case for real surfaces. At a microscopic level even the smoothest crystalline surface contains steps where atomic terraces of different height meet. Furthermore, these steps usually do not have straight edges but display kinks as they meander across a surface. The atoms at steps and kinks can have very different properties from atoms in the middle of terraces, and they often determine surface properties of technological importance such as the growth of crystals and the break up and assembly of molecules in catalytic reactions. Real surfaces are often rather flexible and are able to change their atomic structure in response to interactions with molecules.13,14 We have noted that the (110) surfaces of FCC metals often adopt a (1 2) missing row reconstruction (Fig. 1.4). This occurs because energetically the surface is finely balanced between the perfectly terminated and rather open (110) crystal plane and the (1 2) structure with its lower-energy close-packed (111) facets. Quite small changes to the surface electronic structure can induce changes in the structure of (110) surfaces of FCC crystals. In an electrochemical cell for example, the (1 1) to (1 2) phase transition can be induced on an Au(110) electrode by a change in charge density resulting from a change in the electrode potential and this change is reversible. Similar reconstructions can be induced by changing the potential on the other low index faces of Au in an electrochemical environment. In UHV the (1 2) reconstruction is the equilibrium structure of the Au(110) and Pt(110) faces though small amounts of adsorbed CO will change the Pt(110) surface back to a (1 1) structure. The opposite behaviour is found by the deposition of small amounts of alkali elements on the (110) faces of Ni, Cu, Pd and Ag which induce a (1 1) to (1 2) phase transition. The adsorption of larger molecules can induce more radical changes in surface structure. A dramatic example of this is the adsorption of hexa-tertbutyl-decacyclene (C60H66) on Cu(110).15 This molecule is approximately flat and it anchors to the Cu(110) surface through the formation of a characteristic trench in which 14 Cu atoms are dug out of the surface in a staggered arrangement involving two neighbouring close-packed rows, the free Cu atoms being added to kink sites at steps. When the molecules desorb, the surface is left with these characteristic trenches. It is as if the molecule leaves behind a footprint on the surface.
Fundamental properties of surfaces
15
Another remarkable example of adsorbate-induced restructuring is provided by the study by Bowker and co-workers14 on the adsorption of formic acid on a partially oxidised Cu(110) surface. The adsorption of oxygen creates a well known structure with (2 1) periodicity in which Cu atoms are incorporated into linear O-Cu-O-Cu rows orientated in [001] directions which are anchored at steps and which grow into islands of the (2 1) structure as the oxygen coverage increases. The formation of this structure is facilitated by the high mobility of Cu atoms at this surface. The adsorption of formic acid leads to a reaction with the (2 1) islands in which the Cu atoms at the end of the O-CuO-Cu units are released. These Cu atoms migrate and attach to more stable sites at the step edges between adjacent (2 1) islands. The subsequent desorption of formic acid leaves a surface in which the initial almost linear steps have been transformed into a sharp and jagged sawtooth structure.
1.4
Active sites and kinetics
The term `active site' refers to a specific atomic site on a surface where an interaction or reaction occurs. Active sites often involve atoms located at steps and kinks which have different coordination numbers from those of atoms bound in the terrace planes. The nature and influence of active sites can often be determined from TPD studies as illustrated by the following example of H2 adsorbed on Pt surfaces.13 The ideal Pt(111) surface is flat with hexagonal symmetry and one can identify three obvious adsorption sites as illustrated in Fig. 1.9; the top site where a molecule sits on top of an atom, the bridge site where a molecule is located between two atoms and the three-fold hollow site between three adjacent atoms. TPD studies of hydrogen desorption from the flat (111) surface show two overlapping peaks (Fig. 1.10) indicating that hydrogen occupies two sites on Pt(111) terraces with very similar binding energies. The Pt(557) surface consists of flat (111) terraces and steps aligned along a common direction giving a surface that is rather like a staircase (Fig. 1.9b). TPD results for this surface show peaks in the desorption of hydrogen that occur at two very different temperatures (Fig. 1.10). The peak at lower temperature corresponds to the peaks seen on the Pt(111) surface and is associated with adsorption on the (111) terraces and the peak at higher temperatures is associated with hydrogen that is more tightly bound to the higher coordination sites available at the steps. The TPD results for the desorption of hydrogen from the Pt(12,9,8) surface, which consists of (111) terraces and steps with the steps containing a large number of kink sites (Fig. 1.9c), is shown in Fig. 1.10. An additional peak is observed in the TPD results for this surface compared to the results for the Pt(557) surface (Fig. 1.10) and it is natural to associate this higher temperature peak with the binding of hydrogen to kink sites. Some insight into the nature of the adsorption of hydrogen on Pt surfaces can be obtained from TPD studies of surfaces which are dosed with a mixture of H2
16
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
1.9 Surface structures of (a) Pt(111) showing the three possible adsorption sites, (b) Pt(557) and (c) Pt(12,9,8).
and D2. If the molecules dissociate on the surface it is possible that HD molecules will form prior to desorption. It is found that on well ordered Pt(111) surfaces the formation of HD is below the detection limits of the experiment indicating that the molecules do not dissociate on adsorption. However on stepped surfaces the production of HD indicates that all the molecules dissociate on adsorption. Clearly the symmetry and coordination of the adsorption site has an important influence on the details of the adsorption and desorption processes, a result that is borne out by a large number of studies on a wide variety of other systems.
Fundamental properties of surfaces
17
1.10 TPD results of H desorption from Pt(111), Pt(557) and Pt(12,9,8) (reprinted from ref. 13 with permission of John Wiley & Sons Inc.).
1.5
Controlling crystal growth: Semiconductor technology
One of the most impressive achievements of surface science has been in fostering the growth of semiconductor devices that in the last twenty years have revolutionised many aspects of technology particularly in the field of communication. This industry was not possible until the development of UHV technology and associated surface science techniques of surface preparation and characterisation. Indeed, all stages in the development of semiconductor devices have benefited from the exploitation of advances made in surface science. The key to this technology is establishing control over the growth of single crystal semiconductors and this is usually achieved by the molecular beam epitaxy (MBE) technique, which operates in a UHV environment, or by a variety of chemical vapour deposition (CVD) techniques which operate at higher pressures but in very controlled conditions. We can obtain some insight into the factors that are important in controlling crystal growth by considering the growth of crystals from solution in which the differences in the free energy of different crystal faces have a strong influence on the crystal shape. Provided there is sufficient kinetic freedom during the growth process then atoms being
18
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
added to a crystal during growth will migrate to the face with the lowest free energy. This face will thus grow faster than other faces and, all other factors being equal, the equilibrium crystal shape will be the one in which the relative distances of each face from the nucleation centre is inversely proportional to the ratio of the free energies of the faces. Often, however, the `other factors' are not equal and crystal shape can be strongly influenced by factors such as temperature and the composition of the growth medium. This was discovered several hundred years ago when in 1783 Rome de l'Isle showed that octahedrons are formed instead of cubes if NaCl is grown in the presence of urine.16 This puzzling observation has recently been explained17 in terms of the role of the urea molecule in stabilising the (111) crystal face in solution during growth. A similar rebalancing of kinetic factors caused by subtle changes in the conditions of growth probably explains why natural diamonds tend to have octohedral shapes while those that are grown under high pressure and high-temperature conditions in the laboratory have a more cubic form though the morphology of the latter can be modified to a certain extent by varying the growth temperature. Diamond is also a good illustration of the fact that the structure of a solid is not always in equilibrium since the phase diagram of carbon (Fig. 1.11) shows that at normal pressures and temperatures the equilibrium structure of carbon is graphite, which consists of layers of strongly bonded carbon atoms (Fig. 1.3) with much weaker bonding between the layers. The cubic diamond form in which each carbon is at the centre of a tetrahedron of neighbouring carbon atoms (Fig. 1.12) is thus metastable at room temperature and pressure. The reason diamond does not readily transform into graphite is due to the energy barrier that
1.11 The phase diagram of carbon.
Fundamental properties of surfaces
19
1.12 The diamond crystal structure (reprinted from Introduction to Solid State Physics, 7th edition (1996) by C. Kittel with permission from John Wiley & Sons Inc.).
has to be overcome to re-orientate the inter-atomic bonds. The system is thus not able to reach equilibrium because kinetic factors prevent it from escaping from a local energy minimum. These kinetic factors can be exploited in the growth of diamond. The carbon phase diagram (Fig. 1.11) shows that it is reasonable to expect to be able to grow diamond at the high-pressure, high-temperature region on the border between the graphite and diamond phases. However, it is surprising that diamond can also be grown in the low-pressure and relatively low-temperature region by the chemical vapour deposition (CVD) process, which makes use of a microwave plasma excitation of a hydrocarbon vapour stream. The key to the CVD growth of diamond is to include a very low concentration of carbon in the feedstock gas: a typical growing medium consists of 99.5% H2 and 0.5% CH4. This ensures that the plasma is dominated by H ions and these ions terminate the surface carbon atoms of the diamond ensuring the maintenance of local tetrahedral and near tetrahedral bonding configurations. When an unsaturated surface carbon bond occurs it is unlikely that the adjacent carbon also has an unsaturated bond. Thus in these conditions the growth mode tends to promote the tetrahedral bonding of the diamond structure rather than the planar geometry of the graphite structure. Clearly, in the manufacture of semiconductor devices, it is important to monitor and control surface processes and in particular to achieve an understanding of the kinetic factors that can be exploited to ensure that a complex multilayer device structure maintains its coherence. This control is achieved by the MBE and CVD techniques. We comment here on one small aspect of this field that illustrates the importance of an understanding of surface properties in the design and production of semiconductor devices. A key material of course is Si and at certain stages in device processing it is necessary to `passivate' Si surfaces so that they do not form chemical bonds with molecules in the growth environment. However Si surfaces are very reactive
20
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
because Si adopts the diamond structure in which each atom bonds with four neighbouring atoms (Fig. 1.12) and when a surface is created this leaves the surface atoms with unsatisfied bonds. It is often necessary to passivate such surfaces at various stages in device manufacture. One approach is to deposit an ordered layer of As atoms taking advantage of the natural tendency of As to bond to three neighbours. The difference in the geometry of the Si(100) and (111) surfaces requires different passivating structures. The Si(100) surface is passivated by the formation of As dimers each of which bonds to two Si atoms in the layer below and its neighbouring As in the dimer. On the (111) surface As atoms are coordinated to three Si atoms in the layer below. In each of these structures the As atoms have no unsaturated bonds and the surface is inert ± as illustrated by the fact that the sticking coefficient for the reaction with oxygen is reduced by ~15 orders of magnitude with respect to the corresponding Si surface. This control of surface reactivity is just one of the many ways in which semiconductor device technology is dependent on advances made in surface science.
1.6
Heterogeneous catalysis
It is estimated that industrial processes that employ catalysts have a turnover of the order of £2,000 billion per year in the UK and quite small improvements in the efficiency of catalytic processes can have a major impact on industrial costs. When this is set against a background in which little is known about the actual mechanisms of catalysis one can understand why this field is one of the strongest drivers for research in surface science. The industrial exploitation of catalysis has already had a major impact on the world and one process in particular, the Haber-Bosch method of ammonia synthesis from a mixture of hydrogen and nitrogen gas, has been called the most important invention of the twentieth century because of its role in sustaining the increase in world population through the production of nitrogen based fertiliser (Fig. 1.13).18 This process was discovered empirically and was first used commercially in 1913. The catalytic mechanism is very complex and in spite of a century of research it is still not fully understood. The Haber-Bosch process involves passing N2 and H2 over Fe surfaces. The catalyst is composed of small porous Fe particles of surface area approximately 15 m2/g. A few percent of aluminium oxide (Al2O3), potassium oxide (K2O) and other compounds are added as `promoters' which increase the activity of the iron though their precise role is unclear. The reaction takes place at about 400 ëC in a total pressure of 150 to 300 atmospheres. Ammonia production shows a complex dependence on the partial pressures of N2, H2 and NH3. The reaction can be summarised as follows: N2 and H2 molecules interact with the surface, dissociate into atoms and chemisorb on the surface. The N atoms then react with H atoms to form NH3, which then desorbs from the surface. The main factors
Fundamental properties of surfaces
21
1.13 Growth in global consumption of N fertiliser and increase in world population (figure by Bryan Christie, reprinted from ref. 18).
that determine the rate of ammonia synthesis are the N2 dissociative sticking probability and the N atom chemisorption energy. As illustrated by the Haber-Bosch process a catalyst must be able to bind molecules, often dissociating them in the process, allow the bound species to react with other molecules and then allow desorption of the desired reaction product. Heterogeneous catalyst systems usually involve small particles that are dispersed over a support material ± often a metal oxide. The small particles have size of the order of nanometres leading to the term `nanoparticles'. Surface effects dominate the structural features of nanoparticles, which have high free energies and are thus very reactive. The fact that catalytic processes usually take place at high pressures means that there is a `pressure gap' in trying to obtain insight into catalytic processes from experiments in UHV conditions. Another limitation on the applicability of surface science techniques to the study of catalysis is that industrial catalysts usually employ highly reactive and poorly characterised nanoparticles whereas surface science seeks to simplify the complexities of chemical reactions by
22
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
experimental work on well characterised single crystal surfaces. These limitations aside, surface science has provided some insight into catalytic mechanisms.19 As an illustration of the strengths and limitations of the current level of understanding achieved in surface science we consider two important examples: the Haber-Bosch process of ammonia synthesis and the oxidation of CO in catalysts for automobile exhausts.
1.6.1 The Haber-Bosch process Surface science studies of single crystal surfaces in UHV have yielded some insight into the mechanisms of the Haber-Bosch process. The results are summarised in ref. 13 and experiments on different surface planes of Fe single crystals show that the efficiency of the process reduces in the sequence: (111), (211), (100), (210), (110). These surfaces have different morphologies, and close examination shows that the (111) surface of BCC Fe is relatively rough exposing the first, second and third layer atoms while the (110) surface is relatively smooth exposing the first layer of atoms and a fraction of the second layer (Fig. 1.2). However surface roughness alone cannot explain the observed catalytic activities which are actually determined by the nature of the active sites. High coordination sites, as found on (111) and (211) surfaces, promote reactions and a good correlation has been found between coordination and efficiency. This suggests why small particles are more efficient than larger ones since small particles have larger numbers of high coordination sites.
1.6.2 The oxidation of CO in automobile exhausts In recent years catalysis has found increasing application in mitigating the environmental impact of automobile exhausts. A typical catalytic converter in a car exhaust is constructed from a high surface area honeycomb structure which is coated with a thin mixture of porous aluminium oxide, ceria and zirconia that is impregnated with nanoparticles of reactive metals such as platinum, ruthenium, palladium and rhodium. Platinum is used to oxidise hydrocarbons and carbon monoxide gas while rhodium serves to reduce nitrogen-oxide species. Early work seeking to understand the detail of these reactions adopted the approach of characterising the surface in UHV, conducting a reaction at high pressure and then examining the surface immediately afterwards. Important information has been gained by this approach, revealing changes in structure and composition of the surface following the catalytic reaction. However, the need to monitor and understand such processes at high pressure is illustrated dramatically by the observation that whereas Ru is the least efficient metal for promoting the oxidation of CO in UHV, it is the most efficient for promoting this reaction at high pressures. Fortunately, significant progress is now being made both theoretically and experimentally in this field and the resolution of the
Fundamental properties of surfaces
23
apparent paradox of the pressure dependence of the oxidation of CO by Ru, which is described below, is an excellent illustration of the importance of bridging the pressure gap in the study of surfaces.
1.7
Real surfaces: theoretical advances
In spite of the progress made in surface science in the last forty years, our understanding of the behaviour of surfaces in the real world at normal temperatures and pressures is currently quite poor. However, advances are now being made in the study of real surfaces and much of the impetus for this progress has come from theoretical developments. It is now understood why the capacity of Ru to promote the oxidation of CO is so dependent on pressure. The insights into the resolution of this problem are likely to be generally relevant and are worthy of a brief summary. The key issue is to note that the length and timescales at which processes happen and can be studied experimentally in surface science are very different from those that determine the behaviour of surfaces in the real world. This issue has been reviewed recently by Stampf and co-workers20 who draw attention to three important regiems of length and timescale as shown in Fig. 1.14. The bottom left, microscopic, region of Fig. 1.14 is dominated by the motion of electrons and atoms which occur on timescales of 10ÿ15 seconds and 10ÿ12 seconds respectively. An appropriate length scale is 0.1 nm ± the length over which an atom moves between adjacent atomic sites. This regiem is well described by density functional theory which describes the behaviour of
1.14 The spatial and temporal domains relevant to different aspects of the behaviour of surfaces (reprinted from ref. 20 with permission from Elsevier).
24
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
electrons in the potential environment created by atoms and molecules. Many surface science techniques yield useful information on processes that occur on the length and timescales that characterise this regiem. However, while the behaviour of systems in the microscopic regiem is a determinant of what can happen in the mesoscopic regiem, it is not possible to use results obtained in this regiem to infer what will happen at more macroscopic length and timescales. This is because an understanding of the more macroscopic regiems requires the introduction of approaches from statistical mechanics and thermodynamics. Fortunately, theoretical work in association with relevant experimental results is beginning to make useful links between regiems shown in Fig. 1.14. This work resolves the paradox concerning the behaviour of the Ru surface at high pressure since it makes clear that at high pressure the Ru surface converts to the oxide RuO2 and it is the oxide surface that promotes the oxidation of CO to CO2. The key observation is that at higher temperatures and pressures changes in the relative free energies of the metal and its oxide give rise to an intimate interplay between the progress of the chemical reaction and the morphology and chemical composition of the surface and the surrounding gases. We might expect similar considerations to be important in many other areas of surface science where work in UHV does not lead to a simple understanding of the behaviour of surfaces in the real world.
1.8
Real surfaces: experimental approaches
It is clear from the previous section that an understanding of the behaviour of real surfaces under ambient conditions requires information that can only be obtained using experimental probes that can operate outside of UHV. We saw earlier that scanning probe microscopy and optical probes both have this capability. Since, in general, scanning probes reveal information on the microand nanoscale and are rather slow and optical probes yield an average signal over a macroscopic area and can be rather fast these generic techniques complement each other in both the length and timescale over which they can provide information on surface processes. A good example is the study of Hendriksen and Frenken21 who used STM to observe in situ the oxidation of CO on the Pt(110) surface at semi-realistic conditions of sample temperature 425 K and gas flow of pressure 500 mbar. During the reaction the surface was found to change from a metallic CO-covered surface to an oxide surface. In a similar finding to the Ru case, the Pt-oxide surface was found to exhibit the higher catalytic activity. The potential of optical probes to reveal the dynamics of surface processes at higher pressures is shown by the studies of Rotermund and co-workers22 who used RAM to monitor the oxidation of CO at the Pt(110) surface in both low, ~10ÿ4 mbar, and high, approaching atmospheric, partial pressures of CO and O2. This surface has two states, an inert passive state in which the surface is
Fundamental properties of surfaces
25
`poisoned' by the presence of adsorbed CO and an active oxidising surface covered by the dissociative adsorption of O2. Since the surface is not perfect there will always be a particularly active site which at low pressure will promote local oxidation of CO to CO2. This reaction proceeds exothermically and the energy released locally initiates a reaction-front which, in the low partial pressure regimen, spreads across the surface leaving in its wake the poisoned surface created by the exhaustion of locally adsorbed oxygen. The progress of the reaction-front can be observed in real time by RAM and this technique shows that at relatively low pressures, the surface undergoes an oscillating reaction mediated by variations in the partial pressures of O2, CO and CO2. The oscillations are sufficiently robust that two crystal surfaces exposed to the same gaseous environment will oscillate in phase. It is important to note that in the low pressure regimen the thermal characteristics of these reactions are dominated by the large thermal capacity of the experimental mount that is supporting the Pt crystal. However, as the pressure of the reacting gases is increased, a point is reached where energy is released at the reaction site faster than it can be conducted away. The resulting local increase in temperature accelerates the reaction resulting in a thermal runaway that is terminated only by the local exhaustion of the reacting species. In these conditions the smoothly varying oscillations are replaced by sudden local bursts of activity that have no spatial or temporal coordination. This later mode of activity is likely to be more characteristic of the actual behaviour occurring during catalytic reactions at high pressure and demonstrates the importance of experimental work that can bridge the pressure gap.
1.9
Insight into the biological activity of surfaces
This brief survey of progress in surface science suggests a number of ways in which the characteristics of surfaces are likely to have biological significance. We highlight three areas.
1.9.1 The biological activity of nanoparticles As indicated, nanoparticulate matter is characterised by high free energies and a high concentration of active sites. For these reasons they find application in industrial catalytic processes. However, we should expect that these characteristics also endow nanoparticles with significant biological activity and it is well known that ultra-fine air-borne particulates can have harmful effects, as recently demonstrated by the studies of the damage they cause to the mitochondria in cells.23 As the emerging field of nanotechnology develops it would be sensible to be aware of the implications for the health of the population by the release of novel and biologically active particulates into the environment.24
26
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
1.9.2 Insights into naturally occurring biological processes We have drawn attention to the enormous impact on the world of the application of the Haber-Bosch process for fixing nitrogen and the insight that surface science is providing into the detailed mechanisms of this reaction. However, in comparison with natural mechanisms of fixing nitrogen, the Haber-Bosch process is remarkably inefficient requiring, as it does, high pressures and high temperatures. Natural processes clearly extract nitrogen from the atmosphere and bind it in chemical complexes at normal temperature and pressure. Can surface science provide insight into the mechanisms of natural processes in fixing nitrogen? It is interesting to view the recent advance in the understanding of how Mo complexes fix nitrogen25 in a surface science context. To begin with, the mechanism requires a large molecular complex of nanoparticle dimensions. It also depends on an active catalytic site that shows considerable flexibility during the various reactions that constitute the mechanism of nitrogen fixation. This is consistent with what we have learnt from surface science concerning the importance of free energy, active sites and surface flexibility in promoting chemical reactions. One may speculate that the ultimate success of surface science will be to provide us with a sufficient understanding of catalytic processes that we can escape the restrictions imposed by surfaces and develop ways of constructing tailored active and flexible sites in molecules similar to the complexes that operate in natural processes.
1.9.3 Prospects for the study of biomedical interfaces Surface science has addressed metal, oxide and semiconductor surfaces with an approach involving simple systems studied at the fundamental level with powerful probes. This approach will be beneficial for the investigation of complex biosurfaces. One would anticipate that the important determinants of surface processes such as free energies, kinetic factors and the nature of active sites will have an important influence on the behaviour of biomedical interfaces. Clearly the study of such interfaces would benefit considerably from the development of experimental techniques for studying surfaces in ambient conditions. Some indications of the insight into the behaviour of biomedical interfaces can be obtained from studies of the temporal dependence of proteins deposited on human colostrum immobilised on methylated silicon surfaces from human blood serum.26 This study employed a combination of ellipsometry and antibody techniques to provide a convenient and rapid way to indicate the activation of complement sequences on solid surfaces and facilitated a time-resolved determination of replacement sequences and activation pathways.
Fundamental properties of surfaces
27
1.10 Conclusion In this chapter we have considered some of the fundamental properties of surfaces. We have seen that surface science has had a huge impact on the growth of semiconductor devices and has had some success in the understanding of catalytic processes. We have seen that progress is now being made, both theoretically and experimentally, in the study of real surfaces in ambient conditions. We believe that the insights obtained from the study of surfaces have the potential to make a major contribution to the understanding of biological systems.
1.11 References 1. Wyckoff R W G, Crystal Structures, 2nd edn, Volumes 1±6, Interscience, New York, 1963±1971. 2. Woodruff D P and Delchar T A, in Modern Techniques of Surface Science, 2nd edn, Cambridge University Press, 1994. 3. Zangwill A, Physics at Surfaces, Cambridge University Press, 1996. 4. Prutton M, in Introduction to Surface Physics, Clarendon Press, 1994. 5. Venables J A, in Introduction to Surface and Thin Film Processes, Cambridge University Press, 2000. 6. Attard G and Barnes C, in Surfaces, Oxford University Press 1998. 7. Magonov S N and Whangbo M-H, in Surface Analysis with STM and AFM, VCH, Weinheim, 1996. 8. Martin D S and Weightman P, Surf. Sci. 464 23 (2000). 9. Aspnes D E, Harbison J P, Studna A A and Florez L T, J. Vac. Sci. Technol. A6 1327 (1988). 10. Martin D S and Weightman P, Surface Review and Letters, 7 4 389 (2000). 11. Martin D S and Weightman P, Thin Solid Films, 455±456, 752 (2004). 12. McGilp J F, Surf. Rev. Lett., 6 (3±4), 529 (1999). 13. Somorjai G A, in Introduction to Surface Chemistry and Catalysis, Wiley, New York, 1994. 14. Bowker M and Bennet R A, Topics in Catalysis, 14 1 (2001). 15. Schunack M, Petersen L, Kuehnle A, Laegsgaard E, Stensgaard I, Johannsen I and Besenbacher F, Phys. Rev. Lett., 86 456 (2001). 16. de Rome de l'Isle J B L, Crystallographie (Imprimerie de Monsieur, Paris) 1 379 (1783). 17. Radenovic N, von Enckevoly W, Verwer P and Vlieg E, Surf. Sci., 523 307 (2003). 18. Smil V, `Global population and the nitrogen cycle', Scientific American, 227 76, July (1997). 19. Sinfelt J H, Surf. Sci., 500 923 (2002). 20. Stampfl C, Ganduglia-Pirovano M V, Reuter K and Scheffler M, Surf. Sci., 500 368 (2002). 21. Hendriksen B L M and Frenken J M W, Phys. Rev. Lett., 89, 46101 (2002). 22. Dicke J, Erichesen P, Wolff J and Rotermund H H, Surf. Sci., 462 90 (2000). 23. Li N, Sioutas C, Cho A, Schmitz D, Misra C, Sempf J, Wang M, Oberley T, Froines
28
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
J and Nel A, Environmental Health Perspectives, 111 455 (2003). 24. Report of Royal Society and Royal Academy of Engineering on Nanotechnology, July 2004. 25. Yandulov D V and Schrock R R, Science, 301 76 (2003). 26. Tengvall P, Askendal A and Lundstrom I, J. Biomedical Materials Research, 35 81 (1997).
2
Control of polymeric biomaterial surfaces
V H A S I R C I and N H A S I R C I , METU, Turkey
2.1
Introduction
Polymers are long, linear or branched chains of molecular weight 10,000 daltons or higher consisting of one or more basic structural or monomeric units. The flexibility of the chain depends on the stiffness of the individual units making up the chain, to the bonds that link them together, the length of the chain and the presence and nature of the branches. These chains are found naturally both in the environment and in the human body. They can also be synthesized from the monomers in the laboratory to yield macromolecules of the desired properties.
2.2
Preparation of polymers
Polymers are prepared by the reaction of monomers. The method of polymerization could be classified as `condensation polymerization' and `addition polymerization'. Condensation polymers are formed by molecules with functional groups that could condense to form the chain mostly by the release of a small molecule such as water, ammonia, etc. Addition polymerization require unsaturated molecules to become saturated while adding to the chain after activation by ionic or free radical initiators, or high energy radiation. The synthetic process is started by the use of an initiator and is helped by exposure to highly energetic radiation (i.e. UV, gamma), elevated temperatures and accelerators. Biological polymers (such as proteins and polysaccharides) are formed exclusively through polycondensation but require enzymes for the initiation and progression of the chain formation reaction.
2.2.1 Homopolymerization Polymers could form by the chain reaction of a single monomer through a condensation or addition reaction. The resultant compound is a very large
30
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
molecule consisting of a single molecule (could be represented by A below) repeated hundreds or thousands of times. -A-A-A-A-A-A-A-A-A-A-A-A-A-A-A-
or
-[A]n-
This kind of a molecule is generally linear unless higher functionality is available on the monomer. Some biological macromolecules such as polysaccharides could yield branched structures only because of the high number of -OH groups. Actually there are no natural homopolymers consisting of amino acids or nucleic acids to yield proteins (i.e. polyalanine) or DNA or RNA (i.e. polyU) from a single molecule. A typical example of this kind of polymer is polyethylene which consists of many -CH2-CH2- groups added on the end. This group is called the repeating unit, since it is the basic element of the macromolecule that repeats itself to represent the final product. The number of these repeating units is known as the degree of polymerization, P, which is an average value due to the random nature of the progression of the reaction. When the carbon atoms in the chain are asymmetric (like -CHR- and unlike -CH2-) the steric position of the monomer side group (R) gains importance. An irregular organization of the R groups lead to an atactic polymer while an alternating position leads to a syndiotactic polymer and a same side orientation is called isotactic. Crystallinity of polymers, a very important property of the solid state, is a direct result of this preferential orientation of the side groups.
2.2.2 Copolymerization and terpolymerization (alternating, block, random) Polymers can also form when two or more monomers are involved in the preparation of the macromolecule. The order in which these monomers come together is very influential on the properties of the resultant polymer. If there are two different monomers such as A and B they could take places in the chain in a random manner forming a random copolymer of A and B: -A-A-B-A-B-B-A-B-B-B-A-A-B-A-A-AThis is the case with most industrial copolymers where the composition of the monomer mixture is not reflected in the resultant polymer. The structural units of the polymer could be ordered in an alternating manner to yield an alternating polymer: -A-B-A-B-A-B-A-B-A-B-A-B-A-B-A-BAnother way the monomer could be arranged on the chain is by way of combination of segments or blocks of single monomer chains: A-A-A-A-A-B-B-B-B-B-B-A-A-A-A-A-A-
Control of polymeric biomaterial surfaces
31
2.2.3 Branching and crosslinking In principle, monomers are either bifunctional or they have unsaturations which enable them to interact with two molecules. In either case a linear molecule is formed. In the presence of compounds with more than two functional groups (for condensation) or more than one unsaturation (for addition) a branched molecule is formed. The branches might form simultaneously with the formation of the chains but also could be induced after the polymer formation is completed (Fig. 2.1). Crosslinking is similar to branching but the general understanding is that a number of chains are bonded together with groups which might (or might not) be of the same chemical origin (Fig. 2.2). As the number of crosslinks increase the solubility of the polymeric structure decreases. At a critical number all the chains of the polymer are bonded covalently together leading to an insoluble polymer, the fully crosslinked structure.
2.1 Branched polymers are linear polymers with short chains of the same composition attached.
2.2 Crosslinking involves covalent and transient linking of polymer chains and significantly modifies the mechanical and solution properties.
2.2.4 Grafting and blending In addition to the above there are graft polymers where one chain serves as a backbone and relatively shorter chains of different chemistry are attached to this backbone as branches (Fig. 2.3). Blending, on the other hand, is a physical mixture where there is no covalent bond between chains of two or more different types brought together either by melting or dissolution followed by solvent removal leading to macromolecules of various types of chains.
32
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
2.3 Grafting of B oligomers on the poly A backbone.
2.3
The solid state and structure
Synthetic polymers are formed in the reaction media and each chain is initiated and terminated at a different time and as a result each chain has a different length leading to a distribution of chain lengths. This is unlike the biological system where the genetic material and proteins are of known fixed molecular weights because their production is highly controlled. In the chemical system there is no such control. As a result, rather than a single molecular weight, one determines an average molecular weight, the value of which is dependent on the method employed. The most widely used average molecular weights are weight average molecular weight (Mw ) and number average molecular weight (Mn ). Their ratio is called the Heterogeneity Index (HI) or polydispersity: w M HI Mn and as the HI gets closer to 1 the molecular weight distribution gets narrower. This ratio is especially important in terms of the mechanical properties because as the fraction of very low molecular weight chains increase they act more as plasticizers that reduce the mechanical strength of the material. It is also an important indicator for the mobility of low molecular weight materials to the surface when the polymeric product is introduced into solvents.
2.3.1 Amorphous and crystalline polymers A glassy polymer structure is visualized as densely packed, entangled, random Gaussian coils (Fig. 2.4). The random coil state remains favourable in the glassy state (Stachurski, 2003). Above the glass transition temperature, Tg, where chains gain mobility, the chains are confined to molecular tubes, within which de Gennes reptation takes place. From NMR studies it is confirmed that the chain is not a simple (smooth), constant curvature random coil, but it is further segmented by folds (on itself). The number of folds per chain is a property of the chain (stiffness and chemistry) and of the temperature. The size of the fold is, to a good
Control of polymeric biomaterial surfaces
33
2.4 A glassy polymer structure.
approximation, independent of temperature and chain length. The segments between the folds are between 10 and 20 covalent bonds long. Within the macroscopic volume of the polymer, so-called `free volume' is present as an equilibrium property of the system at Tg. At sufficiently fast cooling rate from this state to a temperature below Tg, the polymer retains a certain amount of the free volume. The actual amount depends on the temperature from which the quench occurs, the cooling rate, and the type of the polymer and its volume. A glassy polymer is formed because the irregular chain architecture prevents crystallization. On cooling to below Tg, a portion of the unoccupied free volume spontaneously diffuses out, allowing the bulk volume to reduce. In the process, the equilibrium end-to-end distance of chains is compressed. Its relaxation time rapidly increases. The prerequisites for the ability to crystallize is regularity, both in terms of composition and stereochemistry of the polymer. Even then it is not enough for the observation of crystallinity. Long periods of cooling might be necessary for allowing the chain substituents to take the required conformation before they can crystallize. They can not, however, completely crystallize; there are always regions (chain ends or side groups) found not to be crystallized when examined by electron microscopy. The resultant structure is what is called the fringed micelle (Fig. 2.5). The rate of cooling is also important because if the cooling rate is high the polymer might not find time to orientate and crystallize and instead solidify in a glassy form. Polymer molecules in the melt are in the form of coils rather than stretched out chains. During the formation of the crystals the coil is still the Ê and the central form. A typical single crystal lamella thickness is around 100 A polymers arrange perpendicular to the plane of the crystal. This has been shown to be true with polyethylene, polypropylene, and low molecular weight paraffins. Since, however, the chains in the lamellae are not equal in length the surface of the single crystal must appear rough.
34
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
2.5 Fringed micelle structure.
2.3.2 Packing, packing density and free volume A glassy polymer is formed because its irregular chain architecture prevents crystallization and it solidifies with a significant volume unoccupied by atoms, which is called the free volume. If this cooling rate is decreased then better packing with a lower free volume is observed. On the other hand when a crystalline polymer is solidified, the organization of the chains and the atoms are such that the unoccupied volume within the solid is minimal. Thus, the free volume in the amorphous polymer is higher than that in a crystalline polymer. The lower free volume indicates a higher amount of interaction between neighboring chain segments and thus to a mechanically stronger structure. In a fringed micelle structure where there is partial crystallinity, certain regions of the polymer are densely packed with low free volume, while the rest is amorphous with high free volume. In such a case the bulk of the polymer as well as its surface has regions of high and low packing density and is expected to have different responses in a biological medium.
2.3.3 Phase states and phase transition Polymers in a solid state could show different properties depending respectively on their chemical structure and presence of crosslinking, the medium temperature and Tg and Tm values of the polymer, the presence or absence of load, and the rate at which it is applied. As a result of this the polymer could function differently than intended, and one needs to know these property changes before converting the polymer into a product. Rubber elasticity When a solid polymeric compound softens upon increase of medium temperature, it still retains the interactions between the chains of a coil and between coils. Upon increase of temperature the chains in a coil and the coils themselves become more and more mobile with respect to each other and few
Control of polymeric biomaterial surfaces
35
contacts are left intra- and intermolecularly. If the temperature is not high enough to completely melt the polymer or if there are covalent linkages (crosslinks) between the chains, it first responds by deforming and then by regaining the original form when subjected to a short deforming force. A change in the position of coils with respect to each other does not take place. This behavior of the material, represented by a strong deformation under a small deforming force and elastic recovery was first observed with natural rubber and is known as rubber elasticity. Relaxation processes When the polymer is brought above its softening point and if the application of the deforming force is sufficiently long, the chains in the structure have time to reorganize with respect to each other into an energetically more favorable state. In this way, the inner tension that has developed in the system is relieved by the process called `relaxation'. If the viscosity of the system is low, the relaxation is too rapid and no recovery can take place. If the viscosity is high the relaxation time is longer and there is a chance for recovery. The latter type of materials flow if the deformation is prolonged, but they are elastic if the deformation is short and rapid. A material that shows both rubber elastic behavior and relaxation is called viscoelastic.
2.4
Polymer-solvent interactions
Polymers present certain chemical and physical properties when dry, but upon coming in contact with liquids all this changes. Certain regions or phases of the polymer might interact with the liquid more than the rest of the structure leading to a different surface composition than in a dry state. The liquid could also lead to swelling or dissolution of the polymer, changing the properties further. It is therefore very important to understand the behavior of the polymer in a variety of solvents.
2.4.1 Polymer gels, hydrogels Crosslinked polymers by definition are composed of a large number of chains strongly (mostly covalently) bonded to each other. Upon immersion of the crosslinked polymer in a solvent the chains forming the structure separate from each other and become solvated but cannot dissolve away due to the restrictions imposed by the links between the chains. This structure is called a gel. If the solvent in which the structure is introduced is water, then the water-swollen structure is called a hydrogel. There are cases where the polymer is introduced to a `less good' solvent, a solvent in which the chemical structures of the solvent and the polymer are not
36
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
similar, and solvation is not as easy as it is in a good solvent. Under those circumstances, an uncrosslinked polymer swells but it is not possible to separate the chains from each other due to the weak interaction with the solvent. In these cases one still obtains gels even though there are no crosslinks. In the latter case, it is possible to achieve solubility by increasing temperature, but a truly covalently crosslinked system cannot dissolve upon increase of temperature.
2.4.2 Sol-gel transition The sol phase is defined as a flowing fluid, whereas the gel phase is non-flowing and maintains its integrity against external forces. Above the critical concentration (critical gel concentration, CGC) of a polymer, the gel phase appears. The CGC is most often inversely related to the molecular weight of the polymer employed. The development of physical junctions is needed for gelation, which must be sufficiently strong to overcome the dissolving forces of the solvent. Thermoreversible gelation of gelatin and polysaccharides such as agarose, amylose, and amylopectin, cellulose derivatives, carrageenans are well known. At high temperatures, they are assumed to have a random coil conformation. On reducing the temperature, they start to form double helices and aggregates. Most natural polymers form a gel phase on lowering temperature. They are said to have Upper Critical Solution Temperature, UCST. However, aqueous solutions of some cellulose derivatives exhibit reverse thermogelation (gelation upon increase of temperature) and are said to have a Lower Critical Solution Temperature, LCST. Cellulose itself is not soluble in water, however, it becomes water soluble upon introduction of hydrophilic moieties (Jeong et al., 2002). When these derivatives have a balance between hydrophilic and hydrophobic moieties, they undergo sol-to-gel transitions upon change of temperature. The temperature at which sol-gel transition takes place depends on the level and location of the substitution. Upon increasing temperature, water becomes a poorer solvent and polymer-polymer interactions become dominant and a gel forms. Table 2.1 shows the LCST values of some polymers.
2.4.3 Influence of bulk and surface properties Creation of polymers with different bulk and surface properties can be achieved in a variety of ways for applications within a wide range of industries. For polymeric materials, the surface energy value is determined mainly by the chemical structure at the surface. It has been suggested that amorphous, comb like polymers possessing a flexible linear backbone onto which are attached side chains with intermolecular interactions exhibit low surface energy values. Surface energy is influenced by parameters such as roughness, the nature of the
Control of polymeric biomaterial surfaces
37
Table 2.1 Polymers with a LCST in water (adapted from Jeong et al., 2002) Polymer
LCST (ëC)
Poly(N-isopropylacrylamide), NIPAM Poly(ethylene glycol), PEG Poly(propylene glycol), PPG Poly(methacrylic acid), PMAA Poly(vinyl alcohol), PVA Poly(vinyl pyrrolidone), PVP Methylcellulose, MC Hydroxypropylcellulose, HPC Poly(N-vinylcaprolactam)
32 120 50 75 125 160 80 55 30
polymer backbone and the pendant chain. For example, grafted perfluorocarbons with varying lengths influence surface properties in a very significant manner (Barbu et al., 2002).
2.4.4 Influence of composition (monomers, polymer type, additives) Polymer-solvent interactions depend on the chemical properties of the solvent, the ingredients of the polymer and the properties of the medium. Every system tends to reduce its internal energy (U) or enthalpy (H) and increase its entropy (S). In other words every system tends to decrease its Gibbs Free Energy (G). The relation between free energy, enthalpy and entropy at a certain temperature is given as: G H ÿ TS When G is decreased a process is spontaneous. During the dissolution process there is an increased mobility of the solute molecules and thus there is an increase in entropy. Enthalpy is also expected to decrease because there should be increased interaction between the solute and the solvent molecules if there is a good solvent for the solute. On the whole, free energy is decreased (G < 0), making the dissolution process spontaneous. The enthalpy change is an outcome of the solvent-solute interaction. When there are more and stronger interactions leading to decreased enthalpy, this leads to increased solubility. The major factor at this stage is the chemistry of the monomer chains and of the resultant polymer. For example, if the polymer is composed of hydrophilic monomers such as N-vinylpyrrolidone, than the interaction with water will be strong and the enthalpy will decrease, leading to decreased free energy and increased solubility. If, however, the molecule in question is styrene, then the polymerwater interaction will be less than polymer-polymer and water-water interactions. Thus, the result would be insolubility. Only upon increase of
38
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
temperature is mobility of chains increased leading to higher entropy and thus eventually a temperature is reached where solubility is achieved.
2.5
The polymeric surface and surface-bulk difference
Polymers are synthesized to yield glassy solids or powders. It is not easy to distinguish between the surface and the bulk. Upon conversion of the polymer into a product, the bulk and surface become different both in terms of chemistry and topography. There are a variety of reasons for the bulk and surface chemistry to differ: · oxidation of the surface · orientation of the macromolecules in a way that gives better interaction with a mould · different free energies of the various components of the macromolecule. Upon introduction into a liquid medium, the differences become more distinct. The interaction of the polymer chains with the solvent modifies the surface and bulk in terms of concentration and localization of hydophilic and hydrophobic groups. Upon introduction to a hydrophilic liquid, the concentration of hydrophilic groups or segments on the surface increases while in the interior hydrophobic groups concentrate. As a result, the surface properties of the polymer become different from those of the bulk. The packing densities on the surface and in the bulk are different. Due to thermodynamic constraints, the hydrophobic groups and segments form more hydrophobic interactions that lead to an increase in the packing density while on the surface, interaction between the solvent and polymer overcomes the polymer-polymer attraction leading to a swollen or highly extended conformation, and a lower packing density. In good solvents, the polymer-solvent interaction is more favorable than the polymerpolymer one. Polymer chains in good solvents swell due to steric repulsion. This spatial size of a polymer coil is much smaller than its extended contour length but larger than the size of a typical chain. The reason for this peculiar behavior is entropy combined with the favorable interaction between polymers and solvent molecules in good solvents. Similarly, for the adsorption of polymer chains on solid substrates, the conformational degrees of freedom of polymer coils lead to salient differences between the adsorption of polymers and small molecules. In the case of `poor' solvent conditions, the effective interaction between polymers is attractive, leading to collapse of the chains and to their precipitation from solution (phase separation between the polymer and the solvent). In this case, the polymer size decreases, like any space filling object embedded in threedimensional space. Thus if the polymer is a homopolymer with no segments of different functionalities, then in the poor solvent the packing on the surface is expected to increase in comparison to the chains in the inside.
Control of polymeric biomaterial surfaces
2.6
39
The general properties of a biomaterial surface
In the past, biomaterial biocompatibility was considered to be passive behavior towards the biological system. This requires the biomaterial to be nonthrombogenic, non-allergenic, non-carcinogenic, and non-toxic (Klee and HoÈcker, 2000). Williams defined biocompatibility, however, as `the ability of a material to perform with an appropriate host response in a specific application' (Williams, 1999). A variety of properties determine biocompatibility. Among these are the mechanical and chemical/physical properties of a material, both in the bulk and at the surface; the surface exerts the heavier influence because it is the component where the biomaterial and the biological system meet and interact. The properties of the surface that have utmost importance are: · the chemical structure ± hydrophilicity ± presence of groups that could initiate reactions in the biological system · the morphology ± the distribution and abundance of hydrophilic/hydrophobic and crystalline/amorphous phases ± surface topography, i.e. surface roughness and the presence of physical forms. The surface characteristics of a polymer are considerably different from the bulk characteristics. In a dry state, due to the minimization of surface energy and chain mobility, the non-polar groups move to the phase boundary with air while the reverse happens in an aqueous medium. Following this, low molecular weight components could migrate either towards or away from the surface leading to differences in the properties of the surface and the bulk. At the phase boundary between the biomaterial and the aqueous surrounding tissue, a different situation arises than at the phase boundary between the biomaterial and air. When the implant comes into contact with the biological system the following reactions are observed: 1.
2.
Within the first few seconds molecules (especially proteins and lipids) from the surrounding body liquids and tissue are deposited. In blood the properties of this adsorbed protein layer determines hemocompatibility, while in tissues it controls further reactions of the cell system. The nature of the adsorbed proteins is dependent on the surface characteristics of the implanted material. Upon implantation, the tissue neighboring the implant undergoes mechanical, chemical or physical damage or a combination of these. This damage could be acute (short-term and intense) or chronic (long-term) depending on the degree of stability of the material surface. In any case a period of inflammation is observed.
40 3. 4. 5.
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials A biocompatible implant, if inert, is surrounded by a thin layer, mainly consisting of collagen. A biocompatible implant, if not stable will undergo some sort of degradation and/or erosion in the harsh biological medium. This will continue until the implant is completely removed from the medium. A nonbiocompatible implant, if not stable and inert, will undergo degradation and erosion but its products will initiate a variety of undesirable reactions.
Since the surface is the outermost region of the implant interfacing tissue, it should fulfill the requirements of biocompatibility.
2.7
Modification of polymer surfaces
Surfaces of polymers are modified intentionally and unintentionally by various mechanisms and approaches as described below.
2.7.1 Oxidation by air Oxidative degradation is a route for unintentional surface modification and plays an important role in the aging of polymers. Since mainly the surface of a polymer is exposed to air, the effect of oxygen is observed more on the surface than the bulk. This oxidation is influenced by light, water, moisture and temperature. With most polymers, the exterior signs of oxidation are yellowing and if oxygen penetration was possible, then as an increase in brittleness. Unsaturated polyolefins are susceptible to oxidation by air. Oxidation generally induces the formation of peroxide which later leads to chain scission and probably simultaneous free radical formation. This decrease in chain length causes a deterioration of mechanical properties. Thus upon exposure to air chain length decreases and surface oxidation leads to more polar groups than initially. The extent of this change in the bulk is very limited and is controlled by the gas permeability of the solid polymer.
2.7.2 Grafting Grafting can be achieved in a variety of ways leading to products with different forms and chemistries, such as interpenetrating, crosslinked, brush, stimuli responsive, etc. Interpenetrating graft Interpenetrating graft copolymers are obtained where a polymer is dissolved in the monomer to be grafted and then allowing polymerization to take place. The
Control of polymeric biomaterial surfaces
41
chains of the earlier polymer will be entrapped in the newly formed structure. If this new polymer has functional groups or more unsaturations than one, the newly formed structure will be crosslinked within itself more strictly entrapping the original polymer. When surface modification via crosslinked grafts is considered, then the approach would involve wetting or swelling of the surface of the polymer by the monomer and then allowing polymerization to take place. The thickness of the grafted region will vary with the extent of wetting of the surface before initiation of polymerization. In this manner the surface of a mechanically suitable hydrophobic polymer could be rendered hydrophilic for increased hemocompatibility or for decreased lipid adsorption. Crosslinked graft Crosslinked graft copolymers are obtained where the unsaturated polymer is dissolved in the monomer to be grafted and allowing polymerization to take place. The newly formed chains could terminate by a reaction with the unsaturations on the chains and lead to crosslinkages. When surface modification via crosslinked grafts is considered then the approach would be as in the case of the interpenetrating graft. Brush graft Brush grafting could be achieved by activating the functional groups on the polymer to react with newly introduced monomers leading to brushes on the surface. For example, in a typical application, hydrophilic polymer brushes bearing alcoholic hydroxyl groups were introduced onto a polyethylene (PE) surface by radiation-induced grafting of 2-hydroxyethyl methacrylate (HEMA), vinyl acetate (VAc), and glycidyl methacrylate (GMA). HEMA already carried a hydroxyl group. VAc or GMA grafted membranes, on the other hand, were hydrolyzed to yield the hydroxyl groups. Thus, a polyethylene surface was made hydrophilic by brush grafting. The brush presence also modified the properties of the material. When adsorption of gamma globulin onto this material was tested it was observed that upon increase of the amounts of the hydrophilic polymer brushes, adsorption of gamma globulin on the PE base was decreased. Also, these hydrophilic polymer brushes bearing multiple glycol groups (from GMA) and alcohol groups (from VAc) provided an attractive site for the linkage of ligands using chemical methods, a property which was not available for untreated PE (Kawai et al., 2003). Stimuli-responsive grafts Stimuli-responsive polymers respond to small changes in their environment with responses that can be used in various applications (Jeong and Gutowska, 2002).
42
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
The most frequently applied changes or stimuli are temperature, pH, and ionic strength. The responses of polymers grafted on surfaces are presented when introduced into solutions. Recent advances in the design of stimuli-responsive polymers have created opportunities for novel biomedical applications. The responses can be observed as shape, surface characteristics, solubility and as enabled sol-gel transition. The extent of the response needs to be controlled, and therefore the reasons (mostly thermodynamic) for them have to be understood. A typical, and most commonly used, stimulus (temperature) responsive polymer is NIPAM (N-isopropyl acrylamide). NIPAM is soluble below 32 ëC and precipitates above 32 ëC in water. Below the phase transition temperature, i.e., LCST, the hydrogen bonds between the polymer and the water molecules are favored, and thus the polymer stays soluble. The chains are fully extended. Above this temperature the hydrogen bonds are ruptured due to excessive thermal motion of the molecules and the polymer chains prefer to interact with each other leading to insolubilization. The properties of this polymer could be modified by copolymerization with other monomers. Copolymerization of NIPAM with butylmethacrylate for example, decreases the LCST of aqueous copolymer solution because the co-monomer is hydrophobic. Copolymerization with hydrophilic co-monomers on the other hand results in an increase in LCST thus enabling modified responses of a system constructed of NIPAM. If two different stimuli-responsive hydrogels are brought together (i.e. NIPAM and Nvinyl caprolactam) in a hydrogel then two different response ranges (such as two different inversion temperatures) can be obtained. The changes in chain extension levels are also important in certain tissue engineering applications. When the temperature of the medium was decreased below 32 ëC, confluent cardiac myocyte layers were lifted from cell culture dishes without need for trypsinization, an enzymatic treatment which might be harmful to the resultant cell culture if not used properly. The sol-to-gel transition temperature of PEG±PLGA±PEG triblock copolymers was shown to be controlled over a temperature range of 15 ëC to 45 ëC in aqueous solution by changing PLGA and PEG length and the ratio of lactic to glycolic acid (Jeong and Gutowska, 2002). Owing to the triblock topology, PEG±PLGA±PEG polymers have limitations in terms of molecular weight and degradation profile and the ability to show the sol-to-gel transition in a desired range of ~10 ëC to 30 ëC. Graft copolymers of PEG±g±PLGA and PLGA±g±PEG, however, present sol-to-gel transitions at ~30 ëC. PEG±g±PLGA copolymers have hydrophilic backbones and form gels with short durability, whereas PLGA±g±PEG copolymers have hydrophobic backbones and form much more durable gels. Poly(L-lysine)±g±poly(histidine) is an example of a pH sensitive or responsive system (Jeong and Gutowska, 2002). Poly(L-lysine) is positively charged at physiological pH. The pKa of poly(histidine) is 6.0, and it therefore undergoes conformational changes at pH lower than this. Poly(propyl acrylic
Control of polymeric biomaterial surfaces
43
acid) (PPA) and poly(ethacrylic acid) (PEA) are also sensitive to pH changes in the environment. Both polymers have the capability to ionize at high pH and are neutral at lower pH. Thus, they are soluble at high pH and insoluble or less soluble at lower pH. This is reflected in the form of abrupt conformational changes at pH around 5 to 6. Certain polymers have the capability to hypercoil or to form hydrophobic bonds to create compact molecules, and this makes it possible to induce the macromolecules to change their conformation in response to local stimuli. Polymers with weakly charged pendant groups, i.e., either weak acids or bases, exist in the form of extended chains due to repulsion between these charged groups. If, in addition, the polymer also bears alkyl or aromatic pendant groups, then the latter will initiate hydrophobic interactions which will lead to the hydrophobic groups being located in the interior of the structure, thus enabling maximal hydrogen bonding between the polar groups and the water molecules. This `hydrophobic effect', is also the principal driving force in the formation of lipid-based assemblies such as cell mebranes and in determining the conformation of native proteins. Once medium properties are altered, the conformation of the molecule can also be reversibly changed (Tonge and Tighe, 2001).
2.7.3 High-energy treatments Polymer surfaces can be activated by application of high-energy radiation such as glow discharge plasma or gamma irradiation. Plasma modification Low-temperature plasmas are produced by electrical discharge in low-pressure gases. They consist of a mixture of highly reactive species, i.e., ions, radicals, electrons, photons and excited molecules. Their chemical composition and physical characteristics are determined, in addition to the gas used, by device parameters, such as chamber geometry, gas flow rate, frequency and the power applied. This method is used to modify the chemistry and morphology of polymer surfaces to a depth of several tens of microns thus leaving the bulk properties practically intact. Thus, completely different chemistry, hydrophilicity or surface roughness can be obtained. Riccardia et al. (2003) used air as the gas to achieve plasma treatment of polyethylene terephthalate. The surface chemical and physical modification on PET fibers was a remarkable increase in hydrophilicity, extensive etching and a low molecular weight. XPS studies revealed formation of C±O and C±N bonds in the surface layer and the simultaneous decrease of C±C and C±H bonds. They interpreted etching as mainly a consequence of ion bombardment, while surface chemical modifications were mainly due to the action of neutral species on the
44
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
plasma-activated polymer surface. The main effects of the active species created from the gas on polymer chains is mainly chain scission with new functional group creation and crosslinking. Grafting of nitrogen-carrying functional groups by plasmas requires nitrogencontaining gases. This is achieved through generation of nitrogen-containing radicals or excited N2, atomic nitrogen, NH, NH2 radicals, etc. Grafting of amino groups by plasmas is generally known to occur in combination with that of other nitrogen functionalities (Meyer-Plath et al., 2003). In another study polyethylene (PE) surfaces were treated with corona discharge with power ranging from 10 to 50 W (treatment duration 5 s) using air as the gas; the wettability of the PE sheet was significantly increased as judged by the water contact angle. New C±O, C=O and O±C=O bonds were detected with XPS (Lee et al., 2003). Gamma irradiation One of the most common irradiation types in industrial use is gamma. This is mainly produced by a Cobalt-60 source. Their main advantage is that they are very penetrating. Crosslinking and chain scission are the two major effects that gamma radiation has on polymers. This exposure could be applied for the purpose of processing or for sterilization. Radiation grafting and hydrogel formation are among the more important gamma irradiation applications (Clough, 2001). Grafting is employed because with it the surface properties can be tailored according to needs, while the material retains its bulk properties. Some outcomes are an improvement of chemical resistance, wettability, biocompatibility and hemocompatibility, dyeability of fabrics and antistatic properties. They could also be made to attach functional groups to enable the material to immobilize enzymes and other bioactive species. The advantage of radiation crosslinking over chemical crosslinking is that the former is more economical, faster, allows substantial decrease in the chemicals in the material processed (thus lower risk of bioincompatibility or allergenic response), and can be carried out at around room temperature. When irradiated, polymers are either inclined to undergo crosslinking or chain scission depending on the chemistry and the processing conditions. A polymer that undergoes chain scission could crosslink when the conditions are modified. Alterations in surface morphology can occur upon irradiation, especially in the form of an increase in roughness, a change that alters properties such as contact angle and cell adhesion.
2.7.4 Self assembled monolayers (SAMs) Self assembled monolayers are spontaneously formed highly ordered structures guided by the surface on which attachment takes place, by the components of the macromolecule and of the solvent. A well known example is alkane thiols on
Control of polymeric biomaterial surfaces
45
gold surfaces where the thiols attach to the gold surface with alkane tails sticking out and eventually align to form a tightly packed crystalline structure. The properties of this assembled layer depend very much on the alkane length. PEI (polyethyleneimine)-PLGA block copolymers were also found to be selfassembled in water where the PLGA segment acted as a hydrophobic aggregate block and the PEI segment as a hydrophilic corona-forming block (Nam et al., 2003). The block copolymers formed micelle-like aggregates in water and the size of the aggregates depended on hydrophobic block length and the ionic state of the hydrophilic block. The aggregate size decreased when the PLGA block length decreased and the PEI block was protonated. The amphiphilic nature of block copolymers consisting of hydrophilic and hydrophobic blocks provides an opportunity to form micelle-like structures in water. However, they do not form if they are introduced directly to an aqueous medium. They form their micellelike aggregates only when the solution of the polymer in an organic solvent such as DMF is introduced into aqueous media and then subsequently dialyzed, allowing time for organization in the form of micelles.
2.7.5 Surface patterning The use of chemical and physical patterns on polymer surfaces is on the rise due to the variety of uses they can be put to. Among them are biomedical uses such as construction of biosensors and tissue engineering applications. Patterning can be achieved by various methods as described in the following paragraphs. Contact printing/microprocessing This is basically a photolithographic approach. A variety of processes such as embossing, fused deposition modelling, ink jet printing, microcontact printing, proton micromachining and rapid prototyping are among the methods that could be classified under this heading. Embossing The first step is to fabricate a master die using electron beam lithography from which all other devices will be made. This master is made using a quartz substrate which has been coated with a thin metal film layer of Ti/Pd/Au to remove charge during exposure and to act as a plating base (Casey et al., 1997). A negative e-beam resist which facilitates the writing of small features over a large area in a relatively short time is used. The resist is developed to produce the pattern which is intended to be transferred into the plastic. The sample is then cleaned using an organic solvent to remove any remnants of resist or primer. It is now electroplated with nickel to the required depth which is typically a half to a third the height of the resist. The resist is removed by
46
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
refluxing in a solvent after which the sample is a nickel die ready to use as an embossing master. If the features required for embossing are less than 150 nm in size, then the master is made by dry etching the resist pattern into quartz using an intermediate titanium layer. The quartz is then etched. The polymer used for embossing could be cellulose acetate which is in l mm thick sheet form. The important characteristics of this plastic are that it has a smooth, gloss surface with good clarity and a relatively low flow temperature in the range 135±175 ëC. The embossing process requires application of a constant force to the die/plastic/ platen stack. It is essential that a constant pressure is maintained throughout not only at the imprinting stage of the procedure, but also during the cooling of samples. Standard embossing times are 30 minutes at the elevated temperature of 135 ëC, followed by a 15-minute cooling period. Fused deposition modelling (FDM) process The FDM method forms three-dimensional objects from computer-generated solid or surface models like a typical rapid prototyping process. Models can also be derived from computer tomography scans, magnetic resonance imaging scans or model data created from 3D object digitizing systems. FDM uses a small temperature-controlled extruder to force out a thermoplastic filament material and deposit the semi-molten polymer onto a platform in a layer by layer process. The monofilament is moved by two rollers and acts as a piston to drive the semimolten polymer. At the end of each finished layer the base platform is lowered and the next layer deposited. The designed object is fabricated as a threedimensional part based on the deposition of thin layers of the polymer. The deposition path and parameters for every layer are designated depending on the material used, the fabrication conditions, the applications of the designed part and the preferences of the designer. This method was employed in the production of novel scaffolds with a honeycomb-like pattern, fully interconnected channel network, and controllable porosity and channel size (Zeina et al., 2002). Poly(-caprolactone) (PCL) was developed as a filamentmodeling material to produce porous scaffolds, made of layers of directionally aligned microfilaments. The PCL scaffolds were produced with a range of channel sizes 160±700 m, filament diameter 260±370 m and porosity 48± 77%, and regular geometrical honeycomb pores, depending on the processing parameters. Ink jet printing technique The technique is very simple. The polymer is dissolved in a volatile solvent (e.g. chloroform, trichloroethylene) and the liquid is ejected by the printing head on the substrate (i.e. alumina). As the drop reaches the surface the solvent evaporates leaving the solidified polymer behind. If more than one drop is
Control of polymeric biomaterial surfaces
47
ejected the solidification time is increased, leading to wider, thicker and more homogeneous polymer deposition (Pede et al., 1996). Microcontact printing of DNA In this method a rubber stamp that carries the inverse of the required pattern is immersed in the patterning solution (DNA, protein, enzyme, antibody, etc.) and then applied on the surface of the target material. The pattern is generally produced by photolithography on silicone based rubbers. In a typical application, photoresist patterns of 5 m line and 10 m space were prepared by photolithography on a silicon substrate which was used as a master for the stamp (Fujita et al., 2002). Patterned poly(dimethylsiloxane) (PDMS) stamps were made by mixing silicone elastomer and a curing agent and pouring the mixture in a plastic disposable container with the silicon master at the bottom. This was then heated in an oven, and the hardened polymer removed. A dilute solution of 3-(2-aminoethyl amino)propyl triethoxy silane (amino silane) was applied directly to the stamp and was microcontact printed on mica substrates. DNA solution was applied on the patterned substrate, washed with pure water, and dried under nitrogen gas thus creating a pattern of DNA on the mica surface. Proton micromachining In this application a beam of protons is focused on the target and scanned to create the pattern needed. A resolution of 1 m could be achieved by this approach. Sanchez et al. (1999) used a piece of PMMA as the template material, exposed to a 0.6 MeV proton beam using a nuclear microscope. The beam spot was scanned over the PMMA in a series of patterns consisting of nine different types of ridge/groove structures. Multiple repeated exposures of the patterns were carried out to achieve a homogeneous exposure. Rapid prototyping This system involves fabrication of scaffolds for tissue engineering applications via robotic desktop rapid prototyping. In one recent application the experimental setup consisted of a computer-guided desktop robot and a pneumatic dispenser (Ang et al., 2002). As dispensing material, chitosan and chitosan/hydroxyapatite (HA) dissolved in acetic acid was chosen. It was forced out through a small nozzle into a dispensing medium which was sodium hydroxide and ethanol. Layer-by-layer, the chitosan was fabricated with a preprogrammed pattern. Neutralization of the chitosan formed a gel-like precipitate and the hydrostatic pressure in the sodium hydroxide (NaOH) solution kept the cuboid scaffold in shape. A good attachment between layers allowed the chitosan matrix to form a fully interconnected channel architecture.
48
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
Laser etching (laser photoablation) Laser photoablation or laser etching is a highly efficient and versatile etching process by which selected regions in a polymer layer can be removed by highenergy UV laser irradiation. The material is removed in a one-step process, requiring no developing or other steps before or after exposure. In addition to a wide variety of polymeric materials, photoablation has also been successfully used for laser-etching of several metals, oxides and other inorganic materials. The largest applications of photoablation include drilling of vias in multilayer microelectronic circuits, fabrication of nozzles in inkjet printheads, and corneal shaping for vision surgery. Numerous other applications of ablation have been implemented and many others are being researched in a variety of electronic, optoelectronic and medical fields. In the laser ablation (LAB) process using high-energy ultraviolet laser beams, polymers are chemically decomposed and removed without heating, therefore, smooth bottoms and sidewalls of the etched holes can be obtained. In practice, a polymer film is glued on a Si substrate and is etched by the LAB process. Slant planes can be easily formed by the relative movement of the laser beam. In a typical system the light source is a KrF excimer laser operating at a wavelength of 248 nm. The laser beam radiating from the source goes through a mask and a pattern on the mask is imaged on a sample. The sample is etched vertically in the irradiated area and the depth of the etched hole is proportional to the number of laser pulses. Laser photoablation can be carried out either in a spot-by-spot fashion using a focused beam from a low-power laser and raster-scanning it to address all the locations, or by projection-imaging the desired pattern of vias, lines, etc., from a mask onto the substrate using a high-power laser, thereby ablating thousands of features simultaneously. In the case of near-IR (NIR) laser patterning, however, it is believed that laser etching mostly results in substantially disordered profiles due to thermal effects. It is accepted that the thermo-mechanical properties of polymer materials play an important role in determining the quality of NIR laser etched surfaces. E-beam etching Conventional lithography involves patterning with light, generally in the UV region, of a thin polymer film that is spin-coated onto a silicon wafer. The radiation crosslinks (negative resist) or degrades (positive resist) the exposed polymer which is then washed (developed) to remove or retain the design, leaving behind a patterned polymeric surface. The same approach could be applied to a polymer with a significant thickness to create a pattern on the surface while retaining the bulk properties. This could be achieved by e-beam irradiation. The e-beam machine plays a significant role in the processing of polymers in a similar fashion. A number of different designs and energies are available.
Control of polymeric biomaterial surfaces
49
Industrial e-beam accelerators with energies in the 150±300 keV range are used when low penetration is needed. Accelerators operating in the range 1.5 MeV are used where more penetration is needed. High-energy commercial e-beams (10 MeV) are used in the sterilization of medical supplies already boxed and ready for shipment. They have high dose rates and therefore short processing times. Low penetration indicates more effective use of e-beam energy than with gamma. In patterning 100 keV electron beams a magnetic lens is used. Patterning is achieved by using an electron scattering mask. E-beam is capable of patterning at around 70 m resolution (Clough, 2001).
2.7.6 Immobilization of functional groups and molecules Chemical modification of the surface through introduction of new groups to the polymeric product is designed to impart certain properties to a material. This does not necessitate the modification of the bulk. In a typical application, thiocyanation of plasticized PVC led to a product with increased hydrophilicity but also significantly reduced retention of two types of bacteria strongly implicated in implant related infections, S. aureus and S. epidemidis (Nirmala and Jayakrishnan, 2003). Immobilization of heparin onto the surface of biomaterials to render them hemocompatible has been used in a large number of studies. Heparin immobilization was reported with PVA, methyl methacrylate, and polyurethane to name a few. Heparin was immobilized on Gore-TexÕ to improve its vascular graft performance (Begovac et al., 2003), to introduce hemocompatibility to nonwoven fabrics of polypropylene (Tyan et al., 2002), to silicone rubber, polyethylene, polypropylene and polyvinylchloride (Michanetzis et al., 2003), to PLA (Zhu et al., 2002), etc. Another approach is surface molecular imprinting. This technique helps introduce specific recognition sites into polymers. It has the ability to be applied to a wide variety of target molecules. If a high interfacial activity functional molecule is used, the enzyme-mimic site can be located on the surface of the polymer. In a specific example, the technique was used to help resolve optically active amino acids (Toorisaka et al., 2003). 2-Methacryloyloxyethyl phosphorylcholine (MPC) polymers were synthesized to mimic the biological membrane structure. MPC polymers are useful for surface modification of conventional materials even when random copolymers composed of MPC and alkylmethacrylate are applied as coating polymers. They effectively reduce protein adsorption and denaturation and inhibit cell adhesion even when the polymer is in contact with whole blood in the absence of any anticoagulants. It was observed that phospholipid polymer surfaces showed excellent blood compatibility (Yamasaki et al., 2003).
50
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
2.8
Surface analysis
A biomaterial surface presents different levels of crystallinity, roughness and chemical groups to the biological environment into which it is introduced. Immediately after implantation, the adsorption of a variety of biological molecules such as proteins and lipids change the surface further (Fig. 2.6). In order to be able to construct the ideal biomaterial, the surface has to be characterized and this is achieved by a variety of techniques. In order to determine the composition and structure of a biomaterial surface, different methods which provide varying degrees of information are commonly used. ATR-IR (attenuated total reflectance infra-red) or ATR-FTIR (attenuated total reflectance Fourier Transform infra-red) spectroscopy supplies the characteristic absorption bands of functional groups with an informational depth of 0.1±10 m. Samples with rough surfaces are studied with photoacoustic spectroscopy (PAS), which allows analysis down to approximately 20 m. The achieved informational depths are usually larger than the thickness of the modified interface which might have a several molecules thick modification as in-plasma modification approaches and therefore the spectra obtained could include peaks due to the bulk as well. X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) (or ESCA, electron spectroscopy for chemical analysis) is a more surfacesensitive analytical method which supplies information not only about the type and amount of elements present but also about their oxidation state and chemical surroundings. Depths of approximately 10 nm can be achieved with this method (about 50 atomic layers). A more surface-sensitive method is secondary ion mass spectroscopy (SIMS) where primary ions interact with the polymer surface and the mass spectra of the formed ions (secondary ions) are obtained which give information about the chemical composition of the outermost atomic layers (approximately 1 nm in thickness). The application of atomic force microscopy (AFM) in comparison to scanning electron microscopy (SEM) delivers information about surface properties as far as molecular dimensions. Another advantage of AFM compared with SEM is that the sample is investigated in the original state (no sputtering).
2.6 A typical biomaterial surface in the in-vivo environment.
Control of polymeric biomaterial surfaces
51
The full characterization of the surface of a biomaterial is often verified only by application of several analytical methods to the sample. The depth of the various analytical systems could deliver information about are: SIMS and AFM about 1 nm, XPS about 10 nm and ATR-IR 4000 nm.
2.8.1 Morphology When modified in one of many ways, the morphology of a polymeric surface is also changed whether intended or not. In order to be able to study the extent and type of these changes, a variety of novel techniques are used. The following three microscopic techniques are among the most effectively and extensively used surface characterization techniques. Scanning tunnelling microscope (STM) Two researchers working at IBM in Switzerland invented in 1982 the scanning tunnelling microscope (STM), for which they were awarded the Nobel Prize for Physics. In this technique, a fine sharpened tip, which is presumed to have a single atom at the apex, is scanned above the surface of the sample. A voltage (bias potential) is applied between the tip and the sample and a small current (tunnelling current) which flows between the gap is measured. The variation in tunnelling current as it passes over the atomically corrugated surface is then recorded and, if this process is repeated across the entire sample, a threedimensional map of the surface can be obtained. The choice of materials investigated was partly limited by the requirement for them to be conducting, so that a tunnelling current could be measured. Atomic force microscopy (AFM) Atomic force microscopy (AFM) is a method increasingly being used to study and quantify surface properties of materials in their untreated, natural form. It is essentially a scanner that creates topographical maps of surfaces. A very sharp tip, located at the free end of a cantilever follows the contours of the surface as it is moved over it. The deflections of the tip are measured by an optical detector and recorded by a computer. This instrument is very similar to STM, except that the tip and the surface are in contact and interatomic van der Waals forces acting between them provide the contrast mechanism, rather than a tunnelling current. There was no longer a requirement for the sample to be conducting, thus opening the way for the study of many other materials (Smith et al., 1997). The data can be used to create a 2-D or 3-D image and measure surface roughness. It is very important in the biomedical sciences because most polymers are highly hydrated in vivo, and thus treatments for visualization as in SEM (high vacuum, conductive coats, etc.) would not maintain their actual surface
52
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
topography. With AFM, however, it was possible to examine very fragile hydrogel materials like soft contact lenses in their swollen form and measure their surface roughness (Grobe et al., 1996). It is also possible to monitor real-time events like hydrolytic degradation. In a study by Davies et al. (1996) the degradation of the components of blends of poly(sebacic acid anhydride) (PSA) and PLA was studied revealing the preferential degradation of the PSA component leaving behind surfaces enriched in PLA. It was thus possible to expose PLA morphology. With the use of a similar technique, scanning force microscopy, close packed, needlelike organization of crystals of poly(butene-1) were shown with a resolution of the order of nanometers (Jandt et al., 1993). It was claimed that individual poly(butene-1) molecules could be observed. In another study, lamellar organization of polyethylene (Jandt et al., 1994) and various spherulitic surfaces (Lustiger et al., 1989; Harron et al., 1996) could be visualized. A similar observation was made by Hasirci et al. (2002) where degradation of PPF-NVP/ EGDMA reinforced PLGA was investigated revealing a lamellar organization of the bone reinforcement plates after a very brief incubation in distilled water. Scanning electron microscopy (SEM) SEM is a microscopic method extremely valuable in polymeric products and biomaterials areas along with many other research and application areas. Its main attributes are that it reveals the 3D topography of the specimen examined and its magnification could be extremely high (factors of hundred thousands). For polymeric materials, high magnifications are generally not possible because of the intensity of the electron beams damaging the thin polymeric samples which generally lead to deformation and even melting of the specimen. Other limitations of SEM are the need for a high vacuum which prevents visualization of solvated samples in their natural state and the need to coat the sample with conductive materials such as gold. In order to overcome these problems, methods of fixation or stabilization and obtaining durable replicas of the actual sample are tried with varying degrees of success. The resultant 3D image is generally worth the effort because it reveals a wealth of information about the specimen examined. SEM was used in a series of studies on drug delivery systems and bone plates with great success. A PLGA rod (or rather fiber with diameter ca. 0.65 mm) controlled pain relief system was designed to deliver analgesics for a duration of 3±4 weeks (Hasirci et al., 2003). The initial tests were carried out in rats by tying the fiber to the sciatic nerve before testing for the loss of sensitivity to external pain inflicting stimuli such as high intensity light. The fiber withstood implantation very well, without disintegrating with the only deformation being at the location where it was tied to the sciatic nerve. The PLLA-PPF based bone plates for fracture fixation in rats reveal that while one would perform its function of stabilizing a fracture properly the other implant would probably disintegrate by cracking under the applied stress (Hasirci et al., 2000).
Control of polymeric biomaterial surfaces
53
2.8.2 Chemistry The surface chemistry of a polymer intended for biomedical applications can be investigated by a number of approaches, mostly based on spectroscopy and surface energetics. In the following section, information about these methods is provided. X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) ESCA is the abbreviation of electron spectroscopy for chemical analysis, and is the same as XPS (X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy). It is a method for studying the energy distribution of electrons ejected from a material that has been irradiated with a source of ionizing radiation such as X-rays. This powerful tool provides quantitative information about basic properties such as binding energy, charge, and valence state, which examines the atom as a part of its chemical environment. The impact of ESCA in polymeric characterization has been twofold: it can analyze relatively intractable materials without the need for special sample preparation and it is a surface sensitive method. In principle, when any material is bombarded by photons with energy greater than the binding energy of an electron in a given atomic shell or sub-shell, there is a finite probability that the incident photon will be absorbed by the atom and an electron is either prompted to move to an unoccupied level or ejected as a photoelectron. This depends on the energy of the incident photon and the atomic number of the target element. The kinetic energy of the photoelectron is: KE h ÿ BE where KE and BE are the kinetic energy and the binding energy of the photoelectron, and h is the energy of the incident photon. Although the X-ray may penetrate deeply into the sample to produce photoelectrons, most of these electrons lose energy in numerous inelastic collisions; only those atoms residing in the top few monolayers give rise to undistorted photoelectron spectra. The typical analysis depth in ESCA and in Ê , and they are truly surface analysis Auger electron spectroscopy is about 3±50 A methods. Auger electron spectroscopy (AES) In AES, an incident primary electron creates an excited ion near the surface which decays by the emission of a secondary Auger electron, whose kinetic energy is measured. As in XPS, the escaping Auger electron's kinetic energy limits the depth from which it can emerge, giving AES its high surface sensitivity and nanometer sampling depth. Auger images or maps can also be generated for specific elements with approximately 200 nm resolution. Auger
54
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
finds its greatest strength in the analysis of inorganic materials not susceptible to electron-beam damage. Surface Raman Since its discovery in 1974, surface enhanced Raman scattering (SERS) has proved to be a very powerful and sensitive technique to investigate the vibrational properties of adsorbed molecules. It has been shown that the enhancement mechanisms can be of two kinds: a chemical phenomenon in which charge transfer between adsorbed molecules and the metallic substrate is involved and an electromagnetic enhancement which considers a localized surface plasmon. Yet, there is still some debate inside the SERS community as to whether one effect predominates or not (Grand et al., 2003). Since its original discovery, surface enhanced Raman scattering (SERS) has developed significantly towards detection of a single molecule. It was also more successful in biological applications than conventional Raman spectroscopy, especially in endoscopy and in-vivo diagnosis. Novel applications in biology include cancer gene detection, spectroscopy of living cells and single protein/ DNA detection. Progress in non-biological applications of SERS has been equally spectacular, with single molecule detection, spectroscopy of single dyes in large nanocrystals, or in carbon nanotubes (Etchegoin et al., 2003). Attenuated total reflectance (ATR) spectroscopy Before the advent of ESCA the only reliable method for polymer surface studies was infra-red spectroscopy (either attenuated total reflectance (ATR) or multiple internal reflectance (MIR) spectroscopy). This method requires fairly large samples with flat or easily deformable surfaces and typically gives information pertaining to surfaces and gives information penetrating to 1 m into the material. In recent years, Fourier transform infra-red (FTIR) has allowed analysis sensitivity to be improved, but even then FTIR can neither match the sensitivity of ESCA nor can it be as focused on the surface. In systems with variable composition within the range 0±1 m, the two methods could be applied to complement each other effectively. Infra-red microscopy Infra-red microscopy is a powerful technique that combines the image analysis capabilities of optical microscopy with the chemical analysis capabilities of infrared spectroscopy. The combination of these two techniques allows infra-red spectra to be obtained from microspectroscopic-sized samples. With the assistance of microscopy, samples as small as 0.01 g or even less (depending on the infra-red absorption characteristics of the components of interest) can be easily located and
Control of polymeric biomaterial surfaces
55
detected. Among its key roles are point identification or point mapping, using single element detectors to fingerprint defects and contaminants, analyze laminate structures, and to map chemical and physical property differences and gradients. These are critical to understanding product behavior, since chemical structure and conformation and physical property anisotropy at the microscopic level significantly influence the macroscopic performance of polymer products. A major limitation of FTIR microscopy has been the time needed using single element detectors to construct high spectral contrast maps of high spatial (lateral) resolution (~10 m) from large areas (e.g. >50 m 50 m). However, over the last few years, images based on mid-infra-red spectral differences and changes generated using FTIR microscopy instrumentation fitted with focal plane array (FPA) detectors have increasingly become available (Chalmers et al., 2002). In one application time-resolved FTIR measurements during isothermal crystallization of samples were carried out on a cast film. The crystallization of samples was traced by the C=O stretching band at 1722 cmÿ1 and the C±D stretching band at 2230 cmÿ1. Because of the large difference in molar absorbance coefficients, the C=O and C±D stretching bands were observed by separate measurements (He et al., 2002).
2.8.3 Energetics Surface energetics is very important in defining the biocompatibility of a polymer because this determines the type of molecules that do and do not adsorb on the surface. Tissue ingrowth, blood coagulation, cell damage to blood elements and immune signalling are all influenced by the energetics of the surface. Zeta potential A charged molecule in motion produces an electric field. The zeta potential is the electric potential of a charged particle at the plane of shear. The shear plane, or the plane of slip, is the distance from the surface to the distance in solution where the solvent molecules are not bound to the surface and are not moving as a unit with the particle. At this boundary, zeta potential can be determined. The surface potential is a very difficult parameter to characterize and it is far easier to determine zeta potential. It is measured at a shear plane near the particle surface and is therefore proportional to surface potential. It is affected by ionic strength; at high ionic strength, potential decreases much more sharply over the distance from the surface to the shear plane. This means a smaller zeta potential. It is therefore important to maintain a relatively constant ionic strength while characterizing the zeta potential of a dispersion as a function of pH. In the biomedical field, a large variety of applications are found. Gene therapy is one of them (Putnam et al., 2003). Complexation of plasmid DNA
56
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
with polycations is a popular method by which to transfer therapeutic nucleic acid sequences to cells. One disadvantage of the approach is that the positive zeta potential of the complexes facilitates interaction with blood constituents, leading to serum protein adsorption and immune response. To circumvent this issue, investigators have developed polycations combined with polyethylene glycol (PEG) to create complexes with reduced protein adsorption potential. Contact angle The investigation of surface wettability by means of contact angle determination is of special interest in the characterization of the polymer surface. Contact angle may be geometrically defined as the angle formed by the intersection of two planes at a tangent to the liquid and solid surface at the perimeter of contact between the two phases and the third surrounding phase. Typically, the third phase will be air or vapor, although systems in which it is a second liquid essentially immiscible with the first are of great practical importance. If one considers the three-phase system where the liquid is designated as l, the surrounding gaseous medium as g, and the solid surface as s, then at equilibrium the contact angle will be given by Young's equation as: gl cos sg ÿ sl where gl , sl and sg are the interfacial tensions at the respective interfaces. Contact angle measurements are carried out in various ways of widely differing sensitivity. Typically they are made with a goniometer and a syringe with a flat-tipped needle that is used to apply the solvent (generally double or triple distilled water) droplet on the surface. Advancing contact angles are recorded while fluid is added to the drop already on the surface. The values are generally reported as an average of five to ten measurements made on different areas of the sample surface. In culturing cells on biomaterial surfaces, contact angle is an important parameter that guides surface property modification attempts. For example, when oxygen plasma treated polyethylene surfaces were tested for tissue engineering purposes, the adherence of PC-12 cells were found to be higher as the water contact angle was lowered (higher surface wettability). However, this adhesion started to decrease as the contact angle was further decreased. Thus a bell-shaped curve for cell adhesion was obtained with the optimum water contact angle of 55 degrees (Lee et al., 2003).
2.9
Surface properties and biomaterials applications
Biomaterials are designed to augment, support or completely take over the functions of natural tissue or organs of human beings and are, therefore, designed to be biocompatible (non-toxic, non-immunogenic, non-inflammatory,
Control of polymeric biomaterial surfaces
57
non-carcinogenic) and to carry properties that match those of the tissue they are replacing. When functioning in the body the tissue-material interface is critical because this is where all the initial interactions such as contact with cells, proteins, and other biological entities takes place. The bulk of the biomaterial needs to satisfy the mechanical and physical requirements of the intended application, while an inert surface has to prevent immune responses, irritation or clotting. Biomaterial surfaces are, therefore, generally treated to improve their in-vivo responses. A typical example is the pyrolitic carbon-coated heart valve where the valve made of a metal or graphite is rendered hemocompatible and impact resistant by coating with a carbon layer. Heparin treated polymeric blood vessels and silicone sheathed sensor leads are all in this category. To improve blood compatibility it is a common approach to increase the hydrophilicity of the surface of the polymeric biomaterial and to achieve this surface modification by use of plasma treatment and subsequent grafting with a hydrophilic polymer. The optimum properties of a biomaterial can still not be elucidated, and a rule of thumb does not exist. The design of the surface of a biomaterial remains by far the most important and difficult task that a biomaterial scientist has to tackle.
2.10 Conclusion Surfaces of materials used in the biomedical field have always been important due to their proximity to the tissues. This is the first plane of contact between them and the nature of this contact is the main factor in determining their biocompatibility. Among the hottest current research trends today is nanobiotechnology where physical and chemical modification of biomaterial surfaces, their characterization and understanding of the nature of materialtissue interactions are of prime importance in today's biomaterials sciences. As the technology and our understanding of these increase, so will our ability to create better biomaterials. We will thus achieve higher quality of life.
2.11 References Ang TH, Sultana FSA, Hutmacher DW, Wong YS, Fuh JYH, Mob XM, Loh HT, Burdet E, Teoh SH (2002), `Fabrication of 3D chitosan±hydroxyapatite scaffolds using a robotic dispensing system', Materials Science and Engineering C, 20, 35±42. Barbu E, Pullin RA, Graham P, Eaton P, Ewen RJ, Smart JD, Nevell TG, Tsibouklis J (2002), `Poly(di-1H,1H,2H,2H-perfluoroalkyltaconate) films: surface organization phenomena, surface energy determinations and force of adhesion measurements', Polymer, 43, 1727±1734. Begovac PC, Thomson RC, Fisher JL, Hughson A, Gallhagen A (2003), `Improvements in GORE-TEX vascular graft performance by Carmeda BioActive surface heparin immobilization', Eur J Vasc Endovasc Surg, 25(5), 432±437. Casey BG, Monaghan W, Wilkinson CDW (1997), `Embossing of Nanoscale Features and Environments', Microelectronic Engineering, 35, 393±396.
58
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
Chalmers JM, Everall NJ, Schaeberle MD, Levin IW, Lewis EN, Kidder LH, Wilson J, Crocombeg R (2002), `FT-IR imaging of polymers: an industrial appraisal', Vibrational Spectroscopy, 30(1), 43±52. Clough RL (2001), `High-energy radiation and polymers: A review of commercial processes and emerging applications', Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research, B, 185, 8±33. Davies MC, Shakesheff KM, Shard AG, Domb A, Roberts JC, Tendler SJB, Williams PM (1996), `Surface analysis of biodegradable polymer blends of poly(sebacicacid anhydride) and poly(DL-lactic acid)', Macromolecules, 29, 2205±2212. Etchegoin P, Maher R.C, Cohen L.F, Hartigan H, Brown RJC, Milton MJT, Gallop JC (2003), `New limits in ultrasensitive trace detection by surface enhanced Raman scattering (SERS)', Chemical Physics Letters, 375(1±2), 84±90. Fujita M, Mizutanic W, Gadd M, Shigekawab H, Tokumotoc H (2002), `Patterning DNA on mm scale on mica', Ultramicroscopy, 91, 281±285. Grand J, Kostcheev S, Bijeon J-L, de la Chapelle ML, Adam P-M, Rumyantseva A, LeÂrondel G, Royer P (2003), `Optimization of SERS-active substrates for near-field Raman spectroscopy', Synthetic Metals, 139(3), 621±624. Grobe GL, Valint PL, Ammon DM (1996), `Surface chemical structure for soft contact lenses as a function of polymer processing', J. Biomedical Materials Research, 32, 45±54. Harron HR, Pritchard RG, Cope BC, Goddard DT (1996), `An atomic force microscope (AFM) and tapping mode AFM study of the solvent induced crystallization of polycarbonate thin films', J. Polymer Science (Pt B): Polymer Physics, 34, 173±180. Hasirci V, Lewandrowski K, Bondre SP, Gresser JD, Trantolo DJ, Wise DL (2000), `High strength bioresorbable bone plates: preparation, mechanical properties and in vitro analysis', Bio-medical Materials and Engineering, 10(1), 19±29. Hasirci V, Litman AE, Trantolo DJ, Gresser JD, Wise DL, Margolis HC (2002), `Investigation of the interpenetrating network structure of a molecularly reinforced biodegradable implant', J. Materials Science, Materials in Medicine, 13, 159±167. Hasirci V, Bonney I, Goudas LC, Shuster L, Carr DB, Wise DL (2003), `Antihyperalgesic effect of simultaneously released hydromorphone and bupivacaine from polymer fibers in the rat chronic constriction injury model', Life Sciences, 73(26), 3323±3337. He W, Shanks R, Amarasinghe G (2002), `Analysis of additives in polymers by thin-layer chromatography coupled with Fourier transform-infrared microscopy', Vibrational Spectroscopy, 30(2),147±156. Jandt KD, McMaster TJ, Miles MJ, Petermann J (1993), `Scanning force microscopy of melt crystallized, metal evaporated poly(butene-1) ultrathin films', Macromolecules, 26, 6552±6556. Jandt KD, Buhk M, Miles MJ, Petermann J (1994), `Shish-kebab crystals in polyethylene investigated by scanning force microscopy', Polymer, 35(11), 2458±2462. Jeong B, Gutowska A (2002), `Lessons from nature: stimuli responsive polymers and their biomedical applications', Trends in Biotechnology, 20(7), 305±311. Jeong B, Kim, SW, Bae YH (2002), `Thermosensitive sol±gel reversible hydrogels', Advanced Drug Delivery Reviews, 54, 37±51. Kawai,T, Saito K, Lee W (2003), `Protein binding to polymer brush, based on ionexchange, hydrophobic, and affinity interactions', Journal of Chromatography B, Analyt Technol Biomed Life Sci, 790(1±2), 131±142. Klee D, HoÈcker H (2000), `Polymers for Biomedical Applications: Improvement of the
Control of polymeric biomaterial surfaces
59
Interface Compatibility', in Advances in Polymer Science, Springer-Verlag, Heidelberg, Vol. 149, 1±57. Lee SJ, Khang G, Lee YM, Lee HB (2003), `The effect of surface wettability on induction and growth of neurites from the PC-12 cell on a polymer surface', Journal of Colloid and Interface Science, 259, 228±235. Lustiger A, Lotz B, Duff TS (1989), `The morphology of the spherulitic surface in polyethylene', J. Polymer Science (Pt B): Polymer Physics, 27, 561±579. Meyer-Plath AA, Schroder K, Finke B, Ohl A (2003), `Current trends in biomaterial surface functionalization±nitrogen-containing plasma assisted processes with enhanced selectivity', Vacuum, 71, 391±406. Michanetzis GP, Katsala N, Missirlis YF (2003), `Comparison of haemocompatibility improvement of four polymeric biomaterials by two heparinization techniques', Biomaterials, 24(4), 677±688. Nam YS, Kang HS, Park JY, Park TG, Han S-H, Changa I-S (2003), `New micelle-like polymer aggregates made from PEI±PLGA diblock copolymers: micellar characteristics and cellular uptake', Biomaterials, 24(12), 2053±2059. Nirmala RJ, Jayakrishnan A (2003), `Surface thiocyanation of plasticized poly(vinyl chloride) and its effect on bacterial adhesion', Biomaterials, 24, 2205±2212. Pede D, Serra G, De Rossi D (1996), `Microfabrication of conducting polymer devices by ink-jet stereolithography', Materials Science and Engineering, C5, 289±291. Putnam D, Zelikin AN, Izumrudov VA, Langer R (2003), `Polyhistidine ± PEG:DNA nanocomposites for gene delivery', Biomaterials, 24(24), 4425±4433. Riccardia C, Barnia R, Sellib E, Mazzoneb G, Massafrac MR, Marcandallic B, Polettid G (2003), `Surface modification of poly(ethylene terephthalate) fibers induced by radio frequency air plasma treatment', Applied Surface Science, 211, 386±397. Sanchez JL, Guy G, van Kan JA, Osipowicz T, Watt F (1999), `Proton micromachining of substrate scaffolds for cellular and tissue engineering', Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research B, 158 185±189. Smith JR, Campbell SA, Mills GA (1997), `Probing atoms', Educ. Chem, 34(4), 107±111. Stachurski ZH (2003), `Strength and deformation of rigid polymers: structure and topology in amorphous polymers', Polymer, 44, 6059±6066. Tonge SR, Tighe BJ (2001), `Responsive hydrophobically associating polymers: a review of structure and properties', Advanced Drug Delivery Reviews, 53, 109±122. Toorisaka E, Uezua K, Goto M, Furusaki S (2003), `A molecularly imprinted polymer that shows enzymatic activity', Biochemical Engineering Journal, 14, 85±91. Tyan YC, Liao JD, Wu YT, Klauser R (2002), `Anticoagulant activity of immobilized heparin on the polypropylene nonwoven fabric surface depending upon the pH of processing environment', J Biomater Appl. 17(2), 153±178. Williams DF, The Williams Dictionary of Biomaterials, Liverpool University Press, 1999. Yamasaki A, Imamura Y, Kurita K, Iwasaki Y, Nakabayashi N, Ishihara K (2003), `Surface mobility of polymers having phosphorylcholine groups connected with various bridging units and their protein adsorption-resistance properties', Colloids and Surfaces B: Biointerfaces, 28, 53±62. Zeina I, Hutmacher DW, Tanc KC, Teoh SH (2002), `Fused deposition modeling of novel scaffold architectures for tissue engineering applications', Biomaterials, 23, 1169±1185. Zhu A, Zhang M, Wu J, Shen J (2002), `Covalent immobilization of chitosan/heparin complex with a photosensitive hetero-bifunctional crosslinking reagent on PLA surface', Biomaterials, 23(23), 4657±4665.
3
Organic thin film architectures: fabrication and properties M C P E T T Y , University of Durham, UK
3.1
Introduction
Molecular electronics is a fast moving and interdisciplinary subject that exploits the electronic and optoelectronic properties of organic and biological materials (Petty et al., 1995; Richardson, 2000; Tour, 2003; Maruccio et al., 2004). The areas of application and potential application are varied, ranging from chemical and biochemical sensors to plastic light-emitting displays. Molecular electronics also offers considerable scope for molecular nanotechnology, e.g., the development of electronic switching and memory structures operating, and addressable, at the molecular level. In most of these examples, the organic materials are required in the form of thin films (1 nm to 10 m). This presents a considerable challenge to materials scientists, as organic compounds, in their bulk form, can be fragile and difficult to handle. In this chapter, an overview of the more popular methods that may be used to fabricate thin layers of organic compounds will first be described. A distinction will be drawn between established deposition technologies, in many cases developed for use with inorganic materials, and those methods that actually allow molecular-scale architectures to be built-up on solid supports. Each deposition method differs in complexity and may be more suited to provide films in a particular thickness range. Specific types of organic compound are necessary for certain processes, e.g., self-assembly exploits the attraction between certain chemical groups. Some methods are `wet' (spinning) while others are inherently `dry' (plasma deposition). There are also implications for the degree of order and contamination levels in the deposited film. Following the introduction to organic film technologies, a brief review of some of the more powerful analytical techniques that can be used to reveal the structure and degree of molecular organization in the thin layers will be presented.
Organic thin film architectures: fabrication and properties
3.2
61
Established deposition methods
3.2.1 Physical vapour deposition Solid materials vaporize when heated to sufficiently high temperatures, this process may proceed through the liquid phase. A thin film is then obtained by the condensation of the vapour onto a colder substrate (Maissel and Glang, 1970). This method has been used extensively to deposit films of inorganic materials, such as metals and their alloys. However, the technique is now being used for the formation of layers of low molecular weight organic compounds. Because of collisions with ambient gas atoms, a fraction of the vapour atoms will be scattered. For a straight line path between the evaporating material (source) and the substrate, it is necessary to use low pressures (< 10ÿ4 mbar) where the mean free path of the gas atoms is much greater than the sourcesubstrate distance. This allows the use of a shadow mask immediately in front of the substrate to define patterns. The low pressure also prevents contamination of the source material (e.g. by oxidation). Figure 3.1 shows a schematic diagram of a typical evaporation system. The system chamber, which can be made from glass or metal, is evacuated to a pressure of 10ÿ4±10ÿ6 mbar, normally with two types of vacuum pump, a rotary and diffusion pump, operating in series. The first step in physical vapour deposition requires the transformation of the condensed phase, solid or liquid, into the gaseous state. This conversion of thermal to mechanical energy can be achieved by a variety of methods. Resistive heating has been used to deposit fluorescent dyes, charge-transfer salts and large
3.1 Schematic diagram of a typical vacuum evaporation system for physical vapour deposition.
62
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
macromolecules, such as the phthalocyanines (Petty, 2000; Park et al., 2004). Typical evaporation rates are 1±10 nm minÿ1. Other techniques include arc evaporation, RF heating or heating by electron bombardment. Deposition of polymer films by laser ablation is an area that offers some promise (Chrisey and Hubler, 1994). Laser pulsed methods have been used successfully for polyethylene, polycarbonate, polyimide, polymethylmethacrylate and, more recently, for the deposition of compounds for organic light-emitting displays and transistors (Salih et al., 1997; Hong et al., 2002; Blanchet et al., 2003). Materials that dissociate in the vapour phase may provide solid films with a stoichiometry that differs from that of the source. Therefore special techniques have been devised. One approach is to use the method of `flash' evaporation. It is also possible to evaporate from two, or more, sources and to control the flux from each to obtain a vapour with the required composition. This has been used effectively to deposit thin films of doped organic charge-transfer salts (Breen et al., 1993): one source is the charge-transfer salt, e.g., tetrathiafulvalene (TTF), while the other is the dopant, e.g., iodine. Laser co-ablation techniques can be used to deposit films of metal-polymer composites (Chrisey and Hubler, 1994). Molecular beam epitaxy (MBE) is a similar, but more expensive, variation of vacuum evaporation (Hara and Sasabe, 1995). However, an ultra-high vacuum (<10ÿ9 mbar) is required to eliminate the scattering by residual gas molecules. The technique consists of directing controlled `beams' of the required molecules towards a heated substrate. Multiple sources, Knudsen cells, can be shuttered and used to create a superlattice structure on the substrate and control the molecular composition, orientation and packing in two dimensions. Some of the first trial observations of real-time epitaxial growth in organic molecular systems have involved a study of phthalocyanine monolayers on cleaved surfaces of MoS2 and on highly orientated pyrolyzed graphite and alkali halides. In-situ reflection high energy diffraction (RHEED) can be used to monitor the actual film growth (Hara and Sasabe, 1995). Highly ordered thin film crystals of perylene derivatives and electrically conductive oligomers for the fabrication of organic field effect transistors have also been produced by MBE (Dimitrakopoulos et al., 1998; Sazaki et al., 2004). A further physical vapour deposition technique, sputtering, is based on the momentum exchange of accelerated ions incident on a target of source material (Maissel and Glang, 1970). A source of ions (e.g. Ar or Xe) is provided by a glow discharge created by an electric field between two electrodes in a gas at low pressure. The material to be sputtered, the target, is the cathode. The vacuum chamber is evacuated and then filled with the inert gas at a low pressure. A potential difference of several kilovolts is applied to the electrodes which causes the gas to become ionized and form a plasma. The positive gas ions are then accelerated by the electric field so that they arrive at the cathode with considerable energy and sputter the target atoms. Some secondary electrons are also produced at the cathode and these accelerate towards the anode and serve to
Organic thin film architectures: fabrication and properties
63
maintain the plasma. There are several variations on the basic sputtering arrangement described above. For example, RF (radio frequency) sputtering can be used to sputter insulating source materials. The principal advantage of sputtering is that almost any material can be deposited. Since no heating is required, materials that are difficult to melt (and therefore to evaporate) are easily sputtered, as are compounds that would dissociate in an evaporation source. The method has been used for some organic polymers such as polyimide (Kinbara et al., 2003) and for producing fluorescent coatings (Maggioni et al., 2003). However, a relatively large amount of the material is needed as a target. This is not always practical for the new organic compounds, which may be available only in very small quantities.
3.2.2 Spin-coating Spin-coating is exploited by the microelectronics industry for depositing layers of photoresist films, generally polyimides, onto silicon wafers (Brodie and Muray, 1992). The various steps involved are illustrated in Fig. 3.2. A quantity of a polymer solution is first placed on the semiconductor wafer, which is then rotated at a fixed speed of several thousand rpm (or the solution can be applied while the wafer is slowly rotating). The resist solution flows radially outwards, reducing the fluid layer thickness. Evaporation of the solvent results in a film of uniform thickness. The resist viscosity (dependent on the concentration of the starting solution) and final film speed are both important process parameters that influence the final film thickness. An increase in angular velocity decreases the film thickness; an inverse power-law relationship usually holds for the thickness dependence on the final spin speed. For a given speed, the film thickness decreases rapidly at first, but then slows considerably at longer times. Although spin-coating is expected to produce films in which individual molecules are relatively disordered, this is not always the case. For instance,
3.2 Schematic representation of the spin-coating technique.
64
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
spin-coated phthalocyanine layers have revealed crystalline order (Critchley et al., 1992) which may result from the centrifugal forces acting upon the individual molecules during spinning. In other cases, order can be achieved by a post-deposition treatment. Application of heat and an electric field normal to film plane (the process of `poling') can be used to align the C-F dipoles in polyvinylidene fluoride films. The result is a polar film possessing piezoelectric and pyroelectric behaviour. A similar method can be used to induce secondorder nonlinear optical behaviour (e.g. second-harmonic generation) in films of appropriate molecules (Petty et al., 1995).
3.2.3 Other techniques Chemical vapour deposition (CVD) is a process in which one or more gaseous species react on a solid surface and one or more of the reaction products is a solid phase material (Maissel and Glang, 1970; Sherman, 1987). The CVD process is based on the decomposition and/or radical generation of chemical species by stimulating vapour with heat, plasma (discharge) or light (laser). The method is used in the microelectronics industry for the fabrication of inorganic semiconducting and insulating films. In plasma-enhanced CVD (PECVD) glow discharge plasmas are sustained within chambers where simultaneous CVD reactions occur (Yasuda, 1985; Lucovsky et al., 1990). The discharge is normally excited by an RF field. One example is the formation of polystyrene films as the dielectric in a nuclear battery (Brodie and Muray, 1992; Lucovsky et al., 1990). The surface of the polymer may be simultaneously removed by reaction with the residual gases (ablation); the balance between ablation and polymerization may be controlled by adding gases that promote one or other effect. For example, CF4 is an effective plasma etch material under normal discharge conditions; however, if a small amount of hydrogen is added, a polymer is deposited. Laser, or more generally, optical chemical processing involves the use of monochromatic photons to enhance and control reactions at substrates (Eden, 1992). Electrochemical deposition, or electroplating, has been known for at least one hundred years. Approximately half of the 70 or so metals can be electrodeposited, either singly or as alloys. The equipment required consists of an anode and a cathode immersed in a suitable electrolyte. Metal is deposited onto the cathode and the relationship between the weight of the material deposited and the various parameters can be expressed by the first and second laws of electrolysis. Anodization is a particular kind of electrolysis. Many polymeric films can be prepared by the anodic oxidation of suitable monomer species, such as pyrrole, thiophene and aniline (Xia et al., 2001; Grigore and Petty, 2003; Alumaa et al., 2004). The method has also been used to prepare thin layers of biopolymers (Kastantin et al., 2003).
Organic thin film architectures: fabrication and properties
3.3
65
Molecular architectures
3.3.1 Langmuir-Blodgett technique A method that allows the manipulation of materials on the nanometre scale is the Langmuir-Blodgett (LB) technique (Petty, 1996). Langmuir-Blodgett films are prepared by first depositing a small quantity of an amphiphilic compound (i.e. one incorporating both polar and nonpolar groups ± the classical materials being long-chain fatty acids) dissolved in a volatile solvent, onto the surface of purified water, the subphase. When the solvent has evaporated, the organic molecules may be compressed to form a floating two-dimensional solid. Monolayer films can exhibit a multiplicity of phases during this compression; these are similar to the mesophases shown by liquid crystals. The surface pressure of the floating organic film is defined as the reduction of the subphase surface tension by the film, i.e. o ÿ
3:1
where o is the surface tension of the pure subphase and is the surface tension of the film-covered surface. In the case of a water subphase (nearly almost all the work on LB films has involved a water subphase) values of of the order of mN mÿ1 are generally encountered; the maximum value of is 72.8 mN mÿ1 at 20 ëC, the surface tension of pure water. Figure 3.3 shows a surface pressure versus area isotherm (i.e. measurement at constant temperature) for a hypothetical long-chain organic material. This generic diagram is not meant to represent that observed for a particular
3.3 Surface pressure versus area per molecule isotherm for a long-chain organic compound. The surface pressure and area are in arbitrary units (a.u.).
66
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
substance, but shows most of the features observed for long-chain compounds (Petty, 1996). In the `gaseous' state (G in Fig. 3.3) the molecules are far enough apart on the water surface that they exert little force on one another. As the surface area of the monolayer is reduced, the hydrocarbon chains will begin to interact. The `liquid' state that is formed is generally called the expanded monolayer phase (E). The hydrocarbon chains of the molecules in such a film are in a random, rather than a regular orientation, with their polar groups in contact with the subphase. As the molecular area is progressively reduced, condensed (C) phases may appear; there may be more than one of these. In the condensed monolayer states, the molecules are closely packed and are orientated with the hydrocarbon chains pointing away from the water surface. The limiting area per molecule in such a state will be similar to the cross-sectional area of the hydrocarbon chain, i.e. approximately 0.19 nm2 moleculeÿ1. If the surface pressure of the monolayer is held constant in one or more of the condensed phases, then the film may be transferred from the water surface onto a suitable solid substrate simply by raising and lowering the latter through the monolayer/air interface. Monolayer transfer speeds are usually of the order of a few mm per second. Several deposition modes are possible depending on the interactions between the polar and nonpolar parts of the molecules, and the nature of the bond between the first layer and the substrate surface. In the commonest form of LB film deposition, known as Y-type deposition, a monolayer is deposited on each traversal of the monolayer/air interface. Instances in which the floating monolayer is only transferred to the substrate as it is being inserted into the subphase, or only as it is being removed are often observed. These deposition modes are called X-type (monolayer transfer on the downstroke only) and Z-type (transfer on the upstroke only). Film transfer is characterized by the measurement of a deposition, or transfer, ratio, . This is the decrease in the area occupied by the monolayer (held at constant pressure) on the water surface divided by the coated area of the solid substrate, i.e.,
AL AS
3:2
where AL is the decrease in the area occupied by the monolayer on the water surface and AS is the coated area of the solid substrate. Transfer ratios significantly outside the range 0.95 to 1.05 suggest poor homogeneity. A schematic diagram of one possible experimental arrangement for the deposition of LB films is shown in Fig. 3.4. The container that holds the water is termed a Langmuir trough. A working area can be defined by a PTFE-coated glass fibre barrier that can be moved using a low-geared electric motor. The barrier motor is coupled to a sensitive electronic balance which continuously monitors, via a sensing plate, the surface pressure of the monolayer. Using a feedback arrangement, this pressure can be maintained at a predetermined value. The physical dimensions of the Langmuir trough are not critical and are governed by
Organic thin film architectures: fabrication and properties
67
3.4 Schematic diagram of LB trough and associated monolayer compression system for multilayer deposition.
the size of the substrate used. A dipping well can be used to accommodate large substrates without increasing the volume of water in the trough. Cleanliness is essential to produce good quality films. To minimize contamination, the system is usually housed in a glove box or in a microelectronics clean room. It is also possible to construct LB films using more than one type of molecular film. In the simplest case, condensed floating monolayers of two different amphiphilic materials are confined (using mechanical barriers) to different regions of the water surface. By lowering the solid substrate through the first layer of, say material A, and raising it up through the other, material B, alternate-layers of structure ABABAB. . . may be built up. This permits the fabrication of organic superlattices with precisely defined symmetry properties.
3.3.2 Self-assembly Self-assembly is a much simpler process than that of LB deposition. Monomolecular layers are formed by the immersion of an appropriate substrate into a solution of the organic material (Fig. 3.5). The best known examples of self-assembled systems are organosilicon on hydroxylated surfaces (SiO2, Al2O3, glass, etc.) and alkanethiols on gold, silver and copper (Ulman, 1991; Tredgold, 1994). However, other combinations include: dialkyl sulphides on gold; dialkyl disulphides on gold; alcohols and amines on platinum; and carboxylic acids on aluminium oxide and silver. The self-assembly process is driven by the interactions between the head group of the self-assembling molecule and the substrate, resulting in a strong chemical bond between the head
68
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
3.5 Self-assembled monolayer of an alkanethiol on a gold-coated substrate.
group and a specific surface site, e.g., a covalent Si-O bond for alkyltrichlorosilanes on hydroxylated surfaces. The self-assembly process is usually restricted to the deposition of a single molecular layer on a solid substrate. However, chemical means can be exploited to build up multilayer organic films. A method pioneered by Sagiv is based on the successive absorption and reaction of appropriate molecules (Netzer and Sagiv, 1983; Netzer et al., 1983). The headgroups react with the substrate to give a permanent chemical attachment and each subsequent layer is chemically attached to the one before in a very similar way to that used in systems for supported synthesis of proteins.
3.3.3 Electrostatic layer-by-layer deposition Another technique for building up thin films of organic molecules is driven by the ionic attraction between opposite charges in two different polyelectrolytes. Figure 3.6 shows a schematic diagram of the processes involved in this layer-by-
3.6 Sequence of immersion of a substrate in polyanion and polycation solutions for electrostatic layer-by-layer deposition.
Organic thin film architectures: fabrication and properties
69
3.7 Schematic diagrams of expected molecular organization in (a) a LangmuirBlodgett film and (b) a film deposited by the layer-by-layer electrostatic technique.
layer (LbL) assembly technique (Decher and Schlenoff, 2003). A solid substrate with a positively charged planar surface is immersed in a solution containing an anionic polyelectrolyte and a monolayer of polyanion is adsorbed. Since the adsorption is carried out at relatively high concentrations of the polyelectrolyte, most of the ionic groups remain exposed to the interface with the solution and thus the surface charge is reversed. After rinsing in pure water, the substrate is immersed in a solution containing the cationic polyelectrolyte. Again, a monolayer is adsorbed but now the original surface charge is restored, thus resulting in the formation of multilayer assemblies of both polymers. It is possible to use a sensitive optical technique, such as surface plasmon resonance to monitor, in situ, the growth of such electrostatically assembled films (Pearson et al., 2001). The layer-by-layer method has been used to build up layers of conductive polymers, e.g., partially doped polyaniline and a polystyrene polyanion (Cheung et al., 1997). Biocompatible surfaces consisting of alternate layers of charged polysaccharides and oppositely charged synthetic polymers can also be deposited in this way (Lvov et al., 1998). A related, but alternative, approach uses layer-by-layer adsorption driven by hydrogen bonding interactions (Stockton and Rubner, 1997). Figure 3.7 contrasts the molecular organization expected in an LB multilayer with that in electrostatically deposited layer-by-layer films. For the latter case, the polyelectrolyte chains within each layer will become entangled, and may even penetrate into the layers above and below, leading to a less ordered film than that produced by LB deposition.
3.3.4 Dip-pen nanolithography Scanning microscopy methods offer a powerful means of manipulating molecules. For instance, careful control of an atomic force microscope (AFM) tip can allow patterns to be drawn in an organic film (Chi et al., 1992). Such
70
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
3.8 Dip-pen patterning technique showing the transfer of an `ink' onto `paper' using the tip of an atomic force microscope (Piner et al., 1999).
techniques can also be used to reposition molecules, such as the fullerene C60, on surfaces and to break up an individual molecule (Gimzewski, 1998). A further approach that has been developed at Northwestern University is called Dip-Pen Nanolithography (DPN) (Piner et al., 1999). This technique, illustrated in Fig. 3.8, is able to deliver organic molecules in a positive printing mode. An AFM tip is used to `write' alkanethiols on a thin gold film in a manner analogous to that of a fountain pen. Molecules flow from the AFM tip to the solid substrate (`paper') via capillary transport, making DPN a potentially useful tool for assembling nanoscale devices. The chemisorption of the `ink' is the driving force that moves the ink from the AFM tip through the water to the substrate as the tip is scanned across this surface. Adjusting the scan rate and relative humidity can control line widths. Recent developments of DPN have included an overwriting capability that allows one nanostructure to be generated and the areas surrounding it to be filled with a second type of ink (Hong et al., 1999). Perhaps the greatest limitation in using scanning probe methodologies for ultra-high resolution nanolithography over large areas derives from the serial nature of most techniques. However, an eight-pen nanoplotter capable of doing parallel lithography has been reported (Hong and Mirkin, 2000). Parallel dip-pen nanolithography with arrays of individually addressable cantilevers has also been developed (Bullen et al., 2004). The DPN method has also been used to deposit magnetic nanostructures (Liu et al., 2002), arrays of protein molecules (Lee et al., 2002) and metal nanocrystals (Thomas et al., 2004).
3.3.5 Ink-jet printing The need to combine large area coatings with device patterning has resulted in the development of other direct-write fabrication methods, such as ink-jet printing. This particular method is attracting the interest of many workers worldwide and is currently a rapidly moving area of research and development, producing many papers and patents (Speakman et al., 2001; PercËin and Khuri-
Organic thin film architectures: fabrication and properties
71
Yakub, 2002; Sirringhaus and Shimoda, 2003). Although ink-jet printhead droplet ejection can be achieved with thermal (bubble-jet) and piezoelectric modes of operation, the majority of published literature on ink-jet printing as a tool for manufacturing organic devices has been the result of using piezoelectric actuated printers. Piezoelectric printhead technology is favoured primarily because it applies no thermal load to the organic inks and is compatible with the printing of digital images. The combination of solution-processable emissive polymers with ink-jet printing offers some promise in the development of lowcost, high-resolution displays (Rees et al., 2002). The technique has also been applied to the manufacture of all-polymer transistor circuits (Sirringhaus et al., 2001; Paul et al., 2003).
3.4
Molecular organization in thin films
The need to understand the structure of organic thin films is paramount if these thin layers are to be exploited commercially. Traditional techniques such as optical and electron microscopies allow the morphology of the layers to be explored, while spectroscopic examination using electromagnetic radiation, electrons or ions can reveal the chemical nature of the films (Ulman, 1994; Tredgold, 1994). In the case of LB or self-assembled layers, special methods, such as X-ray and electron diffraction can show details of the molecular organization in both the out-of-plane and in-plane directions. Generally, two levels of molecular packing must be considered for long-chain molecules in layered structures. The organization of the individual molecules in the multilayer will define the main crystallographic cell while the packing of the C2H4 repeat units in the long hydrocarbon chains defines the subcell (Petty, 1996). The following section provides an overview of the methods that are commonly used to study organic thin films, with an emphasis on those techniques that can reveal useful information about molecular scale architectures.
3.4.1 X-ray, neutron and electron diffraction X-ray diffraction was one of the original methods used to study the structure of fatty acid type LB films. When electromagnetic energy is incident on the surface of a material, some of it will be reflected specularly so that the angle of incidence is equal to the angle of reflection. For crystalline materials, constructive and destructive interference between the radiation reflected from successive crystal planes will occur when the wavelength of the incident radiation is of the same order as the lattice spacing. The condition for maxima in the reflected radiation is provided by Bragg's law n 2dhkl sin
3:3
72
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
where is the angle of incidence, conventionally measured from the plane of reflection in X-ray crystallography, dhkl is the interplanar spacing and the integer n is known as the order of reflection. Figure 3.9 shows X-ray diffraction data from a 43-layer fatty acid salt film (Nicklow et al., 1981). As predicted, the first order Bragg reflection is observed for an angle of incidence close to one degree. In a Y-type LB film, the d001 spacing is equal to the distance between the polar planes, i.e., the thickness of two monomolecular layers. The monolayer thicknesses for fatty acid salt films, obtained from X-ray experiments, are in close agreement with the lengths of the molecules, implying that the hydrocarbon chains in transferred monolayers are orientated at right-angles to the substrate surface. For Y-type LB films of other amphiphilic materials (including simple fatty acids) the X-ray d-spacing is often less than twice the molecular length, suggesting some tilting or interdigitation (or both) of the molecules. X-rays are scattered by their interaction with atomic electrons and interference takes place between X-rays scattered from different parts of an atom. The scattering power or scattering factor decreases with increasing scattering angle, 2, resulting in a decrease in the intensity of the Bragg peaks. However, it
3.9 X-ray diffraction data from a 43-layer LB film of perdeuterated manganese octadecanoate on a silicon substrate. Experimental values are shown as points. The solid curve is based on calculation and is displaced from the data points. (Reprinted from Nicklow, R. M., Pomerantz, M. and Segmuller, A., Physical Review B, 23, 1081±7, 1981. Copyright 1981 by the American Physical Society.)
Organic thin film architectures: fabrication and properties
73
is evident that the height of the third Bragg reflection in Fig. 3.9 is greater than that of the second. This is because the intensity of a particular Bragg peak is not only related to the scattering power of each atom in the lattice but also to the position of the atom in the unit cell. In summing the individual waves to give the resultant diffracted beam, both the amplitude and phase of each wave scattered by the individual atoms are important. The intensity of the scattered radiation Ihkl from a set of planes `hkl' may be written 2 Ihkl sLpFhkl
3:4
where s is a scale factor, L is the Lorentz (geometrical) correction, p is a polarization correction and Fhkl is called the structure factor. The structure factor of the unit cell depends upon the constituent atoms and their individual scattering factors. For a particular d-spacing, the only variable in the cell structure is the nature of the atom. Since Fhkl depends directly on the effective number of scattering electrons per atom, a large Fhkl is given by a high atomic number. Thus fatty acid salt films, containing heavy metals such as cadmium, barium or lead, are generally superior for X-ray diffraction experiments. If the structure factors for a complete set of X-ray reflections are known, the electron density at any position in the unit cell may be calculated. However, the computational problem is formidable. A physical criterion (e.g. a region, such as an alkyl chain, where a constant electron density is expected) is often used to evaluate the electron density profile of multilayer films perpendicular to the substrate. Interference of reflected X-rays from the upper and lower surfaces of a thin film gives rise to Kiessig fringes. These may be used to determine the overall thickness of the film. The use of a neutron beam produces interference effects in a similar way to an X-ray beam. The major difference between the two types of radiation lies in the factors governing the intensity of diffraction. For X-rays, this depends on the electron density variation across the layers. In the case of neutrons, it is the variation of nuclear scattering length density that determines the Bragg intensity. Because neutron scattering is a nuclear property, it may vary considerably from one element to the next and is different for different isotopes, e.g., hydrogen and deuterium. Neutron absorption is usually negligible and the interference effects that cause X-ray scattering to diminish with increasing angle are absent with neutrons and the scattering is isotropic. Electron diffraction provides structural information on multilayer films in much the same way as X-ray experiments. To obtain the structure normal to the film plane, the electron beam impinges at a grazing angle and the reflected beam is observed. For fatty acid type LB films, the diffraction experiments reveal the packing of the C2H4 subcells in the aliphatic chain. One advantage of using electrons as a probe is that the interaction of the electron beam with matter is much stronger than for X-rays. Both transmission and reflection diffraction techniques can be used. Figure 3.10 shows a transmission electron diffraction
74
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
3.10 Transmission electron diffraction pattern for a 22-tricosenoic acid LB film. (After Peterson and Russell, 1984. Reproduced with permission from Taylor & Francis Ltd: http://www.tandf.co.uk/journals.)
pattern of a fatty acid LB film (Peterson and Russell, 1984). This particular diffraction pattern can be indexed as arising from an orthorhombic packing of the subcells. The measurement of reflection high energy electron diffraction (RHEED) patterns in the direction of film deposition and perpendicular to it can reveal the presence of in-plane anisotropy and can also provide the tilt elevation of molecules in the LB film. Figure 3.11 shows that the angle of inclination to the horizontal varies with the deposition surface pressure (Peterson et al., 1988; Barnes and Sambles, 1987). As the deposition pressure is increased, the molecular tilt elevation also increases (i.e. the molecules become more upright).
3.11 Molecular tilt (measured from substrate plane) versus deposition surface pressure for 22-tricosenoic acid. n deposition pH7; l pH3; t pH7 (Barnes and Sambles, 1987) (after Peterson et al., 1988, Copyright 1988, with permission from Elsevier).
Organic thin film architectures: fabrication and properties
75
3.4.2 Infra-red spectroscopy Infra-red (IR) spectroscopy (wavelength in the range 1±100 m) probes the vibrational features of an organic molecule. A particular chemical bond must have a permanent dipole moment associated with it to interact with the infra-red radiation. The compression and extension of the bond can be likened to the behaviour of a spring. This analogy may be taken further by assuming that the bond, like a simple spring, obeys Hooke's law. For a diatomic molecule (e.g. HCl) the vibrational energy levels E are given by 1 E h n 3:5 2 where h is Planck's constant, is the frequency of the radiation and the vibrational quantum number n 0; 1; 2; . . .. For IR spectroscopy, it is usual for the energy of the electromagnetic radiation to be quoted in terms of a wavenumber . This is the reciprocal of the wavelength, in centimetres. Although a normal mode of vibration involves movement of all of the atoms in a molecule, there are circumstances in which movement is almost localized in one part of the molecule. If the vibration involves the stretching or bending of a terminal XY group, where X is heavy compared to Y, e.g., an OH group in a fatty acid, the corresponding vibration wavenumbers are almost independent of the rest of the molecule to which XY is attached. A typical wavenumber for the XY stretching vibration may therefore be referred to. For example, the OH stretching frequency is normally in the region of 3600 cmÿ1. Many group vibrations occur in the region 1500 to 3700 cmÿ1; the stretching and bending vibrations of some well-known groups are listed in Table 3.1. The absorption or reflection intensities resulting from the interaction of IR radiation with monolayer samples are very low, a direct result of the relatively Table 3.1 Characteristic stretching and bending frequencies of molecular groups Group
Approximate wavenumber (cmÿ1)
±OH ±NH2 =CH2 ±CH3
3600 3400 3030 2960 (antisym. stretch) 2870 (sym. stretch) 1460 (antisym. bend) 1375 (sym. bend) 2920 (antisym. stretch) 2850 (sym. stretch) 1470 (bend) 2220 1750±1600 1650
±CH2± ±C=C± >C=O >C=C<
76
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
3.12 Comparison of (a) simple transmission (b) ATR and (c) RAIRS sampling techniques for infra-red spectroscopy. The organic thin films are indicated by the shaded regions.
small numbers of molecules being sampled. In a transmission experiment with normal incidence of the IR beam, the electric field is orientated parallel to the layer plane, as shown in Fig. 3.12(a). In this geometry the projection of the transition moments on the layer plane is probed. An increase in surface sensitivity may be obtained by using a method based on attenuated total reflection (ATR) (Fig. 3.12(b)). In this technique, the sample is deposited onto either side of an IR-transmitting crystal (e.g. silicon or germanium). The radiation is incident at an angle greater than the critical angle and undergoes multiple reflections inside the crystal. On each reflection, the evanescent field of the IR beam penetrates the organic layer and may be absorbed by it. Both the transmission and ATR experiment may be performed using either polarized or unpolarized radiation. Reflection absorption infra-red spectroscopy, RAIRS, requires IR radiation to be incident at a grazing angle to a metal surface onto which the organic film has been deposited (Fig. 3.12(c)). The RAIRS experiment has the very useful ability to detect vibrations that possess a transition dipole with a large component perpendicular to the surface. The orientation of the molecules in organized thin films can be investigated by using different polarizations of incident radiation or by comparing transmission and reflection measurements. In the case of the ATR technique, unpolarized IR radiation will couple to all the molecular dipoles a thin film. In contrast, RAIRS preferentially selects those transition dipoles with large components perpendicular to the film plane. Figure 3.13 shows the
Organic thin film architectures: fabrication and properties
77
3.13 Infra-red spectra of 21 LB layers of cadmium docosanoate on a silicon ATR crystal. (a) ATR mode. (b) RAIRS mode. (Reprinted with permission from Davies and Yarwood, 1989, Copyright 1989 American Chemical Society.)
ATR and RAIRS spectra in the CH stretching region for a 21 layer fatty acid salt LB film (Davies and Yarwood, 1989). The bands that are observed are 2960 cmÿ1 (antisymmetric CH3 stretch), 2920 cmÿ1 (antisymmetric CH2 stretch), 2870 cmÿ1 (symmetric CH3 stretch) and 2850 cmÿ1 (symmetric CH2 stretch). The symmetric and antisymmetric CH2 stretches are both intense in the ATR spectrum. However, in the RAIRS mode, the CH3 bands increase in intensity. The transition dipole moments of the CH2 vibrations are perpendicular to the long axis of the fatty acid molecules, whereas the symmetric and antisymmetric CH3 stretches have components along the chain axis. Therefore, the experimental data shown in Fig. 3.13 are consistent with the long axes of the fatty acid molecules being almost perpendicular to the substrate plane.
3.4.3 Scanning probe microscopies Scanning tunnelling microscopy (STM) and atomic force microscopy (AFM) are both techniques that may be used to provide direct images of metal surfaces with nanometre resolution. Whereas STM records the overlap of the local electron density of states between tip and substrate or its modulation by adsorbate molecules in the gap, AFM measures the interatomic forces between a cantilevered spring tip and the sample surface. The image contrast in AFM is achieved by probing the elastic response of the molecules to the force exerted by the scanning tip. Figure 3.14 shows an example of an atomic force micrograph of a 12-layer neicosanoic acid LB film deposited onto single crystal silicon (Evenson et al., 1996). Lines of individual molecules are evident at the magnification shown.
78
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
3.14 AFM image of a 12-layer n-eicosanoic acid LB film deposited onto silicon. (Reprinted with permission from Evenson et al., 1996, Copyright 1996 American Chemical Society.)
3.5
Future trends
The past three decades have witnessed a marked increase in academic and commercial interest in organized thin organic films. Much of the original work was devoted to understanding the formation and structure of Langmuir-Blodgett films. As applications for these ultra-thin layers have become a possibility, other techniques such as chemical and electrostatic self-assembly have been introduced. All these methods can provide intriguing molecular architectures which can form the basis of fundamental experiments in the research laboratory. For molecular nanotechnology to become a reality, there is still much to be discovered about the nature of the organic compounds that can be used in these techniques and the links between the film structure and its properties. This may require the development or refinement of characterization tools suited to the study of molecular assemblies. In the shorter term, the more established techniques of spin-coating and thermal evaporation may provide cost-effective solutions in the commercial arena for application areas in which a high degree of molecular order is not essential. The long-term stability of organic materials is still a problem for the commercialization of electronic devices. For example, organic light emitting displays require an operating lifetime of about 50,000 hours. The organic thin films that are used in these (and other) devices are very sensitive to contamination, oxidation and humidity. To increase the lifetime of such devices, various methods have been devised for their encapsulation. Hermetic encapsulation using a glass or metal lid has been extensively used to protect the organic films from oxygen and water vapour. However, these approaches are
Organic thin film architectures: fabrication and properties
79
expensive. Other methods based on dry and wet processes are currently being explored. The stability issues associated with organic materials should not, however, deter scientists and technologists in their endeavours to develop products. The commercialization of liquid crystal displays demonstrates clearly that quite sophisticated devices incorporating organic thin films can be marketed. There are, of course, numerous examples of the successful exploitation of organized molecular assemblies in the natural world!
3.6
Further information
The work described in this chapter is highly interdisciplinary and, therefore, further information is to be found in a variety of physics, chemistry and engineering databases. Biologists and biochemists are also taking a keen interest in organized organic films as some of these can possess similar structures to cell membranes found in the natural world. Existing books on organized molecular organic films include those of Ulman (1991), Petty (1996) and Decher and Schlenoff (2003) while the properties and possible applications of these thin layers are covered by Tredgold (1994), Petty et al. (1995) and Richardson (2000). Developments in the fabrication, investigation and applications of organic thin films are the concerns of the International Conference on Organized Molecular Films (LB series) and the European Conference on Organized Films (ECOF series). Both take place every two or three years and their proceedings are published in journals such as Thin Solid Films and Materials Science and Engineering C. In addition, many of the activities are covered in the nanotechnology literature. A good starting source of information is the website of the UK-based Institute of Nanotechnolgy (http://www.nano.org.uk/).
3.7
References
Alumaa A, Hallik A, Maeorg U, Sammelselg V and Tamm J (2004) Potentiometric properties of polypyrrole bilayers, Electrochimica Acta, 49, 1767±1774. Barnes W L and Sambles J R (1987) Surface pressure effects on Langmuir-Blodgett multilayers of 22-tricosenoic acid, Surface Sci., 187, 144±152. Blanchet G B, Fincher C R and Malajovich I (2003) Laser evaporation and the production of pentacene films, J. Appl. Phys., 94, 6181±6184. Breen J J, Tolman J S and Flynn G W (1993) Scanning tunnelling microscopy studies of vapour deposited films of tetrathiafulvalene with iodine, Appl. Phys. Lett., 62 1074± 1076. Brodie I and Muray J J (1992) The Physics of Micro/Nano-Fabrication, Plenum Press, New York. Bullen D, Chung S-W, Wang X, Zou J, Mirkin C A and Liu C (2004) Parallel dip-pen nanolithography with arrays of individually addressable cantilevers, Appl. Phys. Lett., 84, 789±791. Cheung J H, Stockton W B and Rubner M F (1997) Molecular-level processing of
80
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
conjugated polymers. 3. Layer-by-layer manipulation of polyaniline via electrostatic interactions, Macromolecules, 30, 2712±2716. Chi L F, Eng L M, Graf K and Fuchs H (1992) Structure and stability of LangmuirBlodgett films investigated by scanning force microscopy, Langmuir, 8, 2255±2261. Chrisey D B and Hubler G K (eds) (1994) Pulsed Laser Deposition of Thin Films, WileyInterscience, New York. Critchley S M, Willis M R, Cook M J, McMurdo J and Maruyama Y (1992) Deposition of ordered phthalocyanine films by spin-coating, J. Mater. Chem., 2, 157±159. Davies G H and Yarwood J (1989) Infrared intensity enhancement for Langmuir-Blodgett monolayers using thick metal overlayers, Langmuir, 5, 229±232. Decher G and Schlenoff J B (eds) (2003) Multilayer Thin Films Sequential Assembly of Nanocomposite Materials, Wiley-VCH, Weinheim. Dimitrakopoulos C D, Furman B K, Graham T, Hegde S and Purushothaman S (1998) Field effect transistors comprising molecular beam deposited , !-di-hexylhexathienylene and polymeric insulator, Synthetic Metals, 92, 47±52. Eden J G (1992) Photochemical Vapour Deposition, Wiley-Interscience, New York. Evenson S A, Badyal J P S, Pearson C and Petty M C (1996), Variation in intermolecular spacing with dipping pressure for arachidic acid LB films, J. Phys. Chem., 100, 11672±11674. Gimzewski J (1998) Molecules, nanophysics and nanoelectronics, Physics World, 11, No. 6, 25±27. Grigore L and Petty M C (2003) Polyaniline films deposited by anodic polymerization: properties and applications to chemical sensing, J. Materials Science Materials in Electronics, 14, 389±392. Hara M and Sasabe H (1995) in Petty M C, Bryce M R and Bloor D (eds) An Introduction to Molecular Electronics, Edward Arnold, London. Hong S and Mirkin C A (2000) A nanoplotter with both parallel and serial writing capabilities, Science, 288, 1808±1811. Hong S, Zhu J and Mirkin C A (1999) Multiple ink nanolithography: toward a multiplepen nanoplotter, Science, 286, 523±525. Hong C, Chae H B, Lee K H, Ahn S K, Kim C K, Kim T W, Choi N I and Kim S O (2002) The possibility of pulsed laser deposited organic thin films for light-emitting diodes, Thin Solid Films, 409, 37±42. Kastantin M J, Li S, Gadre A P, Wu L Q, Bentley W E, Payne, G F, Rubloff G W and Ghodssi R (2003) Integrated fabrication of polymeric devices for biological applications, Sensors and Materials, 15, 295±311. Kinbara A, Hayashi T, Wakahara K, Kikuchi N, Kusano E and Nanto H (2003) Polyimide-based organic thin films prepared by rf magnetron sputtering, Thin Solid Films, 433, 274±276. Lee K B, Park S J, Mirkin C A, Smith J C and Mrksich, M (2002) Protein nanoarrays generated by dip-pen nanolithography, Science, 295, 1702±1705. Liu X, Fu L, Hong S, Dravid V P and Mirkin C A (2002) Arrays of magnetic nanoparticles patterned via `dip-pen' nanolithography, Adv. Mat., 14, 231±234. Lucovsky G, Ibbotson D E and Hess D W (eds) (1990) Characterization of PlasmaEnhanced CVD Processes, Materials Research Society, Pittsburg. Lvov Y, Onda M, Ariga K and Kunitake T (1998), Ultrathin films of charged polysaccharides assembled alternately with linear polyions, J. Biomater. Sci. Polymer Edn., 9, 345±355.
Organic thin film architectures: fabrication and properties
81
Maggioni G, Carturan S, Quaranta A, Patelli A, Della Mea G and Rigato V (2003) Deposition of fluorescent organic coatings by glow discharge induced sublimation, Surface & Coatings Technology, 174, 1151±1158. Maissel L I and Glang R (eds) (1970) Handbook of Thin Film Technology, McGraw-Hill, New York. Maruccio G, Cingolani R and Rinaldi R (2004) Projecting the nanoworld: concepts, results and perspectives of molecular electronics, J. Mater. Chem., 14, 542±554. Netzer L and Sagiv J (1983) A new approach to construction of artificial monolayer assemblies, J. Amer. Chem. Soc., 105, 674±675. Netzer L, Iscovici, R and Sagiv, J (1983) Adsorbed monolayers versus LangmuirBlodgett monolayers ± why and how? I: from monolayer to multilayer, by adsorption, Thin Solid Films, 99, 235±241. Nicklow R M, Pomerantz M and Segmhller A (1981) Neutron diffraction from small numbers of Langmuir-Blodgett monolayers of manganese stearate, Phys. Rev. B, 23, 1081±1087. Park J H, Kang C H, Kim Y J, Lee Y S and Choi J S (2004) Characteristics of pentacenebased thin-film transistors, Mat. Sci. Eng. C, 24, 27±29. Paul K E, Wong W S, Ready S E and Street R A (2003) Additive jet printing of polymer thin-film transistors, Appl. Phys. Lett., 83, 2070±2072. Pearson C, Nagel J and Petty M C (2001) Metal ion sensing using ultrathin organic films prepared by the layer-by-layer adsorption technique, J. Phys. D: Appl. Phys., 34, 285±291. PercËin G and Khuri-Yakub B T (2002) Micromachined droplet ejector arrays for controlled ink-jet printing and deposition, Rev. Sci. Inst., 73, 2193±2196. Peterson I R and Russell G J (1984) An electron diffraction study of x-tricosenoic acid, Philos. Mag. A, 49, 463±473. Peterson I R, Russell G J, Earls J D and Girling I R (1988) Surface pressure dependence of molecular tilt in Langmuir-Blodgett films of 22-tricosenoic acid, Thin Solid Films, 161, 325±331. Petty M C (1996) An Introduction to Langmuir-Blodgett Films, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. Petty M C (2000) in Functional Organic and Polymeric Materials, ed. T. H. Richardson, Wiley, Chichester. Petty M C, Bryce M R and Bloor D (eds) (1995) An Introduction to Molecular Electronics, Edward Arnold, London. Piner R D, Zhu J, Xu F, Hong S and Mirkin C A (1999) `Dip-pen' nanolithography, Science, 283, 661±663. Rees I D, Robinson K L, Holmes A B, Towns C R and O'Dell R (2002) Recent developments in light-emitting polymers, MRS Bulletin, 27, 451±455. Richardson T H (ed.) (2000) Functional Organic and Polymeric Materials, Wiley, Chichester. Salih A J, Marshall J M and Maud J M (1997) High-mobility low-threshold pentacene thin-film transistors prepared at rapid growth rates by pulsed-laser deposition, Phil. Mag. Letts., 75, 169±177. Sazaki G, Fujino T, Sadowski J T, Usami N, Ujihara T, Fujiwara K, Takahashi Y, Matsubara E, Sakurai T and Nakajima K (2004) Epitaxial relation and island growth of perylene-3,4,9,10-tetracarboxylic dianhydride (PTCDA) thin film crystals on a hydrogen-terminated Si(111) substrate, J. Crystal Growth, 262, 196±201.
82
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
Sherman A (1987) Chemical Vapour Deposition for Microelectronics, Noyes Publications, Park Ridge. Sirringhaus H, Kawase T and Friend R H (2001) High-resolution ink-jet printing of allpolymer transistor circuits, MRS Bulletin, 26, 539±543. Sirringhaus H and Shimoda T (2003) Inkjet printing of functional materials, MRS Bulletin, 28, 802±803. Speakman S P, Rozenberg G G, Clay K J, Milne W I, Ille A, Gardner I A, Bresler E and Steinke J H G (2001) High performance organic semiconducting thin films: ink jet printed polythiophene [rr-P3HT], Organic Electronics, 2, 65±73. Stockton W B and Rubner M F (1997) Molecular-level processing of conjugated polymers. 4. Layer-by-layer manipulation of polyaniline via hydrogen-bonding interactions, Macromolecules, 30, 2717±2725. Thomas P J, Kulkarni G U and Rao C N R (2004) Dip-pen lithography using aqueous metal nanocrystal dispersions, J. Mater. Chem., 14, 625±628. Tour J M (2003) Molecular Electronics, World Scientific, New Jersey. Tredgold R H (1994) Order in Thin Organic Films, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. Ulman A (1991) An Introduction to Organic Thin Films, Academic Press, San Diego. Ulman A (ed.) (1994) Characterization of Organic Thin Films, Butterworth-Heinemann, Boston. Xia C, Fan X W, Park M K and Advincula R C (2001) Ultrathin film deposition of polythiophene conjugated networks through a polymer precursor route, Langmuir, 17, 7893±7898. Yasuda H (1985) Plasma Polymerization, Academic Press, New York.
4
Membranes and permeable films
N A H O E N I C H , University of Newcastle upon Tyne, UK and D M A L I K , Loughborough University, UK
4.1
Introduction
Membranes and thin films represent a barrier between bulk phases which permit selective mass and fluid transport by one or more driving forces, e.g., concentration gradient, pressure difference or electrical potential. Membranes and thin films may be manufactured from a variety of materials and employed in a wide range of applications such as membrane bioreactors for the production of biopharmaceuticals including macromolecular products from fermentation and cell culture, protein recovery and concentration as well as use in clinical settings for treatment of disease or as part of analytical devices, e.g., biosensors. For a number of years, membranes were considered as inert phase separators, however, when used in a clinical context this approach is no longer appropriate as the membrane materials interact with biological fluids. The purpose of this chapter is to provide an overview of membranes and thin film materials and to discuss their manufacture, application and functional performance including biocompatibility.
4.2
Materials and applications
4.2.1 Materials Within the human body, the plasma membrane (Fig. 4.1) regulates the movement of substances into and out of the cell. In order for species to survive, a constant influx and efflux of materials in and out of the cell occurs. There are a number of mechanisms by which substances cross cell membranes: passive diffusion through the lipid matrix, diffusion through protein channels, and active transport. In membrane separation processes these functions are replicated but in a much less sophisticated form. It is potentially possible to manufacture membranes and thin films from a variety of precursor materials including synthetic organic polymers, natural polymer materials such as cellulose, ceramic materials or metals (Fig. 4.2). The manufacturing process for membranes and thin films is varied. The method used will be determined by
84
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
4.1 The structure of plasma membrane. (a) shows the basic arrangement of the lipid bilayer, and (b) a simplified model of the membrane protein arrangement. From Human Physiology The Basis of Medicine by Gillian Pocock, and Christopher D Richards (1999) reproduced by permission of Oxford University Press.
4.2 View of a 0.2 m ANOPORETM inorganic membrane showing 0.23 m latex microspheres retained on the membrane's surface. Membrane thickness approximately 60 m. Illustration courtesy of Whatman Plc.
Membranes and permeable films
85
the format of the membrane, (sheet, tubular or hollow fibre) as well as its application. For example, the manufacture of membranes based on cellulose is by a regeneration process involving a solution of purified cellulose in sodium hydroxide (Visking Process) or by the solubilisation of cellulose in an ammonia solution of cupric oxide (Cuprammonium process). These methods produce membranes that are essentially a macroscopically homogeneous material that is hydrophilic and forms a hydrogel when in contact with liquid. Modified cellulose membranes are a subset of membranes based on cellulose in which modifications aimed at the reduction of the number of hydroxyl (OH) groups in the polymer with other less reactive materials. Substitutions used include acetyl groups (to produce cellulose acetate) N,N, diethylaminoethyl (DEAE) the replacement of the benzyl groups by ether groups or by the grafting of polyethyleglycol (PEG) to the membrane to form a hydrogel on the material's surface. The most recent development of modified cellulose membranes has been the coating of the membrane with Vitamin E, (d-tocopetherol) aimed at reducing the oxidative stress produced during extracorporeal circulatory procedures. Membranes manufactured from synthetic polymers tend to be hydrophobic and require blending with hydrophilic agents generally polyvinylpyrrolidone (PVP). Membranes based on synthetic materials are more porous than their cellulose counterpart, and differ significantly in their structure from cellulosebased materials. The overall structure of the synthetic membranes is dependent upon the manufacturing process and the ratio of the blended polymers. Several different techniques of manufacture exist: sintering, in which the porous structure is derived from treatment of granular material at a high temperature and pressure, stretching, in which the structure of an extruded film made from a crystalline material is modified, etching, whereby the film is exposed to highenergy particles produced by a radiation source and phase inversion. In phase inversion, the polymer is transformed in a controlled manner from a liquid to a solid state. Phase inversion covers a range of different techniques including immersion precipitation and can be used to produce either sheet, tubular or hollow fibre membranes, the latter being produced by the use of a spinnerette as opposed to a flat casting knife. The polymer solution, containing the base polymer plus a solvent and/or other additives such as a second polymer, is pumped through a spinerette under pressure, the extruded fibre then passes through a series of baths where coagulation and structure formation occurs. Both cellulose based membranes and membranes based on synthetic polymers, such as polysulfone, polyarylethersulfones and polyethersulfones, and polyamide are used widely in clinical and industrial applications. In contrast to cellulose membranes which may be considered as a simple hydrogel, the molecular transport in synthetic membranes occurs within the thin surface layer (the skin), whilst the substructure acts as a mechanical support. It is important to bear in mind that whilst the same polymer base might be used, the
Membrane type and pore radius
Symmetric microporous, 100±10,000 nm
Asymmetric microporous, 1±10 nm
Asymmetric skin-type, 0.5±1.5 nm
Cation and anion exchange membrane
Asymmetric homogeneous polymer
Asymmetric homogeneous polymer (A non-porous membrane)
Thin-film membranes
Process
Microfiltration
Ultrafiltration
Reverse osmosis
Electrodialysis
Gas separation
Pervaporation
Nanofiltration
Cellulose acetate and aromatic polyamide
Polyacrylonitrile, polymers
Polymers and copolymers
Sulfonated cross-linked polystyrene
Polymers, cellulosic acetate, aromatic polyamide
Polysulfone, polypropylene, nylon, PTFE, PVC, acrylic copolymer
Cellulose nitrate or acetate, polyvinylidene difluoride (PVDF), polyamides, polysulfone, PTFE, metal oxides
Membrane material
930±1590 kPa
Vapour pressure gradient
Hydrostatic pressure and concentration gradients
Electrical potential gradient
Hydrostatic pressure difference at approx. 2±10 mPa
Hydrostatic pressure difference at approx. 0.1±1.0 mPa
Hydrostatic pressure difference at approx. 10±500 kPa
Process driving force
Removal of hardness and desalting
Separation of azeotropic mixtures
Separation of gas mixtures
Desalting of ionic solutions
Separation of salts and microsolutes from solutions
Separation of macromolecular solutions
Sterile filtration, clarification
Applications
Table 4.1 The characteristics of membranes used in different membrane separation processes, process driving forces and applications of such processes
Membranes and permeable films
87
manufacturing process will influence the structural morphology of the finished product which in turn will influence the material's functional and blood contact behaviour causing membranes based on the same polymer from different manufacturers to behave in quite different ways.1
4.2.2 Applications Membranes and thin films are produced in three basic configurations: sheet, tube and hollow fibre and are additionally used as encapsulation materials, e.g., encapsulating microspheres for use in controlled release drug delivery. The scale of applications range from laboratory, to industrial (Table 4.1). In addition membranes are also used extensively in clinical applications (Table 4.2). In this area the most widely used application is for the treatment of acute and chronic renal failure by haemodialysis, a diffusion based system in which metabolites elevated as a consequence of renal insufficiency are removed across a semi-permeable membrane contained in an artificial kidney or haemodialyser. The diffusion takes place in an electrolyte solution flowing on the outer side of the membrane. Haemodialysis favours the removal of smaller molecular weight solutes and for a number of years the traditional approach to assessing performance has been in terms of urea removal. A number of complications in patients with renal failure treated by haemodialysis may be ascribed to inadequate removal of `middle' molecules.2 This has led to the development of alternative treatment modalities in which species of molecules are transported across the membrane by either convection alone or by a Table 4.2 Medical devices utilising synthetic polymer membranes (adapted from Scott, K. 1995, Handbook of industrial membranes, 1st edition. Elsevier Science Publishers, Ltd) Environment
Device
Permeable solute
Ex vivo
Oxygenator Haemodialyser Haemofilter Plasma separator Plasma fractionator
o
O2, CO2 Small molecules, ions, middle molecules, H2O Plasma Plasma proteins
In vivo
Contact lens Biosensor Bioreactor Drug delivery systems Wound dressing Artificial grafts
o
O2 Biologically active molecules Pharmaceuticals O2, H2O Physiological solution, cells
In vitro
Blood filter Plasma separator Substrate for cell culture
Blood except WBC Plasma Physiological solution
88
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
mixture of convection and diffusion. Separation occurs on the basis of relative size of the permeating species.3 The ability of such techniques to remove protein bound substances remains limited and for removal of such compounds alternative approaches must be used.4 Membranes can also be used in plasma separation or plasmapheresis. In plasmapheresis mediators of the disorder are removed by the filtration of blood against a membrane which retains the cellular elements of blood but removes the plasma component. The removed plasma component is then either treated or replaced by a mixture of fresh frozen plasma and electrolyte solution, infused to replace that removed. A variant of this approach is plasma fractionation in which, rather than replacing the plasma, the patient's own plasma undergoes further filtration to retain blood coagulation factors and immunoglobulins. Such techniques may also be used for the removal of low density lipoproteins.5 Membrane based devices also provide support during cardiac surgery in the form of extracorporeal blood oxygenators where gas transfer takes place into the patient's blood across a permselective porous membrane.6 Other clinical applications of membranes and thin films include the treatment of diabetes by the use of an artificial pancreas, whereby islets of Langherans are sandwiched between membrane sheets or grown inside fibres, thereby providing a degree of immuno-protection and at the same time permitting the transport of key components into the bloodstream that flows on the outer side of the membranes. Such an approach is also used in the treatment of acute renal failure utilising tubular cells deposited on a membrane matrix.7,8 The laboratory based applications of membranes and thin films focus on the separation of biomolecules or the viral reduction of blood products. As well as systems suited for handling large volumes of liquid solutions, samples of up to 500 microlitres for micro-purification of proteins, antibodies and nucleic acids may be achieved by the use of small micro-concentrator modules which can be placed into a centrifuge and spun. The centrifugal force generates forces the filtrate across the membrane and concentrates the sample. Membrane separation in the laboratory may utilise a feed stream which is forced through the membrane and collected. An example of `dead end filtration' is the disposable syringe end filters that utilise membranes bonded to a sealed plastic support plate. The fluid to be filtered is contained in the syringe and is manually driven through the filter and collected. Stirred cells are also examples of `dead end filtration'. In such devices a flat sheet of membrane is placed on an appropriate support structure and spacer that forms part of the cell assembly. The fluid is added and agitated by a magnetic stirrer. The cell is pressurised either by air or nitrogen and the filtrate is forced through the membrane. Alternatively a cross flow configuration may be used to facilitate molecular removal from a solute.
Membranes and permeable films
89
Cross-flow systems are inherently more complex, but their use is associated with high rates of mass transfer, due to high shear rate or tangential velocity as well as turbulence adjacent to the membrane, both of which minimise membrane fouling. In cross-flow filtration modules, which may be hollow fibre or parallel plate design, the feed flow is parallel to the membrane and perpendicular to the filtrate flow. In both these modalities the solvent and solutes smaller than the pore size of the membrane pass through the membrane to form the permeate. Cross-flow systems can deal with a molecular weight range of 500 to 1,000,000 daltons or approximately 10 to 100 Angstroms and is suitable for concentrating or washing macromolecules such as proteins, peptides, polysaccharides, lipids, synthetic polymers, viruses and colloids or the concentration of diluted samples of nucleic acid. Thin films are generally used for coating purposes, for example, to facilitate controlled drug delivery. In such an approach, a polymeric membrane encapsulates the drug which is carried in the form of a saturated aqueous solution containing undissolved particles of the drug to maintain saturation. A variant of this concept is the use of a matrix device, which is analogous to a sponge. The polymer matrix is initially loaded with a drug saturated solution, maintained by drug particles as before. When such a device is implanted, the drug molecules diffuse across the polymer tissue interface and a drug depleted layer forms on the matrix side of the interface. As diffusion continues, this layer increases whilst the surrounding tissue concentration remains constant due to the washing effect of the body fluids in contact with the matrix.
4.3
Membrane characterisation
4.3.1 Physical structure A number of different approaches to membrane classification based on structure exist. Techniques related to permeation parameters (such as liquid and gas flux measurements, solute retention test, and perm porometry) characterise the thin layer in asymmetric membranes but they fail to provide insight into the underlying membrane structure. Morphology-related techniques (such as gas adsorption-desorption, atomic force microscopy, electron microscopy, mercury porosimetry, thermoporometry, and X-ray scattering) give more complete information on the porous structure. Atomic force microscopy (AFM), allows the surface study of nonconducting materials with resolution in the micrometre to subnanometre range, and is able to be used without special sample preparation. In addition to imaging, the technique can also be applied to investigate membrane electrical and mechanical properties, and adhesiveness.
90
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
4.3.2 Transport processes A membrane interposed between two bulk phases or mixtures control the exchange of mass between them. The exchange process can be driven by different forces: a concentration difference across the membrane (dialysis), a pressure difference over the membrane (ultrafiltration, reverse osmosis) or by an (externally) applied electrical field (electrodialysis). If the membrane is impervious to molecular species then fluid alone may be transferred. The separation characteristics of membranes are often expressed in terms of their nominal molecular weight cutoff (NMWC) determined experimentally by measurement of the trans membrane transport of molecules with different sizes or with a range of solutes. The NMWC value is defined as equal to the molecular weight at which >90% is rejected. In cell membranes, transport across the membrane occurs as a consequence of passive transport driven by the kinetic energy of the molecules being transported or by membrane transporters. Thus a molecule or ion that crosses the membrane by moving down a concentration or electrochemical gradient and without expenditure of metabolic energy is transported passively (diffusion). For charged molecules, the electrical potential across the membrane also becomes critically important. Together, gradients in concentration and electric potential across the cell membrane govern passive transport mechanisms. In cell membranes, active transport also takes place, this being the movement of molecular against an electrochemical gradient which requires energy expenditure. In membranes used for membrane separation processes, the volume flux produced may be expressed from consideration of the hydraulic resistance of the membrane used and the pressure drop over the membrane. In general the inverse of the resistance, hydraulic permeability being used. The permeability is defined by the pore size and structure and thickness of the membrane. Membranes can have different structures, they may consist of different, more or less cylindrical pores or may be composed of a packed bed of various small particles (which are of the order of nanometres). If the membrane consists of pores, they are often cylindrical and straight. The permeability of such pores is usually described by the Hagen-Poiseuille equation for flow through cylindrical tubes. If the membrane consists of a packed bed of particles, the specific permeability is derived from the Carman-Kozeny equation. Usually the pressure difference is applied externally to achieve filtration. During this process, solutes are separated from the solvent. These solutes accumulate near the membrane interface. The concentrations of these solutes are thus higher at the feed side than at the permeate side. This causes an osmotic pressure difference that reduces the effective pressure difference across the membrane. The simultaneous presence of both concentration and pressure driving forces across the membrane results in a mixed diffusive convective transport process.
Membranes and permeable films
91
When both these forces are significant, both must be accounted for as well as their interactions. Irreversible thermodynamics provides a framework for the analysis of these complex interactions originally in the form of Kedem Katchalsky equations. More recently a modification of this approach was described by Kargol and Kargol9 who derived mechanistic equations based on the classical approach. These equations have the form: JV LP P ÿ LP and P P JS !D ÿ
1 ÿ CL and represent both the volumetric (V) and solute (S) fluxes. These equations encompass four different processes; filtration, (LP P) osmosis, (LP ) solute P P) and where Lp; and diffusion (!D) and solute convection (
1 ÿ CL ! are coefficients of filtration, reflection or rejection and permeation, is the average concentration in membrane pores. respectively, and C If fluid alone is being transported across the membrane, then the first of the above equations will apply. The volume flux generated as a consequence of ultrafiltration can also be expressed in terms of concentrations by: CW ÿ CP J K log n CB ÿ CP where CW , CP , and CB are the concentration of solute at the membrane interface, in the permeate stream and in the bulk respectively, and K is the mass transfer coefficient in the boundary layer. The degree of separation of a solute from the solution is expressed in a rejection coefficient, which is defined as: 1ÿ
CP CW
The rejection coefficient is dependent upon the molecular species, and its size relative to the pore of the membrane. Membranes are unable to discriminate between macromolecules that have sizes similar to one another, and for this reason membrane separation processes are unsuitable for the separation of soluble molecules whose molecular weight or effective sizes in solution (Stokes radii) differ by less than a factor of 6. When filtering low concentrations of macromolecular solutions by ultrafiltration, their osmotic pressures are low compared to the applied pressure and can be neglected. The osmotic pressure exerted by such a solution is generally in the form: AC A1 C 2 A2 C 3 where A, A1 and A2 are osmotic virial constants and C is the concentration of the bulk macromolecular solution. The coefficient A describes Van't Hoff's limiting
92
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
law for the osmotic pressure which is applicable at very dilute concentrations, whilst A1 can be expressed in terms of the solute molecular weight. Ion transport is important in both biological and biotechnological applications. Ion transport across the membrane will be influenced by charge on the surface of the membrane (zeta or streaming potential) and the manner in which the ions are transported across the membrane. Transport across uncharged membranes may be characterised by consideration of the movement induced by the electrical field, diffusion and bulk convection. The movement resulting from each of these forces may not be in the same direction. The analysis of ion transport across charged membranes is more complex as the charge distribution on the membrane affects the concentration and potential distributions.
4.4
Blood material contact
Membranes and thin films used in therapeutic processes involve their repeated contact with biological fluids such as blood. For example, the treatment of renal failure by dialysis is generally undertaken three times weekly and each treatment session lasts 3±5 hours. Membranes have traditionally been considered as inert barriers, however, it is increasingly recognised that interactions occur between the material and blood components (Fig. 4.3). Thus, in therapeutic treatments
4.3 Biological pathway activation following contact with a material.
Membranes and permeable films
93
this aspect of membrane performance becomes important. A primary requirement, therefore, of any such material is that the material should be biocompatible. The classical definition of biocompatibility is: `the ability of a material to perform with an appropriate response in a specific application'. This historic definition was based on the principle that a biomaterial has to perform and not simply exist, that it has to be associated with appropriate responses to ensure satisfactory performance. This definition recognises the fact that the response to a material will vary from one situation to another and that the appropriateness may vary. Furthermore, the definition allows a distinction to be made between biocompatibility and biological safety. The main difficulty with this definition is that the applications of materials in the clinical setting are varied, and there may be little commonality with the appropriateness of the responses. To account for this, the original definition has recently been revised such that the biocompatibility of a medical device that is repeatedly in contact with blood may be considered as `the ability of the device to carry out its intended function within flowing blood, with minimal interaction between device and blood that adversely affects device performance, and without inducing uncontrolled activation of cellular or plasma protein cascades'.
4.5
Biological events at the membrane and thin film blood interface
The magnitude of biological interactions is governed by the material's surface rather than its bulk characteristics, i.e., molecular interactions. Parameters of importance include hydrophobicity, which may be calculated using contact angle measurements, the presence of specific chemical groups (X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy and IR-spectroscopy), surface roughness (optical profiles and scanning probe microscopy) as well as the flow conditions at the time of the interaction.10 The underlying disease condition and drugs administered, may also play a role. A number of the responses that occur are in part a consequence of the blood recognising the material as non-self, and in part a consequence of the interaction between the material and cell surfaces. In addition cellular components of blood may also be involved, such as the activation of platelets with subsequent generation of thromboxane, the release of leucocyte proteinase enzymes and the generation of cytokines and reactive oxygen species (ROS).
4.5.1 Protein deposition or adsorption There is a common belief in biomaterials research that cellular interactions with natural and artificial surfaces are mediated through adsorbed proteins. The initial event that takes place on blood material contact is the deposition of proteins onto
94
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
the surface.11 This deposition is rapid, occurring in a few milli-seconds and is governed by the interfacial properties of the proteins and the material surface. The importance of protein deposition stems from the fact that the deposited proteins exert a strong influence on subsequent cellular interactions with the surface. The process of protein adsorption comprises the following steps: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5.
transport towards the interface attachment at the interface eventual structural rearrangements in the adsorbed state detachment from the interface transport away from the interface.
The initial proteins deposited may be displaced by other proteins in the following sequence: albumin, immunoglobulins, fibrinogen, fibronectin, high molecular weight kininogen (HMWK) and Factor XII. This is termed as the Vroman effect. The adsorption of proteins may be considered to provide a degree of bioreactivity to the membrane or film surface. On the other hand, in the case of porous materials, such deposition inevitably modulates the diffusive characteristics of molecular species of interest. The adsorption of proteins mediates cellular adhesion to the adsorbed proteins. Primarily platelets are involved, and this sensitivity may be explained by the presence of receptors on the platelet surface (IIb/IIIa, Ib/IX) which facilitate such adhesion and are also involved in neutrophil activation. Many different techniques have been applied to study the molecular adsorption of proteins at interfaces. Several reviews have extensively discussed these techniques.12 The most commonly used techniques for protein adsorption kinetics studies include optical and spectroscopic techniques and electrical methods. Optical techniques include ellipsometry, variable angle reflectometry and surface plasmon resonance (SPR). Ellipsometry can be used with both transparent and non-transparent substrates whereas SPR must be used with a noble metal substrate.13 Spectroscopic techniques rely on the interaction of photons with the species present in the interfacial region to detect molecular events at the interface and include infra-red absorption (IR), Raman scattering, fluorescence emission circular dichroism (CD) and optical waveguide lightmode spectroscopy (OWLS). OWLS is a highly sensitive technique allowing real-time monitoring of protein-substrate interactions based on the measurement of the polarisability density (refractive index) in the vicinity of the waveguide surface. Since radioactive, fluorescent or other types of tagging are not required, measurements reflect the behaviour of unmodified proteins at the biomaterial interface. Other techniques include the use of radioactive isotope labelled proteins to quantitatively determine the extent of the protein adsorption or the spatial
Membranes and permeable films
95
distribution on the surface of the material. Scanning probe microscopy techniques such as AFM provide dynamic imaging of real-time protein adsorption or static imaging of the adsorbed proteins. More interestingly, quantitative measurements of the strength of molecular interactions between the protein and the biomaterial are now possible.14 Protein-biomaterial adhesion force is measured with an AFM using a protein modified probe tip to analyse the actual interaction forces between blood proteins and the biomaterial surface.15 Predicting quantitatively the adsorption of a given protein at a well characterised surface under specified solution conditions remains a challenge.
4.5.2 Activation of the coagulation system Activation of the coagulation system occurs as soon as the blood leaves the vessel, and comes into contact with a non-physiological surface. Minimisation of coagulation may be by the use of drugs with antiocoagulant properties such as Coumarin, Warfarin, glycosaminoglycans, heparin and heparan sulfate. Plasminogen activators may also be used for the control of coagulation. When a foreign surface comes into contact with blood, the preotein deposition onto the surface includes Factor XII which becomes activated (Factor XIIa) and initiates the clotting or coagulation cascade. Fibrinogen is also present on the surface causing the attachment of platelets. The surface aggregated platelets encourage more fibrinogen to fibrin conversion by the production of additional thrombin and thus providing a positive feedback loop up regulating the coagulation system. The thrombotic potential of a material may be most readily assessed in a static experiment in which it is compared with a reference material, usually silicone coated soft glass. The thrombotic potential of the surface is generally evaluted by the timing of the development of a clot. These measurements may be combined with the determination of hemolysis.16 This type of approach, however, does not take into account flow across the surface which may influence the rate of clot formation or red cell damage. In-vivo testing of new materials poses problems, and often an indication of the behaviour of the material may be elicited by the consideration of ex-vivo tests. In such tests, a small volume of blood drawn directly from an animal of volunteer is passed over or placed into contact with the material and is then collected and analysed; considerable deviations from true in-vivo tests may be observed. When considering the behaviour of membranes used in extracorporeal procedures such as haemodialysis, additional issues are present. All therapeutic procedures utilise an anticoagulant, heparin, although less commonly low molecular weight heparin may be used. The adequacy of heparinisation during the procedure is generally measured by clotting time measurement. Of these, the measurement of activated clotting time is the
96
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
simplest, however, it is only a broad non-specific indicator. A more accurate measure is the measurement of activated partial thromboplastin time (APTT). Heparin activity may be determined from the measurement of Factor Xa which is directly related to the amount of heparin present. Serial measurements provide an indicator of the loss of heparin due to adsorption or metabolism although in a clinical setting it is difficult to distinguish between these two. Commercially available kits are available for its determination. These measurements do not, however, provide any indication of the ability of the material to induce thrombus formation. A commonly used method for the measurement of this is by the measurement of thrombin antithrombin III complex.
4.5.3 Activation of the immune system The most thoroughly researched system activated following blood material contact has been the complement system. Activation of the human complement system following contact with a membrane or thin film is principally via the alternative pathway. It is initiated by the deposition of C3b on the material surface which with Factor B forms C3 and C5 convertases. These enzymes cleave the anaphylatoxins C3a and C5a from C3 and C5 by an autocatalytic process. Once in the circulation the C terminal arginine is removed and C3a des Arg and C5a des Arg are formed. These fractions are generally measured when membrane induced complement activation is studied. The cleavage of C5 by C5 convertase results not only in the production of C5a but also of C5b which initiates a macromolecular complex of proteins, the membrane attack complex, formed from C5b, C6, C7, C8, C9. (C5b-9). Complement products are an important mediator of the inflammatory response produced by membranes and are important markers for the biocompatibility of such materials. A wide range of clinical sequalae are associated with the generation of C3a, C5a and C5b-9 and virtually every blood cell type responds either directly via receptors, or indirectly via secondary mediators to these complement fractions. Implantation of devices in contact with blood may be associated with interactions between the implanted material and the host immune system. The aberrant state of monocyte and T-cell activation resulting from these host/device interactions is accompanied by two parallel processes, first, selective loss of Th1 cytokine producing CD4 T-cells through activation-induced cell death and secondly, unopposed activation of Th2 cytokine producing CD4 T-cells resulting in B-cell hyper-reactivity and dysregulated immunoglobulin synthesis through Th2 cytokines and heightened CD40 ligand-CD40 interactions. The net results of these events is that the patient develops progressive defects in cellular immunity and is at risk of infection, or allosensitisation.
Membranes and permeable films
97
In characterising complement activation by biomaterials, older publications dealing with complement activation refer to a less sensitive measure, total complement (CH50), to quantify activation. As discussed above, the primary event is the interaction of the C3 molecule with the material surface. This is followed by a complex series of cascade reactions during which C3a and C5a are released. Upon release into the circulation there is removal of the C-terminus arginine from C3a (C3a des Arg). Such modification abolishes anaphylotoxin activity but does not affect the platelet-stimulating activity of the peptide or release of serotonin.17 The circulating C3a des Arg levels may be measured by commercially produced ELISA kits, but currently no measurement of C5a des Arg is possible. Commercially produced ELISA assays are also available for the quantification of the membrane attack complex (C5b-9).
4.5.4 Cellular activation Leucocytes White blood cells are made up of neutrophils, eosinophils, basophils monocytes and lymphocytes. The principal functions of neutrophils and monocytes are their ability to recognise foreign material and in the body's response to infection. They are attracted to sites of inflammation and phagocytose foreign particles. Following phagocytosis, neutrophils degranulate. Macrophages share the ability of neutrophils to phagocytose foreign materials, but can ingest larger particles and deal with a greater number of particles. In therapeutic procedures such as haemodialysis, plasma separation and membrane oxygenation, following initial contact of the blood and foreign surface, a profound transient neutropaenia occurs. The neutrophils are known to aggregate in the lung vasculature, and it has been shown that the magnitude of neutropaenia is related to the degree of complement activation, however, the molecular mechanisms governing this feature of blood material contact remain incompletely elucidated. It is likely that the activation of neutrophils produced by C5a induces changes in the expression of leucocyte endothelial adhesion molecules as neutrophils have receptors for C3b, C5a, and integrins such as MAC 1 (CD11b/CD18) responsible for adhesion, the modulation of which leads to cell adhesion to the endothelium, and pulmonary sequestration. Measurement of such molecules may be by the use of ELISA kits or by the use of fluorescent antibody cell sorting (FACS) analysis. Neutrophil activation is also associated with superoxide production which can be measured following material contact. Granulocytes (polymorphonuclear neutrophils) release proteinases such as elastase, lactoferrin and myeloperoxidase which may be measured by ELISA kits.
98
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
Platelets Circulating platelets adhere to proteins deposited on the material surface. Changes in circulating platelet numbers may be elucidated by serial measurements. The deposition, however, is not only dependent upon the material but also on the flow conditions. The deposited platelets on the material surface release their granule content. Granules may be alpha or dense. Alpha granules contain platelet factor 4 (PF4) and B thromboglobulin (BTG) Both may be used as markers of activation, however, in a clinical setting other factors need to be considered, namely the clearance of PF4 from the circulation by endothelial binding. Heparin may also induce the release of PF4 from endothelial cells. Release is governed by the material surface as well as circulating factors such as thrombin and thromboxane A2. The dense granules contain ADP, ATP pyrophosphate and serotonin. Kits are available for the measurement of PF4 and BTG. The up-regulation of surface markers on platelets such as CD62 following material contact can be quantified by FACS. Platelet neutrophil interactions Platelet leucocyte co-aggregate formation has been implicated in the pathogenesis of thrombosis and inflammation, and observed during haemodialysis.18 Such interactions may be of relevance in both haemostasis and inflammatory processes. In haemodialysis, the increased formation of platelet leucocyte micro-co-aggregates is thought to be related to a primary platelet activating mechanism that involves P selectin (CD62P) a marker of activated platelets as well as CD15s (the sialyl-Lewis x molecule) a selectin ligand and it is possible that the CD62P/CD15s interaction seen during haemodialysis represents the first stage of leucocyte margination. Monocytes Monocytes are activated during blood membrane contact. C5a induces mRNA IL- and TNF transcription and primes the cells for the translation of cytokines following further stimulation. This further stimulation may be endotoxin entering the bloodstream from the dialysis fluid across the membrane, or by the direct contact of the monocytes with the membrane itself. Eosinophils Eosinophils have anti-histamine properties and congregate around sites of inflammation. Normal blood contains between 1±6% eosinophils, and elevated numbers are known to be present in people with allergic conditions such as hay fever. Eosinophilia is known to occur in haemodialysis patients; its presence has
Membranes and permeable films
99
been associated with allergy to dialysers and exaggerated activation of complement during HD. Its etiology, however, remains unknown. Erythrocytes Red cells are remarkably robust, however, mechanical damage may occur during extracorporeal circulatory processes arising from the blood pump or through rupture of the cell membrane by coming into contact with granular material. Lysis of red cells results in the release of ADP which is a potent mediator of platelet aggregation.
4.6
Improvement of biocompatibility
Improvement of the biocompatibility profile of a membrane material is generally achieved by the alteration of its bulk characteristics by alteration of the manufacturing process or the use of polymer blends. Increased understanding of the molecular mechanisms involved is resulting in better understanding of the role of material related properties influencing the molecular mechanisms and forms the basis of the development of materials with minimal bioreactivity. Controlled chemical modification can lead to the development of predictable biocompatibility profiles. For example, hydrophilic domains on the material surface in polymer blends have a stimulatory part on the complement activation potential of the material, but play little part in determining the material's ability to activate platelets. On the other hand, hydrophobic domains show a reduced influence on the activation of the complement system, but stimulate platelet adhesion.19 Plasma modification of the membrane surface may be a useful way to improve the biocompatibility of polymer membranes by utilising high-energy electrons, ions, atoms, radicals and excited molecules produced by electric discharge. The plasma generates chemically reactive species from otherwise inert molecules (at relatively low temperatures) that may be deposited on the membrane surface (changing its chemical composition) thereby affecting its biocompatibility (Table 4.3).
4.7
Conclusion
Although membrane separation processes are widely used in many major industries a number of unresolved technical requirements remain. These include the availibity of pre-evaporation membranes for organic-organic separations, oxidation-resistant membranes for reverse osmosis and ultrafiltration foulingresistant membranes. Electrodialysis is an established membrane separation process for the desalination of brackish waters which has changed little in the last ten years. Membranes with better temperature stability and spacers with
100
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
Table 4.3 Biomedical applications of plasma modified polymer surfaces (adapted from Scott, K. 1995, Handbook of industrial membranes, 1st edition. Elsevier Science Publishers Ltd) Gases (or monomers)
Polymers
NH3 (or N2 and H2)
Polypropylene (PP) Poly (vinylchloride) (PVC) Polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) Polycarbonate (PC) Polyurethane (PU) Polymethylmethacrylate (PMMA)
Heparin bonding for improved blood compatibility
Hexamethyldisiloxane (HMDS) C2H4 + N2 Alllene + N2 + H2O
Poly (ethylene terephthalate) (PET) Silastic (SR) Polysulfone (PS)
Improved blood compatibility
C2H4, allene, styrene, acrylonitrile, C2F4, C2H3F, C2F3Cl, C2H3Cl
Polystyrene (PSt) SR
Improved tissue compatibility
C2H4, C2F3Cl styrene
SR
Improved tissue compatibility
C2H2 + N2 + H2O
PMMA
Modified contact lens wettability by proteins
improved flow distributions can produce incremental improvements in brackish water desalination systems. A number of novel technologies are also being developed, including magnetic separations, electrically driven systems and liquid membrane systems. In membranes used for clinical applications an ongoing focus is improvement of biocompatibility. New manufacturing techniques involving a more defined pore distribution have also been introduced.20 Tissue engineering offers a number of exciting opportunities for the treatment of a variety of medical conditions. The membranes and thin films provide an ideal artifical support structure for the development of bio-hybrid devices. Such devices are available for both kidney and liver support.21,22 Micro-encapsulation offers the potential to encapsulate the islets of Langherhans for the treatment of diabetes. Such encapsulation may also be used for affinity dialysis for the removal of HIV and toxic viral proteins from blood.23
4.8
References
1. Hoenich NA, Woffindin C, Brennan A, Cox PJ, Matthews JN, Goldfinch M (1996) A comparison of three brands of polysulfone membranes. J Am Soc Nephrol.; 7(6): 871±6.
Membranes and permeable films
101
2. Vanholder R, Smet RD, Glorieux G, Dhondt A (2003) Survival of hemodialysis patients and uremic toxin removal. Artif Organs.; 27(3): 218±23. 3. Colton CK (1987) Analysis of membrane processes for blood purification. Blood Purif.; 5(4): 202±51. 4. Sauer IM, Goetz M, Steffen I, Walter G, Kehr DC, Schwartlander R, Hwang YJ, Pascher A, Gerlach JC, Neuhaus P (2004) In vitro comparison of the molecular adsorbent recirculation system (MARS) and single-pass albumin dialysis (SPAD). Hepatology; 39(5): 1408±14. 5. Klingel R, Fassbender T, Fassbender C, Gohlen B (2003) From membrane differential filtration to lipid filtration: technological progress in low-density lipoprotein apheresis. Therap Apher Dial.; 7(3): 350±8. 6. Wickramasinghe SR, Goerke AR, Garcia JD, Han B (2003) Designing blood oxygenators. Ann N Y Acad Sci.; 984: 502±14. 7. Isayeva IS, Kasibhatla BT, Rosenthal KS, Kennedy JP (2003) Characterization and performance of membranes designed for macroencapsulation/implantation of pancreatic islet cells. Biomaterials.; 24(20): 3483±91. 8. Humes HD, Weitzel WF, Fissell WH (2004) Renal cell therapy in the treatment of patients with acute and chronic renal failure. Blood Purif.; 22(1): 60±72. 9. Kargol M, Kargol A (2003) Mechanistic equations for membrane substance transport and their identity with Kedem-Katchalsky equations. Biophys Chem.; 103(2): 117±27. 10. Spijker HT, Graaff R, Boonstra PW, Busscher HJ, van Oeveren W (2003) On the influence of flow conditions and wettability on blood material interactions. Biomaterials.; 24(26): 4717±27. 11. Ramsden JJ (1995) Puzzles and paradoxes in protein adsorption. Chemical Society Reviews; 24: 73±78. 12. Ramsden JJ (1994) Experimental methods for investigating protein adsorption kinetics at surfaces. Q Rev Biophys.; 27(1): 41±105. 13. Voros J, Ramsden JJ, Csucs G, Szendro I, De Paul SM, Textor M, Spencer ND (2002) Optical grating coupler biosensors, Biomaterials; 23: 3699±3710. 14. Kidoaki S, Matsuda T (2002) Mechanistic aspects of protein/material interactions probed by atomic force microscopy. Colloids and surfaces B.; 23: 153±163. 15. Kidoaki S, Matsuda T (1999) Adhesion forces of the blood plasma proteins on selfassembled monolayer surfaces of alkanethiolates with different functional groups measured by an atomic force microscope. Langmuir; 15: 7639±7646. 16. American Society for Testing Materials (1997) ASTM F 756-93. 17. Polley MJ, Nachman RL (1983) Human platelet activation by C3a and C3a des-arg. J Exp Med.; 158(2): 603±15. 18. Gawaz MP, Mujais SK, Schmidt B, Blumenstein M, Gurland HJ (1999) Plateletleukocyte aggregates during hemodialysis: effect of membrane type. Artif Organs.; 23(1): 29±36. 19. Deppisch R, Gohl H, Smeby L (1998) Microdomain structure of polymeric surfaces ± potential for improving blood treatment procedures. Nephrol Dial Transplant.; 13(6): 1354±9. 20. Ronco C, Bowry S (2001) Nanoscale modulation of the pore dimensions, size distribution and structure of a new polysulfone-based high-flux dialysis membrane. Int J Artif Organs.; 24(10): 726±35. 21. Humes HD, Weitzel WF, Fissell WH (2004) Renal cell therapy in the treatment of
102
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
patients with acute and chronic renal failure. Blood Purif.; 22(1): 60±72. 22. Patzer II JF, Lopez RC, Zhu Y, Wang ZF, Mazariegos GV, Fung JJ (2002) Bioartificial liver assist devices in support of patients with liver failure. Hepatobiliary Pancreat Dis Int.; 1(1): 18±25. 23. Tullis RH, Duffin RP, Zech M, Ambrus JL (2003) Affinity hemodialysis for antiviral therapy. II. Removal of HIV-1 viral proteins from cell culture supernatants and whole blood. Blood Purif.; 21(1): 58±63.
5
Stable use of biosensors at the sample interface J F G A R G I U L I , University of London, UK, A G I L L and G L I L L I E , University of Manchester, UK, M S C H O E N L E B E R , University of London, UK, J P E A R S O N , University of Manchester, UK, G K Y R I A K O U and P V A D G A M A , University of London, UK
5.1
Introduction
Biosensors provide a high degree of elegance in regard to their simple juxtaposition of a bioreagent and a transducer function. To work properly, there must be a direct alignment of a functionally responsive biolayer and a transducer element, which is able to directly extract the binding information resulting from the encounter with the analyte. There is a difficulty associated with such a simple, structurally inflexible combination, due to the fact that optimisation is limited as compared with say the use of a liquid phase bioreagent with its attendant optimised solution parameters of pH, pI, concentration and reagent additives. However, the net result is a solid-state monolithic structure with the potential to perform analyses and to operate potentially in optically opaque samples. In biomedicine, the latter capability holds considerable advantages. Indeed, most if not all biofluids contain colloidal materials that are liable to render the sample optically opaque or, at the very least, to induce a certain amount of light scattering. Furthermore, the majority of clinical sample assays rely on absorbance techniques. Therefore, it is necessary to have access to biosensors that would perform reliably even in opaque samples. Nonetheless, there are still a few drawbacks associated with the use of biosensors in vivo. Although the established biosensor systems operate on the `macro' scale and have seen varying degrees of clinical exploitation,1 a key reason for their limited introduction into the application domain has been the rapid alteration of the biosensor interface through the surface activity of the colloidal elements of any unmodified biological sample. This problem is also intricately linked to that of biocompatibility of the exposed surface of the biosensor in direct contact with either living tissues or the physiological fluids present in the body.
104
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
5.2
Biosensor limitations
5.2.1 Biosensors and bioresponse compromise Whilst the bulk amount of protein, colloid and cell transfer to a `clear' biosensor surface may be relatively low in amount, its diffusional barrier effect on the continued flux of analyte to a responsive biolayer surface will immediately be registered as a reduced biosensor response. The function of any flux dependent biosensor, unless it is merely a qualitative registering device, will be affected sufficiently that accuracy and precision of measurement will be lost, and neither may be recovered simply by recalibration. The devices therefore likely to be most affected will be those using degrading enzymes rather than where a true binding equilibrium is approached, e.g., antibody, lectins, receptors and DNA/RNA. In the case of the latter group, the only effect should be on the rate of approach to equilibrium not on its final value, unless of course the fouling biolayer affects solute partitioning. This is possible in principle if, say, the fouling layer is a charged colloid, and the analyte target is also charged; electrostatic forces are then liable to come into play to either partition in or partition out a given analyte. Exclusion, furthermore, is possible if the analyte target is a macromolecule, in which case it may have limited access to the affinity surface of the biosensor through the limited permeability of the colloid fouling layer. The underlying transducer of the biosensor, whilst not directly affected by surface colloidal deposits, may register the presence of these non-specific elements through its detection domain. Thus, the evanescent wave of an optical wave-guide or SPR system will respond equally to non-specific binding as to specific affinity interactions. Passivation of the transducer element is possible with some surface-active crystalloids. Thus free amino acids and thiol-containing molecules that are surface active can distort and depress the catalytic behaviour of a Pt working electrode used for redox dependent biosensors.
5.2.2 Biosensors and the selectivity compromise Whilst the biological component of a biosensor has accepted selective properties, and is de facto the driver for biosensor development, the underlying transducer, whether based on electrochemical, potentiometric, optical or microgravimetric principles, is vulnerable to a false positive response due to the surface activity of analogue species of either the target molecule or a molecule that is part of the transduction cascade. The most potent expression of the problem is where an electrically polarised noble metal electrode is used to detect the H2O2 product of an oxidase enzyme catalysed reaction in an enzyme electrode. At the typical polarising voltage of +0.65 V vs. Ag/AgCl, numerous species in biological solution are simultaneously oxidased, and false positive responses therefore result.2
Stable use of biosensors at the sample interface
105
5.2.3 Interfacial problems at microfabricated biosensors The issues of direct biosample interfacing of biosensors applies to all biosensors irrespective of length scale. So whilst the x-y plane architecture may be geometrically precise, formulated in a much more reproductive manner using MEMs and other microforming technologies, the biological response of the host sample reacts in rather similar ways, with adverse buildup along the z axis, i.e., normal to the sensor surface. One rider to this equivalence of macro/microsensor outcomes is where response is flux (continuous diffusion) dependent; a sufficiently small sensing microsurface will have spherical and not a planar diffusion based supply of analyte and is thereby less affected by external variables such as fouling. There is also evidence that a microstructure may set up a lower intensity tissue reaction thus leading to reduced surface fouling.
5.3
Biocompatibility
The term `biocompatibility' covers the whole range of interactions that exist between a biomaterial implant and its biological surroundings, as well as the orchestrated sequence of responses the body invokes to essentially reject that implant as non-self. In the case of invasive in vivo monitoring, an electrochemical biosensor requires intimate, direct contact with the sample matrix in order to function properly, notwithstanding the intensity of the body's reactive response to its constituent materials. As a consequence, the observed performance of the biosensor is highly vulnerable to the local accumulation of surface-active agents from the body such as cells, proteins and other less well identified constituents such as colloidal and lipid aggregates. This accumulation of biological compounds on the surface of the sensing device is known as `biofouling', and will with time alter and degrade the biosensor response and performance. Furthermore, biosensors are not bio-inert, not only because of the active redox components they may incorporate but also because of the polymeric materials, as well as the coated or uncoated metal and carbon electrode interfaces they present to the living tissues. In these tissues, they provoke a high intensity local inflammatory reaction simply because they inhabit a wound site and, in blood, they are a nidus for surface coagulation with the attendant threat of local microand later macro-thrombi. The danger of thrombus dissemination in the vasculature, thromboembolism, constitutes a particular concern because of the possibility of considerably wider distribution of tissue damage. There are many examples of implants leading to thrombosis, embolism and death. While the risk might be acceptable for a life-saving device such as a vascular stent, such risk cannot be tolerated when a diagnostic device such as a biosensor is being used. Even if an implanted material is reputed to have no interaction with a biomatrix and is therefore believed to be bio-inert, some interactions at a microscopic scale still occur. A completely biocompatible material does not
106
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
exist. As a consequence, all available materials provoke, to some extent, a biological response, adverse or not, that will impact on overall sensor performance. Indeed, even air entrapped within a tissue will ultimately provoke a local body reaction. Additional bio-effects, beyond local surface phenomena, that need to be taken into account when designing a biosensor for clinical use are carcinogenicity, mechanical stability, immunogenicity, chemical stability and biomechanical compatibility with the local soft tissue. Also, sensors may need to operate in vivo for quite different periods of time, and this must be taken into account when assessing the tolerance limit for biocompatibility. Admittedly, in contrast to the carefully assessed quantitative analytical behaviour of sensors in vitro, little progress has been made in regard to in vivo performance standards and acceptability. Also, the actual limits of tolerance for the degradation of function, resulting from the body's response, are still poorly understood and known. In vivo biocompatibility can be regarded as a hybrid between biomaterials and biosensor research, which deals with both the specific, as well as the complex interactive and cumulative effects of sample matrix constituents upon sensor function and operational life-time.3±5 For all sensors, understanding and predicting the in vivo biological response still poses a great, unmet, challenge. The crucial point is that, in contrast to conventional biomaterials, the surface deposition of the body's diffusive and cellular biocomponents leads to degradation of function, observed within minutes and hours rather than days and months. Whilst the device continues to function, its value as an accurate and precise quantitative system is lost. A hierarchy of biological interfacial phenomena exist, which, though subclassified relatively easily, are difficult to unravel in relation to their complex dynamics and as concerted interactive phenomena. For a long time researchers attempted to avoid the bioresponse entirely via the `mythical' concept of the totally bio-inert implant, leading later to the emergence of the idea of functional biocompatibility.6 In this latter case, a primary issue is not so much the total avoidance of the bioresponse, but rather achieving sufficient control over its adverse effects on the biosensor performance. The definition of biocompatibility is itself an approximation of multiple concepts. However, it is based on the expectation that certain types of materials will be able to provoke just a limited body response. No matter what the material deposited and accumulated at a sensor surface may be, it is whether or not a degradation of response occurs that really matters. The counterpart to this is whether an implant material poses a threat to the patient or not. Both immunological and toxicological dangers exist, for example, through the leaching of additives within covering polymers, the release of polymer degradation products, of metal/metal oxide particulates or of carbon electrode constituents. All are capable of triggering an early inflammatory and toxicological response, but the dangers of long-term effects, including
Stable use of biosensors at the sample interface
107
carcinogenicity are largely uncharted. Again such dangers may be acceptable in the instance of acute life-saving or life quality enhancing implants such as heart valves, aortic grafts and pacemakers, but in the case of a measurement modality such as glucose monitoring, any such dangers have to be negligible. A biosensor can be regarded as a composite material, usually made up of metallic, polymeric and biological components. While it constitutes a minor burden as an implant, as it exhibits trivial mass and volume in relation to the body, it is however more likely to present a multiple combination of potential leachables, which, together with the reaction products of the biosensing reaction, could have significant local effects. Underlining all this is the fact that any release of antigenic protein poses special dangers as an immunogenic trigger, especially if a biosensor is to be implanted repeatedly. The biocomponent (e.g. enzyme) may itself be associated with an undefined constituent due to the presence of low level impurities, as in any bioagent, rendering traceability difficult. A practical expression of this comes from the routine use of bovine serum albumin (BSA) as a crosslinking matrix for glucose oxidase in the early days of research.7 Due to actual and theoretical dangers of the bovine spongiform encephalitis (BSE) agent, such a protein source for enzyme immobilisation is no longer acceptable. In view of the heterogeneity of both sensor internal structure and of the multiple types of surfaces presented to the biomatrix, the body's response maybe quite different over the active sensing regions of the device vs. the support regions. This makes it difficult to determine a precise structure ± biocompatibility linkage.8 Materials considerations are also relevant to the duration of operation envisaged. Short-term monitoring in, say, the critically ill patient, demands quite a different level of materials requirement to the more robust, mechanically resistant devices that, moreover, would have to be well tolerated by the patient over the long term, especially during ambulatory monitoring. Polymer encapsulant degradation and metal corrosion set a limit to the long-term implantation of the sensor in the patient. Furthermore, not only are the body's responses cumulative but a rigid device, mechanically incompatible with local soft tissue, will not be well tolerated, due to the stimulation of local pain sensors. Over time these released constituents, due to the immune response, will be upregulated; so will be the effects of unavoidable products of enzyme reactions and redox centre/mediator components. Wherever a foreign body is lodged in the tissue or the blood compartment, it can also serve as a focus for infection and poses a problem over the long term. Microbial films may form on the surface and these have a powerful way of resisting antibiotic assault. Such films are known as significant contributors to hospital infection rates.9 The situation is compounded if a device is only partially inserted as with, say, a percutaneous glucose needle sensor. These are typically implanted in vascular, partly fatty tissue to only a 10±15 mm depth. Whilst less invasive, they provide a contact pathway for externally derived
108
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
microorganisms. Important in this regard is the fact that the skin surface has its own microbiological flora and cannot be fully sterilised. Diffusible, low molecular weight solutes in biological fluids provide a nominally stable solution environment in vivo, given that this internal environment is designed for physiological stability. Certainly, near-neutral pH conditions normally prevail, and the concentration variation of background electrolytes is relatively small, at least with regard to the major ions such as sodium, potassium and calcium. As an indicator of the total solutes, osmolality in blood ranges quite narrowly between 280±295 mOsm/kg. With the inherent stability of the enzyme within an electrochemical biosensor and its reduced dependence upon pH and background ionic changes due to the immobilisation, one would expect minimal background solute effects upon bioelectrochemical sensor function. However, even small variations will cause some analytical imprecision, especially as sample dilution or other specimen manipulation are precluded in contrast to bench top analysis. The above considerations have been a basis for the use of, say, sampling tissue ultra-filtrate for glucose monitoring via mechanical suction through permeabolised skin.10 However, low molecular weight solutes may still influence working electrode response through adsorption, passivation and then direct surface activity. Such effects may be difficult to identify when conducting measurements in a complex medium such as blood or tissue combining macroand microsolute influences. The former are only external surface active; the latter are able to permeate the entire device. The adsorbed solute can induce degradation of metallic components, as described for electrodes used in electrical stimulation, where increased ionic release and accelerated corrosion have been reported11 with a further facilitating influence due to surface active proteins.12 The electrochemical reaction can also contribute to electrode dissolution, which is of relevance to long-term implantation.13 Beyond standard cylindrical geometries and wire-type devices, emphasis is shifting to MEMs-based devices. However, some implantable sensors based on MEMs constructs are vulnerable to hydration and water ingress. As a consequence, rigorous packaging and encapsulation are needed for long-term function as well as over the short term. Typically, in order to avoid leakage currents and extraneous responses, inorganic or polymeric packaging materials are required.14,15
5.3.1 Protein constituents In terms of the total colloid biomass, proteins comprise the most important surface-active constituents of biofluids other than viable (and dead) cells. Total concentration in plasma is around 80 g/l. Proteins have a special ability to adsorb physically at solid/liquid interfaces and through consequent denaturation to form relatively adherent, immobilised phases, showing only partial remodelling or
Stable use of biosensors at the sample interface
109
recycling between the bulk sample and surface. The adsorbed proteins thus undergo both conformational and orientational changes at the surface. As well as progressively increasing in depth with time, through deposition of solution originated proteins, the entire protein `gel' layer grows unpredictably, modulated by both environmental perturbation (convective, shear, pressure) and inherent structural remodelling, especially evident near the growth surface.16 Again, the key issue is that in contrast to conventional biomaterials, surface deposition effects on a new electrode surface are rapid and accentuated. Whilst the device continues to function, its value as an accurate and precise quantitative system is almost immediately lost, a particular concern in the case of glucose monitoring given the strict control demanded in diabetes management. Protein deposition occurs within seconds of contact,17 but inherent film composition and individual component abundance are conditioned by material surface energy (hydropholicity/hydrophilicity), charge, charge density, surface profile and roughness, degree of molecular ordering, pendent group flexibility and crystallinity. In the case of a polymeric interface, the presence of trace components, plasticiser content and minor degrees of surface oxidation all drive particular types of protein adsorption. Albumin, in particular, is a dominant constituent at the interface, and outcompetes other proteins in plasma such as immunoglobulins, fibrinogen and kininogen. Its presence at a surface, furthermore, helps to reduce the deposition of other surface fouling components including cells, and it is regarded as a passivating protein. The dynamics of the adsorption, however, appears to be different at different surfaces. For example, on a hydrophobic surface, adsorption is a single-step process, whereas on a hydrophilic surface, it involves two steps. The resultant in either case, though, may be the formulation of an equivalent layer with similar passivating behaviour.18 This new view of protein deposition reduces the importance of the primary surface in driving biocompatibility outcomes. Ongoing competition between proteins for the surface leads to the remodelling of the deposited surface layer and, in the context of, say, fibrinogen adsorption from plasma, its transient surface prevalence and subsequent partial displacement (the Vroman effect) represents the outcome of the finite number of available sites on the surface.19 In previous studies, surfaces have been alkyl modified in order to promote albumin deposition, and therefore to reduce platelet adhesion.20 More recently, immobilisation of highly hydrophilic polymers such as poly(ethylene oxide) (PEO) has proved especially valuable in resisting protein deposition.21 The equivalent has also been achieved, for example, through glow discharge deposition using tetraethylene glycol dimethyl ether.22 More classically, heparin immobilised at surfaces has proved effective in resisting a special type of surface deposition, the binding and activation of coagulation components. In this respect, surface bound heparin has been used to good effect at an intravascular oxygen catheter sensor.23
110
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
Heparin works through its anionic sulphonate and aminosulphate groups,24 so attempts have been made to sulphonate artificial polymers, e.g., polystyrene and polyurethane.25 Also, the combined effect of PEO with end-attached sulphates to give heparin-like properties, and the added benefits of PEO flexibility has led to an improved thrombo-resistant polyurethane.26 Polyurethane is already frequently used as an outer membrane barrier for glucose sensors, so this may have a direct application when used in a bioelectrochemical sensor. The fundamental drawback of an enzyme-based biosensor is that it requires continuous substrate flux to the enzyme layer for an ongoing response. This flux has to be purely substrate concentration (gradient) dependent, unperturbed by any newly formed diffusion barrier in, on or around the biosensor itself. The first of the membrane-packaged devices developed to control such adventitious biolayer diffusion limitation was the Clark pO2 polarographic electrode where an external gas permeable membrane served to protect the working electrode from protein and colloid deposition.27 For surface anticoagulation, a primary need is for the prevention of the binding of factor XII, as this is a key trigger in the initiation of the coagulation cascade and eventual deposition of the crosslinked fibrin mat at the surface. An intrinsic pathway and an extrinsic coagulation pathway, the latter being induced by tissue-derived factors, may combine to create an accelerated cascade of fibrin deposition (Fig. 5.1). However, a parallel system of surface-active proteins has been rather neglected. This is the complement system, which undergoes an ordered, sequential response to an artificial surface, eventually to trigger the production and the release of flammatory mediators from white cells.27 This complement activation takes place through one of two pathways, the classical and the alternative. The classical complement pathway is initiated by antigen-antibody complexes, by crystals or bacterial and virus surfaces if antibodies are absent, or by complexes between positively and negatively charged molecules such as those between heparin and protamine. The alternative pathway is not triggered by immune/antibody complexes, but can be initiated by any foreign material introduced into the body, including a biomaterial, lipopolysaccaride, polysaccharide, or bioorganism. It is activated by surfaces with particular chemical characteristics allowing fragment C3b of a larger protein C3 at the surface to initiate the assembly of an amplification system, C3 convertase, at the surface28 for further C3b deposition (Fig. 5.2). With regard to specific sequences, C3 convertase cleaves C3 to generate C3a, and a further fragment C3b. In the nascent state, the latter binds to the surface and augments the convertase enzyme further to amplify C3b deposition on the surface. A further reaction leads to the cleavage of available C5, with the production of a C5a fragment and also recruitment of a C5±C9 sequence of effectors and associated inflammatory changes. It is clear that substantial complement activation can lead to major organ dysfunction, though admittedly
Stable use of biosensors at the sample interface
111
5.1 Surface coagulation cascade initiated either by surface contact (the intrinsic pathway) or by tissue factor (TF, the extrinsic pathway). The two pathways are eventually converting, forming a fibrin clot due to activation of thrombin on fibrinogen. Factor XIII will eventually convert fibrin clot into insoluble fibrin gel.
only following large scale blood/surface interactions as in haemodialysers.29 However, this complex cascade also requires to be considered as a possible contributor to local events at the biosensor surface. Surface amines and hydroxyls, in particular, react with C3 to form complexes, though there is uncertainty whether these are covalent bonds or whether electrostatic and hydrophobic interactions are important.30 Outcomes with regard to systemic effects also need to be unravelled.31 Local effects of relevance to a bioelectrochemical sensor might be abated through control of the surface presented, perhaps through surface heparinisation.32
5.3.2 Blood interfacing Blood consists of about 55% plasma by volume with about 45% solid particles including proteins and cellular elements, especially red blood cells, but with a
112
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
5.2 Surface induced complement activation leading to accelerated complement protein deposition at a surface expressing amino/hydroxyl groups. Side cascade generation of C5±C9 is also indicated.
small white blood cell and platelet volume contribution. Red blood cells contain mainly haemoglobin, carry oxygen to the peripheral tissues and normally do not leave the circulation. White blood cells, however, are able to leave the vascular system to move towards any active disease tissue focus from, say, that due to microorganisms intrusion through a foreign body. The induced tissue disruption is `sensed' very acutely, no matter how localised. Additionally, platelets operate as a natural blood containment system, typically by forming a mechanical microplug at a vascular injury site, eventually producing a defined clot to contain blood in the circulation. The cellular elements of blood play a complex, cooperative role in the maintenance of the surface coagulation process initiated by soluble coagulation factors (vide supra). However, the deposited protein layer from blood at the sensing surface changes the material interface considerably, and it is this layer over which the cellular elements then begin to accumulate. Initially, the most important of these are platelets, which normally circulate in the blood in an inactive state, but are also the most labile of all the formed elements and therefore the most difficult to evaluate in physiological studies. Once they come into contact with a foreign surface, they show strong adhesion. This spreading and aggregation behaviour, associated with the release of intra-platelet adenosine diphosphate (ADP), promotes secondary platelet aggregation and the creation of (adherent) thrombus. In the final analysis, the level of initial coagulation protein deposits at a surface are seen to correlate with platelet
Stable use of biosensors at the sample interface
113
surface activity and therefore, both condition the blood compatibility of a given material.33 Quite apart from any surface effects, platelets are exquisitely sensitive to shear force. Both the magnitude of shear and the overall blood flow profile near a surface, through influence on platelet transport, can completely override surface affinity interactions. Moreover, turbulent conditions and their associated high shear are particularly able to trigger platelet activity and augment surface delivery.34 The platelet delivery process is further accentuated by red cell interactions and local fluid entrainment around red cells, promoting surface collisions.35 The net negative charge on a platelet, due to surface sialic acid groups, is important to surface attachment. However, surface receptor interactions are also a powerful determinant, such as the receptor mediated attachment of platelets to fibrinogen. Following adhesion, platelets degranulate with the release of ADP. Then, a host of other bioactive components are able to promote further platelet activation and the eventual creation of an adherent micro-thrombus. Incorporation into the thrombus of the other cellular components of blood, including white cells and red cells (both influenced by blood flow and pressure gradients), leads to thrombus growth. As a consequence, local blood flow is distorted near the originally smooth surface, further stimulating the growth of thrombus and aggregation of blood components of all types. The effect on a sensing surface is the reduction of solute transport to that surface and the local consumption of oxygen/glucose, depending upon the metabolic state of the cellular aggregates, thereby inducing changes on the locally measured parameters. It becomes especially difficult to characterise material-induced artefactual influences upon a sensor, let alone to model them. Therefore, their subtraction from true responses in vivo becomes problematic, demanding at the very least a frequent in-vivo calibration regimen. It may be that, in the future, the quantity and nature of a surface coagulation phase can be measured using an independent technique. Impedance measurements promise in this regard to allow at least for baseline drift36 but, in reality, the end result at present is the highly unsatisfactory need to recalibrate frequently. The imposed structure of an intravascular electrode disrupts blood laminar flow patterns and can be an indirect cause of surface thrombus formation. Experience with thrombolic events and clinical use of intravascular catheters indicates a relationship between vessel cross-section diameter and catheter size.37 Complicating the assessment of protein deposition, coagulation/ complement activation and platelet retention,38,39 surface irregularity and surface microdepressions over a device may promote thrombus formation.40,41 A smooth surface is an advantage, but, probably, surface anticoagulation is a more effective basis for reducing thrombus formation. There is a clear lesson here for the combination design of smooth, haemodynamically acceptable glucose sensor surfaces and their surface modification.
114
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
Heparin is a natural anticoagulant in blood, and is the most frequently used bioactive surface ingredient used to reduce clotting. The protective action of heparin is based upon its stimulatory effect on antithrombin via an heparinantithrombin complex, though this may be countered by the fibrin interactions of thrombin.42 Surface heparinisation of membranes has allowed more reliable oxygen monitoring.43 Catheter heparinisation has also proved to be of general effectiveness.44 Covalent binding of heparin, though permanent, leads to a more rigid attachment which can reduce effectiveness so bridging groups are an advantage. Also, depending upon the required duration of sensor operation, heparin leaching from a porous membrane or other reservoir could lead to a more potent anticoagulation surface. Overall, heparin can play a major role in reducing the effects of coagulation, but it is not the complete solution to the problem hoped by some. Alternatives to heparin include low molecular weight anionic analogues and, in particular, poly(ethylene oxide) (PEO).45 Furthermore, the use of copolymer structures rather than surface attachment may provide a family of new blood-stable materials in the future.46
5.3.3 Tissue interfacing Subcutaneous tissue is a safer alternative to the intravascular siting of glucose sensors, avoiding the dangers of thromboembolism, as well as of rapid dissemination of infection. Problems of reliable monitoring, though different from those of blood, are nevertheless substantial. The implanted device, through its intrusion into a normal tissue architecture, is perceived by the body for what it is, a disruptive foreign body. As a response, the tissue sets up an intense (acute) inflammatory response designed to degrade, isolate and ultimately reject the foreign material.47 The outcome is locally distorted body fluid composition, i.e., modified functional physiology. As a consequence, no matter how reliable or biocompatible the sensor may be, measurements are thereby performed in an environment that is metabolically distorted and also appears to lose the rapid equilibrium relationship with the local blood and the capillary bed supply (Fig. 5.3). With a low-reactivity material, the acute inflammatory stage subsides to give way to tissue repair, which tends to generate a more vascular environment through capillary proliferation, as well as a matrix rich in fibroblasts. Capillary density in the vicinity of implanted electrodes has been shown to increase with a vascular density maximum at a 50 m distance from the sensor.48 However, measurement distortion was observed (sensor instability and slow response) and was thought to be due to local fluid increase. Whatever the mechanism, the distorted response was only marginally diminished for a tissue-implanted glucose sensor by using slow release of dexamethasone as an anti-inflammatory.49 Due to the presence of soluble bioactive agents, the tissue environment becomes highly hostile to the sensor. Local increases in hydrolase enzyme
Stable use of biosensors at the sample interface
115
5.3 Three general phases of tissue response at implanted electrodes showing various local reactive phases.
activity (acid phosphatase, alkaline phosphatase, aminopeptidase) have also been observed.50 In addition to enzymic hydrolytic action, the local infiltration of white cells (monocytes and macrophages) augments degradative action, not least through the release of free radicals including peroxide.51,52 The latter is a general part of any non-specific inflammatory tissue response, but has long-term consequences for the integrity of any polymeric component of a glucose sensor. In the intermediate phase of the tissue response, the metabolic activity of inflammatory cells53 leads to a general modification of local tissue metabolic profile, and there are some apparent interspecies differences in this,54 which would make it difficult to extrapolate into man. Much depends also upon the size of the sensor burden upon the local tissue. For example, on one larger scale model system where cellulose sponge was implanted subcutaneously,55 extreme lowering of wound oxygen was observed at five days, as well as sequential variation of pH and CO2. The above changes not only feed back into further tissue reactive responses, but also lead to further development of unpredictable `solution' environments for a sensor. Thus, oxygen and lactate have been suggested as regulators of the wound healing process. High levels of lactate accumulation in wounds may improve wound healing through better collagen deposition, though this is contrary to the requirement for a minimal fibrous tissue in order to achieve undistorted tissue glucose monitoring.56 Quite apart from any physical cell/colloid accumulation, tissue remodelling and local fluid volume change, local lymphatics and capillaries are bioreactive components of tissue. During the wound healing process, they are known to undergo fluctuations in size, fluid throughput and perivascular organisation,
116
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
inevitably impacting on fluid exchanges and solute filtration. These changes may also lead to capillary blood glucose supply variations and, therefore, unpredictable fluctuation in measured levels. Such physiological changes in blood flow were proposed as a reason for fluctuating patterns in oxygen response at a (cerebral) tissue implanted oxygen electrode developed by Clark et al.57 Non-traumatic implantation of a glucose sensor is not feasible currently, but clearly minimal trauma induction is a rational approach, and only truly achievable with a miniature device. Indeed, if dimensions can be made much smaller than those currently available, there would be major gains in reliability. However, as with conventional biomaterials, moving into an era of active control of the local tissue response through a local drug delivery strategy and device-incorporated bioactive agents may also change the outcomes. Thus, it is likely that implantable sensors will, in the future, use bioactive components for conventional implants. This would complement ongoing efforts aimed at the refinement of the bioelectrochemical transduction process itself.
5.4
Materials interfacing strategy
Direct biosample interfacing for a bioelectrochemical device is not feasible. Not only does glucose/O2 permeation into the device require better management in the absence of sample preparation, but also an interfacing material has to be provided to protect the internal components. As a consequence, selective encapsulation is mandatory. Therefore, specific investigation is required of membrane, interfacing and packaging parameters, inclusive of solute (e.g. glucose/oxygen) partitioning and transportation requirements.
5.4.1 Membranes for biosensor interfacing Polymers, rather than inorganic membranes, have been used from the start of biosensor technology to separate sample from the sensing components. As packaging and separation phases, they do offer some useful solutions to the interfacing of biosensors with complex sample matrices. This sub-area amounts to a materials sciences effort in the development of both low fouling and high selectivity barrier structures. Membranes may be classified according to their polymeric constituents (charged, neutral, amphiphilic), and their structural anisotropy. The most convenient and relevant for biosensors is the classification based upon available pore size. On the large scale, there are standard filters of 100 m pore diameter; microfiltration membranes of 1±10 m pore size are used to separate viruses and whole cells; ultrafiltration >10 nm membranes are used to discriminate macromolecules and colloids; reverse osmosis membranes of lower nominal pore size are able to resolve small organics and ions, though in reality these have no discrete pore architecture.
Stable use of biosensors at the sample interface
117
In the case of porous structures, pore size variation allows for aperture control, and therefore for control over solute access to and from the device. It is likely that commonly used polyurethane external membranes, for implantable (needle) biosensors, operate as glucose diffusion controlling phases through their inclusion of a defined bulk phase porosity;58 certainly the polymer itself is impermeable. As a consequence, membrane technology offers a generic, adaptive platform for the design of a presenting sensor surface. Almost invariably, polymer membranes are used, and variously optimised according to the transport needs of charged, neutral and amphiphilic constituents.59 However, a wide array of chemical and structural features determine eventual interactions, including charge, surface energy, topography and the presence of specific functional groups. Individual examples of improving compatibility include the use of diamond-like carbon (DLC) coatings,60 as non-plasticised, robust, noncrystalline amorphous layers. Here, controlled analyte transport through DLC thickness variation was achieved, with the degree of surface fouling modified through surface profile and surface energy changes. In another example, surfactant incorporation61 into polymeric phases reduced fouling through creation of a quasi-fluid interface with high surface molecular mobility giving a mimic to natural soft material surfaces. The most striking form of biomimicry has involved direct adaptation of natural cell lipid membrane motifs and molecular components. These were embodied in particular in the phosphorylcholine zwitterionic layers pioneered by Nakabayashi and Chapman respectively,62,63 and are modelled on the external surface of the cell plasma membrane. Though these are functionally relatively effective, with phosphorylcholine being the key component, mechanical stability, however, requires covalent attachment to polymeric materials, detracting from the original fluidity properties of the natural plasma membrane. Also, the need for solute (e.g. glucose) permeability limitation through the lipid construct precludes the use of a high phosphorylcholine content. The fabrication of membranes for biosensors encounters various problems, particularly so when it is reproducible and well-defined porosity that is required. The operational problem is due to the presentation of a porous morphology to the sample matrix and thereby due to the tendency to take up protein aggregates into the pores, leading to progressive blockage. Our understanding of the dynamics of the pore blockage in relation to pore size and geometry is developing64,65 but remains incomplete. Progress in this area would be achieved by the rigorous definition of the term `porosity', a parameter unfortunately dependent upon the method used to determine it.66 There is also the possibility of membrane voids permitting antibody/ signalling molecule access to the antigenic constituents in the device, notably the enzyme or any background inert protein (e.g. albumin) to immobilise the enzyme. Moreover, avoidance of any protein release from the sensor demands
118
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
robust chemical immobilisation, but even release of limited quantities of protein if they occur over extended time periods might lead to body sensitisation in susceptible patients. Paradoxically, release of soluble proteins into the body is more likely to be antigenic than that of larger protein aggregations made up of, say, crosslinked material. The membrane interface is thus an important safety feature for a bioelectrochemical sensor. Given the potential dangers of prions and the more classical hazards of viral particles, biocomponent origin, traceability and quality control will be as important to consider as the external membrane barrier in any implantable device.
5.4.2 Membrane property requirements Important surface properties to consider (Table 5.1) depend upon the biomatrix application. Whilst great emphasis was placed in the past on hydrophobicity and a negative charge, in order to nominally reduce the deposition of negatively charged cells and to avoid polar purchase sites for hydrophilic protein domain interactions, in practice, neither approach can be relied upon in most cases. Adverse surface interactions have proven rather more subtle. There is a strong possibility that membrane surface feature size and profile is important, and that an ideally `perfect', smooth surface would encounter minimum biofouling. Table 5.1 Key surface properties of polymeric membranes Chemistry Mobility Topography
Polar, charged, H-bonded, hydrophobic, ionisable Backbone, sidechain, plasticiser mobility Roughness (molecular, cellular), irregular/regular pattern porosity, pinholes
Also surface fluidity on the micron scale, analogous to cell membrane fluidity, may be a means of avoiding protein cell adsorption. Phosphorylcholine (PC), which has both positive and negative charges, is found on the external surface of red cells. It offers an elegant biomimetic solution in order to achieve low fouling.67,68 However, a comprehensive PC layer is likely to inhibit the transport of polar diffusible species and target macromolecules to the sensing element of a biosensor.
5.4.3 Conferred functional advantages of membranes Membrane and thin film technology may well in future make the difference between commercially viable and non-viable devices, viz. biochips. Thus, they confer a variety of benefits, which reduce the high level intrinsic specifications demanded of microfabricated biochips, so serving as a useful complementary
Stable use of biosensors at the sample interface
119
Table 5.2 Benefits offered to biosensors by use of membrane technologies Membrane technology Surface modification Aperture control Chemical `gate' Sample clean-up Interferent control In-vivo biocompatibility
# Without surface modifications biochips are vulnerable
technology (Table 5.2). Surface modification allows adaptation of the base materials used for biochip production. Aperture control through pore size management allows for reduction of analyte access to the device and therefore, without sample dilution, enables the device to operate at concentration ranges where the biocomponent binding would normally be saturated. Thus, at high concentrations, bioaffinity is zero order with respect to concentration and, in that case, the biosensor becomes of little use. If the membrane has surface-attached pendent groups, then solute transfer through its pores will be affected by solute/ wall interactions. The greater the interaction, the lower the transport. Such chemical `gating', whilst not often used, could resolve mixtures of similar solutes and so underpin resolution by biochip arrays. Sample clean-up may similarly be achieved. There are significant advantages resulting from allowing biosensor detection reactions to be fully partitioned from the sample itself. For interferent control, a homogeneous or reverse osmosis type membrane is generally used since, in that case, microsolutes need to be rejected.
5.5
Membrane systems used in biosensors
Considerable versatility and ingenuity is required to translate membrane fabrication techniques at the macro-scale to the microfabrication of biosensors. Our past work has emphasised the former and, in general, solvent casting of preformed polymers has been used to coat planar and needle-shaped electrodes. Such techniques could be utilised in order to lay down conventional thick films (Table 5.3) for biochip manufacture, but more attention needs to be paid to edge effects and the ambient solvent evaporation conditions encountered when forming microsurfaces. More amenable to microscale deposition is in-situ monomer electropolymerisation. Whilst a conducting surface is obligatory for such a coating process,
120
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials Table 5.3 Membrane materials usable for biosensors Membrane types PVC PVC-lipid PVC-surfactant Diamond-like carbon Cellulose acetate Polyurethane
Silane Sulphonated-PEES Polycarbonate Electropolymerised films Bi-layer lipid membranes
deposition can be highly controlled and solvent-related edge effects eliminated. Electropolymerised films, if conducting, can provide a further means of interrogating the biolayer if biolayer binding to a target is associated with charge related or conductivity behaviour modification of the film.
5.5.1 Thick membrane films at electrochemical sensors Microporous membranes Microporous membranes, based on polycarbonate through which linear track micron diameter pores have been etched, are in common use for particle separation. They are an ideal non-swelling structure for partial colloid and cell separation. In the context of biosensors, the pore size (and pore density) may be independently controlled. As a consequence, so is the aperture for driving down transport of a diffusible target solute into the biosensor. For example, in the case of oxidase-based biosensors, Substrate O2 ! product H2 O2
5:1
such as those for glucose and lactate monitoring, the low Michaelis constant (Km) is in this way extended beyond the upper concentration range of the fluid to be analysed, O2 demand is reduced and, as a consequence, an effective linear dynamic biosensor range may be engineered. The low permeability furthermore eliminates bulk convective flow influences, so that a sample viscosity and stirring independent system results.69 Microporous polycarbonate may be further modified with an outer coating of diamond-like carbon (an amorphous H, C alloy without a crystalline domain). The diamond-like carbon nanofilm has high haemocompatibility70 and, because it is deposited from a plasma source, exquisite control over coating thickness and therefore membrane aperture can be achieved. Silicones deposited on a microporous membrane71 also allow for controlled pore aperture but, because the silicone is O2 permeable and impermeable to organics, a larger aperture for O2 is afforded than, say, for a metabolite substrate such as glucose, pyruvate or oxalate. This allows oxidase-activated biosensors to be produced with extended linear responses, since the reaction (eqn 5.1) is then
Stable use of biosensors at the sample interface
121
even less oxygen demanding. Using silane films, variously produced from the crosslinking of di- or tri- halogen substituted silane monomers, also gives a better haemocompatibility than the base material. A planar microelectrode array utilising the oxidase route for measurement could, in principle, be covered with a single microporous membrane and variously coated with modifying films of silicone or diamond-like carbon. This would create a family of sensors with a wide spectrum of sensitivities (calibration slopes) and linear limits that would allow for multiple redundancy, statistical data acquisition, drift free measurement and higher data security. The challenge is for membrane coating techniques to be carried out on a length scale that matches biochip fabrication. Homogeneous membranes for transport control CuprophanÕ is a well-known and well-established regenerated cellulosic membrane used for medical haemodialysis. It is crystalloid-permeable, colloidrejecting, and non-toxic. As such, it has been used in many reports in the past as a covering barrier layer for enzyme-based biosensors. However, its permeability and selectivity cannot be readily altered. On the other hand, PVC is, at first examination, an unpromising material for selective separation or controlled dialytic transport; it is organic solute
5.4 Response to lactate of a lactate oxidase based sensor that has an outer membrane of PVC permeabilised with the surfactant Triton X-100. As the weight-percentage of surfactant decreases the effective linear response and dynamic range of the sensor is extended.
122
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
5.5 The cationic surfactant (MTAC) is incorporated into cellulose acetate (CA) as an outer membrane coating for pyruvate. As the surfactant content increased the effective response of the sensor also increased due to increased retention of co-factor within the proximity of the working electrode.
impermeable. However, it is an excellent support matrix for surfactant.72,73 Figure 5.4 shows the neutral surfactant Triton X-100 physically supported and entrapped in PVC at varying weight ratios and used as an outer barrier membrane for a lactate oxidase enzyme electrode. The lowering of surfactant content reduces an already remarkably high lactate ion permeability to optimise both biosensor sensitivity and the effective Km (linear range) of the integral oxidase of the biosensor. The addition of surfactants to a polymer membrane helps separate polymer chains in order to create voids for increased solute transport. In Fig. 5.5, cellulose acetate was mixed with a methyltrialkyl cationic quaternary ammonium ion surfactant (MTAC), which allowed better transport of anionic pyruvate across the resulting membrane. Importantly, the membrane cation was able to retain positively charged cofactors for the enzyme. As a consequence, only a relatively low drift was observed, even in cofactor-free sample. Porous membranes for lateral transport control The sandwich immunoassay format (antigen capture by antibody, identification via second labelled antibody) is an advantage for electrochemical detection of the binding event. It is necessary to separate attached second antibody from that which remains free in solution. However, in the case of the electrode being an integral part of the flow system, as is shown in Fig. 5.6 (using a system based on a silicon flow channel), the electrode element needs either to be subjacent to the capture antibody, or strategically placed further downstream. Transport of
Stable use of biosensors at the sample interface
123
5.6 Sandwich immunoassay format within silicon microchannels where the detector electrode is either positioned at or downstream of the immobilised capture antibody site.
reporter antibody in a single step in an open dipstick planar configuration is more difficult, but has the advantage of being pumpless (Fig. 5.7), through exploitation of capillarity. The support material for such transport can be a microporous membrane. However, when nitrocellulose is used, it strongly adsorbs the second antibody (here with an alkaline phosphatase label) and lateral transport is therefore prevented. Nevertheless, the problem can be overcome by preadsorption of a blocking protein (Fig. 5.8). Unfortunately, this strategy cannot be used with cationic nylon for example (Fig. 5.9). As a conclusion, membrane materials have the potential to accommodate fluid microflows and, with judicial choice of the carrier surface (as with surface fouling), the affinity of mobile macromolecules can be modified and their transport behaviour controlled.
5.5.2 Non-conducting electropolymerised films Electropolymerisation of ultrathin films on working electrode materials is a means of film coating that is used with equal facility for macro-scale and microscale electrodes. The basic electrode surface develops a protective layer analogous to that of films used for corrosion protection. One functional aim is to produce low molecular weight cut-off films in order to exhibit high H2O2
124
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
5.7 Open flow planar membrane format in which capture antibody is immobilised on solid phase support; sample and reporter antibody are applied from bulk solution.
Stable use of biosensors at the sample interface
125
5.8 Alkaline phosphatase labelled antibody transported laterally using albumin preblocking of the carrier surface.
selectivity, which is the primary product for biosensing of oxidase-catalysed reactions (eqn 5.1). Such films may also improve haemocompatibility, extend the linear range for the analyte of interest and help better understand the interactions between sample and biosensor surface. Polyphenolic films: biocompatibility and selectivity The electrooxidation of phenol in solution produces a half wave at about +0.65V vs. Ag/AgCl. No reduction wave can be observed on reversing the voltage sweep in cyclic voltammetry (Fig. 5.10). This is a strong evidence of a stable, inert film on the electrode surface, which accumulates on multiple sweeps until a limiting
5.9 Albumin blocking of nylon does not overcome strong antibody adsorption.
126
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
5.10 Electropolymerisation of phenol (10 mM in PBS pH 7.4) on Pt working electrode. Scan rate 50 mV/s. Following initial oxidative wave at +0.65 V vs. Ag/AgCl due to electrooxidation of monomeric phenol, polymerisation occurs such that Pt becomes insulated preventing further oxidation of phenol. The process is therefore self limiting.
5.11 Effect of polyphenol modification on selectivity profile of Pt.
Stable use of biosensors at the sample interface
127
insulating layer is formed, which precludes monophenol oxidation. This film layer provides an entirely different selectivity profile for the device (Fig. 5.11), which in particular is seen to be relatively accessible to H2O2, whilst largely eliminating transport of common blood interferents. Catechol, in this case, is not considered as a constituent of blood but as a potential end product of a redox indicator reaction cascade usable for monitoring dehydrogenase reactions.74,75 The haemocompatibility of a surface is usually improved by polyphenol. Although some drift is observed, the comparison with the bare electrode is still highly favourable (Fig. 5.12). These films may also offer some advantages not
5.12 (a) Susceptibility of bare Pt working electrode to whole blood exposure; (b) Stabilisation of Pt working electrode to whole blood exposure through polyphenol modification.
128
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
only for microfabricated structures used in blood but also in protein loaded solutions as they might be considered for proteomic arrays. Polyphenol variants Phenolics with more complex structures and pendent groups would be expected to modify the selectivity and biocompatibility performances. A range of these have been tested (Fig. 5.13). Of these, poly(rosolic acid) appeared to be the most stable (Fig. 5.14). There is further possible manipulation of the interface using different conditions. For example, polymerisation appears to be faster at higher potentials and the net charge requirement becomes lower. These are free radical propagated polymerisations following the initial phenol oxidation therefore forming efficiencies might be expected to be different. Higher solution pH gives more porous films and selectivity is due to a cumulative effect depending on deposition times. Consequently, individual films may be tailored or used in systematically varied biochip arrays.
5.13 Select ion of phenolic monomer s used during format ion of electropolymerised coatings on Pt working electrodes.
Stable use of biosensors at the sample interface
129
5.14 Selectivity of Pt modified with poly(rosolic acid) coating following exposure to whole blood.
Polyphenols with surfactant entrapment Polyphenols provide entrapment of `bystander' solutes, in solution, provided that these are of sufficiently high molecular weight. Surfactants are of interest, since not only are they sufficiently large to be physically entrapped in the films, but their solubilising effects and variable charge properties (Table 5.4) would help confer a modified function to the films, with possibly better haemocompatibility. Figure 5.15 suggests that fouling in blood may be reduced over time. In all instances, with film coatings, the level of stability in blood is excellent compared to that obtained with a bare electrode (Fig. 5.16). These data strongly indicate that the base Pt (and other) electrode materials are not sufficiently reliable for use in biofluids, no matter how sophisticated the Table 5.4 Surfactants used for entrapment in polyphenols Surfactant
Polarity
Formula weight
Critical micelle concentration (cmc) (mg/ml)
Non-ionic
8400
100
Adogen 464 (methyltrialkyl (C6±C10) ammonium chloride)
Cationic
368±452
n/a
Taurocholic acid
Anionic
537.7
6.7
Pluronic F68
130
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
5.15 Effects of incorporating surfactant within poly(rosolic acid) film on stability of Pt electrode following exposure to whole blood.
5.16 Reduction in sensitivity of bare Pt following exposure to whole blood, shown as normalised response.
electrode may be (e.g. a biochip array), unless some specific means of protecting against fouling has been used.
5.5.3 Conducting polymer films Planar conducting films, whilst potentially usable as a membrane barrier or as a biocompatibility inducing interface, can also operate as reporters for bioaffinity
Stable use of biosensors at the sample interface
131
5.17 Species used for the formation of conducting polymer systems.
reactions. Moreover, they can be formed over microelectrodes with the ease of non-conducting phenolics.76 A range of organic compounds have been used to form conducting films (Fig. 5.17), but polypyrrole appeared to be especially advantageous. Conducting polymers can be switched between the conducting and insulating states. Film conductivity correlates with the prevalence of mobile cationic species (polarons/bipolarons) available on the polymer backbone.77 Polaronic conductivity is due to a delocalised positive charge spread over four pyrrole units, whereas electronic conductivity involves the conduction band of the polymer. The films generally used in aqueous solution demand relatively low potentials for redox switching and changes of the state of conductivity. Film deposition is initiated by the oxidation of a monomer to produce a radical cation, which then reacts with other monomers or monomer radicals to go to a dimer stage and then a trimer stage and so on. Oligomer formation then moves on to nucleation and polymer elongation. Importantly, the charged polymer incorporates solution anions. If these anions are bioreceptors, then a biosensor results. The bioreceptor may be co-entrapped in the films without formal charge-based incorporation, provided that a simple anion is present in solution to facilitate the polymerisation process. Inorganic anions as well as anionic oligostructures, such as sodium dodecyl sulphate (SDS) and toluene sulphonate, can be entrapped as stabilising counter ions.
132
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
Conducting polymer electropolymerisation A planar two-electrode arrangement (Fig. 5.18) comprising interdigitated gold (Au) electrodes if used as a polarisable electrode can allow surface deposition of polypyrrole. Once nucleation has occurred, film growth can be followed during cyclic voltammetry (Fig. 5.19). The counterion incorporated affects the voltammetry signatures of the formed films, which is observed when studying the reduction peaks (Fig. 5.20). However, avidin incorporated into a film, when
5.18 Electrode arrangement for planar film impedance spectroscopy. A schematic indicates the 15 micron gap between electrode fingers.
5.19 Formation of polypyrrole as monitored by cyclic voltammetry. There is a continued increase in the magnitude of the oxidative wave with subsequent potential scans.
Stable use of biosensors at the sample interface
133
5.20 Effect of incorporated counter ion on the reduction peak signature of poly(pyrrole).
134
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
used as a receptor for D-biotin, shows little effect on the cyclic voltammogram. This would seem to indicate that voltammetry is not an appropriate means of detecting receptor changes in the polypyrrole. Some alternative methods of analysis are therefore required. Interdigitated structures (Fig. 5.18) can be bridged by means of polypyrrole. Bridging can then be used to measure film conductivity with any given counterion. To achieve this, a low ionic strength solution is needed to maximise uptake of a receptor molecule and to control the extent of bridging achieved between electrodes. A relatively high polypyrrole concentration is also needed to avoid inhibition of film growth. It is important to recognise that film structure may vary depending on the counterion used. SDS leads to confluent growth and avidin is associated with discoid, multipoint growth. Such variation may have an effect on analyte access to the film, available surface area for binding and the degree to which non-specific surface binding of proteins and cells occurs at the sample interface. Impedance spectroscopy at planar polypyrrole films Once formed on a surface the polypyrrole film can be switched from an insulating to a conducting state based on the impressed polarising voltage. However, a particular redox state can also be sustained, determined by some intermediate polarising voltage. The set redox state can then be followed by twoelectrode electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS). Two electrode EIS can be achieved using a 20 mV RMS sinusoidal potential, and an impedimetric spectrum taken between an extensive frequency range, from 5 Hz to 13 MHz. Independent measures of polaronic and electronic conduction can be obtained, since they take place on quite different voltage oscillatory time scales. A Bode plot is a useful graphical representation of impedance data, combining capacitive current measurement (out of phase with sinusoidal voltage) with impedance measurement (in phase with sinusoidal voltage). Impedance (Z) defines the relationship between applied potential and current and, more 0 formally, is a vector quantity composed of a real (in phase Z ) and an imaginary 00 0 00 Z iZ where `i' is the (out of phase Z ) part related by the equation Zp complex number and is defined by i
ÿ1 and the modulus 0 00 jZj
Z 2 Z 2 0:5 . Physical interpretation of the data is problematic. However, the observed data can be modelled using derived equivalent circuits comprising arrangements of resistors, inductors and capacitors. In practical terms, an electroinactive product or outcome of a bioaffinity reaction can be registered and a two-electrode arrangement is usable, provided that the redox state of the film remains stable. Real films show distinct separate zones respectively of electronic and polaronic conduction (Fig. 5.21). In ionic solutions, such as a phosphate buffer solution, polaronic conduction is augmented because the presence of the mobile anions in the film facilitates charged-linked electron transfer.
Stable use of biosensors at the sample interface
135
5.21 Two electrode impedance spectra at IDEs.
Impedimetric measurements of LH and biotins For a model system incorporating antibody to lutenising hormone (LH), a polaronic phase is identifiable (Fig. 5.22) but, more importantly, there is a capacitance reduction and an impedance increase after binding to LH. This is seen only when a redox cycle is imposed after the binding took place. This provides an indication not only of how antibody can be entrapped within
136
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
5.22 Reagentless binding with LH ± upper capacitance peak, and lower impedance curve trace the zero LH response. LH concentration 100 IU/l.
polypyrrole, while remaining active and accessible to a peptide such as LH, but also of how, in the absence of any apparent voltammetric changes, the impedimetric signature is altered to thereby achieve reagentless binding recognition. The inherent principle should be translatable to other affinity pairs. Thus, for avidin entrapped in polypyrrole, responses are seen for biotin and biotin analogues that are significantly different from the entrapped urease control with regard to phase angle (Fig. 5.23(a)). The biotin derivatives used are amidocaproate succinimide ester (biotin ester) and biotin amidocaproate 3sulpho ester (biotin sulpho). There is firstly an increase in phase angle observed when exposed to phosphate buffer (this is a background effect that would need to be taken into account even if practical measurements are carried out), but the effect of biotin binding is clear-cut. A key feature of all observed binding-induced phase angle changes is the need for one preliminary redox cycling step to unmask the effect on capacitive behaviour (phase angle). Possibly such cycling allows for realignment of polymer chains around the newly formed complex, in turn changing the polymer conformation and, therefore, the ring alignment and polaronic conduction. The importance of the original gold-polypyrrole surface in conditioning the response is illustrated (Fig. 5.23(b)) in the lack of significant biotin response where an electrode had been reused following formic acid cleaning to remove previous films. The subtlety of this effect is underlined by the finding of basic Bode plot profiles for recycled electrodes that are identical to unused electrodes. Thus, either the gold electrode interface is directly important for conditioning cross-IDE impedance, or the gold surface affects the superimposed film structure. The avidin biotin complex is a useful model to study, but the high binding affinity of avidin (KD 10ÿ15 L/M) does not readily allow concentration
Stable use of biosensors at the sample interface
137
5.23 Effect of base IDE condition on polypyrrole film formation. (a) unused electrode (b) recycled electrode.
dependent effects to be followed. These, however, can be seen for a LHantibody combination but it is also notable that with the polyclonal antibody preparation used, notwithstanding a high LH affinity, there was little response in contrast to a monoclonal antibody. Possible reasons for this include blocking contaminants in the polyclonal preparation, molecular heterogeneity, distorting polymer conformation changes following binding and antibody aggregates, reducing microenvironmental effects within the bulk of the film structure. The monoclonal-LH system demonstrated no significant response in phosphate buffer, but response to LH was attenuated by pre-incubation of the LH with bovine serum albumin (3 g/L), tested up to 800 IU/L LH. The albumin possibly blocked binding or there may have been bulk solution associated effects with LH that prevented antibody interaction. Whatever the reason, such complex macromoleculer interactions highlight a further challenge to measurements in biological samples. This is in marked contrast to the use of impedimetric measurements at conducting polymers for gas phase affinity sensing, as developed for artificial nose technology,78 where interferences are minimal.
138
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
5.6
Microflows as surrogate, renewable barrier films
5.6.1 Needle biosensors and in-vivo monitoring Notwithstanding the structural elegance and geometrical precision of MEMs based sensors for in-vitro use, in-vivo insertion, even for percutaneous blood sampling and intravenous lines still relies upon needle technology. The fundamental point is that the cylindrical geometry, miniaturisation and high mechanical specification of needles satisfy the dominant issues for healthcare use and take precedence over the structural and length scale elegance of MEMS devices. In the case of silicon-fabricated devices, there is a further concern over long-term implantation, in that dissolution of silicon and local elemental release may be of significance, an issue that needs quantitative consideration if, say, porous silicon is to be used for in-vivo device construction. The needle design has been consistently used for implantable enzyme-based biosensors. Inevitably the greatest attention has been paid to glucose sensing in view of the healthcare importance of diabetes. One classic construction route for this has used two functional layers aside from the chemically crosslinked enzyme layer of glucose oxidase.69 The first layer is a selective low molecular weight cut off barrier based on a sulphonated polyethersulphonepolyethersulphone (SPEES-PES). This robust ionomeric barrier mostly excludes ascorbate, urate and acetaminophen (TylenolÕ) as major electrochemically active interferents on the combined basis of size and charge. The degree of sulphonation is important and may explain why a high selectivity has not been seen by some.79 The outer layer covering the antigenic enzyme layer must interface with the biofluid. It is also a multilayer porous polyurethane serving to reduce glucose transport to the enzyme layer, retain O2 transport (eqn 5.1) whilst providing mechanical integrity and high resistance to the degradative action of free radicals potentially generated during chemical reactions. The laminate formulation used by us is a combination of five pre-polymer polyurethane layers and a single carbonate polyurethane (CorethaneÕ) outermost layer known for its tissue compatibility and low degradation rates.
5.6.2 Open microflow for in-vivo monitoring Needle glucose electrodes used in tissue for short-term (~24 h) monitoring should, in principle, be acceptable for diabetic home use. In practice though, percutaneous, temporary insertion for such minimally invasive monitoring is difficult to achieve. No matter how stable such devices are in vitro, even in blood, the tissue response to the implant, however, demands firstly a stabilisation period of some hours and then in-vivo calibration in the tissue. Indeed, tissue glucose values, both at steady state and under dynamic conditions, show a clinically acceptable match for nearly all current devices. The reasons for this are complex and reflect transcapillary transport lag time, the limit of the
Stable use of biosensors at the sample interface
139
microcirculation to supply and remove glucose, the nature of the inflammatory exudative tissue response and the distance between the capillary bed and the implanted sensing surface. The last is compounded by the barrier function of the interstitial tissue `mesh'. Open microflow (Fig. 5.24) allows for delivery to the tissue implant site of a film of hydration fluid delivered over the sensing surface of the device and then into the tissue itself. Because subcutaneous tissue mostly operates at a negative hydrostatic pressure, fluid transport does not necessarily require physical pumping and at a net outflow diameter of 0.2 mm, 1±2 L of buffer enters the tissue. The amounts are therefore extremely low, and well within the range of volume exchanges that occur at the capillary bed under physiological conditions, as driven by net positive and negative transcapillary pressures in the Starling mechanism. The externally introduced fluid flow creates a mobile film over the sensing surface that helps to reduce colloid/cell access to the sensor and reduces fouling. Equally important, the juxtaposed tissue is hydrated, and such hydration of connective tissue reduces the diffusional barrier presented to microsolutes. Hydraulic permeability of oedema tissue, for example, is known to be increased several orders of magnitude in comparison with normal connective tissue. The practical consequence of open microflow is that sensor `run in' time is reduced from a typical 3 h down to a mere 30 min. Also the tissue:blood mismatch is reduced as is the commonly observed temporal lag (up to 12 min) for tissue glucose changes. These advantages are most in evidence in the animal model where tissue-related monitoring error appears all but eliminated.
5.24 Percutaneously implanted needle enzyme electrode showing hydration zone at needle tip following pumpless flow of fluid into the dermis.
140
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
Translation into humans shows promise, however, microfluidic design changes are a likely requirement given the interspecies differences in connective tissue composition and capillary bed behaviour.
5.7
Microfluidics and biosensors
While used as `dip in and register' devices, biosensors hold the promise of deskilled analysis. One element of their current attractiveness consists in the fact that they can be produced by microfabrication techniques, and are therefore ready for miniaturisation at single device or industrial scale production. Thus, regardless of this, achieving full analytical benefit depends upon sample presentation. Thus, sample flow, dilution, background composition and the presence of interfering substances all add to the so-called matrix effect in biological samples, and all variously conspire to distort the basic signal readout. It is a fact that sample presentation and delivery have been a much neglected area of research on biosensors. This is also one reason responsible for their lack of widespread uptake, either for extra-laboratory testing, or in drug discovery arrays. However, thanks to rapid advances in microelectromechanical systems (MEMs), it is now possible to design and manufacture high precision flow structures,80 predominantly in silicon or glass. By using these structures, researchers have been able to create designer fluid flows that offer the prospects of precision fluid delivery to targeted locations via valve controllable flow paths. Beyond any size scaling effect, however, fluids under microfluidic flow conditions exhibit quite distinct fluid dynamics. Here, viscous forces are dominant, and any irregularity or turbulence in the flow pattern evens out in order to give a laminar flow, with precise, quantifiable solution transport profiles through an entire length of the microchannel network regardless of channel interconnections and overall geometry. Microchannels or capillaries (usually 0.02 to 2 mm diameter) can be regarded as reaction microenvironments. They exhibit two very specific characteristics. First, they present small internal volumes that can be easily and rapidly filled by fluids. Second, fluids moving inside these channels remain laminar even at very low velocities, with no evidence of turbulence. A microchannel thus constitutes a special delivery vehicle for self-contained and finely controllable sample exposure of a strategically positioned biosensing surface along the flow path. Moreover, the use of miniaturised flow cells giving Reynolds numbers of less than 2000 (vide infra) permits non-turbulent fluid flow so independent, parallel flow streams can be accommodated without turbulent mixing.81 A microfluidic channel presents a relatively high surface area to the bulk sample volume, which thereby enables a wall-immobilised reagent to be highly effective in reacting with bulk solute constituents, e.g., through binding and catalysis. These high surface to bulk interactions also facilitate chromatographic principles of sample separation.
Stable use of biosensors at the sample interface
141
Laminar flow allows delivery of chemical species inside capillaries with remarkable precision. The application of different streams of a multiphase, laminar flow system also allows a reaction to take place exclusively at certain regions of the flow system, either between a stream and channel wall or between two adjacent streams. As a consequence, such devices could be potentially used to carry out in-situ microfabrication experiments, thus paving the way to innovative micro and even nanotechnology strategies.
5.7.1 The Reynolds number In 1883, Osborne Reynolds demonstrated that, under specified conditions, stable laminar flow switched to unstable turbulent mode. He introduced a fundamental equation, which gave a range of dimensionless numbers, the Reynolds numbers, defining the transition from laminar to turbulent flow. The Reynolds number is defined as the ratio of inertial vs. viscous forces and is used in momentum, heat, and mass transfer to account for dynamic similarity It is calculated using: Re
DV
5:2
where Re Reynolds number, D characteristic length, V velocity, density and viscosity. Due to the large number of parameters, there is a great degree of flexibility available regarding the flow cell construction and arrangement. Typically, a single flow within a straight pipe with smooth walls and Reynolds numbers below 2000 is both stable and laminar. Between 2000 and 2300, a transitional flow is observed. Above Reynolds numbers of 2300, the flow becomes turbulent and unstable. Most microfabricated fluid systems operate under low Reynolds number conditions. Since in small channels only small liquid masses are moved and flow velocities are typically low, this ratio is generally small for any given viscosity. Under these conditions, an aqueous stream in a microchannel will behave similarly to viscous oil-like flow at the macroscopic level. Consequently, it is possible to flow two aqueous streams of similar viscosity side by side while preventing turbulent mixing.82 Nonetheless, if flow is subject to an abrupt change of channel geometry or encounters obstacles, it will change from a laminar to a turbulent regimen even at extremely low Reynolds numbers (Re40-300).81 Although turbulent mixing does not normally occur at low Reynolds numbers, diffusion still occurs, and has been utilised by Manz and co-workers to generate microfluidic mixing, otherwise difficult to obtain at such low Reynolds numbers.83 A key consideration when using microfluidics is to understand and control flow characteristics (velocity profile, shear force, etc.) which is a complex area of fluid dynamics that relies heavily on computational modelling in order to
142
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
predict these outcomes. The Navier-Stokes equation is often used to characterise fluid flows provided that the initial conditions are properly established.84 The equation is based on the balance of forces summarised as follows: Transient Convective Body Pressure inertial force inertial force force force
Viscous force
5.3
However, in steady flow, the transient inertial force vanishes. Also, if the fluid is considered as ideal, the viscous force term disappears, simplifying analysis.85
5.7.2 Design and fabrication of microfluidic devices The main trend currently is to consider the biosensor as an integral part of a complete miniaturised analytical system rather than as a separate entity, thus the concept of a micro total analytical systems (TAS) involved microfluidics as part of the system.86,87 A scaled down fluid delivery system can be seen as equivalent to the distributed capillary networks of natural tissues, which permits conservation of sample volume and exquisite flow control and fast switching of flow paths and delay lines. All contribute to the desired, near-ideal conditions needed for the fine-tuning, multiplexing and efficient operation of bio- and other sensor systems. Microfluidics is essentially a basic, though less discussed, component of a TAS. Here, the manipulative steps of an analytical laboratory, notably sample separation, clean-up, reagent introduction, reaction profiling concentration optimisation and analytical endpoint detection are incorporated into a miniaturised structure, alternatively considered lab-on-a-chip. Miniaturisation of many of the relevant processing components has certainly been achieved, but none would be operational without the mobile element embodied in the integral microfluidics; much more needs to be done in developing the technology. Microfabrication of biosensors scales down reagents requirements, a major financial advantage, and also facilitates greater sample throughput. The method requirement is for microfluidics. Before fabricating a microfluidic system, time has to be spent in considering the precise application. Thus, the eventual operating conditions need to be specified. One important choice is that of the basic material (resin, polymer, metal, glass or silicon) from which the device will be fabricated. The material has to be chemically inert and resistant to the various solvents and solutes to which it is exposed during the operational lifetime. Each type of material is associated with different types of manufacturing methods and quite different manufacturing costs, which can be more or less important depending on the individual material used. When an aqueous phase is used, relatively inexpensive polymeric materials like poly(methyl methacrylate) (PMMA) and poly(dimethylsiloxane) (PDMS) can be used to fabricate flow-cells. However, some solvents will alter if not
Stable use of biosensors at the sample interface
143
completely erode these polymeric materials. As a consequence, for a microfluidic device handling a wide variety of solvents (aqueous to organic, polar to apolar), it becomes vital to choose more expensive materials that are chemically inert vis-aÁ-vis these solvents, as well as the solutes they will be carrying. Such materials (metal, glass, silicon) require more complicated, and therefore more expensive, techniques for etching and assembly, reversibly where possible, into a well-sealed microfluidic enclosure. It is also crucial in this instance to choose the right component to dispense and transport the fluids from a reservoir into the microfluidic device. Syringes have to be of glass and the tubing and connectors made of solvent-resistant but still flexible polymeric material, like PTFE (polytetrafluoroethylene) or PEEK (polyetheretherketone), as commonly used in liquid chromatography. Once the choice of material has been made, various etching/assembly techniques available need to be investigated. Microfabrication techniques, in their most basic form, rely on thin-film or thick-film metal pattern formation associated with photolithography.88 This technique has already proved highly efficient and successful in the mass production of silicon chips for the semiconductor industry. A thin metallic layer is deposited onto a substrate (silicon or glass), typically via spin-coating, after which a photoresist is added. Then, a patterned photomask is applied and the whole system irradiated by UV light. The unmasked portions of the photoresist are etched and the exposed metallic areas are then eroded either chemically in solution (wet etching) or by exposure to a plasma (reactive ion etching).89 The metal layer can be replaced by a layer of silicon oxide (SiO2) that is grown on a pure silicon substrate in a furnace over many days. The SiO2 layer can be etched using the same techniques as above. Silicon oxide and glass, which are similar, can be easily etched using HF (wet etching). The microfluidic channels formed can be sealed by anodic bonding of a glass slide or cover slip to the glass or silicon/silicon oxide substrate. The lift-off technique is very similar to the classical photolithography technique except that the photoresist is first deposited onto the substrate, then partially etched by UV light using the patterned photomask. The metal layer is then deposited on both the exposed substrate layer and the remaining photoresist. The photoresist is then dissolved (lift-off) leaving the patterned metallic layer. Anisotropic etching is capable of producing three-dimensional structures as opposed to photolithographic techniques. It is performed with heated alkaline solution using SiO2 or Si3N4 masks. The etching rate is highly controllable and stops at layers of impurities. It is dependent on the crystalline orientation of the substrate. In silicon etching, for example, the most commonly used etching agents are potassium hydroxide and tetramethylammonium.90 Powder blasting is a technique that can be used to generate microstructures in brittle substrates such as glass. It employs a masked substrate and an eroding
144
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
beam of 30 micron sized alumina (or sand) particles in a powder form. This powder is propelled using a compressed air stream, which is able to etch channels down to 100 micron width and 20 micron depth.91,92 Many of the techniques employed for microfabrication are borrowed from the semiconductor industry. However, since silicon is hydrophobic by nature, it may not be suitable for biological studies, and the use of polymers represents a more attractive and cheaper proposition. Poly(methyl methacrylate) (PMMA), for example, can be used and is easily etched using standard mechanical tools or using laser ablation techniques to form very precise microchannels. Hot embossing is a technique capable of generating low-cost devices for the biotechnology industry. It utilises a hot plate with the substrate being pressed between the hot plate and another patterned metallic plate. Micro-injection moulding requires that the polymers used are first reduced to granules, melted above their Tg (glass transition temperature) and injected into a mould, generating microfluidic channels. Another polymer that can be used is Poly(dimethyl siloxane) (PDMS), a clear rubbery, crosslinked polymer that can be easily cast into a patterned metallic or silicon mould, thus generating microfluidic devices at very low cost, ideal for prototyping.93,94
5.7.3 Detection Chemical and biosensing devices integrated into fluidic arrays at multiple locations can allow sequential monitoring of reaction transients or of the kinetic development of reaction profiles along a given flow channel. Little additional structural distortion of precision-formed fluid channels results with wall embedded devices. More accurate kinetic measurements thereby achieved thus can add to end point estimations. In electrochemical sensors oxidisable or reducible molecules generate measurable current flow. With stable fluidics these current responses become further stabilised, and signal to noise is reduced, important for low current outputs. Neurotransmitters and the products of some enzyme reactions (oxidoreductases), either directly or via electron transporting indicators, have been measured in this way and even when using well-known chemistries there are additional benefits due to miniaturisation and the fine tuning of signal outputs. Through a combination of biosensor arrays and variable flow conditions, a spectrum of multiple responses can be obtained giving better sample profiling allowing for greater biosensor redundancy and ultimately improved data reliability. Sample concentration changes are also possible in miniaturised structures through controlled evaporative loss and, in the case of ionic solutes, adsorption/release from electrically addressable surfaces give additional routes to sample adjustment thus allowing the analytical `reach' of biosensors to be extended.
Stable use of biosensors at the sample interface
145
Control over diffusive solute transport from the bulk sample to the biosensor surface can be augmented by in-situ polymerisation of thin conducting and nonconducting films (vide supra), readily formed within the confines of a closed microchannel. Such thin films do not distort flow, but do allow co-entrapment of biological or non-biological reagents for biosensor formation. Fluid conductivity measured with micro-electrode pairs across flow channels or specific ions measured with miniature ion-selective electrodes allow for both profiling of a sample and facilitate sample status monitoring in addition to any integrated biosensor for a specific target. A special opportunity arises through optical fibre or waveguide based optical interrogation of flow components, and detection of an intrinsic solute property (e.g. protein fluorescence) opens up the additional armoury of spectroscopy.
5.7.4 Diffusion and sample separation Laminar flow in microchannels, depending on the flow rate, may allow or prevent the diffusion of solutes from one stream to another. Diffusion becomes more prevalent as the flow rate decreases and the flow path increases. It is also possible to discriminate between analytes depending on their molecular weight. Low molecular weight compounds diffuse more readily than high molecular weight solutes for which diffusion can be almost completely prevented, reducing fouling of a sensing electrode surface. Figure 5.25 shows a schematic microfluidic device, where a bifurcation is used to converge fluid streams in a 200 m wide flow channel. The value of this flow phenomenon is that there is controlled laminar flow over any electrode located in the wall of the flow channel, so convective transport and therefore response of an electroactive species can be correctly modelled. Furthermore, a protective fluid film can be used over the intramural electrode to compartmentalise the electrochemical (or chemical) detection sequence from a potentially contaminating
5.25 Bifurcated flow cell schematic for non-mixing of parallel microflow.
146
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
sample stream. The protective effect primarily applies to microsolute monitoring, where diffusion coefficients are at least one order of magnitude greater than for, say, surface-active proteins; cellular transport, moreover, across the two streams is virtually eliminated. Even with a protruding electrode it may be possible to have a viable monitoring set-up with the protruding device allowing for a high exposed microsurface area and therefore higher currents. In a study on the difference of diffusivity between a high molecular weight solute (glucose oxidase) and a small molecule hydrogen peroxide (H2O2), generated by the reaction between glucose and glucose oxidase, it was shown that with glucose oxidase in the stream adjacent to the electrode and glucose in the opposite stream, a reaction occurred at the interface between the two streams, generating H2O2. With increasing flow rate, the electrochemical current generated by hydrogen peroxide at the electrode decreased and a faster flow reduced the diffusion time for hydrogen peroxide. This behaviour is similar to that of a separation or filtration membrane but in a fluidic, thus renewable, form preventing biofouling of the sensitive sensing surface.
5.7.5 In-situ microfabrication Many experiments have been carried out using the unique behaviour of fluids inside microfluidic channels. Control over reagent delivery has been used to precipitate solid structures in flow channels such as linear wire electrodes or silver and conducting polymeric fibres.81,95 However, microfabrication of complete barrier structures, like free-standing ultra-thin membranes remains a challenging task. Thus, attempts at precipitating cellulose acetate from 0.2 wt% acetone solution at an aqueous stream using first a 1.5 mm (width) 0.5 mm (depth) channel and then a 1.2 mm (width) 0.6 mm (depth) channel led to aggregates of precipitated polymer but not membranes. The formation of distinct membranes with some mechanical strength was achieved by using a polymer that was not easily redissolved by the flow stream. Thus, interfacial polymerisation of nylon 6,6 was attempted. Adipoyl chloride (62.5 mM) in xylenes and 1,6-diaminohexane (62.5 mM) in distilled water were used. Interfacial polymerisation in the diffusion zone led to nylon 6,6 membrane instantly. A solid anchoring point proved to be a key requirement in order to achieve stable membrane attachment. Further development of permeable membrane structures should allow for an interfacial barrier for sensor protection, and could complement separation by liquid-liquid interfaces.
5.8
Conclusion
Though biochip-based and other precisely configured biosensors are precision structures with the opportunity of greater measurement reliability using multiple arrays, the need remains for reliable and stable interfacing. Relevant research in the
Stable use of biosensors at the sample interface
147
areas of materials, membranes, fluidics and films is already available to help adapt and `refashion' biochip surfaces for practical use. A combined effort at this stage is more likely to help deliver viable products for the future, especially in healthcare. Admittedly the advantages may be of overwhelming importance only if measurement is required on a continuous basis or if unmodified (e.g. undiluted, non-deproteinised) samples are to be assayed. However, the over-the-counter medical diagnostic market is a prime example where unmodified samples will be measured, which is likely to benefit from biochip configurations of biosensors as truly reliable and therefore `smart' systems, provided that stability in the sample can be guaranteed. To this end, increasing interest in barrier membranes is anticipated. However, fluid interfaces and in-situ microdeposited membrane barriers could lead to major augmentation of microdevice performance with considerable economy of sample volume requirements.
5.9
Acknowledgements
The authors would like to thank EPSRC, JDFI, BDA and the EU for funding of the ongoing studies presented in this review.
5.10 References 1. J.E. Pearson, A. Gill and P. Vadgama, Ann. Clin. Bioch., 37, 119±145 (2000). 2. T.J. Ohara, R. Rajagopalan and A. Heller, Anal. Chem., 66, 2451±2457 (1994). 3. A. Pizzoferrato, C.R. Arciola, E. Cenni, G. Ciapetti, D. Granchi, L. Savarino and S. Stea, Encyclopedic Handbook of Biomaterials and Bioengineering, Part A: Materials, 1, 329±370 (1995). 4. A. Pizzoferrato, Clin. Mater., 15(3), 173±190 (1994). 5. D. Williams, Definitions in biomaterials, in Progress in Biomedical Engineering, 1987, Elsevier, Amsterdam. 6. C. Baquey, Biorheology, 28(5), 463±472 (1991). 7. S. Churchouse, Anal. Proc., 23, 147±148 (1986). 8. M. Schlosser, Horm. Metab. Res., 26(11), 534±537 (1994). 9. B.D. Hoyle and J.W. Costerton, Prog. Drug Res., 37, 91±105 (1991). 10. S. Kayashima, IEEE Trans. Biomed. Eng., 38(8), 752±757 (1991). 11. B. Conway and H. Angerstein-Kozolowskatt, J. Vasc. Sci. Technol., 14, 352±364 (1977). 12. J.C. Wataha, S.K. Nelson, and P.E. Lockwood, Dent. Mater., 17(5), 409±414 (2001). 13. S.B. Brummer, J. McHardy and M.J. Turner, Brain Behav. Evol., 14(1±2), 10±22 (1977). 14. M.F. Nichols, Crit. Rev. Biomed. Eng., 22(1), 39±67 (1994). 15. L. Bowman and J.D. Meindl, IEEE Trans. Biomed. Eng., 33(2), 248±255 (1986). 16. D.G. Castner and B.D. Ratner, Surface Science, 500(1±3), 28±60 (2002). 17. P. Cuypers, W. Hermens and H. Hencker, Ann. N.Y. Acad. Sci., 283, 77±85 (1977). 18. B. Sweryda-Krawiec, Langmuir, 20(6), 2054±2056 (2004). 19. Slack, S. and T. Horbett, Proteins at interface II, ACS Symposium Series, 602, 112± 128 (1995).
148 20. 21. 22. 23. 24. 25. 26. 27. 28. 29. 30. 31. 32. 33. 34. 35. 36. 37. 38. 39. 40. 41. 42. 43. 44. 45. 46. 47. 48. 49. 50. 51. 52. 53. 54. 55. 56. 57. 58. 59. 60. 61.
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials M.S. Munro, Trans. Am. Soc. Artif. Intern. Organs, 27, 499±503 (1981). P. Claesson, Colloids Surf., A77, 109±118 (1993). G.P. Lopez, J. Biomed. Mater. Res., 26(4), 415±439 (1992). E. Nilsson, Scand. J. Clin. Lab. Invest., 41(6), 557±563 (1981). J. Jozefonvicz, Biocompatibility of Tissue Analogs Vol. 2, D.W. Ed, editor, 1985, CRC Press, Boca Raton. T. Grasel and S. Cooper, J. Biomed. Mater. Res., 23(3), 311±338 (1989). Y.H. Kim, Biomaterials, 24(13), 2213±2223 (2003). Clark, L., US Patent No. 1913386. 1959: USA. M.B. Gorbet and M.V. Sefton, Biomaterials, 25(26), 5681±5703 (2004). D.E. Chenoweth, Anaphylatoxin formation in extracorporeal circuits, Complement, 3(3), 152±165 (1986). J. Wettero, Biomaterials, 23(4), 981±991 (2002). D.E. Chenoweth, Artificial Organs, 8(3), 281±290 (1984). M.D. Kazatchkine and M.P. Carreno, Biomaterials, 9(1), 30±35 (1988). J.H. Elam and H. Nygren, Biomaterials, 13(1), 3±8 (1992). D.N. Bell and H.L. Goldsmith, Microvascular Research, 27(3), 316±330 (1984). H.L. Goldsmith, Biorheology, 36(5-6), 461±468 (1999). M.E. Valentinuzzi, J.P. Morucci and C.J. Felice, Crit. Rev. Biomed. Eng., 24(4±6), 353±466 (1996). D.K. Kido, Invest. Radiol., 23(Suppl.2), S359±365 (1988). K. Kuroki, J. Vasc. Interv. Radiol., 6(5), 819±826 (1995). A.L. Bailly, J. Biomed. Mater. Res., 30(1), 101±108 (1996). A. Moregra, Catheter Cardio. Diag., 38, 355±359 (1996). L. Vroman, Ann. N.Y. Acad. Sci., 516, 300±305 (1987). P.C. Liaw, J. Biol. Chem., 276(24), 20959±20965 (2001). E. Nilsson, Scand. J. Clin. Lab. Invest., 42(4), 331±338 (1982). R.C. Eberhart and C.P. Clagett, Semin. Hematol., 28(4) (Suppl. 7), 42±48; discussion 66±68 (1991). S.J. Sofia, V.V. Premnath and E.W. Merrill, Macromolecules, 31(15), 5059±5070 (1998). S.H. Hsu, C.M. Tang and C.C. Lin, Biomaterials, 25(25), 5593±5601 (2004). D.F. Williams, J. Biomed. Eng, 11(3), 185±191 (1989). S. Ertefai and D.A. Gough, J. Biomed. Eng., 11(5), 362±368 (1989). W.K. Ward and J.E. Troupe, Asaio Journal, 45(6), 555±561 (1999). T.N. Salthouse, J. Biomed. Mater. Res., 10(2), 197±229 (1976). M. Shen and T.A. Horbett, J. Biomed. Mater. Res., 57(3), 336±345 (2001). S. Wittmann, Cytometry, 57A(1), 53±62 (2004). J. Forster, Am. J. Physiol., 256(6 Pt. 1), E788±797 (1989). N. Wisniewski, Am. J. Physiol. Endocrinol. Metab., 282(6), E1316±1323 (2002). L. Niniikoski and T.K. Heughan, Surg. Gynecol. and Obstet., 133, 1003±1007 (1971). O. Trabold, Wound Repair Regen., 11(6), 504±509 (2003). L.C. Clark, G. Misrahy and R.P. Fox, J. Appl. Physiol., 13(1), 85±91 (1958). S.J. Churchouse, Biosensors, 2(6), 325±342 (1986). S. Sun, J. Membrane Science, 222, 3±18 (2003). S. Higson and P. Vadgama, Anal. Chim. Acta, 271, 125±133 (1993). S. Reddy and P. Vadgama, Anal. Chim. Acta, 350, 77±89 (1997).
Stable use of biosensors at the sample interface 62. 63. 64. 65. 66. 67. 68. 69. 70. 71. 72. 73. 74. 75. 76. 77. 78. 79. 80. 81. 82. 83. 84. 85. 86. 87. 88. 89. 90. 91. 92. 93. 94. 95.
149
K. Ishihara, J. Ueda and N. Nakabayashi, N., Polymer J., 22(5), 355±360 (1990). D. Chapman, Langmuir, 9, 39±45 (1993). C. Ho and A. Zydney, J. Memb. Sci., 155(2), 261±75 (1999). M. Wessling, Sep. Purif. Techn., 24, 375±87 (2001). K. Meyer, Cryst. Res. Tech., 29, 903±30 (1994). E.F. Murphy, J.R. Lu, J. Brewer and J. Russell, Macromolecules, 33, 4545±4554 (2000). E.F. Murphy, J.R. Lu, J. Brewer, J. Russell and J. Penfold, Langmuir, 15, 1313±1322 (1999). S. Mutlu, M. Mutlu, P. Vadgama and E. Piskin, Diagnostic Biosensor Polymers, (eds A.M. Usmani, N. Akmal), ACS Symposium Series, 556, 71±83 (1994). S.P.J. Higson and P. Vadgama, Anal. Chim. Acta, 271, 125±133 (1993). S. Gamburzev, P. Atanasov and E. Wilkins, Sensors and Actuators B ± Chemical, 30 (3): 179±183 (1996). S. Reddy and P. Vadgama, Anal. Chim. Acta, 350, 67±76 (1997). S. Reddy and P. Vadgama, Anal. Chim. Acta, 350, 77±89 (1997). P.H. Treloar, I.M. Christie, J.W. Kane, P. Crump, A.T. Nkohkwo and P. Vadgama, Electroanalysis, 7, 216±220 (1995). S.Y. Tham, J.E. Pearson, J.W. Kane, P.H. Treloar and P. Vadgama, Sensors and Actuators, 50, 204±209 (1998). K. Warriner, S. Higson, D. Ashworth, I.M. Christie and P. Vadgama, Materials Science and Engineering, C5, 81±90 (1997). G. Appel, O. Bohme, R. Mikalo, D. Schmeisser, Chemical Physics Letters, 313 (3±4), 411±415 (1999). P.N. Bartlett, J.M. Elliott and J.W. Gardner, Food Technology, 51, 44±48 (1997). Y. Benmakroha, I.M. Christie, M. Desai and P. Vadgama, Analyst, 121, 521±526 (1996). H. Gardniers, R. Schasfoort and A. Van Den Berg, MST News, No. 4, 10±12 (2000). P.J.A. Kenis, R.F. Ismagilov, S. Takayama and G.W. Whitesides, Acc. Chem. Res., 33, 841±847 (2000). B.H. Weigl and P. Yager, Sensors and Actuators B, 38-39, 452±457 (1997). F. Bessot, Anal. Commun., 36, 213±215 (1999). A. Rasmussen, Sensors and Actuators A, 88, 121±132 (2001). Y. Fung, Biomechanics, 1998, Springer Press. E. Dempsey, Anal. Chim. Acta, 346, 341±349 (1997). O. Guenat, Sensors and Actuators B, 72, 273±282 (2001). G. Jobst, Biosensors and Bioelectronics, 8, 123±128 (1993). G. Kumaravelu, M.M. Alkaisi and A. Bittar, 29th IEEE Photovoltaic Specialists Conference, New Orleans, Louisiana, USA, 1±4 (2002). C. Liu, Trends in Biotechnology, 15, 213±216 (1997). E. Belloy, Sensors and Actuators, 84, 330±337 (2000). E. Belloy, Sensors and Actuators, 86, 231±237 (2000). E. Delamarche, A. Bernard, H. Schmid, A. Bietsch, B. Michel and H. Biebuyck, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 120, 500±508 (1998). X. Ren, M. Bachman, C. Sims, G.P. Li and N. Allbritton, Journal of Chromatography B, 762, 117±125 (2001). P.J.A. Kenis, R.F. Ismagilov, G.M. Whitesides, Science, 285, 83±85 (1999).
6
Micro- and nanoscale surface patterning techniques for localising biomolecules and cells: the essence of nanobiotechnology Z A D E M O V I C and P K I N G S H O T T , The Danish Polymer Centre, Denmark
6.1
Introduction
Most reactions in biology occur not in solution, but at interfaces, such as cell membranes. The need to improve the quality of our lives has led to substantial research and development in manipulating material surfaces in an attempt to mimic and control biological reactions that take place at interfaces. Medical implant materials, for example, have played a pivotal role in bringing surface concepts to biology. In the late 1940s the first biomaterials, as we known them today, were developed.1 Almost in parallel, scientists began studying the properties of biomaterial surfaces, which included investigations involving protein-surface and cell-surface interactions, and ways of modifying these surfaces in order to control so-called biointeractions. Present surface science has had considerable impact on biology and medicine. Implant biomaterials,2 affinity chromatography,3 gene chips4 and diagnostic arrays,5 cell culture surfaces6 and biosensors7 are examples where surface technologies have been applied to biological problems. These applications have been largely driven by an early appreciation of the fact that surfaces provide the platform for biological reactions to take place. An optimally functioning human being is made up of tissues that consist of highly organised structures of different cell types, each performing different but complementary functions. All the cells are surrounded by topographic and chemical cues that can align and guide cells.8,9,10 The specific protein-surface and cell-surface interactions are most likely to be strongly influenced by a combination of surface chemistry and surface topography,11 arranged, moreover, into well defined patterns on the surface at both lm and nm length scales.12 The relative importance of these two factors remains poorly understood because we are still developing techniques to create patterns and the analytical methods capable of actually visualising such features. In addition, results achieved so far have shown that topographical modifications are accompanied by chemical variation. Hence, controlling the topography and chemistry of polymer surfaces independently is an important issue. The effect of surface topography on cellular
Micro- and nanoscale surface patterning techniques
151
and tissue response to implanted biomaterials has been known for the past 20 years. Cells have been shown to respond to micro- and nanoscale structures and to topography. Slightly roughened surfaces show increased osteointegration, reduced fibrous encapsulation and enhanced integration of implant materials,13,14,15 a result of increased adhesion of connective tissue cells. An ability to properly engineer cell-surface interactions and to control the spatial location of cells is highly desirable, and essential for creating in-vitro mimetics of physiologically relevant interfaces. Understanding how the surface chemistry and structure of a material can be used to control the biological reactivity of a cell interacting with that surface is the ultimate challenge for biological surface science. Ideally, the surfaces will need to have well-defined arrays of biorecognition sites designed to react specifically with the cells, since many of the important functions of cells depend on the arrangement of biomolecules at their surfaces.16 A large number of fabrication tools exist for tailoring a biomaterial surface. Chemical surface modification can be combined with designed microstructures and nanostructures, aimed at matching biological components or for inducing a desired biological reaction. Controlled protein adsorption is crucial to optimise cellsurface interactions, since cells recognise the protein layer and not the underlying surface. Surfaces must be developed that control the conformation and orientation of proteins with precision so that the body will specifically recognise them. The simplest method for immobilising a biomolecule on a surface is physical adsorption, but this is a purely random event and can lead to denaturation and loss of protein function or displacement by less desirable proteins. A more stable kind of protein immobilisation involves creating covalent bonds between the protein and solid surface. In addition to efforts made to optimise and control protein orientation at surfaces, a new research direction in protein immobilisation is taking place, namely protein patterning.17 It can be defined as protein immobilisation within specific locations in either two- or three-dimensional space.18,19,20 To date, research in this field has had considerable success on the micrometre length scale with patterning in two dimensions, primarily with single proteins. The generation of small structures is central to modern science and technology. The most evident examples are in microelectronics, where smaller has meant less expensive, faster, more components per chip, higher performance and lower power needs.21,22 Micro-fabrication techniques, which have been developed for application in the electronics industry and in information technology, have been progressively employed in biomaterials research to study cell-surface interactions.23 One aim of these studies is the spatial control of cell attachment and organisation.24,25 The ability to generate patterns of proteins and cells on surfaces is important for biosensor technology,26 tissue engineering,27 and fundamental studies of cell biology,28 and can generally be called the field of nanobiotechnology. The positioning of biological ligands at well-defined locations
152
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
on substrates is required for biological assays,29 for combinatorial screening,30 and for the fabrication of biosensors.31 Tissue engineering requires cells that are placed in specific locations to create organised structures in three dimensions. Furthermore, the growing demand in biosensor technology for high-density, high-sensitivity, multi-analyte chips can be met only with precise and reproducible patterning technologies that allow controlled positioning of chemically different active areas. The similarity of needs and limits between the implant and biosensor fields has led to the development of chemical, topochemical and topographical patterning methodologies that are applicable to both areas. Strategies that have been explored for fabricating patterned nanostructures take advantage of at least one of the following principles: · interaction of matter (`lithography') with photons (x-ray,32 ultraviolet33), energetic particles (electrons, ions, neutral metastable atoms) and scanning probes34 · replication against masters via physical contact35 · self-assembly of molecules36 and nanoscale objects.37 Most of these methods involve sophisticated instrumentation or treatments, and only a few of them are suited to create topographical variations at polymer surfaces without changing the chemistry. Photolithography is the most widely applied technology in the fabrication of microelectronic structures but this technique is expensive and too slow for the production of nanometre features. Self-assembly techniques provide the opportunity to produce features with a higher resolution down to a few nanometres. Micro-contact printing allows fast and reproducible production of chemical micro- and nanostructures with a resolution as good as 50 nm. Smaller dimensions are limited by the contact stability of the stamp with the substrate. Dip-pen nanolithography, blockcopolymer lithography, colloidal lithography, and self-assembled monolayer lithography are additional techniques that use self-assembly strategies to produce nanoscale structures. These methods are described in more detail below.
6.2
Lithographic patterning with photons, particles and scanning probes
Photolithography (Fig. 6.1(a)) and electron-beam (e-beam) lithography (Fig. 6.1(b)) are the most frequently used techniques in micro- and nanotechnology, used to manufacture components for computer technology. However, they have also been used most extensively to create features for patterning proteins and cells. Photolithography uses electromagnetic radiation to introduce a latent image into the appropriate material.38,39 The surface is first covered with a radiation sensitive film, usually a polymer called `resist', then exposed to a beam of radiation, which modifies polymer properties at the irradiated areas. Subsequently, a patterned structure can be developed through etching or
Micro- and nanoscale surface patterning techniques
153
6.1 (a) Schematic of the general principle of photolithography and patterning with self-assembled monolayers (SAMs) (e.g. on Au). A photoresist is deposited on the substrate (e.g. by spin-coating) of choice and light is shone through the mask of defined pattern creating a pattern. A SAM with one type of head group (thiol 1) is chemisorbed onto the exposed Au substrate. The leftover photoresist is then dissolved away and a second SAM (with a different head group) is chemisorbed into the gaps, thus creating a surface with different chemical patterns. (b) Schematic of lithography using either electrons (ebeam) or photons. The principle is the same as (a) except the pattern is written directly into the photoresist followed by developing with a solvent. In e-beam lithography features down to 5±10 nm are easily and reproducibly fabricated.
dissolution of the image, leaving a pattern of polymer on the surface that serves as a mask for further surface treatment of the uncoated areas. Different variations of these techniques, such as the use of short wavelength light sources, for example deep UV or X-ray, the chemical adjustment of the polymer resist material to the light source has allowed further decrease of patterned dimensions. The major drawbacks with conventional lithography are the large costs due to cumbersome fabrication processes and low throughput rates for nanometre sized features. In addition, photolithography is also not well suited for the modification of surfaces involving delicate biomolecules.
154
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
6.2.1 Photolithography (smallest feature size obtainable is 50 nm) Photolithographic micro-fabrication of surfaces is a well-established technique for the production of model surfaces with defined topographies or with chemically defined patterns. Photolithography with photons uses a mask or a hole to localise the beam spatially. This technique is one of the most widely used in science and technology. The resolution of photolithography increases as the wavelength of the light used for exposure decreases. On the other hand, as structures become increasingly small, they also become increasingly difficult and expensive to produce. With 193 nm light from an ArF excimer laser, patterning of features down to 150 nm has been achieved.40 Patterning of features below 100 nm becomes challenging because of the lack of transparent materials suitable for lenses or for support for photomasks at wavelengths below 193 nm. Sun et al. developed a scanning near-field photolithography (SNP) technique to pattern self-assembled monolayers (SAMs) on gold with feature sizes of 40±50 nm (Fig. 6.2). These materials have been used as masks for pattern transfer to the underlying gold substrate by wet chemical etching creating three-dimensional architectures.41 Chemical modification of the terminal reactive group of patterned SAMs will enable development of materials of interest and find applications in diverse areas of nanotechnology.42 Photolithography and focused laser methods have been used to pattern surfaces with molecular layers,43,44 but photolithography requires the use of harsh solvents and bases, making it incompatible with many biological molecules. The laser method uses an interference technique that does not allow generation of patterns of arbitrary complexity. However, protein patterning using chemical linkers to create a heterogeneous monolayer is achievable.44 Silanes have been a widely used reagent to attach proteins to silica or metal surfaces because they can withstand the harsh solvent system required to remove the resist. Textor et al. describes a photolithographic technique based on evaporated metal films of titanium, aluminium, niobium and vanadium with patterns in the 50±150 lm size range to study protein and osteoblast cell interactions with different geometries and chemical composition of the patterns.45,46 Spatz et al. used ArF excimer laser ablation to generate selforganised, grating-like periodic structures on the surface of PET films.47 They demonstrated that both the morphology and the orientation of the melanocytes are determined by the topography of the PET substrates structured by the laser. A novel PEG surface modification and patterning process has been proposed.48 This approach mimics traditional photolithography in that spin coating and UV exposure through a photomask are employed to create a polymer pattern. The obtained PEG hydrogel microstructures resisted protein adsorption and cell adhesion whereas non-modified substrate surface promoted cell adhesion and spreading.49
Micro- and nanoscale surface patterning techniques
155
6.2 Generating nanostructures by scanning near-field photolithography (SNP). In this example a combination of self-assembled monolayers and wet chemical etching are used to create the patterns. (a) An AFM topography image reveals a set of 55 5 nm parallel trenches etched into a gold film. The SAM used was a HSC15CH3 molecule chemisorbed to the gold surface. The wet chemical etching was performed using a solution of Fe(CN)62+/Fe(CN)63+. (b) The cross-sectional topography trace orthogonal to the lines (taken from ref. 41, with permission).
Other problems accompanied with photolithography are damage and deformation of the mask on exposure to energetic radiation and the high cost and low speed of this technique. Furthermore, it cannot be easily applied to nonplanar surfaces, tolerates little variation in the materials that can be used and provides almost no control over the chemistry of the patterned surface. Plasma lithography Goessl et al. have developed a method for the patterned immobilisation of cell surface receptor ligands on biomaterials surface based on the combination of radio-frequency glow discharge plasma (RFGD) and photo-microlithography.50 The method called plasma lithography combines the high spatial resolution of photolithography and the chemical versatility of plasma surface modification. In the first step a non-fouling background is deposited onto the polymer surface, and the surface is then coated with a positive photoresist that is exposed to UV
156
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
through a photomask that defines the pattern. In the second step, plasma treatment, a fluorocarbon plasma polymer is deposited onto this patterned surface. Surfaces composed of micro-patterned domains of fluorocarbon polymer can control the shape and size of vascular smooth muscle cells (SMC). Spreading restricted cells formed a well-ordered actin skeleton, and the cells were still confined to the areas of the adhesive pattern after two weeks. Dai et al. generated high-resolution surface patterns of various surface functionalities through the H2O-plasma etching using a TEM grid as a mask.51 They also extended this technique to include conducting polymers using the plasma-patterned, metal-sputtered substrates as the electrodes for electropolymerisation. The regions of the electrode surface covered by the plasma polymer are electrically insulating and hence inactive toward electropolymerisation, whereas the uncovered areas can effectively initiate electropolymerisation. Thissen et al. described a controlled excimer laser ablation technique of a plasma polymer-PEG modified substrate to fabricate surface patterns suitable for spatial control of protein adsorption and subsequent cell attachment.52 By using appropriate masks in the laser beam, a resolution of approximately 1 m was obtained.
6.2.2 Electron beam lithography (e-beam) (feature size obtainable down to 10 nm) In e-beam lithography, a focused electron beam is used to form patterned nanostructures in an electron sensitive resist film.53 Interaction of the electron beam with the resist causes changes in solubility and the formation of local spots that become soluble in a developer. Pattern formation using electrons is a method capable of forming patterns with nanometre resolution in a resist film. With e-beam writing resolution of 10 nm was achieved more then 20 years ago,54 conventional lithography with focused beams of electrons is slow and expensive.55 Consequently, e-beam lithography is more suitable for producing photomasks for optical lithography. Plastic surfaces have been patterned by combining homogeneous polymer grafting with e-beam irradiation and localised laser ablation of the grafted polymer,56 thus fibronectin was adsorbed selectively onto ablated domains and hepatocytes adhered specifically onto the ablated domains adsorbed with fibronectin.
6.2.3 Scanning probe lithography (SPL) (feature size obtainable down to 1 nm) Scanning probe lithography uses a small tip scanned near the surface of a sample to image and modify surfaces with atomic resolution.57,58,59 Advantages of SPL are the ability to generate features with any geometry as well as patterning of
Micro- and nanoscale surface patterning techniques
157
non-planar surfaces.60 Additional advantages of such an approach include simplicity (no need for clean room fabrication environment), the ability to pattern proteins under non-denaturing solution environments, and direct interrogation of protein binding events. Recently, SPL methods have been explored for patterning protein surfaces. Examples include the mechanical scraping of open patches within protein-resistant polymer films for subsequent protein adsorption,61 application of scanning electrochemical microscopy to derivatise electrode surfaces,62 and the use of nano-grafting to incorporate reactive sites into self-assembled monolayers.63 This method offers the possibility of creating as well as of reading extremely high-density protein arrays.64 SPL is used to scratch nanostructure in soft materials,65 to change the head group or packing density of organic monolayer catalytically66 or to write 30 nm patterns of alkanethiols on gold.67 SPL is a slow method because the writing speed is limited by the mechanical resonance of the tip and piezoelectric elements that maintain the constant separation between a tip and sample. For that reason SPL is better suited for the formation of masters than for replication, but efforts to develop faster SPL are continuing. The use of multiple-tip systems has increased production speeds remarkably.68
6.2.4 Dip-pen nanolithography (DPN) (feature size obtainable less than 100 nm) In dip-pen nanolithography (DPN), an atomic force microscope (AFM) tip is inked with a material known to self-assemble on a solid substrate, as depicted in Fig. 6.3. The tip is brought into contact with the surface, a water meniscus is formed and adsorbed ink is transferred to the substrate when the probe is held in contact or moved along the surface.69,70 The first DNP investigations used thiolbased ink and gold substrates67 but later it has been extended to other inks and substrates. Various oligonucleotides functionalised with a hexanethiol linker have been inked on gold.71 Collagen was also written on a gold surface by cysteine binding on the gold without destroying the helical structure of the collagen.72 Thiolated collagen and collagen-like peptide has been patterned on gold with line widths as small as 30±50 nm, the largest molecule thus far positively printed on a surface at such small length scales. Moreover, DPN can be used to generate complex multi-component nano-arrays of native proteins that are biologically active and capable of recognising a biological complement in solution.73,74 Other inks that do not chemisorb to the surface are being developed. Fluoroscently labelled proteins can be written on modified glass surfaces.75 Utilising electrostatic interaction between positively charged parts of a protein and negatively charged silica, proteins have been directly written onto silica surfaces.76,77 Hyun et al. developed a method to fabricate chemically reactive
158
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
6.3 The concept of dip-pen nanolithography (DPN). Schematic of the process using an AFM tip to deposit chemical moieties on surfaces after it is wetted with the desired molecule of choice. (Taken from Ref 67, with permission).
nanoscale features by patterning a SAM of a COOH-terminated alkanethiol on a gold substrate by DPN, followed by covalent immobilisation of biotin on the nano-patterned SAM and subsequent molecular recognition of streptavidin from solution.78 The resulting streptavidin nano-pattern provides a universal platform for molecular recognition-mediated protein immobilisation because of the ubiquity of biotin-tagged molecules. By this method, periodic arrays of biotinBSA with feature size of 230 nm were readily fabricated.
6.3
Soft lithographic techniques
Current lithography techniques appear to have reached their limits in terms of minimal feature size and fabrication cost. Thus, alternative methods need to be explored to go beyond these limits. An attractive candidate for achieving nanoscale structures is the phenomenon of self-organisation, in which certain materials under certain conditions will arrange themselves or self-assemble into stable, well-defined structures, e.g., when deposited onto a surface.79,80 The development of self-assembled systems has been a major advance in material fabrication technology during the last ten years.81,82 Self-assembly concepts originate from biological processes such as the folding of proteins, the formation of the DNA double helix and the formation of cell membranes from phospholipids. In self-assembly, subunits spontaneously organise into stable, well-defined structures based on non-covalent associations. Self-assembled monolayers
Micro- and nanoscale surface patterning techniques
159
(SAMs) provide well-defined ordered structures and chemistries that can be systematically varied. Also, spatially defined arrays of SAMs can be prepared by combining self-assembly with patterning methods such as micro-contact printing83 and photolithography.84 Self-assembly is being examined for patterning at scales greater than 1 m and applications are moving to smaller dimensions. Examples of self-assembly as a method for fabricating nanostructures include micro-contact printing of self-assembled monolayers,85 reactive ion etching with thin films of block copolymers as a mask86 and the synthesis of mesoporous materials with aggregates of surfactants as templates.87 Typically, this is a non-serial process (since the whole system organises itself at the same time) allowing patterning of large areas with high short-range and some long-range order. The thickness of the SAM is usually 2±3 nm, and can be tuned with a accuracy of 0.1 nm by varying the number of carbon atoms in say the monolayer alkyl chain. Polymers and block copolymers are an interesting class of molecules for nanomaterials fabrication88 and show a broad variety of self-organising patterns; such polymeric nanostructures find applications in diverse areas that include optics, biochemistry, and material science. The ability to use different molecules with well-defined chemical end groups adds to the flexibility of this approach to create nanoscale patterns of specific functionalities. Soft lithography has been developed as an alternative to photolithography and comprises a number of lithographic techniques such as micro-contact printing (CP),89 replica moulding (REM),90 micro-transfer moulding (TM),91,92 micromoulding in capillaries (MIMIC),93 and solvent-assisted micro-moulding (SAMIM).94 In soft lithography, an elastomer is cast against a rigid master (silicon wafer) and the elastomeric replica subsequently used as the stamp, giving structures that can be as small as 100 nm. Masters are made using conventional high-resolution nano-lithographic techniques. In this way it is possible to produce multiple copies of indistinguishable nanostructures from a single master, rapidly and economically.95 The common feature of these techniques is the use of a patterned elastomer (usually poly(dimethylsiloxane (PMDS)) as the mould, stamp or mask to generate or transfer a pattern to the substrate. In addition, soft lithography uses flexible organic molecules and materials rather than rigid inorganic materials commonly used in photolithography. Table 6.1 compares the features of photolithographic and soft lithographic approaches to surface patterning.83 In CP a PMDS stamp is used to transfer molecules of the `ink' to the surface of the substrate by contact, whereas in REM a PMDS polymer is used to duplicate structures of a master into multiple copies. In TM a drop of liquid pre-polymer is applied to the patterned surface of a PMDS mould. The filled mould is placed in contact with a substrate and irradiated or heated. After curing of the liquid precursor, the mould is peeled away to leave a patterned microstructure on the substrate surface. In MIMIC a PMDS mould in conformal contact with a substrate surface forms a network of empty channels
160
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
Table 6.1 Comparison of photolithography and soft lithography approaches83 Photolithography
Soft lithography
Definition of patterns
Rigid photomask (patterned Cr)
Elastomeric stamp or mould (PDMS)
Materials that can be patterned directly
Photoresist
Photoresist
SAMs
SAMs Polymers Colloidal materials Sol-gel materials Organic and inorganic salt Biological macromolecules ca. 30 nm
The smallest feature size
ca. 50 nm
that can be filled with a pre-polymer. After curing the liquid into a solid, the PMDS mould is removed leaving a network of polymeric material on the surface of the substrate. SAMIM is a combination of replica moulding and embossing. A PMDS mould is wetted with a solvent, and is brought into contact with the surface of the polymer. The solvent dissolves a thin layer of the polymer, and the resulting gel-like fluid conforms to the surface topology of the mould. After evaporation of the solvent a relief structure is formed on the polymer surface. Soft lithographic techniques require little capital investment and are very simple. They can often be carried out under ambient laboratory conditions. They are not subject to the limitations determined by optical diffraction and optical transparency. Table 6.2 is a summary of soft lithographic and other nonphotolithographic approaches to creating patterned substrates.91,94,96-110 Producing patterned biomolecule layers using soft lithographic techniques has a specific importance to a number of growing techniques such as advanced tissue engineering, biomineralisation, DNA computing and cultured neural networks. It is promising for microfabrication of relatively simple, single-layer structures for use in cell culture, in sensors or as microanalytical systems.111,112
6.3.1 Microcontact printing (CP) (feature size obtainable down to 35 nm) CP is also a method for chemically and molecularly patterning surfaces down to sub-micrometre length scales. It has been used to pattern self-assembled monolayers (SAMs) of compounds such as hexadecanethiols and octadecytrichlorosilane (OTS) on gold113 and SiO2114,115 surfaces. CP has an advantage over conventional photolithographic patterning methods in that it requires no harsh chemicals making it suitable for patterning biologically active layers.
Micro- and nanoscale surface patterning techniques
161
Table 6.2 Summary of non-photolithographic methods83 Method
Resolution
Reference
Injection moulding Embossing (imprinting) Cast moulding Laser ablation Laser-induced deposition Electrochemical micromachining Ink-jet printing Stereolithography Soft lithography Microcontact printing ( CP) Replica moulding (REM) Microtransfer moulding ( TM) Micromoulding in capillaries (MIMIC) Solvent-assisted micromoulding (SAMIM)
10 nm 25 nm 50 nm 70 nm 1 m 1 m 50 m 50 m
96, 97 98, 99 100 101 102 103 104 105 106, 107 108 109 91 110 94
35 nm 30 nm 1 m 1 m 60 nm
Additionally, it should be possible to pattern multiple molecular layers by repeated application of CP. CP was mainly developed with SAMs of alkanothiol on gold113 and silver.116 The CP technique is very simple; a PMDS stamp is first inked with a solution of molecules, often proteins or alkanethiols, and brought into contact with the surface of a substrate. The soft PDMS stamp makes conformal contact with the surface, and molecules are transferred directly from the stamp to the surface in the time frame of a few seconds. After printing, unmodified regions can be back-filled by deposition of a second molecule. Figure 6.4 is a schematic representation of the CP process. A key requirement for successful CP is the appropriate surface chemistry. The surface chemistry should allow high spatial resolution, low background adsorption, and high selectivity for molecule immobilisation. These conditions can be accomplished by using SAMs. If suitable SAMs are chosen, marked contrast in properties such as wetting or protein binding may be obtained. For example, Prime et al. used CP to generate a pattern of hydrophobic alkanethiols sites where proteins deposited from solution while non-patterned regions were blocked with PEG to prevent protein adsorption.117 They extended this method by combining CP and chemical reaction of ligands containing both amino and anhydride groups providing patterned SAMs presenting several ligands on the same surface, especially polar, charged, or structurally complex groups such as proteins, polymers, or oligosaccharides.118,119 Patterned SAMs on gold can also be used as ultra-thin resists in selective wet etching, protecting coated areas from chemical etching, while uncoated gold areas are removed to leave a structured gold film.120 The ability to pattern SAMs by CP, and resulting control over the adsorption of adhesive proteins, enables the patterning of cells on substrates121 and enables change in the size and shape of cells.122
162
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
6.4 Schematic of the well-established microcontact printing process developed by Prof. Georges Whitesides' group at Harvard University (taken from ref. 91, with permission).
However, this strategy cannot easily be extended to other non-metallic surfaces such as silicon or polymers. The importance of using patterning of silicon surfaces is immense for microelectronics, micro-machinery and micro-fluidics. Zhu et al. developed a two-step alkoxy monolayer assembly method for CP used directly on silicon surfaces based on a reaction between alcohol functional groups and Cl-terminated silicon surfaces.123 In an extended method they produced patterns of HO- and CH3O-terminated PEG regions whereby the HOterminated PEG monolayer was activated to immobilise protein molecules covalently.124 Generally, CP is inexpensive, very rapid and a powerful method for surface structuring, also applicable to curved substrates or inner surfaces and able to be used over a relatively large surface area (50 cm2) in a single step.125 Repeated printing using different stamps can allow complex surface patterns to be made of more than one kind of molecule. The smallest features generated to date with CP are trenches etched in gold with lateral dimensions of approximately 35 nm.126 By manipulation of the elastomeric stamps and the chemistry of SAMs formation, it is conceivably possible to reduce the size of features generated even further.127 Patterned microstructures fabricated using this technique may be useful in microelectronics, for micro-analytical systems, sensors, solar cells, and optical components. Patterned SAMs have also been used for the control of extracellular matrix protein adsorption and for the attachment of cells.128 It is possible to control the shape of the cell that attaches to a surface by creating islands of cell
Micro- and nanoscale surface patterning techniques
163
adhesion proteins onto substrate surface and thus to control cell growth and morphology. Polymers are widely used as biomaterials but cannot be modified by SAMs. Therefore, Chilkoti et al. developed a new method called microstamping on an activated polymer surface (MAPS) that enables patterning of biological ligands and proteins on polymer surfaces with a spatial resolution of at least 5 m.129,130 A requirement for MAPS is the presence of reactive functional groups in the polymer. Therefore, the surface of a polymer is modified to introduce the reactive group of interest. In a second step, an elastomeric stamp is inked with a biomolecule containing a complementary terminal reactive group and brought into contact with the activated polymer surface. This results in spatially resolved transfer and covalent coupling of the biomolecule on the polymer surface. To demonstrate the concept of MAPS, they patterned an amine terminated biotin molecule on carboxylated PET.131 Because MAPS is a simple and flexible method, it will be applicable to a wide variety of polymers that are amenable to surface modification. Hyun et al. demonstrated a simple method of patterning cells on commonly used polymeric biomaterials in the presence of cell adhesion proteins.132 This approach involves coating a polymer surface by solution casting a chemically reactive, biologically non-fouling comb polymer presenting short oligoethylene glycol side chains, activation of the surface, and patterning a cell adhesive peptide onto the surface of the comb polymer by MAPS to spatially direct the interactions of anchorage dependent cells with the substrate. The patterns of fibroblasts and endothelial cells were stable for long periods of time depending on the spacing distance between isolated features such as a square or stripe.133 Csucs et al. introduced a new variant of CP based on adsorption of a polycationic graft copolymer, poly-L-lysine-g-poly(ethylene glycol) (PLL-gPEG), on negatively charged surfaces through electrostatic interactions, rendering them highly protein and cell resistant.134 Furthermore, PLL-g-PEG can be modified by introducing biologically active ligands such as short cell adhesion peptide sequences (viz. RGD) at the terminus of PEG chains. Printing cell adhesive, peptide modified PLL-g-PEG followed with backfill with cell repulsive non-functionalised PLL-g-PEG, allows control of the concentration of biomolecules presented to cells at the interface. If the separation distance between adhesion sites was large (at least 30 m spacing) fibroblasts were found primarily on printed, cell-adhesive regions, whereas with smaller spacing between adhesive sites (less then 30 m) the cells were able to occupy nonadhesive regions as well. This observation can be explained by a bridging effect where cell pairs or agglomerates grow over non-adhesive regions without formation of cell-surface contact. Nanoscale objects such as colloidal particles can also be patterned on a variety of substrates including glass, silicon, and polymers using CP.135 An important feature of CP is that many proteins retain their biological activity after printing.136 It is possible to print the same surface with several
164
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
proteins using different stamps having various inks printed many times or using parallel inking of a stamp followed by a single printing.137 However, two limitations of CP as presently used hinder its progress in printing arbitrary patterns of biological molecules. First, the PDMS elastomer used for the stamp in CP is hydrophobic. When printing with water-based, biological solutions, the poor wetting characteristic of the hydrophobic stamp yields extremely non-uniform patterns. Therefore, the hydrophilisation of PDMS is a requirement for employing biomolecules and polar inks for CP that do not have an affinity for native PDMS. The simplest method for preparing a hydrophilic stamp is oxidation of the PDMS surface by O 2 -plasma treatment,138,139 but the stamp does not remain hydrophilic for a long time because of the migration of low-molecular silicone residues from the bulk to the air-stamp interface.140 Delamarche et al. overcame this problem by grafting of a PEG silane onto plasma oxidised PDMS that resulted in a stable hydrophilic stamp surface for an extended period of time.141 The second limitation is that the soft PDMS stamp lacks the rigidity necessary for precision alignment and geometrical control of the pattern and due to stamp deformation is not suited for the printing of features below 250 nm. To resolve this problem, James et al. developed a thin elastomeric stamp on a rigid glass backing in order to allow printing of small isolated features and improve the alignment and geometrical control of the patterns.142 Another, often neglected, drawback of PDMS-based CP is the low molecular weight PDMS contamination presented on stamped surfaces.143 To overcome mechanical and contamination problems, Csus et al. investigated the possibility of new materials in CP applications. A copolymer of ethylene and a -olefin such as butene or octene (POPs) was used for printing protein patterns.144 Due to the higher bulk modulus of the polyolefin stamp, much higher printing quality in submicrometre ranges can be achieved with the POPs stamp than with the PMDS stamp. Also, multiple protein patterning is difficult to achieve; a method for printing different proteins onto a single substrate involves using stamps having different patterns or various inks that are printed many times onto the same substrate. It has been found that accurate reproduction of patterns realised in PDMS stamps on gold substrates is problematic on a scale smaller than 500 nm due to the diffusion of ink molecules from contacted to non-contacted areas.145 Li et al. used CP without ink, and obtained sub-micrometre edge resolution (less than 100 nm).146 They brought a surface oxidised PDMS stamp into contact with SAMs of acid labile adsorbates. The silicon oxide layer on the outer surface of the stamp was acidic enough to hydrolyse these adsorbates. Finally, scanning probe contact printing is a method for generating patterns less than 500 nm using a scanning probe with an integrated elastomeric tip to transfer chemical materials onto a substrate.147 Each contact printing action creates an individual dot. This method allows generation of structures made of organic monolayers on surfaces with excellent multi-ink and alignment registration capabilities.
Micro- and nanoscale surface patterning techniques
165
6.3.2 Micro-fluidic techniques (micro-moulding in capillaries ± MIMIC) In CP the deposition of liquid samples followed by drying can lead to poorly defined patterns, protein aggregation and the loss of biological activity. An alternative method to bring a controlled amount of biomolecule in contact with a surface without loss of biological activity is through use of a micro-fluidic network (-FN). The method is based on conformal contact ± a watertight seal that forms via van der Waals forces ± between a soft PDMS structure and a hard surface such as silicon, glass or some polymer. One or both of the surfaces is structured so that a network of fluidics channels is formed when the two surfaces are brought together. The channel network can guide solutions of proteins or other molecules over the substrate and the molecules adsorb onto the surface of the fluidics channels with the pattern defined by the micro-fluidic network (Fig. 6.5a).148 Once adsorption is complete, the PDMS is peeled off, to give a patterned surface with molecules deposited on surface regions exposed to the solution. Microfluidic networks are a very powerful tool for surface structuring. This method is well suited for patterning highly sensitive entities like proteins and cells on a variety of substrates, and can be used at room temperature with aqueous solutions. It is a simple technique that forms patterned structures in a single step with very high accuracy on a wide variety of surfaces ± flat or curved ± with structures as small as 100 nm. Different molecules can be made to flow in different channels of the network. Delamarche et al.110 used MIMIC to pattern a variety of substrates with immunoglobulins with submicron resolution (Fig. 6.6(a)Ð(c)). Only microlitres of reagent were required to cover several mm2 sized areas. This technique enabled simultaneous and highly localised immunoassay for the detection of different immunoglobulins. The independent network of capillaries allows simultaneous attachment of different biomolecules in each zone of flow, as shown in Fig. 6.6(b).149 Gradients can also be made using solutions at low concentrations. The high surface-to-volume ratio of the small channels results in a depletion of the solution as it travels through the network, resulting in lower and lower quantitites of molecules deposited on the channels walls. Patel et al. developed a micro-fluidic patterning technique for any biotinylated ligand to be patterned onto the surface of a biodegradable polymer. Spatial control over cell appearance was also observed when using these templates to culture endothelial and nerve cells. Furthermore, pattern features containing laminin peptide sequences were achieved for directional control of nerve regeneration.150 However, MIMIC cannot form isolated structures or patterns on contoured surfaces because it forms a hydraulically connected network of capillaries. Additionally, the extremely slow filling of small capillaries may limit the usefulness of MIMIC in certain types of nanofabrication
166
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
6.5 The process of -FN for patterned delivery of proteins. (a) Patterned elastomer that forms a FN by contact with a substrate allows the local delivery of a solution of biomolecules to the substrate. (b) Flow of liquid between the filling pad and an opposite pad fills the array of microchannels that constitute the strategic part of this device. (c) Assembly of different zones of flow on the surface results from the independence of capillaries, each requiring only a small volume (1 l) of liquid to fill the zone and derivatise the underlying substrate. Left panel, top view; right panel, side cut along the channel (taken from ref. 110, with permission).
applications. Micro-fluidic networks must be sufficiently hydrophilic to promote filling of micro-channels by capillary action and should incorporate proteinrepellent surfaces to prevent depletion of proteins by adsorption to the walls of micro-channels. One approach to making micro-fluidic networks wettable and protein-repellent is to functionalise the channels with PEG.151 Another approach has been to prepare a polymer-based micro-fluidic device with defined and chemically reactive interfaces by deposition of sub-micrometre thin reactive coatings on the interior surface of micro-fluidic devices. The resulting coating was then used for immobilisation and self-assembly of a variety of biological ligands, proteins, and cells.152
Micro- and nanoscale surface patterning techniques
167
6.6 Schemes for the delivery and attachment of two different IgGs using a FN (a) followed by an immunoassay for the attached proteins after removal of the FN (b). A composite digital image shows light emitted from fluorescently tagged antispecies IgGs, each specifically recognising its binding partner previously patterned on a glass surface (c). The immunoassay is carried out with a heterogeneous solution of IgGs: tetramethyl rhodamine isothiocyanateconjugated antibody to chicken IgG (red), fluorescein isothiocyanateconjugated antibody to mouse IgG (green), and R-phycoerythrin-conjugated antibody to goat IgG (orange-red), each diluted 1:300 from their concentrated solutions. The left stripe comprises chicken IgGs and the right stripe comprises mouse IgGs. No light was evident from nonspecific deposition of antibodies to goat IgG anywhere on the surface. There was no green fluorescence on the left channel or red fluorescence on the right channel; each colour channel was collected independently so that such emission, resulting from cross-reactivity between the antibodies or their uncontrolled deposition, would have been easy to detect.
168
Surfaces and interfaces for biomaterials
6.4
Colloidal-based fabrication techniques
Colloidal particles as lithographic masks can increase the speed of patterning surfaces with nano-sized features. Colloidal particles of different materials can be produced with mono-disperse size distribution down to nanometre length scales. The colloidal particles served as an etch mask for the underlying substrate leaving the areas under the particles as hills. These particles can also be used as lift-off masks by filling up the surface surrounding the particles with a thin film. After removal of the particles, the underlying surface is exposed where the particles are located. One of the main advantages of this method over other lithographic techniques is that complex sample shapes can be patterned or coated with nano-porous layers. Spatz et al. have developed a copolymer micelle nanolithography method for generation of nanostructures on conductive and isolating substrates. The pattern dimension and geometry is controlled by the combination of the self-assembly of block copolymer micelles with pre-structures formed by photo- or e-beam lithography.153,154 This method allows bridging the length scale between several nm and 200 nm, through linking self-assembly nanostructures to structure sizes available from photo- or e-beam lithography. E-beam and photolithography by themselves are not able to write structures with such small dimensions over large areas, whereas self-assembly methods, such as the formation of nanoparticles in block polymer micelles cannot position particles in patterns with large ( m) separation distance and aperiodic arrangements. After formation of photo or ebeam resist patterning and coating with micelles loaded with a metal precursor, the substrate is dipped in a solvent to remove the resist film and any micelle deposited on top of the resist. The micelles inside the holes or grooves remain adsorbed at exactly the position where the hole originally formed. The substrate is treated with oxygen plasma in order to remove the polymer selectively, leaving behind Au-nanoparticles loaded into the core resembling the lithographic pattern. Combining these two techniques, gold dots of 1 nm diameter can be positioned with high accuracy. These dots c