ISSN 1861-2741 74714
www.sunwindenergy.com
9,50 € • International issue
12/2010
The Magazine for Renewable Energies
4th Solar Thermal world map
Disparity
in the world market
Photovoltaics
Solar Energy
Wind Energy
Module production: frames & adhesives
Solar glass: coatings gaining in importance
A trend towards flow line production
Visit us in Montpellier Energaïa December 8-11, 2010 Hall 12, Booth D600
Yields as secure as the gold in Fort Knox. Since 1936, the United States government has safely stored its gold at Fort Knox. Gold has been a dependable investment for centuries. Wise investors today put their money in PV. So it’s only natural that Fort Knox is equipped with a PV plant. No wonder the security experts have chosen inverters by KACO new energy. But watch out: Some would even steal for maximum PV yields. We say why bother when you can simply buy a KACO inverter. They are the safest investment around. Ask a dealer today! KACO new energy. We turn passion into power.
www.kaco-newenergy.de
Editorial
Fencing or the splits?
I
f you put one foot out in front of you and the other one out behind you, then at best you are ready to fight in the sport of fenc ing. At worst you are about to painfully do the splits. If you look at the development of renewable energies at the year’s close, then it is hard to tell whether the companies compe ting to supply energy from this sector will easily and elegantly grab the next points, or will hit the ground painfully. Take solar thermal: in our annual world map of the solar thermal industry we once again look closely at the sector. The survey of 248 collector manufacturers worldwide shows a clear disparity – the European manufactur ers are fighting against decreasing demand in their main markets, overcapacities and price pressures. Outside Europe things are moving forward at a pace, however. Especially the Chinese manufacturers are profiting from the strong growth in South Africa and Mexico, for example; their tubes are being used in collec tors all around the world. As our author Bärbel Epp has discovered, the top five Chinese vacu um tube manufacturers alone produced more square metres of collector area in 2009 than the 167 manufacturers of flat plate collectors which have disclosed their figures to us. China is also putting a constant price pres sure on European manufacturers in the field of photovoltaics. Although these keep trying to console themselves that their claimed higher quality can get modules made in Europe a price premium of around 10 %, it is uncertain whether this will be enough in the long term. The downward spiral of systems prices will continue, and the module manufacturers will have to bear a large portion of this load. The German sector association BSW-Solar has al ready announced there will be a step back next year – and this in the world’s most im portant PV market in 2010. Approx. 8 GW of newly installed capacity, that’s 54 % of new global installations, is the amount expected
Sun & Wind Energy 12/2010
by analysts for Germany this year – followed by Italy with approx. 1.8 GW. All other mar kets continue to be well below the 1 GW mark. The forecast for newly installed capaci ty in Germany in 2011 is still 6 GW, but from 2012 it is just 3 to 5 GW, with some analysts talking of an annual growth of merely 2 GW. In order to compensate for this, all the other countries would have to achieve annual growth rates of 100 % from 2010 to 2012, say analysts from the international market re search agency EuPD Research. The signals currently coming from the Czech Republic and Great Britain indicate that painfully doing the splits is the more likely outcome, however. And what about the largest bearer of hope: wind power? Here we have declining installa tion figures in Europe and a market collapse to almost half the 2009 figures in the USA. Unlike photovoltaics, though, China also plays an important role as an export market here. In the record year of 2009 the Middle Kingdom alone got 13 GW of new wind power capacity onto the grid, and up to mid-2010 they achieved a further 7.8 GW. Apart from this, only the USA and India are currently in the gigawatt league, at 1.2 GW apiece. Due to priority being given to the home market, China’s industry still doesn’t play an impor tant role in the international wind turbine business, but it does as a supplier of large components such as gearboxes. Perhaps it is this different structure which is enabling com panies to stay relaxed in 2010 despite declin ing installation figures. The wind power sec tor aims to be growing again in 2011 – and not only with one leg leading. With such differing perspectives for the future there is only really one thing which is true for everyone: our business will remain nail-biting.
Dr. Volker Buddensiek Editor-in-chief
[email protected]
3
Table of contentS Cranes: at the limits Cranes whose lifting power was celebrated as sensational 20 years ago are now rather more like toothpicks. There are obviously a lot fewer boundaries on the way up than previously thought.
Page 156
Photo: juwi
Off-grid: an alternative to gridbased supply Growing markets in the developing and emerging countries, and no less the development of new fields of application, have given a noticeable boost to the demand for autonomous PV electrification solutions. The manufacturers of off-grid inverters and charge controllers, however, in future will need to offer not merely individual devices, but rather complete systems for an off-grid power supply.
Page 106
1 74714
ISSN 1861-274
gy.com www.sunwindener
l issue
9,50 € • Internationa
12/2010
12/2010
Photo: Terex Demag
Energies for Renewable THE MAGAZINE
Solar thermal world map: the disparity is growing
Disthpeawroriltdymarket
un Photo: Chromas
MAL WORLD MAP 4TH SOLAR THER
in
PHOTOVOLTAICS
tion: Module produc sives he ad & s me fra
4
SOLAR ENERGY
atings Solar glass: co rtance gaining in impo
This year the world map of the solar thermal industry appears for the fourth time. Since the start in 2007 with 177 companies, participation has grown strongly to 248 flat plate, air and vacuum tube (collector) manufacturers this time. The disparity between the industry in and outside China has continued to grow.
Page 42
WIND ENERGY
s A trend toward tion flow line produc
Sun & Wind Energy 12/2010
Heating networks in Europe: potential for more Throughout the EU, only 40 megawatt-class collector arrays are in operation. However, examples in use show that very low solar thermal energy costs can be reached. Especially in Denmark the construction of solar thermal district heating systems is booming.
Pages 74, 79
Photo: Marstal Fjernvarme
Country Special Russia: second attempt at a green law Russia’s lobby for regenerative energies is small. Its first attempt to introduce a green energy law had failed perhaps for that reason. Now, the lobbyists have made another effort. What the outcome will be is still uncertain.
Page 38
Photo: RMCIP
Review
Solar Energy
88 Anti-reflective glass makes clear gains 94 Solar Power International in Los Angeles
Country Special 38 Russia: second attempt at a green law
Solar Thermal 42 62 66 72 74 79 83
World map of flat plate collectors and vacuum tube technology World map of air collectors Solar heat for luxury hotels Spain: solar contracting for 23 hospitals Heating networks: potential for more? Solar thermal district heating in Denmark Solar thermal products
CSp 84 Cost reduction: beating fossil prices
Sun & Wind Energy 12/2010
= manufacturing technology feature
Photovoltaics
98 Components: frames, laminating, bonding 106 Market overview of off-grid production 118 Dye cells: targeting the 12 % threshold 122 Japan wants to get back to the top 128 USA: “solarization” of the south-west 132 Greek market: Energy Photovoltaic, Athens 136 PV policies and products in Greece 140 Powerful prospects in Bulgaria
146 Automation: smooth transition 156 Cranes: at the limits 160 Gamesa’s global ambitions 162 Poland: plenty of catching up to do
Wind energy
BioENERGY 164 Cooking with wood on a closed fire 167 Biofuels in China: climate-friendly cars
Department 170 Directory 178 Preview and imprint
Photo: GTZ
6 International news 16 Taiwan pushes environmental technology 20 Ecodesign Directive for water heating 24 Optimism at RenewableUK in Glasgow 27 European Future Energy Forum in London 30 CSP Today Summit in Seville 32 A solar roof for Prague Zoo 34 High altitude wind power 36 Incentive schemes worldwide 169 International fairs
Cooking with wood on a closed fire In rural areas of Africa, Asia and Latin America, wood is the most widespread raw material used to generate heat for cooking and heating. However, this use of biomass in such regions is generally viewed as being harmful to the climate, the environment and human health. Now the situation should be improved by the introduction of more efficient stoves to replace open fires.
Page 164
5
Review
International NEWS
International
NEWS
200 kW: largest private solar power plant in the UK According to the company, Solarsense UK Ltd. started operating Britain’s largest private solar power plant. The 200 kW plant is situated on the cowhouse of the Worthy Farm in the town of Glastonbury in southern England. The grounds are used as a venue for Europe’s largest open-air music festival, attended by roughly 200,000 guests from all over the world. In Glastonbury two SolarMax TS series central inverters from Sputnik Engineering convert the direct current from more than 1,100 Romag solar modules into grid-compliant alternating current. Solarsense has purchased the inverters from Sundog Energy Ltd., one of the leading British companies for renewable energy systems. The Glastonbury yield is sufficient to supply 40 households with energy. In addition, the solar plant eliminates 100 tons of carbon dioxide emissions every year.
“The solar plant is our figurehead,“ says Michael Eavis, the owner of the Worthy Farm and initiator of the Glastonbury Festival. Photo: Solarsense
6
Retroactive solar tax shocks Czech PV industry
UK plans to amend FIT for ground-mounted PV systems
The political battle over consequences of the solar boom in the Czech Republic has resulted in a new legislation which will harm the local photovoltaics industry significantly. At the end of October the Czech parliament took the first set of restrictive measures for local photovoltaics. It stopped the tax holidays for all operators of PV plants and changed the write-off scheme to be applied retroactively to all PV plants. After strong protests from local investors, the deputies decided to limit an additional solar tax to a duration of 3 years (2011-2013). The tax will vary from 26 % (FIT for sold power to grid operators) to 28 % (so-called Green Bonus payments for electricity produced and consumed in the consumption place). Under the amendment, new photovoltaic power plants built on agricultural or forest land will no longer be entitled to the support. However, the existing power plants which will supply power to the distribution network will not lose the support. The new solar legislation will limit state support to solar power generation only to small rooftop power plants with solar panels attached to buildings. Moreover, there will also be no subsidies for offgrid systems from 2011. Under the amended law, operators of off-grid solar power plants which will start to operate by end-2010 will have 12 months to connect the facilities to the grid. Their entitlement to the support will be maintained if they connect them to the distribution network. If this is not technically or financially feasible, they will receive no more FIT payments from 2012.
Britain’s Energy Minister Greg Barker indicated plans to change the feed-in tariff (FIT) for ground-mounted PV systems in the UK. During parliamentary questions on November 11 he said that ground-mounted photovoltaic systems should “not be allowed to distort the market” for roof-mounted PV or other renewables. According to reports by the internet platform greenwisebusiness, the Minister said the government had inherited a FIT system that had failed to anticipate PV field systems which in his opinion threatened to distort the solar market. Alluding to the situation in Spain, he also said that the government would not act retrospectively. The Renewable Energy Association (REA) responded to the Minster’s statement by issuing a warning: “This statement is likely to worry potential investors in ground-mounted schemes,” said Gaynor Hartnell, Chief Executive of the REA. “Those that have acted in good faith, and already made substantial investments on legal works and preparation of planning applications, will be feeling very uncomfortable indeed.”
EU funds silicon thin-film research The European Commission is supporting the silicon thinfilm research project PEPPER with € 9.4 million. The project aims at reducing the production costs of silicon-based thin-film modules and raising their efficiency. PEPPER is coordinated by Oerlikon Solar, the manufacturer of production facilities. The project started on 1st September and is scheduled to last three years. The aim is to develop a production line capable of producing 157 W modules with a stable efficiency of 11 %. To this end, the project will study in detail the following points: thinner glass substrates, improved TCO properties (material growth and light trapping), faster silicon deposition and higher silicon quality.
Sun & Wind Energy 12/2010
Shine baby shine!
» Forget about oil. Solar electricity is the energy of the 21st century.*«
Larry Hagman, also known as the oil tycoon from the TV series “Dallas”, always had an intuition for profitable businesses. Now he focuses on clean energy made from the sun and sand, and on solar electricity systems from SolarWorld – winner of the Photon performance test in 2008 and 2009. High performance, German technology. Find out more about our smart solar solutions at www.solarworld.com * On his farm in Ojai, California, Larry Hagman established the largest residential solar power system of the Unites States.
Review
International NEWS
Groundbreaking of Ivanpah power tower plant On 27th October BrightSource Energy broke ground on the construction of the 392 MW power tower CSP plant Ivanpah Solar Electric Generating System. The plant is expected to be fully operational by mid 2013. California Governor Schwarzenegger and Secretary of the Interior Ken Salazar joined with members of the BrightSource Energy team, project partners, and local, state and federal officials to commemorate the event. The US Department of Energy supports the project with a US$ 1,375 million loan guarantee. The produced energy will be sold to various energy suppliers under power purchase agreements (PPA). Each PPA has a duration of 20 to 25 years.
US Secretary of the Interior Ken Salazar, California Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger and NRG CEO David Crane at the groundbreaking ceremony for the Ivanpah Solar Electric Generating System on October 27th.
In addition to the event BrightSource announced that power generation company NRG Energy will invest up to US$ 300 million for a partnership with BrightSource to construct, finance, own and operate the power plant. The Ivanpah power plant is the first commercial large-scale CSP plant in the
Groundbreaking of the 5 MW micro CSP plant Kalaeloa Solar One in Hawaii. Photo: Sopogy
Groundbreaking of 5 MW micro CSP plant in Hawaii At the end of October the Kalaeloa Solar One CSP project broke ground. The 5 MW plant will be equipped with SopoNova parabolic trough collectors from the Hawaiian company Sopogy. The system uses a high temperature energy cycle and works at temperatures of about 200 °C. The collectors are much smaller than collectors used in the commercial plants in Spain and the southwest US. Sopogy expects that they can produce energy at grid parity. In Hawaii this would be around 26 US-Ct/kWh. The Kalaeloa Solar One project is a partnership between the State of Hawaii, Department of Hawaiian Home Lands (DHHL) and Keahole Solar Power (KSL). Sopogy plans to complete the plant before November 2011 to present it at the Asia Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) to leaders from 21 countries. The state of Hawaii also recently announced a feed-in tariff for renewable energy projects. Hawaii plans to generate 70 % of its energy from renewable energy sources by 2030.
Photo: BrightSource Energy
United States that will use power tower technology. The plant will use three receivers, each located on a high tower. Thousands of mirrors will track the sun on two axes and focus the light to the receivers. There water is heated to 550 °C creating superheated steam with a pressure of 160 bar, that is piped to a steam turbine.
Final building permission for 1,000 MW plant Blythe In October, US Secretary of the Interior Ken Salazar authorized the land use rights for the Blythe solar power plant site in California. A total of four solar thermal power plants are to be built there with an overall capacity of almost 1,000 MW. With the approval of the land use rights, the entire approval process has now been concluded. Initially, Solar Millennium will build two power stations with a capacity of 242 MW each. The construction work is scheduled to begin already this year. It is planned that the first power generation unit will be connected to the grid in 2013, followed by the second one in 2014. At the Blythe site, the global irradiance is 2,700 kWh/m2 and thus about 30 % higher than in Spain, the second large CSP market apart from the USA.
CSP plant Hualapai Valley receives environmental certification The Arizona Corporate Commission (ACC) approved the 340 MW Hualapai Valley Solar CSP project’s Certificate of Environmental Compatibility (CEC). The CEC was the last approval for the project developer Mohave Sun to begin construction of the power plant. Beside the plant itself, the CEC approves interconnection and transmission plans. The Hualapai Valley plant got the approval to
8
use wastewater for an evaporative cooling system. The ACC expressed that Hualapai is likely to be the last project that gets approval to use water cooling. Due to the limited water resources in the area, further power plants will have to use dry cooling, which is more expensive. Hualapai Valley Solar and the nearby city of Kingman are evaluating possible sources for wastewater. Since a binding Memoran-
dum of Understanding in December 2009, both sides are working on a water purchase agreement that would supply more than half of the water needed for the power plant. The source would be the city’s Hilltop Wastewater Treatment Plant that treats about 1.5 million gallons of wastewater per day. The agreement for the output of the Hilltop facility is expected to go before the City Council within this year.
Sun & Wind Energy 12/2010
Review
International NEWS
Fresnel collectors in front of the model stadium in Qatar. Photo: Mirroxx
Qatar applies for FIFA World Cup with a solar stadium The Emirate of Qatar hopes to organize the FIFA World Cup in 2022. In order to help get a decision in their favour, in September the application committee presented the FIFA inspectors a model stadium that had been erected especially for this purpose. It offers space for only 500 people but shows what the World Cup stadiums might look like. The stadium is equipped with an air-conditioning system powered by the sun. Fresnel collectors with a total surface area of 1,400 m2 provide the heat to drive the absorption cooling system (T = 200 °C). The collector array was made by the German company Mirroxx GmbH and is its largest project to date. The air that has been cooled by solar energy flows underneath the grandstand. The
stadium roof can be opened and closed as needed. This provides shade in the middle of the day, without which it would not be possible to cool the stadium. In the evening the spectators can admire the starry sky. A photovoltaic system installed on the site makes sure that the stadium has a positive ecological balance in terms of its power supply. The electricity generated is fed into the national grid. The connection to the grid and a generator running on biofuel ensure the stadium’s electricity supply. Apart from Qatar, Australia, Japan, Russia, South Korea, Great Britain and the USA have also applied for the FIFA World Cup. Additionally, there are joint applications from Belgium and the Netherlands as well as from Spain and Portugal.
Solimpeks receives British MCS approval Solimpeks’ photovoltaic/solar heat hybrid collector, which generates hot water and electricity simultaneously, received the Microgeneration Certification Scheme (MCS) approval in the United Kingdom. Thanks to this certificate, the electricity which is produced by the PVT collectors can be sold under the feed-in tariff in the UK. Also the Turkish manufacturer entered into a distribution agreement with the British company Newform Energy. Pilot projects with the PVT collectors are installed in Great Britain and Turkey. “This year, we are going to sell around 1,000 PVT collectors. In 2011, we are already aiming at 10,000 units,” said Kemal Ibis, Communication Director at Solimpeks. The collectors are available in two designs: the Volther PowerTherm for maximum thermal output and the Volther PowerVolt for a maximum electrical output. The classic PowerTherm collectors, which generate only solar heated water also got the MCS approval and can benefit from the Renewable Heat Incentive, as soon as the latter is launched.
10
Pilot project: 24 PowerTherm and 24 PowerVolt collectors are mounted on the roof of the Chedwode children’s home in Surrey County, Great Britain. The financial payback time is 12 years.
Solar prize for candle manufacturer The Solar Agency Switzerland has recently presented the candle manufacturer Fischer Kerzen with one of the Swiss Solar Prizes 2010 in the category energy installations. The medium-sized company Fischer Kerzen AG from Root in Switzerland uses 600 tons of paraffin annually to manufacture candles. Until the beginning of 2010, the two storage tanks for 40 and 27 tons of paraffin were heated exclusively electrically. In order to save electricity, the company then decided to use solar energy. “We quickly realized that the temperature range of 65 to 110 °C that is continuously required here can only be covered appropriately by vacuum tube collectors”, says Business Manager Peter Schlaufer of the Swiss solar planning and installation company BE Netz AG from Ebikon, which designed the system. Vacuum tube collectors from the Swiss company B.energie AG from Rottwiel were chosen, a distributor of collectors from Augusta Solar GmbH in Augsburg, Germany. The heat from the 128 m2 of vacuum tube collectors is fed into the thermal oil circuit that maintains the paraffin’s temperature via a new plate heat exchanger. The use of a second heat exchanger allows hot water generation and the heating system to be additionally supplied with solar energy. The solar installation will provide 40 % of the heating energy needed for candle production in future. “The fact that we are active in a seasonal market, and thus our main production period lasts from May until November, favours the utilization of solar energy”, says Martin Kretz, member of the management board of Fischer. Nonetheless, technological and financial challenges had to be met.
Photo: Solimpeks
Sun & Wind Energy 12/2010
Review
International NEWS
WWEA half-year figures: USA and Spain weak that are currently under construcIn the first half of 2010, a tion are finished by the end of the capacity of about 16 GW year. was installed worldwide, with In Europe, the wind industry China accounting for almost half of , , , cannot complain. In Germany, this figure. The World Wind Energy , , , , 660 MW were installed and , Association (WWEA) speaks of “ro, , 500 MW each in France and Great bust growth”. By the end of the , , , Britain, which are satisfying interyear, 40 GW might be reached. , , im results. The 450 MW in Italy But the wind energy market is , , , , and 230 MW in Portugal mean developing very differently in the , , that in these two southern Euroindividual regions. In Asia, the in, , pean countries the development dustry can be satisfied with the is also proceeding according to figures because development is , , , plan. Only Spain stepped out of proceeding at a fast pace not only , , , line. This country, which was the in China but also in India. There, The top 10 countries with the greatest newly installed wind power market leader in Europe just a 1,200 MW were newly installed in capacity in the first half of 2010 Source: WWEA few years ago, is falling further the first six months of this year – and further behind. Since only this is already almost as much as 400 MW were installed there in the first half of comparison with the market’s potential. In the capacity added in the entire twelve 2010, the target of at least getting close to the 2009, almost 10,000 MW were added in the months of 2009. previous year’s figure (2,500 MW) is now far USA. This year, half of that will be achievable A total of 1,200 MW were also achieved in out of reach. at best – but only if the numerous wind farms the USA, but this is a disappointing result in
South Korea announces 2.5 GW offshore farm According to yonhapnews.co.kr., South Korea is going to build a US$ 7.8 billion offshore wind farm in the Yellow Sea. “The plan is to make South Korea the world’s third-largest country in terms of offshore wind power generation,” Kang NamHoon, Head of the Ministry of Knowledge Economy’s energy and climate change policy division, was reported. The three-phase plan announced by the ministry calls for the construction of a “proving area” by 2013 to test 20 turbines (5 MW) from South Korean manufacturers near Buan, North Jeolla Province, and Yeonggwang, South Jeolla Province. Further 180 turbines of the same size will be installed by 2016 as “experimental complex”, followed by 300 turbines by 2019, to generate a total capacity of 2,500 MW. The electricity will be supplied nationwide through substations in Gochang and Saemangeum in North Jeolla Province.
UDE opens wind farm in France The German group UDE (Unternehmensgruppe Dezentrale Energie) and its French subsidiary éolec S.a.r.l. have put the wind farm Vent d’Orvilliers-Saint-Julien into operation. The 12 MW farm Orvilliers-Saint-Julien, the construction of which began in October 2009, is located in northeastern France, in the southern part of the region Champagne-Ardenne. The farm comprises six Enercon turbines of the type E 82 and has meanwhile been sold to the wind energy company NGE Energie SAS. According to UDE, the completion of the wind farm was preceded by a long development phase because the basic conditions for wind energy in France had kept changing over and over again. “Plans for an extension of the wind farm have already reached an advanced stage, though”, said the General Manager of UDE, Alexander Jäger-Bloh.
Scotland: £ 70 million for offshore wind energy The Scottish government has established a fund with a volume of £ 70 million (about € 82.4 million) to support renewable energies (see article on page 24). This was announced by the Scottish First Minister Alex Salmond at the annual conference of the wind and ocean energy industry “RenewableUK 2010” in Glasgow. The aim of the National Renewables Infrastructure Fund is primarily to finance the expansion of port and production facilities in order to strengthen the entire supply chain from the development to the production of offshore wind turbines in Scotland. The money provided by the fund will be distributed by the economic development agencies Scottish Enterprise and Highlands & Islands Enterprise by 2015. The Scottish government says it has plans for the installation of more than 7,000 wind turbines on the British coast over the next ten years.
12
Many of the guests took the opportunity to get a view of the new wind farm from a hot air balloon. Photo: UDE
Sun & Wind Energy 12/2010
World leader in Solar Water Heaters 30 years before the others discover the power of the sun Thirty years of manufacturing Solar Water Heaters, means thirty years of innovating in the field, and introducing new technologies. Three decades of continuous development, combined with vast experience and extensive research, have established MEGASUN products as leaders in most world markets. Thousands of MEGASUN Solar Water Heaters are successfully in use in most countries of the world –from Athens to America and from Africa to Australia, to all Asia and Europe – providing continuous and abundant hot water. Today HELIOAKMI not only represent highly specialized technology and the experience of thirty years, but high quality systems which meet the highest demands. The solar water heaters are offered in both closed and open circuit, in a range varying from 120 to 300 liters. The forced circulation systems are offered from 150 liters up to 1000 liters, and they are offered as complete units or separately. Each systems consists of: • a storage tank with 1 or 2 heat exchangers (coils) • Collector(s) of 2,10m or 2,60m • Support base of the collector for flat roof or tiled roof • A carton box which includes all the connection accessories, the differential thermostat, the pump, the expansion pot, the antifreeze liquid, valves… etc. Instantaneous efficiency curve of collector
1. Solar collectors 2. Storage tank (boiler) 3. Hydraulic kit 4. Expansion pot 5. Differential Thermostat
Rend.= 0,767 - 0,37
INTERNATIONAL RECOGNITION
Helioakmi S.A., NEA ZOI 19300 ASPROPYRGOS, ATTIKI - GREECE Tel.: (+30) 210 55 95 624 - 210 55 95 625 - 210 55 95 626, Fax: (+30) 210 55 95 723 No 1 under the sun
I n t e r n e t : w w w. h e l i o a k m i . g r • e - m a i l : m e g a s u n @ h e l i o a k m i . g r
Review
International NEWS
Schmack investigates biogas microbes The German company Schmack Biogas AG is attempting the commercially viable breeding of microbes that are able to increase the yield attained in biogas plants by 20 % and the turnover by up to 100 %. The German Federal Ministry of Food, Agriculture and Consumer Protection is supporting the project. Laboratory experiments using two bacterial species discovered by Schmack have
already resulted in a doubling of the volumetric loading of a biogas fermenter without any acidification of the process. Yield increased by almost 20 % on a laboratory scale when various feedstock materials such as cereals, maize and slurry were used. Now, Schmack wants to develop a method to make the sensitive bacteria suitable for storage, transport and commercial marketing.
With the current status of the technology, the targeted addition of microorganisms to biogas plants is not feasible. So far, it has not been possible either to specify the bacterial cultures that become established in the fermenters precisely, or to influence them systematically. Schmack also wants to study the way in which the two isolated bacteria affect the species composition of the microbes involved in the fermentation process.
New Bulgarian renewable energy law The Bulgarian Ministry of Economy and Energy presented the new Law for Renewable Energy. One of the most important changes is that the tenders for grid connection will be replaced by a selection procedure. The procedure will be regulated by the State Energy and Water Regulatory Commission (SEWRC). Investors in green energy will have to apply to the SEWRC. Together with participation from transmission and distribution companies the commission will decide whether the application should be satisfied. Until 28th February every year the operators of electricity distribution grids will have to inform their possibilities of grid connection to the transmission grid operator. The
transmission operator will present the capacities to the SEWRC and to the Ministry of Economy and Energy until the end of April of every year. Until 30th June the SEWRC will present the number of capacities that could be connected. Then investors will have the opportunity to apply to the SEWRC. If there are more applications than free capacities, it will decide which projects are accepted. For each MW of installed capacity the investors will have to pay a connection fee of € 25,000. The money will be distributed to the distribution and the transmission grid to cover all related expenses. If the grid connectors do not connect the power plant within the provided deadline, they will have to pay back an amount which is double the
Aquamarine Power USA receives grant Aquamarine Power USA LLC, subsidiary of wave energy company Aquamarine Power UK, has been awarded US$ 50,000 by the Oregon Wave Energy Trust. The grant will pay for a feasibility study into the potential for deployment of Aquamarine Power’s Oyster wave energy technology off the coastline of the US state of Oregon. The grant is intended to help deploy Acoustic Doppler Current Profile devices that measure and record the frequency, intensity and height of waves as they approach the Oregon shoreline. Aquamarine Power will be searching for local vessels to deploy the devices.
Each passing wave activates a pump, which delivers high pressure water via a closed-loop sub-sea pipeline to the shore. Onshore, the water is converted to electrical power. Photo: Aquamarine Power
14
fee paid by the investor. Renewable energy projects will receive a feed-in tariff which will not be diminished during a long-term contract with the public supplier. For geothermal and solar power this will be a time period of 25 years. For all other renewable energies it will be 15 years. The new law proposes that all new capacities over 1 MW have to be licensed. In the old law this was not necessary until the projects had a capacity of 5 MW. The law also sets ground for a new Agency for Sustainable Energy Development (ASED) which will take functions from the Agency for Energy Efficiency and regulatory procedures for the certification of renewable energy.
South Africa considers a CO2 tax The government of South Africa is discussing the introduction of a CO2 tax. The first proposal for such a tax is currently being examined by the Ministry of Finance. Should the government actually introduce the tax, this is unlikely to happen before 2012 or 2013, says the German Energy Agency (dena). The tax would be intended to help develop the renewable energy sector in South Africa. The country wants to reduce its greenhouse gas emissions by 42 % by 2025. At present, South Africa produces 90 % of its electricity in coal-fired power stations, which places the country among the 20 largest carbon dioxide emitters in the world. A CO2 tax on cars has already been in force since September of this year.
Sun & Wind Energy 12/2010
312 billion for fossil fuels The International Energy Agency (IEA) has published its annual World Energy Outlook. The report reveals that in 2009 the consumption of fossil energy sources was subsidized worldwide with US$ 312 billion. Iran, Saudi Arabia, Russia and India are the countries where the highest subsidies were paid. About half of the total amount is attributed to oil products. The IEA proposes abolishing the subsidies for fossil fuels in order to increase the competitiveness of renewable energies. This could lead to a significant reduction of the worldwide greenhouse gas emissions. Renewable energies are currently supported with about US$ 57 billion annually. If all the political announcements of support for renewable energies were put into practice, these subsidies would rise to US$ 205 billion by 2035. This would not raise the support to the level of subsidies for fossil fuels, but the IEA report says that the competitiveness of regenerative energy sources will also improve due to rising prices for fossil fuels. Therefore, the average subsidies per MWh of electricity produced from regenerative sources will drop from 55 US$/MWh in 2009 to 23 US$/MWh in 2035. According to the IEA, the climate protection measures that have been announced so far are not sufficient to limit the extent of global warming to a maximum of 2 °C. The so-called 450 Scenario shows what would be necessary to achieve this target. In order to limit the atmospheric greenhouse gas concentration to 450 ppm CO2 equivalent, increased efforts in the fields of energy efficiency and renewable energies are necessary. Because this would limit the demand for fossil fuels, the energy prices in the 450 Scenario rise even more slowly than in the other scenarios. The failed climate summit has thus imposed on humanity additional costs in the amount of at least US$ 1 trillion. The failures in our climate protection efforts before 2020 will cause high follow-up costs because after 2020 even greater efforts will then become necessary in order to limit global warming.
Sun & Wind Energy 12/2010
Substituting coal through biomass A power plant, owned and oper- ated by DTE Energy Services in Michigan, is now delivering power from biomass. The 40 MW plant located in Cassville, Wisconsin, was converted to wood waste as fuel instead of coal. So, renewable energy at the plant is produced through the burning of green wood residue from forestry and tree trimming operations, railroad ties, demolition waste and sawdust. A second project by Boldt Construction in Wis-
consin and the British engineering firm AMEC is on its way. The Heating Plant at the University of Wisconsin-Madison will be converted from coal to biomass. The US$ 251 million project will include the replacement of coal-burning boilers, initially with natural gas furnaces, but by 2013, the plant will be burning about 250,000 tons annually of wood chips, corn stalks and switchgrass pellets from around the state, according to the university.
Review
Tigis Taiwan
Taiwan pushes environmental technology At the end of October, three trade fairs all opened their doors at once in Taipei, the Taiwanese capital. In addition to the established “PV-Taiwan” and the “Electric Power”, the “Taiwan International Green Industry Show” (TIGIS) completed the trio.
T
Organic food, bicycles, wind power – everything under a single roof. The TIGIS is still struggling to establish a distinctive profile. Photos: Jörn Iken
16
he “Green Industry Show” is the youngest child among the aforementioned trade fairs, which serve the purpose of demonstrating Taiwan’s export prowess. This year, TIGIS took place for only the second time. The exhibition is still struggling to find a distinctive profile. So far, it has been dominated by a mixed programme ranging from brushes via organic food up to professional wind turbines. Considering its wide spectrum of exhibits, it currently resembles a consumer fair that demonstrates all the areas of life for which products under the premise of sustainable production have become available. But the child is growing. Therefore, it would be a mistake to underestimate the TIGIS as a showcase of an export industry specialized in sustainable products and eco-friendly systems engineering. Taiwan is the second-largest exporter of solar cells and together with the People’s Republic of China controls the global PV market. With regard to the environmental technologies, the relatively small country ranks sixth in the world and second in Asia. Just how seriously the Taiwanese economy is already taking the TIGIS is shown by the fact that more than 180 exhibitors were present at the first repetition of the fair, including such heavyweights as Formosa Heavy Industries and the Taiwanese utility, Taiwan Power. Their participation also indicates that the wind in Taiwan is starting to turn towards a sustainable energy supply system. Neither company – and this became immediately evident in discussions – is a forward-charging pioneer in the field of renewable energies. Formosa Heavy Industries is wellknown worldwide as a supplier of turnkey coal-fired power stations and together with Taiwan Power dominates the Taiwanese energy market. So far, they have both tended to favour conventional methods of power generation. Nevertheless, Formosa Heavy Industries
presented a wind turbine gearbox of its own with a rated capacity of two megawatts, the TFC 2000. This is already the second large component that Taiwan has contributed to the global wind industry supply chain; the other one is rotor blades. At four locations in the People’s Republic of China, the Taiwanese company Red Blades, founded in 2008, produces rotor blades with a length of up to 50 metres – corresponding to a 3 MW turbine. “Red Blades produces chiefly for the Chinese market, and we are better than the Chinese manufacturers”, said Vice Chairman James Lee, laying claim to a position among the premium manufacturers. “Among the companies that are active in China, we were the first to have ourselves certified by Germanischer Lloyd, in 2008”, he emphasized. According to Lee, Red Blades delivered 200 rotor sets in 2009; the target for 2010 is 300 sets. Lee commented: “We supply quality and do not have to hurry up with capacity expansion.” The latter phrase may be considered an understatement: a capacity of 1,200 sets will be achieved by the end of 2010.
Door opener for the Asian market Although the island of Taiwan is currently being held in an economic “brotherly embrace” by the People’s Republic of China – despite far-reaching political differences – Lee complains about the limited access to orders in the People’s Republic. “Only 60 % of the market on the mainland (meaning the PR China: ed) is really free.” But Lee admits that for his Taiwanese company things are nowhere near as difficult as for European companies that want to gain a foothold in the PRC. Lee sees good chances for the Europeans in the emerging offshore industry. “For Europeans, it is important to be present in Taiwan. In Asia, it is not
Sun & Wind Energy 12/2010
Sunny prospects for your profit. gehrtec product innovations. Based on our 16-year experience in the photovoltaic market and realization of many solar power plants, the technicians from Gehrlicher Solar AG constantly develop new product ideas up to production readiness. You can build on our mature product line.
www.gehrlicher. com Gehrlicher Solar AG . Max-Planck-Str. 3 . D-85609 Dornach/Munich . Phone +49 89 420792–134 .
[email protected]
Review
Tigis Taiwan a lways the price that decides, but the connections you have.” Forty locations for offshore wind farms have been identified by the Taiwanese government. It is planned to erect two 5 MW turbines in the sea within the next two years. The French energy group Areva is being discussed in relation to this project. They were present at the TIGIS with a large stand. Lee himself sees further export opportunities for his company in the USA. “We have a Korean partner who delivers to the USA.” The example of Red Blades highlights the function of Taiwan and its companies as a link to China. The country is considered a “renegade province” by the PR China and even militarily threatened, but in terms of economic issues it has enjoyed great and benevolent attention from the Chinese mainland for years. For example, there is a free trade agreement between the two countries. This, and the cultural and ethnic similarity with the mainland Chinese – which still exists despite Taiwan’s western orientation – makes Taiwan a door opener for western companies. The same applies the other way round.
Small wind turbines dominate
Small wind turbines with a three-figure wattage – here a model from Boltun – dominated the scene. They were a clear focus at this year’s TIGIS.
Inevitably, photovoltaics hardly played a role at the TIGIS – solar energy was covered by the neighbouring PV-Taiwan. In terms of power generation, this cleared the way for wind power at the TIGIS – but rather in the form of “small wind power”, which is rather neglected in Europe. Here, a disambiguation is necessary: in Europe and the USA, “small wind power” means the capacity classes from about 20 kW upwards, whereas in Taiwan it is really small. The company “iWind Cell Power”, for example, offers vertical axle turbines with capacities ranging from 300 W to 12.5 kW. Senior Officer Henry Shan points to several awards that have
been presented to iWind, especially for the hybrid systems. “We entered into wind power via the controller of a wind turbine”, says Shan. “Now, we focus on stand-alone systems consisting of a solar panel, a wind turbine and a battery, but we also sell grid-coupled systems.” The small wind turbines start operating at a wind speed of 1 – 1.5 m/s, stop at 16 m/s and can survive typhoons with 60 m/s. This capacity range and the vertical position of the axle predestine the turbines for urban utilization, for example for street lighting. iWind installs the larger units in the kW class, which feed electricity into the grid, on top of high buildings. The company Digisine Energytech has designed its wind turbine as a take-away package, which will be available via the internet in future. At the fair, the wind turbine with its classical horizontal axle could be purchased for just US$ 899 – plug-and-play, of course. The 600 W turbine can also be combined with a 100 W PV panel. If this is coupled with a battery, a street lamp that is equipped with such a system can work for three days without electricity generation. What is still a niche solution in Europe seems to be developing into a mass market in the USA, Malaysia and especially on the islands of Micronesia. According to Digisine President David Wu, the company currently sells 1,500 units per month on average and wants to double its capacity in the short term. Also Jacken Chen, the President of Hi-VAWT Technology Corporation, confirms that business with the small wind turbines is booming. “I firmly believe that the volume of the US market will triple within the next three years.” From his point of view, Taiwan’s industry with its small wind turbines is not only competitive, but also ahead of its international competitors. The turbines are technically mature, says Chen. “Above all, the problem of noise has been solved”, he continues. “Our turbines work at a noise level of 40 to 50 decibels – this is sleeping room noise level. If you want to sell small turbines, you have to comply with this.” The competitor Boltun was somewhat more sceptical at the TIGIS. “The market potential is one thing, actually selling is another”, said Executive Assistant Alex Chen. So far, the share of small wind turbines in overall turnover has been rather small, but: “It keeps growing constantly.” He sees the potential for his company’s small wind turbines in off-grid applications. Boltun has customers in the rural communities of China and Vietnam, in highway lighting in the USA and in the leisure industry. In order to really get going, the market for small wind turbines needs to reach a “critical mass” – this was the unanimous opinion at a wind energy conference that took place parallel to the TIGIS. The Taiwanese felt encouraged by the statement of the Vice Governor of the US state of Idaho – thinly populated and with its untouched landscapes just made for off-grid applications. “We want big projects with small turbines. This field is wide open for Taiwan.” Jörn Iken Further information: www.greentaiwan.tw
18
Sun & Wind Energy 12/2010
Review
Ecodesign Directive
“Above ‘A’ only with renewables” At present, the Ecodesign Directive for water heating systems is in the final review phase. SUN & WIND ENERGY talked to Xavier Noyon, the Secretary General of the European Solar Thermal Industry Federation (ESTIF), about the effects Ecodesign will have on the solar industry. S&WE: Mr. Noyon, when is the Ecodesign Directive for water heating equipment expected to come into force? Xavier Noyon: If the schedule announced in June 2010 is met, it will be adopted by mid 2011 and enter into force by mid 2012 – if every thing goes according to plan. S&WE: There was a lot of criticism of the first drafts of the directive from the solar industry. Only systems combining a solar installation with a boiler were to obtain a label. This would have pushed the providers of purely solar installations out of the game. ESTIF has stood up for changes in this respect. Does the regulation now do justice to the solar industry? Noyon: Yes, we are proud to say that we have changed the content of the text and come up with a solution that broadens its scope and opens interesting perspectives for our industry: the installer label. The energy labelling of a space or water heating system will either be done by the company placing a complete system on the market under its own brand name or by the installer proposing two components, i.e. solar thermal plus another heat generator, from different brands.
“All methods are based on exiting standards or pre-standards” S&WE: In order to be able to classify systems, they have to be measured. What are the measurement methods that will be used? Noyon: There are three options for the determination of the solar output. All methods are based on exiting standards or pre-standards, adapted for the Ecodesign and energy labelling legislation. Firstly, the EN 13202-3 method for complete systems consisting of solar thermal collectors and conventional heater. Each combination of components is tested separately. Secondly, the EN 15316-4-3, B method for solar systems, used when the collector can be tested sep-
20
As in the case of domestic appliances, energy labels will probably also divide heating systems into classes from G to A+++. Photo: BMU/Brigitte Hiss arately from the system. The collector (EN 12975), the heat store (EN 12977-3) and pump are tested separately. Thirdly, the ISO 9459-5 method can be used for all solar systems and, in particular, for systems with an integrated auxiliary heater or with an integrated collector and heat store. The system, consisting of collector, heat store and pump, is tested as a whole. Existing collector, heat store and system test results can be used, although it may be necessary to complement them with additional calculations. Third party testing is not necessary, the norm will be self-certification. S&WE: So there is no institution that certifies the products according to Ecodesign and that assigns the labels? Noyon: The companies placing products on the market and the installers will perform the labelling. As is usual for CE marking and other EU requirements,
Sun & Wind Energy 12/2010
Review
Ecodesign Directive checking by the public authorities will take place through the usual market surveillance procedures. The approach chosen by the European Commission is the one of so-called self-certification. S&WE: For the consumer, the energy label will be decisive. It will presumably divide the products into classes from G to A+++. Where will the systems with a solar component be positioned? Noyon: In the current proposal from the EU, the best fossil fuel condensing boilers can reach A or A+. The combination with solar thermal or heat pumps brings the system to A+, A++ or A+++. With regard to the rating of the solar thermal systems, the discriminating factor will be the surface area of solar collectors rather than their performance. ESTIF has proposed a rating which would make A+ impossible to reach for systems with only fossil fuels and which would reserve A+++ for very high performance collectors.
“The role of public authorities and the industry will be crucial for the success of the energy label.“
Xavier Noyon
Photo: ESTIF
S&WE: Do you expect that Ecodesign will bring forward the renewable energies in the heating sector? Noyon: First of all, and as explained above, the rating must be very clear: above “A” only with renew ables. Then, the role of public authorities and the industry will be crucial for the success of the energy label. The market transformation can only take place if public authorities promote the label and, more importantly, make use of it in the implementation of their own energy efficiency measures, and if the industry incorporates the label in its marketing and supports the installers. The commitment of both public authorities and the industry is crucial because the energy label for space heating and dedicated water heaters is very different from the previous label in two respects: heating systems are not purchased by the end consumers in the same way as tele visions or fridges, and the
“ installer” dealer is vested with a role that does not have an equivalent for other product labels.
“We consider that the consultation process has been long enough” S&WE: At the moment, the EU is concerned with water heaters. How far has the Ecodesign process for space heating systems proceeded? Noyon: The discussion on the dedicated water heaters has nourished the debate on the more complicated methodology for space heating. It seems that after years of consultation processes, the European classical heating industry wants to drastically change the methodology and labelling for space heating. They wish to over-simplify the labelling and change the installer label approach. The solar thermal industry together with the heat pump industry wish to go forward now, we consider that the consultation process has been long enough and we want to take advantage of the impetus on the market provided by the National Renewable Energy Action Plans and the recast of the Energy Performance of Buildings Directive. This very late attempt to delay the process is a real concern for us since the classical heating industry is also a major player in the solar thermal and heat pump industry. They primarily raise two points: the labelling is too complex and includes too many parameters like load profiles and climate zones, and the installer label is too difficult to implement for installers and would, in some cases, give different results than those from the system label, thereby discriminating in favour of solar thermal systems. We think that the current parameters are a must if one wants real information to reach the consumers about the performance of the system and thus cause a real market change. We are aware that the installer label requires some improvements, but we consider that installers of ST systems have the necessary skills to perform what is expected of them. We would not take the risk of compromising our relationship with our main distribution channel: the installers. In general we are concerned that re-opening the debate on space heating might delay the whole pro cess of adoption, including the directive for dedicated water heaters. That is why we have written to Commissioner Oettinger to show our support for the current version of the texts. The interview was conducted by Jens-Peter Meyer.
Ecodesign Directive The aim of the Ecodesign Directive is to formulate minimum requirements on the efficiency of water heaters (see S&WE 1/2010, page 62). It is planned to ban inefficient units from the market, similar to the situation with light bulbs. The energy efficiency label is closely associated with the Ecodesign Directive. The label, which is familiar to consumers from fridges and washing machines, shows the level of energy efficiency of the respective product.
22
Sun & Wind Energy 12/2010
July 12–14, 2011 North America’s Premier Exhibition and Conference for the Solar Industry Moscone Center, San Francisco
800 Exhibitors 1,600 Conference Attendees 22,000 Visitors Co-located with
www.intersolar.us
Review
RenewableUK 2010
Optimism
was the order of the day The 32nd annual RenewableUK conference and exhibition on 2nd November at the Scottish Exhibition and Conference Centre in Glasgow welcomed almost 6,000 delegates and 318 exhibitors, well up on previous years.
I
The three day conference of fered a wide range of sessions and workshops. Photos (3): RenewableUK
24
f you are in the solar sector, you might think that the name “RenewableUK” covers all renewable technologies. In fact, you would have looked in vain for any solar, biomass or geothermal companies at RenewableUK 2010, the three-day conference and exhibition put on by the trade association formerly called the British Wind Energy Association. The name was recently changed to “RenewableUK” in deference to the many wave and tidal energy companies which have joined. So the event dealt exclusively with wind and marine. The “core sponsor” was ScottishPower Renew ables, a division of part of Iberdrola Renovables. While rejoicing over the UK’s having recently hit the milestone of 5 GW of installed wind, Maria McCaffrey, CEO of RenwableUK, in her opening speech focused on the key challenges: the struggle of UK onshore wind to progress, mainly due to local opposition to wind farms and related delays in planning applications, the need for better infrastructure and the need for more government support. Aviation is another challenge for developers.
Despite the problems, recent good news from government created a highly positive atmosphere overall. For several months, in advance of the coalition government’s Comprehensive Spending Review on 20th October, the UK’s renewables community was in a state of deep apprehension. As large spending cuts were threatened, many feared that the feed-in-tariff (FIT), introduced by the previous government in April 2010, could be drastically cut or even eliminated. In fact, the Spending Review maintained the UK’s existing renewable energy support regime, consisting of FITs, and Renewable Obligation Certificates (ROCs). So as delegates converged on Glasgow, renewed optimism was the order of the day. In addition, due in part to heavy lobbying by RenewableUK, the government retained a commitment to upgrade UK ports, essential for the offshore sector, and certain other long promised “green” measures, such as a Green Investment Bank and a Renewable Heat Incentive, are to be introduced in the near term. FITs are due to be reviewed in 2012, with any changes to be implemented in 2013, though the government has reserved the right to review the situation at any time. The timing is less clear on ROCs, but, despite deep spending cuts in other areas of the British economy, the Spending Review recognised the cleantech sector’s need for a measure of certainty on existing schemes.
Sun & Wind Energy 12/2010
Scotland’s First Minister Alex Salmond addressing the delegates at RenewableUK Apart from the support regime, other problems came up at the conference sessions, such as possible competition between the oil and gas sector and the renewable sector in the UK’s offshore waters. Another problem: the lack of recognition given to British manufacturing success along the supply chain. Because Britain still does not have any domestic turbine maker, all wind turbines are imported, mainly from Vestas and Siemens. However, a vast range of components, such as Natural Power’s new lidar technology, called ZephIR 300, for assessing wind speed, is produced in the UK.
Scotland’s claim to leadership in renewables Scotland not only hosted the event but its big push on offshore wind and marine dominated the proceedings. On the opening day, for example, Scotland’s First Minister, Alex Salmond, gave a rousing speech. He restated Scotland’s commitment to 80 % renewable energy by 2020, well ahead of the national government’s target of 15 %, and took the opportunity to announce a new National Renewable Energy Infrastructure Fund for Scotland, which will have £ 70 million (€ 82.4 million) in funding over the next four years. “This is our declaration of faith,” he said. Reviewing progress to date, Salmond claimed that his administration had enabled 35 major renewable energy projects, generating more than 50 MW. In regard to Scotland’s potential in wind, wave and tidal, he estimated 206 GW, “enough to power all of Germany”. “We aim to transform the way we use energy,” he added. He also discussed various Scottish initiatives, including the National Renewable Energy Infrastructure Plan, the Offshore Wind Industry Group and Scotland’s Offshore Route Map.
Sun & Wind Energy 12/2010
Review
RenewableUK 2010 By now, UK government ministers are well accustomed to appearing at renewable energy events where, despite what many in their audience see as failure of real leadership on climate change, they do their best to reassure the sector. With the Coalition government claiming to be “the greenest government ever”, Charles Hendry, Energy Minister, addressed a gala dinner and said: “Some 20 GW of generating capacity will shut down by 2020 and we need to invest £ 200 billion in our energy infrastructure, first to replace it, and then to build the extra electricity capacity that decarbonising our economy will require. And a large part of winning over this challenge is being a world leader in renewables.” He also promised a new “Delivery Plan for Renewables” in the spring. “This will give industry a clear direction and priorities and accurately and realistically reflect market and investor views.” An electricity market reform package was also promised, and the industry was invited to take “vigorous” part in the consultation. Most important, Hendry said there would be no retrospective changes. “If you decide to invest in the UK, you should be able to feel certain that the terms of that investment will not subsequently be altered.” Hendry also promised to “sort out” the planning regime, a major barrier to investment, and to address grid constraints. He also discussed the supply chain and exports: “We are already exporting key components to other offshore wind markets – for example, Burntisland Fabrications has supplied foundations components to the Greater Gabbard project, but has also supplied the German Alpha Ventus offshore wind project.” He concluded by expressing “massive optimism”. “We have in this country the skills, the intellectual genius; the invention; the business leaders; the shared commitment to make this transformation happen.” Delegates listened politely, not necessarily sharing his “massive optimism”. No one knows how much real support will be delivered.
Parallel sessions Besides wind energy novelties the exhibition gave insights into marine energy develop ments.
Throughout the three days, delegates could choose from a wide range of meetings, workshops and side events at any given time, including a technical track. For example, a session called “New Offshore Wind Technology” started the technical track. Søren Houmøller, Di-
rector of Technology, Vestas Offshore, predicted that the design costs of turbines were set to fall and he called for industrialising of the installation process. “Foundations now account for 25 percent of overall costs, of which one third goes for installation,” he said. Norbert Giese, Senior Vice President, Business Unit Offshore at REpower Systems AG, spoke of jobs. “We have 90 people in Edinburgh and we are recruiting 24 for our Ormonde project,” he said. However, at this point the new recruits will be sent to Germany for training, in order to work on larger turbines. Referring to the UK’s perceived lack of manufacturing, Giese reported that the jacket foundations for Alpha Ventus were built in the UK in 2009 – and then shipped to Germany. He also said that Ormonde would have a relatively high “local content” of 50 %. Deeper water requires new boats and Giese reported that a new jackup vessel has been ordered which can service and maintain up to 240 turbines. A platform supply vessel and a workboat have been ordered. “Future projects will be larger”, he added, comparing his company’s 10 MW Beatrice project, opened in 2006-07, with Ormonde, set to generate 150 MW by 2011. The technical session continued with Jonathan Wheals, an innovation engineer at Ricardo UK Ltd, addressing the problem of bearing failure. He claimed that Ricardo’s MultiLife bearing would increase the life of bearings by 500 % when the inner race of a gearbox or direct drive is fixed. A test rig for indexing the inner race is being built, due to start in February 2011. And Makhlouf Benatmane, Director of Business Development at Converteam Ltd., discussed the fusion of a wind power generator and power electronics. His Direct Drive Active Stator is a permanent magnet generator that facilitates the use of DC tower cabling – and will help enable HVDA transmission on the planned supergrid. Amman Lafayette, Marine Energy Manager, E.ON Climate and Renewables, said that his company will have invested € 8 billion in 2007-12 and hopes to be able to cut costs sharply. The company’s first marine project is the Vagr Atferth P2 demonstration project at EMEC – the European Marine Energy Centre in Scotland – uses a Pelamis P2 device that aims to enable quicker progress towards a large scale. E.ON is also working with ScottishPower Renewables on the Orcadian P2 demo project at EMEC. Other sessions addressed grid connections, medium wind, planning, aviation, electricity market reform and other issues. On the last day McCaffrey evaluated the event: “We have gone from strength to strength. This event is bigger than ever.” She also mentioned the role of technology: “Scotland was not expected to be strong in offshore wind as we were limited to 40 to 50 meters of depth by monopiles. However, with developments in jacket technology from the oil and gas sector, and developments in foundations, including floating technology, we’re on our way.” Elizabeth Block Further information: www.renewable-uk.com
26
Sun & Wind Energy 12/2010
European Future Energy Forum
Review
Cause for hope A
t the opening of the EFEF, sponsored by Abu Dhabi Future Energy Company (Masdar) and UK Trade & Investment, the Prime Minister, David Cameron, appeared on video. Prince Charles, as Patron of the Masdar Institute of Science and Technology, inscribed a message in the conference programme. And Secretary of State for Energy and Climate Change Chris Huhne appeared to speak of his commitment to “future energy”, the term in use at the forum. Along with the rest of the first day audience, estimated at more than 800 delegates, the minister knew that the timing of this particular speech was doubly ironic: the forum opened one day before the results of the new Coalition government’s comprehensive spending review were to be announced. And everyone knew that, whatever Huhne said about the urgency of promoting renewables and cutting CO2 emissions by 2050, the spending review would produce severe cuts in government spending, due to the UK’s large deficit. As the minister spoke, however, no one listening knew what tomorrow would bring. So rumours flew around the conference, especially in regard to the UK’s new feed-in tariff, introduced by the previous government in April 2010. Rumours were also rampant about the government’s investment in ports, needed for offshore wind, and the establishment of a Green Investment Bank. In the event, feedin tariffs were retained, the government promised to invest in ports and £ 1 billion was committed to a Green Investment Bank, much less than many had predicted.
If one were to judge the UK’s commitment to new energy by the attention that its most highly placed politicians give to renewable energy conferences, it would appear to be a very strong commitment. The European Future Energy Forum (EFEF) attracted more than 800 delegates to London.
A truly European conference As this was a European conference, several continental ministers spoke on the first day, and tribute was paid to the late Hermann Scheer, the great German advocate of renewable energy who sadly died the week before the conference. Christine Lins, Secretary-General of EREC, said: “We must take Hermann Scheer’s vision forward. We will do our best to pay tribute to his legacy.” Ministers included Lykke Friis, Minister for Climate and Energy in Denmark, Pedro Marin, Secretary of State for Energy in Spain and Carlos Zorrinho, Vice Minister for Energy and Innovation, Portugal. These three ministers participated in a large and very lively panel, entitled “Future Energy Movers and Shakers”, that also included representatives from industry, such as E.ON and Siemens, and “influencers” such as Greenpeace International and WWF-UK. The session was moderated by broadcaster Steve Sedgwick, the anchor at CNBC. In the session, Lykke Friis amused the audience by referring to Larry Hagman, the actor who played
Sun & Wind Energy 12/2010
Dr. Sultan Ahmed Al Jaber, CEO of Masdar (middle), agreed about the need for a “new industrial revolution” in regard to renewable energy with Tony Douglas, CEO of the Abu Dhabi Ports Company (left) and Dominic Jermey OBE, UK Ambassador to the United Arab Emirates. Photos (2): Masdar
27
Review
European Future Energy Forum
Participants of the Zayed Future Energy Prize Workshop (from left to right): Satoshi Ogiso, Toyota Motor Corpora tion; Dipal Barua, Bright Green Energy Foundation; Dr. Sultan Ahmed Al Jaber, Masdar; Amitabha Sadangi, IDE India; Jerry Stokes, Suntech Europe; Jean-Philippe Denruyter, WWF International; Steve Sedgwick, CNBC anchor
the oil magnate in “Dallas”, the famous American soap opera. “Larry Hagman now has a big solar array, his reaction to the Gulf oil spill,” she said, adding that Denmark will not rest on its “green laurels”. “The bill for clean energy is a kind of insurance. We aim to be independent of fossil fuels by 2050.” Pedro Marin called for strong government commitment to R&D and stressed the need for new financial mechanisms to fund renewables. He also mentioned the need for more “inter-complementary” use of renewables and said: “A new energy revolution has started and we must keep up the momentum.” Many other speakers, including Sultan Al Jaber, CEO of Masdar, talked of the need for a “new industrial revolution” in regard to renewable energy. This be-
came one of the themes of the conference, along with the usual appeal for more stable government policy in all countries. Portuguese minister Carlos Zorrinho called for a “real European energy market”. “Portugal has no fossil fuel reserves so we are investing in new energy and energy efficiency.” He claimed the second highest installation of wind energy after Denmark, up sevenfold in five years. Portugal’s lack of fossil fuels contrasts, of course, with the oil-rich situation of Abu Dhabi. Sultan Al Jaber emphasised: “We want to become the global platform in the future energy challenge.” He spoke of growing energy consumption worldwide, along with increased population, and said: “Oil-producing nations like the UAE can be leaders and we are diversifying into renew
Principal Sponsor
DB Climate Change Advisors
Associate Sponsor
Now in its 4th edition, the World Future Energy Summit is the world’s foremost, must-attend annual meeting for the renewable energy and environment industry, held in Abu Dhabi from 17-20 January 2011. In 2010 WFES brought together over 600 exhibitors and 24,000 attendees from 148 countries including world leaders, international policy makers, investors, academia, intellectuals and journalists to find practical and sustainable solutions for today’s energy security and climate change challenges.
Official Transport Partner:
Project Village Research Partner:
International Broadcast Partner:
Media Partners:
ENVIRONMENT EXHIBITION
ables. This is our responsibility and we can provide a major push.” At the solar PV session, Adel El Gammal, Secretary-General of EPIA, talked about uncertainty. “The only market we see as stable for the next two years is Italy. We must fine-tune the system and provide a transparent framework,” he said. Eicke R. Weber, Director of the German Fraunhofer Institute for Solar Energy Systems, talked about the success of the sector. He said: “Even the most optimistic projections of PV back in 2003 have been wildly overtaken. We will reach grid parity in residential and industrial with all other fuels by 2030.”
Competing sessions The EFEF differed from other renewable energy conferences in that it not only had a large exhibition area but the exhibitors presented regular talks, in competition with the sessions in the main halls. This added to the overall “buzz” but made it difficult for delegates to decide on the best use of their time. To make attendance even more challenging, after the first day, the sessions were divided into “streams” such as the infrastructure stream, the renewables stream and the finance stream. The events held by exhibitors included UK Trade & Investment (UKTI), which had its own white plastic “igloo”, Masdar, with its “Future Urban Zone”, Siemens, with its “Green Technology Theatre”, Schneider Electric, with its “Electric Energy Efficiency Theatre”, and other installations. Fortunately, the events in these zones tended to repeat, making it easier for delegates to absorb as much information as possible.
Zayed Future Energy Prize As Masdar is the instigator of the Zayed Future Energy Prize, the most valuable environmental prize in the world at US$ 1.5 million, there were two sessions on this prize. At the first one, 2009 winner Dipal Barua, Founder and Chairman of the Bright Green Energy Foundation, spoke movingly about the large majority of rural people in Bangladesh who have no access to “modern energy”. He explained how he had started back in 1996, using a combination of micro-finance and solar lighting to replace kerosene in 600,000 homes in Bangladesh to date. Many local women have been trained to be solar technicians. The prize conditions require that the prize money be re-invested in the winning scheme. The jury is headed by Rajendra K. Pachauri, Chairman of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. This year’s winners will be announced at the World Future Energy Forum in January 2011 in Abu Dhabi. In conclusion, the EFEF, like many conferences on new energy, raised hopes with strong speeches, but it remains to be seen whether the many ideas and appeals for consistent policy will be heeded. Elizabeth Block
Sun & Wind Energy 12/2010
VISIONS WITH ENERGY
Energy for the future
We offer our European partners sophisticated system solutions for grid-connected and off-grid solar power plants, solar heating plants, solar cooling plants, alternative heating technology and small wind power plants. You receive a comprehensive service and product offer including consulting and support for the development and planning as well as the delivery of components and complete plants of renowned manufacturers – and such from a one-stop shop.
Review
Belén Gallego, organizer of the CSP Today conference, and Michael Geyer from Abengoa Solar at the awards ceremony. Photo: Eva Augsten
cSp today summit
From Spain to the rest of the world At the CSP Today Summit in the Spanish city of Seville, new and emerging markets were a big topic for the 650 attendees.
W
hile it is usually great to meet close friends, there are a few situations when people are happy to see lots of unfamiliar faces. “In pre vious years I knew almost everybody here. This year I see many people I do not know and I am very glad about this, because it means that this conference is getting bigger”, said Valeriano Ruiz, head of the technology platform CTAER, at the opening of the CSP Summit in Seville. Solar thermal power plants are experiencing good times in southern Spain. The CSP industry is grow ing and so is the CSP summit. This year 650 people attended, so it was a fitting event for the country that currently has the biggest CSP market in the world. According to the industry association Pro- termosolar, Spain has 14 operational CSP plants. Twelve more are under construction and more than 30 are pre-approved to ensure that they will receive the feed-in tariff in accordance with Royal Decree 661/2007. The follow-up decree is still in the works, and nobody knows what level of feed-in tariffs to ex pect for future CSP plants in Spain. But surprisingly, the future feed-in tariff was not a topic of discussion at the conference – neither in the official proceed ings, nor in the coffee breaks. The CSP industry seems to be busy and satisfied with the plants still to be built under the old feed-in tariff. Indeed, there is still quite a bit of work to do to finish those plants.
30
Work – or more precisely, employment – is what makes the CSP industry so popular with regional and local governments. Three government entities pre sented a new project at the CSP summit in Seville. The Ministry for Economy, Innovation and Science of the Regional Government of Andalusia, with the help of the Innovation and Development Agency of Anda lusia (IDEA), and the Council of Sanlúcar la Mayor have joined forces to attract enterprises to a new technology park called “Soland” at Sanlúcar la Mayor, next to the Abengoa solar plants. The new technolo gy park offers space for about 100 companies. Due to the pending new legislation on feed-in tariffs, how the CSP market in Spain will develop on the medium term is far from certain. At least, the cur rent draft for the new legislation says that once a tariff has been granted for a particular plant, it cannot be retroactively reduced.
Solar power from the desert Other CSP markets around the world were an important issue at the conference. Charles Ricker of BrightSource Energy shared his impressions of the groundbreaking ceremony for the Ivanpah power plant that took place just a few days before the conference. The Ivanpah power plant will be the first large-scale solar plant in
Sun & Wind Energy 12/2010
the US based on tower technology. Besides the US, where construction of CSP plants is resuming, the Middle East and North Africa (MENA) region is consid ered a very promising market for CSP technology. Of course, the Desertec project that envisages power generation for Europe in the MENA region was a topic at the session dedicated to the region. CSP is commonly expected to play a major role in the Desertec project, due to its dispatchability and be cause it is easily scaled up. Rainer Aringhoff, COO of the Desertec Industrial Initiative, presented a very down-to-earth impression of the opportunities and challenges of Desertec. He pointed out very clearly that, in future, the MENA region will be one of the big gest markets. “You all go where the feed-in tariffs are. But that does not make sense on the long run. You have to go where the resources are,” he said, ad dressing his audience. On the other hand, Aringhoff did not neglect to mention that the CSP industry will have to discuss its costs and prices. He pointed out the drastic price decrease that photovoltaic plants have experienced within the past few years. “We will have to ask how much price difference one kilowatthour of dispatchable power is worth,” he said. Unlike others, Aringhoff does not seem fully convinced that CSP will provide power from the desert to Europe. “If CSP does not get moving within the next three to four years, it has lost the race against photovoltaics,” he said. To drive down costs, innovations will be neces sary. Unfortunately, banks tend to see innovations as a risk rather than an opportunity. How to make inno vations bankable was therefore the topic of another session. Eva Augsten
CSP Today Awards
At the conference dinner six companies were honoured with the CSP Today Awards. A jury of renowned industry experts selected 21 finalists across seven individual categories prior to the event, and the winners were then selected by a popular vote during the course of the summit.
The winners were: CSP commercialized technology innovation: > SkyFuel (SkyTrough collector) Increased dispatchability solution: > ACS Cobra (salt storage at Andasol 1) Emerging markets achievement: > Abengoa Solar (CSP plant Shams 1 in Abu Dhabi) Newcomer of the year: > Cargo Power & Infrastructure from India CSP technology supplier of the year: > Schubert & Salzer (market leading valve manufacturer) EPC contractor of the year: > Abener and Teyma (EPC for CSP plant in Shams) CSP engineering firm of the year: > Foster Wheeler
Sun & Wind Energy 12/2010
31
Review
PRAgue ZOO
Climate and species protection under one roof The zoo in the Czech capital has a new attraction. A total of 68 silicon solar panels will produce 15,000 kWh of ecofriendly solar power annually.
A
s Director Miroslav Bobek emphasises, Prague Zoo itself consumes the solar power it has produced. “We strongly support the environ ment. A priority of mine is to reduce the zoo’s energy consumption and to switch to renewable energy. The photovoltaic system on the African House’s stables allows energy and cost savings. It’s also an interest ing source of information for our visitors”. Prague Zoo was established in the north of the Vltava metropolis in 1931 and today extends over an area of 60 hectares. Some 4,600 animals are kept there and include 660 species from around the world. Prague Zoo’s main responsibility is to breed the ani mals in as natural a habitat as possible, provide infor mation to and raise awareness in visitors. The zoo is involved in different projects to preserve the diversity of species – at both national and international level. For instance, Prague Zoo has significantly contribut ed in preserving Przewalski’s horse (an Asian wild horse). In 2008, Forbes Traveller Magazine declared it one of the best zoos worldwide. Every year, the zoo attracts about 1.2 million visitors.
An IBC Solar and dena project The PV system on the African House has a capacity of nearly 17 kW. Photo: IBC Solar
“Prague Zoo’s solar roof is an efficient and eco-friendly power source with no CO2 emissions”, said Udo Möhrstedt, founder and CEO of IBC Solar AG, when com missioning the solar system which has a total capacity of just under 17 kW. The company has installed the system
in cooperation with the German energy agency dena as part of its Solar Roofs Programme. In the future the solar roof will provide the zoo with eco-friendly power which will largely be used by the zoo itself and compensated with about € 0.43 via the “green bonus” law. Conditions for producing solar power in the Czech Republic are good. The solar radiation values are com parable to those of southern Germany. The legal condi tions for photovoltaic systems in the Czech Republic have also been attractive until recently. Every kilowatthour of solar power from roof systems of up to 30 kW fed into the grid was compensated with almost € 0.47. However, on November 9, the Czech government has decided to cut back feed-in tariffs for 2011 and to intro duce a tax on income from PV systems. To actively promote photovoltaics in the Czech mar ket, IBC Solar offers free training courses for installers, ranging from dimensioning and safe mounting of sys tems, to lightning protection, to financing and statuto ry conditions. “In the long term, IBC aims to expand its trade partner network in the Czech Republic”, explains Gerhard Travnicek, head of the company’s Prague of fice. “To achieve this goal, we will share our years of ex pertise and showcase the wide range of photovoltaic applications. Working closely together benefits all part ners. We can gain from the experience and relation ships of our local installion partners. And our Czech partners can capitalize on our technical expertise and global supplier network”.
Boosting export The PV system for Prague Zoo was part-financed by the “dena Solar Roofs Programme for Foreign Market De velopment”. This initiative was launched to enhance the share of renewable energy in local energy supply abroad, while at the same time supporting German companies’ entry into new markets. It is part of the Renewable Energy Export Initiative and co-financed by the German Ministry of Economics and Technology (BMWi). “The solar system on Prague Zoo is a flagship project in several ways”, confirms Travnicek. “In this way, we can convince visitors of the benefits of solar energy generation every day. It is emission-free, noise less and adversely affects neither visitors nor animals. This project will allow us and dena to promote German solar technology in the Czech Republic.” Anke Müller Further information: www.ibc-solar.com www.ibc-solar.cz www.dena.de dena Solar Roofs Programme: www.exportinitiative.de/solardachprogramm
32
Sun & Wind Energy 12/2010
Bayer MaterialScience AG, 51368 Leverkusen, Germany,
MS00044801
BAYFLEX BAYMER BAYPREG BAYTHERM BAYTEC BLENDUR MULTITE REG®BAYFIT BAYTHERM BAYTEC BLENDUR BAYSAFE MULTITEC VULKOLLAN ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ®®BAYPREG ® ®BAYTHERM ® ® FILL BAYTEC BAYFLEX BAYMER BAYTE AYFLEX BAYMER BAYPREG BAYTHERM BAYTEC BLENDUR BAYSAFE ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ULKOLLAN BAYDUR BAYFILL BAYFIT BAYTEC BAYFLEX BAYMER BAY AYFILL BAYFIT BAYTEC BAYFLEX BAYMER BAYTHERM ® ® ® BAYPREG ® ® ® ®BAY® ® ® MULTITEC ®®VULKOLLAN ® ® ® NDUR BAYDUR BAYFILL BAYFIT BAYTEC BAY EC VULKOLLAN BAYFIT BAYTEC BAYMER ® ® ® BAYDUR ®BAYFILL ® ® BAYFLEX ®® ® ® ® ® ® ® HERM BAYTEC BLENDUR MULTITEC VULKOLLAN BAYDUR BAYFILL LENDUR BAYSAFE MULTITEC VULKOLLAN BAYDUR BAYFILL BAYFIT B ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ®BAYTHERM ® ® ® ® YMER BAYPREG BAYTEC BLENDUR MULTITEC VULKOLL REG BAYTHERM BAYTEC BLENDUR BAYSAFE MULTITEC VULKOLLAN ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ®BAYTHERM ® ® ® FIT BAYTEC BAYFLEX BAYMER BAYPREG BAYTEC BLEND AYFLEX BAYMER BAYPREG BAYTHERM BAYTEC BLENDUR BAYSAFE ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® BA VULKOLLAN BAYDUR BAYFILL BAYFIT BAYTEC BAYFLEX BAYMER AYFILL BAYTEC BAYFLEX BAYMER BAY®® ®BAYFIT ® ® ® ® BAYPREG ® BAYTHERM ® ® ® ® ® ® ® AYTEC BLENDUR MULTITEC VULKOLLAN BAYDUR BAYFILL BAYFIT EC VULKOLLAN BAYDUR BAYFILL BAYFIT BAYTEC BAYMER® ® ® ®® ® ® ® ® BAYFLEX ® ® ® ® BAYDU PREG BAYTHERM BAYTEC BLENDUR MULTITEC VULKOLLAN LENDUR BAYSAFE MULTITEC VULKOLLAN BAYDUR BAYFILL ® ® ® ® ® BAYFIT B ® ® ®BAYPREG ® ® ® ® BAYFLEX BAYMER BAYTHERM BAYTEC BLENDUR MULTITE REG®BAYFIT BAYTHERM BAYTEC BLENDUR BAYSAFE MULTITEC VULKOLLAN ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ®®BAYPREG ® ®BAYTHERM ® ® FILL BAYTEC BAYFLEX BAYMER BAYTE AYFLEX BAYMER BAYPREG BAYTHERM BAYTEC BLENDUR BAYSAFE ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ULKOLLAN BAYDUR BAYFILL BAYFIT BAYTEC BAYFLEX BAYMER BAY AYFILL BAYFIT BAYTEC BAYFLEX BAYMER BAYTHERM ® ® ® BAYPREG ® ® ® ®BAY® ® ® MULTITEC ®®VULKOLLAN ® ® ® NDUR BAYDUR BAYFILL BAYFIT BAYTEC BAY EC VULKOLLAN BAYFIT BAYTEC BAYMER ® ® ® BAYDUR ®BAYFILL ® ® BAYFLEX ®® ® ® ® ® ® ® HERM BAYTEC BLENDUR MULTITEC VULKOLLAN BAYDUR BAYFILL LENDUR VULKOLLAN BAYDUR BAYFILL BAYFIT B ® ® BAYSAFE ® MULTITEC ® ® ® ® ® ®BAYTEC BLENDUR ® ® ® YMER BAYPREG BAYTHERM MULTITEC VULKOLL AYPREG BAYTHERM BAYTEC BLENDUR BAYSAFE MULTITEC VULKOL ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® FIT BAYTEC BAYFLEX BAYMER BAYPREG BAYTHERM BAYTEC BLEND AYTEC BAYFLEX BAYMER BAYPREG BAYTHERM BAYTEC BLENDUR B ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® VULKOLLAN BAYDUR BAYFILL BAYFIT BAYTEC BAYFLEX BAYMER BA AYDUR BAYFILL BAYFIT BAYTEC BAYFLEX BAYMER BAYPREG BAYTH ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® BAYDUR ® ® ® ® AYTEC® ®BLENDUR MULTITEC VULKOLLAN BAYFILL BAYFIT MULTITEC VULKOLLAN BAYDUR BAYFILL BAYFIT BAYTEC BAYFLEX BA® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® BAYTEC ®BLENDUR ®MULTITEC VULKOLLAN ® ® PREG BAYTHERM BAYDU AYTEC BLENDUR BAYSAFE MULTITEC VULKOLLAN BAYDUR BAYFILL ® ®® ®BAYMER®BAYPREG ® ®®BAYTEC® ®BLENDUR®®MULTITE BAYFLEX BAYTHERM AYPREG BAYTEC BLENDUR BAYSAFE MULTITEC VULKOL ® ® BAYTHERM ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ®BAYTHERM ® ® FILL BAYFIT BAYTEC BAYFLEX BAYMER BAYPREG BAYTE AYTEC BAYFLEX BAYMER BAYPREG BAYTHERM BAYTEC BLENDUR B ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ULKOLLAN BAYDUR BAYFILL BAYFIT BAYTEC BAYFLEX BAYMER BAY AYDUR BAYFILL BAYTEC BAYMER BAYPREG BAYTH ® ®BAYFIT ® ® BAYFLEX ®® ® ® ®®BAYFIT® ®BAYTEC®BAY ® NDUR MULTITEC VULKOLLAN BAYDUR BAYFILL MULTITEC VULKOLLAN BAYDUR BAYFILL BAYFIT BAYTEC BAYFLEX BA ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® HERM BAYTEC BLENDUR MULTITEC VULKOLLAN BAYDUR BAYFILL EC BLENDUR BAYSAFE MULTITEC VULKOLLAN BAYDUR BAYFILL BAY ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ®BAYTHERM ® ® ® Sunny ® YMER BAYPREG BAYTEC BLENDUR MULTITEC VULKOLL outlook REG BAYTEC BLENDUR BAYSAFE MULTITEC VULKOLLAN ® BAYTHERM ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® FIT BAYTEC BAYFLEX BAYMER BAYPREG BAYTHERM BAYTEC BLEND AYFLEX BAYMER BAYPREG BAYTHERM BAYTEC BLENDUR BAYSAFE ® ® ® ® ® ® ® for architects, ® ® ® ® ® ® ® BA VULKOLLAN BAYDUR BAYFILL BAYFIT BAYTEC BAYFLEX BAYMER AYFILL BAYTEC BAYFLEX BAYMER BAYPREG BAYTHERM BAY ® BAYFIT ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® YFLEX Y YF F FL L LE E EX X BAYFLEX B BA A AY YF Y F FL L LE E EX X BAYFLEX B BA A AY YF Y F FL L LE EX E X BAYFLEX BAY B BA A AY Y YF FLEX FL F L LE E EX X BAYFLEX BAY B BA A AY Y YF FLE F FL L LE E EX X BAYFLEX B BA A AY Y F FL LEX LE L E EX X BAYFLEX BAY B BA A AY Y YF FLEX FL F LE EX X BA® BA home owners EC VULKOLLAN BAYDUR BAYFILL BAYFIT BAYTEC BAYFLEX BAYMER ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ®AY ® BAYFLEX B AYFL AY FFLEX LE EX XBAYSAFE BAYFLEX BAY B BA AYFLE AY LEX XMULTITEC BAYFLEX BAY B BA AYFL AY FLE LEX EX X®VULKOLLAN BAYFLEX B BA AY A YFL YF FLEX LE EX X BA BAYFLEX B AYFL FFLEX LE EX X and BAYFLEX BAY B BA AYcraftsmen AY FFLEX FL LE EX X®BAYFIT BAYFLEX BAY B BA AYFL AY FFLEX LE E®X LENDUR B ® ® ® ® ® ® BAYDUR ®BAYFILL ® ® ® ® ® ® X BAYFLEX BAY A AY FLEX F FL L BAYFLEX BAY A AY FLEX F FL L BAYFLEX BAY A AY FLEX F FL L BAYFLEX BAY A AY FLEX F FL L BAYFLEX BAY A AY FLEX F FL L BAYFLEX BAY A AY FLEX F FL L BAYFL BAY A AY F FL L REG BAYTEC BLENDUR BAYSAFE MULTITEC VULKOLLAN ® ® ® ® ®® ®® ® BAY ®® BAY ® AYFLEX A AY FLEX EBAYTHERM EX X BAYFLEX A AY FLEX E EX X BAYFLEX A AY FLEX E EX X BAYFLEX BAY A AY FLEX E EX X BAYFLEX BAY A AY FLEX E EX X BAYFLEX BAY A AY FLE E X BAYFLEX BAY A FLEX AY E®X®®B EX AYFLEX BAYMER BAYPREG BAYTHERM BAYTEC BLENDUR BAYSAFE ®® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® YFLEX Y YF F BAYFLEX BAY AYF AY Y®FFLEX®BAYTEC BAYFLEX BAY AYF AY Y®FFLEX BAYFLEX BAY AYF AY Y®FFLEX BAYFLEX BAY AYF AY Y®FFLEX BAYFLEX BAY AYF AY Y®FFLEX BAYFLEX BAY AYF AY Y®FFLEX®BAY BA A AYFILL BAYFIT BAYFLEX BAYMER BAYPREG BAYTHERM ® ® AY ®B ® B ® ® ® ®FLE BAYFLEX BAY B A AY FLEX BAYFLEX BAY B A FLEX BAYFLEX BAY A AY FLEX BAYFLEX BAY A AY FLEX BAYFLEX BAY B A AY FLEX BAYFLEX BAY A AY FLEX BAYFLE BAY B A AY VULKOLLAN BAYFILL BAYFIT BAYTEC BAYFLEX BAYMER BAY ® ® BAYDUR ® ®® ® ® ® ® BAY ® BAY ® ® BAY ® X BAYFLEX BAY A AY Y YF FLEX F BAYFLEX BAY A AY Y YF FLEX F BAYFLEX BAY A AY Y YF FLEX F BAYFLEX A AY Y YF FLEX F BAYFLEX A AY Y YF FLEX F BAYFL A AY Y YF FFL LENDUR VULKOLLAN BAYDUR BAYFILL BAYFIT B ® ® BAYSAFE ® MULTITEC ® ® ® ® ® ® FLEX ®AY ® FLEX ® ® FLEX AYFLEX A AY FLEX X BAYFLEX BAY A AY FLEX X BAYFLEX BAY A AY X BAYFLEX BAY A FLEX X BAYFLEX BAY A AY X BAYFLEX BAY A AY FLEX X BAYFLEX BAY A AY X B AYPREG BAYTHERM BAYTEC BLENDUR BAYSAFE MULTITEC VULKOL ®® ®® ® ® ® ® ®® ®® ® BAY ® BAY YFLEX Y YF F BAYFLEX BAY A AY Y YF FLEX F BAYFLEX BAY A AY Y YF FLEX F BAYFLEX A AY Y YF FLEX F BAYFLEX A AY Y YF FLEX F BAYFLEX BAY A AY Y YF FLEX F BAYFLEX BAY A AY Y YF FLEX F BA AYTEC BAYFLEX BAYMER BAYPREG BAYTHERM BAYTEC BLENDUR BAX ® ® ® ® ® ®® ®® ® ® ® FLEX® B ®AY BAYFLEX BAY B A AY FLEX BAYFLEX BAY B A AY FLEX BAYFLEX BAY B A AY BAYFLEX BAY A FLEX BAYFLEX BAY B A AY FLEX BAYFLEX BAY B A AY FLEX BAYFLEX BAY B A AY FLEX AYDUR BAYFILL BAYFIT BAYTEC BAYFLEX BAYMER ® ® ® ®BAYPREG ®BAYTH ® ® BAY ®® BAY ® ® BAY ® ®F X BAYFLEX BAY A AY FLEX F BAYFLEX BAY A AY FLEX F BAYFLEX A AY FLEX F BAYFLEX A AY FLEX F BAYFLEX A AY FLEX F BAYFLEX BAY A AY FLEX BAYFL BAY A®BA AY FFL MULTITEC VULKOLLAN BAYDUR BAYFILL BAYFIT BAYTEC BAYFLEX ® ® ® ® ® ® ®® ® BAY ® BAY ® BAY ®BAY ® FLEX ® FLEX AYFLEX A AY FLEX E EX X BAYFLEX A AY FLEX E EX X BAYFLEX A AY FLEX E EX X BAYFLEX A AY FLEX E EX X BAYFLEX A AY FLEX E EX X BAYFLEX BAY A AY E EX X BAYFLEX BAY A AY E EX X B AYTEC BAYSAFE MULTITEC VULKOLLAN BAYDUR BAYFILL ® BLENDUR ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® YFLEX Y YF F BAYFLEX BAY ABAYTHERM AY Y®FFLEX BAY YF BAYFLEX AYF AY Y®FFLEX BAYFLEX BAY AYF AY YBLENDUR FFLEX BAY BAYFLEX AYF AY Y®BAYSAFE FFLEX BAY BAYFLEX AYF AY YMULTITEC FFLEX BAY BAYFLEX AYF AY Y®FFLEX BA A AYPREG BAYTEC VULKOL ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ®B ® ® X BAYFLEX BAY B A AY FLEX BAYFLEX BAY B A AY FLEX BAYFLEX BAY B A AY FLEX BAYFLEX BAY B A AY FLEX BAYFLEX BAY B A AY FLEX BAYFLEX BAY A AY FLEX BAYFLEX BAY B A AY FLEX AYTEC BAYFLEX BAYMER BAYTHERM BAYTEC BLENDUR B ® ® ® ® BAYPREG ®® ® ® ® ®F ® BAY ®® BAY ® X BAYFLEX BAY A AY FLEX F BAYFLEX BAY A AY FLEX BAYFLEX BAY A AY FLEX F BAYFLEX BAY A AY FLEX F BAYFLEX A AY FLEX F BAYFLEX A AY FLEX F BAYFL BAY A AY FL F AYDUR BAYFLEX BAYMER BAYPREG BAYTH ® ® ® ® ®® ® ®A ® ®® B AYFLEX AY A YFLEX E®X® BAYFILL BAYFLEX B AY YFLEX E®XBAYFIT BAYFLEX B AY A Y®FBAYDUR LEX EBAYTEC X BAYFLEX B AY A Y F L E EX X BAYFLEX B AY A Y F L E EX X BAYFLEX B AY A Y F L E EX X BAYFLEX AY A Y F LEX E®®XBA B MULTITEC VULKOLLAN BAYFILL BAYFIT BAYTEC BAYFLEX ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® YFLEX Y YF F BAYFLEX BAY AYF AY Y®FFLEX...with BAYFLEX BAY AYF AY Y®FFLEX BAYFLEX BAY AYF AY Y®solar FFLEXmodule BAYFLEX BAY AVULKOLLAN AY Y®FFLEX YF BAYFLEX BAY Amade AY Y®FFLEX YF BAYFLEX BAY AYF AY Y®ex FFLEX BA A® AYTEC BLENDUR BAYSAFE MULTITEC BAYDUR BAYFILL ® ® innovative frames of Bayfl ! ® ® BAYFLEX BAY B A®BAYPREG AY FLEX B BAYFLEX BAY A®BAYTHERM AY FLEX B BAYFLEX BAY A FLEX AY BAYFLEX BAY B A ®FLEX AY BAYFLEX BAY B A ®FLEX AY BAYFLEX BAY B A ®FLEX AY BAYFLEX BAY B A FLEX AY X MER BAYTEC BLENDUR BAYSAFE MULTITEC VU ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® X BAYTEC BAYFLEX BAY ALessFLEX AY E®XBAYFLEX EX BAYFLEX BAY A FLEX AY E®XBAYMER EX BAYFLEX BAY A FLEX AY E®X EX BAYFLEX BAY A demonstrated AY FLEX E®XBAYTHERM EX BAYFLEX BAY A SOLON’s AY FLEX E®Xmultiple-award-winning EX BAYFLEX BAY A FLEX AY E®XBLENDU EX BAYFL BAY A FL AY IT BAYPREG BAYTEC ® is more! The truth statement is impressively ® ® of this ®FLEX ® FLEX ® byFLEX ®AY ®AY BAYFLEX BAY B A AY FLEX BAYFLEX BAY B A AY FLEX BAYFLEX BAY B A AY BAYFLEX BAY B A AY BAYFLEX BAY B A AY BAYFLEX BAY B A FLEX BAYFLEX BAY B A FLEX X BAYDUR BAYFILL BAYFIT BAYTEC BAYTH ® ® The frames ® ® BAYFLEX ® BAYMER ® BAYPREG ®for solar panels. of these modules are equipped with integrated seals and anchoring elements ® ® ® ® ® ® ® X BAY BAYFLEX Aunbeatable AY FLEX EVULKOLLAN EX X BAY BAYFLEX A FLEX AY E®X BAYDUR EX BAYFLEX BAY A FLEX AY E®Xpanels EX BAYFLEX BAY Arequire AY FLEX Eno EX XBAYFIT BAYFLEX BAY A FLEX AY E®X BAY EX BAYFLEX A FLEX AY E®X BAY EX BAYFL A BA AY FL MULTITEC BAYFILL BAYTEC BAYFLEX ® ® speed of ® installation. SOLON additional underlay sheeting, aluminum ® ® solar ® ® ®B ® B ® BAYFLEX BAY B A AY FLEX BAYFLEX BAY B A AY FLEX BAYFLEX BAY B A AY FLEX BAYFLEX BAY B A AY FLEX BAYFLEX BAY B A AY FLEX BAYFLEX BAY A AY FLEX BAYFLEX BAY A AY FLEX X AYTEC BLENDUR BAYSAFE MULTITEC VULKOLLAN BAYDUR BAYFILL ® ® ® love the ® design, while ® ® ® rails or mounting clips. Architects esthetic property owners appreciate the fact that ® ® ® ® ® ® X BAYFLEX BAY AtheyFLEX AY FL BAYTHERM FL BAYFLEX BAY A FLEX AY FL BAYTEC FL BAYFLEX BAY A AY F®L BLENDUR FL FLEX BAYFLEX BAY A FLEX AY F®L OurBAYSAFE FL BAYFLEX BAY A FLEX AY F®Lis the FL BAYFL BAY A FL AY F®L AYPREG MULTITEC VULKOL ® a complete, and solution. contribution Bayfl exX ®®have ® ®long-lasting ®Xcost-effective ® ®BAY ®polyurethane ® B AYFLEX A AY FLEX E EX X BAYFLEX BAY A AY FLEX E EX X BAYFLEX BAY A AY FLEX E EX BAYFLEX BAY A AY FLEX E EX X BAYFLEX BAY A AY FLEX E EX X BAYFLEX A AY FLEX E EX BAYFLEX BAY A AY FLEX E EX X AYTEC BAYPREG BAYTEC BLENDUR ® ®BAYFLEX ®® BAYMER ®and ® BAYTHERM ®information ®local ® B system for the fl exible, UV-resistant weatherproofed frame. Further or a business ® ® ® ® ® YFLEX Y YF FFLEXpartner BAYFLEX BAY AYF AY Y®FFLEX BAYFLEX BAY AYF AY Y®FFLEX BAYFLEX BAY AYF AY YFFLEX BAYFLEX BAY AYF AY Y®FFLEX BAYFLEX BAY AYF AY Y®FFLEX BAYFLEX BAY AYF AY YFFLEX BA A AYDUR BAYFILL BAYFIT BAYTEC BAYFLEX BAYMER BAYPREG BAYTH ® beAY found by visiting: www.bayer-baysystems.com ® FLEXcan ®FLEX ® ® BAY ® ® ® FLEX® BAY ® AY BAYFLEX B BAY A AY BAYFLEX B BAY A BAYFLEX B BAY A AY FLEX BAYFLEX B A AY FLEX BAYFLEX B BAY A AY FLEX BAYFLEX B BAY A AY BAYFLE B A FLE AFE MULTITEC VULKOLLAN BAYDUR BAYFILL BAYFIT BAYTEC BAYFL ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® ® BAY ® ® BAY X BAYFLEX BAY A AY Y YF FLEX F BAYFLEX BAY A AY Y YF FLEX F BAYFLEX BAY A AY Y YF FLEX F BAYFLEX BAY A AY Y YF FLEX F BAYFLEX BAY A AY Y YF FLEX F BAYFLEX A AY Y YF FLEX F BAYFL AYF AY Y®FFL® AYTEC BAYSAFE MULTITEC VULKOLLAN BAYDUR BAYFILL ®BLENDUR ® ® ® ® ® ® AY ®AY ® FLEX ® AYFLEX A AY FLEX X BAYFLEX BAY A FLEX X BAYFLEX BAY A®BAYTEC AY FLEX X BAYFLEX BAY ABLENDUR FLEX X BAYFLEX BAY A AY X BAYFLEX BAY AMULTITEC AY FLEX X BAYFLEX BAY A®VULKOL AY FLEX X B AYPREG BAYTHERM BAYSAFE ® ® ® ® ® ® ® YFLEX Y YF FFLEX BAY BAYFLEX AYF AY Y®FFLEX BAY BAYFLEX AYF AY Y®FFLEX BAY BAYFLEX AYF AY Y®FFLEX BAY BAYFLEX AYF AY Y®FFLEX BAY BAYFLEX AYF AY Y®FFLEX BAY BAYFLEX AYF AY Y®FFLEX BA A ® BAYFLEX BAY B A AY FLEX BAYFLEX BAY B A AY FLEX BAYFLEX BAY B A AY FLEX BAYFLEX BAY B A AY FLEX BAYFLEX BAY B A AY FLEX BAYFLEX BAY B A AY FLEX BAYFLEX BAY B A AY FLEX ® ® ® ® ® ® X® BAY BAYFLEX A FFLEX AY BAYFLEX BAY A AY FLEX F BAYFLEX BAY A AY FLEX F BAYFLEX BAY A AY FLEX F BAYFLEX BAY A AY FLEX F BAYFLEX BAY A AY FLEX F BAYFL BAY A FFL AY AYFLEX A AY FLEX E®X® BAY EX BAYFLEX A FLEX AY E®X® BAY EX BAYFLEX A FLEX AY E®X® BAY EX BAYFLEX A FLEX AY E®X® BAY EX BAYFLEX A FLEX AY E®X® BAY EX BAYFLEX A FLEX AY E®X® BAY EX BAYFLEX A FLEX AY E®X® B EX YFLEX Y FLEX BAY BAYFLEX A FLEX BAY AY BAYFLEX A FLEX BAY AY BAYFLEX A FLEX BAY AY BAYFLEX A FLEX BAY AY BAYFLEX A FLEX BAY AY BAYFLEX A FLEX BA AY A ®
Review
High altitude Wind power
Makani Power is among the innovative companies in the area of high altitude wind power. This is an i nitial prototype from 2009. Photo: Makani
Wind currents at billowing heights Engineers are increasingly focusing on the troposphere to tap into greater wind energy potential.
I
n 2008 Time Magazine included an unusual flying, energy-generating thing – a cross between a helicopter and a kite – in its list of the top 50 inventions. Californian start-up Sky WindPower had introduced the flying windmill – more precisely a flying electric generator, or FEG. What’s pushing the engineers to new heights? Currently, it is mainly young American companies, names like Makani Power, Sky WindPower and Windlift, that are dividing up this market and the research amongst themselves. They presented together at the Airborne Wind Energy Conference at Stanford University in late September; it was the second such conference, following a 2009 event in the small town of Chico. Researchers base their development of high altitude wind turbines on certain fundamental atmospheric factors which are developed into projects that are all currently being tested. The starting point is the fact that wind energy is highly prevalent in the upper layers of the troposphere, the first “story” of the atmosphere. The layer is 8 km from the surface of the earth at the poles and 18 km distant at the equator.
34
At approximately 10 km of altitude, the average wind speed can exceed 45 m/s and the speed drops off as the altitude decreases.
On the way to new dimensions Australian engineer Bryan Roberts began testing gyro windmills some ten years ago. His device was equipped with a power cable which would first be used to transfer electricity upwards, enabling the power generating airship to reach altitude, at which time energy would be generated and begin flowing back to earth. Whole clusters of these flying objects would be installed in an area with a radius of 20 km at an altitude of 4 km and identified as no-fly zones. Len Shepard, CEO of Sky WindPower in the U.S. state of California, refers explicitly to Roberts’ pioneering efforts. His company has calculated that 600 FEGs, each with a capacity of 20 MW could be installed in a 10 x 20 mile area. The total anticipated output of 12,000 MW, according to Shepard’s calculations, would be three times the output of the nuclear power plant in Palo Verde, Arizona. A cost calculation based on a FEG prototype with 2.81 MW of nameplate capacity yields a price of 1.4 US-ct/kWh at 80 % wind capacity. Activists support these innovations. Among them is Cristina Archer who teaches energy meteorology and environmental science at California’s Chico State
Sun & Wind Energy 12/2010
University. Together with Ken Caldeira of the Carnegie Institution for Science in Washington, D.C., she authored the first atlas of high-altitude winds. Fundamental knowledge about the jet streams is the basis for the flying wind machines. In Butte County, to the north of Sacramento, Archer organized the first Conference for High Altitude Wind Power in the small town of Orville in November of 2009. The next conference took place in September at Stanford University. Along with the pioneering US companies like Makani Power, Sky Windpower and Windlift, Europeans also took part. Among them, Lorenzo Fagiano of Polytecnico di Torino, Italy, Roland Schmehl of TU Delft in the Netherlands, and Rolf Luchsinger of Swiss research laboratory Empa.
There are some things you can always rely on.
Still not ready for the market Makani Power in Alameda, California received US$ 15 million of startup capital from Google in 2006. “In the international renewable energy market that’s no great sum,” says CEO Corwin Hardham. Usually US$ 100 million is needed. And every time Cristina Archer is asked when the technology will be ready for the market she answers: no sooner than 10 years. Meanwhile, the high-altitude wind pioneers continue their research and demonstrate their design, among other places, at the National Design Triennial in New York’s Cooper Hewitt Museum (through January 2011) with the M1 airborne wind turbine. The global capacity for high altitude wind turbines has been calculated and published. A scientific network linking atmospheric researchers, energy and materials scientists, as well as urban and landscape planners has been developed. It remains to be seen where and with what storage media these innovative energy supplies will be tested and built. Jürgen Claus Further information: Airborne Wind Energy Conference: www.awec2010.com Makani Power: www.makanipower.com Sky WindPower: www.skywindpower.com Windlift: www.windlift.com
Pitch systems from SSB Wind Systems. Some things never change. And
tion for your wind energy pro-
that’s a good thing. We have
ject. This results in components
been a pioneer in the develop-
that are perfectly coordinated.
ment of pitch systems and other
To make sure they stay that
solutions for wind energy since
way, one thing has changed:
1990. The type of turbine plays
In addition to our experience
no role here. Drawing on our
you now profit from the inno-
standardized, tried and tested
vations of the Emerson Group.
modular sytem, we develop a
Naturally with the same high
custom solution to meet your
level of reliability.
needs. By request with switch and control cabinets as well as
www.ssbwindsystems.de
WindChap®, the software solu-
Tel: +49 5976 946 0
Part helicopter, part kite, these flying objects which have already been tested in models generate socalled high altitude wind power. Photo: Sky WindPower
Sun & Wind Energy 12/2010
35
Review
Incentive Schemes
Selected countries with new incentive schemes GDP = Gross Domestic Product PV = Photovoltaics ST = Solar Thermal
USA GDP: US$ 14.140 trillion (2009) Population: 307,212,123 (2010) Area: 9,826,675 km² Cumulative installed capacity: PV: 440 MW (2009) ST: 220,000 m² (2009) Wind: 35,063 MW (2009)
Source: National and international institutions
Source: National institutions
+++
Uganda
+++
Uganda produces 90 % of its renewable energy from biomass. A share of 3 % comes from solar thermal systems. Compared to the industrial nations, the development of solar power in the country is insignificant. Nevertheless, Uganda is one of the countries in Africa that provides a feed-in tariff system. Uganda’s tariff rates for hydropower and bagasse systems are determined in the Electricity Act of 1999. The maximum capacity of grid-connected systems has been set to 20 MW. The prices vary with the time of day between 1.50 and 12 US$-ct/kWh. According to the Renewable Energy Export Initiative, the Ministry of Energy in Uganda increased the feed-in tariffs by 20 % in October this year. Furthermore, the incentive will be extended to four new technology forms. In the future, the premiums will now be available also for systems below 5 MW in the areas of wind power, geo thermal, biomass and PV.
+++
Poland
GDP: US$ 67.870 billion (2009) Population: 13,276,517 (2010) Area: 108,889 km² Cumulative installed capacity: PV: > 1MW (2009) ST: n/a Wind: 202 MW (2009) Source: National institutions
Incentive sc
+++
Following a long break, Poland is continuing the promotion of solar thermal systems. Since 2009, residential home owners and multi-family houses have again become eligible for rebates and loans for their solar thermal systems. The decision to continue the subsidy scheme is a reaction to the creation of a promotional fund for solar thermal systems by the Polish NFOŚiGW (National Fund for Environmental Protection and Water Management) in cooperation with the funding banks. The new incentive scheme consists of a combination of rebates and loans. Residential home owners can apply for a rebate of up to 45 % and a standard bank loan of up to
36
Guatemala
55 % of the investment costs for their solar thermal system up to a maximum of 2,500 Polish Zloty per m² installed collector surface (approx. 628 €/m²). The subsidy scheme is restricted to solar thermal water heating systems and has a budget of € 34.5 million for the first period 2010/2011. The programme is thought to run until 2014 with an overall budget arriving at € 75 million.
+++ South Korea +++ According to the Ministry of Knowledge Economy, South Korea’s government plans
to invest a sum of US$ 35.4 billion (South Korean Won / KRW 40 trillion) into the development of renewable energies in the course of the next five years. The overall target is to lower the country’s fossil fuel dependencies and make a contribution to the reduction of greenhouse gases. A volume of KRW 7 trillion will be invested in the public sector for developing solar and wind power technologies. The remaining KRW 33 trillion is expected to flow into the private sector. With the investments, South Korea is ambitious to become one of the world’s five top players in renewable energy by the year 2015.
Sun & Wind Energy 12/2010
Poland GDP: US$ 689.300 billion Population: 38,192,000 Area: 322,575 km² Cumulative installed capacity: PV: 1 MW ST: 509,860 m² Wind: 472 MW (2008)
South Korea GDP: US$ 1.364 trillion (2009) Population: 48,508,972 (2010) Area: 99,720 km² Cumulative installed capacity: PV: 284 MW ST: 80,343 m² Wind: 348 MW (2009)
Source: Nat ional institutions
Source: National institutions
Uganda GDP: US$ 38.180 billion (2009) Population: 30.6 million (2009) Area: 241,038 km² Cumulative installed capacity: PV: > 1 MW ST: n/a Wind: 5.1 MW Source: National institutions
hemes worldwide +++ Guatemala +++ The tendering of power generation projects has developed into the key support mechanism in Latin America. After Brazil, Peru and Argentina, Guatemala is now also putting electricity generation capacities out to tender. By May and June next year, the government will invite tenders for a total of up to 480 MW. Next to conventional power generation plants, a share of 60 % is expected to come from renewable energies, particularly from wind power, biomass, hydropower and solar energy. The Power Purchase Agreements will cover
Sun & Wind Energy 12/2010
a period of ten to 15 years. According to the National Electric Energy Commission (Comisión Nacional de Energía Eléctrica), the prices paid out per MWh will range at an average of US$ 110 and 130. Agreements must be active between 2015 and 2020. More than 40 domestic and international companies already expressed an interest.
+++
USA
+++
US Secretary of Agriculture Tom Vilsack has announced a new incentive for biofuel producers in the United States. In the scope of
the Biomass Crop Assistance Program (BCAP), the US government will provide subsidies for up to 75 % of the costs for establishing eligible perennial crops. The programme is scheduled to run over a period of 15 years. Vilsack also announced a five year cooperation between the United States Department for Agriculture (USDA) and the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) concerning a biofuel for the aviation industry. “By driving biofuel production in the United States, we will create jobs, fight global warming, lower our dependency on oil imports and lay the foundation stone for a stronger economy in the 21st century”, said Vilsack. Markus Grunwald
37
Country Special
russia
Second attempt at a green law Russia’s lobby for regenerative energies is small. Its first attempt to introduce a green energy law had failed perhaps for that reason. Now, the lobbyists have made another effort. What the outcome will be is still uncertain.
F
or decades, Russia seemed to believe that ener gy will always be abundant. After all, the coun try is rich in oil and, in particular, natural gas. Russian gas monopolist Gazprom estimated its gas reserves at the end of 2009 at 33.6 trillion m³ while oil and condensate reserves amounted to 3.1 billion tons. And the European energy networks are not the only ones that depend on the Russian pipelines. It comes as no surprise then that energy is cheap in the exporting country Russia. The prices for electricity and natural gas on the domestic market are deter mined by the Federal Tariff Service. In 2009, the pri vate end consumer in Moscow paid 3 Russian rubles (1 RUB = € 0.07) for every kWh consumed. While the costs for electricity generally vary by region, the average price still stays significantly below the world market level – electricity and gas cost about one forth and one fifth of the world price, respectively. Accord
38
In Russia, the domestic module production is mostly directed at small-scale off-grid solutions on private homes such as this 1.1 kW system that was installed in the eco-village Slavnoe in the region of Tula. Photos (2): RMCIP
ingly, renewable energies still have a difficult stand in Russia. “The costs for energy are too low. Without state support mechanisms, the operation of green energy systems is generally not economically profit able”, says Dr. Klaus Thiessen, Photovoltaics Consul tant of Wista-Management GmbH and PV expert for Russia. His hopes are on the introduction of an incen tive scheme.
Difficult task In the past all attempts to initiate such an incentive had failed. In 1997, the lobbyists had already pro posed a first green energy bill that was accepted by the two Chambers of the Federal Assembly two years later. Nevertheless, the bill never got signed by Pres ident at the time Boris Jelzin. “It passed all levels. Re searchers contributed their expertise. But it never came into effect”, criticizes Thiessen. On November 4th 2007, the parliament passed another law envisag ing different measures such as a surcharge (nad bavki) on the market price for renewable energy, which was meant to provide an alternative to a feedin tariff system. While the law has already been signed by President Putin, the specifications for the implementation are still not fully elaborated.
Sun & Wind Energy 12/2010
This 50 kW open space system in the Belgorod region in southern Russia was the first system of its kind to be connected to the grid in Russia. evertheless, progress is slowly being N made, and, on October 20th 2010, a sec tion of the law concerning subsidies for the grid connection of PV systems below 25 MW was signed. In the last year, an other positive signal was given by Vladimir Putin in his new role as Prime Minister. On January 8th, Putin signed an edict that raises the share of energy from green sources in the total energy mix from currently less than 1 % up to 4.5 % by 2020. Meanwhile, there has been yet another bill introduced in the Duma, says Vladimir Nikitenko of the Russian-German Chamber of Commerce (AHK). “That bill was originally expected to be passed by October”, says Nikitenko. Besides the surcharge (nadbavki) on the market price and the subsidies for the grid connection costs, the law also includes a range of other promotional measures.
the onshore potential alone arrives at 127 TWh per year. And RAWI expects that the conditions for wind power will im prove after the year 2011, which is when Russia’s energy market is expected to be fully liberalized and the average electric ity price to rise with the lower subsidies. In 2009, the total installed capacity ar
Lots of wind, little support Positive political signals would also be much needed in the wind energy sector. Three major wind park projects were elaborated between the years 2002 and 2006. The first concerned a 75 MW wind farm in the region around St. Peters burg, the second a 50 MW offshore project in the neighbourhood of Kalinin grad Oblast and the third a 150 MW park in Kalmykia. According to Anatoli Kopylov, Vice President of the Russian Association of Windpower Industry (RAWI), all three projects were eventual ly discontinued by potential investors. It had simply become clear that none of the projects would be viable without a federal incentive, says Kopylov. At the same time, the country enjoys an exceptional wind potential. Estima tions by the market research institute Emerging Energy Research suggest that
Sun & Wind Energy 12/2010
Russia has an enormous wind potential. But the low electricity costs and the lack of incentives are giving the sector a tough time. Photo: RAWI
Country Special
Russia’s pellet producers are registering a rapid growth. The pellet mill of the NorthWestern Holding in the St. Petersburg region has a ca pacity of 50,000 tons per year.
Photo: North-Western Holding
russia rived at 13,275 MW in Russia. Projects with a capaci ty of more than 1,700 MW are currently under con struction and another 3,000 to 3,500 MW have been announced, according to RAWI. The currently largest project being planned (Yeisk Project) will be located in Krasnodar. In 2009, the Germany-based company Cube-Engineering conducted the wind measurements for Greta Energy and provided analyses for the first three sites: Shirochanka, Mirnij and Oktabrskij. An analysis of seven other locations and first negotia tions with the suppliers are currently underway. Con struction is scheduled to commence in 2011. On com pletion, the project’s total capacity will arrive at sev eral hundred megawatts. “Krasnodar and the adja cent regions in the northeast have an exceptional wind potential. I was also surprised to see that the municipalities are very open towards wind power. In general, the legislation is reliable. But there is still a need for guidelines and directives when it comes to the realization of wind projects”, says Cube CEO Stefan Chun. With an equity portion of 20 % and a tariff of 7.5 to 8 €-ct/kWh, the Yeisk Project is expect ed to amortize in the course of ten to twelve years, says Chun. Components for wind parks could soon be available directly in the country: Siemens has entered a partnership with the Russian Rostechnologii and RusHydro. The aim of the joint venture is establishing factories for wind turbine components. In the opinion of Kimal Yusupov, Lead Energy Renewable Division, Siemens, Russia and Central Asia, the sales potential is promising: “Right now, the Ministry of Energy is de veloping a support mechanism for renewable ener gies. Together with our partners, we are planning to install an annual minimum of 250 MW during five years.”
Birthplace of PV When it comes to PV, Russia has already experience as a manufacturing location, as some of the early pro totypes for solar cells had been developed in Russian space travel research labs. Russian manufacturers such as NPP Kvant and Konti Group demonstrate that
40
the way from space application to terrestrial solar plants has not been long. “There used to be three ma jor solar factories for space application. One was based in Moscow and is today called NPP Kvant. The second one is based in today’s Ukraine and another one in Krasnodar. In case of the latter, a small part was saved and now functions as headquarters of the Russian manufacturer Solar Wind”, explains Thiessen. For space application, Russia had originally produced bifacial solar cells, i.e. solar cells with two active sur faces. According to Thiessen, this type of solar cell achieves yield increases of at least 20 % in conven tional solar systems when a reflector is located on the ground to direct sunlight to the other shaded surface. “Solar Wind is still using this technique today. We are currently researching the potential yield increases for solar systems in Central Europe in our test facilities in Berlin”, explains Thiessen. Similarly, Russia’s semiconductor industry en joys a strong tradition. Accordingly, there exist a number of manufacturers in the upstream areas of the value-added chain for solar cells, ingots and wa fers. One example is the company Nitol Solar, which produces polysilicon – and plans to drastically ex pand its production in the near future. By the end of the current year, the company’s annual capacities are expected to arrive at 1,800 tons. With the support of the Ministry of Regional Development, the “Irkutsk Industrial Cluster for Advanced Materials“ will be es tablished in the company‘s neighbourhood in Irkutsk, East Siberian region. By 2020, a volume of RUB 60 billion (€ 1.430 billion) is expected to flow into new production facilities for hi-tech materials, semiconductors, microelectronics and PV. Module manufacturers are still scarce in Russia. One of the key players is Hevel LLC, a joint venture of the Russian Corporation of Nanotechnologies (Rusnano) and the Renova Group of Companies found ed in 2009. Hevel LLC plans to produce tandem thinfilm modules in a new 130 MW factory based in Novo cheboksarsk with equipment supplied by the Switzer land-based Oerlikon Solar. The investment arrives at a total of RUB 20.1 billion (€ 479.405 million).
Sun & Wind Energy 12/2010
In addition, two 12 MW production lines for crys talline modules have been sold by the US-based Spire Corporation to Bogoroditsk Plant of Techno-Chemical Products (BTCP) and Ryazan Metal Ceramics Instru mentation Plant (RMCIP). “Our modules are partly ex ported and partly sold in Russia, although the do mestic market has not really matured yet. The instal lation of the PV systems is carried out by small-sized installer companies, which concerns mostly off-grid systems with a capacity of 1 to 10 kW on private WMF homes”, explains Alexander Stoyakin, Marketing Manager at RMCIP. So far, Russia is almost exclusive ly active as a producer country whose low demand on the domestic market makes it strongly dependent on exports. Thiessen estimates that the total installed capacities only amount to some several hundred kilowatts. However, the first large-scale project is al ready underway. Rusbnano, a specialist for nanotech nology, and the energy conglomerate Renova have announced their plans to build a 12.3 MW open space system in the town of Kislovodsk in the northern Cau casus, which could be operating by 2012.
Interest in bioenergy The lack of incentives affects also solar thermal, which 12/10/10 16:16 Page 1 has remained equally scarce in the country. According to estimations by the globally active heating specialist Viessmann, the total solar thermal surface currently amounts to about 5,000 to 6,000 m² in R16:17 ussia –Page with3 WMF (8p) 12/10/10
WMF (8p)
a slightly rising tendency. Experts describe the domes tic market as very poorly developed but expect a slow, sustained growth in the course of the next few years. However, the effects of the extreme temperature fluc tuations place also high requirements towards the quality of solar thermal systems in the country. When it comes to bioenergy, the situation looks somewhat better. According to Olga Rakitova, CEO of the National Bioenergy Union, a number of about 80 biogas systems are installed in Russia to date – al (8p) 12/10/10 16:16 Page 1 though the majority are believed to be rather small in size. Vyborgskaya Cellulose is currently building what will become the world’s largest pellet factory near the AFinnish resource notOntocompletion, be wasted a premier border. the –facility’s annualevent for waste finance production will reach 900,000 tons. Estimations by the National Bioenergy Union suggest that Russian exports currently arrive at 1 million tons of pellets per year. “Pellet production is following a strong growth trend, as the producers in the United States are expe riencing a rising demand on the domestic market and accordingly scaling back their exports to Europe. Further information: Russia is now filling this gap. But there is also an www.biointernational.ru/en increased interest in pellets for heating by home own www.btcp-crystal.com ers, particularly in the region around Moscow”, says www.nitolsolar.com/enmain www.npp-kvant.ru/en Nikitenko. “Without subsidies, however, the use of www.rawi.ru/en/main.php?lang=EN bioenergy remains interesting only in special cases”, www.renova.ru/en says Nikitenko. If the present attempt at a green en www.rmcip.ru/eng/indexeng.html www.rusnano.com/Home. ergy bill turns out to be successful, this would mean aspx?dummy=634249003110573125 Regis 19 - 20 January 2011in the area of bioenergy. a breakthrough not only www.russland.ahk.de te 3 D ecem r by Jumeirah Carlton Tower Rebecca Raspe www.solwind.ru b
A resource not to be wasted – a premier event for waste finance London, United Kingdom
SAVEer & £200
Organised by
AGENDA AT A GLANCE DAY 1: MONDAY 19TH JANUARY 2011
DAY 2: TUESDAY 20TH JANUARY 2011
Welcome and opening remarks
SESSION 6: Policy and regulatory system reforms
A resource not to be wasted a premier SESSION– 7: Strategies for waste – a corporate answer for waste finance SESSION 8: New infrastructure systems and waste streams SESSIONevent 2: Funding mechanisms
SESSION 1: A macroeconomic perspective
SESSION 3: Financial prospects – debt and equity
SESSION 9: Waste technology finance
Hear from:
SESSION 4: Alternative financial options
SESSION 10: A business case for emerging technologies
Karolina Fras
SESSION 5: Waste risk assessments
SESSION 11: Material reuse and recovery
Venue: Jumeirah Carlton Hotel
Sustainable Production and Consumption Unit, DG Environment, European Commission
Stephen Henderson Holding Fund Manager,
�
Visit: The luxury, five star Jumeirah Carlton Tower Hotel isthe situated in the heart of fashionable Knightsbridge. European Bank Understand evolving waste market andwww.reffwest.com hear from key policyInvestment makers Synonymous with sophistication and luxury, the hotel overlooks the private gardens of Cadogan Call: Place +1 212 224 3570 Email: enerAndrew Hartley Meetskyline. leading financial players and identify the options available for with spectacular views over London’s �
�
[email protected] Regis Director, 19 - 20 January 2011 your waste project te byat a preferential rate, Head of Infrastructure, 3 DCarlton For details of how to reserve your room at the Jumeirah Tower rHotel e Ireland Realise lucrativecbusiness forofthe future Jumeirah Carlton Tower please see page 8. embe projections on the horizonBank r & waste market Malcolm Chilton London, United Kingdom UK Director, Covanta Energy About the Organisers
SAVE £200
A division of Euromoney Institutional Investor PLC, Euromoney Energy Events delivers high-profile events for energy and finance professionals worldwide. Our flagship Renewable Energy Finance Forums started in 1999, in London, and have grown alongside the burgeoning renewable energy industry into a series Supportingeach Organisations of internationally renowned events, catering to over 2,500 professionals year. These include REFF-London, REFF-Wall Street, REFF-West, REFF-China, REFF-Central & Eastern Europe, REFF-Canada REFF Latin America and REFF-India. We are expanding the REFF portfolio of events to new and exciting markets in 2010/11. For more information visit www.euromoneyenergy.com.
Keith Riley
Managing Director, Veolia Environmental Services
Sponsor
Supporters: Visit: www.euromoneyenergy.com/waste Call: +1 212 224 3570 Email:
[email protected]
Sun & Wind Energy 12/2010
41
Solar thermal
World MAP of the Solar Thermal Industry
The disparity is
growing
Doses of melted glass: the Irish vacuum tube manufac turer Kingspan Renewables started completely automated vacuum tube manufacturing in Portadown, Northern Ireland, at the beginning of the year. A finished tube could leave the line every seven seconds, but the European market cannot take up enough collector area at the moment and this capac ity is thus not being reached by far. Photo: Kingspan
42
This year the world map of the solar thermal industry appears for the fourth time. Since the start in 2007 with 177 companies, participation has grown strongly to 248 flat plate, air and vacuum tube (collector) manufacturers this time. The disparity between the industry in and outside China has continued to grow. The five largest Chinese vacuum tube collector manufacturers produced far more collector area in 2009 than the 167 flat plate collector manufacturers listed on the world map put together.
I
n 2009 the world solar thermal market was split into two unequal halves. The European manufacturers fought with diminishing demand on the main markets and with high price pressures and overcapacity. The manufacturers outside Europe (except the USA and Japan), on the other hand, were able to enjoy strongly increasing demand, although demands on quality and systems efficiency also rose partially along with this. The worldwide survey of the solar thermal industry carried out in September and October shows these two opposing trends clearly. The area manufactured by the industry in the European Union (EU) sank by a total of 13 % (68 companies), while the manufacturers outside Europe (except China) increased their production volumes by 9 % (48 companies). Vacuum tube and flat plate collectors were equally hit by the decline within the EU.
Vacuum tubes are conquering the key markets outside Europe The vacuum tube manufacturers made above-average gains outside Europe. In India, for example, the three assemblers of vacuum tubes listed on the world map trebled their manufacturing in 2009 over the previous year, while the traditional flat plate manufacturers produced 6 % less (12 companies). The new vacuum tube assemblers source the evacuated double-walled tubes from China and assemble the collector, tank and frame themselves, in order to be able to offer complete systems. The Indian company Anu Solar, for example, which has been doing business with flat plate collectors for 25 years, sold almost six times as many vacuum tube collectors as flat plate collectors in 2009. In other fast-growing non-European markets such as South Africa and Mexico, the vacuum tubes are
Sun & Wind Energy 12/2010
Has a consolidation of the market begun yet?
a lso gaining in market share, although the collector modules are still being imported fully assembled from China here, so that no assembly companies appear on the world map. From Brazil – so far a market fully characterised by flat plate collector technology – Product Manager Fabiano Lara de Paula from Enalter Engenharia Indústria e Comércio reports that although the company is still importing fully assembled vacuum tube collectors, it is planning to start assembling tubes at its own factory in Brazil within the next six months. It can thus be expected that the 2011 world map will have the first assemblers of vacuum tube collectors in the booming markets outside Europe.
The European solar thermal sector is experiencing a severe crisis. Germany, the largest market in Europe, has shrunk for the second year running in 2010, and by about 20 %. Many manufacturers have been affected by this decline. When asked about their three most important sales markets in 2009, Germany once again managed to get the most responses, though (see fig. 1). Almost half of the 248 manufacturers named Germany, followed by Italy and Spain – these are both countries which have also had to endure negative growth in 2009, although not as strongly as Germany. According to statistics by the European Solar Thermal Industry Federation (ESTIF), the figures were -5 % in Italy and -10 % in Spain. In such times of crisis there is more talk of market consolidation and insolvency. There were no signs of this in this year’s survey of the industry, however. Only one company, Rayosol from Spain, has disappeared from the map due to insolvency. And yet some manufacturers didn’t take part in the survey this year even after being specifically asked. We will thus have to wait until the world map of 2011 to see if this silence may also have had a financial background. Apart from this, the number of new entrants to the collector industry was once again lower in 2010,
Concentrating flat plate col lector: the collector developed by the US American compa ny Chromasun contains a classic Fresnel reflector which is housed together with a stainless steel receiver tube. The collector reaches operating temperatures of 220 °C at 40 bar. Photo: Chromasun
Automated absorber manufac ture at Winkler: the Austrian collector manufacturer started up a new absorber manufac turing line with an automa tically loaded laser welding machine in 2009, in order to produce standard collectors. The equipment was supplied by the German company Fix Maschinenbau. Photo: Fix Maschinenbau Sun & Wind Energy 12/2010
43
Solar thermal
World MAP of the Solar Thermal Industry
The most attractive sales markets in 2009: Germany, Italy, Spain 120
Number of responses in the category: „Which three countries were the most important markets in your sales in 2009?“
100 80 60 40 20
Mexico (5)
South Africa (3)
Australia (2)
Canada (8)
Poland (8)
Turkey (13)
Greece (13)
Great Britain (3)
Portugal (4)
Brazil (18)
India (25)
France (3)
China (23)
Austria (12)
USA (14)
Spain (9)
Italy (12)
Germany (26)
0
Fig. 1: The most attractive sales markets for the collector industry in 2009 in order of the number of responses. The figures in brackets are the number of manufacturers which have their headquarters in that country. 248 questionnaires were evaluated. Countries with over 15 responses are included. The four countries Germany, Italy, Spain and the USA have defended their peak positions from 2008. France, Great Britain and Mexico have slipped back several places. Source: Market survey by solrico in September/October 2010
as fig. 2 shows. During the boom year of 2008, 13 new entrants were shown on the world map: this year it was just 8 companies. Sun Radiant is not one of them. The Italian company postponed its entry planned for the summer of 2010 due to the low general demand: „We are continuing to buy in collectors and are still deciding whether to start with our own production next year,” explains company head Goran Zepponi. The new entrants on the world map come from Azerbaijan, Austria, the USA, Macedonia,
Number of new entrants in collector manufacturing 15
12
9
6
3
44
2010
2009
2008
2007
2006
2005
2004
0
Fig. 2: Number of companies which started flat plate and vacuum tube collector manu facturing in the given years. The air collector industry has not been considered here, as it has its own article starting on page 62. China has also not been considered, as the industry is already too large for an overview. Source: Market survey by solrico in
September/October 2010
lovenia and Norway, and have all decided on flat S plate collector technology: • the state construction company Azenco in Azerbaijan started the production of flat plate collectors in August 2010. The impulse for this was given by the government, which wishes to install solar thermal systems on public buildings. “The state will be our most important customer,” confirms Samir Mammadov, Procurement Officer at Azenco. The collector has an ultrasonically welded copper absorber, an aluminium frame and a glass cover sealed with EPDM rubber. • The Austrian company Estec Energiespartechnik Süd has been producing a flat plate collector with a new omega-shaped aluminium absorber. It consists of a harp register with the omega aluminium sheet around it and the sheet wings are clinched to the fullsurface absorber. The clinching machine was supplied by the Austrian mechanical engineering company RG Fertigungstechnik. • The US American solar wholesaler Solarhot, which was founded in 2006 and has so far imported solar collectors from Turkey, started up its own production in March this year in Morrisville, North Carolina. “We wanted to avoid the transportation costs and follow the rapidly growing demand,” says Jeanette Gretsch, one of the founders of Solarhot, explaining the investment. In the autumn, Solarhot has entered into a strategic partnership with the collector manufacturer Bubbling Springs of Menomonie, Wisconsin. “Bubbling Springs will stock Solarhot products and vice versa and we are sharing some staff. At this time only the Bubbling Spring absorbers will be made at both locations,” says Gretsch. • The US American solar wholesaler SunMaxx and the Austrian flat plate collector manufacturer Geo-Tec entered into a transatlantic strategic partnership in July at the Intersolar North America in San Francisco, USA. The long-term aim of this cooperation is the setting up of a collector factory in the USA. “We entered into the final stage with the US-wide site selection process for the factory and identified possible locations in two US States,” reports Mike Farrell, founder and head of SunMaxx, answering enquiries made in September. Klaus Mischensky, head of Geo-Tec confirms: “We are supplying the technical know-how including the engineering work for planning the ‘made in the USA’ factory.“ As of the editorial deadline a final decision on the factory location had not yet been made. • The company Euroterm in Macedonia was originally a household technology installation company with approx. 35 employees. Two years ago the company management decided to enter collector manufacturing and the production of Solar Keymark certified products should get running properly this year. “We are the only manufacturer in Macedonia with full-surface absorbers,” says Dejan Mickoski, Production Manager at Euroterm. They constructed their ultrasonic welding machine themselves – equipped with frequency generators by the Swiss company Telsonic.
Sun & Wind Energy 12/2010
Solar thermal
World MAP of the Solar Thermal Industry
CANADA Sunsiaray Solar Skies 5,550 (5,215) Bubbling Springs 450
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
SolarRoofs 22,000 Chromasun 400 SunEarth** 45,000
R&R Solar 4,000
Hawaii (USA)
Integrated Solar 5,520 (6,020)
MEXICO
FRANCE New Caledonia
Dawn Solar 1,700 Solarhot Power Partners AET 58,350 (66,300) Solar Development
Grupo IUSA Captasol 42,000 (62,000) Sunway de México 5,000 Módulo Solar 55,000
202 companies in 44 countries
Sun Ray 30,000
Thermo Dynamics 4,000 (1,500)
Kioto Clear Energy 30,000
World map of flat plate collector manufacturers 2010 Publisher: Editors: Layout: Date: Sources:
EnerWorks 10,000
Sun & Wind Energy, www.sunwindenergy.com Bärbel Epp, Stephanie Banse, www.solrico.com Eilers-Media, www.eilers-media.de November 2010 Company data, own research
Caption production site for flat plate collectors production site for flat plate collectors and absorbers1 production site for flat plate collectors, also as OEM products, and absorbers1 production site of absorbers1 only 1) ”absorber” means absorber plate and pipe system 22,000 produced square metres of collectors in 2009 (22,000) produced square metres of absorbers in 2009 * These two manufacturers in Austria and Portugal produce concentrating flat plate collectors. ** Premier Solar in the United Arab Emirates manufactures storage integrated collectors only. This technology also covers part of SunEarth's production output in California. *** Robin Sun in France offers an absorber incorporated into an insulated glass unit.
BRAZIL JMS 32,000 Maxtemper 10,405 Sollider 500 Aconobre 13,000 Tuma 48,000 Solar Minas 11,543 Soletrol 290,000 Enalter 25,000 Colsol 15,000 Solagua 2,050 GET 26,490 A Atual 1,783 Transsen Prosol 300 Cumulus 36,150 Heliotek 80,000 Soltec Unasol 1,200 CHILE 6,000 (18,000) Tosi 3,350 (4,000) Britec 1,500
Example
Bipin Engineers assembles collectors and sells some of them to other branded companies. The Indian manufacturer produced 16,500 m2 of collector area in 2009. Riposol If a factory's output of collectors differs greatly from that 135,000 of absorbers, both figures are mentioned. The manu(151,000) facturer Riposol from Austria produced 135,000 m2 of collector area and 151,000 m2 of absorber area in 2009. Bipin 16,500
46
Sun & Wind Energy 12/2010
South Korea
Europe see next page
Jehin 9,800 Solar Max 15,000 Grand Solar 25,000
RUSSIA
Shinyang SPC Alten Kangnam 15,000 (12,000) Center of Energy Efficient Technology (TSEFT) 600
AZERBAIJAN Sunda 100,000 (90,000) HaiLin 30,000 Micoe 30,000 Sunrain 25,000 Sunpower 1,600
Azenco
Sunjunior 10,000
CHINA Sines 6,600
Solar Polar 9,200 (2,400)
TUNISIA Egyptian Solar 3,000
EGYPT
IRAN
ISRAEL
High-New Technology Bosch Thermotechnik
SOUTH KOREA
Commonpraise 120,000 (110,000) Prosunpro 350,000 (200,000)
UNITED ARAB EMIRATES
Israel, Jordan, Syria
Chromagen 235,000 Elsol 50,000
INDIA
Premier Solar** 5,000
JAPAN Yazaki 40,000
DAST 10,000
SYRIA
Ideal Solar NUR Solar
JORDAN EGYPT
MAURITIUS Mosolar Geosolar 2,000
AUSTRALIA
India
SOUTH AFRICA Atlantic 3,000
Solardome 1,452
Inter Solar 19,500 Hiramrut 1,000 NRG 2,500
Solchrome 6,400 (25,171)
Rheem 300,000
Maharishi 1,445 (1,379)
Sudarshan 7,500 Unisol 1,000 Warmstream 4,000 Ariston/Racold 31,000 Bipin Akson's Solar 3,000 (500) 16,500
Space Age Sun Zone 12,000
Photon 25,000 Nuetech Solar 30,000 Kotak Urja 24,000 Tata BP 55,000 Anu Solar 7,100 Velnet 18,562 Emmvee Solar Systems 67,908
Sun & Wind Energy 12/2010
47
Solar thermal
World MAP of the Solar Thermal Industry
NORWAY
World map of flat plate collector manufacturers 2010
Catch Solar Energy
AES 4,800 (4,000)
202 companies in 44 countries Sun & Wind Energy, www.sunwindenergy.com Bärbel Epp, Stephanie Banse, www.solrico.com Eilers-Media, www.eilers-media.de November 2010 Company data, own research
Publisher: Editors: Layout: Date: Sources:
Caption
Arcon Solvarme
UNITED KINGDOM
production site for flat plate collectors production site for flat plate collectors and absorbers1 production site for flat plate collectors, also as OEM products, and absorbers1 production site of absorbers1 only 1) ”absorber” means absorber plate and pipe system 22,000 produced square metres of collectors in 2009 (22,000) produced square metres of absorbers in 2009 * These two manufacturers in Austria and Portugal produce concentrating flat plate collectors. ** Premier Solar in the United Arab Emirates manufactures storage integrated collectors only. This technology also covers part of SunEarth's production output in California. *** Robin Sun in France offers an absorber incorporated into an insulated glass unit.
DENMARK Batec Solar
Viridian 6,000
GERMANY NETHERLANDS Itho Images 8,000 Zen 25,000
BELGIUM
Example
Vaillant
Vaillant
Rotex 40,000
Viessmann Robin Sun*** 100
FRANCE
Ernst Schweizer 80,000
SWITZERLAND
OCV 12,000
Wallnöfer 7,000
Astersa 22,000
G.M.P. 1,000
Richworld Renewables 22,000 Bosch Thermotechnik
STI 48,000 (43,000)
Soltop 30,000 (35,000)
SLOVENIA Riello 70,000
Wagner
AO Sol* 5,000
PORTUGAL
Sunerg 18,000 (16,000) Ariston 41,000
Grupo Unisolar 6,000 LKN Sistemes 4,800
Cordivari
ITALY
SPAIN Termicol 28,000 Sela Solar 1,000 Andater 10,000 Solaris 3,525
Hucu Solar 10,000
CD Solar
Austria Sunwin Energy 18,000
Sun Master 120,000 (125,000) AKS Doma 27,000
Winkler 12,500
48
Tisun 92,000
Geo-Tec 65,500 (67,500)
Gasokol 62,000 Solarfocus*
AUSTRIA Riposol 135,000 (151,000)
Ökotech 12,000
Re 5
Soleg 4,000 VK CitrinSolar 64,000 Wolf 130,000 Nau 40,000
Openplus Fogãosol 900 (800)
K 5
ForSun 50,000
Roth
Wagner
ESE (10,000)
Bipin Engineers assembles collectors and sells some Bipin of them to other branded companies. The Indian manu16,500 facturer produced 16,500 m2 of collector area in 2009. Riposol If a factory's output of collectors differs greatly from that 135,000 of absorbers, both figures are mentioned. The manu(151,000) facturer Riposol from Austria produced 135,000 m2 of collector area and 151,000 m2 of absorber area in 2009.
Reinhard 10,000 (8,500) Bosch Schüco
TUNISIA
Estec Energiespartechnik Süd GREENoneTEC
Sun & Wind Energy 12/2010
A
Greece SWEDEN Helional 32,000
RUSSIA GREECE
S-Solar 300 (55,000)
Sigma 23,600 (18,600) Cosmosolar 75,000 Helioakmi Megasun
Papaemmanouel 80,000 (90,000) Sole 30,000
Calpak Cicero 40,000
Thermoellas 15,000 Intersolar 8,000 (3,000)
Sammler Solar 88,000
Bachus 750
Maltezos
Dimas 60,000 (180,000)
Prime Laser Tech 105,000 Nobel 80,000 (84,000)
KBB 55,000 (200,000)
Propuls POLAND 2,250 (2,061) Svoboda 188 Solver 20,000 egulus Watt 35,000 5,000 Ensol 4,500 Sunex 63,000 (50,000) Hewalex 40,000 Sunergy 1,000 K Technik 50 T.W.I. 70,000 CZECH REPUBLIC Solarplus Strojírny Bohdalice 10,000
UKRAINE
Sint Solar 900
AUSTRIA Velux
HUNGARY
Lentherminvest 2,400 Solar Thermo Systems Crimean Heat SZR Elsol 200 NES 20,000
SERBIA
BULGARIA MACEDONIA Euroterm Costruzioni Solari 5,000
TURKEY
Baymak 50,000 Fenis 3,000 Eraslanlar Dagsan & ADG Solar
CMG 3,500
GREECE
Derya 60,000 Erksolar 9,500 (4,500)
Sergün 90,000
Ezinç 326,000 (359,000)
Anticam-Sunstrip 36,000 (9,800) Solimpeks Istek 100,000 (120,000) Ouraset Solar 10,000
Efsun Metal 82,000
CYPRUS
Johnsun Heaters 3,500
ISRAEL
Sun & Wind Energy 12/2010
49
Solar thermal
World MAP of the Solar Thermal Industry
The origin of the newly set up factories 2005 to 2010
France; 1 Czech Republic; 1
Azerbaijan; 1
Greece; 1 Norway; 1
Chile; 1
Pakistan; 1 Poland; 1 Slovenia; 1
Spain; 6
South Africa; 2
South Korea; 1
Germany; 6
Thailand; 1 Turkey; 1
USA; 5
Denmark; 1 Denmark 1 Great Britain; 2
Italy; 5 Macedonia; 2 Austria; 3 Brazil; 4 Mexico; 3
India; 3 Portugal; 2
Fig. 3: The origin of the newly set up factories for flat plate, air and vacuum tube collectors from 2005 to 2010. The chart contains 56 companies, entered according to the country in which they have their headquarters. For a few companies the collector factory is actually in a different country, though. Source: Market survey by solrico in September/October 2010
• The Slovenian company Solar Thermo Systems (STS) has risked starting production of both glazed water and air collectors. It has started the series production of façade collectors this year in Celje, and these are being offered with differently coloured absorbers and/or frames. Private investors founded STS in February 2007. Since then the company has in vested € 1,500,000 in research and machinery, partly funded through grants by the European Union. • The capital assets of the Norwegian company Solarnor, which went under at the end of 2009, were bought up by the former Solarnor Managing Director Hans-Christian Francke, who set up a new company called Catch Solar Energy with this in February 2010. This company wants to present a new patented col-
lector type at the end of the year. According to Francke, manual pilot production started at the beginning of November. • The South African company Ikhwezi Solar has already ordered the production line from MiniTec in Germany, and the production of flat plate collectors is due to start in April 2011. “We have decided to capitalize on the momentum created in South Africa with the focus having moved much to renewable energy,” says Pieter Bosch, Executive Director of Ikhwezi Solar, about the investment. From 2011 onwards the company wishes to supply complete solar thermal systems from its base in East London, approx. 500 km from Durban. The new production line has an annual capacity of 20,000 collectors when run in one-shift production.
Turnover of the vacuum tube collector manufacturers
≤ € 5 million
€ 50 ≤ 250 million
€ 5 ≤ 10 million
> € 250 million
€ 10 ≤ 50 million
Fig. 4: Turnover ranges of the vacuum tube collector manufacturers. 34 companies categorised their companies according to their turnover in the field of solar thermal.
Source: Market survey by solrico in September/October 2010
50
Suppliers from Germany: Narva Lichtquellen is one of two German manufacturers of glass tubes for the solar thermal industry. The other is Schott-Rohrglas. Photo: Narva Lichtquellen Sun & Wind Energy 12/2010
Solar thermal
World MAP of the Solar Thermal Industry
Turnover of the flate plate collector manufacturers ≤ € 5 million € 5 ≤ 10 million € 10 ≤ 50 million € 50 ≤ 250 million
Fig. 5: Over half of the collector manufacturers worldwide are companies with less than € 5 million of turnover in the solar thermal field. 168 flat plate col lector manufacturers answered the question: “Please categorise your company according to the turnover in your solar thermal business”. Source: Market survey by solrico in September/October 2010
Made in Chile: this collector system was manufactured by Britec, the only collector manufacturer in Chile. Prisoners from Colina 1 prison in Santiago de Chile manufacture the collectors and earn money with which to support their families. Photos (2): Britec The solar thermal industry is growing worldwide, as can be seen in fig. 3. It contains 56 companies which have started to produce collectors since 2005. Most of the start-ups come from Spain, Germany, the USA and Italy, but the worldwide wave of start-up has meanwhile now also reached new solar thermal markets such as Chile, Thailand and Pakistan, though.
Main characteristics: mediumsized, independent and specialised Many of the founders are ardent solar thermal supporters and run their small and medium-sized businesses independently. They fit well into the strongly fragmented structure of the international solar thermal industry, in which 90 % of companies
Visit us at Energaia Expo Montpellier 08.12. - 11.12.2010
a nswered the question “Is solar thermal technology your core business?” with a yes. Of the 168 flat plate collector manufacturers who answered the question about their turnover range, 54 % had a turnover of less than € 5 million last year. Only 5 % of the companies generated a turnover of between € 50 and 250 million with solar thermal (see fig. 5). Among the vacuum tube manufacturerers the contribution amongst the different turnover groupings is much more even (see fig. 4). Among the vacuum tube manufacturers the distribution amongst the different turnover groupings is much more even. Here only 26 % are in the smallest company group with less than € 5 million turn over, exactly the same percentage as are in the turnover range of over € 50 million, which is full of Chinese companies. Here too the following is true:
Advanced thermal control - easy to use
www.sorel.de Intuitive full text user guidance in up to 18 languages
Temperature Difference Controller - there is a TDC for every application
solar thermal is the core business of the independent companies.
Corporations and holdings: who is behind the manufacturers? Of the total of 248 collector manufacturers who took part in the survey, only 31 companies said they belonged to a corporation or holding (13 %). Some of these company names are already well known in the solar sector, while others have not made an appearance at all. So, who are the “big players” in the solar thermal industry and how are they positioning themselves in the sector? Well known and well positioned are the German heating companies Viessmann, Bosch Thermotechnik and Vaillant, who have this year once again claimed a firm place in the ranking of the largest flat plate collector manufacturers (see fig. 6). The fourth European heating company, BDR Thermea, didn’t yet make it into the ranking of the largest manufacturers in 2009, as their plant in Fabrigas, Spain, didn’t go into operation until the end of last year. It can be expected, however, that BDR Thermea will certainly take up one of the places in the ranking next year, especially as the Turkish manufacturer Baymak, which produced 50,000 m2 in 2009, belongs to the company through a joint venture. In the ranking, shareholdings have generally been allocated to the relevant corporation or holding active in the solar industry, even if these are only 50 % shareholdings. This is the case for the Danish company Solarcap, for example. Listed in the ranking with over 100,000 m2, the holding has been allocated the production figures of the 100 %-owned Arcon in Denmark and Heliodyne in California, plus Emmvee in India, even though it is only 50%-owned by Solarcap. An exception here is GREENoneTEC from Austria. It is jointly and equally owned by the Austrian company Kioto Clear Energy AG and Solarcap. As both companies are active in the solar field and have their own
Sun & Wind Energy 12/2010
53
Solar thermal
World MAP of the Solar Thermal Industry
Central Europe GREAT BRITAIN Kingspan Renewables 60,000
Projprzem-EKO
Akotec 12,000 SolarUK 645
POLAND
GERMANY BELGIUM
Philippine 2,500
ESE 5,000
Narva
18,000 Regulus 3,000
Ritter Solar 136,000
Watt 16,000
CZECH REPUBLIC
Consolar 10,000
AUSTRIA AMK 20,000
SWITZERLAND
Sunex 5,000
GREENoneTEC
HUNGARY Spring Solar 1,000
Thermics 3,500
ITALY
World map of vacuum tube collector manufacturers 2010 45 companies in 13 countries Sun & Wind Energy, www.sunwindenergy.com Bärbel Epp, Stephanie Banse, www.solrico.com Eilers-Media, www.eilers-media.de November 2010 Company data, own research
Publisher: Editors: Layout: Date: Sources:
Kloben 40,000
Caption production site for the assembly of vacuum tube collectors production site for vacuum tube collectors and vacuum tubes production site for vacuum tube collectors, which are also sold as OEM products, and vacuum tubes production site for vacuum tubes only (Baoguang in China and Narva in Germany) 22,000 produced square metres of vacuum tube collectors in 2009 (22,000) produced square metres of vacuum tubes in 2009
Yaohui Companies which produce glass tubes in their factory are marked in bold.
Example Calpak 15,000
Linuo New Material
40,000 (2,000,000)
Calpak assembles vacuum tube collectors and sells some of them to other branded companies. The Greek manufacturer produced 15,000 m2 of collectors in 2009. Linuo New Material combines all three manufacturing steps in its factories. The Chinese company produced 40,000 m2 of vacuum tube collectors and manufactured 2 million m2 of vacuum tubes in 2009.
* These Chinese companies run several production sites which have been depicted as just one point in the map.
54
Sun & Wind Energy 12/2010
Calpak 15,000
GREECE CHINA INDIA Hiramrut 11,000
Electrotherm 650
Ariston/Racold 17,000
THAILAND Ravotek 1,500
Anu Solar 40,500 V-Guard 17,000
China
Tsinghua*
Sunda 80,000 (60,000) Viessmann Tiafe 20,000 (1,000,000)
Linuo New
Himin* 2,000,000 Material* 40,000 (2,000,000)
Yaohui*
Sangle* Linuo Paradigma 1,136,020
Apricus 24,942 Sunpower 260,000
Shana Group (Gomon) 150,000 (1,000,000) Sunrain* 651,229 (1,302,458)
High-New Technology 44,000 (30,000) Ariston 15,000 Sunshore Lucky Solar Shentai
Baoguang (Linuo Group) 800,000
Huayang Micoe* 1,600,000 (1,100,000)
Sun & Wind Energy 12/2010
55
Solar thermal
World MAP of the Solar Thermal Industry
Produced area of flat plate collectors in 2009 [m2] Greenonetec (Österreich) GREENoneTEC (Austria) Bosch Thermotechnik (Dtl.) Bosch Thermotechnik (Germany) Viessmann (Deutschland) Viessmann (Germany) Prosunpro (China) Prosunpro (China) Ezinç (Türkei) Ezinç (Turkey) Rheem (Australien) Rheem (Australia) Soletrol (Brasilien) Soletrol (Brazil) Schüco (Deutschland) Schüco (Germany) Chromagen (Israel) Chromagen (Israel) Thermosolar (Slowakei) Thermosolar (Slovakia) Vaillant (Deutschland) Vaillant (Germany) Wagner (Deutschland) Wagner (Germany) Riposol (Österreich) Riposol (Austria) Wolf (Deutschland) Wolf (Germany) Commonpraise (China) Sun Master (Austria) Sun Master (Österreich) Commonpraise (China) Solarcap (Dänemark) Solarcap (Denmark) Sunda (China) Istek (Turkey) Istek (Türkei) Sunda (China) Tisun (Österreich) Tisun (Austria)
Fig. 6: Ranking of the 20 largest flat plate collector manufacturers worldwide according to the collector area produced in 2009. The German manufacturer Solvis and the Israeli company Nimrod didn’t take part in the survey this year and are thus not included in the diagram. GREENoneTEC belongs jointly and equally to the Danish company Solarcap and the Austrian company Kioto Clear Energy AG, but is still listed as an independent company. Source: Market survey by solrico in September/October 2010
collector manufacturing sites too, GREENoneTEC cannot be clearly allocated to either shareholder and is thus listed independently in the ranking. Two companies from Italy are working on making it into next year’s ranking: Riello and Ariston. According to company statements, Riello already manufactured 70,000 m2 of collector area last year at its plant in
iombino Dese in Northern Italy. Ariston reached about P the same area from its two plants in Serra De Conti, Central Italy, and in Pune, India. The Monier Group also wishes to expand its worldwide production capacities. So far the group has taken up a majority share in the Brazilian collector manufacturer Heliotek. It can be expected that further stakeholdings will follow. The building materials specialist Leitl from Austria already bought into the solar thermal sector several years ago through the German collector manufacturer Nau, and the Kingspan Group took over the British vacuum tube manufacturer Thermomax in 2007. Two of the flat plate collector manufacturers included in the world map belong to holdings which have broadened their involvement in solar technology. The company Wolf is a subsidiary of the marketlisted company Centrotec Sustainable, which specialises in energy efficient building technology. Dreen, the mother company of the Portuguese company AO Sol, also has stakes in companies mainly dealing with photovoltaics and solar thermal power plants. A company which has so far not shown itself much in the solar thermal industry is Daikin from Japan, which took over the German collector manufacturer Rotex in 2008. Another is the Greek company group Medispes, which specialises in medical technology and to which the manufacturer Intersolar belongs. The US American transformer manufacturer Power Partners entered the solar thermal sector in 2007 when it set up a production plant for solar collectors in Athens in the US state of Georgia.
Flat plate collector manufacturers’ ranking: changes in the lower places While the top three GREENoneTEC, Bosch Thermotechnik and Viessmann took the medal-winning spots one to three in fig. 6 as in the previous year, there were changes in the rankings below them. The production figures by the German manufacturers sank,
while foreign companies raised theirs. Prosunpro from China and Soletrol from Brazil experienced strongly growing national markets in 2009 and secured places higher up in the ranking. Overall, the production volumes announced by the top twenty flat plate collector manufacturers for 2009 sank by 7 % compared to the year before. In the lower part of the rankings some places were taken up by new names, as the German collector manufacturer Solvis and the Israeli manufacturer Nimrod didn’t take part in this year’s survey. But the Austrian manufacturer Riposol did send back the questionnaire and secured itself 13th place. The two Greek companies Nobel and Papaemmanouel announced significantly lower production figures than for the year before and thus fell out of the ranking. The others replacing those now off the list are Commonpraise from China, Istek from Turkey and Sunda from China.
Imbalance: Chinese market leader is 21 times the size of the European Nowhere is the disparity between the Chinese and the European collector markets so clear as when comparing production volumes of the vacuum tube collector manufacturers. While Ritter Solar, the largest manufacturer in Europe, announced an output of 136,000 m2 for 2009, the Sunrain Group, the market leader in China, announced a production volume of 2.9 million m2 for the same year, making it 21 times as big. Sunrain thus also overtook the long-running market leader Himin in 2009. The latter stayed constant and announced a production volume of 2 million m2 of collector area for 2009. This incredible growth in the Sunrain Group has come about through a consistent two-brand strategy. Micoe Solar Energy and Sunrain Solar Energy belong to the same company group but are meanwhile run completely separately from each other operatively and in terms of financial management. “Since the end of last year, we began to invest and build many factories nationwide – six production bases at least for Sunrain,” explains Sunrain’s Marketing Manager Ryan Chan on their growth strategy. According to Chan, the two brands are expanding their production capacities independently from oneanother. Micoe is concentrating more on the urban high-end market, while Sunrain is focusing more on customers in rural regions. “We are proud that these two brands hold top spots in the ranking of the largest collector manufacturers,” says Chan (see fig. 7). Sunrain additionally wants to aid transparency on the Chinese market and has thus announced both the figures for the number of tubes manufactured as well as the conversion to gross area. The factories in Lianyungang and Yanzhou, both in the coastal province of Shandong, manufactured 6,237,822 tubes last year. Chan takes a gross area of 0.1044 m2 (58 mm * 1,800 mm) per tube, so that the two factories together reach a gross collector area of 651,229 m2. This equates to approx. half of the gross collector area announced by Sunrain and Chan does
Sun & Wind Energy 12/2010
Solar thermal
World MAP of the Solar Thermal Industry
Vacuum tube collector manufacturers Himin Sangle Micoe Sunrain Linuo Paradigma Sunshore
0
2,000,000
Fig. 7: Gross collector area manufactured by the largest vacuum tube collector manufacturers in China in 2009 [m2]. Sunrain and Micoe are brands of the Sunrain Group, but are run separately from oneanother and are thus also listed in the ranking as two companies. Tsinghua – included in the last ranking – has now fallen back from the leading group and is thus not listed in this year’s ranking.
Source: Market survey by solrico in September/October 2010
indeed confirm that in 2009 half of the tubes were still bought in. Sunrain expects to more than double its tube manufacturing in the current year. The marketing manager also recommends using a conversion factor of 1.5 to convert from gross tube area to gross collector area, but assumes that other companies use higher factors. In this year’s ranking these conversion factors were not yet requested from other companies. Three of the six companies in the ranking manufacture their vacuum tubes themselves: Sangle, Sunshore and Himin. Sunrain/Micoe manufacture approx. 50 % of the tubes in their own factories, with an upward tendency, while Linuo Paradigma sources all of its coated double-glass tubes from Linuo New Materials, a company which also belongs to the Linuo Group.
Mass production in China: Every one of the largest industrial companies in China manufactured more collector area than the largest flat plate collector manufac turer in Europe. Photo. Narva Lichtquellen
And how do things look when it comes to the production of flat plate collectors? Here the Sunrain Group is on the offensive and has published production figures for this segment for the first time in 2010. According to these, Sunrain achieved 25,000 m2 and Micoe 30,000 m2. Sangle and Sunshore also answered the question on whether they had flat plate collector manufacturing with a yes. It can be assumed that on the 2011 flat plate collector world map there will be a whole series of big-name Chinese companies additionally mentioned. Himin and Linuo Paradigma have not yet developed this line of business, though. If you take a look at the diversity of vacuum tube technology, then the Sunrain Group is also in the lead. Apart from the classic direct-flow pressureless
The SEIDO Line of Evacuated Tubes Affordable Aerospace Technology for---
Beijing Sunda Solar Energy Technology Co., Ltd. Tel:+86-10-84933315 Fax:+86-10-84935837 www.sundasolar.com
[email protected]/
[email protected]
Tube types Micoe/Sunrain
Sydney tube/double glass tube with heat pipe in air Sydney tube/double glass tube with U-tube Unpressurised water in tube systems Single glass evacuated tube with heat pipe/U-tube
Himin Sydney tube/double glass tube with U-tube Unpressurised water in tube systems All glass heat pipe
Linuo Paradigma
Sydney tube/double glass tube with U-tube Unpressurised water in tube systems
Sangle
Sydney tube/double glass tube with U-tube Unpressurised water in tube systems
Sunshore
Unpressurised water in tube systems
Total of five biggest companies
Sydney tube/double glass tube with heat pipe in air Sydney tube/double glass tube with U-tube Unpressurised water in tube systems All glass heat pipe Single glass evacuated tube with heat pipe/U-tube
Fig. 8: Share of vacuum tube types for the area produced by the largest Chinese collector manu facturers in 2009. Source: Market survey by solrico in September/October 2010
Sun & Wind Energy 12/2010
”While the wind is blowing, the sun is shining, much of the fossil fuels we are burning is being wasted. Is this acceptable?”
The history of the solar thermal world maps in SUN & WIND ENERGY This year the world map of the solar thermal industry is already appearing for the fourth time. Things started in 2007 with a worldwide overview of production sites for flat plate collectors, which back then included 177 companies. In 2008 the manufacturers of vacuum tubes and their factories were added to the map with a new total of 157 companies. The number was lower than the previous year because the authors of the 2008 map introduced the rule that only companies which took part in the written survey could be included on the world map. Since then things have gone steeply upwards. Although the number of questions has increased, more and more companies have been filling in the questionnaire. In 2009 it was 200 manufacturers of flat plate and vacuum tube collectors, and this year it was even 248 manufacturers which returned the questionnaire. Some of the growth is down to the worldwide overview of air collector manufacturers (see page 62), which is appearing for the first time this year and contains 19 companies, of which three make water-filled collectors as well. Additionally, the production sites of 202 flat plate collector manufacturers are included on pages 46 to 49 and 45 vacuum tube factories on the world map on pages 54/55. 15 companies produce both collector types and are thus included on both maps. Since 2008, solrico – solar market research & international communication has been responsible for the questionnaire and the creation of the world map. For this year the authors have decided only to include production figures for 2009 on the map, as experience from past years has shown that the figures given for the current year are often revised in the questionnaires returned the following year. The solrico database of collector manufacturers meanwhile includes 430 companies. A return percentage of 58 % is a good result for a worldwide survey. The solrico team would like to heartily thank the industry for its willingness to take part and is looking forward to once again receiving many filled-in questionnaires next year.
Solar architecture in China: one by one, Chinese cities are imposing solar building obliga tions. Clever façade solutions are required to fit the required amount of collector area needed for service water heating onto apartment blocks. Photo: Himin
Sun & Wind Energy 12/2010
Sydney tubes, which made up 80 % of the production volume in 2009, Sydney tubes with a heat pipe or a U-pipe and single-glass tubes with various absorbers are also supplied by them. Fig. 8 shows the share of tube types for the big five from China for 2009. Sunshore, for example, has gone for directflow pressureless Sydney tubes for both the home and export markets. Himin is the only large manufacturer to make heat pipe Sydney tubes with a glass condenser in series, the so-called “all-glass tube”. The five vacuum tube collector manufacturers listed in the ranking produced a total of 8.7 million m2 last year and thus achieved a market share of 21 % the total volume of 42 million m2 (see S&WE 7/2010). Of this, 86 % were “China tubes” using water. In second and third place were Sydney tubes with a U-pipe (7 %) and with a heat pipe (4 %). The all-glass tubes achieved 2 %. Only Sunrain supplies singleglass tubes. This tube technology, which is common in Europe, thus only has a negligible 1 % market share in China.
Production for the world market? The disparity between vacuum tube collector manufacturers in China and flat plate collector manufacturers in the rest of the world is becoming more and more pronounced. While manufacturers in Europe had to accept a reduction in production volumes in 2009, the Chinese manufacturers announced record figures. Every one of the largest five industrial companies in China manufactured more collector area than the largest flat plate collector manufacturer in Europe and a multiple of what the largest vacuum tube collector manufacturer in Europe achieved. The Asians are thus in a very good starting position when it comes to serving the global solar thermal markets. The simple gravity systems, often supplied from China fully assembled, are gaining in market influence more quickly here than the high-quality flat plate collectors “made in Europe”. The first traditional flat plate collector manufacturers from India, Brazil, Mexico and Poland said in the survey that they saw vacuum tubes as clearly advantageous over flat plate collectors. They confirmed that the products from China had a good price/ performance ratio and increasing quality. How quickly this trend continues to make headway depends crucially on market developments in Europe, as strong national markets are the most important pillar in the industry for helping exports. Bärbel Epp
Sun & Wind Energy 12/2010
Solar thermal
World map of the Solar Thermal Industry
Upswing for hot air
Northern Arizona University has been fitted out with a typical cladding system by the Canadian company Conserval. Photo: Conserval
Optimism reigns in the air collector sector. The market is characterised by high growth rates and numerous new entrants: reason enough to present the sector on its own world map for the first time.
W
e are seeing increasing awareness and adoption of solar air heating technology,“ is the positive impression gained by Brian Wilkinson, President of the Canadian company Matrix Energy Inc. Having already produced 12,000 m2 of collector area, Matrix is among the world’s largest suppliers of solar air collectors.
62
A total of 30 companies from 14 countries were written to by the market research agency solrico on behalf of SUN & WIND ENERGY, asking them about product and manufacturing data, as well as news on current business developments. 19 companies from 11 countries returned the questionnaires and are shown on the “World map of air collector manufacturers and
Sun & Wind Energy 12/2010
s uppliers 2010”. The main centres of manufacturing lie in Canada, whose air collector market is long-running and traditional, and in central Europe, where apart from traditional companies, there are also many new companies and new entrants. One example of the latter is the German company Kollektorfabrik, which began the production of vacuum tube air collectors in 2006. Another is the similarly German company EnerSearch, which has appeared on the market this year with an air collector with a plastic absorber. Since 2006, in France, the company Opaly has been successfully supplying a special foil which can be printed on. It thus combines heat capture on building façades with advertising. Last but not least, the Slovenian company Solar Thermo Systems (STS) has entered the market with a glazed system this year, whose coloured collectors can be matched to the individual building looks as required.
Broad technology spectrum These four examples already show that the market for air collectors consists of many different technologies. This diversity stems partly from the various climatic conditions in each manufacturing country, but also from the various uses this technology is put to. The solar heating of an industrial hall obviously requires different systems to the drying of wood chips or the ventilation of a holiday home. The world map distinguishes between glazed systems (red) and unglazed systems (green). Unglazed collectors, which are mainly being supplied by the Canadian manufacturers, are generally cladding systems available by the metre that can be matched to each building façade as required. Glazed systems usually have a modular basis and are mounted on the roof or façade of a building. In the field of solar drying these modules can also be integrated directly into the solar dryer. Exceptions in the field of glazed collectors are the Lubi collector by Enerconcept (Canada) and the ActiveSkin collector by Opaly (France). The former is a transparent perforated cladding system which uses each particular wall as an absorber. The latter uses the above-mentioned printable foil.
High blessing for solar air heating: the glazed collector by the Canadian company Your Solar Home is also bringing comfort able room conditions to this church. Photo: Your Solar Home
Sun & Wind Energy 12/2010
Solar thermal
World map of the Solar Thermal Industry
TYFO for your solar installation!
Some quotes by manufacturers
Solar fluids for all thermal solar installations.
“We are seeing increasing awareness and adoption of solar air heating technology.“ Matrix
● High-quality antifreezing and anti-corrosion fluids for flat-plate and vacuum-tube-systems ● Corrosion resistant - protection against deposition ● Environmentally compatible, non-toxic, biodegradable ● Supplied as concentrate or ready mixed ● Proven in thousands of installations Brine for heat pump systems
“We expect continued growth based on the cost- competitiveness and widespread applicability of the solar wall technology in the commercial and industrial sector.” Conserval
Your heat transfer medium specialist since 1975.
TYFOROP CHEMIE GmbH · Anton-Rée-Weg 7 · D-20537 Hamburg Tel.: +49 (0) 40/20 94 97-0 · Fax: +49 (0) 40/20 94 97-20 · www.tyfo.de
“The solar market is continuously expanding in every sector; we believe that for the next 15 years there will be a lot of work to do.” Termotend
Depending on the system, the manufacturing structures of the manufacturers can also vary. While the module suppliers generally produce their collectors 100 % themselves, the situation is partially different for the suppliers of cladding systems. Although the know-how and patents lie in the hands of the suppliers here too, the relatively simply constructed collectors of foil or sheet steel, for example, are sometimes manufactured and delivered by correspondingly specialised manufacturers.
High growth rates in 2010
energy meets design OEM-Manufacturer: Custom-made solutions for our clients • Industrial production of solar thermal collectors • Many years of Solar-Know-How • High performance collectors at fair prices • Flexible production – minor delivery time
rs OEM-collecto ria made in Aust
www www.sunwin-energy.com w sunwin i energy com SunWin Energy Systems GmbH, A-4061 Pasching Tel. +43 (0) 7229 51 444-0,
[email protected]
64
Standing out from the survey were the high growth rates and the good forecasts made by the companies. The Canadian market leader Conserval (SolarWall), for example, reckons with a total collector area of 70,000 m2, after having produced 42,000 m2 in 2009. “We expect continued growth based on the cost- competitiveness and widespread applicability of the solar wall technology in the commercial and industrial sector,” explains Victoria Hollick, Vice President of Operations at Conserval, talking about the planned growth rate of almost 70 %. The planned 2010 production figures for Enerconcept (100 %), Matrix Energy (50 %) and Your Solar Home (25 %) in Canada, Termotend in Italy (50 %) and OM Solar in Japan (33 %), also show a clear rise over the previous year. The European market leader Grammer Solar reckons with a growth of 14 % for 2010 as well, despite difficult market conditions. A further indicator of the positive market development are the new entrants in 2010 – STS from Slowenia, MC2 from Canada and EnerSearch from Germany – as well as companies which are currently eyeing up the market. One manufacturer even stated that the growing number of international enquiries was causing serious problems, and the employee structure would have to be adjusted (language-wise). The company has thus decided to forego the marketing effect of being included on the world map. Claudio Menegatti, head of the Italian manufacturer Termotend, summarises the situation as follows: “The solar market is continuously expanding in every sector; we believe that for the next 15 years there will be a lot of work to do.” Stephanie Banse
Sun & Wind Energy 12/2010
NEW
“BISON”-ultrasonic full plate welding machine for Omega-joints 1. No destruction of the coating with (Patent pending)
a higher overall efficiency
2. Better heat transfer from fin to tubing 3. No bi-metal effect by using copper tube and aluminium sheets 4. Any pipe material, such as copper pipes, stainless steel pipes or aluminium pipes are suitable 5. Outstanding flatness without waviness 6. The “BISON” is universable applicable for full plate absorber or stripe absorber
Ultrasonics Steckmann GmbH Hauptstraße 24 ♦ D-61279 Grävenwiesbach Telefon: 0049 - 6086 1818 E-mail: mail@ultrasonics .de Internet: http:// www.ultrasonics.de
Sun & Wind Energy 12/2010
65
Solar thermal
hOTEL sYSTEMS
Three new luxury hotels in South Africa, Turkey and Dubai are using solar heat to provide their guests with enough hot water. The solar system is not a luxury here, however, as it should lower the energy costs considerably.
Not a luxury The world’s tallest building uses solar heat. 378 solar collectors are installed on a building adjoining the Burj Khalifa tower in Dubai. Photos (2): Sole
66
T
o a lot of people solar thermal heating is an unknown technology: at least they think so. Even if they do not have a solar thermal installation themselves, they may still have used water heated by the sun, in a hotel where they have stayed, for example. This may have been the luxurious Armani hotel in the Burj Khalifa tower in Dubai, presently the highest building in the world, or the extraordinary Cappadocia Cave Hotel in Turkey, where hotel guests sleep in cave-style rooms. Or it may have been the DaVinci Hotel, a new luxury hotel in the centre of Johannesburg. In all three cases the hotel residents do not necessarily see the solar collectors and very likely they will not even spare a thought about how the heat for their showers was produced. However, each of the installations would have been worth look ing at, as the companies involved have been quite creative to plan and install a perfect system.
DaVinci Hotel in Johannesburg The DaVinci Hotel in Johannesburg is the latest hotel of the Legacy Group, which owns hotels and resorts in various African countries. Located on Nelson Mandela Square, it has 230 rooms, including 54 luxury suites. Two restaurants, a fitness centre, a wellness spa and a swimming pool overlooking the square are additional facilities designed to attract hotel guests. “The government has asked everyone in South Africa to reduce their electricity consumption by increasing efficiency wherever possible and by installing alternative means of generation where applicable,” says James Shirley, General Manager of Kayema Energy Solutions (PTY) Ltd., explaining the reasons for having the installation. Energy costs in South Africa have been rising at an average of around 30 % for the last three years, 25 % rises are expected for the
Sun & Wind Energy 12/2010
Two heated swimming pools, two saunas, a snow room, a steam room, other wellness services, 79 luxury rooms and restaurants require a lot of hot water at the Cappadocia Hotel in Central Anatolia. Photos (2): CCR Hotels
In the Cappadocia Hotel guests sleep in rooms which are excavated from the volcanic tuff rock.
next two years, with potentially more price increases after that, he says, and adds: “Couple this with the current inadequate electricity capacity, and you see that installing solar thermal systems to heat water makes perfect sense.” Kayema, an integrator of solar and wind energy solutions in Africa, designed the turnkey solar system for the DaVinci Hotel. The Israeli collector manufacturer Elsol solar energy systems delivered the flat plate collectors. KBI Engineering, a tank manufacturer from Alberton, South Africa, was in charge of installing the reticulation (copper piping, fittings and insulation) for Kayema. Standing in front of the hotel the modern architecture with the sky and clouds reflecting in the glass façade is an eye-catcher. Moving to either the right or left, the visitor will realize how slim the building with its oval shape is. “Because of the slim design of the
Sun & Wind Energy 12/2010
building, roof space is extremely limited,” says Shirley. Thus the number of collectors which could be installed on the rooftop was limited. Besides, the roof is also used as a fire escape. Plus, the rooftop was not initially designed to withstand the added weight of the system. All these circumstances turned out to be major challenges in the construction of the system. The solar collectors were raised on support structures to sit above the other rooftop plant machinery in order to make room for them. “A great deal had to be done to design each stand,” says Shirley. “Each leg of every stand had to be positioned directly over one of the supporting ‘ribs’, while still looking good and being able to withstand wind loads of up to 2 kN/m².” Additionally, chemical bolts, which use a chemical glue and thus create a stronger bond than mechanical bolts, had to be sunk into the slab in their exact positions several months in advance. The prefabricated frames could only be raised the 15 stories and installed after waterproofing had been carried out. In order to have enough space so that people can move under the installation, the system was raised
67
Solar thermal Daniel Schwab, CEO of Kayema Energy Solutions, Enoch Godongwana, South African Deputy Minister of Public Enterprises, and Dov SegevSteinberg, Israeli Ambassador to South Africa, in front of the solar t hermal plant on the DaVinci Hotel in Johannesburg.
hOTEL sYSTEMS 2.1 m above roof level. “It took far longer than normal to install the panels, copper piping and insulation,” Shirley recalls. The engineering and planning phase took two months, and the installation itself about three months. 117 solar collectors with a size of 2.9 m² are installed on the DaVinci Hotel. The system takes the heat produced to a heat exchanger in a plant room 80 m below. Three 10,000 litre tanks store the heat-
ing energy. “It is enough energy to heat 20,000 litres of water from 18 to 60 °C every day,” says Shirley. The system is designed for hot water only. All in all the hotel requires about 600,000 kWh of thermal energy per year for water heating. According to Shirley, the solar system generates 360,000 kWh per year, which amounts to 60 % of the requirements. The rest of the heating demand is generated using electricity. “Should the hotel not be at capacity, however, the solar contribution increases to as much as 100 percent of hot water supply,” he adds. The solar system is automated and controlled via temperature sensors, radiation sensors, flow meters and pumps. It has the ability to collect and deliver all the data via cell phone network to a database for monitoring and tracking purposes. The software gives visual outputs of how the system is operating, how much energy the system is saving and what this equates to in terms of financial savings. “So far the system has been exceeding all expectations, even during winter,” says Shirley. “On several occasions we have had to run the system at night, which releases energy into the air, to cool the boilers down.” In
Due to the slim shape of the Legacy Group DaVinci Hotel in Johannesburg, space for solar collectors was limited.
68
Photos (2): Kayema Energy Solutions
Sun & Wind Energy 12/2010
South Africa, winter months are May, June, July and August. The system went online in April, with the DaVinci Hotel opening in May this year. “A project like this should cost around 2,000,000 South African Rand (ZAR; approx. € 212,000) with a net present value for 20 year operation of this system being around ZAR 6,000,000,” says Shirley and goes on to explain: “Calculations are based on the assumption that the current Eskom price of electricity is ZAR 0.45 per kWh (approx. € 0.046 ) and will rise by 25 % per annum for five years and then another 25 % every five years for fifteen years, and a discount rate of 5 % including maintenance costs, with a payback of approximately five years.”
Turkey – Sleeping in caves Anybody who appreciates special locations might want to visit the Cappadocia Cave Resort & Spa in Turkey. Cappadocia (Turkish: Kapadokya) is the name of a landscape in Central Anatolya, which is famous for its volcanic rock formations. The hotel is only 4 km from the Unesco World Heritage Site Göreme, which is famous for its cave churches. The hotel was excavated from the volcanic tuff rocks in the region. It is thus embedded into the rocks and is built in steps. It includes 79 luxurious cavestyle rooms. The room rates start from € 300 per night and person; the most expensive room rate is € 1,200. Apart from the extravagant location and the amazing view over Capadoccia, the hotel residents may use several wellness services. Among others there are two heated swimming pools (outdoor and indoor), two saunas, a snow (cooling) room, a steam room, two Turkish baths and Jacuzzi rooms for special therapies and treatments. This requires a lot of hot water and thus a lot of heating energy. Before the owners decided to have a solar thermal system installed, they only produced energy with coal. They used boilers which burn coal inside to produce hot water for central heating and domestic hot water via a heat exchanger. Such boilers are still popular in small towns of Anatolia as coal is cheap. The main reason for the new heating systems was to save money and to be more independent of fuel. Besides, the hotel owners wanted to reduce the black exhaust of coal in the winter and to completely avoid it in the summertime in order to keep the natural beautiful surroundings clean. In April 2009, Ezinç Metal A.S., a manufacturer of solar collectors and tanks based in Kayseri, got the order for a solar thermal installation. The project was completed by the Ezinç Project Sales Department. One of Ezinç’s dealers in the Cappadocia region installed the plant. The system consists of 40 blue selective solar collectors of 2.3 m² each to supply 5,000 litres of hot water for domestic use and the hot water needs of the spa. It started operating at the end of June 2009. According to Kutay Ülke, who is responsible for marketing and exports at Ezinç, the system produces 92,142 kWh of energy annually, which means
Sun & Wind Energy 12/2010
[email protected]
www.ayvaz.com
Solar thermal
The main challenge in the project in Turkey was to find space for the installation of 40 solar thermal collectors. The solar company Ezinç decided to install them in the terrace area.
Photo: Ezinç
70
hOTEL sYSTEMS 1,930,344 litres of hot water at 55 °C per year. “With this system they save 17,336 kg of coal each year,” says Ülke. “The biggest challenge for us was the decision where to locate the system,” says Ülke. As the hotel’s construction is in steps and rooms are excavated in the rock, there is a space limitation. “Therefore we decided that the solar collectors could only be installed in the terrace area. There was a distance between the heating room and the solar collectors. We constructed pipes between the tank and collectors with pipe insulation with a matching thickness to minimize heat losses,” explains Ülke further. The 5,000 litre tank is located near the coal-burning boiler in the heating room. According to Ülke, the solar coverage for domestic hot water is around 65 to 70 %. He doesn’t mention the share of room heating achieved through solar heating. The hotel has recorded domestic hot water temperatures of 85 °C in the system. Sometimes in the summer they do not need to store hot water and send it directly for use via a by-pass line. As coal is still the primary fuel for heating the hotel, they use this source for the rest of hot water generation. “To get a higher solar coverage we would have needed more space for the storage of the hot water,” says Ülke, “but because of the limited area for storage tanks and heating boilers, it is not possible at the moment.” However, the owners are currently considering constructing new rooms. This might mean that the solar system can be expanded too.
Dubai – tallest tower in the world The photos of the Burj Khalifa skyscraper in Dubai, which was unveiled in January this year, were some of the most spectacular pictures circulating the media this year. At 828 m (2,716.5 feet) and with more than 160 stories, the Burj Khalifa holds several records. It is the tallest building in the word, it is the tallest freestanding structure in the world, and it has the highest number of stories in the world. The Burj Khalifa is a mixed-use tower with the first Armani Hotel on three levels, one and two bedroom Armani Residences on eight floors, “ultra-luxury residences” – as it says on the official website– on 63 floors, and 37 office floors. Residents may use four swimming pools, an exclusive residents’ lounge, a four-storey-fitness and wellness club and many more luxurious amenities. Visitors may enjoy a meal at the world’s highest dining restaurant at level 122. Such skyscrapers can hardly be energy-saving, however. But Emaar Properties, who is in charge of this building project, committed themselves to including energy-efficient technologies. “Energy efficient measures, especially through use of renewable sources, are not an option but an imperative for sustainable growth. By leveraging solar power, Burj Khalifa is setting an example as well as creating a referral mark on how urban developments can effectively integrate energy-friendly initiatives,” says Ahmad Al Matrooshi, Managing Director – UAE, Emaar Properties, in a press release.
Sun & Wind Energy 12/2010
One of these installations is a solar thermal system with 1,020 m² of selective solar collectors. The collectors were produced by Sole S.A., a solar appliances manufacturer based in Athens, Greece. The collectors are mounted on the roof of an office building which is annexed to the tower. The solar plant brings energy savings equivalent to 690 MWh each year. “Approximately 60,000 litres of water are heated daily,” says Eva Nakou, Export Manager at Sole. She does not give a figure for the solar coverage. The energy is used for the Armani Hotel and all the offices and apartments in the tower. The installation was completed in about two months. More than 50 people were involved in the project. “The approximate cost of the project is in the range of € 300,000,” says Nakou. Another special feature of the tower is its glass surface. More than 174,000 m² of glass is included in the surface. The glass, with special solar and thermal performance, provides an anti-glare shield from the strong desert sun, and a high light reflectance to keep the interior from overheating. According to the manufacturer, Guardian Glass, the glass also withstands extreme desert temperature swings and strong winds. Solar thermal installations in highly frequented places like these are a chance to raise awareness for solar energy. However, to do this the managers will have to inform their guests about the technology. In Johannesburg and in Cappadocia this is not the case
yet. And also on the official website of the Burj Khalifa tower there is no information regarding the energy concept. Hot water in luxury hotels is simply a matter of course. But even if they do not stress their way of energy production, the projects show that solar thermal technology is so advanced that it can be a part of even prestigious buildings and their heating concepts.
The installation of the solar thermal system at the DaVinci Hotel took three months.
Photo: Kayema Energy Solutions
Ina Röpcke
Small gaskets that make a big difference.
Reliability is essential.
Extreme local forces, continuously changing temperatures, and very narrow sealing surfaces – tough demands for gaskets in heating and solar applications. The perfect answer – gaskets made of AFM 34 from Victor Reinz. The high strength and excellent temperature resistance of AFM 34 makes all the difference. Don‘t take any risks, and prevent unnecessary down time. Ensure many years of trouble-free service from your heating and solar plant.
www.reinz.com – Hotline: +49 731 7046-777
Solar thermal
Spain
Solar contracting for 23 hospitals In the Spanish region Castilla y León, 23 public hospitals have been supplied with solar thermal installations. The energy agency of the regional government, EREN, not only maintains the installations, it also acts as a contractor.
Hospitals usually have huge roofs where solar collectors can ospitals, hotels and dormitories are ideal be installed, like the Hospital Del places to use large-scale solar thermal systems. They all have a constant high heating Bierzo in the province of León. The hospital’s roofs hold 477 m² demand and are very likely to have a suitable place of solar collectors. Photos (3): EREN somewhere within the building complex where a
H
large collector array can be installed. That is why such facilities caught the eye of EREN, the energy agency for the Spanish regional government of Castilla y León, when it developed its “Castilla y León Solar Energy Plan” in 2001. Following an energy audit, the agency decided to install solar thermal hot water systems on all of the region’s hospitals. The programme, called Hospisol, was established in 2004. EREN itself acts as the service provider, offering the heating in a contracting arrangement. Castilla y León has nine provinces in northern Spain, among them Salamanca and Valladolid. Roughly 2.5 million people live in the region on some 95,000 km².
Long-term plan The aim of the solar plan is to promote the long-term solar market. To do this, EREN defined four main activities: raising public awareness for the use of solar energy, training installers, providing subsidies for installations, and installing solar plants on public buildings.
72
EREN was founded in December 1996. Three out of 30 employees work in its solar division. Head of the department of renewable energy is Jorge Jové Sandoval. “Hospisol is our most important programme of all the installations we have installed,” he says. All in all, EREN is in charge of 70 solar thermal and photovoltaic installations. “They need our supervision, control, monitoring and maintenance.” By the end of 2001, the surface area of solar collectors installed on private and public buildings in Castilla y León amounted to 10,223 m². EREN defined a goal of having 74,850 m² of solar collector area in operation by the end of 2009. In the energy audit conducted in 2003, EREN found that on average 5,049 kWh per bed per year were required to meet the sanitary hot water demand. In terms of money, this amounts to € 135 per bed per year, or 3.51 €/m³ of sanitary hot water. Energy demand for hot water made up 20 % of total heating demand per year. Furthermore, EREN determined that solar thermal energy could supply 65 % of the annual energy demand needed to heat water. EREN set a goal of supplying over 20 % of hot water heating demand in public hospitals with solar thermal plants. With an investment of € 4.5 million, 9,000 m² of solar collectors were supposed to be installed. All together, the plants are expected to produce 18,800 MWh of thermal energy annually to supply 7,000 beds.
Agency is in charge Sandoval and his team are in charge of nearly every task that the solar projects entail. This starts with designing the installation, drawing up the contract with the hospital, and requesting permission from local authorities. They hire the installers, train hospital maintenance staff, and perform preventive maintenance during the first three years. When asked why EREN opted for contracting, Sandoval says: “Because it is better for the hospitals and for us. At the hospitals they usually do not know the technology and they do not have the money for these activities. For EREN it is good because we want to demonstrate the value of the contracting business.” The model gives the agency the opportunity to present the technology to the public, and the team ensures that the installations run for many years,” he explains. By the end of 2009, 15 solar thermal plants were installed. The biggest installation is on the Hospital de León in the capital of the province León. The installation was completed in February 2007. The hospital has 487 beds. All together, the hospital’s different roofs hold 506.2 m² of solar collectors. The installation includes two storage tanks with volumes of 20,000 and 15,000 litres. EREN invested € 250,600.
Sun & Wind Energy 12/2010
The solar thermal installa tion on the Hospital Virgen del Castañar in Béjar in the province of Salamanca is the smallest one in the Hospisol programme. It has a collector area of 17.6 m². The smallest solar thermal plant can be found on the Hospital Virgen del Castañar in Béjar in the province of Salamanca. It has 15 beds and since March 2007 a collector area of 17.6 m². In Bejar a 1000 litre storage tank is installed. In this case EREN invested € 17,500.
Paying back the investment “We make the installations within our own budget, without any subsidies”, says Jorge Jové Sandoval. The energy provided by the plants is sold to the hospitals. The hospitals pay for the energy they consume at the cost of conventional fuel, less 10 %. The conventional fuel price is updated and tracks the hospital’s fuel procurement cost during each invoicing period. The hospital pays EREN. The agency uses the money to recover its investment, which is calculated at bank rates. Once the investment is paid back, the hospitals assume ownership of their installations. “The hospital has a solar energy installation without technical risk and they are enjoying a lower energy bill right from the beginning,” says Sandoval, naming a few benefits for the hospitals. In total, the 15 solar plants supply enough heating energy for 3,193 beds. So far, 3,425 m² of solar collectors have been installed at a cost to EREN of € 1.83 million. By the end of October 2010 the solar installations had produced 6,850 MWh, saving the hospitals some € 675,000 in energy costs. “They are so happy with the installations,” says Sandoval, speaking of the administrative bodies of the hospitals. But Sandoval does not deny that it is not always easy. Controlling and supervising how the plants are
operated has been most challenging, he says, as well as sensitising maintenance personnel at the hospitals to perform their tasks carefully. “Also, the administrative tasks are sometimes complicated,” he continues. “But most of the problems were caused by a legionella system installed at some hospitals, as it reduces the maximum temperature that the solar installations can provide.” This problem has now been solved by limiting the maximum temperature that the solar thermal installation can provide to the conventional system. Sandoval and his team are now working on their next two installations. One of them will have a collector area of 950 m². Ina Röpcke Further information: www.eren.jcyl.es
At the Hospital Divino Vallés visitors can see the solar col lectors from the parking area. Raising awareness about solar technologies is one goal for the energy agency EREN.
BAOGUANG
WWW.CNBG.CN
PROFESSIONAL SOLAR VACUUM TUBES & HEAT PIPES MANUFACTURER SINCE 1998 4# Industry Area Yuanhua, 314416 Haining, (Zhejiang) P.R. China T. +86.573- 87860877 F. +86.573- 87860677
Sun & Wind Energy 12/2010
www.cnbg.cn
[email protected] [email protected]
73
Solar thermal
Heating Networks
Potential for more? Throughout the EU, only 40 megawatt-class collector arrays are in operation. However, examples in use show that very low solar thermal energy costs can be reached.
S
mall solar energy systems on the roofs of single-family homes are synonymous with solar thermal energy use in Europe today. Only 1 % of the collector surface area is accounted for by large-scale solar energy systems with collector surface areas greater than 500 m². Swedish researcher Jan-Olof Dalenbäck from the planning and consulting firm CIT Energy Management AB recently submitted a microanalysis of the large-scale systems installed in Europe. It was produced as part of the SDHtake-off (Solar district heating in Europe) project, subsidised by the EU IEE (Intelligent Energy Europe) programme. He reports on 126 solar energy systems in Europe, which generate a thermal output of more than 350 kW (or 500 m² of collector surface area). Throughout Europe, there are just 40 “megawatt systems” which generate more than 1 MW. Worse still: it would appear that the best times have passed. From 1997 to 2002, approximately 10 of the large-scale systems were built each year (Fig. 4).
Since then, the number of new systems has decreased rather than increased, with the exception of 2007. However, these figures are deceptive. “The number of systems may be lower, but the collector arrays installed are larger,” says Dalenbäck. Also, in the 90s, almost all systems built were demonstration projects, whereas the systems installed now are commercial. According to Dalenbäck, “we are still at square one”. Most of the large-scale solar energy systems feed thermal energy into district heating networks. “Currently, district heating meets roughly 10 % of the European demand for heating,” affirms Dalenbäck. “If we do not succeed in speeding up the introduction of large-scale systems, both the solar industry and the district heating industry risk losing market share.” However, progress is being made, in Denmark in particular. Several large-scale systems have already been commissioned this year. Further projects with a total surface area of around 170,000 m² are currently in the pipeline, which will be commissioned in 2010 and 2011 (see page 79 ff). In Sweden, the leading nation with 20 large-scale solar systems in operation, another of these collector arrays was built this year. The municipality of Ellös, on the island of Orust on the west coast of Sweden,
Intermediate short-term storage
Fig 1: The Danish systems use the storage tank concept.
74
Graphics (3): Jan-Olof Dalenbäck
Sun & Wind Energy 12/2010
Direct feed into the network
Fig 2: In Austria, the large-scale arrays feed directly into the district heating network. They are generally installed on roofs, but some are also ground-mounted – as is the case at the Andritz Water Treatment Plant in Graz.
invested the equivalent of € 4.5 million in a solarsupported district heating network with a solar collector surface of 1,000 m². The first large-scale systems in Europe were also built in Sweden. The first two were built in 1979 (Fig. 4). These pilot systems are no longer in operation today. They were decommissioned after 10 to 20 years. Throughout Europe, 15 systems had to be decommissioned. “However, very few systems had to be shut down before the end of their expected service life. Most remained in operation longer than expected,” says Dalenbäck.
Intermediate short-term storage Most of the largest-scale solar energy systems feed thermal energy into district heating networks.
Dalenbäck distinguishes between three concepts. Concept 1: the Swedish and Danish solar-supported district heating networks are generally connected to short-term storage tanks. The central solar energy system charges this storage tank from which the district heating network is fed (Fig. 1). The collectors can be installed on roof surfaces or on the ground. Arrays installed on the ground are particularly cost-effective. Danish systems of this type have reached a solar thermal energy price of 0.04 €/kWh without subsidies. This holds up well in comparison with gas boilers. Dalenbäck believes that the current increase in solar district heating in Denmark is also due to the rapid rise in wind energy. This means that power and heat cogeneration in windy periods is no longer economical. Operators of district
PRECISION IN CONTROL Visit our new website:
www.prozeda.com
Superior solar heat and heat pump controllers To continue our rapid international growth we are looking for agencies and local representatives promoting our products on the North American market.
Sun & Wind Energy 12/2010
Prozeda GmbH In der Büg 5 / D-91330 Eggolsheim Tel +49 (91 91) 61 66 0
[email protected]
75
Solar thermal
Heating Networks
As the Andritz Water Treatment Plant system is in a water protection area, S.O.L.I.D. had to install a special leak control system for the glycol-filled solar circuit, which is implemented via pressure measurements. Photo: S.O.L.I.D.
heating networks therefore often use boilers for heat generation, making solar thermal energy suddenly particularly economically interesting. Of course, it is just as important that a strong local company paved the way, like the Danish collector manufacturer and solar pioneer, Arcon Solar A/S.
Direct feed into the network With a solar thermal energy price without subsidies of 0.06 to 0.08 €/kWh, systems built according to
the second concept are slightly more expensive. In this concept, decentralised solar energy systems feed the thermal energy directly into the district heating network (Fig. 2). They are generally installed on roofs. This is the most important reason for the higher thermal energy price. Such systems have been built in Austria, and some Swedish systems are also based on this concept. In Germany, E.ON Hanse Wärme GmbH intends to equip their district heating network in Hamburg with decentralised solar energy systems.
www.solarpraxis.com
SMEThermal 2011
Solar Thermal Materials, Equipment and Technology Conference 10 February 2011, Berlin, Germany Conference management: Solarpraxis AG Anja Kleppek, Phone: + 49 (0) 30 | 726 296-305
[email protected] in cooperation
Gold Sponsors
Contact for sponsors: SUN & WIND ENERGY Christiane Diekmann, Phone: +49 (0) 521 | 595 547
[email protected] Silver Sponsor
Partner
Programm Advisors
Solar thermal energy for the secondary circuit In the third concept presented by Dalenbäck, the solar energy systems are distributed decentrally on house roofs, and feed the solar thermal energy into the heating circuit of a local heating network (Fig. 3). The primary district heating circuit serves only as a backup in this case. Such a system has been implemented in the Ackermannbogen solar-powered community in Munich, Germany. At the same time, Munich is also an example for a concept with seasonal storage, of which there are 20 in Europe. There is another example of this in Crailsheim in Southern Germany, where the largest roof-integrated system in Europe with a collector surface of 7,300 m² is located. The solar thermal energy costs in Crailsheim are 0.19 €/kWh. In contrast to the projects driven by companies, seasonal storage involves projects where research and development is the priority, and demonstrates that high solar coverage rates of the overall thermal energy requirement of residential communities up to around 50 % can be reached.
Specialists take risks The concepts can be distinguished not only via the feed-in method, but also by their business models. Some of the key Danish systems belong to district
Solar thermal energy for the secondary circuit Collector array
Return 40 to 50 °C
Fig 3: In solar local heating networks with seasonal storage like that in Munich’s Ackermannbogen community, the solar thermal energy remains in the local network (secondary circuit). The district heating network (primary circuit) serves only as a backup. heating network companies, while the decentralised collector arrays are held by the housing companies. In this situation, companies which provide customers or tenants with heat make direct investments. Other arrays belong to third parties –
Solar thermal
Heating Networks alenbäck refers to them as ESCOs (Energy Service D Companies). The company installs and operates the solar energy systems and sells the solar thermal energy to the network operators or directly to the home owners connected to the district heating network. This has advantages: “Just like facility managers, many managers of district heating companies consider the risk of a solar energy system too high,” explains Dalenbäck. In the ESCO model, companies with experience in the technology take on the risk. In Austria, the Graz-based company S.O.L.I.D. Gesellschaft für Solarinstallation und Design GmbH pursues this model. S.O.L.I.D. plans and installs the system, while contracting is left to partner companies such as Graz-based solar.nahwaerme.at GmbH. The Andritz Water Treatment Plant system is an example of a project contracted by solar.nahwaerme.at. The Graz municipal public utilities will move into their new water centre of competence there in October. 3,900 m² ground-mounted collectors provide new and existing office buildings with thermal energy for heating and hot water. For this purpose, a 60 m³ storage tank has been installed. If this tank fills up during the summer, the excess thermal energy flows into the district heating network. Contracting company solar.nahwaerme.at has two customers: the heating network operator Energie Graz, and the municipal public utilities, which use the thermal energy to heat their own offices. Energie Graz pays a “competitive price” for the thermal energy. The municipal public utilities receive the thermal energy for the same price they would have to pay for district heating. State subsidies, which provided 30 % of the project funding, are necessary to balance the books for the contractor. A parallel to the Danish model: in both countries, the projects are driven by local companies.
Mistakes to learn from Dalenbäck also analysed the problems which occur in the large-scale solar systems in all concepts and what we can learn from this. Positive: most of the projects reached the predicted solar yield. However, retrospective improvements were often required. For example, buffer management had to be optimised after construction in the Andritz Water Treatment Plant project. In general, it is a greater challenge to integrate solar energy systems into the building services equipment of existing buildings than to install them in new buildings. Dalenbäck puts this into perspective: “There are control problems with all complex systems, not just with solar energy systems.” Ground-mounted solar circuits must withstand great forces. The temperature difference on a single day can reach 90 °C. This brought the solar circuit in the solar community in Hamburg-Bramfeld to its knees at an early stage. It is also very important to clean the solar circuit thoroughly. Valve problems occurred due to insufficient cleaning in the project in Strandby, Denmark. “Of course, small solar energy systems are just as affected by these problems,” explains Dalenbäck. “However, the consequences of a failure are greater in large-scale systems, which is why the requirements for planning and system moni toring are far higher in large-scale systems.” It is also important that all parties involved work together and as few companies as possible are involved in the implementation. The key factor for the success of solar thermal energy networks is that more investors, planners and companies become experienced in building and operating large-scale collector arrays. And there is only one way to do so: far more megawatt systems must be built than is currently the case. Jens-Peter Meyer Further information: SDHtake-off - Solar district heating in Europe: www.solar-district-heating.eu
Development of large-scale solar energy systems in Europe
Fig 4: The number of solar energy systems with thermal capacities of over 350 kW was relatively small (126) at the end of 2009. The boom is yet to come. Source: Jan-Olof Dalenbäck
78
Sun & Wind Energy 12/2010
Solar thermal
Heating Networks
Denmark paves the way The construction of solar thermal district heating systems in Denmark is booming. 25,000 m² of new solar collectors commissioned in Ringkøbing und Jægerspris have already been added this year to the 80,000 m² installed by the end of 2009. This is another major step towards independence from fossil fuels for the Scandinavian country.
I
n Europe, energy from the sun has been used in solar district heating systems for roughly 30 years. Countries in northern Europe in particular have shown great interest in solar heating systems with seasonal storage, which allow them to cover much of their heat requirements in winter. Together with the Netherlands and Sweden, Denmark has taken on a leading role in recent years, making it one of the leaders in solar thermal energy. The reasons for this lie in the past. Denmark, for example, like many other countries, also has a law promoting renewable energy, in particular electricity generated from renewable sources. However, since the change in government in 2002, subsidies and bonuses were reduced significantly, which also made large solar thermal systems more attractive compared with small systems. Rising gas and crude oil prices took care of
Sun & Wind Energy 12/2010
the rest. As a result, Denmark invested in large-scale district heating systems instead of the small individual systems which are prevalent in Germany. “The average heat production costs of our largescale solar thermal systems are 3.5 cents per kilowatt hour, which is significantly lower than the heat prices of oil or gas boilers,” calculates Sten Beltman Jørgensen. This is why the Distribution Manager at Danish systems provider Sunmark has benefitted from major demand for large-scale solar thermal systems. According to Jørgensen, their integration into the many existing district heating systems provides a return on the investment in less than ten years – without state subsidies. In recent years, Denmark has built up the largest combined heating and electricity network in the European Union. Approximately 665 large-scale district
The collector array in Marstal is currently the largest in the world.
Photo: Marstal Fjernvarme
79
Solar thermal
Heating Networks heating systems generate both electricity and heat, while a further 230 systems generate heat only. The majority of the heat and electricity generation is used for public demand – e.g. for swimming pools, hotels and campsites. Thus, Denmark is the leading district heating nation, as over 60 % of the Danes are supplied with district heating. In general, the solar collectors used in Danish solar-based district heating systems are groundmounted fixed-standing systems. Most of the systems are equipped with large-surface flat plate collectors which are faster to mount. On average, Denmark has 1,800 hours of sunshine a year. Annually, the sun provides roughly 1,000 kWh/m² with horizontal measurement and 1,200 kWh/m² with an irradiation angle of 45° and southern orientation. “In recent years, the demand for large-scale solar thermal systems has increased constantly,” says Anders Otte Jørgensen, Director of Arcon Solvarme. The company is one of the pioneers in solar district heating support in Denmark. Based in Skørping on North Jutland, it was founded in 1974 as a specialist for large and medium-sized thermal solar energy systems and is the market leader for this segment in Europe. According to the company, Arcon planned and built more than half of the large-scale systems in Europe with collector surface areas greater than
1,000 m2. In addition to this, the company designed special high-performance flat plate collectors for large-scale solar thermal systems, the HT collectors. The 13.5 m² collectors can supply temperatures of approximately 95 °C, which corresponds to the typical storage temperature in central heating systems. The first Danish solar heating plant was built in Saltum in 1988. It was based on experience from Sweden and is still operating, with 1,000 m² of solar collectors. In 1995, the Danish district heating provider Marstal Fjernvarme A.m.b.a. built a far larger system with 8,000 m² of solar collectors. In 2002, the system was expanded to almost 18,000 m² and a nominal capacity of 13.5 MW. Since then, it has been Europe’s largest solar district heating system – in spite of the construction of further large systems, e.g. in Ringkøbing, Denmark, this year with 15,000 m² of solar collectors.
Multiple expansions In the mid-nineties, Marstal Fjernvarme A.m.b.a. set itself the goal of using renewable energy instead of oil to generate heat in its region, and to reach a 100 % coverage rate during the summer months. In 1994, the company received a government subsidy of 20,000 Danish Kroner (DKK, € 2,600 at the current
Overview of Denmark’s solar district heating networks Location
Commissioned [year] 1
Nominal collector Collector surface output [MW] area [m²] 2
Number of Storage tank residential units size [m³] connected
Fuel
Collector supplier
Tistrup (under construction)
2010
4.0
5,400
1,914
900
natural gas
Arcon Solar A/S
Ringkøbing
2010
10.5
15,000
3,900
1,700
natural gas
Arcon Solar A/S
Jægerspris
2010
6.7
10,000
4,047
2 x 750
natural gas
Sunmark A/S
district heating waste (CHP) network
Arcon Solar A/S
Copenhagen
2009
0.35
755
n/a
Sønderborg
2009
4.0
5,866
30,000
4,000
biodiesel
Sunmark A/S
Tørring
2009
4.6
7,284
2,468
1,600
natural gas
Sunmark A/S
Broager
2009
7.0
10,700
1,019
2 x 960
natural gas
Arcon Solar A/S
Gram
2009
7.0
10,073
1,095
2,300
natural gas
Arcon Solar A/S
Strandby
2008
6.0
8,019
830
2 x 1,500
natural gas
Arcon Solar A/S
district heating natural gas network
Arcon Solar A/S
2,500
natural gas
Arcon Solar A/S
900
wood pellets
Arcon Solar A/S
Hillerød
2008
Brædstrup Ulsted Marstal Rise Nordby-Mårup
2.1
3,007
600
2007
6.0
8,012
1,400
2006
3.46
5,012
473
2002 (1996)
13.5
18,300
1,250
15,600
biodiesel
Arcon Solar A/S
2001
3.0
3,575
n/a
4,000
pellets
Sunmark A/S
2001
1.75
2,500
110
800
mineral oil, wood pellets Arcon Solar A/S
Ærøskøbing
2010 2000 (1998)
3.4
4,900
550
1,400
straw, wood pellets
Arcon, Sunmark
Ottrupgård
1994
0.4
565
22
1,528
n/a
Arcon Solar A/S Arcon Solar A/S Arcon Solar A/S
Ry
1990
2.1
3,025
1,300
district heating n/a network
Saltum
1988
0.7
1,030
267
district heating n/a network
1 Refers to the last expansion phase; initial commissioning of the project and further expansion stages are stated in brackets; systems in order of the date
of initial commissioning; 2 Collector surface area of the total system in the current expansion status
This table lists the Danish solar thermal systems which are already complete or are close to completion. Systems in the map on page 81 which are currently being planned are not shown in the table.
80
Sun & Wind Energy 12/2010
Large-scale solar district heating plants in Denmark
Systems are currently planned for Vijens, Dronningslund, Oksbøl, Hejnsvig and the next expansion phase in Marstal.
exchange rate) for building the planned 8,000 m² solar energy system with a 2,000 m³ storage tank, which supports an existing district heating system. After completion in 1996, the collector surface area was expanded by approximately 1,000 m² four years later to a total surface area of over 9,000 m². Initially, the system had 640 solar collectors, subsequently increased to 1,720, each 12.5 m² in size, installed in 32 rows (now 36 rows) on a 20,000 m² site. Since the expansion of the collector surface area to 18,000 m² in 2002, 30 % of the annual energy demand can be covered by the solar energy system. Today, five different collector types are used in Marstal, including both flat plate and evacuated tube collectors. Currently, there is another project to expand the system, called “Sunstore 4”, with the involvement of
Sun & Wind Energy 12/2010
Status: June 2010
Graphic: Solar District Heating
European experts from Sweden, Italy and Germany. The expansion of the solar thermal system by a further 15,000 m² is one of eleven special European energy projects and is being subsidised by the European Union to a value of 46 million DKK (€ 6.2 million). The new system phase is to be completed by 2012 at the latest, and will then generate 55 % of the total heating requirement of Marstal. The new storage tank will have a volume of 87,000 m³, and support a 4 MW wood-chip boiler. In future, this will supply renewable heat to 1,600 households.
With support from home roofs The district heating system with solar support in Braedstrum on Eastern Jutland, at 8,000 m² was the
81
Solar thermal
Heating Networks third largest solar thermal system in the world when it was commissioned in 2007. However, the system had already lost this status one year later. The market leader for large-scale solar thermal systems, Arcon Solvarme, installed 614 type HAT-SA large-scale collectors with a net surface area of 8,012 m² in Braedstrup. The collectors are connected in rows of 14 units. They feed hot water at a temperature of 95°C into a storage tank with a capacity of 2,500 m³. Braedstrup Fjernvarme’s district heating network comprises 1,400 households, supplying thermal energy to approx. 3,000 people. With a performance of 6 MW and an annual energy yield of approx. 4,000 MWh, the solar company provides 10 % of the total heat requirement. “The solar thermal system reduced the dependency on natural gas and is essential to continue to generate our district heat supply cost-efficiently in future,” explains Per Kristensen, Managing Director at Brædstrup Fjernvarme. The collectors are connected in series according to the following system: the first two collectors do not have film for thermal insulation in the rear walls; they are filled with cold water from the buffer heat exchanger. By contrast, the last two have reinforced rear wall insulation, and are specified for water temperatures of 95°C. In addition to this, Braedstrup Fjernvarme also uses intelligent control systems: three irradiation sensors are distributed among the array. They react to sunlight and start the solar circulation pump before the temperature sensor registers heating by the sun – this is intended to optimise the yield. However, Arcon’s major project is not the end of the story at Braedstrup, Denmark – in the future, home-owners are to be encouraged to install systems on their roofs. Their surplus production will be passed
on to Braedstrup Fjernvarme. For this, the citizens will receive 75 % of the price they would have to pay for district heating in winter.
On the island A further successful example of a solar-backed heating network in Denmark, built by Arcon Solvarme, was expanded in multiple phases on the southern island of Æro in the Syddanmark district in 1998. Before the construction of a solar thermal system in Ærøskøbing, heat was primarily generated there by burning straw, supported by wood pellets and some oil in winter. The objective of building the system was to render the use of the straw boiler unnecessary in summer, while reducing the oil consumption in winter via heat storage. The first part of the system was financed by Ærøskøbing District Heating itself without subsidies, with a total cost of approx. € 1.2 million. The now 7,000 m² ground-mounted flat plate collector system generally provides 100 % coverage from solar thermal energy in the summer. “Our objective in 2007 was to increase the percentage of demand met by solar thermal energy to 20 %, for greater independence from biomass,” says Jan Ivert Kristensen, Manager of Ærøskøbing District Heating. Although Arcon has been responsible for the delivery of the collectors and the technical implementation until now, Ærøskøbing District Heating is now working on the current expansion of the solar thermal system with the Danish company Sunmark, which has already implemented a range of large-scale solar thermal projects in Rise and Jægerspris. Oliver Klempert
An 8,000 m² collector array feeds heat into the network in Braedstrup. In future, many small systems on building roofs will provide solar backup for the district heating system.
82
Photo: Arcon
Sun & Wind Energy 12/2010
Products
Solar thermal
Heat from a ball The Italian company Sferasol S.r.l. has developed a compact, spherical solar thermal system whose surface is constantly exposed to the sun’s rays. Unlike conventional flat solar panels, Sferasol makes the most of diffuse radiation, which during a clear day accounts for 10 % of the total radiation and on cloudy days can reach up to 50 %. According to the manufacturer, Sferasol’s advantage comes from radiation reflected from the ground (albedo), which is absorbed by the spherical collector. The spherical steel absorber, which is coated with selective paint, has a surface area of 4.5 m2. It is placed inside a plastic sphere made of methacrylate. The Sferasol system is a pumped solar water heater. The storage tank is hidden inside. It is made from stainless steel, has the shape of a vertical cylinder and contains up to 150 litres of water. According to the manufacturer, Sferasol is capable of heating water within a shorter time in
comparison with flat solar thermal collectors, since the thermal fluid is exposed to the solar radiation twice. The glycol thermal fluid first flows through one half of the sphere, then through the other half, and subsequently flows through the heat exchanger inside the tank, where the heat exchange with water takes place. Maintenance and installation costs are minimal. It is a “plug and play” system that plugs directly into the secondary circuit like a normal boiler. Sferasol is also available without a tank inside. Cristina Barbero
Thanks to its spherical shape, Sferasol fits in perfectly with the architecture. Photo: Sferasol
Further information: Sferasol S.r.l., Via Pinerolo, 119, 10060 Candiolo (TO), Italy, phone: +39/011/9622318, fax: +39 /011/9622319,
[email protected], www.sferasol.com
Compact solar desalination module The German company Terrawater GmbH with its headquarters in Kiel offers complete desalination systems that can be operated using waste heat, the heat from the sun or heat from the ground. The core of the systems is the TW5 module, which vaporizes raw water using a patented thermal procedure and generates 5 m3 of salt-free condensate per day. The module is capable of desalinating almost any kind of raw water. It may have a salt content of up to 30 % – ten times as much as normal sea water, and close to the solubility limit of sodium chloride. If drinking water is to be produced, however, it is essential that the water does not contain any toxic substances that evaporate at the temperatures used in the process. According to the manufac turer, the system is very robust and easy to operate and causes only low running costs. The electrical power that is required by a TW5 module is only 0.7 kW. Terrawater is currently working on an optimized solar-
powered system. The aim is to lower the water price to less than 4 €/m3 when 100 % solar power is used. Further information: Terrawater GmbH, Wischhofstraße 1-3, 24118 Kiel, Germany, phone: +49 431 22001-0, fax: +49 431/22001/29,
[email protected], www.terrawater.de
Pilot installation in Namibia: the desalination mod ule from Terrawater is easy to operate. Photo: Terrawater
Sun & Wind Energy 12/2010
83
CSP
Cost reduction
Beating fossil prices k Power Bloc
-5%
Storage
-8 to -10% Civil Works
-7%
Heat Transfer Fluid
-30 to -60%
Cost reduction potential of CSP plant components until 2025. Not included is project management, finance allowances and development with a reduction potential of 25 to 30 %. Also not included is balance of plant cost reduction of up to 8 %. Photo: Solar Millennium AG
Data: A.T. Kearney
84
There is only one way to ensure that renewables beat fossil fuels in the long term: make them cheaper. The near-term goal for CSP is to drive down costs a third by 2015.
I
t is the year 2035. Journalists from all over the world are following the installation of the world’s largest solar power plant in the Egypti an desert via a video live stream. To be more pre cise, there are three plants with a total of twelve 250 MW power blocks. Together they will generate 3 GW of electric power around the clock. This ex ceeds the power output of the Aswan Dam. The so lar arrays cover a 100 km2 area. For somebody driv ing alongside them, the rows of mirrors seem end less, but seen from a plane, they are only a small spot in the desert. Finally, even in Egypt and the MENA region with their cheap prices for fossil energy, CSP plants have won the race. At first, they were small plants, built by industrial companies, to secure their own power sup ply when the power grid failed. The solar plants grew bigger and Egypt began exporting electricity to Israel, establishing a close economic relationship. CSP is still not the cheapest renewable energy in the Middle East, but its storage tanks make it a lot more reliable than wind power and photovoltaics – and that counts for a lot. Will this vision come true? Nobody can tell today. What we do know today is that this scenario is defi nitely technically possible and almost certain to be come economically viable. But there is still a long way to go. Until this sum mer, Spain was the only country where significant construction of CSP plants was taking place. Plants in the USA had suffered from financing and permission
problems. Finally, construction has started for two big projects, located at Ivanpah (126 MW in first con struction phase) and Blythe (four 250 MW plants). In Spain, construction is fuelled by a feed-in tariff (FIT) of 27 €-ct/kWh which makes CSP a profitable busi ness for investors. The actual levelised costs of elec tricity (LEC) – the generation costs including invest ment, interest rates, and maintenance, etc. – are around 18 €-ct/kWh for a CSP plant in Spain. From the perspective of an investor, the gap between the LEC and the FIT is easily explained and necessary. CSP is a young technology, which means it might car ry high risk. To attract investors in spite of the risk, relatively high profits are necessary. From the perspective of Spanish consumers, who have to pay the FIT on their electricity bills, 27 €-ct per kWh is a high price, even compared to the FIT for photovoltaic plants. Unlike FITs for PV, the FIT for CSP plants has not been reduced in recent years. In the photovoltaics sector, the reduced FIT has put prices for modules and other components under pressure. The machinery of the market has kicked in. In the CSP industry, the stable FIT still provides a comfortable niche. It is a well known but seldom mentioned fact that the CSP industry could cope well with a some what lower FIT. Eckhard Lüpfert of the German Aerospace Centre (DLR) states, “It is realistic to fore see in the FIT a soft but sensible price degression. It must be soft enough to not block development, but still strict enough and dynamic to keep the cost going down as capacities grow.”
Sun & Wind Energy 12/2010
Solar Fie
-10 to -1ld 2%
To secure political support for this young technol ogy, however, companies will have to make a plausi ble case that prices will go down. Therefore, the Euro pean CSP industry association ESTELA engaged the A.T. Kearney consultancy to prepare a forecast of the cost development of power from CSP plants out to 2025. This freely available 45 page paper concludes that costs will go down by 40 to 55 % by 2025, mak ing plants profitable for investors at a feed in-tariff of 10 €-ct/kWh. As this number reveals, the study fo cuses mostly on the Spanish market. That makes sense at the moment because most of the world’s newly installed CSP plants are being built in Spain. However, it does say much about the future cost of electricity from CSP plants. Experts, including ESTELA and A.T. Kearney, agree that Spain will not continue to be the main market in the future, due to its limited solar irradiation and available land. The US will play a key role in the near and mid term. Building a basi cally identical power plant in California would result in electricity costs (LEC) some 30 to 40 % lower than
those in Spain, due to better climate conditions. In the mid to long term, the Middle East and North Africa will play a role – think Desertec. In Morocco, for in stance, conditions are not as good as those in Cali fornia but LEC would still be 10 to 20 % lower than in Spain.
Thinking big Besides choosing sunnier locations, there are two main factors that will drive down costs: economies of scale and technical progress. Simply stated, economy of scale means that big ger plants are cheaper. There are many cost factors that do not increase proportionally with the plant size, such as engineering, permitting and project management. Regarding maintenance, economies of scale have already come into play. Newly built plants need much fewer staff for operation and maintenance than the first generation plants built in the 1980s in the US. The reason is that the operative units in the new plants are much bigger. The investment cost of a 50 MW parabolic trough plant in Spain, including storage,generating some 160 GWh per year usually amounts to € 300 million. A.T. Kearney estimates that if energy output for such a plant is doubled, using all the same technology, the electricity the larger plant produces would cost about 11 to 13 % less. A plant ten times as big might save more than 20 % of the energy production costs. At 250 to 500 MW per plant, returns begin to level off. Experts agree that it does not technically make sense to increase plant size any further. By 2025, A.T. Kearney estimates that economies of scale will re duce costs per installed capacity by 30 %.
Learning by doing Unfortunately, economies of scale will only have a mi nor effect on the cost of a solar field – to double out put, you have to double collector area. The solar field accounts for almost 30 % of the investment cost of to day’s typical Spanish parabolic trough plant. For larg er plants, the percentage rises as the share of other cost factors comes down, so it is worthwhile to take a close look at reducing the cost of the solar field. For tunately, solar fields involve many young technolo
Overview of main technological and efficiency improvement measures Functionalities Technology
Solar collection
Thermal generation
Storage
Electrical generation
Parabolic trough
• Receiver characteristics • Mirror size and accuracy • Alternative working fluid • Optimized support structure design • Higher operating temperature
• Alternative storage reservoir designs andstorage medium compositions
• Turbine efficiency
Solar tower
• Field configuration and heliostat size optimization • Optimized tracking system costs
• Alternative storage reservoir designs and storage medium compositions
• Turbine efficiency
Dish Stirling
• Optimized support structure design • Optimized mirror sizes for various solar resources
• Storage development
• Engine efficiency and capacity
Linear Fresnel
• Automatic mirror assembly • Optimized mirrors
• Storage development
• Turbine efficiency
• Alternative working fluid • Higher operating temperature • Improved cycle technology
• Receiver characteristics • Higher operating temperature
Initiative improvement potential: high ■ medium ■ low ■
Sun & Wind Energy 12/2010
Source: A.T. Kearney
85
CSP
Cost reduction gies that can be assumed to have a steep learning curve. The learning curve (or experience curve) is a mod el that economists have been using for decades to predict the future costs of all kinds of technologies, and it works amazingly well. It says that whenever the cumulative produced amount of a certain product doubles, the price drops by a certain percentage. The challenge is to estimate this “certain percentage.” In various reports, the International Energy Agency as sumes a learning rate of between 10 % and 15 % overall for CSP plants. According to Eckhard Lüpfert, rates of between 12 and 15 % are most likely. That means that the industry will have to install about 20 to 43 times more CSP power to lower costs by 50 %. Dominik Foucar, one of the editors of the A.T. Kearney report, considers 10 % a rather conservative learning curve. In their estimate, A.T. Kearney distinguished between different assets that contribute to the total costs of a CSP plant. For example, they assume a low learning curve of 10 % for auxiliaries, very mature technologies. For planning the solar field, A.T. Kearney assumes a high learning curve of 30 %, as this is a young discipline and there is much to learn. Regardless of how steep the learning curve will be, the report makes very clear that a decrease in cost depends not on time but on installed capacity. Fortu nately, development in new technologies is exponen tial rather than linear, and political support can con tribute considerably to faster growth, accelerating cost degression. This seems contradictory at first glance. To under stand the mechanism, it is helpful to look at the pho tovoltaics industry: according to the National Renew able Energy Laboratory (NREL), module production – the key technology – has had a price learning curve of almost 20 % since the 1980s. Feed-in tariffs, es tablished in 1999 in Germany and later in other coun tries, gave a decisive boost to the market. For a while,
Learning curve for the photovoltaic industry $80 $60
Learning curve: modul price/W - degression rate
Module price (2006 US$/Wp)
$40 $20 $8 $6 $4 $2 $1 $0,8 $0,6 $0,4
Grid parity 2013 at 65 GW
$0,2
Since the 1980s PV industry has had an experience curve of 20 %. High prices due to silicon shortage and high FITs in Spain have only been a temporary effect. It is likely that CSP will develop in a similar way although experience curves for parabolic troughs are not expected to be that steep. Source: National Renewable Energy Laboratory
86
they kept module prices higher than they should have been according to the learning curve model. But this did not last for long – FITs were reduced and now the price is developing according to the learning curve model again. It seems very unlikely that it would have been possible today to produce PV modules at a cost of less than 1 US$/W, had it not been for the boom triggered by the FIT. To be as successful as photo voltaics, CSP will need market introduction support in its early stages as well. Lüpfert claims: “FITs must go down softly to avoid the last-minute rushes and mar ket blockades seen in the previous years in many of the subsidised technologies.”
Key components for cost reduction Economic theory aside, physicists and engineers have identified the specific components that are like ly to contribute to significant cost reductions. There are two major aspects to how this works. One the one hand, cheaper components will drive down in vestment costs. On the other hand, even components or technologies with slightly higher investment costs per unit may reduce generated electricity cost by in creasing plant efficiency. It is difficult to separate these two effects but together A.T. Kearney expects them to add up to a cost reduction of 30 to 40 % by 2025. Lets zoom in to take a closer look at those key components. A.T. Kearney considers the “thermal generation system” the largest share of costs within the solar field, which includes the receiver and the heat transfer fluid, along with engineering and han dling. Only with a new receiver design and an alterna tive heat transfer fluid – most likely either molten salt or steam – will it be possible to rise the operation temperature at the steam turbine (see S&WE 2/2010). Only a significantly higher temperature allows the turbine to work at its ideal conditions. Receivers have undergone several improvements since the 1980s but no fundamental changes of design. Currently, all three receiver manufacturers – Archimede, Siemens and Schott – are working on new receiver designs and their commercialisation. The new Archimede HEMS08 receiver has been in use since this summer in Italy in a 5 MW power plant with molten salt. The company is currently ramping up its production facil ity. Engineering company Solarlite is currently build ing a 500 kW plant in Thailand which uses direct steam receivers. Apart from new heat transfer fluids, another trend is to scale up receivers so they work with bigger col lectors. This saves installation costs. An example of this approach is Schott’s PTR90 receiver with a tube diameter of 90 mm rather than of 70 mm. Schott pre sented the receiver at the Intersolar exhibition in Germany in summer 2010 and plans to begin selling it in autumn 2011. Project developer Solar Millennium will use a 90 mm receiver in Flagsol’s new HelioTrough collector. The HelioTrough also has a larger aperture area and different support structures than the previous collector. According to Solar Millennium, the HelioTrough will reduce the cost of the solar field by
Sun & Wind Energy 12/2010
Foto: © Fronius International GmbH
20 % and will be used in all of their future plants. De pending on how quickly construction of those plants begins, the reality of CSP development may soon out strip A.T. Kearney’s report. The report anticipated new support structures by 2012. Further developments, such as composite mate rials, are expected after 2015. To name just one ex ample, Flabeg, a manufacturer of glass mirrors, is co operating in work on a support structure based on paper combs coated with synthetic resin to which a thin-film mirror will be applied. The mirrors are one of the most controversial components of CSP technology. New mirror concepts are manifold, as are new production companies. To day, all CSP plants use thick glass mirrors, but alter native concepts are evolving. Thin glass mirrors prom ise a higher reflectivity and a 25 % lower price ac cording to A.T. Kearney, and they seem like a feasible alternative. Furthermore, many companies are work ing on reflective coatings and polymeric materials, as well as on coatings for protecting those materials. There are polymeric reflectors on aluminum sub strate, fully polymeric reflectors, and front-surface silver coatings. New concepts and products keep emerging – not an exhibition or conference passes without the presentation of some new coating ma terial and mirror concept. Up to now, no project devel oper has had enough confidence in the new materials to use them in a large-scale plant, but all of them are
being tested. Companies seem confident that indus trial use of the new mirrors is on the way. Skyfuel, manufacturer of the Skytrough collector based on Reflectech reflecting film, just announced that it will soon ramp up commercial production. The race is still open. A.T. Kearney cannot name the winner yet, but they already predict what the win ner will be like. By 2015 there will be a material with 95 % reflectivity at a 25 % lower price. Such details are of great relevance to companies in the business. Still, one has to zoom out again to get the bigger picture. In the long run, things seem to work out according to plan, Eckhard Lüpfert says. He has been working in CSP research for the German Aerospace Centre (DLR) for 18 years now. He refers to studies the DLR published some years ago, such as the Trans-CSP study from 2006. It says that power from CSP plants will be available for € 0.05 in Europe around the year 2050, including transmission via HVDC lines. The Ecostar-Report from 2005, also writ ten by the DLR, goes so far as to assume that CSP will reach a levelised cost of electricity (LCE) of 5 €-ct per kWh (excluding transmission and profits for the plant owner) as soon as 40 GW are installed, which is like ly to be the case by around 2025. Lüpfert is sceptical about the exact figures. “No one knows what you will be able to buy for five cents in the year 2050”, he says. But he is convinced that the key findings of these reports still apply. Eva Augsten
www.solarpraxis.de
1st Inverter and PV System Technology Forum
Lower cost per kWh via intelligent systems combination and high reliability Technology, R&D, Production, Markets & Finance 24 – 25 January 2011, Berlin, Germany Online registration: www.solarpraxis.de/conferences Information: Miriam Hegner, Solarpraxis AG, Tel.: +49 | (0)30 | 726 296-304, Fax: +49 | (0)30 | 726 296-309,
[email protected] Platinum sponsor
Partners
Gold sponsors
Bronce sponsor
Media partners
Solar Energy
Solar Glass
Anti-reflective glass
makes clear gains
Glass is traditionally an important topic in solar engineering. But nowadays, unlike just a few years ago, the discussion is no longer about a supply shortage. Now, quality in general and coatings in particular are the focus. The manufacturers increasingly sell anti-reflective glass and place emphasis on special coatings for thin-film photovoltaics.
S
Processing: in a vacuum coat ing system, F-Glass applies functional layers to the glass. Photos (2): F-Glass
88
ince this year’s international trade fair Glasstec in Düsseldorf came to an end, we have updated our market overview from last year (see S&WE 7/2009, page 82). Our survey of 15 important manufacturers of solar glass has shown that anti-reflective (AR) coatings are becoming increasingly important. Out of the nine companies that participated in our survey this year, seven stated that they have had an increase in the sales of AR glass. Of the other two, one company does not offer any AR glass yet. One of the companies that deal intensively with AR coatings is Centrosolar Glas GmbH & Co. KG. At its headquarters in Fürth, Germany, Centrosolar Glas
produces float glass and textured glass. The mediumsized company claims to be the worldwide market leader in the field of AR-coated solar glass and to rank among the top three suppliers of uncoated solar glass. This claim is supported by the company’s capacity to process about six million m2 of glass annually. In 2009, the company still coated its AR glass using a dipping process. In the meantime, Centrosolar has put into operation a new production line for single-sided coating. It uses a roller to apply the antireflective coating to the plane glass surface (roller coating method). The Danish company Sunarc Technology A/S from Rønnede is exclusively active in processing glass into
Sun & Wind Energy 12/2010
AR glass. The company buys textured and float glass from other manufacturers and provides it with an anti-reflective coating. Sunarc is the only company to create the AR quality in an etching process. The antireflective layer is generated by etching the surface instead of applying an additional layer. The Liechtenstein-based company Interfloat Corporation produces three types of textured glass in its factory in the East German town of Tschernitz. For the first time, Interfloat now also offers anti-reflective glass – even though solar glass without an AR quality still accounts for the bulk of its products. General Manager Ulrich Frei had already announced this step last year. The company relies on well-tried processes: since Interfloat produces solar glass all the year round – and not in campaigns like many other manufacturers – constant product quality is ensured.
German-Chinese cooperation Hecker Glastechnik GmbH from Dortmund, Germany, also offers AR glass. Since 2001, the company has cooperated with the Chinese Jinjing Group. Jinjing produces textured glass as well as float glass according to European standards. Hecker processes this glass into single-pane safety glass – optionally in AR quality. In the spring of 2011, the current production capacity – Jinjing is one of the largest glass producers in China – will be complemented by an additional line for textured solar glass. Hecker also has an innovative new product: a solar glass with an anti-glare
quality for applications where people could be dazzled. It reduces the dazzling effect in comparison to normal glass, but this does not impair transmittance. Furthermore, this year the two partners have begun to produce anti-reflective glass with a coating on one side for the Chinese PV market. Of course, the Jinjing Group, which complements its own know-how with that of the partner Hecker, also sells solar glass under its own name. Float glass is produced by Shandong Jinjing Science & Technology Stock in Zibo City in the province of Shandong. It is also offered with an AR coating. Just recently, the company has expanded its production capacity for lowiron float glass from 600 to 1,800 tons per day. There are numerous other Chinese glass manufacturers that produce for the European market. In order to prove their products’ quality, these manufacturers like to have their glass certified by the Swiss Institute for Solar Technology SPF. One of them is Henan Succeed New Energy Material. At its headquarters in Qinyang in the province of Henan, the company produces textured glass for solar applications with and without an AR coating. In response to an enquiry from S&WE, the company reported that it is currently developing a special solar glass for the American photovoltaics market. Due to a non-disclosure agreement with the customer, the company cannot yet specify any details. But Succeed is pleased to give information about the expansion of its own production capacities. At present, three production lines for toughened glass and six lines for AR coating are under construction. The new line for toughened glass will have a production capacity of 10 million m2. The new capacity for AR glass will be 4 million m2 for glass coated in a dipping process and 2 million m2 for glass coated using a roller coating process. Succeed wants to significantly increase the proportion of AR glass. In 2009, the capacity utilization of the existing line for toughened glass was 80 %.
Interpane: vacuum coating for jumbo sizes Interpane Glas Industrie AG, which has its headquarters in the North German town of Lauenförde, applies the anti-reflective coating iplus HT to float glass and textured glass. The company has transferred the pro cess from its pilot plant to its industrial coating facility. Since 2006, Interpane has been able to apply solar anti-reflective layers to glass in large sizes up to about 3 m x 6 m using a vacuum process. This can be done either just on one side or on both sides. During subsequent tempering, the glass is not only process ed into single-pane safety glass, but the AR coating is also firmly combined with the glass. At the locations Lauenförde and Plattling in Southern Germany, the company maintains its own solar glass production facilities. Since the beginning of 2010, the anti-reflective coating process developed by Interpane has also been used by the company F-Glass GmbH in SülzetalOsterweddingen (Saxony-Anhalt) in float glass pro-
Sun & Wind Energy 12/2010
89
Solar Energy
Solar Glass
Textured glass is very popu lar in crystalline PV and for flat-plate collectors. It gives the collector or module its characteristic frosted or rough surface. Photo: Saint-Gobain duction. F-Glass is a joint venture between Interpane and the Dutch glass manufacturer Scheuten, which has been active in the glass business since 1959. In the summer of 2009, the joint-venture put into operation a float glass production line in Sülzetal for the continuous production of solar glass. There, a staff of around 270 produces up to 700 tons a day of low-iron float glass, the company says. April 2010 saw the start of operation of the toughening furnace with a capacity of about 4.5 million m2 annually and the continuous coating line with a capacity of 6 million m2 annually. In the 230 m long facility, a mono-broadband coating is applied using the previously mentioned process in order to produce AR glass. The solar glass is processed under ultra-clean vacuum conditions. The AR coating made of robust quartz increases the transmittance, which has been confirmed by flash tests under standard test conditions, and additionally protects the glass from detrimental environmental influences. For thin-film applications, the coating line also provides the option of applying layers by magnetron sputtering.
A cutting plant cuts the glass to the desired dimensions.
90
AGC Solar belongs to the AGC Group, which is based in Japan but active worldwide. Via its parent group, AGC can rely on more than 100 years of experience in glass production. For its textured and float glass, the glass manufacturer offers the anti-reflective coating Sparc, which brings about an increase in transmittance of 2.4 %, measured according to ISO 9050. At present, AGC produces its textured glass in Belgium, China, Japan, Thailand and the US states of Kansas and Tennessee. In response to the rising demand for AR-coated solar glass, this year AGC has also begun to apply the AR layer Sparc in the textured glass factory in the Belgian town of Roux. Saint-Gobain is one of the world’s leading glass suppliers. Hence, it is little wonder that the company is in demand in the solar sector as well. Low-iron float glass and textured glass with a frosted or prismatic surface accounts for the bulk of the solar glass. Furthermore, Saint-Gobain offers a cast glass with a deep texture. A pyramidal or wave shape causes multiple light refractions, which increases yield by 3 % in comparison with standard cast glass, as the French company promises its customers. Also in the case of the Saint-Gobain products, transmittance is increased even further by the AR coating, which can be applied to any of the glass products, even the deeply textured glass. The Turkish company Trakya Cam, which belongs to the Sisecam Group founded in 1924, does not yet offer any AR glass. Instead, the company continues to work on improving the transmittance of its plate glass Durasolar P+, which Trakya produces in the South Turkish city of Mersin. The company conducts its R&D activities in the research centre of the Sisecam Group, which is accredited according to the standard EN 45001 for testing laboratories and is a member of the International Commission on Glass (ICG). Trakya’s glass is certified by the Institute for Solar Technology SPF and is sold to companies in Germany and elsewhere in Europe. The company is making further investments in facilities for the production of solar glass at the Mersin location. For example, the start of operation of a new furnace for casting textured glass is scheduled for the first quarter of 2011.
Sun & Wind Energy 12/2010
There are also several manufacturers from India that offer low-iron glass for the solar industry (see S&WE 10/2010, page 108). Gujarat Borosil Limited, for example, has set up a modern factory to meet the rising domestic demand for high-quality solar glass and in order to export to the EU (see S&WE 9/2010, page 118). The low-iron solar glass is a borosilicate glass, which is offered with a matt-frosted or prismatic-frosted texture. It is tempered according to EN 12150. In Europe, the products from Borosil are distributed by the Dutch company Vertrad NV.
The British company Pilkington is another supplier of solar glass. Since 2006, it has been part of the NSG Group, one of the world’s largest manufacturers of glass and glass products for the construction and vehicle markets. The Pilkington product range includes the float glass Optiwhite, a white glass low in iron oxide and suitable for solar applications. It is produced in Weiherhammer in South Germany. There, Pilkington has recently completely modernized and extended its production line II.
Overview of glass products for modules and collectors Supplier
Designation
Glass type
Transmittance [%]
Glass thicknesses [mm]
Max. dimensions
Standard solar glass AGC Solar
Solite/Solatex Sunmax
textured glass
91.5 %
3.2 / 4.0
1,650 mm x 2,160 mm
float glass
91.0 %
3.2 / 4.0
1,650 mm x 2,160 mm
textured glass
91.5 %
3.2 / 4.0
n/a
3.2 / 4.0
n/a
3 to 12
n/a
Centrosolar Glas
Centrosol MM / SM Centrosol C+
float glass
91.0 %
Euroglas
Eurowhite Solar
float glass
up to 92 % 1
2.8 to 4.0
2,200 x 2,600 mm
F-Glass
F-Solarfloat
float glass
91.3 % 2
Gujarat Borosil
Low Iron Solar Glass
textured glass
91.6 %
3.2 / 4.0
2,500 x 3,500 mm
T-Safe Solar Pattern
textured glass
91.6 %
2.5 / 3.2 / 4.0
2,134 mm x 3,050 mm
Hecker Glastechnik
T-Safe Solar Float
float glass
90.0 %
3.2 / 4.0
2,134 mm x 3,050 mm
Henan Succeed New Energy Material
Succeed Solar Glass
textured glass
91.6 %
3.2 / 4.0
1,200 mm x 2,400 mm
Interfloat
Silk / Cone / Astra
textured glass
92.0 %
2.5 to 6
2,000 mm x 3,000 mm
Pilkington (NSG Group)
Optiwhite
2 to 19
n/a
float glass
up to 91.0 %
Securit Albarino S/T
textured glass
91.5 %
n/a
n/a
Securit Diamant Solar
float glass
91.2 %
n/a
n/a
Shangdong Jinjing Science & Tech nology Stock
Solar Low Iron Glass
float glass
91.0 % 90.8 %
3.2 4.0
2,440 mm x 3,660 mm 3,660 mm x 8,000 mm
Trakya
Durasolar P+
textured glass
91.6 %
3.2 / 4.0
n/a
Sparc
AR coating for textured or float glass
+ 2.4 % 2
3.2 / 4.0
1,650 mm x 2,160 mm
Centrosolar Glas
Centrosol HiT
Nano Power AR coating for textured or float glass
+6%
3.2 / 4.0
n/a
F-Glass
F-Solarfloat HT
AR coating for float glass
+ 2.5 % 2
2.8 to 4.0
2,200 x 2,600 mm
Hecker Glastechnik
Energy Vision
AR-coated solar glass (textured or float glass)
96.6 %
3.2 / 4.0
1,200 mm x 2,250 mm
Henan Succeed New Energy Material
Succeed AR Solar Glass
AR-coated textured glass
97.3 %
3.2 / 4.0
1,000 mm x 2,000 mm
Interpane Glas Industrie
iplus HT
AR coating for textured or float glass
min. + 2.2 % (PV) 2 min. + 4 % (solar thermal) 3
2.8 to 12
3,210 mm x 6,000 mm
Sunarc Technology
depending on the supplier
AR coating to be etched on textured or float glass
+5%
n/a
n/a
PV-AR
AR coating for textured or float glass
+ 2.5 % 4
n/a
n/a
deeply textured glass
+3%
n/a
n/a
Saint-Gobain Solar
Anti-reflective solar glass / anti-reflective coatings AGC Solar
Saint-Gobain Solar
Securit Albarino P/G
1 in the case of glass thicknesses of 3 to 5 mm; 2 energy transmittance according to ISO 9050; 3 according to EN 410; 4 increase in transmittance compared with the basic glass in the case of perpendicular incidence of radiation
This overview shows which types of glass the manufacturers offer. The transmittance values are difficult to compare because they were not mea sured according to uniform standards. Especially the AR figures have to be considered with caution: the mean values specified by the manufac turers can differ widely, depending on the measurement method. Under standard measurement conditions, however, the manufacturers achieve similar values, as AGC, F-Glass, Interpane and Saint-Gobain show. Source: company data
Sun & Wind Energy 12/2010
91
Solar Energy Further information: AGC Solar: www.agc-solar.com Centrosolar Glas: www.centrosolarglas.de Euroglas: www.euroglas.com F-Solar: www.fsolar.de Gujarat Borosil: www.borosil.com Hecker Glastechnik: www.hecker-solarglas.de Henan Succeed New Energy Material: www.succeedglass.com Interfloat: www.interfloat.com Interpane: www.interpane.com Pilkington: www.pilkington.de Saint-Gobain Solar Glass: www.saint-gobain-solar.com Shandong Jinjing Science & Technology Stock: www.cnggg.cn Sunarc Technology: www.sunarc.net Trakya Cam Sanayii: www.trakyacam.com.tr
Solar Glass Coatings for thin-film PV are the trend In addition to the textured and float varieties of solar glass, numerous manufacturers also offer special glass for thin-film photovoltaic applications. For example AGC Solar: its float glass PV 200 deforms to a lesser extent than soda-lime glass when heated and is therefore suitable as a large-area substrate for CI(G)S applications. As a back glass for CI(G)S modules, AGC offers Moly, a molybdenum-coated float glass. For manufacturers of silicon thin-film and CdTe modules, AGC provides float glass with various TCO coatings for application as front glass. The AGC product range also includes special glass products for CSP applications: glass tubes are available with diameters of up to 250 mm. They are suitable as receiver tubes. The extra-thin solar mirror Sun Mirox is laminated onto a carrier material and then acts as a parabolic mirror or a parabolic trough. Interpane, too, offers special coatings for thinfilm photovoltaics, such as blockers, molybdenum coatings and TCO coatings. Shandong Jinjing offers its float glass with a TCO coating. Another company that produces glass for thin-film photovoltaics is Euroglas GmbH. Since June 2009, the company has processed the low-iron float glass Eurowhite Solar for thin-film PV in its new factory in Haldensleben, Saxony-Anhalt. Euroglas has been selling only the TCO-coated Euroglas PV Hy