Studies in Stemmatology II
Studies in Stemmatology II Edited by
Pieter van Reenen August den Hollander Margot van Mu...
170 downloads
1493 Views
12MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Studies in Stemmatology II
Studies in Stemmatology II Edited by
Pieter van Reenen August den Hollander Margot van Mulken With the assistance of Annelies Roeleveld
John Benjamins Publishing Company Amsterdam/Philadelphia
8
TM
The paper used in this publication meets the minimum requirements of American National Standard for Information Sciences – Permanence of Paper for Printed Library Materials, ansi z39.48-1984.
Publication of this volume was financially supported by the Netherlands organization for scientific research (NWO)
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Studies in Stemmatology II / edited by Pieter van Reenen, August den Hollander and Margot van Mulken. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and indexes. 1. Manuscripts. 2. Manuscripts, Medieval. 3. Transmission of texts. I. Reenen, Pieter Th. van. II. Hollander, A. A. den III. Mulken, Margot van Z105.S782 2004 091-dc22 isbn 90 272 3222 9 (Eur.) / 1 58811 535 6 (US) (Hb; alk. paper)
20040100159
© 2004 – John Benjamins B.V. No part of this book may be reproduced in any form, by print, photoprint, microfilm, or any other means, without written permission from the publisher. John Benjamins Publishing Co. · P.O. Box 36224 · 1020 me Amsterdam · The Netherlands John Benjamins North America · P.O. Box 27519 · Philadelphia pa 19118-0519 · usa
Table of contents
Prologue
vii
I. Stemmatological methods and techniques Parallels between stemmatology and phylogenetics Christopher Howe, Adrian Barbrook, Linne Mooney, and Peter Robinson Problems of a highly contaminated tradition: the New Testament: Stemmata of variants as a source of a genealogy for witnesses Gerd Mink
3
13
Kinds of variants in the manuscript tradition of the Greek New Testament 87 Klaus Wachtel How shock waves revealed successive contamination: A cardiogram of early sixteenth-century printed Dutch Bibles August den Hollander
99
The manuscript tradition of the Cligés of Chrétien de Troyes: A stemmatological approach Margot van Mulken
113
II. Textual variation Genealogy by chance! On the significance of accidental variation (parallelisms) Ulrich Schmid Constructing initial binary trees in stemmatology Evert Wattel Trouble in the trees! Variant selection and tree construction illustrated by the texts of Targum Judges Willem F. Smelik
127 145
167
Table of contents
Scribal variations: When are they genealogically relevant – and when are they to be considered as instances of ‘mouvance’? Lene Schøsler The effects of weighting kinds of variants Matthew Spencer, Linne R. Mooney, Adrian C. Barbrook, Barbara Bordalejo, Christopher J. Howe, and Peter Robinson Cluster analysis and the Three Level Method in the study of the Gospels in Slavonic Dina Mironova Different kinds of tradition in Targum Jonathan to Isaiah Alberdina Houtman
207 227
241 269
Valentin and Namelos discover their parentage: Narrative elements in the family tree of an international medieval tale Annelies Roeleveld, Erika Langbroek, and Evert Wattel
285
Index
305
Prologue
The publication of this volume of Studies in Stemmatology is the second in a series. Its predecessor was published in 1996 and opened the most actual state of the art in stemmatology to a broad audience.1 That volume not only aimed at giving scholars access to modern stemmatological methods and techniques, but also at illustrating how profitable the application of these methods might be for their future work. The first volume was very well received by stemmatologists all over Europe and also gave an impulse to new research, as several articles in Studies in Stemmatology II clearly illustrate. The contributions to this present book partly proceed from those of the first volume. Most of them are the result of the on-going scholarly debate on stemmatology of recent years. Several of the contributions to this volume were presented on 13–14 April 2000, during the NOSTER-conference at the Netherlands Institute of Advanced Studies (NIAS) at Wassenaar, and on 13 October 2000, during the Stemmatology Conference at the Vrije Universiteit in Amsterdam. Some others are the result of the annual colloquia of stemmatologists, held at the Vrije Universiteit in Amsterdam.2 The object of this second volume of Studies in Stemmatology is the evaluation of the most recent methods and techniques in the field of stemmatology, as well as the development of new ones. The book is largely interdisciplinary in character: it contains contributions from scholars from classical, historical, biblical (Smelik, Houtman, Den Hollander), medieval and modern language studies, as well as from mathematical and computer scientists (Wattel) and biologists (Howe e.a.; Spencer e.a.). Various manuscript traditions are dealt with here: some of them within one field of language (Van Mulken, Schøsler), some multilingual (Roeleveld/Langbroek/Wattel), the last group of course requiring a special methodological approach to the establishment of variants. Other traditions were very extensive, e.g. the New Testament manuscripts (Mink, Wachtel) and the Old Church Slavonic manuscripts (Mironova). The contributions in the book have been divided into two sections. The first section deals with various stemmatological methods and techniques. The second section focusses more specifically on the various problems concerning textual variation.
Prologue
Stemmatological methods Not a bifurcating tree? Christopher Howe, Adrian Barbrook, Linne Mooney and Peter Robinson present a relatively new stemmatological approach. They explore the similarities between the evolution of DNA sequences and the changes occurring in manuscript traditions. They show how the techniques of evolutionary biology can be applied to stemmatic analysis and how a number of features of manuscript traditions have clear parallels in genetics. They conclude that the process of incorporation into DNA mirrors the incorporation of changes into the manuscripts. It follows that programs for phylogenetic analysis of sequence data can be exploited for stemmatic analysis of manuscript tradition. For this approach the Splits Tree program is used, which has the advantage that it does not presuppose, as many methods do, that the tree is a bifurcating one.
Local stemmata? Methodologically new, and very promising, is the contribution of Gert Mink. In his contribution he broaches the problem of a text tradition of many hundreds of manuscripts in which hardly any type-2 variants are found and contamination is the rule. This is the case in one of the catholic letters of the New Testament, the Epistle of James. In such a tradition existing methods cannot be applied. Instead, Mink has two working hypotheses on which his approach is based: a. If more than one exemplar was consulted by a scribe, the exemplars are closely related. b. Variants are analysed one by one in local trees. Within the local trees the direction of the changes can be determined: they can be oriented by establishing which variant derives from which other variant. When groups of local trees are oriented in the same direction, parts of global trees can be constructed.
Reduction of witnesses Klaus Wachtel also deals with this extremely large textual tradition. In his contribution he shows how the number of manuscripts to examine can be reduced before the structuring of a stemma. The number of extant manuscripts of the
Prologue
New Testament is so large that any reasonable form of reduction of quantities must be accepted before the building of a stemma starts. By distinguishing two groups of manuscripts in the New Testament tradition Wachtel succeeds in doing so. The two groups distinguished are the Majority group and the Byzantine group. If two or more manuscripts are almost alike, there is no need for further analysis. By applying this approach Wachtel succeeds in reducing the numbers considerably, without the risk of excluding manuscripts which contain crucial textual information. The resulting group forms the input of Gert Minks analysis.
Dealing with successive contamination A illuminating example of how profitable the application of modern stemmatological tools can be is given in the contribution of August den Hollander. One of the complex problems a philologist has to deal with is a contaminated text tradition. In the first volume of Studies in Stemmatology Wattel and Van Mulken offered the instrument of the so-called shock waves (cardiograms) as a help to reveal successive contamination in a text tradition which is rather entangled. In his contribution Den Hollander shows how the application of this instrument indisputably revealed successive contamination in the textual tradition of early sixteenth-century printed Dutch Bibles. In her contribution to the present volume, Margot van Mulken shows that the output of the quire separator developed by Wattel (see first volume) may have serious consequences for the further treatment of the stemmatological process. When the separator indicates successive contamination, as in the case of the Cligés, it may be necessary to presuppose a multiple orientation of the stemmata. However, in the case of the Cligés, all the archetypes can be found in the neighbourhood of one manuscript, which fortunately reduces the complexity of this operation.
Textual variation Accidental variation Ulrich Schmid explores the phenomenon of accidental variation (parallelism). His contribution is a reaction to the recent study of B. J. P. Salemans, who systematically reviewed various types of variant readings used in genealogical studies, and offered strict text-genealogical rules in order to exclude possible
Prologue
variants caused by accidental variation.3 In his contribution, Schmid illustrates the implications of applying Salemans’ rules to a text tradition: on the one hand they would exclude too much, leaving out many genealogically ‘valid’ variants, on the other hand even the variants that would be included on the basis of Salemans’ rules, still contain parallelistic readings. Therefore, Schmid concludes, no safe line can be drawn without proper statistical evaluation.
No reduction of variants Evert Wattel also writes as a reaction to the dissertation of Salemans. Textual scholars do not generally agree on which type of variant readings are suitable for the construction of a stemma, and which are not. In his contribution Evert Wattel argues for the acceptance of as many version formulas as possible, in addition to expressing the reliability of the variants by adding more or less weight to the so-called version formulas. His main focus is on the computational problems of constructing a stemma on the basis of the collective formulas. Along with a more general methodological discussion, he dwells on specific problems such as lacunary version formulas and the computational complexity.
Categories of variants In his contribution Willem Smelik deals with variant selection and tree construction in the text tradition of Targum Judges. The core of this study consists of observations on the phenomenon of random variation in the manuscript reproduction. To identify random or coincidental variation, he suggests a transparent, verifiable categorisation of variant readings. Secondly, he discusses the possible genealogical information of these various types of variants in great detail. Further, Smelik draws stemmata for each type or group of types of variants. Finally, comparison of these stemmata reveals which types of variants turned out to be genealogical relevant in his textual tradition, and which not. Lene Schøsler compares the categorised variants of two closely related manuscripts of the Perceval and four (five?) manuscripts of the Charroi de Nîmes. The first two were copied by the same scribe, with perhaps a difference in time. Assuming that the scribe copied twice from the same exemplar, it is remarkable that the variations found between the two manuscripts and those in the tradition of the Charroi de Nîmes are hardly different. In other words, whether the same scribe copies the same manuscript twice or different scribes copy a manuscript may not necessarily result in more variants.
Prologue
Weighting variants? In their contribution Matthew Spencer, Linne Mooney, Adrian Barbrook, Barbara Bordalejo, Christopher Howe and Peter Robinson attempt to increase the chance of reconstructing correct stemmas by categorizing variants into ten different kinds, such as: “line changed completely”, “word change affecting rhyme”, “word variant, changes meaning”, “minor word added or omitted, without changing meaning”. On the assumption that not all kinds of variants are equally reliable, the more a category of variants is reliable the more weight it is assigned. On comparison between stemmata of the 55 manuscripts and three printed versions of Lydgate’s Kings of England, the choice of weights appeared relatively unimportant. However, the authors expect that this may be different in larger textual traditions. The method used to reconstruct the stemmata was neighbour-joining: a simple clustering algorithm which sequentially separates pairs of manuscripts from an initially unresolved stemma. Dina Mironova deals with the problem of a textual tradition of many manuscripts. She compares two different formal genealogical methods in her study of the Gospels in Slavonic: cluster analysis (Alexeev) and the Three Level Method (Wattel). Her research comprises no fewer than 531 manuscripts, still presenting, however, a rather stable text. The large number of witnesses impelled her to work with groups of manuscripts as a way of reduction. Alexeev’s method turned out be less accurate, but more economical, since it is still easier to apply to large traditions. Wattel’s method is, however, more accurate, and forces the scholar to formulate precise classifications or explicit philological labellings. Despite the difficulties with extremely large textual traditions, according to Mironova his method is to be preferred when variants should be evaluated (weighted).
Exclusion of variants Dineke Houtman studies the textual history of Tosefta Targum Jonathan, an extended Aramaic Bible commentary. She focuses on the question of how to deal with this type of text in stemmatological research, especially when comparing it with the Hebrew Bible text and its paraphrasing Aramaic Targum text. All three types of text represent different stages in the textual history. The text of the Targum remains close to the Hebrew Bible, the text of Tosefta Targum, however, gives a more free rendering. Houtman concludes that including textual variants from the Tosefta Targum may introduce a lot of bias in the re-
Prologue
sults of the stemmatological research and should therefore be done with great precaution.
Alternative classification of variants Annelies Roeleveld and Erika Langbroek, in cooperation with Evert Wattel, deal with the text tradition of ‘Valentin and Namelos’. Its extant manuscripts are written in no fewer than four languages/dialects: Middle Dutch, Middle Low German, Middle Mid German and Old Swedish. Other differences between the texts are also considerable: some are in verse, others in prose; some are much more lengthy and elaborate in their descriptions than others; some have been preserved in fragments only. The problem in this tradition is what sort of variant to group in comparable units. The authors develop a classification in which the number of incidents, the order of incidents and the detail in the description of incidents play a part. Although this notion of variant goes beyond the traditional view, their approach shows that satisfactory results can be obtained. The resulting stemma plausibly shows that the Middle Dutch versions are the more original. Rhyme analysis had already pointed in the same direction; the original language was most probably Middle Dutch. The editors hope that this second volume of Studies in Stemmatology will inspire scholars like the first volume did, and stimulate the development of new methods and strategies aiming at further control of variation and contamination in (large) text traditions. Pieter van Reenen August den Hollander Margot van Mulken
Notes . Studies in Stemmatology (1996). Pieter van Reenen & Margot van Mulken (Eds.). Amsterdam/Philadelphia: John Benjamins Publishing Co. . At this place we wish to thank NIAS, NOSTER and the Faculty of Arts of the Free University for their willingness to support the various stemmatological meetings in the past years. . B. J. P Salemans (2000). Building Stemmas with the Computer in a Cladistic, NeoLachmannian, way. The Case of Fourteen Text Versions of Lanseloet van Denemerken (diss. Nijmegen). Nijmegen.
P I
Stemmatological methods and techniques
Parallels between stemmatology and phylogenetics Christopher Howe*, Adrian Barbrook*, Linne Mooney, and Peter Robinson University of Cambridge* / University of Maine, Orono / De Montfort University, Leicester
.
Introduction
The work and ideas we discuss here are part of a project entitled “STEMMA – Studies on Textual Evolution of Manuscripts by Mathematical Analysis”, funded by the Leverhulme Trust. This project aims to apply the techniques of evolutionary biology to the analysis of manuscript traditions. In particular we are interested in the application of computer programs developed for evolutionary biology to the study of manuscripts. In this paper we explore the similarities between the evolution of DNA sequences and the changes occurring in manuscript traditions. We will show how the techniques of evolutionary biology can be applied to stemmatic analysis and how a number of features of manuscript traditions have clear parallels in genetics. Another paper in this volume (Spencer et al.), to which this chapter should serve as an introduction, discusses more specific issues in this work. The computer programs we are using were developed for research in biology, so their application to manuscript stemmatics requires some knowledge of the underlying biology. A more detailed discussion can be found in biological textbooks (e.g. Voet et al. 1999). DNA (deoxyribonucleic acid) is comprised of four kinds of unit. These are collectively called nucleotides (more fully deoxyribonucleotides), and the four kinds are adenosine, guanosine, cytidine and thymidine deoxyribonucleotides. They are more conveniently designated A, G, C and T. DNA molecules are composed of chains of such nucleotides, and the order in which individual nucleotides comes carries the information used in
Christopher Howe et al.
biological systems. It specifies the order of amino acids in proteins, and thus the structure and function of proteins, which are the main functional entities in cells. For example, enzymes, which catalyse the reactions of metabolism, are proteins. In most systems, the DNA chains come in pairs – forming the double helix made famous by Watson and Crick (Watson & Crick 1953). The sequence of nucleotides in one strand determines the sequence in the other. Thus A in one is always opposite T in the other, G in one opposite C in the other. As cells divide, their genetic information has to be duplicated. This process is termed DNA replication, and the aim is to make an identical copy of the parental molecule. However, errors can occur in the replication process, so a parental molecule with sequence, say, ACGGTACTAG TGCCATGATC
might give rise to two daughters, one of which had the same sequence, and the other of which had a different sequence, say ACGGCACTAG TGCCGTGATC
Here, the T in the fifth position in the upper strand has been replaced by a C, and in the lower strand an A has been replaced by a G. We say that a ‘mutation’ has occurred, and the information in the DNA has been altered.
. Recovering phylogenetic trees As biological species evolve and give rise to new species, they accumulate mutations in their DNA. The longer it is since two species had a common ancestor, the more different (in general) is their DNA sequence. So we can use the differences in DNA sequence among species as a way of inferring their evolutionary relationships. We can recover something akin to a family tree, showing which species share a common ancestor to the exclusion of others. This is called a phylogenetic tree. Recovering a phylogenetic tree using a given DNA sequence for a group of species requires both a model for sequence evolution and a method for tree recovery. Models of sequence evolution are in effect a set of assumptions about how the sequences change. They may be explicit (in which case the computer program being used will require them to be specified or use default settings) or
Parallels between stemmatology and phylogenetics Suppose we have species W, X, Y and Z, with the following sequences (in reality, much longer sequences would be used): W X Y Z
AAAAAAAA GGAAAAAA CCTTTTAA CCTTCCAA
The distance matrix would be W W – X – Y –
X 2 – –
Y 6 6 –
Z 6 6 2
and the tree inferred would be: 1 W
1
Y
4 X
1
1
Z
Figure 1. Hypothetical example of a distance matrix analysis.
they may be implicit, in which case one may be unaware that these assumptions are being made. It is particularly important to realize that, even if invalid assumptions are being made, it will still usually be possible to recover a phylogenetic tree. However, the tree may be incorrect as a result of making the wrong assumptions. Examples of the assumptions that may be made as part of a model include the relative frequencies of certain kinds of mutation (often termed the transition/transversion ratio); independence of mutations (i.e. that mutation at one position does not affect the chance of a mutation at another position); or identical distribution (that the same regions of a sequence are potentially able to mutate in all the organisms being considered). Evolutionary biologists use several methods for tree recovery, including distance matrix, parsimony, maximum likelihood (reviewed by Felsenstein 1988; Beanland & Howe 1992) and split decomposition methods (Huson 1998). With distance matrix methods, one calculates a matrix showing the number of differences between pairs of sequences, and determines the tree which has the best fit to this matrix. An example is given in Figure 1. With parsimony methods we prefer the tree which requires the fewest mutations. This is in effect a cladistic analysis. So, for example, with the following DNA sequences (showing only one of the two strands):
Christopher Howe et al.
W X Y Z
AAGCCAAT TAGCCAAT CGCTTGGT GGCTTGGT
Positions 2–7 would require fewest mutations if species W and X shared most recent common ancestry to the exclusion of Y and Z. Then, the most parsimonious tree would be as shown in Figure 2A. Maximum likelihood attempts to find the tree that has the highest probability of generating the data (i.e. sequences) observed. This approach can be very computationally intensive. With split decomposition, as implemented in the program SplitsTree we consider possible splits between the sequences, e.g. (WX, YZ) or (WY, XZ) etc. and look at the number of nucleotide positions consistent with each split. Split decomposition has a number of potentially desirable features. It does not presuppose, as many methods do, that the tree is a bifurcating one. It allows recovery of trees where one individual can have many descendents. It also allows conflicting information to be shown – where there are some positions in the data which are not consistent with the preferred tree. These appear as boxes in the output, giving a network rather than a tree. So the example given in Figure 2B would arise where there was some signal linking W with Y and X with Z, as well as the signal linking W with X and Y with Z. W
Y
X
Z
Figure 2A. Other tree-recovery methods. 2A shows results of parsimony analysis using the hypothetical data shown in the text. W
Y
X
Z
Figure 2B. Other tree-recovery methods. 2B shows the result of a hypothetical split decomposition analysis where there is support both for WX, YZ groupings and for WY, XZ groupings.
Parallels between stemmatology and phylogenetics
. Stemmatic analysis The techniques which are used to recover evolutionary trees can be applied in principle to datasets derived from manuscript traditions, using changes between texts in the same way as evolutionary biologists use changes between the DNA sequence of different organisms (Platnick & Cameron 1977; Cameron 1987; Lee 1989; O’Hara & Robinson 1989; Barbrook et al. 1998). We are applying this to a range of texts, such as John Lydgate’s 15th century poem, Kings of England, which exists in over 30 manuscript versions comprising a set of stanzas describing the Kings of England from William the Conqueror onwards. Thus we have variants such as: Worthy to stand among the worthy nyne Able to stand among the worthi nyne Able to stande among the worthyes nyne
for the same line in different texts. (These are variants of line 96 of the poem in Oxford, Bodleian, Rawlinson C.316, fol. 122v; Cambridge, Jesus College Q.G.8 (56), fol. 47v; and Ipswich, County Hall Deposit C4/4, Percyvale’s Great Doomsday Book, Bk. VI, fol. 239v.) We can encode this information to produce a dataset resembling a nucleotide sequence, (but using any letters or numbers rather than just A, C, G or T) to represent different readings at a given position, and use this directly as an input to a phylogenetic program such as SplitsTree. Thus we recently produced a stemmatic analysis of the extant manuscript versions of Lydgate’s Kings of England based on evolutionary biological techniques, which replicated stemmatic analysis done by traditional methods (Figure 3). Many of the manuscripts grouped together in the traditional stemmatic analysis were also grouped together in the phylogenetic analysis. Some were grouped together in the former, but not in the latter. This might simply reflect a need for more information in the dataset used. All groupings in the phylogenetic analysis were consistent with those in the traditional analysis. This study is described in more detail elsewhere (Mooney et al. 2001). It is remarkable how many parallels there are between the evolution of genetic material and the changes occurring in manuscripts (Howe et al. 2001). These include recombination, convergent evolution and transposition. We will look at these parallels in turn. Genetic recombination is the process whereby two different copies of a gene come together to produce a hybrid called a recombinant. The first part of the recombinant comes from one precursor gene, and the second from the other. The parallel in manuscript traditions is the change of exemplar de-
Christopher Howe et al. Harley 2261 Lambeth 306 Harley 7333 Egerton 1995
Peterborough Nottingham
Harley 2251 BL Ad 34360 Titus D.XX TCC 601 2
Buhler 17 CUL Ad6686
Ashmole 59
Dublin 516
Bodley 48 Bodley 686 Bodley 912 Fairfax 16
TCC 601 1 Harley 372 Pynson Leiden Lansd. 699 Jesus 56 Rawl.C.316 Caius 249
0.01 distance units Linc.Lat 129
Figure 3. SplitsTree diagram of relationships among 27 most complete manuscripts and early printed copies of Lydgate’s Kings of England. Bold indicates group A, italics B, underlined C, suggested by manual analysis (Mooney et al. 2001).
scribed as “successive contamination” (Wattel & van Mulken 1996), when a scribe changed the text from which he was copying part of the way through. We found examples of this in the analysis of the Prologue to the Wife of Bath’s Tale, in that the position of some texts on the stemmatic tree changed when an analysis performed on the first part of the data was compared with one done on the second (Barbrook et al. 1998). Programmes are being developed to identify recombination breakpoints in genes, and these may be useful in stemmatic analysis (e.g. Holmes et al. 1999). As well as generating hybrids where there is a clear breakpoint, recombination can give rise to more complex products, where the resulting DNA sequence is a mosaic of the two parental versions of the sequence (e.g. Medgyesy et al. 1985). This process is analogous to simultaneous (where the scribe used several exemplars simultaneously) and incidental contamination (where the scribe used a single exemplar first and then modified the text afterwards with other exemplars) (Wattel & van Mulken 1996). Transposition of genetic information is when material from one source is inserted somewhere quite different. This is a feature of the life cycle of some viruses, for example. If the source of inserted DNA is a different species it would
Parallels between stemmatology and phylogenetics
be regarded as ‘lateral gene transfer’. We have found parallels in the Kings of England tradition where there is contamination of one tradition with material from another. Thus, the verse relating to William I begins typically: This myghti William Duk of Normandye, As bokes old makith mencioun, By just title and by his cheualrye, Made kyng by conquest of brutes Albyoun... (British Library, Harley 2251)
There exists another fifteenth-century poem on the Kings of England, not by Lydgate, which typically has this for William I: At Westmyster William icrowned was The furst day of Cristemas; A gret thyng after he dude thanne; Made the kyng of Skottys his legeman...
(Bodleian, Ashmole Rolls 21)
However, within this second tradition is a text with a clear example of transposition from the first: This myghtty William duke of Northmandy, That by juste tytill and also by chyualery Conquered this land and king bycome And the kyng of Scotts he made his legeman...
(Bodleian, Bodley 131)
Convergent evolution is when the same change occurs independently in different lineages. Thus, for example an AT base pair might replace a GC base pair at the same position independently in two different species. If this occurs frequently enough, evolutionary tree-building may be misled and species with a large number of convergent changes will be grouped artefactually closely. Convergent evolution is comparable to convergence or parallelism in manuscript traditions (Salemans 1996). So, for example, scribes working independently but in the same geographical area might alter words to fit their own dialect. An example of this might be the substitution of ‘kirk’ for ‘church’ in northern England and Scotland. Thus the same change may happen in two or more manuscripts not as a result of common ancestry, but as a result of having been produced in the same part of the country.
Christopher Howe et al.
. Conclusions The process of incorporation of changes into DNA mirrors the incorporation of changes into manuscripts. For this reason, programs for phylogenetic analysis of sequence data can be exploited for stemmatic analysis of manuscript traditions, and we believe the SplitsTree program has particular advantages. Just as phenomena such as recombination, transposition and convergent evolution may pose problems for the evolutionary biologist, there are closely parallel problems in stemmatic analysis. We hope that the development of techniques in one discipline to deal with these problems will help in their solution elsewhere.
Acknowledgements We thank Matthew Spencer and Barbara Bordalejo for helpful discussions, and the Leverhulme Trust for financial support.
References Barbrook, A. C., C. J. Howe, N. Blake, & P. Robinson (1998). “The phylogeny of the Canterbury Tales”. Nature, 394, 839. Beanland, T. & C. J. Howe (1992). “The inference of evolutionary trees from molecular data”. Comp. Biochem. Physiol., 102B, 643–659. Cameron, H. D. (1987). “The upside-down cladogram: problems in manuscript affiliation”. In H. M. Hoenigswald & L. F. Wiener (Eds.), Biological metaphor and cladistic classification: an interdisciplinary perspective (pp. 227–242). London: Frances Pinter. Felsenstein, J. (1988). “Phylogenies from molecular sequences: inference and reliability”. Ann. Rev. Genet., 22, 521–565. Holmes, E. C., M. Worobey, & A. Rambaut (1999). “Phylogenetic evidence for recombination in dengue virus”. Mol. Biol. Evol., 16, 405–409. Howe, C. J., A. C. Barbrook, M. Spencer, P. Robinson, B. Bordalejo, & L. R. Mooney (2001). “Manuscript evolution”. Trends Genet., 17, 147–152. Huson, D. H. (1998). “Splitstree: a program for analyzing and visualizing evolutionary data”. Bioinformatics, 14, 68–73. Lee, A. R. (1989). “Numerical taxonomy revisited: John Griffith, cladistic analysis and St. Augstine’s Quaestiones in Heptateuchem”. Studia Patristica, 20, 24–32. Medgyesy, P., E. Fejes, & P. Maliga (1985). “Interspecific chloroplast recombination in a Nicotiana somatic hybrid”. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA, 82, 6960–6964.
Parallels between stemmatology and phylogenetics
Mooney L. R., A. C. Barbrook, C. J. Howe, & M. Spencer (2001). “Stemmatic analysis of Lydgate’s Kings of England: a test case for the application of software developed for evolutionary biology to manuscript stemmatics”. Revue d’Histoire des Textes, 31, 275– 297. O’Hara, R. & P. Robinson (1993). “Computer-assisted methods of stemmatic analysis”. In N. Blake & P. Robinson (Eds.), The Canterbury Tales project occasional papers, Vol. 1 (pp. 53–74). London: Office for Humanities Communication Publications. Platnick, N. I. & H. D. Cameron (1977). “Cladistic methods in textual, linguistic, and phylogenetic analysis”. Syst. Zool., 26, 380–385. Salemans, B. J. P. (1996). “Cladistics or the Resurrection of the Method of Lachmann”. In P. van Reenen & M. van Mulken (Eds.), Studies in Stemmatology (pp. 3–55). Amsterdam: John Benjamins. Voet, D., J. G. Voet, & C. W. Pratt (1999). Fundamentals of Biochemistry. New York: John Wiley & Sons. Wattel, E. & M. J. P. van Mulken (1996). “Shock waves in text traditions”. In P. van Reenen & M. van Mulken (Eds.), Studies in Stemmatology (pp. 105–121). Amsterdam: John Benjamins. Watson, J. D. & F. H. C. Crick (1953). “Molecular structure of nucleic acids: a structure for deoxyribose nucleic acid”. Nature, 171, 737–738.
Problems of a highly contaminated tradition: the New Testament Stemmata of variants as a source of a genealogy for witnesses Gerd Mink Westfälische Wilhelms-Universität, Münster
. Introduction It is a well-known fact that the textual tradition of the New Testament poses a formidable challenge in the way of textual criticism and edition technique. The number of manuscripts that have come down is large; some 5600 known copies so far, although most of the older ones, in particular, have been lost. The real cause of the problems, however, is the vast degree of contamination. For such a textual tradition, existing methods of reconstructing the tradition are not sufficient and other approaches have to be developed. This study attempts to show a new way (i) of finding and evaluating the genealogical data that can be used to construct a stemma of such texts, and (ii) of constructing a stemma that reflects all genealogical data.1 The concept of coherence (cf. paragraph 4.11) will be essential for the analysis of genealogical relationships. The method is based on two design choices: (1) Instead of trying to start with the construction of overall structures of the relations between witnesses, the first step is to construct local stemmata of variants. Local stemmata consist of trees based upon just one place of variation, and not more than one. If possible, a local tree is constructed for each place of variation.
These local stemmata are oriented as far as possible, before being used as a basis of (sub)stemmata of witnesses or textual states (not of manuscripts). The following example illustrates how a local stemma can be constructed.
Gerd Mink
(εις εστιν ο νομοθετης) (“one is the lawgiver”) variants: a. και κριτης b. και ο κριτης c. κριτης d. omission local stemma of variants: a James 4:12/10-12
b
και κριτης “and judge” “and judge” “and the judge” “judge”
d c
Figure 1. A local stemma of variants
Following the custom of the Editio Critica Maior (ECM, cf. the next paragraph) the places of variation will be referred to by chapter and verse as well as word address.2 Lower-case letters indicate the variants. In the example from James 4:12/10-12 the best hypothesis is that variant a represents the original text, since the word κριτής (‘judge’) is very important for the author’s argument in the context. The omission in variant d, however, is easily explained as caused by homoioteleuton.3 Variant b occurs in rather unimportant witnesses and only adds the article to variant a.4 Variant c occurs in a single witness only;5 this witness is quite distant from even its closest relatives,6 which are part of the d attestation.7 Even more distant are the relatives that belong to the a attestation. Apparently, variant c is flawed, as the word καί (‘and’), which is in fact indispensable in the context, is missing. The stemma rests on the assumption that variant c is based upon variant d and corrected the omission in accordance with variant a. In that process, καί would have been overlooked, a typical error during revisions. However, it is also possible (hence the interrupted edge from d) that the only basis was variant a, and καί was omitted on account of the similarity of its initial letter with that in κριτής (homoioarkton); yet the closest relatives of the variant c witness (631) are all in the d attestation.8 (2) The contamination in the tradition is viewed as a process. The assumption is that, if contamination occurs, it emerges from those texts which were at the disposal of the scribe, i.e. texts in his direct environment, i.e. texts which are, for the most part, closely related with each other.
Problems of a highly contaminated tradition
James 5:7/45
“The farmer waits for the precious fruit being patient about it” (εως λαβη προιμον και οψιμον) (“until he receives an early and late one” / “until he/it receives something early and something late”) variants: a. (εως λαβη) omission (προιμον και οψιμον) (“until he receives an early and late one” / “until he/it receives something early and something late”) b. (εως λαβη) υετον (προιμον και οψιμον) “(until he/it receives early and late) rain” c. (εως) υετον (λαβη προιμον και οψιμον) “(until he/it receives early and late) rain” d. (εως λαβη) καρπον (προιμον και οψιμον) “(until he receives early and late) fruit” e. (εως λαβη) καρπον τον (προιμον και οψιμον) “(until he receives the early and late) fruit” f. (εως λαβη) και τον (προιμον και οψιμον) “(until he) also (receives) the (early and late one) a local stemma of variants:
c
b
d1
d2
f
e
Figure 2. Local stemma of variants: a more complex case
First of all, another example will demonstrate the importance of a close relationship between witnesses for the construction of a local stemma. After that, the two examples will be used to highlight the different textual developments, so typical of a contaminated tradition, in a given witness and its closest relatives. In Figure 2 the interpretation of variant a is not entirely clear. Is the meaning ‘the early and late fruit’, or something different? The vast majority of witnesses has variant b, resulting in a text of clear meaning. Because so many witnesses have this reading, relationships with witnesses of all variants can be found. Yet, it can be presumed a priori that the oldest layer in the attestation of variant b is to be found in some of its best-known witnesses, 02, 33, 81, 1852. These are more closely related to the witnesses of variant a than to others. The witnesses of variant c are particularly closely interrelated (with 96 to
Gerd Mink
99% agreements). As could be expected, further relatives are to be found in the b attestation. Variant c is not represented in an early layer of tradition. For variant d there is just one single closely related pair of witnesses (996, 1661). The remaining witnesses of d (398, 1175, a corrector of 01) are not closely related with each other; nor is there any special connection with the only witness of variant e (01, first hand). Variant d seems to have emerged on several occasions, by introducing the ‘fruit’ from the preceding context into the variant. 1175 has its closest relatives in the a attestation (03, 1739) and the b attestation (1243, 025; 01 of the e attestation is yet more remote); the other d witnesses have their closest relatives in the b attestation. One would, therefore, trace back their variant to variant b (cf. d2 in the local stemma). The variant of 1175 (d1) could be considered to derive from either a or b. For the time being, the question remains open. The witness of e (01) has its closest relative (03) in the a attestation (the relatives in the b attestation are quite remote). And even if variant f is not grammatically impossible, it is probably an error, which could theoretically have arisen from variants b, d, or e. The closest relatives of the single witness of f (69) are in the b attestation, from which, accordingly, it is being derived. It is a prerequisite for constructing a local stemma like the one in Figure 2 that the relationships between the witnesses as based on their degrees of agreement are known. In addition, one’s provisional assessments of the age and quality of a number of well-known witnesses is taken into account. Close relationships between witnesses alone do not say anything about the direction of textual development. Yet, if in a relationship the ancestor and the descendant can be successfully determined, further possibilities arise to ascertain a local stemma. Thus, in the example the first assumptions were confirmed; additionally, the ancestors of 1175 (variant d1) were successfully located in the a attestation,9 and d1 was accordingly derived from it (see Figure 2). Arguments for the genealogical connections between variants are based partly on their content and linguistic form, and partly on the relationship between their witnesses. The example of Figure 2 makes it clear how these relationships can explain why some witnesses share the same variant and why one variant could arise from another. Yet, a lack of relationship between witnesses can also reveal coincidental correspondences (cf. variant d). Knowledge of the correspondences between witnesses provides a first overview, which must then be examined and supplemented against information about their genealogical relationships. A closer look at the two instances under consideration reveals, in the different attestations of the variants, the traces of contamination among related
Problems of a highly contaminated tradition
witnesses. Witness P74 has 8 close relatives, which contain both instances: 02, 81, 03, 2344, 1735, 218, 01, 1718 (in order of decreasing degree of agreement).10 The distribution of the variants in the two variant places is as follows: James 4:12/10-12 a d James 5:7/45 a b e
01. 02. 03. 81. 1735. 2344. P74. 218. 1718. P74. 03. 02. 81. 218. 1718. 1735. 2344. 01.
Incidentally, it has emerged that all the close relatives mentioned have more older variants than P74.11 Therefore, P74 is probably not the ‘inventor’ of one of the variants at the two places of variation; on the contrary, its text is based on variants which are found in different close relatives with more older variants, and, consequently, we see the traces of contamination.
.
The Editio Critica Maior of the New Testament
The Institute for New Testament Textual Research in Münster, founded in 1959 by Kurt Aland, has by now accomplished – apart from a few exceptions – the task of collecting the basic material of the textual tradition of the New Testament. Nearly all known manuscripts of the Greek New Testament are now available on microfilm. The next aim was to sift the material in an intelligent way, to let new views about important manuscripts find their way into the minor editions of the institute, and finally to present an Editio Critica Maior, which does justice to present-day standards of knowledge and methodology. A first stage of work on the ECM has been the research, published since 1987, on the texts of the Greek manuscripts and their relevance (‘Text und Textwert’).12 This was intended to separate the majority of manuscripts containing the relatively uniform text which was standard at the end of the Byzantine tradition from the still large number of manuscripts which must be considered relevant on account of their deviations from the majority text. The basis was a collation of all available manuscripts according to a system of places of variation. These so-called test passages (‘Teststellen’) were known for the fact that they were different in the newer and older text forms. Research into ‘Text und Textwert’ made it possible to draw on particularly those manuscripts for the ECM, which do not contain the uniform text from the end of the textual tradition. Nevertheless, a number of witnesses of this late text are also represented in the ECM.
Gerd Mink
According to text tradition, the New Testament can be divided into five sections: the Gospels, the Acts of the Apostles and the Catholic Letters (which nearly always follow Acts in the manuscripts, making up, together with Acts, the corpus of the so-called Apostolos), the Letters of Paul and the Revelation of John. The Catholic Letters were the first field of research in the ECM project.13
. The Letter of James: Manuscripts and variants The Catholic Letters, starting with the Letter of James, appeared to be especially suitable to begin work on the ECM with. The number of manuscripts examined in the ‘Text und Textwert’ project (552) is of the same order as that for Acts, which have normally been copied together with the Catholic Letters. It is smaller than that for the Letters of Paul (about 750), and a great deal smaller than that for the Gospels (e.g. 1787 for the Gospel of Luke). Nevertheless, the number of witnesses relevant for the textual tradition is in no way smaller. The degree of contamination made the Catholic Letters very attractive for methodological investigation. As the material for the Letter of James was the first to be completely available, it has been researched most extensively. Unless otherwise indicated, the following refers to the Letter of James. As the ECM is mainly interested in the text of the first millennium, we excluded nearly all the uniform witnesses representing the final state of the Byzantine tradition from our study of James, i.e. 371 manuscripts of a total of 535. In addition, 19 lectionaries were selected for the ECM. Yet, I did not use them for my genealogical study because they cannot really be compared with the other manuscripts; they do not contain the full, continuous text, but lessons selected to be read during services. The remaining 164 Greek manuscripts contain the continuous text, with minor omissions occurring repeatedly. Some manuscripts have also suffered more substantial damage, resulting in lacunae occurring throughout the text. Yet, a number of manuscripts is quite badly fragmented: 10 contain less than 150 out of the 761 places of variation, in some of them no more than a couple of these places has survived. The important manuscript 04, at least, contains more than half of the text. The text of James contains about 1740 words; the exact number depends on textual decisions. The selected 164 Greek manuscripts, including the fragmentary ones, present 2132 genuine variants at 761 places of variation.14 Only variants were counted that appear in the first hands of manuscripts containing the continuous text.15 If the variants from Church Fathers and lectionaries and from early versions (Latin, Coptic, Syriac etc.) of the New Testament are
Problems of a highly contaminated tradition
number of occurrences
1000 900 800 700 600 500 400 300 200 100 0 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10 11 12 13 14 15
number of witnesses exceeded in an attestation (x10)
Figure 3. Distribution of size of the attestations
included, the total number for these 761 places is 2349.16 Since many of these 761 places comprise more than one word and since the text consists of about 1740 words, it follows that about half the text is subject to variation. The variants include all types, except for type 0 variations.17 Type 3 variations hardly play a significant role. Typical variations are A / BCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ (type 1) ABCDEFGH / IJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ (type 2) ABC / DEFGH / IJKLMNO / PQRS / TUV / WXYZ (type 4)
Type 4 variations are the most frequent. In Chapter 2 of James, spot checks revealed about 40% type 4 variations, 30% type 1 variations and 25% type 2 variations. The remainder was made up of type 3 variations. The distribution was atypical in some passages. A single witness is often responsible for the fact that type 1 variations occur more frequently in a major section of the text. On the other hand, longer units of variation in which several changes are mutually interdependent in all probability lead to type 4 variations. The values in Figures 3 and 4 are based on the variants of the 164 witnesses at the 761 places of variation, with each witness being represented by the first hand in a manuscript, and by the text (lemma) in a commentary.18 In Figure 3 the horizontal axis gives the number of witnesses (to be multiplied by 10) which is exceeded in an attestation. The vertical axis tells how often such an attestation occurs (e.g. about 700 attestations cover more than 110 witnesses).19 Figure 3 gives an indication of how the quantity of the attestations is distributed over their total number. The total number of variants and there-
Gerd Mink
450
number of occurrences
400
800
number of occurrences
350 300 250 200 150 100
700
50
600
0
1
500
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21
number of variants
400 300 200 100 0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
number of variants exceeded
Figure 4. Distribution of number of variants per place of variation
fore of attestations is 2132 (see above). It is apparent that small attestations (of up to 10 witnesses) are the most frequent, for there are only 965 instances of more than 10 witnesses. It is not surprising that this result corresponds to a high frequency of very large complementary attestations (more than 120 witnesses, 676 instances). In comparison with that, medium and large attestations make up only a relatively small part (e.g. there are only 128 instances of 41–120 witnesses). Figure 4 (top) shows how many variants (horizontal axis) occur in how many places of variation (vertical axis). In Figure 4 (bottom) the horizontal axis shows the number of variants which is exceeded in one place of variation, and the vertical axis gives the number of places of variation with this number of variants. Thus, while at the top it is shown that there are about 125 places with 3 variants,20 the lower diagram demonstrates that in about 150 places there are more than 3 variants.21 More than half of the places of variation have only 2 variants. More than 6 variants occur in 25 instances, more than 10 in only 4. A comparatively large part is made up of places of variation with 3 to 6 variants.
Problems of a highly contaminated tradition
Letter of James about 1740 words 535 Greek manuscripts available 164 manuscripts selected 761 places of variation 2132 variants of the 164 manuscripts 143 cases identical attestation 800 occurrences 104 cases identical one witness attestation 685 occurrences 39 cases of identical more-than-one-witness-attestation 115 ocurrences
Figure 5. The Letter of James; some numbers
The existence of 59 places of variation with only one variant is caused by deviating variants stemming from lectionaries, Church Fathers, or early versions which are assumed to be based on Greek exemplars at these places, but cannot be traced back to the first hands in the 164 manuscripts. The following numbers are based on the same data as Figure 3 and Figure 4: the variants of the 164 witnesses in 761 places of variation. If corrections, marginal variants, variants in commentaries, and the evidence from lectionaries, Church Fathers and early versions were included in the analysis, not only the total number of variants would be much larger, but the number of occurrences of identical attestations would also be smaller. The 2132 variants represent 2132 attestations of which 1332 are unique, i.e. there is no other attestation containing only the same witness or the same combination of witnesses. These unique attestations include those in the 59 places mentioned above.22 The chances of finding identical attestations among these are slight, as in each of the 59 places a number of witnesses is lacking from the 164 (due to fragmentation, unmotivated omission of larger passages or the like). There are 143 different cases in which identical attestations occur more than once. The sum of all the occurrences of these 143 cases is 800. Out of these 143 cases of identical attestations 104 concern attestations comprising only one witness. The sum of all their occurrences is 685. The 39 remaining cases relate to multiple-witness-attestations. The sum of their occurrences is 115. Of these 39 cases, 12 concern large complementary attestations in two neighbouring
Gerd Mink
places, either to only one Greek witness differing from the entire remainder of the textual tradition, or to witnesses from the field of lectionaries, Church Fathers or early versions. These 12 cases correspond to 24 occurrences. When the 12 cases are subtracted from the 39 cases of multiple-witness-combinations, two-witness-combinations are typical among the remaining ones (21 out of the 27 cases): they occur up to 6 times, typically twice or 3 times. Even wellknown pairs of manuscripts participate in two-witness-attestations only 5 or 6 times. There are only 6 cases (apart from the large complementary attestations mentioned above) in which more than two witnesses are combined. The richest combinations are 2 four-witness-cases. Each of them occurs 3 times. The conclusion of this is twofold: First, if we want to explore the genealogical patterns of the textual history of this tradition, we cannot base our research on identical combinations of witnesses, since they play only a very modest role. Typically, attestations do not have duplicates containing the same witnesses. The number of type 2 variants, the corner stone in the approach of Salemans (2000), is too small. Secondly, the James text is highly contaminated. It is therefore unavoidable that we focus our research on the analysis of contamination.
. Contamination as a process In a dense tradition, it is typical of contamination that a witness shares most of its variants with its closest relative and if it deviates from this relative the variants concerned can be found in other close relatives. In the text of James, contamination is the result of small steps. That these steps are small is visible only if the number of witnesses of the tradition that have been preserved is large. However, where the proportion of witnesses that are not preserved is high, contamination does not appear to be the result of small steps, as so many intermediate witnesses are missing. If the density of a tradition is very high (as it was in the middle ages from the 11th century onwards), nearly all the witnesses have very close relatives. The agreement values are typically high, between 94% and 98%, even if the most uniform Byzantine witnesses are excluded. This implies that typically only 15–45 places of variation saw a change during the step from one preserved witness to the most closely related one that has also survived. Contamination in this context occurs in very small steps, and the steps would be even smaller if all the manuscripts had been preserved. The pattern is as follows: the two or more manuscripts involved in a copying process are among those that are most closely related,23 and even if they are lost,
Problems of a highly contaminated tradition 20
number of manuscripts
18 16
018 020 025 044? 049 033
14 12 10 8
P100? 01 03
6 4
02 04 048 P74
P100?
2 0 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
century
Figure 6. Distribution of manuscripts of the Letter of James in the first millennium
a dense textual tradition may enable us to find very close relatives among the witnesses that have been preserved. It is rather unlikely that the comparatively few manuscripts to survive from the 9th century and before are representative of the totality of the manuscripts of that time; a considerable number must have been lost. Figure 6 shows the manuscripts containing James and written in the first millennium that are not too fragmented.24 Although we do not know how many links are missing between them, we can be sure that a part of the variants found only in the later manuscripts is a reflection of older variants which have not been preserved in the surviving manuscripts of the first millennium. Indeed, for this period we must assume a vast number of missing links. Therefore, the nearest preserved relatives of a witness are not as closely related to it as is the case in later times. As a consequence, agreement values are lower than for the later manuscripts, with values of more than 90% being already quite good. Contamination in this context looks more radical, because of the many missing links. All those very closely related manuscripts which a given scribe might have consulted have disappeared. At first sight, contamination here appears to have had a much greater impact than in the later manuscripts, but it may still be assumed that among the older textual tradition, too, it has followed the normal pattern: the manuscripts of a given copying process must have been among the most closely related ones. But in this case they have all disappeared. We will, however, find a lot of traces in the later manuscripts, and some of them seem to preserve a
Gerd Mink
very old text, only slightly altered in the course of the time. For this reason it is important to make a distinction between manuscripts and their texts. It is impossible to find the genealogical relationship between manuscripts if most of them have not survived. It is merely possible to uncover the genealogical structure of the preserved texts. In this context, therefore, the text is the witness and not the manuscript.25
. A brief outline of the method: Some definitions It may be helpful to present a brief outline of the method I have developed,26 as far as it is relevant for the present subject, for it is quite distinct from the general practice of editors. Nearly all New Testament textual critics accept that the stemma of a tradition contaminated to such a degree as the Letter of James cannot be reconstructed. However, the question of what is the original text for a given passage is widely discussed, independent of what the overall stemma might look like, and every editor has to decide what text he will provide. Willingly or not, he must make genealogical decisions concerning the individual places of variation, as soon as he settles for one of the variants as being the original text at these places. The objective of my method is a comprehensive theory of the structure of the textual tradition, with special regard to the problems of contamination and the coincidental emergence of variants. The result will not necessarily be a stemma in the traditional sense of a graphic representation. I conceive of the stemma here in a more complex sense. It does not only connect witnesses; the data representing the contents of those connections and the data designating the quality of those connections predominantly determine the stemmatic hypothesis. Usually, a stemmatic representation only displays information about the direction of development between two witnesses. Yet, the underlying data are the real substance of a stemma. They are, in a more complex sense, the nucleus of the stemma.27 Graphical representations can show no more than aspects of this complexity. My method has three elements: observations, assessments of what was observed, and structural connections based on these observations and assessments, according to rules based on a model of manuscript tradition. These rules have to be in harmony with a model of the average situation in the history of transmission of a given text. Such a model is necessary in order to have criteria to assess which results are more probable than others. The model de-
Problems of a highly contaminated tradition
pends on what we know about the particular ways of transmission, the habits of the scribes etc. in the respective tradition which we are about to explore. In the case of the New Testament the model is as follows. “Some essential assumptions are considered more probable than their contrary (without excluding that the contrary might happen at some points): (i) a scribe wants to copy a manuscript with fidelity; primarily the scribe does not want to create new readings; (ii) if the scribe introduces other readings,28 they come from another source (normally a manuscript); (iii) if the scribe uses more than one source, few rather than many sources will be used; and (iv) the source copies have closely related texts rather than less related ones.”29 A comprehensive theory results from the total of observations and assessments and allows us to examine the plausibility of each assessment and of each textual decision in the light of an overall view. This is very important for the editors of the text, for there is a circular argument typical of textual criticism: Witnesses are important for reconstructing the initial text, and they are important because of the high number of agreements with the reconstructed initial text. In other words: witnesses are good because of their good variants, variants are good because of their good witnesses. This circle cannot be avoided, but it has to be controlled. We need a method, therefore, which can provide an overall view of the consequences of all the decisions we take, so that also the overall plausibility of what we are doing can be examined.30 In the present method this is done through an iterative process, especially designed to perform this examination. At first, I would like to explain some central concepts of the method, which itself will be outlined subsequently. . Initial text (A) The initial text is a hypothetical, reconstructed text, as it presumably existed, according to the hypothesis, before the beginning of its copying. In a hypothesis, which wants to establish the genealogical relationship between the witnesses, the initial text corresponds to a hypothetical witness A (‘Ausgangstext’). The initial text is not identical with the original, the text of the author. Between the autograph and the initial text considerable changes may have taken place which may not have left a single trace in the surviving textual tradition. Even if this is not the case, differences between the original and the initial text must be taken into account. On the other hand, the initial text is not simply a reconstruction on the basis of the surviving variants, which best explains the emergence of the variants
Gerd Mink
and thus represents the archetype of the tradition. Instead, several hypotheses are possible about the beginnings of the tradition. The simplest working hypothesis must be that there are no differences between the original and the initial text (except for inevitable scribal slips). In that case, the reconstruction of the initial text is not only determined by the subsequent tradition (which text form could have been derived from which?), but also by the author’s intentions as they come to light in the totality of what we know about him (is a variant more likely to come from the pen of the author or from a copyist?).31 Another possible hypothesis might involve an editor in-between the author and the initial text, who might possibly have merged several writings of an author into one. Or there may have been more than one initial text, possibly even going back to more than one autograph if, for example, the author issued several versions of his work. I should also like to point out in this context that the notion of text needs a more exact definition. In textual criticism it is mostly used for what ‘was written down’ in the manuscript, strictly speaking for the sequence of characters the copyist wrote down. On the other hand, the text should convey a meaning. This aim, however, is not directly achieved by the written characters. They represent different things in different languages. A copyist may grasp the sense of a text and copy this sense. Even if he intends to copy the text true to the letter from the exemplar, he may, at the level of the characters, produce variants which emerge from the meaning of the text. But a copyist may also, particularly in long or difficult sentences, copy groups of words, or line by line, while losing the overall meaning of the text. In the case of very difficult words he might even copy character by character, which may lead to readings which hardly make any sense, and even to spectacular errors. Now, the problem is that there is no obvious difference between variants introduced on purpose by copyist, and variants produced accidentally, as long as these variants are meaningful in the widest sense. The text as carrier of meaning is therefore modified by the variants – introduced intentionally or unintentionally by the copyist –, and there is no way of differentiating between intentional and unintentional variants. If, however, a copy contains errors, i.e. readings which clearly do not make sense, these do not necessarily modify the text as a carrier of meaning. The copyist had no intention of changing the text. The copy therefore only contains an erroneous representation of the same text at the level of the characters, which nevertheless sometimes renders it unrecognisable as a carrier of meaning. But not only errors at the level of the characters are possible. After all, any linguistic element can be affected by mistakes of this sort, such as errors of
Problems of a highly contaminated tradition
concord and case, also omissions of key words for the context, which happen accidentally and against a scribe’s intention (lapsus). Even the first exemplar of the entire textual tradition, even the very autograph, may have contained such errors. The text as the actual carrier of meaning, however, would not necessarily be affected by these errors, it would only be represented defectively. Consequently, the ECM records the witnesses of erroneous readings as witnesses for the variants which they represent, albeit defectively. There is even an example where the best witnesses omit a negation (2 Peter 3:10/48-50). Although the preceding passage speaks of the passing away of the heavens, and the dissolution of the elements, and the following verses presuppose the dissolution of heaven and earth (for a new heaven and a new earth are waited for), quite superior witnesses here have the reading ‘the earth and all the works that are therein will be found (εὑρθήσονται)’,32 when logic demands ‘will not be found (οὐχ εὑρεθήσονται)’. The meaning, as a result, is extremely problematic; to my mind the reading does not make sense and must therefore be erroneous.33 Unquestionably, the hyparchetype of all these witnesses did not have the negation. Now, there are two variants (ἀφανισθήσονται ‘they will disappear’,34 and κατακαήσεται ‘they will be burned up’),35 which presuppose and express more graphically a text containing the negation: οὐχ εὑρεθήσονται ‘they will not be found’. Although it is not preserved in any Greek manuscript, it is probable that the initial text had the negation. Even if these variants which indirectly confirm the negation did not exist, the assumption should still be that the initial text contained the negation required by the sense of the text, even though the negation is not in the graphemic representation of the archetype.36 To my mind, this is an almost unavoidable conjecture. . Places of variation Places of variation are places in the text where variants appear. At least two different variants occur in a place of variation; the maximum in James is 24 variants. A place of variation may comprise more than one word, but it can also be the space between words. Ideally, it covers a logical unit of variation. This means that mutually interdependent changes to a text should belong to one unit of variation (e.g. if a subject and correspondingly the predicate are put in the singular). A unit of variation can also be postulated when a group of words presumably belonged together in a copyist’s view (e.g. if a word group consisting of article/particle/noun shows changes in different combinations for the article/noun and for the particle). Sometimes, very pragmatic considera-
Gerd Mink
tions might be adduced to determine a unit of variation, so as to enable the comparison of all texts at a certain place. Places of variation may also overlap. In one place of variation the question may be e.g whether a rather large group of words has been omitted or not; yet another instance of variation may result from variants within that group of words whenever it was not left out. The number of variants offered by the first hand of a witness corresponds to the number of places of variation which have been preserved in the witness. . Variants vs. readings; connective variants “A reading is the generic term for the wording of a textual unit in which a manuscript is distinguished from one or more or from all other manuscripts. A variant refers to one of at least two readings of the same textual unit which is grammatically correct and logically possible. Errors are readings which do not fulfil these criteria .”37 Errors are usually deemed as the variant they represent incorrectly. In some cases, if the corresponding variant is no longer available, the error has to be corrected and incorporated as another variant. It is theoretically possible that new variants originate specifically from an error. In practice, however, at least in the New Testament tradition, this seems to be rare, as the errors are usually corrected into the underlying variants in the further tradition. “Alternative and orthographically possible forms of the same variants are classed as orthographica.”38 Thus in the verb λαμβάνω (‘I take’) the μ, which is really a formative element of the present tense stem, in Koine Greek often gets infixed in other stems. The future form, apart from the actually correct λήψομαι, is frequently λήμψομαι. The two forms are treated as equal and interchangeable. Or the particle ἄν indicating a prospective meaning after relative pronouns and relative adverbs, is replaced by ἐάν in later Greek with the same function and position – a phenomenon caused by the fact that in classical Greek instead of ἐάν (‘if ’) people also wrote ἄν. Any scribe could adapt these things to his usage, without affecting the quality of the copy. Certain morphological divergences are considered equivalent to orthographica. They have it in common with actual orthographica that in the copyist’s view they were also interchangeable, without affecting the quality of a good copy, e.g. if instead of a strong aorist (e.g. ἐγενόμην ‘I became’) he would use a mixed aorist (ἐγενάμην). Often the notion of ‘reading’ is used in a more general way, it is frequently taken to mean ‘variant’. It is very common to speak of an original reading, from which variants were derived in the course of a text’s transmission. Yet,
Problems of a highly contaminated tradition
neutrally speaking, even the reading which is held to be part of the original text, is nothing more than one variant in the textual tradition. For every textual tradition it is necessary to determine – in accordance with language, historical period and literary genre – which readings are to rank as genuine variants. Only variants are the basis of a genealogical relationship of witnesses. If a variant contributes to genealogical coherencies (see paragraph 4.11), it is called a connective variant of the witnesses concerned. Their agreement in this variant is assumed to be not coincidental because (i) they usually have variants in common or (ii) the character of the variant argues against multiple independent emergence (see paragraph 6). . Witness vs. manuscript A manuscript is the physical carrier of the text. A manuscript has properties which can be defined paleographically and codicologically. The text in a manuscript may be considerably older than the manuscript itself. At the very latest the text was produced at the same time as the manuscript. The witness of a variant is the text, not the manuscript.39 A one-witness-attestation is the attestation of a variant found in the text of one manuscript only. A two-witnessattestation is the attestation of a variant found in the text of two manuscripts. Whenever numbers are cited in this study, which are generally used to denote manuscripts, they are used here to designate the texts transmitted in them, not the manuscripts as their physical carriers. The hypothetical witness A represents the hypothetical initial text (see paragraph 4.1). . Attestation Attestation is the total of all the witnesses presenting a certain variant at any one given place of variation. Consequently, the number of variants equals the number of attestations. . Local stemma vs. global stemma A local stemma is a stemma representing the presumed genealogical relationship between variants at one place of variation. It is a key notion in this study. A global stemma is a stemma representing the genealogical relationships between witnesses. It illustrates the overall genealogical hypothesis. A global stemma can only be true if the relationships it shows between the witnesses are compat-
Gerd Mink
ible with the relationships the witnesses have in every single place of variation according to the relationships between their variants, as represented in the local stemmata. It must convey the genealogical coherencies (see paragraph 4.11) of the attestations in any one place of variation correctly. It must reflect all the changes between witnesses and all the non-coincidental correspondences in every place of variation. Meeting these conditions a global stemma is true. A global stemma is the superset of all the optimal substemmata, i.e. it consists of all their nodes (including any intermediary nodes) and edges. It is possible to have more than one global stemma. The number of global stemmata depends on the number of cases in which there are two or more substemmata of equal likelihood, and on the number of alternative substemmata in each case. For any one set of substemmata, containing not more than one substemma per witness, however, only one global stemma is possible.40 . Intermediary nodes Normally, the nodes in a stemmatic graph stand for witnesses, whose genealogically relevant contents are made up of all their variants. Witness x and witness y are immediately connected by an arrow (= a directed edge).41 An intermediary node does not represent a witness, but signifies only a subset of the variants of witness x and/or witness y which are to be connected with each other. It forms part of the connection between witnesses x and y. On the purpose of intermediary nodes, see paragraphs 7 and 8. . Optimal substemma A substemma is part of a global stemma. It links one descendant with its hypothetical ancestor or ancestors (sources of contamination). A substemma is optimal if the smallest possible number of ancestors can explain all variants of the descendant. The ancestors have to exhibit a very high degree of genealogical coherence (see paragraph 4.11) with the descendant, in order to exclude coincidental correspondences. Consequently, they are to be looked for among the potential ancestors (see paragraph 4.10). If at a place of variation a descendant corresponds only to a witness of lesser coherence, the nature of the variant must be used to verify whether the variant in question actually links the two witnesses, or whether the correspondence of variants is only a matter of coincidence. There are, however, two cases in which a connection with a non-ancestor is effected by way of an intermediary node. (i) A connection between a de-
Problems of a highly contaminated tradition
scendant and a non-ancestor may be compulsory if the latter offers the only possible prior variant at some place of variation, although it is not a potential ancestor (for the full issue, see paragraph 7). If this connection were left out, not all the variants of the descendants would be explained correctly, i.e. in accordance with the local stemmata. The substemma would not be optimal. (ii) The agreements between witnesses with a high degree of undirected genealogical coherence (see paragraph 4.11) are not covered by stemmata based on potential ancestry. The connection between such witnesses can be effected by way of intermediary nodes (or undirected edges). Such connections must also be integrated into the optimal substemma (for the conditions of this see paragraph 8). An optimal substemma is true if it is compatible with the genealogical coherencies (see paragraph 4.11) of the attestations in any one place of variation and, therefore, reflects all the changes between the witnesses concerned and all their non-coincidental correspondences. . Prior vs. posterior The local stemmata represent a hypothesis about which variant arose from which. There, each source variant is prior, the one developed from it posterior. In the comparison of pairs of witnesses the proportion of prior variants and posterior variants plays a decisive role. One of the key-questions to be asked is, in how many places does witness x have a prior variant from which the posterior variant of witness y was derived, and in how many places the opposite is true. The result reveals witnesses that are predominantly prior or predominantly posterior. . Potential ancestor Potential ancestors are all those witnesses which show a higher proportion of prior variants than posterior variants in comparison with a given witness. Consequently, this also includes witnesses not represented in a stemma or substemma as ancestors, because they are not needed to explain the variants of a descendant.
Gerd Mink
. Coherence and coherencies; the different types: Pre-genealogical / genealogical (directed and undirected) / stemmatic All surviving witnesses are related to each other and there is coherence within the entire tradition.42 For all the witnesses closest relatives can be found. Between a witness and its closest relatives there is the highest degree of coherence. These closest relatives in turn have their own closest relatives, so that chains of coherencies develop. Thus the particular coherency within each pair of witnesses, within groups and also within the attestations of variants can be evaluated. This way, coherence – represented by coherencies – can be analysed at each place of variation as well as in the entire tradition. Coherencies between witnesses may be qualified as good or poor. Whenever a coherency is mentioned without any qualification, it refers to a useful coherency, i.e. one that is high enough to indicate a closer (genealogical) relation. The absence of coherence consequently means that there is no useful coherency, because it is too poor. The assessment of the quality of the coherency between witness x and witness y depends on the coherencies pertaining to the immediate genealogical environment of witness x and y. The relevant factor in the assessment of the quality of the coherency are the percentage values of the agreements between each of these witnesses and its closest relatives, and not the absolute values, as the number of comparable places of variation changes from pair to pair of the witnesses to be compared. A witness can very effectively be characterised by the percentage of the highest agreement (with its closest relative) and the manner in which the values of agreement (with other relatives) decrease from there. A witness may, for example, have so many individual variants that its text differs very often from the main body of the tradition. In such a case, the rate of agreement with the closest relative may perhaps be only 89%–87%,43 which under these circumstances would still be useful values. A similar situation may occur if the text of a witness was compiled from other texts, which are themselves not very closely interrelated. The case is different if none of the close relatives of a witness have survived (especially so, if a witness is based on the oldest layer of the textual tradition). In such cases one may have to fall back on the range of 92%–89% agreement to discover traces of the lost relatives. If a large number of relatives has agreement rates in the range of 96%–93%, however, a percentage of 89% in another witness is unlikely to yield more usable coherencies, as it is not likely that connective variants will be found there that are not to be found in the large number of closer relatives.44 This holds true unless variants which cannot have developed independently of each other compel one to take lower coherencies into account.
Problems of a highly contaminated tradition
If the assessment of the relationship between witnesses is done only on the basis of their agreements, it is classified as pre-genealogical coherency. This type of coherence is a criterion for determining the probability whether the witnesses allow to take into account a genealogical relationship between variants. Normally, a lack of pre-genealogical coherence within an attestation implies a coincidental multiple development of conform variants. If it is possible to include genealogical data (from the local stemmata) in an assessment of the relationship, it can be referred to as genealogical coherency.45 Here, two points are essential: (i) Based on the number of prior and posterior variants (cf. the local stemmata), the relative positions of the witnesses in the general textual flow (see paragraph 4.12) determine a predominant direction of textual flow between the witnesses (directed coherency – the normal situation). Directed coherencies determine which witnesses are potential ancestors of another witness. (ii) In addition, the rates of correspondence are important in estimating the probability of stemmatic coherencies between pairs of witnesses. Genealogical coherence presupposes pre-genealogical coherence. A special case is the undirected genealogical coherency. It exists between closely related witnesses, which accordingly have a very high pre-genealogical coherency but there is no predominant direction of textual flow. An undirected genealogical coherency is different from a pre-genealogical coherency on account of the fact that in the former case the basis are pre-genealogical and genealogical data. Stemmatic coherence is found in the global stemma and the optimal substemmata. A given stemmatic coherency designates the ultimate stemmatic relationship in an optimal substemma (see paragraph 4.8). Stemmatic coherence presupposes genealogical coherence or at least one connective variant (cf. paragraph 4.3). . Textual flow: General/particular, global/local The genealogical relationships between witnesses are a reflection of the development of the text. There is a textual flow connecting the witnesses. The general textual flow leads from earlier to later textual states. Consequently, each witness can be assigned a relative position compared to any other witness within this general textual flow. A particular textual flow exists between witnesses in the relative positions of potential ancestor and descendant. Here the textual flow is determined by the variants the descendant shares with the ancestor, and by the variants of the ancestor from which new variants in the descendant evolved. They determine the direction of the textual flow. The particular textual flow
Gerd Mink
between ancestors and a descendant becomes part of the global textual flow when ancestors and descendant in a substemma are part of a global stemma. By contrast, local textual flow between ancestors and a descendant, is effected at one place of variation, on the basis of the relationships between their variants in the local stemma and the relationship of the witnesses according to the particular or, if possible, global textual flow between them. Every local textual flow must be reflected in the global textual flow, and vice versa. The local textual flow within the attestation of a variant or for an entire place of variation may be represented in textual flow diagrams. These may be based on genealogical or stemmatic coherencies.
. Procedures It is of central importance to pay attention to coherencies and to the textual flows which rest upon them. The following insight is fundamental for the coherence-based genealogical method: In a textual tradition where all the copies have survived and where the source, or (in case of contamination) the sources, are also known, as well as the origin of every reading in every copy, the genealogical interrelationships between all the variants at any place of variation must appear in a global stemma of the witnesses as genealogical relationship between coherent fields of relationships between witnesses. Conversely, the relationship between each descendant and its ancestor, or (in case of contamination) at least a subset of relationships between it and its ancestors, should appear at any place of variation, namely as the relationship between witnesses sharing the same variant there, or as the relationship between witnesses between which a change of the variant took place which supports the ancestor-descendant relationship. Since every descendant may be an ancestor in relationship to other witnesses, chains of coherencies are formed within attestations. These chains help to find out about unique or multiple emergence of variants. Chains of coherencies connect attestations of different variants where a change of text took place between witnesses.46
Consequently, the places of variation are the points of departure for discovering, by way of the relationships between variants, something about the relationships between witnesses.47 The procedures on which my genealogical studies are based are briefly summarised below.48
Problems of a highly contaminated tradition James 3:12/22-30 a
b
?
c
o
j
h1
d
e
h2
f
g
i
k
l
m
Figure 7. A local stemma of variants
. Construction of local stemmata Local stemmata of variants must be created, including, where possible, the variant that is assumed to be the initial text. This procedure makes use of all the methods and knowledge provided by textual criticism. Two examples have been set out in the introduction. If it is not possible to establish a local stemma, the place of variation does not qualify for further evaluation until a solution has been found. It is not necessary to enter all the variants into the local stemma at all costs. Further evaluation requires clear statements. Either a variant is designated as genealogically dependent on another variant (or on several, if they explain the variant together, e.g. by merging), or the origin of a variant is designated as uncertain. In the latter case the variant is not taken into consideration for further evaluation, unless it should be possible to make a clear statement about it later. All cases in which no definitive statement is possible must remain neutral in the further evaluation. Figure 7 shows the possibilities within a local stemma; the letters represent the variants. h1 and h2 indicate that the coherency of the attestation of variant h is imperfect (see below and paragraph 5.3) and therefore the variant is assumed to have emerged twice, d is considered a mixture of a and h1, and the question mark indicates the questionable source of a variant. Variant n does not appear in the stemma, as its only witness is a lectionary. The underlying type of variant is ABC / DEF / G / H / I / J / KLM / NOP / QR / S / T / UV / W / X. The corresponding absolute numbers of the witnesses are (variant letters in brackets): 7 (a), 8 (b), 1 (c), 1 (d), 1 (e), 1 (f ), 119 (g), 5 (h), 2 (i), 1 (j), 1 (k),
Gerd Mink
Figure 8. Database section with genealogical indications
2 (l), 1 (m), 1 (o) out of the 164 witnesses included. 13 witnesses could not be used because the relevant text is missing from them or uncertain. When local stemmata are constructed – and this is very important – pregenealogical coherencies of witnesses within an attestation or between attestations must be verified. Pre-genealogical coherencies are based only on the agreement of the witnesses and do not provide genealogical information. If not all the witnesses cohere like a chain or a net, the hypothesis is that the variant has evolved independently more than once (cf. variants h1 and h2 in Figure 7). If witnesses in the attestation of a variant do not cohere with witnesses in the attestation of another variant, a genealogical relationship between the respective variants is improbable. . Analysis of textual flow The genealogical links between variants become an integral part of the data sets which contain all genealogical information pertaining to each variant, see Figure 8. Figure 8 is a screenshot of a database section; the first seven fields are address fields; the labez field contains the letter addresses of variants and is up-
Problems of a highly contaminated tradition
dated in labneu for genealogical reasons (for instance two variants are treated as one or one as two);49 the fields Q1, Q2, Q3 contain the letter addresses of the source variant(s) of the variant in the Labneu field; the fields Vq1, Vq1a, etc., Vq2, Vq2a, etc. contain the letter addresses of the variants that are regarded as source variants of the variant in the fields Q1, Q2 etc. Consequently, the witnesses do not only concern variants, but variants which are genealogically linked to other variants and their attestations. These direct links between witnesses give a first idea of the general textual flow throughout the tradition by providing some basic information on the genealogical relationship between witnesses. Above all, we can see which witnesses may be potential ancestors of a given witness, and the particular textual flows connecting them. The general textual flow corresponds to the development of the text (i.e. the variants) throughout its history. This development can be demonstrated at every passage of the text in local stemmata of variants. There are different aspects of this textual flow: a general genealogical one and stemma-orientated aspects, cf. paragraph 4.12. The general genealogical aspect concerns two questions: What may the position of a witness in the general development be, and which role does it play in the general textual flow? The position of a witness within the general textual flow, compared with the position of another witness, can be determined by the ratio of two values. The first value (cf. for instance the xausy fields in Figures 21, 23, 35) is the number of variants that are posterior to those of the witness compared, the second one (the yausx fields) is the number of variants that are prior. These values also determine whether a witness is a potential ancestor of another (cf. paragraph 4.10). The stemma-orientated aspects concern the particular textual flow and the global textual flow between witnesses within a stemma or substemma. If there is a genealogical hypothesis on the relation between two witnesses, it is based on the agreements and the direction of the textual flow between these witnesses.50 A witness is a potential ancestor of another one if the textual flow runs predominantly from that witness to the other one. The potential ancestors are classified according to their degrees of agreement. In Figures 9, 21, 23 and 35, we find a witness under the heading of Zeuge1 the potential ancestors of which are to be determined. These can be found under the heading Zeuge2 if the arrow in the Richtg field is pointing to the left.51 The more a potential ancestor agrees with its potential descendant (cf. the Proz1 field),52 the more probable is a direct genealogical relationship (= stemmatic coherency) in the global stemma.53 A direct relation is a relation in which no potential ancestor has been preserved
Gerd Mink
Figure 9. List of potential ancestors of 1243 and beginning of list of potential ancestors of 2412
as an intermediary witness. Lists like those in Figures 9, 21, 23 and 35 allow for an assessment of the probability whether a potential ancestor will become an ancestor in a stemma or substemma and whether global textual flow will arise in consequence. . Analysis of genealogical coherencies at places of variation Now an analysis of the genealogical coherencies within one attestation and between attestations is possible. If close genealogical coherencies connect the totality of the witnesses without any break the supposed coherency of an attestation is perfect. The hypothesis is: the variant has evolved only once. An example of this is to be seen in Figure 10. The local stemma of variants outlines the hypothesis that b derives from a. In order to verify the genealogical coherencies within one attestation, the potential ancestors of every witness in the attestation have to be determined. Every witness is thus assumed to be a descendant. If witnesses are found which offer the same variant among the potential ancestors which possess a sufficient degree of agreements, the ancestor with the highest degree of agreement is chosen because it makes a direct genealogical relationship more probable. Whether a degree of agreement is high enough is to be read from the way the values decrease (cf. paragraph 4.11).54 In Figure 9 on the left, for example, values of > 89,5% have to be considered as sufficiently high, as 1243 offers a relatively old text form (which follows from the range of witnesses in the Zeuge2
Problems of a highly contaminated tradition
a
stemma:
perfect coherency
b variant a
witnesses
1
2
3
4
variant b
witnesses
5
6
7
8
Figure 10. Example of perfect coherence
field) and, therefore, many more closely related potential ancestors have been lost. In Figure 9 on the right, even a value of e.g. 92,5% is inadequate, as quite a number of closer related witnesses has been preserved, which (not visible here) are not very similar to each other, so that among these witnesses all the variants which may indicate a genealogical coherency are likely to be found.55 The object of the process is to arrive at evaluations of the local stemmata of variants through evaluation of the genealogical coherencies. The quality of genealogical coherencies actually allows for rather accurate predictions about the probability that the genealogical coherencies will result in stemmatic coherencies (cf. paragraphs 4.11 and 5.5). When genealogical data yield undirected genealogical coherencies of witnesses (cf. Figure 9, 21, 23, and 35, where the Richtg field is empty), these coherencies will also lead to coherencies in the attestations if they are sufficiently high (cf. paragraph 8). If the procedure has been completed for all the witnesses of the variant and the result is a chain or net of genealogical coherencies ranging over the whole attestation, the coherency of the attestation is perfect. The witnesses are all genealogically interrelated. The variant did not emerge repeatedly by chance. In Figure 10 the arrows for variant b in each case point from the potential ancestors towards the descendants. For witness 5 no potential ancestor was found in the attestation of variant b. All the other witnesses are only eligible as descendants there. Witness 5 should therefore be the oldest text to display this variant. Its potential ancestor must be identified in a different attestation. In the example it should be witness 3 for variant a. This should be the genealogical coherency between variants a and b. If there is no potential ancestor for witness 5 with variant a, but for example with a variant c, this local stemma of variants must be false. (The other witnesses for a have not been assigned ar-
Gerd Mink
imperfect coherency
stemma:
a c
b1 b2 variant a
witnesses
1
2
3
4
variant b
witnesses
5
6
7
8
variant a
witnesses
9
10
11
12
Figure 11. Example of imperfect coherence
rows, as the example only concerns the perfect coherency in variant b and the connection with variant a). The coherency is imperfect if not all the witnesses of the attestation can be connected by close genealogical coherencies. The hypothesis is: the variant has emerged repeatedly. Logically, we have two or more variants with coincidentally the same text. In Figure 11 the examination of the genealogical coherencies by the method described resulted into two groups in the attestation of variant b. Witnesses 5 and 6 have a coherency, and so have 7 and 8. There is, however, no further genealogical coherency for witness 5 in the attestation of b. The same is true for witness 7. The coherency of the witnesses of variant b is imperfect. Witness 5, for example, has its closest potential ancestor with variant a, witness 7 with variant c. Variant b, consequently, emerged twice. It is therefore split into b1 and b2.56 Another case of imperfect coherency, different from the one in Figure 11, is not crucial for the first analysis. In Figure 12 the direct ancestors of witnesses 5 and 7 are both to be found with variant a. Here the local stemma of variants would be the one of Figure 10. With the aid of data as found in the examples in Figure 9 the genealogical coherencies of the attestations of variants can now be drawn up and assessed in textual flow diagrams. The directed genealogical coherencies will form the basis, as they are the only ones giving direction to the textual flow. If they are not of sufficient quality, undirected genealogical coherencies must be used but as a surrogate only, or fictitiously imperfect coherencies may materialise.
Problems of a highly contaminated tradition
imperfect coherency
a
stemma:
b variant a
witnesses
1
2
3
4
variant b
witnesses
5
6
7
8
Figure 12. Example of imperfect coherence
Lists such as the ones in Figure 9 are used to find the potential ancestors (Zeuge2 field, if the arrow under Richtg points to the left) of the descendants (Zeuge1 field), and the degrees of agreement (the percentage values under Proz1),57 which make it possible to judge whether there is sufficient genealogical coherence.58 A textual flow diagram now establishes the connections between witnesses and their most closely related potential ancestors within the attestation, by means of directed edges (e.g. Figure 13). It is also possible to show by which coherencies the attestations of different variants are connected (e.g. in Figures 14, 15). In Figure 13 such a textual flow diagram is presented. It shows an example of perfect genealogical coherence within an attestation.59 The variant concerned qualified as lectio difficilior. The argument ‘lectio difficilior’ is generally used if the variant is regarded as so difficult that a copyist could not have invented, but only simplified it. If a variant is qualified as lectio difficilior, it is rather uncredible that it could have emerged more than once. In the case of 1 Peter 1:6/18 there are essentially two variants, a and b, which may present the original text. Three further variants derive from them. Variant a shows a participle (λυπηθέντας) in the accusative. The participle correlates to a remote accusative (ὑμας) in 1 Peter 1:4/24, although only slightly earlier, in 1 Peter 1:6/6, the persons involved are the subject. Variant b relates the participle to this subject and correctly puts it in the nominative (λυπηθέντες). Without any doubt, variant a constitutes the lectio difficilior, and the change to b is natural and obvious. So far, variant b has been considered as the original variant, as variant a was not believed to be correct because of its attestation. Figure 13 shows the attestation of variant a. As the data necessary for the assignment of genealogical coherencies for 1 Peter are not yet completely available, and were largely lacking at the time when the text was established, it was
Gerd Mink A
genealogical coherency of the attestation of 1 Peter 1:6/18 variant a (accorging to the genealogical results in James)
01 1175 1243
2492
17352
1852
2344
1448
429
307
206 522 1292 1490 2200 1799
614
1831
453
630
720
918
1678 24644 2818
6234 2805
94
2412 4243
01422 0204 63 69 884 3264 3983 4422 467 629 642 9154 9965 15244 21476 25444 1047 18422 1838 621
61
1848 218 808
1661 254
25412 1359 1127 436 1067 1409 1718 1563 2374
Figure 13. Local textual flow through the attestation of a variant
referred to the genealogical data from James, which were related to the pregenealogical data already known for 1 Peter,60 as they are based exclusively on the agreements. The examples in Figures 13, 14 and 15 make it very clear that thereby a good prediction for the genealogical coherencies was also possible for 1 Peter. For each witness in Figure 13 the most closely related potential ancestor within the attestation was looked for. A, the hypothetical initial text, for exam-
Problems of a highly contaminated tradition
ple, is the closest potential ancestor of quite a number of witnesses (01, 1175, etc.). In principle, it is therefore possible to consider this variant for the original reading. There are also coherent chains (e.g. A – 1852 – 1448 – 429 – 206 – 1799) ranging over the complete attestation. If no superscript is given after the number of the witness, it means that the potential ancestor is the one with the highest degree of agreement altogether (not only within the attestation), and therefore has a very high probability of being ancestor in a global stemma (level 1). This is the case for the vast majority. The superscript numbers indicate lower levels. Of these, levels of 2 to 5 may – generally – still be considered as good, depending on the proximity of the levels. The minimum here, a level of 7 for witness 104, is still acceptable, since quite a number of potential ancestors with almost the same level exists for this witness. It is striking that the superscript numbers predominantly appear with witness 424 and the series below it (0142, 020, etc.), thereby reflecting an area of especially vigorous contamination surrounding the development of the uniform Byzantine text. The main body of the Byzantine witnesses have variant b. For the witnesses followed by a superscript number in Figure 13 the altogether closest potential ancestor is to be found in the b attestation. Most of them are characterised by the fact that their more closely related potential ancestors differ considerably from one another (which is otherwise atypical). The verification of the genealogical coherencies does not actually prove that variant a is original, as the corresponding test for variant b would result into a comparable picture. But the genealogical coherencies in Figure 13 demonstrate, first of all, that derivation of a from A, and therefore its originality, is possible, and, secondly, that no multiple coincidental emergence must be assumed. A further example may demonstrate the advantage of observing the textual flow and coherencies in a contaminated textual tradition (Figures 14, 15).61 There are two main competing variants in 1 Peter 4:16/24-28: a (τῳ μέρει τούτῳ),62 and b (τῳ ὀνόματι τούτῳ),63 cf. Figure 14. So far, variant b has always been favoured and seen as the original because of its attestation in witnesses counting as outstanding: 03, 01, 02, 1739. Variant a, in contrast, is essentially attested by Byzantine witnesses, which have generally been judged to be of inferior value. In addition, there are a few more witnesses (025, 1448, 1735, 2298), which are, however, less highly regarded than some of the most important witnesses for variant b. Yet variant b, which had been considered original in view of its attestation, can hardly have served as the source for a. The meaning of variant a is not immediately clear and a represents a far more difficult reading. Yet variant b does not irritate and its phrasing agrees perfectly with a neighbouring
Gerd Mink 1 Peter 4:16/24-28
variant a
A
variant b 03
025
012 11752 17392
14482
17352
18522 180 453 468 720 918 1678 2186 2818
12432 945 1241 16114 813 2492
307
429
206 522 12922 1490 2200
424
1505
22982
Byz
642 ?
044 02 2344 ? 57 33 623 2464 2805
6142
2138
5 69 88 323 442 915 1832 2718
218
2412 1890 1359
25412
623 2464
1563 1718 2374 436 1067 1409
621 1359 8762 2541
2805
Figure 14. Multiple genesis of variant b
passage (1 Peter 4:14/6-10).64 There are no grounds, however, for changing b into a. It appears more reasonable to assume that b has developed from a. But is this possible considering the attestations? The genealogical coherence for variant a has proved to be very good, and a diagram very much like the one in Figure 13 can be drawn up (symbolised by the rectangular frame on the upper right in Figure 14; Byz = Byzantine witnesses),65 for variant b the genealogical coherence is definitely imperfect. Part of the witnesses for b show unmistakable genealogical coherencies with several witnesses for a (cf. the witnesses on the lower right, connected to the frame).66 This means that the witnesses immediately below the frame read variant a, but none of their most closely related potential ancestors does. In Figure 14, next to the large group on the left, which derives from A through 03 and presents perfect coherence within itself, a large series of witnesses (to the right, under the frame) happen to read the same variant b. If variant b is original, variant a must have been derived from b, and in the third instance several times variants must have been derived from a which happened to have the same phrasing as b. This is quite conceivable, because b, as indicated, presents an obvious reading in the context.
Problems of a highly contaminated tradition A
1 Peter 4:16/24-28 variant b 025
307
14482
17352
180 453 468 720 918 1678 2186 2818 424
22982 429
206 522 12922 1490 2200
A variant a
variant b
025 14485 22982 3073
429
180 453 468 720 918 1678 2186 2818
206 522 12922 1490 2200
17354 424
Figure 15. Differing textual flows with changing initial text hypothesis
This offers an alternative, as shown in Figure 15. Following the coherence examination both alternatives are possible. Figure 15 shows the differences which appear in the textual flow diagram, depending on whether variant a (top) or b (bottom) is seen as initial text. This naturally results in a change of position of A. In addition, there are insignificant changes within the attestation of variant a. The top diagram shows a number of witnesses deriving the original variant directly from A. If the variant is no longer original, as in the bottom diagram, the textual flow has to explain the association of the witnesses in bold print by way of another witness, as A is no longer available. In this case it can easily be done through 025, although that changes the position of 1735 considerably.
Gerd Mink
That such diverging textual flow diagrams are at all possible is due to the degree of contamination, since it requires more than one ancestor in a substemma. To establish such a textual flow diagram the witnesses have to be presented according to the highest levels of probability that one is ancestor to the other (cf. the witnesses without superscripts). Only very rarely is the second to fifth highest level of probability needed (cf. the superscript numbers following some witnesses). . Process of approximation After as many local stemmata of variants as possible have been drawn up for the places of variation, the entire genealogical data and the analysis of genealogical coherencies contribute to revising the local stemmata and the cases unsolved so far. Then new genealogical data can be produced, which may result in further revisions, until a sufficiently stable overall genealogical hypothesis has been achieved. This repetitive procedure is necessary, because the knowledge that will only be the final result of the entire process would be required for the assessment of the genealogical relationships between the variants. An overall hypothesis can therefore only be acquired through approximation and iterative revision of all the intermediate results. I am referring to the circular reasoning which cannot entirely be avoided in textual criticism, but has to be controlled (cf. paragraph 4). Before an overall hypothesis can be achieved, the following point is very helpful. . Construction of graphs based on predominant textual flows Since we have now a selection of potential ancestors and the necessary information to assess the probability that they are ancestors in a global stemma, some hypotheses concerning the textual flow through the witnesses can be proposed. The predominant textual flow (first level of probability,67 Figure 16),68 the textual flow with the highest probability and the textual flow which is second in probability are shown in the top area of the tree (Figure 17).69 In Figures 16 and 17 ‘A’ is the artificial witness of the initial text containing all the readings that are assumed to be initial readings in the local stemmata of variants. The introduction of A is the logical consequence of making textual decisions.70 In the second line of Figure 16 (P74-1852) the witnesses which have the hypothetical initial text as closest potential ancestor appear. Comparing the diagram with usually established stemmata the derivation of such a large number of witnesses may come as a surprise. But the result is based on two arguments.
01 81
307
1840
38
1448
1611
206 522 1490 2200
429
1852
1505
1595
2805 1270 1598 1893
436 1067 1409
2541 1838 621 1751
2243
378 2147
61 1837 1661 876 1832 2494 2652 1563 1718 2374 2412
400 322 1390 104 1842 643 2544 88 321 326 607 996 1251 1367 1765 2674 1359 1127 614 1890
623 2464 1297
5
Figure 16. Predominant textual flow through witnesses of James
330 365 2718
43 1850
2718S
1739
0246 945 1241 2298
1243
93 181 252 319 323 431 442 456 459 676 915 999 1501 2423 2523 218 808 1799 1831 630 1292 2138 2495
018 056 69 312 467 617 629 631 642 1509 1729 2774
197 424
2492
1175
398
94
1827 2180 2242 35 1524 2080 049 665 1845 1874 18751609
254
025
33
18
04
180 453 468 720 918 1678 2186 2197 2818
03
P20
02 044 1735 2344
P100
1066 0142 1853 1848 020 6
048
P74
A
Problems of a highly contaminated tradition
Gerd Mink The two most probable ancestors
A 03 P100
048
01
1175
1852
025 81 02 P74
1448 1243
1735
307 04
468 1739
2344
2298
33 945
most probable second most probable
1241
Figure 17. Predominant textual flows through the top of the tree of Figure 16
Firstly, derivation of a predominant textual flow from hyparchetypes is incompatible with the principle of simplicity, which forbids unnecessary assumptions. The problems that conventionally require the usage of hyparchetypes are solved by a different method, that derives the textual flow from several ancestors in accordance with the contamination (cf. Figures 28, 36, 40). Secondly, the large number of witnesses deriving directly from A is a reflection of the fact that from the first millennium of the textual tradition only a very small percentage of witnesses has been preserved. For, in this case, the direct predominant textual flow means nothing else but that of the many witnesses which stood between A and those of the second line not a single one has survived. In the second line many witnesses of undisputed importance appear: 03 (the best witness), 01, 04, 1739, and the papyri. But also witnesses which so far have been rated less important, like 025, appear, or even an almost disregarded witness like 307. In contrast, an illustrious witness like 02 is missing; it appears in the third line, deriving from 81. Traditionally, this relationship has been assumed to be the other way round, presumably because the text of 02 is preserved in an old manuscript (5th century) and that of 81 in a much later one (11th century). But in James, 81 has a predominantly older textual state than 02. However, what is not visible in this case, is that 02 nonetheless has readings
Problems of a highly contaminated tradition
deriving from A in 28 instances, which do not occur in 81 and therefore cannot derive from 81 (this is reflected in Figure 17, edge from A to 02). As the witnesses in the second line have A as the potential ancestor with the highest degree of agreement, they are of eminent importance for the reconstruction of the textual tradition.71 The diagram (Figure 16) demonstrates impressively that there is a continuous flow through 307, 468, 424, and 617 from the old text into the extensive Byzantine tradition. The right hand branch of the diagram shows how the way leads to the witnesses of another well-know text form (HK) through 1852 and 1448. Incidentally, it is striking that nodes with many edges emanating from them often display numbers belonging to commentary manuscripts (307 in the second line, 424 in line four, 617 in line five). Commentary manuscripts contain, apart from the commentaries, the continuous New Testament text. It is unlikely that these commentary manuscripts served as exemplars for manuscripts containing the continuous text. But it is very plausible that that text form was chosen as the basis for a commentary which was the most highly esteemed at that particular time and place. Accordingly, it would also have been used as an exemplar in the scriptoria. Figures 16 and 17 are not part of a global stemma, they give an overview of textual flows which in the case of Figure 16 should be found, with a very high level of probability, in a global stemma as well. It is possible that in Figure 17, the second most probable textual flow might not explain more variants of a descendant than the most probable one, and therefore becomes superfluous in the global stemma. But this is not very probable, and so a good overview of the position of the witness in the textual history has been achieved. Figure 17 should be compared with the actual results in the optimal substemmata in Figures 28, 36, and 40.
. Typical problems of contamination Figure 17 already points to some of the problems to be expected in a contaminated textual tradition. Very often we find relationships like the following (cf. Figure 18): D originates from C and from B, from which C originates. Probably, the differences between B, C, and D are not very big. Usually the members of a substemma have a high degree of agreement. This is a reflection of the circumstance that in a region with a dense tradition there exists a stable idea about which manuscripts are worth copying.
Gerd Mink B
C D
Figure 18. Model of a simple contamination B
C
D
E
Figure 19. Model of a two-stage contamination if C altered variants of B and if D merged B and C and if D altered variants of B and if E merged D and B and if E altered C-variants included in D according to B
B
C
D
then C may not be potential ancestor of E E may be potential ancestor of C E
Figure 20. Circle possible in a case of multi-stage contamination
The problems arise when there is a chain of relationships like the one shown in Figure 19. In this case it is clear that B and D are potential ancestors of E. But it is also possible that C is not a potential ancestor of E according to the definition of potential ancestry.72 If C altered some variants of B, and if D merged B and C while altering some variants of B, and if E merged D and B, altering the special C variants included in D in accordance with the corresponding B variants, then C is not
Problems of a highly contaminated tradition
a potential ancestor of D, and even a circular relationship becomes probable: E looks like a potential ancestor of C. The condition for this is that E, while it merges D and B, retains enough posterior variants compared to D. This problem will be dealt with in more detail below (cf. paragraph 9). The example demonstrates that edges in a stemma may be misleading if we do not pay attention to the variants whose transmissions and developments are represented by them. A situation like that in Figure 20 is possible, because usually a number of the variants of the ancestor in a contaminated tradition are posterior to the corresponding variants of the descendant, and a number of the variants of the descendant are prior to those of the ancestor. (Figure 23 shows the potential ancestors of witness 1243 in the Zeuge2 field. In the yausx field the number of cases in which 1243 has a prior variant compared with the potential ancestors is listed. In the xausy field we find the number of the posterior variants.) Even if all the substemmata (containing a descendant and its ancestors) are true (as is the case in Figure 19, see below for the meaning of ‘true’), the global stemma may become false if indirect connections are interpreted. A graphic representation like Figure 19 can be read as a group of substemmata. The directed edges indicate only the predominant direction of the textual flow between two witnesses and what textual flow is necessary for the explanation of the textual state of a descendant. A stemma which does not give information on details of the textual flow (i.e. which variants it contains) cannot be used to determine the relation between nodes which are indirectly connected. The data underlying and qualifying a specific stemmatic connection must therefore be available for verification and assessment. It is also evident that the edges in the substemmata are of particular importance as carriers of information. A substemma representing a contaminated tradition must relate a descendant to an optimal combination of ancestors. A combination is optimal if it explains the totality of the variants of the descendant and, if this condition is met, is as small as possible. The requirement is that the substemma is true for every passage of text. In the case of Figure 19 each variant of D agrees with B or agrees with C or has developed from the corresponding variant in B or from the corresponding variant in C. At least one of these possibilities must apply to every passage. The following example shows an optimal substemma, in which the connection is true. It is simple and does not contain contamination. It concerns the best witness we have for the Catholic Letters, 03 (the manuscript is datable to the 4th century). In Figure 21 the witnesses compared are in the Zeuge1 and Zeuge2 fields. Further information is to be found
Gerd Mink
Zeuge1 and Zeuge2 – the witnesses being compared; Richtg – the predominant direction of the textual flow; Proz1 – agreement in percentages; Kon – agreement in absolute numbers; Proz2 – precentage of cases in which Zeuge1 has a variant which represents a further development of a variant of Zeuge2; Xausy – the same in absolute numbers; Proz3 – percentage of cases in which Zeuge2 has a variant which represents a further development of a variant of Zeuge1; Yausx – the same in absolute numbers; Proz4 – percentage of cases in which the source of a variant in Zeuge1 is doubtful; Qfragl – the same in absolute numbers; Kv – cases in which there is no direct connection between the variants of Zeuge1 and Zeuge2.
Figure 21. Potential ancestors of witness 03 A 03
Figure 22. Optimal substemma of witness 03
in the other fields. There are three potential ancestors: A, the initial text, which is hypothetical, and fragments 0166 and 0173. They are potential ancestors, because compared to 03 more variants of these manuscripts are prior than posterior. Thus, the textual flow predominantly runs towards 03. The textual flow between fragment P23 and 03 has no direction. The resulting substemma is simple (Figure 22): A is the ancestor of 03, because in all cases where A and 03 disagree, the variants in 03 were created on the basis of the corresponding readings of A without agreeing with the variants of 0166, 0173, or P23. These witnesses do, indeed, contain prior variants compared with 03 (cf. the xausy field in Figure 21), but in each case they are identical with the A variants. Therefore, these witnesses are not needed in a substemma which explains all the variants of 03. (This conclusion cannot be drawn from the values in the list; we have to know the variants at the places of variation concerned.) It is possible that the text of 03 is also contaminated, although no further source of contamination has been preserved.73 The substemma in Figure 22, like all substemmata, is based on all the places where the local stemmata offer a hypothesis about the relationship between the variants of the descendant and the other variants. Places which remain unsolved or where the descendant has uncertain relations with other variants are therefore not included. For 03 this is the case in one place (cf. Qfragl in Figure
Problems of a highly contaminated tradition
Figure 23. Potential ancestors of witness 1243. See Figure 21 for field legends 1243: 756 places of variation potential ancesstors: A
1175
025
03
1739
01
686 92,6%
694 92,0%
648 91,5%
670 90,2%
677 89,6%
648 87,1%
SUM
X X X X X
X X X X X
X X X X
X X
X
722 732 732 734 736
X
X X
X X
X
X X
734 735
X
Figure 24. Combinations of potential ancestors of witness 1243
21). I will return to this when I discuss the problem of prior variants found only in non-ancestors (cf. paragraph 7). Another example concerning the top area of the global stemma demonstrates contamination. We see 1243 (Figure 23; the manuscript is dated to the 11th century) and its potential ancestors from A to P100. The first three witnesses are fragments and the textual flow between 1243 and each of them has no direction. Their agreements with 1243 are included in the agreements of the other witnesses. Figure 24 shows potential ancestors of 1243, arranged in order of the degree of agreement (not the absolute number of the agreements); in the next lines the numbers and percentages of agreeing variants are presented, and in the right hand column the total number of variants explained by the agreements with at least one witness within some combinations (marked with crosses) can be seen.
Gerd Mink
1243 has 756 places of variation (i.e. 756 variants; 761 is the maximum possible in James). A is the most closely related witness in this group, agreeing at 686 places. The percentage refers to the totality of places of variation extant in 1243 and in the witness compared. The agreements with A or 1175 explain 722 variants in 1243. If we combine A, 1175, and 025, we can explain 732 variants, but adding 03 does not result in a greater number.74 This method allows to test each contribution of potential ancestors to the explanation of the variants of 1243. The top values are shown in Figure 24. The number of 736 variants is not exceeded. Normally, variants not explained by agreements with an ancestor must be secondary, altering a variant of at least one of the ancestors.75 Most of the variants of 1243 are explained by the combination A–1175– 025–1739–01 (Figure 24, marked line). But are 5 ancestors really necessary? The overall agreement of 01 (87,1%) is rather poor. We have to ask, therefore, whether agreements may be coincidental. I summarise the principles of the procedure. A substemma links a descendant with its hypothetical ancestors, which are to be found among the potential ancestors. The substemma, as defined, is optimal if it can explain the textual state of the descendant from as few ancestors as possible. These ancestors will be very similar to the descendant and, consequently, its variants must derive from the agreements with the ancestors in as many places as possible. This is in accordance with the basic model (cf. paragraph 4). Their relationship with the descendant must therefore be based on the highest possible values of agreement. Lower values raise the question whether the agreements are coincidental. What values are to be regarded as high or low depends on the rate at which the percentage agreement values (Proz1 field) in lists like the one in Figure 23 decrease.76 In cases of doubt the decision whether a variant leads to a stemmatic connection between two witnesses has to rest on the character of the variant. A fundamental remark is necessary at this point. The entire procedure is based on all the genuine variants, excluding errors and orthographica. There is no selection of variants assumed to be more important than others. In most cases a scribe copied a manuscript probably using not more than one source copy, and he fulfilled his task very well. In the view of the scribe there existed no variant. He transmitted important and unimportant passages without making any difference. A decision between two variants was only possible if the scribe knew another variant. It is a feature of closely related witnesses that they have important as well as unimportant variants in common. Whether a variant is connective (and not accidental) depends on the degree of agreement of two witnesses or on the character of the variant. If two closely related witnesses agree on an unimportant variant, the variant is connective. The coherence within
Problems of a highly contaminated tradition
an attestation is the most important hint in this respect. We cannot, therefore, decide at the very beginning which variants are connective. If two witnesses not closely related agree, the variant is normally not connective. If these witnesses agree on a significant variant, which is unlikely to have emerged more than once without genealogical dependence, the variant is connective. Such a variant is not possible without contamination. As a witness with relatively few agreements cannot explain enough variants of a descendant, it can only be one of several ancestors. All the variants of a descendant which are explained by a new member of a combination of ancestors have to be examined, especially if no high degree of agreement speaks for genealogical relationship. Is it necessary to assume that the witness is an additional ancestor? If we do assume a combination of ancestors, we must analyse the special role of each ancestor and figure out what the consequences are if we exclude it from the combination. In order to make an optimal decision, the database with all the variants of a witness must be used. The database (Figure 25) containing all the variants of 1243 and its potential ancestors and showing the genealogical relations of the variants is the starting point for establishing the optimal substemma. The database allows to observe what variants of a potential ancestor are suitable for explaining the variants of the descendant. In this way the examination of their wording also becomes possible. The resulting substemma (Figure 26) only gives the information that one of the following possibilities is true: whatever passage we check, (a) at least one of these 4 ancestors agrees with 1243 – this is true for 734 places of variation – or (b) if none agrees, at least one has a prior variant explaining a posterior variant in the descendant – this is true for the remaining 22 places of variation. We cannot, however, see the importance of each ancestor. To each edge some values can be attached (Figure 27 and 28). Of these values, those which exclusively pertain to the agreements have a direct influence on the composition of the substemma. The others indicate the respective qualities of the stemmatic connections and make it possible to assess how sensitive the connections are to changes in the local stemmata of variants. Such changes affect the ratio of prior and posterior variants which is critical to potential ancestry. The stability of the textual flow from ancestor towards descendants must be > 0. In the case of very low values a change may cause the value to become < 0 and the direction of the textual flow to reverse. The witness which was an ancestor may become a descendant. Figure 28 shows a substemma and values qualifying the edges. The values of agreement (cf. strength1 in Figure 27) and priority (included in strength2
Gerd Mink
Anfadr, Endadr – beginning and end of the place of variation; Hsnr – basic witness of the comparison; Labneu – code of its variant; Rg – relation between the variant of the basic witness and the variant of the following ancestor; = – agreeing variants; < – variant of the basic witness posterior; > – variant of the ancestor posterior; ? – relation questionable; - – no relation possible; Mrg – mediate relation; A, Ms1175, Ms025, etc. – names of potential ancestors.
Figure 25. Database section containing the genealogical relationships of the variants of potential ancestors of 1243 with the variants of 1243 A
1175
025 1739
1243
Figure 26. Optimal substemma of witness 1243
in Figure 27) demonstrate the strength of the textual flow. It depends on the character of the witnesses and their place in the textual tradition if values of agreement are considered to be high (cf. paragraphs 3 and 4.11). The priority value need not be high. Very high values argue against close relationships, as they lower the number of agreements. The stability value gives an idea of the reliability of the ancestor-descendant relationship.
Problems of a highly contaminated tradition
The textual flow from a potential ancestor to a descendant strength 1 = a ×c100 (a + p) × 100 strength 2 = c (p – s) × 100 stability = c a: number of agreements c: number of passages where comparison is possible p: number of prior variants of the potential ancestor s: number of posterior variants of the potential ancestor
Figure 27. Properties of textual flow
agreements, absolute: – (%): priority variants (%): stability of the textual flow: additional contribution: maximal contribution: minimal contribution:
686 92,6 7,29 7,29 5 740 2
694 92,0 3,85 0,13 8 723 1
648 677 91,5 89,6 4,10 4,63 0,42 0,40 7–8 2 677 708 3 2
A
1175
025 1739
1243
Figure 28. Values qualifying the edges in the substemma of 1243
Another value shows the additional contribution of an ancestor within a combination, its relevance for it. It indicates the number of variants of the descendant which could not be explained without this witness.77 Witness 1739, for example, explains 2 additional variants, where it does not agree with the other three ancestors. The value of minimal contribution is very interesting. Unlike the value of additional contribution, it concerns cases where coincidental agreement is improbable on account of the character of the variants. In the case of both the additional variants, 1739 is a necessary ancestor of 1243 because no other ancestor explains the variants of 1243 and the variants are also connective due to their character.78
Gerd Mink
genealogical coherencies in small attestation in James 2:14/2-10
variant c
stemma (section) 1243
03
03
1175 04
2:15/16
1175
variant b 1175
1243
1243 04
2:19/8-14
2492
variant e 1243 1175 04
2:26/2-4
variant b 03
1175
1243
2492
Figure 29. Local representation (in attestations, left) of a global stemma (right)
As a result the maximal contribution of 1739 is 708 (agreements, plus any prior variants), and the minimal contribution is 2. In the case of A there are 5 additional contributions. Only 2 of these can be explained exclusively by A.79 The minimal contribution of 1175 is 1 or even 0, for the only reading of 1175 qualifying as minimal contribution could be a simple independent orthographic agreement (as the variant of 1243 could be).80 Nevertheless, it is a member of the group of ancestors. If we were to remove 1175 from the group, assuming the agreements to be coincidental (in spite of their number), 8 variants of 1243 (cf. additional contribution in Figure 28) would remain unexplained by agreements, and we would have to search among the potential ancestors for another witness or other witnesses to explain these variants. But should we find such a witness, its general agreement with 1243 would be lower than that of 1175, and in case of two or more witnesses being necessary for the explanation of the 8 variants under discussion, the group of ancestors in the substemma would increase. In either case we would have an inferior choice and it would not be more likely that the agreements were not coincidental than in the case of 1175. It may be interesting to look at some of the additional contributions where attestations displaying the assumed relationship of 1175 and 1243 contain only
Problems of a highly contaminated tradition
a small number of witnesses. On the right hand side of Figure 29 we see an extract of a stemma. On the left hand side there are variants with their attestations. The edges show their genealogical coherencies, which are completely in harmony with the assumed stemma (cf. Figure 43 and the substemmata in Figures 36 and 40). Although 1175 has not been qualified as necessary at these places of variation because there are other witnesses (except for the second example), and although the variants are not especially significant,81 there is no doubt that 1175 participates in the textual flow, as it usually does. The examples support the general genealogical relations very well. A last question is why 01 is not needed as a further ancestor although it provides two additional instances of agreement (cf. Figure 24, marked line). The reason is that the agreements are rather coincidental in view of the kind of variants and the lower general agreement of 01.82
. Prior variants found only in non-ancestors If any two witnesses of a highly contaminated textual tradition are compared at random almost every single one has prior and posterior variants as compared to the other. Though prior variants prevail in potential ancestors, they also contain a (sometimes only slightly) smaller number of posterior variants. The opposite is true for witnesses to which the predominant textual flow is directed. They are, therefore, not potential ancestors. If the tradition is dense and every witness has a series of closely related potential ancestors, it will be easy to find the prior variants among them which explain the posterior variants in a descendant. Generally speaking, this is also true for a less dense tradition, but in such a tradition the prior variant which corresponds to a posterior one may only occur in one witness, which is not a potential ancestor. In the case of two witnesses C and D, which both can be traced back to an ancestor B, a very simple stemma evolves (Figure 30, left). D is assumed to have incorporated more changes from B than C has. This means that D cannot be a potential ancestor of C. Let us now suppose that there are places where C has variants which evolved from variants found only in D. Yet their number is so small that D is still not a potential ancestor of C. C has, e.g., 10 posterior variants compared to B, D has 30 compared to B, C has 5 posterior variants compared to D, D has 25 compared to C. For the 5 places where C has posterior variants compared to D, the left hand stemma of Figure 30 does not apply.
Gerd Mink B
B C
C
D
C
D
Figure 30. Intermediary node in case D has prior variants compared to C without being its ancestor
A correct stemma should therefore also represent the fact that prior variants are found in a witness which is predominantly not prior and therefore not a potential ancestor. The solution is an intermediary node, pertaining only to prior variants in a non-ancestor (cf. Figure 30, right). If there were no more surviving witnesses than B, C and D, it would be possible to establish the connection between C and D via a hyparchetype. If the connection between B, C and D is perceived as a substemma within a highly contaminated tradition, however, it would not be possible to establish a well founded hyparchetype, if the hyparchetype is in turn also the product of contamination. The intermediary node does not represent a hyparchetype. A hyparchetype would be a hypothetical witness, comparable to other witnesses, but only hypothetical, and would essentially contain variants at all the places of variation. The intermediary node only contains the variants which are relevant in this case. It is not advisable to merge the intermediary node into the edge pointing from B to D, as it might just as easily be situated on the way from B to C, and as it could in principle also be the product of contamination. The intermediary node in this case is to be understood as follows: There are posterior variants in C deriving from prior ones which are found in the non-ancestor D and which evolved from variants in B. C and D are now represented as products of contamination. This may be accurate. The intermediary node may also, as described, be part of the linear development from B to one of its descendants, so that only one of the two witnesses is a result of contamination. Also, in this respect an intermediary node must therefore not be interpreted in the same way as a main node. The stemmatic representation, therefore, is not a definite hypothesis about the location of contamination in the textual tradition and it raises various possibilities. The intermediary node helps to solve a problem which is the result of conflicting data (prior and posterior variants in one and the same witness) and ultimately of contamination and loss of intermediary witnesses.
Problems of a highly contaminated tradition
For an illustration I go back to Figures 21 and 22. The conclusion was that, on the basis of all the places where a certain variant could be assigned to A, and the variant of 03 could be put into a local stemma, the ancestor of 03 in an optimal substemma was A and no other witness. Yet, according to Figure 21 (cf. Qfragl) there is a place where the relationship between 03 and A is doubtful, in James 2:4/2-4. The variants and witnesses in this place are: a: οὐ διεκρίθητε ‘have you not made distinctions?’ (rhetorical question): 01. 02. 03 (additional to the reading of the continuous text). 04 and many others b: οὐχὶ διεκρίθητε (same meaning as variant a): 2544 c: διεκρίθητε ‘you have made distinctions’: 03 (in the text). 1852 d: καὶ οὐ διεκρίθητε (same meaning as variant a): 025 and many others e: καὶ διεκρίθητε (same meaning as variant c): 322. 323. 629
In the ECM variant a was the text established by the editors, although it could well be a simplification compared to d.83 At the time, the quality of the attestation of variant d (essentially characterised by 025 and Byzantine witnesses) did not appear sufficient for assuming it to be the initial text. Other editors following the traditional view of textual history acted likewise. So far, the secondary rise of variant d remains unexplained. The first word in variant d is καί, normally meaning ‘and, also’. Neither these meanings nor any of the other documented meanings make a sense here. The text preceding the place is a rather long conditional clause, interrupted by two short phrases in direct speech. The following apodosis is then introduced in a completely non-Greek manner by καί, a phenomenon which is, however, known from the realm of semitising Greek as ‘καί apodoseos’ and was possibly applied as well in James 4:15.84 It is rare in the New Testament. Later copyists cannot have been familiar with this usage, and the word must have appeared superfluous to them. Further genealogical investigations have revealed that in the attestation of variant d genealogical coherencies are present which could lead, by way of witnesses 025 and 307, to A, the initial text. A is potential ancestor of both 025 and 307, with the highest degree of agreement (cf. Figure 16). Consequently, variant d could also qualify as initial text. As variant a is easily explained as an adaptation of variant d to common usage and a number of witnesses for variant a are easily traced back to A, and as conversely variant d cannot be explained from variant a, variant d was subsequently declared the initial text.85 Figure 31 shows the resulting local stemma.
Gerd Mink d ?
a
c
b
e
Figure 31. Local stemma of James 2:4/2-4 B
03 < 04 03 04
Figure 32. Optimal substemma of 03 with intermediary node
Variant c has not been put into the stemma. On the one hand it might be a simplification of variant e with the objectionable καί left out in the same way as variant a probably did on the basis of variant d. This, however, is not very likely, for the witnesses of e are not potential ancestors and quite remote from 03 as witness of variant c. Within the attestation of c, by the way, 03 is ancestor of 1852. Derivation of variant c from variant d or variant a is more likely. The last word before the place of variation is μου. For variant d the resulting context is μου καὶ οὐ διεκρίθητε, for variant a μου οὐ διεκρίθητε. The reason for variant c appears to be a very common scribal error: the copyist eyeskips from one sequence of characters (here ου in μου) to an identical sequence later on in the text (here οὐ before διεκρίθητε) and continues copying from that point. With both variant d or variant a as a basis, the result would be variant c. If variant c is derived from variant a, the problem arises that there is no potential ancestor of 03 in its attestation. Yet its witnesses would have a prior variant compared to 03 which is not found in any of the potential ancestors of 03. For variant a 03’s closest relative is 04. A correct stemma should therefore include the fact that there are prior variants in a witness which is predominantly not prior. The solution is an intermediary node pertaining only to this one variant (Figure 32). This will ensure that 03 can at the same time be an ancestor of 04 (see Figure 40). If variant c is derived from variant d, the substemma of Figure 22 is true.86
Problems of a highly contaminated tradition
Witnesses which are connected by an undirected genealogical coherency are also to be classed as non-ancestors. No direction of textual flow can be detected between them, for both contain equal number of prior and posterior variants. Let us assume that this applies to witnesses C and D in the example in Figure 30 (right). An analogous picture would result if D has a prior variant which is essential to explain a variant of C. At the same time it is conceivable that C has a variant which is essential to explain a variant of D. In that case there would not only be an intermediary node D > C like the one in Figure 30, but also an intermediary node C > D. P23, for example, is a fragment. However, it actually provides text at 49 places of variation, but there are mostly only one or two witnesses which differ from the initial text at these places. Thus, P23 has undirected coherencies with an abundance of witnesses. Compared to the initial text P23 differs only once: variant ff in James 1:17/40-46. This variant is represented by an erroneous reading in P23, which is probably based on variant d. The witnesses for d are 01 (first hand) and 03. There are also undirected coherencies with these. As in the previous example, 01 and 03 should be linked with P23 by way of an intermediary node in an optimal substemma on account of this prior variant.87 P23 in turn has a prior variant compared to 01 and another one compared to 03.88 But in both cases P23 agrees with the initial text A. A is ancestor in the substemmata of 01 and 03, P23 is therefore in no way necessary to explain a variant in 01 or 03.89
. Undirected genealogical coherencies At the beginning the search for the optimal substemmata is based on the potential ancestors only, because between them and the descendants directed genealogical coherencies exist and only they offer any information about the direction of the textual flow. When a substemma is found which explains all the variants of the descendant with as few ancestors as possible, the possibility remains that the substemma does not explain a number of close genealogical coherencies resulting from frequent agreements of witnesses within attestations. These coherencies may not be indicated by other substemmata either and so not be reflected in the global stemma. This phenomenon is caused by the undirected genealogical coherencies. Let us assume a substemma consisting of an ancestor B and a descendant C. A further substemma links ancestor B with descendant D. The two substemmata are compatible with the situation at a place of variation as represented in
Gerd Mink
variant a
variant b
witness B
witness C
witness D
Figure 33. Undirected genealogical coherency between C and D within an attestation intermediary node relation without direction C=D C
D C
D
Figure 34. Resolution of an undirected edge through an intermediary node
Figure 33. If there is no link between C and D, these witnesses must have developed their variants independently from the variant in B as the diagram seems to suggest. They would coincidentally have the same variant. If we further assume a close undirected genealogical link between C and D (cf. the link between C and D in Figure 33), it is impossible that they have developed the same variant coincidentally. This fact has to be reflected in a global stemma. When we find such witnesses with close undirected genealogical relationships (cf. the undirected edge in Figure 34, left hand graph), intermediary nodes are apparently needed for an exact description of the relationship. The supposition is that witnesses C and D agree in variants which have not emerged independently but stem from common ancestors, and the condition is that one or more attestations exist which contain neither a (surviving) common ancestor of C and D nor a witness which is a descendant of C and an ancestor of D or the reverse. These intermediary nodes are not hyparchetypes in a traditional sense, but should better be understood as a special kind of connection. The content of such a node as in Figure 34 (right hand graph) is all the agreements between C and D. Thus C and D have their ancestors, and the intermediary node establishes a link to the ancestor or ancestors (= sources) of the common variants of C and D. If the content of the intermediary node is the result of contamination, witness B is only one of the ancestors of the intermediary node (cf. Figure
Problems of a highly contaminated tradition
Figure 35. Potential ancestors of witness 1175. See Figure 21 for field legends A
03 1739
1175
A
1243
03
1852
04
Figure 36. Connection between two substemmata through an undirected edge
33). The intermediary node has to be incorporated into the substemmata. If the substemmata of both witnesses are true, the ancestors of the intermediary node have to be the intersection of the witnesses which are ancestors in the two substemmata, or a subset of the intersection. For illustration I take two witnesses which are closely related, but there is no predominant direction of textual flow between them: 04 and 1175 (cf. Figure 35, no arrow in the Richtg field, in accordance with the equal values in the xausy and yausx fields).90 They are shown with their optimal substemmata in Figure 36. 04 and 1175 have 12 places where they have secondary variants in common, but considering the good coherency between the two witnesses, this is no accident. Due to the old text form the agreement values (Proz1 field) begin at relatively low percentages. According to the optimal substemma 1739 is descendant of 04 (Figure 40, top right) and ancestor of 1175 (Figure 36). At 7 out of the 12 places 1739 reads the same variant as 04 and 1175.91 The hypothetical route of the variants at these 7 places could therefore be 04 → 1739 → 1175. At 2 out of the 12 places 03 reads the same variant as 04 and 1175,92 in whose respective substemmata 03 is the ancestor (cf. Figure 36). The route of the variants could therefore be 04 ← 03 → 1175. 3 places now remain,93 where 04 and 1175 agree, but in the same attestations no ancestors of at least one of them are available which could connect these witnesses. The substemmata in Figure 40 are true without a link between 04 and 1175, inasmuch as the variants at
Gerd Mink A
03 1852
1243
04 = 1175
1739
04
1175
Figure 37. Resolution of the undirected edge in Figure 36
the three places are further developments of the source variants offered by at least one of the relevant ancestors found in the substemmata of 04 and 1175.94 However, the relationship between 04 and 1175 would not be expressed by the substemmata. Rather, the fact that there is no stemmatic link between 04 and 1175 at the three instances in question, would promote the false impression that the two witnesses coincidentally share the same variant. Figure 37 shows the result for 04 and 1175 following the model of Figure 34. There is no undirected connection between 04 and 1175. Their common variants are explained with the aid of the intermediary node connecting the sources of the common variants with 04 and 1175 and connecting 04 and 1175 in the same way. As a result of the intermediary node one of the stemmatic coherencies and thereby ancestors may become superfluous, as in this case ancestor 1739 in the substemma of 1175. If there were no instances which make 1739 an ancestor in the substemma of 1175 apart from the 7 instances where the witness plays the role described above (04 → 1739 → 1175) this would be correct. Yet there are a large number. The connection of two witnesses by way of an intermediary node and the incorporation of the node into the relevant substemmata (cf. the substemma of 04 in Figure 40) unquestionably calls for renewed examination and possibly fresh optimising of the stemmata. It is also possible that an intermediary node is only needed from the perspective of one of the witnesses it is going to connect. This is the case for attestations containing no further witnesses genealogically connecting the witnesses (in contrast to the example 04 → 1739 → 1175) and having no common ancestors (in contrast to the example 04 ←
Problems of a highly contaminated tradition
03 → 1175), but an ancestor for one witness only, and if no places are left in which neither witness has an ancestor in the same attestation. Indeed, for 04 and 1175 such a place remains.95 If there were no such place, 04 would have had an ancestor in each place that agrees with 1175, and should not have needed an intermediary node in contrast to 1175. In this case, the edge from this node to 04 could be marked in order to indicate this fact. An optimal substemma can also be constructed for an intermediary node. The ancestors can be found amongst the ancestors common to the substemmata of the descendants involved. The node representing the agreements of 04 and 1175 requires A and 03 as ancestors (cf. Figure 37). As a simpler solution but with a certain loss of information, instead of an intermediary node an undirected edge could be used, cf. paragraph 9 and Figure 43. For intermediary nodes based on undirected coherencies the same restrictions apply as for nodes based on prior variants in non-ancestors. As for the latter, the stemmatic representation opens up various possibilities for the location of contamination in the textual tradition (see paragraph 7). At any rate, we must keep in mind that in the case of undirected coherencies the stability of the textual flow has the value 0 (cf. Figure 27).
. Circular edges The problems in this field have not been definitely solved and further research is necessary. Figure 20 showed how the problem may emerge. If the variants of an ancestor were mixed with the variants of the ancestor’s ancestor, over several generations of copying, thereby reintroducing older variants again and again, this may result in a descendant so rich in older variants that it becomes a potential ancestor of a mediate ancestor. A circle materialises based on contamination in multi-stage phases. But are there more preconditions than multi-stage contamination? Figure 38 refers back to Figure 20. The assumed variants of the 4 witnesses at 8 places of variation are shown in a matrix of 8 lines (in a frame). The variants are in accordance with the requirements of Figure 20. On the right are the local stemmata presupposed at the 8 places of variation. This offers the information how often a witness has a prior variant compared to another. The values are listed on the left. C has prior variants in two cases where D has the respective posterior variants (cf. lines 1 and 6 of the matrix). From the values the predominant textual flows follow, C > D, D > E, E > C.96 From the tex-
Gerd Mink B C
witnesses: B, C, D, E
E
direction/cases C>D D>C
2 1
D>E E>D
3 2
E>C C>E
2 1
variants: a, b, c, a‘, a“
D
B
C
D
E
a a a a a a a a
a b b b b b b b
b a b b b c a‘ a‘
b b a a b a‘ a“ a“
local stemmata for line: 1–5 6 7, 8 a a a
b
b
c
a‘
b
a‘
a“
Figure 38. Circular edges
tual flows follows the potential ancestor of each of the witnesses and a circle materialises. The local stemmata at the first 5 places allow a statement, in each and every case, whether the variant of a witness is prior or posterior to the variant of another witness. The local stemmata at places 6, 7 and 8, however, do not allow such a deduction for each pair of variants, as not all the variants are directly connected. If there were only direct connections like in the first stemma, the circle would no longer occur.97 The question now arises, whether the enrichment with older variants in a branch of the textual tradition is the only cause for a circle or whether other conditions may lead to circles even in small areas of a stemma. From Figure 38 it already appeared that not all the local stemmata there belonged to type a → b, and that this made a circle at least possible. Figure 39 represents a circle of 3 witnesses. The circle is supposed to be part of a stemma. In the upper half of Figure 39 it is assumed that there is only one possibility for a local stemma; it leads from variant a to variant b. The matrix of variants in the middle section, and the information obtained from it, how often each witness has a prior variant compared to another witness (see direction/cases), demonstrates the circular relationship of the 3 witnesses. The local stemma of this simple structure does not allow a circular connection between the witnesses (see above) if all the places in the matrix can only be filled by a or by b. Three positions (the small boxes in the matrix) remain empty in order to obtain the values (cf. direction/cases) needed for a circle. If one of the boxes were to be filled by a or b, there would be no circle. In fact, in the
Problems of a highly contaminated tradition C variants: a, b, c, (x), (y)
witnesses: C, D, E D
direction / cases C>D D>C
2 1
D>E E>D
2 1
E>C C>E
2 1
E
C
D
E
a a b £ b b
b b a a £ £
a b b b a a
dir. / cases A / cases B C>D D>C
4 1(1)
2 1(1)
D>E E>D
2 1(2)
2 1(2)
E>C C>E
3 1
2 1
local stemmata:
C
D
E
a a b c b b
b b a a c c
a b b b a a
a
b
a
a
b
b
c
a
b
(x)
(y)
a
c
b
c
Figure 39. Circular edges in consequence of lacunae (top) or different types of local stemmata
situation where at each place there is just a variant a and a variant b, a circle is only possible if there are appropriate lacunae in the witnesses. It follows that if there are no lacunae, the matrix can only be completed with variants leading to the same circular edges if there are other types of local stemmata. The bottom half of Figure 39 shows a matrix of variants in which the boxes (i.e. the lacunae) of the top matrix have all been replaced with variant c. We assume that at the first three places (= lines of the matrix) the first type of local stemma evidences the genealogical relationship between the variants, but at the last three places the second type of local stemma does. There c derives from b. The a witnesses have no prior variants compared to the variants of the c witnesses. A variant, after all, is only prior compared to a posterior variant which developed from it (cf. paragraph 4.9); c, however, derives from b, not from a. a has mediate priority at most. On the left, under ‘dir./cases A’, the relationship between witnesses is shown from the perspective of the priority and posteriority of their variants. The values are based on the assumption that only the first and the second types of local stemma are true. The values without brackets indicate the number of prior variants. Again a circle results, C > D, D > E, E > C. The values in brackets
Gerd Mink
show the number of indirect relationships occurring here if one witness reads a and the other c. If we now assume that the last three lines of the matrix do not conform to the second type of local stemma but to the third, the resulting values which are found under ‘dir./cases B’ correspond to the values in the top part of Figure 39. The circle remains. The changes reflect the fact that c can no longer be traced back to b. The mediate priority of a is maintained (values in brackets). It proceeds by way of a variant y rendered by witnesses not being part of the circle. If the fourth local stemma is assumed to apply to the three last lines of the matrix, again the same values as in the top of Figure 39 ensue. As a and c now derive from a common source variant x, rendered by witnesses not being part of the circle, no mediate priorities are left at all. It would now be possible to consider the use of the mediate relationships in the construction of a stemma. But there are serious methodical objections to this. Rightly, only direct relationships between variants in the local stemmata are used to determine potential ancestors and textual flows. To determine the genealogical coherency between two witnesses their degree of agreement is essential first of all and secondly the relation between the number of their prior and posterior variants, i.e. only data based on identity of variants or direct genealogical relationships between them. It is only this direct relationship which makes it at all possible to conduct coherence tests at individual places of variation,98 and to find local chains of coherencies incorporated into a global stemma and subsets of the global stemma represented in diagrams which show the textual flow within an attestation.99 It is clear that circles can materialise as a result of different circumstances. The complexity is much higher in reality than in the examples in Figures 38 and 39 – more witnesses, more variants, therefore more complex local stemmata, the several types of which (see Figure 39 bottom half) get mixed up, and that is without taking into account the lacunae. In this situation circles may emerge, but need not. Under the conditions of Figures 38 and 39 a circle does not materialise if variants within the same line of the matrix change places for the same local stemmata. This is of course due to the very small difference between the number of prior and posterior variants of one witness in the circle compared to another. In fact, the smallest difference between pairs of witnesses concerned determines the stability of a circle, and the differences are often very small indeed. The variants have to be distributed among witnesses in a very particular way for a circle to materialise. How frequently this may happen also depends on the frequency of non-direct relationships between variants, and the degree of fragmentation of witnesses.100
Problems of a highly contaminated tradition A
1243 03 1852 04 = 1175
A
04
1175
025 1739
A
1243
04
03
1739
A
1852
025
03
1175
1739 1243 04 = 1175 04
Figure 40. Top: substemmata; bottom: their combination with a circle
Badly fragmented witnesses certainly present a very special risk. The genealogical relationship between a fragmentary witness and another witness is determined on the basis of its limited text supply. As the distribution of prior and posterior variants in a text can be very different, it is possible that an entirely different picture would have resulted from the complete witness, if it had been preserved. Witness 04, in which roughly the first 3 out of 5 chapters of James have been preserved as a continuous text, is a good example how the inclusion of such texts causes the emergence of several circles. Figure 17 presents the two most probable genealogical relations in the top area of a global stemma. This tree suggests that in a global stemma 04 will be ancestor of 1739, 1243 ancestor of 04. Yet, in the substemma of 1243 we find 1739 as an ancestor of 1243 (Figures 28 and 40). Figure 40 represents the optimal substemmata of 04, 1243 and 1739. At the bottom we see their combination, containing the connections in the substemmata. The connection of the intermediary node with 1175 as well is implied. The circle which was to be expected on the basis of Figures 17 and 28 does indeed materialise (04–1739–1243–04, cf. the bold edges). 04 is only available at 482 out of 761 places of variation, whereas the other witnesses can be used almost in their entirety. If only the first three chapters of James instead of five are taken as a basis – i.e. roughly the quantity of text preserved in 04 – the textual flow between 1739 and 1243 changes direction,101 and the circle disappears.102 As Figure 36 shows, 1739 is also an ancestor in the optimal substemma
Gerd Mink intermediary node D³B circular edges
B
B C C D
D
Figure 41. Simplified model for the resolution of circular edges
of 1175. Here again a circle will materialise in which 04 participates. It includes the other circle (04–1739–1175–1243–04). The direction of the textual flow between 1175 and 1739 would change likewise for the first three chapters.103 The problematic side effects of including fragmentary witnesses are evident. They are aggravated by the fact that the stability of the textual flow between both 1175 and 1243 and 1175 and 1739 is very poor.104 Of course, 04 is too large and too important in the textual tradition not to be considered. The example was chosen deliberately, also in order to illustrate how important it is to have access to values and facts behind a stemmatic graph. How is such a circular structure to be pictured? Figure 41 (left hand diagram) shows a simple model of circular edges. The circle can be resolved by introducing an intermediary node containing the variants of D which are the basis of agreeing and secondary variants in B (Figure 41, right hand diagram). But the problem is that the model of circular edges can be rotated. Consequently, we have to treat all the witnesses in the same way. The result is Figure 42 (bottom). The left hand stemma in Figure 43 shows the combination of the substemmata of 04, 1243, and 1739, following the model of Figure 42. The circle 04-1739-1243-04 is now resolved. In addition, the undirected coherency between 04 and 1175 is respected (cf. Figures 36 and 37). The number of edges may be smaller if the edges from A to 04, 1243, or 1739 are “empty” (not transporting variants, for all the variants pass the relevant intermediary node). In Figure 43 the right hand stemma can be interpreted as representing the same facts as the left hand one with its intermediary nodes. There is a circle connecting 1739, 1243, and 04. 1175 and 04 are connected by an undirected edge. The logical meaning of the right hand diagram is the same as that of the left hand diagram, the disadvantage is only that there are no intermediary nodes with their special contents and ancestors. On the other hand, the cir-
Problems of a highly contaminated tradition B
circular edges
C D
C³D
D³B
B³C B
intermediary nodes
C D
Figure 42. Complete model for the resolution of circular edges A
03
A 025
04 = 1175 1852
03
025 1175 1739
1175
1243
1852 1243 ³ 04 04
04 ³ 1739 1243
1739 ³ 1243
04
1739
Figure 43. Stemmata with resolved undirected and circular edges (left) and unresolved undirected and circular edges (right)
cles in the left hand diagram are more difficult to discern. Yet the right hand stemma provides less information. However, full information can be found in neither of the two stemmata. A stemma like the one on the left is only useful for specific purposes and even then one has to know the way that each of the variants follows through the stemma. Further problems arise when more circles materialise in the vicinity of a witness, as is indeed the case for 04 (see above). They have not been taken into account in Figure 43. The number of intermediary nodes increases. Yet the new nodes and edges may be simplified by combining nodes which are not contradictory. This will have consequences for the definition of the simplicity of a
Gerd Mink
(sub)stemma. When intermediary nodes depending on circles start accumulating, the limits of depiction are reached fairly soon. On the other hand, the circles from the underlying data are often easily made out. In reality, circular genealogical relationships are impossible. However, a stemma does not represent historical reality, but structures obtained from the available data. Yet, concerning the data, the relationships of fragments are essentially complicated by the fact that witnesses with different text lengths can only be compared to a certain extent. In any event the result must be interpreted with caution, both if the character of the whole witness is judged from that of the fragment, or if the complete witness is only assessed in the section which is covered by the fragment. Thereby, a circle depending on fragmentation is an artefact. Nevertheless, according to the rules the substemmata involved in the circle remain true. In fact, in the case of the substemma of 1739 (Figure 40) a simpler substemma to explain the variants of 1739 at all places of variation cannot be found. Again, the background data are important for estimating to what extent artefacts contribute to the result. Matters are different with circles depending exclusively on the model of Figure 20. Those circles correspond to a circular development of variants. If we do not know the actual chronological order of the different textual states, we can only detect a circle. Rules for the construction of a global stemma which prevents the emergence of circles will have to result from the respective model of the textual tradition. I do not consider this possible. If the data suggest a circular development it should be represented as circular.
. The construction of a global stemma The global stemma is the superset comprising all the optimal substemmata as subsets including the intermediary nodes incorporated into them or the corresponding connections.105 The stemmatic coherencies between descendant and ancestors ensue from the optimisation of the substemmata. Even if intermediary nodes are not hyparchetypes and sometimes comprise only one variant, their role is technically comparable to that of the main nodes, insofar as they occupy the same position as ancestors if incorporated into a substemma. Thereby, the stemmatic connections on the level of the substemmata are established. They contain all the necessary connections and they contain only those. Each ancestor (apart from A) in a substemma will be a descendant in another substemma. Each descendant will either be an ancestor in one or
Problems of a highly contaminated tradition
more substemmata, or, if not an ancestor, represent a terminal node in the global stemma. The connections in a global stemma are thus absolutely determined by the connections in the substemmata. Consequently, only one single global stemma is possible on the basis of one set of optimised substemmata (with any intermediary nodes). Optimising on the level of the global stemma is impossible. Every change in the substemmata leads to a change in the global stemma, the change, however, being absolutely limited to the range of the substemmata involved. If there are alternative substemmata of the same quality, there are also alternative global stemmata of equal quality. Their numbers may easily mount up. If there is another alternative substemma for a given descendant, the number of possible global stemmata increases only by 1, but it doubles with every alternative substemma for further descendants. In a very dense textual tradition, with texts agreeing almost completely, the case will repeatedly occur that an ancestor in a substemma can be replaced by another without affecting the quality of the substemma. The same can happen with fragments mainly rendering places of variation at which only few witnesses depart from the mainstream of the tradition. Consequently, they will have numerous close relatives agreeing at the same high degree. In addition, it must not be assumed that the character of the lost part of the witnesses corresponds sufficiently to the preserved part if there is a greatly limited or very small number of places of variation. Nevertheless, it is not necessary to refrain from the use of fragments in stemmata at all, but it is essential to know their precise data. It is not possible to refrain from using a witness as important as 04 (see above) in the construction of the stemma, although two chapters of James are missing. Yet 04 belongs to an area of the textual tradition in which nearly all witnesses are lost. The smaller fragments are very unlikely to appear as ancestors anyway, as they explain too few variants in a descendant. It would not be very worthwhile to construct all possible stemmata. As optimising takes place at the level of the substemmata and not in the course of the creation of the global stemma, connections in the global stemma would not change if it is incomplete. It is, therefore, possible to construct parts of a global stemma and leave out those areas where there are alternatives. The remaining connections will still remain true. The informational value of an area in the stemma with many equally good alternatives is meagre at any rate. Yet, on the other hand it may be desirable to see what the development in a specific area is like, cum grano salis. This is possible if all the alternatives lead to very similar results in any case. It would then be sufficient to mark the connections for
Gerd Mink A
03
A
03 1739
025 1739
1175
A
1175
1243
A 1 1: 97,3%; 19; 0 2: 92,5%; 55; 0 3: 92,6%; 54; 0 4: 90,8%; 47; 12 5: 90,4%; 31; 30 6: 92,0%; 29; 28 7: 89,6%; 35; 32 8: 91,5%; 29; 26
03
2
3
1739 5
4
7
025
1175 8
6
1243
Figure 44. Part of a global stemma, compiled from substemmata. Left: qualification of edges: agreements in %, number of prior and posterior variants of the ancestor.
which there are alternatives. This is particularly useful where in a stemma areas without alternatives are separated from each other by an area with alternatives. As the completeness of a stemma is no prerequisite for the accuracy of the connections it is, of course, possible to extract any section of the global stemma, e.g. the top of the stemma, the stemma of a group, without constructing the complete stemma. Figure 44 demonstrates that there is no other possibility for constructing this section of the global stemma on the basis of the substemmata. If any ancestors are available here, then all of them are available. If there are no ancestors available, as with 025 and 1739, they are situated outside the section of the global stemma. If the global stemma were complete, the section of the stemma in Figure 44 would not change.106
. Conclusion It is very clear that the genealogical structure of a contaminated tradition cannot be revealed if evaluations of variants and automatic procedures are not alternated permanently. Accordingly, three levels of falsifiability have to be accounted for: the level of facts, the level of evaluation of readings, and the level of procedures and their rules. Furthermore we have to be aware of the undesirable artefacts caused by method, point of view, and way of visualisation.107
Problems of a highly contaminated tradition
The user of a stemma has some very simple questions. Why is there an edge connecting x and y, and what is the reason for its direction? How reliable is the connection? He needs more information than stemmata usually provide. The stemmatic graph of a contaminated tradition is only one possible surface of a very complex situation. The facts behind the stemmatic connections are extremely important and must be accessible for assessment. The genealogical evaluation of the facts is the basis for their graphic visualisation, if the connections rendered in it are to represent genealogical directions. If a stemmatic graph is the visualisation of a hypothesis and if it is a surface showing only certain aspects of the material, different methodological approaches will be useful in order to recover the patterns within the preserved material. It is all the more important, then, that the user of stemmatic representations should know how to read them, and understand which interpretations are justified and which are not with respect to the theoretical background and all the procedures which contribute to finding the stemma.
Notes . This leads to a more complex concept of a stemma, cf. paragraphs 4, 10, and 11. . The word address, in even numbers, marks the word in the text established in the ECM where the variation starts, and, if not identical, the word with which the variation ends; the address uses odd numbers to mark spaces between words, which is important for additions. . The last word before the place of variation ends in the same letter or letters as the omitted variant. . The witnesses are 467, 643 and 1848. . 631. . The degree of relationship is determined by the degree of agreement. Cf. for this paragraph 4.11 (pre-genealogical coherence). . According to the pre-genealogical coherencies. Nearest relative here is 424 with only 85.9% correspondence. Also when the genealogical coherence (cf. paragraph 4.11) is taken into consideration, the closest potential ancestor (again 424) falls within the d attestation. . If variant c is assumed to stem from variant a only, the link between d and c would disappear from the stemma. The relationship between the a witnesses and the c witness would not change, the relationship between the d witnesses and the c witness would become only slightly remoter (some 0.2 percentage points). Actually, a choice has to be made between the two possibilities, as further processing of alternative local stemmata is not possible. . Cf. Figure 36.
Gerd Mink . For P74 the degrees of agreement start off very modestly: 89.6% with 02. The relative remoteness of the next relatives is caused by a larger number of peculiar variants attested only in P74 or shared only coincidentally with more remote witnesses. . They are potential ancestors, cf. paragraph 4.10. In this context, the dating of the manuscripts is not important, cf. paragraph 4.4. . Cf. Aland (1987, 1991, 1993, 1998–1999). . Cf. Aland, Aland, Mink, and Wachtel (1997, 2000, 2003). . The numerous orthographic modifications and 592 faulty readings, which almost always occur in conjunction with a correct variant were not counted as genuine variants, cf. paragraph 4.3. The places of variation include also 59 places where only variants attested by lectionaries, Church Fathers or (mostly) early versions deviate from the mainstream of the tradition. In the case of Church Fathers and versions variants, as a matter of fact, were only recorded, if they, certainly or presumably, rest upon a Greek exemplar in a now lost Greek text witness. . So not counting variants by correctors, in marginal text and commentaries. . Not including versional variants which are not assumed to rest upon a Greek exemplar. . For the types cf. Salemans (2000: 24–25). . Again not including corrections, marginal text and commentaries, as they do not respresent continuous text. . To be exact, 704 attestations. The dots in the diagram correspond with the following values (from left to right): 969, 875, 832, 804, 794, 782, 766, 753, 734, 722, 704, 676, 629, 533, 154. . To be exact, 124 places. The dots in the diagram correspond with following values (from left to right): 59, 418, 124, 71, 37, 25, 6, 6, 6, 3, 1, 1, 1. . To be exact, 158 places. The dots in the diagram correspond with following values (from left to right): 702, 283, 158, 87, 50, 25, 19, 13, 7, 4, 3, 3, 3, 2, 2, 2, 2, 2, 2, 1. . Although the 59 places do not give any information about the genealogical relationships between the 164 Greek manuscripts involved, they are nevertheless included in the genealogically relevant data, as they are needed for the genealogical assessment of the texts of the lectonaries, Church Fathers and in particular the Greek exemplars of the early versions. The versions can then be subjected to the same procedures as the Greek witnesses. Cf. Spencer, Wachtel, and Howe (2002). . Cf. the model in paragraph 4. . The dark part of the bars in Figure 6 indicates manuscripts of uncertain date. . Cf. witness vs. manuscript, paragraph 4.4. . Cf. also the preliminary study Mink (1993) and Mink (2000). Mink (1993) represents the state of that time and could only be based on the material in the test passages (see paragraph 1; 25 instead of 761 places). . Cf. e.g. the case of 1243, paragraph 6. . Readings here meaning variants.
Problems of a highly contaminated tradition . Mink (2000: 52). . Cf. Mink (1993: 489). . An author does not necessarily always do justice to his intentions. He may formulate a text which is barely understandable, or which requires a great intellectual effort on the part of the reader, while to the author himself its meaning is absolutely clear. A copyist is more likely to produce variants here, in order to replace a lectio difficilior, according to his understanding, at any rate. He might also, as he does not understand the text himself, produce a variant which makes no sense and thus generate a lectio difficilior as compared to the original. . Amongst others 01, 03, 025, 1175, 1739T, and 1852. . If εὑρεθήσονται is accepted without the negation, exegetists and translators attempt to assign meanings to the word which are not recorded anywhere else. Many also have realised the absurdity of this variant and proposed a multitude of imaginative conjectures, cf. Metzger (1971: 706). . Given by 04 and therefore certainly an old variant. . This variant is given by the majority of the witnesses. Some of these also point to the age of the text form: 02, 33, 81, 307, 2298, 2344. Further variants (κατακαήσονται, καήσονται) have the same meaning. . ‘They will not be found’ is actually attested in non-Greek text traditions. It is regularly found in the Sahidic version, in the witness of the Coptic dialect V, and also in some of the witnesses of a Syriac version (Philoxeniana). Either the original variant truly survived here – which is at any rate quite possible for the Sahidic – or this variant is also already a conjecture. An old conjecture is already to be found in P72: εὑρθήσονται λυόμενα ‘they will be found as dissolved ones’. . Aland, Aland, Mink, and Wachtel (1997: 16*) . Ibid. . The distinction between manuscript and text is essential. Cf. Mink (2000: 52): “The manuscript having a palaeographical date gives us only the terminus ante quem non of the text”: there is no earlier attestation of the text. It is also possible to speak of the terminus post quem non: the text in this form came into being at the very latest at this point in time. . For the complete issue, cf. paragraph 10. . For the special case of an undirected connection, cf. paragraph 8. . Cf. Mink (2000: 53), on genealogical coherence: “In a system whose constituents are not independent of one another, those constituents must cohere in a definable manner, if we are to understand that system. Coherence within a group of witnesses means that the members of the group are connected by immediate genealogical relations.” The latter is true if we know the ways of transmission. Normally they are not known, and only part of the witnesses have been preserved. In such a case, coherence is represented by hypothetical coherencies within groups, and the genealogical relations are immediate only because a part of the tradition is lost. . Cf. P74, see note 10.
Gerd Mink . See for this issue also paragraph 6. . For perfect and imperfect coherence at places of variation, see paragraph 5.3. . Translated from Mink (2002). Expansive treatment in Mink (2003: 41–46). . For places of variation, see 4.2. . The present study uses the data available in November 2003. For limitations, see Note 56. . If very similar variants obviously emerge repeatedly from each other or respectively if there is an imperfect coherence within the attestation. . For the special problem of undirected genealogical coherencies cf. paragraphs 4.11 and 8. . If the field is empty, no predominant direction can be determined. . The percentage value is the relevant one, cf. paragraph 4. . This is in keeping with the model of the textual tradition, cf. paragraph 4.11. The degree of agreement does not conclusively determine the probability, it only influences it, for it does not allow to discern whether the textual flow between a potential ancestor x and a descendant z is included in a textual flow between a potential ancestor y and the descendant z. In such a case x would not be ancestor in an optimal substemma. Cf. paragraphs 4.8 and 6. . Smaller fragments must be ignored. Their agreement percentages are often extremely high, as they preserve areas in which only few witnesses deviate from the mainstream. This is true for the major part of the text of James (cf. paragraph 2). It is impossible to say how such a text would look like if it had been preserved in complete form. Even a partially fragmented text like 04, which nevertheless renders more than half of the text in contiuous form and cannot be left out of consideration because of its genealogical importance, presents some difficulties, see paragraph 9. . Further examples of the evaluation of similar lists in Mink (2003: 53–56). . Cf. h1 and h2 in Figure 7. In the most cases, a certain number of erroneous assessments of coherencies in the first step does not affect the overall results very much. If we do not split a variant logically into two or more variants despite the imperfect coherency, the number of agreements of each of the pairs of witnesses in the attestation will increase by 1 due to this variant. If we do split the variant, only the number of agreements of pairs in the same coherency chain will increase by 1. But if the number of agreeing variants of a pair is large, there is a high coherency of those witnesses even if some local coherencies are not realised, and if the number is small, coherence remains low even if some local coherencies are ascribed erroneously. – As regards James, the coherencies within attestations will need a final revision based on the last genealogical coherencies and particular textual flows. Until now, attestations have been split only in cases of obvious imperfect coherencies. A revision is expected to result in splitting more attestations and strengthen the tendencies which can be observed now. In some cases of poor stability of textual flow, ancestor-descendant relations may change. . Under kon the numbers of agreements are listed.
Problems of a highly contaminated tradition . The lists for two quite differing witnesses have been taken as an example here. 1243 has few potential ancestors, which indicates a position in the upper regions of a global stemma. The list for 2412 has been shortened and in reality counted 138 lines. From the top of the list it is obvious that the well-known witness 614 is the most closely related potential ancestor of 2412. The next lines document that the well-known HK group is to be counted among the potential ancestors. . Witness A, the root of the tree, is hypothetical, cf. paragraph 4.1. . Cf. Aland, Aland, Mink, and Wachtel (2000: 21*–22*). The same procedure was not suitable for 1 John because the witnesses are on the average closer to the initial text A and to each other than in James or the Letters of Peter. Therefore, it was necessary to start at those places of variation that can be assessed easily. In this way, determining potential ancestors and predominant textual flows could be based on 621 out of 761 places of variation. The results are preliminary, of course. Yet, they proved to be plausible and sufficient for a first evaluation of genealogical coherence and construction of textual flow diagrams. Cf. Aland, Aland, Mink, and Wachtel (2003: 29*). . Cf. for Figure 14 Mink (2003: 60–62). Figure 11 is a pre-form of Figure 14 here. . “Yet if he suffers as a Christian, he should not be ashamed; but he should glorify God in this part(?) / in this case(?) / on this behalf (?)”. The word μέρος has many meanings. . “Yet if he suffers as a Christian, he should not be ashamed; but he should glorify God in this name”. . “If you are reviled in the name of Christ, you are blessed”. . Cf. the textual flow diagram representing perfect coherence, in Mink, ibid., Figure 10. . A question mark at an edge means that the connection is doubtful and appears elsewhere in the diagram with another question mark. . The level of probability depends on the position of a potential ancestor in a list with descending rates of agreement, cf. Figures 9, 21, 23, 35, and paragraph 5.3. . A few witnesses are lacking in Figure 16. Fragments P23 and 0166 contain very little text, and present few places of variation in these passages. Thus, no directions of predominant textual flow emerge. Fragments P54, 0173 and 1846 contain very little text, too. Here, however, there are too many witnesses with equally strong textual flows directed towards these fragments. With 2718S, the predominant textual flow from two directions is equally strong and has been drawn with interrupted lines. A pre-form of this graph was earlier made available for a lecture of Barbara Aland, which was printed in the Korean Journal of Biblical Research (Aland 2000). . A section of Figure 17 including the textual flows which are third in probability is to be found in Mink (2003: 57 Note 17). Figures 16 and 17 do not include intermediary nodes (cf. paragraph 4.7). Usually the first 3 to 5 levels of probability are important when we are looking for the sources of the textual state of a descendant. In cases of variants which are connective because of their character and if the difference between the levels of probability is rather small, lower levels may be used to give a better choice. Cf. the method for constructing substemmata, paragraph 6. If the differences between the levels are small, the number of witnesses which do not contribute new variants in a substemma increases.
Gerd Mink . Where no initial reading could be hypothesized, A is treated as if it has a lacuna. . Those witnesses with good genealogical coherencies with A are of course of prime importance, since the variants in those witnesses could be expected to be part of the initial text; see Aland, Aland, Mink, and Wachtel (2000: 21*–22*). . Cf. paragraph 4.10. . Otherwise one would have to assume that 19 variants (cf. Figure 21, xausy field) emerged on the way from A to 03 without any intermediate stages, or without any contamination in any of the non-preserved intermediary witnesses. . 03 actually agrees with 1243 in more places than 025 does, but the degree of kinship is smaller. This degree is, however, decisive because of the respective number of places of variation where a pair of witnesses can be compared. A certain degree of fragmentation is normal. 1243 can be compared with 03 in 743 places, with 025 in 708 places. Only stronger fragmentation leads to less significant values resulting from the comparison, and moreover lessens the chance that the witness will become ancestor in substemmata, as it explains too few places of the descendants. . If the tradition is wide-spread, it may happen in a small number of cases that a descendant has a prior variant compared to all potential ancestors. Cf. paragraph 7. . For the conditions cf. paragraph 4.11. . For 025 an additional contribution of 7–8 is indicated. This is based on the fact that at one place it is not clear which variant should be the reading of the initial text A, and 025 makes an additional contribution only if it does not read the same variant as A (James 5:10/26-32). . The common omission of the sentence’s initial conjunction ὅτι in James 1:23/2 was regarded as not coincidental. The same applies to the addition of ἔργων in James 3:17/33. . James 2:3/50-56 (ὑπό, not ἐπί), 2:13/18 (κατακαυχ α ται, not –σθε or –σθω). . James 2:15/16 variant b: aorist participle λιπόμενοι vs. present participle λειπόμενοι; the pronunciation of the two words was the same. There is another place where a minimal contribution could be considered: James 5:20/20-28. 1243 has σώσει τὴν ψυχὴν ἐκ θανάτου. I derive this from σώσει ψυχὴν ἐκ θανάτου, the variant of 1175 and of no other ancestor. But although evolvement of the variant of 1243 from σώσει ψυχὴν αὐτου ἐκ θανάτου is less probable, it is not completely impossible. There are two more witnesses for the variant of 1243: 049 and 2492. 1243 is the closest potential ancestor of 2492. 049, however, is not part of the environment of 1243 at all (only 87% agreement) and only coincidentally reads the same variant, which goes back to the same source variant. . James 2:14/2-10 variant c: omission of an article which is not obligatory; 2:15/16 variant b: aorist participle λιπόμενοι vs. present participle λειπόμενοι – the difference is just one character, the pronunciation of the two words was the same; 2:19/8-14 variant e: reversal of words; 2:26/2-4 variant b: omission of γάρ ‘for’. . In two additional places 01 could explain the variants of 1243 (cf. Figure 24). In James 5:9/6-10, 1243 reads variant c: κατ’ ἀλλήλων ἀδελφοί, 01 has the same with slightly different orthography: κατὰ ἀλλήλων ἀδελφοί. Compared to variant a of the ancestors A, 03, 025 (ἀδελφοί κατ’ ἀλλήλων) this is a reversal of word order, which could have independently
Problems of a highly contaminated tradition
emerged several times. In James 5:12/40 (variant d) 01 (hand 1) and 1243, like several witnesses, change the James text (variant a, the reading of the ancestors of 1243) into the much better known parallel in Matthew 5:37, a variant which is not connective. . Cf. Aland, Aland, Mink, and Wachtel (1997: 28). . Cf. Blass and Debrunner (2001) §442, especially Note 14. . Cf. Aland, Aland, Mink, and Wachtel (2000: 22* Note 4). . The condition is that d has the initial text. If a is regarded as the initial text, the problem is the same: there would be no potential ancestor of 03 with variant d if one derives c from d. . However, an optimal substemma in the case of P23 cannot be established, as there is a large number of equally good hypotheses. . 01 has variant b in James 1:17/38. 03 has variant b in James 1:11/44. P23 in both cases has variant a. . The graph might be simplified as a result, by attempting to link 01 or 03 directly to P23, even though there is no direction of textual flow. Such a decision might, however, have far-reaching consequences. In this case, it would not only be decisive for an immediate and directed stemmatic connection whether a directed textual flow can be detected between two witnesses, but also whether the variants which are not in accordance with the direction of the textual flow are still needed for the construction of a stemma. It is better to postpone such simplifications until the consequences for the basics of the method and the construction of the global stemma are clear. . 04 is rather badly fragmented (482 out of 761 places of variantion are extant), cf. paragraph 9, so it is impossible to conjecture what the result would be, if the complete text would have survived. In the context of the principles of this procedure, however, this is not important. . James 1:18/26-28 (variant b), 1:20/12-14 (variant b), 1:22/14-16 (variant b), 1:26/2-4 (variant b), 2:13/20 (variant b), 2:26/27 (variant b), 3:4/32-42 (variant b). . James 2:14/2-10 (variant c), 2:16/42-46 (variant b). . James 2:15/3 (variant c), 2:18/24-34 (variant b), 2:19/8-14 (variant e). . At 2 out of these 3 places 1243, an ancestor in the substemma of 04, even reads the same variant as 04: James 2:18/24-34 (variant b), 2:19/8-14 (variant e). But 1243 is not an ancestor of 1175. . James 2:15/3 variant c. . Witness B is not presented here, as it is not part of the circle. B has only prior variants. . In James I have not yet found a case in point where, purely as the result of the enrichment of a branch of the tradition with older variants, such a circle actually materialises in the construction of a group of substemmata. I am still expecting this to happen, as the problem arises in diagrams representing textual flows like in Figure 17, but with a larger range and taking into account potential ancestors with lower levels of probability. . Cf. paragraph 5.3. . If the local and the global textual flows do not correspond in this way, the global stemma is falsified. Cf. paragraph 4.6.
Gerd Mink . In James there are 1723 genealogical relationships between variants. 209 of these permit indirect relationships, as they determine source variants of source variants. The number of witnesses concerned by this is relatively small, however. A pair of witnesses can on average be compared at 641 places. In only 4.5 instances on average this does not result in direct genealogical relationships between variants of a pair. 697 places on average are comparable if fragments are excluded which are only comparable at 50 places at most. In that case 4.9 places on average do not produce direct genealogical relationships. . The direction is determined by the values found in Figure 23 in the xausy and yausx fields. For 1739 the ratio of the values is 35:32. This implies a predominant textual flow from 1739 towards 1243. If only Chapters 1–3 are taken as a basis, the ratio is 14:19, so the textual flow changes direction. . This does not mean that 1243 becomes an ancestor in an optimal substemma for Chapters 1–3, as the textual flow from 1243 towards 1739 is included in the textual flow from A towards 1739 and from 03 towards 1739. . Instead of 31:30 (in Figure 35) the ratio is now 18:21. . Cf. for the concept ‘stability of textual flow’ also paragraph 6. . Cf. paragraphs 8 and 9 and Figure 43. . A section in a stemmatic graph rather creates the possibility of adding information to the edges. The values displayed are typical for the top of the stemma: the percentage of agreements is not particularly high. The unusual role of 03 becomes clearer through the figures. The number of posterior variants of the ancestors compared to the prior ones indicates the relative quality of the edges. . For instance, in the method discussed the fact that there is one initial text may be an undesired artefact in some other traditions. Another (negative) artefact is the fact that a relationship in which, as a result of contamination, an immediate descendant acquired more prior variants than one of the immediate ancestors would not be detected. In this case descendant and ancestor may even change places.
References Aland, B. (2000). “Die editio critica maior des Neuen Testaments. Ihre Anlage, ihre Aufgabe, die neu entwickelten Methoden der Textkritik”. Journal of Biblical Text Research, 7, 7–23. Aland, B., K. Aland, G. Mink, & K. Wachtel (Eds.). (1997). Novum Testamentum Graecum, Editio Critica Maior, ed. by Institute for New Testament Textual Research. Vol. IV, Catholic Letters, Installment 1, James. Stuttgart: Deutsche Bibelgesellschaft. —— (2000). Novum Testamentum Graecum, Editio Critica Maior, ed. by Institute for New Testament Textual Research. Vol. IV, Catholic Letters, Installment 2, The Letters of Peter. Stuttgart: Deutsche Bibelgesellschaft. —— (2003). Novum Testamentum Graecum, Editio Critica Maior, ed. by Institute for New Testament Textual Research. Vol. IV, Catholic Letters, Installment 3, The First Letter of John. Stuttgart: Deutsche Bibelgesellschaft.
Problems of a highly contaminated tradition
Aland, K. et al. (Eds.). (1987). Text und Textwert der griechischen Handschriften des Neuen Testaments, Bd. 1. Die Katholischen Briefe. ANTT 9–11. Berlin, New York: De Gruyter. —— (1991). Text und Textwert der griechischen Handschriften des Neuen Testaments, Bd. 2. Die Paulinischen Briefe. ANTT 16–19. Berlin, New York: De Gruyter. —— (1993). Text und Textwert der griechischen Handschriften des Neuen Testaments, Bd. 3. Die Apostelgeschichte. ANTT 20–21. Berlin, New York: De Gruyter. —— (1998–1999). Text und Textwert der griechischen Handschriften des Neuen Testaments, Bd. 4. Die synoptischen Evangelien. ANTT 26, 28, 30. Berlin, New York: De Gruyter. Blass, F. & A. Debrunner (2001). Grammatik des neutestamentlichen Griechisch. Bearbeitet von Friedrich Rehkopf (18th edition). Göttingen: Vandenhoek & Ruprecht. Metzger, B. M. (1971). A Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament. New York: United Bible Societies. Mink, G. (1993). “Eine umfassende Genealogie der neutestamentlichen Überlieferung.“ New Testament Studies, 39, 481–499. —— (2000). “Editing and Genealogical Studies: the New Testament”. Literary and Linguistic Computing, 15, 51–56. —— (2002). “Kohärenzbasierte Genealogische Methode – Worum geht es?” . —— (2003). “Was verändert sich in der Textkritik durch die Beachtung genealogischer Kohärenz?”. In W. Weren & D.-A. Koch (Eds.), New Developments in Textual Criticism: New Testament, Early-Christian and Jewish Literature (pp. 39–68). STAR 8. Assen: Royal van Gorcum. Salemans, B. J. P. (2000). Building Stemmata with the Computer in a Cladistic, NeoLachmannian, Way. Nijmegen: Nijmegen University Press. Spencer, M., K. Wachtel, & C. J. Howe (2002). “The Greek Vorlage of the Syra Harclensis: A Comparative Study on Method in Exploring Textual Genealogy”. TC: A Journal of Biblical Textual Criticism 7. .
Kinds of variants in the manuscript tradition of the Greek New Testament Klaus Wachtel Westfälische Wilhelms-Universität, Münster
.
Introduction
One problem which editors of the Greek New Testament have to face is the large number of manuscripts which transmitted the text from antiquity to the age of printing. For the first installment of the Münster Editio Critica Maior (ECM)1 we had to deal with a total of 553 complete or fragmentary manuscripts. For the Gospels, this number is even three to four times larger. A solution to this problem is offered by an outstanding feature of rich manuscript traditions of antique texts in general: most of the manuscripts are very much alike. Before we decided which manuscripts to collate in full for the ECM, all of them had been tested by probe collations in 98 units of variation in the seven Catholic Letters.2 We could exclude more than two thirds of the manuscripts available, because with few exceptions they witness to the late medieval Byzantine text, the Greek Vulgate or Koine. The manuscript basis of the ECM as well as that of Gerd Mink’s study in the present volume is a selection of 164 complete or fragmentary manuscripts. The Byzantine text itself is represented in the edition by seven manuscripts which share the majority readings at the 98 test passages with a rate of nearly or actually 100 percent.3 I am going to deal first with the variants which distinguish the late Byzantine from earlier textforms and, secondly, with variations which occur within the Byzantine tradition. The first part aims at a revised assessment of the late Byzantine textform, the second at a better documentation of the Byzantine textform itself: one which would not simply have to rely on an admittedly arbitrary rate of agreements with the majority text, which we set at 90% for the Catholic Letters.
Klaus Wachtel
It may be useful to define the terms ‘Majority Text’ and ‘Byzantine Text’ at this point. ‘Majority Text’ is a merely quantitative term while ‘Byzantine Text’ is a historical and text-critical term. The Majority Text consists of the majority readings and passages that have been transmitted without substantial variation. A majority reading is a variant attested to by the majority of extant Greek manuscripts. As a rule, such a reading is attested to by the oldest and best as well as by the largest number of medieval manuscripts. Normally, there is little reason to doubt that it is also the original reading. Yet the Byzantine Text is characterised by those majority readings which differ from the supposedly original text and additionally by those readings which result from a division of the main stream into two and, sometimes, three branches. The branching in the main stream of the manuscript tradition allows the Byzantine and Majority texts to be clearly distinguished. Moreover, it allows us to understand why, for example, two manuscripts that agree with the Majority Text at a rate of about 90%, can still differ from each other at 20% of the variants in question. It should be possible to make use of these differences to come to grips with the problem of an adequate representation of the so-called Byzantine subgroups. I shall return to this point later. But for now some remarks about the features of the main stream are in order.
. The late Byzantine text of the New Testament4 Certain kinds of variants are regarded as typical of the Byzantine text. In the first place there are those variants which enhance the pragmatism of the text. Insertions of particles and pronouns which join sentences or improve their inner structure occur very often. They make it easier to read the text and appear to be meant to avoid any misunderstanding. Forms, word-order, and the wording itself are changed to the same effect. Although there are cases of Byzantine omissions, this textform is considerably longer than older textforms. In many places it seems that a striving for clarity and completeness motivated the rise and dissemination of Byzantine readings. Moreover, we find many harmonisations with the closer or wider context. The wording of the synoptic Gospels is assimilated and quotations from the Old or New Testaments are rendered more precisely. Nevertheless, although there is abundant variation, it is rare for such interpolations to change the meaning of the text considerably. As a rule they only emphasise what the text says in older text forms as well. Are these variants intentional changes? Might they even be regarded as traces of an overall revision of the text in the third or the beginning of the
Kinds of variants in the Greek New Testament
fourth centuries? This stance was taken by eminent New Testament scholars in the past and is still held by some.5 I think we can derive persuasive arguments against this theory from the nature of the variants found in the Byzantine text as compared with older text-forms: First, the changes are inconsistent. There are many places where there is no smoothing to improve the coherence of the text. I am thinking of some difficult passages in Paul, for example. On the other hand, one sometimes finds an obviously intentional change close to a very similar instance which has been left untouched. This may be demonstrated by the following example. In the second chapter of Luke, the infant Jesus is hailed as the coming salvation by Simeon, a man inspired by the Spirit. According to the oldest and best manuscripts, “his father and mother marvelled at what was said about him” (Lk 2:33). The majority of the Greek as well as Latin, Syriac and Coptic manuscripts have “Joseph” instead of “his father”. For obvious reasons, one may think – wasn’t Jesus born of a virgin? Did he not say that his father is in heaven? Might this variant not be classified as an “orthodox corruption of scripture”, a term used by Bart Ehrman in his celebrated study of the same title (Ehrman 1993)? Similarly, it is said in Lk 2:43 that Jesus’ parents did not know that he was with the teachers in the temple, whereas the majority of witnesses read that “Joseph and his mother” did not know where he was. But between these passages there is another where Joseph and Mary are called “his parents” (Lk 2:41) almost unanimously, and at 2:48 Mary says to Jesus, according to all but a few witnesses, “Your father and I have been looking for you anxiously”. This inconsistency, which can be observed in many more instances, excludes orthodoxy as the conscious motive behind the variants that distinguish the Byzantine from older text-forms. If we study the kinds of variants found in our oldest and best manuscripts, we will observe that the characteristics of supposedly typically Byzantine readings occur in these, too, and moreover in each and every manuscript. This means that such readings are not typical of the Byzantine text but of manuscript traditions in general. A scribe occasionally does not write what he reads in the exemplar, but what he understands the text to mean instead. Hence we frequently find what may be called scilicet variants. They normally result in an interchange of synonyms. The replacement of “his father” with “Joseph” in the above example is a variant of this kind, too. The scribe may very well have been subliminally puzzled by the wording of the text he was copying, and his interpretation crept into the text. The oldest Greek manuscript witnessing to this variant is from the 5th century, but there are many clearly secondary majority readings found in the earliest witnesses. Defenders of the general originality of the Majority Text have tried to strengthen their case by
Klaus Wachtel
listing single majority readings attested by early papyri. However, these readings demonstrate neither the early provenance of the Majority Text nor its originality. Rather, they demonstrate only the early genesis of many of the majority readings and the susceptibility of scribes to what Eduard Schwartz called “half-conscious trivialisation”.6 Yet on the other hand, there are many atypical Byzantine readings, i.e. majority readings which by no means smooth out the text but instead render it more difficult or seemingly distorted by obvious scribal errors. A majority reading from the letter of James serves as an example. Near the end of the letter (4:13f.), the author exhorts those striving for worldly gain: “Come now, you who say, today or tomorrow we will go to that town and spend a year there and trade and get gain, you who do not know what will be tomorrow, what your life will be like, for you are [ἔστε] a vapour appearing for a little while ...”.7 The majority reading here is “for there will be [ἔσται] a vapour for a little while”, or, referring to life, “it will be [ἔσται] a vapour for a little while”. This is an obvious scribal slip with an equally obvious reason: interchange of the diphthong -αιand the vowel -7-, both of which have the sound [e] in later Greek. Finally it has to be taken into account that there is evidence to show that the distinctive readings of the Koine text accumulated in stages (cp. Wachtel 1995: 180–198). It is probable that the last, decisive step to standardisation was the change to minuscule production in the ninth century. It was for this purpose that archetypes of many manuscript traditions of Greek literature were produced. For the Greek New Testament, this was the text used and to be used in liturgy and theological study. There can be little doubt that the Byzantine text is distinguished from the original text by many readings. There seems to be a large gap between the socalled Byzantine texttype and textforms preserved in manuscripts from the 3rd to 4th centuries if we focus on the variants attested to by the mass of younger manuscripts against the noble few. In recent times, editors of the Greek New Testament have striven for a reconstruction of the original text according to those old and trustworthy witnesses and have shunned Erasmus’ Textus Receptus, which made the Byzantine text dominate printed editions of the Greek New Testament for three centuries. But if we take the text of the Nestle-Aland edition (NA 27), which is most commonly used for scholarly purposes today, as a reasonably good approximation to the original text, and calculate the distance of each manuscript from this text by counting agreements with and differences from it, we find that pure Byzantine manuscripts come closer to the ‘original text’ than many older documents and their descendants. This has motivated a new interest in the Byzantine text. As editors of the Greek NT, we take it more
Kinds of variants in the Greek New Testament
seriously in all cases that do not show clear signs of scribal error. It is indeed worthwhile to ask which “lines of textual tradition ... fed into the tenth and eleventh centuries”, as did Frederik Wisse in developing the Claremont Profile Method for classifying and evaluating manuscript evidence (Wisse 1982: 5).
. Group readings of Koine manuscripts Due to the large number of extant manuscripts and the fact that most of them witness to the Byzantine text, a New Testament editor’s first task is the determination of three classes of manuscripts: 1. those witnessing to non-Byzantine texts, which probably represent older text-forms; 2. those witnessing to the Byzantine text, of which as many as possible will be eliminated from the list of witnesses that should be included in the edition; and 3. those suitable for representing the Byzantine Codices in the edition. In the following I am going to deal with the last of these points. The question is, which manuscripts are suited to serve as representatives of the Byzantine text in a more discriminating and not merely quantitative manner. I shall use test collations of 1,785 manuscripts for this. These collations were done at 153 short passages in the Gospel of John as a first step towards a future critical edition of this writing. The results were entered into a database. I shall use these results to mark out Byzantine groups for the purpose of finding which manuscripts are typical of the main varieties of the Byzantine text. Such groups may provisionally be defined as sharing more readings with each other than with the majority text. Not all kinds of readings are suited for this evaluation. Above all it is necessary to distinguish between variants and mere readings. A reading is the generic term for the wording of a passage by which a manuscript is distinguished from one or more or from all other manuscripts. A variant is defined as one of at least two readings of the same textual unit which is grammatically correct and logically possible. A reading which does not fulfil these criteria is an error. This means that the manuscript will be treated as witnessing defectively to the variant rendered. Like errors, orthographically or morphologically equivalent forms of the same variant are not classed as textual differences.
Klaus Wachtel
Groups of manuscripts as shown below in the extract from the table of manuscript groupings were determined by the following procedures and qualifications: 1. For each pair of manuscripts which share at least one reading apart from the majority text, the total numbers of agreements including and excluding the majority readings were calculated. This was done by a program which compared their patterns of variants at the 153 test passages. 2. Two manuscripts qualified as members of a group if the percentage of their mutual agreements was greater than the percentage of the readings that one or both of them shared with the majority. 3. The degrees of agreement reached by a manuscript as compared to others were classified. Only those manuscripts which showed at least a third-rate degree of agreement with the base manuscript were included in a group.8 4. If the condition under point 2 was met, but the percentage of agreements apart from the majority text was less than 50%, the respective manuscripts were regarded as weakly related. Manuscripts with such rates of agreement are found in many groups defined by the condition under point 2. This sifting procedure resulted in 1,125 groupings like those shown in the extract. Most of them consist of between two and ten manuscripts, and in the realm of the Koine it is not uncommon for some of the manuscripts to agree at a rate of 100 percent. Such manuscripts are very likely to have been copied from a common exemplar, which may have survived as one of the group members. The biggest clear-cut Byzantine group was named Kr by Hermann von Soden, who discovered it (Soden 1911: (I.2) 757–765). The “K” means Koine, the “r” recension. It is a diligently made manuscript edition which shows the degree of perfection that could be achieved by scribes. There are 40 codices containing the gospel of John which witness to this edition without any deviation at the 153 test passages. The group is distinguished from the majority by four readings that, while supported by Kr , are usually supported by considerably more manuscripts besides. The lowest number of witnesses for one of the Kr readings is 272, the highest 367. This indicates that the editor(s) made deliberate decisions where they knew of variants. There are four group readings of Kr at the test passages, but they are not distinctive readings in the proper sense of the word, as they are shared by manuscripts belonging to other groups. This is the rule with manuscripts which have such a large share of majority readings. Thus it is clear that the starting point for an inquiry into the genealogical background of Kr must be the pattern of variants distinguishing the group from
Kinds of variants in the Greek New Testament
Table 1. Extract from the table of manuscript groupings ms MT 4 8
10
11
13
14
cms dg n
90.8% 973 2 97.4% 65 2 774 1 1168 3 1514 1 90.8% 342 1 895 2 1091 2 1194 2 1517 2 2676 3 248 2 96.1% 1212 2 570 1 1207 1 200 2 944 2 905 2 1444 2 188 2 1179 3 1351 2 2682 2 29 3 148 3 75.7% 543 2 828 3 788 3 346 2 98.7% 140 1 1343 1 2224 1 2522 1 95 1 405 1 123 2 208 2 1080 2 1191 2 1225 1 1585 1
1 8 2 1 3 48 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 3 3 2 3 1 3 1 1 14 131 3 2 1 1 1 1 6 6 6 6 6 20 10 6 10 10 11 9
agr1
agr2
92% (129/141) 98% (150/153) 98% (150/153) 98% (150/153) 98% (150/153) 100% (12/12) 99% (151/153) 98% (150/153) 98% (150/153) 96% (145/151) 96% (142/148) 93% (142/152) 99% (152/153) 99% (151/152) 99% (150/151) 99% (150/152) 99% (150/152) 99% (149/151) 99% (148/150) 98% (150/153) 98% (150/153) 98% (47/48) 97% (31/32) 97% (147/152) 96% (129/134) 93% (119/128) 91% (138/152) 89% (125/140) 89% (73/82) 100% (153/153) 100% (153/153) 100% (153/153) 100% (153/153) 100% (150/150) 100% (106/106) 99% (152/153) 99% (152/153) 99% (152/153) 99% (152/153) 99% (152/153) 99% (152/153)
67% (2/3) 100% (1/1) 100% (1/1) 67% (2/3) 100% (2/2) 100% (1/1) 100% (14/14) 92% (12/13) 92% (12/13) 77% (10/13) 91% (10/11) 100% (9/9) 100% (5/5) 100% (5/5) 100% (6/6) 100% (6/6) 100% (5/5) 100% (6/6) 100% (4/4) 100% (5/5) 100% (4/4) 100% (1/1) 100% (1/1) 100% (4/4) 100% (5/5) 80% (20/25) 79% (26/33) 89% (23/26) 87% (13/15) 100% (2/2) 100% (2/2) 100% (2/2) 100% (2/2) 100% (2/2) 100% (1/1) 100% (2/2) 100% (2/2) 100% (2/2) 100% (1/1) 100% (2/2) 100% (1/1)
ms: manuscript MT: percentage of agreements with the majority text cms: compared manuscript dg: degree of agreement reached by the compared manuscript n: number of manuscripts for which the same degree of agreement is reached by the compared manuscript agr1: percentage and number of agreements proportional to the number of shared test passages including majority readings agr2: percentage and number of agreements proportional to the number of shared test passages excluding majority readings Examples For manuscript 4 (ms, first line) there is only one manuscript which agrees more frequently with it than with the majority text: manuscript 973 (cms). The figures in agr1 show that the two manuscripts agree at a rate of 92% or in 129 of the 141 test passages they share including the majority readings. According to agr2, 4 and 973 agree at a rate of 67% or in 2 of the 3 test passages they share apart from the majority readings. According to the entry in dg, this is only the second best degree of agreement reached by 973. The entry in n shows that 4 is the only manuscript which 973 agrees with at the same degree.
Klaus Wachtel
Table 1. (continued) ms MT
cms
2509 584 1058 15 93.5% 2562 1439 1163 53 902 2374 2502 18 97.4% 35 55 128 201 479 480 645 696 769 789 867 928 955 1023 1072 1117 1147 1339 1401 1493 1496 1550 1560 1584
dg n
agr1
agr2
2 2 2 1 2 1 3 3 2 2 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
99% (152/153) 99% (151/152) 99% (104/105) 99% (151/153) 98% (149/152) 98% (145/148) 95% (146/153) 95% (146/153) 95% (143/151) 94% (141/150) 100% (153/153) 100% (153/153) 100% (153/153) 100% (153/153) 100% (153/153) 100% (153/153) 100% (153/153) 100% (153/153) 100% (153/153) 100% (153/153) 100% (153/153) 100% (153/153) 100% (153/153) 100% (153/153) 100% (153/153) 100% (153/153) 100% (153/153) 100% (153/153) 100% (153/153) 100% (153/153) 100% (153/153) 100% (153/153) 100% (153/153) 100% (153/153)
100% (1/1) 100% (2/2) 100% (2/2) 100% (8/8) 90% (9/10) 90% (9/10) 75% (6/8) 86% (6/7) 100% (4/4) 100% (2/2) 100% (4/4) 100% (4/4) 100% (4/4) 100% (4/4) 100% (4/4) 100% (4/4) 100% (4/4) 100% (4/4) 100% (4/4) 100% (4/4) 100% (4/4) 100% (4/4) 100% (4/4) 100% (4/4) 100% (4/4) 100% (4/4) 100% (4/4) 100% (4/4) 100% (4/4) 100% (4/4) 100% (4/4) 100% (4/4) 100% (4/4) 100% (4/4)
10 10 15 1 1 1 1 1 1 2 40 40 40 40 40 40 40 40 40 40 40 40 40 40 40 40 40 40 40 40 40 40 40 40
This means that 4 and 973 are only weakly related. But as there is no other manuscript which comes closer to 4, we might still start investigating which non-majority readings connect the two manuscripts, if we were interested in the relations of ms. 4 with the varieties of the Byzantine text. We might then look at the manuscripts to which 4 is related by 973 (i.e. the closer relatives of 973 not shown in the present extract). The last manuscript in this extract, 18, which agrees with the majority text at a rate of 97,4% is shown to have many relatives which share more readings with it than with the majority. The first compared manuscript, 35, is one out of 40 which agree at the same rate of 100% with ms. 18, including or excluding the majority readings. Manuscripts 4 and 18 represent extremes. Most groupings consist of between two and ten manuscripts.
the majority text (“MT” in Table 1). The total number of Byzantine groups sharing at least one reading with Kr apart from the majority is 391. 57 of them are connected by patterns of variants which include the complete Kr pattern. The total number of manuscripts involved is 127. The following table shows the patterns coming closest to that of Kr , being represented by minuscule 18.9
Kinds of variants in the Greek New Testament
Table 2. Ms.
% MT
Group Pattern
18 83
97.4 96.7
141 147
96.7 96.1
155
96.1
167
95.4
27:3,
32:2,
189
93.5
12:3,
32:2, 39:4
246 386
97.4 96.7
32:2, 32:2,
394
96.7
32:2,
547
96.6
32:2,
553
96.7
32:2,
685
96.7
32:2,
55:5, 69:3, 55:5, 76:2, 55:5,
689
96.1
32:2,
55:5,
763
96.7
32:2,
781
96.7
797
95.4
32:2, 54:8, 32:2, 32:2B, 54:7,
16:1/2B, 26:3,
32:2, 32:2,
55:5, 55:5,
32:2, 32:2,
55:5, 55:5, 69:3, 55:5, 99,2, 55:5, 60:3, 66:4, 55:5, 69:3, 89:4, 55:5, 55:5, 96,3, 55:5,
32:2,
9:2, 12:3,
18:2,
100:4, 100:4, 127:9, 100:4, 100:4B, 100:4, 151:3 100:4B,
150:4 150:4 150:4 150:4 150:4 150:4
100:4B, 132:3, 134:3, 100:4B, 100:4,
150:4
100:4B, 118:3, 100:4,
150:4
100:4,
150:4
100:4B, 100:4B,
150:4, 152:5 150:4
55:5, 76:2, 55:5,
100:4B,
150:4
100:4B,
150:4
55:5, 69:1/2D
100:4,
150:4
150:4 150:4
150:4
The first line shows that ms. 18, a minuscule from the 14th century which represents von Soden’s Kr in a particularly pure form, agrees with the majority text at a rate of 97,4% of the test passages. The group pattern consists of variants at the test passages that distinguish the group from the majority (e.g. 32:2 is test passage 32, variant 2). Exactly the same pattern is shared by 41 manuscripts, 40 of which are not shown in the figure. The second manuscript
Klaus Wachtel
in the figure, ms. 83, has all the readings of the Kr pattern, but differs from the majority at one more test passage (127:9). The mss. which follow in the table all include the Kr pattern, but all differ from the majority at one or more additional test passages. (Note that in ms. 246 the difference is but a subvariant of 100:4, indicated by the “B”.) It can hardly be due to chance that all of the manuscripts attesting the Kr pattern as a part of their own are found to agree with the majority at more than 92% of the test passages. We have witnesses more remote from the majority text for each single reading of the pattern, but not for the pattern itself. This again indicates that the text of Kr was carefully edited. The editors wanted the new text as much as possible to be in concordance with those in official use, thus introducing a new standard. Our chance to trace the genealogy of Kr and the groups containing its characteristic pattern is not very good. As a rule the readings of the patterns including the one of Kr are attested to by relatively strong minorities of manuscripts and were occasionally picked up by scribes. But our test collations are not a suitable basis for genealogical analysis anyway. This is because the system of test passages cannot serve as a model for the entire text. They were selected in the first place for the purpose of distinguishing witnesses of the Byzantine text from those of other textforms. Yet the present study shows that we can go one step further. The patterns of variants at the test passages allow a more discriminating selection of Koine manuscripts, which should be subjected to full collations and then to genealogical methods as shown by Gerd Mink in the present volume.
. Conclusions 1. There are 1484 manuscripts containing the Gospel of John, which agree with the majority at more than 90 percent of the test passages. The remaining 301 manuscripts are certainly not all candidates for the apparatus of a future Editio Maior of the Gospel of John, because many of the differences from the majority may turn out to be distortions of majority readings. This has to be worked out. 2. The Koine group Kr was identified by means of a distinctive pattern of variants at four test passages. This means that the large number of manuscripts which deviate from the majority in between one to all four of the Kr variants will be well represented by a single Kr manuscript.
Kinds of variants in the Greek New Testament
3. As a clearly defined group Kr can serve as a starting point for further clarification of the group structure of the Koine manuscripts. One question will be whether manuscripts which include the full Kr pattern are more likely to be predecessors or descendants of Kr . Another promising investigation will deal with those Koine manuscripts which share no reading with Kr at the test passages. 4. One basic conclusion may be drawn as to the usefulness of test collation for determining manuscripts for further study: it is demonstrated by the fact that the outlines of the structure of the tradition can be drawn on that basis.
Notes . ECM IV 1997/2003. . Text und Textwert 1989–1999. . Cp. ECM IV, 1: 11*–12*; ECM IV, 2: B8–B9. . This chapter contains statements and conclusions which are explained on a larger scale in Wachtel (1995). . Cp. e.g. Westcott/Hort (1882: 132–139); Soden (1911: (I.2) 707–713); Metzger (1992: 212). . Schwartz (1909: CXLVI) (“halbbewusste Trivialisierung”). . Translation quoted from the Revised Standard Version (2 1971). . A first-rate degree of agreement means that the manuscript being compared does not reach a higher percentage of agreements with any other manuscript. If it has a second-rate degree of agreement, there is at least one manuscript which comes closer to it than the one which the second-rate degree applies to. . [32:2 – 4,1 – ‘Jesus’ instead of ‘the Lord’. Context is “Now when the Lord knew that the Pharisees had heard that Jesus was making and baptizing more disciples than John, although Jesus himself did not baptize...”. It is quite likely that original ‘Jesus’ was replaced with ‘the Lord’ here to avoid the clumsy repetition of ‘Jesus’, the more so because ‘the Lord’ was increasingly used in reference to Jesus. There is a relatively strong fraction of 367 witnesses which share the reading of Kr , some of them ranging among the oldest and best. [55:5 – 5,44 – replacement of ‘from one another’ by ‘from men’ in the sentence “How can you believe, who receive glory from one another and do not seek the glory that comes from the only God.” The reading of Kr makes for a more obvious opposition to ‘the only God’. The total number of witnesses is 381 here. [100:4 – 7,53–8,11 – This passage refers to the story of the adulteress, who is brought to Jesus by the scribes and Pharisees, and who finds forgiveness with him. There is overwhelming evidence for the non-Johannine origin of the pericope (cp. Metzger 1994: 187–189), which is found in the majority of witnesses. Kr has it but obelises it, which is an obvious trace of editorial work. The total number of witnesses for this obelization is 272. [150:4 – 10,39 – “...again they tried to arrest him.” The variant of
Klaus Wachtel
Kr is a transposition which does not affect the meaning at all. Here we have branches of 302 witnesses for the reading of Kr and 439 for still another word-order.
References ECM IV (1997/2000). Novum Testamentum Graecum, Editio critica maior, IV: Die Katholischen Briefe, hg. von B. Aland, K. Aland †, G. Mink, K. Wachtel. Part 1: Text, Part 2: Begleitende Materialien. 1. Lieferung 1997: Der Jakobusbrief, 2. Lieferung 2000: Die Petrusbriefe, 3. Lieferung 2003: Der Erste Johannesbrief. Stuttgart. Ehrman, B. D. (1993). The Orthodox Corruption of Scripture: The Effect of Early Christological Controversies on the Text of the New Testament. New York/Oxford. Metzger, B. M. (1992). The Text of the New Testament, its Transmission, Corruption and Restoration. Oxford 1964 (3 1992). Metzger, B. M. (1994). A Textual Commentary on the Greek Text of the New Testament. Stuttgart 1971 (2 1994). NA27. Novum Testamentum Graece, post Eberhard et Erwin Nestle editione vicesima septima revisa communiter ediderunt B. et K. Aland, J. Karavidopoulos, C. M. Martini, B. M. Metzger, A. Wikgren. Stuttgart 1993. Schwartz, E. (1909). “Prolegomena zu Eusebs Kirchengeschichte”. Eusebius Werke II, 3. Teil: Einleitungen, Übersichten und Register (GCS 9,3) Leipzig. Soden, H. Frhr. v. (1911). Die Schriften des Neuen Testaments in ihrer ältesten erreichbaren Textgestalt. Bd. I, 1–3 Untersuchungen, Göttingen 21911; Bd. II Text und Apparat. Göttingen 1913. Text und Textwert (1989–1999). Text und Textwert der griechischen Handschriften des Neuen Testaments, ed. by Kurt Aland et al. Vol. 1: Die Katholischen Briefe (1987), vol. 2: Die Paulinischen Briefe (1991), vol. 3: Die Apostelgeschichte (1993), vol. 4: Die synoptischen Evangelien (1998/1999). Berlin. Wachtel, K. (1995). Der Byzantinische Text der Katholischen Briefe: Eine Untersuchung zur Entstehung der Koine des Neuen Testaments. Berlin. Westcott, B. F. & F. J. A. Hort (1882). The New Testament in the Original Greek. Bd. I Text, Bd. II Introduction. Cambridge/London 1881 and 1882. Wisse, F. (1982). The Profile Method for the Classification and Evaluation of Manuscript Evidence as Applied to the Continuous Greek Text of the Gospel of Luke. Studies and Documents 44. Grand Rapids, Michigan.
How shock waves revealed successive contamination A cardiogram of early sixteenth-century printed Dutch Bibles A. A. den Hollander Universiteit van Amsterdam / Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam
. Introduction1 One of the complex problems a philologist has to deal with is a text tradition that is so entangled, that its transmission cannot be assessed in a straightforward way. Such a text tradition is generally considered to be ‘contaminated’: some or all of its members present a text not derived from one single exemplar, but composed from several predecessors. Until recently scholars had no aids in trying to handle this problem.2 In their article in the first volume of Studies of Stemmatology, however, E. Wattel and M. J. P. van Mulken offered an instrument, which could deal at least partially with the phenomenon of contamination (Wattel & Van Mulken 1996). In their contribution they distinguished three types of contamination: 1. simultaneous: several exemplars being used at the same time; 2. successive: one exemplar being used for one part of a text, another for a second part, and another (or again the first) for yet another part of the text, etc.; 3. incidental: one exemplar being used for the text, and other exemplars used to verify or improve the text through local interventions. The instrument Wattel and Van Mulken offered helps to trace the second type of contamination: successive contamination. In addition, they suggest a procedure for handling stemmatological problems caused by this phenomenon. Suc-
A. A. den Hollander
cessive contamination makes it impossible to draw one stemma which correctly represents the genealogical relationships throughout the entire text. Stemmas can only be drawn for parts of the text and will only represent the relationships in those particular parts. It is, therefore, advisable to split up the text into sections, for each of which one valid stemma can be drawn. For making sound text divisions in a (successively) contaminated text, Wattel and Van Mulken suggest using a so-called cardiogram of the text tradition. In this article I intend to show how a cardiogram has actually been of great help in tracing successive contamination in the text tradition of the Dutch bibles printed between 1522 and 1545. On the basis of a cardiogram the text tradition could be split up into parts, each of which corresponded with logical units: one or more bible books. It turned out that the bible text in these successive units had indeed been derived from various sources.
.
The cardiogram of a text tradition
A cardiogram is a graphic presentation of the distances between text witnesses (manuscripts/editions). In a text tradition with unambiguous relationships, the similarity (or distance) between two witnesses will remain more or less stable. In case of successive contamination the similarity (or distance) between two witnesses will change at the point of change in relationship3 – probably dramatically. In order to find out whether and at what points in a text such changes in distances between witnesses occur, Wattel developed a distance distribution function, which records the distances between each pair of witnesses at every instance (marked by a variant) of a text tradition. The starting point in the production process of a cardiogram is the list of variants. This list of variants should have a clear data structure and should contain at least the following elements: 1. heading line – presenting the total number of lines and all the witnesses (manuscripts or editions) involved. Each witness is represented by a unique siglum; and each next line stating the following elements in a fixed order: 2. location – of the variant, e.g. number of chapter, verse or line, etc.; 3. formula – mathematical representation of the relation between witnesses; 4. readings – the various readings at a certain variation place. The following fictitious list of variants may serve as an example:
How shock waves revealed successive contamination
6 1 2.1 2.2 4
abcdefg abcd/efg ab/cd/efg abcde/fg a/bcdefg
(heading line) reading 1 / reading 2 reading 1 / reading 2 / reading 3 reading 1 / reading 2 reading 1 / reading 2
In this example the text has 6 lines, with one variant in line 1, two variants in line 2 and again one variant in line 4. Additional information may be added in other columns in the list of variants, such as a typology of variants and weight factors. A typology of variants assigns each variant to a certain type, e.g. the type “inversion of words”. Such a typology makes it possible to test which types of variants are kinship-revealing in a given text tradition, and which are not and should therefore be left out. Therefore, no decision concerning possible genealogical relevance of a certain kind of variant must be taken before the entire list of variants is completed. A weight factor may also be added to each variant. A different weight factor may be assigned to the various types of formulas, in this case concerning typology of variations, not of variants. Type 2 variations, for example, show “two competitive variant readings, which are present in precisely two true groups of text versions”;4 a true group being a group containing two or more members. Type 2 variations, which are considered to be the most important materials for the stemma, can be given a much higher weight factor than the other variation types. Again, the whole process of weighing may be changed at any time and is reversible as well. No final decision concerning possible genealogical relevance of a certain type of variation must be taken during the process of building the list of variants. After the list of variants has been established, the similarity between each pair of witnesses will be measured throughout the entire list of variants. This step will result in a list for each pair, stating whether the two do or do not share a reading. Two witnesses sharing the same reading will have a positive score (similar), two witnesses not sharing the same reading a negative score (not similar).5 When adding up all the scores of a given pair over a large number of formulas results in a positive score, it can be concluded that these witnesses correspond in most cases. When the result is a negative score, it means that the two witnesses have different readings in most formulas. Wattel defined a distribution formula, which makes it possible to visualize the ‘similarity-score’ of a pair of witnesses as a function over the entire text. The graph produced by this function fluctuates somewhere between its extreme values +100% (complete similarity) and –100% (complete dissimilarity).6 This
A. A. den Hollander
F D C B2
25
47 –2
–92
–44 –99
–39
37 –88
97
100 78
26
89 –39
23
67 –39
27
89 –39
24
89 –39
B1 A4 A3 A2 A1 total 0
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
800
900
1000 1100 1200 1300 1400 1500
Figure 1. Similarity of all mss of Charroi de Nîmes with ms B1. Horizontally: line numbers of the text; vertically: sigla of the mss; on the right: maximum and minimum values of the ‘similarity-score’; on the left: the average values.
‘similarity-graph’ clearly shows how each of the other witnesses relates to a given witness and whether any dramatic changes in relationship occur. A relationship is stable when the similarity remains stable through the entire text. A stable relationship will be visualised by a flat graph without many fluctuations. The graphs in Figure 1 show the relationships of eight manuscripts (A1–4, B2, C, D and F) of the manuscript tradition of Charroi de Nîmes with manuscript B1 of the same tradition.7 The graphs clearly show that the relationships between B1 and B2 as well as between B1 and D are stable; B1 and B2 are constantly very similar (maximum +100, minimum +78, average +97, without many fluctuations), and B1 and D very dissimilar (maximum –44, minimum –99, average –92, without many fluctuations). In this article, however, we are not interested in stable relationships. We want to know for each pair of witnesses where major changes in their relationships occur. We are, in other words, not interested in the flat parts of the ‘similarity-graphs’, indicating stable relationships, but in those parts where the graph rises or falls sharply.8 These rises and falls can be visualised in another graph – a so-called shock wave. This shock wave shows for each pair of wit-
How shock waves revealed successive contamination
F D C B2 B1 A4 A3 A2 A1 total 0
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
800
900
1000 1100 1200 1300 1400 1500
Figure 2. Shock waves of all the manuscripts of Charroi de Nîmes. Horizontally the line numbers of the text, vertically the sigla of the manuscripts.
nesses where the ‘similarity-graph’ is flat and where it fluctuates. In the case of a sharp fall or rise, the ‘shock wave’ has a high value, in the case of a stable relationship it has a low value. The minimum value of the shock wave is zero (completely flat ‘similarity-graph’), and its maximum is one (maximum fall or rise). Counting up the values from the shock waves of a given witness with all the other witnesses of a text tradition results in the ultimate shock wave of a witness. Figure 1, e.g., shows the shock wave of manuscript B1. It represents the average value of all the shock waves of pairs of manuscripts of the tradition of Charroi de Nîmes containing manuscript B1. The points where this average value graph sharply rises or falls still indicate important changes in relationships of manuscript B. They seem to occur in the vicinity of line 500, 950, and 1050. It is possible to compute shock waves of all the members of a text tradition. Figure 2 shows the shock waves of all the manuscripts of the tradition of Charroi de Nîmes. The graph at the base line gives the average value of all the shock waves.9 This graph is the shock wave of the entire text tradition of Charroi de Nîmes.
A. A. den Hollander
Figure 2 gives the heart beat – the cardiogram – of the text tradition. The points where the shock wave of the entire text tradition peaks indicate changes in relationship in the text tradition. When all the manuscripts, or at least a substantial number, peak at the same point this could well be an indication of successive contamination.10
. Early sixteenth-century printed Dutch bibles During the period 1522-1545 some eighty Dutch bible editions were published.11 Six of them had a reissue during that period, one as many as three reissues. Seventeen of these eighty-nine editions were complete bibles. Five editions contained the text of the Old Testament, or parts of it, only, and seventy-six editions the text of the New Testament, or parts of it, only. On the basis of an extended random sampling, a comparison was made of the bible text in the various editions. The similarities and differences in reading between the editions were taken up into a list of variants. Separate lists were made for the Old and the New Testament. The list of variants for the Old Testament counted 5099 variants, and for the New Testament 4573 variants. With the help of the instruments Wattel had developed two separate cardiograms were made for the Old Testament and for the New Testament. Figure 3 gives the cardiogram of the Old Testament, consisting of the shock waves of thirteen editions of (parts of) the Old Testament, leaving out the reissues; at the base line is given the shock wave of the text tradition of the Old Testament in early sixteenth-century printed Dutch bibles.12 Several observations can be made after a first glance at the cardiogram. First, observing the shock waves of the thirteen editions it is obvious that the graphs are quite flat and do not show a lot of fluctuation. There are a number of local symptoms, such as JvL1526 en DP1527 peaking sharply at line 780 – and some others peaking less at the same spot. The graphs also show a few more general phenomena, such as the fluctuations at line 213, line 1145, and line 1300. Also the shock wave of the entire tradition at the base line is quite flat, and without a great deal of fluctuation, let alone any number of significant peaks. Except for the peak at line 1145, all fluctuations could be considered as noise. However, looking into the graphs in more detail revealed that at every point where the heart beat of the text tradition at the base line fluctuated visibly, a change of relationship did indeed take place. Even points with minimal fluctuation still marked an actual change in relationship somewhere in the text tradition.13 With the aid of the heart beat the text tradition could be split up
How shock waves revealed successive contamination I II
III II
IV
V II
II VI
VII VI
VIII IV
CvR 1525 SM 1544 JvL 1527 WV 1542 JvL 1542 HPvM 1541 HvL 1538 JvL 1535 HPvM 1535 JvL 1534 WV 1533 JvL 1532 WV 1532 WV 1528 [1531] WV 1528 DP 1527 JvL 1526 HvR 1525 total 0
180
360
540
720
900
1080
1260
Figure 3. The heart beat of the Old Testament. Horizontally the line numbers (based on the list of variants), vertically the abbreviations of the various editions.14
into thirteen separate parts.15 Within these thirteen parts all the relationships remained stable. The thirteen parts all correspond with coherent text units from the Old Testament – one or more bible books16 – and for all thirteen parts separate stemmas were drawn:
A. A. den Hollander
1. Genesis, Exodus, Leviticus, Numbers, Deuteronomy 2. Joshua, Judges, Ruth, 1+2 Samuel, 1+2 Kings, 1+2 Chronicles, Ezra, Nehemiah, Esther (canonical part) 3. Esther (apocryphal part) 4. Job 5. Psalms 6. Proverbs, Ecclesiastes, Song of Solomon 7. Isaiah 8. Jeremiah, Lamentations, Baruch, Ezekiel, Daniel, Hosea, Joel, Amos, Obadiah 9. Jonah 10. Micah, Nahum, Habakkuk, Zephaniah, Haggai, Zechariah, Malachi 11. 3+4 Esdras 12. Tobith, Judith, Wisdom of Solomon, Ecclesiasticus, Daniel (apocr.) 13. 1+2 Machabees Passing from one of these thirteen parts of the Old Testament to the next always resulted in change of relationship, somewhere in the text tradition. Therefore, with each transition a new stemma was required to represent the genealogical relationships in the next part. Not all thirteen stemmas, however, were entirely different, since two or more non-successive stemmas were sometimes identical. A total number of eight different stemmas was required to represent the genealogical relationships in the entire text tradition of the Old Testament in the early sixteenth-century printed Dutch bibles.17 The process of dividing the text tradition into sections on the basis of the cardiogram drew our attention to some striking features of the text tradition of the Old Testament. Why, for example, was there a change in relationships between the books of Isaiah and Jonah? These books belong to a coherent part of the Old Testament, major and minor Prophets, respectively, in which changes in relationship were not be expected. A closer look into the part of the Prophets through study of the list of variants, and the ‘similarity graphs’ in the relevant section of the text tradition, revealed the cause of the change in relationship: various sources were used for the books of the Prophets in the 1526 Bible of the Antwerp printer Liesvelt. Jacob van Liesvelt was the first one to publish a complete bible in the Dutch language.18 His aim was to provide the Netherlands with a Dutch translation of the Luther Bible. In 1526, however, Luther had not completed his bible translation in full. He had translated the entire New Testament a few years earlier,
How shock waves revealed successive contamination
but at that time substantial parts of the Old Testament remained to be done. Luthers translation of the Prophets was not finished until the year 1534. In 1526 Luthers translations of two of the minor Prophets had been issued separately: Jonah and Habakkuk.19 Jacob van Liesvelt must have been able to lay hands on a copy of the edition of Jonah almost at once. Only a few months later, this Luther edition appeared in a Dutch translation in the Liesvelt Bible. For the other books of the Prophets, except for Isaiah, Liesvelt simply reproduced the existing Dutch translation from the 1525 edition of the Old Testament of the Antwerp printer Hans van Ruremunde (HvR1525), which explains the sudden change in relationship.20 A cardiogram was also computed for the New Testament, see Figure 4. On the basis of this cardiogram the text of the New Testament was split up into nine parts. Again all parts were coherent text units, consisting of one or more bible books.21 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9.
Matthew, Mark, Luke, John Acts Romans 1+2 Corinthians, Galatians, Ephesians, Philippians, Colossians, 1+2 Thessalonians 1+2 Timothy, Titus, Philemon Hebrews James, 1+2 Peter, 1+2+3 John Jude Revelation
A total number of eight different stemmas was necessary to represent all the various relationships for the nine sections.22 The same stemma was valid for parts (2) and (9). In this case, it was not very surprising that the same stemma was valid for these two parts. The text of most of the early printed sixteenthcentury editions of the New Testament had been derived from other existing Dutch translations. Some of the editions of the New Testament were printed and published in parts, usually one part containing the Gospels, another part all the Letters, and a third part the two remaining books Acts and Revelation. These parts were independently distributed and were, therefore, separatedly used as sources for new editions. Suppose that the text of an edition of the New Testament A went back to another existing Dutch translation. Suppose also that for the text of Acts and Revelation one of the above-mentioned separate editions was used, which gave a completely different text from the text in the existing edition. In that
A. A. den Hollander (B)
II = IX III
I
IV
V
VII VII IX = II
VI
MC 1539 AvB 1525 JvL 1523.2 JvL 1523.1 CL 1524 JvG 1525 JvL 1526 MHvH 1527 HPvM 1543 JvG 1524 JvL 1522 JvL 1523 JvG 1526.2 AvB 1523 AP 1525 AvB 1524 SM 1545 AvB 1524 WV 1529 CvR 1525 HvR 1525 CvR
1528
WV
1528
JvG 1526.1 CvR
1526
MK/GvdH
1525
DP
1523
HF
1525
total 0
40
80
120
160
200
240
280
320
360
400
Figure 4. The heart beat of the New Testament. Horizontally the line numbers (based on the list of variants), vertically the abbreviations of the various editions.23
case the shock wave of this New Testament A would peak between just before and directly after Acts as well as just before Revelation, indicating changes in relationship.24 On the basis of this shock wave the text would have to be split
How shock waves revealed successive contamination
up into four parts. The final conclusion would be that parts (1) and (3) would share one stemma, and so would parts (2) and (4).
. Conclusions 1. The cardiogram has proved to be a useful instrument for getting, at one glance, an overall picture of the genealogical relationships within the text tradition of the early sixteenth-century printed Dutch bibles. It should be stressed that this overview could be obtained on the basis of just the list of variants. 2. The cardiogram made it visible at a glance how stable the genealogical relationships within the entire text tradition were. The shock waves also clearly revealed these relationships for each of the witnesses. It should be noted, however, that the text tradition of the early sixteenth-century printed Dutch bibles is a very ‘clean’ one. Incidental contamination, for example, can obscure a clear view.25 3. By means of the cardiogram it was also possible to point out those places in the text where changes in relationship might have taken place. Further research with the benefit of the list of variants and the ‘similarity-graphs’ did in fact reveal successive contamination. As a result, the text tradition was split up into coherent parts, and for each of these a separate stemma was drawn. 4. It turned out that the coherent parts were not only genealogically coherent text units, but that these parts also yielded a profile of the actual used sources. The fact, for example, that the single book of Jonah was separated from the other books of the minor Prophets as a non-coherent part raised the question what actual source had been used for the book of Jonah. The search for a potential source of Jonah led to the conclusion that its source had been a separately issued book of Jonah. This meant that other coherent text parts, established after division on the basis of the cardiogram, might also reflect (the size of) the actual used sources. This turned out to be true, as was shown above for separately issued parts of the New Testament. The same conclusions may hold for handwritten texts. Suppose that the cardiogram of a manuscript tradition divides up a text into parts. Since we know that manuscripts were sometimes split up into quires for reproduction, our text division on the basis of the cardiogram might very well result in text parts which relate directly to the separate quires of the exemplars. In that case the
A. A. den Hollander
cardiogram could also function as a quire separator, indicating the actual size of the exemplar.
Notes . This article uses results of my earlier study (Den Hollander 1997, esp. Chapter 3: “De teksttraditie”: 127–242). . In 1957 Paul Maas uttered “Gegen die Kontamination ist kein Kraut gewachsen” (Maas 1957: 31). . See for an example Wattel and Van Mulken (1996: 107). . See for this definition and a definition of other types of variations Salemans (2000: 23– 25). See also the contributions of Salemans and Wattel in this book. . See Wattel and Van Mulken (1996: 110–111) to learn how the scores could be computed. . The shock waves show the actual extreme values of each graph, as well as the average score. . This example was derived from Wattel and Van Mulken (1996: 116). . In order to level out the graph, the maximum rise or fall between two successive measuring points is about 30%. Increase of similarity, for example, from 5% to 95% requires a path of four successive measuring points minimal. The horizontal line consists of 300 measuring points, each measuring point corresponding with 5 textlines. In this way local information is suppressed in order to correct incidental influences. . That the shock wave of manuscript D hardly fluctuates is due to the fact that D hardly ever agrees with any of the other manuscripts in the list of variants. . It is, of course, always necessary to relate these findings to the text tradition itself (such as the list of variants). . Bible editions in this context are complete bibles, individual issues of the Old and New Testaments, individually issued books of the bible and fragments. I exclude individual editions of the Psalms and editions of the lessons from the ‘epistles and gospels’, since these two genres constitute separate text traditions. The bibles printed in this period form a well-defined group, and can be considered as an indepedent text tradition. . This cardiogram already gives an impression of which editions are related and which are not. Related editions will have a similar shock wave. . The small peak at line 175 (between Numbers and Deuteronomy), however, did not refer to a change in relationship. The peak in WV1528 indicated a local phenomenon. . The abbreviations consist of the abbreviated name of the printer and the year of issue: HvR = Hans van Ruremunde; JvL = Jacob van Liesvelt; DP = Doen Pietersoen; WV = Willem Vorsterman; HPvM = Henrick Peetersen van Middelburch; HvL = Hansken van Liesvelt; SM = Steven Mierdmans; CvR = Christoffel van Ruremunde.
How shock waves revealed successive contamination . The parts covered lines (1) 0–123; (2) 219–509; (3) 515–519; (4) 525–566; (5) 572–717; (6) 723–781; (7) 787–851; (8) 857–1044; (9) 1050–1053; (10) 1059–1124; (11) 1130–1159; (12) 1165–1295; (13) 1301–1335. . Separate cardiograms can be made for each of the thirteen parts, which give a more detailed look into the interrelations; see Appendix A for the heart beat of part one of the Old Testament. . Eight different stemmas were valid for various parts: no. 1 for part (1); no. 2 for parts (2), (4), (6), and (9); no. 3 for part (3); no. 4 for parts (5) and (12); no. 5 for part (7); no. 6 for part (8); no. 7 for part (11); no. 8 for part (13). . More extensively in Den Hollander (1999). . Luthers Werke, Die Deutsche Bibel, vol. 2, 392–395. . For the book of Isaiah Liesvelt once more made use of a different source. This time he published a Dutch translation of the Latin text of Isaiah from Oecolampadius (1525) Commentary on the book of Isaiah. This Latin text was not a Vulgate text, but Oecolampadius’ own Latin translation from the Hebrew. See Den Hollander (1997: 185). . The parts covered lines (1) 0–109; (2) 115–142; (3) 148–163; (4) 169–260; (5) 266–294; (6) 300–312; (7) 318–362; (8) 368; (9) 374–395. . See for the stemmas Den Hollander (1997: 99–211). . The total number of editions had been reduced through clustering, see Den Hollander (1997: 155–157). Only the representatives of these clusters have been presented in the cardiogram. The abbreviations consist of the abbreviated name of the printer and the year of issue: HF = Hiero Fuchs; DP = Doen Pietersoen; MK/GvdH = Merten de Keyser/Govaert van der Haeghen; CvR = Christoffel van Ruremunde; JvG = Jan van Ghelen; WV = Willem Vorsterman; HvR = Hans van Ruremunde; AvB = Adriaen van Berghen; SM = Steven Mierdmans; AP = Albert Pafraet; JvL = Jacob van Liesvelt; HPvM = Henrick Peetersen van Middelburch; MHvH = Michiel Hillen van Hoochstraten; CL = Cornelis Lettersnijder; MC = Matthias Crom. . Presuming that Revelation is the final book. Otherwise the shock wave would also peak directly after Revelation, dividing the text in five parts. . See, for example, the cardiogram of the text tradition of Perceval (Figure 5) in Wattel and Van Mulken (1996: 119).
References Hollander, A. A. den (1997). De Nederlandse Bijbelvertalingen/Dutch Translations of the Bible 1522–1545. Nieuwkoop: De Graaf. Hollander, A. A. den (1999). “Dat Oude ende dat Nieuwe Testament. Jacob van Liesvelt en de nieuwe markt voor bijbels in de zestiende eeuw”. Jaarboek voor Nederlandse Boekgeschiedenis, 105–122. Leiden: Nederlandse Boekhistorische Vereniging. Luthers (D. Martin) Werke. Kritische Gesamtausgabe. Die Deutsche Bibel. 12 vols. (1906– 1961). Weimar.
A. A. den Hollander
Maas, P. (1957). Textkritik (3rd. rev. edition). Leipzig: Teubner. Salemans, B. (2000). Building Stemmas with the Computer in a Cladistic, neo-Lachmannian way. The Case of Fourteen Text Versions of Lanseloet van Denemarken (doctoral thesis). Nijmegen: Nijmegen University Press. Wattel, E. & M. J. P. van Mulken (1996). “Shock Waves in Text Traditions. Cardiograms of the Medieval Literature”. In P. van Reenen & M. J. P. van Mulken (Eds.), Studies in Stemmatology (pp. 105–121). Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
Appendix A: The heart beat of part one of the Old Testament
WV 1542 JvL 1542 HPvM 1541 HvL 1538 JvL 1535 HPvM 1535 JvL 1534 WV 1533 JvL 1532 WV 1532 WV 1528 [1531] WV 1528 DP 1527 JvL 1526 HvR 1525 total 0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
180
200
220
The manuscript tradition of the Cligés of Chrétien de Troyes A stemmatological approach Margot van Mulken Katholieke Universiteit Nijmegen
.
Introduction
In order to verify whether the proliferation of intricate relationships between manuscripts is not typical of the Perceval of Chrétien de Troyes, but at least typical of other works of the same author, I decided to examine the relationships between de manuscripts of the Cligés and to subject the manuscripts to a similar treatment as the procedure for the manuscripts of the Perceval (Van Mulken 1993). Like the Perceval, the Cligés is a complex tradition. To quote Foerster: So erklärt sich denn nur durch diesen merkwürdigen Zustand der Überlieferung die dann nicht mehr auffällige Tatsache, daß der Cligéstext jedesmal eine solch große Zahl von Kritikern gefunden hat, während andere Kristiantexte, [..] so gut wie ganz von denselben Herren Kritikern gemieden worden sind: denn hier handelt es sich um wirkliche Besserungen, und nicht um das Vorziehen einer unter zwei an sich passablen Lesarten; und es ist dazu nicht nur eine wirklich gründliche Kenntnis der Sprache, sondern auch wirklicher Scharfsinn unbedingt nötig. (Foerster 1910: lxxv)
The MS tradition of the Cligés consists of 7 more or less complete manuscripts (the fragments will be left out of consideration). In Table 1 all the manuscripts are listed, together with an approximate date attribution (based on Nixon 1993) and localization (based on Gregory & Luttrell 1993; Van Mulken 1993, 1999).
Margot van Mulken
Table 1. MS tradition Cligés Manuscript
Siglum
Date Attribution
Localisation
Tours, BM 942 Paris, BN, fr., 794 Paris, BN, fr., 1450 Paris, BN, fr., 12560
T A B C
12/13 13, 2nd q 13, 2nd q 13, mid
Paris, BN, fr., 1420 Paris, BN, fr., 1374 Paris BN, fr., 375
R S P
13, mid 13, 3rd q 13/14
Anjou Champagne North East Hand 1: East of Ile de France; Hand 2: West, Anglo-Norman Ile de France Yonne Arras
q = quarter, mid = middle
On the basis of textual differences and similarities a list of 370 variants has been established. Criteria for admittance into the list were derived from Den Hollander (1997). However, the following variants have not been included: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5.
Variants concerning a change in word order (see Van Mulken 1993) Lacunae or discrepancies in metre or prosody Variants concerning pronouns, prepositions, particles (Salemans 2000) Variants concerning prefixes (Salemans 2000) Variants concerning tense or mood (Salemans 2000)
It is important to first determine the relationships within the tradition without considering the direction of the variants (i.e. the origin of the readings), since in a first attempt the number of subjective interventions should be reduced as much as possible (in accordance with the Three Level Method, also known as Dees Method; Van Mulken 1993: 45–71). The list of variants, adapted to the guidelines published in Wattel and Van Mulken (1995), served as input to generate a table of quadruples1 and a first draft of a stemma (Figure 1). Of course, the reliability of this stemma depends on the evaluation of the philologist: a draft of a tree can always be drawn on the basis of quadruples, but the reliability rate will not always be high enough. All depends on the extent of noise the philologist is willing to accept, and the degree of inconsistency he/she is ready to allow in order to build a stemma. Some philologists insist upon the reduction of all noise, and are therefore willing to reduce the number of variants; other philologists are ready to allow for a reasonable amount of noise, since some variants may be due to parallelism (Salemans 2000; Van Mulken 1993: 29–32). In this particular case, I estimated that the first draft is far from reliable: only 103 out of the 370 variants (28%) are in concordance with the
The manuscript tradition of the Cligés of Chrétien de Troyes A
C
R
B
T
P
S
Figure 1. Draft structure Cligés, 72% of variants to be rejected
tree: a rather too large degree of inconsistency. We cannot but conclude that the Cligés is not a closed, but an open manuscript tradition. Some reputable philologists working on the Cligés were also disappointed with their trees. Compare the following laments: So ist denn schließlich der Stammbaum stellenweise recht unsicher – es müßten eigentlich deren mehrere aufgestellt werden je nach den verschiedenen Teilen. (Foerster 1910: lxxiii) Dieses schwankende Handschriftenverhältnis [..] führt dazu, daß man an vielen Stellen schwankend wird und mit der gewöhnlichen Formel des Stammbaumes nicht auskommen zu können glaubt. (Foerster 1910: lxxv) [..] Il (le copiste du groupe y) a copié un ms. contaminé qui offre dans son texte des leçons tantôt de S, tantôt de P, tantôt de B. C’est l’explication à adopter, si l’on imagine difficilement l’archétype y allant consulter trois mss. (Micha 1966: 114) Il ressort déjà que le ms. B n’est pas le seul oscillant, puisque S a des rapports assez suivis avec y. (Micha 1966: 112)
In such a case a philologist will conclude that the tradition is contaminated. So did these philologists. [Le ms. d’Annonay] confirme l’existence de ces groupes intermédiaires imputables à une tradition nécessairement contaminée. (Micha 1966: 121) Einzelne Schreiber, von ihren Auftraggebern mit den Vorlagen versehn, [hatten] zufällig beide Auflagen vor sich und [folgten] ihnen nach Gutdünken, falls nicht größere Lücken der Vorlage aus einer anderen, der 2. Redakzion angehörigen Hs. ausgefüllt werden mußten [...]. (Foerster 1910: lxxiv)
. Contamination If there is question of contamination, the premise is always that more than one version of a text was present in a scriptorium or library. Of course, this
Margot van Mulken
is always the case when a new text is produced: after transcription there are always two copies of the same text in one location. However, there are two possible concepts of contamination. 1. Simultaneous contamination presupposes that the copyist used several sources simultaneously to produce a new text. When this is the case, it is only logical that the copyist did so intentionally: he compared readings and made choices. The role of the copyist in the reproduction process, therefore, was very important: the choice of a particular reading is a wellconsidered and deliberate choice, since the copyist judged that determining the ‘correct’ reading was hyper-important. 2. With successive contamination, the copyist refers to different sources one after another, and in this case, it is improbable that he does so consciously. The copyist is unaware of the fact that he is using more than one text as exemplar; he is unconscious of the differences between the versions. The explanation for the fact that he could have had several exemplars at his disposal lies in the transcription process: group production was not unfamiliar in the Middle Ages, when several copyists collaborated to produce a new text, and when copies were produced by quire. After transcription, all the quires were gathered and stitched. Since copyists did not distinguish between old and new quires, it became possible that newly transcribed quires were gathered together with quires of the original exemplar. In addition, it was possible that several exemplars of a text were present in a library already at the beginning of the transcription. In such a case, successive contamination could occur when a copyist, unaware of the differences between the exemplars, switched exemplars in the transcription phase. In three manuscripts of the Cligés tradition (P, C and S) paleographers have distinguished the presence of more than one hand (Stewart & Luttrell 1993). They are all manuscripts dating from the Later Middle Ages. So at least for these manuscripts, collaboration of copyists has been established. A combination of both types of contamination is of course possible, but it remains difficult to prove the existence of simultaneous contamination. The problem with successive contamination is only slightly smaller: the shift in relationships often occurred at a stage prior to the extant manuscript, when (one of) the ancestors of the extant manuscript may have been subject to successive contamination. In such a case, contamination can only be proved indirectly. What remains evident is that successive contamination always betrays itself by the occurrence of a sudden change in relationships.
The manuscript tradition of the Cligés of Chrétien de Troyes
The concept of contamination (and the type the philologist decides it belongs to) depends heavily on the view of text one ascribes to a copyist who writes in the vernacular. In the case of the Cligés, I find it highly improbable, also in view of the large number of singular readings in every extant copy in this tradition, that the copyists were so preoccupied by the exact ‘correct’ reading of a theme that they would have wanted to refer to several exemplars.2 The phenomenon of ‘mouvance’ and the liberal conception of text were generally accepted for the production of vernacular texts, in contrast to other genres (Zumthor 1972). The consequence of this presupposition, as Foerster himself suggests, is that several passages in the Cligés require the drawing of different trees. Successive contamination is an option that needs to be taken seriously in order to solve the contamination in the Cligés.
. The quire separator Thanks to the work of Evert Wattel (Free University Amsterdam), it is now possible to determine quite exactly at what places in the tradition a shift in relationships occurs, since a ‘sudden’ change in relationship can be detected by the presence of contradicting quadruples (see Note 1) (Wattel & Van Mulken 1993; Wattel this volume; Den Hollander this volume). In the case of a new affinity, manuscripts will regroup into new mutual relations. Between shifts in relationships, steady relations can be detected by the presence of consistent quadruples. According to this quire detector, the Cligés presents two important shifts in relationships. 1. The first consistent part covers the beginning of the tradition up to verse 1250 (Structure I)3 2. The second part covers verse 1250 up to verse 4800 (Structure II) 4 3. The third part covers verse 4800 to the end (Structure III) 5 The relation shifts occur around verses 1250 and 4800. It is mss. B and S which are responsible for the first shift: they change places in the region of verse 1250. It is striking that this shift actually occurs at a stage where a change of quires could have taken place: the length of the first part coincides with the number of verses in a quire consisting of 16 pages (i.e. 8 folios) with two columns of 38/40 verses each (i.e. 1216–1280 verses). This unit is among the most common
Margot van Mulken A
C
R
S
P
B
Figure 2. Structure I Cligés vv. 1-1250 A
C
R
B
T
P
S
Figure 3. Structure II Cligés vv. 1250-4800 A
C
R
T B
S
P
Figure 4. Structure III Cligés vv. 4800-end
quire partitions in the Middle Ages and the extant manuscript S has the same distribution. In the region of verse 4800 manuscript P changes places with a nontransmitted intermediary. This second change corresponds more or less with a quire of 24 pages (i.e. 12 folios) with 3 columns of 59/60 verses each (i.e. 4248–4320 verses).6 This is a less current format, but it is precisely the format of manuscript P in the Cligés tradition. It is, therefore, conceivable that in the production phase of (ancestors of) manuscripts S and P quire shifts occurred and that these shifts are responsible for the multiple stemmata. This can only be established by careful codicological
The manuscript tradition of the Cligés of Chrétien de Troyes
Table 2. 1567 Einz li est touz li sens foiz Si que pres an est amuiz Mss ap
Einçois li est li sens failliz Si que pres qu il n’est amuiz Mss bcrsT
research into the extant manuscripts – and it remains possible that it was the ancestors of these manuscripts which were subject to quire shifts and not the manuscripts themselves. After having determined these consecutive structures, I recalculated the consistency within the trees and it appeared that now, in stead of 28%, 51% of the 370 variants could be preserved. This still implies a refutation of 49% of the variants, which is, of course, quite considerable. Every variant that has to be dismissed should therefore be carefully examined and evaluated in the light of parallelism. We shall not discuss all the contradictory readings, but many of the important conflicting variants concern cases of ‘rich rhyme’. For example Table 2. We see here that manuscripts A and P have a rich rhyme ‘foiz: amuiz’. According to Méla this must be an original reading (“[L]’accord AP justifie la correction [de C] pour une rime plus riche”) (Méla 1994: 136). However, the proliferation of rich rhymes is generally thought to be a posterior trend. In this respect, a remark of Foerster is relevant: “[...] daher auch die reichen Reime der späteren, schlechteren Hss.” (Foerster 1910: lxxiii). What is clear is that cases of rich rhyme are likely to have been subject to parallelism, and that they should therefore not be included in the variant list. In spite of the large number of variants that have to be dismissed, I consider the three structures as relevant and corresponding to actual underlying relation shifts.
. Orientation The consequence of the assessment of three underlying structures is that the other phases in the stemmatological process, according to the Three Level Method, are also to be multiplied by three. And this implies that for each structure the orientation and intermediate nodes must be determined. In earlier days, the orientation phase served as a basis to reconstruct the original text of the author. Nowadays, such an attempt is generally considered unrealistic and too far-fetched. The orientation phase is, however, still relevant in the study of the text production process: by orienting the structures we ob-
Margot van Mulken
Table 3. 0313 tuit li baron les esgardoient por ce que biax et genz les voient car li vaslet molt lor pleisoient ne cuident pas que il ne soient mss ab
et li baron forment se taisent que li vallet trestuit lor plesent por ce que biaus et genz les voient ne cuident pas que il ne soient mss cprs
Table 4. 1027 et s’il n’aimme ne n’a amé donc ai ge en la mer semé mss ab
et s’il n’aime ne n’a amé donc ai ge en l’areine semé mss crT (p, s)
tain a better insight into the direction of the pedigree. In order to do this, I tried to determine the original reading of some of the more important variants. Here, I will discuss some of the variants that constitute the arguments for the final orientation. In Table 3 we see that mss. A and B share a reading that does not reflect a possible original reading (the intersection of verses 0313 and 0315, producing a repeated rhyme on -oient), whereas the other manuscripts present a more poignant rhyme. The reverse is true for the next variant in Table 4, where A and B share a probably original rhyme, whereas the other manuscripts have a reading that does not refer to the preceding passage of the ‘secret of the sea’ in verses 548-564 (cf. Méla 1994: 104). The orientation of the first structure must therefore not be looked for in the group AB nor in the group CPRST, and this implies that I located the orientation on the edge between manuscripts AB and CPRS(T). Since T only commences a few verses before the start of Structure II, because its first quire is lacking, it is difficult to determine the position of T in this structure. I decided to leave T out of the first Structure. In the second part, we find the readings as presented in Table 5. The versions in manuscripts APT, though not entirely identical, are similar enough to group them together confronting the other group BCR. The version in the first group is far more lively and detailed and can be considered archetypal. The modification of ‘iert toz jorz estable’ to ‘est si veritable’ (see Table 6) is perhaps semantically cognate, but the fact that four words were modified indicates that a case of parallelism is improbable.
The manuscript tradition of the Cligés of Chrétien de Troyes
Table 5. 1744 car de bien ferir se travaille el plus espés de la bataille vet ensi ferir un gloton que ne li valut un boton ne li escuz ne li haubers ne li valut un cendal pers ms a (ms s: pareisin) (mss. pT: k’en terre ne l’emporte envers)
va un chevalier envair si le fiert par si grant air que mort jus des arçons l’abat si qu’il ne se plaint ne debat (br) (c)
Table 6. 3118 cest amors ne fu pas resnable mes la moie iert toz jorz estable mss. ab
ceste amor ne fu pas renable mais la moie est si veritable mss bprsT
Table 7. 5725 onques meis si male golée ne pois tu doner au monde mss acrs
onques meis si male golée ne pot la mors haper au monde mss bp
In part III, in verses 5725-7 (see Table 7), we see that manuscripts BP present a reading that cannot possibly be original, since it occurs in a passage where Death is directly addressed, and the third person singular (‘pot la mors’) is a sudden stylistic change of perspective. The wordplay with ‘mors’ in the sense of ‘death’ and ‘bite’ in the context of ‘golée’ and ‘haper’ must be a refection. In the second and third parts of the MS tradition, in Structures II and III, the orientation must be located on the edge between AS and the other manuscripts.
. Conclusion We see, then, that the orientation, for each structure, must be looked for in the neighbourhood of manuscript A, the Guiot copy. This is not really surprising, since Micha and Foerster came to the same conclusion with regard to the general quality of the readings and in view of the relative age of the manuscript
Margot van Mulken
(second quarter of the 13th century). However, Foerster prefers manuscript S in the case of the Cligés. He motivates his choice as follows: Einmal ist es die Hs. S die Abschrift eines recht (auch des Französischen) unkundigen Schreibers nach einer guten Vorlage, die an manchen Stellen wieder so schlechte und wertlose Lesarten bietet, daß man nicht begreift, wie sie in den sonst so guten Text kommen konnten. [. . . ] Hier wird (meiner Wertschätzung der Hs. entsprechend) meist an S unter allen Umständen gegen die andern Hss. festgehalten. (Foerster 1910: lxxv–vi)
Micha, on the contrary, continued to consider the Guiot copy as the best manuscript, in the tradition of Bédier, and used it as manuscrit de base for his edition of 1957. Similar arguments led Lutrell and Gregory to edit the Guiot copy in 1993, just as Poirion decided to edit Guiot in 1993. It is true that manuscript A is a remarkable manuscript, but in Van Mulken (2002) I demonstrated that a picardian predecessor must be inferred in the case of the Cligés. The version of the Cligés as laid down in Guiot’s copy is coloured by distinct picardisms, although the champenois provenance of the manuscript remains undisputed: (one of) the ancestor(s) of Guiot must have been a picardian manuscript. But we also know that Chrétien’s dialect was originally a champenois dialect! This implies that the version of Cligés in manuscript A first travelled to Picardy, and then returned to Champagne to be transcribed in the Guiot copy. In other words: even the best manuscript in a tradition, on the grounds of quality and age, may have had a considerable history before it became the best manuscript. The dialectological argument confirms the fact that manuscripts in the vernacular had a complicate production history, as demonstrated by the stemmatological analysis of the Cligés, where the use of the quire separator throws an important light on the contemporary view on vernacular texts in the Middle Ages. Not only the Perceval, but also the Cligés proves to be a ‘rich’ tradition.
Notes . A quadruple is the minimal unit in a Type-2 variant: it covers two similarities and a difference. A variant such as ‘abrs/cp’ can be broken down into: ab/cp; ar/cp; as/cp; br/cp; bs/cp; rs/cp. The advantage of quadruples is that no more than two Type-2 variations exist that can be in contradiction with the quadruple: ‘ab/cp’ can only be in contradiction with ‘ac/bp’ and ‘ap/bc’. If a manuscript tradition is closed and linear, this implies that for each quadruple the score for the competing quadruples will be zero or next to zero (depending on the
The manuscript tradition of the Cligés of Chrétien de Troyes
degree of inconsistency admitted by the philologist). Thanks to the table of quadruples, the philologists can see at a glance whether a tradition is closed or not. . Foerster even goes so far as to presuppose an authorized review of the text by Chrétien (Foerster 1910: lxxiv), Micha thinks several copyists had more than one exemplar at their disposal (Micha 1966: 114). . All verse references follow CFMA Micha 1957. The following important variants are in accordance with the stemma structure of the first part: ab/cprs 0022; 0176; 0290; 0297; 0313; 0331; 0430; 1028; abp/crs 0044; 0054; 0327; 0432; 0631; 0905; 0973; abps/cr 0527; 0724; 0806; 1083 . The following variants are in accordance with Structure II: as/bcprT 1190; 1380; 1386; 1409; 1487; 1535; 1572; 1612; 1640; 2368; 2628.2; 2666; 2800; 2987; 3063; 3086; 3118; 3162; 3362; 3555; 3602; 3743; 3948; 4133; 4380; 4446; 4695; aps/bcrT 1344; 1590; 1613; 1633; 1638; 2360; 2512; 2628; 2945; 3105; 3420; 3478; 3545; 3631; 3651; 3657; 3776; 3824; 4400; 4476; 4607; apsT/bcr 1151; 1201; 1244; 1250; 1285; 1330; 1348; 1403; 1521; 1544; 1666; 1719; 1722; 1741; 1744; 1745; 1754; 1797; 2247; 2394; 2405; 2428; 2588; 2601; 2679; 2681; 2703; 2726; 2836; 2919; 2921; 3026; 3253; 3430; abpsT/cr 1296; 2402; 3106; 3237; 4082.2; 1232; 1244; 1322; 1544; 1602; 1719; 2375; 2394; 2428; 3086.2; 3577; 3707.2 . The following important variants are in concordance with Structure III: as/bcprT 5309; 5560; 5773; 6040; asT/bcpr –; cr/abpsT 5693; 5926; 6084; bp/cprsT 4780; 4769; 4933; 5021; 5497; 5699; 5700; 5715; 5725; 6170 . There still remains a difference of some 480 verses to be explained. Since the exact transition of an underlying structure into another cannot be detected, due to lack of variants at the precise border of a structure, it is very well possible that a different combination of underlying quires must be presupposed.
References Dees, A. (1988). “Analyse par l’ordinateur de la tradition manuscrite du Cligés de Chrétien de Troyes”. In D. Kremer (Ed.), Actes du XVIIIe Congrès International de Linguistique et de Philologie Romanes (pp. 62–75). Tübingen: Niemeyer. Gregory, S. & C. Luttrell (1993). “The Manuscripts of Cligés”. In Keith Busby, Terry Nixon, Alison Stones, & Lori Walters (Eds.), Les Manuscrits de Chrétien de Troyes: The Manuscripts of Chrétien de Troyes (pp. 41–48). Amsterdam: Rodopi. Hollander, A. A. den (1997). De Nederlandse Bijbelvertalingen 1522–1545. Nieuwkoop: De Graaf. Micha, A. (1966). La tradition manuscrite des romans de Chrétien de Troyes. Genève: Droz.
Margot van Mulken
Mulken, M. van (1993). The Manuscript Tradition of the Perceval of Chrétien de Troyes, a stemmatological and dialectological approach. Ph.D. Dissertation: Amsterdam. Mulken, M. van (1999). “Les changements de parenté dans le Cligés de Chrétien de Troyes.” Atti dei Convegni Lincei, 151, 105–114. Roma: Accademia Nazionale dei Lincei. Mulken, M. van (2002). “Le manuscript de Guiot et les influences picardes dans le Cligés de Chrétien de Troyes”. In H. Jacobs & L. Wetzels (Eds.), Liber Amicorum Bernard Bichakjian. Nijmegen: University Press. Nixon, T. (1993). “Romance Connections and the Manuscripts of Chrétien de Troyes”. In Keith Busby, Terry Nixon, Alison Stones, & Lori Walters (Eds.), Les Manuscrits de Chrétien de Troyes: The Manuscripts of Chrétien de Troyes (pp. 17–26). Amsterdam: Rodopi. Salemans, B. (2000). Building Stemmas with the Computer in a Cladistic, Neo-Lachmannian Way. Ph.D. Thesis Katholieke Universiteit Nijmegen: Nijmegen University Press. Wattel, E. & M. van Mulken (1996). Shock Waves in Text Traditions – Cardiograms of the Medieval Literature. In P. van Reenen & M. van Mulken (Eds.), Studies in Stemmatology (pp. 105–121). Amsterdam: Benjamins. Zumthor, P. (1972). Essai de poétique médiévale. Paris: Seuil.
Editions Foerster, W. (1910). Kristian von Troyes. Cligés, Textausgabe mit Variantenauswahl, Einleitung, Anmerkungen und vollständigem Glossar. Halle: Niemeyer3 . Luttrell, C. & S. Gregory (1993). Cligés – Chrétien de Troyes. Bury St. Edmunds: St. Edmundsbury Press. Méla, Ch. (1994). Chrétien de Troyes: Cligés, Edition critique du manuscrit B.N. fr. 12560. Lettres Gothiques. Livre de Poche. Micha, A. (1957). Les Romans de Chrétien de Troyes, Cligés, édités d’après la copie de Guiot (Bibl. nat., fr. 794). Les Classiques Français du Moyen Age. Paris: Champion. Poirion, D. (1993). Œuvres Complètes de Chrétien de Troyes. Paris: Gallimard.
P II
Textual variation
Genealogy by chance! On the significance of accidental variation (parallelisms) Ulrich Schmid Kirchliche Hochschule Bethel, Bielefeld / Vrije Universiteit, Amsterdam
.
Introduction
Relationships between witnesses of a given text tradition are usually defined by the variant readings they share. Structures like ‘groups’ or ‘clusters’ or ‘families’ appear and ideally an overall stemma of the tradition can be established by means of the kinship-revealing process of comparing the variant readings that are displayed by the tradition. Such a process can be executed in different ways. No matter which way is chosen, usually one presupposition is accepted by all: Agreement in reading is agreement in ancestry. Although we may consider some variant readings or even some types of variant readings as not very impressive with regard to their kinship-revealing nature, we usually do not exclude them from the body of variant readings which is registered, counted, and processed. This is all the more true for variant readings that are not mere ‘orthographicals’ or ‘nonsense readings’,1 but sensible readings providing a readable and intelligible text. If variant readings of the latter type are to be noted and found in more than one witness, we must not exclude them from our data processing. Quite to the contrary. This type of evidence is the backbone of every genealogical or stemmatological work