Proceedings of the SEWM2000 Meeting
S T R O N G AND ELECTROWEAK MATTER 2 0 0 0
i , ' -*''
if
Editor
C . P. Korthals Altes World Scientific
S T R O N G AND ELECTROWEAK MATTER 2 0 0 0
Proceedings of the SEWM2000 Meeting
STRONG AND ELECTROWEAK MATTER 2 0 0 0 Marseille, France
13-17 June 2000
Editor
C. P. Korthals Altes Centre Physique Theorique au CNRS Luminy F13288, Marseille, France
V|S* World Scientific « •
Sinqapore* L Singapore • NewJersey New Jersey •London • Hong Kong
Published by World Scientific Publishing Co. Pte. Ltd. P O Box 128, Farrer Road, Singapore 912805 USA office: Suite IB, 1060 Main Street, River Edge, NJ 07661 UK office: 57 Shelton Street, Covent Garden, London WC2H 9HE
British Library Cataloguing-in-Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library.
STRONG AND ELECTROWEAK MATTER 2000 Proceedings of the SEWM2000 Meeting Copyright © 2001 by World Scientific Publishing Co. Pte. Ltd. All rights reserved. This book, or parts thereof, may not be reproduced in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording or any information storage and retrieval system now known or to be invented, without written permission from the Publisher.
For photocopying of material in this volume, please pay a copying fee through the Copyright Clearance Center, Inc., 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923, USA. In this case permission to photocopy is not required from the publisher.
ISBN 981-02-4668-4
Printed in Singapore by Uto-Print
PREFACE
These proceedings contain the talks given at "Strong and Electroweak Matter 2000", a meeting organized at the Centre Physique Theorique and the Centre de Physique des Particules de Marseille, from 13 to 17 J u n e 2000. This meeting is held at a roughly two year basis. T h e first took place in Sintra (Portugal) in 1994, the second in Eger (Hungary) in 1997, the third at the Niels Bohr Institute (Copenhagen, Denmark) in 1998. T h e next meeting will take place in Heidelberg in June 2002. T h e conference is the meeting point of researchers in the p l a s m a phases of particle physics, and in cosmology. T h u s it combines physics on laboratory scale, such as the heavy ion experiments at C E R N (Geneva) and at RHIC (Brookhaven, USA), and on astronomical scales. T h e m a i n body of the talks are on theoretical aspects. Many are analytic in approach, m a n y numerical and a few experimental. T h e meeting had some four discussion sessions, each led by two moderators. Their crafty insistence on getting the audience involved was quite successful. We are sure t h a t the proceedings carry beneficial effects of these sessions. This format implied t h a t many short contributions had to be given as posters, and we thank the participants for their cooperation. They appear in this volume on the same basis as the contributed talks. T h e underlying volume has been divided into main talks, and contributed talks. T h e latter have been subdivided into Equilibrium Systems, Systems out of Equilibrium, and Miscellaneous. T h e talks on Equilibrium Systems have been subdivided into High Density and High Temperature systems. T h e International Committee consisted of J. Ambjorn (Copenhagen), P. Arnold (Virginia), Z. Fodor (Budapest), W. Buchmueller (Hamburg), K. Kaj a n t i e (Helsinki), F. Karsch (Bielefeld), L. McLerran (Brookhaven), A. Patkos (Budapest), A. Rebhan (Vienna), K. Rummukainen (Copenhagen), M. Shaposhnikov (Lausanne), M. Schmidt (Heidelberg), J. Smit ( A m s t e r d a m ) . They provided us with practical and indispensable advice on the format of the conference and otherwise. T h e conference has been sponsored by the Centre National de Recherche Scientifique, the Universite de la Mediterranee, the Ministere des Affaires Etrangeres, by the Conseil General of the Provence-Cote d'Azur and the Ville de Marseille, and we want to thank them for their support. We want to mention the help of the personnel of the C P T and the C P P M with the many forseen and unforseen problems. In particular use of the audi-
v
vi torium of the C P P M was due to the generosity of its director, Elie Aslanides. SEWM2000 participants had to go through severe physical hardships before they got to the conference banquet. Fortunately the afterdinner speech was quite relaxing, and we thank the speaker Prof Bobo Bizarski (who insisted on staying anonymous) for his emotionally and otherwise arousing performance. T h e unflinching assistance of Antonia Sueur, the conference secretary, m a d e the meeting into a success. Last but not least we thank Pierre Giovannangeli for his crucial help with the Proceedings. Chris P. Korthals Altes
CONTENTS
Preface
v M A I N TALKS
Color superconductivity in compact stars M. Alford, J. Bowers and K. Rajagopal
1
The colored glass condensate and extreme QCD E. Iancu
19
Aspects of parity, CP and time reversal violation in hot QCD D. Kharzeev, R. Pisarski and M. Tytgat
32
The deconfining phase transition, the Z/v domain walls and the magnetic Z/v symmetry A. Kovner
46
Electroweak phase transition beyond the Standard Model M. Laine
58
Aspects of semi-classical transport theory for QCD D. Litim
70
Do we understand the sphaleron rate? G. Moore
82
Debye screening in the QCD plasma 0. Philipsen
95
Why the Quark-Gluon plasma isn't a plasma R. Pisarski
107
Isospin matter D. Son and M. Stephanov
118
Non-perturbative dynamics of hot non-abelian gauge fields
129
L. Yaffe VII
VIII
C O N T R I B U T E D TALKS SYSTEMS IN EQUILIBRIUM High temperature systems The effective potential for composite operators in the scalar model at finite temperature G. Ananos and N. Svaiter
136
Three-loop free energy using screened perturbation theory J. Andersen
142
Hot scalar theory in large N: Bose-Einstein condensation P. Arnold and B. Tomdsik
148
The electrical conductivity in high temperature QED L. Bettencourt and E. Mottola
153
Random cluster model, percolation and deconfinement transition in quark-gluon plasma P. Blanchard and D. Gandolfo
160
Screening in hot SU(2) gauge theory and propagators in 3D adjoint Higgs model A. Cucchieri, F. Karsch and P. Petreczky
165
The effect of primordial temperature fluctuations on the QCD transition J. Ignatius and D. Schwarz
170
Dynamical resummation and damping in the O(N) model A. Jakovdc
175
QCD thermodynamics with two and three quark flavors F. Karsch, E. Laermann, A. Peikert, Ch. Schmidt and S. Stickan
180
Hadron correlators in the deconfined phase F. Karsch, M. Mustafa and M. Thoma
186
Testing MEM with diquark and thermal meson correlation functions F. Karsch and I. Wetzorke Improved resummations for the thermodynamics of the quark-gluon plasma A. Rebhan Phase transition in QCD H. Satz
193
199
204
High density systems Dimensional regularization and Mellin summation in high-temperature calculations D. Bedingham
226
Time dependent effective actions at finite temperature T. Evans
231
Scalar fields at finite densities: A delta expansion approach D. Winder
236
SYSTEMS OUT OF EQUILIBRIUM Nonequilibrium fields: Exact and truncated dynamics G. Aarts
241
A new field-theoretical path integral for out-of-equilibrium matter R. Alvarez-Estrada
247
Nonequilibrium dynamics in gauge theories J. Baacke and K. Heitmann
252
Solution of the Boltzmann equation for gluons after a heavy ion collision J. Bjoraker and R. Venugopalan MSSM electroweak phase transition on 4D lattices F. Csikor, Z. Fodor, P. Hegediis, A.jakovdc and A. Piroth
257
263
A new collision operator in hot QCD F. Guerin Baryogenesis at the electroweak phase transition for a SUSY model with a gauge singlet S. Huber and M. Schmidt
268
272
No spontaneous CP violation at finite temperature in the MSSM? P. John
279
Bubble wall velocity in the MSSM P. John and M. Schmidt
284
The quantum mechanics of the slow roll in the linear delta expansion H. Jones
289
Fermion damping rate effects in cold dense matter C. Manuel
294
Electrogenesis in a scalar field dominated epoch T. Prokopec
299
Electroweak baryogenesis M. Quiros
304
Preheating and phase transitions in gauge theories A. Rajantie
316
Scalar field dynamics: Classical, quantum and in between M. Salle, J. Smit and J. Vink
321
Twin peaks M. Salle, J. Smit and J. Vink
327
Exploiting duality in a toy model of QCD at non-zero T and /^: Massive Thirring model, sine-Gordon model and Coulomb gases D. Steer, A. Gomez Nicola, T. Evans and R. Rivers
332
XI
MISCELLANEOUS New physics in the charged relativistic Bose gas using zeta-function regularization? A. Filippi
337
Sphalerons with two Higgs doublets M. Hindmarsh and J, Grant
343
Q-ball collisions in the MSSM T. Multamaki
348
Rho meson properties in nuclear matter from QCD sum rules
353
A. Nyffeler Exact topological density in the lattice Skyrme model B. Svetitsky and A. Schramm
359
Classical order parameter dynamics and the decay of a metastable vacuum state Z. Szep
364
List of Participants
369
COLOR S U P E R C O N D U C T I V I T Y IN C O M P A C T STARS MARK ALFORD Dept. of Physics and Astronomy,
University of Glasgow, G12 8QQ, U.K.
JEFFREY BOWERS AND KRISHNA RAJAGOPAL* Center for Theoretical Physics, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, MA, USA 02139 After a brief review of the phenomena expected in cold dense quark matter, color superconductivity and color-flavor locking, we sketch some implications of recent developments in our understanding of cold dense quark matter for the physics of compact stars. We give a more detailed summary of our recent work on crystalline color superconductivity and the consequent realization that (some) pulsar glitches may originate in quark matter.
1
Color Superconductivity and Color-Flavor Locking
Because QCD is asymptotically free, its high temperature and high baryon density phases are more simply and more appropriately described in terms of quarks and gluons as degrees of freedom, rather than hadrons. The chiral symmetry breaking condensate which characterizes the vacuum melts away. At high temperatures, in the resulting quark-gluon plasma phase all of the symmetries of the QCD Lagrangian are unbroken and the excitations have the quantum numbers of quarks and gluons. At high densities, on the other hand, quarks form Cooper pairs and new condensates develop. The formation of such superconducting phases 1 ' 2 ' 3,4 ' 5 ' 6 requires only weak attractive interactions; these phases may nevertheless break chiral symmetry 5 and have excitations with the same quantum numbers as those in a confined phase. 5 ' 7 ' 8 ' 9 These cold dense quark matter phases may arise in the cores of neutron stars; understanding this region of the QCD phase diagram requires an interplay between QCD and neutron star phenomenology. The relevant degrees of freedom in cold dense quark matter are those which involve quarks with momenta near the Fermi surface. At high density, where the quark number chemical potential \i (and hence the quark Fermi momentum) is large, the QCD gauge coupling g((j.) is small. However, because of the infinite degeneracy among pairs of quarks with equal and opposite momenta at the Fermi surface, even an arbitrarily weak attraction between quarks renders the Fermi surface unstable to the formation of a condensate of •SPEAKER. 1
2
quark Cooper pairs. Creating a pair costs no free energy at the Fermi surface and the attractive interaction results in a free energy benefit. Pairs of quarks cannot be color singlets, and in QCD with two flavors of massless quarks, they form in the (attractive) color 3 channel in which the quarks in a Cooper pair are color-antisymmetric 1 ' 2 ' 3 ' 4 . The resulting condensate creates a gap A at the Fermi surfaces of quarks with two out of three colors, but quarks of the third color remain gapless. Five gluons get a Meissner mass by the AndersonHiggs mechanism; 10 a 5L^(2)coi0r subgroup remains unbroken. The Cooper pairs are flavor singlets and no flavor symmetries are broken. There is also an unbroken global symmetry which plays the role of U(1)B- Thus, no global symmetries are broken in this 2SC phase. There must therefore be a phase transition between the hadronic and 2SC phases at which chiral symmetry is restored. This phase transition is first order 3 ' 11 ' 12 ' 13 since it involves a competition between chiral condensation and diquark condensation. 11 ' 13 In QCD with three flavors of massless quarks, the Cooper pairs cannot be flavor singlets, and both color and flavor symmetries are necessarily broken. The symmetries of the phase which results have been analyzed in Refs. 5 ' 7 . The attractive channel favored by one-gluon exchange exhibits "color-flavor locking." A condensate of the form (V'gVf) oc Aea0AeabA
(1)
involving left-handed quarks alone, with a, ft color indices and a, b flavor indices, locks SU(3)L flavor rotations to SU(3)coior: the condensate is not symmetric under either alone, but is symmetric under the simultaneous SU(3)L+COIOT rotations." A condensate involving right-handed quarks alone locks SU(3)R flavor rotations to SU(3)C0\0V. Because color is vectorial, the combined effect of the LL and RR condensates is to lock SU(3)L to SU(3)R, breaking chiral symmetry. 6 Thus, in quark matter with three massless quarks, the 5J7(3)coior x SU(3)L X SU(3)R X U(1)B symmetry is broken down to the global diagonal SU(3)CO\OT+L+R group. A gauged U(l) subgroup of the original symmetry group — a linear combination of one color generator and electromagnetism, which lives within SU(3)L X SU(3)R — also remains unbroken. All nine quarks have a gap. All eight gluons get a mass. 5 ' 15 There °It turns out 5 that condensation in the color 3 channel induces a condensate in the color 6 channel because this breaks no further symmetries. 8 The resulting condensates can be written in terms of M and K2 where ( V £ a ^ O ~ niSaaSl3b+ K2Sab5l3a. Here, the Kronecker <5's lock color and flavor rotations. The pure color 3 condensate (1) has K2 = —K\. 6 Once chiral symmetry is broken by color-flavor locking, there is no symmetry argument precluding the existence of an ordinary chiral condensate. Indeed, instanton effects do induce a nonzero {qq),b but this is a small effect.14
3
are nine massless Nambu-Goldstone bosons. All the quarks, all the massive vector bosons, and all the Nambu-Goldstone bosons have integer charges under the unbroken gauged U{\) symmetry, which therefore plays the role of electromagnetism. The CFL phase therefore has the same symmetries (and many similar non-universal features) as baryonic matter with a condensate of Cooper pairs of baryons. 7 This raises the possibility that quark matter and baryonic matter may be continuously connected.7 Nature chooses two light quarks and one middle-weight strange quark, rather than three degenerate quarks. A nonzero ms weakens condensates which involve pairing between light and strange quarks. The CFL phase requires (us) and (ds) condensates; such condensates which pair quarks with differing Fermi momenta can only exist if the resulting gaps are larger than of order vr?sj2/z, the difference between u and s Fermi momenta in the absence of pairing. This means that upon increasing m s at fixed /i, one must find a first-order unlocking transition: 8 ' 9 for larger ms only u and d quarks pair and the 2SC phase is obtained. For any ms ^ oo, the CFL phase is the ground state at arbitrarily high density.8 For large values of m s , there is a 2SC interlude: as a function of increasing /x, one finds a first order phase transition at which hadronic matter is replaced by quark matter in the 2SC phase and a subsequent first order phase transition at a higher ^ above which CFL quark matter takes over. For smaller values of ms, the possibility of quark-hadron continuity 7 arises.0 Much effort has gone into estimating the magnitude of the gaps in the 2SC and CFL phases, and the consequent critical temperature above which quark matter ceases to be superconducting. It would be ideal if this task were within the scope of lattice gauge theory. Unfortunately, lattice methods relying on importance sampling have to this point been rendered exponentially impractical at nonzero baryon density by the complex action at nonzero /x. There are more sophisticated algorithms which have allowed the simulation of theories which are simpler than QCD but which have as severe a fermion sign problem as that in QCD at nonzero chemical potential. 16 This bodes well for the future.d Given the current absence of suitable lattice methods, the c
Note that even if the strange and light quarks are not degenerate, the CFL phase may be continuous with a baryonic phase which is dense enough that the Fermi momenta of all the nucleons and hyperons are comparable; there must, however, be phase transition(s) between this hypernuclear phase and ordinary nuclear matter. 8 d Note that quark pairing can be studied on the lattice in some models with four-fermion interactions and in two-color QCD. 1 7 The Nc = 2 case has also been studied analytically in Refs. 4 > 1 8 ; pairing in this theory is simpler to analyze because quark Cooper pairs are color singlets. The Nc —> oo limit of QCD is often one in which hard problems become tractable. However, the ground state of Nc = oo QCD is a chiral density wave, not a color
4
magnitude of the gaps in quark matter at large but accessible /J, has been estimated using two broad strategies. The first class of estimates are done within the context of models whose parameters are chosen to reproduce zero density physics.3,4,11,5,8,9,13,14,23,24,25,22 -J-J^ s e c o n c i strategy for estimating gaps and critical temperatures is to use fi = oo physics as a guide. At asymptotically large /i, models with short-range interactions are bound to fail because the dominant interaction is due to the long-range magnetic interaction coming from single-gluon exchange. 12 ' 26 The collinear infrared divergence in small angle scattering via one-gluon exchange (which is regulated by dynamical screening26) results in a gap which is parametrically larger at fj, —> oo than it would be for any point-like four-fermion interaction. 26 Weak coupling estimates of the gap26'27'28'29-30'31'32>33>34>35,36,37,38 a r e v a j i d a t a S y m p totically high densities, with chemical potentials /x > 108 MeV. 37 Neither class of methods can be trusted quantitatively for quark number chemical potentials /j, ~ 400 — 500 MeV, as appropriate for the quark matter which may occur in the cores of neutron stars. It is nevertheless satisfying that two very different approaches, one using zero density phenomenology to normalize models, the other using weak-coupling methods valid at asymptotically high density, yield predictions for the gaps and critical temperatures at accessible densities which are in good agreement: the gaps at the Fermi surface are of order tens to 100 MeV, with critical temperatures about half as large. Tc ~ 50 MeV is much larger relative to the Fermi momentum than in low temperature superconductivity in metals. This reflects the fact that color superconductivity is induced by an attraction due to the primary, strong, interaction in the theory, rather than having to rely on much weaker secondary interactions, as in phonon mediated superconductivity in metals. Quark matter is a high-Tc superconductor by any reasonable definition. Its Tc is nevertheless low enough that it is unlikely the phenomenon can be realized in heavy ion collisions. 2
Color Superconductivity in Compact Stars
Our current understanding of the color superconducting state of quark matter leads us to believe that it may occur naturally in compact stars. The critical superconductor. 1 9 At asymptotically high densities color superconductivity persists up to Nc's of order thousands 2 0 , 2 1 before being supplanted by the phase described in Ref. 1 9 . At any finite Nc, color superconductivity occurs at arbitrarily weak coupling whereas the chiral density wave does not. For Nc = 3, color superconductivity is still favored over the chiral density wave (although not by much) even if the interaction is so strong that the color superconductivity gap is ~ ft/2.22
5
temperature Tc below which quark matter is a color superconductor is high enough that any quark matter which occurs within neutron stars that are more than a few seconds old is in a color superconducting state. In the absence of lattice simulations, present theoretical methods are not accurate enough to determine whether neutron star cores are made of hadronic matter or quark matter. They also cannot determine whether any quark matter which arises will be in the CFL or 2SC phase: the difference between the u, d and s Fermi momenta will be a few tens of MeV which is comparable to estimates of the gap A; the CFL phase occurs when A is large compared to all differences between Fermi momenta. Just as the higher temperature regions of the QCD phase diagram are being mapped out in heavy ion collisions, we need to learn how to use neutron star phenomena to determine whether they feature cores made of 2SC quark matter, CFL quark matter or hadronic matter, thus teaching us about the high density region of the QCD phase diagram. It is therefore important to look for astrophysical consequences of color superconductivity. 2.1
Equation of State
Much of the work on the consequences of quark matter within a compact star has focussed on the effects of quark matter on the equation of state, and hence on the radius of the star. As a Fermi surface phenomenon, color superconductivity has little effect on the equation of state: the pressure is an integral over the whole Fermi volume. Color superconductivity modifies the equation of state at the ~ (A//i) 2 level, typically by a few percent. 3 Such small effects can be neglected in present calculations, and for this reason we will not attempt to survey the many ways in which observations of neutron stars are being used to constrain the equation of state. 39 We will describe one current idea, however. As a neutron star in a low mass X-ray binary (LMXB) is spun up by accretion from its companion, it becomes more oblate and its central density decreases. If it contains a quark matter core, the volume fraction occupied by this core decreases, the star expands, and its moment of inertia increases. This raises the possibility 40 of a period during the spin-up history of an LMXB when the neutron star is gaining angular momentum via accretion, but is gaining sufficient moment of inertia that its angular frequency is hardly increasing. In their modelling of this effect, Glendenning and Weber 40 discover that LMXB's should spend a significant fraction of their history with a frequency of around 200 Hz, while their quark cores are being spun out of existence, before eventually spinning up to higher frequencies. This may explain the observation that LMXB frequencies are clustered around 250-350 Hz, 41 which is otherwise puzzling in
6
that it is thought that LMXB's provide the link between canonical pulsars and millisecond pulsars, which have frequencies as large as 600 Hz.42 It will be interesting to see how robust the result of Ref. 40 is to changes in model assumptions and also how its predictions fare when compared to those of other explanations which posit upper bounds on LMXB frequencies,43 rather than a most probable frequency range with no associated upper bound. 40 We note here that because Glendenning and Weber's effect depends only on the equation of state and not on other properties of quark matter, the fact that the quark matter must in fact be a color superconductor will not affect the results in any significant way. If Glendenning and Weber's explanation for the observed clustering of LMXB frequencies proves robust, it would imply that pulsars with lower rotational frequencies feature quark matter cores. 2.2
Cooling by Neutrino
Emission
We turn now to neutron star phenomena which are affected by Fermi surface physics. For the first 10 5 ~ 6 years of its life, the cooling of a neutron star is governed by the balance between heat capacity and the loss of heat by neutrino emission. How are these quantities affected by the presence of a quark matter core? This has been addressed recently in Refs. 44>455 following earlier work in Ref. 46 . Both the specific heat Cy and the neutrino emission rate Lv are dominated by physics within T of the Fermi surface. If, as in the CFL phase, all quarks have a gap A » T then the contribution of quark quasiparticles to Cy and L„ is suppressed by ~ exp(—A/T). There may be other contributions to L„, 44 but these are also very small. The specific heat is dominated by that of the electrons, although it may also receive a small contribution from the CFL phase Goldstone bosons. Although further work is required, it is already clear that both Cy and Lv are much smaller than in the nuclear matter outside the quark matter core. This means that the total heat capacity and the total neutrino emission rate (and hence the cooling rate) of a neutron star with a CFL core will be determined completely by the nuclear matter outside the core. The quark matter core is "inert": with its small heat capacity and emission rate it has little influence on the temperature of the star as a whole. As the rest of the star emits neutrinos and cools, the core cools by conduction, because the electrons keep it in good thermal contact with the rest of the star. These qualitative expectations are nicely borne out in the calculations presented by Page et al. 45 The analysis of the cooling history of a neutron star with a quark matter core in the 2SC phase is more complicated. The red and green up and down quarks pair with a gap many orders of magnitude larger than the tempera-
7
ture, which is of order 10 keV, and are therefore inert as described above. Any strange quarks present will form a (ss) condensate with angular momentum J — 1 which locks to color in such a way that rotational invariance is not broken. 47 The resulting gap has been estimated to be of order hundreds of keV, 47 although applying results of Ref. 48 suggests a somewhat smaller gap, around 10 keV. The blue up and down quarks also pair, forming a J = 1 condensate which breaks rotational invariance.3 The related gap was estimated to be a few keV,3 but this estimate was not robust and should be revisited in light of more recent developments given its importance in the following. The critical temperature Tc above which no condensate forms is of order the zero-temperature gap A. (Tc = 0.57A for J = 0 condensates. 27 ) Therefore, if there are quarks for which A ~ T or smaller, these quarks do not pair at temperature T. Such quark quasiparticles will radiate neutrinos rapidly (via direct URCA reactions like d -> u + e + u, u -) d + e+ + v, etc.) and the quark matter core will cool rapidly and determine the cooling history of the star as a whole. 46 ' 45 The star will cool rapidly until its interior temperature is T < Tc ~ A, at which time the quark matter core will become inert and the further cooling history will be dominated by neutrino emission from the nuclear matter fraction of the star. If future data were to show that neutron stars first cool rapidly (direct URCA) and then cool more slowly, such data would allow an estimate of the smallest quark matter gap. We are unlikely to be so lucky. The simple observation of rapid cooling would not be an unambiguous discovery of quark matter with small gaps; there are other circumstances in which the direct URCA processes occur. However, if as data on neutron star temperatures improves in coming years the standard cooling scenario proves correct, indicating the absence of the direct URCA processes, this would rule out the presence of quark matter with gaps in the 10 keV range or smaller. The presence of a quark matter core in which all gaps are 3> T can never be revealed by an analysis of the cooling history.
2.3
Supernova Neutrinos
We now turn from neutrino emission from a neutron star which is many years old to that from the protoneutron star during the first seconds of a supernova. Carter and Reddy 49 have pointed out that when this protoneutron star is at its maximum temperature of order 30-50 MeV, it may have a quark matter core which is too hot for color superconductivity. As such a protoneutron star core cools over the next few seconds, this quark matter will cool through Tc, entering the color superconducting regime of the QCD phase diagram. For T ~ Tc, the specific heat rises and the cooling slows. Then, as T drops
8
further and A increases to become greater than T, the specific heat drops rapidly. Furthermore, as the number density of quark quasiparticles becomes suppressed by exp(—A/T), the neutrino transport mean free path rapidly becomes very long. 49 This means that all the neutrinos previously trapped in the now color superconducting core are able to escape in a sudden burst. If a terrestrial neutrino detector sees thousands of neutrinos from a future supernova, Carter and Reddy's results suggest that there may be a signature of the transition to color superconductivity present in the time distribution of these neutrinos. Neutrinos from the core of the protoneutron star will lose energy as they scatter on their way out, but because they will be the last to reach the surface of last scattering, they will be the final neutrinos received at the earth. If they are released from the quark matter core in a sudden burst, they may therefore result in a bump at late times in the temporal distribution of the detected neutrinos. More detailed study remains to be done in order to understand how Carter and Reddy's signature, dramatic when the neutrinos escape from the core, is processed as the neutrinos traverse the rest of the protoneutron star and reach their surface of last scattering. 2.4
R-mode Instabilities
Another arena in which color superconductivity comes into play is the physics of r-mode instabilities. A neutron star whose angular rotation frequency Cl is large enough is unstable to the growth of r-mode oscillations which radiate away angular momentum via gravitational waves, reducing fl. What does "large enough" mean? The answer depends on the damping mechanisms which act to prevent the growth of the relevant modes. Both shear viscosity and bulk viscosity act to damp the r-modes, preventing them from going unstable. The bulk viscosity and the quark contribution to the shear viscosity both become exponentially small in quark matter with A > T and as a result, as Madsen 50 has shown, a compact star made entirely of quark matter with gaps A = 1 MeV or greater is unstable if its spin frequency is greater than tens to 100 Hz. Many compact stars spin faster than this, and Madsen therefore argues that compact stars cannot be strange quark stars unless some quarks remain ungapped. Alas, this powerful argument becomes much less powerful in the context of a neutron star with a quark matter core. First, the rmode oscillations have a wave form whose amplitude is largest at large radius, outside the core. Second, in an ordinary neutron star there is a new source of damping: friction at the boundary between the crust and the neutron superfluid "mantle" keeps the r-modes stable regardless of the properties of a quark matter core. 51,50
9
2.5
Magnetic Field Evolution
Next, we turn to the physics of magnetic fields within color superconducting neutron star cores. 52 ' 53 The interior of a conventional neutron star is a superfluid (because of neutron-neutron pairing) and is an electromagnetic superconductor (because of proton-proton pairing). Ordinary magnetic fields penetrate it only in the cores of magnetic flux tubes. A color superconductor behaves differently. At first glance, it seems that because a diquark Cooper pair has nonzero electric charge, a diquark condensate must exhibit the standard Meissner effect, expelling ordinary magnetic fields or restricting them to flux tubes within whose cores the condensate vanishes. This is not the case. 53 In both the 2SC and CFL phase a linear combination of the U(l) gauge transformation of ordinary electromagnetism and one (the eighth) color gauge transformation remains unbroken even in the presence of the condensate. This means that the ordinary photon A^ and the eighth gluon G® are replaced by new linear combinations A® = cos ao An + sin ao G® A* = - sin a0 A^ + cos a0 G®
(2)
where A® is massless and A* is massive. That is, BQ satisfies the ordinary Maxwell equations while Bx experiences a Meissner effect. The mixing angle Qo is the analogue of the Weinberg angle in electroweak theory, in which the presence of the Higgs condensate causes the A^ and the third SU{2)w gauge boson to mix to form the photon, A^, and the massive Z boson, sin(ao) is proportional to e/g and turns out to be about 1/20 in the 2SC phase and 1/40 in the CFL phase. 53 This means that the Q-photon which propagates in color superconducting quark matter is mostly photon with only a small gluon admixture. If a color superconducting neutron star core is subjected to an ordinary magnetic field, it will either expel the X component of the flux or restrict it to flux tubes, but it can (and does 53 ) admit the great majority of the flux in the form of a BQ magnetic field satisfying Maxwell's equations. The decay in time of this "free field" (i.e. not in flux tubes) is limited by the Q-conductivity of the quark matter. A color superconductor is not a Qsuperconductor — that is the whole point — but it turns out to be a very good (^-conductor due to the presence of electrons: the BQ magnetic field decays only on a time scale which is much longer than the age of the universe. 53 This means that a quark matter core within a neutron star serves as an "anchor" for the magnetic field: whereas in ordinary nuclear matter the magnetic flux tubes can be dragged outward by the neutron superfluid vortices as the star spins down, 54 the magnetic flux within the color superconducting core simply
10
cannot decay. Even though this distinction is a qualitative one, it will be difficult to confront it with data since what is observed is the total dipole moment of the neutron star. A color superconducting core anchors those magnetic flux lines which pass through the core, while in a neutron star with no quark matter core the entire internal magnetic field can decay over time. In both cases, however, the total dipole moment can change since the magnetic flux lines which do not pass through the core can move. 3
Crystalline Color Superconductivity and Glitches in Quark Matter
The final consequence of color superconductivity we wish to discuss is the possibility that (some) glitches may originate within quark matter regions of a compact star. 48 In any context in which color superconductivity arises in nature, it is likely to involve pairing between species of quarks with differing chemical potentials. If the chemical potential difference is small enough, BCS pairing occurs as we have been discussing. If the Fermi surfaces are too far apart, no pairing between the species is possible. The transition between the BCS and unpaired states as the splitting between Fermi momenta increases has been studied in electron superconductors, 55 nuclear superfluids56 and QCD superconductors, 8,9 ' 57 assuming that no other state intervenes. However, there is good reason to think that another state can occur. This is the "LOFF" state, first explored by Larkin and Ovchinnikov58 and Fulde and Ferrell59 in the context of electron superconductivity in the presence of magnetic impurities. They found that near the unpairing transition, it is favorable to form a state in which the Cooper pairs have nonzero momentum. This is favored because it gives rise to a region of phase space where each of the two quarks in a pair can be close to its Fermi surface, and such pairs can be created at low cost in free energy. Condensates of this sort spontaneously break translational and rotational invariance, leading to gaps which vary periodically in a crystalline pattern. If in some shell within the quark matter core of a neutron star (or within a strange quark star) the quark number densities are such that crystalline color superconductivity arises, rotational vortices may be pinned in this shell, making it a locus for glitch phenomena. In Ref. 4 8 , we have explored the range of parameters for which crystalline color superconductivity occurs in the QCD phase diagram, upon making various simplifying assumptions. We focus primarily on a toy model in which the quarks interact via a four-fermion interaction with the quantum numbers of single gluon exchange. Also, we only consider pairing between u and d quarks, with fid = p, + S/x and fiu — jl — S/j,, whereas we expect a LOFF state
11
wherever the difference between the Fermi momenta of any two quark flavors is near an unpairing transition, including, for example, near the unlocking phase transition between the 2SC and CFL phases. In the LOFF state, each Cooper pair carries momentum 2q with |q| « 1.2(5/x. The condensate and gap parameter vary in space with wavelength 7r/|q|. In Ref. 48 , we simplify the calculation by assuming that the condensate varies in space like a plane wave, leaving the determination of the crystal structure of the QCD LOFF phase to future work. We give an ansatz for the LOFF wave function, and by variation obtain a gap equation which allows us to solve for the gap parameter A^, the free energy and the values of the diquark condensates which characterize the LOFF state at a given 6fi and |q|. We then vary |q|, to find the preferred (lowest free energy) LOFF state at a given dfx, and compare the free energy of the LOFF state to that of the BCS state with which it competes. We show results for one choice of parameters 6 in Fig. 1(a). The LOFF state is characterized by a gap parameter A^ and a diquark condensate, but not by an energy gap in the dispersion relation: we obtain the quasiparticle dispersion relations 48 and find that they vary with the direction of the momentum, yielding gaps that vary from zero up to a maximum of A A- The condensate is dominated by the regions in momentum space in which a quark pair with total momentum 2q has both members of the pair within ~ A^ of their respective Fermi surfaces. Because it violates rotational invariance by involving Cooper pairs whose momenta are not antiparallel, the quark matter LOFF state necessarily features condensates in both the J = 0 and J = 1 channels. (Cooper pairs in the symmetric J — 1 channel are antisymmetric in color but symmetric in flavor, and are impossible in the original LOFF context of pairing between electrons, which have neither color nor flavor.) Both J = 0 and J = 1 condensates are present even if there is no interaction in the J = 1 channel, as is the case when we use a four-fermion interaction with the quantum numbers of Lorentz-invariant single gluon exchange. Because there is no interaction in the J = 1 channel, the J = 1 condensate does not affect the quasiparticle dispersion relations; that is, the J — 1 gap parameter vanishes. The LOFF state is favored for values of S^i which satisfy 6fii < 5fi < <5/i2 as shown in Fig. 1(b), with <S/ii/A0 = 0.707 and 6fi2/Ao = 0.754 in the weak e O u r model Hamiltonian has two parameters, the four-fermion coupling G and a cutoff A. We often use the value of Ao, the BCS gap obtained at Sfi = 0, to describe the strength of the interaction: small Ao corresponds to small G. When we wish to study the dependence on the cutoff, we vary A while at the same time varying the coupling G such that Ao is kept fixed. We expect that the relation between other physical quantities and Ao will be reasonably insensitive to variation of A.
12 8(1-1 /AQ
0.05 A
0.04
BCS (A0)
GeV
| -
0.03
8|i/Ao
!
0.02 LOFF(AA) \ 0.01
|
,V 5u/A0
A=1 -6..,,»^-.'
j^-isf A0
Figure 1. (a) LOFF and BCS gap parameters as a function of <5/i, with coupling chosen so that Ao = 40 MeV. At each <5/i we have varied |q| to find the L O F F state with the lowest free energy. The vertical dashed line marks 8(i = Sfii, the value of <5/i above which the L O F F state has lower free energy than BCS. (b) The interval of <S/z within which the L O F F state occurs as a function of the coupling, parametrized by the BCS gap Ao shown in GeV. Here and in (a), the average quark chemical potential p, has been set to 0.4 GeV, corresponding to a baryon density of about 4 to 5 times that in nuclear matter. A crude estimate 4 8 suggests that in quark matter at this density, <5/i ~ 1 5 - 3 0 MeV depending on the value of the density-dependent effective strange quark mass. Below the solid line, there is a LOFF state. Below the dashed line, the BCS state is favored. The different lines of each type correspond to different cutoffs on the four-fermion interaction: A = 0.8 GeV to 1.6 GeV. (5/JI/AO and 5^2/Ao show little cutoff-dependence, and the cutoff-dependence disappears completely as Ao, S/J, —• 0. A = 1 GeV in (a).
coupling limit in which A 0
13
per unit length is fp « (1 - 3 MeV)/(200 - 400 fm 2 ). The reader may be concerned that a glitch deep within the quark matter core of a neutron star may not be observable: the vortices within the crystalline color superconductor region suddenly unpin and leap outward; this loss of angular momentum is compensated by a gain in angular momentum of the layer outside the LOFF region; how quickly, then, does this increase in angular momentum manifest itself at the surface of the star as a glitch? The important point here is that the rotation of any superfluid region within which the vortices are able to move freely is coupled to the rotation of the outer crust on very short time scales.69 This rapid coupling, due to electron scattering off vortices and the fact that the electron fluid penetrates throughout the star, is usually invoked to explain that the core nucleon superfluid speeds up quickly after a crustal glitch: the only long relaxation time is that of the vortices within the inner crust. 69 Here, we invoke it to explain that the outer crust speeds up rapidly after a LOFF glitch has accelerated the quark matter at the base of the nucleon superfluid. After a glitch in the LOFF region, the only long relaxation times are those of the vortices in the LOFF region and in the inner crust. A quantitative theory of glitches originating within quark matter in a LOFF phase must await further calculations, in particular a three flavor analysis and the determination of the crystal structure of the QCD LOFF phase. However, our rough estimate of the pinning force on rotational vortices in a LOFF region suggests that this force may be comparable to that on vortices in the inner crust of a conventional neutron star. Perhaps, therefore, glitches occurring in a region of crystalline color superconducting quark matter may yield similar phenomenology to those occurring in the inner crust. This is surely strong motivation for further investigation. Perhaps the most interesting consequence of these speculations arises in the context of compact stars made entirely of strange quark matter. The work of Witten 70 and Farhi and Jaffe71 raised the possibility that strange quark matter may be stable relative to nuclear matter even at zero pressure. If this is the case it raises the question whether observed compact stars— pulsars, for example—are strange quark stars 72 ' 73 rather than neutron stars. A conventional neutron star may feature a core made of strange quark matter, as we have been discussing above/ Strange quark stars, on the other hand, are made (almost) entirely of quark matter with either no hadronic matter •"Note that a convincing discovery of a quark matter core within an otherwise hadronic neutron star would demonstrate conclusively that strange quark matter is not stable at zero pressure, thus ruling out the existence of strange quark stars. It is not possible for neutron stars with quark matter cores and strange quark stars to both be stable.
14
content at all or with a thin crust, of order one hundred meters thick, which contains no neutron superfluid.73'74 The nuclei in this thin crust are supported above the quark matter by electrostatic forces; these forces cannot support a neutron fluid. Because of the absence of superfluid neutrons, and because of the thinness of the crust, no successful models of glitches in the crust of a strange quark star have been proposed. Since pulsars are observed to glitch, the apparent lack of a glitch mechanism for strange quark stars has been the strongest argument that pulsars cannot be strange quark stars. 7 5 ' 7 6 , 7 7 This conclusion must now be revisited. Madsen's conclusion50 that a strange quark star is prone to r-mode instability due to the absence of damping must also be revisited, since the relevant oscillations may be damped within or at the boundary of a crystalline color superconductor region. The quark matter in a strange quark star, should one exist, would be a color superconductor. Depending on the mass of the star, the quark number densities increase by a factor of about two to ten in going from the surface to the center. 73 This means that the chemical potential differences among the three quarks will vary also, and there could be a range of radii within which the quark matter is in a crystalline color superconductor phase. This raises the possibility of glitches in strange quark stars. Because the variation in density with radius is gradual, if a shell of LOFF quark matter exists it need not be particularly thin. And, we have seen, the pinning forces may be comparable in magnitude to those in the inner crust of a conventional neutron star. It has recently been suggested (for reasons unrelated to our considerations) that certain accreting compact stars may be strange quark stars, 78 although the evidence is far from unambiguous. 79 In contrast, it has been thought that, because they glitch, conventional radio pulsars cannot be strange quark stars. Our work questions this assertion by raising the possibility that glitches may originate within a layer of quark matter which is in a crystalline color superconducting state. There has been much recent progress in our understanding of how the presence of color superconducting quark matter in a compact star would affect five different phenomena: cooling by neutrino emission, the pattern of the arrival times of supernova neutrinos, the evolution of neutron star magnetic fields, r-mode instabilities and glitches. Nevertheless, much theoretical work remains to be done before we can make sharp proposals for which astrophysical observations can teach us whether compact stars contain quark matter, and if so whether it is in the 2SC or CFL phase.
15
Acknowledgments We acknowledge helpful discussions with P. Bedaque, J. Berges, D. Blaschke, I. Bombaci, G. Carter, D. Chakrabarty, J. Madsen, C. Nayak, M. Prakash, D. Psaltis, S. Reddy, M. Ruderman, S.-J. Rey, T. Schafer, A. Sedrakian, E. Shuryak, E. Shuster, D. Son, M. Stephanov, I. Wasserman, F. Weber and F. Wilczek. KR thanks the organizers of SEWM 2K for an enjoyable conference and for the excuse to visit Provence for the first time. This work is supported in part by the DOE under cooperative research agreement # D F FC02-94ER40818. The work of JB was supported in part by an NDSEG Fellowship; that of KR was supported in part by a DOE OJI Award and by the A. P. Sloan Foundation. References 1. B. Barrois, Nucl. Phys. B129, 390 (1977); S. Frautschi, Proceedings of workshop on hadronic matter at extreme density, Erice 1978; B. Barrois, "Nonperturbative effects in dense quark matter", Cal Tech PhD thesis, UMI 79-04847-mc (1979). 2. D. Bailin and A. Love, Phys. Rept. 107, 325 (1984), and references therein. 3. M. Alford, K. Rajagopal and F. Wilczek, Phys. Lett. B422, 247 (1998). 4. R. Rapp, T. Schafer, E. V. Shuryak and M. Velkovsky, Phys. Rev. Lett. 81, 53 (1998). 5. M. Alford, K. Rajagopal and F. Wilczek, Nucl. Phys. B537, 443 (1999). 6. For reviews, see F. Wilczek, hep-ph/9908480; T. Schafer, nuclth/9911017; S. Hsu, hep-ph/0003140; M. Alford, hep-ph/0003185; D. Rischke and R. Pisarski, nucl-th/0004016; K. Rajagopal, hepph/0009058. 7. T. Schafer and F. Wilczek, Phys. Rev. Lett. 82, 3956 (1999). 8. M. Alford, J. Berges and K. Rajagopal, Nucl. Phys. B558, 219 (1999). 9. T. Schafer and F. Wilczek, Phys. Rev. D60, 074014 (1999). 10. D. H. Rischke, Phys. Rev. D62, 034007 (2000); G. Carter and D. Diakonov, Nucl. Phys. B582, 571 (2000). 11. J. Berges and K. Rajagopal, Nucl. Phys. B538, 215 (1999). 12. R. D. Pisarski and D. H. Rischke, Phys. Rev. Lett. 83, 37 (1999). 13. G. W. Carter and D. Diakonov, Phys. Rev. D60, 016004 (1999). 14. R. Rapp, T. Schafer, E. V. Shuryak and M. Velkovsky, Annals Phys. 280, 35 (2000). 15. D. H. Rischke, Phys. Rev. D62, 054017 (2000).
16
16. S. Chandrasekharan and U. Wiese, Phys. Rev. Lett. 83, 3116 (1999). 17. UKQCD Collaboration, Phys. Rev. D59 (1999) 116002; S. Hands, J. B. Kogut, M. Lombardo and S. E. Morrison, Nucl. Phys. B558, 327 (1999); S. Hands, I. Montvay, S. Morrison, M. Oevers, L. Scorzato and J. Skullerud, hep-lat/0006018. 18. J. B. Kogut, M. A. Stephanov and D. Toublan, Phys. Lett. B464, 183 (1999); J. B. Kogut, M. A. Stephanov, D. Toublan, J. J. Verbaarschot and A. Zhitnitsky, Nucl. Phys. B582, 477 (2000). 19. D. V. Deryagin, D. Yu. Grigoriev and V. A. Rubakov, Int. J. Mod. Phys. A7, 659 (1992). 20. E. Shuster and D. T. Son, Nucl. Phys. B573, 434 (2000). 21. B. Park, M. Rho, A. Wirzba and I. Zahed, Phys. Rev. D62, 034015 (2000). 22. R. Rapp, E. Shuryak and I. Zahed, hep-ph/0008207. 23. N. Evans, S. D. H. Hsu and M. Schwetz, Nucl. Phys. B551, 275 (1999); Phys. Lett. B449, 281 (1999). 24. T. Schafer and F. Wilczek, Phys. Lett. B450, 325 (1999). 25. B. Vanderheyden and A. D. Jackson, hep-ph/0003150. 26. D. T. Son, Phys. Rev. D59, 094019 (1999). 27. R. D. Pisarski and D. H. Rischke, Phys. Rev. D60, 094013 (1999); Phys. Rev. D61, 051501 (2000); Phys. Rev. D61, 074017 (2000); 28. D. K. Hong, Phys. Lett. B473, 118 (2000); Nucl. Phys. B582, 451 (2000). 29. D. K. Hong, V. A. Miransky, I. A. Shovkovy and L. C. Wijewardhana, Phys. Rev. D61, 056001 (2000), erratum ibid. D62, 059903 (2000). 30. T. Schafer and F. Wilczek, Phys. Rev. D60, 114033 (1999). 31. W. E. Brown, J. T. Liu and H. Ren, Phys. Rev. D61, 114012 (2000); Phys. Rev. D62, 054016 (2000); Phys. Rev. D62, 054013 (2000); 32. S. D. Hsu and M. Schwetz, Nucl. Phys. B572, 211 (2000). 33. I. A. Shovkovy and L. C. Wijewardhana, Phys. Lett. B470, 189 (1999). 34. T. Schafer, Nucl. Phys. B575, 269 (2000). 35. N. Evans, J. Hormuzdiar, S. D. Hsu and M. Schwetz, Nucl. Phys. B581, 391 (2000). 36. S. R. Beane, P. F. Bedaque and M. J. Savage, nucl-th/0004013. 37. K. Rajagopal and E. Shuster, hep-ph/0004074. 38. C. Manuel, hep-ph/0005040. 39. For a review, see H. Heiselberg and M. Hjorth-Jensen, Phys. Rept. 328, 237 (2000). 40. N. K. Glendenning and F. Weber, astro-ph/0003426. See also D. Blaschke, H. Grigorian and D. Voskresensky, astro-ph/0009120. 41. M. van der Klis, to appear in Ann. Rev. Astronomy and Astrophysics,
17
(2000) [astro-ph/0001167]. 42. R. Wijnands and M. van der Klis, Nature 394, 344 (1998); D. Chakrabarty and E. Morgan, Nature 394, 346 (1998). 43. L. Bildsten, Astrophys. J. 501 L89 [astro-ph/9804325]; A. Andersson, D. I. Jones, K. D. Kokkotas and N. Stergioulas, astro-ph/0003426. 44. D. Blaschke, T. Klahn and D. N. Voskresensky, astro-ph/9908334. 45. D. Page, M. Prakash, J. M. Lattimer and A. Steiner, hep-ph/0005094. 46. C. Schaab et al, Astrophys. J. Lett 480 (1997) L l l l and references therein. 47. T. Schafer, hep-ph/0006034. 48. M. Alford, J. Bowers and K. Rajagopal, hep-ph/0008208. 49. G. W. Carter and S. Reddy, hep-ph/0005228. 50. J. Madsen, Phys. Rev. Lett. 85, 10 (2000). 51. L. Bildsten and G. Ushomirsky, astro-ph/9911155. 52. D. Blaschke, D. M. Sedrakian and K. M. Shahabasian, astro-ph/9904395. 53. M. Alford, J. Berges and K. Rajagopal, Nucl. Phys. B571, 269 (2000). 54. For reviews, see J. Sauls, in Timing Neutron Stars, J. Ogleman and E. P. J. van den Heuvel, eds., (Kluwer, Dordrecht: 1989) 457; and D. Bhattacharya and G. Srinivasan, in X-Ray Binaries, W. H. G. Lewin, J. van Paradijs, and E. P. J. van den Heuvel eds., (Cambridge University Press, 1995) 495. 55. A. M. Clogston, Phys. Rev. Lett. 9, 266 (1962); B. S. Chandrasekhar, App. Phys. Lett. 1, 7 (1962). 56. A. Sedrakian and U. Lombardo, Phys. Rev. Lett. 84, 602 (2000). 57. P. F. Bedaque, hep-ph/9910247. 58. A. I. Larkin and Yu. N. Ovchinnikov, Zh. Eksp. Teor. Fiz. 47, 1136 (1964); translation: Sov. Phys. JETP 20, 762 (1965). 59. P. Fulde and R. A. Ferrell, Phys. Rev. 135, A550 (1964). 60. S. Takada and T. Izuyama, Prog. Theor. Phys. 41, 635 (1969). 61. M. A. Alpar and C. Ho, Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 204, 655 (1983). For a recent review, see A.G. Lyne in Pulsars: Problems and Progress, S. Johnston, M. A. Walker and M. Bailes, eds., 73 (ASP, 1996). 62. J. Negele and D. Vautherin, Nucl. Phys. A207, 298 (1973). 63. For reviews, see D. Pines and A. Alpar, Nature 316, 27 (1985); D. Pines, in Neutron Stars: Theory and Observation, J. Ventura and D. Pines, eds., 57 (Kluwer, 1991); M. A. Alpar, in The Lives of Neutron Stars, M. A. Alpar et al., eds., 185 (Kluwer, 1995). For more recent developments and references to further work, see M. Ruderman, Astrophys. J. 382, 587 (1991); R. I. Epstein and G. Baym, Astrophys. J. 387, 276 (1992); M. A. Alpar, H. F. Chau, K. S. Cheng and D. Pines, Astrophys. J. 409,
18
64.
65. 66. 67. 68. 69. 70. 71. 72. 73. 74. 75. 76. 77. 78.
79.
345 (1993); B. Link and R. I. Epstein, Astrophys. J. 457, 844 (1996); M. Ruderman, T. Zhu, and K. Chen, Astrophys. J. 492, 267 (1998); A. Sedrakian and J. M. Cordes, Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 307, 365 (1999). N. K. Glendenning, Phys. Rev. D46, 1274 (1992); N. K. Glendenning, Compact Stars (Springer-Verlag, 1997); F. Weber, J. Phys. G. Nucl. Part. Phys. 25, R195 (1999). R. Modler et al, Phys. Rev. Lett. 76, 1292 (1996). P. W. Anderson and N. Itoh, Nature 256, 25 (1975). M. A. Alpar, Astrophys. J. 213, 527 (1977). M. A. Alpar, P. W. Anderson, D. Pines and J. Shaham, Astrophys. J. 278, 791 (1984). M. A. Alpar, S. A. Langer and J. A. Sauls, Astrophys. J. 282, 533 (1984). E. Witten, Phys. Rev. D30, 272 (1984). E. Farhi and R. L. Jaffe, Phys. Rev. D30, 2379 (1984). P. Haensel, J. L. Zdunik and R. Schaeffer, Astron. Astrophys. 160, 121 (1986). C. Alcock, E. Farhi and A. Olinto, Phys. Rev. Lett. 57, 2088 (1986); Astrophys. J. 310, 261 (1986). N. K. Glendenning and F. Weber, Astrophys. J. 400, 647 (1992). A. Alpar, Phys. Rev. Lett. 58, 2152 (1987). J. Madsen, Phys. Rev. Lett. 61, 2909 (1988). R. R. Caldwell and J. L. Friedman, Phys. Lett. B264, 143 (1991). X.-D. Li, I. Bombaci, M. Dey, J. Dey, E. P. J. van den Heuvel, Phys. Rev. Lett. 83, 3776 (1999); X.-D. Li, S. Ray, J. Dey, M. Dey, I. Bombaci, Astrophys. J. 527, L51 (1999); B. Datta, A. V. Thampan, I. Bombaci, astro-ph/9912173; I. Bombaci, astro-ph/0002524. D. Psaltis and D. Chakrabarty, Astrophys. J. 521, 332 (1999); D. Chakrabarty, Phys. World 13, No. 2, 26 (2000).
THE COLORED GLASS CONDENSATE A N D E X T R E M E Q C D E. I A N C U CERN,
Theory
Division,
CH-1211
Geneva
23,
Switzerland
The high energy limit of QCD is controlled by the small-x part of a hadron wavefunction. I argue that this part is universal to all hadrons and is composed of a new form of matter: a Colored Glass Condensate. This matter is weakly interacting at very small x, but is non-perturbative because of the highly occupied boson states which compose the condensate. Such a matter might be studied in high energy lepton-hadron or hadron-hadron interactions.
1
Introduction: Parton saturation at small-a;
There has been much activity in the last few years in an attempt to understand the physics of nuclear and hadronic processes in the regime where Bjorken's x becomes very small 1 _ 1 3 (and References therein). A remarkable feature about this regime is that the gluon density in the hadron wavefunction is so high that perturbation theory breaks down even for a small coupling constant, because of the strong non-linear effects. This is quite similar to high temperature QCD where the physics at the scale g2T is non-perturbative because of the large thermal occupation numbers of the soft gluons 14 (and Refs. therein). The important new phenomenon which is expected in these conditions is parton saturation, which is the fact that the density of partons per unit phase space (dN/d2p± drd2x±) cannot grow forever as x becomes arbitrarilly small (here, r = ln(l/x)). If this growth were to occur, then the cross section for deep inelastic scattering at fixed Q2 would grow unacceptably large and eventually violate unitarity bounds. One rather expects the cross section to approach some asymptotic value at high energy, that is, to saturate. It is also intuitively obvious that this should happen, since if the phase space density becomes too large, repulsive interactions are generated among the gluons, and eventually it will be energetically unfavorable to increase the density anyfurther. Saturation is expected at a phase-space density of order l / a s , a value typical of condensates 6 ' 7 . This, together with the fact that gluons are massless bosons, leads naturally to the expectation that the saturated gluons form a new form of matter, which is a Bose condensate. Since gluons carry color which is a gauge-dependent quantity, any gauge-invariant formulation will neccessarily involve an average over all colors, to restore the in variance. This averaging procedure bears a formal resemblance to the averaging over back19
20
ground fields done for spin glasses 15 . The new matter is therefore called the Colored Glass Condensate 16 (CGC). In what follows, I will briefly explain the assumptions which justify this physical picture, and the mathematical formalism which is used to describe it. 2
The Colored Glass Condensate
The CGC picture holds, strictly speaking, only in the infinite-momentum frame, where the hadron propagates almost at the speed of light, and, by Lorentz contraction, appears to the external probe as an infinitesimally thin two-dimensional sheet located at z — t, or x~ = 0. In what follows, I shall use light-cone (LC) vector notations: for an arbitrary 4-vector wM, I write v" = ( V + , « - , V _ L ) , with v+ = (1/V2)(v° +v3), v~ = {1/V2)(v° - v3), and vx = (vx,v2). The dot product reads then: p • x = p+x~ -\-p~x+ — p± • x±; p~ and p+ are, respectively, the LC energy and longitudinal momentum; correspondingly, x+ and x~ are the LC time and longitudinal coordinate. In the infinite-momentum frame, the parton interpretation makes sense and deep inelastic scattering (DIS) proceeds via the instantaneous absorbtion of the virtual photon 7* (with 4-momentum q^) by some parton in the hadron. The Bjorken XB variable is defined as XB = Q2/2P • q, where Q2 = — <7M<7M, and P M = 6^+P+ with large P+ is the hadron 4-momentum. By kinematics, XB coincides with the longitudinal momentum fraction x = p+ /P+ of the struck parton: XB = x. At x <S 1, the gluon density increases faster, and is the driving force towards saturation. The dynamics responsible for this increase is the BFKL evolution 17 , as I briefly recall now (see also Ref. * and Refs. therein): Let me call soft, respectively fast, a parton having small, respectively, large longitudinal momentum (this separation will be made more precise in a moment). A soft gluon, with p+ = xP+
p+, and thus a longer lifetime. Indeed, by the uncertainty principle, the lifetime of the parton system in Fig. l.a is: A + Ax+ =
1
1 2P+ ~ — = -%- oc x,
(1)
where ek = k\/2k+ is the LC energy of the on-shell excitation with momentum k = (fc+,kj_), and I have used the fact that, for comparable transverse momenta k± and p±, ep » £k,£k-P- To conclude, softer partons have larger energies, and therefore shorter lifetimes.
21
b)
' ^
Figure 1. a) Soft gluon emission by a fast parton; b) a second emission; c) a gluon cascade.
The lowest-order process in Fig. l.a is amended by radiative corrections enhanced by the large rapidity gap A r = ln(fc + /p + ) ~ ln(l/a;). (I assume here that ln(l/x) » 1.) For instance, the probability for the emission of a second gluon with momentumfcj*"in the range k+ > k^ > p+ is (cf. Fig. l.b):
r4
A F oc
dk+
kt
= a.. In
k+
:ln
(2)
and becomes exceedingly large as x -t 0. It is then highly probable that more gluons will be emitted along the way, thus giving birth to the gluon cascade depicted in Fig. I.e. For a fixed number N of gluons in this cascade, the largest contribution, of order (as h ^ l / a ; ) ) ^ , comes from the kinematical domain where £•+ — t + ft
=
ft/Q
> k+
»H
»
»
fc+=p4
(3)
Other momentum orderings give contributions which are suppressed by, at least, one factor of 1/ ln(l/x), and thus can be neglected to leading logarithmic accuracy (LLA). For the dominant contribution in eq. (3), the number of radiated gluons increases exponentially with Ar: N(x) ~ exp{^4as ln(l/x)}, with constant A. This is a coherency effect, consequence of the separation of scales in eq. (3), and of the bosonic nature of the gluons:
22
Indeed, because of its short lifetime, the soft gluon at the lower end of the cascade "sees" the N previous gluons as a frozen color charge distribution, with an average color charge Q = \f{QaQa) oc N. Thus, the N t h gluon is emitted coherently off the color charge fluctuations of the previously emitted gluons, with a differential probability (compare to eq. (2)) : dPN oc asNdrN,
(4)
which implies that N(T) ~ eAa°T, as anticipated. Then, also the gluon density xG(x,Q2) = (dN/dr) oc eAa'T grows exponentially" with r = ln(l/a;). Thus, the BFKL picture is that of an unstable growth of the color charge fluctuations as x becomes smaller and smaller. However, this evolution assumes the radiated gluons to behave as free particles, so it ceases to be valid at very low x, where the gluon density becomes so large that the radiated gluons overlap each other in the transverse plane and start interacting. This is the onset of saturation. This is also the regime where the description in terms of a Colored Glass Condensate becomes appropriate: Because of the hierarchy of scales in eq. (3), the soft gluons "see" the fast partons as an effective color charge which is static (i.e., independent of x+), and localized near the LC (i.e., at x~ = 0), with a random density pa(x~,x±). (This is random since the soft gluons can belong to different cascades, and the instantaneous configuration of the cascades inside the hadron is random. Of course, the integrated color charge over the whole hadron must vanish, because of confinement.) The spatial correlations of the effective charge pa(x~,x±) reflect the quantum dynamics of the fast partons, and are encoded in a statistical weight function W[p]. This color charge acts as a source for the soft gluons which, because of their large occupation numbers, can be treated in the classical approximation. This suggests the following effective theory for the soft gluon correlators, originally proposed by McLerran and Venugopalan 2 : First, one solves the classical Yang-Mills equations with the source pa, and in the LC-gauge6 A+ = 0 :
[^,n
= 6»+Pa(x-,x±).
(5)
In the saturation regime, A ~ p ~ l/g (see Sect. 3.2 below), and eq. (5) must be solved exactly: the classical problem is fully non-perturbative. The nonlinear effects correspond to interactions among the soft gluons, to all orders. The corresponding solution A^ = A^[p] will be constructed in Sect. 3.1. a
A more refined treatment, using the BFKL equation ''This gauge choice will be motivated in Sect. 3.2.
17
, gives A = ANC ln2/7r.
23
Then, the soft correlation functions of interest are obtained as: (A»(X)AZ(V)---)A
= jvPWK[p}A»{x)Al{y)---.
(6)
Note the scale A = A + in eq. (6): this is the separation scale between fast (p+ > A + ) and soft (p+ < A + ) degrees of freedom. Clearly, the structure and the correlations of p will depend upon A (e.g., p has support at x~ ^ 1/A + , and W[p) = WA[P])- Moreover, the soft correlations must be evaluated at longitudinal momenta p+ which are not too small as compared to A + : otherwise, the quantum corrections due to the "semi-fast" gluons with k+ momenta in the range p+ < k+ < A + would be relatively large, of 0 ( Q S ln(A + /p + )), since enhanced by the large rapidity interval A T = ln(A + /p + ) » 1. Remarkably, the equations (5)-(6) are those for a glass (here, a colored glass): There is a source, and the source is averaged over. This is entirely analogous to what is done for spin glasses when averaging over stochastic magnetic fields 1 5 . By computing the two-point function as above, one has found 6 ' 7 a saturation regime where (AlaAla)\ oc l / a s , a value typical for a condensate (see also Sect. 3.2 below). We thus conclude that the matter which describes the small x part of a hadron wavefunction is a Colored Glass Condensate. 3
Saturation in the McLerran-Venugopalan model
In this section, I present the solution to eq. (5) and explore its consequences for the saturation of gluons. 3.1
The non-Abelian Weizsacker-Williams field
Consider first the Abelian version of eq. (5), as a warming up: dvF^
= 5»+p(x),
(7)
where A+ = 0, F " " = d " A v - d"A», and x = (X~,X_L). Eq. (7) can be easily solved in momentum space, with the result that A~ = 0 and
''<•» = - £ 4 ^ y
(8)
y±
Here, one needs a prescription to handle the pole at p+ = 0: different prescriptions correspond to different boundary conditions in x~. For instance,
24
with the "retarded" prescription 0 l/(p+ Ai(x~,x±)
+ie), one obtains dy-dia(y~,x±),
=
(9)
J — oo
with a satisfying — Vj_a(i) = p{x). The vector potential (9) is static, d~A* = (dAi/dx+) = 0, and defines a two-dimensional pure gauge: Tli = 0. But, of course, this is not a pure gauge in four dimensions, since the electric field F%+ = —d+Al — dla is non-zero. The above solution, also known as the Weizsacker-Williams field, is the analog of the Coulomb field in the infinite momentum frame. It turns out that the corresponding non-Abelian solution has a similar structure: Specifically, the solution A^ to eq. (5) in the LC gauge (A+ = 0) can be chosen such as A" = 0, and A1 is static and a two-dimensional pure gauge: T^ = 0. This can be written as follows (for retarded boundary conditions):
A^x-^x.)
= (i/g)U(x-,x±)diUHx~,x±) = Pexp lig
-Via(x)
dz~ a(z~,x±)
(10) i ,
(11)
= ~p{x) = U\x)p{x)U(x),
(12)
where P is the usual path-ordering operator, and p{x) is the value of the classical source in the covariant gauge d^A11 — 0. Note that, while a is linearly related to p, its relation to the LC-gauge source p is more complicated, since the gauge rotations U and W are themselves functionals of a, cf. eq. (11). Thus, in order to perform the average in eq. (6), it is more convenient to use p (rather than p) as the independent variable. This is possible because the measure and the weight function in eq. (6) are gauge invariant; e.g., W A M = W'AIP]- Then, the non-Abelian solution A%\p\ is known explicitly, via eqs. (10)-(12), and eq. (6) is replaced by (A*(x+,g)A*(x+,y)---)A
= JVp
WA[p] A^p) A^p] •••.
(13)
In particular, this equation shows that only the equal-time (x+ = y+) correlators of the soft transverse (/x = i, i = 1,2) fields can be computed in this model; but these are precisely the gluon correlators which are probed in DIS. Recall finally that the source p is created by the fast partons with \p+ \ > + A , so its support is restricted to \x"\ ^ 1/A + . The small-rr external probe, c
Note that the "retardation" refers here to x~, and not to the LC time
x+.
25
on the other hand, is sensitive only to the gross features of the color fields A1 over large distances \x~\ > 1/A+, where one can replace eq. (11) with U*(x-,x±.)
« 8(x~)Pexplig
/
dz~ a{z~ ,x±)\
= 6{x~)v\x1_),
(14)
?i+ « -6{x-)Ai0(x±),
(15)
and therefore (cf. eq. (10)):
A* « 6(x-) - v ^ )
= 6(x-)AUx±),
where, strictly speaking, the ^-function is localized at x~ Js 1/A + . 3.2
Gluon distribution function and saturation
Consider the simple approximation where the weight function for p, which is not yet known, is taken to be a Gaussian 2 :
^A[p]-xp{-i/^||},
(16)
where ^ is the total color charge density squared of the partons with p+ > A + . By using this approximation, it has been possible to compute the gluon distribution function xG(x, Q2) in the MV model 6,T , as I recall now: By definition, G{x,Q2) is the number of gluons in the hadron wavefunction having longitudinal momentum k+ — xP+, and transverse momentum less than Q. In the LC gauge, this is simply related to the Fock-space gluon distribution function6*, and therefore to the gluon two-point function 1:
G<1 2
'« » = / 0 e < « 2 - * > / T5T 2k+ S{x ~ £ ) x(ji(x+,t+,k±)Ai(x+,-lr+,-kj_)),
(17)
where the brackets denote the average over the hadron wavefunction. In the LC-gauge gauge, Fl+(k) = ik+Al(k), and therefore (with k+ = xP+) :
xG(x,Q2) = iJ^Q(Q2-kl)(F^(x+,k)F:+(x+,-k)).
(18)
If the integration over k± were unrestricted, this quantity would be manifestly gauge-invariant. But even for a finite Q2, this has a gauge-invariant meaning Of course, the Fock-space gluon distribution can be defined in any gauge; but it is only in the LC-gauge that the definition (17) can be given a gauge invariant meaning 1 , l s .
26
when evaluated on the non-Abelian Weizsacker-Williams field in Sect. 3.1 16 . In this approximation, Fi+{x+,k) « Ti+{kx_) = - ^ ( f c j . ) (cf. eq. (15)), and xG(x,Q*)*R2J
| ^ |
d
V e - ^ ^ ( < ( 0 ) < ( * x ) )
A
,
(19)
where R is the hadron radius (I have assumed homogeneity in the transverse plane, for simplicity), and the average is to be understood in the sense of eq. (13) with A+ = xP+. Thus, the r.h.s. of eq. (19) is still dependent on x, but only via the respective dependence of the weight function for p. With the Gaussian weight function (16), and the non-linear classical solution in Sect. 3.1, the gluon distribution (19) can be computed exactly 6 ' 7 : U™(0) AZ(x±)) = - ^ — \ / irasNc
-2 x±
,
(20)
where Nc is the number of colors, and Qa oc O:S£A is the saturation momentum and is a function of A + , that is, of Bjorken's x. This equation displays saturation: the vector potential never becomes larger than A1 ~ \/g. This is the maximal occupation number permitted for a classical field, since larger occupation numbers are blocked by repulsive interactions of the gluon field. This interpretation can be made sharper by going to momentum space: If N(k±) is the Fourier transform of (20) [this is the same as (dN/d?k± dr d2x±), the gluon density per unit rapidity and unit transverse phase-space], then: N(k±)
<x as(Q2Jkl)
for
k\ » Q\,
(21)
which is the normal perturbative behavior, but 6 N(k±)
<x -
In %
for
A2QCD
« k\ « Q%,
(22)
which shows a much slower increase, i.e., saturation, at low momenta. Note, however, that the above argument is not rigurous, since the local Gaussian form for W[p] in eq. (16) is valid only at sufficiently large transverse momentum scales so that the effects of high gluon density are small. It is therefore important to verify if saturation comes up similarly with a more realistic form for the weight function, as obtained after including the quantum evolution in x. This will be discussed now. e
I n relativistic heavy ion collisions, one expects 5 Q„ ~ 1 GeV at RHIC, and Qs ~ 2 - 3 GeV at LHC. Thus, at least at LHC, the kinematical window in eq. (22) should be non-negligible.
27
4
The non-linear evolution equation
Because the separation of scales is only logarithmic, the effective theory (5)~ (6) with scale A + applies only to gluon correlations at a scale p+ slightly below A + . If one is interested in correlations at the softer scale 6A+ with i « 1, then, to LLA, one has to include also the corrections of order as \n(l/b) due to the semi-fast quantum fluctuations with longitudinal momenta in the strip bA+ < \k+\ < A+.
(23)
Together with the dynamical information already contained in the effective theory at scale A + ("Theory I"), these additional corrections will determine the effective theory at the softer scale 6A+ ("Theory II"). This suggests an iterative construction of the effective theory where the quantum fluctuations are integrated out in layers of k+, down to the physical scale of interest. At each step in this procedure, the quantum corrections must be computed to leading order in as ln(l/6) (LLA), but to all orders in the strong background field A1 ~ l/g produced by the color source p at the previous step. To compute quantum corrections, one needs the quantum generalization of the McLerran-Venugopalan model 8 - 9 ' 10 . This is obtained by replacing eq. (6) with (below, the gauge condition A+ = 0 is implicit):
J
{
f VA elSlA>ri
J
which involves two functional integrals: a quantum path integral over the soft (k+ < A + ) gluon fields A11, which defines quantum expectation values at fixed p, and a classical average over p, with weight function WA[P]- (This double averaging is similar to the one performed for spin systems at finite temperature and in a random external magnetic field 1B.) Unlike eq. (6), the 2-point function given by eq. (24) is independent of the arbitrary separation scale A + : the cutoff dependence of the quantum loops cancels against the corresponding dependence of the classical weight function WA[P]. The action 5[-4,p] is chosen such as to be gauge-invariant and reproduce the classical equations of motion (5) in the saddle point approximation SS/SA" = 0. It reads 8 : S = SYM +SW, where SYM = / d 4 x { - F * j 4 ) is the Yang-Mills action, and Sw is a gauge-invariant generalization of the eikonal vertex J
= - ^ - / d3x Tr lp(x)T
exp (ig
f dx+A~(x+,x)
j 1 .
(25)
28
Theories I and II are denned as in eq. (24), but with separation scales equal to A + , and bA+, respectively. The difference AW = Wb&—W\ can be obtained by matching calculations of gluon correlations at the scale p+ ^ 6A + in the two theories 16 . In Theory II, and to lowest order in as, these correlations are found at tree level, i.e., in the classical approximation. In Theory I, and to the same accuracy, they involve also the logarithmically enhanced quantum corrections due to the "semi-fast" fluctuations denned by eq. (23). The result can be expressed as an evolution equation^ for WT[p] (with r = l n ( P + / A + ) ) with respect to variations in r, originally derived in Ref. 9 . This reads:
in condensed notations where (with x~ = 1/A+ = e 7 " ^ ) , e.g.,
T - [WTax] = / d2x± -——
f^ rCTa (x x )l,
°Px
L
J
Opa(XT ,X±)
(27)
J
and the functions cra(x±) and Xab(x±,y±) are the one- and two-point correlators of the color charge 6pa(x) of the semi-fast quantum fluctuations: asln-aa(x±) as^TXab(xj_,yj_)
= / dx~ {Spa(x+,x~,xj_))p,
(28)
= / dx~ \ dy~ (8pa(x+ ,x~,xj_)6pb(x+,y~,y±))p
.
Thus, a and \ a r e (generally non-linear) functionals of p obtained by averaging over the semi-fast quantum fluctuations in the presence of the tree-level fields and sources, A1 and p. To the order of interest, the semi-fast fields can be integrated out in the Gaussian approximation; thus, the Feynman graphs contributing to a and x involve, at most, one loop. Some typical contributions to lowest order in p are shown in Fig. 2. As one can see on these figures, a is a one-loop virtual correction to the tree-level source and describes vacuum polarisation, while \ is a tree diagram which describes the real emission of a semi-fast gluon (cf. Fig l.b). The functional equation (26) is equivalent to an infinite hierarchy of ordinary equations for the correlators of the charge density. For instance, by multiplying eq. (26) with pxpy and functionally integrating over p, one obtains an evolution equation for the two-point function: - J - (PxPy)r
= as (Xxy + Px<7y + ^xPy)r
,
ar •^This equation insures that correlation functions like (24) are independent of A+.
(29)
29
Figure 2. Contributions to a (a) and x (t>) to lowest order in p. Wavy lines with a blob denote insertions of p; the continuous lines are propagators of the semi-fast gluons; the external, dotted, lines carry soft momenta.
which in general involves also the higher n-point functions, via a and xBut in the limit of a weak source, i.e., with a and x computed to lowest order in p, this becomes a closed equation for (pp) which coincides with the BFKL equation 8 , as necessary on physical grounds. This is a very non-trivial check of the effective theory in eqs. (24)-(25). Specifically, the linear (in p) contribution to a depicted in Fig. 2.a is evaluated as:
^-^^mm*-'1Nr„,_x
f d2p_L f cPkjL ,-,„. _ , v „ . p± -kj_ - * tx ) - z j
Plkl
'(
with the "form factor" „ — ibA+x
F(x~)
= 9{x-)
-iA H
—e
(31)
which has support at 1/A + ^ x ^ l/bA+, and yields the expected logarithmic enhancement (cf. eq. (28)) after the integration over x~:
I
dx -F(x~)
= ln-.
(32)
The kernel of the two-dimensional integral in eq. (30) can be recognized as the virtual part of the BFKL kernel; the corresponding real part is generated by x when evaluated to lowest order in p (cf. Fig. 2.b) 8 . The general, non-linear, expressions for a and x valid in the saturation regime will be presented somewhere else 16 . (See also Ref. 10 for an alter-
30
native calculation, with different results though.) Here, I would like only to emphasize the longitudinal structure of the quantum corrections, which is already manifest on the linear approximation (30)-(31) : Since generated by modes with k+ momenta in the strip (23), the induced source (5p) is localized at 1/A+ £s x~ ;$ 1/6A + , that is, on top of the tree-level source p (which has support at 0 ;$ x~ ^ 1/A+). Because of that, the functional derivatives in eqs. (26)-(27) are to be evaluated at x~ = x~ = 1/A + : the evolution from WT[p] to Wr+d-rtp] is due to changes in p within the rapidity interval (r, T + dr). In fact, the precise longitudinal picture depends upon the it prescription for the "axial" pole l/p+ in the LC-gauge propagator of the semi-fast gluons 9 . The result in eq. (31) has been obtained 16 by using the retarded prescription l / ( p + + is), for consistency with the classical solution (10)-(12). If the advanced prescription l/{p+ —ie) was used instead, the corresponding (5pa(x)) would be located at negative x~, but its integral over x~ — which defines a(x±), cf. eq. (28) — would nevertheless be the same. That is, the BFKL equation is obtained independently of the axial prescription. This is, however, specific to the linearized (or BFKL) limit of the evolution equation. In general, the non-linear effects depend upon the gauge condition, as shown by the explicit calculations of a and \ using different prescriptions io,i6 rpjjg s i m p i e s t results 16 are obtained by using the retarded, or the advanced, prescriptions alluded to before. With a retarded prescription, both the classical mean field Ala, eq. (15), and the induced source (Spa), eq. (30), sit at x~ > 0, or z < t; that is, the soft gluons fields are behind their source, the hadron (which is located at z = t). It is intuitively plausible that within this picture there are no initial state gluon interactions. This is the counterpart of the conclusion of Mueller and Kovchegov 7 ' 5 who used an advanced prescription l / ( p + — if), and showed that all the final state gluon interactions disappeared. These two prescriptions are simple in that one can either put gluon interactions in the final or initial state. Other gauge conditions such as LeibbrandtMandelstam or principle value do not have this simple feature, and lead to other complications for computations as well 16 . Of course, gauge invariant quantities must come out the same whatever gauge is used for their computation. But the classical color charge pa(x) is not a physical observable by itself, but just a convenient tool to summarize the (generally, gauge-variant) correlations inherited by the soft gluons from the fast partons. The discrepancies between the results for a and \ found in Refs. 10 - 12 ' 13 and Ref. 16 9
T h i s prescription is necessary for fixing the residual gauge freedom in the LC-gauge.
31
may be ultimately attributed to the different methods used to fix the gauge. In fact, our results 16 are consistent with some previous results by Balitskii 3 and Kovchegov 4 , to which they reduce in the large JVC limit. To conclude, the non-linear evolution equation (26) together with the expressions for a and \ t 0 be presented in Ref. 16 provide a theoretical framework to perform calculations in the saturation regime. Further studies within this framework should lead to a quantitative understanding of unitarity in high energy scattering, and of the structure of final states and multiparticle production 2 ' 4 . This would have important applications to the theory of deep inelastic scattering, hadronic interactions and ultrarelativistic nuclear collisions. References 1. A.H. Mueller, hep-ph/9911289. 2. L. McLerran and R. Venugopalan, Phys. Rev. D49, 2233 (1994); 49, 3352 (1994); 50, 2225 (1994). 3. I. Balitskii, Nucl. Phys. B463, 99 (1996). 4. Yu.V. Kovchegov, Phys. Rev. D60, 034008 (1999); D61, 074018 (2000). 5. A.H. Mueller, Nucl. Phys. B558, 285 (1999). 6. J. Jalilian-Marian, A. Kovner, L. McLerran and H. Weigert, Phys. Rev. D55, 5414 (1997). 7. Yu.V. Kovchegov and A.H. Mueller, Nucl. Phys. B529, 451 (1998). 8. J. Jalilian-Marian, A. Kovner, A. Leonidov and H. Weigert, Nucl. Phys. B504, 415 (1997). 9. J. Jalilian-Marian, A. Kovner, A. Leonidov, H. Weigert, Phys. Rev. D59, 014014 (1999). 10. J. Jalilian-Marian, A. Kovner and H. Weigert, Phys. Rev. D59, 014015 (1999). 11. Y. Kovchegov and L. McLerran, Phys. Rev. D60, 054025 (1999). 12. A. Kovner and G. Milhano, Phys. Rev. D61, 014012 (2000). 13. A. Kovner, G. Milhano and H. Weigert, Phys. Rev. D62, 114005 (2000). 14. E. Iancu, in Strong and Electroweak Matter '98, ed. J. Ambj0rn (World Scientific, Singapore, 1999), hep-ph/9903486. 15. G. Parisi and N. Sourlas, Phys. Rev. Lett. 43, 744 (1979). 16. E. Iancu, A. Leonidov and L. McLerran, "Nonlinear Gluon Evolution in the Colored Glass Condensate", to be published. 17. L.N. Lipatov, Sov. J. Nucl. Phys. 23, 338 (1976); E.A. Kuraev, L.N. Lipatov and V.S. Fadin, Sov. Phys. JETP 45, 199 (1977); Ya.Ya. Balitskii and L.N. Lipatov, Sov. J. Nucl. Phys. 28, 822 (1978).
A S P E C T S OF PARITY, CP, A N D TIME R E V E R S A L VIOLATION IN HOT QCD DMITRI E. KHARZEEV, ROBERT D. PISARSKI Physics Department Brookhaven National Laboratory Upton, New York 11973-5000, USA MICHEL H.G. TYTGAT Physique Theorique, CP225, Universite Libre de Bruxelles Bid du Triomphe, 1050 Bruxelles, Belgium We discuss various aspects of parity, CP, and time reversal invariances in QCD. In particular, we focus attention on the previously proposed possibility that these experimentally established symmetries of strong interactions may be broken at finite temperature and/or density. This would have dramatic signatures in relativistic heavy ion collisions; we describe some of the most promising signals.
1
Introduction
It is commonly accepted that strong interactions do not break parity or CP. This is because in QCD, CP violation can arise only through a non-zero value of the 9 angle, and the experimental limit 1 on the neutron dipole electric moment imposes a stringent limit 9 < 3 10~ 10 . Why 9 is so close to zero in Nature is a fundamental question, known as the "Strong CP Problem". There are various proposed solutions to this problem, the most popular being the axion hypothesis (see 2 ), but the discussion of these solutions is not the topic of this talk. Instead we shall assume that, for whatever reason, 9 — 0 precisely, and discuss the behavior of the theory at finite temperature and/or density 3 . If 9 = 0, a theorem by Vafa and Witten states that the vacuum is unique and conserves CP 4 . There are circumstances under which the Vafa-Witten theorem does not apply, however. For instance, no conclusion can be drawn in the presence of a finite net density of quarks. Indeed, the existence of degenerate vacuum states with opposite parity in the superconducting phase of QCD has been discussed by Pisarski and Rischke 5 , and the (pseudoscalar) pion condensate at finite isospin density has been found by Son and Stephanov 6 . If 9 — 7r, the theorem also does not apply. A priori, this corresponds to a CP conserving case because 9 —>• — 9, w and —TT are equivalent modulo 2ir. However, CP can still be spontaneously broken, a phenomenon discovered by Dashen before the advent of QCD 7 . Finally, the theorem is only a statement
32
33 about the ground state of the theory. In particular, it does not preclude the existence of metastable vacua within which CP is broken. In this talk we gather some of the evidence for the existence of extra vacua in hot QCD, and discuss its possible relevance to the ongoing relativistic heavy ion program. 2
0 vacuum in gluodynamics
Consider the Euclidean Yang-Mills action with gauge group SU(NC),
where F^ = ^c^apFap. Because the integrand in the second term is a total derivative q{x) = 1/327T2 TxFF — d^K^, it cannot influence equations of motion on the classical level, and all 9 dependence is through the quantum anomaly. In the dilute instanton gas approximation, the ground state energy is E(e)<xe-8"*!g3cos6,
(2)
which illustrates that 9 is an angle. While the dilute instanton gas should be an adequate concept at high temperature, when the instantons are suppressed by screening, we would like to rely on another approximation in the confined phase. Unfortunately, lattice simulations are inefficient for 9 ^ 0, and the only reliable analytical limit of the theory we know of is the case of large Nc. The large Nc limit 8 is reached by rescaling the gauge coupling g2 —> A = g2Nc, with A kept fixed as Nc —» oo. Similarly, one must rescale 9 to 6/Nc. The latter implies that the low energy effective action for YM theory in the confined phase takes the form Ceff = N2 C[9,d*,...,0/Nc]
(3)
where $ denotes some generic colorless (glueball) state, with mass M$ = 0(N°). The N2 factor comes from counting the number of degrees of freedom. In particular the vacuum energy as function of 9 is E[6] = N2 F[6/Nc]
(4)
To leading order at large Nc, E[9] a N2F{0] + \X 02
(5)
where \ = / ^ (
34 requirement of E[6] = E[6 + 2n]. The remedy has been proposed by Witten 9. If one takes El8} = N?rninF^±^-^
(6)
the vacuum energy becomes a multivalued function, with k labelling the different branches. A similar construction is known to arise, for instance, in the Schwinger model 10 . The expression (6) is quite remarkable: it predicts that
Figure 1. Vacuum energy in gluodynamics as a function of 6. At fixed 9, there is a ground state and a tower of extra vacua.
for each fixed 0, there is a tower of extra vacua (see Fig.l). A corollary is that at 0 = w mod 27r there are two degenerate vacua and CP is spontaneously broken. Also, there is a stable domain wall in the spectrum, very much like in the Schwinger model. If 0 departs from n, one of the vacua becomes unstable. The decay rate of this false vacuum has been estimated to scale with the number of colors as T ~ exp(--/Vc4) 9 . u . 1 2 ' 1 3 - as Nc —>• oo, the metastable (lowest lying) vacua become stable. 3
Vacuum in QCD with Nf light quark flavors
The low energy phenomenological Lagrangian that incorporates both leading order quark mass and large Nc effects is i 4 . 15 . 16 . 17 + Y,Re[tx{MU]j\
C= ^t^d^d^U)
- | ( 0 + i logdet U)2
(7)
where M = diag(m u , md, ms) is the quark mass matrix, S = \(qq)\, U = exp i" X" I fn is a Nf x Nf unitary matrix and the 4>a are the a — 1, . . . , N% would be Goldstone modes. Specialising to the neutral modes, the potential term in (7) gives
V =- £ i=u,d,s
m,-Eco8|i + | ( » - Y. *'-//*)2
(§)
i=u,d,s
A non-vanishing topological susceptibility explicitly breaks the U(1)A symmetry and gives a mass to the rj meson, rr?, « xlfl 18,19 - I n Nature, the
35 value of the susceptibility in the vacuum is \ ~ (180 M e V ) 4 . In one plots the potential for realistic values of the quark mass, the result is a set of almost perfect parabolic curves : this is because the 8 term d o m i n a t e s over the terms containing the quark masses. a In the large Nc limit, because E oc Nc, things become more interesting. To simplify the discussion, let us concentrate on the case of one light quark flavor, with pseudo-Goldstone field rj. For 8 = 0, the potential energy at large Nc is as in Fig.2. There is an absolute m i n i m u m at rj = 0 and extra local m i n i m a at rj « 2?r k. These extra m i n i m a violate CP because (9) = ^
« X (v) ^
-X
(r,)
(9)
A technical remark is in order here. T h e potential (8) is not periodic in the
Figure 2. Potential for rj at large Nc and 8 = 0.
flavor singlet phase. On the other hand it is periodic in 8. Specialising again to one light quark flavor, we see t h a t a shift 8 -4 8 + 27r is compensated by rj —>• rj — 27T. Incidentally, this remark provides us with a way to derive the pure Yang-Mills potential introduced in the previous section. In the large Nc limit, one can integrate out the rj field to the E[6] « \
X
min(0 + k (rj))2
-X
min(0 + k 2n)
I
(10)
k
This construction is ad hoc as the 77 field is essentially m a d e of quark-antiquark pairs while the pure YM potential should be m a d e of gluons. This is remedied if we postulate the existence of a heavy pseudoscalar "glueball" field Q 2 2 and consider instead the following modified Nj = 1 potential 1 V = - A 4 cos Q - mE cos rj + -\{0
+ Q + ijy
(11)
T h i s potential is now manifestly 27r-periodic in 6 and rj and Q. T h e fact t h a t understanding the 8 dependence requires the introduction of a gluonic field is perhaps not surprising - after all, the physical rj' field must contain a "Some interesting features arise at 6 ~ 7r; these include Dashen's phenomenon and the appearance of stable domain walls, but unfortunately this is beyond the scope of this talk 2 0 > 2 1 .
36 significant gluonic component. Similar potentials, with extra heavy degrees of freedom, have been suggested to arise in some supersymmetric YM theories, like M = I SYM 2 3 . 2 4 . 2 5 . Various arguments indicate t h a t these degree of freedom should become very heavy in the large Nc limit, M n cc Nc.2b. T h i s is unlike the usual glueball states, whose mass is 0(NC). If we integrate out the heavy Q field, the effective potential becomes multivalued, pretty much like the pure Yang-Mills potential of Eq. (6). Such a potential has been constructed in 2 6 , starting from the Q C D partition function.
False Vacua (C.'i> conjugaLcl
Vacuum (identify)
Figure 3. Amended potential for j] at 0 = 0. The relative scales have been chosen so as to give a pleasant picture.
4
U(\)A
s y m m e t r y at finite t e m p e r a t u r e a n d d e n s i t y
T h e considerations of the last section should apply in the limit of very large number of colors, Nc —> oo. Inversely, for fixed 7VC, the same effects would arise if the topological susceptibility \ drops with respect to its vacu u m expectation value, \ ~ (180 MeV) 2 3 or, in other words, if there is an a p p r o x i m a t e restoration of U{1)A symmetry. This could arise at finite temp e r a t u r e a n d / o r density. Let us consider again the limit of large n u m b e r of colors. At very high t e m p e r a t u r e , because of Debye screening in the deconfined phase of Q C D , the instanton calculus is reliable. Contributions to the topological susceptibility are then exponentially small x ~ e x P ( — Nc/\) ~ 0. On the other hand, in the confined phase, \ ~ 0 ( 1 ) . T h e transition between these two behaviors is not well understood. Toy model calculations ux D — 1 + 1 show t h a t the instanton picture can be extended all the way down to the critical t e m p e r a t u r e , but not beyond 27>29>30. b In D = 3 + 1, t
I n D = 3 + 1 , the A d S / C F T has shed some light on this issue. Instanton calculus is applicable in theories with conformal invariance, as Af = 4 SYM 3 2 , or when supersymmetry allows
37 lattice simulations of the topological susceptibility show a similar behavior: the topological susceptibility is essentially constant at low temperature, and then drops sharply near Tc. 34>35. Whether this effect permits the appearance of metastable vacua is hard to answer. If we nevertheless naively extrapolate the range of validity of the effective potential (7) to higher temperature, we see that \ must drop dramatically because the existence of the extra vacua is controlled by the mass of the lightest quarks, x(^c)/x(0) ~ 5% 3 C• While the current lattice simulations do not seem to see such a large suppression, they are not far from it. Also, things could improve at finite T and /i, where /i is the quark chemical potential. The argument is as follows. If the U(1)A symmetry is effectively restored at Tc, then universality arguments suggest that the chiral phase transition should be first order, driven by fluctuations 36 . Consider now the phase diagram for QCD with two light quark flavors in the plane of temperature and chemical potential, T — fi. Even though there is no phase transition along the /z = 0 axis, various arguments suggests that there is a line of first order phase transitions, terminated by a critical point (T*,/J») 37 . The position of the point is uncertain, since it is influenced by various effects. For instance if the mass of the strange quark were below some critical value m*, the critical point would move toward the temperature axis and the chiral symmetry breaking phase transition would be first order everywhere. A similar conclusion would be reached if the U(1)A symmetry was restored. This could be controlled by changing the number of colors, for instance . The fact that Ac is a discrete variable is not really an issue here. What we want to emphasize is that, perhaps, Nc = 3 is close to a critical value, N*, at which the U(1)A symmetry is restored, which would "explain" why lattice simulations show a sharp drop near Tc even though Nc is only A"c = 3. By the same token, the restoration of U(1)A could become more pronounced closer to the critical point. These arguments suggest that CP-odd false vacua might exist in hot QCD. While our assumptions might be wrong, they aren't completely crazy, at least to us. If anything, we have exhibited an explicit mechanism through which CP and P-odd effects could exist in QCD, despite the fact that 9 « 0 to a very high precision in Nature. Whether these effects states could have observable consequences is another question. Metastable vacua such as those discussed here could be formed in the early universe, near the QCD phase transition, or in heavy ion collisions. The latter possibility will be the topic of the last section. Of course, the outcome will depend very much on the probability of formation of these metastable states, of their size and number density and, finally, on their lifetime. Once they are allowed to exist, a metastable region is easily formed assuming that the phase of the singlet Goldstone mode, to holomorphically interpolate between weak and strong couplings. In non-supersymmetric theories, however, there seems to be a drastic transition between the instanton and the large Nc description . c This is one of the manifestations of the fact there can be no CP violation if any of the quark is massless. Ideally one would prefer a dynamical explanation, such as the one provided by the instanton liquid picture. 3 1
38 i.e. Oeff, is initially random, as the root mean square of 6efj is quite large, {&ejj)rms = 27r/v3. The size IB of a CP-odd bubble is harder to estimate given the uncertainties of our model, but it could be as large as a few fermi. Finally, the lifetime will depends of the relative size of the false and true vacua region, the difference in pressure between these regions (which could be rather small if U(1)A is very nearly restored), and other factors, like the viscosity of the medium. All together, there are many uncertainties. The most favorable case is obviously if very large bubbles, of about the size of the hot region, can be formed. On the opposite, if many tiny CP-odd regions form and quickly collapse, all CP violating effect would average to zero. Whether this or the former (or none of the above) is realized is a question which, at this stage, can only answered by the experiments. 5
Parity odd bubbles in heavy ion collisions: the observables
Hot QCD matter can be produced and studied in ongoing experiments with relativistic heavy ion collisions. It is therefore important to investigate the possible signatures associated with the excitation of metastable states discussed above. From (8), (11) it is clear that these states will act like regions of nonzero 9. Parity, CP, and time invariance will be violated spontaneously in such a region. The first signature of such states stems from the observation that when the anomaly term a becomes small, there is maximal violation of isospin. 39,40,41,42 At zero temperature, the nonet of pseudo-Goldstone bosons — the n's, K's, r], and rj', are, to a good approximation, eigenstates of SU(3) flavor. It is not often appreciated, but this is really due to the fact that the anomaly term is large, splitting off the rf to be entirely an SU(3) singlet. When the anomaly term becomes small, however, while the charged pseudo-Goldstone bosons remain approximate eigenstates of flavor, the neutral ones do not. Without the anomaly, the n° becomes pure uu, the rj pure dd, and the rf pure ss. Consequently, these three mesons become light. This is especially pronounced for the rj, as it sheds all of its strangeness, to become purely dd. Thus the rj and rj' would be produced copiously, and would manifest itself in at least two ways. First, light 77's and rj"s decay into two photons, and so produce an excess at low momentum. Secondly, these mesons decay into pions, which would be seen in Bose-Einstein correlations 43 . Further, through Dalitz decays, the enhanced production of 77's and rj"s will enhance the yield of low mass dileptons 42 . Recently, a detailed study of the rj and 77' enhancement was carried out by Ahrensmeier, Baier and Dirks 44 , who considered the dynamical evolution of these fields in the decay of the P-odd bubbles. Their result is a dramatic enhancement in the production of flavor-singlet mesons, leading to about a hundred particles in a single event. Similar studies, were recently presented by Buckley, Fugleberg, and Zhitnitsky 45 . The maximal violation of isospin is true whenever the anomaly term becomes small. There are other signals which only appear when parity odd bubbles are produced. Since parity is spontaneously violated in such a bub-
39 ble, various decays, not allowed in the parity symmetric vacuum, are possible. Most notably, the ;; can decay not just to three pions, as at zero temperature, but to two pions. Because of the kinematics, in a parity odd bubble, r] —)• 7r°7r° is allowed, but r) —• 7r+7r~ is not. Unfortunately, the search for the parity violating decays will be made difficult by the fact that the masses of the 7] and 77' in the bubble are different from their canonical values, and depend on the temperature of the system. There is another measure of how parity may be violated 3 , which we will now discuss following the paper 46 . We first argue by analogy. Consider propagation in a background magnetic field. As charged particles propagate in the magnetic field, those with positive charge are bent one way, and those with negative charge, the other. This could be observed by measuring the following variable globally, on an event-by-event basis:
^ bVxf.-M
J=
(12)
here z is the beam axis, and p are the three momenta of the pions. If the quarks were propagating through a background chromo-magnetic field, then J, which is like handedness in jet physics, 47 is precisely the right quantity. However, a parity odd bubble is not directly analogous to a background chromo-magnetic field: TT+'S and 7r~'s propagate in a region with constant but nonzero (f> in the same fashion. Consider, however, the edge of the parity odd bubble: in such a region, U^d^U is nonzero, and does rotate 7r+ and TX~ in opposite directions. Thus it is the edges of parity odd bubbles which contribute to the parity odd asymmetry of (12). Purely on geometric grounds, this suggests that a reasonable estimate for the maximal value of V is on the order of a few percent. Let us now construct global observables which are odd under the discrete symmetries of V, C, and/or CV using only the momenta of charged pions in an event. Our discussion will be general, independent of whatever detailed mechanism might produce nonzero values for these variables. For the collisions of nuclei with equal atomic number, as the initial state is even under V, the observation of a P-odd final state must be due to parity violation, such as by a P-odd bubble. Based upon our specific model 3 , we will then give a rough estimate of the magnitude of the 'P-odd and CP-odd effects; we find that the asymmetries can be relatively large, at least ~ 10~ 3 . At high energy, nucleus-nucleus collisions produce many pions, on the order of ~ 1000 per unit rapidity at RHIC energies. Experimentally, it is probably easiest to detect charged pions and their three-momenta. (All of our comments apply equally well to charged kaons.) Thus we are led to consider constructing observables only from the three-momenta of ^ + ' s , p + , and TT~'S, p_. As vectors, under parity the three-momenta transform as V : p+^-p+ Charge conjugation switches n
+
, p- ->• - p _ .
(13)
and n~,
C : p + <-> p_.
(14)
40
Lastly, time reversal, T, acts like parity on the pion momenta, switching their sign: p+ —»• —p+ and p_ —• —p_ under T. It is a theorem that any P-odd invariant formed from three-vectors can be represented as a sum of terms, each of which involves one antisymmetric epsilon tensor 4 8 . The variable which we considered previously (12) is of this type 3 . In order to form J we have introduced an arbitrary, fixed vector of unit norm, z. If z —> — z under parity, then J is odd under V. In J we use the unit vectors p± = P±/|p±| so that it is a pure, dimensionless number. The variable J is separately odd under V and C, and so is even under CV. It is even under T and CVT• The variable J is closely analogous to "handedness", originally introduced to study spin dependent effects in jet fragmentation 47 . There the axis z is usually defined by the thrust of the jet, with p+ and p_ representing the directions of pions formed in the fragmentation of the jet. Correlations between the handedness of different jets produced in a given event are sensitive to CV-violating effects 47 . It is not difficult to construct other invariants with different transformation properties. We introduce k± as
k± -
YLP+
±
^2P-
' ~k± ~ W fc ± .
t15)
and then form
K ± = J2 (P+xP-)-k±-
(16)
7T+ ,7T~
The variables K± are 'P-odd; K + is C-odd, and so CV-even, while K_ is C-even, and so CV-odd. Both K± are T-odd, so that K + is CPT-odd, and K- is CPT-even. The vector fc+ measures the net flow of the charged pion momentum, while fc_ measures the net flow of charge from pions. We can also form
L= £ ( p + x p _ ) - , (f^f)
•
(17)
The variable L is ^P-odd, C-even, and T-even, so it is odd under CV and CVTIt does not require a net flow of momentum or charge to be nonzero, although as for J, we do need to introduce an arbitrary unit vector z. Similar to L, we can form 49
M-
V
(^A)
(18)
This variable is V-even, C-odd, T-even, and so odd under CV and CVT. Besides using the vectors k±, another way of avoiding the introduction of an arbitrary unit vector z is to use ordered pairs of pion momenta 50>51; this procedure is also used in the studies of spin-dependent effects in jet fragmentation 47 . For any given pair of like sign pions, let p!| denote the n+
41
with largest momentum, so |p_[_| > ]p+|. This ordering is done in the frame in which the observable is measured. Then we can form a triple product as
T ± = J2 (P+ x P-) ' iP+ ± Pi) • IP±I > IP±I 7r+,7T
( 19 )
-
The variables T± are odd under V and T; T + is C-odd, CP-even, and CVTodd, while T_ is C-even, CV-odd, and CPT-even. Besides the variables T ± , one can clearly construct other P - and C-odd observables from triplets, or higher numbers, of pions. On general grounds, any scalar observable should be invariant under the combined operation of CTT 52 . Consequently, the CP-odd variables J, K_, and T_ are allowed under CVT, while K + , L, M, and T + must vanish. We have previously derived the metastable P-odd bubbles within the context of a nonlinear sigma model, with a t/(3) matrix U, UW = 1. The metastable vacua are stationary points with respect to the nonlinear sigma model action, including the terms with two derivatives, a mass term, and an anomaly term (8). In terms of the underlying gluonic fields, the 'P-odd bubbles arise from fluctuations in the topological charge density, GliVGl>v. It is easy to understand how a region in which G^G^" ^ 0 can produce a P-odd effect. Consider the propagation of a quark anti-quark pair through a regioin in which G^vGy,v ^ 0; in terms of the color electric, E, and color magnetic, B, fields, GpvG^ ~ E • B. HE and B both lie along the z direction, then a quark is bent one way, the anti-quark the other, so that (pq xpq) • z ^ 0, where pq and Pq are the three-momenta of the quark and anti-quark, respectively. While physically intuitive, this picture does not allow us to directly relate this bending in the momenta of the quark and anti-quark to an asymmetry for charged pions. To do so, we again resort to using an effective lagrangian. It is known that the effects of the axial anomaly show up in the effective lagrangians of Goldstone bosons in two, and only two 55 , ways. One is through the anomaly term, ~ a, which we have already included. Besides that, however, the axial anomaly also manifests itself in the interactions of Goldstone bosons through the Wess-Zumino-Witten term 53>54. This term is nonzero only when the fields are time dependent, which is why we could ignore it in discussing the static properties of P-odd bubbles. It cannot be ignored, however, in computing the dynamical properties, and in particular the decay, of P-odd bubbles. The Wess-Zumino-Witten term is manifestly chirally symmetric when written as an integral over five dimensions, ( d5x Ea^ia
Swzw = -i-J-;
tr (RaRpRyRgR,,)
,
(20)
1
OUTF* J
Ra — U^daU, but reduces to a boundary term in four space-time dimensions. For U = exp(iu), when dau
J
(21)
42 As discussed by Witten 54 , the coefficient of the Wess-Zumino-Witten term is fixed by topological considerations, and is proportional to the number of colors, which equals three. In a collision, we envision that the trivial vacuum heats up, a P-odd bubble forms, and then decays as the vacuum cools. Since this represents bubble formation and decay, there is no net change in any topological number. Therefore, it is possible for a given event to contain an excess of bubbles over anti-bubbles (or vice versa), and thus to manifest true parity violation on an event by event basis. To estimate the magnitude of the Wess-Zumino-Witten term for a 'P-odd bubble, and to understand its effect on pion production, in (21) we can take three u's to be condensate fields, u ~ u,d,s, a nd two to be charged pion fields, u ~ n±/fn. Suppose that the 7>-odd bubble is of size R, with unit normal f to the surface, and lasts for some period of time. Because of the antisymmetric tensor in (21), all three components of the condensate field must enter. Schematically, we obtain Swzw « r - j
dt
d3r (j>n drd d04>s (p„+ x pn-) -f
(22)
The time integral is J dt do4>s ~ &(j>s = <j>s, since <j>, = 0 in the normal vacuum. Similarly, the spatial integral is / d3r drd (Pn+ x Pv-) ' ^ ~ J dQ J R2dr dr<j>d (p*+ x Pn-) • f" ~ / d£l R24>d (Pn+ x Pn-) • r, where J dil represents an integral over the direction of the normal, r. Further, as the average momentum within the condensate is of order pn ~ 1/R, the size of the bubble drops out as well. We thus obtain a final result which is independent of the size of the bubble, its lifetime, and its width: Syjzw « —-r~i— / d^ \Pn+ xPi,-)-r
(23)
Since the Wess-Zumino-Witten term vanishes for a static field, an asymmetry is only obtained from the decay of a P-odd bubble. In addition, scattering of pions off the P-odd bubble will also produce an asymmetry, although we do not include this at present. Lastly, note that there is only an observable asymmetry when s ^ 0; this is because in the absence of external gauge fields, there is only a Wess-Zumino-Witten term for three, and not for two, flavors. Within this model, Swzw is of similar form for two charged kaons. Using our previous estimates for the <^'s, 4>u ~ 4>d ~ 1 and s ~ 1 0 - 2 , we obtain an effect of order ~ 10~ 3 . At the point where the 'P-odd bubble first appears, (a/c)cr, one can estimate that the energy density within the bubble, relative to the ordinary vacuum, is ~ 25 n2 MeV/fm3, where n is the winding number of the bubble, n — 1,2,3... For a bubble ~ 5/m in radius, there are about ~ 100 n2 pions produced in the decay of the bubble. If a fraction of the produced pions are observed within a given kinematical window, and we assume that all observed pions come from a portion of the total bubble, then we recover the variable J, introduced before in (12), and find an estimate of J ~ 1 0 - 3 . Moreover, we find a natural interpretation of the direction z, which was needed to define J, as the normal to the bubble's surface. One might
43 wonder if the effect is diluted by the necessity to average over uncorrelated pairs. This does not happen, however, because the pion field within the bubble is a classical field, so that all charged pions are affected similarly. Naively, one might expect that J would average to zero over a single bubble. As the bubble is topological, though, the direction in which charged pions are swept is correlated with the sign of the condensate, so that a single 7>-odd bubble can produce an effect in J ~ 10~ 3 . Thus it is possible to distinguish between events in which bubbles are produced, and those in which bubbles are not, by measuring J. At first it may seem surprising that our T-'-odd, C-even, and CV-odd bubble produces a signal in J, which by previous analysis is 'P-odd, C-odd, and CP-even. The Wess-Zumino-Witten term is even under parity, which is To{ — 1)NB , where Vo is the operation of space reflection, and NB counts the number of Goldstone bosons 54 . By scattering off a 'P-odd bubble, we bring in an odd number of condensate fields, J ~ (j>u
44 3. D. Kharzeev, R. D. Pisarski and M. H. Tytgat, Phys. Rev. Lett. 81 (1998) 512 [hep-ph/9804221]. 4. C. Vafa and E. Witten, Phys. Rev. Lett. 53 (1984) 535. 5. R. D. Pisarski and D. H. Rischke, nucl-th/9906050. 6. D.T. Son and M.A. Stephanov, hep-ph/0005225. 7. R. Dashen, Phys. Rev. D3 (1971) 1879. 8. G. t'Hooft, Nucl. Phys. B72 (1974) 461. 9. E. Witten, Phys. Rev. Lett. 81 (1998) 2862 [hep-th/9807109]. 10. S. Coleman, Annals Phys. 101 (1976) 239. 11. M. Shifman, Phys. Rev. D59 (1999) 021501 [hep-th/9809184]. 12. G. Gabadadze, Nucl. Phys. B552 (1999) 194 [hep-th/9902191]. 13. M. H. Tytgat, Phys. Rev. D61 (2000) 114009 [hep-ph/9909532]. 14. P. Di Vecchia and G. Veneziano, Nucl. Phys. B171 (1980) 253. 15. E. Witten, Annals Phys. 128 (1980) 363. 16. C. Rosenzweig, J. Schechter and C. G. Trahern, Phys. Rev. D21 (1980) 3388. 17. P. Nath and R. Arnowitt, Phys. Rev. D23 (1981) 473. 18. G. Veneziano, Nucl. Phys. B159 (1979) 213. 19. E. Witten, Nucl. Phys. B156 (1979) 269. 20. M. Creutz, Phys. Rev. D52 (1995) 2951 [hep-th/9505112]. 21. A. V. Smilga, Phys. Rev. D59 (1999) 114021 [hep-ph/9805214]. 22. M. Tytgat, work in progress. 23. I. I. Kogan, A. Kovner and M. Shifman, Phys. Rev. D57 (1998) 5195 [hep-th/9712046]. 24. G. Gabadadze, Nucl. Phys. B544 (1999) 650 [hep-th/9808005]. 25. G. Gabadadze and M. Shifman, Phys. Rev. D61 (2000) 075014 [hepth/9910050], 26. I. Halperin and A. Zhitnitsky, Mod. Phys. Lett. A13, 1955 (1998); Phys. Rev. D58, 054016 (1998); Phys. Rev. Lett. 81, 4071 (1998); Phys. Rev. Lett. 81 (1998) 4071; T. Fugleberg, I. Halperin and A. Zhitnitsky, Phys. Rev. D59 (1999) 074023 [hep-ph/9808469]. 27. A. D'Adda, M. Luscher and P. Di Vecchia, Nucl. Phys. B146 (1978) 63; 28. E. Witten, Nucl. Phys. B149 (1979) 285. 29. I. Affleck, Nucl. Phys. B162 (1980) 461. 30. A. C. Davis and A. M. Matheson, Phys. Lett. B179 (1986) 135. 31. T. Schafer and E. V. Shuryak, Rev. Mod. Phys. 70 (1998) 323 [hepph/9610451]. 32. T. Banks and M. B. Green, JHEP 9805 (1998) 002 [hep-th/9804170]; M. Bianchi, M. B. Green, S. Kovacs and G. Rossi, JHEP 9808 (1998) 013 [hep-th/9807033]. 33. J. L. Barbon and A. Pasquinucci, Phys. Lett. B458 (1999) 288 [hepth/9904190]. 34. B. Alles, M. D'Elia, A. Di Giacomo and P. W. Stephenson, in NONE Nucl. Phys. Proc. Suppl. 73 (1999) 518 [hep-lat/9808004]; B. Alles, M. D'Elia and A. Di Giacomo, Nucl. Phys. B494 (1997) 281 [heplat/9605013]. 35. P. de Forcrand, M. Garcia Perez, J. E. Hetrick and I. Stamatescu, hep-
45 lat/9802017. 36. R. D. Pisarski and F. Wilczek, Phys. Rev. D29 (1984) 338. 37. S. D. Hsu and M. Schwetz, Phys. Lett. B432 (1998) 203 [hepph/9803386]; J. Berges and K. Rajagopal, Nucl. Phys. B538 (1999) 215 [hep-ph/9804233]; M. A. Halasz, A. D. Jackson, R. E. Shrock, M. A. Stephanov and J. J. Verbaarschot, Phys. Rev. D58 (1998) 096007 [hep-ph/9804290]. 38. H. Leutwyler, Phys. Lett. B378 (1996) 313 [hep-ph/9602366]. 39. P. Di Vecchia and G. Veneziano, Nucl.Phys. B 171, 253 (1980). 40. R. D. Pisarski and F. Wilczek, Phys. Rev. D 29 (1984) 338. 41. Z. Huang, Phys. Rev. D 49, 16 (1994). 42. J. Kapusta, D. Kharzeev and L. McLerran, Phys. Rev. D 53, 5028 (1996); Z. Huang and X.-N. Wang, ibid., 53, 5034 (1996). 43. S. E. Vance, T. Csorgo and D. Kharzeev, Phys.Rev.Lett. 81 (1998) 2205. 44. D. Ahrensmeier, R. Baier and M. Dirks, Phys.Lett. B484 (2000) 58. 45. K. Buckley, T. Fugleberg, A. Zhitnitsky, hep-ph/0006057. 46. D. Kharzeev and R. D. Pisarski, Phys. Rev. D61 (2000) 111901. 47. O. Nachtmann, Nucl. Phys. B 127, 314 (1977); A.V. Efremov, Sov. J. Nucl. Phys. 28, 83 (1978); A. Efremov and D. Kharzeev, Phys. Lett. B 366, 311 (1996). 48. H. Weyl, The classical groups, their invariants and representations, (Princeton Univ. Press, Princeton, 1946). 49. C. P. Korthals Altes, private communication. 50. T. D. Lee, private communication. 51. M. Gyulassy, RIKEN/BNL Research Center memo, March 11, 1999, unpublished. 52. S. Weinberg, The Quantum Theory of Fields, (Cambridge Univ. Press, New York, 1996). 53. J. Wess and B. Zumino, Phys. Lett. B37, 95 (1971). 54. E. Witten, Nucl. Phys. B223, 422 (1983). 55. E. D'Hoker and S. Weinberg, Phys. Rev. D50, R6050 (1994). 56. S. Bronoff and C. P. Korthals Altes, Phys. Lett. B448, 85 (1999). 57. T. D. Lee and G. C. Wick, Phys. Rev. D9, 2291 (1974). 58. P. D. Morley and I. A. Schmidt, Z. Phys. C26 (1985) 627. 59. A. A. Anselm, Phys. Lett. B217, 169 (1989); A. A. Anselm and M. G. Ryskin, Phys. Lett. B266, 482 (1991); J.-P. Blaizot and A. Krzywicki, Phys. Rev. D46, 246 (1992); J. D. Bjorken, K. L. Kowalski, and C. C. Taylor, Les Rencontres de Physique de la Vallee d'Aoste, 7th: Results and Perspectives in Particle Physics, 1993, (Editions Frontieres, 1993), M. Greco, ed.; K. Rajagopal and F. Wilczek, Nucl. Phys. B404, 577 (1993).
T H E D E C O N F I N I N G P H A S E T R A N S I T I O N , T H E ZN D O M A I N W A L L S A N D T H E M A G N E T I C ZN S Y M M E T R Y
A. K O V N E R Department
of Physics, Theoretical Oxford 0X1 3NP,
Physics, England
1 Keble
Road,
We discuss the relation between the deconfining phase transition in gauge theories and the realization of the magnetic Z^ symmetry. At low temperature the Z^ symmetry is spontaneously broken while above the phase transition it is restored. This is intimately related to the change of behaviour of the spatial 't Hooft loop operator V(C). In the confining phase V has a perimeter law behaviour V(C) oc exp{—mP(C')}, while in the deconfined phase it has the area law behaviour V(C) oc exp{—aS(C)}. We also show that the "dual string tension" a is equal to the"wall tension"of the ZN domain walls previously calculated in the literature.
1
Introduction
In this talk I discuss work done in collaboration with Chris Korthals Altes and Misha Stephanov 1>2. T h e question we are asking is twofold 1. Is there a c a n o n i c a l order parameter for the deconfining phase transition in the pure Yang - Mills theory, 2. Is this phase transition associated with the change in the mode of realization of some global symmetry. This may sound at first like a red herring. After all an order parameter for the deconfining phase transition as well as a related ZN symmetry have been discussed for many years. T h e order parameter in question is the free energy of an external static colour source in the fundamental representation: the Polyakov line P = TrPexp{ig fQ dtAo}- T h e ZN s y m m e t r y is the transformation P —> exp{i^-}P. We will refer to this transformation as the electric ZN. However the accent in our question is on the word canonical. T h e Polyakov line is not an operator in the Hilbert space of the theory and as such not a canonical order parameter. It appears as an auxilliary object when projecting onto gauge invariant physical subspace of the Hilbert space. T h e "electric" ZN - the operation t h a t transforms P by multiplying it by a phase - similarly is not a canonical symmetry. There is no transformation of states in the physical Hilbert space t h a t is related to this "symmetry", although it is indeed a symmetry of the Euclidean p a t h integral representing the statistical sum. These issues were discussed in detail in 3 . This is not to say of course t h a t P and electric ZN are useless concepts. 46
47
The standard effective action, defined by the constrained path integral e x p { - 5 e / / (P)} = J DA0S(P - P(A0)) exp -S(A)
(1)
is gauge invariant and is instrumental as an intermediate step in the calculation of physical quantities. However if one wants to describe the deconfinement phase transition in terms of a canonical order parameter in the same way as the Ising transition is described in terms of magnetisation, one should look elsewhere. Thus we have decided to study the behaviour of the "disorder variable" the spatial 't Hooft loop. Let me first recall how this operator is denned and then explain why its study is relevant at all. 2
The 't Hooft loop
In the following we will for definiteness consider the SU(2) gauge group. The generalization to SU(N) is straightforward. The defining property of V4 is that it satisfies the following commutation relation with the spatial fundamental Wilson loop W V\C)W{C')V(C)
= eiwn<-c'C")W(C')
(2)
where n(C, C) is the linking number of the curves C and C". The operatorial representation of V is simplest on the physical states (the states that satisfy the Gauss' law). Consider a closed contour C which lies in the xy plane. Then V(C)=exp{—
f d'S'Ei) (3) 9 Js The integration here is over the surface S which is bounded by C. If no fields in the fundamental representation are present in the theory, the operator V does not depend on this surface, but rather depends only on its boundary C. In the following we will for simplicity always choose the surface S to lie in the xy plane. It is easy to see that A
Vl(C)A?(x)V(C)
= A?(X)+a?(x)
(4)
with a?{x) = 6a36i3—6{x-S)
(5)
48 T h e (^-function in this equation is one dimensional and is defined such t h a t its integral along a curve normal to the surface S is equal to unity. T h e operator V(C) is therefore seen to create an infinitely thin elementary vortex of magnetic field in the third color direction along the curve C. Clearly our choice of the third direction in the color space is arbitrary. One can equaly well consider any other direction. Different operators defined in this way transform into each other under the gauge transformations and therefore are identical when acting on physical states 2 . T h e operator V was introduced by 't Hooft in order to study the phase structure of gauge theories. In the zero t e m p e r a t u r e ground state of the pure Yang-Mills theory the Wilson loop has an area law behaviour, 't Hooft's general analysis showed t h a t (unless the gauge symmetry was partially broken) the area law behaviour of 't Hooft loop and Wilson loop were mutually exclusive. T h e 't Hooft loop therefore has a perimeter law behaviour in the ground state. This s t a t e m e n t however pertains only to the zero t e m p e r a t u r e ground state, which is Lorentz invariant and where the spacelike and timelike loops behave in the same way. Our purpose here is to study the expectation value of the 't Hooft loop at high t e m p e r a t u r e . Why bother at all studying the 't Hooft loop? T h e answer is t h a t if one is interested in the canonical order parameter, this is as good as it gets. T h e 't Hooft loop is indeed the canonical order parameter for confinement. T h e pure Yang Mills theory has a global physical ZM symmetry which acts on the 't Hooft loop by the phase rotation. Spontaneous breaking of this s y m m e t r y is t a n t a m o u n t to confinement, while Wigner type realization is equivalent to deconfinement. We will refer to this symmetry as the magnetic ZM3
T h e m a g n e t i c ZN
symmetry
T h e action of the magnetic ZN symmetry is somewhat different in 2 + 1 and 3 + 1 dimensional cases. In 2 + 1 dimensions it acts very much like usual global symmetry in a scalar theory and we start our discussion with this simpler case. Let us start by recalling the argument due to 't Hooft t h a t a nonabelian SU(N) gauge theory with charged fields in adjoint representation posesses a global ZN symmetry 4 . 3.1
Generalities
Consider a theory with several adjoint Higgs fields so t h a t varying parameters in the Higgs sector the SU(N) gauge symmetry can be broken completely. In this phase the perturbative spectrum will contain the usual massive "gluons"
49 and Higgs particles. However in addition to t h a t there will be heavy stable magnetic vortices. Those are the analogs of Abrikosov-Nielsen-Olesen vortices in the superconductours and they must be stable by virtue of the following topological argument. T h e vortex configuration away from the vortex core has all the fields in the pure gauge configuration
Ha(x)
= U(x)ha,
A"=iUd"Ui
(6)
Here the index a labels the scalar fields in the theory, ha are the constant vacuum expectation values of these fields, and U(x) is a unitary m a t r i x which when going around the vortex location does not return to the same SU(N) group element Uo, but rather ends up at exp{ijj-}UoAdjoint fields do not feel this type of discontinuity in U and therefore the energy of such a configuration is finite. Since such a configuration can not be smoothly deformed into a trivial one, a single vortex is stable. Processes involving annihilation of N such vortices into vacuum are allowed since N-vortex configurations are topologically trivial. At weak coupling the energy of such a vortex is inversely proportional to the gauge coupling constant and therefore very large. T h e spectrum of the theory contains a stable particle even though its mass is much higher than masses of m a n y other particles (gauge and Higgs bosons) and the phase space for its decay into these particles is enormous. T h e only possible reason for the existence of such a heavy stable particle is t h a t it must carry a conserved q u a n t u m number. T h e theory therefore must possess a global s y m m e t r y which is unbroken in the completely higgsed phase. T h e symmetry group must be ZN since the number of vortices is only conserved modulo TV. Now imagine changing smoothly the parameters in the Higgs sector so t h a t the expectation values of the Higgs fields become smaller and smaller, and finally the theory undergoes a phase transition into the confining phase. One can further change the parameters so t h a t the adjoint scalars become heavy and eventually decouple completely from the glue. This limiting process does not change the topology of the gauge group and therefore does not change the symmetry content of the theory. We conclude t h a t the pure Yang-Mills theory also posesses a ZN symmetry. T h e physical considerations given above can be put on firmer formal basis. In particular one can construct explicitly the generator of the ZN as well as the order parameter associated with it - the operator t h a t creates the magnetic vortex 6 .
50
3.2
The Abelian case
Consider first an Abelian gauge theory. In this case the magnetic symmetry is U(l) rather than Z^. The relevant charge is none other than the magnetic flux through the equal time plane, with the associated conserved current being the dual of the electromagnetic field strength $=
/ d2xB(x),
d"F„ = 0
(7)
The current conservation is insured by the Bianchi identity. A group element of the U(\) magnetic symmetry group is exp{ia$} for any value of a. A local order parameter - a local field V(x) which carries the magnetic charge - is also readily constructed. It has a form of the singular gauge transformation operator with the gauge function Q(x — y) which is singular at the point x. The cut discontinuity in the function 0 is not physical and can be chosen parallel to the horizontal axis. Using the Gauss' law constraint this operator can be written as V(x) = exp—
[ dy* etjEiiy) (8) 9 Jc where the integration goes along the cut of the function © which starts at the point x and goes to spatial infinity. The operator does not depend on where precisely one chooses the cut to lie. To see this, note that changing the position of the cut C to C adds to the phase ^z. Js d2xdiE' where S is the area bounded by C — C. In the theory we consider only charged particles with charges multiples of g are present. Therefore the charge within any closed area is a multiple integer of the gauge coupling fs dPxdiE1 = gn and the extra phase factor is always unity. From the commutation relation V(x)B(y)VHx)
= B(y) + —S2(x-y) 9
(9)
it is obvious that V creates a pointlike magnetic vortex of flux 2w/g. Despite its nonlocal appearance the operator V can be proven to be a local Lorentz scalar field7. The locality is the consequence of the fact that V(x) commutes with any local gauge invariant operator in the theory O(y) except when x = y. This is due to the coefficient 2n/g in the exponential which ensures that the Aharonov-Bohm phase of the vortex created by V and any dynamical charged particle present in the theory vanishes. Eqs.(7,8) formalize the physical arguments of 't Hooft in the abelian case.
51
3.3
The non-Abelian
theories
T h e construction can be generalized to nonabelian theories 6 . W i t h o u t giving detailed arguments we describe the main differences between the magnetic s y m m e t r y structure of the Abelian and the non Abelian theories. T h e gauge invariant analog of the dual field strength tensor in the non Abelian theories is not conserved q u a n t u m mechanically 4 , and therefore the magnetic s y m m e t r y is not continuous. Rather it is the discreet Zjq group. This "quant u m anomaly" can be understood as due to the 't Hooft-Polyakov monopoleinstantons. T h e generator of the magnetic symmetry is the fundamental Wilson loop along the spatial boundary of the system W = lim TrVexp
\ig f
C-voo
I
Jc
rf/M')
(10)
J
T h e order parameter is the vortex operator which is constructed just like in the Abelian case. Its explicit form is V(x)=exp
/ dy'djEfiy) 9
3-4
Realizations
of the magnetic
(11)
Jc
ZN and
confinement
T h e mode realization of the magnetic symmetry is rigidly related to the confining properties of the vacuum. If ZN is spontaneously broken the theory is confining. To understand why this is so consider the low energy effective description of a nonabelian theory. T h e relevant degree of freedom a t low energy is the vortex field V. One can also explicitly construct the low energy effective Lagrangian in terms of the field V which realizes the spontaneously broken ZN symmetry. C = d^Vd^V
- \{V*V - / i 2 ) 2 - ((V2 + V*2)
(12)
In weakly coupled confining theories (like the Georgi - Glashow model) this Lagrangian can be derived in controllable manner. A similar effective Lagrangian with some quantitative differences was argued t o be valid also for the pure Yang-Mills theory in 8 . As shown in 6 ' 7 , 8 the charged states in the effective theory eq.(12) are represented by solitonic configurations of the vortex field V with unit winding number. T h e energy of any such state is linearly divergent in the infrared. T h e reason is t h a t due to finite degeneracy of vacuum states, the m i n i m u m energy configuration looks like a quasi onedimensional strip across which the phase of V winds. T h e energy density inside this "electric flux t u b e " is proportional
52 to the vacuum expectation value of V. When the VEV vanishes, so does the string tension. Stated in other words, when V vanishes, the phase fluctuations are large and the winding number is not a sharp observable. An external charge is thus screened easily by regions of space around it with vanishing V . T h e phase with < V >— 0 is therefore not confining. In the theory with several Higgs fields this phase exists even at zero t e m p e r a t u r e and corresponds to a completely Higgsed phase - where the gauge group is broken completely. In such a Higgs phase indeed the colour is screened rather t h a n confined. T h u s confinement is equivalent to nonvanishing of the expectation value of V, or equivalently to spontaneous breaking of the magnetic ZN4
3 + 1 dimensions
T h e generator of the magnetic symmetry in 3 + 1 dimensions is still the large Wilson loop. T h e peculiarity of this situation is t h a t it has not the n a t u r e of a volume integral, like usual conserved charges but rather of a surface integral. Correspondingly its order parameter is not a local field, like in 2 + 1 dimensions but rather a stringlike field which creates an infinitely long magnetic vortex which pierces the surface S once. This is the 't Hooft loop V(C) along an infinite open contour C. One can consider a system which is finite in the direction of the loop, but is infinite in the perpendicular directions. In this case there are two possibilities a) < V > ^ 0 and the magnetic ZN broken, or b). < V > = 0 and the nagnetic ZN restored. In the system infinite in all directions C is necessarily an infinite line, and the expectation value < V(C) > clearly vanishes irrespective of whether ZN is broken or not. T h e 't Hooft loop along a closed contour on the other hand is never zero, since it is globally invariant under the ZN transformation. Nevertheless the behaviour of the closed loop does reflect the realization mode of the symmetry, since it is qualitatively different in the two possible phases. Namely vacuum expectation value of a large closed 't Hooft loop (by large, as usual we mean t h a t the linear dimensions of the loop are much larger t h a n the correlation length in the theory) has an area law decay if the magnetic symmetry is spontaneously broken, and perimeter law decay if the vacuum state is invariant. To understand the physics of this behaviour it is useful to think of the 't Hooft line as built of "local" operators - little "magnetic dipoles". Consider V(C) with the contour C running along the x- axis and the surface S chosen as the {x,y) plane. Let us mentally divide the line into (short) segments of
53
length 2A centered at £;. Each one of these segments is a little magnetic dipole and the 't Hooft loop operator is the product of the operators t h a t create these dipoles. It is convenient to define a single dipole operator in the following way DA(x)
= exp{ifd3y[4(x
+ A - y) + a~(x - A - y)]Tv(Y E{ (y))} (13)
where af{x — y) is the c-number vector potential of the abelian magnetic monopole (antimonopole) of strength An/gN. T h e monopole field correpsonding to a, contains both, the smooth Xi/x3 part as well as the Dirac string contribution. T h e Dirac string of the monopole - antimonopole pair in eq.(13) is chosen so t h a t is connects the points x — A and x + A along the straight line. T h e dipole operators obviously have the property DA(x)DA(x
+ 2A) = D2A{x
+ A)
(14)
This is because in the product the smooth field contribution of the monopole in DA(x) cancels the antimonopole contribution in DA(x + 2 A ) , while the Dirac string now stretches between the points (x — A) and (x + 3 A ) . W h e n multiplied over the closed contour, the smooth fields cancel out completely, while the surviving Dirac string is precisely the magnetic vortex created by a closed ' t Hooft loop operator. T h e 't Hooft loop can therefore be written as V(C) = UXiDA(x,)
(15)
T h e dipole operator D(XJ) is an eigenoperator of the magnetic flux d e fined on a surface t h a t crosses the segment [K, — A , * , + A ] . Suppose the magnetic symmetry is broken. Then we expect the dipole operator to have a nonvanishing expectation value < D > = d(A). If there are no massless excitations in the theory, the operators D(x{) and D(XJ) should be decorrelated if the distance £, — Xj is greater than the correlation length /. Due to eq.(15), the expectation value of the ' t Hooft loop should therefore roughly behave as =d(l)L» = exp{-ln(^)j}
(16)
where L is the perimeter of the loop. In the system of finite length Lx, the vacuum expectation value of the vortex line which winds around the system in ^-direction is therefore finite as in eq.(16) with L —» Lx. On the other hand in the unbroken phase the VEV of the dipole operator depends on the size of the system in the perpendicular plane Ly. For large Ly it must vanish exponentially as d = exp{—aL y }. So the expectation value of V behaves at finite Ly in the unbroken phase as: < V(C)
>=exp{-aLyLx}
(17)
54 and vanishes as Ly -> oo. T h u s in a system which is finite in x direction, but infinite in y direction, the 't Hooft line in the x direction has a finite VEV in the broken phase and vanishing VEV in the unbroken phase. In the limit of the infinite system size Lx —»• oo the VEV obviously vanishes in both phases. This is of course due to the fact t h a t V is a product of infinite number of dipole operators, and this product vanishes even if individual dipole operators have finite VEV. For a closed loop with long sides along x axis at y = 0 and y = R the above argument leads to the conclusion t h a t in the broken phase V must have a perimeter law, eq.(16). In the unbroken phase the correlation between the dipoles a t y = 0 and dipoles a t y = R should decay exponentially < D(Q)D(R) >oc e x p { - a f } and thus
=exF{-a^} = exp{-a^}
(18)
T h u s the perimeter behaviour of < V[C) > indicates a vacuum state which breaks spontaneously the magnetic ZN while the area behaviour means t h a t the magnetic ZN is unbroken. In 3 + 1 dimensions therefore the perimeter law of V(C) signals confinement, while the area law of V(C) means deconfinement.
5
< V ( C ) > at h i g h t e m p e r a t u r e
T h e expectation value of the ' t Hooft loop at finite t e m p e r a t u r e is given by the following expression < V(C)
>= Tre-$(E>+B')ei*?fd*s-Ei
( 1 9 )
Note t h a t formally eq.(19) is the same as for the partition function except t h a t the Hamiltonian has an extra term linear in the electric field
6H =-iT J (PxtiEi
(20)
with aj, defined in eq.(5) and T — i . W i t h the help of the s t a n d a r d manipulations it is easy to cast this expression in the path integral form. Introducing the imaginary time axis and the Lagrange multiplier field A0 in the standard
55 way we obtain" =
f DAiDA0exp{-^
f
dt f d3x {d0A? - (DiA0)a
-
Ta°f+(Ba)2}
(21) Our task is now simple. In this expression the "external field" a, enters only in one place - it shifts the spatial derivative of the zero M a t s u b a r a frequency mode of Ao- The integration of the nonzero M a t s u b a r a modes therefore proceeds in precisely the same way as in the s t a n d a r d calculation of the finite t e m p e r a t u r e effective potential 1 0 , 9 . In fact we can take the whole page from the book of 9 and derive the constrained effective Lagrangian for the zero M a t s u b a r a frequency modes in the presence of the external field a;. It is obvious t h a t the calculation is identical to t h a t of 9 . For simplicity we will restrict ourselves to the one loop result, which is valid at high t e m p e r a t u r e
Sen = ^(dil
+ |«i) 2 + f T V (1 - I?
(22)
Here q is defined 9 as the average value of the first eigenvalue of the m a t r i x AQ = P T at zero M a t s u b a r a frequency. T h e matrices r a are the generators of SU(2) in the fundamental representation and are normalized according to t r r V 6 = \Sab. To find the average of V we have to find the configuration of q which minimizes the action eq.(22). Qualitatively the form of the solution is clear. Let us consider a large 't Hooft loop such t h a t its radius is much larger than the electric mass in eq.(22). Clearly very far from the loop at spatial infinity the field q must take the value which minimizes the potential term in eq.(22). There are two such values q = 0, ;r. For definiteness we take the asymptotic value at infinity to be 0. On the other hand on the surface S, where the external field a; is a delta function, q has to j u m p by ir. It is also clear t h a t for a large loop the solution must be practically x and y independent as long as x and y are well within the surface S. For these values of x and y therefore we are looking for the z - dependent solution which everywhere except at z = 0 is a solution of free equations (the source vanishes), while at z = 0 j u m p s by IT and is constrained to approach 0 at z —> ± o o . But of course we know what this solution is. Recall t h a t the action eq.(22) without the source term allows wall-like solutions qwaii- They interpolate between q — 0 at z —• - c o and q — 7r at z —)• + 0 0 . This is precisely the so called Z2 domain wall 1 1 , 3 . Let "Strictly speaking there are extra commutator terms in passing from eq.(19) to eq.(21). Those however do not affect the leading area law behaviour and we will omit them in the following.
56
us pick the profile which corresponds to the wall at z = 0. This means that qwaii(0) — |-. We can now construct the following function qs{z) = qwaii(z) , qwall{z)
-71",
z<0
(23)
Z > 0
This function has precisely the required properties: it satisfies the correct boundary conditions, has the correct discontinuity and solves the sourceless equations everywhere except at discontinuity. Close to the boundary of S the solution will be of course modified - it is not x,y independent anymore. We will not address here the question of what the exact form of the solution is. It is however clear that the behaviour of q close to the boundary of S does not affect the leading contribution to the action. This leading contribution for the large 't Hooft loop is obviously proportional to the minimal area Sm subtended by the contour C SefJ = aSm
(24)
where a is precisely the wall tension of the Z2 wall which has been calculated both analytically n and numerically 12 , 13 . Note that the action is proportional to the minimal area Sm subtended by the contour C rather than the area of the surface S which appears explicitly in the definition of the operator V and eq.(5). Independence on S is of course a consequence of the fact mentioned earlier, that the operator V is independent of S in the absence of fundamental charges. In the framework of our path integral calculation this can be easily verified. We therefore conclude that the expectation value of a large 't Hooft loop follows an area law < V(C) >= e~s<" = e~aS This calculation generalizes straightforwardly to 6
(25)
SU(N).
Conclusions
To conclude, we have shown that the behaviour of the 'tHooft loop changes from perimeter to area across the deconfining phase transition. The transition itself can be understood as due to restoration of the magnetic ZN symmetry with the 't Hooft loop as a canonical order parameter akin to magnetization in the Ising model. The so called ZN domain wall tension has the physical meaning of the dual string tension which governs the expectation value of the spatial 't Hooft loop. Thus generalizing our discussion at zero temperature,
57
we find that also at finite temperature deconfinement is tantamount to the restoration of the magnetic Z^ symmetry. A cknowledgment s This work has been supported by the PPARC Advanced fellowship. References 1. C.P. Korthals Altes, A. Kovner and M. Stephanov, Phys. Lett. B 469, 205 (1999); 2. C.P. Korthals Altes and A. Kovner,Phys. Rev. D 62, 096008 (2000); hep-ph/0004052; 3. A. Smilga, Ann. Phys. 234, 1 (1994); Acta Phys. Polonica B 25, 73 (1994); 4. G.'t Hooft, Nucl. Phys. B 138, 1 (1978); 5. S. Samuel, Nucl. Phys. B 154, 62 (1979); N.J.Snyderman Nucl. Phys. B 218, 381 (1983); 6. A. Kovner and B. Rosenstein, Int. J. Mod. Phys. A 7, 7419 (1992); 7. A. Kovner, B. Rosenstein and D. Eliezer, Mod. Phys. Lett. A 5, 2661 (1990); Nucl. Phys. B 350, 325 (1991); A. Kovner and B. Rosenstein, Phys. Lett. B 266, 443 (1991); 8. A. Kovner and B. Rosenstein, J. High Energy Phys. 003, 9809 (1998); 9. C.P.Korthals Altes, Nucl. Phys. B 420, 637 (1994); 10. N. Weiss Phys. Rev. D 24, 475 (1981); Phys. Rev. D 25, 2667 (1982); D. Gross, R. D. Pisarski, and L. G. Yaffe, Rev. Mod. Phys. 53, 497 (1981); 11. T. Bhattacharya, A. Gocksch, C. P. Korthals Altes and R. D. Pisarski, Phys. Rev. Lett. 66, 998 (1991); Nucl. Phys. B 383, 497 (1992); 12. K. Kajantie, L. Karkkainen, Phys. Lett. B 214, 595 (1988); K. Kajantie, L. Karkkainen, and K. Rummukainen, Nucl. Phys. B 333, 100 (1990); Nucl. Phys. B 357, 693 (1991); Nucl. Phys. B333, 100 (1990); ibid., B357, 693 (1991); Phys. Lett. B 286, 125 (1992); S. Huang, J. Potvin, C. Rebbi and S. Sanielevici, Phys. Rev. D 42, 2864 (1990); (E) Phys. Rev. D 43, 2056 (1991); R. Brower, S. Huang, J. Potvin, C. Rebbi,Phys. Rev. D 46, 2703 (1992); R. Brower, S. Huang, J. Potvin, C. Rebbi, and J. Ross, Phys. Rev. D 46, 4736 (1992); 13. C. P. Korthals Altes, A. Michels, M. Stephanov and M.Teper, Phys. Rev. D 55, 1047 (1997);
ELECTROWEAK PHASE TRANSITION BEYOND THE STANDARD MODEL
M. L A I N E Theory
Division,
CERN, E-mail:
CH-1211 Geneva 23, [email protected]
Switzerland
Standard theories of electroweak interactions are based on the concept of a gauge symmetry broken by the Higgs mechanism. If they are placed in an environment with a sufficiently high temperature, the symmetry gets restored. It turns out that the characteristics of the symmetry restoring phase transition, such as its order, are important for cosmological applications, such as baryon asymmetry generation. We first briefly review how, by a combination of analytic and numerical methods, the properties of the phase transition can be systematically resolved for any given type of a (weakly interacting) Higgs sector. We then summarise the numerical results available for the Standard Model, and present a generic model independent statement as to how the Higgs sector should differ from the Standard Model for the properties of the transition to be very different. As an explicit example, we discuss the possibilities available for a strong transition in the experimentally allowed parameter region of the Minimal Supersymmetric Standard Model.
1
Introduction
Even though a Higgs particle remains to be discovered, the success of precision computations gives strong support to the idea of an SU(2)xU(l) electroweak theory with one or more Higgs doublets, some of which have, in any practical gauge, a non-vanishing expectation value at zero temperature. However, when the theory is placed in an environment with a sufficiently high temperature, the symmetry generically gets restored. x Thus we may imagine that there was an electroweak phase transition in the Early Universe. An outstanding physics motivation for these considerations was perceived about fifteen years ago. 2 Indeed, an electroweak phase transition might in principle leave as a remnant the matter-antimatter (baryon) asymmetry presently observed. An essential ingredient in this statement is that there are anomalous baryon number violating interactions which are fast enough to be in thermal equilibrium at temperatures above the transition. 2 If the transition is sufficiently strongly of the first order, i.e. discontinuous, baryon number violating interactions are however switched off below the transition temperature, in the broken phase. Together with the CP violation known to exist in nature, as well as the non-equilibrium dynamics always present in first order transitions, these ingredients might suffice to produce an asymmetry with the correct order of magnitude (for a review, see ref. 3 ) . 58
59
In the present talk, we will not enter any details of the actual baryogenesis computations, but simply consider the existence and strength of a first order phase transition. As a reference value, we however recall that the constraint of sufficient baryon violation switch-off after the transition can be related to the Higgs expectation value over temperature v/T in, say, the Landau gauge, or gauge invariantly to an appropriately regularized value of {<j>H)/T2 « v2/(2T2), where <j> is the Higgs doublet. In the case of several SU(2) Higgs doublets, the observable is correspondingly ^^i^i) /T2. The numerical requirement, based on 1-loop saddle point computations (for a summary of their status and accuracy, see 4 ) as well as on a non-perturbative evaluation, 5 is that the discontinuity in v/T across the phase transition should exceed unity, A u / T > 1.0.
2
General formulation of the problem
Let us start by stating more generally the types of quantities that we may want to determine. The most basic characteristic of a finite temperature system is its partition function Z(T, V), or the free energy density f(T), where Z(T,V)
= e-f3V*m=Tre-<1H.
(1)
Here H is the Hamiltonian, (3 = T _ 1 , and V —> oo is the volume. The points T = Tc where f(T) is non-analytic are phase transition points, and if f'{T)\T_^T± is discontinuous, the transition is of the first order. This implies also that the energy density, e(T) = —T2d[T~1f(T)]/dT, is discontinuous. In addition to f(T),e(T), we also want to determine, as discussed above, the value of a (suitably regularized) {$)(T), which is very strongly correlated with the rate of baryon number violation in the broken phase. In perturbation theory, one does not usually address directly / ( T ) or (), D u t rather the effective potential V(v,T) for the length of the Higgs field, \(f)\ = v/y/2. After gauge fixing, V(v,T) can be defined for instance as the free energy density after the introduction of a constraint 6(v/y/2 — V - 1 f d3x\(j)(x)\) in the path integral. In the thermodynamic limit, the value of V(v,T) at the global minimum gives the actual free energy density, f(T). We may now recall that for all such "static" observables, it is straightforward to write down an "imaginary time" Euclidian path integral expression. Thus, in principle we only need to compute simple well-defined functional integrals, without any ambiguities related e.g. to Minkowski space.
60
3
W h y is it non-trivial?
One may ask, why not simply trust V(v, T) computed from the functional integral using perturbation theory? Indeed, such computations have been carried out up to resummed 2-loop level for the Standard Model (SM) 6>7>8, as well as for the MSSM 9 _ 1 5 . It turns out that at finite temperatures perturbative computations are not a priori reliable, however. We will meet circumstances below where even the order of the phase transition is wrong. The reason for the breakdown is referred to as the infrared (IR) problem of finite temperature field theory. 16 It concerns "light" bosonic degrees of freedom, and can be understood as arising from expansion parameters of the type 2
m/
\
92
m « r g2T
s^ ) = -^irzn ~ -^'
(2)
where ri(,(m) is the Bose-Einstein distribution function, g2 is a generic coupling constant, the SU(2) gauge coupling in particular, and m some perturbative mass scale appearing in the propagators. Adding numerical factors from known contributions up to 3-loop order, the largest expansion parameter in the system can more concretely be estimated as 4 ,.92T
irm
(3)
Thus, relatively "light" (m -C g,2rT) degrees of freedom interacting with the Higgses are a problem, and should be studied non-perturbatively. Such modes include, for instance, SU(2) gauge bosons near the symmetric phase. In principle, a seemingly obvious way to study the system non-perturbatively is to carry out four-dimensional (4d) finite temperature lattice simulations. However, in the present context this turns out to be quite demanding. This is, first of all, because the coupling is weak, so that there are multiple length scales, (2nT)~1, (gT)~l, (<7 2 T) -1 , difficult to fit simultaneously on a finite lattice. The second problem is that only the bosonic sector of the theory can be studied anyway, since chiral fermions cannot be efficiently handled in practice. Nevertheless, leaving out the fermions, large scale efforts have been undertaken, complete with an extrapolation to the continuum limit ( 17 ' 18 and references therein). The method we shall follow here is, however, different. 4
Dimensional reduction and 3d effective field theories
It turns out that all the problems mentioned above can be overcome in an economic and precise way by the method of finite temperature effective field
61
theories (for reviews, see 1 9 ). The basic idea of such an approach is to combine perturbation theory and simulations, in regions where they work best: one can integrate out massive modes perturbatively, which works well since the couplings are small, and then study the dynamics of the light modes nonperturbatively. In the first step, the original 4d theory reduces to a threedimensional (3d) effective one. For studying the electroweak phase transition in a weakly coupled theory (m# < 250 GeV), this approach works with a practical accuracy at the percent level, both from the point of view of dimensional reduction, 17 ' 20 ' 21 as well as numerical simulations. 4 . 22 . 23 . 24 More concretely, the degrees of freedom integrated out 8.20>25>26>27 a r e a ll the heavy beyond-the-SM particles, as well as the non-zero Matsubara modes of the SM particles. This includes, in particular, all fermions. The effective masses of such modes are m > irT so that there are no IR-problems but, according to Eq.(3), a small expansion parameter ~ g2/n2- The largest corrections are related to the top Yukawa coupling. After this step, the theory lives in 3d, since all non-zero Matsubara modes have been removed. A second step can also be taken: 8.2°.25>26 the zero components of the gauge fields get radiatively a mass m ~ gT. Thus there are again no IR-problems but, according to Eq. (3), a small expansion parameter ~ g/n. We will not discuss the precise details of these integrations in any more detail here. For previous reviews, we refer to 19 , and for explicit generic rules for the integrations, to 20 . For the logic behind the formal conjecture concerning the parametric accuracy obtained with the types of super-renormalizable effective theories discussed here (viz., SG/G ~ 0(g3), where G is a general non-vanishing bosonic Green's function), we refer to 28 . 5
Phase diagram for the Standard Model
After the heavy degrees of freedom have been integrated out perturbatively, one still has to deal with the non-perturbative bosonic scales m and the spatial SU(2) and U(l) gauge fields, with field strength tensors Fij, Bjj. The Lagrangian is
£3d = ^TrF 2 - + i f i 2 + (DitfDi*
+ m2cf>U + \3(U)2.
(4)
All knowledge about the original modes with their physical zero temperature parameters, as well as about the temperature, is encoded in the expressions for the effective couplings m 2 , A3, g%, g'2. Here g3,g'3 denote the SU(2) and U(l) gauge couplings.
62 130 — '
1
'
1
'
r—
symmetric confinement phase 120 2nd order end x>int
broken Higgs phase 50
60
70 mJGeV
80
Figure 1. The phase diagram of the physical Standard Model. The blobs indicate simulation points (with errorbars), and the solid curve is a fit through them.
To get a feeling for the properties of the effective theory in Eq. (4), let us first apply 1-loop perturbation theory. Ignoring the tiny corrections from d'iIQ\ f° r the moment and tuning mf, to be on the phase transition line, we find a first order transition, with the discontinuity
9l gT (The 0(\3/gl)
8TTA3
(5)
•°§\
corrections are in fact not analytic.) Using that in the SM, A3
1lm" m
8 <
1 of
9
top
\
\(4K)*m*y)'
and inspecting, say, m\v{T) = gv/2 in the broken phase, we however see from Eq. (3) that for large (realistic) Higgs masses m # > rn\v an IR sensitive computation of the type in Eq. (5) cannot be trusted at all. Fortunately, we do not need to rely on perturbation theory. The theory in Eq. (4) is ideally suited for lattice simulations. Due to the simplicity of the action and its low dimensionality, extrapolations to the infinite volume and continuum limits can be systematically carried out 29,3o,3i_ The results of such lattice simulations from refs. 22>32>33 are summarised in Fig. 1. There is a line of first order phase transitions, which however ends at a critical point, after which there is only a crossover. The ending of the transition is in qualitative contrast with the perturbative prediction in Eq. (5). The endpoint location has been determined with great precision, and corresponds in physical units to m w , c = 72.3(7) GeV, Tc = 109.2(8) GeV 33 . The
63
errors here are statistical, remaining after continuum extrapolation. In case one would now not be a priori convinced about the accuracy of dimensional reduction at the percent level, we may note that a similar phase diagram exists also in the bosonic 4d SU(2)+Higgs theory, where also direct 4d simulations have been carried out. 17 While the statistical errors are slightly larger, the results agree completely with the results obtained after leaving out fermions from the dimensional reduction expressions, as well as changing g2 to the larger value used in ref. 17 . A detailed comparison of the whole phase diagram has been carried out in ref. 21 , with full agreement for m # > 30 GeV. Thus, we can really rely on the result in Fig. 1. Let us now discuss the physical conclusions drawn from Fig. 1. As pointed out in the Introduction, for baryogenesis we need a first order phase transition, and even a strong one, Aw/T > 1. We have learned that a first order transition only exists for m # < 72 GeV. Furthermore, it has in fact Av/T< 1.0 down to ran ~ 10 GeV! 4 ' 6 ' 7 Thus, we observe that experimentally allowed Higgs masses m # > 110 GeV 34 are very far from allowing for a first order electroweak phase transition, let alone for electroweak baryogenesis. Finally, let us briefly mention a related physics topic, which is of some interest because its solution is not yet understood as well as the issues above. It is the question as to how the properties of the phase transition change if there are primordial magnetic fields present, 3S or, more generally, whether magnetic fields could in some way be related to the baryon asymmetry. 36 6
How to change the properties of the phase transition?
From the discussion in the previous section, it is clear that if we want to have an electroweak phase transition which is of the first order for realistic Higgs masses, and even strongly so, then a drastic change is needed with respect to the Standard Model. What is it that should be changed? As the strength of the transition is determined by the scalar self-coupling, cf. Eq. (5), we apparently need some new degree of freedom which can decrease the effective A3 by 0(100%). To get such a large correction in the first place, we need a bosonic zero mode with an expansion parameter like in Eq. (3). A simple perturbative 1-loop computation shows that at least the sign of loop corrections of this type is the correct one, negative. But to have an effect of O(100%), we need e ~ 1, so that m ~ g2T/n. That is, the degree of freedom should itself be non-perturbative! In principle, there are two kinds of possibilities for such degrees of freedom. Either it is a new type of a gauge field, maybe something like technicolour, or a scalar. In the latter, more natural case, there are thermal
64
corrections in the effective mass parameter, appearing as m2 ~ m | d + g2T2. Thus, to get a total outcome of order (g2T)2, a cancellation must take place such that the mass parameter m\A is negative. At zero temperature, the physical mass is then roughly m j h y s < m | d + m2op <m2op. In order for such a relatively light degree of freedom not to have shown up so far in precision electroweak observables, it should be an SU(2) singlet. It is interesting that scalar degrees of freedom satisfying these requirements can be found in realistic theories. Consider, for instance, the MSSM. Potential candidates are squarks and sleptons. Since they should couple relatively strongly to the Higgs, we should choose stops. Now, the stops come left- and right-handed, £L,£R (these states can also mix, but for lack of space we ignore this here). The requirement of having a small violation of the electroweak precision observables means that the weakly interacting left-handed one cannot be light, mj ~S> mtop. This helps also in getting a large Higgs mass (see, e.g., ref. 3 7 ) , 2
2
2ofl ,
3
#2
m
toP ,
m
igmiL
,-.
h (7) TO| cos^2/3 + — T — ^ In —%— -. 2 8?r mfv mfop On the contrary, the SU(2) singlet stop in can be "light", and serve as the desired new degree of freedom. (Then we of course lose half of the correction to rnf{ in Eq. (7), but this is the price to pay.) It should not be so light that the stop direction gets broken before the electroweak phase transition, though, because then one cannot get back to the SM minimum afterwards. 14 Another example of a viable light scalar degree of freedom is the complex gauge singlet of the NMSSM, which can also get broken during the transition (for a recent study, see 3 8 ) .
mjf ~
7
Numerical results for the MSSM
Under the conditions described in the previous section, resummed 2-loop perturbation theory indicates that the electroweak phase transition can indeed be strong enough for baryogenesis. 1 0 ~ 1 5 To check the reliability of perturbation theory, a 3d effective theory was constructed in refs. 10 ' 40 . The Lagrangian in Eq. (4) is supplemented by the right-handed stop field U and the SU(3) gauge fields, with the field strength tensor Gif. 5£3d = iTrG?- + {DIUJ*D\U + m2U3U^U + XU3(U^U)2
+ 7 3>W^-
(8)
Simulations with this action have been carried out in ref. 41 , and with a more complicated version thereof, involving two Higgs doublets, in ref. 39 .
65 i
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
r
1.5
,o' "S 1.0
<
I 2-loop 0.5,
tt.O
1-loop
0.5
1.0 Ta
Figure 2. The continuum extrapolation (i.e., lattice spacing a —• 0) of the numerically determined Av/T, compared with perturbation theory, for particular MSSM parameters. 3 9 The transition is strongly of the first order here.
The results are illustrated in Fig. 2 for a particular choice of parameters. We find the encouraging outcome that, in fact, for a light right-handed stop the 2-loop estimates are reliable and even somewhat conservative. This is in strong contrast to the case of the SM at realistic Higgs masses. Next, we must ask more rigorously whether this parameter region is indeed in agreement with all experimental data. The most important constraint comes from the lower bound on the Higgs mass. 34 There is a parameter in the MSSM, mA, which determines whether the Higgs sector resembles that in the Standard Model (mA > 120 GeV) or not (mA < 120 GeV). In the latter case, the experimental lower bound is relaxed, 34 and since the transition needs not always get significantly weaker (see Fig. 3, and ref. 39 for more details), this case is acceptable. The other possibility is having a large mA, but then the left-handed stop should be quite heavy, mi > 2 TeV (see Fig. 3), in order to increase the Higgs mass. 8
C P violation in t h e b a c k g r o u n d field configuration
So far, we have discussed the strength of the phase transition. Let us finally very briefly touch another issue relevant for baryogenesis, CP violation. Even though the strength of the phase transition is determined by a single "dynamical" Higgs doublet, in the MSSM there are of course in principle two
66 rn^—l TeV.tanP=12
mA=120GeV, lanp=12
>
150 m,/GeV
Figure 3. The Higgs mass ran, a n d the maximal discontinuity Av/T according to 2-loop perturbation theory, as a function of m ^ (left) and m i (right). 3 9 With lines we indicate the regions least constrained by experiment (already somewhat smaller than in ref. 3 4 ) .
of them, of which the one discussed above, <j> in Eqs. (4), (8), was a particular linear combination (see, e.g., ref. 3 9 ) . However, the direction orthogonal to 4> could play a role for CP violation. Indeed, when there are two Higgses, H\,H2, then there is for instance a new low-dimensional gauge invariant CPodd observable \mH\H-2. It could obtain a non-vanishing value, in principle even a large one, as is the case in spontaneous CP violation. 42 If so, then at the semi-classical level, fermion mass matrices may obtain non-trivial spacedependent phases, so that particles and anti-particles have different dispersion relations, which could be of relevance to baryon asymmetry generation. However, in practice such interesting effects are quite small. The reason is that all the effects related to the orthogonal direction are suppressed at least by ~ g2T/[ir(m2A + 0.5T 2 )2]. 39 Here mA, experimentally > m ^ , 34 measures the deviation from the single Higgs doublet dynamics at zero temperature, and the temperature correction is seen to increase the suppression further on. This situation is illustrated in Fig. 4, which shows the profile of a stationary phase interface (for perturbative analyses of such objects, see ref. 4 3 and references therein). We observe that in field space, the transition takes place in one particular direction (see also 1 8 ), and CP violation is small, as if the system effectively only had one dynamical CP even Higgs doublet.
67
0.0007
broken phase
0.0006
X
broken phase
symmetric phase
symmetric phase 0„8, 0.593
0.594
0.595
0.596
0.597
0.0004
_l
0.02
t__l
0.03
,
I
0.04
i
L_
0.05
0.06
2
HTH./T
Figure 4. Behaviour of H^H2, plotted against Hi Hi, and — I m i / J ^ 2 > plotted against across a phase interface at Tc, for particular MSSM parameters. 3 9
9
Conclusions
We have reviewed the methods that can be employed in determining the thermodynamical properties of the phase transition related to electroweak gauge symmetry restoration, as well as the numerical results that are already available for the Standard Model and for its Minimal Supersymmetric extension. The general statement to be remembered, is that there is no phase transition at all in electroweak theories with realistic Higgs masses, unless there is also another light scalar degree of freedom available, which plays an essential role in the phase transition dynamics. As a concrete phenomenological example, we have recalled that it is still possible to find parts of the MSSM parameter space, not excluded by experiment, where the electroweak phase transition is strongly enough of the first order to allow for baryon asymmetry generation. However, these parts are quite restricted: not only does one need one "light" stop, mj R < mtop, in order to get a strong transition, but also either another stop which is much heavier, miL > 10m tO p, or a Higgs sector which has at least two independent light particles, m^ < 120 GeV, in order not to violate experimental constraints. Acknowledgments I thank D. Bodeker and K. Rummukainen for useful comments. This work was partly supported by the TMR network Finite Temperature Phase Transitions
68
in Particle Physics, EU contract no. FMRX-CT97-0122, and by the RTN network Supersymmetry and the Early Universe, EU contract no. HPRN-CT2000-00152. References 1. D.A. Kirzhnits, JETP Lett. 15, 529 (1972); D.A. Kirzhnits, A.D. Linde, Phys. Lett. B 42, 471 (1972); S. Weinberg, Phys. Rev. D 9, 3357 (1974); L. Dolan, R. Jackiw, Phys. Rev. D 9, 3320 (1974). 2. V.A. Kuzmin, V.A. Rubakov, M.E. Shaposhnikov, Phys. Lett. B 155, 36 (1985); M.E. Shaposhnikov, Nucl. Phys. B 287, 757 (1987). 3. V.A. Rubakov, M.E. Shaposhnikov, Usp. Fiz. Nauk 166, 493 (1996) [hepph/9603208]. 4. K. Kajantie et al, Nucl. Phys. B 466, 189 (1996) [hep-lat/9510020]. 5. G.D. Moore, Phys. Rev. D 59, 014503 (1999) [hep-ph/9805264]. 6. R Arnold, O. Espinosa, Phys. Rev. D 47, 3546 (1993) [hep-ph/9212235]; ibid. D 50, 6662 (1994) (E). 7. Z. Fodor, A. Hebecker, Nucl. Phys. B 432, 127 (1994) [hep-ph/9403219]. 8. K. Farakos et al, Nucl. Phys. B 425, 67 (1994) [hep-ph/9404201]. 9. J.R. Espinosa, Nucl. Phys. B 475, 273 (1996) [hep-ph/9604320]; B. de Carlos, J.R. Espinosa, Nucl. Phys. B 503, 24 (1997) [hep-ph/9703212]. 10. D. Bodeker et al, Nucl. Phys. B 497, 387 (1997) [hep-ph/9612364]. 11. M. Carenaet al, Nucl. Phys. B 524, 3 (1998) [hep-ph/9710401]. 12. J.M. Cline, G.D. Moore, Phys. Rev. Lett. 81, 3315 (1998) [hep-ph/ 9806354]. 13. M. Losada, Nucl. Phys. B 537, 3 (1999) [hep-ph/9806519]. 14. J.M. Cline et al, Phys. Rev. D 60, 105035 (1999) [hep-ph/9902220]. 15. M. Losada, Nucl. Phys. B 569,125 (2000) [hep-ph/9905441]; S. Davidson, T. Falk, M. Losada, Phys. Lett. B 463, 214 (1999) [hep-ph/9907365]. 16. A.D. Linde, Phys. Lett. B 96, 289 (1980); D.J. Gross, R.D. Pisarski, L.G. Yaffe, Rev. Mod. Phys. 53, 43 (1981). 17. F. Csikor et al, Phys. Rev. Lett. 82, 21 (1999) [hep-ph/9809291]. 18. F. Csikor et al, Phys. Rev. Lett. 85, 932 (2000) [hep-ph/0001087]. 19. M.E. Shaposhnikov, in Erice 1996, Effective theories and fundamental interactions, pp. 360-383 [hep-ph/9610247]; A. Nieto, Int. J. Mod. Phys. A 12, 1431 (1997) [hep-ph/9612291]; M. Laine, in Eger 1997, Strong and electroweak matter '97, pp. 160-177 [hep-ph/9707415]. 20. K. Kajantie et al, Nucl. Phys. B 458, 90 (1996) [hep-ph/9508379]. 21. M. Laine, JHEP 9906, 020 (1999) [hep-ph/9903513]. 22. K. Kajantie et al, Nucl. Phys. B 493, 413 (1997) [hep-lat/9612006].
69 23. O. Philipsen et al, Nud. Phys. B 469, 445 (1996) [hep-lat/9602006]. 24. M. Giirtler et al, Phys. Rev. D 56, 3888 (1997) [hep-lat/9704013]. 25. A. Jakovac, A. Patkos, Phys. Lett. B 334, 391 (1994) [hep-ph/9405424]; Nud. Phys. B 494, 54 (1997) [hep-ph/9609364]. 26. J.M. Cline, K. Kainulainen, Nud. Phys. B 482, 73 (1996) [hepph/9605235]; ibid. 510, 88 (1998) [hep-ph/9705201]; M. Losada, Phys. Rev. D 56, 2893 (1997) [hep-ph/9605266]; G.R. Farrar, M. Losada, Phys. Lett. B 406, 60 (1997) [hep-ph/9612346]; M. Laine, Nud. Phys. B 481, 43 (1996) [hep-ph/9605283]; ibid. 548, 637 (1999) (E). 27. M. Laine, M. Losada, Nud. Phys. B 582, 277 (2000) [hep-ph/0003111]. 28. K. Kajantie et al, Phys. Lett. B 423, 137 (1998) [hep-ph/9710538]. 29. K. Farakos et al, Nud. Phys. B 442, 317 (1995) [hep-lat/9412091]. 30. M. Laine, Nud. Phys. B 451, 484 (1995) [hep-lat/9504001]; M. Laine, A. Rajantie, Nud. Phys. B 513, 471 (1998) [hep-lat/9705003]. 31. G.D. Moore, Nud. Phys. B 493, 439 (1997) [hep-lat/9610013]; ibid. 523, 569 (1998) [hep-lat/9709053]. 32. K. Rummukainen et al, Nud. Phys. B 532, 283 (1998) [hep-lat/9805013]. 33. M. Laine, K. Rummukainen, Nud. Phys. B (Proc. Suppl.) 73, 180 (1999) [hep-lat/9809045]. 34. ALEPH, DELPHI, L3, OPAL Collaborations, http://alephwww.cern.ch/ALPUB/oldconf/oldconf00/29/moriond.ps. 35. P. Elmfors et al, Phys. Lett. B 440, 269 (1998) [hep-ph/9806403]; K. Kajantie et al, Nud. Phys. B 544, 357 (1999) [hep-lat/9809004]; M. Laine, hep-ph/0001292. 36. M. Joyce, M. Shaposhnikov, Phys. Rev. Lett. 79, 1193 (1997) [astroph/9703005]; M. Giovannini, M.E. Shaposhnikov, Phys. Rev. D 57, 2186 (1998) [hep-ph/9710234]; D. Comelli et al, Phys. Lett. B 458, 304 (1999) [hep-ph/9903227]; M. Laine, M. Shaposhnikov, Phys. Lett. B 463, 280 (1999) [hep-th/9907194]. 37. J. Ellis, G. Ridolfi, F. Zwirner, Phys. Lett. B 262, 477 (1991). 38. S.J. Huber, M.G. Schmidt, Eur. Phys. J. C 10, 473 (1999) [hepph/9809506]; hep-ph/0003122. 39. M. Laine, K. Rummukainen, hep-lat/0009025. 40. M. Laine, K. Rummukainen, Nud. Phys. B 545, 141 (1999) [hepph/9811369]. 41. M. Laine, K. Rummukainen, Phys. Rev. Lett. 80, 5259 (1998) [hepph/9804255]; Nud. Phys. B 535, 423 (1998) [hep-lat/9804019]. 42. T.D. Lee, Phys. Rev. D 8, 1226 (1973). 43. S.J. Huber et al, Phys. Lett. B 475, 104 (2000) [hep-ph/9912278].
A S P E C T S OF SEMI-CLASSICAL T R A N S P O R T T H E O R Y FOR QCD
DANIEL F. LITIM * Theory
Division,
CERN,
CH-1211
Geneva
23,
Switzerland.
We discuss some aspects of a recently proposed semi-classical transport theory for QCD plasmas based on coloured point particles. This includes the derivation of effective transport equations for mean fields and fluctuations which relies on the Gibbs ensemble average. Correlators of fluctuations are interpreted as collision integrals for the effective Boltzmann equation. The approach yields a recipe to integrate-out fluctuations. Systematic approximations (first moment, second moment, polarisation approximation) based on a small plasma parameter are discussed as well. Finally, the application to a hot non-Abelian plasma close to thermal equilibrium is considered and the consistency with the fluctuation-dissipation theorem established.
1
Introduction
Reliable theoretical tools to describe transport phenomena of hot or dense QCD plasmas in- or out-of equilibrium are at the basis for an understanding of the quark-gluon-plasma. This extreme state of matter where quarks and gluons are no longer confined is expected to be produced within the up-coming heavy ion experiments at RHIC and LHC. In the present contribution a recently proposed semi-classical method to derive effective transport equations for QCD is reviewed, developed in collaboration with Cristina Manuel in ref. 1'4. The interest in a formalism based on a classical transport theory 5 is that main properties of a hot quantum plasma can already be understood within simple classical terms. Indeed, the soft non-Abelian gauge fields - those having a huge occupation number - can be treated as classical fields, while the hard gauge field modes and the quarks can be treated as classical particles. This approach has been known since long for Abelian plasmas 6 , but a consistent extension to the non-Abelian case was longtime missing. Here, we discuss some conceptual aspects of this method, and in particular the step from a microscopic to a macroscopic (kinetic) formulation, the close relationship between the ensemble average and the notion of coarsegraining, and systematic expansions in a small plasma parameter or gauge coupling. The latter is at the basis for the integrating-out of fluctuations and •DANIEL.LITIMOCERN.CH
70
71
the derivation of collision integrals. For a hot plasma close to equilibrium it has been shown that the HTL effective theory follows to leading order in an expansion in moments 7 . We review how Bodeker's effective theory 8 is recovered at second order in this expansion. Finally, the compatibility with the fluctuation-dissipation theorem is established 3 . 2
Classical particles and fields
The starting point for a classical transport theory is to consider an ensemble of classical point particles interacting through classical non-Abelian gauge fields. Such an approach is known since long for Coulomb plasmas of charged point particles interacting through photons 6 . The new ingredience in the case of QCD is that the particles have to carry a non-Abelian colour charge Qa, where the colour index runs from a = 1 to N2 — 1 for a SU(N) gauge group. These particles interact self-consistently amongst each others, that is, through the classical gauge fields created by the particles. Their classical equations of motion have first been given by Wong 9 , a m^-=p", m^f~ = -ff/o6cpM*gc • (1) m^=gQ FrP„, dr dr dr a abc C Here, A^ denotes the gauge field, F% = d^A" - dvA il + gf A^A „ the corresponding field strength and z = (X,P,Q)(T) the world line of a particle. The particles interact self-consistently through classical Yang-Mills fields,
DpF"" = r ,
(2)
where the current J is the sum of the currents for the individual particles, J = g J2i J dr5(x — ii)dxi/dr. To further a kinetic description it is useful to introduce a microscopic one-particle distribution function f(z) ~ ^ f dr6[z — Z{(T)] which describes an ensemble of such particles. Making use of (1), its kinetic equation is 5
p" (£r*-°^A&w-9Q-F^£-)
f{x p Q) = 0
''
-
(3)
This Boltzmann equation is collisionless, since df/dr = 0 (Liouville's theorem). However, it contains effectively collisions due to the long range interactions as shall become clear in the sequel. The Wong equations transform covariantly under gauge transformations which entails that / and (3) are gauge invariant 7 . Eq. (3) is completed by the Yang-Mills equation (2), where the current J becomes now a functional J[f] of the one-particle distribution function. These equations constitute the basis for the construction of a semiclassical kinetic theory.
72 3
Kinetic theory
W i t h i n the semi-classical approach all informations about properties of the Q C D p l a s m a are given by the microscopic dynamical equations (2) and (3). However, for most situations not all microscopic informations are of relevance. Of m a i n physical interest are the characteristics of the Q C D p l a s m a at macroscopic scales. T h i s includes quantities like d a m p i n g rates, colour conductivities or screening lengths within the kinetic regime, or transport coefficients like shear or bulk viscosities within the hydrodynamic regime. T h e microscopic length scales, like typical inter-particle distances, are much smaller t h a n such macroscopic scales. Given the statistical ensemble - representing the state of the system its macroscopic properties follow as functions of the fundamental parameters and the interactions between the particles. Within kinetic theory, the basic 'macroscopic' quantity is the one-particle distribution function from which all further macroscopic observables can be derived. T h e aim of a kinetic theory is to construct - with as little restrictions or assumptions as possible - a closed set of transport equations for this distribution function. Such an approach assumes implicitly t h a t the ' m e d i u m ' , described by the distribution function, is continuous. If the medium is not continuous, stochastic fluctuations due to the particles should be taken into account as well, and their consistent inclusion leads to a coupled set of effective transport equations for correlators of fluctuations and the one-particle distribution function 6 . In this classical picture, / is a deterministic quantity once all initial conditions have been fixed. Unfortunately, this is not possible, and / has to be considered as a stochastic (fluctuating) quantity instead. The random fluctuations of the distribution function are at the root of the dissipative character of the effective transport theory.
4
Coarse graining and ensemble average
T h e step from a microscopic to a macroscopic (kinetic) description requires an appropriate definition of macroscopic quantities in the first place. There are (at least) two possible options. T h e first one consists in taking both volume and time averages of the microscopic distribution function / , the non-Abelian fields and the Boltzmann equation (3) over characteristic physical length and t i m e scales 3 . Clearly, the notion of a characteristic physical scale depends on the particular problem studied. A reasonable choice for a coarse graining scale r p h has to met some few criteria. T h e coarse graining scale r p h should be sufficiently large such t h a t the number of particles Nph contained in r^h is
73
^> 1. This is at the basis for a plasma description in the first place, because Nph ^> 1 ensures that many particles interact coherently within a coarsegraining volume (quasi-particle behaviour). The inverse of Wph is also known as the plasma parameter e. In addition, rph should be larger than a typical two-particle correlation length r cor r- This ensures that two-particle correlators <72 can be neglected. Finally, rph should be smaller than the macroscopic scales of the plasma to be investigated, like typical relaxation lengths rre\. This way it is guaranteed that the scales of interest are not washed-out. Such coarse grainings remove (irrelevant) microscopic information and thereby modify the transport equation which is expected to become of the Boltzmann-Langevin type, p" (D, - gQaF%d;)
f = C[f] + C •
(4)
Here, we introduced £>M[A]/ = [d^ — gfabcQcA^tbd^]f and the shorthands 9M = d/dx^, d^ = d/dp^ and d$ = d/dQa. The new terms on the r.h.s. are the collision integral C[f] and a related source for stochastic noise £ on the r.h.s. of (4) are due to the fact that the Boltzmann equation (3) is quadratic and cubic in the fields. Physically speaking, these terms arise because the coarse-graining integrates-out the short range modes within a coarse-graining volume. The interactions of such modes can result into additional effective interactions for the remaining long range modes. A second route for obtaining kinetic equations consists in taking an ensemble average of the microscopic transport equation. In the present context we consider particles in a phase space, hence the appropriate average is the Gibbs ensemble average henceforth denoted by (•••). All statistical informations of the system are then contained in the correlators (6f • • • Sf) with Sf = / — ( / ) = / — / denoting the statistical fluctuations of / about its mean value. The most important equal-time correlator is the quadratic one given by (6fx,P,Q 6f*,p>,Q>) =
(27T) 3 J( 3 )(X
- x ' M ( 3 ) ( P - p')6(Q - Q') f + 0(g2)
(5)
where we have neglected higher order corrections due to the two-particle correlation function g2- Similar formula hold for higher order equal-time correlation function. Notice that (5) does not require further informations about the state of the system and applies equally to systems in- or out-of equilibrium. While (5) has been proven rigorously for particles with classical statistics, its generalisation to the case of quantum statistics is known only for weakly interacting particles and consists in replacing
f^f(l±f) in (5) for Bose-Einstein (+) or Fermi-Dirac (—) statistics.
(6)
74
5
Effective transport equations
We now apply the Gibbs ensemble average to the Boltzmann equation (3) in order to derive an effective kinetic equation of the form (4). To that end, we split / into its mean value and a fluctuating part f(x,p,Q)
= f(x,p,Q)+6f(x,p,Q)
,
(7)
where / = (/). The mean value of the statistical fluctuations vanish by definition, (Sf) = 0. This separation into mean fields and statistical, random fluctuations corresponds effectively to a split into long vs. short wavelength modes associated to the mean fields vs. fluctuations. In addition to (7) we split the gauge field into a mean field part and fluctuations, A"(x) = A"(x) + a^(X) ,
(8)
with A — (A) and (a) = 0. This split should been seen on a different footing as the split (7) because the Gibbs ensemble average is defined for the particlelike degrees of freedom in the first place. One may wonder whether (8) - and the subsequent split of the dynamical equations - is compatible with gauge symmetry because the gauge field transforms non-linearly. The situation is very similar to the background field method used in path integral formulations of QFT and the compatibility of (8) with gauge symmetry follows along the same lines. For more details, see ref. 2 . Coming back to the initial set of dynamical equations (2) and (3), we perform the ensemble average to find
p" (A. - 9QaF^p)
f=(r,) + (0 .
(9)
for the effective transport equation, and DrF"" + WJ = J" • (10) for the effective Yang-Mills equations. In (9) and (10), we collected all terms quadratic or cubic in the fluctuations into the functions Ti = gQap>'[(Dllav-D„alt)a
+ gfabcabltal]
£ = 0 p T 6 c Q c [d?al Sf(x,p,Q) J*?. = 9 [ / *
C
abc
A > . X + f abtli
%Sf(x,p,Q)
+galal%f(x,p,Q)]
,
(11)
,
(12)
cde
• (13)
((D«a» - D»a»)c + gf a^)]
The set of equations (9) - (13) is not yet closed as they still involve correlators of fluctuations. Hence, we need their dynamical equations as well. Subtracting (3) from (9) we find for the dynamics of Sf p" (D,-gQaF^d;)
Sf = gQa(D»au -
D„a^)ap»dpJ
+9P»ab,f,fabcQcd?f
+ n + £ - (v + 0 • (H)
75 Subtracting (2) from (10) yields the corresponding equation for the gauge field fluctuations, to wit ( D V - D " ( A , a " ) ) ° + 29rhcF^a^
+ JS£ - ( «
=
6ja
-"
•
(15)
Eqs. (14) and (15) are the master equations for all higher order correlation functions of fluctuations, e.g. multiplying (14) by 6f and taking the ensemble average yields the Boltzmann equation for the correlator (SfSf). This hierarchy of dynamical equations is similar to the B B G K Y hierarchy. All the equal-time correlators of Sf can be derived from the basic definition of the Gibbs ensemble average in phase space and serve as initial conditions 2 . We remark t h a t the set of dynamical equations (9) - (15) is equivalent to the original set of microscopic equations. It is exact in t h a t no further approximations - apart from the assumptions leading to (1) and (2) - have been performed so far. Furthermore, it can be applied to out-of-equilibrium situations simply because the Gibbs ensemble average is not bound to a plasma close-to-equilibrium. 6
Collision integrals
Let us comment on the terms 77, £ and J fl „ c in the dynamical equations. In the effective Boltzmann equation, the functions (77) and (£) appear only after the splitting (7) and (8) has been performed. These terms are qualitatively different from those already present in the transport equation. T h e correlators (77) and (£) are interpreted as effective collision integrals of the macroscopic Boltzm a n n equation. T h e fluctuations in the distribution function of the particles induce fluctuations in the gauge fields, while the gauge field fluctuations, in turn, induce fluctuations in the motion of the quasi-particles. In the present formalism, the correlators of statistical fluctuations have the same effect as collisions. This yields a precise recipe for obtaining collision integrals within semi-classical transport theory. In the Abelian limit the transport equations reduce to the known set of kinetic equations for Abelian plasmas and only the collision integral (77) survives. Here it is known t h a t (77) can be explicitly expressed as the BalescuLenard collision integral 6 . This substantiates the correspondence between fluctuations and collisions in an Abelian plasma. At the same time we observe the presence of stochastic noise in the effective equations. T h e noise originates in the source fluctuations of the particle distributions and induces field-independent fluctuations to the gauge fields. T h e corresponding terms in the effective Boltzmann equations are therefore 77, £ and J f!uc at vanishing mean field or mean current.
76
Finally, we observe the presence of a fluctuation-induced current (Jf|UC) in the effective Yang-Mills equation for the mean fields. This current, due to its very nature, stems from the induced correlations of gauge field fluctuations. It vanishes identically in the Abelian case. While the collision integrals are linear in the quasi-particle fluctuations, the induced current only contains the gauge field fluctuations. As the fluctuations of the one-particle distribution function are the basic source for fluctuations, we expect that a non-vanishing induced current will appear as a subleading effect. In order to find explicitly the collision integrals, noise sources or the fluctuation-induced currents for non-Abelian plasmas, one has to solve first the dynamical equations for the fluctuations in the background of the mean fields. This step amounts to 'integrating-out' fluctuations. In general, this is a difficult task, in particular due to the non-linear terms present in 77, £ and Jfluc. This will only be possible within some approximations. 7
Plasma parameter and moment expansions
When it comes to solving the kinetic equations - and in particular the fluctuation dynamics - it is necessary to identify a small expansion parameter which allows for systematic approximations of the hierarchy of dynamical equations for correlation functions. The non-Abelian plasma is characterised by two dimensionless parameters, the gauge coupling g and the plasma parameter e. A small plasma parameter is mandatory for a kinetic description to be viable. For a classical plasma, e is an independent parameter related to the mean particle number and the gauge coupling. For a quantum plasma, the mean particle number cannot be fixed arbitrarily, and t scales proportional to the gauge coupling as e ~ g3
(16)
This is at the basis for a systematic organisation of the dynamical equations
77 in powers of g.7 To leading order, this concerns in particular the cubic correlators appearing in (n) and (J f | UC )- They are suppressed by a power of g as compared to the quadratic ones. At the same time, the quadratic correlator ~ fabc(abac) within (£) is also suppressed by an additional power of g and should be suppressed to leading order. An expansion in m o m e n t s of the fluctuations has its origin in the framework of kinetic equations, which describe the coherent behaviour of the particles within some physically relevant volume, described by the p l a s m a p a r a m e — 1/2
ter £. T h e fluctuations in the number of particles ~ N h become arbitrarily small if the physical volume - or the number of particles contained in it can be m a d e arbitrarily large. For realistic situations, both of t h e m are finite. Still, the fluctuations remain at least parametrically small and suppressed by the plasma parameter. Hence, the underlying expansion p a r a m e t e r for an expansion in m o m e n t s of fluctuations is a small p l a s m a p a r a m e t e r e < l .
(17)
T h e leading order approximation in an expansion in m o m e n t s assumes e = 0. This is the first moment approximation which consists in imposing / = / ,
or
Sf = 0,
(18)
and neglects fluctuations throughout. Sometimes it is referred to as the mean field or Vlasov approximation. It leads to a closed system of equations for the mean one-particle distribution function and the gauge fields. In particular, the corresponding Boltzmann equation is dissipationless. Beyond leading order, the second moment approximation takes into account the corrections due to correlators up to quadratic order in the fluctuations (SfSf). All higher order correlators like (Sf\Sf2 . . -Sfn) = 0 for n > 2 are neglected within the dynamical equations for the mean fields and the quadratic correlators. This approximation is viable if the fluctuations remain sufficiently small. We remark t h a t the second m o m e n t approximation no longer yields a closed system of dynamical equations for the one-particle distribution function and quadratic correlators because the initial conditions for the evolution of correlators, which are given by the equal-time correlation functions as derived from the Gibbs ensemble average, involve the twoparticle correlation functions g-z- Hence, we have to require t h a t two-particle correlators remain sufficiently small as compared to products of one-particle distribution functions. This approximation is known as the approximation of second correlation functions, sometimes also referred to as the polarisation approximation 6 .
78 For the dynamical equations of the fluctuations these approximations imply t h a t the terms non-linear in the fluctuations should be neglected to leading order, setting t)-(ri)
= 0,
£-(£} = 0,
y fluc - (J f l u c ) = 0 .
(19)
It permits truncating the infinite hierarchy of equations for the mean fields and the correlators of fluctuations down to a closed system of differential equations for both mean quantities and quadratic correlators. T h e polarisation approximation is the minimal choice necessary to genuinely describe dissipative processes, because it takes into account the feed-back of stochastic fluctuations within the particle distribution function. Finally we notice t h a t small fluctuations Sf about / in (16) are already of the same order of magnitude as the small corrections from g f^ once tf/^V/^ ~ ACJi ^ 1- This means t h a t fluctuations do contribute to the effective kinetic equations even if only small departures from the mean value gf^1'
8
Thermal plasmas
We now turn to the specific example of a hot plasma close to thermal equilibrium. 'Hot' implies t h a t particle masses can be neglected to leading order m -C T, and t h a t the gauge coupling, as a function of t e m p e r a t u r e , is very small g(T)
f = feq+gf{1)
+ Sf.
(20)
Solving (9) in the first moment approximation, t h a t is using (20) for Sf = 0, has been shown in ref. 7 to reproduce the HTL effective theory. Beyond the HTL level we employ the polarisation approximation where < 5 / ^ 0 . It consists in discarding cubic correlator terms in (9) in favour of quadratic ones. Employing (19) means t h a t the effects of collisions are neglected for the dynamics of the fluctuations. All these approximations can be systematically improved to higher order.
79
Let us consider colour excitations, described by the colour current density
J„"(*, v) = 9-^- JdQdPod\p\
|p| 3 6(p 0 ) S(p2) Qa f(x,p, Q) ,
(21)
and v^ = p^/po = ( l , v ) , v 2 = 1. The current J is obtained after an angle average over the directions of v as J(x) = J ^j%-J(x, v). The colour measure dQ is normalised f dQ = 1 and contains the Casimir constraints of the gauge group, such as JdQQaQb = C-z&ab with the quadratic group Casimir C2 — N for particles in the adjoint representation of SU(N) and C% = \ for particles in the fundamental 2 ' 7 . The approximate dynamical equations for the fluctuations become (v"D„ 5J")a
= -mly'v"
( £ > V - D"(Da))a
(D,a0 - £» 0 a M ) a - W
+ 2gfabcF^ae,l/
<
j ^
= 6J£ ,
,
(22) (23)
where the quantum Debye mass for SU(N) with Np quarks and anti-quarks
= g2T2(2N
+ NF)/6
(24)
obtains from the equilibrium (Bose-Einstein or Fermi-Dirac) distribution function and the group representation of the particles. The classical Debye mass follows by using the Maxwell-Boltzmann distribution, instead. Solving for the fluctuations in the present approximations yields a closed expression for SJ, and an iterative expansion in powers of the background fields for a (see ref. 2 for the explicit expressions). The seeked-for dynamical equation for the mean quasi-particle colour excitations is ^ A ^ ° + ™ o ^ o = C l l n [J°] + C(z,v) ,
(25)
where the linearised collision integral C\m can now be evaluated explicitly, using the expressions for a and SJ. The Yang-Mills equation remains unchanged at this order. For the collision integral, one finally obtains to linear order in the mean current, and to leading logarithmic order (LLO) in (In l/) _ 1 <s£ 1 Cnn[ja°l(x, v) = gfabc (4(z)SJ^(x,v))\A=0i = -7/^/(v,v')Ja°(*,v')
, . _ . „ ,-
LLO
(26)
with the kernel 7(v,v') = J 2 (v - v') - f ( v . v ' ) 2 / \ / l - (v.v') 2 . Notice that the collision integral is local in coordinate space, but non-local in the angle variables. The rate 7 = ^ j - In \/g is (twice) the hard gluon damping rate.
80 In obtaining (26), we introduced an infra-red cut-off ~ gm£> for the elsewise unscreened magnetic sector. This result has been first obtained by Bodeker in ref. 8 . For alternative derivations, see ref. 1 0 ' n . In addition, the source for stochastic noise £ in (25) can be identified as C a ( x , v ) = 9fabcab,{x)SJ^(x,v)\A=Qj=0
.
(27)
Making use of the basic correlator (5), its self-correlator follows to LLO as (C°(z,vK 6 (2/,v')} = 2 7 m | > T I ( v , v ' ) S a b S(x - y) .
(28)
Notice t h a t the strength of the correlator is determined by the kernel of the collision integral, e.g. by the dissipative process. Next, we show the close relationship to the fluctuation-dissipation theorem ( F D T ) . 9
Fluctuation-dissipation theorem
It is well-known t h a t dissipation in a quasi-stationary p l a s m a ( = no entropy production) is intimately linked to the fluctuations, a link which is given by the F D T . We shall argue t h a t the F D T holds true for the above set of equations. To t h a t end, following ref. 3 , we consider the coarse-grained kinetic equation (4) and ask how the spectral functions of the noise source C, and of / have to be related to C[f] in order to satisfy the F D T . W i t h i n classical transport theory, the F D T is implemented in a straightforward way 1 2 . T h e pivotal element is the kinetic entropy S[f]. We consider small deviations of / from the equilibrium, / = / e q + A / . The entropy, stationary at equilibrium, is expanded to quadratic order in A / , S = 5 e q + AS. Defining the thermodynamical force in the usual way as F(z) = —S(AS)/S(Af(z)), where z = {x,p,Q), we obtain F(s,p,Q) = A/(*,p,Q)//eq
(29)
for a classical plasma. The thermodynamical force for the q u a n t u m case follows from (29) using (6). Given C[f](z), it can be shown 3 ' 1 2 t h a t
<«*<'» = - » £ $ ) is the required noise-noise self-correlator for £ compatible with the F D T . For the particular example studied above, (28) follows from inserting (26) into (30), proving t h a t Bodeker's effective theory is compatible with the F D T . Furthermore, the correlator ( A / A / ) | t = t < can be derived along the same lines and agrees, to leading order, with (5fSf)\t=t' derived from the Gibbs ensemble average. This guarantees t h a t the formalism is consistent with F D T .
81
10
Summary
We have reviewed a semi-classical approach to derive effective transport equations for Q C D based on 'integrating-out' fluctuations about some mean fields. Most interestingly, the approach is applicable for in- and out-of-equilibrium situations, opening a door for future applications to out-of-equilibrium plasmas. T h e formalism is consistent with the underlying non-Abelian mean field symmetry, and allows for systematic expansions controlled by a small p l a s m a parameter which is at the basis for any reliable computation. For thermal plasmas we have discussed how the collision integral as well as the necessary noise source follow explicitly from the microscopic theory to leading logarithmic accuracy, reproducing Bodeker's effective theory, and establishing the consistency with the fluctuation-dissipation theorem. As a final comment we point out t h a t the effective theory is the same for a classical or a q u a n t u m plasma, differing only in the equilibrium distribution function, and hence in the corresponding value for the Debye mass. T h e sole ' q u a n t u m ' effect which entered the computation resides in the non-classical statistics of the particles, which is all t h a t is needed to correctly describe a hot quantum non-Abelian plasma close to equilibrium at the present order of accuracy. References 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12.
D. F. Litim and C. Manuel, Phys. Rev. Lett. 8 2 (1999) 4981. D. F. Litim and C. Manuel, Nucl. Phys. B 5 6 2 (1999) 237. D. F. Litim and C. Manuel, Phys. Rev. D 6 1 (2000) 125004. D. F. Litim and C. Manuel, hep-ph/0003302. U. Heinz, Phys. Rev. Lett. 5 1 (1983) 351; Ann. Phys. 1 6 1 (1985) 48. Yu. L. Klimontovich, "Statistical Physics", Harwood Publ, (1986). P.R. Kelly, Q. Liu, C. Lucchesi and C. Manuel, Phys. Rev. Lett 72 (1994) 3461; Phys. Rev. D 5 0 (1994) 4209. D. Bodeker, P h y s . L e t t . B 4 2 6 (1998) 351; N u c l . P h y s . B 5 5 9 (1999) 502. S. Wong, Nuovo Cim. 6 5 A (1970) 689. P. Arnold, D. T . Son and L. G. Yaffe, Phys. Rev. D 5 9 (1999) 105020. J. Blaizot and E. Iancu, Nucl. Phys. B 5 5 7 (1999) 183. L. Landau and E.M. Lifshitz, "Statistical Physics" P a r t I, Oxford (1981).
DO W E U N D E R S T A N D THE S P H A L E R O N RATE?* G U Y D. M O O R E Department
of Physics,
University
of Washington,
Seattle,
Washington
98195
I begin by answering a different question, "Do we know the sphaleron rate?" and conclude that we do. Then I discuss a crude but purely analytic picture which provides an estimate of the sphaleron rate within the context of BSdeker's effective theory. The estimate, which comes surprisingly close to the numerically determined sphaleron rate, gives a physical picture of baryon number violation in the hot phase, and provides a conjecture of the 7VC dependence of the sphaleron rate in SU(7VC) gauge theory.
1
Introduction
Originally I intended to entitle this talk, "Do we Know the Sphaleron Rate?" Unfortunately the talk would then have been much too short: Yes. Speaking seriously, it is appropriate here to remind the audience of what the sphaleron rate is, why we are interested in it, and how we go about calculating it. As I will discuss, we know the correct effective theory for determining the sphaleron rate; it is called Bodeker's effective theory. We also understand what the physics which goes into deriving that effective theory, is. Further, we can compute within the effective theory quite accurately. But exactly what is going on, within the effective theory, is more opaque. In the second half of the talk I will try to present my picture of what the physics is, which will lead to a purely analytic estimate for the sphaleron rate which is closer than you might think to the right answer. Baryon number (number of baryons minus anti-baryons, essentially the net amount of matter) is known to be very nearly conserved, but not exactly conserved, within the standard model and under ordinary conditions, as shown long ago by t'Hooft 1 . The reason is the anomaly, which shows that the baryon number current is coupled to the SU(2) nonabelian field strength;
where F^ is the SU(2) weak field strength and Np = 3 is the number of generations (and I have dropped an irrelevant term involving hypercharge field •TALK PRESENTED AT "STRONG AND ELECTROWEAK MATTER 2000", MARSEILLE, FRANCE, JUNE 14-17, 2000
82
83 strength). Further, the total derivative on the right hand side, integrated over spacetime in a vacuum to vacuum process, need not be zero; the topology of the group SU(2) shows t h a t it can be any integer, and equals the instanton number of the vacuum to vacuum process. Hence baryon number is violated, but in vacuum to vacuum processes its violation only occurs nonperturbatively. Since the weak coupling is actually small, o w ~ 1/30, the instanton suppression factor exp(—47T/Q W ) is enormous, and baryon number violation is of no consequence under normal conditions. However, the very hot conditions relevant in the very early universe did not constitute "normal conditions." At temperatures in excess of the electroweak phase transition (or crossover) temperature T ~ 80GeV, the population functions for infrared electroweak gauge bosons are large, and nonperturbative physics can be unsuppressed 2 , 3 . This means t h a t baryon number violation becomes efficient; in fact it is only polynomially, not exponentially, suppressed by the size of the weak coupling 4 . Since the universe has a small, nonzero, and very interesting (to us!) abundance of baryons, understanding any cosmological process which changes baryon number seems well motivated, especially when it is associated with physics which we all believe must be there (the standard model gauge group). So there has been significant interest in understanding the efficiency of baryon number violation in the early universe. T h e sphaleron rate, the topic of this talk, is defined to be the diffusion constant for the quantity on the right hand side in Eq. (1),
((/^/A^)
2
) l lim lim -5 — '- = - TNB , (2) v-t-oo t-voo Vt 9 with TTVB the diffusion constant for baryon number. This is related t o how fast a baryon number excess will decay, by a fluctuation dissipation relation. There is a free energy cost associated with having a net baryon number; T =
1
FAveraging over possible NB
1IL
,3)
12 VT* • with exp(—F/T) weight gives
<"!> = ^
.
(6)
(4)
which must be sustained by a balance between baryon number diffusion and baryon number decay, resulting in 1
dNB
NB
dt
39 T 4
T3
(5)
84
Hence, the sphaleron rate tells us how fast a baryon number abundance will decay. Understanding its size is the object of the rest of the talk. 2
Bodeker's effective theory
The context where we want to compute the sphaleron rate is the hot standard model above the temperature of "electroweak symmetry restoration," which to good accuracy means 5 that we may work in Yang-Mills theory. It has been known for some time that the infrared behavior of Yang-Mills theory, even at weak coupling aw -C 1, is non-perturbative 3 . The easiest way to understand this is to consider the thermodynamics. It is well known 6 that the full path integral for the thermodynamics of the standard model is approximated up to corrections suppressed by powers of a w by a 3-dimensional path integral, Z = fvAi
V
, (6)
It is also well known that this 3-dimensional theory is super-renormalizable. That means that it has a characteristic momentum scale, in this case <72T. On scales very large compared to this, it is weakly coupled; in fact it grows more weakly coupled as a power of scale (until the effective theory breaks down at p ~ TTT, where it is as weakly coupled as the underlying theory); conversely, as we look at more infrared scales it becomes more strongly coupled, until at the scale g2T its interactions are nonperturbative. Crudely speaking we could say that this occurs because the occupation number of a Bosonic state with momentum p is ~ T/p; and that the loop counting parameter is enhanced by one power of the occupation number. This also suggests a nice way of understanding the physics which occurs at strong coupling; large occupation number is the classical field correspondence limit, and Eq. (6) is the partition function of the classical field theory at finite temperature. This correspondence led Grigoriev and Rubakov to conjecture 7 that the right effective theory to determine the sphaleron rate is the classical field theory, regulated for instance on a lattice. We see that this cannot be true in Fig. 1; the dependence on the lattice spacing is nontrivial and does not go away at suitably small spacing. This physics was predicted, before the data for the figure were taken, by Arnold, Son, and Yaffe9. They argued correctly that "hard" (momentum scale p ~ wT) physics is important to the dynamics of the infrared gauge fields, which are responsible for Chern-Simons number diffusion. Though not originally presented this way, their argument boils
85
axg^T Figure 1. T for pure lattice classical Yang-Mills theory against lattice spacing. It does not show rapid convergence to a nonzero limit at zero spacing. Data from 8 .
down to fairly well known plasma physics. A plasma-abelian or nonabelianis highly conducting. In a conducting medium, magnetic fields evolve slowly, because electric fields interact strongly with the plasma. In particular, the time evolution of a magnetic field is related to the magnitude of an electric field by (the nonabelian) Faraday's law. But an electric field is quickly shorted out, because it generates a current. The nonabelian Ampere's law reads -E+DxB=j.
(7)
The greater the strength of screening in the medium, the greater the importance of the current term, which because it is a conducting medium is of form ~ jEdt, and causes the E term to "undo" past electric fields. More accurately, the current is j a (x,*) = m
-^
v jdy Uab(x,t;x-vy,t-y)
v-Eb(x-vy,t-y),
(8)
with v a unit vector and its integral df2v, taken over the unit sphere. Here Uab is the straight line, adjoint parallel transporter with initial and final points shown, which renders the equation gauge covariant. Together, Eq. (7) and Eq. (8) give classical Yang-Mills theory with added hard thermal loop effects10'11. (One must also add a noise term, which has a form completely determined by equilibrium thermodynamics; the noise correlator is nonlocal
86
and we will not present it, see 1 2 , 1 3 .) Arnold, Son, and Yaffe advocated considering this effective theory, and argued t h a t the sphaleron rate should scale as T oc 1/mj}. Two numerical implementations of this effective theory exist 14 > 15 . Both are quite complicated and I will not describe them here, though I will momentarily discuss their results for T. Bodeker has argued t h a t it is possible to integrate out the scale gT from the effective theory just presented to arrive at a new, "more effective" theory 1 6 . T h e physical content of his calculation (which is fairly complicated 16,17,18,19^ j g (-jja^ s c a t t e r i n g s between the excitations carrying the current j , exchange the nonabelian charges of the current carriers. T h e mean rate for nonabelian charge randomization turns out to be Ncg2T
= 7
4TT
(9)
log ^ + 0(1) 9 T
This is parametrically larger t h a n the scale where nonperturbative physics happens, ~ g2T, if we are willing to expand in \og(m^/g2T). Doing so, we conclude t h a t a current carrier scatters frequently compared to the time it takes to traverse the length scale we are interested in, ~ l/g2T. Therefore, to leading order the current can only depend on the local value of fields, and we may replace Eq. (8) with a local expression, which must be of form j =
(10)
For obvious reasons the constant cr has been christened the nonabelian conductivity [or "color conductivity," if we think about the SU(JVC) theory rather t h a n SU(2)]. It turns out one may determine
Ncg2T
3 = —2-7,
7 = —:
In ^
+ 3.041
(»)
mp 4ir T h e value for the constant 3.041 is from 2 0 . Further, on the scales of interest the term E in Eq. (7) can be dropped relative to the current term, yielding Bodeker's effective theory, j =
( t f ( x , * ) # ( y , t ' ) } = 2
(12)
with the noise Gaussian and white, with the autocorrelator shown. To determine T within this effective theory requires dealing with the nonlinear form of D x B , necessarily including scales where the appearance of the gauge field in D is as important as the derivative term. It is a hard nonlinear problem and the only controllable techniques known are lattice techniques.
87
Sphaleron rate, different effective theories
Bodeker's theory II
• HTL's via particles A D O HTL's via W's (3 latt. spacings) * Pure classical, small latt. spacing
(g 2 T/m 0 )z Figure 2. Sphaleron rate in Bodeker's effective theory, two lattice implementations of HTL effective theory 1 4 . 1 5 I and pure lattice theory interpreted as HTL effective theory (see 2 4 ) .
However as a lattice problem it is particularly amenable to solution. In particular, the effective theory has a good, well defined limit as the UV regulator is taken to infinity18, and it is possible to compute analytically a matching between a lattice implementation and the continuum theory so the first errors are quadratic in lattice spacing 21 , and to define / F^F^ topologically 22>23. 21,5 One finds numerically that
r = K' ( iX- \ air*
+ 3.041 (13) 7 This is also in good agreement with the results of the HTL effective theory, as summarized in Fig. 2. 3
K' = ( l 0 . 0 ± 0 . 2 ) In ^
Model for the nonperturbative behavior
I would argue that we understand pretty well why Bodeker's effective theory is the correct effective description of the the infrared physics behind baryon number violation. We understand why the IR behavior is classical, and why
88
the length scale l/g2T naturally sets the scale for topology change. We understand why IR gauge field evolution is over-damped, in terms of plasma physics. And we understand why, in a nonabelian theory, a nonabelian Ohm's law becomes valid on the scale l/g2T\og(l/g). But the number in front of Eq. (13) was computed via lattice Monte-Carlo means, which is sort of a "black box." It would be nice to have some physical picture of what is going on within the effective theory. Here I provide a crude picture, which leads to a crude analytic estimate of the sphaleron rate in Bodeker's effective theory. The point by point distribution of F^F^ is as ultraviolet sick as that of F2. So why is its diffusion constant finite and infrared dominated? The answer is that F'"''F^v has topological meaning. It is a total derivative and can be written as the spacetime gradient of a current, (g2/327r2)F/"/'F^„ = d^K^. The associated charge is the Chern-Simons number,
J d3xl<0 = NCS = ^Jd3z
Ujk (F?jAak - 9-jabcA1A)Al)
.
(14)
In vacuum the integral of the A3 term is always an integer; so there must be nonvanishing fields for NQS to take on a non-integral value. And in particular, since FijAk has one fewer derivative than F2, the more concentrated the region where Ncs is stored, the greater the energetic cost. Physically, this means that a fluctuation which creates a small amount of Acs leaves an imprint or "strain" behind in the fields, so there is gradient energy present until either the fields relax in a way which undoes the Acs generated, or enough more is added to get up to the next integer. This is what prevents there from being any UV divergences-in fact, any unsuppressed UV contribution at all-in I\ The other piece of physics we know about the symmetric electroweak phase, or pure 3-D Yang-Mills theory, is that there is magnetic screening. Colored degrees of freedom interact with each other exclusively through gradient interactions, so a colored field at x feels the fields at y only through a parallel transporter from y to x. In fact, the field equations mean that the fields at x will generally evolve under the influence of y through some average over paths for parallel transportation. For x and y of small separation l/g2T, a generic pair of paths give completely different parallel transportations. (Equivalently, the mean trace of large Wilson loops goes to zero.) Roughly, there is a length scale / m a g , called the magnetic screening length, beyond which parallel transportation differs by 0(1) on change of path. This means that the influence of fields at y on fields at x add in-
89 coherently over paths and will approximately cancel. A field cannot "see" colored objects more tiicin /mag away. This arises because of large nonabelian fields in between the two points, which are responsible for making the parallel transportations differ. The physical picture I argue for is that magnetic screening renders the "gradient energy" argument for keeping Ncs from changing, ineffective for field fluctuations on scales J> Zmag. Hence, Ncs will diffuse due to F^F^ from fields at the scale /. These fields will evolve diffusively; but fields on less IR scales will not contribute to the diffusion of iV"cs • Within this picture, we can make a crude calculation of V, as follows. Consider some large volume V as a collection of boxes / m a g on a side. Within each box, the most IR gauge field degrees of freedom diffuse, and all higher wave number modes do not contribute; and the contribution of different boxes are independent. Writing F^F^ = AE?B?, Eq. (2) becomes
r=.r((^^oJ), boxes \ \
/
/
(I5)
where the subscript on the magnetic field means that only the most infrared component is kept. The sum over directions gives the two independent transverse polarizations, giving M^vt ^ [dtidhdx1dx2{Ea(xut1)Eb(x2,t2)B?R{x1,t1)Bbm(x2,t2)). boxes
(16) We determine the E field correlator from Eq. (12). Our argument about scales says that, if we consider only the most infrared component of the magnetic field, then we can neglect the gradient term, D x B, in evaluating the E correlators. In this case E and B are uncorrelated, and the E correlators come only from the noise, IT (Ea(x1,tl)Eb(x2,t2)) = —Sab6(Xl - x2)S(h - t2). (17) (For higher frequency excitations the D x B term is what will ensure no contribution.) This performs one space and one time integral: Jdx1dx2dt1dt2
(Ea{xi,ti)
Eb{x2,t2)
B?K(xltti)
2T f = — 6abdxldx2dtldt26(x1-x2)6(t1-t2) = — Sabj
dtijdx
(BfR(x,tl)Bbm(x,t1))
Bbm{x2,t2)) {BfR(xuti)BiR(x2,t2))
.
(18)
90
This integral can be estimated by equipartition, / dh
d3x
ab [Bfofrh < ( * , .)> = T6 Jo[ dh
=TtS ab
(19)
Probably there is more power in the infrared magnetic fields than equipartition would estimate; but this is only one point at which our analysis is crude. The group indices have reduced to Sab6ab = JVC2—1. The volume of a box ls 'mag , so in a total volume V there are VV'mag boxes. Putting everything together, we get =
4(N?-l)g*T2
(20)
which, on substituting Eq. (11) and re-arranging, gives „2T2
*lT4 l o g — + 3.041
(21) 7 It remains to estimate / m a g , which is a thermodynamic question and can be answered within the 3-D Euclidean theory, Eq. (6). The only natural length scale of hot Yang-Mills theory at weak coupling is / m a g ~ l/g2T, and at large Nc the 7VC dependence must be / m a g ~ l/Ncg2T. The only question is what the coefficient is. I estimate it by trying to find on what length scale the perturbative expansion for 3-D Yang-Mills theory (describing the thermodynamics of the thermal theory) has completely broken down. One estimate is that / m a g \/p for the momentum p with | I I T ( P ) | p , that is, where the one loop transverse self-energy computed with tree propagators is as large as the tree inverse propagator. In Landau gauge (strict Coulomb gauge from the 3+1 dimensional perspective) this is 2
(Ncg n
mag;
m,
II(p,one loop, tree propagators) = — *! — (J>ijP2 — PiPj) >
(22)
so / m a g ~ 64/(llNcg2T). This estimate is gauge dependent; in Feynman gauge the 11 becomes 14. However, since unequal separation correlators are maximal in Landau gauge, it seems the appropriate gauge for estimating where those correlators break down. Alternately, we can take / m a g as the reciprocal of the "magnetic mass" found self-consistently by solving a gap equation 25 . Without endorsing the efficacy of gap resummed perturbation theory to make useful predictions, one can nevertheless say that the mass found gives a characteristic scale where higher order terms in the perturbative expansion are of order the leading ones.
91 Volume d e p e n d e n c e of T
1
i
1 I
i
'
i
i
i
i
i
j
i
I
1
Jw
J II -J
I
II -J
1 i
I
0.5 X z •
-
1
1
i
10
15
Lxg2T Figure 3. Volume dependence of T (pure lattice theory, g2aT = 1/2) illustrates that T turns
A two loop gap equation calculation 26 gives / m a g l / m m a g = 1/0.17 Ncg2T a which agrees with the self-energy estimate. One check on this estimate of / m a g is to look at lattice data in finite volume, and see how large a lattice has to be before T "turns on." We expect that it should have to be about 2/ m a g across, because we use periodic boundary conditions on the lattice. Fig. 3 indicates that our estimate of/ mag is reasonable. In particular, the inverse glueball mass < l/g2T is not the appropriate scale. Using the estimate for / m a g , we get
T ~ .247VC3(7VC2-1)
Ncg2T*
5 rpA
log mo
3.041
(23)
Plugging in Nc = 2 gives T = 11.5{g2T2/m2D)alT4 log(...). The 11.5 should be compared with the actual number, 10.0, presented earlier. The quality of the agreement is probably fortuitous. "The computation 2 6 is in SU(2) but since all graphs at one and two loops are planar, the 7VC dependence must be as shown.
92 4
Conclusion
After reviewing the current status of what the sphaleron rate is, and what the right effective theory for its determination is (Bodeker's effective theory), I have proposed a physical picture of what is going on in the strongly coupled IR physics which determines the rate. My picture is t h a t , on scales longer than / m a g , magnetic screening prevents "any record of being kept" of what past changes have occurred to -/Vcs; therefore, very IR gauge fields evolve diffusively. I have presented a crude estimate of this diffusive evolution and of /mag, and find t h a t the resulting sphaleron rate T is surprisingly close to the value determined in lattice simulations. T h e model here should not be taken as an accurate quantitative predictor of T; rather it should be viewed as a parametric estimate where an effort has been m a d e to include factors of 2 or TT where possible. It also gives an interesting physical picture of /Vcs diffusion in Yang-Mills theory; rather than occasional, integer changes, ./Vcs diffuses from the incoherent accumulation of m a n y contributions individually much smaller t h a n an integer. A more robust prediction of this analysis is for the dependence of T on Nc. Of course the scaling behavior / ~ l/Ncg2T has 0(l/./V c 2 ) corrections, so the Nc dependence in Eq. (23) cannot be relied on absolutely at small Nc. However, it would be interesting to numerically investigate T within Bodeker's effective theory for a few larger Nc and see how well the prediction holds. In particular the case of SU(3) is physically interesting 2 7 . In conclusion: Do we understand the sphaleron rate? I think, perhaps, t h a t we do. Acknowledgment s I thank Peter Arnold, Dietrich Bodeker, Kari Rummukainen, D a m Son, and Larry Yaffe. I particularly thank Larry Yaffe, who convinced me finally to present these ideas. References 1. G. t'Hooft, Phys. Rev. Lett. 37,8 (1976). 2. A. D. Linde, Phys. Lett. B 9 6 , 289 (1980). 3. D. J. Gross, R. D. Pisarski and L. G. Yaffe, Rev. Mod. Phys. 5 3 , 43 (1981). 4. P. Arnold and L. McLerran, Phys. Rev. D 36, 581 (1987). 5. G. D. Moore, hep-ph/0001216.
93
6. K. Farakos, K. Kajantie, K. Rummukainen and M. Shaposhnikov, Nucl. Phys. B425, 67 (1994) [hep-ph/9404201]; Nucl. Phys. B442, 317 (1995) [hep-lat/9412091]. 7. D. Grigoriev and V. Rubakov, Nucl. Phys. B 299, 248 (1988). 8. G. D. Moore and K. Rummukainen, Phys. Rev. D61, 105008 (2000) [hep-ph/9906259]. 9. P. Arnold, D. Son and L. G. Yaffe, Phys. Rev. D55, 6264 (1997) [hepph/9609481]. 10. E. Braaten and R. Pisarski, Nucl. Phys. B337, 569 (1990); J. Frenkel and J. Taylor, Nucl. Phys. B334, 199 (1990); J. Taylor and S. Wong, Nucl. Phys. B346, 115 (1990). 11. J.P. Blaizot and E. Iancu, Phys. Rev. Lett. 70, 3376 (1993) [hepph/9301236]; V.P. Nair, Phys. Rev. D48, 3432 (1993) [hep-ph/9307326]; J. Blaizot and E. Iancu, Nucl. Phys. B421, 565 (1994) [hep-ph/9401211]; V.P. Nair, Phys. Rev. D50, 4201 (1994) [hep-th/9403146]. 12. P. Huet and D.T. Son, Phys. Lett. B393, 94 (1997) hep-ph/9610259]. 13. D.T. Son, UW/PT-97-19 [hep-ph/9707351], 14. G. D. Moore, C. Hu and B. Muller, Phys. Rev. D58, 045001 (1998) [hep-ph/9710436]. 15. D. Bodeker, G. D. Moore and K. Rummukainen, Phys. Rev. D61, 056003 (2000) [hep-ph/9907545]. 16. D. Bodeker, Phys. Lett. B426, 351 (1998) [hep-ph/9801430]. 17. . Bodeker, Nucl. Phys. B566 (2000) 402 [hep-ph/9903478]; Nucl. Phys. B559, 502 (1999) [hep-ph/9905239]. 18. P. Arnold, D. T. Son and L. G. Yaffe, Phys. Rev. D59, 105020 (1999) [hep-ph/9810216]; Phys. Rev. D60, 025007 (1999) [hep-ph/9901304]. 19. D. F. Litim and C. Manuel, Phys. Rev. Lett. 82, 4981 (1999) [hepph/9902430]; Nucl. Phys. B562, 237 (1999) [hep-ph/9906210]; Phys. Rev. D61 (2000) 125004 [hep-ph/9910348]. 20. P. Arnold and L. G. Yaffe, hep-ph/9912305; hep-ph/9912306. 21. G. D. Moore, Nucl. Phys. B568, 367 (2000) [hep-ph/9810313]. 22. G. D. Moore and N. Turok, Phys. Rev. D56, 6533 (1997) [hepph/9703266]. 23. G. D. Moore, Phys. Rev. D59, 014503 (1999) [hep-ph/9805264]. 24. P. Arnold, Phys. Rev. D55, 7781 (1997) [hep-ph/9701393]. 25. W. Buchmiiller and O. Philipsen, Nuc. Phys. B 443 (1995), 47; G. Alexanian and V. P. Nair, Phys. Lett. B 352 (1995), 435; R. Jackiw and S.Y. Pi, Phys. Lett. B 368 (1996), 131; J. M. Cornwall, Phys. Rev. D 57 (1998), 3694. 26. F. Eberlein, Phys. Lett. B 439 (1998), 130.
94 27. L. McLerran, E. Mottola, and M. Shaposhnikov, Phys. Rev. D 43 (1991) 2027; G. Giudice and M. Shaposhnikov, Phys. Lett. B 326 (1994) 118.
DEBYE SCREENING IN THE QCD PLASMA O. P H I L I P S E N CERN
Theory
Division,
1211 Geneva
23,
Switzerland"
Various definitions for the QCD Debye mass and its evaluation are reviewed in a non-pertura itive framework for the study of screening of general static sources. While it is possible to perturbatively integrate over scales ~ T and thus construct a 3d effective theory, the softer scales ~ gT and ~ g2T are strongly coupled for temperatures ^ 10 7 GeV and require lattice simulations. Within the effective theory, a lattice treatment of screening at finite quark densities /i ^ 4 / T is also possible.
1
Introduction
One goal of heavy ion collision experiments is to probe the deconfined phase of QCD, in which matter is expected to exist in a state of quark-gluon plasma. At present, we are still far from a satisfactory understanding of its properties, and hence of unambiguous signals for its detection. Qualitative expectations are based on asymptotic freedom, i.e. the coupling weakening with increasing temperature. However, for any reasonable temperatures below 10 11 GeV, perturbative treatments are badly convergent due to infrared-sensitive contributions. On the other hand, the only non-perturbative first principles approach, four-dimensional (4d) lattice simulations, is severely restricted in the presence of light fermions, and as of yet fails completely at finite baryon density. Considerable progress has been made over the last years in studying the screening of static sources in an equilibrated plasma by simulating dimensionally reduced QCD, as well as 4d pure gauge theory. In this contribution these developments are reviewed with special emphasis on Debye screening, which is believed to play a central role for deconfinement. While at present it is not clear whether screening of static charges can be directly probed experimentally, it is a well-defined physical plasma property, providing the dynamical length scales over which interactions are effective. One difficulty with Debye screening in QCD is properly defining it. After briefly recalling the QED analogue and pointing out the differences in QCD, a non-perturbative framework to study screening of a general static source is given. Next, an effective theory description for hot QCD is reviewed, permitting a convenient non-perturbative study and interpretation of screening 'Address since October 2000: Center for Theoretical Physics, Massachusetts of Technology, Cambridge, MA 02139, USA 95
Institute
96
lenghts, before returning to the question of a gauge-invariant definition and non-perturbative evaluation of Debye screening. Finally, Debye screening in the presence of a finite baryon density is discussed. 1.1
Debye screening in QED
Consider first a QED plasma in equilibrium, into which an external static charge is introduced. The modified Hamiltonian is then H' = H + Hext = I ((E + E e x t ) 2 + B 2 ) .
(1)
In linear response theory the perturbation of the electric field is * S(Ei(x))=
limi /
dt'TrMHextfx'.tO.Eifx.t)])
«/ to
= t_yo lim - i / dt' / d 3 x ' E f t ( x ' ) ( [ E i ( x , t ) , E j ( x ' , t ' ) ] ) . ° Jt0 J
(2)
With Ei(x) = — V,-V(r), the potential of the static source is determined by the correlation of electric fields, or equivalently by the Fourier transform of the AQ propagator,
v(r) =
d3k elkr c ne~mDr Q Qj^u2,u.. -7=rJ 3 F tn + ^=Q n 0 0 (0,k) ~ Anr
(3)
Thus, the electric field of the source is screened by the charges in the plasma, and the Debye mass, or inverse screening length, is defined by the pole of the photon propagator, n00(A:oO,k2 = -m2D) = m?D.
(4)
The leading order one-loop diagram gives m°D = e T / \ / 3 + G(e2T). On the other hand, there is no magnetic screening to all orders of perturbation theory, i.e. Uu(k0 = 0 , k - > 0 ) = 0. 1.2
Non-abelian Debye screening
Following the same steps in an SU(N) theory with Nj fermions and evaluating the pole of the one-loop Aa propagator, one finds the leading order result 1/2
n0~^—, =V (T3 +' ^) Airr ' < "* ~ 6 D
P.
(5)
97 However, at next-to-leading order the problem becomes non-perturbative. T h e general form of the series in g can be shown to be 2 mD^m0D
+ ^ g
2
T \ n ^ + cNg2T gl 1
47T
+ O(g3T),
(6)
which is non-analytic in the coupling constant. While the coefficient of the logarithm is fixed perturbatively, CN is entirely non-perturbative. T h e reason is t h a t , starting from this order in g, the non-abelian AQ couples to the soft magnetic gluons A{ ~ g2T, and hence becomes sensitive to the non-abelian infrared divergencies in the magnetic sector for which there is no perturbative cure 3 : Hu(ko — 0, k —y 0) ~ g2T ^ 0, with contributions from all loop orders two and larger. This raises the conceptual problem whether a perturbative definition of Debye screening in Q C D is at all sensible. Moreover, neither rioo nor the colour-electric field E are gauge-invariant physical concepts in a non-abelian theory. It can be shown t h a t the pole of the Ao propagator is gauge-invariant order by order in a (resummed) perturbation series 4 . However, this does not guarantee the existence of a pole in the full propagator. Even if it exists, its non-perturbative relation to physical quantities remains unclear in a situation where the potential of a single static charge is not defined. There are then two ways to deal with this problem non-perturbatively. One is to assume a pole in the full propagator and to determine its value from the exponential fall-off of the gauge-fixed propagator in space. Results of this approach are presented in another contribution to this conference 5 . T h e second option, which will be discussed here, is to seek a manifestly gaugeinvariant definition of Debye screening. 1.3
Non-perturbative
description
of
screening
Let us first recall the general definitions needed to non-perturbatively describe screening of any gauge-invariant source. Consider gauge-invariant, local operators A(x). Static equilibrium physics is described by spatial correlation functions of euclidean time averages C(|x|) = ( A ( x ) A ( 0 ) ) c ~ e - M l x l ,
A ( X ) = T /
drA(x,-ir) .
(7)
Jo
These fall off exponentially with distance. T h e "screening masses" M have a precise non-perturbative definition: they are the eigenvalues of the spacewise tranfer matrix in the corresponding lattice field theory. Physically, they correspond to the inverse length scale over which the equilibrated plasma is
98
sensitive to the insertion of a static source carrying the quantum numbers of A. Beyond 1/M, the source is screened and the plasma appears undisturbed. With these definitions, all screening lengths corresponding to gauge-invariant sources can be computed on the lattice in principle. 2
Effective theory description
If we are interested in length scales larger than the inverse temperature, |x| ~ 1/gT 3> 1/T, the situation simplifies considerably. In this case the integration range for euclidean time averaging in Eq. (7) becomes very small, and the problem effectively three-dimensional (3d). The calculation of the correlation function C(|x|) can be factorized: the time averaging may be performed perturbatively by expanding in powers of the scale ratio gT/T ~ g, which amounts to integrating out all modes with momenta ~ T and larger (i.e. the non-zero Matsubara modes, in particular the fermions). This procedure is known as dimensional reduction 6 . The correlator C(|x|) of 3d fields is then to be evaluated with a 3d purely bosonic effective action, describing the non-perturbative physics of the modes ~ gT and softer, which can be done on the lattice. The screening masses M now are the eigenvalues of the 3d tranfer matrix. The 3d purely bosonic simulations are much easier and thus more accurate than simulating directly in 4d. However, the perturbative integration over hard modes and neglecting higher dimension operators in the effective action introduces a relative error, which at two-loop level is 7
*-§ ~ Otf).
(8)
In the treatment of the electroweak phase transition, this error is less than 5% 8 , but for hot QCD the coupling and thus the error is larger. An estimate of its size will be given later, when results from the full and the effective theory are compared. The effective theory emerging from hot QCD by dimensional reduction is the SU(3) adjoint Higgs model with the action S = jd3x
I ^ F y F y ) + Tr(D.Ao) 2 + (m° )2Tr(AJj) + A 3 (Tr(A 2 ) 2 } . (9)
Apart from the SU(3) gauge symmetry, the action respects SO(2) planar rotations, two-dimensional parity P, charge conjugation C and Ao-refiections R. Its parameters are via dimensional reduction functions of the four-dimensional gauge coupling g2, the number of colours N and flavours Nf, the fermion masses and the temperature T. In all of the following fermion masses are
99 NpO, T=2TC, L=40, P=28
N,=0, T-10"T C , L=40, p=28
15 j 10
• t 5
• 5
f
? i
.
{
,
O
J
D
0.
t 1-°
A
•
i
»
* •«
I *
0.5 I
I
o
« —r;
< •M
I
a
0
1.5 h
r;— ; 0.0 !—r;
r . 0 . 0 . 0 _
:
1. 1.
2 ,
'
^—r
0 . 0"," 0".
0.
'
' r*:—'
1 4 1.
2\
Figure 1. Spectrum of screening masses in various quantum number channels at low and high temperatures. Filled symbols denote 3d glueball states.
assumed to be zero, but in principle any other values may be considered as well. At leading order in the reduction step one then has gl=g2(fi)T, \3^^(Q
+
4
N-Nf)g
(fi)T.
(10)
T h e reduction step has been performed to two-loop order 9 at which p a r a m eters have relative accuracy 0(g4). Specifying T and a renormalization scale ft completely fixes the effective theory. If we are interested in the longest scales of order ~ l/g2T, one may be inclined to integrate out the fields AQ ~ gT as well, leaving a 3d pure gauge theory. In order to decide which is the correct effective theory in practice, simulation results for screening lengths will now be compared between the reduced and the full theory. Results from simulations 1 0 of the gauge-invariant screening spectrum with the effective theory Eq. (9) are displayed in Fig. 1. Screening masses are classified according to the symmetires of the 3d Hamiltonian by the q u a n t u m numbers J^c. T h e open symbols show states dominated by scalar operators such as T r ( A o ) , T r ( A o F i 2 ) etc., whereas full symbols show states receiving only gluonic contributions Tr(Ff 2 ) etc. It is a remarkable finding of detailed mixing analyses in several models 1 1 . 1 4 . 1 0 ) t h a t the latter are quantitatively consistent with the 3d glueball states 1 2 and completely insensitive to the presence of the A$ scalar field. Because of this pronounced non-mixing, we can state a first i m p o r t a n t result: For any reasonable t e m p e r a t u r e s the largest correlation length of gauge-invariant, local operators belongs to the A0 degrees of freedom and not to the Aj, in contrast to the naive parametric picture. This demonstrates t h a t the physics from the scale gT down to g2T is completely
100
SU(3), T = 2TC M/T 0++ 01+
o; o: 2* l;
3d 2.71(6) 4.6(2)
4d 2.60(4) 6.3(2),
o* 0; 2+ I ;
Figure 2. Comparison of screening masses in hot SU(2) (left) and SU(3) (right) pure gauge theory as determined in 4d (empty symbols) 1 3 and 3d (full symbols) 14>10 effective theory simulations.
non-perturbative, and hence AQ may not be integrated out perturbatively. Only for temperatures T> 10 7 T C becomes the coupling small enough t h a t the parametrically expected ordering of screening masses is realized. Next, we are interested in the accuracy of the reduced theory. Fig. 2 compares the results for hot SU(2) gauge theory as obtained in the full lattice theory 1 3 with those from the effective theory 1 4 . Note t h a t the effective theory is only valid up to its cut-off M/T ~ 2n and above this level disagreement is to be expected. T h e apparent excellent agreement for the two lowest lying states should be taken with care given some systematic uncertainties. In 4d simulations, the projection properties of operators and the scaling behaviour are more difficult to control t h a n in 3d. In the effective theory, there is an ambiguity in the choice of renormalization scale. T h e uncertainty in the comparison may thus be as large as 20%. For the case of SU(3), one finds again quantitative agreement in the largest correlation length but about 20% deviation in the next shorter one. One advantage of the effective theory approach is its easy inclusion of fermions, which are treated analytically and just amount to changing the parameters Eq. (10) of the action to be simulated. However, the screening masses M/T are found to increase with Nf 1 0 , and at Nj = 4 the lowest of t h e m is already of the order ~ 1/2TTT and hence not expected to be quantitatively accurate. Moreover, close to Tc the fermionic modes in the 4d theory feel the chiral phase transition, such t h a t for T< 2 — 3TC the correlation length
101
obtained from pion operators becomes the longest o n e 1 5 . In this situation fermions may not be integrated out and the purely bosonic effective theory is invalid. We may thus conclude t h a t dimensional reduction gives a reasonable description of the largest correlation lengths of hot Q C D for t e m p e r a t u r e s > 2 — 3T C , with an error < 20% t h a t decreases with t e m p e r a t u r e . 3
T h e Polyakov line and the heavy quark potential
A gauge-invariant, non-local operator t h a t has been suggested in the literature to describe Debye screening is the Polyakov line 1 fP L(x) = - T r ^ e x p - i g / d r A 0 ( x , r ) . (11) A Jo Its spatial correlator is related to the free energy of a quark anti-quark pair in the plasma, and thus to the static potential at finite t e m p e r a t u r e 16
T h e idea is t h a t by considering a source together with an anti-source gives a manifestly gauge-invariant operator related to heavy quark systems. In leading order perturbation theory one has L = 1 — t / 2 / 2 T r ( / d r A 0 ) 2 + . . . , and hence the correlator at this order is given by the exchange of two electric gluons leading to (Ar2 _ l)a4
<^(0))c=(8„aj>'
e -2m° D r
(47rr)2,
(13)
with the leading order Debye mass maD. However, this state of affairs is spoilt by higher loop diagrams, as several authors have pointed out 17 > 18 . Fig. 3 left shows a diagram of order <78, where now AQ can couple to two magnetic gauge fields Ai, and hence the exponential fall-off of this diagram is governed purely by magnetic gauge fields. Indeed, through a fermion loop a similar coupling is possible even in Q E D , cf. Fig. 3 right. There, magnetic gauge fields are strictly massless, and the correlator falls off algebraically rather t h a n exponentially. It thus fails to produce the Debye mass for electric fields even in Q E D . W i t h our previous discussion of screening masses at hand, it is not difficult to understand how the Polyakov line correlator should fall off away from Tc. L contains a sum over all Jpc sectors in the fundamental representation. Furthermore, because of gauge-invariance it couples only to gauge-invariant intermediate states. Its correlator should therefore asymptotically fall off with the lightest gauge-invariant screening mass of the spectrum. Indeed, a recent
102
Figure 3. Higher loop diagrams contributing to the Polyakov line correlator in QCD (left) and QED (right).
4d simulation of the SU(3) Polyakov line correlator 2 0 finds it exponential decay to be governed by M/T « 2.5(3), which is fully compatible with the lightest 0 | + mass given in the table in Fig. 2. The same observation is m a d e to rather high precision in a hot (2+l)-dimensional gauge theory 2 1 . 4
A g a u g e - i n v a r i a n t d e f i n i t i o n for mp
A few years ago it was suggested to use a symmetry to distinguish between the electric and the magnetic sectors of the theory 1 8 , namely euclidean time reflection T : r —y —r. This operation changes the sign of the electric gauge fields, A§ —> —Ao, but not t h a t of the magnetic ones. T h e non-perturabtive Debye screening length 1/mo may then be defined to be the largest correlation length measured from a correlator ( J 4(x)B(0)), where A, B are gauge-invariant operators which are local in 3-space and odd under T• Examples of four-dimensional operators with these properties are Tr(ImL),Tr(ImLF12),Tr(F03F22),Tr(F03F12)etc. In the 3d effective theory, where " t i m e " has been reduced away, the remnant of euclidean time reflection is the scalar reflection s y m m e t r y R : A$ —• —AQ. T h e Debye mass then corresponds to the lightest eigenstate with quant u m number R = —. It is now easy to go back to the results for the spectrum in Fig. 1 and identify the lowest mass in the 0 I + channel as the Debye mass according to this definition 11 . The corresponding operator is Tr(AoFjj), which may be interpreted as an electric gauge field dressed by magnetic gluons to make it gauge-invariant. Despite its coupling to Ai, .R-symmetry prohibits its correlation to be governed by the 3d pure gauge sector. This definition certainly refers to a physical quantity. However, as it couples to colour singlet sources, its relation to screening of colour flux and to deconfinement of a quarkonium system is not obvious. a Alternatively, it was proposed to measure matrix elements between R-odd operators and a Zpj domain wall, introduced by a twist in the effective action .
103 Table 1. The different contributions to the Debye mass, Eq. (6). (1+2) refers to the first two terms in units of g2T.
T = 2TC T= 10 U T C
4-1
Perturbative
mD/g2T 1.82 (3) 3.83 (9)
(1 + 2) 0.514 2.165
and non-perturbative
C3
1.65(6) 1.65(6)
contributions
0{g*T)/{g2T) -0.35(8) 0.015(90)
to mo
We may now ask to what extent this Debye mass can be computed in perturbation theory. First, note t h a t the perturbative expansion follows the same p a t t e r n as in Eq. (6). At tree level, the correlator is given by exchange of one electric and two magnetic gluons. Since the latter are massless at tree level, the leading order fall-off is yet again m°D. However, at higher orders the contributions are different from those to the Ao propagator. There is a recipe to compute the coefficient c;v non-perturbatively 1 8 : if t e m p e r a t u r e is sent to infinity, the AQ becomes infinitely heavy and decouples, so it may be integrated out. In this case, AQ turns into a static external source, and the only dynamical fields left are the A\ of a 3d pure gauge theory. We thus have (Tr(A0Fij)(x)Tr(A0Flm)(0)) — • i _ ^ < F * ( x ) W a b ( x , 0 ) F ! > m ( 0 ) ) ,
(14)
where Wab{*,0) is an adjoint representation Wilson line. As a result, our correlator factorizes into the free Ao propagator and a correlator of the magnetic field strength, connected by an adjoint Wilson line representing the static Ao. T h e field strength correlator falls off exponentially ~ exp—(A + c/v)|x|, where A contains a logarithmic divergence which gets absorbed by the renormalisation of the AQ self-energy l 8 . Measuring cN in a 3d pure gauge theory 1 9 and comparing with the measurements of the full 7ii£) we can now summarise the various contributions to the SU(3) Debye mass in Table 1. We observe t h a t at reasonable temperatures the next-to-leading order coefficient c 3 is larger t h a n the leading contribution, and thus the Debye mass is entirely non-perturbative. Again the reason is its coupling to the non-perturbative magnetic sector ~ g2T. Note also t h a t the G(g3T) contributions are small compared to the g2T contributions. Together with the previous observations about scales involved, one m a y then conclude t h a t the physics of screening for all temperatures of pratical interest is dominated by the scale ~ g2T. Only at asymtotically high temperatures T > 10 7 T C is the perturbative picture restored.
104
5
D e b y e s c r e e n i n g at f i n i t e b a r y o n d e n s i t y
In heavy ion collisions the initial state has non-vanishing baryon number, and so does any subsequent plasma state. We would therefore like to know if and how a chemical potential for quarks affects the physics of screening. Unfortunately, finite baryon density cannot be addressed by s t a n d a r d lattice Q C D because of the so-called "sign-problem": when a chemical potential term is added to the theory, the fermion determinant becomes complex prohibiting Monte Carlo importance sampling, which requires a strictly positive measure. To date, no working cure has been found for this problem 2 3 . Recently it was demonstrated t h a t in dimensionally reduced finite density Q C D the sign problem is in fact numerically tractable 2 4 . Inclusion of a chemical potential term for quarks leads to one extra term in the action Eq. (9) and changes the tree level Debye mass, /ji_\ 2 _3Nf W T / 2N N f
(15)
This action is complex and cannot be simulated with standard m e t h o d s . Instead, a re weighting procedure has to be performed, where the complex term of the action is absorbed into the observable, so t h a t
{U)
cos(5 M )) 0 '
l
'
and the averaging is done with ^ = 0. T h e sign problem, i.e. cancelling contributions to the expectation value, occur whenever 5 M 3> 1. Fortunately, the width of the distribution of this quantity, growing as ~ (n/T)Vll2, is narrow enough to permit large enough volumes for simulated masses to reach their infinite volume levels, as long as fi< AT 1 0 . There is one i m p o r t a n t change of the symmetries of the theory, which is relevant for Debye screening 1 8 : the chemical potential term violates R and C, and thus only P is left as a good symmetry to classify the screening states. Since the definition of mo was based on the use of R, it seems no longer applicable in the finite density situation. In the 3d effective theory, the corresponding state can mix with any lighter R — + states and decay. However, for /i = 0, we found the Debye mass to be the lowest state in the 0 I + channel. This is also the lowest state with P = —. As Fig. 4 shows, this remains to be the case as /J./T is switched on, and by continuity one m a y now identify the lowest 0~ mass to correspond to the Debye mass. Finally, it has been demonstrated, t h a t screening masses for /i < T should be accessible to 4d simulations with imaginary /i and analytic continuation 2 4 .
105
firea
H real. J =0
,r=o*
10
io T a
|
*
J
0
0
i
2 { S
tr
2= 5 Q
1
0
I
3
°°V AOV
/iOV 0
1
2
3
Init-
4
0
1
2
3
4
W
Figure 4. The behaviour of the lowest screening masses when a chemical potential is switched on. The triangles in the right panel give the Debye mass according to the gauge invariant definition in the last section.
6
Conclusions
The analogy of Debye screening in QED and QCD is rather limited, because in QCD it is not possible to define the electric field induced by an isolated charge: neither of these are gauge-invariant physical concepts. The problem then is to specify what we mean by Debye screening in QCD. Depending on the definition, one gets different answers and different interpretations of the results. Defining the Debye mass through the pole of the full A$ propagator has the disadvantage that its existence is not guaranteed, and its non-perturbative connection to physical quantities is not clear. Employing the Polyakov line correlator describing a heavy quark anti-quark pair does not probe Debye screening: it mixes electric and magnetic sectors, failing to fall off with mu even in QED. A gauge-invariant definition is possible through correlations of operators odd under euclidean time reflection, which reflects AQ but not Aj. In general, the screening of static sources in equilibrium is a well-defined problem that has been studied non-perturbatively by lattice QCD and with effective field theory methods. A detailed picture of the static length scales for non-abelian plasma physics has emerged. An important lesson for constructing effective theories is that, for all temperatures T < 107 GeV, the scales ~ gT and ~ g2T are not separable non-perturbatively. All static screening physics seems to be dominated by the dynamics on soft scales ~ g2T. Finally, dimensionally reduced QCD gives a realistic description of static phenomena down to temperatures of a few Tc, and is able to non-
106
perturbatively accomodate chemical potentials for quarks y, & AT. It can therefore address the physics of screening in the parameter range relevant for heavy ion collisions. References 1. J. I. Kapusta, Finite-Temperature Field Theory, Cambridge University Press, 1989. 2. A. K. Rebhan, Phys. Rev. D48, 3967 (1993); E. Braaten and A. Nieto, Phys. Rev. Lett. 73, 2402 (1994). 3. A. D. Linde, Phys. Lett. B96 (1980) 289; D. J. Gross, R. D. Pisarski and L. G. Yaffe, Rev. Mod. Phys. 53 (1981) 43. 4. R. Kobes, G. Kunstatter and A. Rebhan, Nucl. Phys. B355 (1991) 1. 5. A. Cucchieri, F. Karsch and P. Petreczky, these proceedings. 6. P. Ginsparg, Nucl. Phys. B170 (1980) 388; T. Appelquist and R. D. Pisarski, Phys. Rev. D23 (1981) 2305. 7. K. Kajantie et al., Nucl. Phys. B458 (1996) 90. 8. M. Laine, JHEP 9906, 020 (1999). 9. K. Kajantie et al., Nucl. Phys. B503 (1997) 357. 10. A. Hart, M. Laine and O. Philipsen, Nucl. Phys. B586 (2000) 443. 11. O. Philipsen M. Teper and H. Wittig, Nucl. Phys. B 469 (1996) 445; Nucl. Phys. B528 (1998) 379. 12. M. J. Teper, Phys. Rev. D59 (1999) 014512. 13. S. Datta and S. Gupta, Phys. Lett. B471, 382 (2000); Nucl. Phys. B534, 392 (1998). 14. A. Hart and 0 . Philipsen, Nucl. Phys. B572, 243 (2000). 15. R. V. Gavai and S. Gupta, Phys. Rev. Lett. 85, 2068 (2000). 16. L. D. McLerran and B. Svetitsky, Phys. Rev. D24 (1981) 450. 17. S. Nadkarni, Phys. Rev. D33, 3738 (1986); E. Braaten and A. Nieto, Phys. Rev. Lett. 74, 3530 (1995). 18. P. Arnold and L. G. YafFe, Phys. Rev. D52 (1995) 7208. 19. M. Laine and O. Philipsen, Nucl. Phys. B523, 267 (1998); Phys. Lett. B459, 259 (1999). 20. O. Kaczmarek et al., Phys. Rev. D62, 034021 (2000). 21. P. Bialas et al., Nucl. Phys. B581, 477 (2000). 22. S. BronofF and C. P. Korthals Altes, Nucl. Phys. Proc. Suppl. 73, 453 (1999). 23. M. Alford, Nucl. Phys. Proc. Suppl. 73, 161 (1999); F. Karsch, Nucl. Phys. Proc. Suppl. 83, 14 (2000). 24. A. Hart, M. Laine and O. Philipsen, hep-lat/0010008.
W H Y THE Q U A R K - G L U O N PLASMA ISN'T A P L A S M A
R O B E R T D. P I S A R S K I Department of Physics, Brookhaven National Laboratory Upton, NY 11973 USA e-mail: [email protected]
An alternate picture of the deconfined phase of gauge theories is described. Instead of a plasma, the theory is viewed as a condensate of Polyakov lines. The pressure is determined by an elementary mean field theory.
A major reason for studying the collisions of heavy nuclei at very high energies is the hope that we might observe a new state of matter, the "QuarkGluon Plasma". In this Proceeding I outline a different picture for the high temperature phase of SU(N) gauge theories: it isn't a plasma — which in this case means a weakly interacting gas of essentially massive quasi-particles — but a condensate of Z(N) spins. That the high temperature phase of a SU(N) gauge theory is like the low temperature phase of a Z(N) spin model is an old and familiar story. The role of a global Z(N) symmetry, and its relationship to confinement, was first introduced by 't Hooft. 2 That Z(N) spins form a rigorous order parameter for the deconfining phase transition in pure glue theories was shown by Polyakov and by Susskind. 3 Svetitsky and Yaffe 4 demonstrated that if the deconfining phase transition is of second order, that the Z(N) spins determine the universality class of the theory. Indeed, the Z(N) spins are the standard order parameter used on the Lattice to pinpoint the deconfining phase transition. What is novel in the following discussion is a mean field theory which relates the pressure to the behavior of the Z(N) spins. I first review the usual quasi-particle picture of the high temperature phase, and then discuss how I was l