Strategic Marketing Planning
This page intentionally left blank
Strategic Marketing Planning Second edition Colin G...
963 downloads
6417 Views
4MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Strategic Marketing Planning
This page intentionally left blank
Strategic Marketing Planning Second edition Colin Gilligan Emeritus Professor of Marketing Sheffield Hallam University and Visiting Professor, Newcastle Business School and
Richard M. S. Wilson Emeritus Professor of Business Administration & Financial Management at Loughborough University Business School and Visiting Professor in the Department of Information Science at Loughborough University
AMSTERDAM • BOSTON • HEIDELBERG • LONDON • NEW YORK • OXFORD PARIS • SAN DIEGO • SAN FRANCISCO • SINGAPORE • SYDNEY • TOKYO Butterworth-Heinemann is an imprint of Elsevier
Butterworth-Heinemann is an imprint of Elsevier Linacre House, Jordan Hill, Oxford OX2 8DP, UK 30 Corporate Drive, Suite 400, Burlington, MA 01803, UK First edition 2003 Second edition 2009 Copyright © 2009 Colin Gilligan and Richard M. S. Wilson. All rights reserved The right of Colin Gilligan and Richard M. S. Wilson to be identified as the authors of this work has been asserted in accordance with the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988 No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, or otherwise, without the prior written permission of the publisher. Permissions may be sought directly from Elsevier’s Science & Technology Rights Department in Oxford, UK: phone: (44) 1865 843830, fax: (44) 1865 853333, E-mail: permissions@ elsevier.com. Alternatively visit the Science and Technology Books website at www.elsevier. com/rights. Notice No responsibility is assumed by the publisher for any injury and/or damage to persons or property as a matter of products liability, negligence or otherwise, or from any use or operation of any methods, products, instructions or ideas contained in the material herein. British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library. Library of Congress Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the Library of Congress ISBN: 978-1-85617-617-0 For information on all Butterworth-Heinemann publications visit our web site at books.elsevier.com
Composition by Macmillan Publishing Solutions www.macmillansolutions.com Printed and bound in Great Britain 09 10 11 12 13 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
Contents
Preface to the Second Edition
ix
Overview of the Book’s Structure
xi
1
Introduction
1
1.1 1.2
1
1.3 1.4 1.5 1.6
2
Learning Objectives The Nature of Marketing (or, ‘Delivering Value and Winning Customer Preference’) The Management Process Strategic Decisions and the Nature of Strategy The Marketing/Strategy Interface Summary
1 6 8 16 39
Strategic Marketing Planning and the Marketing Plan
41
2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4 2.5 2.6
41 41 42 49 54 69
Learning Objectives Introduction The Role of Strategic Marketing Planning So What is Marketing Strategy? The Three Dimensions of Planning Summary
Stage One: Where Are We Now? Strategic and Marketing Analysis
73
3
77
Marketing Auditing and the Analysis of Capability 3.1 3.2 3.3 3.4 3.5 3.6 3.7
Learning Objectives Introduction Reviewing Marketing Effectiveness The Role of SWOT Analysis Competitive Advantage and the Value Chain Conducting Effective Audits Summary
77 77 84 85 102 104 109
v
vi Contents
4
5
Segmental, Productivity and Ratio Analysis
111
4.1 4.2 4.3 4.4 4.5 4.6 4.7 4.8 4.9 4.10 4.11 4.12 4.13 4.14
111 111 113 114 119 121 121 135 136 138 142 144 147 150
Market and Environmental Analysis
153
5.1 5.2 5.3 5.4 5.5 5.6 5.7 5.8
153 153 155 161 167 170 178
5.9 5.10
6
7
Learning Objectives Introduction The Clarification of Cost Categories Marketing Cost Analysis: Aims and Methods An Illustration of Segmental Analysis An Alternative Approach to Segmental Analysis Customer Profitability Analysis Marketing Experimentation The Nature of Productivity The Use of Ratios Analysing Ratios and Trends Ratios and Interfirm Comparison A Strategic Approach Summary Learning Objectives Introduction Analysing the Environment The Nature of the Marketing Environment The Evolution of Environmental Analysis The Political, Economic, Social and Technological Environments Coming to Terms with Industry and Market Breakpoints Coming to Terms with the Very Different Future: The Implications for Marketing Planning Approaches to Environmental Analysis and Scanning Summary
182 189 194
Approaches to Customer Analysis
197
6.1 6.2 6.3 6.4 6.5 6.6
197 197 198 202 211
Learning Objectives Introduction Coming to Terms with Buyer Behaviour Factors Influencing Consumer Behaviour The Buying Decision Process The Rise of the New Consumer and the Implications for Marketing Planning 6.7 Organizational Buying Behaviour 6.8 The Growth of Relationship Marketing 6.9 Summary Appendix: The Drivers of Consumer Change
217 221 229 243 244
Approaches to Competitor Analysis
251
7.1 7.2
251 251
Learning Objectives Introduction
Contents
7.3 7.4 7.5 7.6 7.7 7.8 7.9 7.10 7.11
Against Whom Are We Competing? Identifying and Evaluating Competitors’ Strengths and Weaknesses Evaluating Competitive Relationships and Analysing How Organizations Compete Identifying Competitors’ Objectives Identifying Competitors’ Likely Response Profiles Competitor Analysis and the Development of Strategy The Competitive Intelligence System The Development of a Competitive Stance: The Potential for Ethical Conflict Summary
Stage Two: Where do We Want to Be? Strategic Direction and Strategy Formulation 8
265 271 276 277 279 280 284 289
293
Missions and Objectives
297
8.1 8.2 8.3 8.4 8.5 8.6
297 297 300 303 316
8.7 8.8
9
259
Learning Objectives Introduction The Purpose of Planning Establishing the Corporate Mission Influences on Objectives and Strategy Guidelines for Establishing Objectives and Setting Goals and Targets The Development of Strategies Summary
317 332 336
Market Segmentation, Targeting and Positioning
339
9.1 9.2 9.3 9.4 9.5 9.6 9.7 9.8 9.9 9.10 9.11 9.12 9.13 9.14 9.15 9.16
339 339 341 344 346 347 348 349 352 357 361 365 367 369 372 377
Learning Objectives Introduction The Nature and Purpose of Segmentation Approaches to Segmenting Markets Factors Affecting the Feasibility of Segmentation Approaches to Segmentation The Bases for Segmentation Geographic and Geodemographic Techniques Demographic Segmentation Behavioural Segmentation Psychographic and Lifestyle Segmentation Approaches to Segmenting Industrial Markets Market Targeting Deciding on the Breadth of Market Coverage Product Positioning: The Battle for the Mind Summary
vii
viii Contents
10
11
The Formulation of Strategy 1: Analysing the Product Portfolio
379
10.1 10.2 10.3 10.4 10.5 10.6 10.7
379 379 379 384 392 398 401
The Formulation of Strategy 2: Generic Strategies and the Significance of Competitive Advantage 11.1 11.2 11.3 11.4 11.5 11.6
12
Learning Objectives Introduction The Development of Strategic Perspectives Models of Portfolio Analysis Market Attractiveness and Business Position Assessment Criticisms of Portfolio Analysis Summary
Learning Objectives Introduction Types of Strategy Porter’s Three Generic Competitive Strategies Competitive Advantage and Its Pivotal Role in Strategic Marketing Planning Summary
The Formulation of Strategy 3: Strategies for Leaders, Followers, Challengers and Nichers 12.1 12.2 12.3 12.4 12.5
Learning Objectives Introduction The Influence of Market Position on Strategy Strategies for Market Leaders Marketing Strategy and Military Analogies: Lessons for Market Leaders 12.6 Strategies for Market Challengers 12.7 Strategies for Market Followers 12.8 Strategies for Market Nichers 12.9 Military Analogies and Competitive Strategy: A Brief Summary 12.10 The Inevitability of Strategic Wear-out (or, The Law of Marketing Gravity and Why Dead Cats Only Bounce Once) 12.11 The Influence of Product Evolution and the Product Life Cycle on Strategy 12.12 Summary
403 403 403 404 407 413 453
455 455 455 455 457 468 483 495 497 498 506 510 518
Bibliography
519
Index
537
Preface to the Second Edition
Over the past decade the marketing environment has changed in a series of dramatic and far-reaching ways. Amongst some of the most significant of these changes has been the emergence of what we refer to within this book as ‘the new consumer ’ and ‘the new competition.’ This new consumer is typically far more demanding, far more discriminating, much less brand loyal, and far more willing to complain than in the past, whilst the new competition is frequently far less predictable and often more desperate than previously. At the same time, we have seen the ever-faster pace of technological change and the emergence of new delivery systems. Within the environment as a whole, we have seen and been affected by a series of unpredictable events, including the bombing of the twin towers in New York, the unprecedented rise – and then fall – in oil prices in 2008–2009, tensions in the Middle East, and a global economic crisis that began to emerge in 2007–2008. Together, these changes have led to a very different type of marketing reality which has had major implications for the marketing planning and strategy processes. The question of how marketing planners might respond to the new marketing reality is therefore an underlying theme of this book. In practice, many marketing planners have responded by focusing to an ever greater degree upon short-term and tactical issues, arguing that during periods of intense environmental change, traditional approaches to planning are of little value. Instead, they suggest, there is the need to develop highly sensitive environmental monitoring systems that are capable of identifying trends, opportunities and threats at a very early stage, and then an organizational structure and managerial mindset that leads to the organization responding quickly and cleverly. Within this book we question these sorts of assumptions and focus instead upon the ways in which the marketing planning process can be developed and managed effectively and strategically. We therefore attempt to inject a degree of rigour into the process arguing that rapid change within the environment demands a more strategic approach rather than less. The origins of this book can be seen to lie in our earlier book, Strategic Marketing Management: Planning, Implementation and Control. This was first published in 1992, with the second edition appearing five years later and the third edition in 2005. The very positive response that we received
ix
x Preface to the Second Edition
to the book appears to have been due, at least in part, to the way in which we assumed a certain level of knowledge on the part of the reader and then attempted to develop this further. This led us, in turn, to write the first edition of Strategic Marketing Planning which was published in 2003. The approach that we took within the book was essentially similar to that of Strategic Marketing Management, in that we did not return to first principles but relied instead upon the reader coming to this material with a solid grounding in the subject. The same approach is reflected in this second edition. As in the past, we have tried to give emphasis not just to the changes that are taking place within the marketing environment, but also to their implications for marketing planning and marketing strategy. In doing this, we have refocused parts of the book and included new material covering areas that have developed significantly over the past few years, including experience marketing, e-marketing, and the management of competitive disadvantage. The primary markets for the book can therefore be seen to include: ■
Students reading for degrees involving marketing, but especially MBA candidates and those studying for a specialist Master’s degree in marketing
■
Senior undergraduates following business studies and business related programmes
■
Students of the Chartered Institute of Marketing who are preparing for the Diploma examinations
■
Marketing practitioners who will benefit from a comprehensive review of current thinking in the field of strategic marketing planning. Colin Gilligan, Sheffield Richard M.S. Wilson, Loughborough
Acknowledgement Our thanks go to Janice Nunn for all the effort that she put in to the preparation of the manuscript.
Overview of the Book’s Structure
1 Introduction
2 Strategic marketing planning and the marketing plan
Stage One Where are we now? Strategic and marketing analysis
3 Marketing auditing and the analysis of capability
4 Segmental, productivity and ratio analysis
5 Market and environmental analysis
6 Approaches to customer analysis
7 Approaches to competitor analysis
Stage Two Where do we want to be? Strategic direction and strategy formulation
8 Missions and objectives
9 Market segmentation, targeting and positioning
10 The formulation of strategy 1
11 The formulation of strategy 2
12 The formulation of strategy 3
This page intentionally left blank
CHAPTER 1
Introduction
1.1
LEARNING OBJECTIVES
When you have read this chapter you should be able to: (a) define marketing in strategic terms; (b) understand the basic structure of the book and how this chapter establishes the context for what follows; (c) specify the characteristics of strategy and strategic decisions; (d) understand the nature of the debate about the future role of marketing and its contribution to management, enhancing organizational effectiveness; (e) appreciate the changing emphases within marketing and the implications for the ways in which marketing strategies are developed.
1.2 THE NATURE OF MARKETING (OR, ‘DELIVERING VALUE AND WINNING CUSTOMER PREFERENCE’) The question of what marketing is and what it entails has been the focus of a considerable amount of work over the past 60 years. From this, numerous definitions have emerged, with differing emphases on the process of marketing, the functional activities that constitute marketing, and the orientation (or philosophy) of marketing. The Chartered Institute of Marketing, for example, for a long time defined it as: the management process for identifying, anticipating and satisfying customer requirements profitably. Strategic Marketing Planning Copyright © 2009 Colin Gilligan and Richard M.S. Wilson. All rights reserved.
1
2 CHAPTER 1: Introduction
A slightly longer but conceptually similar definition of marketing was proposed by the American Marketing Association (AMA) in 1985: Marketing is the process of planning and executing the conception, pricing, promotion distribution of ideas, goods and services to create exchanges that satisfy individual and organizational objectives. Although this definition, or variations of it, was used by a variety of writers for a number of years (see, for example, McCarthy and Perreault, 1990; Kotler, 1991), Dibb et al., 2005; Littler and Wilson (1995, p. 1) pointed to the way in which its adequacy was increasingly being questioned in European textbooks (e.g. Foxall, 1984; Baker, 1987). They went on to suggest that too many definitions of marketing have presented marketing as a functional process conducted by the organization’s marketing department, whereas the role of marketing today is increasingly being conceptualized as an organizational philosophy or ‘an approach to doing business’. This strategic as opposed to a functional approach to marketing was initially captured both by Drucker (1973) who, almost forty years ago, put forward a definition of marketing orientation: McDonald (1989, p. 8): Marketing is a management process whereby the resources of the whole organization are utilized to satisfy the needs of selected customer groups in order to achieve the objectives of both parties. Marketing, then, is first and foremost an attitude of mind rather than a series of functional activities. and subsequently by Marketing is so basic that it cannot be considered a separate function on a par with others such as manufacturing or personnel. It is first a central dimension of the entire business. It is the whole business seen from the point of view of its final result, that is, from the customers’ point of view. Although Drucker’s definition had a significant effect upon patterns of marketing thinking, it has increasingly been recognized that it too has a number of limitations. Perhaps the most significant shift in emphasis since Drucker wrote this is to be found in the importance that is now attached to competitive position in a changing world and that the marketing concept is the managerial orientation which recognizes that success primarily depends upon identifying changing customer wants and developing products and services that match these better than those of competitors (Doyle, 1987; Wilson and Fook, 1990). More recently, writers such as Vargo and Lusch (2004), Jobber (2006) and Kotler and Keller (2008) have all pointed to the way in which a new perspective on marketing, characterized by a focus on intangible resources,
The Nature of Marketing
the co-creation of value, and the management of relationships, has emerged that demands a very different type of definition of marketing. Recognition of this highlights some of the inadequacies of the AMA definition within what is now a very different business environment. It could therefore be said that the AMA definition is more of a list than a definition and is therefore clumsy and inconvenient to use; that it cannot ever be comprehensive; and that it fails to provide a demarcation as to what necessarily is or is not marketing. It was in an attempt to reflect the very different role that marketing now plays that the Chartered Institute of Marketing (CIM) revised its definition in 2008, seeing it as: The strategic business function that creates value by stimulating, facilitating and fulfilling customer demand. Underpinning the definition is the CIM’s belief that marketing creates value by building brands, nurturing innovation, developing relationships, creating good customer service and communicating benefits. The contrasting emphases on customers and competitors that are highlighted by these more recent definitions of marketing can be highlighted, as in Figure 1.1. If an enterprise is managed a little better than customers expect, and if this is done in a slightly better way than competitors can manage, then the enterprise should be successful.
Minor
Customer emphasis
Major
Self-centred
Competitor-centred
Major
Competitor emphasis Minor
Customer-oriented
Market-driven
FIGURE 1.1 Customer and competitor orientations (adapted from Day, 1990)
3
4 CHAPTER 1: Introduction
Within Figure 1.1, the customer-oriented and competitor-centred categories speak for themselves. The self-centred category is characterized by an introspective orientation that focuses on year-on-year improvements in key operating ratios, or on improvements in sales volume without making direct comparisons with competitors. Such an orientation is potentially disastrous when viewed in strategic terms. At the opposite extreme is a market-driven approach to marketing, which seeks to balance responsiveness to customers’ requirements on the one hand with direct competitor comparisons on the other (see Illustration 1.1).
Illustration 1.1
But is your organization really market-driven?
When Peter Drucker first outlined the marketing concept over 50 years ago, he equated marketing with customer orientation, arguing that for a firm to be marketdriven meant always putting the customer first and innovating continuously to improve the delivered value. Subsequently, it has been recognized that Drucker’s perspective lacked strategic content in that it gives emphasis to the organizational culture, but fails to provide guidance on which customers to serve and how to serve them. Equally, Drucker’s initial views failed to take explicit account of competitors and the discipline of profit in the analysis of product and market opportunity. It is because of this that customer orientation has been replaced with the broader concept of market orientation. Given this, we can see marketing operating at three levels:
1. Marketing as a culture characterized by a set of values and beliefs that highlights the importance of the customer’s interests
2. Marketing as a strategy concerned with the choice of products, markets and competitive stance
3. Marketing as the set of tactics (essentially the seven Ps of the expanded marketing mix) that provides the basis for the implementation of the business and competitive strategy. Recognition of this has led Webster (1999, pp. 239–40) to argue that the extent to which an organization is market-driven can be measured against eleven dimensions:
1. The extent to which a customer focus pervades the entire organization 2. The commitment to delivering value 3. The identification and development of distinctive competencies 4. The formation of strategic partnerships 5. The development of strong relationships with strategically important customers
6. The emphasis upon market segmentation, targeting and positioning 7. The use of customer information as a strategic asset
The Nature of Marketing
8. The focus on customer benefits and service 9. Continuous improvement and innovation 10. The definition of quality based on meeting customers’ expectations 11. A commitment to having the best information technology available. For Day (1990), the characteristics of a market-driven organization can be stated more succinctly: ■
An externally oriented culture that emphasizes superior customer value
■
Distinctive capabilities in market sensing as a means of anticipating the future
■
Structures that are responsive to changing customer and market requirements.
The significance of being market-driven has, in turn, been highlighted by a series of studies, including one amongst 600 managers in France, the USA, Germany, Japan and the UK, which found that ‘the single strongest influence on company performance is innovativeness. Further, a market-oriented company culture was found to have a positive impact in all five countries, while customer orientation, by itself, has virtually no influence on bottom line performance’ (Webster, 1999, p. 241). It is the recognition of this that, as Webster suggests, highlights the need for firms to innovate continuously in order to exceed the customer’s evolving definition of value.
Given the nature of these three comments, the essential requirements of marketing can be seen to be (Wilson, 1988, p. 259): 1. The identification of consumers’ needs (covering what goods and services are bought; how they are bought; by whom they are bought; and why they are bought); 2. The definition of target market segments (by which customers are grouped according to common characteristics – whether demographic, psychological, geographic, etc.); and 3. The creation of a differential advantage within target segments by which a distinct competitive position relative to other companies can be established, and from which profit flows. The way in which a differential advantage might be achieved – and sustained – is through the manipulation of the elements of the marketing mix. This mix has traditionally been seen to consist of the ‘four Ps’ of marketing: Product, Price, Promotion and Place. Increasingly, however, but particularly in the services sector, it has been recognized that these four Ps are far too limited in terms of providing a framework both for thinking about marketing and for planning marketing strategy. It is because of this that a
5
6 CHAPTER 1: Introduction
Process management • How customers are handled and managed from the point of very first contact with the organization through to the point of very last contact
Physical evidence • Layout • Decor • Ease of access
Product • Product management • New product development • Branding
The marketing mix
People • Employee selection • Employee training • Employee motivation
The four ‘hard’ Ps The three ‘soft’ Ps
Price • Pricing • Discount structures • Terms of business
Place/distribution • Channel management • Customer service • Physical distribution Promotion • Advertising • Sales promotion • Public relations • Personal selling • Merchandising • Sponsorship
FIGURE 1.2 The elements of the marketing mix
far greater emphasis is now given to the idea of an expanded mix that has three additional elements: ■
People
■
Physical evidence
■
Process management.
The detail of both the traditional ‘hard’ elements of the mix and the ‘softer ’ elements appears in Figure 1.2.
1.3 THE MANAGEMENT PROCESS Management can be looked at from a variety of viewpoints. It may be seen from one perspective as being largely an attitude that reflects a willingness to debate issues and resolve them through the use of appropriate techniques and procedures. Alternatively, management may be viewed in terms of its responsibility for achieving desired objectives, which requires the selection of means to accomplish prescribed ends as well as the articulation of those
The Management Process
ends. This view of management can be analysed further by focusing on its task orientation (e.g. in the functional context of marketing) or on its process orientation (i.e. the way in which the responsibility is exercised). In either case it has been suggested that decision-making and management are the same thing (Simon, 1960, p. 1). The process of decision-making is rendered problematic on account of the existence of risk and uncertainty. In the face of risk or uncertainty, some managers postpone making a choice between alternative courses of action for fear of that choice being wrong. What they typically fail to recognize in this situation is that they are actually making another choice – they are deciding not to decide (Barnard, 1956, p. 193), which favours the status quo rather than change. This is not a means of eliminating risk or uncertainty, since it seeks to ignore them rather than to accommodate them: the imperative to adapt is one that cannot be ignored. If the central question in the management process concerns the need to make decisions, we need to know what decisions should be made and how they should be made. This book intends to deal with both these issues by following the first two stages in a sequence that reflects a problem-solving routine. Figure 1.3 summarizes the overall sequence of stages. This is done
Introduction
Stage One* Where are we now? (beginning)
Stage Five How can we ensure arrival? (control)
Stage Two* Where do we want to be? (ends)
Stage Four Which way is best? (evaluation)
Stage Three How might we get there? (means)
*Stages covered in this book. See Wilson and Gilligan (2005) for in-depth information on Stages Three, Four and Five.
FIGURE 1.3 The framework
7
8 CHAPTER 1: Introduction
against the background of a discussion in Chapter 2 of the nature and role of strategic marketing planning and the structure of the marketing plan. Stage One of this process (strategic and marketing analysis) raises the question of where the organization is now in terms of its competitive position, product range, market share, financial position and overall levels of capability and effectiveness. In addressing this question we are seeking to establish a base line from which we can move forward. Chapters 3 to 7 address Stage 1. Stage Two (strategic direction and strategy formulation) is concerned with where the organization should go in the future, which requires the specification of ends (or objectives) to be achieved. While top management in the organization will have some discretion over the choice of ends, this is often constrained by various vested interests, as we shall see later in this chapter. Chapters 8 to 12 address Stage Two. Stage Three of the management process deals with the question of how desired ends might be achieved, something which begs the question of how alternative means to ends might be identified. This strategy formulation stage requires creative inputs, which cannot be reduced to mechanical procedures. Stage Three is not directly addressed in this book, but is examined in detail in Wilson and Gilligan (2005). Stage Four focuses on the evaluation of alternative means by which the most preferred (or ‘best’) alternative might be selected. The need to choose may be due to alternatives being mutually exclusive (i.e. all attempting to achieve the same end) or it may be a consequence of limited resources (which means that a rationing mechanism must be invoked). Again, Stage Four is not directly addressed in this book, but see Wilson and Gilligan (2005). Stage Five covers the implementation of the chosen means, and the monitoring of its performance in order that any corrective actions might be taken to ensure that the desired results are achieved. Since circumstances both within the organization and in its environment are unlikely to stay constant while a strategy is being pursued, it is necessary to adapt to accommodate such changes. Stage Five is not addressed in this book but, again, see Wilson and Gilligan (2005). We therefore begin by focusing upon the nature of strategy and strategic decisions, before turning to an examination of some of the issues facing strategic marketing planners currently and then, in Chapter 2, the detail of the strategic marketing planning process.
1.4 STRATEGIC DECISIONS AND THE NATURE OF STRATEGY Strategic decisions are concerned with seven principal areas: 1. They are concerned with the scope of an organization’s activities, and hence with the definition of an organization’s boundaries.
Strategic Decisions and the Nature of Strategy
2. They relate to the matching of the organization’s activities with the opportunities of its substantive environment. Since the environment is continually changing, it is necessary for this to be accommodated via adaptive decision-making that anticipates outcomes – as in playing a game of chess. 3. They require the matching of an organization’s activities with its resources. In order to take advantage of strategic opportunities it will be necessary to have funds, capacity, personnel, etc., available when required. 4. They have major resource implications for organizations – such as acquiring additional capacity, disposing of capacity, or reallocating resources in a fundamental way. 5. They are influenced by the values and expectations of those who determine the organization’s strategy. Any repositioning of organizational boundaries will be influenced by managerial preferences and conceptions as much as by environmental possibilities. 6. They will affect the organization’s long-term direction. 7. They are complex in nature, since they tend to be non-routine and involve a large number of variables. As a result, their implications will typically extend throughout the organization. Decision-making (whether strategic or tactical) is but a part of a broader problem-solving process. In essence Johnson et al. (2008) suggest that this consists of three key aspects: analysis, choice and implementation. Strategic analysis focuses on understanding the strategic position of the organization, which requires that answers be found to such questions as: ■
What changes are taking place in the environment?
■
How will these changes affect the organization and its activities?
■
What resources does the organization have to deal with these changes?
■
What do those groups associated with the organization wish to achieve? Strategic choice has three aspects:
■
The generation of strategic options, which should go beyond the most obvious courses of action
■
The evaluation of strategic options, which may be based on exploiting an organization’s relative strengths or on overcoming its weaknesses
9
10 CHAPTER 1: Introduction
■
The selection of a preferred strategy that will enable the organization to seize opportunities within its environment or to counter threats from competitors.
Strategic implementation is concerned with translating a decision into action, which presupposes that the decision itself (i.e. the strategic choice) was made with some thought being given to feasibility and acceptability. The allocation of resources to new courses of action will need to be undertaken, and there may be a need for adapting the organization’s structure to handle new activities as well as training personnel and devising appropriate systems. We have given some thought to strategic decisions, but what is meant by strategy? Hofer and Schendel (1978, p. 27) have identified three distinct levels of strategy in a commercial context. These are: 1. Corporate strategy, which deals with the allocation of resources among the various businesses or divisions of an enterprise; 2. Business strategy, which exists at the level of the individual business or division, dealing primarily with the question of competitive position; 3. Functional level strategy, which is limited to the actions of specific functions within specific businesses. Our main concern within this book is in relation to business strategy (i.e. level (2) above) and the way in which this links to marketing as a set of functional activities (i.e. level (3) above), notwithstanding definitions on pp. 1–3 above. Different authorities have defined strategy in lots of different ways; there is no standard definition. However, a range of elements that most writers seem to subscribe to in discussing strategy have been put forward by Simmonds (1980, pp. 7–9) as follows: 1. Strategy is applicable to business within defined boundaries. While the boundaries may change, the strategy applies at any one time to actions affecting a delimited area of demand and competition. 2. There are specified direct competitors. These are competitors selling essentially the same products or services within the defined demand area. Indirect competitors are those operating outside the defined business and whose products are not direct substitutes. Indirect competition is usually ignored or covered by the concept of price elasticity of demand. 3. There is zero-sum competition between the direct competitors for the market demand, subject to competitive action affecting the quantity demanded. Demand within the defined market varies over time. This variation in demand is largely independent of supplier
Strategic Decisions and the Nature of Strategy
strategies, and is often referred to as the product life cycle. At its simplest it is depicted as a normal curve over time with regularly growing then declining demand. 4. Strategy unfolds over a sequence of time periods. Competition evolves through a series of skirmishes and battles across the units of time covered by the product life cycle. 5. Single period profit is a function of: ■ the price level ruling for the period ■ the accumulated volume experience of the enterprise ■ the enterprise’s achieved volume as a proportion of capacity. 6. Market share has intrinsic value. Past sales levels influence subsequent customer buying, and costs reduce with single-period volume and accumulated experience. 7. Competitors differ in market share, accumulated experience, production capacity and resources. Competitors are unequal, identified and positioned. Objectives differ. Enterprises composed of ownership, management and employee factions and operating a range of different businesses have different objectives. Strategic business thinking, however, will usually express these as different time and risk preferences for performance within an individual business, measured in financial terms. 8. Within a given situation there will be a core of strategic actions that will be the essential cause of change in competitive position. Non-strategic (or contingent) actions will support strategic actions and should be consistent with them, but will not change competitive position significantly. 9. Identification of an optimal core of strategic actions requires reasoning (or diagnosis), is not attained through application of a fixed set of procedures, and is situational. In short, thinking is required. Taken together, these elements present a view of business strategy that sees it as a chosen set of actions by means of which a market position relative to other competing enterprises is sought and maintained. This gives us the notion of competitive position. It needs to be emphasized that ‘strategy ’ is not synonymous with ‘longterm plan’, but rather consists of an enterprise’s attempts to reach some preferred future state by adapting its competitive position as circumstances change. While a series of strategic moves may be planned, competitors’ actions will mean that the actual moves will have to be modified to take account of those actions.
11
12 CHAPTER 1: Introduction
We can contrast this view of strategy with an approach to management that has been common in the UK. In organizations that lack strategic direction there has been a tendency to look inwards in times of stress, and for management to devote their attention to cost-cutting and to shedding unprofitable divisions. In other words, the focus has been on efficiency (i.e. the relationship between inputs and outputs, usually with a short time horizon) rather than on effectiveness (which is concerned with the organization’s attainment of goals – including that of desired competitive position). While efficiency is essentially introspective, effectiveness highlights the links between the organization and its environment. The responsibility for efficiency lies with operational managers, with top management having the primary responsibility for the strategic orientation of the organization. Figure 1.4 summarizes the principal combinations of efficiency and effectiveness. An organization that finds itself in cell 1 is well placed to thrive, since it is achieving what it aspires to achieve with an efficient output/input ratio. In contrast, an organization in cell 4 is doomed, as is an organization in cell 2 unless it can establish some strategic direction. The particular point to note is that cell 2 is a worse place to be than is cell 3, since in the latter the strategic direction is present to ensure effectiveness even if rather too much input is currently being used to generate outputs. To be effective is to survive, whereas to be efficient is not in itself either necessary or sufficient for survival.
Strategic management Effective
Ineffective
Efficient
2
Die slowly
Thrive
3 Inefficient
Operational management
1
Survive
4
Die quickly
FIGURE 1.4 Efficiency versus effectiveness (adapted from Christopher et al., 1987)
Strategic Decisions and the Nature of Strategy
Effectiveness in marketing terms can therefore be seen to be the ability on the part of management to search out and embrace changing markets and structures and then reflect this in the marketing strategy. In crude terms, to be effective is to do the right thing, while to be efficient is to do the (given) thing right. An emphasis on efficiency rather than on effectiveness is clearly wrong. But who determines effectiveness? Any organization can be portrayed as a coalition of diverse interest groups each of which participates in the coalition in order to secure some advantage. This advantage (or inducement) may be in the form of dividends to shareholders, wages to employees, continued business to suppliers of goods and services, satisfaction on the part of consumers, legal compliance from the viewpoint of government, responsible behaviour towards society and the environment from the perspective of pressure groups, and so on. Figure 1.5 illustrates the way in which a range of interest groups come together to sustain (and, indeed, constitute) an organization. In so far as the inducements needed to maintain this coalition are not forthcoming, the organization ceases to be effective. Thus, for example, employees may go on strike in furtherance of a pay dispute; shareholders may be unwilling to subscribe
Managers Employees
Suppliers
Customers
The organization
Society
Government Other (e.g.TUC)
FIGURE 1.5 Interest groups
Shareholders
13
14 CHAPTER 1: Introduction
further capital if the value of their shares has fallen due to bad management; consumers may have defected in the light of superior market offerings from competitors; and each of these will remove one vital element from the coalition. It should be apparent from this view of an organization that management’s freedom of movement is constrained by virtue of the expectations of the various interest groups within the coalition. We are unable to assume that a clean slate exists on which any strategy might be drawn, since this may be against the interests of members of the coalition. What we can say, therefore, is that any strategy is potentially available in so far as it ensures that the interests of coalition members are protected. If this is not so the organization cannot be effective, and if it is not effective it will not survive. The failure to achieve an appropriate balance between operational and strategic management has been illustrated at various times by numerous organizations, including Marks & Spencer, Vodafone, the Post Office (subsequently – and unsuccessfully – renamed Consignia and then, more recently, Royal Mail Group) and virtually all of the major flag carrier airlines. In the case of the Post Office, the British government set out its vision for the future of the organization in its report Counter Revolution: Modernizing the Post Office Network. The report highlighted a variety of issues, including: ■
The organization’s failure to come to terms with the service requirements of increasingly sophisticated and demanding customers
■
The lack of any real competitive stance, that led to other service providers (such as TNT, Federal Express, DHL and UPS) being able to capture a substantial share of the organization’s most profitable business
■
The slow adoption of new technologies
■
A belief that the brand equals the branch network.
With approximately 18 500 branches or outlets in 1999/2000, compared with less than one-fifth of this number amongst its most obvious competitors, the organization had proved to be slow and monolithic in its response to the far more focused and agile behaviour of others. In order to overcome this – and indeed to survive – a number of significant changes were needed to the loss-making branch network, the most obvious of which was to identify with a far greater clarity exactly where and how the Post Office brand could best add value to the communications chain for business customers and consumers alike. The organization’s response to this challenge was seen by the public to be perverse in that it announced in 2005 a fundamental review of its branch network and then a series of significant cuts to this, something that reduced levels of customer access and customer service.
Strategic Decisions and the Nature of Strategy
The difficulties of balancing both the operational and the strategic dimensions of management has also been illustrated by Hoover’s problems in coming to terms with the challenges posed by Dyson’s entry to the vacuum cleaner market, and by the ways in which the major airlines such as BA, KLM and Lufthansa all experienced difficulties in meeting the challenge of the lowcost, no-frills entrants to the airlines market, such as Ryanair and easyJet. In the case of BA, for example, having been hit by the low-cost carriers and then by a series of other factors – including the 2001 foot and mouth outbreak, the slowdown in the USA and in the global economy, and the turmoil in the aviation industry after the terrorist attacks in the USA in September 2001 – the company responded by developing and then selling bring text bach its own low(ish) cost airline, Go!, in a management buyout for a little over £100 million. Eleven months later, Go! was taken over by easyJet for £374 million in a deal that strengthened BA’s competitor yet further. Given the nature of these comments, it should be apparent that achieving a consistent balance between operational and strategic issues is inherently problematic, although it is the ability to do this that ultimately determines the organization’s overall level of marketing effectiveness. The question of what determines marketing effectiveness has been the subject of a considerable amount of research, and is an issue to which we return at various points in the book. At this stage, therefore, we will limit ourselves to an overview of the sorts of factors that contribute to the effectiveness of marketing activity (see Illustration 1.2). Illustration 1.2
The dimensions of marketing effectiveness
Although it is tempting to identify the characteristics of marketing effectiveness and to believe that the straightforward adoption of these will lead to business success, it is also potentially simplistic and dangerous, since it can lead to the view that this is the formula for success. Nevertheless, there are certain elements that appear to contribute to effectiveness, and it is in this way that the list below should be seen: ■
A strong sense of vision amongst the member of the senior management team
■
A strong customer orientation across all aspects of the business and a fundamental recognition of the importance of the customer
■
A detailed recognition of the relative value of different segments and customer groups and a clear policy of targeting and positioning
■
A clarity and ambition of marketing objectives
■
A detailed understanding of the organization’s assets and competencies
■
A detailed understanding of the market
■
A willingness to redefine the market and create and exploit windows of opportunity
15
16 CHAPTER 1: Introduction
■
The creation of one or more market breakpoints
■
An emphasis upon differentiation and the leveraging of strong selling propositions
■
A fundamental understanding of the strategic importance of competitive advantage
■
The innovative management of each of the elements of the marketing mix
■
A balanced product portfolio
■
A commitment to product and process innovation
■
An emphasis upon the coordination of activities across the organization
■
A recognition of the fundamental importance of implementation.
1.5 THE MARKETING/STRATEGY INTERFACE On the basis of a literature review, Greenley (1986, p. 56) has drawn some distinctions between strategic planning (seen as being of a long-term nature) and marketing planning (seen as being an annual exercise), including those listed in Table 1.1. These differences indicate that strategic planning logically precedes marketing planning, by providing a framework within which marketing plans might be formulated. As Cravens (1986, p. 77) has stated: Understanding the strategic situation confronting an organization is an essential starting point in developing a marketing strategy. This understanding can be derived from an assessment of: ■
Organizational capabilities
■
Threats from environmental forces
■
Competitors’ strengths and weaknesses
■
Customers’ needs
and fits into an iterative setting, as shown in Figure 1.6. The strong interdependence of strategic and marketing planning is clearly seen in this diagram. We can use this interdependence to develop the marketing mix (of Figure 1.2 above) into a set of elements from which a competitive strategy might be developed (as in Figure 1.7). The aim should be to build strength in those elements that are critical to achieving superiority in areas deemed important by customers. In this way the organization should be able to challenge its competitors from a position in which it can use its relative strengths.
The Marketing/Strategy Interface
Table 1.1 Differences between strategic planning and marketing planning Strategic planning
Marketing planning
Concerned with overall, long-term organizational direction
Concerned with day-to-day performance and results
Provides the long-term framework for the organization
Represents only one stage in the organization’s development
Overall orientation needed to match the organization to its environment
Functional and professional orientation tends to predominate
Goals and strategies are evaluated from an overall perspective
Goals are subdivided into specific targets
Relevance of goals and strategies is only evident in the long term
Relevance of goals and strategies is immediately evident
Marketing strategy selection
Marketing strategy alternatives
Factors affecting strategic situation
Strategic situation determination
FIGURE 1.6 The marketing strategy process
The potential benefits of a strategic underpinning to marketing planning are probably apparent, but what about the problem of implementation? If implementation is ineffective, the carefully devised strategy will be unable to help in improving the organization’s performance. The question becomes, therefore: ‘Given a specific type of strategy, what marketing structures, policies, procedures, and programs are likely to distinguish high performing business units from those that are relatively less effective, efficient, or adaptable?’ (Walker and Ruekert, 1987, p. 15). Part of the answer is undoubtedly the extent to which the organization reflects a customer orientation.
17
18 CHAPTER 1: Introduction
Product • Functional • Technical developments planned • Packaging • Service levels • Range extensions/deletions
Customer • Customer targets • Researching customer needs by segment • Segmenting the market by customer needs • Distribution channels • Export
Distribution • Identifying appropriate channels • Accessing successful distributors • Stock and service levels • Operating costs
Price • List prices • Discount structure Advertising and promotion • Target audience • Communication objective • Media • Advertising weight • Promotion plans and timing • Point of sale Sales force • Customer priorities • Product priorities • Incentives and rewards Manufacturing • Sustainable quality and volume levels • Cost reduction programme: – raw material usage – yields – manpower • Quality enhancement
FIGURE 1.7 Elements of a competitive strategy (source: Milton and Reiss, 1985)
Left-handed and right-handed organizations The issue of customer orientation has been discussed by Doyle (1994, pp. 7–9) in terms of what he refers to as left-handed and right-handed organizations. For many senior managers, he argues, the principal business objectives are profitability, growth and shareholder value. There is, however, a danger in these, he suggests, in that they ignore the customer even though: satisfied customers are the source of all profits and shareholder value. Customers can choose from whom they buy, and unless the firm satisfies them at least as well as competitors, sales and profits will quickly erode. Customer satisfaction should therefore be a prime objective and measure of the performance of managers. This led Doyle to highlight the differences between the two types of organization. In the case of left-handed or financially driven organizations, he suggests that the key planning mechanism is the financial plan or budget, with costs, expenses, debt and assets – and the elements of the marketing mix – all being controlled in order to achieve financial goals; this is illustrated in Figure 1.8. The consequence of this is that, when sales begin to
The Marketing/Strategy Interface
Financial objectives
Financial variables
Marketing decisions
Customers' expectations
Marketing objectives
Product performance, design and choice
The financial plan
Return on investment
Rapid product turnover High margins
The elements of the marketing mix
Prices, discounts and value for money
Target markets
Service and delivery levels
Effective positioning
The marketing plan
Image and reputation Process management
Business strategy
FIGURE 1.8 The left-handed and right-handed organization (adapted from Doyle, 1994)
slip, there is a tendency to cut back on areas such as advertising and R&D in order to maintain or boost profits. By contrast, right-handed or market-driven organizations have as their primary focus the objective of satisfying customers. This involves defining and understanding market segments, and then managing the marketing mix in such a way that customers’ expectations are fully met or exceeded. The difference between the two approaches, Doyle argues, is that ‘Business decisions flow back from an understanding of customers rather than from a financial requirement.’ He went on to suggest that the market-led approach, which is based on the idea of achieving market leadership through superiority in meeting customers’ needs, has typically been associated with Japanese organizations. By contrast, the financially driven approach has all too often been a reflection of British and US organizations. The idea of a left- versus right-handed orientation leads in turn to the notion of wrong-side-up and right-side-up organizations (see Figure 1.9). Given the importance to any organization of its customers, it follows that staff must be customer-led. Doyle argues that the truly fundamental importance of this has been recognized by relatively few organizations; those that have are the ones that achieve true customer delight. Among those that have come to recognize the real significance of a customer orientation are Amazon, Tesco, Singapore Airlines, Caterpillar and, for a short time, in the 1980s, Scandinavian Airlines. Jan Carlzon, the
19
20 CHAPTER 1: Introduction
Senior management
The wrong-side-up organization
Middle management Frontline staff Customers Customers Front-line staff with a higher status who understand the organization’s core values, the need for a customer focus and who are empowered to satisfy customers’ needs Middle management who direct the resources needed and help remove obstacles Senior management who provide the resources and develop the core values
The right-side-up organization
FIGURE 1.9 The two types of organization (adapted from Doyle, 1994)
airline’s Chief Executive at the time, recognized at an early stage the importance of what he referred to as ‘moments of truth’; these are the occasions when the customer deals with the organization’s staff and is exposed to the quality of service and type of personal contact. Carlzon’s thinking in turning round and revitalizing what was at the time a poorly performing airline was therefore straightforward. Because the airline’s frontline staff, many of whom are in relatively junior positions, are the customer’s only really visible point of contact with the airline, he argued that managers need to ensure that all staff understand and act out the values that senior management claims are important. This means they need to be the most customer-oriented, best-trained and most strongly motivated employees in the business. However, the reality in many cases is that these are the people who least understand the core values and are often only poorly trained. The net effect of this is that the organization fails to deliver to the customer what it promises. In an attempt to overcome this, organizations have responded in a variety of ways, including downsizing, developing flatter structures and by supporting and empowering staff. In this way, a more firmly customerled business in which frontline employees are more highly trained and motivated to satisfy customers’ needs should emerge: this is illustrated in Figure 1.9.
The Marketing/Strategy Interface
Marketing’s mid-life crisis We started this chapter by talking about the nature of marketing and its contribution to the overall management process. However, whilst the arguments in favour of marketing, with its emphasis upon the identification of customers’ needs and the delivery of customer satisfaction, are (or appear to be) strong, there was an increasing recognition throughout the 1990s that marketing was (or might be) facing what is loosely referred to as a ‘mid-life crisis’. The basis for this comment was that, although a whole generation of management writers agreed upon the importance of consumer sovereignty, and hence the apparent and pivotal importance of marketing, there was a widespread and growing concern that ‘something is amiss, that the (marketing) concept is deeply, perhaps irredeemably, flawed, that its seemingly solid theoretical foundations are by no means secure and that the specialism is teetering on the brink of serious intellectual crisis’ (Brown, 1995, p. 42). In developing this argument, Brown – who has been one of the wittiest and most vocal critics of marketing as it has traditionally been perceived and practised – made reference to a variety of commentators: ■
Piercy (1991, p. 15), for example, maintains that the traditional marketing concept ‘assumes and relies on the existence of a world which is alien and unrecognizable to many of the executives who actually have to manage marketing for real’.
■
Gummeson (1987, p. 10) states that ‘the present marketing concept … is unrealistic and needs to be replaced’.
■
Rapp and Collins (1990, p. 3) suggest that ‘the traditional methods … simply aren’t working as well any more’.
■
Brownlie and Saren (1992, p. 38) argue that ‘it is questionable whether the marketing concept as it has been propagated can provide the basis for successful business at the end of the twentieth century ’.
■
Michael Thomas (1993) who, after 30 years of disseminating the marketing message, made the frank (and frankly astonishing) confession that he is having serious doubts about its continuing efficacy.
Hooley and Saunders (1993, p. 3), however, pursued a rather different line of argument, suggesting instead that the marketing concept had come of age in that, whereas even ten years earlier many senior managers had not really understood marketing, there appeared now to be a far deeper and wider appreciation of the concept and of the benefits that it was capable of delivering. To a very large extent this was due to the succession
21
22 CHAPTER 1: Introduction
Illustration 1.3
But does marketing work?
The question of whether marketing ‘works’, in the sense that it contributes to or is the principal influence upon higher and more sustained levels of business performance, has been the subject of a number of studies. Some of the best known of these were conducted by: ■
Hooley and Lynch (1985), who examined 1504 British companies and concluded that the high performing organizations were characterized by a significantly greater market orientation, strategic direction and concern with product quality and design than the ‘also rans’
■
Narver and Slater (1990), who focused upon the marketing orientation of the senior managers in 140 North American strategic business units (SBUs) and identified not only a very strong relationship between marketing orientation and profitability but also that the highest degree of marketing orientation was manifested by managers of the most profitable companies
■
Kohli and Jaworski (1990), who conducted a series of semi-structured interviews with marketing practitioners in the USA and discovered a high degree of managerial understanding of the three key component parts of the marketing concept (customer orientation, coordination and profitability), and that the perceived benefits of the marketing philosophy included better overall performance, benefits for employees and more positive customer attitudes
■
Wong and Saunders (1993), who, as the result of a study of matched Japanese, American and British companies, demonstrated that organizations classified as ‘innovators’, ‘quality marketeers’ and ‘mature marketeers’ were significantly more successful in terms of profits, sales and market share than those classified as ‘price promoters’, ‘product makers’ and ‘aggressive pushers’.
of studies that highlighted the contribution that effective marketing programmes are capable of making to organizational performance and success: a number of these are summarized in Illustration 1.3. However, despite this sort of evidence there was still a question mark over the direction that marketing should take in the future. Without doubt, one of the triumphs of marketing as a discipline over the past three decades had been the way in which it has been accepted in a host of areas by managers who previously had denied its value and scope for contributing to the sector ’s performance. Included within these are healthcare, not-for-profit organizations, leisure, religious movements, cultural organizations, and the political arena. Nevertheless, there is still a significant degree of scepticism about the value and future role of marketing. In discussing this, Brown (1995, p. 43) focuses upon four stages of marketing acceptance. The first of these,
The Marketing/Strategy Interface
realization, is characterized by a general acceptance that the marketing concept is sound, but that there is often a problem with its implementation; the most common manifestation of this would be that of getting senior management to accept and embrace the concept. The net effect of this in many organizations has been ‘a preoccupation with making marketing work through a heightened understanding of organizational politics and interfunctional rivalry … [and] a programme of internal marketing’ designed to ensure that organizational transformation takes place. The second position is retrenchment in which, again, the concept is seen to be sound, but there are certain circumstances in which it is either inappropriate or of little immediate relevance; many managers in the very fastest moving high-tech industries have, for example, argued that this is the case. Other sectors and markets in which its role and contribution is, it is argued, of little real value include commodity markets, public administration and poorly developed markets in which either there is a significant imbalance between demand and supply and/or an almost complete absence of infrastructure. The third position, rearrangement, demands a far more fundamental reappraisal of marketing so that it can more easily and readily come to terms with the very different realities of today’s markets. Webster (1988), for example, has argued for a move away from the position in which marketing and strategic management have, for many commentators, become synonymous. Instead of a myopic preoccupation with market share, competitor activity and so on, marketing should, he claims, return to its roots of a true customer focus. A broadly similar line of argument has been pursued by Christopher et al. (1991), who highlight the fundamental importance of marketing relationships rather than oneoff transactions. The fourth, final and most radical position is that of reappraisal which, according to Brown (1995, p. 45), gives acknowledgement to: the simple fact that the marketing concept has not succeeded and is unlikely to prove successful in its present form. Despite the latterday ‘triumph’ of marketing, the failure rate of new products is as high as it ever was – possibly higher. Consumerism, the so-called ‘shame of marketing’, is still rampant, especially in its virulent ‘green’ mutation. Selling has not, contra to the marketing concept, been rendered redundant, because few products actually sell themselves. Companies in countries where the marketing message has not been received loud and clear, such as Japan and Germany, continue to outperform their Anglo-American counterparts and, even in the latter milieux, businesses can still succeed without the aid of modern marketing.
23
24 CHAPTER 1: Introduction
Redefining marketing: coming to terms with the challenges of the next decade and the move towards the era of consent Against the background of our comments so far it is apparent that there is a strong case both for redefining marketing (see our earlier comments) and for thinking about the very different role that it should play in the first quarter of the twenty-first century. For many managers the need for this has been highlighted by the way in which a series of fundamental changes have taken place within many markets, which demand a new and possibly radical rethinking of strategies underpinned by a very different marketing paradigm. Prominent among these changes are: ■
A series of significant demographic shifts, accompanied by a number of far-reaching social changes. In the case of the UK, for example, the proportion of the population aged over 50 is now greater than that under 16. At the same time, one in four children now lives with a lone parent, whilst 31 per cent of the population now lives alone. (Source: ONS, 2008). In The Times (17 January 2009, p. 12) it states that singles make up 31 per cent of UK households and this is expected to increase to 40 per cent – by far the main category of household.
■
A significant shift in the balance of power between retailers and manufacturers
■
The relative decline of a number of the megabrands as the result of attacks from low-branded, low-priced competitors
■
The redefinition of their business and redrawing of boundaries within many organizations. In the case of the supermarkets, for example, 28 million UK shoppers now regularly buy clothes, electrical goods and furniture from the big grocery chains (George, Asda’s clothing range, now has a bigger turnover than Gap or H&M in the UK, whilst Sainsbury’s Turange is now seen to be a serious competitor for Top Shop)
■
The disappearance within many industrial organizations of staff marketing departments, and their replacement by more focused functions with specific line responsibilities
■
The decline in the demand for certain specialist marketing skills, including the collection and analysis of data
■
The emergence of a ‘new ’ type of consumer who demands a far higher value-added offer (refer to Chapter 6)
■
The growth of social networking
■
The development of a 24-hour society
The Marketing/Strategy Interface
■
Markets that are characterized by infinitely more aggressive – and desperate – levels of competition
■
The rapid growth of the Internet and on-line marketing. In 2006, for example, the Internet advertising market overtook that of national press advertising and the time that European consumers spend online overtook the time spent reading newspapers and magazines. (Source: Jupiter Research, 2006). Amongst the consequences of this was that in 2008 Google became the dominant force in British advertising
■
The fragmentation of the media which has led to the emergence of several hundred television channels (this compares with just three main channels 25 years ago) and very different media habits
■
A far greater understanding of the implications of behaviour upon the environment and a consequently greater emphasis within organizations upon the triple bottom line (this theme is developed later in the chapter).
It was against the background of the emergence of these sorts of changes that Kashani (1996, pp. 8–10) conducted an international study of 220 managers with a view to identifying the challenges that marketing managers were facing, how these might best be met, and what the implications for marketing might be. The findings suggested that, in order of importance, the principal challenges were seen to be: 1. High and rising levels of competition across virtually all markets 2. Far higher levels of price competition 3. An increasing emphasis upon and need for customer service 4. A demand for higher levels of product quality 5. Higher rates of product innovation 6. Changing and less predictable customer need 7. The emergence of new market segments 8. The growing power of distribution channels 9. Growing environmental (‘green’) concerns 10. Increases in government regulations 11. European integration 12. Increasing advertising and promotional costs At the same time, there is now a far greater concern with the environment and a much greater awareness of the finite nature of many resources,
25
26 CHAPTER 1: Introduction
something that has led to the idea of the triple bottom line in which attention is paid not just to economic outcomes of marketing activity, but also to the social and environmental dimensions. It is this that, in turn, suggests that marketing has now reached the ‘age of consequences’. The increasing volatility of markets has also been referred to in a number of recent books, such as The State We’re In (Hutton, 1995), The End of Affluence (Madrick, 1995), The End of Work (Rivkin, 1995) and The Age of Turbulence (Greenspan, 2007), all of which argue that the developed Western economies are facing a major step-change in their fortunes as unemployment levels rise, deficits persist and purchasing power declines. There appear to be two major forces that are contributing to these changes. The first is globalization, which leads to an opening up of domestic markets and to the threat of low priced foreign entrants. The second contributory factor is that of the seemingly ever faster pace of technological change. Together these demand that managers have a far more detailed understanding not only of their current and potential markets and of their organization’s ability to capitalize upon the undoubted opportunities that exist, but also of the ways in which these threats might best be minimized; in essence, this is a case for marketers to recognize the fundamental need for their behaviour patterns to be what Ries and Trout (1986) discuss in terms of being faster, more focused and smarter. In the absence of this, an organization’s ability to compete is reduced dramatically. A broadly similar theme has been pursued by Ridderstråle and Nordström (2004) who, in their book Karaoke Capitalism, argue the case for the radically different approach of what they term ‘the hollow corporation’. They suggest that: A single corporate model has dominated business life for some 100 years – that of the vertically integrated company. This was a corporation where most activities were carried out internally. The firm made what it sold. This traditional model is crumbling. IT in general, and the Internet in particular, have ushered in a new age of information that has made markets more efficient and so shifted the advantage to those who play the markets most shrewdly. In essence, we have moved from a world of building to one of buying and the more non-core activities you place outside the firm, the higher the value you can generate. Amongst the techniques for doing this are the use of ‘white-labelling’ – the practice whereby a company supplying a product or service sells it to more than one distributor, with each one adding its own label before selling it to the end-user, and outsourcing. The net effect of this is the move on the part of an ever greater number of companies to being little more than a brand. However, it is the ‘brand carrier ’ which takes responsibility for developing and then delivering on the brand promise.
The Marketing/Strategy Interface
Amongst the examples of the organizations to have done this with enormous success that Ridderståle and Nordström cite are Dell, Ikea, Nike and Sony Ericsson: ‘If, for example, you buy a pair of trainers from Nike or a phone from Sony Ericsson, they are not actually made by Nike or Sony Ericsson, but the company that is selling to the final consumer has to accept responsibility for the entire chain.’ They go on to suggest that a modern company, is ‘like a Lego model. Once, activities and units were welded together. Today you can take them apart and move the pieces around.’ In making out the case for ‘Karaoke Capitalism’, the two authors have highlighted the way that although the boundaries of firms were always moved backwards and forwards, the boundaries today are moving more quickly, with more and more activities being shifted outside the corporation. These changes, Freedman (2004) has argued, are being driven by politics and technology, including the liberalization of international trade (the average level of tariffs in industrial countries is now less than a tenth of the level before the Second World War) and the growth of IT, with personal computers, the Internet and fibre-optic cables all being capable of transferring huge amounts of data at high speed and low cost. These factors, he suggests, have exposed companies to ever more global competition, putting ever more pressure on them to cut costs by outsourcing and offshoring, both of which have become ever easier, but which have significant implications for business behaviour. But, although the new market environment demands more innovative thinking and more creative ways of tackling the market, there are, in many organizations, significant barriers to this. These are illustrated in Figure 1.10. Given the nature of these opposing forces and of the likelihood of those on the right-hand side leading to a failure on the part of the organization to change, the marketing planner needs to focus upon a number of issues,
Forces for change The faster pace of technology New and more aggressive competitors Increased legislative demands Economic growth/decline The emergence of new market opportunities The globalization of markets
Forces against change Conservative management policies Managerial adherence to tired formulae Perceptions of risk Compromise solutions Resource implications Cultural paradigms Previous failures and mistakes
FIGURE 1.10 The conflicting environmental and organizational forces
27
28 CHAPTER 1: Introduction
including what Hamel and Prahalad (1994, pp. 49–71) refer to in terms of ‘learning to forget’. (This is an issue that is developed in detail in Chapter 11.) In arguing for this, they suggest that far too many managers, while acknowledging at an intellectual level the need for change, fail to accept it at an emotional level. In other words, while they are aware of the environmental changes taking place and accept the need to behave more proactively, they are often far too constrained by day-to-day pressures and resist the need for change. In order to overcome this myopia, Fisk (2006) makes a case for what he terms ‘smart marketing’ that is characterized by far clearer differentiation and more accurate targeting, whilst Wind (1996, p. 7) has argued that there needs to be a far greater emphasis upon being close to the customer, together with a far more fundamental recognition of the importance of customer satisfaction, the need for customer relationship building, an emphasis upon understanding customer value and the enhanced product offering, and that brand equity stems from a loyal customer base. The implications of what both Fisk and Wind suggest can be seen to be far-reaching, including the way in which marketing needs to be looked at from a pan-organizational perspective rather than from the far narrower departmental perspective that predominates in many organizations. In turn, this different approach demands a rethinking of an organization’s vision, objectives, strategies and structures, as well as of the sorts of skills that its staff need. In discussing this, Wind (1996, p. 7) argues that managers need to ask – and answer – 12 questions: 1. Is marketing and its focus on meeting and anticipating customers’ needs widely accepted as a business philosophy? 2. Are the business and corporate strategies focused on creating value for all the stakeholders? 3. Do the objectives include customer satisfaction and the creation of value? 4. Is the marketing function integrated with the other functions of the company as part of the key value-creating process? 5. Are the key marketing positions market segment (or key account) managers? 6. Are products viewed as part of an integrated product and service offering that delivers the desired benefit positioning for the target segment? 7. Is the marketing strategy global in its scope? 8. Is full use being made of market research and modelling in generating and evaluating marketing and market-driven business strategies?
The Marketing/Strategy Interface
9. Is there an emphasis upon information technology as an integral part of the organization’s marketing strategies? 10. Does a significant part of the marketing effort constitute innovative practices not previously used by the organization and its competitors? 11. Are strategic alliances for co-marketing activities being formed, and are marketing strategies based on the development of long-term relationships with clients? 12. Is there a sufficient focus of attention and resources upon message effectiveness (instead of media power) and value-based pricing (instead of discounting)? He goes on to argue that it is not enough just to answer ‘yes’ to these 12 questions, but that there is also a need to recognize the interrelationships between many of the questions and that the corporate vision and objectives must reflect a marketing orientation. This, in turn, highlights the critical importance of ensuring that the organizational architecture (this embraces the culture, structure, processes, technology, resources, people, performance measures and incentives) is focused upon the implementation of the new marketing paradigm. This paradigm, Wind suggests, can best be summed up in terms of building upon the historical role of marketing as the linkage between the organization and the environment, but that also focuses upon the 12 questions above, and which, in turn, has implications for marketing as: ■
The leading business philosophy
■
The knowledge and wisdom centre of the company that provides all organizational members with concepts and findings about customers and tools for measuring and forecasting customer behaviour and models and decision-support systems for improving the quality of marketing and business decisions
■
The growth engine that, through creative marketing strategies that utilize technology and mobilize the other business functions of the company, stimulates the top-line growth of the company.
Fisk’s view (2006) is that marketers need to start thinking and executing plans differently. Recognizing that what has worked in the past no longer necessarily works today demands different patterns of thinking and a much higher degree of innovation. In the case of communications, for example, he suggests that it involves moving from the communications free-for-all to an era of consent in which consumers and prospectors are asked how and when they want to talk to you.
29
30 CHAPTER 1: Introduction
Illustration 1.4
The Opposable Mind
Within the hotels business, traditional thinking over many years had led to the emergence of two main business models: large hotels whose economies of scale allowed them to provide business travellers with extra services, and small hotels that offered a greater degree of customer intimacy, but little else. The conventional wisdom was that in order to offer secretarial services, a variety of dining rooms and entertainment and meeting rooms, the hotel needed revenue from at least 1000 rooms. Isadore Sharpe, the founder of Four Seasons, recognized that many business travellers wanted intimacy and service. It was by bringing together the two seemingly contradictory business models that the Four Seasons strategy emerged. Equally, in 2000, when Procter & Gamble was losing market share to lower cost generic and own-store brands, views within the organization were polarized between those who wanted to cut costs and compete on price, and those who wanted to invest heavily in new products in order to compete on the basis of innovation and added value. The newly appointed Chief Executive, A.G. Lafley, pursued a strategy of outsourcing half of all new product development to small companies and laboratories, thereby cutting costs, but also getting the innovation needed. In the case of Red Hat, the largest supplier of Linux open-source software, the founder, Bob Young, questioned the industry views and succeeded by focusing upon the product, service levels and the quality of consulting to such a degree that large organizations decided that they could safely switch to Linux freeware from the more traditional and far more expensive suppliers such as Microsoft and Oracle. Source: How to Rise Above the Either/or Dilemma, R. Evans, Financial Times, 20 December 2007, p. 14.
The need for different patterns of thinking has also been highlighted by Martin (2007), who argues that too many strategists in the past have taken an either/or approach that has oversimplified the complexities of the world. What is required instead, he suggests, is a more integrative and advanced thought process that allows for contradictions to be embraced. In his book The Opposable Mind he pursues this idea and highlights the way in which success is increasingly based on an ability to reconcile contradictions and integrate possibly very different views, something that has been at the heart of the success in recent years of Four Seasons hotels, P&G, and Red Hat (refer to Illustration 1.4). Given the nature of these comments, it should be apparent that marketing is facing a series of fundamental challenges and that many planners are reappraising how marketing might best contribute to the overall management of an organization. As part of this debate, Figure 1.11 attempts to pull together the kinds of relationships that should or might realistically exist between marketing and other areas of a marketing organization. Within this there are several areas to which attention needs to be paid, but most obviously the characteristics of corporate management (the long-term
Corporate Management Lean head office staff A long-term perspective and a strong sense of vision An emphasis upon proactivity and the development of long-term relationships with suppliers, distributors and customers A culture of excellence Clear (and appropriate) core values Leadership rather than management Well-developed internal and external communication patterns A recognition that creativity is the only remaining competitive edge
Marketing
Design and Engineering
Purchasing
Production
A proactive competitive stance and an emphasis upon innovation and creativity
Rapid and constant product improvement
Zero or minimal inventory levels
Just in time and lean manufacturing
A policy of not compromising on quality
Zero defects and a culture of right first time, every time
An emphasis upon developing longterm relationships with a small number of high-quality suppliers
Zero set-up time
An emphasis upon creating and maintaining high levels of customer satisfaction by adding value and 'delighting' the customer A fundamental recognition of the need to build relationships with customers, suppliers, distributors and the media
Benchmarking inside and outside the industry Working with customers
Sales
The development of long-term relationships with distributors and customers
Customers
Fast and regular customer feedback marketing in order to close the loop
Aggressive value for money
Lateral thinking in the search for new ideas
Low financing changes A constant search for product, process and quality improvements
Customization offered where possible
Customization offered where possible A recognition of the need for effective customer process management Innovative segmentation, targeting and positioning A search for new markets and opportunities
An emphasis upon adding value and customer 'delight' Distinctive advertising and promotional appeals
A well-formulated pricing strategy and clear value for money offer Constant environmental analysis and interpretation
FIGURE 1.11 Marketing and its contribution to effective management
Working with customers to identify new leads and opportunities and how they might be met
An emphasis upon best practice
The Marketing/Strategy Interface
Detailed competitor and customer analysis with the results being fed into the strategy development process
Benchmarking inside and outside the industry
31
32 CHAPTER 1: Introduction
perspective, a sense of vision, clear values, proactive patterns of thought and behaviour, and so on), the process linkages between marketing and the other functions, and to the sorts of factors that characterize the effective management of each of the five functions identified.
Changing emphases within marketing As the part of the organization that interacts most directly and immediately with the environment, there is an obvious need for the marketing planner to investigate, analyse and respond to any environmental changes that are taking place. If this is not done – or if it is done only poorly – not only will opportunities be missed, but potential and emerging threats are also more likely to become actual threats, both of which will be reflected in a decline in performance. Because of this, the marketing planner needs to develop a clear vision of the future and of the ways in which the business environment is most likely to develop. In doing this, it is essential that the planner recognizes how patterns of marketing thinking are changing and how the organization might best come to terms with areas of growing importance. Recognizing this, we can identify a number of marketing priorities that marketers need to address: ■
As the pace of change increases, the speed of anticipation and response will become ever more important and time-based competition more essential
■
As markets fragment, so customization will become ever necessary. With expectations rising, quality will become one of the basic rules of competition (in other words, a ‘must have’) rather than a basis for differentiation
■
Information and greater market knowledge will provide a powerful basis for a competitive advantage
■
Sustainable competitive advantage will increasingly be based upon an organization’s core competences. The consequences of a lack of strategic focus will become more evident and more significant
■
As market boundaries are eroded, the need to think globally will become ever more necessary. In this way, the marketing planner will be able to offset temporary or permanent declines in one market against growing opportunities in another. At the same time, of course, the need to recognize the strategic significance of size and scale is increasing. However, in going for size, the marketing planner should not lose sight of the need for tailoring products and services to the specific demands of markets by thinking globally but acting locally
The Marketing/Strategy Interface
■
Differentiation will increasingly be based upon service
■
Partnerships with suppliers and distributors will become far more strategically significant
■
Strategic alliances will become more necessary as a means of entering and operating within markets, partly because they offer the advantages of access to greater or shared knowledge, but also because of the sharing of costs and risks
■
There will be a far greater emphasis upon product, service and process innovation
■
There will be a need to recognize the greater number and complexity of stakeholders’ expectations.
In turn, these marketing priorities have substantial implications for organizational structures and cultures. Doyle (1994, pp. 384–6), for example identified the 10 most obvious of these as being the need to: 1. Break hierarchies and reorganize around flatter structures 2. Organize around small(er) business units 3. Develop self-managing teams 4. Re-engineer 5. Focus upon developing networks and alliances 6. Move towards transactional forms of organization 7. Become a true learning organization 8. Emphasize account management in order to integrate specialist expertise across the organization for the benefit of the customer 9. Recognize the importance of ‘expeditionary marketing’ so that, instead of focusing upon what Hamel and Prahalad (1994) refer to as blockbuster innovation designed to get it right first time, the organization concentrates upon developing a stream of low cost fast-paced innovative products 10. Rethink the way in which the board of directors operates so that it focuses to a far greater extent upon strategic direction rather than control and day-to-day management.
Marketing and a shift of focus Many of the sorts of changes to which we have referred are reflected in the way in which we have seen a move from the sort of mass marketing that prevailed up until the mid-1970s, through just-in-time thinking and time-based competition, to the far greater emphasis today upon one-to-one
33
Prediction
Customers as groups
Customers as individuals
Mass marketing
One-to-one marketing
A focus upon predicting what customers want and then producing it
A focus upon customers as individuals and the proactive tailoring of solutions to meet individual needs
1950s–70s
1990s–2015
1970s–80s Responsiveness
Marketing’s primary emphasis
34 CHAPTER 1: Introduction
The tailoring of products and systems in response to market and technological changes
The tailoring of products and systems in response to group and individual customer needs
Just-in-time
Time-based competition
FIGURE 1.12 The shift from mass marketing to one-to-one marketing (adapted from Datamonitor Analysis, 1996)
marketing. This is illustrated in Figure 1.12. These changes are also reflected in Table 1.2 (see p. 36), which shows the emergence of different marketing paradigms, culminating in today’s paradigm of electronic marketing (the role of the Internet in marketing is discussed in greater detail in Chapter 11 of the book). Although the most obvious driver for this move towards the emerging paradigm of electronic marketing is the development of the technology itself, there are several underlying factors that have led analysts to question marketing practices and the need for a degree of rethinking. In 1993, for example, Coopers & Lybrand (as it then was) surveyed 100 companies and concluded that marketing departments were ‘ill focused and over-indulged’. In the same year, McKinsey released a report suggesting that ‘marketing departments have shown themselves to be “unimaginative”, generating “few new ideas”, and have simply stopped “picking up the right signals” … many consumer goods CEOs are beginning to think that marketing is no longer delivering’. A year later, Booz Allen Hamilton issued a report warning that ‘brand managers were failing to get to grips with commercial realities’.
Table 1.2 Marketing’s four paradigms: the shift from mass marketing to electronic marketing Mass marketing (traditional paradigm)
Target marketing (transitional paradigm)
Customer marketing (the new paradigm)
Electronic marketing (the emerging paradigm)
Key characteristics
Mass selling
Marketing segmentation
A focus upon key customers and database management
The Internet
Underlying assumptions and approaches
■
■
■
Consumers are satisfied with a standard product Resellers are used to reach the consumer Heavy advertisers will be successful
■
■
■
Markets consist of distinct and definable groups Success is gained from clear customer targeting and the development of a strong position within particular segments Targeting can be achieved through market analysis
■
■
■
■
Databases enable organizations to store and interrogate customer information to provide insight Performance is improved by focusing on individual’s needs The costs of customization are reducing all the time Technology now allows for direct marketing
■
■
■
Weaknesses and failings
■
■
A lack of focus and the subsequent waste of resources It ignores the demand for individual responses
■
■
■
■
■
‘Databases’ are often just lists of names and addresses rather than detailed customer profiles Database management and database mining skills are often more limited than is needed
■
Customers may be concerned about security
The Marketing/Strategy Interface
■
Large and profitable segments attract numerous players Customers shift from one segment to another and may belong to contradictory segments Segments may be illusory Some financial services organizations
Customer are more demanding, more discriminating and less loyal; they demand more information and are capable of processing this effectively Buyers want 24-hour access to develop a dialogue Markets are increasingly global in their nature
35
36 CHAPTER 1: Introduction
Given the nature of these (and other) comments, a number of marketing strategists have come to recognize the need for a far stronger and tighter focus upon customers, far better and more effective feedback systems, and a generally more strategic approach to customer management – something that has helped in this movement away from the traditional mass marketing paradigm.
So why do great companies fail? Long-term success is typically based on a combination of investment, innovation, the creation of value and – very importantly – a strong emphasis upon strategic management, something to which Ormerod (2006) refers in his book Why Most Things Fail. In his analysis of US firms, he points to the way in which only 33 of the top 100 firms in 1919 were still in the list 60 years later. Taking the US firms as a whole, the rate of extinction averages 10 per cent a year over a long period. Although ‘extinction’ includes both liquidations and mergers and it is often difficult to disentangle the two, Ormerod’s key point is that as independent entities, firms regularly disappear and that those that succeed in the long-term do so because of the quality of their strategies. However, the quality and consistency of strategic thinking in many organizations has been severely criticized over the past few years. De KareSilver (1997), for example, highlights two studies: one from the consulting firm Kalchas CSC Index, which suggested that ‘only one in ten companies had the information or insight needed to make truly worthwhile strategic decisions’; and one from Business Week (1996), which claimed that ‘only 6% of executives rated their company highly for long-term planning skills’. This led Hamel and Prahalad (1994) to suggest that in many organizations there is an inherent tension between their past and their future, which, unless it is addressed in a radical way, ultimately leads to the organization’s decline and failure. This is illustrated in Figure 1.13. In discussing this, de Kare-Silver (1997) suggests that those organizations that do manage to overcome this tension have several common features: ■
A clear sense of purpose and direction
■
Clearly articulated strategies
■
Continuous investment
■
A focus of resources and effort
■
A commitment to the long-term
■
A determination to overcome roadblocks
The Marketing/Strategy Interface
A successful track record of performance
Performance and success levels confirm the strategy
Few, if any, gaps between expectations and performance
Action and momentum become mistakes for market leadership
Management and stakeholders satisfaction with current performance levels
An ossification of thinking that leads to the failure to reinvest leadership
The inability to escape the past
The inability to invent the future
Resources become a substitute for creativity
A vulnerability to new rules
The emergence of the view that size and resources are the basis for success
Business practices and recipes become deeply etched in organizational practices and thinking
An accumulation of resources
Business systems are seen to be operating optimally
FIGURE 1.13 Escaping the past and inventing the future (adapted from Hamel and Prahalad, 1994)
■
A relentless focus on making their future
■
An emphasis on implementation.
In essence, he suggests they understand competitive advantage and what it takes to win. It is this sort of issue that effective strategic marketing planning is designed to address.
The four horsemen of the corporate apocalypse and the emergence of the neo-marketing organization Given what has been discussed so far within this chapter, it can be argued that there are two types of organization: those with a marketing department, and those with a marketing soul. Those with a marketing department tend to believe still that the business models and formulae that have worked well in the past will continue to work well in the future, despite the sorts of often radical changes that have affected and still are affecting the vast majority of markets. Those with a marketing soul can be seen to be those organizations in which the senior management team has recognized that the way in which marketing had for a long time been interpreted was far
37
38 CHAPTER 1: Introduction
too functional and far too limited. It is this that has led to the rise of what might be termed the neo-marketing organization. One of the first highly credible criticisms of marketing came from Brady and Davies (1993), two consultants working for the management consultancy McKinsey & Co. They argued that ‘doubts are surfacing about the very basis of contemporary marketing’. They went on to say that ‘costly brand advertising often dwells on seemingly irrelevant points of difference’ and that ‘marketing departments are often a millstone around an organization’s neck’. As evidence of this, they suggested that there were far too few examples of new marketing frameworks or fresh approaches: ‘Although the business environment has changed dramatically, marketers are simply not picking up the right signals any more.’ These views have subsequently been echoed by a number of other authors and commentators (see, for example, Brannan, 1993; Thomas, 1994). A number of factors appear to have conspired to have invalidated traditional patterns of marketing thought, the four most significant of which were the saturation of numerous markets, globalization, market fragmentation, and corporate downsizing. Referred to by Brown (1995) as the four horsemen of the corporate apocalypse, he argues that, if organizations are to cope effectively with these pressures, there is the need for a neo-marketing approach, characterized by four key dimensions that together help to create a far more customer-centric and competitive organization: 1. A far stronger corporate philosophy in which emphasis is given to ‘treat(ing) each customer as if they are the only one’. 2. The much greater and more effective use of teams from across the organization, with these teams having to meet specific targets such as the development of a new brand for an emerging segment or the re-launch of a product line. Having achieved the objectives, the team then disbands. Clusters therefore form, break and reform on a regular basis in order to move in time with the rhythm of the market. 3. The better use of alliances in areas such as R&D, so that knowledge can be shared more effectively and mutual advantage can be gained through corporate symbiosis. 4. IT-driven thinking that provides a far greater insight into customers’ patterns of thinking and behaviour, and helps to overcome the confusion caused by market fragmentation and saturation. By using information technology strategically, the marketing planner gains a far greater understanding of buying habits, cross-brand elasticities, marketing sensitivities and market structures, and in this way can raise barriers to entry and move further towards ‘owning the customer ’.
Summary
1.6
SUMMARY
This chapter has sought to offer some ideas constituting a framework for the rest of the book. We began by considering the nature of management and of the management process. The process is often characterized in the following stages: ■
Planning
■
Decision-making
■
Control.
These are related to a series of questions: ■
Where are we now?
■
Where do we want to be?
■
How might we get there?
■
Which way is best?
■
How can we ensure arrival?
In this book we focus very largely on the first two of these questions. Strategy can be seen as a normative matter concerning what an organization would like to achieve. As such, it: ■
Guides the organization in its relationship with its environment
■
Affects the internal structure and processes of the organization
■
Centrally affects the organization’s performance.
Marketing, via its policies and programmes relating to product, price, service, distribution and communications, can provide the means to facilitate the attainment of a strategy. The extent to which the strategy is achieved provides a measure of the organization’s effectiveness. Any organization’s effectiveness depends upon the balance between what is desired and what is achieved on the one hand, and paying due regard to the requirements of all stakeholders, whether internal or external, on the other. It is through the process of organizational control that managers seek to achieve organizational effectiveness, and this gives a reference point for all that follows. However, it should be apparent from what has been discussed within this chapter that marketing is undergoing a series of significant changes and that this is being reflected in the ways in which the subject is defined. If, though, marketing is to succeed, it must offer the customer a clear and meaningful value proposition. In the absence of this, marketing is of little value. Recognizing this, we can contrast what might loosely be called the traditional physical product sequence
39
40 CHAPTER 1: Introduction
of ‘make the product and sell the product’, with the value delivery sequence that is based on a clear understanding of what value means to the customer and which then reflects the idea of ‘choose the value, provide the value and communicate the value’. It is this theme that provides the basis for much of what is said in the subsequent chapters.
CHAPTER 2
Strategic Marketing Planning and the Marketing Plan
2.1
LEARNING OBJECTIVES
When you have read this chapter you should understand: (a) the nature and purpose of strategic planning; (b) the ten schools of strategic thinking; (c) the dimensions of effective planning; (d) the pros and cons of marketing planning; (e) the structure of the marketing plan.
2.2
INTRODUCTION
Within this chapter we focus upon the nature of strategic marketing planning and the development of the marketing plan. In doing this we concentrate initially upon patterns of thinking in strategic management and then, against this background, on the nature and structure of the marketing plan. However, before doing this it is worth remembering a comment that is made in Alice in Wonderland: If you don’t know where you are going, any road will get you there. It is for this reason that we argue throughout this chapter for a clarity of thinking about the organization’s environment, managerial objectives, organizational capabilities, the nature of any constraints that exist, and indeed anything else that impinges upon the process of effective planning and implementation. Strategic Marketing Planning Copyright © 2009 Colin Gilligan and Richard M.S. Wilson. All rights reserved.
41
42 CHAPTER 2: Strategic Marketing Planning and the Marketing Plan
2.3 THE ROLE OF STRATEGIC MARKETING PLANNING Strategic marketing planning is typically seen to be concerned with the definition of marketing objectives and how over, say, a three- to five-year period, these objectives might best be achieved. There is, however, a substantial body of admittedly largely anecdotal evidence to suggest that, although a majority of businesses have plans, these are often used primarily to control spending. Largely because of the rate of environmental change over the past 10 years, there has also been a growing cynicism about formal planning, with many of its detractors arguing that, in a volatile environment, there is little to be gained from planning since both the underlying assumptions and the plan itself are quickly invalidated. It is also often argued that plans frequently suffer from a lack of realism, stifle creativity, lead to a degree of inflexibility in terms of dealing with the unexpected, and frequently give the illusion of control. (These points are discussed in greater detail at a later stage in this chapter.) However, this misses the point, since the process of planning is often as important as the plan itself. The essential value of the planning process is that it forces the planning team to question assumptions, tests the rigour of the team’s thinking, and provides an opportunity to rehearse the future. In order to plan more effectively, the team therefore needs to use the corporate, divisional or brand vision as a guiding star, and to view planning as a learning process rather than as an exercise in control.
Strategy and planning The strategic marketing planning process is concerned with the development of strategies that are based on the planning team’s assessment of the market and perceptions of managerial expectations and organizational capability. However, before we examine the detail of the marketing planning process, it is worth recognizing that strategy and planning are probably two of the most overworked and misunderstood words in the management lexicon. Given this, we need to clarify what is meant by strategy (a number of definitions of strategy appear in Illustration 2.1).
Mintzberg and Strategy For Mintzberg (1987), strategy is concerned with five Ps: 1. Planning, which deals with the direction of the organization 2. Ploys, which are designed to deal with and outwit the competition 3. Patterns, which represent a logical stream of actions 4. Position, which relates to how the organization is located in the market place 5. Perspectives, which reflect the management team’s view of the world.
The Role of Strategic Marketing Planning
Illustration 2.1
Defining strategy
Over the past 50 years a considerable amount has been written about strategy, and from this a variety of definitions and strategic perspectives have emerged. However, one of the first to discuss strategy in a structured way was the Chinese General Sun Tzu (1963), who, in his book The Art of War, suggested that it was better to overcome one’s enemies by wisdom rather than by force alone: One should appraise a war first of all in terms of five fundamental factors and make comparisons of various conditions of the antagonistic sides in order to assess the outcome. The first of the fundamental factors is politics; the second, weather; the third, terrain; the fourth, the commander; and the fifth, doctrine.
One of the first of the more recent writers to define strategy was Drucker (1955), who described it as the answer to two fundamental questions: What is our business, and What should it be? Following on from this, Chandler (1962) described strategy as: the determination of the basic long-term goals and objectives of an enterprise and the adoption of courses of action and the allocation of resources necessary for carrying out these goals.
Although Johnson, Scholes & Whittington (2008) argue against giving a definition of strategy on the grounds that all too often such definitions lead to overly long discussions about the semantics, they suggest that strategy is: the direction and scope of an organization over the long term: ideally, which matches its resources to its changing environment and in particular its markets, customers or clients so as to meet stakeholder expectations.
An alternative approach has been proposed by Stacey (2007), who argues that only rarely is strategy the deliberate set of actions that most writers suggest, and that it is instead a far more organic approach: there is a strong tendency to slip into talking about it as a response that ‘the organization’ makes to ‘an environment’. When we do that, we depersonalize the game and unwittingly slip into understanding it in mechanical terms, where one ‘thing’ moves in predetermined ways in relation to another ‘thing’. The inevitable result is lack of insight into the real complexities of strategic management because in reality organizations and their environments are not things, one adapting to other, but groupings of people interacting one with another.
He goes on to suggest that there are, in essence, eight different types of strategy: 1. Planned strategies, which represent a series of deliberate and precise intentions 2. Entrepreneurial strategies, which emerge as the result of a personal vision 3. Ideological strategies, which reflect the collective vision of the management team
43
44 CHAPTER 2: Strategic Marketing Planning and the Marketing Plan
4. Process strategies, which result from the leadership controlling the process 5. Umbrella strategies, which emerge from a set of broad objectives set by the leadership 6. Disconnected strategies, as the result of sub-units being only loosely connected 7. Consensus strategies, where members converge on patterns 8. Imposed strategies, where the external environment or a parent company dictates patterns of action. The extent to which a strategy (be it planned, entrepreneurial or any of the others identified by Mintzberg) is achieved is determined to a large extent by the ways in which organizational resources are managed; something that is achieved through the business and marketing planning process. The arguments in favour of planning are straightforward, and include: ■
Organizations must plan to coordinate their activities
■
Organizations must plan to ensure the future is taken into account
■
Organizations must plan to be rational
■
Organizations must plan to control.
In practice, however, planning frequently encounters a series of problems, the eight most critical of which were highlighted by Richardson and Richardson (1989): 1. How best to identify and manage organizational stakeholders 2. How to anticipate long(er)-term futures and develop the most appropriate product or market portfolio in order to leverage competitiveness 3. How to plan for things that might foreseeably go wrong with mainstream plans 4. How to manage product and market ‘dreams’ into reality 5. How to seek out major cost-cutting and contribution-creating opportunities and make the required changes to enhance productivity 6. How to create a responsive team culture whereby resources come together to meet changing market conditions and heighten customer satisfaction 7. How to create a base for innovation and then to harness the ability of the enterprise to change effectively its products, services and processes
The Role of Strategic Marketing Planning
8. How to make the most of unexpected opportunities and respond positively to shock events.
Perspectives on strategic thinking In discussing current thinking on strategy and how strategic perspectives have developed, Mintzberg et al. (1998) suggest that: we are all like the blind man and the strategy process is our elephant. Everyone has seized some part or other of the animal and ignored the rest. Consultants have generally gone for the tusks, while academics have preferred to take photo safaris, reducing the animal to two dimensions. As a consequence, managers have been encouraged to embrace one narrow perspective or another – like the glories of planning or the wonders of core competencies. Unfortunately, the process will only work for them when they deal with the entire beast as a living organism. To illustrate this, Mintzberg has identified ten views of the strategy process and how they have developed; these are summarized in Table 2.1.
Table 2.1
A summary of the ten schools of strategic thinking (adapted from Mintzberg et al., 1998)
School
Advocates
Key themes and characteristics
The Design School
Selznick
Strategy development focuses very largely upon matching internal strengths and weaknesses with external opportunities and threats. Clear and simple strategies are developed by senior managers as the result of detailed and conscious thought and are then communicated to others further down the organizational hierarchy
The Planning School
Ansoff
In many ways similar to the Design School, the Planning School is based on a series of formal and distinct steps characterized by checklists and frameworks. Highly cerebral and formal in its nature, it is typically driven by staff planners rather than senior managers as the key players
The Positioning School
Porter
Based firmly upon the work of writers such as Michael Porter, the Planning School emerged from earlier work on strategic positioning by organizations such as the Boston Consulting Group and the PIMS researchers, and reflects thinking on military strategy and the ideas of Sun Tzu (1963). Strategy is ‘reduced’ to a series of generic positions that are chosen as the result of formal analyses of industry situations. Planning is seen to be a highly analytical process, with emphasis being placed upon hard data. Amongst the frameworks to have emerged from the planning school are strategic groups, value chains, and game theories
The Entrepreneurial School
Schumpeter
The Entrepreneurial School gives emphasis to the role of the chief executive, with strategies being based not so much upon detailed designs, plans, positions and framework, but upon visions of the future and the organization’s place within this. A key element of the school is the argument that all organizations need a visionary leader (Continued)
45
46 CHAPTER 2: Strategic Marketing Planning and the Marketing Plan
Table 2.1 Continued School
Advocates
Key themes and characteristics
The Cognitive School
March and Simon
The Cognitive School is concerned not so much with the type or nature of strategy as with the mental processes that underpin any strategy that emerges. Areas of particular emphasis have proved to be cognitive biases and aspects of information processing
The Learning School
Cyert and March; Hamel and Prahalad
With its origins in the ideas of incrementalism (a series of small steps rather than any large one), venturing and emergent strategy (strategy grows from a series of individual decisions rather than as the result of a tightly defined process), strategy development is seen to take place at all levels within the organization. There is an emphasis upon retrospective sensemaking (‘we act in order to think as much as we think in order to act’) and a belief that strategy formulation and implementation are interlinked
The Power School
Allinson (micro) and Pfeiffer et al. (macro)
Seen by many to be a relatively minor school, the Power School gives emphasis to the idea that strategy making stems from power. This power can be seen both at a micro-level in that strategy emerges as a result of politicking between organizational actors, and at a macro-level in terms of external alliances, joint ventures and network relations
The Cultural School
Rhenman; Normann
Whereas the power school concentrates on self-interest and fragmentation, the cultural school is based on a common interest, with strategy development being seen as a social process rooted in the organizational culture. One of the most influential forces in the thinking in this area proved to be the impact of Japanese management in the 1970s and 1980s, as it became evident that difficult-to-copy cultural factors could contribute to competitive advantage
The Environmental School
Hannan and Freeman; Pugh
Whereas much thinking on strategy rests upon how the organization uses its degrees of freedom to develop strategy, the Environmental School focuses upon the significance and implications of demands placed upon the organization by the environment. Included within this is ‘contingency thinking’, in which consideration is given to the responses expected of the organization as the result of specific environmental conditions, and ‘population ecology’, which argues that there are significant constraints upon strategic choice
The Configuration School
Chandler; Mintzberg et al.; Miles and Snow
Seen by many to be a more extensive and integrative school of thought than those referred to above, this is characterized both by the view that the organization is a configuration of coherent clusters of characteristics and behaviours, and by the belief that change must be seen as a dramatic transformation
In practice, of course, managers are unlikely to adhere to the views and perspectives of any single school because, as Mintzberg et al. (1998) suggest: these people have to deal with the entire beast of strategy formation, not only to keep it as a vital force but also to impart real energy to the strategic process. The greatest failings of strategic management have occurred when managers took one point of view too seriously. This field had its obsession with planning. Then came generic positions based on careful calculations, now it is learning, and
The Role of Strategic Marketing Planning
doubtless other perspectives, waiting in the wings, will be greeted with similar enthusiasm before making their exit. A categorization of approaches to strategy formulation has also been proposed by Whittington (1993), who has suggested that there are four principal or generic approaches to strategy formulation: 1. The classical approach 2. The evolutionary approach 3. The processual approach 4. The systemic approach. A summary of these four approaches appears in Table 2.2. The significance of these four approaches – and indeed the differences between them – needs to be understood in some detail by the reader, since the way in which the organization views strategy and the strategy-making process has significant implications for the way in which the marketing strategist goes about the development of marketing strategy. Perhaps the most obvious of these implications can be seen in terms of whether emphasis is placed largely upon a deliberate or an emergent strategy. In commenting upon this, Mintzberg (1994, pp. 24–5) suggests that: intentions that are fully realized can be called deliberate strategies. The literature of planning recognizes both cases, with an obvious preference for the former. What it does not recognize is the third case, which we call emergent strategy, where a realized pattern was not expressly intended. Actions were taken, one by one, which converged in time in some sort of consistency or pattern. For example, rather than pursuing a strategy (read plan) of diversification, a company simply makes diversification decisions one by one, in effect testing the market. First it buys an urban hotel with restaurant, and then another of these, etc., until the strategy (pattern) of diversifying into urban hotels with restaurants finally emerges. As implied earlier, few, if any, strategies can be purely deliberate, and few can be purely emergent. One suggests no learning, the other, no control. All real world strategies need to mix these in some way – to attempt to control without stopping the learning process. Organizations, for example, often pursue what may be called umbrella strategies: the broad outlines are deliberate while the details are allowed to emerge within them. Thus emergent strategies are not necessarily bad and deliberate ones good; effective strategies mix these characteristics in ways that reflect the conditions at hand, the ability to predict as well as the need to react to unexpected events.
47
48 CHAPTER 2: Strategic Marketing Planning and the Marketing Plan
Table 2.2
The four generic approaches to strategy formulation
Approach
Advocates
Key themes and characteristics
The classical approach
Ansoff; Sloan and Porter
The essential underpinning is economic theory, with its advocates arguing that profit maximization is an important objective and that the strategist’s task is to position the organization or business unit in such a way that this can be achieved. Rigorous intellectual analysis represents an essential input to the process, and is designed to contribute to the organization achieving a degree of control over the internal and external environment
The evolutionary approach
Henderson (of the Boston Consulting Group); Friedman; Peters
Similar in a number of ways to the Classical School of thought, strategy evolutionists differ in that they believe that because the strategist cannot control the environment, the idea of a single strategy route is inappropriate. Instead, they argue, the planner needs to recognize the options open to the organization and keep these options open for as long as possible. Its advocates also argue that because large organizations are inherently slow and inflexible, the notion of an all-embracing strategy is unrealistic. In turn, this leads to a belief that long-term strategies can often be counterproductive and that higher levels of long-term performance can often be achieved by a sense of fast-moving, short-term cost-reduction processes. In discussing this, Fifield (1998, p. 9) summarizes a key theme in terms of ‘In a competitive market place the organization should launch as many small initiatives as possible and see what works. The competitive processes inherent in the market place should then allow the best initiatives to flourish and an overall strategy should begin to emerge as a pattern from the market place. In this way, we can see that the idea is that the market dictates the strategy, not the manager’
The processual approach
Mintzberg; Hamel
This pattern of thought can be seen to have emerged from the Evolutionary School, and is based on the idea that a worthwhile strategy can only emerge as the result of the strategist’s detailed involvement in the day-to-day activities of the business. They recognize that the environment is too powerful and unpredictable for the strategist to overcome or manage it purely on the basis of intellectual analysis and that – unlike the evolutionists – markets are not sufficiently or inherently efficient to allow for performance maximization. Given that organizations represent a collection or coalition of individuals and interests, goals – and strategy – emerge as the result of a bargaining process. They believe strongly that planning and implementation need to be firmly interlinked, and that the classical school’s ideas of strong central corporate planning departments are of little value. Mintzberg in particular believes that (effective) strategy involves a series of small steps that then coalesce into a pattern, and that the key to high(er) performance is an emergent rather than a deliberate strategy. This view is also based firmly upon the idea that in the absence of the right competencies, strategy and plans are to all intents meaningless
The systemic approach
Whittington; Morgan
This reflects a belief that there is no one strategy model that is applicable to all types of organization, but that both the objectives and the strategy process are the result of the strategist’s social and cultural backgrounds and of the social context in which they are operating. This view gives emphasis to the way in which strategy and the strategy process are not necessarily objective and rational but, particularly in multinational corporations (MNCs), are a reflection of an amalgam of possibly very different forces that have their origins in social systems. The most obvious ways in which these differences are manifested within an MNC include attitudes to profit, risk, group versus individual decision-making, levels of accountability, timescales and indeed the notion of the free market. Advocates of the systemic school argue that a focus upon implementation is essential and that this is significantly influenced by organizational sociology
So What is Marketing Strategy?
2.4
SO WHAT IS MARKETING STRATEGY?
At its simplest, strategy means knowing where you want to go and then deciding upon how best to get there. Strategic marketing can therefore be distilled down to the planner deciding – with complete clarity – in which markets the organization wants (or is able) to compete, and then how exactly it will do this (see Figure 2.1). Given this, an effective marketing strategy can be seen to be based upon four key dimensions: 1. Being close to the market 2. Developing valid assumptions about environmental trends and market behaviour 3. Exploiting the competencies of the organization 4. Developing a realistic basis for gaining and sustaining competitive advantage. A slight variation on this, which reflects the ‘three Cs’ of marketing strategy, is illustrated in Figure 2.2. An organization’s marketing strategy is not developed in isolation; instead it needs to be developed against the background of and within the constraints imposed by the organization’s overall corporate plan. There is therefore a cascade process, with the marketing strategy emerging from the corporate strategy, and the marketing plan and tactics then emerging from the marketing strategy. An integral part of any marketing strategy is the competitive strategy. In other words, how – in detail – will the organization compete within the market place? Although there are numerous dimensions to any competitive strategy (many of which are discussed in detail in later chapters), competitive strategy at its most extreme can be seen to be about being better than the competition in every function and at every level. The reality for many organizations is often very different, since the organizational culture and overall level of
What customer solutions will we offer?
What are the bases of our competitive advantage?
Which markets do we intend competing in? (and, equally importantly, which markets do we not want to compete in?)
FIGURE 2.1 The key dimensions of marketing strategy
With which products and services?
49
50 CHAPTER 2: Strategic Marketing Planning and the Marketing Plan
In developing the strategic marketing plan, the strategist needs to take as one of the starting points the analysis of the three Cs of strategy: Customers, Competitors and Capabilities. Customers: Who are they? When, where and how do they buy? What motivates them? How is the market currently segmented? How might it be segmented? Competitors: Who are they? What strategies are they pursuing? What are their strengths and weaknesses? What are their areas of vulnerability? How are they most likely to develop over the next few years? Capabilities: What are the organization’s relative strengths and weaknesses in each of the market segments in which it is operating? What levels of investment are available? How might the capabilities best be leveraged?
FIGURE 2.2
The three Cs of marketing strategy
capability prevent this. (See Illustration 2.2 in which we discuss the idea of organizational DNA.) However, regardless of capability, the strategic marketing planning process needs to begin with the identification of key issues, both externally and internally. Externally, these include the general environment, the markets, customers and competitors. Internally, the key issues are both real (e.g. budgetary or production constraints) and imaginary or artificial (e.g. an attitude of ‘we can’t do it that way ’ or ‘it just wouldn’t work’). Having identified these key issues, the next step is their analysis, followed by the strategy and action plans, and then implementation, monitoring, control and feedback (see Figure 2.3). The approach that is reflected in Figure 2.3 can be termed a logical, sequential and rational approach to planning, in that it is based on a highly structured view of how an organization operates. In practice, the planning process is often far less structured. Stacey, for example, whose work is based on chaos theories of management that reflect his view that strategy is a far more dynamic and unpredictable process than is typically acknowledged, has argued for a far more organic approach to strategy and planning. Here, however, we focus largely upon a structured approach to thinking about the process of marketing planning and implementation. An alternative framework for thinking about strategy is illustrated in Figure 2.4. Here, the core organizational values and defining competencies drive the core purpose of the business and, in turn, the vision or what we have labelled ‘the Olympic goal’. Strategies and action plans then emerge from this, with areas such as operational efficiency, the organizational structure, people, and customer service all being aspects of the implementation process. This is then developed in greater detail in Figure 2.5, which explores how the organization might achieve its objective.
So What is Marketing Strategy?
The identification of key external and internal issues
The analysis and evaluation of opportunities, capabilities and gaps
Strategy planning and the leveraging of resources
Action/tactical planning
Implementation, performance monitoring and control
Feedback
FIGURE 2.3 The strategic marketing planning process
The core organizational values, e.g. Market leadership Customer satisfaction Innovation
The core purpose (why the organization exists) The Olympic goal or vision that acts as the key organizational objective and driver for the next 5–10 years
The defining competencies, e.g. Size and scale Organizational infrastructure An emphasis upon excellence Customer focus New product development
Strategies and action plans (how to get there)
Customer service and customer delight
People and behaviour
Profitable growth
The facilitating organizational structure
Operational efficiency
FIGURE 2.4 The Olympic goal as the driver for strategic marketing planning
However, despite all the attention that has been paid to strategy and to the factors that influence it, the reader needs to recognize that an organization cannot really claim to have a strategy if it simply carries out many of the same activities as its competitors, but only a little better. If it does this, it is merely operationally more efficient. An organization can only really claim to have a robust strategy when major points of difference exist between what it is doing and what its competitors are doing. In the absence of this, the organization runs the risk of a self-inflicted vulnerability and of falling into the trap of action without strategy.
51
Satisfy and delight our customers and build our reputations by:
Develop the organizational structure that will help us to meet customers’ needs profitability. To create competitive advantage we will be:
Flexible and attuned to the developing needs of the market
Focused on customers needs
Aware of the ways in which capabilities can be leveraged
Getting closer to our customers
Delivering superb products and services that will match/exceed customers’ expectations
Demonstrating in everything that we do that customers are really important
In doing this we will:
Change the rules of competition
Get better at our core business by
Doing things better
Doing better things
Change the supply side dynamics
Develop and exploit new opportunities
Leverage our capabilities
Communicate clearly and consistently
As part of this we will focus upon:
People and behaviour
Operating efficiency
Strive to be world class
FIGURE 2.5
Learn from best practice
Re-engineer
Developing and implementing strategies
Use technology creatively
Live the brand values
Challenge conventional wisdoms
52 CHAPTER 2: Strategic Marketing Planning and the Marketing Plan
To achieve our objectives we will:
So What is Marketing Strategy?
In discussing this, Neilson and Pasternack (2005) of the consultants Booz Allen Hamilton develop the concept of organizational DNA which, they suggest, is one of the primary determinants of performance. In essence, they argue, there are seven organizational types, only three of which are healthy (refer to Illustration 2.2). The implications of these profiles for planning and, more importantly, for implementation are significant and highlight the ways in which, despite the attention that might be paid to a planning process, if the underlying DNA of the business is unhealthy, little that is different or meaningful is likely to be achieved. Instead, the organization simply zig-zags towards the land of the lost.
Illustration 2.2
Planning and the significance of organizational DNA
In their book Results: Keep What’s Good, Fix What’s Wrong and Unlock Great Performance, Neilson and Pasternack (2005) use the Booz Allen Hamilton DNA profiling tool (see www.orgdna.com) to identify seven types of organization, three of which are healthy and in which planning – and implementation – work effectively. In the other four, a host of factors, including political infighting, a lack of focus and multiple layers of management, conspire to create an environment in which little is likely to be achieved (refer to Figure 2.6). Depressingly, their research suggests that 60% of businesses fall into this category.
The healthy DNA profiles … The military organization: Typically driven (hard) by a small and focused senior leadership team, it succeeds as a result of a well-thought-out and superior business model and superior execution. The resilient organization: Sensitive to the market and sufficiently flexible to cope with these changes, the management team has a clear focus upon the strategy and its implementation. The just-in-time organization: Although it suffers from a degree of inconsistency, there is typically a clear understanding of what is needed to succeed and a high degree of flexibility that allows it to meet market demands. And the unhealthy DNA profiles … The out-grown organization: With strategies, structures, systems and processes more suited to an earlier phase in its life, the outgrown organization often has its decision-making concentrated in the hands of a small number of managers who are increasingly out of touch both with the market and what this demands of the organization. The over-managed organization: Characterized by high levels of bureaucracy, a highly political environment and too many layers of management, the organization typically suffers from paralysis by analysis. The passive-aggressive organization: Although strategies and plans are developed without argument, the organization then struggles with their implementation. The fits-and-starts organization: Typically staffed with large numbers of talented and motivated managers, they rarely agree on the direction of the business.
FIGURE 2.6 The seven types of organizational DNA
53
54 CHAPTER 2: Strategic Marketing Planning and the Marketing Plan
2.5 THE THREE DIMENSIONS OF PLANNING According to Piercy (2002, p. 586) the strategic marketing planning process consists of three principal and interrelated dimensions: 1. An analytical dimension, which is concerned with a series of techniques, procedures, systems and planning models 2. A behavioural dimension, which relates to the nature and extent of the participation, motivation and commitment from members of the management team 3. An organizational dimension, which is concerned with information flows, structures, processes, management style and culture. The effectiveness of the planning process – and hence the ultimate value of the plan – is therefore determined by the way in which these three dimensions are managed. Where, for example, there is a culture in which there is little openness, creativity or involvement from staff across marketing and other parts of the business, the value of any analysis and planning is likely to be reduced dramatically. Equally, if the organizational dimension inhibits information flows and/or an emphasis upon implementation, again the value of the planning process and the plan is reduced. However, although planning has an inherent and logical attraction (a summary of the most commonly claimed benefits of marketing planning appear in Figure 2.7), the reality in many organizations is that the planning process is often managed relatively badly. In attempting to explain why this is so, a variety of issues have been highlighted. Piercy (2002, pp. 583–5), for example, argues that there are ten principal planning pitfalls. These include: 1. An emphasis upon analysis rather than planning, which leads to managers becoming preoccupied with tools and techniques rather than thinking creatively about objectives, positioning and strategy 2. Information instead of decisions, where there is a constant demand for ever more information before decisions are taken 3. Incrementalism, which leads to this year’s plan being an often minor development of what has gone before rather than something that raises fundamental questions about issues of capability, objectives and markets 4. Vested interests, which lead to an emphasis upon maintaining the status quo and the safeguarding of empires and budgets 5. An organizational mindset, which refuses to accept plans that move away from the well-accepted and the well-rehearsed approaches of the past
The Three Dimensions of Planning
Amongst the most frequently claimed benefits of marketing plans and marketing planning are that: 1. The process of planning encourages or forces managers to think ahead and to examine in detail how the environment may develop and where opportunities and threat exist or might come from 2. Following on from this, the planning process leads managers to think in detail about organizational capabilities, priorities, objectives and policies 3. If clearly and realistically developed, the objectives that emerge from the planning process provide the basis for the development of performance standards and the more effective control of the organization 4. Plans should lead to a better co-ordination of company efforts and the more effective utilization of assets 5. By thinking about the future, managers should be better prepared for any unexpected environmental developments 6. By being involved in the development of the plan, managers should feel a (greater) sense of ownership and have a better understanding of their responsibilities and what is expected of them.
FIGURE 2.7 The benefits of marketing planning
6. A general resistance to change amongst members of the management team 7. Little ownership of the plans and a corresponding absence of commitment 8. Inadequate resourcing of the plan 9. A focus upon planning per se rather than planning and implementation 10. A diminishing interest in the plan as a result of its not having been taken seriously in the past and a general shift towards planning simply becoming an annual, time-consuming, irksome and essentially pointless ritual. The pitfalls and difficulties of marketing planning have also been highlighted by McDonald (2007), who has suggested that the ten most common barriers to (effective) marketing planning are: 1. A confusion between marketing tactics and marketing strategy, and an emphasis upon the easier and more predictable short-term issues and performance at the expense of those that are more complex and uncertain long term
55
56 CHAPTER 2: Strategic Marketing Planning and the Marketing Plan
2. A separation of the marketing function from day-to-day operations, with the result that plans are developed without the immediacy of contact with the market 3. A confusion between marketing as a function and marketing as a far broader business concept; the implications of this are seen most obviously in terms of marketing being seen to be synonymous with sales, or advertising, or customer service, rather than as the driving organizational philosophy 4. Organizational barriers that lead to company activities being structured around functional activities rather than customer groups 5. A lack of detailed analysis, and an emphasis instead upon preconceptions and conventional wisdoms 6. A confusion between process and output; something that is manifested most obviously in terms of models such as SWOT being seen as an end in themselves rather than as the basis for providing real insight to issues of capability 7. A lack of knowledge and skills 8. The lack of a systematic approach to planning and a reliance instead upon something that is rather more ad hoc 9. The failure to prioritize objectives on the basis of their impact upon the organization, their urgency and their implications for resources 10. Hostile corporate cultures that lead to marketing and, by extension, marketing planning being viewed as less important than other parts of the business. Given the nature of these comments, it would seem that planning rarely works as well as it should. However, at an intellectual level, few managers would argue against the notion of planning. Instead, it is the way in which planning is often practised that appears to create problems. Recognizing this, the marketing planner needs to think in detail about how the planning process – and therefore the plans – might be improved. However, before doing this, it is worth thinking about four observations made by Giles (1995): 1. Better planning does not invariably lead to better implementation 2. Over-sophistication hinders ownership of the plan 3. Ownership tends to make implementation work, irrespective of the strategy 4. Sophistication follows ownership and implementation.
The Three Dimensions of Planning
Managing the marketing planning process (effectively) If you buy into a strategy, you have to buy into the consequences of that strategy. (Anon) In the light of what has been said so far, it should be apparent that, if the planning process is to be effective, it is not simply a case of imposing a planning structure upon members of the marketing team. Instead, there is the need to demonstrate, first, that planning is a living and meaningful process, and secondly, that the plan is designed to be a working document – in other words, it is designed to be something that is used on a day-to-day basis to guide and inform decisions. Recognizing this, we can identify a number of initial guidelines: ■
The planning format needs to be standardized so that managers across the business are familiar with the process and structure
■
There needs to be an inbuilt flexibility so that, as the external environment changes, the plan can be modified to reflect these changes
■
The plan needs to be based upon opportunity-oriented and strategic thinking rather than simply being a reiteration of what has gone before
■
The priorities and strategy should not be hidden in the detail of the plan, but should instead be immediately apparent.
In addition, the planner needs to think about how to improve levels of commitment and support to the planning process. Some of the ways in which this might be done are examined at a later stage, although at this point it is worth referring to Figure 2.8, in which we show the five levels of commitment and support that typically exist.
The lost art of planning and strategy The implications of a poorly-developed and poorly-implemented approach to planning have been spelled out by a variety of writers, including de Kare-Silver (1997) who, in his book Strategy in Crisis, suggested that many companies have lost the art of planning and strategy-making. They spend too much time, he argues, looking inward at process change, organization and systems, and do not allocate enough time or effort to planning their future, determining where they want to be in their markets, and how they are going to beat competitors. In these circumstances, he suggests, planning processes are typically reduced to annual form-filling and extrapolating numbers without any serious debate about the future. In making this comment, he points to a variety of studies and statements from senior managers: Only 20 per cent of CEOs surveyed put strategy as their starting point in building their company … As few as 6 per cent of business people in the United States would rate their company excellent at planning for the long-term future … We don’t have a strategy, what’s the point when the world is so uncertain?
57
58 CHAPTER 2: Strategic Marketing Planning and the Marketing Plan
Compliance and an involvement with the plan
An overt opposition to the plan and the planning process
A growing enthusiasm for the planning process and a recognition of its strategic and tactical value
A commitment to ownership of the planning process and a fundamental recognition of its strategic and tactical value
A general and often unspecific resistance to the plan
FIGURE 2.8 The ladder of planning commitment and support (adapted from Jobber, D. (2004, p. 757)
To support his argument, de Kare-Silver cites the results of a survey of 100 chief executives of the top 100 companies based in the UK and the United States that was carried out by the consultancy firm Kalchas Group. The results suggested that only 14 put ‘strategy ’ at the top of their list of priorities; this is illustrated in Table 2.3. He goes on to say that: This low ranking for strategy is confirmed by other surveys. For example, another piece of research reviewed in the book Maximum Leadership (1995) concluded that only 20 per cent of CEOs described strategy formulation as their defining role. While most acknowledged its importance, at the same time they put other items such as people, change management and core competencies ahead on their list of priorities: In reality, many of the CEOs we interviewed felt entirely comfortable saying they believed the days of top-down strategy formulation are past. Insofar as it is possible to identify the characteristics of those organizations in which managers have not lost sight of the significance of planning and strategy, they are that: ■
There is a clear sense of purpose and direction
■
Strategies are clearly articulated
The Three Dimensions of Planning
Table 2.3
Where would strategy typically rank on your agenda? (adapted from de Kare-Silver, 1997)
Suggested priority agenda items
Average rankings
People management
1
Financial performance
2
Stockholders
3
Customers
4
Re-engineering
5
Future strategy
6
New products
7
Technology
8
Information management
9
Regulatory environment
10
■
There is continuous investment in people, products, processes and markets
■
Resources and effort are clearly focused upon those elements that are seen to be important and that give or contribute to competitive advantage
■
There is a commitment to the long term
■
The management team is determined to overcome obstacles and roadblocks
■
There is an emphasis upon implementation
■
Managers are concerned with creating their own future, rather than having it created for them by others.
In essence, de Kare-Silver suggests, they not only understand competitive advantage and what it takes to win, but they also recognize that marketing excellence is achieved not through ignorance and guesswork, but through a detailed understanding of the organization’s markets and organizational capabilities, and a clear focus upon segmentation and differentiation. However, a problem for many managers who do attempt to develop and implement a more strategic approach to their markets is that the majority of the best-known and most widely used strategy tools are increasingly being seen as out of date. The Boston Consulting Group’s (1970) growthshare matrix and Porter’s five forces and three generic strategies, for
59
60 CHAPTER 2: Strategic Marketing Planning and the Marketing Plan
example, were all developed against the background of a very different business environment from the one within which many managers operate today and, as a consequence, have a number of limitations (these are touched upon in later parts of this book). In order to overcome this, de Kare-Silver argues for what he terms the Market Commitment model, suggesting that it is this that helps managers to come to terms with the way in which competitive advantage might possibly be built and sustained. The model is based upon two building blocks: commitment and competitive advantage. The first of these stems from de Kare-Silver’s belief that in focusing upon the future, high-performing management teams demonstrate a commitment to win and an almost messianic focus that is so strongly articulated that competitors back away, recognizing that the market will be dominated by the key player. The second building block of the model is competitive advantage. Research by de Kare-Silver and the Kalchas Group led him to suggest that there are four prime areas that differentiate organizations and most frequently influence purchases decisions. These are: 1. Performance 2. Price 3. Emotion 4. ‘Service hustle’. The absolute ideal, he suggests, is the superior performance of the product or service, sold at the most leveraged price, with extraordinary levels of service and compelling emotional values. In practice, of course, there tends to be a focus upon just one or two of these areas rather than all four, and the task of the strategist is therefore to identify which of these is (or are) the most appropriate. Toyota, BMW and Mercedes, for example, focus upon product quality, performance and the development of advances in the product. Marriott Hotels and First Direct base their advantage on delivering very high service levels. Aldi and Wal-Mart use price as the lever, whilst Coca-Cola, Marlboro and Disney base their thinking on the establishment of powerful emotional values with their brands, and the building of customer relationships.
The structure of the marketing plan Against the background of what we have said so far, we can now turn to the structure of the marketing plan: this appears in Table 2.4, together with an indication of the tools and techniques that might be used at each stage. Deliberately, we have opted for something that is highly-structured and through which the planner moves in a step-by-step way.
The Three Dimensions of Planning
Table 2.4
The marketing plan
Key headings of the plan 1.
Executive summary
2.
The background to the plan and the context for what follows (a summary of the position reached and the strategic progress made)
3.
The vision for the organization, the mission and aspirations (e.g. to create superb products and services, to develop and expand the markets in which the company is active, and to create stakeholder value by achieving an exceptional financial performance that will be reflected in the company’s share price), and strategic intent (e.g. to gain leadership within defined strategic groups and markets, as well as achieving an excellent financial performance)
4.
Market overview and situational analysis (the statement of where we are currently, the factors that have contributed to this, and a review of what has been going well and what has been going badly and is in need of attention)
5.
Internal analysis: strengths, weaknesses and measures of capability
Tools, techniques and outcomes
■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■
■
Strengths and weaknesses and their implications Resource analysis Assets and competences Measures of capability Portfolio analysis Product and brand life cycle positions The reality check (why should anyone buy from us?) Strategic intent and strategic reality (what do we want to do, and what are we really capable of achieving?) Benchmarking (how do we perform relative to others?)
5(a). The preliminary assessment of strengths and weaknesses and initial thinking on how to leverage capability 6.
External analysis and the market audit
■ ■
■ ■ ■
■ ■ ■
SLEPT analysis Opportunities and threats: basic beliefs, implications and must do’s Market trends and implications Performance/importance analysis Customer analysis, including customers’ perceptions of the organization, measures of satisfaction, and measures of loyalty Areas of company–customer mismatch Competitor analysis Market product, brand and technology life cycle analysis
(Continued)
61
62 CHAPTER 2: Strategic Marketing Planning and the Marketing Plan
Table 2.4
Continued
Key headings of the plan
Tools, techniques and outcomes
6(a). Preliminary assessment of the opportunities and threats: the issues that emerge from the analysis, including the critical success factors 7.
8.
Critical issues analysis and thinking on positioning in order to reduce competitive threats and how to exploit opportunities
■
The principal assumptions underpinning the plan
■
■
■ ■
■
9.
The target market and its characteristics
■ ■ ■ ■
10. The marketing objectives by market, product group, segment and brand
■ ■ ■
Strategic imperatives and priorities Marketing priorities Critical success factors (the areas in which the organization must excel if it is to outperform its competitors and achieve success) and how these are changing Life cycle projections Probable customer and competitor moves and developments The scope for leveraging capability (what can we do to reinvent the marketing proposition and/or the industry?) Customer and consumer issues Strategic groups Segmentation, targeting and positioning Market space analysis The Ansoff matrix Competitive stance and competitive advantage Profits forecast and sensitivity analysis
11. The positioning statement 12. The marketing and competitive strategy and the competitive stance
13. The management of the seven Ps of the marketing matrix
The type of strategy The big idea – the killer or winning proposition ■ Competitive targets and priorities ■ Issues of differentiation and the competitive stance ■ Approaches to leveraging capability: the three actions/ things that would make a difference ■ Breakpoint thinking ■ Segmentation, targeting and positioning ■
■
■
14. The development of the brand
■ ■
■ ■ ■ ■
The seven Ps (Product, Price, Place, Promotion, People, Physical evidence and Process management) Aspects of customer service/establishing the service levels Market mapping Competitive advantage, selling proposition(s) and brand values The ‘big idea’ and breakpoint thinking The bases for differentiation and competitive advantage Leveraging assets and strategy The delivery of greater value
15. Budgets 16. Review and the possible reformulation of the objectives (Continued)
The Three Dimensions of Planning
Table 2.4
Continued
Key headings of the plan
Tools, techniques and outcomes
17. The action plan 18. Implementation and control
■
Issues of responsibility and accountability Deadlines, intermediate targets and measures of performance Internal marketing The McKinsey 7S
■
Scenario and ‘what if’? thinking
■ ■
■
19. Contingency thinking (what are we going to do if some of the planning assumptions prove not to be valid and/or our objectives and/or environmental conditions change?)
Note: Within this structure, the setting of the budget appears at a relatively late stage. In many organizations, of course, the budget (or at least the initial budget) is allocated at the beginning of the planning cycle, and the planner is therefore faced with the task of developing the plan within this constraint.
Marketing planning and the significance of mindset In his book The Mind of the Strategist, Kenichi Ohmae (1983) claimed that successful strategy was more to do with a particular mindset than with detailed and highly objective analysis. Written in 1975, at the time of a tremendous upsurge in Japanese global economic power, the book was translated into English in 1983 and proved to be particularly successful and influential, since it was at this stage that American business was being hit particularly hard by Japanese firms. Perceived by many to hold the secret to Japanese management thinking, the book was in fact a warning against a belief in a ‘Made in Japan’ miracle of business strategy. Ohmae, a consultant with McKinsey, argued in the book that a considerable amount of Japanese strategy was often based on creativity and intuition – a view that was at odds with the common perception of remorseless Japanese logic and detailed planning, something that was, in turn, reflected in the often small and frequently poorly resourced strategic planning units of Japanese companies. Despite this, Japanese firms at the time were often outstanding performers in the market place. Ohmae contrasted this with the way in which he saw many large American firms being run rather like the Soviet economy in its heyday, with managers feeling that they needed to plan ahead comprehensively and control in detail each stage of the process. In these circumstances, he suggested, creativity and intuition get lost. He also suggested that in these types of organization those who step outside the well-established and clearly-defined planning parameters are often penalized, whilst those who understand and work the system are rewarded. In commenting on this, Merriden (1998) suggests that: If creativity and intuition are the key, then the central thrust of Ohmae’s argument is that successful strategies result not from rigorous
63
64 CHAPTER 2: Strategic Marketing Planning and the Marketing Plan
1. What issues are you facing in your business today, what are the market dynamics, and how are they changing? 2. What actions have your competitors taken in the last three and five years that have had a significant effect upon your organization? 3. What actions have you taken over the last three and five years that have had a significant effect upon the competition? 4. What are the most dangerous and far-reaching actions that your competitors might take, both in the short term and the long term? 5. What are the most effective steps that you could take in the next three years?
FIGURE 2.9
Five questions for the marketing planner and strategist
analysis but from a particular state of mind. ‘In strategic thinking’, he argues, ‘one first seeks a clear understanding of the particular character of each element of a situation and then makes the fullest use of human brainpower to restructure the elements in the most advantageous way.’ Brainpower on its own is not enough. Hence, at the heart of a Japanese business, there is often a single, talented, forceful strategist, who has ‘an idiosyncratic mode of thinking in which company, customers and competition merge’. These three Cs, as Ohmae called them, are allimportant, but for the Japanese it is the customer who has always been at the heart of the Japanese approach to strategy. Ohmae goes on to suggest that an effective strategy is one through which a company can gain significant ground on its competitors at an acceptable cost to itself, and outlines four ways of achieving this. The first is a clear focus on the key factors for success, and a concentration of major resources at an early stage on a single strategically significant function. The second is to build on superiority by employing technology not currently being exploited by your rivals. The third is to pursue aggressive initiatives that upset ‘the rules of the game’. The final route is to make full use of what Ohmae calls ‘strategic degrees of freedom’, focusing on areas in which competitors are not involved. Given the nature of these comments, we can identify a number of questions that marketing planners and strategists need to ask themselves on a regular basis (see Figure 2.9). It is the answer to these questions that (should) help to focus attention upon some of the more significant issues that underpin the development of the strategic marketing plan.
Testing and evaluating the plan In testing and evaluating the strategy and plan, a number of criteria need to be considered – the three most obvious of which relate to the plan’s
The Three Dimensions of Planning
appropriateness (does it, for example, strengthen and exploit the current position?); its feasibility (can it be successfully implemented?); and its desirability (does it close any planning gaps, and are the risk levels acceptable?). A slightly different approach to evaluation is encapsulated in Table 2.5, where the plan is tested against a number of criteria. Having developed the plan and applied the initial test that appears in Table 2.5, there is then the need to take the evaluation a stage further with a straightforward five-stage test. 1. The objectives
To what extent are the objectives measurable, stretching, and motivating, with clear interim steps?
2. A long-term view
Does the plan reflect a long-term perspective, and is there a clear picture of how the future will be or might be different?
Table 2.5
Testing the strategy and plan
To what extent does the strategy and plan:
To a very high degree
Not at all
1. Build upon and exploit our strengths
•
•
•
•
•
2. Address our weaknesses
•
•
•
•
•
3. Leverage and strengthen our competitive position
•
•
•
•
•
4. Exploit emerging opportunities
•
•
•
•
•
5. Provide a basis for meaningful differentiation
•
•
•
•
•
6. Hurt the competition
•
•
•
•
•
7. Leverage marketing assets
•
•
•
•
•
8. Strengthen our image and reputation
•
•
•
•
•
9. Develop our routes to market
•
•
•
•
•
10. Build customer loyalty
•
•
•
•
•
11. Reflect product and/or process innovation
•
•
•
•
•
12. Coordinate resources – including staff – across the organization
•
•
•
•
•
13. Make best use of resources
•
•
•
•
•
14. Satisfy the criteria of simplicity
•
•
•
•
•
15. Satisfy the criteria of flexibility
•
•
•
•
•
65
66 CHAPTER 2: Strategic Marketing Planning and the Marketing Plan
3. The allocation of resources
Are the resources needed for the plan understood in detail, and has this level of resource been committed?
4. Competitive advantage
What are the bases of competitive advantage for the company? How significant are they? To what extent are they capable of being leveraged and how are they to be used?
5. Simple
By ensuring that the strategy is clear, concise and simple, the chances of successful implementation increase dramatically.
Assuming that the plan satisfies these criteria, the focus needs then to switch to that of implementation.
The difficulties of implementation It has long been recognized that it is one thing to develop the strategy and the strategic plan. It is another to implement the plan effectively and translate strategy into action. One of the first to explore this in detail was the Prussian staff officer Karl von Clausewitz (1984) who, in his book On War, suggested that ‘everything in strategy is very simple, but that does not mean that everything in strategy is very easy ’. He went on to say that ‘countless minor incidents – the kind you can never really foresee – combine to lower the general level of performance, so that one always falls short of the intended goal’. He referred to this phenomenon as ‘friction’ and believed it to be the principal reason why strategies fail. Although von Clausewitz was discussing strategy in terms of war, a similar theme has been pursued by numerous business writers, including Ansoff (1984), Dromgoole et al. (2000) and Mintzberg et al. (2005). In some instances, the factors that cause the strategy to fail are built into the strategy itself, in that the underlying assumptions are flawed and/or the underlying environmental conditions change. As an example of this, the car makers General Motors and Ford both assumed for many years that the sports utility vehicle market in the USA, where both companies had considerable strengths, would continue to grow. Faced, however, in 2008 with rapidly rising fuel prices, customers began looking for smaller and more economical vehicles. Equally, the unexpected rejection by customers of ‘New Coke’ in 1985 forced the Coca-Cola company into a very different marketing strategy, whilst in 2004 the US pharmaceutical group Merck was unexpectedly forced into withdrawing one of its key products, the arthritis treatment drug Vioxx.
The Three Dimensions of Planning
Given examples such as these, there are five possible guidelines for the planner: ■
Ensure that the underlying marketing strategy is as realistic as possible
■
Check the external and internal environmental assumptions and conditions on a regular basis
■
Recognize the pivotal importance of ongoing communication so that staff understand what the plan entails and what it demands of them
■
Be prepared for the unexpected and have contingencies in place. Faced with the rapid rise in the price of oil in mid-2008, for example, when oil reached almost $150 a barrel, many organizations were forced into having to think very differently and put in place contingency actions. Airlines, for example, began rethinking routes, mothballing aircraft and imposing additional levies on passengers
■
If market conditions change significantly, be willing to dramatically revise or even drop the plan and begin again.
In an attempt to summarize the primary contributors to poor or ineffective implementation, Piercy and Morgan (1990) have pointed to: 1. The separation of planning activities from the day-to-day management of market, products and brands 2. The hopeless optimism that leads to plans being developed that are divorced, almost totally in some cases, from reality 3. Issues associated with the implementation of the plan being recognized at too late a stage, with the result that the plan that emerges simply cannot be taken further without the injection of new resources, capabilities, systems and people 4. A denial of any potential implementation problems (this is sometimes manifested in terms of senior management taking the approach that ‘if this is the way that we say it is going to be, this is the way it is going to be’). In the absence of buy-in, ownership and commitment, even the most logical of plans is unlikely to be implemented fully 5. Implementation being seen almost as an after-thought and a tidying up of loose ends rather than as something that needs to be an integral part of the planning process from the outset 6. Any barriers or potential implementation problems that are identified are not analysed in sufficient detail, and managers then either over-react or react inappropriately.
67
68 CHAPTER 2: Strategic Marketing Planning and the Marketing Plan
McDonald (1989) offers a broadly similar perspective when discussing the problems of implementation, pointing to: 1. Too little support from senior management, with the result that too few resources are available and levels of buy-in are low 2. The lack of a plan for planning so that few of the team really understand what is required and how the plan will be used 3. The absence of line management support 4. Confusion over the planning terminology 5. A focus upon numbers rather than clearly stated objectives and strategies 6. Too great an emphasis upon detail 7. The emergence of planning as a once-a-year ritual rather than as an ongoing process that involves analysing markets, capabilities and strategic options 8. The failure to distinguish properly between the short- and the long-term and between the operational and the strategic dimensions 9. The failure to integrate marketing planning with corporate planning 10. The temptation to leave planning to a (separate) planning team rather than seeing it to be the responsibility of those who manage the business. Piercy (2008) has highlighted a series of broadly similar issues, suggesting that, if the planning – and implementation – processes are to work effectively, there is the need for the formulization of marketing planning across the organization, supported by high levels of management involvement; a thoroughness which includes resources and rewards; a recognition of the behavioural issues associated with planning; and a culture which ensures that the plan is used. In addition to these points, Freedman (2003) has pointed to the problems of: ■
Strategic inertia which leads to managers being unwilling to change, despite what the plan demands
■
A lack of stakeholder commitment
■
Strategic drift
■
Strategic dilution which is characterized by a lack of clarity about the plan’s ownership and drivers
■
Strategic isolation in communication is poorly developed and the plans increasingly become disconnected from the focus of activity
Summary
■
The failure to monitor and understand the progress being made
■
Initiative fatigue in which (too much) action becomes mistaken for strategy
■
A level of impatience in which the timetable for results is unrealistically short
■
The failure to celebrate success.
In order to overcome these sorts of problems, Piercy and Morgan (1990) advocate taking four steps: ■
Turn planning upside-down. Start with those things that line executives see as most critical. Work back from this to begin putting together a strategic plan.
■
Make participation a controlled variable to get the right blend of line executives and planning analysts, departmental and political interest, ‘change champions’ and ‘culture carriers’, to weld strategy and implementation together.
■
In all strategic plans, demand explicit, costed, researched implementation strategies for every key item. Reject out-of-hand any plan that does not explicitly address implementation issues.
■
Challenge all strategic plans that do not show how the plan gains the commitment of the people who run the business, and that ignore the importance of consistency between what has to be done and what the organization is going to try to do.
Having started this section with a quotation from von Clausewitz, it is perhaps appropriate to finish with a quotation from another military strategist. The Prussian Field Marshal Helmuth von Moltke once said that ‘no plan survives contact with the enemy ’. In business terms, this would be that ‘no plan survives contact with reality ’ and that what looks to be robust as a planning document may not work out in practice.
2.6
SUMMARY
Within this chapter we have examined the nature and role of strategic marketing planning and illustrated some of the different perspectives that have emerged over the past few years. We have also examined the dimensions of marketing strategy and planning and how the planning process might be made to work effectively. Against this background we have introduced the structure of the marketing plan, and it is this that provides the framework for the remainder of the book.
69
This page intentionally left blank
1 Introduction
2 Strategic marketing planning and the marketing plan
Stage One Where are we now? Strategic and marketing analysis
3 Marketing auditing and the analysis of capability
4 Segmental, productivity and ratio analysis
5 Market and environmental analysis
6 Approaches to customer analysis
7 Approaches to competitor analysis
Stage Two Where do we want to be? Strategic direction and strategy formulation
8 Missions and objectives
9 Market segmentation, targeting and positioning
10 The formulation of strategy 1
11 The formulation of strategy 2
12 The formulation of strategy 3
This page intentionally left blank
STAGE ONE
Where Are We Now? Strategic and Marketing Analysis Our primary concern in Stage One is with the ways in which organizations can most clearly identify their current position and the extent of their marketing capability. With the background of the picture that emerges from this analysis, the marketing planner should be in a far better position to begin the process of deciding upon the detail of the organization’s future direction and the ways in which strategy is to be formulated. The starting point in this process of strategic and marketing analysis involves a detailed marketing audit and review of marketing effectiveness. Together, the two techniques are designed to provide the strategist with a clear understanding of: ■ ■ ■
The organization’s current market position The nature of environmental opportunities and threats The organization’s ability to cope with the demands of this environment.
The results of this analysis are then incorporated in a statement of Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities and Threats (SWOT), and subsequently a measure of capability. Although the marketing auditing process is, as we discuss in Chapter 3, a relatively underutilized activity, a growing number of planners, strategists and writers have over the past few years highlighted the nature of its potential contribution to effective strategy formulation. Although there is no single format for the audit, it is generally acknowledged that, if the process is to be worthwhile, account needs to be taken of six dimensions: 1. The marketing environment 2. The current marketing strategy
74 STAGE ONE: Where are We Now? Strategic and Marketing Analysis
3. Organizational issues 4. The marketing systems in use 5. Levels of marketing productivity 6. Marketing functions. Used properly, marketing auditing and a review of marketing effectiveness are recognized as potentially powerful analytical tools that are capable of providing the planner with a detailed understanding of the organization’s marketing capability and the nature of the environment that it is likely to face. This process of analysis is taken a step further in Chapter 4, in which we discuss the ways in which the planner can establish patterns of resource allocation and its productivity by relating inputs (resources or costs) to outputs (revenues and profits). By doing this, the process of cost-effective planning is capable of being improved significantly. Against this background we turn, in Chapters 5, 6 and 7, to the environment as a whole and then to the various ways in which competitors and customers can be analysed. It has long been recognized that marketing strategy is to a very large extent driven by the strategist’s perception of competitors and customers, and because of this the failure to analyse competitors’ and customers’ potential response profiles in depth is likely to be reflected in strategies that lack an adequate underpinning. In the case of competitors, our understanding of how competitive relationships develop and operate has increased greatly over the past few years, largely as the result of the work of Michael Porter. Porter’s work is based on the idea that the nature and intensity of competition within an industry is determined by the interaction of five key forces: 1. The threat of new entrants 2. The power of buyers 3. The threat of substitutes 4. The extent of competitive rivalry 5. The power of suppliers. Analysis of these allows, in turn, for the identification of strategic groups, and for a far clearer identification of the relative position, strengths and objectives of each competitor. In the light of this, the arguments in favour of a competitive intelligence system are compelling. However, as we point out in Chapter 7, the value (and indeed the existence) of such a system is determined to a very large extent by the belief in competitive monitoring on the part of top management. Without this, the evidence that emerges from the work of numerous writers suggests that the organization will be
Where Are We Now? Strategic and Marketing Analysis
largely introspective, with competitive analysis playing only a minor role in the planning process. Broadly similar comments can be made about the role and value of customer analysis (refer to Chapter 6). As with competitive behaviour, our understanding of how buyers behave has advanced significantly in recent years. All too often, however, evidence suggests that firms devote relatively little attention to detailed customer analysis, assuming instead that because they interact with customers on a day-to-day basis they have a sufficient understanding of how and why markets behave as they do. Only rarely is this likely to be the case and, recognizing that customer knowledge is a potentially powerful source of competitive advantage, the rationale for regular and detailed analyses of customers is therefore strong.
75
This page intentionally left blank
CHAPTER 3
Marketing Auditing and the Analysis of Capability
3.1
LEARNING OBJECTIVES
When you have read this chapter you should understand: (a) the nature, structure and purpose of the marketing audit; (b) the nature of the contribution made by the marketing audit to the overall management audit; (c) the need for a regular review of marketing effectiveness and how such a review might be conducted; (d) why a regular review of strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats is necessary; (e) how the marketing effectiveness review, SWOT and TOWS analysis and the marketing audit contribute to the marketing planning process.
3.2
INTRODUCTION
Although the process of marketing auditing is a fundamental underpinning for the marketing planning process, it is for many organizations still a relatively under-utilized activity. This is despite a substantial body of evidence that suggests that an organization’s performance in the marketplace is directly influenced by the marketing planner’s perception of three factors: 1. The organization’s current market position 2. The nature of environmental opportunities and threats 3. The organization’s ability to cope with environmental demands. Strategic Marketing Planning Copyright © 2009 Colin Gilligan and Richard M.S. Wilson. All rights reserved.
77
78 CHAPTER 3: Marketing Auditing and the Analysis of Capability
Given this, the marketing audit is designed to provide the strategist with a clear understanding of these three dimensions and, in this way, provide a firm foundation for the development of strategy, something that is reflected in a comment by McDonald (1995, p. 28): Expressed in its simplest form, if the purpose of a corporate plan is to answer three central questions: Where is the company now? Where does the company want to go? How should the company organize its resources to get there? then the audit is the means by which the first of these questions is answered. An audit is a systematic, critical and unbiased review and appraisal of the environment and of the company’s operations. A marketing audit is part of the larger management audit and is concerned (specifically) with the marketing environment and marketing operations. (emphasis in original)
What is a marketing audit? The marketing audit is, in a number of ways, the true starting point for the strategic marketing planning process, since it is through the audit that the strategist arrives at a measure both of environmental opportunities and threats and of the organization’s marketing capability. The thinking that underpins the concept of the audit is therefore straightforward: it is that corporate objectives and strategy can only be developed effectively against the background of a detailed and objective understanding of both corporate capability and environmental opportunity. The audit is, therefore, the process through which the marketing planner identifies and evaluates the organization’s strengths and weaknesses against the background of the market and the opportunities and threats that exist. Having done this, the planner is then in a far stronger position to develop the strategy and decide upon a meaningful market position. Definitions of the audit have also been proposed by a variety of authors, all of whom highlight the need for the audit to be a systematic, critical, and impartial review of the total marketing operation. In essence, therefore, the audit must embrace the marketing environment in which the organization – or the business unit – is operating, together with the objectives, strategies and activities being pursued. In doing this, the planner needs to take an objective view of the organization and its market and must not be affected by preconceived beliefs. Given this, the three major elements and potential benefits of the marketing audit can be seen to be: 1. The detailed analysis and understanding of the external environment and internal situation
Introduction
2. The objective review and evaluation of past performance and present activities 3. The clearer identification of future opportunities and threats. These three elements can then usefully be viewed against the background of comments made by Ansoff (1968), who has suggested that, ‘irrespective of the size of the organization, corporate decisions have to be made within the constraint of a limited total resource’. Recognizing this, the strategist is then faced with the task of producing ‘a resource allocation pattern which will offer the best potential for meeting the firm’s objectives’. The marketing audit can therefore be seen in terms of providing a sound basis for this process of resource allocation. In this way, any strategy that is then developed should be far more consistent both with the demands of the environment and with the organization’s capabilities and strengths. The rationale for the audit is therefore straightforward and, in a number of ways, can be seen to derive from the more commonly known and widely accepted idea of the financial audit which, together with audits of other functional areas, is part of the overall management audit. The nature of this relationship is illustrated in Figure 3.1.
Marketing audit EXTERNAL (Opportunities and threats) 1 The business and economic environments (political, economic, social/cultural, and technological factors – PEST) 2 The market 3 Competition
Financial audit
Personnel audit
Production audit
The management audit
INTERNAL (Strengths and weaknesses) 1 Organizational performance and structure 2 Operations and resources marketing objectives marketing strategy information systems planning systems control systems functional efficiency interfunctional efficiency profitability analysis cost-effectiveness analysis
FIGURE 3.1 The place of the marketing audit in the overall management audit
79
80 CHAPTER 3: Marketing Auditing and the Analysis of Capability
The structure and focus of the audit In terms of its structure, the marketing audit consists of three major and detailed diagnostic steps. These involve a review of: 1. The organization’s environment, the ways in which it is likely to change and the probable impact of these changes upon the organization. It is this analysis that then provides the basis for a detailed understanding of the opportunities and threats that exist or are likely to emerge 2. Its marketing strategy, structures, systems, processes and culture, and the extent to which they are capable of dealing with the demands of the environment (in essence, this is the identification and analysis of the organization’s strengths, weaknesses and capabilities) 3. Its marketing activities and, in particular, the components of the marketing mix and how well – or badly – they have been managed. It should be apparent from this that the first of these is designed to establish the various dimensions of the marketing environment, the ways in which it is likely to change, and the probable impact of these changes upon the organization. The second stage is concerned with an assessment of the extent to which the organization’s marketing systems are capable of dealing with the demands of the environment whilst the final stage involves a review of the individual components of the marketing mix. It should be apparent from this that, in conducting an audit, the strategist is concerned with two types of variable. First, there are the environmental or market variables, over which the strategist has little or no direct control. Secondly, there are the operational variables, which can be controlled to a greater or lesser extent. This distinction can also be expressed in terms of the macro-environmental forces (political/legal, economic/demographic, social/ cultural, and technological) that affect the business, and micro-environmental actors (customers, competitors, distributors and suppliers) who subsequently influence the organization’s ability to operate profitably in the market place. Regardless of which approach to categorization is used, the process and purpose of the audit is the same. It begins with an external audit covering the macro-environmental forces referred to above and the markets and competitors that are of particular interest to the company. The internal audit then builds upon this by assessing the extent to which the organization, its structure and resources relate to the environment and have the capability of operating effectively within the constraints that the environment imposes. In doing this, the auditor should not view the marketing audit and its result in isolation but should instead, as we observed earlier, give full recognition
Introduction
to the way in which it sits within the general framework of the overall management audit and alongside the audits of the other management functions (refer back to Figure 3.1). In this way the strategist should arrive at an accurate measure not just of environmental opportunity but also of the ability of the organization as a whole to respond effectively. With regard to the question of how frequently the audit should be conducted, this is typically influenced by several factors, the most important of which are the nature of the business, the rate of environmental change, and the planning cycle (annual, bi-annual). In so far as it is possible to provide a reasonably definitive guideline, it is that the organization should undertake a full audit at the beginning of each major planning cycle, supplemented by less intensive but more frequent reviews of specific or key areas as conditions change.
The stages of the audit In conducting a marketing audit, a majority of commentators advocate a step-wise procedure. In this way, they argue, the approach ensures a degree of consistency that allows for a comparison from one period to another. For Grashof (1975), these steps are: 1. Pre-audit activities in which the auditor decides upon the precise breadth and focus of the audit 2. The assembly of information on the areas that affect the organization’s marketing performance – these would typically include the industry, the market, the firm and each of the elements of the marketing mix 3. Information analysis 4. The formulation of recommendations 5. The development of an implementation programme. Cannon’s approach (1968, p. 102) is broadly similar, and again consists of five distinct stages: these are illustrated in Table 3.1. Although for many organizations it is the assembly of information that proves to be the most time-consuming, it is (in terms of Grashof ’s suggested framework) Stages 3 and 5 that often prove to be the most problematic. In analysing information, the auditor therefore needs to consider three questions: 1. What is the absolute value of the information? 2. What is its comparative value? 3. What interpretation is to be placed upon it?
81
82 CHAPTER 3: Marketing Auditing and the Analysis of Capability
Table 3.1
Cannon’s five stages of audit (Cannon, 1968)
Stage Step 1 Define the market
Key elements Develop: Statement of purpose in terms of benefits ■ Product scope ■ Size, growth rate, maturity state, need for primary versus selective strategies ■ Requirements for success ■ Divergent definitions of the above by competitors ■ Definition to be used by the company ■
Step 2 Determine performance differentials
■ ■
■
Evaluate industry performance and company differences Determine differences in products, applications, geography and distribution channels Determine differences by customer set
Step 3 Determine differences in competitive programmes
Identify and evaluate individual companies for their: ■ Market development strategies ■ Product development strategies ■ Financing and administrative strategies and support
Step 4 Profile the strategies of competitors
■
■
Step 5 Determine the strategic planning structure
Profile each significant competitor and/or distinct type of competitive strategy Compare own and competitive strategies
When size and complexity are adequate: Establish planning units or cells and designate prime and subordinate dimensions ■ Make organizational assignments to product managers, industry managers and others ■
It is generally acknowledged that, if these questions are answered satisfactorily, the recommendations will follow reasonably easily and logically. The only remaining problem is then the development of an effective implementation programme. It should be apparent from the discussion so far that a marketing audit, if carried out properly, is a highly specific, detailed and potentially timeconsuming activity. Because of this many organizations often do not bother with a full audit, and opt instead for a less detailed, more general and more frequent review of marketing effectiveness, coupled with an analysis of strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats. In doing this, the typical starting point is a straightforward analysis or review of strengths and weaknesses that is designed simply to highlight the key issues internally and externally. An example of this appears in Figure 3.2. Having done this initial analysis, the next step is to plot each of these elements into the sort of grid that appears in Figure 3.3, with each feature being linked to the customer’s perception of their significance. At the same time that this is being done, the initial external analysis designed to identify opportunities and threats can be conducted, with the
Introduction
Strengths • • • • •
Weaknesses
Product quality and reliability Product performance High levels of after-sales service Brand reputation Low maintenance costs
• Limited product range • Higher prices than the direct competitors • High after-sales prices
FIGURE 3.2 The initial analysis of strengths and weaknesses
Significance to the customer
Low Strengths
10
• Low maintenance costs
0 Weaknesses 10
High
• After-sales service levels
• Product quality and reliability
• Brand reputation
• Product performance
• Limited product range
• Prices • After-sales costs
FIGURE 3.3 Customer perceptions of the significance of the strengths and weaknesses Significance to the customer
results then being brought together in the form of a provisional situational analysis. However, in conducting the external audit, the planner needs to make sure that the analysis does not simply lead to a list of opportunities and threats, but that the issues are plotted on to the sort of matrix shown in Figure 3.4.
Low High
Significance to the organization Low
High
Develop a scenario plan
Think about possible contingency plans
Analyse and plan in detail
Review periodically
Monitor on an ongoing but general basis
Monitor closely and plan
Monitor in very general terms
Review periodically
Monitor and review
FIGURE 3.4 Probability of occurrence
83
84 CHAPTER 3: Marketing Auditing and the Analysis of Capability
Having done this, the results can be used as the basis for the next stage, that of the identification of the product/market opportunities (refer to pages 327–30 and to the Ansoff matrix) and to the identification and evaluation of the strategic alternatives open to the organization. Having identified these, they can then be given an initial attractiveness rating by identifying the contribution that each is capable of making to the filling of the planning gap (refer to pages 330–1).
3.3 REVIEWING MARKETING EFFECTIVENESS Marketing effectiveness is to a very large extent determined by the extent to which the organization reflects the five major attributes of a marketing orientation, namely: 1. A customer-oriented philosophy 2. An integrated marketing organization 3. Adequate marketing information 4. A strategic orientation 5. Operational efficiency. Each of these dimensions can be measured easily by means of a checklist, and an overall rating then arrived at for the organization. It needs to be recognized, however, that an organization’s marketing effectiveness is not always reflected in current levels of performance. It is quite possible, for example, for an organization to be performing well simply by force of circumstances rather than because of good management – in other words, good performance may be due to being in the right place at the right time as opposed to anything more fundamental. A change in strategy as the result of an effectiveness review might well have the result of improving performance from good to excellent. Equally, an organization may be performing badly despite seemingly excellent marketing planning. Again, the explanation may well be environmental rather than poor management. Recognizing this, the purpose of going through the process of a marketing effectiveness rating review is to identify those areas in which scope exists for marketing improvement. Action, in the form of revised plans, can then be taken to achieve this. With regard to the process of arriving at a measure of marketing effectiveness, the procedure is straightforward and involves managers from a number of departments (not just marketing) scoring the organization’s performance on each of the five dimensions referred to above. Scores are then summarized in order to arrive at an overall perception of marketing effectiveness. In practice, and as might be expected, few companies achieve a score in the highest range; among the few to have done this are organizations
The Role of SWOT Analysis
such as IKEA, W.L. Gore, Amazon.com and a small number of the airlines, such as Emirates, Cathay Pacific and Singapore Airlines. The majority of companies, however, cluster around the fair-to-good range, suggesting that scope exists for improvement in one or more of the five areas. Having conducted a review of marketing effectiveness, the marketing planner may decide that the results provide sufficient insight into the organization’s capabilities. There is, however, a strong argument for viewing the marketing effectiveness rating review simply as the jumping-off point for a more detailed analysis of strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats.
3.4
THE ROLE OF SWOT ANALYSIS
Although SWOT analysis is one of the best-known and most frequently used tools within the marketing planning process, the quality of the outputs often suffer because of the relatively superficial manner in which it is conducted. There are several ways in which SWOT analyses can be made more rigorous – and therefore more strategically useful – and this is something to which we will return at a later stage in this chapter. However, before we turn to the detail of the SWOT, it is perhaps worth summarizing the key elements of the four dimensions. These are illustrated in Figure 3.5.
Identifying opportunities and threats Opportunities multiply as they are seized (Sun Tzu, circa 500 BC) Faced with a constantly changing environment, managers need to develop a marketing information system (MkIS) that is capable of tracking trends and developments within the market place. Each trend or development can then be categorized as an opportunity or a threat, and an assessment made of the feasibility and action needed if the organization is either to capitalize upon the opportunity or minimize the impact of the threat. However, in examining opportunities and threats the reader needs to recognize that these can never be viewed as ‘absolutes’. What might appear at first sight to be an opportunity may not be so when examined against the organization’s resources, its culture, the expectations of its stakeholders, the strategies available, or the feasibility of implementing the strategy. Instead, it might simply be a change within the market that is of little real or immediate consequence. At the risk of oversimplification, however, the purpose of strategy formulation is to develop a strategy that will take advantage of the opportunities and overcome or circumvent the threats. For our purposes, an opportunity can be seen as any sector of the market in which the company would enjoy a competitive advantage. These opportunities can then be assessed according to their attractiveness and the organization’s probability of success in this area, as illustrated in Figure 3.6.
85
86 CHAPTER 3: Marketing Auditing and the Analysis of Capability
STRENGTHS: Areas of (distinctive) competence that: • Must always be looked at relative to the competition • If managed properly, are the basis for competitive advantage • Derive from the marketing asset base WEAKNESSES: Areas of relative disadvantage that: • Indicate priorities for marketing improvement • Highlight the areas and strategies that the planner should avoid OPPORTUNITIES: Environmental trends with positive outcomes that offer scope for higher levels of performance if pursued effectively: • Highlight new areas for competitive advantage THREATS: Trends within the environment with potentially negative impacts that: • • • •
Increase the risks of a strategy Hinder the implementation of strategy Increase the resources required Reduce performance expectations
FIGURE 3.5 SWOT: A summary
Low
High
1
2
3
4
Attractiveness
High
Low
Probability of success Cell 1 consists of opportunities offering the greatest scope, and management should focus upon these. Cell 4, by contrast, represents those opportunities that are either too small or the organization is unlikely to be able to exploit effectively. Cells 2 and 3 offer certain attractions, and management should examine these closely to see whether scope exists either for improving their attractiveness or increasing the probability of success.
FIGURE 3.6 The opportunity matrix
The probability of success is influenced by several factors, but most obviously by the extent to which the organization’s strengths, and in particular its distinctive competences, match the key success requirements for operating effectively in the target market and exceed those of its competitors.
The Role of SWOT Analysis
A superior market position (e.g. a differentiated competitive stance, a lower cost base or a protected niche)
A superior knowledge and/or relationship base (e.g. detailed customer knowledge, trade relationships, technical expertise, political links, or cartel membership)
A superior resource base (e.g. size and economics of scale, financial structures, strategic alliances, the breadth of geographic coverage, marketing and manufacturing flexibility, image/reputation, or channel control)
FIGURE 3.7 Sources of competitive advantage (adapted from McDonald, 1990)
However, competence by itself is rarely sufficient in anything more than the short term since, given time, competitive forces will erode this competence. Because of this the strategist needs to concentrate upon developing competitive advantages that are sustainable over time. The bases of a sustainable competitive advantage are illustrated in Figure 3.7 and are discussed in greater detail in Chapter 11. However, at the same time as generating opportunities, the external environment also presents a series of threats (a threat being a challenge posed by an unfavourable trend or development in the environment which, in the absence of a distinct organizational response, will lead to the erosion of the company’s market position). Threats can be classified on the basis of their seriousness and the probability of their occurrence. An example of how this can be done is illustrated in Figure 3.8. Given the nature of these comments, it can be seen that, by putting together a picture of the major opportunities and threats facing the business, the marketing planner is attempting to arrive at a measure of the market’s overall attractiveness. In essence, four possibilities exist: 1. An ideal business, which is characterized by numerous opportunities but few (if any) threats 2. A speculative business, which is high both in opportunities and in threats
87
88 CHAPTER 3: Marketing Auditing and the Analysis of Capability
Probability of occurrence
1
2
3
4
Seriousness
High
Low
Low
High
The threats in cell 1 are serious and have a high probability of occurrence. Because of this, the strategist needs to monitor developments closely and have a detailed contingency plan available to cope with any changes that take place. The threats in cells 2 and 3 need to be closely monitored in case they become critical. At this stage, contingency planning is unlikely to be necessary. Threats in cell 4 are very minor and can be largely ignored.
FIGURE 3.8 The threats matrix
3. A mature business, which is low both in opportunities and threats 4. A troubled business, which is low in opportunities but high in threats.
Identifying and evaluating strengths and weaknesses Although in many markets it is often a relatively simple process to identify a whole series of environmental opportunities, few organizations have the ability or the competences needed to capitalize upon more than a small number of these. Each business therefore needs to evaluate its strengths and weaknesses on a regular basis. This can be done by means of the sort of checklist illustrated in Figure 3.9. Each factor is rated by management or an outside consultant according to whether it is a fundamental strength, a marginal strength, a neutral factor, a marginal weakness, or a fundamental weakness. By linking these ratings, a general picture of the organization’s principal strengths and weaknesses emerges. Of course, not all of these factors are of equal importance either in an absolute sense or when it comes to succeeding with a specific business opportunity. Because of this, each factor should also be given a rating (high, medium or low) either for the business as a whole or for a particular marketing opportunity. Combining performance and importance levels in this way injects a greater sense of perspective to the analysis, and
The Role of SWOT Analysis
Performance Strengths
Fundamental strength
Marginal strength
Marginal Neutral weakness
Importance Fundamental High weakness
Medium Low
Marketing factors 1 Relative market share 2 Reputation 3 Previous performance 4 Competitive stance 5 Customer base 6 Customer loyalty 7 Breadth of product range 8 Depth of product range 9 Product quality 10 Programme of product modification 11 New product programme 12 Distribution costs 13 Dealer network 14 Dealer loyalty 15 Geographical coverage 16 Sales force 17 After sales service 18 Manufacturing costs 19 Manufacturing flexibility 20 Raw material advantage 21 Pricing 22 Advertising 23 Unique selling propositions 24 Structure of competition Financial factors 25 Cost of capital 26 Availability of capital 27 Profitability 28 Financial stability 29 Margins Manufacturing factors 30 Production facilities 31 Economies of scale 32 Flexibility 33 Workforce 34 Technical skill 35 Delivery capabilities 36 Supplier sourcing flexibility Organizational factors 37 Culture 38 Leadership 39 Managerial capabilities 40 Workforce 41 Flexibility 42 Adaptability
FIGURE 3.9 Strengths and weaknesses analysis (adapted from Kotler, 1988)
leads to four possibilities emerging. These are illustrated in Figure 3.10 in the form of a performance–importance matrix. In Figure 3.10 Cell 1 consists of those factors that are important but in which the organization is currently performing badly. Because of this the organization needs to concentrate on strengthening these factors. Cell 3
89
90 CHAPTER 3: Marketing Auditing and the Analysis of Capability
Performance
Importance
High
Low The focus for greater managerial effort in order to improve performance
High 1
2 Continue with the current effort to ensure that performance does not decline 4
Low
3 Areas of low priority
Re-think the current effort. Is it worth spending in these areas?
FIGURE 3.10 The perfomance–importance matrix
consists of unimportant factors. Cell 2 is made up of factors in which the business is already strong but in which it needs to maintain its strengths. Improvements here, while often desirable, have low priority. Cell 4 is made up of unimportant factors in which (possibly as the result of overinvestment in the past) the business is unnecessarily strong. Another way of looking at issues of performance and importance involves focusing specifically upon the organization’s performance relative to the competition. The framework for this is illustrated in Figure 3.11. On the basis of this sort of analysis it should be apparent that, even when a business has a major strength in a particular area, this strength does not invariably translate into a competitive advantage. There are several possible explanations for this, the two most prominent of which are that it may not be a competence that is of any real importance to customers, or that it is an area in which competitors are at least equally strong. It follows from this that, in order to benefit from the strength, it must be relatively greater than that of the competitor. Having identified the organization’s weaknesses, the strategist needs to return to the analysis of these (see Figure 3.9) and consider again their relative importance. There is often little to be gained from overcoming all of the organization’s weaknesses, since some will be unimportant and the amount of effort needed to convert them to a strength would quite simply not be repaid. Equally, some strengths are of little real strategic value, and to use them in anything other than a peripheral way is likely to prove of
Good
Better than competition
The Role of SWOT Analysis
10 9 8
Overinvestment in an unimportant area
Same as competition
Performance
7
Acceptable
6 5
Areas for improvement
4
Worse than competition
Bad
3
Urgent action and investment needed
2 1 0 0 1 Low
2
3
4 5 6 Importance
7
8
9 10 High
FIGURE 3.11 Performance–importance and the competition (adapted from Slack et al., 1998)
little real value. Recognizing this, the marketing planner should focus upon those areas of opportunity in which the firm currently has major strengths or where, because of the size of the opportunity and the potential returns, it is likely to prove cost-effective in acquiring or developing new areas of strength. On occasions, organizations suffer not because of a lack of individual, departmental or divisional strengths, but quite simply because the various departments or divisions do not work together sufficiently well. As part of the SWOT process the strategist therefore should also pay attention to the quality of interdepartmental and divisional relationships with a view to identifying any dysfunctional areas. One of the ways in which this can be done is by conducting a periodic survey in which each department is asked to identify the strengths and weaknesses both of itself and of each other department with which it interacts. Action can then be taken to overcome areas of conflict, misunderstanding and inefficiency. An example of the results of an attempt to identify interdepartmental strengths and weaknesses appears in Figure 3.12. These are based on a consultancy project conducted by one of the authors several years ago. The client company operated in the engineering field, and was a subsidiary of a far larger multinational organization. The company had a strong financial orientation and was rapidly being overtaken by its competitors: for obvious reasons, the client’s name has been omitted.
91
92 CHAPTER 3: Marketing Auditing and the Analysis of Capability
Strengths
Weaknesses
Marketing
Market development Advertising Dealer development Competitor analysis
Long-term planning Liaising with sales Liaising with production Profitable new product development Identifying small but potentially profitable gaps in the market Expectations regarding quality and manufacturing capability Pricing Relations with corporate management
Sales
None identified
Expectations regarding delivery times Providing market feedback Often sell what can only be made with difficulty Little apparent awareness of costs Ignores small orders Patchy productivity Levels of training Sales staff turnover
Production
Quality
Slow to change Unwilling to cooperate with marketing and sales Often late in delivering Tend to want to make what they are good at A lack of flexibility caused by a strong trade-union presence Rising costs Lack of strong management Ageing plant Inadequate training in CAD/CAM
Personnel
Junior management and shopfloor training
Representation at board level Long-term senior management development Poor negotiating skills Willingness to give in to trade-union pressure Lack of real personnel management skills
Finance
Tight cost control Credit control Relationship with corporate management Access to significant financial resources
Over-emphasis on short-term returns Lack of vision Unwilling to cooperate with marketing and sales Unwilling to provide finance for major programmes of new product development Unrealistic reporting demands
FIGURE 3.12 Identifying interdepartmental strengths and weaknesses
Issues of capability Although the analysis of strengths and weaknesses is a valuable step in the auditing process, the reader needs to recognize that strengths and weaknesses by themselves are of little real planning value. Instead, they should be seen as a step towards the planner coming to terms with the broader issue of capability. In doing this, the planner is giving recognition to the way in which the value of any strategy or plan is ultimately determined not by strengths and weaknesses, but by the organization’s capability and the extent to which it is able to outperform its competitors.
The Role of SWOT Analysis
Although capability has been defined in several ways, it is, in essence, the ability of the management team to get things done. In arriving at a measure of capability, the marketing strategist needs to come to terms with seven principal areas: 1. Managerial capability. This includes not just the abilities of individuals, but also – and perhaps more importantly – that of the team. 2. The managerial culture and the organizational DNA (for a discussion of organizational DNA, refer back to Illustration 2.2). 3. Financial capability. This is determined in part by the availability of funds, but also by the expectations of how they are used, the extent to which the management team is willing to take risks when investing, and the returns that are expected. 4. Operational capability. This involves the levels of day-to-day efficiency and effectiveness. 5. Distribution capability. This is determined by a combination of geographic reach or coverage, penetration (the proportion of possible outlets), and the quality of these distributors. 6. Human resource capability. This is a reflection of the nature and experience of staff throughout the business. 7. Intangible factors (such as the brand). In the case of a powerful brand, capability is extended enormously because it provides the opportunity not just for brand stretching, but also for pricing at a premium, gaining access to the strongest forms of distribution and increasing levels of customer loyalty. At the same time, however, the planner also needs to understand the factors that inhibit capability. Typical examples of this include attitudes to risk and an adherence to a well-developed business model.
Making SWOT analyses more effective Although SWOT analysis is a potentially useful input to the strategic marketing planning process, in practice it often suffers from a number of weaknesses. Amongst the most common of these are that: ■
The planner fails to relate strengths and weaknesses to critical success factors
■
Strengths and weaknesses are seen in absolute terms rather than in relation to the competition
■
The elements of the analysis are insufficiently specific
93
94 CHAPTER 3: Marketing Auditing and the Analysis of Capability
■
Competitors’ capabilities are underestimated and/or misunderstood
■
The focus is upon marketing specific issues rather than reflecting a broader company perspective
■
Emphasis is placed largely upon the ‘hard’ or quantifiable elements, and fails to take account of managerial attitudes, cultures, capabilities and competencies.
The implications of this have been highlighted by numerous writers (e.g. Weihrich, 1982; Piercy, 1991; Doyle, 2002; Johnson et al., 2008; McDonald, 2007) all of whom have also argued that, as a result, its full potential is rarely realized. In suggesting this, Piercy claims that ‘the use of this tool has generally become sloppy and unfocused – a classic example perhaps of familiarity breeding contempt’. There are, he believes, several factors that have contributed to this, the most obvious of which are that: (a)
because the technique is so simple it is readily accessible to all types of manager; (b) the model can be used without a need for extensive information systems; (c) it provides planners with a structure that allows for a mixture of the qualitative and quantitative information, of familiar and unfamiliar facts, of known and half-known understandings that characterize strategic marketing planning. In order to make better use of the SWOT framework, Piercy proposes five guidelines: 1. Focus the SWOT upon a particular issue or element, such as a specific product market, a customer segment, a competitor, or the individual elements of the marketing mix. 2. Use the SWOT analysis as a mechanism for developing a shared vision for planning. This can be done by pooling ideas from a number of sources and achieving a team consensus about the future and the important issues. 3. Develop a customer orientation by recognizing that strengths and weaknesses are largely irrelevant unless they are recognized and valued by the customer. One of the ways in which this can be done is by applying the McDonald’s ‘so what?’ test, in which the planner looks at each of the claimed benefits from the viewpoint of the consumer and, by asking ‘well, so what?’, tries to assess its true significance (see pages 429–30). By doing this, the planner is also likely to move away from the trap of making a series of socalled motherhood statements (a motherhood statement is warm,
The Role of SWOT Analysis
reassuring and difficult to argue against). As an example of the most common of motherhood statements to emerge in analyses of strengths is the suggestion that ‘we are committed to the customer ’. The reality, Piercy argues, is often far removed from this. 4. In the same way that strengths and weaknesses must always be viewed from the viewpoint of the customer, so the analysis of opportunities and threats must relate to the environment that is relevant to the organization’s point of focus. Anything else simply leads to a generalized – and largely pointless – set of comments. 5. The final guideline is concerned with what Piercy refers to as structured strategy generation. This involves: ■ Matching strategies – strengths must be matched to opportunities, since a strength without a corresponding opportunity is of little strategic value. ■ Conversion strategies – while often difficult, these are designed to change weaknesses into strengths and threats into opportunities. As an example of this, competitors may well be growing and proving to be an increasing threat. However, by recognizing that a headon battle is likely to prove expensive and counterproductive, the emphasis might shift to developing strategic alliances that then provide both organizations with a greater combined strength – which in turn allows them to capitalize upon growing opportunities. ■ Creative strategies for developing the business – these emerge as the result of a detailed analytical process rather than the vague and unfocused lines of thought to which we referred earlier. ■ Iteration – as the planner goes through the process of identifying hidden strengths, matching strengths to opportunities, converting weaknesses to strengths, and so on, there is a periodic need to go back to the beginning of the process in order to identify how the situation that is emerging changes the SWOT model and any initial assumptions. SWOT analysis can also be made more effective by thinking: ■
To what extent has the relative importance of the various elements been identified?
■
To what extent have the implications of each of the elements been examined?
■
To what extent does the management team really recognize the significance of the elements?
■
To what extent have attempts been made in the past to manage the SWOT analysis outcomes proactively?
95
96 CHAPTER 3: Marketing Auditing and the Analysis of Capability
SWOT to TOWS The limitations that Piercy suggests typically characterize SWOT analyses have also been highlighted by Weihrich (1982). His principal criticism of SWOT is that, having conducted the analysis, managers frequently then fail to come to terms with the strategic choices that the outcomes demand. In order to overcome this he argues for the TOWS matrix which, while making use of the same inputs (threats, opportunities, weaknesses and strengths), reorganizes them and integrates them more fully into the strategic planning process. To do this involves the seven steps illustrated in Figure 3.13. The TOWS matrix is then illustrated in Figure 3.14.
Basic questions concerning the internal and external environments
Step 1: Prepare a profile of the enterprise which embraces (a) the type of business; (b) its geographic domain; (c) the competitive situation; and (d) the preoccupations and culture of the senior management team.
Step 2: Identify and evaluate the economic, social, political, demographic, products and technology, and market/competitive environments. The present and future external environments Step 3: Prepare a forecast, make predictions and assess the future.
The audit of the organization’s internal resources
Step 4: Prepare a detailed strengths and weaknesses audit of (a) the management and organization; (b) operations; (c) finance; (d) marketing; and (e) the other parts of the organization.
Step 5: Identify the strategic choices facing the organization. The actions needed to achieve the organization’s overall purpose and objectives
Step 6: Make the strategic choices.
Step 7: Prepare the contingency plans.
FIGURE 3.13 The TOWS framework
The Role of SWOT Analysis
Internal elements External elements
Organizational strengths
Organizational weaknesses
Strategic options
Environmental opportunities (and risks)
S-O: Strengths can be used to capitalize or build upon existing or emerging opportunities
W-O: The strategies developed need to overcome organizational weaknesses if existing or emerging opportunities are to be exploited
Environmental threats
S-T: Strengths in the organization can be used to minimize existing or emerging threats
W-T: The strategies pursued must minimize or overcome weaknesses and, as far as possible, cope with threats
FIGURE 3.14 The TOWS matrix (adapted from Weihrich, 1982)
Very obviously, the matrix outlined in Figure 3.14 relates to a particular point in time and there is therefore a need to review the various inputs on a regular ongoing basis in order to identify how they are changing and the nature of the implications of these changes. It is also often useful if, when planning and having made particular assumptions, the planner then produces TOWS matrices for, say, three and five years ahead, with a view to identifying how the strategic options and priorities may change. In this way there is a greater likelihood that the planning team will come to terms with what the future really demands. Figure 3.15 illustrates how Mercedes–Benz used the TOWS matrix in its cars division.
But are SWOT and TOWS analyses of any real value? Although TOWS analysis can be seen to add another dimension to the traditional thinking about strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats, a fundamental question can be raised about just how useful this sort of analysis is within today’s markets. In commenting on this, Walton (1999) argues that its value is limited, suggesting that ‘compared with the steady state of the 1960s and 1970s, today’s markets are characterized by an exponential increase in the rate of change, brought about by a combination of social, technological, legislative and other forces’. The implications of this are then reflected by the way in which ‘as more organizations change from portrait
97
98 CHAPTER 3: Marketing Auditing and the Analysis of Capability
Internal strengths
Strategies Tactics Actions
1 2 3 4 5
Cash position Luxury car image New car models Location dose to suppliers Engineering and technology
External opportunities
S-O strategy
1 Demand for luxury cars 2 Eastern Europe, especially East Germany 3 Prosperity through EC 1992 4 Electronics technology
1 Develop new models (using high-tech) and charge premium prices 2 Use financial resources to acquire other companies or increased production capacity
External threats
S-T strategy
1 Decrease in defence needs because of easing of East–West tensions 2 BMW, Volvo, Jaguar, Lexus, Infinity in Europe 3 BMW in Japan 4 Diesel emissions 5 Renault/Volvo cooperation 6 Political instability in South Africa
1 Transform defence sector to consumer sector 2 Develop new models to compete especially in Europe
Internal weaknesses 1 High costs 2 Venturing into unrelated businesses 3 Organizational diversity 4 Reliance on past successes and bureaucracy 5 Long cycle for new model development 6 Relatively weak position in Japan
W-O strategy 1 Reduce costs through automation and flexible manufacturing 2 Manufacture parts in Eastern Europe 3 Reorganizations 4 Daimler-Benz management holding companies
W-T strategy 1 Retrench in South Africa 2 Form strategic alliance with Mitsubishi to penetrate the Japanese market
FIGURE 3.15 TOWS analysis for Mercedes–Benz car division 1990 (source: Weihrich, 1993)
to landscape structures, the mayhem of the operational day-to-day activity often gets in the way – not only of a true understanding of the nature and pattern of competition, but also of the more added-value appreciation of the implications for business strategy ’. Amongst the sorts of factors that have contributed to this planning mayhem are mega-brands, mega-retailers (including category busters such as Toys ‘R’ Us and Wal-Mart) and the sort of technological convergence that we have seen in the software, consumer electronics and telecommunications markets. For Walton (1999, p. 35), convergence has the effect of making competitive appraisal more difficult, and can be the consequence of: industry boundaries blurring and turf disputes opening up between new competitors. Consider how the last decade has seen supermarkets move successfully into petrol, and petrol stations increasingly move
The Role of SWOT Analysis
into food. And how new markets attract players from all quarters. For example, the direct marketing industry has attracted creative agencies, computer software houses, fulfilment businesses and doorto-door distribution companies, each bringing different competencies and skill sets to the market opportunity. Technological convergence can produce even more thrills and spills for marketers. The last two years have shown how digital technology has brought what we have traditionally known as the photographic, video and audio markets all closer together, with significant implications. For instance, for the consumer, who has the brand authority in digital cameras? A film brand like Kodak, a camera brand like Olympus, a video brand like JVC or an imaging brand like Canon? Given this, and what might be seen to be the Pavlovian tendency in mature and highly competitive markets for firms to converge (discussed in Chapter 11 (pages 441–2) in terms of the phenomenon of strategic herding), the implications for competition – and therefore for market and competitive analysis – are significant. As organizations merge, the industry status quo changes dramatically and the idea of the traditional enemy being outside the gates begins to disappear and is replaced by higher levels of internal competition. This internal competition is often geographic in its nature and, for organizations operating across the EU, is typically made more difficult by the degree of cultural diversity that exists – something that Walton suggests has ‘created a kind of tragi-comic Jeux Sans Frontières assault course which can lead to “euromush” marketing resulting from conflicting harmonization demands’. At the same time, with brand strategies now performing a far more pivotal role within marketing and a greater number of management teams beginning to copy what might loosely be termed the Virgin model of brand architecture that is characterized by a far greater degree of mobility across category boundaries, marketing planners need to adopt a far broader perspective of competition. The ‘Maginot-line’ approach to SWOT analysis that many planners have pursued in the past tends to be based on a functional rather than a brand view of competition, and is likely to miss potential new market entrants. The likelihood of this has in turn been compounded by the way in which, because consumers today are far more familiar with brands and open to new patterns of brand thinking, the scope for moving into and out of markets has increased dramatically. Given the nature of these changes, the implications for SWOT analysis are potentially significant and provide the basis for a number of modifications to the traditional approach (see Figure 3.16).
The rise of asset- and competency-based thinking Although TOWS analysis undoubtedly represents an improvement upon the rather more mechanistic examination of strengths, weaknesses, opportunities
99
100 CHAPTER 3: Marketing Auditing and the Analysis of Capability
1 Consider the degree and implications of change to be anticipated in a market – high/medium/low. Is there one major factor you can identify as a window of opportunity or that could be used against you by a competitor as a killer threat? What is on the radar? And who is looking? 2 Within a market or category, what slots are already owned, being actively pursued and/or contested, and by whom? 3 What is the current phase of industry concentration? As we shift from ‘middle game’ to ‘end game’, what are the end game options? Does the industry leader have a future direction? What is our best long-term winning strategy or exit? 4 What industries and technologies are converging with our market? Can we zoom out and see proximate industries? For whom is our market an ‘appetizing lunch’? Can the consumer-value equation be met in a new and radical way? 5 What brand franchises are relevant to a category and can travel quickly and easily from, to and into it? What consumer-relevant brand properties are available to existing and potential market entrants? How robust is our brand architecture against the market and against the competition? Have we got some big guns? 6 How strong is the enemy within? What do we do about the 5th Column? 7 What is the ‘diplomatic status’ of the market place? What is the network of alliances? What extra problems and opportunities does this present? Who is tied up? 8 Who currently sets the industry agenda? How strongly is it controlled? How easy will it be to change the industry agenda? 9 Do the industry bandwagons have a role for us? Benchmark with caution! 10 Above all, can you identify a major disruption or a transformational initiative?
FIGURE 3.16
A checklist for the ‘post-modern SWOT’ (adapted from Walton, 1999)
and threats that underpins many marketing plans, Davidson (2007, pp. 34–5) has argued for an alternative way of diagnosing an organization’s current position and a way forward. His method of asset- and competency-based marketing (ACM) reflects the idea that any business consists only of assets (these are the ‘things’ that the organization owns and typically include brands, property, databases, supply chains and cash) and competences (these are the skills created by staff both individually and in groups, and might include brand development, database management, cost management and trade marketing). The challenge for the marketing planner is therefore one of how best to recognize the organization’s real assets and then, through the competences, how best to exploit them. He argues that for each asset it is essential that there is a corresponding competency. Without this, it is unlikely that the asset will be exploited. For an asset such as a brand, the competency needed is brand management; for databases it is database management and customer service. The issue for the planner is therefore initially that of the recognition of the organization’s asset and then, against the background of a detailed understanding of market needs and opportunities, how these can best be leveraged and exploited.
The Role of SWOT Analysis
For Davidson, the advantage of ACM is that it ‘divides the “strengths” into two key and separate elements – assets and competences – and stresses the process of matching these both with each other, and with future opportunities’. He goes on to say that: Many successful marketers do this instinctively, but due to lack of a systematic processes even they can miss big opportunities. Using ACM those opportunities which are best for a particular company can be revealed systematically. The company can exploit them better than others by capitalizing on its assets, and matching them to its distinctive competences. The result is long-term competitive advantages that are exploitable and sustainable. The application of ACM revolves around a six-step process that involves: 1. Identifying the organization’s exploitable assets and competences. To do this, the planner begins by listing all of the company’s brand assets and competences and then focuses upon those that offer scope for competitive advantage and superior customer value. For Disney, the competency is customer service; for Nike it is brand positioning; for P&G global brand development; and for Marks & Spencer it is the management of their suppliers. 2. Reviewing the extent to which these assets and competences are being exploited currently. In doing this, Davidson highlights a series of action points that include: ■
■
■
Reprioritizing markets, channels, customers or brands, to generate the better utilization of assets Redeploying assets by buying, selling, developing and milking brands or physical assets Identifying the new competences that are needed to exploit assets.
3. Identifying the future shape of the industry and market. By doing this, the planner can see more clearly how a market is likely to change and the sorts of assets and competences that will be needed for the organization to compete effectively in the future. 4. Deciding how the organization’s assets need to change over the next five years. As part of this, the planner needs to focus upon the prospects of current markets, brands and other assets with a view to identifying whether they will deliver the sorts of returns that the organization demands. 5. Building and exploiting assets and competences. 6. Matching assets and competences with future opportunities.
101
102 CHAPTER 3: Marketing Auditing and the Analysis of Capability
Medium
Strong
Low
Exit
Milk profits, refocus the strategy or exit the market
Leverage shortterm profits, and then exit or transform the market
Medium
Assets and competencies
Exit or acquire competencies
Rethink the focus and strategy
Invest heavily to leverage advantage and deliver greater customer value
Acquire competencies by internal investment or acquisition
Invest in order to strengthen the competencies base
Invest to leverage advantage and deliver greater customer value
High
Market attractiveness
Weak
FIGURE 3.17 The asset- and competency-based marketing framework for market prioritization (adapted from Davidson, 2007)
The outputs from ACM thinking should, Davidson argues, more easily enable the marketing planner to: ■
Move assets into areas of higher return
■
Fully exploit all assets and competences
■
Ensure assets and competences are well matched with opportunities
■
Identify new competences that must be developed in the future
■
Spread the marketing mindset by embracing efficient delivery of superior customer value throughout the company.
These ideas are summarized in Figure 3.17.
3.5 COMPETITIVE ADVANTAGE AND THE VALUE CHAIN Having analysed the strengths and resources of the organization, the marketing planner then needs to think about the ways in which these resources can best be used to contribute to the organization’s performance. In other words, how might these resources best be used as a means of gaining and
Competitive Advantage and the Value Chain
/or
nd
na
rgi Ma
The four support activities the firm’s infrastructure human resources management technology development procurement
Operations
Outbound logistics
Marketing and sales
Service activities
Co m ad pet va itiv nta e ge
The five primary activities Inbound logistics
FIGURE 3.18 The value chain (adapted from Porter, 1985a)
maintaining a competitive advantage? One of the ways in which this can be done is by means of the value chain and a detailed understanding of competitive advantage (in this chapter we highlight some of the issues associated with competitive advantage, but a far fuller and more detailed analysis is provided in Chapter 11). Although value analysis has its origins in accounting and was designed to identify the profit of each stage in a manufacturing process, a considerable amount of work has been done in recent years in developing the concept and applying it to measures of competitive advantage. Much of this work has been conducted by Michael Porter, who suggests that an organization’s activities can be categorized in terms of whether they are primary activities or support activities (see Figure 3.18). The five primary activities identified by Porter are: 1. Inbound logistics, which are the activities that are concerned with the reception, storing and internal distribution of the raw materials or components for assembly 2. Operations, which turn these into the final product 3. Outbound logistics, which distribute the product or service to customers. In the case of a manufacturing operation, this would include warehousing, materials handling and transportation. For a service, this would involve the way in which customers are brought to the location in which the service is to be delivered 4. Marketing and sales, which make sure the customers are aware of the product or service and are able to buy it 5. Service activities, which include installation, repair and training.
103
104 CHAPTER 3: Marketing Auditing and the Analysis of Capability
Each of these primary activities is, in turn, linked to the support activities, which are grouped under four headings: 1. The procurement of the various inputs 2. Technology development, including research and development, process improvements and raw material improvements 3. Human resources management, including the recruitment, training, development and rewarding of staff 4. The firm’s infrastructure and the approach to organization, including the systems, structures, managerial cultures and ways of doing business. Porter suggests that competitive advantage is determined to a very large extent by how each of these elements is managed and the nature of the interactions between them. In the case of inbound logistics, for example, many organizations have developed just-in-time systems in order to avoid or minimize their stockholding costs. In this way, the value of the activity is increased and the firm’s competitive advantage improved. Equally, in the case of operations, manufacturers are paying increasing attention to lean manufacturing processes as a means of improving levels of efficiency. Porter’s message is therefore straightforward. Managers, he suggests, need to examine the nature and dimensions of each of the nine activities with a view to identifying how the value added component can best be increased. He then goes on to argue that value chain analysis should not simply stop with the manager’s own organization, but in the case of a manufacturer should also include the suppliers and distribution networks, since the value of much of what an organization does will be magnified or constrained by what they do.
3.6 CONDUCTING EFFECTIVE AUDITS At an earlier stage in this chapter we made reference to the characteristics of effective audits, suggesting that if they are to be worthwhile they should be comprehensive, systematic, independent and conducted on a regular basis. These points are discussed below.
Comprehensive auditing For the auditing process to be worthwhile it is essential that it covers all of the major elements of the organization’s marketing activity, including those that seemingly are doing well, rather than just a few apparent trouble spots. In this way a distinction can be drawn between the marketing audit and a functional audit, which would focus far more specifically upon a particular element of marketing activity, such as sales or pricing. As an example of
Conducting Effective Audits
this, a functional audit might well suggest that a high salesforce turnover and low morale is due to a combination of inadequate sales training and a poor compensation package. A more fundamental reason, however, might be that the company has a poor or inadequate product range and an inappropriate pricing and advertising strategy. It is the comprehensiveness of the marketing audit that is designed to reveal these sorts of factors and to highlight the fundamental causes of the organization’s problems.
Systematic auditing In carrying out the audit it is essential that a sequential diagnostic process is adopted, covering the three areas to which reference was made earlier: the external environment, internal marketing systems, and specific marketing activities. This process of diagnosis is then followed by the development and implementation of both short-term and long-term plans designed to correct the weaknesses identified and, in this way, improve upon levels of marketing effectiveness.
Independent auditing There are several ways in which the marketing audit can be conducted. These include: ■
A self-audit in which managers use a checklist to assess their own results and methods of operation
■
An audit by a manager of the same status but drawn from a different department or division within the organization
■
An audit by a more senior manager within the same department or division
■
The use of a company auditing office
■
A company task force audit group
■
An audit conducted by an outside specialist.
Of these, it is generally recognized that an audit conducted by an outside specialist is likely to prove the most objective and to exhibit the independence that any internal process will almost inevitably lack. Adopting this approach should also ensure that the audit receives the undivided time and attention that is needed. In practice, however, many large companies make use of their own audit teams (something that 3M, for example, has pioneered). This question of who should conduct the audit has been the subject of a considerable amount of research and discussion in recent years with, as indicated above, the argument revolving around the issue of objectivity
105
106 CHAPTER 3: Marketing Auditing and the Analysis of Capability
(in other words, how objective can a line manager be in conducting an evaluation of activities for which he has direct responsibility?). It is largely because of this that it has been suggested that outside consultants should be used to ensure impartiality. This is likely to prove expensive if done annually, and the answer is increasingly being seen to lie in a compromise whereby an outside consultant is used every third or fourth year, with line managers from different departments or divisions being used in the intervening periods. Alternatively, an organization might opt for what is in essence a composite approach, with an external auditor being used initially to validate line managers’ self-audits, and subsequently to integrate them to produce an audit result for the marketing function as a whole. To a large extent, however, it can be argued that the supposed difficulties of achieving impartiality are overstated since a sufficiently well-structured and institutionalized auditing process can overcome many of these difficulties. There is a need, therefore, for managers to be trained in how best to use auditing procedures and, very importantly, for the audit process to be endorsed by senior management. Without top management commitment to the audit process and, in turn, to the need to act on the results that emerge, the entire exercise is likely to prove valueless.
Regular auditing If the company is to benefit fully from the auditing process, it is essential that it be carried out on a regular basis. All too often in the past companies have been spurred into conducting an audit largely as the result of poor performance. Ironically, this poor performance can often be traced to a myopia on the part of management, stemming from a failure to review activities on a sufficiently regular basis – something that has been pointed to by Shuchman (1950), who commented that: ‘No marketing operation is ever so good that it cannot be improved. Even the best must be better, for few if any marketing operations can remain successful over the years by maintaining the status quo.’
But why bother with a marketing audit? Although we have so far argued the case for marketing auditing to be carried out on a regular basis, many organizations quite simply do not bother to do this until things go wrong. Most typically, this would be manifested in terms of declining sales, a loss of market share, under-utilized production capacity, a demoralized salesforce, reduced margins, and so on. Faced with these sorts of problems the temptation for management is to firefight and hence fall into the trap of crisis management. In many cases this is characterized by the rapid launching and dropping of products, price-cutting, and attempts at drastic cost reduction. While this sort of response will often have an immediate and apparent pay-off, it is unlikely that it will solve any
Conducting Effective Audits
underlying and fundamental problems. The audit is designed to avoid the need for crisis management by both identifying and defining these fundamental problems before they have any opportunity to affect the organization. Carrying out a regular and thorough marketing audit in a structured manner will therefore go a long way towards giving a company a knowledge of the business, the trends in the market, and where value is added by competitors, as a basis for setting objectives and strategies. These points have been highlighted in a summary of the ten most common findings of marketing audits: 1. A lack of knowledge of customers’ behaviour and attitudes 2. A failure to segment markets effectively 3. The absence of marketing planning procedures 4. Reductions in price rather than increases in volume 5. The absence of market-based procedures for evaluating products 6. Misunderstanding company marketing strengths 7. Short-term views of the role of promotion 8. A perception that marketing is limited just to advertising and sales activity 9. Inappropriate organizational structures 10. Insufficient investment in the future, particularly in the area of human resources.
The auditing process The auditing process should begin with agreement being reached between the organization’s marketing director and the marketing auditor – whether someone from inside or outside the organization – regarding the specific objectives, the breadth and depth of coverage, the sources of data, the report format and the time period for the audit. Included within this should be a plan of who is to be interviewed and the questions that are to be asked. With regard to the question of who is to be questioned, it needs to be emphasized that the audit should never be restricted to the company’s executives; it should also include customers, the dealer network, and other outside groups. In this way, a better and more complete picture of the company’s position and its effectiveness can be developed. In the case of customers and dealers, for example, the auditor should aim to develop satisfaction ratings that are capable of highlighting areas in need of attention. Once the information has been collected the findings and recommendations need to be presented, with emphasis being given to the type of action
107
108 CHAPTER 3: Marketing Auditing and the Analysis of Capability
needed to overcome any problems, the timescale over which remedial action is to be taken, and the names of those who are to be responsible for this.
Components of the audit Within the general framework of the external and internal audits, there is the need to focus upon six specific dimensions: These are: 1. The marketing environment audit. This involves an analysis of the major macroeconomic forces and trends within the organization’s task environment. This includes markets, customers, competitors, distributors, dealers, and suppliers. 2. The marketing strategy audit. This focuses upon a review of the organization’s marketing objectives and strategy, with a view to determining how well suited they are to the current and forecasted market environment. 3. The marketing organization audit. This aspect of the audit follows on from point (2), and is concerned specifically with an evaluation of the structural capability of the organization and its suitability for implementing the strategy needed for the developing environment. 4. The marketing systems audit. This covers the quality of the organization’s systems for analysis, planning and control. 5. The marketing productivity audit. This examines the profitability of different aspects of the marketing programme and the costeffectiveness of various levels of marketing expenditure. 6. The marketing functions audit. This involves a detailed evaluation of each of the elements of the marketing mix.
How are the audit results used? Having conducted the audit, the question that then arises is how best to use the results. In some companies a considerable amount of time, effort and expense is given over to the auditing process, but the corrective action that is then needed simply falls by the wayside. To ensure that the results are incorporated most effectively within the strategic planning process, the major findings of the audit need to be incorporated within an appropriate framework. This can be done in one of several ways, although undoubtedly the most useful are the SWOT and TOWS frameworks discussed earlier. This should focus on the key internal strengths and weaknesses in relation to the principal external opportunities and threats, and include a summary of the reasons for good or bad performance. It is against the background of this document that the strategist should begin planning at both the functional and the corporate levels.
Summary
3.7
SUMMARY
Within this chapter we have focused upon the role and structure of marketing auditing and SWOT and TOWS analysis. In doing this we have highlighted the way in which the marketing audit represents an important first step in the marketing planning process and how, as a result, the value of much of what follows within this process is determined by the thoroughness of the audit procedure. It is therefore essential that the audit exhibits a number of characteristics, the four most significant of which are that it is: 1. Comprehensive in its coverage of the elements of the organization’s marketing activity 2. Systematic 3. Independent 4. Conducted on a regular basis. The purpose of the audit is to provide the strategist with a clear understanding both of environmental opportunities and threats, and of the organization’s marketing capability. In doing this the strategist begins by focusing upon the principal macro-environmental forces (political/legal, economic/ demographic, social/cultural and technological) that affect the business. He then moves on to consider the micro-environmental actors (customers, competitors, distributors and suppliers) who influence the organization’s ability to operate effectively in the marketplace. The internal audit builds upon this by providing an understanding of the extent to which the organization, its structure and resources relate to the environment and have the capability of operating effectively within the constraints that the environment imposes. In addition to conducting the marketing audit, the strategist needs to carry out regular reviews of the organization’s marketing effectiveness. This can be done most readily by means of a checklist that embraces five principal areas: 1. The nature of the customer philosophy 2. The marketing organization 3. Marketing information 4. The strategic perspective 5. Operational efficiency. Against the background of the picture that emerges from the audit and the review of marketing effectiveness, the strategist should have a clear understanding of both the environment (opportunities and threats) and the organization’s marketing capability (strengths and weaknesses). It is this that provides the basis for subsequent marketing planning.
109
This page intentionally left blank
CHAPTER 4
Segmental, Productivity and Ratio Analysis
4.1
LEARNING OBJECTIVES
When you have read this chapter you should be able to: (a) understand how cost and profit analysis can be applied to marketing segments; (b) appreciate the role of marketing experimentation in improving the allocation of marketing effort; (c) recognize the value of segmental productivity analysis; (d) perceive critically how ratio analysis can be used in order to appreciate the current position; (e) appreciate the relevance of strategic benchmarking.
4.2
INTRODUCTION
In relation to the question ‘Where are we now?’, it is useful to know how resources have been utilized and with what returns. To this end, it helps to think of the organization as a bundle of projects or activities. This is relevant whether the organization is large or small, commercial or noncommercial, engaged in manufacturing or service rendering. Typical projects might be defined as: ■ ■ ■
Reformulation and relaunch of product X Continued market success with service Y The successful development and launch of project Z.
Strategic Marketing Planning Copyright © 2009 Colin Gilligan and Richard M.S. Wilson. All rights reserved.
111
112 CHAPTER 4: Segmental, Productivity and Ratio Analysis
We might go further and define projects or activities in terms of missions: a mission in this context represents the provision of a product or range of products at a particular level of service to a particular customer or customer group, in a particular area. Figure 4.1 illustrates this (see also Chapter 8). An organization’s mix of projects – or missions – will be constantly changing, and each has resource implications and profit consequences. For example, the scarcity of resources inevitably means that choices must be made in rationing available resources (whether in the form of funds, management time, etc.) among competing activities. It may be that new activities can only be adopted if old ones are deleted, thereby freeing resources. But how might a manager know which activities are worth retaining, which should be added to the portfolio, and which should be deleted? One starting point is to establish the cost and profit performance of each of the organization’s existing activities. We can think of cost as being equivalent in broad terms to effort, so what we are initially seeking to establish is how the available effort has been applied to the various activities in which the organization is engaged, and how productive this has been. Before we can really get to grips with this, however, we need to clarify our understanding of some important categories of cost (see Wilson, 1999, 2001).
Level of service Product Customer type Area
FIGURE 4.1 Multi-dimensional mission characteristics (from Barrett, 1980)
The Clarification of Cost Categories
4.3
THE CLARIFICATION OF COST CATEGORIES
Many of the costs of marketing are not satisfactorily identified, since marketing functions are not always carried out by the marketing department. (It could be argued – as was suggested in Chapter 1 – that any members of an organization who deal with customers are carrying out a marketing function even though they may not be recognized in any formal sense as members of the marketing staff.) This is one definitional problem, but not the only one. Another definitional problem concerns the traditional focus adopted by accountants, which puts product costing at the centre of their costing systems. This traditional preoccupation with the manufacturing costs of products and factory processes emphasizes the attributes of whatever is currently being made. Such an orientation fails to deal with patterns of consumer preferences and competitive positioning by market segment. The attributes of market segments – from which profit is derived – are fundamentally different from those attributes that characterize production processes. Any analysis based on product costing will generate insights that are limited by their origins, thereby failing to support marketing orientation. Whatever cost object (or activity) is selected as the focus of attention, some costs will be direct (in the sense of being traceable to the activity – such as direct labour, and direct material inputs into a unit of manufactured output, or a salesperson’s salary and expenses in relation to the sales territory in which that individual operates) while others will be indirect. By definition, indirect costs cannot be traced directly to cost objects, so any procedure whereby these costs are assigned to cost objects will mean that the resulting full (or ‘absorbed’) cost is inaccurate to an unknown extent. The assigning of a ‘fair share’ of indirect costs, along with direct costs, to cost objects is at the heart of absorption costing (of which activity-based costing, or ABC, is a variant). A particular cost item can only be termed direct or indirect once the cost object has been specified. This could be, for example, a particular market offering, a product range, a brand, a customer or customer group, a channel, a sales territory, an order, and so on. Thus a salesperson’s salary will be indirect in relation to the individual product lines sold (assuming the salesperson carries a range of products), but it will be a direct cost of the territory in which that individual is operating. In the same way, the costs of distributing various products to wholesalers may be indirect with regard to the goods themselves but direct if costing the channel of distribution of which the wholesalers are part. The same basic problems arise in attempting to determine the full cost of a cost object in every type of organization, whether a service company, a retailing enterprise, a factory or a non-commercial entity. For example, a garage (as one type of service organization) will treat the servicing of each customer’s car as a separate job (or cost object), to which will be assigned the direct cost of the mechanic’s time, materials, and parts, plus an allowance (usually applied
113
114 CHAPTER 4: Segmental, Productivity and Ratio Analysis
as an hourly rate and associated with the utilization of mechanics’ time) for the use of indirect factors (including power, equipment, rent, rates, insurance, salaries of reception, supervisory and stores staff, etc.). A similar approach is applied by firms of solicitors or accountants, by consulting engineers, architects and management consultants. Non-commercial organizations typically provide services (such as healthcare, defence, education and spiritual guidance) and use resources in carrying out their various activities in much the same way as do commercial undertakings. The logic of absorption costing is equally applicable to non-commercial as to commercial enterprises.
4.4 MARKETING COST ANALYSIS: AIMS AND METHODS Establishing a base line for marketing planning can be seen to be concerned with the allocation of total marketing effort to cost objects (also known as segments), along with the profit consequences of these allocations. It is generally found, however, that companies do not know the profit performance of segments in marketing terms. Useful computations of marketing costs and profit contributions in the multi-product company require the adoption of analytical techniques that are not difficult in principle, but are not widely adopted in practice on account of, inter alia, the preoccupation with factory cost accounting that exists. The fact that most companies do not know what proportion of their total marketing outlay is spent on each product, sales territory or customer group may be due to the absence of a sufficiently refined system of cost analysis, or it may be due to vagueness over the nature of certain costs. For instance, is the cost of packaging a promotional, a production or a distribution expense? Some important marketing costs are hidden in manufacturing costs or in general and administrative costs, including finished goods inventory costs in the former and order-processing costs in the latter. Since few companies are aware of costs and profits by segment in relation to sales levels, and since even fewer are able to predict changes in sales volume and profit contribution as a result of changes in marketing effort, the following errors arise: 1. Marketing budgets for individual products are too large, with the result that diminishing returns become evident and benefits would accrue from a reduction in expenditure 2. Marketing budgets for individual products are too small and increasing returns would result from an increase in expenditure 3. The marketing mix is inefficient, with an incorrect balance and incorrect amounts being spent on the constituent elements – such as too much on advertising and insufficient on direct selling activities
Marketing Cost Analysis: Aims and Methods
4. Marketing efforts are misallocated among missions and changes in these cost allocations (even with a constant level of overall expenditure) could bring improvements. Similar arguments apply in relation to sales territories or customer groups as well as to products. The need exists, therefore, for planning and control techniques to indicate the level of performance required and achieved as well as the outcome of shifting marketing efforts from one segment to another. As is to be expected, there exists great diversity in the methods by which managers attempt to obtain costs (and profits) for segments of their business, but in large part the cost data are inaccurate for such reasons as those listed below: ■
Marketing costs may be allocated to individual products, sales territories, customer groups, etc., on the basis of sales value or sales volume, but this involves circular reasoning. Costs should be allocated in relation to causal factors, and it is order-getting marketing expenditures that cause sales to be made rather than the other way round: managerial decisions determine order-getting marketing costs. A different pattern typically applies to order-filling (e.g. logistics) costs, since sales volume will cause (or drive) order-filling costs: order-getting → sales volume → order-filling. Furthermore, despite the fact that success is so often measured in terms of sales value achievements by product line, this basis fails to evaluate the efficiency of the effort needed to produce the realized sales value (or turnover). Even a seemingly high level of turnover for a specific product may really be a case of misallocated sales effort. (An example should make this clear: if a sales representative concentrates on selling Product A, which contributes £50 per hour of effort, instead of selling Product B, which would contribute £120 per hour of effort, then it ‘costs’ the company £70 for each hour spent on selling Product A. This is the opportunity cost of doing one thing rather than another, and is a measure of the sacrifice involved in selecting only one of several alternative courses of action.)
■
General indirect and administrative costs are arbitrarily (and erroneously) allocated to segments on the basis of sales volume.
■
Many marketing costs are not allocated at all as marketing costs since they are not identified as such but are classified as manufacturing, general or administrative costs instead.
Marketing cost analysis has been developed to help overcome these problems, and aims to: 1. Analyse the costs incurred in marketing goods/services (embracing order-getting and order-filling aspects) so that, when they are combined with product cost data, overall profit can be determined
115
116 CHAPTER 4: Segmental, Productivity and Ratio Analysis
2. Analyse the costs of marketing individual product lines to determine profit by product line 3. Analyse the costs involved in serving different classes of customers, different territories and other segments to determine their relative profit performance 4. Compute such figures as cost per sales call, cost per order, cost to put a new customer on the books, cost to hold £1’s worth of inventory for a year, etc. 5. Evaluate managers according to their actual controllable cost responsibilities 6. Evaluate alternative strategies or plans with full costs. These analyses and evaluations provide senior management with the necessary information to enable them to raise questions regarding which classes of customer to cultivate, which market offerings to delete or encourage, which channels may be preferable and so forth. Such analyses also provide a basis from which estimates may be developed of the likely increases in sales volume, value or profit (i.e. outputs) that a specified increase in marketing effort (i.e. input) might create. In the normal course of events, it is far more difficult to predict the outcome of decisions that involve changes in marketing outlays in comparison with changes in production expenditure. It is easier, for instance, to estimate the effect of a new machine in the factory than it is to predict the impact of higher advertising outlays. Similarly, the effect on productive output of dropping a production worker is easier to estimate than is the effect on the level of sales caused by a reduction in the sales force. The basic approach of marketing cost analysis is similar to that of product costing. Two stages are involved (see Figure 4.2): 1. Marketing costs are initially reclassified from their natural expense headings (e.g. salaries) into functional cost groups (e.g. sales expenses) in such a way that each cost group brings together all the costs associated with a particular marketing activity 2. These functional cost groups are then apportioned to the cost object/ segment of interest (e.g. product lines, customer groups, channels of distribution, etc.) on the basis of measurable criteria that bear as close an approximation as possible to a causal relationship with the total amounts of the functional cost groups. Once the natural indirect expenses have been reclassified on a functional basis, they are then charged to the segment in line with the usual benefit criterion (i.e. the segment is only allocated with that portion of each functional cost group that can be related to it on some approximation of a
Marketing Cost Analysis: Aims and Methods
Phase 1 Assign costs to functions
Phase 2 Assign functional costs to segment
Segment revenue minus
Costs of Function A
Indirect Costs incurred
Costs of Function B
Full cost of segment
Costs of Function C Direct gives Net profit
FIGURE 4.2 Determining segmental costs (from Wilson and Chua, 1993)
cause and effect basis). The logical basis of allocation may be apparent from an analysis of the underlying data, but it is important to observe that some costs vary with the characteristics of one type of segment only. Thus inventory costs depend on the characteristics of products rather than on those of customers, whereas the cost of credit depends on the financial integrity and number of customers rather than on regional factors. Accordingly, not all functional costs should be allocated to products, customers and territorial segments. Allocation should only be made when an actual or imputed cause and effect relationship between an underlying activity and some resultant cost that is relevant to the segment(s) can be identified. It must be remembered when using marketing cost analysis that any cost allocation involves a certain degree of arbitrariness, which means that an element of approximation is inevitably contained within the allocation. Furthermore, it remains necessary to supplement the analysis of marketing costs with other relevant information and with managerial judgement. Marketing cost analysis is the joint responsibility of the financial controller and the marketing manager, with the financial controller supplying most of the information and the marketing manager supplying most of the judgement. Nevertheless, the marketing manager must be fully aware of the method and limitations of marketing cost analysis. The high cost of establishing and maintaining a marketing costing system is justified by the benefits derived from increasing the efficiency of marketing effort. The risks involved in adopting marketing cost analysis before the benefits have been
117
118 CHAPTER 4: Segmental, Productivity and Ratio Analysis
demonstrated can be reduced by initially confining the analysis to a sample of products, customers or territories, and by making periodic rather than continuous analyses. Since a fundamental objective of marketing cost analysis lies in increasing the productivity of expenditures and not necessarily in their reduction, the manager who wishes to introduce marketing cost analysis must emphasize the desire to make better use of existing resources rather than reducing future budgets. The integration of marketing costing with marketing research can assist in this matter. Confining any costing system to data provided from accounting records risks forcing that system to be historical, but marketing research can provide estimates of future outcomes resulting from variations in marketing effort (with or without experimentation and the building of complex models), which enable the efficiency of alternate expenditure patterns to be pre-determined and evaluated in accordance with corporate aims. See Illustration 4.1. Illustration 4.1
My biggest mistake (David Bruce)
(David Bruce, 42, failed his maths ‘O’ level five times before leaving school to work for a brewery. In 1979, he came off the dole queue to open the Goose and Firkin pub in London after raising a loan against his home. By 1988 he had built a chain of 18 pubs, which he sold for £6.6 m, intending to retire with his £2 m share. However, he could not resist going back into business and is now trading as Inn Securities and building up a chain of Hedgehog and Hogsheads pubs outside London.) My biggest mistake was not paying proper attention to my accounts in the early days of the Firkin pubs. We had opened the Goose and Firkin in London in 1979, and I was working 18 lousy hours a day, seven days a week, brewing the beer in the cellar and surviving on adrenalin. I had eight staff and a part-time book-keeper. Everybody said the pub would not work, but people were queuing to get in. It was tremendously exciting and I was on a complete high. The tills were ringing, my break-even point was £2500 a week, but the pub never did less than £4500. So why, I thought, if one has created this extraordinary thing, should one scuttle back home to Battersea and spend hours doing boring old paperwork? The turnover was so good I did not even bother with profit and loss accounts. (And you have to bear in mind that I did not have a natural aptitude for figures.) In May 1980, I opened the Fox and Firkin in Lewisham. I trained a brewer to look after the Goose, but he promptly broke his leg, leaving me to deal with both pubs. There was even less time to do paperwork. Then I opened another pub in London and, because the experts doomed us to failure I thought it would be easier if the pubs traded under separate companies. Each one had a different accounting year – it was a good lesson in how not to run a business. By the time we had opened our fourth pub in 1981, our solicitors, Bishop and Sewell, had watched our progress with great interest and assumed we were incurring a hideous tax bill, so they suggested we met with accountants Touche
An Illustration of Segmental Analysis
Ross. My wife, Louise, and I went along with what little financial information we had, plus a couple of audits that showed we had traded at a loss from day one. In fact, while the turnover for the first year was £1 m, we had made losses of £86 000. One of their corporate finance partners said that if I did not appoint a chartered accountant to the board as financial director immediately we would go bust within a couple of months. So I took on someone from a major brewery, who introduced systems such as stock control and weekly profit and loss accounts. But that did not solve the immediate problems. Touche Ross also said I would have to sell one of the pubs, the Fleece and Firkin in Bristol, because it was costing too much in time and money. Reluctantly I put it on the market. By now it was obvious that I should have appointed a finance director at the beginning. The bank was getting nervous, my borrowings were rising, and I was not producing a profit. If the bank had pulled the rug we would have gone down personally for £500 000. Touche Ross advised me to sell a small percentage of the equity, which of course I did not want to do. Eventually I struck a satisfactory deal with 3i (Investors in Industry), which bought 10 per cent of the business and gave us a loan. Better cash control enabled us to turn a loss into a profit, and the following year, on a turnover of £1.6 m, we showed a profit of £47 000. Touche Ross, who charged us under £5000 to sort the problem out, have done my audits ever since. Paul Adams, our managing director, is the resident chartered accountant. He has kept costs down and introduced budgets that the staff can stick to. In hindsight the solutions were obvious, but I was the victim of my own success. If the turnover had not been so good, I would have realized a lot sooner how close I was to bankruptcy. Source: As told to journalist Corinne Simcock, The Independent on Sunday: Business, 16 December 1990, p. 20.
4.5
AN ILLUSTRATION OF SEGMENTAL ANALYSIS
As discussed above, a segment is any cost object that is of interest, and is synonymous with the notion of activity, project or mission as appropriate. Thus, for example, marketing segments may be one – or a combination – of the following: ■
Product line or range
■
Channel of distribution
■
Sales representative or territory
■
Customer or customer/industry group
■
Size of order.
It is possible to vary the degree of aggregation of segments, as shown in Figure 4.3. Initially the segment of interest must be selected (e.g. territory,
119
120 CHAPTER 4: Segmental, Productivity and Ratio Analysis
Level
Segment
Corporate
ABC Ltd
Division
Machine tools
Electronics
Territory
North
South
Market
Home computers
Calculators
Product
Business
Scientific
Customer
Wholesaler
Retailer
Size of order
Large
Small
FIGURE 4.3 Segmental levels (adapted from Ratnatunga, 1983)
customer, etc.), and then the preferred approach to costing. Essentially there are two major alternatives: 1. Absorption (or full) costing 2. Variable (or direct or marginal) costing. Our earlier discussion dealt with the first of these, and we saw that this approach involves charging both direct and a portion of indirect costs to the segment in question. When set against the segment’s revenue, the result is a net profit figure. Figure 4.4 provides an example of the net profit picture in an organization operating through three different channels of distribution. The net profit figure reflects the result of the allocation of effort as shown by the total of: ■
Costs of goods sold
■
Direct marketing costs
■
Indirect marketing costs.
Once this allocation has been set against the revenue figure, channel by channel, it is evident that the validity of the net profit figures that emerge
Customer Profitability Analysis
£’000s
B
A 875 325
Revenue Cost of goods sold
265 330
C
950 285
550
Gross profit Direct marketing costs Indirect marketing costs
Total
Channel
1,225 490
665 245 275
3,050 1,100
735 450 250
1,950 960 855
Total marketing costs
595
520
700
1,815
Net profit
(45)
145
35
135
FIGURE 4.4 Profit analysis by channel
depend critically upon the adequacy of the means by which indirect costs are apportioned.
4.6 AN ALTERNATIVE APPROACH TO SEGMENTAL ANALYSIS The alternative approach to segmental analysis is the variable costing approach, in which only direct costs are allocated to arrive at a measure of profit known as marketing contribution. The data from Figure 4.4 have been reworked in Figure 4.5 to illustrate the variable costing approach. It has been assumed that the cost of goods sold figures in Figure 4.4 included £700 000 of variable manufacturing costs; that the direct costs are all of a marketing nature and can be split into fixed and variable components as shown in Figure 4.5, and that the indirect costs are all non-allocable to channels. The result is a clear statement that sufficient revenue is being generated via each channel to cover the variable costs and the directly allocable fixed costs. Moreover, there is sufficient total contribution to cover the indirect costs and the fixed manufacturing costs while still making a net profit of £135 000.
4.7
CUSTOMER PROFITABILITY ANALYSIS
An approach to segmental analysis that is of increasing interest is customer profitability analysis (CPA). If marketing effort is to be directed at customers or market segments with the greatest profit potential, it is essential that marketing
121
122 CHAPTER 4: Segmental, Productivity and Ratio Analysis
£’000s
Channel A
B
Total C
Revenue Variable COGS
875 225
950 175
1,225 300
3,050 700
Manufacturing contribution Variable direct marketing costs
650 115
775 105
925 190
2,350 410
Variable contribution Fixed direct marketing costs
535 150
670 140
735 260
1,940 550
Marketing contribution Indirect costs Fixed manufacturing costs
385
530
475
1,390 855 400
Net profit
135
FIGURE 4.5 A direct costing profit statement
managers have information showing both the existing picture with regard to customer profitability and prospects for the future. Customer profitability analysis has been defined (Anandarajan and Christopher, 1987, p. 86) as: the evaluation, analysis and isolation of: ■
all the significant costs associated with servicing a specific customer/group of customers from the point an order is received through manufacture to ultimate delivery;
■
the revenues associated with doing business with those specific customers/customer groups.
The implementation of CPA can be achieved by a series of steps that parallel the steps suggested earlier for other types of segmental analysis. In outline, these steps are: ■
Step 1 – clearly define customer groups and market segments in a way that distinguishes the needs of customers in one group from those of customers in another group.
■
Step 2 – for the customer groups or market segments of interest, identify those factors that cause variations in the costs of servicing those customers. This can be done by identifying the key elements of the marketing mix used for each customer group or segment, from which some indication of the costs of servicing each group should be drawn.
Customer Profitability Analysis
■
Step 3 – analyse the ways in which service offerings are differentiated between customer groups. For example, terms of trade may vary between home-based and overseas customers, or between large and small customers, as might the level of service (i.e. speed of delivery) to key accounts.
■
Step 4 – clearly identify the resources that have been used to support each customer group or segment (including personnel, warehouse facilities, administrative back-up, etc.).
■
Step 5 – determine ways in which the costs of resources (Step 4) can be attributed to customer groups.
■
Step 6 – relate revenues and costs to each customer group, with profit emerging as the difference.
The total of the costs for a given customer group is a measure of the effort that has been allocated to that group, and the profit is a measure of the return from that effort. Until the existing pattern of allocation is known, along with its profitability, it is not possible to devise ways of improving that allocation. See Illustration 4.2.
Illustration 4.2
Evolution
New technologies are beginning to make mass customization feasible, and information systems are allowing us to identify the profitability of each customer. Tower Records recently started offering its customers the top 40 lines of groceries. It was a publicity stunt, of course – a protest at the way supermarkets have started cherry picking their business by selling records from the Top 40 chart. Tower’s initiative amounts to little more than a puff of hot air, but behind it lies an issue of growing importance. Cherry picking is hardly new, but its extent and nature are changing. Increasingly the most aggressive and successful cherry pickers are coming from ‘outside’ the industry concerned – and as such these are invaders with a difference. They’re changing the nature of the market itself. To see what’s happening, we need to take a step back. Consider, for example, how people acquired their clothes 50 years ago. Basically, they had three ways to do it. First, if they were rich, they could go to their tailor, who provided a high quality, high convenience, high service offer, with bespoke fitting at a high price. Secondly, you could buy mass manufactured garments, which offered standard quality and standard sizes at low prices but with low service and low convenience. Thirdly, you could make them yourself, buying cloth and thread and slaving over a hot sewing machine. This way you got bespoke fitting at a very low price, but the service and convenience elements were reduced. Buying bespoke Since then, mass manufacturing has swept nearly all before it. Its ongoing technological revolution has forced down prices and improved quality at such a
123
124 CHAPTER 4: Segmental, Productivity and Ratio Analysis
rate that ‘Royal’ service and DIY have (in most sectors) become tiny niches for the very rich and the very poor respectively. Economies of scale were worth it, but came at a price. Everything was standardized and averaged, and there was, to varying degrees, cross-subsidization between customers. Today, that’s changing. As new technologies are increasing the feasibility of mass customization and information systems are allowing identification of individual customer profitability, marketers are rightly questioning the validity of the mass production trade-off. Inspired by the total quality movement (‘you can have better quality and lower prices’), they’re racing to offer Royal, bespoke products and services at standard prices – an inspiring agenda that will keep them busy for decades. At the same time, they’re realizing that their customer base usually falls into three groups. The first group (let’s call them the Superprofits) actually generates 150 per cent of their profits even though it only accounts for, say, 60 per cent of customers, and makes a crucial contribution to overheads even if its profitability is marginal. The third group actually costs money to serve. De-averaging is now the order of the day. The big drive now is to ‘fire’ or otherwise lose the loss makers while going all out to deepen the relationship with the Superprofits. So far, so good. This is classic segmentation taken to its next logical level. But de-averaging has a sting in the tail. In many a company it threatens to set off a chain reaction that unravels the ties that bound it together into a single entity in the first place. Instead of having one mass production