Studies in Empirical Economics
Studies in Empirical Economics Aman Ullah (Ed.) Semiparametric and Nonparametric Econometrics 1989. ISBN 978-3-7908-0418-8
Thomas Url and Andreas Wörgötter (Eds.) Econometrics of Short and Unreliable Time Series 1995. ISBN 978-3-7908-0879-7
Walter Krämer (Ed.) Econometrics of Structural Change 1989. ISBN 978-3-7908-0432-4
Steven Durlauf, John F. Helliwell and Baldev Raj (Eds.) Long-Run Economic Growth 1996. ISBN 978-3-7908-0959-6
Wolfgang Franz (Ed.) Hysteresis Effects in Economic Models 1990. ISBN 978-3-7908-0482-9 John Piggott and John Whalley (Eds.) Applied General Equilibrium 1991. ISBN 978-3-7908-0530-7 Baldev Raj and Badi H. Baltagi (Eds.) Panel Data Analysis 1992. ISBN 978-3-7908-0593-2
Daniel J. Slortje and Baldev Raj (Eds.) Income Inequality Poverty and Economic Welfare 1998. ISBN 978-3-7908-1136-0 Robin Boadway and Baldev Raj (Eds.) Advances in Public Economics 2000. ISBN 978-3-7908-1283-1
Josef Christl The Unemployment/Vacancy Curve 1992. ISBN 978-3-7908-0625-0
Bernd Fitzenberger, Roger Koenker and Jos é A. E. Machado (Eds.) Economic Applications of Quantile Regression 2002. ISBN 978-3-7908-1448-4
Jürgen Kaehler and Peter Kugler (Eds.) Econometric Analysis of Financial Markets 1994. ISBN 978-3-7908-0740-0
James D. Hamilton and Baldev Raj (Eds.) Advances in Markov-Switching Models 2002. ISBN 978-3-7908-1515-3
Klaus F. Zimmermann (Ed.) Output and Employment Fluctuations 1994. ISBN 978-3-7908-0754-7
Badi H. Baltagi (Ed.) Panel Data 2004. ISBN 978-3-7908-0142-2
Jean-Marie Dufour and Baldev Raj (Eds.) New Developments In Time Series Econometrics 1994. ISBN 978-3-7908-0766-0
Luc Bauwens, Winfried Pohlmeier and David Veredas (Eds.) High Frequency Financial Econometrics 2008. ISBN 978-3-7908-1991-5
John D. Hey (Ed.) Experimental Economics 1994. ISBN 978-3-7908-0810-0
Christian Dustmann, Bernd Fitzenberger and Stephen Machin (Eds.) The Economics of Education and Training 2008. ISBN 978-3-7908-2021-8
Arno Riedl, Georg Winckler and Andreas Wörgötter (Eds.) Macroeconomic Policy Games 1995. ISBN 978-3-7908-0857-5
Giuseppe Arbia · Badi H. Baltagi (Eds.)
Spatial Econometrics Methods and Applications
Physica-Verlag A Springer Company
Editorial Board Heather M. Anderson Australian National University Canberra, Australia
Bernd Fitzenberger University of Freiburg Germany
Badi H. Baltagi Syracuse University Syracuse, New York, USA
Robert M. Kunst Institute for Advanced Studies Vienna, Austria
Editors
Professor Giuseppe Arbia University “G. d’Annunzio” of Chieti-Pescara Department of the Business, Statistical, Technological and Environment Sciences Viale Pindaro, 42 65127 Pescara Italy
[email protected]
Professor Badi H. Baltagi Syracuse University Center for Policy Research 426 Eggers Hall Syracuse, NY 13244-1020 USA
[email protected]
All papers have been first published in “Empirical Economics”
ISBN 978-3-7908-2069-0
e-ISBN 978-3-7908-2070-6
Library of Congress Control Number: 2008935139 Physica-Verlag Heidelberg 2009 This work is subject to copyright. All rights are reserved, whether the whole or part of the material is concerned, specifically the rights of translation, reprinting, reuse of illustrations, recitation, roadcasting, reproduction on microfilm or in any other way, and storage in data banks. Duplication of this publication or parts thereof is permitted only under the provisions of the German Copyright Law of September 9, 1965, in its current version, and permission for use must always be obtained from Physica-Verlag. Violations are liable to prosecution under the German Copyright Law. The use of general descriptive names, registered names, trademarks, etc. in this publication does not imply, even in the absence of a specific statement, that such names are exempt from the relevant protective laws and regulations and therefore free for general use. Cover Design: WMXDesign GmbH, Heidelberg, Germany Printed on acid-free paper 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 springer.com
Contents
1.
Introduction ......................................................................................................... 1 Badi H. Baltagi and Giuseppe Arbia
2
Errors in Variables and Spatial Effects in Hedonic House Price Models of Ambient Air Quality .......................................................................... 5 Luc Anselin and Nancy Lozano-Gracia
3.
A Generalized Method of Moments Estimator for a Spatial Model with Moving Average Errors, with Application to Real Estate Prices.............. 35 Bernard Fingleton
4.
Spatial Analysis of Urban Growth in Spain, 1900–2001 .................................. 59 Julie Le Gallo and Coro Chasco
5.
A Class of Spatial Econometric Methods in the Empirical Analysis of Clusters of Firms in the Space........................................................................... 81 Giuseppe Arbia, Giuseppe Espa, and Danny Quah
6.
A Spatially-Filtered Mixture of -Convergence Regressions for European Regions, 1980–2002........................................................................ 105 Michele Battisti and Gianfranco Di Vaio
7.
Spatial Shift-Share Analysis Versus Spatial Filtering: An Application to Spanish Employment Data ................................................ 123 Matías Mayor and Ana Jesús López
8.
R&D Spillovers and Firms’ Performance in Italy: Evidence from a Flexible Production Function............................................... 143 Francesco Aiello and Paola Cardamone
vi
Contents
9.
The Impact of Decentralization and Inter-Territorial Interactions on Spanish Health Expenditure ................................................... 167 Joan Costa-Font and Francesco Mosconey
10. Regional Evidence on Financial Development, Finance Term Structure and Growth............................................................................. 185 Andrea Vaona 11. Convergence in Per-Capita GDP Across European Regions: A Reappraisal .................................................................................................. 203 Valentina Meliciani and Franco Peracchi 12. Locational Choice and Price Competition: Some Empirical Results for the Austrian Retail Gasoline Market ............................................ 223 Gerhard Clemenz and Klaus Gugler 13. Dynamic Spatial Modelling of Regional Convergence Processes .................. 245 Reinhold Kosfeld and Jorgen Lauridsen 14. Spatial and Supply/Demand Agglomeration Economies: State- and Industry-Linkages in the U.S. Food System .................................. 263 Jeffrey P. Cohen and Catherine J. Morrison Paul
Introduction Badi H. Baltagi · Giuseppe Arbia
Most of the papers appearing in this book also appeared in a special issue of Empirical Economics on spatial econometrics. These papers were solicited from the International Workshop on Spatial Econometrics and Statistics held at LUISS “Guido Carli University” in Rome, Italy, 25–27 May, 2006. This conference also saw the birth of the Spatial Econometric Association. The Association’s aim is to promote the development of theoretical tools and sound applications of the discipline of spatial econometrics, including spatial statistics and spatial data analysis. Spatial econometrics should be viewed in a wide sense involving developments of models and statistical tools for the analysis of externalities, spillovers, interactions etc., in various areas including economics, geography and regional science, etc. (from the By-laws of the Association). In addition, we include four papers on spatial econometrics that appeared in regular issues of Empirical Economics over the period 2003–2006. This book includes methodology papers, see Fingelton’s paper which generalizes the GMM estimator proposed by Kelejian and Prucha (1999) for the spatial regression model with autoregressive errors (SARAR) to a spatial autoregressive model with moving average errors (SARMA). Also, Arbia, Espa and Quah who provide new statistical tools to study the complex interaction between spatial concentration, regional growth and knowledge spillovers. This book also includes applications of spatial econometrics to (1) the valuation of the effect of improved air quality through the
B. H. Baltagi (B) Center for Policy Research, Syracuse University, 426 Eggers Hall, Syracuse, NY 13244-1020, USA e-mail:
[email protected] G. Arbia Department of the Business, Statistical, Technological and Environmental Sciences, University “G. d’Annunzio” of Chieti–Pescara, Viale Pindaro 42, 65127 Pescara, Italy e-mail:
[email protected]
2
B. H. Baltagi, G. Arbia
estimation of hedonic models of house prices, see Anselin and Lozano-Gracia, (2) the evolution of population growth in Spain, see Le Gallo and Chasco, (3) the -convergence model across EU regions, see Battisti and Di Vaio, convergence in per-capita GDP across European regions, see Meliciani and Peracchi, and conditional income and productivity convergence across labour market regions in unified Germany, see Kosfeld and Lauridsen, (4) the evolution of regional employment in Spain, see Mayor and López, (5) the impact of R&D spillovers on production in Italian manufacturing, see Aiello and Cardamone, (6) the economic determinants of health care activity in Spain, see Costa-Font and Moscone, (7) the finance-growth nexus in Italy, see Vaona, (8) the Austrian retail gasoline market, see Clemenz and Gugler, and (9) supply/demand agglomeration economies in the U.S. food system, see Cohen and Morrison Paul.
Summary of the Contributions Anselin and Lozano–Gracia consider the valuation of the effect of improved air quality through the estimation of hedonic models of house prices. Since the potential errors in variables aspect of the interpolated air pollution measures is often ignored, this paper assesses the extent to which this may affect the resulting empirical estimates for marginal willingness to pay (MWTP). It uses an extensive sample of over 100,000 individual house sales for 1999 in the South Coast Air Quality Management District of Southern California. This paper takes into account of spatial dependence and endogeneity. It also accounts for both spatial autocorrelation and heteroskedasticity in the error terms, using the Kelejian–Prucha HAC estimator. Their results are consistent across different spatial weights matrices and different kernel functions and suggest that the bias from ignoring the endogeneity in interpolated values may be substantial. Fingleton generalizes the GMM estimator proposed by Kelejian and Prucha (1999) for the spatial regression model with autoregressive errors (SARAR) to a spatial autoregressive model with moving average errors (SARMA). Monte Carlo experiments are performed which suggest that the GMM estimates behave well and are robust to non-normality. Fingleton also suggests the Bootstrap method as a way of testing the significance of the moving average parameter. The SARMA model is applied to English real estate price data, providing evidence that price levels depend on the level of income both locally and within commuting distance, on local school quality, and on the stock of properties within the area. Fingleton finds a significant effect attributable to the spatial lag of prices, which is interpreted as the net outcome of the displacement of demand and of supply between areas. The moving average error process represents spatially autocorrelated unmodelled variables. Le Gallo and Chasco study the evolution of population growth in Spain using a group of 722 municipalities over the period 1900–2001. In particular, they obtain non-parametric kernel density estimates of the urban population distribution for each decade and analyze its monomodality or multimodality characteristics. They estimate a spatial SUR model for Zipf’s law and show the existence of two main phases: divergence (1900–1980) and convergence (1980–2001). Zipf’s law, or the rank-size rule, claims that the size distribution of cities follows a Pareto law. The density functions and Zipf’s law allow the characterization of the evolution of the global
Introduction
3
distribution, but they do not provide any information about the movements of the urban municipalities within this distribution. This is done by tracking the evolution of each urban municipality’s relative size over time and estimating transition probability matrices associated with discrete Markov chains. Spatial effects are introduced within the Markov chain framework using regional conditioning. This analysis shows a low interclass mobility, i.e. a high-persistence of urban municipalities to stay in their own class from one decade to another over the whole period, and the influence of the geographical environment on urban population dynamism. Studies of knowledge spillovers have received increasing importance in the literature on economic growth. In fact some theories explicitly link the presence of innovations to the growth of cities, seen as the places where the big concentration of individuals, firms and workers create positive externalities which, in turn, foster economic growth. A large part of the empirical literature concentrated on measuring the impact of technological spillovers on the innovation performances of regions. In many instances the number of patents and the relative citations have been used as proxies of the flow of knowledge and of the related innovative output. Arbia, Espa and Quah show the importance of distance based measures of spatial concentration in tackling this important emerging research area. They provide new statistical tools to study the complex interaction between spatial concentration, regional growth and knowledge spillovers. The empirical application involves a study of the inter– sectoral location of innovation in Italy based on the European Patent Office (EPO) dataset which records all patent applications in Europe. They are able to identify some distinctive joint patterns of location between patents of different sectors and to propose some possible economic interpretations. Battisti and Di Vaio apply a spatially filtered mixture regression approach to the -convergence model across EU regions over the period 1980–2002. Their results indicate that spatial effects matter, and that absolute, conditional, or club convergence, are restrictive assumptions when applied to the whole sample. Excluding a small number of regions that behave as outliers, only a few regions show an appreciable rate of convergence. The majority of data show slow convergence much lower than 2%, or no convergence at all. Mayor and López analyze the influence of spatial effects in the evolution of regional employment in Spain. Two non-parametric techniques are used: spatial shift-share analysis and spatial filtering. Advantages and limitations of each of these procedures are discussed, along with their sensitivity with regards to the considered weights matrix. Aiello and Cardamone study the impact of R&D spillovers on production for a balanced panel of 1,203 Italian manufacturing firms over the period 1998–2003. Estimation is based on a translog production function augmented by a measure of R&D spillovers that combines the geographical distance and the technological similarity within each pair of firms. In particular, they calculate the R&D spillovers as the weighted sum of indirect stock R&D capital. The weighting scheme uses an index of similarity for each pair of firms. The hypothesis is that the more similar the two firms are, the greater the flow of innovation between them. The paper finds that the contribution of R&D spillovers to firms’ production is positive. This is robust to
4
B. H. Baltagi, G. Arbia
the weighting scheme of knowledge transmission and the sample of firms used. They also show that geographical proximity matters. Costa-Font and Moscone examine the influence of a set of institutional, political and economic determinants of health care activity in Spain. This is done using panel data on Spanish health care expenditure at the regional level over the period 1995– 2002. Results are consistent with some degree of interdependence between neighboring regions in spending decisions. Spatial interactions among regions seem to play a role in explaining total expenditure and its major categories (pharmaceutical, inpatient, and ambulatory). Empirical evidence of long term efficiency effects of health care decentralization suggests that a specific spatialinstitutional design might improve the health system efficiency as well as regional cohesion. Vaona considers the finance-growth nexus and offers regional evidence on this issue by using cross-sectional and panel data sets of respectively 94 and 73 Italian provinces (NUTS3 regions). Vaona argues that finance leads growth, and is robust to spatial unobserved heterogeneity. Economic growth appears to be favoured by credit to private firms and more by short-term credit than by long-term credit. Meliciani and Peracchi study the convergence in per-capita GDP across European regions over the period 1980–2000. They use median unbiased estimators of the rate of convergence to the steady-state growth path, while allowing for unrestricted patterns of heterogeneity and spatial correlation across regions. Their results differ from those found using conventional estimators in that the mean rate of convergence is much lower, and for most regions this rate is zero. Also, the number of regions for which they reject equality in trend growth rates is substantially lower. They also find significant evidence of correlation of growth rates across neighboring regions and across regions belonging to the same country. Clemenz and Gugler use data from the Austrian retail gasoline market to find that a higher station density reduces average prices. Also, that market (i.e. ownership) concentration does not significantly affect average price, and is negatively related to the density of stations. They argue that the spatial dimension of markets allows the identification of market conduct, which is particularly relevant for competition policy. Kosfeld and Lauridsen introduce a dynamic spatial modelling approach which is suitable to trace regional adjustment processes in space instead of time. It is shown how the spatial error-correction mechanism (SEC model) can be estimated depending on the spatial stationarity properties of the variables under investigation. This is applied to the issue of conditional income and productivity convergence across labour market regions in unified Germany. Cohen and Morrison Paul study cost-impacts of spatial and industrial spillovers on economic performance. These are evaluated by incorporating activity level measures for nearby states and related industries into a cost function model. The focus is on localization and urbanization economies for state level food processing industries, from activity levels of similar industries in neighboring states, agricultural input suppliers, and final product demand. They find significant costsavings from proximity to other food manufacturing centers, and areas with high purchasing power.
Errors in variables and spatial effects in hedonic house price models of ambient air quality Luc Anselin · Nancy Lozano-Gracia
Abstract In the valuation of the effect of improved air quality through the estimation of hedonic models of house prices, the potential “errors in variables” aspect of the interpolated air pollution measures is often ignored. In this paper, we assess the extent to which this may affect the resulting empirical estimates for marginal willingness to pay (MWTP), using an extensive sample of over 100,000 individual house sales for 1999 in the South Coast Air Quality Management District of Southern California. We
This paper is part of a joint research effort with James Murdoch (University of Texas, Dallas) and Mark Thayer (San Diego State University). Their valuable input is gratefully acknowledged. The research was supported in part by NSF Grant BCS-9978058 to the Center for Spatially Integrated Social Science (CSISS), and by NSF/EPA Grant SES-0084213. Earlier versions were presented at the 5th International Workshop on Spatial Econometrics and Statistics, Rome, Italy, May 2006, the 53th North American Meetings of the Regional Science Association International, Toronto, ON, Nov. 2006, the 2007 Meetings of the Allied Social Science Assocations, Chicago, IL, Jan 2007, and at departmental seminars at the University of Illinois. Comments by discussants and participants are greatly appreciated. A special thanks to Harry Kelejian for his detailed and patient clarification of the HAC estimator. The usual disclaimer holds. L. Anselin (B) School of Geographical Sciences, Arizona State University, Tempe, AZ 85287-0104, USA e-mail:
[email protected] N. Lozano-Gracia Spatial Analysis Laboratory (SAL) and Department of Agricultural and Consumer Economics, University of Illinois, Urbana-Champaign, Urbana, IL 61801, USA e-mail:
[email protected] Present Address: N. Lozano-Gracia School of Geographical Sciences, Arizona State University, Tempe, AZ 85287-0104, USA
6
L. Anselin, N. Lozano-Gracia
take an explicit spatial econometric perspective and account for spatial dependence and endogeneity using recently developed Spatial 2SLS estimation methods. We also account for both spatial autocorrelation and heteroskedasticity in the error terms, using the Kelejian–Prucha HAC estimator. Our results are consistent across different spatial weights matrices and different kernel functions and suggest that the bias from ignoring the endogeneity in interpolated values may be substantial. Keywords Spatial econometrics · Hedonic models · HAC estimation · Endogeneity · Air quality valuation · Real estate markets JEL Classification C21 · Q51 · Q53 · R31
1 Introduction An important aspect of assessing the effectiveness of environmental policies that address the improvement of air quality is obtaining a quantitative measure of the economic value of the accrued benefits (e.g., Freeman 2003). In the absence of an explicit market for clean air, several methods have been suggested to estimate this value empirically, such as contingent valuation, conjoint analysis, discrete choice models and hedonic specifications. In this paper, we focus on the latter and consider some methodological issues associated with the estimation of an implicit price for clean air by including one or more pollution variables in a hedonic model of house prices. The rationale behind this approach is that, ceteris paribus, houses in areas with cleaner air will have this benefit capitalized into their value, which should be reflected in a higher sales price. The hedonic approach has become an established methodology in environmental economics (e.g., Palmquist 1991). Originating with the classic studies of Ridker and Henning (1967) and Harrison and Rubinfeld (1978), it has generated a voluminous literature dealing with theoretical, methodological and empirical aspects. Extensive reviews are provided in Smith and Huang (1993, 1995), Boyle and Kiel (2001), and Chay and Greenstone (2005), among others. Recently, empirical econometric work has started to take into account the potential bias and loss of efficiency that can result when spatial effects such as spatial autocorrelation and spatial heterogeneity are ignored in the estimation process. Spatial econometric methods (Anselin 1988), which incorporate the spatial dependence in cross-sectional data into model specification, estimation and testing have become fairly commonplace in empirical studies of housing and real estate, leading to so-called spatial hedonic models. Reviews of the basic specifications and estimation methods are provided in Anselin (1998), Basu and Thibodeau (1998), Pace et al. (1998), Dubin et al. (1999), Gillen et al. (2001), and Pace and LeSage (2004), among others. In the context of the valuation of environmental amenities, a spatial hedonic approach has been less common, although some recent applications include Kim et al. (2003), Beron et al. (2004), Brasington and Hite (2005), and Anselin and Le Gallo (2006). A theoretical perspective is offered in Small and Steimetz (2006).
Errors in variables and spatial effects in hedonic house price models of ambient air quality
7
In Chay and Greenstone (2005) (CG), several methodological issues are addressed pertaining to the identification and consistent estimation of the implicit price of air quality, using total suspended particulates as an environmental indicator. Specifically, CG focus on the potential endogeneity of the pollution variable and suggest an instrumental variable approach to estimate it consistently. They also consider potential endogeneity due to sorting by house purchasers when there is heterogeneity in their preference functions with different pollution levels. While considerable care is taken in addressing these specification problems, the model itself is estimated at a fairly aggregate spatial scale of US counties. Bayer et al. (2006) follow Chay and Greenstone (2005) by suggesting the possibility of local air pollution being correlated with unobserved local characteristics. They address this form of endogeneity by using the contribution of distant sources to local air pollution as an instrument for air pollution at the county level. In this paper, we focus on a separate source of endogeneity of the air quality variables in the hedonic specification. We elaborate on an idea outlined in Anselin (2001c), where it was argued that the use of spatially interpolated values for air quality (or, pollution) results in a prediction error which may be correlated with the overall model disturbance term. This would lead to simultaneity bias in an ordinary least squares regression. We thus consider the treatment of endogeneity in the pollution variable from the particular perspective of an “errors in variables” problem. We use polynomials in the coordinates of the house locations as instruments to correct for this endogeneity. In contrast to the aggregate approach of CG, our empirical work is based on observations for individual house transactions.1 Consequently, we face the mismatch between the spatial support of the explanatory variable, a pollution measure collected at a finite set of monitoring stations, and the dependent variable, the price observed at the location of the house sales transaction. As outlined in Anselin and Le Gallo (2006), this requires a spatial interpolation operation. Several alternatives are possible, each with implications for the precision of the resulting variable. We take an explicit spatial econometric approach and include a spatially lagged dependent variable (spatial lag) in the hedonic specification. The combination of the endogeneity of the spatial lag and the air quality variables requires the application of spatial two stage least squares estimation (Anselin 1988; Kelejian and Robinson 1993; Kelejian and Prucha 1998; Lee 2003, 2006) and specialized test statistics (Anselin and Kelejian 1997). In addition, we allow for remaining spatial autocorrelation and heteroskedasticity of an unspecified nature (HAC) and obtain robust standard error estimates using the method of Kelejian and Prucha (2006a). We believe ours is the first true empirical application of spatial hedonic models in which both types of endogeneity (spatial and non-spatial) are considered jointly and that uses the HAC standard errors.
1 CG also employ a panel data set with observations at two points in time, whereas our sample is a pure
cross-section. CG do not consider spatial effects. In our work, we do not explicitly consider endogeneity due to sorting. However, from an empirical point of view, the source of the endogeneity is irrelevant once it is properly accounted for.
8
L. Anselin, N. Lozano-Gracia
We assess the extent to which the selection of a particular method affects the parameter estimates in the hedonic function and the derived economic valuation of willingness to pay (MWTP) for improved air quality. Specifically, we compare nonspatial to spatial hedonic specifications and estimation with and without instruments for the endogeneity of the air quality variable. We further assess the robustness of our findings by carrying out estimation for different spatial weights and different kernel functions. We pursue this empirical assessment by means of an investigation of a sample of 115,732 house sales in the South Coast Air Quality Management District of Southern California, for which we have detailed characteristics, as well as neighborhood measures and observations on ozone and particulate matter.2 In the remainder of the paper, we first provide a brief discussion of data sources and variables included in the model. We next give some methodological background on the spatial econometric estimators and test statistics used. This is followed by a review of the estimation results, with a special focus on the estimates of the parameters of the air quality variables. In a brief discussion of policy implications, we compare the estimates for marginal willingness to pay. We close with some concluding remarks. 2 Data and variables The basic data used in this paper come from three main sources: Experian Company (formerly TRW) for the individual house sales price and characteristics, the 2000 US Census of Population and Housing for the neighborhood characteristics (at the census tract and block group level), and the South Coast Air Quality Management District for the measures of ozone (OZ) and particulate matter (TSP) concentration. The house price and characteristics are from 115,729 sales transactions of owner-occupied single family homes that occurred during 1999 in the region, which covers four counties: Los Angeles (LA), Riverside (RI), San Bernardino (SB) and Orange (OR). The data were geocoded, which allows for the assignment of each house to any spatially aggregate administrative district (such as a census tract, block group or a school district) and for the computation of accessibility measures and interpolated pollution values for the location of each individual house in the sample. House price and characteristics are matched with neighborhood and locational characteristics at the census tract, and, where possible, at the block group level from the 2000 U.S. Census of Population and Housing.3 The variables used in the hedonic specification are essentially the same as those in earlier work by Beron et al. (2004) and Anselin and Le Gallo (2006). This base set is extended with newly computed measures on crime rates, school quality, distance 2 Other studies of the relation between house prices and air quality in this region can be found in Graves
et al. (1988), Beron et al. (1999, 2001, 2004), and Anselin and Le Gallo (2006), although only the latter two take an explicit spatial econometric approach. Also of interest is a general equilibrium analysis of ozone abatement in the same region, using a hierarchical locational equilibrium model, outlined in Smith et al. (2004). 3 We assume that the values obtained for the 2000 Census are representative of the spatial distribution in
1999.
Errors in variables and spatial effects in hedonic house price models of ambient air quality
9
Table 1 Variable names and description Variable name
Description
Elevation
Relative elevation of the house
Livarea
Interior living space (10,000 sq.m.)
Landarea
Lot size (1,000 sq.m.)
Baths
Number of bathrooms
Fireplace
Number of fireplaces
Pool
Indicator variable for swimming pool
Age
Age of the house (10 years)
AC
Indicator variable for central air conditioning
Heat
Indicator variable for central heating
Beach
Indicator variable for location less than 5 miles from beach
Avdistp
Average distance to parks in meters
Highway1
Indicator variable for location within a 0.25 km from a highway
Highway2
Indicator variable for location within 0.25–1 km from a highway
Traveltime
Average time to work in census tract (CT)
Poverty
% of population with income below the poverty level in CT
White
% of the population that is white in the census block group (BG)
Over65
% of the population older than 65 years in the census BG
College
% of population with college in the CT
Income
Median household income in BG (10,000 US$)
Vcrime
Violent crime rate for the city (or non urban county rate)
API
Average academic performance index for the school district
Riverside
Indicator variable for Riverside county
San Bern.
Indicator variable for San Bernardino county
Orange
Indicator variable for Orange county
OZ
Ozone measured in ppb
TSP
Total Suspended Particles in µ/m 3
to parks, and access to the highway system. All the variables used in the analysis are listed in Tables 1 and 2. We grouped the variables in the Table into five categories: house-specific characteristics from the Experian data set; location-specific characteristics, such as accessibility measures, computed from the house coordinates; neighborhood characteristics, obtained from the Census, supplemented with variables calculated from the FBI Uniform Crime Reports and the State of California Department of Education school performance scores; county dummies; and interpolated air pollution values. Five new variables are included in the current analysis that were not used in Anselin and Le Gallo (2006): Vcrime, API, Avdistp, Highway1 and Highway2. They were computed from different sources. Crime rates for violent crimes taking place during 1998 were obtained from the FBI Uniform Crime database. This measure is reported at the city as well as the county level. Where possible, we assigned the city level crime
10
L. Anselin, N. Lozano-Gracia
Table 2 Basic descriptive statistics for all variables Variable name
Mean
Std. Deviation
Min
Max
House price
243,346
210,000
20,000
5,345,455
Ln(house price)
12.213
0.571
9.900
15.490
Elevation
0.995
0.145
-4.000
6.588
Livarea
0.160
0.073
0.050
3.182
Landarea
8.900
19.072
0.8
2818.332
Baths
1.924
0.799
0.500
9.500
Fireplace
0.643
0.560
0
7
Pool
0.150
0.357
0
1
Age
4.287
2.023
0.1
10
AC
0.407
0.491
0
1
Heat
0.277
0.447
0
1
Beach
0.012
0.111
0
1
Pavdist
5.637
0.991
4.447
8.992
Highway1
0.091
0.288
0
1
Highway2
0.342
0.475
0
1
Traveltime
2.936
0.412
1.014
4.717
Poverty
0.120
0.091
0
0.670
White
0.570
0.221
0
1
Over65
0.105
0.059
0
0.868
College
0.259
0.176
0
0.800
Income
5.946
2.588
0
20.000
Vcrime
0.142
0.057
0.037
0.348
API
5.948
0.920
4.271
8.918
Riverside
0.056
0.230
0
1
San Bern.
0.118
0.323
0
1
Orange
0.172
0.378
0
1
OZ
8.111
1.838
4.717
13.467
TSP
82.101
14.435
54.729
121.240
rate to each house in the city. Where crime rates were not available at the city scale, we used the non-urban crime rate for the county in which the house is located. A measure of the average school quality is computed from the Academic Performance Index (API), published by the California Department of Education.4 This is the primary indicator used by the state to evaluate school performance. The API is an index calculated using both base and growth values of student rankings in the State Standardized tests. It is based on a scale from 200 to 1,000 with the target being 800.
4 http://www.cde.ca.gov/ta/ac/ap/.
Errors in variables and spatial effects in hedonic house price models of ambient air quality
11
The average 1999 API value for all schools in a school district is calculated and then assigned to all the houses in the district.5 We supplement the beach access variable with three other indicators of accessibility to amenities. First, we obtained the locations for each park in the four counties from the Geographic Names Information System website.6 For each house location, we then computed the average distance to parks as a summary measure. We also supplemented the Census travel time measure with two other indicators of access to the highway system. These are intended to capture both the negative externalities (such as noise) experienced from being very close to the highways, as well as positive externalities due to shorter travel distances. We used ArcGIS and detailed highway maps7 to define buffers of 0.25 km around the highways and to create two indicator variables. The first takes the value of one if the house is within 0.25 km of a highway, the second takes the value of one if the house is between 0.25 and 1 km from a highway. Air quality is measured as ambient air pollution. In the literature, hedonic specifications typically include either ozone (OZ) or total suspended particulate matter (TSP) as pollutants, since these are most visible in the form of “smog.” In addition, local news outlets report daily measures of these pollutants and broadcast alerts when dangerous levels are reached. Consequently, it is reasonable to assume that these pollutants enter into the utility function of potential buyers, although the question remains to what extent a continuous measure of air quality is the appropriate metric.8 We include both pollutants in the specification, in order to minimize omitted variable problems.9 We use the average of the daily maxima during the worst quarter of 1998 from the hourly observations recorded at monitoring stations for ozone and suspended particles. It should be noted that the number and locations of stations in the South Coast Air Quality Management District (SCAQMD) is not the same for each pollutant. In 1998, there were measurements for OZ for 28 monitoring stations, while TSP only had 12. The location of the monitoring stations relative to the houses in the sample is illustrated in Fig. 1. This yields a reasonable coverage of the spatial distribution of house locations for OZ, but much less so for TSP, which has fewer than half the number of stations. We interpolate the values at the monitoring stations to the location of every house in the sample using ordinary kriging. Anselin and Le Gallo (2006), find ordinary kriging to be the most reliable among several interpolation methods, including Thiessen
5 It would have been preferable to use a measure of school quality from the year previous to the year in
which the house sale takes place, as we do for the air quality measures. However, information for the API in California school districts is only available starting in 1999. 6 http://geonames.usgs.gov/pls/gnispublic/. 7 ESRI Data & Maps CD-ROM (2002). Redlands, CA, USA: Environmental Systems Research Institute. 8 In Anselin and Le Gallo (2006) discrete categories were also considered. In the current paper, our focus
is on endogeneity and we leave the issue of the proper metric for a separate analysis. 9 We also ran the analysis for specifications with only one pollutant in the equations and the results and
conclusions were qualitatively similar to what we found here. Detailed results are not reported, but available from the authors.
12
L. Anselin, N. Lozano-Gracia
Fig. 1 Spatial distribution of houses and location of monitoring stations
polygons, inverse distance weighting and splines. Figures 2 and 3 show the resulting interpolated values of ozone and particles, with darker color representing higher levels of the pollutant.10 The spatial pattern is very different for the two measures of air pollution. For ozone, lower levels are observed closer to the ocean and air quality seems to worsen as one moves North-East with a suggestion of separate air quality “bands.” For TSP, generally lower pollution is observed in the North-West corner of the Basin, with increasing levels as one moves towards the South-East. The precision of the interpolated value varies across the sample, becoming worse for locations further removed from monitoring sites. To correct for a possible biasing effect of such “high-error” interpolated values, the house locations within the upper 5% of the prediction error distribution for either pollutant were dropped from the sample. This resulted in a final set of 103,867 house locations, of which 67,864 are in LA county, 17,914 in OR county, 12,266 in SB and 5,823 in Riverside county. The observed sales price ranges from $20,000 to $5,345,455, with an overall mean of $243,346. There is considerable variability across counties. For example, the average house price for observations in LA county is $ 261,946, while it is $269,081 in OR, $148,948 in SB and $146,249 in RI. Figure 4 illustrates the spatial distribution of house prices, with higher prices represented through darker colors. Some concentration of high prices per squared meter can be seen in the coast of LA and OR, although overall, 10 Kriging interpolations were carried out using the ESRI ArcGIS Geostatistical Analyst extension. A
spherical model allowing for directional effects was used for both pollutants. For OZ the model chosen included 8 lags with a lag size of 9 km, and the estimated parameters were 303.4 and 9 for the direction (angle), 4.16 for the partial sill, 68,604 and 68,236 for the major ranges and 59,381 and 68,236 for the minor ranges. The model chosen for TSP included 9 lags with a lag size of 6km, and the estimated parameters were 352.8 and 9 for the direction, 546.84 for the partial sill, 50,969 and 50,959 for the major ranges and 11,303 and 50,959 for the minor ranges.
Errors in variables and spatial effects in hedonic house price models of ambient air quality
13
Fig. 2 Kriging interpolation: OZ
Fig. 3 Kriging interpolation: TSP
there is considerable complexity in the spatial distribution of prices. Basic descriptive statistics for all the variables included in the analysis are given in Table 2. 3 Spatial econometric issues We estimate a hedonic function in log-linear form and take an explicit spatial econometric approach. This includes testing for the presence of spatial autocorrelation and
14
L. Anselin, N. Lozano-Gracia
Fig. 4 Spatial distribution of house prices (Price/sq.m.)
estimating specifications that incorporate spatial dependence.11 We follow Anselin (1988) and distinguish between spatial dependence in the form of a spatially lagged dependent variable, and a model with a spatially correlated error term. We refer to these as spatial lag and spatial error models, respectively. Formally, a spatial lag model is expressed as: y = ρW y + Xβ + u,
(1)
where y is a n × 1 vector of observations on the dependent variable, X is a n × k matrix of observations on explanatory variables, W is a n × n spatial weights matrix, u a n × 1 vector of i.i.d. error terms, ρ the spatial autoregressive coefficient, and β a k × 1 vector of regression coefficients. The theoretical motivation for a spatial lag specification is based on the literature on interacting agents and social interaction. For example, a spatial lag follows as the equilibrium solution of a spatial reaction function (Brueckner 2003) that includes the decision variable of other agents in the determination of the decision variable of an agent (see also Manski 2000). In the current setting, which is purely cross-sectional, it is difficult to maintain such a theoretical motivation, since it would imply that buyers and sellers simultaneously take into account prices obtained in other transactions. An alternative interpretation is provided by focusing on the reduced form of the spatial lag model: (2) y = (I − ρW )−1 Xβ + (I − ρW )−1 u, 11 For a general overview of methodological issues involved in the specification, estimation and diagnostic
testing of spatial econometric models, we refer to Anselin (1988, 2001b, 2006) and Anselin and Bera (1998), among others.
Errors in variables and spatial effects in hedonic house price models of ambient air quality
15
where, under standard regularity conditions, the inverse (I − ρW )−1 can be expressed as a power expansion (I − ρW )−1 = I + ρW + ρ 2 W 2 + · · · .
(3)
The reduced form thus expresses the house price as a function of the own characteristics (X ), but also of the characteristics of neighboring properties (W X , W 2 X ), albeit subject to a distance decay operator (the combined effect of powering the spatial autoregressive parameter and the spatial weights matrix). In addition, omitted variables, both property-specific as well as related to neighboring properties are encompassed in the error term. In essence, this reflects a scale mismatch between the property location and the spatial scale of the attributes that enter into the determination of the equilibrium price. From a purely empirical perspective, one can also argue that the spatial lag specification allows for a filtering of a strong spatial trend (similar to detrending in the time domain), i.e., to ensure the proper inference for the β coefficients when there is insufficient variability across space. Formally, the spatial filter interpretation stresses the estimation of β in: y − ρW y = Xβ + u.
(4)
In contrast, spatial error autocorrelation results when omitted variables follow a spatial structure such that the error variance-covariance matrix is no longer diagonal: Var[uu ′ ] = E[uu ′ ] = ,
(5)
where = I, with I as the identity matrix. Arguably, such spatially structured omitted variables may be addressed by means of spatial fixed effects, e.g., by including a dummy variable for each census tract or block group. This rests on the assumption that the spatial range of the unobserved heterogeneity/dependence is specific to each spatially delineated unit. In practice, there may be spatial units (such as school districts) where such a spatial fixed effects approach is sufficient to correct for the problem. However, the nature of omitted neighborhood variables tends to be complex, as is the definition of the correct “neighborhood.” Instead of including spatial fixed effects, we assume a process for the error terms that allows the externalities to spill over throughout the system. More specifically, in contrast to most earlier work, we do not impose a specific functional form, but take a non-parametric perspective, implementing the recent results of Kelejian and Prucha (2006a). By means of the spatial weights matrix W , a neighbor set is specified for each location. The positive elements wi j of W are non-zero when observations i and j are neighbors, and zero otherwise. By convention, self-neighbors are excluded, such that the diagonal elements of W are zero. In addition, in practice, the weights matrix is typically row-standardized, such that j wi j = 1. Many different definitions of the neighbor relation are possible, and there is little formal guidance in the choice of the “correct” spatial weights.12 The term W y in Eq. (1) is referred to as a spatially lagged 12 For a more extensive discussion, see Anselin (2002, pp. 256–260), and Anselin (2006, pp. 909–910).
16
L. Anselin, N. Lozano-Gracia
dependent variable, or spatial lag. For a row-standardized weights matrix, it consists of a weighted average of the values of y in neighboring locations, with weights wi j . In our application, we consider three spatial weights to assess the sensitivity of the results to this important aspect of the model specification. One weight is derived from the contiguity relationship for Thiessen polygons constructed from the house locations. This effectively turns the spatial representation of the sample from points into polygons. The resulting weights matrix is symmetric and extremely sparse (0.006% non-zero weights). On average it contains 6 neighbors for each location (ranging from a minimum of 3 neighbors to a maximum of 35 neighbors, with 6 as the median). We supplement this with two weights based on a nearest neighbor relation among the locations, for respectively 6 and 12 neighbors. The corresponding weights matrix is asymmetric, but equally sparse (respectively 0.006 and 0.012% non-zero weights). The three weights matrices are used in row-standardized form. We first obtain ordinary least squares (OLS) estimates for the hedonic model and assess the presence of spatial autocorrelation using the Lagrange Multiplier test statistics for error and lag dependence (Anselin 1988), as well as their robust forms (Anselin et al. 1996).13 The results consistently show very strong evidence of positive residual spatial autocorrelation, with an edge in favor of the spatial lag alternative (see Sect. 4). This matches earlier results obtained in Anselin and Le Gallo (2006). We therefore focus on the estimation of the spatial lag model but allow remaining spatial error autocorrelation of unspecified form, as well as heteroskedasticity of unspecified form. Our paper takes two distinctive approaches towards estimation and inference of the spatial hedonic model that warrant further elaboration. First, we use a spatial twostage least squares estimator (S2SLS) that allows for a spatial lag as well as other endogenous variables. Consider the spatial lag model (1) with an additional term: y = ρW y + Y ν + Xβ + u,
(6)
where Y is a n × p matrix of endogenous variables, with associated coefficient vector ν. In our model, the endogenous variables are the air quality variables, say y2 and y3 . Since the actual pollution is not observed at the locations i of the house transactions, it is replaced by a spatially interpolated value, such as the result of a kriging prediction. This interpolated value measures the true pollution with error, for example, at location i: ∗ + ψi , y2i = y2i
(7)
∗ is the true air quality that enters into the agent’s utility function, y is the where y2i 2i “observed” value (the interpolated value), and ψi an error term. Note that this error is related to the interpolation error to the extent that the predicted item is also what enters into the utility function. An additional source of error would be a discrepancy between what is predicted as air quality and what is included into the agent’s utility function as
13 See Anselin (2001a), for an extensive review of statistical issues.
Errors in variables and spatial effects in hedonic house price models of ambient air quality
17
air quality.14 From a practical perspective, due to the nature of the kriging predictor, the prediction error will be highly spatially structured. We suggest that it therefore is likely to mimic the spatially structured equation disturbance u. In addition, the failure to predict air quality correctly at a location may be due to similar omitted variables as those that affect the error of the hedonic specification (e.g., the omitted presence of noxious facilities). As a result, it is likely that E[ψi u i ] = 0, causing simultaneous equation bias due to errors in variables. Using traditional notation, Eq. (6) can be rewritten concisely as: y = Z γ + u,
(8)
with Z = [W y, Y, X ] and γ = [ρ, ν ′ , β ′ ]′ . The spatial two stage least squares estimator is an extension of the standard two stage least squares estimator that includes specific instruments for the spatially lagged dependent variable (see Anselin 1980, 1988; Kelejian and Robinson 1993; Kelejian and Prucha 1998; Kelejian et al. 2004; Lee 2003, 2006). Specifically, consider the q × n matrix of instruments Q, with q ≥ k + p + 1: Q = [X, W X, H ],
(9)
where W X is a matrix consisting of the spatially lagged explanatory variables (exogenous variables only, and excluding the intercept), and H is a matrix of instruments for the other endogenous variables (the air quality variables). The use of W X as instruments for the spatial lag is based on the reduced form of the model. The selection of instruments for the errors in variables problem is less straightforward. Proper instruments should be correlated with the unobserved true pollution value y ∗ and uncorrelated with the regression error u. The effects on the estimates of using weak instruments have been widely discussed in the literature (see e.g., Staiger and Stock 1997) and the question of how to specify the right instruments remains unresolved for many economic problems. We chose instruments that are able to proxy the overall spatial pattern of the pollution as a global spatial trend. They therefore are unlikely to be correlated with the hedonic error terms, which reflect local spatial patterns of omitted variables. Specifically, we use the latitude, longitude and their product as the instruments. Note that these instruments may also aid in correcting endogeneity due to other factors, such as sorting. As long as they are uncorrelated with the error term, they will yield consistent estimates. However, if the instruments do not accurately capture the causal mechanism underlying the other sources of endogeneity, the resulting estimates will not be most efficient. This needs to be considered together with other sources of inefficiency, such as unobserved heterogeneity and spatial autocorrelation in the error term. In order for the asymptotic properties of the HAC estimator to hold, we only need consistency of the estimates in the first stage, which 14 An early application of instrumental variables in this context within the economic literature is Friedman
(1957), where a measurement problem appears when using annual income as a proxy for permanent income in estimating a consumption function.
18
L. Anselin, N. Lozano-Gracia
will be satisfied by our instruments (as long as they are uncorrelated with the error term). With the instrument matrix in hand, we obtain the S2SLS estimates as: γˆS2S L S = [Z ′ Q(Q ′ Q)−1 Q ′ Z ]−1 Z ′ Q(Q ′ Q)−1 Q ′ y.
(10)
Inference is based on the asymptotic variance matrix: AsyV ar [γˆS2S L S ] = σˆ 2 [Z ′ Q(Q ′ Q)−1 Q ′ Z ]−1 ,
(11)
with σˆ 2 = (y − Z γˆS2S L S )′ (y − Z γˆS2S L S )/n. We relax the assumption of homoskedasticity used in (11) and allow for heteroskedasticity of unspecified form. A direct application of the approach outlined in White (1980) yields an alternative estimate for the asymptotic variance matrix as: −1
′ Q) AsyV ar [γˆS2S L S−W ] = [Z ′ Q (Q
Q ′ Z ]−1 ,
(12)
−1
′ Q) with (Q = (Q ′ S Q)−1 , where S is a diagonal matrix containing the squared 15 S2SLS residuals. We also continue to test for remaining spatial error autocorrelation, using the generalized LM tests for 2SLS residuals (Anselin and Kelejian 1997). The second distinctive methodological aspect of our approach is that we allow for remaining spatial error autocorrelation of unspecified form. Since the specification tests indicate the presence of such autocorrelation (see Sect. 4), we apply the recently developed heteroskedastic and autocorrelation robust (HAC) approach of Kelejian and Prucha (2006a). This builds upon the framework outlined in Conley (1999) as an extension to the spatial domain of the well-known Newey and West (1987) result from time series analysis (see also Andrews 1991). The core of the HAC technique is a non-parametric estimator for the spatial covariance, using weighted averages of cross-products of residuals, the range of which is determined by a kernel function.16 Formally, we need to obtain an estimate of the matrix = Q ′ Q, where is a non-diagonal spatial variance–covariance matrix for the error terms. As Kelejian and Prucha (2006a) show, the estimator for the individual r, s elements of the matrix is given by:
r,s = (1/n) ψ
i
qir q js uˆ i uˆ j K (di j /d),
(13)
j
15 For a recent discussion of technical aspects associated with heteroskedastic robust estimation in spatial
models, see Kelejian and Prucha (2006b) and Lin and Lee (2005). 16 The origins of this approach can be found in Hall and Patil (1994).
Errors in variables and spatial effects in hedonic house price models of ambient air quality
19
where the subscripts refer to the individual elements of the matrix Q and residual vector u, ˆ and K is a kernel function.17 In the case of OLS, Q is replaced by X , the matrix of observations on the explanatory variables. The kernel function K ( ) determines which pairs i, j are included in the cross products in (13). The kernel function is a real, continuous and symmetric function that is bounded and integrates to one, similar to a probability density function.18 In the current context, the kernel is formulated as K (di j /d), where di j is the distance between i and j, and d is the bandwidth, such that K (di j /d) = 0 for di j ≥ d. In our application, we use three different kernel functions: the triangular or Bartlett kernel, with K (z) = 1 − z (with z = di j /d), the Epanechnikov kernel, with K (z) = 1 − z 2 , and the bisquare kernel, with K (z) = (1 − z 2 )2 . Note that for each of these K = 1 for di j = 0. We implement this using a variable bandwidth, based on the distances to the 40 nearest neighbors. Using the estimates for from (13), the HAC variance for the S2SLS estimates is obtained as: (Q ′ Q)−1 Q ′ Z (Z q′ Z q )−1 , AsyV ar [γˆS2S L S−H AC ] = (Z q′ Z q )−1 Z ′ Q(Q ′ Q)−1 (14) with Z q′ Z q = Z ′ Q(Q ′ Q)−1 Q ′ Z . One final methodological note pertains to the assessment of model fit. In spatial models, the use of the standard R 2 measure is not appropriate (see Anselin 1988, Chap. 14). In order to provide for an informal comparison of the fit of the various specifications, we report a pseudo-R 2 measure, computed as the ratio of the variance of the predicted value to the variance of the observed values. In the classical linear regression model, this is equivalent to the R 2 , but in the spatial models this measure should be interpreted with caution. In the spatial lag model, the spatially lagged dependent variable W y is endogenous. We therefore obtain the predicted value from the expression for the conditional expectation of the reduced form: yˆ = E[y|X ] = (I − ρW ˆ )−1 X βˆ
(15)
This operation requires the inverse of a matrix of dimension n × n, which we approximate by means of a power method, accurate up to 6 decimals of precision. 4 Estimation results We begin the review of our empirical results by focusing on the coefficients obtained using the four estimation methods under consideration: OLS, IV (standard nonspatial 2SLS with the pollutants treated as endogenous), LAG (spatial 2SLS with 17 In practice, the term (1/n) cancels out in the final expression for the variance matrix in (14). We include it here to be consistent with the notation in Kelejian and Prucha (2006a). 18 See, among others, Härdle (1990, Chap. 3), Andrews (1991, pp. 822–823), Simonoff (1996, Chap. 3),
and Cameron and Trivedi (2005, pp. 299–300).
20
L. Anselin, N. Lozano-Gracia
Table 3 Coefficient estimates: traditional hedonic variables— queen weights Variable name
OLS
IV
Constant
12.12
12.5281
8.1169
8.4700
0.0012
0.0009
0.0009
2.6057
2.5864
2.2326
2.2237
−0.0004∗
−0.0029∗
0.0027∗
0.0007∗
Landarea Livarea Elevation
0.0011
LAG
LAG-end
Baths
0.0471
0.04724
0.0415
0.0416
Fireplace
0.0457
0.0441
0.0363
0.0352
Pool
0.0505
0.0508
0.0438
0.0440
Age
−0.0166
−0.0197
−0.0130
−0.0153
Age2 AC
0.0190
0.0153
0.0140
0.0113
−0.0249
−0.0229
−0.0159
−0.0150
Heat
0.0386
0.0363
0.0245
0.0229
Beach
0.2405
0.2661
0.1719
0.1934
Distance Parks
−0.0287
−0.0395
−0.0213
−0.0298
Highway1
−0.0199
−0.0234
−0.0130
−0.0155
Highway2 Travel time Poverty
0.0028∗ −0.0649 0.0142∗
0.0027∗ −0.0579
0.0043∗∗ −0.0541
−0.0210∗
0.0201∗
White
0.3230
0.3179
0.2282
Over65
0.1125
0.0376∗∗
0.0327∗∗
0.0043∗∗ −0.0494 −0.0454 0.2253 −0.0213∗
College
1.0155
0.9192
0.5988
0.5342
Income
0.0212
0.0224
0.0085
0.0096
Vcrime
−0.3938
−0.2450
−0.2446
−0.1261
API
0.0007∗
0.0011∗
Riverside
−0.1405
−0.0025∗
San Bern.
−0.1411
−0.0652
Orange
−0.0077∗∗
R 2 (var ratio)
0.7761
0.0579∗∗ 0.7947
0.0007∗ −0.0977
0.0017∗ 0.0006∗
−0.0938
−0.0413
−0.0126
0.0370
0.7814
0.8017
∗ Not significant ∗∗ Significant at 5%
a spatially lagged dependent variable), and LAG-end (spatial 2SLS with a spatially lagged dependent variable and the pollutants treated as endogenous). We separate the results into those for the traditional hedonic variables, reported in Table 3, and those for the pollutant coefficients, reported in Table 4 together with some model diagnostics. The tables only contain results for the queen spatial weights (to create the spatially lagged dependent variable). The complete set of estimates for all three spatial weights is given in the Appendix. First, consider the OLS results. Overall, the coefficients of the house characteristics are significant and of the expected sign, in accordance with earlier findings in the literature. The only exception is relative elevation, which was not found to be significant. House prices increase as both land and living area increase. Similarly, houses with
Errors in variables and spatial effects in hedonic house price models of ambient air quality
21
Table 4 Pollutant coefficients by estimator—queen weights Variable Name
OLS
IV
LAG
LAG-end
OZ
−0.0253
−0.0137
−0.0195
−0.0099
TSP
−0.0047
−0.0102
−0.0032
−0.0073
ρ
−
−
0.3314
0.3266
RLM-LAG
2357.271
−
−
−
RLM-ERR
1339.671
−
-
−
DWH
2,540
−
−
−
18323.48
60.24
137.46
A-K
more bathrooms, fireplaces, as well as with AC and heating systems are higher valued. As the literature suggests (see among others Bourassa et al. 1999; Beron et al. 2004) there appears to be a quadratic relationship between age and price: prices are higher for more recently built houses. There is also a vintage effect of age on prices that is reflected in the positive sign of the quadratic term. In terms of access variables, there is a significant premium for houses that are located closer to the beach and closer to parks, but the effect of the immediate vicinity to the highway is that of a nuisance. Location in a zone 0.25–1 km from the highway is not significant (for OLS; it is positive and becomes significant at p < 0.05 in the spatial models). The results for the neighborhood variables are also in accordance with conventional wisdom: travel time and crime are negatively valued, whereas % white, the proportion of college graduates and median income have a positive effect. Poverty and the school quality score were not found to be significant. The percentage elderly is positive, but this finding is not stable across estimators (see below). Los Angeles county was used as the base case, which resulted in a negative value for the dummy variables for Riverside and San Bernardino, but no significant difference for Orange county. The overall fit is very satisfactory, with an R 2 of 0.78. However, as the model diagnostics indicate (Table 4), OLS suffers from a number of problems. First, the Durbin–Wu–Haussman test statistic for endogeneity strongly rejects the null hypothesis that the interpolated pollutants are exogenous. In addition, there is evidence of very high residual spatial autocorrelation, with the robust LM test statistic suggesting the lag specification as the proper alternative. We next consider the effect on the estimates for the traditional hedonic variables of treating the pollutants as endogenous (column IV in Table 3), including a spatially lagged dependent variable (column LAG), and combining both spatial lag and endogeneity of the pollutants (column LAG-end). Note that the A–K test for residual spatial autocorrelation also rejected the null for all three non-OLS cases, even after a spatially lagged dependent variable was included. The latter is highly significant, with estimates for the spatial autoregressive coefficient around 0.3. The A–K test points to the need to account for remaining spatial error autocorrelation through the HAC approach. The most appropriate specification is therefore the LAG-end with HAC
22
L. Anselin, N. Lozano-Gracia
variance estimates. The other results are provided to assess the effect of addressing endogeneity and spatial effects in isolation versus in combination. For the individual house characteristics and accessibility variables, the estimated coefficients remain fairly stable across methods, with only marginal changes. The estimates obtained with LAG-end are slightly smaller in absolute value, but all the significance remain the same. This is not the case for the estimates of the neighborhood characteristics. These vary considerably across methods, both in magnitude as well as in significance. For example, Poverty, which is not significant for OLS, IV and LAG, becomes significant and negative in the LAG-end model. In the reverse direction, the % elderly, which is significant in OLS, gradually loses significance (significant only at p < 0.05 for IV and LAG) to become insignificant in LAG-end. The absolute value of the coefficients for Income, College and Vcrime in LAG-end is less than half the magnitude for OLS. These variables are measured at an aggregate scale (census tract or block group, or city for the crime variable) and therefore the disturbances from the model may be correlated within the aggregation groups (Moulton 1990). It is likely that houses in the same census tract share unobservable characteristics leading to correlation in the error terms. We surmise that the inclusion of a spatially lagged dependent variable filters out some of this error and yields more accurate estimates. The pollution variables are similarly affected by the estimation method. Both coefficients of Ozone and TSP are negative and highly significant throughout. However, their absolute value varies considerably across methods. Taken individually, the effect of controlling for endogeneity seems to be strongest, resulting in a change between OLS and IV of −0.025 to −0.014 for Ozone, and of −0.005 to −0.010 for TSP. Between OLS and LAG, the change is much smaller. In LAG-end, accounting for both the spatial effects and the endogeneity yields a coefficient of −0.0099 for Ozone and −0.0073 for TSP. This suggests that a reduction of 1 ppb in OZ levels would raise house prices by 0.99% and a decrease of 1 µ/m 3 in TSP values would increase house values by 0.73%. Since the joint consideration of spatial effects and endogeneity is new in the current paper, there are no results available in the literature to compare our findings to directly. However, our OLS estimates are in line with previous published results. For example, in a meta-analysis of 37 studies, Smith and Huang (1995) suggest that a decrease of 1 µ/m 3 in the TSP values will result in an increase of house values ranging between 0.05 and 0.10%. Using an IV estimator Chay and Greenstone (2005) estimate that a change in 1 µ/m 3 will produce a 0.2–0.4% change in house prices in the opposite direction. These estimates are considerably lower than those obtained in the current study, but it is important to keep in mind that their results are obtained for county aggregates. The OLS results in Beron et al. (2001) suggest that a decrease in one ppb of OZ would produce an increase in house prices ranging from 2.3 to 7.1%, which is consistent with our OLS estimates. Relative to OLS, when accounting for both endogeneity and spatial autocorrelation in the LAG-end model, the effect of ozone on house prices appears to be significantly smaller in absolute terms, while the effect of TSP is larger in absolute value. As shown in Table 4, the A–K test in the LAG-end model still shows significant remaining spatial error autocorrelation. We assess the effect of this on the precision of the estimates for both pollutants by computing three sets of standard errors: classical,
Errors in variables and spatial effects in hedonic house price models of ambient air quality
23
Table 5 Standard errors: OZ Coeff.
Standard errors
OZ
Classical
White
HAC-Ep
HAC-Tr
HAC-Bi
OLS
−0.0253
0.0008
0.0008
0.0018
0.0016
0.0016
IV
−0.0137
0.0010
0.0011
0.0026
0.0023
0.0024
−0.0195
0.0007
0.0008
0.0012
0.0011
0.0011
−0.0099
0.00099
0.0010
0.0017
0.0016
0.0016
−0.01822
0.00078
0.00087
0.00125
0.00115
0.00115
−0.00895
0.00099
0.00108
0.00175
0.00157
0.00158
−0.01802
0.00078
0.00086
0.00123
0.00113
0.00114
−0.00853
0.00098
0.00107
0.00170
0.00154
0.00155
LAG
Queen
LAG-end LAG
Knn6
LAG-end LAG
Knn12
LAG-end
Table 6 Standard errors: TSP Coeff.
Standard errors
TSP
Classical
White
HAC-Ep
HAC-Tr
HAC-Bi
OLS
−0.0047
0.00010
0.00010
0.00021
0.00019
0.00019
IV
−0.0102
0.00019
0.00019
0.00046
0.00041
0.00041
−0.0032
0.00010
0.00010
0.00010
0.00014
0.00014
−0.0073
0.00018
0.00020
0.00032
0.00029
0.00030
−0.0032
0.00009
0.00010
0.00015
0.00014
0.00014
−0.0073
0.00018
0.00020
0.00031
0.00028
0.00028
−0.0032
0.00009
0.00010
0.00015
0.00013
0.00014
−0.0073
0.00018
0.00020
0.00031
0.00028
0.00029
LAG
Queen
LAG−end LAG
Knn6
LAG−end LAG
Knn12
LAG−end
White (heteroskedastic consistent), and HAC. The results are reported in Tables 5 and 6, for the three spatial weights matrices and three kernel functions. The estimates for the pollution variables are essentially the same across the three spatial weights, with only a slight difference for ozone. However, accounting for remaining heteroskedasticity and spatial error correlation has a dramatic effect on the precision of the estimates. The standard errors are up to twice as large for the HAC as the classical and White results with consistently the largest value for the Epanechnikov kernel. By and large, the numerical values are essentially the same across kernels and spatial weights, which provides some evidence of the robustness of our findings. The more realistic measure of the standard errors of the estimates will be important in assessing the precision of the derived welfare measures, such as the MWTP, to which we turn next.
5 Policy analysis We conclude this empirical exercise by comparing the valuation of air quality computed from the parameter estimates obtained by the alternative methods. In a hedonic
24
L. Anselin, N. Lozano-Gracia
model, the implicit price of any characteristic may be obtained as the derivative of the hedonic price equilibrium equation with respect to the characteristic of interest. In a non-spatial log-linear model, the MWTP equals the estimated coefficient for the pollution variable times the price (P), or:19 ∂P = βˆg P, M W T Pg = ∂g
(16)
where g is either OZ or TSP. As shown in Kim et al. (2003), a spatial multiplier effect needs to be accounted for to accurately compute the MWTP in a spatial lag model. For a uniform change in the amenity across all observations the MWTP then follows as: M W T P = βˆg P(
1 ), 1−ρ
(17)
with ρ as the estimate of the spatial autoregressive coefficient. The distinction between (16) and (17) is important in light of the recent discussion by Small and Steimetz (2006). They considered the different interpretation of welfare effects between the direct valuation in (16) and the multiplier effect included in (17). In their view, the multiplier effect should only be considered as part of the welfare calculation in the case of a technological externality associated with a change in amenities. In the case of a purely pecuniary externality, the direct effect is the only correct measure of welfare change. A strong argument in favor of using a spatial lag specification (where warranted by the data) is that it allows the two effects to be considered explicitly. In Tables 7 and 8 we report the calculated MWTP for OZ and TSP for the four estimation methods. For the lag models, we include both the direct effect as well as the total effect. In addition to point estimates, we list a confidence band which consists of ± two standard errors around the point estimate. In the non-spatial models and for the direct effect computation, the standard errors are those reported for the regression coefficients. In the spatial multiplier, the standard error of both βˆ and ρˆ needs to be accounted for jointly, which we implement by means of the delta method (see e.g., for further details Greene 2003). We report the results for the three spatial weights and with standard errors based on the classic form, the White and the three HAC formulations. The MWTP are estimated for a change of 0.1 ppb for ozone and 1 µ/m 3 for particles which correspond to changes of 1.1% on average. For both pollutants, we note a striking difference between the OLS estimate and the result from the LAG-end model, but not in the same direction. For ozone, the OLS result would suggest a point estimate of $616 compared to $330–$358 as the range across spatial weights for the total effect for LAG-end, with $208–$241 as the range for the direct effect. For TSP, the direction of change is opposite, with an OLS result
19 In all cases we use the mean house price in the sample to calculate the MWTP.
Errors in variables and spatial effects in hedonic house price models of ambient air quality
25
Table 7 MWTP for reductions in OZ levels OZ
OLS
IV
LAG Direct
LAG With multiplier
LAG-end Direct
LAG-end With multiplier
Estimate
616
335
475
710
241
358
Classic
575–657
281–388
433–513
652–768
193–289
286–430
White
573–659
277–392
433–517
649–770
189–293
281–435
Queen
HAC-Ep
526–705
204–466
412–538
618–802
154–329
229–489
HAC-Tr
536–695
220–450
417–532
626–794
163–320
242–475
HAC-Bi
535–696
218–452
417–532
625–794
162–320
241–475 334
KNN-6 Estimates
–
–
444
684
218
Classic
–
–
405–4,818
625–743
170–266
260–408
White
–
–
401–486
623–770
165–271
257–435
HAC-Ep
–
–
382–505
592–776
133–303
204–465
HAC-Tr
–
–
387–500
600–768
141–295
218–451
HAC-Bi
–
–
387–500
600–767
141–295
217–452 330
KNN-12 Estimate
–
–
439
706
208
Classic
–
–
400–4768
644–768
160–255
254–406
White
–
–
397–481
649–770
155–260
281–435
HAC-Ep
–
–
379–499
592–776
125–291
204–465
HAC-Tr
–
–
383–494
620–793
132–283
211–450
HAC-Bi
–
–
383–494
619–793
132–283
210–450
of $1,148 contrasted with a range of $2,640–$2,713 for the total effect using LAGend, and $1,705–$1,778 as the range of the direct effect. Taking into account the standard errors, including the much wider ones suggested by the HAC estimates, we can characterize these differences as significant. Even though it is sometimes suggested that OLS results may be appropriate as estimates of the total effect, our findings do not support this.20 It is also interesting to note that the direction of the difference is opposite between the two pollutants, something earlier studies that included only a single pollutant were not able to ascertain. The main conclusion is therefore that OLS estimates are likely to be misleading, but not that they over- or underestimate the total effect in a specific direction. A closer consideration of the results seems to suggest that the primary difference is due to accounting for endogeneity, rather than the inclusion of the spatial lag.
20 This is separate from the issue that on technical grounds OLS will yield inconsistent and imprecise
estimates, due to the presence of both spatial autocorrelation and endogeneity.
26
L. Anselin, N. Lozano-Gracia
Table 8 MWTP for reductions in TSP levels TSP
OLS
IV
LAG Direct
LAG With multiplier
LAG-end Direct
LAG-end With multiplier
Estimate
1148
2489
783
1,170
1,778
2,640
Classic
1,097–1,198
2,392–2,585
733–832
1,096–1,245
1,687–1,868
2,511–2,769
White
1,099–1,197
2,394–2,585
732–833
1,099–1,242
1,678–1,877
2,511–2,769
HAC-Ep
1,042–1,253
2,261–2,716
733–832
1,105–1,236
1,620–1,935
2,419–2,861
HAC-Tr
1,054–1,241
2,289–2,689
712–853
1,071–1,270
1,634–1,922
2,439–2,841
HAC-Bi
1,053–1,243
2,285–2,693
712–853
1,070–1,271
1,632–1,924
2,437–2,844
Estimate
–
–
775
1,195
1,740
2,671
Classic
–
–
726–823
1,119–1,245
1,651–1,830
2,538–2,773
White
–
–
724–825
1,124–1,241
1,642–1,838
2,542–2,769
HAC-Ep
–
–
700–849
1,086–1,279
1,587–1,893
2,441–2,870
HAC-Tr
–
–
706–843
1,096–1,269
1,601–1,880
2,430–2,850
HAC-Bi
–
–
706–843
1,095–1,270
1,599–1,881
2,459–2,852
Queen
KNN-6
KNN-12 Estimate
–
–
743
1,196
1,705
2,713
Classic
–
–
694–791
1,117–1,249
1,616–1,794
2,576–2,777
White
–
–
693–793
1,125–1,241
1,607–1,803
2,586–2,767
HAC-Ep
–
–
670–816
1,084–1,282
1,553–1,857
2,486–2,867
HAC-Tr
–
–
675–811
1,093–1,273
1,564–1,845
2,505–2,848
HAC-Bi
–
–
675–811
1,093–1,274
1,563–1,847
2,503–2,850
The main contribution of including the latter is that it becomes possible to distinguish the direct effect from the total effect. However, taking into account the standard errors (especially from the HAC effects), there does not seem to be a significant difference between the total effect in LAG-end and the estimate obtained for IV. The latter is significantly different from the direct effect estimate under LAGend, so that it would not be appropriate to use the IV results as a welfare measure when pecuniary externalities are underlying the spatial multiplier. A similar comparison holds between the results of OLS and those of the LAG model without endogeneity. It should be noted that the inclusion of the spatial lag has important consequences for the other parameters in the model (such as the neighborhood characteristics) and that we are not suggesting that it should be ignored. However, from a policy perspective, if the sole concern is with an estimate of MWTP irrespective of its composition between direct effects and spatial multiplier effects, the results from a model that accounts for endogeneity (but ignores the spatial lag) may be acceptable. However, ignoring spatial effects leads to unrealistic indications of precision (narrow confidence intervals) which may be misleading in a decision support setting.
Errors in variables and spatial effects in hedonic house price models of ambient air quality
27
6 Conclusion In this paper, we contribute to the empirical literature on the valuation of ambient air quality in spatial hedonic models by considering three novel aspects. First, we considered endogeneity in the form of errors in variables for the interpolated measures of air pollution. This led to a the use of spatial two stage least squares estimation with instruments for the spatially lagged dependent variable as well as the inclusion of the coordinates of house locations and their interaction as instruments for the interpolated pollution values. Second, we implemented the recently developed heteroskedastic and spatially autocorrelation consistent (HAC) estimates for the standard errors to obtain more robust results for the precision of the computed MWTP. Third, we extended the scope of the analysis by including two pollutants in the specification, rather than the traditional focus on a single pollutant. Additionally, we carry this out for one of the largest samples used in the empirical study of spatial hedonic models. Our results underscore the importance of correcting for the errors in variables nature of the interpolated pollution values. The effect is both significant with respect to the coefficient estimates in the hedonic model, as well as for the calculation of the MWTP. For the coefficient estimates, the main changes are seen for the pollution variables and the neighborhood measures. The coefficients for the individual house characteristics were found to be only marginally affected by the estimation method. In all cases, strong evidence was found of spatial error autocorrelation, which persisted even after a spatially lagged dependent variable was included in the model. This provides a solid argument in favor of using HAC estimates of the standard errors. In practice, classical and even White standard errors seriously underestimate the imprecision of the estimates in the presence of remaining spatial correlation and spatial heterogeneity. Interestingly, there is no consistent direction of the bias of the OLS estimates for the pollution variables. Further insight into the precise mechanisms underlying this phenomenon requires additional investigation. The computation of the MWTP is similarly affected by the choice of the estimation method. The need to account for endogeneity is clear and OLS-based calculations are likely to be misleading. Moreover, a spatial lag specification allows for a distinction between direct effects and the role of a spatial multiplier, which are combined in the estimates of the non-spatial models. A number of aspects of estimation were not taken into consideration and remain the subject of future work. Foremost among these is the role of spatial heterogeneity. The strong evidence of remaining heterogeneity and spatial correlation would suggest that perhaps a different scale of analysis might be more appropriate. For example, this might include an explicit accounting for submarkets or for possible sorting of households by preference regarding environmental quality. Finally, the evidence presented here only applies to a single case study, and additional empirical work is needed to start establishing the foundations for general results. It is hoped that accounting for errors in variables of the interpolated pollution measures will become a routine aspect of applied work in spatial hedonic models of ambient air quality.
28
L. Anselin, N. Lozano-Gracia
Appendix Table 9 Estimates from alternative models and standard errors Variable
OLS
IV
Queen weights
knn6 weights
knn12 weights
LAG
LAG-end
LAG
LAG
7.8676
LAG-end
LAG-end
Constant
12.12
12.5281
8.1169
8.4700
8.1911
7.5316
7.900
Classical
(0.0188)
(0.0219)
(0.0730)
(0.07645) (0.0715)
(0.0746)
(0.0727)
(0.0761)
White
(0.02118) (0.0246)
(0.1299)
(0.1336)
(0.1388)
(0.1414)
(0.1344)
(0.1379 )
HAC-Tr
(0.0373)
(0.0457)
(0.1471)
(0.1525)
(0.1607)
(0.1646)
(0.1593)
(0.1649)
HAC-Ep
(0.0418)
(0.0513)
(0.1521)
(0.0764)
(0.1668)
(0.1711)
(0.1653)
(0.1715)
HAC-Bi
(0.0380 )
(0.0465)
(0.1480)
(0.1535)
(0.1622)
(0.1662)
(0.1608)
(0.1666)
0.0012
0.0009
0.0009
0.0009
0.0009
0.0009
0.0009
Landarea 0.0011 Classical
(0.00004) (0.00004) (0.00004) (0.00004) (0.00004) (0.00004) (0.00004) (0.00004)
White
(0.00028) (0.0003)
(0.0002)
(0.0002)
(0.0002)
(0.0002)
(0.0002)
(0.0002)
HAC-Tr
(0.00028) (0.0003)
(0.0002)
(0.0002)
(0.0002)
(0.0002)
(0.0002)
(0.0002)
HAC-Ep
( 0.0002 ) (0.0003)
(0.0002)
(0.00004) (0.0002)
(0.0002)
(0.0002)
(0.0002)
HAC-Bi
(0.0002)
(0.0003)
(0.0002)
(0.0002)
(0.0002)
(0.0002)
(0.0002)
Livarea
2.6057
2.5864
2.2326
2.2237
2.1689
2.1587
2.2004
2.1942
Classical
(0.0207)
(0.02108) (0.0204)
(0.0206)
(0.0204)
(0.0206)
(0.0201)
(0.0203)
White
(0.1235)
(0.1228)
(0.1104)
(0.1098)
(0.1089)
(0.1082)
(0.1084)
(0.1080)
HAC-Tr
(0.1259)
(0.1252)
(0.11141) (0.1108)
(0.1103)
(0.1096)
(0.1094)
(0.1090)
HAC-Ep
(0.1269)
(0.1262)
(0.1120)
(0.0206)
(0.1110)
(0.1103)
(0.1100)
(0.1096)
HAC-Bi
( 0.1259)
(0.1253)
(0.1112)
(0.1107)
(0.1102)
(0.1093)
(0.1093)
(0.1089)
Elevation −0.0004
−0.0029
0.0027
0.0007
0.00007
−0.0018
0.0002
−0.0017
Classical
(0.0057)
(0.0058)
(0.0053)
(0.0054)
(0.0053)
(0.0053)
(0.0053)
(0.0053)
White
(0.0066)
(0.0067)
(0.0062)
(0.0062)
(0.0061)
(0.0062)
(0.0061)
(0.0062)
HAC-Tr
(0.0074)
(0.0077)
(0.0068)
(0.0071)
(0.0066)
(0.0068)
(0.0068)
(0.0071)
HAC-Ep
(0.0075)
(0.0079)
(0.0069)
(0.0073)
(0.0066)
(0.0069)
(0.0069)
(0.0072)
HAC-Bi
(0.0074)
(0.0078)
(0.0069)
(0.0071)
(0.0066)
(0.0068)
(0.0069)
(0.0071)
Baths
0.0471
0.04724
0.0415
0.0416
0.0416
0.0417
0.0409
0.0411
Classical
(0.0019)
(0.0019)
(0.0017)
(0.0017)
(0.0017)
(0.0017)
(0.0017)
(0.0017)
White
(0.0075)
(0.0074)
(0.0061)
(0.0059)
(0.0058)
(0.0059)
(0.0061)
(0.0059)
HAC-Tr
(0.00769) (0.0076)
(0.0062)
(0.0062)
(0.0060)
(0.0060)
(0.0061)
(0.0061)
HAC-Ep
(0.0077)
(0.0472)
(0.0063)
(0.0063)
(0.0060 )
(0.0060)
(0.0061)
(0.0061)
HAC-Bi
(0.0077)
(0.0076)
(0.0062)
(0.0062)
(0.0060)
(0.0060)
(0.0061)
(0.0061)
(0.0002)
Fireplace 0.0457
0.0441
0.0363
0.0352
0.0348
0.0337
0.0352
0.0342
Classical
(0.0017)
(0.0017)
(0.0016)
(0.0016)
(0.0016)
(0.0016)
(0.0016)
(0.0016)
White
(0.0023)
(0.0023)
(0.0020)
(0.0020)
(0.0019)
(0.0019)
(0.0019)
(0.0019)
HAC-Tr
(0.00277) (0.0028)
(0.0023)
(0.0023)
(0.0022)
(0.0022)
(0.0022)
(0.0023)
HAC-Ep
(0.0028)
(0.0029)
(0.0023)
(0.0024)
(0.0023)
(0.0023)
(0.0023)
(0.0023)
HAC-Bi
(0.0028)
(0.0028)
(0.0023)
(0.0023)
(0.0022)
(0.0022)
(0.0023)
(0.0023)
Pool
0.0505
0.0508
0.0438
0.0440
0.0435
0.0437
0.0434
0.0436
Errors in variables and spatial effects in hedonic house price models of ambient air quality
29
Table 9 continued Variable
OLS
IV
Queen weights
knn6 weights
knn12 weights
LAG
LAG
LAG
LAG-end
LAG-end
LAG-end
Classical
(0.0025)
(0.0025)
(0.0023)
(0.0023)
(0.0023)
(0.0023)
(0.0023)
(0.0023)
White
(0.0031)
(0.0031)
(0.0027)
(0.0027)
(0.0026)
(0.0026)
(0.0026)
(0.0026)
HAC-Tr
(0.0034)
(0.0034)
(0.0028)
(0.0028)
(0.0028)
(0.0028)
(0.0028)
(0.0028)
HAC-Ep
(0.0035)
(0.0035)
(0.0029)
(0.0029)
(0.0028)
(0.0028)
(0.0029)
(0.0029)
HAC-Bi
(0.0034)
(0.0034)
(0.0028)
(0.0028)
(0.0028)
(0.0028)
(0.0028)
(0.0028)
Age
−0.0166
−0.0197
−0.0130
−0.0153
−0.0102
−0.0125
−0.0104
−0.0127
Classical
(0.0017)
(0.0018)
(0.0016)
(0.0016)
(0.0016)
(0.0016)
(0.0016)
(0.0016)
White
(0.0026)
(0.0026)
(0.0023)
(0.0023)
(0.0022)
(0.0022)
(0.0022)
(0.0022)
HAC-Tr
(0.0037)
(0.0038)
(0.0028)
(0.0029)
(0.0027)
(0.0028)
(0.0027)
(0.0028)
HAC-Ep
(0.0039)
(0.0041)
(0.0030)
(0.0031)
(0.0028)
(0.0029)
(0.0028)
(0.0029) (0.0028)
HAC-Bi
(0.0037)
(0.0038)
(0.0029)
(0.0029)
(0.0027)
(0.0028)
(0.0027)
Age Sqrd.
0.0190
0.0153
0.0140
0.0113
0.0113
0.0087
0.0110
0.0084
Classical
(0.0017)
(0.0018)
(0.0016)
(0.0016)
(0.0016)
(0.0016)
(0.0016)
(0.0016)
White
(0.0027)
(0.0027)
(0.0024)
(0.0024)
(0.0023)
(0.0023)
(0.0023)
(0.0023)
HAC-Tr
(0.0038)
(0.0039)
(0.0029)
(0.0030)
(0.0028)
(0.0028)
(0.0028)
(0.0029)
HAC-Ep
(0.0041)
(0.0042)
(0.0031)
(0.0032)
(0.0029)
(0.0030)
(0.0029)
(0.0030)
HAC-Bi
(0.0039)
(0.0040)
(0.0029)
(0.0030)
(0.0028)
(0.0029)
(0.0028)
(0.0028)
Beach
0.2405
0.2661
0.1719
0.1934
0.1721
0.1925
0.01688
0.1903
Classical
(0.0079)
(0.0081)
(0.0075)
(0.0076)
(0.0074)
(0.0076)
(0.0074)
(0.0076)
White
(0.0119)
(0.0119)
(0.0114)
(0.0115)
(0.0112)
(0.0113)
(0.0112)
(0.0113)
HAC-Tr
(0.0247)
(0.0247)
(0.0182)
(0.0184)
(0.0174)
(0.0175)
(0.0169)
(0.0171)
HAC-Ep
(0.0275)
(0.0275)
(0.0199)
(0.0200)
(0.0190)
(0.0191)
(0.0183)
(0.0185)
HAC-Bi
(0.0254)
(0.0254)
(0.0186)
(0.0188)
(0.0177)
(0.0179)
(0.0172)
(0.0175)
AC
−0.0249
−0.0229
−0.0159
−0.0150
−0.0148
−0.0138
−0.0144
−0.0136
Classical
(0.0021)
(0.0022)
(0.0020)
(0.0020)
(0.0020)
(0.0020)
(0.0020)
(0.0020)
White
(0.0021)
(0.0021)
(0.0020)
(0.0020)
(0.0019)
(0.0019)
(0.0019)
(0.0019)
HAC-Tr
(0.0029)
(0.0029)
(0.0024)
(0.0024)
(0.0023)
(0.0023)
(0.0023)
(0.0023)
HAC-Ep
(0.0032)
(0.0031)
(0.0025)
(0.0025)
(0.0024)
(0.0024)
(0.0024)
(0.0025)
HAC-Bi
(0.0030)
(0.0030)
(0.0024)
(0.0024)
(0.0023)
(0.0024)
(0.0024)
(0.0024)
Heat
0.0386
0.0363
0.0245
0.0229
0.0235
0.0219
0.0234
0.0219
Classical
(0.0024)
(0.0024)
(0.0022)
(0.0022)
(0.0022)
(0.0022)
(0.0022)
(0.0022)
White
(0.0025)
(0.0025)
(0.0024)
(0.0024)
(0.0024)
(0.0024)
(0.0024)
(0.0024)
HAC-Tr
(0.0033)
(0.0033)
(0.0028)
(0.0028)
(0.0028)
(0.0028)
(0.0028)
(0.0028)
HAC-Ep
(0.0035)
(0.0035)
(0.0029)
(0.0030)
(0.0029)
(0.0029)
(0.0029)
(0.0029)
HAC-Bi
(0.0386)
(0.0030)
(0.0028)
(0.0028)
(0.0028)
(0.0028)
(0.0028)
(0.0028)
Travel time
−0.0649
−0.0579
−0.0541
−0.0494
−0.0519
−0.0472
−0.0516
−0.0472
Classical
(0.00243)
(0.0024)
(0.0022)
(0.0023)
(0.0022)
(0.0022)
(0.0022)
(0.0022)
White
(0.0025)
(0.0025)
(0.0023)
(0.0023)
(0.0023)
(0.0023)
(0.0023)
(0.0023)
HAC-Tr
(0.0049)
(0.0049)
(0.0035)
(0.0035)
(0.0033)
(0.0034)
(0.0033)
(0.0034)
HAC-Ep
(0.0056)
(0.0056)
(0.0038)
(0.0039)
(0.0037)
(0.0037)
(0.0036)
(0.0037)
30
L. Anselin, N. Lozano-Gracia
Table 9 continued Variable
OLS
IV
Queen weights
knn6 weights
knn12 weights
LAG
LAG-end
LAG
LAG-end
LAG
LAG-end (0.0034)
HAC-Bi
(0.0050)
(0.0050)
(0.0035)
(0.0036)
(0.0034)
(0.0034)
(0.0033)
Poverty
0.0142
−0.0210
0.0201
−0.0454
−0.0137
−0.0386
−0.0137
−0.0379
Classical
(0.0152)
(0.0154)
(0.0142)
(0.0143)
(0.0141)
(0.0142)
(0.0140)
(0.0142)
White
(0.0178)
(0.0181)
(0.0164)
(0.0166)
(0.0163)
(0.0165)
(0.0163)
(0.0165)
HAC-Tr
(0.0302)
(0.0318)
(0.0216)
(0.0230)
(0.0206)
(0.0220)
(0.0205)
(0.0219)
HAC-Ep
(0.0336)
(0.0356)
(0.0233)
(0.0251)
(0.0222)
(0.0239)
(0.0218)
(0.0236)
HAC-Bi
(0.0307)
(0.0324)
(0.0218)
(0.0232)
(0.0207)
(0.0221)
(0.0206)
(0.0220)
White
0.3230
0.3179
0.2282
0.2253
0.2241
0.2208
0.2173
0.2151
Classical
(0.0059)
(0.0060)
(0.0057)
(0.0058)
(0.0057)
(0.0057)
(0.0057)
(0.0057)
White
(0.0059)
(0.0060)
(0.0063)
(0.0063)
(0.0063)
(0.0063)
(0.0062)
(0.0062)
HAC-Tr
(0.0117)
(0.0120)
(0.0088)
(0.0089)
(0.0086)
(0.0087)
(0.0084)
(0.0086)
HAC-Ep
(0.0133)
(0.0136)
(0.0096)
(0.0098)
(0.0094)
(0.0096)
(0.0092)
(0.0094)
HAC-Bi
(0.0119)
(0.0122)
(0.0088)
(0.0090)
(0.0086)
(0.0088)
(0.0085)
(0.0087)
Over65
0.1125
0.0376
0.0327
−0.0213
0.0231
−0.0297
0.0239
−0.0276
Classical
(0.0173)
(0.0177)
(0.0162)
(0.0164)
(0.0161)
(0.0163)
(0.0057)
(0.0163)
White
(0.0190)
(0.0189)
(0.0165)
(0.0168)
(0.0162)
(0.0164)
(0.0163)
(0.0165)
HAC-Tr
(0.0340)
(0.0337)
(0.0240)
(0.0246)
(0.0226)
(0.0235)
(0.0224)
(0.0235)
HAC-Ep
(0.0378)
(0.0374)
(0.0260)
(0.0267)
(0.0244)
(0.0256)
(0.0241)
(0.0254)
HAC-Bi
(0.0349)
(0.0346)
(0.0245)
(0.0250)
(0.0229)
(0.0238)
(0.0228)
(0.0238)
College
1.0155
0.9192
0.5988
0.5342
0.5807
0.5156
0.5341
0.4751
Classical
(0.0093)
(0.0098)
(0.0113)
(0.0114)
(0.0111)
(0.0111)
(0.0113)
(0.0113)
White
(0.0110)
(0.0110)
(0.0147)
(0.0141)
(0.0150)
(0.0144)
(0.0149)
(0.0144)
HAC-Tr
(0.0216)
(0.0216)
(0.0204)
(0.0196)
(0.0204)
(0.0196)
(0.0207)
(0.0199)
HAC-Ep
(0.0242)
(0.0244)
(0.0220)
(0.0212)
(0.0219)
(0.0211)
(0.0221)
(0.0213)
HAC-Bi
(0.0221)
(0.0221)
(0.0207)
(0.0199)
(0.0207)
(0.0199)
(0.0210)
(0.0201)
Income
0.0212
0.0224
0.0085
0.0096
0.0083
0.0093
0.0073
0.0085
Classical
(0.0005)
(0.0005)
(0.0005)
(0.0005)
(0.0005)
(0.0005)
(0.0005)
(0.0005)
White
(0.0009)
(0.0009)
(0.0007)
(0.0007)
(0.0007)
(0.0007)
(0.0007)
(0.0007)
HAC-Tr
(0.0014)
(0.0014)
(0.0009)
(0.0009)
(0.0009)
(0.0009)
(0.0009)
(0.0009)
HAC-Ep
(0.0015)
(0.0015)
(0.0010)
(0.0010)
(0.0010)
(0.0010)
(0.0010)
(0.0010)
HAC-Bi
(0.0014)
(0.0014)
(0.0010)
(0.0009)
(0.0009)
(0.0009)
(0.0009)
(0.0009)
Vcrime
−0.3938
−0.2450
−0.2446
−0.1261
−0.2283
−0.1130
−0.2098
−0.0940
Classical
(0.0236)
(0.0251)
(0.0222)
(0.0233)
(0.0220)
(0.0231)
(0.0231)
(0.0231)
White
(0.0239)
(0.0255)
(0.0234)
(0.0242)
(0.0234)
(0.0243)
(0.0234)
(0.0242)
HAC-Tr
(0.0451)
(0.0496)
(0.0325)
(0.0356)
(0.0311)
(0.0342)
(0.0308)
(0.0340)
HAC-Ep
(0.0510)
(0.0562)
(0.0355)
(0.0394)
(0.0340)
(0.0378)
(0.0332)
(0.0372)
HAC-Bi
(0.0459)
(0.0504)
(0.0327)
(0.0359)
(0.0312)
(0.0344)
(0.0309)
(0.0341)
API
0.0007
0.0011
0.0007
0.0017
0.0011
0.0013
0.0016
0.0018
Classical
(0.0013)
(0.0013)
(0.0012)
(0.0012)
(0.0012)
(0.0012)
(0.0012)
(0.0012)
White
(0.0014)
(0.0014)
(0.0012)
(0.0013)
(0.0063)
(0.0012)
(0.0012)
(0.0012)
Errors in variables and spatial effects in hedonic house price models of ambient air quality
31
Table 9 continued Variable
OLS
IV
Queen weights
knn6 weights
LAG
LAG
LAG-end
knn12 weights
LAG-end LAG
LAG-end
HAC-Tr
(0.0028)
(0.0029)
(0.0020)
(0.0020)
(0.0019)
(0.0019)
(0.0018)
(0.0019)
HAC-Ep
(0.0032)
(0.0033)
(0.0022)
(0.0019)
(0.0021)
(0.0022)
(0.0020)
(0.0021)
HAC-Bi
(0.0029)
(0.0029)
(0.0020)
(0.0021)
(0.0019)
(0.0020)
(0.0019)
(0.0019)
Distance Parks −0.0287 −0.0395 −0.0213 −0.0298
−0.0210 −0.0292
−0.0205 −0.0289
classical
(0.0011)
(0.0012)
(0.0010)
(0.0011)
(0.0010)
(0.0011)
(0.0012)
(0.0011)
White
(0.0011)
(0.0012)
(0.0010)
(0.0011)
(0.0010)
(0.0011)
(0.0010)
(0.0011)
HAC-Tr
(0.0021)
(0.0025)
(0.0015)
(0.0017)
(0.0014)
(0.0017)
(0.0014)
(0.0017)
HAC-Ep
(0.0024)
(0.0028)
(0.0016)
(0.0019)
(0.0015)
(0.0018)
(0.0015)
(0.0018)
HAC-Bi
(0.0021)
(0.0025)
(0.0015)
(0.0018)
(0.0014)
(0.0017)
(0.0014)
(0.0017)
SB
−0.1411 0.0652
−0.0938 −0.0413
−0.0897 −0.0384
0.0870
−0.0376
Classical
(0.0040)
(0.0044)
(0.0038)
(0.0041)
(0.0038)
(0.0041)
(0.0038)
(0.0041)
White
(0.0037)
(0.0040)
(0.0036)
(0.0037)
(0.0063)
(0.0036)
(0.0036)
(0.0036)
HAC-Tr
(0.0068)
(0.0084)
(0.0050)
(0.0060)
(0.0049)
(0.0058)
(0.0048)
(0.0058)
HAC-Ep
(0.0077)
(0.0096)
(0.0055)
(0.0068)
(0.0053)
(0.0065)
(0.0052)
(0.0065)
HAC-Bi
(0.0069)
(0.0085)
(0.0051)
(0.0061)
(0.0049)
(0.0058)
(0.0049)
(0.0058)
RI
−0.1405 −0.0025 −0.0977 0.0006
−0.0938 0.0021
−0.0915 0.0021
Classical
(0.0054)
(0.0065)
(0.0050)
(0.0059)
(0.0050)
(0.0059)
(0.0050)
(0.0058)
White
(0.0054)
(0.0062)
(0.0052)
(0.0057)
(0.0052)
(0.0057)
(0.0052)
(0.0057)
HAC-Tr
(0.0102)
(0.0125)
(0.0073)
(0.0085)
(0.0070)
(0.0082)
(0.0069)
(0.0081)
HAC-Ep
(0.0114)
(0.0142)
(0.0079)
(0.0094)
(0.0076)
(0.0091)
(0.0074)
(0.0089)
HAC-Bi
(0.0103)
(0.0127)
(0.0073)
(0.0086)
(0.0070)
(0.0083)
(0.0069)
(0.0081)
OR
−0.0077 0.0579
−0.0126 0.0370
−0.0084 0.0397
−0.0097 0.0384
Classical
(0.0032)
(0.0040)
(0.0030)
(0.0037)
(0.0030)
(0.0030)
(0.0036)
(0.0036)
white
(0.0032)
(0.0039)
(0.0030)
(0.0037)
(0.0029)
(0.0036)
(0.0029)
(0.0036)
HAC-Tr
(0.0066)
(0.0085)
(0.0047)
(0.0060)
(0.0044)
(0.0057)
(0.0044)
(0.0057)
HAC-Ep
(0.0075)
(0.0098)
(0.0052)
(0.0067)
(0.0049)
(0.0064)
(0.0048)
(0.0063)
HAC-Bi
(0.0067)
(0.0087)
(0.0047)
(0.0061)
(0.0045)
(0.0058)
(0.0044)
(0.057)
Highway1
−0.0199 −0.0234 −0.0130 −0.0155
−0.0116 −0.0121
−0.0129 −0.0154
Classical
(0.0030)
(0.0030)
(0.0028)
(0.00283) (0.0028)
(0.0028)
(0.0028)
(0.0028)
White
(0.0030)
(0.0032)
(0.0029)
(0.0030)
(0.0030)
(0.0029)
(0.0030)
(0.0029)
HAC-Tr
(0.0051)
(0.0054)
(0.0038)
(0.0040)
(0.0035)
(0.0038)
(0.0036)
(0.0039)
HAC-Ep
(0.0056)
(0.0060)
(0.0040)
(0.0043)
(0.0037)
(0.0041)
(0.0038)
(0.0041)
HAC-Bi
(0.0052)
(0.0055)
(0.0038)
(0.0041)
(0.0036)
(0.0038)
(0.0036)
(0.0039)
Highway2
0.0028
0.0027
0.0043
0.0043
0.0043
0.0040
0.0046
0.0047
Classical
(0.0018)
(0.0018)
(0.0017)
(0.0017)
(0.0017)
(0.0017)
(0.0017)
(0.0017)
White
(0.0018)
(0.0018)
(0.0017)
(0.0017)
(0.0017)
(0.0017)
(0.0017)
(0.0017)
HAC-Tr
(0.0034)
(0.0036)
(0.0024)
(0.0025)
(0.0023)
(0.0024)
(0.0022)
(0.0024)
HAC-Ep
(0.0038)
(0.0040)
(0.0026)
(0.0028)
(0.0025)
(0.0027)
(0.0024)
(0.0026)
HAC-Bi
(0.0034)
(0.0036)
(0.0024)
(0.0026)
(0.0036)
(0.0024)
(0.0023)
(0.0024)
OZ
−0.0253 −0.0137 −0.0195 −0.0099
−0.0182 −0.0089
−0.0180 −0.0085
32
L. Anselin, N. Lozano-Gracia
Table 9 continued Variable
OLS
IV
Queen weights LAG
knn6 weights
LAG-end LAG
knn12 weights
LAG-end LAG
LAG-end (0.0009)
Classical
(0.0008) (0.0010)
(0.0007) (0.0009)
(0.0007)
(0.0009)
(0.0007)
White
(0.0008) (0.0011)
(0.0008) (0.0010)
(0.0008)
(0.0010)
(0.00008) (0.0010)
HAC-Tr
(0.0016) (0.0023)
(0.0011) (0.0016)
(0.0011)
(0.0015)
(0.0011)
(0.0015)
HAC-Ep
(0.0018) (0.0026)
(0.0012) (0.0017)
(0.0012)
(0.0017)
(0.0012)
(0.0017)
HAC-Bi
(0.0016) (0.0024)
(0.0011) (0.0016)
(0.0011)
(0.0015)
(0.0011)
(0.0015)
TSP
−0.0047 −0.0102
−0.0032 −0.0073
−0.0031
−0.0071
−0.0030
−0.0070
Classical
(0.0001) (0.0001)
(0.0001) (0.0001)
(0.00009) (0.0001)
(0.00009) (0.0001)
White
(0.0001) (0.0001)
(0.0001) (0.0002)
(0.0001)
(0.0002)
(0.0001)
HAC-Tr
(0.0001) (0.0004)
(0.0001) (0.0002)
(0.0001)
(0.0002)
(0.0001)
(0.0002)
HAC-Ep
(0.0002) (0.0004)
(0.0001) (0.0003)
(0.0001)
(0.0003)
(0.0001)
(0.0003)
HAC-Bi
(0.0001) (0.0004)
(0.0001) (0.0003)
(0.0001)
(0.0002)
(0.0001)
(0.0002)
ρ
−
−
0.3314
0.3514
0.3484
0.3787
0.3716
Classical
−
−
(0.0058) (0.0059)
(0.0057)
(0.0057)
(0.0058)
(0.0058)
White
−
−
(0.0105) (0.0104)
(0.0112)
(0.0111)
(0.0109)
(0.0108)
HAC-Tr
−
−
(0.0117) (0.0117)
(0.0129)
(0.0128)
(0.0128)
(0.0127)
HAC-Ep
−
−
(0.0121) (0.0121)
(0.0134)
(0.0132)
(0.0132)
(0.0131)
HAC-Bi
−
−
(0.0118) (0.0117)
(0.0130)
(0.0129)
(0.0129)
(0.0128)
R 2 (var ratio) 0.7761
0.7947
0.7814
0.8017
0.7833
0.8038
0.7849
0.8055
AK test
18323.48 60.24
137.46
146.9
242.05
564.72
646.04
p-value
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0.3266
(0.0002)
References Andrews DW (1991) Heteroscedasticity and autocorrelation consistent covariance matrix estimation. Econometrica 59:817–858 Anselin L (1980) Estimation methods for spatial autoregressive structures. Regional Science Dissertation and Monograph Series, Cornell University, Ithaca Anselin L (1988) Spatial econometrics: methods and models. Kluwer, Dordrecht Anselin L (1998) GIS research infrastructure for spatial analysis of real estate markets. J Housing Res 9(1):113–133 Anselin L (2001a) Rao’s score test in spatial econometrics. J Stat Plan Inf 97:113–139 Anselin L (2001b) Spatial econometrics. In: Baltagi B (ed) A companion to theoretical econometrics. Blackwell, Oxford, pp. 310–330 Anselin L (2001c) Spatial effects in econometric practice in environmental and resource economics. Am J Agric Econ 83(3):705–710 Anselin L (2002) Under the hood. Issues in the specification and interpretation of spatial regression models. Agric Econ 27(3):247–267 Anselin L (2006) Spatial econometrics. In: Mills T, Patterson K (eds) Palgrave handbook of econometrics, vol 1, Econometric Theory. Palgrave Macmillan, Basingstoke, pp 901–969 Anselin L, Bera A (1998) Spatial dependence in linear regression models with an introduction to spatial econometrics. In: Ullah A, Giles DE (ed) Handbook of applied economic statistics. Marcel Dekker, New York, pp 237–289 Anselin L, Kelejian HH (1997) Testing for spatial error autocorrelation in the presence of endogenous regressors. Int Reg Sci Rev 20:153–182
Errors in variables and spatial effects in hedonic house price models of ambient air quality
33
Anselin L, Le Gallo J (2006) Interpolation of air quality measures in hedonic house price models: spatial aspects. Spat Econ Anal 1:31–52 Anselin L, Bera A, Florax R, Yoon M (1996) Simple diagnostic tests for spatial dependence. Reg Sci Urban Econ 26:77–104 Basu S, Thibodeau TG (1998) Analysis of spatial autocorrelation in house prices. J Real Estate Finance Economics 170(1):61–85 Bayer P, Keohane N, Timmins C (2006) Migration and hedonic valuation: the case of air quality. NBER Working Papers Series, Paper No. 12106 Beron KJ, Murdoch JC, Thayer MA (1999) Hierarchical linear models with application to air pollution in the South Coast Air Basin. Am J Agric Econ 81:1123–1127 Beron K, Murdoch J, Thayer M (2001) The benefits of visibility improvement: New evidence from Los Angeles metropolitan area. J Real Estate Finance Econ 22(2–3):319–337 Beron KJ, Hanson Y, Murdoch JC, Thayer MA (2004) Hedonic price functions and spatial dependence: implications for the demand for urban air quality. In: Anselin L, Florax RJ, Rey SJ (eds) Advances in spatial econometrics: methodology, tools and applications. Springer-Verlag, Berlin, pp 267–281 Bourassa S, Hamelink F, Hoesli M, MacGregor B (1999) Defining residential submarkets. J Housing Econ 8:160–183 Boyle MA, Kiel KA (2001) A survey of house price hedonic studies of the impact of environmental externalities. J Real Estate Lit 9:117–144 Brasington DM, Hite D (2005) Demand for environmental quality: a spatial hedonic analysis. Reg Sci Urban Econ 35:57–82 Brueckner JK (2003) Strategic interaction among governments: An overview of empirical studies. Int Reg Sci Rev 26(2):175–188 Cameron AC, Trivedi PK (2005) Microeconometrics: methods and applications. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge Chay KY, Greenstone M (2005) Does air quality matter? evidence form the housing market. J Polit Econ 113(2):376–424 Conley TG (1999) GMM estimation with cross-sectional dependence. J Econom 92:1–45 Dubin R, Pace RK, Thibodeau TG (1999) Spatial autoregression techniques for real estate data. J Real Estate Lit 7:79–95 Freeman AM III (2003) The measurement of environmental and resource values, theory and methods, 2nd edn. Resources for the Future Press, Washington Friedman M (1957) A theory of the consumption function. Princeton University Press, Princeton Gillen K, Thibodeau TG, Wachter S (2001) Anisotropic autocorrelation in house prices. J Real Estate Finance Econ 23(1):5–30 Graves P, Murdoch JC, Thayer MA, Waldman D (1988) The robustness of hedonic price estimation: urban air quality. Land Econ 64:220–233 Greene WH (2003) Econometric analysis, 5th edn. Prentice Hall, Upper Saddle River Hall P, Patil P (1994) Properties of nonparametric estimators of autocovariance for stationary random fields. Prob Theory Related Fields 99:399–424 Härdle W (1990) Applied nonparametric regression. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge Harrison D, Rubinfeld DL (1978) Hedonic housing prices and the demand for clean air. J Environ Econ Manage 5:81–102 Kelejian HH, Prucha IR (1998) A generalized spatial two-stage least squares procedure for estimating a spatial autoregressive model with autoregressive disturbances. J Real Estate Finance Econ 17(1): 99–121 Kelejian HH, Prucha IR (2006a) HAC estimation in a spatial framework. J Econom (forthcoming) Kelejian HH, Prucha IR (2006b) Specification and estimation of spatial autoregressive models with autoregressive and heteroskedastic disturbances. Working paper, Department of Economics, University of Maryland, College Park Kelejian HH, Robinson DP (1993) A suggested method of estimation for spatial interdependent models with autocorrelated errors, and an application to a county expenditure model. Papers Reg Sci 72: 297–312 Kelejian HH, Prucha IR, Yuzefovich Y (2004) Instrumental variable estimation of a spatial autoregressive model with autoregressive disturbances: large and small sample results. In: LeSage JP, Pace RK (eds) Advances in econometrics: spatial and spatiotemporal econometrics. Elsevier Science Ltd., Oxford, pp 163–198
34
L. Anselin, N. Lozano-Gracia
Kim CW, Phipps T, Anselin L (2003) Measuring the benefits of air quality improvement: a spatial hedonic approach. J Environ Econ Manage 45:24–39 Lee L-F (2003) Best spatial two-stage least squares estimators for a spatial autoregressive model with autoregressive disturbances. Econom Rev 22:307–335 Lee L-F (2006) GMM and 2SLS estimation of mixed regressive, spatial autoregressive models. J Econom (forthcoming) Lin X, Lee L-F (2005) GMM estimation of spatial autoregressive models with unknown heteroskedasticity. Working paper, The Ohio State University, Columbus Manski CF (2000) Economic analysis of social interactions. J Econ Perspect 14(3):115–136 Moulton BR (1990) An illustration of a pitfall in estimating the effects of aggregate variables on micro units. Rev Econ Stat 72:334–338 Newey WK, West KD (1987) A simple, positive semi-definite, heteroskedasticity and autocorrelation consistent covariance matrix. Econometrica 55:703–708 Pace RK, LeSage JP (2004) Spatial statistics and real estate. J Real Estate Finance Econ 29:147–148 Pace KR, Barry R, Clapp JM, Rodriguez M (1998) Spatial autocorrelation and neighborhood quality. J Real Estate Finance Econ 17(1):15–33 Palmquist RB (1991) Hedonic methods. In: Braden JB, Kolstad CD (eds) Measuring the demand for evironmental quality. North Holland, Amsterdam, pp 77–120 Ridker R, Henning J (1967) The determinants of residential property values with special reference to air pollution. Rev Econ Stat 49:246–257 Simonoff JS (1996) Smoothing methods in statistics. Springer, Heidelberg Small KA, Steimetz S (2006) Spatial hedonics and the willingness to pay for residential amenities. Economics working paper no. 05-06-31, University of California, Irvine Smith VK, Huang J-C (1993) Hedonic models and air pollution: 25 years and counting. Environ Resource Econ 3:381–394 Smith VK, Huang J-C (1995) Can markets value air quality? a meta-analysis of hedonic property value models. J Polit Econ 103:209–227 Smith VK, Sieg H, Banzhaf HS, Walsh RP (2004) General equilibrium benefits for environmental improvements: projected ozone reductions under EPA’s Prospective Analysis for the Los Angeles air basin. J Environ Econ Manage 47:559–584 Staiger D, Stock JH (1997) Instrumental variables regression with weak instruments. Econometrica 65(3):557–586 White H (1980) A heteroskedastic-consistent covariance matrix estimator and a direct test for heteroskedasticity. Econometrica 48:817–838
A generalized method of moments estimator for a spatial model with moving average errors, with application to real estate prices Bernard Fingleton
Abstract This paper proposes a new GMM estimator for spatial regression models with moving average errors. Monte Carlo results are given which suggest that the GMM estimates are consistent and robust to non-normality, and the Bootstrap method is suggested as a way of testing the significance of the moving average parameter. The estimator is applied in a model of English real estate prices, in which the concepts of displaced demand and displaced supply are introduced to derive the spatial lag of prices, and the moving average error process represents spatially autocorrelated unmodelled variables. Keywords Moving averages · GMM · Real estate · Spatial econometrics JEL Classification R31 · R12 · C21 1 Introduction A recently proposed GMM estimator (Kelejian and Prucha 1998) for regression models with a spatial error process (Anselin 1988a,b, 2003) assumes spatially autoregressive errors (AR), with the implication that shocks are transmitted globally. It is apparent that there could be applications of Kelejian and Prucha—type procedures to other kinds of models, for instance Kelejian and Prucha (1999) mention that higher order spatial models, involving more than one spatial lag of the disturbance term as well as the innovation term, have been considered in the literature. Apart from these autoregressive specifications, one important model that could also be considered is a regression model with a spatial moving average (MA) error process (Haining 1978), as described in this
B. Fingleton (B) Department of Land Economy, Cambridge University, 19 Silver Street, Cambridge CB3 9EP, UK e-mail:
[email protected]
36
B. Fingleton
paper. The rationale for assuming a spatial moving average error process is that in some cases it may be more realistic to treat the transmission of shocks as a local rather than a global phenomenon. Building on the approach of Kelejian and Prucha (1998), in this paper a new GMM estimator is suggested for spatial MA errors, and Monte Carlo methods are used to illustrate the properties of the new estimator. The Monte Carlo results suggest consistency and robustness. The paper also applies the estimator to real data on house prices, and uses of the Bootstrap as a method of assessing the significance of the MA error process. In the house price reduced form, the spatial lag of prices is derived as the net effect of displaced demand and displaced supply. 2 AR and MA error processes Consider the regression specification Y = Xb + u
(2.1)
in which Y is an n × 1 vector of observations of the dependent variable, X is the n × k matrix of regressors, b is a k × 1 vector of coefficients and u is an n × 1 vector produced by a random error process. The AR process is u = ρ1 W u + ξ
(2.2)
in which W is an n × n matrix of non-stochastic weights, which we take to be row-normalized with row sums equal to 1. Also ρ1 is a scalar parameter1 with |ρ1 | < 1, and ξ is a vector of n × 1 identically distributed independent innovations with2 Eξ j = 0 and Eξ 2j = σ 2 with 0 < a− σ ≤ σ 2 ≤ a¯ σ < ∞. We also make the
standard assumption that the innovations have finite fourth moments (Eξ 4j < ∞) thus ensuring a finite domain for estimation. The AR process implies complex interdependence between locations, so that a shock at location j is transmitted to all other locations, as indicated by the expansion of u = (I − ρ1 W )−1 ξ
(2.3)
which is (I − ρ1 W )−1 ξ =
∞ i=0
ρ1i W i ξ = ξ + ρ1 W ξ + ρ12 W 2 ξ + ρ13 W 3 ξ + · · ·
(2.4)
in which W 0 = I, W 2 is the matrix product of W and W , and W i is the matrix product of W i−1 and W . The effect of shock at j is therefore felt directly at j, and there is a 1 The subscript 1 has been used to distinguish this from the equivalent parameter ρ for the MA errors 2 process. 2 E is the expectation.
A generalized method of moments estimator
37
first order effect due to ρ1 W ξ which affects only those location pairs for which there is a non-zero element on the W matrix. If W was a contiguity matrix we might think of these as local effects. The global effect of a shock occurs because it is transmitted also to locations that are ‘neighbours of neighbours’ via the powers of W . Note that the effect rebounds. A shock to j affects the neighbours, and the neighbours of the neighbours, and eventually works its way back to j. In other words the full effect of a shock to j is not simply the shock itself, but the initial shock plus the feedback from the other locations. To summarise, even though some cells of W may be zero, indicating non-zero direct interaction between some locations, given the matrix (I − ρ1 W )−1 with no zero cells, each cell of u depends on ξ j . In contrast the MA error process is u = (I − ρ2 W ) ξ
(2.5)
so that a shock at location j will only affect the directly interacting locations as given by the non-zero elements in W . Hence shock-effects are local rather than global. Consider next the regression specification Y = λW E Y + X b + u
(2.6)
in which W E is another n × n matrix of non-stochastic weights, and W E is row-normalised with row sums equal to 1, with the spatial lag W E Y an endogenous n × 1 vector. With the AR error process, with u given by (2.2), the reduced form is −1 −1 X b + I − λW E Y = I − λW E (I − ρ1 W )−1 ξ
(2.7)
−1 −1 X b + I − λW E Y = I − λW E (I − ρ2 W ) ξ
(2.8)
which is the model discussed by Kelejian and Prucha (1998). We refer to this as a SARAR model (see Anselin and Florax 1995). With the MA error process, with u given by (2.5), the reduced form is
which is the SARMA model of Anselin and Bera (1998). For the SARAR model, a shock at location j affects all other locations, with the global spillover due to the AR error process amplified by the extra spatial multiplier effect due to the SAR . As noted by Anselin (2003), the ‘induced pattern of spatial dependence for the error term is much more complex and involves the interaction between the two spatial parameters as well as the two spatial weights’. This is exemplified3 by comparing Figs. 1 and 2. These show contour lines for the impact of a shock at location j, which is the central cell of a 15 × 15 lattice. Figure 1 shows the outcome for the AR model, and Fig. 2 is what happens under the SARAR model. Figure 3 shows the contour lines for the MA model. Here spillover terminates abruptly 3 These Figures were obtained using the same assumptions as used to generate Table 1, except that ρ2 = −0.9, ρ1 = 0.9, λ = 0.5, 0.ξ ∼ N (0, 1), ξk′ = ξk , k = 1, . . . , n, k = j; ξ ′j = ξ j + 3.
38
B. Fingleton
Fig. 1 Shock effects with AR errors
Fig. 2 Shock effects under SARAR
at contiguous cells. Figure 4 shows the impacts under the SARMA model. The sharp cut-off of the MA specification is moderated by the SAR element of the model. Each impact is the difference in Y as a result of using ξ and ξ ′ . We generalize the SARMA specification given above to include endogenous regressors additional to the spatial lag W E Y , denoting these by the n × c matrix R. Hence Y = λW E Y + H γ + Rη + u X = W E Y, H, R b′ = λ, γ ′ , η′ Y = Xb + u
(2.9)
A generalized method of moments estimator
39
Fig. 3 Shock effects with MA errors
Fig. 4 Shock effects under SARMA
in which H is an n × k matrix of (exogenous) regressors and X is the n × (1 + k + c) matrix of right hand side variables. Also γ is a k × 1 vector and η is a c × 1 vector of parameters. The n × 1 vector of moving average disturbances is u = (I − ρ2 W ) ξ = ξ − ρ2 W ξ = ξ − ρ2 ξ¯
(2.10)
3 Estimating the SARMA model via GMM Kelejian and Prucha (1998) give formal results leading to a feasible generalized spatial two stage least squares (GS2SLS) estimator for the parameters of the SARAR model.
40
B. Fingleton
The present set-up is different since I assume that the error process is a spatial moving average (SARMA) rather than a spatial autoregressive process. I also suggest in equation (2.9) that it would be useful from the applied perspective to allow endogenous variables additional to the endogenous lag, as in Kelejian and Prucha (2004), although in practice the application and simulations in this paper are restricted to the case of exogenous regressors. The low level assumptions made by Kelejian and Prucha (1998) are the basis of theorems they prove to show the consistency of their estimators and appropriate distributional approximations allowing small sample inference. Although the set-up is different here, one might anticipate that similar formal results might ensue for SARMA since some of the assumptions would be clearly the same. While there is a need, in a formal analysis, to fully identify assumptions appropriate to the SARMA context and to explore the implications of these, the aim of this present paper is not to follow this formal route, but to show by Monte-Carlo methods and by application that the proposed estimator is apparently consistent and does provide a practical method of analysis. To summarize, in this paper I give a similar estimator to the GS2SLS proposed by Kelejian and Prucha (1998) but for the SARMA model, and obtain Monte Carlo results which suggest consistency. The method comprises three stages. In the first stage the model is estimated by 2SLS. The second stage uses the resulting 2SLS residuals to estimate ρ2 and σ 2 using a GM procedure. This is based on some new moment relationships I have obtained using the SARMA specification. In the third stage, the estimated ρ2 is used to perform a Cochrane–Orcutt type transformation to account for the spatial dependence in the residuals. Note that this involves multiplying through −1 rather than by I − ρˆ1 W as required for the SARAR model. Given by I − ρˆ2 W a very large W matrix, accurate determination of the inverse may be computationally −1 may turn out to be singular, so Moore-Penrose generchallenging and I − ρˆ2 W alized inverses are used to avoid singularities. Note that Kelejian and Prucha (1998, 1999) assume nonsingularity for the matrix (I − ρ1 W ) for all |ρ1 | < 1. In the first stage, as instruments we employ a linearly independent subset of the exogenous variables and their low order lags,4 since including high order lags will tend to induce linear dependence. This gives Z which is an n × f matrix of instruments, comprising the exogenous variables, H , and their first and second spatial lags (W E H and W E2 H ). Assume matrices X and Z are full column rank with f ≥ (c + k + 1), −1 and Pz = Z Z ′ Z Z is the symmetric and idempotent projection matrix, so that Xˆ = Pz X and −1 Xˆ ′ Y bˆ = Xˆ ′ Xˆ
Yˆ = X bˆ
(3.1)
uˆ = Y − Yˆ 4 In practice in the simulations reported, first and second spatial lags are used, in other words the matrix products of the normalised W matrix and the exogenous variables, denoted by W E H , and the matrix products of W E and W E H .
A generalized method of moments estimator
41
The estimated b equates to regressing Y on the fitted values of the endogenous variables and on the exogenous regressors. Note that if Z = X then Xˆ = X and this estimator reduces to OLS. In order to develop the equation system, consider next the lagged residuals u¯ = W u = W (ξ − ρ2 ξ¯ ) = ξ¯ − ρ2 ξ¯¯
(3.2)
Squaring and summing the residuals and the lagged residuals, and summing the vector of their products, and dividing by n, gives n −1
(ξ − ρ2 ξ¯ )(ξ − ρ2 ξ¯ )
(ξ¯ − ρ2 ξ¯¯ )(ξ¯ − ρ2 ξ¯¯ )
= n −1 n −1
ξ 2 + ρ22
ξ¯ 2 + ρ22
= n −1 n −1
ξ¯ 2 − 2ρ2
ξ¯¯ 2 − 2ρ2
(ξ − ρ2 ξ¯ )(ξ¯ − ρ2 ξ¯¯ )
= n −1
ξ ξ¯ + ρ22
ξξ¯¯ − ρ2
2 ξ ξ¯ = n −1 u 2 u¯ ξξ¯¯ = n −1
ξ¯ 2 −ρ2
uu ¯ ξ ξ¯¯ = n −1
(3.3)
(3.4)
(3.5)
Expectations are taken across the terms in (3.3), (3.4) and (3.5) to give equations (3.11), (3.12) and (3.13), making use of the results in (3.6) to (3.10). It is possible to show the following (see Kelejian and Prucha 1999) ξ2 = σ2 E n −1 (3.6) E n −1 ξ¯ 2 = n −1 E[T r (ξ ′ W ′ W ξ ] = n −1 T r (Eξ ′ ξ W ′ W ) = n −1 σ 2 T r (W ′ W )
in which Tr(.) denotes the trace of a matrix and E is the expectation. In addition, I obtain the new expressions E n −1 ξ¯¯ 2 = n −1 E[T r ξ ′ W ′ W ′ W W ξ ] = n −1 T r (Eξ ′ ξ W ′ W W ′ W ) = n −1 σ 2 T r (W ′ W W ′ W )
E(n −1 ξ ξ¯¯ ) = n −1 T r (Eξ ′ W W ξ ) = n −1 σ 2 T r (W W )
(3.7) (3.8)
I also use the fact that ξ ξ¯ = 0 E n −1
(3.9)
42
B. Fingleton
and
These lead to
ξξ¯¯ = n −1 σ 2 T r W ′ W W E n −1
(3.10)
(3.11)
n −1 σ 2 T r (W ′ W ) + n −1 ρ22 σ 2 T r (W ′ W W ′ W ) 2 u¯ − 2ρ2 n −1 σ 2 T r W ′ W W = n −1 E
(3.12)
ρ22 n −1 σ 2 T r W ′ W W − n −1 ρ2 σ 2 T r (W ′ W ) uu ¯ − n −1 ρ2 σ 2 T r (W W ) = n −1 E
(3.13)
σ 2 + n −1 ρ22 σ 2 T r (W ′ W ) − 0 = n −1 E
u
2
Given that the 2SLS residuals are uˆ and their spatial lags are uˆ¯ = W u, ˆ the expectations on the right hand side of equations (3.11), (3.12) and (3.13) are replaced by ′ ˆ uˆ¯ uˆ¯ and uˆ ′ uˆ¯ in order to estimate ρ2 and σ 2 . their empirical estimates uˆ ′ u, To simplify the notation let us define the following t1 = T r (W ′ W ) t2 = T r (W ′ W W ′ W ) t3 = T r (W ′ W W ) t4 = T r (W W )
(3.14a) (3.14b) (3.14c) (3.14d)
Let ⎡
and
1
⎢t 1 G=⎢ ⎣n 0
t1 n t2 n t3 n
⎡
⎢ ⎢ ⎢ ⎢ g=⎢ ⎢ ⎢ ⎣
0
0
2t3 n t1 n
⎥ 0⎥ ⎦
⎤ uˆ ′ uˆ n ⎥ ⎥ ′ ⎥ uˆ¯ uˆ¯ ⎥ ⎥ n ⎥ ⎥ uˆ ′ uˆ¯ ⎦ n
⎤
(3.15)
t4 n
(3.16)
A generalized method of moments estimator
43
Using equations (3.11), (3.12) and (3.13) we obtain ′ G σ 2 ρ22 σ 2 −ρ2 σ 2 −ρ2 σ 2 − g = ζ ( ρ2 σ 2 )
in which ζ ( ρ2 σ 2 ) is a vector of residuals, and the nonlinear least squares estimators5 are given by (ρˆ2 , σˆ 2 ) = arg min{ζ (ρ2 , σ 2 )′ ζ (ρ2 , σ 2 )}
(3.17)
In the third stage I use the current estimate ρˆ2 to carry out Cochrane-Orcutt type transformations (though this requires the matrix inversion, in contrast to estimating SARAR as in Kelejian and Prucha (1999). Moore-Penrose generalized inverses are used to avoid singularities). −1 Y Y ∗ = I − ρˆ2 W −1 X X ∗ = I − ρˆ2 W
Xˆ ∗ = Pz X ∗ −1 bˆ ∗ = Xˆ ∗′ Xˆ ∗ Xˆ ∗′ Y ∗
(3.18)
From this I obtain a new set of residuals
u˜ = Y − X bˆ ∗
(3.19)
˜¯ which are used in place of the initial values in g to and thus new lagged residuals u, obtain revised estimates ρˆ2 and σˆ 2 again using the GM procedure of stage 2. Stage 3 gives revised residuals u˜˜ so there is the option to again repeat the process.6 Note that with Z = X this procedure reduces to estimation of a MA model with exogenous regressors. On termination of the iterations, the estimated variance-covariance matrix of the parameters is given by Cˆ = σˆ 2 ( Xˆ ∗′ Xˆ ∗ )−1
(3.20)
and the standard errors of the coefficients bˆ ∗ are given by the square roots of the values ˆ thus enabling ‘t-ratios’ to be calculated, with exception of on the main diagonal of C, 5 I use unconstrained non-linear least squares estimation via a modified Newton-Raphson method which
is suitable for minimising any non-linear function. This depends on numerical differences, so there is no need to specify derivatives. 6 After
a few iterations we find that the difference between subsequent values of arg min{ζ (ρ2 , σ 2 )′ ζ (ρ2 , σ 2 )} becomes sufficiently small (using a cut-off criterion of less than 0.000000001) to terminate. The parameter estimates are taken as those for which arg min{ζ (ρ2 , σ 2 )′ ζ (ρ2 , σ 2 )} is minimized overall.
44
B. Fingleton
Table 1 Parameter distributions under SARMA Mean λˆ k
St. dev.
0.7500
0.0002
γˆ0k
1.0017
0.6756
γˆ1k
9.9999
0.0024
γˆ2k
9.9999
0.0024
ρˆ2k
−0.4736
0.1164
σˆ k2
0.9802
0.0469
Skewness
Kurtosis
−0.14
−0.13
0.11
13.07
−0.36
−0.15
9.16
−0.31
−0.19
8.30
0.04
−0.04 0.03
Normality 5.12
−0.28
8.62
−0.39
15.09
Skewness is calculated as (xi − m)3 /(n − 1)s 3 ; Kurtosis is calculated as {(xi − m)4 /(n − 1)s 4 } − 3; where, for variable x, m = xi /n. The goodness of fit to the normal distribution is indicated by the residual deviance which has an asymptotic chi-squared distribution with the specified degrees of freedom. The table √ is formed by dividing the data into n groups of approximately equal observed frequency. The degrees of freedom are n − p − 1, where n is the number of cells in the table of fitted values and p is the number of parameters (2) estimated in the model. Here there are 7 df Table 2 Parameter distributions under SARMA with non-normal errors l. Normal Mean λˆ k γˆ0k
γˆ1k
Mix of normals St. dev.
Skew.
0.7500
0.0002
0.9460 10.0001
γˆ2k
9.9999
σˆ k2
0.9420
ρˆ2k −0.1822
Kurt.
Normal
Mean
St. dev.
Skew.
0.49
1.05
4.93
0.7499
0.23
5.22
0.7596 −0.34
−0.07
3.83
1.2351
0.7985
0.50
0.14
2.26
0.22
−0.47
7.35
0.78
6.78
−0.25
3.92
0.0002 −0.40
0.0023 −0.34
−0.25
3.86
9.9998
0.0022
19.19
18.32
9.9999
0.0775 −0.36
0.41
9.04
29.87
48.83
−0.1802
0.0025 −0.17
0.0026 −3.30 0.2894
4.52
0.9733
0.0804 −0.39 0.1983
0.27
Kurt.
−0.62
Normal
8.53
Normality tested using 7 degrees of freedom
the t-ratio for ρˆ2 . Since equation (3.20) does not provide a standard error for ρˆ2 , this is referred to its Bootstrap distribution to assess its significance. 4 Monte Carlo results The following illustrates typical Monte Carlo outcomes obtained via specific SARMA specifications. Qualitatively similar results are obtained using different assumptions but to save space these are given in the Appendix.7 The results in Tables 1 and 2 are typical8 of the outcomes. For simplicity I restrict the endogenous variable to the spatial lag and assume that W E = W , hence Y = λW Y + γ0 + γ1 H1 + γ2 H2 + u
(4.1)
7 They are also available from the author. 8 These are based on 100 samples, but much larger samples give very similar results, as shown in the
Appendix.
A generalized method of moments estimator
45
and u = (I − ρ2 W ) ξ = ξ − ρ2 ξ¯ , where ξ ∼ N (0, ω2 ). Exogenous variables H1 and H2 are draws from a uniform distribution with upper and lower bounds equal to 0 and 100. The n × n matrix W is a Rook’s case contiguity matrix on a 15 × 15 square, hence n = 225. Matrix W is standardized by dividing each row cell by its row total, so that the maximum and minimum eigenvalues are 1 and −1. The assumed parameter values are ω2 = 1, ρ2 = −0.5, λ = 0.75, γ0 = 1, γ1 = 10, γ2 = 10. For iteration k = 1, . . . ,100(0), sampling n times from ξ for each k, I obtain Yk = (I − λW )−1 (γ0 + γ1 H1k + γ2 H2k + (I − ρ2 W ) ξk )
(4.2)
Applying the three stage estimation method gives estimates λˆ k , γˆ0k , γˆ1k , γˆ2k , ρˆ2k and σˆ k2 . Table 1 summarises the parameter estimate distributions. It is evident that the parameter estimate means are close to the true values, suggesting that the estimators are unbiased, although there is more variance in the ρˆ2 distribution than for the other substantive parameters, and a suggestion of bias towards zero equal to about 0.25 of one standard deviation. Apart from σˆ k2 , none of the distributions differs significantly from normal, using the upper 5% point (14.07) of the χ72 distribution. The Appendix results are based on 1,000 Monte Carlo replications, using both Rook’s (edge touching) and Queen’s (edge and corner touching) definitions of contiguity on a n × n lattice, and also a torus, with opposite side of the lattice considered to be contiguous so as to eliminate edges. In addition, an irregular contiguity matrix is used based on the map of English unitary authority and local authority districts. Simulations provide a measure of bias and of a single indicator combining both precision (variance) and accuracy (bias), as given by a variant of the RMSE statistic (see Appendix). Most attention is focused on ρ2 through the range 0, −0.25, −0.5, −0.75, −0.95, since this equates to positive dependence, with λ = 0.5, and 0, but some results are also given for negative dependence, which on the whole mirror those for positive dependence. Also I set n = 25, 49, 81, 121, 169, 225 and 400. The results show clear evidence of small sample bias in ρˆ2 , which increases in ρ2 , and with positive bias in the case of positive dependence, and negative bias in the case of negative dependence, which means in both cases that the estimated parameter is closer to zero than the true value. However, it is also very apparent that as the sample size (n) increases, the bias in ρˆ2 diminishes and the RMSE also falls, suggesting consistency. From the theoretical perspective, this is not unexpected, since the formal proofs of consistency given by Kelejian and Prucha (1998, 1999) for spatially autoregressive disturbances might also imply that spatial moving average disturbances will also yield consistent estimates, given that the disturbances are consistently estimated as the first step, although a formal proof has yet to be given in the case of SARMA. In this paper I obtain parameter estimates for a model with an endogenous spatial lag using instrumental variables, leading to what appear to be consistent generalized moments estimators of ρ2 and σ 2 , but under a spatial moving average process. Apart from these large sample properties, it is apparent that ρˆ2 is likely to be effectively unbiased for many practical applications, for example there are in excess of 3,000 counties in the USA, and the results given in the Appendix indicate that the difference between the median of the Monte Carlo distribution and the true parameter value (ρ2 = −0.5) is of the order of 0.04 with n ≈ 400.
46
B. Fingleton
A valuable attribute of GMM is that there is no need to make distributional assumptions. To illustrate this, I introduce non-normal errors, meaning that I no longer sample from ξ ∼ N (0, ω2 ). To explore the consequences, I use the distributions described by Kelejian and Prucha (1999). There are two distributions to consider, one is a normalized version of the lognormal, which is asymmetric. The other is a normalized mixture of normals, which has thick tails. The normalized lognormal is ξ ∼
exp(ψ) − exp(0.5)
(exp(2) − exp(1))0.5
ψ ∼ N (0, 1)
(4.3)
Using the same parameter values as for Table 1, except with ρ2 = −0.2, gives the results in Table 2. The point estimate for ρˆ2k appear to be downwardly biased towards zero, again by about 0.25 of one standard deviation, and there is some evidence of non-normality particularly relating to σˆ k2 , but overall the estimates do not deviate significantly from their true values and on the whole a normal approximation holds. The mixture of normals is given by β + (1 − β) 5.950.5 Pr(β = 1) = 0.95 ξ ∼
∼ N (0, 1)
(4.4)
∼ N (0, 100) so that the Bernoulli distribution for β weights the mixture in favour of the N(0,1) distribution but takes 5% of random draws from the distribution. This gives the results on the right hand side of Table 2. These also suggest that the point estimates are robust to non-normality, although the mean of the ρˆ2k distribution is again about 10% below the true value, and a normal approximation seems appropriate for the distributions. One limitation of the proposed estimator is the absence of a standard error for ρˆ2 . To compensate for this, I obtain its Bootstrap distribution, which is assumed to be close to the null distribution of ρˆ2 when ρ2 = 0 is true. In order to indicate its significance, ρˆ2 should be an extreme observation with respect to this distribution, which as demonstrated above may not be normal, and the error distribution may be unknown. Here the Bootstrap distribution for ρˆ2 is provided by sampling at random with replacement from the residuals u, ˆ under the Table 1 assumptions, with the sample size equal to n and the probability of drawing uˆ i equal to 1/n. We assume that ρ2 = −0.2 but various different assumptions closely approximate the null distribution because of randomization.9 The exogenous variables H1 and H2 are each drawn from a uniform distribution with upper and lower bounds equal to 0 and 100, and the assumed error distribution is ξ ∼ N (0, ω2 ), but H1 , H2 and ξ remain fixed at the first draws so that the only cause 9 Although the true value of ρ is −0.2, randomization breaks up the spatial autocorrelation in the residuals 2
and gives moments similar to those obtained for ρ2 = 0.
48
B. Fingleton
in which housing demand (qj ) is positively related to income from local jobs(wl E l ), equal to the local wage rate (wl ) times the local employment level (E l ), and to wage and employment levels within commuting distance (wc E c ), and to the quality of local schooling (A). The Appendix gives more detail about these variables. Demand is negatively related to the price of housing ( p j ), and given that high prices drive down demand, it is assumed that high prices ‘nearby’ will cause demand otherwise attributable to nearby locations to be displaced, spilling over into j. We refer to this as a displaced demand effect. Hence it is assumed that demand at j will be positively related to the weighted average of prices in ‘surrounding’ areas, which is denoted by the matrix product W D p j , in which W D is a weights matrix appropriate to the demand function. Other unmodelled factors such as demand coming from non-wage earners such as the retired and students, and the effects of criminality, social quality of the neighbourhood, amenity, local taxes, etc., are represented by a stochastic error ω ∼ iid(0, 2 I ). The supply function is q j = b0 + b1 p j + b2 O j − ηW S p j + ς
(5.2)
which assumes, ceteris paribus, that the level of housing supply q j increases in the price at j. For example property owners in high price areas may be more likely to want to realise the value of their assets by offering to sell; in contrast in low price locations home owners may prefer to withhold their properties from the market. Likewise property developers will be attracted to areas with high prices, and by the same token it is also assumed that high prices ‘nearby’ (W S p j ) will attract supply away from j, hence the negative sign for η, in which matrix W S is the weights matrix appropriate to the supply function. This is referred to as a displaced supply effect. In addition, controlling for price effects, supply also is assumed to relate to the size of the existing stock of properties (O) and other unmodelled variables are represented by ς ∼ iid(0, 2 I ). The reduced form is obtained by normalizing the supply function with respect to p, thus pj =
1 b0 b2 η ς qj − − Oj − W S pj + b1 b1 b1 b1 b1
(5.3)
and substituting for q gives
p j = c1 [a0 + a1 wlj E lj + a2 w cj E cj + a3 A j − a4 p j + νW D p j + ω] − c0 − c2 O j − c3 W S p j + ξ
Simplifying, and assuming W E = W D = W S , one obtains pj = λ
k= j
E pk + d0 + d1 wlj E lj + d2 w cj E cj + d3 A j + d4 O j + ε j W jk
(5.4)
A generalized method of moments estimator
49
which is the well-known spatial lag model (Ord 1975; Cliff and Ord 1981; Upton and Fingleton 1985; Anselin 1988a,b). Written in matrix terms this is p = λW E p + X b + ε ε ∼ N (0, σ 2 I )
(5.5)
In Eq. (5.5), p is the n × 1 vector of prices, X is an n × k matrix of k-1 exogenous variables (wl E l , w c E c , A, O) with the first column a column of 1s, scalar λ is the spatial lag coefficient and b is the k × 1 vector of exogenous variable coefficients. To facilitate ML estimation, the vector of residuals, ε is here assumed to be normally distribution with mean zero and constant variance σ 2 . The matrix W E is assumed to be relative ‘economic distance’ based on a negative exponential function of straight line distance di j (in miles) between areas i and j, and on the size of each area’s economy (E l ) measured in terms of the total employment level in 1999 (in units of 1,000), thus l l WiE∗ j = E i E j exp(−βdi j )
(5.6)
The coefficient β determining the rate of distance decay is set to the value 100. This is then row standardised giving the asymmetric matrix WiE∗ j WiEj = E∗ W j ij
(5.7)
In this ‘relative economic distance’ allows the quantity of demand and supply that is displaced to depend on economic mass as well as distance. Table 3 shows the resulting ML and 2sls estimates12 and highlights the fact that, despite the presence of the spatial lag, there is significant residual autocorrelation. This is detected using a row standardized contiguity matrix (with 1s present when two UALADs share a common boundary, otherwise 0s). The LM test (Anselin 1988a,b) indicates highly significant residual autocorrelation, with the test statistic having an upper probability equal to 0.00000001 in the chi-squared distribution with one degree of freedom. The corresponding Z score indicates that the residual autocorrelation is positive. For the corresponding 2sls residuals, the standardized value of the Anselin and Kelejian (1997) statistic equals 4.740; this shows a similar high level of positive residual autocorrelation involving contiguous areas. It is clear that there ought to be spatial autocorrelation even in the presence of the spatial lag if the spatial lag is principally a net displacement effect dependent on both economic mass and distance. There are many other variables that one might introduce, such as air quality and neighbourhood quality Anselin (2003), which could turn out 12 Unreported Bootstrap estimates, which may be more robust to error non-normality and heteroscedasticity, are similar. To obtain the 2sls estimates I regress W E p on the exogenous variables wl E l , w c E c , A, O
and their first spatial lags, except for the lag of A which has been omitted to achieve full column rank in the matrix of instruments. Kelejian and Robinson (1993), Kelejian and Prucha (1998) also suggest excluding high order spatial lags to avoid linear dependence.
50
B. Fingleton
Table 3 ML and 2sls estimates for the house price data ML
2sls
Parameter
Par. Est.
Constant
b0
WE p
−704.0501
λ
0.7233
wl E l
b1
0.7162
9.64
0.7166
wc E c
b2
0.0307
7.40
0.0308
O
b3
A
b4
−0.0005
185.0888
σ
35.8172
36.1263
Df
347
347
LM(χ12 )
31.30
Z
5.595
Loglikelihood
−1764.8763
Akaike
−9.25
11.61
−5.47
9.57
−703.6700 0.7212
−0.0005
185.0621
−9.17
10.78 9.52 7.15
−5.41
9.49
4.757
3541.7526
to be omitted spatially autocorrelated variables, the net effect of which is to induce an organised residual pattern (Dubin 1988; Brueckner 2003). Among possible additional variables that one might consider, there are some such as the nature of the housing stock, planning and building regulations, vulnerability to flooding and therefore the additional insurance premiums for areas on flood plains, crime, social, demographic, labour market and cultural differences, and other environmental factors such as air pollution and noise, and so on, that are also likely to be spatially autocorrelated. While displaced demand or supply may cascade outwards in an autoregressive process, I assume no such chain reaction for these variables, so that a shock, on its own, has a limited spatial footprint. I represent these unmodelled effects by the moving average process, leading to the SARMA specification defined as p = λW E p + X b + e u = (I − ρ2 W ) ξ
(5.8)
2
ξ ∼ iid(0, σ I )
Table 4 gives the results of estimating this model via GMM, the negative moving average parameter signifying positive contributions to the residuals from contiguous errors. The Bootstrap distribution for ρˆ2 based on 99 random samples with replacement from the residuals uˆ gives a Bootstrap estimate equal to −0.003907 and Bootstrap variance of 0.008523, so that ρˆ2 = −0.4883 is an extreme observation with respect to its Bootstrap distribution, ranking below any of the 99 reference values, suggesting a significant moving average error process.
A generalized method of moments estimator
51
Table 4 GMM estimates for the SARMA model
GMM (MA) Parameter
Par. Est.
Constant
b0
WE p
−671.4766
λ
0.7429
wl E l
b1
0.5902
wc E c
b2
0.0320
O
b3
A
b4
−0.0005
175.7372
ρ2
−0.4883
MA
σ Df
t-ratio −8.76
8.22
6.90 6.02 −4.54
9.08
34.8145 346
6 Conclusion The paper presents a new GMM estimator for models with spatial moving average errors, and applies it to real estate price data. While Further Monte Carlo exploration would add to our knowledge about the distributional properties of the estimators, there is also a need in future work to provide formal proof of the consistency of the estimators. The indication from the Monte Carlo results is that the method does produce consistent estimates, although there is small sample positive bias in ρˆ2 . Also, the estimator is evidently reasonably robust to non-normality of disturbances. The paper advocates Bootstrap methods to allow inferences about the significance of the MA parameter. The paper shows that the method can be applied in practice by fitting a SARMA model to real estate data for small areas, providing evidence that house price levels depend on the level of income both locally and within commuting distance, on local school quality, and on the stock of properties within the area. In addition, there is a significant effect attributable to the spatial lag of prices, which is seen as the net outcome of the displacement of demand and of supply between areas. However, this does not eliminate spatial autocorrelation attributable to unmodelled effects, and these are captured by the spatial moving average process. The implication for shocks is that they will not be restricted as under a purely MA process because of the confounding effect of the SAR process. Under the model the wider transmission of shocks can be attributed to the displacement effects leading to the direct price interaction across areas in the reduced form, rather than to the spillover of shock effects per se. Acknowledgments This paper was initially presented at the International Workshop on Spatial Econometrics and Statistics, 25–27 May, 2006, Rome, Italy. I am grateful to Michael Pfaffermayr and the other participants for their contribution to the workshop discussion of this paper. I would also like to thank the referees and Editor for their advice and comments.
Appendx: A. Data The dependent variable p is the mean transaction price (all types of residential property) by area for the period July–Sept 2001 for the n = 353 English Unitary Authority
52
B. Fingleton
Table 5 Commuting distances to work in England and Wales Distance
<2km
2–4
5–9
10–19
20–29
30–39
>40km
%
26.63
25.28
20.93
15.90
4.96
2.05
4.25
100
and Local Authority Districts13 (UALADs). The data were provided by the Land Registry. The wage rate (wl ) is the gross weekly pay for all occupations and both males and females taken from the Office for National Statistics’14 (ONS) New Earnings Survey. The employment level for the year 2000 is based on the annual business enquiry employee analysis, also carried out by the ONS and available on the NOMIS database. Total earnings in an area is the product of the average wage rate (wl ) and the total level of employment in 2000, denoted by wl E l . This is assumed to be predetermined with respect to 2001 price levels. The vector wc E c denotes total earnings within commuting distance of a UALAD. This is equal to the matrix product of the n × n matrix C and the n × 1 vector wl E l . The matrix C is defined as follows Ci j = exp(−δi di j ) i = j Ci j = 0 i = j
Ci j = 0 di j > 100 km Cell (i, j) of the C matrix is a function of the (straight line) distance (di j ) between areas i and j and an area specific coefficient δi . This allows for the different levels of transport infrastructure and commuting in different areas, with the choice of exponent δi based on empirical comparisons with observed census data15 on travel-to-work patterns. Table 5 shows the overall proportion of workers16 living in England and Wales travelling various distances from home to work. Given observed travel percentages comparable to Table 5 for each area, the exponent δi for each area was chosen by iterating the function exp(−δi di j ) through a range of values to obtain the value giving the closest fit17 to each area’s commuting data. The quality of local schooling A has been shown to be significantly associated with higher residential property prices (see for example Leech and Campos 2003; Cheshire and Sheppard 2004; Gibbons and Machin 2003). The variable A is based on the results of the 1998 key stage 2 tests taken by 11-year-old pupils. These results, collated by Oxford University for the ONS, have been converted into an indicator of the quality 13 Small administrative areas, with median area equal to 250.77 sq. km. 14 Available on the NOMIS website (the ONS on-line labour market statistics database). 15 1991 Census of Population - Special Workplace Statistics, available from NOMIS. 16 Total employees and self-employed with a workplace coded, tabulated by residents in each zone (10%
sample). 17 Minimum of the sum of the squared deviations of the observed proportions in each distance band up to
40 km and the proportions of the sum of the function exp (−δi di j ) calculated using the upper limit of each distance band.
A generalized method of moments estimator
53
Table 6 Bias and RMSE with increasing positive dependence (ω2 = 1, λ = 0.5, γ0 = 1, γ1 = 10, γ2 = 10) ρ2 = 0
ρ2 = −0.25
ρ2 = −0.5
ρ2 = −0.75
ρ2 = −0.95
Bias −0.03939
−0.05180
−0.06411
−0.06263
−0.05949
−0.03051
−0.00369
−0.00061
0.01321
0.00615
0.00456
0.01227
0.02726
0.06305
0.08007
0.13611
0.18186
γ0
1.105
0.8463
0.9546
1.051
1.118
λ
0.05009
0.04305
0.04139
0.04789
0.04739
γ0 λ γ1 γ2 ρ2
0.00200
0.01438
0.00200
0.00530
0.00043
0.00270
−0.00202
0.00305
RMSE
γ1
0.4183
0.4401
0.3184
0.3837
0.3669
γ2
0.3762
0.3805
0.4214
0.3290
0.3153
ρ2
0.1672
0.1621
0.1928
0.2380
0.2932
The matrix W is a Rook’s case contiguity matrix for a 9×9 square, hence the number of locations is n = 81, and W is of dimension 81 × 81
of schooling in each UALAD. Commencing with 8,413 (English) Wards each with an A (mean) score, I obtain the mean A score for the 353 English UALADs (there are on average 24 Wards per UALAD). The A variable pre-dates the house price variable and so for the purposes of estimation is predetermined. House prices are also assumed to depend on a measure of the stock of properties. This is represented by the number of owner-occupier households (O) reported in the 1991 Census of Population, Local Base Statistics, Table L20 Tenure and amenities: Households with residents; residents in households. This is available in the NOMIS database. These are predetermined with respect to ‘current’ prices. The results of the Monte-Carlo investigation are given in Tables 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, and 14. Appendix B: Monte Carlo investigation
Y = λW Y + γ0 + γ1 H1 + γ2 H2 + u and u = (I − ρ2 W ) ξ = ξ − ρ2 ξ¯ , where ξ ∼ N (0, ω2 ). The exogenous variables H1 and H2 are draws from a uniform distribution with upper and lower bounds equal to 0 and 1. Bias = median − true parameter value
RMSE = bias 2 +
IQ 1.35
2 0.5
54
B. Fingleton
Table 7 Bias and RMSE with increasing negative dependence (ω2 = 1, λ = 0.5, γ0 = 1, γ1 = 10, γ2 = 10) ρ2 = 0
ρ2 = 0.25
ρ2 = 0.5
ρ2 = 0.75
−0.04359
−0.034565
−0.014012
−0.04048
−0.01407
−0.009049
−0.003599
−0.01565
0.02369
0.003091
−0.015776
−0.03566
ρ2 = 0.95
Bias γ0 λ γ1 γ2 ρ2
0.00275
0.001594
−0.00131
−0.000116
RMSE
0.001342
−0.008423
0.00199
−0.01088
−0.02359 0.00072
0.00795 −0.00893
−0.07260
γ0
0.7556
0.6521
0.5302
0.4298
0.3585
λ
0.03675
0.03469
0.03212
0.03062
0.03164
γ1
0.3476
0.3632
0.3976
0.4137
0.4320
γ2
0.4368
0.4478
0.4643
0.4763
0.4844
ρ2
0.1542
0.1585
0.1812
0.2316
0.3210
The matrix W is a Rook’s case contiguity matrix for a 9×9 square, hence the number of locations is n = 81, and W is of dimension 81 × 81
Table 8 Bias and RMSE with increasing lattice size, with positive dependence (ω2 = 1, λ = 0.5, γ0 = 1, γ1 = 10, γ2 = 10, ρ2 = −0.5) Lattice size
5×5
7×7
9×9
11 × 11
13 × 13
−0.2368
−0.13580
−0.05131
−0.05078
−0.03191
−0.0315
0.01304
−0.00155
−0.01711
−0.01573
0.2739
0.13051
0.09159
0.05433
0.04499
Bias γ0 λ γ1 γ2 ρ2
0.0073
−0.0438
0.00551
0.00028
0.00278
0.00328
0.00124
0.02429
0.00236
−0.00780
RMSE γ0
1.886
1.349
0.9417
0.9575
λ
0.08244
0.06069
0.04393
0.04248
0.8380 0.03541
γ1
0.7594
0.4242
0.4141
0.2984
0.2538
γ2
0.6625
0.4811
0.3529
0.2892
0.2589
ρ2
0.3863
0.2466
0.1884
0.1673
0.1410
The matrix W is a Rook’s case contiguity matrix, n = 25, 49, 81, 121, 169
IQ is the interquantile range, equal to the difference between the 0.75 and 0.25 quantile. While this approximation is based in IQ rather than the variance, under normality the median is equal to the mean and apart from slight rounding IQ/1.35 is the standard deviation, so this measure reduces to the standard RMSE statistic (see Kapoor et al. 2007).
A generalized method of moments estimator
55
Table 9 Bias and RMSE with increasing lattice size, with negative dependence (ω2 = 1, λ = 0.5, γ0 = 1, γ1 = 10, γ2 = 10, ρ2 = 0.5) Lattice size
5×5
7×7
9×9
11 × 11
13 × 13
Bias γ0 λ γ1 γ2 ρ2 RMSE
0.01140
0.008986
0.01572
−0.000547
−0.00058
−0.008423
−0.008858
−0.00338
0.5369
−0.00354
−0.014012
−0.04602
−0.00281
−0.003599
−0.02613
−0.02669
−0.015776
−0.00093
−0.03493
0.00102
0.001342
−0.04155
0.007480
−0.004339
−0.01216
−0.01978
γ0
2.041
1.022
0.5302
0.4672
λ
0.1024
0.05315
0.03212
0.02859
0.02825
γ1
0.8913
0.5116
0.3976
0.3519
0.3031
γ2
0.7220
0.5154
0.4643
0.3666
0.2698
ρ2
0.3308
0.2217
0.1812
0.1591
0.1377
The matrix W is a Rook’s case contiguity matrix, n = 25, 49, 81, 121, 169
Table 10 Bias with increasing positive dependence, zero endogenous lag (ω2 = 1, λ = 0, γ0 = 1, γ1 = 10, γ2 = 10) Bias
ρ2 = 0
γ0
0.009549
λ
0.000857
γ1
ρ2 = −0.25
ρ2 = −0.5
ρ2 = −0.75
ρ2 = −0.95
−0.01349
−0.03156
0.02958
0.00325
0.00001
0.002693
0.00450
0.01544
0.01128
0.02087
γ2
0.001488
0.00323
0.01373
0.01448
0.00765
ρ2
0.017635
0.04004
0.07117
0.09901
0.12915
0.00164
−0.00863
0.00285
The matrix W is a Rook’s case contiguity matrix for a 9×9 square, hence the number of locations is n = 81, and W is of dimension 81 × 81
Table 11 Bias with positive dependence, W based on English local authority areas (ω2 = 1, λ = 0.5, γ0 = 1, γ1 = 10, γ2 = 10) Bias
ρ2 = −0.5
ρ2 = −0.75
−0.02116
−0.05811
γ1
0.00368
γ2
−0.00821
−0.00680
γ0 λ
ρ2
0.00078
0.03848
0.00282
−0.00746
0.07116
The W is a contiguity matrix for English unitary authority and local authority districts, hence n = 353 and W is of dimension 383 × 383
56
B. Fingleton
Table 12 Bias with increasing positive dependence, W based Queen’s case contiguity matrix (ω2 = 1, λ = 0.5, γ0 = 1, γ1 = 10, γ2 = 10) Bias γ0 λ γ1 γ2 ρ2
ρ2 = 0
ρ2 = −0.25
ρ2 = −0.5
ρ2 = −0.75
ρ2 = −0.95
−0.05545
−0.09031
−0.12330
−0.15041
−0.19883
−0.01710
−0.01504
−0.01599
0.00025
0.00947
0.08621
0.11039
0.14528
−0.01482
−0.00751
0.00453
0.00547
−0.00437
0.00666
−0.00635
0.01013
−0.00039
0.01262
0.18766
0.22444
The matrix W is a Queen’s case contiguity matrix for a 9 × 9 square, hence the number of locations is n = 81, and W is of dimension 81 × 81 Table 13 Bias with increasing lattice size, with positive dependence and W based Queen’s case contiguity matrix (ω2 = 1, λ = 0.5, γ0 = 1, γ1 = 10, γ2 = 10, ρ2 = −0.5) Lattice size
5×5
7×7
−1.3587
−0.4148
−0.0685
0.0147
9×9
11 × 11
13 × 13
15 × 15
20 × 20
−0.12330
−0.05099
−0.13849
−0.05895
−0.02488
−0.01599
−0.00026
−0.01288
0.01715
−0.00477
0.14528
0.11147
0.07805
Bias γ0 λ γ1 γ2 ρ2
0.0491
0.0288 0.4251
0.0184
−0.0357
0.2503
0.00666
−0.00039
0.00565
−0.00778
0.00673
−0.00611
0.00250
−0.01167
0.06296
0.00225
0.00098 0.03917
The matrix W is a Queen’s case contiguity matrix, n = 25, 49, 81, 121, 169, 225 and 400 Table 14 Bias with increasing lattice size, with positive dependence and W based on a torus (ω2 = 1, λ = 0.5, γ0 = 1, γ1 = 10, γ2 = 10, ρ2 = −0.5) Lattice size
5×5
7×7
9×9
11 × 11
13 × 13
Bias γ0 λ γ1 γ2 ρ2
−0.17578
−0.09959
−0.03626
−0.01696
−0.10304
−0.00836
0.01238
0.01888
0.01372
−0.03448
−0.01573
−0.00789
0.00442
−0.03065
0.26219
0.00253
0.14833
0.00476
0.08906
−0.00002
−0.01300
0.06774
0.00343 0.00536
0.03818
The matrix W is a Rook’s case contiguity matrix based on a torus (with opposite edges of the lattice considered to be contiguous), n = 25, 49, 81, 121, 169
In all cases W is normalised to row totals equal to 1 and the bias and RMSE are based on 1,000 Monte Carlo replications with n = 25, 49, 81, 121, 169, 225 and 400. References Anselin L (1988a) Lagrange multiplier test diagnostics for spatial dependence and spatial heterogeneity. Geogr Anal 20:1–17
A generalized method of moments estimator
57
Anselin L (1988b) Spatial econometrics: methods and models. Kluwer, Dordrecht Anselin L (2003) Spatial externalities, spatial multipliers, and spatial econometrics. Int Reg Sci Rev 26: 153–166 Anselin L, Kelejian HH (1997) Testing for spatial error autocorrelation in the presence of endogenous regressors. Int Reg Sci Rev 20:153–182 Anselin L, Florax R (1995) New directions in spatial econometrics. Springer, London Anselin L, Bera A (1998) Spatial dependence in linear regression models with an introduction to spatial econometrics. In: Ullah A, Giles DE (eds) Handbook of applied economic statistics. Marcel Dekker, New York Brueckner JK (2003) Strategic interaction among governments: an overview of empirical studies. Int Reg Sci Rev 26:175–188 Cheshire P, Sheppard S (2004) Capitalising the value of free schools: the impact of supply characteristics and uncertainty. Econ J 114:F397–F424 Cliff AD, Ord JK (1981) Spatial processes : models and applications. Pion, London Dubin RA (1988) Estimation of regression coefficients in the presence of spatially autocorrelated error terms. Rev Econ Stat 70:466–474 Gibbons S, Machin S (2003) Valuing english primary schools. J Urban Econ 53:197–219 Haining RP (1978) The moving average model for spatial interaction. Trans Inst Br Geogr 3:202–225 Kapoor M, Kelejian HH, Prucha I (2007) Panel data models with spatially correlated error components. J Econom (forthcoming) Kelejian HH, Robinson DP (1993) A suggested method of estimation for spatial interdependent models with autocorrelated errors, and an application to a county expenditure model. Papers Reg Sci 72:297–312 Kelejian HH, Prucha IR (1998) A generalized spatial two-stage least squares procedure for estimating a spatial autoregressive model with autoregressive disturbances. J Real Estate Financ Econ 17:99–121 Kelejian HH, Prucha IR (1999) A generalized moments estimator for the autoregressive parameter in a spatial model. Int Econ Rev 40:509–533 Kelejian HH, Prucha IR (2004) Estimation of simultaneous systems of spatially interrelated cross sectional equations. J Econom 118:27–50 Leech D, Campos E (2003) Is comprehensive education really free? : a case-study of the effects of secondary school admissions policies on house prices in one local area. J Roy Stat Soc A 166:135–154 Ord JK (1975) Estimation methods for models of spatial interaction. J Am Stat Assoc 70:120–126 Upton GJG, Fingleton B (1985) Spatial data analysis by example, vol 1. Wiley, Chichester
Spatial analysis of urban growth in Spain, 1900–2001 Julie Le Gallo · Coro Chasco
Abstract The purpose of this paper is to improve the knowledge of the Spanish urban system. We study the evolution of population growth among the group of 722 municipalities included in the Spanish urban areas over the period 1900–2001. A spatial SUR model is estimated for Zipf’s law and shows the existence of two main phases: divergence (1900–1980) and convergence (1980–2001). Then, the cross-sectional distribution of urban population is characterized by means of nonparametric estimations of density functions and the growth process is modeled as a first-order stationary Markov chain. Spatial effects are finally introduced within the Markov chain framework using regional conditioning. This analysis shows a low interclass mobility, i.e., a high-persistence of urban municipalities to stay in their own class from one decade to another over the whole period, and the influence of the geographical environment on urban population dynamism.
Previous versions of this paper were presented at the 45th Congress of the European Regional Science Association (Vrije Universiteit, Amsterdam, Netherlands, August 23–27, 2005) and at the International Workshop on Spatial Econometrics and Statistics (Rome, Italy, May 25–27, 2006). We would like to thank two anonymous referees, M. Bosker, P. Cheshire, A. Carrington, B. Fingleton, R. Guillain, E. Lopez-Bazo, J. Paelinck and the other participants of these meetings for their valuable comments. Coro Chasco acknowledges financial support from the Spanish Ministry of Education and Science SEJ2006-14277-C04-01. The usual disclaimers apply. J. Le Gallo (B) CRESE, Université de Franche-Comté, 45D, avenue de l’Observatoire, 25030 Besancon Cedex, France e-mail:
[email protected] C. Chasco Departamento de Economía Aplicada, Universidad Autónoma de Madrid, 28049 Madrid, Spain e-mail:
[email protected]
60
J. Le Gallo, C. Chasco
Keywords Convergence · Urban growth · Spatial autocorrelation · Spatial SUR models · Markov chains JEL Classifications C14 · C21 · O18 1 Introduction Economic development is associated with the movement of population from the countryside to cities. This observation raises the question of how cities of different sizes grow during the process of development. The size distribution of cities may become more even over time if smaller cities catch up with larger ones. At the other extreme, urbanization may take the form of the expansion of the largest cities. In this case, the size distribution would become more unequal. In this paper, we consider the particular experience of Spain between 1900 and 2001. Our aim is thus to improve the knowledge of the Spanish urban system and answer the following questions. How has the size distribution evolved over the last century? Has it become more even or more unequal? Is there a lot of mobility of cities within this size distribution? These questions are particularly relevant since the Spanish urbanization process has mainly taken place during the twentieth century producing significant processes of industrialization and economic growth. Specifically in Spain, this process has not been uniform and different results may be found depending on the definition of an “urban area”. In fact, there is no official definition of an “urban area” in Spain and it is not easy to obtain statistical data at the level of municipalities. Hence, analyses of the Spanish urban system are still scarce. Nevertheless, some authors have considered the group of “main cities” -above 50,000 inhabitants—as urban units (e.g. Lanaspa et al. 2003, 2004, Mella and Chasco 2006). In this paper, we propose to work with the set of municipalities that form the Spanish “urban areas”, as defined by the Ministerio de Fomento (2000). It is a heterogeneous group of municipalites that not only includes the main cities but also all the satellite towns that make up the complete metropolitan area. We study the evolution of population growth among this set of 722 municipalities included in the present Spanish urban areas over the period 1900–2001. In order to examine urban evolution and answer the preceding questions, we first examine the city size distribution by centering on the question of whether Zipf’s law or its deterministic equivalent, the rank-size rule, holds for Spanish cities. Zipf’s law has been applied in numerous studies (see Gabaix and Ioannides 2004, for a recent review) but none of them considers the possibility of spatial effects. However, due to the geographical nature of the empirical data used, we emphasize in this paper the need to pay attention to the appropriate econometric methodology needed for a reliable statistical inference. Therefore, we formally test for spatial autocorrelation and spatial heteroskedasticity in the spatial SUR framework suggested by Anselin (1988). This empirical work on the rank-size rule is essentially involved with one particular characteristic of the distribution of city sizes: the shape of that distribution. However, some papers have also paid attention to the intra-distribution dynamics (Eaton and Eckstein 1997; Black and Henderson 1999, 2003; Lanaspa et al. 2004). Indeed, as
Spatial analysis of urban growth in Spain, 1900–2001
61
Quah (1996) has forcefully argued, typical cross-section or panel data econometric techniques do not allow inference about patterns in the intertemporal evolution of the entire cross-sectional distribution. Making such inferences requires estimating directly the full dynamics of the entire distribution of cities. We therefore follow this strand of literature by focusing on how cities develop relatively to the rest of the urban system, both in terms of rankings and relative sizes. For that purpose, the cross-sectional distribution of urban population is analyzed by means of nonparametric estimations of density functions and the growth process is modeled as a first-order stationary Markov chain. The evolution of the shape of the population cross-sectional distribution and the changes in the municipalities’ relative positions within this distribution is then able to uncover the existence of alternate divergence/convergence trends. Moreover, as in the analysis of Zipf’s law, we also adopt an explicit spatial approach by measuring the extent to which the geographical environment influences the urban municipalities’ relative position within the population cross-sectional distribution. Hence, we extend previous studies focusing on the Spanish case (mainly Lanaspa et al. 2003, 2004) in two ways. First, not only do we consider a broader set of cities, but we also analyze the complete set of municipalities that actually belong to the Spanish urban areas: bigger cities and metropolitan towns. This feature allows for a better knowledge of the evolution of the complete urban system in Spain, which is not exactly the same as the one experienced by other groups of cities in the same country. Second, we explicitly introduce spatial dependence specifications and tests in both Zipf’s law and Markov Chains analyses to capture the influence of space on convergence and transition probabilities and we perform a more complete analysis of movement speed and form of convergence in the city size distribution. The paper is organized as follows. In the first section, the evolution of the disparities between the Spanish urban municipalities is characterized by examining the population cross-sectional distribution over the period from 1900 to 2001. We also test the validity of Zipf’s law over this period. In the second section, we estimate a first-order Markov chain and analyze its ergodic properties. The article concludes with a summary of key findings. 2 The evolution of the Spanish urban system 1900–2001 This section examines growth in the Spanish urban system and changes in the relative size distribution of urban municipalities over a 100-year period. 2.1 Data In order to explore these issues, we need a data set with urban areas defined consistently over the century. For that purpose, we have considered the classification proposed by the Spanish Ministry of Urbanism and Public Works (Ministerio de Fomento 2000). It divides the Spanish territory into urban areas, which include a set of 722 municipalities: (1) a set of 495 towns included in the 65 “Large Urban Areas” (areas above 50000 inhabitants each); (2) the group of 227 municipalities considered as “Small Urban Areas” (towns above 10000 inhabitants not included in the Large Urban Areas, with
62
J. Le Gallo, C. Chasco
minor corrections). This is rather different from the approach in Lanaspa et al. (2003), who operated with a sample of 100 largest cities1 as proxies of the Spanish urban system. Moreover, these 722 urban settlements are located across the whole Spanish territory: Andalusia (137), Aragón (10), Asturias (25), Balearics (13), Canary Islands (29), Cantabria (5), Castille and León (23), Castille-La Mancha (17), Catalonia (192), Valencian Community (96), Extremadura (11), Galicia (32), Madrid (33), Murcia (19), Navarre (18), Bask Country (58), Rioja (2), Ceuta and Melilla (2). The evolution of population distribution is analyzed using the Census data over the period from 1900 to 2001. There are 11 decades under consideration: 1900, 1910, 1920, 1930, 1940, 1950, 1960, 1970, 1980, 1991 and 2001. The data on population are extracted from the Spanish Office for Statistics (INE) databank.2
2.2 The evolution of the shape of urban population distribution Using this dataset, we first analyze the evolution of the shape of urban size. For that purpose, we estimate non-parametric kernel density estimates of the urban population distribution for each decade and we analyze its monomodality or multimodality characteristics. More precisely, we examine relative urban municipality size distribution in 1900 and the way this distribution has changed over time in 1950, 1970 until 2001. Relative size distributions are considered, where size for each decade is normalized by dividing by the average municipal area size. Figure 1 shows the relative log urban municipality size distributions in 1900, 1950, 1970 and 2001. This density plot may be interpreted as the continuous equivalent of a histogram in which the number of intervals has been set to infinity and then to the continuum. From the definition of the data, 1 on the horizontal axis indicates Spanish average city size, 2 indicates twice this average, and so on. Figure 1 plots an interesting graph where the distribution is bimodal in 1900 but becomes a unimodal distribution in 2001 (minor mode around 70–80%). This may reflect the existence, in 1900, of a group of urban municipalities with sizes below the average, converging toward a lower population level than the rest of the towns. Compared with 1900, more urban municipalities reported in 2001 population about the Spanish average. The distributions in 1900 and 1950 are quite similar, while the central mass significantly increased in 1970 to reach the highest point in the 2001 distribution. This progressive concentration of probability mass around 100% can be interpreted as evidence for slight convergence. This result is similar to others in the literature (Lanaspa et al. 2003, 2004, for Spanish largest cities; Anderson and Ge 2005, for Chinese cities), though differs from Black and Henderson (2003) results for US metropolitan areas. 1 These authors chose a relatively arbitrary number of “largest cities” after finding that the results were
qualitatively robust to different sample sizes. In a posterior paper, Lanaspa et al. (2004) chose different subsets with the 100, 300, 500 and 700 most-populated municipalities. 2 This data are available in the INE webpage: http://www.ine.es.
Spatial analysis of urban growth in Spain, 1900–2001
63
4.5
1900 1950 1970 2001
4 3.5 3 2.5 2 1.5 1 0.5 0 0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
1.2
1.4
1.6
1.8
Fig. 1 Densities of log relative urban municipality size
2.3 Zipf’s law, or the rank-size rule We continue our exploration of the evolution of the Spanish urban municipality size distribution by using Zipf’s law, or the rank-size rule. Zipf (1949) claimed that the size distribution of cities follows a Pareto law (Pareto 1897) when it holds that: R = a · S −b
(1)
where R is the city rank order of the population distribution; S is the population of the cities; and a and b are parameters, with the latter being the Pareto exponent, always positive by construction. The rank size rule, which emerged from regularly observed features of the data lacking any economic theoretic foundation, has recently been analyzed, among others, by Krugman (1996), Eaton and Eckstein (1997), Overman and Ioannides (2001), Dobkins and Ioannides (2000), Davis and Weinstein (2002), Ioannides and Overman (2003), Cordoba (2003), Rossi-Hansberg and Wright (2004), Gabaix and Ioannides (2004), Soo (2005), Gabaix and Ibragimov (2006). Gabaix (1999a,b) has derived a statistical explanation of Zipf’s law for cities. He shows that if different cities grow randomly with the same expected growth rate and the same variance, the limit distribution of city size will converge so as to obey Zipf’s law. Duranton (2006) provides some economic foundations for Zipf’s law: he embeds the endogenous growth model suggested by Grossman and Helpman (1991) into an urban framework and views investments in R&D as the main driver of city growth. This model can then generate Zipf’s law under some particular condition detailed in the paper. Finally, Nitsch (2005) carries out a meta-analysis combining 515 estimates from 29 studies and finds that cities are on average more evenly distributed than suggested by Zipf’s law. Formally, in this framework, the size distribution of cities is more or less even, depending on the value of the Pareto exponent (b). At the limit, if b tends to infinity, then
64
J. Le Gallo, C. Chasco
all the cities will be of an equal size. When b is equal to one, we obtain the well-known rank-size rule or Zipf’s law. According to this rule, city populations among any group of cities at any time are proportional to the inverse of the ranking of their populations in that group. The Pareto exponent can therefore be interpreted as a convergence indicator. Indeed, values that fall over time indicate relatively more important roles (increasing weights) for the largest cities. More precisely, as b decreases, a 1% increase in city size produces a smaller fall (in %) in rank and the city size distribution becomes more spread out. Therefore, this will cause a divergence trend inside the group of urban municipalities or greater metropolitan concentration. Likewise, a 1% increase in city size produces a larger fall (in %) in rank as b increases. Therefore, increasing values of the Pareto exponent represent convergence dynamics, or in other words, greater dispersion of the population outside the large metropolitan areas and a more balanced population distribution between urban centers of different sizes. Empirically, departing from Eq. (1), we take logarithms on both sides and estimate the resulting linear expression for the set of 722 urban municipalities (i = 1, . . . 722) for each of the eleven decades (t = 1, . . . 11) under consideration: ln Rit = ln at − bt · ln Sit + εit
(2)
Gabaix and Ioannides (2004) have shown by Monte–Carlo simulations that OLS estimation of this equation presents several pitfalls in small samples.3 Moreover, OLS may be affected by the omission of spatial autocorrelation. More precisely, if spatially autocorrelated residuals represent the effects of an unmodelled spatially autoregressive error process, then the parameter estimates remain unbiased but become inefficient. Statistical inference is biased in this case. Conversely, if they are due to the omission of spatial autocorrelated variables, then the parameter estimates are biased. Therefore, and since we have allowed for different intercepts and slopes in each period, we have followed the strategy suggested by Anselin (1988, pp. 203) for the specification of spatial SUR models. In a first stage, we have estimated Eq. (2) by Ordinary Least Squares (OLS) for the 11 spatial equations individually considered (i.e., one equation for each decade under consideration). For each model, we have tested for the presence of spatial effects. As shown in Table 1, the OLS residuals of the 11 equations are non-normal and exhibit both heteroskedasticity and spatial autocorrelation (as pointed out by Jarque–Bera, Koenker–Basset and Kelejian–Robinson tests, respectively). Therefore, we can conclude that both spatial effects (spatial autocorrelation and spatial heterogeneity characterized by heteroskedasticity) are present in the 11 models. We will focus in the remaining discussion on the former problem, leaving an explicit treatment of heteroskedasticity problems for further research. Regarding spatial autocorrelation, the non-normality of the error terms implies that the 3 Gabaix and Ibragimov (2006) also point out that the OLS estimator of b in equation (2) is strongly biased in small samples. To overcome this problem, they provide a simple practical remedy and show, by MonteCarlo simulations, that this bias is considerably reduced when using the Rank −1/2, and run log (Rank −1/2) = α − b log (Size). Although we do not have a small sample and we use estimation methods other than OLS, we have also estimated equation (2) introducing this change. As expected, the results obtained are robust to the modification suggested by Gabaix and Ibragimov, and they are available upon request from the authors.
OLS Basic model
Spatial SUR model (ML)
Spatial SUR spatial-error model (ML)
Spatial SUR spatial lag model (ML)
αˆ
bˆ
JB
KB
KR
αˆ
bˆ
αˆ
bˆ
λˆ
1900
11.04
116
188
10.66
10.43
111
249
10.65
−0.62
0.16
748
−0.62
10.68
11.06
−0.66
728
1910
0.19
10.29
1920
11.04
794
100
287
10.59
0.19
10.18
1930
11.05
668
89
313
10.55
0.20
9.99
1940
10.91
757
85
418
10.40
0.22
9.85
1950
10.82
682
82
493
10.30
0.22
9.69
1960
10.81
616
62
540
10.30
0.23
9.66
1970
10.78
614
37
580
10.31
0.26
9.48
1981
10.67
721
31
509
10.21
0.27
9.25
1991
10.90
744
25
369
10.39
0.25
9.51
2001
11.39
837
13
237
10.83
0.30
9.81
Diagonality tests
−0.66 −0.65 −0.64 −0.62 −0.60 −0.59 −0.57 −0.54 −0.56 −0.60
−0.61 −0.60 −0.58 −0.56 −0.54 −0.53 −0.52 −0.50 −0.51 −0.54
10.67 10.61 10.56 10.41 10.32 10.32 10.32 10.23 10.41 10.87
−0.61 −0.60 −0.58 −0.56 −0.54 −0.53 −0.52 −0.50 −0.51 −0.55
αˆ
LM test:
30.274
–
–
LR test:
22.531
2.928
2.849
bˆ
ρˆ
−0.62
0.04
−0.60 −0.59 −0.57 −0.55 −0.53 −0.52 −0.50 −0.48 −0.49 −0.52
0.05 0.06 0.08 0.08 0.09 0.09 0.12 0.14 0.13 0.14
Spatial analysis of urban growth in Spain, 1900–2001
Table 1 Rank-size regressions, Spanish urban municipalities 1900–2001
Wald homogeneity test b parameter:
687
spatial parameter:
616
513
21
45
Spatial dependence LM-spatial-error:
217
–
–
LM-spatial lag:
81
–
–
LIK
–
6.833
6.778
AIC
–
26.34
48.36
Goodness of fit
65
α = lna OLS Ordinary least squares estimation, ML Maximum likelihood estimation. All coefficients are significant at the 1% level, JB The Jarque–Bera non-normality test on the residuals, KB The Koenker–Basset test for heteroskedasticity, KR The Kelejian–Robinson test for spatial autocorrelation in the error term, LIK The log-likelihood ratio test, AIC The Akaike Information Criterion. All statistics lead to the rejection of the corresponding null hypothesis at 1%
66
J. Le Gallo, C. Chasco
Lagrange Multiplier (LM) tests are less reliable. The Kelejian–Robinson statistics— though highly significant—cannot orient towards a spatial lag or spatial error formulation. In addition, we can also test for the existence of temporal correlation between the 11 equations under the form: E εt εs′ = σts I N with s, t = 1, . . . 11
(3)
where εt is an (N , 1) vector containing the N error terms for time period t and N = 722. This assumption of dependence between equations can be tested for by means of a LM test or a likelihood ratio (LR) test of the diagonality of the error covariance matrix. Note that this specification differs from the most familiar SUR design (Zellner 1962) with N fixed and T → ∞, where the regression coefficients are assumed to vary by crosssections (but are constant over time) and where the error terms are contemporaneously correlated. When the cross-sectional units pertain to spatial units, this latter assumption allows estimating nonparametrically cross-sectional dependence, interpreted as spatial autocorrelation, which is left unspecified as a general covariance (see Hordijk and Nijkamp 1977; White and Hewings 1982 for applications). In our case, N > T , so that the standard SUR is not appropriate and spatial autocorrelation should instead be expressed as a parameterized function. The SUR model can be estimated using FGLS or maximum likelihood (ML). The latter corresponds to iterated FGLS, yielding consistent and asymptotically normal estimates under the assumption of normality of errors. Spatial autocorrelation can be incorporated either in the form of a spatial lag or in the form of a spatial error term. In the first case, the model can be written as follows:
ln Rit = ρt ·
N
wi j ln R jt + ln at − bt · ln Sit + εit
(4)
j=1
where the error terms are as in (3) and where wi j is an element of a spatial weights matrix W . It is equal to 1 if urban municipality i is, at most, 160 km away from urban municipality j. The role of the spatial weights matrix is to introduce the notion of a neighborhood set for each of the urban municipalities.4 This model can also be estimated with ML. Note that for the spatial lag spatial SUR model, the three stage least squares estimation method has also been suggested when the assumption of normality is untenable and/or to avoid the computational problems associated with the Jacobian term in the ML estimation. However, in this case, appropriate instruments must be found and the estimation can yield explosive estimation of the spatial parameter, whereas it remains bounded with ML (see Anselin 1988; Anselin et al. 2007 for further technical details and Fingleton 2001 for an empirical application). Conversely, 4 We have also used a contiguity spatial weights matrix using a Thiessen polygonalization of the Spanish
territory for the 722 urban municipalities. The results are similar and can be obtained upon request from the authors.
Spatial analysis of urban growth in Spain, 1900–2001
67
the spatial error SUR model is as follows: ⎧ ⎨ ln Rit = ln at − bt · ln Sit + εit N wi j ε jt + u it ⎩ εit = λt ·
(5)
j=1
where u it are in the form of (3). Again, this model can be estimated with ML. Two LM tests, LMERR for spatial error and LMLAG for spatial lag, can be computed on the residuals of the spatial SUR model (Eqs. (2), (3)) in order to discriminate between a spatial lag or a spatial error specification (Anselin 1988). Moreover, the temporal stability of the coefficients (αt = ln at and/or bt ) and of the spatial coefficients (ρt or λt ) can be tested for in Eqs. (2), (4) and (5). However, due to the presence of spatial autocorrelation, the Wald tests used in this case must be adjusted. The computation of the LM and LR diagonality tests of the error covariance matrix as well as the Wald test on the homogeneity of the parameters across equations - points out to the superiority of a SUR specification over 11 individual equations (see Table 1). On the other side, both LM tests on spatial dependence reject the null of no spatial autocorrelation. The higher value of the LM test for spatial-error dependence is an indication that the spatial SUR spatial-error model (5) is more appropriate than a spatial lag one (4). Moreover, it shows a better performance in terms of goodness of fit (higher LIK and lower AIC). Figure 2 displays the evolution through time of the three estimations of the Pareto exponent. Though the OLS estimators for this parameter are always higher, they follow a similar evolution. From Fig. 2, it is clear that, in general terms, the estimation over time of the b parameter displays a decreasing trend until 1980, from which it starts to increase. As a result, we can deduce two different patterns over the course of the twentieth century: from 1900 to 1980, the size distribution of the set of 722 urban municipalities is increasingly divergent while from the 1980s to the end of the period this distribution becomes progressively even. Looking in more depth, we can also distinguish two other sub-periods in the first moment: from 1900 to 1930 (smaller divergence) and 1930–1981 (steeped divergence). This result is more or less consistent with Lanaspa et al. (2003) that found an inflexion date in the 1970s for the group of 100 Spanish largest cities. In our case, we find evidence of inflexion in the 1980s—instead of the 1970s—due to the composition of the sample. Indeed, when considering the whole set of urban units—not only a group of metropolises— we can capture suburbanization or deconcentration of individual processes, which were common in industrialized countries during the last decades of the twentieth century (Stanback 1991).5 In the case of Spain, though larger cities started to lose some population during the 1970s, we find evidence for a general phenomenon of counterurbanization during the 1980s, when the declining process of traditional monocentric 5 Fielding (1989) demonstrated that the change from urbanization to counter-urbanization occurred in
Spain during the 1980s, some years later than in most countries in Western Europe. Monclús (1997) and Esteve and Devolder (2004) also reached the same conclusion when analyzing urban growth for different sets of municipalities in Catalonia: the inflexion towards convergence in urban areas took place mainly during the 1980s as a consequence of a broad range of political and socio-economic changes.
68
J. Le Gallo, C. Chasco OLS
b PARAMETER
SSURLAG
0.67
SSURERR
0.60
0.53
0.46 1900 1910
1920 1930
1940 1950
1960
1970
1981
1991
2001
Fig. 2 Evolution of the estimations of the Pareto exponent (N =722). OLS OLS estimation; SSURLAG Spatial SUR lag model; SSURERR Spatial SUR spatial-error model
cities clearly benefited the peripheral cities, leading to the modern multicentric city. This fact can be interpreted as a consequence of a broad range of historical, sociopolitical and economic changes: end of the Franco dictatorship, generalized increase of family income, return of emigrants, crisis in housing supply inside the core cities, demand of more space for housing and industries, improvement in accessibility and motorization, etc. Consequently, the analysis of Zipf’s law leads to an interesting result, i.e., the existence of two main phases in the evolution of Spanish urban municipalities. The main one, which extends over 80 years, consists in an increase of urban concentration only broken after the 1980s. Inside this first stage, we can distinguish two sub-periods, in which the divergence course between urban municipalities has different speeds: • From 1900 to the 1930s, the b parameter displays a slower decreasing trend coinciding with a significant industrialization and urbanization expansion that led to progress and social changes in Spain. In the first decade, though most of the active population was located in the countryside, labor force began to migrate to the main industrial cities, e.g. Barcelona and Bilbao, as well as to Madrid and Valencia. Neutrality during World War I and capital stock growth (provided by American and international investments) helped the development of some industrial activities (only located in certain cities) that demanded more workers (Tuñón de Lara et al. 1982). Moreover, during the 1920s, industrialization and urbanization went on growing, especially in the Axis Madrid-North-Barcelona, leading to an incipient development of other satellite towns along the Cantabric Coast (Bilbao Estuary area, Santander, Asturian cities) and the Mediterranean Coast (Valencia and Alicante). However, during the mid 1930s, the economic crisis and the Civil War stopped the urbanization process (Tuñón de Lara and Malerbe 1982). • From 1940 to the 1970s, the b parameter experiences a quicker decline or, in other words, during this period the largest cities grew at significantly greater rates than the smallest population nuclei, exhibiting an intense divergent growth pattern. Indeed, during the 1940s, Spain lived under an autarkical regime that led to a real ruralization process: the main cities, destroyed after the Civil War, had to be re-built, hunger and poverty expelled a lot of people to the villages and, in general, urban population and active population decreased significantly.
Spatial analysis of urban growth in Spain, 1900–2001
69
Nevertheless, some big cities grew a lot, such as Madrid (due to the huge centralization and bureaucratization of the Regimen), Barcelona and other capitals (Valencia, Saragossa, Alicante and Seville). The incipient political and economic openness during the 1950s stopped the ruralization drive and set the basis for the decisive industrialization and tertiarization process experienced during the 1960s and 1970s (Tuñón de Lara and Viñas 1982). The industrial sector was severely constrained to make it more competitive and many workers had to migrate to Europe or to the Spanish capitals and new economic centers. Development was geographically irregular and affected only the cities located in richer provinces: Guipúzcoa, Biscay, Barcelona, Navarre, Madrid and Álava. Nevertheless, the Development Plans also created new economic poles, such as Vigo, Pontevedra, Coruña and Ferrol (in Galicia), Valladolid and Burgos (in Castile), Huelva, Cádiz, Seville (in Andalusia), Saragossa (in Aragón) and Badajoz (in Extremadura). If in 1960 only 30% of Spanish population lived in cities above 100,000 inhabitants, in 1975, urban population rose to 50%: Spain was no longer rural and became an industrial and urban country (Fusi et al. 1983). During the two last decades of the twentieth century, the Zipf’s parameters change from the 80-year decreasing tendency to a noteworthy increasing one. In other words, the group of 722 urban municipalities displayed a clear convergence growth pattern as the smallest towns grew faster than the largest cities. Actually, Spain went through a strong counter-urbanization process that is not finished yet. By the beginning of the 1980s, there was a peculiar urban structure similar to a star, with its centre in Madrid. In the axis, there were the vast Mediterranean metropolitan areas (GironaBarcelona-Tarragona, Castellón-Valencia-Alicante-Murcia), Andalusia (Seville and Cádiz), Galicia (A Coruña-Ferrol, Vigo) and the Cantabric Coast (Bilbao-San Sebastián, Santander, Gijón-Oviedo). In addition, inside this big star, there was a vast rural desert, only broken by a few urban oases, like Valladolid, Saragossa, Badajoz, Burgos, Vitoria and Pamplona. In the Islands, there was a similar process due to the huge growth of Palma (the Balearics), Las Palmas and Santa Cruz de Tenerife (the Canary Islands). The cities of Madrid and Barcelona grew towards their respective peripheries as did Valencia and Bilbao, although to a lesser extent. Indeed, the whole Basque Country was declared an “urban area”, as well as the Oviedo-Gijón-Avilés triangle (in Asturias) and the cities along the Mediterranean coast from Tarragona (in Catalonia) to Cartagena (in Murcia). The logical problems of the big cities (with uncontrolled growth in the peripheries and an incipient depopulation process of their historical centers) broke their later expansion in favor of middle-sized even small-cities and certain rural areas. Moreover, this de-urbanization of the largest cities was accompanied by some growth in their neighboring towns: suburban settlements gained many inhabitants and city centers were depopulated, restored and converted into CBD’s and/or historical/cultural cores. 3 Mobility within the Spanish urban system 1900–2001 The density functions and Zipf’s law allow the characterization of the evolution of the global distribution, but they do not provide any information about the movements of
70
J. Le Gallo, C. Chasco
the urban municipalities within this distribution. For example, they do not say whether the right tail of the initial distribution (year 1900) contains the same municipalities as the right tail in the final distribution (year 2001). A possible way to answer these questions is to track the evolution of each urban municipality’s relative size over time by estimating transition probability matrices associated with discrete Markov chains (Kemeny and Snell 1976). This line of analysis has been pursued by Eaton and Eckstein (1997) for Japanese and French urban areas and by Black and Henderson (1999, 2003) for the US urban system. 3.1 Markov chains The analysis of the evolution in time of an entire cross-section distribution, or distribution dynamics analysis, is a method aimed at describing the law of motion of the distribution as a Markovian stochastic process. In that respect, working in a discrete state–space has several advantages, as argued by Bulli (2001). Indeed, compared to continuous stochastic kernels,6 discrete probability distribution and transition matrices are easier to interpret: various descriptive indices and the long-run or ergodic distribution are easier to compute. On the other hand, this methodology raises the problem of arbitrary discretization. We will develop this latter problem when presenting the empirical results. Formally, denote Ft the cross-sectional distribution of municipal size (population) at time t relative to the Spanish average. Define a set of K different size classes, which provide a discrete approximation of the population distribution. We first assume that the frequency of the distribution follows a first-order stationary Markov process. In this case, the evolution of the municipal size distribution is represented by a transition probability matrix, M, in which each element (i, j) indicates the probability that a municipality that was in class i at time t ends up in class j in the following period.7 Formally, the (K , 1) vector Ft , indicating the frequency of the urban municipalities in each class at time t, is described by the following equation: (6)
Ft+1 = M Ft
where M is the (K , K ) transition probability matrix representing the transition between the two distributions as follows: ⎡
p11 ⎢ p21 M =⎢ ⎣ ..... pK 1
p12 p2 ...... pK 2
.. .. .. ..
⎤ p1K p2K ⎥ ⎥ ...... ⎦ pK K
(7)
6 For examples of studies using continuous stochastic kernels, see, among others, Quah (1997), Johnson
(2001), Fingleton and Lopez-Bazo (2003) and the references in therein. 7 The so-called Markov property implies that the future of a process depends only on its present class and
not on its history.
Spatial analysis of urban growth in Spain, 1900–2001
71
where each element pi j ≥ 0, Kj=1 pi j = 1. The stationary transition probabilities pi j capture the probability that a municipality in class in t − 1 ends up in class j in t. The elements of M can be estimated from the observed frequencies in the changes of class from one period to another. Thus, following Amemiya (1985) or Hamilton (1994), the maximum likelihood estimator of pi j is: pˆ i j =
ni j ni
(8)
where n i j is the total number of urban municipalities moving from class i in decade t − 1 to class j in the immediate following decade t over all the ten transitions and n i is the total sum of municipalities ever in i over the ten transitions. If the transition probabilities are stationary, that is, if the probabilities between two classes are time-invariant, then: Ft+s = M s Ft
(9)
In this framework, one can determine the ergodic distribution (also called the longterm, long-run, equilibrium or steady state distribution) of Ft , characterized when s tends toward infinity in Eq. (9), that is to say, once the changes represented by matrix M are repeated an arbitrary number of times. Such a distribution exists if the Markov chain is regular, that is, if and only if, for some m, M m has no zero entries. In this case, the transition probability matrix converges to a limiting matrix M ∗ of rank 1. The existence of an ergodic distribution, F ∗ , is then characterized by: F∗M = F∗
(10)
This vector F ∗ describes the future distribution of the urban municipalities if the movements observed in the sample period are repeated to infinity. Each row of M t tends to the limit distribution as t → ∞. According to Eq. (10), this limit distribution is therefore given by the eigenvector associated with the unit eigenvalue of M. The assumption of a first-order stationary Markov process requires the transition probabilities, pi j , to be of order 1, that is, to be independent of classes at the beginning of previous periods (at time t − 2, t − 3, …). If the chain is of a higher order, the first-order transition matrix will be misspecified. Indeed, it will contain only part of the information necessary to describe the true evolution of population distribution. Moreover, the Markov property implicitly assumes that the transition probabilities, pi j , depend on i (i.e., that the process is not of order 0). In order to test this property, Bickenbach and Bode (2003) emphasize the role of the test of time independence. In determining the order of a Markov chain, Tan and Yilmaz (2002) suggest, firstly, to test order 0 versus order 1; secondly, to test order 1 versus order 2; and so on. If the test of order 0 against order 1 is rejected, and the test of order 1 against order 2 is not rejected, the process may be assumed to be of order 1. To test for order 0, the null hypothesis H0 : ∀i : pi j = p j (i = 1, . . . , K ) is tested against the following alternative Ha : ∃i\ pi j = p j . The appropriate likelihood ratio
72
J. Le Gallo, C. Chasco
(LR) test statistic reads as follows: L R (O(0)) = 2
K
i=1 j∈Ai
n i j (t) ln
pˆ i j ∼ asyχ 2 (K − 1)2 pˆ i
(11)
assuming that pˆ > 0, ∀ j( j = 1, . . . , K ). Ai = j : pˆ i j > 0 is the set of nonzero transition probabilities under Ha. To test for order 1 versus 2, a second-order Markov chain is defined by also taking into consideration the population size classes k(k = 1, . . . , K ) in which the municipalities were at time t − 2 and assuming that the pair of successive classes k and i forms a composite class. Then, the probability of an urban municipality moving to class j at time t, given it was in k at t − 2 and in i at t − 1, is pki j . The corresponding absolute number of transitions is n ki j (t), with the marginal frequency being n ki (t − 1) = j n ki j (t − 1). To test H0 : ∀k : pki j = pi j (k = 1, . . . , K ) against Ha : ∃k : pki j = pi j , T the pki j are estimated as pˆ ki j = n ki j /n ki , where n ki j = t=2 n ki j (t) and n ki = T t=2 n ki (t − 1). The pi j are estimated from the entire data set as pˆ i j = n i j /n i .The appropriate LR test statistic reads as follows: LR
(O(1))
=2
K K
k=1 i=1 j∈Chi
K pˆ ki j 2 n ki j ln ∼ asyχ (12) (ci − 1) (di − 1) pˆ i j i=1
Similar to the notation above, Ci = j : pˆ i j > 0 , ci = #Ci , Cki = j : pˆ ki j > 0 and di = Di = #{k : n ki > 0}. If both Markovity of order 0 and of order 1 are rejected, the tests can be extended to higher orders by introducing additional dimensions for population size at time t − 3, t − 4, and so on. However, since the number of parameters to be estimated increases exponentially with the number of time lags, while the number of available observations decreases linearly for a given data set, the reliability of estimates and the power of the test decrease rapidly. Therefore, Tan and Yilmaz (2002) suggest setting an a priori limit up to which the order of the Markov chain can be tested. 3.2 Empirical results In order to carry out the methodology described above, a discretization of the continuous state-space must be chosen. However, as pointed out by Magrini (1999), Bulli (2001) or Cheshire and Magrini (2000), an improper discretization may have the undesired effect of removing the Markov property and therefore may lead to very misleading results, especially when the computation of ergodic distributions are based on the estimates of the discrete transition probabilities. Some authors (Quah 1993; Lopez-Bazo et al. 1999; Kawagoe 1999 or Le Gallo 2004) choose to discretize the distribution in such a way that the initial classes include a similar number of individuals. Conversely, Magrini (1999) or Cheshire and Magrini (2000) base their choice between possible
Spatial analysis of urban growth in Spain, 1900–2001
73
Table 2 Probability transition matrix, 1900–2001: Spain-relative population size 1 <20%
2 <50%
3 <80%
4 <135%
5 <185%
6 >185%
Number of observations 2567
1
0.944
0.053
0.002
0
0
0
2
0.040
0.879
0.074
0.005
0.002
0.001
1751
3
0
0.162
0.752
0.078
0.005
0.003
1029
4
0
0.001
0.184
0.741
0.066
0.008
852
5
0
0
0
0.273
0.632
0.095
315
6
0
0
0
0.001
0.061
0.938
706
classes in terms of the ability of the discrete distribution to approximate the observed continuous distribution. In this paper, we have tried numerous ways of discretizing the distribution, with different numbers of classes (5, 6, 7). Finally, the discretization has been chosen by considering the best performance of the test for order one, though we have tried to set up balanced classes even if it comes at some cost to this test. We distinguish between six different classes: (1) population less than 20% of the Spanish average, (2) population between 20 and 50% of the Spanish average, (3) population between 50 and 80% of the Spanish average, (4) population between 80 and 135% of the Spanish average (5) population between 135 and 185% of the Spanish average, and (6) population more than 185% of the Spanish average. Table 2 contains the first-order transition probability matrix between 1900 and 2001 with the ML estimates pˆ i j of the transition probabilities for population. For example, during the century, there were 2,567 instances of an urban municipality having a population size lower than 20 percent of the Spanish average. The majority of these municipalities (94.4%) remained in that size class at the end of the year, while 5.3% moved up one class by the end of the year. Note also that the transition probability matrix is regular. For the process in Table 2, Markovity of order 0 is tested by comparing each row of the transition matrix to the population distribution at time t using the test statistic (11). The result (L R = 16602.90; pr ob = 0; d f = 25) leaves no doubt that the process strongly depends on the initial condition at time t − 1, i.e., that the chain is at least of order 1. To test Markovity of order 1, six subsamples k = 1, . . . , 6 are defined, representing the urban municipalities’ size at time t − 2. Observations for municipalities that were in the first size class at time t − 2 are allocated to the first subsample (k = 1) and so on. For each of these subsamples, a separate matrix is estimated for observed transitions from time t − 1 to t in the usual way. The general test comparing the matrices for all five subsamples to the matrix for the entire sample simultaneously, similar to Eq. (12) above, results in L R = 198.12. This statistic is significant with 63 degrees of freedom ( pr ob = 0), indicating that the process under consideration is of a higher order, at least of order 2, if Markovian at all. However, there are a number of classes within subsamples for which we cannot expect reliable estimates of transition probabilities because there are only very few observations available. In addition, Fingleton (1983a,b, 1986, 1999) has argued that tests for Markov chains are inflated in the presence of
74
J. Le Gallo, C. Chasco
spatial autocorrelation, which is proved to exist in our case. Therefore, we decided to keep the assumption of order 1 for the Markov chain. We can make several comments about this matrix in Table 2, related to interclass movements, mobility speed, convergence pattern and influence of space. First, the high probabilities on the diagonal show a low interclass mobility, i.e., a high-persistence of urban municipalities to stay in their own class from one decade to another over the whole period. Diagonal elements of the transition approaching 1 have been interpreted as parallel growth by Eaton and Eckstein (1997). However, since these elements are not exactly 1, we can analyze the propensity of cities in each cell to move into other cells. In particular, it appears that the largest and smallest urban municipalities (classes 1 and 6, respectively) have higher persistence while medium-sized cities (categories 3, 4 and 5) have more probability of moving to smaller categories. In addition, in classes 2 and 3, a small number of urban municipalities move up to higher categories more than two steps, even reaching the top (some towns within the Madrid, Barcelona and Bilbao metro areas), while they only move down one cell. Nevertheless, only in class 2 the probability of moving up a class exceeds that of moving down. This low inter-class mobility of urban municipalities is in line with the results found for other cases such as US MSA’s (Black and Henderson 2003) or the largest Spanish cities (Lanaspa et al. 2003): changes in city-size are not drastic over a decade. However, the highest persistence of both the largest and smallest urban municipalities to stay in the initial state highlights the major role of medium-sized towns (10,000 to 70,000 inhabitants) in the processes of urban agglomeration and suburbanization that occurred in Spain during the twentieth century. In other words, on the one hand, a group of cities progressively moved to lower states in the distribution: cities located in the Northwest (Asturias and Galicia), some Castilian provinces inland (mainly Ciudad Real) and in the South of Spain (Andalusia, Alicante and Murcia). On the other hand, another group of medium-sized towns was thriving in Madrid, Barcelona, Bilbao and Seville metro areas, as well as some tourist enclaves in The Balearics, Canary Islands, Comunidad Valenciana, Almería and Málaga. These results demonstrate the existence of some spatial regularity in the main urban changes. Second, in order to determine the speed with which the urban municipalities move within the distribution, we consider the matrix of mean first passage time M P , where one element M Pi j indicates the expected time for a region to move from class i to class j for the first time. For a regular Markov chain, M P is defined as (Kemeny and Snell 1976, Chap. 4): M p = I K − Z + ee′ Z dg D
(13)
where I K is the identity matrix of order K , Z is the fundamental matrix: Z = (I K − M + M ∗ )−1 , M ∗ is the limiting matrix, e is the unit vector, Z dg results from Z setting off-diagonal entries to 0, and D is the diagonal matrix with diagonal elements 1/m ∗j . Table 3 displays the mean first passage time matrix for population. The mean number of years to reach any class is relatively high: the shortest time passage is 91.9 years and the longest is 3110.7 years. Globally, movements up are slower than movements
Spatial analysis of urban growth in Spain, 1900–2001
75
Table 3 Mean first passage time matrix in decades, 1900–2001: Spain-relative population 1 <20%
2 <50%
3 <80%
4 <135%
5 <185%
6 >185%
1
3.93
18.67
39.00
78.88
158,83
311.07
2
51.88
2,82
21.99
62.01
142.50
294.48
3
63.87
11.99
5.53
45.12
127.61
279.61
4
73.55
21.67
9.90
10.20
95.73
251.82
5
82.74
30.86
19.08
9.19
28.87
189.41
6
98.57
46.69
34.92
25.02
18.22
12.89
down, especially for high-size classes, i.e., the expected time to first move from class 5 to class 6 is 1894.1 years. Remember that these calculations account for the fact that starting from class 5, a site might visit classes 4, 3, 2 or 1 before going to class 6. From class 1 it takes 3110.7 years to first visit class 6, with the outstanding upward mobility of some metropolitan cities in the Madrid metro area (Alcobendas, Alcorcón, Coslada, Móstoles, Parla and Torrejón de Ardoz) and the Barcelona metro area (Santa Coloma de Gramenet) as examples of actual moves from state 1 to state 6. This result of faster declines shows that urban municipalities are more likely to lose population than to gain it, especially inland, in big capitals and old industrial centers (e.g. several cities in Andalusia, Asturias, Comunidad Valenciana and Murcia).8 This finding leads to the conclusion of the existence of a general progressive suburbanization process, as in other modern post-industrialized countries (Blakman et al. 1999), which has put an end to the era of big-city growth, favoring the progressive appearance of smaller population nuclei enjoying lower levels of congestion. This conclusion is also compatible with the 80-year phase of divergence, in size, between urban municipalities, only reversed during the last two decades, as pointed out by the Zipf’s parameter in Fig. 2. Third, we consider the ergodic distribution that can be interpreted as the long-run equilibrium urban municipality-size distribution in the urban areas system. Explicitly, given a regular transition matrix, with the passage of many periods, there will be a time where the distribution of urban municipalities will not change any more: that is the ergodic or limit distribution. It is used to assess the form of convergence in a distribution. Concentration of the frequencies in a certain class would imply convergence (if it is the middle class, it would be convergence to the mean), while concentration of the frequencies in some of the classes, that is, a multimodal limit distribution, may be interpreted as a tendency towards stratification into different convergence clubs. Finally, a dispersion of this distribution amongst all classes is interpreted as divergence. Ergodic distributions are computed for population size in Table 4. It appears that the ergodic distribution is more concentrated in the small-size municipalities (1st and 2nd classes), a result that reveals the existence of convergence towards smallersize populations. In addition, we find stability of ergodic distribution compared to the initial one, though there is slightly more probability in category 2. This outcome points to a very slight downward convergence, a result compatible with the kernel density 8 Again, this result contrasts with the US metro areas behavior (Black and Henderson 2003, pp. 358).
76
J. Le Gallo, C. Chasco
Table 4 Initial versus ergodic distributions 1900–2001: Spain-relative population size 1 < 20%
2 < 50%
3 < 80%
4 < 135%
5 < 185%
6 > 185%
Initial distribution
0.356
0.243
0.143
0.118
0.044
0.098
Ergodic distribution
0.254
0.355
0.181
0.098
0.035
0.078
function (Fig. 1) and transition matrix (Table 2) results. As we have mentioned earlier, the choice of a discretization may have a heavy impact on the determination of the ergodic distribution. Consequently, we have also computed other ergodic distributions with different discretization methods and different numbers of classes. For example, with 6 classes and the same number of individuals in each class, there is an increase in probability in the ergodic distribution (compared to the initial distribution) for the classes containing the municipalities with population less than 62% of the Spanish average. When the discretization is chosen so that it minimizes the value of the chisquare test of order 1 versus order 0, there is again an increase in probability for the classes containing the municipalities with a population less than 74% of the Spanish average. In fact, in every configuration we have tried, we observe an increase in probability in the ergodic distribution for the classes containing the municipalities with a population less than 60 to 75% of the Spanish average. We can therefore conclude that our result of slightly downward convergence is robust to the choice of discretization. Fourth, we have analyzed the influence of space on the transition probabilities, as in Le Gallo (2004) and Rey (2001). The relationship between the direction of an urban municipality’s transition in the population distribution and the relative populations of its neighbors is considered more generally in Table 5. The probability of a particular transition (Down, None, or Up) conditioned on the populations of the urban municipality’s neighbors at the beginning of the year is reported. There is clear evidence that the probability of an upward or downward move is different depending on the urban area context. For example, the probability for an urban municipality of moving up in the hierarchy is 7.1% when its spatial lag contains on average less population whereas it is 8% when it contains on average more population. Conversely, the probability for an urban municipality of moving down in the hierarchy is 18.9% when its spatial lag contains on average less population whereas it is only 3.9% (almost five times lower) when it contains on average more population. Specifically, the highest degree of spatial autocorrelation is of positive sign and occurs in nuclei with downward movements that are surrounded by smaller-size neighbors (18.9%). This situation takes place in declining areas with high levels of Table 5 Transition probabilities conditioned on the spatial lag of population
Spatial lag
Move Down
Same
Up
Less population
0.189
0.740
0.071
Same
0.057
0.898
0.045
More population
0.039
0.881
0.080
Spatial analysis of urban growth in Spain, 1900–2001
77
unemployment and emigration, which is the case of some inland capitals (Córdoba, Jaén) and heads of comarca9 (Guadix, Úbeda, Orihuela, Lorca), as well as old industrial settlements (Langreo, Mieres, Linares, Puertollano, Tortosa). Otherwise, the lowest degree of spatial autocorrelation is of negative sign and can be found in regressive towns, which are close to a big city absorbing their population (3.9%). This is the case, amongst others, of the urban municipalities of Huelva, which are attracted by the Seville metro area, or the cities of Teruel and Calatayud, which are close to Saragossa. It is also interesting to highlight that the process of counter-urbanization is related to positive spatial autocorrelation (8%), e.g. growing towns surrounded by a big metropolis. In these cases, the big city spills population out to the peripheral towns that benefit from their advantageous location. Most towns in the metro areas of Madrid and Barcelona share this situation, as well as some tourist municipalities along the Mediterranean coast and the Islands. Finally, there is another case of agglomeration characterized by negative spatial autocorrelation when a thriving city grows if it is surrounded by smaller towns (7%). This condition is present in some capitals that are still in an urbanization process (Málaga) or mainly in prosperous middle-sized cities that attract population from dying rural villages. Therefore, the influence of space on the urban municipality transition probabilities seems more important for downward movements. The influence of neighbors is confirmed by the χ 2 test statistic of independence of direction of move and neighbors population size, with 4 degrees of freedom, which generated a value of 398.087, which is significant at prob = 0. In conclusion, direction of movement in the population distribution of urban municipalities is not independent from the geographic environment. 4 Main conclusions The urbanization process has mainly taken place during the twentieth century producing significant processes of industrialization and economic growth. Specifically in Spain, this process has not been uniform and exhibits different shapes depending on the definition of “urban area”. In our case, we work with a set of 722 municipalities that make up the Spanish urban areas: main cities and their satellite towns. Zipf’s law shows the existence of two main phases in the evolution of these urban municipalities: 1900–1980 (divergence) and 1980–2001 (convergence). The main one extends over 80 years and consists in an increase in urban concentration, though two different sub-periods should be distinguished: 1900–1940 and 1940–1980. In effect, from 1900 to the 1930s, divergence is not that deep, coinciding with a significant industrialization and urbanization expansion that led to progress and social changes. However, this dynamism is violently broken by the end of the decade due to the Civil War. From 1940 to the 1970s, the largest cities grew much more quickly than the smallest population nuclei, leading to a more intense divergent pattern of growth. 9 The comarca is a historical -non official- division of Spanish provinces. This area is headed by a city that
used to be a historic settlement and traditional center of trade, transportation, administration and cultural activities.
78
J. Le Gallo, C. Chasco
During the last decades of the twentieth century, the Zipf’s parameters change from the 80-year decreasing tendency to a noteworthy increasing one. In other words, the group of 722 urban municipalities displayed a clear convergence growth pattern, since the smallest towns grew faster than the largest cities. The logical problems of the big cities (with an uncontrolled growth in the peripheries and an incipient depopulation process of their historical centers) halted their later expansion in favor of middle-sized even small-cities and certain rural areas. The Markov Chains analysis shows a low interclass mobility, i.e., a high-persistence of urban municipalities to stay in their own class from one decade to another over the whole period. However, the largest and smallest urban municipalities display higher persistence than the medium-sized cities, which have more probability of moving to smaller categories. This proves the major role played by the medium-sized cities in the processes of urban agglomeration and suburbanization occurred in Spain during the twentieth century. In general terms, movements up are slower than movements down, especially for high-size classes. This result of faster declines indicates that urban municipalities are more likely to lose population than to gain it, especially inland, in big capitals and old industrial centers. This conclusion is compatible with the 80-year phase of divergence in size between urban municipalities, only reversed during the last two decades. This is why population convergence is still slight and mainly “downwards” inside the group of urban municipalities. Finally, the probability of an urban municipality losing population (moving down in the hierarchy) is almost five times higher when it is surrounded by towns that contain, on average, less population. This result confirms the influence of space on urban population dynamism, also being more important for downward movements. In summary, the Spanish urban municipalities have experienced an agglomeration process throughout practically the whole of the twentieth century, only broken by an incipient suburbanization in the last decades. The main actors of these changes have been the medium-sized towns: on the one hand, some peripheral cities around the metro areas of Madrid, Barcelona, Bilbao and Seville have experienced strong growth whereas on the other hand, a considerable number of industrial nuclei and inland heads of comarcas have lost their old influence and size. The influence of space on urban change is certainly conspicuous. It leads to the so-called “two Spains”, which are no longer split along the usual North vs South partition. In the case of urban growth, another spatial division is relevant: on the one hand, there is a group of declining towns located in the Northwest, Center and South of Spain, which have progressively moved to lower states in the city-size distribution. On the other hand, there is another group of “winners” formed by most of the metro area cities (Madrid, Barcelona, Bilbao and Seville) and some tourist enclaves in The Balearics, Canary Islands, Comunidad Valenciana, Almería and Málaga.
References Amemiya T (1985) Advanced econometrics. Harvard University Press, Cambridge Anderson G, Ge Y (2005) The size distribution of Chinese cities. Reg Sci Urban Econ 35:756–776 Anselin L (1988) Spatial econometrics: Methods and models. Kluwer, Dordrecht
Spatial analysis of urban growth in Spain, 1900–2001
79
Anselin L, Le Gallo J, Jayet H (2007) Spatial panel econometrics. In: Matyas L, Sevestre P (eds) The econometrics of panel data, 3rd edn. Kluwer, Dordrecht Bickenbach F, Bode E (2003) Evaluating the Markov property in studies of economic convergence. Int Reg Sci Rev 26:363–392 Black D, Henderson V (1999) Spatial evolution of population and industry in the United States (AEA Papers and Proceedings). Am Econ Rev 89:321–327 Black D, Henderson V (2003) Urban evolution in the USA. J Econ Geogr 3:343–372 Blakman S, Garretsen H, Van Marrewijk C, Van den Berg M (1999) The return of Zipf: towards a further understanding of the rank-size distribution. J Reg Sci 39:183–213 Bulli S (2001) Distribution dynamics and cross-country convergence: a new approach. Scott J Polit Econ 48:226–243 Cheshire P, Magrini S (2000) Endogenous processes in European regional growth: convergence and policy. Growth Change 31:455–479 Cordoba JC (2003) On the distribution of city sizes. Mimeo, Economics Department, Rice University Davis D, Weinstein D (2002) Bones, bombs, and break points: the geography of economic activity. Am Econ Rev 92:1269–89 Dobkins L, Ioannides YM (2000) Dynamic evolution of the US city size distribution. In: Huriot JM, Thisse JF (eds) Economics of cities. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 217–260 Duranton G (2006) Some foundations for Zipf’s law: product proliferation and local spillovers. Reg Sci Urban Econ 36:542–563 Eaton J, Eckstein Z (1997) City and growth: theory and evidence from France and Japan. Reg Sci Urban Econ 17:443–474 Esteve A, Devolder D (2004) De la ley rango-tamaño (ranz-size) a la ley log-normal: los procesos aleatorios en el crecimiento demográfico de los agregados de población. VII Congreso de la Asociación de Demografía Histórica, Granada Fielding AJ (1989) Migration and urbanization in Western Europe since 1950. Geogr J 155:60–69 Fingleton B (1983a) Independence, stationarity, categorical spatial data and the chi-squared test. Environ Plann A15:483–499 Fingleton B (1983b) Log-linear models with dependent spatial data. Environ Plann A15:801–814 Fingleton B (1986) Analyzing cross-classified data with inherent spatial dependence. Geogr Anal 18:48–61 Fingleton B (1999) Estimates of time to economic convergence: an analysis of regions of the European Union. Int Reg Sci Rev 22:5–34 Fingleton B (2001) Theoretical economic geography and spatial econometrics: dynamic perspectives. J Econ Geogr 1:201–225 Fingleton B, Lopez-Bazo E (2003) Explaining the distribution of manufacturing productivity in the EU regions. In: Fingleton B (ed) European regional growth. Springer, Heidelberg, pp 375–409 Fusi JP, Vilar S, Preston P (1983) De la dictadura a la democracia. Desarrollismo, crisis y transición. Historia 16, vol. XXV Gabaix X (1999a) Zipf’s law and the growth of cities (AEA Papers and Proceedings). Am Econ Rev 89:129–132 Gabaix X (1999b) Zipf’s law for cities: an explanation. Quar J Econ 114:759–767 Gabaix X, Ibragimov R (2006) Rank −1/2: a simple way to improve the OLS estimation of tail exponents. Available for download at: http://econ-www.mit.edu/faculty/index.htm?prof_id=xgabaix&type=paper Gabaix X, Ioannides YM (2004) The evolution of city size distributions. In: Henderson V, Thisse JF (eds) Handbook of regional and urban economics, vol 4. North Holland, Amsterdam, pp 2341–2378 Grossman G, Helpman E (1991) Innovation and growth in the world economy. MIT Press, Cambridge Hamilton JD (1994) Time series analysis. Princeton University Press, Princeton Hordijk L, Nijkamp P (1977) Dynamic models of spatial autocorrelation. Environ Plann A9:505–519 Ioannides YM, Overman HG (2003) Zipf’s law for cities: an empirical examination. Reg Sci Urban Econ 33:127– 137 Johnson PA (2002) A nonparametric analysis of income convergence across the United States. Econ Lett 69:219–223 Kawagoe M (1999) Regional dynamics in Japan: a reexamination of Barro regressions. J Jpn Int Econ 13:61–72 Kemeny J, Snell L (1976) Finite Markov chains. Springer, New York Krugman P (1996) The Self-organizing economy. Blackwell, Cambridge
80
J. Le Gallo, C. Chasco
Lanaspa L, Perdiguero AM, Sanz F (2004) La distribución del tamaño de las ciudades en España, 1900– 1999. Revista de Economía Aplicada 34:5–16 Lanaspa L, Pueyo F, Sanz F (2003) The evolution of Spanish urban structure during the twentieth century. Urban Stud 40:567–580 Le Gallo J (2004) Space-time analysis of GDP disparities among European regions: a Markov Chains approach. Int Reg Sci Rev 27:138–163 Lopez-Bazo E, Vaya E, Mora AJ, Suriñach J (1999) Regional economic dynamics and convergence in the European Union. Ann Reg Sci 33:343–370 Magrini S (1999) The evolution of income disparities among the regions of the European Union. Reg Sci Urban Econ 29:257–281 Mella JM, Chasco C (2006) A spatial econometric analysis of urban growth and territorial dynamics: a case study on Spain. In: Nijkamp P, Reggiani A (eds) Spatial evolution and modeling. Edward Elgar, pp 319–360 Ministerio de Fomento (2000) Atlas Estadístico de las Áreas Urbanas en España, Subdirección General de Urbanismo, Madrid Monclús FJ (1997) Planeamiento y crecimiento suburbano en Barcelona: de las extensiones periféricas a la dispersión metropolitana (1897–1997). Coloquio sobre El desarrollo urbano de Montréal y Barcelona en la época contemporánea: estudio comparativo, Universidad de Barcelona Nitsch V (2005) Zipf zipped. J Urban Econ 57:86–100 Overman HG, Ioannides YM (2001) Cross-sectional evolution of the US city size distribution. J Urban Econ 49:543– 566 Pareto V (1897) Cours d’Economie Politique. Rouge et Cie, Paris Quah D (1993) Empirical cross-section dynamics in economic growth. Euro Econ Rev 37:426–434 Quah D (1996) Empirics for economic growth and convergence. Euro Econ Rev 40:1353–1375 Quah D (1997) Empirics for growth and distribution: stratification, polarization, and convergence clubs. J Econ Growth 2:27–59 Rey S (2001) Spatial empirics for economic growth and convergence. Geogr Anal 33:195–214 Rossi-Hansberg E, Wright M (2004) Urban structure and growth. Mimeo, Stanford University, Economics Department Soo KT (2005) Zipf’s law for cities: a cross-country investigation. J Urban Econ 35:239–263 Stanback T. Jr (1991) The new suburbanisation: challenge to the central city. Westwiew Press, Boulder Tan B, Yilmaz K (2002) Markov chain test for time dependence and homogeneity: an analytical and empirical evaluation. Euro J Oper Res 137:524–543 Tuñón de Lara M, Malerbe PC (1982) La caída del rey. De la quiebra de la Restauración a la República (1917–36). Historia 16, vol. XXIII Tuñón de Lara M, Viñas A (1982) La España de la cruzada. Guerra civil y primer franquismo (1936–1959). Historia 16, vol. XXIV Tuñón de Lara M, Bahamonde A, Toro, J, Arostegui J (1982) La España de los caciques. Del sexenio democrático a la crisis de 1917. Historia 16, vol. XXII White E, Hewings GJD (1982) Space-time employment modelling: some results using seemingly unrelated regression estimators. J Reg Sci 22:283–302 Zellner A (1962) An efficient method of estimating seemingly unrelated regressions and tests for aggregation bias. J Am Stat Assoc 57:348–368 Zipf GK (1949) Human behavior and the principle of least effort. Addison-Wesley, Cambridge
A class of spatial econometric methods in the empirical analysis of clusters of firms in the space Giuseppe Arbia · Giuseppe Espa · Danny Quah
Abstract In this paper we aim at identifying stylized facts in order to suggest adequate models for the co-agglomeration of industries in space. We describe a class of spatial statistical methods for the empirical analysis of spatial clusters. The main innovation of the paper consists in considering clustering for bivariate (rather than univariate) distributions. This allows uncovering co-agglomeration and repulsion phenomena between the different sectors. Furthermore we present empirical evidence on the pair-wise intra-sectoral spatial distribution of patents in Italy in 1990s. We identify some distinctive joint patterns of location between different sectors and we propose some possible economic interpretations. Keywords Agglomeration · Bivariate K-functions · Co-agglomeration · Spatial clusters · Spatial econometrics
A previous version of this paper was presented at the Workshop on Spatial Econometrics and Statistics, held in Rome 25–27 May 2006. We wish to thank the participants for the useful comments received. The comments received by two anonymous referees are also gratefully acknowledged. They improved substantially the quality of our work. G. Arbia (B) Department of the Business, Statistical, Technological and Environmental Sciences, University “G. d’Annunzio” of Chieti-Pescara, Viale Pindaro, 42, 65127 Pescara, Italy e-mail:
[email protected] G. Espa Department of Economics, University of Trento, via Inama, 5, 38100 Trento, Italy e-mail:
[email protected] D. Quah Economics Department, London School of Economics, Houghton Street, WC2A 2AE London, UK e-mail:
[email protected]
82
G. Arbia et al.
JEL Classification C21 · D92 · L60 · O18 · R12 1 Introduction The dominating feature of economic activities is certainly that of clustering both in space and time. However, even if the application of statistical techniques for modelling clustering in time (business cycles) has been a central concern of applied economists for decades, it is only relatively recently that the research has concentrated on the development of appropriate methods to detect spatial clustering of economic activities both on a discrete space and on a continuous space. The possibility of modelling the spatial dimension of economic activities is of paramount interest for a number of reasons. First of all the study of spatial concentration of economic activities can shed light on economic theoretic hypotheses concerning the nature of increasing returns and the determinants of agglomeration. These hypotheses are of paramount importance in international trade and in economic growth theories. A second important reason is constituted by the fact that the effects of policy measures to foster economic growth and development are strongly dependent on geographical clustering. Finally spatial clustering, as a synonym of regional inequality, is a central political issue as a proxy of individual inequality and as the basis for cross-country inequality. After the recent reinterpretation of Marshall’s (1890) insights on nineteenth century industrial clustering in space due mainly to Krugman (1991) and Fujita et al. (1999), the empirical analysis on this subject has developed along two distinct lines of research. Along the first of these two lines in the literature we record attempts to examine directly the underlying economic mechanism, using the spatial dimension primarily as a source of data. Under this respect panel data or pure spatial regressions are used, employing observable covariates related to space. Such regressions end up constructing a hypothetical representative unit (a “site”) and concentrate on the impact of differing covariate values on the performance of that representative unit (see e.g., Ciccone and Hall 1996; Jaffe et al. 1993; Rauch 1993; Henderson 2003). Here we follow the second line of research which attempts to characterize the entire spatial distribution of economic activities relative to a set of hypotheses (e.g., a certain regularity patterns of industrial concentration). In this second instance interest does not rest on the characteristics of a representative unit, but rather on the joint behaviour of the different units distributed across space. Along these lines Duranton and Overman (2005) refer to three generations of measures of spatial concentration. A first generation considered Gini-type measures where space played no rule (e.g., Krugman 1991). A second generation (perhaps initiated by Ellison and Glaeser 1997) introduced measures that take into account space and tend to control for the underlying industrial concentration (Maurel and Sedillot 1999; Devereux et al. 2004). Such measures are based on data observed on a grid of administrative areas thus neglecting the problem of the arbitrariness of the geographical partition used. This problem is known in the statistical literature as the modifiable unit problem (Yule and Kendall 1950) and assumes here the specific facet of the modifiable areal unit problems (or MAUP) discussed at length in Arbia (1989). Arbia (2001) and Duranton and Overman (2005)
A class of spatial econometric methods
83
provide an exhaustive account of the advantages of a third generation of measures that looks at maps of points on a continuous, rather than on a discrete, space: following this approach we can easily compare the results across different scales. In the present paper we look at the distribution of industries as a map of points in the space and we characterize their geographical distribution through the Lotwick– Silverman (Lotwick and Silverman 1982) extension of the spatial statistical nonparametric tool known as the K -function (Ripley 1977). The use of the K functions in economic analysis was first introduced in the literature by Arbia and Espa (1996) and then exploited by Marcon and Puech (2003a,b), by Quah and Simpson (2003) and by Duranton and Overman (2005) amongst the others. Ioannides and Overman (2004) look also at the properties of points on a continuous space, but using a different approach. Compared to previous contributions the major innovation of the present paper is to consider clustering for bivariate (rather than univariate) distributions, which allows uncovering agglomeration and repulsion phenomena between different sectors. The literature often refers to this subject as to co-agglomeration or co-localization (Devereux et al. 2004; Duranton and Overman 2005). The functionals we propose to characterize a joint pattern of points satisfies the five conditions suggested by Duranton and Overman (2005) for a concentration measure.1 In particular we introduce the use of the K function to control for the underlying industrial concentration. The theoretical ground on which such a modelling framework is based is well described in Quah and Simpson (2003) where the authors stressed the importance of being able to specify a model determining a spatial law of motion and its evolution through time. Quah–Simpson model assumes that each individual economic agent aims at maximizing his own profit by locating his activity where the average spatial return is higher with a gradual time-adjustment based on a cost function. Equilibrium is then achieved by optimizing the choices of each individual economic agent. The result is a (space–time) partial differential equation that expresses the economic activity in each point in time and space as a density. A good way of approaching the empirical analysis of clusters in space is then represented by a modelling framework that is able to describe how such densities change in space conditionally upon the observed pattern of points. A field were what Quah and Simpson (2003) define as a spatial law of motion is particularly theoretically grounded is the analysis of the spatial diffusion of innovation and of technological spillovers. For this reason the empirical part of this paper is devoted to the analysis of the joint location of innovations. The studies on knowledge spillovers have received increasing importance in the literature on economic growth. In fact some theories explicitly link the presence of innovations to the growth of cities (Jacobs 1969, 1984; Bairoch 1988) seen as the places where the big concentration of individuals, firms and workers create positive
1 The five requirements suggested by Duranton and Overman (2005) for a concentration measure are
the following: any measure (1) should be comparable across industries; (2) should control for the overall agglomeration of manufacturing; (3) should control for industrial concentration; (4) should be unbiased with respect to scale and aggregation; and, finally (5) should also give an indication of the significance of the results.
84
G. Arbia et al.
externalities which, in turn, foster economic growth. Even if economic theory has produced important advances in this direction (Arrow 1962; Romer 1986; Lucas 1988; Porter 1990) empirical evidence are still largely lacking. In fact a large part of the empirical literature concentrated on measuring the impact of technological spillovers on the innovation performance of regions. In many instances the number of patents and the relative citations have been used as proxies of the flow of knowledge and of the related innovative output (Jaffe and Trajtenberg 1996, 2002; Jaffe et al. 2000). One possible approach is based on the notion of knowledge production function introduced by Griliches (1979) which links regional innovative output with measures of regional innovative inputs like R&D expenses (see e.g., Jaffe 1989; Audretsch and Feldman 1996; Acs et al. 1994). These studies provide significant evidence of the impact of localized R&D inputs on the innovation performance of regions. There is comparatively less empirical evidence on the effects of localized knowledge spillovers (Glaeser 1992; Henderson and Kunkoro 1995; Henderson 2003) and no definite answer is yet available to the question whether knowledge flows are favoured by regional specialization within firms or, vice versa, by industrial diversification. In this paper we wish to show the importance of the distance-based measures of spatial concentration in tackling this important emerging research area and to provide new statistical tools to study the interaction between spatial concentration, regional growth and knowledge spillovers. The layout of the paper is the following. In Sects. 2 and 3 we will thoroughly review the statistical reference framework by presenting a set of tools to identify clusters of industries in the space. Specifically in Sect. 2 we will concentrate on the bivariate version of Ripley’s (1977) K function. In Sect. 3 we will discuss the system of hypotheses at the basis of the identification of clusters and by distinguishing two possible null hypotheses to be contrasted with the hypothesis of spatial clustering of industries. Section 4 is devoted to an empirical application of the bivariate K function in the study of the inter-sectoral location of innovation in Italy based on a dataset of the European Patent Office (EPO). Finally Sect. 5 contains some conclusions and directions for further developments in the field.
2 The statistical theoretical framework: bivariate K functions Univariate K -functions (proposed by Ripley 1976, 1977) have been already used in economic geography to characterize the geographical concentration of industries (see e.g., Arbia and Espa 1996; Marcon and Puech 2003a; Quah and Simpson 2003). In this paper we will consider a bivariate extension of such a method to describe spatial clusters of pairs of firms. Although the approach could be straightforwardly generalized to an arbitrary number of, say, g(g > 2) industries, in this paper we will deliberately restrict ourselves to the bivariate case for the sake of illustrating the methodology. The method is based on a bivariate functional of distance t (that we will refer to as K i j (t)) which characterizes the joint spatial pattern of points or, more precisely, the spatial relationships between two typologies of points located in the same study area: for instance firms belonging to two different industrial sectors, say Type i and Type j. The bivariate K function is defined as follows:
A class of spatial econometric methods
85
K i j (t) = λ−1 j E {# of points of Type i falling at a distance ≤ t from an arbitray Type j point}
(1)
with E{.} indicating the expectation operator and the parameter λ j representing the intensity of Type j point process, that is the number of Type j points per unitary area. Obviously, in the presence of a multivariate point process we have g typologies of events and, consequently, g 2 bivariate K functions that is: K 11 (t), K 12 (t), . . . , K 1g (t), K 21 (t), K 22 (t), . . . , K 2g (t), . . . , K gg (t). In the remainder we will distinguish between univariate and bivariate K functions by calling auto-functions the K functions when i = j and cross-functions those when i = j. Conversely, when i = j, K ii = K i represents the more traditional univariate auto-function K used in the economic analysis by e.g., Quah and Simpson (2003) and Marcon and Puech (2003a) and Duranton and Overman (2005) In Eq. 1, the term λ j K i j (t) represents the expected number of Type j points falling within a circle of radium t centred on an arbitrary Type i point. Symmetrically we interpret the bivariate function K ji (t) in such a way that λi K ji (t) represents the expected number of Type i points falling within a circle of radium t centred on an arbitrary Type j point. Similarly to the case of univariate K function, also the bivariate K function is built under the assumption of isotropy (Arbia 2006) that is the case when no directional bias occurs in the neighbourhood of each point. In a bivariate point map constituted by, say, n i points of Type i and n j points of Type j within an area A, we can define a class of estimators of the cross-functions K by close analogy to those suggested in the univariate case (Ripley 1977; Diggle 1983). To start with, let us consider the indicator function: Ilk (t) =
1 0
if if
dlk ≤ t dlk > t
where dlk represents the distance between the lth Type i point and the kth Type j point. If no border effects are present, then the non-parametric estimator of the cross-function K i j (t) can be expressed as: n1 n2 −1 Ilk (t) Kˆ i j (t) = λˆ i λˆ j A l=1 k=1
n where A is the total surface of the area, λˆ i = nAi and λˆ j = Aj . Analogously, by inverting the role between Type i and Type j points, the corresponding non-parametric estimator for the cross-function K ji (t) is given by: n2 n1 −1 −1 ˆ ˆ ˆ νlk K ji (t) = λi λ j A (t)Jlk (t) l=1 k=1
with νlk (t) and Jlk (t) analogous to the Ilk (t) functions in the previous expression.
86
G. Arbia et al.
If the generating random field is stationary and isotropic (Arbia 2006), then K i j (t) should be equal to K ji (t). However, due to possible border effects2 and to the asymmetry of the related corrections, Kˆ i j (t) and Kˆ ji (t) will be not exactly equal although strongly correlated. A more efficient (although not absolutely efficient) estimator is thus the one proposed by Lotwick and Silverman (1982) given by: K i∗j (t) =
λˆ j Kˆ i j (t) + λˆ i Kˆ ji (t) λˆ i + λˆ j
(2)
Likewise Ripley’s univariate K function, also in the case of the multivariate functions we can introduce the L transformation proposed by Besag (1977) that is characterized by a more stable variance. In the bivariate case the Lˆ i j (t) functions assume the following expressions: Lˆ i j (t) =
Kˆ i j (t)/π
Lˆ ji (t) =
Kˆ ji (t)/π
and
where the functions are linearized dividing by π and the square root stabilizes the variance. Similarly to Eq. 2 we can consider the Lotwick–Silverman transformation: L i∗j (t) =
λˆ j Lˆ i j (t) + λˆ i Lˆ ji (t) ∗ = K ji (t)/π λˆ i + λˆ j
which produces more efficient estimators of the L function. 3 The basic hypotheses of the model: spatial independence or random labelling? In this section we wish to introduce various alternatives offered in the spatial statistical literature to specify the null hypothesis of absence of regularities in the location of pairs of points in space. These will represents our counterfactuals in the subsequent empirical analysis reported in Sect. 4.2. In order to correctly interpret the estimates provided by K i∗j (t) and L i∗j (t) to test the null hypothesis of absence of spatial interaction, traditionally the empirical estimates are compared with simulated envelopes. The reference framework for such tests is provided by Barnard (1963) and adapted by Ripley (1979) to the case of univariate spatial clusters. In the case of bivariate patterns the specification of the null hypothesis is more complicated. In fact we can have two possible definitions depending on the nature of the case examined: a null of 2 On “border effects” and corrections for them see e.g., Ripley (1981). Explicit expressions of the correction
factors in the case of irregular study areas are derived in Goreaud and Pélissier (1999).
A class of spatial econometric methods
87
independence and a null of random labelling (Diggle 1983; Dixon 2002). The choice between the two alternatives can strongly affect the final results and can lead to wrong conclusions. However, this distinction is often ignored in the literature where the univariate procedures are sometimes uncritically applied (among the few exceptions see Diggle 1983 and, more recently Dixon 2002; Goreaud and Pélissier 2003). The two cases will now be discussed in some details. 3.1 The null hypothesis of independence According to a first specification of the null hypothesis the two typologies of points on the map can be conceived as two populations and the resulting spatial pattern can be interpreted a priori as the outcome of two distinct point random fields. In this situation the absence of interaction between the two components corresponds to the lack of interaction between the two generating fields. In other words, the location of points generated by the field related to Typology i is independent of the location of points generated by the field related to Typology j (Lotwick and Silverman 1982). Under this hypothesis, therefore, we have that K i j (t) = π t 2 . We will refer to this first null hypothesis as to the “hypothesis of independence” and we will indicate it with the symbol H01 . If within the circle of radius t centred on an arbitrary Type i point we record the presence of more Type j points than we expect under H01 , then K i j (t) > πt 2 which represents the surface of a circle of radius t. Such a result indicates a positive dependence between the two components and, hence, the presence of agglomeration between the two generating fields. In contrast, if within the circle of radius t centred on an arbitrary Type i point we record the presence of less Type j points than expected under H01 , then K i j (t) < πt 2 , thus indicating repulsion (or inhibition) rather than agglomeration. The confidence band to run formal hypothesis testing procedures at the various distances can be built through Monte Carlo simulation (Besag and Diggle 1977; See also Ripley 1977; Goreaud and Pélissier 2003 for details). 3.2 The null hypothesis of random labelling According to a second specification of the null hypothesis each of the two components depend on some factors that a posteriori produce a differentiation between the two typologies of points. In the case of economic data, such factors can be identified in a set of explanatory variables encouraging location of industries at a certain point in space and producing a different pattern in the two typologies of points. For instance they might refer to a differentiated system of taxes and incentives encouraging location of Type i point while discouraging location of Type j points. We will refer to this second hypothesis as to the “random labelling” and we will indicate it with the symbol H02 . The general reference framework in this second instance is that of the so-called marked point processes (see, e.g., Diggle 1983) that is point processes where not only the location of each object is reported, but also an extra characteristics that differentiates between them (e.g., small and large firms, presence or absence of an innovation etc.)
88
G. Arbia et al.
Let the spatial structure of the indistinct generating process for the two typologies of points be synthesized by the univariate K auto-function (Ripley 1977): λK (t) = E{# points within a circle of radious t around each point in a map} where λ = nA represents the density and n = n 1 + n 2 . n Under H02 , the ratio p j = nj represents the probability of belonging to Typology j. Then we have that p j λK (t) = λ j K (t) = λ j K i j (t) so that K i j (t) = K (t). If within the circle of radius t centred on an arbitrary Type i point there are more Type j points than expected under H02 , then K i j (t) > K (t). This result indicates that at distance t the two components tend to be positively dependent, thus revealing the presence of agglomeration. On the contrary, if within the circle of radius t centred on an arbitrary Type i point there less Type j points than expected under H02 , then K i j (t) < K (t) which indicates the presence of a negative dependence between the two components or inhibition. Again the confidence bands can be generated via Monte Carlo simulation. When H02 holds true, we have that all the bivariate K functions (both the two auto-functions and the two cross–functions) are equal to the univariate K function of the map where there is no distinction between the two components so that K i j (t) = K ji (t) = K ii (t) = K j j (t) = K (t). Operationally the departures from the null of random labelling could be evaluated by computing the pair-wise differences between the various K functionals and by comparing them with the simulated confidence bands (see Diggle and Chetwynd 1991; Gatrell et al. 1996; Kulldorff 1998; Dixon 2002; Haining 2003). It is important to observe that the two alternatives for the null hypothesis considered in this section describe in statistical terms the usual distinction made in quantitative geography between two otherwise undistinguishable effects: the effect of spatial interaction between agents and the effect of spatial reaction to common factors (Cliff and Ord 1981). Both effects give rise to observed regularities in space. They also mirror from a certain view angle the distinction made by some authors in the economic literature between joint-localization and co-localization (see e.g., Duranton and Overman 2005). 4 Characterizing the spatial distribution of innovations in Italy 1995–1999 4.1 Descriptive analysis The empirical analysis focuses on the use of the EPO dataset containing all patent applications made at European Patent Office (established by Monaco’s Convention) starting from 1978. In particular we use the version elaborated at CESPRI, Bocconi University, Milan. The dataset provides us with information about petitioners, inventors, request date, International Patent Classification code (distinguishing the various industrial sectors), and citations among patents. The use of the inventors’ residence allows us to localize exactly each patent (Arbia et al. 2008). In our database we omitted Sicily, Sardinia and the other Italian islands because of the lack of spatial continuity with the main land. This lack of continuity could produce serious biases in our
A class of spatial econometric methods
89
5000
number of paten
number of invento
6000
4000 3000 2000 1000 0 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 t
2000 1800 1600 1400 1200 1000 800 600 400 200 0 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 t
Fig. 1 a Inventors with at least 1 invention and b mono-inventors in the period 1990–1999. Source: European Patent Office data processed at CESPRI, Bocconi University, Milan and at the Department of Economics, University of Trento
procedures that are based on Euclidean distances. The resulting dataset consists of 44,078 inventors, but only 25,312 patents due to the presence of multi-inventors patents. To avoid any subjectivity in the assignment of a unique location to each patent, we considered only patents with one single inventor that amount to 14,632 in our database. We left to future further refinements the problems related to the spatial assignment of patents with multiple inventors. The patents are classified within six industrial sectors, namely: Electricity Electronics (S1), Instruments (S2), Chemical Pharmaceutical (S3), Process Engineering (S4), Mechanical Engineering Machinery (S5) and Consumer Goods Civil Engineering (S6). In our database we also avail temporal information related to two different moments of time of the registration of each patent, namely: (i) the publication date and (ii) the priority date, that is the date of the earliest filling of an application made in one of the patent offices adhering to the convention. The choice of one date or the other is crucial because the time lag between the priority date and the publication date may range from 1.5 to 2.5 years. We chose the latter because it is the date that gets closer to the actual timing of the patented invention. In the modelling phase, we restrict our attention to the most recent years and so we employed only data based on the aggregation of the last 5 years (from January 1995 to December 1999). The dynamic is totally absent in the present analysis and it is our intention to extend the analysis in a future study to a space–time context by exploiting the statistical literature on “space–time” K -functions introduced by Diggle (1993) and Diggle et al. (1995). Figure 1 reports the yearly time series of the 44,078 inventors submitting for patents at EPO (Fig.1a) and those that are mono-inventors in which case the spatial location of inventors and patents are the same (Fig.1b). The selected period 1995–1999 coincides with an evident period of increase in the volume of inventors. With reference to the same dataset Table 1 reports the sectoral distribution of patents with just one inventor in the period 1995–1999. By distinguishing each patent in terms of its specific industrial sector we can interpret our data as a single realization of a multivariate spatial point process. The map reported in Fig. 2 displays the overall spatial distribution of the 8,279 cases. The map reveals a clear agglomeration pattern of the points within some innovative regions, namely Milan’s area in the centre–north and the north-eastern part of the country. Indeed, the whole northern regions are very innovative and contain more than
90 Table 1 Frequency distribution of the number patents with only one inventor distinguished by industrial sector in the periods 1995–1999
G. Arbia et al. Sectors Electricity electronics = S1
951
Instruments = S2
831
Chemical pharmaceutical = S3 Source: European Patent Office data processed at CESPRI, Bocconi University, Milan and at the Department of Economics, University of Trento
Number of patents (1995–1999)
675
Process engineering = S4
1,302
Mechanical engineering machinery = S5
2,830
Consumer goods civil engineering = S6
1,690
Total
8,279
Fig. 2 Location of 8,279 patents in Italy in 1995–1999. Source: European Patent Office data processed at CESPRI, Bocconi University, Milan and at Department of Economics, University of Trento
66% of the total number of patents. Conversely the central part of Italy contains only about the 30%, of the patents with a remarkable concentration around Rome and Florence, and only 4% of the patents are located in the southern regions. These empirical findings are not surprising considering the well-known industrial gap existing between Italian regions and, specifically the dualism between the north and the south of the country. Also, the recent literature on knowledge spill-overs and specifically the research that concentrated on patent citation (Jaffe et al. 1993; Breschi and Lissoni 2001, 2006; Driffield 2006) provides persuasive explanation for the observed geographical pattern. The same kind of information is contained in the graphs reported in Fig. 3 displaying the frequency distribution of inventors (Fig. 3a) and the ratio of the number of investors to the number of individuals aged 15–65 in 1999 (Fig. 3b). In particular Fig. 3b shows that the higher concentration observed in the north cannot be due to population concentration and reveals a genuine prevalence of inventors in that area. It is helpful to disaggregate the previous map into as many point processes as the number of industrial sectors, each one characterised by a different intensity. To help visualizing this aspect Fig. 4 reports the point map for each sector. The same feature
A class of spatial econometric methods
91
Fig. 3 Regional distribution of patents in Italy in the period 1995–1999. a Number of patents, b patents per 1,000 inhabitants. Source: Istat and European Patent Office data elaborated at CESPRI, Bocconi University, Milan and at Department of Economics, University of Trento
Fig. 4 Location of 8,279 patents in Italy in 1995–1999 distinguished by sector. Source: European Patent Office data elaborated at CESPRI, Bocconi University, Milan and at Department of Economics, University of Trento. a Electricity Electronic, b Instruments, c Chemical Pharmaceutical, d Process Engineering, e Mechanical Engineering Machinery, f Consumer goods Civil Engineering
of higher concentration in the north appears evident for all six sectors considered. Indeed, the observed geographical patterns are very similar for the six sectors with evident concentrations around the main industrial northern towns (Milan and Turin). Some minor, but still evident, concentrations can be observed around Bologna and Venice for patents of the Process Engineering, Mechanical Engineering Machinery and Consumer goods Civil Engineering sectors and on the east coast between Rimini
92
G. Arbia et al.
Fig. 5 Kernel estimation of the spatial density of the two point process .The bandwidth parameter is set to τ = 50 km. a Electricity Electronics, b Instruments
and Ancona for the patents of the sector Consumer goods Civil Engineering (see Fig. 4f). 4.2 Modelling the joint location of patents In this section we will first of all illustrate with a certain detail the method used for estimating the bivariate K functions. For the purpose of illustrating the estimation method we will concentrate on the spatial interaction between patents of the Electricity Electronics sector and those of the Instruments sector. For all other pairs of sectors we will only report the results of the estimation procedures. In order to perform an exploratory analysis of the spatial patterns of points, we initially converted the maps displayed in Fig. 4 into spatial densities by using a non-parametric kernel estimator. Figure 5 shows, for the two sectors of Electricity Electronics and Instruments, the kernel density estimation of the random process, say λ(s), s representing the vector of coordinates of the points, s ∈ ℜ2 . For the estimation we considered the following quadratic kernel (see Hastie and Tibshirani 1990; Fan and Gijbels 1996) λˆ τ (s) =
d j <τ
2 d 2j 3 1− 2 πτ2 τ
(3)
where τ represents the bandwidth (that is the parameter controlling the smoothness of the surface), dl is the distance between point s and the event located at point sl and the summation refers to all distances d j < τ . Interesting insights in terms of exploring the relationships between the two sectors are obtained by superimposing the two maps of points reported in Fig. 4a, b. In order to do this we exploited the following kernel estimator: λˆ τ ;i/1+2 (s) =
λˆ τ ;i (s) λˆ τ ;1+2 (s)
, i = 1, 2
where both λˆ τ ;i (s) and λˆ τ ;1+2 (s) were computed using expression (3). We will refer to this kernel estimation as to a dual kernel.
A class of spatial econometric methods
93
Fig. 6 Dual kernel estimation of the spatial density. The bandwidth parameter is τ = 35 km. a Electricity Electronics, b Instruments
Figure 6a, b display the output of the estimation procedure obtained for the joint distribution of the Electricity Electronics and Instruments sectors. In particular in Fig. 6a we display with a different shading the dual measures ranging from 0 (when there are only patents of sector Instruments) to the value of 1 (in the cases where there are only patents of the Electricity Electronics sector). A darker shading in Fig. 6a reveals the prevalence of patents of the Electricity Electronics sector whereas Fig. 6b displays the complementary information for the Instruments sector. In both graphs intermediate values in the scale allows us to identify areas where both sectors are present. Similar graphs were derived for all other pairs of sectors, but they are not reported here since they do not add particular insights. Concerning the identification of the bivariate map it seems more grounded the hypothesis of random labelling with respect to that of independence (see Sect. 3) in that the labelling of the patents to a certain sector occurs in a subsequent moment with respect to the moment of the deposit at the EPO. In the remainder of this section we will report the estimation results of the different bivariate versions of the K function that can be used to study the joint location of all pairs of sectors. To start with, Fig. 7 reports the behaviour of the L ∗ function for the two sectors Electricity and Electronics and Instruments. Similar graphs have been derived for all other pairs of sectors, but they are not reported here in that they display very similar behaviours.3 The effect of co-agglomeration is evident for all pairs of sectors at all distances in that all graphs lay entirely above the diagonal that represents the case of random labelling. Thus points are more clustered than expected under the null hypothesis of random labelling. In order to investigate more closely this effect of co-agglomeration significant insight can be gained by inspecting the behaviour of the K cross-functions. In fact, as already said, under the null hypothesis of random labelling we have that 3 All graphs are available upon request from the authors or can be accessed directly on the website. http://
www.springerlink.com/content/102505/.
96
G. Arbia et al.
Let us start commenting on Fig. 8a that refers to the joint pattern of location of the Electricity Electronics and Instruments sectors. The graphs of the functional Kˆ 11 (t) − ∗ (t) in Fig. 8a is always above the K = 0 horizontal line and is above the bands at 95% K 12 confidence level thus indicating significant attraction at all distances. In contrast the ∗ (t) suggests random labelling at small distances graph of the functional Kˆ 22 (t) − K 12 (t < 30 km) with the line falling entirely within the 95% confidence bands. Conversely, at higher distances, the graph falls in the lower part of the confidence bands suggesting repulsion between the two sectors. As a consequence the location of points referring to the two industrial sectors cannot be considered as randomly labelled, rather they display an interesting pattern of attraction–repulsion. The patents of the Electricity Electronics sector tend to locate close to patents of the same sector, whereas patents of the Instruments sector display (at small distances below 30 km) a tendency to locate in the neighbourhood of patents of Electricity Electronics. Such a gravitational effect is dominated by an internal segregation effect (above the mentioned threshold of 30 km) that prevents the patents of the Instruments sector to constitute patches. In summary: points of Electricity Electronics tend to cluster on one another while point of Instruments display a repulsion on one another and an attraction towards those of Electricity Electronic. The first effect thus confirms Marshall–Arrow–Romer theoretical expectations (Marshall 1890; Arrow 1962; Romer 1986) and Porter’s idea of dynamical externalities generated by specialization (Porter 1990). The second effect follows from the dynamic externalities à–la–Jacobs arising from industrial diversification (Jacobs 1969). By commenting jointly Figs. 7 and 8 we observe that the reciprocal aggregation effect between the Electricity Electronics sector and the Instruments sector suggested by the behaviour of the function L ∗12 (t) in Fig. 7, is not the same in both directions and it appears to be led by the Electricity Electronic sector. From an economic point of view such a results can be easily interpreted by observing that the Instruments sector includes goods whose production requires technologies linked to the Electricity Electronics sector. Thus the knowledge flows generated by firms of the Electricity Electronic sector produce a benefit to the neighbouring industries of the sector of Instruments. In contrast the Electricity Electronics sector includes goods whose production does not require technologies linked to the Instruments sector that most likely benefits from internally generated knowledge flows. In our work we derived the graphs of the functionals Kˆ ii (t) − K i∗j (t) and Kˆ j j (t) − ∗ K ji (t) for all 15 possible pairs of the 6 sectors considered. However here we report only some selected cases due to lack of space.5 By examining all possible pairs of sectors we can identify four different typologies of attraction–repulsion. The most common typology observed is the one that we have described into details when commenting on the relationships between the Electronic Engineering and the Instruments sectors. In fact this pattern is very similar to that displayed by the Electricity and Electronics sector on one side and the sectors Instruments, Chemical Pharmaceutical, Process Engineering and Mechanical Engineering Machinery on the 5 Again, as for the case reported in Fig. 7, the graphs related to all pairs of sectors are available on the
website http://www.springerlink.com/content/102505/.
A class of spatial econometric methods
97
other. A similar pattern is also displayed by the pair constituted by Instruments versus Chemical Pharmaceutical and, with some minor differences, by the pairs involving the Chemical Pharmaceutical sector on one side and Instruments, Process Engineering, Mechanical Engineering Machinery and Consumer goods Civil Engineering sectors on the other side. In this first dominating typology we observe clusters of points of one sector at small distances (between 30 and 50 km) co-existing with points of the second sector that are internally over-dispersed. At high distances points of the second sector become randomly labelled. Only in the case of the relationships between the sector of Chemical Pharmaceutical and Mechanical and Civil Engineering, we observe a tendency to cluster after 100 km. It is, however, important to remember that at these higher distances the number of points on which the estimation is based decreases dramatically and thus the estimates are less reliable due to the lack of degrees of freedom. This first typology well describes the stylized facts suggested by Duranton and Overman (2005). A second typology of attraction–repulsion is displayed by the pairs of sectors involving the relationships between the Instruments sector on one side and the sectors of Process Engineering, Mechanical Engineering Machinery and Consumer Goods and Civil Engineering on the other. As an example of this second typology, Fig. 8b displays the case of Instruments versus Process Engineering. Here the pattern displays clusters on one sector at small distances (less than 20 km) attracting a second sector that is also self-clustered. At higher distances we conversely observe segregation. A third typology is displayed by the pairs of points referring to the relationships between the Process Engineering sector on one side and the Mechanical Engineering Machinery and Consumer goods Civil Engineering sectors on the other. Figure 8c displays the case of Process Engineering versus Mechanical Engineering Machinery as an example of such typology. Here we notice a tendency to cluster for the points of one sector that also produces a strong attraction on the points of the other sector. At high distances (more than 150 km) we conversely observe repulsion in the pattern of the first sector. The effect of concentration of points of the first sector is persistent at all distances in the case of the patents of the Mechanical engineering Machinery sector versus those of the Consumer goods Civil Engineering sector. Finally we have a residual typology where we can classify the exceptions to the three typologies described above. These exceptions are represented by the patterns displayed by Electricity Electronics versus Chemical Pharmaceutical and by Process Engineering versus Consumer goods Civil Engineering. In the first instance we observe clusters of one sector at small distances co-existing with a second sector that appears to be randomly labelled. In the second instance we have clusters of both sectors only at intermediate distances ranging between 120 and 160 km. 4.3 Controlling for the underlying industrial concentration The functionals considered in the previous section can help in identifying bivariate clusters of firms, but they consider the space as homogeneous with all portions of space having a priori the same probability of hosting a point. Conversely the economic space is highly heterogeneous. On these basis Ellison and Glaeser (1997) suggest that, when
98
G. Arbia et al.
looking at the location patterns of firms, the null hypothesis should be that of spatial randomness, but only conditional upon both industrial concentration and overall agglomeration. Their index satisfies this requirement. Similarly Maurel and Sedillot (1999) and Devereux et al. (2004) develop indices with similar properties. Duranton and Overman (2005) notice that “unevenness does not necessarily mean an industry is localized” and translate these consideration into the formal requirement that “any informative measure of localization must control for industrial concentration” (p. 1078; see also Sect. 1 and Footnote 5). They go further in suggesting that not all points in the space can host a new point and requiring that “the set of all existing sites currently used by a manufacturing establishment constitutes the set of all possible locations for any point” (p. 1085). In this last section we wish to introduce the use of the bivariate K functions to fulfil Ellison–Glaeser requirement and we compare for each sector the actual pattern with the pattern generated by all patents considered as a whole. More in details we compute the differences between the bivariate K function for each sector on one side and the univariate K function computed considering all sectors together. Such a difference can help in identifying sectors that are overconcentrated (over-dispersed) not in absolute terms as in the traditional univariate K analysis (Marcon and Puech 2003a), but conditionally upon the spatial pattern displayed by the other firms for the economy as a whole. Of course we are aware that, for this analysis to be complete, we should consider the spatial pattern of all firms in the economy, but in the empirical analysis reported here we restrict ourselves to only the pattern of patents included in the EPO database to have at least some indications. Figures 9a–f report the results of this analysis based on the functional Kˆ ii − Kˆ tt , Kˆ tt representing the K function referred to the all patents considered as a whole. We have also computed the functionals Kˆ tt − Kˆ it , but they are not reported here because they provide very similar information.6 The exam of Fig. 9 reveals some interesting features. First of all, the patents of the Electricity Electronics and Chemical Pharmaceutical sectors display at all distances over-concentration with respect to the underlying global concentration of patents (see Fig. 9a, c). In particular Electricity Electronics presents high and increasing concentration up to 80 km whereas Chemical Pharmaceutical presents the maximum concentration at around 60 km and then a decreasing pattern and even randomness after 160 km. Such results parallel those of Duranton and Overman (2005) that found localization mostly at small scales (less than 60 km) and a general tendency for Chemical Pharmaceutical products to over-clustering. Secondly, the Instruments sector displays over-dispersion with respect to the underlying distribution of patents at distances greater than 50 km. Thirdly, the patents of the Process Engineering sector display a more complex pattern with significant over-clustering only in the interval between 70 and 140 km. Finally the Mechanical Engineering Machinery and the Consumer goods Civil Engineering sectors display random labelling at all distances (remember that estimates at high distances are less reliable due to the lack of degrees of freedom). Therefore in these two sectors there
6 These graphs, likewise those related to Figs. 7 and 8, are available at the website. http://www.springerlink.
com/content/102505/.
100
G. Arbia et al.
seems to be no specific tendency to either clustering of repulsion apart from those that are characteristic of the economy as a whole. 5 Summary and concluding remarks In this paper we extended the use of Ripley’s (1977) K functions previously considered in the economic literature by Arbia and Espa (1996), Quah and Simpson (2003), Marcon and Puech (2003a) and Duranton and Overman (2005) to the analysis of the joint spatial pattern of industries. By applying a methodology based on the bivariate cross-functions K to the spatial distribution of patents in Italy in the period 1995–1999, we have been able to discern quite distinct geographical patterns for the six sectors considered. Our main findings are the following: • The pattern displayed by the patents of all pairs of the six sectors considered is always of agglomeration when analysed in absolute terms looking at the standard bivariate K functions. • However, when looking more closely at the pair-wise relationships between the six sectors considered, a more differentiated situation emerges. In fact, most of the observed joint patterns (precisely 8 of the 15 pairs of sectors considered) display a situation of dominance of one sector on the other. This dominance assumes that there is a leading sector that is clustered in space at small distances (up to 50 km) and a second sector that is dispersed internally and clustered around the leader. In particular this is the pattern displayed by the patents of the Electricity Electronics and the Chemical Pharmaceutical sectors that act as leaders with respect to the other sectors. • Such a specificity of the Electricity Electronics and the Chemical Pharmaceutical sectors emerges also when considering the analysis of agglomeration conditional on the global concentration of patents in the economy as a whole. In fact, in this case, the mentioned sectors are the only two that present over-clustering with respect to the general pattern of all patents. In particular we notice a climax at around 80 km for the patents of the Electricity Electronics sector and at around 60 km for the patents of the Chemical Pharmaceutical sectors. Conversely for the patents belonging to the other sectors we record over-dispersion for the Instruments sectors and no significant departure from randomness in the remaining sectors. The analysis considered here has shown the importance, but also the limits of a static approach and the necessity to introduce temporal dynamics in order to reconstruct the whole process of individual choices behaviour. Thus an important step forward in the application of the spatial econometric techniques discussed here is represented by the introduction of the time dimension. In fact the analysis of the static bivariate K functions registers only the situation in one definite period of time and provides only a single snapshot of the whole dynamic process. Quite obviously, this snapshot can be of help in suggesting the generating mechanism of individual locational choices as it is realized in a dynamic context like a single photogram reveals something about the nature of the movie it is drawn from. For instance, the individual choice behaviour
A class of spatial econometric methods
101
of firms suggested by Fig. 8a could be interpreted as the process through which in a first moment industries of one sector (say Type 1) locate themselves in the space at random and industries of another sector (say Type 2) tend to locate around them to exploit technological and physical spillovers. If new Type 1 industries locate in the area, they tend to locate away from Type 2 industries creating a buffering zone that can be due to physical or economic constraints. This behaviour seems to suggest a leading position of Type 1 industries with respect to Type 2. This dynamic, however, describes only one of the possible behaviours, and more refined spatial laws of motion could be suggested by the analysis of proper dynamic K functions. The theoretical basis for considering dynamic spatial patterns in economic analysis are well depicted by Quah and Simpson (2003). Dynamic “space–time” K -functions (Diggle 1993; Diggle et al. 1995) can be conceived as functionals depending on both spatial distances and the time lag which indicate how many points characterized by a certain label fall within a certain distance of other points after a certain period of time. Such an analysis would greatly help the study of the concentration of industries and the analysis of diffusion processes which, in turn, are issues of tremendous importance when analysing sectoral growth and the rise and fall of regions within one country. Since understanding the dynamics of the spatial distribution of firms can also help to clarify the complex mechanisms of international trade, the development of this field appears to be as one of the most challenging in the future research agenda.
References Acs ZJ, Audretsch DB, Feldman MP (1994) R&D spillovers and recipient firm size. Rev Econ Stat 76(2):336–340 Arbia G (1989) Spatial data configuration in regional economic and related problems. Kluwer, Dordrecht Arbia G (2001) Modelling the geography of economic activities in a continuous space. Pap Reg Sci 80: 411–424 Arbia G (2006) Spatial econometrics: with applications to regional convergence. Springer, Berlin Arbia G, Espa G (1996) Statistica economica territoriale. Cedam, Padua Arbia G, Copetti M, Diggle PJ (2008) Modelling individual behaviour of firms in the study of spatial concentration. In: Fratesi U, Senn L (eds) Growth in interconnected territories: innovation dynamics, local factors and agents, Springer, Berlin (forthcoming) Arrow KJ (1962) The economic implications of learning by doing. Rev Econ Stud 155–173 Audretsch DB, Feldman MP (1996) R&D Spillovers and the geography of innovation and production. Am Econ Rev 86(3):630–640 Bairoch P (1988) Cities and economic development: from the dawn of history to the present. Chicago Press, Chicago Barnard GA (1963) Contribution to the discussion of Professor Bartlett’s paper. J R Stat Soc B25:294 Besag J (1977) Contribution to the discussion of Dr. Ripley’s paper. J R Stat Soc B 39:193–195 Besag J, Diggle PJ (1977) Simple Monte Carlo test for spatial pattern. Appl Stat 26:327–333 Breschi S, Lissoni F (2001) Knowledge spillovers and local innovation systems: a critical survey. Ind Corp Change 10(4):975–1005 Breschi S, Lissoni F (2006) Cross-firm inventors and social networks: localised knowledge spillovers revisited. Ann Econ Stat Ciccone A, Hall RR (1996) Productivity and the density of economic activity. Am Econ Rev 86(1):54–70 Cliff AD, Ord JK (1981) Spatial processes: models and applications. Pion, London Devereux MP, Griffith R, Simpson H (2004) The geographic distribution of production activity in the UK. Reg Sci Urban Econ 34:533–564 Diggle PJ (1983) Statistical analysis of spatial point patterns. Academic, New York
102
G. Arbia et al.
Diggle PJ (1993) Point process modelling in environmental epidemiology. In: Barnett V, Turkman KF (eds) Statistics for the environment. Wiley, Chichester Diggle PJ, Chetwynd AG (1991) Second-order analysis of spatial clustering. Biometrics 47:1155–1163 Diggle PJ, Chetwynd AG, Haggkvist R, Morris S (1995) Second-order analysis of space−time clustering. Stat Methods Med Res 4:124–136 Dixon PM (2002) Ripley’s K function. In: El-Shaarawi AH, Piegorsch WW (eds) Encyclopedia of environmetrics, vol 3. Wiley, Chichester, pp 1796–1803 Driffield N (2006) On the search for spillovers from Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) with spatial dependency. Regional Studies 40, pp 107–119 Duranton G, Overman HG (2005) Testing for localisation using micro-geographic data. Rev Econ Stud 72:1077–1106 Ellison G, Glaeser EL (1997) Geographic concentration in U.S. manufacturing industries: A dartboard approach. J Pol Econ 105(5):889–927 Fan J, Gijbels I (1996) Local polynomial modelling and its applications. Chapman and Hall, London Fujita M, Krugman P, Venables A (1999) The spatial economy: cities, regions, and international trade. MIT Press, Cambridge Gatrell AC, Bailey TC, Diggle PJ, Rowlingson BS (1996) Spatial point pattern analysis and its application in geographical epidemiology. Trans Inst Br Geogr 21:256–274 Glaeser EL, Kallal HD, Scheinkman JA, Schleifer A (1992) Growth in cities. J Pol Econ 100(6):1126–1152 Goreaud F, Pélissier R (1999) On explicit formulas of edge effect correction for Ripley’s K-function. J Veg Sci 10:433–438 Goreaud F, Pélissier R (2003) Avoiding misinterpretation of biotic interactions with intertype K 12 (t)− function: population independence vs. random labelling hypotheses. J Veg Sci 14:681–692 Griliches Z (1979) Issues in assessing the contribution of research and development to productivity growth. Bell J Econ 10:92–116 Haining RP (2003) Spatial data analysis: theory and practice. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge Hastie T, Tibshirani R (1990) Generalized additive models. Chapman and Hall, London Henderson JV (2003) Marshall’s scale economies. J Urban Econ 53(1):1–28 January Henderson VA, Kunkoro M (1995) Turner. Industrial development of cities. J Pol Econ 103:1067–1090 Ioannides YM, Overman HG (2004) Spatial evolution of the US urban system. J Econ Stud 4:131–156 Jacobs J (1969) The economy of cities. Random House, New York Jacobs J (1984) Cities and the wealth of nations: principles of economic life. Vintage, New York Jaffe AB (1989) Real effects of academic research. Am Econ Rev 79(5):957–970 Jaffe AB, Trajtenberg M (1996) Flows of knowledge from universities and federal laboratories: modeling the flow of patent citations over time and across institutional and geographic boundaries. In: Proceedings of national academy of science vol 93, pp 12671–12677 Jaffe AB, Trajtenberg M (2002) Patents, Citations and innovations: a window on the knowledge economy. MIT Press, Cambridge Jaffe AB, Trajtenberg M, Henderson R (1993) Geographic localization of knowledge spillovers as evidenced in patent citations. Q J Econ 108(3):577–598 Jaffe AB, Trajtenberg M, Fogarty M (2000) The meaning of patent citations: report of the NBER/Case western reserve survey of patentees. NBER working paper No. 7631 Krugman P (1991) Geography and trade. MIT Press, Cambridge Kulldorff M (1998) Statistical methods for spatial epidemiology: test for randomness. In: Gatrell A, Löytönen M (eds) GIS and health. Taylor & Francis, London, pp 49–62 Lotwick HW, Silverman BW (1982) Methods for analysing spatial processes of several types of points. J R Stat Soc B44:406–413 Lucas RE (1988) On the mechanics of economic development. J Monet Econ 22(1):3–42 Marcon E, Puech F (2003a) Evaluating geographic concentration of industries using distance-based methods. J Econ Geogr 3(4):409–428 Marcon E, Puech F (2003b) Generalizing Ripley’s K function to inhomeogeneous populations. mimeo Marshall A (1890) Principles of economics. Macmillan, London Martens SN, Breshears DD, Meyer CW, Barnes FJ (1997) Scales of above-ground competition in semi arid woodland detected from spatial patterns. J Veg Sci 8:655–664 Maurel F, Sedillot B (1999) A measure for geographical concentration of French Manufacturing industries. Reg Sci Urban Econ 29(5):575–604 Porter ME (1990) The competitive advantage of nations. Free Press, New York
A class of spatial econometric methods
103
Quah D, Simpson H (2003) Spatial cluster empirics. mimeo Rauch JE (1993) Productivity gains from geographic concentration of human capital: evidence from the cities. J Urban Econ 43(3):380–400 Ripley BD (1976) The second-order analysis of stationary point processes. J Appl Probab 13:255–266 Ripley BD (1977) Modelling Spatial Patterns (with discussion). J R Stat Soc B39:172–212 Ripley BD (1979) Test of ‘randomness’ for spatial point pattern. J R Stat Soc B41:368–374 Ripley BD (1981) Spatial Statistics, Wiley Romer PM (1986) Increasing returns and long–run growth. J Pol Econ 94:1002–1037 Yule GU, Kendall MG (1950) An introduction to the theory of statistics. Griffin, London
A spatially filtered mixture of β-convergence regressions for EU regions, 1980–2002 Michele Battisti · Gianfranco Di Vaio
Abstract Assessing regional growth and convergence across Europe is a matter of primary relevance. Empirical models that do not account for structural heterogeneities and spatial effects may face serious misspecification problems. In this work, a mixture regression approach is applied to the β-convergence model, in order to produce an endogenous sele