Lecture Notes in
Physics
Monographs Editorial Board R. Beig, Wien, Austria J. Ehlers, Potsdam, Germany U. Frisch, Nic...
116 downloads
1920 Views
8MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Lecture Notes in
Physics
Monographs Editorial Board R. Beig, Wien, Austria J. Ehlers, Potsdam, Germany U. Frisch, Nice, France K. Hepp, Zflrich, Switzerland
W. D.
Hillebrandt, Garching, Germany Imboden, Zilrich, Switzerland
Jaffe, Cambridge, MA, USA Kippenhahn, G8ttingen, Germany R. Lipowsky, Golm, Germany H. v. L8hneysen, Karlsruhe, Germany 1. Ojima, Kyoto, Japan H. A. Weidenmiiller, Heidelberg, Germany J. Wess, Mfinchen, Germany J. Zittartz, K61n, Germany
R. L. R.
Managing Editor
Beiglb8ck Springer-Verlag, Physics Editorial Department II Tiergartenstrasse 17, 69121 Heidelberg, Germany
W.
c/o
Springer Berlin
Heidelberg New York
Barcelona
Hong Kong London
Milan Paris
Tokyo
Physics and Astronomy
J NLINE
LIBRARY
http://wwwspringerde/phys/
The Editorial
Policy for Monographs
The series Lecture Notes in Physics reports new developments in physical research and teaching quickly, informally, and at a high level. The type of material considered for publication in the monograph Series includes monographs presenting original research -
angles
in
classical field. The timeliness of
a manuscript is more important than Manuscripts should be reasonably selfcontained. They will often present not only results of the author(s) but also related work by other people and will provide sufficient diotivation, examples, and applications. The manuscripts or a detailed description thereof should be submitted either to one of the series editors or to the managing editor. The proposal is then carefully refereed. A final decision concerning publication can often only be made on the basis of the complete manuscript, but otherwise the editors will try to make a preliminary decision as definite or new
its
as
a
form, which may be preliminary
they can on the basis of the
or
tentative.
available information.
Manuscripts should be no less than loo and preferably no more than 400 pages in length. Final manuscripts should be in English. They should include a table of contents and an informative introduction accessible also to readers not particularly familiar with the topic treated. Authors are free to use the material in other publications. However, if extensive use is made elsewhere, the publisher should be informed. Authors receive jointly 30 complimentary copies of their book. They are entitled to purchase further copies of their book at a reduced rate. No reprints of individual contributions can be supplied. No royalty is paid on Lecture Notes in Physics volumes. Commitment to publish is made by letter of interest rather than by signing a formal contract. Springer-Verlag secures the copyright for each volume.
The Production Process The books
are hardbound, and quality paper appropriate to the needs of the author(s) is used. Publication time is about ten weeks. More than twenty years of experience guarantee
authors the best
possible service. To reach the goal of rapid publication at a low price the photographic reproduction from a camera-ready manuscript was chosen. This process shifts the main responsibility for the technical quality considerably from the publisher to the author. We therefore urge all authors to observe very carefully our guidelines for the preparation of camera-ready manuscripts, which we will supply on request. This applies especially to the quality of figures and halftones submitted for publication. Figures should be submitted as originals or glossy prints, as very often Xerox copies are not suitable for reproduction. For the same reason, any writing within figures should not be smaller than 2.5 mm. It might be useful to look at some of the volumes already published or, especially if some atypical text is planned, to write to the Physics Editorial Department of Springer-Verlag direct. This avoids mistakes and time-consuming correspondence during the production period. As a special service, we offer free of charge LATEX and TEX macro packages to format the text according to Springer-Verlag’s quality requirements. We strongly recommend authors to make use of this offer, as the result will be a book of considerably improved technical quality. For further information please contact Springer-Verlag, Physics Editorial Department II, Tiergartenstrasse 17, D-69121 Heidelberg, Germany. technique
Series
of
homepage
-
http://wwwspringerde/phys/books/Inpm
Marcus Kriele
Spacetime Foundations of General and Differential
0
# Springer
Relativity
Geometry
Author Marcus Kriele
Technische Universit t Berlin
Fachbereich Mathematik, Sekr. MA 8-3 Strasse des 17. Juni 136
lo623 Berlin, Germany
First Edition 1999
Corrected Second
Printing 2001
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data applied for. Die Deutsche Bibliothek
Kriele,
-
CIP-Einheitsaufnahme
Marcus:
Spacetime
foundations of general relativity and differential Marcus Kriele. Berlin ; Heidelberg ; New York; Barcelona Hong Kong; London ; Milan; Paris ; Singapore ; Springer, 1999 (Lecture notes in physics : N.s. M, Monographs; 59) ISBN 3-540-66377-0
geometry
-
ISSN 0940-7677
Tokyo
Notes in Physics. Monographs) Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg New York
(Lecture
ISBN 3-540-66377-0
copyright. All rights are reserved, whether the whole or part specifically the rights of translation, reprinting, reuse of illustrations, recitation, broadcasting, reproduction on microfilm or in any other way, and storage in data banks. Duplication of this publication or parts thereof is permitted only under the provisions of the German Copyright Law of September 9, 1965, in its current version, and permission for use must always be obtained from Springer-Verlag. Violations are liable for prosecution under the German Copyright Law. This work is
subject
to
of the material is concerned,
Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg New York a member of BertelsmannSpringer Science+Business Media GmbH http://www.springer.de Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg iggg Printed in
Germany
The use of general descriptive names, registered names, trademarks, does
not
imply,
even
from the relevant
in the absence of
protective laws
and
specific regulations a
Typesetting: Camera-ready by the author Cover design: design &production, Heidelberg Printed
on
acid-free paper
SPIN: 1o85o74o
55/3141/du
-
5 43
2 10
etc. in
this publication
statement, that such names are exempt and therefore free for general use.
Preface to the first edition
the two most fundamental concepts in our world because all else is unimaginable without assuming that space (or time) exists. It is therefore not surprising that the sophisticated Euclidean
Space and
time
model of space was
a common
are
already existed more than 2000 years. For centuries it belief by scientists and philosophers alike that the Eu-
clidean structure of space was one of the very few eternal truths. It was only at the beginning of the 20th century that this belief was shat-
special and general relativity. Today, Einstein’s theory of general relativity is completely established, and there are many textbooks which explain it at all levels of mathematical sophistication. What is missing, however, is a modern textbook on general relativity for mathematicians and mathematical physicists with emphasis on the physical justification of the
tered with the introduction of Albert Einstein’s theories of
mathematical framework. This book aims to fill this gap. Knowledge of physics is not assumed. While physical and heuristic
proofs. The book is also suitable as an introduction to pseudo-Riemannian geometry with emphasis on the intuition for geometrical concepts. arguments
The
are
given, they
physical
are
not used
as
substitutes for any
theme of the book
general relativity typically start with a more or less pseudo-Riemannian geometry. In such textbooks of some knowledge special relativity is usually assumed, and the reader to is expected accept the geometrical framework presented on trust. This is approach very economical but obscures the extent to which classical general relativity succeeds in describing our universe, and also where it those attemptmay fail. This is a point that is of particular relevance to of view it is Rom a to important to physical point quantise gravity. ing realise which parts of the theory reflect genuine physical insights, and which are dispensible. One way this can be achieved is through a criti-
Modern textbooks
on
formal introduction to
cal introduction that stresses foundational matters. There
textbooks
taking
this
approach, and
I
hope
are no
modern
to fill this gap with my -book.
V111
Preface to the first edition
One of the most
exciting aspects of general relativity is the predicBig Bang. Such predictions gained weight through the singularity theorems pioneered by Penrose. In various textbooks on general relativity singularity theorems are presented and then tion of black holes and the
used to argue that black holes exist and that the universe started with a big bang. To date what has been lacking is a critical analysis of what
really predict-’ We give a proof of a typical singularity theorem and use this theorem to illustrate problems arising through the possibilities of "causality violations" and very weak "shell crossing singularities". These problems add weight to the point of view that the singularity theorems alone are not sufficient to predict the existence of physical singularities. these theorems
The mathematical theme of the book In order to gain both a solid understanding of and good intuition for any mathematical theory, one,should try to realise it as a model of a familiar non-mathematical concept. Physical theories have had an especially important impact on the development of mathematics, and conversely various modern physical theories require rather sophisticated mathematics for their formulation. Today, both physics and mathematics are so complex that it is often very difficult to master the theories in both subjects. However, in the case of pseudo-Riemannian differential geometry or general relativity the relationship between physics and mathematics is especially close, and it is therefore possible to profit from an interdisciplinary approach. Euclidean geometry had its origins as the description of shapes in physical space. It is generally considered a mathematical discipline rather than a physical theory, because it is possible to derive it from a small set of physical postulates, which can alternatively be viewed as mathematical axioms. Since the concept of space is basic to our everyday experience, Euclidean geometry combines mathematical rigor with intuitiveness a combination which has proved to be extremely fruitful for both mathematics and physics. Riemannian geometry is abstracted from the study -
of surfaces in Euclidean space and inherits much of the intuitiveness of Euclidean geometry. Hence Riemannian geometry is very well developed,
and even
growing number of geometers have branched out to Lorentzian or pseudo-Riemannian geometry. In my experience, these fields (and
a
Since I had written this passage a review article (Senovilla 1998) which a very similar theme has been pointed out to me. This article pro-
has
vides many very illuminating examples of spacetimes as well as discussions which reinforce our sceptical approach towards the physical interpretation of singularity theorems.
Preface to the first edition
even
Riemannian
geometry)
appear
quite abstract
to the
Ix
majority of
students. A careful mental
analysis
of space,
time, and free fall
(classical) physical concepts
-
the most funda-
-
leads almost
automatically
to
Lorentzian geometry. With respect to Lorentzian geometry, we are therefore in a similar situation as ancient geometers were with respect to
Euclidean geometry. What’s more, virtually no physical background is required for this approach. Since Riemannian geometry comes to play in the
study of submanifolds representing an instant in time, it is completely straightforward to extrapolate pseudo-Riemannian geometry from the special and physically motivated cases of Lorentzian and Riemannian
geometry. While
some
modern textbooks present
pseudo-Riemannian geometry
(and general relativity) to mathematicians (an example of this is that by O’Neill (1983)), they have not motiv,ated the geometry from basic properties of
space and time. Instead
stract mathematical
theory.
To
they have developed
it
as
an
ab-
that the mathematical
description physical concepts, all definitions have a justification in this book. This approach also leads to a careful treatment of the structural aspects of the mathematics. ensure
mirrors the
How to read this book This book is not
designed
at page 1 and then to read
who take this
approach
so on
that it is necessary for the reader to start until she or he arrives at page 424. People
will very
likely give
14! The material is ordered in such used the
as a
reference
theory
that
a
shortcut.
ning of
a
a
urged As
It is
way
are
page
be
reader who is interested in space and time, and so to follow the guides in the margins, which provide
example, the text in the belonging to the shortcut:
margin denotes the
indicated
by --->2, where
corresponding footnote. The larly. Having understood the
begin-
denotes the page p. 222] the page
p. 111
number where the last shortcut passage ended and number where the present passage will end. Additional the footnotes
they reach
to allow the text to
unfortunate fact that many parts of to the preliminaries are not of imme-
an
passage
up before as
an
logically belong
diate interest to the reader is
source.
a
explanations
in
2 refers to the number of the
end of shortcut passages is marked simimaterial leading to Einstein’s equation it
is then not difficult to return to the parts that have been skipped on an earlier reading. In addition, hints are -given at the beginning of most
sections
’
as
to what is
important and should be read
Explanations referring
to the
guide
in the
margin.
.
P. 111 -2
[I
p.
1
222]
X
Preface to the first edition
This
with its 424 pages is meant to cover both general relativity differential geometry. It is therefore clear that
book,
pseudo-Riemannian
and
important topics had to be omitted. mathematicians, the most important omissions are certainly some topics peculiar to Riemannian geometry, such as the Hopf-Rinow theorem (O’Neill 1983, Theorem 5.21) and the Myers theorem (O’Neill 1983, Theorem 10.24). Because these results are contrary to intuition one should obtain for Lorentzian (or general pseudo-Riemannian) geometry and since they are not needed for the description of space and time, they have been omitted from this book. Physicists may find that the presentation of this book is only loosely linked to other physical theories. This loose linkage is possible since the theory of space and time is fundamental to any other physical theory. some
For
The book is therefore accessible to mathematicians and
physicists alike. applications to astrophysics may wish to consult the book by Weinberg (1972). Weinberg’s approach is opposite to the one used in this book, and personally I believe that it should ideally be read after the reader has a solid knowledge of the conceptional aspects of relativity as presented in this book. Most other books on general relativity also present the "Kerr solution", which is supposed to model the exterior of a rotating black hole. It has been omitted since it is not essential to unders,tanding general relativity. Moreover, it is well described in other books. People interested in this solution should probably first read Chap. 12 of the book by Wald (1984). The purely mathematical aspects of this solutions are clearly presented in O’Neill’s Physicists
book
who
are
interested in
(1995).
Acknowledgements The reader will
undoubtedly
notice that this book
owes
much to excellent
text books and survey articles. For the
I wish to mention
philosophical aspects of this book especially the classic book by Weyl (1923) and the
by Ehlers (1973). freely used material which appears elsewhere (O’Neill 1983; Wald 1984; Beem and Ehrlich 1981; Hawking and Ellis 1973; Sachs and Wu 1979; Karcher 1994; De Felice and Clarke 1990; Abraham and Marsden 1978; Garabedian 1986) without always acknowledging this
survey article
1 have also
fact. I
warmly thank
mended the book
Bernd
project
Wegner, who encouraged me and recomSpringer-Verlag. I wish especially to thank introducing me to relativity but also for read-
to
only for ing through the whole manuscript and for his
Volker Perlick not ments.
many
important improve-
Preface to the first edition
xi
This book is dedicated to two Australian way to
relativity students who on their gaining their doctorates courageously stood up against the immoral behaviour of their supervisor and the highhandedness of their university.
G6ttingen, 19th July
1999
M. Kriele
Table of Contents
1.
Local 1.1
theory Space 1.1.1
1.1.2
of space and time
.......................
I
..............................................
1
Affine space The fundamental theorem in affine geometry and doubly ruled surfaces
.................................
.....................
3
...........................
14
1.2
Euclidean geometry Absolute space and absolute time
1.3
Non-relativistic particles Galilei’s theory of relativity
1.4
Einstein’s
1.1.3
1.2.1
1.4.2 1.4.3 2.
Analysis 2.1
2.2
.....................
17
......................
20
..........................
1.4.1
special theory of relativity Causality in special relativity Length contraction and time dilatation Relativistic particles and photons
on
..................
39
..........
40
...............
43
................................
47
.........................................
48
2.1.1
Construction of manifolds
2.1.2
Partition of
unity
.....................
54
.............................
57
Vector bundles and the tangent bundle 2.2.1 Construction of the tangent bundle
................
61
.............
63
The derivative of maps between manifolds Tensors and tensor fields 2.2.2
2.3
Algebraic preliminaries:
2.3.2
Tensor fields
Vector fields and
2.5
Differential forms
2.7
.......
............................
2.3.1
2.4
2.6
22 27
..................
manifolds
Manifolds
2
tensors
................
69
..................................
84
ordinary differential equations
........
...................................
2.5.1
The lemma of Poincar6
........................
2.5.2
The theorem of Frobenius
2.5.3.
Orientable real manifolds
2.5.4
Integration
on
87 94 102
.....................
106
......................
109
real manifolds
..................
Connections and projective structures Examples of connections
112
.................
121
.............................
132
2.7.1
The Levi-Civita connection
2.7.2
The
Weyl
67 68
connection
....................
132
.........................
135
XIV
Table of Contents
2.8
Curvature
2.9
Applications to Weyl Variation of geodesics
.........................................
2.8.1
3.
4.
structures
142
...............................
143
Space and time from a global point 3.1 Light rays: the conformal structure
of view
...........
151
...................
151
3.2
Inertial observers: the
3.3
Compatibility: Weyl
3.4
Reduction to the Lorentzian structure
projective
structure
Pse udo-Riemannian manifolds
structure
.............
........................
........................
171
4.2
The volume form and the
.....
175
.........
176
............
184
Hodge operator Curvature of pseudo-Riemannian manifolds 4.3.1 2-dimensional pseudo-Riemannian manifolds Submanifolds
star
.....
......................................
4.4.1
Hyperquadrics Umbilic and totally geodesic submanifolds 4.4.3 Warped products Isometries and Killing vector fields Length and energy functionals 4.6.1 Variation of length and energy 4.6.2 Conjugate and focal points 4.6.3 Existence of focal points
...............................
4.4.2
.......
.............................
4.5 4.6
5.
General
Matter
5.2
Some
5.3
5.4
6.
6.2
.......................
.................
216
....................
227
241
.....................................
255
............................................
255
specific
matter models
perfect fluid
.........................
264
.............................
264
The collisionless gas The electromagnetic field
..........................
Einstein’s
equation
The
The Einstein
267
.................................
268
equation
as a
cosmology
Homogeneity and isotropy The initial value problem
equation 271
.......................
279
.........................
287
...........................
287
infinitesimally isotropic spacetimes
................
294
..............................
297
6.3
Geodesics and redshift
6.4
The age of the universe and the A simple model for the universe
6.5
of Einstein’s
system
partial differential equations
for
265
......................
Lagrangian formulation
Robertson-Walker 6.1
205 209
5.2.2
of
204
213
The
5.3.1
202
....................
5.2.1
5.2.3
191
193
.......................
relativity
5.1
160 166
Existence of Lorentzian and Riemannian manifolds
4.4
158
.................
4.1
4.3
137
................
big bang we
live in
..............
.............
300 304
Table of Contents
7.
Spherical symmetry
XV
..................................
7.1
Pseudo-Riemannian manifolds with
7.2
The Schwarzschild solution
spherical symmetry
308
..........................
315
Experimental tests for the Schwarzschild solution. Quasi-linear hyperbolic systems of equations in two independent variables The initial value problem for spherically symmetric perfect fluid spacetimes with non-interacting electromagnetic fields Static perfect fluid stars 7.2.1
7.3
7.4
7.5 8.
9.
.........................
328
.............
337 348
.............................................
357
................................
358
8.2
Cluster and limit
8.3
Achronal submanifolds and
curves
.............................
Cauchy developments
Singularity theorems 9.1 Energy conditions Closed trapped surfaces 9.2 The singularity theorem of Hawking and Penrose 9.3 9.3.1 Applications of the singularity theorem 9.3.2 General problems with Theorem 9.3.1 9.4 Singularities and causality violations
9.5
374 383
..................................
384
.............................
389
.......
390
..........
395
...........
397
..................
397
The G6del solution
...........................
Newman’s
...........................
405
397
.........
409
...............
412
................................................
425
.....................................................
429
References Index
.......
365
..................................
example Strength of singularities and cosmic censorship A simple, 3-dimensional example 9.5.1 9.4.2
322
.............................
Causality 8.1 Causality conditions
9.4.1
307
.
List of
Figures
1.1.3
Additivity of f Additivity of k Multiplicativity
1.1.4
A ruled surface
1.1.5
Proof of Theorem 1.1.2
1.1.6
Proof of Theorem 1.1.2
1.2.1
A
1.2.2 1.3.1
Absolute space, absolute time Parallaxis effect
1.3.2
Tower
1.3.3
1.4.1
Relative space, absolute time A flash of light at times to 0, tI
1.4.2
A
1.1.1
1.1.2
1.4.3 1.4.4
curve
in
8
........
.....................................
of k
10
.....................................
11
-
-
first
case
second
spacetime diagram
a
example
....................
13
.......................
18
........................
19
.....................................
23
......................................
23
t2
=
..................
consisting of linked oscillations Superposition of waves Future light cone and Galileian relativity. The observer moving with spatial velocity U measures a different centre OV of the flash of light and therefore different radii dj, d2 front
25 27
................
28
...............................
29
.....................................
29
wave
wave
12
.................
case
.........................
for its
9
.................................
30
1.4.7
Michelson-Morley experiment, at rest relative to the ether Michelson-Morley experiment, moving relative to the ether Length contraction ..................................
41
1.4.8
Time dilatation
.....................................
41
1.4.9
Twin
1.4.10
The
2.0.1
The torus T2
2.1.1
A
1.4.5 1.4.6
paradox twin paradox
......................................
in
cylindrical
43
.......................................
48
universe
locally homeomorphic
to R
.............................
R 2 which is not
submanifold of R 2
2.1.2
A manifold M
2.1.3
The construction of
2.1.4
The
2.8.1
The immersed surface in Theorem 2.8.1
3.4.1
C
a
and
finally
a
M6bius band
of Lemma 2.1.7
The world lines from
tially
42
.............
a
topological space which is but fails to be Hausdorff
proof
30
x
...
52
....................
53
............................
................
to y of two atoms which
at rest with
51
are
respect to each other
59 138
ini-
......
167
XVIII
4.6.1
List of
Figures
A broken curve
4.6.2
A
of
curve
lightlike geodesic can be smoothed out by a arbitrarily small length minimising the distance between two spacelike
submanifolds Z1 and Z2 4.6.3
Conjugate points
the
on
5.1.1
A localised congruence
5.1.2
Transformation of the
7.2.1
.......................
216
.............................
217
sphere
.......................
232
...............................
258
density
mass
in
special relativity
.
.
Schwarzschild spacetime in Schwarzschild coordinates Schwarzschild spacetime. Radial null geodesics are the
....
7.2.2
const and Y const. The region straight lines X Schwarzschild coordinates is shaded by =
=
ered 7.2.3
central star in Schwarzschild spacetime
a
....
8.1.1
A strip of two-dimensional Minkowski space where future and past boundaries are identified
8.1.2
Misner’s spacetime (S’ x R, 2dtdW + td W2) A gedanken experiment to disprove causality violation
.
8.1.3 8.1.4
8.1.5
317
cov-
............
The size of
263
...................
.............
319 324
359 360
361 A spacetime which is causal but fails to be strongly causal 364 A spacetime which is strongly causal. An infinitesimally
small
with
perturbation of the chronology violation
metric results in
...
spacetime
a
............................
365
............................
366
8.2.1
The
8.2.2
A limit
8.2.3
An example where a limit curve from x to y is not a cluster curve for a sequence of points from x to y 367 A spacetime which is causal but fails to be strongly causal 368
proof of Lemma curve
-y of
a
8.2.1
sequence of
curves
7
..............
367
.......
8.2.4 8.2.5
Assume that
b1c
is rational and
a/b
is irrational. Then
the
projection of the line with slope c/a from torus depicted in the figure is a dense curve is
cluster
8.3.1
of -y The definition of null boundary and achronal
8.3.2
The
Cauchy
9.5.1
The
singularity
every
curve
a
curve
horizon for
a
R 2 to the -y. Hence
.....................
boundary
structure of
singularity singularity
at the
given by Vo + tq
A the
direction and that at B
375
spacetime. The case kI, k2 < suppressed. The sin-
(Wo/i9y)-l (o9q/Oy)
B is
368
set which fails to be achronal.. 381
0. The y-component of spacetime is gularity A is given by I + t
the
..
=
=
0 and
0. Observe that
light cone degenerates in the ydegenerates in the x-direction.
Hence there exist future directed timelike
ing from the singularity and
cosmic
curves
censorship
emanat-
is violated 416
List of
postulates
relativity
1.3.1
Galileian
1.4.1
Invariance of the future
3.1.1
Existence of
3.1.2
Light
........................................
light
cones
conformal structure
........................
25 32
.......................
152
...............................................
153
a
3.2.1
rays Existence of inertial observers
3.2.2
Law of inertia
3.3.1
Compatibility
3.4.1
No second clock effect
5.1.1
5.1.2
Tensorial. character of energy momentum Infinitesimal conservation law
5.3.1
Gravitation is determined
...........................
158
...........................................
158
with the causal structure
..................
...................................
................
............................
by
a
2nd-order
pde
............
160 168 259 264 269
1. Local
theory
of space and time
This book is not meant to be read in the order the material is
presented. Please follow the guide in the margins or skip material as proposed in the italic text at the beginning of most sections.
chapter we will develop those aspects of space and time which can be locally observed, say in a laboratory. We will start with Euclid’s description of space and then incorporate time in to the picture. The path we take is rather historical. It starts with intuitive but surprisingly complicated concepts (Newton’s theory of absolute space and absolute time) and ends with the not so intuitive but mathematically simpler theory of special relativity. The guiding principle of this book will not be mathematical simplification, but the solution of problems occurring In this
in earlier theories.
description in this chapter seems to be global and extrapolations which are not validated by any experiments and which are not generally true. In the following chapters we will take up this point again, and show that the description given in this chapter should be considered infinitesimally rather than globally. This is the theme of The mathematical
leads to
the book.
1. 1
Space
In this section
we
consider space and introduce Euclidean geometry. This
material is assumed to be familiar to the reader and is therefore in
a
presented
rather concise way.
Readers who wish to learn the essentials of the
quickly and do not mind skipping guide in the margins.
M. Kriele: LNPm 59, pp. 1 - 1, 1999 © Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 1999
some
theory
mathematical
of space and time can use the
proofs
P*
1
U
p.
3]
Local
1.
theory
of space and time
1.1.1 Affine space In this section
we
introduce
scription of space. Affine of 0 E R7 are ignored.2 It is
a
basic experience that
space
as
our
elementary de-
most
just R' where the special properties
is
we can
three real numbers. This
by
affine
space
uniquely
describe any point in space
to be the idea of Descartes
seems
(1637)
developed analytic geometry as an example of his Discours de la M6thode. While it is therefore plausible to identify R 3 with (physical) space, R3 contains a distinguished point 0 whereas space apparently does 3 not. Hence by using R as a description of space we introduce a mathematical structure which has no physical counterpart. This would lead who
to constructions which cannot be realised in space. For
instance, there is 3 negative of a vector v e R but there is no way to assign the negative to a point in space. As another example, addition of vectors has no direct interpretation in terms of points in space. If we want to have a reliable description of space with the property that all phenomena exhibited in this description are mirrored by physically verifiable phenomena,
the unique
we
have to abstract from these additional structures.
We will
meaning
isolate those structures of R 3 which have
now
in terms of space. Given two
points
we can
x, y
an
intuitive
construct
an
which points from x to y. This arrow induces a map from space to space. We just move the arrow (without rotating) such that its untipped end coincides with a given point z. The point z is then mapped to the arrow v
It appears that as long definition is independent of the path which
tip of the z.
In
z
-4
R3, z
arrow.
this
+ y
parallel transport Observe that y
x.
-
-
as we
we use
just given by the
is
x
-
don't rotate to
move v
map
stands here for the
v
Ry-x: R3 arrow v
this
-
from
x
--->
to
R3,
which is
not a point. Thus the geometric interpretation is different from a simple addition of vectors. In order to separate the concepts involved we define
the concept of real affine space. We do not yet know what "rotating" should terms
-
following of
our
so
far
we
have
definition
(for
simply
mean
physical picture
a
the n-dimensional
case)
reflects
However, the some properties
parallel transport and does not introduce The set of points is denoted by A'. properties.
naive notion of
additional
in mathematical
in mind.
any
Definition 1.1.1. An n-dimensional real affine space is a set A' and v E Rnj of bijective maps such that the a collection fRv: A' --> A' :
following
holds.
N R,+,, 2
=
Readers who
R,
R,,
Vv,
already have
and connections considered
o
as a
(cf.
Sect.
manifold
w
some
2.6)
G
Rn,
knowledge
together
of manifold
theory (cf. Chap. 2)
take affine space to be the usual R7 with the flat connection.
can
Space
1.1
(ii) for all Rvx,, (x)
allow for
see
A"
there exists
+
or v
unique v,,,y
a
x
v
+
and v.,,Y
x
below that this definition is
more
R' such that
c
y.
R,(x) by
We denote
We will
E
x, y
=
affine spaces than there
by
or
y-x
x--y'.
restrictive that it does not
so
vector spaces.
are
Remark 1. 1. 1. Of course, space is 3-dimensional. We work with general n for several reasons. Firstly, most of the theory we will be
dimension
with the exception of developing does not depend on the dimension a key-result whose proof, however, is too complicated to be presented in this book (cf. Theorem 5.3. 1). Secondly, it is often convenient to compare the theory with lower dimensional analogues which are easier to visualise. -
It is therefore advisable to formulate it in
analogues
a
way which encompasses these
and also shows the restriction of the
exist modifications of Einstein's
dimensions
general theory
analogy. Thirdly, there of relativity to higher
("Kaluza-Klein theories").
Another way to generalise the theory would be to allow for complex vector spaces as well. We refrain from doing so since the main result of Section 1.1.2 Note that for
only x
E
holds for affine spaces
An,
u, x
R' the associative law
v c
(U
+
R.
over
+
V)
(X
=
U)
+
+
V
holds. It is easy to see that all n-dimensional real affine spaces are isomorphic, and can be realised by R' in the following way. Choose E
A' and define
any
o
tify
An with
Rv(x)
=
0,, (A'
An
0,,:
R',
--
and define for
oo(Rv(oo- (x))). Clearly, x,,y
these definitions
are
Oo(x) OO(A'), v
x
E
x
F-+
Observe that
=
recover
the structure of R'
1.1.2 The fundamental theorem in affine
doubly
we
be needed in the
Coniden-
geometry
results
of affine geometry which will 1-4.1. This section is very technical first reading.
present
proof of
and should be omitted
some
Theorem
on
Let o, xj,..., xk E An and a',..., 1 barycentre with masses a 3
o.
by
ruled surfaces
In this section
the
vo,x. Now idenRn the bijection
independent of the arbitrarily chosen point
versely, choosing an o E An we can tifying o with the zero vector 0.
and
=
c
ak a
k
E
R such that
Ek
j=1
a'
=
1. Then
Section 1.1.2 is needed for the proof of Theorem 1.4.1 which is central to our interpretation of the Michelson-Morley experiment. However, the reader is strongly advised against reading this part now.
[
[P_
7 311]
4
1. Local
theory
of space and time
k
al X, +a 2X2+
-
-
-
+a kXk
:
0
`:::
+
Ea
(xi
-
0),
i=1
is
independent
of
defined via the
and therefore
o
right
affine invariant. The
an
hand side and
can
binations" where the real factors add to 1. is
X11
...
is k
7
be
2 k a Xl+a X2+ points f x +01 Xk : Eki=1 a i 1, where fixed pairwise different, points. The affine dimension of B 1
set of
a
symbol + is applied to "linear comAn affine subspace Bof A'
only
xk
are
1. It follows that
affine
subspace is an affine space. An affine an affine line. We call points lying on subspace a single line collinear. Observe that lines are the smallest sets which are invariant under parallel transport. -
an
of dimension 1 is called
Lemma 1. 1. 1. Let x, y, z E An. Then x, y, z lie on an only if there exists a A E R such that x y + A(z-y).
affine line if
and
==
Proof
x
R with
lies
x
=
the line
on
generated by
Oy+(l -O)z
=
y,
y+O(y-y)
z
+
if and
only
if there exists
(1 -0)(z-y)
=
Definition 1.1.2. An affine map is a map f: A' -4 An, A(x-o) + b, where A is a linear map, o E An, and b c Rn.
bijective
then
f
is called
A collineation is collinear points into Consider
given by
a
an
biJ, ection
n
G
f (x) If A
=
is
A' which maps any three
--
line 1 and three points X 1) X2 i X3 A(X2 -X1) is denoted by
X3 -X1
0
affine transformation.
f: A collinear points. a
an
y+ (I -0)(z-y). I
on
1. Then the number A
=
X3-XI
X2-XI
The the
following lemma is the classical theorem of Thales. It will be used in proof of the fundamental theorem in affine geometry (Theorem 1.1.1
below). Lemma 1.1.2. Let a
H1, H2, H3
line which intersects these
C Rn
be parallel hypersurfaces and 1 hypersurfaces. Let xi(l) Hi n 1. Then
be
=
X3(l)-XI(l) X2(l)-X1(l)' does not
Proof.
depend
Denote
on
1.
by R
the
subspace
of Rn which is the associated vector
space to the affine space
H1 (and since H1, H2, H3
H2, H3).
quotient
We consider the
space A
nIft
are
defined
parallel also by
to
Space
1.1
This space has Rn / fJ given by to the
a ir
y-xEfl.
ifandonlyif
x-y
5
natural affine structure with associated vector space Jf (x z) where 7r, f denote the proj ections 7r (z)
(x)
=
-
-
equivalence classes. We have
7r(X3(l))-7r(X1(l)) ::_-';f(X3(l)-X1(l)) Jf
implies
that
(1) -XI X2(l)-XI(l) only depends
ir(xi(l)) Hi
x, y E
==> 7r
(1))
-
(X3 (1)) -7r (XI 7r (X2 (1)) IT (X 1 (1))
X3
that
-XI
X3(l)-XI(l) f (X2 X1 X2(l)-Xl(l) X3(l)-Xl(l) (7 (X2 (1)) 7F (X 1 (1))) X2 (1) -X1
-
which
X3(l)-Xl(l) (X2 (1) (X2(l)-XI(l)
Ir
-
the projected values. Now it is sufficient to observe independent of I since all points in Hi are equivalent:
on
is
(x)
=
7r
(y).
I
It is easy to see that all bijective, affine maps are collineations. Conversely, the fundamental theorem in affine geometry asserts that any
collineation must be affine: Theorem 1.1.1. Let A' be 0
E
A. Let
points
f:
An
--+
into collinear
invertible linear map
An be
an a
affine
space
over
R with
n
> 2
and
fix
bi ection which takes each three collinear
points. Then there f such that f (x)
=
exists
a
f(x-o)
point b E An and for all x E An.
an
+ b
proof is elementary but lengthy and requires some preparatory lemWe will follow (Berger 1987, p. 52-55) where one can also find a version of this theorem which holds in the complex case. Observe that the following proof makes heavy use of the assumption n > 2. The theThe
mas.
orem
does not hold for
points
into collinear
n
=
I since in this
any map maps collinear
case
points.
Lemma 1. 1.3. Let o, x,.... iXk E R, and
An, f
be
a
collineation,
k
x==o+EA'(xi-o)EA
n
i=1
Then there exist
fil.... Ak I
E R
such that k
fW
=
f(o)
+
E Ai ff (xi) i=1
-
f (0))
-
A
Ak E
6
1. Local
Proof.
For k
theory
of space and time
1 the claim is clear
=
by the
Assume now, the assertion is true for all
definition of
1,
m
M+1 X
Then
we
.
.
k
,
collineation.
a
11.
-
For
M
Ai (Xi-0)
+
0
=
.
X,
let
=
0
Ai (Xi-0).
+
have X
=
X/ + Am+, (XM+1 -0)
(1.1.1)
p"
by induction hypothesis there are real numbers y' f (x') f (o) Eim. 1 M" (f (xi) f (o)). We define also and
=
-
with
-
Y
=
z
=
A'+'(xm+,-o),
+
0
2
Y+
(1.1.2)
X
2
The triples I z, x', y 1, 1 y, o, xm+ 1 1, and f z, o, x I consist each of collinear points. This is clear for the first triple and follows from Lemma 1.1.1 for the second triple. To see this for the third triple observe that y-o 1 x1. z x + 12 x' is the centre of the parallelogram defined by o, y, x, x' 2y and therefore the intersection of the line connecting y with x' and the line connecting o with x. Since each of these three triples consists of collinear points there exist a, 0, -/ such that =
-
This
=
f (Z)
=
af (X')+ (I
fW
=
Of (o)+ (I
f (Y)
=
f (o)+-Y(f (x.+i)-f (0)).
-
-
a) f (y),
O)f (z),
implies
fW
=
Of (o)+(I
=
'3(f (0)
-
-
O)f (Z)
f (0))
+
(I
-
(I
-
'3) ((af W) + (I
(I
-
)3) (c, (f (x')
-
0) (f (Z)
-
-
00 f (y))
f (o))
+
(1
-
f (0))
-
f (0))
+
(I
-
A
/i
(f (Xi)
a)-Y(f (X-+1)
-
-
f (0))
f (0)))
M+1 =
E 'U
(f (Xi)
-
f (0))
+
f (0)
-
f (0)
+
a) (f (y)))
M
0) (01
+
+
f (0)
f (0) +
f (o)
Space
1.1
Lemma 1.1.4. Let o, xl,. Xn E An such that f X1 -0i iXn-01 is a basis of R'. If f is a collineation then f f (xi) f (o), if (Xn)-f(O)j is ...
-
...
also
Proof
ol
basis
a
is
of R'.
Let -3- E An be any point and let x f basis of Rn there exist ' E R such that
Since
=
a
Lemma 1.1.3
implies
that there exist
pl,...'
n
x-o
E
=
fxl-o,...
7
Xn-
Enj I V(xi-o).
R such that
k
:
-
f (0)
=
fW
-
f (0)
=
EA
(f (Xi)-f (0))
-
j=1
Since 1--
was
arbitrary the
assertion follows.
Lemma 1.1.5. A
bijection f affine lines.
is
a
collineation
if
and
only if
it 'Maps
affine
lines onto
Proof.
Let x, y E An and denote by 1 the line spanned by these points. a point on the line spanned by f (x), f (y). We have to show
Let i be that
z
=
f-'( )
G
1. If this
was
not true than the vectors z-x,y-x
would be
linearly independent. But then Lemma 1.1.4 would imply that f (z) f (x), f (y) f (x) where linearly independent as well. Contradiction to the construction of I f (z) -
-
=
Lemma 1.1.6. Let
parallel
f
be
collineation. Then f maps parallel lines into
a
lines.
otherwise 1, 1 be two parallel lines (which do not coincide nothing to prove). Since they are parallel they span a plane P rather than a 3-dimensional subspace of An. This plane is mapped into a plane P'. In order to see this consider a line i such that the lines 1, i intersect and span P. It is clear that any line which intersects both 1 and i is contained in P. Moreover, any point y E P lies on a line I which intersects both I and 1. Let P' be the plane generated by the (intersecting) lines f (1) and f (1). f (y) lies on the line f (1) which intersects f (1) and f (i). Hence f (T) (and therefore f (y)) lies
Proof.
Let
-
there would be
in P'.
Having established that f (P) 0. If there f (1) n f (1)
show that
=
would lie in both 1 and V which is
is
subset of
a plane we only have to point z c f (1) n f (1) then f -'(z) impossible since both lines are parallel.
a
was a
I
Lemma 1. 1. 7. Let k: R
and k (a +,3)
=
--->
k (a) + k (,3)
R
for
an
k (a) k ( 3) automorphism, i. e., k (ao) id oz,,8. If k 7 0 then k
all real numbers
=
=
1. Local
theory of
space and time
-
k (0 + 0) k (0) + k (0) implies k (0) 0. Assume, there is an Proof. k (0) 0 0. Then k(o) with a 4 k(a) k(oz)k(ola) 0 for all 0 and k must vanish. Hence k(a) =A 0 Va 34 0. k(l) k(l 1) k(l)k(l) implies 1. By induction we obtain k(n) n for all natural numbers. k(l) k(-n) k(O) k(n) -k(n). Similarly, we have k(l/n) k(O n) =
=
=
=
=
=
=
-
1/k(n)
=
-
=
1/n. For n, m E Z we have now k(n/m) for all rational numbers. a < 0 implies
proved any positive number
is
7
2
we
number. Then there exists
k(-y 2)
have
=
n/m and the lemma k(a) :5 k(,3) since for
=
k(-y)k(-y)
> 0.
Let
now
-y be any
monotonically increasing sequence ai 'Y of rational numbers and likewise a monotonically decreasing sequence of rational numbers Oi Oi which k(ai) < k(-y) < k(0j) -y. Hence ai I implies k(-y) -y. a
-->
--->
=
=
=
Observe that this lemma would be false if z
would be
i-->.
above)
a
counter
This is
example.
is not true for affine spaces
f:
had
we
why
replaced
R
theorem 1.1.1
C
by
(as
as
stated
the field C.
over
R', v -4 f(v) f (o + v) f (o). an automorphism k: R --> R such that proof k (A) f (v) + k (y) f (w) holds for all A, M G R and v, w c R'. f (Av + I-tw) We will use constructions based on parallel lines in order to represent vectors such as v + w, (A + A)v, Attv. Since f maps parallel lines into parallel lines (Lemma 1.1.6) these constructions will be preserved by f and can therefore be used in order to prove linearity and multiplicativity Proof of
Theorem 1. 1. 1.
The idea of
Let
R'
--->
=
-
is to construct
f, k.
of
We will first show that
fis
additive.
f
(o+
(o o
+
V
+
o
o,
of
1.1.1.
+
W)
(0)----Ie- f(lo + V)
Additivity of f
1w that contains
parallel
w) f(V+W) +
V
Let v, w E R' and consider the lines 1,, 1w spanned by o, o + v and + w. The point o + v + w is the intersection of the parallel translation
Since v
W) (o +
f
Fig.
+
W
lines
o
+
is constructed =
v
and of
1, that
mapped analogously
into
are
f(o+V+W)-f(o)
=
contains
o
parallel f (o), f (o
w
(cf. Figure
we
know that
+
lines
1. 1. 1).
f (o
w). f(o+V+W)-f(0+V)+f(o+V)-f(o) from
+
v), f (o
+
+
Hence =
1. 1
Space
f(w) + f(v). Here we have used the f (o) f connecting (o) with f (o + w) and f (o + v) with f (o + v + w) are identical since they correspond to opposite sides of a parallelogram in a plane. Now we show that there is a well defined automorphism k: R --> R f (o
+
w)
f (o)
-
+
f (o
+
v)
=
-
fact that the vectors
such that
f(Av)
k (A)
=
f(v)
for all
v
E
Rn and A E R. We first fix
a
and consider the line 1
vector
R through o spanned by v. Denote by gi: 1 the map o + AV --> A and by gf the i--> Since + ttf(v) map f (o) f /-t. (1) maps the line through o which is spanned by v into the line through f (o) which is spanned by f (o + v) f (o) the map k: R R is well defined the through relationship f (Av) k(A)f(v). From v
-->
-
=
f (o) we see
+ k (A)
that k is
f(v)
f (o)
given by k (A)
+ =
f(Av) gf (1)
o
f (o f
o
gi
+ 1
Av)
f (gi
'(A))
(A).
f
/,00W O+W
AV AV 0
Fig.
0
0
f (0
+ AV + [tv
+ ttv /,V
X" , AV +
Additivity
1.1.2.
+
W)
(*0
f (0) f (0 + AV) f (0 + /,tv) f (0
+ AV +
/-tV)
of k
In order to prove additivity of k we use the fact that (A+M)v Av+,uv be constructed using parallel lines (cf. Figure 1.1.2) Let w E R' be =
can
linearly independent from points
o,
that the
the lines
o
+ w,
o
v
and consider the
+ Av. This
triangle defined by the parallely translated so (We simply parallely translate
triangle
o is mapped into generated by its sides
point
o
can
+ /-tv.
be
indicated in the figure). Since this translation preserves the vectors defined by the sides of the triangle we have obtained a geometric construction of the point o + Av + Aw. Since this construction only employs intersection points and lines it is
preserved by the
k(A)f(v)
+
k(A
map
k(p)f(v) +
p)
=
=
=
f
.
Hence
as
we
obtain
f ((A + /-t)v)
p rallel
=
f (Av)
+
f (ttv)
and therefore
gf (1)
o
f
o
gi
1
(A
+
/-t)
==
gf (1)
o
f (o
f((A + tt)v)) gf (1) (f (o) + k (A) fi(v) + k (M) f(v)) gf (1) (f (o) +
+
(A
+
tz)v)
10
Local
1.
theory
of space and time
gf (1) (f (o) +
(k (A)
+ k (p))
f(v))
=
k (A) + k (y).
f
f (0 o
A> 0
0 + 01
Fig.
f 1(o
+
AW)
+ AW
f (0) (0
W w 0+W
-
W)
+
0 + o4
A[IV f (o + V) f (o (0, + /\V) AV) ff (0
'+U Vlf
()o + pv)
'v 0 + /_tV 0+
\v + AV
f f(o+ (0 + A/,tV)
V
1.1.3.
Multiplicativity of k
proof of multiplicativity is similar and employs a slightly difgeometrical construction (cf. Figure 1.1.3) which is justified by Lemma 1.1.2. The configuration in the first part of Figure 1.1.3 lies in a plane whence hypersurfaces are simply lines. Denote by H2 the line which connects o + v with o + w, by I-I, its parallel translation through o, and by H3 its parallel translation through o + Av. Further denote the line through o and o + v by 1 and the line which connects o with o + w by 1'. Using the notation of Lemma 1.1.2 we have The
ferent
(0 + AV)-0 (0 + V), 0
A
X3(1)-X1(0 X1 (1) X2 (1) -
implies that the intersection of H3 and 1' is really depicted in the figure. We apply this lemma a second time where the three parallel hypersurfaces H2, H1, H3' are now given by the line connecting o + /-tv with o + w, its parallel translation through o, and its parallel translation through o + Aw. It follows that the intersection of H3' with 1 is o + y(Av) o + A/-tv. Since this construction only emlines it is preserved by f and we obtain and intersections parallel 1 loys f (Apv) k(A)k(p)f (v). This implies Hence Lemma 1.1.2 o
+ Aw
as
=
k(Att)
=
=
Hence k is
metrically o.
gf (1)
o
+
Aix)
=
gf (1) (f (o) +
gf (1) (f (o) + k (A) k (y) f(v))
really
our case
=
&yv))
k (A) k (y).
automorphism of the real line. One can geoautomorphism neither depends on v nor on this automorphism is trivially well defined since
an
show that this
However in
f (o
Space
1. 1
11
already know that the only non-zero automorphism of R is the identity. This also implies f (,\v) \f (v) for all X E R, v E Rn Hence the theorem is proved. I we
=
-
We will
now
turn
attention to
our
special subsets of affine
space which
become important in the proof of Theorem 1.4.1. Definition 1.1.3. Let U C R 2 be
an open set and x: U --, An be a C' map such that at each point (s, t) E U the differential Dx(s, t) is injective. Then x is called an immersed surface. If x is also injective
then it is
simply called
surface.
a
A surface should be envisaged by its image, a two-dimensional, smooth subset. An immersed surface may have self-intersections. Since lines have such a fundamental meaning in affine geometry, surfaces which are generated by lines are of special interest.. Definition 1.1.4. A ruled surface is zed
by
sation
a surface which can function of the form x(s, t) c(s) + tw(s). Such is called a ruling of the surface. a
=
Fig.
Example different
(i) (ii)
1.1.1. The
be parametria
parameteri-
1.1.4. A ruled surface
simplest ruled surfaces
those which admit two
are
rulings.
A trivial
example would be any plane. slightly more sophisticated example is given by the rotational hyperboloid. Let c(s) (COS(S), Sin(S), O)T be the unit circle in A
==
R' and consider is
a
Xhyp(S,t)
ruled surface and
t sin (s), sin (s) + t 2
(X hy P)2
-
(X3hy P)2
COS =
surface is described is
a
different ruling.
C(S)
=
+
t(6(8)
+
(0, 0, I)T). Clearly, (COS(S)
explicitly given by Xhyp(S,t)
(8), t) T.
=
Since it satisfies the equation
I it must be
by -Zhyp (8 t) 7
a
rotational
=
C(S)
(xlhy P)2 +
hyperboloid. The
+ t (_ 6(8) +
x -
(1, 0, 0) T)
same
which
Local
1.
12
(iii) A c(s)
theory
example
third
(s, 0, 0)
=
of space and time
'
and
is w
given by the hyperbolic paraboloid. Let 1, ks)T. Then Xpar(S7 t) 2 (0, 1_k1-2
(s)
=
v
+1
8-
X 3ar and Xpar parameterises a p I hyperbolic paraboloid. We can interchange x par and Apar to obT tain a different ruling of the same surface, ;r-par (8) t) (0, S, 0) +
c(s)
+
tw(s)
satisfies
kxlarx2ar p P
=
=
(1,0,kS)T.
I
a surface which admits two different M is a subset of affine transformation rotational hyperboloid, or a hyperbolic paraboloid.
Theorem 1.1.2. Let M C A' be
rulings.
Then
either
plane,
a
-
a
up to
an
-
Proof. It is easy to see that any surfaces M C A' with two rulings can locally be embedded into A'. One just has to consider -a line 11 of the first ruling which intersects a line l'2 of the second ruling. Choose another line l'3 of the second ruling which also intersects 11. Then all three lines further line of span a 3-dimensional affine subspace. At least locally, any the first ruling must intersect both l'2 and l'3 whence it is contained in the same affine subspace. Since M is generated by the lines of the first ruling we have proved the assertion.
1.1.5. Proof of Theo-
Fig. rem
1.1.2
-
first
case
a plane plane. Hence we can assume that any two generators are linearly independent. There are now two possibilities. Either there exist three generators which are all parallel to a single plane or any three generators are linearly independent. In the first case let 111 12,13 be different generators of the first ruling which are all parallel to a single plane. We can now find linear coordinates
If there
are
any two
generators of the first ruling which lie
in
then the ruled surface must be this
I X ,X2,X31
12. By 0, 12 by x1
parallel X
3
=
such that the x1-Axis coincides with 11 and the
to
=
x
2-axis is
choosing the origin appropriately, 11 is given by x a', and 13 is given by x 3 a2, X1 +a 3X2 0, x =
=
2
=
=
0,
a two-plane which contains 11. Then there where a 1,a2,a 2 0. Any generator V P is that such R exists an s E given by x + SX3 both 12 and intersect must P in contained is which second of the ruling
3
E R. Let P be
=
13- We obtain for the intersection points:
1.1.6. Proof of Theo-
Fig.
1.1.2
rem
jPn12j:
X
jPn13j:
X
=
0,
=
a
1
It follows that 1' has the
2
2
X
a
3
a
X
8,
Since the ruled surface is a
eters s, t
2
2
a
a
==
X
s,
second
+ t
-S
W
a2
al)
_
1. ,
3
a
=
2
:
t ER
al
_
1', we have obEliminating the param-
such these lines
generated by
x(s, t) parameterisation (s, t) 3 -a3a 2 2, whence the surface we obtain xlx of it.
-->
=
hyperbolic paraboloid. For the second
case
a2a3s
0
tained
3
X
s,
-
parameter form
-als al
1/
1
13
Space
1. 1
f x1, x2, X31
choose linear coordinates
case we
thatthe X3 -Axis coincides with 13 , the X2-axis is
must be
parallel
to
a
such
12, and the x1
-
chose the origin 0 of the coordinate system 11. parallel 0. Then such that it lies in 13 and such that 12 lies in the plane X3 X2 X1 : there exist numbers al, a2, a3 C R such that 13 01, JX axis is
We
to
can
=
=
12
=
fX
plane an s
X1
=
a', x3
=
01,
and 11
=
which contains 13 and is not
c
family
This
:
parallel
given by x1
R such that P is
fx
X2
:
2
sx
-
a2,X3
=
to
X2
0.
=
=
a3 1. Let P be
Any
line 1' of the second
which lies in P must intersect 11 and 12- We calculate
JP
n
111: x1
fP
n
121:
X
=
sa
=
a
I
2 ,
1 ,
X
X
2
a a
2
2 ,
X
3
a
1
=
,
X
3 =
0.
gives the line a'
a'
alls 0
+ t
-
alls
sa -
-a
3
2
a
2
a
0. Then there exists
=
tGR
3
14
1. Local
(s, t)
It follows that
(s, t)
theory
-a
a
that this
(X 3)2 ( 2)2+ (X3)2 X
1, the
(X 2)2 that
cone
_
our
3X1X2
+
a
2
xIx3
1x2x3
a
_
affinely equivalent either
1, the two-dimensional
=
-
we
eliminate
+
a
I
a3x 2
=
0.
quadric. We could use the Gram-Schmidt-procedure to show quadric is affinely equivalent to a hyperboloid. But since any
in R 3 is
quadric
parameters of the ruled surface. If
are
obtain the equation
we
This is
of space and time
X3
==
1, the rotational
=
(X 1) 0,
2
+
or a
(X2)
2 _
X3
to the
pseudo-hyperbolic
hyperboloid,
=
-
(x')
2
space,
+
plane, we can infer without affinely equivalent to a
(X2)2 + (x 1)2 +
(X 1)2 + (X2)
-
2
0, the hyperbolic paraboloid
surface must be
1.1.3 Euclidean
sphere
2
+ -
(X3) (XI)
2
+
any further calculation rotational hyperboloid.
geometry
Euclidean geometry gives the local model of space. In the following sections we will obtain models of space & time which incorporate Euclidean geometry as description of space. Unless otherwise stated, here and in the following space has dimension n 1. We assume that Eu-
clidean geometry is known to the reader and a
therefore only
summarise
few facts.
In affine space, we have no definition for "length" or "angle". Since these are fundamental concepts for our perception of space, we must endow affine space with an additional structure. The first scientific and ex-
perimentally well tested description ing
and axiomatisation of space involv(ca. 340b.C.-
these notions culminated in the "Elements of Euclid"
270b.C.).
In modern
terminology, Euclid's theory
of space
tified with Euclidean geometry. The central object of Euclidean geometry is the scalar Definition 1.1.5. A scalar
product V
such that
for
any u, v,
w
E
V
--+
(u,v)
F-4
V, A,
A u, V) (i) (U Av + AW) V, U), (ii) (u, V) (iii) (u, U) > 0, OV) u, U) 0 == > U 0 =
,
=
=
hold.
=
x
+
on a
U
product. a
map
(1.1.4)
(U,V)
(u, W),
be iden-
real vector space V is
R
It c R the
can
properties
Space
1.1
We a
define
can now
scalar
Euclidean space
an
as an
affine space
15
equipped with
product.
Definition 1.1.6. An Euclidean space is
(i) A "
(n
is the
-
1) -dimensional,
pair (A",
a
real
affine
where
space with associated
vector space R n- 1,
(") (*C)R1-1 0: An'
A map
is
scalar
a
product
An-1 is
-->
an
R".
on
isometry if and only if
O(Yl)-0(X1)i 0(Y2)-0(X2))R71-1 for
An-1
all Y1) X1 7 Y2 7 X2 c:
physical
The
initions x, y E
It is
notions
wish to capture with
we
A` should
plausible
mathematical def-
our
The distance between two points
"angle". only depend on
"distance" and
are
YI-Xli Y2-X2)Rn-1
:--::
the connecting vector u y-x. x and x + \u is X times =
to demand that the distance of
the distance between
definition dist (x ,
x
y)
and X
x
+
Hence, given
u.
Y Rn-1
-
scalar
a
V(X_y1X_y)R11-1
:=
product, the to be
seems
a
reasonable choice. It is vectors
in order to
clear, however, that needs
one
map Rn
a
x
Rn
measure
of the
real number. The
directions u,
by
Z (u,
v)
=
(
arccos
angle
between two
symmetric in both vector is multiplied by a
entries and remains
defined
unchanged if one angle between two
the
R which is
-->
v
may therefore be
(U,V)R"-l IIUIIR"-l 11V11R11-1
priori clear that a scalar product is indeed the appropriate additional structure for defining lengths and angles. See (Weyl 1923, 19) It is not
for
a
a
theoretical
1.1.1. A map
Proposition ture
(A n-1, (7 *)RII-1)
A: R n-1 and
(Au, Au)R11-1
0: An-1
invariant
Rn- ' and
-4
of the usage of scalar
justification
points
if
only if there
I such that o, b E An-
U) U)Rn-1 for
:=
An-1 leaves the Euclidean
__
and all
products.
u E
exist
V)(x)
struc-
linear map
a
A(x-o)
=
+b [p.
R".
I
Proof. Observe first that all
u
E R
for all v,
O(Yl)
n-1 w
-
c
application of Au, Au)R11-1 u v + w implies (Av, Aw) R11
an
to the vector
R n-1
.
0(X1)i0(Y2)
-
In the
proof
of
x t-->
O(x)
=
A(x-o)
-
I
(U7 U)R11-1 for (V W) R11 =
I
+ b satisfies
0(X2))R11-1
(A(yi-o) =
(A(y,
=
(Y1
-
:--
=
Hence the map
-
-
X1, Y2
Proposition
A(x1-o), A(Y2-0)
x1), A(Y2
1.1.1
-
-
A(X2_o))R11-1
X2))R11-1 X261-1 -
*
we
appeal
14
1]
-4
to Theorem 1.1.1.
-
p. 16
16
Local
1.
theory of
space and time
Conversely, any map V) which preserves the Euclidean structure preserves particular the affine structure. Hence Theorem 1. 1. 1 implies that there
in
linear map A and a point b such that O(x) A(x-o) + b for all Since 0(y) O(x) A(y x) it is clear that A must satisfy
is
a
x
E A.
=
=
-
Au, Au)R,,-'
(ul U)R,,,-'
=
-
for all
u c
R".
P.
Remark 1.1.2. At first
sight our definition of a Euclidean space may general. The reader may feel that in space there is a subset of physically distinguished scalar products: Let e be a vector which we use as measuring stick defining unit length and E a plane which contains el. Using a pair of compasses we can construct a line 1, C E which is orthogonal to el and therefore also seem
to be too
vector e2 of the
length as el but perpendicular to el. We may plane E,, by rotating,e-2 around el and a third plane E,, by rotating el around e2. The intersection E,1 n Ee2 is a line orthogonal to el and e2. Using again or pair of compasses we can construct a third vector e3 which is of unit length and orthogonal to el and e2- Our distinguished scalar product is now given by (ei, ej)R3 6ii' It follows from the Theorem of Pythagoras that the length of a vector u is given by JUIIR3- We can use a pair of compasses to approximately (but arbitrarily well) divide the circle into a fixed number of arcs thereby introducing an approximate measure of angle. From the definition of the cosine it is clear that (up to a constant factor depending on the number of arcs) the size of an angle is given by the definition above. However, this introduction of the standard scalar product is based on procedures which are intuitive but which cannot be defined in mathematical terms without having a scalar product in the first place. In fact, if we had started with any given scalar product (., -) and had defined a
now
construct
a
same
second
=
(i)
a
rotation
as a
linear map which leaves the scalar
product
invari-
ant and
(ii)
a
pair of
containing same
then using
a
length our
compasses
given as
construction
1.1.2. Let
Euclidean spaces. which satisfies
(O(Yl) for
-
a
e
device which for each given plane E produces all vectors e' c E with the
e,
lowing proposition gives Proposition
as
vector
a
we
would just have recovered
(An-1, (*1')R"1-1)
Then there exists
V)(X1)i'0(Y2)
all X1i Yli X21 Y2 E
The fol-
mathematical explanation of this fact.
An-1.
-
an
V)(X2))R11-1
and
affine
=
Yl
R11-1) map
-
0: A'-'
X1) Y2
-
-,
X2 R-l
be two
An-1
1.2 Absolute space and absolute time
Proof. Choose tively
any
be
(respectively
is
a
basis
A'-' and let lei,..., e,,_11 (respec-
E
orthonormal basis with respect to
(-)R11-1)
ei. Then 1) We define the linear map A by A i b desired is the isomorphism. A(x-o) + -
O(x)
=
is often referred to
0
Corollary
an
=
the affine map The map
points o,b
17
as an
Euclidean
transformation.
*) *61-, be a scalar product of Rn-1. Then there 6ij, where en-11 of Rn-1 such that ei, ej )RI-1
1.1.1. Let
lei,
=
6ij is the Kronecker
I
for
0
otherwise
i
=
j,
symbol.
Today, Euclidean geometry is-often taught as a prime example for a closed and consistent mathematical theory. This obscures the fact that angles and distances are physically measurable and that therefore Euclidean geometry can be falsified as a physical theory. (For instance, one of the most influential philosophers since the time of enlightenment, Kant (1781), wrongly considered space as given "a priori"). In modern times, Carl Friedrich GauJ3 (1777-1855) seems to have been the first to realise the possibility that Euclidean geometry may not be the correct description of our world though the legend that he tried to verify Euclidean geometry by measuring the angles between three mountain summits is not true (Osserman 1995, page 66). He has developed a non-Euclidean geometry in which the parallel axiom does not hold but did not publish it. This geometry was also independently discovered by the Hungarian mathematician Jdnos Bolyai (1802-1860). Later in this book we will conclude that space should be described by geometries which are far more general than those considered by GauB and Bolyai. -
1.2 Absolute space and absolute time In this section
we
present the "naive" model of
space and time.
We
complicated it really is. We will also give a short account of Newton's theory of particles which is the main physical justification of this spacetime concept. will take
Time
seems
care
to show how
to have
striking similarities with
space but nevertheless to be
which is very different. Like space time is a continuum. However, space is a 3-dimensional continuum while time is 1-dimensional. Moreover, we can freely move in space but merely drift in time. It is
something
18
1.
Local
theory
of space and time
-----------_-------
--------------
movement
inovement
in tirrie
in
space-
tP1
time
t--------
Fig. 1.2.1. A curve in spacetime diagram often
practical to treat space and time in spacetime diagrams are used to describe Hermann Minkowski
nobody
has
ever
unified
manner.
movements
(1864-1909) (Minkowski 1909)
experienced
space without time
This observation is borne out
following
a
For
instance,
(cf. Fig. 1.2.1).
has
pointed
out that
time without space. space & time in the
or
by characterising
way.
Definition 1.2.1. A primitive spacetime is set. The points time are called events.
of
a
space-
Of course, this definition does not tell anything about the relation of or even allows to distinguish between these concepts.
space and time
In order to do
so we must supplement the primitive spacetime with a geometrical structure. In the preceding section we have recalled that space can well be described by (n I)-dimensional Euclidean space. The fact that time is I-dimensional indicates that spacetime can be considered as an ndimensional affine space which is foliated by (n I)-dimensional subspaces each of them carrying a Euclidean structure. Any foliation with affine hyperspaces corresponds to a linear map T: R' -4 R, where x, y E A' are in the same hyperspace if and only T(x-y) 0. Denote by Ex fy E An : 7-(y-x) 01 the affine hyperplane through x and let o'o/ E An. Then the vector spaces associated with all these affine hyperplanes E., (x E An) are identical. In fact, they are given by -F-1(0) 0 1. Hence we only have to specify one single Euclidean f v E Rn : -r (v) scalar product .),-, (0) on the vector space -r- 1 (0) in order to get a -
-
=
=
=:
=
foliation of
with one
(n
-
l)-dimensional
Euclidean spaces. This is in accordance change from
experience that the geometry of space does not instant of time to another. our
The map
be
interpreted as a world clock: The time difference z is just T(z x). Observe that T is uniquely factor. This factor corresponds to the physical unit in
-r can
between to events
x
and
-
defined up to a which time is measured.
We still need to link events in different
spond
to the
same
point
in space. The
hypersurfaces which simplest way to do so is to
corre-
intro-
1.2 Absolute space and-absolute time
duce
line
second structure
as a
x
+ Rt
by -r(t)
t
as
the
a
vector t and
interpret all points lying
in space at different times. If
point
same
I then the time difference between
=-
Definition 1.2.2. A Newton
spacetime
is
and y
x
=
we
x
where t E Rn is =
the
+ tt is
just
t.
quadruple
a
(1.2.6)
distinguished vector, -r: R' ---),_ (O) is a scalar product on
R
a
1, and (.,
on
normalise
(An, t',r'
,r(t)
19
linear map such that
a
the vector space
This definition is just the content of Isaac Newton's of absolute time and absolute space.5
7-'(0)..
(1642-1727) theory
1.2.2. Absolute space, abso-
Fig.
lute time
We
see
that
is fibred
spacetime
twice, By lines parallel
hyperspaces
of the form
may appear
quite cumbersome but
in
a
geometrical
One
as
defining
notion of rest, and think of
of v
o
it
is
some
to t and
by
fixed event. This structure
captures
naive
our
point of view
way.
think of t
can
where
E,+tt
-r
as
pair (-r, t) induces A +V and -r(,U) 0.
time. The
a
a
time axis and therefore
an
absolute
defining an absolute notion of instant projection -:: R' -->, R', v 1--* 6, where
=
=
A map which leaves the structure of a Newton spacetime invariant a spatial Euclidean transformation as given in Proposition
consists of 1.1.2 and
a
spacetime translation. 1.2.1. A map
Proposition
(An, t,,T, (.' 1 -r- (0)
A:
-4
-F-
1
(0)
and points o, b
(i) O(x) A(x-o) (ii) (Au, Au),-, (0)
+
=
5
V): A' --+ An leaves the Newton spacetime if and only if there exist a linear map
invariant
In the next section
=
we
E
An such that
T(x-o)t + b and u, u),-, (0) for all
will discuss
an
u
E T_
1
(0)
-
improved spacetime model
named after Galileo Galilei who lived before Newton. The is that Calilei
reason
which is for this
emphasised different points than Newton, points which are more important to us nowadays. However, what will be referred to as a Galilei spacetime also incorporates ideas due to Newton.
20
Local
1.
theory
of space and thne
Proof
It is easy to check that maps of this form are isomorphisms of NewConversely, observe that any affine map '0 which maps any affine hyperplane E,, into some affine hyperplaneE,,, is necessarily of the form ton structures.
O(x) where A is
a
linear map of
That A satisfies
follows from
Proposition
T
1
(0)
+
into
-F(x-o)v itself,
t- o
=
E
v
R'*
(u,u),-,(O)
=
1.1.1 and the fact that
0
and o, b c A'.
for all
-r-'(0)
E
u
restricted to Ex is
invariant of the Newton
an
implies 0 (o + t) 0 (o) this equation is equivalent to v
o+
+ b
an
spaces.
Since the vector t is t. But
-
(Au,Au),-,(O)
isometry of Euclidean tion
A(x-o)
=
t
Observe that the choice of
is
o
spacetime the
t and therefore
-
(-r (t) v
+
equa-
b)
-
b
t.
irrelevant,
it
always
can
be absorbed
by
b.
We call the set of all
isomorphisms 0
Newton group JV. Given a Newton spacetime respect to which T (1, 0,
we can
t
=
.
find
=
of the Newton
a
basis
(1, 0,
I
spacetime the
lei,. e,,J of R' with 0) T, and (u, v) (0) ..,
Eni,j=i 6ijuiVi.
1.2.1 Non-relativistic
particles
Here
we very briefly indicate elementary aspects of Newton's theory of particle mechanics. We will only touch on those features which are necessary for later sections. This section is included for the benefit of
mathematicians.
A particle is
thought
to be
a
exterior structure. This is of
small material
course a
object without
interior
gross idealisation of many
or
macro-
scopic objects, but for
some purposes surprisingly good. Billiard balls typical examples. On the other hand, one cannot neglect the internal structure of a football. It will be noticeably deformed when hit. This contributes to its springiness and at the same time shows that the particle model is not adequate. An American football has a shape which are
contributes to its movement when it rolls
particle description would
be
on
a
flat surface.
bad approximation. Newton observed that even if all its structure
material ment in
object does
carry
a
Again,
a
neglected,
a
a
can
be
parameter which characterises its
spacetime. This parameter is its
mass.
move-
1.2 Absolute space and absolute time
Definition 1.2-3. A non-relativistic particle with mass (m,,y) where m E R+ and -y: t --> - (t) G An satisfies T( -y is called its world line in
curve
21
is
m
(t))
=
a
pair
1.
The
'
spacetime.
It has been first
expressed by Galilei (cf. Sect. 1.3) that under ideal particle which is not subjected to any external force moves straight line. 7
conditions
along
a
a
Definition 1. 2.4. A non-relativistic inertial
particle (m, 7) which satisfies It is clear that x
t(t
+
7('Y)
+
Y)
is
a non-
relativistic
some
0.
=
Of
special
interest to
derstand under confined to in the
particle
0.
non-relativistic particle is inertial if and only if -Y(t) point x E A' and some constant vector U with
a
for
=
a
sense
collisions of inertial particles. We unparticles any interaction of them which is
us are
collision of
a
compact subset of spacetime. It is best to think of collisions
of
colliding
billiard balls. But
we
explicitly
allow that par-
ticles break up or stick together. Since the collision is confined in space and time it is possible to speak in connection with a collision of incoming
and outgoing inertial particles. Let (Tni, ^ i)i=1,_k denote the incoming the outgoing inertial particles. Then particles and (m 3, 7
inertial the
following
laws
experimentally well justified.'
are
I:k
(i)
Conservation
of
(ii) (iii)
Conversation
of spatial of kinetic
Conservation k
mass.
Mi
=
Mi
i=1
M,
j,
i=1
M/.,Yf 3
Mi7i
energy. 1
1
E2
Eli momentum. I:k i= 1
oli"07_1(0)
=
1
1: 2
M
i( j, /
j=1
It is easy to see that these laws are invariant with respect to isomorin the Newton group A(. It is clear that most particles do not move along straight lines. In
phisms this
case an
to take
a
external
force
must act
on
the
particle
in order to force it
different path.
Definition 1.2.5. A
(time dependent)
force field
_P
is
a
map F: An
7-1(0). We
only need -r( (t))
> 0 in order to
its future. The normalisation
the world clock t. 7
8
guarantee that the particle moves into I synchronises each particle with
-r( (t))
=
It is not
absolutely clear whether Galilei really meant straight lines or more complicated curves which take into account the shape of the earth. These laws are intimately linked to the homogeneity of space and time. This is the content of the Noether Theorem. For further details cf. any textbook on
(theoretical)
mechanics,
1. Local
22
theory
of space and time
given force field f equation
In
a
a
particle
-y
according
moves
to the differential
my= F.
(1.2.7)
In
particular, vanishing force implies that -y is an inertial particle. According to the physical interactions under consideration a particle may also carry a variety of other parameters besides m. As an example consider an electrical field f : A' ---+ -F 1 (0). Every particle (m, -y) carries -
another parameter q which determines the force with which the electrical on the particle, f qf.
field acts
=
1.3 Galilei's
theory of relativity
In this section
drop
of the structure of Newton spacetime in theory of relativity. We also argue that his revolutionary given the paradigms of the time. we
some
order to arrive at Galilei's
theory Galilei's
was
theory
of
relativity
not feel that the earth
has been motivated
moves
into any
by cosmology. We do preferred direction. It is therefore at rest and that all objects at the
plausible to believe that the earth is sky are moving around it: The sun rises in the East and during the course of a day moves to the West, and there are analogous descriptions of the movements of the moon and the stars. It was already well known that planets are not moving along strictly circular orbits. In the traditional cosmology of the Greek astronomer Claudius Ptolemeaus (ca. 100-160) this was accounted for by an elaborate construction using epicycles. It was a revolutionary act of Nicolaus Copernicus (1473-1543) to assert that the
around the
did
so
sun
sun
is the centre of the universe and that the earth is
just like
any other
in order to arrive at
a
planet
or
star
moving
(Copernicus 1543).
He
model in which movements would be theo-
retically more uniform and which would therefore be in better accordance with the teaching of the ancient Greek philosophers Pythagoras (ca. 570 b.C.-500
b.C.)
and Platon
1984)). However, (using more epicycles
his model
of serious
(i)
If
than
(ca.
428 b.C.-347
was
not
b.C.) (cf. (Kanitscheider
only technically
Ptolemeaus)
more
complicated
but also encountered
a
number
problems.
Copernicus
was right one should be sphere of fixed stars. If
able to discover
a parallaxis sphere and the earth rotate both around the sun with different velocities, then one should observe different angles a, 0 between two neighbouring stars according to the time of the year. (Cf. Fig. 1.3.1). (ii) Some passages in the bible seem to contradict the theory of Copernicus. In particular, it states that Joshua stopped the sun for a few
effect at the
the fix star
hours. This statement would not make have moved before.
sense
if the
sun
would not
1.3 Galilei's
(iii)
The model of
Copernicus
sun
the
other exception
was
around the in the
sky
seems
to be
moves more
theory
of
relativity
23
inhomogeneous. While all planets circle definitely moves around the earth. No known. According to Ptolemeaus, every object is
moon
around the earth. Hence the traditional system homogeneous on a large scale and therefore to be
advantageous.
(iv)
The laws of mechanics
Imagine
(being
a
stone
seem
falling
fixed to the
to contradict
from the top of
ground)
would
move
a
Copernicus' hypothesis. tower. Since the tower
together
with the
earth,
would not expect the freely falling stone to hit the ground at the foot of the tower. However, exactly this is everyday experience. one
(Cf. Fig. 1.3.2).
Fig.
1.3.1. Parallaxis effect
Fig.
1.3.2. Tower
example
(i) has been addressed by Copernicus himself. He just assumed sphere of fixed stars is so large that the parallaxis effect cannot be measured. Ironically, the true radius is orders of magnitudes larger than the radius he proposed. (He was just concerned with making the effect unobservable). The other three objections have been answered by Problem
that the
Galileo Galilei Calilei
was
(1564-1642)
church authorities effect that
some
60 years later.
least successful with Problem
(for instance,
(ii).
While he could quote
Aurelius
Augustinus (354-430)) to the bible literally when it comes to
one should not interpret the questions of physics, the establishment remained unconvinced. One of the reasons has been the fear to set a precedence. If people started to doubt any part of the writing they could as well start to be sceptical about other parts which are closer to the main doctrine. Hence there was a major threat to the whole building of Christian belief. The theory of Copernicus was put on the index and Galilei after having written -
1. Local
24
a
theory
of space and time
brilliant but rather defiant
matter
mild
-
semi-popular
book
(Galilei 1632)9
sentenced to house arrest. He obtained this
was
punishment
after
a
public but
on
the
comparatively
insincere abdication of his scientific
assertions.
Galilei solved Problem
(iii) by careful observation (Galilei 1610).
telescope had just been invented and Galilei was as a scientific tool. He observed that the planet
one
of the first to
The
use
it
Jupiter also has moons show that the to and used this observation cosmological system of Ptolenot more homogeneous than the system of meaus of the universe was other hand, since it was believed that beyond the Copernicus. On the with a medium very different from air, many moon the world was filled philosophers doubted the accuracy of the telescope. They claimed therefore that it was doubtful that the telescope which was acknowledged to work well on earth could be trusted when applied to the position of planets. Galilei argued that the telescope was accurate with respect to all the known phenomena in the sky and that it was therefore justified to
use
it
as a
scientific tool.
(iv) by asserting
of inertia which asserts that a constant movement had no influence on physical processes. Galilei supplemented this law with the important physical assertion that complicated velocities can be decomposed into simpler ones. According to this law the stone would keep its initial tangential velocity while falling down and therefore come to rest at the foot of the tower regardless of the velocity of the earth. It can be argued that this solution of the problem was the most revolutionary act in natural sciences and started physics as a scientific discipline in the modern sense. Recall that everyday experience seems to point against Galilei's law of inertia: If we set a wagon into motion it will certainly come to a stop after some while. Moreover, there was a generally accepted physical theory by Aristotle (384 b.C.-322 b.C.) which explained this experimental fact. (The wagon has an initial impetus which is responsible for the movement and which is used up during the motion.) Galilei gave many examples to make his law of inertia plausible and to show that it is a law for a limiting case without friction. For instance, he claimed that a stone falling from the mast top of a smoothly sailing ship would also reach the ground at the foot of the mast-10 Galilei solved Problem
a
law
-
9
10
This book is
a
literary and physical
master
piece.
Even
today
it is well worth
reading! As compelling this example may appear to us, at the time there were some good reasons to doubt it. Since the velocities involved are rather small it would be difficult to verify Galilei's claim experimentally. Also, while the wind is blowing into the same direction. it is conceivable that the just blown to the right position. (To value the merit of such counter arguments one has to be aware that at this time, good, quantitative physics has not yet been available). Some of these arguments have already been answered by Galilei, who, for instance, circumvented the wind argument by
ship
moves
stone is
1.3 Galilei's
theory
Galilei realised that his law of inertia is not notion of absolute rest. Instead he
postulated
a
relativity
of
25
compatible with the principle of
fundamental
relativity.
(Galileian relativity).
Postulate 1.3.1 move are
relative to each other with constant
the
For any two observers which all physical processes"
velocity
same.
It follows that the vector t in the definition of Newton
defines absolute rest does not have of the a
originality
of Galilei that
spacetime which another sign
physical meaning. (It is Newton thought he had to a
re-introduce
concept which had already been shown to be superfluous). While we have lost the notion of absolute space we can still retain
absolute time. obtain the
Spacetime is then fibred by hyperplanes following simpler structure of sPacetime.
Definition 1.3.1. A Galilei spacetime is
(An, where
Rn
7-:
product
on
R is
--
a
T,
non-zero
the vector space
(., .)
,
_
a
(0)
const and
t
we
triple
)
(1.3.8)
,
linear map and
is
a
scalar
T-1(0).
.40.00.."M
Fig.
1.3.3. Relative space, abso-
lute time
The linear map
-r
defines
a
world clock
time difference between to events
model
by defining 7-(y
-
x)
to be the
and y exactly as in the Newtonian above. In contrast to Newton's spacetime we do not have
presented
x
-
the vector field t at
our disposal and therefore there is no absolute rest replaced "absolute space" by a distinguished family of systems" or "inertial observers". The notion of "Rest" can only
space. We have
"inertial
be defined relative to
an
Definition 1.3.2. Let
(i) 'T
"inertial observer":
(An,,F, (., .),-,(0))
A non-relativistic observer is
( M)
=
I
be
a curve
a
Galilei spacetime.
7: t
->
-y(t)
E An
such that
-
claiming that the physics in a cabin of a smoothly sailing ship would exactly the same as on earth. Strictly speakingl'he only considered mechanical processes.
be
26
Local
1.
(ii) A -/(t) (iii) A
theory
of space and time
non-relativistic inertial observer -y is
==
+
x
tt, where
R', -r(t)
t E
non- relativistic
a
curve
of the form
1.
=
observer y is at rest with respect to
relativistic inertial observer
-y(t)
=
x
if A(t)
+ tt
a non-
t.
Hence
given a non-relativistic inertial observer 7(t) x + tt we obtain splitting of spacetime into space and time relative to -Y. Physically, this amounts to regarding the observer -y as being at rest. We can also a
interpret
t
as a
observer -y
relative time axis. Relative to the
non-
have thus recovered the structure of
we
Notice, however, that this one non- relativistic
a
relativistic inertial
Newton spacetime.
only possible by arbitrarily distinguishing following defi-
is
inertial observer. This motivates the
nition.
Definition 1.3.3. Let t is called
R' be
E
a
T(t)
vector with
1. The
=
given reference frame (t, -F) we obtain a map Y + A where -F(V) unique decomposition v
For any via the
=
1.3.1. A
Proposition time
A:
(An',r'
T-1(0)
pair (t, -F)
non-relativistic reference frame.
a
(0),
T
>
---
a
(i) O(x) A(x-o) 1, and (ii) T(v) (iii) (Au, Au),-,(O) =
An
0:
map
--+
invariant
if
vector
Rn,
+
v
R'
=
G
-r(x-o)v
+
and
A'
leaves the
only if
there
and points o, b
are
cz
F-+
Rn- I
0.
Galilei spacea linear map
An such that
b,
=
(u, u),-,(O) for
=
all
u
Cz
T-1(0).
Proof. It is straightforward to check that maps of this form are isomorphisms of Galilei spacetimes. Conversely, observe that any affine map 0 which maps each affine hyperplane E,, into some other affine hyperplane E,,, is necessarily of the form
O(x) where A is Since
V)
A'. Hence ,T
a
=
linear map of
preserves we
(A (X
which in turn
r we
A(x-o) -
T
1
(0)
have
+
into
T(x-o)v itself,
v
-r(O(x)-O(o))
+ b
and o, b c An. T(x-o) for all x,
E R' =
o
E
obtain
-
0)
+
T(X-O)V
implies -F(v)
=
+
b-b)
=
-r(x-o)-F(v)
=
7-(x-o)
1.
The third property follows since A must preserve the Euclidean scalar I product The Galilei group 9 is the group of maps which leaves the Galilei spacetime invariant.
1.4 Einstein's
special theory
It should be noted that the Galilei
is
relativity
compatible
27
with
described at the end of Sect. 1.2. The
particles well accepted as the correct model of space and time for more than 200 years. However, in the 19th century a theory of electro-magnetism emerged which, together with this spacetime model, was incompatible with Postulate 1. 3. 1. Still, scientists continued to think that the postulate would hold for mechanical processes. Newton's
theory
spacetime
of
of
Galilei spacetime
1.4 Einstein's
as
was
special theory
of
relativity
We start with a discussion of the fundamental Michelson-Morley Experiment which indicates that the velocity of light has an absolute value c. These findings indicate that the set of all possible light rays form a further invariant of nature. We will see that this leads to the structure of a Minkowski spacetime (Theorem 1.4. 1), or, equivalently, to Einstein's special theory of relativity. We use the results from the two preceding sections to show that there is no need for additional structures in spacetime. In Sect. 1.4.2 we give a short discussion of some consequences of special relativity such as the "Twin paradox" (which, of course, is not paradoxical at all). The proof of the fundamental Theorem 1.4. 1 requires section 1. 1. 2
to
ti
t2
Fig.
1. 4. 1. A flash of
light
at times to
=
0,
t17 t2
In the 17th century two
In 1676
Olaf
important properties of light emerged.
R&mer discovered that the
by noticing that the there of the moons of Jupiter. did this
was a
velocity of light is finite. He yearly oscillation in the periods
physicist Christian Huygens (1629-1695) developed a theory of light (Huygens 1690). In a very superficial way, we may light as an analogon to water waves.12
The Dutch wave
view
paragraphs should not be taken too seriously by the overly simplified version of the wave theory of light just enough in order to understand the Michelson-Morley experiment presented below. Moreover, today the theory of quantum electro dynamics provides a much deeper understanding.
The
following
two
reader. We give -
an
28
1.
Local
In water
theory
waves
of space and time
each
cle
"drop
of water"
individually
similar movement
moves
in
a
cir-
thereby inducing (with delay) neighbouring drops. All these moving drops together form a wave (cf. Fig. 1.4.2) Since each drop is influenced by the neighbouring drops these time delays accumulate and the whole wave seems to move. If two different waves meet then (in a very rough approximation) they simply linearly superpose each other.13 This will result in a characteristic (and often complicated) pattern, the "interference pattern". In particular, this superposition will result in a much larger wave if both waves are synchronised and in the other extreme they may cancel, Diffraction experiments indicate that this crude picture qualitatively also applies to light for which, however, matters are mathematically simpler. Again using a very rough model, one may think of the electrical field E at each point as oscillating up and down with respect of a fixed direction. The influence of neighbouring points gives rise of to a wave as described above. The wave length \ is the distance between two consecutive maxima and very small. It specifies the colour of light. If two waves are superimposed then the result may be brighter if they are synchronised. In the other extreme, the waves may even cancel altogether if the setup is arranged such that maxima and minima (of the same size) are superimposed. In this case the result is darkness. (cf. Fig. 1.4.3). In order to explain the wave nature of light one used to believe that space is filled with a substance called "ether" which plays the same r6le as the water for the water waves. An important problem would then be a
a
small time
of
to determine the movement of the earth with
Fig.
1.4.2. A
respect
to the ether.
consisting of linked
os-
directionally dependent,
in
wave
cillations
Since the
velocity
of
light should
not be
the non-relativistic reference frame connected with the ether
a
flash of
light should propagate in concentric spheres (cf. Fig. 1.4.1). The corresponding picture in spacetime would be a cone. To be more precise, consider the non-relativistic reference frame of the ether, given by the pair (t, -r). Let o be the event at which the flash of light is emitted and For water waves, this linear superposition is in fact mation.
a
rather bad approxi-
1.4 Einstein's
1.4.3.
Fig.
Superposition of
special theory of relativity
29
waves
Future
light
Galileian
rela-
Fig.
1.4.4.
cone
and
tivity. The observer moving with spatial velocity V measures a
different centre
OV of the flash of light and therefore different radii di, d2 for its wave front
E,,
Ix
=
have
a
can
v
v
An
:
be
-r(x-o) 01 be the instant of time defined by o. We of A with spatial hyperspaces. Each vector f Eo+ttjtGR =
n
uniquely decomposed
-r(,U)
spatial velocity
6 describes the
respect to the
CO+
=
to
a
C-
0. A
light
ray which is sent out at
curve o,
+
reference frame fixed to the ether
future light
y
=
spatial and temporal components,
into
-r(v)t+V where
==
the
G
foliation
An
:
R(t + cl a
in A n
x .
flash of light
C
EO with
Hence with
corresponds
cone
IICI12_1(0)(,T(Y_O))2
=
Y_01 ))7-1(0) Y-0
I
7-
(Y X) -
-> 0 -
I
C + X-0 of fuspacetime. The fact that the field x --> C: with Galilei to transformations invariant not are cones respect light the would enable reference frame of the to one measure (cf. Fig. 1.4.4) earth with the of the the ether. This was movement to ether, Le, respect in
=
ture
(1852-1931) and Edward Williams Morley (1838-1923) (Michelson 1881), (Michelson and Morley 1887) in their famous interference experiment (cf. Figs. 1.4.5, 1.4.6). A light ray the aim of Albert Abraham Michelson
is
partially reflected
at
a
half silvered mirror H. The part of the
light
ray which is not reflected at H is reflected at a mirror M and then partially reflected at H before reaching the observer 0. The part of the ray
which is
immediately reflected at H is reflected by a mirror M' and then passes through H to arrive at the observer 0. The distance
(partially)
between M and H is 1 whereas the distance between H and M' is 1'. Both
light rays have the same intensity when they arrive at 0. Here they produce an interference pattern which allows to measure the difference
30
Local
1.
theory
of space and time
0
H
lamp
1
H,," H 11 H H11
lamp
M
H MMU
0
M/
M, MIMI
Fig. 1.4.5. Michelson-Morley experiment, at rest relative to the
Fig. Michelson-Morley experiment, moving relative to the 1.4.6.
ether
ether
of the distances which each of the fact that the
wave
light ray has travelled (Here one makes use lengths of visible light are extremely small
and that the superposition effect allows to measure the distance which a light ray has travelled at an accuracy of half a wave length). Since the
laboratory is relativity the
at rest with
HM and the
velocity of the earth. Let c (E R+ be the modulus of the light in the ether, Y be the velocity of the earth relative to
velocity
of the
the ether and
the
ct,
light ==
respect
first that HM
assume
ray will travel from H to
1 +
jjVjj,-1(0)tj.
the distance Ct2
:--=
1
-
The other part of the same
time back to
Y
(cf. Fig. 1.4.6).
in time tj and
7--
1
_
1/2
2
21/c 11,U112,r_,(O)IC2
+
cover
(1.4.9)
'
to M' and in
Jjyjj2_j(0)tj2.
gives
21'1c
2t'
are
interested in the time difference zAt
Since the number
I I 61 I
=
(1.4.10)
C2
(0)
We
The first part of the distance
cover
light ray travels in time t' from H H, thereby covering the distance
2ct' This
11
M,
earth, according to Galileian depend on the angle between
If it travels from M to H in time t2, it will jj'Ujj-r-1(O)t2- These equations imply
tl + t2
the
to the
interference pattern should
2t-
(tl + t2)
for both
paths.
is very small we only need to calculate the , (0) Ic time difference to second order in I JUj Jr 1 (0) 1c. -
1
-
At
=
tl + t2
-
2t'
2 ---
I
-
11
1
-
JjUjj2_1(0)1C2 Ir
-
C
1
11,6112
Ir
_I
(0) /C2
1.4 Einstein's
.j(jj,yjj2_j(0)/C2)j/ I 11,611 2(0) /C2
21+
2
C
special theory
of
relativity
31
j/
_
7'
-
-r
2
(_1
jj
j(jjyjj2_j(0)/C2 + jjjyjj2_j(0)/C2j Jjqj2_j(0)/C2
+
2
C
2
7'
2
(jj (_1 (jjUjj2_j(0)1C2) 1
+
C
+
2
jjUjj2_j(0)1C2j
T
1
11,U112 -1(0)
2JI
C
C2
C
1 + J1. This
zAZI1
2
(I jjUjj2_j(0)/C2)
X
where 1'
1 +
+
gives
a
A
C2
C
2
per
(
2JI
(0)
::Z
A
11,UI12_1(0)
displacement
C, At =
I 2
C
I +
wave
length
JJV112 2
C
21(o)
A of
)
-
depends crucially on the length difference accurately enough. In order to overcome this difficulty Michelson and Morley turned the whole setup by 7r/2 and It follows that the interference
51 which cannot be measured
measured the interference difference. For the rotated setup we must set 2t' ,At tj t2 and interchange 1, 1'. An analogous (but in the details =
-
-
slightly different)
C
zAZ_L
The relative
calculation
At
1 -Z
gives
jjqJ2_1 (0)
2(-61)
C2
C
7'
+
-
,
A
A
displacement depends
only
on
61
21
ljqJ2
A
C
C2
up to second order and is
given by AZ If
one
assumes
spectral
However,
;:
AZI,
that the
line with A
obtain AZ A
=
-zz
-
AZ_L
sun
5.461.
1(0) 2
1
-
1
rests relative to the
10-'Om and has I
ether,
experiments had
negative possible explanation of this negative outcome a
uses
21m then
0.4 which is well in the range which
all such
61) can
the
one
Hg
would
be observed.
outcome.
is that the earth rests
with respect to the ether. But the earth circles around the sun which itself rotates in our galaxy. Since in the course of the year the earth changes direction relative to these other
velocities, it is inconceivable velocity of the earth relative to the ether can be neglected. Another explanation would be that light moves like particles and that therefore Galileian relativity would apply to light as well. Since the light was from earth bound sources and the observations have been its
velocity
that all year round the
32
Local
1.
theory
of space and time
made
on earth, this assumption would explain the negative outcome of experiment. The Michelson-Morley experiment has therefore been
the
repeated using
light
again with negative results. Now one could starlight is reflected at mirrors fixed to the earth, the light reflected light should be viewed as being produced on the earth. This would explain even negative results for star light in the framework of Calileian relativity (Hasse 1995). While this explanation is conceivable, it would demand a new theory of reflection. It is much simpler to assume that the velocity of light is independent of the movement of its source. This is the traditional interpretation which we will adopt in this book. It has been given further support by many consequences of the resulting theory (for instance, the possibility of obtaining huge argue that
star
as soon
as
-
the
amounts of energy from nuclear fission and nuclear
fusion).
interpretation of the experiment of Michelson and Morley is in contradiction to Galilei's theory of relativity we have to reconsider the foundations of spacetime. In order to do so we start with our new Since
insight
our
about the nature of
future
light cones is an following we will chose c
=
2.99792458
light propagation,
invariant structure of units such that
c
i.e. that the set of
possible spacetime. Here and in the
(In
1.
=
the
SI-system,
one
has
108M/S.)
-
(Invariance of the future light cones). Spacetime can be identified with An together with an field of future light cones C C + x-o, X E An. Postulate 1.4.1
invariant
=
We start the
investigation of this postulate, by first determining all maps light cone structure invariant. To simplify the dischoose again a non-relativistic reference frame (-r, t) and de-
which leave this future cussion note
we
by (-) the induced projection
of Rn to
-r-
1
(0). Defining
the bilinear
form 770: Rn we can
C.,
=
x
Rn
R,
(u,v) i-4,q(u,v)
--F(u)-r(v)
=
ly
E
An
:
77(y-x, y-x)
light
cone
and
=
Cx-
0 and
C1
the past
Cx
y E
X
light
cone
transformation which leaves the field of the future
must also leave the field of
form qo is
a
light
Minkowski metric
as
cones x
-*
This
means
that there is
an
Cx
at
:
-r(y-x)
01.
It is clear that
x.
light
<
cones
invariant
invariant. The bilinear
defined below.
Definition 1.4.1. A Minkowski metric 77 is Rn with signature (-, +, ..., +).14 14
+
write
We call Cx the a
-4
a
constant bilinear
"orthonormal basis"
as
defined
form
directly
on
below.
1.4 Einstein's
Jeo,..., en-11 of R'
A basis
spect
to q
11,
E
a
if 77(eo, e,)
f 0,.
..,
n
-
=
is called
-60,, and i7(ej,
,q(u, v)
an
ej)
=
q (Lu, Lv) for
all u,
v E
now easy to find invariant. Let a E R
It is
a
all i, i E
a
tl,..
-,
re-
n
-
linear map L: Rn -- R' such that of all Lorentz transforma-
by O(n, 1).
class of maps which leave the light b G Rn, 0 E An, and 0: Rn
+ b. It is immediate that
cone
isomorphisms
are
of this
structure
Rn be
O(Cy)
n and that therefore the transformation 0 satisfies y E R requirement. The following theorem due to Alexandrov
that all
33
orthonormal. basis with
6ij for
\ 101,
aL(x-o)
=
relativity
Rn. The set
tion is the the Lorentz group and denoted
by O(x)
of
11.
A Lorentz transformation is =
special theory
CO(y) our
given
for all
invariance
(1950) implies
form.
special
be a bijective map such --+ Rn lightlike vectors, 77 (x y, x y) 0 and analogously for 0'. Then there 0 = > ?7(0(x)-O(y), O(x)-O(y)) exist an L E O(n, 1), an a E R \ 101, an 0 E A', and a b E Rn such that TP--TT]1 5 aL(x-o) + b for all x E An. O(x)
Theorem 1.4.1. Let that
0 and 0
map
n
> 3
lightlike
and
0:
Rn
vectors into
-
-
=
=
=
-
1
There
are
several
proofs of
this result. For
instance, Benz (1992)
that the theorem follows from the fundamental theorem of His
proof rests
on
Laguerre
ge-
who gave a particularly elegant affine results in geometry which have been given
ometry. We will follow Alexandrov
proof.
shows
(1975)
in Sect. 1.1.1.
0 and by Proof of Theoreml-4-1. Let y E Q,. Then 77(y-x,y-x) 0. The last equality implies assumption q(O(y)-O(x),O(y)-O(x)) 0(y) G Ck(x) and therefore that 0 maps generators of the light cone Cx into the light cone C,6(,,). Now assume that P is a two-plane which intersects C., in two genera1., tors lx lX. We will show that O(P) is also a two-plane. Since for any y 1,, and Py which is parallel to the cone C. intersects P in generators 1. 1',, (and similarly for y' E 1.,), P is ruled by two different families of parallel generators. Since 0 maps generators into generators O(P) must also be a surface with two different rulings and, by Theorem 1.1.2, be affinely equivalent to either a plane, a rotational hyperboloid, or a hyperbolic paraboloid. Each generator in P of one family intersects all generators of the other family. Since in a rotational hyperboloid the generators at opposite points of the circle c(s) lie in parallel planes, O(P) cannot be affinely equivalent to a rotational hyperboloid. To see that O(P) cannot be affinely equivalent to a hyperbolic paraboloid note that in a hyperbolic paraboloid all generators of a given family are parallel to a single 2-plane and that this property is affinely invariant. Consider 0(y) c 10(x) =
=
=
15
The
proof of this theorem requires the material presented proof is essential for the following.
The theorem but not its
in Sect. 1.1.2.
P. 34
34
1
Local
-
and fix any C,6(y) which
along lo(,,)
theory
of space and time
2-plane Q. Then there are exactly two generators 11, 12 Of are parallel to Q. If we now (parallely) translate the cone
we see
that the generators of the translated
cone
which
are
parallel to Q must also be parallel to 11 and 12. This implies that O(P) is generated by a family of parallel lines. Hence the hyperbolic paraboloid degenerates to a plane. We can now show that 0 is an affine map. Let 1 be any line and x E I and consider two different planes P1, P2 which contain 1 and intersect Q, \ fxJ. The intersections of these planes with Cx consist of two generators each. Then O(Pi) and O(P2) are also planes and their intersection 0(l) a line. It follows from Theorem 1.1.1 that 0 is affine. Since the property
?7(y-x,y-x)
0 is translation invariant is linear. Let t be
77(e,e) Then 0
=,q(ct, et) implies 0(e)) -77(0(t), 0(t))
0
=
be
=:>,q(O(y)-O(x),O(y)-O(x)) =
generality
-1 and let
n(e, t)
1,
=
0
77(t, t)
vector with
a
=
without loss of
we can
c
be
that
vector with
0.
=
(1.4.11) andtherefore
=
=:
assume
a
a,
n(o(e), 0(t))
=
Any vector v can Equations (1.4.11)
0.
decomposed into v v,c + vtt, where e satisfies and v, vt E R. We obtain q(o(v), 0(v)) aTI(v, v) which implies that 1 0 leaves the quadratic form associated with q invariant. But then it must also leave Tj invariant. I =
=
[I
p.
401 Definition 1.4.2. Let 77 be called Minkowski spacetime.
Minkowski metric.
a
The pair
(An, n)
is
Using orthonormal bases it is easy to see that all Minkowski spacetimes are isomorphic, i.e., we can speak of "the" Minkowski spacetime. In a Minkowski spacetime there is no designation of future and past.
(Observe that we needed the 1-form -F in order to define the future direction.) Observe that the set C,\ I ol consists of two connected components, say C0+ \ f ol and Co- \ f ol. We may now choose C (respectively, CO-) as the set of events in Q, to the future (respectively, past) of o (including o). Hence C0+ is the set of all events which can be reached by a light ray with
in
source
o.
By continuity, this
at any other event
x
E
An where
definition coincides with v
E Rn
(i) (ii)
a
w)
q (v,
> 0
or
we
vector
v
w)
can
E
< 0
w
alternatively Rn with
v)
for all
for all
==
(x-o)
=
w
G
E
C
< 0.
C
Then
we
w)
Observe that this
in the
< 0
> 0
for all
for all
define the future direction
q(v, v)
<
0. Since it is
Let
case
have
w)
and q (v,
and 77 (v,
C0+-
+
previous definition
our
vector with q (v,
either 71 (v,
Hence a
be
also determines the future direction
C.+
more
with vectors than with connected components of chooses this alternative definition.
light
CoCo-.
w G
w c
by singling
practical
out
to work
cones one
usually
1.4 Einstein's
ts an
all v, w E Given o
equivalence
Let
a
35
class
[v],
time orientation
setCo-
)5
relativity
[v].
E A is the set
is the
of
(A',,q) a Minkowski spacetime. A time orienta[v] of vectors in Rn such that 77(v, w) < 0 for
Definition 1.4.3. Let tion
special theory
==
we
future light cone at light cone
say that the
C f o + w E C,, q (w, v) :5 01 fo+w EQ, : 77(w,v) >01. :
=
be the invariance group of the
light
and the past
structure and P be
cone
the group of Poincar6 transformations, P fx --> L(x-o) + b : b c orientation Given 0 L an [v], we call P+ P+ n P Rn, 0 E An, E (m, 1) 1. =
=
the group of time orientation preserving Poincare transformations. The discussion above suggests to reduce the group )5 to a subgroup 73+ by asserting that the elements of 13+ map future light cones into future light cones.
(An, 77) JbE
Lemma 1.4.1. Let
J5+
entation. Then
Minkowski
a
b(C,+,)
=
=
spacetime and [v] a time CO+v)(0) I is a subgroup of
ori-
Proof. Clear. The
Lemma 1.4.2.
there is
only if there
is
R
transformation 0 is an element of P if and only if and a 0 E P such that 0 ao; 0 E )5+ if and E R+ \ 101 and a 0 E P+ such that 0 ao.
\ 101
an a
This follows
Proof. A
G
an a
=
=
directly
form Theorem 1.4.1.
it is conceivable that there exist other fundamental invariants
priori
of space and time which would restrict the group even further. We will now show that because of the validity of Euclidean geometry and the
principle
of Galileian
relativity
1.4.1. Fix
Proposition
1.3.1 this is not the
a non-
relativistic, inertial observer
and consider its associated Newton spacetime each
x
E A let
E
=
yE
An
:
case.
F(y-x)
=
(An, t,,r,
t
o
+ tt
(0)).
For
-->
01.
metricq which generates the light cones -* o + tt. as Further, this Minkowski by metric is unique up to a multiple. (ii) Let x cz An The map 0 E )5 restricted to the Euclidean space E.,, (., .),-,(0) is an isometry if and only if 0 E P.
(i)
There exists
a
Minkowski
the observer t
measured
.
(iii) Let P' be a subgroup of the Poincar6 group P such that E., there exists a 0 (a) for each Euclidean isometry 0: E with
(b) for
01
All
0
E
a
0
(E
P'
V),
each non-relativistic observer t
there is
(c)
=
E
P' with
O(o
+
R+t)
=
o' + tt' with
o' +
P' preserve the time orientation.
R+V,
77(t', V)
< 0
36
1. Local
Then P'
theory of
space and time
'P+.
=
Proof. (i):
The adapted Minkowski metric q is just given by q (u, v) Observe that T(w) -7-(u)-r(v) + -77(,T, w) for all W E Rn. (0) (ii): This follows directly form Lemma 1.4.2. (iii): We will first show that for any two different vectors eo, eo with -1 and 77(eo, e0 ) < 0 there is a Lorentz transfor71(eo, eo) q(eO, eO) mation L which leaves spanf eo, e'01 and its q-orthogonal complement spanf eo, e'01 Jf w E A : q(w, eo) q(w, eo) 01 invariant. There is a vector v c R' with 0. Since q (eo, v) we have eo I I eo + v and q (eo, v) 77(v, v) > 0 and the vector el vlV'rq(v, v) is well defined. By definition it satisfies 71(eo, el) 0 andq(el, el) 1. We complete the set of linearly vectors independent f eo, el I to an 77-orthonormal basis f eo, el, e,,,
=
=
-
=:
=
=
=
=
=
=
=
.
of R'. Let L be the Lorentz transformation defined
Leo
(eo
+
Lei
(el
+
v)1 1 JJvJJR_ JJVJJR`-180)1V1
.
.
7
by
2
eo)
-
IIVIIRI-
2 I
,and
ViEf2,...,nJ.
Lei=ei
It maps eo into eO and leaves the subspaces spanf t, 61 1, spanf eil (i E 2, ., n 11) invariant. This transformation is called a Lorentz boost. -
..
We will
now show that the group G generated by all Newton transformations with respect to the inertial frame (eo,,q(eo, .)) and all Poincar6 transformations 0 of the form O(x) o + L(x-o) where L is =
Lorentz boost coincides with the group P+ of time orientation preserving Poincar6 maps. It is clear that G is a subgroup of P+. To show the converse Let o, o' G An and f eo, two oren 1 1, f eo.... e'_lJ n thonormal bases with respect to q. We have to show that the Poincare a
.
transformation V) which maps i is
a
actly
into o' and
(respectively, e ) with 77 (6k 6k) -1) and 77(ek,t) -- 0 (respectively, 77(el,t)
vector ek
=
-
i
renumber the basis vectors such that ek let 01 be the map x -4 x + (o'-o). If eo tor
this
v
E
+ ei into o' + ei for all
o
of maps in JV and G. In each basis there is
composition
one
o
-
77(v, eo)
Rn with
let
be
=:
0, 0
<
71(v, v)
eo If eO Co then there is a veceo 1, and eO 11 eo + v. In
eO, el <
ex-
(respectively, < 0). We can
1
=
=
-
element of the Newton group with respect to non-relativistic inertial frame (eo, 77(eo, .)) which maps o to o' and el to case
v/JJvJJ,-i(o).
01
an
Consider the Poincar6 transformation
02(X)
==
o
+
L(x-o)
where L is Lorentzian boost which maps eo into eO and leaves the plane spanjeo,e'01 invariant. Observe that and
f (02) -1 (eo1)1 (02)
-
I
(ell
(02)
-1
(enl- 1)
are
both orthonormal
with respect to q and that
spanfol (el),
.
.
.
,
bl (e, 1) 1
=
spanf (02)
1
(02) _l(en'_l)J n
1.4 Einstein's
=
Hence there is element non- relativistic
Ix
:
special theory of relativity
71(x
o,
-
eo)
=
37
01.
of the Newton group with respect the to (e0,,q(eo, .)) which leaves o' invariant and
03
inertial frame
1 n 03 0 01 (ei) (02) _1(6s (i 1) This implies 0 02003001Finally we can show that P+ is the only subgroup of P which satisfies
satisfies
=
(a), (b), (c)
=
-
.
-E0, be unique transformation Op
Let
-
0: E0
Euclidean isometry. Then
an
P which leaves t invariant,
E
0 extends to a 0 (x) V) (X 0) + =
Hence the Newton group Ar is a sub-group of P'. Let o' E A' and let V be a vector with Since -F(t') I and
-
-F(x-o)t.
=
By assumption there is a 0 E P which satisfies 0(o + R+t) In particular, the associated Lorentz transformation maps We have
seen
above that there
(t, -r)
such that
are
Newton transformations
77(t', V) =
< 0.
o' + R+t'.
t into
R+V.
01, 03 with
V) 02 0 03 0 01 where a 02 is the Poincar6 corresponds to a Lorentz boost which maps t into R+ V and leaves the spaces spanf t, t'j, and its 77-orthogonal complement ' spanf t, V1 invariant. Hence 02 is the composition of maps provided by assumption (a) and (b). Since V was arbitrary we obtain that P' contains respect to
=
,
transformation that
all Lorentzian boosts and all elements of the Newton group associated I (t, -r). Consequently, P+ P.
with Let
=
(t, -r)
be
a non- relativistic
reference frame
and E, be
a
hyperspace
in
spacetime which represents an instant of time. If we assume the axioms of Euclidean geometry for E,, then, to be consistent, we have to assume that this structure is invariant with respect to any transformation which is an isomorphism of our physical structure. Hence (ii) of Proposition 1.4.1
implies that
we
must restrict to the Poincar6 group P. Preservation of
time orientation reduces this group to
P+. By Proposition
1.4.1
(iii),
the axioms of Euclidean geometry, and Postulate 1.3.1, the Poincar6 group cannot be further reduced. Hence we conclude that space and time
are
well described
by
a
Minkowski spacetime
together
with
a
time
orientation.
The
(arbitrary) non-relativistic inertial frame (t, -r) we have started -1. Recall that t was the velocity vector of the 77(t, t)
with satisfies
inertial observer t
=
+ tt who
was supposed to be at rest. Since the isomorphisms of Minkowski spacetime, any other inertial observer t 1-4 o'+ tt' who can be supposed to be at rest must be linked to t --> o + tt by a time orientation preserving Poincar6 transformation 0. If we denote the associated linear transformation by Lo then V E R+Lo(t) holds." In particular, all admissible observers V must satisfy 77(t, V) < 0. -->
o
Poincar6 transformations
16
Observe that t' not
are
the
0 Lp(t) in general since -r which preserved by Lorentz transformations.
is used to normalise t, is
1. Local
38
theory of
Definition 1.4.4. Let
(A',,q)
be
a
Minkowski 8pacetime with time ori-
[v].
entation
(i)
space and time
(special-relativistic) infinitesimal observer is a vector t E Rn -1, 77(v,t) < 0. 77(t,t) A (special-relativistic) observer is a curve -y: t (ii) -1(t) such that the velocity vector (t) is a special- relativistic infinitesimal observer A
with
=
-
for all
(iii)
t.
(special-relativistic)
A
tt E An where
x
inertial observer is
E A' and t is
a
a
curve
special- relativistic
-/: t
-4
x
+
infinitesimal
observer. For any special-relativistic infinitesimal observer t" E Rn and any any otl E An there is a time orientation preserving Poincare transformation
b which
maps t
1-4
o
+ tt to o" + tt" for all t.
The rest space with respect to (t, -r) at the event o E An coincides with Eo f x E An : 77(x-o, t) 01. Let 0 E P+ such that its associated =
=
Lorentz transformation maps t to V. Since 0 maps E into the set E' 01 this set must be interpreted as the rest space f x1 E An : q(x'-o', V) =
=
with respect to the special-relativistic inertial observer t --> o' + tt'. In general, this space does not coincide with the non-relativistic rest space
E,,,. Hence
we
arrive at the
Definition 1.4.5. Let t be
following a
definition.
special- relativistic infinitesimal
(i) The infinitesimal rest space with respect to 1W G Rn : 'q(t', W) 01 C Rn. (ii) The affine rest space containing o' E An given by o' + t" C An.
observer.
t is the set V
I :=
=
The affine rest space inherits the Euclidean scalar 71 (u, to
V) (v,
w
E
W) ')
with respect to t is
product (u, v)
-
Similarly, the time difference Att, (x, y) of two events x, y with respect the special-relativistic infinitesimal observer V is given by t where
(unique)
t E R is the
number such that
x
+ tt' lies in the affine rest space
of V whichcontains y. The original non-relativistic observer t
-->
o
+ tt is also
a
relativistic observer and for this observer the non-relativistic and
specialspecial-
relativistic definitions for rest space with associated Euclidean scalar product and time difference coincide. The relativity Postulate 1.3.1 im-
plies that for every other special-relativistic inertial observer o' + tt' and time differences lengths and angle should be measured by by Att, (-, -) In conclusion, a Minkowski spacetime together with a time orientation contain all the geometric information of spacetime. This geometric structure is mathematically simpler and more elegant than the structure -
of
a
Galilei
spacetime.
1.4 Einstein's
Remark
1.4-1. The geometric
(1909).
Minkowski
1905)
special theory of relativity
structure of
spacetime
But before him Albert Einstein
39
discovered
was
by
(1879-1955) (Einstein
had realised that absolute time does not exist and
came
to
an
equivalent but less elegant description of spacetime. His work contains the main physical discovery which justifies to speak of Einstein's special theory of relativity. An important precursor of Einstein was Hendrik Antoon Lorentz (1853-1928) whose explanation of the Michelson-Morley experiment anticipated the length contraction17. Causality
1.4.1
We start with
in
special relativity
terminology
some
(A',,q)
Definition 1.4.6. Let
(i)
which will be
justified below.
be the Minkowski spacetime.
A vector w is called
spacelike, if j7 (w, w) > 0, timelike if 77 (w, w) < 0. A vector w is called causal lightlike (or null) if 77(w, w) timelike or lightlike.
0, and
if
it is
(ii)
Let
==
[t]
directed
(iii)
A
be
a
time orientation. A causal vector
(past directed) if q (u, t)
<
0
u
is called future
-
spacelike (resp., timelike, lightlike (or null), causal, future directed, past directed) if all its velocity vectors are spacelike (resp., timelike, lightlike (or null), causal, future directed, past
Let
w
be
there is
curve
directed). a
an
vector and x, y E A' with y
x
and y
=
+
x
t, in particular, these
to
==
x
+
infinitesimal observer t such that
that the events
respect
-y is called
w
lie in the
events
are
w.
If
q(w, t)
same
w
is
=
spacelike then implies
0. This
affine rest space with at the same time
taking place
with t. Hence there cannot be any causal process which links vice
x
to y
or
versa.
On the other either
hand,
wlV-- (w, w)
definiteness
i--+
x
w
y-x is timelike and future directed then
=
-wIVI-77(w, w)
that
assume
inertial observer t
if
or
+t
wl _-,q(w, w W
-) 11 Vf___(W
is
an
infinitesimal observer. For
is in the time orientation. The
connects
x
with y. Hence the event
x
I
definitely place before the event y. This motivates definitions above (see also Postulate 8.0.1). must take
This discussion also as a
causal
Corollary
(i)
implies
that the field of light
(A', n)
be
cones x
our
1-4
causality Cx
serves
boundary. 1.4.1. Let
a
Minkowski spacetime.
of all events y E x which can be causally influenced by processes taking place at x are given by J+(x) := fy E An : y can be reached from x by a causal, future directed curvel.
17
His
The set
interpretation
was
different from
Einstein's, however.
40
Local
1.
theory of
0i) aj+(X) Above
have
we
space and time
C:.
=
that the most important
seen
ingredient
of
our
discussion
spacetime isomorphisms just preserving Poincar6 group P+. The of
is the fact that the
the elements of
are
the time orientation
main step to P+ is contained in Theorem 1.4.1 in connection with Postu-
arrive at
late 1.4.1. One may object that the constancy of the velocity of light is a rather awkward postulate. However, it is closely linked to the funda-
following theorem which has also been replace the light cone structure by (1975) fundamental postulate by the assumption of causality.
mental notion of in
our
Theorem 1.4.2. Let
An
0: causality:
Let
An be
_-,
and consider the Minkowski space (A',,q). bijective map such that 0 and 0' both respect
J+ (x)
* an
y E
allows to
> 3
n
a
Then there exist b E R' such that I
The
causality.
Alexandrov
obtained
O(x)
0(y)
J+ (O(x)) for all
E
0(n, 1), aL(x-o) +
L E
=
an a
b
R
E
for all
x, y E An.
\ 01,
an o
An, and
E
a
An.
E
x
p. 40
Proof. This theorem is a corollary to Theorem 1.4.1. We only have to lightlike vectors are mapped into lightlike vectors by 0 and
show that
We will first prove that for y E J+ (x), x 0 is equivalent to the assertion ,q(y-x,y-x)
4
Z1 i Z2 E
If
J+ (x)
q(y-x, y-x)
Clearly,
ray.
n J-
(y) =
we
any two
,q(x-y,x-y)
< 0
have either zi E J+ (Z2)
0 then
then
J+ (x)
points
on
J+(x)
It follows that U must contain
spacelike Now
vector we
holds. Since
w.
n
a
n J-
light
J-(y)
points
It is clear that z1
(y)
is
ray
p. 40 p.
Z2 E
part of an
Z1 i Z2 which
J+ (Z2) and
"for all
J+ (Zl) a
" -
single light
causally related.
are
contains
must also hold. But this is
,q(0(x)-0(y), OW-0(y))
[I
or
condition
:4=>
If
open set U C An.
are
Z2
connected via
J+ (Zl)
a
-
will prove the theorem. If x-y is lightlike then A (x, y) A(x, y) is formulated entirely in terms of causal relation-
ships, A(O(x), 0(y))
Analogously
a
y the
A(x,y)
=
equivalent =
to
0.
for
1
451
philosophically more appealing to demand causality than inlight cones but it should be noted that our original version to the actual experiments motivating special relativity.
It may be
variance of the is closer
1.4.2 Length contraction and time dilatation Since there
are no
absolute time
a
that
or
absolute space it should not come are observer-
in space and time- differences
lengths surprise dependent. To simplify notation at
let
JJwJJ
==
-\/ (_ww)
for any
spacelike
1.4 Einstein's
special theory
of
relativity
41
Fix an event x E A' and an infinitesimal observer t and conrod which rests in the affine rest space x + t 1 of t. If with respect to the observer its endpoints are given by x and x + f at a time to, then it will sweep out the subset vector
sider
w.
a
S
C:
z
A'
z
X
=
+ M +
/-tt, A
E
[0, 1],
E
RI
Lt
t'
Lt
K
O
Lei
Fig.
in
1.4.7.
Length
contraction
Fig.
1.4.8. Time dilatation
spacetime (cf. Fig. 1.4.7). We complete It, ei 111f Ii to an orthonorf t, ei, e,,- I I of A'. Now consider a second infinitesimal ob=
mal basis
.
t' who
.
.
,
(relative to t) with the velocity v II UII -ei. Let L be a Lorentz transformation which maps t into t' and leaves spanf t, el I invariant. We have V Lt _JIVI, Lei (ei + I I VII t) / _IVI (t + v) / I 12, server
moves
=
=
VIT
=
V-1
=
-
-
Vi E f 2,.. n Lei ei 11. The rest spaces relative to t' are all parallel to Ltj-. In order to determine the length of the rod with respect and
to t'
=
-
.,
we
must calculate the
S n
(x + Lt-L )
=
X
+
length
of
11 yllt..
ei + 01
F_
a .
,
G
[01 IV III
V
It follows that
observer t' is
one
11 'Il
=
of the
reasons
V/1
-
11,61
-
Iltll
<
11 11.
Hence the infinitesimal
shorter
length than t. This Lorentz contraction why initially many physicists found special general
measures a
relativity
hard to understand. It should be remarked that an investigation of 3-dimensional objects shows that the Lorentz contraction is more like
a
rotation. In
particular,
a
moving sphere looks like
a
sphere
at rest.
42
1.
Local
There is
spacetime,
a
a
theory of space and
time
similar effect with respect to time, the time dilatation. In
time interval At with T
(cf. Fig. 1.4.8).
=:
x + tt +
respect t G
a :
[0,./At], a
In order to calculate ,At'
Tn(x+RLt)=
x+t
t +
to t is
we
t-L I
t
V-1-11 m
,
set
must consider the subset
V
-
E
given by the
==
V-1--11,Y112
E
[0, /-At]
spacetime. It follows that At' J_-JJVTJAt < At. This is the for the twin "paradox": Consider two twins, one of them staying at home, the other one travelling with high velocity away, and then, after some years coming home. Afterwards the twin who had travelled will be younger. Let t be the infinitesimal observer associated with the first twin, t, be the infinitesimal observer of the second twin at her outward journey
of
=
reason
and t, be the infinitesimal observer of the second twin
journey. As
a
consequence of time
outset and return with
the time
respect
lapse with respect
to
dilatation, the travelling
during her return lapse between
the time
twin will be shorter then
to the twin at rest. Hence after her return
the twin who has travelled will be younger than the other one. If the time interval and the involved velocities are large enough the effect can
be
spectacular.
This effect is
purely geometrical and
ation. The fact that the situation is not
has nothing to do with accelercompletely symmetric, i.e. that
1A Einstein's
the twin who had travelled
changes
special theory of relativity
43
her direction and therefore is not
an
only
inertial observer is
needed to get her back but has nothing to do with the effect. To make this point clearer imagine that spacetime would
cylindrical. To be concrete, let y be an spacelike and consider the hyperspaces Fx be
and
Fy
=
Iz
EE
A
77(z-y, v)
:
=
01.
event such that =
f
E
z
These two
A
:
is
shown that
just the
locally
set M where
it is
(A',,q). (We will not chapter). If the twins
impossible
Fx and Fy
hyperspaces
she would
(by
y-x is =
01
enclose
assume
identified. It
to differentiate between
a
that
can
(M,,q)
be
and
prove this fact. It will become clear in the next
lived in
(M, 77)
instead of
travels would not need to turn back. As
Fx)
are
=
77(z-x, v)
M which is bounded in the direction of v. Now
region spacetime
v
identification)
(A',,q),
soon as
the sister who
she arrives at
Fy (or
be at the other
hyperspace and therefore on the other side of her sister. Just travelling on she would 2 then M is just an ordinary eventually meet her sister again. If n and visualise the whole it is to cylinder setup (cf. Fig. 1.4.10). easy our
=
t
Lt 0
Fig. 1.4.10. The twin paradox in a cylindrical universe
-1.4.3 Relativistic We give,
particles
and
photons
brief outline of the elementary concepts of photons, paranalogues have been introduced in the,section on the non-relativistic theory of particles (cf. p 20). The content of this section will be used to motivate definitions in Chap. 5. Part of the physical discussion in Chap. 6 also requires this section. a
ticles and their collisions. Their non-relativistic
The
following particle.
is the direct
analogue of Definition
1.2.3 for
a
non-relativistic
44
1.
theory of
Local
space and time
special-relativistic particle with mass m is a pair -1. The a curve satisfying (rn,,y) curve -y is called its world line in spacetime. A special-relativistic inertial particle is a particle -y which satisfies
Definition 1.4.7. A
where
=
m
c
R+ and -y is
0.
Unlike in the non-relativistic case, we have now only one law which covdenote the incoming and (m'., 7j')j=l... .11 ers collisions. Let 3 Then conservation of momentum is excollision. of a particles outgoing
pressed by
the
single equation k
Y mi" Yi
M/j'Y
_
(1.4.12)
i
j=1
i=1
Choose any infinitesimal observer t and denote the projection to the orthogonal complement of t by.: v -* Y. Then the momentum m splits into
spatial
and
temporal parts
follows:
as
(t
M M,Y
Conservation of the
momentum takes the form
spatial
Ek
1
Tni
Ej=l -1--71i 1 _F M
v
IN
"i 112 which is page 21.
a
+
-
3
(1.4.13)
ly
modified form of the non-relativistic conservation law
(ii)
on
conservation takes the form
Energy k Mi
-7
1
-
T,
M
i
VFIF___1 1 jll
(1.4.14)
j=1
Since
1
M
M
+
2
M11,6112
+
0(11,U112)
approximation the non-relativistic law of mass Eli m'i holds exactly we also equality I:ki= 1 mi
we recover as an
vation. If the an
=
approximation
conserrecover
of the conservation law for kinetic energy. The relaonly more transparent and
tivistic version of the conservation laws is not
economical,
it also leads to
Example 1.4.1. tains helium
If
one
important applications:
bombards lithium 7Li with
2He according
to the nuclear reaction
111 +7 Li
--
22He
+ energy.
hydrogen 'H
one
ob-
1.4 Eiristein's
special theory
of
relativity
45
The weights of 1 mol (i.e, 6.02213 1023) atoms of hydrogen (respectively, lithium, helium) are 1, 00783g (respectively, 7.01601g, 4,00260g). It follows that the final product is lighter by about 0, 01864g/mol hydrogen atoms. According to the energy conservation theorem above, this mass difference corresponds to the energy E Pz 1, 864 10-5kg C2 ';Z: 1.67525 1012j. This energy is huge in 1, 864 (2.9979) 10" m kg/s comparison to the amount of material involved. The energy amount of an adult is about 8000 U per day or 2920000 U per year. It follows that 1.67525 .1012j would last a human being for more than 500 years. -
-
-
-
-
-
Observe that the amount of energy which can be obtained from nuclear huge because the velocity of light c is extremely large. In this
fusion is
book
we
chose natural units where
These units
are
appropriate
a
length
unit is defined
to discuss relativistic effects
level but obscure the fact that velocities in with respect to
as
c-time unit.
on a
everyday live
theoretical
are
negligible
c.
photon is (classically) characterised by its velocity and its frequency. hil elementary quantum mechanics one has the relationship E 6.62608 .10-34j S is the Planck constant and v the frequency where h A
From
=
=
photon. These quantities uniquely determine the momentum p of hv be the energy photon. Let t be an infinitesimal observer and E of the photon as measured by t. If 6 is the spatial velocity of the photon relative to t then its momentum is completely determined and given by E(t +,6111cll). Any other infinitesimal observer -C measures the light p -,q(t',p)1h. The frequency of visible light light ranges frequency v' of the
the
=
==
=
from about 4
-
1 014 oscillations
oscillations per second
(ultra
per second
violet
light).
(infra
red
light)
to 8
-
1014M
[p. I
40
11
p. 47
Analysis
2.
on
manifolds
can
minimal amount the reader should know in order to pass
on
[I
to the
chapter is 1. The definition of manifolds: Sect. 2.1 up to Sect. 2.1.1; 2. The tangent bundle: Sect. 2.2; 3. Tensors and tensor fields: Sect. 2.3 up to including Definition 2.3.7, Sect. 2.3.2; 4. Connections: Sect. 2.6 up to including Definition 2.6.2; 5. Examples of connections: Sect. 2.7.
next
There is
a
conceptional problem with
the
theory developed
so
far. From
local experiments we implicitly extrapolated a structure of spacetime which has only been tested in a small part of the small spacetime region our
which is inhabitated
only
by human beings. The Michelson Morley experiment spacetime is nowadays a good description
indicates that Minkowski
of the
spacetime
structure of
a
(comparatively small)
oratory. A weak form of the philosophical guide in the margins analysis on manifolds.
The
assumes
M. Kriele: LNPm 59, pp. 47 - 149, 1999 © Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 1999
earth-bound lab-
Copernican principle
that the reader has
no
states
knowledge
J4]
p. 45 p -1
only be expected to be a good description locally. We will assume that special relativity is an exact "infinitesimal" description, i.e. that it holds as a first order approximation near any given point. A rigorous formulation of this idea requires manifolds and tensor fields which will be introduced in this chapter. This chapter contains much more material than is necessary for the understanding of the following Chap. 3. While in an ideal world, all this material would be standard knowledge of mathematicians and theoretical physicists, we give a self-contained treatment for those readers who still have to learn about analysis on manifolds. We will be a little more general than necessary. Instead of using the field R we will develop the theory for both fields R and C and write K if a statement is valid in both cases. This generality is not needed for the main purpose of the book, i.e., for presenting the theory of spacetime. However, both physicists who go on to study gauge theory and mathematicians who are interested in differential geometry as a mathematical discipline will benefit from this generality. It is also instructive to see which concepts depend on the real structure. Writing K instead of R if possible will not introduce any additional difficulty. While everything presented here will be used somewhere in the book, readers primarily interested in space and time may want to skip material where possible and come back later to it when needed. The
Special relativity
of
P. p.
1
1554]
48
2.
that
our
Analysis
nianifolds
on
position in spacetime is in no way special. In particular, at any spacetime one would observe the same physical laws. Nat-
other event in
ural sciences which go impossible without
be
beyond the mere cataloging of phenomena would adopting this principle. Hence we feel justified to
extrapolate that every event in the universe has
a
time structure is well described
by
We will
see
that this
neighbourhood
whose space-
Minkowski spacetime.
extrapolation is very different from the naive posglobally the structure of a Minkowski space-
tulate that the universe has time.
As
a
first step
we
will have to find out how to connect
our
local
Minkowski spacetimes. To give a simple example which exhibits part of the problem consider the torus T’ which can be obtained from A’ via the identification is
a
c- Z, x E A’, where feiliE 1_-,nj equip Tn in a natural way with a induced by An. While locally there is no possibility to
x
-
x
+ aei for all
fixed standard basis of R1. We
Minkowski metric
(Tn’ 77) (cf. Fig. 2.0.1).
differentiate between different
and
a
can
(A’, 77),
both spaces
Fig.
We will
are
globally
2.0.1. The torus T
very
2
develop the mathematical techniques needed to globalise given by our collection of Minkowski spacetimes. First note that we cannot even expect that locally Minkowski spacetime is an exact description. But it is reasonable to expect that Minkowski spacetime is the better an approximation the smaller the subset of events we are considering.is. This means that we will have to formulate the theory infinitesimally. In Sect. 2.1 we will generalise (part of) the structure of A’ to manifolds which may be thought of as a collection of local A’s. We will now
the structure
then construct tangent spaces to approximations of it (Sect. 2.2).
a
manifold which
are
the infinitesimal
2.1 Manifolds In this section
we
will localise part
foundation for calculus.
of the
structure
of A
and
lay
the
2.1 Manifolds
by
One of the most important structures of R’ is given
49
the collection
of all open subsets, because this collection is needed when one defines limits, the most basic notion of analysis. Since A’ can be thought of as
special properties of the vector 0 been forgotten about there straightforward way to define open sets in A’. The subset U C A’ is C R’ such open if and only if there is a point o E A and an open set R’ with the is
a
thatU=fo+v: vE0J. We will
localise the
now
topological
the structure of A’ which tells
collection
of
r
The collection T
7-
A’, i.e., the part are
of
open.
subsets
(i) 0 E r, M E 7-; (ii) U, V c- r =* U n V E -r; (iii) if A is an index set and Ua U E
structure of
which subsets of An
topological space (M, -F) is a set M together with of M which satisfies the following properties.
Definition 2. 1. 1. A a
us
is called the
and is closed
apointxEM if
if
M
\U
E
-F
for each a
topology of G -F.
E
A then
UaEA Ua
G 7--
M. A set U C M is open
A set V C M is
a
if neighbourhood of
there is anUE-r withxEUCV.
It is clear that the collection of open sets of Kn
(i)-(iii)
(and therefore
also of An)
justifies the definition of a topological space. On the other hand, a general topological space may have properties which are quite pathological. This can be seen from the following two extremal examples. Let M be any set and define -rfine to be the set of all subsets of M and ’Tcoarse f 0, MI. Then A Tfine) and (MiTcoarse) are topological spaces. Definitions which can be stated purely in terms of open sets carry over to topological spaces. satisfies properties
Definition 2.1.2. Let
of Definition 2. 1. 1. This
(M,,T) and(M, fl
be
topological
spaces.
f : M --+ 1 1 is called continuous if f (1 ) E 7 for all bijective, continuous map whose inverse is also continuous is called a homeomorphism. (ii) A subset U C M is compact if for every collection of sets WaIaEA with Ua E T and U C UaEA Ua there are finitely many U,,(1), Ua(k)
(i2
A map
-
1
U E T. A
.
withUc
(iii)
A
.
.
uki=AW(M, -r)
is connected if U, V E -r with U n V 0 or necessarily of the form U M, V V 0. For the topological spaces we are interested in M, U (cf. Definition 2.1.4 below) this is equivalent to the requirement that M. any two points can be connected by a continuous curve [0, 1] A collection subsets basis the is a of open of topology WaJaEA (iv) V* -r if for every open set V there is a subset B C A with UbEB Ub
topological
0 and U
U
V
space
M
are
=
=
=
--->
=
50
2.
(p)
Analysis
on
manifolds
where t! is the closure if V of U, i.e., the smallest closed set containing U. (vi) A collection of open subsets fUa’jae_-A is a sub-basis if all finite intersections of sets U,,, form a basis of the topology -r. A subset U C V is called dense
Lemma 2.1.1. Let M be
a set and jUaja(EA be any collection of subM. Then there is uniquely defined of M which satisfies UaEA Ua topology -r of M such that jUafaEA together with the empty set 0 are a sub-basis of T.
sets
=
I
Proof.
This follows
immediately
from the definition of
a
I
topology.
We
can now describe those topological spaces which cannot be locally distinguished from A’. Let (M, T) be a topological space which is Hausdorff, i.e has the property that for any two different points x, y E M there are neighbourhoods U of x, V of y which satisfy U n V 0. The topological space (M,,r) is locally indistinguishable from A’ (considered as a topological space) if each x E M has an open neighbourhood U such that there is a homeomorphism W: U -* V c R’. 2 The pair (U, o) is called a topological chart of M. Since for each open subset 1 C U the restriction of o to 1 is also a homeomorphism onto its image, we have =
the
following compatibility property. Let
(U, W)
and
0. Then the
(1 , 3)
map
be o
topological charts
p(U)
p-:
n
( (a)
of
(M, -r) with UnO p(U) n ( (a) is
--+
a
homeomorphism. We would like to have not a
structure which allows
there is not
an
only
a
topological
structure
on
M but also
the tools of
analysis. Unfortunately, independent definition of a "differentiable space" which the definition of a topological space. To get an idea how us
to
use
analogous to this difficulty can be overcome we can view the charts (U, W) as a way to induce the local topological structure of R’ on M. To be more precise, let M be any set, WiliEl be a set of subsets of M with Uj, Ui c-I M, and pj: Uj > Vi bijective maps onto open subsets of R’. We can now attempt to define a topology on M by using the sets f oj-’(Wj) : Wj C Uj is openj as a sub-basis for the topology of M. In order to get a topology consistent with a local description we have now also to demand the compatibility property above. Still, the resulting topological space could fail to be Hausdorff (cf. Fig. 2. 1. 1). Since this is a local property, we will demand it in addition. We have now defined a topological structure on M which is locally indistinguishable from the topological structure of is
R1. This definition
2
can
be carried
Recall from the definition of the x --+ x
-
o
is
a
homeomorphism.
over
to the differentiable structure.
topology
of A’ that the map
V),:
X,
--+
R,
Manifolds
2.1
Fig.
identify
51
A topological space locally homeomorphic to
2.1-1.
which is
R but fails to be Hausdorff
Definition 2.1.3. Let I be
(i
c
index set and
an
A Ck-atlas of M is
which is
a Hausdorff. 1) of local homeornorphisms such that
(M,,r)
be
collection
(i) each Uj is open and connected,’ (ii) each x E M is is contained in some Uj, (iii) for each i, j with Uj n Uj V - 0 the map oj (Uj n Uj) is a Ck -diffeomorphism.
oj
o
a
topological Uj
oj:
oj
C
M
oj (Uj n
:
space
-4
Kn
Uj)
pairs (Uj, pj) are called charts of M. A chart (Uj, oj) is centered at 0. Two charts A Oa) (a if x E Uj and Wi (x) 1, 2) are called compatible if they satisfy the compatibility condition (iii). Two atlasses are compatible if each pair of charts in their union is compatible. A Ck_ atlas A is called maximal if any Ck -atlas containing A coincides with The
x
E M
=
=
7
A. Remark 2. 1. 1. In the
erty that Wi
(Wj)-1
case
K
=
Ck -atlas (k
C every
>
1)
has the prop-
analytic, i.e., is locally given by its Taylor series. This follows immediately from the fact that C-differentiable functions are analytic. o
For technical
reasons
ogy of M has
a
(cf.
Sect.
2.1.2)
we
countable basis. This
fVjjjeN
many sets
is
will also demand that the means
that there
are
topolcountably
such that any open set VV is the union of sets Vi.
(M, -r) be a connected topological space which is Hausdorff and which has a countable basis. (M, -r) together with a maximal Ck -atlas is called a Ck -manifold. A C’-manifold is also called We will often refer to smooth manifolds simply as a smooth manifold.
Definition 2.1.4. Let
manifolds. A subset N C M is x
E
N there is
W(U)
n
ly
K’
E
submanifold
a
is
Observe that
a
manifold of M
chart :
an
m-dimensional submanifold
(U, W) of M
y’+’
often called
=
a
centered at
x
y’ 01. An (n hypersurface. ...
subset N C M
=
can
=
be
a
of M if for -
each
W(N n U) l)-dimensional
such that
manifold without
=
being
a
sub-
(cf. Fig. 2.1.2).
The
following lemma guarantees that a manifold is determined by any (not necessarily maximal) Ck -atlas (k > 1) which is compatible with the given maximal Ck -atlas. In practice, it is therefore sufficient to work with any
given atlas. It
can
be shown
(Hirsch 1976)
that any maximal
52
Analysis
2.
Ck -atlas
contains
manifolds
on
Fig.
2.1.2. A manifold M c R 2which is
not
submanifold of R2
a
subatlas which is C’. Hence for most questions it
a
generality to consider only smooth (i.e., C"O) manifolds.’ On the other hand, it should be noted that Co-manifolds are really more general. We will not consider such manifolds in this book. is
no
loss of
Lemma 2.1.2. Let A be
Ck -atlas. Then there
a
is
a
unique, maximal
Ck -atlas containing A.
Proof. Let
B be the set of
chart in A. are
Clearly, compatible. To see
with set
x
E
01 (U
Ck -charts which
A C B.
this let
U. Then the maps o o n V, n V2). It follows
Ck. That 01
0
-1
(02)
is
Ck
are
compatible which each
(Vi, 01) and (V2, b2) in B x G V, n V2 and (U, o) be a chart in A (0j)-1 and 02 (p-1 are Ck in the open by composition that 02 (01) -1 is also
Any
two charts
o
0
be shown in the
can
to prove that B is maximal and
same
way. It remains
unique. The first assertion follows from
the definition of B. Assume that B’ is another atlas every chart of B’ is
B
by the definition
as
well.
compatible with each
chart of
containing A. Since A, it must belong to
of B. Hence B’ C B and the second assertion follows
I
Example 2.1.1. Consider the cylinder which can be obtained by identifying opposite sides of the rectangle [a,, bi] x (a2, b2)
f (a,, y) As charts
we can
x
It
can
a
:
y c
good
-
x
-
-
(b2
(a2, b2)
al
x
2
-
a2), Y)
-4R
[a2, b211
for
x
for
x
<
(a2, b2) bj bj
--
R
2
2al 2al
2
(X,Y).
in fact be shown that there is
it is not
I (bi, y)
bi
(a2, b2))
(x
(al, bl) (x1y)
3
-
(x, Y)
(XI Y 02:
[a2, b211
take the maps
([a,, bij
oj:
y (E
:
idea to restrict to
important technical tools do
always an analytic subatlas. However, analytic atlasses because then some
not work
(cf.
Sect.
2.1.2.)
2.1 Manifolds
Consider
edges
(long) rectangular strip
a
of paper. The two shorter in two ways. Either one obtains
be
53
opposite
glued together a cylinder (cf. Example 2. 1. 1) or a figure which looks like a cylinder with a twist. This Wbius band can mathematically be constructed as follows (cf. Fig. 2.1.3). can
identify Fig.
2.1.3. The construction of
Example
(-2a, 0)
with
a
flip
M6bius band
(M6bius band). Let V, (0, 2a) x (-b, b) C R 2 and V2 (-b, b) C R 2. We define on VI U V2 an equivalence relation
2.1.2 x
=
=
-
by I
(X ,x2)_(Xl
(X1, X2)_(Xl
-
3a, X2)
if
_X2)
if
a,
-
Wi
=
U
V2
-*
(ir_1)IUi (i
E
on
(a, 2 a)
E
(0, a)
x
x
(- b, b),
(- b, b)
=
=
11, 21).
Since manifolds have tiable maps
C
by M (Vi U V2)/-. Denote the canonical proI M, (x ,x2) -, [(XI, X2 )] by,7r and let Ui ir-’(Vi),
and the manifold M
jection V,
(XI, X2) (XI, X2)
a
Then
J(Ul, 01), (42, W2)J
differentiable structure
we
is
an
can
atlas of M.
define differen-
manifolds.
M, N be C1 -manifolds and k < 1. A map f : M Ck -differentiable if for every two charts A, Oa), (Vb, Ob) of M, N the composed map Ob 0 f 0 (W)- I is a Ck -map. A C’ -differentiable map is called smooth. The set of all Ck -differentiable maps from M to N is denoted by Ck (M, N).
Definition 2.1.5. Let N is
for Oa
The maps g: M every chart Pa, o
g: Km
--+
maps from M Ck (K-, M).
Kn
-+
--->
M
are
Ck -differentiable if
K’ and composed maps 9 (Wa)- I: K’ Ck -differentiable. The set of all Ck -differentiable
Oa)
are
K’ and h: K’ the
to K’ and
from
0
K’ to M
are
denoted
--
by
Ck(M, KI)
and
54
Analysis
2.
It is easy to
see
manifolds
that this definition is satisfied if
atlas. For N
given
to any
on
=
K’,
M
=
f
Ck with respect
is
K’, the definition coincides with
the usual definition of
differentiability in elementary analysis. Recall from analysis that a continuously differentiable map F: K’ Km has rank r at x E K’ if the subspace DF(x)K’ C K’ has the dimension Let
r.
Nbea Ck -differentiable map and x G M. If (Ul ol), x and (Viol), (V2) 02) charts centered at
f:M--
(421 W2) f(x), then the rankof the mapsolof oWl-1 at Vl(x) andV)20fo 02_ I at (P2(X) coincide. We can therefore speak of the rank of f at x and the charts centered at
are
following definition
is
independent
Definition 2.1.6. Let M. Let
(U, W)
be
(any)
of N centered
chart
(i) (ii)
has rank is
W(x),
(iii)
is
is
at
an
local
if 0
f: a
Proof
Since
o
if D(o
map and
(V, 0)
be
x
E
(any)
f
f o W-’ has rank r if D(o o f o W-1) is x
and
x
o
f
o
p(x),
at an
o-’)
injective linear
is
a
map
surjective linear
local
at
x
if D(o
o
f
o
o-’)
is
a
bijective
-+
r
at y.
immersion (respectively, a submersion, x) then it is also an immersion (respectively, diffeomorphism) at any y E W.
diffeomorphism a
The map
x
Ck -differentiable
N be a Ck -differentiable map of rank r at neighbourhood W of x such that for each y E W
M
the map f has rank ry > In particular, if f is
submersion,
of
a
M centered at
diffeomorphism
M. Then there is
local
N be
o(x).
Lemma 2.1.3. Let E
x
---*
W(x),
linear map at
x
f (x).
submersion at
an
map at at
(iv)
r
at
M
chart
immersion at
an
at
f:
of the chosen charts.
an
at
D(oof oW-1)
is continous the existence of r
a a
linearly indepen-
dent vectors in D (o o f o o- 1) (,p(x))Kn implies that for y close enough to x there are also r linearly independent vectors in (DO o f o r 1) (,P(y))Kn. Hence the rank of f cannot fall in
a sufficiently small neighbourhood of given point. For the second statement observe that immersions, suband local diffeomorphisms all have maximal rank. p. 47 11 _ZT-11 mersions, F a
I
p. 61
2.1.1 Construction of manifolds
plays a fundamental r6le from infinitesimal assumptions. In this section we show that the inverse function theorem and also similar theorems carry over to manifolds. A special case (Proposition 2.1.1) allows a construction of submanifolds without specifying
In
analysis,
the inverse
function
theorem
because it allows to draw local conclusions
an
Atlas.
2.1
Manifolds
55
We will
who is not
skip this The
occasionally use the results of this section. But the reader primarily interested in analysis on manifolds is advised to
section and to return to it when needed.
following lemma
is
a
consequence of the inverse function theorem.
Lemma 2.1.4. Let U C a
Kn, V C K’ be oPen, x E U, and f : continuous, differentiable map with constant rank r in U.
U
--
V be
Then there exist
(i) an open neigbourhood 0 C U of x, (ii) a homeomorphism 0: 0 f y E Kn : I y I < 11, (iii) an open neighbourhood V D f (U) of f (x), (iv) and a homeomorphism 0: Iz c KI : IzI < 11 -->
such that
f
=
Oop, oo where
MY’,-
ly n)
-4
f)
(yi.... Y" 0’...’ 0).
=
I
Proof. Let E be the (n r)-dimensional vector space E Iv Cz Kn Df (x)v 01 and F C Kn be an r-dimensional vector space with Kn =
-
=
f e,+,,. enj be a basis of E and f el,. ..’ e,j be a basis of F. 4 For each y C Kn let A’(y) be the ith component of y with respect to the e basis f el, The vectors r 1) are a basis fi Df (x) ej (i E f 1, , en 1. E(DF. Let
.
.
=
.
of the r-dimensional vector space Df (x)Kn C K’. We choose linearly is a basis of K". independent vectors f,+l.... f, such that f fl, , f,,, I .
For
z
E K’
let
y’f (z)
.
.
be the ith component of
z
with respect to this
basis. We define
A’f (Z)
0
0
A (Y)
+I(Y)
E
,(Z)
Kn,
1-tf (Z)
f0
=
An (Y)
E
Kn.
0
e
The map g: U
-4
IK’,
continuously differentiable
is
by
y
and
-4
[t
o
Dg(x):
the inverse function theorem there is
f (y) Kn a
+ A (y) -4
Kn is invertible. Hence
neighbourhood 0
such that g is a diffeomorphism from 1 onto the open set is an c > 0 such that B,(x) := Iz E Kn : Iz g(x)l < Ej C define g -’(B, (x)) and the bijective map
c U
g(Z ).
-
U
---
BI (0)
C
Kn’
Y
(g (Y)
This numeration of basis vectors of E 8 F may more practical later on in the proof.
prove to be
-
of
x
There
g(U).
We
g (x)).
seem
slightly
odd but will
Analysis
2.
56
The rank of for all y
for all
are
now
F
E
v
--4
K’ (D
f01
v
101
o
=
=
Df (y)F be
show that the map h
y’+’,..., yn. We write K’ Kn. Since f (y) hQ it f (y)
E
K’ E) K‘
C
r
f
o
0-1
Kn
the inverse to the
ED
-!A(y)
depend
does not
Kr E) K‘ and
variables any
=
is
Let vy: Kr E)
bijective.
both
implies that dim(Df (y)Kn) bijective for all y E U and Dg(y)(v) the maps Df (y): F -+ Df (y)F and U which
on
Dg(y)
Df (y)F
/-t:
latter map. We will
manifolds
is constant
U. Since
E
I-t(Df (y)v)
f
on
-
Iu
o
v
=
f (x)
the
on
V1 (D V2 for
!A(x))
(D
we
have
eDf(y)v
Djhj-!,Aof(Y)ED-,!A(Y)--! PO f (x) E) + D2h, ittof (y)(3)-i cx(y) vy
p
o
o
Df (y)
Av
=
ay
o
/-t
o
Df (y)v,
evy
-
Djhj-,!,UOf(Y)(D-,1A(Y)--! tto f (x) E)
is invertible and A maps K’ onto
to show that ay
only
=
0 in order to prove
D2h
=
-1 A (x) ,
f 0 j Kn-r
0. For
E
v
F
0. The map 0 and and therefore ay o ft o Df (y)v coincided on F with Dg(y) and is therefore bijective. In particular,
A(v)
have
pol)f /-t o Df F
==
Since can
--+
y
,,pof (y)E)!A(y)
Since y have
we we
101 -4K’,
Df (y)v
Av.
o
given by
where ay is the linear map
ay: Kr ED
o
o
equation implies
into this
D2h,.I,,Of (Y)E)i,\(Y)- i./,Of(x)E)iL,\(x)
P
-i.\(x)
-1
c
Inserting Df (y)
0
A (x)
write
We
=
=
101
Kr
we
which is the domain of 7y. Hence ay vanishes. h(y) does not depend on yr+1.... yn
have proven that
h(yi)
identify
instead of
h(yi
(D
Y2)-
K’ with Kr ED K’
r
and write
w
W1 E) W3.
=
be the canonical basis of K‘ and let
jbj,...,b,-rj spanjfr+j,...,f,,j We define the map
V): B, (0) This
C
be the linear map which is defined
-r:
K‘
by -r(bi)
=
0 by
K’
--4
K’
ZI ED Z3
-’
h(ZI
+ A (f (X))) +
’T
(Z3)
-
implies 0
Pr
0
O(Y)
-=
0
0
=
V)
0
=
-0 E
Pr( g(Y)
g(x))
Pr(1P
-IP
0
Pr(P
we
0
f (Y)
0
f (Y)
-
A
0
0
fW
f (X))
+
1A (Y) -1AW)
Let --,
fi.
=
-
6
h(/,t
o
f (y)
-
p
o
f (x)
+
A(f (x)))
57
Manifolds
2.1
=
-
f
h(I-c
o
f (y)). -
projection of tt to the span of the first r canonical basis 0 h o tt. Equation D2h by A. Then we have h o 0 0 0 (Y) h in which turn f IP (Y) gives Pr ( 1 A (f (y))) implies f (y) We still have to show that V) is a homeomorphism. But this follows I since both h and T are homeomorphisms.
Denote the
vectors of K’
=
=
Corollary 2.1.1. Let Mbe an n-dimensional, N be an m-dimensional N be a Ck -differentiable map which has conCk -manifold, and f : M stant rank in a neighbourhood of x E M. Then there exist charts (U, v), (V, 0) centered at x, f (x) such that W(x) 0, O(f (x)) 0, and --
=
=
0
0
f
0-
-
1
:
Kn
(xi
Km’
_
I ....
Xn)
F
---
(XII
...
I
xr, 01
...
10).
Proposition 2.1.1. Let Mbe an n-dimensional, N bean m-dimensional N be a Ck -differentiable map which has conCk -manifold, and f : M stant rank in a neighbourhood of x E M. Let y E f (M). Then the set f -’(y) is a closed (n r) -dimensional submanifold of M. -4
-
Proof.
Let
E
x
f
(y)
and take charts
as
given by Corollary
2. 1. 1. Then
have
we
p(U
n
f -1(y))
=
=
The assertion follows
p(U) o(U)
directly
n n
(0 fz
o
f
o
c- K
n
V-’)-’(O) :
ZI
=
...
=
Z’
from the Definition 2.1.4 of
=
a
01.
submanifold. I
Proposition
2.1.1 is
a
powerful
tool which is used to construct manifolds.
R, x i--> IX12. Example 2.1.3. Consider the submersion f: R’ \ 101 M which O,in radius of > the that sphere p Proposition 2.1.1 implies -I of submanifold is coincides with the set f (p2) an (n I)-dimensional of atlas down an write himself herto for reader or R’. The directly try -+
-
the
sphere
of radius p. It is much
2.1.2 Partition of
more
work.
unity
we provide a method of localisation using functions practical if one wants to define a global object using charts. The prime example is the definition of integration in Sect. 2.5.4. This R. method works only for real manifolds: K This subsection is somewhat technical. The reader may therefore want to skim (or skip) this section on first reading and to return to its proofs when the results of this section are needed.
In this section
which is
=
58
Analysis
2.
manifolels,
on
The aim of this section is to construct
an
atlas and for each chart
a
function with support in this chart such that
(i) (ii)
point there
at any
the
sum
only finitely
are
We start with two
)lVi
)1Vj+j
C
Proof. all
sequence
a
of
jUjjjErj
Let
a
manifold. If
f)/Vilic-N
open sets
UiEN)/Vi
and
many charts which intersect
by (i)) equals
is well defined
I.
topological lemmas.
Lemma 2.1.5. Let M be exists
(which
of all functions
be
a
"::
M is not compact then there
with compact closure such that
M’
countable basis of the
topology of
M such that
Rj- are
compact. Let W1 := U1. Since the closure of this set is compact there is a k, E N with Wj- C Uk, Uj =:: VV2. We proceed now by ini= 1 duction.
Assume,
we
Ui. Then there
have is
already constructed )/Vj, kp+l > kp such that WP C-
a
.
_
Lemma 2.1.6. Let M be cover
all
of M.
.
a
manifold. And lualaEA
Then there exists
a
.
,
)IV,,
Uk,,+l j=1
where
Ui
)/Vp )/VP
be open sets which
jVjjjEN of open
countable collection
sets such that
(i) each Vj lies in some Ua and has compact closure, (ii) each Vj intersects only finitely many Vi. ("’) M Uj E N Vj’ ::-::
Proof. We will first show that countable. Let 0
=
I Oi IiErq
be
a
we
atlas of M. For each Vc there
an
that
Vc
U Zj Oi,,.
=
Let Oi be
index
c(j)
can
restrict to the
countable basis and let are
countably
Since 0 is countable
so
many sets
is the set
that A is
case
f (V,, Oc) I cc- c Oi,,
E
be
0 such
j0j,cjjEN,cEc
C 0.
of these sets and choose for each j C N an E C with Oi c V,(j). Then the collection j(0j, wc(j))IjEN is a a
re-numbering
countable atlas of M. Since Oi is
homeomorphic
to Kn there is for each
dense sequence fXi,j IiEN of points in 0j. For each (i, j) C N x N let a(i, j (E A) be an index with xi,j E Uqjj). Then the countable subset fUa(ij)jijEN Of fualaEA covers all of M. It follows that we can assume
j
a
without loss of Let Wo
=
generality
in Lemma 2.1.5.
by finitely
Ual, (k) N
x
n
many
O/ViliEri be the sequence of sets constructed The set )lVk+l \ Wk is compact and can be covered Ual(k), Ua.,,,(,,) (k) for every k c N. We set Vk’j
(iii)
which defines
Property (i)
a
countable
family
of sets since
is clear from the definition of
follows from the fact that the sets
Finally, property (ii) by finitely many Vk,jM.
=
...
(Wk+2 \ Wk-1)
N is countable.
property
that A is countable.
0 and let
follows because each set
)/Vk+l \ Wk Wk is only
Vk,j
cover
and
all of
intersected
I
Manifolds
2.1
Lemma 2.1.7. Let M be
Then there is
(i) h(x) (ii) h(x)
r,
Fig.
real
a
manifold
C’ -function h: M
a
1 0
--+
and U, V open sets with with
59
R
C
V
-
[0, 1]
for all x E a, for all x E M \ V.
r2
rl
2.1.4. The
proof of Lemma 2.1.7
Proof. We consider first the special
r2
case
but different radii: Let 0 < r, < r2 and Ix (E Rn: jxj < r2j. The map Br,(0)
of two balls with
B,,(0)
=
Ix
(E
origin
Rn
jxj
:
0 E Rn
rij,
<
=
gri,r2: R+
R+,
--
is C’ and has the
t
((t-ri)(t-r2)
O
exp
-->
1
< t < r2
otherwise
Irl, r2l
support
for
-
It follows that t
’, 9r,,12 (s) ds fr,12 gri,r2 (s)ds
jri,r2 (t) is also C’. The
r
properties
j,r1,r2 (t)
j,,,,2 (t)
cz
(0, 1)
jr1,r2 (t) imply
12:
[0, 1]
is well defined and satisfies E
:::::
G
for all t G
0 for all t E
[0, rij, (ri, r2),
[r2) 00)
that the C’-function
h,,
x
for All t
---+
R+,
X
SUPP(h,i,r2)
1-‘
=
gri, r2
(11 X I I )
Br2(0), hr,,r2 (X)
=
1 for all
B, (0). Consider
now
open sets
U,
V with
R
C
V and let
fVjjjEN
collection of open sets as provided by Lemma 2.1.6. For each now construct a smooth function hj which satisfies
j
be
we
a
will
60
2.
Analysis
manifolds
on
(i) hj (x) E [0, 1] for all x E M, I for all x E U n Vj, (ii) hj (x) (iii) supp (hj) c V n Vj. =
Let
U n Vi and
E
x
and Wx c V n
Br2(X)(0)
(IlVx, (,ox )
There
Vj. (PX(WX)’
C
h3.: IlVx X
--+
are
be
a
chart centered at
points
xi,
R+,
...
I
with Wx (X)
0
=
The map
y
hr, (x),r2 (X)
--*
XK
PX (Y)
0
for y E
0
Wx
otherwise
is well defined and smooth. Since U n many
x
positive numbers ri (x) < r2 (X) such that
Vj
is compact there exist
finitely
such that the open sets -
1
(Br, (x,) (0))jk=1,...’K K
Hence the map hj (Y) :=: 1 f1k=1(1 hiX (y)) is also well defined and smooth. Clearly, we have hj(y) c [0, 11 for all y c- M. Since U n
cover
Vj.
0 for all y hx, (y) \ V n Vj If y E U 1. implies hj(y)
E M
=
M
-
-
-
n
Vj
\
Vn
Vj
we
have also
then there exists
an
hj (y)
0 for all y G I which (y)
=
.,
xi with h3X
=
=
The function
h(x)
Ej’ , hj(x)
is well defined since for each
x
all
finitely many hj(x) vanish. h satisfies supp(h) c V, J’(x) > 0 for all x E M, and h(x) > 1 for all x E a. Hence in order to prove the lemma we x c M : h(x) < 1/21. only need to normalise h appropriately. Let U This set is open and its closure is contained in M U. Hence by the same construction there exists another smooth function h with h(x) > 0 for but
all
X
M,
E
and
h
h(x)
> I for
all
x
E
h(x) is well defined and smooth.
then x
E
h(x)
M
1,
do not vanish both at any
\
> I
h(x)
=
supp(h)
C M
by
each
h(x) ~
h(x)
+
h(x)
=
h(x) e
[0, 1]
for all
0 which in turn
0 and therefore
h(x)
=
E M has a neighbourhood of finitely many fa, I for all x. fa(X)
point
x
Observe that
=
x
E
M. If
implies h(x)
x =
E
U
1. If
1
0.
Definition 2.1.7. A smooth partition of unity is f fa: M - [0, 11 IaC-A such that
(i)
\ a.
given point. Hence
Further, h(x)
and therefore
V then
and
a
set
which is
of functions
only
intersected
the support
(") EaEA
=
A partition of unity is subordinate to an open covering every a (E A there is a b (E B with SUPP(fa) C Ub-
fUbjbEB if for
2.2 Vector bundles and the
tangent bundle
61
(Existence of a partition of unity). If jUbjbEB is of a real manifold M then there exists a countable covering open partition of unity ffjjjEN which is subordinate to jUbjbEBTheorem 2.1.1 an
For each
Proof.
neighbourhood exists
a
of
sequence
M let
E
x
b(x)
be
with
Ub(x) 1Xj1jEN and x
an
index with
x
G
and
Ub(x)
Lemma 2.1.6
ab(x)
be
a
implies that there
C
Ub(x).
a
countable collection of open sets
1Vjj
such that
(i) each Vj lies in some Ub(x.,) and therefore Vj (ii) each Vj intersects only finitely many Vj; ("’) M UjEN Vj*
C
Ub(xj);
=
We
can now
to find
a
apply
the
same
argument
to the collection of open sets
countable collection of open sets
(i) each Wk lies in some Vj(k); (ii) each )/Vk intersects only finitely ("’) M UkEN )/Vk =
many
tWkIkEN
Vj
such that
Wj;
*
[0, 1] with By Lemma 2.1.7 there is for each k a function hk: M Since each Vj M for all 0 x E 1 for all x G Wk, hk (X) \ Vj(k) hk (X) 0 for have M each for we x chk (X) intersects at most finitely many Vi well is that the This k. x sum hk (X) all but finitely many implies have in each lies we Since smooth. and some x hk (X) defined Wk ---*
=
=
-
=
I for all
x
G
M. Thus
hk (X)
E’ 1= 1 hi (x) Property (i) of Definition 2.1.7 is satisfied only finitely many Vi and supp(fk) c Vj(k). directly from the definition of fk. Hence ffkjkEN is
is well defined and smooth.
because each
Vj
intersects
Property (ii) follows a partition of unity. That follows from
supp(fk)
C
it is subordinate to the open
Vj(k)
C
I
Ub(.,.1(,)).
Remark 2.1.2. In Lemma 2.1.7 and Theorem 2.1.1 it restrict to the
eral. This is
so
case
K
=
covering UbjbEB
R. If K
=
C, both results
was
are
necessary to
wrong in gen-
complex- differentiable maps are automatically locally be written as a power series. This would be
because
analytic, i.e., can impossible for the function h
in Lemma 2.1.7.
2.2 Vector bundles and the
tangent bundle
ordinary calculus, the derivative Df of a map f : K’ -4 K’ is the linear approximation of f, i.e., it is defined by f (x) f (a) + Dfla(x-a) +
In
=
F-p. 5 j p.
62]
62
Analysis
2.
o(Jx
al)
o(Jx
where
manifolds
on
al)/Ix al --> 0 (x -+ a). To study the linear approximation of a map rather than the map itself is certainly one of the most powerful approaches in mathematics and physics. Because of the -
limit
-
-
0 this approach is often referred to as working infinitesa imally. Until the middle of this century people spoke of infinitesimal (or infinitely small) displacements (meaning the vector x-a if it was ’small’). This terminology can lead to misunderstandings but stresses the main idea of analysis. While we will give a modern presentation, it is a good idea to keep the ’infinitesimal way of thinking’ in mind. x
--
-
The definition of a linear approximation of a function f rests on the linear structure of Kn. In the general case of a manifold, such a structure is not at hand. But it is possible to define a linear approximation of a map in two to the the
[P.
steps. First, we linearise the manifold itself. This gives rise tangent space TaM at a point a of a manifold M. Then we
linearise the map thereby obtaining between (linear) tangent spaces.
linear map
a
Taf : TaM
--+
Tf (,,)N
We will linearise the manifold M
by attaching an n-dimensional vecpoint x C M. At first one may think that it is sufficient to consider the product M X Kn and to define TxM JxJ x Kn. However, this would introduce a global structure via the (global) product x. In order to keep within the spirit of localisation, we can only demand that such a product exists locally. This motivates the following tor space to M at each
definition. Definition 2.2.1. A k-vector bundle
manifold
M is
a
and submersion
(i)
For each
triple consisting of
7rE: E x
c-
(E, 7rE; M) over an n-dimensional (k + n) -dimensional manifold E,
a
M such that
--
M is
(7rE)_1(x)
a
k-dimensional vector space
over
K,
(ii) for
each
x c
M there is
for each
a
linear
over
-
(7rE)
1
(U)
a
diffeomorphism
7
__4
(7rE) -I(Y)
isomorphism.
M is called the base
the fibre
k
-
and
y E U the restricted map
V)y: Kk is
neighbourhood U
UxK
0: where
a
manifold,
7rE
the
y, E the total space, and
projection, Ey := (7rE)-I(Y) 0 the bundle chart or local
trivialisation. The set of tangent spaces of a Manifold forms again a manifold of a special a vector bundle. While we will construct many special vector bundles
type, and
general
vector bundles
definition is not central to
are
our
of
importance
discussion.
in gauge
theory, their general
2.2 Vector bundles and the tangent bundle
We will often
just speak of the
vector bundle E instead Of
63
(E, 7E, M)
-
Kk. We call (E, 7TE) M) trivial if there exists a local trivialisation of the form 0: M X Kk -- E. In this case, E can be identified with M X Kk. An example of a vector bundle which is not trivial is given by the M6bius band. Notice that this is just
Example
(M&bius band,
2.2.1
band M is also
a
(Wi)-’ (x’, 0)
7rm(x)
(XI, X2)
localisation of M
a
continued
from
X
page
vector bundle. The bundle
o
and i
The
projection
R2 is Wi(x) where pl: R2 E 11, 21 is an index with x E Ui.
o
pi
53)).
--4
is
M,5bius
given by
the projection It is clear that
this vector bundle is not trivial. Definition 2.2.2. Let E be which
satisfies IrE(U(X)
==
a
for
x
vector bundle. A map
all
x
E
U is called
a
a:
U C M
--->
E
section of the vector
bundle E. A collection
ful,
...
7
9k
I of sections
spanf a, (x) for all
x
E
U is called
7
following definition
nius
2.5.3).
will
The
play
a
(E, 7TE, M)
be
(F, 7rF, N) of the vector bundle E and submanifold N of M such that
(7E) IF:
IrF
(X) I
Ex
=::::
role later
dle
(i)
Uk
frame of E.
a
Definition 2.2.3. Let
,...
such that
F
--4
N
defines
a
on
Theorem of Frobe-
vector bundle. A vector subbun-
consists
a
(cf.
of
a
submanifold
F
of E
vector bundle structure with base
manifold N,
(ii) Fy
is
a
vector
subspace of Ey for
2.2.1 Construction of the
all y
G
N.
tangent bundle
In affine geometry we had distinguished between points x E A’ and translations (or vectors) in the associated vector space Kn. A translation
global concept.
Notice that
a translation is originally the curve along thought moving yv: [0, 1] -* An, t -+ x + tv to its endpoint. The velocity vector of the curve is v which may be regarded as the infinitesimal (but in this case exact) approximation , An, t --> -y(t), we of -yv. Given an arbitrary smooth curve y: (a, b] take its derviative as its infinitesimal approximation at a given point x - (to). Taking all these velocity vectors at x we obtain a vector space
v: x
F-
x
+
of
v
is
a
the
as
point
x
=:
TxAn which is attached to A’ at x. This vector space is in a natural way isomorphic to the associated vector space given by the translations. In the
following
we
will transfer these ideas to manifolds. The main
F
p. 62
p.
65]
64
2.
difficulty which
Analysis
we
manifolds
on
have to solve is the lack of take the derivative of
we can
Let M be
associated vector space in
an
a curve.
smooth
manifold, x c M and -y: (-E, E) --+ M be a through x at parameter value 0. Another smooth curve (-e, e) with x (O) is called x-equivalent to -y if d o -y) o This definition is independent of the chosen (W (W Tt 0. dt 10 chart and puts all curves through x with the same velocity into one equivalence class [-y,,] smooth
curve
a
in M which passes
=
=
-
Definition 2.2.4. Let M be
a smooth manifold and x cz M. The space of all equivalence classes [-y,,] is called the tangent space of M at x and denoted by T,,M. Its elements are called tangent vectors.
We must show that TxM has indeed the structure of
Choose any chart
(U, W)
centered at
vector space.
a
This chart induces
x.
a
bijective
map
(9 x’: TM which Let
a
we can use
E
dt
(W
to induce
[-yx], [px]
K and
d
[-y,,]
K’,
---
on T,,M the vector T.,M. Then we define
E
a[-yx]
:=
(eP)-l (aRP([7x]))
[AXI
:=
(ex
x
-
-y) 10
space structure of Kn.
x
and
[-Yxl
+
((9x1 OXI)
+
(9x,([-Yxl))
-
This vector space structure is independent of the chosen chart. In let (V, 0) be another chart centered at x and denote (9 ’ o ((9P)
(9’P,w-’. x
x
Then
((9x
we
have
(a(9xI ([,Y.])) =
(’9")
-
1
x
=
0
=
e" x
((9V))-1(9V) x
and
x
-
’W-1
x
(exI,)-,
(en
-1
-1 (aev (eOX) e"([-Yxl))
x
x
o
o
(90 (I
0 x
x
x
Yxi))
,
(01(9X, Q -Y-D)
analogously
(ex
(ex10([-Yxl)
+
(ex ) + (9w x
x
1QAxD)
ex (9x
0
0
((9x,P)
-
I
(e’O x
0
(,g")-l .,e"([-txl) x
x
(e b)-l e b([Mxj) x
x
,
x
x
x
x
fact, by
tangent bundle
2.2 Vector bundles and the
((gqp,w-I)-I
+
(ex
(ex We call the set TM
[_YX D
2.2.1. Let M be
(TM, 7rTm, M)
on
=
a
manifold.
smooth
There is
associated with M such that
UXEM TxM
I A, (Pa)IaEA
Tfa: (7rTM)
-I
and define 7rTM
x.
of M and define the structure of
f ((7rTM) -I (Ua)) Tfa) I
through the atlas
M
infinitesimal models
[p.
a
1]
63
p. 65
natural
(7rTM)
(X)
M.
x E
Let TM
as
I
vector bundle
atlas
+
be understood
can
Proposition
Proof.
.
UxcmTxM the tangent bundle of the manifold
:=
M. The vector spaces TxM of M at x.
TxM for all
(1YXD) ex0 QYXD)
191,
,
x
65
(Ua)
’/x I
K n’
Kn
-4
We choose
an
smooth manifold
a
where Oa (X) 0) 19’p’ x
-4
(/ [XD
-
bijections bijections
The
Oa : Ua
X
Kn
-4
(7rTM)
diffeomorphisms isomorphisms.
are
then
are
linear
-I
(Ua)
such that
(X, V)
i
(Oa.)x:
Kn
-4
-->
(ef"’) _1(v) x
TxM,
v
1-4
-
(ew-)-’(v) x
p. 65
always practical to work with equivalence classes. We will therefore also give an equivalent definition which is better suited for calculations at the cost of being less intuitive. The key observation is that each tangent vector 1-yx] E TxM induces a map
It is not
If
D
f
E
Coo (U, d
-4
at- f
This map has the
0
K)
:
U is
an
open
neighbourhood
of
x
K,
-Y(O).
following properties.
(i) D[,yl.,,, is K-linear, (ii) for any smooth functions f
D[,yl., (fg)
=
.;
,
g: M
---
K the derivation property
D [,yl. (f) g (x) +
f (x) D [,yl. (g)
holds,
(iii)
for any open neighbourhood U of which coincide in U we have , g
f
This motivates the
following
x
and any two smooth functions
(f
(g).
[I
p.
1
75]
66
2.
Analysis
manifolds
on
Definition 2.2.5. A map
If
v :
C’ (U,
c-
K)
U is
:
an
neighbourhood Of xj
open
---->
K
satisfies properties (i)-(iii) above is called a derivation. The vector space of derivations at x with addition and multiplication being defined pointwise, (avx + bw,)(f) a(v.,(f)) + b(wx(f)), is denoted by D ,. which
=
Remark 2.2. 1. The reader may wonder why in our definitions derivations U is an open neighbourhood of xj instead of on If E C’ (U, K) :
act
the
simpler
C’ (M,
K),
(M, K)
set C’
but in the
For K
-
K
case
R
=:
could indeed have chosen
we
C there exist
=
only
very few
globally
defined differentiable maps in general. In fact, in the extreme case of the complex torus only the constant functions are smooth. However, locally there is
always
Lemma 2.2. 1.
v.,(f)
=
0
for
Let
I +
lvx (1)
a
-
If f :
M
K is constant in
--+
=
a.
=
vx
(f)
2avx (1)
Theorem 2.2.1. Dx is
=
(f /a) 2vx (f ). avx
==
is
a
Let
=
--+
avx
=
(1)
=
(I 1)
av.,
-
=
avx
(1)
-
I
n-dimensional vector space.
an
Proof. We know already that Dx n. only to show that dirn(Dx) and let x’: U
neighbourhood of x, then
a
all derivations vx E Dx-
f (x)
Proof.
abundance of smooth functions.
an
vector space and have therefore
(U, W)
be
a
chart centered at
W-’.
K the ith coordinate component of
x
Observe that
K the identity h(y) W(U) h(O) + Enj , hi(y)y’, 1 ah(t’) dt and y is the ith coordinate where hi is defined by hi(y) := L --5 1 K we in Kn. Applying this identity to the function f W- : W(U) we
have for any h:
--+
=
o
obtain n
f(Y)
=
f (X)
Xi (Y)
+
Hence for any derivation vx E Dx to
(f W-’) i W-’ (Y)
f
-
-
get
we
n
vX(f)
=
VX
(f (X))
+ X, (X)vX
The first summand vanishes
x’(x)
vx is
uniquely determined by
0. From vx (f)
((f
by
since
=
E (vX (Xi) (f
+
=
-
0-’)
i
-
0
0))
W
I
WW
-
i
-
Lemma 2.2.1 and the last term vanishes
Ei’- I (f
the
n
o
p
-’),
o
(x’)
W (x) vx
numbers vx (x 1),
.
.
.
,
we see
VX (Xn).
that I
2.2 Vector bundles and the
Definition 2.2.6. Let M be
manifold, (U, p)
a
tangent bundle
be
a
67
chart, and
vi
p":
Kn
--,
vs.
K, vn
Then x’: U
-->
K,
y
-4
p’
(p(y)
o
is the ith coordinate function with
(xl,...,x’) a coordinate system. defined by axi(xi) Jj3 is called the
and the collection
(U,W) respect The pointwise basis to
=
CauBian basis associated with
(U, W)
GauBian vector fields. We will
often simply
Corollary
2.2.1. Let M be
centered at
x
C’(M)
we
write
manifold
smooth
a
fields axi are called 0i instead of
and the vector
and
(U, W)
M. For any derivation v., E D., and any have E
n
V-M
=
n
Evi’9xif
=
ST
0
partial
a
chart E
W-1
axi
i=1
i=1
where D7 is the usual
.’9f
E v%
be
function f
derivative in Kn.
Proposition 2.2.2. The tangent space T ,M is canonically isomorphic to Dx. The isomorphism is given by the map i: TM --+ D,,, iQ-1] ,)(f) A o dtf y(to) and well defined. Proof. Clear by
construction.
dispend with the symbol Dx and always use TxM instead. Our first definition using curves has the advantage to work also in infinite dimensional settings. However, we are only concerned with finite dimensional manifolds and derivations are more practical to work with than equivalence classes of curves. Hence
we can
Definition 2.2.7. Let M be
vx
*
f
:
=
The map
a
manifold,
x
E
M and U be
a
neigh-
For any v., E Tx M and f E C" (U, K) the number df (vx) : vx (f ) is called the derivative of f in direction vx,
bourhood of
x.
=
df :
TM
-->
K,
vx
-->
df (vx)
is the differential
of f
2.2.2 The derivative of maps between manifolds
In the
preceding
section
we
linearise differentiable maps
taining linear
maps
Tx f :
Definition 2.2.8. Let a
differentiable
map.
f: M
Tx M
--->
--+
N between manifolds
Tf (x)
can now
thereby
ob-
N.
manifolds, x E M, and 0: M -4 N be Txo: TxM --> TxN, Txo(v)(f) v(f o V)) is (Or simply the derivative) of V). We will often
M,
Then
called the tangent map denote T,,o by 0.,
have linearised the manifold. We
N be
=
68
Analysis
2.
manifolds
on
Observe that in terms of
given by [-(.,] of the curve 0 o -y ,0
equivalence classes of curves, the derivative of which is clearly the linear approximation
[V) -yp(,,)] at O(x).
is
-4
o
It is instructive to calculate the
.
systems. In these we
tangent
map with
respect
to
a coor-
o) and (a, 3) be charts of M and N respectively, Xn) and (5 1......; k) the associated coordinate charts 0 has the representation T1 o-’ and p 7P
dinate system. Let (U, and denote by (x 1, .
.
,
o
==
o
calculate n
,O.V(f)
E vi’9xi- Y
=
-
0)
V’
=
C W
Hence with respect to
a
0
V)
0
Oxi
i=1
vi’9f
-
-
(V, aP 0
Y
0
,9T13 =
a.V
’9xi
V
W
a;,7 -if .
coordinate system, the tangent map 0" is just Again we see the tangent map Txo is the
the derivative of the map T1. linearisation of 0 at x. The
following is
an
immediate
corollary of Definition
2.1.6 and Lemma
2.1.3.
Corollary 2.2-2. Let M be a manifold and x E M. A continuously differentiable map 0: M ---+ N is a submersion (respectively, immersion, local diffeomorphism) near x if and only if TxV): T M T b (x) N is
surJective (respectively, injective, bijective).
2.3 Tensors and tensor fields fields play a central r6le in geometry and physics. Differential forms are not absolutely necessary for the theory of space and time. However, their usage has many advantages and they also provide a very natural way to define integration. In particular, the integral theorems of Stokes and Gaufl have a very simple, common form when stated in terms of differential forms (cf. Theorem 2.5.5). Unfortunately, the introduction of differential forms requires Tensor
some
technical preparation.
Some readers may
differential forms
on
The tangent bundle of mations
JTMJ.
linearisation
we
therefore wish first reading.
a
to
skip the
sections
dealing
with
manifold is the collection of its linear approxiuse of the simplifications arising from
In order to make
need to express
physical
and geometrical
objects
in terms
of maps which are adapted to the linear structure of T,,M for all x E M. We will see later in the book that the notion of a tensor field provides a
good
section
framework for this we
simply
(here
still rather
introduce tensor fields
as
vague)
idea.’In the present
mathematical concepts.
2.3 Tensors and tensor fields
2.3.1
Algebraic preliminaries:
In linear
algebra,
the concept of
69
tensors tensor unifies
a
vectors, linear forms,
bilinear forms, linear maps, determinants etc. Let V be an n-dimensional vector space over K. Then its dual space V* is the vector space of all linear maps V ---> K. It is easy to see that V* is isomorphic to V. In fact, if jej,... , enj is a basis of V then the set 10 ...... O’l C V*, defined by
Oi (ej)
=
6 ,,
is
a
basis of V*. It is
uniquely
by f el....
defined
7
e,,, I and
called the dual basis. While the
isomorphism
the choice of basis
of V and V* defined
lei,..., enl,
there is
by
iOi depends on isomorphism tv of
ei
canonical
a
V and V**.
V*,
tv: V
tv(v): f
V
-->
f (V)
E
following we will freely make use of this canonical identification given by tv and write v instead of tv(v). Using this identification we not only can view a vector v as a linear
In the
V**
V
Tap V*
--->
A: V*
V
x
generalised
K but also
and
X
which is linear in each
space
VXV*
X
of
s
and an
a
...
V is
--4
a
as
bilinear map can be
V*
--+
K
copies
or a
0
tensor
is
an
times
r
co-
of order
The
by Tsr(V).
is denoted
linear map V
x
We say that
its entries.
=
For
X r
The most important special cases T,O(V) V*. A bilinear form such
T20(V)
V
map
times contravariant tensor
(r)-tensors
of all
...
a
copies
s
s
is
8
V
-->
f (Av). This reasoning following unifying concept. =
,
(")-tensor
Definition 2.3.1. An
variant and
A(f v)
i,
let to the
we are
0:
linear map A: V
a
K, (f, v)
--->
are
Too (V)
as a
scalar
K, To’ (V) V, and product is an element of =
element of
an
T11(V).
explanation of the terminology "covariant/contravariant"
see
will need to define the components of a tensor. This in turn requires the introduction of the (natural) "tensor product" & of tensors which generalises the usual product of numbers. Remark 2.3.1 below. First
Tsl(V), 0 LS+p (V) by
Definition 2.3.2. Let sor
0
product 0 0
0 (Vil
&
...
)
0
E
0
E
G
Tpq(V).
Then
we
define the
,+q
V87 1011 :=
we
...
O(Vi
)
wp)
....
7
W11 Vs,
...
Wi
I
I
Wr, 77,.... 77 q)
...
IWr) O(wj,
wp,
n1,
ten-
70
Analysis
2.
manifolds
on
Observe that the tensor Lemma 2.3.1.
The tensor
Proof. Let 0, 02 03
is not commutative.
product
is associative.
(ri), (r2), (r3)
be tensors of order
7
we
product
81
have
(01
0
02)
(D
Wil (01
03 (V1
...
,,rl+l, X
and
r,
+
,
...
,
1,
.
.
.
....
V"’
I
’
’
W1
03(VSI+S2+11
rl+’r2+1, Wrl+r2+1,
,
VS1 +32 +S3
I
...
7
W
I
V81+82+831
.
.
...
...
I
VS1 +82 +,93
7
)rl +r2 + 1,
I
)02 (Vs, +1,
rl I
VS1 +,92
7
.
Then
,
W
rl
+r2 +r3
,)rl,
I
)
,
*
-
respectively.
83
V81+821 V81+82+11
vs, VS1 +1
I
rl+r2
03 (Vs I +S2 +11
01 (vi X
I
b2) (V1
0
VS1 I VS1 +I I-
I
ri
82
-
’
*
ri
I
VS1 +82
,rl+r2+1,.
+r2 +r3
r1+1 1
rl I
...
+r2
I
,rl+r2+r3)
analogously
01(9(V)2
(D
7P3)(V1
Wil (9
...
rl, W +11
I
....
VS1,
I
( )II
?P3)(Vsj+17-
,,ri +
ri ...
01 (vi,
I
vs 1
I
,rj+1.... X
IVSIIVSI+ll ri
01 (vi
(02
....
,
-
.
*
I
W
rl
I ....
I
1
IVSI+S2+S3)
+r2 +1
rl+r2+r3)
,
VS1+S2 7 VS1+82+11’
i
rl+r2
rl
rl)
.,
+r2’
V)3 (VS1 +S2 +11
Lemma 2.3.2.
.
1W
...
)VS1+827VS1+S2+11’ +r2 +1
ri
+r2 +
1,
.
.
.
,
I
VSI+S2+S3’
Wrl+r2+r3)
U)rl)’02(Vsl+l
....
I
VSI+S2’
) rl
VS 1 +82 +S3
If jej.... enj, 101,
+r2 +1
on I is
I
rl+r2+r3
a
pair of dual bases then
the set
f 0" forms have
a
(9
basis
...
(9 0’. (2) ej, (9
of the
dim(T,,r(V))
=
space
...
(9
T,(V) of
all
(") -tensors. S
in
particular,
Proof. The set of tensors f 0" independent. In fact, let
(9 0i. (9 ej, (9 & ej,, I is be numbers such that ...
n
V)
E V)ij’---j"’0i1
=
j3
.....
we
nrn’.
j’-1
(9
...
(9
0i.
(2) ej, (9
...
(9 ej,
=
0.
linearly
2.3 Tensors and tensor fields
Then 0
:::::::
O(ek,
I
....
e-k,,
,
011
,
...
1017,)
71
hence the tensors 01’-*1’,,, k,
=
...
k
linearly independent. Conversely, we see that for and any v,.... v, E V, 77’ E V we have
0
any tensor
are
all
Tr(V)
E
*
,
n
O(Vi
....
Vs, 17,
O(eii
......r
&oil
I
...
I
ei,
0 ej,
oilI... Oil Oil
I
1
ej,,
(VI
....
VS,
nil
7r).
....
T,,(V) is nrn’ since there are exactly n’ choices of t-tuples (with possible duplication) from a set of n elements. I
The dimension of
ordered
Definition 2.3.3. Let
01,
on
V)
c
Tr (V) and
f ei,
e,,
I
be a. basis
be the associated dual basis. The numbers
0,"
of V and defined by
n
ii
are
the components
physical (and
In the
...
i,’ 0’,
(9
of 0 with respect old
(9 0’. & ej, (9
...
(9 ej,,
f ei,
to the basis
mathematical)
...
en
literature it is the standard to
use
for contravariant entries upper and for covariant entries lower indices. This provides a checking mechanism for the syntactical correctness of tensor formulas and also
ing
tensor
(Einstein’s
effective notation in the
simplifies
the
physics literature
of formulas involv-
interpretation
components. In Remark 2.3.4 below summation
and has at its
will introduce
we
convention)
core
which is
a
very
prevalent
the difference between up-
per and lower indices. Unfortunately, many modern mathematicians lower indices for all entries on grounds of "aesthetics".
terminology "covariant/contravariant"
Remark 2.3.1. The
arose
use
in the
19th century and refers to the transformation of tensor components under transformation of a given pair of dual bases f ell Oil Onj. , e,, 1, f .
Let
v
==
T11 (V) fined
I:ni=1 Viei
be
by ji
we can
V,
W
=
I:ni=1 wiO’
E
=
v
Eni=1 f),Ei, n
W
=
rn _i=l CoiO’. n
W(W)
w
(z-v%)
.
.
V*, and A
invertible linear map. Then f jI, 0’ o (A-’) are also Aei and
an
write
(E
.
.
a
.
.
=
Ei,j Aiei 0 Oj
,
.
For any
w
G
V
.
.
we
n
Cv’A’i-w (ej)
n
Cv’AiWk Ok (e j)
E
n I den 1, f ’, pair of dual bases and
ib’w (Aei)
n
.
Cv’A3j wj
,
have
72
Analysis
2.
manifolds
_Tj’=, Aj’ wj.
Hence cDi
i.e.,
on
in the
The components of
Similarly,
n
(A)
v
(j
( j 0’ A-’)
j 0’(A- v)
-
n
j(A-1)jVkoiej k
j(A-)’k Vk.
i,j,k=l
i,j,k==l
I:nk=l(A -1)’vk, k
=
covariantly,
n
v
n
Hence f)’
transform
as
way
n
v
w
the basis vectors ej. for any A C- V* we have
same
antly with respect
the components of
v
transform contravari-
A, i.e., opposite
to the transformation
to the basis
vectors ej.
Another natural operation which is defined for tensors is their "contraction". Definition 2.3.4. Let
of dual bases. The
slot and the 9th covariant
C,rO(vl,
T,’ (V) and f el, en; 0 ...... of 0 with respect to the th slot of 0 is defined by
contraction
0’ 1 be
a
pair
contravariant
W1....
Vr-1,
dth slot
,Pth slot
n
6-
Vr
-
1, W
....
WS-1)
02,
1
We have to show that this definition is In
fact,
1 1,
if
there exists
and Ok
=
a
6k
qro(vi,
.
.
-
-
I
linear
A-’
o
.
-
,
independent of the choice of basis. pair of dual bases then nj, A: V V --+ with AEj isomorphism ej En 1 Aj j is another
=
Enj= (A-1) 3 03
.
-
=
W1
Vr_ 1,
I
...
.
We calculate
I
n
-,
O(Vl,..., ej,..., Vr-1, W1,
-
-,
-
0i’.
-
-,
W,
n
A1j*(A-’)k’O(vj,---, j.... 7Vr-17W17
-
i,j,k=l n
O(Vl)
-
-
-
jji
Lemma 2.3.3. Let V be
T,r (V).
-
-
a
-,Vr-1,W1,
-
-
vector space
-’0 over
K and
G
TqP(V),
Th e n and
(C9
Z (0 Cq+sr
E
2.3 Tensors and tensor fields
Proof.
This follows
immediately
73
I
from the definitions.
Another class of natural operations on tensors are symmetry operations. We introduce below the two most important symmetry operators, symmetrisation sym and anti- symmetrisatio n alt of entries. First some
technical
we
need
a
bijec-
preparation.
Definition 2.3.5. A
permutation of the numbers (1,...,p)
is
tion
f(il’. .,ip) : fil’. .,ipl
up:
-
-
=
11,
1(il’. .,ip)
-
-
-Al
fil’...’W
11’.. ’Al.
=
If orP is a permutation we write a(ij, ip) (i,(j), i,(,)). The set of all permutations of the p integers j1,...,pj is denoted by Sp. A transposition is a permutation which permutes only two consecutive elements and leaves all other elements fixed. =
-
Lemma 2.3.4. mutation
The set
group)
and is
-
of all permutations Sp forms generated by transpositions.
-
.
a
,
group
(the
per-
Proof. That Sp forms a group is clear since the collection of all bijections a given set forms a group where the composition of maps is the group operation. be any permutation. Starting Let a(ij,...’ip) with the p-tuple (i 1, ip) we can use successive transpositions in order of
to
move
the index
to the last
i,(p)
position. Assume
now
that
i,,(k)
i
...
I
Since ia(kfio-(k) ,... I ic(p) I it must be , p. 1) k It that 1. follows we can Move i.(k, 1) to
positions k, at one of the positions 1, k 1 by successive transpositions which all leave the last p position k have there finite shown that is induction invariant. we a By positions sequence of transpositions which is equivalent to a.
i,(p)
are
at
.
.
.
-
.
.
.
-
-
Lemma 2.3.5.
There is
a
natural
sign: Sp
of
the
mined
permutation
by sign(-rp)
--+
homomorphism
(1-1, 11, .)
group into the group
=
-1
for
of
two elements which is deter-
all transpositions -rp.
prove this lemma by showing that every permutation a is product of an even number of transpositions (sign(O-) 1) or the product of an odd number of transpositions (sign(a) -1). First we show that the identity permutation id is not the product of an odd number of transpositions. Assume that id is the product of finitely many transpositions and denote by n1k the number of all those
Proof. We
either the
=
=
74
Analysis
2.
manifolds
on
transpositions which interchange the numbers I and k. The number must be
the
since at the end 1 must be
even
beginning
change
and since there
k and 1. If
p
E 1=1 (Epl=k n1k) Let
now a
Since id is the
(-ri
=
=
o
set n1l
o
-ri
...
0
0
...
Irk)
-
of k + 1
product
Hence k and I
we
=
which is the
are
Irk 1
0
0
0
...
of
even
even or
A permutation up acts in
0
tl
=
(Tk)
1
-
0
set up 0 (vi,
(-Fl)-’
...
k + 1 must be’even.
tensor
on a
and any 0 E TO(V) p (v,,, (1), V,,, (p)).
vp)
even.
transpositions. 0 ;F, 0 0 ;F_J
are
0
...
Definition 2.3.6. For any we
at
both odd.
natural way
a
n1k
as
numbers and therefore
o, i where Ti,,Tj
...
transpositions the number
both
side of k
other transpositions which inter0 then the number of all transpositions is
-71
11
same
are no
sum
=
the
on
.
.
.
0
TO (V).
c
p
permutation up
E
Sp
,
Lemma 2.3.6. For any permutations -rp, up E T’(V) we have (up o Tp)V) -rp(apV)).
and any tensor
SP
0
=
p
Proof. Let
vi,
vp
V. We calculate
E
-r,) 0 (vi,
(UP
Vp)
(V,P.-,, (1), (V,, (", (1)), 07po (VTT, (1))
V-P .-,, W) V-,, (-,, W) -
(p))
*
Tp (CPO) (V, (1), which
implies
the first
Lemma 2.3.7. sym:
equality.
The maps 0
To M
T M,
p
1
P!
alt:
I: E
"
are
W
up
To P, M
V)
0
Yp M, I
V)
P!
S7,
1:
sign (up) up 0
ESI,
linear projections.
Proof. We only
prove the lemma for the
operator alt since the proof
for sym is completely analogous. That alt is linear is clear.from the definitions. For given V) E To (V), vectors v1, and any permutation , vp p we have -Fp .
alt,0 (vl,
.
.
.
,
vp)
P!
P!
Y_ E
.
.
sign (up) 0 (v,,,, (1).... Va" (p)) I
Sp
E ,pEST,
sign(up) sign (,Tp) V)(v,,,, -T, (1),
V-P -’, W)
2.3 Tensors and tensor fields
=
where
sign(,rp)
alt
have used that R,:
we
-
-
Sp
Sp,
-
,
75
v_gp)),
up
apTp is
1-4
bijection.
a
It
follows that alt
alt
o
0((vj,..., vp)
=
E
-
P! 1 =
o
alt
=
-
-
-
1’r’, W
,
alt
O(vj,..., vp)
-7, E Sp
alt?P(vj,..., vp)
=
and therefore alt
Y
-
P!
sign (-rp) alt V)(v -" (1),
7-7, E Sp
alt.
I
Definition 2.3.7. A covariant tensor V) E T ,(V) is called symmetric (respectively, anti-symmetric) if for all s-tuples of vectors (vl,...,v,) and all permutations a,
b (vi,
V’)
of (1,
0 (v,’ (1),
=
-
-
.
Symmetric analogously.
and
s)
,
the
equality
-V"’ (,))
(respectively, 0 (vi, holds.
.
.
.
.
v,)
,
anti-symmetric
=
sign(o-,) 0 (v,,, (1)
7
...
contravariant tensors
va" (S)))
7
defined
are
p. 65
I
The set of all
r
times contravariant and
TXM, where
E
M, form
x
a
s
times covariant tensors
vector bundle which
generalises
on
the tangent
bundle.
Proposition set
T ,M
2.3.1. Let M be
an
U. CMTr(TxM) of
=
n-dimensional, smooth manifold. The
all
(r) -tensors .
carries
natural vector
a
bundle structure.
Proof.
Let
associate
0,:
a
(U,, o,,,)
be
an
atlas of M. Then with each chart U,,
we can
map
U
T,,r(TxM)
-
0.(U)
x
K
n"n’
xEU,,.
W. W,
where
0", (a) ii
J.
...
GauBian basis lies in at least
are
the components of the tensor
Oxi ......9xr,,. one
....
TrU,,,
:=
that for each
0,
o
V), 1: V)O(TrU,
n
TrUe)
Oy
UxEu,,, Tr(TxM) (a
(TrU,, 0,) forms an atlas pair of indices (a, 0) the map
that the collection
--
....
nj
Ox with respect
It is clear that each tensor
of the sets
isEfl
of TrM
0,(TrU,,
n
we
E c
to the
T,"(TyM) A).
To
see
have to show
TrU,8)
p. 84
76
is
Analysis
2.
We denote the coordinate system associated with y") and let x E U, n UO. For any vector v E Tx M we
diffeomorphism.
a
(UO, oo) by (y’, then write
can
manifolds
on
.
.
.
Eni=1 V i a.xi.
v
=n
V3.
In other
words, the column
nents of the vector
DW,,e (va), row
where
Eni= , v’0 0.,i
a
(WC, ( 00)-’)j -
v
Oyi
By the
v. I
are
=
=
of the components of
by (w’)
by w(v)
defined
with respect to since these
(w") (v,,)
=
w
=
=
-
(wO) (vo) -
..........
argument it follows that the components
same
for all vectors
and
(a) i
I
T,
Ozi ()3) ji ...
related
are
by
,
oki
...
k,
i, oil(0) ilj ...
I
1 jl
...
...
i7.
Hence the components
(U, W,,), (Up, W,3) (y, map 0,,, 0
by
Kn"n" Ox
x
construction of
--,
T,,rM
T,,rM
x
(0.)
we
0,, with respect to the charts isomorphism D,,,3. Thus the
of
linear
is
a
a
is indeed
diffeomor-
a
manifold. That TM is also
M and any chart (U, is a linear isomorphism. c
have TM
Definition 2.3.8. Let M be bundle
a
(WO (y), (D,,3 (W,3)))
bundle follows since for any
Tr(T M)
(0,3)
and
related
are
phism. We have shown that TM
By
of the compo-
-
we
the charts must then be related
components
(v,,,), (va) consisting
vectors
with respect to our charts are related by (v,,) have set W,O o, o (WO) 1. Let w be a 1-form. The
v
(wo), (wO) consisting
vectors
where
W,)
a
vector
the map
TOW.
=
and r,
manifold
is called the tensor bundle
of r
s
E
N U
01.
The vector
times contravariant and
s
times covariant tensors.
The tensor bundle
TIOM
is also denoted
by T*M
and called the cotan-
gent bundle of M.
A’Mof T,M defined by
The bundle of s-forms is the subbundle w
Ei
A’M
-#
w(vj, for
-
-
Vi....
-,
of
any set
(i, P
C
f 1,
-
The bundle of s-forms will
-
vj....
vectors
vp)
=
f vi,
-W(V,,...,Vi.... vi7 vp I and any pair I
.
.
.
...
vp)
,
.,Pl. play
a
fundamental r6le in Sect. 2.5
on
dif-
(which may be omitted on first reading). We will give an definition in Lemma 2.5.8. See also Definition 2.3.9 for the
ferential forms
equivalent
I
vector space
analogon As(V).
2.3 Tensors and tensor fields
77
In the rest of this algebraic section we will introduce the space of a special class of tensors which generalises the notion of de-
p4orms,
terminant and
plays
an
important r6le
in the
analysis
manifolds.
on
For instance, it is fundamental to the integration over a manifolds (cf. Sect. 2.5.4 below) and in the theory of differential systems (Bryant,
Chern, Gardner, Goldschmidt, and Griffiths 1991). However, the usefulness of this concept will only become clear in applications and not on this technical algebraic level. The material presented here will not be used before Sect. 2.5. The reader may therefore wish to postpone the study of the rest of this section.
It turns out that the symmetry operator sym is not of particular importance. On the other hand, tensors 0 which satisfy alt oo 0 generalise =
the determinant and therefore, deserve Definition 2.3.9. A form E
To (V) with alt 0 P
AP(V)
=
alt
The tensor
a
special definition.
(of degree p) (or simply p-form) The vector space
of
all
p-forms
is
a
tensor.
is denoted
by
(To(v)). P
product
Definition 2.3.10.
0 induces
product
a
A of forms:
product (or wedge product)
The exterior
A is the
bilinear map A:
AP(V)
x
Aq(V)
--+
(W, 77)
-4
AP+q(V), W
A 77
:=
p!q!
alt(w
0
(p+q)! is not the Remark 2.3.2. The normalisation factor p!ql
TI). only possible
choice and may appear to be rather unnatural. Other factors are also alt(w & 77). We common, in particular the alternative definition w7\,q =
have chosen
our
in formulas to
factor in order to minimise similar combinatorial factors
come
(see
Remark
2.3.3).
Our choice agrees with the choice of Bryant, Chern, Gardner, Goldschmidt, and Griffiths (1991) and (Abraham and Marsden 1978), but is
(Abraham and Marsden 1967) (Kobayashi and Nomizu 1963).
different from the normalisation factor in and the normalisation factor in Lemma 2.3.8.
(i) (u)An) (ii) W A 77
product
is associative and
AP(V),
n E Aq (V), and A E
AA =wA
(77AA)
and
=
hold.
The exterior E
concretely, formulas More
let
w
(_1)pq
77 A
W.
anti-symmetric.
Ar(V).
Then the
78
Analysis
2.
Proof. (i):
manifolds
on
We calculate
(w
7)
A
A A
((p + q) + r)! alt((w A n) & A) (p + q)!r! ((p + q) + r)! (p + # alt ((w & 7) (p + q)!r! p!q! (p + q + r)! alt(w Oq (D A).
=
-
-
0
A)
p!q!r!
Analogously
shows
one
A
w
(n A A)
(p+q+r) I alt (w Oq 0 p!q!r!
_
associativity.
q)
(ii): (q
=
which proves
Let 7-p+q E Sp+q be the permutation given by Tp+q(l + ) P Then we have sign(Tp+q) + p, 1, 1, (_I)pq and , q , q). ...
+
.
.
.
.
Tp+q (W (9
.
n) (V1
=
.
Vp+q)
W
0 77 (Vq+ 17
77 (D
Using these formulas w
A)
A 77
>"
L
Lemma 2.3.9. Let 1
(i) w A (ii) wl A (iii) wl A
*
1
p! q!
*
A wP
...
7
=
A WP
*
A
wl
A wP
...
sign (0-,+q) ’7p+q(W
(2)
77)
sign (Up+ q) sign (Tp+q) ’7p+q Tp+q(W
0
77)
,p+qESp+,l
(_l)pqT,
=
Vp+q)
,p+qESI,+q
(_I)pq
=
I
alt(w Oq)
I
p!q!
...
Vq)
Vq+pi Vl,.
7
obtain
we
p!q! p!q!
W(V11
...
sign(Cp+q)9p+q(?7
0
W)
+qESp+q
W.
....
wP E V* and irp E
Sp.
A w", (P) sign(7rp)w"P(1) A F,.,ES,, sign(up)wIz,(1) 0 ...
=
=
’PE
0
...
if
and
only if
the 1 -forms
w
0 WIP
1,
-
(P),
wP
are
linearly
dependent.
Proof (i):
Since
to prove this
transpositions generate all permutations, for a transposition
7rP (1 7.... But in this
it is sufficient
equality
case
i’j’...’n)
=
the assertion follows
immediately from Lemma
2.3.8.
2.3 Tensors and tensor fields
(ii):
The assertion is
clearly
true for p
79
2. Assume that it is true
=
for collections of up to q 1-forms wl.... I Wq and denote for any Uq E Sq the permutation (ij, .... iq+1) -4 (Uq(il), ’07q(iq) iq+1) by tq+l(gq)Then
we
have
w1A
A
...
w
q
A
I
q!
Wq+1 (V,,.
E
Vq+l)
,
sign(,Tq+l)(wl
q+1
A
A
...
Wq
(1)
1:
E
sign (-rq+ 1) sign(gq)W
T,I+iESq+l o-qESl
Wq (g
q!
.
", +jESq+j W
q!
.
’Y’
Y-
qESq
0
W
q
Wq+1 (Va q-Or,,+1(1)1
-,,+I
0
1:
W
I
Sign(tq+l (Uq)
VUqO’rq+1(q),
0
Tq+l)W
1
VT,1+1(q+l))
(9
...
ESq+j
q+1
(Vlq+
I
(Uq) 07’,1+ 1 (1)
Sign(Tq+l)W
1
0
1
’
*
’
7
Vtq+ 1 (Uq) 0r,,+ I (q+ 1) )
...
,T,I+iESq+l (9
(iii): a
If
W
U)q(9
1,
W
q+1
wP
are
linear combinations of
w ).
(q))
(1)
w
linearly dependent 2
There exist numbers ai of
we can assume
(otherwise we 2,...,p) with wl
wP
(i
that
w
1
is
could renumber the i=2
aiw’. Hence
right hand side
the
P
W1
A
...
Aw p
E Wi A U)2 A
...
A wP
i=2
products each of them containing some factor w3 twice. by (i). If the forms w 1, wP are linearly independent then we can complete w’ I of V*. Denote the dual basis by f e 1, them to a basis f w 1, 6n I If w’ A A wP would vanish then so would wl A A w’. However, we is the
sum
of
Hence all summands vanish
,
.
...
...
have
W1
A
...
A Wn
(el,
e,) all, E
S",
sign(a,,)J1,,,(j) a
a,, E
S"’
jn
o,,,,
(n)
.
-
,
-
80
2.
Analysis
manifolds
on
If lei,
Lemma 2.3.10.
en
1, 101’...’ Onj
is
a
pair of dual bases then
the set
fO" forms
a
basis
Proof. First
of
we
A
A 0"
...
AP(V)
the space
In
1 I
...
(n). p
particular, dim(AP(V))
show that this set of tensors is
linearly independent.
Let
be numbers such that
77
E
=
ij<
and let k, <
...
p-forms fO" Conversely, A
...
A
O’ll ji, <
0’7’(")
il
<
fO"
A
<
i,O"
A
A
0"
0
77(eki
=
all
are
7
...
,
ek,)
77ki
Sp
E
alt(TO(V)) P spans
==
we can
whence the
k,,,
linearly independent.
A
0"’(’P)
...
sign(up)O"
A
...
restrict to. those
AP(V) AP(V). Since =
0"’
A
0"
A
...
A
O’P with
ip,
The dimension of are
...
A
A
...
permutations up
...
...
know from Lemma 2’.3.2 and
we
that the set of vectors
for all
Then 0
kp.
<
77j,
...
exactly
(n) t
AP(V)
is
(n)
since from
p
choices of ordered
t-tuples
set of
a
without
n
elements there
duplication.
I
Definition 2.3.11. The map J: V
x
AP(V) (V, W)
1--> V
is called the interior
Proof. Wp+q-1
=
-i
(wj’...’ wp-,)
W:
product. If p
Lemma 2.3.11. Let
satisfies v J (w Aq) all q-forms 7).
AP-’(V)
-->
A
77(Wl
(P
7...
7
we
(wo J 71) (Wi,
set
E
1)!q!
+q- I
set
v
J
w
=
0.
v
=
wo. For any vectors wl,...’
sign(Up+q-l)W(WO,W,P+,,-,(l),
ESl,+q-1 X
and A
we
wp-l)
Wp+q-1)
7WO’j,+q-1(P-l))
(- 1)Pw
0
W(V’ Wi,
The interior product w E AP(V) and 0 E Aq(V). (v -i w) Aq + (- 1)P w A (v Jq) for all p-forms W and
For notational purposes G V we have
(WO J W)
=
-->
-
.
.
i
Wp+q- 1)
77(WO’T,+q-I(P)
......
W,,,+,,-I(p+q-1))
2
"
-11tHisors
11.’.F
I)P 1)!
p!(q X
Sign(Tp+q- 1)LO (W7-T,+,j-j (1)1
....
81
W7-j, +,, -I (P)
’rp+q-1ESp+q-1
77(W0IW-rp+q-I(P+1),’-I Ip+q-1(P+’1-1))* W
We consider
all
now
Wp+q-l)-
....
E
-
and tensor fields
We
possible permutations
of the ordered set
divide them into two
can
(wo, wl,
the group SP p+q
subgroups,
where one of the first p positions and the subgroup Sq p+q of the last q positions. Using this notation we can write
where wo is in it is in
one
wA?7(wo, wl,..., Wp+q-1) 1 =
p!q!
1:
(
sign(6’p+q)U) (W&,,+,, (0)
ID&,+,, (1),
7
-
-
-
,
W&,+,, (p- 1))
&, +, E S,’,’+ q X
W&p+q(p+q-1))
77(W&I,+q (P)
E
+
sign( p+q)U) (W. ,,+, (0))
10, p+"(P-1))
....
Sq
P+q
X
?7(W- p+q(P)7W’ p+q(P+I)I
....
Wr,,+q (p+q-
Consider the first summand. For each
by executing unique permutationCp+q-1
the first entry of is
a
w
( p+q
(&p+q)-1(0)
=
shift wo to
Sp+q-lwith
E
(- 1) (&p+q)-1(0) W (WO Wlp+ I
X
&p+q
can
IW&p+q(P-1))?7(W&p+q(P)I
W(W&P+q(0)1*
Observe that
Spp+qwe
E
transpositions. Hence there
is the
7(W,,+q (p),
*
*
"
I
WO’p+q (p+q- 1))
Composition Of
WO’Z)+q (P-
7
q
-
1 (&p+q)- (0) transpositions
and
the permutation i
This
each
implies sign(&p+q) of the p possible
one
I
E
p!q!
Up+ q (i)
for i > 0
0
for i
=
0.
(-1)(4+q)-I(0)sign(9p+q)entries of
sign(&p+q) W (W&I,+
q
w we
Since wo
can
be in
obtain
(0) 7 W&I,+,l (1)
1....
W&7,+,,(P-I))
E S"
p+q
X
P -
p!q!
’7(W&p+q(P)l
....
W&p+q(p+q-1))
sign(9p+q-I)W(W0, Wor,,+,I-j (1), X
q(W,P+ll-
I
(P) I
I
-
-
-
WUp+q- I (p+q-
,
W-p+q- I (P- 1))
82
Analysis
2.
manifolds
on
(Wo J w) Aq(wj,...’ Wp+q-1).
=
Consider
Sq
p+q
an
now
allows
the second summand. An
us
to
(-l)P
additional factor
transpositions,
a
wo to the first
move
since
E q
E
- p+q
entry of 17. In this case we obtain is the Composition Of (’ p+q)_1(0)
’rp+q (i)
for i > 0
0
for i
and the p transpositions which first entry of 17. This and we obtain .1.
for
permutation
i
p!q!
’ p+q
analogous argument
wo from
move
implies Sign(’ p+q)
sign(’ p+q)U)(W_ p+q(0)
7
0,
=
the first entry of -, P+’)
(-I)P(-I)(
=
W’ p+q(l
I...
1
to the
w
(O)T(07p+q)
M 7’+’J(P_ I))
’q ’
Sp+q >(
77
(W’ p
(-’)P- L
+q
p!q!
W- ,,+,(p+q-1))
(P)
E
Sigll(Tp+q- 1)W (WTI,+q-
7’
1
Wr,,+q- 1 (P))
’rp+q-jESp+q-1 77 (WO,
X
=
W-r,)+q
(p + 1) 1...
I
-
(-1)PW
A
7
W-r,,+,,_j(p+q-1))
(Wo J 77)(Wi,..., Wp+q-1). I
Finally,
we
relate the
theory of p4orms to
the determinant of linear maps. following from linear al-
To motivate the definition below recall the
gebra. Assume that orthonormal basis
have
we
Euclidean scalar
an
f ej,...’ e"j.
If
fol’...’ onj
product (, -) and
is the dual basis then
an
one
A on in order to measure the volume of parallel can use the n-form 01 A b, G V one defines the volume of the epipeds. For any vectors bl, A 0 n(bi, parallel epiped spanned by these vectors to be 01 A bn)This number depends on the chosen scalar product but not on the or...
.
.
.
,
...
.
thonormal basis. The determinant of
defined
as
det(B)
:=
01
This definition of
.
.
,
linear map B: V -* V is often B ej. where bi , b,,) determinant obscures the fact that the deter-
A
a
...
A on
(b 1,
a
.
.
=
.
independent of the choice of scalar product. The following equivalent definition is probably the most natural way to introduce the minant is
concept of
a
determinant.
Definition 2.3.12. Let V be k-dimensional vector space
an
over
n-dimensional vector space, W be and A: V -4 W a linear map.
(i)
The pull-back of 0 under A is the defined by A* 0 (vi, (Avi, vp) .
.
.
,
a
K,
.
.
map A*: .
,
vp).
TO (W) P
--->
T’ (V) P
2.3 Tensors and tensor fields
(ii)
W. An(V) \ 10} and assume that V det(A) of A is the number defined by A*/-t
Let tz G
minant
83
Then the deter-
=
det(A)M.
=
We have to show that the map det is well defined. First observe that A* maps A,(V) into AP(V) and recall that An is 1-dimensional by Lemma 2.3. 10. Hence A* y must be a multiple of M. If A is any other non-vanishing n-form then there exists a number a 7-1 0 with A ap. Hence we have =
A*A(vl,.
Vn)
=
A*(a/-t)(vl,..., vn)
det(A)M(vj,..., vn)
=a
which
implies that
a/-t(Avl,..., Avn) det(A)A(vj,..., vn)
=
det(A)
definition for
our
=
does not
depend
on
the
chosen n-form. Lemma 2.3.12. Let V be
an
n-dimensional vector space A: V
linear map and Let the components be
f el....
a
A3
A* (Ol
A
...
A O’P
)
particular
we
n1, fO’7
E ( E
==
.... =:
onj be a. pair of dual bases. rnj= 1 A3j ej. Then we have A"’
sign(up)A"0,7, Ul
( P)) Oil A
17P
...
AOiP.
U7,ESP
jl<...<jp
In
e
7
V
--
defined by Aej
be
K,
over
have
sign(un)A’,, M
det(A)
An
-
a
an
a,,
(n)
E S ,,
Proof. We calculate A*O’l
A
...
A =
O’P (ej,,
.
.
.
I
ej,)
E sign(up)O"(Ae,,,(j,)).....O’P(Ae,p(jp)) orp E Sp
sign(o-p)A" 01P 01)
An
UP
07,
Up E S7,
Remark 2.3.3. We have noted in Remark 2.3.2 above that
torial factors mark
2.3.2)
are
not the
only possible
instead of A,
we
would have had to re-define vj w
in order to preserve Lemma 2.3.11. Another
that the
our
advantage
of
our
simple formula
01
A
...
A
holds for any pair of dual bases
on(e
combina-
choice. If we had chosen A
-
-
-,
en)
=
I
fei1iE{1,...,nj7 joi LE 1,...,nj
-
(cf.
=
p
v
Re_j
w
choice is
Analysis
2.
84
manifolds
on
2.3.2 Tensor fields
Ap.7 5 p. 75
In this section
All
geometrical
and
physical
introduce tensor fields which
we
in terms of tensor fields
U
M
we
tensor valued maps.
will encounter
be defined
can
maps of tensor fields.
of
The vector space
Definition 2.3.13.
0:
or
structures
are
T,M
OW
with
all smooth maps
E
T,(T M)
Vx c M
xEM
by TI(M). These maps are Ox instead of O(x). A (1) -tensor field is a vector field. 0
is denoted
called
(’)-tensor
fields.
Often
S
we
will write
(0) -tensor field
A
with
w
P
W(vj’... for
of
any set
vi)
5
...
7
vj....
vp)
=
Ivil
...
I
vi’...
and any pair (i,j) C p. A differential form
fvl,...,vpl
vectors
-w(vi....
VP)
j1,...’pj
is
of degree p is degree a p-form. often simply M be a smooth map. An Let Z be another manifold and f : Z Z is field a Ts’(M) such that O(x) E along f map 0: (’)-tensor Z.all G x T" (Tf (x) N) for Vector fields and differential forms along f are defined analogously. M its canonical inclusion If Z is a submanifold of M and f: Z then we also say that 0 is a tensor field along Z. called
a
differential form of called
S
--+
(x’,
Let
.
.
.
I
Xn)
be
coordinate system and denote
a
by 91,.
..,
an
its
GauBian basis. Its pointwise dual basis is given by the derivatives (dx’, dx’) (cf. Definition 2.2.7). With respect to these coordinates, any ...
,
(’)-tensor
field
S
0
can
be written
Oi31.1
Ow 1
...
1 jj where the
0’.31
...
j.
...
...
...
Z"
j.
as
(X),Oil
(9
...
0
aj,
0 dx-11 (9
...
(D dx3
i,.
j,, n
are
functions.
They
are
the components
(or component
xn). If functions) of the tensor 0 with respect to the coordinates (x the tensor will field often tensor we is a covariant symmetric drop
(0,)
0 in order to indicate that the
product sign sym has been
sym(O)(x) If N is
a
tensor field
pull-back.
symmetrisation operator
applied, =
1: 1
<
ji
...
second manifold and
T-’(N) P
induces
a
j, :5 nOj,...j, (x) dxjl
f:
M --4N
unique
This tensor field is defined
by
a
...
dxj,
smooth map then each * f 0 E To (M), its
tensor field
P
[ [I
P. 8 p.
2.3 Tensors and tensor fields
f *0., (vl,..., vp)
85
Of ( ,) (Tf (vi),..., Tf (vp)),
:=
Tf : TM --+ TN denotes the derivative of f (Definition 2.2.8). Analogously, each tensor field c TOP (M) induces a unique tensor field f,, c- TOP(N), its push-forward. It is defined by WP) := N is a local of(.,) (wl o Tf,...,wP o Tf). If ?p c- T,(N) and g: M diffeomorphism we define the pull-back of 0 by
where
...,
--
g*,O(vl.... 7vS1W11 :=
0
...
I
Wr)
((g.(V,),
WT (WI)7
-,g-(V ’),
(g-,)* pr))
....
This definition agrees with the definition of pull-back above if 0 is a G T,(M) by push forward of a tensor field
covariant tensor field. The a
local
diffeomorphism g is defined by push-forward agree.
g*
(g-’)
=
If
s
=
0 then
both definitions of
Lemma 2.3.13. For every local diffeomorphism g: M tensor fields 0, 0 C Tr (M) we have
g*(ao
+
g*(O
00)
=
ag*O
b)
=
g*0 (D g*O,
,O
=
C; g*o
0
g *cg
+
--
N and all
Og*o,
If g fails to be a diffeomorphism, and 0, 0 are covariant vector fields then the first two assertions are still true. Analogous statements also hold for the push-forward. Proof. The lemma follows directly
from the definitions.
Remark 2.3.4. It is often practical to denote a tensor field 0 E T,1’ (M) by a, with respect to an unspecified GauBian basis. The components Oal bi
its
...
...
b,.
indices a,.... a, bi b, are "dummy indices" and their only purpose is to give a convenient method for explicitly denoting the entries of the ...
tensor field.
0,
By convention, the tensor is characterised by the core symbol a, cr I .6 However, different general we have Oai Oc, bi b,, di d, 7 Od d, fields of different order can be denoted by the same core symbol
in
so
c
...
tensor
...
since it is clear from the number of
they
must be different
If we
a,,3
...
==
...
E
K, 0,
co-
1
...
and contravariant indices that
objects.
are
two
(’) -tensor S
field, and V)
is
an
-tensor field
write
In
some
East
the exact
European countries, some authors use conventions which are C7. opposite of ours, i.e., they have in general 0,1...a, Ocl b, 0 bl d, dl ...
...
dl
...
d,
It
seems
likely that this
variant will fade in the
near
...
future.
86
Analysis
2.
on
(aO
manifolds
,)
+
al
bi
...
...
a,
a0ai bi
b,,
a,+j )ai bi_b,+,
(0 .
jai
...
Cg ,)ai bi
a,.-,
...
...
’Pb1
Oal bi
b_1
...
...
...
...
Since the indices determine the entries
a,V)ai-..ai Oal bi bs bi bg ...
a,
a,.
/a,
b
00al bi
+
b,,
...
aj _i caF%+l
...
ai
bizi
Oai bi
a,
b,
bii
b,;-l cbg+1
...
...
...
ai
...
bi
...
...
explicitly,
Oal bi
...
...
...
...
a_1
b,,-l
we can
write
a,.
...
b,
...
The notation for contraction is often called the Einstein summation If in
vention:
product
a
of tensors
index and somewhere else has to
sum over
We will also a
basis,
for
as a
these indices in the
use
con-
index letter appears as an upper lower index then it is understood that one one
corresponding coordinate expression.
this notation in order to write
tensor with
a
respect
to
instance, n
Aaaa b
0
dXb
=
Aaaa b
0
dXb.
a,b=l
Symmetrisation and anti-symmetrisation
SYM(O)i
.
.....
i"
and
=
denoted
are
alt(O)i
.
.....
i,
=
0[i
by .
.....
i,;]
An
analogous notation is used for contravariant tensors and for the case that symmetrisation or anti-symmetrisation is only applied to a subset of entries. We is not
use
I
the delimiters
to indicate that
a
certain subset of entries
symmetrised (respectively, anti-symmetrised).
For
instance,
Oab[cdJ(ef)gJhJ i(jJkJ1J(mn)Jo) indicates that the entries corresponding to the indices f c, d, hJ are antisymmetrised and that the entries corresponding to the indices f e, f 1, Jj, 1, ol, Im, nj are each symmetrised. This abstract index notation should not be confused with the
ponents of the
tensor field with
mulas appear to be
identical,
to, whereas in the latter
respect
to
a
given
com-
basis. While all for-
in the former case, the tensor is referred
case one
simply has
a
collection of K-valued
functions.
The main
advantages
notation without indices
of the abstract index notation
over
the usual
that tensor operations are easy to remember since tensors look like their components and that even complicated
multiple
are
contractions and tensor
products can be understood at a glance. disadvantage is that many formulas look unnecessarily clumsy because of the jungle of indices involved. In the physical literature, the abstract index notation is usually preferred and in the mathematical literature the notation without indices is prevalent. In this book, we will
The main
2.4 Vector fields and
both notations.
use
will not
we
reserve
However, unlike
ordinary differential equations
physics literature here special ranges. Moreover, we will
in most of the
certain indices for
sometimes write the summation
2.4 Vector fields and
87
in order to indicate the range.
sign
ordinary
differential
equations
If -y: K --+ M is a curve then for each t E K the vector (t) -= Tt-y(l) is a vector in Ty(t)M. The following question arises naturally: given a vector
field V to
a
M, does there
on
chart, the
answer
exist
a
curvey with
given by
is
(t)
=
V7(t)?
With respect
the fundamental theorem for
ordinary
differential equations which establishes the existence and uniqueness of solutions. Because of its importance we will state it below. However this theorem should
(for mathematicians) 1960, chapter 10) for Theorem 2.4.1
V c
K’, j
C
really be treated or a
proof
courses on analysis physicists. See also (Dieudonn6 slightly more general context.
in
a
(Fundamental
j
f)
c
j
x
V
(to, xo, yo) of (to, yo)
E
j
and
Let U c
K’,
(t,x,y) -->f(t,x,y)
f:j’xUxV-+Kn,
x
ODEs.).
theorem for and
subsets,
K be open
be C’. For each
in standard
mathematics for
U
x a
x
V there exists
unique
map -y:
(t, y)
neighbourhood
a
F-->
-y(t, x)
E
]Kn
with
d-y (t, y)
f (t, -Y (t, Y), Y)
dt
for all (t, y)
E
j
x
V and
-y(to, yo)
=
xo.
Further,
straightforwardly
This theorem translates
Theorem 2.4.2. Let M be
a
smooth
7 is C’.
to manifolds.
manifold and
V be
a
vector
field
M. For every X E M there exists a subset j C K and a curve x and (t) Vy(t) for all t E Jr. -yx: J --+ M with -yx(O) If VX : 0 there exists a neighbourhood U of jxj x 101 C M x R on
=
=
such that the map F: U -- M, (t, y) 1--4 Ft (y) -yy (t) is well defined. Moreover, the map y -4 Fi(y) is a local diffeomorphism for each i, and =
its inverse is
For t, The
s
curve
given by F -i.
small
enough
-y is called
an
we
have Ft
integral
o
curve
F,
=
Ft+,.
and the map
Ft the flow of V.
Proof Let (U, o) be a chart centered at x. Then the fundamental theorem ordinary differential equations (Theorem 2.4.1) implies that there
for
exists
a
solution
0(t)
of the differential equation
d dt
NO
=
( O-V)’3(t)
88
Analysis
2.
13(0)
with -/ ’ (0)
=
o(x).
=
manifolds
on
Hence 7,,
o-’
=:
o
0
is
integral
an
curve
of V with
X.
That F is smooth and well defined follows from the fact that
integral depend smoothly on parameters (cf. Theorem 2.4.1). The map (Fi)-’ is given by (Fi)-’(z) -y_(i) where -y- is the locally unique of -V with curve integral -y-(O) z. Hence Fi is differentiable and has curves
=
=
a
differentiable inverse. The equation
of differential
Ft o F, follows from local uniqueness ’of solutions Ft+, and the fact that both t equations Ft+, (y) and Ft o F, (y) =
-->
are
integral
curves
An
integral
curve
j
-y:
-4
M of
same
a
initial value.
I
vector field V is called maximal if
integral : j --+ M with j C j C K implies J. By the lemma of Zorn and local existence of integral curves
the existence of
j
of V with the
=
an
curve
each
integral curve is contained in some maximal integral curve. The R maximal -integral following Proposition shows that in the case K =
unique.
curves are
Proposition
2.4.1.
j
unique solution -y
C
K and
Proof.
a
Let -y,
If
K
=
R then there is
of - (t)
=
unique maximal subset Vy(t) defined on j. a
be
integral curves of V with -y(O) integral curves coincide on the
=
(O)
=
x.
We must
j of j. In order to do so we will prove that the set IC It E j n j : -y(t) (t)j is both open and closed. Since in the case K R the set jnj is the intersection of two open intervals and therefore show that these
intersection j n
their domains J,
=
=
=
connected, this
set must then coincide with 1C. It is clear that IC is closed.
(U, o)
Let t E K and
be
a
chart centered at
y(t)
=
=
(t).
Given local
coordinates, problem finding integral curve solving a system of ordinary differential equations. An application of the fundamentat theorem for ordinary differential equation (Theorem 2.4. 1) proves that there is a unique local integral curve 0 through 0(: ). Hence there is a neighbourhood of t such that -/ on this neighbourhood. I the
of
of V reduces to
an
=
The
theorem
following
fields
implies that, locally,
Theorem 2.4.3. Let M be vector x
field
with
V(x) 7
such that
(P-
1
(t, X2,
...’
Proof. Let be
There is
a
0.
a
smooth manifold,
Then there is
and the
non-vanishing
vector
integral
N be
an
(n
curves
x
chart
of
V
G
M, and
(U, W) are
V be
a
centered at
given by
t
I)-dimensional submanifold of M through x (i.e., RV(y) (D TyN TyM for all y c N). Let
-
chart of N centered at
an E
a
xn).
which is transverse to V
(V, 0)
all
alike.
are
> 0
such that the map
=
x
and denote the flow of V
by Ft.
2.4 Vector fields and
f (- 6, 0
X
(X 1, X 2’..
0M
M,
n)
FX,
X
.’
is well defined. The differential of
FO
=
ordinary differential equations
f
(2.4.1)
(0 -1(X2.... X’))
(2.4.2)
1
at 0 is
df (xl,.
id and
89
an
)(01
X’)
dx
isomorphism
V(X) =A
since
0.
0
a neighbourhood VV of 0 where this map is an diffeomorphism. The pair (U, W) (f (W), (f 1) ju) is therefore a chart centered at x. For any y E U denote by (yo, prN M) E R x N C R x M the unique pair defined by Fy,) (prN M) y. Then we have o o Ft (y) -’ 1 o Ft (y) f o Ft+yo (prN M) (t + yo, 0 (prN (y))). Hence the intef gral curves of V are indeed the curves t F--+ o‘(tX2’...’Xn). It follows I Ox immediately that o. V
Hence there exists
-
=
=
=
-
=
=
=
Given in
a
vector field
V,
1
-
one can
define the derivative of
a
tensor fiels
direction V.
Definition 2.4.1. Let and
E
x
M, V) be
tensor
a
field,
U be
a
vector
field,
Ft the flow of U. Then
((d) Ft*,O) ,
XU’O(X) is the Lie derivative
(-!!-) dt jt=O
Here sion x
Ft*V)
dt
(x)
It=0
of 0.
is the usual derivative in vector spaces. In
denotes
a
tensor field which is
if t is fixed and small
evaluated at
:=
x.
As
a
enough.
In
defined
particular,
function of t this gives
on a
fact, the
this tensor field
a curve
expres-
neighbourhood can
of
be
in the vector space
T’r (TX M) The Lie derivative
measures
Lemma 2.4.1. Let V be rection V is
a
a
the
vector
derivation, i.e., for
.Cv( O 0 0) -COW + 0)
=
=
change
field.
of
0 along
V.
Then the Lie derivative in di-
any tensor
fields p,,O
the
formulas
CVW 0’0 + W 0 -PVO, -Coo + 40.
hold.
Proof. These formulas follow immediately from the properties of derivatives.
I
90
2.
Analysis
on
manifolds
Theorem 2.4.4. Let
U,
V be vector
fields
and
f
smooth
a
function.
Then
XUf =Uof and .CUV*f =U*Vof -V*Uof. Proof.
.Cuf Let
X
The first d
=
at-It=0
Ft*f (x)
E M and
V C U of
x
equation follows immediately from
(U, p)
and
d
Tt I t=0 f oFt(x)
=
be
a
chart centered at
number
a
of
a
(t, y)
E
(dt d
-
It=o
Ft (x)
There is
df (Ux).
neighbourhood
a
Ft (y) is well defined and
(- 6, E)
V. An
x
application
of
formula to the map t i--+ f o F-t o o-’ implies the existence smooth map j: (-,E, c) x o(V) -- R with f o F-t o W- 1 (z) f (z) +
Taylor
=
tj(t, z) for all (t, z) E f (Ft) (y) f (y) + tgt (y) o
=
d
-dt I t=o (Ft*V).,
"
((Ft V)
dt lt=o d
d
(VFt, (x)
dt I t=o 0
V
0
where in the last step
==
=
V
Vx
satisfies
==
dt It=o
(((F-t),,V),,
9
f)
d
-
gO)X
d
f)
(dt
f)X we
d
0
df
9
0
*
dt It=o
0
w(y))
(((F- t) VFt (x)) f) =dt (VFt (x) (f I t=o
=::
(U
V. The map gt(y) := j(t, for all y E V and we obtain x
f
d
(V
x.
> 0 such that
e
satisfies Ft (y) E U for all for all the
df
==
It=o
(f
*
(V
-
+ 0
e
d
t9t))
U
0
=
-
dt It=o
(V
*
f)Ft(x)
F-
o
+
Vx
t)) 90
f),
have used
f
o
d
it-lt=o
(Ft)
-
1
(-)
)
=
Vx
9
(V
0
df
X
(F- t) (-)
U
0
(
d
dt lt=o
(Ft)
f),
Theorem 2.4.4 shows that the Lie derivative of V in direction U is the commutator of U and V. This motivates the
Definition 2.4.2. the Lie bracket
if
or
If U,
V
are
their Lie bracket vanishes.
fields
vector
the commutator
of
following
then
U and V.
we
definition.
call
Vector
[U, V] fields
=
CUV
commute
2.4 Vector fields and
Commuting
91
are of particular interest since GauBian vector necessarily commuting. The following lemma gives the
vector fields
49,,k, 19.,1
fields
ordinary differential equations
are
to this observation.
converse
(Geometri’c interpretation of the Lie bracket). fields U, V have vanishing Lie derivative, CUV 0, if and only if their flows commute.
Lemma 2.4.2
Two vector
=
Proof Denote the flows of U and V by Ft and G,. The equation Ft o G, G, is the flow of V. Hence we have G, o Ft implies that F-t o G, o Ft o G, o Ft) V Ft*V and therefore T(Ft)-l (jd,,G,) o Ft jd-,,(F-t ds ds =
=
=
=
d
_pUV
( dt ) t=0
=
Conversely, *
Since Fo V that
s 1--4
integral
F-t
o
curves
Ft V
=
(-.4-) dt t=0
V
that X UV
assume
=
0.
0 which is
=
equivalent
* to - !- Ft V
dt
=
0.
V for all t. This implies integration yields (Ft) V G, o Ft is an integral curve of V. From the uniqueness of I we get F-t o Gs o Ft G, for all t, s.
V
=
*
*
an
=
=
a n-dimensional manifold and f U1,...’ U"T pointwise linearly independent, pairwise commuting vector fields defined on an open neighbourhood of x E M. Then there exists a coordinate chart (V, p) centred at x whose Gauflian basis vector fields Ui. satisfy Oxi
2.4.1. Let M be
Corollary be
a
collection
=
Proof.
Denote the flow of
k Uk by Ft and let
O(X’,...,x’)
=
F.1,
o
...
o
F.1, (x)
sufficiently small (xl,...,x’) E K’. Since the vector fields Uj are pairwise commuting so are their flows F j (cf. Lemma 2.4-2). Hence we for
have for every i E
O(X 11
...
fl,...’nj
Ix n)
=
This
implies V).(Ei)
basis
JE1,...’ Ej
Fx i Fx1,
=
o
d
(Xi
o
,
...
0
-1
_P i_l
0
P+1 Xi_1
p(X1’...’xn))
of K’. Since the vector fields
=
0
...
o
F; , (x).
Uj for the standard
f U1,...’ U,,j
are
linear
independent the map 0 has maximal rank and is therefore a local diffeomorphism. Let VV C K’ be an open neighbourhood of 0 such that O(z) is well defined for all z E W and one-to-one on W. We can now define
A W)
=
(V)()/V)l 0-1).
1
Corollary 2.4.2. Let M be a 2-dimensional manifold and U, V be vector fields which are at each point linearly independent. Then M admits local coordinates (XI, X2) such that a,,i 11 U anda,,2 11 V.
92
Analysis
2.
on
Proof. By Corollary f, h with [f U, hV]
2.4.1
=
[f U, hV]
we.
have to show that there exist functions
only
0. We calculate
=
0
manifolds
Vf U(hV)
=
=
f h17UV
=
f h[U, V]
=
f h QU, V]
-
+ -
’7hVf U
f dh(U)
-
hdf (V)U
+ d
f h17VU
hdf (V)U
-
f dh(U)V
+
ln(h)(U)V
d
-
ln(f)(U)V).
wu, wV be the 1-forms which are dual to U, V. Then any solution (f, h) of the uncoupled system of linear ordinary differential equations
Let
0
=
d
ln(h) (U)
-
wV QU, V]),
0
=
d ln(f) (V) +
wu ([U, V])
[f U, hV] 0. This system of differential equations can be solved by the fundamental theorem for ordinary differential equations 2.4. 1. 1
satisfies
In the
=
following
sections
we
will encounter various kinds of tensor deriva-
tiv,es. It is therefore practical Definition 2.4.3. Let D be
fields. If
it
to formalise their a
common
map which maps tensor
properties.
fields
into tensor
satisfies
(i) D(T,(M)) C T,’(M), (ii) D(W 0 0) D(O) 0 W + V) 0 D(W) ("product rule"), (iii) D commutes with contractions, =
then D is called
Corollary
derivation.
a
2.4.3. Let M be
The Lie-derivative
Proof.
Ft*Cr^o
Xv
We have to =
S
CrFt*o 8
derivative
d
dt
a
manifold and
V be
a
verify only
Proof. Writing
an
field
on
M.
the third property. This follows from
Ft*o
CfFt*0
-4
is linear
(so
the
interchanged with this operation).
Proposition 2.4.2. Two derivations coincide if they fields and junctions.
we
vector
derivation.
a
and the fact that
be
can
is
arbitrary
tensor field
V)
in
coincide
on
vector
a
coordinate representation
(9
dxj,
obtain
Do
=
D(0’1‘,9j, ii j.,
0
...
(9
...
aj,
0
dxjl
(9
...
r
+
E’O"ii
+
-
-
-3,",9j,
3,
t=1
aj,
0... &
D(ai,)
&
aj,
...
&
(2)
0... 0
dxjl
(3
aj,
...
0
0
dxjl
(9
D(dx3")
...
(9
0
...
dxjl
(9
dxjl.
2.4 Vector fields and
Hence
we
only have
ordinary
to show that D is
differential equations
uniquely determined
93
for tensor
But this follows from D(w(V)) & V)) EO(M). D(C’(w I I Cll(D(w&V)) Cj1(DwOV+wODV)) Dw(V)+w(DV) for arbitrary I vector fields V and tensor fields w E 710 (M)
fields
E
w
=
=
=
-
Recall that vector fields tions. We show
alised to
now
can
be considered
b,
D,
can
on
func-
be gener-
be derivations. Then the commutator
[D, D] a
acting
arbitrary derivations.
Lemma 2.4.3. Let
is also
derivations
as
that the commutator of vector fields
derivation.
D
:=
D
o
-
D
o
D
Moreover, the Jacobi identity
[D, [D, b]]
+
[D, [D, D]]
[D, [D, D]]
+
=
0
holds.
Proof. For the