SOUTH PACIFIC MUSEUMS EXPERIMENTS IN CULTURE EDITED BY CHRIS HEALY AND ANDREA WITCOMB
Published by Monash University ePress Matheson Library Building 4, Monash University Clayton, Victoria 3800, Australia www.epress.monash.edu.au First published 2006 Copyright © 2006 All rights reserved. Apart from any uses permitted by Australia’s Copyright Act 1968, no part of this book may be reproduced by any process without prior written permission from the copyright owners. Inquiries should be directed to the publisher.
DESIGN A. Katsionis (www.katsionis.com) COVER IMAGES The ‘Uluru’ line. National Museum of Australia. Photograph: Naomi Stead. Jean-Marie Tjibaou statue. Photograph: Kylie Message. Courtesy ADCK-Centre Culturel Tjibaou/Renzo Piano Building Workshop, Architectes. Centre Culturel Tjibaou. Photograph: David Becker. © Centre Culturel Tjibaou – ADCK/ Renzo Piano Building Workshop, Architectes. PRINT ER Sydney University Publishing Service This book is available online at www.epress.monash.edu/spm
ISBN ISBN-13 ISBN ISBN-13
0-9757475-8-4 (pb) 978-0-9757475-8-2 (pb) 0-9757475-9-2 (web) 978-0-9757475-9-9 (web)
Pages: 232
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS This collection has its origins in an Australian Research Council Discovery Project lead by Chris Healy, Gaye Sculthorpe and Paul Walker. We acknowledge that support. Kylie Message, Perrie Ballantyne and Hilary Ericksen all played crucial roles in that research project, which included the symposium ‘The Re-Birth of the Museum’ held at the University of Melbourne in July 2004, at which some of the essays here were first presented. We are grateful to all of the symposium participants for making that event so generative and to the Department of English and the Faculty of Arts at the University of Melbourne for their financial support. Tony Birch, Alison Huber and Paul Williams focused and sharpened Chris Healy’s perspective on the museum. Emmanuel Kasarhérou, the cultural director at the Centre Culturel Tjibaou, and Patrick Greene, the CEO of Museum Victoria, were both generous in responding to our questions. Isabelle de Solier was an invaluable research assistant in the later stages of this project. Penny Johnson was, as always, a wonderful editor. At Monash University ePress, Michele Sabto saw the potential in this collection that others could not, Joanne Mullins in production was a dream to work with and Sarah Cannon gave it an energetic launch into the markets to which it is now consigned. We are grateful to all of the copyright holders for permission to reproduce the images here. Publication of this work was assisted by a publication grant from the University of Melbourne.
SOUTH PACIFIC MUSEUMS MONASH UNIVERSITY EPRESS
iii
ABOUT SYMPOSIUM PAGINATION
A NOTE ABOUT PAGINATION AND CHAPTER IDENTIFICATION Page numbers in this book do not run consecutively across chapters. Instead, page numbering restarts on the first page of each chapter and is prefaced by the chapter number. Thus 01.1 is chapter one, page one; 01.2 is chapter one, page two; 02.1 is chapter two, page one; 02.2 is chapter two, page two; and so on. In the Table of Contents, each chapter is listed with its chapter number (01, 02, 03, etc.) only. This system, in which page numbering is self-contained within each chapter, allows the publisher, Monash University ePress, to publish individual chapters online.
iv
SOUTH PACIFIC MUSEUMS MONASH UNIVERSITY EPRESS
SOUTH PACIFIC MUSEUMS EXPERIMENTS IN CULTURE
CONTENTS INTRODUCTION 01
Experiments in culture: An introduction — Chris Healy and Andrea Witcomb
NEW MUSEUMS 02
Reforming nationhood: The free market and biculturalism at Te Papa — Paul Williams
03
Museums of New Caledonia: The old, the new and the balance of the two — Marianne Tissandier
04
Contested sites of identity and the cult of the new: The Centre Culturel Tjibaou and the constitution of culture in New Caledonia — Kylie Message
05
National Museum of Australia — Linda Young
06
Pluralism and exhibition practice at the National Museum of Australia — Mathew Trinca and Kirsten Wehner
07
Melbourne Museum — Ian McShane
08
Civic laboratories: Museums, cultural objecthood and the governance of the social — Tony Bennett
NEW KNOWLEDGES 09
Museums as cultural guardians — Deidre Brown
10
The Museum of New Zealand Te Papa Tongarewa — Huhana Smith
11
There’s so much in looking at those barks: Dja Dja Wurrung etchings 2004–05 — Pamie Fung and Sara Wills
12
Gab Titui Cultural Centre — Leilani Bin-Juda
13
The museum as cultural agent: The Vanuatu Cultural Centre extension worker program — Lissant Bolton
14
Tuning the museum: The harmonics of official culture — Ian Wedde
15
Bunjilaka — Moira G. Simpson
16
Very special treatment — Chris Healy
NEW EXPERIENCES 17
Hiroshima mon amour: Representation and violence in new museums of the Pacific — Diane Losche
18
The Auckland War Memorial Museum, Tamaki Paenga Hira — Elizabeth Rankin
19
The National Museum of Australia as danse macabre: Baroque allegories of the popular — John Macarthur and Naomi Stead
20
The Museum of Sydney — Kate Gregory
21
How style came to matter: Do we need to move beyond the politics of representation? — Andrea Witcomb
22
The Australian Centre for the Moving Image — Natalia Radywyl
23
Spirit house — Ross Gibson
INTRODUCTION
EXPERIMENTS IN CULTURE: AN INTRODUCTION Chris Healy, The University of Melbourne Chris Healy teaches cultural studies at the University of Melbourne. His publications include The lifeblood of Footscray (editor, 1986), Beasts of suburbia (co-editor, 1994), From the ruins of colonialism (1997), Cultural Studies Review (co-editor, 2002–06), South Pacific museums (co-editor, 2006) and Forgetting Aborigines (forthcoming 2007). Correspondence to Chris Healy:
[email protected] Andrea Witcomb, Deakin University Andrea Witcomb is an associate professor in the Faculty of Arts at Deakin University. She has also worked as a curator at the Australian National Maritime Museum and at the National Museum of Australia, and is the author of Re-imagining the museum: Beyond the mausoleum (2003). Correspondence to Andrea Witcomb:
[email protected]
The last two decades have witnessed an explosion in the development of new public and private museums throughout the world. If this is surprising it is only because, for much of the last 50 years, museums have been regarded by many scholars and cultural critics as, if not extinct, then certainly archaic institutions far from the cutting edge of cultural innovation. This judgment is being proved wrong across the globe as innovative and distinctive museums are staking out new territory for themselves as vital, dynamic, public and civic cultural institutions. Nowhere is this most striking than in the South Pacific where large, new or significantly expanded public museums and cultural centres have opened since the 1990s, including the Museum of New Zealand Te Papa Tongarewa, the National Museum of Australia, the Melbourne Museum, Australian Centre for the Moving Image, the Museum of Sydney, the Gab Titui Cultural Centre in the Torres Strait, the Centre Culturel Tjibaou and the Vanuatu Cultural Centre. Many more museums in that region have undertaken major renovations. South Pacific museums: Experiments in culture brings together a collection of outstanding analysis of these museums by cultural, museum and architectural critics, and historians. A series of snapshots introduces the reader to key museums in the region while the essays explore these museum developments in the broadest possible terms. The museums under analysis are part of the complex field of heritage, where national economies meet global tourism, where cities brand themselves, where indigeneity articulates with colonialism, where exhibitionary technologies and pedagogies meet entertainment, where histories are fought over, where local identities intersect with academic and popular knowledge, where objects and provenance are displayed and contested, where remembering and forgetting dance their endless dance. Our key metaphor in this collection is to consider museums as experiments in culture. Many of our contributors have taken a lead from Tony Bennett’s essay here on museums as ‘civic laboratories’. Bennett suggests that museums can be thought of as cultural assemblages – institutions that bring together people and expertise, artefacts, texts and architecture, all of which are organised in particular ways. Thus museums place visitors in particular relationships to objects in ways that make real ‘prehistory’ or community or art. This perspective is particularly useful for analysing museums in a state of flux or museums as places in which ‘culture’ can be made and remade in different ways. So, for example, many of the contributions to this collection are interested in exploring how national or indigenous interests are experimenting with museum collections that were first put together for entirely different and often antithetical purposes. As
SOUTH PACIFIC MUSEUMS MONASH UNIVERSITY EPRESS
01.1
Bennett has indicated elsewhere (Bennett 2004), it is an approach that can be taken to museums devoted to natural history, technology or art, but here, in the main, our focus is on historical and cultural museums. The metaphor – museums as experiments in culture – is our way into how these museums can be understood as exemplars of what Chris Healy and Kylie Message (2004) call the ambiguous ‘new museum’ phenomenon. In other words, we want to make sense of these museums as selfconsciously new institutions created in the midst of major political, economic and social transformations. Recent worldwide museum developments are, in part, local cultural responses to globalised markets and industries. Not unlike the ways in which a state will build or upgrade transport infrastructure, museums are being renovated so as to produce a better fit between national or city cultural infrastructure and emerging needs. States expect publicly funded museums to play their role in national or regional economies, whether as centrepieces in the reinvigoration of formerly industrial areas as tourist and leisure precincts, or as attempts to re-fashion entire regional or national economies (Witcomb 2003; Kirschenblatt-Gimblett 1998). From Albert Dock in Liverpool or the Guggenheim in Bilbao to the Powerhouse and Darling Harbour in Sydney, Federation Square in Melbourne, Te Papa in New Zealand or the Centre Culturel Tjibaou in New Caledonia, museums have become important icons of new and emerging consumer cultures. Rather than a repository for dinosaurs or archaically dinosaur-like, museums have actually become signs of ‘the new’. You need one if your nation is having a facelift or strutting the catwalk of the international tourist. At the same time, a very different set of pressures have shaped these museums in the South Pacific. In particular, a half-century of decolonisation, the emergence of postcolonial nations and the social movements of the 1960s and 1970s have all contributed to new museological practices. Erstwhile handmaidens of colony or empire needed to be reborn as new demands were formulated by the politics of self-determination and identity. Museums needed to be attentive to a whole new class of social relationships, to recognise difference and the effects of power, to acknowledge the differing historical experiences of people according to their race, class and gender. Firmly embedded within the principles of the new museology, all of these museums model new approaches to the relations between museums and communities (Karp 1992), including reflexive curatorial strategies aware of the politics of identity, particularly those resulting from the colonial encounter. Informed by developments in the new humanities, museums began to produce a museological practice that was more theoretically and politically aware of itself. Museums began to recognise that there was a politics to their work and to make choices as to what they wanted those politics to be. As both Peter Vergo (1989) and Stephen Weil (1990) have put it, rather than asking how, museologists began to ask why. These demands have placed extraordinary pressures on these museums: to engage with popular media, to represent the entirety of history and culture, to be socially inclusive, and to speak to all peoples at the same time while adequately representing both the diversity and singularity of a nation, region or city. The result was a museological practice that, in historical and cultural museums at least, attempted to contextualise objects differently, to address the legacies of history in the contemporary moment and to recognise the very different needs brought by different people to the museum. The difficulties of doing so have not gone undocumented. Sometimes, the tensions between these competing interests have resulted in cultural experiments that go to the heart of contemporary cultural and political debate. Throughout the late 1980s and 1990s there have
01.2
EXPERIMENTS IN CULTURE INTRODUCTION
been moments of deep contestation as major national institutions around the world have attempted to reinterpret the representation of the national past through their efforts at reinterpreting their collections. What these contestations indicate is something about the tension between the state and its desire for a consensual, celebratory representation of the nation and the notion that museums, as educational institutions, have a social and moral responsibility to help the public understand the contexts for cultural, social and political difference within the nation. Fracas such as those that erupted around the Enola Gay and The West as America exhibitions at the Smithsonian institutions, the Into the Heart of Africa exhibition at the Royal Ontario Museum and the new exhibitions at the National Maritime Museum in Greenwich are all examples of this tension. What they show are the difficulties involved in maintaining museums as civic institutions removed from political society (Karp 1992). All of these tensions are evident in new museums in the South Pacific, as they are in the rest of the world. But it is our contention that recent museological practices in this part of the world have a particular salience and relevance, which is both comparable with postcolonial nations such as Canada and the United States and unique. Some of these museums carry the weight of their institutional histories and the histories of their collections no less than their European or North American counterparts. Others, such as the Centre Culturel Tjibaou, carry different historical burdens. In other words, they were born as part of the new museology movement and represent the newer forms of investment by governments in museums. It is also here that the pressures of history are most keenly felt as the clashes between coloniser and colonised, indigenous and settler, reverberate continuously in the present. All museums in the South Pacific have had to engage with the past, particularly the colonial past. In Australia and New Zealand, museums have been charged with the task of representing late twentieth and early twenty-first century forms of nationhood and of creating organisational and exhibitionary forms that contribute to the political process known as ‘reconciliation’. In former colonies such as New Caledonia, Vanuatu and East Timor, there are the challenges of much more recent and violent decolonisation. With different museological histories behind them, these new nations are clearly and creatively experimenting with the museum form that might be appropriate to different needs. As a consequence, it is here perhaps that the new museology takes on its clearest contours. Museums in the South Pacific could perhaps be seen as the most advanced flowering of the new museology, taking risks others have not been prepared to take. They present an interesting moment in the history of the museum, representing not the moment of their birth (Bennett 1995) as perhaps their rebirth or their reinvention into something new. The museums analysed in this book reflect all of these tensions and issues. While each contribution stands of its own, in many cases they unravel multiple issues manifest within the one museum. Nevertheless, we have sought to group them to give a sense of some of the key themes across the South Pacific region. The first grouping of essays in ‘New Museums’ introduces three different museums in distinctive national contexts – Te Papa, the Centre Culturel Tjibaou and the National Museum of Australia – and includes Bennett’s ‘Civic laboratories’ essay. All of these essays grapple with the role of the museum in the nation at particular historical moments under specific political pressures. The second grouping of essays, ‘New Knowledges’, document some of the practices and exhibitions at the point of tension between indigenous and non-indigenous interests in the museum. At the risk of sounding too confident, there is evidence that museums, in their attempt to accommodate to indigenous epistemologies and belief systems are themselves
EXPERIMENTS IN CULTURE INTRODUCTION
01.3
becoming indigenised – not only in terms of their architecture and the ways in which this reflects attempts to represent and enable indigenous cultural practices but also in their ways of working. In the third and final grouping, ‘New Experiences’, our authors take us to some of the key ways in which these museums are engaged in producing that most ineffable of cultural phenomena – experience. Whether through the particular design strategies discussed by Macarthur and Stead or the evocation or ‘spirits’ in Ross Gibson’s closing essay, these contributions get to the ways in which these museums are engaging audiences anew and become significant sites that place us in the world. Finally, we need to be clear that in exploring what we’ve called ‘new museums’ as experiments in culture, we are not interested in rehearsing old clichés or disabling antinomies: ‘Look’, he would say, ‘at the museum of the future. The Russians are already stocking their museums, not with sculptures or ceramics, nor with copies in fibreglass or plaster, but with these constructions of light. Everything can be everywhere, our culture can be, is, world wide... with modern technology, mere possession of the relics of the past is of little importance’ (Byatt 1990, 386).
A few years ago, The New Yorker recently featured an article on Ellen Futter, the newly appointed president of the American Museum of Natural History (Traub 1995). Futter had been hired as the executive officer to prepare the museum for the millennium but, according to the journalist James Traub, her appointment and the ‘brave new museum’ she was proposing had generated some anxiety. Although the article is ostensibly a profile piece, it is the tension between a new museum and an old museum that gives the discussion a sense of drama. Traub begins the article by recalling Salinger’s elegy to the American Museum of Natural History as a place where Holden Caulfield would retreat from the confusion of the world: The best thing... in that museum was that everything always stayed right where it was. Nobody’d move. You could go there a hundred thousand times, and that Eskimo would still be just finishing catching those two fish, the birds would still be on their way south, the deer would still be drinking out of that waterhole... The only thing that would be different would be you (Salinger 1958).
Traub uses this passage to evoke some of the ‘Proustian sort of feeling’, and the ‘persistence of the archaic that evokes nostalgia’, which he suggests are crucial aspects of why people love the museum. These evocations are important because Traub wants to capture some of the tension that attended Fuller’s efforts to transform the Museum of Natural History from an institution of ‘dowdy respectability’ into one directed to a mass public – ‘the kind of place... where Holden Caulfield would not feel at home’. To this end Traub draws a theatrical contrast between those who want the museum to function as an ‘engaged, vital place’ and those who regard the museum as a ‘cherished sepulchre’. Eventually, this tension is resolved. Futter seems certain to transform the museum – in part through a 90-million-dollar reconstruction of the Hayden Planetarium and the building of a Biodiversity Centre – into a museum without walls that mounts exhibitions on AIDS and designs computer software to explain fossils on cladistic principles. But the American Museum of Natural History will also continue to be a research institution upholding (some of) the virtues of traditions, virtues perhaps best characterised for both Futter and Traub by the
01.4
EXPERIMENTS IN CULTURE INTRODUCTION
luminous gorilla group on display in Arkeley Hall – an exhibit that the new chief executive has no intention of changing. While the mock drama of this journalistic piece was precipitated by renovations at the American Museum of Natural History – renovations that seem minor in comparison to many of the new museums and redevelopments discussed here – readers familiar with museums will notice the use of a series of familiar tropes in relation to some of the antagonisms within their institutions over the last 50 years. Call the disputes what you will – between traditionalists and innovators, between those who are research-centred and those who are audience-centred, between modernisers and visionaries, between those who fetishise the object and those enamoured with the optical-fibre-delivered, virtual multimedia total-body experience. These characterisations are clichés, cartoon-like in their simplicity. Nevertheless there are many instances in which these stark alternatives have been mobilised in efforts to reform museum practices or resist their reformation (as indeed they have been used in relation to other institutions) – either you stand fixed and ossified or you join a journey to a brave new future. Read against the grain, this story suggests that in moments of transformation, such as the renovations at the American Museum of Natural History and the recent flowering of new museums in the South Pacific, museums are open-ended experiments in culture.
REFERENCES Bennett, Tony. 1995. The birth of the museum: History, theory, politics. London: Routledge. Bennett, Tony. 2004. Pasts beyond memory: Evolution, museums, colonialism. London: Routledge. Byatt, A. S. 1990. Possession. London: Chatto and Windus. Karp, Ivan. 1992. ‘Introduction: Museums and communities; The politics of public culture’. In Museums and communities: The politics of public culture, edited by Karp, Ivan; Mullen Kreamer, Christine; Lavine, Steven D. Washington and London: Smithsonian Institution Press. Kirschenblatt-Gimblett, Barbara. 1998. Destination culture: Tourism, museums, and heritage. Berkeley: University of California Press. Message, Kylie; Healy, Chris. 2004. ‘A symptomatic museum: The new, the NMA and the culture wars’. Borderlands 3 (3). Available from: http://www.borderlandsejournal.adelaide.edu.au/vol3no3_2004/messagehealy_symptom.htm. Salinger, J. D. 1958. The catcher in the rye. Harmondsworth: Penguin. Traub, James. 1995. ‘Shake them bones’. The New Yorker (13 March). Vergo, Peter, editor. 1989. The new museology. London: Reaktion Books. Weil, Stephen, E. 1990. ‘The proper business of the museum: Ideas or things?’ In Rethinking the museum and other meditations. Washington and London: Smithsonian Institution Press. Witcomb, Andrea. 2003. Re-imagining the museum: Beyond the mausoleum. London: Routledge.
Cite this chapter as: Healy, Chris; Witcomb, Andrea. 2006. ‘Experiments in culture: An introduction’. South Pacific museums, edited by Healy, Chris; Witcomb, Andrea. Monash University ePress: Melbourne. pp. 1.1–1.5. DOI: 10.2104/spm06001.
EXPERIMENTS IN CULTURE INTRODUCTION
01.5
NEW MUSEUMS
REFORMING NATIONHOOD THE FREE MARKET AND BICULTURALISM AT TE PAPA Paul Williams, New York University Paul Williams is an assistant professor and faculty fellow in the Program in Museum Studies at New York University. He has researched museums and memorials in New Zealand, Australia, Cambodia, the USA and Germany, and is most interested in postcolonial museums, the political uses of genocide and war memorials, and the use of photographs in museums. Correspondence to Paul Williams:
[email protected]
In 1998 the Museum of New Zealand Te Papa Tongarewa opened to the public. Two key policies have come to define the new museum: biculturalism and market rationalism. Maori–Pakeha biculturalism is founded on the Treaty of Waitangi, which posits a separate-but-equal relationship between two cultural traditions. In practice, this means the museum is structured as two architectural ‘halves’ with separate galleries and systems of management. Market policies are visible both within the museum, where ‘customer focus’ is manifest in a casual institutional style and myriad interactive exhibits, and from without, wherein the museum forms a provocative symbol of corporate involvement in the public sector. This essay suggests that these policies come together in a somewhat problematic fashion. Eight years after opening, Te Papa remains poised as the captivating but troublesome result of the forces of market-driven public accessibility, postmodern curatorial revisionism and Maori cultural reassertion. While public accessibility is a predictable response to the pressures of financial accountability, the latter two interact awkwardly. While biculturalism was conceived as a way in which the museum could respond to an apparent ‘crisis’ of national identity, its execution has, paradoxically, allowed chief problems in that identity to go unexplored. Despite the museum’s novel postcolonial outlook, the topic of ‘race’ remains elemental. The uncertain, even contradictory effect of embracing an indigenous–settler racial difference while marginalising empire – when in fact empire and race are inextricably bound in New Zealand’s history – attests to the ways that former South Pacific colonies struggle to untangle colonialism.
1984: THE STATE EXPERIMENT The institution that would eventually become the Museum of New Zealand Te Papa Tongarewa (Te Papa) was envisioned in a period of national strife. By the early 1980s the nation was on the brink of economic bankruptcy. After Britain’s entry into the EEC a decade earlier, New Zealand no longer had a singularly reliable market for its agricultural exports and had become crippled by foreign debt. The government could no longer afford to continue the state tradition of ‘socialism without doctrines’; drastic changes were needed to an economy that was perhaps the most highly regulated in the OECD (Bassett 1998). On the political front, the period also saw the culmination of a decade of Maori protests over land rights, marked by demonstrations, strikes and highprofile land occupations. Language, culture and the reaffirming of the authority of the Treatyof-Waitangi history were key markers of unity for Maori groups asserting a new cultural nationalism.1 After earlier rejecting the treaty as ‘a fraud’, Maori rallied around the assertion that it should be afforded a privileged, semi-constitutional role in the nation’s governance. In 1984 a new Labour Party government came to power and immediately set about remedying these urgent concerns. First, it enacted a series of economic transformations that turned New Zealand into one of the most unregulated economies the industrialised world has known. Free
02.1
SOUTH PACIFIC MUSEUMS MONASH UNIVERSITY EPRESS
trade, a deregulated labour market, fiscal restraint and narrow monetarist policies aimed to reposition New Zealand as a prime destination for foreign investment. Second, The Treaty of Waitangi Act 1975 (NZ) gained its ‘teeth’ with a 1985 amendment that extended the Waitangi Tribunal’s powers to investigate Crown actions and omissions in breach of the treaty dating back to 1840.2 At once, much of the nation’s colonial history was the subject of research and possible government redress. Another important 1984 event was the great success of Te Maori. This inaugural international touring exhibition of historic Maori art attracted large crowds in American cities and significant media attention, in part due to the live performances of Maoritanga (culture) at each museum. The 1986–87 ‘return home’ tour of New Zealand was hugely popular, drawing a multitude of Pakeha (the non-Maori majority), many of whom knew little of this Maori heritage. It was hard to miss the range of bright possibilities – economic, social and political – that the Te Maori triumph augured. This cluster of events – the modification of the economy, a fresh politico-judicial framework for addressing Maori grievances and a new national pride in Maori culture – was vital in inculcating a national imaginary deliberately distanced from its colonial origins. All that was missing was a symbol to express all of this: a place, as thenprime minister David Lange called for, that would ‘speak for New Zealand’ (Project Development Team 1985, frontispiece). The Project Development Team (PDT) convened to discuss the shape of a new national museum averred in 1985 that the ‘forbidding monumentality of the traditional museum has no place in the life of a modern Pacific nation, aware and proud of its identity, nurturing and caring of its diverse cultures’ (Project Development Team 1985, 11). The existing national museum was a cool neoclassical edifice on a Wellington hilltop that organised displays in conventional taxonomic divisions. For the PDT, a properly native institution, to be located on the city’s waterfront, would gain wide social relevance by repudiating much of this imperial museum form, not least its staid architecture. The new institution would seek to pull apart the relationship between material heritage and the cultural and class distinctions that New Zealand had inherited in its historical image of being a ‘Britain of the South Pacific’. A revalued Maori culture and emergent postcolonial Pakeha culture were the basis for the vision of a national bicultural institution.3 Planning of the new museum coincided with the government adopting (via the New Zealand Tourism Board) a ‘national brand’ for the first time, whose keywords included the following: unaffected, open and honest; young, active, fresh; not knowing ‘can’t do’; resolute; quiet achievers; and seeking contemporary solutions (New Zealand Tourism Board 1991, 21). The PDT similarly realised that a new museum could augment New Zealand’s draw as a destination for cultural tourism: It is not an outlandish claim to note that a country’s museums can play a considerable role in establishing how a country is viewed from the outside. They can and do act as a significant trigger in tourist destination choices. Despite the high profile tourists already have among New Zealand museum visitors, it is clear from studies that cultural objectives do not figure significantly among tourist expectations of New Zealand (Project Development Team 1985, 10).
Despite having been rapidly urbanised in the postwar period, New Zealand’s tourism draw had been its outdoor environment. To capitalise on the cultural and natural, a museum that
REFORMING NATIONHOOD NEW MUSEUMS
02.2
could draw tourists inside and then away was seen as an ideal outcome. An early policy concept was that of the museum as a waharoa (gateway) to New Zealand’s natural wonderland and cultural uniqueness. If museums were traditionally conceived as an exemplary refuge from overt economic transactions, Te Papa was designed as a provocative symbol of corporate involvement in the public sector. The government program to ‘change the culture’ signals how ‘culture’ referred, in this context, to the complex of social values, customs and beliefs informing workplace relations. In this sense, economics became cultural policy inasmuch as it assumed the status of ideology and generated its own world view and institutional language (such as Te Papa’s twin ‘corporate principles’ of ‘customer focus’ and ‘commercial positivity’). Meaghan Morris has observed how, in such projects, ‘culture’ is redefined ‘as merely the malleable, consumable environment of economic action’ (Morris 1992, 56). The Department of Internal Affairs (that oversaw the museum’s development) stated: [it] is difficult to separate out cultural policy from social and economic policy... it is clear that cultural diversity and an innovative society are necessary ingredients for economic development. There is a strong argument for the Government’s involvement in the arts and cultural area on economic grounds alone (Department of Internal Affairs 1989, iii).
When market liberalism itself constitutes a cultural world view, the conceptual separation of ‘customer focus’ (as cultural policy) and ‘commercial positivity’ (as economic policy) is obfuscated. This conflation strongly suggests that the wider systems of belief and values culturally generated and transmitted – and the public policies through which they find expression – will eventually be harmonised with individualistic concepts informing market liberalism. As it was planned, Te Papa was not just affected by a sharp dive into market-oriented policies, but was positioned as a symbol of the nation’s sleek, new international competitiveness. The museum meant business, and Maori and Pakeha cultural identities were its assets.
THE VIEW, TWO DECADES ON More than two decades after that period of transformation, and almost a decade after its 1998 opening, Te Papa has largely emerged publicly triumphant. Despite an art–religion controversy, a fiscal crisis, content and interpretation predicaments that have necessitated two peer reviews and significant alterations, a Maori censorship dispute, and the surprise resignation of its initial chief executive officer, the museum’s larger story has been its huge public appeal. Its first-year visitation target of 723,000 was achieved in three months; after the first year the figure was 2 million. By June 2001, this had risen to 5 million; the 10 million mark was passed in 2005 (Museum of New Zealand 2005, 4). Currently, Te Papa receives around 1.3 million visitors annually, making it the most visited museum in Australasia. Significantly, the museum has attracted visitors whose age, sex and ethnicity closely mirror that of the larger population (Museum of New Zealand 2005, 12). In all, visitor statistics are Te Papa’s main cause for celebration and the chief weapon in its defence. Te Papa is now closely associated with, and has played a role in the construction of, an image of ‘the little country that could’. An incisive case involves the way in which the museum has tied
02.3
REFORMING NATIONHOOD NEW MUSEUMS
its reputation to that of the Lord of the rings film trilogy. In December 2003 the entirety of Wellington’s inner city was partitioned as several hundred thousand gathered for a street parade, cultural performances and an opening speech by Prime Minister Helen Clark. Postage stamps, billboards, city flags, TV advertisements, specially painted aeroplanes and signs at the airport effectively made the New Zealand countryside ‘Middle-earth’. Indeed, Wellington’s daily newspaper temporarily renamed itself the Middle Earth Evening Post, and a senior cabinet member was named ‘Minister for Lord of the Rings’, whose remit was to exploit the economic opportunities the film represented. Weekly updates on box-office takings underscored the David versus Goliath nature of this triumph. The last time such a commotion had been seen – the large crowds, street performances and prime ministerial speeches, followed by frequent updates on visitor numbers – had been at the opening of Te Papa. The two phenomena were mutually rewarding: Te Papa’s immersive Lord of the Rings exhibition (2002–03, 2006) broke museum attendance records, before travelling to Boston, London, Sydney and Singapore. Not since Te Maori had a New Zealand-produced exhibition fared so well internationally. This time around, the message was the ingenuity of the nation’s creative economy. The hardware and software displayed not only attested to the film, but also endorsed the interactive style and heavy use of Internet technology in Te Papa’s design structure (Kaino 2005, 37). Perhaps the most surprising aspect to emerge in the Lord of the rings frenzy is how the films were financed. In an extraordinary move, the government created a special tax shelter for the film that allowed New Line Cinema, a US-based company, to defray one-third of its NZ$600 million production costs against tax. (The OECD criticised this move as providing an unfair competitive subsidy.) According to Treasury, the net cost to the country was around NZ$217 million (Campbell 2004). State largesse had earlier been extended to Te Papa: while the museum is required to fund 25 per cent of its operating costs, taxpayers paid for its original $320 million cost (Tramposch 1998a, 343). These cases do not involve the same kind of speculation in arts and culture; public funding of museums has a long tradition in Australasia, and can be expected to produce educational and social benefits that blockbuster films do not. Yet the investments in both are justified in similar economic terms, including the creation of local jobs, export earnings and flow-on effects in tourism. Indeed, the museum might consider itself vindicated: while international visitors represented one quarter of Te Papa’s total in its early years, by 2005 they represented a 54 per cent majority (Positively Wellington Tourism 2005). ‘Our Place’, the museum’s brand name, now inevitably proceeds aware of the tension between serving as a place of national self-recognition and as our place for them. Yet these outcomes are not necessarily at odds: where self-recognition is celebratory rather than critical, there may be little tension at all. But what remains of that unquantifiable asset: the educational and social benefits?
BETWEEN THE MUSEUM’S WHORLS: THE STRUCTURE AND STYLE OF BICULTURALISM The museum’s logo, a thumbprint, communicates its infatuation with New Zealanders’ unique cultural imprint. If whorls suggest a labyrinth-like variety of cultural spaces and experiences, those new to Te Papa may be surprised to learn that it is architecturally structured as two distinct ‘halves’ – one Maori, one Pakeha. Overlooking the harbour to the sea are the Maori galleries; on the landward side towards the city are the Pakeha galleries. The interpretive plan states that
REFORMING NATIONHOOD NEW MUSEUMS
02.4
‘the northern (Maori) part of the museum, aligned with the harbour axis, expresses the natural elements associated with papatuanuku tangata whenua [the earth people of the land], while the southern (Pakeha) part is aligned with the urban grid of the city’ (Museum of New Zealand 1992, 87). This spatial dichotomy constructs the Western and indigenous in a familiar scheme that opposes the Maori natural world to Western built forms, the spiritual to the material, and ecological harmony to capitalist exploitation. The Treaty of Waitangi exhibition Signs of a Nation physically cleaves these spaces and aims to express the concept of the encounter of world views. Indeed, it is the treaty that explains and accounts for this separate-but-equal design scheme, also found in Te Papa’s management structure, which is similarly divided into Maori and Pakeha ‘halves’. As a Crown entity created in the years since the mid-1980s, Te Papa was inevitably structured in relation to the Treaty of Waitangi ‘principles’, which, since that era, has forged the idea of (a sometimes contested) partnership between two forms of governance. I now want to describe four permanent exhibitions that are fairly representative of the museum’s approach to cultural history: Golden Days, On the Sheep’s Back, Mana Whenua and Signs of a Nation. I can only briefly refer to its other parts and functions: Te Papa is also the national art museum. Made in New Zealand displays selections from the national collection, centered around works that depict forms of Maori–Pakeha exchange; Te Papa also contains significant natural history exhibitions. Awesome Forces uses interactive displays to depict the nation’s precarious geology and meteorology; Mountains to Sea showcases national flora and fauna; Bush City is an outdoor recreated native environment. Each of these displays applies both Western scientific and indigenous cosmological interpretive frameworks. Another section worth noting for its novelty is The Time Warp and its motion simulator rides. ‘Future Rush’ takes visitors on a tour of Wellington in a ‘state-of-the-art flying car’ in the year 2055. Strapped on their backs in moving seats, the ride takes visitors through a futuristic house before zooming around electrified Wellington city streets and onto a ski field. ‘Blastback’ uses digital animation to fuse geology and Maori creation myth. New Zealand is torn from primordial Gondwanaland and mythical Maori ancestors fashion the landmass in the same seamless story. These simulated rides offer sensation with little specific cultural context; ‘they simply produce effect, and in so doing they erase the social conditions of their production’ (Harvey 1998, 153). Te Papa’s vision of the nation’s future is one where technology and cultural diversity can be effortlessly integrated. GOLDEN DAYS Among the Pakeha galleries, persistent queues form outside a small weatherboard bungalow. An old bicycle leans against the painted yellow facade. ‘Flat 2 – Keep Out’ is roughly painted on a window. About 20 visitors at a time are led in by a Te Papa ‘host’ and seated on a motley collection of chairs. The dimly lit room is stacked with bric-a-brac. A newsreel whirrs into action and the screen shows the window of a junkshop looking out on to Willis Street, a short distance from Te Papa. An old man appears and pulls down the shop’s grille, ending his day’s work. Instantly, like magic, the footage changes to old New Zealand newsreels, movies and advertisements. Simultaneously, announcements and accompanying sounds bombard the audience and the previously immobile curios spring to life in animated synchronicity. War footage shows troops in lemon-squeezer hats on Europe’s battlefields, while toy soldiers march across a coffee table and two Vickers guns reel off rounds. A storm blows up on screen, and a ferry figurine capsizes. Queen Elizabeth is crowned and a spotlight falls on a biscuit tin lid depicting her wedding photo.
02.5
REFORMING NATIONHOOD NEW MUSEUMS
Shots of a suburban front lawn are shown as a Victa lawnmower runs up and down a strip of fake grass. Disasters, wars, sporting triumphs, pop music, cinema and local industry are orchestrated in this clever marionette theatre. If Te Papa is viewed as a microcosmic advertisement for New Zealand’s ‘great outdoors’, then Golden Days is a microcosm of the museum. Its fast, fractured sequence of images aims to jog the memory, rather than provide any linking narrative or chronologic cause and effect. The events depicted – generally isolated, one-off occurrences like a disaster, coronation or musical performance – are suited to this narrative style. ‘Chronology doesn’t matter’, Steve La Hood, the installation’s creator has stated; ‘people just want to know emotionally where we are’ (quoted in Robinson 1998). The film aims for recognition rather than understanding: Te Papa likens the film to ‘a national home movie’. This domestic metaphor is consistent with Te Papa’s institutional theme, yet it more directly points to the role of TV in producing a shared national culture, and also reinforces the elision of the domestic and public that the consumption of TV, in particular, has helped to produce. The multimedia cinema of Golden Days represents a broadly postmodern narrative technique. As an exhibition aesthetic, postmodernism is characterised by ‘the kaleidoscopic approach, the ambition only to provide a “series of impressions”, the abandonment of a master narrative and the frequent collage-like use of pre-existing statements (films/objects/images)’ (Cochrane and Goodman 1988, 38). The arrangement of images around a nationalist narrative in Golden Days lifts events out of their specific histories and de-politicises them as ‘golden moments’. The exhibition appears to have given up on history as a disciplinary system of organisation. Its superficial narrative style draws attention to the distinction between a critical analysis of the national past and the sentimental construction of national history, where ‘good history’ is ‘history that feels good’. If history can be conceptualised as a convention that organises experience across time, then Golden Days effaces historical depth and simulates history. This criticism does not mean, however, that Golden Days lacks a message altogether. Rather than seeing this emptying of meaning as a melancholic reflection of current curatorial practice, it is more useful to note the location and function of Golden Days among the social history displays. The theatrette is physically cloistered from the other permanent Pakeha history exhibitions: Passports, which deals with immigration, and On the Sheep’s Back. It is revealing that Golden Days is the only place in Te Papa that familiar, mainstream events (such as war, sporting victories and coronations) are represented. Rather than viewing this as a base-covering tactic, the superficial treatment of this material is perhaps more pointed: their relegation to nostalgia communicates the museum’s desire to show the nation’s distance from the dusty symbols of nation associated with its colonial past. After all, as repositories of the sentimental, provincial and kitsch, junkshops contain memories piled in disarray; they are connotatively antithetical to the fresh and progressive. The name ‘golden days’ also suggests a somewhat ironic, knowing standpoint towards this welltrod material. The sophisticated digital orchestration of the show also suggests a mastery over this past, implicitly marking it off as lacking the vital new perspectives that might inform a newer national identity formation. ON THE SHEEP’S BACK On the Sheep’s Back focuses on wool as the emblematic base for a broad field of meaning encompassing Pakeha material comfort, rural social life and communion with the physical environment. ‘We’re all farmers at heart’, chief Pakeha ‘concept leader’ Jock Phillips asserted. ‘Farming culture
REFORMING NATIONHOOD NEW MUSEUMS
02.6
has deeply penetrated the New Zealand identity’ (quoted in Poot 1998, 117). Perhaps out of the awareness that wool represents a rather dour subject, the tone of the exhibition is distinctly playful. Visitors see several mini-displays. ‘Shear Hard Work’ shows images of Pakeha shearers at work, wool samples, an old wool press, and a photomontage of record-breaking shearing feats set inside a reconstructed wooden woolshed. ‘Home Is Where the Art Is’ celebrates ‘the homespun creativity of New Zealanders working with wool’. This area includes material items such as tea-cosies, Maori cloaks, socks from the World War I Great National Sock Appeal (which yielded over 30,000 pairs), and woollen flowers made by a schoolgirl in 1885. In ‘Woollen Yarns’, fashion garments from contemporary designers are displayed alongside pristine woollen suits stockpiled on remote Stewart Island in case of shipwreck. This section also features the results of Te Papa’s competition for the best tale about a ‘Swanni’ (woollen bush shirt). One man used his to bury his favourite sheepdog. Another, trapped in a flooded creek, apparently turned his into a raft by tying it up and (somehow) inflating it. On the Sheep’s Back is incongruously placed in a new hi-tech museum representing an emerging postcolonial nationhood. This is particularly palpable in the Time Warp section. One ‘game’ provides the chance to test one’s shearing skills, using a barcode reader in place of a razor handpiece. To play, visitors swipe the plastic sheep’s barcodes in sequence as quickly as possible. If the sheep takes the shearer over 41 seconds, he or she is declared a ‘townie’! The effect of witnessing the general ineptitude of local visitors playing this digital game, in front of a reconstructed shed inside a museum, situated on a waterfront location near downtown Wellington, produces an uncanny relation to Phillips’s idea of a nation of ‘farmers at heart’. The shearing game hints at how the cultural use of ‘country’ (a word used by New Zealanders for both the rural and the nation) has been urbanised – and even made virtual: the game suggests a perceptual shift from the country as the farming backbone of the nation to the country as a play-space for tourists and film producers. On the Sheep’s Back is one of several exhibitions that expose the limitation of Te Papa’s stringent bicultural segmentation. While Maori are not explicitly excluded from the theme of working the land (and indeed Maori have historically comprised a high proportion of farmhands and shearers), the exhibition is located on the Pakeha side. As we shall see shortly, visitors could scarcely be blamed for forming the impression that the ‘real’ Maori relationship with the land is environmental rather than agricultural. This disconnection denies Te Papa the opportunity to engage with a major area of twentieth-century Maori labour history. Moreover, Te Papa does not (and perhaps cannot) reconcile farming culture in On the Sheep’s Back with its attention in Signs of a Nation to the swathe of injustices that flowed from treaty-sanctioned land acquisition. This incommensurability is captured in a revealing exchange between Georgina Te Heuheu, a board member, and Ronald Trotter, former chairman of the board: [Georgina Te Heuheu:] How do we make that [biculturalism] underpin our exhibitions? If we’re talking about peopling ourselves and exhibiting ourselves, then we have to bring Maori into the equation. While the sheep runs were being developed, Ngai Tahu [the principal South Island tribe] over 20 years, lost all their land. [Sir Ronald Trotter:] I came from a tough Scottish farming stock who came out in 1860 to the South Island where there were none of Tipene’s [Sir Tipene
02.7
REFORMING NATIONHOOD NEW MUSEUMS
O’Regan, leader of Ngai Tahu] people – it was too cold for them – and if we don’t give pride to that, well, we wouldn’t be here. I mean we wouldn’t be the country we are today. If we only stole things, and god knows they never thought they were stealing, then that’s also part of our understanding on the other side (Cottrell and Preston 1999).
The total avoidance of the 1845–72 New Zealand Land Wars in On the Sheep’s Back shelters Pakeha from the less desirable aspects of their formative history and, indeed, the exclusion of any Maori perspective masks the political, social and economic dominance that allowed Pakeha to enjoy unhindered ownership of land. The considerable wealth that Pakeha extracted from farming meant that workers’ wages remained comparatively high. If this contributed to a national myth of egalitarianism celebrated at Te Papa, it concealed the real division between Maori alienated from their land and settlers, among whom the wealth from Maori land functioned to reduce class conflict (Steven 1989, 30–31). MANA WHENUA Te Papa’s Maori collection, numbering almost 16,000 items, dates predominantly from the lateeighteenth to the mid-nineteenth century. Carved pieces include meeting houses, canoes, storehouses, palisade posts, weapons, musical instruments and burial containers. Weaving consists of feather and dog-skin cloaks, flax skirts, baskets, fish nets and war belts. There is also a wide range of stone adzes, fishing and food cultivation tools, and domestic implements. Over the past 20 years, the ownership, lending, handling and display of this material have become a flashpoint between Maori and museums. Museum workers have become particularly concerned about their role in the political climate of Waitangi Tribunal treaty decisions, international indigenous rights protocols, and the governmental shift to an official bicultural policy. These pressures have generally encouraged strident support for Maori aspirations – and a rhetorical endorsement of Maori culture that is evaluative rather than analytic. Consider Te Papa’s description: Mana Whenua [customary authority over lands] captures and conveys the richness, complexity and dynamism of the Maori people... contemporary Maori artworks explore and reinforce the continuum of tipuna [ancestor] culture and whakapapa, linking past generations to present day descendants and the dynamics of cultural continuity... these taonga, or treasures, reconnect through whakapapa, or genealogy, to the living descendants of today in dynamic and meaningful ways... Mana Whenua presents and celebrates the mana (power, authority, dignity) of our culture... (Museum of New Zealand n.d., my emphasis).
This assenting description contains two competing currents often invoked in contemporary accounts of Maori identity. One is essentialist, rooted in tradition and formalised in legal and bureaucratic spheres as a bounded ethnicity. The other discourse, articulated in the academic, cultural and artistic spheres, stresses a dynamic, postmodern and reflexive approach to identity. Tension recurs throughout Te Papa’s work between an official Maoritanga located in indigenous custom and knowledge that is a constituent part of a biculturalism, and the multiple and unstable interpretations of identity that apply to the creative realm.
REFORMING NATIONHOOD NEW MUSEUMS
02.8
In general, Te Papa seems to firmly support the former conception of Maori culture. A striking aspect of Mana Whenua in the context of Te Papa’s overall tone is its traditional ethnographic feel; taonga were not exhibited in greatly dissimilar ways at the old national museum. At both institutions, taonga have been displayed on the basis that race and cultural material are isomorphically related, and that there is a natural fit between art and cultural style. In this scheme, Maori art and ethnography are not opposite categories but complementary modes based on a common epistemological premise. Mana Whenua is dominated by a meeting house, canoe and storage house, which are held to be almost-mandatory elements in Maori displays.4 Around these large objects visitors see smaller displays on topics such as Pacific voyaging, traditional musical instruments, and the ancestors, places and customs significant to particular tribes. As the authoritative statement of Maori culture at Te Papa, Mana Whenua amplifies and aestheticises difference through what appears to be a strong nineteenth-century focus. While there are contemporary works in the gallery, they are often faithful to traditional forms, as if to demonstrate that old techniques have not been abandoned. Taonga are simultaneously presented as fine artworks and as examples of the sacredness of Maori culture. Conventionally, there has been a strategic division between the curatorial principles of natural history and anthropology museums, and those of art museums. In the former, objective and dispassionate information ideally allows visitors to reach their own conclusions. Art museums, by contrast, are concerned not only with supplying information, but with aesthetics and conveying abstract interpretive frameworks (Ames 1992, 51–52). In recent years, several commentators have expressed a concern that this distinction has collapsed – particularly in the display of indigenous cultures. For example, in a review of the Bunjilaka Aboriginal Centre at the Melbourne Museum, Peter Timms reports that the gallery has opted for an ‘unashamedly biased presentation that makes few claims to objectivity’. He argues that the Bunjilaka gallery intermixes art and artefact as the basis for conveying a system of ideological beliefs about the nature of identity, rather than supplying factual information about Aboriginal history and life (Timms 2000, 7). James Clifford has called this new approach to indigenous displays, brought about by the erosion of the opposition between art and anthropology, ‘aestheticized scientism’ (Clifford 1988, 203). A reluctance to define taonga solely as art is no longer justified on the grounds that they lack the aesthetic qualities of European art. Instead, Maori express unease about defining their objects through a ‘Western’ lens, and argue that the spiritual presence that inhabits objects enlarges them beyond the status of ‘art’. Accordingly, Maori stress that the category of taonga embraces a far greater sphere than ‘artworks’ – it includes, for instance, greenstone pendants, geothermal pools, weaving techniques, a proverb or a song (Tapsell 1997, 331). In Mana Whenua, utilitarian objects, previously distinguished from artworks in older taxonomic displays, are accorded the same status as taonga precisely because they also have an ancestral past. The principle that taonga encapsulate a whole world view plays a vital role in rejecting structuralist anthropological categories, which may be charged with artificially disconnecting, say, spirituality from war or kinship from carving. While Mana Whenua is not light-hearted or interactive in the manner of the rest of the museum, it is not lifeless. Objects gain a renewed charge through their display at Te Papa, partly out of the public drama and fresh display tactics of a new museum, which includes Maori language placards, traditional background music and personable Maori ‘hosts’. The gallery also sits next to the self-consciously novel Te Marae. Te Papa claims to be the world’s only museum to have
02.9
REFORMING NATIONHOOD NEW MUSEUMS
a culturally functioning marae (ceremonial meeting space). Carved by young Maori apprentices from throughout New Zealand, the appearance of Te Marae is quite unique: The decorative three-dimensional figures are cobbled together from pieces of composition board, embellished with pieces of galvanised iron cut with tinsnips, and painted with aerosol shading in garish non-Maori colours such as peacock blue, purple, apricot, and pale emerald, surrounding an inverted Japanese archway leading into a shallow interior surmounted by a row of Turkish minarets leading up into an impossibly sapphire sky (Haden 1998, 6).
Figure 2.1 Detail of Te Marae © Museum of New Zealand Te Papa Tongarewa. Used with permission.
Carvings of mythical Maori creation figures, gods and ancestors are positioned beside settler figures such as a missionary, farmer and schoolmaster. Its interior walls feature carved reliefs similar in appearance to stained-glass windows, while the back section features medieval Gothic doorways. The structure is an explicitly bicultural meeting space. As conceived in museum policy, Te Marae represents a novel arrangement whereby ‘the shared genealogy of the museum’s collection’ allows all peoples to feel ‘at home’ on the marae. Te Papa asserts that the ‘concept of Mana Taonga [the authority of ancestral treasures] will enable the marae to extend its mana, or spiritual power, over the treasures of both cultures, and will allow both cultures to use the marae for events and ceremonies’ (Museum of New Zealand 1992, 17). While its appearance is unorthodox, the issue of the cultural ownership of the marae space is arguably more contentious: traditionally, the marae is the key symbol through which tribes assert their customary possession over land (and recognise another’s). The local tribe exercises rights of invitation and procedure that governs the conduct of outsiders. In this case, however, the concept of the marae has been nationalised.
REFORMING NATIONHOOD NEW MUSEUMS
02.10
In Te Papa’s bicultural model, Maori indifference to chronological ‘national time’ has nothing to do with ideas of relative cultural progress. The almost entire absence of ‘Maori history’ – understood in categories like labour relations, war, urbanisation, demographic changes, gender relations, significant sporting or cultural events, or education and health standards – is revealing. Compared with, for example, the Bunjilaka display at the Melbourne Museum, the First Australians Gallery at the National Museum of Australia, or the Indigenous Australia Gallery at the Australian Museum, Te Papa is much less forthright about twentieth-century racism and inequality. While this may reflect the lesser degree of historical persecution Maori have suffered, it might also say something about the differentiating effect of bicultural museum policy. That is, the desire to absent Maori artefacts from national social history categories may represent a resistance on the part of Maori to define the Maori historical experience in accordance with the assimilative effect associated with a national institution. The projected image in Mana Whenua is of a selfsecure and self-contained Maori culture that possesses pathways to advancement somewhat independent of the larger nation. SIGNS OF A NATION Signs of a Nation is the physical and conceptual meeting point of Pakeha and Maori sections. The space is dominated by a huge glass replica of the (largely illegible) Treaty of Waitangi itself. On each wall are six-metre-high wooden panels inscribed with the full text. On one side is the Maori version; on the other is the English. Seats in front of these versions of the treaty provide a place for visitors to contemplate its articles. A theme of contestation is communicated in several ways. A small display that places an English translation of the Maori text alongside the English text shows how the two versions do not match. It asks the reader to judge which text offered Maori more (the evident conclusion being the Maori version). At the entrance, visitors are surrounded by a thicket of poles (highly reminiscent of the Edge of the trees installation outside the Museum of Sydney) from which a variety of voices of ordinary New Zealanders articulate conflicting views about the treaty: ‘These protestors – you never know what they want’; ‘The Treaty is just a gravy train for the rich Maori elite’; ‘We need to stop this bickering, we are one people – at least that’s what Governor Hobson said’; ‘We can support a symphony orchestra, but a full time Maori culture group wouldn’t even be considered’. Historical conflict is also represented by three display cases that organise objects according to the three treaty articles. The ‘Government/Kawanatanga’ display contrasts Maori icons such as a 1830s United Tribes flag, Huia feathers, a Rakau whakapapa (staff with notches for reciting genealogy) and a toki poutanga (greenstone weapon), alongside Crown items such as the colonial flag, a ballot box and an 1841 Seal of the Colony. A video shows a range of historical dramatisations of Maori and Pakeha talking about the effect of the treaty on their lives: we see Maori women peeling vegetables and discussing the Queen’s impending 1954 visit; contemporary Maori rugby players comparing treaty relations to sport; a young Maori woman likening 1970s prime minister Norman Kirk’s appreciation of the land to that of Maori; a Scottish female colonist indignantly describing their own claim to the new country; and postwar Maori shearers doing the same. In ‘Land and Cultural Heritage/Te Whenua me Nga Tikanga tuku iho’, we see the iron ruler, surveyor’s chain and theodolite, and gold pocket watch that were tools of land appropriation. Maori objects next to these include an eighteenth-century whenua pot (for burying placenta) and a nineteenth-century carved pouwhenua (signpost). In ‘Citizens’ Rights/Mana Tangata’ the shared experience of Maori
02.11
REFORMING NATIONHOOD NEW MUSEUMS
Figure 2.2 Poles at the entrance to Signs of a Nation © Museum of New Zealand Te Papa Tongarewa. Used with permission.
and Pakeha is signified by a copy of the Magna Carta, a barrister’s wig, a bayonet, wire-cutters, and a World War I Maori battalion helmet. Rumination of the treaty in Signs of a Nation works alongside other performances (such as rubbing greenstone in Te Marae or removing one’s shoes to enter Mana Whenua’s main meeting house) that encourage the practice of ‘being bicultural’. The exhibition is promoted as providing a contemplative space removed from everyday life where visitors can discuss and debate the treaty without interference. A text panel reads: The Treaty of Waitangi is a living social document. Debated, overlooked, celebrated. A vision of peaceful co-existence, or the cause of disharmony? An irrelevancy, or the platform on which all New Zealanders can build a future? The meaning of the Treaty changes depending on who’s speaking. Engage with our founding document… The floor is open for discussion.
Signs of a Nation can only struggle to make biculturalism, at heart a state strategy for managing difference, a democratic topic. Due to the ambiguous language of the original treaty document (exacerbated by changes in wording across translations that encompass several different versions, combined with the nuances of tribal oral histories) the Waitangi Tribunal makes its recommendations based on ‘the spirit of the Treaty’ rather than any literal meaning. While drawing viewer attention to the original text may help the public to appreciate the original intentions of the Crown, it does little to elucidate what the treaty spirit, so critical in political decisions, might entail. If Te Papa’s goal (encapsulated in its mission statement) is to act as ‘a forum for the nation’, it appears to have achieved this chiefly in the way it contains a multitude of experiences. It is a place, according to Te Papa’s William Tramposch, ‘where something is always happening’ (Tramposch 1998b, 32). While this activity faintly gestures towards the forum in that it offers
REFORMING NATIONHOOD NEW MUSEUMS
02.12
visitor (or ‘customer’) choices, it does not alone necessarily invite debate over, say, the legacy of colonial history, contemporary social inequality or, indeed, issues that originate far beyond New Zealand. Te Papa’s strategy of immersing visitors in sights, sounds, activities and emotional responses is probably more an issue of display strategies than a rethinking of the museum’s role in the public sphere. After all, although visitors will undoubtedly take different ‘experiences’ away with them, these remain tightly choreographed by the museum. Te Papa’s one-way communication is geared towards allowing the visitor to ‘try out’ and gauge the emotional appeal of a variety of ideas about cultural roots and national identity. This tactic, which Gary Edson calls ‘socioexhibitry’, is premised on the belief that people’s cultural identities rather than objects should be the starting point of the museum’s work (Edson 2001, 40–44). The idea of communicating in a wide variety of modes to a broad array of private selves may be a popular and inexorable museum tactic, but it is not one that is suitably described as a public forum. Instead, my position is closer to that of Arjun Appadurai, who is interested in how the granting of expressions of minority and indigenous self-representation and uniqueness can ultimately act as a state strategy of containment: National and international mediascapes are exploited by nation-states to pacify separatists or even the potential fissiparousness of all ideas of difference. Typically, contemporary nation-states do this by exercising taxonomic control over difference, by creating various kinds of international spectacles to domesticate difference and by seducing small groups with the fantasy of self-display on some sort of global and cosmopolitan stage (Appadurai 1996, 39).
Appadurai’s reference to both ‘taxonomic control’ and ‘the fantasy of self-display’ hints at the double-inscription of museums both as modern institutions of governmental classification and as spaces of glorification, descended from competitive imperial projects. His use of the phrase ‘to domesticate difference’ – particularly apt for a museum branded as ‘Our Place’ – describes the ideological effect when cultural difference is publicly celebrated within an entirely national frame. Consideration is needed to how the ‘forum’ can be utilised, in a postcolonial environment, as a promotional tool for nationalist articulations. That is, in a time when unitary national cultures are viewed suspiciously (particularly by the liberal consensus that often dominates the institutional climate of museums), metaphors that cluster around the ideas of contact, meeting, dialogue and engagement provide a way of dramatising and enlivening the museum itself and its subject – in this case, the nation.
CONCLUSION: MAKING A SPECTACLE OF OURSELVES If, as David Lowenthal (1999) has avowed, ‘the most successful museums are those that are able to play on the divisions and problems of nations’, then how does Te Papa fare? Outwardly, Te Papa directly addresses New Zealand’s chief social and cultural schism through its bicultural focus. Yet bicultural nationhood is realised at the exhibition level in a highly idiosyncratic manner. The difference between what visitors might expect, involving some representation of how Maori and Pakeha have lived together, and what is portrayed, in the form of conceptual and substantive disconnection, is quite disconcerting. Empire, for instance, is almost absent at Te Papa, even as a point of Pakeha origin. G. B. Dahl and Ronald Stade have observed:
02.13
REFORMING NATIONHOOD NEW MUSEUMS
Once a museum was either the self-glorifying institution of national romanticism seeking the roots of a nation in an idealised rural background, or an exoticising museum depicting the colonial other. In territories where indigenous peoples were subjected to European conquest these two categories are today often muddled, signalling new relations between nation-building and indigenous-ness (Dahl and Stade 2000, 157).
While Te Papa stresses a new postcolonial outlook, the central issue of ‘race’ remains fundamental. The uncertain, even contradictory effect of embracing a settler–indigenous racial difference while marginalising empire – when in fact empire and race are inextricably bound in New Zealand’s history – attests to the ways that former colonies struggle to untangle colonialism. In nationalist discourse, cultural identity is asserted as both a fixed object, passed from one generation to the next, and as a territorial claim, where the space of culture becomes imbricated with ethnic and national ideas. This forms a potent combination of blood and soil – precisely the link that tangata whenua articulates. However, the spiritual aspect of Pakeha heritage is not presented in a continuum with the notion of taonga. Yet the blithe tone of exhibitions like Golden Days and On the Sheep’s Back does not necessarily reflect the security of Pakeha identity. Unlike parts of Europe and America, where national museums helped to make national histories in the service of nation building, New Zealand’s museums do not have a long background in narrating national history. However, Te Papa is engaging with this topic at precisely the time when ‘national history’ itself has become unfashionable among many public historians. The result is the demystification of something that was arguably never mystified – at least in the museum setting. An internal inquiry found that: The material culture of the Pakeha is profoundly under-represented in the Museum, such that it is neither fulfilling its fundamental statutory function as the repository of comprehensive collections of truly national significance, nor is it capable of presenting Pakeha history and culture in public displays (Review Team Report 1994, 7).
In this sense, Te Papa has leapt towards a postmodern critique of national history, without having exhausted the modern history of the nation. The historical disparity in collecting practices – where Maori material culture was hoarded according to the needs of a ‘salvage ethnography’ while Pakeha believed that they scarcely had a history worth documenting – again reflects the nation’s colonial origins. Further, a scant object-base also partly explains Te Papa’s reliance on technologically mediated experience. Paradoxically, then, the museum’s bright postcolonial veneer owes a kind of debt to an institutionalised form of colonial cringe. In sum, the received message is that Pakeha identity is a malleable historical experiment, whereas Maori is an immutable cultural world view. Eight years after opening, Te Papa remains poised as the captivating but troublesome result of the forces of market-driven public accessibility, postmodern curatorial revisionism and Maori cultural reassertion. While public accessibility is an emergent and inevitable response to the pressures of financial accountability, the latter two interact awkwardly. Biculturalism was conceptualised as a way in which Te Papa could respond to the crisis of national identity. Its
REFORMING NATIONHOOD NEW MUSEUMS
02.14
implementation has, paradoxically, allowed important problems in that identity to go unexamined. By presenting biculturalism as an achieved postcolonial state, Te Papa overlooks not only a history of colonialism, but also the continuing inequality between Maori and Pakeha that made biculturalism a necessary response in the first place. For now, however, the glamour of international attention (and growing international tourists) seems to produce the sense that constant museological innovation in display tactics supersedes the need to reinterpret overarching cultural concepts.
ENDNOTES 1
The 1840 Treaty of Waitangi was an agreement between the British Crown and Maori chiefs, which remains, in essence, contested. For the purposes of the treaty, the British recognised those Maori who signed it as representing the whole of Maoridom. The treaty consists of a preamble and three articles. The first article signs the rights of sovereignty in New Zealand over to the British Crown. In the Maori version, something quite different (kawanatanga, or governorship) was granted to the Crown. The second article reserved Maori tino rangatiratanga (full sovereign authority) over their lands, forests, fisheries and me o ratou taonga katoa (everything they valued). The third article stated that everyone in New Zealand would have the rights and privileges of British subjects.
2
The Waitangi Tribunal is a permanent commission of inquiry charged with investigating and making recommendations to parliament on claims brought by Maori relating to actions or omissions of the Crown that breach the promises made in the Treaty of Waitangi.
3
The act establishing the museum stated that the board shall: ‘Endeavour to ensure both that the Museum expresses and recognises the mana [authority] and significance of Maori, European, and other major traditions and cultural heritages, and that the Museum provides the means for every such culture to contribute effectively to the Museum as a statement of New Zealand’s identity’. Although this wording suggests the possibility for a multicultural framework, there was very little subsequent development of ‘other major traditions’ in policy. See Department of Internal Affairs (1992), section 8, part b.
4
The objects to which I refer are the whare wananga Te Hau ki Turanga (1842), the waka taua Teremoe (1860), and the pataka Te Takinga (1820).
REFERENCES Ames, Michael M. 1992. Cannibal tours and glass boxes: The anthropology of museums. Vancouver: University of British Columbia Press. Appadurai, Arjun. 1996. Modernity at large: Cultural dimensions of globalization. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press. Bassett, Michael. 1998. The state in New Zealand, 1840–1984: Socialism without doctrines? Auckland: Auckland University Press. Campbell, Gordon. 2004. ‘Ring cycle’. New Zealand Listener 192 (3323): 13. Clifford, James. 1988. The predicament of culture: Twentieth-century ethnography, literature, and art. Cambridge: Harvard University Press. Cochrane, Peter; Goodman, David. 1988. ‘The great Australian journey: Cultural logic and nationalism in the postmodern era’. Australian Historical Studies 23 (91): 21–44, edited by Janson, S.; MacIntyre, S. (special issue). Cottrell, Anna; Preston, Gaylene, directors. 1999. Getting to our place. [Film]. 72 mins. Wellington: In association with NZ On Air and TVNZ. Dahl, G. B; Stade, Ronald. 2000. ‘Anthropology, museums, and contemporary cultural processes: An introduction’. Ethnos 65 (2): 157–171.
02.15
REFORMING NATIONHOOD NEW MUSEUMS
Department of Internal Affairs. 1989. ‘A proposed ministry for arts and culture: Discussion paper’. Wellington: Department of Internal Affairs. Department of Internal Affairs. 1992. Museum of New Zealand Te Papa Tongarewa Act. Wellington: Department of Internal Affairs. Edson, Gary. 2001. ‘“Socioexhibitry” as popular communication’. Museum International 53 (3): 40–44. Haden, Frank. 1998. ‘The Museum of Lady Godiva’. Sunday Star Times (22 March): 6. Harvey, Penelope. 1998. ‘Nations on display: Technology and culture in Expo “92”’. In The politics of display: Museums, science, culture, edited by Macdonald, Sharon. London and New York: Routledge. Kaino, Lorna. 2005. ‘What difference does a museum make? Te Papa’s contribution to the New Zealand economy’. Media International Australia Incorporating Culture and Policy 117: 31–42. Lowenthal, David. 1999. ‘From cosmopolis to culture wars: A national museums saga’. Paper presented at the Australian National University Centre for Cross-Cultural Research conference National Museums: Negotiating Histories. 13 July; Australian National University, Canberra, Australian Capital Territory. Morris, Meaghan. 1992. Ecstasy and economics. Sydney: Empress Publishing. Museum of New Zealand Te Papa Tongarewa. 1992. ‘Museum of New Zealand Te Papa Tongarewa interpretive plan: A conceptual framework for exhibitions’. Wellington: Museum of New Zealand Te Papa Tongarewa. Museum of New Zealand Te Papa Tongarewa. 2005. ‘Annual report, July 1994 – 30 June 1995’. Wellington: Department of Internal Affairs. Museum of New Zealand Te Papa Tongarewa. n.d. ‘Te Papa – Communications – Mana Whenu’. [Press Release]. New Zealand Tourism Board. 1991. Tourism in New Zealand: A strategy for growth. Wellington: New Zealand Tourism Board. Poot, E. 1998. ‘Finding ourselves at Te Papa’. New Zealand Geographic 38: 110–127. Positively Wellington Tourism. 2005. ‘Wellington Tourism Statistics’. [Internet]. Positively Wellington Tourism. Accessed 7 April 2006. Available from: http://www.wellingtonnz.com/AboutUs/Tourism+Statistics.htm. Project Development Team. 1985. ‘Nga Taonga o te motu: Te Marae Taonga O Aotearoa, Treasures of the nation: National Museum of New Zealand; A plan for Development’. Wellington: Department of Internal Affairs. Review Team Report. 1994. ‘An agenda for scholarship: Scholarship and research in the Museum of New Zealand Te Papa Tongarewa’. Wellington: Museum of New Zealand Te Papa Tongarewa. Robinson, Simon. 1998. ‘Where the Heart Is’. Time 7 (16 February): 9–10. Steven, Rob. 1989. ‘Land and white settler colonialism: The case of Aotearoa’. In Culture and identity in New Zealand, edited by Novitz, D.; Willmott, B. Wellington: GP Books. Tapsell, Paul. 1997. ‘The flight of the Pareraututu: An investigation of Taonga from a tribal perspective’. Journal of the Polynesian Society 106 (4): 323–374. Timms, Peter. 2000. ‘The Manipulative Museum’. The Age (15 November): 7. [Melbourne]. Tramposch, William. 1998a. ‘Te Papa: Re-inventing the museum’. Museum Management and Curatorship 17 (4): 339–350. Tramposch, William. 1998b. ‘Te Papa: An Iinvitation for redefinition’. Museum International 199 (1): 28–32.
Cite this chapter as: Williams, Paul. 2006. ‘Reforming nationhood: The free market and biculturalism at Te Papa’. South Pacific museums, edited by Healy, Chris; Witcomb, Andrea. Monash University ePress: Melbourne. pp. 2.1–2.16. DOI: 10.2104/spm06002.
REFORMING NATIONHOOD NEW MUSEUMS
02.16
NEW SYMPOSIUM MUSEUMS
MUSEUMS OF NEW CALEDONIA THE OLD, THE NEW AND THE BALANCE OF THE TWO Marianne Tissandier, Musée de Nouvelle-Calédonie Marianne Tissandier is the conservator at the Musée de Nouvelle-Calédonie. Correspondence to Marianne Tissandier:
[email protected]
A few museums and cultural centres can be visited in New Caledonia, but this snapshot of New Caledonia’s museums is centred on the two main cultural institutions dealing with Kanak culture: the Museum of New Caledonia and the Centre Culturel Tjibaou. Despite their common focus, they offer radically different forms of interpretation. The Musée de Nouvelle-Calédonie (MNC) is New Caledonia’s oldest heritage institution. It has seen successive transformations through the nation’s history associated with changes in function and name. Beginning as the Local Museum it was to become the Colonial Museum. After a lapse of activity, it re-emerged as the New Caledonian Museum later becoming the Territorial Museum before emerging in its present form. ‘Indigenous curiosities’ and mineralogical and botanical specimens were collected for the museum in New Caledonia as early as 1863, only ten years after France took possession of the nation. This nascent collection was mostly considered as a supply of artefacts destined for international and French exhibitions to promote the colony in Europe. From 1895 to 1903, thanks to the director Julien Bernier, the Colonial Museum, housed in the same building as the library, grew through his focused collection and inventory practices. Artefacts were exchanged with other museums and ethnographic objects from Vanuatu, the Solomon Islands, the Marquesas Islands and Australia were acquired. Following Bernier’s death the museum was abandoned in favour of the library, and its collections were neglected until the 1940s. At this time the museum was revived and reconfigured as the New Caledonian Museum and the ethnographic collections were expanded with broader representation of the Pacific region. In 1963 the Kanak collection gathered by the anthropologists Jean Guiart and Maurice Leenhardt at the Institut de la France d’Outre-Mer was given to the museum, which opened in its current building in 1970. Mineralogical and Pacific ethnographic collections collected by the consecutive institutions, despite inevitable attrition due to poor environmental and storage conditions, were mostly put on display. Reorganised again in 1983 as the Museums and Heritage Department (Service des Musées et du Patrimoine), the museum, which had always been part of the Education Ministry, became autonomous within the local administration of the French overseas territory of New Caledonia. The natural history collections were dispersed and the museum’s ambitions were focused on Melanesian and particularly Kanak art and society. The museum is now supported by the Government of New Caledonia and invites visitors to discover local traditions as part of the Pacific region (Kasarhérou 1996, 3–5). Situated in the centre of the city of Noumea, the architecture of the Museum of New Caledonia is typical of the 1970s. It is surrounded by a lawn planted with coconut trees and its white-washed cube-shaped buildings are interconnected with roofed courtyards and delimited by square columns and large wrought-iron gates displaying engraved rock designs. Two gardens extend the display areas of the museum out of doors. The ethno-botanical garden presents trees and plants traditionally used in Kanak and Pacific cultures. The other open-air exhibit recreates part of a customary village with an alley of local pine trees leading up to a traditional Kanak hut.
03.11
SOUTH PACIFIC MUSEUMS MONASH UNIVERSITY EPRESS
Figure 3.1 The traditional Kanak hut in the garden of the Museum of New Caledonia © Musée de Nouvelle-Calédonie
The ground floor of the permanent display rooms presents all aspects of Kanak social life with some of the 1500 objects of the MNC Kanak collection. It is one of the world’s most significant Kanak collections, alongside that of the Basel Ethnography Museum, and well known for its holdings of traditional sculpture produced for ceremonial huts. The first floor is dedicated to cultures from other parts of Melanesia as well as Polynesia and Micronesia, the MNC having a considerable collection of Melanesian artefacts with approximately 1000 objects. The permanent exhibition is displayed according to the design from the 1980s, which features aluminium showcases and black walls. The lively tours of the Kanak guides, which connect the traditional and contemporary aspects of their culture, usually help the visitor to overlook these trappings of museological history. Once a year, a temporary exhibition of three to six months in duration gathers artefacts from the Pacific region around an aspect of social life, with ever-changing contemporary designs and efforts made at giving visitors a more dynamic experience of the museum.1 In relation to the local culture, the MNC is seen by Kanaks not only as a repository of tradition, the guardian of the indigenous ancestral culture, but also as a cemetery where objects are out of context. It is a significant place that holds powerful, special objects belonging to the dead,
MUSEUMS OF NEW CALEDONIA NEW MUSEUMS
03.2
with most no longer used in society. That these objects are exposed to all visitors is disturbing to many Kanaks. Furthermore, the issue of Kanak objects being part of museum collections is still a sensitive one, tied as it is to colonialism and the loss of culture. Going to the museum is something most people consider with caution and some hesitancy. As elsewhere, the relationship between indigenous people from a primarily oral culture and ‘mute’ museum objects does not flow seamlessly (Kasarhérou 2003, 62). The importance of public programs to communicate and interpret culture has been acknowledged by the museum’s staff and efforts are being made to foster meaningful contact between Kanak and other people and objects. For example, activities involving elders are organised, albeit infrequently. With regard to the scale of New Caledonia, the MNC can be seen as a large museum that has decent funding, equipment, collections and unique expertise in conservation, with the only trained conservator and conservation laboratory in the country. Its small staff, however, and the weight of its colonial inheritance impede its evolution as a vital, dynamic public institution at present.2 Hopefully this will change in the near future with the completion of the museum policy and the renewal, upgrading and extension of the building and display designs, partly funded by the French government and due to happen before 2010. The Tjibaou Cultural Centre (Centre Culturel Tjibaou, CCT) has not inherited the same colonial history as the museum, yet it also has to engage with the various ethnic groups brought together by the colonial past and the political leaders’ will to constitute a common heritage for all to share in the future (Neaoutyine 2000). The CCT was funded by the French central government to be the headquarters of the Agency for the Development of Kanak Culture (ADCK), as one of the state’s major undertakings (known as ‘the Great Projects of the Republic’).3 By doing so, Kanak culture has been positioned as an emblem of this French territory, recognising Kanak peoples’ cultural identity while disrupting non-indigenous consciences (Neaoutyine 2000). The cultural centre’s modern, streamlined architecture designed by Renzo Piano, architect of the George Pompidou Centre in Paris, has been renowned and celebrated since its completion. On the wooded peninsula where the Melanesia 2000 festival was held, ten wooden buildings with evocative names rise.4 Their design is drawn from that of traditional ceremonial huts. They are connected by a semi-open central passageway evoking the traditional Kanak village alley. The ‘Kanak pathway’ (chemin kanak) that meanders around the buildings through gardens and traditional huts highlights the culture’s spiritual connection with nature and introduces visitors to the Kanak identity. The CCT opened in 1998, after three years of planning during which Kanak specialists in Kanak culture and European specialists in museology, research, communication and show business tried to place the centre as a hub of artistic creativity, influence and cultural exchange through the presentation of shows and concerts. The objectives of the CCT were and still are similar to those of the ADCK: the promotion and preservation of Kanak heritage, the encouragement of contemporary modes of expression within Kanak culture, the organisation of research programs, and the promotion of cultural exchange, particularly within the South Pacific region (Centre Culturel Tjibaou 2003). Its aim is also to offer Kanak heritage as a cultural inheritance of the whole Caledonian population, in order to provide cultural references on which artistic creation may be founded (Del Rio 1998, 35). Its goal is to present a culture that all Kanaks may recognise as theirs and which is also recognised as such from the outside (Neaoutyine 2000).
03.3
MUSEUMS OF NEW CALEDONIA NEW MUSEUMS
Figure 3.2 Centre Culturel Tjibaou Photograph: David Becker. © Centre Culturel Tjibaou – ADCK/ Renzo Piano Building Workshop, Architectes.
All these objectives are being implemented by the considerable staff numbers dispersed through the various departments of the CCT.5 As a reminder and a starting point for all activities, the CCT first presents a few historical Kanak artefacts on temporary loan from French museums. Throughout the year, the Performance and Events Department promotes and encourages training and presents traditional and contemporary performing arts of New Caledonia, the Pacific and the rest of the world. The Library is a specialised resource centre focused on Kanak and Oceanian cultures. The Department for Cultural Development, Heritage and Research publishes the Mwà Véé Kanak cultural magazine and funds research programs, cultural radio and Kanak language broadcasts. The Public Development Department communicates and organises activities and workshops, especially involving young people. Additionally, the Visual Arts and Exhibitions Department fosters worldwide artists’ workshops focused on the creation of manual arts using contemporary means that are linked to a solid base of heritage and regional consciousness (Centre Culturel Tjibaou 2003). Through the permanent exhibition of its collection of contemporary Kanak and Oceanian art and the organisation of temporary exhibitions of contemporary art, the CCT also tries to associate Caledonian and Kanak contemporary art with art production in the Pacific region to promote the broader international interest in and recognition of Pacific art (Del Rio 2004, 33).6 The CCT probably presents the best organised, professional heritage institution in New Caledonia to the outside world. Contemporary art supported by the centre seems a powerful and meaningful compromise between tradition and modernity. Paradoxically, the creation of an authentic image of Kanak culture to serve as a reference to other cultures endangers Kanak cultural diversity and some denounce the CCT vision as a misrepresentation of ‘The Culture’ (Neaoutyine 2000). This is perhaps where the significance of an ethnographic museum such as
MUSEUMS OF NEW CALEDONIA NEW MUSEUMS
03.4
the MNC lies, standing as it does across from a modern cultural centre such as the CCT. Here the MNC can serve as a reference for tradition and as the foundation for expressions of cultural diversity, balancing tradition and modernity.
ENDNOTES 1
Recent exhibits were Pacific Tapa, Exchange Currencies, Melanesian Bows and Arrows, and Jewellery and Adornment of Melanesia.
2
Fourteen people are employed, with cleaning, security and mount-making staff making up more than half.
3
The funding comes as part of the Oudinot Accords, which complement the Matignon Accords signed by the French government and the two major political parties of New Caledonia on 20 August 1988.
4
The festival was organised by Jean-Marie Tjibaou in 1975 to emphasise Kanak culture and cultural revival (see http://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jean-Marie_Tjibaou). The buildings bear names such as Kanaké, Jinu (the spirit), Bwénaado (the customary gathering), Kavitara (the entrance of the hut) or Mvmko (little house).
5
There are almost 70 people employed there, according to Emmanuel Kasarhérou who has been the cultural director of the centre since its opening (personal communication, 2 May 2006).
6
The collection of contemporary Kanak and Oceanian art comprises approximately 700 paintings, sculptures, installations and works of art on paper.
REFERENCES Centre Culturel Tjibaou. 2003. ‘Presentation of the project’. [Internet]. Agency for the Development of Kanak Culture. Accessed 10 May 2006. Available from: http://www.adck.nc/en. Del Rio, G. 1998. ‘A Prefiguration Inscribed in Reality’ (Une préfiguration inscrite dans la réalité). Mwà Véé 19 (January–March): 34–38. Del Rio, G. 2004. ‘Contemporary Art at the Tjibaou Cultural Centre’ (L’art contemporain au Centre Culturel Tjibaou). Mwà Véé 45 (July–September): 32–43. Kasarhérou, E. 1996. ‘Extension project of the Territorial Museum’ (Projet d’aménagement et d’extension du Musée Territorial). Unpublished report. Services des Musées et du Patrimoine. Kasarhérou, E. 2003. ‘Museums and indigenous people in the Pacific’ (Musées et populations autochtones en Océanie). Proceedings of Indigenous Networks, Partnership, Ethical Issues: The International Conference. 20–21 March; Muséum d’Histoire Naturelle de Lyon, France: 59–65. Neaoutyine, M. S. 2000. ‘New Caledonia Searching for a National Identity’ (Nouvelle-Calédonie en quête d’une identité nationale). Akoz 7.
Cite this chapter as: Tissandier, Marianne. 2006. ‘Museums of New Caledonia: The old, the new and the balance of the two’. South Pacific museums, edited by Healy, Chris; Witcomb, Andrea. Monash University ePress: Melbourne. pp. 3.1–3.5. DOI: 10.2104/spm06003.
03.5
MUSEUMS OF NEW CALEDONIA NEW MUSEUMS
NEW MUSEUMS
CONTESTED SITES OF IDENTITY AND THE CULT OF THE NEW THE CENTRE CULTUREL TJIBAOU AND THE CONSTITUTION OF CULTURE IN NEW CALEDONIA Kylie Message, Australian National University Kylie Message holds an Australian Research Council Special Research Centre Research Fellowship in the Centre for Cross-Cultural Research at the Australian National University, where she is also convenor of the Museums and Collections graduate program. She is the author of New museums and the making of culture (Berg, 2006). Correspondence to Kylie Message:
[email protected]
The forward-looking ideology of the Centre Culturel Tjibaou has enabled it to engage both with new museums globally and with the political and social objectives associated with New Caledonia’s independence struggles of the 1980s. I explore the features of the cultural centre: its relationship with the French government, its juggling of tradition and modernity, and the multitude of varying responses that the centre has received since its opening in 1998. I argue that the centre has itself become an important and progressive, albeit highly complicated, symbol for a territory undergoing change, and that by looking at how these discussions occur both within and in relation to the centre, we can clearly identify the role that museums play in the constitution of culture. Opened in Noumea in 1998, the Centre Culturel Tjibaou (CCT) provides a spectacular example of the ‘new museum’ concept that has attracted critical and popular interest over the last decade.1 The museum draws materially and conceptually on its geopolitical environment, so that despite being situated on the outskirts of the capital city (on the main island, known as Grand Terre), it draws influence from the diverse Kanak communities residing elsewhere across the New Caledonian islands. The circling pathway that leads from the car park to the centre’s entrance is lined with plants from various regions of New Caledonia. Together, these represent the myth of the creation of the first human: the founding hero, Téâ Kanaké. Signifying the collaborative design process, the path and centre are organically interconnected so it is difficult to discern any discrete edges existing between the building and gardens. Similarly, the soaring huts appear unfinished as they open outward to the sky, projecting architect Renzo Piano’s image of Kanak culture as flexible, diasporic, progressive and resistant to containment by traditional museological spaces. Reflecting on the design process, Piano explains: ‘It dawned on me that one of the fundamental elements of Kanak architecture is the very construction process: “building the House” is every bit as important as “the finished House”. From this, I began to develop the concept of a permanent “building work-site”, or rather of a place which would suggest an unfinished housebuilding project.’2 In this essay I suggest that the centre presents an ‘unfinished’, transformative effect to reflect its ongoing commitment to an image of newness. This effect provides the centre with features associated with contemporary museums across the world, showing its fluency in postmodern architectural discourse as well as its ability to perform as a significant cultural actor on a global stage. While this encourages a steady flow of international visitors interested in the centre’s spectacular architecture and its programs, the constant reiteration of the new is tied to the specific political objective of reconciliation between coloniser and colonised. Fundamentally connected
SOUTH PACIFIC MUSEUMS MONASH UNIVERSITY EPRESS
04.1
to the CCT’s founding mandate, the ideology of the new is more than dogmatic. It is used to produce convincing symbols of national identity for a state undergoing a process of political transition, and aims to evoke a real interest and investment in an evolving public culture. The CCT’s desire to be new can thus be seen to accord with its role in domestic and international affairs, and as indicating, above all else, the need for a clear articulation of cultural politics in New Caledonia, as well as the inseparability of these terms.
Figure 4.1 Exterior of Centre Culturel Tjibaou, from traditional gardens and Kanak path Photograph: Kylie Message. Courtesy ADCK-Centre Culturel Tjibaou/Renzo Piano Building Workshop, Architectes.
THE CENTRE CULTUREL TJIBAOU AND NEW MUSEUMS The CCT embodies many of the key components and features that have become identified with a shift in the way that museums are conceptualised in the Western world. This movement away from a more traditional museological approach has quickly resulted in a series of differences in the ways that museums are designed, made, experienced, and understood to function (Vergo 1988; Lumley 1988; Preziosi and Farago 2004). Often presented as interdisciplinary sites of postmodernity, where subjectivity is presented as contextual and contingent rather than static, new museums may also challenge the continued relevance and role of the nation-state and its boundaries in a contemporary, globalised context (Chakrabarty 2002; Kasarhérou 1995; Losche 2003; Message and Healy 2004, Aldrich 2005, Message 2005). Key features include the incorporation of a self-conscious approach to representation, a heightened political awareness that is informed by postcolonial theories, a unique building that is designed by a high-profile architect, the desire to encourage direct community involvement in relation to the generation of ideas about culture, and the interlinked production of discussions about cultural identity. These elements contribute significantly to producing an image of newness or difference for the museum, a point that is reflected in Margaret Jolly’s description of the CCT: The Tjibaou Cultural Centre is unsurpassed in the Pacific for its architectural splendour and its expensive high-tech virtuosity. It sustains a singular stress on
04.2
CONTESTED SITES OF IDENTITY NEW MUSEUMS
contemporary Pacific arts rather than the curating and display of older objects… There are about thirty older artefacts in the Bwenaado house (mainly masks, houseposts, and roof sculptures on loan from European museums), but most older Kanak artefacts are still housed in the Territorial Museum of New Caledonia in town. The emphasis in the Ngan Jila (house of riches) is rather on contemporary works by named artists in both indigenous and introduced genres. According to Emmanuel Kasarhérou, this is faithful to Tjibaou’s vision of Kanak culture not as frozen in the past, but as open and lived in(Jolly 2001, 434).
New museums also emphasise interactive and multimedia modes of display to enhance this image of newness, and highlight the technological innovation (and ‘expensive high-tech virtuosity’) of their architecture (Montaner 2003). They tend to combine cultural history exhibitions with contemporary arts, often inciting controversy on the basis of their apparently incongruous approaches to exhibition, or because of their perceived privileging of popular culture and entertainment over ‘high’ culture. They frequently function as a site for community festivals and other cultural activities. Aiming to attract a wide and diverse audience, they often deploy alternative modes of history and storytelling, non-linear and multiplicitous narratives and a postcolonial dedication to the politics of authorship, governance and authority (Simpson 1996; Macdonald 2003; Bennett 1995).
LOCALISING A GLOBAL PHENOMENON In many ways, the CCT can be understood as the ideal example of this new museum model because while it conforms so closely with its principles and effects, it does this for reasons that are very clearly connected to its local context, and with the conditions and reasons for its production. This means that although the architecture is breathtaking and eminently suitable for the global marketplace of postcard photography and tourist imagery, its exhibitions and programs engage both with the complexity within Kanak communities and the broader geopolitical context of New Caledonia. For instance, while the CCT’s main exhibition spaces include the growing permanent collection of contemporary Kanak and Oceanian art displayed in the Bérétara Hall and Jinu House, traditional objects of Kanak heritage on loan from the Musée de l’Homme in Paris are exhibited in the Bwénaado House. It also hosts temporary exhibitions, such as Impressions Pacifique: Estampes Contemporaines (2005), which was the result of collaboration between the CCT and the Centre Culturel Goa Ma Bwarhat in Hienghène, and which aimed to produce inter-regional partnerships (Agency for the Development of Kanak Culture 2005, 27). Engagement with rural Kanak communities is promoted through outreach programs that include artists’ workshops and ingenious ‘Travelling Educational Kits’, which are folded-up, suitcase-sized models of the cultural centre, its grounds and its activities. These are taken to schools and community centres to show the cultural centre and its activities, to demonstrate the relationship between Kanak architecture and Renzo Piano’s stylised building, and to encourage children to participate in the visual arts. The CCT has a well-resourced library and digital catalogue that facilitate access to, and the preservation of, Kanak cultural heritage, particularly the remaining 25 languages spoken across the islands (Kasarhérou 2005). It also encourages interaction with other cultural centres and museums in
CONTESTED SITES OF IDENTITY NEW MUSEUMS
04.3
Figure 4.2 The steel frame underlying the fading iroko timber Photograph: Kylie Message. Courtesy ADCK-Centre Culturel Tjibaou/Renzo Piano Building Workshop, Architectes.
the Pacific region (through agencies such as the Pacific Islands Museums Association and institutions including the Vanuatu Cultural Centre, with which it discusses issues including the preservation of intangible heritage and language) and promotes dialogue between New Caledonia and museums and other cultural institutions in France and other countries. These programs reflect the centre’s official primary purpose as expressed in its mission statement: to ‘promote and preserve the Kanak archaeological, anthropological and linguistic heritage’.3 This shows the CCT to be concerned with creating a very particular relationship with the postcolonial politics of image-construction: a point that is significant in relation to the centre’s
04.4
CONTESTED SITES OF IDENTITY NEW MUSEUMS
official publicity and rhetoric, as well as for the Kanak communities it aims principally to represent and engage with. The CCT may be seen to provide an official site for testing and holding dialogue and debate over what kinds of images and ideas may be appropriate signifiers of a renewed cultural identity for New Caledonians as the country continues to negotiate its future direction.4 Before the centre opened, the Agency for the Development of Kanak Culture (ADCK) stated: ‘The intention is not to make a static presentation of works as in a conventional museum but to make available to be seen, to be admired and, it will be said, “to live again”, objects that have become what the Elders have termed “ambassadors of Kanak culture” throughout the world’.5 These objects are part of the ‘dispersed Kanak heritage’ that exists in museums and collections globally. Emmanuel Kasarhérou, the cultural director of the CCT, explains that an inventory was taken in the 1980s of objects belonging to Kanak heritage acquired during and since the contact period by Western collectors and museums. In the consultations that followed between the Kanak Cultural, Scientific and Technical Board (the organisation that preceded the ADCK) and Kanak communities, it was decided that the centre would not actively seek the return of these objects, many of which have spent up to 150 years away from New Caledonia (and which, according to traditional beliefs, may be dangerous if the conditions of acquisition are unknown). Instead, they would be considered ‘ambassadors’ of Kanak culture, employed to ‘let the rest of the world know that Kanaks exist’.6 The CCT is, however, committed to ongoing discussion about how these objects are conserved and displayed overseas. For example, in a recent case, the CCT sent two Kanak carvers to a regional museum in south-west France to show by demonstration and discussion how the sculptures in their collection had traditionally been made (Kasarhérou 2005). Beyond the issue of repatriation, there are other differences between traditional Western-style museums and the CCT. As Kasarhérou explained during a workshop in Papua New Guinea: In New Caledonia many people think that a museum must keep the past but should not exhibit it. Another explanation of our difficulties in attracting Kanak visitors is their fear of entering a place where artefacts of the past are displayed. They feel as if they were entering a cemetery where devils live. The matter however must not be forced, attitudes will change gradually. The only thing to do, is to explain why it is important for the future of our cultures to have a museum. We must explain why museums did not exist in the past and why they are important nowadays… (Kasarhérou 1992, 166).
In this same forum, the director of the National Museum and Art Gallery of Papua New Guinea, Soroi Eoe, similarly suggested that this may be a dominant perception among Pacific Island cultures, where museum collections are perceived as ‘little more than odd assortments of exotic curios… This view was and still is reinforced by the conviction that museums are only partly the emanations of an indigenous cultural personality: they do not really meet the needs of the great majority of indigenous Pacific islanders’ (Eoe 2005, 1).7 As one measure of the CCT’s success as a social actor within the local community, it seems that both the CCT and the Museum of New Caledonia now attract larger numbers of Kanak visitors and culture workers than was the case in the late 1980s. Expanding its own agenda from ethnography to include social history and current issues, the Museum of New Caledonia now hosts contemporary events such as EXPO:
CONTESTED SITES OF IDENTITY NEW MUSEUMS
04.5
La violence, tu sais ce qu’on lui dit? (2005). These examples suggest that the ‘new museum’ paradigm might be more indebted to the practices of ‘museum-like’ spaces, such as the French lineage of cultural centres and eco-museums, than to traditional ethnographic museums (Kasarhérou 2005). It also shows that new museums, cultural centres and other exhibitionary sites in New Caledonia, by expanding their focus to include an interest in contemporary culture, are also playing a part in attempting to bring to fruition Jean-Marie Tjibaou’s dream that the country would one day be ‘irrigated’ with ‘small cultural centres that would be heritage conservation centres and places for contemporary creativity’.8
THE POLITICAL CULTURE AND PERSONALITY CULT OF JEAN-MARIE TJIBAOU The focus on open configurations, representational strategies, and the general commitment to achieving a convincing, ongoing effect of newness is important for new museums at the level of novelty, as a way to keep audiences coming back and to continually attract others. In the case of the CCT, the dedication to forward-looking and non-constant images of identity and culture also emerged as a direct extension of the ideology of Jean-Marie Tjibaou, after whom the centre was named. Leader of the dominant, pro-independence Union Calédonienne party, Tjibaou was revolutionary in his belief that political strength would emerge as a by-product of cultural pride. In a widely quoted statement, he argues that ‘[t]he return to tradition is a myth… No people has ever achieved that. The search for identity, for a model: I believe it lies ahead of us… Our identity lies ahead of us’ (Agency for the Development of Kanak Culture 1998, 4–5; see also Tjibaou 1996; Tjibaou and Missotte 1978; Rollat 1989). Tjibaou rejected the idea that Kanaks must become ‘black Frenchmen’ in order to achieve power or authority, and he envisaged ‘a peaceful resolution of the settler-native confrontation, as long as Kanaks could face France with “a firm personality”, meaning a self-confident identity rooted in culture and history’ (Chappell 1999, 377). He is remembered by many for being, at least in his later years, moderate and reformist, especially in the wake of the ethnic insurgencies that had taken place throughout the 1980s (Agency for the Development of Kanak Culture 1998). He believed that if Kanaks worked toward unified expressions of culture and identity, and a progressive version of tradition that was not at odds with contemporary culture, they would be able to achieve political power more effectively than through any policy of direct action or further violence. Tjibaou’s pointed inter-implication of culture and politics was strategic and relevant, and responded to the fact that, historically, culture has often been the ground on which Kanaks have been persecuted or attacked by the settler community (Maclellan and Chesneaux 1998, 162). Tjibaou argued that ‘to show one’s culture is to show that one exists… There is no cultural phenomenon that doesn’t have an institutional and therefore political impact’.9 Presenting itself as an actor that contributes in concrete ways to social (and possibly political) change, the CCT was designed to embody the intent to formulate a renewed national iconography that is socially progressive as well as culturally sustaining. Despite the sophistication of this objective, it has been writ large in the massive bronze statue of Tjibaou himself that is located atop a nearby hill peak. From here, Tjibaou, dressed partly in Western attire and partly in chiefly garb, oversees his realm, which extends beyond the CCT to encompass the countryside around the city of Noumea. The statue’s privileged location and pose confirm that the centre was envisaged as both ‘the recognition of Kanak culture and the souvenir of Jean-Marie Tjibaou’ (Kasarhérou, quoted
04.6
CONTESTED SITES OF IDENTITY NEW MUSEUMS
Figure 4.3 Jean-Marie Tjibaou statue. Photograph: Kylie Message. Courtesy ADCK-Centre Culturel Tjibaou/Renzo Piano Building Workshop, Architectes.
in Jolly 2001, 432). Determinedly social realist in style, the statue reveals the potential dangers associated with the desire to produce urgently reconfigured national symbols by promoting the personality cult of Jean-Marie Tjibaou. Indeed, the specific problem here, according to Peter Brown, is that ‘[i]n the postmodern age of multiple identities, the search to promote a particular cultural or ethnic identity seems to be a utopian if not regressive gesture, when it is not simply rhetorical and tactical’ (Brown 1998, 136). And yet, as Brown also notes, ‘this cult is also a subtle shift in significance, as Tjibaou the politician calling for independence is replaced by the image of the promoter of his culture’ (134). This shift in strategy, whereby the political is overlaid with
CONTESTED SITES OF IDENTITY NEW MUSEUMS
04.7
the cultural, rather than positioned in opposition to it, has formed the framework for the CCT and for events contributing to its development, including the important Melanesia 2000 festival, organised by Tjibaou and held on the site of the CCT in 1975. The festival was designed to invest the culture of politics with ‘the art of life’ (Chesneaux 1988, 63), so that ‘Kanak political culture’ could become a more unified and effective force that had a clearer understanding of its relationship with traditional culture and custom. As ‘the first great urban cultural demonstration of Kanak culture’ that was held in ‘Nouméa-la-Blanche’ (white Noumea), the festival ‘aimed at a global representation of the Kanak world and for a unified vision, yet without eliminating the particularities of each of its constituents’.10 It sparked a cultural renaissance. A key figure of support for Tjibaou’s legacy throughout the period leading up to the production of the CCT was Alban Bensa. An anthropologist at the École des Hautes Étrudes en Sciences Sociales and principal advisor to Renzo Piano, Bensa reiterated Tjibaou’s fear that Kanaks would be relegated to the ‘prehistoric’.11 He thus advocated a forward-looking ideology that avoided the depiction – and definition – of Kanaks in relation to past images only, where they can have no current agency, political or otherwise. Bensa’s role as advisor to the project clearly had implications in the way it came to be realised. He argued strongly against the simple reconstitution of a traditional Kanak village, which would have been either picturesque or kitsch (with demonstrable links to the Kanak villages displayed at French colonial expositions in 1889 and 1931).12 He also rallied against building the centre as a theme-park-like and overly saturated media-enriched environment (like the Polynesian Cultural Centre in Hawaii). In recommending against a ‘regionalist replica’ style of design, and in rejecting the straightforward incorporation of history into the project, Bensa argued for development of what would become a paradoxical collection of international and global features, and regional references and tensions (Bensa 2000, 162). While this illustrates a rejection of history that is closely connected to the cult of the new in general terms (and reveals the favouring of newness that is the condition of new museums everywhere), what is unique in regard to the CCT is the relationship that this had with Tjibaou’s guiding philosophy of newness and regeneration (Bensa 1992).
THE CONSTITUTION OF CULTURE IN NEW CALEDONIA: TRADITION, MODERNITY AND LES GRANDS TRAVAUX Renzo Piano was commissioned to design the new CCT after winning a competition that was administered by the ADCK and judged by an international panel of architects and other experts (which included the president of ADCK, Marie-Claude Tjibaou; the head of New Zealand’s Maori Affairs Department, Tia Barrett; an Australian anthropologist, Marcia Langton; and the director of the Solomon Islands National Museum, Lawrence Foanoata). The appointment process reflects the desire to project an image of New Caledonia that is progressive and forward-looking. The choice of Piano, which was internationally lauded, provided those involved with a sense of optimism that the CCT might achieve the effect and status of a grand travaux (great work), as well as the creation of a renewed and visible concrete symbol of unification, which was regarded at the time as an urgent task (Graille 2001, 6). Indeed, before construction of the new CCT began, the president of France, François Mitterrand, decreed that it was to be one of the French state’s most important undertakings. It was to be the first of an elite group of significant institutions, known collectively as ‘the Great Projects of the Republic’, to be invested in or built outside
04.8
CONTESTED SITES OF IDENTITY NEW MUSEUMS
of France (Main 1998, 9). Other ‘Great Projects’ in Paris include the Pyramid of the Louvre, the arch at La Défense and the Bibliothèque Nationale de France. The CCT benefited further from the popular ‘hearts, minds and pockets’ policies of the current French President Jacques Chirac in his two years as prime minister in the 1980s, so that the French Government not only covered the 320 million francs initially required for building the CCT but agreed to support substantially the ongoing administration costs of the site (Connell 2003, 128). Given these rich expectations and resources, the CCT aimed to bridge the gap between the apparently conflicting aspirations of the French Government and the desire by activists to achieve a new and independent state of Kanaky. This struggle over nationhood is represented in a biographical exhibit dedicated to the life and works of Jean-Marie Tjibaou. This demonstrates the ‘entanglement of Kanak and French culture, even as it documented the racism of the French and the violence of New Caledonia’s colonial history’ (Jolly 2001, 434). Located in the Mâlep House (mâlep means ‘to live’ in the yâlayu language), the display includes photographic and textual narrative sections under the headings ‘His land, his loved ones’, ‘Serving others, the priesthood and community works’, ‘A political vision based on Kanak culture’, and ‘The Kanak leader opens the way to a common destiny’. Appropriate to Tjibaou’s dream for Kanak culture to resist becoming caught in the past or rendered as static, very few objects are included. As items that correspond directly to the as-yet-unattained future independent state, a ‘Government de Kanaky – FLNKS’ stamp, the flag of Kanaky, and Jean-Marie Tjibaou’s case and passport are shown in one section. No text explains the significance of this arrangement (that would perhaps be obvious to New Caledonians), yet it refers to an important occasion in 1985 when Tjibaou went to Paris and introduced himself as the head of the provisional government of Kanaky (Ouest France, 25–27 May 1985, quoted in Dornoy-Vurobaravu 1994, 11). Bensa, who saw the CCT as ‘a new opportunity to carry forward the political struggle on the cultural and symbolical front where Jean-Marie Tjibaou had so wished it could also develop’, also promoted these aspirations for unification under a centralised independent state (Bensa 2000, 175). He understood that the building had to be convincing in a symbolic sense, as well as impressive and effective in terms of the contribution it could make to the more pragmatic development of cultural confidence in Kanak communities. It needed to provide Kanaks with an emblem of cultural identity that was optimistic, contemporary and open enough to be interpreted and appropriated widely. More than anything else, it needed to embody a promise for the future. Kasarhérou describes the resultant building in the following terms: For the main part of JMTCC [CCT], Piano has incorporated the Kanak concept of a central avenue aligned with groups of grand case (Kanak chiefs’ houses). However Piano has translated this form, giving it a profound new expression: the circular structures of the grand case soar up to thirty metres in height but they are not thatched nor are the walls fully clad. Reminiscent of (Kanak) houses but opening onto a dream of the future, they have a feeling of incompleteness, bringing to mind that Kanak culture itself is not static but is always open to change (Kasarhérou, quoted in Losche 2003, 81).
In addition to providing a physical manifestation of the ideological principles motivating the development of the centre, Kasarhérou explains that Piano’s building aspires to the principles of
CONTESTED SITES OF IDENTITY NEW MUSEUMS
04.9
a pure architectural modernism, so that the structure appears to lift ephemerally up and away from the ground around it. Piano himself says, ‘while the form of the Tjibaou Cultural Centre may have nothing to do with local constructions, it has their spirit, without denying anything of my own modernity’.13 Further registering a break between the traditions of Western architectural practice and the cultural practice of the Kanak communities for whom the centre was designed, it has also been reported that Kanak visitors seem to be most interested in and respond most positively to the ground area surrounding the building, where some communities maintain traditional gardens (Kasarhérou and Mozziconacci 1998, 20; see also Kasarhérou et al. 1998). Instead of seeking a direct relationship with its immediate landscape, however, Piano chose to centralise universalising symbols such as the atmosphere or air, and the passing breeze. His emblems of identity for the future stretch upward and away from the ground that is occupied by the participating Kanak communities. In association with the airy and expansive exhibition spaces inside the buildings, the structure manifests a beauty that challenges rather than replicates the way that the traditional (closed and exclusivist) power structures of Kanak culture have been reproduced in traditional modes of building. It supports a global image of indigenous architecture, or the revisioning of indigenous architecture according to a renewed globalised genre; and yet simultaneously rewrites the traditional pedagogical non-Western style of authority (Memmott and Reser 2000; Dovey 2000; Fantin 2003). Consistently with this, the building appears to privilege a particular version of contemporary Kanak cultural practice that is connected to ideas of progress and development implicit within Piano’s centralised Western position (Austin 1999; Baker 2002). In his critique of the building, Brown quotes from Bensa to suggest that the processes of overinscription (of both the architectural surfaces and the ways of talking about the building) have replaced the traditionally articulated form of closure with the projected illusion of ‘a non-discriminatory and “democratic” openness, in this building [that has been] commissioned and underwritten by a modern Western European state’ (Brown 2002, 283). In appointing Piano and building the project according to an international style of modernism (which links both typologically and genealogically back to the Centre Georges Pompidou in Paris), the CCT manipulates architecture ‘to appropriate the spatial power base of an old [privileged Western] regime for use in the identity formation of a new one’ (Vale 1999, 393). Furthermore, the CCT’s status as a ‘great project’ evidences how: the modern era of nation-states calls for multiple allegiances and alliances, often to be upheld across great distances. Especially in cases where single states encompass multiple would-be-ethnic nations, architectural and urbanistic efforts to articulate a single ‘national identity’ are deeply controversial… [this reflects] the need to extend international identity through staking some new claim to noteworthy modernity… (Vale 1999, 396).
This brings us back to the anachronistic bronze statue of Jean-Marie Tjibaou, and to the risks associated with such overtly singular and non-compromising symbols of nationhood. The primary difficulty with Piano’s building is that it appears literally to seek transcendence from its present location, while at the same time it offers to overlay an international kind of architecture into the local context. This integration provides a reinscription of the local custom and culture, not by
04.10
CONTESTED SITES OF IDENTITY NEW MUSEUMS
local Kanaks, but by Piano and his advisers (that is due also, in part at least, to the limited consultation that preceded building) (Brown 2002, 282; Veracini and Muckle 2002, fn 46). Brown’s critique is not directed toward Piano’s referencing of customary Kanak huts per se, but at his attempt to tweak the politics internal to them. He is concerned that at a symbolic level, Piano’s design ‘updates’ the huts so they fit more comfortably within a European image of social modernity and progress (and as modelled in exemplary form by the Centre Georges Pompidou). Piano’s imprint of unified progress and optimism for the future might thus be interpreted as problematically illustrating a direct connection to the French Government’s plan to reflect the ideologies and interests of the ‘modern’ nation-state of France as the commissioning agency and overriding authority.14 In this case, the modernist architecture may be understood, possibly too simplistically, as signifying a very specific political statement (keeping in mind that although Piano had won a competition held to find the best designer for the project, he already had a particular history with French institutions and government, having designed the Centre Georges Pompidou in Paris in 1977 with Richard Rogers). Not only is the Pompidou Centre an explicit symbol of social progress and an icon of modernity, but it is also widely accepted as the prototype of the new museum model: a point made evident by the architects’ intention to ‘create a new kind of public forum, a non-monumental building of such infinite flexibility that it would be in constant process. The structure’s interdisciplinary organisation was supposed to democratise the arts’ (Newhouse 1998, 193). Perhaps Piano’s popularity was connected to this prior experience of designing ‘populist’ buildings that constitute ‘anti-monuments’. As the most famous of these, the Pompidou Centre has become connected to, and symbolic of, Paris despite the architect’s intention to provide a space that rejected the pedagogical structure and traditional hierarchies of art museums. If we compare the intention toward and effect presented by the Pompidou Centre and the CCT, we can see that not only does the CCT succeed in reflecting an image of New Caledonia that is democratic-looking and progressive in outlook, but that it appears to offer a symbolic (if not thematic) synchronicity with the ideological grandeur and impressive scale of the Pompidou Centre. By asking why it was that a self-consciously new and internationalist style of museum was selected for the purpose of representing Kanak culture, it may be possible to evaluate whether the CCT as a new museum can possibly live up to the rhetorical claims made on its behalf. In epitomising key characteristics of the new museum so effectively, the CCT may ultimately offer an internationally palatable monument for consumption by audiences from outside New Caledonia. If this is the case, it might confirm Claude Patriat’s argument that ‘out of all democratic countries, the French nation has taken furthest the assertion of an active political presence in the cultural field’ as a way to ensure its authority (Patriat, quoted in McGuigan 2004, 66).
THE DESIRE FOR RÉÉQUILIBRAGE (REBALANCING): HISTORY, POLITICS AND INDEPENDENCE Because of the competing political and economic pressures historically at play within New Caledonia, it is simply not possible to separate the global from the local in the context of the CCT. This means that while an international audience may well have been considered primary for the centre’s success, it was also the result of local political action. Specifically, the decision to construct a forward-looking cultural centre dedicated to the preservation and continued devel-
CONTESTED SITES OF IDENTITY NEW MUSEUMS
04.11
opment of Kanak cultural traditions emerged out of the obligation of the Matignon (and Oudinot) Accords (1988) to work toward achieving a degree of political and economic self-autonomy for Kanaks in New Caledonia. In signing this agreement, the French Government undertook ‘to provide for the expression and fulfilment of the Melanesian personality in all its forms’ and ‘to ensure that everyone has access to information and culture’ (Veracini and Muckle 2002). The accords were seen as a way of reducing tension in the area, and of also preserving the principle (and possibly the practice) of the French presence (Maclellan and Chesneaux 1998, 170). They were followed by the Noumea Accord (1998), which replaced a referendum on independence that was to have been held that year but was postponed for another 15–20 years as part of the new agreement. This accord formally acknowledged the trauma of colonisation for Kanaks, and all signatories recognised that ‘Kanak identity’ was central to a new, more autonomous territory with its own citizenship. It legislated the end of New Caledonia’s previous status as a territoire d’outre-mer (overseas territory) of France, and while many felt that this implementation of an ‘irreversible’ process for the transfer of administrative power did not go far enough toward achieving full indépendance kanak et socialiste (Kanak socialist independence), it was generally understood as a reconciliatory gesture and precedent-setting compromise for decolonisation in a multi-ethnic state (Chappell 1999, 373; Maclellan 2004). Central to the accords was the recognition that political progress rested on the capacity to put Kanak culture, custom, identity and experience at the centre of life in New Caledonia. As a key signatory of the Matignon Accords (in his capacity as leader of Union Calédonienne), Tjibaou lobbied for these principles until he was assassinated in 1989 by a dissenting Kanak independentist, Djubelli Wea (Dornoy-Vurobaravu 1994, 10; Henningham 1992). Despite the belief of extremists that the accords would compromise the potential for independent sovereignty,15 the Matignon Accords established the conditions whereby indigenous culture and rights were not to be acknowledged in a rhetorical or symbolic sense only, but were to become the basis for the political reconstruction of the new, multi-ethnic country. The close relationship that emerged between the constitution and development of the CCT and the Matignon Accords and then the Noumea Accord (the CCT opened one day before the latter agreement was signed) was intended as a gesture of goodwill on behalf of the French Government toward Kanaks. The ADCK was established (as part of the Matignon Accords) to be the territory’s principal cultural body, and was charged with promoting Kanak culture and heritage. The interweaving of culture and politics may, as such, have been officially recognised in the constitution of the ADCK, and the CCT may have been intended to open out a space for what James Tully calls a ‘post-imperial dialogue – informed by the spirit of mutual recognition and accommodation of cultural diversity’ (Tully, quoted in Connell 2003, 141).
NEGOTIATING NEW FORMS OF CULTURAL IDENTITY FOR A MULTI-ETHNIC STATE This approach toward representing Kanak culture continues to be legitimated within the CCT on the basis of Tjibaou’s desire to create a space of possibility for the emergence of new and shifting forms of cultural identity and practice: a point that continues to be contextualised by another ongoing dialogue about the relationship between modernity and Kanak culture. And while Tjibaou’s idea of a modern Kanak identity can be understood according to a postcolonial
04.12
CONTESTED SITES OF IDENTITY NEW MUSEUMS
framework, whereby identity is historically and socially contingent and shifting (Clifford 2001, 468), Caroline Graille comments that in 1998, a curator at the CCT claimed that it would be ‘unthinkable’ for the CCT to include work by non-Kanak artists in the centre. This has since occurred, however, and may reveal a broader and more recent attempt at constructing (through the agency of the centre as a key actor in this) a ‘multicultural Caledonian identity’ (Graille 2001, 6). She argues further that: the project to construct ‘postcoloniality’ in a multicultural context as neither a Kanak national state nor a French-dominated quasi-colony is still very recent in New Caledonia… Local artists are only just beginning to produce ‘national’ aesthetic icons whose symbolism will necessarily break with a very Eurocentric, essentialist vision of Kanak culture as ‘traditional’/‘pre-contact’ (and thus colonised and dead), but also be very different from the colonialist vision of New Caledonia as a ‘small France in the Pacific’ (8).
This intent is evident in the general style of work included in the contemporary Kanak and Oceanian collection (many of which were commissioned by the CCT) that is exhibited in the Bérétara Hall (Cochrane 1996). The Kanak works, such as Jean-Noël Mero’s sculpture Oubliées de l’historie (Abandoned by history) (2001) and Yolande Moto’s painting Un nouveau regard sur notre passé (A new look on our past) (1997), often combine aspects of traditionalism with imagery that is highly narrative in style and reminiscent of the cultural renaissance of the 1970s. While this reveals the struggle to come to terms with what it means to be Kanak in a contemporary world,16 it also displays the attempt to represent diversity within the Kanak community and to recognise the immigrant groups living in New Caledonia (the population today is over 215,000 people: 42.5 per cent are Kanak, and while Europeans form the majority, other ethnic groups include immigrants from Wallis and Futuna, French Polynesia, Indonesia, Vietnam and elsewhere).17 Expanding the centre’s focus on Kanak cultural heritage and identity has meant that it can focus on the intersections and cross-cultural dialogue that have historically occurred between communities and cultural forms in New Caledonia. This agenda was recently employed in a temporary exhibition (Paris–Noumea: Les Communards en Nouvelle-Calédonie) on Louise Michel, exiled to New Caledonia for her involvement in the 1871 Paris Commune. Shown in Komwi Hall, the exhibition used events in Michel’s life to illustrate colonial relationships and dialogues between French settlers, convicts and Kanaks. Including artefacts such as large shells engraved with images of ‘European man’ or ‘Kanak man’, the exhibition showed how each culture represented itself and each other at this time. As the country grapples with the conceptual issues pertaining to representation in a national context and how to represent diversity, the centre has become the subject of much debate among New Caledonians. While many support the work it does in promoting Kanak cultural identity and representing this to the world, others have criticised it as a biased symbol that is either too focused on Kanak culture or ‘not Kanak enough’ (Bensa and Wittersheim 1998, 243; Pacific Islands Forum Secretariat 2005, 168; see also Guiart 2001). Commenting, for example, on the CCT’s perceived lack of local visitors and support – ‘of Kanaks, for whom the Centre was built, one hardly meets any. Of Caldoches [descendents of early French settlers (Maclellan and
CONTESTED SITES OF IDENTITY NEW MUSEUMS
04.13
Chesneaux 1998, 145)], even less’ – local journalist Anne Pitoiset noted that the CCT, ‘established to enable and promote the cultural rebirth of the Kanaks… has become not only an identifiable emblem of New Caledonia; but perhaps, to date, the only really internationally successful symbol’ (Pitoiset 2002; Graille 2001, 7; Maclellan and Chesneaux 1998, 145). Pitoiset argues that the CCT’s lack of support by Kanaks is connected to its repudiation of history, on the basis that it risks denying the facts and experiences of colonisation. Others, she explains, see it as preaching a version of colonially constructed culture back to them (‘we do not need the Centre to know our culture’) (Pitoiset 2002). A customary chief who heads the Kanak Socialist Liberation Party, Nidoish Naisseline, has argued that it is a Kanak centre for white people, saying, ‘I have the impression that ethnologists from Paris have come here to teach us about our culture’ (quoted in Main 1998, 9). Dissatisfaction with the CCT is not just expressed by Kanaks: Pitoiset reports that some non-Kanaks resent the CCT as being designed ‘only for Kanaks’, while others wish it represented a more multi-ethnic population, so that ‘[w]hen one goes into the Centre, one should have an idea of New Caledonia as a whole…’ (Pitoiset 2002). This controversy about the representational responsibilities of the CCT has also continually surrounded festivals and other cultural events staged there, from the 1998 exhibition of Pacific art that accompanied its opening, to the highly political eighth Festival of Pacific Arts in 1999, which ‘generated protests from radical Kanak, who called it a “folk-lorisation” of their culture’. On the other hand, though, supporters of this festival ‘saw it as the Kanak reclaiming their “place in the sun” as Tjibaou put it’ (Chappell 2001, 549).
THE CENTRE CULTUREL TJIBAOU, THE OVERSEAS MEDIA AND THE ‘GLOBAL WAR OF IMAGES’ The depth of difference that characterised local receptions to the CCT has not, however, tended to be replicated by international commentary on the centre and its programs.18 This may be because the ADCK actively solicited international press interest during the years leading up to the centre’s opening and throughout its opening festivals. While most of this focused on the muchpromoted architecture emerging on the site, the reports, if making anything other than the most superficial of comments in relation to the building, frequently correlated the emergent building with a new-found peacefulness (the violent insurgencies that wracked the territory throughout the 1980s appeared suppressed to the visiting writers). Located predominantly in the ‘Arts’ or ‘Travel’ sections of major daily newspapers, the resulting columns generally expressed the belief that the CCT was designed to function as a new emblem of hope for, and belief in, cultural reconciliation. In one case, the writer says: ‘Just as France has designed a model decolonisation for New Caledonia, it has bestowed a jewel of a monument on its historically troubled territory’ (Main 1998, 9). These expressions of relief reflect more than just the writers’ enjoyment of the new spectacle. While every country has to negotiate ongoing issues in relation to the form and content of dominant images of national identity, this process is especially fraught for New Caledonia, which continues negotiations over cultural, political and economic independence (or inter-dependence) while balancing the national, sub-national, international and individual impulses that are associated with an increasingly globalised and transnational context. And while architecture and urban design have always performed important roles in the clarification of spatial and social order,
04.14
CONTESTED SITES OF IDENTITY NEW MUSEUMS
newspaper reportage of the early days of the CCT show how the media contributes to producing or promoting particular images, which also demonstrates the ideological processes that are present in the production of the CCT itself. As an important form of ‘publicity’ (as well as a useful, albeit partial, mode of gauging public reception), media sources provide a textual archive and are significant for what they reveal about the public sphere and public culture that emerged in New Caledonia in response to the CCT. In explaining the ongoing political urgency of images, whether they be manifested in print or built form, Murray Edelman says: ‘Especially subtle, powerful, and common are buildings that reinforce a belief that people’s ties to a historic past or a promising future are their important identities’ (Edelman 1995, 76). Accordingly, of the international responses to the centre that I surveyed, the dominant images produced by the CCT presented an idealised picture of Kanak tribal culture that is depicted as forward-focused, ongoing and part of a much greater universal continuum, but that was combined with a much more chimerical, albeit omnipresent, effect of a still-present colonial regime. This focus on the far-reaching past and future means that the inter-ethnic tensions of the interim period (or the complexity of local responses to the centre) are not highlighted (See, for example, Cerebona 1998; Harley 1997; Madoeuf 1998; McGillick 1999; McIntyre 2004; McLean 1998; Power 1998; Riding 2000; Venter 2000; Zinn 1998). These characteristics present an image of the CCT that is consistent with Lawrence Vale’s definition of a ‘mediated monument’ (Vale 1999). While taking into account the point that ‘architecture and design have always performed important roles in the clarification of spatial and social order’ so that the built environment can often be seen as providing a demonstration of or means to interpret national identity, Vale contends that the central point of these structures is that they function as ‘monuments that are inseparable from the media campaigns conducted to construct (and constrict) their interpretation’ (391). In these buildings, political power is often conveyed through the self-conscious construction of ‘forward-reaching symbols’ (391) that have become further animated by the publicity campaigns and international press interest associated with the CCT’s opening. In this case, the media has been particularly influential in shaping public interpretation internationally, and in paying attention to the parade of symbols produced by the opening celebrations and the initial exhibitions of contemporary visual culture and Pacific arts commissioned from across the region. The effect is to risk privileging a forward-looking focus that, when accompanied by a lack of critical analysis, makes only ‘politically useful’ links to the past (Vale 1999, 391). Moreover, contributing to the validity of this argument, Vale contends that ‘[i]n the Pacific Rim of the 1990s and beyond, we are witnessing a global war of images’ (397).
CONCLUSION Driving up from Noumea to the Centre Culturel Tjibaou for the first time, noticing how the grandes cases look persistent and unforgiving about having forced their way through the natural vista, the centre’s pose appeared to me to be confrontational. Despite the CCT’s involvement in contemporary politics (and indeed, considering that it was the product of such politics), the real impact and urgency of these politics – cultural politics – struck me, and something James Clifford had said about Tjibaou vividly came to mind. He said that Tjibaou had insisted that the cultural centre be located in the hostile, settler city of Noumea because, according to Clifford, ‘the
CONTESTED SITES OF IDENTITY NEW MUSEUMS
04.15
politics of cultural and political identity, as he saw it, always worked the boundaries’ (Clifford 2001, 471). I had initially taken note of this because I had never really understood why the centre was located in such a hostile environment, when to my mind it would have been a more convincing gesture of reconciliation for the French Government to finance the existent Centre Culturel Goa Ma Bwarhat, designed by Tjibaou, in the (traditionally pro-independence) northern town of Hienghène (Rosada and Huneau 2004). But when I saw the CCT, looming large – and looking like a series of shields (or upcast fists) that have burst through the ground and now refuse to give way – Clifford’s comment about Tjibaou’s statement suddenly made sense. Later I asked Emmanuel Kasarhérou for his view on this, and he reiterated Tjibaou’s point, explaining that it was important that the centre be in town, as a visible symbolic reminder of the continued existence of Kanak culture (for urban Kanaks, visitors from regional tribes and non-Kanaks). Further reading revealed it was Jean-Marie Tjibaou’s idea to ‘implant’ the ADCK and the CCT ‘in the very city in which Kanaks had hitherto been second-class citizens if not entirely excluded’.19 Kasarhérou also said that if the centre had been located in a rural region, it would have further ostracised Kanaks by suggesting that they are linked to tradition and the past rather than the contemporary reality and changing cultural identities of Kanaks living in the city (which more and more are doing). This would have amounted to ‘putting the Tjibaou Centre out of view, in your back yard’ (Kasarhérou 2005), rather than offering a contemporary and progressive symbol of national identity. Yet even more than this, the centre appears to stand over the city, holding it to account for the events of the past while also offering a progressive and spectacular symbol of identity. This image has stayed with me: of the CCT as an extremely complex case study that shows perhaps more than any others the inter-implication of culture and politics, and the high stakes that are attached to the production of new museums.
Figure 4.4 Looking over the Centre Culturel Tjibaou from Tjibaou statue Photograph: Kylie Message. Courtesy ADCK-Centre Culturel Tjibaou/Renzo Piano Building Workshop, Architectes.
04.16
CONTESTED SITES OF IDENTITY NEW MUSEUMS
ENDNOTES 1
2 3 4 5
6
7
8 9 10
11 12 13 14 15 16
17
18
19
This essay was published previously in reCollections: Journal of the National Museum of Australia, no. 1, vol. 1 (2006): 7–28. From Renzo Piano’s notebooks, see http://www.adck.nc. From ADCK mission statement, http://www.adck.nc. http://www.adck.nc. ‘Courants océaniens, Pacific currents’, Mwà Véé (Kanak cultural review), special edition, no. 14, October 1996, p. 44. Kasarhérou (2005); ‘Living heritage, Kanak culture today’, Mwà Véé, special edition, October 2000, p. 34. See also Pacific Islands Forum Secretariat (2005, 168). For further discussion see Stanley (1998); Murphy (2002); Cochrane (1999). Text from Tjibaou exhibition, Mâlep House, Centre Culturel Tjibaou. In ‘Living heritage, Kanak culture today’, Mwà Véé, p. 8. ‘Living heritage, Kanak culture today’, Mwà Véé, p. 8; Graille (2001, 9, fn. 5); Chesneaux (1988, 62). Bensa (2000, 162); ‘Living heritage, Kanak culture today’, Mwà Véé, p. 8. ‘1931 Des Kanak à Paris’, Mwà Véé, no. 13, June 1996. ‘Living heritage, Kanak culture today’, Mwà Véé, p. 11. For the effect of this on other parts of the islands’ economy, see Horowitz (2004). ‘Separatists still divided on Caledonia’s future’, Sydney Morning Herald, 18 July 1998. ‘Courants océaniens, Pacific currents’, Mwà Véé, p. 50; ‘Living heritage, Kanak culture today’, Mwà Véé, p. 34. For demographic statistics for New Caledonia see The world factbook, updated 1 November 2005. Available from: http://www.cia.gov/cia/publications/factbook/geos/nc.html. Reception by the international mainstream media has been overwhelmingly positive: Cerebona (1998); Harley (1997); Madoeuf (1998); McGillick (1999); McIntyre (2004); McLean (1998); Power (1998); Riding (2000); Venter (2000); Zinn (1998). There has been some critique in academic contexts; see Jolly (2001, 440); see also Brown (2001). ‘Living heritage, Kanak culture today’, Mwà Véé, p. 9.
REFERENCES Agency for the Development of Kanak Culture. 1998. ‘Tjibaou Cultural Centre’, translated by Beynon, Roy. Noumea: ADCK. Agency for the Development of Kanak Culture. 2005. ‘Programme saison 2005 Centre Culturel Tjibaou’. Noumea: ADCK. Aldrich, Robert. 2005. Vestiges of the colonial empire in France: Monuments, museums and colonial memories. Hampshire: Palgrave Macmillan. Austin, Mike. 1999. ‘The Tjibaou Cultural Centre’. Pander OS 2.0 (8). Available from: http://www.thepander.co.nz/architecture/maustin8php. Baker, Carolynne. 2002. ‘The Tjibaou Cultural Centre: Centring Kanak identity’. In De-placing difference: Architecture, culture and imaginative geography, edited by Akkach, Samer. Adelaide: Centre for Asian and Middle Eastern Architecture, University of Adelaide.
CONTESTED SITES OF IDENTITY NEW MUSEUMS
04.17
Bennett, Tony. 1995. The birth of the museum: History, theory, politics. London and New York: Routledge. Bensa, Alban, editor. 1992. La réalisation du Centre Culturel Jean-Marie Tjibaou: Analyses, enquêtes, documentation. Noumea/Paris: Ministère de la Culture, Mission des Grands Travaux. Bensa, Alban. 2000. Ethnologie et architecture: Le Centre Culturel Tjibaou, une réalisation de Renzo Piano. Paris: Adam Biro. Bensa, Alban; Wittersheim, Eric. 1998. ‘Jean Guiart and New Caledonia: A drama of misrepresentation’. Journal of Pacific History 33 (2): 221–225. Brown, Peter. 1998. ‘New Caledonia: Strangers in paradise, stranger than paradise’. International Journal of Francophone Studies 1 (3): 125–139. Brown, Peter. 2001. ‘New Caledonia: A Pacific island or an island in the Pacific? The eighth Pacific arts festival’. International Journal of Francophone Studies 4 (1): 33–41. Brown, Peter 2002. ‘Book review: Ethnologie et architecture: Le centre culturel Tjibaou, une réalisation de Renzo Piano’. Contemporary Pacific 14 (1): 281–284. Cerebona, Ron. 1998. ‘Nouméa centre focuses on Kanak culture’. Canberra Times (15 June). Chakrabarty, Dipesh. 2002. ‘Museums in late democracies’. Humanities Review 9 (1): 5–12. Chappell, David. 1999. ‘The Nouméa Accord: Decolonisation without independence in New Caledonia?’ Pacific Affairs 72 (3): 373–391. Chappell, David. 2001. ‘Book review: En pays Kanak: Ethnologie, linguistique, archéologie, histoire de la Nouvelle-Calédonie’. Contemporary Pacific 13 (2): 592–594. Chesneaux, Jean. 1988. ‘Kanak political culture and French political practice’. In New Caledonia: Essays in nationalism and dependency, edited by Spencer, Michael; Ward, Alan; Connell, John. St Lucia: University of Queensland Press. Clifford, James. 2001. ‘Dialogue: Indigenous articulations’. Contemporary Pacific 13 (2): 468–490. Cochrane, Susan. 1996. ‘Pacific stories from New Caledonia’. Artlink 16 (4): 52–54. Cochrane, Susan. 1999. ‘Out of the doldrums: Museums and cultural centres in Pacific Islands countries in the 1990s’. In Art and performance in Oceania, edited by Craig, Barrie; Kernot, Bernie; Anderson, Christopher. Honolulu: University of Hawaii Press. Connell, John. 2003. ‘An infinite pause in decolonisation?’ Round Table 368: 125–143. Dornoy-Vurobaravu, Myriam. 1994. Policies and perceptions of France in the South Pacific: New Caledonia and Vanuatu. Vanuatu: Institute of Pacific Studies and USP Complex. Dovey, Kim. 2000. ‘Myth and media: Constructing Aboriginal architecture’. Journal of Architectural Education 54 (1): 2–6. Edelman, Murray. 1995. From art to politics: How artistic creations shape political conceptions. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. Eoe, Soroi. 2005. ‘The role of museums in the Pacific: Change or die’. In Museums and cultural centres in the Pacific, edited by Eoe, Soroi; Swadling, Pamela. Papua New Guinea: National Capital District, Papua New Guinea National Museum. Fantin, Shaneen. 2003. ‘Aboriginal identities in architecture’. Architecture Australia (September–October). Available from: http://www.archmedia.com.au. Graille, Caroline. 2001. ‘From “primitive” to contemporary: A story of Kanak art in New Caledonia’. [Internet]. A State Society and Governance in Melanesia discussion paper, Research School of Pacific and Asian Studies, Australian National University, Canberra, no. 01/2. Accessed 4 July 2006. Available from: http://rspas.anu.edu.au/melanesia/dplist.php?searchterm=2001. Guiart, Jean. 2001. ‘Comment: A reply to A Bensa and E Wittersheim, “Jean Guiart and New Caledonia: A drama of misrepresentation”’. Journal of Pacific History 36 (2): 247–249. Harley, Robert. 1997. ‘Renzo Piano building a vision’. Australian Financial Review (28 November). Henningham, Stephen. 1992. France and the South Pacific: A contemporary history. Sydney: Allen and Unwin. Horowitz, Leah. 2004. ‘Toward a viable independence? The Koniambo project and the political economy of mining in New Caledonia’. Contemporary Pacific 16 (2): 287–319.
04.18
CONTESTED SITES OF IDENTITY NEW MUSEUMS
Jolly, Margaret. 2001. ‘On the edge? Deserts, oceans, islands’. The Contemporary Pacific 13 (2): 417–466. Kasarhérou, Emmanuel. 1992. ‘The New Caledonian museum’. In Museums and Cultural Centres in the Pacific, edited by Eoe, Soroi; Swadling, Pamela. Papua New Guinea: National Capital District, Papua New Guinea National Museum. Kasarhérou, Emmanuel. 1995. ‘“Men of flesh and blood”: The Jean-Marie Tjibaou Cultural Centre in Nouméa’. Art and Asia Pacific 2 (4): 90–95. Kasarhérou, Emmanuel. 2005. Interview by Kylie Message. Centre Culturel Tjibaou. 16 November. Kasarhérou, Emmanuel; Mozziconacci, Cécile. 1998. Centre Culturel Tjibaou. Noumea: ADCK. Kasarhérou, Emmanuel; Wedoye, Béalo; Boulay, Roger; Merleau-Ponty, Claire. 1998. Guide to the plants of the Kanak Path. Noumea: ADCK. Losche, Diane. 2003. ‘Cultural forests and their objects in New Caledonia, the forest on Lifou’. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Art 4 (1): 77–91. Lumley, Robert, editor. 1988. The museum time machine: Putting cultures on display. London: Routledge. Macdonald, Sharon. 2003. ‘Museums, national, postnational and transcultural identities’. Museum and Society 1 (1): 1–16. Maclellan, Nic. 2004. ‘From Eloi to Europe: Interactions with the ballot box in New Caledonia’. [Internet]. Available from: http://www.usp.ac.fj/fileadmin/files/Institutes/piasdg/Electoral_Systems_2004/es2004_Maclellan.pdf. Maclellan, Nic; Chesneaux, Jean. 1998. After Mururoa: France in the South Pacific. Melbourne: Ocean Press. Madoeuf, Franck. 1998. ‘New Caledonia cultural center to express Kanak identity’. Agence France Presse (3 May). Main, Victoria. 1998. ‘New Caledonia takes a gamble on beauty’. The Press (2 December). McGillick, Paul. 1999. ‘A sublime Kanak creation’. Australian Financial Review (13 March). McGuigan, Jim. 2004. Rethinking cultural policy. Berkshire, England: Open University Press. McIntyre, Andrew. 2004. ‘Independence in the Pacific: France’s positive approach’. National Observer (Summer): 12–15. McLean, Sandra. 1998. ‘Accent on culture’. Daily Telegraph (5 September). Memmott, Paul; Reser, Joe. 2000. ‘Design concepts and processes for public Aboriginal architecture’. PaPER 55–56: 69–86. Message, Kylie. 2005. ‘Representing cultural diversity in a global context: The Museum of New Zealand Te Papa Tongarewa and the National Museum of Australia’. International Journal of Cultural Studies 8 (4): 465–485. Message, Kylie; Healy, Chris. 2004. ‘A symptomatic museum: The new, the NMA and the culture wars’. Borderlands e-journal 3 (3). Available from: http://www.borderlandsejournal.adelaide.edu.au/vol3no3_2004/messagehealy_symptom.htm. Montaner, Josep Maria. 2003. Museums for the 21st Century, translated by Black, M. Barcelona, Spain: Gustavo Gili. Murphy, Bernice. 2002. ‘Centre Culturel Tjibaou: A museum and arts centre defining New Caledonia’s cultural future’. Humanities Review 9 (1): 77–90. Newhouse, Victoria. 1998. Towards a new museum. New York: The Monacelli Press. Pacific Islands Forum Secretariat. 2005. A pacific plan for strengthening regional cooperation and integration (final draft). Suva, Fiji: Pacific Islands Forum Secretariat. Pitoiset, Anne. 2002. ‘What is the Tjibaou Centre being used for? Disappointed hopes of the CCT’. L’EXPRESS.fr (10 October). Available from: http://www.lexpress.fr/. Power, Liza. 1998. ‘French tropical twist’. The Age (26 September). Preziosi, Donald; Farago, Claire, editors. 2004. Grasping the world: The idea of the museum. Burlington, Vermont: Ashgate Publishers. Riding, Alan. 2000. ‘Showcasing a rise from rebellion to respectability’. The New York Times (5 March). Rollat, Alain. 1989. Tjibaou le Kanak. Lyon: La Manufacture.
CONTESTED SITES OF IDENTITY NEW MUSEUMS
04.19
Rosada, Alexandre; Huneau, Philippe. 2004. ‘October 16, 2004: The arts centre of Hienghène celebrates its 20 years’. [Internet]. Available from: http://www.rosada.net/hienghene.htm. Simpson, Moira. 1996. Making representations: Museums in the post-colonial era. London: Routledge. Stanley, Nick. 1998. Being ourselves for you: Global display of cultures. London: Middlesex University Press. Tjibaou, Jean-Marie. 1996. La présence Kanak, edited by Bensa, Alban; Wittersheim, Eric. Paris: Editions Odile Jacob. Tjibaou, Jean-Marie; Missotte, Philippe. 1978. Kanaké: The Melanesian way, translated by Plant, Christopher. Papeete: Les Editions du Pacifique. Vale, Lawrence. 1999. ‘Mediated monuments and national identity’. Journal of Architecture 4 (Winter): 391–408. Venter, Nick. 2000. ‘Pacific architecture puts NZ to shame – Goff’. Dominion (12 July). Veracini, Lorenzo; Muckle, Adrian. 2002. ‘Reflections of indigenous history inside the national museums of Australia and Aotearoa New Zealand and outside of New Caledonia’s Centre Culturel Jean-Marie Tjibaou’. Electronic Journal of Australian and New Zealand History. Available from: http://www.jcu.edu.au/aff/history/articles/veracini_muckle.htm. Vergo, Peter, editor. 1988. The new museology. London: Reaktion Books. Zinn, Christopher. 1998. ‘Cultural centre symbolises island’s birth’. Manchester Guardian Weekly (15 November).
Cite this chapter as: Message, Kylie. 2006. ‘Contested sites of identity and the cult of the new: The Centre Culturel Tjibaou and the constitution of culture in New Caledonia’. South Pacific museums, edited by Healy, Chris; Witcomb, Andrea. Monash University ePress: Melbourne. pp. 4.1–4.20. DOI: 10.2104/spm06004.
04.20
CONTESTED SITES OF IDENTITY NEW MUSEUMS
NEW MUSEUMS
NATIONAL MUSEUM OF AUSTRALIA Linda Young, Deakin University Linda Young is a senior lecturer in the Cultural Heritage and Museum Studies program at Deakin University, Melbourne. She is a museum critic, a historian of heritage genres and practice, and a student of nineteenth-century Anglo domestic and personal material culture. Correspondence to Linda Young:
[email protected]
A national museum for Australia might always have seemed a redundancy, given that seven colonial museums and art galleries were established in the nineteenth century. Federation took place in 1901, but it was via a peaceful process of referendum, and though the idea of a national museum was mooted in the 1920s, and occasionally thereafter, a monumental representation of national unity was never anyone’s priority. Such need as might have been felt was met in 1941 with the opening of the Australian War Memorial; a museum commemorating the Great War, it was primed with the acknowledged national story of Aussie diggers in battle and has presented that theme to public acclaim ever since. Nonetheless, the prosperity of the post-World War II period, the cultural nationalist revival of the 1970s, and the rise of Australian history and heritage consciousness began to suggest that a national story should have institutional expressions. The Australian National Gallery opened in 1973, crossing the Rubicon of collecting artworks in contest with the state galleries. The Australian Heritage Commission was launched in 1975, asserting the value of conserving colonial, Victorian, vernacular and even modern buildings as identifiers of national character. In the 1980s the state museums began to revive, starting with developments in Western Australia to display the finds of Dutch coastal wrecks of the seventeenth century and in New South Wales to mark the 1988 bicentenary of white settlement. Establishing a national museum was among the recommendations of a government inquiry in 1975, with a three-part program to represent the environment, Indigenous culture and people, and the history of European settlement (Committee of Inquiry 1975, 70–71). It achieved legislative reality in 1980, with a handful of staff and a mandate to collect, but no promises to build. In this form, the National Museum of Australia (NMA) puttered along for nearly twenty years, living from hope to hope that government would pick up its cause. When this finally happened, it was Liberal Prime Minister John Howard who decreed in 1998 that a formal home for the museum would be the centrepiece of the 2001 centenary celebrations of Federation. For such a huge development project, the schedule was woefully short. The museum had no charismatic leadership, having long been the creature of efficient but politically ineffective public servants. Ministerial action suddenly switched the site from a paddock, long planned to be capable of further development, to a picturesque but very constrained peninsula. The competition to design the building was so pressed that it was officially blackballed by the Institute of Architects, but it produced an Australian design of sufficient flair for controversy. Melbourne firm Ashton Raggatt McDougall infused their plans with cosmic rhetoric, subversive jokes and contemporary references, which were more prominent than functional exhibition galleries, but they fulfilled the unspoken requirement for a spectacular museum building. A large American design company was contracted to produce the complex internal installations and multimedia requisite for a museum of the third millennium. Content suggested by collections had been in the minds of curatorial staff for some years, and now had to be cast rapidly into exhibits shaped by what was
SOUTH PACIFIC MUSEUMS MONASH UNIVERSITY EPRESS
05.1
taken to be accepted cultural policy in multiculturalism and Indigenous rights, expressed via current directions in academic and popular history. The large story of the National Museum’s galleries remained much as in the original threepart format proposed in 1975, now conceived as land, people and nation. Dawn Casey, the director in the seat at the time of opening, articulated the museum’s approach as a forum for ideas about being Australian: ‘We intend the Museum to speak with many voices, listen and respond to all, and promote debate and discussion about questions of diversity and identity’ (Casey 2001, 6). To academics and museum professionals, this seemed the very model of a modern national history museum. Curatorial staff were aware of the potential for criticism of interpretative cultural histories fed by new techniques of historiography, and anticipated contention in the Gallery of First Australians. But the ‘history wars’ between ‘black armband’ apologists and ‘white blindfold’ progressives had not yet moved from academe into the public sphere. First Australians: Gallery of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Peoples dealt with the most sensitive subject for the NMA. The central plank of the gallery was that Indigenous cultures are distinct, resilient and here-and-now, as shown in the presence of Aboriginal people via a large investment in multimedia. Its presentation of the land rights issue was always going to be the acid test of its commitment to modern historiography and Indigenous cultural rights: the NMA made the case by invoking primal documents to show that the earliest European colonists were expected by the Crown and, indeed, expected themselves to negotiate with the native people for rights to land. At the same time, new trends in Aboriginal oral history and cultural mapping were interpreted in exhibits showing that murder and even massacre also played roles in the settlers’ struggle for the land. When the museum opened, there were rumbles of protest about calumny against pioneers and the say-so words of traditional knowledge, but there was also praise from Indigenous and white groups.
Figure 5.1 Gallery of First Australians, National Museum of Australia, 2001. Photograph: Brendan Bell. © National Museum of Australia 2001.
05.2
NATIONAL MUSEUM OF AUSTRALIA NEW MUSEUMS
Nation: Symbols of Australia was the museum’s primary statement about the nature of Australian identity, and in an attempt to avoid perceived clichés, it was presented via symbols of power and popular culture. Thus exhibits on the symbolism of wool, gold, the World War I digger and transport construed as communication were as close to popular tropes of national history as the museum ventured. The theme of the backyard, ‘where Australians are most truly themselves’, drew on the recently confirmed iconic power of the Hills hoist and the Victa lawnmower, bestowed by the opening ceremony of the Sydney 2000 Olympics. ‘Nation’ also featured one of the most spectacular multimedia items in a hi-tech museum: a vast sequence of statistics, accounts and images projected on a very large map of the country. Visitors were surprised by the mixture, and a few were hostile. Horizons: The Peopling of Australia since 1788 constituted the museum’s offering on the big Australian story of immigration, beginning with Captain Cook’s discovery and moving rapidly onto the twentieth century. Horizons contained more narrative and chronology than the other galleries, and was liberal with personal case histories. The pressure of national inclusiveness was evident in the range of specimen stories: one from every state, representing men and women, Anglos and other ethnicities, early-day convicts to the most recent arrivals from Kosovo. More interesting was the gallery’s perspective on the ambivalence of immigration and of immigrants’ receptions – issues polarised by the Tampa affair in late 2001, just after the museum’s opening. Horizons turned out to bear the brunt of the formal criticism of the NMA made in the subsequent Carroll Review, for minimising the heroic dimension of the British founding fathers (National Museum of Australia Review Committee 2003). Tangled Destinies: Land and People in Australia expressed what used to be called ‘natural history’ – presented at the NMA through the lens of seeing and understanding the land. It produced a history of the natural history of Australia, tracing ideas about the environment and its plant and animal inhabitants over millennia of Indigenous occupation and two centuries of subsequent immigrant history. Many startling objects made the point that the European style of knowledge frequently and drastically misunderstood the Australian environment. By the time it was understood how old and fragile both landforms and human presence were, great damage had been done. Yet for better or worse, argued the exhibition, the invaders – human, animal, vegetable – became Australian too. The direction was grounded in an approach to objects and specimens as ideas made material rather than as artefacts pure and simple; the style pleased some but was called ‘over-intellectual’ by others. Eternity: Stories from the Emotional Heart of Australia was the most original gallery in the museum; it might be called a contemplation of the human condition through individual objects presented in the context of their owners’ emotional lives. It proposed ten emotions or affects, such as hope, joy and loneliness, each expressed five times by a single object belonging to an Australian or Australian-associated person, a few well-known, most unknown. The significance was not always clear to the visitor – how could it be? But all viewers possess objects that are precious for associations with special people or crucial places or defining moments in personal history, and visitors responded frankly with their own on-the-spot video accounts, which were added to the loops of visuals throughout.
NATIONAL MUSEUM OF AUSTRALIA NEW MUSEUMS
05.3
Figure 5.2 Eternity Gallery, National Museum of Australia, 2003 Photograph: George Serras. © National Museum of Australia 2001.
Public response about the content and depth of the museum’s offerings was (and has remained) overwhelmingly positive (National Museum of Australia 2006). But crucial elements of the museum’s governing council objected deeply to what they saw as a mockery of national achievement, and succeeded in launching a full-scale review of the exhibits, reporting in 2003. The resulting report surprised many by focusing its criticism less on the Indigenous culture gallery than on Nation, Horizons, and the natty multimedia theatre Circa, an orientation piece at the entry to the museum galleries. A consistent theme of critique was the absence of strong narrative stories, evidently underlaid by the primary author’s conviction of modern society’s need for inspiring myths (Carroll 2001). Museum staff responded with a revision document outlining a unifying theme of ‘place’, backed up by substantial acquisitions. Accepted by the council, the Federal Government laid out substantial new funding for collection growth and gallery redevelopment, unfurling in 2007–08.
05.4
NATIONAL MUSEUM OF AUSTRALIA NEW MUSEUMS
REFERENCES Carroll, John. 2001. The western dreaming: The western world is dying for want of a story. Pymble, New South Wales: HarperCollins. Casey, Dawn. 2001. ‘The National Museum of Australia: Exploring the past, illuminating the present and imagining the future’. In National museums: Negotiating histories: Conference proceedings, edited by McIntyre, Darryl; Wehner, Kirsten. Canberra: National Museum of Australia. Committee of Inquiry on Museums and National Collections. 1975. Museums in Australia 1975. Canberra: Australian Government Publishing Service. National Museum of Australia. 2006. ‘Likes (and dislikes) about the National Museum of Australia’. [Internet]. Accessed 9 June 2006. Available from: http://www.nma.gov.au/about_us/corporate_documents/evaluation_and_visitor_research/likes_and_disli kes/#row_4. National Museum of Australia Review Committee. 2003. ‘Review of the National Museum of Australia, its exhibitions and public programs’. [Internet]. Accessed 18 June 2006. Available from: http://www.nma.gov.au/about_us/corporate_documents/exhibitions_and_public_programs_review/review_re port/.
Cite this chapter as: Young, Linda. 2006. ‘National Museum of Australia’. South Pacific museums, edited by Healy, Chris; Witcomb, Andrea. Monash University ePress: Melbourne. pp. 5.1–5.5. DOI: 10.2104/spm06005.
NATIONAL MUSEUM OF AUSTRALIA NEW MUSEUMS
05.5
NEW SYMPOSIUM MUSEUMS
PLURALISM AND EXHIBITION PRACTICE AT THE NATIONAL MUSEUM OF AUSTRALIA Mathew Trinca, National Museum of Australia Mathew Trinca is a senior curator and head of Collections and Gallery Development at the National Museum of Australia. His research interests are in Australian cultural history and museology. Correspondence to Mathew Trinca:
[email protected] Kirsten Wehner, National Museum of Australia Kirsten Wehner is a senior curator at the National Museum of Australia and a visual anthropologist, completing her doctorate through New York University on the development of the National Museum 1997–2001. Her research interests encompass the anthropology of history, cultural politics of representation, museological practice, and histories of film and photography. Correspondence to Kirsten Wehner:
[email protected]
Growing recognition of the plural character of contemporary societies has underwritten significant changes in museum practice in recent years. Cultural institutions are now by and large sensitive to the differentiated nature of the communities in which they are located. In museums, a more nuanced and complex view of difference has led to improvements in outreach programs and public accessibility, and regard for the need to welcome groups formerly distant or disaffected from the museum. The collaborative, enduring partnerships between museums and Indigenous communities that have developed in recent decades are welcome examples of these changes. In this paper, we explore how the ‘new museology’ has influenced the history of the National Museum of Australia and the consequences of a recent, well-publicised review of the museum’s exhibitions and public programs. We then consider how contemporary museums have used a concept of ‘multiple voices’ or ‘multi-vocality’ to represent pluralist societies and advance social inclusion, and suggest some of the problems in such an approach, especially for a museum charged with exploring national meaning. In thinking about alternative approaches, we consider the museum exhibition as a performative space and draw on the concept of the flâneur as we refocus attention on visitor behaviour in galleries. We then outline how this approach might inform development at the National Museum of Australia of a new permanent gallery representing a general history of the nation.
THE NATIONAL MUSEUM OF AUSTRALIA The word ‘national’ was invoked rhetorically by colonial museums and galleries in Australia long before Federation in 1901.1 Notwithstanding these semantic flourishes, calls for a national museum began in earnest toward the end of the nineteenth century, and were initially defined by interests in natural history and biological sciences (Robin 2003). In almost every decade after that, until the National Museum of Australia (NMA) was established by legislation in 1980, arguments for a national museum were made and remade. Variously, there were calls for national museums of zoology, ethnology, entomology, botany and history. Some of these – particularly the energy which surrounded Sir Colin MacKenzie’s foundation of the Australian Institute of Anatomy in the 1920s – were founded on the high regard for the nation-building value of scientific knowledges.
06.1
SOUTH PACIFIC MUSEUMS MONASH UNIVERSITY EPRESS
The National Museum of Australia may be the inheritor of MacKenzie’s collections, but its foundation is more concretely traced to the 1975 report of the Committee of Inquiry on Museums and National Collections, often known as the Pigott Report. The report – distinguished professors John Mulvaney and Geoffrey Blainey were key authors – called for the establishment of a Museum of Australia centred on three themes, loosely described as:
• Indigenous histories and cultures; • ‘European’ histories from 1788; and • Environmental histories of Australian places. (Committee of Inquiry on Museums and National Collections 1975, 70–71) As well as a sense of mission and optimism, the Pigott Report was remarkably prescient about the debates within which the ‘national museum’ would one day find itself. It recognised that a national purview was not easily defined, nor would its responsibilities be simply discharged. Infused with a palpable sense of moment, the report argued that: In defining the scope of a national museum we recommend that the phrase ‘national’ should be interpreted in a wide sense. The museum should portray, when appropriate, European and Asian and American influences on Australia’s human and natural history. Australia’s communications with the outside world should be an important theme in the museum (Committee of Inquiry on Museums and National Collections 1975, 73).
The committee was alert to the dangers of any narrow interpretation of the new museum’s role. Five years later enabling legislation – the National Museum of Australia Act 1980 – established the museum as an institutional entity, if not as a physical presence. Within the act, there was direction about the expected national ‘reach’ of the institution, and its responsibilities to reflect Australian history domestically and internationally. Specifically, the museum was also charged with building a collection of material culture to range over the breadth of national experience, which has become known formally as the National Historical Collection.
THE NEW MUSEOLOGY While the NMA began collecting actively in the early 1980s, successive governments dithered over the scale and site of its planned exhibition buildings. Imagined first at a western lakeside site and then at Yarramundi Reach, in Canberra, the museum’s main building was finally opened in 2001 on Acton Peninsula, closer to the city’s main civic centre. In the intervening years, however, the conceptual landscape for museums had shifted, with the academy and museum professionals defining new purpose and practice under the emerging rubric of the ‘new museology’. There are clear difficulties in precisely defining this field, once famously described by Peter Vergo as ‘a state of widespread dissatisfaction with the “old” museology’ (Vergo 1989, 3). Vergo’s line is glib, but does at least represent the critical sense that has underpinned theorising of the contemporary museum in recent decades. Some characteristics of this movement have clearly informed museum developments in this country – in common with those in other parts of the world – not least the NMA. Tony Bennett’s influential book The birth of the museum
PLURALISM AND EXHIBITION PRACTICE AT THE NMA NEW MUSEUMS
06.2
deconstructed the cultural politics of the museum, revealing the authoritative, ideological intent springing from a sense of its social role. Bennett recognised that: the division between the hidden space of the museum in which knowledge is produced and organized and the public spaces in which it is offered for passive consumption produces a monologic discourse dominated by the authoritative cultural voice of the museum. To break this discourse down, it is imperative that the role of the curator be shifted away from that of the source of an expertise whose function is to organize a representation claiming the status of knowledge and towards that of the possessor of a technical competence whose function is to assist groups outside the museum to use its resources to make authored statements within it (Bennett 1995, 103–4).
Bennett’s arguments helped sustain the ‘new’ democratic mood in the contemporary museum, even though he was himself aware of the internal contradictions this posed (103n). If the museum was an ‘exhibitionary complex’ that expressed a powerful will to mould ideal citizens, then the answer in part seemed to be that it should adopt modes of practice that decentred an insistent authoritative voice. Such practices included bringing a greater range of perspectives and interests to the museum’s exhibition making. Following this lead, the NMA described its mission in terms that de-emphasised a singular authority, preferring instead to accent representational breadth, social inclusion and a textual reflexivity. Soon after opening the Acton building in 2001, then director Dawn Casey described the NMA as a ‘forum, a place for dialogue and debate… We intend the museum to speak with many voices, listen and respond to all, and promote debate and discussion about questions of diversity and identity’ (Casey 2001, 6, our emphasis). The exhibitions at the Acton site tended to emphasise a complex narrative that embraced multi-vocality and representational breadth. This many-voiced exhibition practice was designed not only to represent the ways in which people might hold different views of the past, but also to encourage diverse groups to locate themselves in the national story. By representing a selection of opinion or views about an event or condition, the museum was also striving to be sensitive to the contingent nature of historical truth.
THE REVIEW OF THE NATIONAL MUSEUM OF AUSTRALIA Soon after opening its doors at Acton in 2001, the NMA found itself caught in the crossfire of the history wars (Macintyre and Clark 2003). Largely fought over conflicting views of Australia’s frontier history, the combatants also raged over other themes in the broader historical record. In a sense, there was nothing new in this. From the nineteenth century, opposing interests have wrestled for the iconographic high ground in Australia – there have been intense debates between emancipists and exclusives, between labour and capital, between Irish and Anglo traditions, and between the left and right of Australian politics, among others. For many, it is this continuing contest for national meaning that itself exemplifies the nation’s healthy, robust civil society. It was in this oppositional climate that a panel of review of the NMA was appointed in January 2003. Chaired by Professor John Carroll, of La Trobe University, the panel included museum anthropologist Philip Jones, paleontologist Patricia Vickers-Rich and businessman
06.3
PLURALISM AND EXHIBITION PRACTICE AT THE NMA NEW MUSEUMS
Richard Longes. After a series of meetings with museum staff and external interests, and review of written submissions, the panel released its report in July 2003: Review of the National Museum of Australia: Its exhibitions and public programs (the Carroll Review). While it opened with a broad statement praising the ‘extraordinary achievement’ of the museum, the report went on to make substantial criticisms of its curatorial and exhibition practices. In particular it said much about the need for clearer narratives and storylines in the museum, and for iconic – what it called ‘numinous’ – artefacts to be included in its galleries (Commonwealth of Australia 2003, 42). The Carroll Review’s criticisms went to both the content and form of the NMA’s exhibitions. In terms of the museum’s representation of nation, it argued that the pre-eminent goal of the NMA was to tell the ‘Australian story’ by ‘means of generating consistent themes articulating objects, and thereby to inspire, to satisfy curiosity, to educate and to entertain’ (Commonwealth of Australia 2003, 12). It also made clear its concern that the museum should represent the ‘establishment of a notably stable, efficiently managed, prosperous democracy, with very low levels of institutional corruption, with relatively low social inequality and a largely inclusive ethos, which has integrated immigrant peoples from hundreds of other places with reasonable success’ (8). At the same time, the panel was keen to emphasise its divergence from Graeme Davison’s views that ‘rather than suppressing difference by imposing a single authorial voice… the NMA might better begin with the assumption that the imagined community we call the nation is by its very nature plural and in flux’ (Commonwealth of Australia 2003, 8). Instead of Davison’s support for ‘interpretative pluralism’, the Carroll Review emphasised a view that saw ‘more consensus than plurality at the core of the national collective conscience’ (8). The panel therefore set the future of the NMA within a clearly divided rhetorical contest over the character of the nation. It contrived a division between a consensual and plural view of the national community, and by implication contested the inclusive politics that lay at the heart of the new museology.
REPRESENTING AN INCLUSIVE SOCIETY Acknowledgment of the social role of museums dates back to the Enlightenment (HooperGreenhill 1989; Hooper-Greenhill 1992); what is different in the contemporary museum is the way in which that role has been construed. The new museology has tended to emphasise the capacity of museums to foster social inclusion through a specific representational politics (Karp et al. 1992; Newman and McLean 2002). By describing a representational breadth, commentators have argued, the museum creates opportunities for visitors to find themselves within a text, to feel a part – in the case of the NMA – of a national community. In common with counterparts overseas, contemporary Australian museums have recently delineated a role for themselves in building civic capacity and promoting social inclusion. In the United Kingdom, the National strategy for neighbourhood renewal, PAT 10: Arts and sport (2001) identified social inclusion as a priority for museums and other cultural institutions (Department of Culture, Media and Sport 2001). The American Association of Museums’ 2002 report Mastering civic engagement established a similar argument (Archibald 2002, 3; see also Sandell 2002 and Gaither 2004, 111). In the aftermath of the Carroll Review at the NMA in 2003, the profession’s peak body, Museums Australia, contended that:
PLURALISM AND EXHIBITION PRACTICE AT THE NMA NEW MUSEUMS
06.4
policies of social inclusion have become the mandate for museums as we enter the 21st century… Fundamental to the realisation of social inclusion in museums is the presentation of stories highlighting the diversity of a nation’s population, a nation’s history from the multiple viewpoints of its citizens and the celebration of people from all walks of life, all stations, all creeds (Scott 2003).
This argument of an expanded social role, emphasising an inclusive representational frame achieved through the ‘multiple voices’ featured in exhibitions, underpinned professional practice at the NMA through the 1990s, and through the project development of its exhibition space at Acton. The museum’s permanent galleries included objects that ranged from the everyday to the iconic, and which attempted to represent the practical reality of Australia’s pluralist society. It also chose to avoid simplistic attempts to settle hoary questions of national identity, preferring to depict the nation as the sum of its parts through serried perspectives represented in its exhibitions. Furthermore, the museum adopted a playful tone, juxtaposing contrary views of historical events and consciously using irony and satire in its permanent galleries. This approach, however, is not without its problems. Arguing the value of the NMA in such instrumental terms – as an agent of social cohesion – is based on problematic idealisations of what constitutes an inclusive community. After all, the discourse of social inclusion itself has critics: opponents on the left challenge that a socially inclusive society subsumes difference rather than respects it; while the right is sceptical about prospects for collective transformations of this kind. Both criticisms reveal the difficulty in abstracting community and civic values as social goods. Moreover, the representation of difference in exhibitions cannot of itself discharge the museum’s responsibilities to a plural Australian community (Bennett 1995, 102–103). It tends to obscure the enduring reality of a conscious and insistent curatorial authority in exhibition making. The selection of perspectives represented in any exhibition – even those that include several voices – must ultimately be revealed as limited and partial. While this may be an understandable function of the museum’s spatial and textual constraints, it is still galling to visitors whose expectations are formed by institutional claims to representational breadth. An example of this was seen in the NMA’s gallery devoted to immigration, Horizons, in which the presentation of stories from several ethnic groups provoked complaints from others who felt they had been omitted. In these terms, the museum’s attempts to represent ethnic diversity through ‘multiple voices’ drew attention to its limited range, rather than promoting a sense of an inclusive society. Inevitably, the museum is forced to admit that it simply cannot mimic the differentiated nature of the national community in its exhibitions. At the same time, there are problems with the museum abstracting multi-vocality to represent the deeper and far-reaching complexities of a plural, differentiated community. The presentation of different voices in a museum display may create a sense of textual equivalence that misrepresents the actual relations of power in a given historical moment. For example, displaying nineteenthcentury English, Irish and Chinese experiences of religious practice may say something about the breadth of spiritual devotion in colonial Australia, but little about the differentiated quality of social relations between these groups. While it may be laudable to use these perspectives to represent religious diversity – and support a concomitant argument about a plural social realm – the precise historical conditions that gave rise to these experiences tend to fade from view.
06.5
PLURALISM AND EXHIBITION PRACTICE AT THE NMA NEW MUSEUMS
Untethered from precise historical conditions, such voices lose potency and communicative strength, and begin to appear as banal examples of a contemporary imperative, rather than as personal perspectives on the past. This poses a dilemma for a museum facing community expectations to reflect, perhaps even define, national meaning or self-understanding. In relying on ‘multiple voices’ to represent the varied character of contemporary society, museums have sometimes obscured shared historical meanings or occluded the specificity of past conditions. The discursive tactic of defining the national community through many voices runs the risk of misrepresenting the record of experiences that are broadly felt, or sentiments that are expressed collectively, across the nation. Perhaps museums should heed Stephen Weil’s caution: Museums might also be more modest about the extent to which they have the capability to remedy the ills of the communities in which they are embedded. We live, all of us, in a society of startling inequalities, a society that has badly failed to achieve community, and a society that seems determined to lay waste to the planet that is its sole source of support. Museums neither caused these ills nor – except by calling attention to them – have it within their power alone to do very much to cure them (Weil 1995, xvi).
The attempts of contemporary museums to address plural interests through including multiple voices in exhibitions have therefore brought us to something of an impasse. We can neither detail the representational range needed to truly reflect plural societies, nor escape the tendency for such exhibitions to reduce difference to an abstract signifier of nation. One way to respond to this might be to re-examine the particular environment of the museum exhibition and the subjective experience of visitors within it, and better understand the exhibition as a performative space. In doing this, we can look to continuities in exhibition practice and visitor behaviour between the ‘old’ and ‘new’ museums. The durability of nineteenth-century museum forms and experiences in contemporary museums should be kept in mind as one considers the specific changes wrought by more recent theoretical perspectives (Witcomb 2003, 18–26). The nineteenth-century museum, and the display impulses that emerged from successive public exhibitions of the fruits of industrialism in the course of that century, was strongly informed by a deliberate, educative zeal (Bennett 1995, 59–88). The ‘new museology’ has striven to unpack and reveal this authoritative intent, and replace it with arguments for greater democracy and social inclusion in the museum. Both these perspectives reconfirm a vision of the museum exhibition as a rational mechanism charged with an important social role. Even the recent growth in visitor evaluation, part of the contemporary museum’s new-found interest in audiences, proceeds in similarly instrumental terms.
EXHIBITION ENVIRONMENTS A journey through the galleries of the NMA instructs us in the chaotic sociality of exhibition spaces: school groups move as noisy packs harvesting information, older couples read labels intently, a cleaner pauses to gaze at a display, a father discusses the workings of a car with his son and young families chat with museum hosts over a touch trolley. There is little sense of ordered
PLURALISM AND EXHIBITION PRACTICE AT THE NMA NEW MUSEUMS
06.6
progression in the galleries. Visitors wander and talk, creating their own routes, generating meanings and narratives as they find ways through the exhibition spaces. The fluidity and complexity of visitor behaviour in exhibition galleries reminds us of the continuities between museum exhibitions and other public arenas of display, such as international fairs, department stores and city streets. As Andrea Witcomb argues, the museum emerging in the nineteenth century developed a distinct institutional identity but was also part of a broader field of cultural practice that incorporated these more populist sites of representation and recreation. These institutions were joined in producing a modern urban cosmopolitanism – a sensibility centred on the crowded city street in which wanderers might discover and consume representations of the world in miniature (Witcomb 2003, 18n). This cosmopolitanism was largely grounded in popular culture, in experiences of pleasure and curiosity, rather than in higher culture values of rational and moral improvement. This history of the museum emphasises the agency of ‘visitors’ in creating meanings as they walk through and between displays. From this perspective it may be more appropriate to think of the museum visitor not as a ‘reader’ consuming a text external to themselves, but rather as an embodied ‘performer’ who makes the museum text as he or she moves through an exhibition. We might consider the museum as an inhabited landscape, such as the city or the department store, and the museum visitor as a relative of the flâneur.2 The flâneur is a key figure in theorising modern urbanism. At first, as he is defined in the work of Charles Baudelaire and the later commentary of Walter Benjamin, the flâneur is tied to a specific time and place: nineteenth-century Paris. As Baudelaire described him, the flâneur was a gentleman of leisure, a solitary figure who wanders the city streets, taking up residence in the windows of coffee shops where he can watch the world go by. The flâneur was both a detached observer of the complex world around him and a person looking for contact with and even immersion in the crowd. Baudelaire wrote: The crowd is his domain, just as the air is the bird’s and water that of the fish. His passion and his profession is to merge with the crowd. For the perfect idler, for the passionate observer it becomes an immense source of enjoyment to establish his dwelling in the throng, in the ebb and flow, the bustle, the fleeting and the infinite. To be away at home and yet to feel at home anywhere (Baudelaire 1972, 399; cited in Solnit 2000, 199).
The flâneur seeks out contact with the city crowds in order to realise his own existential self, his identity defined and developed through his collection and interpretation of encounters with strangers and places in the street. Later writers have considered the flâneur as a more abstract figure, an emblem for the experience of living in the city that may encompass people other than the white, upper-middle-class male of the nineteenth century.3 The flâneur emerges as a figure defined by practices of walking through inhabited public spaces, by activities of observing and deciphering the spatial environment, who produces narratives that explicate the world encountered in wandering (Frisby 1994, 82–83). The flâneur, moreover, is defined by a certain attitude towards the world through which he or she moves. As Tester (1994a) argues, flânerie as described by Baudelaire and Benjamin is an idle activity, a considered strolling that delights in a lack of direction and an absence of destina-
06.7
PLURALISM AND EXHIBITION PRACTICE AT THE NMA NEW MUSEUMS
tions. The flâneur gazes around at a mysterious world, his or her curiosity stimulated by the possibility of discovering the unknown. In a sense, the flâneur is a private detective, but a detective who searches for experience to fuel his own sense of self (Frisby 1994, 83). The figure of the flâneur does not map completely to the museum visitor – for one thing, the flâneur is essentially solitary while many visitors encounter the museum as part of a group – but the flâneur nevertheless powerfully suggests how subjecthood is produced as people move through, observe and engage with socialised spaces. The flâneur insists that we understand exhibitions not as texts to be read through analysis, but rather as environments in which meanings are made as visitors subjectively interpret what and who they encounter. The exhibition as a space for wandering has long preoccupied museum professionals interested in understanding visitor behaviour and learning. As George Hein describes, the earliest known observation of visitors in a museum sought to categorise them according to how they moved through the exhibition. Hein cites an appealing French study of visitors to a natural history museum, which classified visitors as: Ants, who moved methodically from object to object; Butterflies, who moved back and forth among the exhibits, alighting on some displays; Grasshoppers, who chose specific objects and ‘hopped’ from one to another; and Fish, who glided in and out of the exhibition with few stops (Hein 1998, 105).
The highly individual nature of exhibition visitation has often been perceived as a problem, particularly by educators embracing behaviourist models of learning. If everybody is wandering about on their own path, how can the museum ensure visitors ‘receive’ the messages it is trying to communicate? Anxiety about visitors’ propensity for wandering has often been expressed through debates over the kinds of historical narratives realised in museums. Exhibitions that don’t organise visitors to encounter displays in a certain order, that lack a linear narrative, are seen to confuse rather than enlighten and educate. This criticism was directly expressed by the Carroll Review, which described the museum’s displays as ‘fragmentary’ and argued that the distribution of themes across multiple galleries would mean that “all but the most conscientious visitor” would fail to connect them in a coherent narrative (Commonwealth of Australia 2003, 13). For the panel, visitors’ failure to share a single experience of the exhibits meant that the museum was failing in its educative role.4 If we think of museum visitors as related to the flâneur, however, the different paths they take through the museum become less a problem and more a possibility. The flâneur directs attention to how all museum visitors experience exhibitions as embodied encounters with ideas. Seeking greater awareness and understanding of personal subjectivity through encounters with others, the flâneur wanders the city. The flâneur wants to both recognise his or her own differences from and connections with others, seeking out encounters that address his or her own subjectivity. In the same way, we can think of museum visitors moving through exhibitions, comparing and contrasting their own experience to that evoked or represented by what they see. Visitors
PLURALISM AND EXHIBITION PRACTICE AT THE NMA NEW MUSEUMS
06.8
make meaning as their own subjectivity is thrown into relief by their engagement with the exhibition. Hence, enabling visitors to determine the circumstances of their exhibition encounter – rather than simply representing multiple voices – opens up a suite of possible meanings that are literally ‘brought to life’ by them. This encourages us to think of museum exhibitions as performative environments in which meaning or understanding is created through engagements between visitors, objects displayed and spatial environments. What is important in understanding how meaning is created in exhibitions is not so much an analysis of the ‘type’ of visitors, but rather the subjectivity they bring to the museum. Visitors are not external to the exhibition text in this conception of museological practice, but rather an integral part of it. This concept of meaning making in the museum resonates with a number of areas of contemporary scholarship. Constructivist learning theory, as Eilean Hooper-Greenhill describes, emphasises that knowledge is produced in the museum through visitors’ active interpretations of their exhibition experiences. Meaning is constructed through relationships between the active interpreters, the objects they encounter, and their experience of them (Hooper-Greenhill 1999, 4). Hooper-Greenhill argues that the nature of these relationships depends on, first, the prior knowledge visitors bring to the museum that helps them make sense of an object, and, second, the cultural competencies or interpretive strategies they have at their disposal. Researchers within this tradition have begun to describe museum visitors in terms of ‘interpretive communities’ whose members share ‘common frameworks of intelligibility, interpretive repertoires, knowledge and intellectual skills’ (Hooper-Greenhill 2000, 12). As Hooper-Greenhill states, the significance of the concept of interpretive communities comes from the way in which it acknowledges that ‘although each individual actively makes sense of their own experience, the interpretive strategies and repertoires they use emerge through prior social and cultural events’ (122). Constructivist learning frameworks remind us that visitors are not atomistic individuals, but rather people who engage the museum through (partially) shared cultural understandings. The figure of the flâneur importantly reminds us that these shared understandings are not simply practices of reason. Constructivist theories tend to consider the museum visitor as a ‘learner’ – a seeker of rational enlightenment – and to characterise the museum visit as primarily a cognitive and intellectual encounter. In contrast, the flâneur – with his or her walking, wandering and interest in idleness and pleasure – powerfully invites us to understand museum visiting as an embodied, subjective experience. Attending to the embodied quality of museum visiting opens up analyses of meaning making in exhibitions to respond to the roles of ‘feeling’ – in the senses of both emotional engagement and haptic and kinesthetic responses to the environment. Emotions constitute the means through which people evaluate sensory perceptions, identifying their relevance and shaping reactions appropriately (see Csordas 1994; Lyon and Barbalet 1994). They consequently play a crucial part in visitors’ experiences within exhibitions. As Kit Messham-Muir (2006) has recently pointed out, emotional response is closely tied to the spatial dynamics of exhibition spaces. Our perceptions of objects – for example, whether we observe them from above, or feel dwarfed by them, or have to peer inside a tiny, hidden case to see them – powerfully shape our understandings of those objects and consequently the meanings we make within exhibitions.
06.9
PLURALISM AND EXHIBITION PRACTICE AT THE NMA NEW MUSEUMS
In museological scholarship, emotional, sensory and kinesthetic reactions have traditionally been understood as phenomena beyond analysis. They are seen to be highly individual, essentially different from the shared cultural frameworks visitors bring to exhibitions.5 Museum professionals have consequently tended to argue for their importance only in instrumental terms, seeing them as primarily provocations or catalysts for critical inquiry. As Messham-Muir argues, following art theorist Jill Bennett (2005), ‘When museums present their objects in ways that allow them to communicate not only cognitively, but affectively – that allow objects to be ‘felt’ as well as ‘read’ – they draw visitors to the conceptual and analytical via the sensory and experienced’ (Messham-Muir 2006, 5). The figure of the flâneur insists, however, that we should see ‘feeling’ not simply as a means to an end, a mechanism to persuade visitors to rational learning, but as an end in itself. The flâneur suggests that ‘feeling’ – embodied engagement with the world – is itself a form of knowledge integral to the formation of the subject. For the flâneur gains knowledge and produces him or herself through the practice of flânerie – the acts of walking, of encountering others in the crowd, of finding a way through the city streets, of sitting on park benches and sheltering under trees, of, in short, gaining an embodied understanding of the material realities of others’ lives – as well as through the practice of reflecting on his or her walking, observing and collecting. The complexity of flânerie reminds us that analytical inquiry and intellectual understanding are only two of many activities in which visitors may be engaging in exhibitions. Museum visitors, like the flâneur, may equally be searching for titillation, taking pleasure in seeing new people and in being seen by new people, seeking solitude and anonymity, enjoying the company of friends, avoiding work or pursuing the satisfaction of demonstrating known information. Museum visitors arguably engage exhibition displays through multiple contexts, and pleasure may be as important as intellectual profit to understanding how visitors produce meaning in museums. The figure of the flâneur reminds us that any account of the shared understandings visitors bring to the museum must be joined by a nuanced understanding of the processes through which individuals produce and reproduce their own subjectivities in encounters with the world. Conceptualising museum exhibitions as performative environments prioritises the active meaning-making role of the visitor. This suggests that the question we should be asking, in regard to addressing pluralism, is how visitors are enabled to ‘perform’ difference through their encounter with objects and ideas in the museum, rather than relying exclusively on multiple voices in an exhibition. How can we build an exhibition that heightens visitors’ sense of the specificity and commonalities of their own experience and that of others? Put another way, how can we encourage visitors to be aware of their own subjectivity, and build an understanding of pluralism through comparing their experience with that of others?
A NEW GALLERY AT THE NATIONAL MUSEUM OF AUSTRALIA Recent scholarship that examines histories of place and environment emphasises the ‘located’ character of Australian experience. The work of Tom Griffiths, Peter Read, Tim Bonyhady, Libby Robin and Jay Arthur, among others, encourages the NMA to describe a national reach through located histories, rather than defining or representing a national type or identity. In a 2003 paper in the Griffith Review, Mark McKenna discussed inclusion of a reference to the nation’s territory, or ‘land’, in any new preamble to the Australian Constitution. He wrote
PLURALISM AND EXHIBITION PRACTICE AT THE NMA NEW MUSEUMS
06.10
that ‘By emphasizing the centrality of the land to any new constitutional preamble, perhaps nonAboriginal Australians are also wishing to end the sense of alienation and exile that is embedded within their colonial experience. Home is no longer elsewhere. The mother country is here’ (McKenna 2003, 192). McKenna suggests a way in which cultural landscapes inform our selfunderstanding as a community. A focus on place also helps reveal the layered historical meanings of landscapes and acknowledges the museum’s obligation to include Indigenous and non-Indigenous histories in representing the past. Integrating a focus on place with an ethnographic approach to historical events helps detail the circumstances of change and continuity in the historical record. Moreover, it reinserts place as an active presence, or ‘character’, in the past and acknowledges the temporal and geographical specificity of encounters between peoples, places and ideas. Ethnographic history encourages close examination of particular experiences in their time and place.6 This approach builds a complex relationship between the ‘ethnography of the historical moment’ set against the continuity of cultural landscapes. It can promote care and precision in representing the past, without losing a sense of historical continuities between experiences in different times and places. It also informs the practice of history in the contemporary museum, which depends on material culture to evoke people’s lives in the past. Ethnographic history’s emphasis on event and context resonates with the common curatorial practice of investigating an object’s specific meaning within a broader historical frame. The suggestion then is for the new gallery at the NMA to describe a continental reach to the national story, exploring continuities in the historical record with a precision and care for particular experiences in the past. Such an approach allows for connections to be drawn between common experiences in different places, including those geographically distant from each other. We imagine that visitors will bring their own perspective to the precisely located histories in the gallery. They will be able to reflect on the differences between their own experiences and those represented in the exhibition. Rather than responding to an abstract concept of the national community, they may explore differentiated experience of common themes and draw their conclusions about what constitutes a national biography. This approach offers alternative interpretive opportunities compared with that of describing the national community as the sum of multiple voices. In the latter approach, people’s stories can become dislocated from historical circumstances and abstracted to stand as emblems of nation. Further, such an approach describes an equivalence of difference in the nation’s life, which misrepresents actual social conditions. In contrast, we argue for connecting object and place to provoke visitors’ awareness of their own subjectivity in the physical and conceptual space of the exhibition, allowing pluralism to be ‘performed’ rather than represented.
CONCLUSION The Carroll Review has stimulated thinking about how the museum might represent Australian history in its galleries. In response to both the review and visitor feedback, which suggests difficulties with a complex layering of voices in exhibitions, the museum is now looking at how exhibition practice might move beyond simple oppositions between pluralist and consensual views of nation. We have found that the new museology offers limited help in this regard, and argue here that the discourse has reached something of a cul-de-sac. The new museology emphasises
06.11
PLURALISM AND EXHIBITION PRACTICE AT THE NMA NEW MUSEUMS
breadth in representational practice – the inclusion of diverse peoples, perspectives and experiences – yet this asserts an ideal that is impossible for any museum to realise. Multi-vocal exhibitions also run the risk of reducing difference to an abstract signifier of a plural society or nation, rather than representing the actual relations of power in a given historical moment. We want to look beyond this instrumentalism, with its roots deep in the early history of the museum, and consider instead the performative, subjective aspects of visitors making their own histories in space. In keeping with that, we have turned to an archetype of subjective experience, the flâneur, variously located in the nineteenth-century city and the public exhibition. Imagining the flâneur helps reposition the subject as an active, creative and self-conscious agent in the interpretive space of the museum. The self-consciousness of the flâneur, of the idling gaze that seeks to be seen as much as see, recalls the performance of the museum visit and a sense of the exhibition as a socialised space. While it is not a simple analogy of the museum visitor, the flâneur suggests the highly subjective and volatile nature of visitors in the spaces of the museum, and refocuses our efforts in trying to redetermine a more open, truly democratic – rather than demotic – exhibition practice. It also resists glib restatements of the museum’s mission as the socialising of idealised citizen-subjects. We have also briefly outlined proposals for a new gallery at the NMA that seek to include histories that are more precisely located in place and time, rather than attempting to display the entire field of pluralist views. This is not to deny the virtues of properly articulating the reality that Australian nationhood is characterised by difference, but rather to describe opportunities for visitors to bring their own subjectivities to the performance of pluralism in the exhibition. To that end, this paper suggests a series of questions for further research into understanding what might be called performative pluralism in historical exhibitions. First, we consider more work is needed to develop a phenomenology of visitor experience in exhibitions, drawing on ethnographic analyses of audiences. Second, we think that more detailed understanding of the life histories of objects, and the nature of objecthood, driven by the renaissance in material culture studies in recent years, will help develop a sense of the breadth of readings possible in the exhibition (Appadurai 1986). Third, investigation of the architectures of display, focusing on the relationships between physical elements that comprise the exhibition furniture and related installations will deepen our sense of the interpretive differences between the museum exhibition and other media of historical knowledges (MacLeod 2005). Inasmuch as we have reached an impasse in understanding the relationship between the museum exhibition and cultural function, these studies seek to refocus this question in terms that are sensitive to the volatility of visitors’ agency in exhibitions. Taken altogether, they present the possibility that new exhibition practices may re-inform theorisations of the contemporary museum and its social role, and deepen an understanding of the museum and its relationship to public space.
PLURALISM AND EXHIBITION PRACTICE AT THE NMA NEW MUSEUMS
06.12
ENDNOTES 1
The views expressed by the authors in this paper are their own and not necessarily those of the National Museum of Australia.
2
Similarities between the museum visitor and the flâneur are identified by Witcomb (2003, 20–21) and Storrie (2006, 18n).
3
See Tester (1994b) for a collection of essays exploring different constructions of the flâneur.
4
See Witcomb (2003, 144n) for a discussion of a similar debate over historical narrative in the exhibitions of the Australian National Maritime Museum.
5
This understanding is sharply contested by much recent scholarship in the anthropology, history and sociology of embodiment, emotion and the senses. This work emphasises the social construction of the body, subjectivity, emotional systems and sensoria, and seeks to describe how these vary across different cultures and historical periods. See Csordas (1990), Csordas (1994), Featherstone et al. (1991) and Howes (2003).
6
For examples of this approach see Dening (1992), Isaac (1982) and Clendinnen (2003).
REFERENCES Appadurai, A. 1986. The social life of things. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Archibald, R. 2002. Mastering civic engagement: A challenge to museums. Washington: American Association of Museums. Baudelaire, C. 1972. ‘The painter of modern life’ [1863]. In Selected writings on art and artists. Cambridge: University of Cambridge Press. Bennett, J. 2005. Empathic vision: Affect, trauma and contemporary art. Stanford, California: Stanford University Press. Bennett, T. 1995. The birth of the museum. London: Routledge. Casey, D. 2001. ‘The National Museum of Australia: Exploring the past, illuminating the present and imagining the future’. In National museums: Negotiating histories, edited by McIntyre, D.; Wehner, K. Canberra: National Museum of Australia. Clendinnen, I. 2003. Dancing with strangers. Melbourne: Text Publishing. Committee of Inquiry on Museums and National Collections. 1975. Museums in Australia 1975: Report of the Committee of Inquiry on Museums and National Collections including the report of the Planning Committee on the Gallery of Aboriginal Australia. Canberra: AGPS. Commonwealth of Australia. 2003. Review of the National Museum of Australia: Its exhibitions and public programs. Canberra: Department of Communications, Information Technology and the Arts. Csordas, T. 1990. ‘Embodiment as a paradigm for anthropology’. Ethos 18: 5–47. Csordas, T. 1994. ‘Introduction: The body as representation and being-in-the-world’. In Embodiment and experience: The existential ground of culture and self, edited by Csordas, T. J. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Dening, G. 1992. Mr Bligh’s bad language: Passion, power and theatre on the Bounty. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Department of Culture, Media and Sport, Government of the United Kingdom. 2001. National strategy for neighbourhood renewal, PAT 10: Arts and sport. London: UK Government. Accessed 20 June 2006. Available from: http://www.neighbourhood.gov.uk/publications.asp?did=322. Featherstone, M.; Hepworth, M; Turner, B. S., editors. 1991. The body: Social process and cultural theory. London: Sage Publications. Frisby, D. 1994. ‘The flâneur in social theory’. In The flâneur, edited by Tester, F. London and New York: Routledge.
06.13
PLURALISM AND EXHIBITION PRACTICE AT THE NMA NEW MUSEUMS
Gaither, E. B. 2004. ‘“Hey! That’s mine”: Thoughts on pluralism and American museums’. In Reinventing the museum: Historical and contemporary perspectives on the paradigm shift, edited by Anderson, G. Walnut Creek California: AltaMira Press. Hein, G. 1998. Learning in the museum. London and New York: Routledge. Hooper-Greenhill, E. 1989. ‘The museum in the disciplinary society’. In Museum studies in material culture, edited by Pearce, J. Leicester: Leicester University Press. Hooper-Greenhill, E. 1992. Museums and the shaping of knowledge. London: Routledge. Hooper-Greenhill, E. 1999. ‘Museums and interpretive communities’. Paper presented at Musing on Learning seminar. 20 April; Australian Museum, Sydney. Accessed 20 June 2006. Available from: http://www.amonline.net.au/amarc/pdf/research/paper2.pdf. Hooper-Greenhill, E. 2000. Museums and the interpretation of visual culture. London and New York: Routledge. Howes, D. 2003. Sensual relations: Engaging the senses in culture and social theory. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press. Isaac, R. 1982. The transformation of Virginia, 1740–1790. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press. Karp, I.; Kreamer, C. M.; Lavine, S. 1992. Museums and communities: The politics of public culture. Washington DC: Smithsonian Institution Press. Lyon, M. L.; Barbalet, J. M. 1994. ‘Society’s body: Emotion and the “somatization” of social theory’. In Embodiment and experience: The existential ground of culture and self, edited by Csordas, T. J. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Macintyre, S.; Clark, A. 2003. The history wars. Melbourne: Melbourne University Press. MacLeod, S., editor. 2005. Reshaping museum space: Architecture, design, exhibitions. Melbourne: Routledge. McKenna, M. 2003. ‘Poetics of place’. Griffith Review 1 (2): 187–194. Messham-Muir, K. 2006. ‘Body hits: The dynamics of kinespherics and interpretation in current museum displays’. Paper presented at Exploring Dynamics: Cities, Cultural Spaces, Communities conference. May; Brisbane. Accessed 19 June 2006. Available from: http://www.museumsaustralia.org.au/dbdoc/Conf%2006%20Messham-Muir%20Concurrent.pdf. Newman, A.; McLean, F. 2002. ‘Architectures of inclusion: Museums, galleries and inclusive communities’. In Museums, society, inequality, edited by R. Sandell. London: Routledge. Robin, L. 2003. ‘Collections and the nation: Science, history and the National Museum of Australia’. Historical Records of Australian Science 14 (3): 251–289. Sandell, R., editor. 2002. Museums, society, inequality. London: Routledge. Scott, C. 2003. Submission to the Review Secretariat, Department of Communication, Information, Technology and Arts. 3 March. Accessed 20 June 2006. Available from: http://www.nma.gov.au/libraries/attachments/review/review_submissions/museums_australia/files/11 8/Museums_Australia.pdf. Solnit, R. 2000. Wanderlust: A history of walking. New York: Penguin Books. Storrie, C. 2006. The delirious museum: A journey from the Louvre to Las Vegas. London: I.B. Tauris & Co Ltd. Tester, F. 1994a. Introduction to The flâneur. London and New York: Routledge. Tester, F., editor. 1994b. The flâneur. London and New York: Routledge. Vergo, P. 1989. Introduction to The new museology, edited by Vergo, P. London: Reaktion. Weil, S. 1995. A cabinet of curiosities: Inquiries into museums and their prospects, Washington: Smithsonian Press. Witcomb, A. 2003. Re-imagining the museum: Beyond the mausoleum. London: Routledge.
Cite this chapter as: Trinca, Mathew; Wehner, Kirsten. 2006. ‘Pluralism and exhibition practice at the National Museum of Australia’. South Pacific museums, edited by Healy, Chris; Witcomb, Andrea. Monash University ePress: Melbourne. pp. 6.1–6.14. DOI: 10.2104/spm06006.
PLURALISM AND EXHIBITION PRACTICE AT THE NMA NEW MUSEUMS
06.14
NEW SYMPOSIUM MUSEUMS
MELBOURNE MUSEUM Ian McShane, Swinburne University of Technology Ian McShane has a background as a curator and heritage consultant and has published in the areas of history, museology and public policy. He is currently completing a doctoral thesis on aspects of the history and policy of civic infrastructure.
The opening of the Melbourne Museum in 2000 marked the end of a period in which the thematics, locations and corporate arrangements of Victoria’s nineteenth-century state museums were thoroughly overhauled. While the provocative siting and expressive architecture of the Melbourne Museum are emblematic of the political style of state premier Jeffrey Kennett, who led a Liberal (conservative) government from 1992 to 1999, the merging of colonial museums of natural sciences and technology to form the Museum of Victoria in 1983 provides a necessary point of reference for the Melbourne Museum project. The Museum of Victoria was a response to intellectual challenges posed by social history, postcolonialism and environmentalism, as well as practical problems associated with poor accommodation and visitor experience at the library–museum complex in Swanston Street in Melbourne’s CBD. A thematic structure of science and technology, natural sciences, indigenous studies and social history undergirded the new entity and the first social history curatorial appointments made. The development of The Story of Victoria, an exhibition that wove together the state’s natural and human history, signalled new, more inclusive museum narratives. Planned building development on a site adjacent to the existing Swanston Street complex was thwarted by heritage considerations and dwindling political support. Heritage management dilemmas, though, offered an alternative solution. Abandoning plans for a single building, director Robert Edwards (1984–1990) proposed a Smithsonian-style campus model. The first component, Scienceworks, opened in 1992 on the site of a disused pumping station on the Yarra River in Melbourne’s industrial western suburbs. In 1998 a second campus, the Immigration and Hellenic Antiquities Museum (the latter, a personal interest of Premier Kennett) opened in a former customs building on the southern fringe of the city. New possibilities for museums to combine education, entertainment and tourism engaged the interest of planning and finance bureaucracies during the 1980s, and the state government included a museum in its plans for a cultural, residential and business precinct on the south bank of the Yarra River (Dovey 2005). However, political fallout from the economic recession in the late 1980s and burgeoning public debt following the crash of a state government bank brought defeat of the state Labor government. While incoming Premier Kennett was eager to politically distance his government from its predecessor, he built on its strategy of major project development through public–private partnerships. He abandoned the skeletal framework of the Southbank museum to a convention centre and, financed by gaming tax revenue from the new Crown Casino, selected a new site in a public reserve in the suburb of Carlton, on the northern fringe of the CBD. The choice of the site was rich with symbolism. It was adjacent to the Royal Exhibition Building (REB), built for the Melbourne International Exhibition of 1880–81, an artefact of the gold-rush prosperity and brittle confidence of the city described by contemporaries as Marvellous Melbourne.
07.1
SOUTH PACIFIC MUSEUMS MONASH UNIVERSITY EPRESS
Melbourne architects Denton Corker Marshall (DCM)’s winning entry in the 1994 museum design competition paired Melbourne’s nineteenth-century exhibition infrastructure with a dramatic twenty-first century variant. DCM’s building runs along the same east-west axis as REB, creating an expansive and somewhat desolate plaza between. The internal configuration of Melbourne Museum gestures towards REB’s central circulatory spine (as well, perhaps, as surveyor Robert Hoddle’s grid plan for Melbourne), but there the similarity ends. The rectilinear form of the DCM design is punctuated by an angular ‘blade’ soaring above the Forest Gallery, an ecological exhibition in the building centre that recalls earlier plans for Southbank. A dedicated children’s museum on the building’s western side imitates a Rubik’s cube, its angular, tumbling appearance a motif for other structural elements expressed out of the building’s core. Relocation of the site from Southbank to Exhibition Gardens contributed to a persistent Melbourne narrative of the alienation of public open space. Residents of the surrounding suburb of Carlton maintained a vigorous campaign against both the site and the DCM design, achieving partial success with a reduction of the length of the blade cantilevering over the Forest Gallery. However, the merits of arguments against juxtaposing the museum building with REB were undercut by a history of unsympathetic additions to the latter and the use of its curtilage for car parking. Ironically, in 2004 REB and its gardens became the first non-Indigenous cultural site in Australia to be inscribed on UNESCO’s World Heritage List. The initial public encounter with Melbourne Museum’s interior is a view through a glass wall of staff offices on upper levels of the building, a common feature of late-twentieth-century museums that fuses democratic and disciplinary instincts. The interior design, with circulation corridors running past the galleries along the building’s length, gives exemplary attention to visitor orientation but reinforces thematic divisions that evoke earlier institutional and intellectual histories: the natural sciences and human history sections are separated by the forest, where the two co-mingle. Carolyn Rasmussen’s outline of the museum’s program development suggests that the strong interpretive and authorial intent of curatorial staff was pulled back by Museum Board of Victoria chairman Professor David Pennington’s injunction to focus on ‘core knowledge’, at least in the natural sciences galleries (Rasmussen 2001, 390). However, neither the Science and Life and Mind and Body galleries sermonise; their emphasis falls towards critical inquiry and constructivist learning theory in object-rich environments. A reflexive thread runs through the natural science galleries (admittedly, an imperfect title given the range of the displays), with early collections placed in their intellectual and institutional contexts. Indeed, museum stories emerge as some of the most engaging: the anti-evolutionary convictions that shaped foundation director Frederick McCoy’s display of gorillas, and curator William Blandowski’s unflattering comparison of new fish species to museum board members are but two. The Mind and Body gallery benefits from the concentration of publicly funded research in Melbourne, particularly in the biomedical field. Equipment from Commonwealth Serum Laboratories highlights its pioneering research into vaccines and antivenoms; a more adventurous interpretation might extend the theme to discussion of the consequences for our intellectual ‘commons’ of widespread commercialisation and privatisation. Side-by-side displays of ‘virtual reality’ visual technology and the 1949 CSIRAC computer – the world’s fourth resident memory computer – suggest the hazards of museums attempting to match the world of commercial entertainment rather than concentrating on their strengths in authenticity. The aesthetic and educational richness provided by the room-sized CSIRAC is unmatched by the passive cinematic
MELBOURNE MUSEUM NEW MUSEUMS
07.2
experience offered by the ‘virtual room’. A soaring space on the northern wall of these galleries accommodates megafauna collections and a richly detailed exhibition on evolution. The eastern side of the building houses the indigenous and social history galleries: Bunjilaka (discussed elsewhere in this volume), Te Vainui o Pasifika and Australia Gallery. Te Pasifika displays water craft from Polynesia, Melanesia and Micronesia, its narrative of indigenous exploration and trade given added context by criticism of the National Museum of Australia’s lack of attention to early British seafaring and mercantilism (Commonwealth of Australia 2003). Australia Gallery’s title points to a wider problem for the major Australian museums in finding an appropriate narrative structure and range for their social history programs. Australia Gallery is probably the least resolved of the Melbourne Museum galleries, in both content and design terms. Each vignette of the entry display Windows onto Victoria: Eight Moments in Victoria’s History is interesting, but the display is unconvincing as an ensemble approach to the state’s history. Melbourne: Stories from a City is richer in contextual detail, and, together with displays on Melbourne industry, working life and sport (confined to football and cricket), underscores the point that Australia Gallery is largely focused on Melbourne’s urban history. Intangible heritage is given welcome space through the treatment of schoolyard chants; suburban experience is less satisfactorily approached through a set from the Melbourne-based soap opera Neighbours. Both installations are heavily graffitied by visitors fulfilling their brief to contribute to the schoolyard exhibit. Australia Gallery also houses the Melbourne shrine to the famous New Zealand-born racehorse Phar Lap – its relics are spread across three Australasian museums. The interpretation of ‘Big Red’s’ popularity is aided by discussion of the development of broadcast media and the uplift of sporting success during the inter-war depression. Finally, a small community collections area in this gallery continues the trend of Australian museums towards provision of spaces that invert the conventional relationship between museum staff and audience, with wall panels of previous exhibitions closing off questions about the even-handed use of this gallery. Having excised part of Carlton Gardens for the museum building, the Forest Gallery returns a small portion as a simulacra of Victoria’s tall mountain forests. The interpretive intent of Forest Gallery (‘People see the forest in different ways and this influences how they interact with it’) is initially overwhelmed by sensory contrasts with the other galleries. However, this is a subtle space that rewards those who linger. The first component of Melbourne Museum to open (1998) was an Imax large-screen cinema, co-developed with a private cinema company. With its combination of civic and commercial elements (the latter also found in car parking, shop and café concessions, sponsored galleries, and touring exhibition hall), Melbourne Museum conforms to Mark Schuster’s use of the term hybridisation to model the spectrum of ways that cultural institutions have responded to pressures exerted by new public management outlooks and declining state support (Schuster 1998). The Melbourne Museum campus successfully integrates visitor and museum services within an accessible form. As architectural critic Paul Walker (2001) observed, the building has reasserted a distinctive role for public architecture in Melbourne. However, governments are generally more supportive of capital works projects than recurrent costs incurred thereafter. Securing the flow of public funds to support research activities has proved troublesome in Museum Victoria’s past. In the 1980s the museum reinterpreted its agricultural history collections to focus on ecological sustainability. This project serves as a metaphor for the sustainability challenge that lies ahead for Melbourne Museum.
07.3
MELBOURNE MUSEUM NEW MUSEUMS
REFERENCES Commonwealth of Australia. 2003. Review of the National Museum of Australia: Its exhibitions and public programs. Canberra: Commonwealth of Australia. Dovey, Kim. 2005. Fluid city: Transforming Melbourne’s urban waterfront. Sydney: University of New South Wales Press. Rasmussen, Carolyn. 2001. A museum for the people: A history of Museum Victoria and its predecessors 1854–2000. North Carlton, Melbourne: Scribe Publications. Schuster, J. Mark. 1998. ‘Beyond privatization: The hybridization of museums and the built heritage’. In Privatization and culture: Experiences in the arts, heritage and cultural industries in Europe, edited by Boorsma, Peter B; van Hemel, Annemoon; van der Wielen, Niki. Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic Publishers. Walker, Paul. 2001. ‘Melbourne Museum: Denton Corker Marshall skilfully negotiate the complexities of the contemporary museum’. Architecture Australia January/February. Available from: http://www.archmedia.com.au/aa/aaissue.php?issueid=200101&article=9&typeon=2.
Cite this chapter as: McShane, Ian. 2006. ‘Melbourne Museum’. South Pacific museums, edited by Healy, Chris; Witcomb, Andrea. Monash University ePress: Melbourne. pp. 7.1–7.4. DOI: 10.2104/spm06007.
MELBOURNE MUSEUM NEW MUSEUMS
07.4
NEW SYMPOSIUM MUSEUMS
CIVIC LABORATORIES MUSEUMS, CULTURAL OBJECTHOOD AND THE GOVERNANCE OF THE SOCIAL Tony Bennett, Open University Tony Bennett is Professor of Sociology and a director of the ESRC Centre for Research and Socio-cultural Change at the Open University and a Professorial Fellow at the University of Melbourne. His books include The birth of the museum (1995), Culture: A reformer’s science (1998) and Pasts beyond memory (2004). Correspondence to Tony Bennett:
[email protected]
This essay examines the extent to which the perspectives of science studies and actor-network theory can be combined with those of post-Foucauldian governmentality theory to understand the processes through which cultural institutions fabricate distinctive entities and bring these to bear on the governance of the social. The argument is developed by considering the respects in which the procedures of museums and the distinctive forms of cultural objecthood these give rise to can be illuminated by comparing them to laboratories. This prepares the way for an examination of the ways in which such forms of objecthood have been mobilised in programs of social and civic governance both within museums and outside them, paying due attention to the differences between their functioning in these regards in the context of liberal forms of government and more directive forms of role. These general arguments are then illustrated with reference to contemporary debates focused on the refashioning of museums as instruments of cultural diversity. The paper concludes by reviewing the respects in which the perspectives it develops suggest the need to question the analytical effects of the extended concept of culture that has underlain the development of cultural studies and contemporary sociological understandings of culture. My primary purpose in this essay is to explore the extent to which methods developed in science studies for the study of laboratory practices can usefully be applied to the processes through which, in museums, new and distinctive forms of cultural objecthood are produced and mobilised in the context of programs of civic management, which aim to order and regulate social relations in particular ways.1 I pay particular attention in this regard to current concerns to refashion museums so that they might function as instruments for the promotion of cultural diversity. In addressing these concerns, however, I also explore a more general set of questions concerning the relations between specific forms of cultural expertise and processes of social management, and the historical configuration of the relations between culture and the social in those societies we call modern. There is, of course, nothing new in the suggestion that museums are usefully viewed as machineries that are implicated in the shaping of civic capacities. To the contrary, in the late-nineteenth-century debates leading to the establishment of the Museums Association in 1889, museums were commonly referred to as ‘civic engines’ to be enlisted in the task of managing a newly enfranchised mass male citizenry (Lewis 1989). The value of viewing them specifically as ‘civic laboratories’, then, depends on the light that such an analogy is able to shed on the modus operandi of museums as technologies which, by connecting specific forms of expertise to programs of social management, operate in registers that are simultaneously epistemological and civic. Nor is the suggestion that there is a kinship – a family resemblance, say – between museums and laboratories a new one. It informs two recent assessments of the distinctive qualities of the
08.1
SOUTH PACIFIC MUSEUMS MONASH UNIVERSITY EPRESS
modern art museum. In the first of these, Donald Preziosi characterises the nineteenth-century art museum as ‘a laboratory for the education and refinement of bourgeois sentiment’ (Preziosi 1996, 168) in view of its role in providing both a setting and an occasion for a new set of practices of inwardness, which, in turn, were connected to the fashioning of new forms of civic virtue. In the second, Philip Fisher argues that art museums furnish a context in which what he calls portable objects – easel paintings is the case he mentions – are ‘open to resocialisation and resettlement within this or that cluster of what are now taken to be similar things’ (Fisher 1996, 18). It is, however, the laboratory that serves Fisher as the epistemological model for this form of portability, in view of its ability to replicate experimental arrangements of objects from one laboratory setting to another and so make possible portable, and hence generalisable, results. That these essays should have been written by art historians is not entirely accidental. For there is now a fairly developed literature in which a number of art institutions have been likened to laboratories. Although concluding that it does not fit the laboratory case as well as she had thought it might, Svetlana Alpers none the less finds that laboratory practice provides a useful means of probing the respects in which, like the laboratory, the artist’s studio provides a means of withdrawing from the world for the purpose of better attending to it (Alpers 1998). Bruno Latour’s remarks point in the same direction when he compares attempts – including his own – to free science studies from its epistemological past to the work of those who have struggled to free art history from aesthetics. Science studies, he argues, has learned a good deal from the new material histories of the visual arts that have formed a part of this severing of the aesthetic connection, especially for the light they have thrown on the multiplicity of heterogeneous elements (from the quality of the varnish and the organisation of art markets, through the history of criticism, to the organisation of the studio and the operations of art museums) that have to be brought together to make the work of art. It has also, he suggests, a good deal more to learn from the respects in which these new material histories of art have helped to displace dualistic constructions of the relations between ‘the representing Mind and the represented World’ (Latour 1998, 422) by demonstrating the extent to which each of the poles of such dualities is the effect of the material instruments and practices through which their relations are mediated. While acknowledging the force that the art museum – laboratory connection has thus accumulated, I shall argue for a broader approach. This will involve, first, drawing on the perspectives of science studies and actor-network theory to look at the processes through which different types of museum are able to fabricate new entities as a result of the distinctive procedures (of abstraction, purification, transcription and mediation) through which they work on and with the gatherings of heterogeneous objects that they assemble (Latour and Woolgar 1986). It will also involve considering how the ordering of the relations between objects, and, to bring the visitor into the picture, between objects and persons, that such procedures give rise to mediate the relations between particular forms of expertise and citizens in the context of programs of social and civic management. I shall, in pursuing these issues, be particularly concerned to distinguish the role that museums play in these regards in liberal forms of government from those associated with their role in more directive forms of rule. There are, it will be clear, some tensions in these formulations which – in aiming to incorporate the methods of science studies within a post-Foucauldian concern with the role played by specific forms of cultural expertise in the governance of the social – have none the less to engage with the different, albeit related, ways in which these traditions theorise and engage with both culture
CIVIC LABORATORIES NEW MUSEUMS
08.2
and the social, and the relations between them. I shall, therefore, return to these questions in concluding. I want first, though, to probe more closely how far and in what respects museums are usefully likened to laboratories.
MUSEUMS AS LABORATORIES The work of Karin Knorr-Cetina is the best route into the issues I want to explore here. This is partly because she has always been alert to the similarities between the ways in which laboratories arrange the relations between objects and persons and similar arrangements in other scientific settings (the psychoanalytic situation) and cultural contexts (cathedrals) (Knorr-Cetina 1992). It is, however, what she says about laboratories as such – with the qualification that it is the experimental laboratory she has in mind – that I want to focus on here. The essence of laboratory practice, she argues, consists in the varied displacements to which it subjects ‘natural objects’.2 Rather than relating to these as things that have to be taken as they are or left to themselves, there are three aspects of ‘natural objects’ that laboratory science does not accommodate. First, Knorr-Cetina argues, laboratory science ‘does not need to put up with the object as it is’ but can work with a variety of substitutes – the traces or inscriptions of objects on recording machinery, for example, or , and Pasteur’s production of microbes is a case in point (see Latour 1988), their purified versions. Second, since they do ‘not need to accommodate the natural object where it is, anchored in a natural environment; laboratory sciences bring objects home and manipulate them on their own terms in the laboratory’. And third, ‘laboratory science does not need to accommodate an event when it happens; it does not need to put up with natural cycles of occurrence but can try to make them happen frequently enough for continuous study’ (Knorr-Cetina 1992, 117). The conclusion she draws from this capacity of laboratories to reconfigure objects and their interrelations is as follows: Laboratories recast objects of investigation by inserting them into new temporal and territorial regimes. They play upon these objects’ natural rhythms and developmental possibilities, bring them together in new numbers, renegotiate their sizes, and redefine their internal makeup… In short, they create new configurations of objects that they match with an appropriately altered social order (Knorr-Cetina 1999, 27).
In referring to ‘an appropriately altered social order’, Knorr-Cetina is thinking about the ways in which reconfigurations of the relations between objects, and between objects and persons, that are enacted within laboratories come to be connected to, and play a role in, the reconfiguration of social relations. The example she gives concerns the effects of laboratories connected to the medical sciences and their relation to the clinic in undermining the earlier system of bedside medicine in which the authority of the physician, resting mainly on the notoriously unreliable interpretation of symptoms, was easily challenged and contested by both patients and their families. The substitution of a new set of relations between doctor and patient, in which the patient was de-individualised as diagnosis came to depend on the laboratory analysis of samples, altered the balance of power between them, as the patient was obliged to submit to the authority of the new social collective of doctors and technicians that the laboratory brought into being.
08.3
CIVIC LABORATORIES NEW MUSEUMS
Bruno Latour’s contention that it is ‘in his very scientific work, in the depth of his laboratory’ that ‘ Pasteur actively modifies the society of his time’ (Latour 1999a, 267) points in the same direction. For it was his ability to mobilise the microbes produced in his laboratory that gave Pasteur the ability to reshape society as an example of the processes of translation understood as encompassing ‘all the negotiations, intrigues, calculations, acts of persuasion and violence, thanks to which an actor or force takes, or causes to be conferred on itself, authority to speak or act on behalf of another actor or force’ (Callon and Latour 1981, 279). By virtue of the microbes he was able to control and interpret, and which were enrolled as actants in and through the practices of the whole corps of socio-medical personnel who invoked them as allies in their strategies for managing the social, Pasteur’s scientific activities became directly political: If by politics you mean to be the spokesman of the forces you mould society with and of which you are the only credible and legitimate authority, then Pasteur is a fully political man. Indeed, he endows himself with one of the most striking fresh sources of power ever. Who can imagine being the representative of a crowd of invisible, dangerous forces able to strike anywhere and to make a shambles of the present state of society, forces of which he is by definition the only credible interpreter and which only he can control (Latour 1999a, 268).
The scope for thinking of museums analogously as places in which new forces and realities are constructed, and then mobilised in social programs by those who are empowered to act as their credible interpreters, is readily perceptible. Museums have served as important sites for the historical production of a range of new entities (such as art, community, prehistory, national pasts or international heritage), which, through contrived and carefully monitored ‘civic experiments’ directed at target populations (the workingman, children, migrants) within the museum space, have been brought to act on the social in varied ways. The role that museums have played in mapping out both social space and orderings of time in ways that have provided the vectors for programs of social administration conducted outside the museum has been just as important, playing a key role in providing the spatial and temporal coordinates within which populations are moved and managed. ‘Give me a laboratory and I will raise the world’ is the title of one of Latour’s articles (Latour 1999a). This suggests, as a rough equivalent, ‘Give me a museum and I will change society’ in view of the museum’s capacity, through the studied manipulation of the relations between people and things in a custom-built environment, to produce new entities that can be mobilised – both within the museum and outside it – in social and civic programs of varied kinds. However, before pursuing this line of thought further, it needs to be acknowledged that both Knorr-Cetina and Latour have been taken to task for working with a more generous interpretation of the idea of the laboratory than others think is warranted. Ian Hacking, for instance, has cautioned against seeing too much overlap between laboratories and more open network systems (Hacking 1992a). Moreover, whereas Latour includes collections and archives in his definition of laboratories, Hacking explicitly excludes the classificatory and historical sciences from his definition, which stresses instead the ability of the laboratory sciences to interfere directly with the object of study. ‘The laboratory sciences’, he writes, ‘use apparatus
CIVIC LABORATORIES NEW MUSEUMS
08.4
in isolation to interfere with the course of that aspect of nature that is under study, the end in view being an increase in knowledge, understanding, and control of a general or generalisable sort’ (Hacking 1992b, 33). This means, Hacking concludes, that while museums may undoubtedly contain laboratories in their basements, they cannot be so considered in their archival and classificatory functions since these lack, or do not comprise, an apparatus of intervention on the laboratory model. The point is debatable. John Pickstone has thus shown how the intellectual operations of a range of early-nineteenth-century sciences were essentially museological in the respect that their comparative and classificatory procedures depended on the ability to make observations across the large bodies of material collected in museums and to abstract from these the systems of relations between them that their assemblage in collections made visible (Pickstone 1994; Pickstone 2000). Nélia Dias also reminds us of the relations between the skull collections of late-nineteenthcentury anthropological museums and craniological experiments, and between both of these and the forms of intervention in the social represented by the colonial administration of colonised peoples (Dias 2004, 220–228). However, when these caveats are entered, I suspect that, technically speaking, Hacking is right here. The knowledges that have been most closely associated with the development of museums and that have provided the basis for their curatorial specialism have been a mix of historical and cultural sciences which, while often drawing on laboratory sciences (through carbon-dating techniques, for example), have typically fabricated the entities they construct by different means (the fieldwork situation and the archeological dig, for example). Yet the laboratory analogy is still a productive one in drawing attention to the ways in which the museological deployment of such knowledges – alongside those of education officers, designers, and so on – brings objects together in new configurations, making new realities and relationships both thinkable and perceptible. The crucial point, though, is the occurrence of this within a space that is simultaneously epistemological and civic for it is this that enables such assemblages and the relationships between persons they enter into in the museum space to constitute an apparatus of intervention in the social. It will be useful, in developing this argument, to go back to the three aspects of laboratory science identified by Knorr-Cetina: namely, that laboratories do not have to make do with objects as, where, or when they ‘naturally’ occur. For it is true of the museum just as much as it is of the laboratory that it does not need to ‘put up with the object as it is’. The museum object is, indeed, always non-identical with itself or with the event (natural, social or cultural) of which it is the trace. Its mere placement within a museum frame constitutes a detachment from its ‘in itselfness’, and one that renders it amenable to successive reconfigurations through variable articulations of its relations to other, similarly constituted objects. It is equally true that in ‘bringing objects home’, detaching them from where they ‘naturally’ occur, museums are able to manipulate those objects on their own terms in ways that make new realities perceptible and available for mobilisation in the shaping and reshaping of social relationships. This was, indeed, Hegel’s central contention concerning the productivity of the art museum. By severing the connections linking works of art to the conditions of their initial production and reception, the art museum opened up the space for a properly historical cultural politics that would be alert to the possibilities presented by transformations of the relations between cultural artefacts. It constituted a space in which the meanings and functions of artefacts could be made more pliable to the extent that, once placed in a museum, they were no longer limited by their anchorage within an origin-
08.5
CIVIC LABORATORIES NEW MUSEUMS
ating social milieu or immanent tradition (see Maleuvre 1999, 21–29). Latour’s conception of anthropological and natural history museums as centres of collection, in which objects from a range of peripheral locations are brought together, is another case in point (Latour 1987, 223–228), one which foregrounds the relationship between collecting expeditions and museums as ‘the sites in which all the objects of the world thus mobilised are assembled and contained’ (Latour 1999b, 101). Their functioning in this regard has played a pivotal role in the organisation of the socio-temporal coordinates of colonialism as a consequence of the differentiation they established between, on the one hand, the far-away and the primitive and, on the other, the closeat-hand and the modern (Bennett 2004, 19–24). There are, however, many other examples that might be cited. The ensemble ecologique developed by Georges-Henri Rivière at the National Museum of Popular Arts and Traditions in Paris has played a key role in producing, as both a surface of government and a locus for new forms of agency, communities identified in terms of the regional cultural ecologies, or territorially defined ways of life, that such arrangements make visible (see Poulot 1994). Another case in point is the close relations between art museums and art history in producing art as an autonomous entity as the necessary precondition for its (contradictory) mobilisation in civilising programs or as a key marker in processes of social differentiation. In all of these cases, museums are a prime example of those processes through which technologies are able to accumulate in themselves powers and capacities derived from the different times, places and agents that are folded into them through what they bring together – powers and capacities that can then be set in motion in new directions (Latour 2002a). They are all cases, too, in which the productive power of institutions is made manifest in their ability to fabricate new entities out of the materials they assemble. ‘Boeing 747s do not fly, airlines fly’: this is how Latour once summarised his contention that only corporate bodies could absorb and regulate the proliferation of mediators through which we and our artefacts have become ‘object institutions’ (Latour 1999b, 193). If it is true, similarly, that it is art museums and not artists who make art, the perception is one that needs to be extended to the wider range of entities (community, heritage, regional cultures, and so on) that are produced by museums as ‘object institutions’ par excellence. If such entities are museum fabrications, then, to come to the third aspect of Knorr-Cetina’s characterisation of laboratory science, it is through the observation of the effects of the different orderings of the relations between visitors and such entities that museums dispense with ‘natural’ cycles of occurrence to organise experimental situations in which contrived and staged encounters between people and objects can be arranged for the purpose of both continuous and comparative study. Museums are, in this regard, one of the most intensively monitored spaces of civic observation that we have with countless studies drawing on a plethora of quantitative and qualitative techniques (for instance, sociological and psychographic visitor profiling, exit interviews, and time and motion studies) to assess and calibrate the museum’s precise civic yield in terms of learning outcomes, improved visitor attentiveness, increased accessibility, social cohesion or greater cross-cultural understanding. And it is through the variety of ways in which they thus monitor and assess the outcomes of such ‘civic experiments’ that museums generate ‘civic results’ that are portable from one museum to another. While acknowledging that there are, of course, limits to how far the museum–laboratory analogy can and should be taken (not least, of course, because visitors practice their own forms of often quite unpredictable agency within the museum space), there is one further aspect of
CIVIC LABORATORIES NEW MUSEUMS
08.6
Knorr-Cetina’s approach to laboratories I want to draw on. She contends that what she calls the ‘epistemic objects’, which are produced through the research process in settings such as laboratories, have a complex, necessarily unfinished structure that breaks with everyday and habitual relations to objects, to generate an ongoing creative intellectual engagement with them. Here is how she puts it: The everyday viewpoint, it would seem, looks at objects from the outside as one would look at tools or goods that are ready to hand or to be traded further. These objects have the character of closed boxes. In contrast, objects of knowledge appear to have the capacity to unfold indefinitely. They are more like open drawers filled with folders extending indefinitely into the depth of a dark closet. Since epistemic objects are al