In This Issue
November 2004 In This Issue Click article title to open Reviews
People
AAS Tassman v4.0
AIM: Association Of Independent Music
Physical Modelling Synth (Mac/PC) Tassman is not the oldest 'virtual modular' software synth, but it's always been one of the better ones around. We check out the latest version...
Alison Wenham • Steve Johnston We would all like to make a living from selling our own music — but how would you actually go about it? The UK-based Association Of Independent Music offer some thoughts on how to cope with the opportunities and pitfalls of the modern music industry.
ADAM ANF10 Passive Nearfield Monitors ADAM's new passive nearfields combine proprietary ribbon tweeters with doped-paper woofers to provide high-precision monitoring on a budget.
AKG C414B XLS & XLII Capacitor Microphones One of the all-time classic microphones gets a 21stcentury makeover.
Allen & Heath WZ316:2 Analogue Mixer Allen & Heath's Mix Wizard range of multi-purpose analogue mixers has just been redesigned and rereleased. But is the old magic still there?
Apple Logic Pro 7 PREVIEW: MIDI + Audio Sequencer (Mac OS X) When Apple bought Emagic two years ago, the question on everyone's lips was 'What will they do with Logic?' Now they have unveiled perhaps the most radical overhaul the sequencer has ever seen, with improvements ranging from new instruments and effects to a networking system that could eliminate CPU restrictions completely. We explain what's changed in this PREVIEW (full in-depth review will follow next month).
Cakewalk Kinetic PC Software Studio With pattern-based sequencing, plenty of \npresets and a powerful analogue-style synth, Cakewalk's affordable soft studio package could be a valuable compositional tool.
Fishman Aura Acoustic Guitar Preamp This digital processing unit promises a whole new level of realism from acoustic guitar pickups. Although
Bill Szymczyk Producer From unlikely beginnings as a naval SONAR operator with no musical training, Bill Szymczyk became a legendary producer and engineer whose work with The Eagles would define the hifi sound of '70s rock.
Business End Listen & Learn from Reader Tracks Listen online to the tracks while you read what the MPG (Music Producers Guild) members thought of the latest batch of SOS readers' submitted recordings.
Crosstalk: Your Communications Readers Writes Replies to more of your emails, faxes and letters.
Keeping Hardware Alive Leader SOS Editor In Chief, Paul White, believes that if the manufacturers of studio hardware outboard equipment still want to be building it in significant numbers in five years' time, then a system similar to the one he proposes in this article is the only thing he can see that will keep them in the game. Read on...
Mark Nevers Producing Lambchop Fed up with being treated badly by spoilt divas, engineer Mark Nevers abandoned the country music establishment to start his own studio, and has made a name for himself on the 'other side' of Nashville.
Secrets Of House & Trance Darren Tate's Production Tips Darren Tate is one of Britain's leading house and trance producers with nine Top-40 hits under aliases including Jurgen Vries, Angelic and Citizen Caned, his latest success being the DT8 Project's summer anthem 'The Sun Is Shining (Down On
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/In%20This%20Issue.htm (1 of 4)9/26/2005 8:17:02 AM
In This Issue
primarily aimed at live performance, could it be a serious Me)'. He reveals the personal production tricks which make his option for the studio too? records stand out.
Korg CR4
Sounding Off
Cassette Multitracker Korg, one of the main manufacturers of digital workstations, have just released another multitracker, but this time it's cassette-based!
Duncan Williams Is entry-level software killing musical creativity?
Latest Sample CDs Hot Releases Tested Reviews/appraisals of the latest sample CDs: Tekniks Xtreme House 2 ***** MULTI-FORMAT PMI The Emperor ***** MULTI-FORMAT Tekniks Ghetto Grooves 2 **** AUDIO+WAV PMI The Old Lady ***** MULTI-FORMAT.
Plug-In Folder Latest Plug-ins Tested We test and report on another crop of highly insertable software Plug-ins: Elemental Audio Eqium & Firium Formats: Mac RTAS, VST & Audio Units; PC RTAS & VST TC Electronic TC30 Formats: Mac & PC Powercore
Studio SOS Tony Global Tony Global's background is in the dance-music/DJ scene. The SOS team help him to polish his vocal sounds and improve his mixes.
The History Of Roland Part 1: 1930-1978 The Roland name is almost synonymous with music technology — there can't be an SOS reader who has not made use of their instruments at some time. As founder Ikutaro Kakehashi approaches his 75th birthday, we begin a journey through the company's extraordinary history... Technique
Audio Pitch and Tempo Manipulation in Performer
SE Electronics Icis
Digital Performer Notes A guide to DP's options for audio pitch and tempo manipulation is on the agenda for this month's instalment of Performer Notes.
Valve Microphone This strikingly styled new valve mic offers a sound inspired by vintage classics.
Choosing A PC Audio Interface: The SOS Guide
Steinberg Cubase SX 3 MIDI + Audio Sequencer (PC & Mac OSX) Cubase SX 3 is the latest incarnation of one of the bestknown brands in sequencing software, offering many new features and tying up the loose ends from previous generations of Cubase. But with increased competition, most notably from Apple and Cakewalk, can Steinberg maintain their cross-platform advantage?
TC-Helicon Intonator HS Pitch-correction Plug-in (TC Powercore) A Powercore version of Antares' ubiquitous Auto-Tune pitch corrector was announced in 2001, but it never appeared. Is TC's new Intonator HS plug-in a viable alternative?
Voyager By Bob Moog Version 2 OS Updates • Anniversary Edition • VX351 • CP251 Since the release of the Voyager analogue monosynth last year, Bob Moog's company have been busy producing OS updates, special-edition versions, and accessories. We bring you up to date with a look at the lot.
PC Musician There are now so many sizes, types and formats of audio interface available that it can seem well-nigh impossible to find the one that best suits your needs. We sort out the spec features that are really important.
CLASSIC TRACKS: Sade's 'The Sweetest Taboo' Producers: Robin Millar, Sade Adu, Mike Pela, Ben Rogan Sade's ice-cool vocals and sophisticated, jazz-tinged instrumentation defined a new kind of soul music for the '80s. Engineer and producer Mike Pela describes the organic recording process that produced one of the singer's most memorable hits from 1985.
Demo Doctor Reader Recordings Diagnosed Think your own music is good? Listen to these tracks from SOS readers and see if you agree with the good Doctor's prognosis...
Einstürzende Neubauten Alexander Hacke: Recording Phase 1 & Perpetuum Mobile After more than 20 years making uncompromising industrial records, pioneering German band Einstürzende Neubauten escaped a creative and financial crisis through an Internet
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/In%20This%20Issue.htm (2 of 4)9/26/2005 8:17:02 AM
In This Issue
Zero-X Beat Quantizer Multitrack Beat Slicer & Quantizer (PC) If you are an avid slicer of beats, then Zero-X's latest offering might just appeal. With its support for multitrack slicing and quantizing, is Beat Quantizer the best thing since sliced bread? Competition
SUBSCRIBE & WIN Inta Audio PCbased/M-Audio computer recording studio WIN Focusrite Liquid Channel Sound Advice
Q. Can I get a more accurate bass sound using a subwoofer? Q. Can I use acoustic screens to effectively prevent drum spill? Q. Do I really need touch-sensitive moving faders? Q. Is it OK to paint acoustic foam? Q. Why does the speed at which you burn a CD make a difference?
project which allowed their fans to influence the recording of their latest album.
Investigating Core Audio Performance Under Mac OS X The Ins & Outs Of X In recent months, SOS's online Mac Music forum has highlighted the difficulty with achieving the same number of channels of audio I/O under Mac OS X and Logic that were possible under OS 9. We investigate the problems and provide some solutions.
Marquee Tool Tips in Logic Logic Notes Once you find out all the things you can do with the Marquee tool, you'll wonder how you ever lived without it, so this month's column offers some advice on how to put it to work in your projects.
Organising Tracks & Plug-ins in Sonar Sonar Notes Organise your tracks with Sonar 4's Track Folder feature, nudge them into place with sample accuracy, and reclaim older plug-ins for use in newer versions of Sonar.
PowerBook power; new iMac; OS X tips Apple Notes We discuss Apple's brand-new iMac, investigate how much power a musician can really expect from the latest Powerbooks, and explain how to save some hard disk space when installing Mac OS X.
Reason: Alternatives To 4/4 Time Reason Notes Reason seems firmly fixed in a 4/4 time signature — but clever use of the Redrum and Matrix pattern-based devices allows you to explore more unusual signatures. This month we explain how, as well as bringing you the essential news and tips.
Should PC musicians install XP Service Pack 2? PC Notes The Windows XP Service Pack 2 is out, and it offers valuable bug fixes as well as enhanced Internet security measures. But as reports of a few audio-related problems surface, should musicians go ahead and install it?
Solving Computer Audio Problems Banish Them For Good Many of the unwanted hums, clicks, and whirrs that compromise the performance of your computer studio are nothing to do with software. We take a look at what causes them, and how to banish them for good!
SX Embracer, Tonic and Monologue plug-ins Cubase Notes file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/In%20This%20Issue.htm (3 of 4)9/26/2005 8:17:02 AM
In This Issue
We take a closer look at the Embracer, Tonic and Monologue plug-ins that come supplied with Cubase SX.
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/In%20This%20Issue.htm (4 of 4)9/26/2005 8:17:02 AM
AAS Tassman v4.0
In this article:
Stage By Stage In Performance Favourite Performances Improved Algorithms Other Tweaks Conclusions
AAS Tassman v4.0 Physical Modelling Synth (Mac/PC) Published in SOS November 2004 Print article : Close window
Reviews : Software
pros Vast new high-quality library. Significantly improved Tassman is not the oldest 'virtual modular' software acoustic algorithms. synth, but it's always been one of the better ones Integral multi-effects and around. We check out the latest version... external sync options. Can now be used as a plugin effect as well as an instrument. Martin Walker
cons User-created acoustic Instruments will sound different with updated algorithms. No demo period on challenge/response registration.
summary Tassman v4.0 adds a rich layer of sophistication to its sounds, while its much larger library finally proves just how capable the AAS analogueand physical-modelling modules really are.
information Retail boxed version, £249; Internet boxed version, US $349; Internet download version, US $289; upgrade for existing users, US $99 (the upgrade is free for all new users who have bought Tassman since 1st January 2004). SCV London +44 (0)20 8418 0778. +44 (0)20 8418 0624. Click here to email www.scvlondon.co.uk
Ever since I reviewed version 1.2 of Applied Acoustic Systems' Tassman modular software synth designer way back in SOS July 2000, I've been fascinated by its blend of physical modelling, analogue synths, and step sequencing. Since then its list of modules has grown considerably, VSTi and DXi support has been added, a Mac version has been developed, and the two-part Builder/Player has been integrated into one much neater interface. However, although it's easier to design with than NI's Reaktor, Tassman has never taken off in quite the same way, despite a loyal following.
With a large new library of Performances and a new Output section (on the topmost row), Tassman v4.0 is far more capable than ever before.
So what's new in version 4.0? Well, the two biggest improvements are a new Performance Mode, which combines an instrument, a preset, effects, and MIDI maps, and a new Output Stage. No, these didn't sound particularly exciting to me either, that is until I heard the results. What AAS have done is put a shine on the already capable engine at the heart of Tassman by adding all those final touches that make the sounds of MIDI hardware synths so enticing. To cap it all, they've teamed up with their US distributors Ilio to develop a greatly expanded library.
Stage By Stage
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/AAS%20Tassman%20v4.0.htm (1 of 4)9/26/2005 8:17:13 AM
AAS Tassman v4.0
www.appliedacoustics.com
Test Spec 2.8GHz Pentium 4C PC with Hyperthreading, an Asus P4P800 Deluxe motherboard with an Intel 865PE chipset running an 800MHz front side buss, and 1GB of DDR400 RAM, running Windows XP with Service Pack 1. Steinberg Cubase SX v2.2. Steinberg Wavelab v4.01a.
AAS Tassman v4.0 £249
In Tassman's Player view, the new Output Stage appears automatically as an extra module at the top of each instrument's rack, but offers far more than its name suggests. From left to right, you get Sync, Delay, Reverb, Output, and Master Recorder sections. You could previously sync modules together internally, but the new output Sync section lets you set overall internal tempo or lock to the tempo of a suitable host application using the new Master Sync Input module. The Delay section uses the new Sync Ping Pong Delay module, which can also be externally sync'ed if required, and provides feedback, low-pass filter and stereo-panning facilities. As with the similar effect in NI's Pro 53, this is surprisingly versatile considering its low CPU overhead, and is capable of a range of effects from simple stereo thickening to flanging and chorus to multi-tap delays. The reverb section uses the new stereo Reverberator module that's a huge improvement over the offering in v3. It has four size options from room to large hall, decay, diffusion, low and high damp controls, and I found it more versatile than some plug-in reverbs in simulating short ambiences all the way through to cavernous cathedrals with smooth, non-metallic tails. The Output section provides overall volume level and metering, while the Master Recorder lets you capture the real-time output of Tassman as a WAV or AIFF file. Finally, the settings of all five of these Effects Stages can be saved as presets.
In Performance All Instruments automatically use the Output Stage, but its current settings are not saved with them. To do this, you need to use one of the new Performances, which consists of an Instrument design, one of its Presets, a MIDI map containing controller allocations for real-time performance, and a complete set of Output Stage settings. Once you add some carefully chosen effects to an Instrument or Preset it really comes to life, sounding far more polished and 'complete', and of course both the delays and reverb help greatly in disguising abrupt note endings when using low polyphony. To make the most of this new regime, AAS provide a greatly expanded library with plenty of new analogue Instruments, and loads of the new Performances, which are sorted into 18 folders by genre. The first folder labeled 'Super Models' contains 101 entries, followed by others named 'Ambient', 'Audio Processing', 'Bass', 'Bell Type', 'Bowed', 'Flute Type', 'FX Synth', 'Keys', 'Lead', 'Mallet Type', 'Motion', 'Organ', 'Pad', 'Percussive', 'Plucked', 'Polysynth', and 'Sequencer'. Each one contains at least a dozen performances, and often 50 or more — there must be nearly a thousand in all, and I've highlighted some of my favourites in the box below.
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/AAS%20Tassman%20v4.0.htm (2 of 4)9/26/2005 8:17:13 AM
AAS Tassman v4.0
The eagle-eyed among you will already have spotted another feature given away by the 'Audio Processing' performance folder — Tassman v4.0 now includes new Audio In and Stereo In modules, so you can use it as an effects processor as well. AAS include a dynamic pitch-shifter, a dynamic delay, an unusual Tone control, and a vocoder to get you started, but I was soon using its sequencers to create some complex synchronised step-filtering effects.
Favourite Performances 'Bassmosphere': A classic slowly evolving bass drone with sequenced digital burbles. 'Kalimba-Breeze': A delicate, woody sound with mod-wheel control of stiffness from hard to slow and breathy. 'Meditation': A new preset for the 'Arnold' Instrument, using 12 oscillators to create a complex and evolving performance of singing bowls and gongs. 'Sample&Hold This': A stereo bouncing monophonic S&H filtered sequence. 'SquawkBox 2': A squelchy analogue sequenced loop accompanied by FM-sequenced bass and stereo glass-plate rhythms.
Improved Algorithms The VCO module is now more CPU efficient, while the response of the Multimode module used by the majority of acoustic algorithms including beams, membranes, plates, and strings has also been improved. In a side-by-side comparison with Tassman v3, version 4 Instruments definitely sound tighter and punchier, with a more defined impact on struck and plucked objects, as well as greater dynamic range and expression. The CPU overhead of acoustic instruments has also changed considerably. For example, a four-voice Dulcimer, which took up nearly 50 percent in version 3, now only uses up a total of five percent in version 4. In contrast, the four-voice Bowed Skin patch which took up 22 percent in version 3 now takes about 28 percent in version 4. Thankfully, most of the changes are in the downward direction, and often by a considerable margin, while the new effects impose only a tiny extra overhead. Some of the version 3 presets have disappeared from some instruments, as have some of the instruments themselves, although you can export these and import them into version 4 using the TXF (Tassman eXchange File) format. If you're upgrading, install both side by side or save the version 3 library folder elsewhere before you uninstall the application, and if you've already used Tassman v3 in some existing songs, you'll ideally need to keep its 53MB installed alongside version 4, or face some tweaking and remixing.
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/AAS%20Tassman%20v4.0.htm (3 of 4)9/26/2005 8:17:13 AM
AAS Tassman v4.0
Other Tweaks For the first time, the toolbar not only displays the polyphony and MIDI channel assigned to the current Instrument, but also lets you quickly change them via drop-down boxes. The toolbar also provides a new CPU meter to monitor the total processor overhead, and has a handy Builder/Player switch. The Browser now lets you view various combinations of Performances, Instruments, Modules, Sub-Patches, and Imports, to help you find what you're looking for more quickly. Other useful additions include a MIDI program change map, so you can switch Performances from your keyboard or sequencer. By default, the 101 performance Super Models are mapped to program changes 0 to 100, but you can create your own maps referencing any Performance. You can now also choose the rack row in which each Module appears in the Player from a menu command.
Conclusions AAS are victims of their own modesty. While adding a new Performance Mode, Output Stage, Expanded Library, Audio Input Processing, and Improved Algorithms sounds interesting if not revolutionary, the truth is rather more exciting. Tassman v4.0 sounds more sophisticated than its predecessors, from its basic algorithms to the fairy dust of its multi-effects. It's now able to show its versatility as a effects plug-in, too, and it has a library that finally taps its potential to prove to new users what it's capable of. Whether you're searching for delicate acoustic timbres or analogue sounds with attitude, Tassman v4.0 delivers them in spades. As you've probably gathered, I'm impressed! Published in SOS November 2004 Sound On Sound, Media House, Trafalgar Way, Bar Hill, Cambridge CB3 8SQ, UK. Email:
[email protected] | Telephone: +44 (0)1954 789888 | Fax: +44 (0)1954 789895
All contents copyright © SOS Publications Group and/or its licensors, 1985-2005. All rights reserved. The contents of this article are subject to worldwide copyright protection and reproduction in whole or part, whether mechanical or electronic, is expressly forbidden without the prior written consent of the Publishers. Great care has been taken to ensure accuracy in the preparation of this article but neither Sound On Sound Limited nor the publishers can be held responsible for its contents. The views expressed are those of the contributors and not necessarily those of the publishers. Web site designed & maintained by PB Associates | SOS | Relative Media
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/AAS%20Tassman%20v4.0.htm (4 of 4)9/26/2005 8:17:13 AM
ADAM ANF10
In this article:
Construction Accelerated Ribbon Technology Listening Tests
ADAM ANF10 £399
ADAM ANF10 Passive Nearfield Monitors Published in SOS November 2004 Print article : Close window
Reviews : Monitors
pros A superbly transparent monitor given the price. Good dynamics and high SPL capability. Spacious and stable stereo imaging.
ADAM's new passive nearfields combine proprietary ribbon tweeters with doped-paper woofers to provide high-precision monitoring on a budget.
cons Optimal spectral balance requires careful placement in relation to walls.
summary A modestly sized two-way passive nearfield monitor, employing ADAM's unique ART tweeter to provide exceptional mid-range and treble clarity. Careful positioning is required to produce a well-balanced frequency response, but expansive stereo imaging comes as standard!
information £399 per pair including VAT. Audiostate +44 (0)1933 227228. +44 (0)1933 277577. Click here to email www.audiostate.co.uk
Hugh Robjohns
The ADAM range of loudspeakers from Germany may not be the most common form of monitoring found in UK studios, but the company's fine reputation is becoming much better known these days. We have reviewed two ADAM monitors in the pages of SOS — the S2.5A and the slightly larger S3A — but this review is for the smallest and newest model in the range, the ANF10 passive nearfield monitor.
Photos: Mark Ewing
As with all the other monitors in the ADAM range, the ANF10 uses the unique Accelerated Ribbon Technology (ART) tweeter design (see box for details). However, instead of the Hexacone bass drivers used in most of the larger models, the ANF10 employs a more traditional doped-paper bass/mid-range driver, presumably to reduce the overall cost of this compact monitor.
www.adam-audio.de
Construction The black-painted cabinet shares the 'house style' chamfered corners either side of the tweeter (to reduce edge diffraction and improve dispersion) and measures a compact 330 x 180 x 280mm (hwd). It weighs just 5kg and the rear panel carries a single pair of gold-plated 4mm binding posts.
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/ADAM%20ANF10.htm (1 of 4)9/26/2005 8:17:16 AM
ADAM ANF10
The ART tweeter is mounted vertically above a 180mm (seven-inch) dopedpaper bass/mid-range driver, with a 45mm circular reflex port venting to the front from the bottom left-hand corner of the baffle. As a result, the ANF10 can be positioned close to rear walls without compromising the LF reinforcement provided by the port, and since the drive units are magnetically shielded the monitors can be used close to computer VDUs without problems either. Although the tweeter looks, superficially at least, identical to those used in other ADAM monitors, it is apparently a completely redesigned version built especially for the ANF10. The specifications claim an overall frequency response of 50Hz-35kHz (±3dB), and although the actual crossover point is not given I would estimate it to be around 2kHz. (The ART tweeter has a useful range down to about 1.8kHz, and most of the ADAM two-way monitors cross over between 1.8kHz and 2.2kHz.) The speaker is rated to handle 90W on music programme (60W continuous), and although I used my trusty Bryston 4B amplifier (which provides 300W into an 8 (omega) load) I found the ANF10s were able to deliver substantial levels in a nearfield situation without any hint of strain at all. Like any passive monitor, you only get out what you put in, and the ANF10s are able to resolve a lot of detail, so a decent amplifier is a necessity to really allow these monitors to perform to their best ability.
Accelerated Ribbon Technology The Accelerated Ribbon Technology tweeter employed in all ADAM monitors is fundamentally different from the more common soft-dome and metal-dome drivers used by most speaker manufacturers. The design is based on technology developed over thirty years ago called the Air Motion Transformer, which ADAM have refined to produce both tweeter and mid-range units for the company's exclusive use. In essence, the ribbon is placed between the poles of a very strong magnet as in any other ribbon design, but it doesn't operate in a simple pistonic fashion as other drivers do. Instead, the diaphragm is deeply folded, like a concertina, and the current is forced to flow around the ribbon folds in such a way that they move to actually pump the air in and out, rather than just pushing it back and forth. One of the most significant advantages of the ribbon design is that the diaphragm is also the motor, so there is a much smaller moving mass involved than in any moving-coil-driven design. The direct result is a far better transient response and wider bandwidth, in much the same way that a ribbon microphone has a much better transient response that a moving-coil mic. The ART design is also capable of handling more than double the thermal power of a conventional one-inch-dome tweeter, which means it is completely reliable even in high-powered professional monitors. Whereas simple pistonic diaphragms move at the same speed as the air they displace, the unique pumping action of the ART design moves the air four times faster than the diaphragm itself. This makes it much more efficient than conventional tweeters and helps to match the mechanical impedance of the diaphragm and air more accurately — producing high output levels (typically 93dB/
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/ADAM%20ANF10.htm (2 of 4)9/26/2005 8:17:16 AM
ADAM ANF10
W/m) and a better transient response.
Listening Tests When mounted in free space, well away from walls, the stereo imaging is huge, with wall-to-wall sound when replaying suitable material. Accurate coincident stereo recordings are portrayed with fine resolution and believable depth cues, and the 'sweet spot' is wide and stable, allowing you to move around the desk without losing the spatial imaging. The spectral balance is very good for a box of this size, and kick drums and bass guitar lines are delivered with reasonable weight and depth. However, with the monitors on stands well away from the rear and side walls I felt the overall balance tended slightly towards a mid-range and treble emphasis — an impression confirmed when I listened to some spoken voice tracks which sounded vaguely disembodied. Moving the speakers closer to the back wall allowed the room to provide some additional acoustic reinforcement, which I felt helped to redress the balance and fill out the bottom nicely — but without sacrificing any of the impressive imaging qualities. The ART tweeter is certainly very fast and crisp, delivering transients with excellent precision and dynamism. Indeed, the whole of the upper midrange is very accurate and clean, allowing the listener to hear subtle details well inside a complex mix. This is a true monitor in that sense — faults are not glossed over at all. However, the ANF10 is not a fatiguing speaker either, and although you are left in no doubt as to what is going on in a mix I found I was quite happy to continue using the monitors for many hours at a time on a complicated editing project.
ADAM's proprietary ART tweeter unit.
As always, I made some test mixes using these monitors and found them a pleasure to work with. Small EQ changes were easy to judge, and although the fundamentals of bass instruments were subdued on these monitors (you can get too used to big PMCs!) replaying the mixes on other systems reassured me that everything came out in the right proportions — kick-drum and bass-guitar lines were balanced as I was expecting. At this UK price the ANF10 finds itself amongst such worthy competition as the Dynaudio BM5 and Tannoy System 600 monitors. Comparing it directly with my own BM5s, I would say the ADAM monitor had the upper hand when it came to hearing into mixes, and the imaging was more impressive too — although the
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/ADAM%20ANF10.htm (3 of 4)9/26/2005 8:17:16 AM
ADAM ANF10
Dynaudio speaker is no slouch in either respect given the UK asking price. The ANF10 is intended mainly for nearfield use in modest project and home studios, but would be a good choice for any application where detailed nearfield monitoring is required. Like all good monitors, this speaker is able to reveal the limitations of mediocre power amps, so I would recommend that they be partnered with as good an amplifier as you can afford. Overall, though, the ADAM ANF10 is a very welcome new passive design for the budget end of the quality monitoring market, and one which should certainly be auditioned seriously. Published in SOS November 2004 Sound On Sound, Media House, Trafalgar Way, Bar Hill, Cambridge CB3 8SQ, UK. Email:
[email protected] | Telephone: +44 (0)1954 789888 | Fax: +44 (0)1954 789895
All contents copyright © SOS Publications Group and/or its licensors, 1985-2005. All rights reserved. The contents of this article are subject to worldwide copyright protection and reproduction in whole or part, whether mechanical or electronic, is expressly forbidden without the prior written consent of the Publishers. Great care has been taken to ensure accuracy in the preparation of this article but neither Sound On Sound Limited nor the publishers can be held responsible for its contents. The views expressed are those of the contributors and not necessarily those of the publishers. Web site designed & maintained by PB Associates | SOS | Relative Media
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/ADAM%20ANF10.htm (4 of 4)9/26/2005 8:17:16 AM
AKG C414B XLS & XLII
In this article:
Two Of A Kind Switchable Facilities Testing Times Classic & Modern
AKG C414 XLS & XLII £800/£850
AKG C414B XLS & XLII Capacitor Microphones Published in SOS November 2004 Print article : Close window
Reviews : Microphone
pros Maintain the classic C414 sound. New switching system with LED indicators.
One of the all-time classic microphones gets a 21stcentury makeover.
Additional wide cardioid polar pattern. Improved technical spec. Excellent accessories included.
Paul White
The C414 is probably the best-known microphone that AKG make, alongside the legendary C12. cons Nevertheless, the C414 has undergone a number of LEDs make 'stealth' miking evolutionary changes over its long lifetime, changing more difficult in TV and film applications. shape, adding and discarding transformers, and now, in its latest incarnation, sprouting LEDs! summary Although the overall shape of the new versions is The new C414s are classics brought up to date. Numerous unmistakably C414, virtually everything about the improvements have been microphone has been redesigned in an effort to made without sacrificing what retain the original sound, while at the same time made this mic so popular in improving the technical performance. AKG cite 15 the first place. improved features, though one of these relates to information the depth of engraving and the colour of the infill, so C414B XLS, £799.99; clearly some are of more importance than others! C414 XLII, £849.99. Prices include VAT. Harman Pro UK +44 (0) 1707 668222. +44 (0)1707 668010. Click here to email www.harmanprouk.com www.akg.com
Photos: Mike Cameron
Two Of A Kind In fact there are two new C414s, the C414B XLS and the C414 XLII, though the only performance difference between the two models is that the XLII has a more pronounced presence peak than the XLS. A slight additional lift above 3kHz gives this model a slightly more airy and open top end that is useful when miking vocals to capture a contemporary 'crisp' sound, or when miking instruments at a distance where the high lift helps compensate for the natural HF loss that occurs at a distance. Visually, the XLS model has a silver grille matched by silver engraved legending, while the XLII has a gold mesh and legend. As the mics are so similar, I'll simply refer to them as the C414 until the time comes to describe their tonal differences.
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/AKG%20C414B%20XLS%20&%20XLII.htm (1 of 4)9/26/2005 8:17:19 AM
AKG C414B XLS & XLII
These C414s are large-diaphragm, multi-pattern capacitor microphones utilising a gold-sputtered diaphragm where only the front side of the diaphragm is coated, the aim being to avoid electrical shorting between the diaphragm and backplate at very high SPLs. The capsule hangs in a newly designed four-point suspension, and even the way the various pattern, pad, and filter options are selected is quite unlike anything AKG have done before. Rather than use slide switches, the mics are now fitted with soft-touch rocker switches that are linked to digital switching circuitry, status LEDs, and a non-volatile memory so that settings are retained when the mic is disconnected from the phantom power source.
Switchable Facilities The pickup pattern can be switched in five steps to encompass omni, wide cardioid (not available on previous C414 models), cardioid, narrow cardioid, and figure of eight. A tiny system of green LEDs below the switch illuminates whichever option has been selected, and the current selection can be temporarily locked by pressing and holding the rocker selector switch for three seconds. Pressing again for three seconds, or switching off the phantom power, unlocks the setting. The same pattern-selection LED doubles as a clip warning light, and turns red for around one third of a second 2dB prior to clipping. At a recent AKG press event, we were also told that the pattern LEDs are recessed, so that if you can see the LED clearly from the position of the instrument or voice being recorded, the mic is being aimed correctly. This seems like a good idea, except in the event of clipping, where it could be argued that only the person or instrument being miked will be able to see the LED turn red! Maybe all the LEDs should flash red when clipping takes place? The pad switch now has 6dB, 12dB, and 18dB settings — as with the pattern selection, this works by changing the polarising voltage on the capsule. Because very high impedances are involved around the capsule itself, any changes made using these switches will take a few seconds to become active. The familiar bass-cut switch has also had a face-lift with 40Hz, 80Hz, or 160Hz settings, as well as off. A slope of over 12dB/octave is used for the lower two settings, while the 160Hz setting has a more gentle 6dB/octave characteristic. Re-engineered, transformerless electronic circuitry has extended the dynamic range of these microphones to around 134dBA by maximising headroom and minimising self noise, the latter down to an impressive 6dBA. To achieve this, the mic requires a full 48V phantom power source that file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/AKG%20C414B%20XLS%20&%20XLII.htm (2 of 4)9/26/2005 8:17:19 AM
The reverse side of the new mic carries pad and filter switches.
AKG C414B XLS & XLII
conforms to the DIN/IEC spec, where the phantom voltage is positive with respect to the cable's ground screen. During the makeover, the capsule and circuitry have been made less susceptible to humidity and temperature by locating the function switches in the lowimpedance section of the circuitry, which also minimises switching thumps. Matching between microphones has been tightened as well, so there's no need to buy matched pairs for stereo work. Interestingly, because the microphone utilises microprocessor-controlled switching, we are told that it will be possible to control the functions remotely via normal mic cables, and AKG are apparently working on a remote control, to be called the R414, for this purpose. However, no further details were available at the time of this review. Cosmetically, the mics certainly look more modern than their predecessors, and they also come with a more comprehensive range of accessories, specifically a foam-lined aluminium flight case that also includes a high-strength plastic shockmount with bayonet quick-release mechanism, plus a separate mesh pop shield with flexible gooseneck. You also get the old fashioned foam wind sock and a manual in an assortment of popular languages.
Testing Times Tonally, these mics come very close to the earlier transformerless C414s, though the top end seems a little smoother than I remember it. Even the top-lift XLII model sounds open rather than harsh, and the difference between the two mics is more subtle than I expected it to be. The obvious test for the C414 is a lead vocal, and as expected the mic handled this like the thoroughbred it is, combining body with high-end clarity, and here the choice of two slightly different high-end characteristics means that if one of these mics doesn't quite do the trick for you the other one probably will. I'm not sure whether the HF contouring is a function of the capsule design or the electronics, but if the latter then it might have been preferable from the user's point of view to have just one model available with a switchable high-end lift. The other test was, of all things, a folk concertina which I miked in stereo, the XLII covering the high end and the XLS the bass notes. I know that a purist stereo recording should use identical mics, but I actually achieved excellent results with great stereo separation and minimal spill from the other instruments playing in the room, and there was no obvious tonal disparity. Acoustic guitar was also a doddle with the XLII, giving an expensive, sparkly sound but not at the expense of depth. Recording the acoustic piano is another favourite for C414s, and as the overall tonality hasn't changed to any significant degree I can see this tradition continuing. On a practical note, the LEDs, which are fairly discreet, help in setting up under poor lighting conditions, and also avoid the need for clunky slide switches, but I can't help feeling they could be a disadvantage for TV work, where you need the file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/AKG%20C414B%20XLS%20&%20XLII.htm (3 of 4)9/26/2005 8:17:19 AM
AKG C414B XLS & XLII
mic to be as inconspicuous as possible. Maybe the forthcoming new remote control could include a LED kill switch?
Classic & Modern While the new C414s are not cheap mics, the new design and the use of modern manufacturing methods have allowed AKG to peg the UK price, retain the classic sound, and introduce some very real improvements, both practical and technical. Furthermore, when compared with flagship mics from other companies, the cost of the C414s compares very favourably. Over the few weeks I've had these mics, I haven't found anything they do badly, and I've found lots of things they do well. AKG's new control system is rather neat, as is the promise of remote control, and you can't fault the selection of accessories, which includes a tough flight case, a very well-designed shockmount, and a pop shield. These new mics successfully uphold the classic C414 tradition for sound, while their extended dynamic range, greater sensitivity, and very low background noise make them suitable for the most demanding music recording tasks. I'll be sorry to see them go back. Published in SOS November 2004 Sound On Sound, Media House, Trafalgar Way, Bar Hill, Cambridge CB3 8SQ, UK. Email:
[email protected] | Telephone: +44 (0)1954 789888 | Fax: +44 (0)1954 789895
All contents copyright © SOS Publications Group and/or its licensors, 1985-2005. All rights reserved. The contents of this article are subject to worldwide copyright protection and reproduction in whole or part, whether mechanical or electronic, is expressly forbidden without the prior written consent of the Publishers. Great care has been taken to ensure accuracy in the preparation of this article but neither Sound On Sound Limited nor the publishers can be held responsible for its contents. The views expressed are those of the contributors and not necessarily those of the publishers. Web site designed & maintained by PB Associates | SOS | Relative Media
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/AKG%20C414B%20XLS%20&%20XLII.htm (4 of 4)9/26/2005 8:17:19 AM
Allen & Heath WZ316:2
In this article:
The News The Big Picture Aux Sends & Effects EQ & Preamps Jumping Inside Internal Effects In Conclusion
Allen & Heath Mix Wizard WZ316:2 £961 pros Very clean preamps with loads of gain. Well-chosen effects. Plenty of user configuration options. Individually selectable phantom power on each channel. Inserts and direct outputs on every channel. Discrete circuit boards for each channel.
Allen & Heath WZ316:2 Analogue Mixer Published in SOS November 2004 Print article : Close window
Reviews : Mixer
Allen & Heath's Mix Wizard range of multipurpose analogue mixers has just been redesigned and rereleased. But is the old magic is still there? Tom Flint
The Mix Wizard 3 family, comprising the WZ316:2, WZ312:2, WZ314:4:2, and WZ320S models, are multipurpose mixers blessed with feature sets that cater for both studio and live applications. If the name Mix Wizard cons sounds familiar, it is because Allen & No EQ bypass switch. Heath have previously manufactured No dedicated effects bypass two generations of Mix Wizards, and switch. what we have here for review is Limited access to effect version number three. parameters via the front panel. Access to the jumper switches could be easier.
Photos: Mike Cameron
The original WZ16:2 was released way back in 1997, and just over a year later the improved DX version appeared. Since then, Allen & Heath have continued summary developing their professional live mixing consoles, and established a new range A very well-made mixer, of DJ-friendly products, but what happened to the Mix Wizards? Stiff competition which is just as valid in the from programmable digital mixers, computer-based mixing software and budgetstudio, acting as 16 channel strips for a digital system, as it priced hardware may well have damaged the company's confidence in the studio is on stage. market. Nevertheless, the demand for analogue studio gear has never gone information away, and many people with software studios happily use analogue preamps and EQs in conjunction with their digital equipment. WZ316:2, £961.10; optional Sys-Link II card, £288.70. Prices include VAT. Allen & Heath +44 (0) 1326 372070. +44 (0)1326 377097. Click here to email
The News Anyone who has used or seen one of the previous generations of this mixer will
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Allen%20&%20Heath%20WZ316%202.htm (1 of 10)9/26/2005 8:17:22 AM
Allen & Heath WZ316:2
www.allen-heath.com
recognise it immediately; it shares the same layout and colour scheme as its predecessors, and its overall feature set is very similar. Nevertheless, the circuits have been completely redesigned to incorporate newly available components and to take advantage of improved manufacturing methods. Separate circuit boards are still given to each of the mixer's channels, but they are produced using surfacemount manufacturing, which makes assembly easier, faster, and (no doubt) cheaper, and the resulting circuits apparently offer an improved performance due to their better noise rejection. While redesigning the circuits, Allen & Heath took the opportunity to modify the feature set, basing their changes on several years of user feedback. Some modifications clearly benefit the live engineer most: a socket for connecting a gooseneck lamp is most needed in darkened venues, for example, and the inclusion of a connector for use with a second power supply, configured so it kicks into action if the main source fails, is something worry-prone live engineers will welcome. The redesign also includes a number of minor improvements, including things such as extra rubber feet on the connector pod for when you're using the mixer on a desktop, and moulded plastic side trims, the latter largely added for aesthetic reasons, as far as I can see. Details like these are nice, but there is a batch of far more significant improvements on offer too. Just like its predecessors, the WZ316:2 fits into a standard 19-inch rack, once its plastic end cheeks have been removed, so there is limited front-panel space for adding new features. Nevertheless, the designers have managed to squeeze in some physical additions, the most obvious of which is a black fader labelled 'M', situated next to the 'L' and 'R' (left and right) master channel faders. In this instance, 'M' is a mono channel which has its own balanced XLR output on the rear panel. The channel can be fed either a summed version of the left and right channels or the signal from the Aux 6 buss. A tiny blue recessed button nearby allows the selection of one or the other. The 'M' channel could be used in a number of ways, and is best thought of as a flexible buss with its own level control. Perhaps most welcome of all the mixer's improvements is the introduction of independent phantom-power switching on all 16 mixer channels. The DX had just the one switch governing the delivery of phantom power to all its channels, which might have been restrictive for anyone wanting to use a mixture of dynamic and condenser mics. I still think that it would have been better if Allen & Heath had used phantom-power buttons of the transparent LED-lit type though, so that their status was totally clear at a glance. With the aid of a screwdriver it's possible
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Allen%20&%20Heath%20WZ316%202.htm (2 of 10)9/26/2005 8:17:22 AM
Allen & Heath WZ316:2
to re-configure the mixer for rackmount Less obvious to the eye are a number of use, rotating the connector pod through 90 customisation options offered by jumper degrees and exposing the rack ears by switches located on circuit boards inside removing the plastic side trims. the mixer casing. (See the 'Jumping Inside' box for a full listing of these options.) These are largely intended as semi-permanent customisation options that the user will set up to suit their way of working, but will thereafter rarely touch. In the past the Mix Wizard's custom options required the cutting of certain resistors, or the insertion of various ICs into specific parts of the circuit, and for one particular customisation shown in the manual this is still what you have to do. However, the use of jumpers is a much better idea, as it is easily reversible.
The 16:2 also provides a few new effects-routing options by way of four knobs situated in the master section, labelled Aux 1, 2, 3, and 4. These are dedicated send controls for delivering the feed from the internal effects (more on the effects later) to the first four auxiliary outputs, presumably so that any stage monitors hooked up to the aux sends can receive independent effect mixes. As standard, the internal stereo effects are sent in mono to each of the four Aux sends, although one of the internal options allows the effects to be sent in stereo to oddeven pairs. The other main additions to the WZ316:2 include a footswitch input for muting the effects return channel, and a back-panel slot for the installation of a Sys-Link II board. Once fitted, the optional board allows the desk to be connected to the fourbuss WZ314:4:2 or to some of the larger Allen & Heath mixers, where it acts as an input expander with linked auxes and synchronised PFL control. Allen & Heath mixers have often been praised for their sound quality, so I was interested to read that the WZ3 range has been given a new preamp design and has altered EQ settings. As it turns out, the EQ's high and low shelving filters have been adjusted so that they are more responsive at the important frequencies of 10kHz and 100Hz respectively. The preamps have received a slightly more radical reworking. Firstly the gain range has been increased by 10dB, so that the preamps provide 10-60dB of gain instead of 20-60dB, and in the process the gain law on the potentiometer has been optimised so that better use is made of the sweep of the pot. At the same time, the 30dB pad of old has been reduced to a 20dB pad, so that up to 40dB gain is available when the pad is selected.
The Big Picture Having discussed the new features on offer, let's have a more general look at this new Mix Wizard. All sixteen of the WZ3's input channels are identical, unless a channel is re-configured via the internal jumpers. Signals enter a channel through either a balanced XLR or balanced quarter-inch jack input socket situated on the back panel. Each channel has its own insert point and direct output courtesy of two further jack sockets. After the aforementioned preamp, file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Allen%20&%20Heath%20WZ316%202.htm (3 of 10)9/26/2005 8:17:22 AM
Allen & Heath WZ316:2
each channel has a high-pass filter switch attenuating at 12dB/octave below 80Hz, and operating just before the insert point. Next comes the four-band EQ, followed by six auxiliary sends. At the base of the channel is a pan knob, a channel mute switch, a pre-fader monitoring switch, and a smooth 100mm fader. All of the WZ3's connectors are situated on the back panel, apart from the fixing for the goose-neck lamp and the headphone socket, both of which are on the front panel. The connector panel is on a hinged section of the mixer, which can be rotated from 90 to 180 degrees relative to the front panel once two fixing screws are removed. In its 90degree position, the chassis acts as a stand for the mixer, tilting it up towards the engineer. When it's folded back at 180 degrees, the mixer can be installed in a rack more easily. Besides the channel inputs, insert points, and direct outputs already mentioned, there is a row of six jack sockets for the aux send outputs. When these are used to send signals out to effects, the returning signal can be plugged into either one of the two pairs of jack sockets labelled ST1 and ST2, although the unbalanced ST2 is partly intended as an audio input for a device playing pre-recorded interval music during live shows. These inputs are situated next to a pair of impedancebalanced outputs marked AB, which offer an alternative version of the stereo mix and are intended for sending a signal to an external stereo recorder. Just below the AB outs is a blanking panel where the Sys-Link II option can be added. The remaining inputs include a single MIDI input for editing the internal effects, the footswitch jack input, the DC input for connection to a backup power adaptor, plus a pair of insert jacks specifically for the stereo master channel. The remaining connectors not yet mentioned are the three outputs for the left and right channels and the new mono master channel, and these are provided by balanced XLRs.
Aux Sends & Effects The WZ3 has six mono auxiliary sends available to each channel. Aux 1 and Aux 2 are pre-fader, which is fairly standard on desks used for live work — these auxiliary busses can then be used to feed stage monitors and wedges, and their level settings will remain independent of the main mix. These aux busses are also fed from a point before the insert and the EQ, although this can be changed independently for each channel by moving certain of the circuit-board jumpers. Aux 3 and Aux 4 can be switched pre/post-fader via a front-panel button, whereas Aux 5 and Aux 6 are post fader, and are routed to the internal effects as standard. In the mixer's master section six auxiliary master controls allow overall buss level file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Allen%20&%20Heath%20WZ316%202.htm (4 of 10)9/26/2005 8:17:22 AM
Allen & Heath WZ316:2
adjustment, and next to these are a set of switches which determine which auxiliaries can be heard through the monitoring channel. By selecting the relevant buttons, the engineer can monitor single auxes, pairs of auxes (by pressing the appropriate buttons together), and also the activity of the ST1 and ST2 channels. The onboard effects, which we'll detail a little later, This Sys-Link II card can be inserted behind are routed so that they receive signals the blanking panel at the bottom right-hand from Aux 5 as standard, although when side of the mixer's back panel. Once the Dual FX mode is selected, and installed, the WZ316:2 can act as an input expander module for the WZ314:4:2 or a both effects processors are activated, variety of Allen & Heath's larger mixers. the second receives the Aux 6 signals. A master level pot labelled ST1/FX Lev returns the combined effects to the LR mix. As mentioned earlier, four further aux send controls deliver the effects to the first four aux busses. The level of these sends is unaffected by the ST1 control, so the effect feed to the mix remains separate. The pair of ST1 jack inputs are intended to handle the input from external effects devices. These too are routed to the main LR mix buss via the ST1/FX Lev control. There are three more knobs in the master section which I haven't yet mentioned. The most obvious is the headphone level control with its own PFL LED indicating its mode. Elsewhere is the ST2 Lev knob with an associated switch which routes anything plugged into the rear-panel's ST2 inputs to the main LR mix buss. The last knob controls the level of the AB output. The control has its own recessed mini-switch so that the LR output or the monitor signal can be output through the rear AB output jacks as required.
EQ & Preamps As demonstrated by the lengthy listing of features above, the WZ316:2 has a lot to offer, but nothing that would count for very much if its EQ and preamps were poor. Earlier we discussed the redesign of both, but the question of how they actually perform remains. Firstly, a brief run-down of the EQ components: there are high and low shelving filters, as well as two sweepable mid-bands. The high shelving filter provides ±15dB/octave above 12kHz and the low filter operates below 80Hz, although both filters actually begin working somewhere close to 1kHz, their response curves becoming steeper as they move towards the frequency extremes, as well as acting more vigorously than before at 100Hz and 10kHz. The lower mid-band filter offers 15dB of cut or boost centred anywhere from 1kHz down to 35Hz. The upper mid-band can also be swept, this time from the overlapping value of 500Hz all the way up to 15kHz. Modern digital EQs offer
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Allen%20&%20Heath%20WZ316%202.htm (5 of 10)9/26/2005 8:17:22 AM
Allen & Heath WZ316:2
variable Q settings which allow EQ bands to be focussed precisely on certain troublesome frequencies, but without that option an analogue mixer has to provide a fixed Q that works for all occasions. The setting of 1.8 offered by both mid-bands is a good, effective choice which sounds natural even with extreme processing. Four bands of EQ is generous — many similar-sized analogue mixers only offer three — but the most important thing is that these filters are good enough to be used liberally without fear of making a sound appear unnaturally affected. However, I also wish there was an EQ bypass switch so that radical EQ settings could quickly be compared with the unprocessed signal. The sixteen preamps are impressively quiet. I didn't have a previous-generation Mix Wizard to hand, so I couldn't check whether the surfacemount technology, or indeed the optimised gain law, had improved matters, but the new design certainly compared favourably with other preamps I have used in recent years, and it's hard to imagine how much better even the very best preamps could possibly be. They're perhaps not quite as kind to an input signal as the preamp in my TL Audio 5051 voice channel, but, at the same time, they appeared to be slightly quieter. They are certainly much quieter than those in my Yamaha AW4416, which, admittedly, is not renowned for the quality of its preamps. In a side-byside subjective listening test with a Behringer Eurorack MX1602A, which boasts the same ultra-low-noise preamps as the top-of-the-range MX9000, the WZ316:2 fared pretty well. At 60dB gain, the two products exhibited similar levels of noise, which, in practice, were vanishingly low compared to any reasonable audio signal. Subjectively, the Mix Wizard seemed to me to have a slightly warmer sound, although the differences were hard to detect on most material.
Jumping Inside After removing the metal panel which covers the underside of the WZ316:2, it is possible to change some of the mixer's settings by moving various jumper switches located on the circuit boards. Things aren't completely straightforward, however, because you need a Torx star-head key to get inside, and the manual's diagrams, while clear, aren't always easy to relate to the actual mixer internals. Each of the 16 channel boards has 13 sets of pins, six of which already have jumpers across them. The jumpers themselves are small plastic caps containing a conductive bridge. Moving jumpers is
Here you can see the internal construction
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Allen%20&%20Heath%20WZ316%202.htm (6 of 10)9/26/2005 8:17:22 AM
Allen & Heath WZ316:2
simply a matter of sliding them off one set of pins and replacing them on another. I say simple, but it is quite fiddly getting between the boards and grasping the jumpers, and easy to drop them into the bowels of the mixer by mistake — I'm sure anyone wanting to change the settings for all channels would find the job extremely frustrating!
of the mixer, using individual circuit boards for each channel. The inset on the left shows the IC sockets which can be used to alter the balancing properties of the auxiliary outputs. Jumpers on each channel, shown in more detail in the right-hand inset, can be re-configured to alter the characteristics of the aux sends and direct outputs.
The first two jumpers serve the pre-fade auxes, and configure Aux 1 and Aux 2 so that they are fed from a point after the equaliser. The next two jumpers switch the position of the direct outputs from pre-fader to post-fader. The remaining eight jumpers govern the pre/post-fader status of the six auxiliary sends. At one extreme, all auxes can be made pre-fader, while another patching scheme would turn all six into post-fader mode. It's also possible to have any of the auxes change its position under the control of the front-panel switch. The inner of the two boards serving the mixer's master section contains a set of IC sockets relating to the six auxiliary channels. By snipping the legs of a set of resistors and then inserting the correct IC components into the sockets (the ICs are not supplied as standard), the mixer's auxes can be changed from their default impedance-balanced condition, operating at -2dBu, to an electronicallybalanced condition with a +4dBu nominal level. The manual is clear on how to insert the ICs, which type can be used, and which resistors need to be cut, although it labels the sockets from U7 to U12 for some reason, and no such labelling was apparent on my review model. I even opened up the connector panel just to double check I wasn't supposed to be looking at a different set of sockets! The outer board of the master section holds the four jumper plugs required for changing the AB output source from the factory post-fader setting to a pre-fader one. Allen & Heath quite reasonably suggest the pre-fader setting be used when the AB outs are feeding a tape with its own level control, or a similarly remotely attenuated broadcast feed. The last option offered by the WZ316:2 is a switch for changing the status of the ST1 stereo return signal, which by default is summed into a mono signal and then fed to the monitor channel's four aux feeds. Moving the jumper diverts the left signal to Aux 1 and Aux 3 and the right signal to Aux 2 and Aux 4. After some scrutiny of the diagram I found the jumper on the inner board of the master section hiding under two capacitors. Reaching it from the side is impossible due to the protruding hinge of the Pod, and I'm not sure how anyone would be able to see the position of the jumper clearly without taking the mixer apart. Moving this jumper shouldn't be attempted without some needle-nosed pliers and one of those mirrors on a stem used by dentists for studying the back of someone's teeth!
Internal Effects As mentioned above, the Mix Wizard offers its own internal effects processor which works in Single FX or Dual FX modes depending on the status of a small blue recessed switch under the aux master controls. In Single FX mode, there are 16 effects available, split into two banks of eight. Of the sixteen, half are file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Allen%20&%20Heath%20WZ316%202.htm (7 of 10)9/26/2005 8:17:22 AM
Allen & Heath WZ316:2
reverb variations, while the rest are a selection of delays, choruses, and combination effects. In Dual FX mode, the first eight effects, which are mostly reverbs, are fed from Aux 5, leaving the second batch of reverbs, delays, choruses, and phasing effects to Aux 6. Annoyingly, the only way to turn the internal effects off is by scrolling to an 'off' position at the end of the effects bank. More irritating still, the effects turn themselves on every time you change between Single FX and Dual FX mode. The ST1/FX Mute button does mute the effects, as does a pedal switch, but it also mutes any external effects signal input via the ST1 jacks. Why not include a switch for just the internal effects for when only external effects are required? The internal set of reverbs and ambience settings are well chosen, and balancing the channel send with the master aux return level provides enough control for most applications. According to Allen & Heath's chief designer, the factory presets were chosen to 'provide general-purpose reverbs and delays as a starting point for live mixing'. However, ironically, their emulations of live acoustic spaces actually make them quite useful for adding a live effect to studio recordings! The delays are more problematic, however, as there is no way to adjust delay time without using software. Should you wish to edit the delay time, the internal effects parameters can be accessed by hooking the mixer up to a sequencer's MIDI port and then using Allen & Heath's freely downloadable software (available on their web site) to do so. There can't be too many live engineers who will want to have on their mixer hooked up to a PC just to tweak effects, although someone with a MIDI-enabled laptop could easily do so. Studio musicians might be a little more accommodating, but I really can't see why anyone should have to resort to using computer software to operate a stand-alone piece of hardware such as this. Way back in 1998 I used a Studiomaster Vision 8 powered mixer for a series of live gigs. Its effects section offered memory options, EQ, and, most importantly of all, it had a fader allowing the immediate adjustment of the effect's delay time. Even though the Mix Wizard has no room for such a fader, delay time could still be controlled via a hardware tap-tempo button, as found on numerous effects processors. In terms of sound quality, the internal effects are comparable to those in my respectable Lexicon MPX100, which I ran through the ST1 input during testing. In fact, the algorithms are the same Digitech-supplied ones as used in the previous DX model, although Allen & Heath say that the WZ316:2's improved hardware and converter circuits make better use of the effects than before.
In Conclusion After looking closely at this product and studying the manual, I really get the feeling that Allen & Heath have aimed the Mix Wizard at the live market first and the studio market second. Nevertheless, the WZ316:2 is the sort of hardware a file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Allen%20&%20Heath%20WZ316%202.htm (8 of 10)9/26/2005 8:17:22 AM
Allen & Heath WZ316:2
lot of project studio owners still desire. Even though just about all digital workstations have their own preamps and mixers, and computer sequencers all come with mixing facilities as standard, many people will want to use the Mix Wizard's low-noise preamps and EQ as a front end for their digital recorders, or before sending signals to their computer soundcards. The sixteen direct outputs make this eminently possible, and having inserts on all the channels also allows analogue compressors or gates to be inserted into the signal path. This is particularly desirable when recording a large drum kit, for example. Others may choose to use the WZ3 for mixdown, inserting a mastering compressor into the main LR channels. The internal effects are disappointing in their implementation, even though their actual sound quality is fine. Allen & Heath were clearly running out of frontpanel space with the rack design, but offering editing via a computer seems like a cop-out. The strength of such a piece of hardware lies in its independence from computer software, and the addition of just a few controls would allow the WZ3 to stand strong on its own. With so many customisation options and such an array of input and output options, the WZ316:2 is extremely flexible. Even without the jumpers, there are enough well-chosen front-panel adjustments to be getting on with. For example, the combination of AB and 'M' outputs, ST1 and ST2 inputs, and the various switching options allow the mixer's facilities to be divided up and used in quite a number of ways. Having so many options means that the WZ316:2 can be adapted to suit the needs of a developing studio or venue, and the Sys-Link II option offers the potential for expanding the system in the future. Inevitably, some people will flinch at the price, and point out that there are other mixers in the UK market with a roughly similar collection of basic features selling for a lot less — Soundcraft, Mackie, and Behringer all offer such products, for example. However, at the end of the day, with an Allen & Heath mixer you get what you pay for. I'm sure the company could knock a lot off the price of this mixer if they just used one large circuit board for all the channels' circuitry and control knobs, and mounted it parallel with the control surface — that is certainly what some cheaper mixers look like inside. But the WZ316:2 has a separate board for each channel and instead of having the control knobs mounted on the circuit board so that they poke through the mixer's metalwork, all the controls are firmly bolted to the front panel. Any knocks the controls receive will be taken by the metal casing and won't flex the more fragile circuit boards. In fact, wiggling the pots reveals that they have hardly any play compared to circuit-board-fixed pots which tend to flex like joysticks!
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Allen%20&%20Heath%20WZ316%202.htm (9 of 10)9/26/2005 8:17:22 AM
Allen & Heath WZ316:2
It's nice to know that if you decide to keep the mixer for many years, noisy pots and faders can be replaced one channel at a time, rather than having to replace the whole board. In that respect, the 16:2 is best thought of as 16 channel strips plus a master section, and in those terms the asking price doesn't sound unreasonable at all. Published in SOS November 2004 Sound On Sound, Media House, Trafalgar Way, Bar Hill, Cambridge CB3 8SQ, UK. Email:
[email protected] | Telephone: +44 (0)1954 789888 | Fax: +44 (0)1954 789895
All contents copyright © SOS Publications Group and/or its licensors, 1985-2005. All rights reserved. The contents of this article are subject to worldwide copyright protection and reproduction in whole or part, whether mechanical or electronic, is expressly forbidden without the prior written consent of the Publishers. Great care has been taken to ensure accuracy in the preparation of this article but neither Sound On Sound Limited nor the publishers can be held responsible for its contents. The views expressed are those of the contributors and not necessarily those of the publishers. Web site designed & maintained by PB Associates | SOS | Relative Media
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Allen%20&%20Heath%20WZ316%202.htm (10 of 10)9/26/2005 8:17:22 AM
Apple Logic Pro 7
In this article:
Apple Pie Order Logic Pro 7 Main Features Join The Network Compensation Delayed Plug-Ins Apple Loops Effective? First Use Final Analysis
information Pricing to be confirmed. Sound Technology +44 (0)1462 480000. +44 (0)1462 480800. Click here to email www.soundtech.co.uk
Apple Logic Pro 7 PREVIEW: MIDI + Audio Sequencer (Mac OS X) Published in SOS November 2004 Print article : Close window
Reviews : Software
When Apple bought Emagic two years ago, the question on everyone's lips was 'What will they do with Logic?' Now they've unveiled perhaps the most radical overhaul the sequencer has ever seen, with improvements ranging from new instruments and effects to a networking system that could eliminate CPU restrictions completely.
www.emagic.de
Paul White
Because of Apple's policy of not announcing products or upgrades until they are very close to shipping, Logic Pro 7 will probably already be in the shops by the time you read this feature, written after a flying visit to Hamburg for a pre-launch preview followed by a couple of days' opportunity to play with the software for myself. A full review will follow next month when I've had a chance to use the program in anger, but in the meantime, I've learned enough to offer this detailed exclusive preview. Some elements may be subject to change at the last minute, but if all goes to plan, the release version will be on sale by the end of September or very early in October. Logic has retained backwards compatibility with Mac OS 9 for longer than most applications, but version 7 will be the first to support OS X only. With its distinctive new Apple-style packaging, Logic Pro 7 is without doubt the biggest overhaul Logic has ever seen. Emagic's office in Hamburg still operates under the Emagic name, but that name is no longer on the Logic box, and the fact that Logic Pro is now an Apple product has been made very clear. Apple's strategy is to slot Logic Pro into their existing range of high-end media applications such as Final Cut Pro, and to this end, they've tidied up certain file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Apple%20Logic%20Pro%A07.htm (1 of 12)9/26/2005 8:17:25 AM
Apple Logic Pro 7
visual aspects of the program using what can best be described as Apple's house style. Any suggestions that Logic Pro is being dumbed down to make it more of a consumer product are firmly dispelled by the direction Logic 7 is taking, though not surprisingly, Apple have aimed for a greater degree of compatibility and file interchangeability with their other media software. Inevitably, there are new features, new plug-ins and improvements to existing features, but there are also some welcome surprises, not least being the inclusion of the Waveburner CD-writing application. In fact the leap from Pro 6 to Pro 7 is so significant that it's difficult to know where to start.
Apple Pie Order Visually, the program is quite clearly still the Logic Pro we all know and love, yet it has benefited from a significant degree of 'Appleisation' most evident in the Arrange window, the menus and the preference panes, with the result that these items are much better organised and clearer to read. This facelift also extends to the score window, where the original bitmapped fonts have been replaced by scaleable, smoothed fonts for a more professional look when printed. Under the hood, the Apple Loops audio engine employed in Garage Band has been integrated into Logic Pro, offering a load of new features for working with loopbased music: for instance, the standard Logic region-looping facility is retained alongside the one used in Garage Band where loops are created by dragging from the end of an original audio region to the desired location. The Arrange, Matrix, Hyper Edit and Score Edit windows have also gained an extra section called Global Tracks where the user has graphical control over tempo, key and time signatures, markers, and more. It is also now where imported video can be shown on a timeline with the automatic detection and display of scene changes. Tempo can now be managed using an editable 'line' in very much the same way as other track automation functions. You'll also find a new Chord Track that maintains what Apple call a 'harmonic map' of the song's MIDI parts. This can be constructed manually or extracted from MIDI parts, and allows global harmonic changes to be made very easily. Any compatible Apple Loops will follow chord changes incorporated into the Chord Track. Where an arrangement contains conventional audio parts, these won't be altered when a tempo change or harmonic change is added, although it is apparently possible to convert standard audio recordings into Apple Loops, after which they can be manipulated freely in both pitch and tempo.
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Apple%20Logic%20Pro%A07.htm (2 of 12)9/26/2005 8:17:25 AM
Apple Logic Pro 7
A Transpose Track controls conventional 'root note' transposition and is linked with the Chord Track so that making changes in either one results in the correct change to the MIDI and Apple Loop data. The Signature Track displays both time and key signatures, and this is also linked to the processing of Apple Loops. To conserve screen space the Global Track, which is normally at the top of the Arrange window's working area, may be hidden when not required, but from what I've seen, its video thumbnail features in particular will be welcomed by anyone who does sound-to-picture work as it includes handy automatic options, such as the ability to create markers to denote scene changes and tempo tools to help match visual and musical hit points. Logic's new-found compatibility with Garage Band goes much further than allowing the use of Apple Loops, as entire Garage Band songs can now be imported. Apparently many serious musicians have been using Garage Band as an ideas scratchpad for writing songs on the move and viewed the lack of compatibility as as a gaping hole in Apple's strategy. As well as providing a logical upgrade path for Garage Band users, Logic Pro now supports XML import and export, making it easier to move material between Logic and applications such as Final Cut Pro. Quicktime movie soundtracks can also be imported or exported, and Logic Pro has also been upgraded to handle AAC Audio (Advanced Audio Coding) making it possible to provide multi-channel support with the benefits of a data compression system that is technically superior to MP3. AAC is already used by many Internet radio stations and digital broadcast facilities and is supported by iTunes, which in turn means songs can be transferred to an iPod in this format.
Logic Pro 7 Main Features New networking system enables additional computers to share the CPU load. New plug-ins including the Sculpture and Ultrabeat instruments and Guitar Amp Pro amp modeller. New Shuffle, multiple Snap and Crossfade audio edit modes. 34 software instruments including all the Garage Band collection. Over 70 plug-in effects and processors. Save and load of channel strip configurations. Up to 255 stereo audio tracks. Up to 128 software instrument tracks. Up to 64 busses and 64 aux channels. Up to 15 inserts and 8 aux sends per channel. New controller learn mode. Offline bouncing of single or multiple tracks. Support for Apple Loops.
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Apple%20Logic%20Pro%A07.htm (3 of 12)9/26/2005 8:17:25 AM
Apple Logic Pro 7
Can import Garage Band songs.
* Final Cut/XML, AAF, OMF and Open TTL file import and export. AAC and MP3 import and export.
Join The Network Perhaps the biggest single new feature in Logic Pro 7 is that it now provides a way to use additional computers to share the processing load. This really needs G5s to work effectively and operates over high-speed Ethernet using the TCP protocol, where the additional computers function as networked nodes. The documentation suggests that connection over Firewire will also be possible, although apparently this is not the best choice, as the Firewire bandwidth is lower than Gigabit Ethernet and has to be shared with any Firewire interfaces or hard drives that are also in use. Where more than one node (additional computer) is connected, the network switcher used must be able to offer a bandwidth of at least one Gigabit, enabling it to handle up to 128 simultaneous stereo tracks to and from the node system. Logic Node, as the system is called, requires OS 10.3 or later, with the host machine being a G4 or later and the nodes ideally being The main Logic windows, such as the Arrange page, are familiar from previous G5s. The necessary node software versions, but have benefited from Apple's comes with Logic Pro 7, no additional graphical makeover. XS Keys are needed and Logic Pro only needs to be installed on the master machine. I asked about the latency implications of using a system like this and was told that there are certain latency penalties for real-time instrument tracks running on nodes, but you can switch tracks from the host processor to node processing at the touch of a Track Node button so this isn't really an obstacle. All you need to do is ensure that a software instrument is running on the host machine when you are recording its part and you'll have no more latency than normal. Once the part has been recorded, you can switch it to run on a node for future playback. According to Apple, the use of TCP means that as faster networking technologies become available, the increased bandwidth will support more simultaneous audio channels. I saw this running with a G4 laptop as the master machine and a G5 as the node and it worked seamlessly. Of course if you don't have extra computers, there's always the existing track Freeze button, and one recurring user request was for a way to make Frozen tracks permanent. This hasn't been implemented quite as expected, but a Total Track Bounce mode can be used to render all the audio and software instrument tracks to permanent audio files. There's also a new External Instruments I/O plugin for feeding hardware instruments into the mix, although it's not yet possible to file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Apple%20Logic%20Pro%A07.htm (4 of 12)9/26/2005 8:17:25 AM
Apple Logic Pro 7
bounce these tracks like software instrument tracks.
Compensation Delayed Several criticisms have, in the past, been levelled at the audio capabilities of Logic, not least the ease with which audio can be edited, the absence of sampleaccurate audio editing in the Arrange page and the lack of plug-in delay compensation in audio paths other than the main tracks. Apple are aware of the need to provide comprehensive plug-in delay compensation but have chosen not to prioritise it for this release; nor have they addressed the sample-accuracy editing issue. The latter doesn't bother me too much, but I'm surprised that the plug-in delay compensation issue hasn't been resolved as it impacts on the way that plug-ins can be deployed in audio Objects other than tracks. However, they have weighed in with some long-overdue and very useful new Arrange window editing modes, specifically Shuffle, multiple Snap and Crossfade. Shuffle lets you seamless stack regions without gaps or overlaps in a similar way to Pro Tools, but goes one better by offering separate Shuffle Left and Right modes, while the Snap menu provides the option to snap regions to a user-definable time grid. Crossfade creates an automatic crossfade when two audio regions are overlapped by dragging one over the other. Several other workflow enhancements have been added, including the one that was right at the top of my list — you can now start a new song as a Project rather than simply being able to save it as a Project afterwards. All imported media can be automatically Amongst other improvements, the Track moved or copied into the newly created Mixer now allows you to store and load channel strip settings, including multiple Project folder as the work progresses so you can be confident that everything instrument and effects plug-ins. the song needs is in the same place. The Project Manager has also been tidied up with a new, clean Apple look and speedier operation. Another nice touch is the addition of Templates, which are conceptually similar having to multiple Autoload songs, each customised for different tasks. Here you can create different default setups for the different types of jobs you do and then call up the optimum one when you start a fresh project. Furthermore, you can now create the desired number of audio tracks, instrument tracks and so on from a setup dialogue box rather than having to manually change the Logic Environment and Arrange page. Where there aren't sufficient audio Objects already available in the Environment, appropriate new ones will be created automatically as you specify the number you need. From within the Track Mixer or the Channel Strip in the Arrange window, you can now load and save complete channel strip settings — this is another feature many users have been asking for, and means that you can now recall complex setups involving multiple
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Apple%20Logic%20Pro%A07.htm (5 of 12)9/26/2005 8:17:25 AM
Apple Logic Pro 7
plug-ins and instruments from a simple menu, with over 450 instrument and audio channel strip presets supplied. Multiple Objects may be selected and their routing edited simultaneously, which is another great time-saver, and each track now has its own Solo button. However, the niggles with the Auto Track Zoom function have not yet been addressed, though they are apparently on the list. My main gripe here is that when this function is active, the track zooms whether selected in the main 'working' part of the Arrange window or within the track header section at the left of the window. Zooming when you click in the track header is fine, but because zooming also occurs when you're in the main part of the Arrange page, tracks have a habit of jumping around when you're trying to edit them, and if the automation is visible, you end up grabbing the automation when you were trying to edit the object length or position. Giving the user the option to have this work only when clicking in the track header would make far more sense to me. A further welcome time-saver is that the Finder menu can now be accessed directly from within the Audio window so that you can browse audio files on various drives, while a new Audio Window Groups function has been introduced to allow you to organise audio files into logical groups for easier handling. Multiple undo has been extended to the Sample Edit window The new physical modelling Sculpture instrument. and new keyboard features accessible via the Caps Lock key have been introduced to allow note and velocity information to be input from a QWERTY keyboard — handy for songwriting on the train! While on the subject of convenience, Logic Pro is now easier to set up for use with external MIDI control devices, such as controller keyboards with MIDI controller knobs or faders. This has been achieved by adding an easy-to-use MIDI learn feature where you select the on-screen parameter you wish to control, then twiddle the physical control you wish to assign to it to make the connection. The Logic 6 limitation of 128 MIDI-controllable parameters per track has now been lifted, and the controller learning features will work with third-party plug-ins as well as Logic's own instruments and effects.
Plug-Ins If the number of augmentations in the look, feel and general capability of Logic Pro seems generous, what's happened in the plug-in department is staggering. Logic Pro now ships with some 34 software instruments and over 70 effect/ processor plug-ins, some of which are incredibly sophisticated. At Winter NAMM earlier this year, we got a sneak preview of Sculpture, a physical modelling synth that can emulate the vibrational modes of strings and pipes, then manipulate and
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Apple%20Logic%20Pro%A07.htm (6 of 12)9/26/2005 8:17:25 AM
Apple Logic Pro 7
morph them in a number of ways to provide both organic-sounding instruments and some incredible abstract creations that span all musical genres, from cuttingedge dance to ambient and pop. A central panel allows the user to move between different materials from which the modelled vibrating components are made, while the Exciters section determines how the sound is initiated — bowed, picked, struck, blown or whatever. Up to three Exciters can be combined along with other parameters that disturb the vibration in a variety of natural and unnatural ways. It has to be worth upgrading just to get your hands on Sculpture — but there's more! We were also given a glimpse of Ultrabeat at the Winter NAMM show; this synthetic drumsound generator combines analogue-style synthesis, FM, sample playback and component modelling to offer the most amazing range of drum and percussion sounds. Each voice provides two oscillators, a noise generator and a ring modulator, and you can also use your own drum samples. Up to 24 different voices can be generated simultaneously, while Ultrabeat's beatbox-style internal step sequencer can be triggered from within Logic Pro's Arrange page using MIDI notes, to allow patterns to be changed during the course of a song. The level and gate times can be set for each sequencer step and there are also some handy randomise functions that can be used to add variety to the loops you create. There's also a 25th voice which spans the rest of the keyboard and is used for monosynth and bass sounds.
It might not make any noise of its own, but the Multimeter metering plug-in will nonetheless prove hugely valuable thanks to its sophisticated spectral analysis and phase tools.
Compared to these two heavyweights, EFM1 looks fairly small and simple, but in reality it is a powerful FM synth that is great for creating all the classic 'DX-like' bells, organs and electric piano sounds. It's also possible to deliberately overmodulate the oscillators to produce more aggressive effects. If this isn't enough, Logic Pro also comes with the full suite of Garage Band software instruments — if you think about it, it has to have these in order to be able to open and run existing Garage Band songs. The EXS24 sampler has also been updated to allow the drag-and-drop placement of samples in the Edit page — another favourite on the wish-list. Additionally, the previously optional Extreme Analogue and Extreme Digital sample libraries now come as part of the new bundle, along with many new samples and instruments, the total running to some 900 sampler instruments and 3.4GB of samples.
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Apple%20Logic%20Pro%A07.htm (7 of 12)9/26/2005 8:17:25 AM
Apple Logic Pro 7
Apple Loops Apple Loops are a special type of audio file used by Soundtrack and Garage Band as well as Logic 7. As well as the audio data, Apple Loops also contain metadata, enabling them to be pitch-shifted or time-stretched over a fairly wide range with the minimum of side-effects. The metadata also includes 'tag' information describing the loops' genre, instrumentation and so on, allowing you to search for loops that meet particular criteria. Some Apple Loops contain both the audio and MIDI versions of the file, so that the performance can be recreated using a software instrument rather than just the original audio. Now that Logic Pro supports Apple Loops, all Garage Band and Soundtrack loop packs can be used directly from within Logic, as can any of the third-party offerings in that format. Apple are actively encouraging third-party development of material in this format so the range seems certain to increase significantly in the future. Apple have recently announced two more titles to be added to their Garage Band Jam Pack — one aimed at the dance music composer and one offering a mix of generalpurpose pop and rock material.
Effective? The additions to the effects and processor plug-in armoury are no less dramatic. Guitar Amp Pro is a new take on the amp/speaker modelling familiar to guitar players everywhere and allows the user to combine amplifers, EQ sections and speakers from a range of different models. There are also reverb and tremolo effects based on convolution technology for the greatest degree of realism, and early listening experiences were very encouraging. It's also possible to use some or all of the components of Guitar Amp Pro for re-amping existing recordings or for processing synthesized sounds. Next up comes Ringshifter, which despite the name isn't a description of the aftereffects of a particularly piquant chicken Jalfrezi! This effects plug-in combines ring modulation with frequency-shifting and is generally useful for turning tame musical sounds into clangorous mayhem. You can also use it in a more genteel way to create phasing or chorus effects. Beside it in the 'take a perfectly good sound and bugger it up good and proper' category is the new Vocal Transformer which can create robot voices, formant-shifted cartoon mice and so forth. Go on, you know you want to! As if by way of apology for what the above-mentioned plug-ins are capable of doing to your sound, the next very welcome inclusion is Pitch Correction. Like most of the other intonation-correction plug-ins doing the rounds, this can nudge imperfect vocal or instrumental recordings on to the correct pitch. A piano keyboard display allows you to set up the notes in the scale you wish to use as your correction template and the correction rate is variable, so you use medium to slow correction for a natural-sounding result or fast correction for that cliched 'not unlike Cher' vocal effect. The information I have on this makes no mention of a real-time MIDI-controlled correction mode, but as with all Logic plug-ins, the
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Apple%20Logic%20Pro%A07.htm (8 of 12)9/26/2005 8:17:25 AM
Apple Logic Pro 7
parameters can be automated using Logic's track automation. Logic's channel EQ now has a Linear Phase counterpart that offers the same functionality — you can even copy EQ settings between the conventional and Linear Phase versions — but without introducing the phase shifts normally associated with most equaliser designs. Real analogue equalisers Ultrabeat is a powerful percussion always introduce phase shifts, and this synthesizer with its own pattern sequencer. is part of their sonic charm, but on some material the surgical clarity of a zero-phase EQ can be a useful alternative. Inevitably, this type of filter has a fairly large inherent processing delay so this EQ is best used after recording rather than while tracking. A nice addition, but not as dramatic as Match EQ. Match EQ is Logic's take on the now-familiar fingerprint equaliser, which allows the audio spectrum of one signal to be imposed upon another. In essence, the filter 'learns' a section of reference audio which is then copied over to the plug-in in the target audio track. Match EQ then computes a multi-band filter to match the audio spectrum of the target piece to that of the reference. This can be used to match the characteristics of recordings made in different rooms or with different mics, and it can also be useful in processing whole mixes to make them sound tonally similar to a reference mix. A number of simple tools are available to vary the depth of processing imparted and in the examples I heard, the results were very impressive. As with any fingerprint EQ of this type, when you're matching the tonality of mixes, the target and reference pieces need to be of a similar musical style and they should ideally have similar instrumentation, otherwise the end result can be rather unpredictable. Good fingerprint EQ plugins can be quite costly, so having one thrown in for the price of an upgrade is amazing value. The next plug-in is neither effect nor processor but rather a very sophisticated meter. Multimeter incorporates a third-octave spectrum analyser, a precision level meter with a log scale, a stereo correlation meter to show up phase problems and, my favourite, a goniometer to show the signal's stereo phase and balance on a single display. Hardware meters of this kind can cost as much as Logic Pro plus the Mac you run it on, so getting one bundled is a real bonus. There are more plug-ins that I don't have space to cover here, but one long overdue feature that has been added is the ability to link plug-in windows to the Arrange window, so that when you change tracks, you see the plug-in associated with that track. Where multiple plug-ins are being used in a track, the topmost one is shown. A final welcome surprise is that Emagic's Waveburner CD-writing application has now been incorporated into Logic, although I didn't get to see it in action.
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Apple%20Logic%20Pro%A07.htm (9 of 12)9/26/2005 8:17:25 AM
Apple Logic Pro 7
First Use Having had just a few hours so far to explore Logic Pro 7 for myself, I have discovered some interesting little tweaks and tucks such as the replacement of telescope zoom buttons by sliders that quickly scale the zoom value to whatever you need. However, the track icon list hasn't had any new additions and it is now accessed via an interminable list rather than a nice clear panel, so that's a step back in my view. There's also a reassuring AU checking program that examines all your non-Emagic AU plug-ins for compatibility so as to avoid stability problems. Normally this only happens when you install Logic Pro or add new plug-ins, so it allows Logic Pro to open much more quickly under normal circumstances. You can still use plug-ins that it rejects if you add them to the list yourself, but they appear in a category called 'Incompatible'. Unfortunately, all my Waves, Spectrasonics, Native Instruments and Powercore plug-ins crashed the AU checker or failed some aspect of the test, but when I ticked them anyway, they worked fine. A test info window indicates that the failure may be due to not opening in a specific period of time, though why this should cause problems I'm not sure. My Korg Legacy Collection, which is the latest version, was also flagged as failed, but this too worked fine. Ironically, one of Apple's own AU plug-ins was failed too! This is, however, a great feature and when it has been improved to prevent it crashing out when it sees something it doesn't want to deal with, it will be even better. One very welcome surprise is that Space Designer has suddenly acquired a huge library of reverb presets that completely dwarfs the original and that includes all the interesting rooms and concert halls that the original lacked. Logic Pro and its songs also have a new icon so there's no chance of confusing Logic songs with Quicktime files as there was in the past. Yet another nice feature is the way the channel strip is displayed on the Arrange page. This part of the screen has been redesigned to allow the whole channel strip to be viewed on smaller monitors and if it still won't fit or if you resize the Arrange window height, the top of the channel strip 'slides under' the boxes above it so that you can still leave the all-important fader poking out.
Final Analysis Inevitably, any major software update is a balancing act between adding new features to wow the marketplace and fixing problems or shortcomings to satisfy the existing user. Logic Pro 7 has its share of both, though there are some important issues that I feel are fundamental to a professional audio application that still haven't been addressed, so I can only hope these are planned for the next revision. Most serious is the lack of proper plug-in delay compensation for all audio paths, while I still don't feel that Logic has particularly good limiter or denoising plug-ins, and it's a shame that Apple haven't followed MOTU's lead in supporting multiple audio interfaces simultaneously under Core Audio. However, most of what I've seen is very good news for the user. In my view, the excellent plug-ins that came with Logic Pro version 6 made it the best value of all the MIDI + Audio packages out there but in the plug-in file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Apple%20Logic%20Pro%A07.htm (10 of 12)9/26/2005 8:17:25 AM
Apple Logic Pro 7
department, version 7 is better than Christmas! In fact there are so many great plug-ins now included as standard that some of the third-party plug-in designers are going to have to work very hard in order to tempt the Logic Pro user to spend more money. (Speaking of pricing, no UK prices had been set when we went to press, but Apple had confirmed that US pricing would be unchanged.) The ability to eliminate restrictions on processing power without the use of dedicated DSP hardware, by networking one or more extra G5s, will also be a killer feature for power users The Space Designer convolution reverb who need to run lots of instruments — now includes an extensive new library of especially as you won't need to shell out presets. for extra copies of Logic to run on the other machines. The streamlining and general makeover is well thought out, and finally I get my wish of being able to start a song as a Project. By way of ease of use, the improved setup assistant plus the ability to store numerous different templates makes a lot of sense, as does the integration with Garage Band that allows Logic to import and play back Garage Band songs with all their original instruments. And, of course, there's the usual welter of more minor improvements — one that stands out to me is the provision of a discrete level control for the Centre channel in surround mixes. Logic Express users also benefit, with more plug-ins (37 in total) including Guitar Amp, Channel EQ and Platinumverb. The software instrument total in Logic Express rises to a generous 18, you get the same 1000 Apple Loops as are bundled with Logic Pro 7, and again Garage Band songs can be imported. Apple have a reputation for launching software that is stable from the first incarnation: if a feature can't be made reliable, then it gets left out until it is fixed. I'm told this philosophy is also being applied to Logic Pro, which may account for why some of the popular items on the wish-list aren't yet implemented. However, Apple have been reviewing all of the suggestions you sent in via Logic Notes and they have conveyed their thanks. They tell me that around half of the points that regularly arise have already been addressed in Logic Pro 7 and inevitably more will follow. Published in SOS November 2004
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Apple%20Logic%20Pro%A07.htm (11 of 12)9/26/2005 8:17:25 AM
Apple Logic Pro 7
Sound On Sound, Media House, Trafalgar Way, Bar Hill, Cambridge CB3 8SQ, UK. Email:
[email protected] | Telephone: +44 (0)1954 789888 | Fax: +44 (0)1954 789895
All contents copyright © SOS Publications Group and/or its licensors, 1985-2005. All rights reserved. The contents of this article are subject to worldwide copyright protection and reproduction in whole or part, whether mechanical or electronic, is expressly forbidden without the prior written consent of the Publishers. Great care has been taken to ensure accuracy in the preparation of this article but neither Sound On Sound Limited nor the publishers can be held responsible for its contents. The views expressed are those of the contributors and not necessarily those of the publishers. Web site designed & maintained by PB Associates | SOS | Relative Media
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Apple%20Logic%20Pro%A07.htm (12 of 12)9/26/2005 8:17:25 AM
Cakewalk Kinetic
In this article:
What's It All About? Getting Closer System Requirements PSyn In Depth Effects Groovesynth & Groove Player Engine Conclusions
Cakewalk Kinetic £99 pros Easy to use. Almost worth the asking price for PSyn alone. Comprehensive effects capabilities. Free Roland Groovebox in software! Full and easy automation.
Cakewalk Kinetic PC Software Studio Published in SOS November 2004 Print article : Close window
Reviews : Software
With pattern-based sequencing, plenty of presets and a powerful analogue-style synth, Cakewalk's affordable soft studio package could be a valuable compositional tool. Derek Johnson
It would be really easy to think of Kinetic, Cakewalk's new loop-based software studio, as a cut-down version of their established Project 5 (see SOS June 2003 cons or read the review on-line at www.soundonsound.com/sos/jun03/articles/ PC-only (as are, to be fair, all Cakewalk products). cakewalkproject5.asp). True, it borrows a couple of features and has some Would like more background effects processing in common, but in releasing the new sub-£100 product, and user tips for PSyn. Cakewalk are aiming for a different market. Quick edit knob assignment doesn't work as advertised.
Initially, the target would appear to be unschooled music enthusiasts who might get a kick out of mixing and matching the hundreds of MIDI and audio loops that In limiting, somewhat, the are bundled with Kinetic. But Cakewalk are craftier than that. The software might choices available in Kinetic, be marketed as a fast and easy way for anyone to create electronic music on Cakewalk have actually their PC — and Kinetic is PC-only — but its life doesn't end at recycling the liberated the user. There is plenty here to entertain the (admittedly good) preset loops. Cakewalk's own marketing says "even if you newcomer or casual computer have no musical background, it's a snap to get started making tracks", but if you musician, but there is want to go further, or if you don't want to use the factory material at all, Kinetic surprising depth to those who will still oblige. wish to explore more deeply
summary
— not bad for £99, three sound modules and a handful of effects!
information £99 including VAT. Edirol Europe +44 (0) 870 350 1515. +44 (0)20 8747 5948. www.edirol.co.uk www.cakewalk.com
What's It All About? Integration is the name of Kinetic's game. Pattern-based sequencing, sound creation, effects processing, mixing and automation are all pretty much available on one level. There are also limits to what the software offers and to what it will do, but these limits, combined with the integration, result in a comfortable, easily comprehensible composition and sound-design environment. And that
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Cakewalk%20Kinetic.htm (1 of 8)9/26/2005 8:17:28 AM
Cakewalk Kinetic
Test Spec Cakewalk Kinetic v1.0.0.44. PC with 3.06GHz Pentium 4 and 512MB RAM, running Windows XP.
environment is expandable: Kinetic is compatible with most Direct X plug-in effects, and will function as a Rewire slave in a similarly equipped host application. One of the limits of the software appears to be, initially, in the soundgeneration department. There are two synths on board, plus the Groove Kinetic's main, and only, screen, in its Edit All mode. The drum pattern illustrated in the Player Engine, which plays back WAV middle is shown in Advanced Editor mode, or Acid-format audio files (the latter and shows velocity data as shaded columns capable of following tempo changes). behind drum hits. One synth, PSyn, is a fine modelling analogue synth inherited from Project 5. Groovesynth is the other, amazingly providing the sampled sonic guts of a Roland Groovebox instrument — fruit, no doubt, of Roland's 'interest' in Cakewalk, and their development work together. Groovesynth, which appears to be roughly equivalent to an MC303, comes equipped with 400 patches (238 Groovebox MIDI loops are also on board), and is the source of Kinetic's drum sounds. When a drum kit is selected, Groovesynth even changes colour! Trying to tweeze apart Kinetic's elements is an interesting process, and it's hard to know where to start. First of all, we have to adopt Cakewalk's nomenclature; like it or not, we're going to hear the word 'Groove' a lot. For Cakewalk, a Groove is what most of us call a pattern. A Kinetic Song is equipped with 64 Grooves, arranged in four banks of 16, selected by the Groove Picker matrix at the top left of the screen, right beside the Groove Mixer. Patterns do have a place in Kinetic, but here they're the MIDI data or audio files played by one of the 16 Parts that make up a Groove. Thus, Kinetic can be seen as having a 16-channel mixer, a 16-track sequencer, and a 16-part sound generator, all fully integrated. Though, as I said, the software comes with a lot of ready-to-wear Patterns, it's easy enough to create your own, either This Edit All view shows an audio file — and in step or real time. As well as notes, Acidised drum loop — in the middle display, played by the Groove Player Engine. It has automation and controller data can be no further editing parameters, though it can recorded into Patterns. There is no effective limit to a Pattern's length, and be treated to a chain of effects which can be edited and automated. Patterns of different lengths can be mixed within one Groove; shorter Patterns simply keep looping while the longer ones finish playing and loop themselves. Thus, even within a Groove, it would, for example, be possible to create a simple four-bar loop backing and record a long-form part over the top using a Pattern that's 32 bars long.
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Cakewalk%20Kinetic.htm (2 of 8)9/26/2005 8:17:28 AM
Cakewalk Kinetic
In order to create a finished track, Grooves are chained in the Song Arranger, which runs across the bottom of the main screen. This is a straightforward process, and it's possible to record and manipulate automation data over the top of the chain; notes, however, can't be overdubbed here.
Getting Closer Now let's start looking at Kinetic in detail. Though I'll be talking about individual bits of the program, it's worth always remembering that a Part — a single track, if you like — consists of a Groove Mixer channel, a sound source, effects, MIDI or audio data and automation. They cannot be separated. Starting at the top, we have the Groove Mixer and Groove Picker. The latter is used to choose a Groove for playback, and also houses the Groove transport controls — there is a dedicated transport for the Song Arranger. Song tempo, swing level and Groove position (in beats) are also displayed here. There is no on-screen time signature parameter, but this can be changed (between 1/8 and 99/32!) under the Edit menu.
Kinetic's secret weapon, PSyn is worth the price of admission alone, offering detailed sound design and a rich and authentically analogue sound. It then goes over the edge into a noughties groove, with comprehensive modulation and full remote control of all parameters.
Clicking in a Groove Mixer channel selects one of 16 Parts for editing. What is visible in the large space in the middle of the display depends on which Part Editor button you've clicked in the side bar to the left of the main screen. The buttons are labelled:
Choose Pattern & Patch: if you want to work with the dozens of preset MIDI and audio Patterns, go to this option. The middle screen is divided in two, and in the left half, you can work through a hierarchy of Patterns: select a type, followed by a style, followed by the Pattern itself. If you select an audio loop, the Groove Player Engine is loaded automatically. Choose a MIDI loop, though, and you'll have to go to the Patch Selector window to the right and choose an instrument, together with the Patch it'll play. Again, you navigate a three-tier list, starting with instrument type, musical style and then the Patch itself. At this level, there is no distinction between PSyn and Groovesynth: you simply choose the Patch you want based on the hierarchy's criteria. In the upper right of both windows, there are tiny icons. In the Pattern selector, these allow you to open a new Pattern from anywhere on your hard drive (and it's with this icon that you load your own WAV files, confusingly), create a new Pattern, and save your own Patterns for use later. Likewise, the Patch selector
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Cakewalk%20Kinetic.htm (3 of 8)9/26/2005 8:17:28 AM
Cakewalk Kinetic
allows you to save your own Patches. Edit Pattern: The middle screen now turns into a large Pattern editor, with 'Step' and 'Advanced' (real-time) options; Advanced presents the display in terms of bars and beats. Notes can be manually input or recorded via MIDI here, in either mode, and automation can also be drawn in. Volume, pan, mute, any MIDI controller and Kinetic instrument The Pattern (left) and Patch (right) selectors, and effect parameters can be easily showing a brief window into the wide variety of material available out of Kinetic's box. handled here, appearing as shaded columns behind the note grid. Painting notes and drawing automation, using dedicated tools, can be a little tricky to get used to, but a little display above the note or drum name column to the left of the grid flashes the current note name or controller value; strangely, it flashes note names even when you're inputting drum hits, when I'd rather expect to see drum names. Step resolution has its own control, and the display can be set to anything between a bar and a 128th note, with dotted and tripled options. The step size never changes in the display, though: you simply have to do a little more scrolling to access all the steps at the finer resolutions. In the Advanced Editor, this step duration control is joined by a snap resolution parameter; it can be disabled so that your performance is not pre-quantised as you record it. An abbreviated Pattern selector is also visible, should you wish to explore different presets. If the currently selected part is an audio loop, then the Pattern Editor window displays that Part's audio file. There's not a lot you can do to the file itself, but mix and effect parameters can be automated here. Edit Patch: The central display becomes somewhat sparse. There's a compact Patch selector display, but the currently selected sound source appears as a little icon, with a handful of 'quick edit' knobs, in a strip across The Roland-inspired Groovesynth, showing the middle of the display dubbed the the layout for a standard voice. Adaptive Controller Pane (ACP) by Cakewalk. According to the documentation, the quick edit knobs are user-definable — you should be able to assign your choice of PSyn or Groovesynth parameters to the knobs. In practice, this facility is missing from the version of Kinetic reviewed. The quick edit knobs can be easily assigned to external MIDI controllers, though. If the current Part is playing a sample, whether Acid format or ordinary WAV, then a Groove Player Panel appears, with no controls. Double-click on PSyn or Groovesynth, however, and a full front panel pops up in a floating window.
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Cakewalk%20Kinetic.htm (4 of 8)9/26/2005 8:17:28 AM
Cakewalk Kinetic
Kinetic's integrated nature is further in evidence here: each Part is equipped with an effect and processing sub-window, called the Audio FX Bin. Simply select effects from the drop-down menu, and they're chained together; a new effect is alway placed in front of the currently selected effect. A little bit of window is given to four parameters for the currently selected effect, but if you double-click on the little box that represents an effect in the chain, an editing window pop-up appears. With the basic Kinetic effects, this may simply show the same four parameters in more accessible form, but some effects show in much more graphic detail. What you see depends on what you've got installed in your system, and which other Cakewalk products you own, since many Direct X plugin effects will be compatible with Kinetic. In the case of the effect quick edit knobs, it is possible to assign any effect parameter to them, for quick customisation. Edit All: With this option, everything appears on screen, often in abbreviated form. But, surprisingly, the result is not crowded or unusable. The overview offered is valuable, and lets you quickly work with Patches and effects while recording or tweaking Patterns and so on. The remainder of the window is given over to the Song Arranger. This is a strange, thin strip across the bottom of the display. It can't be stretched to make editing easier — as mentioned earlier, controller data and automation can be recorded here — but one soon gets used to the situation. The Song Arranger has its own set of tools, plus its own transport bar and location display (bars and beats). A loop can be set in the Song Arranger, either for creative purposes or to cycle a section while overdubbing mix data.
System Requirements Windows 2000 or XP. 800MHz or faster processor. 256MB RAM. 180MB free hard disk space. 16-bit colour monitor with 800 x 600 or better resolution. CD-ROM drive for installation. Windows-compatible soundcard and MIDI interface.
PSyn In Depth PSyn will be familiar to long-term SOS readers as a significant element from within Project 5. It's a four-voice analogue-style synth, capable of up to 64-voice polyphony. It's a highly programmable synth, and is almost as complex as the rest of Kinetic put together. Given Kinetic's Rewire capabilities, one might almost be tempted to suggest that the £99 price tag is worth it for accessing PSyn — in
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Cakewalk%20Kinetic.htm (5 of 8)9/26/2005 8:17:28 AM
Cakewalk Kinetic
fact 16 PSyns at once — from whichever Rewire host you might be using! PSyn is modular in the sense that different parts of the synth can be disabled if not required, and doing so saves on processor overhead. Let's start with the four oscillators. First of all, you have a choice of six Here, a drum kit is being played by waveshapes — sine, triangle, square, Groovesynth. positive and negative sawtooth and noise — with width and phase controls. Comprehensive tuning controls are provided, along with depth controls for EG and LFO. The icing on the cake is that each of these oscillators is equipped with a sub-oscillator! Quite remarkably heavy and rich sounds can be created with just a single oscillator, and multiple-oscillator tricks such as sync, frequency modulation and ring modulation are also offered — at times, you'd hardly believe you were programming a subtractive synth emulation! The synth also comes with a pair of filters, which can be used in serial or parallel; both offer cutoff and resonance controls, but the first is a 12dB/octave device, with high-pass, low-pass, band-reject and band-pass options, while the second is a 24dB/octave low-pass filter. No fewer than five six-stage envelope generators are on board, along with three comprehensive tempo-sync'able LFOs — the same waveform options as provided by the audio oscillators are available here, along with delay, phase, depth and other controls. Comprehensive modulation routing is available, along with a portamento control. And to finish it off, PSyn can store eight banks of 128 presets, independently of Kinetic's own Patch system. A Kinetic Patch, whether for PSyn or Groovesynth, consists of the synth, knob settings, plus effects complement. If there's one thing I could say against PSyn it's that Kinetic's documentation seems a little light on background on the synth. A newcomer wanting to go deeper would be at a bit of a loss, though it has to be said that the 'blindly turning knobs' approach taught me a lot in my early hardware synth days!
Effects I was confused, initially, about what effects were provided with Kinetic, since all the Direct X plug-ins I had in my system showed up as choices — which is good! But basically, the software largely duplicates the set provide with Project 5. The latter's Studioverb 2 is missing, replaced by a much simpler reverb, but the rest is the same. Thus, you find a tempo delay, mod filter, parametric EQ, high-frequency stimulator, compressor/gate, chorus/flanger, plus the nifty Spectra FX, which is missing from P5. The last is a great multi-effects processor with graphic X-Y controller. Quality is good, and editability is often more than what you'd expect. If you're a Sonar user, you may find you have more effects available.
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Cakewalk%20Kinetic.htm (6 of 8)9/26/2005 8:17:28 AM
Cakewalk Kinetic
Groovesynth & Groove Player Engine There's a lot less to say about Groovesynth, as welcome as it is. It's largely preset in that from within the synth, the user can only call up one of the 400 patches. There are a range of parameter offset controls, though, so customisation is possible to a reasonable degree. Filter cutoff frequency and resonance controls are there, along with three-stage envelope, vibrato (LFO), portamento and tuning knobs. Further sound modification is available through the application of 'Character' and three-band EQ. That sums up standard voices. Drums are slightly different. Filter and EQ are provided, but only as global tweaks: making changes affects all sounds in a kit. It is possible to alter the level, pan position and coarse/fine tuning of individual voices within a kit, but I would have liked a little more.
The remarkable SpectraFX is typical, graphically at least, of many of the supplied effects processors. No others, though, feature the excellent X-Y controller. Fully automatable, its moves are animated on Groove or Song playback if the effect is floating above the main Kinetic window.
Like PSyn, Groovesynth is somewhat underdocumented in Kinetic's soft and hard manuals, but the up side is that both benefit from complete automation: simply pop a Pattern into record while the floating synth window is active, and any knob tweaks you make will be recorded into the Pattern. Easy. There's nothing much to say about the Groove Player Engine, since it has no editable parameters. You can easily bring your own audio into the program, to be played by the GPE, but if you want new Acid-format material, you'll need Acid: Kinetic can't process the audio for you. The audio supplied consists solely of drum loops in many styles: it's a good variety, and should keep the casual user happy for quite some time. The supplied MIDI loops are largely drawn from Roland's Groovebox library, and are also very good. If you're not confident of your skills in, say, creating drum patterns, then having a library such as this to hand will both save the day and be quite instructional.
Conclusions I started off with a bad feeling about Kinetic — the packaging and promotional material didn't work for me. But as soon as it was installed, I realised we had something that had more depth than the average loop tracker. The option to use it via a Rewire host opens up more options, and the fact that Direct X plug-ins are compatible means that effects will seldom be a sticking point; VST plug-ins can be used via an optional adaptor. You'd expect to be able to bounce a mix to disk,
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Cakewalk%20Kinetic.htm (7 of 8)9/26/2005 8:17:28 AM
Cakewalk Kinetic
and you can, as a WAV file. MP3 export is available as an option. It's also possible to export individual Grooves, which is a great option for someone like me who quite enjoys messing with loops in a sound-design sort of way; I can always bounce something sonically interesting before I carry on tweaking. The newcomer will find much to entertain them, and any budding DJ will find the preset material to work in a good range of contemporary styles. You will create instant, happening tracks, quickly. But I hope that such users are intrigued enough by the creation process to dig just a little deeper, as there is a very capable, and great-sounding, tool under the surface. Published in SOS November 2004 Sound On Sound, Media House, Trafalgar Way, Bar Hill, Cambridge CB3 8SQ, UK. Email:
[email protected] | Telephone: +44 (0)1954 789888 | Fax: +44 (0)1954 789895
All contents copyright © SOS Publications Group and/or its licensors, 1985-2005. All rights reserved. The contents of this article are subject to worldwide copyright protection and reproduction in whole or part, whether mechanical or electronic, is expressly forbidden without the prior written consent of the Publishers. Great care has been taken to ensure accuracy in the preparation of this article but neither Sound On Sound Limited nor the publishers can be held responsible for its contents. The views expressed are those of the contributors and not necessarily those of the publishers. Web site designed & maintained by PB Associates | SOS | Relative Media
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Cakewalk%20Kinetic.htm (8 of 8)9/26/2005 8:17:28 AM
Fishman Aura
In this article:
Fishman Aura
Design Challenges Acoustic Guitar Preamp Introducing The Acoustic Published in SOS November 2004 Imaging Blender Aura Factory Sound Images Print article : Close window Setting Up Reviews : Preamp Onboard Compression Aura In Action Conclusion
Fishman Aura £399 pros Dramatically improves the sound of under-saddle acoustic guitar pickups. Upgradable via additional FSI files. Custom Sound Images available. Easy to use. Robust and well built.
This digital processing unit promises a whole new level of realism from acoustic guitar pickups. Although primarily aimed at live performance, could it be a serious option for the studio too? Dave Lockwood
Accurately reproducing the sound of an acoustic guitar without using a cons microphone remains one of the great Some Sound Images a little challenges of music technology. There noisy. are good reasons for wanting to do this, Programs can only be saved of course; in live sound there are to their original location. always feedback and separation issues, summary and in a recording situation, using a pickup gives you isolation from If your amplified acoustic suffers from 'piezo quack', the environmental noise, independence Aura really is capable of from the room acoustics, and the ability transforming the sound into to work on speakers rather than headphones when tracking and overdubbing. something far more satisfying and real, but do make sure you try it with an appropriate Sound Image for the guitar you are using or you might wonder what all the fuss is about. This is an important product that signifies the shape of things to come in this market.
information £399 including VAT. FCN Music +44 1892 603730. Click here to email www.fcnmusic.co.uk
Design Challenges One of the major problems facing the designer of any pickup system for acoustic guitar is that the instrument's sound is actually a combination of several elements — the string vibration, the soundboard resonances, the body-cavity resonances — all interacting in complex ways. The two most popular approaches to acoustic pickups, the piezo crystal under-saddle transducer (UST) and the magnetic pickup, have one significant limitation in common in that they both almost exclusively 'hear' the string vibration alone, conveying few or none of the other elements. Piezos are also significantly nonlinear in their output — if you double the input energy, you get about four times the output — resulting in an
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Fishman%20Aura.htm (1 of 9)9/26/2005 8:17:33 AM
Fishman Aura
www.fishmanaura.com
Test Spec Apple G5 dual 2GHz with 1.5GB RAM, running Mac OS 10.3.3. Emagic AMT8 MIDI interface. Fishman Aura Gallery v1.0.
overemphasised note attack and a characteristic brittle harshness often referred to as 'piezo quack'. Magnetic pickups have their own problems, with a more limited frequency and transient response and string-to-string balance issues. No 'quack', but also not quite as much of an inherently 'acoustic' flavour either. Some acoustic pickup designs compensate for the lack of resonance in the sound by incorporating secondary systems, such as onboard mini-mics inside the guitar, blended into either a magnetic or UST output. This is generally more realistic than the primary pickup alone, but is compromised in any situation where feedback is likely, and often sounds rather boxy as well. Other approaches have included using slightly The Aura Gallery software offers a simple microphonic magnetic pickups that are way to organise your Sound Images and able to detect a little of the resonance transfer them as necessary into the memory of the Aura hardware. of the top that they are attached to, or adding auxiliary vibration detectors to key points around the body, bridge plate, or soundboard. In general, the more pickup elements you add, the more sophisticated and real the sound may become, but there is always a trade-off; for instance, at some frequencies parts of the soundboard will be out of phase, causing cancellation, whilst at other frequencies there will be additive summing, and the more contact sensors you add, the more problems you get with handling noise and potentially feedback too. Many of these systems are nevertheless beautifully engineered, highly ingenious solutions, born out of a real insight into the workings of acoustic guitars. The one thing they all have in common, however, is that even the designers themselves probably wouldn't choose to use them if they didn't have to! The fact is, they are the best we've got, so we make do. As players, we become used to bending our technique and learning to 'play the pickup'.
Introducing The Acoustic Imaging Blender One of the most interesting recent developments in this field, however, sidesteps the limitations of conventional pickup systems altogether, using real-time digital processing to achieve the desired result. The Aura Acoustic Imaging Blender, from US-based acoustic-guitar pickup specialists, Fishman Transducers, uses AST (Acoustic Spectral Transform) technology developed (but never marketed) by Akai, to take a known frequency response, say that of an under-saddle piezo transducer on a particular guitar, and transform it in real time into that of a specific microphone pointed at the same guitar. Effectively it's EQ, but very sophisticated multi-band digital EQ along with some phase manipulation within the very narrow individual bands that make up the whole transform. The Aura
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Fishman%20Aura.htm (2 of 9)9/26/2005 8:17:33 AM
Fishman Aura
divides the spectrum between 20Hz and 20kHz into about 2000 bands, each of which may receive individual amplitude and phase adjustment to get to the desired target response. Fishman engineers initially establish the sonic 'signature' of the guitar as heard via its pickup system, exciting the guitar's resonances in every way they can think of and averaging the result. They then record the rather different spectrum as detected by an optimally placed microphone when the same stimuli are applied. The result is a frequency/phase transfer characteristic, or Sound Image, capable of transforming one sound into the other. The concept is not entirely new; 'fingerprint EQ' as it is often referred to, has been available for as long as there have been fast enough computers around to do it, with one of the most successful recent implementations being TC Electronic's Assimilator software for their Powercore co-processor card. The Aura, however, does it in real time in a floor box, and it does it affordably! As soon as you know how the process works it will be apparent that the closer you can get your actual source to that used to create the Aura's Sound Image, the better it will function, and that is certainly borne out in practice. This is definitely not a 'transform your guitar into any other guitar' box. Indeed, radically mismatching real source and Sound Image can produce some less-than-optimal noises. Properly set up, however, the Aura is capable of making your DI'd acoustic guitar sound dramatically more like an optimally miked instrument than any pickup system you will have heard before. Logic suggests that the best performance of all would be achieved by creating the reference image Here you can see the list of from the actual guitar and pickup that you will be Sound Images which were using with it, and indeed this is so. Fishman offer a available on the Fishman web site as we went to press. service to create a Sound Image from your own guitar, but this naturally involves shipping the instrument to their facility in Massachusetts, USA. More practical and attractive to most people will be the option to have a Sound Image created by Fishman from a recording of your guitar via its pickup and a recording of the same guitar via your preferred microphone. The resulting file, and others from an extensive library of FSI (Fishman Sound Image) files, can then be downloaded over MIDI to the Aura via the dedicated Aura Gallery library program (available for both Mac OS X and versions of Windows from 98 to XP) which can be downloaded from the very good support web site that Fishman have put together for the Aura (www. fishmanaura.com). Aura Gallery worked painlessly for me on the review model via a Mac under OS X, and I've heard similarly positive results from PC users. The Aura's distinctive heavy-duty, curved silver top plate sits above a standard half-rack 1U box. The all-metal construction bestows a certain confidence and results in a substantial weight for a unit without an internal power supply. Three file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Fishman%20Aura.htm (3 of 9)9/26/2005 8:17:33 AM
Fishman Aura
heavy-duty metal footswitches, three knobs, and a rotary selector switch govern the Aura's inner workings, with the only visual feedback being via a two-character numeric LED display. On the rear face are connections for external 9V DC supply (battery-powered operation is not an option), MIDI In, guitar input (5M(omega) input impedance), low-level (-10dBV) unbalanced jack out, and high-level (+4dBu) balanced XLR out, with ground lift. With digital conversion at 16bit/44.1kHz, it is important to maximise the input level in order to keep the noise floor as low as possible. With the output maxed on my onboard Fishman preampequipped guitars, input gain sat at an ideal 75 percent, and setting the output to around the same achieved unity gain through the system. At these settings, system noise was certainly not a problem and was comparable to using any other additional preamp stage of reasonable quality. Moving over to my Rare Earth Blend system required a bit more input gain on the Aura and, with slightly higher source noise from the pickup too, I found I had to roll off some top end and reduce the Sound Image contribution to the output to achieve an acceptable background noise level for solo or exposed parts.
Aura Factory Sound Images The Aura's factory set of images pretty much covers most bases, although more are being added to the Aura web site all the time. In addition to the single classical guitar preset, there are 10 for under-saddle systems and five for magnetic pickups. UNDER-SADDLE PROGRAMS Based on Fishman Prefix Stereo Blend, Fishman Matrix Natural II, or Fishman Prefix Plus. Dreadnought 1: Martin D28, rosewood; Shure SM58 dynamic. Dreadnought 2: Martin D16, rosewood; Neumann U47 large-diaphragm condenser. Dreadnought 3: Collings D2H, rosewood; DPA 4011 small-diaphragm condenser. Dreadnought 4: Martin D28, rosewood; Sanken CU31 small-diaphragm condenser. Grand Auditorium: Taylor 414, ovangkol; DPA 4011 small-diaphragm condenser. Grand Concert 1: Martin 0018, mahogany; DPA 4011 small-diaphragm condenser. Jumbo 1: Gibson J200, maple; Neumann U47 large-diaphragm condenser. Jumbo 12 string 1: Guild F412, maple; Shure SM58 dynamic. Jumbo 2 Mag: Gibson J200, maple; Shure SM58 dynamic. L-Style: Larivee L09, rosewood; Sanken CU31 small-diaphragm condenser. Orchestra Model 1: Martin OM21, rosewood; Audix CX111 large-diaphragm condenser.
MAGNETIC-PICKUP PROGRAMS Based on Fishman Rare Earth Humbucking soundhole pickup. Dreadnought 5 Mag: Martin D16, rosewood; Sanken CU31 small-diaphragm condenser. Grand Auditorium 2 Mag: Taylor 414, ovangkol; Neumann U47 large-diaphragm condenser. Orchestra Model 2 Mag: Martin OM21, rosewood; Audix CX111 large-diaphragm condenser.
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Fishman%20Aura.htm (4 of 9)9/26/2005 8:17:33 AM
Fishman Aura
Grand Concert 2 Mag: Martin OO18, mahogany: DPA 4011 small-diaphragm condenser.
Setting Up With the slide switch in the centre of the panel set to Play mode, the Aura's 50 programs (stored combinations of Sound Image, blend, phase, and EQ settings) can be sequentially selected from the centre and right footswitches. Slide it across to Edit and the rotary Parameter selector and data-entry knob come into play. The first and perhaps most fundamental selection to be made is the choice of the Sound Image itself. The Aura ships with four immutable images, numbered P1 to P4 ('P' for permanent, I guess), and then a further 12 (see the 'Aura Factory Sound Images' box for details) that can be replaced with images of your choice from the ever-growing library on the Aura web site. Having selected the image that most accurately represents your instrument rendered via the microphone of your choice, you can then set low, middle, and high EQ for the image; balance of image against unprocessed pickup signal; EQ for the pickup; relative phase of pickup and image; compression; global output phase (polarity); and finally a level tweak (+3dB to -9dB) for the whole program to compensate for EQ or heavy compression. Sliding the Edit/Play switch back to Play then stores your edited patch, but only into the location you started from — there is no facility for saving to another location and therefore none for copying a patch either. Any further editing tweaks that you make will always overwrite the current patch the moment you return to Play mode. This is not actually quite as much of a pain in use as it might seem, due to the limited number of parameters involved, but the Aura documentation's recommendation of making multiple versions of the same patch with progressive volume settings might tax the patience a bit. I'm not sure if this operating system was adopted on cost grounds or in order to keep the product as simple as possible for potentially technophobic acoustic guitarists, but in my experience amplified acoustic guitarists these days have embraced technology with a vengeance, albeit mostly out of necessity. An outboard rack consisting of preamp, EQ, dynamics, feedback eliminator, and effects is not uncommon, and all with the aim of making the guitar sound like it does when it's not plugged in! The Aura's facilities are completed by an onboard tuner, activated by pressing both program-selection footswitches at the same time, and an anti-feedback notch filter. The tuner defaults to muting the output when activated, although you can choose to have the output remain active if you prefer audible confirmation of tuning. In use, the tuner is impressively stable, fast, and accurate, albeit with a slight tendency to read the pitch envelope (in other words, to show the natural rise in pitch that always occurs with the initial attack of the plucked string). The built-in feedback eliminator defaults to a 100Hz notch filter (-14dB with a quarter-octave bandwidth), although you can initiate an automatic 'seek and destroy' mode by pressing and holding the footswitch until the LED flashes. It will then lock onto the next bit of feedback it encounters and set the filter at that frequency instead. You can store feedback filter on/off status and notch file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Fishman%20Aura.htm (5 of 9)9/26/2005 8:17:33 AM
Fishman Aura
frequency as part of each patch, but, given that you can't copy a patch, if you want to set up a series of similar patches all designed for the same guitar, you will have to do the 'search and destroy' thing for every one of them. Feedback elimination is effective, although not without audible consequence, as the first feedback mode is usually the primary resonance of the body with acoustic guitars, but then it would hardly be realistic to expect state-of-the-art narrownotch performance when the whole Aura unit costs less than some stand-alone feedback eliminators.
Onboard Compression The onboard compressor has automatic make-up gain, which keeps the output level constant as you dial in more gain reduction. There is the choice of a 'C' setting for strummed chords and an 'L' setting for single-note lead playing, the latter having a slower attack time which allows more transient to come through. The threshold and ratio are both fixed, so it's not exactly a tweakaholic's compressor, but all the defaults are sensibly chosen, and the fact is it works, smoothing out strummed parts and making lead lines sing a bit more. With individual settings stored for each patch, you can kick it in just when you need it. The compressor naturally raises the noise floor a little, although certainly not unacceptably unless an inappropriate setting is used — say, maximum compression with very light finger picking. There is a noise gate that kicks in automatically whenever the compressor is used, although its action is very subtle and you'd be hard pushed to know with anything like normal playing dynamics.
Aura In Action Provided that you are using an instrument and a pickup system that are the same as, or at least very close to, the ones used to create the selected Sound Image, the Aura is capable of realising a quite remarkable transformation in the sound. Across the spectrum, the 'plasticky', brittle quality of a typical piezo under-saddle pickup takes on the warmth and complex 'bloom' of the real acoustic sound, with the removal of any trace of the piezo's characteristic hardness. The first reaction of listeners, as I punched the process in and out, was unfailingly an openmouthed 'wow!', and there is no denying that the Aura's output sounds a whole lot more like a miked acoustic than any pickup system by itself has ever done. In assessing its performance, I think it is important to remember that it is the sound of a miked acoustic guitar that you are listening to, not the guitar itself. The acid test is not A/B'ing against the guitar heard acoustically, but A/B'ing against the guitar miked up in your headphones. There you can hear just how close the Aura gets, and it is truly remarkable. Playing techniques and subtleties that are normally 'lost in translation' via a pickup come through just as they should; flatpick, fingers, and above all, finally, a strummed acoustic guitar via an undersaddle pickup that doesn't have the same sonic effect as fingernails on a blackboard! Extended playing in a studio situation had me initially reaching for the onboard
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Fishman%20Aura.htm (6 of 9)9/26/2005 8:17:33 AM
Fishman Aura
EQ to tame the top end a bit and fill in what felt like a bit of a 'hole in the middle'. With the Sound-Image/pickup mix set to full Sound Image (the recommended balance for recording), I found that the sound was missing a bit of immediacy and solidity. It was undeniably the spectrum of a miked acoustic guitar, with lots of warmth and air, but it didn't feel entirely comfortable to me, almost like trying to play whilst monitoring an over-compressed signal in your headphones. Adopting the recommended live performance blend of 50/50 image and pickup improved things a whole lot in the feel department, without reducing the 'reality' of the overall sound at all, to my ears. The ability to balance the Sound Image against the raw pickup is one of the Aura's most useful parameters, one that I found crucial to achieving the sound I wanted in different acoustics or with different guitars. The dry (nonAura-processed) signal passes through the A-D converter, as it has to be fractionally delayed to align it with the processed signal, thereby avoiding unwanted comb filtering when the two sources are mixed together. The total time through the system is not discernable as any form of delay or latency, although the Aura's phase tweaks do seem to succeed in 'slowing the signal down' to the right degree — it has always been one of the complaints levelled at string-based pickup systems that they 'speak' so much more quickly than the time it takes for the soundboard and bridge plate to do their stuff, thereby changing the feel of the instrument. Testing the Aura in a live setting, both direct into a PA and into dedicated Waveform analysis screens used by Fishman in developing the Aura's acoustic acoustic-guitar amps (AER Acousticube IIa and Trace Elliot TA50), Sound Imaging process. Top: the instantaneous attack of the pickup signal I found I wanted subtly different EQ; (upper trace) can be seen to differ from the dipping the mid-range on the pickup microphone's slower onset (lower trace), and rolling off a little of both top and arising partly from the guitar's whole resonant structure being slower to 'speak' bottom from the Sound Image. At than just the string itself, and also party from performance volume, I also found I the distance between the guitar and the preferred to reduce the Sound Image microphone. Spectral (tonal) differences can contribution to less than 50 percent. It be seen in the two lower screens. seems that even a small amount of body resonance and 'air' from the Sound Image is enough to take away the impression of 'piezo quack'. Using a lot of Sound Image on stage also tends to provoke an earlier onset of feedback, file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Fishman%20Aura.htm (7 of 9)9/26/2005 8:17:33 AM
Fishman Aura
particularly at low frequencies. Although the Aura has Sound Images for both under-saddle transducers and magnetic soundhole pickups, I found that the process worked significantly better with the USTs. There is some logic to this; an under-saddle always reads what's happening at one end of the string, whereas a magnetic reads a constantly changing harmonic balance as its relative position is altered according to where you are playing on the neck. A real-time spectral transform process such as that used by the Aura obviously would benefit from having a more consistent source such as that provided by a UST. I was pleasantly surprised to discover that the single factory preset on the Aura dedicated to classical (nylon-string) guitar actually does a spectacular job on my Fishman UST-equipped classical. I have always felt that classical guitar is particularly ill-served by under-saddle systems, with a pronounced transient thump on the top strings and weedy, thin bottom strings, with little body resonance to support the note. The only way to make classical guitars sound even half acceptable via a pickup system has always been to use additional body and/or bridge-plate sensors, but that comes at a price in the feedback department. The Aura transforms a classical UST into something infinitely more like the sound and feel of the real instrument and I found I could happily use a setting of 75 percent Sound Image in a live situation and 100 percent Image for recording. I am occasionally required to play the odd track involving classical guitar on stage, and I can honestly say the Aura has transformed that activity from a real pain to an absolute pleasure. During the month that I have been writing this review, the lone factory classical image has also been augmented by a number of additional classical guitar Sound Images on the Aura web site, including some with different miking distances. There is a momentary interrupt when changing programs, and this remains whether you use the standard sequential access method, or the Aura's alternative 'pre-select and activate' strategy. It is perhaps easy to see why this might be the case when changing from one Sound Image to another, but more difficult to see why it should do this when switching to another program using the same image, where perhaps only a single parameter might be different. I was pleased, however, to discover that you can actually select programs via MIDI, enabling the Aura to be tied into complex MIDI-switched rigs — the manual doesn't mention this, but it certainly works, although it's still subject to the brief dropout.
Conclusion Fishman's Aura takes us a whole big step closer to the amplified acoustic guitarist's Holy Grail ('my guitar, only louder') and it's great to see that being done in such an affordable product. It has already become a central part of my home studio — like many home studio owners, there are times when it is impractical for me to record with microphones, but using a pickup for serious work was just not file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Fishman%20Aura.htm (8 of 9)9/26/2005 8:17:33 AM
Fishman Aura
an option before. With the Aura, it certainly is. I'm also never going to go out on another acoustic gig without it! Just how much of an impression it makes on you will be determined by how picky you are about the sound of amplified acoustic instruments and to a large extent by what you are comparing it to — if you are a 'piezo into the PA' man, you can't fail to love it. If you run a state-of-the-art multi-source system with a huge rack of outboard, then your benchmark will be that bit further along, but you might still cast an envious glance in the direction of the Aura's compact simplicity! Don't expect to be able to plug in any old guitar off the wall of your local shop and dial up some presets at random, however, for the Aura is not the acoustic player's Line 6 Pod, with a palette of new and exciting sounds on tap. It can turn one acoustic guitar sound into another, but it is much better regarded as a precision tool designed to do the very specific job of making an amplified acoustic guitar actually sound like itself! In my experience with it, it is only when you have a Sound Image that matches the guitar you are using that it is able to reach its true potential. There is undoubtedly a lot more to come from this area of development, with increasingly powerful digital technology making possible processes and applications that would have been unimaginable only a few years before. In fact, you can already get certain Martin guitar models with an Aura processor built in as a factory option. The Aura's UK price has obviously been chosen to make this new technology available to the maximum number of people, but that does mean that some compromises have been made, such as the limited user interface and the 16-bit processing, but it is not too hard to envisage a future addition to the range, say a rackmount unit with remote switching, 24-bit conversion, even more detailed Sound Images, and a full LCD-based GUI... The future looks more exciting than ever for acoustic guitarists willing to embrace new technology in both recording and live performance, and it is highly likely that, in years to come, we will look back on the Aura as a hugely significant first step in a new direction.
Published in SOS November 2004 Sound On Sound, Media House, Trafalgar Way, Bar Hill, Cambridge CB3 8SQ, UK. Email:
[email protected] | Telephone: +44 (0)1954 789888 | Fax: +44 (0)1954 789895
All contents copyright © SOS Publications Group and/or its licensors, 1985-2005. All rights reserved. The contents of this article are subject to worldwide copyright protection and reproduction in whole or part, whether mechanical or electronic, is expressly forbidden without the prior written consent of the Publishers. Great care has been taken to ensure accuracy in the preparation of this article but neither Sound On Sound Limited nor the publishers can be held responsible for its contents. The views expressed are those of the contributors and not necessarily those of the publishers. Web site designed & maintained by PB Associates | SOS | Relative Media
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Fishman%20Aura.htm (9 of 9)9/26/2005 8:17:33 AM
Korg CR4
In this article:
Korg CR4
What Do You Get? Cassette Multitracker Bouncing Back Modelling Effects Processor Published in SOS November 2004 Noise Reduction Print article : Close window The CR4 In Use Reviews : Multitrack Recorder Conclusions
Korg CR4 £199 pros Makes a nice practice amp and DI. Very portable. A great way to demo ideas. Two headphone sockets.
cons
Korg, one of the main manufacturers of digital workstations, have just released another multitracker, but this time it's cassette based. Tom Flint
The effects and amp models are only available on one channel at a time. The Ampworks effects cannot be used on recorded tracks or on the full mix. No tape varispeed. No system to reduce tape hiss. No internal or external effects loop.
summary The CR4 is an unusual product which has been designed to fill a small niche in the market. As a four-track cassette multitracker, the machine is very basic, but it also functions well as a practice amp and as an input device for guitars, bass, and vocals.
information £199 Including VAT. Korg UK Brochure Line +44 (0)1908 857150. +44 (0)1908 857199. Click here to email www.korg.co.uk www.korg.co.jp
The first multitrack owned by many of us of a certain age was a cassette four-track, but when digital recorders came along, bringing with them digital editing, mix recall, automation, and noisefree recording, it seemed as though tape had had its day. Indeed, digital has made high-quality recording a possibility for the home studio owner in a way that the compact cassette could never do. Yet despite the growth and development of the digital recorder market over the last decade, cassette-based multitrack machines have soldiered on surprisingly well, and, as Korg have demonstrated with the release of the CR4, some of the big names in the industry are still prepared to spend time and money developing new cassettebased products.
Photos: Mark Ewing
So why would you choose to buy a cassette multitracker these days? Well, it wouldn't be your first choice for making release-quality recordings, because of tape's inherently high level of noise, but for creating rough demos, or for the purpose of jotting down musical ideas in a simple and immediate way, such machines do have their place. Compact cassettes are still a very cheap recording medium, they can be bought just about anywhere, they're easy to use, pretty reliable, and very robust — shake a cassette as hard as you like, for example, but it's still unlikely to lose data or become corrupted! Even the most technically minded musicians covet immediacy when they are in creative flow, so being able
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Korg%20CR4.htm (1 of 6)9/26/2005 8:17:36 AM
Korg CR4
to plug in and record without worrying about data integrity or software routing issues is still very attractive.
What Do You Get? Although Korg have called the CR4 a four-track cassette recorder, in offers both more and less than that title suggests. The extra features it brings to the table are the pair of built-in speakers and Korg's own Ampworks modelling processor and multi-effects. Used in combination, the speakers and modelling effects allow the CR4 to be used as a practice amp for guitarists, bassists, and vocalists. It can also act as a modelling preamp or DI device. For example, if a guitar lead is plugged into one of the inputs, an amp simulation can be applied, as can an effect, and the resulting signal can be output into a separate recorder. Absent from the CR4, however, are any real mixing facilities. True, the four tracks can be panned and mixed to make a stereo signal, but that's about it. The CR4 can't internally bounce tracks, it cannot apply effects or processing to recorded material, and it has very limited monitoring facilities. It also lacks a varispeed control, which I always felt was one of the best things tape offered to the creative musician. At the top of the front panel is a counter and reset button, although the CR4 has no 'zero return' facility. Underneath the tape mechanism are six standard transport buttons, including the all-important Record, which can only operate when a tape with unbroken write-protect tabs is loaded. Under the Pause button is an LED indicating whether power is on, plus four further metering LEDs showing the output signal level. Below these is a master level control for adjusting the line output, speaker, and headphone volume levels. The remaining controls that are situated between the two speakers are shared between the four recordable tracks. Every channel has its own fader, Pan knob, track-arming button, and Trim control, with dedicated overload LED. The trackarming buttons also have their own LEDs which flash green when they are selected for recording, stay green during recording, and turn red when a signal overloads the tape. There is also an Effect button for each channel, and these buttons enable the CR4's internal processor to be applied to a particular input source. Signals are input channel by channel via four quarter-inch jack sockets mounted on the front edge of the machine. To the left of the inputs are Main and Sub headphone sockets. It's a nice to be able to use two sets of phones with such a budget machine. Inserting a headphone lead into the one labelled Main cuts the signal to the speakers, and the Sub socket remains inactive unless the Main socket is in use. There is also a dedicated speaker on/off switch on the back panel. The speakers themselves have 8cm drivers, are of the bass reflex type and deliver 2.5W each. The cones are protected by sturdy metal grills, which also prevent guitar picks and bits of food from vanishing inside the vents! The file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Korg%20CR4.htm (2 of 6)9/26/2005 8:17:36 AM
Korg CR4
remaining back panel features are the left and right Line Out phonos, the input for the 12V power adaptor (included with the CR4), and the master power button.
Bouncing Back The CR4 doesn't have a bussing system, which means that its recording options are fairly restricted. In the past, many four-track recorders actually made it possible to record up to 10 separate tracks using just one machine. This was done by recording on the first three tracks and then bouncing them to the remaining track together with one further part played live through the fourth channel input. New parts would then be recorded onto tracks one and two, which would then be bounced to track three together with another live part. The final bounce would require a new part to be recorded on track one, and then bounced to track two, together with yet another live part. That would leave track one available for recording the tenth track. Although the CR4 is probably not intended for serious multitracking, some sort of bussing system would have been welcome, even if it just allowed the four inputs to be mixed to a single record track. As it is, the manual suggests bouncing down to a second stereo recorder and then feeding the resulting tracks back to the CR4 ready for overdub. While this is a possibility, it does require the use of a second machine, and that idea conflicts with the all-in-one character of the CR4.
Modelling Effects Processor One of the CR4's big selling points will surely be the inclusion of Korg's Ampworks effects and REMS (Resonant structure and Electronic circuit Modelling System) proprietary modelling technology. Both effects and models are available to a recording channel when the relevant Effects button is pressed, although they can only be used by one track at a time. Two rotary dials, one labelled Modelling and the other Effects, provide a limited but carefully chosen selection of treatments. The eleven presets available on the Effect dial are Comp, Wah, Chorus, Flanger, Phaser, Trem, Rotary, Delay, Reverb, Cho+Dl (chorus and delay) and Cho+Rv (chorus and reverb). Although there is no way to access all the parameters of each effects patch, the CR4 does offer a Tap button for setting the modulation speed of many of the effects and the decay time of the Reverb algorithm. None of the compressor's parameters can be changed by the Tap button, and the sweep speed of the wah-wah is also uneditable. Nevertheless, the up/down direction of the filter sweeps can be set by adjusting the Effect Depth control. The CR4's Modelling dial offers a selection of eleven preamp and processor emulations. Amongst these are two bass-amp models, named Valve and LA Studio, plus two models designed specifically for vocals. Vocal 1 is tantalisingly described as a 'widely used Austrian condenser microphone sound', while Vocal 2 is supposedly 'a standard dynamic microphone' model.
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Korg%20CR4.htm (3 of 6)9/26/2005 8:17:36 AM
Korg CR4
Some of the guitar amp models are also named slightly cryptically. For example, we are told that the UK '80s is modelled on a UK-manufactured 100W master-volume head from 1983 — there are clearly some legal issues preventing Korg from naming some of the products these models have been based on! The labelling of the AC30TB model is not quite so cryptic, however, and the manual states that it is the classic Vox AC30's Brilliant channel. Overall, the amp models are quite a wellchosen bunch, ranging from the clean, such as the Btq Cln, to the very dirty, demonstrated best by the Nu Metal option, and they should be enough to please most of the people most of the time. The Ampworks section's set of six rotary knobs work in conjunction with the modelling algorithms and effects. The three centre controls are labelled Treble, Middle, and Bass and provide a three-band EQ section as one might find on a guitar amp. The Volume knob simply adjusts the amp level and the Mid-FC/Gain alters its gain, although if a clean model has been selected (such as Vocal 1/2, Valve, LA Studio, or Ac EQ) this control sweeps the mid-band. The remaining knob, labelled Effect Depth adjusts the level of the effects processor, although it can also be used to set the threshold of the internal noise gate (see the Noise Reduction box), and, as explained above, operates as an up/down selector for the wah-wah effect.
Noise Reduction The Ampworks effects section has what Korg call a 'noise-reduction system' which actually turns out to be a variable noise gate. Its threshold can be set by holding down the tap button and then adjusting the Eff Depth control to the appropriate level. There is no LED to indicate the status of the gate, so a little trial and error is necessary when setting it up. Thankfully, doing so is quick and easy, so it doesn't take long to find a suitable level. Unfortunately there is no noisereduction system for reducing the recorder's tape hiss.
The CR4 In Use As you would hope, the CR4 is easy to use, which will suit those who just want to concentrate on the process of getting their ideas on tape with the minimum of fuss. Loading a tape is just a matter of lifting the plastic lid and clicking the tape in place. Standard compact cassettes of any kind can be used, although the manual recommends using high-bias type-II chromium dioxide tapes of less than 60 minutes in length. To record, simply plug in a guitar, microphone, or whatever, set the Trim pot so
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Korg%20CR4.htm (4 of 6)9/26/2005 8:17:36 AM
Korg CR4
that the associated red LED doesn't flicker too much, and then raise the channel and master faders until you have a comfortable monitoring level. The position of the channel fader affects the level of the recording, so this needs to be set as high as possible, and the second channel overload LED gives a fair indication of the optimum level. The master LEDs do not represent the recording level at all, and any overload shown here relates to the output level only. If effects processing is required, this can be selected instantly by pressing the channel Effect button. The amp models are easily applied, and the control knobs allow the desired adjustments to be made directly. The gain control and EQ really do react like the knobs on a real guitar amp. Similarly, using the Tap button to adjust the effects couldn't be easier. Although the CR4's simplicity is to be commended, there are some aspects of its design which would really have benefited from being developed a little further. For example, it's a shame that the Ampworks models and effects are only available when recording, and can't be used on a pre-recorded track. I can't imagine that it would be too difficult for Korg to include a switch to insert the models and effects into a channel on mixdown, or even to place them across the stereo output buss. Having more flexible effects routing would mean that, for example, a guitarist could lay down a rough idea, and decide on exactly how much processing to use at a later date. Multitrackers of old rarely, if ever, had the luxury of built-in effects, but they usually provided an effects send-return loop, so external processors could be used. Given that this recorder cannot use its own effects on mixdown, such a facility would have been a welcome addition here. It's also annoying that the EQ is wholly part of the Ampworks section, and cannot be used to treat the mixed signal. Once again, if the effects could be applied to the stereo mix, then the EQ would expand the CR4's feature set significantly.
Conclusions Korg have produced a rather unusual product, which, given its limitations as a recording device — it suffers, of course, from tape hiss — will probably only be used as a portable notepad or very rough demo recorder. Fortunately, many of the reasons why someone might want this product have little to do with multitrack recording as such. I think a better description of the CR4 would be 'guitar, bass, and vocal practice amp/DI with modelling effects and a built-in four-track recorder' — although that might look just a little bit messy printed on the box! This is a no-nonsense product which does a limited number of things simply and file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Korg%20CR4.htm (5 of 6)9/26/2005 8:17:36 AM
Korg CR4
effectively, so the use of the compactcassette format is quite understandable. For example, compared to hard drives, which are easily damaged and need to be backed up regularly, tapes are extremely robust and damage resistant. So much so that, even after a dodgy tape mechanism has chewed up a segment of tape, the recording can usually be rescued. I can imagine bands dragging the CR4 along to their practice sessions or taking it along with them on the road, or even musicians with sophisticated studios using it to jot down ideas quickly before booting up the rest of the studio gear. I'm not quite sure why the CR4 has two speakers, though. They are so close together that they don't really provide a stereo image, and for a practice amp two speakers are unnecessary. I would have preferred it if Korg had sacrificed one of the speakers and used the resulting panel space and budget to add some more features. Alternatively, a single larger speaker could have been installed, which would have benefited the bass end, and would therefore have made the CR4 a more useful practice amp for bassists, guitarists and vocalists alike. On the other hand, I can appreciate that physics may have affected the CR4's design. It might be possible to damage a recording by placing a cassette too near a speaker magnet. Furthermore excessive vibrations from a powerful speaker could cause problems by shaking the tape mechanism. In terms of price, the CR4 represents reasonable value in the UK, given that the product is a practice amp, modelling DI device, and four-track recorder in one. For the same price there are better products available in each of those market areas, but I can't immediately think of anything else that brings together the same features into one product. The CR4 is a little mad, occasionally flawed, but an interesting product nonetheless, and it's sure to be just the thing that a few people have been waiting for. Published in SOS November 2004 Sound On Sound, Media House, Trafalgar Way, Bar Hill, Cambridge CB3 8SQ, UK. Email:
[email protected] | Telephone: +44 (0)1954 789888 | Fax: +44 (0)1954 789895
All contents copyright © SOS Publications Group and/or its licensors, 1985-2005. All rights reserved. The contents of this article are subject to worldwide copyright protection and reproduction in whole or part, whether mechanical or electronic, is expressly forbidden without the prior written consent of the Publishers. Great care has been taken to ensure accuracy in the preparation of this article but neither Sound On Sound Limited nor the publishers can be held responsible for its contents. The views expressed are those of the contributors and not necessarily those of the publishers. Web site designed & maintained by PB Associates | SOS | Relative Media
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Korg%20CR4.htm (6 of 6)9/26/2005 8:17:36 AM
Latest Sample CDs
In this article:
Xtreme House 2 ***** The Emperor ***** Ghetto Grooves 2 **** The Old Lady *****
Star Stevie Wonders
Latest Sample CDs Hot Releases Tested Published in SOS November 2004 Print article : Close window
Reviews : Sound/Song Library
***** Ray Charles **** Stevie Wonder *** Michael Jackson
Xtreme House 2 *****
** Jay Kay
MULTI-FORMAT
* Adam Levine
The CD-ROM supplied contains not only almost 800MB of house samples in compressed archives, but also Battery, EXS24, and Reason Redrum sampler profiles. This is accompanied by an Audio CD of all the loops, excluding a folder of single drum hits. In the Beats folder, you get many solid electronic 'four to the floor' clichés, interspersed with some more imaginative programming and a number of nice meaty breakbeat grooves. Layers of electronic and ethnic percussion weave in and out, adding lots of internal dynamics, and effects are used both creatively and tastefully. Overall there's a lot of variety, albeit within the 117-140bpm range, in a way which frequently reminded me of Basement Jaxx — a compliment as far as I'm concerned! If you're after variations on any of the patterns here, though, then you'll have to get out Recycle, as you mostly get only one version of each loop. The bass sounds are mostly synthetic, but cover a lot of ground. You've got woody square waves, muffled subbass monsters, and many a restless filter. Effects again make their presence felt and, although a little mad at times, mostly remain within the bounds of usability. Some nice stepsequencer-style patterns and reverse envelopes are scattered around too, which always add a bit of extra rhythmic interest. In addition to the synth lines, there are some nicely chosen bass-guitars, many heavily reminiscent of '70s funk records, and all of these have some nice driving rhythm or unusual corner which demands attention. Again, you'll have to get editing to make your own lines up, but with the synths this is likely to present few problems in practice.
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Latest%20Sample%20CDs.htm (1 of 6)9/26/2005 8:17:40 AM
Latest Sample CDs
Things begin to get more esoteric in the Synths & Keys folder. Dreamy, wistful, and euphoric washes and arpeggiations nestle adjacent to lively piano, rhodes, hammond, and clav rhythms. Staccato synth motifs trigger triplet delays, and thick ensembles fill out the texture around the occasional spiky lead line or crispyfried sample. There seemed to be little to distinguish the Filtered folder from Synths & Keys, except that the former has the odd guitar and beat loop, and the processing is perhaps a bit more severe. Finally there is the small single hits folder, which supplies a handful of kicks, snares, hats, percussion and one-shot effects. What I most like about this library is that the loops seem to have real depth, by which I mean that you get more out of them the more you listen. What seems like a straightforward organ arpeggiation might reveal a couple of interesting background clunks which make it much more punchy and characterful, for example; or some editing artifacts give a simple piano riff a pleasingly drunken stagger; or a low-level crunchy delay adds a sprinkle of syncopation which drives the groove forward. This kind of inner sonic detail makes Xtreme House 2 really inspiring to delve into, and it not only means that you need fewer samples to carry a track, but also that each one continues to twist your ear beyond the first few repetitions. I'd have liked more informative documentation and better subdivision of the Synth & Keys and Filtered samples, but the extra softwaresampler settings just tilt the balance back into the five-star category. Mike Senior Audio CD and WAV, Battery, EXS24, and Reason Redrum CD-ROM set, £59.95 including VAT. Time + Space +44 (0)1837 55200. +44 (0)1837 55400. Click here to email www.timespace.com www.tekniks.co.uk
The Emperor ***** MULTI-FORMAT Like a big-game hunter, Michiel Post obsessively stalks the musical jungle in search of new prey. A recent expedition to the wilds of South East England was particularly fruitful, yielding a brace of impressive trophies which include the 'king of beasts' of the classical piano world, the mighty Bösendorfer 290 Imperial Grand. (If you ever find one bearing down on you, don't shoot till you see the whites of its ivories!) Post Musical Instruments already have a Grandioso Bösendorfer 290 on their books, glowingly reviewed in SOS March 2003, but today's piano is a top-of-therange 290SE model that has been refurbished to a very high standard by its UK owner. The SE suffix stands for 'Stahnke Electronics', indicating the attachment of a hi-tech player/recorder mechanism designed by US mastermind Wayne Stahnke. Post programmed this fabulous gizmo to 'play' the instrument's white
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Latest%20Sample%20CDs.htm (2 of 6)9/26/2005 8:17:40 AM
Latest Sample CDs
notes at around a dozen precisely calculated dynamic levels over an 88-note span. Although the recording took place in a medium-sized concert hall space, there's no obvious reverb in the sound; rather than adding room ambience, the release samples recreate the tiny 'bump' of the damper returning to the strings as the key is released. The resulting samples uphold Bösendorfer's formidable reputation, sounding open, clean, and majestic, with that characteristic low-end 'zing'. The bottom register rumbles like quiet thunder, while the top notes have a crystal clarity and transparency. Right across its range, the piano's notes 'speak' with a precise, clear attack which never sounds too percussive. To pop ears, the Bösendorfer timbre might appear a little stern and 'classical', but that serious, austere quality is offset by the richness, depth, and maturity of its tone and the latent power of the loud samples — add some EQ and compression, and the bass notes really roar. Having so many dynamic layers under the bonnet ensures a pleasingly natural response to variations of velocity, allowing players to move freely between hushed, quiet notes and loud, clangorous ones with no trace of timbral 'stepping'. A great bonus, the 'pedal down' samples add a subtle, lush, floaty layer to the piano's already rich sustains. Most of the sampled pianos I have played disappointed in one area or another. I was beginning to give up hope of finding a truly inspirational instrument, but PMI's latest releases have given me new faith in the possibility of producing expressive music from a sampled grand. With the pound currently high against the dollar, this is a good time to consider splashing out on this superior, charismatic, and above all playable instrument. Dave Stewart EXS24, Gigastudio 2 & 3, Halion, or Kontakt DVD-ROM, £115.95; bundle deal with The Old Lady, £173.80. Prices include VAT. Time + Space +44 (0)1837 55200. +44 (0)1837 55400. Click here to email www.timespace.com www.postpiano.com
Ghetto Grooves 2 **** AUDIO+WAV Unsurprisingly, this is a follow-up to Tekniks successful Ghetto Grooves, which obtained a four-star review in the SOS September 2002. Well, if it ain't broke, don't fix it — the new release is aimed at exactly the same hip hop and R&B styles as the original, and follows a similar format; some 25 construction kits are complemented by a generous collection of individual bass, synth, kick, snare, and hi-hat samples. The WAV files total over 650MB, while each of the
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Latest%20Sample%20CDs.htm (3 of 6)9/26/2005 8:17:40 AM
Latest Sample CDs
construction kits provides between six and about a dozen loops, plus a few individual samples. The musical contents of the kits themselves are definitely aimed at the sparser end of the field — think Jay Z rather than R Kelly — so if smooth and soulful late-night R&B tunes to turn the lights down to are your thing, then you would need to look elsewhere. Original tempos for the construction kits are generally between 90bpm and 110bpm, and the emphasis throughout is on the beats. Each kit generally contains three or four drum loops and some have additional percussion loops. These are all well put together, with plenty of aggressive kick and snare sounds to give the loops just the right attitude. Most of the sounds seem to be classic drum-machine fodder, and the large collection of individual kick, snare, and hi-hat samples (well over 2000 in total) would provide plenty of ammunition if you wished to programme your own loops to sit alongside those provided. The instrumental loops are mostly simple and uncluttered, and this is generally the right way to go with this style of music where the vocals (sung or rapped) are the dominant feature. Most of the kits include a bass and synth loops, but there is also a good smattering of guitar, Rhodes, string, and clav, plus some occasional trumpet and even a sitar or two. Despite the deliberate simplicity of the majority of the bass or synth riffs, there is enough in the way of musical hooks to add some character between the vocal elements during song construction. With the appropriate tempo- and pitch-shifting, mixing and matching the various loops between different kits proved straightforward — the consistency of the styles and original recording tempos made this easier than with some other loop sets. In use, perhaps my only criticism was that it might have been nice to have a few more instrumental variations (particularly bass loops) within some of the construction kits. A little extra work with the beat-slicing tools or a sampler using the numerous individual samples supplied would soon put this right however. All in all, Ghetto Grooves 2 seems to follow on where the original left off. The loops and sounds are pretty much spot on and, without sounding too clean or sanitised, would fit right into the grittier end of the current (very commercial) hip-hop/R&B marketplace. John Walden Audio CD and WAV CD-ROM set, £59.95 including VAT. Time + Space +44 (0)1837 55200. +44 (0)1837 55400. Click here to email www.timespace.com www.tekniks.co.uk
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Latest%20Sample%20CDs.htm (4 of 6)9/26/2005 8:17:40 AM
Latest Sample CDs
The Old Lady ***** MULTI-FORMAT And still they come! Keyboard specialist Michiel Post has a second new release, The Old Lady — not, as the title might suggest, a collection of recordings of Mrs Post's finest musical moments, but yet another lavishly sampled grand piano to add to the prolific Dutch samplist's ever-growing catalogue. This Steinway is a 1920s 'D' model, widely regarded as the manufacturer's best, and should not be confused with PMI's Grandioso Steinway D piano, as reviewed in SOS in October 2002. The lovely old instrument is the pride and joy of a UK piano enthusiast, who gave it its affectionate feminine nickname. In this project, Mr Post recorded eight precisely calibrated dynamics of 'pedal off' notes, then eight more with the sustain pedal down. The latter have been cleverly programmed — when layered with the 'pedal up' notes, they play all the time but are muted until the sustain pedal is pressed, at which point they quickly fade up into the mix. This produces a reasonable imitation of the effect of a real piano's sustain pedal. For an 80-year-old, this old lady is in the best of health, the sound ringing out with great depth and clarity over a range of more than seven octaves. The mic placement is finely judged, allowing the piano's tone to breathe while preserving its precise, well-defined attack. Eight dynamic layers are sufficient to cover the instrument's tonal range, and once you've found the right velocity-curve setting on your keyboard controller, the samples respond to dynamic changes in a convincingly organic way. It's interesting to compare this piano with The Emperor's Bösendorfer 290SE — while the two sound broadly similar, close examination reveals some significant timbral differences. The Steinway has a warmer, more lyrical tone with more apparent middle energy. It lacks the Bösendorfer's steely, somewhat masculine presence, but sounds more at home in jazz and improvisatory styles — it can even handle intimate solo passages without causing embarrassment. The Old Lady layers with other keyboards like a dream, and sounds great in pop tracks; the only area where it could be said to be slightly deficient are the crashingly bombastic, anvil-like sonorities required for a Bat Out Of Hell-style rock psychodrama. Overall, I enjoyed playing this Steinway piano very much and found it a great sound source for composing and arranging. Sampled pianos can never replace the real thing, but if you're looking for a versatile, classic-sounding instrument which combines strength and beauty of tone with expression and subtlety, this is it. Dave Stewart EXS24, Gigastudio 2 & 3, Halion, or Kontakt DVD-ROM, £115.95; bundle deal with The
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Latest%20Sample%20CDs.htm (5 of 6)9/26/2005 8:17:40 AM
Latest Sample CDs
Emperor, £173.80. Prices include VAT. Time + Space +44 (0)1837 55200. +44 (0)1837 55400. Click here to email www.timespace.com www.postpiano.com Published in SOS November 2004 Sound On Sound, Media House, Trafalgar Way, Bar Hill, Cambridge CB3 8SQ, UK. Email:
[email protected] | Telephone: +44 (0)1954 789888 | Fax: +44 (0)1954 789895
All contents copyright © SOS Publications Group and/or its licensors, 1985-2005. All rights reserved. The contents of this article are subject to worldwide copyright protection and reproduction in whole or part, whether mechanical or electronic, is expressly forbidden without the prior written consent of the Publishers. Great care has been taken to ensure accuracy in the preparation of this article but neither Sound On Sound Limited nor the publishers can be held responsible for its contents. The views expressed are those of the contributors and not necessarily those of the publishers. Web site designed & maintained by PB Associates | SOS | Relative Media
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Latest%20Sample%20CDs.htm (6 of 6)9/26/2005 8:17:40 AM
Plug-In Folder
In this article:
Elemental Audio Eqium & Firium Firium TC Electronic TC30
Plug-In Folder Latest Plug-ins Tested Published in SOS November 2004 Print article : Close window
Reviews : Software
Elemental Audio Eqium & Firium Formats: Mac RTAS, VST & Audio Units; PC RTAS & VST Since analogue EQ is generally considered to be the reference in terms of sonic results, many software EQs attempt to recreate that type of character, and as a side-effect they tend to mimic the specifications, controls, and sometimes even the look of analogue hardware EQs. With Eqium, Elemental Audio have thrown that particular rule-book a considerable distance away, showing a refreshing propensity to think outside of the box. As a result, Eqium offers the user a possibly unparalleled degree of freedom. For a start, Eqium lets you stack as many EQ filters as you wish, provided you have enough CPU power available. Each one of these filters can be parametric, low or high shelf (two types), low-pass, high-pass, bandpass, notch, harmonic 4 or harmonic 8. The latter two may need further explanation: they are parametric filters that are applied automatically not only to a fundamental, but also to its even harmonics, odd harmonics or both, with up to eight instances of the filter in Firium's State Overview mode allows you to total. The gain scale between the view up to 50 stored EQ curves. chosen fundamental (centre frequency) and its harmonics can be constant, increasing or decreasing. Since harmonics are often vital to the timbre of an instrument, these filters are excellent for lifting an individual instrument out of a full mix, provided of course that its pitch does not vary too much. It certainly works well for instance on a repetitive bass note, enhancing its presence in a more natural fashion than could be achieved with a simple parametric EQ. Another nice touch is that, for each active filter, the stereo version of Eqium lets you apply different settings to the left and right channels. This makes a lot of file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Plug-In%20Folder.htm (1 of 6)9/26/2005 8:17:45 AM
Plug-In Folder
sense when working with stereo tracks, especially full mixes that feature different instruments on either side. Furthermore, this stereo functionality is cleverly implemented: it only takes one mouse-click to group or ungroup the left and right sides of a filter, and the filter graph uses three colours to help visualise the left (blue), right (red) and combined (purple) filter curves. Eqium allows you to edit filter settings by dragging 'handles' in the graph, or using cursors and arrows below it. If you use the graph handles, modifer keys allow you to restrict changes to the gain or centre frequency only. The Handlers are used to assign controllers in your host to the filters of your choice. Since you can use any number of filters simultaneously, an effective filter-management system is crucial to easy operation and this is provided as well. The filters can be ordered in the Created Filters area at the bottom left according to their identifier number, L and/or R channel assignment, centre frequency, gain setting, type or associated Handler. While the ergonomic features are too numerous to list comprehensively here, I must also mention the two 'workspaces' (edit buffers) that permit easy A/B comparisons, along with the solo function that allows the effect of a single filter to be monitored at any time. As I suggested at the beginning of this review, Eqium offers a lot of freedom, and the cost of that freedom is immediacy. It's not that Eqium is any more difficult to use than it has to be, considering the extent of its abilities. In fact it is very well thought-out and could hardly be easier to approach. But this is not just a 'plugand-go' equaliser. You will probably need to read the manual, or at least part of it, to get the full benefit of its features. While the manual in question is comprehensive and very well written, anyone seriously involved in music production and sound engineering expects to be able to use an EQ instantly, so the question is, is it worth it? Having tested Eqium on a number of tracks and compared it to a few of its competitors, I found that it held up very well sonically to other software EQs in the same price bracket, while offering more possibilities. When it comes to applying the final tweaks to a finished track, it could easily become your first choice... although Elemental Audio would probably like you to use their Firium mastering EQ for that. Since Eqium only uses CPU power according to the number of filters you activate and is available in mono and stereo, multiple instances can also be used for flexible channel EQ'ing. In short, it may be all that you need. And since a demo version is available, you owe it to yourself to check it out. Personally, I would not want to be without it.
Firium Firium is a specialised stereo mastering EQ that uses Finite Impulse Response filters (FIR — hence its name, I gather), also known as linear-phase filters, and a clever graphical interface to deliver transparent equalisation with extremely precise control. Indeed, since filters of this type introduce a noticeable processing delay, they tend to be used in mastering plug-ins rather than channel plug-ins. If you decide to use Firum for an individual stereo pair of channels anyway, you will find a useful delay indication in the main display (this is invaluable if your host
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Plug-In%20Folder.htm (2 of 6)9/26/2005 8:17:45 AM
Plug-In Folder
does not have automatic plug-in delay compensation). I tested Firium in the Soundscape Editor v4.0 and in Cubase SX 2.0, and the delay was reported as 3072 samples at 44.1kHz and 6144 samples at 96kHz in both programs, on a 1GHz Pentium III PC. The claimed benefit of FIR filters is that the audio does not suffer degradation through phase shift, and indeed Firium is extremely transparent and 'respectful' of the source material. It does not flatter by superimposing its own character on the audio, but nor does it introduce unpredictable artifacts alongside the correction that you apply. Operationally, Firium is reminiscent of a graphic equaliser, in that you can draw a curve in the graph using 50 'control points' that span the frequency range. However, the facilities on offer far exceed those of a traditional graphic EQ. The curve can be shaped in a number of ways. Clicking above or below a control point will cause it to jump to the clicked position. The whole curve can also be drawn freehand by dragging the mouse in the graph. Finer adjustments can then be made by dragging individual control points, or by using the automatic Smooth function, which can be applied repeatedly if necessary. When the mouse pointer is directly on a control point, a circle appears around it to indicate 'coupling mode', in which dragging that control point will also move its neighbours according to a Gaussian (smooth) or geometric (more 'pointy') curve. The degree of coupling can be adjusted. Finally, in 'dynamic mode', the selected (circled) control point is dragged up or down to adjust the gain for the corresponding frequency, while dragging the mouse pointer horizontally will expand or narrow the filter. Further editing can be applied globally: the whole curve can be moved along the gain or frequency axis by using cursors, scaled, or inverted. Two buttons also allow you to move along the history of changes you have made. Now to the deeper stuff: Firum always operates in one of 50 'states', which could be superficially described as EQ programs. You can move from state to state by using the cursor at the top of the Firum window and, of course, all edits made in a particular state are memorised. The big news is that using states allows you to morph between EQ curves. You could for instance create a state 1 EQ curve and a state 33 EQ curve, move to the State Overview mode, use the automatic Fill function to create intermediary EQ curves for states 2 to 32, then automate the movement of the State cursor to move gradually between states. The EQ states can be also be managed (copied or swapped) in State Overview mode, where they are presented as 50 curve diagrams. Note that while the History function keeps track of all the curve changes produced by moving between states, moving the History cursor does not change the current State. It took some file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Plug-In%20Folder.htm (3 of 6)9/26/2005 8:17:45 AM
Plug-In Folder
experimentation to make sure of that, since I did not find confirmation in the otherwise very helpful manual. Just like Eqium, Firium allows separate treatment of the left and right channels and uses different colours to display both curves simultaneously. In this respect Firium is even more flexible than Eqium: the channels can respond completely independently, they can be locked such that the left and right curves are identical and edits are applied to both, or they can be linked in Strong mode (where the overall curves may be different but new edits to a control point in either curve are also applied to the corresponding control point of the other curve) or in Weak mode, where control point edits for either curve are applied relatively to the corresponding control point of the other curve. Firium also features a Match EQ ripping facility. This function analyses the spectral content of two different segments of audio and automatically defines an EQ curve which can then be applied to the 'target' segment so that it matches the frequency response of the 'source' segment. Firum offers so much that I cannot cover everything here. I have focused on the essentials, but rest assured that all the ergonomic features you would expect are implemented, including two edit buffers (A and B) and visualisation of the left and right input and output signals. Overall, Firium is a fantastically flexible mixing tool. It provides excellent results, all the facilities you are likely to need and some that you probably won't need very often. Personally I would rarely use EQ matching, but this may be useful on occasions, for instance to tame excessive differences between successive tracks of an album, or to close the sonic gap between takes by the same performer recorded on different days or in different places. Most importantly, the overall sonic performance of the EQ is extremely good. I found that I could impose a rather large amount of correction without it being obvious, which is always a good sign. Adding 'air' to a track was particularly straightforward and pleasing, and generally, after appropriate adjustment, bypassing Firium caused the material to sound disappointing. At $129, Firium represents excellent value for money. At $169, the Firium/Eqium bundle has no equivalent that I am aware of. A demo version of Firium is available, so you can listen to it, get to grips with its interface and explore its numerous possibilities before deciding whether you want to part with your money. And while you're at it, have a look at the free Inspector analysis plug-in! Vincent Chenais Eqium and Firium $129 each; Firium/Eqium bundle $169. Click here to email www.elementalaudio.com
TC Electronic TC30 Formats: Mac & PC Powercore Though the TC Powercore platform now comes with the Tubifex guitar amp modelling system as standard, TC30 is somewhat more specialised and is file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Plug-In%20Folder.htm (4 of 6)9/26/2005 8:17:45 AM
Plug-In Folder
entirely dedicated to creating an accurate representation of that British classic guitar amplifier, the Vox AC30. We looked into the background of this rather unusual plug-in back in the May 2004 issue of Sound On Sound, where designer Stefan Moeller explained that he wanted to recreate exactly the sound of the Vox AC30 combined with Brian May's treble booster so that he could get that magical Queen guitar sound. The operation of this plug-in is very simple as there are very few controls — the tremolo and top-cut tone control of the original have not been included. The treble booster, which was designed after studying circuits of the analogue original, has an additional three-way 'character' switch for Original, Crunch or Clean, while the Peak switch sets the resonant centre frequency to 0.5kHz, 1kHz, 2kHz or 4kHz to suit the guitar being used. Overdrive is set using the amp's Trim gain control (in conjunction with the treble booster settings) where a four-section LED meter monitors the input level and warns of clipping. You can even choose whether the speakers should 'move' or not as you play! TC's no-latency mode is supported by the plugin, at the expense of increased CPU overhead, and there's also an oversampling mode for even better sonic fidelity that eats more heavily into the Powercore card's resources. So far then, this looks disarmingly simple, but the real surprise is how good it sounds. It may not have many tonal tricks, but it responds beautifully to playing intensity and it captures that magical class-A guitar amp feel perfectly. I used to own two original Vox AC30s and I wasn't all that impressed with them, as to get a good sound, you had to turn them up so loud that everyone left! With this little plug-in, you can get that classic sound at any volume and it really works, especially if you have a Fender Strat, as it captures those hollow 'on the edge of distortion' tones marvellously well. Jimi Hendrix may have used a Marshall stack, but you can get 'that sound' very easily using TC30, providing you have the playing moves to go with it. Having played with TC30 for a while, I think it is fair to say that it is strongest when dealing with bluesy tones, jangly clean tones or vintage pop sounds. It's a shame that the top boost channel and tremolo of the original haven't been included, but perhaps that's something for a future update? With the treble booster on full thrust, the Brian May sound is uncannily accurate, but again you have to be able to play like the man to sound like him, so my tests were quite limited in this respect! However, I hear Brian has a Powercore and a copy of TC30 himself now, so if you're reading this Brian, please let us know what you make of it. Paul White 252.63 Euros including VAT.
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Plug-In%20Folder.htm (5 of 6)9/26/2005 8:17:45 AM
Plug-In Folder
TC Electronic UK +44 (0)800 917 8926. +44 (0)800 917 6510. Click here to email www.tcelectronic.com Published in SOS November 2004 Sound On Sound, Media House, Trafalgar Way, Bar Hill, Cambridge CB3 8SQ, UK. Email:
[email protected] | Telephone: +44 (0)1954 789888 | Fax: +44 (0)1954 789895
All contents copyright © SOS Publications Group and/or its licensors, 1985-2005. All rights reserved. The contents of this article are subject to worldwide copyright protection and reproduction in whole or part, whether mechanical or electronic, is expressly forbidden without the prior written consent of the Publishers. Great care has been taken to ensure accuracy in the preparation of this article but neither Sound On Sound Limited nor the publishers can be held responsible for its contents. The views expressed are those of the contributors and not necessarily those of the publishers. Web site designed & maintained by PB Associates | SOS | Relative Media
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Plug-In%20Folder.htm (6 of 6)9/26/2005 8:17:45 AM
SE Electronics Icis
In this article:
Session Notes
SE Electronics Icis £349 pros Sensible cost. Comes with shockmount and hard case. Warm, articulate sound.
SE Electronics Icis Valve Microphone Published in SOS November 2004 Print article : Close window
Reviews : Microphone
cons No pad or LF roll-off switches.
summary This is a very solidly built and nice-sounding tube microphone that comes without the excessive price tag of the acknowledged studio classics.
A strikingly styled new valve mic offers a sound inspired by vintage classics. Paul White
SE Electronics' Icis microphone is one of the company's new range of models and seems to information be aimed both at the professional user and the more serious project-studio owner. Although £349 including VAT. Sonic Distribution +44 (0) priced above the budget 'me too' market, this cardioid-pattern mic is still very attractively 1525 840400. +44 (0)1582 843901. priced in the UK for such a well-specified and Click here to email solidly engineered tube microphone. It has a distinctive domed grille housing a 1.07-inch www.soniccapsule featuring a gold-sputtered, edgedistribution.com terminated diaphragm, and it comes complete www.seelectronics.com with a massively constructed shockmount that reminds me somewhat of the Deep Space Nine space station! This shockmount has a heavy metal sleeve at its core, and the Icis fits neatly Photo: Mike Cameron into this, secured by a chunky locking ring at the bottom of the mic. You need to fasten the shockmount's swivel nut tightly to prevent drooping, as the combination of mic and shockmount is pretty weighty, but once secure everything seems to stay put. Also included is the necessary power supply and cable, all contained in a hard camera-style case — the mic has its own hardwood case that fits inside the camera case. The cable attaching to the mic uses an eight-pin locking militarygrade connector, while the signal output from the PSU box is a conventional balanced three-pin XLR. There are no pad or filter switches either on the mic or on the PSU, though there is a recessed mains voltage switch to select 230V or 110V operation. Power comes in on a standard IEC mains lead, and there's a mains switch on the PSU. As the mic has its own power supply, it doesn't need phantom power. file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/SE%20Electronics%20Icis.htm (1 of 3)9/26/2005 8:17:48 AM
SE Electronics Icis
Like many classic mics, the tubular casework of the Icis is machined from brass and secured with a threaded end cap, the removal of which allows access to the circuitry. A 12AX7 dual-triode valve is used for the preamp circuit in combination with low-noise Japanese components and high-quality glass-fibre circuit boards, so although the mic is designed to appeal to those who like the sound and the classic styling of retro tube mics, nobody needs to put up with classic noise, high cost, or poor spares availability. Unlike some so-called tube mics that use the tube mainly for cosmetic purposes, the circuitry here is all-tube, with a transformer-balanced output, and the tube runs with a suitably high anode voltage, which is necessary to allow the tube to perform correctly. The body of the mic is finished in a new grey matt-finish paint, and though I've experienced finger-marking problems with some earlier SE mics, this new paint seems to have remedied that particular shortcoming. Rather than use screen printing, the SE logo (which denotes the live side of the mic) is embossed, and the model number and company name are engraved through the paintwork into the brass beneath. As expected, the grille is of dual-mesh construction to provide both electrical screening and physical protection for the capsule, and it is finished in satin nickel. In all, the quality of finish is excellent, and the weight of metal used in the construction is impressive! The overall size is 60 x 205mm. The frequency response of the microphone covers the full audio range of 20Hz-20kHz with a respectable weighted output noise figure of 16dB. Examination of the response curve reveals a gentle low-end roll-off starting at around 100Hz, augmented by a wide, smooth presence peak rising to around +5dB at 12kHz. Off axis, the mic exhibits a mid-range dip, which imparts a kind of loudness 'smile curve' character to the sound, though in most applications this type of microphone would tend to be used fairly close and on axis. The sensitivity of the mic is 20mV/Pa and the maximum SPL for 0.5 percent THD at 1000 Hz is 130dB. These figures are fairly typical for this type of microphone, but the specifications only tell part of the story. What really The ECC83 valve at the matters is how the microphone sounds, and largeheart of the Icis is diaphragm mics like this tend to be built with a sound in socketed for easy replacement. mind rather than being designed for absolute accuracy. The manufacturers recommend the microphone for studio vocals, choirs, classical instruments, and wind instruments, though it is also proved itself to be well suited to acoustic-guitar recording, where it turned in a warm, solid sound with plenty of high-end detail.
Session Notes
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/SE%20Electronics%20Icis.htm (2 of 3)9/26/2005 8:17:48 AM
SE Electronics Icis
I checked out the Icis on a studio session where I needed to record voice and acoustic guitar at the same time. The Icis was used as the vocal mic, where it delivered a very natural sound that was simultaneously warm, dense, and articulate, without any of the annoying nasal characteristics that some cardioid mics exhibit. It needs to be used with a good pop shield as, like most largediaphragm mics, it is prone to popping when it's close-miking vocals, but that's normal behaviour for this kind of microphone. Switching the mic onto acoustic guitar also confirmed that the Icis is a good performer in that area too, and though a large-diaphragm mic may not be the obvious choice for acoustic instruments, the warm and subtly flattering nature of the sound can sometimes be helpful. In conclusion, I think SE have got this design about right, as it delivers a sound reminiscent of classic mics but without sounding hyped, forced, or aggressive. It manages to combine smoothness with detail and responds well to EQ when needed. Noise was never a problem, though users without a low-cut filter switch on their desk or preamp might miss not having one on the mic. Having said that, if you use a nice mic like this one with a cheapo mixer or preamp that doesn't have the requisite functions, you're probably not going to do it justice anyway. So, if you're in the market for a properly designed tube mic that can deliver the goods and look impressive without costing silly money, you owe it to yourself to add the SE Icis to your list of 'must try' mics. Published in SOS November 2004 Sound On Sound, Media House, Trafalgar Way, Bar Hill, Cambridge CB3 8SQ, UK. Email:
[email protected] | Telephone: +44 (0)1954 789888 | Fax: +44 (0)1954 789895
All contents copyright © SOS Publications Group and/or its licensors, 1985-2005. All rights reserved. The contents of this article are subject to worldwide copyright protection and reproduction in whole or part, whether mechanical or electronic, is expressly forbidden without the prior written consent of the Publishers. Great care has been taken to ensure accuracy in the preparation of this article but neither Sound On Sound Limited nor the publishers can be held responsible for its contents. The views expressed are those of the contributors and not necessarily those of the publishers. Web site designed & maintained by PB Associates | SOS | Relative Media
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/SE%20Electronics%20Icis.htm (3 of 3)9/26/2005 8:17:48 AM
Steinberg Cubase SX 3
In this article:
Steinberg Cubase SX 3
Warp Factor 10 MIDI + Audio Sequencer (PC & Mac OSX) And That's Not All Published in SOS November 2004 Quality, Performance & Freezing Print article : Close window Colour Me Bad Reviews : Software Play (Order) It Again, Sam Video Killed The Play Order Star Mapping It Out No Need To Open The Cubase SX 3 is the latest incarnation of one of the Editor On My Account... best-known brands in sequencing software, offering Performance & System many new features and tying up the loose ends from Requirements previous generations of Cubase. But with increased Key Improvements competition, most notably from Apple and Cakewalk, In, Out, Route It All About can Steinberg maintain their cross-platform Your Assignment, Should advantage? You Choose To Accept It Automated Improvements It's About Time Mark Wherry It's The Little Things... Do You Think I'm S3Xy?
For Stanley Adams, a day made a big difference. For Steinberg, however, a Steinberg Cubase SX 3 year seems to make a far bigger £570 difference. Since the first release of pros Cubase SX in 2002, the company Audio Warping allows audio to be time-stretched and pitch- started a trend of releasing a new version of this popular Windows and shifted in real time, which offers an enhanced method of Mac sequencing application each working with audio loops. successive year: 2003 saw the release The Play Order Track offers of Cubase SX 2, and now, in 2004, we a new, flexible approach to have the third version of Cubase SX. trying out different arrangement ideas. MIDI Device Panels enable external MIDI gear to be used in the same way as VST Instruments when working with MIDI tracks. A large number of improvements that might not sound exciting, but will certainly improve your workflow.
Audio Warping brings real-time pitch-shifting and time-stretching to Cubase SX. Here you can see a multitrack audio Project where each Event is being 'warped' so that it stays locked to the Project's Tempo Track. Note the main text to see why the performance meter is interesting here, and also notice how much smaller tracks can now appear in the Project window in version 3.
As with previous version of SX, Cubase and Nuendo, Steinberg's postproduction-oriented media production system, share a common programming foundation, meaning that Cubase SX 3 includes many of the improvements that went into later version of Nuendo, as well as being the first of the two applications to be released with the new version 3 code base. Long-time cons Steinberg users will remember that this situation is the reverse of last year's Some of the synchronisation round of upgrades, where Nuendo was first application out of Hamburg with the file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Steinberg%20Cubase%20SX%203.htm (1 of 19)9/26/2005 8:17:55 AM
Steinberg Cubase SX 3
features still need a little attention. Large Projects can still take a few minutes to load, and the general performance of the application can still suffer when working with large number of tracks.
version 2 code, with the upgrade to Cubase following a month or so later. This year, Nuendo users can expect an upgrade to follow, if history is to repeat itself, that encompasses all of the features described in the following review, along with some additional enhancements aimed specifically at Nuendo users. But for now, let's investigate what new features lie in wait for Cubase users in this latest version.
summary In this third version of SX, Cubase is now starting to feel like a mature sequencing application again, with almost all of shortcomings from previous versions addressed, and features that were lacking compared to previous generations of Cubase replaced with much improved solutions.
Warp Factor 10 One of Steinberg's headline features for Cubase SX 3 is the new audio 'warping' feature, which builds Acid, Live, or Garage Band-like functionality for pitchshifting and time-stretching audio in real time directly into Cubase. The basic operation of Audio Warping is fairly straightforward, and the process of taking a pre-recorded audio loop into Cubase and getting it to play in time with the Project usually takes just a few mouse clicks.
information Once you have imported an audio file, all you need to do is open it in the Sample Editor, select the new, snappily named Audio Tempo Definition Tool to detect the tempo and length of the Audio Event, and activate Musical Mode for that Event. Many www.arbitergroup.com Setting up an Audio Event for warp speed users will welcome the fact Cubase www.steinberg.net (groan...) is easy with the new Audio Tempo now imports Acid files and will Definition Tool, which you can see selected automatically extract the tempo and here. Test Spec length information for you and activate Cubase SX 3.0 build 339/357. Musical Mode. With Musical Mode active, the Warp icon will glow orange in the Sample Editor and you can configure the Warp Setting from a pop-up menu, Desktop PC with Intel 3.2GHz Xeon, Intel which includes a variety of presets to choose the type of material, such as SE7501HG2 motherboard, Drums, Plucked or Vocals, along with an Advanced Setting to configure the Grain 2GB registered ECC DDR266 size, Overlap and Variance parameters manually. RAM, two ATI Radeon 9200 £569.99 including VAT. Arbiter Music Technology +44 (0)20 8970 1909. +44 (0)20 8202 7076. Click here to email
PCI graphics cards, Intel SRCS14L SATA RAID controller, 7200rpm HGST SATA drives, RME HDSP 9652 audio card, one Emagic Unitor 8 and seven AMT8 MIDI interfaces, running Windows XP Professional. IBM X40 laptop with 512MB PC2700 RAM, Intel Extreme Graphics 2 onboard video, 40GB 4200rpm hard drive, Echo Indigo I/O audio card, Edirol PCR1 USB keyboard, running Windows XP Professional.
Using the Audio Tempo Definition Tool is fairly simple and Cubase will make its best guess at the tempo as soon the tool is selected — as long as the audio loop is cut to fit an exact length, setting the correct number of bars and beats for the loop is usually enough. However, even if your loop isn't cut to length, Cubase lets you set start and end points within the Sample Editor, and you can drag the bar and beat division lines with the Tempo Definition Tool, just as you could with the Time Warp tool when building tempo maps, to assist Cubase in finding the tempo of the loop. Any operation you undertake with the Tempo Definition Tool has no effect on the timeline or tempo of the Project, as Cubase switches from the Project's timeline to an independent timeline in the Sample Editor just for that loop when the tool is chosen. Once you have set up an Audio Event for Audio Warping, as described earlier, it will now always play back at the current tempo of the Project, and while in the
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Steinberg%20Cubase%20SX%203.htm (2 of 19)9/26/2005 8:17:55 AM
Steinberg Cubase SX 3
past it was usually possible to get this far for material such as drum or bass loops by slicing them up, Audio Warping now lets you do the same for content that wouldn't be suitable for slicing, such as a guitar or vocal part. However, the really neat thing is that (like Acid and Live, admittedly) 'warped' audio will also follow tempo changes, no matter how tricky. Setting up your audio to play over a ramped Tempo Event, for example, is a especially neat way of seeing this, particularly in a multitrack example.
And That's Not All If Audio Warping stopped there, it would be a useful tool and a great addition to Cubase. However, Steinberg have gone much further and made it possible to 'warp' certain parts of an Audio Event differently without affecting the rest of the Event. If you select the new Warp Samples tool you can create so-called Warp Tabs, which can be thought of in a similar way to Hitpoints — indeed, rather than create Warp Tabs manually for each beat of an Audio Event, you can instead create Hitpoints and use the new the Create Warp Tabs From Hitpoints command in the Audio / Realtime Processing menu. Once you've created some Warp Tabs, you can drag them with the Warp Samples tool to time-stretch a section of the Audio Event. The Warp Tab you drag acts as a midpoint between two other Warp Tabs (or the start and end of the Audio Event), so if you drag the Warp Tab backwards, for example, the audio in front of the Tab is expanded and the audio behind the Tab is squashed up. This basically does for audio what the Time Warp tool did for MIDI in SX 2 — and the great thing about Musical Mode Audio Warping is that the Time Warp tool can now work with audio as well, since 'warped' audio always follows the Project's tempo.
The Play Order Track is a flexible new feature in SX 3 that allows you to easily try out different arrangement ideas within a Project. Notice the Play Order Transport controls in the Play Order Editor window and on the Project window's toolbar, and the way that many of the Play Order Editor window's lists are duplicated in the Inspector.
A good example of where Warp Tabs can be useful is when you might have a bass note that just misses the beat. By creating three Warp Tabs (one on the previous note, one on the out-of-time note, and one on the next note), you can drag the out-of-time note on to the beat and have Cubase time-stretch everything to fit — pretty neat. And Steinberg's developers have actually gone one step further and implemented a Quantise Audio command, whereby all Warp Tabs in an Audio Event can be moved to fall on a beat within the Project's current timeline. As mentioned earlier, the Audio Warping feature in Cubase SX 3 also allows realfile:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Steinberg%20Cubase%20SX%203.htm (3 of 19)9/26/2005 8:17:55 AM
Steinberg Cubase SX 3
time pitch-shifting, and you can now transpose an Audio Event in exactly the same way you would transpose a MIDI Part on the Project window. Simply select the Audio Event (or Events) you want to transpose and adjust the Transpose parameter on the Event Infoline in the Project window — unlike the timestretching features of Audio Warping, no setup or configuration is required for this to work. The Transpose parameter, as with MIDI Parts, allows you to transpose Audio Events up or down by the specified number of semitones, and alongside this parameter is a Fine Tune setting, which allows you to adjust the pitch of the audio in cents. While this feature works well, the only problem is that if you're trying to run Cubase on a 1024 x 768 display, the Event Infoline is actually too small to even see the Transpose and Fine Tune parameters, so you have to temporarily make your Project window bigger than your display to access these settings. It's a shame they don't appear in the Project Browser to provide an alternative workaround.
Quality, Performance & Freezing The quality of the results when using the Audio Warping is pretty reasonable, especially, as with all time-stretching and pitch-shifting operations, when you don't stray too far from the original tempo of pitch. And the great thing is that the performance drain on your computer is pretty minimal. I wrote the text for this review on an IBM Thinkpad X40, a small sub-notebook that I use for day-to-day tasks which has a 1.2GHz Pentium-M processor, integrated graphics, 512MB RAM and a 40GB 4200rpm hard drive — in other words, not the kind of laptop you'd normally replace your studio with! However, with one of Steinberg's demo songs that consisted of a combination of 38 16-bit mono and stereo audio tracks, all with Warped Audio Events, my CPU use was less than 50 percent, even with a couple of plug-in effects and instruments on top. If you find the quality of the Audio Warping not entirely satisfactory with certain material, once you've got the tempo of your audio basically correct using the realtime features, you can freeze the processing with the Freeze Time-Stretching and Transpose command. This creates a new file based on the higher-quality MPEX algorithm, although if you're freezing a selection of Events based on the same file, you need to make sure you create independent Events so that new files are created for each instance of the same Event. In addition to the new Audio Warping features, there are many other improvements for working with audio in SX 3, especially regarding the Freeze feature implemented in SX 2. The Freeze function only worked on VST Instruments in SX 2, but SX 3 adds a Freeze button to every audio track/channel so that you can freeze an audio channel to reduce the CPU load by removing the need for audio insert plug-ins to work in real-time. This seems to work pretty well and when you unfreeze an audio channel, Cubase gives you the option of deleting the Freeze files that were created or keeping them for future use. The functionality for freezing VST Instruments has also been improved so that file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Steinberg%20Cubase%20SX%203.htm (4 of 19)9/26/2005 8:17:55 AM
Steinberg Cubase SX 3
you can now either freeze just the VST Instrument, leaving any insert effects used on VST Instrument channels active, or both the VST Instrument and any insert effects on the corresponding VST Instrument channels. There's also a handy option for unloading the VST Instrument from memory (while still keeping it in the VST Instrument rack for unfreezing later) once you have frozen its output. This is a much-needed feature, especially when using VST Instruments that use a large amount of memory, such as software samplers, as in previous versions the extra CPU power saved by the Freeze feature was often negated by the fact there was no more memory available to load additional VST Instruments.
Colour Me Bad One area of Cubase that's been improved in SX 3 is the use of colour for tracks, channels and Parts, which has definitely been taken somewhere over the rainbow, way up high — and beyond — in this release. In past releases, the only way you could see what colour you had assigned to a track was to have a Part on that track set to Default Colour, but now there's a new Show Track Colours button at the top of the Track List that, when enabled, adds a block of colour framed behind the track's Level Meter to show what colour has been assigned, in a similar way to Logic. The track's colour is also displayed behind the track's name in the General section of the Inspector, and also on that track's channel on the mixer, just below the level meter. This definitely improves clarity, but I think it would help more on the mixer if there was some way of making the colouring vertically deeper as it becomes hard to distinguish colours when there are a large number of channels on screen, especially when the mixer is set to Narrow View. In addition to the Colour pop-up menu on the Project window's toolbar, you can now also assign a track's colour by clicking on the colour bar in the Track List or clicking on the small arrow in the General section of the Inspector. On the mixer, you can also change the colour by clicking on the colour bar just below the level meter. The only thing I'd really like to see in terms of assigning colours to tracks is an automatic option, where the next colour in the list is assigned to a newly created track, cycling through the available colours, which could definitely save time. SX 3 also features a new Colour tool, which looks like a paint bucket and allows you to colour the currently selected Part (or Parts) via one simple click with the currently selected colour. The colour to be used by the Colour tool can be selected by clicking the small colour bar under the Colour tool, or you can choose the colour at the time you click on the selected Part (or Parts) by Shift-clicking instead, which displays a colour pop-up to pick a colour to colour the current selection. You can also change the selected colour based on the colour of another Part by clicking the Part with the Colour tool and the Alt/Option key held down, which changes the pointer into a ink droplet instead to sample the colour. I'll leave it there in case you feel like you've mistakenly stumbled across a review of Photoshop instead of Cubase — but It's safe to say that colour is not a problem with SX 3.
Play (Order) It Again, Sam
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Steinberg%20Cubase%20SX%203.htm (5 of 19)9/26/2005 8:17:55 AM
Steinberg Cubase SX 3
The audio warping features will certainly appeal and be useful to many users, but I have to say that my favourite new feature in SX 3 is probably the Play Order Track. In the days before graphical arrange windows, most sequencers were pattern-oriented, meaning that you would sequence a collection of patterns and later choose a playback order for these patterns as a way of creating an arrangement. C-Lab's (and later Emagic's) Notator on the Atari was possibly the best-implemented example of this, and since everyone has progressed to graphical arrange windows, various attempts at incorporating the better points of pattern-based sequencing have been made over the years. The original Cubase had Groups (not to be confused with SX's Grouping of Tracks and Group Tracks), SX had Folder Tracks with Folder Parts that could potentially be used to contain whole songs, while Logic has (and Vision had) the 'arrange window within an arrange window' approach to Folders for pattern arranging. The Play Order Track in Cubase SX 3, however, is perhaps the best attempt yet to bring together the best aspects of both graphical arranging and patternbased sequencing, building on a concept not dissimilar to Cubase's original Groups. As you might expect, a Play Order Track is an actual track that appears on the Project window, and it behaves in a similar way to the Marker Track in that you can only have Here is the somewhat daunting editor window for a MIDI Device, where you can one Play Order Track in a Project. The create Panels to be displayed in various basic principle is that a Play Order parts of the application. Notice the main Track contains Play Order Parts, which editor area in the middle, the subnode list to are created like any other type of Part the left, and the available object pool to the right, which shows the styles of fader in the Event Display, and via the Play available for your Panels. Order Editor window or the Play Order Track's Inspector you can arrange the Play Order Parts into a Play Order. The Play Order Parts are by default named 'A' through to 'Z', although you can rename them, and a Part is added to the current order simply by double-clicking it, or dragging it from the list of Parts to the Play Order List in the editor window or Inspector. You can specify how many times a Play Order Part should be played in a given entry on the Play Order List, so a typical Play Order might be to play 'A' twice, 'B' once, 'A' again, 'C', and, of course, 'A' to finish. Play Order Parts can overlap, whereby an overlapped Part is displayed smaller so you can see the different Parts more clearly, and it's possible to have multiple Play Order Lists in a Project. The icing on the cake with the Play Order Track is that once you have a Play Order you like, you can 'flatten' it out into one linear Project, removing the Play Order Track altogether, by clicking the appropriately named Flatten Play Order button in the editor window. In order to control the Play Order Track during playback, a new set of Transport controls is available to the Transport Panel and Project window's toolbar, in
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Steinberg%20Cubase%20SX%203.htm (6 of 19)9/26/2005 8:17:55 AM
Steinberg Cubase SX 3
addition to the Play Order editor window. For a Play Order to play back you need to activate Play Order Mode with the appropriate button, and in this mode Cycle Mode becomes unavailable, meaning that you can either work with Play Order or Cycle Mode, but not both at the same time. This makes sense, since looping or skipping a section while playing back a Play Order would really confuse matters. In addition to toggling Play Order Mode, the transport controls also enable you to step through each Play Order Part in the list, or each iteration of a given Play Order Part. All in all, the Play Order Track is an incredibly useful arranging tool that allows you to try out different arrangement ideas on an existing Project, or build up more abstract Projects that consist of sections arranged together with various Play Orders. A film composer, for example, could have all of his or her ideas and themes for a film in one Project and construct various ideas for cues from different Play Orders, saving a new Project when he has something that works and flattening the Play Order to work on the cue in more detail.
Video Killed The Play Order Star My biggest problem with the Play Order Track, especially given the previous filmoriented example, is that there are some real issues to be resolved when running with video. If you're trying to use Cubase's internal Video playback window, forget it! The Video window will only play back assuming you have your first Play Order Part starting at the beginning of the Project; and even if this is the case, the video will only play back for the duration of that first Play Order Part. Unusable is the word that springs to mind. If you're running video on a separate machine slaved via MIDI Time Code (MTC), you have slightly more luck. Cubase's new 'MIDI Time Code follows Project time' option in the Synchronisation Setup window allows MTC to run continuously if disabled (see the 'That Sync'ing Feeling' box), which means you can run your Play Order back with video slaved via MTC — so long as you start from the beginning. And that's the problem. With this method of working, if you start playback part of the way through a Play Order, Cubase will start outputting MTC based on the actual SMPTE time position of the Project Cursor against the Ruler, ignoring the Play Order altogether. In other words, the Play Order Track doesn't work out what the SMPTE time would be based on the length of time that would have elapsed by that point based on the Play Order, which is a bit of a shame. Hopefully these issues will be resolved shortly so that media composer can make full use of this great feature.
Mapping It Out One feature long-time Cubase users might have missed in SX is Mixer Maps: the ability to create on-screen control panels to remotely access the parameters on file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Steinberg%20Cubase%20SX%203.htm (7 of 19)9/26/2005 8:17:55 AM
Steinberg Cubase SX 3
your external MIDI hardware. But Mixer Maps are to be missed no longer because they've been reborn as MIDI Device Panels in Cubase SX 3, incorporated into the functionality of a newly designed MIDI Device Manager. And the best thing about MIDI Device Panels in SX 3 is that, unlike the Mixer Maps of old, a MIDI Device Panel doesn't just have to appear in its own dedicated window, because you can also create Device Panels that appear in the new User Panel Section of the Inspector and Extended Channel Strip on the Mixer. Very useful. Rather than being incorporated into the lower part of the MIDI Device Manager window as before, MIDI Devices now have a dedicated editor window, which can be opened by selecting the device to be edited in the MIDI Device Manager and clicking Open Device. By default, the MIDI Device's editor window shows the Panel (if one is defined) for that device, and this window also incorporates Read and Write Automation buttons so you can read and write automation for MIDI Device Panels in exactly the same way you would for effect and instrument plugins, along with a Preset menu to store snapshots of parameters. Incidentally, this editor window can also be opened by clicking the Open Device button in a MIDI track or channel's controls or the Key Editor, just as you would usually click this button to open a VST Instrument's editor window for a track assigned to a plug-in. Clicking the MIDI Device editor window's Edit button switches the window into edit mode, where you can create or edit MIDI Device Panels, or configure banks and patch names in the same way you would in previous versions of the MIDI Device Manager. Creating your first MIDI Device Panel can seem a little daunting initially, although once you've built your first Panel (with a little help from the manual and other pre-made Panels), everything starts to make a little more sense. MIDI Device Panels can be displayed in both the Inspector and the Extended Channel Strip, as shown here with the example Virus C Panel included with SX 3. Note the pop-up menu that appears, allowing you to choose a suitable User Panel to display.
In the MIDI Device's editor, a hierarchical view of the Device is displayed in the top left of the window and Panels can be attached to a Device directly, along with any of that Device's Subnodes. A Subnode is basically a logical way of breaking down the complexity of a MIDI Device into smaller building blocks, and each of these building blocks is represented by a Subnode. For example, a simple synthesizer might feature the following Subnodes: Oscillator, LFO, Filter and Amplifier. Each of these Subnodes has a collection of parameters associated with it and would also have a Panel attached for the appropriate controls. The Panel from each Subnode can later be used to build a full Device Panel using the templates feature, and the included Virus C MIDI Device Panel is a good example of this,
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Steinberg%20Cubase%20SX%203.htm (8 of 19)9/26/2005 8:17:55 AM
Steinberg Cubase SX 3
as shown in the screenshots on the previous page. To get you started with MIDI Device Panels, Steinberg include a selection with Cubase for devices such as Access's Virus C, Oberheim's Matrix 1000, Roland's JV1080, MC303, MC505 and XP50, and TC Electronic's Finaliser. Not all of these are recent units, of course, but they could be useful just for figuring out how MIDI Device Panels should be put together, even if you don't actually own one of them. Fortunately, old Mixer Maps from Cubase VST can be imported, although I didn't have a chance to try this myself, and hopefully, as with the Mixer Maps of old, suitable Panels from various enthusiasts will start appearing on the Web. The implementation of MIDI Device Panels is really well thought-out and consistent, enabling you to use VST Instruments and external MIDI hardware in much the same way in Cubase. The ability to include Panels in the Inspector and the Extended Channel Strip is really neat, and I really hope Steinberg develop a feature like this for displaying certain controls from plug-ins in these areas of the application as well.
No Need To Open The Editor On My Account... One interesting new editing option for MIDI Parts in SX 3 in the Edit In-Place function, which, when enabled for a given track, presents a version of the Key Editor in that MIDI track's lane in the Project window. This means the actual MIDI Events get displayed on a piano-roll-style grid (just as you would expect) in the Project window, enabling you to edit MIDI Events directly on the Project window. This is a feature Pro Tools has had for some time in the absence of separate MIDI editor windows, and it can be pretty handy, especially since the Project window's implementation of the Key Editor also includes the ability to show one or more Controller Lanes for editing controller data. Since many of the toolbar functions are very similar between the Project window and Key Editor, the Edit InPlace function bases most of its operations, such as Snap and The new Edit In-Place function brings the Quantise features, on the current Key Editor to the Project window, allowing you to edit the MIDI Events within a Part on settings of the Project window, and a the corresponding MIDI track's lane on the selected note (or notes) on the Project Project window. Notice how the Edit In-Place window displays its information in that function also includes multiple Controller window's Event Infoline. For the Key Lanes, just like the Key Editor. Editor functions that aren't duplicated on the Project window, a secondary pop-up toolbar can be displayed by clicking on a triangle that appears in the topright area of the track in the track list, and this provides Audition and Edit Active Part toggles, a Part List pop-up menu, Insert Velocity and Length Quantise settings, and the colour mode to use for displaying notes and controller data. You file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Steinberg%20Cubase%20SX%203.htm (9 of 19)9/26/2005 8:17:55 AM
Steinberg Cubase SX 3
can scroll the piano keyboard by dragging up and down to the left of the keyboard, and dragging left and right in this same space changes the vertical zoom factor used. The Edit In-Place feature can be used on multiple tracks simultaneously, and definitely comes in handy when you want to make a quick edit on a note without breaking the flow of using the Project window. The ability to line other Events up against certain notes is also very useful, since it's possible for all Events to now be displayed against one timeline — MIDI, Audio, Automation, Markers, and so on — except, sadly, for Tempo and Time Signature Events. When Edit In-Place is active on a track, the notes take priority over the Part that contains them, meaning that if you drag a selection box around a track you're editing, along with Parts on other tracks, it's the notes that will be selected on the track with Edit In-Place active, rather than the Part. Similarly, although you can resize Parts while using Edit In-Place mode, you won't be able to create new or move existing Parts, which is a shame. For future Cubase versions, it might be nice to be able to still work with Parts while Edit In-Place mode is active, especially since you can still see them in the lower area of the Track Lane.
Performance & System Requirements To help improve performance with the latest systems, SX 3 includes a number of specific optimisations, including better support for Intel's Prescott generation of Pentium 4s The MMC Master Device enables incoming (which presumably means SSE3 MTC to be monitored and provides a way of support), and IBM's G5 processor remote controlling the transport of external used by Apple. There is also devices. support for the upcoming Windows XP 64-bit Edition, a preview version of which can already be downloaded from Microsoft's web site for users of either AMD's AMD64 or Intel's EMT64 platforms. The big difference here is the ability for Cubase SX to address up to 4GB of RAM, which is useful when running software samplers such as Halion that benefit from being able to address more memory, as opposed to the current 2GB limitations in Windows XP and Mac OS 10.3. The forthcoming Mac OS 10.4 Tiger release should overcome these issues for G5 users, as discussed in September's Apple Notes (www.soundonsound.com/sos/ sep04/articles/applenotes.htm). Although I do have a dual-Opteron system on which I could have installed Cubase SX 3, there's something of a shortage of suitable 64-bit drivers for audio cards, with M Audio being the only manufacturer I know of to date who have released at least beta 64-bit drivers for AMD users. Unfortunately, I wasn't able to get my hands on a suitable card to make any useful comments about running Cubase SX on a 64-bit operating system, so I'll follow this up in a subsequent SOS article when I can make some worthwhile comparisons. In terms of requirements for running Cubase SX 3, Steinberg recommend a minimum of an 800MHz Pentium or Athlon processor running Windows XP with file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Steinberg%20Cubase%20SX%203.htm (10 of 19)9/26/2005 8:17:55 AM
Steinberg Cubase SX 3
MME-compatible audio hardware, or an 867MHz G4 processor running Mac OS 10.3.3 or higher, 384MB RAM, a DVD-ROM drive, a free USB port for the copy protection, and a display resolution of at least 1024 x 768 pixels. However, Steinberg's suggested requirements for a smoother ride are to have a 2.8GHz Pentium or Athlon processor, or a dual-1.8GHz G5 Power Mac or better, 512MB RAM, ASIOor Core Audio-compatible audio hardware for Windows and Mac users respectively, and a dual-screen setup with each display offering a resolution of 1152 x 864 pixels. However, there is still no support for accessing multiple audio I/ O devices in the Mac version of SX 3. The performance of Cubase SX 3 is generally The Synchronisation Setup good, although large Projects can still take window has been redesigned in slightly longer to load than you might like, and SX 3 to make it easier to once you start to work with Projects containing understand the settings and how several hundred tracks, you'll notice it can take they interact with each other. tens of seconds to add VST Instruments and effects plug-ins to the Project, which is apparently due to calculations required for Cubase's plug-in delay compensation. However, handling of large Projects, loading times, accessing the copy-protection device and delay compensation calculation has improved since SX 2, so at least Steinberg are going in the right direction. That Sync'ing Feeling The Synchronisation Setup window has been completely redesigned in SX 3 to improve clarity and demonstrate the logical flow of the various settings and how they affect other settings in the same window. Along with this improvement is a noticeably better MIDI Machine Control (MMC) implementation, which now offers a new MMC Master window so that when Cubase is an MMC master you can monitor the incoming MTC loop back, in addition to remotely arming tracks. I tried using this feature with Cubase as my MMC master and Pro Tools as my MMC slave and all seemed to work well, although Cubase SX can also operate as an MMC slave with the MMC Slave Device available from the Device Setup window. If I was being picky, I'd say it might be more convenient if the MMC Slave and Master settings were both in the Synchronisation Setup window. The MIDI Time Code Destinations group now contains a new 'MIDI Time Code follows Project time' option, which, when enabled, means that the outgoing MIDI Time Code should always match where the Project cursor is in the timeline. It's useful to disable this for features such as Play Order (discussed in the main text) or Cycle Mode, so you can try out different structural ideas while keeping a slaved machine playing back linearly without staying locked to the absolute SMPTE time in the Cubase Project. However, one curious thing I noticed is that even when this new option is enabled, once playback has commenced, locating a new playback spot in the Ruler has no effect on the slaved machine, so it keeps playing back as if nothing had changed. You have to stop and restart the playback so that a slaved machine can relock.
Key Improvements file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Steinberg%20Cubase%20SX%203.htm (11 of 19)9/26/2005 8:17:55 AM
Steinberg Cubase SX 3
In addition to now appearing in the Project window, the Key Editor itself also features some useful improvements in SX 3. Perhaps the most important is that you can now see controller data in the Controller Lanes for Parts other than the active Part when you have multiple Parts displayed in the Key Editor at the same time. This was particularly annoying in version 2 and it's great to see this has been addressed in the new release. One other nice thing about this new behaviour is that when you create controller data over a region from the active Part into a different Part, the controller data is created in the appropriate Part, rather than only in the active Part as before. The Controller Lane now features an incoming data indicator that displays the current value of the data on a given Controller Lane as it comes into Cubase, just like the similar feature in Cubase VST. So if you're editing volume in a Controller Lane, the incoming value of any volume data is displayed to the right of the Controller Lane, and if you're editing velocity, the current velocity of any notes you play on your MIDI controller will be displayed. Key command fans will appreciate the fact you can now access the first 16 Controller Lane presets via key commands, up from five in the previous version, although it would be really good if the actual names of the presets were used in the Key Commands window, as opposed to anonymously numbering the commands from one to 16. A new Snap option that comes in handy on both the Project and Key Editor windows is the Grid Relative mode, which means that when you move an Event, it snaps relative to its original offset from a grid position. For example, if an Event is just off the second beat of a bar, dragging with Snap set to Grid Relative and Grid set to Bar means that Event will snap to just off the second beat of any bar you try and move it to. If Grid was set to Beat, the Event would snap to a position just off any beat it was moved to. Finally, values such as pitch and velocity can now be edited by selecting the value on the Event Infoline and triggering a new pitch or velocity on your MIDI controller, which is neat, and Cubase now gives audible feedback when you change the velocity of notes — essential for quickly finding a multisample's split point.
In, Out, Route It All About The VST Connections window, introduced in SX 2 as a more streamlined way of creating input and output busses that can be attached to physical audio hardware connections, has been expanded further in SX 3. In addition to the Input and Output tabs from before, there are now three additional tabs: Group/FX, External FX and Studio. The Group/FX tab provides another way of creating Group and FX channels, but is useful in that allows you to manage these channels in a far more convenient way than using the Project or Mixer windows, since it provides a very clear overview of all Group and FX channels and to which Output busses they are assigned. file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Steinberg%20Cubase%20SX%203.htm (12 of 19)9/26/2005 8:17:55 AM
Steinberg Cubase SX 3
One small improvement with multi-channel Group and FX channels is that you can now create mono child busses within the parent buss, making it possible to send from one channel to only the left or right channel in a stereo Group or FX channel, for example. However, one further improvement I'd really like to see with Cubase's internal routing is the ability to set the output of a Group channel as the input of an Audio channel, allowing you to record submixes within the mixer — a feature that even Pro Tools LE offers. The advantage of this over simply exporting is clearer when you want to record more than a couple of submixes simultaneously, at which point exporting each submix separately becomes a real pain. The External FX tab allows you to more seamlessly integrate external effects units attached to your audio hardware into the VST environment, by configuring so-called External FX busses. An External FX buss consists of two separate busses: the Send buss, to specify which audio ports to send the signal to be processed by an external effects unit, and the Return buss, to set on which audio ports the The Process Tempo window offers a way to processed signal will be returned. scale multiple Tempo Events in one When you create an External FX buss calculation — essential for film composers you can set different widths for the needing to hit specific frames when working Send and Return busses, so that you with video. can have a mono send and a stereo return, for example, or a stereo send and a 5.1 return. Once created, you can also set a separate send and return gain value, along with a delay in milliseconds, which is used to specify the time your effects unit takes to process the signal and send it back to Cubase. This value, if set higher than zero, can be used for the delay compensation features in Cubase so that the signal processed by your external hardware doesn't sound delayed behind other audio channels. After you've configured an External FX buss, your external effects hardware can be used just like it was a VST plug-in, as External FX busses show up in your list of plug-ins under a special 'External FX' folder in the pop-up menu. You can use your external unit as an insert on any one Audio channel you like, or as a send effect by setting up a FX channel and putting your External FX buss as an insert on that channel, just like you would for any other send effect in Cubase. The External FX buss's editor window offers duplicates of the controls available in the VST Connections window for setting the send and return gains and the delay setting. Finally, the Studio tab provides just one feature at the moment, which is to configure the routing of a new Output buss referred to as the Audition buss. In previous versions of Cubase, the audio output when previewing audio, such as
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Steinberg%20Cubase%20SX%203.htm (13 of 19)9/26/2005 8:17:55 AM
Steinberg Cubase SX 3
when you're in the Import Audio file selector or playing back from the Sample Editor, was always routed to the first pair of outputs in the system directly, which was usually the main stereo output buss. In SX 3, however, the audio output when previewing audio is instead routed to the new Audition buss, which is a definite an improvement and offers a little more flexibility. You can set which physical outputs on your audio hardware the Audition buss is output to (just like setting up an Output buss), and the Mixer now includes an Audition channel so you can adjust the level of the audio you're previewing, or mute the signal completely.
Your Assignment, Should You Choose To Accept It As in version 2, where it was first introduced, the VST Connections window continues to be useful way of setting up inputs, outputs, and other routings in SX 3. However, when you're working with more than a couple of audio hardware ports, such as 192 inputs and outputs with certain higher-end ASIO devices, it becomes frustrating that there isn't a better way of incrementing the input or output assignments when configuring the Input and Output busses. For example, if you want to create 64 stereo Output busses using mono pairs one and two, three and four, and so on, there's no quick way of doing this, although you can at least create 64 stereo Output busses in one operation now, where you would have had to click the Add Buss button 64 times in SX 2. Occasionally it seems as though Cubase is trying to do something clever, since at times I've created four outputs and they've automatically assigned themselves to 5/6, 7/8, 7/8 and 3/4 respectively, but clearly some attention is needed here. On the plus side, there are now at least some handy features for assigning inputs and outputs to tracks and channels on the Project or Mixer windows. If you have multiple tracks or channels selected and you hold down Alt or Option while choosing an Output buss, that Output buss is assigned as the output for all selected channels. Similarly, if you hold down Shift instead, the selected channels' outputs are incremented automatically from the chosen Output buss. So if you select four channels and set the first Output buss while holding down Shift, the other three channels will be assigned to the second, third and fourth Output busses respectively. Very useful indeed! The Alt/Option method also works for assigning Audio Input busses, but unfortunately the Shift key doesn't seem to increment busses automatically at the moment.
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Steinberg%20Cubase%20SX%203.htm (14 of 19)9/26/2005 8:17:55 AM
Steinberg Cubase SX 3
Automated Improvements Cubase VST implemented a feature called Dynamic Events, whereby you could attach volume and pan envelopes to individual audio Events that would alter the level of those audio Events relative to the overall level of the channel. Despite the fact you could have fade-in and out curves and an audio Event level control in previous versions, some users still missed the functionality of Dynamic Events and so SX 3 features Event Envelopes that enable audio Events to have their own volume envelopes — currently Envelope Events enable you to create the pan Dynamic Events are still missing, although I don't think this is volume data tied to specific audio Events before the audio is output through an audio going to be a big problem. Event channel, just like volume Dynamic Events in Envelopes can be created by Cubase VST. clicking with the pencil tool on the audio Event in question (Event Envelopes aren't available on audio Parts), and you can do this with either the Project window or the Audio Part editor. The automation settings on the Project window's toolbar now offer an Automation Return Time, which sets the time in milliseconds over which a parameter should return to the previous setting once you release that parameter when in Touch Fader mode after writing new automation data. Another automation highlight is a new 'MIDI Controller Input To Automation Tracks' option in the MIDI panel of the Preferences window, which, as the name suggests, allows you to record Automation Events for Automation Tracks using an ordinary MIDI controller for the selected track, as opposed to using a specially configured remote control device. For example, this means you can now control the volume for the currently selected audio track with a standard MIDI volume fader, such as you might use to record articulation data in the Controller Lanes of MIDI tracks. However, it's important to disable this option when you don't need it to avoid recording duplicate automation and controller data, although this is made easy as this preference can be toggled with a key command. And while thinking about automation for MIDI tracks, it's worth noting that Steinberg have now added all possible MIDI Controllers to the list of possible automatable parameters for a MIDI track.
It's About Time This is usually the point in a Cubase SX review where I start to moan about the lack of tempo features for media-oriented composition, and how great this functionality used to be in previous generations of Cubase. However, SX 3 sees the return of the Process Tempo command to Cubase (as implemented in the file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Steinberg%20Cubase%20SX%203.htm (15 of 19)9/26/2005 8:17:55 AM
Steinberg Cubase SX 3
later builds of Nuendo 2.x at the request of film composer Hans Zimmer), with a newly polished interface in line with the redesigned Click and Synchronisation windows. As discussed in this August's Cubase Notes (www.soundonsound.com/sos/ aug04/articles/cubasenotes.htm), the Process Tempo feature provides a way of scaling the Tempo Events in your Project to make a certain number of beats fit within a certain amount of time. For example, if you have your last tempo change at bar five and you want bar nine to hit a specific timecode value, you can set your Start and End Points in the Process Range section of the Process Tempo window to bars five and nine, and then set the End Time in the New Range Section to the timecode you want bar seven to hit. Cubase will adjust the tempo at bar five so that bar seven now hits the required frame. Although the Time Warp tool was invented to help provide a solution to this problem, the big problem with the Time Warp tool is that it can only adjust the previous Tempo Event. This is actually fine for the example given above, but suppose that there was a subtle tempo arc between bars five and nine and you wanted to keep this shape while still making bar nine hit the required time. Rather than just process the last Tempo Event, you want to be able to scale all of the Tempo Events between bars five and nine so the correct frame is hit, and this is when the Process Tempo feature really comes into its own. Process Tempo is absolutely indispensable if you're trying to write frameaccurate music for picture, and I know that a great many film composers will rejoice in its return, especially with the new interface that really does make it easier to figure out what's going on. The Time Warp tool is still part of SX 3, of course, and now, finally, shows timecode when you're dragging a bar or beat on the Project window or one of the editors; and a timecode info box will now be displayed when moving an Audio Event's sync point in the Sample Editor with timecode selected in the Ruler. Another small change is that when you change the start time of your Project, Cubase now asks you if you want the Events in the Project to keep their current time locations, or if the time locations should be adjusted to be relative to the new start time of the Project — just the same as in Pro Tools.
It's The Little Things... Despite the new features that make the headlines for SX 3, some of the most welcome changes are in the smaller improvements that can be found in most areas of the application. In the Project window, for example, you can now click in any part of an Inspector Section's title to toggle between open and closed states, rather than just the part with a graphical symbol, and Sections can also be toggled via a set of new key commands. On the subject of key commands, a set are now (finally) included for Logical Editor presets where you can either select a
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Steinberg%20Cubase%20SX%203.htm (16 of 19)9/26/2005 8:17:55 AM
Steinberg Cubase SX 3
preset, if the Logical Editor is open, or operate on the current selection with a given preset if it's closed, as with the latest 2.x version of Nuendo. One very welcome new option in the Project window is the ability for the Ruler and Event Display to show Bars and Beats Linear rather than Time Linear when Bars and Beats is selected as the main Display Format, as you could with other editor windows in SX 2. In previous versions, you could only display Bars and Beats in Time Linear, which meant that Cubase displayed the length of each bar relative to the amount of time it would take to be played, so that a 2/4 bar at 30bpm was displayed longer than a 4/4 bar of 120bpm. While this option makes sense for displaying audio, it can be off-putting for the musician to see a 2/4 bar shown as being longer than a 4/4 bar. Choosing the new Bars and Beats Time Linear option solves this by basing the display length of bars on the number of beats they contain instead. Staying with the Project window, another very welcome improvement is in situations where you copy a MIDI Part so that a new track is created. Previously, a new MIDI track would be created with default settings, whereas now, if a MIDI track is created by the user dragging a MIDI Part into an empty spot of the Project window, the MIDI track is created with the same parameters as the MIDI track containing the Part you're dragging. This is especially useful when dragging a MIDI Part from one Project window to another, empty Project window.
The redesigned Metronome Setup window offers pitch controls for the metronome beep or the ability to use audio samples of your choice.
The Metronome Setup window has been redesigned in a similar way to the Synchronisation Setup window, although it seems a little less logical, with the starting point for the settings beginning in the bottom left of the window, rather than having the top-down approach taken by the Synchronisation window. However, the best thing about the new metronome window is the ability to either adjust the pitch of the now-infamous Cubase 'beep', or use your own samples for the Hi (first beat of the bar) and Lo (every other beat), which are output via the Audition buss. It could be argued that the Studio tab in the VST Connections window should now include a separate Metronome buss as well, though, which could be useful when setting up cue mixes; but this current solution is a definite step in the right direction if you don't want to set up a VST Instrument to be your click source in every Project. The Device Setup window has also been redesigned, with a new hierarchical Device List to the left of the window, which makes a great deal of sense. And you set Cubase's internal Video Player window to display full-screen by right-clicking in the window. Another Device-related improvement is that control surfaces with touch-sensitive faders, such as Mackie Control, now include an Enable Auto
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Steinberg%20Cubase%20SX%203.htm (17 of 19)9/26/2005 8:17:55 AM
Steinberg Cubase SX 3
Select option where the appropriate channel or track becomes automatically selected when you touch a fader on the control surface. Users of Cubase SX's advanced Score editor will also welcome some new features, including improved slur handling and text importing, the ability to create and edit custom symbols, and the playback of structure symbols, such as repeat marks and da capo symbols. And anyone with a Yamaha digital mixing console will benefit from Steinberg and Yamaha's Studio Connections initiative, which allows Yamaha's Studio Manager software to be integrated with total recall support in SX 3. We'll cover the use of Studio Connections in more detail in a forthcoming Cubase Notes column. Finally, Cubase's previous Window Layouts feature, which many users had problems with, has been completely replaced by a new Workspaces feature that is conceptually very similar to the Screensets implementation in Logic, but has some additional features to manage your Workspaces for additional flexibility. As with Window Layouts, the idea of Workspaces is to create presets for the way Cubase's windows are arranged on screen at any one time, and this really works much more reliably now, especially when you're working with multiple monitors.
Do You Think I'm S3Xy? Some existing Cubase users have been disappointed that they will have to upgrade to SX 3 in order to resolve issues they had with SX 2, such as problems that many experienced with crossfades, there being no intermediate SX 2 release. At the end of the day, though, existing Cubase users who do pay to upgrade to SX 3 are unlikely to be disappointed with the purchase since there are so many other great new features aside from fixes that were requested in regard to SX 2. In terms of the competition, it's perhaps a shame that Steinberg haven't responded more aggressively to Apple's Logic Pro package, which bundles together all of Emagic's software instruments and effects. While Apple have an advantage in being able to recoup revenue from computer hardware sales and Steinberg can't simply afford to give away their entire product line, including the SE versions of Steinberg's more popular VST Instruments might have been an interesting sweetener, encouraging users to upgrade to the full versions. Even the £200 Logic Express now includes a playback-only version of EXS24 MkI, the ES1 synth (although Steinberg and Waldorf's included A1 is a good alternative), and the EVP73 modelled electric piano — and the just-announced version 7, previewed elsewhere in this issue, promises more goodies including all of Garage Band's instruments. Nevertheless, Cubase SX 3 brings Cubase back to a level where it can seriously be used for music composition and production, especially in the film and media industries where many previous users have either looked elsewhere or stuck with Cubase VST 5 in the absence of a suitable successor. These users should now file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Steinberg%20Cubase%20SX%203.htm (18 of 19)9/26/2005 8:17:55 AM
Steinberg Cubase SX 3
seriously look to Cubase SX 3 as it's a definite improvement over previous versions of Cubase, both SX and VST, despite a few MTC issues to be resolved with the otherwise brilliant Play Order Track feature. Speaking of the Play Order Track, though, features like this in SX 3 make it feel like there is some genuinely musically interesting functionality in the application again, as opposed to purely utilitarian features like a new mix engine. Improvements can be seen in almost all areas of Cubase in this new version, and while Steinberg hasn't quite got all of the loose ends tied up, this is undoubtedly a far superior sequencer to SX 2. What a difference a year makes; and the difference is you... Published in SOS November 2004 Sound On Sound, Media House, Trafalgar Way, Bar Hill, Cambridge CB3 8SQ, UK. Email:
[email protected] | Telephone: +44 (0)1954 789888 | Fax: +44 (0)1954 789895
All contents copyright © SOS Publications Group and/or its licensors, 1985-2005. All rights reserved. The contents of this article are subject to worldwide copyright protection and reproduction in whole or part, whether mechanical or electronic, is expressly forbidden without the prior written consent of the Publishers. Great care has been taken to ensure accuracy in the preparation of this article but neither Sound On Sound Limited nor the publishers can be held responsible for its contents. The views expressed are those of the contributors and not necessarily those of the publishers. Web site designed & maintained by PB Associates | SOS | Relative Media
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Steinberg%20Cubase%20SX%203.htm (19 of 19)9/26/2005 8:17:55 AM
TC-Helicon Intonator HS
In this article:
Through The Pitch Window Using Intonator Concluding Thoughts
TC-Helicon Intonator HS £179
TC-Helicon Intonator HS Pitch-correction Plug-in (TC Powercore) Published in SOS November 2004 Print article : Close window
Reviews : Software
pros Easy to use. Flexible display options. Few side-effects unless grossly overused.
cons No obvious workarounds for the lack of MIDI note support in AU hosts such as Logic. Some users will bemoan the fact that you can't get the creative 'Cher' Auto-Tune effect.
A Powercore version of Antares' industry-standard Auto-Tune pitch corrector was announced in 2001, but it never appeared. Is TC's new Intonator HS plugin a viable alternative? Paul White
Several years ago, TC-Helicon produced a hardware Intonator which While I don't think the pitch was a direct competitor for Antares' corrector has yet been ATR1 hardware Auto-Tune box, devised that could rescue my offering real-time vocal pitch correction. singing, I was immediately This new incarnation of the product in impressed by the sound quality and ease of use of plug-in form sees a refined version of Intonator HS. If you own a the original 'Hybrid Shifting' (hence HS) Powercore system and record algorithm combined with a very vocalists, this plug-in is more straightforward user interface. Intonator an essential than a luxury. HS works with both the PCI and information Firewire versions of the system, £179 including VAT. supporting audio hosts that can run TC Electronic UK +44 (0) VST or Audio Units plug-ins. As with 800 917 8926. other Powercore plug-ins, the installed +44 (0)800 917 6510. version of the software is personalised to one of the Powercore devices in your Click here to email system and so needs that device to be present and switched on in order to run. www.tc-helicon.com Once the plug-in is registered on the TC web site, you are given a download location from which to obtain your personalised Intonator, and because it only Test Spec works on your Powercore hardware, you can make multiple backups and install it on multiple machines, which is particularly handy if you have a Firewire Apple G5 dual 2GHz with 2GB RAM, running OS 10.3.3. Powercore unit. summary
TC Powercore PCI and Powercore Firewire with v1.8 software. Tested with Emagic Logic Pro v6.4.1.
Through The Pitch Window
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/TC-Helicon%20Intonator%20HS.htm (1 of 4)9/26/2005 8:18:01 AM
TC-Helicon Intonator HS
The Intonator window is dominated by a large real-time pitch and processing display at the top showing the maximum pitch correction range of ±600 cents. The meter has five possible display modes showing permutations of the input pitch, the output pitch or the difference between the input and output pitches; I found the 'correction only' option most useful as that's what I'd got used to when using Auto-Tune. If you're wondering how these different metering options are configured with no obvious buttons in sight, the answer is that you have to click on the pitch meter itself to get to the Meter Options menu. Level metering is also included, in the form of a clip meter with a clip hold facility that can hold indefinitely or for 10, 6, 1 or no seconds. Clicking the red Clip indicator resets it. Just below the meter-like pitch display, you'll see a shaded area with triangular handles on each end. This adjusts the capture range around the target pitch so that only notes within a certain proximity to the target note are corrected. This ranges up to six semitones, the large values coming in useful for special scales or effects such as forcing all input notes to just one or two notes. As with Auto-Tune, the displayed pitch correction is influenced by the control settings, specifically the correction Amount and Rate dials. The Attack control adjusts the rate at which pitch correction is applied. If it is set too fast, the correction process is unnaturally fast and tends to strip out some of the natural inflections in the voice, though you can't get the abused Auto-Tune sound — Intonator is far too subtle for that. Slower attack settings take a little longer to move notes to the correct pitch, which usually sounds more natural. Intonator's Amount control deserves a little further explanation as it doesn't do quite what you might imagine. Specifically, if the amount is set to zero, some correction still takes place if the input is a long way out of tune. The idea behind this is that small 'errors' of the kind that occur naturally in a good singer are allowed through unchanged, but when the singer really drifts off, the processing gets stronger to compensate.
You can define your own scale or use one of Intonator HS's many preset options.
The correction applied is based on scales, which can be chosen from a list containing major, minor, harmonic minor, melodic minor, chromatic and a whole load of more obscure scales, and can be set to any key via the keyboard beneath the Pitch Meter. In Manual mode, you can use this keyboard to input the notes of your custom scale; conversely, when MIDI mode is active, the pitch corrects to notes played from a MIDI source, such as a keyboard or sequencer. Virtual LEDs above the keys track the current input pitch. Additionally, there's a pitch-bend wheel on the front of the plug-in window which can have some fairly disturbing effects if used other than very carefully, as it has a bend range of plus/minus six semitones! Unfortunately, Logic and other Audio Units hosts can't send MIDI note information to insert plug-ins, only to instruments, so the MIDI function can only be used in the VST version. file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/TC-Helicon%20Intonator%20HS.htm (2 of 4)9/26/2005 8:18:01 AM
TC-Helicon Intonator HS
There's little other processing apart from a choice of adaptive or fixed-frequency low-cut filtering, designed to attenuate unwanted low-frequency components in as unobtrusive a way as possible — it seems that when the input level drops, more aggressive filtering is applied. When Frequency is set to Infinite, the low-cut filter attempts to track just below the lowest input pitch of the signal, and on vocals this is generally quite unobtrusive. Though Intonator is simple enough to set up afresh every time you need it, you can store presets if you want to. Presets are saved as discrete files so that you can arrange them into subfolders if you're an organised kind of person, and in the time-honoured way, a saved preset will appear in your File menu available for future use. A and B buttons allow fast comparisons to be made between two different settings, but these locations are only temporary and so are lost when the system is powered down or if you quit or crash the host program.
Using Intonator I tested Intonator on some vocal parts that were fairly well sung but still a little 'iffy' in parts. I'd already tried the competing pitch correction plug-ins with a decent level of success, but straight away, Intonator sounded more natural, applying more assertive correction without giving itself away through side-effects. If you try to correct too quickly, the sound does become a little unnatural, but nothing like the warbling 'Cher' effect that spawned a whole era of Auto-Tune abuse. I haven't yet tried the latest incarnation of Auto-Tune, but compared with earlier versions, Intonator sounds a lot more polished, and seems better at making slightly unsteady vocals sound more confident. As with its competitors, Intonator also works well on many monophonic instrument sounds, such as fretless bass and even lead guitar. Where the input isn't monophonic, no pitch correction is applied. Having a MIDI mode means you can pitch-correct pieces of music that don't stick to a rational scale, and of course most of the parameters can be automated, host sequencer permitting. Having said that, I couldn't find any easy way to handle mid-song transpositions when working in Logic, so I resorted to splitting the lead vocal on to two tracks and using a different instance of Intonator on both, with the appropriate scales set for the keys of the two song sections. The low-cut filter is pretty clever and seems to works rather like a dynamic noise filter in reverse, cutting the low end during quiet passages rather than the high end. This is a useful process in its own right, and in some applications, can be more natural-sounding than sophisticated, multi-band denoising software when it comes to removing low-end hum and grumble.
Concluding Thoughts file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/TC-Helicon%20Intonator%20HS.htm (3 of 4)9/26/2005 8:18:01 AM
TC-Helicon Intonator HS
Powercore's plug-ins are generally a cut above their native counterparts and it seems as though Intonator is trying hard to uphold this tradition. While all the pitch-correction software currently doing the rounds is very good (a lot better than it has any right to be, when you think about what a difficult job it has to do!), I think Intonator now has the edge on sounding natural and being able to apply the most assertive correction without sounding artificial. The inability to use MIDI note control in AU hosts is somewhat irritating, and although it is an AU issue, it should have been possible to design Intonator to work in an instrument plug-in slot and then route audio to it from another track via a side-chain, rather as vocoder plug-ins do already. If this doesn't look like getting resolved from the Logic/AU side of the fence, then maybe it's something TC could consider adding in a future update to Intonator? Published in SOS November 2004 Sound On Sound, Media House, Trafalgar Way, Bar Hill, Cambridge CB3 8SQ, UK. Email:
[email protected] | Telephone: +44 (0)1954 789888 | Fax: +44 (0)1954 789895
All contents copyright © SOS Publications Group and/or its licensors, 1985-2005. All rights reserved. The contents of this article are subject to worldwide copyright protection and reproduction in whole or part, whether mechanical or electronic, is expressly forbidden without the prior written consent of the Publishers. Great care has been taken to ensure accuracy in the preparation of this article but neither Sound On Sound Limited nor the publishers can be held responsible for its contents. The views expressed are those of the contributors and not necessarily those of the publishers. Web site designed & maintained by PB Associates | SOS | Relative Media
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/TC-Helicon%20Intonator%20HS.htm (4 of 4)9/26/2005 8:18:01 AM
Voyager By Bob Moog
In this article:
Voyager By Bob Moog
Finishing The Voyager Version 2 OS Updates • The Anniversary Edition Published in SOS November 2004 The VX351 CV Expander Putting Everything Together Print article : Close window The CP251 Control Reviews : Keyboard Processor Conclusions
Anniversary Edition • VX351 • CP251
Voyager OS Updates pros
Since the release of the Voyager analogue monosynth last year, Bob Moog's company have been busy producing OS updates, special-edition versions, and accessories. We bring you up to date with a look at the lot.
These updates (from v1.5 to v2.3) make the Voyager the instrument that was promised back in 2002. Flexible new 6, 12 and 18dBper-octave filter options from the OS v1.5 revision. The v2 OS adds four more Gordon Reid modulation busses that address many of my biggest complaints in the earlier It has been nearly two years since Bob Moog's Voyager first hit these shores, revisions. and it has been developing ever since. The operating system has now reached Version 2 also adds version 2.3, with the last four updates addressing almost all of the points that I envelope triggering from raised when I originally reviewed the instrument in SOS June 2003 (see www. numerous sources... soundonsound.com/sos/jun03/articles/moogvoyager.asp). There have also been ...and completes the MIDI specification. two hardware additions to the family. The VX351 CV Expander is specifically a
cons Even OS v2.3 does not address the pitch-bend problems inherent in earlier Voyagers. The touch-screen still exhibits errors. Glide still does not affect the filter cutoff frequency.
Voyager expander, while the other, the Moogerfooger CP251 Control Processor, has wider application, but is nonetheless happy to act as a member of the clan.
In addition to all of these, there's also a new version of the Voyager — the Anniversary Edition (pictured throughout this review), which is a limited edition that celebrates Bob Moog's 50 years in the music business. summary In fact, although it's cosmetically For a while, it looked as if the different, the Anniversary's internals Voyager was at risk of are no different from the latest becoming one of those Photos: Mark Ewing permanently unfinished standard Voyagers being produced, so synthesizers. But with the we can treat it like the latest version of latest revisions of the v2 OS, the instrument. Given that the original review is now hopelessly out of date, I everything is in place, and the reckon that it's high time that we returned to the Voyager to see what the latest instrument takes on a new hardware, the changes in the operating system, and the add-on boxes mean for lease of life. If you have a Voyager, you must upgrade it. both new and existing users. Voyager Anniversary file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Voyager%20By%20Bob%20Moog.htm (1 of 14)9/26/2005 8:18:07 AM
Voyager By Bob Moog
Edition £1999 pros A couple of significant hardware faults in previous models have been cured. Like all Voyagers, it sounds excellent.
cons It still suffers from poor aftertouch response. A couple of significant hardware faults in previous models have not been cured. The backlight whines.
Finishing The Voyager You may recognise the table on the right — it's the list of future updates that were promised for the Voyager at the time of my original review. Happily, these have now all been carried out, although some of them didn't happen until the version 2 OS arrived, as you can see. Over the course of the past year, I've acquired my own Signature Edition, so I've followed the Voyager through its various upgrades, even before the Anniversary Edition arrived for review at SOS. So let's see what's changed...
One of the most annoying things about the original Voyager operating system was the way the cursor buttons worked. When you pressed Up, the selection Despite a couple of moved Down, and vice versa. I was delighted when this was corrected in OS unresolved niggles, the v1.5. What's more, OS v1.5 introduced numbering of each mode's menu items, Voyager is an excellentsounding synthesizer. And if which helped users to navigate the system. More significantly, it introduced you are in the market for an scrolling of the '+' and '-' buttons, with acceleration if you held either button for a analogue monosynth that will few seconds. Other small but welcome improvements included the Voyager turn heads, the Anniversary Edition is probably the one for powering up in Panel Mode, and it remembering and returning to the sound you were using before you switched off. you. VX351 CV Expander £150 summary
pros Adds useful functionality to the Voyager. Quarter-inch sockets. I like quarter-inch sockets.
cons The build quality of the sockets and knobs is a bit suspect. You must install a piggyback board.
summary I'm not keen on having to buy what is simply a muscular breakout box, but if you're interested in using the synthesis potential of the Voyager to the full, the manufacturers have seen to it that there is no alternative. On the bright side, if you can forget the money issue, you will be glad that you bought one.
CP251 Control Processor £190
VOYAGER UPDATE SCHEDULE (SEPTEMBER 1ST, 2004)
STATUS IN VERSION 2 OS
Hold -1/+1 buttons to scroll through values Upgrade touch surface destinations
Done (OS v1.5)
Add filter pole selection (12dB-per-octave) Local control On/Off
Done (OS v1.5)
Done (OS v1.5)
Done (OS v1.5)
MIDI In On/Off & MIDI Out On/Off
Done (OS v2)
Receive MIDI CCs, Note On, velocity and aftertouch Transmit MIDI CCs, aftertouch and pitch-bend Receive MIDI Clock for LFO sync
Done (OS v1.5)
Done (OS v2)
Add filter envelope gate sources
Done (OS v2)
Add amplitude envelope gate sources
Done (OS v2)
Updates to modulation buss PGM shaping System Reset
Done (OS v2)
Done (OS v1.5)
Send and receive single memory via SysEx Transpose MIDI output
Done (OS v1.5)
Done (OS v2)
Done (OS v2)
OS version 1.5 also saw the arrival of MIDI Sync for the Voyager's internal LFO.
pros file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Voyager%20By%20Bob%20Moog.htm (2 of 14)9/26/2005 8:18:07 AM
Voyager By Bob Moog
A cost-effective way to obtain seven useful synthesizer functions. It complements the Voyager well. More quarter-inch sockets. I like more quarter-inch sockets.
cons The build quality is more suspect than that of the CP251; the review unit had two dodgy jacks. A VCA is not included. It uses ±3V and ±5V inputs and outputs, which can make it tricky to connect it to other manufacturers' equipment.
Of course, this is not MIDI Clock control of the LFO rate, which would be tricky to implement using an analogue oscillator. Instead, it is 'hard sync' of the start point of the LFO cycle, with seven options ranging from one 'sync' every two MIDI Clock beats to one sync every quarter of a MIDI Clock beat. Other upgrades in OS v1.5 included Local On/Off, Program Change On/Off, and Merge, which merges incoming MIDI messages with those generated within the synth, and then transmits the resulting stream from the MIDI Out. This revision also received velocity and aftertouch over MIDI. But just as important as this was the ability to Dump and Load single patches via SysEx. This made it possible for the first time to save and restore individual sounds, and to build banks from disparate combinations of existing sounds.
One of the biggest problems with the original Voyager was the hard-wiring of the touch-screen to the filters' cutoff frequencies, spacing and resonance, and the fact that the position memory applied only to the values sent to the modulation summary busses, not to the filter destinations. Things improved in OS v1.5; the fixed The CP251 comprises a destinations were disconnected, and three of the touch-screen's degrees of reasonably priced selection of freedom (X-axis, Y-axis and Area) appeared to offer four independently modules and adds a useful assignable parameters: Destination, MIDI CC transmitted, Direction (the 'polarity' range of facilities to any of the parameter) and Amount (the MIDI CC transmission didn't work under OS modular synth. Beware, however, that it does not v1.5, but this has now been attended to — more on this in a moment). handle the ±10V signals generated by many modular synthesizers.
information Voyager Anniversary Edition, £1999; Voyager Performer Edition, £1799; VX351, £149.99; CP251, £189.99; CP/VX Expander kit, £49.99. All prices include VAT. Turnkey +44 (0)20 7419 9999. +44 (0)20 7379 0093. Click here to email www.turnkey.co.uk
No fewer than 32 touch-screen destinations were added (see the table above), but the Amount parameter was less flexible than you might think. This offered just three options — 0 percent, 50 percent, and 100 percent — meaning that the maximum amount of control exerted by X, Y or A was zero, half of the destination's total variability, or 100 percent of the destination's total variability. This improvement introduced a problem of its own, although it only affected owners who used patches created on earlier OS revisions. When loaded into an upgraded Voyager, pre-OS v1.5 patches lost their fixed touch-screen destinations and ended up with random settings. These patches sounded correct until you touched the screen, at which point strange things could happen. Not a fundamental flaw, this nonetheless required a frustrating hour or two spent reassigning the touch-screen parameters to get back to where you started.
www.moogmusic.com
Test Spec Voyager OS versions reviewed: v1.5, v2.0, v2.1, v2.3 (version 2.4 — a minor update — was posted on the manufacturer's web site at the very end of the review period, but not in time to be considered for this article).
Another problem concerned the new global touch-screen memory and modulation buss touch-screen memory functions. These were supposed to remember where your finger was the last time you touched the screen, and to continue to apply the appropriate 'X' and 'Y' CVs to their destinations after you removed it. I found it extremely difficult to remove my finger without shifting the position of final contact slightly, so that the magnitude of the remembered CV was always slightly more or less than I wanted it to be. But after a while, I began to think that the fault was not mine alone, and a couple of tests showed that the screen does not hold extreme values correctly; it substitutes values that are closer to the 'centre' of the screen. This means that, in almost all cases, sounds glitch slightly when you remove your finger from the screen, and glitch again when you next touch it. If anything is going to be done about this, it still hadn't
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Voyager%20By%20Bob%20Moog.htm (3 of 14)9/26/2005 8:18:07 AM
Voyager By Bob Moog
happened following the OS v2.3 upgrade.
TOUCH-SCREEN DESTINATIONS SOURCES
AMPLIFIER VCA attack. VCA decay.
Oscillator 1 level.
VCA release.
Oscillator 1 octave.
VCA sustain.
Oscillator 1 waveform.
Volume.
Oscillator 2 frequency.
FILTERS
Oscillator 2 level. Oscillator 2 octave. Oscillator 2 waveform.
Filter cutoff.
Filter resonance.
Oscillator 3 level.
Filter spacing.
Oscillator 3 waveform. Noise level. External audio input level.
Glide rate. Keyboard pitch CV. LFO rate. Mod wheel modulation buss amount. Pedal/On modulation buss amount.
Filter keyboard amount.
Oscillator 3 frequency.
Oscillator 3 octave.
MODULATION & CONTROL
Filter envelope amount. Filter attack. Filter decay. Filter sustain. Filter release.
One OS v1.5 upgrade significantly expanded the sonic character of the instrument. This was the long-awaited inclusion of 12dB-per-octave filters. Indeed, the Voyager's manufacturers went two steps beyond their original promise; the Voyager now offers 6, 12, 18 and 24dB-per-octave slopes independently for both the high-pass and low-pass filters. This is no trivial upgrade, and it allows you to sculpt sounds with characters reminiscent of many other synthesizer manufacturers. I noted in last June's review how the Voyager's high-pass/low-pass option lent itself to the creation of Korg-y and ARP-ish timbres, but the new slopes take things further, making the Voyager a true sonic chameleon. Regrettably, the filters still lacked some features in OS v1.5, and these have not yet been added in the current revision. Firstly, despite many users' requests, it remains impossible to control and modulate the filters independently; you can't sweep one and leave the other unaffected, or have one on the edge of selfoscillation while the other exhibits zero resonance. Secondly, there's still no option to place the filters in series in dual low-pass mode. And thirdly, there is still the on-going problem, mentioned in my previous review, that Glide cannot be made to affect the filter cutoff frequency. One of the most interesting facilities promised by the Voyager's original sales blurb was MIDI control over all the Voyager's programming parameters. This file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Voyager%20By%20Bob%20Moog.htm (4 of 14)9/26/2005 8:18:07 AM
Voyager By Bob Moog
appeared in OS v1.5, with the synth responding to no fewer than 53 messages that control almost all aspects of its sound. Transmission of continuous controller information did not become possible until the version 2 OS arrived, but now that it has, the Voyager has become a feast of MIDIness. You can transmit CCs from the left-hand controller panel (pitch-bend and modulation), you can transmit aftertouch, and you can send a CC from every front-panel control with the exception of the fine-tune and headphone volume knobs. Even more excitingly, you can now program the touch-screen to transmit the CCs of your choice on all four degrees of freedom (X-position, Y-position, Area and Gate). This is no small benefit, and opens up all manner of possibilities for innovative control of instruments such as digital workstations that suffer from more limited control capabilities. Although more subtle, other MIDI updates in OS2.x are just as useful. These include MIDI In On/Off, MIDI Out On/Off, programmable SysEx ID (which allows you to control more than one Voyager over MIDI simultaneously), the ability to dump any patch via SysEx, and three velocity curves for the output MIDI velocity. Another improvement that I've been requesting since the Voyager appeared involves MIDI Key Transpose. To their credit, the Voyager's programmers have surpassed themselves here, implementing not one, but two Transpose functions: keyboard transpose (which affects the note emitted by the Voyager itself when you play it from its own keyboard) and MIDI Key Transpose (which affects the MIDI Note Numbers transmitted when you play the Voyager keyboard). Among other things, this means that you can now use the Voyager to program or play rhythm parts on standard MIDI note numbers. The most recent upgrades also include many tweaks to the menus in Edit Mode and, for me, this is where the most significant improvements reside. Let's start with a couple of minor ones. 'Compare to Preset' allows you to decide whether to overwrite the sound being edited, or find a sound that you The touch-screen in the centre of the don't mind losing. There's also the Voyager was previously hard-wired to fixed parameters, but is now freely assignable, addition of a factory setup (reset) and transmits MIDI continuous controllers. menu, which allows you to reload the factory patches and reset various performance parameters to their default values. Next, we come to a new method of naming patches, in which you can use the keyboard as an alphanumeric keypad. More significant is the 'User Definable Pitch-bend Amount', which allows you to define the amount of pitch-bend, rather than being limited to a handful of well-tempered options. As we shall see later, this helps (in part) to sidestep an extremely annoying fault in the hardware of early Voyagers. Another important addition is the introduction of alternative Gate sources for the filter and amplifier envelopes. In addition to the standard sources, these now file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Voyager%20By%20Bob%20Moog.htm (5 of 14)9/26/2005 8:18:07 AM
Voyager By Bob Moog
include the Gate signal from the touch-screen, the LFO square wave, and MIDI Clock. Provided that you remember to switch the Env Gate switch to On/External, these sources should be enough for all but the most arcane requirements. The touch-screen Gate signal now has many other uses, too. You can use it to switch the Glide and Release switches on and off, as well as every switch on the front panel. I'm not immediately sure how I might use this, but I can think of numerous ways in which it could be useful. Moving relentlessly up the scale of significance, we now come to the addition of two more 'Shaper' sources, one for each of the modulators. There's a huge list of sources for these (43 in all) that includes many of the front-panel controls as well as conventional sources such as velocity and aftertouch. Having four Shaper sources makes possible a huge number of complex modulation options that, in many ways, echo those of a modular synthesizer. However, these still don't allow you to use the Shapers to introduce modulation where none existed before... they only allow you to modulate the amount of an existing modulation, as explained in my original Voyager review. Last on my list, but most significant among the upgrades for me, are the oddly named 'Pot Mapping Source/Destination' parameters. These provide four new modulation paths that are completely independent of the modulation busses. This is quite something... it allows you to send (for example) aftertouch directly to modwheel amount, keyboard CV directly to LFO rate, velocity directly to filter cutoff frequency, or choose from hundreds of other Source/Destination combinations, without being subject to the complexities and limitations of the mod wheel and Pedal/On busses. There are 40 sources and 40 destinations in the Pot Mapping system, and four modulation maps available at any given time, which means that there are, umm... 1600 to the fourth power combinations, which is... over six and a half trillion source/destination combinations. I'm suitably impressed, especially since each of the four modulation paths can have positive or negative polarity and an 'amount' of 0, 25, 50 or 100 percent. Silly numbers aside, the great thing about these paths is that they're simple to understand and use. What's more, by allowing you to direct a single modulation controller (aftertouch, say) to four destinations simultaneously (for example filter cutoff, amplifier gain, LFO depth and LFO rate), pot mapping makes the Voyager extremely responsive and musical.
The Anniversary Edition Following in the footsteps of the Signature Edition, the Anniversary Edition is another limited-edition Voyager. It comes in a stunning black finish, but the most noticeable thing about it is the illuminated front panel on which all the controls' annotations glow at you in an almost actinic blue. The intensity of illumination is controlled by a small knob set into the small wooden strip immediately to the right of the keyboard. Turning this knob anticlockwise to its minimum switches off the backlight, and turning it progressively clockwise increases the intensity until the file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Voyager%20By%20Bob%20Moog.htm (6 of 14)9/26/2005 8:18:07 AM
Voyager By Bob Moog
illumination of the panel legends becomes visible even in daylight, which equates to being dazzling in a darkened studio. Unfortunately, at anything higher than minimal intensity, the system emits an annoying whine. This is not going to be of concern at a gig, but in my studio it renders the backlight almost unusable. I also wish that the designers had sited the intensity knob more sensibly — I kept catching it with my fingers when playing at the top end of the keyboard. Moving back to musical matters, the Anniversary Voyagers — and, I assume, others of this vintage — have been cured of two of the hardware faults exhibited by earlier versions. The most obvious of these concerns the quiet but annoying noise emitted by some Performers and Signatures when you turn the Master Volume knob past '5' in either direction. This has been eliminated. A more significant fault on early models concerned pitch-bend. No matter how you programmed the values in the menus, the pitch-bend interval was far from what was promised. What's more, the whole instrument went flat when you increased the pitch-bend range. Happily, the upward bend on the Anniversary is exactly what the menu promises, even over large bends of two octaves or more. The downward bend is not quite right — a two-octave bend is sharp by a few cents — but the error isn't noticeable when using musical intervals of a handful of semitones. Furthermore, I found that when programming the pitch-bend using the new Pitch-bend Amount parameter, the upward and downward intervals were identical. But there's bad news for owners of older Voyagers. The errors in the pitchbend intervals in early models were not a function of dodgy software; they were the result of a hardware fault. This means that, even if you upgrade the OS of a Signature (as I have done) or one of the earlier Performers, you still cannot obtain the correct pitch-bend intervals without returning your pride and joy to a workshop for a hardware modification. How is that a very expensive synth can suffer from a hardware fault as easily spotted as this?
The previous hardware fault with the Voyager's pitch-bend wheel has been attended to on the Anniversary Edition. The attractive blue backlighting of the Anniversary is also visible emanating from under the wheels in this shot.
This is where the 'User Definable Pitch-bend Amount' parameter can help. Take, for example, the '1 Octave' pitch-bend setting on my Signature. Pushing the wheel fully away from me sharpens the pitch by 13 semitones, but pulling it fully toward me flattens it by just 11 semitones. A user-defined pitch-bend value of 104 sharpens the pitch by exactly an octave (12 semitones). Having said that, the same value flattens the pitch by ten-and-a-bit semitones, which is useless. So you can now make your older Voyager more useable than before, but it's still a sorry state of affairs. file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Voyager%20By%20Bob%20Moog.htm (7 of 14)9/26/2005 8:18:07 AM
Voyager By Bob Moog
Fortunately, it is now possible to correct all Voyagers of their tendency to go flat when you increase the pitch-bend range. You need to remove the controller panel to the immediate left of the keyboard (it's not as hard as it sounds) and adjust a trim pot while watching a parameter value on screen. I set up my Signature according to the method described in the documentation, and it was cured of this problem. Another fault with all Voyagers concerns the Envelope Gate switch. When set to On/External, this should hold the VCA permanently 'open' at the Volume Envelope Sustain Level, but it doesn't. What actually happens is that the Level starts at the correct point, but immediately enters a very slow decay. Next, I would like to point out another slight deficiency that has become apparent on all Voyagers. The synth's manufacturers claim that the 12-bit A-D converters used to translate the positions of the front-panel knobs into digital values, the interpolation of those values when the CVs are generated, and the scanning speed of the front panel are all sufficient to ensure that the Voyager is indistinguishable from a pure analogue synthesizer. However, this is not the case. To discover this for yourself, just sweep two knobs simultaneously while listening to a patch. If one of the parameters you're adjusting makes obvious changes to the sound — say, the filter cutoff frequency — you will hear audible stepping. To be fair, the amount of 'zippering' is very small, and will bother almost no-one, but it's there nonetheless. A final fault that is cured neither in the Anniversary Edition nor by upgrading my Signature Edition concerns the nature of the aftertouch response. This was always like on on/off switch, and so it remains, making it extremely hard to introduce modulation progressively without using a VX351 and a CP251 to smooth and attenuate the response. This is very unmusical behaviour for an instrument of this value. However, it provides the perfect excuse to move on to discuss... the aforementioned VX351 and the CP251. For the background and basic functionality of these two add-ons, see the boxes below and over the page respectively. For more on using them with the Voyager, read on.
The VX351 CV Expander As I stated last June, the Voyager's numerous control inputs are not complemented by equivalent outputs so, while you can control an unadorned Voyager from external sources, you cannot use it to control other non-MIDI synths and modules. Nor can you patch CV routings that are not provided by the internal busses (although this is now far less of an issue thanks to the pot-mapping facilities added in the version 2 OS). Both of these functions can be added using the VX351 CV Expander. Now, you might think that the 25-way 'D' connector marked 'Accessory Port' on the back of the synth would tap the Voyager's control voltages, and in this you would be partly right. Unfortunately, it seems that matters are not straightforward, because the VX351 comes with a small piggy-back board that you must insert file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Voyager%20By%20Bob%20Moog.htm (8 of 14)9/26/2005 8:18:07 AM
Voyager By Bob Moog
inside the Voyager before the port will work as specified. I'm not sure why this is necessary, because I tested some of the CVs without it and they seemed to be correct. Nonetheless, I had no wish to risk faulty operation (I seem to remember that one user reported that the LFO failed without the board) so I installed it before proceeding further. At this point you The VX351 control-voltage breakout box. might ask, "If it is necessary to have a piggy-back board to use the expansion port, why does this come only with the VX351?" Since the piggy-back comprises just four resistor networks, it should have been simple to build its functionality onto the Voyager's main board, or at least to ship it with the piggyback board already installed. The unattractive thought has occurred to me that the board might be a way to compel you to buy the VX351 rather than build your own CV breakout box, but this is just speculation on my part, and — I hope — untrue. With the piggy-back board installed, the VX351 provides outputs for 18 CV sources, two Gates, and the noise generator, and adds two attenuators and two four-way multis to the Voyager. Together, these transform the instrument from a powerful integrated monosynth into a powerful semi-modular monosynth. Strangely, all of the VX351's facilities appear to be passive. This is a non-trivial point... even the sockets in the multiples are soldered together without buffering, which means that when you use the multiple as a signal splitter, you may experience voltage 'droop'. More seriously, if you try to use either of the multiples as a cheapo mixer (as many people do) you may — at best — obtain unexpected results. At worst, you will sum voltages in excess of the Voyager's ability to handle them. Beware! Hang on a moment, let's step back half a paragraph... semi-modular? I'm afraid so. Neither the synth nor the CV Expander offer individual patch points for the audio generated by the oscillators, so the combination of the Voyager and the VX351 is architecturally closer to a Korg MS20 than an ARP 2600. Some users have complained that the VX351's 21 CV and Gate sockets do not drive other synths correctly, so I measured voltages for those outputs that I could determine using a digital multimeter. After two to three hours 'on' at room temperature, most voltages fell a fraction short of specification, although a number were well over five percent off (by the way, I think that the quoted 'A' range for the touch-screen should be 0V to +5V, not ±5V as specified in the VX351's literature). Nevertheless, the measurements do not fall too far outside the expected ranges... this is an analogue synth, after all! The measurements I took allayed one significant fear I had: that the VX351 would be incapable of driving my 1V-per-octave modular synths correctly. This is because the voltage-to-pitch scaling within the Voyager itself is 0.935V-peroctave, which is not just non-standard — it's unique to the Voyager. Apparently, the earliest VX351s did indeed output this strange scale, but it seems that this has now been fixed; the review unit produces almost precisely 1V-per-octave, and a trimmer allows you to calibrate the pitch CV if it becomes necessary to do so.
Putting Everything Together file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Voyager%20By%20Bob%20Moog.htm (9 of 14)9/26/2005 8:18:07 AM
Voyager By Bob Moog
I received the VX351 and CP251 some months before OS v2 existed, so my first experiences of them were with my Signature Edition Voyager running OS v1.5. I installed the required piggy-back board (see box below), connected the VX351 and CP251, and was ready to start experimenting. This was when I noticed how useful the optional £50 CP/VX rackmount kit would be. The kit converts the two boxes into a shallow, 3U rackmount assembly, and allows the Voyager to power the CP251 through the VX351. My first use for the VX351 was to route control voltages back into the Voyager in otherwise unavailable ways, and this allowed me to overcome a number of limitations in the synth itself. For example, it was obvious how to patch the VX so that the Voyager could trigger its envelopes using its own LFO. This is now no longer necessary thanks to the new facilities in the version 2 OS, but the principle remains valid. Likewise, I eventually worked out how to use the VX and CP to overcome the Voyager's maddening Modulation Buss problems... To recap this problem briefly, which is described in more detail in my original review; the Shaping options in the modulation busses do not allow you to introduce an effect from zero, which is a remarkable limitation in so expensive an instrument. But if you add the VX and CP to the equation, it becomes relatively simple. Let's hypothesise that you want to use aftertouch to introduce and control vibrato. The solution works like this... You patch the Pressure output on the VX through the CP251's slew generator to slow the almost instantaneous 10V sweep from -5V to +5V that occurs whenever you lean on a key, and then route the modified aftertouch CV back to the Voyager's Mod1 buss input, whereupon it acts as a multiplying factor for the Amount control in the Pedal/On buss. Having patched the devices, you must now set the Voyager's Pedal/On source as the LFO triangle wave (which generates the vibrato) and set the destination to Pitch. The position of the Shaping control is irrelevant (although I suspect that it's best set to 'On'), but the Amount must have a non-zero value, or no modulation is produced by the buss. You can now set the mod wheel to zero (ie. fully towards you) and use aftertouch alone to introduce pitch modulation into an otherwise unmodulated signal. This certainly works, but why does it need to be so convoluted? Now, you might say that the pot-mapping facilities introduced by the Voyager's version 2 OS render all of this unnecessary, and for the most part you would be right. However, leaning even gently on the Voyager's keys causes the aftertouch value to jump from zero to 'lots', so that the pot-mapping destination jumps almost instantaneously from one state to another. Patching pressure sensitivity through the VX and CP produces a more pleasing effect, because of the slew you can introduce into what is otherwise an almost on/off response. Once I'd got used to the low-budget feel of the VX and CP's connectors and sockets, and had used both units to overcome two of my biggest complaints regarding the Voyager, I started to feel rather more enthusiastic about them, and used them to cure the Voyager's inability to apply portamento to the filter cutoff file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Voyager%20By%20Bob%20Moog.htm (10 of 14)9/26/2005 8:18:07 AM
Voyager By Bob Moog
frequency (which still exists, even in OS v2.3). I did this by directing the VX351's keyboard CV output to the CP251's slew generator and returning the resulting signal to the synth's filter CV input (remember to set keyboard tracking in the Voyager to zero, or you'll get 200-percent tracking when you try this). It wasn't possible to match the filter portamento precisely to the keyboard Glide, but I found that all manner of interesting sounds were now available, primarily by forcing the self-oscillating filter to track the VCOs, with different amounts of glide on each. I also created some interesting effects by setting the amount of slew differently for playing up the keyboard than for playing down. Unfortunately, you can't apply this trick to the oscillators themselves, because you can't disconnect the internal keyboard CV, so the patch always generates 200-percent tracking, which is — for melodic work — useless. Even setting Oscillator 3's tracking to 'Off' does not work, because this also disconnects it from the CV input. I found that, with the 'aftertouch patch' permanently in place, it was no mean trick to keep track of the 'virtual' patching within the busses themselves, as well as the physical patching between the three boxes. But once I had got the hang of things, creating traditional modular synth effects became straightforward. For example, I used the CP251's LFO and sample-and-hold facilities to trigger the Voyager's envelopes and modulate its filters, while at the same time producing slow pitch sweeps and pulse-width modulation effects using the Voyager's internal LFO. This took me deep into sound effects territory, but the combination of the three units was equally at home creating musically interesting patches that are often the preserve of modular synths and their software equivalents. While experimenting, I found that the Inverter in the CP251's Mixer proved to be an unexpected bonus, and I ended up wishing that there were more of these. It's useful to be able to modulate one parameter upwards while another is sweeping downward 180 degrees out of phase. Likewise, I became accustomed to having the CP's and VX's attenuators at my disposal, finding that these tamed the Voyager's performance CVs, thus making it possible to create patches that were more subtle than those available on the synth alone. Once I had upgraded to OS v2.3, it was immediately obvious that I needed the VX and CP far less frequently to overcome restrictions in the Voyager itself. This then released them for more esoteric duties. I placed the Voyager, CP251 and VX351 alongside my Analogue Systems Integrator RS8000 modular, and started cross-patching between the two systems. Suddenly, the Voyager leapt into life as the (almost) modular system it had always promised to be. Using the VX351 to direct pitch CVs and Gates to the Integrator, I found that the RS oscillators tracked perfectly, and that its envelopes and VCAs responded exactly as one would wish. Remembering to use the VX's and CP's attenuators to protect the Voyager from the Integrator's meaty ±10V signals, cross-patching was a doddle, and I finally realised why I — and all other Voyager owners — will eventually have to cough up for the VX. Why? Because it makes experimental synthesis with the Voyager fun. Imagine playing both synths simultaneously, directing the Integrator's output to the Voyager's external signal input so that you can filter and re-filter it using the Moog's filters as well as its own comb filters, EMS Synthi filters and on. The resulting sounds are big. Really big.
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Voyager%20By%20Bob%20Moog.htm (11 of 14)9/26/2005 8:18:07 AM
Voyager By Bob Moog
The CP251 Control Processor Although part of the Moogerfooger range, the CP251 can also be used as part of a Voyager system, although it requires a separate power supply when used as a stand-alone unit. The module offers seven distinct sections: a four-channel CV mixer, a slew or lag generator, a dual-waveform LFO, dual attenuators, a four-way multiple, a noise source, and a sample-and-hold section. Five of these offer TRS sockets that allow you to use expression pedals if desired. These sockets are denoted by the red, rather than black, retaining nuts. You can also use conventional tip/sleeve jack plugs in these, but they will short the power supply to ground, resulting in a tiny current flowing within the plug itself. There's no risk associated with this, nor will there be any adverse effects on the operation of the unit, but shorting any one socket in this way disables the ability of any other sockets to work with pedals. The Mixer is in many ways the most interesting part of the CP251. It combines two inputs with attenuators (inputs 1 & 2), two direct inputs (3 & 4), an Offset control that provides a DC offset, and a Master knob that controls the amplitude of the mixed signal, up to a maximum of unity gain, subject to an absolute maximum of +5V. Oh yes, and there are positive and negative outputs available simultaneously. The Mixer has a bandwidth in excess of the upper limit of human hearing, so it's also capable of audio mixing, but there's no way to use it as a VCA, which is a shame. Alongside the Mixer, the Slew Generator (or 'Lag Processor') has a novel twist: independent controls for slewing the rise time and fall time of a waveform. This means that if, for example, you direct the square wave output from the LFO to the Slew In, you can shape it into a trapezoid, a sawtooth, a ramp wave, or a triangle, with many subtle variations in between. I like this. The fastest and slowest slew rates are quoted as 1ms and 1s respectively and, although the slowest is still rather rapid to be considered all-encompassing, it will be adequate for many synthesis tasks. This brings us to the LFO itself which, as on the Voyager, offers just two cyclic waveforms; triangle and square, with a nominal frequency range of 0.2Hz to 50Hz. However, you can apply control voltages to the Pedal In socket to extend this down to 0.03Hz at the low end (which can produce the languorous sweeps I like) and up to 100Hz or more at the top end, which suggests a number of FM possibilities.
The CP251 control-voltage processor.
The dual attenuators do their job well, with a measured output of 0 percent at the minimum setting, and very nearly 100 percent at the maximum. Likewise, the fourway Multiple does what it says on the tin, although — as on the VX351 — its sockets are merely soldered together without buffering. The CP251's noise generator is different from the noise source provided on the Voyager, being altogether smoother and 'bluer'. If you heard either in isolation you would think it typical, but an A/B comparison demonstrates how different they are from one another. Bear in mind, however, that the output is low. At well under 1V, file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Voyager%20By%20Bob%20Moog.htm (12 of 14)9/26/2005 8:18:07 AM
Voyager By Bob Moog
this restricts the CP251's use as a noise modulation source. Finally, as with the Mixer and Slew Generator, the S&H section offers somewhat more than is immediately apparent, with the stepped signal presented at Output 1, and a smoothed (low-pass filtered) version presented at Output 2. The low-pass filter frequency is determined by the LFO Rate knob, which is a bit strange, but this ensures that a consistent response is obtained if the LFO is used as the S&H Trigger. Regrettably, the maximum sample voltage is of the order ±3V, which means that you must take care when you use the CP251 with other modular synths. What's more, the sample is triggered by a falling transient, not a rising one, so you will obtain unexpected results unless you take this into account. The seven sections on offer seem to be reasonable choices, although the CP251 is let down by the lack of a VCA. Notwithstanding this, if you tried to purchase all of these modules in modular synth form, they would almost certainly cost more, so I'll sum up by saying that the CP251 is good value for money, if you want the exact combination of facilities it offers. A word of warning, however... When I first used the CP251, inputs 1 and 2 on the Mixer were unusable, refusing to allow a quarter-inch jack plug all the way in, so no connection was made. Having first satisfied myself that there was no internal obstruction, I managed to get a jack into each with a bit of 'encouragement'. After this, the plugs worked as normal, but it didn't leave me with a good feeling about the CP251's build quality.
Conclusions We've covered a vast amount of ground in this review, with two major revisions of the Voyager's operating system, a new hardware model, and two add-on boxes that you can use in all manner of ways to enhance your synthesis. Starting with the operating system upgrades, there's only one conclusion to be drawn: you would be certifiably insane if you did not upgrade to the current OS. It doesn't cure all the bugs in the Voyager, and even ignoring the hardware faults, there should be at least one further software revision to iron out the remaining problems with the touch-screen. However, minor faults aside, the version 2 OS has fulfilled the promises made nearly two years ago. The Voyager is now a much better instrument. In fact, it's excellent. Moving on to the Voyager hardware, you may think that I've been rather uncompromising, poring over all manner of minor defects and quibbles. This may be true, but, at this price, you have the right to expect something that is finished and works correctly. Thankfully, we are now much closer to that ideal than ever before, with the Voyager performing as specified, and with fewer faults than previously. As for the Anniversary Edition, it's very nice, and seems slightly better built than the Signature model that I own. The switches are a tad more positive, the LEDs are brighter, and there's that all-important fix to the pitch-bend wheel. However, you'll have to decide whether you can live with the whine that the backlight emits. If you can, this is the Voyager for you. If you can't, you can always leave the file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Voyager%20By%20Bob%20Moog.htm (13 of 14)9/26/2005 8:18:07 AM
Voyager By Bob Moog
backlight permanently off. Next... I was initially a little disappointed with the VX351. It promised much, but seemed a bit clumsy, and didn't add quite as much as I had hoped. It wasn't until I stopped using it to overcome limitations within the Voyager itself and placed it next to another patchable synth that the VX proved its worth... which then proved to be considerable. I still have reservations about paying extra for outputs that should — in my opinion — be built into the synth itself, but if you are truly serious about synthesis and own a Voyager, the VX is almost a necessity. I'm less convinced by the CP251, but that's because — in keeping with most players interested in modular synthesis — I already have access to its functions elsewhere. But here's the acid test... If I were today offered my walnut Signature for its original price of approximately £3000, or an Anniversary for under £2000, there is no contest which I would choose... the Anniversary Edition. It looks great, works better and, with the money I had saved, I could buy the VX351 and CP251, and still have enough cash left over for a cheap holiday in the sun. Published in SOS November 2004 Sound On Sound, Media House, Trafalgar Way, Bar Hill, Cambridge CB3 8SQ, UK. Email:
[email protected] | Telephone: +44 (0)1954 789888 | Fax: +44 (0)1954 789895
All contents copyright © SOS Publications Group and/or its licensors, 1985-2005. All rights reserved. The contents of this article are subject to worldwide copyright protection and reproduction in whole or part, whether mechanical or electronic, is expressly forbidden without the prior written consent of the Publishers. Great care has been taken to ensure accuracy in the preparation of this article but neither Sound On Sound Limited nor the publishers can be held responsible for its contents. The views expressed are those of the contributors and not necessarily those of the publishers. Web site designed & maintained by PB Associates | SOS | Relative Media
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Voyager%20By%20Bob%20Moog.htm (14 of 14)9/26/2005 8:18:07 AM
Zero-X Beat Quantizer
In this article:
Thinly Sliced Further Features Groovy Baby! Summing Up
Zero-X Beat Quantizer $250
Zero-X Beat Quantizer Multitrack Beat Slicer & Quantizer (PC) Published in SOS November 2004 Print article : Close window
Reviews : Software
pros Excellent way to tidy up timing or add groove to a multitrack performance. Very easy to use.
cons Stand-alone operation may put some users off. User-interface could be a little slicker in some respects.
If you are an avid slicer of beats, then Zero-X's latest offering might just appeal. With its support for multitrack slicing and quantising, is Beat Quantizer the best thing since sliced bread? John Walden
summary Beat Quantizer is a wellfeatured beat-slicing tool, with the added bonus of very effective and creative groove quantise functions.
information $250. www.beatcreator.com
Test Spec Beat Quantizer v1.02. PC with 2.4GHz Pentium 4 and 1GB RAM running Windows XP Pro, with Echo Mia 24, Egosys Wami Rack 24 and Yamaha SW1000XG soundcards. Tested with Sony Acid Pro 4, Steinberg Cubase SX 2.2, Propellerhead Recycle 2.1.
Only those who have been locked away in a very dark corner for the last few years can have failed to notice the rise and rise of software tools designed for slicing and dicing audio beats. As demonstrated by Simon Price's recent beatslicing masterclass (SOS June 2004, available on-line at www.soundonsound. com/sos/jun04/articles/beatslicing.htm), these tools are now available whatever platform or sequencer application cranks your particular handle. Swedish-based Zero-X have a pedigree in this field with Beat Slicer and Beat Creator. While the former is a slicing tool, Beat Creator also offers quantising options, but both are restricted to use with a single mono or stereo track. Beat Quantizer adds multitrack support to the mix, allowing several loops to be manipulated together and quantised to the same groove. An obvious application is for tightening up a multitrack drum part — with snare, kick, hi-hat, and so on all recorded on separate tracks — but it is also possible to apply a groove to guitar, keyboard or bass parts.
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Zero-X%20Beat%20Quantizer.htm (1 of 4)9/26/2005 8:18:12 AM
The Master Track (at the top of the screenshot) is key to Beat Quantizer's multitrack 'slice and quantise' capabilities.
Zero-X Beat Quantizer
Thinly Sliced Beat Quantizer's loop-slicing features are more than capable of the sorts of processes described by Simon in his masterclass article, but they can also do a lot more besides. Like Propellerhead's Recycle, Beat Quantizer is a stand-alone application — any loops must be opened within the application, sliced and diced, and then exported again prior to use within a sequencer or other audio application. While using a slicing tool within a host application (such as Phatmatik Pro or Cubase SX's Hitpoint functions) has some advantages, in practice, the stand-alone nature of Beat Quantizer is not such a big deal — the benefits of multitrack support certainly outweigh any disadvantage here. When working in multitrack mode, it is easier if each audio file is the same length and tempo, although tools for tempo and/or pitch adjustment plus a loop multiplier (which, for example, can make a copy of a one-bar loop so that it has a length of two bars) are available via the Process and Edit menus if required. The quality of these tools seems to be good, and quite marked tempo reductions are possible before obvious audio artifacts appear. From the Beat menu, each track is sliced individually into beats, and the series of slice markers created is termed a 'grid'. As with similar beat-slicing applications, the user can adjust the sensitivity of the slicing process and slice markers can also be added, adjusted and deleted manually. Although the user interface is perhaps not quite a slick as that of Recycle, the slicing process itself seems very effective. If slicing is all that is required, Beat Quantizer can then output each sliced track in a variety of popular formats. These include Acidised WAV files, REX, MIDI and Beat Quantizer's own ZEX format. However, simply slicing loops for manipulation elsewhere would be missing out on the 'Quantizer' bit of this application's name — and much of the creative fun that it provides. In essence, Beat Quantizer is a lot like the Beat Detective tool in current TDM versions of Pro Tools.
Further Features As well as the core functionality described in the main text, Beat Quantizer also provides a neat collection of ancillary features. A few highlights include: Export to Fruity Loops. Batch processing of files. Support for Zero-X groove file format in Halion 3. Basic EQ, limiter and multi-mode filter effects that can be applied to loops within Beat Quantizer. SCSI sample dump to various popular hardware samplers.
Groovy Baby! file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Zero-X%20Beat%20Quantizer.htm (2 of 4)9/26/2005 8:18:12 AM
Zero-X Beat Quantizer
In both single-track and multitrack modes, Beat Quantizer can also quantise sliced loops, either to a fixed beat such as 16ths (a 'static' quantise) or to a groove. This groove can be read from a pre-saved file but, by utilising Beat Quantizer's Master Track (created via the Multi-Track menu), groove quantising a series of loops becomes a much more intuitive process. This is perhaps best explained by means of a brief example. For the purposes of testing, I loaded five two-bar loops into Beat Quantizer featuring kick drum, snare drum, hi-hat, bass guitar and rhythm guitar. These were taken from a rapid mixand-match session done in Acid Pro 4 and, while the loops worked well enough together in terms of style, they were fighting with each other a little in terms of timing. Having sliced each loop, I then created an empty Master Track (this appears at the top of the track list). Slice markers from one or more tracks can be copied to the Master Track, and in this case I copied the slice markers from the kick and snare tracks, since they were the main elements in the arrangement that defined the groove. Beat Quantizer's quantise functions were then used to apply this 'master' groove to the other The user has good control over the quantise tracks. Like most MIDI sequencers, options. Beat Quantizer can push and pull events towards the groove represented by the Master Track slice markers, and a selection of controls helps the user dictate how tightly this groove is applied. Once the tracks are quantised, Beat Quantizer will then play back the loops together so the results can be auditioned. In my simple example, this process produced an instant tightening of the hi-hat, bass and rhythm guitar performances relative to the kick/snare pattern, and the result was much more musical than the original combination of the unprocessed loops. Of course, having created a tight groove from these performances, it is perfectly possible to produce some variations on it. Having saved the initial snare/kickdriven groove, I then repeated the process using the slice markers from the hihat pattern to control the groove quantise. What resulted had a noticeably different feel, while clearly being the same musical performance — and using the two grooves at different points within a song structure helped to provide some subtle variety that can often be missing from loop-based music. Once a loop has been quantised, it is then 'finalised' — Beat Quantizer smooths the gaps or overlaps between any audio slices that have been moved by the quantise process. Again, the user can control exactly how this smoothing operates, and one useful element here is the 'pre-cut' feature that defines a short period of time prior to each slice marker, which is included as part of the slice.
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Zero-X%20Beat%20Quantizer.htm (3 of 4)9/26/2005 8:18:12 AM
Zero-X Beat Quantizer
This means that the initial stages of a transient are not lost when two slices overlap. Whatever processing Zero-X have going on behind the scenes here, the end results are very smooth. The processed loops can then be exported as new audio files (Acidised WAV and REX are both included amongst the various export options) and returned to a sequencer for incorporation into a full arrangement.
Summing Up In use, I would only have two minor criticisms of version 1.02 of Beat Quantizer. First, there are a small number of quirky things about the user interface that occasionally result in a few extra mouse clicks than are perhaps necessary to perform some tasks (for example, you have to clear a warning box each time a slice grid is cleared, and it would be nice to have the option to disable this). Second, the PDF manual, while very informative, still needs a little polish. However, Peter Segerdahl, the programmer behind Beat Quantizer, seems to keep up a steady stream of updates, so I suspect some of these (very minor) rough edges will disappear as development continues. It is possible to achieve the same 'slice and quantise' results with some presliced loops via Dr. Rex in Reason or using Hitpoints in Cubase SX, but as a dedicated tool, Beat Quantizer is certainly a very efficient environment to experiment with this sort of groove manipulation. Providing extreme time-, tempoand pitch-shifting is avoided, the processing generally provides glitch-free results. While it is priced just far enough above the £100 mark not to be considered an instant purchase for the hobbyist, for those who need to tidy up some sloppy live drumming or who would like more control over the groove of their loop-based music, Beat Quantizer is a very useful and creative tool. There is some wellestablished competition, but for all slicers and dicers of loops, Beat Quantizer certainly deserves a test drive — and potential purchasers can do just that, as a save-disabled demo is available via the Zero-X web site. Published in SOS November 2004 Sound On Sound, Media House, Trafalgar Way, Bar Hill, Cambridge CB3 8SQ, UK. Email:
[email protected] | Telephone: +44 (0)1954 789888 | Fax: +44 (0)1954 789895
All contents copyright © SOS Publications Group and/or its licensors, 1985-2005. All rights reserved. The contents of this article are subject to worldwide copyright protection and reproduction in whole or part, whether mechanical or electronic, is expressly forbidden without the prior written consent of the Publishers. Great care has been taken to ensure accuracy in the preparation of this article but neither Sound On Sound Limited nor the publishers can be held responsible for its contents. The views expressed are those of the contributors and not necessarily those of the publishers. Web site designed & maintained by PB Associates | SOS | Relative Media
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Zero-X%20Beat%20Quantizer.htm (4 of 4)9/26/2005 8:18:12 AM
Q. Can I get a more accurate bass sound using a subwoofer?
Q. Can I get a more accurate bass sound using a subwoofer? Published in SOS November 2004 Print article : Close window
Sound Advice
What are your opinions on having a subwoofer in the studio? I have recently demoed the Blue Sky Media Desk 2.1 system and I was very impressed by its quality and its price, but I have a few concerns. I'm worried that having a sub in my bedroom studio may cause more problems than it solves. The room is on the second floor of a semidetached house, has thin walls and a lot of other annoyances (fitted cupboards and so on) though I will be treating the room as best I can. There are calibration tests that you can do for the 2.1 system but I cannot afford to spend another £200 or more on a spectrum analyser kit to carry them out. How easy is it to do these kind of tests by ear, and, in any case, can the response of this sort of system be made accurate in any kind of room, no matter how unsuitable? My music tends to be quite bass-heavy (drum & bass and hip-hop), so I want as accurate a bass response as possible. I also demoed the Genelec 8030As as a stereo pair, which sound very nice, but I have read that they need their matching sub to reach their full potential (the satellites go down to 58Hz). So, what would give me a more accurate bass response under my conditions: the 2.1 system set up as well as possible by ear, or a standard stereo setup like the 8030As? Simon Epstein PC music specialist Martin Walker replies: Thankfully, small Genelec monitors like the 8030As don't hype up the upper bass area just above the point where their response suddenly disappears altogether like many ported (bass reflex) speakers do, which is what helps to make them sound so natural. However, their response does fall off pretty dramatically below 58Hz, so for drum & bass or hip-hop you'll still need some low-end reinforcement from a subwoofer like Genelec's 7050A model to judge the low end of your mixes — assuming, that is, that your thin walls still make this acceptable to those on the other side! So, I suspect that whichever of these two systems you choose, you'll end up with two smaller satellites and a subwoofer. Personally I'm always a little wary of trying to achieve really low bass in a small room, whether using a large pair of speakers or small satellites and a sub. It's certainly possible, but without some acoustic treatment most rooms already have serious problems below 200Hz that will only be aggravated by trying to generate sizeable amounts of additional low end below about 50Hz or 60Hz. file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Q.%20Can%20I%20get%20a%20m...curate%20bass%20sound%20using%20a%20subwoofer.htm (1 of 3)9/26/2005 8:18:24 AM
Q. Can I get a more accurate bass sound using a subwoofer?
There's some good advice to be found in Mallory Nicholls' article on choosing and installing a subwoofer from SOS July 2002 (www. soundonsound.com/sos/jul02/articles/subwoofers.asp). One useful technique for finding the optimum position for the subwoofer, as described in SOS April 2003's Studio SOS (www.soundonsound. com/sos/apr03/articles/studiosos0403.asp), is to start by putting it in the centre of your listening position and then crawl around close to the wall behind the satellites until you find the spot where the bass sounds most even and balanced, then put the subwoofer there.
Subwoofer placement is critical when using a 2.1 monitoring system like Blue Sky's Media Desk.
Adjusting its level is also crucial. Remember that if you dial in unnatural, window-rattling bass your friends may be impressed, but your mixes will sound thin on most other systems. In the absence of any test equipment other than your ears, slowly increase the relative level of the subwoofer until it just starts to draw attention to itself as a separate source, and then back it down a little — the perfect setting should seamlessly add bass to the satellites without being obvious. By listening to some familiar CDs on your setup, you can judge its settings, gain a reference point for your own mixes and gauge how well they will translate to other systems. Mind you, if you want an accurate bass response you'll have to install at least some acoustic treatment. In most rooms, you'll encounter room modes (the resonant frequencies determined by the room's dimensions) that give an extremely lumpy bass end with several huge peaks and troughs, which would still make judging mixes of drum & bass and hip-hop extremely difficult. You can hear these yourself by playing a bass guitar over its bottom octave (the low 'E' on a four-string is 41Hz, and the low 'B' on a five-string bass 31Hz) or a clean bass sound on a keyboard. Most of the notes should have similar volumes, but a few will be significantly louder (peaks) and a couple will probably be a lot quieter (troughs). If you don't have any other test equipment, you can just move the subwoofer a few inches at a time and try again for a smoother response until you find the best position in your room. However, in an untreated room this response will also vary hugely depending on your listening position, with huge bass levels in the corners (where the modes pile up). In the case of a small room like yours where your listening position will probably be about halfway between the front and back of the room, with no acoustic treatment you may even find an almost complete null at one high-bass frequency at the listening position. The easiest way to hear these positional variations is to play sustained bass tones at the peak or trough frequencies you've already determined and walk around the room — I guarantee you'll be shocked at how their levels will vary. So if you want an accurate bass end, installing some bass traps in the corners, like the Real Traps Minitraps I reviewed in SOS September 2004 (www.soundonsound.com/sos/sep04/articles/realtraps.htm) will provide a good start in flattening out the response of your room, and only then will your mixes sound neutral at the listening position, but also remain reasonably consistent when you move around. Published in SOS November 2004
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Q.%20Can%20I%20get%20a%20m...curate%20bass%20sound%20using%20a%20subwoofer.htm (2 of 3)9/26/2005 8:18:24 AM
Q. Can I get a more accurate bass sound using a subwoofer?
Sound On Sound, Media House, Trafalgar Way, Bar Hill, Cambridge CB3 8SQ, UK. Email:
[email protected] | Telephone: +44 (0)1954 789888 | Fax: +44 (0)1954 789895
All contents copyright © SOS Publications Group and/or its licensors, 1985-2005. All rights reserved. The contents of this article are subject to worldwide copyright protection and reproduction in whole or part, whether mechanical or electronic, is expressly forbidden without the prior written consent of the Publishers. Great care has been taken to ensure accuracy in the preparation of this article but neither Sound On Sound Limited nor the publishers can be held responsible for its contents. The views expressed are those of the contributors and not necessarily those of the publishers. Web site designed & maintained by PB Associates | SOS | Relative Media
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Q.%20Can%20I%20get%20a%20m...curate%20bass%20sound%20using%20a%20subwoofer.htm (3 of 3)9/26/2005 8:18:24 AM
Q. Can I use acoustic screens to effectively prevent drum spill?
Q. Can I use acoustic screens to effectively prevent drum spill? Published in SOS November 2004 Print article : Close window
Sound Advice
I'm wanting to record a band all at the same time and in the same room, and my main problem is that the drummer is much too loud. I'll be recording them in a rehearsal room and I'm worried about the other performers' mics picking up excessive spill from the kit. Would it be possible or advisable to try and isolate the kit using some screens? I've seen live performances on TV where the drummer is boxed off with clear perspex screens. Would there be a suitable DIY alternative? SOS Forum Post Technical Editor Hugh Robjohns replies: It's virtually impossible to use free-standing screens to generate useful or effective sound isolation, but they can be helpful in reducing spill. They are most effective at high-mid and high frequencies — the laws of physics, the wavelengths of the sounds involved and the physical size of the individual screens determine which frequencies a screen will stop (or, at least, reduce) and which it won't. Don't expect screens to be able to help much in controlling lowfrequency spill — the long wavelengths of low-frequency sounds mean that the spill will get everywhere no matter what! But you can screen off some of the mid- and high-frequency sounds, such as cymbal splashes and snare noise. In my experience, rather than trying to box in the drum kit in an effort to stop its sound from escaping, screens work much more effectively Using mic pickup patterns to reduce spill. if you place them around the microphones that are picking up the most spill, to try to keep the unwanted sound from reaching them. In terms of reducing the amount of drum spill recorded, stopping it leaving and preventing it from arriving come to pretty much the same thing, but the latter is far easier and more effective! You can also reduce the amount of spill by paying careful attention to where you position the musicians relative to each other in the studio, the polar response patterns of their microphones, and where you point those mics. Cardioid and hypercardioid pickup patterns (see diagram), which reject sound coming from the rear and, to a lesser extent, from the sides, are the order of the day. Don't forget that, in addition to the direct sound from the kit, the other mics may also be picking up reflected sound from the surrounding walls. In such cases, an additional screen behind or to the sides of the performer and microphone can help to cut out those unwanted reflections. file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Q.%20Can%20I%20use%20acousti...ens%20to%20effectively%20prevent%20drum%20spill.htm (1 of 2)9/26/2005 8:18:28 AM
Q. Can I use acoustic screens to effectively prevent drum spill?
Boxing in the drum kit with hard reflective surfaces (like perspex panels) often causes more problems than it solves. It is a necessary evil on sound stages sometimes, but as I say, I find you can get better results if you concentrate on trying to stop unwanted sound getting into specific mics from specific directions, rather than trying to stop the unwanted sound from leaving the source. That's more of a job for King Canute! At the end of the day, you will probably have to live with a degree of spill, but this is not the end of the world, especially if you're aiming for a 'live' sound. In fact, in most cases a modest amount of spill only becomes a major problem if you want to overdub something like a completely different guitar solo, when you can still hear the original in the spill on other tracks! Barring any problems with phase cancellation (where spill from a more distant mic interferes with the close-miked signal — switching in phase reverse on the mixer channels for the distant mics should help solve the problem), spill can even help to knit the mix together in a subtle way. As you are recording in a rehearsal room, in conditions which, I assume, will not be ideal, you will have to compromise — if you can get a dry enough drum sound, and can isolate each instrument enough to have control over the balance of the mix, consider your job done. Published in SOS November 2004 Sound On Sound, Media House, Trafalgar Way, Bar Hill, Cambridge CB3 8SQ, UK. Email:
[email protected] | Telephone: +44 (0)1954 789888 | Fax: +44 (0)1954 789895
All contents copyright © SOS Publications Group and/or its licensors, 1985-2005. All rights reserved. The contents of this article are subject to worldwide copyright protection and reproduction in whole or part, whether mechanical or electronic, is expressly forbidden without the prior written consent of the Publishers. Great care has been taken to ensure accuracy in the preparation of this article but neither Sound On Sound Limited nor the publishers can be held responsible for its contents. The views expressed are those of the contributors and not necessarily those of the publishers. Web site designed & maintained by PB Associates | SOS | Relative Media
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Q.%20Can%20I%20use%20acousti...ens%20to%20effectively%20prevent%20drum%20spill.htm (2 of 2)9/26/2005 8:18:28 AM
Q. Do I really need touch-sensitive moving faders?
Q. Do I really need touch-sensitive moving faders? Published in SOS November 2004 Print article : Close window
Sound Advice
I'm looking to buy a moving-fader control surface for my DAW and I'm wondering if it's worth paying a bit extra for one with touch-sensitive faders. How important a feature is this? I understand the principle behind them — that touching the fader knob completes an electrical circuit, and the system responds by giving you control of the fader (disengaging the motor) and recording any fader movements — but so what? I've seen other control surfaces advertised which are not touch-sensitive but nevertheless automatically disengage automation when you move a fader by hand. Are there some other advantages to touch-sensitive faders that I'm missing? SOS Forum Post Technical Editor Hugh Robjohns replies: I find that touch-sensitive faders can be a real mixed blessing. They are very handy — even essential — when mixing with automation because they allow the system to drop into automation record mode the moment you touch the fader, and stop recording automation as soon as you release it. They also stop you having to fight against the fader motors, which aren't always that quick to respond. However, for general live mixing with a digital desk, I find touch-sensitive faders a complete pain. I am currently using a Yamaha DM1000 which, by default, assigns the channel whose fader you are touching to the control screen for adjustment. This is all well and good until you want to keep your hand on one or more faders at the same time to adjust their channel levels while also wanting to adjust some other channel settings on the screen! Needless to say, I now have this touch-sensitive channel selection mode switched off. Another potential problem with touch-sensitive faders is that if you have particularly dry skin or move the faders with long finger nails, the system may not detect that you have moved the fader at all, resulting in no change in sound level. Then, when you grab the fader harder in desperation, the system
The touch-sensitive faders, like those on the Yamaha DM1000, are a useful feature, once you get used to using them.
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Q.%20Do%20I%20really%20need%20touch-sensitive%20moving%20faders.htm (1 of 2)9/26/2005 8:18:32 AM
Q. Do I really need touch-sensitive moving faders?
suddenly realises it has been moved and implements a step level change to the new position! Careful setting of sensitivity thresholds can help, but it is an inherent problem with all touch-sensitive designs. Overall, when properly implemented and adjusted, touch-sensitive faders are probably more of a help than a hindrance — although you will have to adjust to using them. If you can afford such a system, I would seriously consider it, especially if you use a lot of track automation. Published in SOS November 2004 Sound On Sound, Media House, Trafalgar Way, Bar Hill, Cambridge CB3 8SQ, UK. Email:
[email protected] | Telephone: +44 (0)1954 789888 | Fax: +44 (0)1954 789895
All contents copyright © SOS Publications Group and/or its licensors, 1985-2005. All rights reserved. The contents of this article are subject to worldwide copyright protection and reproduction in whole or part, whether mechanical or electronic, is expressly forbidden without the prior written consent of the Publishers. Great care has been taken to ensure accuracy in the preparation of this article but neither Sound On Sound Limited nor the publishers can be held responsible for its contents. The views expressed are those of the contributors and not necessarily those of the publishers. Web site designed & maintained by PB Associates | SOS | Relative Media
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Q.%20Do%20I%20really%20need%20touch-sensitive%20moving%20faders.htm (2 of 2)9/26/2005 8:18:32 AM
Q. Is it OK to paint acoustic foam?
Q. Is it OK to paint acoustic foam? Published in SOS November 2004 Print article : Close window
Sound Advice
Can you tell me how I should go about painting my acoustic foam panels? They are currently white and rather ugly! Is there a particular type of paint — spray paint perhaps — or any other way to colour them that won't damage them or affect their acoustic properties? SOS Forum Post Technical Editor Hugh Robjohns replies: Acoustic foams work because of their open cellular structure. If you paint over the surface of the foam you are very likely to clog up the pores and the effectiveness of the foam in absorbing high- and mid-frequencies will be greatly diminished. I do know people who have used thin emulsion paint with a degree of success, but I really wouldn't recommend it. A much better option would be to cover the foam panels with some cloth — anything thin and acoustically transparent would be suitable. Build a simple four-sided wooden frame to surround the foam panels, with a hardboard back onto which the foam can be glued (perforated board can be used to some advantage). The depth of the frame should be slightly greater than that of the foam, and you can then stretch a coloured fabric of your choice over the frame and staple or pin it tight at the rear. This construction will have negligible effect on the acoustic properties of the foam, will enable any colour scheme you like, and will look more professional to boot! Published in SOS November 2004 Sound On Sound, Media House, Trafalgar Way, Bar Hill, Cambridge CB3 8SQ, UK. Email:
[email protected] | Telephone: +44 (0)1954 789888 | Fax: +44 (0)1954 789895
All contents copyright © SOS Publications Group and/or its licensors, 1985-2005. All rights reserved. The contents of this article are subject to worldwide copyright protection and reproduction in whole or part, whether mechanical or electronic, is expressly forbidden without the prior written consent of the Publishers. Great care has been taken to ensure accuracy in the preparation of this article but neither Sound On Sound Limited nor the publishers can be held responsible for its contents. The views expressed are those of the contributors and not necessarily those of the publishers. Web site designed & maintained by PB Associates | SOS | Relative Media
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Q.%20Is%20it%20OK%20to%20paint%20acoustic%20foam.htm9/26/2005 8:18:37 AM
Q. Why does the speed at which you burn a CD make a difference?
Q. Why does the speed at which you burn a CD make a difference? Published in SOS November 2004 Print article : Close window
Sound Advice
Can you explain once and for all why the speed at which you burn a CD should make a difference to the quality of the audio on it? I've read that higher burn speeds adversly affect sound quality and that this can be clearly measured, but I don't see why this should be the case. Surely, since the data is digital, the ones and zeros should be the same whether you burn at 1x, 8x, 24x or whatever else? SOS Forum Post Technical Editor Hugh Robjohns replies: Different burn speeds do indeed have a measurable effect on the quality of the signal burned into a CD-R, but it also depends on the quality of the CD burner and the CD-R itself. Higher burn speeds don't induce more errors in the disc directly, but you have to remember that while the data is digital, the physical process of burning a CD is an analogue one, and that the error protection embedded in audio CDs is much inferior to that of data CDs. The CD burner creates small bumps in the playing surface of the CD-R that the CD player can then detect. The spacing between each bump is critical to being able to detect and decode the data signal. But more importantly, the rising and falling edge (the beginning and end) of each bump is also critical, and this is the aspect that is most affected by different combinations of burn speed, disc media and the state of the laser. If the bumps have shallow edges rather than nice sharp, crisp edges, the CD player extracts a very jittery signal with ambiguous timing references. Depending on how well designed the player is, a jittery output can often throw the rest of the data decoding system into a state of unreliability, leading to a higher error rate and thus a greater number of uncorrected errors.
HHB's CD-Rs provide one example of a range of media designed and tested for audio applications.
It is generally acknowledged as good practice to burn audio CDs at speeds no higher than 4x, but it is also important that you use good-quality blank media specifically designed for low-speed burning. Most computer media these days is designed for very high-speed burning, usually over 24x. Such discs may not give reliable results when burned at low speeds.
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Q.%20Why%20does%20the%20s...0you%20burn%20a%20CD%20make%20a%20difference.htm (1 of 2)9/26/2005 8:18:40 AM
Q. Why does the speed at which you burn a CD make a difference?
So, matching media and burning speed is critical. However, burning at very fast speeds is inherently less accurate than burning at low speeds. Precision will certainly fall as the speed increases — it's a necessary consequence of the physics of the burning process. Within reasonable limits, this reduced precision in the way the pits are burned isn't a problem for data discs because of the enhanced error protection they employ. Consequently, error checks on data discs will generally confirm that there is no significant increase in error rates when burned at high speeds when the media and burner are up to the task. However, Red Book-standard audio CDs work in a different way, have a much lower error protection capability and rely on the spacing between the bumps and the angle of their edges to retrieve and decode the data properly. High-speed burning makes the problem much harder to resolve, and hence most experienced mastering engineers prefer to copy discs at relatively low speeds. Don't underestimate the importance of the chemistry of the CD-R itself. Just like CD burners, not all CD-Rs are created equal and there is a significant difference in the quality of the media from different manufacturers, sometimes even from batch to batch from the same manufacturer. I would advise only using reputable, branded media designed specifically for audio purposes. Published in SOS November 2004 Sound On Sound, Media House, Trafalgar Way, Bar Hill, Cambridge CB3 8SQ, UK. Email:
[email protected] | Telephone: +44 (0)1954 789888 | Fax: +44 (0)1954 789895
All contents copyright © SOS Publications Group and/or its licensors, 1985-2005. All rights reserved. The contents of this article are subject to worldwide copyright protection and reproduction in whole or part, whether mechanical or electronic, is expressly forbidden without the prior written consent of the Publishers. Great care has been taken to ensure accuracy in the preparation of this article but neither Sound On Sound Limited nor the publishers can be held responsible for its contents. The views expressed are those of the contributors and not necessarily those of the publishers. Web site designed & maintained by PB Associates | SOS | Relative Media
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Q.%20Why%20does%20the%20s...0you%20burn%20a%20CD%20make%20a%20difference.htm (2 of 2)9/26/2005 8:18:40 AM
AIM: Association Of Independent Music
In this article:
AIM: Association Of Independent Music
What Can AIM Offer You? Alison Wenham • Steve Johnston Coping With Divergence Published in SOS November 2004 Team Player The One-man Operation & Print article : Close window AIM — Buzz Records People : Music Business Testing Times Five Become Four The Small Record Label & AIM — Hospital Records Dealing With The Internet We'd all like to make a living from selling our own That Sharing Feeling music — but how would you actually go about it? The The Media Empire & AIM — UK's Association Of Independent Music offer some The Echo Label/Chrysalis thoughts on how to cope with the opportunities and Music pitfalls of the modern music industry. The Virtual Major Simon Trask
The worldwide music industry is at a crossroads — on the one hand, the Internet offers new means of selling and distributing music, but on the other, traditional record companies everywhere are consolidating and merging, as seen most recently in the case of the Sony/BMG merger, which reduced the worldwide 'big five' of record labels to a tremendously powerful quartet of companies. Of course, the smaller the label, the more they are vulnerable to to the effects of these farreaching changes, and into this category fall all independent record companies and 'one-man band' operations, such as those started by SOS readers to sell the results of their own musical endeavours. Without a mechanism for these labels to act and negotiate deals collectively, the UK's healthy tradition of diverse, independent music could be endangered. And this wouldn't be merely a cultural loss — taken as a whole, the UK independent record sector is not only strong creatively, but also financially. Last year, the indie market generated 30 percent of the year's platinum-selling artist albums, and accounted for 25 percent of sales in the UK market, worth around £420 million in total. In the UK — the third largest market in the world for music sales, after the US and Japan — squaring the circle of indie solidarity and indie diversity is a task which has fallen to the Association of Independent Music (AIM) ever since they opened their doors in March 1999. Created by the independent sector to represent the interests of indie labels, AIM are a non-profit trade body which handles educational, promotional, lobbying and negotiating activities on behalf of their membership — now more than 800 labels strong.
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/AIM%20%20Association%20Of%20Independent%20Music.htm (1 of 12)9/26/2005 8:18:51 AM
AIM: Association Of Independent Music
What Can AIM Offer You? Both labels and distributors can join AIM providing they are at least 50-percent independently owned. Which means a major can have a stake in a member company, so long as it's not a controlling one. Members must also produce or distribute records and/or music videos in the UK, and have a place of business in the UK. In addition, labels need to be PPL members. This is because their annual subscriptions are derived from a percentage deduction from their PPL income (12 percent this year, up from nine percent previously). For those labels who don't yet have any PPL income, AIM has introduced a £120 annual subscription fee. Labels also pay a one-off joining fee of £100 plus VAT, while distributors all pay a set annual fee of £750 plus VAT. If you're a sole trader making your own music, you can still be a member of AIM. However, you need to be running your own record label. And like all AIM label members, you need to be a member of PPL and also a copyright owner — which you would be, of course, unless you'd signed your rights away.
The AIM web site at www.musicindie.org.
"The company could be a limited partnership, it could be a sole trader, it could be a cooperative, it could be a number of different corporate entities." says Alison Wenham. "But it needs to be a copyright owner. There are more and more managers who are copyright owners nowadays. The world is changing, and so are the old business models. The record company role may be fulfilled by other entities like managers, publishers, artists or artist communities." AIM membership benefits include access to a members-only section of the AIM web site (containing a wealth of advice and information and a web forum discussion board), a free copy of The AIM Guide to Survival and Success in the Music Business (a rather large PDF file, almost 700 pages long, which comes on CD-ROM, and is also available to non-members for £10 plus VAT and postage). Members also get regular email updates on AIM activities, access to specialist legal, financial and technology advice, and the ability to participate in regular educational and networking events, as well as access to the Internet licensing deals negotiated by AIM's new media arm, Musicindie. Companies which have business connections to the independent record sector can help support AIM and have special access to members and events by becoming Friends of AIM for an annual fee of £1000 plus VAT. Currently AIM has almost 50 Friends, among them Capital Radio Group, Channel 4, OD2 and Shazam. Microsoft are the latest company to become a Friend — although Apple are conspicuous by their absence.
Coping With Divergence Of course, the British record industry as a whole has had a body fighting its corner since 1973, when the BPI were formed, principally to fight the growing problem of music piracy, and representatives of both the majors and the
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/AIM%20%20Association%20Of%20Independent%20Music.htm (2 of 12)9/26/2005 8:18:51 AM
AIM: Association Of Independent Music
independents sit on the BPI's Council. However, back in the '90s, as most of the large independent labels were swallowed up by one or other of the majors, a number of independent-label BPI members began to feel that the organisation couldn't effectively address both their needs and those of the majors. "There had been growing concern that the direction of the industry would lead to increasing divergence between the agendas of small and large, and national and multi-national, companies," says Alison Wenham (above), AIM's chair and chief executive, who has headed up the organisation since its inception. "As a result, a growing number of independent labels, the leaders of whom were on the BPI Council, felt that even though the industry had an effective trade body, it couldn't solve, or accommodate, the gap that they saw opening up. It was partly to do with on-line music sales, and partly to do with globalisation." So it was that a group of about 40 indie labels got together in 1998 and decided that they needed a Photo: Piers Allardyce professional organisation dedicated to supporting and Alison Wenham, CEO of promoting the interests of the independent sector. AIM. Interviews followed, and Wenham got the job of leading AIM, and representing what Mute label boss and former AIM board member Daniel Miller once called "a bunch of disparate despots." Part of the rationale behind forming AIM was a perception that the indies' on-line interests would diverge from those of the majors. "The Internet's a global distribution platform, and the majors obviously have the investment capability to exploit that opportunity, while the independents, left to their own individual devices, wouldn't necessarily have had as much opportunity or choice," says Wenham. "So we've worked extremely hard to give smaller companies access to on-line licensing services." Wenham points to two recent examples of ways in which AIM and the BPI have divergent priorities: "If you take the Sony/BMG merger, the BPI are on record as saying that they do not feel it appropriate to make comments about the business intentions of two of their members. I, on the other hand, representing the independent sector, have no such problem. The independent sector needed to object to the merger. And I gave a quote when the BPI announced they were intending to sue [file-sharing] customers, which was that AIM support efforts to control piracy but not to the extent that it means suing the customers. We do not endorse the suing of our customers. The independents are not culturally attuned to litigation. They would rather cut a deal, they would rather let bygones be bygones and find a pragmatic solution than throw lots and lots of lawyers and money at proving a point."
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/AIM%20%20Association%20Of%20Independent%20Music.htm (3 of 12)9/26/2005 8:18:51 AM
AIM: Association Of Independent Music
Team Player Occupying modest offices in Chiswick, London, AIM remain a lean operation like many of the labels they represent. A core team of three full-time employees and several part-time staff is augmented by a 15-member Council and six committees, including those dedicated to Legal & Business Affairs, New Media, International, and Training, Education & Mentoring — all of which draw on representatives from the member labels. Member representatives on the Council are elected by the membership on a one-member, one-vote basis. Wenham herself brings to AIM a long and varied history in the music industry, going back over 25 years, which has seen her working in both the independent and multi-national sectors. She's run her own distribution company and her own independent record label, and for around four years prior to taking up the AIM post, she worked at BMG as a Managing Director. She's also sat on the BPI Council and the PPL Board. But it's not just her industry experience which makes her ideal for the task of shepherding the indie sector through increasingly challenging times — she has a steely determination born of enthusiasm for the job she does. From the outset she has been determined that AIM wouldn't be an organisation that tried to effect change by "standing on a hill and throwing stones at the existing structures" as she puts it. "We've achieved change by sitting at the table and negotiating, rather than by being accusatory, obstructive, and therefore easy to be ignored."
The One-man Operation & AIM — Buzz Records Scottish blues guitarist Dave Arcari is living proof that AIM encompasses even one-man indie labels — and that its membership base extends beyond London and South-east England. Based in Perth, Scotland, he singlehandedly runs Buzz Records — primarily an outlet for his band Radiotones — along with Buzz Artist Management and Buzz Publicity (collectively the Buzz Group). An AIM member since the organisation's early days, Arcari first heard about the then-new Association of Independent Music in 1999 at a meeting of NEMIS (NEw Music In Scotland), itself at the time a newly established network for the Scottish music industry. "I thought 'Well, I'm a PPL member, so I can join AIM fairly easily'," he recalls. "Our subscription was taken from our PPL income, and there was also a deal that if you were part of NEMIS, you could join AIM for what was really a token payment. So I joined, and then started finding about all their initiatives and seminars. They're very supportive of people regionally, and I feel confident that if there was a big issue up here they would have no hesitation in helping us." Arcari points to AIM's presence at tradeshows
The one-man label — Dave Arcari of Buzz Records.
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/AIM%20%20Association%20Of%20Independent%20Music.htm (4 of 12)9/26/2005 8:18:51 AM
AIM: Association Of Independent Music
like MIDEM, the deal it negotiated with leading Russian distributor Soyuz, and its 2001 Far East trade mission as ways in which it effectively represents and promotes UK indies large and small. "Through going to MIDEM and what have you, we've managed to get good distribution in the States and Canada, Australia and Sweden. And these distributors are fantastic, they're pro-active." He's less impressed with UK distributors, and says his current one is winding down. A visit to an AIM distribution day in London proved useful, however. "It was great to sit down with all these various distributors. I certainly felt that I learned a lot from it, from a strategic point of view." For the moment, however, he's decided to concentrate on the self-help approach — which means focusing on Internet-based sales. "We're selling more CDs online than we are through distribution in Britain and Europe put together. And that's been the case for a while," he reports. Arcari is also expanding into selling Buzz Records' catalogue on-line as MP3 downloads, using the Paypal-based Payloadz. com to provide the e-commerce facility. Meanwhile, he's been getting the label's catalogue into the on-line music services for several years by signing up to AIM's Internet deals, beginning with the original Napster. "We've basically signed up for all of them. Anything that's non-exclusive, we go for," Arcari says. "Originally I thought, 'Nobody's ever going to pay for a download!'. Now I watch the money rolling in! Well, not quite rolling, more like a trickle, but it's a trickle that wouldn't be there otherwise." www.thebuzzgroup.co.uk www.radiotones.com/buzz/records.htm www.davearcari.com
Testing Times Perhaps more than any other in AIM's history, this year has highlighted the divergence of issues facing the majors and the independents, and underscored the importance of collective bargaining power for the indies. First, European independents had to face down MTV in contract renegotiations. The music video broadcast giant wanted to halve the amount it had been paying for the rights to show their videos on its MTV Europe channels, while increasing the number of channels covered — and threatened to stop showing indie videos altogether if they didn't comply. AIM were at the forefront of organising collective resistance to this move, not least by organising and chairing a conference call for the press to highlight the issue. Then came the iTunes Music Store launch in the UK, France and Germany, and the spat between Apple and the indie community which left the on-line music store launching over here without the rights to sell music by any European indie artists (see the News pages in SOS's August and September issues). Although Apple were negotiating directly with the likes of sizeable indie Beggars Group rather than with AIM, it was in effect negotiating with AIM, or at least with the sense of collective enablement that AIM has fostered. Ultimately, it was the solidarity of the biggest independent labels with all the rest right down to the
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/AIM%20%20Association%20Of%20Independent%20Music.htm (5 of 12)9/26/2005 8:18:51 AM
AIM: Association Of Independent Music
smallest which brought both MTV and Apple back to the bargaining table, and resulted in deals which benefited the indie community as a whole. "We have the backbone of support from the large labels, who could do their own deals but believe in the collective approach," says Wenham. "They believe in a community benefit, and they're very happy that smaller labels are getting more as a result. It's no skin off their nose, they get a good rate, but so do the younger, newer labels."
Five Become Four The other big issue to confront the independents this year has been the merger by Sony and Bertelsmann of their recorded music divisions to form Sony BMG. As SOS reported a couple of months ago, the merger has been given the goahead by both the European and US anti-trust regulatory bodies — in both cases, essentially on the basis that there wasn't enough evidence to rule to the contrary. Speaking at AIM's AGM in advance of the decision, Wenham herself said it would be "an act of cultural vandalism" on the Commission's part if the merger went through. Now that it has, four multi-national companies between them control some 80 percent of the global recorded music market. "There's now an increasing need for independents to work together, not just on a national level but also an international level," Wenham says. She summarises the implications of the merger for the music market in general as "further concentration and consolidation." and feels that it increases the chance of an EMI/ Warner merger. However, the prospect of a 'super-indie' is unlikely, she says. "The indie business structures are, and always have been, more flexible than the corporate model. And size is no longer a guarantee of success. The far more likely scenario is that the indies will do well through successful A&R and working in partnership."
Photo: Piers Allardyce The full AIM team (from left to right): Michael Fuller (Director of Business Affairs), Remi Harris (Project Manager), James North (Assistant Press Officer), Lara Baker (Association Administrator), Sam Shemtob (Press Officer), Judith Govey (International and Membership Manager), Steve Johnston (Head of Licensing, Musicindie) and Alison Wenham.
Meanwhile, a lot of people are set to lose their jobs as Sony and BMG set about combining two businesses into one. "The only silver lining is that there are a lot of people with relevant skills coming onto the job market," says Wenham. "Some of them will start their own independent companies, and some of them will go to existing independent companies, which is a good thing."
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/AIM%20%20Association%20Of%20Independent%20Music.htm (6 of 12)9/26/2005 8:18:51 AM
AIM: Association Of Independent Music
For the most part, however, Wenham sees the effects in a negative light. On past form, it's likely that there'll be a cull of the artist rosters, as the sheer size and scale of the majors as businesses will push them towards having fewer, biggerselling artists. "I think the corporate model for music is one which will mitigate against diversity," says Wenham. "The naive, simplistic view is that bigger and fewer majors means more artists signing to the indies. The naivety in there is that it presupposes you can reach the market. Market share is market power. And the more you concentrate market power into the hands of the few, the more difficult it becomes to keep the access open to all forms of music. You need access to the intermediaries, to radio, magazines, television, and retail. If you're not played, you're not heard, and if you're not heard, you're not bought. It's as simple as that. Consumer habits, behaviour and expectations are somewhat modelled by the mass-market principle, and therefore one cannot just assume that a multiplicity of genre-specific radio stations on the Internet will reach an audience sufficient to make it commercial." Wenham points out that the trend of consolidation has been with us for some years, with consolidation in retail being particularly of note. "It's not just the structure and size of the majors, it's the structure and size and dominance of retail. There are now fewer distributors as well, because of this contraction in diversity and choice, and the contraction in retailing, which unfortunately confirms the trend. I'm not sure that it will be better in the on-line world either; I think one or two players will dominate. Dominance is never good for culture." So how can AIM best help their members meet the challenges of a more consolidated market? "By acting as the fifth major, keeping market access open through both commercial and political activity, aiding international development, sharing knowledge, and providing hands-on help," Wenham replies succinctly.
The Small Record Label & AIM — Hospital Records London-based indie drum and bass label Hospital Records, which has been going since 1996, joined AIM at the beginning of 2000. "At that time Hospital were still quite small," says label co-founder Tony Colman. "It was a gut feeling for me. I spoke to a couple of people who were involved with AIM, and I thought 'Maybe this will fail, maybe it'll succeed, but I want to give it a chance.' And it soon became apparent that this was a very important thing for any independent label to be involved in." Colman also cites the importance of AIM's — and in particular Alison Wenham's — ability to bring the indies together as a collective force. "The size of our membership now means that we're collectively another major label in terms of our bargaining power. Alison is very charismatic, she's very driven, and she's one of the few people I know who can actually steer this ship. It needs someone like her who's extremely headstrong and knowledgeable and good at negotiation. She confronts everybody in the world on our behalf when it's needed." Without an organisation like AIM, he avers, a lot of independents would file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/AIM%20%20Association%20Of%20Independent%20Music.htm (7 of 12)9/26/2005 8:18:51 AM
AIM: Association Of Independent Music
end up arguing among themselves instead of working together. Hospital have been growing significantly in size over the past few years, with an ever-expanding catalogue of releases on CD and vinyl from a growing roster of artists. This year has also seen the label's first music DVD release, and while they've had their own web shop selling physical product for about the past five years, latterly with AIM's help they've been moving into Internet and mobile download sales as well, through the likes of Wippit, O2, Sony Net, iTunes and Napster. Not surprisingly, then, Colman considers AIM's new media activities through its Musicindie arm to be a significant part of what the trade body does.
Tony Colman, co-founder of Hospital Records and creator of the London Elektricity project .
"Our main formats are still CD and vinyl, but the on-line digital formats will no doubt increase exponentially in importance over the next few years," he says. "I've had someone here full-time since last October working on new media, and it's really helped him to work with AIM, attending their monthly meetings and using some of their contracts. They're basically invaluable in terms of the information and telling you what deals are coming up, because we'd be blundering about in the dark otherwise. "AIM can introduce you to deals, allow you to use their contracts, help you as much as they can, but you have to bear in mind that they're not your mother, and they don't make sure that you get paid at the end of the day!" www.hospitalrecords.com
Dealing With The Internet A key area of AIM's activities has to do with on-line licensing deals, which are negotiated by their new media arm, Musicindie. On behalf of AIM's label members, Musicindie have struck deals with a growing number of Internet and mobile music companies, such as OD2, O2, Crosswarp, So-net, Napster MkII, Wippit, and Sony Connect. All the deals are open to any member to take advantage of, whether they're a multi-label group like Beggars or Sanctuary, or a one-man operation like Buzz Records (see the box below). "We're creating far better access than independent labels could achieve individually, but the old-fashioned jobs of marketing and promotion still have to be done," Wenham cautions. "There's a lot of work needed to create awareness and interest, but that's not our job." Each member label is free to opt in or not to each of AIM's download service deals. And in the case of OD2, which licenses its music e-commerce platform to a variety of on-line retail outlets, labels can opt in on a per-outlet basis. Now that non-music companies are starting up on-line music stores to add to their core businesses, it's clear that this was a clever move which respects the diversity of views among the membership. Not all labels might want to sign up to Wal-Mart Music or MyCokeMusic, for instance. On the file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/AIM%20%20Association%20Of%20Independent%20Music.htm (8 of 12)9/26/2005 8:18:51 AM
AIM: Association Of Independent Music
other hand, Oxfam's OD2-based download store Big Noise Music, launched at the end of May this year, is not only a very clever marriage of music and Oxfam's international social agenda, with a percentage of each sale going to support Oxfam's fair-trade campaign, but also a very comfortable fit culturally for many indie labels. "There are some parallels there with the music industry; globalisation doesn't necessarily lead to healthy local sustainable economies," observes Wenham. "And AIM is very much about making sure that in music there will be a sustainable, healthy, strong, vibrant, independent industry."
Photo: Piers Allardyce Steve Johnston, head of the Internet-licensing part of AIM, Musicindie.
AIM have been open from the outset to working with the commercial on-line music services — even with the original Napster, which could have become a going commercial concern if the majors had followed AIM's lead instead of concentrating on suing the file-sharing service into oblivion. Wenham proudly observes that AIM are the only organisation to have struck licensing deals with both versions of Napster. "How about that for a unique claim to fame!" she grins. On a more downbeat note, she views the closing down of the original Napster by the majors as a "big, big mistake". "Shawn Fanning was the Richard Branson of the new music-business model. And the people who ran Napster, although they were in court and it was an illegal file-sharing service, they were doing their very best to change Napster into a legitimate on-line service that would compensate artists. They had some record-industry people in there, and they were trying very hard to reach an accommodation that everyone could live with for the future. Whereas KaZaA have no such intention, never had any such intention, and don't give a damn. There are very different corporate consciences at work there."
That Sharing Feeling Wenham says that AIM don't have a public position on file sharing, because the membership itself encompasses a diversity of views — for instance, for the smaller labels in particular, limited marketing budgets make file sharing an attractive way to build awareness. "The independents are as different from each other as they are from the majors," Wenham observes. "Whereas it might be easier for the publishers or the BPI to be emphatic about a position, my position with over 800 label members is that I respect the differences as much as I respect the similarities. What is right, though, is that any copyright owner should have the choice as to whether their music is made available for free or not." Musicindie's Head of Licensing Steve Johnston (above), who has negotiated file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/AIM%20%20Association%20Of%20Independent%20Music.htm (9 of 12)9/26/2005 8:18:51 AM
AIM: Association Of Independent Music
many of AIM's on-line deals on behalf of its members, has an interesting perspective on where the indies should be headed. The deals with the likes of iTunes, Napster MkII and Sony Connect are "not earth-shattering innovation in the independent style," he says. "These are like big corporate services. We're not just following the majors where they're plodding, we're trying to think outside these mainstream channels, because that's what iTunes is really, it's a mainstream retail channel." Johnston says that independents shouldn't be complacent about making use of the opportunity that's offered by the Internet to make a much wider choice of music available for people to listen to. "The majors have never been interested in people hearing that much music, they're more interested in controlling the amount of product that people get to hear." Instead, he talks in terms of an "outbreak of peace" with the file-sharing networks. "We continue talks with them, because if we can find the business model that means artists are remunerated, we'll do that deal," he says. "At the moment, these services are just like a bugbear for the majors. But the independents appreciate how much music consumers can get hold of now that they couldn't easily before. If we can put in the business structures to make sure that the artists get their due, then independents are going to succeed massively in this area."
The Media Empire & AIM — The Echo Label/Chrysalis Music Like the other two indie labels highlighted in this piece, The Echo Label joined AIM early on. Unlike them, they're part of a large independent media empire. Parent company the Chrysalis Group encompasses a Music division, a Books division, a Radio division, and — since March of this year — a Mobile division as well. Echo, naturally enough, come under the Chrysalis Music division, which also encompasses music publishing and music licensing. The label was formed in 1993, and today includes the likes of Feeder, Moloko, and The Stands on its artist roster (Chrysalis Records, incidentally, is owned by EMI, having been bought by the major from Chrysalis back in 1989). Jeremy Lascelles, chief executive of the Chrysalis Music division, was elected to the AIM board last year, and also sits on the BPI Council. He has a long history in the independent sector. Following 13 years at Virgin Records in A&R and Marketing positions as well as a spell as MD of label subsidiary 10 Records, he became MD of Chrysalis Music in 1994, then MD of The Echo Label in 1998, before assuming his current post in 2001. "I'm a great believer in the importance of independent music companies for the health of the industry, and I think it's incredibly important that they're able to stand shoulder-to-shoulder on certain key industry issues," he says. "But they also tend to be under-resourced, and many of them don't have departments devoted to negotiating industry issues. So I'm emotionally supportive of AIM as the body that represents them, and acts as one voice negotiating on everyone's behalf."
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/AIM%20%20Association%20Of%20Independent%20Music.htm (10 of 12)9/26/2005 8:18:51 AM
AIM: Association Of Independent Music
Lascelles cites the independents' victory against MTV earlier this year as an example of what can be achieved by indie solidarity. But he also points to the value of the on-line music service deals that Musicindie have negotiated. "Musicindie's knowledge in the on-line field is something we take full advantage of, otherwise I'd have had to look at redeploying my resources, or even bringing someone in to do all those kind of deals. It's an increasingly important part of our business model." As a well-established label with all the resources of the Chrysalis Group behind it, Echo don't need all the services and advice that AIM offer to labels. Nevertheless, Lascelles is supportive of the breadth of AIM's work. "A company that's really just one person operating out of his front room, with very modest turnover; that's still a valid business. People who are starting out with very little money in their bank account, trying to run a small independent label — their business survival is as important as anyone's. And AIM provide the information services that will let people like that find out more about how things work." www.echo.co.uk www.chrysalis.com
The Virtual Major Of AIM's many initiatives, the most ambitious one has to be the Worldwide Independent Network, or WIN, which is just getting off the ground. The project's goal is to network together the various record label trade bodies around the world utilising the Internet. Wenham refers to WIN as a "virtual major" — and given that the independents collectively are on the scale of a major, it's a concept which makes sense. "The majors have got global infrastructure, the independents haven't," says Wenham. "When I sat down and thought about what the differences were between the independents and the majors, that was one of the key things. So the question was what could we do to create global infrastructure without interfering with our members' businesses." Initially WIN will network together AIM and their companion indie trade bodies in Australia (AIR), Canada (CIRPA), and the US once the new body gets started — but AIM have also been actively approaching independent trade associations in other countries such as Brazil and Japan. WIN will be a closed network, accessible only to members of the various participating trade bodies. Johnston comments: "Principally, it will be an information resource for UK acts to understand how, say, the Australian market works, how they get there, who the tour agents are, who the promoters are. And likewise, to be a source of information about the UK market for the Australian industry as well." Wenham enthuses that WIN will grow to become "a worldwide information, communication, networking, licensing, shopping, learning network." If you're a hip-hop label in Australia, she says, or a reggae label in the States, and you're looking for a radio station in Germany that specialises in playing your type of
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/AIM%20%20Association%20Of%20Independent%20Music.htm (11 of 12)9/26/2005 8:18:51 AM
AIM: Association Of Independent Music
music, WIN will be the place you'll go. "It's going to be a deals platform as well, and there'll be things like a parcel tracker, currency converters, and templates for standard license deals and distribution deals. I'd also like it to have an on-line licensing platform." It's a bold and ambitious vision, and only time will tell if it's successful. Despite Wenham's long-ranging, some might say lofty ambition for the indie music industry that she loves, she also takes a pragmatic view. "You don't know what's going to affect the indie industry at any time. You can predict certain things, others you couldn't possibly predict. All I want is for AIM to be there, at the ready, able to move quickly and appropriately to meet the agenda that we can set, and the agenda that we don't yet know about." Published in SOS November 2004 Sound On Sound, Media House, Trafalgar Way, Bar Hill, Cambridge CB3 8SQ, UK. Email:
[email protected] | Telephone: +44 (0)1954 789888 | Fax: +44 (0)1954 789895
All contents copyright © SOS Publications Group and/or its licensors, 1985-2005. All rights reserved. The contents of this article are subject to worldwide copyright protection and reproduction in whole or part, whether mechanical or electronic, is expressly forbidden without the prior written consent of the Publishers. Great care has been taken to ensure accuracy in the preparation of this article but neither Sound On Sound Limited nor the publishers can be held responsible for its contents. The views expressed are those of the contributors and not necessarily those of the publishers. Web site designed & maintained by PB Associates | SOS | Relative Media
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/AIM%20%20Association%20Of%20Independent%20Music.htm (12 of 12)9/26/2005 8:18:51 AM
Bill Szymczyk
In this article:
Underwater Sound Factory Fresh Welcome To California Eagle Sounds Caribou Ranch Enter The Eagles
Bill Szymczyk Producer Published in SOS November 2004 Print article : Close window
People : Artists/Engineers/Producers/Programmers
From unlikely beginnings as a naval SONAR operator with no musical training, Bill Szymczyk became a legendary producer and engineer whose work with the Eagles would define the hi-fi sound of '70s rock. Dan Daley
"An ongoing series of happy accidents," is how Bill Szymczyk (pronounced 'Sim-zik') characterises a career that seems custommade for a movie of its own. The stars did seem to align perfectly throughout much of his life. For instance, growing up in Muskegon, Michigan, Szymczyk built a crystal radio from a kit, as many kids did in the 1950s. You could only receive one station — if you were lucky enough to get any at all — and which one was completely a matter of chance. As it turned out, Szymczyk's windings connected him (after the antenna lead accidentally came in contact with his mattress's bed springs, Bill Szymczyk (seated) with the J Geils amplifying the signal) with WLS in Band, for whom he would produce Nashville, then one of the nation's foremost several hit albums. outlets for blues and R&B, the kind of niche station that played the records of artists like BB King and Robert Johnson. "Of all the stations that a white kid in the middle of the Midwest would bump into..." he recalls of the moment. Fifteen years later, Szymczyk found himself producing King in New York. The bluesman hesitantly allowed him to put string parts on a track entitled 'The Thrill Is Gone', which would help King to become the most recognisable icon of blues the mainstream music world has ever had.
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Bill%20Szymczyk.htm (1 of 9)9/26/2005 8:18:54 AM
Bill Szymczyk
Szymczyk seems to have slid easily into each of the many serendipitous scenarios that fate had in store for him, and it is perhaps that ability to accept things as they are that allowed him to benefit from each new turn of events, and for the artists he worked with to reap similar advantages. "I'm a professional listener," is how Szymczyk describes what he does as both an engineer and as a producer. "I listen and I react. I never was a musician, so I don't bring any preconceived prejudices to the table; I don't favour the guitar over the keyboard, and so forth. I just listen and try to figure out if I have anything I can bring to a song."
Underwater Sound Szymczyk's audio career began in an offbeat manner. In 1960, the 18-year-old signed on with the US Navy. "It was the height of the Cold War at the time," he recalls. "Our arch-enemy, the Russians, supposedly had submarines everywhere, loaded with missiles ready to attack us. So the Navy had put a premium on finding recruits with very good ears, to become SONAR operators. As soon as they inducted you, they gave you an audiometer test to check your hearing. The people who scored in the top five percent they sent directly to SONAR school. They didn't ask you; they just sent you, whether you liked it or not. I guess I had pretty good ears, because in the next six months they crammed about three years' worth of college-level electronics knowledge into me." Four years later, Sonarman Petty Officer Third Class Szymczyk was mustered out of the service having never even imagined a career in music, and never learned to play an instrument or had any particular desire to do so. "I'd always loved music," he says, "but as a listener, not a player." While in the Navy, however, his boat had been docked a few times at the Brooklyn Navy Yard in New York, and he'd made some friends there. A Bill Szymczyk's production of 'The Thrill Is course in radio and television Gone' helped to turn BB King into perhaps production he'd taken in the service led the biggest name in blues music. him to apply to the Media Arts school at New York University, which accepted him. "Thing was, I had gotten out of the Navy in February, 1964, and classes didn't start until September, so I had to find a way to kill some time," he remembers. A friend got him an interview at Dick Charles Recording, a studio heavily used by the new generation of songwriters that came up as the old Tin Pan Alley faded in file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Bill%20Szymczyk.htm (2 of 9)9/26/2005 8:18:54 AM
Bill Szymczyk
the city. Don Kirshner was running Screen Gems Music, with staff writers like Carole King, Gerry Goffin, Neil Sedaka and Neil Diamond, who were using the studio to cut demos to acetate. "The first time I went into the studio I saw a session with Carole King and Gerry Goffin," Szymczyk says, still sounding somewhat awestruck at the memory. "I kinda got interested at that point." Interested enough that, when NYU asked for a tuition check a few months later, Szymczyk decided to stick with music for a while to see where it led him. For 70 dollars a week, Szymczyk made the acetate copies of the demos that were being churned out on Dick Charles Recording's mono machines at a furious pace, in the days before the singer-songwriter undercut the notion of the professional pop composer. Within a year, though, he had worked his way into the engineer's seat, cutting some of the demos by ping-ponging back and forth on a pair of mono tape decks. A songwriter, Helen Miller, referred Szymczyk to Bob Lifton, owner of Regent Sound a little further uptown and substantially further upscale. "At Dick Charles, we only had mono decks," he explains. "Regent was a full four-track facility with a Scully multitrack machine. Bob took me on and I ended up managing the place as well as doing sessions there. We did folkies in the daytime, like Phil Ochs, Tom Rush and David Blue, and we did these independent R&B records at night, like Van McCoy. I got to the point where I was working 80 hours a week."
Factory Fresh The next serendipitous occurrence took place in 1967 when Szymczyk met Jerry Ragavoy, producer for R&B artists like Paul Butterfield, Dusty Springfield and Dionne Warwick, who was preparing to open the Hit Factory studio at its original location at 701, Seventh Avenue. (Ragavoy moved it twice, and operated from multiple locations, before selling the studios to the late Ed Germano in the 1970s, who consolidated them into the current huge facility.) Szymczyk became the Hit Factory's first regular engineer, and saw working closely with Ragavoy as more than worth the position: "If anyone taught me how to be a producer, it was Jerry Ragavoy. I saw how he handled musicians, how he chose songs, how he got performances out of people. The kinds of things you can only learn by being and working with someone closely for months and months on end." It was information he'd make good use of. Szymczyk saw the careers of engineers-turned-producers like Tom Dowd and Glyn Johns taking off, and wanted to make the same transition himself. "One way would have been to keep freelance engineering and hope that bands would recognise my production potential, too," he says. But when a chance to become a staff producer at Paramount-owned ABC Records was offered to him, he didn't hesitate, even though it meant a pay cut, from the $1000 he was earning a week as busy freelancer to the $300 the label was offering. Shortly after signing on, Szymczyk began lobbying executives to let him make a record with BB King, whose label, Blues Way Records, just happened to be a subsidiary of ABC Records (more file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Bill%20Szymczyk.htm (3 of 9)9/26/2005 8:18:54 AM
Bill Szymczyk
happy accidents). Reluctant at first to pair a white producer with a black artist, the A&R department relented on the condition that they could sell the idea to King himself. King's records had recently been produced by Johnny Pate, using King's road band. Szymczyk envisioned a more energetic recording and pressed King to use certain New York session players, musicians he had met while working with Ragavoy. "The way it was, BB was basically recutting the same record over and over again," Szymczyk says. "We met at his hotel room and I outlined what I hoped to do. He said it was interesting, but he wanted to hedge his bets, so he said we won't do the whole album that way, just half of it, the other half being done the way he always made records, with his band."
Bill Szymczyk today.
Live & Well came out in early 1969 and spawned the R&B hit 'Why I Sing The Blues', which also made a dent in the pop charts. This convinced the label and King to quickly take another shot at this combination. Later that same year, Completely Well came out with 'The Thrill Is Gone', which would become King's signature song. "On that record, I used Herbie Lovelle on drums," Szymczyk says, "Gerald Jemmott on bass, Paul Harris on keyboards and Hugh McCracken on guitar. It was an evenly mixed band racially. Half black, half white, but they were all young guys. The energy was there. BB started playing the song riff in that minor key and Paul picked up on it immediately on the Wurlitzer electric piano. It fell into its groove in minutes. I was freaking out, that's how good it was. Then I got the idea to put strings on it. I called BB and he hesitated a bit. But I called in a great arranger who wrote this killer, hypnotic chart and we put it down. That was his breakthrough record." It would be a good one for Szymczyk, as well. ABC gave him the green light to find and sign his own acts to produce. One of the first was the James Gang, fronted by the eccentric Joe Walsh. They recorded at the Record Plant and at the second incarnation of the Hit Factory, where Szymczyk worked the hand-built 10:2 console and Scully eight-track deck. The studio was outfitted with Altec 604E monitors, but Szymczyk was aware of the value of nearfield monitoring even in those days, so he asked for and got a pair of KLH 17s for the James Gang mixes. Szymczyk's next happy accident was when ABC Records merged with Dunhill Records and those staff in New York not made redundant — both of them — were shipped to Los Angeles. Szymczyk was one of them. He, his wife and twoyear-old child flew out on New Year's Eve, 1969 and landed on New Year's Day, 1970. A new year, a new decade, a new chapter.
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Bill%20Szymczyk.htm (4 of 9)9/26/2005 8:18:54 AM
Bill Szymczyk
Welcome To California Szymczyk's first assignment in LA was an odd one. He was designated the music supervisor for a bizarre rock-western film being shot in Mexico. Zachariah would not only feature the music of the James Gang, the New York Rock & Roll Ensemble (featuring as lead singer the late Michael Kamen), Country Joe & the Fish and Elvin Jones, but it would be their on-screen feature film debuts, as well. (Country Joe was the cinema veteran, having been in the Woodstock film the year before.) "It was all very weird, very weird," Szymczyk says. "It was the perfect way to get introduced to Hollywood." Szymczyk lived there little more than a year before a sizeable earthquake sent him literally running for the hills. In February, 1971, he and a colleague from ABC/ Dunhill decided to start a label, Tumbleweed Records, and located it in a rented house in Denver, which Szymczyk figured was far enough away from any new earthquakes. The first few months were a struggle — Szymczyk took a DJ job at a local radio station while his partner, Larry Ray, scrounged for start-up capital in New York. Finally, Famous Music came through with $1 million and both the label and a joint production company were off and running. "I made sure that the agreement that we had with the production company was non-exclusive, allowing me to produce records that weren't on our label," Szymczyk explains. And it would seem he was going to be busier elsewhere than in Colorado for a while. Besides producing Joe Walsh's classic first solo record, Barnstorm, and subsequently The Player You Get, The Smoker You Drink, which had the hit 'Rocky Mountain Way' on it, Szymczyk also met with the J Geils Band, rootsy blues-rockers from Boston. Realising he'd rather be in the studio fulltime, Szymczyk traded his half of the record label for Ray's half of the production company. Szymczyk and the J Geils Band settled into the Record Plant Studios in New York. He was getting them on their second LP, The Morning After, which spawned the hit 'Looking For A Love'. "The band always recorded ensemble," he recalls. "There were really very few overdubs, occasionally a harp solo by Magic Dick. Even Peter Wolf's vocals were often cut live as the band was putting down the track. We made those records in between three and four weeks."
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Bill%20Szymczyk.htm (5 of 9)9/26/2005 8:18:54 AM
Bill Szymczyk
Eagle Sounds Eagles records were a benchmark for drum sounds in their time. Bill Szymczyk says he and Henley invested a lot of time experimenting with microphone choices and placements, but that most of the time they reverted to fairly common configurations. "There was a lot of flavour-of-the-week with microphones back then," he says. "But it would usually come back to a Shure 57 on the top of the snare, either U67 or 87s as overheads, sometimes AKG 414s. It was the usual stuff, and always on just four tracks. One of the reasons the drums sounded good was because they were a kit, not a whole bunch of separate tracks. We didn't use a lot of room sound on the drums, but we did use the EMT plates a lot. We actually used the first electronic drum on 'Heartache Tonight'. I had gone to a bar in Miami and heard this band using a SynAir and we decided we'd use it to double the snare on that track. It was groundbreaking for its time." Szymczyk also began to use comping to get the Eagles' signature vocals. "Studio C at Criteria had this one-of-a-kind MCI console. It had LEDs that could turn channels on and off much more quickly than the usual buttons. It was instant. I'd usually do five takes of the lead vocal and then start comping my way through them, picking out lines, phrases and words. And we did it all without automation." The Eagles's background and harmony vocals were stacked on two or three tracks, panned modestly at about eight and four o'clock. They were always recorded ensemble, around a single microphone. "The great thing about them was that they really could sing and they could connect with each other as they sang. But it was also the most tedious part, because when you have four voices on one track, that's four chances for one to make a mistake. Sometimes we'd do the same phrase for three hours to get it right." However, it was all worth it, says Szymczyk — the madness, the pharmaceuticals, the arguing. "What stays with me now is how proud I am that those records we made have withstood the test of time," he says, with genuine emotion. "It's very gratifying to stand in a restaurant or a lobby and hear 'Hotel California' playing in the background."
Caribou Ranch But Szymczyk was still living in Colorado, which was becoming the rustic retreat for some of the LA music industry's odder citizens. It was about to become a recording centre, assuring that the flow of eccentricity from west to east would continue. Producer Jimmy Guercio had had considerable success producing the file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Bill%20Szymczyk.htm (6 of 9)9/26/2005 8:18:54 AM
Bill Szymczyk
bands Chicago and the Illinois Speed Press. He had moved to nearby Nederland and was in the process of converting a barn into a recording studio. Szymczyk and Walsh, just starting on Walsh's solo record, managed to burn out the mixer at Walsh's home on the first day. "So I drove over to Guercio's ranch," Szymczyk says. "It had a huge barn with the interior about two-thirds done, but very little gear. We talked and he said he was going to Hollywood to make a movie, Electraglide In Blue, with Robert Redford. He was originally the producer but he fired the director and was going to direct it himself, so he would be gone for a while. He had ordered an MCI 4Series console and it was installed but the building had no plumbing and the main floor still had a dirt floor and horse stalls. But upstairs where the studio was was carpeted and it had a nice new grand piano. We could make it work." Thus, Szymczyk christened what would be dubbed the Caribou Ranch with Walsh's Barnstorm LP followed by Rick Derringer's All American Boy and the single 'Rock & Roll, Hoochie Koo'. (Szymczyk had met Derringer when the former was the engineer on Edgar Winter's famous instrumental 'Frankenstein'.) When James Guercio returned to Caribou with the Beach Boys and Chicago in tow for records, Szymczyk saw it as another sign that things were going to change for him once again. He had done a few scouting trips to Miami. "All the New Yorkers were down there," he says. "Tom Dowd had gone down there. He really sold me on the move. And there was a great studio there, Criteria."
Enter The Eagles One of the first records Szymczyk did in Criteria was Walsh's second, The Smoker You Drink, The Player You Get, which Walsh had started there on his own; Walsh and Szymczyk ultimately took it back to Colorado and finished it at Caribou Ranch. Walsh was managed by Irving Azoff, who also managed the Eagles. Szymczyk recalls the way he and that band would become intertwined for the next decade. "They had worked with Glyn Johns on the first record, but I was told that they didn't get along. Don [Henley] and Glenn [Frey] felt that Glyn was a tyrant in the studio. They regarded themselves as an American band, a country-rock band with the emphasis on rock. They saw Glyn as taking them more towards a slicker pop sound. "They had already had a couple of hits from that first record — 'Take It Easy' and 'Peaceful Easy Feeling', but the second record didn't sell as well as the first. They started the third record with Glyn in London and had completed most of it when they decided to work with me. They were willing to start all over. I agreed, but on one condition: that I check with Glyn and that he was OK with it. He was one of the producers I had looked up to for a long time. I called him in London and I guess the feeling was mutual, because he said 'Better you than me, mate!'" Szymczyk and the Eagles went into Criteria and cut On The Border in three weeks. It was a substantial change from how they had worked with Johns. "Don file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Bill%20Szymczyk.htm (7 of 9)9/26/2005 8:18:54 AM
Bill Szymczyk
Henley asked me how many microphones I used on drums," Szymczyk recalls. "I said I used about eight or so. He was stunned; Glyn used to use two or three at the most. Don wanted to be a rock drummer, and he heard the sounds they were getting on rock records. That's what he wanted and he was convinced that was how you got those sounds." Their first recordings together were done on a 16track machine, but multiple 24-track As the '70s wore on, Eagles projects took up decks soon followed. (In fact, more and more of Bill Szymczyk's time — Szymczyk is not being curmudgeonly but the rewards were, he insists, worthwhile. when he says that he believes younger Although he has officially retired, Szymczyk engineers are at a disadvantage continues to work with Glenn Frey (left) and because of access to virtually unlimited the current Eagles line-up. tracks. "What you don't learn when you work in Pro Tools is how to make decisions," he states. "When you're running six microphones to mono, you definitely learn to make decisions right on the spot, because you can't fix it in the mix. The advent of multitracking led to the ability to defer decision-making. But at some point, somebody's gotta deal with it.") The Eagles were no strangers to internal turmoil. Founding member Bernie Leadon had quit during the second album in a dispute that found him wanting to emphasise the 'country' part of the band's country-rock equation while the rest wanted it to stress the latter. Bassist Randy Meisner was essentially fired and replaced by Timothy B Schmidt (who had also previously replaced Meisner in Poco). Szymczyk says his production style was well-suited to this turgid environment. "I was a bud, not a boss," he says. "They would not react well to someone dictating what should happen. Mostly I just listened and was always willing to try new stuff." What definitely got tried was Szymczyk's patience. The next album, The Long Run, took 18 months to complete, and tempers flared often. It was recorded in Studio A at Criteria. The next, One Of These Nights, was split between Criteria and Record Plant in LA, as was Hotel California. Some of the Eagles' recordings were also done in a personal studio, Bayshore Recording, that Szymczyk had put together in 1976. It had an MCI console, like virtually every other studio in the area, since MCI's founder, the late Jeep Harned, was based there. Szymczyk's pace slowed down as his work with the Eagles began to turn into a career. "I
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Bill%20Szymczyk.htm (8 of 9)9/26/2005 8:18:54 AM
Bill Szymczyk with Kenney Jones of the Small Faces and the Who —
Bill Szymczyk
Szymczyk produced the latter's used to make six or seven records a year," he 1981 album Face Dances. says. "Now, the Eagles were becoming a fulltime job. We were renting the studios by the month; each album was taking longer to make. On The Border, they came in with all the songs completely written. On the next record, they had maybe five or six finished songs and a bunch of ideas they developed in the studio. As things progressed, it became more like 'Let's cut some tracks and try to write songs around them later.' By the time of Hotel California, that was the norm for them. But every record was selling better than the one before it. They were minting money. So we all stayed with it. It was a life of excess, and I was right there with them in the middle of it."
There is another new Eagles record sitting in the can, but sadly, in the can it will likely stay. Szymczyk and the band began working on it nearly three years ago, but the same personality conflicts that scuttled the band the first time are preventing this career coda's completion. "We have 17 tracks — and three sets of completed lyrics," smiles Szymczyk, who retired officially in 1990 to a spacious, secluded home in North Carolina after racking up a few more hits with artists such as Bob Seger (he produced and engineered 'Against The Wind') and the Who's Face Dances. "Some things never change." (One track, 'Hole In The World', was finished and released on the Eagles' second best-of collection.) The basic tracks were done in Los Angeles between O'Henry Studios and the Henson Studios, formerly A&M Records' studios, which Szymczyk says has the best drum room he's ever heard. Overdubs get done — sporadically — at Glenn Frey's home studio. "There's some incredible tracks we have," Szymczyk laments. "I hope they get to see the light of day some day." Published in SOS November 2004 Sound On Sound, Media House, Trafalgar Way, Bar Hill, Cambridge CB3 8SQ, UK. Email:
[email protected] | Telephone: +44 (0)1954 789888 | Fax: +44 (0)1954 789895
All contents copyright © SOS Publications Group and/or its licensors, 1985-2005. All rights reserved. The contents of this article are subject to worldwide copyright protection and reproduction in whole or part, whether mechanical or electronic, is expressly forbidden without the prior written consent of the Publishers. Great care has been taken to ensure accuracy in the preparation of this article but neither Sound On Sound Limited nor the publishers can be held responsible for its contents. The views expressed are those of the contributors and not necessarily those of the publishers. Web site designed & maintained by PB Associates | SOS | Relative Media
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Bill%20Szymczyk.htm (9 of 9)9/26/2005 8:18:54 AM
Business End
In this article:
Business End
OK Junior Raising Listen & Learn from Reader Published in SOS November 2004 Sand Audrey Print article : Close window This People : Miscellaneous Month's Panel
Tracks
Business End enables you to have your demo reviewed by a panel of producers, songwriters, musicians and managers. If you want your demo to be heard by them, please mark it 'Business End'.
OK Junior Track 1 Sam Stubbings (SS): "It seems like they're going for an Ian Brown/Happy 3Mb Mondays sort of vibe. I can't hear a word that they're singing, though. I know that goes with the style of music they're doing but I don't think I'm ever going to really love a band where I just can't hear what they're saying. I think the one thing that the Stone Roses and the Mondays have is an incredible groove — a really strong groove which just carries everything else and I don't think this has got enough of that to get away with mumbling vocals. I don't think the songs are strong enough as instrumentals to get away with having such quiet vocals. They could do with a good producer, they need to be mixed properly — it's kind of hard to judge them as it is. Considering the speakers we're listening to this on, it sounds pretty murky and muddy and very poorly mixed.
"They've obviously got a good idea of where they want to go and it sounds like their songs might be OK if you could hear them properly. You can imagine them making quite a relaxing album that could have quite major appeal; people love the Beta Band and Ian Brown and there aren't that many bands like that around. There's no reason why they couldn't do really well if only you could hear them properly." Lauren Bloxham (LB): "I really like it actually. When it started it was quite funky and it's got a summery West-Coast feel to it. I agree with Sam about the vocals being too quiet. I think the sort of people who would like this kind of thing would want to know what they're saying. It'd be nice to hear them really rock out occasionally — like the Beta Band do live. Some serious drumming would go down really well, maybe they do that live, I don't know, but it'd be good if they did it on record. "It's cool, it's non-offensive, it's easy to listen to and I think there would definitely be people who would be interested in this commercially. Despite the fact that the Beta Band or whoever have a similar sound I think that there's room for new bands doing this sort of style." SS: "The occasional lyrics that you can hear are OK — they sound fairly poetic, it wasn't just a love song or whatever — not the sort of thing you want to be hiding." file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Business%20End.htm (1 of 5)9/26/2005 8:18:57 AM
Business End
LB: "You really think 'I want to be able to hear what he's saying' and it's a shame that so much of it is just lost." Howard New (HN): "The tracks sound great, the melodies are good, I think they need to look at their arrangements a bit though — it's a little bit 'verse, chorus, back to the verse and then pedal for eight bars because we don't know what to do'. From a writing point of view they need to dig a bit deeper. Considering the constraints that they've got this sounds good, good enough for a demo anyway, but the vocals are just lost. It sounds like all you're hearing is the return of the reverb and no dry signal. From a purely sonic point of view the vocals just aren't engaging and because of that you go looking for something else to listen to. "I was pleasantly surprised when it started because it's actually quite good. There are elements of the Stone Roses, the Happy Mondays, a bit of Beck — there's definitely a lot of potential, it just hasn't been realised properly yet and that's largely because of how the singer comes across. He's a lot clearer in the third track than in the first two." Neil Tucker (NT): "I think the third song sounds a bit too choppy — everything kind of breaking down and then building back up again. It almost seems that they haven't put that much thought into their arrangement. I definitely want the vocals to be a lot louder and not so distant. I'm used to hearing vocals really up front in the mix — so it's almost like the person's singing to you — and I don't get that at all from this performance. I agree with Howard about the arrangements, it all sounds a bit linear really. It doesn't sound like the singer's that excited about what he's doing, it sounds like he's just reading the lyrics off a sheet of paper and not really feeling it."
Raising Sand Track 1 LB: "I like this, I think it's funny — it's cool. I bet they're good live, you can really 2.9Mb imagine them being a really great live band. I kept expecting them to do that Justin Hawkins falsetto thing though. They've got loads of energy, they're a lot of fun, it could be a good night out if you want to go and hear a live band. I'd definitely go and see them play live. I think there's a lot of stuff to work on here, it's fun and there's definitely potential. They have to keep trying!"
HN: "The thing about the Darkness is that they're a shit-hot band and they're as tight as two coats of paint, as they say. The same thing's true with Led Zep or AC/DC. If you listen to something like 'Black Dog', not only are the rhythm section tight as fuck but the guitar and bass are inseparable. This sounds like it was recorded at a gig — it was all over the place. Because they're not selling themselves on their songs — and there are sections where there's no song for 30 seconds and it's just riffs — I don't think it's up to the competition. If you're going to go out and just rip it up you need to be shit-hot. They need to play more and rehearse more because they're just not tight enough to be doing what they're doing. To be doing that you've got to be great and at the moment they're just good. "When it first started it was exciting and great, even down to the EQing on the guitars. But the melodies were very generic and sometimes the vocalist sounds like someone doing a Lemmy impression at a karaoke night. It's a shame they haven't sent a photograph, I want to see if they wear Lycra." SS: "The thing that all the bands Howard mentioned — Led Zeppelin, AC/DC and even the Darkness — have in common is cracking choruses. Their tracks build up to those choruses where the singer lets go and it's euphoric and everything. With the first track of this I got it into my head that it was going to go into a file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Business%20End.htm (2 of 5)9/26/2005 8:18:57 AM
Business End
really big chorus. It kept building up and up and up and then it just didn't amount to anything. "They sound they're decent musicians and it sounds like they're having a lot of fun with what they're doing. If they're going to take this really seriously they're going to need choruses. The Darkness have got wonderful choruses and wonderful melodies — I'm not a fan of theirs at all, but I recognise that about them. At the moment these guys would make a great pub band but they're not going to sell a million CDs." NT: "It's very exciting at the beginning but after a while it starts to seem like one long jam session. Like Sam said, you're waiting for the pay-off, the killer chorus, but it just doesn't happen. "The recording's very good; the first track starts with real oomph and you're like 'Fucking hell!' It's very well mixed and it's been really well put together, you can hear everything and there's some great separation with the guitars."
Audrey Track 1 LB: "I think these guys are Coldplay wannabes. It's jumping on the whole Snow 2.6Mb Patrol/Keane bandwagon. I think that market's saturated with this sort of thing at the moment and I don't think that there's room for any more. The lyrics on the first track are self-indulgent and boring and I'm just not interested in this sort of thing any more. Maybe I was when Coldplay first started, but not now, I think it's passed its peak really. They're called Audrey, right? I think they should be called Dreary...
"I'm interested in lyrics and I think music like this should have something to say and this doesn't. It really feels like they've just latched onto something because it's quite commercial." NT: "The mix sounds good, it's a lot clearer than the first band, but, like Lauren, I've heard it all before — I find myself switching off. Technically, it's very adept, I mean it sounds like it could have been done in a studio like this [ie. Metropolis] and they say in their letter they say that it was recorded on to a PC in a rehearsal room. That's very impressive. It's nice when you don't have to struggle to hear everything." SS: "I like it. It's very well produced and I think they could be quite a nice band to see live. You can see that they really care about what they do. I don't think they'll ever make it but they could be a good live band. They're good songs, they're well crafted, they obviously think about what they do and they're good musicians — they're just missing that 'special something'. There's just nothing original there, there's nothing that's going to make me remember them tomorrow. It's not just that they sound like Coldplay and Snow Patrol, they also sound like thousands of other bands — it's just fairly bland guitar-rock. As I said, they're good musicians and maybe if they got together three killer tracks then they could be the next Coldplay or whoever, but, from what we've heard they haven't got them at the moment. They're in a very competitive market and they're also fighting against about 30 years of very, very good music." HN: "This is very well put together from a mix and song-arrangement point of view, they've thought very hard about it. It sounds like it's been very well mastered as well — just the sheer volume of it for a start, it's so much louder than the first CD and we haven't touched the volume knob.
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Business%20End.htm (3 of 5)9/26/2005 8:18:57 AM
Business End
"There's nothing original about it, though, and there's nothing that sets them out as being a band that's going to do well in 2004 or 2005. There's just nothing fresh about any of it."
This Month's Panel
Sam Stubbings is the Senior Producer for the DVD division of Metropolis. He began his career five years ago at Abbey Road and has since worked with artists ranging from Paul McCartney to Muse. More recently he has produced both the first DVD single (Bjork's 'All Is Full Of Love') and the first commercial DVD-Audio disc (Holst's The Planets). He also has his own act, Redstar, who are currently recording an album and gigging in London. Howard New has experienced both sides of the music business. Signed to Parlophone from '93 to '97 he has seen what it takes to make, tour and promote a record. He opened for Tina Turner on her European stadium tour, playing Wembley six times. More recently he has been writing and producing for the likes of Gareth Gates, Louise, BBMak, Beverley Knight and Boyzone. He still performs on his own and also lectures and runs courses on songwriting. Neil Tucker's recording career began at a small studio in north London which he helped to wire and set up while attending SAE. After successfully completing his diploma course he began work at Metropolis Studios as an in-house engineer and programmer specialising in Pro Tools and Logic. He has since worked with a range of artists including Black Eyed Peas, Missy Elliott, Lauryn Hill, Elton John, Tom Jones, Mis-Teeq and Liberty X. Lauren Bloxham works in sales promotions for EMI and is closely involved with the EMI field team, indie retailers and regional clubs and venues in promoting acts across the EMI, Virgin and Parlophone labels. Lauren's interest in music began at an early age and she later went on to study Music and Music Business at university. After graduating Lauren worked for MTV Networks Europe in Talent & Music before going on to EMI. Many thanks to Sam Stubbings and Metropolis Studios (www.metropolis-group.co.uk) for organising and hosting the session. Published in SOS November 2004
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Business%20End.htm (4 of 5)9/26/2005 8:18:57 AM
Business End
Sound On Sound, Media House, Trafalgar Way, Bar Hill, Cambridge CB3 8SQ, UK. Email:
[email protected] | Telephone: +44 (0)1954 789888 | Fax: +44 (0)1954 789895
All contents copyright © SOS Publications Group and/or its licensors, 1985-2005. All rights reserved. The contents of this article are subject to worldwide copyright protection and reproduction in whole or part, whether mechanical or electronic, is expressly forbidden without the prior written consent of the Publishers. Great care has been taken to ensure accuracy in the preparation of this article but neither Sound On Sound Limited nor the publishers can be held responsible for its contents. The views expressed are those of the contributors and not necessarily those of the publishers. Web site designed & maintained by PB Associates | SOS | Relative Media
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Business%20End.htm (5 of 5)9/26/2005 8:18:57 AM
Crosstalk: Your Communications
In this article:
And On Lead Wardrobe... Upwardly Mobile Making Us SMiLE
Crosstalk: Your Communications Readers Writes Published in SOS November 2004 Print article : Close window
People
And On Lead Wardrobe... I found David Greeves' reply to the question, 'What can I use to trigger drums?' [Q&A, SOS September 2004], really interesting. I also find that the rhythms I play with my hands on the side of the lift in our flats, or on the wardrobe more exciting than the ones I program in drum machines. There is another way of transforming these rhythms into drum samples without MIDI equipment which wasn't mentioned, although it may be slightly more time-consuming. Play the rhythm on your knees, desk or even sing, human beat-box style, and record it with a microphone — the standard of the recording is not that important. Then put the recording into an audio editor and place markers at the beginning of the attacks. I do this manually in Prosoniq's Sonicworx, but I understand it can be done automatically in Propellerhead Recycle or Bitshift Phatmatik Pro. Drum samples can then be pasted in at the markers, and a blank audio file, with just the markers, can be saved as a template. If the rhythms are well recorded, these could even be processed and used as a percussion loop. This method makes it easy to convert speech rhythms into musical loops, as well as taking the groove or feel from other recordings. In fact, any recording can become a potential rhythm template, even random sounds such as throwing a can down the stairs. Ian Stewart News Editor David Greeves replies: Your solution to the problem of how to turn spontaneous, ad hoc drumming into MIDI data is an interesting and direct one,
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Crosstalk%20%20Your%20Communications.htm (1 of 4)9/26/2005 8:19:00 AM
Crosstalk: Your Communications
and certainly sounds like it could throw up some unusual rhythms. While the reader who posed the question that appeared in the September issue (www. soundonsound.com/sos/sep04/articles/qa0904-9.htm) was looking for a MIDI controller that would allow him the same freedom as he had when bashing out rhythms on his knees, you've chosen to input audio rather than MIDI data and then 'convert' it by hand. As you say, both Recycle and Phatmatik Pro, and, indeed, Zero-X's Beat Quantizer, reviewed on page 184, can be used to detect hit points automatically, and many sequencer packages have similar tools built in — Pro Tools' Beat Detective, for example. At best, however, these utilities will only leave you with a series of hit points. You'll still have to set the velocity and duration (if required) and the note or sample to be triggered by each hit manually. One bit of software that will track the level, as well as the timing, of incoming audio is WaveMachine Labs' Drumagog (pictured), a Direct X plug-in designed for replacing recorded drum parts with samples, reviewed back in SOS February 2003 (see www.soundonsound.com/sos/feb03/articles/wavemachinedrumagog. asp). A pre-trigger band-pass filter means that different frequencies in the audio signal can be used to trigger different sounds, and the Pro version has a MIDI output. However, if you're not a PC user, this avenue is closed to you. But your way of doing things, though time-consuming, gives you plenty of flexibility and, ultimately, gets the job done!
Upwardly Mobile I'm considering buying a Line 6 Pod XT. I read the review you wrote a while back and found it informative and helpful — some of the descriptions of how it worked were more enlightening than the Line 6 manual I downloaded! I was wondering if you would consider writing a review on the firmware updates that Line 6 are offering. Is the Pod XT now a significantly different product from the one you reviewed? It would seem that firmware updates are something we're going to see more of in the future. Matt Saxey News Editor David Greeves replies: As you note, software and firmware updates are becoming more and more common as manufacturers seek to add extra value to their products, which is great news for us consumers. Indeed, it's almost reached a point where any manufacturer who doesn't promise free updates and downloadable sounds and templates is putting themselves at a disadvantage! As chance would have it, the new features in the Pod XT's version 2.0 software are discussed in this month's News section, and your letter also file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Crosstalk%20%20Your%20Communications.htm (2 of 4)9/26/2005 8:19:00 AM
Crosstalk: Your Communications
coincides with the review of a major software update to the Voyager synth (see page 90). We try and review as much new gear each month as we possibly can, but even in a mag the size of SOS, it's impossible to fit a review of every upgrade in, so we tend to wait, as with the Voyager, until the upgrades have made a huge difference to the product before we re-review something. In this case, the Pod XT's version 2.0 software tweaks the unit's existing amp and effects models, adds some new ones and increases the available preset memory. However, the device's core features and functionality are essentially the same as the model we originally reviewed (see www.soundonsound.com/sos/ jan03/articles/line6podxt.asp).
Making Us SMiLE Over the years I have been reading Sound On Sound, it seems to get better as the equipment reviewed gets better. The reason I'm writing is to say how amazed I was with the Brian Wilson SMiLE article [SOS October 2004]. This is a once-in-a-lifetime album that might never have became a reality, and there to tell the world how it was done was Sound On Sound. Brilliant! Peter Morrisin Managing Editor Matt Bell replies: Thanks for your kind comments about the feature, Peter, and thanks also to all the other SOS readers who commented on it. SMiLE is certainly unlike any other record I can think of; as well as being a milestone musical and production achievement, no other album in the history of popular music, as far as I know, has ever been completed by the original composers after an interruption of nearly 40 years. During that time, the reputation surrounding the music ensured that much of what was recorded was extensively bootlegged, and because there wasn't a completed version authorised by Brian Wilson until this year, many fans have spent years trying to 'solve the puzzle', and put the bootlegged pieces together in an order that made musical sense — the Internet is littered with home-made SMiLE mixes. The more you investigate the album, the more interesting layers like this you find regarding production techniques, compositional, lyrical and thematic innovation, and simply fascinating music. If you'd like to know more, check out www.thesmileshop.net.
Published in SOS November 2004
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Crosstalk%20%20Your%20Communications.htm (3 of 4)9/26/2005 8:19:00 AM
Crosstalk: Your Communications
Sound On Sound, Media House, Trafalgar Way, Bar Hill, Cambridge CB3 8SQ, UK. Email:
[email protected] | Telephone: +44 (0)1954 789888 | Fax: +44 (0)1954 789895
All contents copyright © SOS Publications Group and/or its licensors, 1985-2005. All rights reserved. The contents of this article are subject to worldwide copyright protection and reproduction in whole or part, whether mechanical or electronic, is expressly forbidden without the prior written consent of the Publishers. Great care has been taken to ensure accuracy in the preparation of this article but neither Sound On Sound Limited nor the publishers can be held responsible for its contents. The views expressed are those of the contributors and not necessarily those of the publishers. Web site designed & maintained by PB Associates | SOS | Relative Media
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Crosstalk%20%20Your%20Communications.htm (4 of 4)9/26/2005 8:19:00 AM
Keeping Hardware Alive
Keeping Hardware Alive Leader Published in SOS November 2004 Print article : Close window
People : Industry/Music Biz
Last month I wrote about the possibility of synth modules being built to properly integrate with a computer-based workstation, and this month I'd like to explore a similar avenue with regard to external effects processors. Despite all the wonderful plug-ins to which we have access, hardware still wins out in many areas, most noticeably dynamics control, synthetic reverb and mastering devices. If you have spare analogue or digital I/O on your system, then you can patch in an external device or two fairly easily as long as you pay attention to any latency or delay-related issues, and in the case of a reverb box, what's a millisecond or two of extra delay when added to 70ms of pre-delay anyway? However, this solution only works for small numbers of units, and there's still no on-screen control panel to edit the device in question. What I'm proposing isn't that radical, as TC Electronic's Powercore system has long since established that plugins running on external hardware can be controlled and deployed in exactly the same way as native plug-ins. And it doesn't take too great a stretch of the imagination to figure out that what they've done for Powercore, they could also do for their own hardware digital processors in the future if they'd a mind to. However, this could only be a solution for those products designed to be part of such a system, and the number of Firewire ports on a typical computer is fairly limited. Perhaps a better way would be for interested manufacturers to get together and agree upon or licence a suitable technology to develop a data transfer/control system and connection hub into which a realistic number of hardware devices can be plugged simultaneously. It wouldn't matter who the manufacturer of the hardware was as long as the standard audio/Firewire port had been included in their design. Digital equipment designed to integrate fully with the system would of course have plug-in-style displays and control panels just like 'real' plug-ins. Each new device would ship with a plug-in-like software front end that the user could interact with when accessing the device as a plug-in, enabling settings to be saved in the sequencer song. Older analogue equipment could still be connected by means of additional analogue I/O port modules (analogue-to-Firewire digital?) and though its controls obviously couldn't be directly addressed via software, it should be possible to at least provide some sort of template display that appears when its particular audio port is called up as a plug-in and where the user can set virtual knobs to the same position as the actual hardware to act as a reminder for the settings. Of course computer data protocols change every few years, so what happens when Firewire is replaced by something else? The reality is that Firewire will always be fast enough to send and receive a couple of channels of audio, no matter what silly bit rates and sample resolutions are inflicted upon us in years to come. file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Keeping%20Hardware%20Alive.htm (1 of 2)9/26/2005 8:19:05 AM
Keeping Hardware Alive
It can even cope with surround and leave capacity to spare. All the real strain would be on the hub that deals with the computer, and if a better, faster interface came along, then you would simply develop a new hub (or interface port for the old one) that uses the new protocol for talking to the computer, yet still talks to your hardware via Firewire. If this seems to demand a lot of co-operation, don't forget that MIDI did too, and at the time MIDI was introduced, manufacturers of hardware weren't being forced to the brink of extinction by software as they are now. If the manufacturers of studio hardware outboard equipment still want to be building it in significant numbers in five years' time, then a system similar to the one proposed is the only thing I can see that will keep them in the game. Paul White Editor In Chief Published in SOS November 2004 Sound On Sound, Media House, Trafalgar Way, Bar Hill, Cambridge CB3 8SQ, UK. Email:
[email protected] | Telephone: +44 (0)1954 789888 | Fax: +44 (0)1954 789895
All contents copyright © SOS Publications Group and/or its licensors, 1985-2005. All rights reserved. The contents of this article are subject to worldwide copyright protection and reproduction in whole or part, whether mechanical or electronic, is expressly forbidden without the prior written consent of the Publishers. Great care has been taken to ensure accuracy in the preparation of this article but neither Sound On Sound Limited nor the publishers can be held responsible for its contents. The views expressed are those of the contributors and not necessarily those of the publishers. Web site designed & maintained by PB Associates | SOS | Relative Media
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Keeping%20Hardware%20Alive.htm (2 of 2)9/26/2005 8:19:05 AM
Mark Nevers
In this article:
The Studio Floor Another Man's Spillage The Master Keyboard Awesome Cats The Joy Of Analogue A Mixing Challenge Girl Power
Mark Nevers Producing Lambchop Published in SOS November 2004 Print article : Close window
People : Artists/Engineers/Producers/Programmers
Fed up with being treated badly by spoilt divas, engineer Mark Nevers abandoned the country music establishment to start his own studio, and has made a name for himself on the 'other side' of Nashville. Tom Doyle
Mark Nevers is fast becoming the producer of choice for key alt-country artists the world over, including Lambchop, Bonnie 'Prince' Billy, Calexico and the Silver Jews, but the Nashville-based studio owner and engineer admits that he often wonders how he managed to find himself in his current position. "I really don't know," he shrugs. "I mean, I love the Ramones! So I don't know how I got Photo: Steve Gullick into the hushed-down world. But actually, y'know, I find it's harder to Mark Nevers, playing the ukelele. record than the loud stuff. The quiet stuff drives you nuts because all it takes is the singer having a dry throat and everything's ruined." His punk roots notwithstanding, Nevers' studio grounding was very much in the world of traditional Nashville country music. The son of a Vietnam fighter pilot, he first became interested in tape machines as a kid, recording messages to send out to his father ("I was infatuated by my voice sounding different when I heard it back"). In his early '20s, having studied engineering in Florida, he graduated with SSL experience — invaluable in the mid-'80s — and landed a job at Castle Recording in Nashville, chiefly thanks to the ineptitude of the previous engineer, who'd managed to snap a master in the middle of a session.
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Mark%20Nevers.htm (1 of 9)9/26/2005 8:19:09 AM
Mark Nevers
"This was back in the day when you couldn't really fix stuff when you'd ruined it," he recalls. "It was on the first digital 3M machine and it looked like film the way it went around the heads. And he snapped it in half somehow right in the middle of the bridge and they couldn't fix it. So they were real suspicious of me when I came in there — they wouldn't let me touch nothing." Over the next 10 years, Nevers put in countless hours recording what he describes as "the first renaissance of reborn traditionalists" like Randy Travis and Hank Williams Jr, as well as country legends like Johnny Cash and George Jones. Although this was obviously a fascinating and important period in his life, the producer looks back on those days with mixed feelings, particularly due to the incredibly off-hand, old-fashioned treatment of engineers by some artists. "A lot of people are dickheads and they don't remember your name. You can have years of working with somebody and they still don't remember your name. It's like 'I've been up all night in the studio making you rich, please remember my name.'" Perhaps inevitably, given his plain-speaking attitude, something was bound to give eventually, and in 1995, Nevers walked out of a session and never went back. "This chick was singing and screaming at me and it was terrible," he remembers, with a grimace. "It was like 'This is not what I went to Nashville to do.' And I just thought 'I can't do this any more.' It had got to the point where I couldn't face it for another second."
The Studio Floor For the next few years, Nevers returned to his second profession as a chef, though he continued to build his home studio, the Beech House, seeing it through from its modest beginnings with a Portastudio through his purchase of a Tascam T38 half-inch eight-track machine and onto its current status as a facility offering the best of both the analogue and digital domains, with its combination of MCI JH16 two-inch 16-track and Pro Tools. It was through his development of the Beech House that Nevers first met Lambchop frontman Kurt Wagner, at the time working as a hardwood flooring specialist. The singer offered to lay a floor for the producer in return for some studio time. But while the recordings took place, funnily enough, the work on the floor never happened. "He scammed me!" jokes Nevers. "But I'm gonna put in a new floor soon and he's gonna at least polish it. I'm gonna bring him back to his roots..." Lambchop's latest and most ambitious file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Mark%20Nevers.htm (2 of 9)9/26/2005 8:19:09 AM
Deeply sceptical about the value of professional studio designers, Mark Nevers chose to build a studio in his own house.
Mark Nevers
effort, the two-albums-released-as-one package of Aw C'Mon/No You C'Mon, was the first to be recorded entirely at the Beech House using Nevers' most recent purchase, a Sphere Eclipse 28-channel desk originally built for Doppler Studios in Atlanta, Georgia in 1978. "They only made about 50 of them," he explains. "Its design was kinda ripped off by API for their parametric EQs and stuff. It's a very quiet desk and it has these giant transformers on the outputs. There was a scam on transformers on tape machines and stuff when they ruled the world, people said they were noisy. So they brought the chip in and it was like 'Hey, we got rid of the noise.' But, no, what they did was they got rid of the 100dollar transformer and replaced it with a 10-cent chip which is quieter but sounds like shit. "Anyway, my partner John Kelton picked it up from Doppler and it wasn't working that well, so I brought it over to the house and spent a couple of days with some techs and got it working. All it was was capacitors. Everybody always says 'The old shit's all fucked up,' but it's usually things like the knobs on APIs or Neves click and they break. The shit that doesn't click doesn't have a problem and the Sphere doesn't have a click. "Because it was from Atlanta in the late '70s, I'm sure a lot of disco and R&B was recorded with it. But then I read this thing about the Sphere that said that a lot of heavy metal like Krokus and Lynyrd Skynyrd was recorded using it. It's weird 'cause sometimes if they play a song on the radio, I can hear its sound. It's got the top, it's got the bottom — a Neve to me is mushy on the bottom and an API doesn't have any bottom, but a Sphere is like both of them combined, with a hard bottom and a good top." Nevers explains that as a studio, the Beech House has completely taken over his home, to the point where he lives "upstairs or on the couch". Throughout the development of the facility, though, he's remained defiantly resistant to any kind of professional The current line-up of Lambchop, lined up. acoustic tweaking. "I didn't have to have anything done to it because it's a bungalow — which in America means it's got wooden floors and a basement under it and plaster walls — and so it just sounds great naturally. I always had problems with studio designers. There's this guy called Tom Hidley and he was the dude that would never let a window be put in a studio. So us engineers always hated him 'cause we were the ones that had to sit there in that studio without a window. It's not natural not to see time progress with sunlight. It's like being in a submarine. So I don't give a shit about sound reflection at all, just give me a window so that I know whether it's day or night. It's like, get NS10s, put a window in and screw all that shit." In terms of layout, the studio is situated on the ground floor of the property and centred around what Nevers calls the 'den room' where the main recording takes place, with five ante-rooms which are used as iso booths for amp placement.
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Mark%20Nevers.htm (3 of 9)9/26/2005 8:19:09 AM
Mark Nevers
"I've got the console facing the wrong way — it doesn't face the band, so I have to turn around, but that's fine. I try to keep everybody that's playing at the same time in the same room so they can get the feel. In Nashville they have this thing where everybody gets separated — drummer's in one room, piano player in the other room, and it's just discombobulating. I like to be able to hear the guitar player strumming on the drum overheads. "The only thing you really have to separate is the piano because that'll cause you hell. If it's being played delicately, if it's close to the other sounds, it'll pick it up and it'll make everything real distant and muddy. So you've got to get the piano the hell out of there. The same with the acoustic guitar, that's gotta be separated. But as far as all the rocking dudes go, they should be right in there and their amps somewhere else. I don't mind bleed at all, as long as it's not too far away to the point where you can no longer make it tight." Perhaps unsurprisingly, given the largely hushed nature of Lambchop's music in particular, the monitoring levels at the Beech House are always on the quiet side. "If you listen too loud, it wrecks your ears and it also fools you about pitch," Nevers points out. "If it's loud, you're forgiving about stuff being out of pitch, especially vocals. If you listen lower, you're like 'Oh that's crap, we've gotta fix that.'"
Another Man's Spillage Nevers' first project with Lambchop was engineering 1998's What Another Man Spills, though it was only with their 2000 breakthrough album Nixon that he first picked up a production credit. He remembers that even in the preliminary stages, he and Wagner were determined to make that particular record very special. "Before we did Nixon, me and Kurt decided that we were gonna spend the time to make a record that competed with people that had a lot of money. We wanted the record to sound as good as the records that cost hundreds of thousands of dollars. Because of the situation I was in with John Kelton who had this great studio, Wedgetone, with an SSL and all the gear, we could do that. If we were paying real rates, we couldn't have. We knew we had to fix certain things with the band, but the sonic thing was the main driving force. To take it out of the crappy console world." Having succeeded in elevating Lambchop out of the world of makeshift indie recording, Nevers and Wagner repeated the trick with 2002's stripped-down set Is A Woman. Approaching Aw C'Mon/No You C'Mon proved more of a headache, however, mostly due to the sheer volume of material (Wagner had set himself the task of writing a song a day in the period before recording) and the fact that the Lambchop frontman was still using working titles for the songs that were often just the date when they'd been written. "That was hell, 'cause he had 35 songs and they were all called 'January 14th' or file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Mark%20Nevers.htm (4 of 9)9/26/2005 8:19:09 AM
Mark Nevers
'January 15th'. So we're trying to work on them and there's nothing to grab onto. The band was just as confused as hell. But Kurt always does that. He's always like 'We're gonna do a new record,' and it's three records." Sessions began in April 2003 and normally the band — whose membership can at various points swell from a trio to a 14-piece — would The Beech House studio is based around a turn up on day one. Ask Nevers '70s Sphere desk. whether the band rehearse the songs beforehand and his response is typically blunt. "I wish they would! For the last record, Kurt actually did demos on his little Pro Tools unit and he gave them to the band members. The demos are just guitar and vocal and a bad drum machine which drove the drummer crazy because he had to mimic it and he couldn't." In terms of the basic live recording process, the producer says he likes to nail as much as possible live. "Basically, the bass, the drums, the guitars and with Kurt, his vocal, he always does it live. That's why it kind of feels like it's him playing with a band behind him, instead of him singing on top of something. He's always in the hallway looking at the band through the window, playing his Gibson. That causes problems too because I have to put a spy mic in it, just in case he wants to redo a word or something, so you don't miss the strumming. So I put a spy mic inside the guitar itself to get the 'click'. "When we're tracking, there'll be five or six of the band there. On Is A Woman the whole band was there and that was a nightmare because we had to go back and fix everything. This time we controlled it more. With Is A Woman, I guess because I didn't use enough compression, there's actually a whole lot of shit going on. "On this one, the recordings actually went too quickly — we booked the band for a month and we did it in, like, two weeks. So we've still got to pay them for two weeks! Thirty-five songs in two weeks. The working hours are very short because everybody has their families and stuff, so it'd be only from like 11 to five in the afternoon. That was as far as the tracking went."
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Mark%20Nevers.htm (5 of 9)9/26/2005 8:19:09 AM
Mark Nevers
The Master Keyboard Aside from Kurt Wagner's vocal, the primary feature of Lambchop's sound on recent albums is Tony Crow's ornate piano playing, which is recorded using a Yamaha C3 conservatory piano that, unusually, has been wired for MIDI. "John Kelton gave it to me because it was in the other studio and it wasn't being used," says Mark Nevers. "I was like 'What if we restrung it and repegged it?' And he's like 'Well if you do that, cool, but I'm gonna put MIDI in it.' I don't know how they do it, but they do! So now I can run it into the computer and Tony can be playing his beautiful Liberace shit and then I can use Reason and put space sounds under it following the notes. So he doesn't have to track the parts."
Awesome Cats Kurt Wagner's distinctive baritone vocal is usually recorded using what Nevers calls the 'dark' Neumann U87. "People always say 'How do you get that vocal sound?' It's funny because I learned this trick from my country music days, which is just using the Dbx 160, the cheapest compressor in the world. But it has the Over Easy function on it where you can squash the shit out of it, but you don't hear it. So with Kurt, I've got it going through the Sphere and we're adding highend and the 160 is squashing it, but you can't hear it." If the basic track-laying was relatively painless, then it was followed by what Nevers describes as "aeons of hell overdubbing". This included all of the elaborate string parts that adorn the songs, which were arranged by Lloyd Barry ("a great old soul guy") and played by the Nashville String Machine. Nevers has nothing but utter respect for these musicians, particularly since the band were still tweaking the arrangements even as the parts were actually going down.
The Yamaha C3 piano in the Beech House has been modified to output MIDI.
"These Nashville cats are so awesome," he enthuses, "and they don't have a problem, they can just play it. We used a 10-piece — six violins, two violas, two cellos — and then we doubled it. I tend to use Neumanns, it's back to 87s and then 47s for the cellos. I record strings two different ways. The dude that did all the great Motown shit, he just put two mics up, but he had a great room. If you don't have a great room, you have to close-mic it, then create it. What I do is I close-mic them and then I put them far away, so when I do the different passes, I can do far away or close."
file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Mark%20Nevers.htm (6 of 9)9/26/2005 8:19:09 AM
Mark Nevers
The Joy Of Analogue One recurrent feature of Nevers' recordings is their warm, spacious sound, a factor he puts down to the combination of the Beech House's Sphere desk and JH16 reel-to-reel multitrack. He recalls the moment he finally matched the two together as being a defining moment in the history of the studio. "I already had the tape machine but when I put it together with the desk, it was like they'd been lost forever. It was like 'Oh my God, this is the way they're supposed to be.' You can just put a 57 in front of anything, and the shittiest mic through that preamp to that tape machine sounds a lot better than a 47 through Pro Tools. Because back then they cared about sound instead of convenience." As you may gather, Nevers is a firm analogue fan, even if he uses Pro Tools for editing and mixing. "Pro Tools is such a great editing machine, but when digital first came out, its big thing was that there was no tape hiss. But if that was the reason to get rid of analogue, then analogue — if you do it right, like, on 16-track with proper tape — is as quiet as digital, so that excuse is no longer there. And you have the 3D and you'll never have 3D with digital. "I feel kinda like a fish out of water, 'cause the way I make records is very hard. It's carrying tape around and lining up machines and using old shit. I still use Pro Tools, but it's after the fact. They've got it to the point where it's not as piercing, but it's never gonna have the imagery, it's never gonna have the depth. You put on a Todd Rundgren record or an Elton John record from the '70s and you can hear right into it. Then you listen to the modern shit and it's just right in your face, there's nothing behind it." On the digital side, Nevers runs Pro Tools on an Apple G4 using OS 9.2, though he prefers to use the Apogee converters from his two Mitsubishi 850 32-track digital machines ("They're crunchy, more rock & roll, they actually have a life to them"). Everything, eventually, ends up on the Pro Tools rig. "At one time I was locking two 16-tracks up," he explains, "but it's such a pain and it's gonna end up on a CD anyway. So what I started doing is I record everything originally to 16-track. I take that and I dump it into Pro Tools and then I dump the stuff I need back onto 16-track for slaves and then overdub on that." In terms of mics, Nevers says that everything is very much geared around what sounds good with the Sphere. "Because of the impedance, there's different mics that sound like crap on modern-day consoles, but on the Sphere they sound amazing. Like the dark 87 from the mid-'80s, it's just amazing. The trick that my partner John Kelton taught me about the Sphere is that you turn up the 12kHz all the way, so it's too bright, but you're recording analogue, so later on when you're mixing, you turn it back the other way and it gets rid of the hiss. "I use a lot of 87s and then on guitars I still use 57s 'cause they're great and they've got the punch. I'm very primitive on that, I don't have a lot of fancy mics and the newest and the best. Basically it's the tape machine and the preamps. Last thing I'd want to do is spend $10,000 on a new Neumann. I mean, John got the Sphere for $3000 and I spent another couple of thousand dollars getting it working, so the thought of buying one microphone or one GML preamp for the cost of that whole console is just mind-boggling."
A Mixing Challenge file:///H|/SOS%2004-11/Mark%20Nevers.htm (7 of 9)9/26/2005 8:19:09 AM
Mark Nevers
Mixing for Aw C'Mon/No You C'Mon was done in the Beech House's sister studio, John Kelton's SSL room Wedgetone, and lasted a month, which isn't bad going since the finished product features 24 songs. Nevers says his biggest problem was balancing the orchestral arrangements with Wagner's vocals. "That's when it became hard because he was singing real quiet and also there's this huge orchestra. It's like 'How do you get him above the orchestra?' But like John Kelton says, 'If he's a star, turn his vocal up, don't worry about it.' It does come do