Topics in Applied Physics Volume 89
AvailableOnline Topics in Applied Physics is part of the SpringerLink service. For all customers with standing orders for Topics in Applied Physics we offer the full text in electronic form via SpringerLink free of charge. Please contact your librarian who can receive a password for free access to the full articles by registration at:
http://www.springerlink.com/orders/index.htm If you do not have a standing order you can nevertheless browse through the table of contents of the volumes and the abstracts of each article at:
http:/Iwww.springerlink.com/series/tap/ There you will also find more information about the series.
Springer
Berlin Heidelberg New York Hong Kong London Milan Paris Tokyo
Physics and Astronomy~
ONLINELIBRARY
http://www.springer.de/phys/
Topics in Applied Physics Topics in Applied Physics is a well-established series of review books, each of which presents a comprehensive survey of a selected topic within the broad area of applied physics. Edited and written by leading research scientists in the field concerned, each volume contains review contributions covering the various aspects of the topic. Together these provide an overview of the state of the art in the respective field, extending from an introduction to the subject right up to the frontiers of contemporary research. Topics in Applied Physics is addressed to all scientists at universities and in industry who wish to obtain an overview and to keep abreast of advances in applied physics. The series also provides easy but comprehensive access to the fields for newcomers starting research. Contributions are specially commissioned. The Managing Editors are open to any suggestions for topics coming from the community of applied physicists no matter what the field and encourage prospective editors to approach them with ideas. See also: http://www.springerlink.com/physlbooks/tapl Managing Editors Dr. C l a u s E. A s c h e r o n
Dr. H a n s J. K o e l s c h
Springer-Verlag Heidelberg Topics in Applied Physics Tiergartenstr. 17 69121 Heidelberg Germany Emaih
[email protected]
Springer-Verlag New York, Inc. Topics in Applied Physics 175 Fifth Avenue New York, NY 1001o-7858 USA Email:
[email protected]
A s s i s t a n t Editor Dr. W e r n e r S k o l a u t Springer-Verlag Heidelberg Topics in Applied Physics Tiergartenstr. 17 69121 Heidelberg Germany Email:
[email protected]
Irina T.Sorokina KonstantinL.Vodopyanov (Eds.)
Solid-State Mid-Infrared Laser Sources With 263 Figures and 36 Tables
~
Springer
Dr. Irina T. Sorokina
Photonics Institute Technical University of Vienna
Dr. Konstantin L. Vodopyanov Ginzton Laboratory Stanford University
lO4O Vienna Austria
vodopyan@stanford, edu
Gusshausstr. z71387
Stanford, CA 943o5-4o88
USA
sorokina~tuwien, ac. at
Library of Congress Cataloging in Publication Data Solid-state mid-infrared laser sources/Irina T. Sorokina, Konstantin L. Vodopyanov (eds.). p. cm. - (Topics in applied physics, ISSN o3o3-4z16; v. 89) Includes bilbiographical references and index. ISBN 3-54o-o0621-4 (alk. paper) a. Solid-state lasers, z. Laser materials. I. Sorokina, Irina T., 1963- II. Vodopyanov, Konstantin L., 1953IIl. Series
Physics and Astronomy Classification Scheme (PACS): 4z.72.Ai, 42.55.-f, 42.62.-b, 42.65.Ky, 42.65.Yj ISSN print edition: o3o3-4216 ISSN electronic edition: 1437-o859 ISBN 3-54o-oo621-4 Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg New York This work is subject to copyright. All rights are reserved, whether the whole or part of the material is concerned, specifically the rights of translation, reprinting, reuse of illustrations, recitation, broadcasting, reproduction on microfilm or in any other way, and storage in data banks. Duplication of this publication or parts thereof is permitted only under the provisions of the German Copyright Law of September 9,1965, in its current version, and permission for use must always be obtained from Springer-Verlag. Violations are liable for prosecution under the German Copyright Law. Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg New York a member of BertelsmannSpringer Science+Business Media GmbH htt p://www.springer.de ' Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2oo3 Printed in Germany The use of general descriptive names, registered names, trademarks, etc. in this publication does not imply, even in the absence of a specific statement, that such names are exempt from the relevant protective laws and regulations and therefore free for general use. Typesetting: DA-TEX - Gerd Blumenstein www.da-tex.de Cover design: design 6" production GmbH, Heidelberg Printed on acid-free paper
56/3141/mf
5 4 3 21 o
Preface
According to the Encyclopaedia Britannica, the "middle infrared" region covers the portion of the electromagnetic spectrum between 400 and 4000 wave numbers, which corresponds to the wavelength range 2.5-25 gin. This range is of particular interest for many applications, especially for spectroscopy, since the electromagnetic frequencies involved coincide with frequencies of the internal vibrational motion of most molecules (the "molecular fingerprint" region). In our book, we define the "mid-infrared" more loosely to cover a slightly broader range starting from ~ 2 gm wavelength. On the longer wavelength end, we even included two chapters on terahertz wave generation, reflecting the fact that as terahertz waves are pushed further to higher frequencies, they converge with the long-wavelength infrared domain (for example, a frequency of 10 THz corresponds to a wavelength of 30 ~tm). The development of solid-state laser sources in the mid-infrared opens unprecedented possibilities in spectroscopy~ as compared to traditionally used Fourier-transform spectrometers. The obvious advantages of lasers are directionality, coherence, narrow linewidth or small pulse duration, and high spectral brightness. Compact and efficient nfid-infrared laser sources can serve advantageously for remote light detection and ranging (LIDAR) (down to parts-per-billion in volume) of many trace gases and vapors that are important in pollution detection, and atmospheric chemistry. Other opportunities for fixed-wavelength and tunable mid-infrared laser sources include medical applications (e.g. microsurgery, dentistry, keratectomy or non-invasive diagnostics by means of breath analysis), ultrasensitive detection of drugs and explosives (down to one part per trillion) using photoacoustie or cavity ringdown spectroscopy, and free-space communications. Near-infrared laser sources (0.8 1.6 p.m) achieved significant market penetration during the past decade, but the technology for mid-infrared lasers, especially those which operate at room temperature, needed considerable improvement, despite the fact that mid-infrared lasers have existed since the beginning of the laser era. In recent years, however, scientific research in the field of generation of coherent radiation in the mid-infrared experienced a revolution. On the one hand, it was largely connected with the rapid progress in semiconductor technology, and on the other, with exploiting new physical ideas and new material development. The most spectacular example is
VI
Preface
the q u a n t u m cascade laser, pioneered by Lucent Technologies in 1994. Another example is optical parametric oscillators that can operate with > 10 W average power or have up to 95 % quantum conversion efficiency. Periodically poled ferroelectric materials revolutionized nonlinear optics and made it possible to create new, highly efficient tunable devices. We have also seen a gigantic leap forward in fiber laser technology with infrared fiber lasers delivering multi-watt output power. Quite different scientific domains (semiconductor physics, solid state physics, material science, nonlinear optics, laser physics, q u a n t u m optics) are converging to investigate new nfid-infrared sources. This book assembles the results from different scientific communities focused on achieving the goal of creating an efficient and inexpensive solid-state mid-infrared laser source. The first two chapters concentrate on semiconductor lasers: Andrd doullid, Philippe Christol, Alexei Baranov and Aurore Vicet describe the latest advances in the 2 5 gm heterojunction laser diodes based on I I I - V as well as IV VI semiconductor structures. Daniel Hofstetter and Jdrdrne Faist review results on distributed feedback q u a n t u m cascade lasers in the wavelength range around 5 p.m and around 10 ~ n and discuss their applications in spectroscopy and free space communications. The chapter by Cornelia Fischer and Markus Sigrist addresses the nonlinear optical technique known as difference frequency generation and gives some examples of spectroscopic applications. The next two chapters describe in detail the underlying principles and advances in nfid-infrared optical parametric oscillators operating in the pulsed mode (chapter by Konstantin Vodopyanov) and in the continuous-wave and synchronously pumped modes (chapter by
Majid Ebrahimzadeh ).
The current state-of-the-art in mid-infrared fiber lasers is reviewed by
Markus Pollnau and Stuart Jackson. The authors describe lasers at transi-
tions ranging from 1.9 to 4 gm in the rare-earth ions T m 3+, Ho 3+, and Er 3+, their population mechanisms, and their power-scaling methods. The chapter by Irina Sorokina surveys ion-doped crystalline lasers operating in the mid-infrared between 2 and 5 microns. Her review includes rare-earth- and transition-metal-based laser crystals, as well as the color-center lasers, with special emphasis on compact r o o m - t e m p e r a t u r e tunable sources based on vibronic lasers. The chapter by Tasoltan Basiev, Vyacheslav Osiko, Alexander Prokhorov and Evgeny Dianov presents the latest achievements in the field of R a m a n lasers based on a variety of crystals and optical fibers. The next two chapters describe terahertz (THz) coherent sources: Kodo Kawase, Jun-ichi Shikata and Hiromasa Ito review methods of generating widely tunable THz waves using nonlinear optical techniques: parametric generation and difference frequency generation. In the chapter by Hiroshi Takahashi, Hidetoshi Murakami, Hideyuki Ohtake, and Nobuhiko Sarukura, the authors describe generation of THz radiation using ultrafast lasers and semiconductor-based materials. The techniques include semiconductor opti-
Preface
VII
cal switches, optical rectification and difference frequency generation, as well as generation of THz waves based on intersubband transitions in semiconductor quantum wells. The last two chapters discuss applications of mi.d-infrared lasers: Frank Tittel, Dirk Richter and Alan Fried present a large number of spectroscopic laser techniques for sensitive, selective, and quantitative trace gas detection with tunable narrow-linewidth mid-infrared coherent sources. The chapter by Benedikt Jean and Thomas Bende reviews applications of mid-infrared lasers in medicine. These applications exploit strong laser light absorption in tissue due to the presence of natural chromophores and include: gynaecology, otorhinolaryngology, neurosurgery, dermatology, urology, dentistry, ophthalmology, cardio vascular surgery and angioplasty. We believe theft this book will be useful for academics, researchers and engineers in various disciplines who require a broad introduction to the subject and would like to learn more about the state-of-the-art and upcoming trends in mid-infrared coherent source development. Finally, we would like to thank all contributors who have found the time, energy and enthusiasm to write these chapters.
Palo Alto Vienna May 2003
Konstantin Vodopyanov Irina Sorokina
Contents
Mid-Infrared 2 - 5 pxm H e t e r o j u n c t i o n Laser D i o d e s A n d % JoulliS, P h i l i p p e Christol, Alexei N. B a r a n o v a n d A u r o r e Vicet . . . 1 1. 2. 3.
Introduction ........................................................ Historical . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . State of the A r t . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.1. T y p i c a l H e t e r o j u n e t i o n Laser S t r u c t u r e . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.2. M a x i m u m T e m p e r a t u r e of O p e r a t i o n . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.3. M a x i m u m O p e r a t i n g T e m p e r a t u r e in the 2-5 ~tm W a v e l e n g t h D o m a i n . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4. A n t i m o n i d e Q u a n t u m Well Laser Diodes for the 2 - 3 p.m Spectral R a n g e . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.1. S t r a i n e d G a I n A s S b Alloys a n d Q u a n t m n Wells . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.2. F a b r i c a t i o n of A n t i m o n i d e Q u a n t u m Well Laser Diodes . . . . . . 4.3. A n t i m o n i d e Q W Laser Diodes for the 2.0-2.3 ~tm Spectral R a n g e . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.4. G a I n A s S b Q W Laser Diodes E m i t t i n g b e y o n d 2.3 bm~ . . . . . . . . 4.5. C h a r a c t e r i z a t i o n of A n t i m o n i d e - B a s e d Laser Diodes Dedicated to Gas D e t e c t i o n . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5. 3 5 bun I n t e r b a n d T y p e - I I Laser Diodes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.1. I n A s S b / I n A s T y p e - I I M u l t i - q a n t u m Well Laser . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.2. I n A s / G a I n S b T y p e - I I I "W" Laser . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6. C o n c l u s i o n . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
1 3 5 5 9 11 13 14 20 23 28 33 40 41 45 48 50
High Performance Quantum Cascade Lasers and Their Applications Daniel Hofstetter a n d J6r6me Faist . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1. 2.
Introduction ....................................................... G a i n Region Designs . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.1. Basic W o r k i n g P r i n c i p l e s of QC Lasers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.2. T h r e e Q u a n t u m Well G a i n Region . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
61 61 64 64 66
X
Contents
2.3. G a i n Region with D o u b l e - p h o n o n R e s o n a n c e . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . F a b r i c a t i o n Technologies . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.1. Surface G r a t i n g with L a t e r a l C u r r e n t h @ c t i o n . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.2. Lasers with I n P R e g r o w t h . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.3. J u n c t i o n Down M o u n t i n g . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4. M e a s u r e m e n t Results . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.1. M e a s u r e m e n t Setup . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.2. D F B Laser with Lateral C u r r e n t I n j e c t i o n in the 5 lain a n d 10 p.m B a n d . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.3. D F B Lasers with I n P O v e r - G r o w n G r a t i n g . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.4. High Power J u n c t i o n Down M o u n t e d Lasers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.5. R o o m T e m p e r a t u r e C o n t i n u o u s Wave O p e r a t i o n of QC Lasers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5. A p p l i c a t i o n s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.1. P h o t o - A c o u s t i c Spectroscopy . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.2. O p t i c a l D a t a Link Using a QC Laser . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6. Conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
84 86 86 89 92 92
Mid-IR Difference Frequency Generation Cornelia Fischer and Markus W. Sigrist . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
97
3.
1. 2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
I n t r o d u c t i o n to T u n a b l e M i d - I R Laser Sources . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Basic Principles of N o n l i n e a r Optics a n d Difference F r e q u e n c y G e n e r a t i o n . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.1. F r e q u e n c y C o n v e r s i o n Processes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.2. N o n l i n e a r Optical Coefficient . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.3. P h a s e M a t c h i n g . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Material Considerations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.1. Selection of N o n l i n e a r M e d i u m . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.2. P u m p a n d Signal Laser Sources for Difference F r e q u e n c y G e n e r a t i o n . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Difference F r e q u e n c y Laser Systems R e p o r t e d in the L i t e r a t u r e . . . 4.1. Difference F r e q u e n c y Laser Sources . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.2. Difference F r e q u e n c y Laser Sources Applied in Gas Sensing . Detailed Description of a M i d - I R D F G Laser Source . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.1. E x p e r i m e n t a l Set-Up a n d S y s t e m P e r f o r m a n c e . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.2. Nd:YAG P u m p Laser . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.3. E x t e r n a l C a v i t y Diode Laser . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.4. T u n i n g with Periodically Poled LiNbO3 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.5. D e t e c t i o n Schemes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A p p l i c a t i o n s of M i d - I R Difference F r e q u e n c y Laser Systems in Gas Sensing . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.1. G e n e r a l C o n s i d e r a t i o n s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
66 68 68 70 70 71 71 72 80 82
97 100 100 103 105 118 119 121 122 122 122 125 125 126 127 128 129 131 131
Contents E x a m p l e s of Gas S p e c t r o s c o p y P e r f o r m e d w i t h O u r D F G Laser Source . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7. Conclusions a n d O u t l o o k . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
XI
6.2.
132 135 136
Pulsed M i d - I R Optical P a r a m e t r i c Oscillators Konstantin Vodopyanov ..............................................
141
1. 2. 3.
141 142 145 145 146 149 151 151 153 153 154 155 160 161 162 163 164 165 165 166
Introduction ...................................................... P r i n c i p l e of O P O O p e r a t i o n . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . O P O s in t h e 2 5 p.m R a n g e . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.1. C o m p a r i s o n of N L O M a t e r i a l s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.2. O P O s B a s e d on P P LN . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.3. O e O s B a s e d on P P K T P a n d P P R T A . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.4. O P O s B a s e d on P P K T A . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.5. O P O s Using C o n v e n t i o n a l P h a s e - m a t c h i n g in O x i d e s . . . . . . . . 4. O P O s in t h e 4 201xm R a n g e . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.1. C o m p a r i s o n of N L O M a t e r i a l s S u i t a b l e for ~ > 5~tm . . . . . . . . 4.2. O P O s B a s e d on A G S a n d A G S e . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.3. O P O s B a s e d on Z G P . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.4. O P O s B a s e d on O t h e r C r y s t a l s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5. T r a v e l i n g - W a v e O p t i c a l P a r a m e t r i c G e n e r a t o r s ( O P G s ) . . . . . . . . . . . 5.1. O P G s B a s e d on P P LN . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.2. O P G s B a s e d on Z G P . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.3. O P G s B a s e d on G a S e . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.4. O P G s B a s e d on C G A . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6. N a r r o w - L i n e w i d t h O P O s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.1. U s i n g I n t r a c a v i t y S p e c t r a l - N a r r o w i n g E l e m e n t s . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.2. N a r r o w - L i n e w i d t h O p t i c a l P a r a m e t r i c G e n e r a t o r O p t i c a l Parametric Amplifier ( O P G OPA) Systems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.3. O P O s w i t h I n j e c t i o n Seeding . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.4. U s i n g a D o u b l y R e s o n a n t C a v i t y . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7. E m e r g i n g N o n l i n e a r O p t i c a l M a t e r i a l s for M i d - I R A p p l i c a t i o n s . . . 8. S u m m a r y a n d C o n c l u d i n g R e m a r k s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
167 168 169 171 173 174
Mid-Infrared Ultrafast and C o n t i n u o u s - W a v e Optical P a r a m e t r i c Oscillators Majid Ebrahimzadeh 1. 2.
.................................................
Introduction ...................................................... Optical Parametric Process . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.1. O p t i c a l P a r a m e t r i c G a i n . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.2. O p t i c a l P a r a m e t r i c A m p l i f i c a t i o n . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
179 179 181 183 184
XII
3.
4. 5.
6.
Contents 2.3. M i d - I n f r a r e d P a r a m e t r i c G e n e r a t i o n . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Mid-Infrared OPO Devices ....................................... 3.1. N o n l i n e a r M a t e r i a l . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.2. L a s e r P u m p S o u r c e . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Mid-Infrared Nonlinear Materials ................................. Mid-Infrared Ultrafast OPOs ..................................... 5.1. M i d - I n f r a r e d P i c o s e c o n d O P O s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.2. M i d - I n f r a r e d F e I n t o s e e o n d O P O s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Mid-Infrared Continuous-Wave OPOs .............................
186 188 188 190 191 196 197 201 207
7. S u m m a r y . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References ............................................................
212 214
Mid-Infrared Fiber Lasers M a r k u s P o l l n a u a n d S t u a r t D. J a c k s o n 1. 2.
...............................
219
Introduction ...................................................... Fiber Materials ................................................... 2.1. S i l i c a t e s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.2. F l u o r i d e s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.3. C h a l c o g e n i d e s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.4. C e r a m i c s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Fiber, Pump, and Resonator Geometries .......................... 3.1. P i b e r D e s i g n s for C l a d d i n g P u m p i n g . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.2. F i b e r - L a s e r R e s o n a t o r s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.3. T h e r m a l I s s u e s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
219 220 221 222 222 222 223 223 225 226
4.
S p e c t r o s c o p i c a n d L a s e r P r o p e r t i e s of R a r e - E a r t h I o n s . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.1. S p e c t r a of R a r e - E a r t h I o n s i n G l a s s e s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.2. I n t r a i o n i c P r o c e s s e s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.3. I n t e r i o n i c P r o c e s s e s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.4. O v e r v i e w o f M i d - I n f r a r e d F i b e r L a s e r s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
226 227 228 230 232
5.
T h u l i u m - D o p e d F i b e r L a s e r s a t 1 . 9 - 2 . 0 g m a n d 2.3 2.5 ~ m 5.1. T h r e e - L e v e l L a s e r s a t 1.9 2.0~xm . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.2. F o u r - L e v e l L a s e r s a t 2.3 2.51xm . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
233 233 234
6.
H o l n f i u m - D o p e d F i b e r L a s e r s a t 2.1 g m a n d 2.9 Ixm . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.1. T h r e e - L e v e l L a s e r s a t 2.1 g m . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.2. F o u r - L e v e l L a s e r s a t 2.9 g m . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . E r b i u m - D o p e d F i b e r L a s e r s a t 2.7 2 . S g m . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.1. E x c i t e d - S t a t e A b s o r p t i o n a n d C a s c a d e L a s i n g . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.2. L i f e t i m e Q u e n c h i n g b y P r 3+ C o - D o p i n g . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
3.
7.
.......
7.3. E n e r g y R e c y c l i n g b y E n e r g y - T r a n s f e r U p c o n v e r s i o n . . . . . . . . . Fiber Lasers at Wavelengths Beyond 3 gm ........................ 8.1. Z B L A N F i b e r L a s e r s a t 3.22 ~tm, 3.45 p.m, a n d 3.95 ~tm . . . . . . 8.2. F u t u r e M i d - I n f r a r e d F i b e r L a s e r s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9. C o n c l u s i o n s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References ............................................................ 8.
235 236 237 238 238 239 240 242 243 243 244 245
Contents
XIII
Crystalline Mid-Infrared Lasers Irina T. S o r o k i n a . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
255
1. 2. 3.
255 257 260 261 281 283 285 285 286 289 292 294 295 310 314 321 323
Introduction ...................................................... Historical O v e r v i e w . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Principles of S o l i d - S t a t e Lasers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.1. S p e c t r o s c o p i c B a c k g r o u n d . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.2. Influence of S p e c t r o s c o p i c P a r a m e t e r s on Laser P r o p e r t i e s . . . 3.3. R e a c h i n g t h e T h r e s h o l d . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4. Laser Design C o n s i d e r a t i o n s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.1. P u m p Sources . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.2. C a v i t y Design . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.3. T u n i n g M e t h o d s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.4. Q - s w i t c h e d a n d M o d e - L o c k e d O p e r a t i o n . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5. M i d - I n f r a r e d Lasers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.1. T M 2 + - D o p e d Lasers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.2. Color C e n t e r Lasers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.3. R a r e - E a r t h D o p e d Lasers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6. C o n c l u s i o n a n d O u t l o o k . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Crystalline and Fiber R a m a n Lasers T . T . Basiev, V . V . Osiko, A. M. P r o k h o r o v a n d E . M . D i a n o v
........
351
I n t r o d u c t i o n (Historical a n d T h e o r e t i c a l Background} . . . . . . . . . . . . . N a n o s e c o n d S R S B a s e d on B a ( N O 3 ) 2 C r y s t a l s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . LiIO~ R a m a n Lasers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . P i c o s e c o n d R a m a n Lasers B a s e d on K G W C r y s t a l s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . N a n o s e c o n d R a m a n Lasers B a s e d on K G W C r y s t a l s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Search for N e w SRS M a t e r i a l s and Comparative Spectroscopy Study . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7. N e w B a W O 4 S R S C r y s t a l s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8. B a W O 4 a n d SrWO4 N a n o s e c o n d R a m a n Lasers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.1. M i d - I R B a W O 4 R a m a n Laser . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.2. M i d - I R Lasing in a C r 2 + : Z n S e C r y s t a l w i t h B a W O 4 R a m a n Laser P u m p i n g . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9. B a W O 4 P i c o s e c o n d R a m a n F r e q u e n c y Shifters . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10. P b W O 4 S R S Shifters a n d R a m a n Lasers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11. D i o d e - P u m p e d C W R a m a n F i b e r Lasers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11.1. R a m a n F i b e r Lasers B a s e d on G e r m a n o s i l i c a t e F i b e r s . . . . . . . 11.2. P h o s p h o s i l i c a t e F i b e r - B a s e d R a m a n Lasers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12. C o n c l u s i o n . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
351 355 361 362 366
1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6.
368 371 372 374 376 376 379 380 381 382 388 388
XIV
Contents
N a r r o w - L i n e w i d t h Tunable Terahertz-Wave Sources Using Nonlinear Optics K o d o Kawase, J u n - i c h i S h i k a t a a n d H i r o m a s a Ito
....................
1. 2. 3.
Introduction ...................................................... T h e o r y of T H z - W a v e P a r a m e t r i c G e n e r a t i o n Using P o l a r i t o n s . . . . Injection-Seeded THz-Wave Parametric Generator (is-TPG) ...... 3.1. E x p e r i m e n t a l S e t u p . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.2. P o w e r E n h a n c e m e n t . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.3. S p e c t r u m N a r r o w i n g . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.4. W i d e T u n a b i l i t y . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4. A r r a y e d Silicon P r i s m C o u p l e r for a T H z - W a v e P a r a m e t r i c Oscillator . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.1. E x p e r i m e n t a l S e t u p . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.2. E x p e r i m e n t a l R e s u l t s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5. T u n a b l e T H z - W a v e G e n e r a t i o n from D A S T C r y s t a l Using D u a l S i g n a l - W a v e P a r a m e t r i c O s c i l l a t i o n of P P L N . . . . . . . . . 5.1. E x p e r i m e n t a l S e t u p . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.2. E x p e r i m e n t a l R e s u l t s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6. C o n c l u s i o n . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
397 397 399 402 403 404 406 408 411 412 413 416 417 418 419 420
Mid-Infrared and THz Coherent Sources Using S e m i c o n d u c t o r - B a s e d Materials Hiroshi Takahashi, H i d e t o s h i M u r a k a m i , H i d e y u k i O h t a k e and Nobuhiko Sarukura . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1. 2.
Introduction ...................................................... T H z R a d i a t i o n from S e m i c o n d u c t o r - B a s e d M a t e r i a l s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.1. P h o t o c o n d u c t i v e S w i t c h . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.2. Q u a n t u m C o n f i n e d S t r u c t u r e . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.3. S e m i c o n d u c t o r Surface . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.4. N o n l i n e a r O p t i c a l P r o c e s s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3. C o n c l u d i n g R e m a r k s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
425 425 426 426 431 437 440 442 442
Mid-Infrared Laser Applications in Spectroscopy F r a n k K. T i t t e l , Dirk R i c h t e r a n d A l a n Fried 1.
2.
.........................
S o l i d - S t a t e M i d - I R S p e c t r o s c o p i c Laser Sources . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.1. Class "A" Laser Sources . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.2. Class "B" Laser Sources . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . F u n d a m e n t a l s of A b s o r p t i o n S p e c t r o s c o p y for Trace Gas D e t e c t i o n . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
445 445 447 455 462
Contents Spectroscopic Techniques: Signal E n h a n c e m e n t a n d Noise R e d u c t i o n . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.1. B a l a n c e d B e a m a n d B a l a n c e d R a t i o m e t r i c D e t e c t i o n (Noise R e d u c t i o n ) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.2. W a v e l e n g t h a n d F r e q u e n c y - M o d u l a t i o n Spectroscopy (Noise R e d u c t i o n ) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.3. Long O p t i c a l P a t h L e n g t h Spectroscopy (Signal E n h a n c e m e n t ) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.4. C a v i t y - E n h a n c e d Spectroscopy M e t h o d s (Signal E n h a n c e m e n t ) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.5. P h o t o a c o u s t i c a n d P h o t o t h e r m a l Spectroscopy (Signal E n h a n c e m e n t ) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4. Mid-hffrared Spectroscopic A p p l i c a t i o n s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.1. Detailed E x a m p l e s Using Selected Spectroscopic Sources a n d Techniques . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5. S u m m a r y a n d O u t l o o k . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
XV
3.
Mid-IR Laser Applications in Medicine Benedikt Jean and T h o m a s Bende . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.
2.
3.
4.
Introduction ...................................................... 1.1. A b s o r b e r s a n d N a t u r a l l y O c c u r r i n g C h r o m o p h o r e s . . . . . . . . . . 1.2. Laser Sources . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Laser Tissue I n t e r a c t i o n . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.1. P h o t o t h e r m a l Laser Tissue I n t e r a c t i o n . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.2. I R P h o t o t h e r m a l A b l a t i o n . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.3. P h o t o s p a l l a t i o n . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.4. Collateral T h e r m a l D a m a g e . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Experimental Photothermal Ablation Using Free E l e c t r o n Lasers (FEL) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.1. Collateral T h e r m a l Effects as a F u n c t i o n of ~Vavelength . . . . . 3.2. P h o t o m e c h a n i c a l I n t e r a c t i o n . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.3. T h e Influence of Specific A b s o r b e r s in the Target M a t e r i a l .. 3.4. Feedback Laser C o n t r o l . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Clinical Laser A p p l i c a t i o n s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.1. G y n e c o l o g y . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.2. O t o r h i n o l a r y n g o l o g y ( E N T ) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.3. N e u r o s u r g e r y . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.4. D e r m a t o l o g y . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.5. Urology . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.6. D e n t a l Surgery . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.7. O p h t h a l m o l o g y . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.8. C a r d i o v a c u l a r Surgery, A n g i o p l a s t y . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
466 467 470 472 473 478 480 481 496 497
511 511 512 514 516 516 521 522 523 524 525 525 525 527 529 529 530 530 531 533 533 535 535
XVI
Contents
5. P e r s p e c t i v e o f a T u n e a b l e I R L a s e r S o u r c e . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References ............................................................
536 538
Index
545
................................................................
Mid-Infrared 2–5 µm Heterojunction Laser Diodes Andr´e Joulli´e, Philippe Christol, Alexei N. Baranov, and Aurore Vicet Centre d’Electronique et de Microopto´electronique de Montpellier (CEM2), UMR CNRS n◦ 5507, Universit´e de Montpellier II, Sciences et Techniques du Languedoc, case 067, 34095 Montpellier Cedex 05, France {joullie,baranov,vicet}@univ-montp2.fr
[email protected] Abstract. High performance mid-infrared (2–5 µm) laser diodes are needed for applications such as high resolution and high sensitivity chemical gas analysis and atmospheric pollution monitoring. The goal is to obtain continuous wave laser emission at room temperature, with output power > 1 mW. Different technologies are under investigation to reach this objective. The GaInAsSb/AlGaAsSb strained multi-quantum-well laser showed striking results in CW operation at and above room temperature and appears as a well established technology for laser emission in the 2.0–2.7 µm wavelength range. Beyond 2.7 µm, the IV–VI lasers based on the PbSe/PbSrSe system, type-II “W” quantum well lasers based on the InAs/GaInSb system, and type-II interband and intersubband III–V cascade lasers, are competitive technologies. They could all operate at room temperature or near room temperature, but only in the pulsed regime. This paper presents an overview of the state of the art of these different mid-infrared systems emitting in the 2–5 µm wavelength range. Two heterojunction laser technologies are detailed: the 2–3 µm GaInAsSb multi-quantum-well laser, and the 3–5 µm type-II and type-II “W” laser diodes.
1
Introduction
Light sources emitting in the mid-infrared (IR) wavelength domain (2–5 µm) arouse a growing interest due to their potential applications in telecommunications and molecular spectroscopy. Optical telecommunications can be achieved through the 2–2.5 µm and 3.5–4 µm high transparency atmospheric windows [1]. Gas detection with a high resolution can be developed because a lot of polluting gases and combustion products have strong absorption lines in the mid-IR region, as shown in Fig. 1: NH3 (2.1 µm), HF (2.5 µm), CH4 (2.35 µm and 3.3 µm), HCHO (3.5 µm), HCl (3.5 µm), N2 O (3.9 µm and 4.5 µm), SO2 (4 µm), CO2 (4.25 µm) and CO (2.3 µm and 4.6 µm) [2]. The use of mid-IR emitters offers rich possibilities for areas such as atmospheric pollution monitoring, industrial process control, leak detection, automotive engine exhaust analysis, drug detection, and for the medical diagnosis of disease. Other potential applications include laser surgery, rangefinding, IR I. T. Sorokina, K. L. Vodopyanov (Eds.): Solid-State Mid-Infrared Laser Sources, Topics Appl. Phys. 89, 1–61 (2003) c Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2003
Andr´e Joulli´e et al.
WAVELENGTH (µm)
-1
-2
LINESTRENGTH [cm / (molecules.cm )]
2
5 4.5
4
3.5
3
2.5
2
1E-16
1E-23
1E-17
CH4 HF CO CO2 HCl H2O
1E-18 1E-19 1E-20 1E-21 1E-22
1E-22 1E-21 1E-20 1E-19 1E-18
1E-23
1E-17
1E-24
2000
1E-24
2500
3000
3500
4000
4500
1E-16 5000
-1
WAVENUMBER (cm ) Fig. 1. Strength of absorption lines for various pollutants in the 2–5 µm wavelength domain (HITRAN data base – 1996). Water spectrum in blue refers to the right y-axis. The spectra of CH4 , HF, CO, CO2 and HCl chemical species refer to the left y-axis
illumination and IR countermeasures. These applications require light emitters having a small spectral width and high optical power and brightness. Semiconductor laser diodes can fulfil these criteria. The goal is to obtain devices operating in continuous mode (CW) at room temperature, promising compact sources more widely applicable than conventional technology such as optical parametric oscillators. For gas analysis tunable diode laser absorption spectroscopy (TDLAS) is classically employed [3]. CW output powers of 1–10 mW and single optical mode emission are required, with the ability to tune the lasing wavelength in a wide spectral domain. For other applications much higher CW output powers (≈ 1 W) are needed. A weak temperature dependence of the laser characteristics is also wanted. The characteristic temperature T0 , which describes the evolution of the current threshold with temperature from the approximate expression Ith = I0 exp(T /T0 ), must be high, typically higher than 100 K. Nowadays, in the 2–5 µm wavelength domain, there is no semiconductor laser diode able to work at room temperature in the continuous regime, with the exception of GaInAsSb injection lasers which could operate CW in the shortest mid-IR wavelength region, from 2 to 2.7 µm [4]. Different material systems are employed for the fabrication of mid-IR lasers: lead salt IV–VI lasers, which are the oldest mid-IR devices, for years the only ones commercially available; lasers based on HgCdTe material, which is widely used in IR detection; antimony based type-I or type-II interband lasers which include in their active zone GaInAsSb/AlGaAsSb or GaInAsSb/GaSb quantum wells
Mid-Infrared 2–5 µm Heterojunction Laser Diodes
3
(QWs); type-II “W” quantum well lasers which possess four layers in each period of the active region (e.g. InAs/GaInAsSb/InAs/AlGaAsSb); III–V GaInAs/AlInAs/InP and GaAs/AlGaAs quantum cascade lasers (QCLs), which employ conduction intersubband radiative transitions; and interband quantum cascade lasers (ICLs) which associate interband transitions and the cascade effect. In this chapter we present an overview of the recent developments of these different mid-IR systems operating in the 2–5 µm wavelength domain. Then we detail heterojunction laser systems which are able to operate at room temperature under electrical pumping in this wavelength range: the 2–3 µm GaInAsSb/AlGaAsSb multi-quantum-well (MQW) laser diodes, and the 3–5 µm type-II and type-II “W” laser diodes.
2
Historical
The first demonstrations of mid-IR emission were in 1963, from an InAs p-n junction at 3.1 µm [5] and from an InSb p-n junction at 5.3 µm [6,7]. Laser emission at much longer wavelengths was reported from PbTe and PbSe p-n junction diodes [8]. During the 1980s, standard mid-IR lasers were exclusively fabricated from narrow gap lead and lead-tin based IV–VI semiconductors PbTe, PbSe, PbS, PbSnTe, PbSnSe and PbSSe. Typical devices were diffused laser diodes, operating at low temperature (4–77 K), which emitted in the wavelength range 4–30 µm, the shortest wavelength being limited by the energy gap of PbS or PbTe, to approximately either 4 µm or 5.5 µm at 77 K [9]. A noticeable improvement in IV–VI laser properties was achieved with double heterostructure (DH) lasers, fabricated using advanced growth techniques such as liquid phase epitaxy (LPE), hot wall epitaxy (HWE) and molecular beam epitaxy (MBE) techniques. In 1990, DH lasers based on lead salt compounds remained the standard for mid-IR lasers. Grown on PbS, PbSe or PbTe substrates, they cover the wavelength range from 3 to 30 µm, and can operate beyond 100 K CW. They used as active layers PbEuSSe for the short wavelength region 3–4 µm [10], PbEuSeTe or PbEuSe for the 4–8 µm range, and PbSnTe or PbSnSe for wavelengths beyond 8 µm [11]. At the same time new IR materials are emerging: the GaInAsSb and InAsPSb III–V solid solutions. AlGaAsSb/GaInAsSb/AlGaAsSb DH lasers grown on GaSb substrate, and InAsPSb/InAsSb/InAsPSb DH lasers grown on InAs substrate, showed excellent performance, at room temperature in the 2.0–2.5 µm range [12,13,14,15,16] and at 80 K in the 3–4 µm range [17,18], respectively. An example of a DH laser grown by LPE on an InAs substrate is shown in Fig. 2. Original structures were also studied, where photons are generated, for the first time, from type-II indirect transitions. They consisted of Ga(In)(As)Sb/GaInAsSb p-n [19] and p-p [20] heterojunctions, grown by LPE, which possess at their interface a triangular type-II quantum well.
4
Andr´e Joulli´e et al.
Fig. 2. Cross-section of the first III–V double heterojunction laser emitting beyond 3 µm [17]
After 1990 substantial progress occurred, mainly due to the perfect mastery of the molecular beam epitaxy technique and its use for the growth of DH and quantum well lasers. That was the case for IV–VI laser diodes based on the PbSe/PbSrSe system, which could present high temperature operation in the 3–5 µm wavelength range [21,22,23], and for II–VI lasers based on HgCdTe solid solution which could emit coherent light under electrical injection for the first time [24,25]. But the most impressive results were obtained with III–V quantum well lasers designed by band structure engineering [26,27]. The aim of band structure engineering is to decrease the non-radiative Auger recombination which is the main loss mechanism in long wavelength lasers, and to imagine new laser structures able to reach high optical efficiency. III–V heterostructures possess strong differences in band gap energy and band discontinuity which allows the formation of deep and confining quantum wells. Besides the growth feasibility of extremely complex epitaxial structures by MBE permits the design and fabrication of high performance devices. In 2000, three III–V laser technologies have emerged in this way for laser emission in the mid-IR: the type-II “W” lasers based on the InAs/GaInSb system [28,29,30,31], the interband cascade laser also based on the type-II InAs/GaInSb system [32,33,34,35], and the intersubband quantum cascade lasers employing the GaInAs/AlInAs system [36,37,38,39,40,41,42]. Room temperature or near room temperature operation was obtained from these different technologies in the 3–5 µm wavelength region. On the other hand, in the 2–3 µm wavelength domain, the more conventional strained MQW laser diodes based on the GaIn(As)Sb/AlGaAsSb system showed striking results in CW operation at high temperature and appear as the definitive established technology for laser emission near 2 µm [4,43,44,45,46,47,48,49].
Mid-Infrared 2–5 µm Heterojunction Laser Diodes
3 3.1
5
State of the Art Typical Heterojunction Laser Structure
A schematic drawing of a Fabry–P´erot laser diode is shown in Fig. 3. The active zone is sandwiched between two thick (2–3 µm) confining layers, which possess high band gap and low refractive index, and must be lattice-matched to the substrate. Classically, the substrate and the first confinement layer are n-type, the active region is undoped, and the second confining layer has a p-type conductivity, so that the heterojunction lies between the active and one cladding layer. A thin and highly doped layer is grown at the top of the structure for contacting. It is often recommended to insert a layer of graded composition between the substrate and the adjacent confining layer, or generally between each confining layer and the adjacent low band gap material, in order to facilitate carrier injection and reduce the series resistance of the laser diode. In DH lasers the active region consists of a thin layer of a narrow band gap material. The radiative transitions arise from band to band recombinations of hole–electron pairs and the emitted wavelength obeys the equation λ(µm) = 1.24/Eg (eV), which means that in order to cover the 2–5 µm spectral range, active mid-IR materials in a DH laser must have a band gap energy in the 0.25–0.62 eV range. There exists an optimal thickness for the active layer, typically 0.15–0.5 µm, depending the wavelength and the optical confinement factor [50]. In III–V lasers, the used substrates are GaSb or InAs, the confining layers are Alx Ga1−x Asy Sb1−y (x ≈ 0.8–1.0), InAs1−x−y Py Sbx (x + y ≈ 0.5) or InAs/AlSb superlattice (the latter provides a straightforward lattice-match to the substrate and circumvents the need for tellurium doping), and the narrow band gap material is Ga1−x Inx Asy Sb1−y quaternary solid solution (for emission at λ ≈ 2–3 µm) or InAs1−x Sbx alloy (for emission at λ ≈ 3–5 µm). For IV–VI DH lasers, the used substrates are n-PbS, p-PbSe or p-PbTe, and typically the p- and n-type confinement layers and the active
Fig. 3. Schematic drawing of a stripe-contact heterojunction laser diode
6
Andr´e Joulli´e et al.
layers all consist of Pb1−x Eux Sey Te1−y , Pb1−x Srx S or Pb1−x Srx Se materials, with an extremely small Eu or Sr concentration in the active layer and a larger Eu concentration in the confining layers. In QW lasers the active region consists of quantum wells shared in the center of a spacer layer (often called a waveguide layer) which has a lower band gap energy and higher refractive index than those of the two adjacent cladding layers. The role of this spacer layer is to reduce the penetration of light in the cladding layers in order to reduce optical absorption loss. QW lasers can be classified into three categories, depending the nature of the band alignment at the well-barrier interface (Fig. 4): nested (type-I), staggered (type-II) and broken gap (type-III). In the first case electrons and holes are confined into the same material (Fig. 4a), while in the two other cases carriers are spatially separated into the adjacent layers. As a consequence indirect radiative recombinations are generated (Fig. 4b and 4c). Note that the typeIII band alignment is a particular case of the type-II one where the conduction band of the well is placed below the valence band of the barrier (Fig. 4c). The knowledge of conduction and valence band-offsets at the interface of a heterostructure is fundamental for the design of the QW laser. Using band gap values, extracted from standard parameters of III–V compounds (Table 1), and valence band-offset values of III–V unstrained hetero-interfaces cladding a) layer
cladding layer
Active zone
waveguide layer
e1
waveguide layer
hh1
Type-I b)
cladding layer
Active zone
cladding layer waveguide layer
e1
hh1
waveguide layer
hh1
Type-II cladding c) layer
cladding layer
Active zone
e1 waveguide layer
hh1
hh1
waveguide layer
Type-III (Type-II broken gap)
Fig. 4. Schematic representation of type-I (a), type-II (b) and type-III or type-II broken gap (c) quantum wells. The fundamental radiative electron–hole transition e1 –hh1 is shown
Mid-Infrared 2–5 µm Heterojunction Laser Diodes
7
Table 1. Material parameters of various III–V compound semiconductors Parameters
AlAs
AlSb
a0 (˚ A) Eg 4 K (eV)
5.6622 3.13 (Γ) 2.23 (X)
Eg 300 K (eV)
3.03 (Γ) 2.168(X) 0.30 1.25 0.53 2.47
6.1355 2.384 (Γ) 2.327 ( ) 1.696 (X) 2.300 (Γ) 2.211 ( ) 1.615 (X) 0.67 0.88 0.43 1.38
−5.64
Γ (eV) c11 (1012 dyn/cm2 ) c12 (1012 dyn/cm2 ) hydr. deform. pot. av (eV) hydr. deform. pot. ac ( ) (eV) shear deform. pot. b (eV) m∗e (mo ) Ep (eV) m∗lh (mo ) m∗hh (mo ) m∗sh (mo )
GaAs
GaSb
InAs
InP
InSb
5.6532 6.0954 6.0584 5.8688 6.4794 1.519 0.871 ( ) 0.418 1.418 0.236 0.808 ( ) 1.424
0.761 ( ) 0.725 ( )
0.356 1.345 0.172
0.340 1.18 0.54 1.16
0.761 0.88 0.40 0.79
0.380 0.110 0.810 0.83 1.02 0.66 0.45 0.58 0.36 1.00 1.27 0.36
−6.97
−7.17
−6.85
−5.08 −5.04 −6.17
−1.5
−1.4
−1.7
−2.0
−1.8
0.083 21.10 0.160 1.785 0.29
0.102 18.70 0.162 0.469 0.24
0.0665 22.71 0.090 0.377 0.15
0.042 25.7 0.045 0.222 0.075
0.023 0.073 0.0136 21.11 17 22.49 0.027 0.095 0.014 0.263 0.471 0.244 0.049 0.16 0.02
−1.6
−2.1
(Table 2), calculated from the data of Tsou [51], it is possible to determine the type of band alignment for a number of III–V unstrained heterostructures. Figure 5 presents a schematic view at scale of the band-edge alignments of some unstrained III–V binary systems. We can remark that heterointerfaces between arsenides (or antimonides) are always type-I, whereas interfaces between arsenides and antimonides can be type-I (InSb/AlAs, GaSb/AlGaAsSb), type-II (InAs/AlSb, GaInAsSb/GaSb, InAsSb/InAs) and type-III (InAs/GaSb, InAs/GaInSb). This figure also shows that extremely deep quantum wells (of the order of 1 eV) are realized in the conduction band by associating compounds with type-II or type-III band offsets (e.g. InAs/AlSb, InAs/GaSb). In the case of IV–VI heterojunctions, unfortunately, there is a lack of information on the band-offset values, and for studied systems like PbSnTe/PbTe or PbTe/PbEuSeTe, results have been controversial [21]. Besides it was shown that band offsets are temperature dependent for some IV–VI systems like PbSe/PbEuSe. Type-I band alignment and an offset ratio ∆ Ec /∆ Ev = 0.5 are often predicted, but quantitative data on band offsets are needed for a proper design of the IV–VI laser structure.
8
Andr´e Joulli´e et al.
Table 2. Valence band offsets of unstrained III–V systems
A material
'Ev >0 ∆ Ev (eV)
GaSb/AlSb GaSb/AlAs GaSb/GaAs GaSb/InAs GaSb/InSb InAs/InP InAs/AlAs InAs/GaAs AlSb/AlAs AlSb/InAs InSb/InAs InSb/AlAs InSb/AlSb InSb/GaAs InSb/InP GaAs/InP GaAs/AlAs GaAs/AlSb GaAs/GaP
+0.40 +1.16 +0.68 +0.51 +0.08 +0.45 +0.65 +0.17 +0.76 +0.11 +0.43 +1.08 +0.32 +0.60 +0.88 +0.28 +0.48 −0.28 +0.19
AlSb 1.6 eV (X)
InAs 0.35 eV
GaAs 1.42 eV
AlAs 2.16 eV (X)
0.4 eV
Ev
Band alignment Type Type Type Type Type Type Type Type Type Type Type Type Type Type Type Type Type Type Type
I I I III II I I I I II III I I I I II I I I
InSb 0.17 eV
T = 300 K
Ec
GaSb 0.72 eV
A/B system
Fig. 5. Conduction and valence band edges of unstrained III–V binary compounds showing the conduction and valence band discontinuities at the hetero-interfaces for adjacent systems (This diagram is not transitive)
Mid-Infrared 2–5 µm Heterojunction Laser Diodes
3.2 3.2.1
9
Maximum Temperature of Operation Threshold Current Limitations
The different contributions to the current in an injection laser are the nonradiative Schockley–Hall–Read (SHR) recombinations on deep levels, the interband spontaneous recombinations and the non-radiative Auger recombinations [52]: J = qd(Rnr + Rsp + RAuger ) .
(1)
In (1) J is the current density, d is the width of the active region, Rnr is the SHR recombination rate, Rsp the radiative recombination rate and RAuger the Auger recombination rate. Equation (1) is described by the phenomenological equation: J = qd(AN + BN 2 + CN 3 ) ,
(2)
where N is the concentration of the injected carriers (supposed much higher than equilibrium carrier concentrations of the active region). A is the nonradiative SHR coefficient, B is the spontaneous emission coefficient and C is the Auger coefficient. The laser threshold is obtained when the modal gain Gmod (N ), which increases with the injected carrier concentration N , becomes equal to the total optical losses αtotal : Gmod (N = Nth ) = Γ Gmax (N = Nth ) = αtotal = αint + αFP .
(3)
Γ is the optical confinement factor, Gmax is the maximum optical gain for an injected carrier concentration N , αint is the internal loss coefficient and αFP is the mirror loss of the Fabry–P´erot cavity. The carrier concentration at threshold Nth is then determined by (3), and the threshold current density Jth is given by: 2 3 + CNth ). Jth = qd(ANth + BNth
(4)
For long wavelength lasers, the Auger contribution is widely dominant at room temperature for two reasons: the Auger coefficient exponentially increases with the wavelength [52,53], the internal losses, and particularly losses due to free carrier absorption [54,55], and equally strongly increases with wavelength. As a consequence the carrier concentration at threshold Nth is raised, and the Auger rate, which varies as N 3 , is dramatically increased. In the free carrier absorption mechanism, the photon disappears by collision with a free carrier, electron or hole, which increases its energy. That increase requires a change in the k wave number with the aid of a diffusion mechanism (impurity, optical phonon). The free carrier absorption mechanism is not simple to quantify. A practical equation is [55]: αfc = K[N (cm−3 )/1017 ][λ(µm)/9]p ,
(5)
10
Andr´e Joulli´e et al.
Table 3. Coefficients for the calculation of the free carrier absorption coefficient using (5), as reported by reference [56] Compound
N (1017 cm−3 )
K
p
GaAs InP GaSb InAs InSb AlSb
1–5 0.4–4 0.5 0.3–0.8 1–3 0.4–4
3 4 6 4.7 2.3 15
3 2.5 3.5 3 2 2
-1
FREE CARRIER ABSORPTION (cm )
where K and p are constants dependent on a given material (Table 3). Figure 6 shows the variation of the free carrier absorption coefficient αfc of different mid-IR materials as a function of the carrier concentration N , for a wavelength λ = 3.5 µm. One can see that the αfc value for AlAsSb material, which is currently used as cladding layer in a mid-IR laser structure, becomes high (≈ 20 cm−1 ) at carrier concentrations around 1018 cm−3 which are typical values for injected carriers at threshold. Conversely, the free carrier absorption coefficient of GaSb, InAs and InAsPSb materials, which are usually employed as waveguide layers, remains reasonably small (≈ 2 cm−1 at N = 1018 cm−3 ). Room temperature Auger coefficients for a number of mid-IR materials are shown in Fig. 7. In this figure are reported the experimental data of Meyer et al. [57], Vurgaftman et al. [31], Joulli´e [47,58], and Pautrat [59]. The following findings can be drawn: In the 2–5 µm mid-IR wavelength domain, the Auger coefficient of II–VI and III–V compounds strongly increases with temperature (from ≈ 10−28 cm6 /s to ≈ 10−26 cm6 /s). In the wavelength range
100
300 K 3.5 µm 10
Sb 0.84 AlAs 0.16 b .13 P 0.29S 0 InAs 0.58
1
0.1
InAs
1
b GaS
10 17
-3
CARRIER CONCENTRATION (10 cm )
Fig. 6. Free carrier absorption coefficient versus free carrier concentration of different mid-IR materials calculated for a wavelength of 3.5 µm
Mid-Infrared 2–5 µm Heterojunction Laser Diodes
11
Fig. 7. Auger coefficient versus gap wavelength of mid-IR semiconductor materials; open circles: bulk materials; open boxes: type-I GaInAsSb/AlGaAsSb and InAsSb/AlInAsSb multiple quantum wells; solid circles, solid triangles and solid boxes: type-II staggered GaInAsSb/GaSb multiple quantum wells and type-II broken gap InAs/GaInSb “W” quantum wells. For these materials Auger coefficients were derived from photoconductivity measurements (solid circles), pump probe experiments (solid triangles) and correlation of laser threshold with calculated threshold (solid boxes); open triangles: HgCdTe compound; : lead salts
2.0–2.6 µm type-II staggered GaInAsSb/GaSb quantum wells show Auger coefficients smaller than those of type-I GaInAsSb/AlGaAsSb quantum wells. In the 3–5 µm wavelength region, InAs/GaInSb type-II broken gap “W” quantum wells show smaller Auger coefficients than bulk material (HgCdTe, InAs, InAsSb). This reduction is noticeable (its corresponds to a factor ≈ 5), but it is far from that predicted by calculations [60,61]. Around 4 µm, the Auger coefficient of lead salts is strongly inferior to that of type-I and type-II III–V systems by a factor superior to 10. 3.3 Maximum Operating Temperature in the 2–5 µm Wavelength Domain The maximum temperatures of operation Tmax achieved to date from semiconductor laser diodes emitting in the mid-IR wavelength region in the pulsed regime and in the CW regime are shown in Fig. 8 and Fig. 9. In the pulsed or CW regime, whatever the system, the maximum temperatures of operation Tmax regularly decrease with the wavelength. Below 3 µm, excellent results are obtained with type-I MQW not only in the pulsed regime (Tmax = 180 ◦ C at λ = 2.3 µm) but also in CW mode (Tmax = 130 ◦ C at λ = 2.3 µm). In contrast, RT operation is more difficult to achieve beyond 3 µm. In the pulsed
12
Andr´e Joulli´e et al.
GaInAsSb/AlGaAsSb
GaInAs/InAlAs
PULSED Tmax (K)
400 GaInAsSb/GaSb
InAs/GaInSb
lead salts
300 200 InAsSb InSb/AlInSb
100 HgCdTe
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
4.5
5.0
5.5
WAVELENGTH (µm) Fig. 8. Maximum operating temperature of pulsed semiconductor laser diodes in the mid-IR; open circles: Sb-based DH lasers; open boxes: Sb-based type-I MQW lasers; solid boxes: Sb-based type-II MQW lasers; +: Sb-based type-II interband cascade lasers; ∗ GaInAs/AlInAs inter sub-band quantum cascade lasers; : lead salt lasers; open triangles: HgCdTe lasers
CW Tmax (K)
400
GaInAsSb/AlGaAsSb
300
GaInAsSb/GaSbInAs/GaInSb
lead salts
200
InAsSb
100
GaInAs/InAlAs 0 (b)
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
4.5
5.0
5.5
WAVELENGTH (µm) Fig. 9. Maximum operating temperature of CW semiconductor laser diodes in the mid-IR; open circles: Sb-based DH lasers; open boxes: Sb-based type-I MQW lasers; solid boxes: Sb-based type-II MQW lasers; +: Sb-based type-II interband cascade lasers; ∗: GaInAs/AlInAs inter sub-band quantum cascade lasers; : lead salt lasers; HgCdTe laser diodes do not operate CW
CW OUTPUT POWER (mW/facet)
Mid-Infrared 2–5 µm Heterojunction Laser Diodes
13
10000 1000 InAs/GaInSb 100
GaInAsSb 300K
10 1 0.1
GaInAs/InAlAs
InAsSb (50K)
Type-I MQW DH
ICL
Type-II MQW
QCL
1.5
2.0
80K
W
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
4.5
5.0
5.5
WAVELENGTH (µm) Fig. 10. Output power per facet of CW semiconductor laser diodes in the midIR; open circles: Sb-based DH lasers; open boxes: Sb-based type-I MQW lasers; solid boxes: Sb-based type-II MQW lasers; +: Sb-based type-II interband cascade lasers; ∗: GaInAs/AlInAs inter sub-band quantum cascade lasers; : lead salt lasers; HgCdTe laser diodes do not operate CW
regime, only three systems operate at RT (lead salts, type-II “W” and intersubband cascade lasers) while in the CW regime, the best result is obtained for lead salts lasers with a Tmax value of 223 K at (λ = 4.2 µm). In comparison with Fig. 7, we can remark that the performances of laser diodes are strongly dependent on the Auger recombination. Best performances are realized in the wavelength range where the Auger coefficient values are lower. The maximum output power per facet in the CW regime exhibited by the previous systems is reported in Fig. 10. The same behaviour can be observed with a strong decline of the performances beyond 3 µm. Nevertheless, significant output power (100 mW/facet) is measured at low temperature (T = 80 K) for the III–V systems. Lead salt lasers exhibit weak output powers, and HgCdTe laser diodes did not operate in CW mode at T = 80 K.
4 Antimonide Quantum Well Laser Diodes for the 2–3 µm Spectral Range Semiconductor laser diodes emitting between 2 and 3 µm are strongly needed for molecular spectroscopy, remote sensing, and pollution monitoring. The interest in this spectral range is due to the fact that the absorption of many molecules is much stronger compared with shorter wavelengths and, on the other hand, high performance semiconductor light sources and photodetectors operating at room temperature can be realized. The spectroscopic applications require single mode and single frequency laser diodes which can work in the continuous wave (CW) regime near RT. High power CW and quasi-CW
14
Andr´e Joulli´e et al.
(QCW) lasers are attractive as sources for infrared countermeasure applications. The evolution of the diode lasers for the 2–3 µm spectral range followed the requirements imposed by these two fields of application. Two material systems can be used to fabricate laser diodes emitting beyond 2 µm. The first is the InP based materials employing compressively strained GaInAs quantum wells and lattice-matched GaInAsP barriers grown on InP substrates [62,63,64,65,66,67,68,69]. The devices emitting between 2.0 and 2.07 µm [66] exhibited high performance at RT. Pulsed threshold current density as low as 300 A/cm2 and CW output powers as high as 0.8 W/facet have been obtained [69]. Distributed feedback (DFB) lasers operating at 2.043 µm have been realized with the threshold current as low as 6 mA and the maximum output power of 6 mW [68]. Employing InAs quantum wells with GaInAs barriers the spontaneous emission at RT can be extended to 2.4 µm [70] but to date the longest reported emission wavelength for InPbased diode lasers is 2.2 µm [71]. The second system is GaSb based incorporating GaInAsSb active layers and GaAlAsSb barrier/confining layers grown on GaSb substrates. The first MBE grown strained GaInAsSb QW lasers [43] largely outperformed the double heterostructure lasers and type-II interface QW devices and became the main basis for further progress in RT diode lasers for the 2–3 µm spectral range. 4.1
Strained GaInAsSb Alloys and Quantum Wells
The band gap of Ga1−x Inx Asy Sb1−y lattice matched to GaSb varies between 0.725 eV (GaSb) and 0.29 eV (InAs0.91 Sb0.09 ) at RT but strains in mismatched quantum wells usually employed in laser structures modify significantly the band parameters of the material. Type-I and type-II quantum well structures can be fabricated using strained GaInAsSb alloys for the QWs and GaSb barriers. The energy position of the conduction and the valence bands has been calculated in [72,46] using the Van de Walle model [73] based on the local density functional formalism and the “model-solid” approach allows one to calculate energy level shifts due to strains. The strained band offsets have been obtained by adding the shifts due to strain to the unstrained band offsets interpolated from the experimental data on binary compounds. Results obtained with this semi-empirical method are in good agreement with available experimental data [74,75,76]. Figure 11 shows the calculated valence band offset between GaSb and Ga1−x Inx Asy Sb1−y for the entire range of the alloy compositions [72]. As seen from these data, the more favorable for lasing type-I band alignment between the quaternary alloy and GaSb can be obtained only with small As concentrations. With increasing As content both the conduction and the valence bands of GaInAsSb move down with respect to GaSb band positions, improving electron and worsening hole confinement in the QW, and beyond some As concentration the type-II alignment takes place between
Mid-Infrared 2–5 µm Heterojunction Laser Diodes
15
Fig. 11. Compositional diagram of the Ga1−x Inx Asy Sb1−y quaternary alloy showing the composition of GaSb-lattice-matched alloys (dotted line) and the composition of alloys having a constant strained valence band offset with GaSb (solid lines) [72]. Positive values of band-offsets correspond to a band alignment!type-I Ga1−x Inx Asy Sb1−y / GaSb band alignment; negative values correspond to a typeII band alignment
Fig. 12. Valence band offset between GaSb and strained Ga1−x Inx Asy Sb1−y alloys as a function of As content [46]
these materials. In Fig. 12 the GaInAsSb/GaSb valence band offset is shown as a function of As content for several In concentrations in the alloy [46]. The calculated band gap of pseudomorphic Ga1−x Inx Asy Sb1−y grown on GaSb is shown in Fig. 13 [46]. In the case of compressively strained material (right parts of the curves) the band gap is formed by the Γ -minimum of the conduction band and the heavy hole valence band; for tensile strains (left parts of the curves) the energy distance between the conduction band and the light hole valence band was taken as the band gap. A very important parameter depending on strains which must be taken into account in designing
16
Andr´e Joulli´e et al.
Fig. 13. Band gap of strained Ga1−x Inx Asy Sb1−y alloys grown on GaSb substrates [46]
Fig. 14. Splitting in the valence band of strained Ga1−x Inx Asy Sb1−y /GaSb alloys [46]
laser structures is the spin–orbit splitting in the valence band. The resonance between the split-off valence bands and the energy of emitted photons results in a significant increase of the Auger recombination rate [77] and enhanced intervalence band absorption [78], which deteriorates laser characteristics. The energy difference between the heavy hole valence band and the spin–orbit split-off band is shown in Fig. 14 as a function of the Ga1−x Inx Asy Sb1−y composition as well as the strain induced splitting between the heavy and light hole bands [46]. In a type-II GaInAsSb/GaSb quantum well the radiative transitions occur between electrons in the QW and holes localized in the GaSb barriers near the interface. The energy of these indirect transitions is smaller than in the case
Mid-Infrared 2–5 µm Heterojunction Laser Diodes
17
Fig. 15. Emission wavelength as a function of the Ga0.5 In0.5 Asy Sb1−y /GaSb quantum well width [46]
of the direct recombination inside the quantum well and the photon energy can be even smaller than the band gap of the QW material. This gives an additional degree of freedom in developing mid-infrared lasers. As the first approximation one can consider that the photon energy is defined by transitions between the fundamental electron level (E1) in the QW and the valence band of GaSb. The emission wavelength calculated in this manner is represented by dashed curves in Fig. 15 as a function of the Ga0.5 In0.5 Asy Sb1−y /GaSb QW width for different As concentrations [46]. In the case of type-I structures the emission wavelength was calculated for direct e1 –hh1 transitions (solid lines in Fig. 15). The calculations were carried out for QW widths not exceeding the critical thickness of strain relaxation if it was found to be smaller than 100 ˚ A. High In and low As concentrations in the QW are required to obtain the type-I band alignment with GaSb. On the other hand, the QW should be narrow enough in order not to exceed the critical thickness, which limits the emission wavelength in structures with direct recombination inside the well. It was found that the maximum emission wavelength of 2.5–2.6 µm at RT still due to the type-I transitions can be achieved with a 80-˚ A-thick QW of Ga0.5 In0.5 As0.12 Sb0.88 and GaSb barriers (Fig. 15) but in the structures with several quantum wells the critical thickness may be exceeded. In general, the indirect radiative recombination in type-II quantum wells is considered as less efficient compared with type-I structures because of the weaker carrier wavefunction overlap. However, under injection electrons confined in the type-II quantum well attract holes from the barriers due to the Coulomb interaction. The hole density near the QW interfaces grows, which increases the wavefunction overlap and the radiative recombination efficiency [79]. Besides, the non-radiative Auger recombination can be signif-
18
Andr´e Joulli´e et al.
icantly reduced in the optimized type-II QW structures compared with their type-I counterparts [80]. Ga1−x Inx Asy Sb1−y /GaSb multiple quantum well (MQW) lasers with different compositions of the (6–7)-nm-wide wells have been studied in [72]. The In concentration was fixed at x = 0.26 or x = 0.35 while the As fraction increased from 0 to 0.16 thus changing the band alignment from type-I to type-II. The laser emission wavelength at RT varied from 1.98 µm to 2.36 µm increasing with the In and As concentrations. No significant degradation of the laser performance was observed after the change of the band alignment type. The threshold current density of (500–900)-µm-long Fabry–P´erot lasers was as low as 280 A/cm2 for the 4-QW type-I structures emitting near 2.0 µm [72,81] and 305 A/cm2 for the 2.36 µm type-II devices with five QWs [82,72]. Moreover, the threshold current density per quantum well of these type-II lasers (62 A/cm2 ) is among the lowest values reported for any lasers emitting beyond 2 µm. The InAs/GaSb system, which is potentially suitable for longer wavelengths, presents an extreme case of the type-II band alignment since the conduction band of InAs lies below the valence band of GaSb. Unlike in conventional type-II structures, the lowest energy of indirect radiative transitions in the InAs/GaSb QW structures is not limited and can be, in principle, tuned down to zero just by increasing the InAs QW width [83]. In order to emphasize this feature of the InAs/GaSb system and for the sake of simplicity the term “type-III” was used in [84] for this kind of band alignment instead of habitual “type-II broken gap”. The InAs/GaSb QW structures were proposed for use in light emitting diodes and lasers quite long ago but at that time they were investigated by photoluminescence and electroluminescence only at low temperatures [85,86,87]. Type-III MQW diode lasers with the active zone consisting of thin InAs layers sandwiched between 30-nm-thick GaSb layers have been reported in [83,46]. The thickness of the InAs QWs was varied from 2 to 8 monolayers (MLs) (0.6–2.4 nm), the number of InAs layers being 5 or 12. The MQW region was embedded between undoped GaSb layers providing the total thickness of the active zone of 0.6 µm required for optical confinement. During the growth special shutter sequences were used at each InAs/GaSb interface in order to force the formation of “InSb-like” bonds, as superior optical properties of this kind of interface have been demonstrated [88]. The structures exhibited bright room temperature electroluminescence (EL). The peak emission wavelength of spontaneous EL shifted from 1.95 µm to 3.3–3.4 µm at RT as the InAs QW width increased from 2 to 8 monolayers. The measured peak emission wavelengths are compared in Fig. 16 with theoretical values calculated for radiative transitions between the first quantified electron state in the InAs QW and hole state located close to the GaSb valence band extremum. The stimulated emission was obtained at 80 K at 1.78–2.85 µm, the threshold current density increasing from 130 A/cm2 to 1.2 kA/cm2 with the InAs
Mid-Infrared 2–5 µm Heterojunction Laser Diodes
19
Fig. 16. Emission wavelength of InAs/GaSb quantum well structures versus QW width [84]
Fig. 17. Spontaneous and stimulated emission spectra of structures with different width of InAs/GaSb quantum wells: 1–0.6 nm, 2–1.2 nm, 3–2.4 nm [84]
QW width. The five QW structures demonstrated higher threshold current densities than the twelve QW ones. For structures with the thickest QWs, laser action was observed only on the twelve QW devices. Lasing at room temperature was achieved on twelve QW structures containing 0.6- and 1.2nm-thick quantum wells, threshold current densities for 500-µm-long devices being 1.8 and 7.9 kA/cm2 , respectively (Fig. 17). The observed evolution of laser characteristics was attributed to the change in the wave function overlap decreasing with the InAs QW width and to the small gain by QW in type-III structures. For the 0.6-nm-thick QW structure, the characteristic temperature T0 , was 90 K near RT. The peak output power of lasers fabricated from this wafer reached 200 mW, the external quantum efficiency being 25–30 %. In InAs/GaSb QW structures the potential barrier for hole tunneling to the InAs QW is very high compared with the GaInAsSb/GaSb structures discussed above. The wave function overlap, and thus the efficiency of indirect radiative recombination, depends mainly on the position of the electron quantum level. In thin InAs quantum wells the electron level lies close to the conduction band of GaSb providing with electrostatic interaction strong wavefunction overlap. The structures with 2–3-monolayer thick InAs quan-
20
Andr´e Joulli´e et al.
tum wells and barriers made with a smaller bad gap material like GaInAsSb have been proposed to achieve RT lasing near 3 µm. The carrier confinement in the GaInAsSb quantum wells can be improved by use of GaAl(As)Sb instead of GaSb in the barriers. The valence band offset ∆ Ev for the type-I interfaces GaSb/Ga1−x Alx Sb has been calculated in [89] following the common anion rule: ∆ Ev (x) = 0.42x − 0.04x(1 − x) ≈ 0.41x (in eV) .
(6)
The relationship (7) has been proposed in [90] for the valence band offset between GaSb and the lattice matched Ga1−x Alx SbAs alloy: ∆ Ev (x) = 0.48x (in eV) .
(7)
In order to find the valence band offset in GaInAsSb/GaAl(As)Sb quantum wells the values calculated from (6) or (7) should be added to ∆ Ev in the GaInAsSb/GaSb system presented in Figs. 11, 12, and 14. Estimations made on this basis show that type-I GaInAsSb/GaAl(As)Sb quantum wells providing emission at wavelengths up to ≈ 3 µm can be realized. 4.2
Fabrication of Antimonide Quantum Well Laser Diodes
The GaSb based QW laser structures are usually grown on (100)-oriented nGaSb substrates in solid source MBE systems. As a rule, the MBE machines are equipped with a valved arsenic cracking source producing As2 molecules, which provides better control of relatively small As amounts in the epitaxial layers than As4 cells. On the other hand, both Sb2 and Sb4 sources were successfully employed to grow high quality laser structures. Beryllium is used for p-type doping of the antimonide materials and Te-doped n-type layers are grown with GaTe or Sb2 Te3 sources. The growth temperatures are in the range of 420–480 ◦C but sometimes the first GaAlAsSb cladding layer is grown at 500–530 ◦C. A typical GaSb based QW structure is shown in Fig. 18 [91]. The active zone contains 1–5 GaInAsSb quantum wells and 20–30 nm thick GaAlAsSb barriers, sandwiched between GaAlAsSb spacers (SCH layers in Fig. 18) of the same composition. The QW thickness varies in the 6–20 nm range, 10 nm being the most popular value. The Al concentration in these layers lattice matched with the substrate varied from 0.25 to 0.4 but lasers with GaSb barriers have also been reported [46,72,82,92,93,94,95]. The active zone is usually undoped and is of weak p-type (p = (1 − 5) × 1016 cm−3 ) due to the native acceptors in GaSb based materials. The Al fraction in GaAlAsSb cladding layers is greater than in the barriers in order to provide electrical and optical confinement; its value is usually 0.8–0.9 in the structures with an active zone based on the quaternary alloy and 0.55–0.6 in the type-II structures with GaSb barriers. The graded gap regions before the first cladding layer and after the second one (Fig. 18) serve to reduce the series resistance
Mid-Infrared 2–5 µm Heterojunction Laser Diodes
21
Fig. 18. Energy band diagram of a GaAlAsSb/GaInAsSb/GaSb laser structure, after [91]
due to the high potential barriers at these interfaces. The growth of the structures is started with an n-GaSb buffer layer and ended with a heavily doped p-GaSb contact layer. The GaInAsSb solid solutions are not miscible in the entire range of their compositions because the sizes of the constituent atoms differ considerably. As a consequence, a solid phase miscibility gap exists in this system at temperatures used for MBE growth (Fig. 19). The stable region in the alloy composition plane is limited by the binodal curves. In this region, the solid phase decomposition can take place without surmounting an activation barrier. In the region between the binodal and spinodal curves, an energy barrier retards the decomposition and the solid is metastable [96]. Calculated spinodal isotherms for GaInAsSb solid solutions are shown in Fig. 19. In most MBE grown GaInAsSb QW laser structures, stable alloys with low As concentrations have been employed. It is necessary to note that the consideration used often to calculate the miscibility gap [96] concerns the solid in thermodynamic equilibrium. The real MBE epitaxial growth conditions may be far away from the equilibrium favoring formation of the unstable alloy. Besides, once the solid is formed, the decomposition process can be largely prevented by the presence of an energy barrier related to the strain produced by forming a lattice-mismatched second phase in a single crystalline alloy [97,98]. For these reasons both metastable and unstable materials can be grown using MBE or MOVPE. However, the metastable nature of the solid leads to clustering of like constituents and/or ordering of the large and small atoms in a planar geometric arrangement. These phenomena lead to major changes in the properties of the semiconductor alloys, which depends significantly on the growth conditions [97]. The Ga0.46 In0.54 Sb0.52 As0.48 alloy
22
Andr´e Joulli´e et al.
Fig. 19. Spinodal isotherms for (solid curves). Gax In1−x As1−y Sby Straight line designates the separation direction. Dashed lines represent compositions for lattice-matching to GaSb (a), InAs (b) and InP (c), after [96]
lattice matched with GaSb having the composition lying in the center of the miscibility gap has been successfully used in double heterostructure diode lasers emitting near 3 µm up to 255 K in the pulsed regime and up to 170 K in CW mode [48]. The metastable GaInAsSb solid solutions have also been employed in high performance QW lasers [48,95]. The majority of results on antimonide QW lasers reported to date have been obtained on devices with cleaved Fabry–P´erot resonators. The cleaved facets are often coated for high reflection (> 95 %) on the backside and for partial antireflection (3 %) on the front facet in order to increase the singleended output power and to protect the AlSb based claddings against oxidation. The ridge waveguide geometry is used to produce single mode and single frequency lasers (Fig. 20, [99]). To obtain a single mode waveguide the ridge must be narrow (5–10 µm) and the etch depth should be carefully controlled. Too deep etching favors lateral waveguide modes and shallow etching increases the device threshold because of the current spreading. Lasers designed for high power emission are wide (100–200 µm) in order to improve heat removal by the laser heatsink.
Fig. 20. Schematic of a GaSb-based single-frequency ridge waveguide laser, after [99]
Mid-Infrared 2–5 µm Heterojunction Laser Diodes
23
4.3 Antimonide QW Laser Diodes for the 2.0–2.3 µm Spectral Range Antimonide lasers emitting between 2 and 2.3 µm can be realized on the basis of type-I GaInAsSb quantum wells with large conduction and valence band offsets. The wells can be made of the alloy in the region of stable compositions and its quality is less sensitive to the MBE growth conditions. The first MBE grown GaSb based QW lasers were reported by Choi and Eglash in 1992 [43]. The active zone of the structure consisted of five 10 nm thick Ga0.84 In0.16 Sb0.86 As0.14 quantum wells and six 20 nm thick Ga0.8 In0.2 As0.02 Sb0.98 barriers. Broad stripe lasers 100 µm wide with uncoated facets were fabricated from the grown wafer. They emitted near 2.1 µm with the threshold current density as low as 260 A/cm2 for 2-mm-long lasers and differential quantum efficiency of 70 % for devices 300 µm long. The lasers operated at up to 150 ◦ C in the pulsed regime and their characteristic temperature T0 was 113 K near RT. The maximum output power in the CW regime at 20 ◦ C reached 190 mW/facet with the initial slope efficiency of 0.1 W/A. Large lasers emit in several spatial modes and in multiple frequencies (longitudinal modes), which makes them unsuitable for molecular spectroscopy. The 8-µm-wide ridge waveguide (Fig. 20) single frequency lasers have been fabricated from the same wafer [99]. The threshold current was as low as 29 mA for the lasers 300 µm long. The maximum output power in the coated facets diodes reached 28 mW/facet with the initial slope of the light-current curves corresponding to the quantum efficiency of 23 %. The lasers exhibited single frequency emission at 2.135 µm with the side mode suppression ratio (SMSR) of 20 dB. In the structure reported in [43,99] the thickness of the active zone (0.17 µm) is comparable with the total thickness of the QWs. In such a waveguide the main part of the lasing mode propagates in the doped cladding layers, where free carrier absorption losses are considerable. Free carrier absorption increases with wavelength, and the effect of the cladding layer loss becomes stronger in long wavelength lasers. Separate confinement heterostructures (SCH) with a broadened waveguide were proposed in [91] in order to decrease internal losses in long wavelength QW lasers. In these structures the region containing the QWs is surrounded with SCH layers (spacers) thus increasing the thickness of the waveguide and decreasing the part of the lasing mode propagating in the cladding layers (Fig. 18). Three laser structures emitting near 2 µm at RT with different waveguide thickness were investigated. The threshold current densities for 2-mm-long facet coated devices were in the range of 260–400 A/cm2 . The internal loss was found to decrease from 32 cm−1 to 2 cm−1 in the structures where the total waveguide thickness W was increased from 0.12 to 0.88 µm. The part of the light propagating in the cladding layers drops from 40 % to 4 % in this series of structures while the QW confinement factor is nearly constant (5–9 %) because the mode intensity in the center of the waveguide, where the QWs are located, does not
24
Andr´e Joulli´e et al.
change significantly. A maximum output power of 1.2 W and a maximum CW efficiency of 36 % were observed for a 100-µm-wide and 2-mm-long laser which had the broadest waveguide. The maximum output power and differential quantum efficiency were lower in the structures with thinner waveguide (Fig. 21). In the single quantum well (SQW) structure with an 0.8-µm-thick waveguide the threshold current density was reduced to 115 A/cm2 for uncoated lasers with 2–3 mm cavity lengths [100,101]. These lasers exhibited a CW output power of 1.9 W, a differential quantum efficiency of 53 %, and a QCW output power of 4 W (Fig. 22). Broadened waveguide GaInAsSb/GaAlAsSb SQW lasers with the threshold current density as low as 50 A/cm2 for 3-mm-long devices have been reported in [102,103]. In this structure the strain in the QW was increased to 1.4 %, using the alloy with the In fraction of 0.22, instead of 1 % in the QWs with xIn = 0.19 employed in [91,100,101]. These lasers had emission wavelengths of ≈ 2.05 µm, characteristic temperature of 65 K, internal quantum efficiency of 95 %, and internal loss coefficient of 7 cm−1 . A single ended CW power of 1 W has been obtained for a 100 µm aperture and the maximum power efficiency was 22.5 %. Linear arrays of tapered lasers operating with 1 ms current pulses have been fabricated from the same wafer [104]. Peak power over 3 W was obtained for nine-element arrays at 18.5 A. Up to 1.7 W peak power, within a 65 mrad full angle cone, was measured in the far field using anamorphic collimating lens arrays, fabricated by mass transport in GaP. The efficiency of the carrier confinement in the active zone defined by band offsets between quantum wells and barriers influences considerably the laser performance. The band offsets can be tuned by the QW composition and strain and the composition of barrier layers. GaInAsSb/GaAlAsSb QW lasers with increased Al concentration in the barriers have been reported
Fig. 21. The CW output power characteristics for 2 mm cavity length, coated lasers with different waveguide thicknesses W , emitting at 2 µm, after [91,101]
Mid-Infrared 2–5 µm Heterojunction Laser Diodes
25
Fig. 22. Output power characteristics of a 2 µm GaAlAsSb/GaInAsSb SCH SQW broadened waveguide facet coated laser with 2 mm cavity and 200 µm aperture: (a) CW regime at 15 ◦ C; (b) QCW regime at 10 ◦ C with 100 µs pulse duration and 100 Hz repetition rate, after [100,101]
in [105,106]. The 0.924-µm-thick active zone of the structures contained two or four strained Ga0.85 In0.15 Sb0.94 As0.06 wells 10.5 nm wide separated by 18-nm-thick barriers with Al fraction of 0.4 compared with xAl = 0.25 in [91,100,101,102,103]. The change in the Al concentration deepens ∆ Ev by about 70 meV up to 154 meV. Threshold current densities for a 2060-µmlong 2-QW laser and 1730-µm-long 4-QW devices were 174 and 225 A/cm2 , respectively. A differential quantum efficiency of 74 % was observed for a 900µm-long 2-QW laser and a characteristic temperature of 140 K was measured
26
Andr´e Joulli´e et al.
for a 4-QW device in the pulsed regime. The improvement of these parameters has been explained by the increased valence band offset. GaInAsSb/GaAlAsSb QW lasers emitting at 2.26 µm near RT have been reported in [107,108,109]. To achieve this emission wavelength the In concentration in 10-nm-thick QWs was increased to xIn = 0.3, the As fraction being yAs = 0.06. The threshold current density for 2-mm-long lasers at 280 K was as low as 100 and 200 A/cm2 for the structures with one and three quantum wells (TQW), respectively. The characteristic temperature of the threshold current was 110 K. Single-ended output powers of 240 mW [107] and 350 mW [109] in the CW regime were obtained for 64-µm-wide TQW lasers with coated facets at 280 K. Single frequency operation required for spectroscopy applications can be achieved in narrow ridge Fabry–P´erot lasers [99] but DFB lasers provide better noise characteristics and a high side mode suppression ratio which is less sensitive to driving conditions, i.e. laser current and temperature. Usually DBF is obtained by a grating, which is patterned with the period of the Bragg wavelength in the laser waveguide. After the patterning the epitaxy is continued in order to complete the laser structure. For InP based lasers the overgrowth technique is well established. For GaSb based DFB lasers complications arise as Al-containing layers are used in the cladding layers of the waveguide. Because of the reactivity of the Al with oxygen high quality overgrowth is very difficult. Gain coupled GaInSb/GaAlAsSb QW DFB lasers fabricated without regrowth have been reported in [110]. In these lasers single frequency DFB emission was obtained by a first-order chromium Bragg grating with a period of 273.4–269.4 nm on both sides of the 4-µm-wide laser ridge. The Bragg grating acts as a periodic absorber for the evanescent part of the laser mode and thereby provides gain coupling. For lasers with 900 µm length threshold currents were around 20 mA and the maximum CW output power was 10 mW at 20 ◦ C. The lasers exhibited single frequency emission near 2 µm with SMSR of 31 dB (Fig. 23). In Fig. 24 the DFB emission wavelength versus temperature is compared with the data obtained on a reference Fabry–P´erot laser without grating. The wavelength shift with increasing temperature is 0.20 nm/K for the DFB mode, while it is 1.22 nm/K for the Fabry–P´erot mode. The fast shift of the Fabry–P´erot emission reflects the temperature dependence of the band gap. For DFB lasers the emission wavelength is less dependent on the temperature as the mode is predominantly determined by the refractive index. Another type of semiconductor laser, which easily provides single frequency emission, is a vertical cavity surface emitting laser (VCSEL). In a VCSEL light propagates vertically rather than laterally through the structure consisting of an active zone embedded between distributed Bragg reflectors (DBRs). With such a small cavity, the gain bandwidth of the device can only support a single longitudinal mode. The very high difference in refractive indexes of GaSb and AlSb permits one to fabricate high qual-
Mid-Infrared 2–5 µm Heterojunction Laser Diodes
27
Fig. 23. Spectrum of a laterally coupled DFB laser under CW operation. The cavity length is 900 µm and the facets are ascleaved, after [110]
Fig. 24. Temperature variation of laser emission wavelength for a laterally coupled DFB laser with 900 µm cavity length, after [110]
ity DBRs with reflectivity sufficient for VCSEL operation (> 99 %) using less than 20 stacked pairs on the base of these materials. The first electrically pumped VCSEL emitting beyond 1.8 µm has been reported in [111]. The Te-doped bottom and Be-doped top DBRs consisted of 17.5 period and 15 period AlSb0.93 As0.07 − GaSb quarter-wave stacks, respectively. Six 6.5 nm thick Ga0.65 In0.35 Sb0.9 As0.1 quantum wells with 22-nm-thick GaSb barriers were surrounded by 225 nm of GaSb to form a one wavelength long optical cavity. The last p-GaSb quarter-wave layer of the top DBR also served as a contact layer. The 200-µm-diameter VCSELs fabricated from different parts of the wafer emitted between 2.18 and 2.32 µm in the pulsed regime at RT with a threshold current density of 2 kA/cm2 and an output power of 20 mW. Emission spectra of a VCSEL are shown in Fig. 25. In the spontaneous regime the VCSELs emitted up to 1 mW of continuous optical power concentrated in a spectral band as narrow as 10 nm.
28
Andr´e Joulli´e et al.
Fig. 25. RT spontaneous and lasing emission spectra of a GaSbbased VCSEL [110]. (a) spontaneous spectrum measured from the edge of the device (b) spontaneous spectrum measured from the surface (c) lasing emission spectrum measured from the surface. Driving conditions: (a,b) repetition rate: 20 kHz, pulse width: 20 µs (c) repetition rate: 10 kHz, pulse width: 1 µs
4.4
GaInAsSb QW Laser Diodes Emitting beyond 2.3 µm
A series of RT lasers emitting beyond 2.3 µm based on type-II GaInAsSb/ GaSb QW structures has been reported in [46,72,82,92,93,94,95]. The initial structure [71,82] contained five 7-nm-thick Ga0.65 In0.35 Sb0.85 As0.15 quantum wells between 30-nm-thick GaSb barriers, the total thickness of the active zone being 0.3 µm. The wells and the barriers had a type-II band alignment with a valence band offset ∆ Ev of −60 meV (the heavy hole subband for the QW) and a conduction band offset ∆ Ec = 350 meV. The 200-µm-wide lasers emitted between 2.35 and 2.39 µm with a threshold current density of 305 A/cm2 for 820-µm-long devices at 23 ◦ C and T0 = 55 K. Ridge waveguide 8-µm-wide lasers operating in the CW regime at RT were fabricated from a similar wafer [94]. The lasers had threshold currents in the range 60–140 mA and emitted 2–5 mW/facet of optical power in the range 2.34–2.4 µm. Employing a broadened 0.8-µm-thick waveguide and an optimized QW growth procedure internal losses were reduced from 17 to 7.8 cm−1 and the laser performances were considerably improved [95]. The 10 µm ridge lasers operated in the CW regime up to 50 ◦ C with an output power of 20 mW/facet at RT. The internal quantum efficiency was found to be 89 % and the power
Mid-Infrared 2–5 µm Heterojunction Laser Diodes
29
efficiency reached 20 %. The lasers exhibited single frequency operation in a large range of currents and temperatures. The side mode suppression ratio reached 30 dB (Fig. 26) and was nearly constant between longitudinal mode hops. Hysteresis was observed in the lasing wavelength versus current characteristics (Fig. 27), which indicated autostabilization of the main mode. The high SMSR, comparable with that of DFB lasers, and the observed autostabilization of the lasing mode have been explained by the photorefractive effect due to DX centers in the Te-doped Ga0.4 Al0.6 Sb0.95 As0.05 cladding layer acting as a periodic saturable absorber. The 2.3 µm laser performances have been further improved by using the Ga0.65 Al0.35 Sb0.98 As0.02 alloy in the waveguide instead of GaSb [48,112]. The 0.8-µm-thick active zone consisted of three 10-nm-thick type-I GaInAsSb quantum wells of nearly the same composition, xIn = 0.35, yAs = 0.16, as
Fig. 26. Emission spectrum of a type-II GaInAsSb/GaSb QW laser measured at 10 ◦ C [95]
Fig. 27. Laser emission wavelength versus current (same laser as in Fig. 26) [95]
30
Andr´e Joulli´e et al.
in [95], the Al concentration in cladding layers being increased to xAl = 0.9. Narrow ridge 5-µm-wide Fabry–P´erot diodes with uncoated facets were soldered epi-side down onto copper heatsinks with a lead–tin alloy. At 22 ◦ C and in the CW regime the threshold current was as low as 20 mA for 440-µm long devices increasing to 55 mA for a length of 2.5 mm. The maximum output power reached 45 mW/facet and was limited by catastrophic degradation of the uncoated facets at an optical power density of the order of 1 MW/cm2 . The devices operated in the CW regime at temperatures up to 140 ◦ C (Fig. 28) and up to 180 ◦C in the pulsed regime (1 µs, 10 kHz) despite the high thermal resistance of these narrow ridge devices with non-optimized heatsinks. The threshold current increased very slowly with temperature, the characteristic temperature T0 being as high as 110–130 K near RT and 60– 80 K at 100 ◦C in the CW regime. The differential quantum efficiency also varied slowly with temperature. Its near threshold value decreased from 50– 75 % at RT to 35–50 % at 100 ◦ C depending on the cavity length. The internal quantum efficiency and internal losses were found to be 90 % and 8 cm−1 , respectively [112]. The emission wavelength shifted with temperature from 2.25 µm at RT to 2.43 µm at 135 ◦ C in the CW regime and single frequency operation could be obtained with a side mode suppression ratio up to 20 dB (Fig. 29). The autostabilization of the lasing mode was not observed in these devices, which is due probably to smaller concentration and activation energy of DX-centers in the Te-doped GaAlAsSb alloy with higher Al content [113]. The emission wavelength of the type-II lasers with GaSb barriers was increased to 2.65 µm by use of the Ga0.5 In0.5 Sb0.78 As0.22 alloy in the 7-nmthick wells [46,93]. A pulsed threshold current density of 1.5 kA/cm2 with a characteristic temperature T0 = 45 K has been obtained for 80-µm-wide devices. Total peak output power reached 130 mW with a differential quantum efficiency of 14 %. The internal quantum efficiency and the internal loss were found to be 33 % and 62 cm−1 , respectively. The high internal loss was
Fig. 28. Output power characteristics of a 680-µm-long GaInAsSb/ GaAlAsSb QW ridge waveguide laser at different temperatures [112]
Mid-Infrared 2–5 µm Heterojunction Laser Diodes
31
Fig. 29. Emission spectra of a GaInAsSb/GaAlAsSb QW ridge waveguide laser at different temperatures [112]
explained by strong free carrier absorption in the cladding layers for this quite narrow, 0.35-µm-thick, waveguide. GaInAsSb/GaAlAsSb QW lasers emitting at 2.78 µm have been reported in [45]. This long emission wavelength was obtained with relatively small concentrations of In and As in four 10-nm-thick quantum wells, xIn = 0.24 and yAs = 0.16, respectively. Pulsed laser operation of stripe lasers 22 µm wide was obtained at 15 ◦ C with a threshold current density of 10 kA/cm2 , maximum power output of 30 mW, and a maximum differential quantum efficiency of 9 %. The lasers operated pulsed up to 60 ◦ C with a characteristic temperature of 58 K over the range of 0–40 ◦C. The same devices exhibited CW operation up to 234 K emitting at 2.7 µm at this temperature with an output power of 1 mW and a differential quantum efficiency of 0.6 % [114]. GaInAsSb/GaAlAsSb double QW lasers operating between 2.3 and 2.7 µm at RT were studied in [115,116,117,118]. The laser structures contained two Ga1−x Inx Sb0.98 As0.02 quantum wells, Ga0.7 Al0.3 Sb0.98 As0.02 barriers and spacers in an undoped 0.8-µm-thick active zone. The In content in the 10–20 nm-thick wells varied from 0.25 to 0.4 while the As concentration was fixed at the low level in order to keep the well composition outside the miscibility gap. The compressive strain in the QWs increased from 1.5 % to 2.3 % with increasing In fraction. Gain guided Fabry–P´erot lasers with 100µm-wide stripe contacts and 1 or 2 mm cavity lengths were characterized. The devices were mounted epi-side down onto water cooled copper heatsinks. The laser emission wavelength shifted from 2.3 to 2.7 µm with increasing In concentration in the wells. All the devices were able to operate in the CW regime at RT. Figure 30 shows differential quantum efficiency (ηd ) and the threshold current density (Jth ) for 2-mm-long diodes emitting at different wavelengths. The threshold current density in the pulsed regime increased only slightly, from 230 to 300 A/cm2 , while the wavelength increased from 2.3 to 2.6 µm. Corresponding values of ηd were independent of wavelength between 2.3 and
32
Andr´e Joulli´e et al.
Fig. 30. Threshold current densities (pulsed and CW) and differential efficiencies (pulsed) for lasers of different wavelength. For uncoated lasers (2.6 and 2.7 µm), the measured values of efficiencies were doubled to account for light emission from both facets, after [4]
Fig. 31. CW output power characteristics for three diode lasers of different wavelength. For 2.6 µm diode lasers, the measured values were doubled to account for light emission from both facets, after [4]
2.6 µm and close to 30 % for all 2-mm-long devices. Figure 31 shows CW output powers of 500, 250, and 160 mW that were obtained for lasers emitting at 2.3, 2.5 and 2.6 µm, respectively. The characteristic temperature T0 near RT decreased with wavelength from 90–100 K for 2.3 µm lasers to 30–40 K for 2.7 µm devices and the upper limit of CW operation decreased from about 100 ◦ C to 30–40 ◦C in the same range. Despite much longer emission wavelengths, antimonide QW lasers emitting between 2 and 2.7 µm exhibit excellent performances comparable or even superior to those of telecommunications lasers benefiting from well established growth and processing techniques of InP based materials. Their remarkable thermal stability (CW operation up to 140 ◦C, CW T0 of 130 K at 2.3 µm and pulsed T0 of 140 K at 2.0 µm) is due to better electron confinement in GaInAsSb/GaAlAsSb quantum wells possessing high band offsets, which reduces carrier leakage at elevated temperatures. The strained GaInAsSb/GaAlAsSb material system renders a high degree of freedom in
Mid-Infrared 2–5 µm Heterojunction Laser Diodes
33
band engineering of QW structures. By varying the QW and barrier composition the same emission wavelength can be obtained from the wells with different band offsets in the conduction and in the valence band. Analysis of the obtained results allows one to conclude that strong confinement of one sort of carriers (electrons) is more advantageous than moderate confinement of both electrons and holes. The Coulomb attraction prevents current leakage from the QW in the structures with low confinement barriers for one type of carriers and provides efficient recombination even in type-II structures where the holes are located outside of the QW. The less impressive temperature behavior of type-II GaInAsSb/GaSb lasers is due to weak confinement of electrons in the wells with GaSb barriers rather than to absence of hole confinement without injection. The performances of lasers employing unstable GaInAsSb alloys in the quantum wells show the high quality of these MBE grown materials, at least at the small penetration into the miscibility gap. The disadvantage of antimonide laser diodes compared with InP based devices is the use of easily oxidizing high Al content GaAlAsSb cladding layers, which causes rapid degradation of the lasers. This problem can be solved by coating the laser facets and/or encapsulation of the devices in the inert gas environment. The ageing test of a GaInAsSb/GaAlAsSb ridge waveguide laser [48] which is in progress at the Montpellier University (France) shows no significant degradation of the diode with uncoated facets encapsulated in a housing filled with dry nitrogen for more than 13 000 h. 4.5 Characterization of Antimonide-Based Laser Diodes Dedicated to Gas Detection Antimonide-based semiconductor lasers are well adapted to gas detection in the atmosphere. Their emission window, between 2 and 2.8 µm, is centered on a vapor window [119] (at 2.3 µm) where many pollutant gases present absorption lines (Fig. 1). Gas detection requires two main conditions from laser diodes: single frequency emission and tuning. Gas detection with multimode laser diodes is of course possible but it presents more difficulties for the identification of the line and the calibration of the measure. In order to realize a more correct measure, laser diodes without pure single frequency emission suppose the use of a monochromator to select a mode, which makes the optical setup more complicated [120]. The tuning is the property of the laser to exhibit a variation of the emitted wavelength function of injected current or operating temperature. This tuning must be obtained at least for a few GHz to be able to perform gas detection at atmospheric pressure. Gas detection at low pressures (< 50 Torr) requires less tuning, but is more demanding about the spectral width of laser diodes which has to be smaller than the HWHM of the detected line. Of course, industrial applications require a significant lifetime (more than 10 000 h) from the devices.
34
Andr´e Joulli´e et al.
4.5.1 Laser Diode Characterization for Gas Detection Applications The results presented here have been obtained on type-I [49] and type-II [48] strained quantum well laser diodes. These devices exhibited single mode or multimode emission, a function of the injected current and/or the laser temperature. To select a diode for a specified application, it is necessary to know which are its operating conditions. A classical way is to measure the emission spectra at different currents or temperatures in order to build a mode map. Figure 32 shows a typical mode map realized for two lasers. These data give information about the emitted wavelength, the spectral purity and the tuning, but the main drawback is that it takes a long time to acquire. New methods have to be developed to characterize the laser diodes for gas analysis. Fabry–P´erot interferometers are widely used in Tunable Diode Laser Absorption Spectroscopy (TDLAS) to calibrate the tuning of light sources and identify the absorption lines [121]. The interference figure given by the emitted light through such an interferometer depends on the spectral purity of the beam. Figure 33 shows the data for a type-I laser diode maintained at 67 ◦ C, recorded using a bulk germanium interferometer of 2.3 GHz FSR and 2380 Gain tuneability 1 nm/K
20°C CW
2.28
Mode tuneability 0.1 nm/K
2370
III II
I
2.24
Lambda (nm)
Lambda (µm)
IV 2.26
2360
2.22
2350 2.20 30
40
50
60
70
I (mA)
(a)
80
90
100
0
5
10
15
20
25
Temperature (°C)
(b)
Fig. 32. (a) Mode-map realized CW from 30 to 100 mA of a type-I GaInAsSb/AlGaAsSb QW laser diode emitting around 2.27 µm at a fixed temperature (Tlaser = 20 ◦ C). Emitted power is represented in a log scale. One can see four zones: I–Multimode emission; II–Mode hopping area; III–Monomode emission in a large current range giving a 2 cm−1 continuous tuning; IV–Multimode emission. (b) Mode-map of a type II GaInAsSb/GaSb QW laser diode around 2.3 µm as a function of temperature. The gain tunability changes 10 times faster than longitudinal mode tunability
Mid-Infrared 2–5 µm Heterojunction Laser Diodes T = 67°C CW
35
4 3
P(a.u.)
2
1
0
20
40
60
80
100
I(mA)
Fig. 33. Single acquisition of a Fabry–P´erot cartography of a type-I GaInAsSb/ AlGaAsSb QW laser diode realized at 67 ◦ C. One can see four zones. Zone (1) is before lasing, no light is emitted, the laser threshold is 41 mA. (2) and (4) zones show well-contrasted oscillations: the emission is single-frequency. (3) shows nocontrasted oscillations: the emission is multimode 200
Multi frequency
180
Single frequency
160 140 I(mA)
120 100 80 60
Threshold current
40 Spontaneous emission
20 0 14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
T(°C)
Fig. 34. Fabry–P´erot mode-map in the current/temperature space for a type I GaInAsSb/AlGaAsSb QW laser diode. The threshold current is materialized by a white line from 75 mA at 14 ◦ C to 80 mA at 22 ◦ C and correspond to a T0 of 160 K in this temperature range. Dark areas show multimode emission and clear areas show single-frequency emission
a GaInAs photodiode. Because the data are difficult to extract, a numerical recipe is necessary for giving a constant value function of the spectral purity of the emission. By acquiring such data at different temperatures, one can build a Fabry–P´erot cartography (Fig. 34) which gives a convenient way to characterize the spectral quality of the laser [122]. To perform gas detection, it is important to know if a laser diode is suitable to detect a specific species. Keeping the idea of cartography from
36
Andr´e Joulli´e et al. 100
80
I(mA)
60
40
20
0 15
16
17
18
19
20
T(°C)
21
22
23
24
25
Fig. 35. Map in the temperature/current space of the absorption of a type-I laser diode emitting around 2.28 µm. This map has been realized with a tiny calibrated cell containing pure CH4 for a 10 mm-length. The threshold current varies from 40 mA at 15 ◦ C to 45 mA at 25 ◦ C
Fabry–P´erot maps, absorption cartography has been developed. In this procedure, a laser diode is tuned by a current ramp at different temperatures. The emitted laser beam is detected after passing through a gas cell containing a calibrated molecular species. Gas detection is very sensible when realized on a strong absorption line. An example of absorption cartography is given in Fig. 35. In the map, strong absorption lines appear as white lines. The absorption lines are iso-energy lines (at constant wavelength): that gives precious information to localize strong absorption lines and to know how to compensate the temperature effect by the current to follow a given line. Such cartographies can be made for different gas species in order to evaluate if the tested diode is adapted to a gas or another one. These new methods are of great interest for testing and selecting laser diodes for gas analysis. They are all based on the tuning property of the laser diodes. 4.5.2
Tuning Properties of Antimonide-Based Laser Diodes
For a laser cavity of length L, the wavelength λ of the longitudinal mode m is given by: λ=
2nL . m
(8)
The real refractive index n[T, N (T )] is sensitive to the temperature T and to the carrier density N . The carrier density is quasi-constant above the threshold N ≈ Nth but it is temperature dependent. Therefore, the sensitivity of the refractive index to a change of the junction temperature can be given by: ∂n ∂n dN ∆ = + × × ∆T . (9) ∂T ∂N dT
Mid-Infrared 2–5 µm Heterojunction Laser Diodes
37
From the plasma effect, a change ∆ N of the carrier density induces an adjustment ∆ n of the refractive index given by [123]: r0 λ2 m0 ∆ = ∆N , (10) 2πn me where r0 and m0 are, respectively, the radius and the mass of a free electron and me is the effective mass of the carrier. The temperature dependence of the threshold current can be fitted in a small temperature range by the experimental Pankove law Jth = J0 exp TT0 2 = kNth . By differentiation and with Nth ≈ N at threshold, one obtains:
dN N = . dT 2T0
(11)
As the temperature expansion of the laser length L is negligible compared to the other variations, the temperature tunability of a laser diode is: λ dn r0 λ2 m0 N ∆λ = − . (12) ∆T n dT 2πn me 2T0 One can note that for very low characteristic temperature T0 , it is possible to observe a blue shift of the wavelength. This effect has been previously observed by Baranov et al. on InGaAs QW lasers grown by OMCVD on InAs having a very low characteristic temperature (T0 = 21 K) and emitting around 2.6 µm [124]. As expected in GaInAsSb QW lasers, high values of T0 give a red shift and the first term in the bracket is the most important. The tunability by the current is: ∆λ ∆T ∆λ = . ∆I ∆T ∆I
(13)
T In order to obtain ∆ ∆ I , two experimental techniques can be used. The first one consists in the measurement of the thermal resistance RTh as defined by:
T (I) = RTh PTh (I) ,
(14)
where T (I) is the junction temperature for the injected current I and PTh (I) the thermal power. T (I) can be measured from CW and pulsed measurements of the emitted optical power Pop (I). One can deduce the thermal power PTh (I) from: PTh (I) = I(Vd + Rs I) − Pop (I) ,
(15)
where Vd is the voltage corner of the laser I(V ) characteristic and Rs the series resistance.
38
Andr´e Joulli´e et al. 2.8 20.5°C 24°C 28.5°C 33°C 40°C 44°C
2.6
'Q/'I (GHz/mA)
2.4 2.2 2.0
50°C 55°C 59.5°C 67.3°C 70.7°C 83.1°C
1.8 1.6 1.4
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
Average current (mA)
Fig. 36. Current tuning of a type-I GaInAsSb/AlGaAsSb QW laser diode for different temperatures measured using a Fabry–P´erot bulk germanium crystal
As Pop (I) = (I − Ith )ηd (I) hν e , by differentiation one obtain: hν hν dηd dT (I) = RTh Vd − ηd (I) − (I − Ith ) + 2Rs I dI e e dI
(16)
which shows that the tuning is independent of the temperature and linear with the injected current. This is clearly shown in Fig. 36 which presents a typical experimental measurement of the tuning of a GaInAsSb QW laser emitting around 2.3 µm. The experimental data are in agreement with the dn = 1.47 × 10−4 K−1 given by Ghosh [125]. model using the value dT By differentiation of λ(T, I), one obtains for ∆ λ = 0: ∆T ∂λ/∂I =− . ∆I ∂λ/∂T
(17)
As seen in Fig. 37, one can obtain ∆ T /∆ I directly in a map of a gas absorption line (∆ λ = 0) in the current temperature space. 4.5.3
Gas Detection with Antimonide-Based Laser Diodes
Antimonide-based laser diodes are well adapted to TDLAS, especially for detecting species like CH4 , NH3 , H2 O, CO, CO2 or HF. Figure 38 gives the optical scheme of an open path gas analysis demonstrator using a GaInAsSb laser device. It is a 30 cm × 30 cm setup, where the detection is based on 2f wavelength modulation spectroscopy. The diode laser emission goes through a mirror objective [126] which makes a focus point of the laser considered as a point source. One of the main interests of such optical scheme is to provide a geometrical focus point from which the whole setup can be designed. It
Mid-Infrared 2–5 µm Heterojunction Laser Diodes
39
80 70
'T = 1,4°C 60
'I = 12,7 mA
I (mA)
50 40 30 20
T0=97K
10 0 16
17
18
19
20
21
T (°C)
Fig. 37. Map of a gas absorption line in the current temperature space. One can easily deduce (∆ T /∆ I) = 110 K/A. The black line gives the evolution of the threshold current versus temperature. For this laser the T0 parameter is 97 K
Fig. 38. “Open path” optical setup used for gas analysis
is also less dependent on chromatic aberrations and absorption than transmission systems. The beam is collimated through a lens to a 200 ˚ A pellicle beam splitter. A large part of the light is transmitted and directed to a corner cube, then it comes back to an off-axis parabolic mirror (F = 110 mm, θ = 26◦ ) and it is focused on a GaInAs detector detecting up to 2.6 µm. The signal recorded by this detector is the “open path signal”. 8 % of the incident light is reflected by the splitter, passes through a reference cell filled with a calibrated pure gaseous species near atmospheric pressure and is focused on the same GaInAs detector by an off-axis parabolic mirror (F = 110 mm, θ = 26◦ ). This signal is the “reference signal”. Comparison by correlation
40
Andr´e Joulli´e et al.
800 700
Output power
600 500 400 300 200 0
100 0
0
20
2000
40 60 I (mA)
4000
80
100
6000
8000
10000
12000
14000
Hours Fig. 39. Time evolution of the emitted power of a laser diode. Working conditions are 65 mA CW at 23 ◦ C. The stability is quite good; the relative variations are due to the influence of ambient temperature on the detector which is not stabilized
of the two signals gives, after calibration, the concentration of the analysed species in the atmosphere. Industrial applications need data about the lifetime of the devices. Figure 39 shows, in arbitrary units, the evolution in time of optical power of a type-I GaInAsSb/AlGaAsSb laser diode emitting around 2.27 µm. This diode was maintained at constant temperature (23 ◦ C) and current (65 mA, or 2Ith ). One can see that the emitted power and P (I) characteristics stay relatively constant in time, without any degradation. This laser diode exhibited 15 500 h of CW working [122].
5
3–5 µm Interband Type-II Laser Diodes
To achieve laser emission in the mid-wavelength infrared region (3–5 µm, a wide variety of Sb-based systems, grown on GaSb or InAs substrates, have been investigated. There are InAsSb/InAsPSb [127] and GaInAsSb/ AlGaAsSb [128] double heterostructure lasers, type-I or type-II quantum well lasers with InAsSb/InAs [129,130,131], InAsSb/InAlAsSbg [132,133], InAsSb/InAsP [134,135] or InSb/AlInSb [136] heterostructures. All these traditional systems have presented excellent performance at low temperatures, but laser emission was limited to 225 K in the pulsed regime (Fig. 8) and to 175 K in the CW regime (Fig. 9) [133]. To improve the
Mid-Infrared 2–5 µm Heterojunction Laser Diodes
41
maximum temperature of operation Tmax , a new laser design has been proposed based on interband type-II broken gap InAs/GaInSb/InAs “W” structures [28]. This system presents several advantages. First, the “W” arrangement induces a phase position of the carriers that increases the electron–hole overlap integral and hence the optical matrix elements, giving values comparable to type-I structures. Next, this structure keeps the advantages of type-II ones like a substantial reduction of Auger recombination [57,60] and internal losses [137], because of the small in-plane electron and hole masses and the elimination of the resonance between the energy gap and the split-off valence band or with any other lower valence subbands. Based on these considerations, interband type-II “W” laser diode seems to be a convenient structure to reach room temperature operation in the mid-infrared wavelength range (3–5 µm). That result was obtained around 3.3 µm at RT in pulsed mode [29], and the laser diodes operated in CW up to 195 K [30]. In this part, we report results of two kinds of non-cascade quantum structures: type-II InAsSb/InAs MQWs grown on InAs substrate and InAs/ GaInSb/InAs “W” structures grown on GaSb substrate. 5.1
InAsSb/InAs Type-II Multi-qantum Well Laser
The InAsSb/InAs system possess a weak type-II band alignment [138,139]. Figure 40 shows the energy-band diagram of the InAs0.92 Sb0.08 /InAs MQW laser structure on an InAs substrate, calculated using a Qc value, the ratio of the strained conduction band-offset to the band gap difference between
Fig. 40. Band diagram of the type-II InAs0.92 Sb0.08 /InAs MQW structure on InAs substrate. On the lower part, fundamental electron (e1 ) and heavy hole (hh1 ) presence probability densities are reported. The calculated fundamental e1 −hh1 optical transition is 3.41 µm at 80 K and 3.86 µm at RT. The overlap wavefunction |fe1 |fhh1 |2 is 42 %, neglecting electrostatic interaction between carriers of opposite charge
42
Andr´e Joulli´e et al.
the strained well and the InAs barrier, equal to 2.30 [139]. This MQW structure is composed by ten 50 ˚ A-thick InAsSb wells and nine 200 ˚ A-thick InAs “barrier” surrounded by 0.5 µm thick InAs waveguide layers to optimize the optical confinement. In Fig. 40, we present only five InAsSb QWs and four InAs barriers for the sake of simplicity. The cladding layers are made from AlAs0.16 Sb0.84 material lattice-matched to InAs, providing good optical and electrical confinement. The electron and heavy hole presence probability densities reported in the lower part of Fig. 40 show that InAsSb quantum wells are not completely decoupled by the 200 ˚ A thick InAs barriers. Consequently, without injection, an important value of the carrier wavefunction overlap |fe1 |fhh1 |2 = 42 % is obtained for this indirect radiative structure. On the other hand, the 2D dimensionality of carrier dispersion energy, which theoretically ensures high differential gain, is not seriously degraded with a first electron miniband of about 6 meV thick. The electron–hole overlap integral increases under injection as a consequence of the Coulomb attraction between the carriers of opposite charges [79]. Such electrostatic interaction generates a modification of the band structure near the type-II heterointerfaces and enhances the optical coupling between electrons and holes. Under typical carrier injection (σ = 1 × 1012 cm−2 ) overlap values as high as 60 % can be obtained, making this type-II structure comparable to a type-I one. In order to evaluate the lasing performances of such type-II structures, the optical gain G(ω) was calculated for different injected carrier densities σ in the active region [140,141]. The optical gain G increases with the injected carrier density σ in the active layer, varying from σ = 0.25 × 1012 cm−2 to σ = 2×1012 cm−2 (Fig. 41). At low temperature (Fig. 41a), it is easy to induce gain because the difference between electron and hole quasi-Fermi energies (Efc − Efv ) reaches the energy transition e1 -hh1 from a carrier injection of σ = 0.2 × 1012 cm−2 . On the other hand at RT (Fig. 41b), it is necessary to inject at least σ = 0.70 × 1012 cm−2 to satisfy the Bernard–Duraffourg condition. However, whatever the temperature, the maximum gain Gmax due to the first energy level transition (e1 -hh1 ) increases with the injected carrier v ) with σ. density like the variation of the Fermi–Dirac distribution (fnc − fm To achieve laser emission, it is necessary to satisfy the following condition: Gmod = αtotal ((3) in Sect. 3.2.1), where Gmod is the modal gain of the structure (the useful part of the gain) and αtotal the total optical losses. The modal gain is obtained from the relation: Gmod = Np Γp Gmax , where Gmax is the peak gain value extracted from the gain curves (Fig. 41), Np is the number of QW periods (Np = 10) and Γp is the optical confinement factor per QW. Γp was found to be 0.33 % for this structure [141]. Figure 42 displays the modal gain versus carrier concentration N3D at T = 100 K and T = 300 K, respectively. The carrier concentration is deduced from the relation N3D = A). σ/Leff where Leff is the effective width of each quantum well (50 ˚
-1
OPTICAL GAIN (cm )
Mid-Infrared 2–5 µm Heterojunction Laser Diodes 1200 1100 1000 900 800 700 600 500 400 300 200 100 0 -100 200
V = 2.0 x 10
12
-2
cm
43
a)
1.75
T = 100 K
1.5
TE mode
1.25 1.0 0.75 0.5 0.25
250
300
350
400
450
500
550
ENERGY (meV)
400
-1
OPTICAL GAIN (cm )
V = 2.0 x 10
300
T = 300 K
12
-2
cm
b)
1.75
TE mode
1.5
200
1.25 1.0
100
0.75
0 0.5
-100 150
0.25
200
250
300 350 400 ENERGY (meV)
450
500
Fig. 41. Gain spectra versus photon energy in a single InAsSb/InAs MQW structure for different carrier injection densities varying from σ = 0.25 × 1012 cm−2 to σ = 2 × 1012 cm−2 . Calculations are made at T = 100 K (a) and T = 300 K (b), respectively
The maximum modal gain which can be reached at low temperature is 55 cm−1 (N3D = 1 × 1018 cm−3 ) but only 11 cm−1 at RT. It is evident that the InAsSb/InAs MQW laser possesses a too poor modal gain to operate at RT. Two combined effects limit the modal gain value: firstly, it is a consequence of insufficient carrier confinement in the InAsSb well, added to a low confinement factor Γp per well; secondly, there is a restrictive injection value because of the relocation of electrons outside the quantum well when the pseudo-Fermi level Efc reaches the top of the quantum well at high injection from N3D = 1 × 1018 cm−3 . The MQW laser structure was grown on (100) oriented n-InAs substrates in a solid-source MBE system [142]. Mesa-stripe Fabry–P´erot laser diodes were fabricated from these QW structures. The devices exhibited, under the
44
Andr´e Joulli´e et al. 60 55 50
-1
Modal Gain (cm )
45
MQW InAsSb/InAs
T=100 K
10 periods
40 35 30 25 20 15
T=300 K
10 5 0 0,0
TE mode
0,5 1,0 18 -3 N3D (10 cm )
1,5
Fig. 42. Modal gain Gmod versus carrier concentration N3D calculated at T = 100 K and T = 300 K. The MQW active region is composed of ten periods
pulsed regime, laser emission at 3.4–3.5 µm with a maximum operating temperature of 220 K [143]. Figure 43 shows the peak optical power versus current in the pulsed regime at 90 K and the emission spectrum recorded at 200 mA is shown in the inset. The threshold current is 130 mA, corresponding to a threshold current density of 200 mA/cm2 and the initial slope efficiency is 47 mW/A/facet. At low temperature, up to 120 K, the threshold current slowly increases, with a characteristic temperature T0 = 110 K. Above 150 K, it rapidly increases, with T0 = 20 K (Jth = 15 kA/cm2 at T = 220 K). The internal loss coefficient was estimated to be 30 cm−1 and then the total optical loss was around 45 cm−1 . This value confirms the impossibility to operate at RT. In the CW regime, ridge waveguide lasers emitted near 3.5 µm up to 130 K (Fig. 44), with output power efficiency of 40 mW/A/facet at 90 K and a characteristic temperature T0 = 40 K. This conventional MQW structure on an InAs substrate showed excellent performance at low temperature but seriously limited above 220 K. To reduce the threshold current and increase the maximum operation temperature, it is possible to optimize the active region design by using a “W” geometry for laser structures grown on an InAs substrate or a GaSb substrate. That was made in references [144] and [145], where the “W” geometry was obtained from the InAs/InAsSb/InAs/InAlAsSb type-II QW system grown by MBE [144], and from the InAsP/InAsSb/InAsP/InAsPSb type-II QW system grown by MOVPE [145]. Despite excellent results exhibited at 80 K (CW operation with output efficiency of 30–60 mW/A/facet), no improvement of the maximum temperature of operation was observed. Growth problems, arising from the solid phase miscibility gap of the quaternary alloys (InAlAsSb waveguide, In(As)PSb cladding layers), inducing crystal imperfections and
Mid-Infrared 2–5 µm Heterojunction Laser Diodes
45
80
Mesa stripe w = 70 µm L = 900 µm 0.1 µs - 10 kHz
POWER (mW/facet)
70 60 50 40
200 mA
30 20 2,0 2,5 3,0 3,5 4,0 4,5 5,0
10
WAVELENGTH (µm)
0 0,0
0,5
1,0
1,5
2,0
2,5
3,0
CURRENT (A)
Fig. 43. Peak output power versus current for an InAsSb/InAs MQW device having a cavity length of 900 µm, measured at 90 K in the pulsed regime. Inset shows the emission spectrum at 200 mA [143] 100 105 111 116
0,5 CW POWER (mW/facet)
90 K
121 126
0,4 Ridge 10 µm L = 670 µm 0,3
0,2 130 K 0,1
0,0
0
20
40
60 80 100 CURRENT ( mA )
120
140
Fig. 44. CW output power versus current for a ridge laser of length 670 µm, at several temperatures varying from 90 to 130 K [143]
excessive optical losses, have to be solved to obtain the expected increase of Tmax . 5.2
InAs/GaInSb Type-III “W” Laser
InAs/GaInSb heterostructures possess type-III band alignment where electrons and holes are spatially separated. As a consequence, the overlap of the electron and hole wavefunctions is weak, inducing poor radiative efficiency.
46
Andr´e Joulli´e et al.
In order to increase this overlap, a new interband laser design on a GaSb substrate has been proposed by Meyer et al. [28] obtained from band-structure engineering. The designed active region is made of several QW periods, each period including a GaInSb “hole” quantum well sandwiched between a double InAs “electron” quantum well, which forms a conduction band profile in the shape of a “W”. Excellent results have been obtained by the “W” structure design reported in Fig. 45 [29,30]. The active region consisted of five or A)/InAs (15 ˚ A) separated ten W periods of InAs (15 ˚ A)/Ga0.75 In0.25 Sb (27 ˚ by a AlGaAsSb (80 ˚ A) spacer layer. This layer furnishes a two-dimensional dispersion for both electrons and holes with strong confinement in each “W” period. These MQWs are embedded in a 0.6 µm thick AlGaAsSb waveguide layer to maximize the optical confinement factor Γ in the active region, while minimizing free-carrier absorption losses in the cladding layers. The optical cladding layers are made from AlGaAsSb, lattice-matched to GaSb. The fundamental e1 –hh1 optical transition was expected around 3.3 µm at RT. Figure 46 displays the modal gain Gmod versus carrier concentration N3D at T = 100 K and T = 300 K, respectively. Whatever the temperature, comparison with the classical InAsSb/InAs MQW (Fig. 42) shows the superiority of the “W” structure with a Gmod value four times higher. For a reasonable injected carrier concentration N3D = 1×1018 cm−3 , the modal gain can reach 230 cm−1 at T = 100 K and 35 cm−1 at T = 300 K. This last value confirms that the “W” structure can theoretically operate at RT, but only for laser structures having small optical losses with excellent structural quality of the grown layers. Modal gain versus total current density J (3) is shown in Fig. 47. Standard values for Sb-based structures are considered [141]. The non-radiative recombination coefficient A = 108 s−1 can be taken as temperature independent; the radiative coefficient B was taken equal to 7 × 10−11 cm3 /s and AlGaAsSb
GaInSb
conduction band
valence band
InAs InAs 2
I
I = 57 %
fhh1
2
fe1
2
˚)/InAs (15 A ˚)/ Fig. 45. Schematic band diagram of the InAs(15 ˚ A)/GaInSb (27 A AlGaAsSb (80 ˚ A) “W” laser structure. In the lower part, the fundamental electron 2 are reported. (e1 ) and heavy-hole (hh1 ) presence probability densities fe21 and fhh 1 The carrier wavefunction overlap is 57 %
Mid-Infrared 2–5 µm Heterojunction Laser Diodes
47
500 450
W structure
400
T = 100 K
-1
Modal gain (cm )
350 300 250 200 150
T = 300 K
100 50 0 0,0
0,5
1,0
1,5 18
2,0
2,5
3,0
-3
N3D (x 10 cm )
Fig. 46. Modal gain Gmod against injected carrier concentration N3D calculated at T = 100 K and T = 300 K. The active region is composed of ten “W” periods 350
-1
MODAL GAIN (cm )
300
InAs/GaInSb W structure
250
T = 100 K
200 150
T = 300 K
100 50 0
10
100
1k
10k
100k 2
TOTAL CURRENT DENSITY (A/cm )
Fig. 47. Modal gain Gmod versus total current density J (A/cm2 ) calculated at T = 100 K and T = 300 K. The active region is composed of ten “W” periods
4 × 10−11 cm3 /s and the Auger coefficient C, which governs the current, was fixed at C = 5 × 10−29 cm6 /s and C = 5 × 10−27 cm6 /s, at T = 100 K and T = 300 K, respectively. The theoretical results confirm the experimental values reported in [29,30] with a threshold current density of 16 kA/cm2 at 300 K. The laser devices were processed into 100 µm wide stripes. In the pulsed regime (0.2–0.5 µs, 200 Hz), the device, with ten “W” periods, operated up to 310 K. At this temperature, the laser emission was observed at 3.27 µm, the output power was 370 µW and the threshold current density Jth was 25 kA/cm2 . On the contrary, in the continuous regime, the best results were
48
Andr´e Joulli´e et al.
Fig. 48. CW output power versus injected current at 180 K and 195 K, after [30]. The CW spectrum at 195 K, with a minimum resolution of 1 nm and an injection current of 3.5 A, is shown in the inset
obtained with five “W” periods. At 80 K the measured threshold current density was 63 A/cm2 , and the CW output power was 140 mW. The CW lasing performances improve when the number of QWs is kept small to limit the threshold, while in the pulsed regime at higher temperature, the ten-period devices outperformed the five ones because significant gain is needed. CW measurements yielded a maximum operating temperature of 195 K (Fig. 48) with a threshold current density of 1.4 kA/cm2 and a characteristic temperature T0 = 38 K [30]. To date, this result is the highest CW Tmax operation temperature for III–V mid-infrared laser diodes (Fig. 9).
6
Conclusion
Different technologies are in competition for the achievement of mid-infrared 2–5 µm laser diodes operating CW at room temperature: conventional GaInAsSb/AlGaAsSb quantum well lasers, lead salt lasers, intersubband GaInAs/InAlAs quantum cascade lasers, type-II InAsSb/InAs multiquantum well lasers, type-III “W” InAs/GaInSb lasers and interband cascade lasers based on the same system. Impressive results have been obtained in the 2.0–2.3 µm wavelength range from GaInAsSb-AlGaAsSb type-I QW lasers: CW output powers of the order of 1 W/facet at 300 K, threshold current densities of 50–150 A/cm2 , characteristic temperatures T0 higher than 100 K, CW operation up to 140 ◦C, high internal efficiencies (up to 95 %) and extremely small internal loss coefficient (as low as ≈ 2 cm−1 ). Beyond 2.3 µm and up to 2.7 µm, the laser characteristics slightly degrade. Above 2.78 µm the laser diodes could not operate at
Mid-Infrared 2–5 µm Heterojunction Laser Diodes
49
room temperature. Gas detection by TDLAS using GaInAsSb QW lasers operating around 2.3 µm was successfully demonstrated. The used devices are Fabry–P´erot ridge lasers which have single mode emission in a wide range of temperature and injection current. Lead salt lasers presented excellent laser characteristics beyond 3.5 µm: room or near room temperature operation in pulsed conditions and the highest CW Tmax (223 K) in the 3–5 µm spectral range. That is the result of their small non-radiative Auger coefficient (of several 10−28 cm6 /s) which is one order of magnitude smaller than that of III–V compounds. Unfortunately their CW output power remains too small, even at low temperature (of the order of mW), for numerous IR applications. Intersubband quantum cascade lasers employing Ga0.47 In0.53 As/ Al0.48 In0.52 As material lattice-matched to an InP substrate are becoming the dominant technology for IR devices emitting at more than 5 µm (they can now operate in continuous mode at room temperature [146]). For shorter wavelength emission, it is necessary to increase the conduction band offset between the two semiconductor materials. That was obtained from straincompensated GaInAs/AlInAs/InP structures which could emit pulsed at room temperature near 3.5 µm. Nevertheless, in CW conditions the maximum temperature of operation is very low (less than 100 K). Another system was proposed for the realisation of intersubband QC lasers operating in the 3–5 µm wavelength range: the InAs/AlSb system grown on a GaSb substrate [147]. The very high conduction band discontinuity (2.1 eV at Γ points) of this material system allows the design of QC devices at short wavelengths. First results are encouraging, and efforts are being made to improve the design of the QC structure to achieve laser emission at room temperature [148]. Interband heterostructures with type-II (or staggered type-II) and type-III (or broken-gap type-II) band alignment have been considered because they lead to substantial reduction of the Auger recombination rate and internal losses if intervalence resonances are avoided. Type-II interband InAsSb/InAs multi-quantum-well lasers are attractive because of their growth simplicity and excellent performance at 80 K. But they are limited to operation temperatures less than 220 K, and theoretical predictions show that it would be very difficult to increase Tmax with this system. Type-III “W” quantum well laser diodes are basically interesting because they combine strong overlap of electron and hole wavefunctions (and hence large optical matrix elements) with two-dimensional densities of states for both carriers (and hence high differential gain). Mid-infrared “W” lasers based on the InAs/GaInSb type-III system were grown by MBE. They showed the highest operating temperatures of III–V laser diodes in the 3–5 µm wavelength domain (pulsed Tmax = 310 K and CW Tmax = 195 K for an emission at λ = 3.3 µm). Gain modal calculations in this “W” laser structure show
50
Andr´e Joulli´e et al.
that RT operation is feasible, but only with samples having small optical losses, which requires high crystal quality and optimized design. Interband quantum cascade lasers, taking advantage of the type-III band alignment of the InAs/GaInSb system to reuse electrons for sequential photon emissions, have been grown by MBE. Good results have been obtained in the pulsed regime (near room temperature operation and very high peak output power at 80 K: 4 W/facet at emission wavelengths of 3.8–3.9 µm). But like strained intersubband QC lasers the CW operation of IC lasers is difficult to obtain at high temperature (CW Tmax = 127 K at 3.7 µm). It appears finally that GaInAsSb/AlGaAsSb QW laser diodes based on GaSb substrates are the best and already well-established technology for emission wavelengths shorter than 2.7 µm. Beyond 2.7 µm the other technologies under consideration showed encouraging performance, but they must be optimized to achieve the goal of CW mid-infrared emission at room temperature.
References 1. H. A. Gebbie, W. R. Harding, C. Hilsum, A. W. Pryce, V. Roberts: Atmospheric transmission in the 1 to 14µ region, Proc. Soc. A 206, 87 (1951) 1 2. L. S. Rothman, R. R. Gamache, R. H. Tipping, C. P. Rinsland, M. A. H. Smith, D. C. Benner, V. M. Devi, J. M. Flaud, C. Camy-Peyret, A. Perrin, A. Goldman, S. T. Massie, L. R. Brown, R. A. Toth: The HITRAN molecular data base: editions of 1991 and 1992, J. Quantum Spectrosc. Radiat. Transfer 48, 469 (1992) 1 3. H. I. Schiff, G. I. Mackay, J. Bechara: The use of tunable diode laser absorption spectroscopy for atmospheric measurements, in Air Monitoring by Spectroscopy Techniques, M. W. Sigrist (Ed.) (Wiley, New York 1994) 2 4. D. Z. Garbuzov, H. Lee, V. Khalfin, R. Martinelli, J. C. Connolly, G. L. Belenky: 2.3–2.7 µm room temperature CW operation of InGaAsSb-AlGaAsSb broad waveguide SCH-QW diode lasers, IEEE Photon. Technol. Lett. 11, 794– 796 (1999) 2, 4, 32 5. I. Melngailis: Maser action in InAs diodes, Appl. Phys. Lett. 2, 176–178 (1963) 3 6. J. Phelan, A. R. Calawa, R. H. Rediker, R. J. Keyes, B. Lax: Infrared InSb laser diodes in high magnetic fields, Appl. Phys. Lett. 3, 143–145 (1963) 3 7. C. B. Guillaume, P. Lavallard: Laser effect in indium antimonide, Solid State Commun. 1, 148–151 (1963) 3 8. J. F. Butler, A. R. Calawa, R. J. Phelan, T. C. Harman, A. J. Strauss, R. H. Rediker: PbTe diode laser, Appl. Phys. Lett. 5, 75–77 (1964) 3 9. Y. Horikoshi: Semiconductor lasers with wavelengths > 2 µm, in Semiconductors and Semimetals 22, W. T. Tsang (Ed.) (Academic Press, London 1985) pp. 93–151 3 10. D. L. Partin, C. M. Trush: Wavelength coverage of lead-europium-selenidetelluride diode lasers, Appl. Phys. Lett. 45, 193–195 (1984) 3 11. H. Preir: Physics and applications of IV–VI compound semiconductor lasers, Semicond. Sci. Technol. 5, S12–S20 (1990) 3
Mid-Infrared 2–5 µm Heterojunction Laser Diodes
51
12. C. Caneau, A. K. Srivastava, A. G. Dentai, J. L. Zyskind, M. A. Pollack: Room temperature GaInAsSb/AlGaAsSb DH injection lasers at 2.2 µm, Electron. Lett. 21, 815–817 (1985) 3 13. A. N. Baranov, T. N. Danilova, B. E. Dzhurtanov, A. N. Imenkov, S. G. Konnikov, A. M. Litvak, V. E. Umanskii, Yu. P. Yakovlev: CW lasing in GaInAsSb/GaSb buried channel laser (T = 20◦ , λ = 2.0 µm), Sov. Techn. Phys. Lett. 14, 727–730 (1988) 3 14. A. E. Bochkarev, L. M. Dolginov, A. E. Drakin, P. G. Eliseev, B. N. Sverdlov: Continuous-wave lasing at room temperature in InGaSbAs/GaAlAsSb injection heterostructures emitting in the spectral rang 2.2–2.4 µm, Sov. Techn. Phys. Lett. 14, 727–730 (1988) 3 15. A. N. Baranov, E. A. Grebenschikova, B. E. Dzurthanov, T. N. Danilova, A. N. Imenkov, Yu. P. Yakovlev: Long wavelength lasers based on GaInAsSb solid solutions near the immiscibility boundary (λ ≈ 2.5 µm; T = 300 K), Sov. Tech. Phys. Lett. 14, 798–800 (1988) 3 16. A. N. Baranov, C. Fouillant, P. Grunberg, J. L. Lazzari, S. Gaillard, A. Joulli´e: High temperature operation of GaInAsSb/AlGaAsSb double heterostructure lasers emitting near 2.1 µm, Appl. Phys. Lett. 65, 616–617 (1994) 3 17. H. Mani, A. Joulli´e, G. Boissier, E. Tourni`e, F. Pitard, A. M. Joulli´e, C. Alibert: New III–V double heterojunction laser emitting near 3.2 µm, Electron. Lett. 24, 1542–1543 (1988) 3, 4 ˙ Yakovlev: 2.7–3.9 µm 18. A. N. Baranov, A. N. Imenkov, V. V. Sherstnev, Yu.P. InAsSb(P)/InAsSbP low threshold diode lasers, Appl. Phys. Lett. 64, 2480– 2482 (1994) 3 19. A. N. Baranov, B. E. Dzhurtanov, A. N. Imenkov, A. A. Rogachev, Yu. M. Shernyakov, Yu. P. Yakovlev: Generation of coherent radiation in a quantumwell structure with one heterojunction, Sov. Phys. Semicond. 20, 1385–1389 (1986) 3 20. K. D. Moiseev, M. P. Mikhailova, O. G. Ershov, Yu. P. Yakovlev: Longwavelength laser (3.26 µm) with a single isolated p-GaInAsSb/p-InAs type-II heterojunction in the active region, Tech. Phys. Lett. 21, 482–483 (1995) 3 21. G. Bauer, M. Kriechbaum, Z. Shi, M. Tacke: IV–VI quantum wells for infrared lasers, J. Nonlinear Opt. Phys. Mater. 4, 283–312 (1995) 4, 7 22. Z. Shi, M. Tacke, A. Lambrecht, H. B¨ ottner: Midinfrared lead salt multiquantum-well diode lasers with 282 K operation, Appl. Phys. Lett. 66, 2537– 2539 (1995) 4 23. M. Tacke: Lead salt lasers, Philos. Trans. R. Soc. London A 359, 547–566 (2001) 4 24. M. Zandian, J. M. Arias, R. Zucca, R. V. Gil, S. H. Shin: HgCdTe double heterostructure injection laser grown by molecular beam epitaxy, Appl. Phys. Lett. 59, 1022–1024 (1991) 4 25. J. M. Arias, M. Zandian, R. Zucca, J. Singh: HgCdTe infrared diode lasers grown by MBE, Semicond. Sci. Technol. 8, S255–S260 (1993) 4 26. E. P. O’Reilly, A. R. Adams: Band structure engineering in strained semiconductor lasers, IEEE J. Quantum Electron. 30, 366–379 (1994) 4 27. C. R. Ram-Mohan, J. R. Meyer: Multiband finite element modeling of wavefunction engineered electro-optical devices, J. Nonlinear Opt. Phys. Mater. 4, 191–243 (1995) 4
52
Andr´e Joulli´e et al.
28. J. R. Meyer, C. A. Hoffman, F. J. Bartoli, L. R. Ram-Mohan: Type-II quantum well lasers for the mid-wavelength infrared, Appl. Phys. Lett. 67, 757–759 (1995) 4, 41, 46 29. H. Lee, L. J. Olafsen, R. J. Menna, W. W. Bewley, R. U. Martinelli, I. Vurgaftman, D. Z. Garbuzov, C. L. Felix, M. Maiorov, J. R. Meyer, J. C. Connolly, A. R. Stugg, G. H. Olsen: Room-temperature type-II quantum well diode laser with broadened waveguide emitting at λ = 3.30 µm, Electron. Lett. 35, 1743–1745 (1999) 4, 41, 46, 47 30. W. W. Bewley, H. Lee, I. Vurgaftman, R. J. Menna, C. L. Felix, R. U. Martinelli, D. W. Stokes, D. Z. Garbuzov, J. R. Meyer, M. Maiorov, J. C. Connolly, A. R. Stugg, G. H. Olsen: Continuous-wave operation of λ = 3.25 µm broadened-waveguide W quantum-well diode lasers up to T = 195 K, Appl. Phys. Lett. 76, 256–258 (2000) 4, 41, 46, 47, 48 31. B. I. Vurgaftman, C. L. Felix, W. W. Bewley, D. W. Stokes, R. E. Bartolo, J. R. Meyer: Mid-infrared “W” lasers, Philos. Trans. R. Soc. London A 359, 489–503 (2001) 4, 10 32. R. Q. Yang: Infrared lasers based on intersubband transitions in quantum wells, Superlattice Microstr. 17, 77–83 (1995) 4 33. R. Q. Yang, J. D. Bruno, J. L. Bradshaw, J. T. Pham, D. E. Wortman: Highpower interband cascade lasers with quantum efficiency > 450 %, Electron. Lett. 35, 1254–1255 (1999) 4 34. R. Q. Yang, J. D. Bruno, J. L. Bradshaw, J. T. Pham, D. E. Wortman: Interband cascade lasers: progress and challenges, Physica E 7, 69–75 (2000) 4 35. J. D. Bruno, J. L. Bradshaw, R. Q. Yang, J. T. Pham, D. E. Wortman: Lowthreshold interband cascade lasers with power efficiency exceeding 9 %, Appl. Phys. Lett. 76, 3167–3169 (2000) 4 36. J. Faist, F. Capasso, D. L. Sivco, C. Sirtori, A. L. Hutchinson, A. Y. Cho: Quantum cascade laser, Science 264, 553–556 (1994) 4 37. C. Gmachl, A. Tredicucci, F. Capasso, A. L. Hutchinson, D. L. Sivco, J. N. Baillargeon, A. Y. Cho: High power λ ≈ 8 µm quantum cascade lasers with near optimum performance, Apl. Phys. Lett. 72, 3130–3132 (1998) 4 38. J. Faist, F. Capasso, D. L. Sivco, A. L. Hutchinson, S.-N. G. Chu, A. Y. Cho: Short wavelength (λ ≈ 3.4 µm) quantum cascade laser based on straincompensated InGaAs/AlInAs, Appl. Phys. Lett. 72, 680–682 (1998) 4 39. F. Capasso, C. Gmachl, R. Paiella, A. Tredicucci, A. L. Hutchinson, D. L. Sivco, J. N. Baillargeon, A. Y. Cho, H. C. Liu: New frontiers in quantum cascade lasers and applications, IEEE J. Sel. Topics Quantum Electron. 6, 931–947 (2000) 4 40. F. Q. Liu, Y. Z. Zhang, Q. S. Zhang, D. Ding, Bo Xu, Z. G. Wang, D. S. Jiang, B. Q. Sun: High-performance strain-compensated InGaAs/InAlAs quantum cascade lasers, Semicond. Sci. Technol. 15, L44–L46 (2000) 4 41. A. Y. Cho, D. L. Sivco, H. M. Gmachl, A. Tredicucci, A. L. Hutchinson, S. N. G. Chu, F. Capasso: Quantum devices, MBE technology for the 21st century, J. Crystal Growth 227/228, 1–7 (2001) 4 42. B. Ishaug, W. Y. Hwang, J. Um, B. Guo, H. Lee, C. H. Lin: Continuous-wave operation of a 5.2 µm quantum-cascade laser up to 210 K, Appl. Phys. Lett. 79, 1745–1747 (2001) 4 43. H. K. Choi, S. J. Eglash: High power multiple quantum well GaInAsSb/AlGaAsSb diode lasers emitting at 2.1 µm with low threshold current density, Appl. Phys. Lett. 61, 1154–1156 (1992) 4, 14, 23
Mid-Infrared 2–5 µm Heterojunction Laser Diodes
53
44. H. K. Choi, G. W. Turner, S. J. Eglash: High-power GaInAsSb-AlGaAsSb multiple quantum well diode lasers emitting at 1.9 µm, IEEE Photon. Technol. Lett. 6, 7–9 (1994) 4 45. H. Lee, P. K. York, R. J. Menna, R. U. Martinelli, D. Z. Garbuzov, S. Y. Narayan, J. C. Connolly: Room temperature 2.78 µm AlGaAsSb/InGaAsSb quantum well lasers, Appl. Phys. Lett. 66, 1942–1944 (1995) 4, 31 46. A. N. Baranov, N. Bertru, Y. Cuminal, G. Boissier, Y. Rouillard, J. C. Nicolas, P. Grech, A. Joulli´e, C. Alibert: Mid-infrared GaSb-InAs based multiple quantum well lasers, Proc. SPIE 3284, 247–257 (1998) 4, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 20, 28, 30 47. A. Joulli´e: New developments in mid-infrared Sb-based lasers, J. Phys. IV (Paris) 9, Pr2.79–Pr2.96 (1999) 4, 10 48. D. A. Yarekha, G. Glastre, A. Perona, Y. Rouillard, F. Genty, E. M. Skouri, G. Boissier, P. Grech, A. Joulli´e, C. Alibert, A. N. Baranov: High temperature GaInAsSb/GaAlAsSb quantum well singlemode continuous wave lasers emitting near 2.3 µm, Electron. Lett. 36, 537–539 (2000) 4, 22, 29, 33, 34 49. D. A. Yarekha, A. Vicet, A. Perona, G. Glastre, B. Fraisse, Y. Rouillard, E. M. Skouri, G. Boissier, P. Grech, A. Joulli´e, C. Alibert, A. N. Baranov: High efficiency GaInAsSb/GaSb type-II quantum well continuous wave lasers, Semicond. Sci. Technol. 15, 390–394 (2000) 4, 34 50. J. Bhan, A. Joulli´e, H. Mani, A. M. Joulli´e, C. Alibert: III–V heterostructures for laser emission in 2.55 wavelength region, Materials and Technologies for Optical Communications Proc. SPIE 866, 126–134 (1987) 5 51. Y. Tsou, A. Ichii, E. M. Garmire: Improving InAs double heterostructure lasers with better confinement, IEEE J. Quantum Electron. 28, 1261–1268 (1992) 7 52. G. P. Agrawal, N. K. Dutta: Long wavelength semiconductor lasers, Sanjit Mitra (Ed.) (Van Nostrand Reinhold, New York 1986) 9 53. A. Haug: Auger recombination in quantum well semiconductors: calculation with realistic energy bands, Semicond. Sci. Technol. 7, 1337–1340 (1992) 9 54. B. K. Ridley: Quantum Processes in Semiconductors (Clarendon, Oxford 1988) 9 55. E. Rosencher, B. Vinter: Opto´electronique (Masson, Paris 1998) pp. 265–271 9 56. H. Y. Fan: Semiconductors and Semimetals, R. K. Willardson, A C. Beer (Eds.) (Academic, New York 1967) Vol. 3, Chap. 9 10 57. J. R. Meyer, C. L. Felix, W. W. Bewley, I. Vurgaftman, E. H. Aifer, L. J. Olafsen, J. R. Lindle, C. A. Hoffman, M. J. Yang, B. R. Bennett, B. V. Shanabrook, H. Lee, C. H. Lin, S. S. Pei, R. H. Miles: Auger coefficients in type-II InAs/ Ga1−x Inx Sb quantum wells, Appl. Phys. Lett. 73, 2857–2859 (1998) 10, 41 58. A. Joulli´e, P. Christol, A. Wilk, P. Grech, M. El Gazouli, F. Chevrier, A. N. Baranov: Recent developments and prospect in mid-infrared (3-5m) Sb-based laser diodes, Quantum Electronics and Photonics 15, mid-IR Workshop, Glasgow (2001) 10 59. J. L. Pautrat: private communication, reported in: Opto´electronique, E. Rosencher, B. Vinter (Eds.) (Masson, Paris 1998) p. 234 10 60. C. H. Grein, P. M. Young, H. Ehrenreich: Theoretical performance of InAs/Inx Ga1−x Sb superlattice-based midwave infrared lasers, J. Appl. Phys. 76, 1940–1942 (1994) 11, 41
54
Andr´e Joulli´e et al.
61. G. G. Zegrya, A. D. Andreev: Mechanism of suppression of Auger recombination proocesses in type-II heterostructures, Appl. Phys. Lett. 67, 2681–2683 (1995) 11 62. S. Forouhar, A. Ksendzov, A. Larsson, H. Temkin: InGaAs/InGaAsP/InP strained-layer quantum well lasers at ≈ 2 µm, Electron. Lett. 28, 945–947 (1992) 14 63. U. Martinelli, R. J. Menna, A. Triano, M. G. Harvey, G. H. Olsen: Temperature dependence of 2 µm strained-quantum-well InGaAs/InGaAsP/InP diode lasers, Electron. Lett. 30, 324–326 (1994) 14 64. M. Ochiai, H. Temkin, S. Forouhar, R. A. Logan: InGaAs-InGaAsP buried heterostructure lasers operating at 2.0 µm, IEEE Photonics Techn. Lett. 7, 825–827 (1995) 14 65. M. Oishi, M. Yamamoto, K. Kasaya: 2.0-µm single-mode operation of InGaAsInGaAsP distributed-feedback buried-heterostructure quantum-well lasers, IEEE Photonics Techn. Lett. 9, 431–433 (1997) 14 66. M. Mitsuhara, M. Ogasawara, M. Oishi, H. Sugiura: Metalorganic molecular beam epitaxy-grown In0.77 Ga0.23 As/InGaAs multiple quantum well lasers emitting at 2.07 µm wavelength, Appl. Phys. Lett. 72, 3106–3108 (1998) 14 67. M. Mitsuhara, M. Ogasawara, M. Oishi, H. Sugiura, K. Kasaya: 2.05-µm wavelength InGaAs-InGaAs distrubuted-feedback multiquantum-well lasers with 10 mW output power, IEEE Photonics Techn. Lett. 11, 33–35 (1999) 14 68. J. Dong, A. Ubukata, K. Matsumoto: Characteristics dependence on confinement structure and single-mode operation in 2-µm compressively strained InGaAs-InGaAsP quantum-well lasers, IEEE Photonics Techn. Lett. 10, 513– 515 (1998) 14 69. J. S. Major, J. S. Osinski, D. F. Welch: High-power 2.0-µm InGaAsP laser diodes, IEEE Photonics Techn. Lett. 5, 594–596 (1993) 14 70. E. Tourni´e, P. Grunberg, C. Fouillant, A. N. Baranov, A. Joulli´e, K. H. Ploog: Strained InAs/Ga0.47 /In0.53 As quantum-well heterostructures grown by molecular-beam epitaxy for long-wavelength applications, Solid-State Electron. 37, 1311–1314 (1994) 14 71. J.-S. Wang, H.-H. Lin, L.-W. Sung: Room-temperature 2.2 µm InAs-InGaAsInP highly strained multiquantum-well lasers grown by gas-source molecular beam epitaxy, IEEE J. Quantum Electron. 34, 1959–1962 (1998) 14, 28 72. A. N. Baranov, Y. Cuminal, N. Bertru, C. Alibert, A. Joulli´e: Strained multiple quantum well lasers grown on GaSb emitting between 2 and 2.4 µm: Proc. SPIE 2997, 2–13 (1997) 14, 15, 18, 20, 28 73. C. G. Van de Walle: Band lineups and deformation potentials in the modelsolid theory, Phys. Rev. B 39, 1871–1879 (1989) 14 74. S. L. Wong, R. T. Warburton, R. J. Nicholas, N. J. Mason, P. J. Walker: A magneto-optical study of coupled quantum wells in strained GaInSb/GaSb, Physica B 184, 106–110 (1993) 14 75. L. Q. Qian, B. W. Wessels: Optical properties of strained-layer Inx Ga1−x Sb/GaSb heterostructures with x ≤ 0.4, J. Vac. Sci. Technol. B 11, 1652–1659 (1993) 14 76. A. N. Baranov, Y. Cuminal, G. Boissier, J. C. Nicolas, J. L. Lazzari, C. Alibert, A. Joulli´e: Electroluminescence of GaInSb/GaSb strained single quantum well structures grown by molecular beam epitaxy, Semicond. Sci. Technol. 11, 1185–1191 (1996) 14
Mid-Infrared 2–5 µm Heterojunction Laser Diodes
55
77. A. Haug: Band-to-band Auger recombination in semiconductors, J. Phys. Chem. Solids 49, 599–605 (1988) 16 78. N. A. Gun’ko, G. G. Zegrya, N. V. Zotova, Z. N. Sokolova, N. M. Stus’, V. B. Khalfin: Influence of valence band absorption on the threshold characteristics of long-wavelength InAs lasers, Semicond. 31, 1204–1208 (1997) 16 79. P. Christol, P. Bigenwald, A. Joulli´e, Y. Cuminal, A. N. Baranov, N. Bertru, Y. Rouillard: Improvement of Sb-based multiquantum well lasers by Coulomb enhancement, IEEE Proc. Optoelectron. 146, 3–8 (1999) 17, 42 80. G. G. Zegrya, A. D. Andreev: Mechanism of suppression of Auger recombination processes in type-II heterostructures, Appl. Phys. Lett. 67, 2681–2683 (1995) 18 81. N. Bertru, A. N. Baranov, Y. Cuminal, G. Almuneau, F. Genty, A. Joulli´e, O. Brandt, A. Mazuelas, K. H. Ploog: Long-wavelength (Ga,In)Sb/GaSb strained quantum well lasers grown by molecular beam epitaxy, Semicond. Sci. Technol. 13, 936–939 (1998) 18 82. A. N. Baranov, Y. Cuminal, G. Boissier, C. Alibert, A. Joulli´e: Low-threshold laser diodes based on type-II GaInAsSb/GaSb quantum-wells operating at 2.36 µm at room temperature, Electron. Lett. 32, 2279–2280 (1996) 18, 20, 28 83. G. A. Sai-Halasz, R. Tsu, L. Esaki: A new semiconductor superlattice, Appl. Phys. Lett. 30, 651–653 (1977) 18 84. A. N. Baranov, N. Bertru, Y. Cuminal, G. Boissier, C. Alibert, A. Joulli´e: Observation of room-temperature laser emission from type-III InAs/GaSb multiple quantum well structures, Appl. Phys. Lett. 71, 735–736 (1997) 18, 19 85. P. S. Kop’ev, N. N. Ledentsov, A. M. Monakhov, A. A. Rogachev: Noninjection light-emitting diode, RU patent no. 2019895 (1991) 18 86. S. V. Ivanov, B. K. Kurinkiev, N. N. Ledentsov, B.Ya. Meltser, A. A. Monakhov, A. A. Rogachev, S. V. Shaposhnikov, P. S. Kop’ev: Middle infrared (λ = 2–5.5 µm) high quantum efficiency luminescence in GaSb/InAs II-type multi-quantum well structures, in Workbook of 6th International Conference on Modulated Semiconductor Structures, Garmisch-Partenkirchen, (1993) p. 1047 18 87. P. S. Kop’ev, B. Ya. Meltser, S. V. Ivanov, A. A. Rogachev, S. V. Shaposhnikov: Photo- and electroluminescence study of type-II InAs/GaSb quantum well heterostructures grown by molecular beam epitaxy, in Proceedings of the VIII International Conference on Molecular Beam Epitaxy, Osaka (1994) p. 542 18 88. J. Schmitz, J. Wagner, F. Fuchs, N. Herres, P. Koidl, J. D. Ralston: Optical and structural investigations of intermixing reactions at the interfaces of InAs/AlSb and InAs/GaSb quantum wells grown by molecular-beam epitaxy, J. Crystal Growth 150, 858–863 (1995) 18 89. A. Mujica, A. Mu˜ nioz: Self consitent tight binding calculations of band offsets in GaAs/Alx Ga1−x As (110) and GaSb/Alx Ga1−x Sb (110) heterojunctions. Theoretical evidence for a new common-anion rule, Solid State Commun. 81, 961–968 (1992) 20 90. J.-L. Lazzari: Etude des h´et´erostructures GaInAsSb/GaSb et GaAlAsSb/ GaSb et de composants lasers et d´etecteurs ` a base de GaSb op´erant entre 2 et 2.5 µm, Dissertation, Universit´e Montpellier II, Montpellier (1993) 20
56
Andr´e Joulli´e et al.
91. D. Z. Garbuzov, R. U. Martinelly, H. Lee, P. K. York, R. J. Menna, J. C. Connolly, S. Y. Narayan: Ultralow-loss broadened-waveguide high-power 2 µm AlGaAsSb/InGaAsSb/GaSb separate-confinement quantum-well lasers, Appl. Phys. Lett. 69, 2006–2008 (1996) 20, 21, 23, 24, 25 92. N. Bertru, A. N. Baranov, Y. Cuminal, G. Almuneau, F. Genty, A. Joulli´e, O. Brandt, A. Mazuelas, K. H. Ploog: Long-wavelength (Ga,In)Sb/GaSb strained quantum well lasers grown by molecular beam epitaxy, Semicond. Sci. Technol. 13, 936–940 (1998) 20, 28 93. Y. Cuminal, A. N. Baranov, D. Bec, P. Grech, M. Garcia, G. Boissier, A. Joulli´e, G. Glastre, R. Blondeau: Room-temperature 2.63 µm GaInAsSb/GaSb strained quantum-well laser diodes, Semicond. Sci. Technol. 14, 283–288 (1999) 20, 28, 30 94. A. Joulli´e, G. Glastre, R. Blondeau, J.-C. Nicolas, Y. Cuminal, A. N. Baranov, A. Wilk, M. Garcia, P. Grech, C. Alibert: Continuous-wave operation of GaInAsSb-GaSb type-II quantum-well ridge lasers, IEEE J. of Select. Topics in Quant. Electron. 5, 711–715 (1999) 20, 28 95. D. A. Yarekha, A. Vicet, A. Perona, G. Glastre, B. Fraisse, Y.Rouillard, E. M. Skouri, G. Boissier, P. Grech, A. Joulli´e, C. Alibert, A. N. Baranov: High efficiency GaInAsSb/GaSb type-II quantum well continuous wave lasers, Semicond. Sci. Technol. 15, 283–288 (2000) 20, 22, 28, 29, 30 96. K. Onabe: Unstable region in quaternary In1−x Gax As1−y Sby calculated using strictly regular solution approximation, Jpn. J. Appl. Phys. 21, 964 (1982) 21, 22 97. G. B. Stringfellow: Thermodynamics of semiconductor alloys for optoelectronics, in Materials for Optoelectronics, M. Quillec (Ed.) (Kluwer Academic, Dordrecht 1996) pp. 23–61 G. B. Stringfellow: Immiscibility and spinodal decomposition in III/V alloys, J. Cryst. Growth 65, 454–462 (1983) 21 98. A. N. Baranov, S. G. Konnikov, T. B. Popova, V. E. Umanskii, Yu. P. Yakovlev: Liquid phase epitaxy of GaAlAsSb/GaSb and the effect of strain on phase equilibria, J. Cryst. Growth 66, 547–552 (1984); 21 99. H. K. Choi, S. J. Eglash, M. K. Connors: Single-frequency GaInAsSb/ AlGaAsSb quantum-well ridge-waveguide lasers emitting at 2.1 µm, Appl. Phys. Lett. 63, 3271–3272 (1993) 22, 23, 26 100. D. Garbuzov, R. U. Martinelli, H. Lee, R. J. Menna, P. K. York, L. A. DiMarko, M. G. Harvey, R. J. Matarese, S. Y. Narayan, J. C. Connolly: 4-W quasi-continuous-wave output power from 2 µm AlGaAsSb/InGaAsSb singlequantum-well broadened waveguide laser diodes, Appl. Phys. Lett. 70, 2931– 2933 (1997) 24, 25 101. R. J. Menna, D. Z. Garbuzov, H. Lee, R. U. Martinelli, S. Y. Narayan, J. C. Connolly: High power broadened-waveguide InGaAsSb/AlGaAsSb quantumwell diode lasers emitting at 2 µm, Proc. SPIE 3284, 238–246 (1998) 24, 25 102. W. Turner, H. K. Choi, M. J. Manfra: Ultralow-threshold (50 A/cm2 ) strained single-quantum-well GaInAsSb/AlGaAsSb lasers emitting at 2.05 µm, Appl. Phys. Lett. 72, 876–878 (1998) 24, 25 103. H. K. Choi, G. W. Turner, J. N. Walpole, M. J. Manfra, M. K. Connors, L. J. Missaggia: Low-threshold, high power, high brightness GaInAsSb/AlGaAsSb quantum-well lasers emitting at 2.05 µm, Proc. SPIE 3284, 268–273 (1998) 24, 25
Mid-Infrared 2–5 µm Heterojunction Laser Diodes
57
104. J. N. Walpole, H. K. Choi, L. J. Missagia, Z. L. Liau, M. K. Connors, G. W. Turner, M. J. Manfra, C. C. Cook: High-power high-brightness GaInAsSbAlGaAsSb tapered laser arrays with anamorphic collimating lenses emitting at 2.05 µm, IEEE Photonics Techn. Lett. 11, 1223–1225 (1999) 24 105. T. C. Newell, L. F. Lester, X. Wu, Y. Zhang, A. L. Gray: Gain and threshold current density characteristics of 2 micron GaInAsSb/AlGaAsSb MQW lasers with increased valence band offset, Proc. SPIE 3284, 258–267 (1998) 25 106. T. C. Newell, X. Wu, A. L. Gray, S. Dorato, H. Lee, L. F. Lester: The effect of increased valence band offset on the operation of 2 µm GaInAsSb-AlGaAsSb lasers, IEEE Photonics Techn. Lett. 11, 30–32 (1999) 25 107. G. Mermelstein, S. Simanowski, M. Mayer, R. Kiefer, J. Schmitz, M. Walther, J. Wagner: Room-temperature low-threshold low-loss continuous-wave operation of 2.26 µm GaInAsSb/AlGaAsSb quantum-well laser diodes, Appl. Phys. Lett. 77, 1581–1583 (2000) 26 108. S. Simanowski, N. Herres, C. Mermelstein, R. Kiefer, J. Schmitz, M. Walther, J. Wagner, G. Weimann: Strain adjustment in (GaIn)(AsSb)/(AlGa)(AsSb) QWs for 2.3–2.7 µm laser structures, J. Cryst. Growth 209, 15–20 (2000) 26 109. S. Simanowski, C. Mermelstein, M. Walther, N. Herres, R. Kiefer, M. Rattunde, J. Schmitz, J. Wagner, G. Weimann: Growth and layer structure optimization of 2.26 µm (AlGaIn)(AsSb) diode lasers for room temperature operation, J. Cryst. Growth 227–228, 595–599 (2001) 26 110. T. Bleubel, M. Muller, A. Forchel: 2–µm GaInSb-AlGaAsSb distributedfeedback lasers, IEEE Photonics Techn. Lett. 13, 553–555 (2001) 26, 27 111. A. N. Baranov, Y. Rouillard, G. Boissier, P. Grech, S. Gaillard, C. Alibert: Sbbased monolithic vertical cavity surface emitting laser operating near 2.2 µm at room temperature, Electron. Lett. 34, 281–282 (1998) 27 112. D. Yarekha: Etude et r´ealisation de diodes lasers ´emettant entre 2.2 et 2.4 µm pour application ` a l’analyse de gaz, Dissertation, Universit´e Montpellier II, Montpellier (2001) 29, 30, 31 113. A. Baraldi, C. Ghezzi, A. Parisini, R. Magnanini, L. Tarricone, S. Franchi: Occupancy level of the DX center in Te-doped Alx Ga1−x Sb, J. Appl. Phys. 85, 256–263 (1999) 30 114. D. Z. Garbuzov, R. U. Martinelli, R. J. Menna, P. K. York, H. Lee, S. Y. Narayan, J. C. Connolly: 2.7 µm InGaAsSb/AlGaAsSb laser diodes with continuous-wave operation up to −39 ◦ C, Appl. Phys. Lett. 67, 1346–1348 (1995) 31 115. D. Garbuzov, R. Menna, M. Maiorov, H. Lee, V. Khalfin, L. DiMarco, D. Capewell, R. Martinelli, G. Belenky, J. Connolly: 2.3–2.7 µm room temperature CW-operation of InGaAsSb/AlGaAsSb broad-contact and single-mode ridge-waveguide SCH-QW diode lasers, Proc. SPIE 3628, 124–129 (1999) 31 116. A. D. Andreev, D. V. Donetsky: Analysis of temperature dependence of the threshold current in 2.3–2.6 µm InGaAsSb/AlGaAsSb quantum-well lasers, Appl. Phys. Lett. 74, 2743–2745 (1999) 31 117. D. Garbuzov, M. Maiorov, H. Lee, V. Khalfin, R. Martinelli, J. Connolly: Temperature dependence of continuous wave threshold current for 2.3–2.6 µm InGaAsSb/AlGaAsSb separate confinement heterostructure quantum well semiconductor diode lasers, Appl. Phys. Lett. 74, 2990–2992 (1999) 31 118. M. Maiorov, J. Wang, D. Baer, H. Lee, G. Belenky, R. Hanson, J. Connolly, D. Garbuzov: New room temperature CW InGaAsSb/AlGaAsSb QW ridge
58
119.
120.
121.
122.
123.
124. 125.
126.
127.
128.
129. 130.
131.
132.
133.
134.
Andr´e Joulli´e et al. diode lasers and their application to CO measurements near 2.3 µm, Proc. SPIE 3855, 62–71 (1999) 31 L. S. Rothman, R. R. Gamache, A. Goldman, L. R. Brown, R. A. Toth, H. M. Pickett, R. L. Poynter, J. M. Flaud, C. Camy-Peyret, A. Barbe, N. Husson, C. P. Rinsland, A. H. Smith, The HITRAN database: 1986 edition, Appl. Opt. 26, 4058–4097 (1987) 33 A. Vicet, J. C. Nicolas, F. Genty, E. M. Skouri A. N. Baranov, C. Alibert: Room temperature GaInAsSb/GaSb quantum well laser for tunable diode laser absorption spectroscopy around 2.35 µm, IEE Proc. Optoelectron. 147, 172–176 (2000) 33 R. Mucke, P. Werle, F. D’Amato, A. Lancia: Precise measurement of CO2 concentration using room temperature diode lasers, 5th International Symposium on Gas Analysis by Tunable Diode Lasers, (1998) pp. 83–92 34 A. Vicet, D. A. Yarekha, A. Perona, Y. Rouillard, S. Gaillard, A. N. Baranov: Trace gas detection with antimonide-based quantum-well diode lasers, Spectrochim. Acta Part A 58 2405–2412 (2002) 35, 40 B. Botteldooren, R. Baets: Influence of band-gap shrinkage on the carrierinduced refractive index change in InGaAsP, Appl. Phys. Lett. 54, 1989–1991 (1989) 37 A. N. Baranov, V. Sherstnev, C. Alibert, A. Krier, New III–V semiconductor lasers emitting near 2.6 µm, J. Appl. Phys. 79, 3354–3356 (1996) 37 B. K. Ghosh, L. K. Samanta, G. C. Bhar: The temperature and pressure dependence of refractive index of some III–V semiconductors, Infrared Phys. 26, 111 (1986) 38 J. B. McManus, P. L. Kebabian, M. S. Zahniser: Astigmatic mirror multipass absorption for long-pathlength spectroscopy, Appl. Opt. 34, 3336–3348 (1995) 38 A. Popov, V. Sherstnev, Y. Yakovlev, R. M¨ ucke, P. Werle: High power InAsSb/InAsSbP double heterostructure laser for continuous wave operation at 3.6 µm, Appl. Phys. Lett. 68, 2790–2792 (1996) 40 H. K. Choi, S. J. Eglash, G. W. Turner: Double-heterostructure diode laser emitting at 3 µm with a metastable GaInAsSb active layer and AlGaAsSb cladding layers, Appl. Phys. Lett. 64, 2474–2476 (1994) 40 Y. H. Zhang: Continuous wave operation of InAs/InAsx Sb1−x mid-infrared lasers, Appl. Phys. Lett. 66, 118–120 (1995) 40 S. R. Kurtz, R. M. Biefeld, A. A. Allerman, A. J. Howard, M. H. Crawford: Pseudomorphic InAsSb multiquantum well injection laser emitting at 3.5 µm, Appl. Phys. Lett. 68, 1332–1334 (1996) 40 B. Lane, D. Wu, A. Rybaltowski, J. Diaz, M. Razeghi: Compressively strained multiple quantum well InAsSb lasers emitting at 3.6 µm grown by metalorganic chemical vapor deposition, Appl. Phys. Lett. 70, 443–445 (1997) 40 G. W. Turner, M. J. Manfra, H. K. Choi, M. K. Connors: MBE growth of high power InAsSb/InAlAsSb quantum well diode lasers emitting at 3.5 µm, J. Crystal Growth 175/176, 825–832 (1997) 40 H. K. Choi, G. W. Turner, M. J. Manfra, M. K. Connors: 175 K continuous wave operation of InAsSb/InAlAsSb quantum well diode lasers emitting at 3.5 µm, Appl. Phys. Lett. 68, 2936–2938 (1996) 40 R. M. Biefeld, S. R. Kurtz, A. A. Allerman: The metal-organic chemical vapor deposition growth and properties of InAsSb mid-infrared (3–6 µm) lasers and LEDs, IEEE J. Select. Topics Quantum Electron. 3, 739–748 (1997) 40
Mid-Infrared 2–5 µm Heterojunction Laser Diodes
59
135. B. Lane, Z. Wu, A. Stein, J. Diaz, M. Razeghi: InAsSb/InAsP strained-layer superlattice injection lasers operating at 4.0 µm grown by metal-organic chemical vapor deposition, Appl. Phys. Lett. 74, 3438–3440 (1999) 40 136. T. Ashley, C. T. Elliott, R. Jefferies, A. D. Johnson, G. J. Pryce, A. M. White, M. Carroll: Mid-infrared In1−x Alx Sb/InSb heterostructure diode lasers, Appl. Phys. Lett. 70, 931–933 (1997) 40 137. W. W. Bewley, I. Vurgaftman, C. L. Felix, J. R. Meyer, C. H. Lin, D. Zhang, S. J. Murry, S. S. Pei, L. R. Ram-Mohan: Role of internal loss in limiting type-II mid-IR laser performance, J. Appl. Phys. 83, 2384–2391 (1998) 41 138. Y. B. Li, D. J. Bain, L. Hart, M. Livingstone, C. M. Ciesla, M. J. Pullin, P. J. Tang, W. T. Yuen, I. Galbraith, C. C. Phillips, C. R. Pidgeon, R. A. Stradling: Band alignment in In(As,Sb)/InAs superlattices, Phys. Rev. B 55, 4589–4595 (1997) 41 139. P. Christol, P. Bigenwald, A. Wilk, A. Joulli´e, O. Gilard, H. Carr`ere, F. LozesDupuy, A. Behres, A. Stein, J. Kluth, K. Heime, E. M. Skouri: InAs/InAs(PSb) quantum-well laser structure for the midwavelength infrared region, IEE Proc. Optoelectron. 147, 181–187 (2000) 41, 42 140. D. Ahn, S. L. Chuang: Optical gain and gain suppression of quantum-well lasers with valence band mixing, IEEE J. Quantum. Electron. 28, 13–24 (1990) 42 141. P. Christol, M. El Gazouli, P. Bigenwald, A. Joulli´e: Performance simulation of 3.3 µm interband laser diodes grown on InAs substrate, Physica E 14, 375–384 (2002) 42, 46 142. A. Wilk, F. Genty, B. Fraisse, G. Boissier, P. Grech, M. El Gazouli, A. Joulli´e, P. Christol, J. Oswald, T. Simecek, E. Hulicius: MBE growth of InAs/InAsSb/AlAsSb laser structures for mid-infrared lasers, J. Cryst. Growth 223, 341–348 (2001) 43 143. A. Wilk, M. El Gazouli, M. El Skouri, P. Christol, P. Grech, A. N. Baranov, A. Joulli´e: Type-II InAsSb/InAs strained quantum-well laser diodes emitting at 3.5 µm, Appl. Phys. Lett. 77, 2298–2300 (2000) 44, 45 144. A. Wilk, B. Fraisse, P. Christol, G. Boissier, P. Grech, M. El Gazouli, Y. Rouillard, A. N. Baranov, A. Joulli´e: MBE growth of InAs/InAsSb/InAlAsSb “W” quantum well laser diodes emitting near 3 µm, J. Crystal Growth 227/228, 586–590 (2001) 44 145. A. Joulli´e, E. M. Skouri, M. Garcia, P. Grech, A. Wilk, P. Christol, A. N. Baranov, A. Behres, J. Kluth, A. Stein, K. Heime, M. Heuken, S. Rushworth, E. Hulicius, T. Simecek: InAs(PSb)-based “W” quantum well laser diodes emitting near 3.3 µm, Appl. Phys. Lett. 76, 2499–2501 (2000) 44 146. M. Beck, D. Hofstetter, T. Aellen, S. Blaser, J. Faist, U. Oesterle, E. Gini: Continuous-wave operation of quantum cascade lasers, J. Crystal Growth 251, 697–700 (2003) 49 147. C. Becker, I. Prevot, X. Marcadet, B. Vinter, C. Sirtori: InAs/AlSb quantumcascade light-emitting devices in the 3–5 µm wavelength region, Appl. Phys. Lett. 76, 1029–1031 (2001) 49 148. C. Becker, H. Page, M. Calligaro, V. Ortiz, M. Garcia, X. Marcadet, C. Sirtori: GaAs- and GaSb-based quantum cascade lasers: the challenge of the new materials, 5th Int. Conf. Mid-infrared Optoelectronic Materials and Devices (MIOMD-5), Annapolis, MD (2002) 49
Index
Auger recombination, 4, 9–11, 13, 16, 17, 41, 47 band alignment, 6–8 – type-I, 6, 7, 14–18 – type-II, 6, 14–18, 28, 41 – type-III, 6, 18, 19, 45 band offset, 7, 8, 14, 15, 20, 24, 26, 28, 32, 33 characteristic temperature, 2, 19, 23–26, 30–32, 37, 44, 48 confinement factor, 5, 9, 23, 42, 43, 46 critical thickness, 17
internal quantum efficiency, 24, 28, 30 intersubband cascade laser, 4, 13 IV–VI semiconductor, 3, 5, 7 laser – double heterostructure, 3–5, 14, 22, 40 – interband cascade, 3, 4 – intersubband cascade, 4, 13 – lead salt, 2–4, 11, 13 – quantum cascade (QCL), 3 lead salt laser, 2–4, 11, 13 lifetime, 33, 40 miscibility gap, 21, 22, 31, 33, 44
differential quantum efficiency, 23–25, 30, 31 double heterostructure (DH) laser, 3–5, 14, 22, 40 Fabry–P´erot interferometer, 34 Fabry–P´erot laser, 5, 9, 18, 22, 26, 30, 31, 43 free carrier absorption, 9, 10, 23, 31 – loss, 23, 46
non-radiative (SHR) coefficient, 9, 46 optical gain, 9, 42 – maximum gain, 9, 42 – modal gain, 9, 42, 43, 46 optical loss, 9, 42, 44–46 – internal loss, 9, 23, 24, 28, 30, 41, 44 – mirror loss, 9 quantum cascade laser (QCL), 3
GaInAsSb/AlGaAsSb, 2–4, 11, 13–40 GaInAsSb/GaSb, 2, 7, 11, 15, 16, 20, 29
radiative (spontaneous) coefficient, 9, 46 radiative recombination, 6, 9, 17, 19
HgCdTe, 2, 4, 11, 13 series resistance, 5, 20, 37 InAs/AlSb, 5, 7, 49 InAs/GaInSb, 4, 7, 11, 41, 45–48 InAs/GaSb, 7, 18, 19 InAsSb/InAs, 7, 40, 41 InAsSb/InAsP, 40, 44 InAsSb/InAsPSb, 3, 40 interband cascade laser, 3, 4, 12, 13
thermal resistance, 30, 37 tunable diode laser absorption spectroscopy (TDLAS), 2, 34, 38 type-I laser, 2, 11, 14, 17, 18, 20, 23–29, 34, 40–42 type-II laser
Index – “W” laser, 1, 3, 4, 11, 13, 41, 46–47 – interband laser, 1, 2, 4, 41 – intersubband laser, 1, 49 – MQW laser, 4, 13, 28–33, 41–44 type-III laser, 18, 45–48
vertical cavity surface emitting laser (VCSEL), 26, 27
waveguide layer, 6, 10, 42, 46
61
High Performance Quantum Cascade Lasers and Their Applications Daniel Hofstetter and J´erˆome Faist Institute of Physics, University of Neuchˆ atel, 2000 Neuchˆ atel, Switzerland [email protected] [email protected] Abstract. This chapter describes our results on distributed feedback quantum cascade lasers in the wavelength range around 5 µm and around 10 µm. We present two different gain region designs; one with three quantum wells and one with a double phonon resonance. Several fabrication techniques are also presented and analysed in terms of fabrication simplicity, performance, yield, and reliability. We will outline typical results for all devices and also show some interesting applications. In light of this, the chapter is organized as follows: We start with a brief introduction; in Sect. 2, the advantages and drawbacks of the different gain regions are outlined; Sect. 3 deals with the fabrication technology which was required to build these lasers; in Sect. 4, we present the measurement results on the devices; and finally, Sect. 5 describes two examples of interesting applications in the fields of optical spectroscopy and optical data transmission. The chapter ends with a brief conclusion and an outlook.
1
Introduction
The development of high-performance mid-infrared light sources has experienced tremendous progress during the last couple of years. Pacemakers of this progress were the appearance and the subsequent improvements of the quantum cascade (QC) laser [1,2,3]. After the pioneering work of Kazarinov and Suris about transport and gain in superlattice structures in 1971 [4], it took 23 years to realize the first working QC laser. During this long period, researchers investigated many different aspects of intersubband transitions [5,6] and the nature of resonant tunneling effects in thin semiconductors [7,8]. They also learned to control the growth of extremely thin semiconductor layers by methods like molecular beam epitaxy (MBE) [9,10,11] and metalorganic vapor phase epitaxy (MOVPE) [12,13]. All these important developments were crucial milestones towards the realization of a midinfrared semiconductor laser based on intersubband transitions. But this kind of preparative work done in the 1970s and the 1980s also paved the way for a rapid development of the QC laser once it was born. Only one year after the demonstration of the QC laser by Faist et al. at Bell Labs in 1994 [1], the first continuous wave (CW) QC laser was operating at cryogenic temperatures [14,15]; and in 1996, room temperature pulsed operation could be I. T. Sorokina, K. L. Vodopyanov (Eds.): Solid-State Mid-Infrared Laser Sources, Topics Appl. Phys. 89, 61–98 (2003) c Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2003
62
Daniel Hofstetter and J´erˆ ome Faist
achieved [2]. From 1997 to 1999, some progress was made to push the highest CW operating temperatures towards higher values, but the relatively large threshold current densities of these devices (5 kA/cm2 at 300 K) prevented a real breakthrough [16,17,18,19]. The magic value of 200 K, which would have allowed operation on a thermo-electric cooler, seemed not to be as easy to reach as people had hoped initially. In 1999, for instance, the record CW operating temperature was 175 K [20]. As the performance of Fabry–P´erottype lasers improved steadily, the gas sensing applications soon called for single-mode lasers based on the distributed feedback (DFB) principle. The performance of these DFB QC lasers went pretty much in parallel with the one of the FP-lasers. Different coupling schemes like index-coupling [21,18] and gain/loss-coupling [22] were tried in order to achieve stable single-mode operation over a wide temperature range. Continuous temperature tuning over more than 1% of the emission wavelength could be demonstrated. Later on, the effort concentrated rather on novel material systems like AlGaAs or AlGaN [23,24,25,26], and on the implementation of the QC laser in systems like gas sensors and telecommunication [27,28,29,30]. During the year 2000, substantial progress was made again on the performance of the lasers themselves, mainly in terms of higher pulsed operating temperatures [31] and high duty cycle operation [32]. This development found its culmination in summer 2001, when the first room temperature CW operated QC laser was published [33]. Rapid progress was also made on GaAs/AlGaAs-based midIR QC lasers [34,35,36], where room temperature pulsed operation has been possible since 2001. Very recently, laser action on far-IR QC lasers at wavelengths close to 70 µm was demonstrated [37,38]. All these examples show that there is still a great deal of development potential behind these devices. For several potential applications, especially in the area of optical sensors for atmospheric trace gases, it is advantageous to operate with single-mode, single frequency lasers. For this purpose, DFB QC lasers have found widespread use and are also well understood [21,22,39]. Although DFB lasers have obvious performance benefits, there are some severe fabrication drawbacks. One of them is the requirement of epitaxial regrowth, which makes fabrication rather complicated and prolonged. This is not only due to the regrowth process itself, but also because of the fact that the material can be tested only after grating fabrication and over-growth. In Sect. 3.1, we will describe a simple method to circumvent some of the typical DFB laser fabrication problems. For certain special applications, the availability of a surface-emitting laser would greatly facilitate the coupling of the light into the optical system. Since, for fundamental reasons (TM polarization), a QC laser cannot be configured as a vertical cavity surface-emitting laser, other methods to achieve surface emission have to be pursued. An additional desired property of a light source for sensors is its single-mode behavior even in pulsed operation and at high power levels. In order to achieve single-mode operation, DFB QC lasers have
High Performance Quantum Cascade Lasers and Their Applications
63
already been extensively investigated and characterized [18,21,22,39]. An elegant method to obtain surface emission is the fabrication of a DFB QC laser utilizing a second-order diffraction grating [40]. This has the additional advantage that the grating with a period of around 3.15 µm can be fabricated by moderate-resolution contact-lithography instead of holography. This contactlithography technique was successfully utilized by the group of the technical University of Vienna [36]. Accordingly, such a device, again with lateral current injection, will be presented in this work. For most potential applications, however, properties like high output power, low power consumption, room-temperature operation, and a large single-mode tuning range are key features. Since continuous-wave operation of QC DFB lasers is not yet possible at room temperature, one has to deal with high average powers under pulsed current injection [18,41,42,43,44,45]. So far, high output powers were mainly a privilege of superlattice QC lasers. However, their major advantage, namely the short lifetime of the lower laser level, was usually obtained at the cost of a slightly worse injection efficiency. We have chosen a combination of two different measures to reach high output powers: first, a new type of gain region was investigated and implemented; second, we mounted our devices junction down to increase the thermal conductance. We will therefore report on QC lasers with a 4 quantum well (QW) gain region which combines the good injection efficiency of the diagonal anticrossed 3 QW design [46] and the short ground state lifetime of the superlattice QC laser [47,48]. But we will also give a brief overview of the performance of junction down mounted devices. Since QC lasers have their strongest output powers in the absorption bands of many gases, it was realized very soon that they are potential candidates for spectroscopic and other applications. With the recent progress in photo-acoustic (PA) spectroscopy such as the advent of highly sensitive microphones and microphone arrays, the construction of resonant multipass PA-cells, or the deployment of Helmholtz-resonator shaped PA-cells, QC lasers are, despite their still limited output power, becoming very interesting light sources for this sensitive technique. Nevertheless, the average QC laser output power was usually not large enough to perform spectroscopy in the ppm or even the ppb range. It is thus necessary to achieve high average power operation under temperature conditions which can be maintained with thermo-electric coolers [41,49,50,51]. We therefore show also results of DFB lasers with lateral current injection which emit up to 13.6 mW average power at −30 ◦C. But there exist more reasons why QC lasers are interesting light sources: their emission lies in the so-called atmospheric window regions around 5 µm and 10 µm. So far, the main application field was infrared (IR) spectroscopy, but thanks to the good transparency of the atmosphere in these wavelength bands even under foggy or rainy conditions, optical data transmission could
64
Daniel Hofstetter and J´erˆ ome Faist
be a new interesting application field for QC lasers. We thus present also measurements on this topic.
2
Gain Region Designs
In this section, we will first describe the basics of QC laser operation and then briefly discuss the main properties of the two gain region designs which were used for all devices presented in this work. Obviously, the list of possible designs is not complete, and the two cases outlined here are not treated in a very detailed way. 2.1
Basic Working Principles of QC Lasers
Compared to their ‘predecessors’, the lead salt diode lasers, the most striking features of QC lasers are their high output powers and the fact that they can function at temperatures of up to 470 K. In addition, unlike in diode lasers, the fundamental optical transitions are between conduction band sublevels (subbands) rather than between the conduction band and the valence band. Finally, QC lasers are unipolar devices, meaning that only one type of carrier, i.e. electrons, is involved in the process of light generation. The big advantage of these so-called intersubband transitions is that their energy can be tailored in a wide range by adjusting the thickness of the QWs and barriers. In contrast to interband transitions, where the material bandgap defines the transition energy, one can use the same two semiconductor materials for a variety of intersubband transition energies. Of course this nice advantage has its price. The first and most important drawback of intersubband transitions is that the lifetime of an excited state in a QW is extremely short, on the order of 1 ps. This time, which is a factor of 1000 shorter than in typical interband transitions, is controlled by optical phonon scattering, a process which works very efficiently at room temperature. The second point deserving attention is that the optical gain produced by one single intersubband transition is usually not sufficient to reach lasing threshold. While the second issue can be circumvented by using a cascade of up to 35 stages of gain and injector regions, the first point needs a more careful treatment. The fundamental idea for the generation of a population inversion in an intersubband laser structure is to take advantage of a three level system like in Fig. 1. The two lower levels (levels 1 and 2) are separated by exactly one optical phonon energy (34 meV for InP-based materials, 36 meV for GaAs-based materials). This results in a lower state lifetime of about τ21 = 0.5 ps, whereas the lifetime of the upper state (level 3) can be as long as τ32 = 2.0 ps. This trick was at the basis of the first working QC laser, and it has been refined since. Today’s state-of-the-art QC lasers use even a four level system with a double-phonon resonance at the lower laser level. The resulting improvement of the lifetime ratio has led to a considerably lower threshold current
High Performance Quantum Cascade Lasers and Their Applications
3
Te>>Tl
65
Te=Tl continuum
τ32 minigap 2 1
τ21 miniband
gain region injector region Fig. 1. Basic design features of a generic QC laser cell. One period is divided into a gain region (left half ) and an injector region (right half ). The flow of electrons is indicated by one-head arrows going from left to right; the optical transition by a wavy line. Te is the electron temperature, while Tl denotes the lattice temperature
density at room temperature. A typical stage of a QC laser is composed of a gain region (usually three or four QWs and barriers) and an injector region. The injector region fulfills different tasks; the most important ones are to build a minigap at the energy of the upper lasing level, to provide a miniband aligned with the lower laser levels, and to efficiently inject electrons via a tunnel barrier into the downstream gain region. The injection barrier has a thickness which results in an anticrossing energy splitting of about 15 meV between the injector ground state and the upper laser level. The injector minigap is needed to prevent the injected electrons from directly escaping into the continuum. Finally the miniband helps to efficiently extract the electrons from the gain region. As the carriers move towards the next injection barrier, the injector miniband reduces its width from initially roughly 150 meV to about one half of this value. This narrowing is important in order to cool down the electron distribution within the injector. Quite generally, one can calculate an approximate voltage drop of one photon energy plus roughly two or three phonon energies per period. For a laser operating at 10 µm emission wavelength, one computes 200 mV per period. If the threshold voltage does not exceed 7.6 V, we end up with a maximal number of stages of 38. In a QC laser, the current is obviously, at least in first order, not affected by this cascading scheme. One has therefore multiplied the gain at constant drive current, but at the cost of a relatively high operating voltage. The latter sometimes causes problems, for example when trying to reach CW operation at elevated temperatures or when directly modulating QC lasers at high frequencies. Let us now have a closer look on the two gain region designs which were used throughout this work. They are referred to as the three QW gain region
66
Daniel Hofstetter and J´erˆ ome Faist
or ‘diagonal-anticrossed’ design and the four QW gain region or ‘doublephonon resonance’ design. 2.2
Three Quantum Well Gain Region
Among the first working QC lasers were devices using double QW gain regions. Their width and barrier thicknesses were designed in order to produce three states named level 1, 2, and 3 as outlined in Sect. 2.1. Level 1 and level 2 are separated by a single phonon energy which makes the lifetime of level 2 very short (on the order of 0.5 ps). Levels 3 and 2 are separated by the desired photon energy and have a high spatial overlap. This results in a vertical transition with a lifetime of the upper lasing level of typically about 1–2 ps. In the three QW gain region design, which is also referred to as diagonal-anticrossed, the main novelty was the introduction of a third, narrow QW just between the injection barrier and the QW pair forming the three lasing states. This narrow well slightly delocalizes the wavefunction of level 3 towards the injection barrier, leading to an increased overlap between level 3 and the ground state of the injector, g. Since the first excited state of this thin well is energetically much higher than levels 1 and 2, their corresponding wavefunctions are not dragged towards the injection barrier; and therefore the overlap argument does not apply for these lower states. Due to the much smaller resulting overlap between level g and levels 1 and 2, injection into the lower laser levels is quite unlikely, while injection into level 3 is very efficient. The main results of the three QW design are thus a good injection efficiency into the upper laser level, a low probability of injecting into states 1 and 2, and a sufficiently high matrix element for the optical transition between the lasing levels 3 and 2. Because of the slightly diagonal nature of this transition, a pronounced Stark shift can be observed at high bias voltages. This effect has been utilized to fabricate Fabry–P´erot lasers with a large tuning range [52]. 2.3
Gain Region with Double-phonon Resonance
In order to achieve a further improvement of the lasing properties, new designs for the gain region have been invented. Taking advantage of the pioneering work of Scamarcio et al. [47] and Tredicucci et al. [53] on superlatticeinterminiband QC lasers,we developed a gain region which combines the good extraction efficiency of those devices and the efficient injection of the three QW gain region [19,46]. This new design is referred to as double-phonon resonance or 4 QW gain region [54], and it works equally well for lasers in the 5 µm and the 10 µm band. In the following, we present a design for a 5.3 µm QC laser, where the central portion of the waveguide consisted of 28 periods; each one of the latter contained a gain region and an injector region, separated by an injection- and an exit barrier. A schematic conduction band diagram of one period of the gain region is shown in Fig. 2.
High Performance Quantum Cascade Lasers and Their Applications
67
Injection barrier Exit barrier
g
4
MINIGAP 3 2 1
MINIBAND g
4 QW gain region
Injector region
Fig. 2. Schematic conduction band diagram of a portion of the active region and moduli squared of the relevant wavefunctions of a 5.3 µm QC laser with a 4 QW gain region. An electric field of 7.5 × 104 V/m was applied to align the structure. The In0.6 Ga0.4 As/In0.44 Al0.56 As layer sequence of one period of the active region, starting from the injection barrier is as follows: 42/13/14/50/14/44/15/39/24/29/19/26/20/23/21/22/23/21/30/21. Thicknesses are in ˚ A, In0.44 Al0.56 As barrier layers in bold, In0.6 Ga0.4 As QW layers are in roman, doped layers (Si, 4 × 1017 cm−3 ) are underlined
The upper and lower lasing states are the wavefunctions with numbers 4 and 3, respectively; and the ground state of the injector is denoted with the letter g. The gain region was composed of 4 QWs which resulted in three coupled lower states (levels 1, 2, and 3). Each two of the latter (i.e. level 3 to 2, and level 2 to 1) were separated by one phonon energy. This double-phonon resonance yielded a short intersubband electron scattering −1 −1 −1 + τ31 ) = 0.25 ps), and time (τ32 = 0.31 ps, τ31 = 1.24 ps, τlow = (τ32 therefore an efficient extraction of the electrons into the injector region. The upper lasing state exhibits a much longer intersubband electron scat−1 −1 −1 −1 + τ42 + τ41 ) = 1.25 ps (using τ43 = 3.41 ps, tering time of τup = (τ43 τ42 = 3.26 ps, and τ41 = 5.07 ps). The relatively large dipole matrix element, z43 = 2.1 nm, confirms that the lasing transition is mainly a vertical one. Thanks to the thin first well, which reduces the overlap of the injector ground state g with the lower lasing state wavefunctions 1, 2, and 3, the injection efficiency was kept similarly high as in the classical 3 QW design. Finally, the use of strained material makes the barrier height considerably larger (620 meV
68
Daniel Hofstetter and J´erˆ ome Faist
instead of 520 meV like for unstrained material), which quite efficiently reduces electron tunneling from the upper lasing state into the continuum. In addition, all wells can be made somewhat thicker, which has a positive effect on the interfacial roughness scattering. This is consistent with the relatively narrow linewidth of the luminescence peak measured at 4 K (hν = 244 meV, ∆E = 11 meV) and at 300 K (hν = 233 meV, ∆E = 25 meV).
3
Fabrication Technologies
In this section, we present several key processing steps which were used for the fabrication of the different DFB lasers described in the current work. The aim of these processes was, at least in the beginning, to find simple solutions which would yield acceptable results. Later we went on to more sophisticated fabrication methods which resulted in higher performance. 3.1
Surface Grating with Lateral Current Injection
Epitaxial regrowth is often considered as a costly and risky process. The most obvious method to avoid epitaxial regrowth in DFB lasers consists of fabricating the grating directly on top of the waveguide [39]. However, in order to prevent the top contact metal from introducing a large waveguide loss (which is especially harmful for QC lasers since they are operating in TM mode), one has to either decrease the grating coupling coefficient by utilizing a thicker top cladding layer, choose a metal with small refractive and absorption indices [55], or completely avoid the metal on top of the waveguide [56]. As shown in Fig. 3, such a device consists basically of a waveguide with a semiconductor lower cladding layer and air acting as top cladding. The heavily n-doped InGaAs cap layer, which serves as host layer for the grating, is highly conducting to allow lateral current injection and distribution throughout the device. The most important consequences of such a design are obviously that there is a large refractive index step between semiconductor and air, and that there are low calculated losses of 12 cm−1 . This results in both a high coupling coefficient of the grating and a relatively high net gain of the laser; thus it potentially allows the fabrication of short devices with a low threshold current. This type of DFB laser operating in both the 5 µm and the 10 µm bands will be presented in Sect. 4.2. The growth for this type of QC laser was based on MBE of lattice matched InGaAs/InAlAs layers on top of an n-doped InP (Si, 2 × 1017 cm−3 ) substrate. The growth process started with the lower waveguide layer (In0.53 Ga0.47 As, Si, 6 × 1016 cm−3 , total thickness 1.5 µm), proceeded with an active region (thickness 1.75 µm) and a 2.1 µm thick upper waveguide layer (In0.53 Ga0.47 As, Si, 6 × 1016 cm−3 ) and was terminated with a 0.5 µm thick highly n-doped contact layer on top (In0.53 Ga0.47 As, Si,
High Performance Quantum Cascade Lasers and Their Applications
69
InGaAs waveguide layers grating and lateral contact layer ZnSe isolation layer
active region
Ti/Au contact layer
InP substrate
(a)
50 µm
(b)
Fig. 3. (a) Schematic cross-section through the laser waveguide showing the exact position of the grating with respect to the active layer and the metal top contact. (b) Scanning electron microscopy picture of a QC DFB laser. Please note that there is no metal in the central top part of the ridge waveguide
2 × 1018 cm−3 ). This contact layer was also the host layer for the grating. The active region, which thus formed the central part of the waveguide, consisted of 35 periods; those were alternating n-doped funnel injector regions and un-doped triple QW gain regions. The laser transition in the latter was diagonal, similar as described in [19]. The layer sequence of the structure, starting from the injection barrier, is as follows: 42/31/9/64/10/60/28/39/10/38/12/37/15/39/17/40. All thicknesses are in ˚ A, In0.52 Al0.48 As barrier layers are in bold, In0.53 Ga0.47 As well layers are in roman, and n-doped layers (Si, 2.5 × 1017 cm−3 ) are underlined. A more detailed description of the structure was published in a paper about wavelength tunable Fabry–P´erot lasers fabricated from material using the same active region [52]. The fabrication of these DFB lasers relied on holographically defining a grating with 1.59 µm period (neff = 3.22), and wet chemical etching of
70
Daniel Hofstetter and J´erˆ ome Faist
the grating in an HBr:H2 O2 :H2 O solution to a depth of 0.4 µm. We used a 488 nm Ar-ion laser and a 90◦ corner reflector mounted on a rotational stage for the grating exposure. Standard processing techniques were then employed to define ridge waveguides with a width of 35–55 µm (etch depth 4.5 µm) and a length of 1–1.5 mm. 300 nm of ZnSe served as an electrical passivation layer, Ti/Au (10/400 nm) was used as the top contact metal. Thinning, back contacting (Ge/Au/Ag/Au, 12/27/50/100 nm), and cleaving completed the processing. As shown by the schematic cross-section in Fig. 3a and the scanning electron microscopy picture in Fig. 3b, the contact metal covered only the edges (about 5 µm on each side) of the ridge to prevent large absorption losses in the waveguide, but still allow lateral current injection. 3.2
Lasers with InP Regrowth
Although DFB lasers with surface gratings are, among other amenities, quite simple to fabricate, they suffer from their own specific drawbacks. The most important one is the fragile top contact which tends to overheat, and which does not help very much in distributing the heat. In order to improve the thermal conductivity and the modal overlap, the top cladding should consist of the same material as the lower cladding layer. This can be achieved by growing, in a first step, only the active region and the waveguiding layers. In a second epitaxial growth, the InP top cladding is grown, ideally in an MOVPE system. The second growth is performed after a thorough cleaning of the surface in concentrated sulfuric acid. Depending on the emission wavelength of the laser, the typical sequence of these layers might be as follows: a 2.5 µm thick top cladding layer (InP, Si, 1 × 1017 cm−3 ), a 0.85 µm thick contact layer (InP, Si, 7 × 1018 cm−3 ), and a 10 nm thick cap layer (InP, Si, 1 × 1020 cm−3 ). An even further improvement of the thermal properties can be achieved by growing InP around the entire active region (buried heterostructure design). This requires two regrowth steps in the MOVPE. The first one for the top cladding; the second after having etched ridge waveguides into the material. Such a process will be described in Sect. 4.5. 3.3
Junction Down Mounting
In order to fully benefit from the good thermal conductivity of an InP top cladding, it is necessary to mount the lasers with their active area directly on the heatsink material. This technique is called junction down mounting. For all mounting techniques, we thermally evaporated a 2 µm thick In layer on copper heatsinks. A thin layer of soldering flux was then deposited on the surface. Afterwards, the laser chips were pressed onto this surface and the whole sandwich was heated to 160 ◦ C for a couple of seconds. Flux remnants were then removed by acetone and subsequent O2 -plasma cleaning. An important parameter of the whole procedure is the distance between the front facet and the front edge of the copper heatsink. If this distance is too large,
High Performance Quantum Cascade Lasers and Their Applications
71
the facet cannot be cleaned properly; if the distance is too small or ‘negative’ (overhanging laser), there is a certain risk that the end section of the laser is not correctly cooled; this can cause severe damage of the device at high duty cycle operation.
4
Measurement Results
This section describes the results achieved with the different devices. We will first present the measurement setup, and then continue with the results from DFB lasers with lateral current injection, surface-emitting DFB lasers, devices with InP-regrowth, and junction-down mounted DFB lasers. At the very end of the section, we will briefly outline the results of the experiments with our room temperature CW QC lasers. 4.1
Measurement Setup
For device testing at low duty cycle, we mounted the lasers on small copper heatsinks which were then placed into a temperature controlled N2 flow cryostat. The light of the QC DFB laser was collected by f/0.8 optics and fed into a high resolution Fourier transform IR spectrometer (Nicolet type Magna-IR 860, FTIR), where we detected it using a liquid nitrogen cooled HgCdTe detector. For the measurement of L–I curves, we measured the intensity with a calibrated 250 × 250 µm2 room temperature HgCdTe detector. Typical pulsed operating conditions used throughout this work were 100 ns pulses with a 5–10 kHz repetition frequency. These conditions guaranteed that minimal device heating would occur during the single pulse. A boxcar integrator allowed us to detect the intensity during that period within the pulse where the laser ran stably. When going to elevated duty cycles, mounting was typically junction down, either on copper heatsinks or on diamond platelets soldered onto copper. Testing was done in a Peltier-cooled aluminum box with an antireflection coated ZnSe window. In this box, they were held at a constant temperature between −30 ◦ C and 60 ◦ C. A commercial pulse generator (Alpes Lasers, TPG 128) with power supply (Alpes Lasers, LDD 100) allowed us to deliver arbitrary long current pulses (10–200 ns) at a variable repetition frequency of up to 5 MHz to the laser. For spectral measurements, two different possibilities were investigated; namely a grating spectrometer and FTIR. In the case of testing with a grating spectrometer, the light of the QC DFB laser was collected by an f/1.33 Au-coated parabolic mirror, directed onto a flat mirror to turn the polarization, and finally bounced off a f/3.75 parabolic mirror to enter the 200 µm wide entrance slit of the spectrometer (Jobin-Yvon, dfocal = 0.3 m). Behind the spectrometer, the light was detected with a battery-driven pyro-electric detector. For the measurement of L–I curves, we measured the average power
72
Daniel Hofstetter and J´erˆ ome Faist
directly in front of the ZnSe window with a calibrated thermopile detector. In the case of the spectral measurement with an FTIR, we used the same optics as already mentioned above. 4.2 DFB Laser with Lateral Current Injection in the 5 µm and 10 µm Band This section is devoted to the results from lasers with lateral current injection. This technique is simple, reliable, and yielded lasers with very good peak powers. It has also been tried for Fabry–P´erot lasers in the 5 µm band. The drawback of this method is clearly the poor thermal management. Edge Emitting DFB Laser at 10 µm
4.2.1
Typical L–I and I–V curves of a 45 µm wide and 1.2 mm long device are shown in Fig. 4. The current pulses were 100 ns long, and a pulse repetition frequency of 5 kHz was used for all temperatures. At low temperatures, we observed a threshold current of 1 A and a maximum output power of 230 mW for 9.7 V bias voltage. The slope efficiency at this temperature was 220 mW/A and a threshold current density of 1.85 kA/cm2 was determined. At room temperature, we still obtained 80 mW optical output power with a slope efficiency of 80 mW/A; however, the threshold current increased to 2.9 A (threshold current density of 5.4 kA/cm2 ), and an operating voltage of 12.5 V was seen. From the increase in threshold current, we were able to derive a characteristic temperature T0 of 204 K.
20
300
Voltage [V]
15
T0 = 204 K
80K
4
100K 150K
2 100
10
200
200 300 Temperature [K]
200K 250K
80K
100 280K
5 300K
Output power [mW]
2
j th [kA/cm ]
6
300K
0
0
1 2 3 Injection current [A]
4
0
Fig. 4. L–I and I–V curves of a 45 µm wide and 1.2 mm long DFB QC laser measured at different temperatures. The inset shows a plot of the threshold current density versus device temperature
High Performance Quantum Cascade Lasers and Their Applications
73
A spectral measurement below the lasing threshold revealed regular Fabry–P´erot modes with a spacing of 1.7 cm−1 (cavity length: 850 µm). The Bragg reflector’s stopband with a width of 2.5 cm−1 occurred almost at the centre of the spontaneous emission peak, at 995.7 cm−1 (85 K), 994.6 cm−1 (105 K), and at 992.3 cm−1 (150 K). From the stopband-width, we determined the coupling coefficient of the grating to be κ = ∆ λπneff /λ2 = 24 cm−1 ; this number agrees well with a value obtained from an estimation based on the effective refractive index difference of ∆ n = 1.8 × 10−2 between areas with and without the grating layer (κ = π∆ neff /2λ = 28 cm−1 ). A relatively small free carrier absorption loss of 12 cm−1 was calculated for this device, whereas a laser utilizing our standard waveguide design with a 2.2 µm thick InAlAs/InGaAs upper cladding layer and a metal-covered grating would suffer from a waveguide loss of 30 cm−1 . In addition, the refractive index contrast would be reduced by almost two orders of magnitude, namely to a value of ∆ n = 2.3 × 10−4 . Since the partial removal of the contact layer leads to a slight gain variation, a small amount of loss coupling might also be present in this device. Figure 5 shows the lasing spectra at temperatures between 85 K and 300 K. We observed single-mode operation for all temperatures and, in particular, at maximum power for each individual temperature. We determined the linewidth to be on the order of 0.3 cm−1 , which corresponds to the resolution limit of our experimental set-up. The emission wavelength at 85 K was 996 cm−1 ; at room temperature, it decreased to 982 cm−1 . As already mentioned above, the luminescence peak was found in the vicinity of 975 cm−1 for all temperatures. The temperature tuning coefficient of the lasing peak was constant over the entire temperature range, and its magnitude was 1/λ × ∆ λ/∆ T = 6.5 × 10−5 K−1 (∆ ν/∆ T = −0.063 cm−1 /K). These numbers are consistent with what has been reported in the literature [22].
Intensity [a.u.]
1.0 0.8 0.6
300K
85K
0.4 0.2 0 970
980
990
1000
1010
-1
Wavenumbers [cm ] Fig. 5. Lasing spectra of a 45 µm wide and 850 µm long DFB QC laser at different temperatures between 85 and 300 K. All spectra were measured with the maximum possible output power at each individual temperature
74
Daniel Hofstetter and J´erˆ ome Faist
In a second processing run with a changed grating period of 1.63 µm (instead of 1.59 µm), we were able to perform some measurements regarding the influence of a detuning between the Bragg peak and gain peak. The first series of DFB lasers with a detuning of about 5–10 cm−1 at room temperature (Λ = 1.59 µm) showed high performance at all temperatures. The second series with a detuning of about 30 cm−1 (Λ = 1.63 µm) did not lase at room temperature, and at low temperatures, the output power did not exceed 60 mW. Since we determined a full width at half maximum (FWHM) of the gain peak of ∆ ν = 65 cm−1 , it is clear that the laser performance will degrade rapidly with increasing de-tuning between the Bragg reflection maximum and gain peak. 4.2.2
Surface Emitting 10 µm DFB Laser
The fabrication of these second order DFB lasers started again by holographically defining a grating with 3.15 µm period (neff = 3.22), and wet chemical etching of the grating in a HBr:H2 O2 :H2 O solution to a depth of 0.6 µm (etch rate approximately 100 nm/s). The grating lines run along the dove-tail direction of the crystal in order to achieve a non-rectangular tooth profile and to obtain a sufficiently high first-order Fourier component. This is quite critical for device performance because a symmetric rectangular second-order grating contains no first-order Fourier component. Unfortunately, grating fabrication by holography and wet etching usually results in under-etching and leads to narrow grating lines and large spaces between them. Because a small duty cycle reduces the average refractive index and therefore the overlap factor of the grating layer, the coupling coefficient and the diffraction efficiency of the grating become small, resulting in a limited amount of surface-emitted power. Typical edge emission L–I and current versus voltage (I–V ) curves of a 55 µm wide and 1.125 mm long device showed a threshold current of 1.3 A and a maximum output power of 210 mW from the facet (Fig. 6). The slope efficiency at this temperature was 105 mW/A and a threshold current density of 2.1 kA/cm2 was determined [57]. At room temperature, we obtained 70 mW optical output power from the facet, with a slope efficiency of 70 mW/A. However, the threshold current increased to 3.45 A (threshold current density of 5.6 kA/cm2 ), and an operating voltage of 10.5 V was seen. From the increase in threshold current, we were able to derive a characteristic temperature T0 of 258 K. The higher slope efficiencies at 150 and 200 K (compared to 85 K) are due to the fact that the grating resonance wavelength is tuned at the center of the gain peak at these temperatures. This also explains the higher T0 value of these devices than our previously published DFB lasers [39]. Figure 6 shows a comparison between the L–I-characteristics for both the facet and grating emissions. Because of the unfavorable duty cycle of the grating (about 0.25–0.35 instead of 0.7), there is a bigger fraction of the total energy radiated from the facet than from the grating. Nevertheless, we
High Performance Quantum Cascade Lasers and Their Applications
75
200 85 K
Output power [mW]
175
150K
150 125 100 75
grating emission facet emission
300 K
85 K 50 150 K 25
300 K
0 0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 3.0 3.5 4.0 4.5
Injection current [A] Fig. 6. Comparison between L–I curves with the output intensity collected from the facet and the grating at three representative temperatures. The inset shows a scanning electron micrograph of the grating
Far field intensity [a.u.]
1.0
perpendicular parallel
0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0.0 -15
-10
-5
0
5
10
15
Far field angle [ °] Fig. 7. Far field distributions of the surface emission from a second-order DFB QC laser measured in two orthogonal directions (along and perpendicular to the waveguide)
obtained an optical output power from the grating of 60 mW at 85 K and 18 mW at 300 K; these values correspond to slope efficiencies of 30 mW/A and 18 mW/A, respectively. In Fig. 7, we present the far field distribution of the grating emission in both directions. In the direction along the waveguide, we observed, due to the wide aperture and the Bragg reflection, a very narrow far field angle of about 1◦ (FWHM), whereas in the other, perpendicular direction, the far field angle was equivalent to the one observed at the corresponding direction of the facet, namely about 14◦ (FWHM). According to [58], a certain amount of gain/loss coupling is always present in
76
Daniel Hofstetter and J´erˆ ome Faist
a second order DFB laser. This loss coupling should prevent the device from oscillation in both stopband modes. Most likely because of their relatively weak coupling coefficient, we nevertheless observed, on short devices and at high injection currents, lasing action in both stopband modes. This allowed us a relatively precise measurement of the Bragg reflector’s stopband-width; the value was ∆ ν = 1.1 cm−1 . From this figure, we determined the coupling coefficient of the grating to be κ = ∆ λπneff /λ2 = 12 cm−1 ; with neff being the effective refractive index of the propagating mode. This number is of the same order of magnitude as the calculated value obtained from the effective refractive index difference of ∆ neff = 1.8 × 10−2 between areas with and without the grating layer (κ = π∆ neff /2λ = 9 cm−1 ) and the first Fourier component of the grating teeth. The spectral behavior was very similar as presented for the edge emitting DFB laser presented in Sect. 4.2.1. The emission wavelength at 85 K was 1003 cm−1 ; at room temperature, it decreased to 989 cm−1 . The luminescence peak was found in the vicinity of 1000 cm−1 for all temperatures. The temperature tuning coefficient of the lasing peak was constant over the entire temperature range, and its magnitude was 1/λ × ∆ λ/∆ T = 6.1 × 10−5 K−1 (∆ ν/∆ T = −0.06 cm−1 /K). 4.2.3
Improved Average Power Operation at 10 µm
Some fine tuning in the crystal growth and an improved top metallization made these DFB lasers much more robust. This resulted mainly in higher duty cycle operation than what was reported in Sect. 4.2.1 [19,39,57]. The fabrication process started again by holographically defining a grating with 1.6378 µm period (neff = 3.163), and wet chemical etching of the grating to a depth of 0.3 µm in a H3 PO4 :H2 O2 :H2 O solution (4:1:10, etch rate 800 nm/min). The main difference to the former device processing was the thickness of the top contact. Here, we used 1 µm Au instead of only 400 nm. This had a positive effect on the device heating, but also improved the contact problem across the 4 µm high step between the top of the ridge and the contact pad. At 1.5% duty cycle, we observed threshold currents of 4.35 A at −30 ◦ C and 5.8 A at 60 ◦ C; these values are equivalent to threshold current densities of 5.3 kA/cm2 and 7 kA/cm2 , respectively. Figure 8 shows the maximal average output power measured at a duty cycle of 3%. The highest output power was achieved at −30 ◦ C; its value at the thermal roll-over point was 13.6 mW. At room temperature, we still observed 4 mW, and finally, at 60 ◦ C, the value decreased to 1.5 mW. The last number which was smaller than the one for 1.5% duty cycle indicates that, at a temperature of 60 ◦ C, the duty cycle with the best performance is smaller than 3%. Considering the high voltage necessary to achieve these output powers, it becomes clear that the device suffers from excessive heating, in particular at higher temperatures. This hypothesis is confirmed by the emission spectra at maximal output power and different temperatures between −30 ◦ C and 60 ◦ C. A pulse length of 45 ns and a pulse repetition frequency of 667 kHz was
High Performance Quantum Cascade Lasers and Their Applications
77
Voltage [V]
-30 °C
10
10
5
-30 °C
5
60 °C
0
60 °C
0
2
4 6 Current(A)
8
Average power [mW]
15 S1805g7up 3 % duty cycle junction up
15
0
Fig. 8. Average power and voltage versus current curves of a 1.5 mm long QC DFB laser operated at 3% duty cycle and at different temperatures between −30 ◦ C and 60 ◦ C
used to drive the laser at a duty cycle of 3%. The single emission peak tunes from 968.6 cm−1 at −30 ◦ C to 961.4 cm−1 at 60 ◦ C. The temperature tuning is ∆ ν/∆ T = −0.08 cm−1 /K, a value which is 27% larger than the one we reported earlier for devices running at low duty cycle. Since the temperature tuning of a DFB laser is only due to a temperature-induced refractive index change, we are able to estimate the overheating of the laser at a heatsink temperature of 60 ◦ C. Under the assumption of a temperature difference ∆ T between the active region and the device holder at −30 ◦ C, we find at 60 ◦ C using the usually observed temperature tuning of DFB lasers a much larger temperature difference of ∆ T + 25 K. This is consistent with the observed increase in threshold current from 5.8 A to 6.1 A at this temperature when going from 1.5% to 3% duty cycle. 4.2.4
High Temperature Operation at 5.3 µm
These lasers utilized a gain region based on a double-phonon resonance as outlined in Sect. 2.3. Fabrication relied this time on MBE of straincompensated In0.6 Ga0.4 As/In0.44 Al0.56 As layers on top of an n-doped InP (Si, 2 × 1017 cm−3 ) substrate. The growth process started with the lower waveguide layers (In0.53 Ga0.47 As, Si, 6 × 1016 cm−3 , thickness 0.34 µm), proceeded with an active region (Si, thickness 1.43 µm) and was finished by a thicker set of upper waveguide layers (In0.53 Ga0.47 As, Si, 6 × 1016 cm−3 , thickness 0.5 µm) and a highly n-doped cap layer (In0.53 Ga0.47 As, Si, 2 × 1018 cm−3 , thickness 0.4 µm) on top. This cap layer was also the host layer for the grating, as reported earlier [39,57]. The fabrication process started once more by holographically defining a grating with 0.825 µm period (neff = 3.21), and wet chemical etching of the grating to a depth of 100 nm in a H3 PO4 :H2 O2 :H2 O solution (4:1:10, etch rate 800 nm/min). Wet chemical etching in a HBr:H2 O2 :H2 O solution (1:1:10, etch rate 800 nm/min) was then used to define broad ridge waveguides with
78
Daniel Hofstetter and J´erˆ ome Faist
a width of 44 µm (etch depth 5 µm) and a length of 3 mm. 300 nm of Si3 N4 served as an electrical passivation layer and Ti/Au (10/1000 nm) was used as the top contact metal. Thinning to a thickness of 150 µm, back contacting (Ge/Au/Ag/Au, 12/27/50/100 nm), and cleaving completed the processing. Typical L–I and I–V curves of a 44 µm wide and 3 mm long device are shown in Fig. 9. The 45 ns long pulses came along with a pulse repetition frequency of 333 kHz; this corresponds to a duty cycle of 1.5%. The emitted peak power drops from 1.15 W at 0 ◦ C via 0.45 W at 60 ◦ C to 92 mW at 120 ◦ C. These maximum power values correspond to slope effciencies of 247 mW/A at 0 ◦ C, 135 mW/A at 60 ◦ C, and finally 45 mW/A at 120 ◦ C. We observed threshold currents of 4.1 A at 0 ◦ C, 5.6 A at 60 ◦ C, and 7.4 A at 120 ◦ C; these values are equivalent to threshold current densities of 3.1 kA/cm2 , 4.2 kA/cm2 , and 5.6 kA/cm2 at the respective temperatures. The characteristic temperature, T0 , which empirically describes the behavior of the threshold current as a function of the temperature, was 203 K. As a comparison, we also fabricated Fabry–P´erot (FP) lasers from the same material, using the same lateral current injection scheme and an identical geometry. For those multimode lasers, we achieved even higher peak powers of 1.76 W at 0 ◦ C (dP/dI = 311 mW/A, jth = 3 kA/cm2 ) and 0.83 W at 60 ◦ C (dP/dI = 258 mW/A, jth = 5.4 kA/cm2 ). T0 was with 190 K comparably high as for the DFB lasers. The excellent performance of both DFB and FP devices demonstrates that lateral current injection with or without surface gratings is a very effective technique for high power QC lasers [54]. In Fig. 10, we present the emission spectra measured at the thermal rollover point for five representative temperatures between 0 ◦ C and 120 ◦C. The same pulse lengths and repetition rates as in Fig. 9 were used for this experiment. The single lasing mode tunes linearly with temperature from 1898 cm−1
Voltage [V]
15
1.2
S1869b2dn junction up 1.5 % duty cycle
0 °C
0.8
10
0 °C 120 °C
0.4
5
Peak power [W]
0
Current density [kA/cm2] 2 4 6
120 °C
0
0
2
4 6 Current(A)
8
0 10
Fig. 9. L–I and I–V curves of a 44 µm wide and 3 mm long QC DFB laser at a wavelength of 5.3 µm. The curves were measured at a duty cycle of 1.5% and at five different temperatures between 0 ◦ C and 120 ◦ C
High Performance Quantum Cascade Lasers and Their Applications
Wavelength [µm] 5.32 5.30 5.28
5.34
Intensity [a.u.]
10 1
79
5.26
S1869b2dn junction up 1.5 % duty cycle
0.1
0°C
120 °C
0.01 1870
1880
1890
1900 -1
Wavenumbers [cm ] Fig. 10. Emission spectra of a 44 µm wide and 3 mm long QC DFB laser at a wavelength of 5.3 µm. The spectra were collected at the same five temperatures as the L–I–V curves of Fig. 9 and at the thermal roll-over point for each temperature
at 0 ◦ C to 1881 cm−1 at 120 ◦ C. We thus obtained a temperature tuning rate of ∆ ν/∆ T = −0.145 cm−1 /K. Because of the limited dynamical range of our set-up, a correct measurement of the side mode suppression ratio (SMSR) is not possible. Keeping this fact in mind, we understand that the signal to noise ratio (SNR) of the lasing peaks in Fig. 10 is only a lower limit for the SMSR. Due to the power decrease at higher temperatures, these SNR values drop from 30 dB at 0 ◦ C to 20 dB at 120 ◦C. Obviously this does not necessarily mean that the SMSR dropped also by 10 dB. The full width at half maximum linewidth of the emission peaks is on the order of 0.75 cm−1 for all investigated temperatures. It is obvious that thermal chirping dictates this linewidth, similar as outlined in [45]. For this reason, we made experiments with a reduced pulse length (down to 20 ns) and found a linewidth on the order of 0.15 cm−1 . The maximal average output power at three different temperatures was measured up to 60 ◦ C. This experiment was done using 45 ns pulses as well, but with a higher repetition frequency of 1.11 MHz; this results in a duty cycle of 5%. The highest output power was achieved at 0 ◦ C; its value at the thermal roll-over point was 39.5 mW. At room temperature, we still observed 22.5 mW, and finally, at 60 ◦ C, the value decreased to 9.5 mW. As reported in Sect. 4.2.3 on a 10.4 µm DFB laser using the same lateral contact scheme, we observed that the duty cycle yielding the highest thermal rollover power changed with temperature. This is illustrated best when dividing the average thermal roll-over powers at 5% and 1.5% duty cycle for the three available temperatures. At 0 ◦ C, the ratio r = Pmax (5%)/Pmax (1.5%) is 2.28, at 30 ◦ C we find r = 1.94, and finally at 60 ◦ C we obtain r = 1.38. This shows how the laser suffers from overheating at elevated temperatures, which
80
Daniel Hofstetter and J´erˆ ome Faist
is understandable when taking into account the small area into which current is injected. Another indication for this overheating effect is given by the temperature tuning rate of ∆ ν/∆ T = −0.145 cm−1 /K, which is somewhat larger than what has been published in the literature. In [21], for example, a value of ∆ ν/∆ T = −0.124 cm−1 /K was reported. Finally, the overheating manifests itself also in slightly higher threshold current densities, for example 3.35 kA/cm2 for 5% at 0 ◦ C compared to 3.1 kA/cm2 for 1.5% at 0 ◦ C. Taking into account the T0 value from above, such an increase of the threshold current density corresponds to a temperature increase in the active region of almost 15 K. 4.3
DFB Lasers with InP Over-Grown Grating
Overheating effects like the ones mentioned in Sect. 4.2.3 play an important role for laser performance and ageing. This is particularly critical for DFB lasers comprising a lateral current injection scheme. Because of their small contact area, the current density in the narrow metal stripes reaches a multiple of the one in the entire laser structure. Already at moderate duty cycles of a few percent, this can lead to contact degradation. Furthermore, if high average output powers are pursued, junction down mounting is the way to go. Since a metal layer on a surface grating is detrimental for device performance, lasers with a lateral contact scheme do not allow junction down mounting. Thus, for reaching high output powers, epitaxially regrown DFB lasers are better suited. In the following, we will present two different laser structures. They are both based on double-phonon resonance gain regions; and they both have the grating overgrown with an InP top cladding. Device S1850 was tested only in junction up configuration. Nevertheless, it performed extremely well at high temperatures of up to 150 ◦ C. On the other hand, S1810 (which was mounted junction down) could be driven at high average output powers. The layer structure of S1850 has been published in [32]. For the first of these DFB lasers, L–I and I–V curves as a function of temperature are presented in Fig. 11. This device was 24 µm wide and 1.5 mm long. The curves are obtained at 1.5% duty cycle in order to demonstrate the excellent high temperature capability of the material. The highest temperature for which we could reliably measure the L–I–V curve was 130 ◦ C. The threshold current increase from 0.95 A at −20 ◦ C to 2.2 A at 130 ◦ C corresponds to a characteristic temperature of 179 K. At −20 ◦ C, we observed a slope efficiency of 187 mW/A with a roll-over power of 300 mW; while at 130 ◦C, 62 mW/A and 47 mW were seen. In Fig. 12, we present the emission spectra measured at temperatures between 0 ◦ C and 150 ◦ C and a constant current of 2.5 A. The duty cycle for this series of measurements was 0.1% with 20 ns long pulses and a repetition rate of 50 kHz. Depending on the heatsink temperature, a side mode suppression ratio of at least 20 dB was seen. The emission peak shifted continuously from
High Performance Quantum Cascade Lasers and Their Applications 12
Voltage [V]
300
8
200 4
100
0
1
2
3
Peak power [mW]
400 S1850b2 junction up 1.5% duty cycle
0
81
0
Current [A]
Fig. 11. Series of L–I and I–V curves of a 24 µm wide and 1.5 mm long DFB laser taken from the sample S1850 and at different temperatures between −20 ◦ C and 130 ◦ C. For this particular measurement, a duty cycle of 1.5% (45 ns pulse length/ 333 kHz pulse repetition frequency) was used
Intensity [a.u.]
1000
S1850b2 junction up 0.1 % duty cycle
100 10 1 1100
1105
1110
1115 -1
Wavenumbers [cm ] Fig. 12. Series of emission spectra of a 24 µm wide and 1.5 mm long DFB laser taken from the sample S1850 and at different temperatures between 0 ◦ C and 150 ◦ C (spacing 10 ◦ C). Each spectrum was measured at an injection current of 2.5 A and at 0.1% duty cycle
1114 cm−1 at 0 ◦ C to 1102.4 cm−1 at 150 ◦ C. This is equivalent to a temperature tuning coefficient of 1/λ × ∆ λ/∆ T = −6.95 × 10−5 K−1 . At low temperatures, where the operating current of 2.5 A was much larger than the threshold current, the laser suffered somewhat from chirping. This led to a small shoulder on the long wavelength side (i.e. the small wavenumber side) of the main peak. The high operating temperature of these DFB lasers could be used to investigate the temperature dependence of the thermal conductivity of the S1850 laser material. For this purpose, we measured another two series of
82
Daniel Hofstetter and J´erˆ ome Faist
emission spectra under slightly different conditions. In the first experiment, the baseline of the electrical pulses was shifted from 0 mA to 50 mA. This is equivalent to having a 50 mA DC bias, on top of which we added a pulsed signal 50 mA smaller than before. For each temperature and a total current of 2.5 A, the wavelength was compared to the one obtained at normal conditions (no DC bias). In the second measurement, we increased the DC bias to 100 mA and measured again the emission wavelength for each temperature. The DC bias-induced heating caused a measurable wavelength shift of the DFB laser. For each given temperature, this wavelength shift (or temperature increase) remained at a constant value of −0.12 cm−1 for 50 mA DC bias (Vdevice = 2.5 V) and −0.36 cm−1 for 100 mA DC bias (Vdevice = 3.5 V). Since a constant temperature increase was observed for all investigated temperatures (when adding a certain DC bias), we can conclude that the thermal conductivity remained unchanged with increasing temperature. From the additional power to be dissipated and the observed temperature increase, we can calculate the thermal resistance using Rth = ∆ T /(Vdevice × IDC ); this yields Rth = 14.7 K/W or (taking into account the area of the laser) gth = 190 W/K cm2 . 4.4
High Power Junction Down Mounted Lasers
Different spectroscopic techniques in the mid-IR wavelength range have suffered from the absence of convenient semiconductor light sources. Lead salt lasers have existed for a long time, but their highest CW operating temperature could not be pushed beyond 220 K [59]. In addition, even at cryogenic temperatures, their output power remained relatively small, in the range of a couple of milliwatts [60]. Since QC lasers can work in continuous wave up to room temperature, they are very interesting light sources for spectroscopic applications. A variety of different experimental configurations and emission wavelengths has been published in the last couple of years, among them PA spectroscopy [29,42] and single-pass or multiple-pass absorption spectroscopy [50]. As mentioned above, the highest power output is possible if a DFB laser with InP top cladding is mounted with its active side directly on a copper holder. This is exactly what we did with S1810. The layer sequence of sample S1810, starting from the injection barrier, was 38/21/7/63/9/59/9/54/22/36/14/34/14/32/18/31/20/31. All thicknesses are in ˚ A, In0.52 Al0.48 As barrier layers are in bold, In0.53 Ga0.47 As well layers are in roman, and n-doped layers (Si, 3 × 1017 cm−3 ) are underlined. Figure 13 shows a series of L–I and I–V curves of a 26 µm wide and 1.5 mm long DFB laser taken from sample S1810. For this particular measurement, a duty cycle of 16% was used. The emitted average power was 71 mW at −30 ◦C and 15 mW at 60 ◦ C. At 1.5% duty cycle, we observed maximal slope efficiencies of 194 mW/A at −30 ◦ C and 93 mW/A at 60 ◦ C. The corresponding threshold currents were 2.3 A and 3.34 A; these values are equivalent to threshold current densities of 5.9 kA/cm2 and 8.55 kA/cm2 at
High Performance Quantum Cascade Lasers and Their Applications
60
-30 °C
8 40
-30 °C
4
20
60 °C
0
60 °C
0
1
2
3 4 Current(A)
5
6
Average power [mW]
Voltage [V]
80
S1810c6 junction dn 16 % duty cycle
12
83
0
Fig. 13. Series of L–I and I–V curves of a 26 µm wide and 1.5 mm long DFB laser taken from the sample S1810 and at different temperatures between −30 ◦ C and 60 ◦ C. For this particular measurement, a duty cycle of 16% (45 ns pulse length/ 3.6 MHz pulse repetition frequency) was used
the respective temperatures. The characteristic temperature, T0 , which empirically describes the behavior of the threshold current as a function of the temperature, was 243 K. Exact matching between the Bragg and gain peak was achieved at 40 ◦ C; this led to a T0 value which was somewhat better than the one observed with the Fabry–P´erot laser fabricated from the same material (T0FP = 183 K). At 16% duty cycle, the threshold currents were 2.7 A for −30 ◦ C and 4.4 A for 60 ◦ C, giving rise to a slightly lower T0 value of 184 K. From the threshold current values at low and high duty cycle and the T0 at low duty, one can estimate the temperature increase ∆ T in the active region with respect to the copper heatsink. This calculation shows that for higher temperatures, the laser active region heats again faster than the heatsink (∆ T = 39 K at −30 ◦ C and ∆ T = 67 K at 60 ◦ C) [45,57]. This is also illustrated by the slightly elevated temperature tuning coefficient which can be derived from the spectra shown in Fig. 14. These spectra are measured at 16% duty cycle and the maximal output power for each temperature. The laser can be continuously tuned from 1046 cm−1 at −30 ◦C to 1038 cm−1 at 60 ◦ C with a tuning coefficient of 1/λ × ∆ λ/∆ T = −8.5 × 10−5 K−1 . Due to the overheating of the active region, this value is about 22% larger than expected from the temperature-induced refractive index change [21]. The spectral width of about 1 cm−1 is due to the duration of the electrical pulses; for shorter electrical pulses, we observed a proportional linewidth narrowing. The side mode suppression ratio was on the order of 20 dB for the entire investigated temperature range. In Fig. 15, we present an overview of all DFB lasers which have been described in this chapter. The figure maps peak and average output powers as a function of emission wavelength. In the inset, average power as a function of duty cycle is plotted. Filled circles represent peak powers and empty circles stand for average powers. The whole figure shows nicely how the performance
84
Daniel Hofstetter and J´erˆ ome Faist
Intensity [a.u.]
100 10 60 °C
-30 °C
1 0.1 0.01 1030
1035
1040
1045
1050
1055
-1
Wavelength [cm ] Fig. 14. Series of emission spectra of a 26 µm wide and 1.5 mm long DFB laser taken from the sample S1810 and at different temperatures between −30 ◦ C and 60 ◦ C. Each spectrum was measured at the maximum output power at 16% duty cycle
1 0 0 1 0 1
S 1 8 4 0
S 1 8 6 9
S 1 8 5 0 8 0 A v e ra g e p o w e r [m W ]
O u tp u t p o w e r [m W ]
1 0 0 0
5
S 1 5 3 6
S 1 8 4 0
6 0
S 1 8 4 0
4 0
S 1 8 1 0
S 1 8 6 9
2 0 0
S 1 8 1 0 S 1 8 0 5
S 1 8 5 0
S 1 8 5 0
S 1 8 1 0
S 1 5 3 6 S 1 8 0 5 0
6
1 0
S 1 8 0 5
2 0 D u ty c y c le [% ]
7
3 0
8
S 1 5 3 6
9
1 0
1 1
W a v e le n g th [µ m ] Fig. 15. Map of all presented DFB lasers of this chapter. Peak (filled circles) and average (empty circles) power versus emission wavelength are shown. The inset contains the information of average power versus duty cycle
improved with increasing sample number (or over time). But it becomes also clear that, for example, the highest average powers do not necessarily correlate with the highest possible duty cycles. 4.5 Room Temperature Continuous Wave Operation of QC Lasers As already mentioned in the introduction, room temperature CW operation of a mid-infrared (9 µm) QC laser was achieved in summer 2001 [33]. This major breakthrough was possible thanks to different innovations which needed to
High Performance Quantum Cascade Lasers and Their Applications
85
be successfully combined. First and foremost, the new types of active region design have led to lasers with room temperature pulsed threshold current densities on the order of 3 kA/cm2 . When processed appropriately in the narrow stripe buried heterostructure technique, this results in devices with pulsed threshold currents of 300 mA and below. The junction down mounting technique mentioned in the previous paragraph was then used together with diamond heatsinks and ZnSe/PbTe-based high-reflection facet coatings. Thanks to the latter, facet reflectivites of about 70% per facet were achieved; this allowed the use of very short laser cavities with a length of only 750 µm. The stripe width of the best devices was 12 µm resulting in relatively small amounts of heat to be dissipated. As shown in the L–I curves of Fig. 16, we observed 395 mA threshold current at 19 ◦ C heatsink temperature. A continuous output power of 13 mW was achieved under these conditions. The laser could be operated up to 39 ◦ C, at which temperature the threshold current increased to 515 mA and the output power dropped to 2 mW. Due to a small defect in the cavity, this laser was single-mode for all investigated temperatures and currents. This is shown in the inset of Fig. 16. The tuning of the lasing mode with temperature and input electrical power allowed us to determine the thermal conductivity of the mounted device. We found values on the order of 574 W/cm2 K. Based on the threshold current increase at higher temperatures and the pulsed threshold current, we were able to model the maximal possible operating temperature. The result of 48 ◦ C was in good agreement with experiment. The main reason for the much better performance of this laser compared to a normal ridge waveguide sample was the reduced thermally induced shear stress at the top corners of the ridge. In the conventional design, we computed a stress 15 19 ° C 24 ° C
6 Intensity [a.u.]
Voltage [V]
S1850d3-bh junction down
3
100 313 K
29 ° C
295 K
10
34 ° C
1 1091
1093
1095
1097
-1
Energy [cm ]
0
0
10
0.2
0.4 Current [A]
5
39 ° C
0.6
CW optical power [mW]
9
0
Fig. 16. L–I curves of a room temperature continuous wave operated QC laser at temperatures between 292 K and 312 K. The inset shows a series of emission spectra at different temperatures up to 313 K
86
Daniel Hofstetter and J´erˆ ome Faist
of 22 MPa, whereas the much narrower buried heterostructure laser revealed only 3.6 MPa. Due to the large shear stress in case of a ridge waveguide sample, these lasers failed quite systematically at current densities of 4 kA/cm2 . With the buried heterostructure design, however, the maximal current density could be increased to 6 kA/cm2 without device failure. The laser shown in Fig. 16 could be driven at this current density for several hours without any noticeable degradation. When going to even narrower stripes, we hope to lower the threshold current and the temperature-induced shear stress sufficiently to reach operating temperatures on the order of 100 ◦ C.
5
Applications
In this last section, we would like to concentrate on the two most interesting applications of the devices presented in this work. While the use of QC lasers for spectroscopy is well known and also established, optical data transmission is a relatively new field of application. The latter became particularly interesting with the demonstration of room temperature continuous wave operation. 5.1
Photo-Acoustic Spectroscopy
As already mentioned in Sect. 4.4, single-mode QC lasers have become very attractive light sources for mid-infrared absorption spectroscopy [18,54]. They have already been used in different experimental configurations such as PA spectroscopy [30], and single-pass or multiple-pass absorption spectroscopy. For PA spectroscopy however, they have been operated at cryogenic temperatures which required quite an advanced experimental setup. The cryogenic operating conditions were necessary because room temperature performance used to be insufficient to result in low detection limits for PA spectroscopy. Recently, high performance DFB QC lasers, whose room temperature average power is sufficiently large for PA spectroscopy, were developed [45]. Up to now, most PA spectroscopy experiments were done with CO- or CO2 -lasers which emit IR radiation around 5 µm and 10 µm [49,61]. However, the discrete emission spectrum of these gas lasers can be problematic, especially if a gas absorbs between two emission lines. In such a case, high pressure CO2 -lasers are a possible but sophisticated solution [62]. Another possibility is the use of a light source based on difference frequency generation between a pump and a signal laser beam in a nonlinear optical medium [63]. The preferred choice, however, are QC DFB lasers operated at or near room temperature. Their emission wavelength tunes continuously over nearly 1% by simply changing the device temperature. If both design and operating conditions are carefully chosen, the emission peak can be swept across the absorption line of a particular gas. The QC lasers used during this work are single-mode DFB lasers with a surface grating and lateral current injection. But since the linewidth of
High Performance Quantum Cascade Lasers and Their Applications
87
a pulsed laser is a critical parameter, we would like to present first some measurements of the linewidth dependence on electrical pulse-length and device temperature. Measurements using an FTIR with a long path length difference are shown in Fig. 17; they revealed a linewidth minimum of 0.048 cm−1 both at 3 ns and 10 ns, while seeing slightly larger linewidths when going to 5 ns and 15 ns. In a simple picture, the linewidth of a QC laser should be Fourier transform limited for short pulses and dominated by heating for long pulses, so that it can be written as ∆ ν(t) = C1 /t + C2 × t. The constant C1 = 0.0466 ns/cm is obtained by calculating the linewidth of transform limited rectangular pulses, while C2 was fitted to the experimental data. Deviations from the theory can be attributed to two major causes. First of all, we could not control the shape of the electrical pulse with high accuracy. In fact, a measurement of the optical pulse shape suggested that electrical ringing occurred, especially at a pulse duration of 5 ns. As shown in Fig. 17, this resulted in a much larger error bar for this particular point. Secondly, a Fourier transform limited linewidth can be seen only if the laser is operated near the gain maximum, where the linewidth enhancement factor α is close to zero. Depending on the detuning between Bragg peak and gain peak, the α-factor can become as large as 0.5. Based on this effect, Paiella et al. recently demonstrated the operation of a QC laser in the mode-locked regime [64]. Based on these results, we decided to work with pulse widths of 25 ns and a duty cycle of 3–4% for both lasers used in the following measurements. The PA cell used for these experiments is a 12 cm long cylindrical chamber (diameter d = 5 cm) with a 6 cm long buffer volume (d = 12 cm) on each side. The laser enters and leaves the cell through two ZnSe Brewster windows. This whole setup is embedded between two spherical concave mirrors, which allow for 36 passes of the light through the PA cell [65]. With an overall length of
FTIR spectrometer grating spectrometer calculation
0.5
-1
Linewidth [cm ]
0.6
0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 0
0
20
40 60 Pulse length [ns]
80
Fig. 17. Linewidth versus electrical pulse length for a QC DFB laser emitting at 10.4 µm. For the grating spectrometer data, there is a linewidth saturation at 0.16 cm−1 for pulse lengths below 20 ns
88
Daniel Hofstetter and J´erˆ ome Faist
70 cm and the number of passes, we end up with a total optical path length of 24 m (15 m inside the PA cell). Because of the limited transmission per pass (96.1%), this results in a power enhancement factor of 19 (instead of 36 for 100% transmission). In the center of the PA cell, a radial microphone array with 16 microphones increases the signal to noise ratio (SNR) of the setup by a factor of 4. By chopping the beam mechanically with the first longitudinal resonance frequency of the cell (f = 1250 Hz), one gains another factor of 70 (i.e. the Q-factor of the resonance) in the strength of the PA signal [66]. As a result of these three measures, we increased the PA signal by a factor of 64 000 compared to a non-resonant single-pass arrangement. The light of the QC laser was collected with a ZnSe lens (f/1.0), collimated and then directed collinearly with a HeNe laser beam for alignment purposes. Within the PA-cell, the laser beam was left collimated; behind the cell, a pyro-electric detector recorded its power in order to normalize the PA signal. The set-up is fully computer-controlled including the control of the laser wavelength, the stabilization of the chopper frequency on the resonance frequency of the PA cell, the data recording, etc. In Fig. 18, several absorption spectra of ammonia diluted in synthetic air in the wavelength range between 965 and 968 cm−1 are presented. Measurements at atmospheric pressure resulted in a relatively noisy spectrum. This is presumably due to coupling of acoustic noise into the cell. For 400 mbar, the best SNR was achieved; at this pressure and concentration, the laser linewidth equals approximately that of the ammonia absorption features. At lower pressure, we observed the convolution of the laser line-shape with the
PA signal [mV/W]
100
10
1
NH3 HITRAN (a.u.) NH3 PA @ 0.6 ppmV / 950 mbar NH3 PA @ 10 ppmV / 400 mbar NH3 PA @ 10 ppmV / 200 mbar
966.0 966.5 967.0 967.5 968.0 -1
Wavenumbers [cm ] Fig. 18. Comparison between the absorption spectra of NH3 based on the HITRAN database and by PA spectroscopy (10 ppmV/400 mbar, 10 ppmV/200 mbar, 600 ppb/950 mbar, all buffered in synthetic air, 300 K)
High Performance Quantum Cascade Lasers and Their Applications
89
absorption spectrum owing to the smaller pressure broadening of the ammonia lines. Since the microphone responsivity decreases with lower pressure, the PA signal decreased as well; and this resulted again in a smaller SNR of the measurement. A value of 300 ppbV at 400 mbar was identified as the detection limit for this particular configuration (with SNR = 3). Good agreement with HITRAN data was achieved. 5.2
Optical Data Link Using a QC Laser
As demonstrated in Sect. 4, mid-IR QC lasers have reached a level of maturity that allows one to think of applications other than spectroscopy [67]. Today’s state-of-the-art devices can be operated CW above room temperature [33,54]. While most potential applications lie in the field of optical spectroscopy [29], there are also some other interesting areas of deployment. These include, for example, free-space optical data transmission [68]. In contrast to fiber optical telecommunications, this technique has the advantage of not requiring additional cables to be buried in the ground. Especially in urban areas where lots of fiber optical connections already exist, fast free-space optical data links could be quite convenient. QC lasers are very suitable for such applications because their emission wavelength can be chosen in the so-called atmospheric window regions, i.e. around 5 µm and 10 µm. In addition, the fast internal lifetimes in the device should allow for reasonable modulation frequencies of up to 5–10 GHz. Recently, Martini et al. published results of an optical data link using a high-speed modulated, liquid-nitrogen cooled QC laser over a distance of 70 m and under laboratory conditions [27]. They also succeeded in transmitting a video image via a common TV channel frequency. Since this experiment was carried out within the building, one of the main benefits of using QC lasers, namely having an emission wavelength which is barely affected by atmospheric conditions like rain or fog, was not yet demonstrated. In addition, the use of liquid nitrogen cooled equipment on both sides makes the technique less attractive for applications in the field. In order to take full advantage of our existing QC laser technology, we present here an optical data link between two different buildings separated by about 350 m and using a Peltier-cooled QC laser as well as a room temperature HgCdTe detector [28]. On the emitter side, we used a 3 mm long 9.3 µm multimode QC laser mounted in a Peltier-cooled, temperature-stabilized aluminum box (Alpes Lasers SA) and an f/0.8 Ge lens with 37.5 mm diameter to collimate the laser beam. The device was held at a temperature of 258 K, operated at nearly 50% duty cycle, and pulsed at different repetition frequencies. Using a bias-T, the laser was driven simultaneously at a constant current of 2 A (which corresponds to 0.72 × Ith ) and a 10 W radio frequency signal of up to 350 MHz. On the receiver side, we employed a mirror telescope with a diameter of 16 cm and a focal distance of 62.5 cm, a fast room temperature HgCdTe detector, and a 15 dB small signal amplifier for the detection of the incoming signal.
90
Daniel Hofstetter and J´erˆ ome Faist
Fig. 19. Schematic drawing of the optical data link in the free atmosphere between two University buildings. The picture was taken from the Physics Institute, and the arrow in the photo shows the ‘targeted’ building in a distance of 350 m
As schematically shown in Fig. 19, a 1 mW red semiconductor laser pointer was directed collinearly with the QC laser beam to facilitate alignment. In the first stage, we aligned the two laser beams in the lab; then the two beams were bounced off a steering mirror and directed towards the other building where the telescope was installed. The steering mirror could be tilted and rotated by manual micrometer screws. The angular accuracy of this kind of beam steering was about 3×10−5 rad. In the distance of the building with the telescope, this corresponded to roughly 1 cm. In order to align the infrared beam correctly into the telescope, the voltage corresponding to the optical signal was transmitted to the emitter side via Ethernet. At a temperature of 258 K and for 50% duty cycle, the threshold current of the QC laser used was 2.7 A (jth = 3.0 kA/cm2 ). For the maximal injection current of 3.2 A, we observed an average output power of 14 mW. When repeating the power measurement at the other end of the transmission line and at 300 MHz, we still obtained 1.9 mW average power for clear sky conditions; the measured peak power was thus on the order of 3.8 mW. With foggy conditions, the visibility range dropped to a value below 100 m. However, the average power signal decreased by barely 20%. Since the loss was thus on the order of 8 dB, these numbers show clearly the advantage of working at an emission wavelength in an atmospheric window region.
High Performance Quantum Cascade Lasers and Their Applications
91
Average power [mW]
10
Signal [mV]
5
0
4 3 2 1 0
100 150 200 250 300 350 Frequency [MHz]
-5
-10
0
25
50 Time [ns]
75
100
Fig. 20. Transmitted signal at a frequency of 300 MHz. The inset shows the frequency response of the transmitted signal with a substantial decrease of power above 330 MHz
As shown in Fig. 20, the typical transmitted signal consisted of a stream of almost sinusoidal pulses with a repetition frequency of up to 330 MHz and a pulse width of 1.5 ns. For 300 MHz, a noise level of roughly 0.25 mW (peak-to-peak value, before amplification) was observed; together with the transmitted peak power mentioned above, this corresponds to a signal to noise ratio of 15. It should√be noted, however, that the detector had a figure of merit of D = 2.2×107 cm2 Hz/W. From √ this value, we can calculate the noise equivalent power (NEP) using D = ∆ f × A/NEP. With A = 0.625× 10−2 cm2 being the detector area and ∆ f = 1 GHz the bandwidth of the detector system, we end up with a NEP (amplitude) of 0.11 mW. The signal to noise ratio is therefore entirely limited by the detectivity of the detector. In a second experiment, whose result is shown as an inset in Fig. 20, we measured the transmitted average power as a function of the pulse repetition rate. It is evident from the figure that the power has a resonance at 325 MHz, and then drops quickly to quite small values. A naive calculation shows that 325 MHz corresponds roughly to the electrical resonance frequency of the laser. The parasitic capacitance defined by the large contact pad area (3 × 0.5 mm2 ) is about 150 pF; together with the resistance of the low impedance line supplying the current to the laser (approximately 4 Ω), we end up with an RC time constant of 600 ps. The maximum modulation frequency is thus about 250 MHz, in fair agreement with the experimental value. In a different experimental configuration, we used the QC laser to optically transmit data between two computers. This data link was set up over
92
Daniel Hofstetter and J´erˆ ome Faist
a distance of 10 m between two optical tables and put together entirely within one laboratory building. On the emitter side, we used the serial port of the first PC and an RS232/TTL signal converter to produce a TTL modulation signal at 115 kbit/s. This signal was used to electrically gate the continuous stream of laser pulses. At the receiver side, the signal was low-pass filtered, amplified, and brought into rectangular shape again with a comparator. After this, we used a timer logic circuit triggered by the positive slopes of the single laser pulses to revert to the initial gate signal, and the final TTL/RS232 converter made the signal compatible to the serial port of the second computer. By this technique, we were able to communicate optically between the two computers at the standard transmission speed of 9.6 kbit/s, and also at the highest possible speed of 115 kbit/s. When decreasing the laser power, the link still worked successfully down to a measured signal to noise ratio of 3.
6
Conclusions
We believe that this work clearly shows the big application potential of QC lasers. More effort is necessary in order to get reliable continuous wave operation at room temperature and also at wavelengths other than the one initially demonstrated. In any case, we foresee a brilliant future for this rather new type of semiconductor laser. We would like to thank the following people for their contributions to this work: Mattias Beck (University of Neuchˆ atel), Ursula Oesterle, Marc Ilegems (both EPFL) and Emilio Gini and Hans Melchior (both ETHZ) for crystal growth, Thierry Aellen for device processing and cleaving, Daniel Varidel, Jean-Pierre Bourquin, Michel Rochat, and St´ephane Blaser (all University of Neuchˆ atel) for technical support. In addition, the financial support of the Swiss National Science Foundation and the European Science Foundation are gratefully acknowledged.
References 1. J. Faist, F. Capasso, D. L. Sivco, C. Sirtori, A. L. Hutchinson, A. Y. Cho: Quantum cascade laser, Science 264, 553–556 (1994) 61 2. J. Faist, F. Capasso, C. Sirtori, D. L. Sivco, J. N. Baillargeon, A. L. Hutchinson, S. Chu, A. Y. Cho: High power mid-infrared (λ ∼ 5 µm) quantum cascade lasers operating above room temperature, Appl. Phys. Lett. 68, 3680–3682 (1996) 61, 62 3. C. Sirtori, J. Faist, F. Capasso, D. L. Sivco, A. L. Hutchinson, S. Chu, A. Y. Cho: Continuous wave operation of mid-infrared (7.4–8.6 µm) quantum cascade lasers up to 110 K temperature, Appl. Phys. Lett. 68, 1745–1747 (1996) 61 4. R. F. Kazarinov, R. A. Suris: Possibility of the amplification of electromagnetic waves in a semiconductor with a superlattice, Sov. Phys. Semicond. 5, 707–709 (1971) 61 5. T. Ando, A. B. Fowler, F. Stern: Electronic properties of two-dimensional systems, Rev. Mod. Phys. 54, 437–446 (1982) 61
High Performance Quantum Cascade Lasers and Their Applications
93
6. L. C. West, S. J. Eglash: First observation of an extremely large-dipole infrared transition within the conduction band of a GaAs quantum well, Appl. Phys. Lett. 46, 1156–1158 (1985) 61 7. R. Ferreira, G. Bastard: Evaluation of some scattering times for electrons in unbiased and biased single-and multiple-quantum-well structures, Phys. Rev. B 40, 1074–1086 (1989) 61 8. F. Capasso, K. Mohammed, A. Y. Cho: Resonant tunneling through double barriers, perpendicular quantum transport phenomena in superlattices, and their device applications, IEEE J. Quantum Electron. 22, 1853–1869 (1986) 61 9. A. Cho: Molecular Beam Epitaxy (AIP, Woodbury, NW 1994) 61 10. H. Morkoc, C. Hopkins, C. A. Evans, Jr., A. Y. Cho: Chromium and tellurium redistribution in GaAs and Al0.3 Ga0.7 As grown by molecular beam epitaxy, J. Appl. Phys. 51, 5986–5991 (1980) 61 11. M. Y. Yen, B. F. Levine, C. G. Bethea, K. K. Choi, A. Y. Cho: Molecular beam epitaxial growth and optical properties of InAs1x Sbx in 8–12 µm wavelength range, Appl. Phys. Lett. 50, 927–929 (1987) 61 12. R. R. Saxena, J. E. Fouquet, V. M. Sardi, R. L. Moon: High quality InP layers grown by organometallic vapor phase epitaxy using tertiarybutylphosphine and phosphine, Appl. Phys. Lett. 53, 304–306 (1988) 61 13. T. Y. Wang, K. L. Fry, A. Persson, E. H. Reihlen, G. B. Stringfellow: Atomic steps in thin GaInAs/lnP quantum-well structures grown by organometallic vapor phase epitaxy, J. Appl. Phys. 63, 2674–2680 (1988) 61 14. J. Faist, F. Capasso, C. Sirtori, D. L. Sivco, A. L. Hutchinson, A. Y. Cho: Continuous wave operation of a vertical transition quantum cascade laser above T = 80 K, Appl. Phys. Lett. 67, 3057–3059 (1995) 61 15. C. Gmachl, A. Tredicucci, F. Capasso, A. L. Hutchinson, D. L. Sivco, J. N. Baillargeon, A. Y. Cho: High-power λ ∼ 8 µm quantum cascade laser with near optimum performance, Appl. Phys. Lett. 72, 3130–3132 (1998) 61 16. J. Faist, A. Tredicucci, F. Capasso, C. Sirtori, D. L. Sivco, J. N. Baillargeon, A. L. Hutchinson, A. Y. Cho: High-power continuous-wave quantum cascade lasers, IEEE J. Quantum Electron. 34, 336–343 (1998) 62 17. C. Sirtori, J. Faist, F. Capasso, D. L. Sivco, A. L. Hutchinson, A. Y. Cho: Pulsed and continuous-wave operation of long wavelength infrared (λ = 9.3 µm) quantum cascade lasers, IEEE J. Quantum Electron. 33, 89–93 (1997) 62 18. C. Gmachl, F. Capasso, J. Faist, A. L. Hutchinson, A. Tredicucci, D. L. Sivco, J. N. Baillargeon, S. Chu, A. Y. Cho: Continuous-wave and high-power pulsed operation of index-coupled distributed quantum cascade laser at λ ∼ 8.5 µm, Appl. Phys. Lett. 72, 1430–1432 (1998) 62, 63, 86 19. J. Faist, C. Sirtori, F. Capasso, D. L. Sivco, J. N. Baillargeon, A. L. Hutchinson, A. Y. Cho: High-power long-wavelength (λ = 11.5 µm) quantum cascade lasers operating above room temperature, IEEE Photon. Technol. Lett. 10, 1100–1102 (1998) 62, 66, 69, 76 20. C. Gmachl, A. M. Sergent, A. Tredicucci, F. Capasso, A. L. Hutchinson, D. L. Sivco, J. N. Baillargeon, S. Chu, A. Y. Cho: Improved CW operation of quantum cascade lasers with epitaxial-side heat-sinking, IEEE Photon. Technol. Lett. 11, 1369–1371 (1999) 62 21. J. Faist, C. Gmachl, F. Capasso, C. Sirtori, D. L. Sivco, J. N. Baillargeon, A. Y. Cho: Distributed feedback quantum cascade lasers, Appl. Phys. Lett. 70, 2670– 2672 (1997) 62, 63, 80, 83
94
Daniel Hofstetter and J´erˆ ome Faist
22. C. Gmachl, J. Faist, J. N. Baillargeon, F. Capasso, C. Sirtori, D. L. Sivco, S. Chu, A. Y. Cho: Complex-coupled quantum cascade distributed-feedback laser, IEEE Photon. Technol. Lett. 9, 1090–1092 (1997) 62, 63, 73 23. C. Sirtori, P. Kruck, S. Barbieri, P. Collot, J. Nagle, M. Beck, J. Faist, U. Oesterle: GaAs/Alx Ga1−x As quantum cascade lasers, Appl. Phys. Lett. 73, 3486–3488 (1998) 62 24. C. Gmachl, F. Capasso, E. Narimanov, J. U. N¨ ockel, D. Stone, J. Faist, D. L. Sivco, A. Y. Cho: High-power directional emission from microlasers with chaotic resonators, Science 280, 1556–1564 (1998) 62 25. C. Gmachl, H. M. Ng, A. Y. Cho: Intersubband absorption in degenerately doped GaN/Alx Ga1−x N coupled double quantum wells, Appl. Phys. Lett. 79, 1590–1592 (2001) 62 26. D. Hofstetter, L. Diehl, J. Faist, W. J. Schaff, J. Hwang, L. F. Eastman, C. Zellweger: Midinfrared intersubband absorption on AlGaN/GaN-based highelectron-mobility transistors, Appl. Phys. Lett. 80, 2991–2994 (2002) 62 27. R. Martini, C. Gmachl, J. Falciglia, F. G. Curti, C. G. Bethea, F. Capasso, E. A. Whittaker, R. Paiella, A. Tredicucci, A. L. Hutchinson, D. L. Sivco, A. Y. Cho: High-speed modulation and free-space optical audio/video transmission using quantum cascade lasers, IEE Electron. Lett. 37, 102–103 (2001) 62, 89 28. S. Blaser, D. Hofstetter, M. Beck, J. Faist: Free-space optical data link using Peltier-cooled quantum cascade laser, IEE Electron. Lett. 37, 778–780 (2001) 62, 89 29. D. Hofstetter, M. Beck, J. Faist, M. N¨ agele, M. W. Sigrist: Photoacoustic spectroscopy with quantum cascade distributed-feedback lasers, Opt. Lett. 26, 887– 889 (2001) 62, 82, 89 30. B. A. Paldus, T. G. Spence, R. N. Zare, J. Oomens, F. Harren, D. H. Parker, C. Gmachl, F. Capasso, D. L. Sivco, J. N. Baillargeon, A. L. Hutchinson, A. Y. Cho: Photoacoustic spectroscopy using quantum-cascade lasers, Opt. Lett. 24, 178–180 (1999) 62, 86 31. B. Ishaug, W. Hwang, J. Um, B. Guo, H. Lee, C. Lin: Continuous-wave operation of a 5.2 µm quantum-cascade laser up to 210 K, Appl. Phys. Lett. 79, 1745–1747 (2001) 62 32. D. Hofstetter, M. Beck, T. Aellen, J. Faist, U. Oesterle, M. Ilegems, E. Gini, H. Melchior: Continuous wave operation of a 9.3 µm quantum cascade laser on a Peltier cooler, Appl. Phys. Lett. 78, 1964–1966 (2001) 62, 80 33. M. Beck, D. Hofstetter, T. Aellen, J. Faist, U. Oesterle, M. Ilegems, E. Gini, H. Melchior: Continuous-wave operation of a mid-infrared semiconductor laser at room-temperature, Science 295, 301–305 (2002) 62, 84, 89 34. H. Page, C. Becker, A. Robertson, G. Glastre, V. Ortiz, C. Sirtori: 300 K operation of a GaAs-based quantum-cascade laser at λ ∼ 9 µm, Appl. Phys. Lett. 75, 3529–3531 (2001) 62 35. S. Anders, W. Schrenk, E. Gornik, G. Strasser: Room-temperature emission of GaAs/AlGaAs superlattice quantum-cascade lasers at 12.6 µm, Appl. Phys. Lett. 80, 1864–1866 (2002) 62 36. W. Schrenk, N. Finger, S. Gianordoli, L. Hvozdara, G. Strasser, E. Gornik: GaAs/AlGaAs distributed feedback quantum cascade lasers, Appl. Phys. Lett. 76, 253–255 (2000) 62, 63 37. R. K¨ ohler, A. Tredicucci, F. Beltram, H. E. Beere, E. H. Linfield, A.Giles, G. Davies, D. A. Ritchie, R. C. Iotti, F. Rossi: Terahertz heterostructuresemiconductor laser, Nature 417, 156–159 (2002) 62
High Performance Quantum Cascade Lasers and Their Applications
95
38. M. Rochat, L. Ajili, H. Willenberg, J. Faist, H. Beere, G. Davies, E. Linfield, D. Ritchie: Low threshold terahertz quantum cascade lasers, Appl. Phys. Lett. 81, 1381–1383 (2002) 62 39. D. Hofstetter, J. Faist, M. Beck, A. M¨ uller, U. Oesterle: Demonstration of highperformance 10.16 µm quantum cascade distributed feedback lasers fabricated without epitaxial regrowth, Appl. Phys. Lett. 75, 665–667 (1999) 62, 63, 68, 74, 76, 77 40. G. A. Evans, D. P. Bour, N. W. Carlson, J. M. Hammer, M. Lurie, J. K. Butler, S. L. Palfrey, R. Amantea, L. A. Carr, F. Z. Hawrylo, E. A. James, J. B. Kirk, S. K. Liew, W. F. Reichert: Coherent, monolithic two-dimensional strained InGaAs/GaAs quantum well laser arrays using grating surface emission, Appl. Phys. Lett. 55, 2721–2723 (1989) 63 41. P. Repond, T. Marty, M. W. Sigrist: A continuously tunable CO2 laser for photoacoustic detection of trace gases, Helv. Phys. Acta 65, 828–829 (1992) 63 42. M. N¨ agele, D. Hofstetter, J. Faist, M. W. Sigrist: Low power quantum-cascade laser photoacoustic spectrometer for trace-gas monitoring, Analytical Sci. 17, 497–499 (2001) 63, 82 43. P. Hess: Principles of photoacoustic and photothermal detection of gases, in Principles and Perspectives of Photothermal and Photoacoustic Phenomena IV, ed. by A. Mandelis (Elsevier, New-York 1992) Chap. 4 63 44. R. K¨ ohler, C. Gmachl, A. Tredicucci, F. Capasso, D. L. Sivco, S. Chu, A. Y. Cho: Single-mode tunable pulsed, and continuous wave quantum-cascade distributed feedback lasers at λ ∼ 4.6–4.7 µm, Appl. Phys. Lett. 76, 1092–1094 (2000) 63 45. D. Hofstetter, T. Aellen, M. Beck, J. Faist: High average power first-order distributed feedback quantum cascade lasers, IEEE Photon. Technol. Lett. 12, 1610–1612 (2000) 63, 79, 83, 86 46. J. Faist, F. Capasso, D. L. Sivco, A. L. Hutchinson, S. Chu, A. Y. Cho: Short wavelength (λ ∼ 3.4 µm) quantum cascade laser based on strained compensated InGaAs/AlInAs, Appl. Phys. Lett. 72, 680–682 (1998) 63, 66 47. G. Scamarcio, F. Capasso, C. Sirtori, J. Faist, A. L. Hutchinson, D. L. Sivco, A. Y. Cho: High-power infrared (8-micrometer wavelength) superlattice lasers, Science 276, 773–776 (1997) 63, 66 48. A. Tahraoui, A. Matlis, S. Slivken, J. Diaz, M. Razeghi: High-performance quantum cascade lasers (λ ∼ 11 µm) operating at high temperature (T ≥ 425 K), Appl. Phys. Lett. 78, 416–418 (2001) 63 49. S. Bernegger, M. W. Sigrist: CO-laser photoacoustic spectroscopy of gases and vapours for trace gas analysis, Infrared Phys. 30, 375–429 (1990) 63, 86 50. B. Mizaikoff, C. S. Murthy, M. Kraft, V. Pustogow, A. M¨ uller, D. Hofstetter, J. Faist, N. Croitoru: Novel mid-infrared gas sensors based on hollow waveguides and quantum cascade lasers, in Proc. PITTCON 2000 (New Orleans, LA 2000) 63, 82 51. R. K¨ astle, M. W. Sigrist: CO-laser photoacoustic spectroscopy on the dimerization of fatty acid molecules, J. Phys. IV (Paris) Colloque C7, 491–494 (1994) 63 52. A. M¨ uller, M. Beck, J. Faist, U. Oesterle: Electrically tunable, roomtemperature quantum-cascade lasers, Appl. Phys. Lett. 75, 1509–1511 (1999) 66, 69
96
Daniel Hofstetter and J´erˆ ome Faist
53. A. Tredicucci, F. Capasso, C. Gmachl, D. L. Sivco, A. L. Hutchinson, A. Y. Cho: High performance interminiband quantum cascade lasers with graded superlattices, Appl. Phys. Lett. 73, 2101–2103 (1998) 66 54. D. Hofstetter, M. Beck, T. Aellen, J. Faist: High-temperature operation of distributed feedback quantum-cascade lasers at 5.3 µm, Appl. Phys. Lett. 86, 396–398 (2001) 66, 78, 86, 89 55. C. H. Wu, P. S. Zory, M. A. Emanuel: Contact reflectivity effects on thin p-clad InGaAs single quantum-well lasers, IEEE Photon. Technol. Lett. 6, 1427–1429 (1994) 68 56. R. L. Thornton, W. J. Mosby, H. F. Chung: Surface skimming buried heterostructure laser with applications to optoelectronic integration, Appl. Phys. Lett. 59, 513–515 (1991) 68 57. D. Hofstetter, J. Faist, M. Beck, U. Oesterle: Surface-emitting 10.1 µm quantum-cascade distributed feedback lasers, Appl. Phys. Lett. 75, 3769–3771 (1999) 74, 76, 77, 83 58. W. Streifer, R. D. Burnham, D. R. Scifres: Radiation losses and longitudinal mode selection in distributed feedback lasers, IEEE J. Quantum Electron. 12, 737–739 (1976) 75 59. M. Tacke: New developments and applications of tunable IR lead salt lasers, Infrared Phys. Technol. 36, 447–463 (1995) 82 60. G. Springholz, T. Schwarzl, M. Aigle, H. Pascher, W. Heiss: 4.8 µm vertical emitting PbTe quantum-well lasers based on high-finesse EuTe/Pb1−x Eux Te microcavities, Appl. Phys. Lett. 76, 1807–1809 (2000) 82 61. A. Olafsson, M. Hammerich, J. B¨ ulow, J. Henningsen: Photoacoustic detection of NH3 in power plant emission with a CO2 laser, Appl. Phys. B 49, 91–97 (1989) 86 62. P. Repond, M. W. Sigrist: Continuously tunable high pressure CO2 laser for spectroscopic studies on trace gases, IEEE J. Quantum Electron. 32, 1549– 1556 (1996) 86 63. D. Richter, D. G. Lancaster, R. F. Curl, W. Neu, F. K. Tittel: Compact midinfrared trace gas sensor based on difference-frequency generation of two diode lasers in periodically poled LiNbO3 , Appl. Phys. B 67, 347–349 (1998) 86 64. R. Paiella, F. Capasso, C. Gmachl, D. L. Sivco, J. N. Baillargeon, A. L. Hutchinson, A. Y. Cho, H. C. Liu: Self-mode-locking of quantum cascade lasers with giant ultrafast optical nonlinearities, Science 290, 1739–1742 (2000) 87 65. D. Herriot, H. Kogelnik, R. Kompner: Off-axis paths in spherical mirror interferometers, Appl. Opt. 3, 523–525 (1964) 87 66. A. Karbach, P. Hess: Photoacoustic signal in a cylindrical resonator: Theory and laser experiments for CH4 and C2 H6 , J. Chem. Phys. 84, 2945–2967 (1986) 88 67. M. Beck, J. Faist, U. Oesterle, M. Ilegems, E. Gini, H. Melchior: Buried heterostructure quantum cascade lasers with a large optical cavity waveguide, IEEE Photon. Technol. Lett. 12, 1450–1452 (2000) 89 68. N. Mustafa, L. Pesquera, C. Cheung, K. A. Stone: Terahertz bandwidth prediction for amplitude modulation response of unipolar intersubband semiconductor lasers, IEEE Photon. Technol. Lett. 11, 527–529 (1999) 89
Index
absorption – loss, 68 ammonia, 88 beam steering, 90 Bragg reflector, 75 broad ridge waveguides, 77 buried heterostructure design, 70 buried heterostructure technique, 85 CO laser, 86 CO2 laser, 86 comparison grating emission/facet emission, 74 de-tuned grating, 73 diamond heatsink, 71, 85 double QW gain region, 66 double-phonon-resonance gain region, 66 duty cycle, 71 edge-emitting laser, 72 electrical passivation, 69 extraction efficiency, 66 far field, 74 Fourier components, 74 Fourier transform IR spectrometer, 71 Fourier transform limit, 87 free carrier absorption – loss, 73 free-space optical data link, 89
Herriot multipass cell, 87 HgCdTe – detectors, 71 high speed modulation, 89 high thermal conductivity, 70 HITRAN database, 88 holography, 69 index coupling, 74 injection efficiency, 66 injector region, 64 interfacial roughness scattering, 68 intersubband electron scattering time, 67 intersubband transition, 64 junction down mounting, 70 laser – CO, 86 – CO2 , 86 – quantum cascade (QCL), 64–68 – surface-emitting, 74 – surface-skimming, 68 lateral current injection, 68 loss coupling, 74 microphone array, 87 microphone responsivity, 88 molecular beam epitaxy growth, 68 overgrown grating, 70 overheating of active region, 80
gain region design, 64 grating coupling coefficient, 68 grating spectrometer, 71
Peltier cooling, 89 photoacoustic spectroscopy (PAS), 87 processing steps, 68
Henry linewidth parameter, 87
quantum cascade laser (QCL), 64–68
98
Index
room temperature CW operation, 84 shear stress, 85 spectroscopy – photoacoustic (PAS), 87 stopband, 73, 76 – -width, 73, 76 strain-compensated material, 67, 77 subthreshold, 72 superlattice – gain region, 66 surface-emitting laser, 74 surface-skimming laser, 68
telecommunication, 89 temperature difference, 80 thermal conductivity, 85 – measurement, 81 thermal management, 70 thermal roll-over, 78 three QW gain region, 66
waveguide loss, 68 wavelength tuning, 76 wet chemical etching, 69
Mid-IR Difference Frequency Generation Cornelia Fischer and Markus W. Sigrist Swiss Federal Institute of Technology (ETH), Institute of Quantum Electronics, Laser Spectroscopy and Sensing Laboratory, Hoenggerberg, HPF, 8093 Z¨ urich, Switzerland {Cornelia.Fischer,Sigrist}@iqe.phys.ethz.ch Abstract. The availability of continuously tunable narrow-band laser sources emitting in the mid-infrared region of the electromagnetic spectrum between 2.5 µm and 15 µm is important for a large variety of applications. One way to achieve both broad tunability and narrow linewidth is frequency conversion in a nonlinear optical material, in particular difference frequency generation (DFG). After a brief introduction to the requirements of tunable mid-infrared sources, we present an overview of the theoretical background of frequency conversion processes. Emphasized are phase-matching issues, as well as material and design considerations to be observed when implementing a DFG laser source. The variety of possible combinations of pump/signal sources and nonlinear crystals is illustrated by numerous reports found in the literature. Finally, design issues are discussed for a practical example of a DFG laser source wherein the experimental arrangement and system performance, as well as tuning characteristics, are treated. Examples of spectroscopic applications reflect the advantages such as broad and continuous tuning range, narrow linewidth, and compact set-up of a DFG source, but also the drawbacks such as relatively low output power and high costs. The chapter is completed by some concluding remarks and a short outlook.
1
Introduction to Tunable Mid-IR Laser Sources
For many applications in the broad field of spectroscopy, e.g., for trace-gas sensing, the availability of a tunable laser source in the mid-IR region of the electromagnetic spectrum would be of great advantage because most small organic and inorganic molecules have their strong fundamental absorption lines in this region [1]. This is illustrated in Fig. 1 where the absorption ranges of some important functional groups of molecules are plotted for the wavelength range between 2 µm and 20 µm (Fig. 1, top), whereas strong fundamental absorption features of a few selected molecules are listed at the bottom of Fig. 1. The requirements for an appropriate laser source are manifold, depending on the application: broad tunability, narrow linewidth, sufficient laser power, room-temperature operation and robustness. First of all, a broad and preferably continuous tuning range, as well as a narrow linewidth, are prerequisites for multicomponent measurements while maintaining high selectivity. This is illustrated in Fig. 2a,b where the I. T. Sorokina, K. L. Vodopyanov (Eds.): Solid-State Mid-Infrared Laser Sources, Topics Appl. Phys. 89, 97–143 (2003) c Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2003
98
2
Cornelia Fischer and Markus W. Sigrist
4
6
8
10
12 14 16 Wavelength in µm
18
alkane alkene alkyne / allene aromatic homocyclic alcohol / phenol ethers organo - sulphur organo - halogen organo - phosphorus CO2 NO2 SO2 O3 NH3 CH4 20 22 24
Fig. 1. Absorption ranges of some important functional groups of molecules (top) and of selected molecules of environmental importance (bottom)
spectra of various substances at different concentrations calculated using the HITRAN database [2] are plotted in the limited wavelength range between 3.2 µm and 3.7 µm. Figure 2a shows the single spectra of four gases. The overlapping absorption features imply the need for tunable narrow-band sources to guarantee selectivity. Figure 2b is the compound spectrum of the same four gases as in Fig. 2a plus an additional two gases at the indicated concentrations. The arrows mark unique absorption lines for each one of the six gases of the mixture. Furthermore depending on the used absorption detection scheme, sufficient laser power (at µW to mW level or above) is needed to achieve high sensitivity. Finally, (near)-room temperature operation and a compact set-up are preferred for potential applications in industry and for in situ measurements in the field. There have been many attempts to meet all or at least some of these requirements. Each system has it advantages, but also its disadvantages. For instance, CO2 lasers offer high output power and a large tuning range (9.2– 10.8 µm for 12 CO2 ). However, the tunability is not continuous since the emission spectrum coincides with the CO2 emission lines [3]. This disadvantage can be overcome by operating the laser at higher gas pressure ( 10 bar) when continuous tunability is achieved, yet at the loss of CW operation [4]. Similarly, CO lasers emitting in the 5–6 µm wavelength range, with overtone operation extendable to 2.7 µm only offer discrete line tunability [5]. Both these well-established gas lasers have successfully been employed in sensing applications, yet their line tunability sometimes limits the applications
Transmission for 1 m pathlength
Mid-IR Difference Frequency Generation
99
1.0000
0.9995
0.9990 NO2 N2O H2CO CH4
0.9985
0.9980
3300
3400 3500 Wavelength in nm
3600
a) Single spectra of 4 different gases
Transmission for 1 m pathlength
1.000
NO2 3.44 ppm
0.995 CH4 357 ppb
0.990
C2H6 357 ppb 0.985
N2O 51.3 ppm H2CO 2.26 ppm
H2O 0.25 % 0.980
3300
3400 3500 Wavelength in nm
3600
b) Compound spectrum of 6 different gases
Fig. 2. (a) Overview spectra of four different trace gases absorbing around 3.3 µm. (b) Compound spectrum of six gases at the concentrations indicated. In addition to the four gases shown in (a), H2 O and C2 H6 are included
because the laser lines do not always overlap with fundamental molecular absorption lines of interest. Quantum cascade lasers (QCL) can be tailored to emit in a wide range of mid-IR wavelengths [6,7]. The wavelength region accessible with QCLs ranges from 3.5 µm to about 17 µm [8], and recent progress has shifted the limit further to the infrared region, currently to 66 µm [9]. With their compact size, operation temperature up to room temperature and average laser power of several mW, these devices might have a promising future in sensing applications [10,11,12]. Currently, however, the tuning range of a single device is limited to a few cm−1 .
100
Cornelia Fischer and Markus W. Sigrist
Lead salt diode lasers are based on ternary IV–VI compounds. Depending on their composition, their wavelength range can be selected throughout the mid-infrared region between 3 µm and 30 µm [13,14,15]. Mode-hop-free tuning, though, is limited to ≈ 1 cm−1 . In addition, these devices require cryogenic cooling for CW operation, and the power is usually around 0.1 mW. In the near-infrared region, external cavity diode lasers offer large continuous tuning ranges (up to 100 nm) and a narrow linewidth. These systems, however, operate only at wavelengths up to approximately 2 µm and are thus only suited to access the much weaker overtone and combination bands of molecular absorption [16]. Interestingly, there exists a gap with respect to available widely and continuously tunable laser sources between about 2.8 µm and 4 µm. There are to date no active laser materials known emitting in that particular wavelength region. As shown in Figs. 1 and 2, though, there are major molecular absorption features in this wavelength range. Thus, other concepts need to be developed if this particular wavelength region is to be accessed.
2 Basic Principles of Nonlinear Optics and Difference Frequency Generation As pointed out in Sect. 1, there are to date no active laser materials with a broad tuning range in the mid-infrared region around 3 µm. A powerful scheme is the use of frequency conversion in a nonlinear optical material. This method is well established and widely used today for various IR wavelength regions of interest. 2.1
Frequency Conversion Processes
In order to describe the different possible frequency conversion processes, the dielectric polarization P of the material in which the frequency conversion is to take place needs to be considered. This material polarization is induced by the electric field of the incident light which distorts the wavefunctions of the outer electrons. This in turn results in a separation of charges which gives rise to a dipole moment. The dipole moment per unit volume is called the polarization of the material. It can be separated into two different parts: a linear part P lin and a nonlinear part P nl : P = P lin + P nl .
(1)
The linear polarization P lin of the material can be written in the form: P lin = ε0 χ(1) E ,
(2)
where ε0 is the permittivity of free space and χ(1) is the linear susceptibility: χ(1) = n2 − 1 ,
(3)
Mid-IR Difference Frequency Generation
101
where n is the refractive index of the medium [17]. The nonlinear polarization P nl can be expanded as a power series of the electric field E and the nonlinear susceptibilities χ(m) of order m (the socalled electric dipole approximation): P nl = ε0
∞
χ(m) E m .
(4)
m=2
For the power series to converge, the following must hold: χ(1) E χ(2) E 2 χ(3) E 3 . . . .
(5)
Equation (5) is always true if the electric field of the incident light is much weaker than the electric field of the atoms. χ(m) is a tensor quantity and thus depends on the direction of the electric field involved. For example, the χ(2) tensor is represented by its 3 × 3 × 3 tensor elements. In tensor notation, the second-order nonlinear polarization is: (2)
Pi
(2)
= ε0 χijk Ej Ek ,
(6)
where the first index i corresponds to the index of the induced polarization while the second index j and the third index k are related to the indices of the incident electric field. All these indices represent the three axes of space (1, 2, 3). The electric field mentioned in (6) is the total electric field of the incident light. The lowest-order nonlinear susceptibility χ(2) describes second-order nonlinear processes (m = 2) – which only occur in non-centrosymmetric materials – briefly summarized in the following. Second harmonic generation (SHG) as illustrated in Fig. 3:
ω
Nonlinearly Active Material
ω ω + ω
2ω
2ω
Fig. 3. Schematic illustration of second harmonic generation
If the nonlinear optical material is pumped at high intensity, the second harmonic of the incident frequency ω is generated in the material. Two photons of the initial beam are converted into a single photon at twice its frequency (2ω). SHG was the first nonlinear optical effect observed. It was discovered in 1961 [18].
102
Cornelia Fischer and Markus W. Sigrist
Sum frequency generation (SFG), illustrated in Fig. 4:
ω1 ω2
Nonlinearly Active Material ω 1 + ω2
ω3
ω3
Fig. 4. Schematic illustration of sum frequency generation
Sum frequency generation is a process where two incoming photons at different frequencies ω1 and ω2 are mixed in a nonlinear optical material resulting in the sum frequency ω3 of these two frequencies, i.e., ω3 = ω1 + ω2 . SFG is of interest for the generation of higher frequencies, generally in the UV. Difference frequency generation (DFG), illustrated in Fig. 5:
ω3 ω2
Nonlinearly Active Material ω3 − ω2
ω1
ω1
Fig. 5. Schematic illustration of difference frequency generation
The difference frequency ω1 = ω3 − ω2 results from nonlinear mixing of two incoming photons at frequencies ω3 and ω2 . By convention, the laser beam with the highest frequency ω3 is called the pump laser beam, the one with the lowest frequency ω1 is the idler beam, and the remaining one is the signal laser beam at a frequency ω2 . Optical parametric generation (OPG), illustrated in Fig. 6:
ω3
Nonlinearly Active Material ω3
ω1 + ω 2
ω2 ω1
Fig. 6. Schematic illustration of optical parametric generation
Optical parametric generation is a process wherein the incoming light is converted into two beams at different frequencies. OPG is parametric fluorescence and thus always occurs in a nonlinear optical material. The phasematching condition determines which frequencies are generated. Both the
Mid-IR Difference Frequency Generation
103
DFG and the OPG process are of special interest for the generation of mid-IR wavelengths. In the following, we will focus on the DFG process. Optical rectification (OR): Optical rectification is a process where the incoming beam at frequency ω mixes with itself or another beam at the same frequency resulting in a difference frequency ∆ ω = 0. This process was first observed by Bass et al., in 1962 [19]. For all processes mentioned above, the energy is conserved: hω 1 + h ¯ ¯ ω2 = h ¯ ω3 ,
(7)
where h ¯ = h/(2 π) denotes Planck’s constant. 2.2
Nonlinear Optical Coefficient
Nonlinear optical materials which show second-order nonlinear processes are commonly described by their nonlinear coefficients dijk . These coefficients (2) are proportional to the nonlinear susceptibilities χijk : P (2) = ε0 χ(2) E E = 2 ε0 d E E ⇐⇒ or in tensor notation:
χ(2) = 2 d (2)
χijk = 2 dijk .
(8)
Since d is a tensor quantity, it can be described by its tensor elements. Due to symmetry aspects (intrinsic to the definition of dijk , j and k can be permuted) some of the elements have the same value. Thus, we can write the d-tensor as a 3 × 6 matrix dim . By convention, the index m is given by the numbering scheme outlined in Table 1. Table 1. Numbering convention for nonlinear optical coefficients d j=1
j=2
j=3
k=1
m=1
m=6
m=5
k=2
m=6
m=2
m=4
k=3
m=5
m=4
m=3
An appropriate coordinate system has to be introduced to describe the tensor quantity d. The system chosen depends on the material and is usually related to the crystallographic symmetries of the crystal used. Unfortunately,
104
Cornelia Fischer and Markus W. Sigrist
different coordinate systems can be found in the literature (a,b,c: natural crystallographic axes, X,Y ,Z: rectangular, right-handed crystallographic axes, x,y,z: dielectric axes, 1,2,3: dielectric axes used in nonlinear optics (NLO) for indexing the nonlinear optical coefficient). In the following, we explain the system that was proposed as standard by Roberts in 1992 [20]. Historically, the first nonlinear optical effects were analyzed in optically uniaxial crystals. We will thus start our description of the coordinate system with optically uniaxial crystals for which the nomenclature is easier and more consistent. The existence of a rotation axis (i.e., symmetry axis) is a common feature of optically uniaxial crystals. In crystallography, this highest symmetry axis is labeled the c-axis. As the a,b,c coordinate system is not necessarily rectangular, there is a corresponding rectangular X,Y ,Z frame. The c-axis is usually chosen (and is also proposed to be used as a standard for NLO [20]) to coincide with the Z-axis of the tensor coordinate system. In NLO, the rotation axis of the crystal is usually chosen to coincide with the often cited optical axis (or 3-axis or z-axis) of the crystal. This nomenclature has the advantage that the refractive index for light polarized perpendicularly (ordinarily) with respect to the 3-axis of the coordinate system is always the so-called ordinary refractive index no . For a uniaxial crystal, the ordinary refractive index is independent of the direction of propagation. Light polarized parallel to the optical axis – i.e., extraordinarily polarized light – sees the extraordinary refractive index ne . Unlike no , the extraordinary refractive index ne depends on the direction of propagation. Important is the angle Θ between the optical axis of the crystal and the direction of propagation of the incoming laser beams as it will determine which nonlinear coefficient the light actually sees. This coefficient is called the effective nonlinear coefficient. The 1-axis of the NLO coordinate system proposed to be the standard for NLO [20] is then chosen along the crystal a-axis, the remaining 2-axis needs to be perpendicular to the 1- and 3-axes. The refractive index for a uniaxial crystal is commonly described by the index ellipsoid or indicatrix introduced in Fig. 7. For uniaxial crystals, two different cases are distinguished: positive and negative birefringent crystals. In the case of a positive uniaxial crystal, the extraordinary refractive index is larger than the ordinary index, i.e., ne > no (Fig. 7a). For a negative uniaxial crystal, the opposite is true, i.e., ne < no (Fig. 7b). Mathematically the equation of the ellipse shown as shaded area in Fig. 7 is given by: sin2 Θ cos2 Θ 1 = + . n2 (Θ) n2e n2o
(9)
Equation (9) clearly indicates the dependence of the refractive index n(Θ) on Θ.
Mid-IR Difference Frequency Generation c
105
3 ne > no c
3
ne < no
ne ne
1
no no b
a)
a
no
2
Optical uniaxial positive birefringent crystal
1
no
a
b
b)
2
Optical uniaxial negative birefringent crystal
Fig. 7a,b. The indicatrix giving the optical axis along which the light sees the refractive indices ne or no
Whereas for uniaxial crystals, the above described nomenclature is widely accepted and found in most publications, the situation for biaxial nonlinear crystals is much more complicated and many different nomenclatures are found. The coordinate system often chosen to describe the nonlinear tensor is the following [20]: The different crystal classes are distinguished. For monoclinic crystals, the 2-axis is chosen along the b-axis of the crystal. For orthorhombic crystals, the axes are chosen along the (a,b,c)-axes of the crystal. For triclinic crystals, the axes are chosen arbitrarily. For a centrosymmetric crystal, all tensor elements vanish; for triclinic crystals, all elements are non-zero. For most other symmetries, many terms of the nonlinear tensor are zero which simplifies the calculations. In Table 2, the nonlinear coefficients given in units of pm V−1 (10−12 mV−1 ) of some commonly used materials for frequency conversion are listed. 2.3
Phase Matching
Phase matching (or momentum conservation) is a crucial issue in frequency conversion. The different phase-matching types including quasi-phasematching will be discussed in this section both for positive and negative birefringent nonlinear bulk crystals and periodically poled materials. Other important parameters such as conversion efficiency, walk-off, acceptance angle, and acceptance bandwidth will be introduced.
106
Cornelia Fischer and Markus W. Sigrist
Table 2. Nonlinear optical coefficients dim of some commonly used nonlinear inorganic uniaxial and biaxial crystals for frequency conversion around 1.064 µm or around 10.6 µm Crystal AgGaS2
Nonlinear coefficient dim (pm V−1 )
Wavelengths λ( µm)
d36 = 17.5 [20]
1.064
d36 = 11.2 [20]
10.600
AgGaSe2
d36 = 33 [20]
AgSbS3
d22 = 8.2 [21]
Ba2 NaNb5 O15
d15 = −12.8 [21]
d24 = 12.8 [21]
d32 = −12.8 [21]
d33 = −17.6 [21]
10.600 d31 = 7.8 [21] d31 = −12.8 [21]
10.600 1.064 10.600
Ba2 TiO3
d32 = −13.5 [23]
d33 = −5 [23]
BeSO4
d14 = 0.22 [20]
d25 = 0.22 [20]
d36 = 0.22 [20]
1.064
β-BaB2 O4 (BBO)
d16 = −2.3 [20]
d21 = −2.3 [20]
d22 = 2.3 [20]
1.064
d24 = 0.1 [20]
d31 = 0.1 [20]
d32 = 0.1 [20]
1.064
1.064
CdGeAs2
d36 = 282 [21]
CdS
d15 = −16 [20]
d24 = −16 [20]
d32 = −16 [20]
d33 = 32 [20]
10.600
CdSe
d31 = −18 [20]
d33 = 36 [20]
10.600
CsH2 AsO4 (CDA)
d36 = 0.40 [22]
CsTiOAsO4 (CTA)
d31 = 2.1 [21]
10.600 d31 = −16 [20]
1.064 d32 = 3.4 [21]
d33 = 18.1 [21]
d36 = 83 [20]
GaAs
10.600
1.064 10.600
GaP
d36 = 37 [20]
GaSe
d14 = 105 [21]
InP
d14 = 263 [22]
10.600
KD2 PO4 (KD∗ P)
d36 = 0.37 [20]
1.064
KH2 PO4 (KDP)
d36 = 0.39 [20]
K3 Li2 Nb5 O15
d31 = 5.8 [21]
KNbO3
d15 = −12.8 [20]
d24 = 11.3 [20]
d32 = 11.3 [20]
d33 = −19.5 [20]
d15 = 5.2 [20]
d24 = 2.9 [20]
d32 = 2.9 [20]
d33 = 12 [20]
d15 = 3.6 [20]
d24 = 2.0 [20]
d32 = 2.0 [20]
d33 = 8.3 [20]
KTiOAsO4 (KTA) KTiOPO4 (KTP) LiB3 O5 (LBO)
10.600 d22 = 54 [21]
10.600
1.064 d33 = 10.5 [21]
d15 = 0.85 [20]
d24 = −0.67 [20]
d32 = −0.67 [20]
d33 = 0.04 [20]
1.064 d31 = −12.8 [20]
1.064
d31 = 5.2 [20]
1.064
1.064 1.064 d31 = 3.6 [20]
1.064 1.064
d31 = 0.85 [20]
1.064 1.064
LiIO3
d15 = 4.4 [20]
d31 = 4.4 [20]
d33 = 4.5 [20]
1.064
LiNbO3
d15 = −4.3 [20]
d24 = −4.3 [20]
d31 = −4.3 [20]
1.064
d32 = −4.3 [20]
d33 = −27 [20]
LiTaO3
d22 = 2 [24]
d31 = −1 [24]
d33 = −21 [24]
1.064
ND4 H2 PO4
d36 = 0.52 [22]
NH4 H2 PO4 (ADP)
d14 = 0.47 [20]
RbH2 PO4 (RDP)
d36 = 0.40 [21]
RbTiOAsO4 (RTA)
d31 = 2.3 [23]
Se
d11 = 97 [21]
1.064 1.064
d36 = 0.47 [20]
1.064 1.064
d32 = 3.8 [23]
d33 = 15.8 [23]
1.064 10.600
SiO2 (Quartz)
d11 = 0.3 [20]
1.064
Te
d11 = 598 [21]
10.600
ZnGeP2
d14 = 69 [20]
d25 = 69 [20]
d36 = 69 [20]
10.600
Mid-IR Difference Frequency Generation
2.3.1
107
Birefringent Phase Matching
The kind of nonlinear process actually observed mainly depends on the phasematching condition which corresponds to the conservation of momentum. The phase-matching condition in a nonlinear optical single crystal is given by: ∆ k = kp − ks − ki = 0 ,
(10)
where ∆ k is the so-called phase mismatch, and kp , ks , and ki denote the wavevectors of the pump, signal, and idler beam, respectively. All the materials showing second-order nonlinear optical activity are non-centrosymmetric, even though the wavevectors do not necessarily depend on the state of polarization of the incident light according to their crystal class. Two different perpendicular polarizations are distinguished according to the crystallographic point group of the material: ordinary (o) and extraordinary (e) polarization. For processes in nonlinear optical crystals, two different types of phase matching (type I and type II) occur. Historically, they originate from SHG experiments [25]. Kaschke and Koch suggest that a third type (type III) is added [26]. Here, we cite the definition of all three types both for SHG/SFG and DFG processes, but will then concentrate on type I and II phase matching. Table 3 summarizes the possible combinations for both positive and negative birefringence. Using |k| = nc/λ, where c is the speed of light and λ the wavelength, the phase-matching condition in the case of collinear wavevector propagation, Table 3. Different phase-matching types for SHG and DFG processes for positive and negative birefringent crystals (λi ≥ λs > λp : wavelengths of the idler, signal, and pump beams, respectively, PM: phase matching, e: extraordinarily polarized, o: ordinarily polarized, in: incident laser beams, out: generated beam) PM type
Birefringence in λi
SHG/SFG out λs
→
λp
DFG in λp
out λs
→
λi
I
positive
e
e
→
o
o
e
→
e
I
negative
o
o
→
e
e
o
→
o
II
positive
o
e
→
o
o
e
→
o
II
negative
e
o
→
e
e
o
→
e
III
positive
e
o
→
o
o
o
→
e
III
negative
o
e
→
e
e
e
→
o
108
Cornelia Fischer and Markus W. Sigrist
type I phase matching, and a positive birefringent crystal can be expressed as follows for a difference frequency generation (DFG) process: ne (ωi , Θ) nDFG no (ωp ) ne (ωs , Θ) = = − . λi λDFG λp λs
(11)
Using (9), one obtains: −1 no (ωp ) ne (ωs , Θ) sin2 Θpm 1 1 − sin2 Θpm − = + , λp λs λi [ne (ωi )]2 [no (ωi )]2
(12)
where Θpm is the so-called phase-matching angle. Phase matching can be realized by different methods which all take advantage of the fact that the refractive index changes as a function of the incident angle (12), temperature or wavelength. Accordingly, one distinguishes between angle, temperature, and wavelength tuning: Angle Tuning: The most common way to reach phase matching in a single crystal is by rotating the crystal until the phase-matching condition (12) is fulfilled. For a uniaxial crystal, the rotation axis is usually chosen perpendicular to the symmetry axis of the crystal. The situation is depicted in Fig. 8. ne
k ne(ω, Θ)
Θ
n(Θ)
no no(ω,0) no(ω,Θ) = no(ω,0) ne(ω,0)
Fig. 8. Angle tuning (by angle Θ) of a uniaxial crystal changes the refractive index the light experiences, and thus the phase-matching condition can be met by angle tuning of the crystal. The corresponding refractive indices no and ne are indicated
Mid-IR Difference Frequency Generation
109
Temperature Tuning: Another approach to reach phase matching involves changing the temperature of the crystal as the refractive indices not only depend on the angle Θ, but also on the temperature T and the wavelength λ. Only at a well-defined temperature will the phase-matching condition thus be fulfilled and the nonlinear optical process take place. Wavelength Tuning: A third possibility to reach phase matching is to change the wavelength of the pump and/or the signal beam. In contrast to the previous schemes, this, however, requires a tunable pump and/or signal source. 2.3.2
Acceptance Angle and Acceptance Bandwidth
The angle Θ for which phase matching is fulfilled is defined as the angle between the optical axis and the wavevector k of the light. The indicatrix gives the two refractive indices ne and no for each angle Θ as shown above in Fig. 8. For a uniaxial crystal, the refractive index no is independent of Θ whereas ne takes different values for each angle. For biaxial crystals, both refractive indices depend on Θ. In addition to the different types of phase matching (I and II), critical and non-critical phase matching are distinguished. Figure 9 illustrates the difference. ne
ne
acceptance angle
acceptance angle ne(ω) ne(ω)
no(2ω) no(2ω) no no(ω)
a) non-critical phasematching: ne > no
no no(ω)
b) critical phasematching: ne > no
Fig. 9. Phase matching in a uniaxial birefringent crystal for SHG. (a) Situation for non-critical phase matching. Small deviations from exact phase matching do not cause large efficiency losses. (b) In the case of critical phase matching, small deviations from exact phase matching lead to a large phase mismatch
110
Cornelia Fischer and Markus W. Sigrist
In the case of non-critical phase matching, a small angle mismatch (e.g., induced by a small angle tuning of the crystal) will only have a minor effect on the conversion efficiency. In the case of critical phase matching, a small deviation from prefect phase matching will reduce the conversion efficiency considerably. The acceptance angle δΘ is defined as follows: If the phasematching angle Θpm is tuned to Θpm ± δΘ, the intensity of the generated DFG light shall drop to half its peak intensity, i.e., the acceptance angle gives the deviation from the phase-matching angle Θpm for which the idler intensity decays to half its peak value. This deviation is characterized by the phase shift ∆ kL/2 for which sinc2 (∆ kL/2) = 0.5 for Θ = Θpm ± δΘ (L denotes the crystal length). To obtain the acceptance angle δΘ, the phase mismatch ∆ k is expanded as a power series around Θ = Θpm : 2 ∂n(Θ) ω ω 2 ∂ n(Θ) + (Θ − Θpm ) . (13) ∆ k = 2 (Θ − Θpm ) 2 c ∂Θ Θ=Θpm c ∂Θ Θ=Θpm In the case of non-critical phase-matching, the first derivative vanishes at Θ = Θpm . Thus, only the second term needs to be considered. In the case of critical phase matching, the first term of the Taylor expansion is used to determine the acceptance angle. In order to judge how critical the alignment of the system as a whole and the positioning of the crystal in particular are, not only the acceptance angle, as described above, but also the spectral and temperature acceptance bandwidths need to be considered as the phase mismatch (∆ k) depends on both Θ and λ. The spectral acceptance δλ describes in principle the required degree of coherence of the light in order to achieve efficient phase matching. It is defined similarly to the acceptance angle: the phase shift ∆ kL/2 shall be such that sinc2 (∆ kL/2) = 0.5, i.e., the idler intensity will drop to half its peak value at λ = λpm ± δλ where λpm is the phase-matching wavelength. In order to find an expression for the acceptance bandwidth, the phase mismatch is again expanded as a power series, but this time around the phase-matching wavelength λ = λpm . Similar to the acceptance angle and the spectral acceptance bandwidth, there is also a temperature acceptance bandwidth δT . It is derived from the phase-matching temperature Tpm and is defined as the temperature deviation δT for which the intensity of the generated light drops by a factor of two. 2.3.3
Conversion Efficiency
A nonlinear process is commonly characterized by the conversion efficiency η. This parameter is the ratio of the power Pout or intensity Iout at the desired output wavelength (DFG wavelength here) to the incident laser power or intensity, respectively, i.e., the rate of the incident intensity that is converted
Mid-IR Difference Frequency Generation
111
into the intensity at the desired wavelength. As there are two laser beams incident on the nonlinear crystal for a DFG process, two different conversion efficiencies can be defined:
ηp =
Pout Iout = Pp Ip
(14)
ηs =
Pout Iout = , Ps Is
(15)
where ηp , ηs , Pp , Ps , and Ip , Is are the conversion efficiencies, the powers and the intensities for the pump and the signal laser, respectively. We here assumed that the cross-sectional area A for the pump, signal and idler beams are equal, i.e., Ip = Pp /A and Is = Ps /A. In the case of difference frequency generation (DFG) and of perfect phase matching, the conversion efficiency η is in the limit of low conversion efficiency [27]:
ηp = 2
ωi2 d2eff L2 Is , c3 ε 0 n p n s n i
(16)
ηs = 2
ωi2 d2eff L2 Ip , c3 ε 0 n p n s n i
(17)
and in the case of ∆ k = 0, i.e., for non-perfect phase matching: ω 2 d2 L2 Is ηp = 2 3i eff sinc2 c ε 0 np ns ni ηs = 2
ωi2 d2eff L2 Ip sinc2 c3 ε 0 n p n s n i
∆ kL 2 ∆ kL 2
,
(18)
,
(19)
where ωi is the frequency of the generated light (i.e., the frequency of the idler beam). np , ns , ni indicate the refractive indices of the pump, the signal, and the idler beams, respectively, c is the speed of light, and ε0 the dielectric constant. deff denotes the effective nonlinear coefficient depending on the type of phase matching and other parameters such as the angle Θ as described below. L is the interaction length (i.e., the pathlength of the light within the crystal where the incident beams interact with each other). As mentioned above, two different conversion efficiencies exist for a DFG process: ηp and ηs . ηp describes how much of the pump laser power is converted into DFG radiation, whereas ηs describes how much signal laser power is converted. The effective nonlinear coefficient deff depends on the direction of propagation of the light within the crystal as well as on the direction of the polarization and the crystal orientation. In Table 4, the effective nonlinear
112
Cornelia Fischer and Markus W. Sigrist
Table 4. Effective nonlinear optical coefficient for some crystallographic point groups and both positive and negative birefringent crystals. Θ denotes the angle between the direction of propagation and the optical axis of the crystal, whereas φ is the angle between the 1-axis (or a-axis) of the crystal and the projection of the direction of propagation onto the a–b plane (standard “Euler” angles in the coordinate system described above in Sect. 2.2) Crystal group
Positive birefringent crystals Type II phase matching deff Type I phase matching deff
6, 4
−d14 sin 2Θ
d15 sin Θ
622, 422
−d14 sin 2Θ
0
6mm, 4mm 0 ¯ 6m2 d22 cos2 Θ cos 3φ
d15 sin Θ −d22 cos Θ sin 3φ
3m ¯ 6
d22 cos2 Θ cos 3φ
d15 sin Θ − d22 cos Θ sin 3φ
cos Θ(d11 sin 3φ + d22 cos 3φ)
cos Θ(d11 cos 3φ − d22 sin 3φ)
3
cos2 Θ(d11 sin 3φ + d22 cos 3φ) −d14 sin 2Θ
cos Θ(d11 cos 3φ + d22 sin 3φ) +d15 sin Θ
32 ¯ 4
d11 cos2 Θ sin 3φ − d14 sin 2Θ
d11 cos Θ cos 3φ
sin 2Θ(d14 cos 2φ − d15 sin 2φ)
− sin Θ(d14 sin 2φ + d15 cos 2φ)
¯ 42m
d14 sin 2Θ cos 2φ
−d14 sin Θ sin 2φ
Crystal group
Negative birefringent crystals Type II phase matching deff Type I phase matching deff
6, 4
d31 sin Θ
d14 sin Θ cos Θ
622, 422
0
d14 sin Θ cos Θ
2
6mm, 4mm d31 sin Θ ¯ 6m2 −d22 cos Θ sin 3φ
0 d22 cos2 Θ cos 3φ
3m ¯ 6
d31 sin Θ − d22 sin 3φ cos Θ
d22 cos2 Θ cos 3φ
cos Θ(d11 cos 3φ − d22 sin 3φ)
cos2 Θ(d11 sin 3φ + d22 cos 3φ)
3
cos Θ(d11 cos 3φ − d22 sin 3φ) +d31 sin Θ
cos2 Θ(d11 sin 3φ + d22 cos 3φ) +d14 sin Θ cos Θ
32 ¯ 4
d11 cos Θ cos 3φ
d11 cos2 Θ sin 3φ + d14 sin Θ cos Θ
− sin Θ(d31 cos 2φ + d36 sin 2φ)
cos 2φ(d14 + d36 ) sin Θ cos Θ − sin 2φ(d15 + d31 ) sin Θ cos Θ
¯ 42m
−d36 sin 2φ sin Θ
(d36 + d14 ) cos 2φ sin Θ cos Θ
Mid-IR Difference Frequency Generation
113
optical coefficients for some crystal groups and both negative and positive birefringent crystals are given. The intensity of the generated light generally scales with the interaction length L (normally corresponding to the crystal length) and is proportional to the conversion efficiency η. For perfect phase matching, it is given as: IDFG = 2
ωi2 d2eff L2 Ip Is . c3 ε 0 n p n s n i
(20)
This equation is valid as long as there is no pump depletion, i.e., as long as the conversion efficiency is small (ηp,s < 0.3), and if the cross-sectional areas of all three beams can be assumed to be equal. As can be seen from (20), the intensity of the generated DFG light scales with both the pump and the signal laser intensity. If the pump intensity is high, the output DFG power will increase. But there is also a trade-off: if the pump intensity is high, other nonlinear processes – in particular optical parametric generation (OPG) and optical parametric amplification (OPA), which have undesired effects on the linewidth of the generated light – become efficient. In the case of critical phase matching, the waves with different polarizations and different wavelengths will travel along different paths within the crystal due to the crystal birefringence. After some distance, denoted as the walk-off distance, the three beams will be completely separated. There will be no further interaction between the three laser beams and thus the intensity of the generated light will not increase further even if the crystal length L is much longer than the walk-off distance la (also called the aperture distance) [28]: √ πw , (21) la = ρ where w is the 1/e power radius of the Gaussian beam spot of the idler or the signal beam (for an actual calculation, the beam spot of the smaller of the two beams is chosen). The parameter commonly used to describe the walk-off effect is the walk-off angle ρ which describes the angle between two beams of different polarization. In the case of DFG and birefringent phase matching, there are thus two different walk-off angles depending on the type of phase matching. For bulk LiNbO3 , this angle is about 2◦ and depends on the direction. For most birefringent materials, the walk-off angle is between 1◦ and 2.5◦ . Equation (17) gives the maximum conversion efficiency which may be achieved assuming that no losses occur, neither within the crystal, nor due to focusing, nor when coupling into the crystal, etc. In practice, there are always losses, and the conversion efficiency taking into account focusing losses
114
Cornelia Fischer and Markus W. Sigrist
is written as [29]: ηp = 2
ωi2 d2eff L2 Is h(µ, ξs , ρ) , n p n s n i c3 ε 0
(22)
ηs = 2
ωi2 d2eff L2 Ip h(µ, ξp , ρ) , n p n s n i c3 ε 0
(23)
2 where µ = ks /kp , ξs,p = L/(ks,p ws,p ) with ws , wp denoting the Gaussian beam spot radius of the signal and pump laser beam, respectively. The function h(µ, ξ, ρ) contains information about the focusing geometry. For optimum focusing and in the case that there is no birefringence, h(µ, ξ, ρ) ∼ 1 which corresponds to ξ = 1 [30]. If birefringence cannot be neglected, h(µ, ξ, ρ) and thus the efficiency η are reduced. The conversion efficiency described by (16) and (17) is often used as the figure of merit for DFG processes. Unfortunately, there also exist other definitions of the figure of merit. For instance, a normalized conversion efficiency in the form:
ηnorm,1 = 2
ωi2 d2eff L2 3 c ε 0 np ns ni
,
(24)
or in the form: ηnorm,2 = 2
ωi2 d2eff 0 np ns ni
c3 ε
(25)
is also a suitable definition of the figure of merit. The advantage of both these definitions of the figure of merit is that they are independent of the incident laser power and in the case of (25) even independent of the crystal length. 2.3.4
Quasi-phase-matching
Owing to the shape of the dispersion relation within a material, it is often difficult or even impossible to fulfill both energy and momentum conservation simultaneously for most materials. The situation is illustrated in Fig. 10a. For normal dispersion (dn/dω > 0, which can also be expressed as dn/dλ < 0), it is impossible to reach phase matching between the fundamental and the second harmonic of the fundamental at twice the frequency. The same holds true for the nonlinear mixing of two arbitrary frequencies as shown in Fig. 10a. For birefringent materials, however, it is possible to fulfill both energy conservation and phase matching under certain conditions (since the refractive index depends on the polarization of the material) as illustrated in Fig. 10b. There are many materials for which the phase-matching condition and energy conservation can simultaneously be fulfilled. Unfortunately, the largest nonlinear coefficient can quite often not be used for the frequency conversion process. An example is the well-known negative birefringent nonlinear
Mid-IR Difference Frequency Generation
115
n ω normal normaldispersion: dispersion:dn/d dn/dω >> 00
ω
k
n
energy conservation: ω i = ω p - ωs phase-matching: type I, positive birefringent ne(ωi) ωi = no(ωp) ωp - ne(ωs) ωs
kp ki + ks ks ki
normal dispersion
ωi ωs
ωi + ωs= ωp
ω
a)
ωp
ωs ω i
ne(ωi) ne(ωs) no = no(ωp) λ
b)
Fig. 10. (a) Normal dispersion relation (dn/dω > 0): Phase matching (10) and energy conservation (7) cannot be fulfilled simultaneously. (b) For a birefringent material, the phase-matching condition and energy conservation can simultaneously be fulfilled
material LiNbO3 . Its largest nonlinear coefficient is d33 which implies that the polarizations of all three beams involved are the same. In birefringent phase matching, this coefficient unfortunately cannot be used as it is neither compatible with type I, nor with type II phase matching (see Table 3 above). Thus, other approaches are desirable. One way to avoid this conflict is to use periodically poled nonlinear materials and take advantage of quasiphase-matching (QPM) which is illustrated in Fig. 11. If the phase-matching condition is not met (∆ k = 0), after each coherence length lc given by lc = π/∆ k, the newly generated light will destructively interfere with the light generated in the previous coherence length. Thus, after twice the coherence length all generated light will be destroyed (case C in Fig. 11). On the other hand, if the polarization of the material is changed by 180◦ after each coherence length, the nonlinear optical coefficient will change its sign. Thus, the light will constructively interfere with the light from the previous coherence length and a build-up of the generated light is observed (case B in Fig. 11). The figure also shows that the build-up of the generated intensity is lower than in the case of perfect phase matching where ∆ k = 0 (case A in Fig. 11). Case B is called quasi-phase-matching, and as Fig. 11 implies, the length of the domain ΛQPM with constant polarization must be an even multiple of the coherence length lc , i.e., ΛQPM = 2lc . For a quasi-phase-matching process, the phase mismatch ∆ k is: ∆k =
2π = kp − ks − ki = 0 . ΛQPM
(26)
116
Cornelia Fischer and Markus W. Sigrist IDFG IDFG(4lc)
A
(2/π)2 IDFG(4lc) B
C 0
lc
z
lc
polarisation direction
nonlinear material
Fig. 11. Quasi-phase-matching in a periodically poled nonlinear optical material. (A) Idler intensity for a DFG process in a single crystal if the phase-mismatch ∆ k is equal to zero. (B) Idler intensity for quasi-phase-matching. (C) Idler intensity in a single crystal if the phase-matching condition is not met. lc denotes the coherence length
Although the efficiency of the process is lower than in the case of birefringent phase matching (where ∆ k = 0), one of the major advantages is that quasi-phase-matching is not restricted to type I and type II phase matching, but also other processes are possible, in particular the process e + e → e using the nonlinear coefficient d33 which is largest for many nonlinear materials (see Table 2). In addition for this particular process (e + e → e), the walk-off angle (21) is zero as all involved polarizations are the same. Another advantage is that QMP usually operates in the non-critical phase-matching regime. The conversion efficiency of the pump laser beam ηQPM,p for this process is given as:
ηQPM,p = 2
ωi2 3 c ε 0 np ns ni
ωi2 =2 3 c ε 0 np ns ni
2deff mπ
2
dQPM m
L2 Is 2 L2 Is ,
(27)
Mid-IR Difference Frequency Generation
117
where m is the order of quasi-phase-matching and dQPM the effective nonlinear coefficient for quasi-phase-matching. An analogous expression is obtained for the conversion efficiency of the signal laser beam ηQP M, s simply by replacing Is in (27) by Ip . The order of the QPM process is given by the number of coherence lengths after which the intensity build-up continues, i.e., first-order quasi-phase-matching means that after each coherence length the build-up continues as shown in Fig. 11, third-order QPM means that only after the third coherence length the sign of the nonlinear coefficient is changed and a further intensity build-up will take place. Usually, first-order QPM is employed, but if the coherence length of the material is short, it becomes difficult to produce the fine periodically poled structure. Thus, the period length ΛQPM is extended. In order to achieve any intensity build-up, the period length needs to be an uneven number of coherence lengths lc of the nonlinear material employed. Owing to the fact that the largest nonlinear optical coefficient can be exploited and that in collinear frequency conversion the whole length of the crystal can be used (since the aperture distance la (21) is usually much larger than the coherence length or there occurs no walk-off at all due to the fact that all involved polarizations are the same), much higher intensities can be achieved with QPM than with birefringent phase matching for many materials [31]. Table 5 compares the achieved effective nonlinear coefficients for several commonly used nonlinear crystals. λPM is the wavelength at which the nonlinear coefficient was measured in the case of birefringent phase matching (at Table 5. Comparison of quasi-phase-matching (QPM) and birefringent phase matching (PM) systems for SHG. λPM is the birefringent phase-matching wavelength, d is the corresponding nonlinear optical coefficient, ∆ λPM is the acceptance bandwidth for a 1 cm-long crystal, λQPM the quasi-phase-matching wavelength, dQPM is the effective nonlinear optical coefficient for QPM, and ΛQPM is the period length of the periodically poled structure Crystal
λPM (nm)
dim (pm V−1 )
∆ λPM (nm)
CsLiB6 O10
478
d36
KNbO3 (KN)
858 858 982
d31 −12.8 d32 −11.3 d24 −11.3
0.09 0.09 0.18
d31 d32
3.6 2.0
0.08
d31
0.85
KTiOPO4 (KTP) LiB3 O5 (LBO)
994 1082 552
1.1
λQPM (nm)
dQPM (pm V−1 )
ΛQPM ( µm)
0.5
850
8.3
4.0
1
LiNbO3 (LN)
1086
d31 −4.3
0.04
850
−17
3.0
LiTaO3 (LT)
1058
d31
0.12
850
10
3.8
1
118
Cornelia Fischer and Markus W. Sigrist
room temperature and for non-critical phase matching), λQPM denotes the corresponding wavelength for QPM. The effective nonlinear optical coefficient dQPM is the one for first-order QPM: dQPM =
2 deff . π
(28)
The acceptance bandwidth ∆ λPM is given for a 1 cm-long bulk crystal. Table 5 clearly shows that the effective nonlinear coefficient for QPM is usually higher than for birefringent phase matching. Equation (27) can be used to calculate the maximum achievable DFG intensity IDFG for QPM: IDFG
ωi2 =2 3 c ε 0 np ns ni
2 deff mπ
2 L2 Ip Is .
(29)
The DFG power PDFG is then given as: PDFG
ωi2 =2 3 c ε 0 np ns ni
2 deff mπ
2 L2 Pp Ps
1 , A
(30)
where A is the cross-sectional area of the beam assuming that A is not altered during the DFG process and that the two incoming beams have the same cross-section. The equations given in this section were all derived for a flat wave approximation. A careful analysis shows that the cross-section A of the laser beam is proportional to the length of the crystal (for most practical cases). Thus, the overall efficiency, DFG intensity, and DFG power is proportional to length L instead of L2 .
3
Material Considerations
The implementation of a DFG laser source requires selecting a pump and signal source as well as an appropriate nonlinear medium. Several parameters such as transparency range, nonlinear coefficient, and damage threshold of the nonlinear crystal, as well as wavelength tunability and power of the available lasers, come into play. Obviously, the selection of the lasers and the crystal has to be carefully matched. With the advent of new laser types and a variety of novel nonlinear crystals and particularly periodically poled materials, new combinations have become available. In the first part of this section, we focus on the nonlinear material while the choice of laser sources is emphasized in the second part.
Mid-IR Difference Frequency Generation
3.1
119
Selection of Nonlinear Medium
Table 6 and Fig. 12 summarize the most important properties of various nonlinear media which might be used for mid-IR difference frequency generation. The nonlinear material selected needs to be transparent for all wavelengths involved, i.e., for the signal, the pump, and the idler wavelength. Furthermore, the nonlinear coefficient should be as high as possible for high conversion efficiencies. In addition, the material has to be able to cope with high intensities (especially if a high output DFG power shall be achieved) as the intensity of the generated light scales with the intensities of the pump and signal source (20). The damage thresholds of some selected materials are given in Table 6. Table 6 implies that a wide variety of crystals is available for frequency conversion. Also, a large wavelength range is covered (0.1–20 µm).
CdGeAs 2
100
Absolute nonlinear coefficient in pmV-1
ZnGeP2 GaSe CdSe
AgGaSe2
PPLN
HgGa2S4
KNbO3 PPRTA
AgGaS2 PPKTA
AgAsS 3
10
PPKTP LiIO3
KTA LiNbO3 KTP
RTA
KDP
1
CLBO LBO ADP BBO SiO2 0.1
1
10
Transparency range in µm
Fig. 12. Transparency range of some selected nonlinear crystals used for mid-IR DFG generation as a function of the absolute value of the nonlinear coefficient. For the periodically poled materials (PPLN, PPRTA, PPKTA, PPKTP), the nonlinear coefficient d33 is given. For n-th order QPM processes, the values given need to be multiplied by 2/(nπ)
120
Cornelia Fischer and Markus W. Sigrist
Table 6. Important properties of different nonlinear crystals commonly used for difference frequency generation. d denotes the nonlinear optical coefficient. The damage threshold is given in GW cm−2 for the indicated pulse duration in ns Crystal
Transparent ( µm)
AgAsS3 AgGaS2 AgGaSe2 AgSbS3 β-BaB2 O4 (BBO)
0.6–13 0.46–13 0.71–19 0.7–14 0.2–2.6
CdGeAs2 CdSe
2.4–18 [33] 0.75–25 [33]
CsTiOAsO4 (CTA) CsLiB6 O10 (CLBO) GaSe KD2 PO4 (KD∗ P)
0.35–5.3 0.18–2.75 0.62–20 0.19–1.6
[33] [33] [33] [33] [33]
[33] [33] [33] [34]
daim (pm V−1 ) d36 d36 d36 d22 d22 d21 d36 d31 d33 d33 d33 d22 d36
10.4 17.5 33 8.2 2.3 −2.3 282 −18 36 18.1 1 54 0.37
[33] [20] [20] [33] [20] [20] [33] [33] [20] [33] [22] [33] [20]
0.19–1.3 [34] KH2 PO4 (KDP) KNbO3 0.4–5.5 [24] KTiOAsO4 (KTA) 0.35–5.3 [33] KTiOAsO4 (PPKTA)
d36 0.39 [20] d33 −19.5 [20] d15 5.2 [20] d33 12 [20]
KTiOPO4 (KTP) KTiOPO4 (PPKTP) HgGa2 S4 HgS LiB3 O5 (LBO)
0.34–3.2 [33]
d15 d33 d36 d11 d31
3.6 8.3 24 50 0.85
[20] [20] [33] [33] [20]
LiIO3 LiNbO3 LiNbO3 (PPLN) LiTaO3 MgO:LiNb3 NH4 H2 PO4 (ADP) RbTiOAsO4 (RTA) RbTiOAsO4 (PPRTA) SiO2 (Quartz) ZnGeP2
0.3–5.8 [33] 0.35–5.5 [34]
d33 d15 d33 d33 d33 d36 d32 d33
4.5 −4.3 −27 −21 17 0.47 4.6 12.1
[20] [20] [20] [20] [35] [20] [33] [33]
0.55–13 [33] 0.62–13 [33] 0.2–3.2 [33]
0.32–5.2 0.40–5 0.18–1.5 0.35–5.8
[34] [33] [33] [23]
0.2–3.1 [34] 0.74–12 [33]
d11 d36
0.3 [20] 69 [20]
Damage threshold [32,33] (GW cm−2 ) (ns) 0.025 0.025
10 10
9.9 5
1.3 10
0.060
10
26
1
0.5 6 8.4 0.1 10
10 0.25 1.3 10 10
0.16 4.6
20 1.3
18 87 0.06 0.5
1.3 0.03 20 10
0.5
60
1
2
a Note: The nonlinear optical coefficients d11 , d22 , and d33 can only be used in combination with quasi-phase-matching
Mid-IR Difference Frequency Generation
121
The fabrication of large crystals is advantageous for a high conversion efficiency, especially in the case of birefringent phase matching. Costs of the material will also have to be considered as they increase for larger crystals. In addition, the walk-off angle or the aperture distance la (21) needs to be kept in mind. If the walk-off angle is large, the advantage large crystals offer becomes obsolete since the two incident laser beams disperse and do not interact any longer beyond the aperture distance. Since there often exists no material which meets all material requirements (large nonlinear coefficient, right transparency range, low costs, etc.), some sort of trade-off has to be taken into account. Finally, the possibility of the use of quasi-phase-matching needs to be considered before the system is set up. In recent years, many periodically poled materials have become commercially available. Today, the most commonly used periodically poled materials are PPLN, PPRTA, PPKTA, and PPKTP. Note that the period of the domains required for the wavelengths of interest is not always available, but that usually a larger nonlinear coefficient can be taken advantage of, although it is reduced by a factor 2/π. 3.2 Pump and Signal Laser Sources for Difference Frequency Generation Along with the selection of a suitable nonlinear material, laser sources with appropriate properties need to be found. The tuning range of one of the two lasers (either pump or signal laser) needs to be broad enough in order to cover the desired wavelength range for spectroscopic applications. The difference frequency of the two lasers chosen, of course, has to be in the desired wavelength region and all three lasers should be within the transparency range of the crystal. Furthermore, the laser power plays an important role. The intensity and thus the power of the generated DFG light scales with the pump and signal intensity. If the pump intensity is too low, the generated intensity can be limited by pump depletion [36]. However, for high pump intensities, other nonlinear processes like optical parametric generation (OPG) and amplification (OPA) will compete with DFG. Unwanted side effects of such processes are, e.g., an enlarged linewidth of the generated light. As an example, stateof-the-art external cavity diode lasers (ECDL) offer a broad tuning range. Their CW output power at mW level is appreciable, but still OPG/OPA and other nonlinear processes are sufficiently suppressed. The achieved average idler power using an external cavity diode laser as pump source though is usually only at the µW level which might not be sufficient for spectroscopic applications. Despite their limited CW laser power, ECDLs can successfully be employed as signal lasers in a DFG set-up [37]. A final issue to be considered is the DFG laser linewidth which needs to be sufficiently narrow for many applications. For example in gas sensing, the linewidth should be considerably smaller than the width of the molecular
122
Cornelia Fischer and Markus W. Sigrist
absorption line. At atmospheric pressure, molecular absorption linewidths are typically 0.5 cm−1 (15 GHz), thus a DFG linewidth of ∼ GHz would be desirable. Since the DFG laser linewidth is given by a convolution of the linewidth of the pump and the signal laser, both laser sources need to be narrowband. This requirement further limits the choice of pump and signal sources. For instance, the pulse length of pulsed lasers should not be too short since short and ultrashort pulses in the ps and fs regime exhibit too large intrinsic linewidths. In addition, the peak power of ultrashort pulse lasers might exceed the damage threshold of the crystal, especially at high pulse repetition rates.
4 Difference Frequency Laser Systems Reported in the Literature Although various requirements are posed on pump and signal sources as well as on the nonlinear crystal for efficient difference frequency generation, there is still a large variety of possible combinations. The first DFG system reported dates back to 1974 [38]. It involved an Ar+ laser, a dye laser and a LiNbO3 crystal as nonlinear medium. With the availability of new laser types, new and improved nonlinear optical materials, and driven by numerous applications, many DFG laser sources have been reported. The publications can be divided into two different groups. On the one hand, pure systems without presentations of applications have been described. On the other hand, there also exist reports on DFG systems applied, e.g., for spectroscopic measurements. 4.1
Difference Frequency Laser Sources
Selected laser systems based on difference frequency generation that have been reported in literature in recent years are listed in Table 7. Given are the types and the wavelengths of the two incident lasers (pump laser and signal laser), the wavelength range of the generated DFG beam, along with information about the nonlinear crystal and the type of phase matching used. 4.2
Difference Frequency Laser Sources Applied in Gas Sensing
Table 8 lists some systems employed for spectroscopic applications. Given are the types and wavelengths of the two incident lasers and the wavelength range of the generated DFG signal. In addition, the nonlinear material is stated along with the type of phase matching used. Finally, the gases analyzed are listed.
Mid-IR Difference Frequency Generation
123
Table 7. Selected DFG systems recently reported. Listed are pump and signal laser types with their wavelengths λp and λs , the generated DFG laser wavelength range λDFG , the nonlinear crystal, and the type of phase matching (PM). (ECDL stands for external cavity diode laser, Dye for dye laser, Ti:Sa for Ti:sapphire laser, Nd:YAG for Nd:YAG laser, DL for diode laser, Nd:YLF for Nd:YLF laser, OPG/OPA/OPO for optical parametric generation, amplification, and oscillation, HeNe for HeNe laser, CO for CO laser, FP for Fabry–P´erot, TDL for tunable diode laser) λp (nm)
λs (nm)
λDFG (nm)
540–620
910–1050
1064
Ti:Sa DL
Pump laser
Signal laser
Dye
Ti:Sa
Nd:YAG
CO
Nd:YAG DL
Crystal
PM
Ref.
1200–1900
KTiOPO4 (KTP)
II
[39]
2600–4100
1430–1800
RbTiOAsO4 (RTA)
532
770–820
1500–1730
LiB3 O5 (LBO)
I
[41]
780
∼1500
∼1500
LiNbO3
QPM
[42]
[40]
Ti:Sa
DL
784
1539
∼1597
LiNbO3
QPM
[43]
Nd:YLF
Ti:Sa
523
750–850
1649–1707
KTiOPO4 (KTP)
QPM
[44]
Ti:Sa
Ti:Sa
690–750
910–1050
2300–2800
KTiOPO4 (KTP)
II
[39]
OPA
OPA
1100–1600
1600–2933
2400–12000
GaAsS2
I & II
[45]
Ti:Sa
OPG/OPA
ECDL
HeNe
Ti:Sa
Nd:YAG
Nd:YAG
806
1200–1500
2500–7600
(3)
CaF2 & BaF2
χ
[46]
1500–1580
3391
2689–2958
Ti:LiNbO3
QPM
[47]
770–820
1064
3000–3600
KTiOPO5 (KTP)
II
[41]
OPO
1064
1430–1600
3200–4200
RbTiOAsO4 (RTA)
n.a.
[48]
OPO
OPO
1700–2010
2260–2840
5000–18000
GaAsSe2
I & II
[49]
Ti:Sa
Nd:YAG
1052–1068
1320
5200–5600
GaAs
QPM
[50]
FP-TDL
ECDL
DL
DL
ZnGeP2 OPG
ZnGeP2 OPG
ECDL
ECDL
ZnGeP2 OPG
ZnGeP2 OPG
1290
1504–1589
7143–7407
AgGaSe2
I
[51]
766–786
830–868
6800–12500
AgGaS2
II
[52]
4000–5000
6500–9500
7000–20000
CdGeAs2
I
[53]
778
842
10200
AgGaS2
I
[54]
∼ 4790
∼ 6740
15600–17600
GaAs
QPM
[55]
124
Cornelia Fischer and Markus W. Sigrist
Table 8. DFG systems reported in the literature which were used for spectroscopic applications. Listed are pump and signal laser types with their wavelengths λp and λs , the generated DFG laser wavelength range λDFG , the nonlinear crystal, and the type of phase matching (PM), and the gases detected. (crit. stands for critical PM, Dye for dye laser, Ar+ for argon ion laser, ECDL for external cavity diode laser, Nd:YAG for Nd:YAG laser, DL for diode laser, DFB for distributed feedback laser, GaAlAs for GaAlAs laser, and Ti:Sa for Ti:sapphire laser) Pump laser
Signal laser
Dye
Ar+
λp (nm)
λs (nm)
λDFG (nm)
Crystal
1887–5263
LiIO3 &
PM
Gas Ref. formula H+ 3 , CO N2 O, H2 CO
LiNbO3
[56]
ECDL
DL
775–795
1096
2650–2900
LiNbO3
QPM
H2 O
[57]
ECDL
Nd:YAG 795–825
1064
3160–3670
LiNbO3
I
CH4 , H2 CO NO2 , C2 H6
[58]
Nd:YAG
ECDL
1064
1500–1600 3176–3660
LiNbO3
QPM
CH4
[37]
Nd:YAG
ECDL
1064
1515–1585 3236–3798
LiNbO3
QPM
CH4
[59]
DL
ECDL
1083
DL
DL
∼ 760
ECDL
ECDL
H2 CO ∼ 980
3262–3454
LiNbO3
QPM
O2 , H2 O CH4
[60]
DFB DL 814–870
1083
3280–4400
LiNbO3
QPM
CH4 , CO2 SO2 , HCl
[61]
DL
775–795
1010
3330–3730
LiNbO3
QPM
CH4
[57]
DL
DL
775–795
1010
3330–3734
LiNbO3
QPM
CH4
[62]
ECDL
Nd:YAG 795–825
1064
3350–3630
LiNbO3
crit. PM
CH4 H2 O
[63]
3358
LiNbO3
DL
Nd:YAG 808
1064
QPM
CH4
[64]
Nd:YAG
ECDL
1064.4
1500–1600 3450–3750
KTiOAsO4 QPM (KTA)
CH4
[65]
Nd:YAG
ECDL
1064.4
1500–1600 3450–3750
KTA, KTP QPM RTA
CH4 N2 O
[66]
DL
DL
1083
1561
3531
LiNbO3
QPM
H2 CO
[67]
ECDL
Nd:YAG 839–864
1064
3980–4620
LiNbO3
QPM
CO, CO2 SO2 , N2 O
[68]
DL
Nd:YAG 852
1064
4250
LiNbO3
QPM
CO2
[69]
DL
Nd:YAG 850
1064
4250
LiNbO3
QPM
CO2
[70]
GaAlAs
Nd:YAG 853–865
1064
4310–4629
LiNbO3
QPM
CO, N2 O
[71]
DL
DL
800–807
4487–5071
AgGaS2
noncrit.
CO OCS
[72]
GaAlAs
Nd:YAG 865
1064
4624
LiNbO3
QPM
CO, N2 O
[73]
AgGaS2
CO2 684–691
DL
Dye
668–673
768–785
5010–5230
I
NO
[74]
Ti:Sa
Ti:Sa
700–810
790–910
8000–19000 GaSe
I
C 2 H2
[75]
Ti:Sa
Ti:Sa
780–900 780–900 8800–15000 GaSe
I
C2 H4
[76]
Mid-IR Difference Frequency Generation
5
125
Detailed Description of a Mid-IR DFG Laser Source
In the following, we present the design, implementation and applications of a compact DFG laser system developed in our laboratory. Most design considerations and system characteristics have been described in detail previously [77]. 5.1
Experimental Set-Up and System Performance
The whole measurement set-up is shown in Fig. 13. The DFG source basically consists of the pump and signal laser and a periodically poled LiNbO3 (PPLN) crystal. The quasi-phase-matching condition is met by controlling the temperature of the PPLN crystal using a specially designed oven. A unique feature of our DFG source is the combination of a pulsed pump laser with a continuous wave (CW) signal laser. In this configuration, OPG/OPA processes are considerably suppressed, especially when the system is run at low output DFG power (below 2 mW). An appreciable average power (up to 14 mW) has been generated, yet at the loss of the narrow linewidth due to OPG/OPA processes competing with the DFG process. For a pure OPG/OPA process, the linewidth was measured to be as wide as 195 GHz compared to only 154 MHz for a pure DFG process. amplifier trigger pulse Si-photodiode CRD BS
ECDL
PAS
(1500 - 1610 nm, cw)
half-wave
L 2 plate
"Signal" laser, 8 mW power
L3
oven
Gefilter
L4
multipass transmission
"Idler", 3.2 - 3.7 µm, 600 W peak power, up to 14 mW average power
Nd:YAG laser
temperature control unit
(1064 nm, pulsed)
L1 "Pump" laser, 5 kW peak power, 8.4 kHz, 6 ns
detector
PPLN
quarter- and half-wave plate
Fig. 13. Set-up of the difference frequency laser source with different detection schemes for gas sensing. ECDL: external cavity diode laser, PPLN: periodically poled LiNbO3 crystal, CRD: cavity ring-down, PAS: photoacoustic spectroscopy, BS: beam-splitter, L1−4 : lenses
126
Cornelia Fischer and Markus W. Sigrist
The pump laser is a diode-pumped pulsed high peak power passively Q-switched Nd:YAG laser in a non-planar ring oscillator (NPRO) configuration [78] and sets the pulse repetition rate and the linewidth of 154 MHz, as well as the pulse duration for the generated DFG signal. The signal laser is a continuous-wave (CW) external cavity diode laser (ECDL) tunable between 1500 nm and 1600 nm which sets the tuning range of the DFG laser source. The DFG process takes place in a periodically poled lithium niobate crystal (PPLN). The crystal has eight different gratings with grating periods Λ between 29.1 µm and 30.4 µm. Thus, the whole tuning range of the ECDL is accessible for the DFG process. The main features of the DFG laser source are summarized in Table 9. Table 9. Characteristics of the difference frequency laser source Characteristic Parameter
Data
Wavelength range
3.2 µm–3.7 µm
Line width (at low DFG power)
154 MHz
Temperature acceptance bandwidth a
17 ◦ C
Average power of the DFG signal
0.2 mW–14 mW
Pulse repetition rate
3 kHz–8 kHz
Pulse length
6 ns
At powers above ∼ 2 mW, OPG/OPA processes dominate resulting in an enlarged linewidth
a
5.2
Nd:YAG Pump Laser
The exact wavelength of the difference-frequency laser source can easily be determined using the equation for energy conservation introduced above in (7). However, this approach requires the wavelengths of the pump and the signal lasers to be known with sufficient accuracy. We used a different method: The wavelength of the CW ECDL was measured with a commercial wavemeter, whereas the DFG wavelength was deduced from spectroscopic measurements on methane using the local maximum of the transmission curve of 100 ppm methane diluted in synthetic air (79.5 % N2 , 20.5 % O2 ) at around 3380.2387 nm. The accurate wavelength of the pulsed Nd:YAG laser could then be derived by using (7) [79]. As Fig. 14 implies, the wavelength shows a distinct dependence on the temperature of the Nd:YAG crystal.
Mid-IR Difference Frequency Generation
Measured data
1064.57 Nd:YAG wavelength in nm
127
1064.55
1064.53
1064.51
Slope: 0.014 nm / °C
1064.49 22
24
26
28
30
32
34
36
Temperature in °C
Fig. 14. Dependence of the Nd:YAG laser wavelength on the temperature of the Nd:YAG crystal
In general, the emitted wavelength increases as a function of the temperature. There are five distinct leaps indicating mode hops. The sections between two successive leaps show a linear wavelength increase with temperature with a slope of 0.014 nm/ ◦ C. 5.3
External Cavity Diode Laser
The signal laser is an external cavity diode laser with a large and continuous tuning range and with a CW laser power of 5–8 mW. The combination of these two lasers results in a high average power whilst still considerably suppressing other nonlinear processes. As seen in the previous section (Tables 7, 8), diode lasers emitting around 800 nm are often used as one of the laser sources. In those cases, however, the low-power tunable laser around 800 nm is the pump laser and lower DFG intensities will result due to pump repletion [36]. The disadvantage of the high pump laser intensity, though, is that other nonlinear optical processes will take place in the nonlinear crystal, especially for an optimized temperature of the nonlinear crystal. As a matter of fact, we observed second and third harmonic generation of the pump wavelength, sum frequency generation between the pump and signal laser wavelengths, as well as optical parametric generation (OPG) and amplification (OPA). The optical parametric processes generate the same wavelength as the DFG process and result in an enhanced output power, yet also in an enlarged linewidth of the laser source and thus in a lower spectral resolution of the system. Hence, the DFG linewidth can be tailored by adjusting the pump laser power. For the DFG process at low conversion efficiency, the generated DFG intensity is proportional to both the intensity of the pump and the intensity of the signal
128
Cornelia Fischer and Markus W. Sigrist
laser (20). For the OPA process at high conversion efficiency, the intensity scales exponentially with the pump laser electric field. 5.4
Tuning with Periodically Poled LiNbO3
Idler Wavelength in µm
The tuning of the generated difference frequency wavelength is carried out varying two parameters. On the one hand, the wavelength of the signal laser is changed in order to reach different wavelengths. Energy conservation (7) determines which wavelength will be generated if the quasi-phase-matching condition (26) is fulfilled, i.e., if the crystal period length ΛQPM is appropriately chosen. The phase-matching condition is achieved by selecting the right grating period of the PPLN crystal (out of eight periods as given by the crystal manufacturer) and by heating the crystal to the right temperature. Although the temperature acceptance bandwidth of LiNbO3 is rather large (17 ◦ C), the crystal still needs to be heated to roughly the optimized temperature. In Fig. 15a, the optimized temperatures for efficient frequency conversion are shown for five different grating periods of the PPLN. 29.5 µm grating period 29.7 µm grating period 29.9 µm grating period 30.0 µm grating period 30.2 µm grating period
3.6 3.5 3.4 3.3 3.2 3.1 20
30
40
a)
50
60 70 80 90 100 Crystal Temperature in °C
110
120
Idler Wavelength in µm
4.0
130
29° C 47° C 63° C 81° C 97° C 114° C Corresponding calculated Sellmeier curves
3.8 3.6 3.4 3.2 3.0 2.8 28.5 b)
29.0
29.5 30.0 Crystal Period in µm
30.5
31.0
Fig. 15. Tuning characteristics for different grating periods of the PPLN crystal. (a) Temperature tuning for five different grating periods. The overlap of the generated ranges of idler wavelengths from different grating periods is clearly visible. (b) Generated idler wavelength as a function of the grating period for different temperatures. The solid lines represent the calculated Sellmeier curves [80]
Mid-IR Difference Frequency Generation
129
Figure 15b shows the generated idler wavelength as a function of the grating period for different temperatures. The calculated Sellmeier curves (solid lines) well coincide with the measured data points. Only by selecting the right grating and by varying both parameters – temperature and signal wavelength – is efficient phase matching over a large wavelength range possible. 5.5
Detection Schemes
In view of applications of the described continuously tunable DFG laser source in the area of gas sensing, we implemented different detection schemes into the set-up as shown in Fig. 13 above. To date the system has been mainly operated with two different detection schemes. 5.5.1
Transmission Spectroscopy
Transmission spectroscopy relies on the measurement of both the incident and the transmitted intensity. On the basis of the familiar Beer–Lambert absorption law, the gas concentration can be determined if the molecular absorption cross-section and the absorption pathlength are known [13]. The detection sensitivity can be enhanced by extending the pathlength and reducing the noise originating from the detector or the laser source. Thus, often multipass absorption cells are used. We implemented a Herriot-type multipass cell with a total pathlength of 36 m into our system. The total throughput of the empty cell is about 23 % at wavelengths around 3 µm. The advantage of this detection method is the high sensitivity achievable even at low laser power. As transmission spectroscopy is an indirect absorption measurement, i.e., a small deviation from a large signal is measured, the sensitivity depends on the signal-to-noise ratio of the detectors used to record both the incident and the transmitted intensity. For low incident laser powers, cooled detectors designed for low powers can be used which usually exhibit a better signal-to-noise ratio. Thus, the small deviation of the transmitted power from the incident laser power can be detected more easily . The disadvantage of this indirect detection technique is the distinct wavelength characteristic of the mirror reflectivity. In addition, the adjustment of the cell is rather difficult. 5.5.2
Photoacoustic Spectroscopy
As an alternative, we developed a small single pass resonant photoacoustic cell for trace-gas detection with the described DFG system. The cell is equipped with four microphones and has a resonance frequency which coincides with the pulse repetition rate of the laser (5.7 kHz) [37].
130
Cornelia Fischer and Markus W. Sigrist
Photoacoustics has the great advantage that it is a direct absorption measurement, i.e., the measured signal is directly proportional to the absorbed laser power and thus the absorption coefficient of the gaseous sample [81]. This is in contrast to transmission spectroscopy which is an indirect absorption measurement technique where a small intensity difference between two measured signals yields the absorbed laser power. Furthermore, the detection scheme itself is wavelength independent and operated at room temperature since the signal detection is performed by means of microphones. The disadvantage of the photoacoustic detection scheme is that the signal scales with the laser power, i.e., in the case of low laser power like for our compact DFG laser source where only a few mW average power is achieved, it is essential to use strong absorption lines for sensitive gas monitoring. In addition, the pulse repetition rate needs to be stable enough to take advantage of the resonant detection scheme. 5.5.3
Cavity Ring-Down Spectroscopy
A third detection scheme to be considered is cavity ring-down (CRD) [82]. In this case, the laser light is injected into an external cavity usually consisting of two highly reflecting mirrors with a typical reflectivity of > 99.9 % for the wavelength of interest. The ring-down of the radiation leaking out of the cavity is monitored as a function of time with a fast and sensitive detector. The resulting high sensitivity of the detection method originates from the very long pathlength (up to several km). The advantage of cavity ring-down spectroscopy (CRDS) is that it is again a direct absorption measurement. The transmitted intensity is recorded as a function of time. The decay time then allows the absorption coefficient to be determined. Since the decay time can be determined from each single pulse entering the cavity, the pulse-to-pulse fluctuations (both in intensity and in the time between two consecutive pulse) do not alter the sensitivity of the system nor do they add any additional error to the measurement. The disadvantage of CRDS is the requirement of highly reflecting mirrors which can only be accomplished for a certain wavelength range ∆ λ, typically ∆ λ/λctr ≈ 10%, where λctr refers to the center wavelength of the high mirror reflectivity. This implies that unlike in photoacoustic spectroscopy, measurements in a different wavelength region require a different set of mirrors. A further aspect of mid-IR CRDS, especially of pulsed CRDS, concerns the need for sensitive mid-IR detectors. Despite cryogenic cooling, these detectors are still less sensitive than photomultipliers commonly used in the visible or near-IR wavelength range. This implies that higher powers are advantageous for achieving high sensitivities.
Mid-IR Difference Frequency Generation
131
6 Applications of Mid-IR Difference Frequency Laser Systems in Gas Sensing Applications of difference frequency laser systems are manifold. Most applications, though, are found in gas sensing. In the first part of this section, we briefly outline different fields of gas sensing applications. In the second part, we present multicomponent trace-gas measurements performed with the DFG laser system introduced in Sect. 5. 6.1
General Considerations
Although other applications of tunable mid-IR laser sources can be envisaged, the main area of application is in chemical sensing, particularly in trace-gas monitoring and analysis. There are several fields of interest. 6.1.1
Environment
Potential applications include atmospheric monitoring of pollutants, of photochemical smog compounds, of volcanic, or greenhouse gases such as methane, analyses of unknown gas samples, e.g., from industrial stack emission, road emissions, etc. 6.1.2
Industry
Potential applications are gas sensing in process industry to optimize certain processes and simultaneously minimize dangerous emissions, e.g., in the semiconductor or chemical production industry. Another issue is the surveillance of working place concentrations. Many working places are subject to potentially dangerous concentrations of hazardous compounds where continuous monitoring is of great importance to ensure the safety of the workers. 6.1.3
Agriculture
Fruit fermenting processes are known to result in the emission of certain gases such as ethene, methanol, ethanol, water, carbon dioxide, etc. [83,84]. The continuous monitoring of the concentrations of these gases can thus help to optimize the storage conditions. Other applications concern sensing of, e.g., ethane emission of plants, detection of wilting of flowers or deterioration of meat. 6.1.4
Medicine
The analysis of the exhaled human breath could be used as a valuable noninvasive diagnostic tool for certain human diseases, e.g., for the early detection of ulcers, colon cancer or diabetes [85].
132
Cornelia Fischer and Markus W. Sigrist
6.2 Examples of Gas Spectroscopy Performed with Our DFG Laser Source The main advantages of the DFG system described above is its large and continuous tuning range between 3.2 µm and 3.7 µm. This wavelength region coincides with the absorption range of many atmospheric trace-gases, e.g., methane, formaldehyde, ethane, carbon monoxide, carbon dioxide, ammonia, etc. The small linewidth (154 MHz) of the system allows for both high resolution and highly selective measurements. The system is thus ideally suited to measure and analyze multicomponent gas samples. In Table 10, some compounds of interest absorbing in the accessible wavelength range of the DFG source are listed, along with their main absorption line and absorption strength. The absorbance is calculated for 100 ppm of the particular gas at a total pressure of 1 bar and room temperature and for an absorption path length of 1 m. The last column gives the maximum permissible working place concentration (MAK). A typical measurement of a two-component gas sample using the photoacoustic detection scheme is shown in Fig. 16. It depicts a recording of methane and ethane around 3.3 µm at room temperature and 1 bar total pressure. The data clearly demonstrates the advantage of both the large continuous tuning range and the narrow linewidth. The absorption lines of the two Table 10. Gases absorbing in the 3.2–3.7 µm range and their absorption strength Compound
Formula
Absorbancea
Wavelength ( µm)
MAKb (ppmV)
Ammonia
NH3
0.011
3.456
Carbonyl sulfide
OCS
0.018
3.410
Ethane
C2 H6
0.383
3.348
Formaldehyde
H2 CO
0.239
3.574
0.5
Methane
CH4
0.181
3.381
10000
0.493
3.270
Methyl bromide
CH3 Br
3.382
20 10000
5
Methyl chloride
CH3 Cl
0.062
3.372
50
Hydrogen chloride
HCl
0.613
3.375
5
Nitrogen dioxide
NO2
0.046
3.458
3
Ozone
O3
0.0027
3.460
0.1
Absorbance A = log(1/T ), T = transmission for a concentration of 100 ppm diluted in synthetic air (20.5 % oxygen, 79.5 % nitrogen) at room temperature and 1 bar total pressure b MAK = maximum permissible working place concentration as regulated by the Swiss Federal Government a
Mid-IR Difference Frequency Generation
30.0 2.0.10-3
20.0 10.0
0.0
0.0 3.2696
3.2700 3.2704 Wavelength in µm Normised PA signal in mV/W
20.0
10.0
10 ppm methane 9 ppm ethane
4.0.10-3
methane
3.2708 3.0.10-3
30.0 ethane
2.0.10-3
20.0
1.0.10-3
10.0
Absorbance
30.0
40.0
Absorbance
Normised PA signal in mV/W
Normised PA signal in mV/W
40.0
133
0.0 0.0
3.3472
3.3476
3.3480
3.3484
3.3488
Wavelength in µm
0.0
3.27
3.28
3.29
3.30 3.31 Wavelength in µm
3.32
3.33
3.34
3.35
Fig. 16. A measurement of a gas sample containing 9 ppmV ethane and 10 ppmV methane diluted in synthetic air at room temperature and 1 bar total pressure
gases can easily be distinguished and recorded at high resolution. Despite the rather low average DFG power, photoacoustic measurements are feasible. A measurement with the resolution shown in the insets of the figure takes about 40 minutes each. Between the measurements only the temperature of the PPLN crystal needs to be changed. As PPLN has a rather high temperature acceptance bandwidth, the temperature only needs to be optimized within a few ◦ C. From these measurements, the current detection limits can be determined to be about 1 ppmV for both methane and ethane at a signal-to-noise ratio of 3. These detection limits are low enough to use the system for air monitoring at working places and can further be lowered by increasing the average laser power and improving the photoacoustic cell design. Measurements with the multipass cell yield similar results as shown in Fig. 17 for a three-component mixture of NO2 , N2 O, and H2 O vapour. Despite the large tuning range of the system, highly resolved measurements are possible due to the narrow linewidth and the fact that the injected laser intensity plays a minor role for multipass transmission measurements provided the detectors are sensitive enough, i.e., the detector noise level is sufficiently small. The sensitivity can considerably be enhanced by increasing the averaging time for a single measurement point. The detection limits using the 36 m multipass transmission cell are in the ppbV range for many gaseous species, e.g., 7 ppbV for methane, 3.5 ppbV for ethane, 80 ppbV for nitrogen
134
Cornelia Fischer and Markus W. Sigrist
transmission
1.000
0.995
0.990
2888.3 cm-1
0.985 calculated NO2 conc.: 3.44 ± 0.22 ppm averaging time: 5 s 0.980 0.0
0.1
0.2
0.3
relative wavenumber in cm-1
transmission
1.000
0.995
0.990
0.985 0.0
2786.0 cm-1 calculated N2 O conc.: 51.3 ± 4.3 ppm averaging time: 10 s 0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
relative wavenumber in cm-1
transmission
1.00
0.95
2966.0 cm-1
0.90
0.85 0.0
calculated H2 O conc.: 0.250 ± 0.006 % averaging time: 1 s 0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
relative wavenumber in cm-1
Fig. 17. Example of multicomponent trace-gas analysis. The baseline corrected spectra were recorded using the 36 m multipass transmission cell filled with a mixture of three different gases at the indicated concentrations diluted in synthetic air at atmospheric pressure. The large tuning range allows measurements at many different wavelengths, e.g., at 2888.3 cm−1 for NO2 , 2786.0 cm−1 for N2 O, and 2966.0 cm−1 for H2 O vapour
Mid-IR Difference Frequency Generation
135
dioxide, and 30 ppbV for formaldehyde for an averaging time of 60 s for each data point and a signal-to-noise ratio of 3. The DFG laser source based spectroscopic system presented is thus suitable for trace-gas monitoring. The system performance in terms of achieved detection limits and detection selectivity meets the requirements for most applications by far. The compact room temperature operated system can thus be employed for a whole variety of gas sensing applications as briefly discussed above.
7
Conclusions and Outlook
Mid-infrared laser systems are expected to play an increasing role in the future. Although laser sources emitting at a fixed, desired wavelength are of interest for specific studies, by far more applications require tunable lasers for optical sensing. In order to access the important finger print region of molecular absorption for spectroscopic applications, difference frequency generation represents a powerful and useful tool. The generated average power in the µW to mW range allows measurements with most common detection schemes. The wavelength range accessible can be chosen between, e.g., 2 µm and 19 µm depending on available pump and signal sources and nonlinear crystals. The tuning of a DFG source is straightforward, and the wavelength generated can simply be calculated. The linewidth of the generated coherent light is basically given by the linewidth of the pump and signal laser allowing for narrow linewidths needed for high resolution spectroscopy. The set-up of a DFG laser system can be made compact, especially if diode lasers are used as pump and signal sources. With the advent of ever improved solid-state and diode lasers to be employed as pump and signal sources in a DFG laser set-up, further improvements with respect to performance can be expected. Potential also lies in the development of nonlinear crystals and periodically poled materials with either better quality and higher damage thresholds or even of novel materials with larger nonlinear coefficients and extended transparency ranges enabling higher conversion efficiencies and hence output powers, as well as a further extension of accessible wavelengths. Acknowledgements The authors thank a number of coworkers for their valuable input. Specially acknowledged are Dr. M. Seiter for experimental contributions to this work and Dr. I. Biaggio for critically reading the manuscript.
136
Cornelia Fischer and Markus W. Sigrist
References 1. P. L. Hanst, S. T. Hanst: Gas measurements in the fundamental infrared region, in Air Monitoring by Spectroscopic Techniques Chem. Anal. Ser. 127, M. W. Sigrist (Ed.) (Wiley, New York 1994) pp. 335–470 97 2. L. S. Rothman, C. P. Rinsland, A. Goldman, S. T. Massie, D. P. Edwards, J. M. Flaud, A. Perrin, C. Camy-Peyret, V. Dana, J. Y. Mandin, J. Schroeder, A. McCann, R. R. Gamache, R. B. Wattson, K. Yoshino, K. V. Chance, K. W. Jucks, L. R. Brown, V. Nemtchinov, P. Varanasi: The HITRAN molecular spectroscopic database and HAWKS (HITRAN atmospheric workstation), 1996 edition, J. Quant. Spectrosc. Radiat. Transfer 60, 665–710 (1998) 98 3. W. J. Wittemann: The CO2 Laser, Springer Ser. Opt. Sci. 53 (Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg 1987) 98 4. P. Repond, M. W. Sigrist: Continuously tunable high-pressure CO2 laser for spectroscopic studies on trace gases, IEEE J. Quant. Electr. 32(9), 1549–1559 (1996) 98 5. W. Urban: Physics and spectroscopic applications of carbon monoxide lasers, a review, Infrared Phys. Technol. 36(2), 465–473 (1995) 98 6. J. Faist, F. Capasso, D. L. Sivco, C. Sirtori, A.-L. Hutchinson, A.-Y. Cho: Quantum cascade laser, Science 264, 553–556 (1994) 99 7. F. Capasso, J. Faist, C. Sirtori, A.-Y. Cho: Infrared (4–11 µm) quantum cascade lasers, Solid State Commun. 102, 231–236 (1997) 99 8. F. Capasso, C. Gmachl, D. L. Sivco, A.-Y. Cho: Quantum cascade lasers, Phys. World 12, 27–33 (1999) 99 9. J. Faist: private communication (2002) 99 10. A. A. Kosterev, F. K. Tittel: Chemical sensors based on quantum cascade lasers, IEEE J. Quantum Electron. 38(6), 582–591 (2002) 99 11. D. Hofstetter, M. Beck, J. Faist, M. Naegele, M. W. Sigrist: Photoacoustic spectroscopy with quantum cascade distributed feedback lasers, Opt. Lett. 26(12), 887–889 (2001) 99 12. B. A. Paldus, T. G. Spence, R. N. Zare, J. Oomens, F.-J. M. Harren, D. H. Parker, C. Gmachl, F. Capasso, D. L. Sivco, J. N. Baillargeon, A.-L. Hutchinson, A. Y. Cho: Photoacoustic spectroscopy using quantum-cascade lasers, Opt. Lett. 24 (3), 178–180 (1999) 99 13. H. I. Schiff, G. I. Mackay, J. Bechara: The use of tunable diode laser absorption spectroscopy for atmospheric measurements, in Air Monitoring by Spectroscopic Techniques Chem. Anal. Ser. 127, M. W. Sigrist (Ed.) (Wiley, New York 1994) pp. 239–333 100, 129 14. M. Tacke: New developments and applications of tunable IR lead salt lasers, Infrared Phys. Technol. 36(1), 447–463 (1995) 100 15. P. Werle, F. Slemr, K. Maurer, R. Kormann, R. M¨ ucke, B. J¨ anker: Near- and mid-infrared laser-optical sensors for gas analysis, Opt. Lasers Engin. 37, 101– 114 (2002) 100 16. A. Boschetti, D. Bassi, E. Iacob, S. Iannotta, L. Ricci, M. Scotoni: Resonant photoacoustic simultaneous detection of methane and ethylene by means of a 1.63-µm diode laser, Appl. Phys. B 74, 273–278 (2002) 100 17. J. D. Jackson: Classical Electrodynamics, 3rd ed. (Wiley, New York 1999) 101 18. P. A. Franken, A. E. Hill, C. W. Peters, G. Weinreich: Generation of optical harmonics, Phys. Rev. Lett. 7(4), 118–119 (1961) 101
Mid-IR Difference Frequency Generation
137
19. M. Bass, P. A. Franken, J. F. Ward, G. Weinreich: Optical rectification, Phys. Rev. Lett. 9(11), 446–448 (1962) 103 20. D. A. Roberts: Simplified characterization of uniaxial and biaxial nonlinear optical crystals: a plea for standardization of nomenclature and conventions, IEEE J. Quant. Elect. 28(10), 2057–2074 (1992) 104, 105, 106, 120 21. V. G. Dmitriev, G. G. Gurzadyan, D. N. Nikogosyan: Handbook of Nonlinear Optical Crystals, (Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg 1993) 106 22. Eksma Co. Lasers, Optics, Electronics, Lithuania: http://www.eksma.lt 106, 120 23. D¨ ohrer Elektrooptik, Germany: http://www.doehrer-elektrooptik.de/ 106, 120 24. Crystal Technology, Inc., California: http://www.crystaltechnology.com/productdata.html 106, 120 25. J. Q. Yao, T. S. Fahlen: Calculations of optimum phase match parameters for the biaxial crystal KTiOPO4 , J. Appl. Phys. 50(1), 65–68 (1984) 107 26. M. Kaschke, C. Koch: Calculation of nonlinear optical polarization and phase matching in biaxial crystals, Appl. Phys. B 49, 419–423 (1989) 107 27. R. L. Byer, R. L. Herbst: Parametric oscillation and mixing, in Nonlinear Infrared Generation, Topics Appl. Phys. 16, Y. R. Shen (Ed.) (Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg 1977) pp. 81–137 111 28. G. D. Boyd, A. Ashkin, J. M. Dziedzic, D. A. Kleinman: Second-harmonic generation of light with double refraction, Phys. Rev. A 137(4), 1305–1320 (1965) 113 29. T. B. Chu, M. Broyer: Intracavity CW difference frequency generation by mixing three photons and using Gaussian laser beams, J. Phys.(Paris) 46, 523–533 (1985) 114 30. G. D. Boyd, A. Ashkin: Theory of parametric oscillator threshold with singlemode optical masers and observation of amplification in LiNbO3 , Phys. Rev. A 146(1), 187–198 (1966) 114 31. L. E. Myers, R. C. Eckardt, M. M. Fejer, R. L. Byer, W. R. Bosenberg, J. W. Pierce: Quasi-phase-matched optical parametric oscillators in bulk periodically poled LiNbO3 , J. Opt. Soc. Am. B 12(11), 2102–2116 (1995) 117 32. Gs¨ anger Optoelektronik GmbH: http://www.linos-photonics.de/en/homefr2.html 120 33. V. G. Dmitriev, G. G. Gurzadyan, D. N. Nikogosyan: Handbook of Nonlinear Optical Crystals, 2nd rev. ed. (Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg 1997) 120 34. J. S. Browder, S. S. Ballard, P. Klocek: Physical property comparisons of infrared optical materials, in Handbook of Infrared Optical Materials, Opt. Engin. Ser. 127, P. Klocek (Ed.) (Marcel Dekker, New York 1991) pp. 155–425 120 35. Caladox Ltd, Scotland, UK: Product Catalog 120 36. M. Seiter, M. W. Sigrist: Trace-gas sensor based on mid-IR difference-frequency generation in PPLN with saturated output power, Infrared Phys. Technol. 41 (5), 259–269 (2000) 121, 127 37. C. Fischer, M. W. Sigrist, Q. Yu, M. Seiter: Photoacoustic monitoring of trace gases by use of a diode-based difference frequency laser source, Opt. Lett. 26(20), 1609–1611 (2001) 121, 124, 129 38. A. S. Pine: Doppler-limited molecular spectroscopy by difference-frequency mixing, J. Opt. Soc. Am. 64(12), 1683–1690 (1974) 122 39. T. Momose, T. Wakabayashi, T. Shida: Tunable-narrow-linewidth continuouswave mid-infrared light generation by difference-frequency mixing, J. Opt. Soc. Am. B 13(8), 1706–1712 (1996) 123
138
Cornelia Fischer and Markus W. Sigrist
40. O. Pfister, M. M¨ urtz, J. S. Wells, L. Hollberg, J. T. Murray: Division by 3 of optical frequencies by use of difference-frequency generation in non-critically phase-matched RbTiOAsO4 , Opt. Lett. 21(17), 1387–1389 (1996) 123 41. J. Hong, A.-D. O. Bawagan, S. Charbonneau, A. Stolow: Broadly tunable femtosecond pulse generation in the near and mid-infrared, Appl. Opt. 36(9), 1894– 1897 (1997) 123 42. M. H. Chou, K. R. Parameswaran, M. M. Fejer, I. Brener: Multiple-channel wavelength conversion by use of engineered quasi-phase-matching structures in LiNbO3 waveguides, Opt. Lett. 24(16), 1157–1159 (1999) 123 43. M.-H. Chou, J. Hauden, M. A. Arbore, M. M. Fejer: 1.5-µm-band wavelength conversion based on difference-frequency generation in LiNbO3 waveguides with integrated coupling structures, Opt. Lett. 23(13), 1004–1006 (1998) 123 44. G. M. Gibson, G. A. Turnbull, M. Ebrahimzadeh, M. H. Dunn, H. Karlsson, G. Arvidsson, F. Laurell: Temperature-tuned difference-frequency mixing in periodically poled KTiOPO4 , Appl. Phys. B 67(5), 675–677 (1998) 123 45. B. Golubovic, M. K. Reed: All-solid-state generation of 100-kHz tunable midinfrared 50-fs pulses in type I and type II AgGaS2 , Opt. Lett. 23(22), 1760–1762 (1998) 123 46. H. K. Nienhuys, P.-C.M. Planken, R.-A. van Santen, H. J. Bakker: Generation of mid-infrared pulses by χ(3) difference frequency generation in CaF2 and BaF2 , Opt. Lett. 26(17), 1350–1352 (2001) 123 47. D. Hofmann, G. Schreiber, C. Haase, H. Herrmann, W. Grundk¨ otter, R. Ricken, W. Sohler: Quasi-phase-matched difference-frequency generation in periodically poled TiLiNbO3 channel waveguides, Opt. Lett. 24(13), 896–898 (1999) 123 48. D. L. Fenimore, K. L. Schepler, D. Zelmon, S. K¨ uck, U. B. Ramabadran, P. Von Richter, D. Small: Rubidium titanyl arsenate difference-frequency generation and validation of new Sellmeier coefficients, J. Opt. Soc. Am. B 13(9), 1935– 1940 (1996) 123 49. K. S. Abedin, S. Haidar, Y. Konno, C. Takyu, H. Ito: Difference frequency generation of 5–18 µm in a AgGaSe2 crystal, Appl. Opt. 37(9), 1642–1646 (1998) 123 50. P. Bravetti, A. Fiore, V. Berger, E. Rosencher, J. Nagle, O. Gauthier-Lafaye: 5.2–5.6-µm source tunable by frequency conversion in a GaAs-based waveguide, Opt. Lett. 23(5), 331–333 (1998) 123 51. B. Sumpf, D. Rehle, K. Kelz, H. D. Kronfeldt: A tunable diode-laser spectrometer for the MIR region near 7.2 µm applying difference-frequency generation in AgGaSe2 , Appl. Phys. B 67(3), 369–373 (1998) 123 52. V. Petrov, C. Rempel, K. P. Stolberg, W. Schade: Widely tunable continuouswave mid-infrared laser source based on difference-frequency generation in AgGaS2 , Appl. Opt. 37(21), 4925–4928 (1998) 123 53. K. L. Vodopyanov, P. G. Schunemann: Efficient difference-frequency generation of 7–20-µm radiation in CdGeAs2 , Opt. Lett. 23(14), 1096–1098 (1998) 123 54. D. Lee, T. Kaing, J. J. Zondy: An all-diode-laser-based, dual-cavity AgGaS2 CW difference-frequency source for the 9–11 µm range, Appl. Phys. B 67(3), 363–367 (1998) 123 55. D. Zheng, L. A. Gordon, Y. S. Wu, R. S. Feigelson, M. M. Fejer, R. L. Byer, K. L. Vodopyanov: 16-µm infrared generation by difference-frequency mixing in diffusion-bonded-stacked GaAs, Opt. Lett. 23(13), 1010–1012 (1998) 123 56. M. G. Bawendi, B. D. Rehfuss, T. Oka: Laboratory observation of hot bands of H+ 3 , J. Chem. Phys. 93(9), 6200–6209 (1990) 124
Mid-IR Difference Frequency Generation
139
57. K. P. Petrov, A. T. Ryan, T. L. Patterson, L. Huang, S. J. Field, D. J. Bamford: Mid-infrared spectroscopic detection of trace gases using guided-wave difference-frequency generation, Appl. Phys. B 67(3), 357–361 (1998) 124 58. M. Seiter, M. W. Sigrist: On-line multicomponent trace-gas analysis with a broadly tunable pulsed difference-frequency laser spectrometer, Appl. Opt. 38(21), 4691–4698 (1999) 124 59. L. Goldberg, J. Koplow, D. G. Lancaster, R. F. Curl, F. K. Tittel: Midinfrared difference-frequency generation source pumped by a 1.1–1.5 µm dualwavelength fiber amplifier for trace-gas detection, Opt. Lett. 23(19), 1517–1519 (1998) 124 60. U. Gustafsson, J. Sandsten, S. Svanberg: Simultaneous detection of methane, oxygen and water vapour utilising near-infrared diode lasers in conjunction with difference-frequency generation, Appl. Phys. B 71(6), 853–857 (2000) 124 61. D. Richter, M. Erdelyi, R. F. Curl, F. K. Tittel, C. Oppenheimer, H. J. Duffell, M. Burton: Field measurements of volcanic gases using tunable diode laser based mid-infrared and Fourier transform infrared spectrometers, Opt. Lasers Engin. 37 (2), 171–186 (2002) 124 62. K. P. Petrov, A. T. Ryan, T. L. Patterson, L. Huang, S. J. Field, D. J. Bamford: Spectroscopic detection of methane by use of guided-wave diode-pumped difference-frequency generation, Opt. Lett. 23(13), 1052–1054 (1998) 124 63. M. Seiter, D. Keller, M. W. Sigrist: Broadly tunable difference-frequency spectrometer for trace gas detection with noncollinear critical phase matching in LiNbO3 , Appl. Phys. B 67(3), 351–356 (1998) 124 64. K. P. Petrov, S. Waltman, E. J. Dlugokencky, M.-Arbore, M. M. Fejer, F. K. Tittel, L. W. Hollberg: Precise measurement of methane in air using diodepumped 3.4-µm difference-frequency generation in PPLN, Appl. Phys. B 64(5), 567–572 (1997) 124 65. K. Fradkin-Kashi, A. Arie, P. Urenski, G. Rosenman: Mid-infrared difference frequency generation in periodically poled KTiOAsO4 and application to gas sensing, Opt. Lett. 25(10), 743–745 (2000) 124 66. A. Arie, K. Fradkin-Kashi, Y. Shreberk: Frequency conversion in novel materials and its application to high resolution gas sensing, Opt. Lasers Engin. 37(2–3), 159–170 (2002) 124 67. D. Rehle, D. Leleux, M. Erdelyi, F. K. Tittel, M. Fraser, S. Friedfeld: Ambient formaldehyde detection with a laser spectrometer based on difference-frequency generation in PPLN, Appl. Phys. B 72, 947–952 (2001) 124 68. K. P. Petrov, R. F. Curl, F. K. Tittel: Compact laser difference-frequency spectrometer for multicomponent trace gas detection, Appl. Phys. B 66(5), 531–538 (1998) 124 69. D. Mazzotti, P. De Natale, G. Giusfredi, C. Fort, J. A. Mitchell, L. W. Hollberg: Difference-frequency generation in PPLN at 4.25 µm: an analysis of sensitivity limits for DFG spectrometers, Appl. Phys. B 70(6), 747–750 (2000) 124 70. D. Mazzotti, G. Giusfredi, P. Cancio, P. De Natale: High-sensitivity spectroscopy of CO2 around 4.25 µm with difference-frequency radiation, Opt. Lasers Engin. 37, 143–158 (2002) 124 71. K. P. Petrov, L. Goldberg, W. K. Burns,, R. F. Curl, F. K. Tittel: Detection of CO in air by diode-pumped 4.6-µm difference-frequency generation in quasiphase-matched LiNbO3 , Opt. Lett. 21(1), 86–88 (1996) 124
140
Cornelia Fischer and Markus W. Sigrist
72. B. Sumpf, K. Kelz, M. N¨ agele, H. D. Kronfeldt: A CW AgGaS2 difference frequency spectrometer with diode lasers as pump sources, Appl. Phys. B 64(5), 521–524 (1997) 124 73. T. T¨ opfer, K. P. Petrov, Y. Mine, D. Jundt, R. F. Curl, F. K. Tittel: Roomtemperature mid-infrared laser sensor for trace gas detection, Appl. Opt. 36(30), 8042–8049 (1997) 124 74. H. D. Kronfeldt, G. Basar, B. Sumpf: Application of a CW tunable infrared spectrometer based on difference-frequency generation in AgGaS2 for selfbroadening investigations of NO at 5 µm, J. Opt. Soc. Am. B 13(9), 1859–1863 (1996) 124 75. W. Chen, G. Mouret, D. Boucher: Difference-frequency laser spectroscopy detection of acetylene trace constituent, Appl. Phys. B 67(3), 375–378 (1998) 124 76. W. C. Eckhoff, R. S. Putnam, S. Wang, R. F. Curl, F. K. Tittel: A continuously tunable long-wavelength CW IR source for high-resolution spectroscopy and trace-gas detection, Appl. Phys. B 63(5), 437–441 (1996) 124 77. M. Seiter: Novel pulsed difference-frequency laser sources for compact midinfrared trace-gas sensors, No. 13354, ETH Z¨ urich (1999), and in Ser. Quantum Electron. 14, 1–94 (Hartung-Gorre, Konstanz 1999) 125 78. I. Freitag, A. T¨ unnermann, H. Welling: Passively Q-switched Nd:YAG ring lasers with high average output power in single-frequency operation, Opt. Lett. 22(10), 706–708 (1997) 126 79. C. Fischer, E. Wettstein, M. W. Sigrist: Accurate spectroscopic wavelength determination of pulsed lasers, Appl. Phys. B 73(3), 233–237 (2001) 126 80. D.-H.. Jundt: Temperature-dependent Sellmeier equation for the index of refraction, ne , in congruent lithium niobate, Opt. Lett. 22(20), 1553–1555 (1997) 128 81. M. W. Sigrist: Air monitoring by laser photoacoustic spectroscopy, in Air Monitoring by Spectroscopic Techniques, Chem. Anal. Ser. 127, M. W. Sigrist (Ed.) (Wiley, New York 1994) pp. 163–238 130 82. G. Berden, R. Peeters, G. Meijer: Cavity ring-down spectroscopy: experimental schemes and applications, Int. Rev. Phys. Chem. 19(4), 565–607 (2000) 130 83. M. N¨ agele, M. W. Sigrist: Mobile laser spectrometer with novel resonant multipass photoacoustic cell for trace-gas sensing, Appl. Phys. B 70(6), 895–901 (2000) 131 84. H.-S.-M. de Vries, F.-J. M. Harren, L.-A.-C. J. Voesenek, C.-W.-P. M. Blom, E. J. Woltering, H.-C.-P.-M. van der Valk, J. Reuss: Investigation of local ethylene emission from intact Cherry tomatoes by means of photothermal deflection and photoacoustic detection, J. Plant Physiol. 107, 1371–1377 (1995) 131 85. L. G. Sandstrom, S. H. Lundquist, A. B. Petterson, M. S. Shumate: Tunable diode laser spectroscopy at 1.6 and 2 µm for detection of Helicobacter pylori infection using 13 C-urea breath test, in Selected Topics in Quantum Electronics, IEEE J. Quantum Electron. 5(4), 1040–1048 (1999) 131
Index
β-BaB2 O4 (BBO), 106, 120 absorption – fundamental, 97 acceptance angle, 109, 110 acceptance bandwidth, 109 ADP, 106, 120 AgAsS3 , 120 AgGaS2 (AGS), 106, 120 AgGaSe2 (AGSe), 106, 120 AgSbS3 , 106, 120 ammonia, 132 angle tuning, 108 aperture distance, 113 Ba2 NaNb5 O15 , 106 Ba2 TiO3 , 106 BeSO4 , 106 cavity ring-down spectroscopy (CRDS), 130 CdGeAs2 (CGA), 106, 120 CdS, 106 CdSe, 106, 120 CO (carbon monoxide), 132 CO laser, 98 CO2 , 132 coefficient – effective nonlinear optical, 104, 111 – nonlinear optical, 103, 106, 116, 117, 120 coherence length, 115 conversion efficiency, 110 critical phase matching (CPM), 110 crystal, 106, 117, 120, 121 – biaxial, 106 – biaxial nonlinear, 105 – centrosymmetric, 105
– class, 105 – group, 112, 113 – monoclinic, 105 – negative birefringent, 104, 112 – orthorhombic, 105 – positive birefringent, 104, 112 – triclinic, 105 – uniaxial, 104, 106 – uniaxial negative, 104 CsH2 AsO4 (CDA), 106 CsLiB6 O10 (CLBO), 117, 120 CsTiOAsO4 (CTA), 106, 120 damage threshold, 118, 120 detection limit, 133 detection scheme, 129 difference frequency generation (DFG), 102, 107, 108, 122 – system, 122 dipole moment, 100 dispersion, normal, 114 domain length, 115 effective nonlinear coefficient, 104, 111 electric-dipole – approximation, 101 energy conservation, 103, 114, 128 environment, 131 ethane, 132 formaldehyde, 132 frequency conversion process, 100 GaAs, 106 GaP, 106 gas sensing, 122, 131 GaSe, 106, 120 HgGa2 S4 , 120
142
Index
HgS, 120 HITRAN database, 98 idler, 102 index ellipsoid, 104 indicatrix, 104 InP, 106 interaction length, 111 K3 Li2 Nb5 O15 , 106 KD2 PO4 (KD∗ P), 106, 120 KH2 PO4 (KDP), 106, 120 KNbO3 , 106, 117, 120 KTiOAsO4 (KTA), 106, 120 KTiOPO4 (KTP), 106, 117, 120 laser – CO, 98 – CO2 , 98 – ECDL, 100, 121, 126, 127 – external cavity diode, 100, 121, 126, 127 – lead salt, 100 – Nd:YAG, 126 – quantum cascade (QCL), 99 – signal, 102, 125 LiB3 O5 (LBO), 106, 117, 120 LiIO3 , 106, 120 LiNbO3 , 106, 117, 120 – periodically poled (PPLN), 120, 126, 128 LiTaO3 , 106, 117, 120 MAK, 132 medicine, 131 methane, 126, 132 MgO:LiNb3 , 120 momentum conservation, 107 monolithic non-planar ring oscillator (NPRO), 126 ND4 H2 PO4 , 106 Nd:YAG laser, 126 NH4 H2 PO4 , 106, 120 non-planar ring oscillator (NPRO), 126 nonlinear figure of merit (FOM), 114 nonlinear optical coefficient, 103, 106, 116, 117, 120 – effective, 111, 112
optical parametric amplification (OPA), 121, 127 optical parametric generation (OPG), 102, 121, 127 optical rectification (OR), 103 period length, 117 periodic poling, 115 phase matching, 105, 129 – angle, 108 – birefringent, 107 – critical, 109, 110 – first-order quasi-, 117 – non-critical, 109 – non-perfect, 111 – perfect, 111 – quasi-, 114 – type I, 107, 112 – type II, 107, 112 – type III, 107 phase mismatch, 107 polarization – dielectric, 100 – extra-ordinary, 107 – nonlinear, 101 – of light, 107 – ordinary, 107 potassium titanyl phosphate (KTiOPO4 , or KTP), 106, 117, 120 PP KTA, 119, 120 PP KTP, 119–121 PP RTA, 120, 121 PPLN, 120, 121, 126, 128 pump, 102, 125, 126 quartz, 106, 120 quasi-phase-matching (QPM), 114 – first-order, 117 RbH2 PO4 (RDP), 106 RbTiOAsO4 (RTA), 106, 120 refractive index, 101 – extraordinary, 104 – ordinary, 104 Se, 106 second harmonic generation (SHG), 101, 107, 127
Index signal laser, 102, 125 SiO2 , 106, 120 spectral acceptance, 110 spectroscopy, 97 – cavity ring-down (CRDS), 130 – gas, 132 – photoacoustic, 129 – transmission, 129 sum frequency generation (SFG), 102, 107, 127 susceptibility – linear, 100 – nonlinear, 101 telluride, 106 temperature acceptance bandwidth, 110, 128 temperature tuning, 109 third harmonic generation, 127
transparency – range, 118–120 tuning – angle, 108 – temperature, 109 – wavelength, 109 tuning characteristic, 128 walk-off angle, 113 walk-off distance, 113 wavelength tunability, 118 wavelength tuning, 109 wavevector propagation – collinear, 108 working place concentration, 131 – maximum permissible, 132 ZnGeP2 (ZGP), 106, 120
143
Pulsed Mid-IR Optical Parametric Oscillators Konstantin Vodopyanov Ginzton Laboratory, Stanford University, Stanford, CA 94305-4088, USA [email protected] Abstract. Optical parametric oscillators (OPOs) are the laser sources of choice when one needs broad continuous tunability (one octave or more), high peak (> 1 kW) or average (> 1 W) power, and high (> 30 %) conversion efficiency. OPOs use the nonlinear-optical frequency down-conversion mechanism to get a tunable output. This chapter reviews pulsed OPOs in the 2–20 µm region of the spectrum. It contains a description of the principle of OPO operation, reviews existing and emerging nonlinear optical materials suitable for OPO applications and describes different OPO schemes including cascaded OPOs, narrow-linewidth OPOs as well as traveling-wave devices.
1
Introduction
Frequency conversion using optical parametric oscillators (OPOs) is an effective means of generating coherent light at frequencies where lasers perform poorly or are unavailable. OPOs can generate coherent tunable light ubiquitously from the UV to the infrared and even THz domain. In the infrared, they play a particularly important role in the ‘molecular fingerprint’ region of the spectrum, 2–20 µm, where molecular species have their fundamental absorption features, and where we lack broadly tunable lasers similar to dye lasers in the visible, or titanium:sapphire in the near-infrared. The broad tuning range of optical parametric oscillators (in many cases limited just by the optical transparency of the crystals) and efficient power conversion characteristic make them attractive sources in many applications requiring wide tunability and high peak power. Since the first demonstration of optical parametric oscillation by Giordmaine and Miller in 1965, using a LiNbO3 crystal [1], OPOs have made a transition from being a research curiosity to an actual tool in real applications. This transition happened due to many factors including the advent of novel nonlinear-optical materials with low optical losses and high laserdamage thresholds. Periodically structured nonlinear-optical materials revolutionized nonlinear optics by enabling devices with extremely low pumping thresholds to be built. Dramatic improvement in the optical quality of semiconductor materials having intrinsically very high second-order optical nonlinearities and deep mid-IR transparency made it possible to extend the tuning range of existing optical parametric oscillators far beyond 5 µm. Equally important are the advances in high peak power all-solid-state pump lasers, I. T. Sorokina, K. L. Vodopyanov (Eds.): Solid-State Mid-Infrared Laser Sources, Topics Appl. Phys. 89, 141–180 (2003) c Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2003
142
Konstantin Vodopyanov
including microchip and fiber lasers, and new OPO optical designs including cascaded OPO schemes, optical parametric generator–optical parametric amplifier (OPG–OPA) designs, and others. The robustness and compactness of OPOs make them extremely attractive for new applications like laser spectroscopy (both linear and nonlinear), remote chemical sensing, laser radar imaging, trace gas and vapor detection, biology, medicine and free space communications. The focus of this chapter is pulsed optical parametric oscillators, where typically nanosecond-range lasers are used as a pump source.
2
Principle of OPO Operation
OPOs convert monochromatic laser radiation (pump) into a tunable output via a three-wave mixing process with quantum conversion efficiencies which can exceed 50 %. The heart of an OPO is a nonlinear optical (NLO) crystal which is characterized by a NLO coefficient, deff . In the NLO crystal, the pump photon decays into two less energetic photons (signal and idler) so that the sum of their energies is equal to that of the pump photon (Fig. 1). An important further constraint is that the sum of the signal and idler wavevectors (k-vectors) must equal that of the pump – momentum conservation or ‘phase matching’ (PM) condition [2]. The latter condition is never satisfied in the transparency range of isotropic media, where normal dispersion applies, but can be fulfilled in birefringent crystals. Alternatively, it can be fulfilled in ‘quasi-phase-matched’ (QPM) crystals with periodically modulated nonlinearity (a typical example is periodically poled lithium niobate), where the artificially created grating of optical nonlinearity [3] compensates for the wavevector mismatch (Fig. 2). Speaking in a different language, the PM condition is achieved in QPM structures because the relative phase is corrected at regular intervals using a structural periodicity built into the nonlinear medium. Parametric frequency down-conversion in an OPO can be regarded as the inverse process of sum-frequency generation. Alternatively, a NLO crystal can
hw1 w3 =w1+w2
hw3
hw2
k3 =k1+k2
Fig. 1. Optical parametric frequency conversion. In the NLO crystal, the pump photon decays into two less energetic photons (signal and idler) so that the sum of their energies is equal to that of the pump photon
Pulsed Mid-IR Optical Parametric Oscillators
+-
2p/L K1 K3
Period L
143
K2
Fig. 2. In quasi-phase-matched (QPM) crystals with periodically modulated sign of the nonlinearity (e.g. periodically poled lithium niobate), the artificially created grating compensates for the wavevector mismatch
simply be viewed as a catalyst that promotes decay of the pump photon into two smaller photons. This process depends on the instantaneous intensity of the pump laser beam, thus short laser pulses and tight focusing is an advantage. Rotating the crystal (in the case of birefringent crystals) or changing its temperature changes, via the phase matching condition, the ratio between the signal and idler photon energies, and thus tunes the frequency of the output. The easiest way to illustrate the parametric frequency conversion is to consider the case of a short (duration of a few ns or less) intense (power density ≈ 1 GW/ cm2 ) pump pulse. In this case (Fig. 3a), a single pass through a NLO crystal is sufficient to convert a substantial fraction (> 10 %) of the pump into the signal and the idler. This type of single-pass device is called an optical parametric generator (OPG). Essentially, OPG is an amplifier of quantum noise with a gain factor of 1010 or more. For pump pulses with longer pulse duration (> 5 ns) and, correspondingly lower power density, parametric frequency conversion is weaker and one needs a resonator OPO cavity (e.g. a Fabry–P´erot-type cavity) to enhance this process (Fig. 3b). To achieve a narrow linewidth output, one can incorporate a diffraction grating into the OPO cavity (Fig. 3c). Eventually, when a continuous-wave pump is used and tight focusing is necessary, one can use a four-mirror ring OPO cavity with two flat and two concave mirrors (Fig. 3d). A single-pass power parametric gain factor (for zero phase mismatch) is expressed [2,4] as G = Pout /Pin = cosh2 (Γ L), where L is the length of the nonlinear crystal and Γ is the gain increment given by: 2 2 2 deff 2ω1 ω2 Ipump deff 8π Ipump . (1) = Γ2 = 3 3 n ε0 c n3 λ1 λ2 ε0 c Here Ipump is the pump laser intensity (power density), ω1 and ω2 are idler and signal frequencies, λ1 and λ2 are idler and signal wavelengths, deff is the effective nonlinearity and n is the average refractive index. Also, d2eff /n3 is often referred to as the nonlinear optical figure of merit (NLO FOM) of the crystal.
144
Konstantin Vodopyanov hwpump= hwsignal + hwidler
(a) signal
SINGLE-PASS OPTICAL PARAMETRIC GENERATOR
IN idler
pump
OUT
NONLINEAR CRYSTAL
(b) PULSED OPTICAL PARAMETRIC OSCILLATOR
IN OUT
NONLINEAR CRYSTAL OUTPUT MIRROR
INPUT MIRROR
(c) NARROWLINEWIDTH OPTICAL PARAMETRIC OSCILLATOR
IN
NONLINEAR CRYSTAL INPUT MIRROR
OUT
DIFFRACTION GRATING
(d) CONTINUOUS WAVE OPTICAL PARAMETRIC OSCILLATOR
OUT
IN
NONLINEAR CRYSTAL INPUT MIRROR
OUTPUT MIRROR
Fig. 3. Diferent OPO schemes. (a) When short intense pump pulses are used, a single pass through a NLO crystal (OPG) is enough to convert a substantial fraction (> 10 %) of the pump into the signal and the idler. (b) For the pump pulses with smaller intensity, parametric frequency conversion is weaker and one needs a resonator OPO cavity to enhance this process. (c) For a narrow-linewidth OPO applications, one can incorporate a diffraction grating into the cavity. (d) When a CW pump is used and tight focusing is necessary, one can use a four-mirror ring OPO cavity with two flat and two concave mirrors
Pulsed Mid-IR Optical Parametric Oscillators
145
In the low gain limit (Γ L 1), cosh2 (Γ L) ≈ 1 + (Γ L)2 ,
(2)
while in the high gain limit (Γ L 1), cosh2 (Γ L) ≈ 1/4 × e2Γ L .
(3)
As a numerical example, consider the case of OPO based on periodically poled lithium niobate (PPLN) with λ3 = 1.06 µm (pump), λ2 = 1.6 µm (signal), and λ1 = 3.2 µm (idler). The effective nonlinearity of PPLN in this wavelength range is pretty well established and is deff = 14.2 pm/V [5,6]; the average refractive index is n = 2.131 . At the pump intensity Ipump = 1 MW/cm2 and L = 1 cm we get Γ L = 0.35 and a single-pass parametric gain G = cosh2 (Γ L) = 1.13 (13 % increase in power). At higher pump intensity, 100 MW/cm2 , and L = 4 cm, we get Γ L = 14 and a single-pass gain as high as G = cosh2 (Γ L) = 3.5 × 1011 . To achieve a threshold of an OPO resonating at one of the waves (‘signal’ or ‘idler’) with 10–30 % round-trip losses, and with pumping by 10–100 ns pulses, one needs typically Γ L = 0.3–2. This value is determined by two main factors: compensating the round-trip loss in the cavity and build-up of the intracavity intensity from quantum noise (equivalent input power ≈ nW)2 to a detectable limit, over a limited number of round-trips (10–100) in the OPO cavity [7]. The total build-up of intracavity intensity thus amounts to a factor of about 1010 . In contrast, to achieve a threshold of a single-pass OPG, one needs G ≈ 1010 , corresponding to Γ L ≈ 12; naturally, higher intensities must be applied in this case (e.g. by using short pump pulses).
OPOs in the 2–5 µm Range
3 3.1
Comparison of NLO Materials
The most advanced and suitable nonlinear optical materials for the 2–5 µm range are ferroelectric oxides, namely lithium niobate (LiNbO3 ), potassium titanyl phosphate (KTP), potassium titanyl arsenate (KTA) and rubidium titanyl arsenate (RTA). Periodic poling of all four ferroelectrics is now well developed, using electric field poling techniques [3]. Quasi-phase-matching in periodically poled 1
2
We have used the LiNbO3 coefficient d33 = 27 pm/V reported for the second harmonic generation of 1.06 µm and scaled it to appropriate wavelengths via Miller’s rule; 2/π coefficient was added to account for the effect of quasi phasematching. The equivalent input quantum noise power of an OPO is given by Yariv [2] as (photon energy)×(bandwidth). For λ ≈ 3 µm (photon energy = 6.6 × 10−20 J) and for a typical bandwidth of 1 cm−1 = 3 × 1010 Hz, we get a quantum noise power of 2 nW
146
Konstantin Vodopyanov
(PP) nonlinear optical materials offers significant advantages over conventional (birefringent phase matching) schemes for the realization of efficient optical parametric oscillators. These advantages include: • collinear propagation of the pump and the generated waves: there is no birefringent (Poynting vector) walk-off in space, hence tight focusing is possible which results in very low OPO thresholds; • large acceptance angle due to so-called non-critical phase-matching (NCPM); • possibility of using the largest nonlinear optical tensor (e.g. d33 ) element to maximize deff . In PP LiNbO3 (PPLN), for example, quasi-phase-matching with all waves polarized parallel to the z-axis yields a gain enhancement over the birefringently phase-matched process of (2d33 /πd31 )2 ≈ 16; • avoiding limitations on tunability imposed by PM condition – due to extra degree of freedom provided by the possibility of engineering different quasiphase-matched grating periods. Therefore, except for a few cases of high-power OPOs, we will mostly consider OPOs based on quasi-phase-matched materials in this section. Table 1 compares linear and nonlinear optical characteristics of the four periodically poled QPM oxide crystals, namely LiNbO3 (LN), KTP, KTA, RTA. The transparency range is given at the ‘zero’ level of transmission, corresponding to an absorption coefficient ≈ 5 cm−1 . The NLO coefficient corresponds to the largest d33 tensor element for the OPO process around 1.06 µm → 1.6 µm + 3.2 µm and includes the 2/π reduction factor [3] due to the QPM effect. Using the relative (with respect to PPLN) NLO figure of merit from this table, and the numerical example of Sect. 2, one can easily estimate the parametric gain in these crystals at a given pump intensity. Table 1. Comparison of linear and nonlinear optical properties of periodically poled oxide crystals in the mid-IR (from [5,6,8,9]) Crystal
PP PP PP PP
3.2
LN KTP KTA RTA
deff Average Transparency d33 range ( µm) (pm/V) (pm/V) refractive index 0.40–5.5 0.35–4.3 0.35–5.3 0.35–5.3
22.3 16.9 16.2 15.8
14.2 10.8 10.3 10.1
2.13 1.8 1.8 1.8
NLO FOM d2eff /n3 with respect to PPLN 1.00 0.95 0.87 0.83
OPOs Based on PP LN
Owing to its highest nonlinear coefficient among the oxides (Table 1), good optical quality, low absorption and well-established poling technology, peri-
Pulsed Mid-IR Optical Parametric Oscillators
147
odically poled lithium niobate (PPLN) is now one of the most widely used nonlinear materials for generating tunable light in the 1–4 µm range. The first OPO based on a PPLN crystal was reported by Myers et al. [6]. The authors used a 15 mm long, 0.5 mm thick PPLN crystal with a 31-µm grating period. A Q-switched diode-pumped 1.064-µm Nd:YAG laser with 7–20 ns pulse duration and 100 Hz–10 kHz repetition rate was used as a pump. The OPO resonator (Fig. 4) was a linear cavity with mirrors selected to resonate at the signal wave as a singly resonant oscillator (SRO). The mirrors with 25-mm radius of curvature were separated by 33 mm. They were highly reflective (98 % and 92 %) at the signal wavelength, and transmissive (70–95 %) for the pump and the idler. The pump laser was focused in the crystal to a spot size of 47 µm. The OPO pump threshold was 12 µJ and the output was continuously tunable from 1.66 to 2.95 µm, with the crystal temperature varying from room temperature to 180 ◦ C. To extend the tuning range of the PPLN OPO, the same team reported an OPO which used multiple grating sections on a single PPLN ‘chip’. The PPLN chip was 26 mm long and consisted of 25 gratings (0.5 mm wide) with QPM periods from 26 to 32 µm in 0.25-µm steps (Fig. 5) [10]. The SRO oscillation threshold was as low as 6 µJ with a 7 ns pump pulse (fluence 0.09 J/cm2 ). For tuning, the PPLN crystal was translated across the beam so that it interacted with different grating sections and a tunable IR output from 1.36 to 4.83 µm was achieved. The OPO tuning curve, as a function of grating period, is shown in Fig. 6. At the repetition rate of 1 kHz and the average pump power 100 mW, the output power at 4 µm amounted to 6 mW. To exploit the PPLN OPO operation in the regime of long pulses and a long-wave pump, Hansson et al. have used a diode-pumped Tm:YAG laser at 2.01 µm with 530 ns duration as an OPO pump [11]. The AR-coated PPLN OPO crystal (50 × 11 × 0.5 mm3 ) was periodically poled in eight stripes of different QPM periods over the full length of the material. Domain period lengths ranged from 25.5 to 28.7 µm. A pump pulse energy of 5.1 mJ generated 0.65 mJ of signal and idler at a 50 Hz repetition frequency. By changing the temperature and grating period, tuning over a wide range of idler wavelengths, 3.26–5.34 µm, was performed. A PPLN OPO driven by a fiber laser was reported by Britton et al. [12]. The authors used a Q-switched erbium fiber laser near 1560 nm, which operated at 300 Hz and produced pulses of up to 150 µJ and 50 ns duration. The
Fig. 4. Setup for the first PPLN-based OPO using a Q-switched 1.064-µm Nd:YAG laser as a pump [6]
148
Konstantin Vodopyanov
Fig. 5. Experimental setup for the multigrating QPM OPO. For tuning, the PPLN crystal is translated through the resonator so the pump beam interacts with different grating sections [10]
Fig. 6. OPO tuning as a function of grating period, achieved by translation of the PPLN crystal through 24 different grating sections. Solid line: Theoretical curve [10]
laser output was frequency doubled to get pulses with up to 60 µJ energy at 780 nm, which were used as an OPO pump. The PPLN sample, 20 mm long and 0.5 mm thick, contained a number of different grating periods (19, 19.5, 20, and 20.5 µm) suitable for 780 nm pumped OPO operation in the signal range 950–1450 nm. The OPO cavity had a concave (R = 10 cm) input coupler and a flat output coupler. Both mirrors were reflective at the signal wave (reflectivity 99.5 and 75 % correspondingly) and transmissive for the pump and the idler band. The pump beam was focused to a spot diameter of 80 µm within the PPLN sample. The OPO threshold was ≈ 10 µJ, and the idler wave tunability 1.69–4.45 µm. The quantum conversion efficiency was ≈ 9 %. To get mid-IR pulses of higher energy, one needs larger PPLN apertures, since the limiting factor is the optical damage of the crystal’s surfaces. An OPO based on a 1 mm thick and 20 mm long PPLN with grating periods
Pulsed Mid-IR Optical Parametric Oscillators
149
ranging from 27 to 30 µm has been reported by Bellomonte et al. [13]. The singly resonant cavity was pumped by a Q-switched diode-pumped Nd:YAG laser. At the pump pulse energy of 8.5 mJ and the beamsize of 0.85 mm, the idler energy of 1 mJ was extracted at 3.9 µm, corresponding to the photon conversion efficiency of ≈ 40 %. Thus, PPLN proves to be an ideal material for generating mid-IR radiation in the 2–4 µm range with moderate pulse energies – of up to 1 mJ. However because of the existence of the unwanted photorefractive effect in undoped lithium niobate at room temperature, it needs to be operated at elevated (> 100 ◦C) temperatures. 3.3
OPOs Based on PP KTP and PP RTA
Periodically poled potassium titanyl phosphate KTiOPO4 (PP KTP) and its isomorphs – rubidium titanyl arsenate RbTiOAsO4 (RTA) and potassium titanyl arsenate KTiOAsO4 (KTA), were successfully developed recently as an alternative OPO material to PPLN. Their advantages are high laser damage threshold (several times higher than in PPLN) and small susceptibility to thermal lensing which makes them suitable for high average power optical parametric oscillation. Furthermore, the coercive field of ≈ 2 kV/mm in these crystals is an order of magnitude lower than that in LiNbO3 . This lower field allows thicker (3 mm) samples to be periodically poled. Also, very low sensitivity to photorefractive damage permits operation at room temperature. Hellstr¨ om et al. [9] used a 1 mm thick and 20 mm long PP KTP crystal to demonstrate an efficient nanosecond OPO pumped by a flash-lamp-pumped Q-switched Nd:YAG laser with 5 ns pulse duration, 20 Hz repetition rate and a focused beam waist of 240 µm. The OPO cavities were 25 mm long and consisted of two flat mirrors that were antireflection coated for the pump and reflective in the signal region. Changing the temperature from 10 to 100 ◦ C resulted in tuning from 1.85 to 1.92 µm for the signal wavelength and from 2.51 to 2.39 µm for the idler. A maximum total (signal + idler) output energy of 1.8 mJ was obtained (in both directions) at a pump level of 3.5 mJ with conversion efficiency reaching 50 %. The OPO threshold was ≈ 0.3 mJ. Peltz et al. have reported optical parametric oscillators with high average powers and high pulse energies using 3 mm thick PPKTP and PP RTA [14]. The samples in this study had the useful length of 8 mm (PP KTP) and 7 mm (PP RTA). In high average power experiments, a diode-pumped Nd:YVO4 laser system was used, which produced nearly diffraction limited (beam quality factor M 2 = 1.2) pulses at 1064 nm. The pulse duration was 5.8 ns and the repetition rate 10–20 kHz. The resonator of the PPKTP OPO consisted of two mirrors resonating at the signal wave; one had a radius of curvature 100 mm and the other (the output coupler) was flat. The signal reflectivity of the output coupler was 64 %. Both mirrors were highly transmissive for the pump and idler wavelength; they were placed close to the crystal surfaces so that the cavity length was 15 mm. The pump beam was focused into
150
Konstantin Vodopyanov
the OPO cavity to a beam waist radius of 130 µm. The PPKTP sample was kept at room temperature. At a repetition rate of 10 kHz and 4.8 W pump power, corresponding to a peak intensity of 310 MW/cm2 , the OPO generated 830 mW of signal power (at 1.72 µm) and 500 mW of idler power (at 2.76 µm). The slope efficiency was 33 % and the maximum photon conversion efficiency was 28 %. The measured OPO threshold in this configuration was 900 mW (90 µJ per pulse). At an even higher repetition rate, 20 kHz, the pump power was 7.2 W and the total (signal + idler) output power reached 2 W. Similar experiments were made with the PPRTA-based OPO. The laser repetition rate was 20 kHz and the beam waist inside the cavity was 90 µm. The measured pump power at OPO threshold was 4 W. With a maximum pump power of 8 W (peak intensity 540 MW/cm2 ) the OPO generated 1 W of signal (at 1.58 µm) and 0.27 W of idler (at 3.26 µm) radiation. The conversion efficiency for this particular cavity configuration was 16 %. In the high pulse energy OPO experiments by the same authors, thick PPKTP and PPRTA crystals were pumped by Q-switched flash-lamppumped Nd:YAG lasers at a repetition rate of 10 Hz and pulse duration 10 ns [14]. The pump-beam diameter was approximately 2.5 mm. The OPO consisted of the crystal within a plane parallel cavity. The input mirror was highly reflective for the signal wavelength. The output coupler had a signal reflectivity of 80 %. In the PPKTP case, the OPO threshold was 0.1 J/cm2 , the conversion efficiency reached 38 % with total OPO pulse energies of up to 18.3 mJ. In the case of a PPRTA crystal, the OPO signal-pulse energy reached 17 mJ when pumped with 65 mJ pulses. The pump to signal efficiency was 26 %. From the authors’ point of view [14], large aperture PPKTP and PPRTA crystals show very similar OPO output characteristics and can be used for high power/energy applications. The biggest difference between the two materials is in their transparency: RTA has an advantage over KTP at λ > 3 µm, since its cut-off lies farther into the infrared part of the spectrum. Scaling a nanosecond OPO to high pulse energies entails increasing the beam diameters to avoid surface damage. The OPO cavity, however, should be kept short for high efficiency and low threshold. As a result, the cavity Fresnel number (NF = d2 /λL where d is the beam diameter and L is the cavity length) increases which worsens the spatial coherence across the beam. Hansson et al. [15] used an unstable OPO resonator to improve the beam quality of a PP RTA OPO. The unstable resonator effectively filters out OPO modes with high spatial frequency components by a combination of laser-mode magnification and feedback of only the lowest-order spatial modes. The PP RTA crystal was 8 mm long and 3 mm thick; the QPM period was 40.2 µm so that the OPO generated a signal at 1.56 µm and an idler at 3.33 µm when pumped at 1.064 µm. The OPO cavity was formed by a 30-cm radiusof-curvature concave input coupler (Fig. 7) and a 25-cm radius-of-curvature convex output coupler which formed a confocal unstable resonator of 1.2 times magnification when used with an optical path cavity length of 2.5 cm.
Pulsed Mid-IR Optical Parametric Oscillators
151
Fig. 7. PP RTA-based OPO with an unstable resonator cavity [15]
At the pump beam size of 3 mm, the Fresnel number was ≈ 200. With an unstable resonator, the authors have achieved a factor of three improvement in M 2 over a comparable flat–flat resonator (M 2 of 2.3–2.5 was obtained for the idler wave). The output energies were similar in both cases: ≈ 4.5 mJ (signal + idler) at 30 mJ pump. 3.4
OPOs Based on PP KTA
Another member of the KTP family group is the material KTiOAsO4 (KTA). Its optical properties in the mid-infrared region are similar to those of RTA (a cutoff wavelength 5.3 µm and nonlinear optical coefficient d33 = 16.2 pm/V, Table 1). Rosenman et al. [16] reported the fabrication, by low temperature poling, of PP KTA crystals (0.5 mm thick, 10 mm long) and the observation of optical parametric oscillation in the mid-infrared region. Two uncoated samples were tested in OPO devices pumped by a diode pumped Nd:YAG laser. The OPO resonator consisted of two plane mirrors, 15 mm apart. The input coupler was highly transmitting at the pump wavelength and highly reflecting at the signal wavelength. The CaF2 output coupler was highly reflecting at pump and signal wavelengths and highly transmitting at the idler wavelength. The measured signal and idler wavelengths were 1.505 and 3.631 µm, respectively, for the 39 µm QPM period and 1.439 and 4.083 µm, respectively, for the 37.4 µm QPM period. The maximal total conversion efficiency was 30 % at 20 MW/cm2 pump power density. 3.5
OPOs Using Conventional Phase-matching in Oxides
Despite the fact that QPM crystals are more attractive, as compared to bulk crystals using birefringent phase matching, due to their large acceptance
152
Konstantin Vodopyanov
angles, higher gain and lower OPO thresholds, the latter may be beneficial for high power applications, when large apertures are required. For example, Wu et al. have achieved 4.1 W of 3.5 µm output from an optical parametric oscillator using a noncritically phase-matched type-II KTA [17]. The authors have used an intracavity OPO configuration – the OPO was pumped within the cavity of a Q-switched diode-pumped Nd:YALO laser operating at 10 kHz. The laser cavity (Fig. 8) was formed by flat mirrors M1 and M2 with high reflectivity (HR) at 1 µm. The KTA OPO consisted of an x-cut (θ = 90◦ , φ = 0◦ ), 7 × 7 × 35 mm3 KTA crystal placed between flat mirrors M3 and M1. The mirror M3 is AR coated for 1 µm and is highly reflective (R > 99 %) at both 1.5 and 3–4 µm. Besides acting as a high reflecting mirror at 1 µm, M1 was also the output coupler for the OPO. It was AR coated at 3-4 µm and had R = 90 % at 1.5 µm. Hence, this KTA OPO was a singly resonant OPO. Furthermore 4.1 W of the output at 3.5 µm, 10.9 W of 1.5 µm and 11.3 W of 1 µm radiation were obtained simultaneously. A KTP OPO with the average power of 53 W has been achieved by Cheung et al. [18]. As a pump laser, the authors used a diode arraypumped Nd:YAG master oscillator–power amplifier system with repetition rate 20 kHz, pulse duration 40 ns and average power 135 W. The degenerate OPO (that is λsignal = λidler = 2.13 µm) used six KTP crystals, 3 × 3 × 6 mm3 in size, cut for type-II phase matching in a walk-off compensated configuration. The pump beam diameter was 0.6 mm and the reflectivity of the OPO outcoupler mirror was only 30 %. The average power of 53 W (in two orthogonal polarizations) has been achieved at 2.13 µm with 43 % conversion efficiency. Vysniauskas et al. [19] demonstrated a high-energy OPO based on a critically phase-matched (CPM) angular-tuned KTA crystal. The OPO was pumped by a Q-switched Nd:YAG laser (Continuum Surelite I) with 5 ns pulse duration and 10 Hz repetition rate. The pump beam had a diameter
Fig. 8. Schematic diagram of the intracavity KTA OPO. Mirrors M1 and M2 form the Nd:YALO laser cavity, while M1 and M3 form the KTA OPO cavity [17]
Pulsed Mid-IR Optical Parametric Oscillators
153
of 4 mm and was double-passed through the 15 mm KTA crystal, for higher efficiency. The OPO was singly resonant for the idler wavelength and had an unstable resonator cavity to improve the spatial beam distribution. The idler beam tunability over the 2.6–3.2 µm range has been achieved with the pulse energy as high as 14–17 mJ at 2.9 µm for a pump pulse energy of 145 mJ. Even higher mid-IR OPO output energies were reported by Mennerat and Kupecek [20]. An OPO was based on a 50 mm long, 15 mm aperture 47◦ -cut CPM LiNbO3 crystal and was pumped at 1.064 µm (15 ns pulse duration). Maximum output energy of 300 mJ (signal + idler) was achieved near degeneracy (λ ≈ 2 µm) for a 600 mJ pump.
4
OPOs in the 4–20 µm Range
4.1
Comparison of NLO Materials Suitable for λ > 5 µm
Table 2 compares linear and nonlinear optical characteristics of the five most promising nonlinear optical crystals, suitable for NLO applications in the λ > 5 µm region. It contains four chalcopyrites: silver gallium sulfide AgGaS2 (AGS), silver gallium selenide AgGaSe2 (AGSe), zinc germanium phosphide ZnGeP2 (ZGP), and cadmium germanium arsenide CdGeAs2 (CGA); and layered chalcogenide gallium selenide GaSe. All five crystals utilize birefringent phase matching. Using relative NLO figures of merit (with respect to PPLN) from this table, and the numerical example of Sect. 2, one can estimate the parametric gain in these crystals at a given pump intensity. The last three crystals in Table 2 – namely ZGP, CGA, and GaSe – exhibit larger NLO figures of merit, as compared to AGS and AGSe. In addition, the former have much higher thermal conductivity (exceeding that of AGS and AGSe by more than an order of magnitude), and higher laser damage thresholds (> 1 J/cm2 ). Table 2. Comparison of linear and nonlinear optical properties of birefringent crystals suitable for the λ > 5 µm region (from [8]) Crystal Transparency deff range ( µm) (pm/V) AGS AGSe ZGP GaSe CGA
0.47–13.0 0.71–19.0 0.74–12.4 0.62–20.0 2.40–18.0
12 33 75 54 236
Average refractive index
NLO FOM d2eff /n3 with respect to PPLN
2.40 2.65 3.13 2.73 3.60
0.5 2.8 8.8 6.8 57.0
154
Konstantin Vodopyanov
4.2
OPOs Based on AGS and AGSe
The first OPO based on AGS was reported in 1984 by Fan et al. [21]. A type-I OPO was pumped by a Q-switched Nd:YAG laser. (τ = 18 ns) and was tunable from 1.4 to 4 µm. The photon conversion efficiency was 16 %. Lately, Vodopyanov et al. demonstrated an AGS optical parametric oscillator with a much larger tuning range of 3.9–11.3 µm [22]. The singly resonant angle-tuned OPO was formed by two flat mirrors and used a 20 mm AGS crystal cut at θ = 45.1◦ to the optical z-axis for type-II phase matching. It was pumped by 1.06 µm pulses from a Nd:YAG laser with 12–100 ns pulse duration and yielded up to 0.37 mJ idler wave energy at 15 mJ pump. In the configuration with the recycling of the pump and idler beams, the OPO pump threshold was as low as 85 µJ. The OPO linewidth was ≈ 1 cm−1 and the quantum conversion efficiency reached 22 %. This AGS OPO with its tuning range of 3.9–11.3 µm can be considered to be the longest wavelength OPO pumped at 1 µm. Figure 9 shows the CO absorption spectrum taken with the OPO, which is compared with the FTIR spectrum with a 2 cm−1 resolution. Silver gallium selenide, AgGaSe2 (AGSe), provides broader IR tunability than AGS, but it cannot be pumped at 1 µm, because of phase matching limitations; however it phase-matches with a variety of pump sources in the range 1.3–3 µm. Eckardt et al. have reported the first AGSe OPO [23] which was pumped by a Q-switched Nd:YAG laser at 1.34 µm or a Ho:YLF laser at 2.05 µm. In the latter case, the tunability of 2.65–9.05 µm was achieved with a photon conversion efficiency of 18 %.
wavelength (mm) 4.8
4.7
optical density = -ln(T)
3 2
4.6
4.5
CO absorption L=10cm p=0.83atm FTIRspectrometer res. 2 cm-1
1 0 1cm-1
6
AgGaS2 OPO
5
2164 2166 2168
4 3 2 1 0 2050
2100
2150
2200
wavenumber (cm-1)
Fig. 9. CO absorption spectrum taken with an FTIR spectrometer (2 cm−1 resolution, upper curve) and with the AGS OPO system (lower curve) [22]
Pulsed Mid-IR Optical Parametric Oscillators
155
Raffy et al. [24] have used a 1.064 µm Q-switched Nd:YAG laser to pump two OPOs in series. The first one used a LiNbO3 crystal and was tuned to λ = 1.82 µm. It pumped the second OPO which used an AgGaSe2 crystal and was tunable between 2.15 and 12 µm. The total conversion from the 1.064 µm laser to the mid-IR output was 1.75 %. Chandra et al. [25] reported an AGSe OPO, which provided continuously tunable output in the 6–14 µm range when pumped by the 1.57 µm signal output from a Nd:YAG pumped KTP OPO. The latter used a 20 mm long noncritically phase-matched KTP crystal and had a 4 cm long flat–flat cavity with a gradient reflectivity mirror outcoupler. When pumped with 80 mJ, 10 ns pulses at 1.06 µm (repetition rate of 5 Hz, beam diameter 3 mm), up to 35 mJ of the 1.57 µm output was obtained, with a pulse width of 6 ns and spectral bandwidth of 5.7 cm−1 . The second stage OPO used a 6.5 × 6.5 × 35.3 mm3 type-I AgGaSe2 crystal cut at θ = 54◦ . The resonator was designed to resonate the signal and double pass the 1.57 µm pump. At the pump beam diameter of 6 × 5.4 mm2 , the OPO threshold was 0.02 J/cm2 , or 3 MW/cm2 in power density. The output idler energy reached 1 mJ at 9 µm, which corresponds to 20 % quantum efficiency, with respect to 1.57 µm pump, and 1.25 % overall efficiency of converting 1 µm into 9 µm radiation. Continuous tuning was obtained from 6.1 to 14.1 µm by a 40◦ rotation of the AgGaSe2 crystal. The idler bandwidth was measured to be 5 cm−1 near λ = 9 µm. It should be noted that low thermal conductivity and susceptibility to surface degradation resulting from a low laser damage threshold (0.1– 0.25 J/ cm2 ) severely limit the practical application of AGS and AGSe. 4.3
OPOs Based on ZGP
The very high nonlinear optical coefficient of ZGP – its NLO FOM is almost 9 times that of PPLN (see Table 2) – combined with good optical, mechanical, and thermal properties, favors a variety of nonlinear optical applications, including efficient high-average-power, as well as broadly tunable OPOs. Because of some residual absorption in the near-IR region, ZGP pump wavelength should be chosen at 2 µm or above. Thus, 2-µm holmium or 3-µm erbium lasers are good candidates for this purpose. Using ZGP crystals, mid-IR OPOs with the highest reported average output power at λ > 3 µm have been built. For example, Budni et al. [26] reported a 10 W coherent 3–5 µm light source for IR countermeasure applications based on ZGP. The type-I OPO using a 14 mm ZGP crystal was pumped at 10 kHz by 11 ns, 2.05 µm pulses from a diode-pumped Q-switched Ho,Tm:YLF laser operating at T = 77 K. At the maximum pump drive level of 20.1 W (two diode-pumped amplifier stages were used) incident onto the OPO crystal, the output average power (signal at 3.67 µm plus idler at 4.67 µm) reached 10.1 W, corresponding to a conversion efficiency of 50.2 %.
156
Konstantin Vodopyanov
It is important that the operation of this OPO at maximum power levels was well below the crystal’s damage threshold. In the work by Cheung et al. [18] even higher powers in the 3–5 µm range were obtained from a single ZGP OPO. The type-I ZGP OPO was pumped by 25 W of average power at 2.13 µm from a Nd:YAG-laser-pumped KTP OPO (20 kHz, 40 ns), and its signal + idler output, tunable between 3.7 and 4.8 µm, reached an average power of 14 W. Also, more than 20 W of average power was extracted from two independent ZGP OPO stages pumped by two orthogonal polarizations of the KTP OPO. An extremely efficient ZGP OPO emitting simultaneously at 3.8 and 4.65 µm was reported by Budni et al. [27]. The OPO pump source was a 2.09 µm Ho:YAG laser operating at 10 kHz with ≈ 30 ns pulse duration and 9.5 W average power. It was pumped in turn by a continuous-wave Tm:YLF laser at 1.9 µm, end-pumped by 60 W of 793 nm diode laser power. More than 4.2 W of output was achieved from the ZGP OPO working in the 3.8 and 4.65 µm spectral region. Thus, the optical-to-optical conversion efficiency (793 nm laser diode to mid-IR) achieved in this work was > 7 %. Also, as compared to [26], the whole system worked at room temperature. Wu et al. [28] demonstrated a coupled tandem ZGP OPO approach, where 2 µm output of a KTP OPO pumps a ZGP OPO. Not only is the ZGP OPO placed within the oscillator of the first KTP OPO, but also the KTP OPO is placed within the oscillator of a diode-pumped Nd:YALO laser (Fig. 10). The Nd:YALO laser is able to generate ≈ 58 W of linear polarized, 1 µm output power at the repetition rate of 5 kHz and is formed by a high reflector M1 and an output coupler M2. The KTP OPO utilizes four Type-II, 51◦ -cut, 5 mm × 5 mm × 8 mm, diffusion bonded walkoff compensated KTP crystals, placed between mirrors M3 and M1. A ZGP OPO is placed in the arm of s-polarization of 2 µm KTP OPO output and is formed by a type-I, 53◦ cut, 5 mm × 5 mm × 10 mm ZGP, and mirrors M4 and M5. The output from the ZGP OPO was tunable over the range 3–6 µm. The maximum output power ~ 43 cm DBWOC KTP OPO Laser cavity ZGP OPO 1-mm
A-O Q-switch
DBWOC KTP
2-mm
Mid-IR
Nd:YALO
P M2 R=85%@1-mm
Nd:YALO Pump Module
M3 AR@1-mm HR@2-mm
M1 R=20%@2-mm HR@1-mm
M4 AR@2-mm HR@3~5-mm
M5 R=60%@3~5-mm HR@2-mm
Fig. 10. Schematic diagram of the coupled tandem KTP OPO–ZGP OPO. DBWOC KTP stands for Diffusion Bonded Walkoff Compensated KTP [28]
Pulsed Mid-IR Optical Parametric Oscillators
157
was achieved at 4.3 µm and was 2.53 W at approximately 580 W of diode pump power. The M 2 beam quality factor at 4.3 µm was MH2 ≈ 3.0 and MV2 ≈ 5.5, respectively. Allik et al. [29] reported a high-energy-per-pulse ZGP optical parametric oscillator pumped by a 2.8 µm Er,Cr:YSGG laser with a 10 Hz repetition rate, 25 mJ energy and 50 ns duration. A 25 mm long ZGP crystal was cut at θ = 65◦ for type-II phase matching. The OPO yielded idler output in the ‘forward’ direction of 0.7–2.4 mJ per pulse, in the wavelength range 6.9–9.9 µm. The quantum conversion efficiency reached 29 % and the OPO linewidth was typically 4 cm−1 . A ZGP OPO with a wide (3.8–12.4 µm) mid-IR tunability and more than 1 mJ output idler energy was demonstrated by Vodopyanov et al. [30,31]. The pump source was a Q-switched flash-lamp-pumped erbium laser with λ = 2.8 µm (Er,Cr:YSGG) or 2.93 µm (Er,Cr,Tm:YAG), with ≈ 100 ns pulse duration, 10 Hz repetition rate, and 10 mJ energy. The AR-coated ZGP crystal was 20 mm long and was cut for type-I (θ0 = 49.5◦) or for type-II (θ0 = 70◦ ) phase matching. The lowest OPO threshold was obtained in the flat–flat cavity configuration shown in Fig. 11. The front mirror, M1 , was transmissive for the pump and the idler and highly reflective (98 %) for the signal. The gold rear mirror, M2 , was highly reflective (R > 98 %) for the pump, signal, and idler. Thus, the signal wave resonated, while the pump and the idler were double-passed. A dichroic beam splitter (BS) separated the incoming pump beam from the outcoming idler. The pump beamsize was 0.82 mm. The OPO output was continuously tunable, via crystal angle tuning, from 3.8 to 12.4 µm (type-I phase matching) and from 4 to 10 µm (type-II phase matching) with a linewidth of 2–3 cm−1 . Figure 12 shows the OPO temporal pulse shape (at λ ≈ 8 µm) together with the incoming (undepleted) pump pulse. The plot of the OPO idler energy (at λ = 6.6 µm) versus pump pulse energy is shown in Fig. 13. The inset to Fig. 13 shows the far zone beam intensity distribution, measured using a 2D infrared beam profiler. The shape is close to the Gaussian and corresponds to the beam quality factor M 2 ≈ 1.5. Figure 14 represents the OPO output energy as a function of the idler wavelength, at two different pump energies: 5 and 10 mJ. Also, the dashed curve corresponds to the OPO pump threshold dependence. Remarkably, the OPO pump threshold was less than 1 mJ in the whole 4–12 µm range and the quantum conversion efficiency reached ≈ 50 % at 6–8 µm output. Pelouch et al. [32] took advantage of the reduced OPO threshold in a noncritical phase matching scheme. The ZGP crystal was 15 mm long and cut at 90◦ . The OPO pump source was a tunable (2.2–2.7 µm) Cr2+ :ZnSe laser (0.35 mJ, 1000 Hz) pumped by a Q-switched Tm:YALO laser operating at 1.94 µm. With the 2.55 µm pump wavelength, the ZGP OPO signal and idler wavelengths were 4.7 and 5.6 µm correspondingly. The pump threshold was 50 µJ and at the 200 µJ pump energy, 80 µJ of the output (signal + idler) was
158
Konstantin Vodopyanov ZGP
M2
M1 BS
out 3.8-12.4mm
pump
Er:Cr:YSGG-laser l=2.8mm
Fig. 11. Schematic and general view of an erbium-laser-pumped ZGP OPO. M1 and M2 are OPO mirrors, BS is a beamsplitter which separates the pump from the OPO output. A continuous tuning range of 3.8–12.4 µm has been demonstrated with the photon conversion efficiency reaching ≈ 50% at 6–8 µm incoming pump OPO
-100
0
100 ns
Fig. 12. ZGP OPO (λ ≈ 8 µm) temporal pulse shape shown together with the incoming (undepleted) pump laser pulse at 2.8 µm
Pulsed Mid-IR Optical Parametric Oscillators
159
1.4 idler energy (mJ)
1.2 1.0
l=6.6mm
0.8 0.6 5 mrad
0.4 0.2 0.0 0
2 4 6 8 10 input laser energy (mJ)
Fig. 13. ZGP OPO energy curve at the output wavelength λ = 6.6 µm. Solid line: trace to guide the eye. Inset: The far zone beam intensity distribution at 6.6 µm [31]
Fig. 14. OPO output energy as a function of the idler wavelength for two pump energies: 5 and 10 mJ. Dashed curve, the OPO pump threshold dependence. Inset, transmission spectrum of the antireflection-coated L = 2 cm ZGP crystal [30]
achieved. In this system, one can achieve the ZPO OPO tuning by tuning the pump; however the dependence of the idler wavelength on the pump wavelength near 2.2–2.7 µm is very weak. A widely tunable low-threshold tandem OPO based on PPLN and NCPM ZGP crystals has been demonstrated recently by Vodopyanov and Schunemann [33]. A noncritically phase-matched ZGP OPO was pumped by the idler wave output of a PPLN OPO with the focused beam size ≈ 200 µm. The latter was pumped by a diode-pumped Nd:YAG laser (1.6 mJ, 20 ns, 1 kHz). The singly resonant OPO (Fig. 15) contained a 24 mm θ = 90◦ ZGP crystal and was formed by a concave output coupler mirror M1 (highly reflective at the signal and transmissive at the idler and the pump) and a gold reflector mirror M2 which was deposited directly into the polished flat surface of the ZGP crystal (the front surface of the ZGP was AR-coated). Tuning the PPLN
160
Konstantin Vodopyanov
ZGP OPO wavelength, mm
Fig. 15. Schematic of the widely tunable NCPM ZGP OPO pumped by the output of a PPLN OPO. M1 and M2 are OPO mirrors, BS is a dichroic beamsplitter which reflects the pump and transmits the OPO output 10
ZGP OPO
9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2.2 2.4 2.6 2.8 3.0 3.2 3.4 3.6 3.8 PPLN pump wavelength, mm
Fig. 16. Noncritically phase-matched ZGP OPO tuning curve as a function of the pump wavelength. Solid lines: theoretical curves
OPO wavelength in the range 2.3–3.7 µm resulted in tuning the ZGP OPO output from 3.7 to 10.2 µm. OPO tuning curves versus pump wavelength are shown in Fig. 16; the dotted lines on this figure correspond to theoretical prediction based on known dispersion data [34]. The ZGP OPO idler output (λ ≈ 7 µm) amounted to 25 µJ at 1 kHz corresponding to a photon conversion efficiency of 30 % and total conversion from the 1.064 µm laser to the 7 µm output of 1.5 %. At a smaller pump beam size of 125 µm (at λ ≈ 3.1 µm) which is close to the confocal focusing condition, the OPO pump threshold was remarkably low, ≈ 2 µJ; this is the lowest threshold reported so far for singly resonant OPOs. 4.4
OPOs Based on Other Crystals
A tandem OPO based on a CdSe crystal (deff = 18 pm/V) was demonstrated by Isyanova et al. [35]. The first OPO, using KTA, was pumped by a Q-switched Nd:YLF laser (200 mJ, 30 ns). The second OPO, based on NCPM CdSe, 35 mm long, was pumped by the idler of the first OPO. By
Pulsed Mid-IR Optical Parametric Oscillators
161
tuning of the pump wavelength between 2.7 and 3.5 µm the authors achieved tuning of the CdSe OPO in the 4.5–5.2 µm range (signal) and 8–10.6 µm range (idler). The total conversion efficiency of 1 µm radiation to 10 µm was ≈ 1 %. The GaSe crystal has an exceptionally wide transparency range and high second-order nonlinearity (Table 2); most important, it can be pumped by a 1.06 µm laser. Nevertheless, a GaSe OPO has not been demonstrated yet, partly because of the problems associated with the softness of the crystal, the infeasibility of cutting the crystal at the desired angle, and difficulties with AR coating. However, GaSe became the base for the most widely tunable mid-IR OPG (3.3–19 µm), which we will discuss in Sect. 5.3. CGA, the ‘Holy Grail’ of infrared NLO materials because of its enormous second-order nonlinearity (236pm/V), has proved effective for numerous NLO mid-IR applications, including second harmonic and difference frequency generation [8,36]. Yet, CGA OPO has been demonstrated only quite recently by Zakel et al. [37], and this was a result of improvement in the crystal’s optical properties and the availability of a pump source matching the crystal’s transparency. The pump was the second harmonic (λ = 4.8 µm) of a TEA CO2 laser with 2 Hz repetition rate, pulse duration 85 ns and 5.5 mJ energy. The 6 mm × 6 mm × 13 mm CGA crystal, cut for type-I phase matching (θ = 33◦ ), had absorption coefficients of 0.2 and 0.44 cm−1 for the pump and OPO wavelengths respectively. At the focused pump beam size of 256 µm, the measured OPO threshold was 0.95 mJ (5 MW/cm2 ). The OPO output was tunable between 8.5 and 11 µm (that is within the important 8–12 µm atmospheric transmission window); the total conversion efficiency was 3.5 % and the authors expect higher conversion efficiencies with better quality crystals.
5 Traveling-Wave Optical Parametric Generators (OPGs) As mentioned in Sect. 2, the principle of operation of a travelling-wave (superfluorescent) OPG is based on a single-pass high-gain (> 1010 ) amplification of quantum noise in a nonlinear crystal pumped by intense short laser pulses. The main advantages of the travelling-wave OPG scheme are: • Simplicity of the optical design (no cavity mirrors). • Ability to produce very high peak power outputs (> 1 MW) in the form of a single short pulse. • Broad tunability, restricted only by phase matching conditions and the crystal’s optical transparency. • No ‘build-up’ time – hence the possibility of generating two or more synchronized, independently tunable pulses from different OPGs pumped by the same laser, which is attractive for time-resolved laser spectroscopy. However, higher pump intensities (108 –1010 W/cm2 ) must be applied in this case – for example by using short (few ns to sub-ps) pump pulses. Also,
162
Konstantin Vodopyanov
the bandwidths of OPG output can be broad – from a few cm−1 to a few hundreds of cm−1 . 5.1
OPGs Based on PP LN
An elegant PPLN-based OPG pumped by a microchip laser was demonstrated by Zayhowski [38]. The Nd:YAG microchip laser, passively Q-switched with Cr4+ :YAG, was longitudinally pumped with a fiber-coupled 12 W diode-laser array. At pulse repetition rates ≈ 1 kHz the microchip laser produces 157 µJ of energy in a single-frequency TEM00 pulse. The duration of the laser pulse was 0.9 ns and the size of the unfocused laser beam was 94 µm corresponding to the confocal parameter of 5.2 cm. A 13 mm long PPLN was placed next to the laser, without any intervening optics (Fig. 17). The PPLN QPM period was designed to convert 1.064 µm radiation to 1.59 µm signal and 3.22 µm idler radiation. Since the crystal had uncoated parallel faces, it was slightly tilted from the normal, to eliminate the possibility that the PPLN would oscillate, forcing it to act as a single-pass OPG. With an incident pump intensity of 1 GW/cm2 , the PPLN OPG was 1.5 times above threshold and converted 25 % of the incident pump radiation into the signal and idler wavelengths, which corresponds to 26 and 12 µJ output pulses at 1.59 and 3.22 µm, respectively. The estimated bandwidth of the output pulses was ≈ 250 cm−1 . S¨ udmeyer et al. reported recently a very high repetition rate single-pass OPG based on periodically poled lithium niobate. An OPG was directly pumped by the output of a passively mode-locked 1.03 µm Yb:YAG laser with pulse duration of 0.6 ps, and repetition rate of 35 MHz [39]. A 7 mm long, 0.5 mm thick PPLN crystal contained ten QPM gratings with poling periods between 27.1 and 30.4 µm. The laser beam was focused to a 40 µm waist in the middle of the PPLN crystal. By switching between the QPM gratings, the OPG signal output was tunable in the spectral region of 1.38–1.56 µm corresponding to the idler tunability of 3.03–4.06 µm. At 5 W of average pump
Fig. 17. Experimental setup for PPLN-based OPG pumped by a Nd:YAG microchip laser [38]
Pulsed Mid-IR Optical Parametric Oscillators
163
power, the signal wave power was measured to be between 0.25 and 0.5 W and the output idler power was estimated to be up to 0.25 W. 5.2
OPGs Based on ZGP
A schematic diagram of the long-wavelength ZGP OPG, tunable between 3.9 and 10 µm, reported by Vodopyanov et al. [40], is presented in Fig. 18. Single 100 ps pulses from an actively mode-locked, Q-switched and cavitydumped 2.8 µm Er,Cr:YSGG laser [41] were amplified to get an energy of 3 mJ. A double-pass OPG setup used a dichroic beam splitter (HR at the laser wavelength, and HT at the OPG wavelengths) and a back reflecting gold mirror. Both type-I (L = 11 mm) and type-II (L = 40 mm) ZGP crystals were utilized in this experiment. A lens L was used to slightly focus the laser beam into the crystal in such a manner that the laser intensity at the second pass through the crystal was 3–4 times higher than at the first pass, and amounted to a few GW/cm2 . Thus, the first pass served as a superluminescent seed, with the second as a parametric amplifier. The focusing was made to ensure that the parametric gain reaches saturation at the second pass, thus giving maximum conversion efficiency. Compared to a single-pass geometry, the double-pass OPG scheme produces much smaller output beam divergence, corresponding to ≈ 2× diffraction limit. The continuous tuning range achieved was 3.9–10 µm with quantum conversion efficiency 10 %. The OPG linewidth was typically 100 cm−1 for the type-I PM and ≈ 10 cm−1 for the type-II. The single-pass OPG threshold (L = 40 mm crystal) was 90 MW/cm2 , which was 300 times less than the ZGP surface damage threshold. In the work by Petrov et al. [42], a type-II ZGP traveling wave OPG was pumped by the output of a seeded optical parametric amplifier (Ti:sapphirelaser-pumped MgO:LiNbO3 OPA) with λ ≈ 3 µm and 2.7 ps pulse duration. With a two-pass arrangement, 5–11 µm tunability was achieved with µJ output energies, nearly bandwidth-limited pulses and 20 % internal quantum Beam splitter out NLO crystal
L pump 2.8mm 2-3mJ
4- pass Er,Cr:YSGG AMPLIFIER
Er,Cr:YSGG laser l=2.8 mm 100ps 0.7mJ
Fig. 18. Schematic of the double-pass travelling-wave OPG pumped by an erbium laser
164
Konstantin Vodopyanov
efficiency. Femtosecond optical parametric generation in a very short (2 mm) ZGP was also reported [43]. In this case, the output of a Ti:sapphire-laserpumped BBO OPG, with λ ≈ 2 µm and 140 fs pulse duration, was used to pump a single-pass type-I ZGP, cut at θ = 52.5◦ . The output wavelengths were around 3.1 µm (signal) and 6.1 µm (idler), the pump threshold was found to be 25 GW/cm2 , and conversion efficiency 2.5 %. 5.3
OPGs Based on GaSe
A GaSe OPG with the record continuous tunability of 3.3–19 µm has been reported by Vodopyanov et al. [40,44]. The OPG was pumped, in a double-pass geometry (Fig. 18), by 100 ps , 3 mJ , λ = 2.8 µm pulses from an Er,Cr:YSGG laser. Despite the fact that GaSe can be cleaved only along the (001) plane (z-cut, θ = 0◦ ), its extremely large birefringence (∆ n ≈ 0.35) allows almost any conceivable three-wave interaction in its transparency range to be phasematched. The GaSe crystal length was 14 mm, and elliptical focusing with an aspect ratio 1:20 was used for the 2.8 µm pump beam, in order to keep the beam size sufficiently large in the walk-off plane (the walk-off amounted to 0.8 mm for the internal angle θ = 12◦ ). The OPG threshold intensity was 1.1 GW/cm2 . Figure 19 shows GaSe tuning curves (as a function of the tilt of the crystal) obtained with the 2.8 µm pump for type-I and type-II phase matching. The output linewidth was typically 10–30 cm−1 . The tuning range of 3.3 to 19 µm is the largest tunability range ever obtained with parametric generators/oscillators. It is also worth noticing that the whole tuning range can be covered with a single z-cut crystal. Figure 20 shows the OPG quantum efficiency as a function of the wavelength. The decline in efficiency at longer wavelengths is due to the increase of linear absorption and decreasing of parametric gain. The quantum conversion efficiency reached 5 % at Ipump ≈ 5 GW/cm2 . 20 18
type I
Wavelength, mm
16
GaSe type II
14 12 10 8 6 4 2
30
40
50
External angle qo
60
70
Fig. 19. OPG tuning curves obtained with the z-cut GaSe and 2.8 µm 100 ps pump [40]
Quantum conversion efficiency (%)
Pulsed Mid-IR Optical Parametric Oscillators
165
10 1 0.1 0.01
GaSe OPG
1E-3 1E-4
5.4
4
6
8 10 12 14 16 18 20 Output wavelength (mm)
Fig. 20. GaSe OPG quantum conversion efficiency as a function of the output wavelength [40]
OPGs Based on CGA
The first results on OPG based on CGA crystal has been reported recently by Vodopyanov et al. [45]. The 7 mm long CGA sample was cut at θ = 33◦ for type-I phase matching. The crystal faces were polished but not antirefection coated; the absorption coefficient was less than 0.1 cm−1 in the whole range of 5–12 µm. As a pump source for the OPG, the authors have used λ = 5 µm pulses from the Free-Electron Laser FELIX in Nieuwegein, Netherlands. The pump wavelength was chosen in such a range so as to minimize the linear and two-photon absorption in CGA. The laser beam consisted of a train of ≈ 100 short pulses (600 fs, 10 µJ), which were separated by intervals of 40 ns. The laser spectral width was 24 cm−1 and the overall repetition rate 10 Hz. The pump laser beam was focused into the CGA crystal with a beam size of 450 µm. An OPG threshold was observed at the incoming peak laser intensity of 3 GW/cm2 . The OPG output was angular-tuned within the range 7–18 µm and the spectral width of the OPG output was typically 250 cm−1 away from degeneracy, and 600 cm−1 near degeneracy (λ ≈ 10 µm); the last two values are close to the acceptance bandwidth for the 7 mm CGA crystal. At the peak pump intensity of 6 GW/cm2 , typical OPG internal photon conversion efficiency was 3 %.
6
Narrow-Linewidth OPOs
In many cases, spectroscopic applications of OPOs require narrow linewidths. For example, gases and vapors at atmospheric pressure have spectral features which are typically a few 0.1 cm−1 wide. Alternatively, at low pressures where Doppler broadening dominates, these features can be even sharper: < 10−2 cm−1 . In the latter case, a single-longitudinal-mode OPO is desirable. The spectral width of a pulsed Fabry–P´erot-type OPO without any intracavity spectral-narrowing elements normally ranges between 1 cm−1 and 100 cm−1 , depending on the phase matching type, output wavelength, proximity to the degeneracy point, crystal length, etc. Primarily, it is determined by the OPO phase matching acceptance bandwidth and decreases as the square root of the number of round-trip passes in an OPO.
166
6.1
Konstantin Vodopyanov
Using Intracavity Spectral-Narrowing Elements
In the early work of Brosnan and Byer [46], narrow linewidths (0.08 cm−1 ) have been achieved in the Nd:YAG-laser-pumped mid-IR singly-resonant LiNbO3 OPO with the use of 600 lines per mm diffraction grating and a 2 mm Fabry–P´erot etalon with the finesse of 7 inside the cavity. With addition of the second (reflective) etalon, the OPO output collapsed to a single (< 0.02 cm−1 ) longitudinal mode which was remarkably stable in frequency. Raffy et al. [47] have shown that a LiNbO3 OPO (pumped at 930 nm by a Ti:sapphire laser) can be both tuned and linewidth-narrowed with an electrically tunable Fabry–P´erot interferometer that consists of two mirrors separated by an air layer of a few micrometers. Recently, Schlup et al. [48] reported a nanosecond Nd:YAG-pumped optical parametric oscillator based on periodically poled lithium niobate (20 mm long, 0.5 mm thick) whose optical bandwidth has been narrowed to a single longitudinal mode with less than 250 MHz (≈ 0.01 cm−1 ) linewidth by the use of a grazing incidence (88.6◦ ), 900 lines per mm diffraction grating. The single-mode OPO output could be tuned over 1.48–1.80 µm (signal) and 2.61–3.82 µm (idler), with a threshold pump energy of 1.1 mJ and slope efficiencies of up to 36 % (signal) and 10 % (idler). When pumped with 1.6 mJ pulses, output pulse energies of 170 µJ at the signal and 52 µJ at the idler wavelengths were observed. Richman et al. have developed a PPLN-based pulsed mid-IR ring cavity OPO that resonates the signal wave and uses just one intracavity etalon to restrict lasing to a single longitudinal mode of the resonator cavity [49]. The OPO ring resonator (Fig. 21) consisted of three mirrors. The two dichroic mirrors on either side of the PPLN crystal (25 mm long, 0.5 mm high, and 19 mm wide) transmitted the pump and idler beams and reflected the signal beam. The third mirror outcoupled 10 % of the signal beam. The airspace etalon was made of one convex and one concave mirror, with a 95 % reflective coating for the signal wave and each with a curvature that matches the phase-front curvature of the ring cavity TEM00 mode. The etalon mirror spacing was 357 µm (free spectral range 14 cm−1 ), it had a finesse of 60 and an insertion loss of 30 %. The pump was a narrow-linewidth 1 kHz repetition rate Q-switched laser with injection seeding (Continuum Model HPO-1000). It was nearly diffraction limited in profile, and was focused with a 350 mm focal-length lens to a 240 µm spot size in the PPLN crystal. Both the etalon mirror spacing and the OPO resonator length were adjusted electronically by piezoelectric translators (PZTs) so that it was possible to tune the frequency continuously over 10 cm−1 without using motorized parts. Translation of a multigrating (or fan grating) PPLN wafer can allow access to, and local tuning of, any wavelength from 1.45 to 1.8 µm (signal) and from 2.6 to 4 µm (idler). Up to 18 µJ/pulse in the idler beam and up to 15 µJ/pulse in the signal beam were produced with only 200 µJ pump energy at 1.06 µm. The measured single-mode OPO linewidth was 0.005 cm−1 .
Pulsed Mid-IR Optical Parametric Oscillators
dichroic mirrors Nd:YAG pump laser
PPLN crystal
lens air-space etalon (PZT)
signal output coupler
167
idler output and residual pump
cavity length (PZT)
cavity length (PZT)
Fig. 21. Schematic of the narrow-band tunable OPO (from [28]). The ring resonator consists of three mirrors. The two dichroic mirrors on either side of the PPLN crystal transmit the pump and idler beams and reflect the signal beam. The third mirror outcouples 10 % of the signal beam for spectral characterization. The airspace etalon is made of two lenses, each with a 95 % reflective coating and each with a curvature that nearly matches the phase-front curvature of the ring cavity TEM00 mode. The right-hand dichroic mirror and the third mirror are on a single translation stage driven by a PZT to control the cavity length [49] (Courtesy of B. A. Richman)
At longer wavelengths, a narrow-linewidth (≈ 0.1 cm−1 ) ZGP OPO tunable from 3.7 to 8 µm was demonstrated by Ganikhanov et al. [50]. A type-II ZGP OPO (Fig. 22) was pumped by the output of a LiNbO3 OPO at 2.55 µm, pumped in turn by a Q-switched Nd:YAG laser with a 15 ns pulse duration and 10 Hz repetition rate. Despite the fact that the pump linewidth at 2.55 µm was fairly broad (≈ 15 cm−1 ), the authors demonstrated that one can achieve a narrow-linewidth output at the resonating wavelength in a singly resonant OPO, containing an intracavity diffraction grating, in the Littrow configuration and a Fabry–P´erot etalon. The grating had 240 lines/mm (blazed at 3.2 µm) in the case of the SRO cavity to oscillate on the signal wave, and 120 lines/mm (blazed at 6.4 µm) for oscillating on the idler wave. The etalon was simply a 1 mm thick uncoated plane-parallel silicon plate (finesse ≈ 2.6). The output energies were in the range of 10–200 µJ and the linewidth of 0.1 cm−1 corresponded to ≈ 3 axial OPO cavity modes. 6.2 Narrow-Linewidth Optical Parametric Generator–Optical Parametric Amplifier (OPG–OPA) Systems An interesting configuration for a narrow-bandwidth OPG–OPA laser source was reported by Aniolek et al. [51]. The output of the PPLN OPG was spectrally filtered and amplified in a PPLN optical parametric amplifier (OPA).
168
Konstantin Vodopyanov Broadband pump, 2.55 mm
DIFFRACTION GRATING
etalon (Si-plate)
ZGP CRYSTAL Gold Mirror
OUT
Fig. 22. Schematic of a narrow-linewidth 3.7–8 µm ZGP OPO pumped at 2.55 µm [50]
The pump laser was a passively Q-switched (with Cr4+ :YAG) Nd:YAG microlaser, end-pumped by a fiber-coupled diode laser. It delivered 2.6 ns pulses with up to 650 µJ energy in a single longitudinal and lateral mode, at a 120 Hz repetition rate. The two PPLN crystals were 50 mm long by 11 mm wide, with a thickness of either 0.5 mm (for the OPG) or 1.0 mm (for the OPA stage). Both crystals were poled in stepped fashion along the width dimension, with poling periods ranging from 28.5 to 29.9 µm, in 0.2 µm steps. The pump into the OPG was focused to a waist of 190 µm and the optical parametric generation threshold for the first stage was ≈ 70 µJ. When the first stage was pumped with 100 µJ energy, the signal pulse energy was 8 µJ. The spectrum of the OPG signal output was broad, ≈ 15 cm−1 . Filtering it with a highfinesse (450 maximum at 1.55 µm) tunable air-spaced Fabry–P´erot etalon formed a spectrally narrow seed for the OPA stage. The filtered signal output was combined with the pump beam having 250 µJ energy at 1.064 µm (both beams had a waist of 400–450 µm) in the OPA stage to get the output of the seeded OPA with idler pulse energies of 10 µJ and signal pulse energies of 30 µJ. The output bandwidth of such an OPG–OPA system was estimated to be 0.05 cm−1 by means of cavity ring-down spectroscopy measurements of the room temperature water-vapor line at 2893.8 cm−1 . 6.3
OPOs with Injection Seeding
So far we have regarded passive methods of spectral narrowing which use intra- or extra-cavity frequency selective elements to get a narrow linewidth. Injection-seeding OPOs with narrow-linewidth continuous-wave (CW) lasers form an alternative approach to achieve narrow-linewidth OPO. This technique, however, requires an additional single-longitudinal-mode seed laser source for each spectral region, which makes the whole setup more sophisticated.
Pulsed Mid-IR Optical Parametric Oscillators
169
Baxter et al. [52] reported a seeded narrowband PPLN OPO, pumped at 1.064 µm by a pulsed (≈ 10 ns pulse duration), single-mode Nd:YAG laser. The actively controlled PPLN OPO ring cavity was injection seeded at its resonant signal wavelength of 1.55 µm by a 5 mW CW single-mode externalcavity diode laser. The corresponding idler output was tunable near 3.4 µm and had a linewidth of 130 MHz (0.0043 cm−1 ), close to the limit imposed by the Fourier transform of the pulse duration. For spectroscopic applications, the OPO output was amplified in an OPA stage based on bulk LiNbO3 , so that the combined pulse energy of signal and idler output was typically 2 mJ. Injection-seeded nanosecond OPG–OPA was reported by Wu et al. [53]. For the reason that OPG–OPA has no cavity modes, it amplifies a whole continuum of frequencies inside its phase matching acceptance bandwidth, and there is no need of frequency mode-matching between the seed and OPG– OPA modes. Pump pulses in this work were provided by the third harmonic from a single longitudinal mode Nd:YAG laser which delivered pulses of 2.5 ns width at 355 nm, with 0–160 mJ of pulse energy at repetition rates up to 100 Hz, 5 mm beam diameter and a flat-top intensity profile. The OPG and the OPA stage each consisted of two walk-off-compensated beta-barium borate (BBO) crystals. The OPG–OPA setup was capable of tuning from 410 to 2400 nm without gaps. However, seeding was performed in a much narrower range, using a CW SLM laser with a few mW power tunable around 815 nm. The linewidth of such seeded ns OPG–OPA was measured to be 650 MHz (0.02 cm−1 ), close (within a factor of 4) to the transform-limited bandwidth of a 2.5 ns pump pulse. Since BBO material absorbs at wavelengths greater than 2 µm, a PPLN crystal can be used instead, in order to extend the IR tuning range. With a 1064 nm pump, similar OPG–OPA design and a SLM seed laser at 1.3–1.7 µm, one can achieve 4–5 µm tunability. 6.4
Using a Doubly Resonant Cavity
An attractive idea of how to achieve pulsed single longitudinal mode (SLM) operation with wide tunability in a doubly resonant optical parametric oscillator (DROPO) was exploited recently by Scherrer et al. [54,55]. DRPOs are resonant both at the signal and the idler wavelengths and have smaller pumping thresholds, as compared to singly resonant OPOs, but were traditionally considered to be impractical for spectroscopy because the double resonance condition is satisfied only at particular wavelengths, leading to cluster-hopping effects that preclude continuous frequency tuning. To overcome the problems of frequency clustering, a dual-cavity (or ‘entangled cavity’) DROPO was proposed. A schematic of the OPO is illustrated in Fig. 23. The signal and idler waves oscillate between the pairs of mirrors M1 –M3 and M2 –M4 , respectively. The inner mirrors (M2 , M3 ) are deposited onto the NLO crystal faces whereas the external mirrors (M1 , M4 ) are mounted on two PZT actuators for fine tuning of the lengths. A compact passively Q-switched Nd:YAG laser based on a non-planar ring oscillator delivers single-frequency
170
Konstantin Vodopyanov signal
M2 M1
idler
M3 M4
Fig. 23. Schematic top view of the dual-cavity (entangled cavity) DROPO for SLM operation. M1 – M3 form signal cavity, and M2 –M4 form idler cavity. M1 and M4 were moved with piezoelectric translators (Courtesy of E. Rosencher)
output pump pulses (1.064 µm, 20 µJ, 14 ns) at a 12 kHz repetition rate. The pump beam was focused to a 75 µm spot in the NLO crystal. The crystal was a 6 × 3 × 0.5 mm3 multiple-grating PPLN comprising three QPM grating sections with 27.8, 28.2 and 28.7 µm periods. The output coupling of the idler field is obtained through M4 which has a partial reflectivity (70 %) around 4 µm. The finesses of the signal and idler cavities were 900 and 13 respectively. The tunability of the OPO was investigated by changing the PZT voltages which control translating of mirrors M1 and M4 , whereas the crystal grating was fixed. Discrete tuning by means of mode hops of ≈ 0.33 cm−1 was achieved by changing only one cavity length. The OPO linewidth remained less than 80 MHz (0.0027 cm−1 ), demonstrating stable single-mode operation. Small (few µm) changes of the idler cavity length create a shift of the idler mode distribution with respect to the signal one. Therefore, as depicted in Fig. 24, doubly resonant operations will occur successively at the signal cavity resonances with a spectral separation given by the signal mode spacing (Vernier effect). The same is valid for the signal cavity PZT displacements. By selecting the PPLN grating section and adjusting the crystal temperature, SLM output was achieved in the 3.8–4.1 µm range. Continuous (hop-free) frequency tuning was obtained by changing the lengths of the signal and idler cavities in opposite directions. The OPO pump threshold was as small as 8 µJ (7.5 MW/cm2 ), and the pump–idler conversion efficiency reached 5.2 %. Fig. 24. Schematic diagram of discrete tuning with mode hops. Initially, the exact coincidence is obtained with the mode m0 , then the idler mode structure is shifted to the right by changing the idler PZT voltage, and consequently, the signal frequency jumps to the mode m0 − 1 [54]
Pulsed Mid-IR Optical Parametric Oscillators
171
Table 3. Some linear and nonlinear optical properties of zincblende semiconductors (from [56,57]) Crystal Transparency range (µm) GaAs GaP ZnSe ∗
0.90–17.0 0.51– 7.2 0.51–18.0
deff ∗ (pm/V) 2/π · 94.0 = 60.0 2/π · 37.0 = 23.6 2/π · 26.4 = 16.8
Average refractive index
NLO FOM d2eff /n3 with respect to PPLN
3.30 3.05 2.44
6.20 2.30 0.93
The 2/π factor represents the fact that the crystal can only be quasi-phase-matched
7 Emerging Nonlinear Optical Materials for Mid-IR Applications Zincblende semiconductors (GaAs, GaP, ZnSe and others) are extremely attractive for nonlinear optical frequency conversion, due to their good infrared transparency, high optical nonlinearity, superior thermal conductivity, and large surface damage threshold. Some of these properties are listed in Table 3. Most important is that the technology of growth of these crystals is in a very mature state. The only obstacle preventing them from serving as ideal mid-IR NLO materials is that their cubic crystal structure lacks birefringence. The phase matching problem arising from the optical isotropy of zincblende-type semiconductors can be solved by quasi-phase-matching that require spatial modulation of the optical nonlinearity. Unfortunately, zincblende-type semiconductors are not ferroelectric and no techniques analogous to electric field poling in LiNbO3 exist for inducing a quasi-phasematching domain grating in an already grown crystal – domain reversal should be incorporated into the crystal growth process. Angell et al. [58] succeeded in the growth of alternating 100/111oriented stripes of CdTe on a GaAs substrate using metalorganic chemical vapor deposition. The CdTe layer was shown to be a suitable template to pattern the orientation of subsequently grown wide-band-gap II–VI films of ZnSe or ZnTe which may serve as a waveguide or bulk media for nonlinear optical interaction. An ideal QPM could be accomplished in zincblende crystals by creating a√111/111 pattern, in which the nonlinear coefficient deff varies as ±2d14 / 3. The combination of 111/100 orientations, √ utilized in [58], results in an amplitude modulation of deff , between 2d14 / 3 and 0, which is one fourth as efficient as the ideal case. Recently, an all-epitaxial process for fabrication of orientation patterned (domain-inverted) GaAs structures has been developed [59,60,61], and has been applied for making structures for nonlinear optical applications. The orientation patterned GaAs (OP-GaAs) films were fabricated by a multistep process illustrated in Fig. 25. First, GaAs/Ge/GaAs heteroepitaxy is used to create a sublattice-reversed (SR) or antiphase GaAs layer on a GaAs sub-
172
Konstantin Vodopyanov
Fig. 25. Fabrication process of periodically patterned (domain-inverted) GaAs. (a) First, GaAs/Ge/GaAs heteroepitaxy is used to create a sublattice-reversed (SR) GaAs layer on a GaAs substrate. (b) Then the wafer is patterned, using photolithography and wet chemical etching, to create an orientation template with the period determined by a specific QPM process. (c) This template then undergoes two epitaxial growth steps (molecular beam epitaxy and hydride vapor phase epitaxy) to produce thick OP-GaAs film [61]
strate (Fig. 25a), after which this wafer is patterned, using photolithography and wet chemical etching, to create an orientation template (Fig. 25b) with the period determined by a specific QPM NLO process. This template then undergoes two epitaxial growth steps (molecular beam epitaxy and hydride vapor phase epitaxy) to produce thick OP-GaAs film (Fig. 25c). In this fashion, OP-GaAs layers can be grown to a thickness of 0.5 mm and length of up to 2 cm with excellent optical quality. Figure 26 shows the polished cross-section of an OP-GaAs sample with the QPM period of 61 µm. Orientation-patterned GaAs samples with different domain periods ranging between 27 and 212 µm, were characterized by continuous-wave CO2 laser frequency-doubling experiments [60] and mid-IR difference frequency generation between 7.95 and 8.6 µm [62] which have shown conversion efficiencies which were close to theoretically predicted for a given crystal’s length. Lately, Skauli et al. [57] performed an absolute comparison between nonlinear figures of merit of OPGaAs and periodically poled LiNbO3 , using quasi-phase-matched second har-
Fig. 26. Cross-section of an OP-GaAs sample with the QPM period of 61 µm (Courtesy of L. A. Eyres)
Pulsed Mid-IR Optical Parametric Oscillators
173
monic generation using λ ≈ 4 µm radiation, and found the nonlinear optical FOM ratio to be (d2eff /n3 )GaAs /(d2eff /n3 )PPLN = 6.2 ± 0.6. Also the authors demonstrated an efficient 4 µm → 2 µm frequency doubling in OP-GaAs with > 30 % internal efficiency at the energy of pump pulses of only 50 µJ. Thus, all-epitaxially grown OP-GaAs proves to be an extremely efficient material for nonlinear optical applications including OPOs and it may serve as a long-wavelength (λ > 5 µm) substitute of PPLN, but with much superior properties – higher nonlinearity, higher thermal conductivity and higher laser damage threshold.
8
Summary and Concluding Remarks
The state-of-the-art of pulsed mid-IR OPOs can be summarized as follows: OPOs can produce an average power of more than 10 W and energies of more than 100 mJ per pulse; continuous OPO/OPG tunability can be as wide as 3–19 µm (almost three octaves) in a single arrangement without changing any optics or crystals; the OPO linewidth is typically a few cm−1 but it can be reduced to its Fourier-transform limit of 10−2 –10−3 cm−1 if the OPO is forced to work in a single longitudinal mode regime; quantum conversion efficiency from the pump laser to the OPO output can exceed 50 %, and pump thresholds can be as low as 2 µJ in a singly resonant OPO. Periodically poled LiNbO3 , PPLN, can serve as a work horse for the majority of spectroscopic applications in the wavelength range 1.5–4 µm, thanks to the crystal’s robustness, high nonlinearity and affordable cost. Yet, the maximum 1 mm thickness combined with the inherent low-damage threshold of PPLN limits the use of this material in high-energy applications. On the other hand, PP KTP, PP RTA and PP KTA have similar NLO characteristics but are better suited for higher energy-per-pulse applications, due to their larger thickness and larger surface damage threshold; also, RTA and KTA have a longer infrared cut-off (> 5 µm). Because of its robustness and huge nonlinearity, ZGP serves in many midIR high average power OPO applications in the 3–5 µm range; also, it has high potential for biomedical and spectroscopic applications in the 3–10 µm range. For example, the first spectroscopic detection of explosives (TNT, RDX and using ZGP OPO via absorption measurements of fundamental bands between 6 and 8 µm. [63]. CGA seems to be the crystal of choice for long-wave applications (especially in the 8–12 µm window where it has very low absorption) and is expected to have the smallest OPO pumping threshold, due to its highest NLO coefficient. However, CGA needs a compact all-solid-state pump laser source in the 3–5 µm range. In contrast, a GaSe OPO can be directly pumped by a 1.06 µm laser and deliver continuous tunability of 1–18 µm, provided that the AR coating and mechanical hardness problems are solved.
174
Konstantin Vodopyanov
Even though it is still at a materials research level, orientation patterned GaAs has proven to be attractive in many senses for future applications: it can be pumped at 1 µm, has a broad transparency range (1–17 µm) and one can expect very low OPO pump thresholds of a few µJ because of the crystal’s high nonlinearity and non-critical phase matching which is a characteristic of all QPM crystals. Now OP-GaAs can be fabricated all-epitaxially with a 20 mm length and 0.5 mm thickness, sufficient for practical bulk nonlinear optical applications. Difference frequency generation of mid-infrared radiation has been demonstrated as well as highly efficient second harmonic generation. In summary, major progress in creating advanced NLO materials and pump lasers has enabled efficient, high power, and broadly tunable optical parametric devices for the mid-IR range of the spectrum to be built. It is important to notice that all these devices work at room temperature. New challenges include further development of artificial QPM materials (GaAs, AlGaAs, InP, GaP, ZnS, ZnSe), and progress towards compact all-solid-state mid-IR OPO devices based on diode-pumped laser technology.
References 1. J. A. Giordmaine, R. C. Miller: Tunable coherent parametric oscillation in LiNbO3 at optical frequencies, Phys. Rev. Lett. 14, 973–976 (1965) 141 2. A. Yariv: Quantum Electronics, 3rd ed. (Wiley, New York 1988) 142, 143, 145 3. M. M. Fejer, G. A. Magel, D. H. Jundt, R. L. Byer: Quasi-phase-matched 2nd harmonic-generation, Tuning and tolerances, IEEE J. Quantum Electron. 28, 2631–2654 (1992) 142, 145, 146 4. R. L. Byer, R. L. Herbst: Parametric Oscillation and Mixing, in Nonlinear Infrared Generation, Y.-R. Shen (Ed.), Topics Appl. Phys. 16 (Springer, Berlin 1977) 143 5. D. A. Roberts: Simplified characterization of uniaxial and biaxial nonlinear optical crystals, A plea for standardization of nomenclature and conventions, IEEE J. Quantum Electron. 28, 2057–2074 (1992) 145, 146 6. L. E. Myers, R. C. Eckardt, M. M. Fejer, R. L. Byer, W. R. Bosenberg, J. W. Pierce: Quasi-phase-matched optical parametric oscillators in bulk periodically poled LiNbO3 , J. Opt. Soc. Am. B 12, 2102–2116 (1995) 145, 146, 147 7. S. J. Brosnan, R. L. Byer: Optical parametric oscillator threshold and linewidth studies, IEEE J. Quantum Elec. 15, 415–431 (1979) 145 8. V. G. Dmitriev, G. G. Gurzadyan, D. N. Nikogosyan: Handbook of Nonlinear Optical Crystals (Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg 1997) 146, 153, 161 9. J. Hellstr¨ om, V. Pasiskevicius, F. Laurell, H. Karlsson: Efficient nanosecond optical parametric oscillators based on periodically poled KTP emitting in the 1.8–2.5-µm spectral region, Opt. Lett. 24, 1233–1235 (1999) 146, 149 10. L. E. Myers, R. C. Eckardt, M. M. Fejer, R. L. Byer, W. R. Bosenberg: Multigrating quasi-phase-matched optical parametric oscillators in periodically poled LiNbO3 , Opt. Lett. 21, 591–593 (1996) 147, 148 11. G. Hansson, D. D. Smith: Mid-infrared-wavelength generation in 2-µm pumped periodically poled lithium niobate, Appl. Opt. 37, 5743–5746 (1998) 147
Pulsed Mid-IR Optical Parametric Oscillators
175
12. P. E. Britton, D. Taverner, K. Puech, D. J. Richardson, P. G. R. Smith, G. W. Ross, D. C. Hanna: Optical parametric oscillation in periodically poled lithium niobate driven by a diode-pumped Q-switched erbium fiber laser, Opt. Lett. 23, 582–584 (1998) 147 13. G. Bellomonte, A. Grisard, L. Becouarn, E. Lallier: High efficiency mid-infrared optical parametric oscillation in thick periodically poled lithium niobate, Conference on Lasers and Electro-Optics Europe, Tech. Digest (Eur. Phys. Soc./ IEEE/ Lasers & Electro-Opt. Soc./ Opt. Soc. Am., 2000) p. 332 149 14. M. Peltz, U. B¨ ader, A. Borsutzky, R. Wallenstein, J. Hellstr¨ om, H. Karlsson, V. Pasiskevicius, F. Laurell: Optical parametric oscillators for high pulse energy and high average power operation based on large aperture periodically poled KTP and RTA, Appl. Phys. B 73, 663–670 (2001) 149, 150 15. G. Hansson, H. Karlsson, F. Laurell: Unstable resonator optical parametric oscillator based on quasi-phase-matched RbTiOAsO4 , Appl. Opt. 40, 5446–51 (2001) 150, 151 16. G. Rosenman, A. Skliar, Y. Findling, P. Urenski, A. Englander, P. A. Thomas, Z. W. Hu: Periodically poled KTiOAsO4 crystals for optical parametric oscillation, J. Phys. D: Appl. Phys. 32, L49–L52 (1999) 151 17. R. F. Wu, K. S. Lai, H. F. Wong, W. J. Xie, Y. L. Lim, E. Lau: Multiwatt mid-IR output from a Nd:YALO laser pumped intracavity KTA OPO, Opt. Express 8, 694–698 (2001) 152 18. E. Cheung, S. Palese, H. Injeyan, C. Hoefer, R. Hilyard, H. Komine, J. Berg, W. Bosenberg: High power conversion to mid-IR using KTP and ZGP OPO, in Advanced Solid-State Lasers, Tech. Digest (Opt. Soc. Am., Washington, DC 1999) p. 358–361 152, 156 19. G. Vysniauskas, D. Burns, E. Bente: Development of a nanosecond high energy KTA OPO system operating 2.9 µm, in Conference on Lasers and ElectroOptics (CLEO-2002), Tech. Digest (Opt. Soc. Am., Washington, DC 2002) p. 333. http://www.photonics.ac.uk/lib/ 152 20. G. Mennerat, P. Kupecek: High-energy narrow-linewidth tunable source in the mid infrared, in Advanced Solid-State Lasers, Tech. Digest (Opt. Soc. Am., Washington, DC 1998) p. 47–49 153 21. Y. X. Fan, R. L. Eckardt, R. L. Byer, R. K. Route, R. S. Feigelson: AgGaS2 infrared parametric oscillator, Appl. Phys. Lett. 45, 313–315 (1984) 154 22. K. L. Vodopyanov, J. P. Maffetone, I. Zwieback, W. Ruderman: AgGaS2 optical parametric oscillator continuously tunable from 3.9 to 11.3 µm, Appl. Phys. Lett. 75, 1204–1206 (1999) 154 23. R. C. Eckardt, Y. X. Fan, R. L. Byer, C. L. Marquardt, M. E. Storm, L. Esterowitz: Broadly tunable infrared parametric oscillator using AgGaSe2 , Appl. Phys. Lett. 49, 608–610 (1986) 154 24. J. Raffy, T. Debuisschert, J. P. Pocholle, M. Papuchon: An AgGaSe2 optical parametric oscillator pumped by a LiNbO3 OPO, Ann. Phys. (Paris) 20, S75–76, (1995) 155 25. S. Chandra, T. H. Allik, G. Catella, R. Utano, J. A. Hutchinson: Continuously tunable, 6–14 µm silver-gallium selenide optical parametric oscillator pumped at 1.57 µm, Appl. Phys. Lett. 71, 584–586 (1997) 155 26. P. A. Budni, L. A. Pomeranz, M. L. Lemons, P. G. Schunemann, T. M. Pollak, E. P. Chicklis: 10 W mid-IR holmium pumped ZnGeP2 OPO, in Advanced Solid State Lasers, Tech. Digest (Opt. Soc. Am., Washington, DC 1998) p. 90–92 155, 156
176
Konstantin Vodopyanov
27. P. A. Budni, L. A. Pometanz, M. L. Lemons, C. A. Miller, J. R. Mosto, E. P. Chicklis: Efficient mid-infrared laser using 1.9-µm-pumped Ho:YAG and ZnGeP2 optical parametric oscillators, J. Opt. Soc. Am. 17, 723–8 (2000) 156 28. R. Wu, K. S. Lai, W. E. Lau, H. F. Wong, Y. L. Lim, K. W. Lim, L. C. L. Chia: A novel laser integrated with a coupled tandem OPO configuration, in TOPS Vol. XX, Conference on Lasers and Electro-Optics (CLEO-2002), Tech. Digest (Opt. Soc. Am., Washington, DC 2002), p. 154 156, 167 29. T. H. Allik, S. Chandra, D. M. Rines, P. G. Schunemann, J. A. Hutchinson, R. Utano: Tunable 7–12-µm optical parametric oscillator using a Cr,Er:YSGG laser to pump CdSe and ZnGeP2 crystals, Opt. Lett. 22, 597–599 (1997) 157 30. K. L. Vodopyanov, F. Ganikhanov, J. P. Maffetone, I. Zwieback, W. Ruderman: ZnGeP2 optical parametric oscillator with 3.8–12.4-µm tunability, Opt. Lett. 25, 841–3 (2000) 157, 159 31. K. L. Vodopyanov: OPOs target the longwave infrared, Laser Focus World 37, 225–232 (2001) 157, 159 32. W. S. Pelouch, G. J. Wagner, T. J. Carrig, W. J. Scharpf: Mid-wave ZGP OPOs pumped by a Cr:ZnSe laser, in Advanced Solid State Lasers, Tech. Digest (Opt. Soc. Am., Washington, DC 2002) PD1-1–PD1-3 157 33. K. L. Vodopyanov, P. G. Schunemann: Broadly tunable non-critically phasematched ZGP optical parametric oscillator with a 2-microjoule pump threshold, Opt. Lett. 28, 441–443 (2003) 159 34. D. E. Zelmon, E. A. Hanning, P. G. Schunemann: Refractive-index measurements and Sellmeier coefficients for zinc germanium phosphide from 2 to 9 µm with implications for phase matching in optical frequency-conversion devices, J. Opt. Soc. Am. B 18, 1307–1310 (2001) 160 35. Y. Isyanova, A. Dergachev, D. Welford: Multi-wavelength, 1.5–10-µm tunable, tandem OPO, in Advanced Solid State Lasers, Tech. Digest (Opt. Soc. Am., Washington, DC 1999) p. 548–553 160 36. K. L. Vodopyanov, P. G. Schunemann: Efficient difference frequency generation of 7-20 µm radiation using CdGeAs2 , Opt. Lett. 23, 1096–1098 (1998) 161 37. A. Zakel, S. D. Setzler, P. G. Schunemann, T. M. Pollak, M. Burky, S. Guha: Optical parametric oscillator based on cadmium germanium arsenide, in Conference of Lasers and Electro-Optics (CLEO 2002), Tech. Digest (Opt. Soc. Am., Washington, DC 2002) p. 172 161 38. J. J. Zayhowski: Periodically poled lithium niobate optical parametric amplifiers pumped by high-power passively Q-switched microchip lasers, Opt. Lett. 22, 169–171 (1997) 162 39. T. S¨ udmeyer, J. A. D. Au, R. Paschotta, U. Keller, P. G. R. Smith, G. W. Ross, D. C. Hanna: Novel ultrafast parametric systems: high repetition rate singlepass OPG and fibre-feedback OPO, J. Phys. D: Appl. Phys. 34, 2433–2439 (2001) 162 40. K. L. Vodopyanov, V. Chazapis: Extra-wide tuning range optical parametric generator, Opt. Commun. 135, 98–102 (1997) 163, 164, 165 41. K. L. Vodopyanov: Parametric generation of tunable infrared radiation in ZnGeP2 and GaSe pumped at 3 µm, J. Opt. Soc. Am. B 10, 1723–9 (1993) 163 42. V. Petrov, Y. Tanaka, T. Suzuki: Parametric generation of 1 ps pulses between 5 and 11 µm with a ZnGeP2 crystal, IEEE J. Quantum Electronics 33, 1749–55 (1997) 163
Pulsed Mid-IR Optical Parametric Oscillators
177
43. V. Petrov, F. Rotermund, F. Noack, P. Schunemann: Femtosecond parametric generation in ZnGeP2 , Opt. Lett. 24, 414–416 (1999) 164 44. K. L. Vodopyanov: Mid-IR optical parametric generator with extrawide (3–19 µm) tunability, Applications for spectroscopy of two-dimensional electrons in quantum wells, J. Opt. Soc. Am. B 16, 1579–86 (1999) 164 45. K. L. Vodopyanov, G. M. H. Knippels, A. F. G. van der Meer, J. P. Mafetone, I. Zwieback: Optical parametric generation in CGA crystal, Opt. Commun. 202, 205–208 (2002) 165 46. S. J. Brosnan, R. L. Byer: Optical parametric oscillator threshold and linewidth studies, IEEE J. Quantum Electron. 15, 415–431 (1979) 166 47. J. Raffy, T. Debuisschert, J.-P. Pocholle: Widely tunable optical parametric oscillator with electrical wavelength control, Opt. Lett. 22, 1589–1591 (1997) 166 48. P. Schlup, G. W. Baxter, I. T. McKinnie: Single-mode near- and mid-infrared periodically poled lithium niobate optical parametric oscillator, Opt. Commun. 176, 267–271 (2000) 166 49. B. A. Richman, K. W. Aniolek, T. J. Kulp, S. E. Bisson: Continuously tunable, single-longitudinal-mode, pulsed mid-infrared optical parametric oscillator based on periodically poled lithium niobate, J. Opt. Soc. Am. B 17, 1233–1239 (2000) 166, 167 50. F. Ganikhanov, T. Caughey, K. L. Vodopyanov: Narrow-linewidth middleinfrared ZnGeP2 optical parametric oscillator, J. Opt. Soc. Am. B 18, 818–822 (2001) 167, 168 51. K. W. Aniolek, R. L. Schmitt, T. J. Kulp, B. A. Richman, S. E. Bisson, P. E. Powers: Microlaser-pumped periodically poled lithium niobate optical parametric generator–optical parametric amplifier, Opt. Lett. 25, 557–559 (2000) 167 52. G. W. Baxter, Y. He, B. J. Orr: A pulsed optical parametric oscillator, based on periodically poled lithium niobate (PPLN), for high-resolution spectroscopy, Appl. Phys. B 67, 753–756 (1998) 169 53. S. Wu, V. A. Kapinus, G. A. Blake: A nanosecond optical parametric generator/ amplifier seeded by an external cavity diode laser, Opt. Commun. 159, 74–79 (1999) 169 54. B. Scherrer, I. Ribet, A. Godard, E. Rosencher, M. Lefebvre: Dual-cavity doubly resonant optical parametric oscillators, Demonstration of pulsed single-mode operation, J. Opt. Soc. Am. B 17, 1716–29 (2000) 169, 170 55. C. Drag, A. Desormeaux, M. Lefebvre, E. Rosencher: Entangled cavity optical parametric oscillator for mid-infrared pulsed single-longitudinal-mode operation, Opt. Lett. 27, 1238–1240 (2002) 169 56. D. N. Nikogosyan: Properties of Optical and Laser-Related Materials (Wiley, Chichester, New York 1997) 171 57. T. Skauli, K. L. Vodopyanov, T. J. Pinguet, A. Schober, O. Levi, L. A. Eyres, M. M. Fejer, J. S. Harris, B. Gerard, L. Becouarn, E. Lallier: Measurement of nonlinear coefficient of orientation-patterned GaAs and demonstration of highly efficient second harmonic generation, Opt. Lett. 27, 628–630 (2002) 171, 172 58. M. J. Angell, R. M. Emerson, J. L. Hoyt, J. F. Gibbons, L. A. Eyres, M. L. Bortz, M. M. Fejer: Growth of alternating (100)/(111)-oriented II-VI regions for quasiphase-matched nonlinear optical devices on GaAs substrates, Appl. Phys. Lett. 64, 3107–9 (1994) 171
178
Konstantin Vodopyanov
59. C. B. Ebert, L. A. Eyres, M. M. Fejer, J. S. Harris: MBE growth of antiphase GaAs films using GaAs/Ge/GaAs heteroepitaxy, J. Cryst. Growth 201, 187– 193 (1999) 171 60. L. A. Eyres, P. J. Tourreau, T. J. Pinguet, C. B. Ebert, J. S. Harris, M. M. Fejer, L. Becouarn, B. Gerard, E. Lallier: All-epitaxial fabrication of thick, orientation-patterned GaAs films for nonlinear optical frequency conversion, Appl. Phys. Lett. 79, 904–906 (2001) 171, 172 61. S. Koh, T. Kondo, Y. Shiraki, R. Ito: GaAs/Ge/GaAs sublattice reversal epitaxy and its application to nonlinear optical devices, J. Cryst. Growth 227, 183 (2001) 171, 172 62. O. Levi, T. Skauli, T. Pinguet, K. L. Vodopyanov, P. S. Kuo, X. Yu, L. A. Eyres, J. S. Harris, M. M. Fejer, S. E. Bisson, T. J. Kulp, B. Gerard, L. Becouarn, E. Lallier: Continuously tunable long-wave IR frequency generation in orientation patterned GaAs, in Conference on Lasers and Electro-Optics (CLEO-2002), Tech. Digest (Opt. Soc. Am., Washington, DC 2002) p. 416–417 172 63. M. W. Todd, R. A. Provencal, T. G. Owano, B. A. Paldus, A. Kachanov, K. L. Vodopyanov, M. Hunter, S. Coy, J. I. Steinfeld, J. T. Arnold: Application of mid-infrared cavity ringdown spectroscopy to trace explosives vapor detection using a broadly tunable (6–10 µm) optical parametric oscillator, Appl. Phys. B 75, 367–376 (2002) 173
Index
AgGaS2 (AGS), 153, 154 AgGaSe2 (AGSe), 153, 154
nonlinear optical figure of merit (NLO FOM), 143, 155, 173
CdGeAs2 (CGA), 153, 161 CdSe, 160 Cr2+:ZnSe, 157 critical phase matching (CPM), 152
OPG–OPA, 142, 167, 169 OPO cavity, 143–145, 148, 150 optical parametric generator (OPG), 143, 145, 161, 163–165 optical parametric oscillator (OPO), 141–170, 173 orientation patterned GaAs (OPGaAs), 171–174
doubly resonant optical parametric oscillator (DROPO), 169, 170 Er:Cr:YSGG laser, 157, 158, 163, 164 ferroelectric oxide, 145 GaAs, 171 GaP, 171 GaSe, 153, 160, 161, 164, 173 KTiOAsO4 (KTA), 145, 146, 149, 151–153, 160, 173 KTiOPO4 (KTP), 145, 146, 149–152, 155, 156 laser – Er:Cr:YSGG, 157, 158, 163, 164 – Nd:YAG, 147–156, 159, 162, 166–169 LiNbO3 , 141, 145, 146, 149, 153, 155, 163–167 – periodically poled (PPLN), 142, 145–149, 153, 155, 157–162, 166–173 MgO:LiNb3 , 163 Nd:YAG laser, 147–156, 159, 162, 166–169 non-critical phase-matching (NCPM), 146, 152, 157, 159, 160, 174
parametric frequency down-conversion, 142 parametric gain, 143, 145, 146, 153, 164 parametric noise, 143, 145 phase matching, 142 – critical, 152 – non-critical, 146, 152, 157, 159, 160, 174 potassium titanyl phosphate (KTiOPO4 , or KTP), 145, 146, 149–152, 155, 156 PP KTA, 146–151 PP KTP, 146, 149, 150 PP RTA, 146, 149–150 PPLN, 142, 145–149, 153, 155, 157–162, 166–173 quasi-phase-matching (QPM), 142, 143, 145–148, 150, 151, 162, 170–174 RbTiOAsO4 (RTA), 145, 146, 149–151 single longitudinal mode (SLM), 165, 166, 168–170, 173 singly resonant oscillator (SRO), 147, 167 threshold
180
Index
– of an OPO, 145 – of a single-pass OPG, 145
zincblende, 171 ZnGeP2 (ZGP), 153, 155–160, 163–173 ZnSe, 171
Mid-Infrared Ultrafast and Continuous-Wave Optical Parametric Oscillators Majid Ebrahimzadeh School of Physics and Astronomy, University of St Andrews North Haugh, St Andrews, Fife KY16 9SS, Scotland, UK [email protected] Abstract. This chapter provides an overview of optical parametric oscillators (OPOs) in the ultrafast picosecond and femtosecond time-scales as well as the continuous-wave (CW) regime, operating in the mid-infrared spectral range at wavelengths above ∼ 2 µm. The treatment includes a discussion of the basic principles of optical parametric generation and amplification, with emphasis on mid-infrared generation, fundamental material and pump laser requirements, and a review of the pertinent mid-infrared materials and phase-matching schemes. The main OPO device configurations and operating principles are highlighted, and the important recent advances in mid-infrared ultrafast and CW OPOs are summarized.
1
Introduction
For nearly 40 years, optical parametric oscillators (OPOs) have been recognized as versatile sources of coherent light for spectral regions inaccessible to conventional lasers [1]. They are potentially capable of providing tunable radiation across extended spectral regions from a single device, offer the advantages of solid-state design, high efficiency and practical output powers, and can deliver output throughout the entire temporal spectrum from the continuous wave (CW) to ultrafast femtosecond time-scales. Operation of OPOs, however, is critically dependent on the spectral and spatial quality of the pump laser as well as the properties of the nonlinear material. Following the demonstration of the first prototype device in 1965 [1], the development of practical OPOs was for many years held back by the absence of suitable laser sources of sufficient coherence and intensity in desired spectral regions and nonlinear materials with favorable optical properties and high damage threshold. These difficulties compounded to render OPOs unreliable sources of cohereht radiation for many practical applications. As a result, there was a conspicuous decline in OPO research and a long period of quiescence in this field for nearly 20 years until, in the 1980s, the advent of new nonlinear materials once again prompted a major resurgence of interest in these devices. The emergence of a new generation of nonlinear optical crystals such as β-BaB2 O4 (BBO), LiB3 O5 (LBO), and KTiOPO4 (KTP), amongst others, with damage thresholds far exceeding those of the more classical materials and superior linear and nonlinear optical properties provided I. T. Sorokina, K. L. Vodopyanov (Eds.): Solid-State Mid-Infrared Laser Sources, Topics Appl. Phys. 89, 179–219 (2003) c Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2003
180
Majid Ebrahimzadeh
new impetus for research efforts in OPOs. At the same time, the availability of high-power laser sources with improved spectral and spatial coherence enabled the development of OPO devices at unprecedented power levels. More recently, the advent of quasi-phase-matched nonlinear materials such as periodically poled LiNbO3 (PPLN) has led to minimal pump power requirements, bringing the operation of OPOs within the reach of commonly available laser pump sources. The remarkable advances in this field have transformed OPOs from proof-of-principle laboratory prototypes to viable sources of coherent radiation and have now firmly established these devices as an important class of practical tunable light sources for many applications. The operating domain of OPOs, once confined to selected spectral and temporal regimes, now spans across extended spectral regions from the near-ultraviolet (near-UV) to the mid-infrared (mid-IR) and over all time-scales from the CW to the ultrafast femtosecond regime. Figure 1 compares the wavelength coverage of a number of OPO devices developed to date with that of several conventional tunable lasers. In the mid-IR spectral range, where there has traditionally been a famine of practical laser sources, OPOs offer particularly attractive alternatives for the generation of coherent radiation. As is evident from Fig. 1, while extended wavelength regions in the mid-IR still remain inaccessible to lasers, OPOs can offer broad and continuous tuning coverage in this range, often from a single device based on one nonlinear crystal. The aim of this chapter is to provide an overview of OPO devices operating in the mid-IR, from basic
Periodically poled LiNbO3 (PPLN) β-BaB2O4 (BBO)
OPOs
LiB3O5 (LBO)
Alexandrite
Tm3+:YAG 3+
Cr :Mg2SiO4
Dye
Co2+:MgF2 3+
Cr :YAG Ti:sapphire
0.2
1.0
Lasers
Cr2+:ZnSe
2.0
3.0
4.0
5.0
6.0
7.0
Wavelength (µm)
Fig. 1. Comparison of the spectral coverage of prominent conventional tunable lasers with that of a number of OPO devices developed to date. Vertical scale has no significance
Mid-Infrared Ultrafast and CW OPOs
181
operation principles to the important recent developments in the field. The treatment includes a description of the basic principles of optical parametric generation and amplification, design criteria and optimization, material and pump laser selection, and a review of devices. While much of the treatment is applicable to OPO devices of all types, particular emphasis is placed on midIR wavelength generation. In the discussion, we will not be concerned with the background to the origin of the nonlinear optical effects and a discussion of crystal optics, which can be found in other reference texts [2,3,4,5]. Other reviews on OPOs can also be found elsewhere in the literature [5,6,7,8,9,10]. We will adopt MKS units throughout.
2
Optical Parametric Process
Optical parametric generation is a second-order nonlinear process involving the interaction of three optical fields at frequencies ω3 , ω2 and ω1 , such that ω3 = ω2 + ω1 .
(1)
The field at ω3 corresponds to an intense input optical pump field, giving rise to a pair of generated fields at ω2 and ω1 . The generated field at the higher frequency, ω2 , say, is usually referred to as the signal, while the field at the lower frequency, ω1 , is termed the idler, although variations in this nomenclature are also frequently used in the literature. The optical parametric process is a consequence of the second-order nonlinear susceptibility χ(2) in noncentrosymmetric crystalline media. More rigorous treatments of the underlying physical principles responsible for the process can be found elsewhere [11,12]. Here, we restrict our attention to the essential features of the treatment and focus on the main results of the analysis. At a fundamental level, the parametric process can be described by considering Maxwell’s wave equation for the propagation of three optical fields, the pump, signal, and idler, at respective frequencies ω3 , ω2 , and ω1 , in a noncentrosymmetric crystalline medium exhibiting second-order nonlinear susceptibility, χ(2) . The propagation of the three optical fields in such a medium involves the solution of Maxwell’s nonlinear wave equation with the secondorder nonlinear polarization as the source term, namely ∂2E ∂2E ∂ 2 P (2) = µε 2 + µ , 2 ∂z ∂t ∂t2
(2)
where P (2) = ε0 χ(2) E 2 is the second-order polarization and E is the electric field of the propagating wave defined as 1 E(z)ei(kz−ωt) + cc , (3) E= 2 with E(z) representing the complex field amplitude. In writing (2), we have ignored nonlinear polarization terms higher than second-order. We have also
182
Majid Ebrahimzadeh
used a scalar notation for convenience and taken the propagation to be along the z-axis. We have also assumed that the medium is lossless, nonconducting, and nonmagnetic, as is generally true in practice. Since the parametric process involves the interaction of three optical fields, the total field E will comprise three harmonic waves representing the pump, signal, and idler, so that E = E 1 (ω1 ) + E 2 (ω2 ) + E 3 (ω3 ) .
(4)
To simplify the analysis further, it is also assumed that the optical fields are infinite uniform plane waves and monochromatic. The parametric interaction process can then be understood by seeking a solution to the nonlinear wave equation (2). This is done by separating (2) into three components at the three different frequencies ω1 , ω2 , ω3 , each of which must separately satisfy the wave equation. Then, by considering the three separate wave equations at each frequency and assuming that the field amplitudes vary only slowly over distances compared to a wavelength, after some manipulation, we obtain the variations of three field amplitudes with propagation as ∂E1 (z) = iκ1 E3 (z)E2∗ (z)ei∆ kz , ∂z ∂E2 (z) = iκ2 E3 (z)E1∗ (z)ei∆ kz , ∂z ∂E3 (z) = iκ3 E1 (z)E2 (z)e−i∆ kz , ∂z
(5a) (5b) (5c)
where κj = (ωj deff /nj c), with j = 1, 2, 3, n is the refractive index, ∆ k = (2) k3 − k2 − k1 is the phase-mismatch parameter, and deff = χeff /2 is the effective nonlinear coefficient representing the appropriate combination of the nonlinear tensor elements taking part in the parametric process. These are the coupled-wave equations governing the parametric interaction of the pump, signal, and idler in a dielectric medium exhibiting second-order nonlinear susceptibility. The coupled-wave equations are the starting point in the analysis of a wide range of nonlinear optical effects and apply universally to any three-wave mixing process involving the second-order susceptibility, where the frequencies of the fields satisfy (1). These include sum-frequency mixing (ω1 + ω2 → ω3 ), difference-frequency mixing (ω3 − ω2 → ω1 ), second harmonic generation (ω + ω → 2ω), and most importantly in the context of this discussion, optical parametric generation (ω3 → ω2 +ω1 ). We notice from (5) that the amplitudes of the three optical fields are coupled to one another through deff . Physically, this coupling provides the mechanism for the exchange of energy among the interacting fields as they propagate through the nonlinear medium. The direction of energy flow in a given three-wave mixing process depends on the relative phase and the intensity of the input fields.
Mid-Infrared Ultrafast and CW OPOs
2.1
183
Optical Parametric Gain
In practice, the parametric process is initiated by a single intense pump field at frequency ω3 at the input to a nonlinear crystal. This field, which is provided by a laser, in turn mixes, through the nonlinear susceptibility, with a signal field at ω2 to give rise to an idler field at ω1 = ω3 − ω2 . The idler field so generated in turn mixes back with the pump to produce additional signal and the regenerated signal remixes with the pump to produce more idler. Under suitable conditions (Sect. 2.2), the process can continue in this way until power is gradually transferred from the strong pump to the initially weak signal and idler fields. The generated signal and idler fields can therefore grow to macroscopic levels by draining power from the input pump field as they propagate through the nonlinear crystal. In the absence of a coherent source of signal and idler beams at the input, the initial supply of photons at ω1 and ω2 for mixing with the input pump is provided by the spontaneous break-up of pump photons through spontaneous parametric fluorescence. This process, also referred to as parametric noise or parametric luminescence, may be viewed to arise from the mixing of the zero-point flux of the electromagnetic field at the signal and idler frequency, quantized within the volume of the crystal, with the incoming pump photons, through the nonlinear polarization [13,14]. The effective zero-point flux at the signal and idler is obtained by allowing one half-photon of energy at both ω2 and ω1 or one photon of energy at either frequency to be present in each black-body mode of the quantizing volume. We can obtain the gain and amplification factor for the growth of the signal and idler fields in the parametric process from the solution of the coupled-wave equations (5). The general solution is beyond the scope of the present discussion and can be found elsewhere [15]. However, if it is assumed that the input pump field does not undergo strong depletion with propagation through the medium, then ∂E3 /∂z = 0 in (5c). The coupled-wave equations are reduced to two, with E3 independent of z in both (5a) and (5b). Subject to the initial condition of no input idler field, E1 (z = 0) = 0, and finite input signal, E2 (z = 0) = 0, the net fractional gain in signal intensity with propagation through the nonlinear crystal is obtained as G2 () =
I2 (z = ) sinh2 [Γ 2 2 − (∆ k/2)2 ]1/2 − 1 = Γ 2 2 , I2 (z = 0) [Γ 2 2 − (∆ k/2)2 ]
(6)
where is the interaction length, I = ncε0 EE ∗ /2 is the intensity or flux (in W/ m2 ), and Γ is the gain factor defined as Γ2 =
8π 2 d2eff I3 (z = 0) . cε0 n1 n2 n3 λ1 λ2
(7)
Here, n and λ are the refractive index and wavelength of the respective waves, I3 (z = 0) is the input pump intensity and deff has units of meters/volt. From the same analysis, an expression similar to (6) may be derived for
184
Majid Ebrahimzadeh
the growth of the idler field from its initial zero value at the input to the nonlinear crystal [11]. The case of non-zero input idler as well as signal can also be treated similarly [9] and results analogous to (6) can be derived for the amplification of the generated fields. It is sometimes useful to express the gain factor in the form Γ2 =
8π 2 d2eff (1 − δ 2 )I3 (z = 0) , cε0 n20 n3 λ20
(8)
where δ is the degeneracy factor defined as 1+δ =
λ0 , λ2
1−δ =
λ0 λ1
(0 ≤ δ ≤ 1) ,
(9)
where λ0 (= 2λ3 ) is the degenerate wavelength, and n0 is the refractive index at degeneracy, with n0 ∼ n1 ∼ n2 . The factor δ is a measure of how close the signal and idler wavelengths are to degeneracy. It is clear from (8) that parametric gain has a maximum value at degeneracy, where δ ∼ 0, and decreases for operation away from degeneracy as δ → 1. 2.2
Optical Parametric Amplification
It can be seen from (6) that the magnitude of the nonlinear gain in the parametric process depends on material parameters such as the refractive index, interaction length, and nonlinear coefficient, the signal and idler wavelengths, as well as the input pump intensity. It is also seen that amplification is strongly dependent on the phase-mismatch parameter ∆ k. For ∆ k = 0, the generated fields experience maximum gain, whereas the growth of the parametric waves is severely undermined by an increase in the magnitude of ∆ k. The general functional dependence of G2 () on ∆ k, as represented by (6), can be found in several reference texts [9,12,14]. In practical devices, however, we are usually interested in maximum gain and amplification for the parametric waves, which occurs for ∆ k = 0. This is achieved through phasematching. Under this condition, (6) is reduced to G2 () = sinh2 (Γ ) .
(10)
Parametric devices often operate under different gain conditions, depending on the magnitude of the gain factor, Γ . In the low-gain regime, corresponding to Γ 1, (6) can be approximated by G2 () ≈ Γ 2 2 .
(11)
On the other hand, in the high-gain regime, Γ 1, and so (6) can be simplified to G2 () ≈
1 2Γ e . 4
(12)
Mid-Infrared Ultrafast and CW OPOs
185
Therefore, under the phase-match condition (∆ k = 0), the single-pass intensity gain has a quadratic dependence on Γ in the low-gain limit, whereas it increases exponentially with 2Γ in the high-gain limit. Experimentally, the low-gain limit corresponds to parametric generation when using CW or lowto moderate-peak-power pulsed pump sources. This regime is pertinent to most parametric devices, and in particular to optical parametric oscillators (OPOs). On the other hand, the high-gain limit is valid when pumping with high-intensity, pulsed, and amplified laser sources, and corresponds to optical parametric generator (OPG) and optical parametic amplifier (OPA) devices. To obtain an estimate of the magnitude of parametric gain under different pumping conditions, we can consider the main operating regimes of parametric devices. These are summarized in Table 1, where the gain factor, Γ , and the net single-pass intensity gain, G2 (), have been calculated under the phase-matched condition (∆ k = 0) for different pumping conditions, using (8) and (10). We have taken typical values for pump pulse energy, duration, power, focused beam waist radius (w0 ) and crystal length () appropriate to each mode of operation in practice. We have also assumed a typical nonlinear coefficient of deff ∼ 3 pm/V and have considered degenerate operation at 2 µm (λ2 ∼ λ1 ∼ 2 µm) with n3 ∼ n0 ∼ 1.5, for convenience. We can see from Table 1 that the magnitude of the single-pass parametric gain varies from a mere 0.8 % under continuous-wave (CW) pumping with a relatively powerful 5-W laser to as much as ∼ 3.4 × 1031 when using highenergy ultrashort pump pulses. The latter would correspond to the use of high-intensity, mode-locked and amplified laser systems based on regenerative amplification and cavity-dumping schemes. In the intermediate regime of Table 1. Parametric gain factor and the net single-pass intensity gain for different pumping regimes, calculated from (7) and (9). The calculations are based on typical experimental values for pump laser and nonlinear material parameters for each operating regime and assume phase-matched interaction (∆ k = 0) and near-degenerate operation at ≈ 2 µm CW
Q-switched
Mode-locked
Mode-locked amplified
–
10 mJ
15 nJ
10 µJ
Pump pulse duration –
10 ns
100 fs
200 fs
Peak pump power
5W
1 MW
150 kW
50 MW
Focused waist radius (wo )
20 µm
1 mm
15 µm
15 µm
Peak intensity (I3 )
400 kW/cm2 30 MW/cm2 20 GW/cm2
7 TW/cm2
Crystal length ()
10 mm
1 mm
1 mm
Pump pulse energy
10 mm
Γ
0.09
0.77
1.99
37
G2 ()
0.008
0.72
12.88
3.4 × 1031
186
Majid Ebrahimzadeh
pumping with Q-switched nanosecond pulses (see the chapter by Vodopyanov in this volume), optical gains of ≈ 70 % are available, whereas with ultrashort pulses of relatively low energy, corresponding to typical mode-locked lasers (e.g. Ti:sapphire), single-pass intensity gains on the order of ≈ 1300 % are expected. Given that the initial signal intensity at the crystal input is provided by spontaneous parametric emission, it is clear that any meaningful amplification to macroscopic levels over a single pass of the crystal is not practicable, except in the high-energy ultrashort pump pulse regime where large exponential gains are available. This is the configuration corresponding to OPG and OPA devices. In all other operating regimes, discernable output can only be made available by enclosing the nonlinear material within an optical resonator to provide feedback at the generated parametric wave(s). This is the OPO device configuration, which is the most common architecture for parametric devices. In this treatment, we focus mainly on a description of OPO devices, with particular emphasis on mid-IR generation. More extensive discussions of high-gain parametric devices, namely OPGs and OPAs, can be found elsewhere in the literature [15]. 2.3
Mid-Infrared Parametric Generation
From the preceding discussion, it is clear that providing the phase-matching condition (∆ k = 0) can be satisfied, the efficiency of the optical parametric generation process is critically dependent on the gain factor, Γ , through (10)– (12). It is also clear from (7) and (8) that the gain factor is itself determined by a number of inherent material parameters such as the nonlinear coefficient and refractive indices, as well as the pump, signal and idler wavelengths. In the context of mid-infrared generation, these parameters play an increasingly important role in determining the interaction efficiency because of their dependence on wavelength. This can be best understood by writing (7) in terms of a so-called nonlinear figure of merit, F , for the material as 8π 2 1 I3 (z = 0) , (13) Γ =F cε0 λ1 λ2 with F given by deff F = √ . n1 n2 n3
(14)
The nonlinear figure-of-merit thus incorporates the fundamental material parameters. It is essentially a measure of the strength of parametric generation for a given material in a particular wavelength range and for a given set of controllable parameters including the pump intensity and crystal interaction length. The larger the value of F , the higher the nonlinear gain and hence the efficiency of parametric generation. Inspection of (14) reveals a direct dependence of F on the pump, signal and idler wavelengths through dispersion
Mid-Infrared Ultrafast and CW OPOs
187
of refractive indices, n1 , n2 and n3 . However, the F parameter also has an indirect dependence on wavelength through dispersion of deff , as described below. In the context of mid-IR parametric generation, these dependencies play an increasingly important role in influencing the magnitude of F , and hence the efficiency of the parametric process. We can obtain a measure of this influence by considering the wavelength dependence of each term on the right-hand-side of (14) separately. Clearly, one can see from the equation that 1 1 ∼ 3/2 , F ∝ √ n1 n2 n3 n
(15)
where, for the sake of simplicity, we have assumed that n1 ∼ n2 ∼ n3 = n. We can also see from (14) that F ∝ deff , with deff itself related to the effective (2) second-order nonlinear susceptibility by deff ∼ χeff /2. On the other hand, we also know, from Miller’s empirical rule [16], that χ(2) is related to the linear susceptibility of the material, χ(1) , through (16) χ(2) (ω3 , ω2 , ω1 ) = ∆ χ(1) (ω3 ) · χ(1) (ω2 ) · χ(1) (ω1 ) , where ∆ is Miller’s constant. We also know that the linear susceptibility is related to the refractive index of the material by χ(1) = n2 − 1. Hence, we can write the dependence of F on deff in terms of the refractive index as 3
F ∝ (n2 − 1) ∼ n6 ,
(17)
where we have again assumed that n1 ∼ n2 ∼ n3 = n for simplicity. Combining (15) and (17), we find the overall dependence of F on material dispersion as F ∝
1 n3/2
· n6 ∼ n9/2 .
(18)
It is thus seen that the nonlinear figure-of-merit is strongly dependent on the refractive indices of the material. This clearly has important implications in the context of mid-IR parametric generation. Because of normal dispersion, the strong dependence of F on refractive index implies that, for a given nonlinear material, the parametric gain decreases towards longer wavelengths. Hence, for a given pump intensity and crystal length, the parametric generation efficiency is progressively diminished in going from the visible and near-IR spectral range towards the mid-IR, purely as a result of fundamental material properties relating to dispersion. At the same time, we see from (13) that regardless of material parameters, for a given pumping intensity, parametric gain also has a direct dependence on the signal and idler wavelengths through Γ ∝√
1 . λ1 λ2
(19)
188
Majid Ebrahimzadeh
Again, this dependence has important consequences for mid-IR parametric generation. We can clearly see that the magnitude of the nonlinear gain decreases with the increase in the signal and idler wavelengths. Hence, for a given nonlinear material and pumping intensity, parametric generation again becomes increasingly less efficient towards the mid-IR spectral regions due to the wavelength factor.
3
Mid-Infrared OPO Devices
In this treatment, we are concerned with a discussion of mid-IR OPOs operating in the CW and ultrafast (picosecond and femtosecond) time-scales. The principal design criterion for optimum operation of these devices is the same as that for other types of OPOs, namely the maximization of the gain factor, Γ , through suitable choice of nonlinear material and laser pump source. Other issues relate to suitable cavity design and appropriate choice of resonance configuration, optimization of phase-matching and focusing parameters. We will not concern ourselves here with a detailed description of OPOs including the different device architectures, cavity resonance configurations, threshold conditions, and efficiencies, which can be found elsewhere [5,6,7,8,9]. Instead, we concentrate on the fundamental design parameters relating to the nonlinear material and laser pump source pertaining to midIR parametric generation. We also provide a survey of the current status of CW and ultrafast OPOs operating in the mid-IR. For the purposes of the discussion, we refer to the mid-IR spectral region as that which includes the wavelength range from ≈ 2 µm to beyond ≈ 5 µm. 3.1
Nonlinear Material
The selection of nonlinear material for mid-IR OPOs is governed by a number of universal factors that are equally applicable to all types of OPO devices. Clearly, a fundamental material parameter is a broad transparency range in the mid-IR and the ability to be phase-matched in the wavelength range of interest. As highlighted in Sect. 2.3, it is also important for the material to have a large nonlinear figure-of-merit, F , for the attainment of the highest efficiency. This, in turn, means that the material must possess a large effective nonlinear coefficient, deff . Other material requirements include a high optical damage threshold, good optical quality and low absorption loss at the pump, signal and idler wavelengths, mechanical, chemical, and thermal stability, and availability in bulk form and sufficiently large size. In addition to the fundamental material parameters highlighted above, there are also a number of other material requirements that are desirable for optimum operation of OPOs. These include favorable phase-matching geometries, small double-refraction and spatial walkoff and, in the case of femtosecond OPOs, low temporal walkoff and group velocity dispersion. It is also
Mid-Infrared Ultrafast and CW OPOs
189
desirable for the material to display large tolerances to possible deviations in the spectral and spatial quality of the pump beam, which result in an increase in the magnitude of the phase mismatch ∆ k from zero. Such deviations arise in practice from the finite spectral bandwidth and divergence of the pump beam. The tolerance of the nonlinear crystal to such effects is measured in terms of the so-called spectral acceptance bandwidth and angular acceptance bandwidth, which can be calculated from the rate of change of phase-mismatch with the wavelength spread (∆ λ) and angular divergence (∆ θ) the pump, using a series expansion of ∆ k [2]. The acceptance bandwidths can then be obtained by solving for the quantities ∆ λ and ∆ θ, using the boundary condition |∆ k| ∼ 2π. For a given crystal length, , the acceptance bandwidths set an upper limit to the maximum allowable pump linewidth and divergence before parametric gain is severely diminished. Equivalently, for a given pump linewidth and angular divergence, the acceptance bandwidths determine the maximum length of the nonlinear crystal that can effectively contribute to the nonlinear gain. Since the crystal length follows an inverse relationship with the maximum allowable pump bandwidth and divergence, for shorter crystal lengths larger deviations in pump beam quality can be tolerated and vice versa. For materials that exhibit temperature-dependent refractive indices and hence a temperature-tuning capability, one can similarly define a temperature acceptance bandwidth, ∆ T , which is a measure of the sensitivity of phase-matching, and thus parametric gain, to changes in the crystal temperature. As a general rule, for the attainment of maximum nonlinear gain and minimum OPO threshold, it is advantageous to use materials which exhibit large spectral, angular, and temperature acceptance bandwidths. In the operating regime of CW and ultrafast OPOs, however, there is an additional material requirement that is generally critical for successful device operation. It arises from the relatively low pumping intensities available from the commonly available (low- to moderate-power) CW and mode-locked lasers compared to, for example, pulsed nanosecond pump lasers. This essential material parameter is non-critical phase-matching (NCPM), which allows phase-matched interaction along a principal optical axis of the material with no spatial walkoff. Given the generally low pump powers available from CW and mode-locked pump lasers, the absence of beam walkoff under NCPM enables tight focusing of the pump beam to achieve the necessary intensities without the deleterious effects of beam walkoff. In the absence of a NCPM capability, tight focusing will generally be precluded by the increase in spatial walkoff, with the result that the OPO will not even reach oscillation threshold. Therefore, NCPM is generally a highly important material property in the context of CW and ultrafast OPOs. This requirement is somewhat less stringent when deploying high-power (multi-watt) pump sources for picosecond OPOs, or in femtosecond OPOs, where the high peak powers and short interaction lengths of the material allow the use of critical phase matching (CPM)
190
Majid Ebrahimzadeh
in collinear or noncollinear schemes (Sect. 5.2). However, even in these cases NCPM still offers the advantage of zero spatial walkoff and hence higher nonlinear gain. Another important advantage of NCPM is that under this geometry the angular acceptance bandwidth of the material is maximized, because of the small sensitivity of refractive indices to beam propagation angle along a principal optical axis. Therefore, the NCPM geometry is also highly beneficial when using pump beams of poor spatial quality. 3.2
Laser Pump Source
As with nonlinear materials, the choice of laser pump source is also governed by a number of universal factors relating to the maximization of nonlinear gain. A principal requirement is set by phase-matching to access the wavelength regions of interest and the pump wavelength should obviously be within the transparency range of the material. The pump source must also be of sufficient intensity, as evident from (7), to provide appreciable nonlinear gain for the OPO to reach operation threshold. This, in turn, necessitates a sufficiently low beam divergence to allow high focused intensities and depth of focus within the nonlinear material. Considerations of the phase-mismatch, ∆ k, place further demands on the spectral and spatial coherence of the pump beam. As can be seen from (6), parametric gain is strongly dependent on the phase-mismatch parameter, ∆ k. Maximum gain occurs for ∆ k = 0, while increases in the magnitude of ∆ k result in severe reductions in nonlinear gain. Despite the use of phase-matching techniques, the attainment of perfect phase-matching (∆ k = 0) is generally not possible in practice, because of finite spectral bandwidth and spatial divergence of the pump beam. This leads to an increase in the magnitude of ∆ k, with the net result that the parametric gain is severely reduced from its peak value at ∆ k = 0. The maximum allowable pump bandwidth and divergence can be calculated from considerations of phase-mismatch [17]. As discussed in Sect. 3.1, such limitations to pump beam quality can be equivalently considered in terms of the spatial and spectral acceptance bandwidths for the nonlinear process. To maintain high parametric gains, it is important to employ laser pump sources of narrow linewidth and low beam divergence. From (19), it is also clear that for a given nonlinear material and pumping intensity, the efficiency of parametric generation is diminished in the mid-IR due to the increasing signal and idler wavelengths, regardless of the particular laser pump source. However, another important factor in mid-IR parametric generation is the quantum defect, defined as the ratio of the input pump photon energy to the generated (signal or idler) photon energy (ω3 /ω1,2 ). Foregoing all other material and pump laser considerations, the quantum defect sets the ultimate limit to the maximum power that can be generated in the parametric waves for a given pump wavelength at 100 % photon conversion efficiency. The larger the wavelength difference between the pump and the parametric waves, the larger the quantum defect, and hence the smaller
Mid-Infrared Ultrafast and CW OPOs
191
the maximum generated parametric power. For mid-IR parametric generation, where long signal and idler wavelengths are involved, this implies that for a given input intensity, higher output powers will be available with longer pump wavelengths. Hence, it is desirable to use longer wavelength (near-IR) laser pump sources. In practice, however, it is the availability of the suitable pump laser that will dictate the magnitude of the quantum defect. In the absence of practical laser sources at wavelength > 1.2 µm in the nearIR, the Nd:YAG and the Ti:sapphire laser have become the predominant pump sources for mid-IR OPOs operating in the CW and ultrafast regimes. Other novel pump sources including near-IR semiconductor lasers have also been recently used for CW and ultrafast OPOs operating into the mid-IR (Sects. 5.1, 5.2 and 6).
4
Mid-Infrared Nonlinear Materials
Before the advent of the new generation of nonlinear crystals in the early 1980s, the only promising material candidates for mid-IR wavelength generation were the classical crystals such as AgGaS2 , AgGaSe2 , Ag3 AsS3 , CdSe, LiNbO3 and Ba2 NaNb5 O15 . The main optical characteristics of a number of these materials are summarized in Table 2. As can be seen from the table, particularly attractive properties of most of these materials are broad mid-IR transparency (> 10 µm) and large effective nonlinear coefficients (> 10pm/V). On the other hand, the development of CW and ultrafast mid-IR OPOs based on classical materials has been largely precluded by a general lack of NCPM capability for mid-IR parametric generation when pumped in the near-IR using commonly available pump sources such as the Nd:YAG laser. As a result, the majority of mid-IR OPOs based on these materials have only been successfully operated in the pulsed nanosecond regime, where the requirement for NCPM is not imperative due to the larger available pumping intensities. However, even under nanosecond pulsed pumping, the development of practical devices has in many cases been hampered by the relatively low material damage threshold. The low damage tolerance is in part a consequence of the relatively long short-wavelength absorption cut-off in the classical materials, leading to significant absorption of near-IR pumping radiation, and in part due to the relatively poor optical quality resulting in increased absorption and scattering losses in many cases. The short-wavelength absorption edge of classical materials also makes the use of other pump sources such as the Ti:sapphire laser impractical for mid-IR OPO development. The introduction of novel nonlinear materials based on KTiOPO4 (KTP) and its arsenate analogs, particularly KTiOAsO4 (KTA), RbTiOAsO4 (RTA) and CsTiOAsO4 (CTA) in the 1980s, provided a new class of crystals for parametric generation into the mid-IR. While exhibiting significantly lower effective nonlinear coefficients (≈ 4 pm/V) and shorter mid-IR transmission cutoff (≈ 5 µm) than classical materials (Table 2), they offer the important
192
Majid Ebrahimzadeh
Table 2. Characteristics of a number of prominent near- and mid-infrared nonlinear materials, including the classical crystals as well as the new generation of birefringent and quasi-phase-matched materials. For a more comprehensive survey of nonlinear crystals, see [2] Nonlinear Material
Optical category
Transmission range ( µm)
Effective nonlinear coefficient (pm/V)
Observed damage threshold∗ (GW/cm2 )
≈ 13 ≈ 33 ≈ 15 ≈ 18 ≈ 75 ≈5 ≈ 15
∼ 0.05 ∼ 0.05 ∼ 0.05 > 0.05 > 0.03 ∼ 0.3 ∼ 0.003
≈4 ≈4 ≈4 ≈4 ≈ 12
∼ 0.5 ∼ 0.5 ∼ 0.5 ∼ 0.5 0.01–0.2
≈ 16 ≈8 ≈8 ≈8 ≈8
0.3 — — — —
Classical birefringent phase-matched materials AgGaS2 AgGaSe2 Ag3 AsS3 CdSe ZnGeP2 LiNbO3 Ba2 NaNb5 O15
Uniaxial Uniaxial Uniaxial Uniaxial Uniaxial Uniaxial Biaxial
0.5–13 0.71–18 0.6–13 0.75–20 0.74–12 0.33–5.5 0.37–5
New birefringent phase-matched materials KTiOPO4 KTiOAsO4 RbTiOAsO4 CsTiOAsO4 KNbO3
Biaxial Biaxial Biaxial Biaxial Biaxial
0.35–4.3 0.35–5.3 0.35–5.3 0.35–5.3 0.4–5.5
New quasi-phase-matched materials PPLN PPKTP PPRTA PPKTA PPLT ∗
Uniaxial Biaxial Biaxial Biaxial Uniaxial
0.33–5.5 0.35–4.3 0.35–5.3 0.35–5.3 0.28–5.3
Damage thresholds: λ = 1.06 µm; τ = 10 ns [2]
advantage of NCPM, good optical quality, and increased damage threshold. Equally importantly, a short-wavelength absorption cutoff below ≈ 400 nm in these materials enables the use of readily available laser sources without the onset of pump absorption. These characteristics have permitted use of Nd:YAG and Ti:sapphire lasers as the pump source for successful operation of mid-IR OPOs in both CW and ultrafast picosecond and femtosecond regimes. In CW and picosecond operation, however, these devices are characterized by a mid-IR tuning limit of ≈ 3.5 µm, set by the longest idler wavelength that can be phase-matched under NCPM when pumped with the Nd:YAG or Ti:sapphire lasers (Fig. 2). In femtosecond operation, alternative noncollinear CPM schemes can be employed to achieve wavelength extension beyond 5 µm in these materials, as will be discussed in Sect. 5.2. In addition to KTiOPO4
OPO wavelength (Pm)
Mid-Infrared Ultrafast and CW OPOs 4.0
4.0
4.0
3.5
3.5
3.0
3.0
3.0
2.5
2.5
2.5
2.0
2.0
2.0
1.5
1.5
1.5
1.0 40
1.0 90 0
3.5
(a)
50
60
70
80
deff (pm/V)
θ (deg) 13-plane (φ =0°)
193
1.0 20 40 60 80 90 80 70 60 50 40 φ (deg) 12-plane (θ=90°) θ (deg) 23-plane (φ =90°)
4.0 4.0 4.0 (b) 3.5 3.5 3.5 3.0 3.0 3.0 2.5 2.5 2.5 2.0 2.0 2.0 1.5 1.5 1.5 1.0 1.0 1.0 40 50 60 70 80 90 0 20 40 60 80 90 80 70 60 50 40 φ (deg) 12-plane (θ=90°) θ (deg) 23-plane (φ =90°) θ (deg) 13-plane (φ =0°)
Fig. 2. (a) The tuning behavior and (b) corresponding effective nonlinear coefficient under type-II birefringent phase-matching in the principal optical planes of RTA for a Ti:sapphire pump wavelength at 830 nm [67]. Note that under NCPM (θ = 90◦ or φ = 90◦ ), wavelength tuning coverage is limited to ≈ 2.5 µm at 830 nm. The tuning behavior is similar in KTA and CTA. The tuning limit in RTA and other arsenate isomorphs of KTP can be extended to ≈ 3 µm using longer Ti:sapphire pump wavelengths [26] and to ≈ 3.5 µm using the Nd:YAG laser pump wavelength at 1.064 µm
and its arsenate isomorphs, there have also been significant developments in other nonlinear materials for mid-IR generation, most notably KNbO3 (KNB). However, a lack of NCPM in this crystal has confined its utility to femtosecond OPOs using noncollinear CPM schemes (Sect. 5.2). At the same time, a particularly important breakthrough in OPO device technology over the past decade, with major impact on mid-IR OPOs, has been the development of quasi-phase-matched nonlinear materials [18]. Whereas the traditional birefringent phase-matching (BPM) methods expolit the natural birefringence of the optically anisotropic crystal to compensate for dispersion [19,20], quasi-phase-matching (QPM) relies on the periodic reversal of the electric dipole domains in the material along the beam propagation direction to achieve phase-matching. The technique was first proposed four decades ago [12], but its practical implementation was not realized until the recent development of reliable fabrication methods in ferroelectric materials [18]. A practical method to achieve domain reversal is through periodic poling of the ferroelectric material by applying a high electrical field (several kV) across the crystal using patterned electrodes. The period of the domain reversal is determined by the coherence length for the parametric interaction
194
Majid Ebrahimzadeh
in the particular wavelength range of interest – it varies typically from a few µm in the visible to a few tens of µm for mid-IR generation. The end result of the QPM process is that the generated signal and idler waves can undergo quasi-continuous growth as they propagate with the pump through the material. While the growth of optical waves in the QPM process is not monotonic, as is the case in BPM, the overriding advantage of the technique is that it can be freely engineered. Moreover, because QPM does not rely on birefringence, the polarization of optical waves and the direction of propagation can be freely chosen to access the largest diagonal elements in the χ(2) susceptibility tensor, not available in BPM, hence leading to the highest effective nonlinear coefficient in the material. This ability more than compensates for the quasi-continuous nature of amplification in QPM compared with BPM and ensures larger growth of the generated waves. The schematic illustration in Fig. 3 provides a qualitative comparison of parametric gain defined under BPM and QPM conditions. The plots correspond to the low
QPM:
BPM:
'k
'k o ∆kQ
k3 k2 k1
Phase-Match Condition:
'k
k3 k2 k1
Parametric Gain (arbitrary)
k2
Phase-Match Condition:
0
k3 k2 k1 − kG ∆kQ
k1
k3 k2 k1 − kG = 0 k2
k3
k1
kG
k3
QPM
2
K
G2 (QPM) ªdeff (QPM) º » «deff (BPM) ¼ G2 (BPM) ¬
K ~ 15 (in LiNbO3) BPM
4S / "
2S / "
0 kG 0
2S / "
4S / "
'k ∆kQ
Fig. 3. Qualitative comparison of parametric gain, as defined through (5), between BPM and QPM. For simplicity we have assumed collinear interaction. The relative gain is represented by η. In the case of BPM, the phase-mismatch is given by ∆ k and the peak gain is centered at ∆ k = k3 − k2 − k1 = 0. In QPM, the phasemismatch is given by ∆ kQ and is centered at ∆ k = k3 − k2 − k1 = kG . While in QPM, an additional phase-mismatch is induced by the presence of the grating vector, kG , the larger available nonlinear tensor coefficients result in substantially higher parametric gains. In the case of LiNbO3 , the increase in peak gain can be as much as 15 times
Mid-Infrared Ultrafast and CW OPOs
195
gain operating regime, pertinent to the large majority of OPO devices in all 2 operating regimes, for which Γ 2 2 (∆ k/2) . Under this condition, the general dependence of parametric gain on ∆ k, as defined through (6), can 2 be approximated by a sin2 (∆ k/2)/(∆ k/2) dependence [6], as depicted in Fig. 3. From the plots, the overriding advantage of QPM over BPM is clearly evident. Because of the flexibility provided by QPM, it is in principle possible to obtain parametric generation in any desired wavelength range throughout the material transparency by fabricating the correct poling period. Another highly important advantage of QPM is the ability to use NCPM geometry by choosing a propagation direction along a principal optical axis during the fabrication process, without any constraints imposed by birefringence as is the case in BPM. As noted earlier, this capability is generally imperative in the context of CW and ultrafast OPOs employing commonly available low- to moderate-power laser pump sources. These characteristics make QPM a highly promising route for development of CW and ultrafast OPOs, particularly in the mid-IR, where other birefringent materials cannot be readily used due to the simultaneous requirements highlighted earlier. To date, several quasi-phase-matched nonlinear materials have been successfully developed, with their main optical characteristics included in Table 2. Of these, periodically poled LiNbO3 (PPLN) has become the most widely established material, because of its relatively mature fabrication and poling technology, commercial availability in long interaction lengths (up to 60 mm), and large effective nonlinear coefficient (deff ∼ 16 pm/V) [18]. Another highly important class of new quasi-phase-matched materials is based on KTP and its arsenate isomorphs, where the application of successful poling methods has led to the availability of periodically poled KTP (PPKTP) and RTA (PPRTA), with progress continuing towards the development of PPKTA. Other promising materials include periodically poled LiTaO3 (PPLT) and KNbO3 (PPKNB). As can bee seen from Table 2, all these materials are viable candidates for mid-IR parametric generation, due to the broad transmission range to > 5 µm, short wavelength absorption cutoff < 500 nm, and substantially larger effective nonlinear coefficients than their birefringent counterparts. Combined with a NCPM capability, these characteristics allow the practical development of CW and ultrafast OPOs for the midIR by the use of commonly available near-IR pump sources, most notably the Ti:sapphire and the Nd:YAG laser, without the onset of pump absorption. By suitable design of the poling period, any desired wavelength within the 1–5 µm spectral range can be accessed under NCPM using such schemes. Wavelength tuning across the entire mid-IR band is generally attainable with a single crystal either through temperature tuning (e.g. in PPLN) when using a fixed-frequency pump source (e.g. Nd:YAG) or pump wavelength tuning (e.g. in PPKTP or PPRTA) with a tunable pump laser (e.g. Ti:sapphire), or by combination of both methods. In materials such as PPLN, where several
196
Majid Ebrahimzadeh
different poling periods can be incorporated onto a single crystal, grating tuning can also be used as an alternative method of obtaining coarse wavelength tuning over extended spectral bands.
5
Mid-Infrared Ultrafast OPOs
The ultrafast OPO operating regime corresponds to the deployment of modelocked laser pump sources, which provide picosecond and femtosecond pulses at high repetition rates of typically > 50 MHz. This is a particularly attractive operating regime for OPOs, because the high peak intensities available from the ultrashort pump pulses greatly aid the attainment of large nonlinear gains (see (7) and (8)) to overcome threshold, even in the singly resonant oscillator (SRO) configuration characterized by the highest operation threshold. Moreover, the low energy fluence associated with ultrashort pulses results in increased material damage tolerance, thereby enabling reliable operation of the OPO at high average powers using high-power input pump sources. On the other hand, unlike CW and pulsed nanosecond devices, operation of ultrafast OPOs is based on the principle of synchronous pumping. Because of the instantaneous nature of nonlinear polarization, optical gain in an OPO is available only in the presence of the pump pulse, during which macroscopic amplification of the parametric waves from noise to coherent output must take place. However, in the case of picosecond and femtosecond pulses, the temporal window of the pulse is too narrow to allow sufficient number of cavity round-trips for the build up of the parametric waves over the pump pulse length, even for practical OPO cavity lengths as short as a few millimeters. To overcome this difficulty, the OPO resonator length is matched to the length of the pump laser, so that the round-trip transit time in the OPO cavity is equal to the repetition period of the pump pulse train. In this way, the resonated parametric pulses experience amplification with consecutive coincidences with the input pump pulses as they make successive transits through the nonlinear crystal. In general, the technique is practical only at relatively high pulse repetition rates (> 50 MHz). At lower repetition frequencies, the required OPO cavity lengths for synchronous pumping become too long and cumbersome to be useful in practice. In general, ultrafast OPOs may be classified into either CW or pulsed (quasi-CW) synchronously pumped devices. In CW oscillators, the input pump radiation comprises a continuous train of ultrashort pulses, whereas in pulsed devices the pump consists of trains of pulses contained within a nanosecond or microsecond envelope. With regard to their operating characteristics, CW ultrafast OPOs may be treated as steady-state devices in the same way as CW OPOs, but with the peak pump pulse intensity determining the nonlinear gain. As such, the steady-state analysis of CW OPOs is similarly applicable to CW ultrafast OPOs by using the peak pulse intensity as the incident pump intensity. On the other hand, the operating dynamics of
Mid-Infrared Ultrafast and CW OPOs
197
pulsed ultrafast OPOs is analogous to nanosecond oscillators, where a transient analysis taking account of rise time effects is necessary to adequately describe the device behavior. In pulsed ultrafast OPOs, the nonlinear gain is similarly determined by the peak pulse intensity, but as in nanosecond OPOs rise time effects resulting from the finite duration of the pulse envelope lead to an additional loss mechanism. In either case, however, additional effects pertinent to the operation of ultrafast OPOs including temporal walkoff and group-velocity dispersion also have to be taken into account to fully describe the device behavior. In picosecond OPOs involving pulse durations of > 1 ps, such temporal effects can generally be ignored for practical crystal lengths of up to tens of millimeters. However, they become increasingly important in femtosecond OPOs involving pulses of 100 fs or shorter, as discussed in Sect. 5.2. For most practical applications, the CW synchronously pumped OPO is the most desired device configuration because the output consists of a truly continuous train of identical pulses. In pulsed oscillators, the amplitude, intensity and duration of the output pulses can vary across the pulse envelope, and the output does not generally constitute a truly repetitive pulse train. However, because of the significantly higher peak powers available from pulsed mode-locked than the equivalent CW mode-locked pump lasers, operation of ultrafast OPOs has in the past been more readily attainable under pulsed conditions, particularly in SRO configurations of practical interest. For this reason, most of the early ultrafast OPOs based on birefringent materials have been pulsed oscillators, pumped predominantly by the mode-locked and Q-switched (MLQS) Nd:YAG laser and its variations. In contrast, because of the lower peak intensities available from CW mode-locked pump lasers, early attempts in CW ultrafast OPOs were based on a doubly resonant oscillator (DRO) configuration characterized by low oscillation thresholds. However, the concomitant disadvantages of amplitude and spectral instability of the DRO approach limited the practical utility of such devices. With the availability of high-power CW mode-locked laser sources and novel nonlinear materials in recent years, operation of CW ultrafast OPOs in SRO configurations has become a practical reality, circumventing the need for pulsed pumping or the use of the DRO configuration. We therefore focus on a description of mid-IR ultrafast OPOs in the CW SRO configuration, as this represents the most practical and stable mode of operation for ultrafast picosecond and femtosecond OPOs. 5.1
Mid-Infrared Picosecond OPOs
The majority of CW picosecond OPOs demonstrated to date have been based on the mode-locked Nd:YAG laser or its variations as the pump source. For mid-IR generation, an early attempt was based on the classical nonlinear material AgGaS2 in CPM configuration, pumped by a flashlamp-pumped 100 ps Nd:YAG laser [21]. The operation of this device was, however, confined
198
Majid Ebrahimzadeh
to a single idler wavelength of 5.05 µm in the mid-IR. Moreover, to avoid thermal lensing in the AgGaS2 crystal, the pump light had to be mechanically chopped. An average mid-IR idler power of 6 mW was generated from this OPO for 625 mW of pump power. In the meantime, the introduction of KTP and its arsenate isomorphs provided a new class of materials for mid-IR picosecond pulse generation. By using a high-power 40 ps Nd:YLF laser at 1.053 µm and 76 MHz repetition rate to pump KTP in near-NCPM geometry, mid-IR average powers of up to 800 mW were generated over a wavelength range of 3.22–3.28 µm [22]. This device generated a total average power of 2.8 W in the signal and idler for 15 W of input pump power and the signal pulses were of ≈ 12 ps duration. A similar OPO was demonstrated using temporally compressed 2.2 ps pulses from a Nd:YAG laser at 1.064 µm to pump KTP in near-NCPM configuration [23]. This device provided a mid-IR idler coverage from 3.21 to 3.30 µm with an average output power of ≈ 100 mW at 75 MHz, for 4 W of input pump power. The near-IR signal power from this OPO was ≈ 250 mW with signal pulse durations of ≈ 2.8 ps. More recently, operation of a mid-IR picosecond OPO at unprecedented power levels was achieved by using a diode-pumped, CW mode-locked Nd:YVO4 oscillator-amplifier laser system at 1.064 µm to pump the crystal of KTA in a NCPM geometry [24]. With the pump radiation consisting of 7 ps pulses at ≈ 83 MHz repetition rate and an average power of 29 W, the OPO delivered as much as 6.4 W of idler output at 3.47 µm in the mid-IR. The combined signal and idler output power from this OPO was as high as 21 W, corresponding to an external efficiency in excess of 70 %. A major limitation of KTP and its arsenate isomorphs, when pumped by the Nd:YAG laser, is the restricted tuning capability under NCPM. For the attainment of extended mid-IR tuning, the mode-locked Ti:sapphire laser represents an attractive alternative, because the tuning capability of this laser allows wavelength tuning of the OPO under NCPM, without resort to angle (or temperature) phase matching. This also minimizes intracavity reflection losses caused by crystal rotation, thus allowing maximum efficiency to be maintained across the available tuning range. By using NCPM in KTP and a Ti:sapphire laser, tunable picosecond mid-IR pulses in the 2.3–2.9 µm spectral range were generated by tuning the pump laser over 720–853 nm [25]. Average mid-IR output powers of up to ≈ 200 mW and total powers of ≈ 700 mW were produced for 1.6 W of pump. The signal pulse durations from this OPO were ≈ 1.2 ps at ≈ 82 MHz repetition rate. For wavelength coverage further into the mid-IR, the arsenate isomorphs of KTP, namely KTA and RTA, represent excellent material candidates because of their extended transparency beyond that of KTP, as well as their NCPM capability under Ti:sapphire pump tuning. The use of NCPM in KTA has enabled the generation of mid-infrared picosecond pulses with average powers in excess of 100 mW at 81 MHz in pulses of ≈ 3-ps duration [26]. A total signal and idler output power of up to 400 mW could be obtained from the OPO. The
Mid-Infrared Ultrafast and CW OPOs
199
wavelength tuning range of this device was from 2.26 to 3.16 µm, limited by the tuning range of the pump laser, as shown in Fig. 4. Ultimately, however, the mid-IR wavelength tuning range available to picosecond OPOs based on KTP and its arsenates under NCPM is limited to ≈3.5 µm with Nd:YAG or Ti:sapphire pump lasers and extension of the tuning range beyond this limit would require practical picosecond laser sources at longer wavelengths. On the other hand, the advent of periodically poled materials has provided new opportunities for the development of CW picosecond OPOs with enhanced tuning capability further into the mid-IR and improved overall performance characteristics based on Nd:YAG and Ti:sapphire pumping. The phase-matching flexibility provided by QPM has permitted picosecond pulse generation across the transparency range of a number of periodically poled materials to beyond 5 µm under NCPM. At the same time, the large effective nonlinear coefficients (deff ≈ 8–16 pm/V) offered by QPM, combined with the availability of long interaction lengths (up to 60 mm in PPLN), have led to minimal power requirements, enabling the deployment of compact, lowto moderate-power diode-pumped solid-state laser pump sources. In particular, compact all-solid-state OPOs based on PPLN or PPRTA and pumped by mode-locked Ti:sapphire and Nd:YLF lasers have been shown to be versatile sources of picosecond pulses with tunability across the entire range of 1–6 µm, often from a single device [27,28,29]. These devices exhibit average pump power thresholds as low as 10 mW, and can provide total output powers of ≈ 400 mW in pulses of ≈ 1–5 ps, with > 10 mW of mid-IR idler power available beyond 5 µm. Figure 5a,b represents the mid-IR wavelength tuning range of picosecond OPOs based on PPRTA and PPLN pumped by Ti:sapphire and Nd:YLF lasers, respectively [27,28]. The configuration of PPLN OPO based on a semi-monolithic cavity design for enhanced power
k3
k2
k1
Output Wavelength (µm)
3.5
(a)
(b)
(i)
3.0 (ii)
2.5
idler
2.0 1.5
(ii)
signal
(i)
1.0 0.76
0.8
0.84
0.88
0.92
Pump Wavelength (µm)
Fig. 4. (a) Collinear phase-matching and (b) the mid-infrared tuning coverage of KTA picosecond OPO under collinear birefringent type II NCPM along the optical x-axis using Ti:sapphire pump tuning [26]. The solid curves (i) and (ii) represent the calculated tuning range based on two different sets of Sellmeier equations for the material
200
Majid Ebrahimzadeh
Output wavelength (µm)
6 Λ = 29 µm
5
30 µm
31 µm
idler 4
(a)
3
(b)
2
signal 1 0.82
0.84
0.86
0.88
0.90
0.92
0.94
Pump wavelength (µm)
Fig. 5. (a) The mid-infrared tuning range of PPRTA picosecond OPO under type I NCPM along the optical x-axis pumped with a Ti:sapphire laser [27]. Using a single grating period, Λ = 30 µm, an idler tuning range to 5 µm can be obtained under pump tuning at room temperature. The solid curves correspond to the calculated tuning range for three different grating periods, Λ = 29, 30, 31 µm using the appropriate Sellmeier data. (b) The tuning coverage of PPLN picosecond OPO with type-I NCPM along the optical x-axis, pumped by a Nd:YLF laser [28]. Under temperature tuning, mid-IR idler wavelengths out to 6.3 µm can be generated using an amplified laser pump source
extraction in the mid-IR and the corresponding tuning range [28] are shown in Fig. 6. Power scaling of CW picosecond OPOs to unprecedented levels has become possible by using flashlamp-pumped Nd lasers in combination with PPLN. By using a picosecond Nd:YLF pump laser, an average mid-IR output power of 2.4 W in pulses of ≈ 45 ps at ≈ 76 MHz repetition rate were generated in PPLN, with a mid-IR tuning range from ≈ 2.15 to ≈ 2.6 µm [30]. The OPO generated a total output power of ≈ 5 W for 7.4 W of input pump power. Substantial enhancements in the mid-infrared output power and photon conversion efficiency have been shown to be attainable by using intracavity difference-frequency-mixing techniques [31]. In this scheme the generated signal photons from the OPO are further difference-frequency-mixed in a second nonlinear crystal within the OPO cavity to provide additional idler photons. In this way, pump-to-idler photon conversion efficiencies in excess of 100 % can be achieved, yielding enhanced mid-IR output power from the OPO, as shown in Fig. 7. In a separate experiment, the use of 80-ps pulses at 76 MHz from a high-power Nd:YAG laser has permitted the generation of more than 4 W of mid-IR idler power from a PPLN picosecond OPO, with a tunable range over 2.2–2.8 µm [32]. With an average input pump power of 18 W, the OPO provided a combined signal and idler output power of up to 12 W at ≈ 65 % extraction efficiency. Operation of CW picosecond OPOs has recently also been extended to novel mode-locked semiconductor pump lasers operating at GHz repetition rates. By using an InGaAs oscillator-amplifier system delivering 7.8 ps pulses at 2.5 GHz, up to 78 mW of mid-IR idler power
Mid-Infrared Ultrafast and CW OPOs
201
Fig. 6. (a) Cavity configuration of the semi-monolithic PPLN OPO for the midIR. L: lens; M: mirror; P: prism. (b) Pump tuning range of the PPLN OPO in the mid-IR idler beam for different grating periods at a fixed temperature of 180 ◦ C. The solid curves are the calculated tuning range using the appropriate Sellmeier data for the material
over a tunable range of 1.99–2.35 µm was generated from a PPLN OPO for 900 mW of input pump power [33]. Figure 8 provides a summary of the performance characteristics of CW picosecond OPOs, including mid-IR devices, developed to date. 5.2
Mid-Infrared Femtosecond OPOs
Optical parametric oscillators operating in the femtosecond time domain represent the newest class of parametric devices. The high peak powers available from femtosecond pulses are particularly attractive for the attainment of large nonlinear gains in OPO devices. However, because of the short temporal duration (≈ 100 fs) and large spectral content (≈ 10 nm) of femtosecond pulses, additional effects such as group velocity dispersion, temporal walkoff, and spectral acceptance bandwidths play an important role in the operation of
8 7 6 5 4 3 2
Majid Ebrahimzadeh
(a)
OPO-DFM
OPO
1 0 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 incident pump power [W]
photon conversion efficiency [%]
idler power [W]
202
120
idler
(b)
100
OPO-DFM
inferred measured
80
idler
60
inferred measured
OPO
40 OPO-DFM
20 difference
inferred
0 0
2
4
6
8 10 12 14 16
incident pump power [W]
Fig. 7. (a) Idler output power and (b) photon conversion efficiency in a picosecond optical parametric oscillator with intracavity difference-frequency mixing [31]
theses devices. Group velocity dispersion often leads to pulse broadening, while temporal walkoff can degrade nonlinear gain or even modify the temporal characteristics of the output pulses. The large spectral bandwidth can also reduce gain as well as set a lower limit to the minimum attainable pulse duration from the OPO. The influence of temporal walkoff and spectral bandwidth can be minimized by using short crystal lengths of typically 1–2 mm, while the effects of group velocity dispersion can be overcome by the inclusion of dispersion compensation in the OPO cavity, as in conventional femtosecond lasers. The choice of nonlinear crystal for femtosecond OPOs, therefore, requires a trade-off with the crystal length. The need for long interaction length for maximum nonlinear gain, see (10),(11),(12), must be traded against the desire for large phase-matching bandwidth and low temporal walkoff. While crystal lengths of 1–2 mm are too short to provide sufficient gain in picosecond and CW OPOs, the large peak powers available with femtosecond pulses can adequately compensate for this shortfall in gain. The high in-crystal peak intensities (few GW/cm2 ) can also induce additional higher-order nonlinear effects such as self-phase-modulation in femtosecond OPOs. Such effects, which are not generally present in picosecond devices, often lead to spectral broadening and chirping of the output pulses and become more pronounced with longer interaction lengths. The spectral broadening due to self-phasemodulation can, however, be exploited for subsequent compression of output pulses. On the other hand, the use of short interaction lengths provides additional phase-matching flexibility in femtosecond OPOs, where alternative collinear or noncollinear CPM schemes can be used for wavelength generation into the mid-IR. These schemes are generally not available to CW and picosecond OPOs, where lower pumping intensities and longer interaction lengths are involved.
Mid-Infrared Ultrafast and CW OPOs
203
KTA (7 ps, 83 MHz)
20.0
PPLN (50 ps, 75 MHz)
10.0 PPLN (45 ps, 75 MHz)
5.0
KTP (12 ps, 75 MHz) LBO (22 ps, 75 MHz)
Average Output Power (Watts)
1.0
CTA (1 ps, 80 MHz)
Mid-Infrared KTP (1 ps, 80 MHz) LBO (22 ps, 75 MHz)
0.5
PPLN (4 ps, 120 MHz) KTA (1-3 ps, 80 MHz) LBO (1-2 ps, 80 MHz) LBO (15 ps, 75 MHz)
LBO (1-2 ps, 100 MHz)
PPRTA (1 ps, 80 MHz) PPLN (0.5 ps, 322 MHz) PPLN (1 ps, 75 MHz)
AgGaS2 (50-80 ps, 75 MHz) LBO (1 ps, 80 MHz)
0.1
LBO (1-2 ps, 125 MHz)
PPLN (8 ps, 2.5 GHz)
KTP (1-2 ps, 125 MHz)
0.02
AgGaS2 (50-80 ps, 75 MHz)
PPLN (4 ps, 120 MHz)
0 0.2
1.0
2.0
3.0
4.0
5.0
6.0
7.0
Spectral Coverage (µm)
Fig. 8. Survey of the performance characteristics of several CW picosecond OPOs demonstrated to date. The pump sources have been based primarily on the modelocked neodymium or the Ti:sapphire laser. The average output powers represent the maximum combined power in the signal and idler beams. The indicated tuning limits correspond to the potential tuning range available to the particular crystal in the given phase-matching geometry and pumping configuration, although the experimental tuning range may have been limited by the available mirrors and crystal coatings. The pulse durations correspond to the measured signal or idler pulse width within the tuning range
The first report of a CW femtosecond OPO was in a crystal of KTP pumped by 170-fs pulses from a mode-locked dye laser at 620 nm [34]. To access the necessary peak pumping intensities, the KTP was pumped at the intracavity focus of the dye laser in a noncollinear CPM geometry. This device produced 220 fs signal pulses at milliwatt average power levels in the nearinfrared. The approach was subsequently extended to an externally pumped oscillator where increased output powers of up to 30 mW were generated [35]. The availability of the mode-locked Ti:sapphire laser soon after provided a new source capable of providing femtosecond pulses at substantially higher
8.0
204
Majid Ebrahimzadeh
powers. This laser has since become the primary pump source for femtosecond OPOs, enabling the development of a KTP-based devices capable of producing total average output powers of up to 750 mW at wavelength < 2 µm in the near-IR using noncollinear CPM or collinear NCPM schemes [36,37,38]. Pulse durations of < 100 fs at repetition rates of 75–85 MHz are routinely available from these devices. For mid-IR pulse generation, the noncollinear CPM scheme was soon extended to other KTP-based OPOs [39], as well as to KTA [40,41], CTA [42,43], RTA [44], and KNB [45], providing femtosecond pulses into the 2–5 µm spectral range using pump and angle tuning schemes. Total average powers of hundreds of milliwatts and mid-IR output powers of tens of milliwatts in 100–200 fs pulses have been obtained from these devices. Figure 9 shows the mid-IR tuning coverage of a Ti:sapphire-pumped femtosecond OPO based on KTA in the noncollinear CPM configuration [41]. By using the NCPM scheme in combination with Ti:sapphire pump tuning, operation of a femtosecond OPO based on RTA has also been demonstrated with power thresholds as low as 50 mW, providing mid-IR pulses in the 2–3 µm spectral range at 50–100 mW of average power [46]. More recently, the introduction of periodically poled nonlinear materials has led to further advances in femtosecond OPOs. Devices based on PPLN, PPRTA, and PPKTP have been shown to be highly versatile sources of femtosecond pulses, offering minimum pump thresholds, high output powers, and vast spectral coverage from a single device. Operation of femtosecond OPOs based on periodically poled materials has been demonstrated over a wide spectral range from 1 to 6.8 µm using noncollinear CPM or collinear NCPM schemes combined with temperature, grating, or angle-tuning [47,48,49,50]. Because of the large nonlinear gains available, these oscillators exhibit pump
(a)
z
(b)
s2 θ3
s1
k3
∆θ 2
ρ
∆θ 1
∆θ k
x
k2
k1
Fig. 9. (a) Noncollinear phase-matching. S and k represent the Poynting vector and the wavevector, respectively. (b) The mid-infrared tuning coverage of KTA femtosecond OPO under noncollinear type-II birefringent CPM in the optical xz -plane with angle tuning [41]. The solid curves represent the calculated tuning range based on appropriate Sellmeier equations for the material for two different Ti:sapphire pump wavelengths
Mid-Infrared Ultrafast and CW OPOs
205
PPLN PPLN
55 44
Wavelength (µm)
Wavelength (µm)
power thresholds typically well below 100 mW, enabling the use of all-solidstate Ti:sapphire lasers as the pump source [47,49]. These devices can readily provide practical powers in excess of 100 mW in the 1–4 µm range, with milliwatt level output available in the difficult spectral regions beyond 5 µm. Output pulse durations of 100–200 fs at ≈ 80 MHz repetition rate are typically available. Because of the large nonlinear gain bandwidth of periodically poled crystals, combined with the short interaction lengths used in femtosecond OPOs, devices based on such materials have been shown to be particularly flexible in providing extensive wavelength coverage only through cavity length tuning of the OPO [48,49,50]. This provides a highly convenient method for wavelength tuning and without the need for pump, angle, grating, or temperature tuning. This tuning mechanism occurs because the cavity length detuning introduces a loss at the signal wavelength by reducing the synchronism between the pump and signal pulses. To maintain synchronism and optimize gain, the signal shifts to a more favorable wavelength with a group velocity that satisfies a constant round-trip time. This cavity length tuning, which was observed in the first demonstration of a femtosecond OPO [34], is a useful mechanism for tuning the output wavelength, often by as much as 50 nm in birefringent crystals. In periodically poled materials, the large phase-matching bandwidths can provide cavity length tuning over hundreds of nanometers, limited by the bandwidth of OPO mirrors. The large phase-matching bandwidth of PPLN and PPRTA and the correspond-
1
(a)
33 sinc2('kl/2) 0
22 11 19.5
PPRTA
55 44
1
(b)
33 sinc2('kl/2)
22
0
11 20 20.0
20.5
21 21.0
21.5
22 22.0
Grating period (µm)
22.5
23 23.0
28 28
29 30 31 29 30 31 Grating period (µm)
Fig. 10. Parametric gain bandwidth and cavity length tuning in Ti:sapphirepumped femtosecond OPOs based on (a) PPLN and (b) PPRTA. Phase-matching diagrams representing the variation of normalized gain coefficient with the phasemismatch, ∆ k, are shown as shaded areas [49]. The darker shaded areas, corresponding to regions of significant nonlinear gain, indicate the wide phase-matching bandwidths available in these materials. Broadband wavelength tuning, represented by the experimental data, is achieved for a given grating period at a fixed pump wavelength by simply adjusting the OPO cavity length. The pump wavelengths corresponding to the plots in (a) and (b) are 803 nm and 830 nm, respectively
206
Majid Ebrahimzadeh
ing cavity length tuning of femtosecond OPOs based on these materials are shown in Fig. 10a,b, respectively. An alternative approach to mid-IR femtosecond pulse generation has been the use of a cascaded, two-stage pumping arrangement, where the output of a Ti:sapphire-pumped CTA OPO has been used as the pump for a second oscillator based on the classical nonlinear material AgGaSe2 [51]. The wavelength flexibility of the primary OPO provides a suitable pump wavelength above the absorption edge of the material, which avoids material absorption and at the same time facilitates the required phase-matching condition for mid-IR generation. Using this technique, femtosecond pulses in the 4–8 µm spectral range with average powers of up to 35 mW and pulse durations of 300–640 fs have been obtained at 82 MHz repetition rate. Successful implementation of this technique has, however, necessitated the use of high-power 0.9 KTP (75 fs, 90 MHz)
0.8 0.7
Mid-Infrared
0.6
Average Output Power (Watts)
LBO (40 fs, 80 MHz)
0.5
RTA (58 fs, 80 MHz)
0.4
KNB (60 fs, 75 MHz) CTA (56 fs, 75 MHz) PPLN (60 fs, 81 MHz)
0.3
PPRTA (115 fs, 84 MHz) KTP (62 fs, 76 MHz)
0.2
KTA (85 fs, 100 MHz) PPLN (140 fs, 85 MHz)
BBO (13 fs, 80 MHz)
0.1
AgGaSe2 (230 fs, 82 MHz)
0.08 PPLN (150 fs, 84 MHz)
0.06 0.04 KTP (175 fs, 76 MHz)
0.02 0 0.2
1.0
2.0
3.0
4.0
5.0
6.0
7.0
8.0
Spectral Coverage (µm)
Fig. 11. Summary of the performance characteristics of Ti:sapphire-pumped CW femtosecond OPOs demonstrated to date. The indicated tuning limits correspond to the potential tuning range available to the particular crystal in the given phasematching geometry and pumping configuration, although the experimental tuning range may have been limited by the available mirrors and crystal coatings. The output powers on the vertical scale correspond to the maximum combined signal and idler power generated within the demonstrated tuning range. The pulse durations correspond to the measured signal or idler pulse width within the tuning range
Mid-Infrared Ultrafast and CW OPOs
207
input laser pump sources. Figure 11 provides a summary of the performance characteristics of several Ti:sapphire-pumped CW femtosecond OPOs, including mid-IR devices, demonstrated to date.
6
Mid-Infrared Continuous-Wave OPOs
Of the different types of OPO devices demonstrated to date, practical development of OPOs in the CW regime has been consistently more difficult than pulsed and synchronously pumped devices because of the substantially lower nonlinear gains available under CW pumping. Indeed, while the attainment of operation threshold in the simplest and most practical cavity configuration – the SRO – has been readily attainable in nanosecond pulsed and ultrafast OPOs, in CW operation it has been beyond the reach of existing birefringent materials and available CW laser sources. To overcome the high CW SRO threshold, a variety of techniques have been deployed for CW OPOs based on alternative resonance configurations [6]. These include the use of the traditional DRO configuration, as well other novel resonance schemes such intracavity SRO (IC-SRO), pump-enhanced SRO (PE-SRO), and triply resonant oscillator (TRO). These techniques have successfully brought about major reductions in CW OPO thresholds, from tens of watts in SROs to as low as a few milliwatts in TROs, thus enabling the use of a wide range of nonlinear materials and laser pump sources in CW OPO development. On the other hand, the use of such multiply-resonant cavities places stringent demands on the mechanical stability of the OPO as well as the frequency stability of the laser pump source [6]. Practical implementation of CW OPOs, therefore, generally requires active stabilization techniques for spectral control, tuning, and power stability and the use of stable single-frequency laser sources in many cases. The recent development of novel birefringent and periodically poled nonlinear materials, new innovations in resonance and pumping techniques, and the advent of stable, high-power solid-state laser pump sources have led to important breakthroughs in CW OPOs in the past few years. These developments have also had an important impact on the advancement of devices for the mid-IR spectral range at wavelengths > 2 µm. Because of the NCPM capability, moderate nonlinear optical coefficients, an extended transparency window to 5 µm, the birefringent material KTP and its arsenate isomorphs, KTA and RTA, have been shown to be promising candidates for mid-IR CW OPOs. Configured in IC-SRO cavities and pumped by Ti:sapphire lasers, devices based on KTP and KTA have been shown to be practical sources of CW mid-IR radiation, providing total output powers of up to 1.46 W, with as much as 840 mW of idler power available in the 2.4–2.9 µm spectral range [52,53]. In alternative TRO and PE-SRO resonance configurations, low-threshold operation of mid-IR CW OPOs has also been achieved with the use of semiconductor diode lasers as the pump source [54,55]. By using
208
Majid Ebrahimzadeh
KTP and RTA under NCPM and GaAlAs diode lasers at ≈ 800 nm, pump power thresholds < 100 mW and mid-IR wavelength tuning in the 2.1–2.7 µm range have been demonstrated through the tunability of the diode laser pump source. Because of a lack of significant temperature tuning in KTP and its arsenate analogs, wavelength tuning in CW OPOs based on these materials is generally achieved through static pump tuning while maintaining the NCPM condition. With the available laser pump sources based on CW Ti:sapphire, semiconductor, and Nd:YAG lasers, the potential mid-IR spectral coverage of CW OPOs based on the KTP family of crystals under NCPM conditions is limited to ≈ 3.5 µm. On the other hand, the most important recent advances in CW OPOs, with a major impact on mid-IR devices, have been brought about by the development of periodically poled materials. In particular, the advent of PPLN with high effective nonlinearity and long interaction lengths has brought the threshold of CW SROs within the reach of CW solid-state lasers and enabled the operation of these devices at unprecedented power levels and conversion efficiencies in simple external pumping schemes. Using a 50-mm long PPLN crystal pumped with a high-power diode-pumped Nd:YAG laser, midIR output powers of as much as 3.6 W have been generated from a CW SRO over a spectral range from 3.25 to 3.95 µm, for 13.5 W of input pump power [56]. The configuration of this OPO and the output power characteristics are shown in Figs. 12a and b, respectively. Wavelength tuning was achieved through temperature tuning or by using different grating periods incorporated onto the single crystal. Alternative tuning schemes include the use of PPLN with fanned gratings, where the grating period is progressively
Fig. 12. (a) Cavity configuration of a high-power mid-IR CW SRO based on 50 mm PPLN crystal in a simple external pumping arrangement [56]. (b) Pump depletion and idler output power as a function of input pump power at a mid-IR wavelength of 3.25 µm. The oscillation threshold is 3.6 W and a maximum idler output of ≈ 3.6 W is obtained for 13.5 W of pump power
Mid-Infrared Ultrafast and CW OPOs
209
varied across the crystal [57]. This can allow continuous long-range tuning of single-mode output over extensive spectral regions. With the advent of PPLN, the operation of CW SROs in external pumping configuration has also been extended to high-power semiconductor diode pump lasers [58]. Pumped by an InGaAs laser at 925 nm in a master oscillator-power amplifier configuration and a 38 mm PPLN crystal, an SRO operation threshold of 1.7 W and idler output powers of 480 mW were generated over a tuning range of 2.03–2.29 µm, for 2.5 W of pump power. Appropriate synchronization of pump tuning and cavity length scanning results in a wide, continuous, single-frequency tuning range. More recently, high-power fiber lasers have been successfully used to drive CW PPLN-based SROs [59]. Using an Yb-doped CW fiber laser tunable over 1.031–1.100 µm and delivering 8.3 W of pump power into a 40 mm PPLN crystal, mid-IR idler powers of up to 1.9 W over a spectral range of 2.98–3.7 µm have been generated, with a SRO power threshold at 3.5 W. At the same time, the use of intracavity pumping schemes in combination with PPLN have for the first time permitted CW SRO operation with minimal operation threshold based on commonly available, low-power, diodepumped solid-state lasers [60]. Using a Nd:YVO4 laser pumped by a 1 W diode laser, practical mid-IR output powers of 70 mW over a spectral range from 3.16–4.02 µm have been generated from an IC-SRO in a simple, compact, all-solid-state design, with a diode pump power threshold of only 310 mW. The cavity configuration and the tuning range of this device are shown in Figs. 13a and b. Operation of mid-IR CW OPOs based on PPLN has also been achieved in PE-SRO configurations. Pumped by a diode-pumped singlefrequency miniature Nd:YAG laser, 140 mW of idle power over the range 2.29– 2.96 µm has been obtained from a PE-SRO, for 800 mW of pump power. The device had an external pump power threshold of 250 mW and wavelength tuning was available by a combination of temperature and grating period tuning. More recently, operation of a mid-IR PPLN PE-SRO pumped by a CW single-frequency Ti:sapphire laser and tunable from 4.07 to 5.26 µm was also reported [61]. By using a twin-cavity arrangement, mode-hop-free tuning of the single-frequency idler over 10.8 GHz was demonstrated by fine tuning the pump laser over 12.3 GHz. The high optical nonlinearity of PPLN and availability in long interaction lengths has also permitted the development of PE-SRO devices pumped directly by single-stripe semiconductor diode lasers. Operation of a device based on a 50 mm PPLN crystal and pumped at ≈ 810 nm with a singlemode extended-cavity AlGaAs laser has been achieved with a power threshold of only around 25–30 mW [62]. This device could provide up to 4 mW of unidirectional idler power in mid-IR, with tuning coverage from 2.58 to 3.44 µm. The pump tuning behavior and power characteristics of this OPO are shown in Fig. 14a and b, respectively. Using alternative DRO configurations, similar CW OPOs based on PPLN have also been demonstrated by the use of solitary, single-stripe diode lasers [63,64]. These devices have been
210
Majid Ebrahimzadeh
Fig. 13. (a) Configuration of a low-pump-threshold CW IC-SRO based on a 50 mm PPLN crystal with a 1 W diode laser as the primary pump source [60]. (b) Wavelength coverage of the CW PPLN IC-SRO with temperature and grating tuning. The solid curves are the calculated tuning range based on appropriate Sellmeier relations for PPLN. The grating periods corresponding to the curves range from 28.5 µm at the lower end of the signal tuning range to 29.9 µm at the higher end of the signal tuning range (and vice versa over the idler tuning range)
shown to operate with pump powers of less than 20 mW and can provide practical mid-IR output powers of up to 5 mW over a spectral range from 2.2 to 3.7 µm. It is important to note that the potential tuning range available to all PPLN-based CW OPOs under Ti:sapphire, Nd:YAG, or direct diode laser pumping extends across a continuous range of ≈ 1.5–5 µm, limited by the increasing absorption in the material beyond ≈ 5 µm. By suitable choice of OPO mirror and crystal coatings, it is possible to access this entire tuning range with one device incorporating a single PPLN crystal.
Mid-Infrared Ultrafast and CW OPOs
211
Idler power (mW)
Wavelength (Pm)
Λ=22.0 µm
3.0 Λ=21.6 µm
2.5 1.2
(a)
3
0.8 (λp ≈ 810 nm)
2
(b)
0.6 0.4
1
Signal power (mW)
1.0 Λ=21.8 µm
3.5
0.2
1.1
0
1.0 806
808
810
812
814
Pump wavelength (nm)
816
30
40 50 60 Pump power (mW)
0.0
Fig. 14. (a) Pump tuning range of CW PE-SRO based on a 50 mm PPLN crystal pumped directly by an AlGaAs laser diode at a fixed temperature of 129 ◦ C for different grating periods. The mid-IR idler coverage is from 2.6 to 3.42 µm. The solid curves are the calculated tuning range based on appropriate Sellmeier relations for PPLN. (b) Output power in the signal (at 1.16 µm) and idler (at 2.68 µm) as a function of input diode pump power. The PE-SRO pump power threshold is ≈ 25 mW
At the present time substantial progress continues in the development of CW OPOs based on PPLN. These devices have now been developed to the point where they can provide widely tunable, stable, single-frequency coherent radiation at practical power levels in the mid-IR. However, effective frequency control and power stabilization of PPLN devices, particularly under high-intensity pumping regimes in SRO configurations, is impeded by the photorefractive effect, thermal phase-mismatching and green-induced infrared absorption, and so practical operation of these devices requires careful control of these parameters. In this context, alternative periodically poled materials, particularly phosphates and arsenates of KTP, represent attractive material candidates for mid-IR CW OPOs, because of the absence of such detrimental effects, an equally extended transparency range to > 5 µm, and lower coersive fields for poling. However, the shorter available interaction lengths (typically < 20 mm) and lower effective nonlinear coefficients lead to higher operation thresholds than in equivalent PPLN devices. This precludes SRO operation in external pumping configurations even with a high-power multiwatt laser pump source, and so other approaches based on the DRO, PE-SRO and IC-SRO are the most viable route to the development of mid-IR CW OPOs based on these materials [65,66]. At the present time, the KTP family of periodically poled materials also offer more limited tuning flexibility than PPLN, because of the lack of significant temperature tuning and the difficulty in incorporating several different grating periods onto a single crystal due to limited apertures. However, the continuing advances in poling and fabrication technology are expected to pave the way for the practical development of stable and widely tunable CW OPOs for the mid-IR based on these materials. Figure 15 provides a summary of the spectral coverage and power
212
Majid Ebrahimzadeh 5 PPLN
4 3
CW Output Power (Watts)
2
KTA
1
KTP
Mid-Infrared
0.8 LBO
0.6
KTP, PPKTP
PPLN
0.4 0.2 0.1
LBO
PPRTA
PPLT
MgO: LiNbO3
PPKTP
0.08
PPLN
0.06 PPLT
0.04
PPLN
0.02 0 0.2
1.0
2.0
3.0
4.0
5.0
6.0
Spectral Coverage (µm)
Fig. 15. Survey of a number of CW OPOs demonstrated to date. The indicated tuning limits correspond to the potential tuning range available to the particular crystal in the given phase-matching geometry and pumping configuration, although the experimental tuning range may have been limited by the available mirrors and crystal coatings. The output powers on the vertical scale correspond to the maximum combined signal and idler power generated within the demonstrated tuning range
performance of several CW OPOs, including mid-IR devices, developed to date.
7
Summary
This chapter has provided a description of a particular class of solid-state laser technology for the mid-IR based on OPOs. The treatment has included a summary of the basic principles of parametric generation, with emphasis on mid-IR generation, and a survey of the most recent developments in OPO devices operating in the high-repetition-rate ultrafast as well as pure CW regime. The current status of ultrafast OPO technology permits access to mid-IR wavelengths to ≈ 6 µm in picosecond and up to ≈ 8 µm in femtosecond operation, using a variety of pumping configurations and phase-matching schemes. In picosecond operation, mid-IR average powers in excess of 6 W and pulse durations from typically < 1 to > 50 ps have been generated from OPO devices. The operation of picosecond OPOs has also been extended to diode-pumped all-solid-state architectures and even direct diode-pumping
Mid-Infrared Ultrafast and CW OPOs
213
using novel semiconductor laser sources. In the femtosecond regime, mid-IR average output powers of up to a few hundred milliwatts can be obtained in pulse durations from typically < 100 to > 200 fs. In CW operation, OPOs have been shown to be capable of providing mid-IR output powers of up to ≈ 4 W and wavelength coverage to > 5 µm. At the same time, innovations in pumping schemes, novel cavity designs and resonance configurations have led to substantial reductions in power thresholds, bringing the practical operation of CW OPOs within the reach of diode-pumped solid-state lasers as well as semiconductor and fiber pump lasers. A key element in the rapid advancement of ultrafast and CW OPOs into the mid-IR has been the recent development of new nonlinear materials, replacing the more traditional nonlinear crystals. In particular, the advent of PPLN, PPRTA and other periodically poled materials, as well as birefringent materials such as KTP and its arsenate isomorphs have greatly aided the recent advances in this area. On the other hand, the development of practical ultrafast and CW OPOs for mid-IR wavelengths beyond 5 µm remains difficult due to the absorption cutoff in the exiting materials, and further progress in this area is critically dependent on new advances in material science. A particularly important route will be the advancement of QPM technology to the classical nonlinear crystals with extended transparency well beyond 5 µm. This will provide yet another new class of periodically poled materials with further enhanced nonlinearities and flexible NCPM capability for wavelength generation into the 5–20 µm spectral range. Other recently developed mid-IR materials such as LiInS2 , which exhibit a short-wavelength cutoff below ≈ 500 nm, offer a promising route for femtosecond pulse generation in the 5–10 µm range using Ti:sapphire pump lasers. Another important factor will be the advancement of practical tunable CW and mode-locked laser sources for wavelengths significantly longer than 1 µm (e.g. Cr:YAG, Cr:ZnSe, etc.). This would allow the development of CW and ultrafast midIR OPOs based on a number of existing classical materials (e.g. ZnGeP2 , AgGaSe2 , etc.) in birefringent phase-matching, by avoiding pump absorption as well as enabling flexible NCPM schemes to be used. In combination with temperature- or pump-tuning, such an approach could provide tunable generation at wavelengths longer than 5 µm. The use of longer pump wavelengths will also enable the attainment of higher output power efficiencies in the mid-IR by reducing the quantum defect between the pump and the generated photons. Other potential approaches include the use of cascaded, two-stage pumping arrangements using two OPOs in series. Here, the tunable output in a suitable wavelength range from the first OPO would be used to provide convenient phase-matching in a second OPO based on a classical material to obtain wavelength extension beyond 5 µm. While such a technique has already been demonstrated using high-power nanosecond and femtosecond pump sources, its extension to picosecond and CW OPOs has not yet been demonstrated due to the substantially lower peak intensities available.
214
Majid Ebrahimzadeh
To make such an approach practicable with moderate pumping intensities in the CW, picosecond, and femtosecond regime, a promising route would be the deployment of intracavity pumping schemes, where the second OPO crystal is placed internal to the cavity of the first OPO to access higher circulating pumping intensities. Other emerging technologies for mid-IR OPOs include integrated waveguide devices based on conventional nonlinear crystals as well as isotropic semiconductors based on GaAs technology using novel phase-matching techniques. The potential for the advancement of CW and ultrafast OPOs further into the mid-IR therefore remains strong and the deployment of the different techniques and technologies highlighted above will continue to pave the way for further progress in this area.
References 1. J. A. Giordmaine, R. C. Miller: Tunable coherent parametric oscillation in LiNbO3 at optical frequencies, Phys. Rev. Lett. 14, 973–976 (1965) 179 2. V. G. Dimitriev, G. G. Gurzadyan, D. N. Nikogosyan: Handbook of Nonlinear Optical Crystals (Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg 1991) 181, 189, 192 3. M. Ebrahimzadeh, A. I. Ferguson: Novel nonlinear crystals, In Principles and Applications of Nonlinear Optical Materials (Chapman and Hall, London 1993) pp. 99–142 181 4. C. L. Tang: Nonlinear optics, In Handbook of Optics (McGraw-Hill, New York 1995) pp. 38.3–38.26 181 5. R. L. Sutherland: Handbook of Nonlinear Optics (Marcel Dekker, New York 1996) 181, 188 6. M. Ebrahimzadeh, M. H. Dunn: Optical parametric oscillators, In Handbook of Optics, Vol. 4 (Optical Society of America, Washington, D. C. 2000) 181, 188, 195, 207 7. S. E. Harris: Tunable optical parametric oscillators, Proc. IEEE 57, 2096–2113 (1969) 181, 188 8. R. L. Byer: Optical parametric oscillators, In H. Rabin and C. L. Tang (Eds.), Treatise in Quantum Electronics (Academic Press, New York 1973) pp. 587–702 181, 188 9. R. G. Smith: Optical parametric oscillators, In A. K. Levine and A. J. DeMaria (Eds.), Lasers (Marcel Dekker, New York 1976) pp. 189–307 181, 184, 188 10. M. H. Dunn, M. Ebrahimzadeh: Parametric generation of tunable light from continuous-wave to femtosecond pulses, Science 286, 1513–1517 (1999) 181 11. R. W. Boyd: Nonlinear Optics (Academic Press, New York 1992) 181, 184 12. J. A. Armstrong, N. Bloembergen, J. Ducuing, P. S. Pershan: Interaction between light waves in a nonlinear dielectric, Phys. Rev. 127, 1918–1939 (1962) 181, 184, 193 13. W. H. Louisell, A. Yariv, A. E. Siegman: Quantum fluctuations and noise in parametric processes, Phys. Rev. 124, 1646 (1961) 183 14. Y. R. Shen: Principles of Nonlinear Optics (Wiley, New York 1984) 183, 184 15. R. Danielius, A. Piskarskas, A. Stabinis, G. P. Banfi, P. Di Trapani, R. Righini: Traveling-wave parametric generation of widely tunable, highly coherent femtosecond light pulses, J. Opt. Soc. Am. B 10, 2222–2231 (1995) 183, 186
Mid-Infrared Ultrafast and CW OPOs
215
16. R. C. Miller: Optical second harmonic generation in piezoelectric crystals, Appl. Phys. Lett. 5, 17 (1964) 187 17. M. Ebrahimzadeh, A. J. Henderson, M. H. Dunn: An excimer-pumped β-BaB2 O4 optical parametric oscillator tunable from 354 nm to 2.370 µm, IEEE J. Quantum Electron. 26, 1241–1252 (1990) 190 18. L. E. Myers, R. C. Eckardt, M. M. Fejer, R. L. Byer, W. R. Bosenberg, J. W. Pierce: Quasi-phase-matched optical parametric oscillators in bulk periodically poled LiNbO3 , J. Opt. Soc. Am. B 12, 2102–2116 (1995) 193, 195 19. J. A. Giordmaine: Mixing of light beams in crystals, Phys. Rev. Lett. 8, 19–20 (1962) 193 20. P. D. Maker, R. W. Terhune, M. Nissenoff, C. M. Savage: Effects of dispersion and focusing on the production of optical harmonics, Phys. Rev. Lett. 8, 21–22 (1962) 193 21. E. C. Cheung, K. Koch, G. T. Moore: Silver thiagallate, singly-resonant optical parametric oscillator pumped by a continuous-wave mode-locked YAG laser, Opt. Lett. 19, 631 (1994) 197 22. Ch. Grasser, D. Wang, R. Beigang, R. Wallenstein: Singly resonant optical parametric oscillator of KTiOPO4 synchronously pumped by the radiation from a continuous-wave mode-locked Nd:YLF laser, J. Opt. Soc. Am. B 10, 2218– 2221 (1993) 198 23. J. Chung, A. E. Siegman: Singly resonant continuous-wave mode-locked KTiOPO4 optical parametric oscillator pumped by a Nd:YAG laser, J. Opt. Soc. Am. B 10, 2201–2210 (1993) 198 24. B. Ruffing, A. Nebel, R. Wallenstein: All-solid-state CW mode-locked picosecond KTiOAsO4 (KTA) optical parametric oscillator, Appl. Phys. B 67, 537 (1998) 198 25. A. Nebel, C. Fallnich, R. Beigang, R. Wallenstein: Noncritically phase-matched continuous-wave mode-locked singly resonant optical parametric oscillator synchronously pumped by a Ti:sapphire laser, J. Opt. Soc. Am. B 10, 2195–2200 (1993) 198 26. S. French, M. Ebrahimzadeh, A. Miller: High-power, high-repetiton-rate picosecond optical parametric oscillator for the near- to mid-infrared, Opt. Lett. 21, 131–133 (1996) 193, 198, 199 27. G. T. Kennedy, D. T. Reid, A. Miller, M. Ebrahimzadeh, H. Karlsson, G. Arvidsson, F. Laurell: Broadly tunable mid-infdrared picosecond optical parametric oscillator based on periodically poled RbTiOAsO4 , Opt. Lett. 23, 503–505 (1998) 199, 200 28. L. Lefort, K. Peuch, G. W. Ross, Y. P. Svirko, D. C. Hanna: Optical parametric oscillation out to 6.3 µm in periodically poled lithium niobate under strong idler absorption, Appl. Phys. Lett. 73, 1610–1612 (1998) 199, 200 29. M. Ebrahimzadeh, P. J. Phillips, S. Das: Low-threshold, mid-infrared optical parametric oscillation in periodically poled LiNbO3 synchronously pumped by a Ti:sapphire laser, Appl. Phys. B 72, 793 (2001) 199 30. K. Finsterbusch, R. Urschel, H. Zakarias: Fourier-transform-limited, high-power picosecond optical parametric oscillator based on periodically poled lithium niobate, Appl. Phys. B 70, 741–746 (2000) 200 31. M. E. Dearborn, K. Koch, G. T. Moore, J. C. Diels: Greater than 100% photonconversion efficiency from an optical parametric oscillator with intracavity difference-frequency mixing, Opt. Lett. 23, 759–761 (1998) 200, 202
216
Majid Ebrahimzadeh
32. C. W. Hoyt, M. Sheik-Bahae, M. Ebrahimzadeh: High-power picosecond optical parametric oscillator based on periodically poled lithium niobate, Opt. Lett. 27, 1543 (2002) 200 33. A. Robertson, M. E. Klein, M. A. Tremont, K.-J. Boller, R. Wallenstein: 2.5-GHz repetition-rate singly resonant optical parametric oscillator synchronously pumped by a mode-locked diode oscillator amplifier system, Opt. Lett. 25, 657 (2000) 201 34. D. C. Edelstein, E. S. Wachman, C. L. Tang: Broadly tunable high repetition rate femtosecond optical parametric oscillator, Appl. Phys. Lett. 54, 1728–1730 (1989) 203, 205 35. G. Mak, Q. Fu, H. M. van Driel: Externally pumped high repetition rate femtosecond infrared optical parametric oscillator, Appl. Phys. Lett. 60, 542–544 (1992) 203 36. Q. Fu, G. Mak, H. M. van Driel: High-power, 62 fs infrared optical parametric oscillator synchronously pumped by a 76-MHz Ti:sapphire laser, Opt. Lett. 17, 1006–1008 (1992) 204 37. W. S. Pelouch, P. E. Powers, C. L. Tang: Ti:sapphire-pumped, high-repetitionrate femtosecond optical parametric oscillator, Opt. Lett. 17, 1070–1072 (1992) 204 38. J. M. Dudley, D. T. Reid, M. Ebrahimzadeh, W. Sibbett: Characteristics of a noncritically phase-matched Ti:sapphire-pumped femtosecond optical parametric oscillator, Opt. Commun. 104, 419–430 (1994) 204 39. S. W. McCahon, S. A. Anson, D.-J. Jang, T. F. Boggess: Generation of 3–4 mm femtosecond pulses from a synchronously pumped, critically phase-matched KTiOPO4 optical parametric oscillator, Opt. Lett. 22, 2309–2311 (1995) 204 40. P. E. Powers, S. Ramakrishna, C. L. Tang, L. K. Cheng: Optical parametric oscillation with KTiOAsO4 , Opt. Lett. 18, 1171–1173 (1993) 204 41. D. T. Reid, C. McGowan, M. Ebrahimzadeh, W. Sibbett: Characterization and modeling of a noncollinearly phase-matched femtosecond optical parametric oscillator based on KTA and operating beyond 4 µm, IEEE J. Quantum Electron. 33, 1–9 (1997) 204 42. P. E. Powers, C. L. Tang, L. K. Cheng: High-repetition-rate femtosecond optical parametric oscillator based on CsTiOAsO4 , Opt. Lett. 19, 37–39 (1994) 204 43. G. R. Holtom, R. A. Crowell, L. K. Cheng: Femtosecond mid-infrared optical parametric oscillator based on CsTiOAsO4 , Opt. Lett. 20, 1880–1882 (1995) 204 44. P. E. Powers, C. L. Tang, L. K. Cheng: High-repetition-rate femtosecond optical parametric oscillator based on RbTiOAsO4 , Opt. Lett. 19, 1439–1441 (1994) 204 45. D. E. Spence, S. Wielandy, C. L. Tang: High average power, high repetition rate femtosecond pulse generation in the 1–5 µm region using an optical parametric oscillator, Appl. Phys. Lett. 68, 452–454 (1996) 204 46. D. T. Reid, M. Ebrahimzadeh, W. Sibbett: Noncritically phase-matched Ti:sapphire-pumped femtosecond optical parametric oscillator based on RbTiOAsO4 , Opt. Lett. 20, 55–57 (1995) 204 47. K. C. Burr, C. L Tang, M. A. Arbore, M. M. Fejer: Boradly tunable mid-infrared femtosecond optical parametric oscillator using all-solid-state-pumped periodically poled lithium niobate, Opt. Lett. 22, 1458–1460 (1997) 204, 205
Mid-Infrared Ultrafast and CW OPOs
217
48. D. T. Reid, Z. Penman, M. Ebrahimzadeh, W. Sibbett, H. Karlsson, F. Laurell: Broadly tunable infrared femtosecond optical parametric oscillator based on periodically poled RbTiOAsO4 , Opt. Lett. 22, 1397–1399 (1997) 204, 205 49. D. T. Reid, G. T. Kennedy, A. Miller, W. Sibbett, M. Ebrahimzadeh: Widely tunable near- to mid-infrared femtosecond and picosecond optical parametric oscillators using periodically poled LiNbO3 and RbTiOAsO4 , IEEE J. Sel. Top. Quantum Electron. 4, 238–248 (1998) 204, 205 50. P. Loza-Alvarez, C. T. A. Brown, D. T. Reid, W. Sibbett, M. Missey: Highrepetition-rate ultrashort-pulse optical parametric oscillator continuously tunable from 2.8 to 6.8 µm, Opt. Lett. 24, 1523–1525 (1999) 204, 205 51. S. Marzenell, R. Beigang, R. Wallenstein: Synchronously pumped femtosecond optical parametric oscillator based on AgGaSe2 tunable from 2 µm to 8 µm, Appl. Phys. B 69, 423–428 (1999) 206 52. F. G. Colville, M. H. Dunn, M. Ebrahimzadeh: Continuous-wave, singly resonant intracavity parametric oscillator, Opt. Lett. 22, 75–79 (1997) 207 53. T. J. Edwards, G. A. Turnbull, M. H. Dunn, M. Ebrahimzadeh, F. G. Colville: High-power, continuous-wave, singly resonant intracavity optical parametric oscillator, Appl. Phys. Lett. 72, 1527–1529 (1998) 207 54. M. Scheidt, B. Beier, R. Knappe, K.-J. Boller, R. Wallenstein: Diode-laserpumped continuous-wave KTP optical parametric oscillator, J. Opt. Soc. Am. B 12, 2087–2094 (1995) 207 55. M. Scheidt, B. Beier, K.-J. Boller, R. Wallenstein: Frequency-stable operation of a diode-pumped continuous-wave RbTiOAsO4 optical parametric oscillator, Opt. Lett. 22, 1287–1289 (1997) 207 56. W. R. Bosenberg, A. Drobshoff, J. I. Alexander, L. E. Myers, R. L. Byer: 93% pump depletion, 3.5 W continuous-wave, singly resonant optical parametric oscillator, Opt. Lett. 21, 1336–1338 (1996) 208 57. P. E. Powers, T. J. Kulp, S. E. Bisson: Continuous tuning of a continuous-wave periodically poled lithium niobate optical parametric oscillator by use of a fanout grating design, Opt. Lett. 23, 159–161 (1998) 209 58. M. E. Klein, D. H. Lee, J.-P. Meyn, K.-J. Boller, R. Wallenstein: Singly resonant continuous-wave optical parametric oscillator pumped by a diode laser, Opt. Lett. 24, 1142–1144 (1999) 209 59. P. Gross, M. E. Klein, T. Walde, K.-J. Boller, M. Auerbach, P. Wessels, C. Fallnich: Fiber-laser-pumped continuous-wave singly-resonant optical parametric oscillator, Opt. Lett. 27, 418–420 (2002) 209 60. D. J. M. Stothard, M. Ebrahimzadeh, M. H. Dunn: Low-pump-threshold, continuous-wave, singly resonant optical parametric oscillator, Opt. Lett. 23, 1895–1897 (1998) 209, 210 61. G. A. Turnbull, D. McGloin, I. D. Lindsay, M. Ebrahimzadeh, M. H. Dunn: Extended mode-hop-free tuning using a dual-cavity, pump-enhanced optical parametric oscillator, Opt. Lett. 25, 341–343 (2000) 209 62. I. D. Lindsay, C. Petridis, M. H. Dunn, M. Ebrahimzadeh: Continuous-wave pump-enhanced singly-resonant optical parametric oscillator pumped by an external-cavity diode laser, Appl. Phys. Lett. 78, 871–873 (2001) 209 63. I. D. Lindsay, G. A. Turnbull, M. H. Dunn, M. Ebrahimzadeh: Doubly-resonant continuous-wave optical parametric oscillator pumped by a single-mode laser diode, Opt. Lett. 23, 1889–1891 (1998) 209
218
Majid Ebrahimzadeh
64. A. J. Henderson, P. M. Roper, L. A. Borschowa, R. D. Mead: Stable, continuously tunable operation of a diode-pumped doubly resonant optical parametric oscillator, Opt. Lett. 25, 1264–1266 (2000) 209 65. T. J. Edwards, G. A. Turnbull, M. H. Dunn, M. Ebrahimzadeh: Continuouswave, singly-resonant optical parametric oscillator based on periodically poled RbTiOAsO4 , Opt. Lett. 23, 837–839 (1998) 211 66. T. J. Edwards, G. A. Turnbull, M. H. Dunn, M. Ebrahimzadeh: Continuouswave, singly-resonant optical parametric oscillator based on periodically poled KTiOPO4 , Opt. Exp. 6, 58–63 (2000) 211 67. D. T. Reid, M. Ebrahimzadeh, W. Sibbett: Efficient femtosecond pulse generation in the visible in a frequency-doubled optical parametric oscillator based on RbTiOAsO4 , J. Opt. Soc. Am. B 12, 1157–1163 (1995) 193
Index
angular acceptance bandwidth, 189 coherence length, 193 coupled-wave equations, 182 critical phase matching (CPM), 189 degeneracy factor, 184 gain factor, 183 idler, 181 KNbO3 , 193 non-critical phase-matching (NCPM), 189 nonlinear figure of merit (FOM), 186 optical optical 185 optical 185 optical
parametic amplifier (OPA), 185 parametric generator (OPG),
parametric fluorescence, 183 parametric luminescence, 183 parametric noise, 183 periodic poling, 193 phase matching, 184 – critical, 189 – non-critical, 189 phase mismatch – parameter, 182 PP KTA, 192 PP KTP, 192–195 PP RTA, 192 PPLN, 191–212 quasi-phase-matched material (QPM), 193 signal, 181 spectral acceptance – bandwidth, 189 synchronous pumping, 196
parametric oscillator (OPO), pump field, 181
temperature acceptance bandwidth, 189
Mid-Infrared Fiber Lasers Markus Pollnau1 and Stuart D. Jackson2 1
2
Advanced Photonics Laboratory, Institute for Biomedical Imaging, Optics and Engineering, Swiss Federal Institute of Technology 1015 Lausanne, Switzerland [email protected] Optical Fibre Technology Centre, Australian Photonics CRC. The University of Sydney 206 National Innovation Centre, Australian Technology Park Eveleigh NSW 1430, Australia [email protected]
Abstract. The current state of the art in mid-infrared fiber lasers is reviewed in this chapter. The relevant fiber-host materials such as silicates, fluorides, chalcogenides, and ceramics, the fiber, pump, and resonator geometries, and the spectroscopic properties of rare-earth ions are introduced. Lasers at transitions ranging from 1.9 to 4 µm occurring in the rare-earth ions Tm3+ , Ho3+ , and Er3+ and their population mechanisms are discussed on the basis of the fundamental spectroscopic properties of these ions. Continuous-wave, fundamental-mode power levels ranging from a few mW near 4 µm up to ≈ 10 W near 2 µm have been demonstrated in recent years. Power-scaling methods and their limitations, the possibilities to optimize the population mechanisms and increase the efficiencies of these lasers, as well as the prospects of future mid-infrared fiber lasers in a number of rare-earth ions at transitions in the wavelength range beyond 3 µm and extending to 5 µm are described.
1
Introduction
Since the introduction of the double-clad fiber more than a decade ago and with the recent technological advances in the fields of fiber fabrication and beam-shaped high-power diode lasers, the performance of diode-pumped fiber lasers has steadily improved. Today, fiber lasers can compete with their corresponding bulk crystalline systems in certain applications, especially when transverse-fundamental-mode, continuous-wave (CW) laser operation at output powers in the milliwatt to multiwatt range is required. The increased recent interest in fiber lasers emitting at mid-infrared wavelengths between 2 and 3 µm primarily relates to the high potential of these wavelengths for applications in laser microsurgery. Due to the high absorption of water in the spectral region at 2.7–3.0 µm, high-quality laser cutting or ablation has been demonstrated in biological tissues. In addition, laser wavelengths near 2 µm could be suitable for tissue welding. A number of other potential laser applications in the mid-infrared spectral region, e.g. environmental trace-gas I. T. Sorokina, K. L. Vodopyanov (Eds.): Solid-State Mid-Infrared Laser Sources, Topics Appl. Phys. 89, 219–255 (2003) c Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2003
220
Markus Pollnau and Stuart D. Jackson
detection, are currently becoming increasingly important. In all these applications fiber lasers may find their niches. The high development costs of fabricating fibers with sufficiently low losses in the mid-infrared spectral region has impeded the necessary research efforts in the field of mid-infrared fiber lasers. The currently available fiber materials that are suitable as host materials for specific rare-earth-doped fiber lasers in the spectral region 2–5 µm will be introduced in Sect. 2. More than any other idea, the invention of the double-clad fiber geometry has accelerated the output-power scaling and hence the success of fiber lasers. The various aspects of the fiber, pump, and resonator geometries will be described in Sect. 3. A significant number of spectroscopic investigations has led to a better understanding of the population mechanisms of rare-earth-doped laser systems. The fundamental spectroscopic properties of rare-earth ions in solid-state host materials will be reviewed in Sect. 4. Equipped with this general information, the performance of the most important mid-infrared fiber laser transitions in the wavelength range 2–3 µm can be understood in detail. Sect. 5 will be devoted to the Tm3+ fiber lasers at 1.9 and 2.3 µm, whereas the Ho3+ fiber lasers at 2.1 and 2.9 µm will be discussed in Sect. 6. An impressive example of the variety of population mechanisms and operational regimes in a single system is the Er3+ 2.7 µm fiber laser transition that will be investigated in Sect. 7. At wavelengths beyond 3 µm, it becomes increasingly difficult to find suitable host materials for actively doped laser systems. This statement holds true for glass fibers in the same way as for crystalline materials. The prospects of future midinfrared fiber lasers in this wavelength range will be discussed in Sect. 8. Besides general introductions to the different topics of lasers [1,2] that include many aspects relevant also to mid-infrared fiber lasers, a comprehensive introduction to the field of rare-earth-doped fiber lasers can be found in [3].
2
Fiber Materials
The choice of the fiber material involves a number of considerations: the maximum phonon energy, the environmental durability, the draw ability, the rare-earth solubility, and the purity of the starting materials. The maximum phonon energy of the glass sets the overall infrared transparency range of the fiber and the multiphonon relaxation rates which influence the quantum efficiency. The multiphonon relaxation rates for the common fiber glasses as a function of the energy gap between energy levels are shown in Fig. 1. The optical transparency range relates to both the size of the band gap and also the infrared absorption cut-off, hence to the vibrational frequency ν of the anion–cation bonds of the glass. For an ordered structure, (1) ν = (1/2π) k/M ,
-1
Multiphonon Relaxation Rate (s )
Mid-Infrared Fiber Lasers 10
12
10
11
10
10
221
-1
Borate (1400 cm ) -1
Phosphate (1200 cm )
9
10
8
10
-1
Silicate (1100 cm )
7
10
-1
Germanate (900 cm )
6
10
-1
Tellurite (700 cm )
5
10
4
-1
10
ZBLA (500 cm )
3
10
2
10
1
10
-1
GLS (350 cm )
2000
3000
4000
5000
6000
7000
-1
Energy Gap (cm )
Fig. 1. Calculated and measured multiphonon relaxation rates as a function of the energy gap between energy levels for glasses with different maximum phonon energies. (Data taken from [4,5])
where M = m1 m2 /(m1 + m2 ) is the reduced mass for two bodies m1 , m2 vibrating with an elastic restoring force k. While for disordered structures like glass, this is not an accurate expression, nevertheless, it does highlight the important contributions to the glass transparency. The relative cation– anion bond strength is intimated by the field strength Z/r2 , where Z is the valence state of the cation or anion and r is the ionic radius. Generally, glasses composed of large anions and cations with low field strengths display high transparency in the mid-infrared spectral region. The important physical properties of the popular glasses used for optical fibers are shown in Table 1. Table 1. Properties of popular fiber materials Fiber material
Max. phonon energy (cm−1 )
Silica ZBLAN GLS
1100 [4] 550 [7] 425 [5]
2.1
Propagation losses Infrared transparency (λ at minimum) (dB/km) ( µm) < 2.5 < 6.0 < 8.0
0.2 (1.55 µm) 0.05 (2.55 µm) 0.5 (3.50 µm)
Thermal conductivity (W/K m) 1.38 [6] 0.7–0.8 [8] 0.43–0.5 [9]
Silicates
This glass is perhaps the most important material used for optical fiber production [3,10], however, the maximum phonon energy is high (≈ 1100 cm−1 ) and has so far limited the emission wavelength of mid-infrared fiber lasers using this material to ≈ 2.2 µm [11]. Silica is robust and involves the very effec-
222
Markus Pollnau and Stuart D. Jackson
tive modified chemical vapor deposition (MCVD) technique for fiber fabrication. Reducing the OH− content in the glass, which has two main absorption peaks in the range 1.3–2.0 µm [12], improves the near-to-mid-infrared utility. Rare-earth ions such as Nd3+ and Er3+ which have high field strengths have low solubility in silicate glass which can lead to clustering and micro-scale phase separation. 2.2
Fluorides
The use of fluoride glasses, especially the heavy-metal fluorides [13,14], as host materials for mid-infrared fiber lasers has found wide acceptance. The most common form of heavy-metal fluoride glass is the fluorozirconate (ZrF4 ) composition and the most widespread fluoride fiber material is ZBLAN [15], a mixture of 53 mol.% ZrF4 , 20 mol.% BaF2 , 4 mol.% LaF3 , 3 mol.% AlF3 , and 20 mol.% NaF. Since it can be readily drawn into single-mode optical fiber [16] it is particularly important to mid-infrared fiber lasers [17]. The large atomic weight of the zirconium atom combined with relatively weak bonding provides a maximum phonon energy for ZBLAN of ≈ 550 cm−1 and allows for high infrared transparency up to ≈ 6 µm. Multiphonon relaxation, however, becomes significant for transitions at wavelengths longer than ≈ 3 µm. Compared to silica, ZBLAN has a lower damage threshold and a lower level of inhomogeneous spectral-line broadening (Sect. 4.1) because the rareearth ion is placed in sites of a less perturbed network. The crystal-field strength is also comparatively weaker [18]. An overview of the spectroscopic properties of rare-earth ions doped into ZBLAN has been given in [7]. 2.3
Chalcogenides
Chalcogenides are composed of the chalcogen elements S, Se and Te [19,20,21]. They are environmentally durable, have a low toxicity and have reasonably large glass forming regions. When the rare-earth ions are doped into these glasses [22], the radiative transition probabilities and, therefore, the absorption and emission cross-sections are high as a result of the high refractive index (≈ 2.6) of the glass and the high degree of covalency of the rare-earth ion with the surrounding medium. Maximum phonon energies of 300–450 cm−1 produce low rates of multiphonon relaxation, see Fig. 1, and therefore high quantum efficiencies. The low thermal conductivity, see Table 1, is however an important factor to be considered in the design of chalcogenide-based lasers. Of the large number of rare-earth chalcogenides studied for luminescent emission, the most important glasses are the sulfide glasses GaLaS (GLS) [23] and GeGaS [24] because of the reasonably high rare-earth solubility. 2.4
Ceramics
Studies into the use of ceramics as host materials for the rare earths have recently made a lot of progress [25]. These ceramics are composed of nano-
Mid-Infrared Fiber Lasers
223
crystallites of materials such as Y3 Al5 O12 (YAG) and can be produced in a simple and cost-efficient process at relatively low temperatures. This allows the fabrication of materials with very high melting points [26] that are difficult to grow by other techniques such as the Czochralski method [27]. This class of materials is also available in fiber geometry [28]. Ceramic fibers combine the characteristics of crystalline materials such as high absorption and emission cross-sections, large thermal conductivity, and even the possibility of doping with transition-metal ions [28] with the convenience of guiding the pump and signal light in a fiber. Currently, the losses of these fibers are comparatively high, but further improvement can be expected.
3
Fiber, Pump, and Resonator Geometries
The light oscillating in a fiber-laser resonator can be either free running or deliberately modulated depending on whether CW or pulsed output, respectively, is desired. Consequently, a large number of techniques for pulsed operation including Q-switching and mode locking of fiber lasers have been explored. These techniques have been investigated intensively for the common laser transitions at 1 µm in Nd3+ and Yb3+ and at 1.5 µm in Er3+ , and are usually described in combination with these lasers. The small fiber size limits the peak power through the damage-threshold intensity (propagating power per core area) and, hence, crystalline lasers in bulk geometries or optical parametric processes are often preferred when high-energy short pulses are needed. This argument accounts especially for mid-infrared ZBLAN-based fiber lasers, because these fibers possess a lower damage threshold compared to silica fibers. The description of mid-infrared fiber lasers is, therefore, confined to CW operation and specific techniques for pulsed operation of fiber lasers are not discussed in this chapter. In an analogous way to the optical excitation of bulk gain media, doped optical fibers can be either end pumped (core pumped) or side pumped (cladding pumped). The former method is less scalable since it relies on the use of expensive high-beam-quality pump sources because core areas are usually < 100 µm2 . On the other hand, the larger cladding area (> 104 µm2 ) allows for high-power diode-array pumping [29,30,31,32,33]. The obvious simplicity of the core-pumping method negates further explanation and we will concentrate on the cladding-pumping technique: one of the most important developments in fiber-laser technology. 3.1
Fiber Designs for Cladding Pumping
In the design of fibers for cladding pumping, the core of the fiber is generally made to guide a single-transverse LP01 mode. The shape of the multimode pump cladding, see Fig. 2, however, remains somewhat flexible and can be shaped with a number of considerations in mind. The pump cladding,
224
Markus Pollnau and Stuart D. Jackson Jacket
Outer cladding
(a)
(b)
Pump cladding
(c)
Core
(d)
Fig. 2. Principal double-clad fiber geometries which include (a) circular shaped pump cladding with axially positioned core, (b) circular shaped pump cladding with off-axially positioned core, (c) rectangular shaped pump cladding and (d) D-shaped pump cladding
which in turn is surrounded by a low-refractive-index transparent polymer or glass, provides a high numerical aperture (NA) of 0.3–0.55 for the pump cladding. There are three main double-clad-fiber layouts: circular, circular with offset core, and rectangular as shown schematically in Fig. 2. Maximum pump-light absorption sees the core near the outer edge of the circular pump cladding [34] because a portion of the launched light is skew to the fiber axis and produces an inner caustic and never crosses the central region of the pump cladding. Scrambling these skew rays by bending [35] or by using a graded and slightly elliptical pump cladding [36] increases the pumpabsorption efficiency as does spatially varying refractive-index fluctuations in inhomogeneous pump claddings [37]. Inner caustics can be avoided by rectilinearly shaping the pump cladding [38] which has the ancillary advantage of matching the shape of diode-array output. The overall absorption coefficient of the fiber is reduced by the ratio of the core area to the area of the pump cladding [34]. The propagation losses for the rectangular-shaped pump cladding are higher and the effective numerical aperture lower as compared to the circular shape [39]; however, in certain cases higher dopant concentrations can provide shorter fiber lengths that also lead to reduced nonlinear effects. A D-shaped or truncated circular pump cladding [40], see Fig. 2d, is also effective while being easier to make than rectangular preforms. The circular-multimode pump cladding may also have the gain medium distributed in a ring around the edge of the pump cladding either discretely or continuously in multi-core [41] and M-profile [42] arrangements, respectively. The effective absorption coefficient is now further increased while maintaining high-beam-quality output. A large-mode-area core [43] can also increase the effective absorption coefficient of the fiber. Recently, double-clad pump schemes have been demonstrated also with holey fibers [44]. These structures offer the additional advantage of singlemode guiding over a broad spectral range [45].
Mid-Infrared Fiber Lasers
3.2
225
Fiber-Laser Resonators
Typical free-running fiber-laser resonators are shown schematically in Fig. 3. In the simplest resonator, see Fig. 3a, the pump light passes through a dichroic mirror that is highly reflective for the oscillating laser light. Fresnel reflection at the cleaved output end facet of the fiber can provide sufficient feedback for laser oscillation; however, with an output-coupler mirror – and pump retroreflector – placed at the output end of the fiber the optical efficiency can be maximized. In an alternative arrangement, the pump light can be launched into the output end of the fiber, see Fig. 3b. A dichroic mirror oriented at 45◦ to the fiber axis extracts the laser output and a broadband highly reflecting mirror is placed at the rear fiber end. To scale the output power, each end of the fiber can be pumped, see Fig. 3c. Periodic V-grooves [46] or prism coupling [47] along the fiber to distribute the pump access allow one to further scale the output power and are useful for pumping fiber ring resonators. Spectrally combining the output from a number of separate fiber lasers is also a promising power-scaling technique [48,49,50]. The highest reported fiberlaser output powers of 110 W in a singly Yb3+ -doped fiber [51] and 150 W in a Nd3+ ,Yb3+ -codoped fiber [52] have been obtained using arrangements as shown schematically in Fig. 3c. Bragg gratings can substitute the fiber-butted mirror if spectrally well-defined output is required. (a)
Output
Pump Fiber M (b)
Pump
M Fiber M Output
(c)
M Pump
Pump Fiber M Output
Fig. 3. Schematic diagram of resonators used for free-running fiber lasers with (a) a single-end co-propagating pump, (b) a single-end counter-propagating pump and (c) dual end pumps. M represents the mirror
226
3.3
Markus Pollnau and Stuart D. Jackson
Thermal Issues
As higher pump powers become available from laser-diode systems, it is generally recognized that thermal and thermo-optical issues set limitations to the power scalability of end-pumped bulk-laser systems. Owing to the unfavorable temperature dependence of thermal and thermo-optical parameters [53], the large heat load in the crystal leads, firstly, to a significant temperature increase in the rod, secondly, to strong thermal lensing with pronounced spherical aberrations, and ultimately, to rod fracture in a high-average-power end-pumped system. Due to its geometry, the fiber provides potentially high pump- and signalbeam intensities without the drawbacks of significant thermal and thermooptical effects. Its large surface-area-to-volume ratio means that the heat generated from multiphonon relaxation in the core is dissipated effectively by radiation and convection from the outer surface of the fiber. This is especially true for single-clad, core-pumped single-mode fibers where this ratio is highest [54]. Double-clad fibers have a relatively smaller surface-area-tovolume ratio and thermal issues need to be taken into account [6,55,56]. Thermal management will be required when very high output powers are desired. In particular, for high-power mid-infrared operation, thermal management may be very important because of the decreased quantum efficiency and the consequently higher amount of heat dissipation.
4 Spectroscopic and Laser Properties of Rare-Earth Ions The structure of a glass is less well defined as compared to a crystalline material. The local variation of the chemical environment of active ions in a glass has a number of consequences. Most important, the active ions may undergo chemical reactions during the fabrication process and be incorporated in the host in several oxidation states with different spectroscopic properties. Oxidation states other than the desired one may act as impurities that introduce undesired optical effects such as parasitic pump absorption, the reabsorption of oscillating laser light, the lifetime quenching of the laser ion, and the trapping of the excitation energy. A stable oxidation state of the optically active ion is thus highly desirable. The necessity of a stable oxidation state excludes a number of transition-metal ions from the list of suitable dopants in glass environments. This is one of the possible reasons why examples of transitionmetal-ion-doped lasers in glass hosts are rare. On the other hand, most of the rare-earth ions prefer to stabilize in the trivalent oxidation state and are, therefore, suitable candidates as glass and fiber dopants. This chapter will, therefore, concentrate on the rare-earth ions as active dopants of fiber lasers.
Mid-Infrared Fiber Lasers
4.1
227
Spectra of Rare-Earth Ions in Glasses
The optical transitions of lanthanide (rare-earth) ions in the visible and infrared spectral region occur within the 4f subshell. This subshell is shielded by the outer 5s and 5p subshells and the influence of the host material is relatively small compared to, e.g., the 3d transitions in transition-metal ions. The electronic structure of trivalent rare-earth ions derives from the perturbation of the 4f energy level in the central-field approximation by the noncentrosymmetric electron–electron interaction, the spin–orbit interaction, and the crystal-field splitting (Stark effect); see the example of the energy-level scheme of Er3+ in Fig. 4. The spin–orbit multiplets are commonly denoted by their 2S+1 LJ terms in Russell–Saunders coupling, although the 4f electrons of lanthanide ions exhibit intermediate coupling and the total angular momenta J of the spin–orbit multiplets are linear combinations of the total orbital angular momenta L and total spins S. Single crystal-field (Stark) transitions between two spin–orbit multiplets cannot be distinguished in glasses at ambient temperature, because inhomogeneous spectral-line broadening occurs due to the local variation of the ligand electric field. Also homogeneous (lifetime) broadening mechanisms are relevant in a number of glasses. This spectral-line broadening makes glasses the preferred hosts when broadband,
4 11
4f Er3+
2 4 4
H S
F
4
I
4
F3/2 4
F7/2 F5/2 2 H11/2 4
S3/2
4
F9/2
4
I9/2
4
I11/2
4
I13/2
CentralNonSpinField Centrosym. Orbit Approx. Splitting Splitting 4
I15/2
CrystalField Splitting
Fig. 4. Energy-level scheme of trivalent erbium indicating the splitting of the 4f 11 configuration in the centralfield approximation by the noncentrosymmetric electron–electron interaction, the spin–orbit interaction, and the Stark splitting by the local electric field of the host material (indicated only for selected spin–orbit multiplets)
228
Markus Pollnau and Stuart D. Jackson
continuous tunability of lasers is desired. On the other hand, the spectralline broadening leads to lower absorption and emission cross-sections for the same transition in glasses compared to single-crystalline hosts. The reduced cross-sections lead to generally higher pump threshold of laser transitions in glasses, a fact that is compensated in fiber geometry because a high pump confinement is achieved over the whole fiber length. 4.2
Intraionic Processes
Generally, the probability of an allowed electric-dipole transition is seven orders of magnitude larger than that of an allowed magnetic-dipole transition. Since electric-dipole transitions within the 4f subshell are parity forbidden, the intensities of radiative transitions in rare-earth ions are weak and the radiative lifetimes of the emitting states are long, typically in the ms range. Mixing of the 4f states with higher-lying (typically 5d) electronic states of opposite parity at ion sites without inversion symmetry, however, means that electric-dipole transitions become partially allowed and are usually the dominant transitions between 4f electronic states. The oscillator strengths f and integrated absorption and emission cross-sections σ of these spin–orbit multiplet-to-multiplet transitions can be calculated with the help of the semiempirical Judd–Ofelt theory [57,58]. If the degree of inhomogeneous spectralline broadening is relatively small and the absorption and emission spectra remain structured, as is the case for ZBLAN, the cross-sections σ(λ) at individual wavelengths that are relevant to pump absorption and stimulated emission of narrow laser lines must be determined experimentally. Besides ground-state absorption (GSA), excited-state absorption (ESA) of pump photons, see Fig. 5a, can play a significant role in fiber lasers, specifically in the case of high-intensity core pumping. An experimental example will be given later in Sect. 7.1. Since the absorption increases exponentially with the absorption coefficient α(λP ) = N σ(λP ), ESA becomes relevant for the population dynamics of a laser when (a) the ESA and GSA cross-sections σ(λP ) are comparable at the pump wavelength λP and (b) the population density N of the excited state in which the second pump-absorption step originates becomes a significant fraction of the density of ions in the ground state, i.e., a large degree of ground-state bleaching must be present for ESA to play a significant role. A radiative transition from an excited state i to a lower-lying state j is characterized by the radiative rate constant Aij . If the decay occurs to several lower-lying states, the overall radiative rate constant Ai is the sum of all individual rate constants. The branching ratio of each radiative transition is defined as βij = Aij /Ai . Radiative decay of excited states is in competition with nonradiative decay by interaction with vibrations of the host material, called multiphonon relaxation. The rate constant of a multiphonon relaxation process decreases exponentially with the energy gap to the next lower-lying state and with the order of the process, i.e., the number of phonons required
Mid-Infrared Fiber Lasers
(a)
229
(b) 2
2 Pump (ESA) 1
1 Pump (GSA)
Pump
0
0 Ion
Donor Ion
Acceptor Ion
(c)
(d)
2
2 Laser
1
Acceptor Ion
Laser
1 Pump
Pump
0
0 Sensitizing Ion A
Laser Ion B
Laser Ion A
(e)
(f)
2
2
1
1 Pump
Pump
0
Quenching Ion B
Pump
0 Donor Ion
Acceptor Ion
Donor Ion
Acceptor Ion
Fig. 5. Intra- and interionic processes in fiber lasers: (a) excited-state absorption (ESA); (b) energy migration; (c) sensitization and (d) quenching of a laser ion by an ion of a different type; (e) cross-relaxation and (f ) energy-transfer upconversion
230
Markus Pollnau and Stuart D. Jackson
to bridge the energy gap [59,60]. This fact is illustrated in Fig. 1 for different glasses. The rate constant of multiphonon relaxation increases with host temperature. The measurable luminescence lifetime τi of an excited state i is the inverse of the sum of the overall radiative rate constant Ai and the rate constant of multiphonon relaxation, Wi . The radiative quantum efficiency is defined as η = Ai /(Ai + Wi ). The influence of multiphonon relaxations is stronger in oxides as compared to fluorides because of the smaller atomic mass m2 of the anion and the larger elastic restoring force k, see (1), due to stronger covalent bonds in oxides [3], both resulting in larger maximum phonon energies in oxides. A brief example: The luminescence lifetime of the 4 I11/2 upper laser level of the erbium 3 µm laser (Sect. 7) is partly quenched by multiphonon relaxation. Typically, nonradiative decay becomes dominant if five or less phonons are required to bridge the energy gap. With an energy gap between the 4 I11/2 and the next lower lying 4 I13/2 levels of ≈ 3400–3500 cm−1 , radiative decay prevails for phonon energies below ≈ 600 cm−1 , roughly the maximum phonon energy of ZBLAN, see Table 1. Fluorides are, therefore, preferred over oxides as host materials for most of the mid-infrared laser transitions. Like absorption, the strength of a stimulated-emission process is characterized by the emission cross-section σ(λL ) of the laser transition. From a simple analysis, for one resonator round-trip of oscillating laser photons, the product τ σ(λL ) with τ the luminescence lifetime of the upper laser level, is identified as a “figure of merit” for a possible laser transition. The larger this product, the lower is the expected pump threshold of the laser transition. This “figure of merit”, however, does not take into account the numerous parasitic effects that can occur in the population dynamics of a laser system, such as pump ESA, reabsorption of laser photons, and energy-transfer processes. It is often these parasitic processes that lead to surprising performance characteristics – as likely in the negative as in the positive sense – and make the interpretation of rare-earth-doped solid-state lasers challenging. Examples will be discussed in Sects. 5–7. 4.3
Interionic Processes
In addition to intraionic excitation and decay mechanisms, radiative energy transfer due to reabsorption of emitted photons by other active ions in the sample and nonradiative energy-transfer processes due to multipole– multipole or exchange interactions between neighboring active ions can occur. Radiative energy transfer leads to an increase in the luminescence lifetime. Among the nonradiative energy-transfer processes, most common is the electric dipole–dipole interaction, which can occur as a direct [61] or phononassisted [62] energy transfer. A direct energy transfer requires spectral resonance between the involved emission and absorption transitions whereas an indirect transfer can also be nonresonant, i.e., an existing energy gap between the emission and absorption transitions involved in the transfer is bridged by
Mid-Infrared Fiber Lasers
231
one or several phonons. A process that leads to phonon emission has typically a higher probability than a process requiring phonon absorption. Since the electrostatic field of an electric dipole decreases with distance r as r−3 , the probability of an energy transfer between two such dipoles exhibits a strong distance sensitivity of r−6 . Therefore, nonradiative energy transfer occurs predominantly between neighboring active ions. An obvious possibility of an energy-transfer process is shown in Fig. 5b. An excited ion transfers its excitation to a nearby ion of the same type. If this process occurs consecutively between a number of similar ions and the energy is thus transferred over a larger distance, it is called energy migration. Quenching of the luminescence lifetime of an excited state by energy transfer to impurities is often accelerated by energy migration among the excited donor ions [63]. Figure 5 displays further energy-transfer processes that typically occur in rare-earth-doped solid-state lasers. Rare-earth ions of a different type can be deliberately co-doped into the host material in order to influence the laser properties of the lasing ions. Efficient excitation by means of absorption and energy transfer of pump light from sensitizing ions to the upper laser level of the lasing ions, see Fig. 5c, can be exploited when the lasing ions do not sufficiently absorb the pump light at the desired pump wavelength or the dopant concentration of the lasing ions is limited because, e.g., the laser transition terminates in the ground-state multiplet. Similarly, the transfer of excitation from the lower laser level of the lasing ions to nearby quenching ions, see Fig. 5d, is desirable when the lifetime of the lower laser level is extremely long. The low relaxation rate from the lower laser level would otherwise lead to accumulation of excitation in this level, which can result in self-terminating laser behavior and/or bleaching of the ground-state population density and, consequently, decreased GSA. Energy-transfer processes that have both ions in excited states before or after the energy transfer are shown in Fig. 5e,f. In the former case, an excited ion transfers part of its excitation to a nearby ion in its ground state. This process is called cross-relaxation. Its rate increases with the average number of non-excited neighboring ions, i.e., with dopant concentration. Therefore, cross-relaxation leads to concentration quenching of the measured luminescent decay time of the initial excited state involved in the transfer process. In the inverse process – called energy-transfer upconversion (ETU) – excitation is transferred from one to another excited ion, see Fig. 5f. After the absorption of two low-energy pump photons, ETU leads to a single excitation of higher energy and a single high-energy photon may be emitted from the second excited state. In the presence of fast energy migration among the active ions, the excitation is spatially diffused and all these energy-transfer processes can be described by rate-equation analysis using a rate term W Nd Na that comprises a macroscopic energy transfer probability W and the population densities Nd
232
Markus Pollnau and Stuart D. Jackson
and Na of the initial states of the donor and acceptor ions, respectively [64]. This model, however, is usually not applicable at low dopant concentrations where energy migration is weak. In addition, a number of authors reported on active-ion clusters in fiber materials, see, e.g., [65,66,67,68]. This or any other non-uniform distribution of active ions complicates the analysis of the influence of energy-transfer processes on the performance of rare-earth-doped fiber lasers, as ions within such clusters are more susceptible to interionic processes than isolated ions. In the simplest approach, this distinction defines two different classes of ions that exhibit different population dynamics [69]. 4.4
Overview of Mid-Infrared Fiber Lasers
The relevant parameters of the fiber lasers with the highest output powers reported as of the end of 2001 for each mid-infrared transition are summarized in Table 2. As can be seen, most of the realized mid-infrared fiber lasers used ZBLAN as the host material, because silica glasses, on the one hand, have maximum phonon energies that are too high and hence a transparency that is too low in the wavelength region beyond ≈ 2.2 µm and chalcogenide glasses, on the other hand, are only at the beginning of their career as fiber-laser host materials. The transitions included in Table 2 will be discussed in detail in the following sections of this chapter. Table 2. Mid-infrared fiber lasers Ion Tm3+ Ho3+ Tm3+ Er3+ Ho3+ Ho3+ Er3+ Ho3+ a)
Fiber host
λPump (nm)
λLaser ( µm)
Transition
Silica ZBLAN ZBLAN ZBLAN ZBLAN ZBLAN ZBLAN ZBLAN
787 805 790 792 1150 532 653 890
1.9 2.1 2.3 2.7 2.9 3.22 3.45 3.95
F4 → 3 H6 I7 → 5 I8 3 H4 → 3 H5 4 I11/2 → 4 I13/2 5 I6 → 5 I7 5 S2 → 5 F5 4 F9/2 → 4 I9/2 5 I5 → 5 I6 3
5
Output power 14 W 8.8 W 22 mW 1.7 W 1.3 W 11 mW 8 mWb) 11 mWb)
Slope Eff. a) 46 % 36 % 7% 17 % 30 % 2.8 % 3% 3.7 %
Ref. [70] [71] [72] [73] [74] [75] [76] [77]
The values of the slope efficiency are given versus incident, launched, or absorbed pump power as stated by the authors and are not necessarily comparable to each other b) Operation with the fiber cooled below ambient temperature
Mid-Infrared Fiber Lasers
233
5 Thulium-Doped Fiber Lasers at 1.9–2.0 µm and 2.3–2.5 µm The use of the Tm3+ ion for mid-infrared fiber laser applications has been widespread mainly as a result of the convenient absorption band near 0.79 µm which allows for AlGaAs diode laser pumping. The primary luminescent transitions of Tm3+ relevant to mid-infrared laser emission are the 3 F4 → 3 H5 transition at ≈ 2.3 µm and the 3 H4 → 3 H6 ground-state transition at ≈ 1.9 µm, see the energy-level scheme in Fig. 6. The 3 F4 level is excited by the 0.79 µm pump wavelength. 5.1
Three-Level Lasers at 1.9–2.0 µm
The first explorations into fiber lasers utilizing the 1.9 µm ground-state transition related to the dye-laser pumping at 797 nm of a Tm3+ -doped silica fiber laser [79]. Overlap of the main absorption band with the emission wavelength of AlGaAs diode lasers quickly resulted in diode-laser pumping of these fiber lasers based on either silica [80] or fluoride [81] glass hosts. A useful phononassisted cross-relaxation process, (3 F4 , 3 H6 ) → (3 H4 , 3 H4 ), can transform one absorbed pump photon into two excitations in the 3 H4 upper laser level of the 2 µm transition [82], see Fig. 6. The efficient room-temperature CW operation of Tm3+ -doped diode-pumped bulk crystalline lasers [83] is largely due to this self-quenching process. This process is highly dependent upon the overall concentration of Tm3+ ions and competition by multiphonon relaxation from the 3 F4 level. High concentrations of Tm3+ in low-phonon-energy glasses enable full exploitation of this beneficial phenomenon. The significantly stronger multiphonon relaxation and corresponding shorter lifetime of the 3 F4 level in silica (≈ 20 µs) means that the cross-relaxation process is significantly weaker in silica as compared to fluoride glass. The large degree of Stark splitting of the 3 H6 ground state provides the 3 H4 → 3 H6 transition with a very broad emission spanning ≈ 400 nm in 3
τ3 = 1.5 ms
F4 Laser 2.3 µm NR
CR
3
H5 NR
3
τ1 = 6.8 ms
H4 GSA
Laser 2.0 µm
3
H6 Tm3+
Fig. 6. Partial energy-level scheme of Tm3+ displaying the measured lifetimes when doped into fluoride glass [78]. NR and CR represent nonradiative decay and cross-relaxation, respectively
234
Markus Pollnau and Stuart D. Jackson
many hosts and represents one of the broadest luminescent transitions available from any rare-earth ion. The broad emission spectrum produces a large degree of wavelength tunability [84]. Since the Tm3+ 1.9 µm transition can be favorably operated in silica fiber (with its higher peak-power damage threshold compared to ZBLAN fiber), pulses in the range of 190–500 fs have been obtained in additive-pulse [85] or passive [86] mode-locking from this broad emission spectrum. The smaller emission cross-section and the three-level nature of the laser transition usually resulted in relatively higher pump thresholds as compared to the standard Nd3+ -doped fiber lasers. Reabsorption from the ground state of the Tm3+ ions has to be overcome because the groundstate multiplet is the lower laser level. Reducing the population of the higher Stark levels of the ground state by way of cooling the fiber causes emission at shorter wavelengths. Tunability to longer wavelengths can be obtained by variation of the fiber length because of the increased level of reabsorption by the ground state with longer lengths of fiber [87]. Early power-scaling experiments involved the use of the convenient 1.064 µm Nd3+ :YAG laser which pumped the short wavelength side of the 3 H5 level [88]. Pumping the long wavelength side of the 3 H5 level with a high-power 1.319 µm Nd3+ :YAG laser also yields efficient output [89]. Inband pumping of the transition at 1.57 µm in silica [90] and at 1.58–1.60 µm in fluoride glass [91,92] has also been demonstrated. Whilst theoretical modeling of Tm3+ -doped silica fiber lasers [93] confirms that inband pumping is the most efficient pump method for silica based fiber lasers because of the high Stokes efficiency, nevertheless, the wide availability of high-power AlGaAS diode lasers means that diode-cladding-pumped systems in both standing-wave [87,70] and ring-resonator [94] arrangements are perhaps the most practical ways of producing high output power, see Fig. 7. Currently, the Tm3+ -doped silica fiber laser is probably the most mature of the midinfrared fiber-laser systems primarily because of the robustness and convenience offered by the silica glass host. While less efficient than Tm3+ -doped fluoride fiber lasers, the comparatively higher pump threshold relevant to Tm3+ -doped silica fiber lasers is easily provided for by currently available high-power diode-laser pump sources. The maximum output power from highpower Tm3+ -doped fiber lasers is still currently an order of magnitude lower than comparable diode-pumped crystalline systems [95]. 5.2
Four-Level Lasers at 2.3–2.5 µm
The increased quantum efficiency of the 3 F4 level when Tm3+ ions are doped into a ZBLAN host offers a greater range of emission wavelengths. Besides lasers at shorter wavelengths such as ≈ 1.47 µm (3 F4 → 3 H4 ) and ≈ 0.8 µm (3 F4 → 3 H6 ), the mid-infrared four-level CW laser at ≈ 2.3 µm (3 F4 → 3 H5 ) [96,97,72] is of interest, see Fig. 6. Deliberately designing the fiber to have a relatively low Tm3+ -ion concentration reduces cross-relaxation and hence severe lifetime quenching of the 3 F4 level. The lifetime of the lower
Mid-Infrared Fiber Lasers 3+
14
1.8 wt.% Tm
12
3.6 mol.% Tm , 0.4 mol.% Ho
3+
Output Power (W)
235
3+
3+
2.2 wt.% Tm 10 8 6 4 2 0 0
10
20
30
40
50
Incident Pump Power (W)
Fig. 7. Measured output powers from diode-cladding-pumped fiber lasers using 1.8 wt.% Tm3+ -doped silica [86], 2.2 wt.% Tm3+ -doped silica [70], and 3.6 mol.% Tm3+ , 0.4 mol.% Ho3+ -doped fluoride glass [71]
laser level of the 3 F4 → 3 H5 transition is quite short and leads to a low pump threshold and broad tunability which can extend from 2.25 µm to 2.5 µm [78]. Simultaneous lasing on the 3 H4 → 3 H6 transition at 1.9 µm produces a two-color fiber laser [98]. Applications requiring highly efficient output or multi-mid-infrared-wavelength output will benefit from the use of Tm3+ -doped ZBLAN fibers.
6
Holmium-Doped Fiber Lasers at 2.1 µm and 2.9 µm
The use of the Ho3+ ion as the active dopant for fiber lasers opens up a number of very useful mid-infrared transitions. In this section, we will concentrate on the 5 I7 → 5 I8 ground-state transition at ≈ 2.1 µm and the 5 I6 → 5 I7 transition at ≈ 2.9 µm, see the energy-level scheme in Fig. 8. One of the significant shortcomings of Ho3+ , however, is the lack of GSA transitions [99] that overlap with convenient high-power pump sources. As a result, many of the early demonstrations of Ho3+ -doped room-temperature crystalline CW lasers [82] involved sensitizing with Tm3+ in order to access the convenient absorption bands and the practical cross-relaxation process Tm3+ provides. Energy migration amongst the Tm3+ ions and a suitable Tm3+ :Ho3+ concentration ratio ensures that efficient energy transfer to Ho3+ takes place [100,101], see Fig. 8. The results of a recent spectroscopic study of Ho:YAG [102] suggest that the cross-relaxation process (5 I5 , 5 I8 ) → (5 I7 , 5 I7 ) and the related ETU process will probably be important in some highly Ho3+ -doped fibers; however, the cross-relaxation process (5 I6 , 5 I8 ) → (5 I7 , 5 I7 ) and its related ETU process seem to have a negligible effect on the overall population dynamics.
236
Markus Pollnau and Stuart D. Jackson 5
S2
Laser 3.2 µm
5
F5
5
I4
3
F4
3
H5
5
I5
Laser CR 3.9 µm ET
3
H4
5
I6
Laser 2.9µm
5
I7
Laser 2.1 µm
GSA
3
H6
6.1
5
Tm3+
Ho3+
I8
Fig. 8. Partial energy-level scheme of Ho3+ with Tm3+ sensitizer. ET represents energy transfer
Three-Level Lasers at 2.1 µm
As is the case with the ground-state transition of the Tm3+ ion discussed above, the 5 I7 → 5 I8 ground-state transition has been the most widely explored laser transition of Ho3+ . The first fiber laser configuration making use of this transition employed ZBLANP glass (a variant of ZBLAN) and argonion pumping [103]. A year later, this was followed by a demonstration of an argon-ion-pumped Ho3+ -doped silica fiber laser [104]. In both cases, the fiber was singly doped with Ho3+ , the output power < 1 mW, and each needed a relatively high pump power to reach laser threshold. Improvements in the output power and efficiency have been made recently with Yb3+ -doped silica fiber laser pumping of the 5 I6 level [105]; however, the output power has only increased to 280 mW. As mentioned above, a practical method of efficiently generating laser emission on the 5 I7 → 5 I8 transition is to co-dope Ho3+ laser ions with Tm3+ sensitizer ions. The first demonstration of a fiber laser operating with the Tm3+ , Ho3+ system occurred in 1991 [106] when 250 mW was generated at a slope efficiency of 52 % from a Ti:sapphire-pumped fluoride fiber laser. A year later [107], this work was followed by an increase in the Tm3+ concentration to improve the cross-relaxation and resulted in a higher slope efficiency being obtained. Demonstration of a Tm3+ , Ho3+ -doped silica fiber laser soon followed [108,109]; however, owing to lower Tm3+ concentrations and strong multiphonon relaxation of the 3 F4 level which forces weaker cross-relaxation, significantly lower slope efficiencies were measured, especially when pumped at 1.064 µm [11]. To date, the highest output power from a fiber laser operating on the 5 I7 → 5 I8 transition has been produced by a diode-cladding-pumped Tm3+ , Ho3+ -doped fluoride fiber laser [71], see
Mid-Infrared Fiber Lasers
237
Fig. 7. In an analogous way to recent demonstrations in bulk laser systems [110,111], tandem-pumping Ho3+ with a separate Tm3+ laser operating at 1.9 µm may also prove effective in fibers, because it similarly exploits the cross-relaxation process between Tm3+ ions but avoids any ETU between Ho3+ ions in the 5 I7 upper laser level and excited Tm3+ ions [112]. 6.2
Four-Level Lasers at 2.9 µm
As a result of the infrared absorption cut-off of silica and the strong multiphonon relaxation quenching of mid-infrared transitions of rare-earth ions in this host, four-level fiber lasers operating on the 5 I6 → 5 I7 transition at ≈ 2.9 µm have to date only involved fluoride glass as the host material. The lifetime of the 5 I7 level is longer than the lifetime of the 5 I6 level and hence the 2.9 µm transition can be self-terminating. The first demonstration of a fiber laser using this transition [113] produced only ≈ 13 mW when pumped at a wavelength of 640 nm. High-power cascade lasing at 2.9 µm and 2.1 µm has been employed recently to extend the output power and to remove bottlenecking at the 5 I7 level [114]. With direct pumping of the upper laser level, 1.3 W of output power has been measured from this laser scheme [74]. Sensitizing Ho3+ with Yb3+ ions, see the energy-level scheme in Fig. 9, in order to exploit the more favorable absorption features of Yb3+ has been used in diode-pumped crystalline lasers for the generation of both 2.1 µm [115] and 2.9 µm [116] output. When sensitizing with Yb3+ ions, Ho3+ -doped silica fiber lasers at 2.1 µm may produce significantly more output because Yb3+ can be doped to quite high levels in silica thus ensuring strong absorption and sufficient energy transfer to Ho3+ . Similarly, a Yb3+ -sensitized Ho3+ -doped ZBLAN fiber will also be diode-laser pumpable and may efficiently provide high-power 2.9 µm output without the costly requirement of an intermediate laser system. Initial spectroscopic results look encouraging [117]. ET
5
I5
2
F5/2
5
τ2 = 3.5 ms GSA
I6
Laser 2.9 µm
5
I7
τ1 = 12 ms
Laser 2.1 µm 2
F7/2
5
Yb3+
Ho3+
I8
Fig. 9. Partial energy-level scheme of Ho3+ with Yb3+ sensitizer displaying the measured lifetimes of Ho3+ when doped into fluoride glass host [114]
238
7
Markus Pollnau and Stuart D. Jackson
Erbium-Doped Fiber Lasers at 2.7–2.8 µm
The first observation of coherent emission near 3 µm from erbium ions was reported in 1967 [118]. In 1983, the first CW lasing near 3 µm was obtained [119]. The first erbium 3 µm fiber laser was demonstrated in 1988 [120]. Although the lifetime of the 4 I13/2 lower laser level exceeds that of the 4 I11/2 upper laser level, CW lasing can be obtained on this four-level-laser transition in ZBLAN without employing special techniques to depopulate the 4 I13/2 lower laser level, because the lower laser level is not fed significantly by luminescent decay or multiphonon relaxation from the upper laser level [121]. In addition, the Stark splitting of the laser levels contributes to population inversion, because the laser transition occurs between a low-lying Stark component of the upper and a high-lying Stark component of the lower laser level [122]. During the relaxation oscillations at the onset of lasing, a red-shift of the lasing wavelength is often observed in erbium 3 µm laser systems [123,124,125], because the excitation energy is accumulated in the long-lived 4 I13/2 lower laser level and the character of the lasing process changes from four-level to three-level lasing [122]. For the same reason, the tunability range of a 3 µm CW laser [126] is narrowed and red-shifted with increasing pump power. Depending on the erbium concentration and fiber geometry, the 3 µm fiber laser has been operated in a number of different regimes that will be discussed in the following sections. 7.1
Excited-State Absorption and Cascade Lasing
Pump ESA has a major influence on the performance of low-doped, corepumped erbium 2.7 µm ZBLAN fiber lasers. Pumping at 980 nm directly into the upper laser level provides the highest Stokes efficiency of ηSt = λp /λl = 35 % [127]. However, ESA at 980 nm from the 4 I11/2 upper laser level [128] is detrimental to lasing and must be avoided. Experimentally, the best pump wavelength [129] is near 792 nm. This wavelength is at the peak of ESA from the 4 I13/2 lower laser level [130], as can be seen from the measured GSA and ESA cross-sections in Fig. 10a. The reason for the strong influence of this ESA is that depletion of the lower laser level by ESA favorably results in a redistribution of its population density and overcomes the bottleneck that results from the long lower-level lifetime. Slope efficiencies obtained in this way were < 15 %. Moreover, a saturation of the output power at 2.7 µm was observed, regardless of the pump wavelength, and the highest reported output powers were in the 20 mW region [131,132]. The output power saturated, because the excitation of the metastable 4 S3/2 level (lifetime ≈ 580 µs [133]) led to inversion with respect to the 4 I13/2 level. A second laser transition at 850 nm repopulated the 4 I13/2 lower laser level of the 2.7 µm transition, see Fig. 10b, causing the 2.7 µm laser to saturate at low output powers [129].
Mid-Infrared Fiber Lasers
(a)
(b) 24
4
4I15/2 4I13/2 4I11/2
-22
cm2]
20
σ ESA [10
239
F7/2 H11/2 4 S3/2 2
τ5 = 580 µs Laser Laser 1.7µm 850nm
16 12
4
F9/2
4
I9/2
4
I11/2
ESA
8 4 0 780
790
800
810
820
830
τ2 = 6.9 ms Laser 2.7µm
840
Wavelength [nm] 4
τ1 = 9.0 ms
I13/2
GSA
4
I15/2 Er3+
Fig. 10. (a) Absorption cross-sections in ZBLAN:Er3+ near 800 nm: GSA 4 I15/2 → 4 I9/2 and ESA 4 I13/2 → 2 H11/2 , 4 I11/2 → 4 F3/2 , and 4 I11/2 → 4 F5/2 . (Data taken from [130].) (b) Partial energy-level scheme of erbium indicating the processes relevant to the ZBLAN:Er3+ cascade laser: Lower loop with GSA to 4 I9/2 , multiphonon relaxation, laser transition at 2.7 µm, luminescent decay, and upper loop with ESA to 2 H11/2 , thermal relaxation, laser transition at 1.7 µm, multiphonon relaxation, laser transition at 2.7 µm. Competitive lasing at 850 nm is suppressed in the cascade regime
Significant improvement in the performance of this laser system was obtained by deliberately operating a third laser transition 4 S3/2 → 4 I9/2 at 1.7 µm, thereby suppressing the competitive laser at 850 nm and recycling the excitation energy accumulated in the 4 S3/2 level into the upper laser level, see the energy-level scheme in Fig. 10b. The slope efficiency of the 2.7 µm transition increased significantly to 23 % [134], close to the Stokes-efficiency limit of 29 % under 800-nm pumping. An output power of 150 mW was demonstrated experimentally [134]. This cascade lasing regime represents the best option for dopant concentrations of typically 0.1 mol% (≈ 1.6×1019 cm−3 ) at which ESA is important. Also a three-transition-cascade lasing regime with additional lasing at the transition 4 I13/2 → 4 I15/2 near 1.6 µm was demonstrated [135], but no further improvement was obtained. 7.2
Lifetime Quenching by Pr3+ Co-Doping
In ZBLAN fibers with higher dopant concentrations of typically 1–5 mol% (≈ 1.6–8 × 1020 cm−3 ) and with the double-clad geometry, ESA is much less
240
Markus Pollnau and Stuart D. Jackson
important, because the reduced pump intensity with low-brightness diode lasers leads to smaller excitation densities. The relatively high fabrication costs of ZBLAN double-clad fibers means that pre-calculation and optimization of the expected device performance on the basis of the available spectroscopic parameters becomes an important tool. Currently, the most successful approach towards a high-power erbium 2.7 µm fiber laser is co-doping of the fiber with Pr3+ [73]. This idea was reported already in [131,136,137] and was proposed for the double-clad fiber laser in [138]. In this approach, the Er3+ 2.7 µm transition is operated as a simple four-level laser, see the energy-level scheme in Fig. 11a: The 4 I13/2 lower laser level is depopulated by the energy-transfer process ET1 to the Pr3+ co-dopant and fast decay to the ground state by multiphonon relaxation within Pr3+ . This energy-transfer process is much more efficient than the energy-transfer process ET2 from the 4 I11/2 upper laser level to the Pr3+ co-dopant, because the oscillator strength in Pr3+ is much higher for the transition involved in the former process [133]. The relatively weak lifetime quenching of the upper laser level affects the pump threshold, but it does not influence the slope efficiency. The strong lifetime quenching of the 4 I13/2 lower laser level and the fact that the 4 I11/2 population density is clamped to laser threshold significantly reduces ground-state bleaching and excitation of the laser levels, thus making the influence of ESA negligible, but similarly preventing energy recycling by ETU [139]. Like in the cascade-lasing regime (Sect. 5.2), each pump photon can at best produce one laser photon in the Er3+ , Pr3+ -co-doped system. The theoretical limit of the slope efficiency is given by the Stokes efficiency, which is 29 % under 800-nm pumping. Experimentally, a slope efficiency of 17 % and an output power of 1.7 W were obtained [73], see Fig. 11b. Other researchers [140] reported output powers of 660 mW. Since ESA from both laser levels is negligible, the system can alternatively be pumped near 980 nm, which provides the highest possible Stokes efficiency of 35 %. In this way, the experimental slope efficiency could be increased to 25 % [141]. The fiber that was used in these experiments contained an erbium concentration of 3.5 mol.%. 7.3
Energy Recycling by Energy-Transfer Upconversion
Energy-transfer processes between erbium ions govern the population mechanisms of highly erbium-doped laser systems. In the energy-level scheme of Fig. 12a, the important ETU and cross-relaxation processes are introduced. The ETU process (4 I13/2 , 4 I13/2 ) → (4 I15/2 , 4 I9/2 ) leads to a fast depletion of the lower laser level. Half of the ions that undergo this process are upconverted to the 4 I9/2 level and, by subsequent multiphonon relaxation, are recycled to the 4 I11/2 upper laser level from where they can each emit a second laser photon, for a single pump-photon absorption. For a large number of ions participating in this process, the quantum efficiency ηq = nl /np of
Mid-Infrared Fiber Lasers (a)
241
(b)
4
2
F7/2 H11/2 4 S3/2 1
D2
4
F9/2
4
I9/2
4
I11/2
ET2 1
G4
Output Power [W]
2
1
0 0
ET1 4
3
F4 F3 3 F2 3 H6
I13/2
2
4
6
8
10
12
Launched Pump Power [W]
3
Laser GSA
3
H5
3
4
H4
I15/2 Er
3+
3+
Pr
Fig. 11. (a) Partial energy-level scheme of erbium indicating the processes relevant to the ZBLAN:Er3+ lifetime-quenching laser: GSA at 980 nm to the 4 I11/2 upper laser level (or at 790 nm to the 4 I9/2 pump level and subsequent multiphonon relaxation to 4 I11/2 ), laser transition to the 4 I13/2 lower laser level, and relaxation to the ground state via energy transfer ET1 to the Pr3+ co-dopant. The energy transfer ET2 from the 4 I11/2 upper laser level to the Pr3+ co-dopant is weak. (b) Output power at 2.7 µm under 792-nm pumping (Data taken from [73])
pump photons np converted to laser photons nl increases from 1 to 2 [122]. In a simple rate-equation system which includes the processes shown in Fig. 12a the slope efficiency is given by [142] ln (1 − T ) b2 W22 ηsl = ηSt , (2) 2 − 12 ln [(1 − T ) (1 − L)] b2 W11 with T , the transmission of the outcoupling mirror, L, the internal resonator losses, and bi and Wii , the Boltzmann factors and ETU parameters of the upper (i = 2) and lower (i = 1) laser levels, respectively. If ETU occurs only from the lower laser level, i.e., W22 = 0, we obtain a factor-of-two increase in slope efficiency from (2). The slope efficiency is reduced, however, by the resonator losses, the nonperfect mode overlap, and the ETU process from the upper laser level in the case of W22 > 0. Energy recycling by ETU is the most efficient way to operate a CW erbium laser near 3 µm. The highest slope efficiency obtained experimentally is currently 50 % in LiYF4 :15 % Er3+ [143]. Quasi-CW excitation reduces the
242
Markus Pollnau and Stuart D. Jackson
(a)
(b)
F7/2 H11/2 4 S3/2 2
ETU2 4
F9/2
4
I9/2
4
I11/2
4
I13/2
CR
ETU1
W [10 -17 cm3s -1], Ratio
4
10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0
W11 W22 Ratio
0
ETU1
4
5
10
15
Erbium Conc. [10 20 cm-3]
ETU2
CR
I15/2 Er3+
Fig. 12. (a) Partial energy-level scheme of erbium indicating ETU1 from 4 I13/2 , ETU2 from 4 I11/2 , and cross-relaxation (CR) from the thermally coupled 4 S3/2 and 2 H11/2 levels. (b) Macroscopic parameters of ETU1 from 4 I13/2 (W11 ) and ETU2 from 4 I11/2 (W22 ) and the ratio W11 /W22 in ZBLAN:Er3+ bulk glasses. (Data taken from [133])
slope efficiency, because the lower laser level is less populated and ETU is less efficient in this case [144]. The parameters Wii of both ETU processes in ZBLAN bulk glasses [133] versus Er3+ concentration are shown in Fig. 12b. The criterion for optimization of the slope efficiency in (2) is maximizing the ratio W11 /W22 . For Er3+ concentrations of > 2–3 mol% at which ETU processes become important, this ratio is ≈ 3, see the dashed line in Fig. 12b, a more favorable value than reported for LiYF4 :Er3+ [145]. Energy recycling by ETU at high Er3+ concentrations [146] might lead to output powers at 3 µm on the order of 10 W. So far, two research groups tried to exploit energy recycling [147,148], however the slope efficiencies in these experiments did not exceed the slope efficiencies obtained in Er3+ ,Pr3+ -co-doped fibers pumped at corresponding pump wavelengths [73,141].
8
Fiber Lasers at Wavelengths Beyond 3 µm
Generating wavelengths longer than 3 µm from fiber lasers is a task which tests the limits of current glass technology. The need for lower phonon ener-
Mid-Infrared Fiber Lasers
243
gies has to be balanced with acceptable mechanical, chemical, and thermal properties. Since the highly developed ZBLAN glass is only useful for laser transitions up to 3–3.5 µm, glasses such as the chalcogenides [149] will need to fill the gap. It is because these glasses have to be drawn into low-loss fiber which has prevented long-wavelength emission to the extent that is possible in crystalline-based solid-state lasers [150]. Creating efficient and high power mid-infrared fiber lasers with output wavelengths > 3 µm is at the forefront of current fiber-laser research efforts. 8.1
ZBLAN Fiber Lasers at 3.22 µm, 3.45 µm, and 3.95 µm
The operation of lasers at the longer wavelengths of 3.22 µm [75] and 3.95 µm [151] has been obtained from Ho3+ -doped ZBLAN fiber and at 3.45 µm [76] from Er3+ -doped ZBLAN fiber. It was, however, necessary to cool the ZBLAN fiber for the 3.45 µm and 3.95 µm transitions. These two laser transitions span five or six maximum phonon energies in ZBLAN, therefore the lifetime of the upper laser level for each of these transitions is short and engenders an increase in the pump threshold compared to other ZBLAN fiber lasers operating at the shorter mid-infrared wavelengths. In addition, the lower laser levels of these transitions possess quite long lifetimes and some saturation of the output power has been observed [77]. This problem (while it can be mitigated with cascaded lasing), combined with the use of inconvenient pump sources has impeded the full utilization of these laser transitions. The 3.95 µm wavelength emitted from the cooled ZBLAN fiber laser is currently the longest laser wavelength that has been generated from a fiber laser. A laser transition that has as yet not been realized but might work well in ZBLAN fibers is the 6 H13/2 → 6 H15/2 transition at 3.0–3.4 µm in Dy3+ . 8.2
Future Mid-Infrared Fiber Lasers
As mentioned above, fiber lasers operating on laser transitions which have wavelengths > 3 µm will need to use glasses which have very low phonon energies. While rare-earth-doped heavy-metal oxides [152] have been studied for 2–3 µm mid-infrared emission, up to now, there has been no report of laser action for a fiber laser comprised of such a glass. Heavy-metal oxides do not seem to be suitable for lasers at wavelengths beyond 3 µm, because their maximum phonon energies are comparable to fluoride glasses and are too high for laser transitions beyond 3 µm. The chalcogenide glasses have, by contrast, been doped with a number of rare-earth ions including Ho3+ [153], Tm3+ [154], Tb3+ [154], Dy3+ [155], Pr3+ [156], and Er3+ [157,158] for studies into > 3-µm mid-infrared luminescence, see Table 3. Fiber-laser action has been reported, however, only for an Nd3+ -doped GLS glass operating at a wavelength of ≈ 1 µm [159]. Recent demonstrations of fabricating Bragg gratings [160], single-mode fiber [161] and holey fiber [162] with chalcogenide glass highlight the utility of this glass
244
Markus Pollnau and Stuart D. Jackson
Table 3. Examples of luminescent transitions investigated as candidates for midinfrared lasers in sulfide fibers Ion 3+
Dy Tm3+ Ho3+ Dy3+ Tb3+ Ho3+
λLaser ( µm) 3.2 3.8 3.9 4.3 4.8 4.9
Transition
Ref.
H13/2 → H15/2 3 H5 → 3 H4 5 I5 → 5 H6 6 H11/2 → 6 H13/2 7 F5 → 7 F6 5 I4 → 5 I5
[155] [154] [153] [155] [154] [153]
6
6
for fiber-based applications; however, the purity and toxicity of the starting materials and the difficulty of making ultra-low loss fiber currently impede the widespread use of chalcogenide glass for mid-infrared fiber-laser applications. Once these obstacles have been overcome, future > 3-µm fiber lasers will most likely involve the rare-earth ions Pr3+ , Nd3+ , Dy3+ , and Ho3+ doped into chalcogenide glass because most of the important mid-infrared transitions relevant to these ions can be accessed with pump-photon wavenumbers < 10 000 cm−1 . Judicious choice of the overall dopant-ion concentration and the use of particular sensitizer and quenching ions will enable the production of efficient > 3 µm output some time in the future.
9
Conclusions
On our journey through the forest of the various established and yet to be demonstrated mid-infrared fiber lasers, we have found that the shorter the wavelength, the better is the laser performance. When we approach longer wavelengths in the mid-infrared spectrum, we find that the quality and durability of the required low-phonon-energy fibers decline, Stokes and slope efficiencies decrease, whereas the thermal problems increase. The assumption that due to its large surface-to-volume ratio, the fiber geometry might avoid all thermal problems has been questioned by several recent high-power fiberlaser experiments in the near- and mid-infrared spectral region. All the above phenomena are not much different from the situation found in crystalline lasers. Nevertheless, there remain distinct differences between these two host categories. When flexibility of the resonator design, short pulses, and high peak powers are required, the fiber shows some disadvantages. On the other hand, fiber lasers are preferred when high beam quality or low pump threshold combined with medium CW output power are desired. The low pump threshold is an invaluable advantage when cascade-laser operation is required to depopulate the long-lived terminating level of one laser transition by a second laser transition. The comparatively low dopant concentrations that are useful in fiber lasers due to the long interaction lengths can minimize energy dissipation by interionic processes but, equally true, limit the exploitation of
Mid-Infrared Fiber Lasers
245
these processes as a tool to optimize the population mechanisms of a certain laser system. Although still a great challenge with respect to the fabrication process, chalcogenide-glass fibers have the potential to revolutionize CW midinfrared lasers in the wavelength range between 3–5 µm.
References 1. A. E. Siegman: Lasers (University Science Books, Mill Valley, CA 1986) 220 2. O. Svelto: Principles of Lasers, 3rd ed. (Plenum Press, New York 1989) 220 3. M. J. F. Digonnet (Ed.): Rare-Earth-Doped Fiber Lasers and Amplifiers, 2nd ed. (Marcel Dekker, New York 2001) 220, 221, 230 4. R. Reisfeld, M. Eyal: Possible ways of relaxations for excited states of rare earth ions in amorphous media, J. Phys. (Paris) 46, C349 (1985) 221 5. T. Schweizer: Rare-earth-doped gallium lanthanum sulphide glasses for midinfrared fibre lasers, Dissertation, University of Hamburg, Germany (1998) 221 6. D. C. Brown, H. J. Hoffman: Thermal, stress, and thermo-optic effects in high average power double-clad silica fiber lasers, IEEE J. Quantum Electron. 37, 207 (2001) 221, 226 7. L. Wetenkamp: Charakterisierung von laseraktiv dotierten Schwermetallfluorid-Gl¨ asern und Faserlasern, Dissertation, Technical University of Braunschweig, Germany (1991) 221, 222 8. S. M. Lima, T. Catunda, R. Lebullenger, A. C. Hernandes, M. L. Baesso, A. C. Bento, L. C. M. Miranda: Temperature dependence of thermo-optical properties of fluoride glasses determined by thermal lens spectrometry, Phys. Rev. B 60, 15173 (1999) 221 9. S. M. Lima, T. Catunda, M. L. Baesso, L. D. Vila, Y. Messaddeq, E. B. Stucchi, S. J. L. Ribeiro: Thermal-optical properties of Ga:La:S glasses measured by thermal lens technique, J. Non-Cryst. Solids 247, 222 (1999) 221 10. B. J. Ainslie, S. P. Craig, S. T. Davey: The absorption and fluorescence spectra of rare earth ions in silica-based monomode fiber, J. Lightwave Technol. 6, 287 (1988) 221 11. S. D. Jackson, T. A. King: CW operation of a 1.064 µm pumped Tm-Ho-doped silica fiber laser, IEEE J. Quantum Electron. 34, 1578 (1998) 221, 236 12. O. Humbach, H. Fabian, U. Grzesik, U. Haken, W. Heitmann: Analysis of OH absorption bands in synthetic silica, J. Non-Cryst. Solids 203, 19 (1996) 222 13. D. C. Tran, G. H. Sigel, Jr., B. Bendow: Heavy metal fluoride glasses and fibers: a review, J. Lightwave Technol. 2, 566 (1984) 222 14. P. W. France, M. G. Drexhage, J. M. Parker, M. W. Moore, S. F. Carter, J. V. Wright: Fluoride Glass Optical Fibres (Blackie, Glasgow 1990) 222 15. S. T. Davey, P. W. France: Rare earth doped fluorozirconate glasses for fibre devices, BT Technol. J. 7, 58 (1989) 222 16. M. Monerie, F. Alard, G. Maze: Fabrication and characterisation of fluorideglass single-mode fibres, Electron. Lett. 21, 1179 (1985) 222 17. L. Wetenkamp, G. F. West, H. T¨ obben: Optical properties of rare earth-doped ZBLAN glasses, J. Non-Cryst. Solids 140, 35 (1992) 222 18. Y. D. Huang, M. Mortier, F. Auzel: Stark level analysis for Er3+ -doped ZBLAN glass, Opt. Mater. 17, 501 (2001) 222
246
Markus Pollnau and Stuart D. Jackson
19. P. N. Kumta, S. H. Risbud: Rare-earth chalcogenides – an emerging class of optical materials, J. Mat. Sci. 29, 1135 (1994) 222 20. J. S. Sanghera, J. Heo, J. D. Mackenzie: Chalcohalide glasses, J. Non-Cryst. Solids 103, 155 (1988) 222 21. L. D. DeLoach, R. H. Page, G. D. Wilke, S. A. Payne, W. F. Krupke: Transition metal-doped zinc chalcogenides: Spectroscopy and laser demonstration of a new class of gain media, IEEE J. Quantum Electron. 32, 885 (1996) 222 22. L. B. Shaw, B. Cole, P. A. Thielen, J. S. Sanghera, I. D. Aggarwal: Mid-wave IR and long-wave IR laser potential of rare-earth doped chalcogenide glass fiber, IEEE J. Quantum Electron. 48, 1127 (2001) 222 23. Y. D. West, T. Schweizer, D. J. Brady, D. W. Hewak: Gallium lanthanum sulphide fibers for infrared transmission, Fiber Integrated Opt. 19, 229 (2000) 222 24. J. Heo, Y. B. Shin: Absorption and mid-infrared emission spectroscopy of Dy3+ in Ge-As (or Ga)-S glasses, J. Non-Cryst. Solids 196, 162 (1996) 222 25. J. R. Lu, T. Murai, K. Takaichi, T. Uematsu, K. Misawa, M. Prabhu, J. Xu, K. Ueda, H. Yagi, T. Yanagitani, A. A. Kaminskii, A. Kudryashov: 72 W Nd:Y3 Al5 O12 ceramic laser, Appl. Phys. Lett. 78, 3586 (2001) 222 26. J. Lu, J. Lu, T. Murai, K. Takaichi, T. Uematsu, K. Ueda, H. Yagi, T. Yanagitani, T. Works, A. A. Kaminskii: Optical properties and highly efficient laser oscillation of Nd:Y2 O3 ceramics, in CLEO Europe, OSA Tech. Digest (Opt. Soc. Am., Washington, DC 2002), p. 60 223 27. G. Huber, V. Peters, K. Petermann: New solid-state lasers based on rare-earth doped sesquioxide crystals, in CLEO Europe 2000, OSA Tech. Digest (Opt. Soc. Am., Washington, DC 2000) p. 386 223 28. B. N. Samson, P. A. Tick, N. F. Borrelli: Efficient neodymium-doped glassceramic fiber laser and amplifier, Opt. Lett. 26, 145 (2001) 223 29. H. Po, E. Snitzer, R. Tumminelli, L. Zenteno, F. Hakimi, N. M. Cho, T. Haw: Doubly clad high brightness Nd fiber laser pump by GaAlAs phased array, in Proc. Optical Fibre Communication Conf. (1989) paper PD7 223 30. H. Po, J. D. Cao, B. M. Laliberte, R. A. Minns, R. F. Robinson, B. H. Rockney, R. R. Tricca, Y. H. Zhang: High power neodymium-doped single transverse mode fibre laser, Electron. Lett. 29, 1500 (1993) 223 31. I. N. Duling III, W. K. Burns, L. Goldberg: High-power superfluorescent fiber source, Opt. Lett. 15, 33 (1990) 223 32. J. D. Minelly, W. L. Barnes, R. I. Laming, P. R. Morkel, J. E. Townsend, S. G. Grubb, D. N. Payne: Diode-array pumping of Er3+ /Yb3+ co-doped fiber lasers and amplifiers, IEEE Photonics Technol. Lett. 5, 301 (1993) 223 33. H. M. Pask, J. L. Archambault, D. C. Hanna, L. Reekie, P. S. J. Russell, J. E. Townsend, A. C. Tropper: Operation of cladding-pumped Yb3+ -doped silica fibre lasers in 1 µm region, Electron. Lett. 30, 863 (1994) 223 34. A. Liu, K. Ueda: The absorption characteristics of circular, offset, and rectangular double-clad fibers, Opt. Commun. 132, 511 (1996) 224 35. H. Zellmer, U. Willamowski, A. T¨ unnermann, H. Welling, S. Unger, V. Reichel, H.-R. M¨ uller, T. Kirchhof, P. Albers: High-power CW neodymiumdoped fiber laser operating at 9.2 W with high beam quality, Opt. Lett. 20, 578 (1995) 224 36. A. Ankiewicz, W. L. R. Perera, P. L. Chu, D. A. C. C. Jayasinghe: Use of graded elliptical cladding for efficient pumping of doped fiber cores, Opt. Commun. 133, 82 (1997) 224
Mid-Infrared Fiber Lasers
247
37. D. Kouznetsov, J. V. Moloney, E. M. Wright: Efficiency of pump absorption in double-clad fiber amplifiers. I. Fiber with circular symmetry, J. Opt. Soc. Am. B 18, 743 (2001) 224 38. M. H. Muendel: Optimal inner cladding shapes for double-clad fiber lasers, in CLEO 9, OSA Tech. Digest Ser. (Opt. Soc. Am., Washington, DC 1996), p. 209 224 39. A. Liu, K. Ueda: Propagation losses of pump light in rectangular double-clad fibers, Opt. Eng. 35, 3130 (1996) 224 40. V. Doya, O. Legrand, F. Mortessagne: Optimized absorption in a chaotic double-clad fiber amplifier, Opt. Lett. 26, 872 (2001) 224 41. P. Glas, M. Naumann, A. Schirrmacher, Th. Pertsch: The multicore fiber – a novel design for a diode pumped fiber laser, Opt. Commun. 151, 187 (1998) 224 42. P. Glas, M. Naumann, A. Schirrmacher: A novel design for a high brightness diode pumped fiber laser source, Opt. Commun. 122, 163 (1996) 224 43. G. P. Lees, D. Taverner, D. J. Richardson, L. Dong, T. P. Newson: Q-switched erbium doped fibre laser utilising a novel large mode area fibre, Electron. Lett. 33, 393 (1997) 224 44. K. Furusawa, A. Malinowski, J. H. V. Price, T. M. Monro, J. K. Sahu, J. Nilsson, D. J. Richardson: Cladding pumped ytterbium-doped fiber laser with holey inner and outer cladding, Opt. Express 9, 714 (2001) 224 45. T. A. Birks, J. C. Knight, P. St. J. Russell: Endlessly single-mode photonic crystal fiber, Opt. Lett. 22, 961–963 (1997) 224 46. D. J. Ripin, L. Goldberg: High efficiency side-coupling of light into optical fibres using imbedded v-grooves, Electron. Lett. 31, 2204 (1995) 225 47. T. Weber, W. L¨ uthy, H. P. Weber, V. Neuman, H. Berthou, G. Kotrotsios: A longitudinal and side-pumped single transverse mode double-clad fiber laser with a special silicone coating, Opt. Commun. 115, 99 (1995) 225 48. C. C. Cook, T. Y. Fan: Spectral beam combining of Yb-doped fiber lasers in and external cavity, in Trends Opt. Photonics Adv. Solid-State Lasers 26, 163–166 (Opt. Soc. Am., Washington, DC 1999) 225 49. W. A. Clarkson, V. Matera, T. M. J. Kendall, D. C. Hanna, J. Nilsson, P. W. Turner: High-power wavelength-combined cladding-pumped Tm-doped silica fibre lasers, in Conference on Lasers and Electro-Optics, OSA Technical Digest, Vol. 56 (Optical Society of America, Washington, DC 2001) pp. 363– 364 225 50. S. J. Augst, A. K. Goyal, R. L. Aggarwal, T. Y. Fan, A. Sanchez: Wavelength beam combining of ytterbium fiber lasers in a MOPA configuration, in CLEO, OSA Tech. Digest (Opt. Soc. Am., Washington, DC 2002) pp. 594–595 225 51. V. Dominic, S. MacCormack, R. Waarts, S. Sanders, S. Bicknese, R. Dohle, E. Wolak, P. S. Yeh, E. Zucker: 110 W fibre laser, Electron. Lett. 35, 1158 (1999) 225 52. J. Limpert, A. Liem, S. H¨ ofer, H. Zellmer, A. T¨ unnermann, S. Unger, S. Jetschke, H.-R. M¨ uller: 150 W Nd/Yb codoped fiber laser at 1.1 µm, in CLEO, OSA Tech. Digest (Opt. Soc. Am., Washington, DC 2002), pp. 590– 591 225 53. M. Pollnau, P. J. Hardman, M. A. Kern, W. A. Clarkson, D. C. Hanna: Upconversion-induced heat generation and thermal lensing in Nd:YLF and Nd:YAG, Phys. Rev. B 58, 16076 (1998) 226
248
Markus Pollnau and Stuart D. Jackson
54. M. K. Davis, M. J. F. Digonnet, R. H. Pantell: Thermal effects in doped fibers, J. Lightwave Technol. 16, 1013 (1998) 226 55. L. Zenteno: High-power double-clad fiber lasers, J. Lightwave Technol. 11, 1435 (1993) 226 56. N. A. Brilliant, K. Lagonik: Thermal effects in a dual-clad ytterbium fiber laser, Opt. Lett. 26, 1669 (2001) 226 57. B. R. Judd: Optical absorption intensities of rare-earth ions, Phys. Rev. 127, 750 (1962) 228 58. G. S. Ofelt: Intensities of crystal spectra of rare-earth ions, J. Chem. Phys. 37, 511 (1962) 228 59. L. A. Riseberg, H. W. Moos: Multiphonon orbit–lattice relaxation of excited states of rare-earth ions in crystals, Phys. Rev. 174, 429 (1968) 230 60. J. M. F. van Dijk, M. F. H. Schuurmans: On the nonradiative and radiative decay rates and a modified exponential energy gap law for 4f –4f transitions in rare-earth ions, J. Chem. Phys. 78, 5317 (1983) 230 61. D. L. Dexter: A theory of sensitized luminescence in solids, J. Chem. Phys. 21, 836 (1953) 230 62. T. Miyakawa, D. L. Dexter: Phonon sidebands, multiphonon relaxation of excited states, and phonon-assisted energy transfer between ions in solids, Phys. Rev. B 1, 2961 (1970) 230 63. V. P. Gapontsev, N. S. Platonov: Migration-accelerated quenching of luminescence in glasses activated by rare-earth ions, Mater. Sci. Forum 50, 165 (1989) 231 64. W. J. C. Grant: Role of rate equations in the theory of luminescent energy transfer, Phys. Rev. B 4, 648 (1971) 232 65. E. Delevaque, T. Georges, M. Monerie, P. Lamouler, J.-F. Bayon: Modeling of pair-induced quenching in erbium-doped silicate fibers, IEEE Photonics Technol. Lett. 5, 73 (1993) 232 66. J. L. Wagener, P. F. Wysocki, M. J. F. Digonnet, H. J. Shaw, D. J. DiGiovanni: Effects of concentration and clusters in erbium-doped fiber lasers, Opt. Lett. 18, 2014 (1993) 232 67. R. S. Quimby, W. J. Miniscalco, B. Thompson: Clustering in erbium-doped silica glass fibers analyzed using 980 nm excited-state absorption, J. Appl. Phys. 76, 4472 (1994) 232 68. E. Maurice, G. Monnom, B. Dussardier, D. B. Ostrowsky: Clustering-induced nonsaturable absorption phenomenon in heavily erbium-doped silica fibers, Opt. Lett. 20, 2487 (1995) 232 69. M. Pollnau, D. R. Gamelin, S. R. L¨ uthi, H. U. G¨ udel, M. P. Hehlen: Power dependence of upconversion luminescence in lanthanide and transition-metalion systems, Phys. Rev. B 61, 3337 (2000) 232 70. R. A. Hayward, W. A. Clarkson, P. W. Turner, J. Nilsson, A. B. Grudinin, D. C. Hanna: Efficient cladding-pumped Tm-doped silica fibre laser with high power singlemode output at 2 µm, Electron. Lett. 36, 711 (2000) 232, 234, 235 71. S. D. Jackson: 8.8 W diode-cladding-pumped Tm3+ , Ho3+ -doped fluoride fibre laser, Electron. Lett. 37, 821 (2001) 232, 235, 236 72. R. G. Smart, J. N. Carter, A. C. Tropper, D. C. Hanna: Continuous-wave oscillation of Tm3+ -doped fluorozirconate fibre lasers at around 1.47 µm, 1.9 µm and 2.3 µm when pumped at 790 nm, Opt. Commun. 82, 563 (1991) 232, 234
Mid-Infrared Fiber Lasers
249
73. S. D. Jackson, T. A. King, M. Pollnau: Diode-pumped 1.7-W erbium 3 µm fiber laser, Opt. Lett. 24, 1133 (1999) 232, 240, 241, 242 74. T. Sumiyoshi, H. Sekita, T. Arai, S. Sato, M. Ishihara, M. Kikuchi: Highpower continuous-wave 3- and 2 µm cascade Ho3+ :ZBLAN fiber laser and its medical applications, IEEE J. Sel. Topics Quantum Electron. 5, 936 (1999) 232, 237 75. C. Carbonnier, H. T¨ obben, U. B. Unrau: Room temperature CW fibre laser at 3.22 µm, Electron. Lett. 34, 893 (1998) 232, 243 76. H. T¨ obben: CW-lasing at 3.45 µm in erbium-doped fluorozirconate fibers, Frequenz 45, 250 (1991) 232, 243 77. J. Schneider, C. Carbonnier, U. B. Unrau: Characterization of a Ho3+ -doped fluoride fiber laser with a 3.9 µm emission wavelength, Appl. Opt. 36, 8595 (1997) 232, 243 78. R. M. Percival, S. F. Carter, D. Szebesta, S. T. Davey, W. A. Stallard: Thuliumdoped monomode fluoride fibre laser broadly tunable from 2.25 to 2.5 µm, Electron. Lett. 27, 1912 (1991) 233, 235 79. D. C. Hanna, I. M. Jauncey, R. M. Percival, I. R. Perry, R. G. Smart, P. J. Suni, J. E. Townsend, A. C. Tropper: Continuous-wave oscillation of a monomode thulium-doped fibre laser, Electron. Lett. 24, 1222 (1988) 233 80. W. L. Barnes, J. E. Townsend: Highly tunable and efficient diode pumped operation of Tm3+ doped fibre lasers, Electron. Lett. 26, 746 (1990) 233 81. J. N. Carter, R. G. Smart, D. C. Hanna, A. C. Tropper: CW diode-pumped operation of 1.97 µm thulium-doped fluorozirconate fibre laser, Electron. Lett. 26, 599 (1990) 233 82. T. Y. Fan, G. Huber, R. L. Byer, P. Mitzscherlich: Spectroscopy and diode laser-pumped operation of Tm,Ho:YAG, IEEE J. Quantum Electron. 24, 924 (1988) 233, 235 83. R. C. Stoneman, L. Esterowitz: Efficient, broadly tunable, laser-pumped Tm:YAG and Tm:YSGG CW lasers, Opt. Lett. 15, 486 (1990) 233 84. D. C. Hanna, R. M. Percival, R. G. Smart, A. C. Tropper: Efficient and tunable operation of a Tm-doped fibre laser, Opt. Commun. 75, 283 (1990) 234 85. L. E. Nelson, E. P. Ippen, H. A. Haus: Broadly tunable sub-500 fs pulses from an additive-pulse mode-locked thulium-doped fiber ring laser, Appl. Phys. Lett. 67, 19 (1995) 234 86. R. C. Sharp, D. E. Spock, N. Pan, J. Elliot: 190-fs passively mode-locked thulium fiber laser with a low threshold, Opt. Lett. 21, 881 (1996) 234, 235 87. S. D. Jackson, T. A. King: High-power diode-cladding-pumped Tm-doped silica fiber laser, Opt. Lett. 23, 1462 (1998) 234 88. D. C. Hanna, I. R. Perry, J. R. Lincoln, J. E. Townsend: A 1-Watt thuliumdoped CW fibre laser operating at 2 µm, Opt. Commun. 80, 52 (1990) 234 89. P. S. Golding, S. D. Jackson, P.-K. Tsai, B. C. Dickinson, T. A. King: Efficient high power operation of a Tm-doped silica fiber laser pumped at 1.319 µm, Opt. Commun. 175, 179 (2000) 234 90. T. Yamamoto, Y. Miyajima, T. Komukai: 1.9 µm Tm-doped silica fibre laser pumped at 1.57 µm, Electron. Lett. 30, 220 (1994) 234 91. R. M. Percival, D. Szebesta, C. P. Seltzer, S. D. Perrin, S. T. Davey, M. Louka: 1.6 µm semiconductor diode pumped thulium doped fluoride fibre laser and amplifier of very high efficiency, Electron. Lett. 29, 2110 (1993) 234
250
Markus Pollnau and Stuart D. Jackson
92. T. Yamamoto, Y. Miyajima, T. Komukai, T. Sugawa: 1.9 µm Tm-doped fluoride fiber amplifier and laser pumped at 1.58 µm, Electron. Lett. 29, 986 (1993) 234 93. S. D. Jackson, T. A. King: Theoretical modeling of Tm-doped silica fiber lasers, J. Lightwave Technol. 17, 948 (1999) 234 94. J. Q. Xu, M. Prabhu, L. Jianren, K. Ueda, D. Xing: Efficient double-clad thulium-doped fiber laser with a ring cavity, Appl. Opt. 40, 1983 (2001) 234 95. K. S. Lai, P. B. Phua, R. F. Wu, Y. L. Lim, E. Lau, S. W. Toh, B. T. Toh, A. Chng: 120-W continuous-wave diode-pumped Tm:YAG laser, Opt. Lett. 25, 1591 (2000) 234 96. R. Allen, L. Esterowitz: CW diode pumped 2.3 µm fiber laser, Appl. Phys. Lett. 55, 721 (1989) 234 97. J. Y. Allain, M. Monerie, H. Poignant: Tunable CW lasing around 0.82, 1.48, 1.88 and 2.35 µm in thulium-doped fluorozirconate fibre, Electron. Lett. 25, 1660 (1989) 234 98. R. M. Percival, D. Szebesta, S. T. Davey: Highly efficient and tunable operation of 2 color Tm-doped fluoride fiber laser, Electron. Lett. 28, 671 (1992) 235 99. K. Tanimura, M. D. Shinn, W. A. Sibley, M. G. Drexhage, R. N. Brown: Optical transitions of Ho3+ ions in fluorozirconate glass, Phys. Rev. B 30, 2429 (1984) 235 100. J. K. Tyminski, D. M. Franich, M. Kokta: Gain dynamics of Tm:Ho:YAG pumped in near infrared, J. Appl. Phys. 65, 3181 (1989) 235 101. V. A. French, R. R. Petrin, R. C. Powell, M. Kokta: Energy-transfer processes in Y3 Al5 O12 :Tm,Ho, Phys. Rev. B 46, 8018 (1992) 235 102. L. B. Shaw, R. S. F. Chang, N. Djeu: Measurement of up-conversion energytransfer probabilities in Ho:Y3 Al5 O12 and Tm:Y3 Al5 O12 , Phys. Rev. B 50, 6609 (1994) 235 103. M. C. Brierley, P. W. France, C. A. Millar: Lasing at 2.08 µm and 1.38 µm in a holmium doped fluorozirconate fiber laser, Electron. Lett. 24, 539 (1988) 236 104. D. C. Hanna, R. M. Percival, R. G. Smart, J. E. Townsend, A. C. Tropper: Continuous-wave oscillation of holmium-doped silica fiber laser, Electron. Lett. 25, 593 (1989) 236 105. A. S. Kurkov, E. M. Dianov, O. I. Medvedkov, G. A. Ivanov, V. A. Aksenov, V. M. Paramonov, S. A. Vasiliev, E. V. Pershina: Efficient silica-based Ho3+ fibre laser for 2 µm spectral region pumped at 1.15 µm, Electron. Lett. 36, 1015 (2000) 236 106. J. Y. Allain, M. Monerie, H. Poignant: High-efficiency CW thulium-sensitized holmium-doped fluoride fiber laser operating at 2.04 µm, Electron. Lett. 27, 1513 (1991) 236 107. R. M. Percival, D. Szebesta, S. T. Davey, N. A. Swain, T. A. King: Thulium sensitized holmium-doped CW fluoride fiber laser of high-efficiency, Electron. Lett. 28, 2231 (1992) 236 108. K. Oh, T. F. Morse, A. Kilian, L. Reinhart, P. M. Weber: Continuous-wave oscillation of thulium-sensitized holmium-doped silica fiber laser, Opt. Lett. 19, 278 (1994) 236 109. Ch. Ghisler, W. L¨ uthy, H. P. Weber, J. Morel, A. Woodtli, R. D¨ andliker, V. Neuman, H. Berthou, G. Kotrotsios: A Tm3+ sensitized Ho3+ silica fibre laser at 2.04 µm pumped at 809 nm, Opt. Commun. 109, 279 (1994) 236
Mid-Infrared Fiber Lasers
251
110. C. Bollig, R. A. Hayward, W. A. Clarkson, D. C. Hanna: 2-W Ho:YAG laser intracavity pumped by a diode-pumped Tm:YAG laser, Opt. Lett. 23, 1757 (1998) 237 111. P. A. Budni, M. L. Lemons, J. R. Mosto, E. P. Chicklis: High-power/highbrightness diode-pumped 1.9 µm thulium and resonantly pumped 2.1 µm holmium lasers, IEEE J. Select. Topics Quantum Electron. 6, 629 (2000) 237 112. G. Rustad, K. Stenersen: Modeling of laser-pumped Tm and Ho lasers accounting for upconversion and ground-state depletion, IEEE J. Quantum Electron. 32, 1645 (1996) 237 113. L. Wetenkamp: Efficient CW operation of a 2.9 µm Ho3+ -doped fluorozirconate fiber laser pumped at 640 nm, Electron. Lett. 26, 883 (1990) 237 114. T. Sumiyoshi, H. Sekita: Dual-wavelength continuous-wave cascade oscillation at 3 and 2 µm with a holmium-doped fluoride-glass fiber laser, Opt. Lett. 23, 1837 (1998) 237 115. T. Rothacher, W. L¨ uthy, H. P. Weber: Diode pumping and laser properties of Yb,Ho:YAG, Opt. Commun. 155, 68 (1998) 237 116. A. Diening, P. E.-A. M¨ obert, E. Heumann, G. Huber, B. H. T. Chai: Diodepumped CW lasing of Yb,Ho:KYF4 in the 3 µm spectral range in comparison to Er:KYF4 , Laser Phys. 8, 214 (1998) 237 117. B. Peng, T. Izumitani: Ho3+ doped 2.84 µm laser glass for laser knives, sensitised by Yb3+ , Rev. Laser Eng. 22, 9 (1994) 237 118. M. Robinson, P. D. Devor: Thermal switching of laser emission of Er3+ at 2.69µ and Tm3+ at 1.86µ in mixed crystals of CaF2 :ErF3 :TmF∗3 , Appl. Phys. Lett. 10, 167 (1967) 238 119. K. S. Bagdasarov, V. I. Zhekov, V. A. Lobachev, T. M. Murina, A. M. Prokhorov: Steady-state emission from a Y3 Al5 O12 :Er3+ laser (λ = 2.94 µm, T = 300 K), Kvant. Elektr. (Moscow) 10, 452 (1983) [Engl. transl. Sov. J. Quantum Electron. 13, 262 (1983)] 238 120. M. C. Brierley, P. W. France: Continuous wave lasing at 2.71 µm in an erbiumdoped fluorozirconate fibre, Electron. Lett. 24, 935 (1988) 238 121. R. S. Quimby, W. J. Miniscalco: Continuous-wave lasing on a self-terminating transition, Appl. Opt. 28, 14 (1989) 238 122. M. Pollnau, S. D. Jackson: Erbium 3 µm fiber lasers, IEEE J. Select. Topics Quantum Electron. 7, 30 (2001) 238, 241 123. V. Lupei, S. Georgescu, V. Florea: On the dynamics of population inversion for 3 µm Er3+ lasers, IEEE J. Quantum Electron. 29, 426 (1993) 238 124. J. Schneider: Kaskaden-Faserlaser im mittleren Infrarot, Dissertation, Technical University Braunschweig (Cuvillier, G¨ ottingen 1996) 238 125. B. C. Dickinson, P. S. Golding, M. Pollnau, T. A. King, S. D. Jackson: Investigation of a 791-nm pulsed-pumped 2.7 µm Er-doped ZBLAN fibre laser, Opt. Commun. 191, 315 (2001) 238 126. N. J. C. Libatique, J. Tafoja, N. K. Viswanathan, R. K. Jain, A. Cable: ‘Fieldusable’ diode-pumped ≈ 120 nm wavelength-tunable CW mid-IR fibre laser, Electron. Lett. 36, 791 (2000) 238 127. R. C. Stoneman, J. G. Lynn, L. Esterowitz: Direct upper-state pumping of the 2.8 µm Er3+ :YLF laser, IEEE J. Quantum Electron. 28, 1041 (1992) 238 128. R. S. Quimby, W. J. Miniscalco, B. Thompson: Excited state absorption at 980 nm in erbium doped glass, in Fiber Laser Sources and Amplifiers III, Proc. SPIE 1581, 72–79 (1991) 238
252
Markus Pollnau and Stuart D. Jackson
129. S. Bed¨ o, M. Pollnau, W. L¨ uthy, H. P. Weber: Saturation of the 2.71 µm laser output in erbium doped ZBLAN fibers, Opt. Commun. 116, 81 (1995) 238 130. M. Pollnau, Ch. Ghisler, W. L¨ uthy, H. P. Weber: Cross-sections of excitedstate absorption at 800 nm in erbium-doped ZBLAN fiber, Appl. Phys. B 67, 23 (1998) 238, 239 131. J. Schneider, D. Hauschild, C. Frerichs, L. Wetenkamp: Highly efficient Er3+ :Pr3+ -Co-doped CW fluorozirconate fiber laser operating at 2.7 µm, Int. J. Infrared Millimeter Waves 15, 1907 (1994) 238, 240 132. J. Schneider: Mid-infrared fluoride fiber lasers in multiple cascade operation, IEEE Photonics Technol. Lett. 7, 354 (1995) 238 133. P. S. Golding, S. D. Jackson, T. A. King, M. Pollnau: Energy-transfer processes in Er3+ -doped and Er3+ ,Pr3+ -codoped ZBLAN glasses, Phys. Rev. B 62, 856 (2000) 238, 240, 242 134. M. Pollnau, Ch. Ghisler, G. Bunea, M. Bunea, W. L¨ uthy, H. P. Weber: 150 mW unsaturated output power at 3 µm from a single-mode-fiber erbium cascade laser, Appl. Phys. Lett. 66, 3564 (1995) 239 135. M. Pollnau, Ch. Ghisler, W. L¨ uthy, H. P. Weber, J. Schneider, U. B. Unrau: Three-transition cascade erbium laser at 1.7, 2.7, and 1.6 µm, Opt. Lett. 22, 612 (1997) 239 136. J. Y. Allain, M. Monerie, H. Poignant: Energy transfer in Er3+ /Pr3+ -doped fluoride glass fibres and application to lasing at 2.7 µm, Electron. Lett. 27, 445 (1991) 240 137. L. Wetenkamp, G. F. West, H. T¨ obben: Co-doping effects in erbium3+ - and 3+ holmium -doped ZBLAN glass, J. Non-Crystal. Solids 140, 25 (1992) 240 138. M. Pollnau: The route toward a diode-pumped 1-W erbium 3 µm fiber laser, IEEE J. Quantum Electron. 33, 1982 (1997) 240 139. S. D. Jackson, T. A. King, M. Pollnau: Modelling of high-power diode-pumped erbium 3 µm fibre lasers, J. Mod. Opt. 47, 1987 (2000) 240 140. B. Srinivasan, J. Tafoya, R. K. Jain: High-power ‘watt-level’ CW operation of diode-pumped 2.7 µm fiber lasers using efficient cross-relaxation and energy transfer mechanisms, Opt. Express 4, 490 (1999) 240 141. S. D. Jackson, T. A. King, M. Pollnau: Efficient high power operation of erbium 3 µm fibre laser diode-pumped at 975 nm, Electron. Lett. 36, 223 (2000) 240, 242 142. M. Pollnau, R. Spring, Ch. Ghisler, S. Wittwer, W. L¨ uthy, H. P. Weber: Efficiency of erbium 3 µm crystal and fiber lasers, IEEE J. Quantum Electron. 32, 657 (1996) 241 143. Ch. Wyss, W. L¨ uthy, H. P. Weber, P. Rogin, J. Hulliger: Emission properties of an optimised 2.8 µm Er3+ :YLF laser, Opt. Commun. 139, 215 (1997) 241 144. M. Pollnau, R. Spring, S. Wittwer, W. L¨ uthy, H. P. Weber: Investigations on the slope efficiency of a pulsed 2.8 µm Er3+ :LiYF4 laser, J. Opt. Soc. Am. B 14, 974 (1997) 242 145. T. Jensen: Upconversion-Prozesse und Wirkungsquerschnitte in Er3+ -dotierten 3 µm Fluorid- und Granat-Lasern, gepumpt mit CW und quasi-CW Dioden-Arrays, Dissertation, University of Hamburg, Germany (1996) 242 146. M. Pollnau, S. D. Jackson: Energy recycling versus lifetime quenching in erbium-doped 3 µm fiber lasers, IEEE J. Quantum Electron. 38, 162 (2002) 242
Mid-Infrared Fiber Lasers
253
147. B. Srinivasan, E. Poppe, J. Tafoya, R. K. Jain: High-power (400 mW) diodepumped 2.7 µm Er:ZBLAN fibre lasers using enhanced Er-Er cross-relaxation processes, Electron. Lett. 35, 1338 (1999) 242 148. T. Sandrock, D. Fischer, P. Glas, M. Leitner, M. Wrage, A. Diening: Diodepumped 1-W Er-doped fluoride glass M-profile fiber laser emitting at 2.8 µm, Opt. Lett. 24, 1284 (1999) 242 149. R. Reisfeld: Chalcogenide glasses doped by rare earths: structure and optical properties, Ann. Chim. Fr. 7, 147 (1982) 243 150. S. R. Bowman, L. B. Shaw, B. J. Feldman, J. Ganem: A 7 µm praseodymiumbased solid-state laser, IEEE J. Quantum Electron. 32, 646 (1996) 243 151. J. Schneider: Fluoride fibre laser operating at 3.9 µm, Electron. Lett. 31, 1250 (1995) 243 152. W. H. Dumbaugh, J. C. Lapp: Heavy-metal oxide glasses, J. Am. Ceram. Soc. 75, 2315 (1992) 243 153. T. Schweizer, B. N. Samson, J. R. Hector, W. S. Brocklesby, D. W. Hewak, D. N. Payne: Infrared emission from holmium doped gallium lanthanum sulphide glass, Infrared Phys. Technol. 40, 329 (1999) 243, 244 154. T. Schweizer, B. N. Samson, J. R. Hector, W. S. Brocklesby, D. W. Hewak, D. N. Payne: Infrared emission and ion–ion interactions in thulium- and terbium-doped gallium lanthanum sulfide glass, J. Opt. Soc. Am. B 16, 308 (1999) 243, 244 155. T. Schweizer, D. W. Hewak, B. N. Samson, D. N. Payne: Spectroscopic data of the 1.8-, 2.9-, and 4.3 µm transitions in dysprosium-doped gallium lanthanum sulfide glass, Opt. Lett. 21, 1594 (1996) 243, 244 156. D. W. Hewak, J. A. Medeiros Neto, B. N. Samson, R. S. Brown, K. P. Jedrzejewski, J. Wang, E. Taylor, R. I. Laming, G. Wylangowski, D. N. Payne: Quantum-efficiency of praseodymium doped Ga:La:S glass for 1.3 µm optical fibre amplifiers, IEEE Photonics Technol. Lett. 6, 609 (1994) 243 157. C. C. Ye, D. W. Hewak, M. Hempstead, B. N. Samson, D. N. Payne: Spectral properties of Er3+ -doped gallium lanthanum sulphide glass, J. Non-Cryst. Solids 208, 56 (1996) 243 158. T. Schweizer, D. J. Brady, D. W. Hewak: Fabrication and spectroscopy of erbium doped gallium lanthanum sulphide glass fibres for mid-infrared laser applications, Opt. Express 1, 102 (1997) 243 159. T. Schweizer, B. N. Samson, R. C. Moore, D. W. Hewak, D. N. Payne: Rareearth doped chalcogenide glass fibre laser, Electron. Lett. 33, 414 (1997) 243 160. M. Asobe, T. Ohara, I. Yokohama, T. Kaino: Fabrication of Bragg grating in chalcogenide glass fibre using the transverse holographic method, Electron. Lett. 32, 1611 (1996) 243 161. R. Mossadegh, J. S. Sanghera, D. Schaafsma, B. J. Cole, V. Q. Nguyen, R. E. Miklos, I. D. Aggarwal: Fabrication of single-mode chalcogenide optical fiber, J. Lightwave Technol. 16, 214 (1998) 243 162. T. M. Monro, Y. D. West, D. W. Hewak, N. G. R. Broderick, D. J. Richardson: Chalcogenide holey fibres, Electron. Lett. 36, 1998 (2000) 243
Index
absorption, 222–224, 228 – coefficient, 224, 228 bleaching, 231 branching ratio, 228 broadening (lifetime), 227 cascade lasing, 237, 239 ceramics, 222, 223 chalcogenide, 222, 243 – glass, 232, 243, 244 cladding – pumped, 223 co-dopant, 240 co-doped, 231, 236, 240 core pumped, 223, 226, 228 cross-relaxation, 231, 233, 235–237, 240 cross-section, 228, 238 double-clad – fiber, 224, 226, 240 – geometry, 239 – pump, 224 Dy3+ , 243, 244 electric-dipole – transition, 228 emission cross-section, 222, 223, 228, 230 emission spectra, 228 energy migration, 231, 232 energy recycling, 241, 242 energy transfer, 230–232, 235, 237, 240 – upconversion (ETU), 231, 240–242 energy-level scheme, 227, 233, 235, 237, 239, 240 Er3+ , 223, 227, 232, 243 excited-state absorption (ESA), 228, 230, 238, 239
fluoride, 230 fluoride fiber , 222 fluoride glass, 222 – fluoride, 222 four-level – CW laser, 234 – fiber laser, 237 – laser, 240 – – transition, 238 GaLaS (GLS), 221, 222, 243 ground-state, 231 – bleaching, 228, 240 – transition, 233, 236 ground-state absorption (GSA), 228, 231, 235, 238 heat, 226 Ho3+ , 232, 243, 244 lanthanide, 227 laser, 234 – self-terminating, 231 – three-level, 234, 238 – transition-metal-ion-doped, 226 lifetime, 228, 230, 231 – quenching, 226 loss, 221, 223, 224, 243, 244 multiphonon – relaxation, 220, 222, 226, 228, 230 multiplet, 227, 228 Nd3+ , 223, 225, 243, 244 nonradiative decay, 228, 230 numerical aperture, 224 oxides, 230, 243
Index parity, 228 phonon energy, 220–222, 230, 232, 243 Pr3+ , 240, 243, 244 Pr3+ -co-doped, 240 pump, 224 pump absorption, 224, 226, 228 pump cladding, 223, 224 quantum efficiency, 220, 222, 226, 230, 234, 240 quenching, 231, 233, 240, 244 radiative decay, 228, 230 radiative transition, 228 rare-earth ion, 222, 226–228, 231, 243, 244 rare-earth solubility, 222 rare-earth-doped – chalcogenides, 222 – fiber laser, 232 – heavy-metal oxide, 243 – solid-state laser, 230, 231 rate constant, 228, 230 reabsorption, 226, 230, 234 recycling, 239, 240 refractive index, 222, 224 – fluctuation, 224 resonator, 225, 230 self-terminating laser, 231
255
self-terminating transition, 237 sensitizing, 231, 235–237, 244 silica, 221 – glass, 232 silicate, 222 slope efficiency, 232, 236, 238–242 solubility, 220, 222 spectral-line broadening, 222, 227, 228 Stark, 227, 233, 238 – component, 238 – level, 234 stimulated emission, 228, 230 Stokes efficiency, 234, 238–240 sulfide fiber, 244 sulfide glass, 222 Tb3+ , 243 thermal conductivity, 221–223 three-level laser, 234, 238 threshold, 228, 230, 234–236, 240, 243 Tm3+ , 232, 235–237, 243 transition-metal ion, 223, 226 transition-metal-ion-doped laser, 226 transparency, 220–222, 232 tunability, 234, 235, 238 – of lasers, 228 Yb3+ , 223, 225, 237 ZBLAN, 221–223, 228, 230, 232, 243
Crystalline Mid-Infrared Lasers Irina T. Sorokina Institut f¨ ur Photonik, Technische Universit¨ at Wien Gusshausstr. 27/387, A-1040 Vienna, Austria [email protected] Abstract. A survey of the well-established as well as newly emerging ion-doped crystalline lasers, operating in the mid-IR spectral range between 2 and 5 µm, is presented. The review includes rare-earth- and transition-metal-based ionic crystals, as well as color-center lasers. The emphasis is made on state-of-the-art compact all-solid-state room-temperature tunable sources, belonging to the broad class of vibronic lasers. The announcement of the efficient high-power room-temperature operation and super-broad tunability, as well as the possibility of generating ultrashort pulses from the novel class of chromium doped chalcogenide lasers led to a strong revival of research interest in vibronic laser systems, involving 3dn transition-metal ions. The review outlines the underlying physics of mid-IR lasers and sorts out the essential spectroscopic and laser characteristics, allowing assessment of the suitability of laser materials to serve as active media in diode-pumped laser systems.
1
Introduction
The purpose of this chapter is to review the existing crystalline lasers, covering the wavelength range roughly between 2 and 5 µm. Although various kinds of lasers are being considered, the emphasis is made on state-ofthe-art continuous-wave, diode-pumped and tunable lasers. These lasers are based on both rare-earth ion doped crystals, which usually operate at fixed wavelengths, but allow high-power operation, and transition-metal (TM) ion doped- and color-center crystals, allowing broad tuning and in some cases also ultrashort pulse generation. The bandwidth of the gain medium is therefore one of the most important parameters when reaching the operation threshold (especially in the diodepumped regime) and tuning are to be considered. Throughout this chapter, bandwidth will be understood as the full width at half maximum relative to the gain maximum at λ0 , i.e. ∆ λ/λ0 ≈ ∆ ν/ν0 . Besides the fact that this definition is the same in the wavelength and frequency domains, it also allows one to compare gain media with different central wavelengths. Figure 1 provides a fair comparison of the existing crystalline active media, having the broadest gain in a certain wavelength range at room temperature, going on the wavelength scale through the near-infrared to mid-IR range. For ultrashort pulse generation, (∆ λ/λ0 )−1 has the physical meaning of the number of optical cycles per pulse. I. T. Sorokina, K. L. Vodopyanov (Eds.): Solid-State Mid-Infrared Laser Sources, Topics Appl. Phys. 89, 255–351 (2003) c Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2003
Gain spectrum
256
Irina T. Sorokina Ti:Saph Cr:LiSGaF
700
1000
Cr:YAG
1400
Cr:ZnSe
2000
Tb:KPb2Cl5
3000
4500
6000
Wavelength (nm, log scale)
Fig. 1. Broadband gain media. The abscissa is a logarithmic scale, keeping the relative bandwidth ∆ λ/λ0 constant
The mid-IR (MIR) wavelength region, which is also often called the “molecular fingerprint” region, and in particular, the range between 2 and 5 µm is characterized by the presence of strong fundamental vibrational absorption lines of atmospheric constituents, vapors and other gases (see, e.g. Fig. 1 in the chapter by Fischer and Sigrist). Those include, e.g. water vapour (H2 O), filling the whole range between 2.5 and 3 µm with a maximum around 2.7 µm; carbon monoxide (CO) with strong features around 2.3–2.4 µm; carbon dioxide (CO2 ) absorbing around 2.7–2.8 µm and 4.3 µm; nitrous oxide (N2 O), having several absorption features all through the 2–4 µm range, as well as many other species. Detection of low concentrations of these and other molecules (for details see the chapter by Richter et al.), constituting air pollutants or green-house gases for the purpose of environmental diagnostics or even human breath for the purpose of medical diagnostics, is currently done using laser systems, which are based mainly on nonlinear optical conversion techniques and include optical parametric oscillators (OPO, see the chapters by Vodopyanov and by Ebrahinzadeh) and difference-frequency generators (DFG, see the chapter by Fischer and Sigrist). Semiconductor lasers, including heterojunction lasers, lead-salt, antimonide and quantum cascade laser sources, are probably the simplest and the most cost-effective sources in the mid-IR wavelength region. However, except for a few cases they require cryogenic cooling and provide limited output power levels. Crystalline solidstate lasers, on the other hand, can provide very high power levels retaining good beam quality and narrow spectral linewidth. In combination with nearinfrared diode lasers as pump sources these lasers [1,2] can offer stability, efficiency and compactness as well as broad spectral coverage and tuning ranges, which are generally inaccessible for semiconductor lasers. Therefore, the availability of room-temperature diode-pumped tunable solid-state lasers as a simple and compact alternative in this wavelength region is a significant step forward in remote sensing and trace gas detection, as well as in other applications. Furthermore, the ultrabroad gain bandwidth of some laser crystals allows generation of ultrashort pulses of only a few optical cycles. This makes these lasers attractive for such applications as mid-IR free-space communica-
Crystalline Lasers
257
tions, optical frequency standards, as well as optical coherence tomography (OCT) in medicine. Further medical applications of mid-IR solid-state lasers include tissue cutting and welding, ophthalmology, neurosurgery, etc. (see the chapter by Jean and Bende). Summarizing, numerous applications in the mid-IR benefit from the development of the low-cost rugged broadly tunable solid-state lasers. The chapter is organized as follows. After a brief introduction and description of the historical evolution of these lasers (Sect. 2), the chapter provides the spectroscopic background necessary to understand the basics of laser operation of tunable crystalline lasers (Sect. 3) starting with the differences between rare-earth and transition-metal ion spectroscopy in octahedral and tetrahedral positions. The next sections give a systematic account of the available combinations of active ions and crystalline hosts (Sect. 3.1.1), of the commonly used pump sources, tuning and mode-locking techniques as well as power scaling approaches (Sect. 4). Although the used laser techniques are similar to those used in the visible and near-infrared regions, an attempt to simply extend those towards the mid-IR spectral region causes a number of new aspects and problems, requiring considerable modification of the experimental techniques and reconsideration of the existing theories (like e.g., in the case of Kerr-lens mode-locking). Other sections review existing continuous-wave and pulsed lasers.
2
Historical Overview
The first discussion of the feasibility of the infrared solid-state laser technique appeared in a paper by Schawlow and Townes in 1958 [3]. Crystalline lasers have played an important role in the history of lasers in general, and midIR lasers in particular. Indeed, chromium ions in a sapphire host has been a key player in laser devices since the first demonstration of the ruby laser (Cr3+-doped Al2 O3 ) by Maiman in 1960 [4,5]. Ironically, the very first brief Letter to Physical Review Letters titled “Optical maser action in ruby” was rejected by the editor, and was finally published in Nature [4]. A ruby laser is an example of a three-level system, and at that time could be operated only in the pulsed regime. In the same year Sorokin and Stevenson built the first mid-IR pulsed laser, which was based on calcium fluoride doped with trivalent uranium [6]. This laser operated at 2.6 µm with xenon flash-lamp pumping and liquid helium cooling. Later improvements in crystal quality permitted operation at room temperature. The U3+:CaF2 laser was a typical example of a fourlevel system. Shortly afterwards in 1962 Kiss and Duncan announced the successful operation of another mid-IR system, dysprosium-doped calcium fluoride at 2.36 µm [7]. This laser could be operated both pulsed and continuous-wave (CW) [7,8] and was pumped by a xenon flash-lamp. Sunlight has also been
258
Irina T. Sorokina
used to pump dysprosium-doped calcium fluoride cooled by liquid hydrogen [10]. Another interesting peculiarity of this material is the slow decrease of the active ion concentration of the divalent dysprosium, Dy2+, due to the valence change to Dy3+. Apart from this negative effect, preventing the longterm use of this material, until recently this was the only laser operating in the very interesting, for many applications, 2.3 µm water window wavelength range. The first tunable continuous-wave solid-state lasers to be demonstrated were those based on the divalent 3d transition-metal ions. In 1963 laser operation of nickel and cobalt ions in fluoride hosts was demonstrated at Bell Labs by Johnson, Dietz and Guggenheim [11]. The flash-lamp pumped Ni2+:MgF2 laser operated around 1.6 µm. A year later laser operation of Co2+:MgF2 and Co2+:ZnF2 was achieved by the same authors in the wavelength range between 1.75 and 2.16 µm [12]. Later, the operation of Ni2+ and Co2+ in several other hosts was reported [13,14]. However, all these media were characterized by low effective emission cross-sections. In the case of Ni2+-doped crystals this was due to excited state absorption. The only way to increase gain in these materials was to increase the upper laser level lifetime by cooling the crystal. Therefore, in order to be operated, all these lasers required cryogenic cooling. This, in part, hindered the commercial development of these very useful devices. The further advent of laser pumping allowed the tight focusing of the pump beam into the laser medium and therefore partially compensated for the low emission cross-section. Using laser pumping, CW operation has been achieved in Co2+ as well as in Ni2+-doped MgF2 [15,16]. Later also room-temperature operation was achieved by Welford and Moulton [17]. The discovery of color-center lasers (otherwise called F-center lasers), which may also be attributed to the class of broadly tunable vibronic lasers, was an important event in the solid-state laser community. The available tunable range of the color-centers in alkali halide crystals spans the mid-IR region between 2.3 and 4 µm [18]. When cryogenically cooled and optically pumped, these laser crystals have low threshold pump powers, relatively high output powers, and are smoothly and broadly tunable. In single-mode CW operation color-center lasers have extremely narrow spectral linewidths; in modelocked operation they can provide ultrashort pulses (down to < 50 fs [19]). In the 1970s and 1980s, F-center lasers, including commercial ones, found widespread use in various applications, especially in high-resolution spectroscopy requiring high spectral or temporal resolution, and in frequency standards. However, the main drawbacks of this type of source include the use of an insulating vacuum, and the necessity of cryogenic cooling, especially in the mid-IR region. Room-temperature color-center lasers exist nowadays only in the visible and near-infrared regions up to 1.3 µm [20]. This problem is similar to that of Co2+ and Ni2+-doped crystals, and is the reason for the decline of interest in these devices in recent years.
Crystalline Lasers
259
Another important group of ions includes rare-earth ions such as Tm3+, Ho3+ and Er3+, operating in the mid-IR spectral region at a whole number of wavelengths around 1.6, 2, and 3 µm. Limited continuous tunability is possible in lasers based on these ions, and is connected with the vibronic (i.e. phonon assisted) nature of the involved transitions. However, one should note that vibronic line broadening in lanthanide ions is much weaker than that in transition-metal ions due to the much lower interaction of ions with the lattice crystalline field. The pioneering works on Tm, Ho- and Er-doped crystalline media go back to 1962, when Johnson et al. reported the laser operation of Tm and Ho in CaWO4 at 2 µm [22,21] and Kiss and Duncan reported the operation of Er in the same crystal at 1.6 µm [24]. Those were the major milestones in the development of mid-IR crystalline (insulating) lasers during their first “discovery” or “pioneering” period. The discovered ions could be divided into four major groups: transitionmetals (e.g., Ni2+, Co2+ ), divalent and trivalent lanthanides (Dy, Er, Ho,Tm), actinides (U3+ ), and F-centers. In order to broaden the absorption pump bands of the ions, thus increasing laser efficiency, Voron’ko et al. suggested a new type of host matrix, which was a mixed disordered system (solid solution) [25]. This concept was further successfully used to develop both tunable and ultrashort-pulsed lasers. This way even femtosecond pulse generation became possible from the rather narrow-band rare-earth ions [26]. During this period, most important information on the physics of stimulated emission in crystals was accumulated. The experimental and theoretical methods known from maser pyhsics were extended towards lasers. The theoretical basis for the operation of broadly tunable lasers on vibronic transitions was established [27,28]. The maser concept of a three- and four-level scheme was successfully implemented in lasers. In the following two decades a burst of studies on the new laser materials took place, and hundreds of new laser types, operating at various wavelengths, were developed. For an extensive collection of existing crystalline laser materials and commonly used crystalline lasers the reader is referred to the books by Kaminskii [29] and Koechner [30]. The variety of energy levels of active ions provided the possibility of creating different complex excitation schemes, including step-wise excitation based on upconversion and cross-relaxation [31,32,33,34], cascaded excitation [35] and sensitization of the active ion with another ion/s, absorbing the pump energy and transferring it to the upper laser level (see, e.g. [36]). The term “crystal engineering” has become common in the laser community, and indeed active media could be very often “engineered” to possess specific spectroscopic and thermo-mechanical properties necessary to develop a new laser in the required wavelength range [37]. During the last decade the solid-state laser field was driven by a number of factors. Those include the invention of laser- and especially diodepumping [1], opening the possibilities for the creation of compact, room-
260
Irina T. Sorokina
temperature tunable sources, the success of the CW tunable and ultrashort pulsed Ti:sapphire laser [38], and the appearance of new applications for such sources. Crystals doped with Tm3+ (e.g., Tm3+:YAG, Tm3+:YLF, Tm3+:YVO4 and Tm3+:YSGG) provide tunable CW operation between 1.86 and 2.3 µm [39,40] and those doped with Er3+ can operate around the 2.7– 2.9 µm wavelength range which is very interesting for medical applications. Huber et al. [41] and Fan [42] were the first to report the room-temperature laser- and diode-pumped operation of Tm, Ho, and Er-doped garnets. Pulses as short as 40 ps could be obtained from Er-containing media [43] and 25 ps from Tm-containing mixed garnets [44]. However, when speaking about tunability and ultrashort pulse generation the priority should certainly be given to the new class of vibronic materials, Cr2+-doped II-VI compounds, that was first suggested in the mid-1990s by the group of scientists at the Lawrence Livermore Laboratory [45,46,47]. This type of lasers allows high-power room-temperature continuous-wave operation [48] tunable over more than 1000 nm between 2 and 3 µm. The principles of operation and description of the existing state-of-the-art Er, Tm, and Hodoped oxide and fluoride, as well as Cr-doped chalcogenide lasers will be given in the following sections of this chapter. All through the chapter crystalline solid-state lasers will be referred to as just “solid-state lasers”.
3
Principles of Solid-State Lasers
In this section the spectroscopic background will be provided to the extent that is necessary to understand the principles of laser operation and the characteristic features distinguishing tunable, mainly vibronic active media, from their fixed-wavelength counterparts (for a detailed recent spectroscopyrelated review see [49]). Vibronic lasers are those that operate on the transitions that involve the simultaneous absorption or emission of both photons and phonons. The emission bandwidth exceeds the energy of the maximum phonon in such media. Usually these are lasers based on transition-metal ions (exceptions are rare-earth ions such as Ce3+, Eu2+, Sm2+ or Yb3+ [50], but they are not known to lase in the mid-IR). Although it exists (see e.g. [51]), the vibronic broadening in rare-earth ion-doped crystals is much smaller than in transition-metal doped crystals. However, noticeable tunability can also be achieved in this group of crystals. The available bandwidth in this case is determined by the combined action of vibronic interaction, significant Stark splitting, and sometimes inhomogeneous broadening due to the multicenter nature of the mixed solid-solutions (see e.g. [25,52]). Nevertheless, when going into the infrared the relative contribution of the phonons to the transition (in energy units) becomes larger, and eventually, all fixed-wavelength (in the visible) lasers become broadband and potentially tunable.
Crystalline Lasers
3.1
261
Spectroscopic Background
The rare-earth ions, which operate in the mid-IR range, include: the trivalent lanthanides Tm, Ho, Er, Dy, Pr, Tb, Nd; divalent Dy and the trivalent actinide U. To the present moment the wavelength range, covered by the paramagnetic ions (with incomplete electronic shells) in crystals extends up to 7.2 µm [53]. The successfully operating tunable transition metal ions are divalent Co, Ni, Cr, and Fe in fluorides and chalcogenides. 3.1.1 Ion-Host Interaction: Octahedrally versus Tetrahedrally Coordinated Ions, Energy Levels, Configurational-Coordinate Model The lanthanide rare-earth ions have filled 4d, 5s, 5p, and 6s shells, and the valence electrons enter either 4f or occasionally 5d shells. Because of the better stability the rare-earth ions in crystals have a strong tendency to be incorporated in the trivalent state. The valence electrons form bonds with the neighboring fluorine or oxygen atoms. The remaining optically active 4f electrons are shielded from the surrounding crystalline environment by the filled 5s and 5p shells. The filled shells are spherically symmetric and do not affect the 4f electrons. Therefore, there is only limited interaction with the crystalline field. Due to the shielding by the outer shell electrons, the crystal field splitting is treated in the weak-field limit, and the spin–orbit coupling is the most significant interaction that determines the free-ion multiplets. The free-ion Hamiltonian H can be written as a sum of the unperturbed Hamiltonian H0 of the interaction of each electron with a nucleus, a Hamiltonian Hcoul of the Coulomb interaction of electrons with each other, and a Hamiltonian Hso of the spin–orbit coupling. For an ion inside the host an additional term describing the interaction with the crystalline field Hcryst is added, and the overall Hamiltonian becomes equal to [54,55] H = H0 + Hcoul + Hso + Hcryst .
(1)
As can be seen in Fig. 2 in rare-earth ions (weak crystal field limit [55]) the magnitude of the Coulomb and the spin–orbit couplings is approximately equal and is of the order of tens of thousands of wave numbers. The Stark splitting due to the crystalline field is much smaller and is of the order of hundreds of wave numbers. The energy levels of rare-earth ions generally retain the character of the corresponding levels of the triply ionized rare earth ions in a gas, and change only slightly from host to host. Therefore, it is justified to use the well-known and very useful Dieke diagram [56] to estimate the relative position of the multiplets and the widths of the Stark splittings in crystals. Figure 3 provides a simplified Dieke diagram, containing only the levels of the rare-earth ions discussed in this chapter, which are relevant to the tunable mid-IR operation. For a detailed overview the reader is referred to [57,58,56,54].
262
Irina T. Sorokina
F r e e io n
C o u lo m b fie ld
C r y s ta l fie ld
F 5
4 f1
S p in - o r b it in te r a c tio n
S 5
~ 1 0 0 0 0 c m 0
-1
I4 5 5
5
I 5
5 2 0 0 c m
-1
5
E le c tr o n c o n fig u r a tio n
T e rm s
M u ltip le ts
I5 I6 5 I7
1 7 s u b le v e ls (1 5 o b s e rv e d ) 4 7 0 c m
I8
-1
S ta rk c o m p o n e n ts
Fig. 2. The effect of the crystalline field on the energy level splitting in lanthanide ions in the 4f electron shell. The terms and numbers on the graph correspond to the Ho3+ in the YSGG crystal
In contrast to lanthanide ions, where the optically active ions have transitions in the inner 4f electron shell, the actinide rare-earth ions have partially filled 5f shells. Therefore, they are more sensitive to the crystalline environment. As a result, these ions can be found in various, up to 6+, ionization states. The radioactivity of these ions restricted their use to trivalent uranium in various fluorides: CaF2 [6,59], BaF2 [60], SrF2 [61] and YLF [62]. Similarly to transition-metal ions their spectroscopic properties depend more on the crystalline host environment, and vibronic line broadening plays a correspondingly larger role. The Stark splitting is larger and the f –f transitions are stronger for actinides than for lanthanides. For example, the ground 4 I9/2 level of U3+ in YLF is split to 1113 cm−1 , favoring the four-level operation scheme [63]. The relatively smooth emission spectrum extends between 2.2 and 2.8 µm, and laser action has been observed at various wavelengths in this range depending upon the host. There exists a large potential for U3+-doped fluorides as tunable mid-IR lasers. In 1994 room-temperature CW laser operation at 2.8 µm was demonstrated in YLF [62]. However, the interest in this laser revived at that time did not find further development, most probably due to the discovery in 1995 of a new class of tunable lasers in the same wavelength range: transition-metal doped chalcogenides [45,46,47]. In order to get a better understanding of the influence of the host on the spectral characteristics of an ion let us consider as an example a typical laser host such as a garnet. Garnets have a stoichiometric formula A3 B2 C3 O12 , comprising an eight-fold coordinated (relative to oxygen) dodecahedral A site, a six-fold octahedral B site and a four-fold tetrahedral C site [64,65,66]. The elementary cell contains eight such formula units. Most of the trivalent rare-earth ions of interest are incorporated into the dodecahedral and octahedral sites (Fig. 4) and are surrounded by a set of nearest-neighbor oxygen ions (ligands). Analogously, in the case of a fluorite host this is a set of fluo-
Crystalline Lasers
263
Fig. 3. Simplified Dieke diagram (rare-earth ions in LaCl3 ) [56]
rine ions. As can be seen in Fig. 4 the dodecahedral sites are the largest and therefore are usually occupied by the largest ions. The rare-earth ions usually enter dodecahedral and octahedral sites and transition-metal ions prefer octahedral and tetrahedral sites. The consequence of this site preference rule is illustrated in the following: with a decrease of the ionic radii from Ho3+ to Er3+ and Tm3+ (rare-earth ions with larger atomic number have smaller ionic radii, this is known as lanthanide contraction [58]) an increase in the occupation probability of the octahedral site takes place. This leads to multiple sites for these ions (see e.g. [68,69,70]), and as a result, to inhomogeneous line broadening. Although the multisite occupation is generally considered
264
Irina T. Sorokina
- o x y g e n a n - o c ta h e d ra - te tra h e d ra - d o d e c a h e
io n s l s ite s l s ite s d r a l s ite s
Fig. 4. Oxygen polyhedra in a garnet host, forming octahedral, tetrahedral, and dodecahedral sites (after [66])
to be a negative feature for a laser, this is certainly a positive feature for tunability purposes. Now let us consider the most common tunable laser media based on 3d–3d transitions of transition-metal ions of the iron group, which are most sensitive to the crystalline environment. This is so, because in contrast to lanthanides, where the active ions are characterized by the optical transitions of the electrons in the inner 4f electron shell, which is shielded from the crystalline field, the optical transitions in transition-metal ions occur in the outer, open 3d-shell. The interaction of transition-metal ions with the crystalline host creates broad absorption and emission bands, which are finally used to tune the laser. Therefore knowledge of the mechanisms of such interaction is important for understanding the principles of tunable solid-state lasers. The active ions interact with the ligands through an electrostatic Coulomb interaction. This ion–host interaction had been treated by several theories. Bethe [71] introduced crystal-field theory [71]. Later Van Vleck and coworkers proposed an alternative theory based on covalent bonding [72,73]. Nowadays it is known as ligand-field theory [74]. In spite of the drawbacks and shortcomings of this elegant and rather simple theory, the description of which is beyond the scope of this review, it provides a useful tool for analysis of spectroscopic information (for details see [75,55]). This theory allows us to qualitatively predict the crystal-field splitting of the free ion energy levels due to a certain type of crystal-field symmetry at the ion’s site. The quantitative prediction of the Stark splitting of the levels is more difficult. Nevertheless, very often it is adequate to reduce the problem to the simplified point charge model, where the active ions and the ligands are point charges, possessing specific symmetry. In this case the active ion experiences the crystal field determined by the symmetry of the ligand environment. Figure 5
Crystalline Lasers
265
Fig. 5. Ion arrangements producing electrostatic crystalline fields of octahedral, tetrahedral, and cubic symmetry (after [55])
shows the three typical ion arrangements of the specific symmetries: octahedral, tetrahedral and cubic. One uses to say that the active ions occupy then the octahedral, the tetrahedral and the cubic sites. Among the common laser crystals the most frequently occupied sites are those of octahedral and tetrahedral symmetry. However, in reality there is usually a distortion from the perfect octahedron or tetrahedron and the site has lower symmetry. Usually one considers the crystal field as consisting of two components: a strong octahedral (or tetrahedral) component and a weaker one of lower symmetry, which is considered as a perturbation in the perturbation theory analysis of the energy levels. In contrast to the rare-earth ions, where the crystalline field is relatively weak because of the screening effect of the electrons in the outer shells, in the case of transition-metal ions the crystalline field is stronger or comparable to the Coulomb interaction between the 3d electrons, and the latter is stronger than the spin–orbit coupling interaction. This holds true for the intermediate and strong crystal field limit characteristic of transition-metal ions [55]. Therefore the position of the energy levels E is calculated as a function of the crystal-field strength Dq (parameters D and q always occur as a product, and hence Dq can be regarded as a single parameter) and of the Racah parameters B and C. The latter reflect the Coulomb interaction between the ion and the ligands [55]. The Tanabe–Sugano diagrams [76,77] for the 3dn configuration for n = 2 to 8 show the dependence of the level energy E/B on the crystalline field Dq/B at the fixed value of C/B. Both the level energy, which is measured from the ground level, and the strength of the crystalline field are scaled by B as a unit. The elegance of the Tanabe–Sugano representation consists in the certain symmetry. Indeed, the energy levels of the ions in the 3dn configuration are inverted relative to those in the 3d10−n configuration. This is so because the Coulomb energy of the electrostatic interaction between the n positive charges is the same as that between n negative charges. Hence, the free ion energy levels are the same in both systems, but the interaction energy between the positive charges and the crystalline field will be opposite in sign to that for the negative charges. Moreover, all the calculations of crystal field splittings for the case of octahedral coordination can be used for the case of tetrahedral coordination with the same ion-to-ligand distance. One only needs to reverse
266
Irina T. Sorokina
the sign of the parameter Dq and reduce its value according to the following rule [55]: Dq (tetrahedral) = −4/9 Dq (octahedral) .
(2)
The conclusion that can be drawn from this general rule is that the energy levels of the ions in the tetrahedral coordination experience smaller energy splittings due to the crystalline field. This results in the correspondingly longer wavelength optical transitions. The parameter C/B mentioned above is almost constant through the transition metal series. In addition, the B parameter is of the order of 1000 cm−1 for all known ions [37]. Thus, Tanabe–Sugano diagrams also allow an approximate quantitative analysis of energy level structures of all transition-metal ions in almost any crystalline environment. Examples of Tanabe–Sugano diagrams for mid-IR active ions such as Co2+ ions in octahedral sites, occurring, e.g. in the Co2+:MgF2 laser and corresponding to the 3d7 configuration, and Cr2+ ions in tetrahedral sites, used e.g. in various chalcogenide crystals and corresponding to the 3d4 configuration, can be found in Fig. 6. The left scale shows the splitting energy both in E/B units and in cm−1 , using the empirical values of the B parameter. The lines on the diagram represent different energy levels and are classified according to their spin state and group symmetry. In addition, the corresponding electronic configurations are given in parentheses. It is easily seen that the
Fig. 6. Tanabe–Sugano diagrams for (a) octahedrally coordinated Co2+ ions (3d7 configuration) and (b) tetrahedrally coordinated Cr2+ ions (3d4 configuration). Free-ion terms are shown to the left of the diagram. Energy levels with different spin states are shown by lines with different thickness. Both ions experience low crystalline field (Dq/B < 1.1 for most hosts). The transition, marked as ESA, is spin-allowed for the Co2+ ion, but is spin-forbidden for the Cr2+ ion. Only a part of the full diagram [76] is shown, corresponding to lower energies, that are relevant to the mid-IR transitions
Crystalline Lasers
267
energy intervals between the levels belonging to the same configurations tend to be rather independent of the Dq/B (the lines go almost parallel), while energy intervals of levels, belonging to different configurations, depend strongly on crystal field strength (the tilts of the lines are different). This has a major implication on spectral parameters of the ions: as will be seen later, the absorption and emission lines corresponding to the transition between states with the same electronic configuration tend to be narrow-band, and those corresponding to transitions involving configuration change are broadband. A typical example of the d4 (Cr2+ ) configuration in tetrahedral symmetry is shown in Fig. 6b. The lowest free-ion 5 D state of Cr2+ is split by the crystal field potential by an amount defined as the crystal field splitting ∆ = 10Dq into an excited orbital doublet 5 E and a ground-state orbital triplet 5 T2 , where Dq =
Ze2 r4 . 24πa5
(3)
Here, Ze is the charge on the ligand ion, is the dielectric susceptibility, a is the distance between the ion and the ligand, and r4 is the matrix element for the 3d-orbital, where r is the distance from the ion nucleus. Both the orbital triplet ground- and the orbital doublet excited states are further split by the Jahn–Teller effect [78,79,80], which plays a large role in spectroscopic properties of transition metal ion doped crystals (e.g. in Ti:sapphire [38], as well as in Cr:ZnSe and other chalcogenides [81,82,83,84,85]). The Jahn–Teller theorem was formulated in 1937 and states that “any non-linear molecular system in a degenerate electronic state will be unstable and will undergo distortion to form a system of lower symmetry and lower energy thereby removing the degeneracy”. The simple crystal-field treatment fails to take into account the Jahn–Teller splitting. It is therefore important to treat the lattice as a dynamic system coupled to the electronic d shell of the active ion. One of the results of this coupling to the lattice is to allow Jahn–Teller deformation at the impurity ion site. These Jahn–Teller effects can be either of dynamic or static type [86,87,88]. The magnitudes of these deformations can be derived from group-theoretical considerations. It is not the purpose of this paper to go into details of this phenomenon. It is only worth noting that the splitting of the ground state and the excited states (amounting in some cases to several hundreds of wavenumbers) caused by the Jahn–Teller effect should always be kept in mind, when considering tunable transitionmetal doped lasers. As an example of the influence of such splitting on the laser characteristics, one may consider the passive losses in Cr:ZnSe at the laser wavelength of 2.5 µm [165]. The absorption around 2.5 µm arises from the overlap between the absorption band due to 5 T2 → 5 E transition and the transition within the ground state 5 T2 due to the static Jahn–Teller effect around 6.6 µm [89,81]. As a result, losses due to ground-state absorption (GSA) within the ground state are intrinsic to Cr:ZnSe crystals and provide an upper limit for the figure of merit (FOM) of this material. A characteristic
268
Irina T. Sorokina
such as FOM is a useful parameter, describing the optical quality of the lasing material. It is commonly defined as the ratio between the attenuation at the maximum of the absorption to the attenuation at the lasing wavelength. This value differs in various laser materials, achieving ∼ 100 or more in good ones. It should also be noted that transitions of the ion in a tetrahedral site are generally stronger. Strictly speaking the transitions between energy levels of the 3dn configuration are transitions of the same parity and therefore obey the Laporte rule [90], i.e. are electric-dipole forbidden. This selection rule can be weakened as a result of the influence of odd-parity crystal-field terms, which mix the d and p orbitals, having different parity. In the centrosymmetric octahedral sites, odd-parity crystal-field terms may occur due to the small site symmetry distortion, or in the presence of vibronic (vibrational and electronic) coupling between wavefunctions with opposite parities. During vibrations the ion spends part of its time away from its equilibrium position, i.e. it is no longer at a center of symmetry. In contrast to the octahedral site case, in tetrahedral sites the crystal field has no inversion symmetry, the mixing of orbitals is strong, the Laporte rule does not strictly apply and the transitions are characterized by the much higher oscillator strength. The oscillator strength f is connected to the absorption coefficient k by the following relation: mc k(ν)dν , (4) f= πN e2 where N is the number of active centres per cubic centimeter, ν is the frequency in Hz, and m and e are the mass and the charge of the electron correspondingly. Since k(ν) = σ abs N , where σ abs is the absorption crosssection, the above expression for the oscillator strength relates it to σ abs or the inverse radiative lifetime τ rad by the following relation: 8π 2 e2 ν 2 f. (5) τ rad mc3 Indeed, transition-metal ions in tetrahedral sites are characterized by transition cross-sections that are generally higher than in octahedral sites and the shorter lifetimes. Compare, e.g. the absorption cross-section in Cr3+:LiCAF [91], which is of the order of 2·10−20 cm2 , with that in the tetrahedraly coordinated Cr2+:ZnSe or Cr2+:ZnS, which is of the order of 10−18 cm2 . Such high cross-sections and short lifetimes may be good for CW and ultrashort-pulsed operation, but may in some cases be disadvantageous because of the decreased energy storage capability of the short-lived media. Finally, the tetrahedral sites provide lower crystal-field stabilization of the ions than the octahedral sites [92]. Covalent bonding plays larger role in the tetrahedral sites, causing the frequently observed multiple valence states of the transition-metal ions in these sites and the high probability of chargetransfer processes. Indeed, whereas in octahedral sites internal e ↔ t2 transitions do not significantly redistribute the charge around the active ion (i.e., 1
=
Crystalline Lasers
269
both the initial and the final one-electron wave functions are almost equally localized around the impurity, hence the term “internal” transitions), in covalent tetrahedral sites such excitations can redistribute the charge from impurity-centered orbitals (i.e. essentially purely d-like e states) to ligandcentered orbitals (i.e., p-d hybridized t2 states) [93,94]. They are, therefore, not really “internal” transitions. This is especially true for tetrahedrally coordinated Cr2+ ions in II–VI compounds, which are used as broadly tunable crystalline active media in the mid-IR wavelength range. As has been recently shown, the related charge transfer processes in some cases may affect the laser performance of tunable CW lasers with the active ions in tetrahedral sites [95,96,97,98]. For the analysis of the vibronic line bandwidth the ion in the crystalline environment can be approximated by a one-dimensional harmonic oscillator. In Fig. 7, the potential energies of the ion in different electronic states are shown as parabolae along a generalized configurational coordinate, corresponding to one of the irreducible vibrational modes of the lattice. As the electronic wavefunctions in the upper and lower states are different, the equilibrium positions of the ion along the vibrational coordinate may not be the same. As electronic transitions occur on a time scale much faster than vibrational movement of heavy ions (the Born–Oppenheimer or adiabatic approximation), absorption and emission of photons leaves the ion in an excited vibrational state. The excess energy ∆ E is transferred nonradiatively to the phonons of the lattice, causing a Stokes shift ≈ 2∆ E between absorption and emission photon energies. For laser oscillation purposes, it is advantageous to have ∆ E kT so that the thermal population of the lower laser level is low (four-level laser scheme). Large ∆ E also increases the transition bandwidth (∆ λ/λ0 ∝ ∆ E/E0 ) and the laser tuning range. At the same time, the two parabolic potential curves eventually intersect at some higher energy, allowing thermally activated nonradiative decay with activation energy Eact (Fig. 7), which inversely scales with the Stokes shift Eact ∝ E02 /∆ E. The detailed description of the nonradiative decay processes is not the pur-
Fig. 7. Energy level diagram in configuration space, indicating the four-level nature of the vibronic laser
270
Irina T. Sorokina
pose of this chapter and can be found in [55,99,100,101]. The nonradiative decay rate 1/τnr rapidly increases with temperature, having an exponential asymptotic dependence of ≈ exp(Eact /kT ) at higher temperatures. Thus, the large Stokes shift causes a high nonradiative decay rate and the condition ∆ E E0 should be fulfilled. In the mid-IR spectrum range the photon energy hν = E0 − ∆ E is small, so that the combination of the two conditions E0 ∆ E kT can hold only at low temperatures. In the case of rare-earth ions, which have a negligible shift of their electronic energy parabolae along the configurational coordinate, the competition from nonradiative decay processes may also become significant. The analytical form of the nonradiative decay rate is different from transition-metal ions and is governed by the direct multiphonon processes, having the form: 1 = Wnr (p)(n(ω, T ) + 1)p , τnr
(6)
where p = ∆ E/¯ hω is the number of phonons with frequency ω necessary to bridge the energy gap, n(ω, T ) = [exp(¯ hω/kT ) − 1]−1 is the mean thermal occupancy in this vibrational mode, and Wnr (p) exponentially decreases with p [55]. Thus, the nonradiative decay rate depends on the maximum phonon frequency of the lattice. Table 1 summarizes the typical values of the maximum phonon energies for various mid-IR laser materials. As can be seen from the table, one should expect the earliest (at the shortest wavelength) onset of the nonradiative decay in oxides, then in fluorides, and only afterwards in selenides, chlorides and bromides. As has been recently confirmed in comprehensive experimental and theoretical studies of multiphonon relaxation processes in rare-earth ions carried out by Basiev and co-workers [102,103,104,105,106,107,108] as well as by Auzel and co-workers (see e.g. [109,110,111]), an increase of the anion and cation atom mass and increase of the lattice parameter decreases the maximum phonon frequency and increases the number of phonons. According to formula (6) this leads to a decrease of the nonradiative decay rate and an increase of the fluorescence quantum yield. Thus, the heavier the ions of the lattice, the slower the multiphonon relaxation rate. Besides, there exists a strong dependence of this rate on the distance R0 between the rare-earth ion and the nearest ligands and the rare-earth ionic radius ri . The shorter R0 and the larger ri the faster the multiphonon relaxation rate is [105]. The larger the Stark splitting of rare-earth ion energy levels and the larger the matrix elements of the respective electronic transition the faster the multiphonon relaxation rate is [107]. Knowledge of these tendencies allows a directed search for new active media in the mid-IR region. Thus, nonradiative decay is one of the most important processes for midIR crystalline lasers. It sets the fundamental limit for obtaining continuouswave room-temperature laser operation from vibronic transitions at longer wavelengths. In fact, until the invention of Cr.ZnSe type materials there were no broadband lasers in the mid-IR wavelength range operating at room tem-
Crystalline Lasers
271
Table 1. Maximum phonon frequencies of different compounds Crystalline host
Oxides
Fluorides Selenides Chlorides Iodides Bromides
Maximum phonon 600–1200 350–650 frequency, cm−1
∼ 250
200–300
∼ 160
∼ 140
perature. Even narrowband fixed-wavelength lasers seldom operate at roomtemperature beyond 3 µm. 3.1.2 Intra- and Interionic Interactions: Ground-State Absorption, Excited-State Absorption and Upconversion In this final part of the section devoted to the overview of the spectroscopic background such processes as ground-state absorption (GSA), excited-state absorption (ESA) and upconversion will be defined. The relative contributions of the last two processes in the population dynamics of the upper laser level are different for broadband transition-metal ion-doped and rare-earth ion-doped crystals. ESA generally plays a large role in broadband materials, and upconversion is an important interionic process in narrow-band (longlived) media. Both can be considered as a loss mechanism (the exception is the use of upconversion in the multistage population of the upper laser level, described, e.g. in chapter by Pollnau and Jackson in this volume) in a laser. The GSA is an intraionic process, describing the absorption of a photon from the ground state. It is usually measured in a spectrophotometer and obeys the Lambert–Beer law: I(λ) = I0 (λ)e−nσGSA (λ)l ,
(7)
where n is the active ion concentration, σGSA (λ) is the GSA cross-section, and l is the active medium length. Spectroscopists use the GSA absorption spectra in order to obtain information on the position of the ion energy levels relative to the ground state and on the magnitude of the oscillator strength f of the transition. The ESA is another intraionic process, describing the absorption of a photon by the ion in the excited state, whereas the ion is excited into an even higher-lying state. As can be seen from Fig. 8, when the offset between the configuration curves of the first and second excited states is large (which is often the case in many transition-metal doped crystals), ESA appears as a broad band. It is a two-step excitation process and is sometimes referred to as reversed saturable absorption or nonlinear absorption. ESA is usually measured using the pump-probe technique, which is best described in [115]. Using this technique one measures the difference in the transmitted inten-
272
Irina T. Sorokina
Fig. 8. Configurational coordinate description of the broadband ESA
sities between the pumped and unpumped (Ip − Iu ) cases relative to the intensity in the pumped case Ip , which is equal to [115]: Ip (λ) − Iu (λ) = C [σGSA (λ) + σ(λ) − σESA (λ)] , Ip (λ)
(8)
where σGSA is the GSA cross-section, σESA is the ESA cross-section, σ is the emission cross-section, and C is a constant, which includes the sample thickness l, the population density in the excited state nexc and the lock-in amplification factor A, i.e. C = Anexc l. From (8), σESA is given by [49]: σESA (λ) = σ(λ) + σGSA (λ) −
1 Ip (λ) − Iu (λ) . C Ip (λ)
(9)
This method of determination of ESA is most widely used. However, it has some deficiencies because of the impossibility of precisely measuring the constituting parameters as well as the necessity of providing optimal pump and probe beam overlap. Another recently suggested alternative method of ESA measurement, which is partially free of the above deficiencies, is based on a relaxation oscillation study [116,117] (for the detailed treatment of relaxation oscillations in a laser see, e.g. [113]). This method is based on the fact that relaxation oscillations parameters ω, frequency, and 2γ, spectral width, both depend on pump in the excited-state absorption cross-section at the pump wavelength σESA the following way: (r − 1) , τ pump −1 σESA r n th 2γ = , 1+ 1− τ Nt σGSA
ω 2 τc =
(10)
(11)
Crystalline Lasers
273
where r is the relative pump rate, τc is the photon lifetime in the resonator, τ is the metastable state lifetime, n th is the critical inversion, Nt is the total concentration of the active ions, and σGSA is the pump absorption cross-section. The latter method has an advantage of being insensitive to misalignment or not optimal overlap between pump and probe beams, but requires knowledge of the relative threshold inversion. It can be quite sensitive to the fluctuations of the pump source if these occur close to the relaxation oscillation frequency and should better to be used in directly diode-pumped systems. Upconversion, opposite to ESA, is an interionic process and involves interaction of at least two ions, both being in the excited state. It was extensively studied in the mid-1960s, including the pioneering works by Ovsyankin et al. [118,119,120,121,122]. In the course of nonradiative energy transfer between ions in close proximity, the first ion is excited into an even higher-lying level and the second one relaxes to the ground state (Fig. 9a). In other words, the low-energy photons are converted to higher-energy photons in the course of the energy transfer. Therefore, one sometimes refers to upconversion as energy transfer upconversion (ETU). However, one should distinguish upconversion from two other ways of conversion of low-energy photons to high-energy photons. This is, first, a two-step photon absorption (Fig. 9b) that involves pumping of the upper laser level via ESA [124,125], and second, the so-called avalanche absorption upconversion process (Fig. 9c) that involves both ESA of the pump light and interionic cross-relaxation [126]. Within this chapter we limit our treatment to the first type of process, in the following referred to simply as upconversion. The opposite process is called cross-relaxation [34]. The latter is a unique process, allowing luminescence quantum yields greater than unity [123]. This process plays a major role in the population of the upper laser level in such rare-earth mid-IR lasers as Tm- and Er-doped lasers. At high active ion concentrations upconversion can be considered as a nonlinear process: its efficiency increases with the increase of the excited ion concentration n. According to the simplified and frequently used upconversion model the process rate has a dn/dt = −αn2 dependence [127], where the upconversion macroparameter α is an effective interaction rate constant between
hn2
hn1
(a)
(b)
(c)
Fig. 9. Schematic illustration of (a) upconversion, (b) twostep photon absorption, and (c) avalanche absorption upconversion
274
Irina T. Sorokina
the excited ions. However, as shown in [127,128,129] in many practically important cases the experimental upconversion kinetics cannot be described in terms of αn2 . There might be different mechanisms of upconversion: a static mechanism corresponding to direct energy transfer from the donor to acceptor ion, and migration-assisted energy transfer corresponding to the case when excitation migrates over the subsystem of donor ions before it reaches an acceptor. Varying the overall ion concentration N , one can change the mechanism of nonlinear upconversion from migration-assisted to the static one in the same type of crystal. In the latter case the initial part of the upconversion kinetics can be reasonably well fitted by the simple model accounting for the three-particle upconversion interaction described in terms of α n3 . Therefore, in order to correctly describe upconversion one should always carefully take into account the microscopic interaction constants and other parameters of the system. In [130] the analytical formula, describing upconversion beyond the αn2 approximation was obtained and the boundary ion concentrations were determined, separating different upconversion regimes. The term αn2 enters the rate equations along with the decay term n/τ , so that the upconversion is most important in media with long (millisecond) lifetimes at high levels of excitation, when αn becomes comparable to the spontaneous decay rate 1/τ . These upconversion processes take place in all kinds of laser systems based on: rare-earth doped (e.g. in Ho3+-doped) systems [131,132], mixed rareearth and transition-metal doped (e.g. in Cr3+,Er3+-doped [133,134,135] or Cr3+,Tm3+,Ho3+-doped garnets [136,137]) as well as purely transition metal doped crystals [138]. However, the probability of upconversion is higher in crystals with several metastable excited states with rather long lifetimes. These conditions are best realized in rare-earth doped (i.e. fixed-wavelength) laser materials (for details see Sect. 3.1.1). The classical objects for the study of upconversion processes are Er3+ ions, having a long millisecond lifetime of the lowest excited states [139]. This is also the reason why upconversion was better studied in the rare-earth doped systems (for a review on upconversion lasers see e.g [140]). Summarizing this section, it can be concluded that whereas ESA is a predominant loss mechanism in transition-metal ion-doped crystals, upconversion plays a major role mainly in rare-earth doped laser materials. 3.1.3
Energy Transfer Processes
In this section various types of energy transfer processes, radiative as well as nonradiative, leading to population and depopulation of excited states in laser crystals are considered. The population dynamics is explained using the examples of the energy level schemes for commonly used mid-IR lasers such as 3 µm Er and 2 µm Tm, Ho lasers. For more information on energy transfer processes in laser crystals the reader is referred to the books [141,142,143,144].
Crystalline Lasers
275
Nonradiative energy transfer processes between active ions in laser crystals (usually referred to as “donors” and “acceptors”) play an important role in both inversion population of the upper laser level as well as in its depopulation [145]. In other words they influence both gain and loss. The loss issues will be discussed in Sect. 3.2. In this section some important schemes of inversion population creation will be considered. In the mid-IR region lasers based on crystals co-doped with Cr3+, Er3+, Tm3+, or Ho3+ are of importance as sources of CW, Q-switched and modelocked radiation around 2 and 3 µm. The type of the interaction between the broadband transition-metal ions and narrow-band rare-earth ions (3d–4f interaction) differs from that between the rare-earth ions (4f –4f interaction). The principal difference is that in the former case the electrons of the outer partly filled 3d shell of transition-metal ions interact with the electrons of the inner partly filled 4f shell of rare-earth ions, which are shielded from the crystalline field by the filled s- and p-electron shells, and in the latter case the electrons of the inner 4f electron shells interact with each other. Such pair interactions between the active ions are described within various energy transfer theories. In particular, the theory of weak incoherent energy transfer in terms of the dipole–dipole interaction between ions, which was first suggested by F¨ orster [146,147], is widely applied for the description of the energy transfer between ions in laser materials. This theory is generally valid for relatively low concentrations of active ions. The validity conditions of this theory are given in [148]. Dexter [149] further developed this theory for the case of the higher-order multipole interaction. This theory is often used in the case of higher active ion concentrations. Both, dipole–dipole and multipole interactions have a Coulomb nature. Later Inokuti reported also on the exchange mechanism of energy transfer [150]. No matter what the energy transfer nature is (Coulomb or exchange), all types of interactions can be divided into resonant [151] and nonresonant (phonon assisted). Galanin, Agranovich and Agabekyan [151,142,152] developed energy transfer theories for the particular cases of strong coherent and incoherent interactions. Special attention was devoted to “hopping mechanism of energy transfer” [153], as well as to its particular case of supermigration and enhanced migration within percolation theory [154,155]. These mechanisms of energy transfer were studied, in particular, in conjunction with the problem of excitation migration over the subsystem of Tm3+ ions in various Tm3+, Ho3+ systems, where the concentration of Tm3+ ions is kept high in order to provide efficient cross-relaxation and delivery of the pump excitation to the lasing Ho3+ ions. Without going into details, these theories have laid the basis for nonradiative energy transfer studies in laser crystals. Radiative energy transfer, often referred to as radiation trapping, is another process that plays an important role in the population dynamics of the upper laser level. This process was thoroughly studied first in gases [156,157] and then in the solid state [158,159,160,161,163,164]. Radiation trapping is
276
Irina T. Sorokina
a result of reabsorption of the ions spontaneously emitted from the metastable level by the ions in the ground state. This reabsorption is followed by the subsequent emission of photons, and the whole process repeats. As a result, the effectively measured fluorescence time lengthens by up to a few times relatively to the radiative lifetime. The result is the reported discrepancy in the stimulated emission cross-sections measured by different authors. The phenomenon is characteristic of two, three and quasi-three level schemes. In the mid-IR region these are mainly Tm3+ and Er3+-doped systems. In codoped media (like e.g. Tm,Ho or Yb,Er-doped crystals) the radiation trapping increases not only the energy storage capability of the medium, but also enhances the nonradiative energy transfer between donors and acceptors and the energy transfer upconversion [164]. Recently reabsorption has been found to be significant also in Cr2+-doped lasers [165]. In particular, it was found that in four-level systems in the presence of reabsorption in order to measure passive losses it is justifiable to use only the inverse slope efficiency analysis [166] and not the commonly used Findlay–Clay analysis [167]. Before the beginning of the 1980s flash-lamp pumping was the common way to create inversion population in solid-state laser media. Sensitization of rare-earth ion luminescence by broadband chromium ions allowed increasing laser efficiency [168,169]. It is interesting to note that sensitization of luminescence in the mid-IR is more efficient than in the visible and near-infrared since with increasing wavelength the competing spontaneous emission rates within the sensitizers decrease as 1/λ3 . New excitation schemes [33] became possible with increasing use of selective laser excitation and opening the possibility of diode pumping. The obvious advantages of diode pumping are accompanied by the possibility of using nonlinear cooperative processes in exciting high-lying rare-earth levels, where direct lamp pumping is extremely ineffective. The pioneering work of Johnson, Guggenheim and Antipenko [170,171,33] laid the foundation for important diode-pumped mid-IR lasers such as 3-µm Er and 2-µm Cr,Tm,Ho lasers. The energy level diagram in Fig. 10 is an illustrative example of the multistep excitation of the upconversion-pumped 3-µm Er:BaY2 F8 laser. It incorporates nearly all the energy transfer processes discussed up to this point, e.g. cross-relaxation, upconversion, radiation trapping, etc. Although for the Er3+ ion there exist several laser transitions spanning the wavelength range between the visible and mid-IR, only two transitions are of interest in the mid-IR range, namely, 4 F9/2 →4 I11/2 around 2 µm and 4 I11/2 →4 I13/2 around 2.58–2.94 µm depending upon the host. Since the 2-µm range is well covered by Tm and Tm,Ho lasers, only the 4 I11/2 →4 I13/2 3-µm transition is referred to in connection with Er lasers. This laser transition is especially interesting because of the water absorption lines in this wavelength range (for a review of medical applications of Er lasers see the chapter by Jean and Bende). The main problem of the Er laser is the self-termination of the lower laser level 4 I13/2 , the lifetime of which is longer than that of the upper laser level
Crystalline Lasers
277
Fig. 10. Energy level diagram and main population and relaxation processes in Er3+:BaY2 F8 (after [164]). I – pumping; II – cross-relaxation; III – radiation and multiphonon relaxation; IV – radiation trapping (reabsorption); V – upconversion 4
I11/2 . At the beginning of Er laser development, this was the main obstacle, preventing continuous-wave operation in a YAG crystal. However, in highly concentrated crystals, e.g. 10% Er:BaY2 F8 , the population mechanism works as follows (Fig. 10): the pumping occurs via the 4 I15/2 →4 F7/2 transition; following the fast multiphonon relaxation 4 F7/2 →4 H11/2 →4 S3/2 there are two main nonradiative energy transfer processes [173,174,175] that play a role in the population of the upper laser level 4 I11/2 : (1) cross-relaxation according to the scheme 4
S3/2 →
4
I13/2 , 4 I15/2 →
4
I9/2 ,
(2) upconversion according to the schemes 4
I13/2 →
4
I15/2 , 4 I13/2 →
4
I9/2 and
4
I11/2 →
4
I15/2 , I11/2 →
2
H11/2 .
4
Finally, the excitation relaxes to the upper laser level 4 I11/2 . It was found that if multiphonon processes leading to population of the upper laser level are predominant, then the laser action occurs due to transitions between the Stark components of the 4 I11/2 and 4 I13/2 levels with the highest oscillator strengths. If nonradiative transitions due to ion–ion interaction are more probable, a “red shift” is observed in the lasing spectra [176]. Cross-relaxation processes contribute to the increase of the pumping efficiency. Upconversion results in depopulation of the lower laser level and additional population of the upper laser level, thus leading to a stationary inversion population. Due to reabsorption the lifetimes of both the upper and lower laser levels effectively increase. This may have two consequences: first, the effective
278
Irina T. Sorokina
threshold decreases [177], and second, enhancement of the upconversion processes [164]. Zhekov and Huber [175,41] showed that the interaction among Er-ions of the following type: 4 I13/2 →4 I15/2 , 4 I13/2 →4 I9/2 with the subsequent transition to 4 I11/2 leads to the elimination of the self termination of the laser transition 4 I11/2 →4 I13/2 . In Er:YLF this upconversion process which depopulates the lower laser level and populates the upper laser level allows this transition to operate in a CW mode [172]. The interplay of all the discussed processes together with the optimized Er-ion concentration and the proper choice of the host allowed the engineering of several 3-µm Er lasers, operating in continuous-wave, Q-switched and mode-locked regimes (see Sect. 5.3.2). These lasers are based, first of all, on (Y1−x Erx )3 Al5 O12 [173], as well as on Y3 Sc2 Ga3 O12 (YSGG) [178], Gd3 Sc2 Al3 O12 (GSAG) [179], (Lu1−x Erx )3 Al5 O12 and YAlO3 [180], CaF2 [181], SrF2 and LiYF4 [182], BaY2 F8 [183] and some other crystals [29,184]. Another illustrative example of multistep excitation of the upper laser level is the 2-µm laser operating on the 5 I7 →5 I8 transition of Ho3+ ions. Since the mid-1960s several research groups have been working towards the development of a crystalline 2-µm laser. The concept of such a laser consisted in the sensitization of the lasing Ho3+-ion by Er3+ and Tm3+ ions. One of the first and most efficient realizations of the 2-µm laser is the BaEr2 F8 laser [185] based on the combination of active ions suggested in 1965 by Johnson [186]. The excitation of the upper laser level 5 I7 of Ho ions takes place according to the scheme in Fig. 11. The relatively high efficiency of this laser (5.2%) is explained by the high quantum efficiency and the decreased thermal loading of the cross-relaxational schemes, first studied in [187]. The high concentration of Er3+ ions in the host provides good absorption of flashlamp pumping. There exist three possibilities for the energy flow towards the upper laser level 5 I7 of Ho3+ ions. The first one is depicted in Fig. 11. After two stages of cross-relaxation within the Er3+ and Tm3+ ions the excitation is accumulated in the levels 4 I13/2 of Er3+ ions and 3 H4 of Tm3+ ions and is further transferred to the upper laser level 5 I7 of Ho3+ ions. This process implies a quantum efficiency of three. Another possibility is limited to only one stage of cross-relaxation with the subsequent nonradiative transition 4 I9/2 →4 I13/2 and the final energy transfer to the upper laser level like in the previous case. This process implies a quantum efficiency of two. Finally, the third possibility includes the nonradiative cascading transfer of energy to the 4 I13/2 level of Er3+ ions with the following energy transfer to the upper laser level of Ho3+ ions. The latter process has a quantum efficiency of unity. In [188] it was shown that the thermal load in this crystal is decreased by a factor of three and that the only really working scheme is the one depicted in Fig. 11 having a quantum efficiency of three. With the advent of powerful pump diodes this scheme became less attractive for CW operation, because it is possible now to pump directly into the Tm3+ ions at 780–800 nm, achieving over 50% efficiency. However, this energy transfer scheme is very interesting
Crystalline Lasers
279
Fig. 11. Energy level diagram of Tm3+,Ho3+:BaY2 F8 . Demonstration of the crossrelaxational mechanism to populate the upper-laser level in Ho3+ ions
for another reason. Recently, Barnes and colleagues [189] made use of this energy transfer scheme and demonstrated an extremely simple and elegant wavelength selection method in Cr3+,Er3+,Tm3+,Ho3+:YAG allowing tuning to one of the wavelengths, corresponding either to 2.1 µm or 2.9 µm (for details see Sect. 5.3.1). Antipenko was the first to suggest the concept of the Cr, Tm, Ho:YAG laser (Fig. 12), where the chromium ions absorb the pump radiation and transfer it to the thulium ions with the subsequent exchange of one excitation for two [34] and the energy transfer of the electron excitation to the upper laser level 5 I7 of Ho3+ ions [190]. The crystals allowing realization of this concept include besides Y3 Al5 O12 (see e.g., [190,192,193,41,42] such crystals as Gd3 Sc2 Ga3 O12 (GSGG) [194,195], Gd3 Sc2 Al3 O12 (GSAG) [196], Y3 Sc2 Ga3 O12 (YSGG) [197], Y3 Sc2 Al3 O12 (YSAG) [198], mixed scandium garnets [199], Lu3 Al5 O12 (LuAG) [186,200] as well as LiYF4 (YLF) [201,202]. All these crystals are characterized by the high pump efficiency of the broadband visible pump sources as well as the high conversion efficiency of the absorbed light into the inversion population of the upper laser level of Ho ions. The first is explained by the use of Cr3+ as a sensitizer (donor) ion. The absorption bands of Cr3+ (together with Tm3+ and Ho3+ absorption bands)
280
Irina T. Sorokina
Fig. 12. The excitation scheme of the Ho3+ upper-laser level in Cr3+, Tm3+, Ho3+:YAG
cover most of the visible range. This also lowers the requirements to the pump source. Due to the relatively low crystalline field in these crystals and according to the corresponding Tanabe–Sugano [49] diagram the energy gap ∆ E between the levels 2 E and 4 T2 of chromium is low (≤ kT at room temperature). The latter combined with the high concentration of Tm3+ ions (nTm = 3–15 at.%) makes the energy transfer to Tm ions efficient: (1)
2
E → 4A2 (Cr3+ ), 3 H6 →
3
F3 (Tm3+ ) .
The high Tm concentration also favors efficient cross-relaxation with a quantum efficiency close to two [34]: (2)
3
F4 →
3
H4 , 3 H6 →
3
H4 (Tm3+ ) ,
and nonradiative energy transfer to the upper laser level of Ho ions [202,196]: (3)
3
H4 →
3
H6 (Tm3+ ), 5 I8 →
5
I7 (Ho3+ ) .
Like in the previous case of Er lasers the cross-relaxational mechanism of energy transfer allows considerable decrease of the thermal load in the active medium. Combined with the increased capability of the medium to absorb the flashlamp pump this leads to the increase in the slope efficiency of the triply doped crystals in comparison to the crystals which are singly doped with Ho ions. As in the case of the previous scheme, direct diode-pumping into the 3 F3 level of the Tm3+ ion is much more efficient than flashlamp pumping, and the Cr,Tm,Ho-doped laser is used only in pulsed applications. The multitude of these existing energy levels in Cr,Tm,Ho-doped systems provides many possibilities not only for the discussed energy transfer processes, but also for parasitic energy flow channels such as the energy transfer
Crystalline Lasers
281
from Tm to Ho ions via the upper energy states: (1)
3
F4 →
3
H6 (Tm3+ ), 5 I8 →
5
I4 (Ho3+ ),
as well as for two upconversion processes, including the resonant one: (2)
5
I7 →
5
I8 , 5 I7 →
5
I6 (Ho3+ ),
and the nonresonant one: (3)
3
H4 →
3
H6 (Tm3+ ), 5 I7 →
5
I5 (Ho3+ ).
These processes are not marked in Fig. 12 for the sake of simplicity. However, they have been extensively studied in the literature [203,204,205]. Their influence on the laser output characteristics is different depending upon the operation regime. It is therefore important to carefully take them into account, when choosing the optimum host or the optimum concentration of the active ions [206]. Summarizing, in this section the most important energy transfer processes and the population dynamics of the rare-earth-doped 2- and 3-µm lasers have been considered. The multistep pumping schemes of the upper laser levels have been shown to be efficient and useful for creation of inversion population in the mid-IR. 3.2
Influence of Spectroscopic Parameters on Laser Properties
In the previous paragraphs the processes influencing formation of the inversion population in mid-IR crystalline solid-state lasers were introduced. In this section the effect of these processes on laser operation, i.e. on laser threshold and efficiency, will be analyzed. The case of continuous-wave operation will be considered as the most demanding one. In this case assuming the four-level scheme the balance equation for the population of the upper laser level n can be written as [207]: n dn = F pump σGSA (Nt − n) − F las σem n − − αn2 , dt τ
(12)
where the first three terms stand for pumping, stimulated emission and spontaneous decay, respectively. The last term corresponds to upconversion with the upconversion macroparameter α. Nt is the total concentration of the active ions, n is the excited ion concentration, σGSA is the GSA cross-section at the pumping wavelength (pump absorption cross-section), σem is the emission cross-section at the laser wavelength, F pump is the pumping photon flux, F las is the intracavity emission photon flux, and τ is the temperature dependent lifetime of the upper laser level. Note that the ESA terms do not enter (12) under the assumption that the quantum yield from the upper states to the upper laser level is equal to unity, and therefore ESA, even if it is present, does not change the excited ion concentration. If the upper states have long
282
Irina T. Sorokina
lifetimes and possess different decay routes, then the laser schemes and rate equations become quite complicated (see, e.g. the chapter by Pollnau and Jackson in this volume). The rate equation for the photon flux at the laser wavelength can be written as: c dF las F las c las = F las σem nla − − F las σESA nla , dt l τc l
(13)
where the first two terms on the right-hand side stand for stimulated emission and loss, while the last term describes the ESA. The photon lifetime in the resonator is τc = l/(T + L)c, where l is the effective cavity round-trip length, and (T + L) are the logarithmic round-trip losses, consisting of the output coupling (T ) and other losses (L). From (13), the threshold population n th can be determined [207]: n th =
T +L , las ) la (σem − σESA
(14)
where la is the active medium length. The threshold absorbed pump power in longitudinally pumped configuration is then given as [207]: hν las λ las A pump σem τ λ pump −1 pump las n th σESA σESA × (1 + αn th τ ) 1 − 1+ σem σGSA (Nt − n th )
abs = (T + L) P th
(15)
which is proportional to the losses (T + L), the saturation intensity (hν/στ ), the Stokes shift λ las /λ pump , and the pumped area A pump . The last three terms represent the upconversion, ESA at the laser wavelength, and ESA at the pump wavelength, respectively. From the same equations one can obtain the expression for the slope efficiency with respect to the absorbed pump power: −1 pump las σESA n th λ pump T σESA , (16) 1 + ηslope = 1 − pump λ las T + L σem σESA (Nt − n th ) where the first two terms represent the Stokes shift and output coupling efficiency, while the last two stand for the efficiency loss due to the ESA at the laser and pump wavelengths, respectively. For completeness, we note that the quantity las λ pump σESA 1− (17) η0 = λ las σem is usually referred to as the intrinsic slope efficiency. As follows from (15) and (16), upconversion and temperature reduction of the active ion lifetime increase the laser threshold but do not affect the slope efficiency. To keep upconversion losses at minimum (αn th τ 1), one should
Crystalline Lasers
283
keep overall losses T +L low to reduce the threshold population (14). It is also seen from (15) and (16) that losses and ESA affect both threshold and slope efficiency. However, ESA at the pump wavelength is relatively unimportant in four-level lasers, where n th < Nt , and its influence can be further decreased by lowering losses (14). The expressions (12)–(16) can be readily generalized for the case of three- and quasi-three level systems. The effect of reabsorption on laser parameters is rather ambiguous. As has been discussed in Sect. 3.1.3 a straightforward consequence of reabsorption is the lengthening of the lifetime. According to (15) this leads, in the first approximation, to the effective decrease of the laser threshold. On the other hand, as discussed in Sect. 3.1.3, reabsorption increases the quantum yield of the energy transfer processes, and in particular, that of upconversion. In laser systems, where upconversion represents a loss mechanism, the effect of reabsorption is the same as described above for upconversion. However, in other laser systems that use upconversion pumping, e.g. 3-µm Er lasers, reabsorption finally leads to an improvement in efficiency. 3.3
Reaching the Threshold
It is an easily noticeable fact that laser transitions in the mid-IR tend to be broadband, even those in rare-earth ions. Indeed, the widths of the individual states (in energy units) are determined by the particular crystal-lattice interaction and inhomogeneous broadening, which are characteristic for the given ion and host. The transition bandwidth h∆ ν (in energy units) is then the sum of the widths of the upper and lower states. Since the transition energy h∆ ν is inversely proportional to the wavelength, the relative bandwidth of the transition ∆ ν/ν ≈ ∆ λ/λ increases towards the infrared. This is well illustrated in Fig. 1 on the example of room-temperature Tb3+ ion luminescence around 5 µm in KPb2 Cl5 [208]. The transition bandwidth is one of the most important characteristics, determining the ability of the laser material to lase and to be tuned. Another two characteristics of interest, which will be discussed here, are the transition lifetime and cross-section. Both are in one way or another connected with the bandwidth of the laser transition. The treatment of absorption, spontaneous and stimulated emission using an elegant thermodynamic treatment given first by Einstein [112] can be found elsewhere (see, e.g. [113,114]). Based on this treatment the spontaneous-emission cross-section σem (λ) can be obtained from the fluorescence intensity signal I(λ) using the relation: σem (λ) =
I(λ)λ5 A , 8πcn2 I(λ)λdλ
(18)
where A is the full spontaneous emission probability (radiative decay rate) from the upper laser level, c is the speed of light and n is the index of refraction. The measured fluorescence intensity signal I(λ) is usually corrected to
284
Irina T. Sorokina
the spectral sensitivity of the recording system, using, e.g. a calibration lamp. Formula (18) follows from basic principles [27,38] and does not contain assumptions other than neglecting the polarization dependence of fluorescence that can also be correctly accounted for. In practice, taking the inverse lifetime at low temperature as the best-known approximation for the radiative decay rate, one usually obtains the effective emission cross-section σem (λ). One of the direct consequences of the ion–host interaction discussed in the previous section is nonradiative decay. The usually measured luminescence lifetime τ consists of purely radiative and nonradiative components: 1 1 1 = + . τ τ rad τnr
(19)
From (18) the radiative lifetime of the broadband transition has the form 1 1 ∆λ σem (λ)dλ = A = 8cn2 ≈ 8cn2 σem (λ0 ) 3 , (20) 4 τ rad λ λ0 λ0 clearly demonstrating the general tendency that lifetime inversely scales with emission bandwidth. We can see from (15) that the minimum absorbed pump power density at threshold is proportional to the loss coefficient and the gain saturation intensity. The necessary incident pumping intensity is therefore inversely proportional to the pump absorption coefficient: I th ∝
αloss hν , α abs σ(ν)τ
(21)
where αloss may include the absorption from the ground state in the case of three- and quasi-three-level schemes. Combining (20) and (21), the following scaling rule for the required pump intensity at threshold can be obtained: I th ∝
1 ∆ λ n2 1 , F OM η QE λ0 λ40
(22)
where η QE is the quantum yield of the transition, defined as: η QE =
τ . τ rad
(23)
One important conclusion is that the threshold power density scales with the bandwidth. This explains the relatively high threshold, characteristic for broadband materials. Only the progress in pump sources, when laser pumping became available, made possible laser action of broadband materials. As a result, the first argon-laser pumped tunable Ti:sapphire appeared [191,38], followed by a number of exciting developments in femtosecond pulse generation [210,211,212,213]. Nowdays there exists only a limited number of directly diode-pumped broadband solid-state lasers. These include: Cr:LiSAF[214] and Cr:LiSGaF [207,215], Cr:YAG [96], and since recently also Cr:ZnSe [97]
Crystalline Lasers
285
and Cr:ZnS [98]. Due to the relatively high pump saturation intensity of Ti:sapphire, the diode-pumping of this material will remain a severe problem, even if high-power blue-green laser diodes become available. The analysis of the formula (22) shows also that there is a factor λ4 in the denominator, which effectively decreases the threshold for longer wavelength transitions. For mid-IR this is a very encouraging factor. Provided that the active material has a high FOM and high quantum yield (like it is in the case of e.g., Cr:ZnSe) this makes direct diode-pumping in the mid-IR feasible. To get a feeling for what difference the λ−4 factor can produce, compare, e.g. otherwise quite similar Ti:sapphire (λ0 = 780 nm) and Cr:ZnSe (λ0 = 2450 nm): the threshold intensity differs by two orders of magnitude!
4
Laser Design Considerations
In this section the typical experimental techniques will be reviewed, which are used to create a working laser: pumping arrangements and cavity schemes as well as tuning, Q-switching, and mode-locking techniques. Most of these are well-known. Therefore the present consideration will concentrate on features specific to mid-IR lasers. 4.1
Pump Sources
For optical pumping of solid-state lasers one can use a gas discharge lamp, high-power laser diodes, or another laser at shorter wavelength. As described in the Introduction, flashlamp pumping of mid-IR lasers has been used from the very first demonstrations. The high-brightness noble gas discharge lamps emit most of their energy in the visible and near-infrared region of spectrum. Thus, the flashlamps are useful only for laser media with sufficient absorption in this region and all the energy difference between the pump photons in the visible and the emission photons in the mid-IR (Stokes shift) has to be dissipated in the medium as heat. Many rare-earth ions have absorption lines, suitable for flash lamp pumping. However, these absorption lines only partially overlap with the total emission spectrum so that the absorption efficiency remains low. Some improvement in this respect can be achieved by using energy transfer schemes (see Sect. 3.1.3), with the first absorbing ion having broad bands in the visible (like, e.g. chromium). A point in case is the Cr,Tm,Ho:YAG crystal [216], which has successfully entered commercial production. However, while sensitization solves the problem of spectrum overlap, it does not reduce the Stokes shift and excessive heat production remains an important issue. High-power diode lasers have a spectrum bandwidth of ∼ 2–4 nm that can be set to match the absorption band during diode fabrication. This significantly improves the pumping efficiency. Continuous-wave diode laser arrays have output power per unit length comparable with arc lamps, but emit
286
Irina T. Sorokina
partially coherent light in a limited solid angle while the lamps emit incoherent light in all directions. With proper illumination optics, diodes allow much higher pumping intensity, thus decreasing the pumping threshold power of solid-state lasers. At the same time, efficient high-power diode lasers exist only in certain wavelength ranges and cannot always be used for direct pumping of some ions. Most of the high-power laser diodes emit in the nearinfrared. The Stokes shift and the corresponding heating are thus somewhat lower than in the case of lamp pumping. For pulsed laser operation, pump diodes perform worse than the flashlamps. The reason for this lies in the different damage behavior of diodes and flashlamps. The output power limit for the laser diode is set by the optical damage of the emitting surface and is practically the same for pulsed and CW operation. On the contrary, the maximum flashlamp pulse energy scales as the square root of the pulse duration. For a 100-µs pump pulse, this would mean a 100-fold increase in the peak power as compared to the CW case. This compensates for all the disadvantages of flashlamps as compared to laser diodes, and makes flashlamps still competitive in high-energy pulsed applications. In the case of active media with long upper level lifetime, like e.g. Ho- and Tm-doped crystals with τ ≈ 10 ms, pump diodes can be driven at much lower peak power and are preferred to flashlamps. Optical pumping by a high-quality beam of another laser, while increasing the complexity and cost of the system, has certain advantages. First, the coherent laser output can be much more easily focused to create a very high pumping intensity, enabling laser action of materials with high laser threshold. Second, laser pumping allows operation of materials with absorption bands, which cannot be directly pumped by lamps or laser diodes. And finally, multistage pumping decreases the Stokes heat production in the laser medium. This can be understood if one recalls that primary pump photons are generated in the visible (lamps) or near-IR (diodes) spectral regions. With the final laser wavelength lying in the mid-IR, most of the photon energy should dissipate as heat. As pointed out in Sect. 3.1.1 long-wavelength media are especially temperature-sensitive due to the influence of thermally activated nonradiative decay. In a multi-stage scheme a significant share of the Stokes heat can be dissipated in the pump laser, thus helping to keep the heating in the final stage of the crystal low. 4.2
Cavity Design
The cavity design guidelines for solid-state mid-IR lasers are the same as for any other spectral region [114,30,113]. An important difference however is that in many cases the atmosphere cannot be considered transparent because of the absorption by water and carbon dioxide molecules. In these cases the cavity should be kept as short as possible or purged (filled) with dry nitrogen or inert gases.
Crystalline Lasers
287
The power scaling approaches for solid-state lasers in the mid-IR are also generally the same as in other spectral regions [30]. The discussion issues include efficient pump concentration and delivery, crystal cooling, thermal lens and induced birefringence compensation, as well as crystal fracture prevention. For high-energy pulsed systems, the optical damage of the cavity elements is an important factor, even if the average power remains moderate due to the low pulse repetition rate. High-power laser diodes are typically 1–2 cm long arrays of single emitters on a heatsink, with an output power of up to 40–50 W per cm of length. The radiation