SHAKESPEARE’S COMPANIES
General Editor’s Preface Helen Ostovich, McMaster University Performance assumes a string of ...
31 downloads
1098 Views
853KB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
SHAKESPEARE’S COMPANIES
General Editor’s Preface Helen Ostovich, McMaster University Performance assumes a string of creative, analytical, and collaborative acts that, in defiance of theatrical ephemerality, live on through records, manuscripts, and printed books. The monographs and essay collections in this series offer original research which addresses theatre histories and performance histories in the context of the sixteenth and seventeenth century life. Of especial interest are studies in which women’s activities are a central feature of discussion as financial or technical supporters (patrons, musicians, dancers, seamstresses, wigmakers, or ‘gatherers’), if not authors or performers per se. Welcome too are critiques of early modern drama that not only take into account the production values of the plays, but also speculate on how intellectual advances or popular culture affect the theatre. The series logo, selected by my colleague Mary V. Silcox, derives from Thomas Combe’s duodecimo volume, The Theater of Fine Devices (London, 1592), Emblem VI, sig. B. The emblem of four masks has a verse which makes claims for the increasing complexity of early modern experience, a complexity that makes interpretation difficult. Hence the corresponding perhaps uneasy rise in sophistication: Masks will be more hereafter in request, And grow more deare than they did heretofore. No longer simply signs of performance ‘in play and jest’, the mask has become the ‘double face’ worn ‘in earnest’ even by ‘the best’ of people, in order to manipulate or profit from the world around them. The books stamped with this design attempt to understand the complications of performance produced on stage and interpreted by the audience, whose experiences outside the theatre may reflect the emblem’s argument: Most men do use some colour’d shift For to conceal their craftie drift. Centuries after their first presentations, the possible performance choices and meanings they engender still stir the imaginations of actors, audiences, and readers of early plays. The products of scholarly creativity in this series, I hope, will also stir imaginations to new ways of thinking about performance.
Shakespeare’s Companies William Shakespeare’s Early Career and the Acting Companies, 1577–1594
TERENCE G. SCHOONE-JONGEN Independent Scholar, Washington, DC, USA
© Terence G. Schoone-Jongen 2008 All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise without the prior permission of the publisher. Terence G. Schoone-Jongen has asserted his moral right under the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act, 1988, to be identified as the author of this work. Published by Ashgate Publishing Limited Wey Court East Union Road Farnham Surrey GU9 7PT England
Ashgate Publishing Company Suite 420 101 Cherry Street Burlington, VT 05401-4405 USA
www.ashgate.com British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data Schoone-Jongen, Terence Shakespeare’s companies: William Shakespeare’s early career and the acting companies, 1577–1594. – (Studies in performance and early modern drama) 1. Shakespeare, William, 1564–1616 – Stage history – To 1625 2. Shakespeare, William, 1564–1616 – Stage history – England – London 3. Shakespeare, William, 1564–1616 – Relations with actors 4. Theater – England – London – History – 16th century 5. Theatrical companies – England – London – History – 16th century I. Title 792’.09421 Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Schoone-Jongen, Terence. Shakespeare’s companies: William Shakespeare’s early career and the acting companies, 1577–1594 / by Terence Schoone-Jongen. p. cm. — (Studies in performance and early modern drama) Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN-13: 978-0-7546-6434-5 (alk. paper) ISBN-10: 0-7546-6434-1 (alk. paper) 1. Shakespeare, William, 1564–1616—Stage history—To 1625. 2. Shakespeare, William, 1564–1616—Stage history—England—London. 3. Shakespeare, William, 1564–1616— Relations with actors. 4. Theatrical companies—England—London—History—16th century. 5. Theater—England—London—History—16th century. I. Title. PR3095.S37 2009 792’.09421—dc22 2008017879 ISBN: 978-0-7546-6434-5
For Tom
This page intentionally left blank
Contents Acknowledgements Introduction Part 1
viii 1
Towards a Chronological Framework
1 In Stratford
11
2 Greene’s Groatsworth of Wit and Shakespeare’s First Plays
17
Part 2
Theatrical Contexts
3 Provincial Playing, c. 1577–1588
43
4 London Playing, 1588–1594
57
Part 3
Shakespeare and the Companies
Introductory Note
85
5 The Queen’s Men
87
6 Strange’s Men
103
7 Pembroke’s Men
119
8 Sussex’s Men
147
9 The “Lancashire Connection”
159
10 Leicester’s Men and Lesser Claimants
173
Conclusion: The Misguided Mission
197
Appendix: Company Itineraries, 1584–1594
201
Bibliography Index
229 247
Acknowledgements I wish to thank, above all, my adviser, mentor, and friend Tom Postlewait. This study’s origins lie in two papers written for two of his graduate seminars. By his suggestion, those papers became a Master’s Thesis, which in time became a preliminary manuscript, which, several incarnations later, became this book. Throughout this process, Dr. Postlewait offered his encouragement, guidance, and enthusiasm, all of which made completion of this project possible, and also his editing and proofreading. I am grateful to Andrew Gurr, who offered feedback on one of the papers that now forms a part of Chapter 4, and to Sally-Beth MacLean, who gave me a number of helpful pointers while I was compiling what has become the Appendix. Thanks also to Alan Woods for suggesting a number of emendations and clarifications on early versions of this study. I owe general thanks to Sally-Beth MacLean and all of the people at Records of Early English Drama (REED) at the University of Toronto, who were willing to make time in their busy schedules to allow me to ask questions and rummage through the unpublished REED transcriptions in the summer of 2002. I especially thank Elizabeth Baldwin, David Mills, John Coldewey, Peter Greenfield, Sally-Beth MacLean, Alexandra Johnston, Barbara Palmer, John Wasson, Diana Wyatt, and Jane Cowling, all of whom generously gave me permission to cite their unpublished REED transcriptions. Special thanks also to Glynn Parry for sharing his unpublished research regarding Shakespeare’s “Lancashire connection” with me. I offer additional special thanks to Erika Gaffney and Helen Ostovich at Ashgate for helping a first-time book author navigate the publication process. Thanks also to my many friends whose interest in, and encouragement of, this undertaking helped make the writing and revision process easier than it might have been. To list them all would take a separate book; you know who you are. A final thanks to Mom, Dad, and Brendan for their love and support.
Introduction
Though yet heaven knows it is but as a tomb Which hides your life and shows not half your parts. Sonnet 17.3–4 [...] the “object” that the historian studies is not only incomplete; it is markedly variable as records are lost or rediscovered. Louis Gottschalk, Understanding History 46
After decades of archival research on the life of Shakespeare, the eminent eighteenthcentury scholar Edmond Malone had finally identified the company that Shakespeare joined as an actor before arriving in London in the early 1590s (or perhaps the late 1580s). Malone declared that Shakespeare, before launching his career as a playwright, must have been a player with Lord Leicester’s servants. Or perhaps with the Queen’s Men. Or maybe with Lord Warwick’s players (Malone, “The Life of William Shakespeare” 166–7). So much for certainty. No wonder Malone was unable to finish his biography of Shakespeare. Malone’s doubts, though a measure of his scholarly integrity, have proved to be a prologue to two hundred years of confusion, debates, claims, and counterclaims on Shakespeare’s early life. The long, scholarly search for Shakespeare amid the various acting companies operating in the 1580s and early 1590s—the shadowy or “lost” years before he shows up in the Lord Chamberlain’s Men in 1594—reveals, in a nutshell, the changeable and troubled history of Shakespearean biography across the centuries. It also reveals some fascinating developments in the scholarly approaches to theatre history and textual scholarship. This search is one among many unresolved problems that permeate Shakespeare studies (authorship, sexuality, religious loyalties, biographical details implied by the sonnets, date and order of the plays, suspect anecdotes, to name a few). Malone’s uncertainty opened the floodgates in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries. Scholars and biographers have put forward a wide range of conjectures on Shakespeare’s apprentice years: It is clear, then, that it is quite possible that Shakespeare may have followed in Leicester’s train. I think the passage in Sidney’s Letter converts that possibility into something more than a probability. (Thoms, Three Notelets On Shakespeare [1865] 117–18) ... it would appear not altogether unlikely that the poet was one of Lord Strange’s actors in March, 1592; one of Lord Pembroke’s a few months later; and that he had joined the company of the Earl of Sussex in or before January, 1594. (Halliwell-Phillips, Outlines of the Life of Shakespeare [10th ed., 1898] i.122)
2
Shakespeare’s Companies In 1587 they [Leicester’s] were in England, playing at Stratford-on-Avon during their autumn travel ... At Stratford, in my opinion, Shakespeare joined them. (Fleay, A Chronicle History of the London Stage, 1559–1642 [1890] 82) Most of his colleagues of latter life opened their histrionic careers in Lord Leicester’s professional service, and there is plausible ground for inferring that Shakespeare from the first trod in their footsteps. (Lee, A Life of William Shakespeare [1917] 54) There is therefore really some basis for the suggestion made long ago by Halliwell-Phillips that [Shakespeare] is to be looked for during these years in Pembroke’s company until its collapse and then in Sussex’s. (Chambers, The Elizabethan Stage [1923] ii.130) ... it seems highly probable that [Shakespeare], too, was one of Strange’s Men before 1594. (Honigmann, Shakespeare: ‘the lost years’ [1985] 60) The case for Shakespeare having belonged either to the Queen’s Men or Pembroke’s seems evenly divided. (Gurr, The Shakespearian Stage, 1576–1642 [3rd ed., 1992] 248) ... Shakespeare is thereby identifiable as an actor or a writer, or both, for the Queen’s Men. (Sams, The Real Shakespeare [1995] 59) ... I am almost convinced that Shakespeare was with his plays in Pembroke’s Company at the Theatre in 1592 and 1593. (Gurr, The Shakespearean Playing Companies [1996] 271) The conjecture that best answers these conditions is that Shakespeare belonged to the Queen’s Men early in his career, perhaps in some other capacity than as a writer. (McMillin and MacLean, The Queen’s Men and Their Plays [1998] 165) Was Mr. Shakspere one of the actors in his [the Earl of Oxford’s] employ? This seems likely. (Sobran, Alias Shakespeare [1997] 221) The young Shakespeare was to stay with Worcester’s men for four or five years. (Southworth, Shakespeare the Player [2000] 29) ... as to Shakespeare’s roles in the course of his apprenticeship and early career as an Admiral’s man. (Southworth [2000] 50) ... [Shakespeare] perhaps came to the notice of Sir Fulke Greville ... and for a couple of years served him in some capacity, probably as a player. (Duncan-Jones, Ungentle Shakespeare [2001] 36)
Over the years, scholars have advanced their particular theories concerning Shakespeare’s pre-1594 acting company affiliations, but no one has ever attempted to systematically identify, outline, and analyze all of these competing theories. E.K. Chambers’s Elizabethan Stage and Andrew Gurr’s Shakespearean Playing Companies treat some, but not all, of these theories; S. Schoenbaum’s Shakespeare’s Lives, which takes up nearly all of the other Shakespeare controversies and debates, mentions this one only in passing.
Introduction
3
The goal of this study is therefore to explain, analyze, and assess the competing claims about Shakespeare’s pre-1594 acting company affiliations. It is not, however, my intention to demonstrate that a particular argument for Shakespeare’s pre-1594 company is correct. Rather, the goal of this study is to demonstrate that this topic is in fact a nexus for key issues in Elizabethan theatre history, Shakespearean biography, and historiography. In fact, I aim to show that the biographical issue of Shakespeare’s pre-1594 company affiliation is so closely intertwined with the attendant historiographic issues and related theatre history issues that these three topics cannot be intelligibly separated. Accordingly, this study has been structured with Shakespeare’s biography, theatre history, and historiography in mind. The first two chapters deal primarily with the known facts of Shakespeare’s early life; the next two chapters set out and clarify the theatrical contexts in which Shakespeare emerged as an actor and dramatist; and the remaining chapters examine a wide variety of arguments scholars have made over the last two centuries regarding Shakespeare’s theatrical whereabouts before 1594. Likewise, each individual chapter frequently evidences the inseparability of biography, historiography, and theatre history when it comes to Shakespeare. For example, what is known regarding Shakespeare’s biography in 1592 simply cannot be discussed without some understanding of the theatrical conditions of that time, but on both counts one must reckon with competing scholarly claims about both Shakespeare and the London theatre of 1592.1 Similarly, one cannot fully understand the reasons and liabilities for thinking Shakespeare might have once belonged to Strange’s Men without some knowledge of the suggestion that Strange’s and the Admiral’s Men were once an “amalgamated” company, a claim based on many questionable assumptions about acting company patronage, provincial playing, and the dating of one particular document.2 Many previous studies have focused primarily on Shakespeare with theatrical contexts as a background; others have focused on Elizabethan theatre history with Shakespeare at the periphery; still others have focused on a critique of previous Shakespearean biographers. This study seeks to do all three. While admittedly ambitious, it is my hope that by focusing on a limited part of Shakespeare’s professional career, I will be able to more clearly present him in terms of his contexts while still doing justice to these contexts (provincial, court, and London playing, dynamics between acting companies and patrons, publication practices, etc.). At the same time, I will be tracing a problem—Shakespeare’s pre-1594 acting company—that has not been traced in such detail before. Perhaps even more to the point, this study will offer a detailed analysis of the biographers and theatre historians who have presented so many different and contradictory versions of Shakespeare’s professional affiliations between the late 1570s and 1594. In this sense, my study offers both a history and a critique of Shakespearean biographers and their historical methodologies. The biographers have presented a confusing picture of not only the London theatre scene 1 2
For more on this, see Chapter 2. For more on this, see Chapters 4 and 6.
4
Shakespeare’s Companies
in these years but also the activities of the theatre companies, both inside and outside of London. It is my hope to bring some clarity to several of these issues and problems in the historical and biographical study of Shakespeare and his time. Although I will not identify which company Shakespeare worked with before 1594, I will be able to demonstrate why many explanations are impossible, why others are improbable, and why only a few meet the qualifications of historical possibility. No definitive explanations will emerge, but a number of false explanations will be exposed. In the process, perhaps, this study can set some basic conditions for writing both the biography of Shakespeare and the theatre history of the 1580s and early 1590s, those key years before two major companies—the Lord Chamberlain’s Men and the Admiral’s Men—were consolidated in London. A number of key facts are known about Shakespeare and London theatre after 1594; it behooves us to bring some clarity to the conditions before that date. This study is not, then, just another biography of Shakespeare. If anything, by focusing on this one troublesome aspect of Shakespeare’s biography I am seeking to shift attention away from the difficult, even impossible, issues of a too exclusive focus on Shakespeare. Rather, I am trying to show that the theatre history and historiographic issues are at least as significant as the life of one actor-turned-playwright; once again, these issues are not separable from the life anyway. In the end, it is not possible to prove where Shakespeare was, but it is possible to gain a more complex understanding of one of the major moments of transformation in English theatre history, all the while providing a historiographical analysis of the problems that have plagued the search for Shakespeare. In doing so, I will be following the example of scholars such as William Ingram (The Business of Playing), Roslyn Lander Knutson (Playing Companies and Commerce in Shakespeare’s Time), and Scott McMillin (The Elizabethan Stage and the Book of Sir Thomas More). In analyzing the competing claims for Shakespeare’s early theatrical career (and a number of Elizabethan theatre history issues), my assessment relies heavily on a terminology of the possible, the plausible, and the probable. I regard a possibility as a hypothesis which no evidence flatly contradicts; in other words, if something is not demonstrably false, it is a possibility, although not necessarily a good one. A plausibility is something more than a possibility, in that it is speculation which can be justified (though not proven) on one or more counts. A plausible conjecture is thus based on some sort of positive evidence, rather than on the absence of negatory evidence. At the same time, however, a plausibility is not strong or convincing enough to rule out other possibilities or plausibilities. In the case of a probability, other possibilities can effectively be laid aside because the probable hypothesis is so much stronger or more likely than any alternatives. A probability is not certain, but it is pretty likely. Here again, however, I wish to emphasize that this study is not concerned only with deciding what is or is not possible, plausible, probable, or certain. While this study will encounter arguments or hypotheses that can be dismissed as implausible, the arguments or hypotheses themselves may still have value outside of their conclusions, in that they may bring up important issues beyond Shakespeare’s whereabouts. The issues raised, in other words, may be more rewarding to consider than the biographical search itself.
Introduction
5
*** Before proceeding any further, I should note that it is my operating assumption that William Shakespeare of Stratford did, in fact, write the plays which have been attributed to him and will not, for the most part, be taking up any anti-Stratfordian scholars. Generally speaking, anti-Stratfordian arguments about Shakespeare’s authorship rest on two contentions: 1. They doubt that a boy from Stratford would have received the necessary education or would have been able to acquire the necessary erudition they find evident in Shakespeare’s plays and poems. Diana Price, for instance, claims that “It is difficult to square Shakspere’s probable but incomplete grammar school training with the works of Shakespeare—works that attest to a highly educated mind” (235). 2. They argue that the biographical information available about Shakespeare, much of which consists of financial transactions and lawsuits, does not square with the poetic sensibilities present in the poems and plays. Bertram Fields, for instance, comments that “it is difficult to reconcile the crass actions and attitudes of the Stratford man with the sensitivity and humanity manifest in Shakespeare” (132) while Diana Price argues that “most analyses of Shakespeare’s plays find few parallels to Shakspere’s documented life” (267). The first of these objections smacks of elitism; more importantly, studies of the Elizabethan educational system demonstrate that Shakespeare would have received a basic education quite impressive by twenty-first century standards (see Chapter 1). The second of these objections rests on the assumption that the available court and financial records tell the reader everything about the Stratford man’s personality. As the available documents are concerned with matters for which there would be no call for Shakespeare to reveal his poetic sensibilities, this is not a particularly safe assumption. Besides, as Louis Gottschalk observes, the past “is likely to have gone through eight separate steps at each of which some of it has been lost; and there is no guarantee that what remains is the most important, the largest, the most valuable, the most representative, or the most enduring part” (46). More importantly, in voicing dissatisfaction over the apparent lack of continuity between the certain facts of Shakespeare’s life and the spirit of his literary output, anti-Stratfordians adopt the very Modernist assumption that an author’s work must reflect his or her life. Neither Shakespeare nor his fellow Elizabethan writers operated under this assumption, and many literary critics and schools of literary criticism have been increasingly prone to challenge this assumption and argue, accordingly, that using literary works as evidence for the biography of the author is an undesirable, if not unsafe, practice (New Criticism, Michel Foucault, Roland Barthes, and nearly every other strain of poststructuralism, to name but a few). While it may today seem commonsensical that it is possible to detect an author’s biography in his or her works, Marc Bloch reminds scholars that “the worst of common sense is that it exalts to the level of the eternal observations necessarily borrowed from our own brief moment in time” (67).
6
Shakespeare’s Companies
Quite apart from holding these questionable assumptions, anti-Stratfordians have been unable to find a “real” author in any way more plausible than William Shakespeare of Stratford. Instead, anti-Stratfordians offer a laundry list of details about the life of their favored candidate(s), contend that these details “prove” the life of Oxford, or Bacon, or Marlowe, or Rutland, or Queen Elizabeth better fits the attitudes present in Shakespeare’s works, and consider the case closed. This is hardly a rigorous process; it is, instead, an argument based on a “rhetoric of accumulation,” to use Paul Werstine’s term, which proves nothing besides the ability of the proponent of a particular argument to amass a list of individually unconvincing coincidences (“Shakespeare, More or Less” 130, 140). Such an argument does not follow any accepted method of historical argument; it merely pokes (or claims to poke) a few holes in one thesis, offers an alternative hypothesis dependent entirely on coincidence, and presents no further evidence, beyond literary interpretation, in support of the new hypothesis. Such “evidence” fails to stand up to Gottschalk’s tests for evidential credibility. Coincidence and literary interpretation alone cannot tell the historian if those who produced the coincidence or literary interpretation were (1) willing or (2) able to tell the truth, (3) whether the coincidence or literary interpretation is accurate, or (4) if there is any independent corroboration, besides more coincidences and literary interpretations, to independently corroborate the “evidence” derived from the original coincidence or interpretation (150). As will become apparent in the pages of this study, many orthodox Shakespeare scholars and biographers also depend far too heavily on coincidence and literary interpretation when they argue about Shakespeare’s pre-1594 whereabouts. There are, however, two points at which this study and the anti-Stratfordian arguments converge. First, anti-Stratfordians have often concerned themselves with the attack on the “upstart crow” in Greene’s Groatsworth of Wit and Henry Chettle’s supposed apology to the “upstart crow.” The proliferation of anti-Stratfordian interpretations of these documents would be irresponsible to ignore, particularly since some anti-Stratfordians have raised valid criticisms of the traditional interpretations of Chettle’s apology (see Chapter 2). Second, in at least one instance an anti-Stratfordian has mounted an argument concerning William Shakespeare’s acting company before 1594. Analyzing this argument (Chapter 10) is, of course, well within the scope of this study, and also affords an opportunity to point out several other liabilities in the anti-Stratfordian position. *** The chapters that follow are divided into three sections. In the first section, I define the chronological parameters of this study. It is possible to say with certainty that Shakespeare was born in 1564 and joined the Lord Chamberlain’s Men at, or very soon after, its formation in the late spring of 1594. It is also possible to set down some other chronological certainties within these thirty years. In Chapter 1, I discuss when at the earliest Shakespeare could have reasonably left Stratford to embark
Introduction
7
on his theatrical career. In Chapter 2, I try to determine a rough framework for Shakespeare’s pre-1594 London activities. To do so, I first consider two possible pre1594 allusions to Shakespeare (Greene’s Groatsworth of Wit and Thomas Nashe’s Pierce Pennilesse), which firmly place Shakespeare in London by 1592, after which I consider the evidence we have for dating some of Shakespeare’s early plays. These first two chapters will show that Shakespeare could have left Stratford as early as the late 1570s, that he likely arrived in London by about 1588, and was established as a playwright by 1592 before becoming the Chamberlain’s Men’s leading playwright in 1594. Having set up this chronological framework, I provide a discussion in Part 2 of the theatrical contexts Shakespeare would (and could) have worked in between about 1577 and 1594. Chapter 3 will provide a brief overview of touring practices and active companies between 1577 and 1588, while Chapter 4 will offer an overview of London playing between 1588 and 1594. I will outline several key changes that occurred during those years and also address several misconceptions about the activities of playing companies during this period. The ensuing chapters in Part 3 will set out and analyze, within the framework furnished by Parts 1 and 2, the various arguments for Shakespeare’s membership in particular playing companies. The first four chapters in Part 3 analyze the four most prominent, substantive, and complex arguments for Shakespeare’s early company affiliations. These chapters are organized in a way designed to follow the chronological development of Shakespearean biographies and historical scholarship. Accordingly, Chapter 5 takes up the Queen’s Men, one of the companies Edmond Malone thought Shakespeare might have joined, while Chapters 6, 7, and 8 consider the three companies J.O. Halliwell-Phillips, followed by E.K. Chambers and many others, believed Shakespeare belonged to before the Chamberlain’s Men: Strange’s Men, Pembroke’s Men, and Sussex’s Men. Chapter 9 then considers the argument that Shakespeare spent several of his teenage years in Lancashire, in the service of the Hoghton family. This suggestion was first made in 1923, but since the 1980s and E.A.J. Honigmann’s Shakespeare: the ‘lost years’, it has attracted a good deal of attention and been endorsed by several prominent scholars. This chapter will focus on the Lancashire connection as a whole, but also pay special attention to Honigmann’s suggestion that, while in Lancashire, Shakespeare belonged to companies of players patronized by Alexander Hoghton and Thomas Hesketh. Finally, Chapter 10 examines a number of other, less popular and less substantive arguments that have been made regarding Shakespeare’s pre-1594 theatrical activities. This chapter will begin with a consideration of the argument for Shakespeare’s presence in Leicester’s Men, before examining how the methods used to locate Shakespeare in Leicester’s Men parallel those used to place him in Worcester’s, Warwick’s, Oxford’s, and the Admiral’s Men. After a brief conclusion, the Appendix includes the itineraries for the Queen’s, Strange’s, Pembroke’s, and Sussex’s Men between 1577 and 1594, as I make frequent reference to these itineraries in the relevant chapters. Before proceeding, a few general notes about the text are in order. First, because of the structure of this study, there is necessarily a fair amount of repetition. For
8
Shakespeare’s Companies
example, some of what is discussed in Chapter 4 regarding London playing companies between 1588 and 1594 is repeated and expanded on in Chapter 6, but in the context of Strange’s Men’s activities in London during the same period. The reason for this repetition is to ensure that the reader always has all information relevant to the topic at hand, rather than constantly referring the reader back to previous chapters. Second, this study is primarily a work of synthesis rather than a work of original documentary research. It is the arguments that have been erected on factual foundations—not the foundations themselves—that I am primarily concerned with. For this reason, the reader will notice that most documentary sources are cited from secondary sources (Records of Early English Drama and English Professional Theatre, 1530–1660, to name two particularly prominent secondary sources). Finally, although for the most part I directly cite play scenes and lines when a scholar makes use of such in his or her arguments, there are a few instances where I do not directly cite to the play and instead cite to the scholar’s argument. I have done this only where the scholar’s references to particular plays or scenes are in passing, or are minor parts of a much larger pattern of argumentation.
PART 1 Towards a Chronological Framework
This page intentionally left blank
Chapter 1
In Stratford
The incontrovertible facts of Shakespeare’s pre-London existence are minimal. The exact date of his birth cannot even be determined. Tradition has assigned his nativity to 23 April 1564, St. George’s day, but this tradition is motivated by happy coincidence rather than documentary evidence. He was christened on 26 April, so could not have been but a few days old at that point; beyond this, nothing can be said with any certainty about his birth.1 He was the third child born to John and Mary Shakespeare, but the first to make it past the age of two; Joan, christened 15 September 1558, seems to have died soon thereafter, and Margaret too passed away shortly after her christening on 2 December 1562. The family continued to grow after William’s birth: Gilbert was christened on 13 October 1566, a second Joan on 15 April 1569, Anne on 28 September 1571, Richard on 11 March 1574, and Edmund, who, like his eldest brother, would become a player, on 3 May 1580, just over a year after the death of his sister Anne (Schoenbaum, Compact 23–8; Loomis 6–13). After his christening, William Shakespeare is not heard of again until 1582, when, on 27 November, according to the Episcopal Register of the diocese of Worcester, he and Anne Whateley of Temple Grafton were issued a marriage license; the next day, a bond was granted allowing young William to marry an Anne Hathaway. The general consensus is that the clerk keeping the register that day made a mistake in taking down the bride’s name, but several biographers, such as Frank Harris (1909), have seized upon the possibility William wanted to marry Anne Whateley, only to be coerced into a union with the other Anne. Whatever the truth of William’s marital intentions, it was definitely Anne Hathaway, seven or eight years his senior, who became his bride, and who, six months later, gave birth to their first child, Susanna, christened 26 May 1583. Less than two years later, she gave birth to the twins Hamnet and Judith, christened 2 February 1585 (Schoenbaum, Compact 75–94; Loomis 17–21).2 After 1585, William Shakespeare disappears from the records until 1588, when he is mentioned in a lawsuit brought against his father. The suit, however, merely says he is John’s son; it says nothing about his activities, employment, or whereabouts 1 For a more in-depth discussion of the dating of Shakespeare’s birth, see Bearman, Shakespeare and Schoenbaum, Compact 24–6 and 325, note 3. 2 For a concise consideration of the problems surrounding Shakespeare’s marriage, see Ingram, The Business of Playing 19–24 . Joseph Gray’s Shakespeare’s Marriage (1905) is another useful study of all of the circumstances surrounding the marriage.
12
Shakespeare’s Companies
(Schoenbaum, Compact 39–40; Loomis 23–5). He may have been engaged in some sort of theatrical occupation by that time since, by 1592, he was a dramatist of sufficient note to draw the wrath of Robert Greene, or someone writing under Greene’s name (the authorship, nature, and reliability of this attack will be discussed in the next chapter). Greene’s well-known attack clearly indicates Shakespeare was an actor before he was a dramatist. He must therefore have started acting some time before 1592. Perhaps Shakespeare was an actor for years before he began writing; alternatively, he could have taken up playwriting shortly after he began to act. He must have left Stratford well before 1592, as he would have needed at least some time to establish himself within the London theatre scene. Did he go directly into theatre? Would he have first joined a provincial acting company, or would he have gone directly to London and joined a company there? Did he start writing before or after he went to London? Could he have had other occupations outside of Stratford before going to London or going into theatre? There is no consensus on any of these questions, as the ensuing chapters will demonstrate. There is no other direct evidence for Shakespeare’s activities before his London emergence, and one is reminded of George Steevens’s famous comment: As all that is known with any degree of certainty concerning Shakespeare is—that he was born at Stratford upon Avon,—married and had children,—went to London, where he commenced actor, and wrote poems and plays,—returned to Stratford, made his will, died, and was buried—I confess my readiness to combat every unfounded supposition respecting the particular occurrences of his life. (Malone, Supplement i.654)
Happily, more evidence survives concerning John Shakespeare’s activities, which in turn shed some light on William’s early life. Despite several reports which describe the father as a butcher (John Aubrey’s Brief Lives) or wool-dealer (Nicholas Rowe’s “Some Account of the Life, &c. of Mr. William Shakespear”), surviving documents clearly indicate John Shakespeare was primarily a glover, although he did have dealings in other trades, including wool, timber, and barley; he also rented out property. Like many people of his station in Elizabethan England, he was often involved in lawsuits, both as plaintiff and defendant (Schoenbaum, Compact 30–32). He was well regarded among his fellow Stratfordians: in 1556, he was named one of the town’s two ale-tasters, and in 1558 he was one of the town’s four constables. The next year he served as the town’s afeeror, and about this time he became one of the community’s fourteen burgesses. From 1561 to 1563 he was one of Stratford’s two chamberlains, and he served as acting chamberlain in 1565 and 1566. In 1565 he received the additional honor of being elected one of the town’s fourteen aldermen, and in 1567 he was elected bailiff, Stratford’s highest office. Although he served only one term as bailiff, he remained an important community figure, serving as chief alderman and deputy to the bailiff in 1571 (33–7). John Shakespeare’s status as burgess is particularly important in regards to William’s early life, because the children of Stratford burgesses were entitled to a free education at the King’s New School of Stratford-Upon-Avon (Schoenbaum, Lives 8). There is therefore no
In Stratford
13
reason why William could not have attended the school when he was old enough. Unfortunately, the records for the school’s sixteenth-century pupils vanished well before any scholars were interested in perusing them for the name of the boy who would become the school’s most famous student (10). As a student at the King’s New School, William Shakespeare would have received the typical and rigorous primary education of the day.3 It is unclear, however, if he finished the school’s course of study. Nicholas Rowe, for instance, reports that William was withdrawn from school owing to his father’s growing financial difficulties (i.ii–iii). Surviving records testify to John’s troubles: in 1576 he stopped attending local meetings for the most part, and beginning in 1578 he faced a series of debts, lawsuits, and mortgages pointing to strained financial circumstances for the Shakespeare family. John’s fellow burgesses and aldermen made efforts to accommodate his difficulties, exempting him from certain fees, but this aid apparently failed to alleviate John’s financial condition, as he attended his last council meeting in 1582; after four years’ grace, the council elected a replacement for him. He still occasionally was asked to perform important town duties, indicating the esteem he once enjoyed had not completely eroded, money problems and delinquency as an alderman notwithstanding; nevertheless, as late as 1592 John was avoiding church attendance for, he asserted, fear of debt collection (Schoenbaum, Compact 39–43; Loomis 30). The facts, however, do not necessarily lend credence to Rowe’s claim that William was withdrawn from school. Such an action on his father’s part certainly was possible, but it may not have been a necessity. Stratford, like much of rural England, was deep in recession during this period (Schoenbaum, Compact 42), so John’s difficulties were likely not isolated; not only that, in spite of the evidence of John’s financial strain, other records indicate he was able to produce significant sums of money during the time of his supposed financial disarray. For instance, he was able to raise £10 for someone’s bail bond (43). Coupled with the fact William’s education would have been free until John was replaced as burgess in 1586, it is distinctly possible that William could have finished his course of education despite his family’s troubles. Even if Shakespeare did prematurely leave the King’s New School, it cannot have been very long before he would have finished his studies. His father’s financial problems began around 1576, when William was twelve, and most students finished grammar school at the age of fourteen or fifteen (Schoenbaum, Compact 73). Whatever the case, Shakespeare found himself in need of employment around 1578 or 1579. Once again, there is no evidence whatsoever indicating what occupation he took up at this time, although two early sources (both removed from the events by over a century) independently report he entered the family business: Nicholas Rowe (1709) simply asserts William entered his father’s employment, while John Aubrey reports (c. 1681) 3 The definitive works on this topic remains T.W. Baldwin’s William Shakspere’s Petty School (1943) and William Shakspere’s Small Latine & Lesse Greeke (1944), which meticulously trace the typical sixteenth- century grammar school curriculum and how it is manifested in Shakespeare’s works.
14
Shakespeare’s Companies
more specifically, and erroneously, that William, like his father, became a butcher (Schoenbaum, Compact 74–5). Rowe and Aubrey base their assertions on legends which, Richard Dutton notes, were reported too long after Shakespeare’s death to be entirely trustworthy, “but too early to be dismissed out of hand” (Literary Life 3). Other possibilities that have been advanced for his early employment include law clerk, soldier, seaman, barber, surgeon, physician, and schoolmaster (Schoenbaum, Compact 109–11). The proponents of most of these conjectures maintain he held a non-theatrical occupation for some years before entering the theatre, gaining such entrance with either his emigration to London, or else with the visit of a playing company to Stratford in the mid-to-late 1580s. It is, however, at least possible he began his theatrical career earlier, perhaps even upon his completion of, or withdrawal from, school. The difficulties posed by such a scenario—namely how Shakespeare, if a traveling player, could have met, impregnated, and married Anne Hathaway— have not stopped several biographers, such as Katherine Duncan-Jones (Ungentle Shakespeare) and John Southworth (Shakespeare the Player), from making just such an argument. Most biographers ground themselves in the more traditional assumption that he worked in Stratford for a number of years before joining a playing company, although there is a notable group that contends Shakespeare traveled north for a time, finding employment, possibly theatrical, in Lancashire (see Chapter 9). Before he joined a company, however, young Shakespeare could have been exposed to theatrical entertainment in several different ways in and around his home town. First, Stratford was home to Whitsuntide entertainments, which Shakespeare might have participated in as a youth and young man; in 1583 the corporation actually paid 13s, 4d to a Davy Jones “and his company for his pastime at Whitsuntide” (Schoenbaum, Compact 112). While no other such payments are recorded around this time, it is certainly possible such entertainments were performed on other Whitsuntides during Shakespeare’s youth. Second, he may have participated in Christmas mummings. Aubrey, believing John Shakespeare was a butcher and that William worked for him, says when William “killed a calf, he would do it in a high style, and make a speech” (Schoenbaum, Compact 74). Of course, John Shakespeare was not a butcher, so the reliability of this anecdote is in doubt; however, some biographers, such as A.L. Rowse (William Shakespeare: A Biography) and Ian Wilson (Shakespeare: The Evidence), suggest this report is in fact a corrupted recollection of William’s participation in the traditional Christmas mumming play of killing the calf (Schoenbaum, Lives 67; Rowse 86; I. Wilson 61–2). Such speculation is impossible to verify. Third, Shakespeare almost certainly would have had to read various classical plays as part of the King’s New School curriculum, as was common practice in English schools at the time (Schoenbaum, Compact 68–9); perhaps there were opportunities to hold recitations, or to mount productions, in the course of his study (69). But of course there is no evidence for such activities. During his youth, Shakespeare would also have had at least two opportunities to see spectacular entertainments near Stratford. In 1575, Robert Dudley, Earl of Leicester, entertained Queen Elizabeth at Kenilworth, only twelve miles from Stratford, and many locals flocked to the spectacular entertainments Dudley staged. What the crowd
In Stratford
15
witnessed on this occasion was a water-pageant which had more in common with later court masques than with the sorts of plays Shakespeare would write; nevertheless, it is possible John Shakespeare, at the time an alderman, might have journeyed to Kenilworth with his eldest son, then aged eleven, in tow (Schoenbaum, Compact 115–16). Stephen Greenblatt cites a number of incidents in Shakespeare’s plays which might allude to Kenilworth; while Greenblatt does not argue Shakespeare was actually at the entertainment, he contends that Shakespeare would have heard, and may have read, about it (43–50). A few years later, when he was fifteen, Shakespeare would have had the opportunity to make the slightly lengthier trek to Coventry to witness one of the last performances of that city’s famous Mystery cycle. In both cases, there is no evidence to suggest the future playwright took advantage of these opportunities, but in both cases his attendance at these events is clearly within the realm of possibilities (Schoenbaum, Compact 111, 161). During Shakespeare’s early years, Stratford records also record numerous visits by professional playing companies. During the 1568–69 fiscal year, when his father was bailiff, the Queen’s players (predecessors to the more famous Queen’s Men, formed in 1583) visited Stratford, as did Worcester’s Men, which would return in 1574–75, 1576–77, 1580–81, 1581–82, and 1583–84. Leicester’s Men passed through Stratford in 1572–73 and 1576–77; Warwick’s Men made its sole Stratford visit in 1574–75. Strange’s Men made its Stratford debut on 11 February 1579, followed by the Countess of Essex’s players sometime before September 1579. Derby’s Men made its way to Stratford in 1579–80; the next year, Berkeley’s gave a performance, followed by another in 1582–83, a year in which Chandos’s Men also made an appearance. In 1583–84, Oxford’s and Essex’s Men made their first Stratford visits; no companies visited in 1584–85, and an unnamed company (perhaps Sussex’s Men) passed through town in 1585–86. During the 1586–87 fiscal year, no fewer than five companies visited Stratford: the Queen’s, Essex’s, Leicester’s, Stafford’s, and an unnamed company all performed. This fiscal year represents the apex of professional activity in Stratford, as playing company notices trail off. The Queen’s Men passed through twice in the early 1590s, and four unnamed companies visited the town at the end of the 1590s (Minutes and Accounts ii.68–9, 77, 105–6, iii.13–14, 43, 46, 98, 119, 136–37, 148–49, iv.16, 31–2, v.7, 19, 123). All these playing notices were recorded, of course, because the town paid each of these companies; it may be that there were other visits during Shakespeare’s youth which, for whatever reason, were not recorded. In any event, Shakespeare had ample opportunity to see professional playing companies during his youth, and it may be he joined one of the companies named in the Stratford records. Indeed, of the thirteen separate companies named in the Stratford Chamberlains’ accounts, six of them have, at some point, been advocated as the company he first acted, and by extension wrote, for.4 Throughout his childhood and early adulthood, then, William Shakespeare had numerous chances to see and participate in local theatrical entertainments and also 4
The six companies in question are: The Queen’s Men, Leicester’s Men, Warwick’s Men, Oxford’s Men, Worcester’s Men, and Strange’s Men . For the particular advocates for each of these companies, see the corresponding chapters in Part Three.
16
Shakespeare’s Companies
had the opportunity to witness performances by a number of professional playing companies. Sometime after 1577 (at the absolute earliest) he sought out theatrical employment. He may have done so by joining a professional company which visited Stratford, perhaps soon after finishing (or leaving) school, perhaps after having first worked in a non-theatrical capacity for several years. He may have left Stratford for London for non-theatrical work and subsequently found his calling on the London stage. Or he may have left Stratford with the goal of “making it” as a London actor or playwright. Whatever the case, by 1592 he was a playwright of sufficient note to attract the attention—and enmity—of a fellow writer.
Chapter 2
Greene’s Groatsworth of Wit and Shakespeare’s First Plays
After his 1585 marriage in Stratford-upon-Avon, Shakespeare disappears from view until 1592, when he emerges as a playwright in London. Two allusions in 1592 verify his presence in the city, and both seemingly testify to Shakespeare’s prominence as a popular playwright. In the first edition of Pierce Pennilesse, entered into the Stationers’ Register on 8 August 1592 (Arber ii.619), Thomas Nashe comments on the condition of the London stage: How it would have ioyed brave Talbot (the terror of the French) to thinke that after he head lyne two hundred years in his tombe, he should triumphe agane on the stage, and have his bones newe embalmed with the teares of ten thousand spectators at least (at severall times) who in the Tragedian that represents his person, imagine they behold him fresh bleeding. (87)1
Only one extant Elizabethan play—Shakespeare’s 1 Henry VI—features Talbot, although it is possible there may have been other Talbot plays by 1592. In the absence of additional evidence, however, it is probable, though not certain, that Nashe was referring to 1 Henry VI. If so, this means that by August 1592 Shakespeare had written a phenomenally successful play seen by “ten thousand spectators at least (at severall times).” It also means Shakespeare, or at least one of his plays, had impressed one of the prominent writers and literary commentators of the day.2 Such approval was not, however, universally the case. Robert Greene: Death and Deathbed Confessionals A second allusion to Shakespeare appeared soon after Nashe’s first edition of Pierce Pennilesse. A pamphlet entitled Greenes Groats-worth of witte, bought with a million 1 I quote G.B. Harrison’s edition. Harrison uses Pierce Pennilesse’s third edition, published late in 1592 (ix). 2 Gary Taylor has suggested in his article “Shakespeare and Others: The Authorship of Henry the Sixth, Part One” that Nashe’s enthusiasm may have had ulterior motives. Specifically, Taylor suggests Nashe collaborated with Shakespeare on this play. Edward Burns, editor of the Arden King Henry VI Part 1 similarly regards the text as collaborative, but he does not speculate as to the identity of Shakespeare’s collaborators (75, 79). For objections to Taylor’s argument, see Hattaway’s introduction to the 1990 Cambridge edition of 1 Henry VI (1–2, 42–3).
Shakespeare’s Companies
18
of Repentance, entered into the Stationers’ Register on 20 September 1592 (Arber ii.620), is often cited as the first definite allusion to Shakespeare as a playwright, as well as the earliest definite evidence of Shakespeare’s London—and indeed theatrical—activities. This short work has generated several controversies, most of them pertaining directly to what, if anything, it has to say about Shakespeare. Because Groatsworth, as it is referred to hereafter, is such a contentious document, and because it is pivotal for Shakespeare’s biography, the circumstances, characters, and implications contained in it warrant close scrutiny. Groatsworth is allegedly the deathbed confession of Robert Greene, who died on 3 September 1592. Greene had been a leading literary figure of his day, writing numerous poems, novels, plays, and pamphlets, the latter not infrequently containing satirical jibes at other active writers of the time. As a playwright, he was, with Thomas Nashe, George Peele, and Christopher Marlowe, one of the universityeducated group of playwrights often referred to retrospectively as the University Wits. Greene was one of the more successful, and prolific, of the Wits, and a number of his works sold well for the time; in fact, on more than one occasion the type size for his name was much larger than that of the work’s title (Groatsworth itself being an example; see Carroll, Groatsworth v). Part of Greene’s success, however, was tied to his character, or at least his persona in the popular imagination of his readers. Greene was notorious for fraternizing with underworld types and leading a life of general dissipation. Some of his last works were “conycatching pamphlets” that described the lifestyle and practices of various groups of ill-repute. The extent of Greene’s real-life underworld connections is debatable, but by 1592 many London bookstall patrons would have heard rumors of Greene’s riotous living.3 In the late summer of 1592, Greene took ill; he was dead by 3 September. Almost immediately, writings about Greene’s last days were being sold at the bookstalls. Gabriel Harvey, Greene’s literary nemesis, set out what he understood to be the facts of Greene’s last days in a letter dated 5 September and published soon thereafter (Carroll, Groatsworth 7). Harvey characterizes Greene as a man who “sought Fame by diffamation of other” (5), a “madde libeller,” “the king of the paper stage,” “the Monarch of Crosbiters,” and “the very Emperour of shifters” (5–9).4 Despite his certainty that all Londoners had “heard of his dissolute, and licentious liuing” (9), Harvey catalogues various nefarious deeds of Greene’s: his “vnseemely apparell,” his “impious profaning of sacred Textes,” and his “forsaking of his owne wife” (9–10). Harvey claims Greene took up with a prostitute, had a child by her, and then descended into poverty and lice-infested squalor. After “a surfett of pickle herringe and rennish wine” (5) Greene took ill and his friends abandoned him. At the end, Harvey says, the prostitute and Greene’s landlady were his only companions. Harvey alleges that he visited the landlady, who gave him some of the details of Greene’s last days and showed him a letter Greene had written to his wife, asking her to pay
3 4
For more on the life of Robert Greene, see Charles W. Crupi, Robert Greene. I quote G.B. Harrison’s edition of Harvey’s Four Letters and Certain Sonnets.
Greene’s Groatsworth of Wit and Shakespeare’s First Plays
19
off his debt to the landlady (10–12). All told, Greene’s last days had turned him into “a very proverbe of Infamy, and contempt” (5). Perhaps due to these comments of Harvey’s, or perhaps feeding off the same morbid interest in Greene’s end, pamphlets claiming to be Greene’s last thoughts flooded into print. The first of these was Groatsworth, which was advertised as “published at his dyeing request” (Carroll, Groatsworth v). The text, a patchwork of Greene’s alleged last writings, does not form a single coherent narrative or essay, although certain recurring themes—particularly betrayal—lend the work a sort of unity. In an opening epistle, William Wright, the pamphlet’s publisher, claims the document “happened into his handes” after Greene’s death (41).5 Next, a brief epistle from the author (who, because he is not universally accepted as Robert Greene, I shall refer to as “Greene”) declares that what follows are his parting thoughts (42). Then begins the story of “Roberto,” a disinherited scholar who, upon a failed attempt to dupe his brother out of his money, begins writing stage plays at the encouragement of a richly-dressed player. Although successful in his theatrical endeavors, Roberto descends into a life of vice and riotous living, which leaves him broke and ill. Fearing that his end is near, he resolves to pass on to others the belated wisdom that should have guided his life (46–75). Abruptly, but perhaps not surprisingly, “Greene” breaks off the story of Roberto and reveals that he has been talking about his own life the whole time. After setting out rules for virtuous living (75–6), “Greene” alludes to a letter of warning to his “fellow Schollers about this Cittie” (79). This letter immediately follows, declaring that “To those Gentlemen his Quondam acquaintance, that spend their wits in making plaies, R.G. wisheth a better exercise, and wisdome to prevent his extremeties” (80). In this letter, “Greene” singles out three writers for rebuke, who are referred to as “thou famous gracer of Tragedians,” “yong Juvenall, that byting Satyrist,” and “S. George” (80–83). Having warned all three to change their ways, “Greene” launches into the diatribe that has become the most famous part of the entire Groatsworth: Base minded men all three of you, if by my miserie you be not warnd: for unto none of you (like mee) sought those burres to cleave: those Puppets (I meane) that spake from our mouths, those Anticks garnisht in our colours. Is it not strange, that I, to whom they have all beene beholding: is it not like that you, to whome they all have beene beholding, shall (were yee in that case as I am now) bee both at once of them forsaken? Yes trust them not: for there is an upstart Crow, beautified with our feathers, that with his Tygers hart wrapt in a Players hyde, supposes he is as well able to bombast out a blanke verse as the best of you: and being an absolute Johannes fac totum, is in his owne conceit the onely Shakescene in a countrey. (83–5)
Shakespearean biographers and other interested scholars have inevitably focused their attention on this one section of “Greene’s” letter to the playwrights. However, major problems with the interpretation of this passage continue to recur, in large part because scholars immediately focus on “Shake-scene” without taking the time 5
In all cases I cite D. Allen Carroll’s edition of Groatsworth.
20
Shakespeare’s Companies
to analyze the context (and even content) of the entire passage. Here are some typical comments: Among the significant pieces of evidence cited by Stratfordians is Robert Greene’s reference to an actor he calls “Shake-scene,” and his use of language that may suggest that “Shake-scene” was a playwright as well. (Fields 107) The pun in Shake-scene and ridicule of a line from 3 Henry VI ... leaves us no doubt as to Greene’s target. (Honigmann, “Shakespeare’s Life” 4) The line is read as giving special significance to the term “Shake-scene.” (Ogburn 57) “Shake-scene” clearly puns on the name Shakespeare, and “tiger’s heart wrapped in a player’s hide,” paraphrases a line from one of the most memorable scenes in this play Henry VI. (Wells 49) The pun in “Shake-scene” leaves no doubt that Shakespeare is meant (J. Dover Wilson, Essential 44) That it is Shakespeare who is under attack is plain from the pun on his name and from the allusion to the scene in Henry VI Part 3 (Wood 144)
Basically, discussions of the passage have been plagued by a tendency among commentators to base their identifications on the “Shake-scene” allusion and then make the rest of the passage fit this identification. Accordingly, this matter becomes a touchstone for a pattern of inadequate historical testing of the biographical sources. We shall return to this contentious passage after finishing the description of Groatsworth and several related issues it raises. Following the attack on the “upstart Crow” and players in general, “Greene” urges his addressees to give up playwriting and practice virtue (86–7). Groatsworth concludes with a retelling of Aesop’s fable of the Grasshopper and the Ant, wherein at the end the Ant is blamed for abandoning his old friend, the Grasshopper, in his time of need; some have seen this as still another swipe at Shakespeare.6 At the end of the fable, “Greene” declares that he feels his life leaving his body and beseeches “them that shall burie my bodie, to publish this last farewell written with my wretched hand” (89). As an epilogue, Groatsworth closes with “A letter written to his wife, founde with this booke after his death” (90–91), quite different from the one Harvey reports, wherein he begs his wife’s forgiveness for the wrongs he did her in life and implores her to receive their child back into her care. Groatsworth was not the last supposed Robert Greene deathbed confessional published in the wake of his death. The Repentance of Robert Greene—a much shorter and substantially different confessional than Groatsworth—was entered into 6 The main proponent of this identification is E.A.J. Honigmann in Shakespeare’s Impact on His Contemporaries (1–6), although the eccentric anti-Stratfordian Alden Brooks anticipated this identification in Will Shakspere: Factotum and Agent (1937) and Will Shakspere and the Dyer’s Hand (1943). See Schoenbaum, Lives 429–30.
Greene’s Groatsworth of Wit and Shakespeare’s First Plays
21
the Stationers’ Register on 6 October (Arber ii.621). Like Groatsworth, Repentance consists of disparate elements pertaining to Greene’s life and death, including two accounts of Greene’s life of dissipation (9–28), an outline of his literary career (25), a list of virtues or “Cauiats” for “a frend of his” to follow (29–30), a report on his death, including a letter to Greene’s wife quite similar to the one of Harvey’s report (31–2), and a prayer Greene allegedly wrote “in the time of his sicknesse” (33–4). However, Repentance differs from Groatsworth in several key ways. Firstly, while Repentance is less specific than Groatsworth concerning biographical details, those it does include essentially square with Harvey’s account of Greene’s last days (Jowett, “Johannes Factotum” 480). Secondly, the tone of Repentance is one of contrition, and the anger and bitterness permeating Groatsworth are entirely absent. Finally, Repentance contains no diatribes against the theatre community. Repentance mentions that Greene wrote plays, but does not overtly connect this activity with his shameful personal life. Moreover, Repentance does not even mention actors, let alone single them out for abuse. Given these discrepancies between Groatsworth and Repentance, and given that they both claim to be Greene’s dying musings, it is hard to be confident that either one is a genuine document from the pen of Robert Greene.7 Unsurprisingly, the authenticity of both was explicitly or implicitly called into question following their publication. Some time after Groatsworth’s publication, the second edition of Nashe’s Pierce Pennilesse was issued (the date is not certain, but must have been in the autumn of 1592).8 Here, in an opening epistle, Nashe expresses a desire to tell Greene’s ghost “what a coyle there is with pamphleting on him after his death” (1)9 and specifically makes reference to Groatsworth: Other news I am aduertised of, that a scald trivial lying pamphlet, cald Greens groatsworth of wit is giuen out to be of my doing. God neuer haue care of my soule, but vtterly renouce me, if the least word or sillable in it proceeded from my pen, or if I were any way priuie to the writing or printing of it. (2–3).
7
Of the two, Groatsworth is most usually seen as a hoax; Repentance is often assumed to be genuine, since its account of Greene’s last days is similar to Harvey’s letter. Jowett’s “Johannes Factotum” suggests that Repentance was for the most part genuine, with an editorial overlay; Sanders (“Greene’s ‘Editors’”) and Bolz (43) both argue the Repentance is a forgery. Whatever the case, both pamphlets, while published by different stationers (Groatsworth— William Wright, Repentance—Cuthbert Burby), were printed by the same individual—John Danter (Jowett, “Johannes Factotum” 467–8). Jowett suggests Chettle edited Repentance and forged Groatsworth (477–8). 8 The first edition was entered in the Stationers’ Register on 8 August 1592 (Arber ii.619); the third edition was published at the end of 1592 (Harrison, Pierce Pennilesse ix). The second edition therefore must have been printed after Groatsworth (20 September), but long enough before the end of 1592 to allow for it to sell out, thus necessitating the third edition. 9 I cite G.B. Harrison’s 1923 edition, which is based on the third edition of Pierce Pennilesse, published at the end of 1592; Nashe’s comments on Groatsworth were first included in the second edition (ix).
22
Shakespeare’s Companies
Evidently someone believed Groatsworth was a forgery and had accused Nashe of fabricating it, a charge Nashe emphatically denies. Significantly, however, Nashe seems to agree with the forgery charges, given his characterization of Groatsworth as “a scald trivial lying pamphlet.” Nashe was not the only person accused of forging Groatsworth. In December of 1592, Henry Chettle shed more light on the controversy in his Kind-Hart’s Dream (entered into the Stationers’ Register 8 December 1592—Arber ii.623). Writing “To the Gentlemen Readers,” Chettle makes several important statements. First, Chettle asserts that, upon Greene’s death, he had obtained many of his papers, “among others his Groats-worth of wit. “Second, Chettle reveals that two of the “play-makers” addressed in the “upstart Crow” letter had taken offense at “Greene’s” scolding. Moreover, these playwrights had apparently accused Chettle of being responsible for the pamphlet: “because on the dead they cannot be auenged, they wilfully forge in their conceites a liuing Author: and after tossing it two and fro, no remedy, but it must light on me. “Chettle claims this is unfair, as he has always “hindred the bitter inueying against schollers. “Chettle then offers his assessment of the two playwrights who had taken offense at Groatsworth: With neither of them that take offence was I acquainted, and with one of them I care not if I neuer be: The other, whome at that time I did not so much spare, as since I wish I had ... I am as sory, as if the originall fault had been my fault, because my selfe haue seen his demeanor no lesse ciuill than he excelent in the qualitie he professes. Besides, divers of worship haue reported, his uprightnes of dealing, which argues his honesty, and his facetious grace in writting, that aprooues his Art. For the first, whose learning I reuerence, and at the preusing of Greenes Booke, stroke out what then in concsience I thought he in some displeasure writ: or had it beene true, yet to publish it, was intollerable: him I would wish to use me no worse than I deserue. (A3v–A4)
Third, Chettle acknowledges he was involved in the publication of Groatsworth, but only as an editor who transcribed what he claimed was Greene’s near-illegible original manuscript. Fourth, after claiming neither he nor Nashe had had anything to do with Groatsworth, Chettle makes a startling confession: “Neither was he [Nashe] the writer of an Epistle to the second part or Gerileon, though by the workemans error T.N. were set to the end: that I confesse to be mine, and repent it not” (A3v– A4). Apparently, then, Chettle had been involved with some previous literary mischief, although he conveniently assigns ultimate blame for the past incident to the printer. Perhaps this is the reason why, unlike Nashe, who only offered a quick dismissal of forgery charges, Chettle felt he had more to answer for. Interestingly, unlike Nashe, Chettle does not call on God to witness his denials of responsibility for Groatsworth. Two further publications concerning Greene’s death serve to complicate matters of its accuracy, let alone authenticity, even more. First, Nashe, in Strange News (entered into the Stationers’ Register 12 January 1593—Arber ii.624) openly challenged Gabriel Harvey’s account of Greene’s death. In contrast to Harvey’s letter, as well as both Groatsworth and Repentance, Nashe asserts Greene had not died in poverty and squalor at all: “For the lowsie circumstance of his poverty before
Greene’s Groatsworth of Wit and Shakespeare’s First Plays
23
his death, and sending that miserable writte to his wife, it cannot be but thou lyest, learned Gabriell” (287).10 While many scholars accept Harvey’s letter as reliable— E.H. Miller describes it as “devastatingly accurate” (157)—Nashe’s denial, coupled with the common printing-house origin of both Groatsworth and Repentance,11 must call Harvey’s accuracy into question. Second, the title page of Greene’s Vision, published sometime in late 1592, claims that this work was “Written at the instant of his death;” its publisher further asserts that “Manie have published repentaunces under his name, but none more unfeigned than this, being everie word of his owne: his own phrase, his own method” (A3). Greene’s Vision is in fact apparently by Robert Greene; however, its composition is datable to 1590 and is therefore far from being Greene’s last words (Carroll, Groatsworth 6). At any rate, this is a third “deathbed” confessional, and one that claims that the other “repentaunces”—Groatsworth and Repentance—are themselves feigned. After these final two comments on Greene’s death, the initial controversy surrounding Groatsworth seemingly died down. In the long run, however, controversy concerning Groatsworth refused to disappear entirely; if anything, in recent times it has burned brighter than ever. Greene’s Groatsworth of Wit: Authorship Apart from the 1592–93 controversy, three ensuing controversies have arisen concerning Groatsworth. The first involves, as did the initial controversy, the pamphlet’s authorship; the second concerns the identities of the characters in the letter to the playwrights, especially the identity of the “upstart Crow;” and the third deals with the precise nature of the charges against that upstart Crow. In the case of the first two controversies, some tentative conclusions can be reached; doing so is more difficult in the case of the third. Over the last century, the authorship question of Groatsworth had attracted a great deal of attention. What follows is a brief summary of the various issues involved in this controversy.12 Because of Chettle’s apology, scholars in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries tended to take him at his word that Groatsworth was all Greene’s doing (Jowett, “Johannes Factotum” 454). Doubts about Greene’s authorship were 10
I cite R.B. McKerrow’s edition. Harvey’s Four Letters, which contained the letter concerning Greene, when published in December of 1592 was entered in the Stationers’ Register to John Wolfe (Arber ii.623), who was Danter’s co-printer for Groatsworth and Kind-Hart’s Dream (Thomas, “Printing” 196), thereby forming a printing syndicate of sorts connected with almost all of the posthumous Greene material; then again, Nashe’s Strange News was itself printed by Danter (Arber ii.624). Sorting out what happened with all of the posthumous Greene material is a task indeed. 12 For fuller treatments of the authorship issue, see Carroll’s introduction to his edition of Groatsworth; John Jowett’s “Johannes Factotum: Henry Chettle and Greene’s Groatsworth of Wit” and “Notes on Henry Chettle;” C.E. Sanders’s “Robert Greene and his ‘Editors;’” and Warren B. Austin, A Computer-Aided Technique for Stylistic Discrimination: The Authorship of “Greene’s Groats-worth of Wit.” 11
Shakespeare’s Companies
24
expressed from time to time,13 but were rarely, if ever, actively pursued. Beginning in the early twentieth century, however, serious doubts about Greene’s contributions to Groatsworth were voiced. Although certain favorite themes and motifs of Greene’s, such as the prodigal son and repentance, show up in Groatsworth, and although parts of the pamphlet do have Greene’s style about them (Carroll, Groatsworth 22), a number of important problems and inconsistencies have been pointed out over the years: 1. Serious doubts about Groatsworth’s authenticity were voiced within days of its publication. 2. The biographical information contained in Groatsworth does not square with any of the other available accounts of Greene’s last days. 3. The biographical details in Groatsworth easily could have been derived from other sources; furthermore, certain Groatsworth components are seemingly derived from previous writings of Greene’s. That Greene would repeat himself is plausible enough, but why would he go so far as to derive a new work from previous ones (Jowett, “Notes” 388 and “Johannes Factotum” 463–6; Sanders, “‘Editors’” 397–8; Carroll, Groatsworth 7–12, 22)? 4. “Greene” is inconsistent in regards to his commentary on his health. In the first three quarters of the pamphlet proper, there is no indication at all that he will die, but when he breaks off Roberto’s story and begins talking in the first person, he clearly senses his impending death. But in the epistle preceding the story of Roberto, “Greene” seems to fear he might die. The reader is apparently expected to think “Greene” wrote the epistle before he finished the work, but this was not the usual way of doing things at the time—epistles were written following completion of a work (Sanders, “‘Editors’” 400; Carroll, Groatsworth 9–10). 5. The letter claiming to be from Greene to his wife is of dubious authenticity. In it, “Greene” asks his wife to take into her care the child he has with him; Greene refers to this child as “the fruit of thy wombe” (90). But Harvey’s letter says that Greene recommended his bastard son to his wife. Harvey’s letter seems to be accurate in this regard, in that Harvey claimed the bastard son’s name was “Infortunatus,” and in 1593 a “Fortunatus Greene” was buried in Shoreditch. This being the case, it seems that the letter in Groatsworth is confused as to the details of the situation, which Greene himself ought to have been clear on (Sanders, “‘Editors’” 398; Carroll, Groatsworth 10–11). 6. Besides Groatsworth’s title page, Chettle’s explanation of affairs in Kind-Hart’s Dream is the only insistent claim that Groatsworth is in fact by Greene.14 Chettle, however, does not explain how he came by the manuscript, weakly claims that he was involved in the publication only because Greene’s handwriting was so bad, and even admits to a separate case of forgery. None of this inspires confidence in 13
See Carroll 6, note 17. “B.R.” in Greene’s News Both From Heaven and Hell, entered in Stationers’ Register 3 February 1593 (Arber ii.626), says that Groatsworth was written by Greene, but only in passing; nowhere else is Greene equated with the author of Groatsworth (Carroll, Groatsworth 21). 14
Greene’s Groatsworth of Wit and Shakespeare’s First Plays
25
Chettle’s own “uprightness of dealing.” No one else seems to have seen Greene’s original manuscript. We are therefore forced to rely on the word of an admitted forger (Jowett, “Notes” 387). 7. Finally, in the Stationers’ Register entry for Groatsworth, publisher William Wright wrote that he was entering the pamphlet “uppon the perill of Henrye Chettle” (Arber ii.620). This curious phrase indicates that from the outset some trouble with the pamphlet was expected (Jowett, “Johannes Factotum” 471). If Groatsworth was genuine, and if Chettle had merely copied the work to make it legible, why would he have been made responsible for any adverse outcome resulting from the document’s publication? Taken together, these various details and observations suggest that Robert Greene was not in fact directly responsible for Groatsworth. At the least, the possibility of forgery must be admitted when these factors are taken into account. The question, then, is who was responsible for the pamphlet if Greene himself was not. Who indeed? It should come as no surprise that the answer to this question, in the opinion of several scholars, has been Henry Chettle.15 The grounds for suspecting Chettle can be quickly laid out: 1. He was suspected of being the source for Groatsworth in his own day, as he himself states in Kind-Hart’s Dream. 2. The Stationers’ Register entry for Groatsworth, while it does not accuse Chettle of writing the work, suggests Chettle had some larger role in the text’s history, over and beyond copying it. 3. Chettle competently imitates Greene’s style in Kind-Hart’s Dream in the passages spoken by the character of Greene’s Ghost (Sanders, “‘Editors’” 401–2; Jowett, “Johannes Factotum” 476–7; Carroll, Groatsworth 18). 4. Chettle had a history of literary mischief, if not fraud. He admits this in KindHart’s Dream, acknowledging that he had written the epistle to Gerileon that had been signed “T.N.,” obviously meant to be taken as “Thomas Nashe.” Moreover, Chettle was involved with the publication of other questionable texts, including the 1597 quarto of Romeo and Juliet (Jowett, “Notes” 387, 518; Carroll, Groatsworth 16–17). 5. Chettle’s denial of culpability in Kind-Hart’s Dream is weak. First, Chettle does not, like Nashe, swear to God that he had nothing to do with the composition of Groatsworth. Second, Chettle, in apologizing to one of the target playwrights, suggestively comments that he (Chettle) is “as sory, as if the originall fault had been my fault” (Carroll, Groatsworth 4–5). Last, Chettle says that while he did write the epistle to Gerileon, it was the printer that added the initials “T.N.” Carroll points out, however, that certain allusions in the Gerileon epistle are clearly meant to make it sound like Nashe’s work (3). Thus, while admitting his
15
For more on Chettle, see Harold Jenkins, The Life and Work of Henry Chettle and John Jowett, “Notes on Henry Chettle.”
Shakespeare’s Companies
26
involvement in Gerileon, Chettle gives a fine demonstration of equivocation. One cannot help but wonder if the same is going on in his denial of involvement in Groatsworth. 6. Various writers at the time testify to the lucrative nature of Greene’s name in the publishing business, as does the proliferation of works referring to Greene after his death (Greene’s Funerals, for example, or Greene’s News Both From Heaven and Hell). Comments made by Chettle in Kind-Hart’s Dream indicate that he was hard up for cash in September of 1592 (Carroll, Groatsworth 12–13; Sanders, “‘Editors’” 394). 7. Besides his own literary mischief, Chettle, in his occupation as a printer, was involved with at least one disreputable character in London printing and publishing: John Danter.16 For Groatsworth, Danter printed half the pamphlet for publisher William Wright (John Wolfe printed the other half). Chettle’s own Kind-Heart’s Dream was printed under exactly the same arrangement. Such an association may say something about Chettle’s character, at least in 1592, and they provided him with an associate capable of fraud. His access to this circle of printers and publishers also would have given him access to the various texts that Groatsworth seems to draw on (Carroll, Groatsworth 14–16; Jowett, “Notes” 385–6 and “Johannes Factotum” 466–75). 8. Finally, a 1969 computer-aided analysis by Warren B. Austin (Computer-Aided Technique) seemingly demonstrates that Groatsworth’s style was closer to Chettle’s than Greene’s. Most other scholars have hesitated to regard Austin’s study as conclusive,17 but most recognize that, in light of the other factors pointing to Chettle’s authorship, Austin’s study strengthens the case that Chettle had a hand in the writing, as well as the printing, of Groatsworth. Taken together, all of these observations make a strong case for Chettle’s authorship. The case may not be conclusive, but it certainly makes Chettle a much more likely culprit than any others who have been suggested as the pamphlet’s author.18 16
Greg describes Danter’s career as “nothing but a record of piracy and secret printing, from the time he infringed his master’s rights during apprenticeship to the time when he disappears in disgrace from the records of the [Stationers’] Company” (Two Elizabethan 130). A more measured assessment of Danter’s career appears in Kastan, Shakespeare and the Book 14–49. 17 R.L. Widman (214–15) and Richard Proudfoot (182–3) both raise objections to Austin’s methodology, but concede that his findings open up reasonable lines of inquiry. Jowett (“Johannes Factotum” 455) and Carroll (Groatsworth 24–6) are more confident about Austin’s findings, but also agree with some of Widman and Proudfoot’s reservations. 18 Recently, Katherine Duncan-Jones has argued that Nashe was responsible for Groatsworth. She argues that Groatsworth’s style is too “memorably brilliant” to have been Chettle’s doing, but fits very well with Nashe’s style; that a passage in the opening epistle to the second edition of Pierce Pennilesse could be interpreted as a half-confession; and that there are parallels between certain themes and passages in Groatsworth and Nashe’s own writings (44–8). Duncan-Jones’s characterization of Chettle as a “journeyman” is open to
Greene’s Groatsworth of Wit and Shakespeare’s First Plays
27
Greene’s Groatsworth of Wit: The “Upstart Crow” It is now possible to return to the controversy of the identity of the figures alluded to in the letter to the playwrights. The heading of the letter makes it clear “Greene” is addressing fellow university-trained playwrights. He addresses three of these writers individually: the “famous gracer of Tragedians” (80) “yong Juvenall” (82) and “S. George” (83). Typically, these writers are identified as Christopher Marlowe, Nashe, and George Peele. The word “gracer” can be read as a pun on “Christopher,” and the accusations “Greene” makes against this writer—that he is an atheist—make the Marlowe identification a near certainty (Carroll, Groatsworth 115–21).19 Because “Greene’s” advice for the “gracer” is so extensive and nasty it has often been assumed that Marlowe was one of the two writers Chettle mentions as having taken offense at the letter. Of the other scholar-playwrights about London, “yong Juvenall” seems to best fit Thomas Nashe, who, like Juvenal, was an accomplished, and young, satirist in 1592 (124–9).20 As for “S. George,” no candidate other than George Peele has ever been proposed. These identifications are not certain, and not everyone agrees on them, but all three are plausible. In warning these playwrights about the allegedly disloyal players, “Greene” warns them of one player in particular: “an upstart Crow, beautified with our feathers, that with his Tygers hart wrapt in a Players hyde, supposes he is as well able to bombast out a blanke verse as the best of you: and being an absolute Johannes fac totum, is in his owne conceit the onely Shake-scene in a countrey” (84–5). Controversy has raged around the identification of the “upstart Crow”/”Shake-scene,” and while each of the candidates offered for this identification will be considered in the following discussion, if the passage is properly understood the correct identification is virtually certain. Often times, commentators first make their favorite identification fit the “Shake-scene” allusion and then attempt to make the rest of the passage fit this identification. But “Shake-scene” is clearly the clincher, not the first clue, for “Greene’s” readers. Prior to this allusion, “Greene” gives three crucial pieces of information about this figure:
question, given his later activities (see Chambers, Stage iii.263–4, iv.394). Moreover, her assertion that Groatsworth contains echoes of Nashe’s subject matter and style may simply point to borrowing or mimicry, not a common author. 19 C.E. Sanders is one of the few dissenting voices on this identification, arguing instead that “gracer” is Thomas Watson (“Greene’s Last Years” 489). 20 A number of scholars have argued that “yong Juvenall” is Thomas Lodge. “Greene” does refer to having written “a comedy” with “yong Juvenall;” assuming that the comedy is in fact a play, some have argued that there is no evidence Nashe and Greene ever collaborated, while there is evidence that Lodge and Greene did. However, the main problem is that Lodge was as old as Greene and thus not particularly likely to be referred to as “young.” Moreover, Nashe was apparently known as “young Juvenal” in other circles in his day (Carroll, Groatsworth 123–9).
Shakespeare’s Companies
28
1. He is a player. The “upstart Crow” is clearly connected to the “them” of “Yes trust them not,” which refers to the actors in general. 2. He has turned to playwriting. Some commentators argue “Shake-scene” was merely an actor,21 but the phrasing of the attack makes it clear that the “upstart Crow” is writing plays: he “supposes he is as well able to bombast out a blanke verse as the best of you” (emphasis mine). This portion of the attack makes no sense if the “upstart Crow” is only an actor. Several scholars have argued that “bombast out a blanke verse” refers to bombastic acting (e.g., Chapman 31), but the qualifier “as the best of you” makes no sense in such a context. “The best of you” clearly refers to “Greene’s” addressees, the playwrights, not the actors. The “upstart Crow” is an upstart because he is an actor who has turned to writing plays. 3. The italicized phrase “Tygers hart wrapt in a Players hyde” is punning on a line from either 3 Henry VI (I, iv, 137) or The True Tragedy of Richard Duke of York (B2v line 17). These plays are related, although it is unclear what that relationship is, or which came first.22 Whatever the case, “Greene’s” diatribe connects the “upstart Crow” to this line, suggesting that the player/playwright in question either wrote the line or played the character who speaks it. There are thus three criteria for determining the identity of the “upstart Crow”/ ”Shake-scene.” “Shake-scene” is a fourth criterion: there must be a way this pun fits the player-turned-playwright who is connected to the line from 3 Henry VI/True Tragedy. Rather than beginning with identifying an individual who purportedly fits the “Shake-scene” pun and proceeding to make the other parts of “Greene’s” attack fit that identification, a better way to interpret this passage is to recognize, as Irvin Matus does, that “Shake-scene” “caps” the attack on the player-playwright (67). Whatever their approach, commentators have advanced five candidates as the “upstart Crow”: William Kempe, Christopher Marlowe, Robert Wilson, Edward Alleyn, and of course William Shakespeare. William H. Chapman first suggested William Kempe was the “upstart crow” in 1912. Chapman alleges “Shake-scene” would have meant “dance-scene” in the sixteenth century, a claim for which he offers no evidence (13–14). Accordingly, Chapman says, “Shake-scene” refers to a dancing performance on the stage. In 1592, 21
See Joseph Sobran (35–6); Winifred Frazer (“William Kemp” 140–41); and William H. Chapman (11–37). 22 For more on these issues, see the recent editions of all three Henry VI plays, as well as Yashdip S. Bains, The Contention and The True Tragedy; Robert E. Burkhart, Shakespeare‘s Bad Quartos; Kathleen O. Irace, Reforming the “Bad” Quartos; Laurie E. Maguire, Shakespearean Suspect Texts; Grace Ioppolo, Revising Shakespeare; Steven Urkowitz, “Good News about ‘Bad’ Quartos” and “If I Mistake in Those Foundations Which I Build Upon;” Randall Martin, “The True Tragedy of Richard Duke of York and 3 Henry VI: Report and Revision;” Roger Warren, “The Quarto and Folio Texts of 2 Henry VI: A Reconsideration,” and Hardin Craig, A New Look At Shakespeare’s Quartos, among others.
Greene’s Groatsworth of Wit and Shakespeare’s First Plays
29
one actor would have particularly fit this bill: William Kempe, the clown also famous for his morris-dancing. Chapman claims that Kempe was boastful and arrogant, a “personification of what Greene found detestable” (15). Chapman points to the publication of Nine Days Wonder as evidence that Kempe wrote plays (16). In addition to these points, Winifred Frazer notes that a ballad called “The Crow Sits Upon the Wall” was attributed to Richard Tarlton, the leading clown of his era. This ballad, she says, “no doubt resulted in some crow-like pantomime and jigging” (“William Kemp” 140). Following Tarlton’s death in 1588, Kempe became the most famous clown on stage, and thus could be called an “upstart Crow” (141). Eager to discredit another candidate, Frazer argues that, since Shakespeare’s name had not appeared in print in 1592, he could not have been the target of “Greene’s” attack; Kempe, on the other hand, was well known at the time and complaints about him “may have been commonplace” (141). Frazer insists that the attack is on an actor, not a playwright, and that since Shakespeare was supposedly “gentle” and “honey-tongued” he cannot, as an actor, have been the sort “Greene” singles out (140–41). Frazer’s reasoning for dismissing Shakespeare’s candidacy is problematic. The fact Shakespeare’s name had not appeared in print by 1592 does not disqualify him from being Greene’s target, nor does it mean “Greene’s” readers would have failed to understand the attack. Similarly, the adjectives “honey-tongued” and “gentle,” regardless of their accuracy, refer to Shakespeare as a writer and human being, respectively, not an actor, so they are not evidence for dismissing Shakespeare’s candidacy (Honigmann, Impact 14–21).23 Frazer also misunderstands “Greene’s” attack. She correctly notes that ideally, for Greene, “there is no crossing of the line between actors and playwrights” (140). But the point of the attack is that an actor has crossed the line. Frazer, accordingly, misses the reason behind the attack. As for Kempe, his candidacy does not live up to the first three criteria for the “upstart Crow.” Nine Days Wonder, published in 1600, is the only evidence of Kempe’s writing ambitions, unless one counts the “merriments” scene designated in the title of A Knack to Know a Knave, with Kempe’s Applauded Merriments (1592).24 Besides being written too late to attract Greene’s wrath, this body of work suggests Kempe was a dabbler in playwriting, not an actor trying to compete with the University Wits. Finally, the Tygers hart wrapt in a Players hyde allusion makes little sense if Kempe is the target, as the the line is spoken by York, a serious role Kempe is unlikely to have played. Thus, Kempe fails on two of three necessary counts to be the target of the “upstart Crow” passage. In 1927, C.E. Sanders suggested that Christopher Marlowe was the “upstart Crow.” Sanders’s main concern is that Greene attacked Marlowe several times in 23
Meres (1598) describes Shakespeare as “hony-tongued” in regards to his sonnets; R. Barnfield refers to Shakespeare’s “hony-flowing Vaine” as evidenced in Venus and Adonis and Lucretia (Honigmann, Impact 15); the first references to Shakespeare as “gentle” are in the two poems Ben Jonson contributed to the First Folio, several years after Shakespeare’s death (16). 24 For more on A Knack to Know a Knave, see Chapter 8.
Shakespeare’s Companies
30
print between 1587 and 1591, and the two, Sanders contends, never reconciled. Accordingly, Sanders says, it is unlikely Marlowe is one of the three playwrights addressed in the Groatsworth letter. Instead, Sanders offers Marlowe as the “upstart Crow,” arguing there are ways in which the allusions in that passage could fit Marlowe (“Greene’s Last Years” 489). Unfortunately, Sanders’s supposition is flawed in several ways. The writers addressed in Groatsworth are not friends of Greene’s, but acquaintances with similar credentials and occupations. Thus, enmity between Greene and Marlowe does not disqualify Marlowe as the “gracer of Tragedians,” an identification which has a great deal of merit. More importantly, Marlowe fails the first qualification for being “Greene’s” target: there is no evidence he was ever an actor. If he wasn’t an actor, he could not have been the “upstart Crow,” even if some connection to 3 Henry VI/True Tragedy could be demonstrated.25 Like Marlowe, Robert Wilson, suggested as an “upstart Crow” candidate by William Chapman, also fails to meet one of the three criteria for the “upstart Crow.” Although, as Chapman notes, Wilson was an actor turned dramatist, and also was an enemy of Greene’s (25–7), there is no evidence to connect Wilson to 3 Henry VI or True Tragedy as either writer or actor. Moreover, Wilson was acting already in 1572, was writing plays by about 1579, and had a play published as early as 1584 (Chambers, Stage ii.349). He was thus hardly an “upstart” in 1592, and in any case he had been active in the theatre for over a decade before Greene came on the scene, so even if they were enemies, terming Wilson an “upstart” wouldn’t make sense. In recent years, two commentators have concluded Edward Alleyn was the “upstart Crow” attacked by “Greene.” Jay Hoster argues the “Shake-scene” pun best fits Alleyn, whose acting style was so physical that he once cracked some stage boards—a literal Shake-scene, in other words. Hoster also suggests that Alleyn may very well have played the role of York in 3 Henry VI or True Tragedy, thereby solving the allusion problem (Sobran 34). None of this has any merit, of course, unless Alleyn wrote plays. Such is the contention of A.D. Wraight, who correctly realizes that the “upstart Crow” is not just an actor. Unfortunately, Wraight first identifies Alleyn as the “upstart Crow” and only then looks for other evidence that Alleyn wrote plays. Wraight links Alleyn to the “upstart Crow” by assuming Greene was the author of Groatsworth and Repentance. As such, she accepts both as valid sources of biographical information on Greene’s life (130–31, 136–41). She also argues that all references and accusations to players in Greene’s supposed writings are linked. By combining disparate disparaging mentions of players in Greene’s body of work, Wraight concludes Greene had an ongoing battle with Edward Alleyn, the leading actor of the day (142–3; 163–4). Like Hoster, Wraight asserts “Shakescene” applies to Alleyn since the phrase “was a commonly used term descriptive of a great Elizabethan actor’s performance” (134–5). Moreover, she says the Johannes fac totum line perfectly describes Alleyn, who did quite a few things besides acting, 25
Although such theories fell into disfavor many decades ago, it is worth noting that Marlowe has often been listed as one of several possible collaborators on True Tragedy.
Greene’s Groatsworth of Wit and Shakespeare’s First Plays
31
as his surviving papers demonstrate (190). Since Alleyn fits the rest of the parts of the “upstart Crow” attack to Wraight’s satisfaction, she assumes he must also fit the player-turned-playwright charge, and she goes on to identify a small dramatic corpus for Alleyn.26 The argument for Alleyn as the “upstart Crow” relies on several questionable assumptions. Wraight accepts without question that Groatsworth and Repentance are autobiographical documents written by Greene himself, and thus fails to consider the differences between the two documents, as well as the fact Greene may not have been involved in the writing of both or either text. Wraight’s belief that all of Greene’s alleged autobiographical writings combine to paint a coherent picture of the “upstart Crow” also is unsupported by evidence. Still more problematic is the fact that Wraight’s basis for thinking that Alleyn was a playwright rests on Alleyn’s identification as the “upstart Crow,” a clear case of circular reasoning. If these assumptions are set aside, Alleyn’s identification as the “upstart Crow” has no merit, mainly because there is no evidence Alleyn ever tried to write plays. This is particularly problematic in light of the fact that many of Alleyn’s personal papers survive. If he had written plays, surely some evidence of this fact would be included in his papers. Moreover, while Alleyn may have acted in 3 Henry VI/True Tragedy,27 there is no definite proof that he did. Thus, Alleyn fails to meet two of the three “upstart Crow” criteria. In contrast to Kempe, Marlowe, Wilson, and Alleyn, Shakespeare does fit all three criteria. He was an actor, as numerous documents attest to. He obviously was a playwright, and the first of his plays was published (not written) in 1594 (Titus Andronicus). And he is connected with 3 Henry VI, having, of course, written it.28 As we shall see momentarily, he was probably an emerging playwright in 1592, so the epithet “upstart” is appropriate. “Shake-scene,” Greene’s clincher, is thus a pun on Shakespeare’s name, similar, as Carroll observes, to the “shake a stage” pun used in Ben Jonson’s encomium to Shakespeare (“Upstart Crow” 151). As for Johannes fac totum (“would-be universal genius,” “one who meddles with everything,” or “Jack of all trades”—Groatsworth 138–39), it could refer to the “upstart Crow’s” 26
This alleged Alleyn corpus includes the play Faire Em (190–99, 219–28), A Knack to Know an Honest Man (220–29), and certain scenes from 1 Henry VI (266–76). 27 One should note, however, that York, the character who speaks the “Tiger’s heart” line and the character that Hoster and Wraight assert Alleyn played, dies before the end of Act I in 3 Henry VI; one assumes audiences of the day paying to see Alleyn would be severely disappointed with the lead actor dying so early in the play (unless Alleyn doubled as another role later in the play). 28 As Shakespeare is the only candidate who fits all the criteria of this argument, and since he can be linked to 3 Henry VI but not necessarily to True Tragedy, it would seem “Greene” is referring to 3 Henry VI here. Then again, Shakespeare probably also had some sort of involvement with True Tragedy, since it is so closely connected to 3 Henry VI. See Chapter 7 for a more detailed discussion of why Shakespeare cannot necessarily be linked to True Tragedy.
Shakespeare’s Companies
32
general attitude; it might signal that he both acted and wrote; or it may mean he filled a number of functions around the theatre. Any of these could plausibly apply to Shakespeare: he may have thought highly of himself (he would later acquire a coat of arms), he clearly was both an actor and a playwright, and since nothing is known of his daily London activities, it is possible he did other things besides act and write. Objections to Shakespeare as the “upstart Crow” will doubtlessly continue, but it is also doubtless that the case for Shakespeare being “Greene’s” target is far stronger than that of any other “upstart Crow” candidate. In sum, the case for Shakespeare is more plausible than any other possibility; it is, in fact, probable. In this matter, as in all of the other issues and problems that this study will take up, basic criteria of historical evidence and argument, as laid out by scholars such as Louis Gottschalk, will guide this investigation. In order to ascertain verifiable facts, the documents must be tested for authenticity; they must also be assessed for the credibility of all information and statements; in turn, all possible facts must be challenged according to established principles and guidelines for examining and analyzing records, sources, and documents (27–8, 52). Furthermore, each piece of evidence will be scrutinized to ensure that any arguments based on it safely rest on “credible particulars” (52) extrapolated from that piece of evidence. These particulars must be able to be verified by other evidence. As Marc Bloch says, historians “have no right to make any assertion which cannot be verified” (73), and usable evidence must “show a certain correspondence to the allied evidences (100). Moreover, because documents “will speak only when they are properly questioned” (53), this study will endeavor to find, and then ask, the proper questions of given documents or ostensible evidence. Greene’s Groatsworth of Wit: The Charges Against Shakespeare The final controversy surrounding Groatsworth has to do with the nature of the attack on the “upstart Crow,” who can now safely be identified as Shakespeare. What precisely is “Greene” driving at by calling Shakespeare “an upstart Crow, beautified with our feathers?“ Scholarly opinion has been split on this point between plagiarism and pride. In 1787, soon after Groatsworth had been brought to scholarly attention as an allusion of Shakespeare,29 Edmond Malone asserted that “Greene” was accusing Shakespeare of plagiarism: [Greene] therefore, in direct terms, charges [Shakespeare] with having acted like the crow in the fable, beautified himself with their feathers; in other words, with having acquired fame furtivis coloribus, by new-modelling a work originally produced by them, and wishing to depreciate our author, he very naturally quotes a line from one of the pieces which Shakespeare had thus re-written. (Carroll, Groatsworth 132)
29
The allusion was discovered by Thomas Tyrwhitt and published in the 1778 SteevensJohnson edition of Shakespeare (Carroll 132).
Greene’s Groatsworth of Wit and Shakespeare’s First Plays
33
Malone’s evidence for this assertion are the plays The First Part of the Contention and The True Tragedy of Richard Duke of York, which are shorter treatments of the same events in Shakespeare’s 2 and 3 Henry VI. Groatsworth, in Malone’s opinion, confirms that Shakespeare revised the shorter Contention and True Tragedy, apparently written by Greene or/and his circle, into 2 and 3 Henry VI. Malone further observed that the word “bombast” could mean “to amplify and swell out,” which would additionally fit the theory that Shakespeare was expanding the older, shorter plays into longer versions. “Greene’s” anger comes from the fact that the fame of Shakespeare and his revised versions has rivaled, if not surpassed, that of the “originals.” (Carroll, Groatsworth 132). Based on this reading, numerous scholars have constructed a narrative whereby Shakespeare’s early dramatic work was that of a “play-patcher” who fixed up and rewrote the plays the work of other playwrights. This theory, that Groatsworth’s attack on Shakespeare was an accusation of plagiarism, remained the scholarly consensus for more than a century, although there were a handful of dissenters.30 Scholarly opinion took another direction in the 1920s and 1930s when Peter Alexander demonstrated, to most everyone’s satisfaction at the time, that Contention and The True Tragedy were in fact derived from 2 and 3 Henry VI (Shakespeare’s Henry VI and Richard III). As such, “Greene’s” complaint must have been was about something other than plagiarism. Accordingly, Alexander suggests that “Greene” is accusing Shakespeare, a mere player, of being audacious enough to think himself as able a playwright as the University Wits (39–50). In other words, as Richard Dutton suggests, “Greene” is accusing Shakespeare not of plagiarism, but of “aping his betters and sharing in the general ingratitude of the players towards the writer” (Literary Life 19). Since Alexander, most scholars have tended to agree with the charge of pride rather than plagiarism (Carroll 131–2). In 1955, however, J. Dover Wilson argued that a charge of plagiarism against Shakespeare could still be supported on two grounds. First of all, Wilson considers Chettle’s apology in Kind-Hart’s Dream to one of the two parties that had taken offense at the Groatsworth letter. Like many others, Wilson assumes that Chettle is apologizing to Shakespeare. Wilson notes that Chettle’s apology is profuse, speaks to the offended individual’s “honesty” and “uprightness of dealing,” and refers to “diverse of worship” having come to the offended party’s aid. If “Greene” simply attacked Shakespeare for having been an actor-turned-playwright, why, Wilson asks, would “divers of worship” have felt the need to come to Shakespeare’s aid? Wilson answers that the charge was, in fact, the much harsher accusation of plagiarism (“Malone” 58–62). Wilson tries to support this assertion by noting classical allusions linking crows and plagiarism. After Alexander, scholars had assumed the “upstart Crow” referred to an Aesopian fable wherein a crow is guilty of undeserved pride (Carroll, Groatsworth 135). Wilson, though, argues that “Greene” had Horace’s crow in mind (third Epistle I.iii.9–20), which does carry connotations of plagiarism 30
Dissenters included Charles Knight in 1843, Thomas Kenny in 1864, Richard Simpson in 1874, and C.F. Tucker Brooke in 1912 (Carroll, Groatsworth 133).
Shakespeare’s Companies
34
(“Malone” 64–5). Further, Wilson notes that lines 5–6 (C1) in the ninth sonnet of Greene’s Funerals (published 1594), seem to connect feathers and plagiarism: “Nay more the men, that so Eclipst his fame:/Purloynde his Plumes, can they deny the same?” (63). Since Wilson’s article, most arguments concerning “Greene’s” accusations have either challenged Wilson’s understanding of the charge contained in the Greene’s Funerals passage (Austin, “Supposed” 377) or noted other “crow” allusions that support either the Aesopian or Horacian understanding of the “upstart Crow” passage.31 It may not be possible to figure out precisely which crow “Greene” had in mind, however, because, as Wilson himself observes, “crow” allusions of the era suggest that the crows of Aesop and Horace were related in the minds of many writers and readers of Shakespeare’s day (“Malone” 65).32 While the exact nature of “Greene’s” accusations may be indecipherable given present evidence, it should be noted that Wilson’s “pro-plagiarism” argument depends largely on the assumption Chettle was in fact apologizing to Shakespeare in KindHart’s Dream. Lukas Erne has recently challenged this assumption by observing that Chettle explicitly states that it was two of the writers “Greene” addressed in the “upstart Crow” passage were the offended parties. But Shakespeare was not one of the writers; he was the individual “Greene” warned the writers about. Moreover, Chettle linked the offended parties with “schollers.” Shakespeare, however, was never referred to as a scholar in his own day, and given Elizabethan preoccupations with social distinctions, it is thus difficult to believe Chettle refers to Shakespeare in his apology (432–4). If Chettle was not apologizing to Shakespeare, a number of claims about Shakespeare’s early life and personality are called into question. Chettle’s supposed apology to Shakespeare has been used as evidence for Shakespeare’s level of education, refinement, gentlemanliness (Kay 167), honesty and uprightness of dealing (Schoenbaum, Compact 156–7), writing talent (Adams 142), artistry, charm, and polite nature (J. Dover Wilson, Essential 48), gracefulness in his art and life (Wood 146), acting ability (Fraser 168), good breeding (Honigmann, Impact 21), urbanity and social polish (Wells, All Time 50), civility and elegance (Bate, Genius 18), tendency to dress well, integrity and courtesy (I. Wilson 127), level of respect and admiration among his peers as well as “divers of worship” (Wells, All Time 50), and, of course, gentleness (Adams 142). Chettle’s apology would seem to be one more piece of evidence for Shakespeare’s biography which has been handled according to wishful sentiment. But in allowing sentiment to guide historical inquiry, the actual available evidence for Shakespeare’s biography is either displaced or exaggerated (Dutton, Literary Life 1–3). At any rate, Erne’s observations more immediately undermine Wilson’s assertion that Chettle’s apology signals “Greene’s” charges involved something more than pride: if Shakespeare was not addressed in Chettle’s 31
See, for instance, H.P. Smith, Arthur Freeman (“Notes”), Peter Berek, David Chandler. Schoenbaum makes the same observation in William Shakespeare: A Documentary Life (116–17). David Chandler has suggested that “Greene” may have also had Pliny’s crow in mind; Pliny’s crow seems to refer specifically to “the proud assumption of a superior station, or social milieu, to justify and mask a humble background” (294). If Chandler is correct, this would seem to strengthen Alexander’s case and weaken Wilson’s. 32
Greene’s Groatsworth of Wit and Shakespeare’s First Plays
35
apology, Chettle sheds no light on the significance of “Greene’s” attacks. Wilson’s argument—and indeed the entire controversy over the charges against the “upstart Crow”—is thus reduced to quibbling interpretations of which “crow” (if indeed it is just one crow) “Greene” is invoking. Some have wondered if Shakespeare’s works respond to “Greene’s” accusations. If so, Shakespeare’s position as the “upstart Crow” would be strengthened and perhaps something about the nature of the charges, as well as Shakespeare’s early London career, would be revealed. Muriel Bradbrook claims Venus and Adonis was an indirect response to “Greene,” in that it allowed Shakespeare to prove he was just as talented as the university-educated playwrights (“Beasts and Gods” 68–71). Robert Fliessner suggests Polonius’s comment in Hamlet II, ii, 111–12 that “‘beautified’ is a vile phrase” refers to Groatsworth, since “beautified” is of course not a phrase and Shakespeare has no reason, metrical or otherwise, for choosing “phrase” over “word;” perhaps Shakespeare is hinting at a larger context for the use of the word “beautified,” namely “Greene’s” attack on the “upstart Crow” (145). Maureen Godman suggests that Comedy of Errors contains a subtle response to “Greene’s” attack in the repeated use of the word “crow” in the comic banter between Antipholus and Dromio of Ephesus in III, ii (58–60). And Greenblatt asserts that the character of Falstaff is an oblique parody of Robert Greene (215–25). Of course, all of these conjectures are possibilities put forward without any supporting evidence. They are literary interpretations, not historical inquiry and analysis. Gary Taylor’s suggestion that Shakespeare’s tendency to avoid collaboration may have something to do with “Greene’s” attack at least rests on quantifiable facts: as near as Shakespeare’s plays can be dated, it seems that those written before September of 1592 exhibit a degree of collaboration, while those after 1592 don’t (“Shakespeare and Others” 186). Correlation, however, has never proved causation. All of these speculations also overlook the possibility that Shakespeare’s response was that most devastating response to satire: silence. Dating Shakespeare’s Early Plays Between Pierce Pennilesse and Groatsworth, it is possible to set down a few important details of Shakespeare’s career. First, Groatsworth proves that Shakespeare, after having been an actor for a time, was a playwright of at least some note by September of 1592. Second, Groatsworth proves that either 3 Henry VI or The True Tragedy of Richard Duke of York had been written by 1592, and that Shakespeare was connected, presumably as author, to whichever play Greene had in mind. Third, Pierce Pennilesse seemingly demonstrates that 1 Henry VI had also been written by August of 1592. 3 Henry VI is clearly a sequel to 2 Henry VI, just as The First Part of the Contention is a sequel to The True Tragedy, so 2 Henry VI or Contention (or both) must also have existed by September of 1592.33 So by the time of the 1592 attack, Shakespeare 33
See note 22 above for more on the relationship between 2, 3 Henry VI and Contention and True Tragedy.
36
Shakespeare’s Companies
had written at least three plays (although the order they were written in is far from certain).34 Furthermore, since the playhouses were closed in late June of 1592 and not reopened until December of that year, all three of these plays must have been written (and presumably performed) before mid-1592. Philip Henslowe’s Diary records several successful performances of a play called “harey the vj” from March 1592 until January 1593 (Foakes 16–20); this may have been one of Shakespeare’s Henry VI plays, though there is no way to be certain.35 It is unlikely (although possible) that Shakespeare wrote all three of the Henry VI plays in a matter of only a few months, so we can reasonably assert that he started writing plays no later than 1591, perhaps earlier. Because the plays were written especially for the London stage,36 it would presumably have been necessary for Shakespeare to become familiar with that stage before commencing his writing career, so we can reasonably push his arrival in London back to 1590 or even 1589. What else happened between Shakespeare’s arrival in London, whatever the date, and “Greene’s” attack is a matter of pure speculation. Predictably, however, biographers have dealt with the lack of evidence by turning to anecdotes. One anecdotal tradition, apparently originated by William Davenant, embellished by Samuel Johnson, and accepted by Sidney Lee, holds that Shakespeare, upon arriving in London, found his first theatrical employment by taking care of audience members’ horses during the performances (Lee 45–6; Schoenbaum, Lives 75–6). Another anecdotal tradition, first recorded by Nicholas Rowe and again repeated by Lee and others, asserts that Shakespeare’s first London job was “a very mean rank” in an acting company (Lee 46); Malone records the more detailed tradition, accepted by Lee and Sams, among others, that this “mean rank” was that of stage prompter (Lee 46; Sams 56–7; Schoenbaum, Lives 75). Some biographers, such as Michael Wood, have gone so far as to assert that Shakespeare began his backstage work for James Burbage at the Theatre (108–9). A third anecdotal tradition, already commented on, is that Shakespeare found work in London as a “play patcher” who revised the work of other playwrights. This tradition has been accepted by, among other biographers, Edmond Malone (Schoenbaum, Lives 121), Sidney Lee (99), J.Q. Adams (134–7), and more recently Peter Levi (39). Some traces of Shakespeare’s activities between Groatsworth and his first definite connection with the Lord Chamberlain’s Men at the end of 1594 also survive. 34 There is evidence that 1 Henry VI is a prequel to 2, 3 Henry VI, but not all scholars find that evidence convincing. For more on the issue of the order of composition of the Henry VI plays, see the studies listed in note 22. 35 For a more detailed discussion of “harey the vj,” see Chapter 6. 36 This, at least, is the usual assumption. Consider, for instance, Gurr’s comments in The Shakespearean Stage: “Except for the occasional university student like Jasper Mayne, or the amateur satirist of Hog Hath Lost His Pearl, writing for a group of apprentices, no poet wrote with anything but the London companies in mind” (6), or again, “the only place where a play could be profitably marketed was with the companies working in London” (6–7). There has not, to my knowledge, been any concerted challenge to this assumption.
Greene’s Groatsworth of Wit and Shakespeare’s First Plays
37
He wrote Venus and Adonis during 1592 or 1593 (it was entered in the Stationers’ Register on 18 April 1593—Arber ii.630). These were years during which London theatres were often closed due to plague. Soon after Venus and Adonis, Shakespeare wrote The Rape of Lucrece (entered in the Stationers’ Register on 9 May 1594— Arber ii.648). He also had written Titus Andronicus by 6 February 1594 (Arber ii.644). Henslowe records performances of a play by this name, presumably Shakespeare’s, in early 1594 by Sussex’s Men (Foakes 21); the title-page of the published version lists Sussex’s as the third company to perform the play (Derby’s and Pembroke’s being the other two—Chambers, Stage iv.383), so unless the titlepage is referring to a joint performance by all three companies, as David George suggests in “Shakespeare and Pembroke’s Men,” Titus Andronicus would seem to have had a stage life before Sussex’s 1594 performance. A vague reference in Ben Jonson’s Bartholomew Fair (1614) states that the judgment of anyone who would number “Andronicus”—presumably Shakespeare’s Titus Andronicus—would have “stood still, these five and twentie, or thirtie yeeres” (8). If correct, this statement could date the play to 1589 or earlier. There is no agreement on the accuracy or validity of this statement,37 but it at least opens the possibility that Shakespeare had arrived in London as early as 1587 or 1588. A play called The Taming of A Shrew was also published in 1594 (entered in Stationers’ Register 2 May—Arber ii.648), but the relationship of this text to Shakespeare’s The Taming of the Shrew is unclear.38 It is therefore unsafe to regard the existence of A Shrew as absolute proof of the existence of The Shrew. While there is definite proof that Shakespeare had written all three Henry VI plays as well as Titus Andronicus and his two narrative poems by the time he joined the Chamberlain’s Men in 1594, it is much less clear when these plays were written. Opinions on this topic vary considerably. 1 Henry VI has been variously dated to 1588 (Honigmann), 1589–91 (Hattaway), 1591 (Sokol), 1591–92 (Chambers), and 1592 (Michael Taylor, Wells and Taylor, Burns); 2 Henry VI to 1589 (Honigmann), 1590 (Knowles), 1589–91 (Hattaway), 1590–91 (Chambers), 1591 (Wells and Taylor), and 1591–92 (Warren); 3 Henry VI to 1590 (Honigmann), 1590–91 (Chambers), 1591 (Wells and Taylor), 1590–92 (Martin), 1592 (Hattaway), and by 1592 (Cox and Rasmussen); and Titus Andronicus to 1586 (Honigmann), 1588 with a 1592 revision (Hughes), 1589 (Metz), 1592 (Wells and Taylor, Waith), and 1593–94 (Chambers, Bate). Besides these four plays that must have been written before Shakespeare joined the Chamberlain’s Men in 1594, various scholars have assigned several other plays, including Richard III, Comedy of Errors, Taming of the Shrew, Two Gentlemen of 37
See, for instance, Sidney Thomas’s “On the Dating of Shakespeare’s Early Plays,” his assessment of Honigmann’s “early start” chronology (especially 192). 38 Nearly any edition of Taming of the Shrew will include a discussion of the A Shrew/ The Shrew relationship. For some recent discussions of this issue, see Ann Thompson, ed., The Taming of the Shrew; H.J. Oliver, ed., The Taming of the Shrew; Elizabeth Shafer, ed., The Taming of The Shrew; and Laurie E. Maguire, Shakespearean Suspect Texts: The ‘bad‘ quartos and their contexts, among others.
Shakespeare’s Companies
38
Verona, King John, Romeo and Juliet, and Love’s Labour’s Lost to the period before Shakespeare became aligned with the Chamberlain’s Men. Of these, Two Gentlemen of Verona, Richard III, and Taming of the Shrew may have been written before 1594, according to most recent estimates.39 Many scholars, though not all, assert that, of the other four plays, Comedy of Errors belongs to Shakespeare’s pre-Chamberlain’s days; some scholars believe King John and Romeo and Juliet similarly were preChamberlain’s plays, although most favor a later date; and Honigmann is virtually alone in thinking Love’s Labour’s Lost was written before 1594–95.40 The reasons for these various datings are complex; it is sufficient to observe that even the most cautious scholars think that Shakespeare was writing plays by 1590. Although the scholars that believe unequivocally that Shakespeare was writing by the late 1580s are a decided minority, there are enough of them (Hongimann, Schlueter, Morris, Shafer, and Ros King, among others) that the possibility must at least be considered. Even among this minority, few insist that Shakespeare began writing plays before 1588 (Honigmann being the most vocal exception). Accordingly, Shakespeare’s arrival in London, assuming it corresponds roughly to the commencement of his playwriting career, cannot safely be dated to much before 1587 or 1588, although an earlier arrival certainly remains a possibility, though perhaps not a strong one. Based upon the temporal benchmarks of Shakespeare’s Stratford years, the allusions in Pierce Pennilesse and Groatsworth, and surviving playtexts, we can derive the following framework for his “lost years.” He may have left Stratford as early as the late 1570s, although he did need to pay his hometown occasional visits to start his family in the early 1580s. Sometime in the later 1580s, perhaps 1587 or 1588, he probably arrived in London. He may have started writing plays immediately, and certainly was doing so by 1590–1591. By 1592, he had emerged as a sufficiently prominent dramatist to draw the wrath of “Greene,” and had written all three of the Henry VI plays. Between 1592 and 1594, he wrote two long poems, which won him additional literary fame, and he must have written Titus Andronicus by 1594, when it was published. Although definite evidence is not forthcoming, most scholars agree that Shakespeare had also written Two Gentlemen of Verona, Richard III, and Taming of the Shrew by 1594; he may also have written Comedy of Errors, King John, 39
Two Gentlemen of Verona: 1587 (Honigmann), late 1580s (Schlueter), 1590–91 (Wells and Taylor), 1594–95 (Chambers); Taming of the Shrew: 1588 (Honigmann), 1589 (Morris), 1590–91 (Wells and Taylor), 1591–92 (Thompson), no later than 1592 (Oliver, Shafer), 1593– 94 (Chambers); Richard III: 1590 (Honigmann), 1591–92 (Jowett), 1592–93 (Chambers, Wells and Taylor, Lull). 40 Comedy of Errors: 1589 (Honigmann), 1590 revision of a late 1580s text (Ros King), 1592–93 (Chambers), 1594 (Wells and Taylor), late 1594 (Whitworth); King John: before 1591 (Beaurline), 1591 (Honigmann), 1595–96 (Braunmuller), 1596 (Wells and Taylor), 1596–97 (Chambers); Romeo and Juliet: 1591 (Honigmann), 1593–95 (Levenson), 1594– 95 (Chambers), 1595 (Wells and Taylor), 1596, although before 1594 is plausible as well (Evans); Love’s Labour’s Lost: 1592 (Honigmann), 1594–95 (Chambers, Wells and Taylor, Pendergast), 1594–96 (Hibbard).
Greene’s Groatsworth of Wit and Shakespeare’s First Plays
39
Romeo and Juliet, and Love’s Labour’s Lost before joining the Chamberlain’s Men, although once again there is neither definite evidence nor scholarly consensus for when they were written. Some of the Sonnets may also have been written before 1594.41 The Lord Chamberlain’s Men formed by 3 June 1594; Shakespeare may already have been in the company at that time, although he is not definitely connected with it until he appears as a court payee for Chamberlain’s performances on 26 and 28 December 1594 (Chambers, Stage iv.164). And thus this study’s chronological framework has been established. What now remains to be seen is how various scholars have filled the gaps in Shakespeare’s theatrical life between the late 1570s and 1594. Before this is possible, however, it is necessary to investigate in more detail the theatrical circumstances and conditions of this era, both inside and outside London. Shakespeare’s biography cannot be fully discussed without an examination of these contexts, and many arguments about Shakespeare’s pre-1594 whereabouts are closely intertwined with—or unsupported by—what is known of Elizabethan theatrical conditions. But, as with Shakespeare’s biographical details, taking stock of these circumstances involves sorting through speculations, conjectures, and failures on the part of many scholars to distinguish between possibility, plausibility, probability, and fact.
41 Schoenbaum, Compact 180, briefly discusses dating the sonnets and the attendant problems. Stephen Booth notes that versions of two sonnets appeared in 1599 as part of the Passionate Pilgrim. Besides this, the only evidence for the date of the sonnets is the 1609 publication of all of them in quarto form. In 1598 Francis Meres mentioned Shakespeare’s “sugred Sonnets among his private friends;” Booth says that this “testifies to nothing except that Meres knew of some Shakespeare sonnets by 1598; whether he referred to all or any of the sonnets in Q is a matter of pure guesswork. The same is true of all efforts to date some or all of the sonnets by internal details, by their style, by their subject matter, or by biographical speculation” (545). As an example, Booth invokes Martin Seymour-Smith’s commentary on Sonnet 107: “There is no doubt that this sonnet contains a specific [biographical] reference; the difficulty lies in discovering it ... There is a theory from almost every year, from 1588 to 1609” offered by the likes of Hotson, Butler, Chambers, and Harrison (342–3).
This page intentionally left blank
PART 2 Theatrical Contexts
This page intentionally left blank
Chapter 3
Provincial Playing, c. 1577–1588
To this point, we have seen that Shakespeare could have left Stratford by the late 1570s at the earliest, and that he quite plausibly arrived in London between 1588 and 1590. Many biographers propose Shakespeare joined a playing company in the provinces at some point during the intervening years. It is therefore necessary to consider the provincial playing conditions he would have encountered and to set out what is known about provincial activity between about 1577 and 1588. Usually, these years are associated with the rise of London commercial theatre, The Theatre (and perhaps Newington Butts) having opened in 1576, The Curtain in 1577, and The Rose in 1587. As such, this period has often been characterized as the beginning of the end of provincial playing, a time when companies wanted to center their activities in London and toured only when forced to by plague or other playing inhibitions (Bentley, Profession 178).1 According to this view, touring, while still a necessity even for London companies, was an uncomfortable, dirty, grueling, and not especially rewarding activity undertaken only to offset London misfortunes (Chambers, Stage ii.6; Bentley, Profession 178–9). Proponents of this view, like G.E. Bentley, point to declining touring records in the 1590s and complaints from playing companies and dramatists as evidence of the undesirability of touring (Profession 180–84). In the words of a petition made by Lord Strange’s Men in or about 1593, traveling was “intolerable ... and the continuance thereof will be a mean to bring us to division and separation whereby we shall ... be undone” (183). Although negative views of touring long held sway—Bentley repeated this view in his 1984 The Profession of Player in Shakespeare’s Time—such perceptions of provincial playing have been increasingly challenged since the mid-1970s. It is still common to run across references to touring as undesirable or unprofitable, but there is a growing scholarly consensus that playing companies—London and otherwise— regarded touring as the norm, not a last resort, throughout the sixteenth and into the seventeenth century, well after the emergence of London commercial playing. Siobahn Keenan notes that even when companies “had access to permanent, purposebuilt theatres and larger audiences” London boasted, they nevertheless “continued to travel the country on a regular basis” (2). Indeed, it would seem, as Andrew Gurr states, that “Travelling dictated all the early playing practices” (Companies 36). According to this revised view of traveling, the period between 1577 and 1588 1
Following the lead of E.K. Chambers, many scholars have focused exclusively on companies that played in London, ignoring those whose ambitions may have lain elsewhere (see Stage vol. ii).
Shakespeare’s Companies
44
was at or near the apex of the era of traveling playing companies in England. True, London was emerging as a theatrical center, but it was not until a few years later, in the early 1590s, that playing companies began to see London as a “home base.” Instead, London was one touring stop among many, albeit the most important, and potentially most lucrative (McMillin and MacLean 5–7). Even when companies began to think of London as their base, traveling was “the guiding principle” among playing companies until the early 1600s; a company playing in London was not a “London company,” but rather a traveling company with the good fortune to play in London for a time (Gurr, Companies 36, 44). Traveling may have had its difficulties, but it was a practice all companies viewed as an integral part of their activities and which, Barbara Palmer argues, “clearly contributed to professional practices and to the maintenance of competitive professional standards” (291). This change in perception of traveling has been a direct result of the efforts of the Records of Early English Drama (REED) project, based at the University of Toronto. This project has dispatched scholars to each town and county in England and Wales with the goal of combing all surviving records for items pertaining to playing up until 1642. As of 2007, the project has published 19 volumes, with more to come. Thanks to REED, scholars have been able to construct revised, much fuller accounts of provincial playing. An increasing number of articles are now available regarding traveling practices,2 and several book-length, or chapter-length, studies of provincial playing are now available which give a fuller and fairer treatment of touring than earlier studies.3 The evidence for provincial playing comes from diverse and disparate sources. These sources are often incomplete, but thanks to REED there is sufficient evidence to allow for a cautious filling of many of these gaps. The largest body of evidence for provincial playing consists of various sorts of payments made to visiting playing companies which are found in town, church, and noble household accounts. Usually little is recorded besides a given company’s name, the year of its visit, and the payment awarded it. Sometimes the specific date of the visit might be noted, and on occasion other information, such as the number of players in a given company, might be provided; just as often the information might be less detailed, failing to name even the company’s patron. On the whole, household accounts tend to be slightly more detailed than town accounts, since many households kept weekly
2
For example, MacLean, “The Players on Tour: New Evidence from Records of Early English Drama” (1988); Ingram, “The Costs of Touring” (1993); Somerset, “‘How Chances it They Travel?’: Provincial Touring, Playing Places and the King’s Men” (1994); Greenfield, “Touring” (1997). 3 Bradley, From Text to Performance in the Elizabethan Theatre (1992); Gurr, The Shakespearean Playing Companies (1996); McMillin and MacLean, The Queen’s Men and Their Plays, 1583–1603 (1998); Keenan, Travelling Players in Shakespeare’s England (2002).
Provincial Playing, c. 1577–1588
45
records,4 but even here the information is often incomplete. If a particular visit of a touring company was exceptional or controversial in some way, other records of the visit might survive. For instance, an individual was arrested in Canterbury in 1596–97 for attacking one of the Queen’s Men (REED, Kent 233). Contemporary allusions to, or descriptions of, provincial playing also survive, such as actors’ papers (including wills, like that of Simon Jewell, or the correspondence of Edward Alleyn). Furthermore, a number of plays make reference to provincial playing (the players in Hamlet being perhaps the most famous example). These references are not generally sympathetic or complimentary to traveling players, and are often clearly exaggerations or caricatures, such as in Thomas Dekker’s Lanthorne and Candlelight, in which he refers to traveling troupes as “players that (without socks) trotte from towne to towne upon the hard hoofe” (Non-Dramatic Works iii.255). Then again, as with any caricature, there may be a kernel of truth in such accounts (Keenan 10). Finally, a series of laws passed on the legal status of traveling players and their patronage also sheds some light onto the life of players on the road. Each playing company operating during this period had a patron. In earlier years, the laws regarding patronage were quite loose, and a company could be patronized by just about anyone, or could simply list a town as their patron, as in the case of the New Romney players.5 By 1577, however, the laws governing patronage were stricter. Specifically, the 1572 Act for the Punishment of Vagabonds and for the Relief of the Poor and Impotent stipulated that a playing company’s patron had to be of baronial rank or higher, or else be licensed by two local justices;6 otherwise, the company would be regarded as a group of vagabonds, subject to imprisonment (Wickham, Berry and Ingram 62–3). In 1572, the players of the Earl of Leicester, no doubt in response to this Act, appealed to their patron for some protection, and in 1574 Leicester secured a royal patent allowing his players to perform throughout the country. This practice was followed by other patrons, it seems, so that after 1574, each company carried a patent or license with them in order to prove they had a legitimate patron (205–6; Gurr, Companies 37). Even with a patent, a company was not guaranteed the ability to perform since, in 1559, a proclamation gave local authorities the right to authorize or deny performances of plays (Wickham, Berry and Ingram 51–2), and local authorities took advantage of this proclamation on occasion. 4
See, for instance, the Stanley household accounts and Derby Household Books (REED, Lancashire 179–84); the Household accounts of Sir Richard Shuttleworth (REED, Lancashire 166–79); the Cumberland and Clifford Household accounts (Stone 17–28); Robert J. Alexander, “Some dramatic records from Percy household accounts on microfilm;” Suzanne Westfall’s Patrons and Performance in Early Tudor Household Revels; and Barbara Palmer’s “Early Modern Mobility: Players, Payments, and Patrons.” 5 The New Romney players played at Lydd 8 times and twice at Hythe in the 15th century, as well as at Dover in 1547–48 and 1561–62 (REED, Kent 447, 461, 621, 623, 646–8, 652, 656, 659, 664, 668). 6 The ability of justices to license a company was removed in 1598 (Gurr, Companies 37; Keenan 5).
Shakespeare’s Companies
46
At Cambridge University in 1580, for example, Oxford’s Men were prevented from playing (REED, Cambridge i.290–91; Wickham, Berry and Ingram 250–51). At Norwich in 1584–85 Leicester’s, Oxford’s, and Essex’s were turned away (but Essex’s not without incident—REED, Norwich 80–81). And at King’s Lynn in 1591 Essex’s was paid to leave (“Records of Plays and Players in Norfolk and Suffolk” 65).7 It is difficult to say to what extent these laws were consistently enforced. There are records of companies with a patron below baronial rank playing after 1572, such as “Sir Thomas Cycylles” players at Norwich in 1586–87 and 1587–88 (REED, Norwich 86, 89) and Cavendish’s Men at Coventry in 1585–86 (REED, Coventry 313). Towns may not have always checked to see if a given company was carrying a patent, and in any case a company could, and apparently occasionally did, forge a patent when a legitimate one was not available, as may have been the case for one of the two Chandos’s companies that visited Norwich in September of 1591 (REED, Norwich 98; Gurr, Companies 37). Nevertheless, a traveling playing company could reasonably expect to have to operate under these legal strictures and regulations. Without question, the daily life of a traveling company was not always easy. The sheer number of traveling companies active between 1577 and 1588 guaranteed stiff touring competition. Traveling could also prove dangerous. Players are known to have attacked audience members and each other, and audience members are known to have attacked players or vandalized their vehicle. In 1583 John Singer and John Bentley, Queen’s players, attacked and killed a Norwich man who had been throwing rocks at them (REED, Norwich 66–76). William Knell, one of the Queen’s players, was killed by fellow actor John Towne at Thame in 1587 (McMillin and MacLean 52). A local thief robbed one of Chandos’s Men in “Buck Towne” in 1608–1609 (Keenan 10). And in Faversham in 1597–98 “certen persons” were fined for the “misusage of a wagon or coache of the Lo. Bartlettes players” (REED, Kent 563). Nor was traveling without economic difficulties. Companies could, and did, go bankrupt while on tour. Pembroke’s Men’s ill-fated 1593 tour is probably the most famous example of a company going broke in the provinces (Foakes 280). Despite these potential difficulties, many players chose to live as traveling players, and even the later London-based companies continued to tour on a regular basis (Greenfield, “Touring” 252; Gurr, Companies 40; Keenan 10). This suggests that life on the road had some advantages and benefits. The recorded payments traveling companies received were not especially substantial (Greenfield, “Touring” 253–4; Ingram, “Costs” 57–61; Gurr, Companies 40–41, 47), but the recorded payments do not of course necessarily represent all the money a company could have made during a visit to a given town. Records of rewards at country houses could be quite generous (e.g., the Berkeley household rewards reach £3—Greenfield, “Entertainments” 14). In addition to a monetary reward, the players could expect free food, lodging, and other accommodations during their stay at the household, as at the Clifford family houses (Wasson, “Touring Companies” 53–4; Palmer 272). On the whole, provincial 7
This right of refusal was effectively removed in 1616, when the Master of the Revels began directly licensing playing companies (Gurr, Companies 38).
Provincial Playing, c. 1577–1588
47
circuits must have been consistently profitable, given repeat visits by particular companies to particular locations; after all, “neither players nor hosts would continue were the experiences not rewarding to both” (Palmer 272). It is also worth noting that touring may very well have provided companies with a respite from London playing: it allowed companies to use the same plays, costumes, and props over and over, so touring presumably did not involve many of the extra costs involved with preparing new plays. It could also be that the players “enjoyed the challenge of adapting their performances for different stages and audiences as well” (Keenan 11). The size of a given touring company appears to have varied considerably. Recent scholarship is increasingly hesitant to accept the traditional theory that touring companies were much smaller than London companies, and that London companies, when on tour, reduced their numbers. This is because the few records in which the size of a touring company is noted vary greatly. Sussex’s Men had six players on a 1569–70 visit to Ludlow (REED, Shropshire 84); in 1606 Thomas Dekker wrote of a fictional touring company of nine players (Non-Dramatic Works ii.146); Derby’s Men was fourteen strong at Chatsworth in 1611 (Bentley, Profession 185), and an unnamed company of 28 visited Norwich in 1635 (REED, Norwich 218).8 This evidence suggests that the average company size increased between 1570 and 1635, and according to John M. Wasson this is precisely the case (4). Still, the average company size may not have increased at a constant rate. For instance, Andrew Gurr notes that in 1576, Clinton’s Men was six strong. In 1577, three companies that visited Southampton—Leicester’s Men, Bath’s Men, and Worcester’s Men—contained twelve, eleven, and ten players respectively. When Worcester’s visited Norwich and Leicester in 1583, it still had ten players, but in 1585—well before Dekker wrote of his fictional company of nine—Leicester’s Men had grown to fifteen players (Companies 43). Moreover, although traveling company size steadily grew between the 1560s and early 1590s before slightly declining again, even during the late 1580s and early 1590s small companies of only a few players existed alongside large companies of twelve or more (47). Gurr theorizes that company size was directly related to company repertory, and vice versa: plays written before the mid- to late 1580s called for small casts, whereas the plays after the formation of the Queen’s Men—especially history plays—called for much larger casts. The companies that had these large-cast plays were accordingly large, while the companies that continued to use the older plays saw no need to increase their numbers (47). This explanation seems plausible, but the precise relations, including cause and effect, between cast size and company size has yet to be determined. At any rate, during the period between 1577 and 1588, company size could have ranged anywhere from four to twelve or more. Whatever the company size, the players would have gotten around by foot, or if the company was especially financially endowed, by horseback (as seems to have 8
It is not clear that all 28 persons in this company were actors; this number could include servants as well as players (Bentley, Jacobean ii.679–80).
Shakespeare’s Companies
48
been the case for the Queen’s Men—McMillin and MacLean 39, 61). Many—but not necessarily all—companies presumably used a wagon of some sort to protect properties, costumes, playbooks, and any other items the players may have needed to keep safe and dry, and a number of references to a playing company’s wagon or wagons indeed survive (REED, Kent 563; REED, Bristol 166–7; Honigmann and Brock 59). How long a given company would remain on the road before returning “home”—be that London, the patron’s estate, or somewhere else—is not clear. Some companies were probably perpetually on tour, only rarely taking a break; companies based in London appear to have undertaken very short tours as well as more extensive tours, sometimes necessitated by plague but usually apparently of their own free will. It is similarly difficult to say how many stops a given tour consisted of; once again, the numbers vary considerably (Keenan 11).9 Companies appear to have tried to make frequent stops in a particular region or along a particular touring route, especially in areas favorably disposed towards their patron; for instance, Warwick’s Men and Leicester’s Men—patronized by Ambrose Dudley, Earl of Warwick, and his brother Robert Dudley, Earl of Leicester—both were frequent Warwickshire visitors during this period (McMillin and MacLean 37; Greenfield, “Touring” 262–3; Keenan 9). Given all these variations, it is difficult, if not impossible, to speak of a “typical” tour, even for an individual company. If Shakespeare was a member of a playing company during this time, he could have been perpetually on tour, frequently in London, or even frequently near Stratford, depending on the company (or companies) he joined. Although it is possible to speak of oft-traveled touring routes,10 it is difficult to say how planned out a given tour may have been. Since particular companies visited some of the same locations year after year,11 tours likely followed some sort of planned itinerary. Barbara Palmer even argues that playing company visits to noble households were even booked in advance. Palmer notes that despite the fact families such as the Cavendishes had multiple residences, playing troupes almost
9
For instance, every London company undertook long tours during the long plague closures in 1592 and 1593. Strange’s Men is a good example—after few provincial appearances before 1592, in that year they undertook an extensive tour consisting of at least 10–15 stops over at least 5 months. Yet in 1590–91, when they seemingly were playing in London, and when there were no recorded playhouse closures of any kind, they went on a short tour that apparently took them only to Faversham. See the Appendix for more detailed information on Strange’s movements. 10 For more detailed discussions of touring routes, see McMillin and MacLean 39; Greenfield, “Touring” 261–3; Keenan 8–9. 11 The Queen’s Men is recorded year after year in most surviving town accounts; other examples of “favorite” touring stops include Ipswich for Sussex’s Men (1587, 1588, 1589, 1590, 1591, and 1592–93), Leicester for Worcester’s Men (1590–91, 1591, 1591–92, 1592–93, 1593–94, 1594–95, and 1596), the Cavendish Household for Ogle’s Men (1593–94, 1594–95, 1595–96, and 1596–97), and Coventry for Berkeley’s Men (1577–78, 1578–79, 1579–1580, 1580–81, 1581–82, 1582–83, and 1583–84).
Provincial Playing, c. 1577–1588
49
always showed up wherever the family was staying, thus strongly suggesting a “communication system” between players and the nobles they visited (275–80). At the same time, the players during this time were nothing if not resourceful, and particular stops may have been spur-of-the-moment. Companies had to be prepared to move on a moment’s notice, given the threat of plague closures or hostile authorities, in London as well as in the country. Companies also appear to have been opportunistic about forming alliances with other entertainers while on tour. Numerous records exist of players traveling with groups of musicians, sometimes, but not always, supported by the same patron. For example, Worcester’s appeared with Derby’s musicians in Shrewsbury in 1590–91 (REED, Shropshire i.248). Players also appear to have occasionally traveled with groups of acrobats, as in 1589–90, when the Queen’s appeared with tumblers and rope dancers in Shrewsbury (REED, Shropshire i.247), Bristol (REED, Bristol 135–136), and Norwich (REED, Norwich 96). Somewhat less frequently, two playing companies would combine forces for a performance, or sometimes even for a group of performances. Such temporary “amalgamations” may have been premeditated, as when the Queen’s and Sussex’s appeared together in several towns over the course of 1590–91,12 but it is equally possible that they were spontaneous in nature, a way to guarantee that, when two companies showed up at a given town at the same time, both were guaranteed a reward of some kind. “Amalgamations” could also serve political or symbolic ends, depending on the patrons involved (such as the alliance between Essex’s and the Queen’s on 4 January 1590 in Faversham—REED, Kent 560) (Keenan 11–13). Although evidence is limited, it is possible to make reasonable conjectures about what sorts of things the players took with them when traveling. The will of Simon Jewell, a player who traveled with either Pembroke’s or the Queen’s Men in the early 1590s, indicates players took costumes, properties, and musical instruments with them when on tour. Such items, particularly the costumes, were the most valuable part of a company’s stock, and as such they may have had some sort of protection from the elements, such as the aforementioned (presumably covered) wagons (Edmond 129–34; Keenan 11, 15). Jewell’s will does not say anything about playscripts, but it does seem that a company also took these with it on tour. A note from the Master of the Revels to the town of Leicester in 1583 (Murray ii.320) indicates that the local authorities were expected to verify that a play offered for performance had been authorized by the Master, and the proof of authorization was the Master’s signature on the actual playbook (Gurr, Companies 42). Of course, once again this law may not have been rigidly enforced in the provinces, but it does show that at least someone expected touring players to be carrying their playtexts with them.
12 The two companies played together in 1590–91 in Gloucester (REED, Cumberland/ Westmorland/Gloucestershire 312), on 14 February 1591 in Southampton (REED, “Southampton” 56), in late February or early March in Bristol (REED, Bristol 140), and on 24 March in Coventry (REED, Coventry 332).
50
Shakespeare’s Companies
The precise nature of the texts taken on tour has often been the object of heated debate. A longstanding assumption has been that players shortened their texts for touring. This assumption was predicated on the further assumption that a company on tour reduced its personnel. Just as this second assumption has recently been challenged, the assumption that playtexts were shortened has also been challenged as of late. Shortened versions of longer plays do exist (for example, The First Part of the Contention and The True Tragedy of Richard Duke of York are shorter versions of 2 and 3 Henry VI, respectively), but it is not a foregone conclusion that these shorter texts were made for the purposes of touring, especially owing to the fact that the shortened texts do not call for appreciably smaller casts than their longer counterparts. If, then, these shorter texts were not made for touring, it does not follow that touring texts were abridgments of longer texts. Besides, there is no compelling reason why touring companies would have wanted texts of shorter length while on tour. So although assumptions and conjectures have been circulating for years regarding the “differences” between “London” and “touring” texts, there is no evidence to suggest there actually was any difference (Bradley 58–74). That having been said, virtually nothing is known about the playtexts used by traveling companies. A few isolated records in town accounts give the name of the play the company performed, such as several Bristol records between 1575 and 1579 (REED, Bristol 112, 115–17), but in almost every case the named plays have been lost. The companies themselves do not seem to have kept any sort of touring records; therefore, London repertories, when known, provide the only real clues to what sorts of plays were taken on tour. It is also difficult to say how many plays a given company took with them when touring. Purely provincial companies presumably had all of their plays with them at all times, but that tells us nothing about the number of plays in the repertoire of a traveling company. London-based companies presumably did not take all their plays on tour, nor would they have needed to; after all, touring would have allowed them to use a handful of plays over and over without wearing the audiences out, as long as the company kept moving (Greenfield, “Touring” 264). The texts themselves may have been manuscript texts, or printed texts the company had purchased or else borrowed texts from another company (Keenan 14). It may also be that the patron, or a member of the audience with literary aspirations, supplied players with material. There are references to nobles penning plays for common players, and Hamlet furnishes an example of a member of the audience giving the players textual additions (14). It is not possible, of course, to determine how widespread such practices were, but it could be that in Hamlet Shakespeare relates a fictionalized version of a practice he had either seen or heard about earlier in his career. In any case, if Shakespeare joined a traveling company between 1577 and 1588, he may or may not have found himself in a group of players hungry for new plays. It is possible that his first company would have encouraged him to develop his literary skills early on; but it could also be that it was not until he gained a London base that he began to pursue literary ambitions. Once in a given town, there were a number of places a playing company could, at least in theory, play. Most of these playing spaces appear to have been indoors,
Provincial Playing, c. 1577–1588
51
although traveling companies sometimes would play outdoors, when necessary or desirable. As the largest building in a town, the town hall presented the most obvious playing space for a traveling company,13 but there are records of companies also performing in other large city structures. Players definitely performed in a school in Lyme Regis in 1606–1607 (REED, Dorset/Cornwall 218), and certain regulatory statutes from Newark in 1568 and Boston in 1578 indicate schools were being used for performances (Keenan 109). Traveling companies played in churches in Lyme Regis in 1558–59 (REED, Dorset/Cornwall 212), Bewdley in 1571–72 (REED, Herefordshire/Worcestershire 361), Aldeburgh in 1573–74 (“Playing Companies at Aldeburgh” 19), and in several other instances as well. Berkeley’s Men played in an inn chamber at Dorchester in 1608 (REED, Dorset/Cornwall 195, 342). And ample records of players at noble houses exist.14 In terms of outdoor spaces, records survive of the Queen’s Men performing in a churchyard in Gloucester in 1589–90 (REED, Cumberland/Westmoreland/Gloucestershire 311) and an innyard in Norwich in 1583 (REED, Norwich 70). Performances also took place in marketplaces, such as Essex’s 1584 performance in a Shrewsbury apple market (REED, Shropshire i.238– 47). Moreover, in a few cases provincial cities, such as Bristol, had purpose-built playhouses (Gurr, Companies 39–40; Greenfield 264–5; Keenan 144–64). These provincial playhouses, however, were not built until well after 1588 and are, as such, beyond the scope of the current chapter. While there was probably no such thing as a “typical” visit by a playing company, it seems most visits took something of the following form, as described by Robert Willis, who recollected a playing company’s visit to Gloucester during his boyhood in Mount Tabor (1639).15 Upon arriving in town, the players would meet with the mayor, or equivalent authority, and present their patent (110). In some cases the mayor might turn the players away, with or without payment, for whatever reason: perhaps he was hostile to playing; perhaps he feared disorder, as at Norwich in 1614 (REED, Norwich 140); perhaps he worried that the players brought plague with them; perhaps the town as suffering a plague outbreak and was trying to avoid 13
Keenan reckons that of the 160 named playing places in the REED volumes published by 2002, 120 of the playing places are town halls (24). A somewhat different figure is given on the REED Patrons and Performances website which, as of 2008, lists 172 venues, the majority of them private residences. At present (2008), the site notes that performance venue research is still ongoing, even for those volumes for which complete patron and performance data has been uploaded. As the REED site continues to expand, it will become the most extensive and complete list of playing places. 14 Some of the noble houses whose theatrical activities have been closely studied are the Shuttleworths and Stanleys (REED, Lancashire), the Berkeleys (Greenfield, “Entertainments”), the Middletons (REED, “Nottinghamshire”), and the Cavendishes and Cliffords (Palmer, “Early Modern Mobility”). 15 Although written in 1639, Willis’s account is of a performance he saw as a child; since Willis was born in 1563 or 1564, the performance he writes about must have been in the late 1560s or early 1570s. No one has ever raised any serious objections to the accuracy of Willis’s description.
Shakespeare’s Companies
52
large gatherings, as at Cambridge in 1580 (Wickham, Berry and Ingram 250–51); or perhaps the town was in mourning, as at Canterbury in 1603 (REED, Kent 241). The outright rejection of a company’s request to play seems to have been the exception rather than the rule; instead, players were usually very much welcome when they arrived at their destination (Palmer 273). In towns, the mayor would often request what Robert Willis refers to as a “mayor’s play” (110), wherein the players would perform their play for the mayor, other local officials, and perhaps the public at large. The “mayor’s play” presumably presented the local officials with an opportunity to screen or censor the productions, exercise control over the gathering, or demonstrate their power and goodwill to the community. After the conclusion of the play, the town would give the players some sort of reward (ranging from a few pence to several pounds, and sometimes including other non-monetary compensation). Then the mayor would perhaps give the company permission to play elsewhere in the locality. It could be that there would be more than one civic performance; such performances gave the local government an opportunity to show their wealth, power, and beneficence towards the players, or even towards the public (Willis 110; Greenfield, “Touring” 255–56; Keenan 15, 18–20). Before a performance, players might publicize their presence in several ways. Some records indicate that players would play drums and trumpets as they marched through the town, as happened in Edinburgh in 1599 (Chambers, Stage ii.267). A scene from John Marston’s Histrio-mastix suggests that the players could also issue a proclamation from some central space announcing the forthcoming production (The Plays of John Marston iii.258).16 On occasion, a company may have posted notices around the town, as the Queen’s Men did in 1592 in Cambridge (REED, Cambridge 342, 723). At the performance itself, the audience could expect to see something fairly sophisticated. One record notes that players damaged a ceiling, suggesting complicated staging of some sort (REED, Devon 46). The costumes and properties the players brought with them no doubt added to the spectacle. Apparently, though, necessary set pieces were borrowed from the locals, as indicated by a 1605 record from Leicester compensating a citizen for a chair of his visiting players had damaged (Keenan 21). Performances may have taken place either in the afternoon or evening, and sometimes a company appears to have offered two performances on the same day. It is unclear how long a company would remain in one location; company visits seem to have ranged anywhere from a day or two to a week or more. The Admiral’s Men performed in Ipswich on 26 May 1587 (“Players at Ipswich” 274) and Aldeburgh on 28 May (“Playing Companies at Aldeburgh” 21), so their visit to Ipswich was quite short. Queen Anne’s Men were allowed to play in Norwich for a week in 1611 (REED, Norwich 136); Richard Weekes and John Shanke were permitted to play for 12 days in Norwich in 1635 (219). Whatever the length of a company’s stay, their performances could make marked impressions on their audiences. Richard Willis 16
Marston’s authorship of this play is not certain and has been recently challenged by Knutson in “Histrio-Mastix: Not by John Marston.”
Provincial Playing, c. 1577–1588
53
commented that, years after having seen a morality play, it remained fresh in his mind (110–14). The players’ performance in Hamlet elicits a reaction of extreme guilt in Claudius that Shakespeare evidently thought his audience would regard as plausible (Hamlet III, 2 and III, 3). And Thomas Heywood, in Apology for Actors (1612), relates an anecdote about a woman so moved by a play she confessed to a v murder she had committed years before (Book Three, G –G2). These, then, were the general characteristics of touring between 1577 and 1588 and those that Shakespeare would have encountered, if he did indeed join a traveling company during this time. What, then, were the specific conditions for touring between 1577 and 1588, especially the companies active in the provinces at the time?17 Thanks to the REED collections, it is possible to summarize provincial playing activity during these years. In 1577, there were a number of important touring companies ranging throughout the provinces. Of these, the Earl of Leicester’s Men, based on its provincial appearances was the most prolific touring company, as it had been for some time. Leicester was apparently relatively involved in the activities of his players, and also often used them for political purposes (McMillin and MacLean 18–24; Gurr, Companies 185–92). His company was not, however, without stiff competition, as Derby’s, Howard’s (later known as the Lord Admiral’s), Sussex’s, Warwick’s, Worcester’s, and Berkeley’s Men all frequently appeared in the provinces in the late 1570s. Companies belonging to Lord Strange18 and the Countess of Essex were also relatively important at the time, as were Stafford’s and Sheffield’s Men. Most of these companies remained highly active between 1577 and 1583, with the exception of the Countess of Essex’s company, which appears to have disbanded around 1580 (Gurr, Companies 170). During the late 1570s and early 1580s, several other notable companies emerged on the provincial scene: Hunsdon’s Men appear in 1581, Oxford’s in 1580, and Chandos’s and Morley’s in 1581–82. Furthermore, Essex’s Men (if distinct from the Countess of Essex’s Men) begin to appear in 1581–82. Other companies did not fare as well between 1577 and 1583. Warwick’s Men, for instance, does not appear in the provinces after 1581–82, and Howard’s Men appears only once between 1578–79 and 1584–85. In 1583, the face of English theatre was changed with the formation of the Queen’s Men. Francis Walsingham granted Edmund Tilney, Master of the Revels, the authority to form this company by selecting the best members from other active companies. 17
More specific details about the individual companies mentioned in the following discussion can be found in the individual chapters dealing with particular companies (where applicable), as well as in the Appendix. 18 The Strange’s company of the late 1570s is often referred to as “players.” Between 1580 and 1587, however, each time Strange’s performed at court, it seems to have done so as tumblers (Chambers, Stage iv.156–61). Accordingly, it may be that the late 1570s Strange’s was this group of tumblers, although the use of the phrase “players” opens up the possibility that (1) these tumblers were also actors, or (2) there was a separate Strange’s players at the time the tumbling troupe was also active. At present (2007), the REED Patrons and Performances website describes the company as “players,” not tumblers or acrobats.
Shakespeare’s Companies
54
The result was a company with more players, better patronage, and better talent than any of its rivals. Judging solely by playing notices before and after 1583, many of the other companies of the day suffered from the formation of the Queen’s Men. Leicester’s players seem to have taken a year or so off after 1583, as was the case with Sussex’s Men,19 while notices of Derby’s Men trail off after 1582–83, and the company disappears entirely after 1584–85 Beverly performance. The Queen’s Men, however, flourished, dominating London, court, and provincial playing for a number of years. In fact, the Queen’s Men dominated provincial playing like no other company before or after, and the sheer number of appearances between 1583 and 1603 has allowed scholars to construct more detailed provincial itineraries for the Queen’s Men than for any other English acting company of the era. Competition did not, however, completely melt away in the face of the Queen’s Men’s dominance. The activities of Worcester’s Men do not appear to have been interrupted by the Queen’s formation, nor those of Hunsdon’s, Chandos’s, Stafford’s, Morley’s, or Sheffield’s Men. Provincial notices of performances by Essex’s, Berkeley’s, and Oxford’s Men actually increase in 1583 and 1584, and between 1583 and 1585 Oxford’s Men appears in the provincial records more often than the Queen’s Men. However, by 1585–86 the Queen’s was decidedly the chief traveling company in the land, its provincial notices easily exceeding Oxford’s Men. Beginning in 1584–85, several other traveling companies reemerged, and although they did not challenge the Queen’s Men in terms of number of provincial notices, they seem to have fared pretty well. Howard’s/Lord Admiral’s Men toured again in 1584–85 and remained a major force in the provinces into the seventeenth century. The Sussex’s Men that emerged in 1584–85 would frequently perform in the provinces over the next decade. Leicester’s Men also made a 1584–85 comeback, and between 1586 and 1588 it would be second only to the Queen’s in terms of provincial appearances. The reemergence of these three formidable companies may have impacted the fortunes of those who had challenged the Queen’s Men during its first two years of existence. Several companies apparently ceased traveling for a few years to regroup, reorganize, or to be completely reconstituted (Worcester’s disappears between 1585 and 1589, Berkeley’s between 1586–87 and 1591–92, and Morley’s between 1586 and 1591), while others, like Oxford’s in 1587 and Sheffield’s in 1585–86, disappeared completely. By 1588, then, the Queen’s Men and Leicester’s Men were easily the two primary traveling companies in England, with Essex’s, the Lord Admiral’s, and Sussex’s Men forming a second tier of sorts; Hunsdon’s, Chandos’s, and Stafford’s Men, while not as active, nevertheless maintained a consistent provincial presence through 1588. The companies named in the preceding discussion constitute only the most active, or most noted, traveling companies between 1577 and 1588. Many other companies operated during this timeframe as well, but they either did not tour as extensively as the companies already mentioned, or else fewer records of their visits to provincial 19
Thomas Radcliffe, Earl of Sussex, died in 1583 and was succeeded by his son, Henry. The Sussex’s that appears in 1584–85 thus may be distinct from the previous group.
Provincial Playing, c. 1577–1588
55
towns have survived. Several such companies are mentioned multiple times between 1577 and 1588; these include Monteagle’s, Huntingdon’s, Mountjoy’s, Arundel’s, Cecil’s, Radcliffe’s, Bath’s, Kinderton’s, and Hertford’s Men. Some of these companies had a more substantial existence either before or after the time period this discussion is concerned with, and all of them probably had a more substantial existence during this time period than the surviving records indicate. Besides this handful of “minor” traveling companies, a number of other companies are named at least once during this period, including Willoughby’s, Montagu’s, Mordaunt’s, Evelyn’s, Sturton’s, Rogers’s, Hesketh’s, Cavendish’s, Lincoln’s, Windsor’s, Eglionby’s, Compton’s, Dudley’s, Lucy’s, Beauchamp’s, Ogle’s, Bartholomew’s, and Rich’s Men. In addition to these companies, at least one boy company, the Chapel Children, toured briefly during this period, appearing in two locations in 1586–87; moreover, a company apparently patronized (or claiming to be patronized) by the Master of the Revels appears several times in 1583 and 1584. The general story of provincial playing between 1577 and 1588 seems to be the story of the emergence of the Queen’s Men and the perseverance, or disappearance, of the other major touring companies. Among both major and minor companies, there was a rapid turnover, although it may not have been out of the ordinary. The apparent capriciousness of company fortunes between 1577 and 1588 indicates just how volatile touring could be, but the fact that there were so many traveling companies also testifies to the viability, even attractiveness, of the life of a traveling player. Again, traveling must have been rewarding as well as difficult; were it otherwise, so many people would not have gravitated towards such a lifestyle. Recorded profits may not have been great, but large sums of money were involved in touring; this, along with the possibility of eventually playing in London or at court must have drawn a number of young men into the playing profession. There was no guarantee of glory in such a lifestyle, but the potential for it, however small, was nevertheless there, and in any case it would have attracted curious and free-spirited young men, including some of artistic potential. It is to this difficult-yet-rewarding lifestyle that many biographers and theatre historians argue young William Shakespeare of Stratford-Upon-Avon was drawn. It is distinctly possible that he received his first professional theatrical employment and training with some provincial playing company; the question, however, is which one. Our biases perhaps lead us to think he was more likely to have been a member of one or more of the larger, successful companies during this era, but it is equally possible that he was, for a time, associated with one or more of the obscure companies active between 1577 and 1588. It is also possible that he was not active in the theatre at all during this time. Locating him in any specific company is, therefore, a complex matter of possibilities and plausible conjectures. But is it possible to develop arguments based upon probabilities? Part III will show just how complex this picture becomes. First, however, it is necessary to turn from provincial playing to what was, by 1588, becoming the center of Elizabethan theatrical activity: the London stage.
This page intentionally left blank
Chapter 4
London Playing, 1588–1594
While Shakespeare may have been involved in provincial playing before 1588, he was definitely a part of the London theatre scene by the early 1590s. The exact year of Shakespeare’s arrival in London is impossible to date with certainty, but as he was a playwright of some mettle by 1592, it is reasonable to place his arrival sometime in the late 1580s. As Peter Thomson notes, biographers have often chosen 1587 as the exact year Shakespeare came to London (Shakespeare’s 20), but some have argued for earlier as well as later dates.1 Even if Shakespeare did not move to London until 1591, 1588 marks the beginning of a number of key changes that would significantly alter London playing. Shakespeare, his career, and whatever company or companies he was affiliated with before 1594 were very much bound up with these changes. This being the case, any attempt to reckon with the London contexts Shakespeare found himself in before 1594 must begin no later than 1588. Quite apart from Shakespeare’s emergence, the years between 1588 and 1594 were pivotal for London playing for a number of reasons. Firstly, it was about 1588 that the Queen’s Men’s dominance of London playing began to wane. This decline has often been linked to the death of Richard Tarlton in September 1588, but the Queen’s Men was already being challenged in terms of court performances in 1585–86 (Astington, English 231). Audience tastes were also changing by 1588, so Tarlton’s death, rather than causing the Queen’s London decline, was more of a symbol of a decline already underway (McMillin and MacLean 52–3). As the Queen’s presence in London waned (the company’s provincial preeminence remained intact for another decade), other companies moved into the void: Strange’s, the Admiral’s, and, a few years later, Pembroke’s and Sussex’s. Secondly, audience tastes changed significantly between 1588 and 1594. At the beginning of this period, moralities and “medley” style plays continued to draw large audiences. While audiences did not completely lose their taste for plays of this kind, the vogue for the chronicle history play, inaugurated by, among others, Marlowe and Shakespeare, exploded onto the London scene during these years (Gurr, Playgoing 119–58; McMillin and MacLean 121–24, 155–60). Along with other emerging genres, such as revenge tragedy and citizen comedy, the chronicle history play brought new playwrights to the fore and, it seems, changed the organization of the acting companies during this period. This was to be an era of large-cast plays, 1
The range of London arrival dates includes 1580 (Southworth 27), 1582 (Sams 52), “after 1585” (Halliwell-Phillips 47), 1586 (Lee 37), 1588 (Fraser 7–8), “as early as 1589” (Duncan-Jones 43), and about 1590 (Adams 125).
58
Shakespeare’s Companies
and acting company size swelled to the highest level it would ever reach during the Elizabethan period (Gurr, Companies 59–60). These six years also saw the temporary disappearance of the boy companies, which had been very popular up to 1589. The suppression of these companies following (and perhaps a result of their participation in) the Martin Marprelate controversy of 1589 changed the dynamics of court playing, and also forced audiences who had preferred to attend performances of boy companies to look elsewhere for theatrical entertainment. Similarly, the suppression of the boy companies forced playwrights writing for them to find other outlets for their creative energies. The disappearance of the boy companies thus effectively created a truly popular theatre, wherein all theatrical tastes and audiences mingled together (Gurr, Companies 218–26; Playgoing 137–8; Cook, “Audiences” 318). Finally, the period between 1588 and 1594 saw the emergence of Philip Henslowe as a theatrical power. He was, with son-in-law Edward Alleyn, to influence London playing well into the seventeenth century. Henslowe had opened his Rose Theatre in 1587, inaugurating a new era in playhouse building and introducing professional theatre to the south bank of the Thames. Moreover, thanks to Henslowe’s Diary, in which he began keeping daily theatrical records in 1592, a great deal is known about his theatrical activities between 1588 and 1594 (and beyond). The Diary also serves as the main source of information about London company organization and operations in the last decade of the sixteenth century. With such pivotal changes occurring during this six year period, it is surprising that there has never been a systematic attempt to consider these years in their own right. The years before 1588 are treated in William Ingram’s The Business of Playing, but he stops his account in 1586, the year before Henslowe built the Rose theatre in Southwark. Similarly, the decade after 1594 has received scholarly attention from Andrew Gurr (The Shakespeare Company, 1594–1642), Roslyn Knutson (The Repertory of Shakespeare’s Company, 1594–1613) and Ingram (A London Life in the Brazen Age). The years between 1588 and 1594 are often discussed in studies of the theatrical activity from 1594 to 1603 (and beyond), but as precursors to later developments. McMillin and MacLean (The Queen’s Men and Their Plays, 1583– 1603) consider theatrical conditions during these years, but only in the context of the Queen’s Men’s activities. Scholars concerned with Pembroke’s Men, such as Karl Wentersdorf (“Repertory” and “Origin”) and David George (“Shakespeare and Pembroke’s Men”) have also given serious thought to the conditions of 1588–94, but by focusing on this one company, their accounts suffer under the (unsolvable) problems of figuring out where Pembroke’s Men came from and what its relationship was to other acting companies active at the same time. This chapter, accordingly, considers the dynamics of these six years not as a prelude to later developments, or as an interlude between “stable” playing periods, but as a time of pivotal changes and interesting theatrical activity in their own right. Apart from sketching a context for Shakespeare’s London emergence, this chapter serves to address a number of assumptions and errors concerning the playing companies active during this period. Addressing these issues will not only make it
London Playing, 1588–1594
59
possible to talk more sensibly of Shakespeare’s whereabouts before 1594, but will also help set the stage for future, and fuller, discussions of London playing during these years. Playing Places and Audiences Between 1588 and 1594, adult acting companies in London had at least eight potential venues. Four of these venues were innyards. “The Four Inns,” as they are collectively referred to, were the Bel Savage, the Bell, the Bull, and the Cross Keys. When they were first used for public performances is unknown, but all four were active as playhouses by the mid 1570s. Documents demonstrate that the Bel Savage was used for performances by 1575, the Bell by 1577, the Bull by 1578, and the Cross Keys by 1579 (Wickham, Berry and Ingram 297–8). No records indicate which companies performed at the inns before 1583, but between 1583 and 1588, the Queen’s Men played at all four. Strange’s Men played at the Cross Keys in 1589. The Admiral’s Men may have played at the Bel Savage between 1588 and 1594.2 And the Lord Chamberlain’s Men played at the Cross Keys in 1594 (300– 304). After 1594, no mentions exist of the Four Inns being used as playhouses, and in 1600 the Privy Council expressly forbade playing at the city inns (305). Of course, the need for such an order may suggest that the inns continued function as playhouses throughout the 1590s.3 Besides inn-yards, playing companies used the larger, and better-known, purposebuilt playhouses. Five such venues had been built by 1588, but only four remained in operation. The first public playhouse, the Red Lion, was built in Stepney in 1567 by John Brayne, a grocer. Records demonstrate the playhouse had been completed by July 1567. Brayne filed a lawsuit against the carpenter who built the stage in autumn 1568, but after this nothing more is heard of the Red Lion. Brayne’s reasons for building the Red Lion are not known, but James Burbage, one of Leicester’s leading players, was his brother-in-law. In any case, no company can be linked to the Red Lion, and it is not clear if Brayne envisioned it as a permanent structure in the first place (Wickham, Berry and Ingram 291–4).4 In 1576, Brayne and Burbage built the Theatre in Shoreditch, which was clearly conceived as a permanent playhouse. Again, few companies can be linked to the Theatre in its early years. Burbage, a member of Leicester’s Men in 1574, perhaps 2
This is suggested by a reference to Dr. Faustus being performed there; the only company known to have performed this play before the closure of the inns is the Admiral’s Men. 3 For more on the Four Inns, see Wickham, Berry and Ingram 295–305; Oscar Brownstein, “A Record of London Inn-Playhouses from c. 1565–1590;” Wickham II.ii 95–109; Salkeld, “The Bell;” and Chambers, Stage ii.380–83. 4 For more on the Red Lion, see Wickham, Berry and Ingram 290–94; Janet S. Loengard, “An Elizabethan Lawsuit: John Brayne, His Carpenter, and the Building of the Red Lion Theatre;” John H. Astington, “The Red Lion Playhouse: Two Notes;” Herbert Berry, “The First Public Playhouses, Especially the Red Lion;” and Ingram, Business 102–12.
Shakespeare’s Companies
60
built the Theatre for his own company, but this, as Andrew Gurr says, “is a hopeful presumption unsupported by any evidence” (Companies 189). In 1579, Gabriel Harvey vaguely commented that Leicester’s, Warwick’s, Vaux’s, and Rich’s Men performed at “the Theatre or some other painted stage” (Wickham, Berry and Ingram 341). An April 1580 scuffle between Inns of Court students and Oxford’s Men demonstrates that company occupied the Theatre at that time (Gurr, Companies 307), and the Queen’s Men performed there at least as early as June 1584 (Wickham, Berry and Ingram 345–6). Depositions filed in conjunction with lawsuits involving Giles Allen, leasor of the land the Theatre stood on, Margaret Brayne, John’s widow (he died in 1586), Robert Miles, an old business partner of Brayne’s, and James Burbage and his sons Richard and Cuthbert demonstrate that the Admiral’s Men had been playing at the Theatre for a time before May 1591, when several of its number were drawn into the Burbage-Brayne/Miles conflict (349–64). In 1594, the Lord Chamberlain’s Men took up residence at the Theatre soon after its 1594 formation. In 1599, lease troubles forced Richard and Cuthbert Burbage (James died in 1596) to dismantle the Theatre. They rebuilt it in Southwark as the Globe; the Lord Chamberlain’s Men made the move with the Theatre’s timbers (346–8, 367– 72, 375–87; Gurr, Stage 41).5 At roughly the same time the Theatre was built, a playhouse was erected at Newington Butts, south of London. The playhouse’s builder cannot be identified with certainty, but William Ingram has demonstrated it was probably Jerome Savage, the leading player in Warwick’s Men (Business 163–77).6 It is therefore possible Warwick’s Men first occupied the playhouse, but no definite evidence proves this conjecture. Warwick’s disappears from the records in 1580, although it may have been reconstituted as Oxford’s Men, which Ingram thinks briefly played at Newington, although no definite evidence supports this assertion (171–5). Sometime in the early 1590s (and definitely before September 1593), Strange’s Men performed at Newington, as testified to by an undated Privy Council order (327–8). Henslowe’s Diary records performances by both the Admiral’s and Lord Chamberlain’s Men at the playhouse from 3–13 June 1594 (Foakes 21–2), just before the Admiral’s took up permanent residence at the Rose and the Lord Chamberlain’s at the Theatre. A man named Paul Buck, who may have been a player, acquired the playhouse on 6 July 1594 on the condition that playing cease there (Wickham, Berry and Ingram 329). Buck seems to have abided by these terms, for no further records exist of playing at Newington, and by 1599 the playhouse had definitely been replaced by houses (329).7 5
For more on the Theatre, see Charles William Wallace, The First London Theatre, Materials for a History; Berry, ed., The First Public Playhouse: The Theatre in Shoreditch 1576–1598; and Ingram, Business 182–218. 6 Ingram’s conjecture has been generally accepted. An older proposal, made by Ida Darlington, is that the playhouse at Newington was built by Richard Hickes, who definitely owned the land the playhouse was built on (Ingram, Business 153; Darlington, St. George’s Fields 86). 7 For more on the playhouse at Newington, see Wickham, Berry and Ingram 320–29; Ingram, “The Playhouse at Newington Butts: A New Proposal” and Business 150–81, 243–5.
London Playing, 1588–1594
61
In 1577, the Curtain opened in Shoreditch, virtually next door to the Theatre. Henry Lanman, who owned the Curtain from 1585 to 1592, is often credited as its builder, but there is no definite evidence this was the case (Wickham, Berry and Ingram 405). As with the other theatres, the early occupants of the Curtain are unknown. Lord Arundel’s Men may have played there in 1584 (410), and, according to Tarlton’s Jests, the Queen’s Men also performed at the Curtain during the comic’s lifetime (B3). No evidence survives for its occupants between 1588 and 1594. Records do survive, however, of a curious arrangement reached between Lanman and Burbage and Brayne in 1585, whereby the profits of both playhouses, for a period of seven years, were split, half going to Lanman, half to Burbage and Brayne. Why this arrangement was instituted remains a mystery, but it was still in place in 1592, and the parties involved seem to have found it satisfactory (Wickham, Berry and Ingram 348–9, 405; Ingram, Business 227–36).8 The Rose, the last of the public playhouses in operation between 1588 and 1594, was originally built in 1587 by dyer/financier Philip Henslowe and grocer John Cholmley (Wickham, Berry and Ingram 419–25). Before 1592, there is no evidence for what company or companies played at the Rose, but in that year Henslowe remodeled it and began keeping daily records of Rose receipts in his Diary. When these records commence on 19 February 1592, Henslowe lists Lord Strange’s Men as the Rose’s resident company. Strange’s may have been playing at the Rose before then, but it is also possible that 19 February marked the beginning of the troupe’s occupancy. Whatever the case, Strange’s played at the Rose until 22 June 1592; after a six-month break because of the plague, Strange’s returned to the Rose on 29 December. Strange’s second Rose run ended on 1 February 1593, again owing to plague outbreak. When the Rose reopened on 27 December 1593, Sussex’s Men, rather than Strange’s, was the resident company. Sussex’s season lasted until 6 February 1594; then, from 1 to 8 April, Sussex’s and the Queen’s Men both played at the Rose. From 14–16 May the Lord Admiral’s Men played at the Rose; this company returned on 15 June 1594 and the Rose was its London home for the remainder of the 1590s (Foakes 16–22).9 In addition to the public playing places available to professional adult companies, a small playhouse at St. Paul’s hosted public performances by Paul’s Boys up to 1591, as it had since at least December 1575 (Wickham, Berry and Ingram 306, 309–10). It is sometimes believed this playhouse closed owing to the Paul’s Boys’ involvement in the Martin Marprelate controversy; however, this controversy took place in 1589 and the Privy Council order that sought to prevent theatrical interference in “matters of divinity and state” says nothing about closing theatres 8
For more on the Curtain, see Wickham, Berry and Ingram 404–18; Ingram, “Henry Lanman’s Curtain Playhouse as an ‘Easer’ to the Theatre, 1585–1592;” Ingram, Business 219–38; and Lucyle Hook, “The Curtain.” 9 For more on the Rose, see Ernest L. Rhodes, Henslowe’s Rose; Carol Chillington Rutter, ed., Documents of the Rose Playhouse (2nd ed.); Christine Eccles, The Rose Playhouse; W.W. Greg, ed., Henslowe’s Diary, and R.A. Foakes, ed., Henslowe’s Diary.
Shakespeare’s Companies
62
or suppressing companies (311–12). The first mention of plays as Paul’s being suppressed occurs on 4 October 1591, when the printer of Lyly’s Endymion noted that “plays in Paul’s were dissolved” (A2). Still, as Gurr points out, “A clamp-down because of their involvement in the Marprelate troubles is certainly a possible cause for the company’s closure” (Companies 226). In any case, the playhouse at St. Paul’s was closed by 1591, and with its closure boy companies ceased to be a major force in London playing until their return in 1599–1600.10 Besides public playing places, companies fortunate enough to play at court used several venues. Between the 1587–88 and 1594–95 court seasons, playing companies performed at Whitehall, Greenwich, Richmond, and Hampton Court (Astington, English 232–4). No fewer than ten companies performed at court between 1588 and 1594. The Queen’s Men, Paul’s Boys, the Admiral’s Men, and Strange’s Men were the most frequent court performers during these years, with ten, eight, three (but possibly five) and nine (possibly eleven) performances, respectively. Lesser presences at court during these years were Mr. Evelyn’s Men and “John Simons ... and his Companie,” performing once each in 1587–88, the Gentlemen of Gray’s Inn, performing once in 1587–88 and again in 1594–95, Sussex’s Men and Hertford’s Men, playing once each in 1591–92, and Pembroke’s Men, which performed twice in 1592–93 (Astington, English 232–4; Chambers, Stage iv.161–5). It is not entirely clear what sorts of audiences saw plays in these London venues. Court performances were attended by elite audiences,11 and plays at Paul’s drew educated, moneyed, and privileged individuals. But there were only a handful of court performances a year, and performances at Paul’s, which took place once a week at most, could accommodated only 200 spectators (Gurr, Playgoing 22–3, 133–4). The vast majority of the playgoing public thus went to outdoor public playhouses. Alfred Harbage (Shakespeare’s Audience and Shakespeare and the Rival Traditions) thinks open-air audiences consisted of lower, working class individuals; Ann Jennalie Cook (The Privileged Playgoers) argues these audiences were mostly made up of people of wealth, status, and education; Andrew Gurr (Playgoing) and Martin Butler (Theatre and Crisis) point to a division between higher class indoor audiences and somewhat lower class outdoor audiences, with Gurr emphasizing the heterogeneous nature of outdoor audiences. Today, most scholars agree outdoor audiences were diverse, but there is still no agreement on what end of the social spectrum the “typical” playgoer gravitated toward. Despite fragmentary and contradictory evidence concerning public playhouse audiences (Cook, “Audiences” 305), a few generalizations can be made, although 10
For more on Paul’s boys and the playhouse at Paul’s, see Wickham, Berry and Ingram 306–19; Gurr, Companies 218–29; Reavley Gair, The Children of Paul’s; Berry, “Where was the Playhouse in which the Boy Choristers of St Paul’s Performed Plays?”; and Bowers, “The Playhouse of the Choristers of Paul’s, c. 1575–1608.” 11 Astington points out that, although a court audience was an audience of elites, it is difficult to piece together a more detailed picture of court audiences. For his own attempt at doing so, see English Court Theatre, 1558–1642, Chapter 5.
London Playing, 1588–1594
63
one must bear in mind that these generalizations apply to the whole period of public performances up to 1642; the composition of audiences may have shifted over time, and some of these generalizations may be more (or less) applicable to the period of 1577–88 than others. First, both men and women attended the outdoor theatres; young men were seemingly particularly well-represented (315). Second, audience members had money and free afternoons; the presence of refreshments, thieves, and prostitutes at theatres also suggests a certain level of audience means, although less well-off people seem to have flocked to the theatres on holidays (317–18). Finally, contemporary references to audiences (collected in Gurr’s Playgoing, 213–62, with others cited by Bernard Capp, “Playgoers,” and Salkeld, “Allusions”) mention a wide variety of classes in the audiences, ranging from apprentices to aristocrats. Whoever was in the audiences, it is clear that they were often physical and vocal in their behavior. There are a number of violent incidents, even riots, on record, but these events were extreme and relatively unusual. Audiences did, however, frequently compete with the players for attention in the course of a performance, through display or minor disruption. This was the case even at court performances (Gurr, Playgoing 45–9; Cook, “Audiences” 311–13). What relationships or interactions would Shakespeare have plausibly had with these playing places and audiences? In terms of venues, he could have had contact with any number of them as an actor and/or playwright during his emergence as a major London theatrical figure. He would not likely have had any contact with Paul’s company or playhouse, but he may have played at or written for companies performing at any of the outdoor theatres and innyards, and he could have been involved with a number of court performances. Whatever the venue he worked at, he would have had to please, as both actor and playwright, large, diverse, and volatile audiences. And it was exactly his ability to write plays that appealed to a wide variety of audience members and tastes that propelled him to the front ranks of the playwriting profession during the early 1590s. Playing Companies in London The period between 1588 and 1594 was a particularly pivotal time for playing companies in London. Companies that had once been prominent in London disappeared into the country (or disappeared altogether), and new companies took the place of the old, only to themselves disappear from London by 1594. These new companies—notably the Admiral’s, Strange’s, and Pembroke’s Men—were seemingly the first adult playing companies to think of themselves as predominantly London companies, and thus mark the emergence of London-based playing companies. The early years of London-based playing companies were highly disorganized: a succession of playing companies with London aspirations came and went rapidly, players apparently switched company affiliations frequently, and plague outbreaks limited the amount of time any company could actually play in London (and leave evidence of its activities). This state of affairs makes it difficult, if not impossible,
64
Shakespeare’s Companies
to reconstruct a complete or satisfying history of playing companies in London during these years. Moreover, scholarly narratives concerning the London playing companies between 1588 and 1594 have been riddled with problematic assumptions and questionable conclusions, especially in regards to the relationships between the various companies that played in London during this period. Before considering which of the playing companies Shakespeare may have belonged to before 1594, it is necessary to clear up some of this confusion. In doing so, though, one must recognize that the incomplete nature of the evidence for playing company activities during this period effectively prevents a systematic determination of the pattern of relationships between the various companies and the buildings and inns in which they performed (which in turn carries implications when certain claims about London playing between 1588 and 1594 are brought to bear in debating which company Shakespeare was aligned with at this time). The Queen’s Men Before 1588, several companies had frequently performed in London, but none of them can definitely be described as London-based companies. Leicester’s Men and Warwick’s Men both might have aspired to such a status, since individual members of each company had invested in purpose-built playhouses, but there is no evidence that either of these companies had long runs in London. The Queen’s Men, however, seems to have had a much more substantial London existence between about 1583 and 1588. The Queen’s performed in every, or nearly every, available London playing space and frequently performed at court. Nevertheless, there is again no evidence that the Queen’s Men ever engaged in, or attempted to engage in, long runs in London, save for a short stint at the Rose in 1594. Rather, it seems to have viewed London as a stop, albeit an important one, on its touring circuit (McMillin and MacLean 5–7). Between 1588 and 1594, the Queen’s Men experienced a marked decline in its London fortunes, symbolized by the death of Richard Tarlton in September 1588. While the impact of his death on the Queen’s Men can be, and often has been, overstated, the loss of the company’s most popular player cannot have helped the Queen’s Men’s London prospects. In any event, within two years of Tarlton’s death, notices of the Queen’s Men playing in London decline markedly, as do its court appearances. The company appeared twice at court in 1588–89, twice again in 1589– 90, and five times in 1590–91, but just once in 1591–92, not at all in 1592–93, and only once in 1593–94, which proved to be its final command performance (Astington, English 232–4; Chambers, Stage iv.161–5). It would seem that for much of the 1588–94 period, the Queen’s Men operated as two distinct branches. Four of the 1590–91 court performances are designated as performances by a Queen’s company led by Laurence and John Dutton, while the fifth was designated as a performance of a Queen’s company led by John Laneham (Chambers, Stage iv.163). These two groups seem to have conducted separate provincial tours as well, as indicated by the fact several provincial notices specify visits by the Dutton branch of the Queen’s Men
London Playing, 1588–1594
65
(REED, “Nottinghamshire” 35; REED, “Southampton” 57; REED, Coventry 336; REED, Cambridge i.340–41; REED, Dorset/Cornwall 217). The Laneham branch apparently also briefly toured jointly with Sussex’s Men (REED, “Southampton” 56; REED, Cumberland/Westmorland/Gloucestershire 312; REED, Bristol 140; REED, Coventry 332). After 1592–93 branch distinctions are not specified in any records, and the number of yearly recorded provincial visits by the Queen’s Men declines somewhat, suggesting that the practice of splitting was discontinued. The final documentable London appearance of the Queen’s Men is from early 1594. Following a court performance on 6 January (Chambers, Stage iv.164; Astington, English 234), the Queen’s appeared at the Rose, between 1 and 8 April, seemingly in combination with Sussex’s (Foakes 21). This piece of evidence has led some scholars to conclude that Laneham’s branch was the troupe in question, given its previous association with Sussex’s Men, but there is no other evidence besides the four 1590–91 provincial entries to support such speculation.12 After this stint at the Rose, the Queen’s Men appears to have faded entirely from the London scene, although there are hints it may have made one final London gamble in 1595 (Ingram, London Life 115–20; McMillin and MacLean 51; Knutson, Playing Companies 61–2, 67). John Heminges, who may have been a Queen’s player,13 joined the Chamberlain’s Men at this time (Gurr, Shakespeare Company 230); if he had indeed been a Queen’s man, one wonders if other leading Queen’s Men followed him to the Chamberlain’s. Regardless, the years between 1588 and 1594 were clearly ones of decline for the Queen’s London fortunes. When the Chamberlain’s and Admiral’s Men were formed in 1594, the Queen’s Men’s days as a major company in London and at court came to an end. The Admiral’s Men Charles Howard became the Lord High Admiral in 1585, commanded the English fleet that defeated the Spanish Armada in 1588, and remained Lord High Admiral until 1619. He also became Earl of Nottingham in 1596 and Lord Steward in 1597 (Chambers, Stage ii.134). Howard had patronized a company of players as early as the late 1570s, but this company seems to have disbanded in 1578–79.14 Upon becoming Lord Admiral, Howard apparently decided to sponsor a playing company 12 G.M. Pinciss (“Shakespeare, Her Majesty’s Players, and Pembroke’s Men” 134) and Karl P. Wentersdorf (“Origin” 58) both argue that Laneham’s Queen’s played with Sussex’s at the Rose in 1594; David George, however, argues that it was the Duttons’ branch that played with Sussex’s at the Rose (318, 322). 13 Heminges married the widow of William Knell on 10 March 1588, less than a year after Knell’s death. While this may suggest Heminges was one of Knell’s fellows, there is no evidence to verify that Heminges was indeed a Queen’s player (McMillin and MacLean 195; Gurr, Shakespeare Company 230; Chambers, Stage ii.320–23). 14 There is, however, an isolated of a company under his patronage appearing at Ipswich in 1582 (“Players at Ipswich” 273).
Shakespeare’s Companies
66
again, as a Lord Admiral’s Men began appearing in the provinces in town records from the 1584–85 civic year. This company performed at court during the 1585– 86 holiday season (Chambers, Stage iv.161; Astington, English 231), which may suggest that it was playing in London during this time. The Admiral’s Men was definitely playing in London in November 1587, when law student Philip Gawdy reported in a letter to his father that the misfiring of an onstage gun accidentally killed a child and a pregnant woman and injured an old man (Wickham, Berry and Ingram 277).15 The Admiral’s Men’s presence in London in 1587 is corroborated by a letter from an anonymous army officer to Sir Francis Walsingham in January of that year which names the Admiral’s as one of the companies playing in London “every day in the week” (90–91). Between 1587 and 1589, the Admiral’s Men performed only infrequently in the provinces (and then only at Oxford and Cambridge), yet it performed at court in 1588–89 and 1589–90 (Chambers, Stage iv.162–3; Astington, English 232–3). Given that the Admiral’s was definitely playing in London in 1587, it is possible that the company was playing in London throughout the late 1580s. The only further evidence to support this conjecture, however, is a letter from the Lord Mayor to Lord Burghley noting that the Admiral’s was playing in London in early November of 1589 (Wickham, Berry and Ingram 93–4). More substantial evidence attests to the Admiral’s Men’s presence in London in 1590 and 1591, when it was at the Theatre and may have appeared twice at court with Strange’s Men (a more detailed consideration of this evidence follows in the discussion of Strange’s Men). After May of 1591, about which time the Admiral’s Men nearly came to blows with James Burbage, the company is not traceable in London again until 14 May 1594, when it took up residence at Henslowe’s Rose (Foakes 21). Numerous records, however, attest to its presence in the provinces. While the Admiral’s Men performed exclusively outside London after 1591, its most famous member, Edward Alleyn, appears to have parted company with the Admiral’s, electing to join the company that would prove to be the most dominant of the early 1590s: Lord Strange’s Men. Lord Strange’s Men The Strange’s Men that rose to prominence in the late 1580s and early 1590s was likely distinct from the Strange’s that appeared in the provinces and at court during the late 1570s and early-to-mid 1580s (Chambers, Stage iv.161–2).16 The patron, however, was the same: Ferdinando Stanley, Lord Strange. Stanley became Lord Strange in 1572 and was summoned to parliament under that title in 1589 (Tiner 11). The latter group of Strange’s Men is first recorded in 1587–88, when it performed in Coventry (REED, Coventry 321). Like the Admiral’s Men, Strange’s rarely appeared in the provinces over the next several years, but it performed at court twice in 1590–91 and 15
No additional documents verify Gawdy’s report of the deaths and injury. As noted in Chapter 3, the company is often referred to as “players,” but court records indicate the company was primarily a group of tumblers. It is also possible there were two distinct Strange’s companies at this time, one players, one tumblers. 16
London Playing, 1588–1594
67
six times in 1591–92 (Chambers, Stage iv.163–4; Astington, English 233) and was playing at the Cross Keys Inn in November of 1589 (Wickham, Berry and Ingram 93–4). These London appearances, combined with the paucity of provincial activity, suggest Strange’s was based in London during these years. This was definitely the case by 1592, when Henslowe’s Diary records an uninterrupted five-month run by Strange’s at the Rose beginning on 19 February. This run concluded on 22 June; the next day, the theatres were closed due to plague and would remain so until 29 December 1592 (Gurr, Companies 91). Strange’s returned to the Rose on that day, possibly after a brief run at Newington Butts17 (Foakes 19). The company also performed three times during the 1592–93 court season (Chambers, Stage iv.164; Astington, English 234). Strange’s Men’s second run at the Rose was again ended by plague on 1 February 1593. This time, the playhouses remained closed for nearly 11 months, reopening only on 27 December 1593 (Gurr, Companies 91). During this enforced period of touring, Strange’s Men became Derby’s Men, as its patron became Lord Derby on 25 September 1593 (Gurr, Companies 265). The change in name roughly corresponds to an apparent decline in fortunes. Strange’s/ Derby’s was not called to court in 1593–94, and it did not return to the Rose when it reopened in late December of 1593. It is possible the company played at another London playhouse instead, but no evidence supports this conjecture. Even if Strange’s/Derby’s did return to London in 1593, another plague closure on 3 February 1594 would have forced it back on the road. The London theatres had reopened by April 1594 (91), but by this time London’s theatrical landscape had been radically altered and the Chamberlain’s and Admiral’s Men were quickly becoming London’s leading playing companies. Edward Alleyn and most of the other known Strange’s/ Derby’s players joined one or the other of these companies; to make matters worse, Ferdinando Stanley, Strange’s/Derby’s patron, died on 16 April 1594 (265). With these changes in the air, Derby’s Men disappeared from London playing until a new Derby’s Men, under the patronage of William Stanley, would make London inroads in about 1600 (265–6; Chambers, Stage iv.166; 105–109, 453–5). The Strange’s–Admiral’s “Amalgamation” The London activities of Strange’s Men and the Admiral’s Men in the late 1580s/ early 1590s have often been muddied by the belief that the two companies formed one “amalgamated” company during these years. This belief, first propounded by W.W. Greg18 and E.K. Chambers in the early twentieth century and repeated 17
The document which reveals Strange’s played briefly at Newington Butts is undated, and while many scholars believe it is from 1592, others have argued that it may belong to 1591 or 1594 (Foakes 283–5; Wickham, Berry and Ingram 328). 18 As noted below, Greg did not usually use the term “amalgamation,” but since he described the Strange’s–Admiral’s union in largely the same way as Chambers, and since subsequent scholars have adopted Chambers’ term, I occasionally use the term “amalgamation” in relation to Greg for the sake of convenience and economy of language.
Shakespeare’s Companies
68
by numerous scholars since that time,19 is an erroneous one that rests on faulty assumptions and inadequate evidence. It should be discounted as an unfortunate, although somewhat understandable, mistake. Andrew Gurr has forcefully argued against the “amalgamation” in Shakespearean Playing Companies and “The Chimera of Amalgamation,” but in spite of his well-reasoned arguments many scholars have continued to talk about the “amalgamation” as fact. Because scholars continue to accept the existence of the “amalgamation,” because Gurr does not deal with several items which support his case, because the existence (or lack thereof) of the “amalgamation” has several important implications for the history of Elizabethan theatre between 1588 and 1594, and because several arguments for Shakespeare’s company affiliation have been based in part on the existence of the “amalgamation,” it is necessary to outline the argument for the “amalgamation” and to provide the reasons why this argument does not withstand close scrutiny. The idea of an “amalgamation” between the Lord Admiral’s Men and Lord Strange’s Men received its first, and fullest, articulation in 1923 in E.K. Chambers’s The Elizabethan Stage. The idea that these two companies shared some sort of link was not new in 1923; as early as 1910, John Tucker Murray posited a “close connection” (i.62) between Strange’s and the Lord Admiral’s Men. It was, however, Chambers who first developed the hypothesis of an actual “amalgamation” between the two companies. Several years after this initial formulation, W.W. Greg endorsed the hypothesis in his 1931 Dramatic Documents from the Elizabethan Playhouses (volume i), although in 1908 he had already suggested the possibility of a “union” between the two companies (Henslowe’s Diary ii.71). The accounts given by Chambers and Greg of the “amalgamation” have yet to be superseded, at least among supporters of this theory. In The Elizabethan Stage, Chambers listed four primary reasons for suspecting a Strange’s–Admiral’s “amalgamation” between about 1588 and 1594: 1. During the court season of 1590–91, Privy Council records include warrants for two performances by the Lord Admiral’s Men on 27 December 1590 and 16 February 1591. However, the payments for these performances list “George Ottewell” as the payee, and his company is referred to as Strange’s Men (ii.120). 2. Several provincial notices between 1588 and 1594 appear to indicate joint performances of Strange’s and the Admiral’s Men: the two are listed together at Shrewsbury in 1592–93, and the Admiral’s and Derby’s are listed together at Ipswich on 7 August 1592 (although here something is amiss, since Strange’s did not become Derby’s Men until nearly two years later) (ii.120–21). 19
The list of scholars who have accepted the existence of a Strange’s–Admiral’s amalgamation includes: Alfred Harbage and S. Schoenbaum in 1964 (Annals 302), Mary Edmond in 1974 (9), G.M. Pinciss also in 1974 (134), Alexander Leggatt in 1975 (101), David George in 1981 (322), Charles Boyce in 1990 (4, 616), Andrew Gurr in 1992 (Shakespearian Stage 24–40), T.J. King also in 1992 (14, 27–32), W.R. Streitberger in 1997 (346–7), Mark C. Pilkinton in his Bristol volume for REED in 1997 (145), and Park Honan in 1998 (130–31).
London Playing, 1588–1594
69
3. Edward Alleyn, although one of Strange’s Men in 1592 and 1593, continued to wear the livery of the Lord Admiral, his previous company’s patron (ii.120). 4. Chambers’s last piece of evidence for the “amalgamation” is the so-called “plot” of The Second Part of the Seven Deadly Sins. This “plot” is a document, found among Edward Alleyn’s Dulwich papers, which provides an unusually complete list of the players performing The Second Part of the Seven Deadly Sins. While the document is undated and the company unnamed, many of the players listed are traceable in other documents. Based on what else is known of these players, Chambers and Greg concluded the “plot” must have belonged to the company that was playing at the Theatre in about 1591 or 1592, since Richard Burbage, son of the Theatre’s proprietor, is on the cast list. Many of the other players named on the “plot” were members of Strange’s Men in 1593, as attested to by a Privy Council license granted Strange’s Men in that year. Strange’s company is never recorded as having played at the Theatre, but if it “amalgamated” with the Admiral’s before the latter company left the Theatre in 1591, this would explain how Strange’s players could be named on a document for a performance at the Theatre (ii.125–6; Shakespeare i.48–52).20 Based on these four pieces of evidence, Chambers speculated that the “amalgamation” may have begun as early as 1588–89, most likely was in place by 1589–90 when “the residue of Strange’s” joined the Admiral’s at the Theatre, was “a fact by 1590–91, and lasted until 1594” (ii.120). Chambers figured the two companies performed together while in London (at the Theatre before 1592, the Rose thereafter) or at court, but split into their component companies for purposes of touring, as indicated by the continuing provincial notices of both a Strange’s and Admiral’s company, although they would join up on the road whenever convenient (ii.121). W.W. Greg largely agreed with these conjectures in Henslowe’s Diary and Dramatic Documents, but tended to avoid using the word “amalgamation.” He also contended that the “plot” of Seven Deadly Sins was from a performance by Strange’s Men only at the Theatre in about 1590, and he thought Strange’s was the “amalgamation’s” controlling company (Diary ii.71–2).21 Both Chambers and Greg were cautious in their initial descriptions of the “amalgamation,” but became more certain of themselves in later books and articles and, as often happens, allowed
20
Chambers, it should be noted, is hesitant to assign the “plot” to the “amalgamated” company; rather, he says that “it may have come into the possession of Strange’s or the Admiral’s or the combined company before ever they reached the Rose” (Stage ii.125). Elsewhere, however, he does seem to indicate that he believes the “plot” belonged to the “amalgamation,” though he never explicitly says so (Shakespeare i.50–52). 21 Chambers, elsewhere in The Elizabethan Stage, also suggests that Strange’s was the controlling interest in the “amalgamation” (ii.136–7); apparently Chambers himself did not seem to be able to decide entirely what the nature of the “amalgamation” was.
70
Shakespeare’s Companies
speculation to harden into fact.22 Later scholars, for the most part, have accepted these speculations as facts. In 1993 and 1996, however, Andrew Gurr revisited the “amalgamation” theory and concluded it had no merit. Gurr points out two main assumptions at work in the “amalgamation” theory which, besides playing a role in the formation of the theory, have been used to justify it: 1. the “amalgamation” was necessary in order for the large-cast plays23 of the late 1580’s and early 1590’s to be effectively staged in London (“Chimera” 85–7); and 2. in retaining two separate licenses, the “amalgamation” made touring easier, insofar as the company could break into its constituent parts, which was necessary since it was difficult to survive while on tour (86–7). Both of these underlying assumptions are highly problematic. First, at least four companies are known to have performed large-cast plays (Strange’s, the Admiral’s, Pembroke’s, and the Queen’s). Even if one were to argue that Strange’s and the Admiral’s performed their large-cast plays in combination, Pembroke’s and the Queen’s appear to have been capable of staging these plays by themselves. Moreover, most of the large-cast plays were performed by the Admiral’s Men by themselves after 1594, again suggesting an “amalgamation” was not necessary for the performance of these plays (85–6). Second, David Bradley raises strong arguments that call into question the idea companies deliberately pared themselves down for touring: (1) sizeable companies are known to have played in the provinces; (2) a London company that reduced its cast size to tour would have rendered its own playtexts that called for a full-size company useless, an action it is difficult to believe a company would have willingly, or regularly, taken; (3) at least one surviving text allegedly shortened for touring, Orlando Furioso, still requires a relatively large cast of sixteen (“Chimera” 86; Companies 42–3; Bradley 58–74). Moreover, Gurr observes, a single company keeping two licenses would have violated the licensing rules of the time. Since Strange’s and the Admiral’s were two of the best–known companies of the time, it is unlikely that such an illegal maneuver, in London itself, would go unnoticed. Authorities would be angry at the misuse of the licenses, and the company patrons
22 For instance, despite his uncertainty over the “amalgamation” in Stage, Chambers later states “It is difficult to resist the inference” that Strange’s and the Admiral’s were “amalgamated” and writes his chapter on London playing in the early 1590s with this as an operating assumption (Shakespeare i.27–56, especially 43 and 48–52). 23 Gurr regards the following as large-cast plays: The Wounds of Civil War; Edward I, II, III; I Henry VI; 2 Henry VI; The Contention; 3 Henry VI; The True Tragedy of Richard Duke of York; Sir Thomas More; Titus Andronicus; 2 Seven Deadly Sins; The True Tragedy of Richard III; The Famous Victories; Friar Bacon and Friar Bungay; The Massacre at Paris; and The Taming of the Shrew (Gurr, “Chimera” 88, Companies 59–60).
London Playing, 1588–1594
71
would likely be annoyed at the careless handling their names would receive under such an arrangement (“Chimera” 86–7). These arguments are directed at the reasons for, rather than the fact of, the “amalgamation,” but Gurr also objects to the theory on several factual counts: 1. The Seven Deadly Sins “plot,” Gurr argues, can and has been interpreted in different ways, all of which seem logically valid. Gurr offers Scott McMillin’s 1989 interpretation (“Building Stories”), which dates the “plot” to 1593 or 1594, as a viable alternative to that of Chambers (and Greg, for that matter). Gurr’s own analysis of the “plot,” it should be noted, is very similar to that of Greg. Recently, however, David Kathman has published a new, extremely thorough analysis of the “plot” which reaches very different, but arguably equally logically valid, conclusions from those of Chambers and Greg. Kathman observes that, because the “plot” was discovered amidst Edward Alleyn’s papers at Dulwich University, it is generally assumed the “plot” was made for a performance involving a playing company Alleyn belonged to, although Alleyn himself is not named on the “plot.” Because several other names on the “plot” were Strange’s Men in 1593, as was Alleyn, the general consensus has been that the company in question was Strange’s. Kathman demonstrates, however, that the history of other items in the Dulwich collection should prevent scholars from assuming Alleyn ever had contact with the “plot” (14–18). Eleven of the actors named on the “plot” can be identified elsewhere during the 1590s, but only two of them are otherwise known to have been acting as early as 1590 (19–26). If Alleyn is left out of the reckoning, virtually all of the players on the “plot”—including those in Strange’s Men in 1593—can be linked to the 1597–98 Chamberlain’s Men. Furthermore, if the “plot” is dated to 1597–98, the usual identifications for actors for whom only a first name is supplied on the “plot” are easier to corroborate than if the “plot” is dated to c. 1590 (26–9). Kathman’s analysis is as logical and rigorous as those of Greg, Chambers, Gurr, and McMillin, illustrating perfectly Gurr’s claim that the “plot” is kaleidoscopic in nature: shake the pieces one way, and one interpretation emerges; shake them again, and a different, equally valid interpretation emerges (“Chimera” 87–8). 2. Gurr argues that the 1590–91 court records discrepancy, in which the Admiral’s company is named on the Privy Council warrant but Strange’s company is named in the payment accounts, can be accounted for by confusion on the part of a record keeper, as had been assumed prior to Greg and Chambers (Companies 234, “Chimera” 87). We will consider several possibilities which satisfactorily explain such a mistake momentarily. 3. Gurr notes that after the 1590–91 court season, which allegedly was near the beginning of the “amalgamation” period, the company in question is always referred to as Strange’s in court records, official documents, and, most tellingly, in Henslowe’s Diary and correspondence, which also names Alleyn as a Strange’s player. Alleyn is sometimes singled out as an Admiral’s man, but the Admiral’s company does not appear in any London records between early 1591 and the summer of 1594 (“Chimera” 88).
72
Shakespeare’s Companies
4. If the company which played at the Rose in 1592–93 was, as Chambers claimed, a combination of Strange’s and the Admiral’s, then it is virtually inexplicable why neither Tamburlaine nor Dr. Faustus, two of the most successful plays of the late 1580s, both of which belonged to the Admiral’s, was performed during the Rose run. The best explanation for this circumstance is that the Admiral’s Men was not involved with the company at the Rose, despite Alleyn’s retention of the Admiral’s livery and the possible presence of one or two other former Admiral’s Men at the Rose (“Chimera” 90–91, Companies 237). 5. Gurr argues that the provincial records which Chambers cites for joint Strange’s– Admiral’s performances are not clear on whether two companies did, in fact, perform together. Instead, the relevant records may merely indicate that the two companies were in the same town at the same time (“Chimera” 90, Companies 235–6). Based on these observations, Gurr proposes the following analysis of the relationship between Strange’s and the Admiral’s. The Admiral’s, a major acting company in the late 1580s, underwent a change around 1590 or 1591 which resulted in Alleyn, and possibly others, leaving for Strange’s. Owing to some sort of personal allegiance, Alleyn opted to keep the Admiral’s livery, but this marked him as an Admiral’s servant, not a player in the Admiral’s Men. What was left of the Admiral’s Men went to the provinces and stayed there for the next several years. This company presumably retained Tamburlaine, Dr. Faustus, and possibly other Admiral’s plays that cannot be accounted for between 1591 and 1594. Strange’s, meanwhile, became the preeminent London playing company, playing first at the Theatre and then the Rose. When Strange’s disintegrated in the spring of 1594, Alleyn returned to a rejuvenated or reconstituted Admiral’s while many other former Strange’s players joined the Lord Chamberlain’s Men (“Chimera” 90–93). Beyond Gurr’s objections, there are four additional factors which further weaken the “amalgamation” hypothesis. 1. According to Chambers, the “amalgamation” was in place by about 1589 (Stage ii.120). If so, the activities of the Admiral’s and Strange’s Men between 1589 and 1594 ought to reflect similar modes of operation. This is the case between 1592 and 1594 when both companies appear frequently in the provinces, but this would have been the case whether or not they were “amalgamated,” as London plague closures forced all companies to tour during these years. Between 1589 and 1592, however, the itineraries of the two companies suggest very different operating styles (see the Appendix for the 1577–94 Admiral’s and Strange’s itineraries). Between 1589 and June of 1592, Strange’s Men gave only one recorded provincial performance (at Faversham in 1591–92) (REED, Kent 561). Five additional provincial performances took place during 1591–92, but four of these performances could have come after the 22 June 1592 plague closure of the Rose. This evidence suggests a company that was not interested in touring and remained in London as much as possible. The Admiral’s Men, by contrast,
London Playing, 1588–1594
73
appeared in the provinces at least twenty-two times between 1589 and 1592. Clearly, the Admiral’s company was more active in the provinces during these years than Strange’s Men. Why would two supposedly “amalgamated” companies behave so differently? 2. Two provincial performances by the Admiral’s Men seemingly violate Chambers’s contention that the two companies were united in London and at court, but divided on the road.24 a. The Admiral’s Men performed in Leicester on 19 December 1592 (REED, “Leicester” 78), while Strange’s performed at court on 27 December (Chambers, Stage iv.164 Astington, English 234). While it is true touring companies were remarkably mobile, it is odd that the Admiral’s would have ranged so far afield so close to the court season if an “amalgamated” company was needed to perform at court, even if plague closure prevented playing in London proper.25 Strange’s had been called to court six times the previous holiday season; if the Admiral’s Men was in partnership with Strange’s, it is hard to believe that the Admiral’s would have been so far away from London on 19 December. Strange’s does not display similar behavior: its latest recorded pre-court season performance took place in Oxford in early October (REED, Oxford 218). b. According to several sources, the Admiral’s Men played at Shrewsbury on 3 February 1592 (Chambers, Stage ii.120n; Gurr, Companies 254). Strange’s, however, played at court on 9 January and again on 6 February (Chambers, Stage iv.164; Astington, English 233). Quite apart from the difficulty in moving an entire company from Shrewsbury on 3 February to London in time to play at court on 6 February, one wonders why the Admiral’s was on tour at all in the midst of the court season, unless it hadn’t performed at court on 9 January and didn’t on 6 February. At least one source, however, lists the Admiral’s Shrewsbury performance as 3 February 1593 (REED, Shropshire 277).26 This date again conflicts with the “amalgamation” hypothesis, since Strange’s played at the Rose until 1 February 1593 (Foakes 20). As the Rose season ended due to plague closure, it is unlikely the “amalgamated” company was prepared to undertake a tour the next day; even if it was, it could not have covered the 150 miles in time to perform at Shrewsbury on 3 February. Still, 24 The following assumes that the dates of the performances concerned are more or less accurate, which is not always the case in records of provincial performances. 25 This assumes companies that believed they could be called on for command performances tried to play in or near London during the court season (Gurr, Playing Companies 19). Probably the strongest evidence backing up this assumption is the fact that, between 1594 and 1599, only two companies—the Admiral’s and the Chamberlain’s—were sanctioned to play in London, and during this period only they were called to perform at court. 26 It should be noted that if Somerset’s dating is correct, it means the Admiral’s visited Shrewsbury three times between 29 September 1592 and 29 September 1593, which is an unusually high number of (recorded) visits for a single year.
Shakespeare’s Companies
74
it is possible the 3 February date is not accurate, or that it refers to the date the record was made, rather than to the date of the Admiral’s visit. 3. Although Chambers speaks of other companies “amalgamating” from time to time, the six other possible London amalgamations between 1585 and 1603 provide no precedent for the sort of long-term “amalgamation” proposed for the Admiral’s and Strange’s Men. a. During the court season of 1585–86, the Lord Chamberlain’s and the Lord Admiral’s companies may have staged a joint court performance on 6 January 1586 (Chambers, Stage iv.161; Astington, English 231); the Admiral’s and the Chamberlain’s are also listed together at Dover on 12 June 1585 and Leicester during 1585–86 (REED, Kent 477; REED, “Leicester” 65). In absence of any further evidence about these three performances, it is impossible to say if they were joint or if both companies performed separately on the same dates. Even if the two companies did play jointly on all three occasions, such a six-month amalgamation (June 1585–January 1586) hardly provides precedent for the three-to-five year “amalgamation.”27 b. Henslowe’s Diary records that the Queen’s and Sussex’s Men performed “to geather” at the Rose between 1 and 8 April 1594 (Foakes 21). During this short season, five plays were performed: Friar Bacon and Friar Bungay (1 and 5 April), The Ranger’s Comedy (2 April), The Jew of Malta (3 and 7 April), The Fair Maid of Italy (4 April), and King Leir (6 and 8 April). Of these, Friar Bacon and King Leir were Queen’s plays and Fair Maid was Sussex’s. Sussex’s had also played Jew during its 27 December 1593–96 February 1594 Rose season, but this play was also performed by every company which performed at the Rose during the 1590s. The Ranger’s Comedy would subsequently appear in the Admiral’s Rose repertory. It is once again unclear if the companies played jointly or separately on different days, although the phrase “to geather” may mitigate toward joint performances. If the two companies were amalgamated, it was only for a week, again hardly a precedent for a three-to-five year Strange’s–Admiral’s “amalgamation.” c. Henslowe’s Diary records a run from 3 to 13 June at Newington Butts which featured both the Lord Chamberlain’s and Lord Admiral’s companies (Foakes 21–2). Yet again, it is unclear if the companies played jointly or separately on different days. Of the seven plays performed during this run, three were almost certainly Lord Chamberlain’s plays (Titus Andronicus, The Taming of A Shrew, Hamlet) and a fourth (Hester and Ahasuerus) probably was, while three (Cutlack, Belin Dun, and The Jew of Malta) subsequently appear in Henslowe’s Diary as Admiral’s plays performed at the Rose (Foakes 21–2; 27
It should also be noted that during the course of 1585 Charles Howard held both the office of Lord Chamberlain (until July) and Lord Admiral (after 8 July), at least raising the possibility that the records referring to seemingly joint Admiral’s-Chamberlain’s performances in 1585–86 do not refer to two companies playing jointly, but to one company listed under both of its patron’s recent offices.
London Playing, 1588–1594
75
Gurr, Companies 279–80). Henslowe’s records do not yield any intelligible pattern of alteration between the repertories of the two companies; if this signals they were playing jointly, though, this arrangement was hardly anything like the long-term “amalgamation” envisioned by Chambers and Greg. d. The title page of the 1594 quarto of Titus Andronicus announces it was played “by the Right Honourable the Earle of Darbie, Earle of Pembroke, and the Earle of Sussex their Seruantes.” It is presumed that the reference to “Darbie” should actually read “Strange’s,” which was Derby’s by 1594 (but unlikely to have ever had access to Titus Andronicus once the name change occurred). Most scholars interpret the list of companies on the title-page as a catalog of successive companies that performed the play, beginning with Strange’s, then Pembroke’s, followed by Sussex’s. A later edition of the play adds the Lord Chamberlain’s to the list, bolstering this interpretation (Gurr, “Reluctant” 158). Some scholars, however, have argued that the title page lists a combined company which performed the play (George 316–17). Even if one accepts the unlikely argument the three companies played jointly, this amalgamation would have been brief—perhaps only a single performance— and as such provides no precedent for the supposed Strange’s–Admiral’s “amalgamation.”28 e. The Admiral’s Men and Pembroke’s Men may have amalgamated during 1597–98. Daily entries of Admiral’s performances in Henslowe’s Diary abruptly stop during February 1597, about the time several Admiral’s actors (Richard Jones and Thomas Downton, at least) left the Rose to join Pembroke’s Men, the resident company at Francis Langley’s Swan playhouse (Gurr, Companies 239). The Swan venture ended in late July 1597 (Shakespearian Stage 108), and Jones and Downton subsequently reappear in Henslowe’s Diary (on 6 August and 6 October, respectively). At least three actors who had been attached to Pembroke’s Men also appear in the Diary at roughly the same time (Robert Shaw on 6 August 1597, William Borne alias Bird on 10 August 1597, and Gabriel Spencer by 25 March 1598) (Chambers Stage iv.152–3). Henslowe resumed keeping daily records of Rose receipts on 11 October 1597 under the heading “my lord admirals & my lord of penbrockes men” (Foakes 60). There are no indications of separate accounts for the two companies, and a few entries for purchases Henslowe made for the players list both companies as recipients (Greg, Diary ii.91–2). References to both the Admiral’s and Pembroke’s Men continue in the Diary until 5 November 1597, but thereafter entries again refer only to the Admiral’s, although a list of receipts begun on 21 October 1597 and running until 4 March 1598 lists both companies in the heading (Foakes 71–3). On 27 December 1597, the Admiral’s appeared at court with no other company named, as it did on 28 February 1598 28
More will be said about George’s theory in Chapter 8.
76
Shakespeare’s Companies
(Gurr, Companies 253). Since the names of actors known to have been Pembroke’s Men at the Swan continue to appear in the Diary after 27 December, it would seem the union of Pembroke’s and the Admiral’s was so thorough there was no longer any reason to use two names for the same company. The nature of the Admiral’s-Pembroke’s union is complicated by two factors, however. First, a Pembroke’s company played at Bristol twice between 28 August and 10 September 1597, just after the closure of the Swan (REED, Bristol 150). Second, a Pembroke’s Men appears in the provinces in 1598–99 (Greg, Diary ii.91–2). These records suggest that not all of Pembroke’s Men took up playing at the Rose. This situation is problematic because if one Pembroke’s company was on tour while another was at the Rose, this would have been a violation of the law restricting the use of a patron’s name to a single company. Legal issues aside, records of a provincial Pembroke’s Men raises questions as to whether the Pembroke’s that unified with the Admiral’s at the Rose was a full-size company or just a few players unable or unwilling to remain with their fellows who went to the provinces. Whatever the case, the union of Pembroke’s and the Admiral’s once again seems to have been brief—roughly 11 October until 8 December 1597—and as such a weak precedent for the long-term Admiral’s-Strange’s “amalgamation.” f. A Privy Council order dated 31 March 1602 officially recognized a combined Oxford’s/Worcester’s Men, “joyned by agrement togeather in on Companie,” as the third company sanctioned to play in London, along with the Admiral’s and Chamberlain’s Men (Gurr, Companies 318–19; Wickham, Berry and Ingram 109–10). How and why the two companies had joined forces is not clear; the Privy Council order itself was apparently written by the Earl of Worcester, leading Gurr to speculate that Worcester himself enforced the merger (Companies 319). Although this “amalgamation” apparently became permanent, it did so only under Worcester’s name, and never split into its component parts while touring. Moreover, it seems that this merger was a governmental imposition, rather than a combination of convenience, such as the Strange’s–Admiral’s “amalgamation” supposedly was. 4. Finally, the known personnel of Strange’s Men (as listed in a 1593 document— Wickham, Berry, and Ingram 191–2) do not include any players, with the exception of Edward Alleyn, who belonged to the Admiral’s Men before 1594. The known pre-1594 Admiral’s players are Edward Alleyn, James Tunstall, Richard Jones, probably Robert Browne, possibly John Bradstreet and Thomas Sackville, and perhaps Edward Alleyn’s brother John, who may or may not have been a player (Nungezer 11–12; Chambers, Stage ii.137–9, 298–9; Gurr, Companies 234). Each of these individuals appears in documents from the same period as the “amalgamation’s” supposed existence, but only Edward Alleyn can be connected to Strange’s Men. Thomas Downton, like Alleyn, moved from Strange’s to the Admiral’s Men in 1594, but there is no evidence to connect him to the Admiral’s Men before 1594 (Gurr, Companies 237; Foakes 282–3).
London Playing, 1588–1594
77
The balance of the evidence, then, is clearly against the existence of any Strange’s– Admiral’s “amalgamation,” unless the transfer of a player from one company to the other constitutes an amalgamation. This, however, would be like saying that Manchester United amalgamated with Real Madrid when David Beckham switched teams, or that the Boston Red Sox amalgamated with the New York Yankees when Babe Ruth switched teams. Of course, the initial “problem” which resulted in the “amalgamation” theory still exists: the 1590–91 court records which list the Admiral’s as performers and Strange’s as payees. This may be a simple mistake in the records, but there may be other ways to account for it which involve Alleyn’s transfer from the Admiral’s to Strange’s. We will return to this issue presently. The Admiral’s, Strange’s, and The Theatre, 1591 Discarding the misconceived Admiral’s-Strange’s “amalgamation” hypothesis in turn allows misconceptions about an alleged Edward Alleyn-James Burbage quarrel at the Theatre in late 1590 or early 1591 to be cleared up. As the story is usually narrated, Edward Alleyn and his company played at the Theatre in 1590–91. At the time, James Burbage and his sons were involved in a lawsuit by Margaret Brayne, John Brayne’s widow. One afternoon, Margaret Brayne and several of her supporters came to the Theatre in an effort to collect the money she believed she was owed. They encountered a hostile James Burbage. Several members of Alleyn’s company intervened on Brayne’s behalf, making Burbage more belligerent. Several days later, the players were involved in another altercation with the elder Burbage; as a result, they left the Theatre and took up residence at the Rose in 1592. This narrative, which C.W. Wallace (19–21) derived from legal documents, has been repeated by various scholars, including Chambers (Stage ii.120), Greg (Dramatic Documents i.13, 17, 100–111), and Gurr (Companies 71, 259–62, 270, 274). Each of these scholars has supposed the company in question was either the Strange’s–Admiral’s “amalgamation” (Chambers and Greg) or Strange’s Men alone (Gurr and others).29 Setting aside the “amalgamation” seemingly leaves Strange’s Men as the company at the Theatre, but careful reconsideration of the documents involved reveals 1) Strange’s was not the company at the Theatre; 2) the company at the Theatre did not necessarily leave after the fight with Burbage; and 3) Edward Alleyn may not have even been involved in these events.30 The narrative of the Burbage-Alleyn quarrel is based on two court depositions given by John Alleyn, Edward’s brother, in 1592 concerning the hostile encounter between the Burbages and Margaret Brayne. The first deposition, filed 6 February 29
C.W. Wallace lists the Admiral’s Men as the company involved in the Burbage quarrel, but he believes the Admiral’s, Strange’s, Pembroke’s, and Sussex’s Men were basically one company, so he, too, essentially favors the “amalgamation” (21). 30 Roslyn Lander Knutson, in Playing Companies and Commerce in Shakespeare’s Time, has already questioned the Burbage-Alleyn quarrel narrative, not on factual bases, but to combat the assumption that the history of playing companies can be boiled down to competition based on personal quarrels (1–20).
Shakespeare’s Companies
78
1592, describes John Alleyn as a 35-year-old innholder familiar with the parties involved in the case. Alleyn, describing himself as “a servaunt withe” James Burbage, relates that he was at the Theatre when Margaret Brayne and Richard Miles, her ally, confronted the elder Burbage, who responded by driving Brayne and Miles out “wt vyolence.” Alleyn describes how he then tried, to no avail, to persuade Burbage to come to terms with Brayne. According to Alleyn, after eight days he came to the Theatre to collect money Burbage owed Alleyn “and his fellowes,” but that Burbage refused to pay. Alleyn accused Burbage of dealing with him the same way he was dealing with Brayne, and threatened to “compleyne to ther lorde & Mr. the lord Admyrall.” At this, Burbage flew into a rage; Alleyn does not comment on what the outcome of this confrontation was (Wallace 98–102). In Alleyn’s second deposition, dated 6 May 1592, he said that the incidents recorded in his first deposition had occurred “about A yere past” and that James Tunstall and others had been present when Alleyn attempted to collect the money from Burbage. In responding to a peripheral question, Alleyn also mentions that, although he never saw James Burbage deliver payments owed to Henry Lanman, owner of the Curtain, before the death of John Brayne, he had seen Burbage deliver such payments since Brayne’s 1586 death (124–7). Alleyn’s depositions reveal key information about events at the Theatre in 1590–91. Firstly, his testimony dates the incidents reported therein to about May 1591. Secondly, he clearly indicates that the company playing at the Theatre at that time was the Admiral’s Men; James Tunstall, an actor, presumably was among the company’s members at that time. John Alleyn himself apparently was involved with the Admiral’s in some capacity, as he refers to the players as his “fellowes,” but he does not indicate that he himself was a player. Finally, Alleyn’s discussion of Burbage’s payments to Lanman before and after John Brayne’s death seems to indicate that Alleyn, at least, had been involved with Burbage for some time; this in turn suggests that the Admiral’s Men had also acted at the Theatre for some time before 1591, as Brayne had died in 1586. Alleyn’s depositions do not, however, make any mention of Edward Alleyn, Strange’s Men, or any playing company leaving the Theatre as a result of Burbage’s tantrums. In other words, the available evidence does not support any of the key points of the usual narrative, save that there was a quarrel at the Theatre in 1591. How, then, did Edward Alleyn, Strange’s Men, and the departure of a playing company become part of this tale? The answer is likely the Seven Deadly Sins “plot.” Again, this plot is often dated to 1590–91; as Richard Burbage is named on it, the Theatre has been assumed as the likely venue for the performance. Because Burbage is not listed as “Mr.,” it has been assumed he was younger, and not a sharer, in the performing company; scholars have therefore assumed the “plot” belonged to a pre-1594 company (Greg, Dramatic Documents i.20, 86, 118; Chambers, Stage ii.125–6; Gurr, Companies 71).31 Because other names on the “plot” are known to have been Strange’s Men in 1593, the performing company is assumed to have been Strange’s (Greg, Dramatic Documents i.19, 21; Gurr, Companies 60, 71, 261). Thus, Strange’s must have been 31
David Kathman has also questioned this assumption (20–21).
London Playing, 1588–1594
79
at the Theatre in the early 1590s. But Henslowe’s Diary records that Strange’s played at the Rose by early 1592, so it must have left the Theatre at some point. And when better to leave than after a fight with James Burbage? Because Edward Alleyn was a leading Strange’s player in 1592–93, and because his brother was in the thick of the altercations at the Theatre in 1591, it has been further assumed Edward must have been involved in these altercations. If all these assumptions are joined together, one can arrive at the narrative of Edward Alleyn quarreling with James Burbage and leading Strange’s away from the Theatre. But all these assumptions depend on dating the Seven Deadly Sins “plot” to 1590–91, and we have already seen there is reason to doubt this dating; Kathman in particular has made a strong case for dating the “plot” to 1597–98 (14). If the undated and contentious “plot” is set aside and John Alleyn’s eyewitness testimony alone is relied on for determining the course of events, Strange’s Men is nowhere to be found. If any company left the Theatre in 1591, it was the Admiral’s Men, and at any rate John Alleyn has nothing to say about the results of his altercation with James Burbage. Finally, apart from John Alleyn’s presence at the Theatre, nothing else suggests Edward Alleyn had any part in these events. Indeed, one would think if Edward had been involved in these events, his own brother would have mentioned him. By discarding the “amalgamation” hypothesis and relying on John Alleyn’s testimony rather than assumptions generated by a questionable dating of the 2 Seven Deadly Sins “plot,” it is possible to outline the London activities of Strange’s and the Admiral’s in the late 1580s and early 1590s. The Admiral’s clearly played at the Theatre in 1591 and perhaps had done so for several years before. No direct evidence survives to support this conjecture, but the Admiral’s frequently played at court during the mid-to-late 1580s and is known to have played in London in 1587 and 1589. In any case, the Admiral’s was playing at the Theatre by late 1590 or early 1591 and remained there until at least May 1591. After this, the Admiral’s left London altogether and spent several years exclusively in the provinces.32 Strained relations with James Burbage may have precipitated the departure, but this is not certain. Strange’s also likely played in London between 1589 and 1592, although its exact venue is unknown, save for the 1589 performance at the Cross Keys in defiance of a mayoral order (Wickham, Berry and Ingram 302). Strange’s was not, as is often supposed, at the Theatre. It may even be that Strange’s played at the Rose before Henslowe began keeping daily records. The Rose had, after all, been built in 1587; presumably some company or other used it from time to time before the 1592 remodeling. The Admiral’s, Strange’s, and the Alleyns, 1589–1591 The one unresolved issue in the Strange’s–Admiral’s story is why the two companies were confused in court records during 1590–91. Perhaps this was a flat out mistake, 32
Some Admiral’s players also toured the continent (Chambers, Stage ii.273–7; Gurr, Companies 234–6; Schrickx 114–31, 184–219).
Shakespeare’s Companies
80
but as this confusion corresponds roughly to Edward Alleyn’s transfer from the Admiral’s to Strange’s Men, there could be another explanation. For instance, Alleyn may have switched companies just before the court season; perhaps the Queen wanted to see Alleyn perform, so she summoned his company. Until recently, this had been the Admiral’s, and he still wore the Admiral’s livery, so the warrant may have been made out to the Admiral’s for any or all of these reasons. But Alleyn’s company was now Strange’s Men, so it, led by Alleyn, performed and was paid accordingly. It seems as though the payment records are more likely to be correct anyway, since money actually changed hands, whereas no such exchange took place when a warrant was issued. Yet other documents complicate this version of events. John Alleyn’s court depositions, for instance, identify him as a fellow of the Admiral’s Men in May 1591, meaning the Alleyn brothers at this point would have been involved with different companies if Edward already was with Strange’s Men. But other records indicate the brothers worked together on certain theatrical matters: 1. A 3 January 1589 document reveals John and Edward bought Richard Jones’s share in an unnamed company, in which Robert Browne was a sharer. Jones, Browne, and Edward Alleyn were Worcester’s Men in the early 1580s, but as Worcester’s is not traceable after 1585,33 the company in question seems to be the Admiral’s Men. The Admiral’s emergence (c. 1585) corresponds to Worcester’s disappearance, and John Alleyn was associated with the Admiral’s in 1590–91; moreover, Browne and Jones would tour the continent in the early 1590s under a passport from the Admiral. While it remains possible that another company’s internal changes are recorded in this document, the Admiral’s Men is probably the company in question (Foakes 273–4; Chambers, Stage ii.137–8). 2. A 23 November 1590 deed shows John alone buying what appears to be theatrical apparel; James Tunstall is a witness (Alleyn Papers 11–12). 3. A 6 May 1591 deed shows John and Edward buying theatrical apparel, with Tunstall again the witness (Alleyn Papers 12–13). 4. A document from 25 July 1591 records John and Edward’s acknowledgment that they were in debt (Alleyn Papers 14–15). The first of these documents was once the matter of some contention, as various scholars were unable to agree upon what company was involved.34 The general consensus now is that it is the Admiral’s, and that Edward and John were buying out Richard Jones’s share in the company as he prepared to depart for a European tour with Robert Browne (Gurr, Companies 232–3). Whatever the case, this document does not interfere with the premise that Alleyn left the Admiral’s for Strange’s in late 1590 or thereabouts. Edward does not appear in the second of these documents, so 33
A new, seemingly unconnected Worcester’s appears in 1589. Greg argued Alleyn was buying out other Worcester’s sharers on behalf of the Admiral’s; Frederick Fleay, along the same lines, believed Alleyn was buying out Worcester’s on behalf of Strange’s. Chambers asserted that the documents were evidence of some internal reorganization of the Admiral’s (Chambers, Stage ii.137–9; Greg, Diary ii.70, 83; Fleay 82–3). 34
London Playing, 1588–1594
81
this document also does not challenge the assumption Edward left the Admiral’s for Strange’s at about this time. The fourth document shows that two brothers were in debt; even if a theatrical debt, family members helping each other out, even possibly across acting company lines, and as a result going into debt together, is hardly a surprising occurrence.35 The third document, however, does present difficulties, if one assumes that Edward was a member of Strange’s by late 1590, that he exclusively dealt with Strange’s Men after that date, and that John exclusively dealt with the Admiral’s Men. James Tunstall is the complicating figure in this document. He was, according to John’s court deposition, an Admiral’s player in May 1591, so it seems odd that he would witness a deed of sale for an actor belonging to a different company. It also seems odd that John and Edward would jointly buy theatrical apparel when belonging to different companies. This, however, assumes that their companies were in fact competitors, which they may not have been. The belief the London theatre world was one of cutthroat competition has been increasingly challenged, especially by Roslyn Lander Knutson (Playing Companies 1–20). It may be that the Alleyn documents provide evidence of different companies cooperating. Then again, these documents may also be evidence that the Alleyns and Tunstall were still in the same company in May 1591 and Edward Alleyn joined Strange’s after that date, in which case his transfer from the Admiral’s to Strange’s does not explain the confusion in the 1590–91 court documents.36 So while it is possible to untangle the confusion surrounding the “amalgamation” and the events at the Theatre in 1590–91, it may not be as easy to untangle Edward Alleyn’s movements before 1592. Pembroke’s Men By 1592, Strange’s Men occupied the Rose. The Admiral’s seems to have left London by about this time. The Queen’s Men perhaps still played in London, but if it did, no evidence of its presence survives, apart from scattered court performances. With no other strong companies in London besides Strange’s, the time was ripe for a new company to try its London fortunes. Accordingly, in 1592 notices of a company 35
For example, on 8 May 1593 Philip Henslowe lent his nephew Francis £15 to buy a share in the Queen’s Men and lent him a further £9 on 1 June 1595 to buy an additional half share “wth the company wch he dothe play wth,” presumably still the Queen’s (Foakes 7, 9). At the time of the first loan, the Rose was between companies; Strange’s had left in February due to plague closure, and Sussex’s would play there in December. At the time of the second loan, the Admiral’s was playing at the Rose. Thus, in the second instance, Philip was helping a family member associated with a company that may have even been associated with the rival Swan Theatre (Ingram, London Life 115–20; McMillin and MacLean 51; Knutson, Playing Companies 61–2, 67). 36 There is at least one other example of one company being called to court and another delivering the performance: on 11 February 1578 Leicester’s Men was summoned to court but the Countess of Essex’s actually performed (Chambers, Stage iv.153).
82
Shakespeare’s Companies
called Pembroke’s Men begin to appear. The company’s patron was Henry Herbert, who became the Earl of Pembroke in 1570 and the Lord President of Wales in 1586 (Chambers, Stage ii.128). Pembroke’s Men played at court twice during the 1592– 93 court season (iv.164; Astington, English 234), which suggests Pembroke’s was operating in London. No further evidence, though, attests to its London activities. Of course, only records of theatrical activity at the Rose survive for these years. Because Pembroke’s began its short life just as London theatre was falling prey to long plague closures, most of the rest of the available information about Pembroke’s Men comes from provincial records. This, coupled with the fact that several plays apparently in Pembroke’s repertory are seemingly abridged, has led many scholars to suppose Pembroke’s was exclusively a provincial company (Chambers, Stage ii.129; Pinciss 134; Edmond 130; and George 307, among others). But this was not the case. On the one hand, the fact Pembroke’s played twice at court in 1592–93 strongly suggests it was playing in London at the time; on the other hand, a 1593 letter from Philip Henslowe to Edward Alleyn mentions that Pembroke’s players, after a difficult tour, were “at home” in London (Foakes 280–82). This is the last we hear of the company in London before 1597, when a reconstituted Pembroke’s briefly played at the Swan. Beyond these few facts, little of certainty can be said concerning Pembroke’s London career. The various speculations about the nature and personnel of this company will be taken up in Chapter 7. Sussex’s Men Strange’s Men played at the Rose between February and June of 1592, and then again between December 1592 and February 1593. Strange’s leading player, Edward Alleyn, was Philip Henslowe’s son-in-law, and the two remained in close contact during Strange’s 1593 tour. It is therefore surprising to discover that, when the Rose reopened on 26 December 1593, Sussex’s Men, not Strange’s, took up residence there (Foakes 20–21). Sussex’s patron was Henry Radcliffe, Earl of Sussex since 1583 (Chambers, Stage ii.92). Sussex’s Rose repertory is completely different from that of Strange’s in 1592 and 1593, and Strange’s continued to play in the provinces after late 1593, so Sussex’s does not appear to have been a reconstituted Strange’s under a new patron. Sussex’s may, in fact, have played in London before its sudden appearance at the Rose, as it performed at court on 2 January 1592 (iv.164; Astington, English 233). Moreover, on 29 April 1593 the Privy Council issued “an open warrant for the plaiers, servantes of the Erle of Sussex, authorysinge them to exercyse theire qualitie of playinge comedies and tragedies in any county, cittie, towne or corporacion” more than seven miles from London (Chambers, Stage ii.94). Strange’s Men, decidedly a company with London connections, was issued a similar warrant a week later (6 May) which explicitly indicates the warrant was being issued to a London company that wanted to guarantee smooth provincial travel (Wickham, Berry and Ingram 191–2; Chambers, Stage ii.123). In any event, why Sussex’s Men replaced Strange’s at the Rose in December 1593 remains a mystery. Perhaps Sussex’s was near London when the inhibition on
London Playing, 1588–1594
83
playing was lifted and Henslowe, needing to reopen the Rose as soon as possible, could not wait for his son-in-law’s company to return. Perhaps a personnel shift took place in the fall of 1593, making Sussex’s a more attractive company than Strange’s/ Derby’s; for example, maybe popular ex-Pembroke’s Men had joined Sussex’s and brought successful plays, such as Titus Andronicus, with them, which Sussex’s then played to great acclaim at the Rose (Foakes 21). Or perhaps Edward Alleyn had again switched companies. This, however, is pure speculation.37 In any case, Sussex’s played at the Rose from 26 December 1593 until 6 February 1594, when plague again stalled London playing (Foakes 20–21; Gurr, Companies 91). Playing resumed on 1 April, and Sussex’s again performed at the Rose, but this time with the Queen’s Men; Henslowe records the two companies played “to geather” (Foakes 21), although it is not clear if this refers to joint playing or simply two companies performing at the same playhouse on different days. These two companies had briefly toured together in 1590–91, but why they now combined forces again is a matter of speculation.38 It may have been a matter of necessity. Playing companies certainly faced great difficulties because of the plague closures of the early 1590s; perhaps this Sussex’s-Queen’s alliance was one way of facing the challenging theatrical conditions during these years. It may also be that Henslowe had family connections to the Queen’s Men; in 1593 he lent his nephew Francis money to buy a share in the Queen’s Men, and two years later lent Francis money to buy a half share in a company that was almost certainly the Queen’s again (Foakes 7, 9). Perhaps Francis had persuaded his uncle to help his company out in April 1594. Whatever the case, the Sussex’s-Queen’s arrangement lasted only until 9 April 1594 (Foakes 21). After this, Sussex’s Men disappears for good. *** When Henslowe resumed his daily records on 14 May 1594, the Admiral’s company was playing at the Rose. After three performances, the records again stop. The next daily entries, beginning 3 June 1594 and lasting until 13 June, are for the Chamberlain’s and Admiral’s Men at Newington Butts. On 15 June, the Admiral’s returned to the Rose and would remain there for the next number of years, while the Chamberlain’s took up residence at the Theatre (Foakes 21–2). This would remain the legally sanctioned London playing arrangement for the remainder of the sixteenth 37
For a more developed consideration of Sussex’s connection to Titus Andronicus, The Jew of Malta, and Edward Alleyn, see Chapter 8 as well as Scott McMillin’s “Sussex’s Men in 1594.” 38 It may be misleading to characterize this 1594 association as a continuation of the 1590– 91 one. In 1590–91, Sussex’s clearly was touring with Laneham’s branch of the Queen’s Men; the Queen’s company that joined Sussex’s at the Rose may have been the Duttons’ branch, or else a combination of Laneham’s and the Duttons’ personnel. See the following chapters on the Queen’s Men (Chapter 5) and Sussex’s Men (Chapter 8) for more on this point.
84
Shakespeare’s Companies
century, although several other companies would attempt London incursions in the following years. With the establishment of this “duopoly,” the first, unstable phase of London-based playing companies comes to an end and the second, much more stable phase begins. Frustratingly, few statements about playing companies in London between 1588–94 can be made with absolute certainty, but many tantalizing hints survive which allow us to form the foregoing picture, murky as it is, of the events of these years. It is, in any case, within this volatile context of plague closures, restless players, and rapidly rising and falling acting companies that William Shakespeare gained entrance to the London theatre world and embarked on his playwriting career. Having now established an outline for Shakespeare’s Stratford and pre-Chamberlain’s London life, as well as the provincial and London playing contexts he would have found himself in, it is at last possible to turn to the various arguments for Shakespeare’s pre-Chamberlain’s company membership.
PART 3 Shakespeare and the Companies Introductory Note
Each of the next four chapters deals in detail with arguments that have been put forward over the years for which playing company (or companies) Shakespeare belonged to before his emergence as a Lord Chamberlain’s player in 1594. Each chapter is divided into two sections. The first section of each chapter traces the history of the company in question, focusing particularly on the years when Shakespeare might have joined that company. The second section of each chapter surveys reasons scholars have given for thinking Shakespeare was in that particular company and provides a running commentary on the strengths and weaknesses of these arguments. Again, it is not my intention to demonstrate that one of these arguments is the “best” or “right” argument, but rather to show the variety of scholarly hypotheses on this issue that have accumulated over the years and to consider the ways in which the history of this controversy opens onto other scholarly issues of equal, or greater, importance to the overall history of Elizabethan theatre. To that end, I have attempted to avoid an organization that privileges one argument or another. These chapters do not move from strongest to weakest or vice versa. Instead, I have elected to use a roughly chronological sequence of the scholarship on both Shakespeare and the history of Elizabethan theatre. Thus, since Malone proposed Shakespeare might have been in the Queen’s Men, I begin with chapter on this company before moving on to Strange’s Men, Pembroke’s Men and Sussex’s Men. Following these four chapters, I examine the currently popular proposition that Shakespeare went to Lancashire as a teenager, possibly acting under the patronage of Alexander Hoghton and Thomas Hesketh. A final chapter is dedicated to examining the argument for Shakespeare’s membership in Leicester’s Men, which I use a springboard to discussing arguments for Shakespeare’s presence in Essex’s, Worcester’s, Warwick’s, Oxford’s, and the Admiral’s Men, all of which have relatively little evidence to support them. Over the course of these chapters, I intend to provide not only a comprehensive examination of the amazing variety of biographical conjectures on Shakespeare’s early professional life, but also an examination of what we now know about each of these theatre companies of the 1580s and 1590s. Moreover, I offer a historiographical critique of the scholarship surrounding Shakespeare’s early theatrical affiliations. This body of scholarship has often been inconsistent, contradictory, and not as rigorous as it might be. Indeed, each argument for Shakespeare’s early playing company membership runs up against significant difficulties. But in examining
86
Shakespeare’s Companies
these difficulties, it becomes evident that the search for Shakespeare’s “lost years” or pre-Chamberlain’s playing company is not an end in and of itself, but a touchstone for a number of issues pertaining to biography, Elizabethan theatre history, and historiography. In this regard, Shakespeare is the beginning, rather than the end, of this study.
Chapter 5
The Queen’s Men
In Will in the World: How Shakespeare Became Shakespeare (2004), Stephen Greenblatt joins the speculation on Shakespeare’s first acting company. He asserts that “The most intriguing possibility that scholars have explored in recent years concerns the Queen’s Men” (162). Greenblatt is partially correct in this statement. There have indeed been a number of recent attempts to demonstrate the likelihood, or at least possibility, that Shakespeare was once a Queen’s man: Eric Sams’s The Real Shakespeare (1995), Scott McMillin and Sally-Beth MacLean’s seventh chapter of their book The Queen’s Men and Their Plays (1998), and Katherine DuncanJones’s Ungentle Shakespeare (2001). Less recently, G.K. Pinciss, writing in the 1960s and 1970s, and A.W. Pollard, writing in the 1930s, similarly proposed the Queen’s Men as Shakespeare’s first company. The notion that Shakespeare might have been a Queen’s player, however, reaches back further still, to none other than Edmond Malone, the first of Shakespeare’s great biographers. But before turning to the possibility that Shakespeare was once among the Queen’s Men, it is necessary to give an account of the history of the Queen’s Men. The Queen’s Men Scott McMillin and Sally-Beth MacLean’s The Queen’s Men and Their Plays (1998) stands as the most thorough study of the history, repertoire, personnel, and organization of the Queen’s Men. Because McMillin and MacLean so effectively lay out the story of the Queen’s Men, it is not necessary to go into great detail concerning the company’s history here. The Queen’s Men was formed in March 1583, when Sir Francis Walsingham, in effect the secretary of state, authorized Edmund Tilney, the Master of the Revels, to bring the best players at the time into a single, large company (Chambers, Stage ii.104; McMillin and MacLean 24–5). McMillin and MacLean, noting Walsingham’s involvement, suggest court politics and national policy contributed to the Queen’s formation. First, a royal company regularly called to perform at court could have reduced infighting amongst Privy Councilors who used court performances by their playing companies to demonstrate—or improve— their standing with Elizabeth (26). Second, the Queen and Privy Council may have seen a traveling royal company as a way to unify the religiously and political divided England of the early 1580s, as “a travelling company of Queen’s Men would not only carry the name and the influence of the monarch through the country, but would also give the impression of a watchful monarch, one whose ‘men’ ranged over the land” (28). Moreover, in demonstrating the Queen’s support for theatre, the Queen’s Men
Shakespeare’s Companies
88
blunted radical Protestant attacks on the theatre, thereby keeping this potentially dangerous group at bay.1 Accordingly, the Queen’s company served as cultural ambassador, as part of the government’s intelligence network, and as a weapon in the emergent cultural, social, political, and religious disputes in the 1570s and 1580s (28–32). Gurr, by contrast, says nothing about the Queen’s Men’s potential as cultural ambassadors. Instead, he focuses on “more local and immediate concerns” (Companies 196). Specifically, he follows Barroll (“Drama and the Court”) and an earlier McMillin article (“The Queen’s Men and the London Theatre of 1583”) by emphasizing the usefulness of the Queen’s Men in diffusing the aforementioned rivalries between great lords played out through their playing companies. Gurr also suggests the formation of the Queen’s Men guaranteed the safety of leading players of the day from hostile civic leaders, which in turn ensured the availability of Christmas entertainment for the Queen. Gurr also suggests that the Queen’s Men was an innovation not of Walsingham’s, but of Charles Howard, later Lord Admiral, with the assistance of Tilney, Howard’s cousin (Companies 196–8). Regardless of who masterminded the formation of the Queen’s Men and his or her motivations, the company was active by the summer of 1583. A late 1583 City of London record lists the original twelve members as John Adams, John Bentley, Lionel Cooke, John Dutton, John Garland, William Johnson, John Laneham, Tobias Mylles, John Singer, Richard Tarlton, John Towne, and Robert Wilson (Chambers, Stage ii.106). Johnson, Laneham and Wilson were former Leicester’s Men; Adams and Tarlton came from Sussex’s; and Dutton formerly led Oxford’s players (Gurr, Companies 200–201). The other six are not traceable before 1583, but they presumably were leading players in one of these or other prominent companies, such as Derby’s or Hunsdon’s Men, both of which played at court during the 1582–83 season (201). After an initial provincial tour, the Queen’s was granted permission in November 1583 to play at the Bull and Bell inns on Wednesdays and Saturdays until Shrovetide 1584 (Wickham, Berry and Ingram 300). During the tour, several Queen’s players were involved in an altercation in Norwich (REED, Norwich 70–76), but the first London run passed without incident, apart from a November 1584 complaint by the City of London that, despite the fact only the Queen’s had been sanctioned for London playing the previous year, “all the places of playing were filled with men calling themselves the Queen’s players” (Wickham, Berry and Ingram 301). The Queen’s Men made its court debut in 1583–84, playing on 26 and 29 December 1583 and again on 3 March 1584. For this and the following court season, the Queen’s was 1
Examples of radical Protestant attacks on playing include Gosson’s School of Abuse (1579) and Plays Confuted in Five Actions (1582) and Anthony Munday’s Second and Third Blast of Retrait from Plays and Theatres (1580). Munday later returned to writing plays for the public stage (McMillin and MacLean 28, 30–32). For more on sixteenth-century attacks on theatre, see Chambers, Stage i.236–68, iv.184–259; chapter IV of Barish, The Antitheatrical Prejudice (especially page 82 note 5, which gives a short bibliography on Puritan attacks on the stage); Collinson, Birthpangs of Protestant England; and White, Theatre and Reformation.
The Queen’s Men
89
the only adult company that performed at court (Astington, English 231; Chambers, Stage iv. 159–61). The company appears to have still been in London in June 1584, when it met with the City Recorder during a period of unrest; during this meeting, the players mentioned James Burbage, perhaps suggesting the Queen’s had been playing at the Theatre (McMillin and MacLean 46–7). By 9 July 1584, the Queen’s was on tour, playing in Cambridge on that day (REED, Cambridge 311). A relative paucity of provincial records during the rest of 1584, 1585, and the first half of 1586 (see Appendix) may indicate the Queen’s was more interested in London playing during this period, although provincial records could be incomplete. In the middle of 1586, the company’s recorded provincial visits jumps markedly. For both 1586 and 1587, datable tour stops begin in June and last through October or November; presumably the company played in London from October or November until June during these years. Starting with the 1585–86 court season, the Queen’s was no longer the sole adult company called to court, but it remained the dominant adult company at court through 1590–91, always performing at least as often as any other adult company each season (Astington, English 231–3; Chambers, Stage iv.161–3). Between 1583 and 1588, the Queen’s seems to have played at most available London venues. In addition to the Bell, the Bull, and the Theatre, books containing Tarlton’s jests describe him plying his trade at the Curtain and Cross Keys, and the Stationers’ Register entry for Tarlton’s last sonnet claims it was performed at the Bel Savage (Wickham, Berry and Ingram 301–2, 345; Gurr, Companies 212). For the Curtain, Bel Savage, and Cross Keys, reference is only made to solo Tarlton performances; accordingly, it is not certain his fellow Queen’s Men also played at these locations.2 Given its presence at all these venues, McMillin and MacLean agree with Oscar Brownstein that even when in London, the Queen’s was “on tour,” lacking a permanent home (McMillin and MacLean 46; Brownstein 22). In 1588, the Queen’s apparently began traveling earlier, and remained on tour longer, than in previous years. The company was in Canterbury on 2 February and played at Dover as late as Christmas day. This does not necessarily mean the Queen’s had moved to a pattern of year-round touring. As early as 1583, conflicting provincial records point to a practice of splitting the company into branches.3 This practice apparently was an increasingly settled practice after 1586; by 1589, each branch— one apparently led by John and Laurence Dutton, the other by John Laneham—was 2 For more on Tarlton and his solo performance, see Peter Thomson’s “The True Physiognomy of a Man” as well as John Astington’s “Tarlton and the Sanguine Temperament.” 3 In 1583, for instance, the Queen’s company is recorded at Nottingham at 2 September (McMillin and MacLean 175) but at Rye on 14 September (REED, Sussex 130). As McMillin and MacLean note, the players at Nottingham “cannot have been the same Queen’s Men who were playing the south-east towns at about the same time” (44). Although later records indicate that multiple Queen’s branches were sanctioned by their patron, and this may have been the case already in 1583, it is also of course possible that one of these 1583 groups was a company of players passing themselves off as the Queen’s Men.
Shakespeare’s Companies
90
sometimes identified by its leader as well as patron (McMillin and MacLean 44, 62–3, 211). Initially, the divided branches may have been a touring practice, but by 1590–91 it seemingly was a permanent arrangement, as the Dutton-led Queen’s four court performances were distinguished from the Laneham-led Queen’s one in the Chamber accounts (Chambers, Stage iv.163). Despite regular court performances and extensive tours, not all was well for the Queen’s in the late 1580s. Beginning in 1585, with the deaths of Tobias Mylles (or Mills) and John Bentley, the company sustained a series of personnel losses. William Knell, apparently Bentley’s replacement and a noted tragic actor, was killed during a fight with fellow Queen’s player John Towne on 13 June 1587 in Thame (McMillin and MacLean 52). Barely a year later, Richard Tarlton, easily the most popular actor of the day, fell ill and died. The impact of his death on the Queen’s should not be overstated, as the company continued to play frequently at court (and thus perhaps also in London, at least during the holidays) and still received generous payments when on tour (53). By the early 1590s, however, the Queen’s status as England’s leading company was eroding, likely due to increased competition from companies like Strange’s and the Admiral’s. After the five 1590–91 court performances by the two Queen’s branches, the company played at court only once in 1591–92, not at all in 1592–93, and once in 1593–94 before disappearing from court records entirely. Some scholars argue that during this time one of the Queen’s branches may have sought a new patron as a way of reviving flagging fortunes, but evidence for such a maneuver is sparse.4 In 1593–94, the Queen’s briefly played at the Rose with Sussex’s; this was its last recorded London performance. Perhaps by 1594, and certainly by 1597, the Queen’s ceased to operate as two branches and became a single, exclusively provincial company (65, 211).5 It would be incorrect to regard this relegation to the provinces as a failure for the Queen’s Men, however. The company still bore the Queen’s name and patronage, and it still received handsome payments in the provinces. Thus, while it faded from the London scene, it remained an important traveling company until its ultimate dissolution