EDUCATION • PUBLIC POLICY
That is the central question of this volume and scholars from a variety of dis-
ciplines—che...
123 downloads
1133 Views
657KB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
EDUCATION • PUBLIC POLICY
That is the central question of this volume and scholars from a variety of dis-
ciplines—chemistry, economics, education, philosophy, political science, psychol-
RIMMERMAN
W
hat are the connections between service-learning and a liberal arts education?
HOW AND WHY IT WORKS
ogy, public policy, religious studies, and sociology—answer it here. The scholars, collected by Craig A. Rimmerman, ground their essays in the positive assumption that service-learning contributes significantly to students’ moral, ethical, and social
The contributors engage in the critique of service and then respond to that critique within the context of their individual chapters. Readers will have a better understanding of what does and does not work in and out of the classroom and why. The practical appeal of this volume lies in the fact that other teachers and students who are interested in both developing their own service-learning courses and connecting those courses to broader issues of citizenship, democracy, theories of justice, ethics, and morality can find advice and applications of successful service-learning endeavors within it.
CRAIG A. RIMMERMAN is professor of public policy studies and political science and the Joseph P. DiGangi Endowed Chair in the Social Sciences at Hobart and William Smith Colleges.
For orders and information please contact the publisher LEXINGTON BOOKS A division of Rowman & Littlefield Publishers, Inc. 4501 Forbes Boulevard, Suite 200 Lanham, Maryland 20706 1-800-462-6420 • www.lexingtonbooks.com
Service-LearningLITHO.indd 1
ISBN-13: 978-0-7391-2121-4 ISBN-10: 0-7391-2121-9 90000 9 780739 121214
SERVICE-LEARNING AND THE LIBERAL ARTS
development within the broader context of a liberal arts education.
SERVICELEARNING AND THE
LIBERAL ARTS edited by
CRAIG A. RIMMERMAN Foreword by Mark D. Gearan • W. AVERELL H. BAUDER • PATRICK M. COLLINS • DAVID W. CRAIG • DEBRA DEMEIS • MICHAEL DOBKOWSKI • KATHLEEN FLOWERS • MARK D. GEARAN
• JACK D. HARRIS • STEVEN P. LEE • JO BETH MERTENS • H. WESLEY PERKINS • CRAIG A. RIMMERMAN • CYNTHIA SUTTON • CHARLES TEMPLE
10/13/08 4:19:17 PM
Service-Learning and the Liberal Arts
Service-Learning and the Liberal Arts How and Why It Works
Edited by Craig A. Rimmerman
LEXINGTON BOOKS A division of ROWMAN & LITTLEFIELD PUBLISHERS, INC.
Lanham • Boulder • New York • Toronto • Plymouth, UK
LEXINGTON BOOKS A division of Rowman & Littlefield Publishers, Inc. A wholly owned subsidiary of The Rowman & Littlefield Publishing Group, Inc. 4501 Forbes Boulevard, Suite 200 Lanham, MD 20706 Estover Road Plymouth PL6 7PY United Kingdom Copyright © 2009 by Lexington Books All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, or otherwise, without the prior permission of the publisher. British Library Cataloguing in Publication Information Available Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Service-learning and the liberal arts : how and why it works / edited by Craig A. Rimmerman. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN-13: 978-0-7391-2121-4 (cloth : alk. paper) ISBN-10: 0-7391-2121-9 (cloth : alk. paper) ISBN-13: 978-0-7391-3213-5 (electronic) ISBN-10: 0-7391-3213-X (electronic) 1. Service learning—United States. 2. Education, Humanistic—United States. 3. Moral education (Higher)—United States. 4. Hobart and William Smith Colleges—Public services. I. Rimmerman, Craig A. LC220.5.S4554 2009 378'.012—dc22 2008031987 Printed in the United States of America
⬁ ™ The paper used in this publication meets the minimum requirements of American National Standard for Information Sciences—Permanence of Paper for Printed Library Materials, ANSI/NISO Z39.48–1992.
To our students, who remind us of the many joys of teaching
Contents
Foreword Mark D. Gearan
ix
Acknowledgments
xi
Introduction Craig A. Rimmerman
1
1
Service-Learning in an Ethics Course Steven P. Lee
2
Service-Learning: Process and Participation Jack D. Harris
3
Understanding Service at the Service of Understanding: An Exploration of Service-Learning in the Arts Patrick M. Collins
41
Teaching the Unteachable: Service-Learning and Engagement in the Teaching of Genocide and the Holocaust Michael Dobkowski
61
4
7 21
5
Service-Learning and Public Policy Craig A. Rimmerman
71
6
America Reads as Service-Learning: A Stereophonic Report Kathleen Flowers and Charles Temple
85
vii
viii
7
Contents
Incorporating Service-Learning in Quantitative Methods Economics Courses Jo Beth Mertens
8
The Evolution of a Service-Learning Course Debra DeMeis and Cynthia Sutton
9
Learning about Student Alcohol Abuse and Helping to Prevent It through Service-Learning Initiatives: The HWS Alcohol Education Project David W. Craig and H. Wesley Perkins
10
11
HWS Responds: A Case Study of How the Civic Engagement Office and Co-curricular Service-Learning Can Enhance the Liberal Arts W. Averell H. Bauder Service-Learning Lessons Craig A. Rimmerman
107 137
151
171 187
Bibliography
191
Index
201
About the Contributors
209
Foreword
Service-Learning and the Liberal Arts: How and Why It Works comes at an important time in our nation’s history. With the steady rise in interest in Americorps, Peace Corps, City Year, Teach for America, and many local efforts, young Americans are increasingly looking for meaningful ways to make a difference. Studies show more young people enter college interested in community service. This collection of thoughtful essays written by colleagues at Hobart and William Smith Colleges comes at an opportune time to update scholarship and consider the best practices in service learning that will foster greater civic engagement. Readers have the opportunity to consider articles across disciplines from experienced faculty who have considered a broad array of topics. As the former director of the Peace Corps and member of the board of directors of the Corporation for National and Community Service, I have seen firsthand the energy and commitment of young Americans interested in serving in the United States or around the world. Today, as a college president on a campus infused with an ethic of service, I am heartened by the interest of students seeking to blend their dedication to volunteering with a reflective component enriched in the classroom. The service movement is now a mature and vibrant presence on college and university campuses across the country. Twenty years ago the presidents of Brown, Georgetown, and Stanford joined together to create Campus Compact, a president’s organization committed to service-learning; today more than 1,000 presidents belong to the organization. Many campuses
ix
x
Foreword
have an office of community service, while others explore creative ways to reward faculty offering service-learning courses. As a citizen, I am encouraged by the growing interest in service among young people. As an American, I am pleased that policymakers have fostered the service movement. And as a college president, I am proud to have colleagues like the authors published here who prepare our students for lives of consequence. Mark D. Gearan Geneva, New York
Acknowledgments
This book would not have been possible without the support of Jean Salone and Cindy Blacklaw, who did such fine work preparing the book for publication. I also thank the Hobart and William Smith Committee on Faculty Research and Honors for their support for this project. Hobart and William Smith President Mark Gearan and Dean of Faculty and Provost Teresa Amott were also encouraging from beginning to end. Thank you, too, to Brenda Hadenfeldt, editor at Rowman and Littlefield, who recognized that the original book proposal had merit and sent it to Joseph Parry at Lexington Books, who was a most supportive and helpful editor with whom to work. A huge thank you to Joseph Cammarano, who read the entire manuscript carefully with a thoughtful critical eye, and who made useful revision suggestions that have improved the final manuscript. Of course, this book would not have been accomplished without the enthusiasm, generosity, and cooperation of my Hobart and William Smith colleagues and contributors, who are all doing such important work in the service-learning area. We are all fortunate to teach at Hobart and William Smith Colleges, an institution that prides itself on interdisciplinary teaching and scholarship that is rooted in the liberal arts. Our students over the years have reminded us of our privileged lives as teachers working with young people who challenge and inspire us in the best of ways. It is to them that I dedicate this book.
xi
Introduction Craig A. Rimmerman
In their recent book, Colby, Ehrlich, Beaumont, and Stephens have written: “We believe that higher education has a critical role to play in shaping character and a sense of social responsibility in the U.S. citizenry because such a large share of the population attends college for at least some period of time.”1 This book is rooted in that positive assumption about the importance of higher education in contributing to our students’ moral, ethical, and social development within the broader context of a liberal arts education. In doing so, the chapters here all discuss how service-learning courses can contribute in positive ways to a liberal arts education. What also distinguishes this volume is that a number of the contributors engage the critique of service and then respond to that critique within the context of their individual chapters. A further distinguishing feature is the diversity of academic disciplines represented here—chemistry, economics, education, philosophy, political science, psychology, public policy, religious studies, and sociology. All of the contributors teach at Hobart and William Smith Colleges, a four year undergraduate liberal arts institution, which first developed service-learning courses in the late 1980s and which has celebrated itself over the years as being “ferociously and totally liberal arts.” This book reflects the interdisciplinary nature of our institution and the field of servicelearning as it has evolved over the past fifteen or so years. Our goal has been to write chapters that would have practical appeal to other teachers, scholars, activists, and students who are interested in developing their own service-learning courses and connecting those courses to broader issues of citizenship, democracy, community, difference, and theories of justice, 1
2
Craig A. Rimmerman
ethics, and morality. A further goal is to connect the theories at the foundation of service-learning to pedagogical practice as developed in the courses represented in this edited collection. We hope that this volume will have appeal to those associated with a wide array of higher education institutions (e.g., small liberal arts institutions, larger universities, technical institutions) that offer liberal arts courses. Taken as a whole, the chapters in this book contribute to the literature on service-learning and to the literature on the goals of a liberal arts education. How does service learning contribute to the study of ethics? In the lead essay to this volume, Steven Lee addresses that important question. In doing so, he connects the theoretical, philosophical discussions in his classroom with the practical experiences of student participation in the surrounding Geneva, New York, community by interrogating the important connections between morality and self-interest. Lee’s essay (and course) is especially noteworthy for its unwillingness to take anything for granted, including the role of community service and service-learning. He identifies four main criticisms of service-learning: (1) it is obfuscating and naïve; (2) it fails to appreciate the distinction between charity and justice; (3) it does not recognize the distinction between public and private morality; and (4) it ignores the proper role of self-assertion in a human life. As Lee interrogates these important issues, he engages in a crucial task of the liberal arts educator: challenging students’ assumptions and preconceptions of their roles as citizens. Jack Harris, a sociologist and a keen analyst of organizations, reminds us in his essay that the challenges of creating and implementing a successful service-learning course are formidable. The key to overcoming these challenges is to be aware of them, to confront them head on during the planning of the course and as the course unfolds, and to work closely with community partners throughout the entire process. Like Steven Lee, Harris recognizes that service-learning courses risk reinforcing the worst assumptions of students who have been raised in a service-oriented, therapeutic culture. For example, students can easily fall within the trap of construing their community work as a form of noblesse oblige. In addition, Harris understandably worries that students might interact with the community from a perspective of superiority given their education, economic class, social class, and/or race privilege. His chapter provides some excellent practical suggestions to faculty who wish to overcome these pedagogical challenges. “Are there instances in which the civic requirement of service may undermine other epistemic aims of experimental learning?” That is the central question posed by Patrick Collins in his essay, one that evaluates the value of service-learning within the broader context of a liberal arts education. Collins’s essay is important because of his creative use of service-learning in his Drama in a Developmental Context education course, a course that is
Introduction
3
experientially based (studio or workshop-based) and that attempts to help students develop their personal understandings of the potential associated with using dramatic activity to foster human development at both the individual and social levels. Collins responds to a perceived need in the larger Geneva, New York, community by requiring students in the course to teach a small after school program in drama for local children. Can the servicelearning model be used effectively in such a setting? Collins’s response to that question is complex and interesting, given his thoughtful and nuanced analysis of his course within the broader context of the service-learning literature. For Michael Dobkowski, service-learning in his religious studies course on genocide and the Holocaust enables students to “channel their desire to put what they have learned into a form of action.” He poses this important question: How does one teach the incomprehensible and the overwhelming to contemporary students? Dobkowski’s response is a compelling one because he recognizes the importance of inspiring his students to process intellectually and emotionally challenging material by doing something in the form of community service. He is especially mindful that the teaching of Holocaust studies could numb rather than energize his students. With this in mind, he believes that participating in community-based organizations, such as working in the Rochester, New York, Holocaust Resource Center, affords students an opportunity to do something in response to the crucial moral, ethical, and philosophical issues raised in his course. Like Dobkowski, political scientist Craig A. Rimmerman requires students to connect participation in the larger community to broader issues of his course—public policy and democratic theory. The pedagogy of servicelearning allows faculty members and their students to engage these questions: What role do citizens play in the American policy process? What role should they play? And how would such a society informed by participatory democracy engage the challenging domestic social policy issues (HIV/AIDS, health care, affirmative action, welfare policy, and education policy) underlying his course on Social Policy and Community Activism? Rimmerman develops a pedagogical model rooted in critical education for citizenship. In doing so, he identifies the exciting possibilities for service-learning-based courses, but also highlights the constraints facing those faculty who embrace the service-learning model. In doing so, he builds on the work of Steven Lee, Jack Harris, and Patrick Collins, all of whom recognize that the pedagogical challenges associated with successful service-learning courses are formidable. To Katie Flowers and Charles Temple, the America Reads program provides an excellent opportunity for service-learning projects in colleges and universities. Proposed in 1996 and funded by Congress in 1997, America Reads represents the intersection of two strong movements in education—service learning
4
Craig A. Rimmerman
and literacy. Flowers and Temple believe that it offers faculty opportunities for developing a pedagogical strategy that enables students to reflect on their roles as citizens, much like Craig Rimmerman does in his course on Social Policy and Community Activism. What makes Flowers and Temple’s essay so informative is that it situates the America Reads program on a liberal arts campus within the broader context of the work that Katie Flowers does for the campus-wide Center for Community Engagement and Service-Learning, and the work that education professor Charles Temple has done over the years as the primary campus advisor to the program. They offer a rich evaluation of student and community involvement in the program and link their analysis to the larger literatures on service-learning and literacy. How can service-learning be used effectively in a quantitative methods course? Jo Beth Mertens, an economist, provides evidence from her course that service-learning can be used to enhance rigorous courses on formal quantitative methods. One of Mertens’s central pedagogical goals is to create responsible and intentional learners among her students. To Mertens, “a successful quantitative economics course teaches students specific skills and tools that can be utilized for life, thereby creating empowered and informed learners.” Like other contributors to this volume, Mertens believes that service-learning provides an excellent vehicle for meeting these challenging pedagogical goals. Much of the current work in service-learning is now focused on how to best assess whether service-learning pedagogies have been successful. Mertens provides us with techniques for evaluating servicelearning growing out of her course, techniques that are rooted in the thoughtful and critical voices of her students. How does service-learning inform a team-taught, bidisciplinary course entitled Children in Contexts: Families and School? Debra DeMeis (Department of Psychology) and Cynthia Sutton (Department of Education) situate their course within the broad context of the goals associated with liberal education and how service learning can create engaged citizens. Building on the criteria used by the historian William Cronon to identify what a liberal education should look like in practice, DeMeis and Sutton extend and apply his analysis to service learning by identifying three components that are responsible for developing responsible citizenship: “engagement with the community, focus on social problems, and collaboration between faculty and students.” They then offer a rich analysis of how an incorporation of service-based components in their course enables students to “become engaged with the problem of childhood poverty and to develop a sense of social and civic responsibility.” But like other contributors to this volume, DeMeis and Sutton recognize that “the charity model” of noblesse oblige must be transcended and they offer some concrete pedagogical suggestions for doing so.
Introduction
5
For David Craig and H. Wesley Perkins, the service-learning model is an integral component of their team-taught, bidisciplinary course—Learning about Student Alcohol Abuse and Helping to Prevent It through ServiceLearning Initiatives: The HWS Alcohol Education Project. Craig (a biochemist) and Perkins (a sociologist) have written extensively on the social norms approach to alcohol education and their work is reflected in the Hobart and William Smith Alcohol Education Project, which is designed to reduce alcohol misuse and harm by engaging students in an array of community-based programs. How is community service integrated as an integral component of their course? Students conduct a campus-wide survey of alcohol use and its impact on the campus. The data are then used in prevention program delivery and assessment of progress. Students also play an important campus-wide education role by developing course-related materials for distribution beyond the classroom. Perkins and Craig do an excellent job of placing the service-learning component of their course within the larger theme of this volume: how service-learning can enhance students’ liberal arts educations and faculty members’ pedagogies. In the book’s final chapter, Averell Bauder, Hobart and William Smith’s director of Public Service (now renamed The Center for Community Engagement and Service-Learning), uses the campus response to Hurricane Katrina as a vehicle for interrogating broader issues of servicelearning. Bauder quotes Provost Teresa Amott from her opening convocation speech in August 2005: “I am confident that at Hobart and William Smith Colleges, a campus committed to civic engagement and public service, we will find ways to give of our time and our resources to support the rescue and recovery efforts now underway.” Building on Provost Amott’s vision, Hobart and William Smith Colleges organized a number of education and public service initiatives (aptly named HWS Responds), all of which Bauder describes from the vantage point of the coordinating office, the Center for Community Engagement and Learning. Bauder’s analysis is important because he uses his case study of HWS Responds to highlight larger lessons to be learned for reflections on the purpose of a liberal arts education and the possible connections between civic engagement and service-learning. Bauder’s closing theme does well in recapitulating the broader implications of the entire volume. We hope that readers will find these essays useful as they consider how to build service-learning into existing courses and/or how to better improve on the service-learning components that already exist in their classes. Service-learning is exciting, challenging, and meaningful. But it is also important for those of us in the field to recognize that there is often a disjuncture between service-learning theory and practice in the classroom. It is not easy to devise and implement a pedagogically
6
Craig A. Rimmerman
sound service-learning course. We hope that the chapters in this volume provide avenues that make the challenges less formidable for teachers, scholars, community members, administrators, and students.
NOTE 1. Anne Colby, Thomas Ehrlich, Elizabeth Beaumont, and Jason Stephens, Educating Citizens: Preparing America’s Undergraduates for Lives of Moral and Civic Responsibility (San Francisco: Jossey-Bass, 2003), 263–64.
1 Service-Learning in an Ethics Course Steven P. Lee
Service-learning is a pedagogical tool that helps students to understand and to incorporate into their lives the material of a course. It helps the instructor to make clear the gap between theory and practice, and it shows how that gap can be crossed. Incorporating community service into a course is a recognition that practice has a role to play in education. Service-learning is using the practice of community service to deepen the students’ understanding of the theory presented in the classroom and its texts. The classroom is about the real world, but it is separate from the real world. Servicelearning is pedagogically valuable, in part, because it has the ability to bring the real world into the learning process. The theoretical discussions of the classroom are joined with the practical experiences of the service activity. The use of service-learning is in furtherance of the liberal arts ideal that the role of education is to create individuals who have not merely mastered a body of theory, but who have become capable of taking their place as democratic citizens. Service provides the practice; service-learning informs the practice in a way that allows students to appreciate its meaning and to better understand the theory. One place where this aspect of service-learning is especially clear is in a philosophy course in ethical theory. Ethics is about practical reasoning, as opposed to theoretical reasoning (to use Aristotle’s distinction), and practical reasoning, to be adequately grasped, must be exercised in practice. An ethics course can often lose sight of this point and focus exclusively on theory, with the practical dimension being slighted or treated only in the abstract. In this chapter, I discuss my use of community service in a course I teach in ethical theory. I first explain the course and the role of service in it. 7
8
Steven P. Lee
Then I consider how service helps me to teach the theoretical issues of the course. Finally, and more generally, I discuss some of the limitations of service-learning, as I see them, and explore some criticisms that are made of it. While this chapter proceeds by discussing my particular course, I believe that it makes points worth considering about service-learning in general, especially in the critical discussion at the end.
I For a number of years, I have taught a course in ethics, which I call Morality and Self-Interest, as a service-learning course. This is a course in ethical theory, one that examines the basis and nature of morality in general, not a course in “applied ethics,” which would involve the application of morality to a particular area of social or political concern, such as medical ethics or environmental ethics.1 As the title of my course indicates, it is organized around the theme of the relation between morality and self-interest. This is a useful pedagogical device because students are already familiar with the distinction between morality and self-interest, and they generally accept the idea that acting morally involves sacrificing one’s self-interest for that of others. In other words, students come into the course inclined to believe that morality and self-interest diverge. My approach is to teach ethics by considering the extent to which this is true. The question running through the course, then, is whether morality and self-interest diverge or instead converge. One aspect of this question is the concern that if morality and self-interest do diverge, a motivation to act morally would generally be lacking. This makes community service especially valuable for the course. Doing community service is seen as a paradigm of acting morally. It is helping out others in need and fulfilling one’s obligations to the community. It is just the sort of activity that, on its face, is regarded as moral. At the same time, service is seen as a person’s giving of himself or herself for the benefit of others, acting altruistically rather than selfishly. So, service activity sets up the beginning position that morality and self-interest diverge. From the point of view of most students, the time they are required to give to service is time taken away from what they would otherwise rather be doing, thus putting the morality of service activity at odds with their self-interest.2 From a commonsense perspective, self-interest and morality, self-regard and other-regard, are based on opposing motivations. Morality is seen as requiring a sacrifice of self-interest. But this appearance may be mere appearance. Many of the theories we examine in the course imply that morality and self-interest, when correctly understood, actually converge. In addition, it is a common claim that acting morally is in a person’s self-interest in the long-term, if not in the short-term. Of course, there are complications and
Service-Learning in an Ethics Course
9
qualifications that must be appreciated when community service is viewed in this way, but considering these complications and qualifications as they come up is part of what makes service a useful component of the course. Doing community service is doing good, in a moral sense, but is it also doing well? Students in the course are required to do two to three hours of community service per week, a total of about twenty-five hours over the semester. There are a variety of service assignments they may choose from, working with a variety of people in need. These include the Geneva Boys and Girls Club, local day care centers, the Geneva Community Lunch Program, Geneva Head Start, America Reads, the Geneva General Hospital, and the Geneva Family Counseling Center. The assignments are coordinated through our campus Public Service Office. Students are also free, with approval, to use a service activity other than the standard ones offered, including ones with which they may already be involved. Geneva is a diverse community, with significant minority populations, so our largely majority students often end up interacting extensively with people of color for the first time in their lives. The students keep a journal of their service activity, which I read periodically during the semester. I ask that their journal entries include, first, a description of the service site and their activities and interactions there, and, second, some critical reflections on the service experience and some discussion of how the activity illustrates or provides evidence regarding the concepts and theories examined in class. The service work itself is not graded, but students must complete it to pass the course. The service activities are a frequent subject of class discussion. As part of the final paper for the course, students must relate these activities to the theoretical issues in the course. My approach to the service activity is the same as my approach to the course in general. I seek to teach students how to think, not what to think. I seek not to fill them up with a correct theory, but to contribute to their development as moral beings. I seek to teach the skill of critical, practical reasoning. When students face serious moral problems in their lives, as they will, I hope to have prepared them by having developed their abilities to recognize the moral dimensions of the problems and to reason well about what in the situation they should do.3 Much of the immoral behavior in the world, in my view, is due not to malice or other forms of viciousness, but to moral insensitivity and moral immaturity. A course in ethics has serious limitations in its ability to turn vices into virtues, but it can help some to become more moral by making them more thoughtful, more aware of the moral dimensions of their lives. When the students have learned how to understand and reason better about their situation from a moral perspective, they will, to that extent, have become morally better people. The service activity is meant to further these aims. This critical spirit is reflected in how I
10
Steven P. Lee
ask the students to incorporate the service experience into the course work. For example, I emphasize that there is no expected line they are supposed to take in their reaction to the service in their journals. I do not want the students to assume that their journal entries must reflect what they think my expectations are. If they do not like the service, think it is a waste of time, or do not find it relevant to the course material, they are urged to say so and to reflect on why that is the case. What sort of comments do students have about their service? Let me mention some of the points students frequently make in their journal reflections, mostly on the topic of whether morality and self-interest diverge or converge. Many of their comments might be dismissed as clichés, but in most cases, it seems to me, the students are registering that while they may be familiar with the cliché, they are only now appreciating its content. Many students speak of the community service as a chore they did not want or like to do. But many others speak of the benefits they receive from the service. They speak of it as being personally rewarding, as providing positive feelings, and as making them feel good about themselves or making them feel like good people. They say that they had originally not wanted to do it, but were glad they did. For example, some indicate that they had almost decided to drop the course when they learned of the service requirement, but were glad to have stuck it out. They discuss how they had been lost in their own world, and that service helped to bring them out of that world, forcing them out of their comfort zone. Some say that the people in need who they helped give them back more than the people in need were given. Apparently continuing to think that community service is necessarily against their wishes, some speak of forgetting while serving that they were doing service, and some ask how the service could be moral when it makes them feel good. But there were many negative comments, beyond simple statements of dislike of being required to do the service. Some wonder whether the service really does any good, and some question whether it is worth doing the service at all since the problems it tries to deal with are so vast. One person suggested that service in the course was indeed an obligation, but an academic one rather than a moral one. This remark suggests that some students feel coerced into doing the service, since they are threatened with failure for the course if they do not do it. They feel it is nonvoluntary. This issue is often raised in class discussions of the service. Many students have previously encountered community service as a requirement, for example, for high school graduation, and felt negatively about the service because of its nonvoluntary nature. There are several aspects of this issue that get teased out in the discussions. One is whether the service is in fact coerced, given that their taking the course (which is an elective not a requirement) is itself voluntary. But the main aspect of this issue, from my point of view, is whether
Service-Learning in an Ethics Course
11
coerced service is really service at all, and, in either case, whether such coerced activity can play its expected role in a course about morality. Most ethical theorists would hold that an action must be voluntary in order to be an instance of moral behavior. Assuming that the service is coerced, does this undermine its role in the course as a paradigmatically moral activity?
II One of the first theoretical issues addressed in an ethics course is moral relativism. Are moral standards in some sense objective, or are they instead relative to a culture, or even individually subjective? Perhaps our moral views are simply preferences, like a person’s favorite flavor of ice cream. I present some arguments to show that moral standards are objective. One of these is based on implications of the fact that we argue about morality, but not about preferences. The students, however, come from a culture in which relativism is implicit, if not explicit, and, as a result, such arguments (however sound) are not often, by themselves, persuasive. Community service can help make the case. Relativism is one issue where practice is crucial to theory. Students often find themselves during their service activity needing to make moral choices. For example, one student wonders what she should do when one of the young children she is working with states, “Women are for hitting.” Another wonders what to do when he perceives that a day care worker he is assisting is not responding appropriately to the children. The agony of choice that students face in situations like this may convince them, if anything can, that morality is not just a matter of preferences. The agony is a sign that the students are searching for the right thing to do. We don’t generally agonize over our preferences. Another central issue in the course is the nature of self-interest. To know whether morality and self-interest converge or diverge, one must know not only what morality is, but also what self-interest is. At the beginning, the students tend to view self-interest as transparent; they see it as doing what one wants to do or achieving a high standard of living or material possessions. But their reaction to the service activity helps them to begin to question this simplistic view. I raise this issue initially in the way the ancient Greeks did: What is the good life for a person? Is the idea of the good life equivocal, depending on whether it is a matter of the morally good or the prudentially good? (This repeats the course question, whether morality and self-interest converge or diverge.) In their service activity, as suggested by the comments reported above, many begin to recognize that there are things valuable to them beyond simply doing what they want to do or having possessions, such as the good feeling that comes from helping others. As we examine the theorists and the primary texts of the course, two concepts
12
Steven P. Lee
become key in helping focus on the nature of self-interest and its relation to morality: happiness and community. The main theorists we consider are Plato, Aristotle, Epictetus, Hobbes, Butler, Hume, Kant, Mill, and Nietzsche. I will now briefly discuss how the contributions of these theorists are used in the course to help to reveal the relation between morality and self-interest, and then I will consider how the community service relates to this aspect of the course. After that, I will return to the concepts of happiness and community. Both the convergence and the divergence of morality and self-interest are illustrated by the theorists we study from the ancient world. The most straightforward example of divergence is presented by the character Thrasymachus in book 1 of Plato’s Republic, who argues that if one acts justly, one is acting to the advantage of others, specifically, the stronger, and not to one’s own advantage. Plato (through the character Socrates), Aristotle, and Epictetus all offer views that represent a convergence between morality and self-interest. These views have in common the idea that being happy necessarily involves acting morally. Jumping to the modern era, Thomas Hobbes presents a view that I call quasi-convergence (sharing this view with Plato’s character Glaucon). According to this view, morality is based on a social contract, and it is in everyone’s interest to accept that contract because outside the contract, life is “nasty, brutish, and short.” It is in one’s interest to be moral, for otherwise one is punished by the law (or community opinion). Crime doesn’t pay. But the view represents only quasi-convergence because if you could get away with crime, if no one knew you did it, it would pay, it would be in your interest to act immorally (as the Glaucon’s Ring of Gyges story in book 2 of Plato’s Republic is meant to illustrate). In my construction of the history of ethical theory, I see theorists in the modern era as shifting the focus in a basic way from that of the ancients. The ancients placed self-interest first, so to speak, arguing in effect that selfinterest (or happiness) was, by the way, convergent with morality. A person is moral for the sake of his or her self-interest (a view I refer to this as “moral narcissism”). Self-interest can provide the motivation for being moral. In contrast, the moderns tend to consider behavior moral only when it is done for its own sake (or for the sake of the other), not when done out of self-interest. This makes the convergence of morality and self-interest problematic.4 Hume and Butler address this difficulty by pointing out that because we have altruistic desires, we naturally want to help others, and when we act on those desires, we are acting for the sake of others. Because we are thereby satisfying our own desires, however, we are also, by the way, furthering our own self-interest. Kant goes in the other direction, arguing that an action is moral only if it does not arise from desire, selfish or altruistic. In this sense, Kant abandons the effort to find convergence between morality and self-interest.5 For Kant, an action is fully moral not when done
Service-Learning in an Ethics Course
13
for the sake to the person thereby helped, but when it is done for the sake of the moral law itself. I present the utilitarian Mill as holding, like Hume and Butler, that moral action is primarily for the sake of others (the greatest happiness for the greatest number), but that we can, by improving education and reforming social institutions, help to insure that acting morally will also generally be in tune with the desires of the actor.6 Nietzsche I will discuss later. How does community service help students achieve an understanding of these theories? For one, because the theories will imply different views about the value of community service (and also about its pedagogical role in a service-learning course), talking about these differences helps to get the theories across to the students.7 Beyond this, I ask the students to discuss, in their journal entries, their experiences in the light of what the theorists would say. Let me offer a few examples of the sorts of comments this elicits. Aristotle is often used when the students are discussing whether they like or dislike service. Assuming that service is a moral activity, if the students like it, they observe that this shows that they have, as Aristotle would put it, a moral character. If, on the other hand, they do not like the service, they cite Aristotle to suggest that they are on their way to developing a moral character by habituating themselves to acts of beneficence. Hobbes was frequently mentioned, especially by those working with children. Students pointed out, for example, that children seem as if they are in a Hobbesian state of nature, or that their adult caregivers are instructing them in social cooperation so that they can leave the state of nature and enter society. Those who were not enjoying their service also cite Kant because of his separation of desires and duty. Also Kant is cited because his categorical imperative is similar to the familiar golden rule. Along these lines, students spoke of their service as putting themselves in the other’s shoes and, reflecting the reciprocity central to Kant’s social contract theory, as giving back for what others have given them.8 The idea of happiness is central to the course and the notion of selfinterest not only because it is emphasized by Aristotle, but also because it is valuable vehicle for comparing morality and self-interest. The idea is contested ground for arguments about convergence and divergence. One issue is whether happiness is objective or subjective: Is happiness different for different people and a matter of how one feels, in which case it is subjective, or is it an objective characteristic of our humanity, the same for all? Students tend to view happiness as subjective, as a matter of satisfying the current desires one happens to have. Aristotle offers an objective account in which happiness is defined as engaging in rational activity, including the activity of practical reason. This is a critical account of happiness, one which has implications about how one ought to behave. On Aristotle’s objective account, in contrast with a subjective account, people may not know
14
Steven P. Lee
whether they are happy and may be mistaken about what will make them happy. Some actual desires are not in one’s self-interest to fulfill, and satisfying them does not lead to happiness. Thus, the apparent divergence between morality and self-interest (for example, a person’s not desiring to do what morality requires) does not entail their actual divergence, and, indeed, Aristotle argued that they converge. In terms of community service, Aristotle’s objective idea of happiness can underlay a discussion of the transformative power of such activity for the person doing the service. Acting morally can make us better moral beings and lead to our happiness. A second major concept developed in the course, especially in connection with service, is community. Students frequently point out, in their journals and in class discussion, that what is most interesting about service is the social aspect, the working with other people. Those who have little or no contact with the people they (indirectly) serve find their service to be less interesting and rewarding. If students are stuck at a desk doing computer work for a social service agency (as is not uncommon, given the computer skill of the younger generation), they routinely express dissatisfaction with lack of contact with clients. It is direct service, not indirect service, that is most gratifying.9 The students most enjoyed the community in community service. One student commented that service was as much a social event as it is doing good. But the suggestion in this comment that functioning in a community and being moral are distinct activities may be mistaken. To understand both morality and self-interest, it may be that one must see each in the context of community. Happiness, as Plato and Aristotle believe, may come from playing a role in a community, and part of playing such a role is acting morally (and vice versa). On this view, morality and self-interest converge: Service creates and reinforces community, and its being a moral activity resides in this feature. Community also figures into class discussions in a different way, as represented by one student’s question: How large is our community? The idea is that an increase in moral understanding comes from a recognition not only that our community has a moral dimension, that a community is constituted in part by our moral obligations, but also that this community is larger than we may have perceived. Students need to understand their place in a larger moral community, and this is one of the benefits that community service can bestow.10 This also helps to emphasize the universal nature of morality, the claim that our moral community is all of humanity, a point emphasized by Kant. Discussion of community is central in our examination of other theorists as well. It figures, for example, into the contrast between the ancient theorists, who emphasize the essential role of community in ethical theory, and the modern theorists, whose focus on the individual makes community less central. This raises theoretical questions such as whether community is chosen, as the social contract theorists be-
Service-Learning in an Ethics Course
15
lieve, or natural, as Aristotle and Plato believe. Is community constitutive of the individual? Are social relations internal or external to the individual? In our own era, these questions arise as part of the debate between liberalism and communitarianism.
III But given the critical approach of the course, nothing is taken for granted, including the role of community service and service-learning. There is a set of criticisms of these practices raised in the course. I suggest three overlapping lines of criticism and a fourth distinct one. These criticisms are that a focus on community service and service-learning (1) is obfuscating and naïve, (2) fails to appreciate the distinction between charity and justice, (3) does not recognize the distinction between public and private morality, and (4) ignores the proper role of self-assertion in a human life. Here, my discussion becomes more general, applying directly to any service-learning course. Considering the first criticism, community service and service-learning can be obfuscating and naïve because those participating in them tend not to appreciate the contrast between community service and political activism. Both are concerned with making a better world, but the former tends to see existing institutions as fixed and the latter not. Though almost all of my students have already done community service earlier in their lives,11 few have more than a minimal understanding of politics and the political process, and fewer have been politically active.12 Occasionally, students express awareness and anger at the political and social institutions they perceive as responsible for the neediness of those they serve, but this is infrequent. It seems that most students are not very aware of the political dimensions of the problems community service is designed to address. This leads students to assume that what is needed to solve these problems is simply more community service by more people. A focus on community service and service-learning tends to reinforce this thought, and to this extent it is naïve in not appreciating the nature of the problem and obfuscating in its tendency to mask the necessary solutions. In contrast, a political approach to these problems would lead students to ask the critical question about why people in need are in need, and this would lead to recognition that political action may be necessary. This is not to reject the value of community service and service-learning, but to see them as needing to be balanced, in theory and in practice, by an appreciation of the political dimensions of social change. Pedagogically, I point out to the students the need to consider the moral values that may be embedded in particular social policies and institutions, and the role these values may play in either promoting or undermining solutions to the problems of human need.13
16
Steven P. Lee
The second line of criticism is that community service and service-learning tend to mask the important contrast between charity and justice. This point applies generally to service-learning courses, but is especially relevant to a course in ethical theory. An important distinction in ethics is between acts that are morally good to do but not obligatory, acts done “out of the goodness of one’s heart,” and acts that are morally obligatory. The former are acts of charity and the latter acts of justice. The model on which community service is usually based (though this need not be the case) is that service is charity, that it is morally good to do, but not morally required.14 To the extent that this is the model, service, and a course in service-learning, may fail to represent the true nature of our moral relations in community. This can be related to the attitude with which students approach service, which is sometimes a classist one of paternalism or noblesse oblige directed toward the less fortunate. We are good people if we provide charity for those in need, but we have no obligation to do so. This attitude is sometimes implicit in the way we refer to those at the receiving end of our service as “clients.” Or our attitude may be the precise reverse, that is, we may see those to whom we provide service as giving something to us; the servers are the needy. We make use of them for our educational purposes. In either case, the clients are treated as means rather than as ends, to use Kant’s distinction. The alternative to both of these approaches is to see relationships within community as a matter of reciprocity, not a one-way street (in either direction). The third line of criticism is closely related to the first two. A focus on community service and service-learning fails to appreciate the distinction between public and private morality. It puts forth a model in which private action becomes the sole solution to public problems.15 But both individuals and the community have obligations to address social problems; we have obligations to others as private individuals (private morality) and obligations to others as members of the community (public morality). Obligations of public morality are for the community as a whole and require governmental action. The government must be involved for several reasons. In many cases, only the government has the financial resources and expertise to solve the problems, the ability to coordinate the assistance so that it is used effectively and efficiently, and the transparency to insure that help is provided without a violation of the rights of those helped. But also, only a government can insure fairness in the contributions from all individuals in the community to the solution to the community problems. Because government efforts are supported by a (presumably) fair system of taxation, everyone pays their fair share and the burden does not fall only on a minority of the citizens. Only in this way is there a solution to the “prisoners’ dilemma” that tends to suppress private contributions. According to this criticism, those who emphasize community service either (a) fail to recog-
Service-Learning in an Ethics Course
17
nize the public dimension of efforts to solve social problems (in which the third criticism is close to the first one) or (b) are seeking, in the name of minimal government or a denial of the existence of public moral obligation, to put an end to government efforts in this area. The fourth line of criticism is very different from the others, and I owe it to Nietzsche, whose work on ethics we read at the end of the course. Nietzsche offers a basic criticism of our commonsense morality, which he refers to as a “slave” morality. To put it very roughly, in his view, the source (or genealogy) of this morality is a kind of intellectual revolt in the past by the ruled against their rulers. The rulers were naturally superior, natural aristocrats, and the ruled were naturally inferior. In resentment over being ruled by their superiors, the inferiors managed to impose a new moral code on society according to which natural superiority and inferiority had no moral relevance, all humans were morally equal, and “the meek shall inherit the earth.” In contrast, the old or aristocratic morality emphasizes self-assertion and the free exercise of one’s powers as an individual. The criticism arising from this view is not against community service or service-learning as such. Instead, it is against the way they are usually conceived in the context of our commonsense or “slave” morality. Nietzsche tends to see the obligations that, according to our commonsense morality, bind individuals as so many fetters against the free exercise of their natural powers. If community service is seen as obligatory in this way, he would presumably oppose it. In class, we discuss what community service in the way Nietzsche would endorse it would be like what community service would be like as a free exercise of an individual’s powers. In some respects this takes us back to the beginning of the course and the work of Aristotle, a return to moral narcissism.
IV I will close this chapter by rehearsing five key notions I ask the students to keep in mind as they relate their service activity to the nature of morality and the material of the course. First, motivation: What is your motivation for community service? For example, is it found in the activity itself or in the activity as a means to an end, such as fulfilling a course requirement? Second, enjoyment: Do you find your service activity to be enjoyable? If so, why, and if not, why not? Third, benefit: Does the service activity benefit you and does it benefit others? What is the overall balance of benefit and disbenefits? Fourth, change: Has the service activity changed you? Has it made you a different person in any significant sense? Fifth, identity: Is doing service crucial to or part of what you are, or is it something you could take or leave?
18
Steven P. Lee
NOTES 1. In this chapter, I will use the terms “ethics” and “morality” in somewhat different senses, with “morality” referring to rules about how people ought to behave and “ethics” referring to a study of or a theory of morality. 2. Interestingly, the self-interested activity students most often cite as one they must forego in order to do their community service is sleeping—doing the service often requires students to wake up earlier than they would like to. 3. Many have, of course, already faced significant moral problems in their lives. One of the ways I seek to make use of such experiences is to ask the students at the beginning of the course to write for me their moral autobiography, discussing how they have, to that point, developed as moral beings, including any significant moral problems they have faced and the effect this has had on them. 4. This view is, I believe, the basis of the students’ initial idea that morality and self-interest diverge—an action is moral only if it is done for the sake of others, not for one’s own sake. If I act as morality would require in order to impress others, then it is not really a moral action. 5. At least as something about which we can have knowledge. 6. Some students are very committed to the welfare of animals and do their community service in animal shelters. I point out how such service can be seen as moral in terms of Mill’s utilitarian theory, in that animals, like people, can suffer, and utilitarian theory is concerned with the alleviation of suffering. This contrasts with the view of Kant, who thought primary moral obligations are owed only to rational beings. 7. The discussion of these differences in how the theorists would view service and service-learning drives home to the students that there is not one theoretical framework for understanding the value of service and its role in the course. 8. One student, working off of Mill’s remark regarding the quality of pleasures, that it is better to be a Socrates dissatisfied than a fool satisfied, suggested that it is better to be a participant in community service dissatisfied than a nonparticipant satisfied. 9. On this distinction, see Eugene Valentine, “Service-Learning as a Vehicle for Teaching Philosophy,” in Beyond the Tower: Concepts and Models for Service-learning in Philosophy, ed. David Lisman and Irene Harvey (Washington, DC: American Association for Higher Education, 2000), 139–66, at 142–43. 10. See Sally Scholz, “Service-learning in Ethics: A New Pedagogical Approach to the Old Theory-versus-Practice Challenge,” in Beyond the Tower, ed. David Lisman and Irene Harvey (Washington, DC: American Association for Higher Education, 2000), 185–92, at 185–86. 11. For example, for a few years now, all incoming students at my institution perform community service as part of their first-year orientation program. 12. This is confirmed by my colleague Craig Rimmerman, the editor of this volume, who periodically does surveys in his political science and public policy classes about the political consciousness and activity of his students. 13. An example of this is offered by Eugene Valentine, who raises the question whether the neediness of individuals with whom our students work is due more to a lack of values on their part (their fault) or a lack of social and economic opportu-
Service-Learning in an Ethics Course
19
nities (society’s fault). See his “Service-learning,” p. 152. Which of these assumptions is more embedded in our social service policies and institutions, and does this help or hinder addressing the needs? 14. This is complicated, in ways I will not explore here, by the distinction between perfect and imperfect moral obligations (as presented in Kant’s theory). Both sorts of obligation must be performed, but perfect obligations are owed to particular individuals, while imperfect obligations are not. We have choice, in the case of imperfect obligations, about whom we assist in carrying out the obligation. 15. I refer to this as the “thousand points of light” criticism, after the phrase used by the first President Bush in recommending an increase in private efforts, rather than an increase in public efforts, to address the problems of need in our society.
2 Service-Learning: Process and Participation Jack D. Harris
As an experiential learning experience attached to a course, service-learning requires additional preparation and attention to process. Service-learning does not happen by itself and much can go wrong if it is not done correctly. Students may be indelibly imprinted to their prejudices, relationships between the college and service agencies may be damaged, and those receiving the services that students provide could come to harm. To insure that the service-learning experience meets our pedagogical needs, to insure that there is a reliable stable of community partners willing to collaborate with us to provide effective service-learning activities, and to insure that our service-learning agenda provides bona fide service to the community, careful planning must be accomplished together with the community partners. On the one hand, service-learning is not unlike other forms of experiential learning through which students enrich their study of a subject by having some practical, hands-on experience. The intention is for students to deepen their theoretical understanding of a component of everyday human activity by enacting the theory from a practitioner’s point of view. However, service-learning, unlike most other experiential learning activities, places students in an emotionally charged and value-laden environment in which there may be a myriad of hazards. For example, in such environments, interactions may be strained by the students’ superior status by virtue of their economic class, education, social success, or race. Agency clients may be especially vulnerable and require particular care. Information on a person may be held in strict confidence. Neighborhoods may be less than safe in which students travel and do service tasks.
21
22
Jack D. Harris
To complicate matters, we teach students that service-learning is not “charity” and that an attitude of noblesse oblige is an archaic and elitist stance (of course, by virtue of their university student status they are elites in American society). Certainly, requiring course-based service-learning declares an imperative about the good: Civic engagement, citizenship, and personal responsibility are invoked as a social virtue that challenges our students’ moral and ethical values. Students are to learn they should be, routinely, community participants and activist partners in community wellbeing, Moreover, the human beings and organizations who are the subjects of our study and with whom we interact (it is, after all, learning that is the primary point of the service-learning experience) often do not behave as neatly as our theories describe, nor are they as grateful as we hope they will be, nor are our students necessarily as sympathetic as we would like to imagine. Who of us teachers has not had a student return from a service experience confirmed in their prejudices about the persons or groups for whom they are providing service? As a result of these complexities, structuring and staging experiential service-learning experience to work through these nuances and minefields requires an awareness of these issues and very careful planning. Campus Compact (2007) has a thorough and especially useful website with excellent resources for faculty about service-learning, including pointers and references to other service-learning-related sites. Service-learning course planning should consider several issues: • • • • • •
Student placement method; Student orientation to service-learning; Engaging a “service-learning colleague”; Including service-learning community partners; Tactics for classroom-based service-learning; Institutional integration.
STUDENT PLACEMENT There are many different venues in which students can do service-learning and be civically engaged. Some agencies provide social services, some provide educational services, and others provide civic services. The social service agencies provide community service opportunities for our students to work for and with people who are often destitute, hungry, or sick. Mentors in these agencies, such as a free lunch program, work in a nursing home, work at the food pantry, and the like provide models of leadership and a thoughtful caring that are of great benefit to our students.
Service-Learning: Process and Participation
23
Educational agencies, primarily schools, provide opportunities for our students to work with groups of students or as tutors to a single student. Students can be placed into government-sponsored programs such as America Reads and America Counts, or community-based agencies such as Boys and Girls Clubs. Students can work with bilingual preschoolers, children with learning challenges, or students with disabilities. Such experiences often lead to emotional bonds and a sense of accomplishment, along with the realization of how much there is still to do. Civic agencies are generally not-for-profit or government agencies that provide some tangible benefit to citizens. Students can work in environmental awareness agencies, downtown redevelopment, housing authorities, fine arts councils, and the like. Students often like doing service-learning in these settings because the work is often project-oriented with a chance of completion before the semester has ended. While there may be debate about which forms of civic engagement are of the most value to the community, and which forms cultivate the most effective service-learning, the quality of the organization and the talents of the mentor are a better index of value for the purposes of classroom-related activity than perceived social value. There are three primary strategies for student placement, and there are combinations of each: 1. Random assignment of students to a multitude of community partners; 2. Allowing individual students to choose based on a list of community partners and descriptions; 3. Creating teams of students who deliberate and choose an agency with which to work. The first model too often seeks to liquidate the number of requests for student volunteers from potential service sites. This distorts the pedagogy in several ways. Students go in without having participated in a deliberation or education about the agency or site. The second model seeks to allow individual students choice with the idea that they might be more motivated. Asking students to rank their choices also allows for coverage of the requests from potential service sites. This promises better learning than random assignment. Attaching student clusters (teams) to a community partner to create site coverage (which provides for reciprocity) and to allow small group work provides for common experiences among students. Teams can be the basis of teamwork between the students and with the community partner. Exercises can be devised that make them liaisons between the community partner and the campus, conveying to the campus
24
Jack D. Harris
information about the agency and service, producing lesson plans for the course with community partner, presenting public poster sessions and recognition events, managing Blackboard discussions about their site and their experiences, and producing a team paper on their service-learning experience.
STUDENT ORIENTATION TO SERVICE-LEARNING How we convey the context of service-learning to students is a challenge that must be addressed in the orientation to service-learning prior to the students’ initial engagement. It is here that students can have a discussion that explores the differences between public service–based servicelearning, community volunteering, and charity, a subject that invariably finds its way repeatedly into class discussion. An orientation must be unambiguous about the primary focus of the activity, which is the learning related to the course material, but also about the nature of civic engagement and ongoing good citizenship, identification with the commonweal, and a sustaining community connection. In this way, there is always context, text, and subtext. Pedagogically, service-learning links theory with practice, and is part of our interest in developing the feeling intellect. Service-learning integrates the real world with the academic world. Service-learning affirms the idea that the individual citizen can be involved and active in his or her community and make a difference. Service-learning and acts of public service are acts of creating community. In the process of service, students become leaders and active agents in community making, and become a critical component in affirming self and other, as they create a web of relationships through acts of public service. Students are unlikely to be prepared for many of the initial experiences inherent in a service-learning work environment. Throughout the semester, students will reveal a set of cognitive and emotional responses in their service engagements that should be understood rightly as cognitive and affective developmental challenges. These must be addressed transparently during the orientation. This will provide students with a framework for cognizing, and recognizing, these social and social-psychological responses as they participate in self-reflection and self-reflexive discussions inside and outside of the classroom. It is likely that students will display considerable disengagement to the service-learning component of the course. There are plenty of reasons why students are disengaged. Some arrive at college self-absorbed, or needing to earn money, or simply into a student routine. Students often say that they do not have the time to fit the service required by the service-learning
Service-Learning: Process and Participation
25
course component into their busy day. Surprisingly, after the service-learning experience they often confess that they did not realize how much time they were wasting. When students register for a course, they may not be aware that there is a service-learning component. When they discover this, it is often too late to drop the course and register for another. Our claims that service-learning is voluntary is, frankly, suspect. Students are captives to our syllabus. The first effort to engage their enthusiasm for the service-learning activity is in its initial presentation to students when introducing the syllabus, and next at the service-learning orientation. The introduction to the syllabus is a critical learning moment because it sets the stage for student engagement in the course and the service-learning activities. It requires thoughtful persuasion on the part of the faculty member to begin a dialogue about why and how students should embrace the responsibilities and rewards of engaged citizenship. Avoid preaching, ask questions to understand where the students are about their role as citizens in their society, and work through with them the idea of civic engagement that is at the core of the service-learning enterprise. Another problem to be addressed during the orientation is one of social distance. Depending on a particular student’s social location (class, ethnicity, race, gender), they often feel significant social distance between themselves as college students and their new clients. There are many barriers of difference to overcome. What is the nature, and the desired outcome, of the social interaction between our students as service providers and the people whom they will encounter who are the recipients of their service? Agencies have different concepts of these relationships. Names for the recipients of services vary from clients, consumers, and partners, and these names all help faculty to understand what social relationship the community partner seeks to establish. Depending on that relationship, students may be expected to close the social distance or to maintain it. Certainly, students will be challenged about their motives and credentials, and should have authentic responses that do not confuse the relationship. In addition, in the classroom some faculty may talk about the participants as “subjects” and this must be held distinct from the relationship to which the community partner is oriented. A third challenge to be addressed at orientation and throughout the semester reflections is student stereotypes and prejudices. Many students have grown up in a society in which their understanding of class, racial, and ethnic differences are filled with stereotypes and prejudices. Not surprisingly, students are likely to deny that they have any prejudices at all. Without a proper orientation to the dynamics of prejudice, students may believe that what they are seeing confirms prejudices (“See, they spend their money on junk food . . .”). The other result is often exceptionalism. Students may
26
Jack D. Harris
present their service story by referring to the people for whom they are providing service as “different” from others of their race, ethnicity, religion, or social class. In this way students can imperfectly reconcile maintenance of their stereotypes and prejudices while having a more open and kindly approach to the person who is receiving their service. How then are we to help the students to build bridges based on feelings of empathy and the recognition of human commonalities and differences? How are we to confront prejudices and stereotypes? In all of these cases, establishing boundaries, clear operating procedures, and unambiguous discussion of these issues with the students, in a dialogue with the community partners, will do much to fostering the learning objectives of the service-learning experience. Confronting students often fosters shame or guilt that may lead students to be silent rather than to participate openly in class discussions. By recognizing, first in oneself, and supported by course materials, that prejudice is an everyday dynamic of our society and pervasive and deeply embedded in the culture, students can create an intellectual framework for processing their own thinking and feeling and begin to come into dialogue with others on these hard issues for self and group reflection. Careful reflection, less as personal therapy and more nuanced by the texts, lectures, and discussion, can provide a context where students will realize that they belong to a bigger human circle, and their own humanity and their awareness of themselves and others can become more expansive as well. It is through reflecting on their interaction with others in less familiar situations that students begin to understand the nature of difference, the organization and purpose of social institutions, and an appreciation for the unequal life chances and unequal opportunities that are so fundamental to our experiences in American society. As part of the service-learning orientation, students might be presented with a list of activities and asked to evaluate and rank how each might be understood as “civic engagement” (see figure 2.1). The list might contain activities such as joining the armed forces, helping to start an after-school program for children whose parents work, talking with a friend about a social issue of importance to you, giving blood, working for a candidate in a local election, serving on a jury, and the like. Having the students rank each activity provides an opportunity for value clarification and an opportunity to discover what the class values as well. It provides a basis for lively discussion when students discover that aggregation of their selections displays a consensus or dissensus among students in the classroom. Once students have a sense of the range of activities that constitute civic engagement, they are better prepared to understand several critical concepts related to the service-learning experience. There are several ways to talk about service-learning, with its emphasis on citizenship and civic engagement. The first is to introduce our students to the concept of community. Certainly, in a world in which, as Disraeli re-
Service-Learning: Process and Participation Figure 2.1.
27
How Do You Define Civic Engagement?
The concept of civic engagement is about acting in such a way that it contributes to the public good. People define civic engagement in many different ways. Some people think of it as activities centered around being a good citizen, while others think of it as activities centered around serving the community. Represented below are actions that people might cite as exemplary civic engagement. Place a 1 next to the action that most closely models your own idea of civic engagement. Place a 2 next to the action that is the second closest, and so on, up to 15. Joining the armed forces. Helping to start an after-school program for children whose parents work. Talking with a friend about a social issue of importance to you. Working for a candidate in a local election. Serving on a jury. Picketing and protesting at a local plant that has laid off a large number of its workforce. Giving to a not-for-profit charitable organization. Leaving your car at home and biking or walking to work or school every day. Tutoring a migrant worker. Attending a neighborhood meeting. Providing dinner once a week at a homeless shelter. Visiting different houses of worship (churches, synagogues, mosques, etc.) every week to learn about different religions in the community. Giving blood. Driving within the posted speed limit in a school zone. Voting. Source : Adapted from Rick Battistoni “How do you Define Citizenship?” (2002), originally from Nadinne Cruz, “How Do You Define Service?” (2002) [February,1996].
marked, “modern society acknowledges no neighbor,” our students, more often than not, have not experienced community. Such a community, however sentimentalized, is represented in the American imagination by the small town, its volunteer fire department, and neighborhood and often faith-based assistance to neighbors. It is a social entity that continues to exist in the United States but is challenged by the sterility and monotony of a suburbanized and bureaucratized America. One task, then, is to reground the students in the concepts of community and mutual aid.
28
Jack D. Harris
In addition, students often suggest that they need to “settle down” in one place after college before they can engage in civic participation. But our students are not settling down—they have several careers and move about the country (and countries) across their careers. The challenge for the teacher is to help the students conceive that their school, and the community in which it resides, is the first of many communities they will join, and that civic participation will be a series of engagements in community making and building throughout their lives. Several diagrams are useful to help students understand these themes. The first is a representation of the “concentric circles of community” (see figure 2.2). From village to town, from Vietnam to the United States, traditional communities have had the property of embracing the individual in concentric circles of attachment and obligation. As such, individuals defer to the
Figure 2.2.
The Concentric Circles of Community
Service-Learning: Process and Participation
29
group, positive membership and negative shame are the primary social psychological drivers, and communities generally take care of their own. The second diagram represents a “segmented society,” one that students generally recognize immediately as closer to their own (see figure 2.3). Sociologically, this type of society is based on the individual as the primary social unit, and contract as the basis of agreement and obligation. In such societies the experience of community is generally limited to family. Specialized agencies, whether governmental, not-for-profit, or faithbased, typically substitute for the mutual aid found in the local village, community, and neighborhood. A third diagram, a simple grid, demonstrates that there are multiple opportunities for engagement, and that engaged citizens discover what they value and make choices about where to put their energies (see figure 2.4). The “Point X” moment is a time and place in which a person chooses to self-consciously act and to engage. We all have many Point X moments every day in which, through our action in various settings, we express our full commitment, our focused engagement to our mission or our goals and objectives. For a teacher, for example, Point X opportunities happen in the classroom, when advising a student, when engaging in scholarship, or when participating in curricular discussions. Service-learning is an occasion for Point X engagement in the civic life and well-being of the student’s oncampus and off-campus community, while exploring the practical parameters and consequences of a classroom lecture or text.
Figure 2.3.
Segmented Society
30
Jack D. Harris
Figure 2.4.
“Point X” Opportunities
One challenge to us, and to our students, is the paralysis of choice, in which there are so many social needs and so many venues for civic engagement that it is difficult to choose to commit to any course of action. The other challenge is a claim that one act of civic engagement is more valuable than another. While for practiced social analysts and cost-benefit experts that may be so, the reality is that people engage in what they value, in the context of competing demands and time and energy constraints. One of the key benefits of service-learning is the opportunity for our students to individually and collectively clarify their own values, develop new ones, and make choices that are right for them. A final theme is one of leadership and responsibility. During the servicelearning experience students often find themselves struggling with the social distance between themselves and their “clients.” Perhaps students are working in an alcohol rehabilitation clinic where clients are disheveled or have been economically unsuccessful, or they are working in an educational setting where the parents seem disinterested in their child’s education and progress. What are our expectations of students, emotionally and politically? This is a tricky business. Do we want them to feel sympathy? Do we want them to suspend personal judgment and their sense of disappointment in another? We cannot be too proscriptive here and preach, but what we can do is teach. What do our texts say, what is the stance of our disciplines or our perspectives? Good citizenship and good leadership go hand-in-hand. A compelling view of good leadership is that of the inverted pyramid (see figure 2.5).1 Good leadership is “customer driven” and is a critical component of good service, and it creates effective partnerships between collaborators.
Service-Learning: Process and Participation
Figure 2.5.
31
Inverted Leadership Pyramid
Leaders are at the bottom of this pyramid (as distinct from the top) because they provide the firm foundation for the organization or activity. Their authority as a leader is their ability to sustain, take responsibility for, and organize critical activities. The leaders’ broad shoulders support the mission of the organization as it serves the “client.” At its best, this is the role we imagine for our students in their adult lives, and students are likely to see this form of service leadership enacted in the community partner mentor. Our use of the service-learning experience is to provide a grounded understanding of the social and personal contexts of the human experience and to value forms of social engagement that honor the humane and the just. This is the goal of service-learning, especially as it is practiced in the liberal arts. All of these themes may be introduced in the orientation to servicelearning. Teachers and students will find in these themes a useful baseline to return to throughout the course. Student reflections on the value of the service they are doing, the needs of the people who are being serviced, and the student’s responsibilities as a member of a community are fruitful points of discussion as students move though the developmental stages of their service-learning experience.
32
Jack D. Harris
ENGAGING A “SERVICE-LEARNING COLLEAGUE” If the faculty member is lucky enough to have a public service office with experienced students trained in service-learning, or if there is a practiced student from the faculty member’s previous course, it is extremely useful to have a “service-learning colleague.” A student in this role has two critical tasks. First, the student is a teaching assistant and a thoughtful model of reflective learning activity. The service-learning colleague becomes a critical conduit for discussion that inspires the students in the course. In cooperation with the colleague, teachers can develop a series of classroom and homework exercises that match the developmental stages of student services experiences with the sequence of course materials. Second, the student is likely to be present in class and, more often, at the student service sites and will be an experienced hand at working directly on student issues with the community partner. It is best when service-learning colleagues earn credit (rather than cash) for an independent study or course equivalent.
INCLUDING SERVICE-LEARNING COMMUNITY PARTNERS An effective relationship with community partners is critical to the success of service-learning activities. Launching students into an agency, institution, or a department is a serious endeavor and it will be the community partner who is the primary supervisor of student service activities. While students are appreciated for the added value they bring in extending services or providing additional support, the service-learning component should not be merely “dental extraction” where we ask the agency to meet our curricular needs, but not in a reciprocal and collaborative relationship. Bringing the community partner into the planning process, and including them in classroom sessions, are effective ways to create reciprocity and collaboration. It is important to narrow the focus to specific agencies, institutions, or departments so that distribution of students is manageable, the servicelearning objectives can be reliably met, and programmatic themes can be developed and mature. This will allow the development of long-term relationships with several well-seasoned and trained community partners who are ready, willing, and able to be mentors to students. Community partners will do their own orientation to their agency, institution, or department, and this orientation should cohere with the orientation provided by the teacher. The point is that this must truly be a partnership, and it is worthwhile to ask community partners to be present at the student orientation, to make a contribution to the presentation, and to be prepared to come
Service-Learning: Process and Participation
33
into the classroom to participate in discussions. Workshops held for prospective and current community partners that provide them with the context for service-learning allow them to help define their role in the experiential activity, develop collaborative themes (diversity, leadership, and civic engagement work well), and generate authentic service activities critical to the maintenance of student motivation, all insuring greater success and honoring the expertise community partners bring to the table.
TACTICS FOR CLASSROOM-BASED SERVICE-LEARNING Service-learning can be placed in the syllabus as something that is supplemental and periodic, or it can be used as the experiential base of the course with a full array of activities and exercises to support it and to amplify course material. At its most ambitious, it is a full-court press. The following is a design that makes service-learning a collective, collaborative, and central course component: 1. Service teams are created around each community partner agency and a community partner mentor. 2. The faculty member (and/or the service-learning colleagues) mentors service teams and develops agency relationships. 3. Teams are the liaison for the class to community partner. They take on the following tasks: a. Development of a service-learning website about the agency and its service; b. Create a lesson plan with the community partner mentor, and conduct a class session about the agency in the context of assigned readings; c. Service teams create a public poster session and a recognition event. 4. The faculty member (and/or the service-learning colleagues) manages and encourages use of Blackboard discussion board. 5. Each service team writes a public problem statement. 6. Each individual team member writes an initial paper demonstrating his or her understanding of the organization’s strategic objectives and operations. 7. Each team writes a final paper reflecting on individual and collective service-learning experiences, lessons learned, and an assessment about the services performed, including self-reflective evaluation of their own attendance, attentiveness, and performance.
34
Jack D. Harris
Note that this model is relatively labor intensive and requires the faculty member or service-learning colleague to be directly involved in monitoring service-learning activity. Some schools also have public service offices with staff that do the on-site follow-up and monitoring of student service activity. Modifications are possible to this most ambitious plan, based on what else is planned for the course, what other course demands there are that semester, and the energy and commitment of community partner mentors. A more streamlined effort might eliminate the development of the website and the public poster session activity. In addition, one could also eliminate the class sessions with the community mentor and students, although this has proved to be quite valuable in cementing the servicelearning experience and the relationship between the community partner and the faculty member. In students’ first encounter with the service-related organization, and prepared by course readings, students can be asked to write a public problem statement for their community service organization.2 In such an exercise, useful for their first formal assignment, students are asked to consider the following: • • • • • • •
Why does the problem exist? What are the consequences of the problem? What makes it a “public” problem? How many people does it affect? Is there more than one cause? Are there political, cultural, economic effects? Are the causes interdependent?
This exercise creates opportunities for careful and significant reflection, and is likely to tie directly back to the course texts and critical concepts. It is an example of how designing the process of the service-learning experience, combined with participation in significant and critical reflection activities, can contribute to achieving the learning objectives of the course. As students commence their service experience they can be assigned to collect the mission statement of the community partner’s agency, an organization chart, and annual reports and statistics about the agency’s services. This is a great exercise in context making and broadens the student’s experience of his or her service activities. Specifically, it teaches the students to be attentive to the strategic goals and objectives of the program, agency, or institution, including the claims of purpose, resolve, results, and value made to the larger funding audience. It also helps students to understand the supporting tactics that are used in service of the strategic claims, and that as student volunteers they are enacting a part of the tactical in service to the strategic. A second and perhaps final paper can be an assessment that reconsiders the strategic goals and supporting tactics.
Service-Learning: Process and Participation
35
A good example of how a student can link the tactical back to the strategic can be found in this brief excerpt from a student’s final paper. The firstyear student has understood the need for, and the unfortunate absence of collaboration that is hindering the program from achieving its objectives. Note that she is suggesting a practical communications plan, a critical part of any successful project:
Figure 2.6. There are two parts to this paper. The first part is a description of the organization within which you are working. The second is a contextualization of the organization’s function in the context of current readings. For the first part you should: 1. Identify the mission of the organization within which you are participating in community service; 2. Identify the nature of the clients for whom the organization serves; 3. Produce an organization chart indicating the nature of the formal social relationships between coworkers and workers and clients; 4. Recognize and report the actual processes of interaction that you have observed and interpret and report the meaning that the participants give to their behavior; 5. Interpret and report any other structures of meaning that may be embedded in the interaction and behavior. For the second part you should consider the mission of the organization within which you are participating in community service in the applicable national contexts described by George Ritzer in McDonaldization of Society, Derber in Pursuit of Attention, the maps, and the class lectures.
Figure 2.7. In this paper I want you to do the following: 1. Identify, analyze, and explain the social forces and social problems that create the conditions your volunteer site seeks to ameliorate. Be sociological! Use sociological concepts such as social organization, social stratification, stereotyping, and the dynamics of race and gender, to analyze and explain. 2. Evaluate and discuss the success of your volunteer site in terms of its mission. 3. Are the site coordinators optimistic or pessimistic about what the agency is accomplishing, and the future of its services? Why? Are you optimistic or pessimistic about what the agency is accomplishing, and the future of its services? Why? Based on your sociological analysis, what would you do differently to ameliorate the conditions that are the context for the agencies services?
36
Jack D. Harris
For my community service project, I volunteered through the America Reads organization. America Reads is an organization that works to promote child literacy and to “ensure that every child can read well and independently by the end of third grade.” The organization was founded because there was and continues to be a high instance of illiteracy in the United States, due in part to inadequate education in public schools, especially for children with learning disabilities. . . . There are, however, several things I would change. First of all, the amount of time spent each session is not sufficient to get a substantial amount of work done. We are supposed to be there for an hour, but we usually arrive a bit late, and the children lose interest when they know that their parents will be picking them up soon. I also think that the communication between the child’s teacher, the parents, and the tutor needs to be improved. The way I see it, each child’s success is the number one goal of the three people involved in terms of the program, and without that communication, the child may feel confused. I felt disadvantaged for several reasons because I had so little communication with Sean’s parents and teachers. First of all, a child like Sean needs to be in a highly structured environment where people can make sure that he is in fact on top of all of his assignments and that he understands what is expected of him. There were several instances where Sean would say that he did not want to work on a particular task with me because his Mom liked to help him with it. At the next session, he usually had not done it. . . . To solve this problem, I think that I would set up a meeting at least once or twice during the year to simply meet the child’s teacher and parent, even if it were for a few minutes one day after school. This would serve as a forum to plan a communication system for the year and for the parent and teacher to inform the tutor a little bit about the child, his/her strengths and weaknesses, and possible goals for the year. Obviously, the tutors have lives outside of this program, as do the parents, so a solid basis of checks would keep the child’s progress a priority. [Andrea Katkish, William Smith College]
SERVICE-LEARNING AS AN INSTITUTIONALLY INTEGRATED ACTIVITY IN TIME AND SPACE Service-learning has a life beyond the single classroom. In many cases several faculty are providing service-learning opportunities as part of their course curriculum. There are significant opportunities to leverage all of this service-based activity. The success of this may depend on formal administrative structures, or it may be the result of organized faculty collaboration. In its fullest form, service-learning can be integrated into campus and student life and diffused and infused into the larger college curriculum. While such an institutional enterprise can be thematically agnostic, the most effective programs are likely to settle on a set of conceptual themes, or a particular set of concrete service goals and objectives. Much of what is en-
Service-Learning: Process and Participation
37
acted as service-learning already coheres with some of the national themes espoused by Campus Compact and the AAC&U. Such themes as diversity learning, leadership development, and the value of civic engagement are infused in service-learning programs nationwide. See figure 2.8 for an institutional service-learning model that focuses on particular conceptual themes, uses strong partnerships with selected community partners, and eschews the silos so common on college campuses to reach out in collaboration with faculty and administrative units beyond the classroom. Such a model provides several venues for service-learning, infusing and integrating a campus, and providing students with the opportunity for consciously designed integrative service-learning experiences throughout the student’s on-campus career. An institutional strategy for effective civic engagement would embrace the planning and processes discussed earlier in this chapter. As isolated learning experiences, courses that include service-learning have their own value. However, an integrated approach would maximize and reinforce the service-learning experience. Our students would come to understand that service-learning is not an isolated activity and that their local service work is linked to broader global service activities. In uniting the theoretical and analytical with practical action, our students would be reinforced that ideas have consequences and that they can make effective contributions to the world in which they live.
SERVICE-LEARNING AND OUTCOMES FOR THE STUDENT AND THE COMMUNITY What are we seeking when we encourage students to go out and serve the community, and more specifically when we ask them to participate in “service-learning” courses? Too often we work to sell the students on “civic engagement,” our often-used term for citizen participation in one’s community. Most students understand this, and a large number will testify that they found the experience satisfying and will do it again. In fact, based on solid research from scholars of service-learning such as Zlotkowski, Astin et al., Eyler et al., Vogelsgang and Astin, and Steinke and Buresh,3 among others, we know that service-learning creates positive cognitive outcomes and an affective disposition that may motivate students to additional volunteer community service after the service-learning course. However, hopes that the majority of students will continue to find service placements during their college career, and later become active citizens in their communities, may be overestimated. Two approaches may secure powerful benefits for our students and for the community. The first, mentioned earlier, is a more integrated approach that demonstrates to students that civic engagement is an important part of
Figure 2.8.
A Model for Institutionally Integrated Service-Learning
Service-Learning: Process and Participation
39
everyday life. The second is to provide, in the context of service-learning and community service, essential skills that will serve them now and in the future, and that students’ value. Such skills include developing and practicing the arts of persuasion and leadership, developing effective communication skills, becoming a problem solver, learning to be an analyst, and learning to be a good organizer.
NOTES 1. The source of the idea of the “inverted pyramid” is unknown. It is a concept used in management in many customer-service-oriented and public service, not-forprofit organizations. 2. Adapted from Community Service Practicum (Fall 1999), Rick Battistoni and Dana Farrell, instructors, Providence College. 3. See Edward Zlotkowski, Successful Service Learning Programs: New Models of Excellence in Higher Education (Bolton, MA: Anker Publishing Co., Inc., 1998); Alexander W. Astin, Lori J. Vogelgesang, Elaine K. Ikeda, Jennifer A. Yee, “How Service Learning Affects Students” (Los Angeles: Higher Education Research Institute, 2000), available at: www.gseis.ucla.edu/heri/PDFs/HSLAS/HSLAS.PDF (accessed May 24, 2007); Janet Eyler, Dwight E. Giles Jr., Christine M. Stenson, Charlene J. Gray, At a Glance: What We Know About the Effects of Service-Learning On College Students, Faculty, Institutions and Communities, 1993–2000, 3rd ed. (Nashville, TN: Vanderbilt University, 2001), available at: servicelearning.org/filemanager/ download/4192_AtAGlance.pdf (accessed May 24, 2007); Lori Vogelsgesang and Alexander Astin, “Comparing the Effects of Community Service and ServiceLearning,” Michigan Journal of Community Service Learning 7 (2000): 25–34; Pamela Steinke and Stacey Buresh, “Cognitive Outcomes of Service Learning: Reviewing the Past and Glimpsing the Future,” Michigan Journal of Community Service Learning 8, no. 2 (2002): 5–14.
3 Understanding Service at the Service of Understanding: An Exploration of Service-Learning in the Arts Patrick M. Collins
The educational goals and objectives that may be served by service-learning are both various and variable and depend on factors such as the population to be served, the needs of the students involved, the demands and structures of the academic discipline in question, and the pedagogical preferences of the instructor.1 Despite this potential variety of purpose, service-learning is often justified on two grounds. First, service-learning is promoted as a means of educating students for civic engagement. In this case, though as Battistoni points out civic engagement may be understood in many ways, the argument is that community service is significant as a tool for developing the kinds of attitudes, skills, and knowledge necessary for one to function as a socially responsible member of a democratic society.2 Second, many argue from a Dewian perspective that service-learning is justified as a form of experiential education. Genuine education requires active learning, learning that calls for both action and reflection, and, in so far as community service actively engages students in meaningful experiences for reflection, it represents a powerful pedagogy regardless of discipline.3 On this view service-learning serves an epistemic function beyond that of civic understanding. The suggestion here is that it can foster understanding in domains other than the civic. Clearly, both experiential learning and civic education are noble ideals and so their intersection in service-learning seems to provide a double-barreled case for service-learning. One of the assumptions at work here is that the civic and the epistemic dimensions of servicelearning reinforce, or at least complement, each other. But is this necessarily the case? Much service-learning is aimed at civic education, but there are also many instances in which civic aims are secondary to more 41
42
Patrick M. Collins
traditional academic, or what I call epistemic, aims of a course. Are there instances in which the civic requirement of service may undermine other epistemic aims of experiential learning?4 I intend to explore this issue by examining a course that I teach entitled Drama in a Developmental Context.
ON THE ARTS, EDUCATION, AND THE LIBERAL ARTS Drama in a Developmental Context is a liberal arts course taught within the Education Department at Hobart and William Smith, but it is not a teacher education course designed for pre-service teachers. Faculty in the Education Department split their time between teaching within the teacher certification program and teaching liberal arts courses in education. In order to fully understand the nature of Drama in a Developmental Context, one first needs to understand these two aspects of our work as they relate to the liberal arts education we try to provide our students. The teacher certification program at Hobart and William Smith Colleges is based on two assumptions: (1) People best learn to teach by teaching and then systematically reflecting on that practice, and (2) good teachers need a background in the liberal arts that is both broad and deep. All students who wish to certify as elementary or secondary teachers do so by completing the teacher education program in addition to completing a full academic program in the liberal arts. The colleges do not offer a major in education. Students who wish to certify do so by completing four semesters of part-time fieldwork in local classrooms and at least five professional “teacher seminars” that do not carry any academic credit but are recognized by New York State as meeting the requirements for certification.5 The teacher seminars are designed to provide students with background on the nuts and bolts of teaching (methods and techniques) while also providing them with opportunities to reflect on their work in schools. Students complete these practica and seminars concurrent with a full load of liberal arts courses, which means their work in the teacher certification program is essentially an overload.6 Education Department faculty spend half of their time teaching these professional seminars and supervising students in the schools and spend the other half of their load teaching liberal arts courses in education. The Education Department offers a wide range of liberal arts courses. These are not traditional courses on methods of teaching and they are independent of the teacher certification program. Liberal arts courses in education, which are open to all students at the colleges, are theoretically based courses that explore issues of education from a variety of disciplinary and often interdisciplinary perspectives. In addition to traditional courses on the foundations (e.g., history and philosophy) of education, the department offers courses on topics such as literacy, multicultural education, sci-
Understanding Service at the Service of Understanding
43
entific and mathematical thinking, special education, popular culture, and education and the arts. The purpose of these courses is not to prepare teachers (the majority of students in most courses are not in teacher certification). The primary purpose of liberal arts courses is to provide students from across campus with a rich array of opportunities to examine the meaning, significance, and potential of education on a variety of levels: personal, social, cultural, and historical. These courses often examine the theory and practice of education in terms of each other with the ultimate goal of helping students gain a better understanding of the nature of educational endeavors as they relate to the human condition. Drama in a Developmental Context is one of these courses. My own approach to teaching this course within the context of the liberal arts is based on my assumptions about the aims of education and about the nature of the arts as ways of knowing. The basic aim of a liberal arts education is to provide students with the tools they need not only to understand themselves and the worlds in which they live, but also to help them acquire the wherewithal to ultimately be able to change, remake, or recreate themselves and those worlds. The aim of a liberal arts education is to help students develop the knowledge, skills, attitudes, values, and dispositions necessary to engage in acts of what Nelson Goodman referred to as worldmaking. Goodman’s use of this term does not necessarily have social or political implications, but it is meant to capture the transformative power of cognitive activity at large. For Goodman, worldmaking is essentially a cognitive act and different kinds of thinking constitute different “ways of worldmaking.”7 Howard Gardner has followed in the footsteps of Goodman in arguing for a symbol systems approach to human cognition.8 In this view, the primary means by which humans come to gain knowledge and understanding is through the use of various symbol systems. The most familiar of these is language, but other common symbol systems of note include systems such as mathematics, biology, physics, history, philosophy, painting, dance, and drama. Each of the symbol systems available to an individual potentially provides that individual with a different view of the world. Different symbol systems provide us with different kinds of knowledge and understanding. The actor and the biologist may each study human movement, but they apply different symbol systems in doing so and therefore they each provide us with a different set of understandings about that movement. Different symbol systems provide us with different ways of worldmaking. The various symbol systems mastered by an individual provide a person with a number of windows through which he or she may learn about the world, and one of the primary purposes of a liberal arts education should be to provide students with a variety of such windows. One of the measures of a liberally educated person is the degree to which he or she has mastered a wide range of symbol systems. A fundamental goal of a liberal arts education should
44
Patrick M. Collins
be to move students toward what may be called symbolic literacy by helping them develop a working understanding of multiple symbol systems central to the arts, sciences, and everyday life.9 One of the implications of this view of education is that each of the arts, as symbol systems, cannot just be viewed as natural modes of expression or creativity, but that they must be recognized (and taught) as fundamental ways of knowing and that as such we have a responsibility to move students toward literacy in the arts as well as in language, mathematics, science, or technology. The arts are basic ways of worldmaking.
DRAMA IN A DEVELOPMENTAL CONTEXT I have been teaching Drama in a Developmental Context at the colleges for approximately a dozen years. The underlying epistemic aim of the course is to move students toward dramatic literacy by helping them develop a basic understanding of the potential of drama to influence human development at both the personal and sociocultural levels.10 As used here, the term drama is best defined as “an improvisational, nonexihibitional, process-centered form of drama in which participants are guided by a leader to imagine, enact, and reflect upon human experiences.”11 In this case drama does not include dramatic literature but is a participatory activity that is related to, yet distinct from, both theatre and the natural play of young children. Within these parameters drama is a comprehensive term that applies to a variety of pedagogical approaches, including creative dramatics, improvisation, drama in education, informal drama, and process drama.12 The goal of the course is not to prepare students to teach drama but to help them develop an understanding of the potential of dramatic activity for furthering human development in the hope that such an understanding will inform the lives they lead and the work they do (as citizens, parents, taxpayers, community activists, professionals, etc.), regardless of the paths they choose upon graduation. My hope is that the course will provide students with the motivation and conceptual background they need to become genuine advocates for the inclusion of drama (and the arts at large) in education. Drama in a Developmental Context is a small course that is generally limited to eighteen students. The course draws students from a variety of disciplinary backgrounds: Some have backgrounds in theatre or education, but many don’t. There are no prerequisites. The course, which meets for two eighty-five-minute periods a week, integrates three different kinds of pedagogy: reading and discussion, drama workshops, and educational outreach. During the first ten or eleven weeks of the course, class time is divided between discussion and workshops. After initially exploring the nature of drama, especially as it relates to both theatre and the dramatic play of young children, students read and discuss a wide range of theoretical and
Understanding Service at the Service of Understanding
45
research-based material that examines the potential functions of drama. The issues addressed in these discussions include the role of drama in developing aesthetic sensibility, language skills, critical thinking abilities, and social skills; the expressive and therapeutic functions of dramatic activity; drama as a mechanism for personal and social problem solving; drama and diversity; and drama as a vehicle for learning in other disciplines. The objective here is to provide students with an opportunity to critically examine (in small and large group discussions) contemporary literature on drama and education in order to help them attain an overview of the theoretical landscape of the field. Concurrent with these discussions about the nature and functions of drama, I also engage students in a number of ongoing drama workshops. These are essentially studio classes in which I lead students through a variety of drama exercises and improvisational activities. The specific activities engaged in here depend upon the experience, needs, and interests of the students in the class. However, over the course of the semester I attempt to provide them with first-hand experience with a number of approaches to drama, including traditional creative drama techniques, theatre games, process drama, teacher in role, and mantel of the expert.13 In contrast to drama workshops in more traditional courses in educational drama, my primary purpose here is not to teach my students how to teach drama by providing them with a set of tools for doing drama with children. My purpose is to provide them with personal experiences, as participants in dramatic activities, which will help them better understand the role of drama in human development. The workshops provide an experiential base for the theoretical material in the course. Though the direction of the workshops remains flexible, I generally attempt to design workshops that reinforce, exemplify, or extend the theoretical material under consideration at the moment.14 For example, when reading about the connection between drama and writing, I engage students in drama work that requires them to write, generally in role, from within the drama itself. Students keep a daily reflective journal throughout the course. The purpose of this journal is to provide students with a structured opportunity to personally reflect upon the relationship between their experience in the workshops and their own personal growth, especially in terms of the theoretical views presented throughout the course. In addition to describing each activity as they experienced it, students are asked to use the journal to analyze and evaluate their personal responses to the dramatic work by addressing questions such as: How comfortable were you with the activity? Did the activity challenge you? How? Why? Why not? What did you learn about yourself from the activity?
46
Patrick M. Collins
What kinds of learning and personal growth did the activity foster? Why? Did the activity somehow stunt or constrain your personal growth? If so, why? What connections can you make between the activity and class readings or discussions? How does the activity relate to other workshop activities we have completed? In addition, class discussions often demand that students draw upon their journals in making connections between their participation in drama workshops, their own development, and course readings. The final component of the course, which serves as a culminating activity, is an educational outreach program that we call Drama Worlds. For four or five classes toward the end (final month) of the course, my students run an after-school drama program for local children in kindergarten through the fifth grade.15 Students work in pairs or trios designing a series of drama lessons that they then teach to a group of between ten and fifteen children. This means that in about the fifth week of the course students need to begin thinking about, researching for, and planning the units they will be teaching in the after-school program. In addition to planning and teaching the unit, each of my students keeps a teaching journal and portfolio (separate from the reflective journal described earlier) in which they evaluate and reflect upon the effectiveness of each of their lessons in terms of the goals and objectives they set for their group of children and in terms of developments they are able to observe within individual children. At the end of Drama Worlds they also write an extended entry assessing the overall success of the project. My initial impetus for including the outreach program as part of Drama in a Developmental Context was rooted in the local community. Since 1986 I had been running a large summer theatre program for local children in grades four through twelve. By the early 1990s I regularly had parents and teachers indicate that there was a substantial community interest in having some sort of drama program, especially for younger (K–3) children, during the school year. Drama Worlds was initially conceived of as one way to meet this need while at the same time providing my students with an experience that would further enhance their understanding of drama as a way of worldmaking.
THE CONUNDRUM Initially, the idea of developing an after-school program seemed to be a win-win proposition: My students could be involved in a project that would
Understanding Service at the Service of Understanding
47
address a genuinely perceived need in the local community while at the same time being engaged in a learning experience that would deepen and extend their understanding of dramatic activity. Drama Worlds seemed to be an ideal way to integrate service-learning with experiential education in the arts. However, it didn’t take long for doubts to begin to set in and for me to begin to sense an emerging tension between the service component of the course and my larger epistemic aim of moving my students toward dramatic literacy. Indeed, after two or three years of teaching the course, I began to wonder if the after-school program wasn’t actually undermining the basic aim of the course. The problem was that I was feeling pressure, from students and from myself, to more overtly prepare students to teach in the after-school program. The potential of the Drama Worlds experience to positively affect my students’ understanding of dramatic activity was contingent on the degree to which the teaching experience was successful, which depended on how well prepared they were. More importantly, the civic responsibility of undertaking this project required that my students be adequately prepared to make a success of their work with children. Adequate pedagogical preparation seemed to be a necessary condition of fulfilling both the civic and the epistemic goals of Drama Worlds. As a result I began to change the way I approached the design of the inclass workshops in Drama in a Developmental Context. My tendency became to use workshops to provide students with as many techniques for working with children as possible without compromising the level and depth of their own dramatic work. This would not have presented such a difficult problem in a teacher education course where understanding is largely placed at the service of learning to teach. But this was a liberal arts course in which I was essentially trying to use teaching to enhance understanding. The more I focused on pedagogy and provided students with tried and true activities, methods, and resources for using drama with children, the less time I was able to spend on the kind of extended, in-depth, dramatic experiences that were developmentally more appropriate for helping college students (not necessarily interested in teaching) more fully understand the power and potential of drama in their own lives. My sense was that I was compromising the fundamental aim of the course. For several years I continued, somewhat blindly, to try to serve both masters while remaining uncomfortable with the sense that I wasn’t serving either very well. In hindsight, much of this discomfort was due to my inability to clearly articulate the tension I was experiencing between the epistemic aim of the course and the responsibilities of the community service. I assumed that both the workshops and the after-school program were valuable experiences and therefore continued to pursue both. I simply perceived the problem as the typical pedagogical dilemma of how to make everything
48
Patrick M. Collins
work given the time constraints of the course. Then two years ago I finally realized that the question I needed to be asking wasn’t, “How do I fit it all in?” Given the aims of the course, the prior question needed to be, “Does the after-school program help my students deepen their understanding of the potential of drama to foster human development?” If the answer to that question was no, which I feared it was, I would need to consider the possibility that the service project was undermining the epistemic goals of this course and possibly eliminate it. If the answer was yes, then I would at least be reassured that trying to make everything fit was worth the effort and might even conclude that the effect of the pedagogical changes brought about by the need to prepare students to teach was a benefit rather than a liability.
DOING, SEEING, AND THINKING ABOUT DRAMA The question has yet to be fully answered, but over the last two years I have been more focused on ascertaining the answer. In addition to more carefully reviewing course evaluations for evidence of the effects of Drama Worlds, I have added the following item to the course evaluations that are completed by students at the end of the course: “Did your Drama Worlds experience help you deepen you own understanding of the potential of drama to foster human development? If so, how? If not, why not?” I have also tried to focus class discussions of the Drama Worlds experience as much on the impact of the experience on my students’ own thinking about drama as I have on the efficacy of the teaching experience itself. Though at best informal, these efforts are beginning to provide me with a better understanding of how my students experience the after-school program within the larger context of the course. My initial findings are encouraging. Historically, when asked on course evaluations “has this course deepened or extended your understanding of the relationship between drama and human development?” students have overwhelmingly responded in the affirmative. This pattern has held over the past two years with twenty-five of the twenty-eight students who have taken the course indicating improved understanding. In elaborating on their responses to this question, students have occasionally alluded to the role of the after-school program in enhancing their understanding, but since the question is a relatively open-ended one, their responses do not provide any substantial evidence that Drama Worlds was a key factor here. Further generalized support for Drama Worlds is found in examining student responses to the following item: “What (if any) aspects of this course
Understanding Service at the Service of Understanding
49
should definitely not be changed for next year? Explain.” Nineteen students cited Drama Worlds as something that should not be changed. The second most common response was “workshops,” which was indicated by six students.16 Once again, since this was an open-ended question these responses do not provide any evidence that the after-school program improved student understanding, but they do provide solid evidence that students found Drama Worlds valuable for one reason or another. However, for the last two years I have also included the item that explicitly asks students to address the import of Drama Worlds (“Did your Drama Worlds experience help you deepen your own understanding of the potential of drama to foster human development? If so, how? If not, why not?”). Of the twenty-four students who responded to this item, nineteen indicated that Drama Worlds did play a significant role in developing their understanding, one said that it did not, and four gave mixed responses or indicated that they were unsure. These are heartening but hardly surprising results: Students generally enjoy working with children and in this case it can be expected that they would construe this experience in positive terms. Furthermore, others have long illustrated the connection between service and understanding. Indeed, among the results of their extensive study of college students, Eyler and Giles concluded that students consistently reported that service-learning enhanced their understanding of course content.17 What is more interesting are the reasons students gave, and the language they used, to describe the positive effects of Drama Worlds. Given student responses to the items described above, combined with observations made by students in class discussions and their writing (reflective journals, teaching portfolio, and final paper) in the course, there appear to be three common reasons they found Drama Worlds to be “imperative,” as one student put it, to their experience in the course.18 The first of these reasons, that the service-learning helped students integrate theory and practice, is not surprising; however, the second and third explanations caught me a bit off guard. Students in Drama in a Developmental Context often made comments such as the following when describing how Drama Worlds helped them develop a better understanding of drama as a way of worldmaking: Because I saw the theories from the books put into action, I feel as though I gained a much greater understanding of the potential of drama It was nice to have a hands-on experience with the theories. I had a chance to apply my knowledge through community service. [Drama Worlds] proved first hand how drama fosters human development.
50
Patrick M. Collins
The repeated enthusiasm for hands-on learning and for being given an opportunity to apply theories learned in class also echoes the findings of Eyler and Giles. The service-learning students in their study agreed it was easier for them to make sense of material because “hands-on experience is definitely a lot better than hearing it, because it doesn’t click in your mind until you experience it or relate to it.” They found that the understanding attained from service-learning enhanced what they learned from books and lectures. “We learn these theories and ideas in school, but until we really apply them or see them in action, they’re not real. And we come out of school . . . not understanding.”19
Of course hands-on learning and the application of theory are not exclusive to service-learning and are longstanding hallmarks of experiential education at large. Therefore, my students may very well (if prompted) have made the same case for the importance of the in-class drama workshops. In fact, these are precisely my reasons for designing Drama in a Developmental Context as a studio-based or workshop-based course. In doing so I was following a long tradition in American education that views learning in the arts as largely a function of “doing” or “making” art.20 As indicated earlier, the objective of the workshops is to provide students with firsthand experiences as active participants in dramatic activity in order to help them better understand the theoretical underpinnings of the course. My assumption has been that the best way to help students develop a full understanding of drama as a way of knowing is to give them an inside view of drama by actively engaging them as “actors” and then helping them reflect on that experience in terms of theory. The purpose of the workshops is to allow students to experience the application of theory from the inside-out. Until now, I have always assumed that, given the goals of this course, doing drama was a more effective form of experiential learning than teaching because it provided a more authentic inside-out experience with the art. Unfortunately, I have not yet attained the same sort of explicit feedback concerning the efficacy of the workshops as I have acquired on the after-school program. Therefore I do not want to hazard a judgment about the relative merits of the two activities. But an examination of the second reason students used to explain the epistemic efficacy of Drama Worlds will prove to be both surprising and instructive. I have been struck by the degree to which students regularly used the language of sight to describe how Drama Worlds helped them develop an understanding of dramatic activity. As the following examples illustrate, students often used verbs such as see, observe, view, and witness to explain their experience: Drama Worlds . . . helps an individual see how drama can help in human development.
Understanding Service at the Service of Understanding
51
Actually giving the kids the activity and observing their behavior had such a more powerful impact compared to reading about it. [Drama Worlds] allowed me to personally view the impact on growth and development that drama has on a student. While working with the children through[out] our five sessions with them, I witnessed some sort of development through the work of drama . . . I saw a huge growth [in] our children. I personally saw the use of drama increase their [the children’s] ability to develop into intelligent and happy people. I could see multiple differences and changes within the children.21
Many students also went on to describe in detail specific developments they had seen, observed, or witnessed among their children. One student described the impact of an outer-space drama she and her partners lead with a group of fourth and fifth graders as follows: We were able to . . . engage the children’s imaginations and emotions on several levels. The children were able to imagine and develop a setting where [space] aliens, that they could originally only conceive of as hostile, could evolve (through dramatic interaction) into helpful intelligent beings with similar needs and wants. This wouldn’t have happened in as much depth, say, if we had just read a story, taught a lesson, or just asked them to write based on preconceived notions of what “aliens” were.
Students not only claimed that the service-learning project had helped them see the power of drama, but they often described what they had seen in terms that clearly illustrated they had acquired a deep understanding of drama as a way of knowing. Far from undermining the epistemic goal of the course, this anecdotal evidence suggests that Drama Worlds may be a key to helping students meet the primary goal of the course. My initial fears about the possible deleterious effects of the pedagogical alterations forced upon me by service-learning appear to have been unfounded. The question is, why is this the case? Why does teaching drama appear to be at least as effective as doing drama in a workshop setting? One answer to this question is implied in the visual language used by students to talk about the teaching experience. For years I have been working on the assumption that the inside-out view of drama was the most effective way to help students deepen their understanding of dramatic activity. However, students seem to be suggesting that an “outside-in” view may be at least as important. I wanted to provide students with every opportunity I could to reflect on their own personal experiences with drama, but they are telling me that the experience of seeing others (children) engage in drama
52
Patrick M. Collins
may be just as significant. Students need, if you will, both inner and outer views of artistic development. The in-class workshops, by definition and design, provide students with a subjective view of dramatic experience: They demand that students look inward. Teaching, and service-learning at large, requires students to look outward. It may be that the epistemic value of Drama Worlds is to be found in the act of reaching out to, connecting with, and seeing others engaged in dramatic activity. My sense is that students seldom use the more objective language of “seeing” in writing about their workshop experiences; they are more naturally inclined to use the subjective language of “feeling.” But, as Goodman also indicates, developing literacy in any art form requires a combination of both objective and subjective kinds of knowing.22 And Dewey himself claimed that one of the basic principles of experiential education is that “it assigns equal rights to both factors in experience—objective and internal conditions.”23 Far from undermining the experiential base of the course, the service-learning component has helped insure its success by bringing the subjective and objective, the inner and outer, views of drama into balance within the course at large. There is one other possible interpretation of the use of visual language by my students. We all know that it is often easier to see some things in others than it is in ourselves. It may simply be easier for students to recognize the effects of dramatic experience in others than it is in themselves. There is no doubt that students in this course regularly have intense learning experiences within our drama workshops, but in so far as these tend to be highly personal and subjective experiences, it may be difficult for them to see (or at least articulate) this learning as having more objective value. But being able to observe others engaged in similar activities may provide them with the cognitive distance necessary to recognize developments in others that they cannot see in their own dramatic experience. Once again, understanding benefits from the interaction of both subjective and objective experience. In addition to being able to apply theory and see the effects of drama, there is a third explanation students often suggested in explaining the epistemic efficacy of the after-school program: planning. As one student noted: “Going through each step of the process, from the planning to the actual execution of the lesson plans, allowed me to think about, create, and then teach different ways of learning and looking at things. I was able to see first hand how drama can be applied to learning and as a result how it can foster human development as a whole.” Indeed, this student highlights all three explanations (application, seeing, and planning) being examined here, and she is not alone in doing so. Initially this recognition of the importance of planning was unexpected, but in retrospect it is not so surprising. The planning component of Drama Worlds is substantial. Students have to meet repeatedly with the other members of the their teaching teams and with me in developing relatively detailed plans for each of the five days they
Understanding Service at the Service of Understanding
53
are to teach. As we all know, there is no better way to learn something than to have to teach it. But it isn’t so much the actual teaching that teaches, it is the learning we do in the process of planning to teach which is most instructive. As the student cited above suggests, the planning involved in Drama Worlds forced students to think about the nature of drama in ways that they otherwise would not have had to consider. The planning process literally put students into dialogue with each other, with me, with the theoretical literature, with their own experience, and ultimately with their own students in ways that required them to think deeply, yet practically, about the connections between drama and human development. In this case it was the planning that provided them with further opportunities to see and understand the potential of drama in new ways, ways that were not accessible to them through readings or even through workshop experiences. In sum, the evidence suggests that students found the after-school program to be a vital factor in their emerging understanding of dramatic experience and that they did so for good reason. Drama Worlds enabled students to do, see, and think about drama in ways that workshops and class discussions didn’t make available. It allowed them to test their understanding by allowing them to apply what they learned in class. It provided them with an outside-in view of drama that balanced the inside-out view emphasized in workshops. And it forced students to think deeply about the educational and developmental functions of drama. It is still hard for me to judge whether student understanding would benefit more from a greater emphasis on personal dramatic experience and less on preparation for teaching in our workshops, but as far as my students are concerned Drama Worlds is clearly paying some substantial dividends in terms of their view of drama as a way of worldmaking. Rather than undermining the epistemic aim of the course, the service project appears to be enhancing it in significant ways.
LESSONS LEARNED AND QUESTIONS RAISED This exploration started on a skeptical note by asking whether servicelearning might sometimes undermine what I have called the epistemic aims often embedded in experiential learning. I have provided a brief sketch of the evolution, and subsequent de-evolution, of that skepticism as illustrated in my own teaching. Some of that skepticism still remains, but this exploration has provided me with a better understanding of the ways in which service may engender varieties (other than the civic) of understanding in the liberal arts, especially understanding in the fine and performing arts. Along the way lessons have been learned and new questions have been raised.
54
Patrick M. Collins
Pedagogically, the most significant lesson learned for my own teaching is that I need to make more purposeful use of the opportunities for seeing drama in action that are offered by the educational outreach component of Drama in a Developmental Context. Students need to be more conscious of the roles that both objective and subjective experience play in the construction of their own understandings of drama. As such, I intend to engage students in conversations, writing assignments, and perhaps even dramatic activities that make them more cognizant of the interplay between the inner vision of drama experienced in workshops and the outer view presented to them in Drama Worlds. In addition to helping students sharpen their ability to see and observe the effects of drama more carefully, such an approach will hopefully provide me with more sources of feedback on the epistemic efficacy of both the after-school program and the inclass workshops. This analysis has also raised a number of questions that require further exploration: How effective are the workshops in helping students develop an understanding of the relationship between drama and human development? Do the workshops really help students develop an “inside-out” view of drama as suggested here? Is the after-school program more, or less, effective than the workshops in helping students achieve the epistemic aim of the course? Is there really a trade-off between preparing students for Drama Worlds and providing them with developmentally appropriate experiences with drama? If so, are their ways to minimize the trade-off? All of these questions need to be examined in a more deliberate and structured way than they have been to date. This analysis also raises a number of broader questions: Are there preexistent conditions under which service-learning is more likely to compromise epistemic aims? My sense is that there are, but that they can often be managed and that one can often alter pedagogy without compromising goals and objectives. I have altered my workshop pedagogy in ways that I still find questionable in terms of artistic value, but this compromised pedagogy apparently has not compromised the primary aim of the course. Students indicate that this altered approach apparently aids them in developing a deeper understanding of drama. My guess is that one of the conditions under which service-learning is more likely to threaten the development of understanding is when the service project requires extensive training, expertise, or prior experience to be successful. It is more difficult to prepare novices to teach drama than it is to prepare them to rake leaves or even to read a book to children. It is more difficult still to prepare the novice to effectively teach a musical instrument. There are surely other conditions that make service-learning in the service of epistemic aims difficult. It is important to recognize and understand them so they can be managed in ways that may minimize their effects on student learning.
Understanding Service at the Service of Understanding
55
Are there preexistent conditions under which service-learning is more likely to complement or enhance epistemic aims? There is a rich literature that identifies conditions that need to be created in order for service-learning to be successful.24 But there are also preexisting conditions that need to be recognized as conducive to using service for epistemic ends. For example, one of the reasons students cited in explaining the effectiveness of the after-school program was that it allowed them to apply what they learned in class. One may surmise from this that having a well-defined body of knowledge with clear practical applications increases the chances of designing an epistemically effective service-learning experience. The likelihood of service-learning being successful may also be greater in domains where there are fairly accessible structures or schemata to guide work in the domain.25 Both drama and teaching are complex phenomena that take years to master, but preparing my students to teach drama was probably aided by some fundamental principles and strategies that I was easily able to share with them. Once again, if we can identify those conditions that are conducive to fostering understanding within a domain, we will be better able to capitalize on them in designing successful service-learning experiences. If we assume that one of the aims of a liberal arts education should be to move students toward symbolic literacy, what role can service-learning play in helping students master various symbol systems? Since different symbol systems have different structures that place different demands upon users, the answer to this question will vary by symbol system. But I will venture a few thoughts here about drama and the fine and performing arts at large. While each of the arts has its own structure, becoming literate in any of them does seem to hinge on some shared kinds of knowing. Dancers, actors, painters, and poets each need to become familiar with a basic set of techniques necessary for dancing, acting, painting, or writing. They all need to know how to apply those techniques in new and imaginative ways. They all need to understand ways in which their work may affect others and how others (audiences) may affect a given piece of work. But becoming artistically literate requires more than understanding how art is made. A variety of other abilities are also essential: the ability to perceive intelligently within the art form; the ability to form critical judgments about the merits of specific works; the ability to understand and interpret works within their social, cultural, and historical contexts; and the ability to use the art form as a means of personal exploration and expression.26 Literacy in any art requires a functional understanding of how the art form may be used, both expressively and receptively, as a way of worldmaking. Literacy in any symbol system is not acquired in one place, at one time, or in one course. The acquisition of literacy is cumulative and ongoing. No one course is going to make a student dramatically literate, visually literate, or mathematically literate. All we can do as teachers is try to move our
56
Patrick M. Collins
students further down the road to literacy, and it seems as though (civic engagement aside) service-learning may be able to help us. But we need to be careful about what we expect service-learning to do for us. In most cases it seems unlikely that service would be an especially effective way to help students master the basic tools and processes of an art form. The students in my course may have tasted the work of the actor, but they did not master the basic skills of acting (e.g., script analysis, vocal projection, stage movement, etc.). That was not the aim of the course. But the service component of the course did help them achieve the actual aim of the course because it provided them with an opportunity to see the interplay between drama and other members of the community. It is here, at the intersection of the arts and the other, at the point where the arts naturally intersect with the community, that service-learning holds its greatest promise for moving students toward artistic literacy. In so far as the arts, especially the performing arts, are communal in nature, service in the arts does have the potential to generate not only a sense of civic engagement, but also fundamental understandings about the arts. Despite images of the solitary artist locked in the studio, learning in the arts is not a wholly personal, individual, or subjective experience. An inside view may be necessary to become literate within a given art form, but it is not sufficient. Artistic literacy also requires an outside view that may be found in carefully designed servicelearning projects.
CONCLUSION Service-learning clearly has great potential for educating students for civic responsibility. I have raised the question here of whether the civic responsibility which comes with service may sometimes interfere with other epistemic aims of a liberal arts education. Whether or not this analysis has significant implications beyond Drama in a Developmental Context is for others to determine. It may be that the problem posed here is peculiar to the course in question. It may be that the way the problem has been framed is peculiar to my experience as a member of an education department at an institution that often bills itself as “ferociously and totally liberal arts.” Where I speak of epistemic aims others may prefer to think about academic learning, learning in the disciplines, or content knowledge. But regardless of one’s situation, it is important to remain both skeptical of and open to the perils and promise of service-learning. I still remain somewhat skeptical about the effect of service-learning on epistemic aims in certain situations. But this exploration has alleviated some of that doubt and revealed some of the promise of service-learning. It has provided hints of how and
Understanding Service at the Service of Understanding
57
why service-learning, especially in the arts, may contribute, epistemically as well as civically, to the development of a liberally educated person: a person who not only recognizes his or her responsibility to be a worldmaker, but who has also become literate in multiple ways of worldmaking.
NOTES 1. Joan Schine, Service Learning (Chicago: NSSE, 1997), 187–89. 2. See Richard Battistoni, “How Do You Define Citizenship?” Civic Engagement across the Curriculum (Campus Compact, 2002), and Craig Rimmerman, The New Citizenship: Unconventional Politics, Activism, and Service, 2nd ed. (Boulder, CO: Westview Press, 2001). 3. Janet Eyler and Dwight E. Giles, Where’s the Learning in Service Learning? (San Francisco: Jossey-Bass, 1999), 7–9. 4. The term “epistemic aim” (goal or outcome) will be used throughout this analysis to refer to aims that are primarily concerned with the development of knowledge and understanding other than that associated with civic engagement. This is not meant to minimize the importance of civic engagement or the role of knowledge and understanding in being educated for engagement. Civic education clearly requires the acquisition of significant knowledge. But the primary concern here is to examine the effects of service-learning in cases (courses) where the civic aims are secondary to other epistemic aims. The term “epistemic aim” is simply intended to provide an efficient shorthand for making the distinction between these two kinds of aims. 5. Students must also complete a semester of full-time student teaching for which they do receive academic credit. 6. All students pursuing certification (including students pursuing certification to teach elementary school) must complete a major outside of education (in one of the arts or sciences). Students may elect (but are not required) to take a minor in education. 7. Nelson Goodman, Ways of Worldmaking (Indianapolis: Hacket Pub. Co., 1978), 7–17. 8. See Howard Gardner, Art, Mind, and Brain: A Cognitive Approach to Creativity (New York: Basic Books, 1982) and Frames of Mind: The Theory of Multiple Intelligences (New York: Basic Books, 1983). It should be noted that Goodman himself built upon the work of both Ernst Cassirer (An Essay on Man; An Introduction to the Philosophy of Human Culture [New Haven, CN: Yale University Press; London: H. Milford / Oxford University Press, 1944]) and Susanne Langer (Philosophy in a New Key; A Study in the Symbolism of Reason, Rite and Art [Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1942]) in suggesting that understanding how humans use symbols is key to understanding how we acquire and generate knowledge. 9. For a cogent description of symbolic literacy in the arts, see Elliot Eisner, “The Role of the Arts in the Invention of Man,” New York University Education Quarterly, Spring 1980, 2–7.
58
Patrick M. Collins
10. For a description of dramatic literacy as an aim of education, see Patrick Collins, “Toward Dramatic Literacy: A Position Paper,” Children’s Theatre Review 34, no. 4 (1985): 3–6. 11. Jed Davis and Tom Behm, “Terminology of Drama/Theatre with and for Children: A Redefinition,” in Theatre, Children and Youth by Jed Davis and Mary Jane Evans (New Orleans: Anchorage Press, 1987), 262. 12. Betty Jane Wagner, Educational Drama and the Language Arts: What Research Shows (Portsmouth, NH: Heinemann, 1998), and Nellie McCaslin, Creative Drama in the Classroom and Beyond, 8th ed. (Boston: Pearson Education, 2006). 13. On creative drama, see McCaslin, Creative Drama in the Classroom and Beyond. On theatre games, see Viola Spolin, Theatre Games for the Classroom (Evanston, IL: Northwestern University Press, 1987). For descriptions of process drama, teacher in role, and mantel of the expert, see Cecily O’Neill, Drama Worlds: A Framework for Process Drama (Portsmouth, NH: Heinemann, 1995), and Dorothy Heathcote and Gavin Bolton, Drama for Learning (Portsmouth, NH: Heinemann, 1995). 14. It should also be noted here that since much of the work done in workshops is improvisational and depends on the emerging skills, energy (or lack thereof), and interests of the group, the distribution of time between workshop days and discussion days remains fluid. There are some weeks where we are able to have one workshop day and one discussion day. There are other periods where we may have two, three, or even four workshops in a row followed perhaps by two or three days of discussion. There are other days when we split the time between workshop and theory. 15. For the first several years of the program, Drama Worlds was held on campus at the colleges. However, for the past two years the program has been folded into an already existing after-school program which takes place in the Geneva City Schools. Generally speaking, Drama Worlds serves between sixty and eighty children per year. 16. When asked “what should definitely be changed,” one student did indicate that we spent too much time on Drama Worlds, but three students also indicated that we should spend more time on Drama Worlds. 17. Janet Eyler and Dwight E. Giles Jr., Where’s the Learning in Service Learning? (San Francisco: Jossey-Bass, 1999), 68–81. 18. In addition to keeping a reflective journal and a teaching portfolio, students are assigned a final paper in which they are “to draw on [their] experience in this course (including, course readings and discussions, class workshops, and [their] Drama Worlds experience, etc.) in writing a logical and coherent analysis of what [they] consider to be the most important function(s) of drama in education.” 19. Eyler and Giles, Where’s the Learning in Service Learning?, 69. 20. George Geahigan, “The Arts in Education: A Historical Perspective,” The Arts, Education, and Aesthetic Knowing: Ninety-first Yearbook of the National Society for the Study of Education, ed. Bennett Reimer and Ralph Smith (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1992). 21. These comments, as well as the excerpt below, are all quoted from student responses to the question on the course evaluation asking whether Drama Worlds enhanced student understanding. 22. Nelson Goodman, Languages of Art: An Approach to a Theory of Symbols (Indianapolis: Hackett Publishing Company, 1976).
Understanding Service at the Service of Understanding
59
23. John Dewey, Experience and Education (New York: Macmillan Company, 1938), 42. 24. For example, see Norris M. Haynes and James P. Comer, “Service Learning in the Comer School Development Program,” in Service Learning: Ninety-sixth Yearbook of the National Society for the Study of Education, ed. Joan Schine (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1997), and Eyler and Giles, Where’s the Learning in Service Learning? 25. For more on the significance of the structure of domains, see Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi, Creativity: Flow and the Psychology of Discovery and Invention (New York: HarperCollinsPublishers, 1996), 36–41. 26. See both Ralph Smith, Culture and the Arts in Education (New York: Teachers College Press, 2006), and Bennett Reimer, “What Knowledge Is of Most Worth in the Arts?” in Reimer and Smith, The Arts, Education, and Aesthetic Knowing, for detailed descriptions of kinds of knowing required in the arts.
4 Teaching the Unteachable: Service-Learning and Engagement in the Teaching of Genocide and the Holocaust Michael Dobkowski
Teaching the Holocaust is both impossible and imperative—teaching a subject that defies both language and conventional explanations. There are enormous limits—of thought, imagination, comprehension, language— that hinder any attempt to grasp and express the experience we wish to tell. “I wanted to return to Sighet,” explains Moishe the Beadle in Elie Wiesel’s Night, “to describe to you my death so that you might ready yourselves while there is still time . . . only no one is listening to me. . . .”1 In these few words we have a paradigm of the dilemma facing teacher and student— what to tell so that it can be integrated into the consciousness and consciences of our students? How does one deal with the inevitable tensions between the need to be reasoned and analytical and the equally strong urge to be passionate and emotional and engaged? One voice says be removed and objective and quiet; the other says teach in a constant scream. Neither voice worked for Moishe. He tries to warn us of the collapse of meaning and the distortion of the human and divine image taking place around us, then and now. We listen, but we seem not to understand. Few topics or subject matters in teaching are fraught with such limitations, nor are teachers in other fields confronted by such a pervasive sense that what they seek to accomplish may well be unattainable. In part, genocide is hard to come to terms with because of the magnitude of the subject—the sheer numbers killed, the methods used, the breadth of complicity, its pervasiveness in history. Addressed directly, the Holocaust is overwhelming, provoking constant temptations to stop talking about it and ignore its reality, to intellectualize or abstract it from people thereby destroying its reality, or to despair and sink in the mire of believing that 61
62
Michael Dobkowski
genocide is all of reality. The philosopher John Roth asserts that “the Holocaust—its reality, history, politics—creates burdens. These burdens are not abstract, nor are they impersonal. . . . The burdens of Holocaust history are immense because the Holocaust itself was immense.”2 The agony of confronting the material, the struggle to balance one’s intellectual and emotional responses to the content and to the students, the challenge of restraining oneself from imposing values, and the difficulty of dealing with an abundance of complex, painful content characterize the challenges of Holocaust teaching. The difficulty is not that Auschwitz cannot be imagined; indeed it consisted of everything imaginable. The problem, rather, is that it cannot be thought. Recall Jean Améry’s observations on the function of the intellectual in the camps. “It was not the case that the intellectual—if he had not already been destroyed physically—had now become unintellectual or incapable of thinking. On the contrary, only rarely did thinking grant itself a respite. But it nullified itself when at almost every step it ran into its uncrossable borders. The axes of its traditional frames of reference then shattered.”3 Those of us who try to “teach” the Holocaust or situate it within a curriculum are faced, in some small measure, with similar obstacles. Yet, I am convinced that the teaching of the Shoah is an effort of uncommon importance, one that is pivotal not only to our understanding of the past, but also to whatever prospect there may be for a more decent and humane future. Genocide presents some of the deepest philosophical and religious questions we can face in the classroom. Students often query: in light of so much suffering and killing, what does it mean to say one is human? They raise questions concerning God’s existence and the possibility of intelligibility in the universe. If there is a Supreme Being, what kind of Supreme Being would allow such perverse evil and suffering to exist? From the point of view of secular values and institutions, they ask whether it is possible to believe any longer that history leads to progress. How could a nation that prided itself as modern, cultured, and educated perpetuate such an atrocity? Is modern civilization itself implicated? No assessment of twentieth-century civilization can ignore the fact that science and technology, celebrated as the conduits of progress, then climaxed in the factories of death, and the realization that the unlimited, value-free use of knowledge and science, had paved the way for the mass murder by a faceless, mindless bureaucracy. The Holocaust was an advance warning of the genocidal potential in modern culture. Students are drawn to these questions and to courses that confront them. And teachers are as well, even though, constantly stalked by despair, most teachers, I believe, are idealists. However jaded we may become, most of us became teachers because we wanted to play our part in mending the world. That hope, however, encounters discouragement aplenty. Genocide’s history provides it. So does teaching. No
Teaching the Unteachable
63
matter how hard we try, indifference persists, prejudice remains, and ignorance endures. Education’s gains take place slowly and imperceptively. There is nothing inevitable about the process. So what can be learned by studying the Holocaust? We learn that the moral order around us is very fragile and that some ideas and their institutional forms can lead to genocide and that ordinary people established Auschwitz and that these ordinary people are not fundamentally different from the generations that followed. It is one thing for students to be interested or stimulated by a topic; it is another question whether or not they are adequately prepared to confront the material and the issues that will face them; for once you immerse yourself in the Shoah and the other genocides of our time, the world is never the same again. The events can shatter us even as they free us from our confident and comforting illusions. There may be a pedagogical position that holds the idea of shattering the illusions of students as a good thing, but we must not forget that shattered illusions can also be profoundly painful. Why, then, teach a topic so laden with the dark impulses of the human experience—a subject matter that does not elevate but depresses, a history that is not inspiring but rather filled with the worst that the human species is capable of? The dangers it presents are faced by teachers and students who, as they explore the evils that define the Holocaust and genocide, can easily become depressed and even cynical. Historian Omer Bartow argued that its very nature prevents us from learning anything from this genocide. “The Holocaust is a tale that signifies nothing. Indeed, it is precisely the meaninglessness of the event, made all the clearer now . . . the senselessness of it all, the total and complete emptiness in which this hell on earth unfolded, that leaves us breathless, bereft of power of thought and imagination.”4 My many years of teaching about the Holocaust, despite the despair that permeates the topic, suggest a very different conclusion. Even more, such teaching makes me understand that despair is not the appropriate response because to let it have its way would be, to paraphrase theologian Emil Fackenheim, to give every genocidal act a victory it does not deserve and must never have. It has convinced me that there is much to be gained, in fact, for both instructors and students. Rather than promoting cynicism or apathy, the courses often stimulate student engagement and activism through fostering a greater appreciation of justice and equality. One of the ironies of teaching this field of human history is that despite the darkness that surrounds it, it is very rewarding. Most rewarding are the questions the students raise about religion, humankind, morality, democracy, values, and civilization—for it is from such probing questions that serious learning within a moral framework takes place. As they become aware that the genocidal impulse is part of the human condition, students often relate what they are learning about the Holocaust to the problems of extreme poverty,
64
Michael Dobkowski
racism, and intolerance still pervasive in the world, as well as to the later genocides in Cambodia, Rwanda, the Balkans, and Darfur. Many also come to appreciate the profound truth of Jean Améry’s insight that we need to create memory since “no one can become what he cannot find in his memory.” Or Elie Wiesel’s admonition that “if we stop remembering we stop being.” I have come to believe that one cannot teach effectively about the Holocaust and remain a disinterested bystander passing on instrumentalist knowledge not informed by a moral theology. The Holocaust was about power and about the ultimate reification of ideas and ultimately people who were manipulated, exploited, and when drained of all further use, were turned into refuse to be consumed by fire. Teaching will necessarily involve us personally, exposing who we are and what we do and why we choose to do it. At the college and university level, where dispassion and objectivity are very highly valued, it is often forgotten that the very term professor denotes in its most literal sense someone who has something to profess— something worth declaring and considering by those who hear it. It is not about imposing one’s views, but about professing and pointing, as Martin Buber suggested, in the direction of the idea being explored. So, how does one teach the incomprehensible and the overwhelming to contemporary students? How can a cause be configured so that you maximize the probability that students will derive the greatest benefit and come away empowered not deflated? I begin with the premise that the study of the Holocaust should be metadisciplinary because it goes beyond the parameters of any given discipline or combination of disciplines. And this is so because the Shoah is distinguished by its assault on the premises of meaning and truth that define any discipline. Eli Wiesel has said that a novel about the Holocaust is either not a novel or not about the Holocaust. “There is no such thing as Holocaust literature—there cannot be. Auschwitz negates all literature as it negates all theories and doctrines; to lock it into a philosophy means to restrict it.”5 A Holocaust memoir is not the reflective recollections of one’s life; it is the desperate testimony of one’s imminent death in an effort to give meaning to a life that was not meant to be lived. A Holocaust history is not the recounting of events; it attempts to bear witness in such a way as to transform its listener into a witness. My efforts are guided by a fundamental distinction between the process of learning and the process of integrating the meaning and implications of that learning into consciousness and conscience. One can study the Holocaust by consuming and assimilating the factual data, but though this can be an important act of witnessing in itself, it is not sufficient because learning does not necessarily indicate understanding. The latter is the result of integration and some level of engagement and action. If understanding and integration are the larger goals, then offering students ways they can process this material reflectively and ways they can take this “learning” and reinforce it and
Teaching the Unteachable
65
actualize it in deed outside the classroom presents new pedagogical challenges and objectives to strive for. By integration I mean that the subject matter has been somehow successfully absorbed by the students into their moral and intellectual world so that it helps inform how they will now view that world. The point of venturing into the Holocaust universe is not to get lost in it and succumb to despair, even though that is a risk that we take. No, the point is to acquire a deeper capacity for response—a deeper responsibility to and for other human beings. I want students to become sensitive to the cause of genocidal destruction, and in the best case that sensitivity will lead to engagement, the actions of resisting anything that reflects a genocidal process. From the point of view of developing an understanding of genocide, there seems to be a prevailing good reason to force ourselves and our students to confront so much pain and suffering, and that is to make teacher and student more deeply aware of and resistant to the conditions and processes that are involved in the destruction of a people. It is these additional goals beyond covering the history of the phenomenon—making students aware of statesupported violence, heightening their readiness for activism and exposing them to complex moral dilemmas—that both intensifies these courses and makes the effort difficult and frustrating. Holocaust courses are more about the future than the past. Many students who delve into the marrow of Holocaust history for the first time experience a certain cognitive disorientation. They think they know a great deal about the subject, but most come to understand that they don’t, and this realization can upset and confuse them. Teaching the Shoah imposes on the instructors a sensitivity toward students and a responsibility to them and to their cognition and emotional well-being. Christian students, for example, are likely to experience a particular dissonance and even feelings of guilt. They are likely to question assumptions about the influence of Christianity in preparing the context and paving the way for the perpetration of the Holocaust. They have to face the history of the long tradition of Christian antiJudaism, “the teaching of contempt,” and are compelled to reconcile that history with genocide and with the teachings and actions, or inactions, of the Church. Secular and non-believing students are forced to confront the values of modernity that also provided a fertile soil for genocidal ideas and deeds. The role of Nazi doctors and scientists, as well as judges and academics along with their students, who were either actively complicit or actively indifferent, may undermine their faith in education and the professions as forces of civility and humanitarianism. Jewish students have to struggle with the realities of Jewish victimhood and reconcile that experience with their connections to Judaism as a religion of faith and future. A classroom environment and curriculum should be created that is open, non-judgmental, and safe and that encourages students to feel hopeful about the future.
66
Michael Dobkowski
Based on these ultimate challenges and goals, I have attempted to incorporate introspective writing and service-learning components into the curriculum, asking the students to do extensive introspective writing that aims to help them find their own voices and to recognize how they might use their voices as a force for change and progress. In writing, perhaps more than in any other academic act, we are compelled to face the consequences of our words and to make ourselves vulnerable, known, exposed to those we write to. If, indeed, words have consequences, if words are the impetus for action, as the Holocaust powerfully confirms—all genocides begin with words—then we have the responsibility as writers to exercise care about the way we express ourselves on the page. Although students may feel at times overwhelmed by the weight of their own thoughts and narrative, I believe that writing instills a “healthy” sense of responsibility in students that the words they use have political, ethical, and cultural implications and they need to be aware of these implications when they express their thoughts. Writing is a fundamentally social act, a communication act, and an act that gestures outside of itself—however personal a given issue may seem to be. The study of the Holocaust should provide questions, should unsettle us. Reflective writing and interactive grappling with selected Holocaust texts are used to engage students in meaningful dialogue. They are encouraged to express their own experiences, ideas, and emotions concerning these texts with each other. As they respond to other students through spoken and written dialogue, they learn history and they learn about themselves. The hope is that their shared inquiry will enrich and enhance their understanding of what transpired, its importance, that it will raise questions and unsettle, and that it will encourage them to “brush history against the grain,” as Walter Benjamin advised. “Under Hitler,” philosopher Emmanuel Lévinas argued, “the Jews endured an ordeal that is without name, and cannot be placed in any sociological category. It is a lie to locate it within the series of natural causes and effects or to defer to ‘human sciences’ and seek to explain it by examining the thoughts and ‘readings’ of an Eichmann, . . . or the ‘structures’ of European society between the wars.”6 The statistics that social scientists invoke, the analyses that historians and psychologists apply, the methods that shape literary and philosophical investigations have the potential of transforming the event into something that it is not, something that can be studied and understood in conventional ways thereby rendering it more harmless and comfortable and distant. In order to make it present for students without numbing them and to reinforce the metadisciplinary nature of the study of the Shoah, I have incorporated service-learning projects into the curriculum as a capstone experience. Edward Zlotkowski, one of the national leaders of service-learning, argues that “it produces the best outcomes when meaningful service activi-
Teaching the Unteachable
67
ties are related to the course material through reflective activities such as directed writings, small group discussions, and class presentations.”7 After being exposed to the history and experiential realities of these horrific events, students often express the need to do “something,” to take what they have now learned and apply it to their lived realities, their communities, and their campus. They feel that knowledge, even understanding, without action is somehow inadequate in the face of what they are studying. They have become witnesses to atrocity, but they don’t want to be silent witnesses. They feel a moral obligation to pass their knowledge on, to tell someone, to effect some change. In that spirit, I have encouraged students to participate in a number of projects that may provide that outlet, that integration between what they are studying and how it can be applied to the world in which they live that is still characterized by genocidal tendencies. These projects have included working with middle school students in a local public school who are studying the Holocaust as a unit and reading Elie Wiesel’s Night. They pair up with these students, do a careful reading of the text together, share journal entries, work on a reflective paper, and help them prepare a creative project. They also have the option to work in the Holocaust Resource Center in Rochester doing a variety of research and academic tasks, as well as interacting with survivors of the Holocaust. Students are encouraged to design ways to share what they have learned about racism, homophobia, anti-Semitism, discrimination, and so on, with the college community or with their religious communities in their home towns. They can also get involved with and organize on behalf of human rights and genocide awareness organizations such as the Save Darfur Coalition, Human Rights Watch, and Amnesty International. They can work on and plan the annual Yom Hashoah Holocaust Commemoration. They are encouraged to become active participants in the Genocide and Human Rights Symposium Committee on campus, planning events and speakers, raising funds and awareness, doing publicity, and so on. They are invited to join the March of Remembrance and Hope, an interfaith leadership study tour to Holocaust sites in Poland with the expectation that they will bring back to their communities insights derived from this extraordinary educational opportunity. And they can participate in the “adopt a survivor, surrogate survivor” program. This option pairs a student with a survivor of the Holocaust or other genocide who lives in the region. The student does extensive interviewing of the survivor, learning as much as possible about their lives and experiences. After many hours of interaction and contact, the student may feel qualified to become a “surrogate” survivor of sorts, an individual who is competent on some level to represent that survivor’s experiences to others in the future when the survivor is no longer able to do so. These service-learning options allow the student to appropriately channel their desire to put what they have learned into a form of action. It also helps
68
Michael Dobkowski
them deal with the inevitable “compassion fatigue” that most students face at some point in the course. Accumulated accounts of genocide over a semester can create a condition of fatigue that leads to less integration of material and less engagement with the world, rather than more. Genocide is horrible, but presenting only the horror without giving the students a way to process that horror or a sense that there is something to be done can induce a kind of vicarious trauma or burnout. Service-learning experiences, I have found, energize rather than numb, embody the issues, vitalize them rather than objectify them, and provide the students with a richer intellectual experience as well as a sense of personal accomplishment and fulfillment. They can also help protect against the tendency that teaching about genocide can be potentially exploitative. Exposing students to genocidal tales of horror can play with students’ emotions in a manipulative fashion that can turn into a psychological or emotional exercise of power. Teaching itself can be about power and power relationships, if the instructor is not careful. This is especially true when the material is so emotionally charged and when students are particularly vulnerable. Empowering students is a wonderful way to diffuse this tendency. I encourage them to take what they have learned in the classroom and find ways to actualize it in their various communities. “No one can become what he cannot find in his memory.” Actions, deeds, and service help contextualize memory, help bring the ashes of history back to life in some small way, and help merge that memory into our consciousness.8 Maybe Moishe the Beadle was wrong, maybe we will listen, but only by doing, by following the ancient proclamation of the Israelites at Sinai during the Revelation—“we will do and then we will listen and understand.”
NOTES 1. Eli Wiesel, Night (New York: Hill and Wang, 2006), 7. 2. John K. Roth, Holocaust Politics (Louisville, KY: Westminster Knox Press, 2001), 38–39. 3. Jean Améry, At the Mind’s Limits: Contemplations by a Survivor on Auschwitz and Its Realities, trans. Sidney Rosenfeld and Stella P. Rosenfeld (Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 1980), 19. 4. Omer Bartov, “An Idiot’s Tale: Memories and Histories of the Holocaust,” in Murder in Our Midst: The Holocaust, Industrial Killing, and Representation (New York: Oxford University Press, 1996), 89. 5. Eli Wiesel, A Jew Today, trans. Marion Wiesel (New York: Random House, 1978), 197. 6. Emmanuel Lévinas, Difficult Freedom: Essays on Judaism, trans. Séan Hand (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1990), 129.
Teaching the Unteachable
69
7. Edward Zlotkowski, ed., Successful Service-Learning Programs: New Models of Excellence in Higher Education (Boston: Anker Pub. Co., 1998), xiv. 8. This essay was informed by the insights contained in Testimony, Tensions and Tikkun: Teaching the Holocaust in Colleges and Universities, which owes it origins to the Pastora Goldner Holocaust Symposium that I have been a participant in, as well as Teaching the Shoah in the Twenty-first Century.
5 Service-Learning and Public Policy Craig A. Rimmerman
[T]he ingenuity and idealism of the younger generations represent a potent resource for civic renewal. —Robert Putnam, Bowling Alone: The Collapse and Revival of American Community Today’s young adults are less politically interested and informed than any cohort of young people on record.
—Thomas Patterson, The Vanishing Voter: Public Involvement in an Age of Uncertainty
What does it mean to be a citizen in a country that calls itself a “democracy?” How does one take a charity model of helping, of service, that our students have been socialized into and know so well and inspire students to instead contemplate a more centrally focused political and policy model, one rooted in the language of social movements and participatory theories of democracy? In what ways does a service-learning course in a liberal arts institution provide a unique space for encouraging students to reflect on the real meaning of service for their lives as well as the lives of the members of the community with whom they interact? This chapter broaches these questions within the tensions represented by the above quotations and within the context of a 300-level public policy course—Social Policy and Community Activism. This analysis begins with several claims. Virtually all of the students who I teach in all of my courses have participated in some form of service after 71
72
Craig A. Rimmerman
they have arrived at college. Very few of these same students have been involved in anything that we would remotely call politics: (1) political organizing in their communities; (2) working on a campaign; (3) going to a town meeting and participating at that meeting; and (4) working with others to develop or influence policies for the communities in which they live. When I ask my students on the first day of class if they have a good understanding of the American political system and the policy process that governs our lives, many of them readily admit to me that they know little about the larger political system in which they live. They have little sense of history, especially of various social movements that have been so important in serving as a catalyst for policy change on behalf of those at the margins of American society. And they generally think of politics merely in terms of the vote and cannot conceive of a more expansive vision of what it might mean to be a citizen. One of the central goals in all of my courses is to inspire students to think about what it means to be a citizen from a number of perspectives. What role do citizens play in the American policy process? What role should they play? The argument of this essay is that service-learning courses afford faculty and students a unique opportunity to explore these questions and issues related to democracy and public policy. In doing so, we integrate the model of critical education for citizenship as the underlying theme of the course.
CRITICAL EDUCATION FOR CITIZENSHIP AND THE NEW CITIZENSHIP The critical education for citizenship model is at the basis for what I have called the New Citizenship. This model of education contains the following elements: (1) it should present the full critique of American democracy to the student; (2) it should allow students to see the importance of participating in public decisions; (3) it should ask educators and students to conceive of democracy broadly to include community discussions, community action, public service, and protest politics; (4) it should ask students to conceptualize participation very broadly to include workplace and community opportunities for participation; (5) it should encourage students to take into account the important relationship among gender, race, sexual orientation, and class concerns in the participatory process and to develop a respect for and understanding of difference; (6) it should place a discussion of democracy within its appropriate historical context by focusing on democratic movements, such as the African American civil rights movement, the antiwar movement, and the women’s movement; (7) it should ask students to confront their assumptions regarding power and leadership as well as the
Service-Learning and Public Policy
73
sources of such assumptions; (8) it should prepare students for their place in the world by affording them a chance to make an informed choice about what it is that they want to do with their lives and how they connect what they do with the communities where they live and work. How does the critical education for citizenship model connect to the New Citizenship? It is the foundation for a more expansive vision of the role that the citizenry plays in a society that purports to adhere to democratic goals. The New Citizenship is rooted in participatory democratic principles and emphasizes grassroots organizing, mobilization based on community building, cooperation, and alliance formation. It embraces unconventional politics when they are necessary to achieve public policy goals. It is reflected in the rise of citizen organizations at the grassroots and in the proliferation of college student organizations committed to economic, social, and environmental justice. It is reflected in the increased use of the Internet for political organizing across campus communities. Finally, the New Citizenship encompasses the commitment on college campuses to service-based learning. Service-based learning is a pedagogical method that combines student (and sometimes faculty) participation in the community with curriculum-based learning. It requires students to have an opportunity to build in time for students to reflect on their community experiences and to explore various elements of the New Citizenship. As the chapters in this volume suggest, it is also very much interdisciplinary in nature.
SOCIAL POLICY AND COMMUNITY ACTIVISM: COURSE OVERVIEW This is a course about social policy and community participation and activism; it is also a course about democracy, community, and difference. All students are required to be fully engaged in a semester-long community activism/service project. In addition, students are afforded an opportunity to reflect upon how their participation in the community influences their own lives, their perspectives on democracy, and their understanding of democratic citizenship. Several questions are at the core of the course: (1) What should the role of the citizenry be in the American political system and the American policy process? (2) Is it possible to construct a society that encourages people to asset their identities and celebrate their differences, while maintaining the community, stability, and civility of that society? Would we want to live in such a society? Why or why not? (3) What role should the federal government play in funding and overseeing social service programs at the local level? How might modern conservatives, modern liberals, and democratic socialists respond to that question? (4) How are all of these questions played out in Geneva, New York?
74
Craig A. Rimmerman
In answering these questions, students consider their service/public policy work in the larger Geneva community. The course requires them to engage their service experience from at least two perspectives. First, Geneva itself is a community that represents, in many ways, the negative consequences of the deindustrialization of America. Students’ work in the community involves them, in many cases, with human beings who have been cornered by a very limited menu of social and economic choices. How they negotiate these interactions is a significant part of their service-learning experiences. Students are given the opportunity to do so within the context of a public-policy-focused course, one that interrogates education, welfare, health care, AIDS, and criminal justice policy from a number of perspectives through the course readings, discussions, films, and lecture materials. In addition, community members visit the course throughout the semester to share their diverse perspectives on the many challenging issues raised in the course. All of this is meant to complement and to enhance the work that students do in the community as the course unfolds. Second, the service/policy work that the student does within the context of the course (and any work that they have done before the course began or after it concludes) is, itself, a project in citizenship. The course asks students to connect their service-learning experiences with the nature of and challenges to democratic citizenship in our time. This component of servicelearning is an essential and quite important commitment in its own right. What does citizenship mean now? What ought it mean? How does it relate to various perspectives on justice, democracy, community, and difference? The service-learning model allows us to consider and possibly rethink these very basic and quite critical concepts by requiring students to engage various theoretical approaches to citizenship, including the democratic theory of elitism and participatory democracy. In addition, the service-learning model enables faculty and students to explore challenging issues of power and inequality as they are played out in the community at large as the policy process unfolds at the local level. A further course theme is the relationship between a privileged liberal arts campus, Hobart and William Smith Colleges, and the surrounding Geneva, New York, community. Service-learning affords an excellent opportunity to explore this theme in all of its complexity. Throughout the course, students are asked to consider these questions: Just what is that relationship? And what should that relationship be? How might we achieve a more positive relationship? What are the barriers? How might the barriers be overcome? Various community members visit the class throughout the semester. The underlying rationale for bringing community members into the classroom is that we have much to learn from the Geneva community; and what better way to signal that commitment to learning than to break down the artificial barriers that colleges and universities often construct. If
Service-Learning and Public Policy
75
students are going out into the community as a required component of the course, then those same students should have an opportunity to hear from community members within the context of the classroom. For example, the local director of the Head Start program and the director of Family Services for that organization discuss the evolution of Head Start over time with particular attention to funding issues (and issues of federalism) in the Clinton/Bush years. What role should the federal government play in terms of funding, implementation, and oversight? How do Head Start administrators address the paucity of funding for their program initiatives? These are important public policy questions that students will have an opportunity to access first-hand, depending on the nature of their semester-long community project. One of the most interesting, moving, and inspiring moments in the course occurred when I asked the Head Start representatives to discuss how they maintain their commitment, energy, and positive spirit from year to year. One of the organization’s representatives responded by saying that she is “inspired every day by the people she interacts with, people who have so much stacked against them in life but who won’t allow that to defeat them.” In amplifying this point, she described one woman who walks many miles several times a week to visit the Head Start office even though she has physical disabilities. The administrative assistant to the Geneva Episcopal Church also visits the class to discuss the Neighbor’s Night Program, which she coordinates. Her visit is an important component of the course because her program represents the kind of faith-based initiative that President Bush has extolled as a part of his compassionate conservatism. Her contribution is also important because it nicely connects to Marvin Olasky’s book, Compassionate Conservatism, which is required reading for the course. What happens to those Geneva residents who need legal assistance but cannot afford proper legal representation? The executive director of the Legal Assistance of the Finger Lakes addresses that question when she visits the course. Some students who are enrolled in the course are interested in the intersection of community activism, public policy, and the law. This class session enables students to make appropriate connections across race and class divides. Hobart and William Smith Colleges president Mark Gearan visited the course to discuss his sense of the relationship between the colleges and the larger Geneva community with attention to how that relationship has developed over the course of his presidency and areas where improvement is also needed. President Gearan also brought his expertise as former chair of the National Campus Compact, as a member of the Partnership for Public Service, and as former Peace Corps director under President Clinton to the classroom. Dean of faculty and provost Teresa Amott visited the class, as well, to discuss some of the same themes but
76
Craig A. Rimmerman
also made an invaluable contribution to the class by discussing her work as a welfare rights organizer in Boston in the late 1960s. Her presentation and discussion facilitation allowed students to make useful connections to Michael Katz’s book, The Price of Citizenship: Redefining the American Welfare State, which is required reading for the course. How does all of this relate to the course assignments? Students were required to participate in community fieldwork for at least two hours per week for the entire semester. Many of the students worked longer hours given their commitment and interests. Students are engaged in an array of community-based organizations, including literacy programs, the local food pantry, the Boys and Girls Club, the Geneva Family YMCA, Neighbor’s Night at the Episcopal Church, after-school tutoring, the Geneva community lunch program, the Geneva Housing Authority, and Legal Assistance of the Finger Lakes, among others. Our campus Office of Public Service placed students, offered an evening of orientation and training before they went into the field, provided field assessment and offered overall logistical support. A central component of the course is a required course journal. The idea behind the journal is that communication, experience, and critical reflection are crucial components of intellectual and ethical growth. In addition, I asked students to relate their twice-weekly journal entries to the public policy issues that we were discussing in class and, most importantly, the course readings. The journal is meant to provide opportunities for communication and reflection while also creating a community of learning within the course itself. The goal is for our students to write journal entries that enable them to reflect upon their field work in some detail so that they can see how their observations have changed as the course unfolds. There are opportunities throughout the course for students to offer substantive observations regarding their fieldwork in light of the course material. In this way, the students learn from one another and get a much richer understanding of the larger Geneva community. Another important course requirement is a major course research paper, one that examines a public policy issue from a number of perspectives, by providing an historical overview of their chosen issue, discussing past policy solutions, outlining where the issue stands now in the legislative process, and then proposing policy recommendations in light of their understanding of the American policy process by discussing possible barriers to their recommendations and how those barriers might be overcome. Students are required to integrate relevant course readings (as well as material presented by our guest speakers/discussion facilitators) and to engage in considerable outside research. They are also encouraged to integrate their community fieldwork to enhance their overall policy analysis.
Service-Learning and Public Policy
77
THE CRITIQUE OF SERVICE Many of those opposed to courses that require students to participate in community or public service believe that such service simply cannot possibly achieve all that it purports to achieve. For example, “community service is not a cure for young people’s political apathy,” because “it teaches us little about the arts of participation in public life.”1 In addition, it falls far short of providing the everyday connections to the political process that students must have. Furthermore, most courses that require community service fail to afford students the opportunity that they need “to work effectively toward solving society’s problems.”2 Other critics of service-based fieldwork lament the fact that most student participants avoid tackling larger policy questions and issues. In this sense, the participants often conceive of service as an alternative to politics. Indeed, service is often a way for participants to avoid talking about politics.3 Boyte points out, for example, that the language of community service is infused with the jargon of “helping” rather than “a vocabulary that draws attention to the public world that extends beyond personal lives and local communities.” Service volunteers rarely have the ability to grapple with the complex intersection of class, race, and power that is created when middleor upper-middle-class youths engage in projects in low-income areas. In the absence of “a conceptual framework that distinguishes between personal life and the public world, community service adopts the ‘therapeutic language’ that now pervades society.”4 It is this therapeutic approach that cannot begin to deal with the inequalities that structure the relationship between the so-called servers and the served. Boyte explains further that “the current emphasis of volunteerism ‘dumbs down’ citizenship by highlighting personal traits like caring and individual acts of kindness and eclipsing questions of power, collective action, the cultures and functioning of institutions, and larger systemic problems.”5 In the end, service activity is devoid of politics, and, therefore, it is a relatively empty way of tackling the complex structural issues that arise out of the conditions that prompt service activity in the first place. Some contend that it ultimately contributes to “the narrowing political role of American citizens.”6 Yet another set of criticisms raises questions about the relationship of the individual to the State. According to Eric Gorham, “Community service is an institutional means by which the State uses political discourse and ideology to reproduce a postindustrial capitalist economy in the name of good citizenship.”7 For Gorham and other critics, community service reinforces the worst form of clientelism and tacitly accepts the structural inequalities growing out of the limited American welfare state. It does so by largely working within the confines of the current system without always affording students the opportunity to critique that system in a fundamental way. It
78
Craig A. Rimmerman
thus promotes an invidious form of authoritarianism. In addition, service assumes that all participants can afford to volunteer for little or no pay. Unfortunately, many students need one or two jobs merely to make ends meet while they pursue their undergraduate education. As a result, many are prevented from participating in service opportunities because of economic barriers. Gorham raises serious practical considerations that need to be addressed by proponents of any community service. To Gorham, these are the most important questions: 1. How well can the practice of national service fulfill its theoretical goals? 2. What does “inculcating civic education” mean in concrete terms? In what sense will national service offer opportunities for democracy, equality, and participation to those who serve? 3. Is the goal of citizenship appropriate to all people, regardless of their race or gender? 4. Does national service contribute to citizenship in any material way? 5. Furthermore, how should citizenship be nurtured? 6. Do the ideas of the planners of national service coincide with those of the philosophers who might view it as appropriate to their ends?8 Critics such as Eric Gorham point out that most proponents of service fail to ask these questions and, as a result, avoid discussing the kind of theoretical underpinnings that should be at the core of any courses that require students to participate in service activities. The libertarian perspective offers a final critique of national service programs. Libertarians—for example, Doug Bandow—point out that President Clinton’s national service proposal will ultimately lead to government coercion because all government service programs assume at their core that citizens are not responsible to one another, but are responsible to the State. In this way, the “volunteers” are actually coerced by the government to participate in service programs, thus losing their liberty and freedom. Bandow’s critique is particularly relevant to the present analysis because it raises interesting questions about whether students should be required to participate in any service experience as a part of a college course or courses.9
ONE RESPONSE TO THE CRITIQUE OF SERVICE In addressing the critique of service, I return to the course that underlies this chapter. One way to engage the critique is to inspire students to engage the
Service-Learning and Public Policy
79
arguments offered by those who criticize service-learning and to offer thoughtful responses in light of their own work in the community. Indeed, a service-learning public policy course affords many opportunities to do so. For example, one of the most important issues is to try to ascertain how the community perceives student fieldwork. And what does the community think of a service-learning requirement that ends once the course is over? Students invariably make important ties to human beings who come to count on their presence in their lives. This is always a difficult issue to negotiate and does not have easy answers, since it is built into the very nature of the relationship between the community and any college or university that offers service-learning courses. The key is to confront it head on and to ask students to write about it in light of their community participation. In addition, the Office of Public Service should work with the sites where students are placed to insure that the relationship is a positive one from the vantage point of the community. Another useful way to engage the critique of service-learning is to establish clear criteria at the outset for evaluating service-learning courses. Anne Colby, Thomas Ehrlich, Elizabeth Beaumont, and Jason Stephens pose these important evaluation questions: 1. Are the service-learning placements challenging (providing growth in important moral and civic skills)? 2. Are the students well prepared for the placements? 3. Do the field experiences contribute directly to the academic goals of the course? 4. Does the course have a structured reflection component that examines the issues addressed by the service in terms of systematic causes and policy responses as well as in interpersonal terms? 5. Do students use the reflection opportunities to think through their assumptions, values, and identities when appropriate as well as to focus on the substantive issues raised in the service experience? 6. Was the student participation effective from the point of view of the community partners?10 In addressing these questions and the critique of service, what students report as the course unfolds is crucial. The sources for this material are student observations in class, their course journal reflections, and their discussions with me in my office or in other campus settings. In its most successful moments, the course encourages students to develop the democratic imagination and personal commitments to be an active citizen. One compelling example of student growth involved a young female student working with a local food group that is responsible for distributing groceries to low-income individuals and families. She wrote in her journal
80
Craig A. Rimmerman
about her intense feelings of guilt and her privileged position in society when compared to the plight of the people she worked with as a part of her service experience. She came from a middle-income family in New England, a family that embraced fairly progressive political positions and had keen sensitivities to the needs of others. Nevertheless, she experienced deep anxiety about her own feelings of social distance and privilege. Ultimately, however, she worked through these emotions to grapple coherently with issues of class, race, and difference within the context of her fieldwork. In doing so, she was discovering crucial elements of what it means to be a citizen. Another student worked at the local food pantry and had a transforming interaction there one morning. He reported in class discussion that a young man who shared his birthday (and was also the same age) came in to get food for his girlfriend and their two children. The student, who came from a privileged background, stared in the face of poverty like he had never seen it before. What he described in class to all of us made for a spellbinding listening experience, one that helped to set a context for issues regarding inequality and poverty that helped to frame the entire course. The student later wrote about this experience in his course journal by connecting it to larger analytical issues of poverty policy. What was particularly interesting about this journal entry was how he was able to situate his interaction in the community within the context of broader public policy course themes. Individual student experience varies among the service opportunities. Some students challenged their own value systems, whereas others had routine involvement with agencies. One young woman working with a women’s organization confronted issues of sexual abuse that resonated with her own personal experience. Her journal revealed deep reflection about the assigned readings, especially those that discussed the intersection between gender and poverty. Although her field experience was deeply personal, it was not so qualitatively different from the experiences of many of the other students. Most of them were able to relate their service work to issues of equity, justice, individualism, and community. For almost all of them, it was their first opportunity to frame their community work in a larger context of rigorous intellectual work and group reflection. Other students encountered firsthand some of the fundamental social barriers to ethnic and racial harmony within the Geneva community. Working with neighborhood improvement groups, they witnessed the underlying racial antagonism that surrounds such issues as providing program services to low-income people, usually Latino or African American. Over time, the depth of racial and class divisions became very real to them, and most students increase their determination to reduce these divisions. The ability of some of these students to grapple with race, class, and social justice con-
Service-Learning and Public Policy
81
cerns within the context of their service experiences is a positive reason for requiring service in appropriate college courses. In addition, most students witnessed first hand the pernicious consequences of funding cutbacks in the implementation of social programs such as Head Start. How do social service agencies and not-for-profit organizations cope with funding challenges and uncertainty? What do these cutbacks mean for the operation of the organization and the provision of services on a day-to-day basis? These are important public policy questions that students had an opportunity to engage in light of their fieldwork. They were also required to connect their observations about program funding and fiscal austerity to required course books that addressed HIV/AIDS policy, poverty policy, affirmative action, and economic policymaking. None of this could have been accomplished without the required service/fieldwork component of the course. At the same time, however, the course has suffered from some of the weaknesses identified by critics of service-learning. For example, some students were reluctant to relate the course reading and discussion materials to politics and the broader issues of democracy and citizenship. There are several possible explanations for their unwillingness to do so. First, it is possible that the faculty facilitator was not tough enough in encouraging the students to make the appropriate connections. Yet it is difficult to be forceful in a course that is rooted in participatory democratic principles. Second, there can be little doubt that most students have been socialized to accept the basic elements of American “democracy” without the questioning or critical self reflection that the course and the notion of critical education for citizenship requires. As a result, we should not be surprised that students are reluctant to engage in this important critical process. Third, as some critics have pointed out, it may well be that there is a flaw in the structure and nature of courses that require service to the extent that they fail to connect service appropriately to issues of democracy, politics, and citizenship, as Harry Boyte has suggested.11 Some students probably resisted discussing issues of democracy, politics, and citizenship because, in their minds, their service activities had little relevance or connection to these broader issues. In addition, some students may hold antidemocratic or elitist attitudes, views that make them fundamentally hostile to the participatory democratic vision. Finally, a few students were uncomfortable with the servicelearning model and the radical critique, one that allowed them to think of politics much more broadly in terms of community organizing, advocacy, and creating progressive social movements. I am also convinced that one course cannot possibly tackle issues of democracy, citizenship, diversity, and difference with the kind of depth and attention to detail that such important concerns deserve. A central question underlying the course is, how are democracy, citizenship, diversity, difference,
82
Craig A. Rimmerman
and multiculturalism connected to or disconnected from one another? One cannot just assume that these connections will be readily apparent to all students. Participation in service-learning gives some students an opportunity to confront some of these concerns, but it is in the classroom that the task of making important connections must take place. One semester-long course cannot possibly do justice to the magnitude of the issues raised by servicelearning and the literature on democracy, citizenship, and service. What all this means is that students need to have opportunities to tackle important citizenship issues within the broader context of several different policy courses. To be sure, courses on citizenship are limited to the extent that they do not connect students directly with politics and the policymaking process. But that does not mean that such courses should be abolished. Indeed, we need more courses that allow students to think as public citizens, that link their classroom discussions with concerns in the larger society. At a time when students are socialized to think in highly private ways, they need opportunities to connect to the larger public sphere, where they will spend much of their lives. Faculty should build on the obvious commitment to public service that many students bring with them when they arrive on their campuses. Robert Putnam has pointed out: Young Americans in the 1990s displayed a commitment to volunteerism without parallel among their immediate predecessors. This development is the most promising sign of any that I have discovered that America might be on the cusp of a new period of civic renewal, especially if this youthful volunteerism persists into adulthood and begins to expand beyond individual caregiving to broader engagement with social and political issues.12
This commitment on the part of young people is clearly a source for optimism about the future. Courses in community politics, organizing, public policy, and service-based learning can build on this commitment by addressing the goals associated with the New Citizenship and by engaging students who are alienated from the political system at large. This is not easy work, but it is important and necessary work that lends itself well to education in a liberal arts setting.
NOTES 1. Harry C. Boyte, “Community Service and Civic Education,” Phi Beta Kappan, June 1991, 765. 2. Boyte, “Community Service and Civic Education,” 766. 3. Nina Eliasoph, Avoiding Politics: How Americans Produce Apathy in Everyday Life (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1998), 61. 4. Boyte, “Community Service and Civic Education,” 766.
Service-Learning and Public Policy
83
5. “Public Work: An Interview with Harry Boyte,” Higher Education Exchange (Kettering Foundation, 2000), 43. 6. Matthew A. Crenson and Benjamin Ginsberg, Downsizing Democracy: How America Sidelined Its Citizens and Privatized Its Public (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 2002), 9. 7. Eric B. Gorham, National Service, Citizenship, and Political Education (Albany: SUNY Press, 1992), 1. 8. Gorham, National Service, Citizenship, and Political Education, 131. 9. See Doug Bandow, “National Service: Utopia Revisited,” Policy Analysis, March 15, 1993, 1–20. 10. Anne Colby, Thomas Ehrlich, Elizabeth Beaumont, and Jason Stephens, Educating Citizens: Preparing Undergraduates for Lives of Moral and Civic Responsibility (San Francisco: Jossey-Bass, 2003), 263–64. 11 See Boyte, “Community Service and Civic Education.” 12. Robert Putnam, Bowling Alone: The Collapse and Revival of American Community (New York: Simon and Schuster, 2000), 133.
6 America Reads as Service-Learning: A Stereophonic Report Kathleen Flowers and Charles Temple
A decade ago the America Reads Challenge set in motion President Clinton’s dream of sending a million college students into local schools to help at-risk children learn to read. The period of active promotion of America Reads by the federal government was brief—it was proposed in 1996, funded by Congress in 1997, and quietly set aside by the Bush administration in 2001.1 But that period coincided with a spurt of enthusiasm for service-learning projects in colleges and universities, for which the America Reads Challenge was a ready vehicle. Besides, the rules governing federal work-study funding continue to require colleges and universities to use 7 percent of their federal work-study funds2 to support students involved in community service projects, expressly including tutoring in literacy; so America Reads projects continue cheerfully along on many campuses, even if the cheering from the government has stopped. The literature on America Reads tends to run in three veins. Some of it looks at the program as a vehicle for service—even as a partial resumption of the War on Poverty, when the imaginations of large numbers of young people in America were captured by the ideal of alleviating the injustices suffered by the many Americans surviving on low incomes and low levels of education. Some of the literature addresses America Reads as an opportunity for students to reflect on citizenship, especially in the spirit of what Professor Craig Rimmerman calls the “New Citizenship.”3 Most of it deals with the practical side of taking students with little training and having them make a difference in young children’s literacy levels with just a few brief meetings each week. In this paper we will look at some issues that arise between the service, the learning, and the practical strands. One is the 85
86
Kathleen Flowers and Charles Temple
strong tension that comes between using voluntary social service as a vehicle for liberal arts learning on the one hand, and on the other hand doing justice to the social service—devoting the time and specialized training to prepare students to perform the service well. Second, we acknowledge that for a project like America Reads to thrive on a college campus, it must have success over time, which means it must have buy-in from students for more than the semester in which a service-learning course operates. And that means it must have a support staff who do countless things to make the project successful—things most professors of the service-learning courses might not be aware of. In the sections that follow, we will take turns talking about an America Reads project on a liberal arts campus—Kathleen from the point of view of the day-to-day manager of the project, working out of the Center for Community Engagement and Service-Learning at the Colleges, and Charles speaking from the perspective as a professor who helped set up the project and has advised it over the years. The narrator of each section will be identified in a heading.
TEMPLE The education course on literacy that I teach has supported the America Reads Challenge from the beginning—as it had America Reads’s predecessors on campus. For twenty-five years the course has been flexible in its aims, since Hobart and William Smith Colleges had long ago “decoupled” our education courses from our teacher certification programs. Students who want to be certified learn to teach by teaching—and because our education courses are not required for students preparing for a profession, they are framed as liberal arts courses, free to look broadly and deeply at interesting and important topics in the area of education and open to any student on campus. For the first several years the literacy course allowed students many pathways to experience issues related to literacy. We read about emergent literacy, and some students went to explore that phenomenon in primary classrooms. We read literary theory, and some went into schools to conduct discussion groups. We read Paolo Freire on critical consciousness, and some students volunteered in a GED class downtown to see how literacy and consciousness interacted. When Jonathan Kozol’s Illiterate America (1986) began circulating, the emphasis of the literacy course changed. Kozol called for college students to go out into their communities to teach the 60 million American adults who cannot read. Soon after his book appeared, Professor Craig Rimmerman brought his political science students over with a question. They were reading Kozol and wanted to go into the community right away and teach adults
America Reads as Service-Learning
87
to read. Where could we find some? I introduced them to Bird Stasz, a local adult education teacher. She invited the students to come along to her GED classes, and soon a hefty group of students had been recruited to do so. Shortly afterwards, the Student Literacy Corps Assistance Act was funded, our students heard of it and wrote a proposal, and in 1989 we received one of the first twenty-five grants in the nation. The grant brought Bird Stasz to work on campus, and students’ involvement in literacy work exploded. They did bilingual writing projects with parents in the Head Start center, they taught reading in the GED center, they taught GED classes in the county jail, they ran writing workshops in the battered women’s shelter. Bird and I began to team-teach the literacy class, which became more focused on the problems of illiterate adults, as well as the young people who were on their way to joining them. It is true that we had less time in the course for our more long-haired topics, but the students had a feeling of urgency about their mission, and so did we. After a run of only five years, the Student Literacy Corps was zero-funded in 1994.4 Our literacy activities continued, nevertheless. The dean’s office, which had become been vigorously promoting service-learning under an American Commitments grant from the AACU, supported the salary of a volunteer coordinator. Students’ activity in literacy continued at a high level. The literacy course began to focus on ways of intervening with at-risk young readers, and as part of the course the class spent two days each week tutoring young children in a local primary school. We still do. America Reads was passed into law by Congress in 1997 as a body without a head, because it potentially sent students out to tutor children with no guidance from teachers dedicated to supervising them.5 Knowledgeable educators had long argued that for volunteer tutoring programs to succeed, they have to be tightly structured in lessons that contain the proper selection of activities; and the lessons have to work with children at carefully graduated levels of difficulty.6 This combination of factors essentially requires that a skilled supervisor be on site with the tutors and children to assess the children’s needs, supervise the tutors, and keep the instruction going at the right pace and on the right level for each child. The Clinton administration had proposed that teachers be hired under the act to serve this purpose, but Congress refused to provide them. We brought America Reads to campus in 1996 and patterned our program on the Howard Street tutoring model, designed by Darrell Morris at Appalachian State University.7 Our program, like his, had a structured lesson that would be used by the tutors during each forty-minute session. The lesson called for the tutor to guide the child as she reads one short book on the easy side and another on the challenging side of her reading level; then conduct writing, word study, and spelling activities; then preview a book to
88
Kathleen Flowers and Charles Temple
read in the next lesson; and finally read aloud to the child. The specifics of the lesson are written on one side of a lesson plan form. On the other side of the form was space for the tutor to write down quickly how each activity went—whether that part of the lesson seemed to be above, below, or right at the student’s level of competence. Each tutor had a portfolio containing lesson plan forms, books on levels assigned for the child being tutored, and word cards for word study. Site supervisors packed the portfolios, based initially on information gained from assessing each child’s reading level with a short test, and later on the basis of the tutor’s reports. Also, site supervisors were present while the tutoring was going on and would make suggestions for the lessons. But how would the site supervisors be trained? That brings us back to my literacy course. We could obviously use a cadre of students on campus who knew something about how children learn how to read. Ideally, they would become site supervisors for America Reads. The literacy course thus tightened its focus even further. Now, while the students still read much of the theoretical work about the linguistic, anthropological, and literary theoretical underpinnings of literacy, they read a lot more about assessment and teaching. Moreover, now the whole class became involved in tutoring. The class meets for three periods each week for a semester. After giving three weeks to orient students to the issues of the course and preparing to assess and tutor (mostly preparing to assess and tutor their children), the students and I begin going out to a local elementary school for two periods every week, meeting one normal class and one lab period on campus to conduct other course business. Out in the school, pairs of students work with one child, taking turns teaching and taking notes. I am free to move from table to table, supervising the assessment and the teaching, and collecting examples that can be discussed in a later class. Students keep journals, in which they record what happened when they tutored, and relate those experiences to the readings and class discussions. They write an extensive case study of the child they were working with, and they also write a term paper about some aspect of literacy that interested them. In the course of the term, the students learn how to administer and interpret several literacy assessment devices and also how to apply teaching methods for fluency, comprehension, and word recognition and writing. Several of them become long-term volunteers with America Reads, meaning that they may be site supervisors or are available to give advice to the student tutors.
FLOWERS The America Reads program is the most extensive opportunity for HWS students to participate in consistent service. It is housed in The Center for
America Reads as Service-Learning
89
Community Engagement and Service-Learning, hereafter referred to as “The Center.” Approximately seventy-two tutors work with sixty-six children at six local schools two or three times per week for ten weeks each semester. The center’s staff, through service opportunities and related reflection, seek to meet students where they are developmentally in reference to their understanding of the definition of community service and help move them along a continuum of comprehension toward civic engagement, then civicleadership, and ultimately engaged citizenship. America Reads tutors are tasked with the challenge of thoughtfully addressing a major problem facing our community’s children and feel compelled to act. They utilize (limited) training in conjunction with classroom discussion to think critically about why some children arrive ill prepared to succeed in school and what they, as compassionate and capable college students, can do to help. We consider tutoring an example of the second stage of the continuum, “civic engagement.” The program would not function without the strong leadership of veteran tutors, known as coordinators. The coordinators facilitate each session and serve as role models to both the children and tutors; coordinators are living examples of “civic leadership.” The final stage in the continuum will ideally occur during the lifetime of our graduates. As “engaged citizens,” former tutors will be able to synthesize the knowledge acquired from training, related course work, and reflection to commit to a life of social justice. The majority of students who apply to become tutors are those that have federal work-study as part of their financial aid package. They receive minimum wage for their efforts to engage local children as the tutor and child work together to improve the child’s reading abilities and confidence. The tutors represent all academic majors and class years, although not surprisingly many hail from the humanities field. In addition to new tutors, there are numerous “veteran” tutors at each site since many students return to America Reads. Each site has one exceptional veteran tutor, known as the coordinator, who is responsible for the facilitation of each session. A positive trend at HWS Colleges has been for nonfederal work-study students to apply to become tutors (allocation and amount of federal work-study is based on financial need demonstrated by the student during the financial aid process). These students are considered “volunteer” tutors since they aren’t eligible to be paid. The expectations held of them are no different than their peers who receive a biweekly pay check in their mailbox. A challenge that I face regarding volunteer tutors is how to best recognize and appreciate their efforts since they aren’t eligible for compensation. More children receive tutoring support at no budgetary impact when volunteers are hired, but I have concerns that to distinguish their participation in the program above from that of their (paid) peers might reveal information that they would prefer not to disclose. Lastly, a small number of tutors receive service-learning credit as they are able
90
Kathleen Flowers and Charles Temple
and encouraged to utilize the America Reads program to meet the thirty-hour requirement for a class. To summarize, we’ve learned that tutors share many interests, which include their desire to invest in learning about Geneva beyond the campus limits and an idealistic “can do” attitude when it comes to the task at hand. They draw from positive interactions with teachers and mentors and seek to duplicate that in the relationships they form with their tutees. We recruit students who have financial need and pay them an hourly rate but strive to include volunteer tutors in the program. We hope that tutors are able to utilize their experience in conjunction with a service-learning class because we know they’ll likely gain a deeper understanding of the issues related to economics, race, and the subsequent challenges to succeed in school. Although the America Reads Challenge has a relatively simple mission, “for all children to read well and independently by third grade,” our center has lofty expectations. We hope to assist teachers by increasing the reading skills of the children they send us and we strive to generate civically engaged student leaders (archives).
TEMPLE America Reads is perhaps above all an opportunity for students to serve their community. As service-learning advocates like to remind us, colleges and universities acknowledge that obligation right in our charters; indeed, the expectation that our institutions will serve the communities in which we are located is a major reason private colleges are tax exempt. Sociologist George Farkas developed a literacy tutoring program that partly inspired the America Reads Challenge,8 and he is a good example of someone interested in America Reads because he values the service. Farkas sees tutoring projects like America Reads as an opportunity to help low-income children who desperately need this help, and he urges the academy in general and sociologists in particular to mobilize their students to the cause of helping lowincome children close the literacy gap. That is a worthy goal in its own right, he argues, because “[t]he continued existence of . . . disadvantage in one of the world’s richest and most powerful nations, which began a War on Poverty more than thirty years ago, is . . . scandalous.”9 Farkas does not see the benefits to the students to be the main point of their participation in community service programs like America Reads: Service-learning has been springing up on college campuses around the country. In two regards, however, these activities often resemble the poorly-designed training efforts of education and social work schools. First, the preparation of students in these courses often gives too little attention to the technical de-
America Reads as Service-Learning
91
mands of training them to deliver worthwhile service. And second, the assistance given these students to learn from the experience, and thereby increase their and our store of knowledge, is too unscientific in its approach to data and evidence to produce knowledge of much value.10
For Farkas the big problem in service-learning as the basis for fielding tutoring programs like Americas Reads is that it results in minimal and, to his thinking, inadequate training for tutors to teach. He makes a good point, and it has two parts to it. One is that teaching reading well does require that someone know more than a little about the learning processes involved in literacy and best practices in teaching. Literacy is the most intensely studied topic in the field of education, and there is room for suspicion that whoever contemplated sending a million untrained college students out to teach reading may have underestimated the complexity of the task. The other aspect of Farkas’s complaint is that the reflection piece in a servicelearning course will take up valuable time that would be better spent training students to teach reading, which in Farkas’s view is a misallocation of time because the reflection work will not be done effectively anyway. In the literacy course I experience a similar tension in our teaching, too, in the extensive need to train students to be effective tutors. My problem in this area is different, though. I am capable of training students to tutor children in reading because I have a background in that area. But how much time should the students spend in class learning to be tutors? The course on literacy is a broadly based liberal arts course and not a training program. I am reluctant to turn it into an intensive training program in literacy—partly because there are many other issues I want the class to discuss in the course, but still more because on a liberal arts campus we don’t present only one way to do things, but rather encourage the students’ originality as thinkers and problem solvers.11
FLOWERS In concert with the ideal of a liberal arts experience, we provide the tutors with information and training, and we encourage them to use their creativity as they work to address the problem in our community of children who aren’t able to read at the appropriate grade level. I’d like not to make Farkas’s case that the tutors are inadequately prepared to make a significant difference to the child or make noteworthy gains in their own learning, but I can certainly appreciate that his concerns are sometimes well founded. The next few paragraphs outline in detail the training that the tutors receive, and sprinkled throughout are anecdotes taken from anonymous end-ofsemester tutor evaluations. During the three trainings that occur prior to the
92
Kathleen Flowers and Charles Temple
arrival of the first child, we discuss how a child’s socioeconomic status and race will impact his or her educational experience, and then we train each tutor on how to confront their tutee’s reading difficulties through utilization of the lesson plans. They don’t always apply the information the way we anticipate, but as noted below many creative solutions have arisen from tutors’ suggestions and resourcefulness. Tutors receive training to prepare them for what to do in each America Reads session and are made aware of resources available that they will (ideally) utilize to engage the tutee and keep behavioral issues at bay. During the initial training for new tutors I facilitate a variety of “ice breakers,” which include having a tutor recall a favorite childhood story, remember an event from the year on a coin drawn from a hat (coins are of course pre-selected to correspond with dates the tutors were in elementary school!) or remember a mentor or role model and the subsequent impact. These activities serve the initial purpose of getting to know names and faces of new peers, but they also help the tutor realize that the special bond formed between a caring adult often has an impact that is remembered long after the last encounter. The same training includes an interactive PowerPoint presentation that is largely a summary of Intervening for Literacy: The Joy of Reading to Young Children.12 Tutors aren’t surprised to hear information that supports what they can already infer, that children who have a strong vocabulary from being read to have an easier time acquiring additional knowledge to be successful in school when compared to peers from under-supportive literacy environments. They learn about how and why early and consistent involvement of caring parents, teachers, and tutors is so important to a child’s ultimate success; and they become versed in the probable outcome should caring adults not intervene. What the tutors don’t anticipate, though, are the huge obstacles that stand in a child’s way of proficient reading and learning success. The compelling statistics that describe the actual number of words that children from wealthy families are exposed to per hour when compared to children from poor families is both surprising and unsettling. Equally unexpected from the tutors are the realities of risk factors that are associated with reading success. “What do you mean children from racially segregated schools [will likely struggle with reading], we don’t have ‘segregated’ schools in America!” Since the reality of many of the tutors entailed rural or suburban public and predominantly white public or private schools, it’s difficult to fully grasp that race and ethnicity will largely dictate a child’s trajectory for school success. New tutors also learn how a “typical” America Reads session is organized, strategies to utilize during sessions, and reading and writing activities to do when the child finishes three books. Each session starts with reviewing a book from the previous session, reading a new book, and previewing a
America Reads as Service-Learning
93
book for the next session. The strategy is not difficult to understand, repetition of a book breeds confidence (“Wow, you struggled with the words ‘neighborhood’ and ‘tricycle’ last session, and you just breezed right by them today!”), exposure to a new story provides an opportunity to acquire vocabulary (“sound it out; what sound does a ph make?”), and previewing a book is a fun way to get the child to be creative and lay the groundwork for future comprehension (“on this ‘picture walk’ don’t worry about the words yet; by looking at the illustrations, what do you think will happen?”). Additionally, they receive a “quiz” as prior instructions asked them to log on to the America Reads Blackboard site. Embedded in the links for activities, articles, and websites are logos for candy bars and local restaurants. It’s my (overly idealistic?) hope that while searching for the “Subway” logo, they’ll stop to see how many colleges and universities across the county host America Reads programs, or skim articles that explain why “fluency” and “phonemic awareness” are important to fledgling readers. Tutors print out the logo to prove that they were on the site and receive a corresponding prize. An extra prize goes to the tutor that found Maslow’s hierarchy of needs triangle and can explain what self-actualization has to do with America Reads. Most explanations will do, but variations of the “wet mitten syndrome,” which portrays the child with wet socks or mittens, will have a tough time acquiring new language and reading confidence if they are distracted. Finally, they are taught that how you read with a child is equally important to what you read with the child. “Scaffolding,” the term used to describe how a tutor and child read together (“I read this sentence and you read the next”) and the value of open-ended questions are discussed. Interactive reading is something that occurred naturally in many of the tutors’ childhoods, and they learn why asking a child how they would choose to end the story if they were the author is more important than they ever realized. We don’t delve into Leo Vygotsky’s “zone of proximal development,” but we do discuss briefly that reading books that are just challenging enough is the main objective of each session. The first training of the semester for “veteran” tutors includes a more indepth session with education professor Charlie Temple. Charlie goes farther into depth about how to teach to build fluency and comprehension. We discuss why a child’s ability to read smoothly and comprehend what was just read is of utmost importance to the child as it relates to the current testing standards under “No Child Left Behind.” The veteran tutors read passages from actual tests and uncover inherent biases and discuss the usefulness and futility of frequent testing in early grades. The veterans ask the professor specific questions that arose from previous encounters with their tutee. The responses to the challenges help all veterans become more prepared to have productive sessions and more confident in their abilities to positively affect the lives of the tutees.
94
Kathleen Flowers and Charles Temple
The second training for all tutors is held jointly in the newly formed groups that are the team of tutors for each of the six sites. The coordinator has an agenda to follow so that each cohort of tutors is exposed to similar material. There is room, however, for the coordinator to adjust to his or her preferences, including ice breakers and site-specific information, and advice passed along by the veteran tutors in each group. These meetings are held at the Geneva Public Library in the fall semester so that all tutors can obtain a library card. The children’s room at the library is stocked with a wonderful assortment of children’s books in English and Spanish, as well as other resources available to the tutors. The ideal is that after the tutor uncovers the tutee’s interests, he or she will use the newly acquired library card to augment books selected by the coordinator from the center’s “book nook.” The “book nook” has a small collection of children’s books, and as previously mentioned the coordinator packs a folder of three books for each child for each session. However, some tutors often comment that the child doesn’t like to reread books, “sometimes I felt my tutee was a little bored by the monotonous cycle of rereading books from the previous session. Group exercises like BINGO were a fun way to break the cycle.” The remarkable tutors are the ones that supplement each session with books from the Geneva Public Library that correspond to the child’s interests and reading level; predictably these tutors tend to have less behavioral management issues than the tutors that don’t utilize additional resources to enhance each session. However, I can’t necessarily fault tutors for not using the public library or America Reads Blackboard site because I can’t pay them for the additional investment of their time. The third and final training that tutors receive before their first day occurs on site with the principal or assistant principal and the teachers that will be sending children to the program. Teachers will advocate for the children who don’t receive much support at home to join the program. These teachers know first hand what the research tells us; when a child’s home life includes stories at bed-time selected from a personal “library” of books, that child will have an easier time achieving at school when compared to peers that don’t have similar home environments. The best onsite orientation I’ve seen is at the school where the teachers are visibly excited to meet their students’ new tutors. They bounce into the library or cafeteria and describe previous examples of progress made from past tutor/child pairings and jest with each other “I deserve more tutors this year!” They share stories of how many parents specifically request that their son or daughter is enrolled in America Reads because of a sibling or neighbor that had participated. Next, the teacher holds up a headshot of each child and describes the child’s personality, reading struggles, and corresponding reading level so that the coordinator can select books accordingly.
America Reads as Service-Learning
95
The teacher describes the ideal tutor, for example, “Jake doesn’t have a dad in the picture and his first language is Spanish, so a positive male role model who speaks even a little Spanish would be great.” A Hobart student will inevitably raise his hand and say “I’d like to work with him” and the teacher and tutor meet separately to more fully discuss plans for young Jake and share contact information should there be questions or problems.
TEMPLE The literature about service-learning courses often speaks of the benefits to college students’ civic consciousness, their political awareness, and their empathy and problem-solving skills. Considering America Reads on one West Virginia campus as a service-learning experiment, for example, political scientists Hunter and Brisbin13 described the effects of participation as tutors on the college students’ civic knowledge and disposition toward engagement. They found that service by itself did a little to move students along this dimension, but most of the effects were felt if the professor hammered these points home: Volunteer service activities appear to raise students’ assessments of the values of paying attention to politics, racial diversity, and community responsibility for addressing problems like poverty and hunger. Service apparently has some value for increasing political knowledge and fostering civic responsibility. Specific attention by the instructor to the explanation of political meaning and interpretation of experiences should sharpen the students’ appreciation of their service experience. To the extent that faculty incorporate discussions of civic responsibility and democracy into these service-learning courses, it is likely that student understanding of these concepts will be enhanced.14
In my literacy course, the reflection pieces assigned have to do with literacy—how children learn to read, what the assessments show, the relations between what emerges from an assessment and what students observe when they are working with a child every other day, and how all this compares with what they have studied about the interactions of things like phonemic awareness, orthographic knowledge, schemata, fluency, and motivation. In the meetings students have in the America Reads program, a few other issues come up.
FLOWERS In an ideal world where resources and time were limitless, we’d have sufficient opportunity to delve into the complexities involved with how to teach
96
Kathleen Flowers and Charles Temple
a child to read as well as the devastating impact that illiteracy has on families and society. We’d discuss current policy and brainstorm new ideas with corresponding budgets that we’d send to our congressmen and congresswomen for contemplation. All the while we’d be able to pay tutors for each hour they invested preparing for the sessions in addition to the time spent actually tutoring. Alas, we have limited federal work-study funds that curtail the training we’d like to provide as well as the number of students we could send. In addition to the two or three weekly tutoring sessions, the federal work-study budget enables us approximately three hours of training for each tutor prior to sessions, one hour per tutor during the semester to problem-solve, and one hour per tutor at the conclusion of each semester to reflect. After the three pre-session trainings, a separate one for new and veteran tutors, a combined meeting when the tutors meet as a team, and the third meeting held on site to tour the school and meet teachers and the administrator, is it possible that tutors are adequately prepared to start working one-on-one with a child? They certainly know what they are supposed to do, but when the ideal of the session meets the reality of a challenging child, I struggle to adequately prepare all tutors for the situations that inevitably occur when the child is distracted, uncooperative, or disinterested in reading. The children have a wide variety of issues that they bring to each session, including feelings of incompetence, anxiety from watching rated “R” movies, an incarcerated parent; the list could go on indefinitely, and it is difficult for tutors to anticipate these issues and know how to respond appropriately. One tutor noted that “it was frustrating to see that Quincey would come to sessions hungry and exhausted, no one can think about reading when all they want is breakfast.” Another tutor questioned the balance between being a tutor with a reading agenda to accomplish and a caring adult to provide reassurance, “my tutee had many problems at home and I wasn’t always sure how to handle that, do I sacrifice reading time to listen?” A further example involves a tutor that was very concerned about his tutee’s well-being; “It was clear that Anthony had a lot of issues going on at home. I knew that he wasn’t encouraged to read, that his parents were going through a brutal divorce, and that his after school life basically consisted of watching television. I know it was nothing I could control however it was so frustrating to see him not get the help he needed.” During difficult situations, I hope that the tutor knows to reach out to me, the site coordinator, professors in the education department, the child’s teacher, or Blackboard. Certainly, the few tutors that are enrolled in servicelearning psychology, education, and public-policy courses are able to draw from rich in-class discussion and service outside the classroom. They are more prepared to view these challenges in the complicated context of a
America Reads as Service-Learning
97
struggling child in an unsupportive family and school environment when compared to their peers that aren’t enrolled in such classes. This is the reflection from a tutor’s end-of-semester evaluation: “I felt like I was really helpless in a lot of situations, the students were sometimes out of control. When Rucianno refused to wear his glasses, I didn’t really know what to do to encourage him [everything I was saying was ineffective]. When Rucciano didn’t progress very far [just two levels] I was a little disappointed I wasn’t able to help him more. It’s really hard to build internal motivation.” A tutor noted that her tutee didn’t like to read so he didn’t like America Reads. Another tutor commented “my kid hardly ever wanted to read and came in each session already defeated; sometimes she would refuse to read altogether and would get easily frustrated.” Overall, it seems that new tutors are adequately prepared to start tutoring when the child is happy, but they struggle to thwart behavioral issues if and when they arise. Veteran tutors are noticeably more confident with their tutoring and behavioral management skills. Each semester, the tutors that return express a deeper respect for the role that caring parents, teachers, and mentors play in a child’s life and realize the power of positive influence. The tutors realize that they have become the advocates that many of them were lucky to have throughout their childhoods, and equally important they understand the devastating impact that can result when no one is there to support a child. Both new and veteran tutors show surprise at how quickly bonds are formed; one tutor noted how flattered he was when his tutee started to dress like him, “[he] showed up for sessions in khaki colored pants and a polo shirt.” Another tutor noted that she “was surprised . . . that [my tutee] really seemed to enjoy spending time with me.”
TEMPLE Within the education field, much of the literature on America Reads has focused on practical issues surrounding tutoring children in literacy. The question of literacy is of huge importance, as Farkas correctly declared. The National Assessment of Educational Progress15 showed that 40 percent of American fourth graders could not read with basic competence. For African American and Latino children the figure was over 60 percent. The National Adult Literacy Survey16 found the same percentages of adults reading poorly—and showed that people’s income and other quality-of-life factors (like having a good job, and staying off welfare and out of jail) marched precisely in step with their literacy levels. The adult literacy survey extensively tested 26,000 adults over the age of sixteen. A fourth of them could barely make sense of any printed language. Half of them could not intelligently distinguish between one-page descriptions of automobiles—or,
98
Kathleen Flowers and Charles Temple
presumably, of political candidates or retirement plans. Moreover, this study found that the people with the least ability to read, write, and calculate did not see that as a problem. (We will return to this later.) The findings of both these studies are shocking. What should be done? One clue is that reading problems have roots in early childhood. Hart and Risley17 showed four-fold differences in the language experience of poor people’s and professional people’s preschool children. Learning to read is easier for children who have more vocabulary, more background knowledge, and more metalinguistic awareness—awareness of language itself. It is also easier for children who have had early and continuing exposure to printed language.18 Some children are woefully behind others in these things when they enter first grade. Twenty years ago, schools were not likely to offer the necessary help to children who came to school under-prepared. When Connie Juel identified the bottom 10 percent of the readers in the fourth grade of one school, most of them—86 percent—were still at the bottom four years later, but by then their deficits were far more serious than they had been earlier.19 Keith Stanovich20 showed how risk factors—and success factors—compounded on each other, according to what he called “Matthew Effects,” after the Gospel according to St. Matthew (25:29).21 Fortunately, the experience of some tutoring programs showed that it is possible to intervene with first-grade children who show signs of reading failure and teach them what they need to know in order to learn adequately thereafter, right along with their classmates.22 But these tutoring interventions are normally quite expensive. The most widely used model of early intervention, Reading Recovery,23 requires that a specially trained professional teacher work one-on-one every day for some forty-five minutes with each, and that teacher typically works with only eight students in a year. The cost of professional tutoring programs leads people to ask if college student volunteers could achieve some of the same benefits. Research has shown that the student volunteers can indeed be successful.24 Fitzgerald,25 for instance, showed that children tutored by college students at the University of North Carolina gained one-and-a-half year’s growth in reading in six months of tutoring. With a good quality design and strategies to keep the instruction focused on things children need to know and at the proper levels of challenge, volunteer tutoring programs can help young children overcome reading failure, and do so at a fraction of the cost of the professional programs. This is why we are talking about America Reads. The close relationship between the literacy course and the America Reads program has worked well from many points of view. There is a strong connection between theory and practice in the literacy course. Just about every topic we discuss in the course is illuminated by the students’ practice in their tutoring. It is natural to extrapolate beyond our tutoring experience to
America Reads as Service-Learning
99
other issues. For instance, we read a fair amount about the importance of literacy, about the connection between literacy and consciousness, and about attempts to improve literacy rates both in the United States and around the world. One thing that comes home to my students right away is how hard this work is. Even when the desirable supports are present in a child’s life, many children struggle to make progress in learning to read. What must the situation be like in parts of the world where children’s parents don’t read, where there are eighty first graders in a class, one textbook for every ten children, and no library? We sometimes go and see. In my life outside of college teaching I work extensively in literacy projects in Central Europe, the Caucasus, Central and South America, and East and West Africa. Three times in recent years students have come along, two to Tanzania and one to Argentina. But students wonder about the international situation with literacy because they often go overseas on their own, through the term abroad programs that go to thirty countries, many of them developing countries where they can visit schools and literacy projects.
FLOWERS In an attempt to join theory and practice, we hire one student annually to serve in a dual capacity of both site coordinator and “literacy office assistant.” The student is hired because of previously demonstrated exceptional work as a creative and engaged tutor as well as leadership potential. The position is so important to the success of the program, so we always recruit from the list of students that have taken Charlie’s class. We know that the experience in the class will prepare them to understand the challenges and opportunities inherent in pairing tutors that will receive just three hours of training with children that are reading below grade level. To provide additional support, the student is sent to the Student Coalition for Action in Literacy Education (SCALE) conference sponsored by the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill or encouraged to partake in an equivalent professional development opportunity. Rachel Sumner, office assistant during the 2005–2006 academic year, commented about her experience at the SCALE conference: “I learned about the ‘Matthew effects’ in previous America Reads trainings, and I saw firsthand how success begets success (as well as the reverse) when I tutored. However, attending workshops at the SCALE conference made me realize how pervasive and devastating the problem of illiteracy in America is as well as how extensive the efforts are to address it. It was both overwhelming and energizing to witness. I have acquired subsequent internship experience and set future career goals with these experiences in mind.” Rachel
100
Kathleen Flowers and Charles Temple
interned at D.C.-based non-profit “First Book” last summer and plans to apply to “Teach for America” upon graduation in May 2008. The literacy office assistant creates activities for the tutors to complete with the children each week. The position often serves as an “assistant coach” and hears firsthand what the “head coach” might not. The range of feedback, both informally conveyed or formally posted to Blackboard, serves as a good indicator for how the tutors and tutees are progressing. An indirect benefit of the America Reads program occurs when engaged and thoughtful tutors become friends and allies. I believe that participation in America Reads, and similar extracurricular activities, serve as a positive retention tool. These are excepts from the evaluations, Blackboard, and anecdotes that either the literacy office assistants or I have heard in the past three years: “I love the America Reads program. I think it has taught me a lot and I love being able to help kids,” “working with my kid usually brightened my day,” “AR was a refreshing break from school work and sports,” “I think that AR is one of the best programs at the colleges, what it does for students (both tutors and tutees) is amazing.” Perhaps disconcerting, although not astonishing, are the following comments: “Sometimes it was the only reason I got out of bed in the morning” “I think I would have transferred if I hadn’t found this program.” Tutors create Facebook groups and buy America Reads t-shirts; it’s clear that they are proud of what they do, and they want to belong to a larger group of people who care about children, literacy, and service.
TEMPLE The literacy course supports a program that does a lot of good for young people in our city of Geneva. Most years, it is said that between our America Reads program and the special reading services the schools provide, we are reaching every child or nearly every child in the first three grades who needs a tutor. People sometimes stop me on the street to speak of the difference a tutor has made in a child’s school life. The America Reads program has led to career paths for many of our students, either into the teaching field, or through the Peace Corps, or through publishing, or through other kinds of community service work. Still, there are issues, cautions, that must be pointed out. The America Reads program has thrived, it is true, but that success has depended very heavily on the excellent day-to-day support it has enjoyed from dedicated supervisors and a committed group of student leaders and student tutors. Our America Reads and similar projects have had tireless and excellent leadership over the years, first from Matt Adams, Dave Mapstone, Karen Wiszniewski, Jenna Logue, and now from Katie Flowers. Good projects don’t run themselves.
America Reads as Service-Learning
101
If a tutoring project in literacy is to be successful, so the experts tell us, the tutors must do the right thing, just about every hour they are with their children. That means their efforts must be fairly closely prescribed by a knowledgeable teacher. Too much inventiveness on an untrained tutor’s part is not likely to be beneficial for the child being tutored; this time is precious, and we owe it to the children to use it as best we can. Yet it is surely true that the tutors must have some leeway to be creative— first because their motivation requires that they be in control, and second because they often do have better ideas about what will work with this child at this time than a professor at some remove. Maintaining the balance between a responsible level of professional direction and room for the tutor’s creativity is critical and difficult.
FLOWERS I am constantly amazed at tutors’ thoughtful suggestions and creative solutions for improving the sessions. A few years ago, tutors would play “hangman” with the children when the three books were completed. A tutor told me about an uncomfortable conversation he had with a child when asked what a “noose” was while playing the game. We agreed that “hangman” was not the best activity tutors and children should play when taking into account all of the other resources available, and together we created a new version of the last resort game where a smiley face would be created instead. Additional changes to the program include the group training at the Geneva Public Library, which is a result of a coordinator suggestion. Tutors often send me links to wonderful websites they’ve found and want me to post on Blackboard so that others might benefit. They create games like the “folding fortune teller” to practice vocabulary and bring in flash cards, Mad-Libs, jokes, and riddles. One tutor, who took note of his tutee’s obsession with skate boards, would have the child call his friend who was a professional skate boarder to tell him about the books they read that day. The best tutors go to great lengths to make each session a positive and productive experience for the child and realize in hindsight that they too learned something on the journey. They have “aha” moments like the children, evident with the tutor that realized “I couldn’t make him learn. This semester taught me to let go of that a little, as long as I work my hardest as a tutor, I just have to hope for the best.” They learn to laugh along the way, like the tutor that fondly recalls that his tutee said he didn’t know how to spell “Supercalafragalisticexpialadotious” because he didn’t speak Spanish. Another tutor commented that “my tutee would make all sorts of sounds when she was reading. Just like meows and other animal noises, but the funniest by far was her goat impression.”
102
Kathleen Flowers and Charles Temple
TEMPLE In order for the literacy course to serve the America Reads program well— and also to be prepared for the tutoring the students do in the class—we have had to devote much class time to teaching and assessment matters, and we have devoted less time to other topics (Patrick Collins is addressing the same issue in his chapter in this volume). I believe the trade-off is worth it, but it is a trade-off that should be acknowledged. For example, during the three weeks before we go out into the schools for the first time, the class is working almost full time on reading assessment—not on assessment of learning in general, but on how to do this assessment. On those items that have to be covered in exact detail—because the students are working with a live kid, and it is imperative that they know what they are doing—I try to relate the specifics to larger issues, through readings, class discussions, and reflective journals. But there is never enough time to do this adequately. Finally, as a policy issue, it strikes me as odd that the federal government has lost faith in the power of college students to serve as volunteer tutors and that few people have commented on that. In the debates over the America Reads legislation in 1997, conservatives in Congress wanted for-profit companies rather than volunteering college students to offer supplemental teaching to children who needed it. Their wish was eventually written into the No Child Left Behind legislation that became law in 2002.26 Many of the consequences of this law are only now being felt, as schools that are deemed to be failing are facing federally mandated sanctions. Parents of children in those schools are entitled to ask for their child to be moved to a better-performing one, or else to receive supplemental educational services—that is, tutoring. It is still early to tell how successful the tutoring efforts will be. But two observations can be made. First, a great many of these service providers are commercial companies, along with faith-based groups, Boys and Girls Clubs, and a few non-failing schools. But very few are programs staffed by volunteer college students.27 The second is that not many parents are availing themselves of these services. A report on supplemental educational services recently released by the Rand Corporation showed that even for children who were performing well below grade level and were eligible for services by virtue of attending under-achieving schools, only one family in eight requested the services. (This low rate of participation should not completely surprise anyone who has read the National Adult Literacy Survey.) It is tempting to compare those figures with the anecdotal estimates from our America Reads project: virtually all of the students in the first three grades in our town who need a tutor get one—and they get it because the child’s teacher asks for it.
America Reads as Service-Learning
103
FLOWERS Is it a sign of success or failure that each of our six program partners have all requested additional tutors? We worry that we fall short in our commitment to each tutor and child because the ideal of the America Reads Challenge can’t get beyond the reality of a “body [operating] without a head,” and the on-campus training cannot make up for the lack of on-site supervision. We worry that we have not done all we could, because budget limitations entitle each school to receive only twelve tutors even though there exists far more interest on behalf of the college students. On the positive side, it’s a sign of success because the tutors gain an understanding of the problems facing elementary school students and get a “sneak peak” into how and why literacy education is of utmost importance to a child’s success. Possibly, it’s a sign of our success that tutors strive to make legitimate progress with the children and take steps toward the “engaged citizenship” that we hope will have a lasting impression long after graduation as alumnae become parents, PTA members, and policymakers. Ultimately, we have experienced some of both, and we continue to move forward with a new group of tutors each semester, new modifications to the program, and creative solutions to problems as they arise.
NOTES 1. Perhaps the best contemporary sign of an abandoned priority is an archived website. That is what rewards a search for “America Reads” on www.ed.gov, at the U.S. Department of Education. 2. Colleges and universities were authorized to use part of the federal work-study dollars to pay students for work “in the public interest” from the time federal workstudy funding was introduced in 1964. Starting in 1992, schools were required to use “at least 5 percent of the total amount of funds granted to such institution under this section in any fiscal year to compensate students employed in community service.” The requirement was raised to 7 percent in FY 2000, under a law signed by President Clinton in 1998. (See Campus Compact, www.compact.org/policy/ fws_history.) 3. Craig A. Rimmerman, The New Citizenship: Unconventional Politics, Activism, and Service, 3rd ed. (Boulder, CO: Westview Press, 2005). 4. There was much talk about literacy in Congress, though. President Clinton had proposed the America Reads program during his second election campaign in 1996, and when Congress resisted he took steps to launch as much of the idea as he could through administrative rules changes. Students earning federal work-study funds could continue to be paid for serving as tutors of reading, and they were encouraged to. The Clinton administration asked Congress for money to pay more collegebased tutors, and also funds to hire qualified teachers in the schools to supervise
104
Kathleen Flowers and Charles Temple
their work. They asked to channel money to AmeriCorps for volunteers who could coordinate tutoring projects. Republicans in Congress were willing to go along with providing tutors, but they were skeptical about having tutoring done by student volunteers. They preferred to have commercial tutoring companies provide the help. They did not endorse hiring teachers in the schools to supervise the work of the tutors. In the end, the idea of college students working as tutors carried the day, but funds for the teachers to supervise them were not approved, and neither was the funding for coordinators that was to have been provided through AmeriCorps. See Riddle, 1998. 5. See Rimmerman, The New Citizenship. 6. Darrell Morris made this point to me repeatedly when I worked with him at Appalachian State University for a semester during a sabbatical leave in 1993. I had gone down to learn more about his Howard Street model, which is the oldest and best-documented program in the country that sends volunteer tutors out to help atrisk children learn to read. See his book, Darrell Morris, Howard Street Tutoring Manual: Teaching At-Risk Readers in the Primary Grades, 2nd ed. (New York: Guilford Press, 2005). See also a review of the program in Morris, Shaw, and Perney, 1990. Connie Juel later published a study on what works in volunteer tutoring programs. She found it helped if tutors “scaffolded” their students’ learning (that is, provided finely tuned help), and if they taught books with repetitive language on reading levels that carefully matched each child’s current ability. Her tutors were college athletes at a large university, though, many of whom read at low levels themselves. See Juel, 1996. 7. See Rimmerman, The New Citizenship. 8. George Farkas, “Teaching Low-Income Children to Read at Grade Level,” Contemporary Sociology 29 (2000): 53–62. 9. Farkas, “Teaching Low-Income Children to Read at Grade Level,” 53. 10. Farkas, “Teaching Low-Income Children to Read at Grade Level,” 59. 11. It is odd that Farkas advocates offering courses that are very narrow “methods” courses, especially since he evinces little faith in the people who normally teach such courses. For example, Farkas urges sociologists to show education professionals how to read their own research: [S]ociologists could make a major contribution to the achievement of low-income children. Within the sociology of science and the sociology of the professions, we might investigate and attempt to reduce the tendency of faculty and training staff in education and social work to ignore the excellent research on effective practices for low-income children (phonics reading instruction) while embracing ineffective practices (whole language reading instruction) (56).
Farkas practiced what he preached and set up an effective tutoring program using college students to teach low-income children (George Farkas, “Reading Oneto-One: An Intensive Program Serving a Great Many Students While Still Achieving Large Effects,” pp. 75–109 in Social Programs That Work, ed. Jonathan Crane [New York: Russell Sage, 1998]). Indeed, the program was one of the models considered by the Clinton administration in designing the America Reads Challenge. Unfortunately, after the Clinton years, all that remains of Farkas’s thinking in the Bush
America Reads as Service-Learning
105
administration is a single-minded faith in phonics instruction as a cure to the literacy problem The Bush administration abandoned the use of volunteer tutors, preferring to hire the job out to for-profit companies and faith-based groups. In fact, the difference between George W. Bush and George H. W. Bush on the use of volunteers is striking. The senior Bush started the “Thousand Points of Light” campaign and First Lady Barbara Bush started the Barbara Bush Foundation to encourage people to volunteer their efforts to help people learn to read. Younger Bush, in contrast, has created a windfall for Socratic Learning, Inc., an online tutoring service from Plano, Texas; Sylvan Learning Systems; Academic Advantage, from Los Angeles; Academic Achievement Tutoring Services, from Redford, Michigan; and others. 12. Charles Temple and James MaKinster, Intervening for Literacy: The Joy of Reading to Young Children (Boston: Pearson/A and B, 2005). 13. Susan Hunter and Richard Brisbin, “The Impact of Service Learning on Democratic and Civic Values,” Political Science and Politics (September 2000). 14. Hunter and Brisbin, “The Impact of Service Learning,” 626. 15. National Center for Educational Statistics, National Assessment of Educational Progress (Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Education, 1994). 16. National Center for Educational Statistics, National Adult Literacy Survey (Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Education, 1992). 17. Betty Hart and Todd Risley, Meaningful Differences in the Everyday Experiences of American Children (New York: Paul Brooks, 1995). 18. Temple and Makinster, Intervening for Literacy, 2005. 19. Connie Juel, “Learning to Read: A Longitudinal Study of Fifty-four Children from First through Fourth Grade,” Journal of Educational Psychology 80 (1988): 437–47. 20. Keith Stanovich, “Matthew Effects in Reading: Some Consequences of Individual Differences in the Acquisition of Literacy,” Reading Research Quarterly 21 (1986): 360–406. 21. “For unto every one that hath shall be given, and he shall have abundance: but from him that hath not shall be taken away even that which he hath.” 22. Diane DeFord, Cynthia Lyons, and Gay Su Pinnell, Bridges to Literacy: Learning from Reading Recovery (Portsmouth, NH: Heinemann, 1991). 23. Marie M. Clay, Reading Recovery: A Guidebook for Teachers in Training (Portsmouth, NH: Heinemann, 1993). 24. R. Darrell Morris, Beverly Shaw, and Jan Perney, “Helping Low Readers in Grades 2 and 3: An After-School Volunteer Tutoring Program,” The Elementary School Journal 91, no. 2 (Nov. 1990): 132–50. Barbara A. Wasik, “Volunteer Tutoring Programs in Reading: A Review,” Reading Research Quarterly 33, no. 3 (1998): 266–91. 25. Jill Fitzgerald, “Can Minimally Trained College Student Volunteers Help Young At-Risk Children to Read Better?” Reading Research Quarterly 36 (2001): 28–46. 26. Says the Education Department web page: In conducting its approval process, the SEA [State Education Agency] must ensure that each provider [of supplemental education services, i.e., tutoring] it approves: 1. Has a demonstrated record of effectiveness in increasing student academic achievement [Section 1116(e)(12)(B)(i)];
106
Kathleen Flowers and Charles Temple 2. Will use instructional strategies that are high quality, based upon research, and designed to increase student academic achievement (see C-17 for additional information) [Section 1116(e)(12)(C)]; 3. Provides services that are consistent with the instructional program of the LEA and with State academic content and achievement standards (see C-18 for additional information) [Sections 11116(e)(5)(B) and 1116(e)(12)(B)(ii)]
Note that these requirements are substantially the same as those proposed by the Republican majority in Congress in 1997: Tutorial services would be provided in locations near pupils’ schools by entities that “have established a record of effectiveness” in providing reading (or reading readiness) instruction, based on “reliable, replicable research,” which is consistent with the instructional methods used at the pupil’s school. Recipient LEAs [local education agencies] would establish criteria for determining the eligibility of tutorial services providers, and maintain lists of entities in the local area that meet these eligibility requirements. Both LEAs and schools could assist parents of eligible children in selecting among the listed tutorial services providers for their child, but the final selection among eligible providers would rest with the parents. (U.S. Library of Congress, 1997)
27. See, for example, New York State’s list of approved supplemental educational service providers, at www.emsc.nysed.gov/nyc/SES/ApprovedProviders/AlphaList.html. See also the latter part of note