Self-Reference in the Media
≥
Approaches to Applied Semiotics 6
Mouton de Gruyter Berlin · New York
Self-Reference...
27 downloads
1685 Views
5MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Self-Reference in the Media
≥
Approaches to Applied Semiotics 6
Mouton de Gruyter Berlin · New York
Self-Reference in the Media
edited by Winfried Nöth Nina Bishara
Mouton de Gruyter Berlin · New York
Mouton de Gruyter (formerly Mouton, The Hague) is a Division of Walter de Gruyter GmbH & Co. KG, Berlin.
앝 Printed on acid-free paper which falls within the guidelines 앪 of the ANSI to ensure permanence and durability.
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Self-reference in the media / edited by Winfried Nöth, Nina Bishara. p. cm. ⫺ (Approaches to applied semiotics ; 6) Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 978-3-11-019464-7 (hardcover : alk. paper) 1. Mass media ⫺ Semiotics. 2. Reference (Linguistics) 3. Metalanguage. I. Nöth, Winfried. II. Bishara, Nina, 1977⫺ P96.S43S45 2007 302.230114⫺dc22 2007033759
ISBN 978-3-11-019464-7 ISSN 1612-6769 Bibliographic information published by the Deutsche Nationalbibliothek The Deutsche Nationalbibliothek lists this publication in the Deutsche Nationalbibliografie; detailed bibliographic data are available in the Internet at http://dnb.d-nb.de. © Copyright 2007 by Walter de Gruyter GmbH & Co. KG, D-10785 Berlin All rights reserved, including those of translation into foreign languages. No part of this book may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopy, recording, or any information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publisher. Cover design: Christopher Schneider, Berlin. Printed in Germany.
Introduction Winfried N¨oth and Nina Bishara
Communication, the conveyance of messages, is the purpose of the media according to the self-professed ethics of the mass communicators. Messages and their communication imply otherness: they are about something other than messages and communication, something in some other place and time, addressed to others by a self. Nevertheless, despite their dimensions of otherness, messages, communication, and the media have always been about themselves, too – self-referential messages about messages, communication about communication, media about the media. Street criers who once called out their public announcements did not only attract the audience’s attention to their messages but also captured their imagination by means of their voices, rhetoric, gestures, and appearance. The newspaper in its competition with other media does not only inform its readers about the world of otherness, it also informs how and why it informs so well. The movies do not only bring ever new stories about heroes and heroines, they also raise an enormous interest and curiosity in the private lives of those who convey the messages about these heroes and heroines, i.e., the movie actors and actresses. The topics of the present volume are the ways in which the media have become self-referential or self-reflexive (as some researchers prefer to call it) and the degree to which they have ceased to mediate between the real or fictional worlds about which their messages pretend to be and their audience which they pretend to inform, to counsel, or to entertain. The self-referential networks in which the media and their audiences are caught up – indeed, by which we are all so significantly shaped – will be investigated in the following chapters. The papers are presented in seven sections. Part I on Theoretical Frameworks introduces two theoretical approaches to reference and self-reference inspired by the semiotics of Charles S. Peirce. In his keynote paper on “Self-reference in the media: The semiotic framework”, Winfried N¨oth contextualizes the general topic in its cultural background in postmodernity, gives a survey of its transdisciplinary implications, and draws the outlines of a systematic framework for the study of self-reference in the media as a matter of levels and degrees. Vincent Colapietro, dealing with “Distortion, fabrication, and disclosure in a self-referential
vi
Winfried N¨oth and Nina Bishara
culture: The irresistible force of reality”, investigates the concepts of reality, reference, and self-reference against the background of Peirce’s realism and shows how media such as television, radio, and the world wide web constitute intricate and arguably insular networks of self-citation and self-commentary. Part II, Self-Referential Print Advertising, studies self-reference in the pictorial and verbal messages of advertisements of the print media. Siegfried J. Schmidt introduces a systems theoretical perspective in his analysis of reflexive loops in advertisements in their relations to other social systems, and he proposes a typology of “Modes of self-reference in advertising”. On the basis of a distinction between “Metapictures and self-referential pictures”, Winfried N¨oth shows how pictures in advertisements have become pictures about pictures, and Nina Bishara, in “‘Absolut Anonymous’: Self-reference in opaque advertising”, argues how and why opaque elements in advertisements, which make their comprehension more difficult, evince a mode of self-reference in the media. Part III, on Self-Referential Photography, begins with Winfried N¨oth’s paper with the metaphorical title “The death of photography in self-reference”, in which the author examines the so-called loss of the referent in digital photography, especially in art photography. Kay Kirchmann follows with the essay “Marilyn: A paragone of the camera gaze”, which studies Marilyn Monroe’s modes of self-observation and self-presentation in photos for the media as presented in the 1999 ARTE series Les cent photos du si`ecle / One Hundred Photographs of the Century. Part IV on Self-Referential Films is about the movies in the movies, filmic allusions to other films, quotations from films in films, and nostalgia created by filmic self-reference. Gloria Withalm presents reflections on “The self-reflexive screen” and draws the “Outlines of a comprehensive model” for the study of many forms of self-reflexivity and self-reference in the movies on the basis of Rossi-Landi’s socio-semiotics. Andreas B¨ohn’s paper, “Nostalgia of the media / in the media”, discusses nostalgia, memory, remembrance, and oblivion as forms of filmic self-reference, and Jan Siebert, in his article on “Self-reference in animated films”, presents examples from the cartoons offering insights into self-referential scenes and devices that testify to the close connection between humor, paradox, and self-reference. Self-Referential Television is the topic area of Part V. In “On the use of selfdisclosure as a mode of audiovisual reflexivity”, Fernando Andacht presents two studies, one of the television show Big Brother Brasil and the other of a documentary film by E. Coutinho, demonstrating the illusionary paradox that self-reflexivity is a means of the media to give additional evidence of the “real” reality in the presentations of these programs. In “The old in the new: Forms and
Introduction
vii
functions of archive material in the presentation of television history on television”, Joan Bleicher shows how the visual language of television has become self-referential in its more and more frequent presentations of archive material recalling the history of television itself thus creating a collective memory of the medium. From the point of view of media economics, Karin P¨uhringer and Gabriele Siegert, in “There’s no business without show-business: Self-reference as self-promotion”, give statistical evidence of how self-promotion has become one of the most important forms of self-reference in the mass media. Computer games are the topic of Part VI, entitled Self-Referential Games. “Computer games [are] the epitome of self-reference” is Lucia Santaella’s argument in her paper putting forward a typology of seven types of self-reference in games. Bo Kampmann Walther proposes “A formalistic approach” to the study of self-reference in computer games, defining rules, strategies, and interaction patterns as their core elements and examining how and to what extent computer games can be defined as complex dynamic systems. Britta Neitzel, in her paper on “Metacommunication in play and in (computer) games”, shows that Gregory Bateson’s theory of play is fundamental to the study of games, and Bernhard Rapp, in “Self-reflexivity in computer games: Analyses of selected examples” concludes the section with exemplary analyses and proposals for future research on the topic. Part VII presents three papers on Other Self-Referential Arts in such diverse fields as web art, body art, and music. Marie-Laure Ryan contextualizes selfreflexivity in the history of literature since Don Quixote and gives evidence of the predominance of self-reflexivity in digital art on the Internet in her paper “Looking through the computer screen: Self-reflexivity in net.art”. Christina Ljungberg, in “The artist and her bodily self: Self-reference in digital art/media”, constructs a typology of degrees and forms of self-reference in digital art exemplified by multi-media works of visual artist and performer Laurie Anderson, video/digital artist Selina Trepp, and media artist Char Davies. Werner Wolf concludes the volume with his paper entitled “Metafiction and metamusic: Exploring the limits of metareference”. Based on a definition of meta-reference in contrast to self-reference and self-reflexivity in the narrower sense, Wolf presents new typological tools for the comparative study of meta-music and offers original proposals for a comprehensive program of future research on the topic. The volume is one of the main results of a research project on self-reference in the media with special focus on advertising, the movies, and computer games, carried out at the Interdisciplinary Center for Cultural Studies of the University of Kassel from 2003 to 2006. Supported by a grant from the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG), the project was directed by Winfried N¨oth,
viii
Winfried N¨oth and Nina Bishara
whose collaborators were Nina Bishara (Kassel), Britta Neitzel (now Siegen), and Karin Wenz (now Maastricht). With few exceptions, the papers presented here were contributions to the international conference Self-Reference in the Media organized in the framework of the aforementioned DFG project by Winfried N¨oth, Britta Neitzel, and Nina Bishara at the University of Kassel in July 2005. Thanks are due to the DFG for their substantial support and encouragement of this volume as well as to the University of Kassel for unbureaucratically providing the necessary infrastructure. Especially worth mentioning is the DFG supported collaboration of the research project Self-Reference in the Media with the Postgraduate Program in Semiotics and Communication Studies of the Catholic University of S˜ao Paulo, whose immediate results presented in this volume are the contributions by Lucia Santaella, Vincent Colapietro, and Fernando Andacht. Thanks are also due to Dr. Renira Gambarato for improving several diagrams and to Diena Janakat for editorial assistance.
Contents
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Winfried N¨oth and Nina Bishara
v
Part I: Self-referential media: Theoretical frameworks Self-reference in the media: The semiotic framework . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Winfried N¨oth
3
Distortion, fabrication, and disclosure in a self-referential culture: The irresistible force of reality . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Vincent Colapietro
31
Part II: Self-referential print advertising Modes of self-reference in advertising . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Siegfried J. Schmidt
47
Metapictures and self-referential pictures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Winfried N¨oth
61
“Absolut Anonymous”: Self-reference in opaque advertising . . . . . . . . . . Nina Bishara
79
Part III: Self-referential photography The death of photography in self-reference . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Winfried N¨oth
95
Marilyn: A paragone of the camera gaze . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 107 Kay Kirchmann
x
Contents
Part IV: Self-referential film The self-reflexive screen: Outlines of a comprehensive model . . . . . . . . . 125 Gloria Withalm Nostalgia of the media / in the media . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 143 Andreas B¨ohn Self-reference in animated films . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 155 Jan Siebert Part V: Self-referential television On the use of self-disclosure as a mode of audiovisual reflexivity . . . . . . 165 Fernando Andacht The old in the new: Forms and functions of archive material in the presentation of television history on television . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 183 Joan K. Bleicher There’s no business without show-business: Self-reference as self-promotion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 195 Karin P¨uhringer and Gabriele Siegert Part VI: Self-referential games Computer games: The epitome of self-reference . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 207 Lucia Santaella Self-reference in computer games: A formalistic approach . . . . . . . . . . . . 219 Bo Kampmann Walther Metacommunication in play and in (computer) games . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 237 Britta Neitzel Self-reflexivity in computer games: Analyses of selected examples . . . . . 253 Bernhard Rapp Part VII: Other self-referential arts Looking through the computer screen: Self-reflexivity in net.art . . . . . . . 269 Marie-Laure Ryan
Contents
xi
The artist and her bodily self: Self-reference in digital art/media . . . . . . . 291 Christina Ljungberg Metafiction and metamusic: Exploring the limits of metareference . . . . . 303 Werner Wolf Index of names . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 325 Index of subjects . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 331
Part I. Self-referential media: Theoretical frameworks
Self-reference in the media: The semiotic framework Winfried N¨oth
1. Self-reference in postmodernity and in the media Self-reference is a much discussed characteristic of postmodernity (Lawson 1985; N¨oth 2001; Petersen 2003). In an era in which everything seems to have been said, the “grand narratives” have lost their credibility, and representations can no longer represent (Lyotard 1979: 27). To escape from this dilemma, literature, the visual and the audiovisual arts and media have become increasingly self-referential, self-reflexive, autotelic. Instead of representing something heard about, seen, lived, or otherwise experienced in social life, culture, and nature, journalists, commercial artists, designers, and film directors report increasingly what has been seen, heard, or reported before in the media. The mediators have turned to representing representations. Instead of narrating, they narrate how and why they narrate, instead of filming, they film that they film the filming. The news are more and more about what has been reported in the news, television shows are increasingly concerned with television shows, and even advertising is no longer about products and services but about advertising. The messages of the media are about messages of the media, whose origin has become difficult to trace. In literature, fiction has become metafiction, novels have become metanovels, and texts are being discovered as intertexts whose reference is not to life but to other texts. Last but not least, art is now about art, and even architecture is about architecture. The digitalization of pictures and films, which has liberated the media from the bonds of factual reference to a world which they used to depict, has contributed to the increase of self-reference. No longer originating in a world which leaves its documentary traces on the negatives of a film, the pictures of the new media have become the result of digital imaging and art work, whose origin is in the software of the semiotic machines (cf. N¨oth 2002) by means of which they are produced. One of the most striking symptoms of the current concern with self-reference in culture and in the media is probably the recent phenomenon of culture jamming (Klein 2000, chapt. 12), the critical transformation of media messages by
4
Winfried N¨oth
activists who display their protest against the age of consumerism, globalization, and social surveillance in public places and urban spaces in subversive forms such as adbusting, graffiti, flash mobs, hacktivism, cybersquatting, or sousveillance (cf. http://en.wikipedia.org, 16.05.06), not without creating the self-referential paradox that they depend on the media in their subversive attacks against the media.
2. Self-reference as a multidisciplinary topic of research The study of self-reference and related phenomena, such as self-similarity, selforganization, autopoiesis, replication, or recursion is a topic of interest to various fields of research. Bartlett (1987: 10–24) gives a comprehensive survey of relevant topics and studies in no less than twenty-one fields of research, from mythology to neurophysiology, among them the following ones not dealt with in detail below: linguistics (reflexivity), space and time (loops, circles, Moebius strip), law (self-referring and self-limiting laws, mutuality of contracts), economics (business cycles), game theory (rules permitting self-modification), anthropology (Sapir-Whorf hypothesis: culture determining language and hence culture), mythology (cosmic cycles), psychiatry (narcissism), psychotherapy (Bateson’s theories of play and double bind), neurophysiology (neuronal circuits), and general systems theory (see N¨oth 1977). The following survey of more recent research in self-reference excludes systems theoretical approaches to self-reference which have been reviewed elsewhere with particular reference to semiotics (N¨oth 2000b; Jahraus and Ort 2003). In the natural sciences, the theory of complex systems in physics and mathematics (chaos and fractals: Peitgen, J¨urgens, and Saupe 1992), chemistry (dissipitative structures: Prigogine and Stengers 1984), biology (self-reference, selfdescription, autopoiesis: Hoffmeyer 1996: 39–51), and even meteorology (butterfly effect) are bringing more and more evidence of the omnipresence of selfreference and related phenomena in nature: self-observation, self-description, self-organization, self-replication, self-similarity, autopoiesis, feedback loops, iteration, replication, recursion, or downward causation (Andersen et al. 2000) are the key concepts in this context. In computer science, the recursivity of Turing machines (Winkler 2004: 170– 182) and the theory of autonomous agents (Pattee 1995; N¨oth 2002) are relevant to the study of self-reference. The close affinity between recursion and selfreference, for example, is evident when we consider the mathematical definition of recursivity as a group “using the own group or function that it calls to the own function” (http://www.mind-graph.net/foundations/mathematical/ recursivity.htm, 16.05.06).
Self-reference in the media: The semiotic framework
5
Logic and the philosophy of language have given special attention to selfreference with respect to tautology, the petitio principii (taking for granted what should first be proved), other semantic circularities (Myers 1966), or selfreferential propositions that lead to antinomies and paradoxes. Much attention has been paid to forms of self-reference implied in metalanguage (Hofstadter 1979, 1985) and paradoxes (Whitehead and Russell 1910; Bartlett and Suber 1987; Fitch 1987; Bartlett 1992b; Scheutz 1995; Sch¨oppe 1995). Other philosophical aspects of self-reference are philosophical reflexivity (Nietzsche, Heidegger, Derrida: Lawson 1985), the phenomenology of the self and its identity (B¨uttner and Esser 2001), the problem of self-consciousness (Potthast 1971; Colapietro 1989; Kienzle and Pape 1991), also a topic of cognitive science (self-awareness: Brook and DeVidi 2001), and the topics of self-reflection, selfrepresentation, autosymbolism, or the autotelic function in aesthetics (Shir 1978; Luhmann 1984; Menninghaus 1987; N¨oth 2000a: 425, 432; Metscher 2003). Literary studies are one of the fields of research (besides aesthetics) in which the theory of self-reference has its longest tradition since the essence of literature has often been described in terms which imply self-reference. Key concepts in this context are aesthetic autosymbolism (Shir 1978), self-representation (Hempfer 1976: 70, 129; Jay 1984; Johansen 2002: 174–288), literary autonomy, autonymy, or the autotelic function of literature (cf. N¨oth 2000a: 458). While most of these theories have been developed against the background of poetry, often with reference to Jakobson’s definition of the poetic language as a selfreferential language (Jay 1984; Whiteside 1987; Block 1999; N¨oth 2000a: 453; Johansen 2002: 174–182), self-reference in prose and drama is a more recent topic. It has first been approached in the 1970s under the heading of metalanguage (Smuda 1970), later as metatext, especially metafiction (Waugh 1984; Siedenbiedel 2005), or metanovel (Zavala 2000). In the study of narratives, the topic has also been subsumed under the general heading of reflexivity (Stam 1992), self-reflexivity (Hempfer 1982; Scheffel 1997; Huber, Middecke, and Zapf 2005), or self-reference proper (Wolf 2001; Krah 2005a, 2005b). Comprehensive surveys on the topic can be found in Scheffel (1997) and Wolf (2001). Language about language, fiction about fiction, or the novel about the novel, these are evidently topics which deal with self-reference at a very general semiotic level. The theory of intertextuality (Broich and Pfister 1985) implies a similarly general mode of self-reference since it deals with the way a text refers to a text instead of to the adventures of its protagonists. Metafiction containing reflections about the text in which these reflections are narrated may be described as evincing a higher degree of self-reference than intertextuality. Intertextual references also evince references to texts, but these references are to other texts.
6
Winfried N¨oth
Like literature, music and the traditional visual arts have had self-reference inscribed in their canonical definitions since the classics of philosophical aesthetics. L’art-pour-l’art, autonomy and autoreflexivity have been key concepts in this tradition (cf. N¨oth 2000a: 434, 426–427). The new trend since postmodernity has been that artists have begun to reflect programmatically about art in their art works, so that art has become art about art (Lipman and Marshall 1978) and even architecture has become architecture about architecture (Wittig 1979). A conspicuous symptom of the increasing concern with self-reference in the visual arts is the current interest in representing and exhibiting the artist’s own bodily self in works of visual art (cf. Santaella 2004; N¨oth and Hertling 2005; N¨oth ed. 2006; Ljungberg, this vol.). Media studies have discussed the argument that self-reference is at the root of every medium. Each individual medium has a historical precursor to which it refers back in media history. The more the media interact today and turn intermedial, the more they refer to the media in self-referential loops. These were some of the reasons why McLuhan (1964) declared that the medium is the message. The famous tenet expresses among other things the view that each message in the media refers both to its own medium and to other media, and thus characterizes messages as partially self-referential. McLuhan (1964: 8) develops this argument on the basis of his very broad concept of medium as an extension of man, according to which even light is a medium: The electric light is pure information. It is a medium without a message, as it were, unless it is used to spell out some verbal ad or name. This fact, characteristic of all media, means that the “content” of any medium is always another medium. The content of writing is speech just as the written word is the content of print, and print is the content of the telegraph. If it is asked, “What is the content of speech?”, it is necessary to say, “It is an actual process of thought, which is in itself nonverbal”.
Notice that in this description of how the messages in the media circulate in a process of infinite semiosis which even includes thought as a content of a medium, the medium described as the most self-referential of all is light. A medium without a message which nevertheless conveys “pure information” can only be a medium that refers to nothing but to itself. All other media evince self-reference to the degree that they refer to other media, which implies a divided reference. To the degree that the media refers to the media, they are self-referential, to the degree that they refer to other media, it is (allo)referential (see below). Intermediality (M¨uller 1996; Paech 1998; Spielmann 1998; Helbig 2001; Rajewsky 2002), the media in the media (Liebrand and Schneider 2002), media change (Ort 2003), as well as remediation (Bolter and Grusin 1999), i.e., the
Self-reference in the media: The semiotic framework
7
refashioning of the traditional media in the digital media, are the topics of research in self-reference in the media related to McLuhan’s dictum in one or the other way. From various other perspectives, self-reference in the media has been approached in the contexts of film (Karpf, Kiesel, and Visarius 1996; Kirchmann 1996; Paech 1998; Buckland 2000: 53–76), television (Withalm 1995; Frieske 1998; Bleicher 1999), journalism (Marcus 1997; Bl¨obaum 1999; Kohring 1999; Weber 1999), and advertising (Schmidt and Spieß 1996). For further references, see the papers of this volume. Various aspects of self-reference concerning other domains of culture are discussed by Hofstadter (1979, 1985), who has shown that self-reference is at the root of cultural creativity (see also Sch¨oppe 1995), in particular of humor and paradox. Self-reference in popular culture from the comics to rock music and video-clips is the topic of the book on metapop by Dunne (1992). Among the topics of cultural semiotics with particular relevance to self-reference are the semiotics of mirrors (Eco 1984; Ort 2003) and the semiotics of fashion. It was Barthes (1967: 287) who described fashion as a “tautological system” which defines itself reflexively only through itself, a system of signs “deprived of content but not of sense, a kind of machine to operate sense without ever fixing it” with the only goal of making the “insignificant significant”, or, as Goebel (1986: 476) put it, a system that keeps conveying the same message for ever: fashion is hence “a language that consists of nothing but synonyms”. In the interpretation of the phenomenon of ever increasing self-reference in postmodern culture, we find the “apocalyptic” critics opposing the “integrated” ones. The former, among them Baudrillard (1976, 1981, 1991), deplore the loss of referents in a more and more self-referential world in which reality has degenerated to constructed, simulated or virtual reality. The latter interpret selfreference as a symptom of increasing critical consciousness in a world that has lost its confidence in ultimate truths (Lawson 1985). However, while the integrated ones may lack critical distance in face of the aporias of postmodern self-reference, the apocalyptic ones run the risk of finding themselves involved in paradoxes as long as they are unable to explain the nature of those referents whose loss they deplore (N¨oth 2001; N¨oth and Ljungberg 2003).
3. Self-reference and reference: Semiotic premises In the framework of the present research project on self-reference in the media (cf. N¨oth 2005b), the concept of self-reference has been adopted in the very broad sense similar to the outline proposed by Bartlett (1987: 6), whose point of departure is the following reflection on self-reference in human thought:
8
Winfried N¨oth When we employ thought to understand the nature of thinking, when we seek to know the presuppositions involved in knowing, we define a task that essentially involves the subjects we would study. Reflexivities of this kind are widespread: sociology, anthropology, biology, and many other disciplines, as we shall see, exhibit varieties of self-reference. Attempting to understand reflexivity gives one the sense of trying to lift oneself by the bootstraps.
Our own point of departure is a semiotic one: any sign that refers to itself or to aspects of itself is a self-referential sign. Signs that do not refer exclusively to themselves but only to parts, aspects, constituents, or elements of themselves are self-referential to a degree that remains to be specified (see below on levels and typology of s.-r.). Self-reference in the broad sense adopted here includes a number of concepts which are sometimes used as synonyms of this term as well as certain concepts which some authors, in the context of media and cultural studies, explicitly distinguish from self-reference. The most frequent synonym is reflexivity (Whitehead and Russell 1910; Lawson 1985). Typically enough, both concepts appear in title of the book by Bartlett and Suber (1987), which is Self-reference: Reflections on Reflexivity. Some other terminological alternatives are self-reflexivity (Huber, Middecke, and Zapf 2005), self -representation (Johansen 2002: 174–288), or autoreferentiality (Pavliˇci´c 1993). Some authors distinguish these alternative concepts from the one of selfreference. Connotations associated with such distinctions are the following: reflexivity and self-reflexivity connote reflections on the process of the author’s own writing or self-cognition and self-consciousness, for example, in the philosophical tradition of the Romantics (Menninghaus 1987), the tradition of phenomenology (Lawson 1985), or anthropology (Babcock 1980); selfrepresentation is often preferred in the context of aesthetics (Metscher 2003). In the context of literary semiotics, Johansen (2002: 174–288) avoids the concept of self-reference and uses the term self-representation instead (in opposition to other-representation). This terminological decision is understandable from the point of view of Peircean semiotics, since representation, and not reference is a key concept of Peirce’s theory of signs. Wolf (2001: 56) distinguishes between self-reference as a “noncognitive” and “self-reflection” as a cognitive process, using the former term to describe textual recurrences and repetitions and the latter term to designate reflection on the writer’s self (for details, see Wolf, this vol.). In Luhmann’s systems theory no such distinctions are drawn; the general term is always self-reference. Luhmann’s concept is very fundamental: it refers to the capacity and tendency of a living system to establish reference to itself in its interactions with the nonself, that is, its environment (cf. N¨oth 2000b).
Self-reference in the media: The semiotic framework
9
The study of self-reference requires an elucidation of its opposite, reference. By definition, reference, in contrast to self-reference, means referring to something else. When the term is used in opposition to self-reference, it is also called alloreference, heteroreference (Wolf 2001) or other-reference, which comes closest to Luhmann’s German term “Fremdreferenz”. What is reference and what does it mean to refer? Despite much controversy over the “inscrutability of reference” (cf. Geach 1970; Evans 1991; Katz 2004), Bartlett (1987: 5) takes the concept for granted, when he considers reference as a necessary constituent of human communication, stating that “without a wide range of abilities to refer, we would be bereft of thoughts, memories, and sensations” and that “the world as we perceive it, remember it, and conceptualize it would, in the absence of appropriate referring capacities, collapse into impossibility”. However, is reference really a necessary ingredient of human communication and a necessary term in semiotics? Ferdinand de Saussure is known to have banned reference from linguistic semantics for decades, Peirce hardly uses the term, and the linguist Roman Jakobson, defines the referential function of language as only one of six functions of verbal communication all of which differ from the concept of reference although they do not exclude the possibility of the message being referential to a certain degree either (see below on the semiotic paradox and degrees of s.-r.). In English, the concept of reference has been introduced in its current sense with Max Black’s translation of Gottlob Frege’s dichotomy of “Sinn” vs. “Bedeutung” as sense vs. reference (M¨unch 1992: 385; N¨oth 2000a: 152–54). In this tradition, reference is defined as the relation between a verbal expression and the observable things or qualities to which it refers; that to which it refers is called its referent, extension, or designatum. An expression that refers to a referent identifies it as an individual or a class of objects, actions, or events (Kempson 1977: 13). For example, the word king, at the turn of the millennium, refers to the present kings of Spain and Sweden and the past kings of these and many other countries. Sense or meaning, by contrast, consists of the ideas or concepts evoked in the mind of those who use or understand the word. The word “king” has the conceptual meaning “man who rules a country as a descendant of a royal family”. In this tradition of logical semantics, it is possible for a word to have meaning but no reference. In the year 2000, the expression “the present king of France” is meaningful and makes sense because we understand the ideas associated with its words, but the expression is without a referent because there is no individual in France to whom it might presently refer. Although there are even abstract objects, such as the object of imagination which refers to the class of all acts of imagination, some words have no reference, since they refer to nothing that has
10
Winfried N¨oth
extension, for example, and, or, what, whether, of, unicorn, or the first woman to land on the moon. The logical theory of reference as something in the external world to which the sign refers, or points to, has not remained undisputed. In the framework of Saussurean structuralism, linguists developed a semantic theory which ignored the theory of reference for decades (cf. N¨oth 2000a: 74–75). The semiotic structure of a verbal sign was sought in its meaning only, which was studied exclusively in its relation to other signs and not in relation to its referents. The same aversion against approaching the dimension of reference is characteristic of constructivism and systems theory. Niklas Luhmann, for example, justifies his exclusion of the referent from his theory of social and cultural systems as follows: There is indeed no reference for the sign as a form; which is to say: one can either make use of the distinction between signifier/signified or not. There is no “external” point of reference that would force one to select either option; neither is there any truth criterion for choosing a first distinction as a starting point. That is why a theory of language constructed as semiotics must relinquish the idea of language’s external referent. (Luhmann 1993: 24)
Nevertheless, despite this plea against the theory of reference, self-reference vs. alloreference is a fundamental dichotomy of his systems theory of communication, culture, the media, and the arts (cf. N¨oth 2000b). Both concepts have to do with observation. While alloreferential observing is directed towards phenomena in the environment of a system (or an observer), self-reference is directed towards the observing system, the observer, the process of observation, or the process of communication (Luhmann 1995: 15, 28). Furthermore, quite against basic tenets of both the Peircean and the Saussurean semiotics, Luhmann (1993: 24) even defines alloreference as external reference, when he states that “an operationally closed, language-using system [. . . ] must distinguish between self-reference and external reference”. However that may be, the concept of self-reference can apparently be used without assuming the Fregean view of reference. Among the constructivists, S. J. Schmidt adopts a similar position. On the on hand, he argues that signs are not anchored in “a sphere beyond discourse”, hence, are not anchored in referents; on the other hand, he nevertheless uses the term of reference, albeit in a different sense. Reference, according to Schmidt, is not a matter of semantics, but one of pragmatics; it concerns the process of communication and not the relation between the sign and its referent. Reference, in this perspective, “is a renvoi from communication to communication which permits connections and relays” (Schmidt 1994: 145), while self-reference is
Self-reference in the media: The semiotic framework
11
a matter of how communication refers to communication (and hence to itself). Schmidt even goes so far as to postulate that signs and communication, being essentially about signs and communication, are always self-referential “in the first place”. Still other premises of a theory of self-reference derive from Charles S. Peirce’s semiotics on which this outline of a program for research in selfreference in the media and several papers in this volume are based. Peirce would never have subscribed to Frege’s theory of reference, nor does the noun reference or the verb to refer belong to Peirce’s basic vocabulary (N¨oth 2006). Instead of the referent or extension, Peirce speaks of the object of the sign, and instead of saying that the sign refers to its object, Peirce says that the sign represents its object. The Peircean object, which a sign represents, does not necessarily have an extension, and it does not need to be a piece of the so-called real world at all, since signs or ideas can be the object of a sign. The object of the sign is something which precedes and thus determines the sign in the process of semiosis as a previous experience or cognition of the world (cf. N¨oth 2006). Such an object of the sign can be a sign itself, and this is where self-reference begins with signs representing signs. Reference in the narrower sense of referring or even pointing to something else is a semiotic characteristic of only one of Peirce’s major classes of sign, the indices. For example, the deictic words you, there, or then refer to a person, a place, or a moment which is distal in relation to the speaker and the place and time of speaking. Indexical signs identify and in this sense refer to objects and events in time and space in many other ways, for example by means of adverbial descriptions or nonverbal gestures of pointing. However, indexical signs can also evince self-reference, namely in the case of proximal deixis in words such as I, here, and now, which refer to the speaker and the circumstances of the utterance. Symbols, such as cat or speaker, by contrast, do not refer in this sense; they represent general concepts with which our experience of these objects is connected. Even less so can icons, such as the speaker’s picture, be said to refer to their objects. Pictures represent or show; they do not refer to their object. In sum, instead of self-reference, Peirce would use the term self-representation, but out of consideration for the wider acceptance of the term self-reference in media theory, this term will not be adopted here.
12
Winfried N¨oth
4. The semiotic paradox and degrees of self-reference in the media A sign, according to its medieval definition, is something that stands for something else: aliquid stat pro aliquo (cf. N¨oth 2000a, 2000b, 2006). If we disregard certain problems associated with the verb to stand for and admit a broader range of relational verbs as its interpretation, such as referring to, representing, or evoking the concept of, the formula is reduced to a dyad which is considered in all definitions of the sign. Whether dyadic or triadic, the basic assumption of the difference between the sign and something other than the sign to which it refers or which it represents is a distinction drawn in all definitions: the signifier is not the signified, the sign is neither its referent nor its object, just as the map is not its territory, as A. Korzybski (1933) put it. Self-reference thus creates a semiotic paradox: the sign does no longer refer to or represent something else; it is its own object, a map that is its own territory. It is true that signs also have other functions in addition to the one of reference. Roman Jakobson, e.g., distinguished no less than five other functions of language besides the one of reference in the narrower sense: the expressive, the conative (appellative), the metalingual, the phatic, and the poetic function (cf. N¨oth 2000a: 105–106). Some of them, for example the expressive, the poetic, and the metalingual function, indeed evince characteristics of self-reference since they are associated with messages about the sender of the message, or the message itself and its signs, but language without a potential of representing and referring to a world it represents and above all which is absent in time and place would fail its evolutionary, cultural, and social purpose. If it is the purpose of signs to represent or to refer to something else, this purpose should be no less characteristic of the signs in the media. After all, the concept of “media” implies mediation, and mediation is a process of semiosis, the action of signs. Medium is even a synonym of sign in the framework of Charles S. Peirce’s semiotics, and Peirce even considered substituting the concept of sign for the term medium, when, in 1906, he exclaimed: “All my notions are too narrow. Instead of ‘Sign’, ought I not to say Medium?” (MS 339: 526). The media must be able to inform about, narrate or evoke events, persons, places, and messages from elsewhere in time and space. Their potential to do so has turned the world into a global village. Global communication without reference is unthinkable. To fulfill their function, the signs of the media must evince the potential of reference or representation. Any message from the mass media is referential by necessity as far as its enunciation is concerned, since it is a message from elsewhere, the radio station for example, about an event which happened or originated at still another place in the world. Even the music that we hear is not without elements of reference to other times and other places;
Self-reference in the media: The semiotic framework
13
jazz refers to New Orleans, samba to Brazil, and Bach to 17th century Europe, but music is essentially self-referential, in particular the art of the fugue which is highly recursive and in this respect self-referential (Hofstadter 1979). Reference and self-reference are thus evidently a matter of degree. Various degrees of self-reference can be distinguished, from the sign that refers to nothing but itself to the sign that refers only partially to itself and partially still to something else. No message in the media is completely devoid of self-reference. Even in everyday verbal communication, the speaker indicates himself or herself as a speaker, whether intentionally or unintentionally. A message in the NewYork Times refers self-referentially to the profile and status of this newspaper, and each television picture that shows the station logo in its upper left or right hand corner refers self-referentially to the station itself, but at the same time it is an alloreferential message which serves to draw a distinction to all other stations. A statement of the President of the USA about the Iraq is highly referential, since it concerns events in very remote places, but it is also self-referential insofar as it is a message referring to Bush, his own and the US politics as well as to his own language, the English language in which he transmits the statement. The media differ as to the degree to which their messages are typically selfreferential or (allo)referential. Consider advertising, film, and computer games. Advertising is referential at its roots, since it has the purpose of promoting and selling products or services. For this reason, genuine self-reference would be counterproductive; a genuinely self-referential message would be unable to fulfill its commercial purpose of propagating a message about goods and services. Nevertheless, advertisements make use of the creative devices of selfreference to draw the consumers’ attention towards the message. Feature films, by contrast, which have both fictional and aesthetic qualities, are referential and self-referential at the same time. While their narrative plot is referential or indexical (Bettetini 1971) insofar as it narrates events from the lives of its protagonists, their aesthetic devices are based on self-reference, and if Lyotard (1979: 27) was right when he proclaimed the end of the grand narratives, it is only natural that self-reference in films must have increased. In computer games we are finally faced with a medium in which alloreference has been secondary since its beginning, since playing and games create their own self-referential worlds apart from the world of referential facts and realities.
14
Winfried N¨oth
5. Levels and typology of self-reference in the media Self-reference occurs at different levels of the media and the message in which it occurs. The degree of self-reference is related to the level in the hierarchy from the level of elementary signs to the one of complex signs and from the level of a text or message to the level of the media system as a whole. For example, a newspaper article (level: text) that criticizes the media in general (to which it belongs itself) is less self-referential than a newspaper article that criticizes only the newspapers and not the other media; and an author’s selfreferential comments on his or her own story are more (directly) self-referential than reflections of an author on the principles of narrating in general since these refer only partially to the story in which it is included. A distinction between different levels of self-reference is implicit in some proposals that have been suggested for a typology of forms of self-reference. Among other varieties of self-reference, Bartlett (1987, 1992a), for example, distinguishes between self-reference at the level of indexical words, paradoxical and tautological sentences, and pragmatic or performative self-reference in statements in which the speaker’s intentions are self-referentially involved. Scheutz (1995: 24) proposes a typology beginning with self-referential symbols, having self-referential sentences as its second, and self-referential theories as its third level. The levels of self-reference in the media distinguished in the following are equally inspired by the ambition of establishing a hierarchy from the most elementary to the highest level of self-reference in the media. The first three levels are derived from Peirce’s trichotomy of the interpretant, which draws the distinction between the rheme, the dicent, and the argument (cf. N¨oth 2000a: 65–67). A rhematic sign or rheme is a verbal or pictorial sign at a level equivalent to the one of the word or concept in language. The above-mentioned self-referential symbols and indexical words are types of rhematic self-reference. A dicentic sign corresponds to the level of sentences or statements in language. Paradoxical and tautological sentences belong to this level of self-reference. An argument presupposes a sequence of sentences in which a conclusion is derived from premises. The logical fallacy of the petitio principii (the taking for granted what should first be proved) and similar argumentative circularities evince argumentative self-reference. In extension of these levels derived from the three Peircean categories of the interpretant, forms of self-reference at the following higher levels will be distinguished: intratextual, intertextual, and intermedial self-reference and enunciative self-reference. While (intra)textual self-reference concerns the level of an individual text, a single advertisement, film, or computer game, for example,
Self-reference in the media: The semiotic framework
15
intertextual self-reference concerns references from one text to other texts of the same genre or medium, e.g., from one to another advertisement or film or game, respectively. The term “intermedial” will be used to refer to the relation between different media or genre, for example painting and film, film and games, or advertising and cinema. In addition to these forms of self-reference distinguished according to the hierarchical order of signs in the media, three other forms of self-reference will be distinguished according to criteria which overlap or combine with the above hierarchical typology: enunciative, iconic, and indexical self-reference (cf. N¨oth 2007). Enunciative self-reference involves the communicative situation and describes reference of the speaker, writer, composer, or producer of the sign but also the role of the audience or spectators. Iconic and indexical self-reference involves self-referential icons and indices. Self-reference that is not specific of the media, such as the elementary self-referentiality of communication (we communicate that we communicate), will not be considered in this context.
5.1.
Rhematic self-reference: Examples from advertising
“Maybe, just maybe” was the advertising slogan of the British national lottery of 1998 (Knowles 2004: 4) which illustrates well rhematic self-reference. The slogan is a verbal rheme, a sign that affirms nothing but expresses a mere potentiality, and the slogan is self-referential in its repetition to the same extent that any repeated form refers back to itself in an iconically self-referential way. Rhematic self-reference is a popular strategy in advertising. One of its most frequent forms is the advertisement that attracts the consumers’ attention to nothing but the brand name without saying anything about the product.A parallel strategy is the mere showing of the product in the form of a picture. In both cases, the message consists of a rhematic sign. Unlike a dicent, a rheme affirms nothing. Without a predication, a praise of its qualities, for example, an advertisement of his kind merely shows, and thus remains open to many interpretations. Like a word without context, e.g., “beer”, the rheme refrains from designating anything in specific. Its meaning is a mere possibility, and its context in time and space is undetermined. In advertising, the meaning of the rhematic message about a product is left to the consumers’ imagination, but their prior knowledge about the product is important. A new product cannot be introduced with rhematic advertisements. The prototype of a rhematic advertising campaign is the classical Coca-Cola sign at a countryside highway. It shows nothing but the Coca-Cola bottle with the name of the soft-drink as its label. “Coke, nothing but Coke” or “Coke
16
Winfried N¨oth
forever” seems to be an implicit quasi-tautological message. Since it remains unsaid whether the drink is good, desirable, or unique it seems to be assumed that the consumer knows its qualities well enough. The tacit assumption is that it would be a tautology to repeat what everybody knows anyhow. However, not to repeat it makes the message equally redundant, for if it need not be said what else is the purpose of the advertisement? This is the circularity which constitutes the basic self-referentiality of these advertisements. Rhematic signs of a product that conveys no other message than the one of its name or picture have some affinity with signboards, for example, the pictorial sign of a shoe indicating a shoemaker’s shop. However, the difference between signboards and rhematic advertisements is semiotically important. The shoemaker’s shop sign is also a rheme since it corresponds to a mere word, but in contrast to the Coca-Cola sign, the shoemaker’s shop sign refers indexically to a specific place. It is a rhematic index, which conveys the alloreferential message: “Here is a shoemaker.” Rhematic advertisements which merely show the product, by contrast, indicate nothing. Without any reference to a specific object, they are rhematic icons, signs which evince qualities of their objects without any indication of it. Insofar as it shares the qualities of its object and insofar as it is tautological in its reference to the well-known and hence presupposed qualities of the product, the rhematically iconic advertisement is a self-referential sign. Self-reference of this kind is frequent in current print advertising for fashion labels which reduce their message to a mere showing of the clothes for sale with the inscription of the designer logo (e.g., Joop, Boss, Gucci, etc.; cf. Bishara, forthcoming). Without any further comment, the message suggests that neither the name nor the product need any comment since they speak for themselves. On its surface, it is an open and hence rhematic message, but in a certain way, advertisements are never open; their message always presupposes or takes for granted that quality and desirability are characteristics of the product. On this assumption, the rhematic sign disguises a dicentic message affirming that there is only one product that deserves consideration which is the best, the most desirable, and the one that must be bought.
5.2.
Dicentic self-reference in advertising
Dicentic self-reference can be illustrated with the famous German tautological advertising slogan for Persil washing powder “Persil bleibt Persil” [‘Persil remains Persil’]. Explicit tautologies, such as the one of this slogan, or quasitautologies are statements and hence dicentic signs. At first sight, the claim has the form of a predication. However, instead of a predicative and thus alloref-
Self-reference in the media: The semiotic framework
17
erential statement of the form “A is B”, we are confronted with a tautological and consequently self-referential statement of the type “A is A”. The rhetoric of tautology serves to remind of a quality that no longer needs to be stated. The advertising slogan simply presupposes the knowledge of the quality inherent to the product. In a more recent BMW campaign, the tautology is even a twofold one: “A BMW is a BMW is a BMW. . . ” Other popular kinds of dicentic circularities are created by means of elliptical constructions. A slogan for the detergent Domestos bleach of 1959 claims: “Kills all germs” (Knowles 2004: 4). To understand this message, the reader is obliged to fill the gap left by the ellipsis of the subject “Domestos” from the packaging of the product and to substitute the missing proper noun from the product which it designates. The product in its package utters, so to speak, the self-referential message: “I kill all germs.” Still another rather frequent kind of self-referential circularity caused by elliptical constructions at the level of the dicent has the form of an open predicate whose scope includes the argument from which it should differ. The slogan “Persil washes whiter” is an example (Persil washing powder, GB, 2006). The enigma is: “whiter than what?” The comparative clause left out at the end of this slogan seems to be “than everything”, and this interpretation does not exclude the paradoxically self-referential reading “Persil washes whiter than Persil”.
5.3. Argumentative self-reference in advertising Self-referential arguments in advertising occur in many forms of circular reasoning. Most of them are elliptical and oblige the consumer to substitute the missing links in the chain of arguments. In 2006, Unilever of Great Britain launched a new advertising campaign under the name “Dirt is good” (http:// www.unilever.co.uk/ourbrands/advertising/persil/persil dig.asp, 16.05.06). The paradoxical slogan “Persil – Dirt is good” can only be understood as an elliptical argument or more precisely pseudo-argument, whose pseudo-syllogistic line of reasoning must be: Premise 1: Dirt is bad. Premise 2: Good Persil removes bad dirt. Conclusion: Bad dirt removed by good Persil: how good! Implicitly circular or quasi-circular arguments are quite frequent in advertising. The quality of a product stated at the end of the elliptical argument is already presupposed from its beginning. Such a rhetorical device suffers from the fallacy of the petitio principii. “Winston tastes good like a cigarette should” was a famous advertising slogan of the 1960s with a semi-circular way of arguing (cf. http://www.anagramgenius.com/archive/winsto4.html, 16.05.06). The reason for the alleged quality of this cigarette is already only implied in its mere
18
Winfried N¨oth
being a cigarette. The conclusion only confirms what the general premise presupposes: all cigarettes (should) taste good, and therefore this cigarette tastes good, too. – “The world has changed. The dictionary also”, was the slogan with which Hachette launched a new dictionary. The two propositions of this slogan sound like the major and the minor premise of a syllogism (“All S is P” and “Some S is P”) calling for the conclusion that the new dictionary incorporates al recent changes of the world of which it is a part. The second premise with its syntactic and semantic parallelism to the first creates an iconically self-referential circular argument: the dictionary must be good since it reflects the changes of the changing world of which it is a part. Of course, the conclusion is not valid since the dictionary could have changed from good to bad, or it could not have changed at all. Furthermore, there is another circularity in the argument, since a dictionary, being a part of the world that has changed, must change in a trivial sense by necessity with every new edition.
5.4.
(Intra)textual self-reference: Cinema and advertising
There are two major sources of (intra)textual self-reference, poetic features and metatextual passages of a text about the text. As Jakobson has argued, poetic features draw the readers’ attention towards the text as a text by means of recurrence, symmetry, rhyme, loops, or stylistic and rhetorical devices. The former devices evince iconic self-reference since they are based on similarities and forms of sameness, the latter testify to indexical self-reference, insofar as style is indicative of an author, epoch, or otherness in general (cf. N¨oth 2005a). Selfreference is particularly conspicuous in filmic loops (Manovich 1999: 187–191) in general and in the film Run Lola Run (Tom Tykwer, D, 1998; http://www.lolarennt.de, 16.05.06), a film that is self-referential already in its English title and which returns to its beginning and anticipates its end several times. Examples of metatextual self-reference are comments on the text, its narrative form, its content and its structure, its plot, previous or subsequent chapters, its beginning and its end. In the movies, textual self-reference occurs when the film begins and ends with a trailer marking its beginning by presenting its title and its end by concluding with the message THE END in writing. In advertising, the line Advertisement above the text refers to the text as a particular type of text (and not one that belongs to the news reports, for example).Textual self-reference of this kind in advertising runs the risk of being in conflict with the goals of the genre. The metamessage “This it is an advertisement” reminds the readers that the message is one-sided and pursues the goal of influencing the public for the sole purpose of buying the product. Instead of saying (alloreferentially) “Prod-
Self-reference in the media: The semiotic framework
19
uct X is good”, the advertisement says: “This message is an advertisement for product X”. Advertisements tend to avoid this kind of self-reference since the credibility of commercials is generally low, and the admission that the message is “only” publicity puts the efficiency of the message at risk.
5.5.
Intertextual and intermedial self-reference
Quotations, allusions, adaptations, influences, borrowings from texts, films, or any other medium are the sources of intertextual self-reference. When several media are involved, such as painting in the cinema, films in games, or novels in the film, there is intermedial self-reference. In a way, borrowings from other texts or media are certainly alloreferential, since there is reference from one message to another so that the object of the quoting sign is a quoted sign from which it differs. On the other hand, a film A that quotes a film B makes intertextual reference to its own medium and not to the world which both films represent, and the TV spot that quotes another TV spot remains within the world of advertising. These messages are intertextually self-referential to the degree that its quotations remain within their own world beyond films. Furthermore, every quotation presupposes repetition and sameness which is the source of iconic self-reference. There are several kinds of loops and circularities in intertextual and intermedial self-reference which have been studied elsewhere. One of them is the intermedial d´ej`a-vu effect which has often been exemplified with certain side effects created by the news reports on September 11. In one of his “Essays on ˇ zek (2002: 17) writes: “The question we September 11 and related dates”, Ziˇ should have asked ourselves as we started the TV screens on September 11 is simply: Where have we already seen the same thing over and again?” In our ˇ zek is of relevance. context, only the aspect of self-reference addressed by Ziˇ ˇ zek reminds us of is that the TV pictures of the collapsing World Trade What Ziˇ Center on September 11 did not only arouse shock, horror, and despair but it also created some feeling of d´ej`a-vu. In a way, the film reports of the September 11 catastrophe in the news media only seemed to repeat the scenarios which the genre of disaster movies had displayed for decades. The TV pictures seemed to lack absolute novelty because the viewers had been all too familiar with similar pictures of catastrophes, wars, destruction, and invasions by enemies and aliens, some of them even in New York City. As Tim Dirks’s (2006) list of the “Greatest disaster film scenes” demonstrates, the world’s highest glass tower building had been aflame before (although in a fictional version in which the towers were located in San Francisco), namely in the movie The Towering Inferno of 1974,
20
Winfried N¨oth
and there are dozens of catastrophe film scenarios resembling the September 11 events with plane crashes, terrorists of many kinds, out for control fires, nuclear annihilations, and even end of the world scenarios. On September 11, the media had been ahead of the event; reality seemed to lag behind. In short, the d´ej`a-vu effect on the screen accounts for a particular form of self-reference in the media, which consists in the repetition of the same scenario, whether fictional of nonfictional.
5.6.
Enunciative self-reference: Examples from the movies
Enunciation has been a key concept in film semiotics since Christian Metz (Buckland 2000; Buckland 1995). It pertains to the communicative situation of a message, the way the addresser interacts with the addressee of a message. In verbal communication, the study of enunciation is concerned with the many voices of the speaker, especially the narrator, their intentions and modes of manipulating the addressee (Santaella and N¨oth 2004: 113–126). Enunciative (or communicative) self-reference occurs when the author, the narrator, the actor, the reader, or the spectator become the topic of the message. Instead of presenting or representing ideas or events in the world from elsewhere, the text deals with its own communicative context, its function, the presuppositions of its narration, and the text has thus its own communicative situation as its topic. Alfred Hitchcock, for example, leaves his place behind the camera to mingle with the actors on the screen, reminding the spectators of his permanent presence in his film, even when invisible. In a so-called screen passage, one of Woody Allen’s actors in The Purple Rose of Cairo (US, 1985) even steps out from his role as an actor on the screen to mingle with the audience. For decades, films used to conceal the traces of their production, for example the details of the film studio and the staff behind the scenes, as much as possible with the purpose of creating a perfect real-life illusion. Alloreference was on the agenda. Modern digital film technology has increased the potential for illusion and enables the alloreferential representation of previously impossible “realities”. The audience is no longer restricted to viewing the sinking Titanic above the sea level but can also participate in the drama below the water surface. As a result of the new possibilities of digital picture manipulation, it is no longer possible to distinguish real shots from digital additions (cf. Manovich 1999). The alloreferential perfection of this pictorial manipulation makes us forget its digital construction. More and more accurate representations and the increasing possibilities of representing the world in all of its visual facets create the illusion of a growth of alloreference of the medium.
Self-reference in the media: The semiotic framework
21
On the other hand, there are those new strategies and effects of illusion that conduce from a world of the “real” to the awareness of a world of simulation. The more the pictures distance themselves from reality, the more doubts in the authenticity and plausibility of the feigned worlds arise. The ever repetitive effects of simulation shatter the audience’s belief in the communicative contract between filmmaker and audience. Films deal with the premises and conditions of this communicative contract as a result of a critical reflection of this situation. It eventually becomes the subject matter of filmed representation itself: filmmakers appear on the screen in the role of actors, actors play the role of the producer, and last but not least, they leave the screen entirely in an effective screen passage to join the audience in the cinema (cf. Stam 1992; Karpf, Kiesel, and Visarius 1996, and Withalm, this vol.). New forms of pragmatic selfreference are emerging with interactive films in which the spectator becomes the producer of his own viewing. Enunciative self-reference is of a different kind in computer games. Not unlike other games, reference to the world is secondary in computer games. Games do not want to simulate real life. In contrast to other forms of play, the computer game offers still more possibilities for the creation of new worlds. Their virtual character is highly self-referential from the beginning on. Players can interact with the program code and thus control the referential action, and they can become producers of the text. In which way communicative selfreferential autonomy of the players is actually attained remains open for further investigation.
5.7.
Iconic self-reference: Loops, repetitions, and recursion
Among the most important iconic modes of textual, intertextual, and intermedial self-reference are recursion and recurrence. Recursion, the circular or loop-like return to an earlier point in the same text, in other texts, or media, is similar to recurrence, the principle of repetition. There are diverse functions and effects. In music, art, and literature, the nontrivial recurrence of varied forms is a source of aesthetic effects: repetitio delectat. As the trivial repetition of the same, recurrence and recursion are signs of the trivial, for example in soap operas. In games, recursion can even be a means of punishment, for example in the classical ludo, where the return to the point of departure can be an element of suspense, satisfaction, or disappointment. In advertising, repetitive campaigns a` la Marlboro exemplify best the principle of intertextual recurrence and hence intertextual self-reference with their permanent return to the same scenario. Evidently, the Marlboro man does not
22
Winfried N¨oth
only refer alloreferentially to scenes of the myth of the Wild West but also self-referentially to the never changing world of the Marlboro posters. In the movies, too, we have become accustomed to intertextual self-reference. The most recent James Bond films, for example, are hardly discussed in terms of what they represent. Instead, intertextuality is the topic as public interest focuses on the question of how these films can be compared with those which preceded. Nina Bishara, in a comment on this paper, describes this form of self-reference in the most recent James Bond movie Die Another Day (UK/US, 2002) as follows: Not only are well-established and recurrent James Bond themes taken up (e.g. good against evil, the pre-titles sequences, “My name is Bond – James Bond” etc.), the 20th Bond movie also has strong allusions to the previous movies so that the real connoisseur can indulge in a guessing game. One scene with Bond girl Halle Barry resembles a scene with Ursula Andress from the first Bond movie Dr. No (1962) and props that played an important role in previous movies reappear. Allegedly, each of the previous films is included in the new Bond movie in some form or other. Moreover, cases of intermedial self-reference can be found in the product placements of cars (Ford, Jaguar, Aston Martin), Bond’s favorite champagne (Bollinger), spy tools such as the watch by Omega or the Ericsson mobile phone. Even print advertisements self-referentially refer back to these product placements, for example a BMW ad which advertises the fact that the new BMW model appears in the James Bond movie The World is not Enough (1999). Another intermedial form of self-reference can be observed in the video clip for the title song by Madonna for the 20th Bond movie which is also called Die Another Day and which re-enacts scenes from the movie. One of the characteristic features of digital film is the increasing possibility of self-repetition in the form of loops, as in Run Lola Run, where several variations of the same event are connected by means of time loops. There is no true beginning and no real end when this form of textual self-reference predominates. There is nothing but a sequence of recursive loops. Loops and recursivity, however, are not only modes of repetition; they are as well loci of variation (cf. Winkler 2004: 170–182). In computer games, recursion in the form of textual self-reference is still more advanced. For example, the player can chose a certain point of departure in the game and then try out a number of possible variations of the same strategy. Furthermore, the well-known order “Return to X” (i.e., to a previous position) clearly exemplifies textual self-reference. Textually self-referential recursion is probably the most characteristic feature of computer games, since the underlying algorithms are not only the basis of the production but also of the execution of the game.
Self-reference in the media: The semiotic framework
23
6. Self-reference between subversion, play, and art Self-reference in the media is hardly subversive, as it might seem when it results in paradox; its functions tend to be predominantly playful and aesthetic. Being directed towards itself without any ambition to represent, the world beyond the signs, a self-referential message cannot transmit a subversive message in the sense of a message that wants to undermine social or cultural values. However, a self-referential message can be subversive in the sense of breaking with the codes and conventions of the genre. In this sense, self-reference is most subversive in advertising, where the self-referential message is incompatible with the goal of advertising services or products. In films, too, self-reference has been a subversive device of the genre when it was first introduced as a stylistic device. Both media, however, have always shown self-referential elements in their poetic and aesthetic dimensions, since poetry and art are self-referential by nature. In games, by contrast, self-reference is not the exception, but the rule, since play and playful conduct have always tended to be self-referential. The values of chess figures, such as the king, the queen, the bishop, or the pawn, find very little correspondence in real life. Carnival seems to be revolutionary in allowing the peasant to become the prince, but carnival has never been suppressed by those in power, since they quickly recognized that playful conduct is self-oriented and cannot develop a revolutionary impetus. Computer games, however, have begun to create new realities and to simulate virtual realities which raise the question of subversion in a new way. Do they conduce to merely self-referentially playful activities, to play for play’s sake, as in chess, or do they create virtual realities with the potential to subvert the conventional values of culture and society?
References Andersen, Peter Bøgh, Claus Emmeche, Niels Ole Finnemann and PederVoetmann Christiansen (eds.) 2000 Downward Causation. Aarhus: University Press. Babcock, Barbara A. 1980 Reflexivity: Definitions and discriminations. Semiotica 30: 1–14. Barthes, Roland 1967 Syst`eme de la mode. Paris: Seuil. Bartlett, Steven J. 1987 Varieties of self-reference. In: Steven J. Bartlett and Peter Suber (eds.), Self-Reference: Reflections on Reflexivity, 5–30. Dordrecht: Nijhoff.
24
Winfried N¨oth
1992a
The role of reflexivity in understanding human understanding. In: Steven J. Bartlett (ed.), Reflexivity: A Source-Book in Self-Reference, 3–18. Amsterdam: North Holland. Bartlett, Steven J. (ed.) 1992b Reflexivity: A Source-Book in Self-Reference. Amsterdam: North Holland. Bartlett, Steven J. and Peter Suber (eds.) 1987 Self-Reference: Reflections on Reflexivity. Dordrecht: Nijhoff. Baudrillard, Jean 1976 L’´echange symbolique et la mort. Paris: Gallimard. 1981 Simulacres et simulation. Paris: Galil´ee. 1991 La guerre du Golfe n’a pas eu lieu. Paris: Galil´ee. Bettetini, Gianfranco 1971 L’indice del realismo. Milan: Bompiani. Bishara, Nina forthcoming Selbstreferenzielle Werbung. Bleicher, Joan-Kristin 1999 Unterhaltung in der Endlosschleife. In: Michael Latzer, Ursula MaierRabler and Gabriele Siegert (eds.), Die Zukunft der Kommunikation, 109–114. Innsbruck: Studien-Verlag. Block, Friedrich W. 1999 Beobachtung des ICH. Zum Zusammenhang von Subjektivit¨at und Medien am Beispiel experimenteller Poesie. Bielefeld: Aisthesis. Bl¨obaum, Bernd 1999 Selbstreferentialit¨at und Journalismus. In: Michael Latzer, Ursula Maier-Rabler and Gabriele Siegert (eds.), Die Zukunft der Kommunikation, 181–188. Innsbruck: Studien-Verlag. Bolter, David and Richard Grusin Remediation: Understanding New Media. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. 1999 Broich, Ulrich and Manfred Pfister (eds.) 1985 Intertextualit¨at. T¨ubingen: Niemeyer. Brook, Andrew and Richard C. DeVidi (eds.) 2001 Self-Awareness and Self-Reference. Amsterdam: Benjamins. Buckland, Warren 2000 The Cognitive Semiotics of Film. Cambridge: University Press. Buckland, Warren (ed.) 1995 The Film Spectator: From Sign to Mind. Amsterdam: University Press. B¨uttner, Stefan and Andrea Esser (eds.) 2001 Unendlichkeit und Selbstreferenz. W¨urzburg: K¨onigshausen & Neumann. Colapietro, Vincent 1989 Peirce’s Approach to the Self. Albany: State University of New York Press.
Self-reference in the media: The semiotic framework Dirks, Tim 2006
25
Greatest Disaster Film Scenes. http://www.filmsite.org/filmdisasters.html (16.05.06).
Dunne, Michael 1992 Metapop: Self-Referentiality in Contemporary American Popular Culture. Jackson: University Press of Mississippi. Eco, Umberto 1984 Mirrors. In: Umberto Eco, Semiotics and the Philosophy of Language, 202–226. Bloomington: Indiana University Press. Evans, Gareth 1991 The Varieties of Reference. Oxford: Clarendon. Fitch, Frederic B. 1987 Self-reference in philosophy. In: Steven J. Bartlett and Peter Suber (eds.), Self-Reference: Reflections on Reflexivity, 221–230. Dordrecht: Nijhoff. Frieske, Michael 1998 Selbstreferentielles Entertainment: Television¨are Selbstbez¨uglichkeit in der Fernsehunterhaltung. Wiesbaden: Deutscher Universit¨atsverlag. Geach, Peter T. 1970 Reference and Generality, 2nd ed. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press. Goebel, Gerhard 1986 Notizen zur Semiotik der Mode. In: Silvia Bovenschen (ed.), Die Listen der Moden, 458–479. Frankfurt: Suhrkamp. Helbig, J¨org 2001 Intermedialit¨at: Eine Einf¨uhrung. Frankfurt: Suhrkamp. Hempfer, Klaus W. 1976 Poststrukturale Texttheorie und narrative Praxis. Munich: Fink. 1982 Die potentielle Autoreflexivit¨at des narrativen Diskurses. In: Eberhard L¨ammert (ed.), Erz¨ahlforschung, 130–156. Stuttgart: Metzler. Hoffmeyer, Jesper 1996 Signs of Meaning in the Universe. Bloomington: Indiana University Press. Hofstadter, Douglas R. 1979 G¨odel, Escher, Bach. New York: Basic Books. 1985 Metamagical Themas. New York: Basic Books. Huber, Werner, Martin Middeke and Hubert Zapf (eds.) 2005 Self-Reflexivity in Literature. W¨urzburg: K¨onigshausen & Neumann. Jahraus, Oliver and Nina Ort (eds.) 2003 Theorie – Prozess – Selbstreferenz: Systemtheorie und transdisziplin¨are Theoriebildung. Konstanz: UVK.
26
Winfried N¨oth
Jay, Paul 1984
Being the Text: Self-Representation from Wordsworth to Roland Barthes. Ithaca: Cornell University Press. Johansen, Jørgen Dines 2002 Literary Discourse: A Semiotic-Pragmatic Approach to Literature. Toronto: University of Toronto Press. Karpf, Ernst, Doron Kiesel and Karsten Visarius (eds.) 1996 Im Spiegelkabinett der Illusionen. Filme uber ¨ sich selbst. Marburg: Sch¨uren. Katz, Jerrold J. 2004 Sense, Reference, and Philosophy. Oxford: University Press. Kempson, Ruth M. 1977 Semantic Theory. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Kienzle, Bertrand and Helmut Pape (eds.) 1991 Dimensionen des Selbst: Selbstbewusstsein, Reflexivit¨at und die Bedingungen von Kommunikation. Frankfurt: Suhrkamp. Kirchmann, Kay ¨ 1996 Zwischen Selbstreflexivit¨at und Selbstreferentialit¨at. Uberlegungen ¨ zur Asthetik des Selbstbez¨uglichen als filmische Modernit¨at. In: Ernst Karpf, Doron Kiesel and Karsten Visatius (eds.), Im Spiegelkabinett der Illusionen. Filme uber ¨ sich selbst, 67–86. Marburg: Sch¨uren. Klein, Naomi 2000 No Logo. Toronto: Knopf Canada. Knowles, Elizabeth (ed.) 2004 The Oxford Dictionary of Modern Quotations, 2nd ed. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Kohring, Matthias 1999 Selbstgespr¨ache: Der Begriff der Selbstreferenz und das Fallbeispiel des Journalismus. In: Michael Latzer, Ursula Maier-Rabler and Gabriele Siegert (eds.), Die Zukunft der Kommunikation, 189–198. Innsbruck: Studien-Verlag. Korzybski, Alfred 1933 Science and Sanity. Lakeville, CN: Int. Non-Aristotelian Library. Krah, Hans 2005a Selbstreferentialit¨at, Selbstbez¨uglichkeit, Selbstreferenz: Die Begriffe und ihr Bedeutungsspektrum. Zeitschrift f¨ur Semiotik 27(1–2): 3–22. Krah, Hans (ed.) 2005b Selbstreferenz und literarische Gattung. Special issue of Zeitschrift f¨ur Semiotik 27(1–2). T¨ubingen: Stauffenburg. Lawson, Hilary 1985 Reflexivity: The Post-Modern Predicament. London: Hutchinson. Liebrand, Claudia and Irmela Schneider (eds.) 2002 Medien in den Medien. Cologne: DuMont.
Self-reference in the media: The semiotic framework
27
Lipman, Jean and Richard Marshall (eds.) 1978 Art about Art. New York: Dutton. Luhmann, Niklas 1984 Das Kunstwerk und die Selbstreproduktion der Kunst. Delfin 3: 51– 69. 1993 Zeichen als Form. In: Dirk Baecker (ed.), Probleme der Form, 45– 69. Frankfurt: Suhrkamp. Transl. M. Irmscher. 1999. Sign as form. Cybernetics and Human Knowing 6.3: 21–37. 1995 Die Realit¨at der Massenmedien. Opladen: Westdeutscher Verlag. Lyotard, Jean-Fran¸cois 1979 La condition postmoderne. Paris: Minuit. Engl. (1984). The Postmodern Condition, G. Bennington and B. Massumi (transl.). Minneapolis: Minnesota University Press. McLuhan, Marshall 1964 Understanding Media: The Extensions of Man. London: Routledge and Kegan. Manovich, Lev 1999 What is digital cinema? In: Peter Lunenfeld (ed.), The Digital Dialectics: New Essays on the New Media, 172–192. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. Marcus, Solomon 1997 Media and self-reference: The forgotten initial state. In: Winfried N¨oth (ed.), Semiotics of the Media, 15–45. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter. Menninghaus, Winfried 1987 Unendliche Verdopplungen: Die fr¨uhromantische Grundlegung der Kunsttheorie im Begriff absoluter Selbstreflexion. Frankfurt: Suhrkamp. Metscher, Thomas ¨ 2003 Ahnlichkeit und Selbstrepr¨asentation. In: Silja Freudenberger and Hans J¨org Sandk¨uhler (eds.), Repr¨asentation, Krise der Repr¨asentation, Paradigmenwechsel, 271–299. Frankfurt: Lang. M¨uller, J¨urgen 1996 Intermedialit¨at: Formen moderner kultureller Kommunikation. M¨unster: Nodus. M¨unch, Dieter 1992 Referenz, Referenztheorie. In: Joachim Ritter and Karlfried Gr¨under (eds.), Historisches W¨orterbuch der Philosophie, Volume 8, 386–387. Basel: Schwabe. Myers, C. Mason 1966 The circular use of metaphor. Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 26: 391–402.
28
Winfried N¨oth
N¨oth, Winfried 1977 2000a 2000b
Dynamik semiotischer Systeme. Stuttgart: Metzler. Handbuch der Semiotik, 2nd rev. ed. Stuttgart/Weimar: Metzler. Selbstreferenz in systemtheoretischer und semiotischer Sicht. In: Achim Barsch, Gebhard Rusch, Reinhold Viehoff and Friedrich W. Block (eds.), Festsite Siegfried J. Schmidt. http://sjschmidt.net/konzepte/texte/noeth1.htm (16.05.06) and 2002 in: etc: Empirische Text- und Kulturforschung 2.2002: 1–7. 2001 Autorreferencialidad en la crisis de la modernidad. Cuadernos: Revista de la Facultad de Humanidades y Ciencias Sociales 17: 365– 369. 2002 Semiotic machines. Cybernetics and Human Knowing 9(1): 5–22. 2005a The art of self-reference in Edward Lear’s limericks. International Journal of Germanic Linguistics and Semiotic Analysis 10(1): 47–66. 2005b Formen der Selbstreferenz in den Medien. In: Sigrid Schade, Thomas Sieber and Georg C. Tholen (eds.), SchnittStellen, 133–146. Basel: Schwabe. 2006 Repr¨asentation und Referenz bei Peirce. In: Hans-J¨org Sandk¨uhler (ed.). Theorien und Begriffe der Repr¨asentation (= Schriftenreihe der von derVolkswagenstiftung gef¨orderten Forschergruppe Repr¨asentation 1), 43–61. Bremen: Universit¨at. 2007 Narrative self-reference in a literary comic: M.-A. Mathieu’s L’Origine. Semiotica 165:173–190. N¨oth, Winfried (ed.) 2006 Semiotic Bodies, Aesthetic Embodiments, and Cyberbodies. Kassel: University Press. N¨oth, Winfried and Christina Ljungberg (eds.) 2003 The Crisis of Representation: Semiotic Foundations and Manifestations in Culture and the Media. (= Special Issue of Semiotica 143.1–4). N¨oth, Winfried and Anke Hertling (eds.) 2005 K¨orper – Verk¨orperung – Entk¨orperung. Kassel: University Press. Ort, Claus-Michael 2003 Medienwechsel und Selbstreferenz. T¨ubingen: Niemeyer. Paech, Joachim 1998 Zur theoretischen Grundlegung von Intermedialit¨at. In: J¨org Helbig (ed.), Intermedialit¨at.Theorie und Praxis eines interdisziplin¨aren Forschungsgebiets, 14–30. Berlin: Erich Schmidt. Pattee, Howard H. 1995 Evolving self-reference: Matter symbols, and semantic closure. Communication and Cognition 12(1–2): 9–28. Pavliˇci´c, Pavao 1993 What is the purpose of autoreferentiality? Neohelicon 20(1): 97–106.
Self-reference in the media: The semiotic framework
29
Peirce, Charles Sanders 1931–58 Collected Papers, vols. 1–6, ed. Charles Hartshorne and Paul Weiss, vols. 7–8, ed., A. W. Burks. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. – Quoted as CP. 1963–66 The Charles S. Peirce Papers. 30 reels, microfilm edition. Cambridge, MA: The Houghton Library, Harvard University Microproductions. – Quoted as MS; see Robin, comp. 1967. Peitgen, Heinz-Otto, Hartmut J¨urgens and Dietmar Saupe 1992 Chaos and Fractals. Berlin: Springer. Petersen, Christer 2003 Der postmoderne Text. Kiel: Ludwig. Potthast, Ulrich ¨ 1971 Uber einige Fragen der Selbstbeziehung. Frankfurt: Klostermann. Prigogine, Ilya and Isabelle Stengers 1984 Order out of Chaos. New York: Bantam. Rajewsky, Irina O. 2002 Intermedialit¨at. T¨ubingen: Francke. Robin, Richard S. 1967 Annotated Catalogue of the Papers of Charles S. Peirce. Amherst: University of Massachusetts Press. (MS refers to the numbers of this catalogue.) Santaella, Lucia 2004 Corpo e comunica¸cao. ˜ S˜ao Paulo: Paulus. Santaella, Lucia and Winfried N¨oth 2004 Semi´otica e comunica¸cao. ˜ S˜ao Paulo: Hacker. Scheffel, Michael 1997 Formen des selbstreflexiven Erz¨ahlens. T¨ubingen: Niemeyer. Scheutz, Matthias 1995 Ist das der Titel eines Buches? Selbstreferenz neu analysiert. Vienna: WUV. Schmidt, Siegfried J. 1994 Kognitive Autonomie und soziale Orientierung. Frankfurt: Suhrkamp. Schmidt, Siegfried J. and Brigitte Spieß 1996 Die Kommerzialisierung der Kommunikation: Fernsehwerbung und sozialer Wandel 1956–1989. Frankfurt: Suhrkamp. Sch¨oppe, Arno 1995 Theorie paradox: Kreativit¨at als systemische Herausforderung. Heidelberg: Carl Auer. Shir, Jay 1978 Symbolism and autosymbolism. Journal of Aesthetics and Art Criticism 37(1): 81–89.
30
Winfried N¨oth
Siedenbiedel, Catrin 2005 Metafiktionalit¨at in Finnegans Wake. W¨urzburg: K¨onigshausen & Neumann. Smuda, Manfred 1970 Becketts Prosa als Metasprache. Munich: Fink. Spielmann, Yvonne 1998 Intermedialit¨at. Das System Peter Greenaway. Munich: Fink. Stam, Robert 1992 Reflexivity in Film and Literature: From Don Quixote to Jean-Luc Goddard. New York: Columbia University Press. Waugh, Patricia 1984 Metafiction. London: Methuen. Weber, Stefan 1999 Das System Journalismus: Oszillieren zwischen Selbstreferenz und Fremdsteuerung. In: Michael Latzer, Ursula Maier-Rabler and Gabriele Siegert (eds.), Die Zukunft der Kommunikation, 161–180. Innsbruck: Studien-Verlag. Whitehead, Alfred N. and Bertrand Russell (eds.) 1910 Principia Mathematica. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Whiteside, Anna 1987 The double-bind: Self-referring poetry. In: Anna Whiteside and Michael Issacharoff (eds.), On Referring in Literature, 14–32. Bloomington: Indiana University Press. Winkler, Hartmut 2004 Diskurs¨okonomie. Frankfurt: Suhrkamp. Withalm, Gloria 1995 Fernsehen im Fernsehen im Fernsehen. . . : Selbstreferentielle Zeichen¨ prozesse. Vienna: OGS/ISS. Wittig, Susan 1979 Architecture about architecture: Self-reference as a type of architectural signification. In: Seymour Chatman, Umberto Eco and JeanMarie Klinkenberg (eds.), A Semiotic Landscape, 970–978. The Hague: Mouton. Wolf, Werner 2001 Formen der literarischen Selbstreferenz in der Erz¨ahlkunst. In: J¨org Helbig (ed.), Erz¨ahlen und Erz¨ahltheorie im 20. Jahrhundert, 49–84. Heidelberg: Winter. Zavala, Lauro 2000 Una tipolog´ıa estructural de estrategias metaficcionales en cine y literatura. Xochimilco: Universidad Aut´onoma Metropolitana. ˇ zek, Slavoj Ziˇ 2002 Welcome to the Desert. London: Verso.
Distortion, fabrication, and disclosure in a self-referential culture:The irresistible force of reality Vincent Colapietro
1. Introduction: The cultural frame Reflexivity has been taken to be a hallmark of postmodernity (Lawson 1985; Bartlett 1992; Dunne 2001; N¨oth, this vol., Part I). There is unquestionably a warrant for doing so. For ours is manifestly a time in which self-reference, especially in its most intensified forms and paradoxical implications, is a pervasive and thus inescapable facet of our lives.1 The forms and effects of this reflexivity are far from superficial: they are, indeed, integral to the structures of our lives, including our modes of embodiment, engagement, and affectivity (Lenoir 2000; Gitlin 2002: 6; Santaella 2003). Arguably, our propensity toward irony, our incredulity toward metanarratives, our longing for immediacy, our ambivalence regarding authenticity, and various other factors are intimately connected to the reflexivity so characteristic of our time. Whether or not these connections can be established, there is little doubt about reflexivity being a hallmark of postmodernity. Though its character, forms, and significance invite numerous questions, this connection is itself beyond question. This is nowhere more evident than in the forms and effects of reflexivity generated and intensified by the interlocking networks of contemporary media, ranging from long-established ones such as newspapers to cutting-edge technologies such as computer simulation of war games (Lenoir 2000). The news being broadcast via such media as television, radio, and blogs on the world wide web (www) constitutes unquestionably intricate and arguably insular networks of self-citation and self-commentary. The news reports on the news as much as anything else. Individuals are celebrities for no other reason than being celebrated in the media. Popular entertainment constructs a world of complex allusions to the fabrications of the entertainment industry itself. Nowhere is intertextuality more manifest than, for example, in the structures of cinema. In light of all of this, we seemingly inhabit a world of our own making, one in which claims about reality are viewed with deep suspicion, if not outright dismissal.
32
Vincent Colapietro
Even the character of the “real” world of global politics has come increasingly to take on that of the fabricated world of the entertainment industry (a point to which I shall return). The crisis of representation, insofar as it is generated by the inherent dynamic of, and theoretical reflections on, mass media, is inseparably connected to the forms of reflexivity so pervasive in a culture so radically structured by such media. The possibilities of reference and representation in anything approximating a straightforward sense seem to be increasingly – and paradoxically (N¨oth 2003: 9–11) – limited to those of self-reference and self-representation. Indexical signs in their most rudimentary form are assumed at every turn, but theoretically erased. In an increasingly self-referential culture, the relationship of the self to itself paradoxically works to shatter the putative unity and stability of the self. The self is, on Richard Rorty’s account at least, a centerless web of contingent beliefs and desires (see, e.g., 1989: 10). Such an account seems to be tailored to the sensibility of those who are mobile nodes in an expanding network of selfreferential media. For such “selves”, self-consciousness tends to assume a form in which self-identification becomes increasingly problematic and awkward, but at the same time a form in which self-estrangement does not ordinarily feel selflacerating. The self is affectively attached to an identity or endeavor from which it can readily distance itself, very often through ironic self-commentary. In an increasingly self-referential culture such as our own, our relationship to a common reality is no less radically altered than our relationship to our innermost selves. Indeed, our confidence in our ability to refer to a shared reality tends to be deeply shaken, if not entirely undermined. Insofar as we (at any rate, you and I individually) lack such confidence, the reality of community itself becomes problematic.2 Our ever deepening skepticism regarding the ability to appeal to a shared understanding or to refer to a common reality is, at once, widely felt and communally debilitating.3 More and more of us feel this way and the more we actually do the less we are possible (i.e., the less likely communal norms and ideals are concretely embodied in shared habits, practices, and institutions). The solidarity requisite for political opposition grounded in shared concerns, grievances, and hopes can be, for example, more ephemeral (at least less efficacious) than the fabricated sense of national unity. Actual forms of solidarity are rendered more and more insubstantial and ineffective, while fabricated or, more precisely, fantastic forms of identity become more and more central and energizing. In the writings of C. S. Peirce we encounter a theorist who combines a robust sense of reality with an acute sense of the fragile and (in no small measure) illusory character of the self. For this and other reasons, some of his most distinctive
Distortion, fabrication, and disclosure in a self-referential culture
33
contributions (above all, his doctrine of signs, his version of pragmatism, and more broadly his account of inquiry) seem especially relevant to the task of making sense out of our selves and our world, as both are encountered in an increasingly self-referential culture. For Peirce, the self is in no small measure a fabrication (CP 4.68; Short 1997: 307); and, in turn, our only access to reality is through the mediation of signs. Even so, a fragile, fissured, and fallible self, as much (if not more) illusory as real, might have adequate resources (if only barely adequate resources) to know reality. But such a self can do so only in conjunction with other such selves, forming thereby a community of inquirers defined by a commitment to open-ended self-criticism. To paraphrase Peirce, the idea of reality is inseparably connected to not only the idea but also the reality of community.
2. A contemporary example in light of Peircean realism A pragmatist is, according to the originator of this doctrine, a theorist for whom “the distinction of reality and fiction is naturally highly prominent. But I cannot see how such a mind can deny the reality of generals” (MS 313, p. 19). Though highly prominent the distinction between fact and fancy, reality and figment is continuous, such that the one shades into the other (facts always begin in some measure imaginative depictions and fancies real affairs). For a pragmatist committed to maintaining this distinction, however, generals are in countless instances no mere fictions: the reality of generals needs to be acknowledged along with the ubiquity of imagination and the otherness of reality. The mediated (or semiotic) realism of Peirce is able to do fuller justice to the complex actualities of contemporary culture than more influential theories of radical constructivism (Colapietro 2000). For theoretical and practical purposes, the language of disclosure must not be completely jettisoned in favor of the language of distortion or that of fabrication (or construction). One of the purposes of this paper is to make this argument as briefly and yet as pointedly as possible. Disclosure is inevitably partial, perspectival, and fallible, just as facts are (as the root of the word suggests) something wrought (facts being, in a sense, fabrications or constructions). Even so, our use of signs generates possibilities wherein some facets of reality are disclosed, are revealed often to our surprise and even frustration. I want to make this argument for Peircean realism in the teeth of hyper reflexivity in the media, as illustrated in an editorial in the New York Times (one wherein the world of politics is mapped onto that of film). In an editorial entitled “The two wars of the worlds” (New York Times, July 3, 2005), Frank Rich compares George W. Bush’s speech at Fort Bragg and Steven Spielberg’s just released “War of the Worlds”.4 The premise of Rich’s
34
Vincent Colapietro
piece is that both the president and the director are aiming at inducing terror in their audience, Bush for the purpose of reversing the mounting skepticism regarding his adventure in Iraq, Spielberg for the purpose of entertainment, profit, and possibly edification.5 Both are in fact reruns or remakes: Spielberg is offering (according to the website for this movie) “a contemporary reading of H. G. Wells’s seminal classic”, while Bush was giving at Fort Bragg “almost the identical televised address, albeit with four fewer 9/11 references, at the Army War College in Pennsylvania in May 2004”. The “dazed response” of the military audience to Bush’s “summer rerun” however stands in marked contrast to the excited response of audiences to Spielberg’s remake. Much of this might be the result of Bush’s ineptitude in crafting a narrative. At least, Rich argues this point; and his argument is rich in allusions to the history of cinema and television. Mr. Spielberg’s movie illuminates [. . . ] how Mr. Bush has flubbed the basic storytelling essential to sustain public support for his Iraq adventure. The president has made a tic of hammering [home his points] in melodramatic movie tropes: good vs. evil, you’re with us or you’re with the terrorists, “wanted dead or alive”, “bring ’em on”, “mission accomplished”. When you relay a narrative in that style [Rich continues], the audience expects you to stick to the conventions of the genre; the story can only end with the cavalry charging in to win the big final battle. That’s how Mr. Spielberg deploys his platoons, “Saving Private Ryan”-style, in “War of the Worlds”. By contrast, Mr. Bush never marshaled the number of troops needed to guarantee Iraq’s security and protect its borders; he has now defined “mission accomplished” down from concrete victory to the inchoate spreading of democracy. To start off sounding like [General George] Patton and end up parroting [President] Woodrow Wilson is tantamount to ambushing an audience at a John Wayne movie with a final reel by Frank Capra.
The conclusion of Rich’s piece is also especially worthy of our attention, since he not only continues to frame his argument in reference to cinema but also casts Bush himself in the role of an alien. The “current war’s unpopularity now matches the Gallop findings during the Vietnam tipping point, the summer of 1968”. For a number of reasons, “it’s the Bush presidency, not the insurgency, that will [soon] be in its last throes”. The figure of a dying alien is, Rich implies, an apt image for this failing president: “Is the commander in chief so isolated in his bubble that he does not realize this [that he, not the insurgency, is soon to be in his last throes]?” He accordingly concludes with a piece of his advice: “G.W.B., phone home”. The cartoon by Barry Blitt accompanying Frank Rich’s editorial underscores the current war as a media event in which the significance of the event itself
Distortion, fabrication, and disclosure in a self-referential culture
35
invites comparison to cinema. In this cartoon, “War in the Gulf: The Sequel” is being “Held Over” at Quagmire Theatre. But, in the course of depicting Bush’s speech as “a summer rerun” and media event (albeit one of lackluster quality), Rich asserts: Much of what Bush said in this speech “was, as usual, at odds with reality”. The comparison between “The Two Wars of the Worlds” is consequently intended not to erase the distinction between depiction and reality (much less that between fabrication and disclosure) but to highlight, in reference to Bush’s words, the clash between what has been actually asserted and what can be responsibly established. What Peircean realism tries to secure, above all else, is the colloquial sense of what is meant when a journalist or anyone else claims that an utterance, report, or other use of signs is “at odds with reality”. The very meaning of reality is partly derived from that which has the capacity to thwart even our most strenuous endeavors or to disrupt our habitual responses.6 Often, our present selves, as concrete representatives of the determinate past carried into and beyond the actual present (above all) by the tenacity of our habits, cannot effectively negotiate the scene in which we are entangled and, of greater significance, the one in which we will continue to be entangled. When effort and habit prove to be ineffective (when we cannot negotiate the scene in which we are entangled), we need to renegotiate the terms of our coexistence with the things and persons around us. Indeed, the metaphor that seems best to capture the complexity of this process is that of renegotiation. This metaphor suggests a political as well as communal process, one in which power is brokered and people repositioned vis-`a-vis one another. The real is that which brings to light unsuspected deficiencies in the cumulative results of our ongoing negotiations. For the Peircean realist, however, the locus of the real is not so much at the origin of any process of renegotiation as at the provisional conclusions of an ongoing process (CP 8.12, 8.208, 8.284). The real is what the course of such renegotiations has forced us to acknowledge, above all, to acknowledge as what we would need to consider if the pursuit of our purposes is to be successful. Human purposes abound and extra-human factors are interwoven with what is, even in a seemingly simple, single deed, best seen as the dramatic, simultaneous enactment of multiple purposes. The multiplicity of our purposes and the complexity of our circumstances, the propulsive force of our present habits and the often upsetting presence of environing objects and their characteristic dispositions, all point to the abiding need to acknowledge real externality and to articulate in more concrete terms than we have thus a robust realism (Colapietro 2000). The irrepressible force of reality is such that, in however coded and distorted a form, its traces7 are innumerable and (to some extent) both discernible and decipherable (both identifiable and interpretable). This force is also such
36
Vincent Colapietro
that we can position ourselves to feel more fully and to discern more finely its efficacy, but only to the extent we adhere to rigorous ideals of self-critique. We can observe, in the self-referential tendencies evident in various media, a multiplicity of functions. Such tendencies seem to serve “predominantly ludic and aesthetic functions” (N¨oth), though Hilary Lawson and others argue that they contribute to the largely unacknowledged enhancement of critical consciousness in a world where ultimate truths and absolute certainty are so widely taken to be cultural illusions. Some theorists even take these tendencies to be inherently subversive, to carry by their own momentum the power to undermine the sanctity of traditional authorities and to disclose the historicity of allegedly timeless truths. Others (and I agree with them) contend that subversion is not so easily accomplished (N¨oth). But, in addition to the ludic, aesthetic, and subversive functions just mentioned, I take it to be important, even urgent, to stress the critical function made possible by the open-ended reflexivity so characteristic of distinctively human uses of signs and media (a function distinct from that conceived by Lawson and others who seem to make critical consciousness an inevitable outcome of the inherent dynamic of subversive tendencies characteristic of reflexive media). Self-reference is a condition for self-criticism and, in turn, self-criticism is indispensable for responsibly establishing what is so. In some contexts, self-reference does not serve to enclose us in an ever more insular world, but rather works to expose us to an always somewhat unpredictable domain in which ongoing revision, and at least occasionally radical revision, of our habitual modes of description and explanation is the price to be paid for framing a reliable account of the world (for disclosing as accurately as our finitude and fallibility allow the contours, facets, and textures of reality). Such, at least, is the central claim of Peircean realism. As defended by Peirce himself, it is inseparably connected to his fallibilism, synechism, and pragmaticism. But rather than argue for this claim in a theoretical manner, I want now to illustrate it in a deceptively simple way. This illustration is, however, intended to have the force of an argument; it is offered as a means of showing how selfreference in the media can serve the ideal of self-criticism and, in turn, how the ideal of such criticism is vital to the disclosure of reality. Such reference serves a variety of other functions, ones often eclipsing and even counteracting the critical function of reflexive discourse. But it also generates the possibility, however fragile and fleeting, of self-criticism. Such criticism is, at bottom, the result of a moral stance, that of holding oneself accountable to others, to both what others have said and also what allegedly “mute objects” (Bakhtin 1981: 351) in effect say in response to our depictions of them (cf. Colapietro 2003: 14–15). More or less reliable disclosures of some facet of the world depend
Distortion, fabrication, and disclosure in a self-referential culture
37
utterly upon such a stance. In the media as much as anywhere else, we discern just this possibility, along with countless examples of effective distortions and insulating fabrications. I now offer an example of this.
3. An example of journalistic reflexivity Thus, allow me to turn at this point to the task of reporting on a report about the activity of reporters working in the “mainstream media” in the United States (Gitlin 2005: 6). This might seem to be a case of hyperreflexivity or self-referentiality (terms I use synonymously here); moreover, hyperreflexivity appears to be characteristic of the very processes by which our relationship to reality becomes ever more attenuated, if not entirely severed. My purpose in doing so, however, is not to construct a hall of mirrors in which an endless multiplication of reflections frustrates the desire to locate the palpable source of those reflections. Rather my aim is to use this example of self-reference in the media as a way of bringing into focus the irreducibly complex relationship of reflexivity, rationality, and reality, though in such a way that emphasis on reflexivity is not allowed to eclipse rationality and reality.8 So, let us attend to a report in the media on the activity of those in the mainstream media in the U.S. More exactly, this report concerns less the activity than the failure of reporters, less what they did than what they have failed to do. It is a story about what until recently has been missing in the media and indeed who have been missing (in the sense of not reporting for duty, not doing what they have vowed to do). In a regular feature entitled “Press Watch” in an issue of The Nation (July 4, 2005), Todd Gitlin constructs a compelling case for the noteworthy failure of mainstream media simply to report a significant “fact”. The focus of his concern in the piece under consideration is, to repeat, what the mainstream media have failed to report. The title of his article makes this point immediately clear: “MIA: News of Prison Toll”. In this instance, the reporters are the ones missing in action (MIA). The news regarding the number of those who have died while prisoners of the U.S. under suspicion of terrorism is that this number has not been reported in the news. In the New York Times, Thomas Friedman (an opinion columnist, not a news reporter) declared, “the abuse at Guant´anamo and within the whole U.S. military prison system dealing with terrorism is out of control. Tell me, how is it that over 100 detainees have died in U.S. custody so far? Heart attacks?” (May 27, 2005; quoted in Gitlin 2005: 6). In Gitlin’s piece, one member of the media is chastising other members9 and therein the media is exhibiting a seemingly irrepressible tendency to report on
38
Vincent Colapietro
itself. One of the effects of this is, however, not to sustain an ever more insular network of self-reference (though one of the results is, arguably, to generate an ever more intricate system of such references). At any rate, reflexivity is not operating here in the service of insularity. Rather it is pushing to render a system vulnerable to the pressures – ultimately, the reality – of what this system has so strenuously tried to exclude. In other words, reflexivity here is operating in the service of registering a reality resolutely ignored. Reflexivity is fulfilling this function through a process of self-questioning: a representative of the media is questioning the media in the name of what they (the media themselves) promise to convey. In turn, such questioning is integral to our understanding of rationality. The acknowledgment of any complex reality (especially any controversial reality) is impossible apart from responsiveness to ongoing interrogations, often ones of an increasingly reflexive character. Whatever else we might mean by rationality, responsiveness in this and indeed other respects is central to the meaning of this word.
4. Conclusion: “Vision of the cobblestones” Allow me to draw these reflections to a close by recalling an arresting image offered by a contemporary author. In the Preface to The Captive Mind, Czeslaw Milosz confessed about himself as a younger man, “Hitherto, I had had no strong political affinities and was only too ready to shut myself off from the realities of life. But reality would never let me remain aloof for long” (1953: vi). Later in this work he insists: “The work of human thought should withstand the test of brutal, naked reality. Probably only those things are worth while which can preserve their validity in the eyes of a man threatened with instant death.” He valorizes this decisive perspective in an unforgettable way when he writes: A man is lying under machine-gun fire on a street in an embattled city. He looks at the pavement and sees a very amusing sight: the cobblestones are standing straight up like the quills of a porcupine. The bullets hitting against their edges displace and tilt them. Such moments in the consciousness of a man judge all poets and philosophers. Let us suppose, too, that a certain poet was the hero of the literary caf´es, and wherever he went he was regarded with curiosity and awe. Yet his poems [or someone else’s theories], recalled in such a moment, suddenly seem diseased and highbrow. The vision of the cobblestones is unquestionably real, and poetry based on an equally naked experience could possibly survive triumphantly that judgment day of man’s illusions. (1953: 39)
Distortion, fabrication, and disclosure in a self-referential culture
39
At least one of the most critical tests of poetry and theories, news reports and presidential addresses, is their ability to appear other than diseased when exposed to such experience. Such experience might never be naked, in the sense of unmediated. The mediated yet direct encounter with the displaced and tilted cobblestones (or some analogue), however, secures in our experience a basis for maintaining an irreducible (if not necessarily “highly prominent”) distinction between reality and fiction, disclosure and fabrication. That the ongoing mediations of a self-consciously historical community of self-critical inquirers are required to ascertain the significance of these encounters is no argument against a direct encounter with the actual world; for Peircean realism insists that all our encounters with reality are direct yet mediated affairs (Smith 1992: 20–25; cf. Smith 1978: 87–95; Colapietro 1995: 42–44). The recognition of the ubiquitous thirdness inherent in experience does not require us to ignore or deny the salient secondness characteristic of experience (the direct confrontation with irreducible otherness). A nuanced understanding of human experience suggests rather the abiding need to accredit the disclosive potential of our direct encounters but also the equally persistent need to embrace the task of interminable critique (Bernstein 1981: 116–120). Reality is, as Peirce suggests, what inquiry would disclose in the indefinite long run (see, however, Smith 1970: 104–108). In the meantime, it is what the most reliable of our investigations have intimated, however revisable these intimations turn out to be (Colapietro 1996: 137–38). In this light, reality is at once frustratingly elusive, brutally insistent, and inherently intelligible. Reflexive rationality, especially in the form of reflexive interrogation (more simply, in the form of self-questioning), is required for disclosing the contours, facets, and dimensions of reality, insofar as this is possible. Self-referentiality in the media can be an instance of nothing less than such rationality. But, then, it also can be one of the principal forces by which an increasingly insular world of autotelic systems maintains itself. The markedly aesthetic dimension of contemporary existence is nowhere more evident than in the degree and manner in which the technological, communicational, educational, and other networks assume the character of autotelic systems. Even so, the marked presence of the aesthetic and ludic functions of increasingly reflexive media does not preclude the effective operation of a critical function, one operating often in the name of the strenuously repressed, the systematically ignored, and the grossly distorted. Such a function is necessary for disclosing the degree to which we humans and our uses of signs are so often “at odds with reality”. In light of the distortions and fabrications so vital to the maintenance of power, this everyday expression and its numerous equivalents in their colloquial sense are, in turn, vital to the ever unfinished work of humane critique (Bernstein 1981: 118–120). Is such critique
40
Vincent Colapietro
truly rendered impossible or unnecessary in such a radically self-referential culture as our own?
Notes 1. This point is finely articulated by Winfried N¨oth in his introductory chapter to this volume: “The visual, and the audiovisual arts and media have become increasingly self-referential, self-reflexive, autotelic. Instead of representing something heard about, seen, lived, or otherwise experienced in social life, culture, and nature, journalists, commercial artists, designers, and film directors report increasingly what has been seen, heard, or reported before in the media. The mediators have turned to representing representations. Instead of narrating, they narrate how and why they narrate, instead of filming, they film that they film the filming. The news are more and more about what has been reported in the news, television shows are more and more concerned with television shows, and even advertising is no longer about products and services but about advertising. The messages of the media are about messages of the media, whose origin has become increasingly difficult to trace. In literature, fiction has become metafiction, novels have become metanovels, and texts are discovered as being intertexts whose reference is not to life but to other texts, and in the visual arts, art is now about art, and even architecture is about architecture. The digitalization of pictures and films, which has liberated the media from the bonds of factual reference to a world which they used to depict, has contributed to the increase of self-reference.” In this essay, N¨oth also carefully distinguishes the forms and means of self-reference. In addition, he helpfully stresses the point that there are degrees of reflexivity: “Various degrees of self-reference can be distinguished, from the sign that refers to nothing but itself to the sign that refers only partially to itself and partially still to something else.” Finally, he notes, “self-reference concerns different levels of the media and the message in which it occurs” (emphasis added). My own approach to this topic has been crucially informed by this paper and other writings by Prof. N¨oth. 2. In one of the articles (“Some Consequences of Four Incapacities”) in the series in which C. S. Peirce so brilliantly argued for a semiotic conception of cognition, consciousness, and selfhood, he stresses: “The real, then, is that which, sooner or later, information [i.e., experience, V.C.] and reasoning would finally result in, and which is therefore independent of the vagaries of me and you. Thus, the very origin of the conception of reality shows that this conception essentially involves the notion of a COMMUNITY, without definite limits, and capable of a definite increase of knowledge. And so those two series of cognition – the real and the unreal – consist of those which, at a time sufficiently future, the community will always continue to re-affirm; and those which, under the same conditions, will ever after be denied” (CP 5.311; EP 1, 52).
Distortion, fabrication, and disclosure in a self-referential culture
41
3. An important practical question is whether such a widely felt matter can serve as one of the bases for the recovery – or reconstruction – of local sites of effective community. 4. Rich points out: “Ever since Jaws, a movie set on the July Fourth weekend, broke box office records 30 summers ago, Independence Day has come to stand for terror as much as for freedom” (2005: 11). 5. Rich reports that, in Spielberg’s movie, “Tim Robbins (who else?) pops up to declare that when aliens occupy a country, the ‘occupations always fail’. Even Tom Cruise’s doltish teenage screen son is writing a school report on the ‘French occupation of Algeria”’. I do not have to remind Europeans, as I would have to remind Americans, that Jacques Chirac told George Bush that Iraq will prove to be America’s Algeria, to which Bush responded, “I could not disagree with you more”. Perhaps the doltish adolescent in Spielberg’s terrifying thriller is, as a result of his research, in a better position than the adolescent President to appreciate the analogy. 6. This would be reality in its secondness, in the form of otherness, resistance, obsistence, or oppugnancy (CP 1.322, 1.324, 2.79, 8.291). But, in Peirce’s lexicon, reality is a subtle, nuanced term, and reality in its secondness is hardly exhaustive of its meaning. 7. The notion of trace is crucial to the argument of this paper. This implies that so too is that of index, for the trace in the sense intended here is an instance of indexicality. See N¨oth, “The death of photography in self-reference” (this vol., Part III). 8. One of the most crucial aspects of the relationship between rationality and reflexivity is brought into immediate focus by Peirce when he suggests: “‘rational’ means essentially self-criticizing, self-controlling and self-controlled, and therefore open to incessant question” (CP 7.77). 9. The situation is even more complex than this since Gitlin is amplifying a criticism first voiced by Friedman in an editorial. He is also underscoring the fact that the news regarding the number of deaths was in effect reported in an editorial. At a time when the New York Times has made a renewed effort to draw “a sharper demarcation between news and opinion”, “the presumably hard side of the news” has, concerning “a stark and consequential matter of fact”, been missing in action (Gitlin 2005: 6). For news regarding the number of deaths of those detained by US as terrorists individuals in that country have had to rely on an opinion writer. Gitlin’s search on LexisNexis database of television news yielded these results: No report of this number on CSP, “one brief mention on NBC, another on ABC”, but nothing at all on CNN, Fox, or MSNBC; also nothing in either Time or Newsweek. On Corporation for Public Broadcasting (CPC), under intense fire for allegedly “liberal bias”, Jim Lehrer in his “News Hour” did give the number of such deaths as 100, counting 20 as homicides.
42
Vincent Colapietro
References Bakhtin, Mikhail M. 1981 The Dialogic Imagination: Four Essays by M. M. Bakhtin. Michael Holquist (ed.). Austin, TX: University of Texas Press. Bartlett, Steven (ed.) 1992 Reflexivity: A Source-Book in Self-Reference. Amsterdam: North-Holland. Bernstein, Richard J. 1981 Toward a more rational community. In: Kenneth L. Ketner et al. (eds.), Proceedings of the C. S. Peirce Bicentennial International Congress, 115–120. Lubbock: Texas Tech University. Colapietro, Vincent 1995 Immediacy, opposition, and mediation: Peirce on the irreducible aspects of the communicative process. In: Lenore Langsdorf and Andrew Smith (eds.), Recovering Pragmatism’s Voice, 23–48. Albany, NY: SUNY Press. 1996 The ground of semiosis:An implied theory of perspectival realism? In: Vincent Colapietro and Thomas Olshewsky (eds.), Peirce’s Doctrine of Signs: Theory, Applications, and Connections, 129–140. Berlin and New York: Mouton de Gruyter. 2000 Robust realism and real externality: The complex commitments of a convinced pragmaticist. Semiotica 130: 301–372. 2003 Signification and interpretation. Jornada CEPE [S˜ao Paulo] (October 30), 5–20. Dunne, Michael 2001 Metapop: Self-Referentiality in Contemporary American Popular Culture. Jackson, MS: University Press of Mississippi. Gitlin, Todd 2005 MIA: News of prison toll, The Nation (July 4), 6–8. 2002 Media Unlimited. New York: Metropolitan/Owl Book. Lawson, Hilary 1985 Reflexivity: The Post-Modern Predicament. London: Hutchinson. Lenoir, Timothy 2000 All war is simulation: The military-entertainment complex. Configurations 8: 289–335. Milosz, Czeslaw 1953 The Captive Mind. New York: Vintage Books. N¨oth, Winfried (ed.) 1997 Semiotics of the Media. Berlin and New York: Mouton de Gruyter. N¨oth, Winfried and Christina Ljungberg (eds.) 2003 The crisis of representation: Semiotic foundations and manifestations in culture and the media. Semiotica 143(1–4). (Special Issue).
Distortion, fabrication, and disclosure in a self-referential culture
43
Peirce, Charles S. 1931–1958 Collected Papers of C. S. Peirce. Ed. Charles Hartshorne, Paul Weiss and Arthur Burks. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. – Quoted as CP. 1963–1966 1979 The Charles S. Peirce Papers, 30 reels, 3rd microfilm edition. Cambridge, MA:The Houghton Library, Harvard University, Microreproduction Service. – Quoted as MS. 1867–1893 2003 The Essential Peirce. Ed. Nathan Houser. Bloomington, IN: Indiana Unversity Press. – Quoted as EP. Rorty, Richard 1989 Contingency, Irony, and Solidarity. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Rich, Frank 2005 The two wars of the worlds. The New York Times (July 3), 11. Santaella, Lucia 2003 Culturas e Artes do P´os-humano: Da Cultura das M´ıdias a` Cibercultura. S˜ao Paulo: Paulus. Short, Thomas L. 1997 Hypostatic abstraction in self-consciousness. In: Jacqueline Brunning and Paul Forster (eds.),The Rule of Reason:The Philosophy of Charles Sanders Peirce, 289–308. Toronto: University of Toronto Press. Smith, John E. 1970 Themes in American Philosophy: Purpose, Experience, and Community. New York: Harper & Row. 1978 Purpose and Thought: The Meaning of Pragmatism. New Haven: Yale University Press. 1992 America’s PhilosophicalVision. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Part II. Self-referential print advertising
Modes of self-reference in advertising Siegfried J. Schmidt
1. Media culture societies on their way to self-reference In recent decades, there has been a clear tendency in the development of media culture societies towards self-referential structures and processes. As far as I can see, there are three different reasons for this tendency: – Studies of the origin as well as of the functioning of communities and societies have revealed the crucial role of self-reference in terms of reflexivity. Today, reflexivity can be regarded as the fundamental process of generating social structures. The best example is communication. Communication relies on collective knowledge which bridges the gap between the cognitive autonomy of individuals and their necessary social orientation. Collective knowledge can be described in terms of reflexive loops of expected expectations in the domain of knowledge and imputed imputations in the domain of motives and intentions. As part of each individual’s stock of knowledge, it is more or less shared by all members of a society and plays an essential role in the coordination of their behavior and their communicative practice. – Self-referential reflexivity has become part of everyday experience in the last century through the development of a complex media system since media – conceived of as complex social systems – primarily serve the purpose of enabling specific self-observations of media culture societies. Furthermore, media increasingly observe each other. Accordingly, an immensely complex network or process system of observations has emerged, steered by the fundamental constructive processes of reflexivity in terms of self-referentiality. – The more societies increase the degree of their observability through the development of self-referential media systems, the more urgent becomes the question for the functional and integrative performance of culture programs1 for actors and social subsystems alike, since reflexive structures of observation inevitably lead to the experience of contingency. For this reason, societies whose models of reality and culture programs are a permanent subject of discussion in complex media systems automatically develop media cul-
48
Siegfried J. Schmidt
tures marked by a high level of plurality and a low level of compulsion in traditional problem solutions. In light of these considerations, it becomes plausible that advertising in media culture societies had to generate modes of self-reference, too. In this paper, advertising is conceived of in terms of a social system which can be characterized as a subsystem of the economic system, which follows its own system specific logic. The advertising system sells creativity for money. It aims at arousing attention for its media supply which is then transferred to the goods, services, persons, and messages to which it seeks to draw attention. In order to arouse attention, advertising must permanently translate changing social events and developments into communication contents and forms, into pictures and stories which promise economic profit. Since advertising appears in public in the form of expensive media supply, it is necessarily related to three dimensions, viz., economy (money), creative processes of advertisers and their target audience, and communication processes initiated by advertising activities. These systematic interrelations need to be taken into consideration when we talk about the media supply of advertising, which is only the final result of these interrelations and does not simply speak for itself. Today, advertising is not only an important economic sector but an influential instrument of socialization since it forms an integral part of our daily life. In 2002, for example, 2.6 billion commercials were shown on German television; the print media are full of commercials; internet, radio, or city lights confront us with hundreds of ads every day and everywhere. Furthermore, due to the increasing commercialization of communication, advertising has become an important power of motivation in the dynamics of the media system.
2. The semiotics of self-reference Before turning to a description of self-referential modes in advertising, I would like to clarify my concept of semiotic self-reference. I advocate a processoriented three-digit concept of “sign” which systematically combines (1) semiotic material, (2) the use of such material in accordance with the rules of a given language, and (3) the result of these processes. Semiotic material consists of structurally organized condensations of social experiences which can trigger cognitive as well as communicative follow-up processes. The arbitrariness of such triggering is kept in check by the fact that language-users refer to collective knowledge about semiotic routines as an efficient operative fiction, that is to say collective knowledge which is regarded to be mutually shared by all members of a society.
Modes of self-reference in advertising
49
The use of semiotic material can be modeled as a context-bound process of referring to previous references or, in Charles S. Peirce’s phrase, as reference to previous experiences or cognition of the world. In using semiotic material, we refer to successful previous uses. In other words, we do not represent objects, events etc. but we refer to previous descriptions (of objects and events) we deem socially acceptable. Accordingly, these references mark a time difference between previous and actual descriptions, they occur in social contexts, and they necessarily rely upon collective cultural knowledge. In other words, signs do not present stable reference-relations, but are used by communicators in real situations to trigger follow-up operations in the cognitive or communicative domain of communication partners which happen according to the conditions of the respective systems. In and through using semiotic material subject-dependent cognitive processes are triggered. These processes result in self-referential constructions of ordered cognitive states that rely on culturally programmed knowledge about socially acceptable usages of the respective semiotic materials. That is to say, expected expectations or reflexive loops establish a socially successful relation between semiotic materials on the one hand and subjective cognitive operations on the other. Again – the point bears repeating – I do not model semiotic processes in terms of representations of items beyond language but in terms of references to previous references to cognitive processes and imputed collective knowledge. These considerations imply that self-referential operations presuppose second-order observation, the observation of one’s own or other people’s activities performed on a first-order level. This particular mode of observation is possible because of the time-difference between first-order and second-order operations, since the more or less automatic first-order processes have to be interrupted in order to impose on them various kinds of structures and postprocesses. In my view, this is the reason why semiotic self-reference and cognitive reflexivity both fall into the category of reflexive looping.
3. Modes of reference in advertising In accordance with its general aim – to produce maximum attention for the goods, services, messages and persons it advertises – the advertising system is distinguished by specific communication-processes or discourses; that is, by a specific macro-form of communication, which competes with other macro-forms of communication such as journalism, literature/art or public relations, each of which possesses a different mode of reference. Journalism, e.g., claims to re-
50
Siegfried J. Schmidt
fer to “the reality” in an objective, reliable and authentic way; literature claims to refer to a fictitious world according to aesthetic practices and expectations; and public relations claim to refer to wishful images of persons, institutions or firms which have been established by previous communications. Advertising, by contrast, refers neither to truth nor to objectivity but to brand values on the side of the consumers, hence to experiences, expectations, emotions, desires, needs etc. – and everybody in media culture societies can know that. Therefore, everybody is assumed to know that advertising does not and cannot lie, because everybody knows that ads are biased, one-sided and prejudiced in favor of the items advertised for. Ads have to touch people emotionally; they have to entertain. They tell what people want to believe and should believe in order to become happy. Fascination comes before semantic information. Accordingly, what matters in advertising communication is the meaning and importance of the promises ads make, not the truth of their messages. Social actors in the advertising system know that ads promise to solve insoluble problems here and now – you only have to believe their message and buy the product. In addition, advertising refers to collective knowledge in those domains which can be instrumentalized in ads: famous landscapes or buildings (the Riviera or the Eiffel Tower), stereotypes of professions or national characteristics (the doctor or the Frenchman) or well-known works of art (Michelangelo’s David or Leonardo’s Gioconda). Finally, advertising refers to collective knowledge about social practices regarding, for example, the interaction of genders and generations, the relevance of religious or political activities and the evaluation of the female and male bodies, of clothing, eating and drinking, of sports or trendy leisure-time activities. In sum, advertising selectively refers to collective mentalities, needs and desires of specific target groups.
4. Modes of self-reference in advertising Generally, it can be said that only owing to self-referential maneuvers of or in the advertising system we as the addressees of media supply are able to observe the advertising system at all. This general hypothesis will be explained in the following: (a) In his paper “Self-reference in the media: The semiotic framework”, Winfried N¨oth (this vol., I, 5.5) mentions self-referential practices in advertising which may be subsumed under the heading of intertextuality, such as citations, repetitions, recursions, or other kinds of reference to signs, texts, or other media.
Modes of self-reference in advertising
51
Such practices make use of what since the 1990s has been called recycling or sampling (Figure 1a/1b).
Figure 1a. Stiebel (1995)2
Figure 1b. Nirvana (1991) 3
In other words, media supply refers to media supply, and the efficiency of this strategy depends upon whether or not the addressees recognize the recycled components (Figure 2). According to N¨oth (this vol., I, 5.1), another type of self-reference in advertising is tautology or quasi-tautology. A good example is the famous German slogan for Persil washing powder, “Persil bleibt Persil” (Persil remains Persil; Figure 3).
52
Siegfried J. Schmidt
Figure 2. Die Marke [the brand]
This slogan claims that Persil will remain the same regardless of what will happen in the future. This promise tames the paradox that on the one hand, Henkel, the producer of the washing powder, will and has to develop the new Persil (“das neue Persil”) as soon as possible, which of course has to be so much better than the present one but which, on the other hand, will still remain Persil and nothing else. In other words, as long as Persil is available, it will be of outstanding quality – a quality nevertheless to be always improved. In addition to this tautology, another kind of self-reference can be observed in this example, viz., reflexive stabilization of ad communication. Guido Zurstiege (2003) has
Modes of self-reference in advertising
53
Figure 3. Persil remains Persil4
pointed out that the highly emotional relation between brands and consumers is based on trust. Persil campaigns are famous for their repetition of the same advertising pattern: my grandmother and mother, says the pretty young lady in the TV commercial, have successfully used Persil, so I will continue this successful tradition. The message is clear: Persil’s customer-brand relation is defined by continuity in trust on both sides – this is the aspect of redundancy. At the same time, this trust is a challenge to the producer to improve the quality of the product in order to ensure this confidence by a continuity of successful applications of this washing powder – this is the variety aspect. Continuity and variety are reconciled by the self-referentiality in Persil’s advertising throughout the decades. Another good example is the exact repetition of a TV spot presenting an Audi Quattro on a ski-jumping platform on occasion of the 25th birthday of this car (Figure 4).
54
Siegfried J. Schmidt
Figure 4. Audi Quattro
Modes of self-reference in advertising
55
A genuine example of self-reference is finally exposed by the following Coca-Cola ad (Figure 5).
Figure 5. A Coca- Cola neon sign
(b) In another perspective of self-reference, advertising refers to the advertising system. This strategy is realized in the following ways: – Advertising advertises for advertising. Every advertising media supply advertises for the advertising system as such and as a whole and in so doing inevitably generates a public discourse about the pros and cons of advertising: it generates the topic advertising, which then allows for or provokes either approval or rejection (Figure 6). – Advertising has become its own best client. Today, the advertising system invests more money in advertising than the automobile industry does. – Advertising becomes a topic in advertising media supply: the advertising system demands attention for itself, in most cases in an ironical or humorous way, playing with the collective knowledge of the public (Figure 7).
56
Siegfried J. Schmidt
Figure 6. Hingerichtet [executed]
Figure 7. Lucky Strike (left): “Advertising gives a completely wrong picture, doesn’t it? – Lucky Strike. Nothing else.”
(c) Advertising observes its own practices by means of advertising research carried out by the advertising agencies themselves; for example, through targetgroup research and research into the efficiency of campaigns or social trends. For example, the advertising agency Grey has established a large archive in which journals and ads of the last thirty years have been and are being collected. It has also founded the so-called “Grey Academy”, a department for strategic planning, and the “Magic Lab”, an institute for research in communication
Modes of self-reference in advertising
57
and its development. This kind of self-reference qua self-observation has to be distinguished from the external observation of the advertising system by other social systems including sociological research and communication studies. (d) Another type of self-reference occurs in self-descriptive statements by advertising agencies concerning their own visions, missions, and philosophies. As the following examples will show, such philosophies tend to be extremely poor. McCann-Erickson believes in “truth well told” and in “total communication”. Scholz & Friends answer the question how people can be fascinated “by ideas. But then, what is an idea? An idea is new”. The DDB-Group promises: “We believe that brilliant ideas can achieve extraordinary results.” Springer & Jacoby follow the strategy: “simple, imaginative, exact”, and so on. (e) Finally, in recent years more and more “stars” of the advertising system have published books with their ideas about best practices in advertising. The majority of these books can be characterized as how-to-do-it literature but some of the advertising stars have developed a specific kind of self-reflexion – one that looks at the advertising system in terms of its present internal and external problems, the relation to scientific disciplines, efficient problem solving strategies etc. Relevant examples include Jean Etienne Aebi’s, Einfall oder Abfall. Was Werber warum erfolgreich macht (2003) [Idea or trash. What makes advertisers successful and why], Wulf-Peter Kemper’s Brandholdervalue. Was Auftraggeber zu mehr Werbe- und Markenerfolg beitragen k¨onnen (2003) [Brand holder value. What customers can contribute to more success of advertising and brands]; and Holger Jung / Remy von Matt’s Momentum – die Kraft, die Werbung heute braucht (2002) [Momentum – The power advertising needs today].
5. Advertising as a mode of self-reference Until now the focus was on modes of self-reference in the advertising system. The final considerations will deal with the fact that the advertising system itself is the result of self-referential relations. The advertising system can be characterized as an instrument of observation and description; it is an instrument societies use for the purpose of selfobservation and self-description. Modern media culture societies can neither be observed nor described as a whole and from the outside, for every discourse is of necessity situated within this society; there is no social system which is not part of it. Self-reference therefore takes the form of partial observations and descriptions, which can be found in, among other things, academic disciplines,
58
Siegfried J. Schmidt
literature, and the advertising system. Advertising observes social phenomena according to the logic of the advertising system. That is to say, it observes both very precisely and very selectively. Observations have to be exact because only collective knowledge, mentalities of target groups, their needs, aims, and dreams can be detected and incorporated in ads, whose aim, after all, is to establish an emotionally persuasive connection between these components and the promoted item. Only in this way can advertising arouse attention for its message in the highly competitive media system. The selectivity of such observations has a double reason. On the one hand, only domains such as consumption, services, lifestyle, and taste are relevant to the advertising system in the economic respect which dominates its activities. On the other hand, as mentioned above, advertising exclusively tells positive stories about its promoted goods and services. Even Benetton’s advertising campaigns which focused on war, Aids, ecological pollution, and erotic relations between Catholic priests and nuns, turned out to be advertising for advertising. By breaking the iron rule of the advertising system – to exclude all negative components from the ads – and banning its products from these campaigns, it advertised for attention for advertising (Figure 8).
Figure 8. Benetton5
Modes of self-reference in advertising
59
In light of these considerations, it becomes clear that advertising cannot be a mirror of society, as has been assumed by many authors. Instead, I think it can be characterized as an indicator of those social phenomena which can be related to goods, services, messages, and persons for which advertising makes publicity. The advertising system may thus be regarded as an interface between the capitalist economy and the media or, as Michael Schudson (1984: 232) once said: “Advertising is capitalism’s way of saying ‘I love you’ to itself.” It provides the various groups of society with a self-observation of those needs which are deemed relevant by members of these target groups, and it publicly draws attention to the mechanisms of satisfying them. Advertising realizes a short circuit of needs and satisfactions. It promises to solve all problems by the mere consumption of goods and services. Thus, as Guido Zurstiege (2003: 77) has pointed out, the advertising of a society is at the same time advertising for a specific society.
6. Conclusion In this paper, I tried to describe different reflexive loops in advertising and in the relations between advertising and other social systems. It has become clear that advertising works primarily as an instrument of observation. The video artist Maciej Toprowicz has created a video in which he generates another interesting reflexive loop: he observes as an artist how advertising observes society, and confronts this type of affirmative observation with irritating similarities or contraries, irritatingly similar and dissimilar ways of acting and observing during the Nazi regime. Toprowicz deliberately counteracts the principles of the advertising system. In this way, he confronts us with what we see when we observe how advertising observes society.
Notes 1. By culture I understand the basic program for solving the essential problems of a society. 2. Figures 1a, 2, 4, 5, 6, and 7 are from the author’s files of print, TV, and outdoor advertisements. 3. Nirvana album cover “Nevermind” (1991). 4. See Wolfgang Feiter. 1997. 90 Jahre Persil. Die Geschichte einer Marke, 2nd ed. D¨usseldorf: Henkel, p. 49. 5. See Lorella Pagnucco Salvemini. 2002. Toscani. Die Werbekampagnen f¨ur Benetton 1984 – 2000. M¨unchen: Knesebeck, p. 104.
60
Siegfried J. Schmidt
References Schudson, Michael 1984 Advertising, the Uneasy Persuasion: Its Dubious Impact on American Society. New York: Basic Books. Zurstiege, Guido 2003 Zwischen Kritik und Faszination: was wir beobachten wenn wir die Werbung beobachten, wie sie die Werbung beobachtet. Cologne: Halem.
Metapictures and self-referential pictures Winfried N¨oth
1. Pictures, signs, absent, and present objects Pictures are signs which represent the visual or visually imaginable world. Since the cave paintings of the Stone Age, pictures have represented by similarity. A drawing of an elephant, a painting of a landscape, and a photograph of Sir Winston Churchill are pictorial signs which evince similarities to the objects they represent. Pictures which are similar to the object they represent are iconic signs. Language, by contrast, consists of mostly symbolic signs since words usually evince no similarity to their objects but must be associated with what they refer to by learning, habit, and convention (cf. Santaella and N¨oth 1998). Despite this essential difference between words and pictures, there are also fundamental similarities in their semiotic potential. Both words and pictures are signs which can evoke the image of, or refer to, absent objects. In his list of design features of language, Charles Hockett (1977) introduces the term displacement to describe the semiotic potential of language to refer to objects remote in time and space (cf. N¨oth 1990: 236). Derrida (1972: 9) discusses this feature as an aspect of the sign in general when he states: “A sign represents what is present in its absence.” However, the generalization that all signs refer to something absent cannot be sustained since signs can also refer to something that is present. Mirror images and shadows, in spite of Eco’s arguments to the contrary (Eco 1986), are indexical signs, images which indicate the presence of their object, and, as we will see below, self-referential signs are also signs which refer to their objects in their presence. Despite the potential of pictures to indicate objects in their absence or in their presence, it would be wrong to say that reference to, or representation of, objects is necessarily their primary function. For example, prehistoric rock art most probably served magical and ritual purposes and not representational ones (Anati 1994), and paintings of the more recent history of art are not art because of what they show (referential function) but for how they show (aesthetic function). Nevertheless, from the perspective of present day media culture, displacement
62
Winfried N¨oth
is certainly one of the most important features of pictures since it is evidently the prerequisite of global communication. Besides displacement, prevarication, the potential to deceive, is another semiotic feature which pictures have in common with language. Whereas displacement makes the representation of objects remote in time and place possible, prevarication serves the opposite purpose; a message which lies represents an object the temporal, local, or qualitative characteristics of which are not those which the sign indicates. Evidently, the feature of prevarication does not only enable language users and picture makers to lie but also to create illusions and fictions. The present paper is about another way in which a picture may be nonrepresentational; it deals with metapictures and self-referential pictures. Metapictures are pictures about pictures (Mitchell 1994: 35–82; Alessandria 1996). Instead of referring to the world of nonpictorial objects, they refer to other pictures. Self-referential pictures refer to themselves, that is, they have their object of reference inside and not outside their own pictorial frame. Self-reference is the opposite of alloreference or simply reference, in the sense which Derrida (1972: 9) has in mind when he writes about the absence of the object and how signs are traditionally defined as referring to, or standing for, something else, which is not the sign.
2. Pictures and metapictures Self-referential pictures are often metapictures, that is, pictures about pictures, but not all metapictures are self-referential. The two categories overlap, but the difference between them has often been ignored, for example by Mitchell (1994: 35) who defines “metapictures” as “pictures about pictures – that is, pictures that refer to themselves, pictures that are used to show what a picture is”. Let us try to distinguish between metapictures and self-referential pictures in analogy with the distinctions which linguistic terminology has established between metalanguage and self-referential language. The term metapicture is coined after the term metalanguage, which means language about language. Terms such as vowel, consonant, word, sentence, conjugation, or declension are metalinguistic words, verbal signs which refer to nothing but language. Metalanguage is the opposite of object language. Words that belong to object language are words that have their referents in the nonverbal world, for example, duck, love, or freedom. In analogy, the term metapicture should designate a picture about a picture or a picture of a picture. The term object picture may be useful to designate ordinary pictures which are not
Metapictures and self-referential pictures
63
metapictures, such as the picture of a flying duck or a running cheetah. Instead of object picture we may simply use the term picture whenever there it is no risk of confusion. Examples of metapictures are the following: (1) a picture of a room with a framed painting hanging on the wall (2) a picture “quoting” a famous painting in a new style, as in Duchamp’s transformed drawing of Leonardo’s Mona Lisa with the disrespectful legend “L.H.O.O.Q.” (3) a picture of a painter (not in a self-portrait) painting the portrait of a lady (4) a picture of a photographer (not in a self-portrait) taking photos (5) an ambiguous picture, such as the Necker cube (6) a picture of a room with a teichoscopic mirror, showing a scene from the otherwise invisible rear of this same room as in Brassa¨ı’s Au Bal-Musette of 1932 (cf. Machado 1994: 87) The criteria according to which these pictures are metapictures are the following: pictures (1) to (3) are pictures depicting another picture; picture (2) refers both to what and how the other picture represents; (3) is a pictures about painting pictures; (4) is not a picture of a picture but a picture about taking a picture; the difference between the metapictures of the kind (1) or (2) and (3) or (4) can be described with Mitchell (1994: 37) as the difference between showing showing and showing the shower; (5) is the case of pictures with two readings in conflict (rabbit or duck?; old woman or elegant lady? etc.; cf. Mitchell 1994: 47–57). Such pictures do not depict other pictures; they include a second picture as an alternative reading and thus create a visual dialogue between the two readings; Example (6) requires two additional comments. (a) Teichoscopic mirror is probably a new word coinage; teichoscopia is the ancient dramatic device of extending the limitations of the dramatic scenery visible to the audience by introducing a messenger who narrates what he, from his own privileged perspective (for example while standing on a wall), is discerning in the distance concealed to the audience. Analogously, a teichoscopic mirror is a mirror which extends the pictorial scenario by adding a view from an otherwise inaccessible perspective. (b) A mirror image is not usually considered to be a picture but it is not a “real-world” scene either; instead, it is the reflection of such a scene, and as such it is an indexical sign of such a field of vision which is not its own. Hence, a teichoscopic mirror is certainly a sign, and the picture of such a mirror (indeed of any mirror) is certainly a metasign. Let the depicted teichoscopic image thus be included in the category of metapictures even though, as mentioned above, a mirror image is not really a picture.
64
Winfried N¨oth
Most metasigns in the context of pictures are verbal messages, but these are not the topic of this paper (but see Mitchell 1994 on “talking metapictures”; Santaella and N¨oth 1999; N¨oth 2003b). Typical examples of how words function as signs about pictures are the title of a picture, the painter’s signature, the caption of a press photo, or the body copy of an advertisement.
3. Self-referential metapictures Let us now introduce the term self-referential metapicture for those metapictures which refer to themselves in a narrower sense. Such pictures are self-referential because they are representations representing their own representation, that is, they depict a picture of what they depict, how they depict, or under which circumstances they came to depict. Usually, a self-referential depiction is only a partial representation of the picture it represents. Examples are: (7) a picture mise en abyme, i. e., one which represents a scene which contains a picture of this scene (cf. Owens 1978; Conant 2005) (8) a picture of a painter “quoting” an earlier work by himself (9) a picture of a teichoscopic mirror reflecting its own mirror image from another mirror (10) a picture of a photographer taking his own picture in front of a mirror (11) a picture showing a lady looking into a mirror, which reflects her own mirror image (12) a drawing of a hand (Escher) or a man (Steinberg) that draws itself resp. himself In contrast to the pictures (1) to (6), pictures (7) to (12) do not depict other pictures, but themselves; (7) contains itself in a smaller picture; (8) depicts itself in a picture by its own painter; (9) is a self-reflected mirror image; (10) is a selfreferential “showing of the shower” of his own picture in contrast to (4) which was the showing of the shower of a different picture; (11) is self-referential under the condition that the portrait of the person appears twice in a similar view (and not, e. g., once in a frontal and once in a dorsal perspective; (12) is self-referential in a metaleptic way (see below): the picture includes its own representation which seems to be the product of its representation. The preliminary definitions of metapictures and self-referential metapictures may profit from the comparison with the distinctions between metalanguage, object language, and self-referential metalanguage drawn in linguistics. For example, of the metalinguistic terms vowel, syllable, word, sentence or text, only the term word is a self-referential metalinguistic term, since only word is a word
Metapictures and self-referential pictures
65
itself, whereas syllable is not one syllable but two, and the mere word text is not yet a text. At the syntactic level, an example of self-referential metalanguage in written English is: This senntence contains a mistake. It is not only an example of language about language (and hence metalanguage), but in addition, there is self-reference because the referent of the word senntence, namely a spelling mistake, is located within the very sentence that asserts the mistake it contains. By contrast, the sentence The preceding sentence contained a mistake is metalinguistic but not self-referential since it refers to a sentence other than itself. Metapictures thus give evidence of a semiotic feature which pictures have in common with language, the feature of reflexiveness, as Hockett (1977) calls it, that is, the potential of language to create its own metalanguage. However, there is an important difference between metapictures and metalanguage. While language has a particular class of signs which serve exclusively as verbal metasigns, pictures, with one exception, have no sign repertoire of pictorial metasigns. The exception is the picture frame, a topic to which we will turn below.
4. Iconic and indexical self-reference The vocabulary of metalanguage consists of symbolic signs; words such as “word”, “sentence”, or “preposition” are signs which designate by convention. Metapictures, by contrast, are essentially iconic; a picture can only depict another picture if it is similar to it. Self-reference, in language as well as in pictures, is iconic and indexical. The very term “self-reference” suggests both kinds of sign. While “reference” is essentially indexical, involving a mode of pointing (“referring”) from the sign to its object, self-reference, with its loop that suggests a return from the sign back to itself, implies iconicity; the sign that reappears in its own object is evidently an icon of itself. Despite this duality of all selfreferential signs, some are more iconic and others are more indexical. Let us examine more in detail the role of icons and indices first in self-referential language and then in pictures. The following words are iconically self-referential for different reasons: (13) (14) (15) (16) (17) (18)
cock-a-doodle-doo quick English longest black bold
66
Winfried N¨oth
All of these words evince some similarity to what they refer. Cock-a-doodledoo is a sound symbolic word; its acoustic form is similar to the acoustic event it refers to. (14) to (18) are words that evince the quality they refer to, either in its phonetic or in its written form. The word quick is itself quick in its pronunciation, consisting of a single syllable with a short vowel. The word English is selfreferential in a metalinguistic way, both in pronunciation and in spelling; it is not only a word of the English language that refers to itself (English is evidently an English word), but it also sounds English and is English in its spelling. The superlative form longest is relationally (that is, diagrammatically) iconic. In English, the word is not really very long (in contrast to its Portuguese translation long´ıssimo, a word with four syllables), but the superlative longest is longer than the base form long. The written word black is self-referential in any type that is not colored, and the word bold is self-referential whenever it is written in bold type. Examples of indexically self-referential expressions are: (19) (20) (21) (22) (23)
I, me, we here, in this city now, today, this month I promise, I accept, I bet, I ask you to I am coming; we are arriving
(19), (20), and (21) belong to the so-called autodeictic expressions (cf. Harweg 1990). Such expressions refer to the circumstances of a speech act. The first person pronouns I, me, we are indices referring to the speaker, expressions such as here, in this city refer to the place, and now, today, this month to the time of the utterance at the moment of its utterance. Other modes of indexical self-reference occur in illocutionary speech acts such as I promise. The very utterance of a promise constitutes the obligation to which the promise refers. Finally, the I who speaks in the continuous form, as in I am coming, does not only refer to something that is being done but also to the simultaneity of the discourse about what is being done. The mother who says I am coming is not only coming, she also says (self-referentially) that she is coming. (Does the son who says I am listening speak self-referentially? Can he listen while he is speaking?)
Metapictures and self-referential pictures
67
5. Iconically and indexically self-referential object pictures The criteria for distinguishing between iconic and indexical self-reference in language can serve to elucidate the nature of self-reference in pictures, in particular those which are not metapictures. Consider these examples of iconically self-referential object pictures: (24) (25) (26) (27)
a triangle in a geometry book a monochrome painting in red the picture of a symmetrical form, e.g., a butterfly a photograph of a photograph
A triangle in a geometry book does not only illustrate and hence represent the features of this geometrical figure; it is itself a triangle. For the same reason, a monochrome painting in red is self-referential; it represents a quality which it evinces itself, namely the quality of redness. Iconic self-reference is a characteristic of abstract art; deprived of the function of referring to something else, abstract paintings show only their own chromatic and geometrical qualities (cf. N¨oth 2003a, 2004, this vol., Part III). All symmetrical forms are self-referential; the symmetrically reflected form is an icon of the reflecting form, which repeats itself. A photograph of a photograph is self-referentially iconic to a lesser degree; the representing medium is the same as the represented medium. There is indexical self-reference in a picture whenever it indicates the circumstances under which it was produced (where, when, how). In one respect, pictorial self-reference is weaker than self-reference in spoken language. The I, the now, and the here of a pictorial enunciation are in the past and not in the immediacy of the present, as in spoken language. However, this is not a categorical difference between verbal and visual communication, since pictures share their remoteness from their origo, as Karl B¨uhler (1934) called it, with written texts. Analogies between pictorial and verbal indices of self-reference must therefore be drawn from written language, for instance, documents which indicate their authenticity and are authentic, the handwriting which identifies a writer and in a way constitutes partly the writer’s identity, narratives which indicate their narrator who would not exist without this narrative, street signs which indicate and are at the same time the name of a street. Let us consider along these lines the following examples of self-reference in pictures (which are not metapictures): (28) a self-portrait (29) van Gogh’s self-portrait (30) an original Rubens
68
Winfried N¨oth
(31) a Rococo scene painted by Watteau (32) my passport photo Any self-portrait is self-referential in the same way as any product is an index of its producer (28). A self-portrait “shows its shower” without being a metapicture about making pictures. In addition, van Gogh’s self-portrait (29) also “shows its showing” in a certain way; the portrait contains unmistakable indices of van Gogh’s way of painting; the picture indicates the painter and his style. The van Gogh self-portrait does not only depict van Gogh it is also a van Gogh (painting). An original style is always indexically self-referential; it identifies its own authenticity; the Rubens painting communicates “I am a Rubens” (30). In Watteau’s Rococo scene (31) there is a further index of selfreference. The Rococo painting depicting a scene with elegant ladies dressed in the fashion of the time of its being painted is not only a picture which depicts a Rococo scene; it is at the same time a Rococo picture. A passport photo (32) is in its origin simply an indexical picture like all photos are. However, when I use it to identify myself I use it in a self-referential way. I may say: this picture is a document of the light rays that once emanated from my body; hence it is an extension, maybe even part of, my body. In a self-referential loop, the picture which is in this sense part of my body refers back to the body from where it emanated. – Notice that from the opposite perspective, the one of the border official, my passport photo, may even constitute my identity: the picture is the legal document, and I should better look like my picture in the passport if I do not want to get into trouble. The border official who first looks at the photo and then at my face wants to check whether I, the person he looks at, am like (i.e., the icon of) the photo and whether I can prove the correspondence of my face with my photo. From this perspective, the passport photo is not self-referential at all. It is like an original (or even a piece of “reality”) of which I should be the picture and true copy. An indexical feature of pictorial self-reference which will be discussed in the next section is the frame. Is it a metasign or a self-referential metasign? The answer depends on whether the frame is considered as something that is part of the picture or whether it is considered as something external to the picture. In the first case, the frame is a self-referential metasign, in the second case it is a metasign, but not a self-referential one. The heading of the next section presupposes the first of the two ways of seeing a frame.
Metapictures and self-referential pictures
69
6. Frames: Self-referential pictorial metasigns Every picture contains a self-referential pictorial metasign in the form of its frame, which is an indexical sign conveying a metamessage such as: “I am a picture” (and not, for example, a landscape seen through a window). There is an analogy between this metasign at the root of pictorial representation and a metasign that can be found at the root of verbal communication. Verbal messages, too, convey a fundamental message identifying the situation as a communicative one. Austin (1962) called the speech act in which such signs are produced the locutionary act. Its message is more or less, “I am speaking.” Prieto (1966), with reference to signs in general, called it the semic act. Roughly, the semic act identifies a message as a message and states “I am a message.” There are two fundamental ways in which a picture can be said to be framed. The first is related to the space a picture takes up in a visual field. Let us call it the spatial frame. Its message is basically: “The space I delimitate is a picture.” The second is a frame in a metaphorical sense. It refers to the circumstances which make pictorial information a message emitted by an addresser and addressed to an addressee. In analogy to the terminology introduced by Christian Metz (1991) in the context of film studies, this kind of frame will be called enunciative frame. The frame which delimits the picture in a spatial sense is either a material or an immaterial frame. The material frame does not only delimitate, it also occupies a space itself, situated between the picture and its visual environment. It may be a wooden or metal frame enclosing its margins or a pane of glass covering its surface. In printed pictures, it is the white or colored margin between the picture and the edge of the page or a white margin that separates one picture from the next on the same page. The material frame marks the boundaries between the picture and the visual field in which it is inserted. In one way, the material picture frame is part of the picture since it marks the picture as an object of a certain value that deserves to be preserved, exhibited, sold, or possessed. In another way, the material frame is not part of the picture. For example, it can be exchanged for a new frame, and the picture will remain essentially the same. This ambiguity of the material frame, which seems to be part of the picture and not to be part of it at the same time, ceases to be one when a framed picture is depicted and thus transformed into a metapicture. As part of the metapicture, the painted frame is clearly an object picture of a material frame. The immaterial picture frame is the frame which every picture has, whether it is materially framed or not. It determines the limits of the space available for pictorial representation. Every picture has an immaterial frame even though this frame may be vague, blurred, or otherwise difficult to determine. Sometimes,
70
Winfried N¨oth
this frame is coextensive with the contours of a figure which emerges from a ground, for example, the figure of a political hero painted on a white wall. In this case, the contours of the figure constitute the immaterial picture frame; the ground of this picture is simply a painted wall and not a picture. Without an immaterial frame in the sense of a spatial delimitation of the picture, the picture would be coextensive with the visual universe and lose its character of being a picture. Even a picture cut out of a larger picture is immaterially framed. The enunciative picture frame identifies the addresser as a painter, a photographer, an advertising agency, an editor, or a publisher, and the viewer as an art connoisseur, a magazine reader, visitor of a museum, or as a consumer exposed to publicity. Perspective is a significant element of the enunciative picture frame. It shows whether the addresser took or painted the picture from below or from above, and it has to do with the addressee’s point of view in face of the picture. The theories of verbal and pictorial enunciation are closely related to the theory of narrativity with its search for narrative voices and their real or implied readers. Apart from its spatial frame, a pictorial message does not evince any other specific “segmental” sign repertoire to identify self-referential or metapictorial features of the picture. Unlike language, which has a rich vocabulary of metalinguistic terms and of deictic words to identify the addresser and the addressee in time and space, pictures are without a repertoire of metasigns, and indicators of self- or metapictorial reference must be inferred by the viewer from indirect evidence. Such inferences may be ambiguous or misleading, and the play with such ambiguities has been much used to create paradoxical pictures, for example, pictures depicting windows that look like painted on the wall or the opposite, pictures depicting pictures that look like windows with the landscape seen through them. We will return to such ambiguities between pictures and metapictures or between pictures and self-referential pictures below, after a brief exemplification of the analytical categories discussed so far.
7. Three cheetahs or one? Let us examine more in detail the features of metapictures and self-referential pictures in the pictorial message of the upper half of an advertisement for the Brazilian internet provider terra (Figure 1). While the lower part of this advertisement contains a verbal message with information about the services of this company, the upper half shows the picture of a cheetah. The only connection between both is the quality of rapidity which is ascribed explicitly to the internet services offered by the provider and implicitly or by presupposition to the
Metapictures and self-referential pictures
71
Figure 1. A metapicture about the picture of a cheetah1
cheetah that is shown running at a high speed. The discrepancy between the semantic fields of animal nature and high technology leads the reader to the conclusion that the cheetah must be interpreted as a visual metaphor of rapidity. No other connection between the technology provider and the world’s fastest land animal seems plausible. As a visual metaphor, the picture of the cheetah
72
Winfried N¨oth
is a metapicture, a picture that serves to illustrate something else, namely the idea of rapidity. In this respect, the cheetah picture is an alloreferential and not a self-referential metapicture. The pictorial message of this advertisement shows a stack of three overlapping pictures, each of them representing a cheetah. The picture on top is an incomplete instantaneous photo of a cheetah, taken in a shot whose focus cut off the cheetah’s head and tail on its right and left margins. Below, the other two pictures supplement the missing parts with their overlap, in a way that the missing head and tail of the first photo are complemented to result in a complete picture of the cheetah. The second picture in the stack is a charcoal drawing of a cheetah of the same size of which we only see the tail while its trunk is apparently hidden below the first photo which covers it partially. The picture below the first two pictures is an oil painting of a cheetah with the painter’s signature at the bottom right; it serves to supplement the head missing in the instantaneous photograph, while its rest is covered by the two other overlapping pictures. The visual message of this advertisement can be read in two ways. It can either be viewed as a picture of three pictures, or it can be interpreted as one picture made up of three partial representations of a cheetah. Read as a picture of three pictures, the message is interpreted as a metapicture in which each single picture contains a message concerning the two other pictures. For example: (1) the three cheetah pictures complement each other from the left to the right; (2) the first cheetah picture is on top, the second between, and the third is below two other pictures; (3) the third protrudes to the right, the second to the left, etc. Read as one (patchwork) picture of a cheetah, the pictorial message is viewed as a self-referential metapicture in two major respects. First, it is a picture about taking pictures. It shows what happens when the photographer fails in selecting the proper focus; it shows some of the specific differences between the three pictorial genres of color photography, black-and-white charcoal drawing, and oil painting; it shows three kinds of framing, framing by a white margin, by an immaterial frame, and by a wooden frame; it creates the mental image of three complete pictures of the same size, each of which are iconic signs one of the other, etc. Secondly, the photo on the top of the stack is self-referential in quite a different way. It is an instant photo, which means, a rapidly produced one. Furthermore, it was apparently taken too rapidly so that the result was unfortunately an incomplete picture. The rapidity of picture taking inscribed in the photograph with these faults is an image of the rapidity of the cheetah in fast motion. The picture that depicts rapidity in a metaphorical way evinces itself the feature of rapidity, and in this sense it is a self-referential picture.
Metapictures and self-referential pictures
73
Of the three pictures, the instant photo and the oil painting are clearly marked by a material frame which is a white margin in the case of the photo and a wooden frame in the case of the painting. The charcoal drawing, by contrast, has only its immaterial frame, which is the edge of the white paper. In addition, the first and the second frames on the stack are marked by a shadow indicating the direction of their illumination, which comes from the top left. The enunciative frames indicate the first pictorial addresser as a photographer, the second as a draftsperson and the third as a painter. Considered as one picture, the addresser is the designer of the advertisement who integrated the three messages into one; it is the advertising agency addressing among others those by whom they were contracted; it is the internet provider addressing its potential clients, etc.
8. Illusionist and deceptive enunciative frames Let us now return to the enunciative picture frames and examine some examples that may better exemplify their relevance than the previous example in which its description lead to a somewhat obvious result. The relevance of these frames is most apparent when there is some kind of ambiguity with respect to the enunciative situation of the picture, an uncertainty as to its addresser, its addressees, or even its being a picture at all. Four examples will serve to illustrate such ambiguities, (1) photorealist paintings, (2) pictorial fakes, (3) Parrhasios’s super-illusionist curtain, and (4) Magritte’s anti-illusionist pipe. Photorealism. Can a picture also be a total self-representation, in which the representing picture is coextensive with the represented one? It seems as if it is impossible for a picture to be self-referential in its totality. Such a picture would be self-referential of itself, and how can we distinguish between the represented and the representing picture if both are coextensive? Nevertheless, approximations to the borderline case of total pictorial self-representation seem to exist. Consider a photo-realistic painting. Such a painting creates the illusion of being a photograph, but it pretends at the same time to be nothing but a painting. Being a complete picture of a picture, the photorealist painting is a metapicture as any copy is, but it is also self-referential. It is a picture which refers to two kinds of pictures at the same time which do not really exist as two separate objects. Many photorealist paintings are not even copies of existing photos, and even if they are, their reference to the photo of which it is a copy is quite marginal. Since the reference to the photo is only a mental one, the depicting and the depicted picture can be said to be co-extensive.
74
Winfried N¨oth
Fakes. Copies and fakes are metapictures when it is known they are not the original. Both are pictures representing other pictures as faithfully as possible, but as long as they do not conceal what they are, their metapictorial designation as copy and fake emphasizes the difference between the representing and the represented picture. A copy so to speak conveys the message “I am not the original”. It thus refers to and at the same time emphasizes its difference from the original. With this distancing, the copy declares itself to be an alloreferential metapicture. The same holds true for the fake which is known to be a fake. A fake that is taken to be an original, by contrast, is viewed as an original, it is not a metapicture. Parrhasios’s superillusive curtain. In language, the enunciative frame is mostly a matter of who is speaking; rarely does the question arise whether someone is speaking at all. Situations are rare in which a speaker needs to signalize that he or she is speaking and not, for example, breathing, listening, watching, eating, or singing. While the question Do you hear me? is not unusual in everyday conversation, a situation is hard to imagine where one would have to ask a question such as: Are you speaking? Speech sounds do not compete with as many acoustic signals emitted in the environment of a speaker. Pictures, by contrast, are much more immersed in a visual field of competing nonpictorial signs, and it is no coincidence that the question “picture or not?” asked in the context of the visual arts as “art or not?” has been one of the great topics of the visual arts since Dada. This is why pictures seem to be much more in need of an analogously fundamental self-referential message of the kind “I am a picture”. The question was already raised in Greek mythology. Pliny tells the legend of two painters, Zeuxis and Parrhasios, who competed for a prize for the best painting (Nat. hist. xxxv: 65). Zeuxis exposed a picture of grapes painted so well that the birds approached to pick them. Proud of having deceived the birds to take his picture for real, Zeuxis turned to his competitor and asked him to remove the curtain which concealed his competitor’s picture. Parrhasios was triumphant. The curtain was merely painted, and his work of art had not merely deceived birds but even his fellow painter, who took a painted for a real curtain. The legend is about the art deceiving by means of pictures (cf. Moeller 2003). Both painters succeed in hiding the basic self-referential message by which their paintings convey the message: “I am a picture.”
Metapictures and self-referential pictures
75
Magritte’s anti-illusionist pipe. Magritte took the opposite road in questioning the enunciative frame message. In his famous picture of a pipe with the seemingly contradictory verbal legend Ceci n’est pas une pipe, his strategy was to destroy the pictorial super-illusionism a` la Parrhasios. Read as a comment on the enunciative picture frame, there is no contradiction at all in his verbal metamessage about the picture: the represented object must indeed not be confounded with the representing picture.
9. Verbal paradoxes and metaleptic self-reference in pictures Self-reference is one of the sources of paradox in language. Consider Epimenides, the Cretan, who says: All Cretans are liars. The utterance creates the famous paradox according to which Epimenides either says the truth and thus falsifies the statement that all Cretans lie, since at least one Cretan is speaking the truth, or he lies, like all other Cretans, but then his proposition would negate itself and mean: “It is a lie that all Cretans are liars”, which by double negation would mean the opposite, namely that no Cretan lies. The source of this paradox is in its self-referential nature: the speaker’s utterance refers to the speaker’s speech act, but the semantic level of the proposition enters into a conflict with the pragmatic level of what the speaker utters and the scope of what he refers to, which is partly what others say, partly what he himself says. The Epimenides paradox exemplifies a mode of verbal self-reference which is not metalinguistic in the narrower sense since the Cretan says nothing about phonemes, words or sentences nor does he say anything about the Greek or the Latin languages. It is true that the concept of metalanguage is occasionally also extended to a broader sense which includes also self-referential speech acts such as the one of Epimenides, and in this broader sense, one could argue that the Epimenides paradox is also a metalinguistic one. However, there is an important difference between metalanguage in the narrower sense and metalanguage in such a broader sense. While metalinguistic terms such as “word” or “sentence” always explicitly refer to language, the Epimenides paradox is only implicitly self-referential. The source of the verbal self-reference is in the unexpressed illocutionary act which can be made explicit in the form of the metalinguistic paraphrase: “I, the Cretan, say that all Cretans say untrue things.” There is a well-known parallel between Epimendes’s paradox and pictorial representation: Escher’s hand that draws itself. The kind of self-reference we are confronted with in this picture is metaleptic self-reference (cf. Ryan 2004). Metalepsis, a concept borrowed from rhetoric, is a narrative device by which a narrator begins to participate in the life of the fictitious persons who are nothing
76
Winfried N¨oth
but his or her own creation, or vice versa, in which the characters of the author’s own narrative creation begin to enter into a dialogue with the author (as in Pirandello’s Six Characters in Search of an Author). The self-referential nature of narrative metalepsis has its explanation in the enunciative frame: the addresser turns into a self-addressed addressee. The metaleptic element in the picture of the hand that is drawing itself consists in the transformation of the drawn hand into a drawing hand. Escher’s message seems to convey this paradoxical message: “I, the draftsman’s hand am drawing a hand that draws itself.” The device of pictorial metalepsis enjoys some popularity in the genre of the cartoons where figures of animals or humans occasionally begin to change their appearance because the drawn figure begins to change its own drawing by adding, deleting or changing the lines and shapes of its own drawing.
10. Conclusion and prospects The differences and overlaps between metapictures and self-referential pictures were the topic of this paper. Despite the many distinctions set up in this study, it remains to be pointed out there are still other forms of pictorial self-reference which deserve to be discriminated (cf. N¨oth, this vol., Part II). Furthermore, the study of the categories established in this paper may reveal the necessity of admitting gradual transitions between metapictures, self-referential pictures, and self-referential metapictures. From a more general semiotic perspective, it may be even true that all metapictures evince some kind of self-reference and that all self-referential pictures may, in a way, be metapictures. After all, metapictures are pictures of pictures, which suggests a certain self-referential loop. Both metapictures and self-referential pictures invite reflections on the nature of pictorial representation. However, the very general common denominators of metapictures and self-referential pictures do not invalidate the more subtle distinctions that can and should be drawn between them.
Note 1. See Veja 38.33 [Aug 17], 2005, p. 140.
Metapictures and self-referential pictures
77
References Alessandria, Jorge 1996 Imagen y metaimagen. Buenos Aires: Universidad, Faculdad de Filosofia y Letras Anati, Emmanuel 1994 Constants in 40,000 years of art. In: Winfried N¨oth (ed.), Semiotics of the Media, 385–403. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter. Austin, John L. 1962 How to Do Things with Words. Oxford: University Press. B¨uhler, Karl [1934] 1978 Sprachtheorie. Frankfurt: Ullstein. Conant, Chlo´e 2005 Mise en abyme / mirror text. Dictionnaire international des termes litt´eraires. http://www.ditl.info/arttest/art2025.php (18.05.06). Derrida, Jacques 1972 Marges de la philosophie. Paris: Minuit. Eco, Umberto 1986 Mirrors. In: Paul Bouissac, Michael Herzfeld and Roland Posner (eds.), Iconicity: Essays on the Nature of Culture, 215–237. T¨ubingen: Stauffenburg. Harweg, Roland 1990 Studien zur Deixis. Bochum: Brockmeyer. Hockett, Charles 1977 The View from Language. Athens: University of Georgia Press. Machado, Arlindo 1984 A ilus˜ao especular. S˜ao Paulo: Brasiliense. Metz, Christian 1991 L’´enonciation impersonnelle ou le site du film. Paris: Klincksieck. Mitchell, W. J. Thomas 1994 Picture Theory. Chicago: University Press. Moeller, Hans-Georg 2003 Before and after representation. Semiotica 143: 69–78. N¨oth, Winfried 1990 Handbook of Semiotics. Bloomington: Indiana University Press. 2003a Photography between reference and self-reference – Fotografie zwischen Fremdreferenz und Selbstreferenz. In: Ruth Horak (ed.), Rethinking Photography I+II: Narration and New Reduction in Photography – Narration und neue Reduktion in der Fotografie, 22–39. Salzburg: Fotohof Edition.
78
Winfried N¨oth
2003b
Press photos and their captions. In: Harry L¨onnroth (ed.), Fr˚an N¨arpesdialekt till EU-Svenska: Festskrift till Kristina Nikula, 169–188. Tampere: University Press. 2004 Semiotic foundations of the study of pictures. ημειωτ ικ η: ´ Sign Systems Studies 31(2): 377–392. N¨oth, Winfried and Christina Ljungberg (eds.) 2003 The Crisis of Representation: Semiotic Foundations and Manifestations in Culture and the Media. (= Special Issue of Semiotica 143.1–4). Owens, Craig 1978 Photography en abyme. October 5: 73–88. Prieto, Luis J. 1966 Messages et signaux. Paris: Presses Universitaires de France. Ryan, Marie-Laure 2004 Metaleptic machines. Semiotica 150: 439–469. Santaella, Lucia and Winfried N¨oth 1998 Imagem: Cogni¸cao, ˜ semi´otica, m´ıdia. S˜ao Paulo: Iluminuras. Trad. Roque Graciano. 2003. Imagen: Comunicaci´on, semi´otica y medios. Kassel: Reichenberger.
“Absolut Anonymous”: Self-reference in opaque advertising Nina Bishara
1. Referential and self-referential advertising According to the old AIDA-formula of marketing strategists, advertising aims at attracting attention, raising interest, creating desire, and initiating action. With these goals, advertising is a means to an end but never an end in itself. The means begin with attracting attention for a message which praises available goods or services for their alleged positive qualities. The end of “getting action” is to create consumption and profit. Both means and ends testify to the referential nature of advertising. Advertising wants to convey a message about something. As soon as we discover that we are confronted with an advertisement, we know that we are faced with a referential, or, more precisely, alloreferential message – a message referring to a segment of the market. Self-referential advertising, that is, advertising that refers to itself instead of referring to products and services, creates a paradox: since a self-referential message is one that refers to nothing but itself, how can such a message be about goods and services, and how can it result in economic action? Can such a message be an advertisement at all?
2. Opaque advertising as a form of self-reference The topic of this paper is opaque advertising, i.e., advertising in which the product or service, the trademark, the advertiser and the advertising message itself are disguised and can only be discovered through a special effort of advertisingliterate interpreters. Depending on the degree of the interpreters’ advertising literacy, such ads may trigger incomplete processes of semiosis as defined by Peirce: they may fail to result in the triadic process in which a sign, determined
80
Nina Bishara
by its object, generates an interpretant. The object by which the advertisement is determined may remain opaque, without any indices, except for those which point back to the message itself. The object of the sign which pretends to advertise remains enigmatic, and the interpretant incomplete. The enigma, as will be argued, does not so much concern the identification of the text genre itself since formal indicators such as placement, layout, typography, and other graphic devices clearly distinguish the advertisement from its surrounding messages and so announce, in a first step towards semiosis, that “this is advertising”. However, in interpreting what has been identified as an advertisement, the readers may not be able to identify the real object of the advertising message without investing more time and effort in decoding it. The semiotic framework of this paper is Charles S. Peirce’s triadic sign model. What other semiotician’s have called reference is the relationship between the sign and its object, according to Peirce, while self-reference means that the sign refers to itself, instead of to an object which is elsewhere. Peirce distinguishes two kinds of objects, the immediate and the dynamical object, and he further differentiates three kinds of interpretants: the immediate, dynamical, and the final interpretant.
3. Semiotic premises “Nothing is a sign unless it is interpreted as a sign” (CP 2.308). With these words, Charles S. Peirce describes the pragmatic and functional character of the sign process. A sign can be described as a mediator between an object and a mind. In advertising, this process, called semiosis, occurs as follows: potential customers must become aware of the advertisement (the sign) whose object is a product, a service, a market, a company, etc. The consumers’ minds must be affected by the message about the object and perhaps become motivated to buy or consume the product promoted by the advertisement. These are results of the sign which constitute its interpretant. The semiotic and economic process cannot be triggered if the potential consumers are unable to interpret the message successfully. According to Peirce, any process of semiosis involves the three universal categories of firstness, secondness, and thirdness. Firstness refers to the mere “suchness” of still undifferentiated and independent possibilities and qualities. It is a mode of being without reference to anything else. An advertising message perceived in its mere firstness would not yet be a message at all since its verbal and pictorial elements would be perceived without being related to anything else. At the level of secondness, a first is related to a second. The first is the adver-
“Absolut Anonymous”: Self-reference in opaque advertising
81
tisement, the second the product, the service, etc. Secondness predominates in indexical advertising which points to the existence of the product or commodity and appeals to its purchase. Thirdness presupposes firstness and secondness; it is the category of mediation (between a first and a second), of meaning, expectation, and habit. In advertising, it is the phase of familiarity with the message and with the product. Thirdness is fully developed in an advertisement when it is anchored in memory and habit. For Peirce, signs constitute a triadic relation of a signifier, a thing signified, and an interpretant created in the mind of an interpreter. According to one of his most frequently cited definitions: A sign, or representamen, is something which stands to somebody for something in some respect or capacity. It addresses somebody, that is, creates in the mind of that person an equivalent sign, or perhaps a more developed sign. That sign which it creates I call the interpretant of the first sign. The sign stands for something, its object. It stands for that object, not in all respects, but in reference to a sort of idea. (CP 2.228)
Applied to advertising, these three correlates of the sign are the sign, the object, and the interpretant. The sign (or “representamen”) is the advertising text as such, for example, a magazine advertisement or a TV commercial; elsewhere, Peirce calls it the “perceptible object” (CP 2.230) which functions as a sign. The object of the sign is essentially the product, the service, the “corporate image” of a company or an ideology which the advertisement conveys in its message. However, the sign cannot establish the recognition of the object by itself; it rather presupposes the acquaintance with its object. In semiosis, the object thus actually precedes the sign. Furthermore, Peirce distinguishes two kinds of objects, the immediate and the dynamical object: We have to distinguish the Immediate Object, which is the Object as the Sign itself represents it, and whose Being is thus dependent upon the Representation of it in the Sign, from the Dynamical Object, which is the Reality which by some means contrives to determine the Sign to its Representation. (CP 4.536)
The immediate object is the object as it is represented by the sign whereas the dynamical object is in a way the reality from which the sign originates. However, the latter is inaccessible; it can only be indicated by the sign and requires for its recognition the interpreter’s “collateral experience” of this object (CP 8.314). According to Peirce, “no sign can be fully understood – unless the interpreter has ‘collateral acquaintance’ with every Object of it” (CP 8.183). This knowledge of the dynamical object, or, in Peirce’s terms: its reality is one
82
Nina Bishara
which can only be apprehended by approximation. In their unlimited scientific research, scholars may approach the dynamical objects of the signs more and more.1 If, in advertising, the immediate object is that commodity or service as represented by the advertisement, then the dynamical object includes all the economic forces of the market, the most detailed product information, price regulations and mechanisms etc. – intricacies of which even economists or market researchers are never fully aware. The ideas, thoughts, conclusions, impressions, and actions created or triggered by the advertising text in the mind of an interpreter constitute its interpretant, which can in its turn become a new sign in the unlimited process of semiosis (CP 2.303). The interpretant of a sign is a sign itself. When the sign evokes an idea, for example, the interpretant is a mental sign, when it evokes a question or a reply, it is a verbal sign, and when it evokes an action, the interpretant is a nonverbal sign. Each sign thus becomes a new sign in an unlimited process of semiosis (CP 2.303). Peirce differentiates three types of interpretants: the immediate, the dynamical, and the final interpretant (CP 8.315).2 The immediate interpretant is any impression or feeling that may be produced by the quality of a sign (e.g., the color design of or the music in an advertisement). It is the first effect a sign produces but not yet any concrete reaction or direct effect produced by a sign, the latter being the dynamical interpretant, for example, to comply to the appeal “Come in and find out”, as the slogan of a perfumery demands. Among the effects of the dynamical interpretant are mental agitation and physical action, the consumer’s curiosity and his movement towards a shelf
Figure 1. The sign in advertising in a Peircean perspective
“Absolut Anonymous”: Self-reference in opaque advertising
83
in supermarket in order to buy a product. The logical interpretant is determined by law or habit. In science, it is the final result of research for which truth and consensus can (ideally) be claimed (e.g., a dictionary definition of a word). In advertising, it is the consumers’ habit to consume what the advertisement recommended. Figure 1 represents the three correlates of Peirce’s sign model as applied to the genre of advertising.
4. Exemplifications The following examples of opaque advertising show how the object and the interpretant of the advertising message are not immediately apparent. Readers may even fail to be affected by the object and so create an interpretant unrelated to it when attempting to decode the advertisement. The semiotic process in opaque advertising may result in confusion, puzzlement, and astonishment since the sign seems to represent nothing at all. The sign does not fulfill its straightforward function of representing its object; instead, it refers back to the advertisement itself, thus coming close to being self-referential. Figure 2 shows an example of an (initially) self-referential advertisement in the form of a pictorial riddle. Whereas the text can clearly be identified as an
Figure 2. McDonald’s company logo in disguise3
84
Nina Bishara
advertisement due to the contextual frame (here: a page in a magazine that is markedly different from the surrounding editorial texts), the product advertised for and the sender of the message remain opaque to the average recipient due to the apparent lack of verbal or pictorial cues. The immediate object of this message is an indefinable red background with a green sign depicting three white pictograms: the one of a running man, of an arrow pointing to the right and of an image resembling two arches or the capital letter “M”. From their world knowledge, “collateral experience”, as Peirce would call it, the readers may identify the green sign with the white pictograms as an emergency exit sign – this format being the international convention for emergency exit signs – and so may translate the pictograms to indicate one of the following messages as its interpretant: “In case of an emergency run in the direction of (a) . . . two arches (unspecified) / (b) . . . a meeting point (unspecified) / (c) . . . ‘M’ (unspecified).” It remains open in where one should run to in case of emergency. The reader can therefore conclude that the solution to the riddle lies in the identification of the unspecified destination. Recipients familiar with the advertising world and the world of company logos, that is, consumers for whom a prior “collateral acquaintance” of the object can be presupposed, will decipher the two arches as a stylized letter “M”, the symbol for the fast-food chain McDonalds which is usually yellow against a red background. By change of color, the advertisers have simulated an object of the sign which is difficult to access and they have created an interpretant which will mislead its readers for a while. Those recipients who succeed in recognizing the company logo will create an interpretant which relates it to their experience of those places in which they became acquainted with the fast-food company and its services, thus reversing the initial self-reference into reference to the world of McDonalds. Their prior acquaintance with the company logo has made its re-cognition possible. To those who recognize McDonalds’s message, the immediate object, the object as the sign represents it, is closer to the dynamical object of this message. Those who are misled – either because they fail to recognize the disguised company logo or simply because they are not acquainted with it as an established symbol – remain unaffected by this dynamical object. They must fail to recognize the logo for lack of sufficient “collateral experience” with it and can take the advertising message only as an incomplete rhematic sign whose message remains open. Their interpretation is restricted to the level of an immediate interpretant creating feelings of confusion, surprise, or lack of relatedness to anything. Figure 3 shows an advertisement that deliberately masks the identity of the product which it promotes by concealing the product name which is completely blurred on the label of the depicted bottle. Hence, the slogan beneath the picture of the bottle is nothing but redundant since it only repeats what we have already
“Absolut Anonymous”: Self-reference in opaque advertising
85
Figure 3. An opaque product name (Absolut Vodka)4
concluded from the blurred label: this message is “absolut(ely) anonymous”.The object represented in the sign remains enigmatic. Although the advertisement succeeds in attracting the viewers’ attention and maybe even in raising their interest, desire and action cannot be elicited as long as the identity of the product remains opaque and the advertisement only refers to itself.5 To avoid the complete failure of the message, the advertisement contains some clues which can help to decode its message. A first clue is provided by the slogan “absolut anonymous” which strikes its readers as grammatically incorrect and which should read “absolutely anonymous” since the word preceding “anonymous” should be an adverb (even in the form of an adjective it should be spelled “absolute”). The word “absolut” evinces a grammatical mistake which serves to attract the attention of its readers to this slogan. These might recall the name of the Swedish vodka called Absolut, and this piece of previous knowledge (“collateral experience”) allows a better interpretation of the advertisement. Those readers, however, who are unfamiliar with the brand name Absolut still face the riddle of a self-referential message. However, if they pay attention to the
86
Nina Bishara
small print text on the label of the bottle, they will also succeed in identifying the product. This text informs them that the bottle depicted in the advertisement contains liquor (“40% vol.”), specifically “superb vodka” that “has been sold under the name Absolut since 1879”. For readers who do not participate in the search for the object, the message remains self-referential and lacks any indices that point to something other than itself.
Figure 4. An opaque brand (Volkswagen New Beetle) (bottom left reads: “Seen at the mall”, bottom right reads: “Drivers wanted – VW”)6
Verbal anchorage plays an important role in the advertisement depicted in Figure 4. At first sight, the advertisement seems to follow traditional advertising strategies. It shows a picture, albeit not exactly an attractive one, a company logo (VW), and an appeal in the form of the slogan “Drivers wanted” (bottom right). Consumers can quickly deduce that this is an advertisement for Volkswagen automobiles. The message fulfils the complete triad of a sign (the advertisement itself), its object (VW automobiles, available for purchase) and the interpretant (consumers eager to purchase VW cars and convinced of their unquestionable quality). A legend in the lower left-hand corner of the advertisement, however, gives rise to confusion. Its elliptical message is: “seen at the mall.” The statement arouses the readers’ curiosity: what was seen at the mall? The text can only refer to the picture depicting a tiled floor with some cracks in it and a shopping bag in
“Absolut Anonymous”: Self-reference in opaque advertising
87
its right-hand corner. There is no apparent relationship between this picture and VW automobiles. Nevertheless, the legend asserts that there is something to be discovered in the picture. At a closer look, the object of this pictorial message can be identified: one dent in the tiled floor is especially prominent; it has the shape of a Volkswagen Beetle. As in the other cases of opaque referents discussed so far, the dynamical object of the sign which seemed to be invisible was indeed present all the time. However, the identification of this cryptic object of the message does not only require the readers’ efforts to decode the advertisement. It is also necessary to bring in knowledge about the world of products, markets, and advertisements. Such knowledge necessarily precedes the sign and is determined by its dynamical object. In the VW example, consumers must be familiar with the form of the legendary Beetle car in order to solve the riddle. Readers who do not recognize the shape of this car will still be able to extract a very general message, namely that this is an advertisement for VW automobiles, but they would not grasp its additional ludic value. In other words, the self-referential feature of this advertisement is rooted in the legend and its comment on the picture “seen at the mall”. This comment remains enigmatic and self-referential as long as readers cannot identify the object that leaves its trace in the picture “seen at the mall”. Let us consider one last example. In the summer of 2000, a new energy provider on the German market began to make future customers aware of its existence by launching a campaign that attracted everybody’s attention. The campaign consisted of print advertisements, billboards, and TV commercials, all of which showed nothing but the color red, i.e., there was a completely red page in a magazine, a red poster, or, for a few seconds, there was nothing but red as a commercial on TV. As the name of the energy provider was not included in the campaign and since the unidentified company was absolutely new to the market, nobody could draw upon any prior knowledge about the firm and its advertising strategies. The consumers were faced with an utterly enigmatic and nothing but self-referential advertising message. Not a single clue as to the meaning, sender, or intention of the advertisement was provided on the red surface. Nevertheless, extratextual markers clearly identified the messages as advertisements: on TV, the red surface appeared during the commercial break; in news magazines, the headline “Advertising” distinguished the red page from its surrounding editorial texts, and posters were placarded on the appropriate hoardings for outdoor advertising. The mere presentation of the color red without reference to anything particular in space or time leaves the advertising message open to and indefinite number of interpretations. The message is a rhematic qualisign, characterized twice as a sign of firstness and mere suchness. A sign of this kind that remains
88
Nina Bishara
without reference to anything else is self-referential in every respect. No object relation (secondness) can be established and no triadic process of semiosis can take place. Although consumers may identify the color red as the symbol of love, danger, or of the political parties of the left, there are no signs in this advertisement that indicate and support any interpretation of this kind. Reference to the tradition of monochrome painting, e.g., Monochrome Crimson by Claude Tousignant (1981), does not lead to any solution of this opaque message either. The consumers are confronted with a genuine riddle which, in contrast to the above examples, does not entail any stylistic or formal indices conducing to a meaningful advertising message. The object of the message must remain enigmatic, although there might be some kind of secondness in it based on the color red, e.g. attention, compulsion to act (red traffic light), etc. Figure 5 illustrates this with reference to Peirce’s categories of the object and interpretant.
Figure 5. Opaque object and enigmatic interpretant in a self-referential advertisement
What is the aim of such an advertisement? It certainly attracts attention by violating the conventional means of advertising. It also requires a follow-up campaign that offers a solution to the riddle. A few weeks upon appearance of the red-color-campaign, the red surface was complemented by the company name E.ON and the motto “Neue Energie” (‘new energy’). As the energy provider E.ON was new to the market, the advertisers wanted to achieve public awareness of the new company and to ensure future associations of the color red with E.ON. The company’s homepage commented on its advertising strategy as follows:
“Absolut Anonymous”: Self-reference in opaque advertising
89
“Germany literally saw red. After the company color was acquired, the secret was disclosed”.7 Red became a part of the company’s corporate identity and is still dominant in its advertising campaigns.
5. Riddles and opaque advertising The examples of opaque advertising discussed so far were all classified as enigmatic. Research in riddles has distinguished between true and false riddles such as joking or wisdom questions (Abrahams and Dundes 1973). The latter, although enigmatic, cannot be answered from the content presented in the question, the solution to joking questions being entirely arbitrary8 and the answer to wisdom questions depending on the riddlees’ general knowledge.9 True riddles, by contrast, although also designed for the purpose of confusion, are questions with descriptions or cues that allow the referent to be guessed. Riddles are required to use their wits and to interpret or “read” the signs correctly in order to arrive at the proper solution.10 Enigmatic advertisements which leave the object of their message opaque are like true riddles. A completely enigmatic advertisement incapable of conveying a message about its object must necessarily be unsuccessful. Advertisers cannot afford the risk of empty messages. They must incorporate reliable clues to help the consumers in the decoding of their messages. The consumers should get the message and are indeed prepared for it. After all, they have a clear notion of the aims of advertising and know its core message, which is the promotion of goods and services. They know that an advertisement is never without this purpose and will therefore be alert to discover the slightest textual clue of this intent. Riddles without a solution cannot be admitted. It is true that E.ON used this device for a time, but it was only a means of temporary suspense. The solution was ahead in the continuation of the advertising campaign.
6. Style and function of opaque advertising Enigmatic advertising is a stylistic device aiming at creating curiosity by means of deviations from the standard patterns of the genre which suggest to the consumers that they are faced with something different, worth their attention. Riddles have something in common with metaphors, as Aristotle observed. Both can be used with profit in the art of persuasion. The consumers are invited to invest an extra effort in the decoding of the message. However, the consumer’s willingness to dedicate time to solving riddles posed by advertisers is limited.
90
Nina Bishara
If the message remains too opaque and turns out to be merely self-referential the purpose of the message will fail. A self-referential message that only points back to itself cannot convey any advertising message. Without a specific referent its message is open to many possible readings. Deviation from the standard patterns of advertising messages is a means of attracting attention. It is one of the strategies of poetic semiosis: not only does the advertising text which deviates from the conventional expectations about the genre attract the consumers’ attention; it also demands more effort in the process of decoding. Assmann (1988) has introduced the term “wild semiosis” to describe such processes of creativity: by violating the standard patterns of expectation something unexpected and unknown is being created which turns the viewers’ attention to the materiality and form of the text as such. Self-reference is one of the means of wild semiosis. In addition to its poetic quality and its potential to capture the consumers’ attention, opaque advertising is likely to create intellectual pleasure. Riddling is fun and makes the advertisement attractive as well as entertaining. Furthermore, it demonstrates the consumers’ competence and advertising literacy. Above all, opaque advertising, despite its risk of failing, is likely to contribute towards a higher memory value of the message and thus to the success of the advertising campaign.
7. Conclusion Advertising is essentially a means to an end but never an end in itself. The messages of the marketplace are signs whose objects are the products and services which the advertisers want to promote. In order to promote a product, a message must refer to it. The referential function, a highly indexical sign process, tends to be the primary function of advertising. However, creative advertisers have discovered the advantages of hiding their messages in the disguise of self-reference. Their messages are opaque and seem to point to nothing but to themselves. Such messages seem to constitute a paradox. Can they still achieve their purpose of promoting a product? Furthermore, they seem to be counterproductive to the primary aims of transmitting a message to the consumer. Opaque advertising contains indices of an object which remains concealed and creates an interpretant which is likely to remain incomplete. Its enigmatic message is self-referential as long as the consumers do not succeed in discovering the object of reference. However, opaque advertisements never remain truly opaque and self-referential. Consumers who pay attention to their message are bound to discover the referent in disguise. Enigmatic advertisements are thus likely
“Absolut Anonymous”: Self-reference in opaque advertising
91
to capture better the consumers’ attention, arouse their interest and desire, and implant their message better in the memory of those who have to pay for what they saw when they decide to purchase the product.
Notes 1. An example of an immediate and dynamical object given by Peirce is the statement “The sun is blue” of which the perception or sensation of the sun’s blueness constitutes the immediate object, while the physical phenomenon of wave lengths causing the blue appearance is the dynamical object (CP 8.183). 2. These terms are sometimes used synonymously with the emotional, energetic, and logical interpretant. Some scholars, however, understand the emotional, energetic, and logical interpretant as a subdivision of the dynamical interpretant, and for some it is a threefold subcategorization of the triad of the immediate, dynamical, and final interpretant (N¨oth 2000: 65). 3. See Willi Schalk, Helmut Thoma and Peter Strahlendorf (eds.). 2000. Jahrbuch der Werbung 2000. Berlin: Econ, p. 144. 4. See Der Spiegel 46/2002, p. 62. 5. Advertising-literate recipients will of course immediately grasp the pun of this advertisement and will identify its referent since Absolut vodka has maintained its advertising style for several decades: depiction of the vodka bottle and a two-word slogan always beginning with “Absolut”. This repetitive style of advertising is selfreferential in a different way. 6. See Volkswagen Advertising Database, Nr. BE020USPR. 7. http://www.E.ON-ag.com/E.ON0493106069 (03.02.03). 8. Example: What is red and green and goes round and round? – A frog in a mixer. 9. Example: Which is the first book of the Bible? – Genesis. 10. It is interesting to note that the words riddle and to read are related etymologically.
References Abrahams, Roger D. and Alan Dundes 1973 Riddles. In: Richard M. Dorson (ed.), Folklore and Folklife, 129–143. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. Assmann, Aleida 1988 Die Sprache der Dinge. Der lange Blick und die wilde Semiose. In: Hans Ulrich Gumbrecht and K. Ludwig Pfeiffer (eds.), Materialit¨at der Kommunikation, 237–251. Frankfurt: Suhrkamp. N¨oth, Winfried 2000 Handbuch der Semiotik, 2nd rev. ed. Stuttgart: Metzler.
92
Nina Bishara
Peirce, Charles S. 1931–1958 Collected Papers of C. S. Peirce. Ed. Charles Hartshorne, Paul Weiss and Arthur Burks. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. – Quoted as CP.
Part III. Self-referential photography
The death of photography in self-reference Winfried N¨oth
1. The death of photography and the birth of the postphotographic era The Death of Photography is the provocative title of an anthology with papers on the role of photography in the visual arts of the 19th and the 20th centuries (Beckley and Aguilar 2007). At the occasion of its publication, art critics, art historians, semioticians, and – ironically – also photographers (Bill Beckley, Samuel Jamier, Siri Hustvedt, Winfried N¨oth, Max Kozloff, and Renee Cox) discussed the topic at a symposium in the Museum of Modern Art in New York on May 4, 2005. It was not the first time that the death of photography had been declared in face of the technological transformations of the medium since the advent of digital imaging. Ritchin (1990) foresaw a “revolution in photography” more than a decade ago, Mitchell (1992) announced the beginning of a “postphotographic era” in the 1990s (cf. Santaella 1997; Santaella and N¨oth 1998: 166; Carani 1999), and David Acton (2004) even declared the “end of photography” in the last chapter of his book on Photography at the Worcester Art Museum. Ironically, photography itself had once been considered the cause of the death of another pictorial medium, namely painting. In 1839, after examining photography commissioned by the French Academy for Daguerrian photography, Paul Delaroche announced: “From this day on, painting is dead” (apud Weibel 2002: 611). It is, of course, a paradox when those who continue producing photographs and exhibiting them publicly declare the death of photography, but it is wellknown that we are merely confronted with a metaphorical death. The death which this metaphor evokes means the birth of the new digital technologies of image making and processing by means of cameras. Photography is dead, long live photography! But if photography continues to exist as a technologically and semiotically transformed medium, what is it that has died in postphotography?
96
Winfried N¨oth
The now defunct photography is the one about which Roland Barthes (1980: 87) once said: “Photography never lies: or rather, it can lie as to the nature of the thing, being by nature tendentious, never as to its existence.” The traditional photograph does not lie in the sense that the light rays emitted by the object are projected via the lens and registered by the film in a process of optical and chemical causality. In Mitchell’s words (1992: 24): “A photograph is fossilized light, and its aura of superior evidential efficacy has frequently been ascribed to the special bond between figurative reality and permanent image that is formed at the instant of exposure. It is a direct physical imprint like a fingerprint left at the scene.” The faith in the truthfulness of photography which derives from this natural causality is as old as the history of the medium. Early in the 19th century, the painter Eug`ene Delacroix (1799–1863) praised the daguerreotype, the precursor of the photograph, for the reliability of the picture in its faithful reflection of the object: “Daguerrotypy is more than a blueprint, it is the reflex of the object”, and Hypolyte Taine, in his Philosophie de l’art of 1865 praised the truthfulness of the new medium: “Photography is the art which imitates on a plane surface, with lines and tones, with perfection and without possibility of error the form of the object which it must reproduce” (apud Arrouye 1978: 74). The truthful photograph, causally connected to its referent and dying in the age of digital simulation, is that medium whose pictures, despite all their similarity to their referential object, Charles Sanders Peirce defined as primarily indexical signs: Photographs, especially instantaneous photographs are very instructive, because we know that they are in certain respects exactly like the objects they represent. But this resemblance is due to the photographs having been produced under such circumstances that they were physically forced to correspond point by point to nature. In that aspect, then, they belong to the second class of signs [i.e., to the indexical signs], those by physical connection. (CP 2.281, circa 1895)
2. The loss of the referent and the crisis of representation Some have hailed the “revolutionary” changes which digital photography has brought about, while others have deplored the losses that the postphotographic media have been suffering with the “death of photography”. The praise of the new medium is for the expanded creative potential of digital image making. As summarized by Kevin Robins (2007: 22): “There is the sense that photography was constrained by its inherent automatism and realism, that is to say, by its essentially passive nature; that the imagination of photographers was restricted
The death of photography in self-reference
97
because they could aspire to be no more than mere recorders of reality.” From a historical perspective, the postphotographic era also leads back to the precursor of photography, painting, which it once seemed to have dethroned: Since captured, “painted”, and synthesized pixel values can be combined seamlessly, the digital image blurs the customary distinctions between painting and photography and between mechanical and handmade pictures. A digital image may be part scanned photograph, part computer-synthesized shaded perspective, and part electronic “painting” – all smoothly melded into an apparently coherent whole. It may be fabricated from found files, disk litter, the detritus of cyberspace. Digital imagers give meaning and value to computational readymades by appropriation, transformation, reprocessing, and recombination; we have entered the age of electrobricolage. (Mitchell 1992: 7)
Parallel with the praise of the enhanced potential of visual expression, the postphotographic era has brought about theoretical encomia of the new semiotic, aesthetic and even psychoanalytic horizons of digital image making, such as: “The certainties of the photographic era have been deconstructed, and we are now ready, it seems, to come to terms with the fragility of ontological distinctions between imaginary and real” (Robins 2007: 24). From the semiotic perspective, the most important revolutionary feature of the postphotographic era seems to be that the new images have become “independent of referents in the ‘real word”’ (Robins 2007: 22). Although this independence may enhance the artist’s creative potential, the ensuing “loss of the referent” has also given rise to discourse about a “crisis between reality and its image” in the “age of electronic simulation” (Grundberg 2007: 63). In a critical perspective, this loss of the referent can “disturb and disorient by blurring comfortable boundaries and by encouraging transgression of rules on which we have come to rely” (Mitchell 1992: 223). The new potential of absolute manipulation and simulation of merely virtual worlds seems to have “subverted traditional notions of authenticity and originality” (Robins 2007: 27). However, if the death of photography is the advent of pictures which have lost their referent this “death” must have occurred many times in the history of photography. The death of photography is a manifestation of the “crisis of representation” (cf. N¨oth and Ljungberg 2003) whose roots in the visual arts are the roots of modernity with which we have been familiar since impressionism, pointillism, cubism, abstract painting, Dada, etc. It is indeed na¨ıve to assume that there has been an uninterrupted tradition of indexical photographs which point to a referent. The loss of such referents has begun early in the history of photography, and there have been many forms and modalities of this death, e.g., deletion or insertion by retouch with the purpose of
98
Winfried N¨oth
deceit, defamiliarizing the referent by representing it incompletely, in a distorted way, by double exposure, or by abstraction from the referential object with an aesthetic purpose. The loss of the referent in traditional photography can have its cause in alloreference or in self-reference. Alloreference, that is, reference to something else, is the expected mode of reference of an ordinary photograph. The photo is an indexical sign of its referent, a person, a building, a landscape, etc. When this object disappears because it is distorted, fuzzy, hidden, unrecognizable, or falsified by retouch, the loss of the referent is an alloreferential one.
3. Seven self-referential deaths of the photographic referent A different kind of disappearance of the referent in photography is due to selfreference. Instead of being the indexical sign of a referential object, the selfreferential photo shows only itself, it draws attention to nothing but the photo, and invites the eye to get immersed in the forms and colors of the photographic composition. By negating alloreference, the self-referential picture negates the referent as such, either partially or entirely. Various forms and strategies of pictorial self-reference have been invented in the history of photography. In the following, we will discuss seven of them. 3.1. The negated self in a paradoxical self-portrait In 1839, the photographer Hippolyte Bayard (1801–1897) portrayed himself in a photo entitled “Self-portrait of a drowned man”. It shows him in a reclined position half naked and with closed eyes (see Mitchell 1992: 194). Like any self-portrait, the picture is to a certain degree self-referential: the sender of the message is part of the message himself so that the picture refers to the source of its own production. The self-referential message of this portrait is true and false at the same time. It is true that we see a picture of the photographer, but it is false that he is dead, as the title claims. The referent is thus partially hidden by the false claim of the title. Parallel with this false indexical message attached to the referent, we are faced with a logical paradox, as it often occurs in selfreferential statements. It requires no indexical reference at all to realize that the self-referential title which is supposed to identify its referent is false. It is a matter of logic that a dead man cannot portray himself. The solution to this paradox leads back to the photo, and we readily conclude that this photo is not a self-portrait of a drowned man.
The death of photography in self-reference
99
3.2. The camera in the picture About 1880, August Giraudon took the photo “Mirrors in Versailles Caste” (see Govignon 2004: 37). It is a picture of a large mirror in the Versailles mirror hall, which does not only show a highly ornamented wall reflected in the mirror on the opposite wall, but also, right in the center of the picture, the large camera on a tripod which is taking this very picture. Strangely, the photographer is absent in the picture. The self-referential aspect of the photo is evident. The camera, instrument of taking a picture other than itself, represents itself, but it shows only partially the referent it is supposed to depict. There is a loss of the referent, the mirror in the palace, insofar as the view of the reflected palace wall is obstructed by the camera. Again, the result is a paradoxical relationship between the verbal and the pictorial message. While the verbal message states “Mirrors in Versailles Castle”, the pictorial message is: “This picture does not (only) show mirrors in Versailles Castle, but it shows the taking of a picture of mirrors in Versailles Castle.” Furthermore, the photographer’s absence leaves the eye with the suspicion of a second paradox: can a photo be taken in absence of a photographer? The self-referential presence of the photographer’s instrument of image making, the camera in the picture, violates the ancient principle of ars est celare artem [art requires the hiding of art], which goes back to Quintilian and Ovid (cf. Wetzel 2003). The artist should show in an alloreferential way something other than himself. He should avoid self-reference by concealing any indices of his artistic doing. The violation of this ancient principle makes this self-referential picture a picture and metapicture at the same time.
3.3. Abstraction from the referent The third “death” of the photographic referent can be illustrated with Paul Strand’s “Abstraction. Porch Shadows” of 1917 (see Govignon 2004: 77). The picture shows an aesthetically well-formed pattern of parallel stripes of black and white, but it seems impossible to recognize the form of an object. Despite the indication given by the title, which tells us that we see porch shadows, the referential object remains indiscernible. It even remains unclear whether the enigmatic pattern represents shadows of a porch or in a porch. However, we are not disappointed about the absence of the referent since the aesthetic quality of the photo resides entirely in its material and formal qualities. Although we are informed that there is reference, the impression of a missing referent predominates. Once more, we are confronted with a paradox. The title
100
Winfried N¨oth
affirms the existence of a porch, whereas the pictorial message is that there is none. The loss of the referent is total, but the self-referential gain in aesthetic quality compensates this loss entirely. 3.4.
Double exposure
Under the influence of cubism and Dada, experimental photography of the 1920s and 1930s discovered the technique of double exposure with the result of pictures which were indexical signs of two referents. Such double exposure seems to result in the opposite of the loss of the referent, since a photo exposed twice is a sign of at least two referents. However, the pictorial space of a photo is restricted, and the doubling of the referent can only be achieved at the cost of the pictorial space of one of the two overlapping pictures. The overlapping causes the disappearance of the part of the underlying referent that is hidden by the overlap. In this sense, there is a loss of the referent. Consider Maurice Tabard’s “Composition (Double Exposure)” of 1931 (see Govignon 2004: 277). It shows the lateral view of a face overlapped by the front view of the same face. The referent that disappears partially is the one of the face in its lateral perspective. The relation between the photo and its referential object is one of double indexicality insofar as the two views of the same face refer to its two perspectives seen at two different moments from two different points of view. Internally, however, the photo evinces the repetition of the same of the face from its two perspectives, which makes one perspective the iconic representation of the other and vice versa. This internal iconicity is a mode of self-reference. Once again, pictorial self-reference results in a pictorial paradox: the photo cannot be an indexical photo since it reflects an impossible perspective of the real face, but at the same time it is nothing but a photo. 3.5. Aesthetic deconstruction The partial destruction and similar forms of manipulation of the paper surface of a photograph for the purpose of its exhibition in an art gallery leads to another mode of self-reference, which exemplifies our fifth “death” of the referent in photography.Arnulf Rainer’s self-portrait of 1951, entitled “The empty painting” (see Weibel 2002: 598), shows the artist in a gallery between one of his paintings and two empty frames. In addition to being self-referential in the sense that every self-portrait is a self-referential message, the photo evinces a different kind of self-reference in so far as it was torn into two pieces by the artist himself, who
The death of photography in self-reference
101
put the fragments once more together to exhibit the fragmentary result as a new deconstructed whole. The photo is a photo and a metaphoto at the same time. On the one hand, it is a portrait of the artist, on the other hand, it conveys the message: “This is a photo torn to pieces and reassembled once more.” The paradox consists in two contradictory messages at the metalevel, which can be paraphrased as: “This is a photo and not a photo at the same time.” It is the destruction of the photo by the artist which conveys the message “This is no more a photo (but scraps of paper)”, whereas his gesture of putting it together once more conveys the opposite message: “This is a photo.” The loss of the referent occurs at the metalevel. It is the loss of the referent which results from the destruction of the photo, since a fragmented photo is impeded from fulfilling its function of indicating its referent. 3.6.
Mise en abyme
The sixth type of the “death” of the referent appears in the strategy of selfreferential photos in the photo (mise en abyme). The semiotic implications are similar to the ones discussed in the case of double exposure. Consider the example of the photo entitled “Kassel is everywhere or: Where am I?” of the Arbeitsgruppe Fotoforum of 1979 (see Heyne 2003: 53). A giant photo of a street is inserted in the picture of the same street taken from the same point of view. The method of insertion is not double exposure, but photographic selfdepiction. The group of artists appears in the photo carrying their giant photo of the same street. Everything except for the artists is represented twice, which constitutes genuine iconic self-reference. At the same time, the photo inserted by the artists in the foreground is hiding part of the background scenery. It obstructs the view of the street right in the middle of the picture. However, the resulting loss of the background referent can be recuperated from the scenery represented by the photo in the foreground which is the picture of what is invisible. Several paradoxes are involved. The photo is a photo, but at the same time it is two photos. The photo makes visible and invisible at the same time. Strangely, the two photos in one have one and the same referent. In their double reference, the two photos are indexical signs of their referential objects, in their mutual sameness, they are iconic and self-referential signs.
102
Winfried N¨oth
3.7.
Self-obliteration
Photo-collage, photomontage, and intermedially hybrid photographs are paraphotographic genres which extend the method of photographic deconstruction considered above in the example of Arnulf Rainer’s self-portrait. While Rainer’s destruction of his own photo was only a partial one – after all, the pictorial loss by the tear in his picture is only a small impediment to our eye – Timm Ullrichs went all the way in the destruction of his own self-portrait with his “Self-effacement by painting” [‘Selbstausl¨oschung durch Malerei’] of 1973– 1976 (see Weibel 2002: 618). The technique by which this work was produced is described as “heavy paint-overpainting of a sheet of glass as a sequence in ten photos laminated onto cardboard” (Weibel 2002: 618). In the top left corner we see the artist’s complete photographic self-portrait behind a window-like sheet of glass. In the sequence of the ten pictures from left to right and top to bottom, Ullrichs’s portrait gradually disappears while the artist is shown in a sequence of photos in which he is overpainting the sheet of glass between himself and the camera with white paint, which makes him gradually disappear. The background behind the glass shows the artist in the different stages of self-effacement. Only the first picture is a full portrait. From the second to the last but one frame only parts of his body can be discerned while his body gradually disappears behind the painted portions of the glass. In the tenth picture, the portrait becomes altogether invisible. It is no longer a photo of the artist, but one of a sheet of glass painted white. Ullrichs’s metapicture abounds with self-references and paradoxes. Each of the ten pictures is a portrait of the artist, even the last one where the artist is invisible because he disappears behind the coat of white paint, which creates the paradox of a portrait of an invisible man. In the end, the self-referential gesture of effacing himself and hence making the referent of the photographic portrait disappear leaves us to solve the paradoxical doubt whether the last picture is a photo of a monochrome painting or a deleted photo, hence the mere negation of a photo? Furthermore another major paradox all the while is: How can an artist go on to produce a self-portrait while he himself disappears in the process of doing so?
4. Postphotographic pictures without a referent Despite the various forms of the disappearance of the referent in its seven selfreferential forms of “death” distinguished so far, traditional photography always left some indexical traces of the referents which it depicted. The shadows which
The death of photography in self-reference
103
we perceived as an abstract array of black and white stripes were really the emanation of sunrays in or of a porch captured by the lens of a camera, and the artist’s disappearance behind a white sheet of glass, left us not only with the indexical picture of this glass, but also with the possibility of reconstructing the artist’s image behind the glass by a process of visual inference, which leads us back to the first photo in the sequence, where we saw him fully. Only in digital photography have photos entirely devoid of indexical anchors in the visual world become possible. Being programmatically without any referent, they have become self-referential right from the beginning. Photos of this trend in postphotography did not lose their referent, they never had one. In contrast to Abstract Photography, which used to abstract from the referent, they have become Concrete Photography, which creates its own images without abstracting (cf. J¨ager 2003: 178). In a manifesto about his own postphotography, which can be exemplified with his black-and-white photographs on canvas of 1993 and 1995 entitled “Sources” (see Selichar 2003: 270), the Austrian digital photographer G¨unther Selichar declares: “These images look like paintings, speak about new media and are photographs: reproductions of a ‘grammar of media’, located on the paper-thin boundary between the figurative and the abstract, which ultimately shows that categories like this have perhaps become obsolete” (2003 268).
5. Nonrepresentational photography as self-referential genuine icons From a semiotic perspective, the question remains to be answered whether such pictures without a referent can still be considered as signs. Does not the notion of sign require the correlate of a referent, and if so, can semiotics still contribute to the study of such signs without a referent? Is the concept of the nonreferential sign a contradiction in terms? In more detail, I have given answers to these questions from the perspective of Peirce’s semiotics elsewhere (N¨oth 2005). In a very brief summary, signs do not require a referent in the sense of an object in the real world. Peirce does not even use the concept of the referent. The term that he uses instead of “referent” is the “object” of the sign, and the object of the sign can be something real, but also a mere thought, a concept, or an idea. Even in concrete photographs without any indexical anchors in the “real” world, the pictures are signs. Their objects are our previous experience of the visual world, of the forms, colors, and textures with which we have become acquainted in our pictorial culture.
104
Winfried N¨oth
The principal semiotic innovation of the postphotographic era is not the disappearance of the object of the photographic sign, but the shift from indexical to genuinely iconic pictures. The self-referential photos of Concrete Photography, whose visual message is in their formal design only, are genuine icons, according to Peirce (N¨oth 2003). A genuine icon does not depict in the traditional sense of mimesis. It refers to nothing but its own simple visual qualities of form, luminosity, contrast, or texture. The genuinely iconic sign constitutes a kind of degree zero of semioticity since it is reduced to the category of firstness, “the mode of being of that which is such as it is, positively and without reference to anything else” (CP 8.328). Such an icon is a sign merely by virtue of qualities of its own, and since it is not yet distinguished from its object, it does not refer to or “stand for” it at all. Peirce says that the genuine icon “does not draw any distinction between itself and its object” since it is a sign by virtue of its own particular qualities: “[Genuine] icons are so completely substituted for their objects as hardly to be distinguished from them. [. . . ] The distinction of the real and the copy disappears, and it is for the moment a pure dream – not any particular existence, and yet not general” (CP 5.74, 4.447).
6. Conclusion The “death of photography” began, and ran parallel, with the “crisis of representation”. It begins with the emergence of pictures which are losing their indexical reference to an object in the visual world. There are several forms and modalities of this death of traditional photography. Some are due to alloreference, some to self-reference. Self-reference in photos first meant a partial loss of the referent, in digital photography we are faced with photos that have never had a referent. We identified seven kinds of such losses of the referent in the history of predigital photography. The postphotographic era is not the “end of photography”, but the beginning of a new “postphotographic photography”. Pictures in Concrete Photography are signs without a referent in the “real” world, but not signs without an object in the sense of Peirce’s definition of the sign. Although these photographs represent nothing, they are nevertheless signs. Whereas the nowdefunct classical photography produced indexical signs, the postphotographic art of Concrete Photography is a self-referential art of genuine icons.
The death of photography in self-reference
105
References Acton, David 2004
Photography at theWorcesterArt Museum: Keeping Shadows. Worcester, MA: Worcester Art Museum and Ghent: Snoeck.
Arrouye, Jean 1978 S´emio-photo ou la mort de l’analogie. Critique 368: 72–87. Barthes, Roland 1980 La chambre claire: note sur la photographie. Paris: Cahier du cinema. Transl. 1982. Camera lucida: Reflections on Photography. New York: Noonday. Beckley, Bill and Katherine Aguilar (eds.) 2007 The Death of Photography And Other Modern Fables on the Visual Arts. New York: Delano Greenidge. Carani, Marie 1999 Au del`a de la photo positiviste: de la photo post-moderne a` la postphotographie. Visio 4(1): 67–91. Govignon, Brigitte (ed.) 2004 La petite encyclop´edie de la photographie. Paris: Matini`ere. Transl. 2005. Kleine Enzyklop¨adie der Photographie. Munich: Knesebeck. Grundberg, Andy 2007 Photography in the age of electronic simulation. In: Bill Beckley and Katherine Aguilar (eds.),The Death of Photography, 61–68. NewYork: Delano Greenidge. Heyne, Renate (ed.) 2003 Kunst und Fotografie: Floris Neus¨uss und die Kasseler Schule. Marburg: Jonas. J¨ager, Gottfried 2003 Abstract photography. In: Ruth Horak (ed.), Rethinking Photography I+II: Narration and New Reduction in Photography, 162–195. Salzburg: Fotohof Edition. Mitchell, William J. 1992 The Reconfigured Eye: Visual Truth in the Post-Photographic Era. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. N¨oth, Winfried 2000 Handbuch der Semiotik. 2nd rev. ed. Stuttgart: Metzler. 2003 Photography between reference and self-reference. In: Ruth Horak (ed.), Rethinking Photography I+II: Narration and New Reduction in Photography, 22–39. Salzburg: Fotohof Edition. 2005 Warum Bilder Zeichen sind. In: Stefan Majetschak (ed.), Bild-Zeichen: Perspektiven einer Wissenschaft vom Bild, 49–61. Munich: Fink.
106
Winfried N¨oth
N¨oth, Winfried and Christina Ljungberg (eds.) 2003 The Crisis of Representation: Semiotic Foundations and Manifestations in Culture and the Media. (= Special Issue of Semiotica 143(1–4). Peirce, Charles Sanders 1931–1958 Collected Papers, vols. 1–6, ed. Charles Hartshorne and Paul Weiss, vols. 7–8, ed., A. W. Burks. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. – Quoted as CP. Ritchin, Fred 1990 In Our Own Image: The Coming Revolution in Photography. New York: Aperture. Robins, Kevin 2007 Why images move us still. In: Bill Beckley and Katherine Aguilar (eds.), The Death of Photography, 21–44. New York: Delano Greenidge. Santaella, Lucia 1997 The prephotographic, the photographic, and the postphotographic image. In: Winfried N¨oth (ed.), Semiotics of the Media, 121–132. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter. Santaella, Lucia and Winfried N¨oth 1998 Imagem: Cogni¸cao, ˜ semi´otica, m´ıdia. S˜ao Paulo: Iluminuras. Trad. Roque Graciano. 2003. Imagen: Comunicaci´on, semi´otica y medios. Kassel: Reichenberger. Selichar, G¨unther 2003 Photography remixed. In: Ruth Horak (ed.), Rethinking Photography I+II: Narration and New Reduction in Photography, 248–287. Salzburg: Fotohof Edition. Weibel, Peter 2002 An end to the ‘end of art?’ On the iconoclasm of modern art. In: Bruno Latour and Peter Weibel (eds.), Iconoclash, 570–684. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. Wetzel, Michael 2003 Artem celare – The cryptic mediality of the photographic. In: Ruth Horak (ed.), Rethinking Photography I+II: Narration and New Reduction in Photography, 58–81. Salzburg: Fotohof Edition.
Marilyn: A paragone of the camera gaze Kay Kirchmann
In his study The Reality of the Mass Media, sociologist Niklas Luhmann asserts a dual status of reality in the contemporary mass media. The first reality of the mass media, in Luhmann’s words its “real reality” (Luhmann 1996: 12), consists of its own operations, that is in the fact that there is printing, broadcasting, and reading, that programs are received, movies watched. All this is permeated and framed by pretexts and recursive elements, by “countless communications of preparation and talking about it afterwards” (Luhmann 1996: 13). This is why, according to Luhmann, “the real reality of the mass media has to be understood as the communications that exist within it and run through it” (Luhmann 1996: 13). From the point of view of systems theory, something else is far more important for the operative functionality of the media: One can also talk of a second meaning of the reality of the mass media, namely in the sense of what passes as reality for it and through it for others. [. . . ] This meaning implies that the actions of the mass media are not simply considered to be a sequence of operations, but a sequence of observations. [. . . ] In order to reach this understanding of the mass media, we have to observe it observing. For the meaning first introduced, an observation of the first order is sufficient, as if it were all about facts. For the second option of understanding, one has to take up the position of an observer of the second order – an observer of observers. (Luhmann 1996: 14–15)
However, it is well known that in his own theoretical work, Luhmann has kept a critical distance from empiricism, and in a very general sense his concept of observation only implies that distinctions are made according to the binary codifiers (+/–) generated in a system. His concept therefore cannot be equated with the act of (visual) perception as such (cf. Baraldi, Corsi, and Esposito 1997: 124). But in the context of (audio-)visual media observation, this term will inevitably take on this second meaning as well, since the differentiations at hand are also (though not exclusively) articulated in visual form. And it is only in this form that they, in turn, are accessible to us as observers of the second order – since, according to another famous distinction of Luhmann’s (form/medium), the medium itself is not accessible, it is only perceptible through the forms it
108
Kay Kirchmann
generates (cf. Luhmann 1997: 195–215). Accordingly, to observe the observations of (audio-)visual media means quite literally to observe (audio-)visual forms; forms in which the distinctive systemic operations of the respective mass media are condensed into “objects of perception” (Baraldi, Corsi, and Esposito 1997: 58). What generally interests me in the following is not so much the theoretical edifice of systems theory as such: I am specifically interested in the figure of a medial function of observation implicit in it – and this only in the sense of a heuristic base category; a methodological starting point for concrete inquiries in the field of media analysis. In the context of a number of current phenomena of media reality (in the sense introduced above), the mode of medial self -observation appears to me particularly significant. Luhmann himself has conceded – with reference to the base dichotomies of system and environment, of external- and self-reference (cf. Baraldi, Corsi, and Esposito 1997: 128) – that as a system, the mass media can observe itself, albeit only through quite complex operations: A special case of self-observation presents itself when the observation is itself an operation of the observing system and takes part in its autopoiesis. By autopoiesis we do not mean an operation which observes itself while observing (something that is impossible), but rather an operation that observes something of which it is also a part (another operation of the system of which it partakes). (Baraldi, Corsi, and Esposito 1997: 127)
Even if the epistemological problems that come with such an operation are ignored for a moment, it remains worth considering whether “the” mass media can be taken so collectively as the subject, instrument, and object of such a selfobservation. After all, such an observation can only take place in one medium and through its instruments. In view of the multiplicity of contemporary media, it is highly unlikely that the self-observation of the medial realm could extend to all media – including itself. Hence one should rather speak of a figure of medial media-observation that is, first, necessarily selective and, second, oscillating between external- and self-observation. And, finally, one would have to investigate whether, as Luhmann thinks, such medial self-observation has already reached its purpose in causing a system to become auto-dynamic (cf. Baraldi, Corsi, and Esposito 1997: 128), or whether we can find entirely different intentions and functions. I would like to consider these questions by looking at a paradigmatic example: an approximately six-minute-long feature broadcast by the French-German television station ARTE in 1999 as part of the series Les cent photos du si`ecle / One Hundred Photographs of the Century (cf. Robin 1999). The series belongs
Marilyn: A paragone of the camera gaze
109
to a new sub-genre, the “retrospective view of the century” (cf. Filk and Kirchmann 2000), which surfaced on diverse TV channels in the wake of the recent turn of the millennium. Other than most series in this format, the ARTE series approached history from the outset in a way that emphasized and reflected on the comprehensive saturation of our cultural memory by the media. Accordingly, the series did not even attempt to reconstruct a past that would be accessible without any recourse to media. Instead, it focused exclusively on history’s media documents; in this case, famous photographs. While individual episodes center on the history of production of individual photographs, the photograph itself is elevated to an object in which individual biographies randomly intersect at a particular moment in time, namely those of the photographers and of the person photographed. Thereby history is interpreted as a contingent field of fleeting events and of meetings that receive historic prominence only in retrospect. From a conceptual point of view, One Hundred Photographs of the Century draws on a wide definition of historical relevancy according to which the history of popular culture – and therefore also the mass media – is a constitutive element of history as well. For this very reason the series also includes an episode entitled “Marilyn 1960” that deals with the photograph shown in Figure 1.
Figure 1. The central photograph in the episode “Marilyn 1960”: Eve Arnold’s photograph of Marilyn Monroe on the set of The Misfits
110
Kay Kirchmann
Depending on a viewer’s pre-existing knowledge, this photograph, with which the episode opens, will call up different pretexts: all viewers will probably recognize Marilyn Monroe as the person depicted, which in turn will conjure up the much-publicized biography of the actress – her problematic personal life, her mysterious suicide, etc. A large section of the audience will also recognize in the mystifying apparatus on the left margin of the picture a boom, or they will at the very least associate it with cinematic recording technology – that is to say, they will properly place the photograph into the context of film production. Veritable film buffs, on the other hand, might immediately recognize the landscape and identify it as the setting of The Misfits, a John Huston picture Monroe shot in the Nevada desert in 1960. And they might furthermore remember that the film’s legendary status in the history of cinema partly derives from the fact that it was Marilyn Monroe’s and Clark Gable’s last film; that Marilyn Monroe’s then-husband, dramatist Arthur Miller, had written the film script for her as a birthday present in a final attempt to secure for her the “serious” role she desperately desired; that the marriage of the two had nevertheless suffered its final break-down during filming and that they shortly after divorced; that despite all the problems and personal crises on the set, the film would go on to win multiple Academy Awards, etc. (cf. Miller and Toubiana 2000: 49–96). Those who are also well-versed in the history of aesthetically ambitious press photography will furthermore know that the rights for all set photography on this film were given exclusively to the famous “Magnum” agency, which had dispatched some of its most highly-regarded members to the film set (cf. Miller and Toubiana 2000: 67–74), including Henri Cartier-Bresson, Ernst Haas, Cornell Capa, and, last but not least, Eve Arnold, who is credited with having taken the picture under consideration here. The pre-knowledge called up by this opening is thus layered, and the layers correlate with the complexity of the attendant figure of observation: in this case, the medium television observes the medium photography as it observes a film production (in retrospect, a legendary one) and a celebrated film star who in turn is one of the most photographed people of the 20th century – and we find ourselves in the position of trying to observe this almost infinite regression. After the opener, the television episode deals with the multiple preconditions of the history of the photograph and the biographies of the protagonists tied to it, as it were, in fast forward mode. It dedicates a mere 45 seconds to the genesis of The Misfits, almost a full minute to the biography of Monroe, and 20 seconds to the importance of the “Magnum” agency in the history of photography. Clearly, the episode is not so much concerned with filling in substantial gaps in the pre-knowledge of its audience; it rather attempts to activate this pre-knowledge once more. In a marked difference to the other episodes of the
Marilyn: A paragone of the camera gaze
111
series, this section does not set out to provide a contemporary reassessment of significant historical fragments included in this photography. This episode of One Hundred Photographs of the Century makes something entirely different the object of its observation of medial observations, and it is left to Eve Arnold, by now almost 90 years old, to provide the sound bites for this deeper theme: Marilyn loved the photo camera – just as she loathed film cameras. When she worked for the cinema, she had to put on make-up, prepare, learn her lines, be on time, and, above all, she had to listen to people telling her what to do. During a photo shoot, it was she who controlled everything. Her true profession was to have her picture taken. Photography was her toy. It allowed her to present herself as she really was. She knew without prompting to affect the appropriate look and how to achieve the result she wanted. She knew how to move her hands, how to throw back her hair, and how to make use of her famous pout, which made her appear even more sensuous. She was extremely gifted. She not only knew how to take in the photo camera but also, and in particular, the photographer. (Transcript of the TV program by the author)
Quite obviously, this medial media observation serves the purpose of developing a discourse about different kinds of camera gazes and therefore of different visual media, a discourse that clearly favors photography. Television here contends that photography – by contrast with the film camera – has passed down the correct gaze at Monroe. I will specify in more detail below how this theory is developed. For now, I would like to stress that the critical comparison of different camera gazes stays within a classical discursive tradition of European cultural history: the paragone. From the Renaissance to Lessing’s Laokoon, the paragone (literally “a critical comparison, often the result of an argumentative dispute”, Reck 1992: 120) served as a means to divide up spheres of influence between the arts themselves and between the arts and other social sub-systems, such as the sciences. Studying the aesthetic order of the semiotic material unique to them was an attempt to establish the distinctiveness of individual art forms. While, according to art historian Hans-Ulrich Reck, the historical paragone in the long run created “an awareness that the arts do not all deal with the same material or have the same meaning” (Reck 1992: 120), the paragone that resurfaces here is quite at odds with this option of shared labor within different, co-existing media. In the so-called media age, every object has to be potentially accessible and adequate to every medium. In the face of a highly competitive market and the bully mentality that comes with it, any notion of a co-existence or a careful discrimination of objects have long been superseded by claims for omnipotence and plain competitiveness of individual media forms. Marilyn Monroe, and in this respect the thematic choice of the ARTE short feature is anything but ran-
112
Kay Kirchmann
dom, is herself a highly significant example because already in her own lifetime, she was a medial object embroiled in competitive struggles between photography, the print media, cinema, and – albeit in a weakened form – television of the time. Against this background, it is only logical that the paragone discourse of our example shifts from a semiotic onto an ontological level. We are no longer dealing with the traditional question of which medial sign system is the “proper” one for Monroe, we rather have to ask which amongst the camera gazes (all of them potentially relevant to the object in question) will be able to show us the “true” Monroe. The respective verdict of the ARTE episode in favor of the photo camera and against the film camera draws implicitly on the popular understanding that behind Monroe’s image on the screen hides a “genuine”, fragile, and lonely woman; a woman even who was victimized by being continuously typecast by a ruthless studio system as a blonde sex goddess, etc. However, this argument could just as easily be reversed – particularly in light of the pin-up photographs which had brought Marilyn Monroe fame even before her film career started (cf. Arnold 2005: 24–36). As observers of this medial media observation, however, we cannot simply focus on a question that must necessarily remain speculative, the question about the ultimate “truth” behind Marilyn Monroe. Rather, we must focus exclusively on the discursive figure as developed by television in her specific case. Again, having been trained in Luhmann’s constructivism, the question whether mass media products refer to reality can of course never refer to an “ontological, existing, objectively accessible, unconstructively recognizable reality” (Luhmann 1996: 20). It can only be: “How do the mass media create reality?” The construction affected by this TV program works in part through a deliberate reference to the pertinent position that Eve Arnold takes. By virtue of its rhetorical structure, Arnold’s above quoted statement constantly brings into play the opposition between photo and film camera and joins it with an ontological question. Let us consider the quote once more with a special focus on its rhetorical devices (marked by italics): Marilyn loved the photo camera – just as she loathed film cameras. When she worked for the cinema, she had to put on make-up, prepare, learn her lines, be on time, and, above all, she had to listen to people telling her what to do. During a photo shoot, it was she who controlled everything. Her true profession was to have her picture taken. Photography was her toy. It allowed her to present herself as she really was. She knew without prompting to affect the appropriate look and how to achieve the result she wanted. She knew how to move her hands, how to throw back her hair, and how to make use of her famous pout, which made her appear even more sensuous. She was extremely gifted. She not only knew how to take in the
Marilyn: A paragone of the camera gaze
113
photo camera but also, and in particular, the photographer. (Transcript of the TV program by the author; emphasis added.)
These sound bites by Eve Arnold only paraphrase again what she reiterated before and after in the records of her work with Marilyn Monroe: “When you photographed her, she controlled and manipulated the whole set: me, the camera. . . She knew her way around cameras and enticed reactions from it like I have seen no other person do. In this set-up, she got whatever she wanted simply because the pressure of shooting a film, which would threaten to bury her, was missing” (Miller and Toubiana 2000: 71). Similarly, in another passage: “Having her picture taken was a safe way for her of being loved and admired” (Arnold 2005: 137). Arnold even calls upon her colleague at the Magnum agency, Inge Morath, who was also on the set of The Misfits, to bear witness once more to Marilyn’s entanglement with the two kinds of cameras: “She was in charge of the still camera – she was the animal tamer, the photographer was the beast. She fought constantly with film cameras, but in front of the photo camera, she was free” (Arnold 2005: 72). Because of the amount of printed and reprinted statements, the producers at ARTE presumably had to have been very aware of what they could expect Eve Arnold to say about Marilyn and photo cameras, and this awareness must have influenced their choice in making these specific photos and this specific photographer the focal point of this episode. Both in written statements and in the sound bites taken from the TV program under consideration here, the main argument always stays the same: Eve Arnold shifts the question onto an ontological level, and her comments locate the functional relation between visual image and visual object in a decidedly anthropomorphic dimension. In this dimension, cameras and actress interact against a backdrop of personalized, inter-human – and thus de-medialized and de-technicalized – patterns of action. A visual object is infused with the power to love or to hate cameras, to control them or turn them into toys, to manipulate them or force them into an unexpected reaction – and vice versa. In the process, the bond between Marilyn and the camera carries all the traits of an eroticized relationship; one in which the camera surrenders voluntarily and passionately to the actress’s art of seduction and manipulation. The stylized erotic pas de deux introduces a moment of secret complicity between Marilyn, the camera, and the photographer which neatly balances what has been conceded before – that Marilyn has control over the camera and the photographer. This complicity in turn allows Monroe to grant the photo camera – and only the photo camera – what seems to be a privileged glance into her innermost self. She does so by voluntarily choosing to concede control in order to display her “true nature” to the camera. It is this claim of a reciprocal willingness to be seduced that
114
Kay Kirchmann
legitimizes a specific photographic gaze on a companion and friend – a gaze that seems not to be entangled in hierarchies and is therefore as appropriate as it is intimate. While making comments to this effect on Marilyn’s predilection for the photo, which the Magnum-photographer took in the Nevada desert, Eve Arnold also supplies pertinent instructions on how to make sense of it: This photo she [Marilyn] loved especially since it transmitted a sense of loneliness. [. . . ] When she is putting her hands to her face like this, you have a feeling that she cries for help. For me, the main point this photo is making is a cry for help. You can think she cries “Help me, I’m in danger!” (Transcript of the TV program by the author)
The TV program leaves little doubt that this danger does indeed originate from the medium film. While the bond between Marilyn and the photo camera is characterized, as we have seen, by a sense of passion and complicity, the actress’s interactions with a film camera are dominated by such aspects as force, control, and a lack of authenticity. These interactions cannot be characterized as a reciprocal bond between lovers: instead, they feature as the frightening suppression of a young woman who in her daily life is subjected to an uncomfortable but sensible arrangement – in short: we are witnessing the passion play of married life. What we can observe is a calculated transformation of a photograph into a narrative, complete with the established narrative topoi: the classic melodramatic narrative involving the plight of a blonde, beautiful, and suffering heroine who is caught between an understanding lover and a husband who tries to dominate her, between an erotic liaison that offers her fulfillment and the silent suffering of married life constantly regulated by the intricate mechanisms of patriarchal domination. Since there is no way out of this conflict, the only logical result seems to be the untimely death of the woman. This narrative frame changes our perception of Arnold’s photo and structures our reading of it. The program cuts to the respective photo again and again and favors, by means of selection and camera movement, the established pattern of meaning. This dramaturgy of repetition seems to demonstrate in actu, as it were, the change in perception mentioned above: the boom suddenly seems to turn into a frightening, almost animalistic instrument; a pensive and attentive Marilyn changes into a desperate one, the bizarre beauty of the desert landscape metamorphoses into a gloomy site of existential struggle. In retrospect, it becomes apparent just how much the selection of this photo (and this photographer) was owed to the cold rationale of dramaturgy. If this had been just about Marilyn’s life, other and possibly even more famous photographs would have been more than fitting in the context of a short feature – for example,
Marilyn: A paragone of the camera gaze
115
116
Kay Kirchmann
Marilyn: A paragone of the camera gaze
Figure 2a–f. Six photographs by Eve Arnold taken on the set of The Misfits
117
118
Kay Kirchmann
one from the legendary last session with George Barris shortly before Monroe’s death, or even the photo that Elliot Erwitt took on the set of Billy Wilder’s The Seven Year Itch which has since been reprinted countless times: Marilyn standing on a ventilation shaft, her white dress blown up into the air. But only in the photographs taken by Eve Arnold on the set of The Misfits was and is the paragone already implied which so obviously interested theARTE programmers. Therefore, the editorial decision in favor of the pictures of this photographer was anything but arbitrary. If you look at further pictures by Eve Arnold taken during the 1960 production (Figures 2a–f), the repetitive pattern of staging becomes fully obvious. These, by the