Seeking Real Truths
Seeking Real Truths Multidisciplinary Perspectives on Machiavelli
Edited by
Patricia Vilches an...
82 downloads
3450 Views
4MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Seeking Real Truths
Seeking Real Truths Multidisciplinary Perspectives on Machiavelli
Edited by
Patricia Vilches and Gerald Seaman
LEIDEN • BOSTON 2007
Cover illustration: by Rafael Francisco Salas. Photography by Diane Mockridge. Salas and Mockridge are professors at Ripon College. Brill has made all reasonable efforts to trace all right holders to any copyrighted material used in this work. In cases where these efforts have not been successful the publisher welcomes communications from copyright holders, so that the appropriate acknowledgements can be made in future editions, and to settle other permission matters. This book is printed on acid-free paper.
ISBN: 978 90 04 15877 1 Copyright 2007 by Koninklijke Brill NV, Leiden, The Netherlands. Koninklijke Brill NV incorporates the imprints Brill, Hotei Publishing, IDC Publishers, Martinus Nijhoff Publishers and VSP. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, translated, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without prior written permission from the publisher. Authorization to photocopy items for internal or personal use is granted by Koninklijke Brill NV provided that the appropriate fees are paid directly to The Copyright Clearance Center, 222 Rosewood Drive, Suite 910, Danvers, MA 01923, USA. Fees are subject to change. printed in the netherlands
For Mario and Riccardo And all who have come before
CONTENTS
Editors’ Preface ........................................................................... Acknowledgements ..................................................................... Contributors ................................................................................ Editors’ Introduction The Enduring Power of Niccolò Machiavelli: An Overview of his Life and Times ................................................................. Patricia Vilches
ix xiii xv
1
GOVERNMENT An Introduction to The Prince Edited and translated by Gerald Seaman .................................. Marie Gaille-Nikodimov
21
Machiavelli’s Burden: The Prince as Literary Text ...................... Charles D. Tarlton
43
The Discourses on Livy: Preserving a Free Way of Life ................ Julia Conaway Bondanella
69
Machiavelli: Rhetoric and Prudence .......................................... Eugene Garver
103
SOCIETY Machiavelli and Women ............................................................. Jo Ann Cavallo
123
Masculinity and Machiavelli ...................................................... Gerry Milligan
149
viii
contents
Machiavelli on Stage: Mandragola and Clizia .............................. Salvatore Di Maria
173
Debauchery, Mayhem, and Sex in Machiavelli’s Mandragola .................................................................................... Salvino Bizzarro
199
The Mask in the Mirror: Nicomaco as an Imprudent Ruler-Prince in the Clizia ........................................................... Patricia Vilches
219
To Hell with Men and Meaning! Vesting Authority in Belfagor ......................................................................................... Sante Matteo
245
RECEPTION Historical Reception of Machiavelli .......................................... Mary Walsh
273
Machiavelli the Revolutionary: A Modern Reinterpretation .... Susan A. Ashley
303
Marlowe’s Tamburlaine: Idealized Machiavellian Prince .......... Joseph Khoury
329
Shakespeare and Machiavelli: The Prince and the History Plays ............................................................................................ John Roe
357
Machiavelli, Thucydides, and the Anglo-American Tradition ..................................................................................... William E. Klein
389
Machiavelli in the Modern World ............................................. RoseAnna Mueller
421
Index ...........................................................................................
443
EDITORS’ PREFACE
The sixteen chapters of this volume present a perspective on Machiavelli that is intended to be benecial simultaneously to an audience of generalists seeking background and reference material and to specialists who are interested in examining and/or discovering critical thinking on Machiavelli from a variety of disciplinary angles and points of view. Our goal, as editors, has been to be broad, not narrow, in our presentation because the work of Machiavelli demands such an approach. Indeed, no single discipline in the academy can claim Machiavelli exclusively: political science and government, history, literature, language, theatre, philosophy—Machiavelli is, for each of these elds, an important and inuential thinker, and the reader will nd all of them represented in this collection. In addition to disciplinary breadth, we have also sought to widen the scholarly lens on Machiavelli to include the work of scholars from countries beyond the United States and Italy, such as France, England, Canada, and Australia. Contributors to our volume are connected to leading research universities and institutions, such as Columbia, Indiana, the University at Albany, New York University, Miami University of Ohio, and the University of Tennessee in the United States; the Centre National de Recherche Scientique (CNRS) in France, the University of York, England, the University of Canberra, Australia, St. Francis Xavier University, Canada; and American colleges and liberal arts colleges such as St. John’s (Minnesota), Colorado College, Columbia College (Chicago), the College of Staten Island, CUNY, Lawrence University, and Ripon College. The diversity of the various institutions represented here is an indication of the great wealth of intellectual resources that can be marshaled in support of creative inquiry and high-quality scholarship. We are indeed fortunate to have so many dedicated and insightful colleagues. After an Introduction that provides an overview of Machiavelli’s life and times, this volume is divided into three sections: Government, Society, and Reception. No single section is exhaustive in its coverage, and the volume intentionally does not construe itself as an encyclopedia or compendium of scholarship on every aspect of Machiavelli’s career. Some readers may be disappointed to nd that the section on Government
x
editors’ preface
does not include chapters that are explicitly dedicated to The Art of War or to Machiavelli’s letters. Neither of these important works is ignored, of course. But, our choice to focus on The Prince and The Discourses on Livy, we believe, is a defensible one. These are, in fact, the key Machiavellian treatises on government, and the tensions and connections between the two coalesce into an indisputable crux for understanding the purpose and inuence of our author. The entries by Marie GailleNikodimov, Charles Tarlton, Julia Bondanella, and Eugene Garver in this section provide a rich perspective on this stage of Machiavelli’s writing and career. A mix of overview and incisive analysis, these chapters carefully respect our overall goal of speaking both to the student and to the specialist. The section on Society can be thought of in two pieces, one focused on gender, the other on theatre. The initial two entries, by Jo Ann Cavallo and Gerry Milligan, provide a broad and deep analysis of gender in Machiavelli. Revealing and understanding the role and place of masculinity and women in Machiavelli’s writings is crucial to our ability to contextualize and make sense of Machiavelli’s thought and discourse both in his times and in ours. The subsequent entries, by Salvatore Di Maria, Salvino Bizzarro, Patricia Vilches, and Sante Matteo, analyze Machiavelli’s creative work for the stage: the Mandragola, Clizia, and Belfagor. The curious reader might ask why we have chosen to group these particular chapters under the heading Society. Generally speaking, we have done so because each scholar looks at the theatre as a form that stages a Machiavellian reection on the attitudes, behaviors, and mores that prevailed among his contemporaries. That Machiavelli’s preferred theatrical mode was comedy should not go unnoticed. And it may suggest that, to establish a sufcient amount of critical distance between the author and his piercing observations on Florentine life, Machiavelli felt it necessary to make recourse to ction—however thin the actual veil on reality—and to levity—however serious the subject and however biting the critique. The chapters in the nal section of this volume are grouped under the heading of Reception and offer perspectives on the inuence, the uses and ( perhaps) the abuses of Machiavelli that reach beyond his native Italy and extend into the Anglo-American world. In some ways, this section is by necessity the most open-ended of the volume and provides a set of boundaries for fertile elds of future work. Seeing, in the entries by Joseph Khoury and John Roe, the impact of Machiavelli in the works of Marlowe and Shakespeare provocatively suggests a direc-
editors’ preface
xi
tion for further inquiry on the place of Machiavelli in other literatures, cultures, and times. Susan Ashley’s piece on Machiavelli and Gramsci shows that Machiavelli is truly something more than a political abstraction in the modern world. Mary Walsh, William Klein, and RoseAnna Mueller offer wide-ranging overviews of the inuence of Machiavelli on history and government, his place in contemporary texts and discourse, and his connections to political traditions in England and the United States. Whether student or scholar, the reader will nd something in this section that speaks forcefully to the enduring presence of Machiavelli and his thought in the construction and elaboration of political, historical, and social thinking in our contemporary life. Machiavelli famously wrote that, with his offer of The Prince to Lorenzo, his highness should “consider it and read it with attention.” It is in a similar spirit that we offer this not-so-little “libello” on Machiavelli in the hope that it too may offer some small benet to individuals as they pursue their studies and their lives and as they invariably confront Fortuna e Virtù. Heeding Machiavelli’s advice, we have attempted to follow the lion and the fox, with strong and intelligent arguments, and thus to overcome the wolves and avoid the traps. As you judge the measure of our success, please take this book “con quello animo che [noi] lo mand[iamo].” Patricia Vilches and Gerald Seaman Appleton, Wisconsin, U.S.A. December 2006
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
In preparing this volume, we have received support—professional, material, emotional, and otherwise—from many people and places. Our gratitude is great and wide-ranging, greater than any few small words on a page can encompass. That said, we would like to thank explicitly our family and friends and our colleagues, especially those whose essays follow in this book, for their patience and understanding, and for their kind attention to the sorts of deadlines and constraints that can make publishing a collection with multiple authors, shall we say, complicated. Our editors at Brill have been extraordinarily gracious in helping us to manage such a circumstance and in guiding this book to its nal form. This form is also largely due to the tireless effort of Joanne Johnson, whose assistance with proof-reading and formatting the nal manuscript was invaluable and indispensable. We are grateful to Italica and its editor, Andrea Ciccarelli, for permission to reprint Sante Matteo’s “To Hell with Men and Meaning! Vesting Authority in Machiavelli’s Belfagor.” Likewise, we are grateful to Marie Gaille-Nikodimov and the Librairie Générale Française for permission to translate and adapt her French Introduction to The Prince. Finally, we would like to thank Lawrence University and Ripon College for providing us with grant support and intellectual sustenance. It is our hope that this book reects the immeasurably positive qualities that permeate the scholarly atmosphere and environment of these two ne American liberal arts colleges.
CONTRIBUTORS
Susan A. Ashley is Professor of History and Dean of the College/Dean of the Faculty at Colorado College. She published Making Liberalism Work: The Italian Experience, 1860–1914 in 2003 (Greenwood Press) and is currently completing a study of French and Italian visions of marginality in late nineteenth and early twentieth century France and Italy. Other publications include an examination of the serial murderer, Joseph Vacher. (Vincent, K. Steven and Alison Klairmont-Lingo, eds. The Human Tradition in Modern France, “Vacher the Ripper of the Southwest,” 83–98, Wilmington, DE: Scholarly Resources, 2000.) Salvatore Bizzarro is Professor of Romance Languages at the Colorado College, having also served as Director of the Italian in Italy Program from 1990 to the present, and having participated twice in the Associated Colleges of the Midwest Program in Florence, Italy, devoted mostly to Renaissance Art and Literature. He has written an important volume on the poetry of Pablo Neruda, Pablo Neruda/All poets the Poet, published by Scarecrow Press in 1979; has contributed as author and Associate Editor to an equally important publication on Latin America, Latin America During Nixon’s Second Term, published by the American College in Paris (1976); and his third edition of the Historical Dictionary of Chile (rst published by Scarecrow Press in 1972; with a second edition in 1986 and the third in 2005) is a truly major reference work, with excellent-cross references that balance entries on history, geography, politics, economics, literature, art, and biography, giving us a view of ancient and modern Chile. He has contributed several sections to Encyclopedias and numerous articles for scholarly journals. Julia Conaway Bondanella is Professor of French and Italian at Indiana University. She is the author of Petrarch’s Visions and Their Renaissance Analogues and co-editor of the Cassell Dictionary of Italian Literature. She is translator and co-editor of the Norton Critical Edition of Rousseau’s Political Writings. For Oxford University Press, she has translated, edited, annotated, and introduced Giorgio Vasari’s Lives of the Most Famous Artists, Machiavelli’s Discourses on Livy, and Benvenuto Cellini’s My Life with Peter Bondanella. For Barnes and Noble’s Classics Series, she has co-edited, annotated, and introduced the Longfellow translation
xvi
contributors
of Dante’s Purgatorio and Paradiso. She is author of a variety of articles on Medieval and Renaissance topics. She has served as Executive Secretary of the American Association for Italian Studies; President of the National Collegiate Honors Council; Assistant Chairman for Programs of the National Endowment for the Humanities; and, for over two decades, as Associate Dean of Indiana University’s Hutton Honors College. Jo Ann Cavallo is Associate Professor of Italian at Columbia University. She is the author of Boiardo’s Orlando Innamorato: An Ethics of Desire (Associated University Presses, 1993), The Romance Epics of Boiardo, Ariosto, and Tasso: From Public Duty to Private Pleasure (University of Toronto Press, 2004), and co-editor of Fortune and Romance: Boiardo in America (Medieval and Renaissance Texts and Studies, 1998). She has also published articles on early Christian and gnostic literature (the Gospel of Matthew and the Gospel of Truth), on Italian authors from the medieval to the modern period (Dante, Petrarch, Boiardo, Ariosto, Castiglione, Machiavelli, Tasso, Giordano Bruno, and Elsa Morante), and on folk traditions that dramatize epic narratives (Sicilian puppet theater and the epic Maggio of the Tuscan-Emilian Apennines). Salvatore Di Maria received his early education in the Italian public schools, the BA in French from the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, the PhD in Italian from the University of Wisconsin in 1978, and has been teaching at the University of Tennessee since 1985. In 1984, he co-authored with Robert Rodini, a book on Ariosto (Univ. of Missouri Press), and has since written articles on various authors, ranging from Dante, Boccaccio, Machiavelli, Bandello, Cecchi, and many others. Recently, he published The Italian Tragedy (Bucknell, 2002) and is presently working on the originality of imitation in the Renaissance Theater. Marie Gaille-Nikodimov is a researcher for the National Center for Scientic Research (CNRS) and works in the Research Center on Meaning, Ethics and Society (CERSES, Paris, France). She has translated Il Principe in French (Le Prince, Le Livre de Poche, 2000), published a study on the theory of civil conict in Machiavelli’s work (Conit civil et liberté. La pensée machiavélienne entre histoire et medicine, Champion, 2004), and edited with Th. Ménissier Lectures de Machiavel (Ellipses, 2005).
contributors
xvii
Eugene Garver is Regents Professor of Philosophy at Saint John’s University. He is author of Machiavelli and the History of Prudence (University of Wisconsin Press, 1987), and, more recently, Confronting Aristotle’s Ethics: Ancient and Modern Morality (University of Chicago Press, 2006), and For the Sake of Argument: Practical Reasoning, Character and the Ethics of Belief (University of Chicago Press, 2004). Joseph Khoury is Assistant Professor in the Department of English at St. Francis Xavier University. He received his PhD in Comparative Literature from Carleton University, Ottawa, Canada. His main interests are Machiavelli, Shakespeare, Marlowe, Political Philosophy, Literary Theory, Theories of Inuence, and Comparative Literature. Joseph is now preparing a critical edition of Barnabe Riche’s romance, The Adventures of Brusanius, Prince of Hungaria, a source text for Shakespeare’s Measure for Measure. Joseph’s most recent article outlines William Thomas’s plagiarism of Machiavelli (in Carmine Di Biase, ed., Travel and Translation in the Early Modern Period, New York and Amsterdam: Rodopi, 2006). William E. Klein teaches the history of political discourse in New York University’s General Studies Program and in the Honors Program. He writes on a range of topics, from Renaissance political thought to constitutional history to modern crime. Sante Matteo, Professor of Italian and Coordinator of Italian Studies at Miami University, in Oxford, Ohio, was born in Italy, in Petrella Tifernina (CB), graduated with a BA in French from Kenyon College, and received a PhD in Italian from the Johns Hopkins University. His publications include books on Foscolo and Manzoni and articles spanning all periods of Italian literature and culture, including cinema. In 1998 he convened an international symposium on Africa and Italy that spawned two edited collections of essays: one published in Italy in Italian, Africa Italia: Due continenti si avvicinano (Fara, 1999), and a larger volume in English, ItaliAfrica: Bridging Continents and Cultures (Forum italicum, 2001). More recently, in the summer of 2006, one of his research interests, Marco Polo’s legacy in Italian culture, took him on a two-month trek along the Silk Road through Central Asia, from China to Turkey.
xviii
contributors
Gerry Milligan is Assistant Professor of Italian at the College of Staten Island, CUNY, where he teaches courses on women writers and Renaissance Italian literature. He has written several articles on masculinity in the Italian Renaissance, and his current research focuses on gender and warfare. RoseAnna Mueller received her PhD in Comparative Literature from the City University of New York Graduate School. She teaches Italian and humanities at Columbia College Chicago. She has taught Machiavelli in “Crisis and Creativity: the Italian Renaissance” at the Santa Reparata School of International Art in Florence. She is a contributor to Voices in Italian Americana, Italica, and the Renaissance Quarterly. John Roe is Reader in English & Related Literature at the University of York, UK. He is the 2006–07 Visiting Gillespie Professor of English at The College of Wooster, Ohio. He has recently published an updated edition of Shakespeare: The Poems for Cambridge University Press (2006), and he is the author of Shakespeare and Machiavelli (Cambridge: D. S. Brewer, 2002). Gerald Seaman is Professor of Romance and Classical Languages and VP/Dean of Faculty at Ripon College. He received his MA and PhD from Stanford University and his BA from the University of Wisconsin—Madison. Mr. Seaman has studied in France at the École Normale Supérieure (Paris) and the Institut d’Études Politiques (Aix-en-Provence) and has published and presented widely on medieval and early modern French and Italian literature. Charles D. Tarlton is Professor Emeritus in the Department of Political Science, The University at Albany, Albany, New York. He has, over the years, written about Locke, Hobbes, and Machiavelli. He is currently researching the connection between politics and autobiography in Rousseau. He lives with his wife, Ann, in Normandy. Patricia Vilches received her PhD in Romance Languages and Literatures from the University of Chicago. Her concentration was Italian Renaissance treatises and Spanish Golden Age prose. She has published and presented at conferences on the works of Niccolò Machiavelli, and her research now concentrates on Machiavelli and the New World. She is an Associate Professor of Spanish and Italian at Lawrence University.
contributors
xix
Mary Walsh is a Senior Lecturer in Political Theory and Politics at the University of Canberra, Australia. She is the convenor of the Bachelor of Philosophy Honours Program and teaches Politics and Democracy, Introduction to Government, and Identity Politics. She has previously taught at the University of Queensland, Grifth University, and the Queensland University of Technology. Dr. Walsh has published several journal articles and book chapters in the areas of political theory, democratic theory, feminist theory, and Australian politics. Current publications appear in Contemporary Political Theory and Philosophy in the Contemporary World. Dr. Walsh is currently completing work on Hannah Arendt and Simone de Beauvoir and is the author of the forthcoming book Introducing Political Theory.
THE ENDURING POWER OF NICCOLÒ MACHIAVELLI: AN OVERVIEW OF HIS LIFE AND TIMES Patricia Vilches
I. Machiavelli’s Redemption Niccolò Machiavelli wrote his political masterpieces within closed chambers and while in exile. He made a commitment to examine “the material things that are available to the human senses.”1 He determined not to follow the rationalizations of classical Western philosophers who afrmed that truth derived from “reason and/or revelation.”2 Machiavelli, then, refused to live in a Neoplatonic cave because he desired to gure the concrete truth of the matter; after him, the papal and secular courts had to digest and reckon with his separation of the exemplary from the necessary. As Sebastian de Grazia states so brilliantly, Machiavelli uncovered new territories; he was an explorer of the human psyche and followed “a path not yet tread by anyone, seeking new ordering principles, ‘to nd new modes and orders.’ ”3 Today, his thoughts live out in the public sphere and clearly illuminate social and political conduct in the Western World. Machiavelli’s ideas about human interactions are ever present in our society.4 Political struggles that take place either in the international community or in the domestic realm unambiguously demonstrate the cunning acts of the generality of men in which only “a few will judge with their hands.”5 Individuals, then, enact, on a macro and micro social stage, Machiavelli’s observations about human nature. Hence, his ideas have immediacy and appear contemporaneous.
1 Robert A. Kocis, Machiavelli Redeemed: Retrieving His Humanist Perspectives on Equality, Power, and Glory (Bethelem: Lehigh University Press and London: Associated University Presses, 1998), 43. 2 Ibid. 3 Machiavelli in Hell (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 1989), 21. 4 See, for instance, Anthony Jay, Management and Machiavelli: An Inquiry into the Politics of Corporate Life (New York: Holts, Rinehart, & Winston, 1968, 1967). 5 De Grazia points to the fact that Machiavelli refers to men’s bad ways in general and not in particular. The critic observes: “The context of the passage about ‘ungrateful, shifty’ men makes a distinction in time of circumstance,” 105–106.
2
patricia vilches
The reections we nd in Machiavelli are those of a humanist steeped in classical Western tradition. His work teaches us that our free will allows us to control at least half of our human affairs; the other half belongs to Lady Fortuna.6 If we follow his advice, we must “remain exible and intellectually alert to rapid political and social change.”7 We must act like the fox and the lion; with the cunning of the fox and the strength of the lion, we must seek to beat adversity. We must use virtù (strength, prowess, etc.), a concept deeply rooted in classical tradition, to be prepared to react accordingly when Lady Fortuna is ready to strike. We must not be afraid, for she favors vigor in an individual; we must act physically young at heart; we should never let our guard down, for the world is in continuous strife and, to win over fate, one has to be ready to act. Machiavelli has been called a philosopher, the founder of political science in the Western world, a republican, reactionary, proto-Marxist, devil worshipper, etc., to name just a few of the different ways in which individuals have reacted to or (mis)interpreted him. For Maurizio Viroli, however, Machiavelli was not a political scientist but a rescuer of the Romans’ civil wisdom, a magnicent rhetorician who could ascertain “political reality by uncovering meanings that were not immediately visible but which could be identied.”8 His texts, then, must be uncovered by the very few individuals who can see through what really transpires in the course of human behavior and events. In order to accomplish that task, humans must use shrewd tactics and, in following the path of the great, be innovators.9 In the Anglo-Saxon world, there is a tendency to differentiate and nd the “real” Machiavelli in The Discourses, which antecedes “modern Western democracies.”10 One thing is for certain: his writings have affected political, philosophical, and literary ideas positively or negatively. No
6 See Quentin Skinner, Machiavelli (New York: Hill and Wang, 1981). Skinner states that “Machiavelli’s most graphic image for this sense of man as the master of his fate is again classical in inspiration. He stresses that “Fortune is a woman” and is in consequence readily allured by many qualities. So he sees a genuine possibility of making oneself the ally of Fortune, of learning to act in harmony with her powers, neutralizing her varying nature and thus remaining successful in all one’s affairs,” 28. 7 Peter Bondanella and Julia Conaway Bondanella. Introduction and translation. Niccolò Machiavelli’s Discourses on Livy (New York: Oxford University Press, 1997), xv. 8 Maurizio Viroli, Machiavelli (Oxford & New York: Oxford University Press, 1998), 2. 9 Leo Strauss, Thoughts on Machiavelli (Glencoe, IL: The Free Press, 1958), 73. 10 Francesco Bausi, Machiavelli (Roma: Salerno Editrice, 2005), 15.
the enduring power of niccolò machiavelli
3
one who has read his texts has remained unmoved. As expected, those of us contributing to a companion to Machiavelli studies are profoundly and positively moved by Machiavelli’s original and visionary thoughts on human relationships. How did he conceive his political ideas? He did so by long study of ancient Rome’s political leaders’ actions and through his own experience as a secretary for the Second Chancery in the Florentine republic. Machiavelli’s ideas cannot be easily catalogued or quickly dened. Harvey C. Manseld and Nathan Tarcov state, “[ he] did not write in such a mode as to prevent dispute about what he said.”11 For instance, Machiavelli wrote The Prince, his most well-known text in which he instructs heads of state on how to keep absolute power in newly acquired territories, and he composed The Discourses on Livy, a text that adheres to republicanism and to the right of the people to be free from political tyranny. Both texts were published after his death in 1532 and 1531 respectively. How could one person engage in such diverse political thinking? What should we make of the fact that The Prince and The Discourses were written within a short interval of each other? How do we reconcile such opposing views on statecraft? Some scholars contend that the segretario interrupted The Prince to initiate The Discourses, adding the last chapter of The Prince at a later date. According to John Najemy, we can only presume to identify the precise occasione that was at hand when the secretario wrote the “Exhortation to Seize Italy and Free Her from the Barbarians.”12 Furthermore, Manseld and Tarcov contend that the contrast in the two political treatises is not that deep because underneath it all, The Prince is partly republican, and The Discourses are partly princely and tyrannical.13 From a rhetorical viewpoint, because Machiavelli sought a “partisan truth,” he permitted himself to write “The Prince to give advice to a prince on how to secure his state, and The Discourses on Livy to instruct his compatriots on how to order and govern a free republic.”14 At the core, then, is Machiavelli’s originality
11
Harvey C. Manseld and Nathan Tarcov, Niccolò Machiavelli Discourses on Livy (Chicago & London: The University of Chicago Press, 1996), xvii. All quotations from the Discourses are from this text. 12 Between Friends: Discourses of Power and Desire in the Machiavelli-Vettori Letters of 1513–1515. (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 1993), 179. 13 Ibid., xxii. Manseld and Tarcov argue that The Prince does not only address heads of state, “it does not endorse principalities or tyrannies over republics in the way that The Discourses recommends republics over principalities or tyrannies,” xxii. 14 Viroli, Machiavelli, 3. Viroli is adamant to set the record straight about Machiavelli’s
4
patricia vilches
in excising moral ethics and religious favor from discussions of political and social action. In their place, the secretary deals almost exclusively with the concrete. Maurizio Viroli states that Machiavelli detractors of the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries called him “the corrupter of the true (Aristotelian) ideas of politics.”15 What Machiavelli had to offer was not pretty. For this reason, perhaps, he might have expected a negative reaction to his advice to rulers because it was in some ways unsavory. As an outcast, the former segretario did not have much to lose and so endeavored to impart truth and wisdom about the need for concealment in a topsyturvy world. In this respect, Robert A. Kocis afrms, “the concrete world is always a bit ‘messier’ than the world of ideas.”16 Through his experience and vast reading of classical history, the segretario analyzed with gusto the messy ways of human interactions in which individuals take responsibility and act with autonomy.17 Machiavelli himself tells us with pride that he is not interested in following the trendy and erudite ways of his time. On the contrary, he tells his readers in chapter 15 of The Prince that his approach to his text does not follow traditional guidelines; hence, he adds, “I fear that, when I too write about it, I shall be thought conceited, since in discussing this material I depart very far from the methods of the others.”18 What matters for him are ideas that will trigger action and, thus, declares that “I have decided that I must concern myself with the truth of the matter as facts show it rather than with any fanciful notion” (15, 57). With this statement, he brushes aside traditionally fawning manifestoes and replaces them with practical and useful political advice for rulers. In this sense, he is a revolutionary of the mind. It should not surprise us, then, that in his political texts, the segretario advises rulers to dissociate themselves from ethical and religious comportment for reasons of state. Gone are the Neo-Platonic ideals of a Speculum of princes, since
being a consummate rhetorician who could use ornate words to persuade. Hence, he states, we should not be puzzled that the segretario wrote for two different audiences. “The great puzzle that has tormented so many interpreters is, in fact, no puzzle at all, if we read [The Prince and The Discourses] for what they are—namely, two exemplary texts of political rhetoric,” 3. 15 From Politics to Reason of State: The Acquisition and Transformation of the Language of Politics 1250–1600 (Cambridge & New York: Cambridge University Press, 1992), 127. 16 Kocis, 44. 17 Ibid., 45. 18 All quotations from The Prince are from The Chief Works and Others. Ed. and trans. Allan Gilbert. Fourth Ed., 3 vols. (Durham: Duke University Press, 1965), 57.
the enduring power of niccolò machiavelli
5
one must confront the verità effettuale or, as Gilbert translates it, “the truth of the matter” of the political arena. In fact, Machiavelli praises contemporary rulers who, in the name of ethics and religion, have conquered new territories precisely by eschewing moral and religious conduct. Among them, Ferdinand of Aragon stands out, “[who] never preaches anything except peace and truth, and to both of them he is utterly opposed. Either one, if he had practiced it, would many times have taken from him either his reputation or his power” (18, 67). The uniqueness of Machiavelli is that he devises his political ideas by rationalizing concealment within displays of exemplary behavior by rulers. Using this device, he creates the modern prince.
II. Machiavelli’s Time and Place Machiavelli’s life spanned strenuous political times for the Italian states. When he was born, on May 3, 1469, Italy could only look with longing on its glorious past. Niccolò di Bernardo Machiavelli descended from a family of noble background that held political clout in Florence. His father Bernardo, however, had chosen to pursue the study of the classics and had neglected to become more active in politics.19 Machiavelli’s mother was Bartolommea di Stefano Nelli. Though noble, Machiavelli’s family was by no means wealthy; hence, “his prospects were modest at best”20 Being an avid humanist himself, Bernardo, notwithstanding his lack of material means, moved in the right circles of Florence and instilled in young Niccolò a love for the classics. Bernardo gave his son the tools to become, among other professions, a political philosopher and a playwright.21
19 De Grazia reports in detail the familial background of Machiavelli: “Niccolò’s paternal grandfather, Niccolò di Buoninsegna, died a bachelor. On his deathbed he legitimated a natural child, Bernardo, as his son and charged a brother with raising him. This Bernardo, our Niccolò’s father, administered the modest family estate (not always managing to stay in the black) and was evidently a man for good conversation,” 5. 20 The Portable Machiavelli. Ed. and trans. Peter Bondanella and Mark Musa (New York: Penguin Books, 2005, 1979), 9. Bondanella and Musa declare: “But if Bernardo’s means were insufcient to guarantee his son instant access to economic and political power, his great interest in books, particularly the Latin classics, was perhaps a more valuable legacy. We know that he possessed a copy of Flavio Biondo’s Decades, that he borrowed a copy of Justin’s history, and that he obtained a prized copy of Livy’s history of republican Rome in return for laboriously compiling for the printer an index of Livy’s place-names,” 9. 21 Skinner, in analyzing Bernardo Machiavelli’s diary, states that “in spite of the
6
patricia vilches
The year 1494 is of particular interest to Machiavelli biographers. J. R. Hale afrms: “The period from the invasion of Italy in 1494 by Charles VIII of France, when Machiavelli was twenty-four, to the savage sack of Rome by the troops of Charles V in 1527, the year of Machiavelli’s death, wrenched the course of the peninsula’s history so sharply from its track that contemporaries looked at their own world with the same amazed interest that an astronomer might show were the moon suddenly to reveal its back.”22 In truth, the Italian Early Modern period bestowed upon Western thought humanistic jewels in science, arts, and letters which inuenced the rest of Europe and eventually the New World. The politically divided Italian nation-states, on the other hand, were at the same time subdued by the politically powerful nations of France and Spain. Machiavelli, as a studious reader of the past, was a true patriot who reected on and wrote about Rome’s political success and saw it again in the contemporary examples of France and Spain. He adamantly sought both a united Italy and a united militia that would be able to repel and subdue foreign invasion. For Machiavelli, political liberty can be obtained through astute negotiations that will have a favorable outcome for a nation state. His ideas clearly demonstrate the contradictory philosophies of the Italian Renaissance, a time of acute critical thought during which moral values were modied in order to reconcile a growing sense of individual liberty with religious restrictions. Religious treatises were still in demand, but intellectuals were more interested in rediscovering and understanding the individual of antiquity and of the natural world that surrounds us.23 In this connection, Jacob Burckhardt depicts Italy as an ebullient place above morality and religion, with a considerably hedonistic thirst
large expense involved—which he anxiously itemized—he was careful to provide his son with an excellent grounding in the studia humanitatis. We rst hear of Machiavelli’s education immediately after his seventh birthday when his father records that ‘my little son Niccolò has started to go to Master Matteo’ for the rst stage of his formal schooling, the study of Latin. By the time Machiavelli was twelve he had graduated to the second stage, and had passed into the care of a famous school-master, Paolo da Ronciglione, who taught several of the most illustrious humanists of Machiavelli’s generation,” 5. 22 J. R. Hale, Machiavelli and Renaissance Italy (New York: MacMillan Company, 1960), 1. 23 See Federico Chabod, Machiavelli and the Renaissance. Trans. David Moore (Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1960), esp. chapter 4, “The Concept of the Renaissance.”
the enduring power of niccolò machiavelli
7
for knowledge.24 On the other hand, Hans Baron asserts that cultural ourishing comes accompanied by servitude to foreign tyrants.25 Just like Machiavelli’s supposedly opposing political ideas in The Prince and The Discourses, contradictory perceptions of Renaissance Italy are tightly intertwined. This fact helps us to understand better that Machiavelli, whose name has been associated with Old Nick, was at the same time considered a staunch patriot, a moralist, and a conservative. Machiavelli initiated his political career in the wake of the failed government of Frate Girolamo Savonarola, who ruled Florence with an iron hand from 1494–1498.26 The Dominican friar’s successful tenure reected a perceived moral decay and a desire for social change in the republic.27 In truth, Savonarola embraced the beliefs of future European religious Reformers and opposed the materialistic turn taken by the ofcial church. His desire was to make the church return to an idealized time in which there was a direct communion with Christ, without the need for human intervention. In Florence, he presided over the infamous Bonre of the Vanities, burning any item deemed prone to incite moral laxities: women’s mirrors, silk dresses, erotic poetry ( judged so by Savonarola), etc. The Dominican friar’s ruthless purity and unabashed
24 The Civilization of the Renaissance in Italy. Trans. S. G. C. Middlemore (New York: Albert and Charles Boni, 1935), 426–443. 25 Hans Baron, The Crisis of the Early Italian Renaissance: Civic Humanism and Republican Liberty in an Age of Classicism and Tyranny (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 1966). 26 Viroli, in chapter 2 of From Politics to Reasons of State, discusses Savonarola’s Tratatto del reggimento di Firenze, “a work designed to set the guidelines for the new republican constitution . . .” In his treatise, “Savonarola gives the traditional concept of a political regime, a decided republican thrust, stressing at the same time that only a true ‘civil government’ may succeed to prevent the rise of tyranny and protect the most precious good of liberty,” 122. 27 Burckhardt dedicates an entire section of his book to “Morality and Religion.” Under the heading “Morality and Immorality,” the critic afrms: “At the beginning of the sixteenth century, when the civilization of the Renaissance had reached its highest pitch, and at the same time the political ruin of the nation seemed inevitable, there were not wanting serious thinkers who saw a connection between this ruin and the prevalent immorality. It was not one of those methodical moralists who in every age think themselves called to declaim against the wickedness of the time, but it was Machiavelli, who, in one of his best-considered works, said openly: ‘We Italians are irreligious and corrupt above others.’ Another man would perhaps have said, ‘We are individually highly developed; we have outgrown the limits of morality and religion which were natural to us in our undeveloped state, and we despise outward law, because our rulers are illegitimate, and their judges and ofcers wicked men.’ Machiavelli adds, ‘because the church and her representatives set us the worst example,’ ” 262.
8
patricia vilches
commitment to his religious agenda nally turned on him. Both the papacy and the Florentines saw him as a liability. Machiavelli was a witness of Savonarola’s horrible death and tells us in The Prince that the religious leader failed politically because he was “unarmed; hence he was destroyed amid his institutions when they were still new” (6, 27). Savonarola’s execution facilitated Machiavelli’s entrance into the realm of politics in the Second Chancery of the Florentine Republic. He was twenty-nine. He exemplied, then, the ideal ruler because he had the virtù or the chops to perform at a high level as second chancellor of the republic, and he also had the Fortuna of being his father’s son. Clearly, Machiavelli became a favorite to win the political post, not because of inuential and powerful familial ties but because his father had imbued him with a strong humanistic background. Machiavelli had read the classics and was immersed in Roman tradition, especially in Ciceronian rhetoric. He displayed mastery in Latin and had been taught moral philosophy. Thus, we can say that, since his family did not hold the social clout of other more prominent Florentine families, Niccolò rose in Florentine politics on the strength of his intellect and his background as a scholar, not by connection or nepotism. He was the right man for the job. The Italian nation states were at that time so vulnerable that Machiavelli’s diplomatic career abruptly ended with the collapse of the Soderini government and the return of the Medici in 1512. For fourteen years, however, the segretario had pursued a very successful career and acquired a wealth of knowledge that would benet him greatly when it came time to reect on political leadership. He proclaims, in his texts, that most of the decay in Italy was caused by the excessive power of the church over the Italian territories, and that the more Christian a nation appeared the less religious it acted. Powerful nations adhered to the church’s tenets in name only. The Roman court, he declares in The Discourses, had kept the Italian territory divided, and “because of the wicked examples of that court, this province has lost all devotion and all religion” (I.12, 38). By keeping the territories divided, there was no desire to ght for one’s land, and there was no sense of “political virtue” in Italians.28 Foreign invasions were frequent, and Italians had to depend on mercenary armies who did not engage in heroism because they were not ghting for their own nation or patria. Having a militia, then,
28
Chabod, 62.
the enduring power of niccolò machiavelli
9
became a major preoccupation for Machiavelli, who fought for the development of one in Florence and had to contend with the wrath of opposing factions when Florence’s sovereignty was at stake. He makes the case adamantly in The Prince: “The mercenary and the auxiliary are useless and dangerous; if a prince continues to base his government on mercenary armies he will never be either stable or safe; they are disunited, ambitious, without discipline, disloyal; valiant among friends, among enemies cowardly; they have no fear to God, no loyalty to men” (12, 47). Machiavelli was pessimistic about human nature. He tells us, in The Prince, that a ruler cannot “keep [ ] his promises and live [ ] with sincerity” if he wants to keep his realm (18, 64). A prudent prince must conceal and pretend to keep promises: because men “are bad and do not keep their promises to you, you likewise do not have to keep yours to them” (18, 65). In fact, Machiavelli’s pessimism about human nature makes the harsh reality of his times more acute to the eye of the reader. He speaks of a general illness that existed in his time and presents a recurrent metaphor of a medico searching for a cure for such an illness. In order to nd the right medico, “Italy needed to be brought to her present condition, to be more slave than the Hebrews, more servant than the Persians, more scattered than the Athenians, without head, without order, beaten, despoiled, lacerated, devastated, subject to every sort of ruination” (26, 93). Machiavelli’s most admired leaders are the ones who, like Cesare Borgia, did not disclose their intentions and favored necessary duplicity to accomplish their political strategies. In his career as a diplomat, Machiavelli came into contact with the newly installed duke of Romagna when Borgia demanded to be formally aligned with Florence, and Machiavelli was chosen by the chancery for the delicate ambassadorship. Quentin Skinner maintains that this was Machiavelli’s perfect job because he could be “a rst-hand observer and assessor of contemporary statecraft.”29 In his Legations, as Skinner argues, Machiavelli composed well-developed reections on his mediations with Borgia that were later translated into The Prince. In the Legations, the segretario remarked how the son of Rodrigo Borgia, who became Alexander VI, relied too heavily on Lady Fortuna.30 Borgia’s luck had run out. He had contracted
29 30
Skinner, 9. Ibid., 10.
10
patricia vilches
his father’s malaria or—as it was rumored at the time—was poisoned along with the pope and was facing his own death. For the segretario, as he reported to the Ten of War, Borgia erred after his father’s death in giving his support for the papacy to cardinal Giuliano della Rovere, a bitter enemy of Alexander VI who was forced into exile when Rodrigo Borgia became pope. Once elected to the papacy, della Rovere took the name Julius II, and “Machiavelli watched [ Julius II and Borgia] these two masters of duplicity beginning to circle around one another . . . [demonstrating] that his initial doubts about the duke’s abilities had been thoroughly justied.”31 Shortly, the effects of the election of Julius II took a toll on Borgia, and the Duke Valentino’s interactions in Rome with Machiavelli were not the energetic and positive ones of the past. The segretario quickly realized that the pope was not going to make Borgia Gonfalonier of the Church. The duke was being beaten by Julius II at his own game of not keeping his promises; “he began to feel the ground give way beneath his feet; he was astonished and did not know what to do.”32 The election of Julius II did not augur well for the Florentine republic. After nine years of a tug-of-war between Soderini, France, and Rome, the pope forced Soderini out and helped reinstate the Medici, signaling the end of Machiavelli’s political career. When campaigning, Cardinal della Rovere made promises that he clearly did not keep. The pope has a prominent prole in both The Prince and The Discourses. In The Prince, Machiavelli blamed Borgia for the pope’s election because Julius II, he argued, would turn on Borgia “through fear or hate” (7, 34). Because of his ambassadorial position, Machiavelli saw rsthand how the prelate conducted his business. When discussing “being altogether wicked or altogether good” in The Discourses, the segretario pondered Julius II’s bravura, throwing himself—“by that fury with which he governed all things”—into the enemy hands of the powerful Giovampagolo Baglioni, the tyrant of Perugia. Machiavelli was disappointed by the fact that
31
Ibid., 11. Roberto Ridol, The Life of Niccolò Machiavelli. Trans. Cecil Grayson (London: Routledge & Kegan Paul, 1963), 71. Through letters to the Ten of War, Machiavelli gives a detailed account of the doomed Duca Valentino: “Of his hero’s nal steps to ruin, Machiavelli ironically remarks: ‘We see that this Pope is beginning to pay his debts honourably; he wipes them out with the cotton-wool from the inkstand. Nevertheless his hands are blessed by all.’ And two days later, speaking again of Borgia’s fortunes: ‘One can see that his sins have brought him little by little to penance.’ Finally he wrote: ‘And so, inch by inch, the Duke slips into the tomb.’ Amen,” 72–73. 32
the enduring power of niccolò machiavelli
11
Giovampagolo, “who did not mind being incestuous and a public parricide, did not know how—or, to say better, did not dare, when he had just the opportunity for it—to engage in an enterprise in which everybody would have admired his spirit and that would have left an eternal memory of himself as being the rst who had demonstrated to the prelates how little is to be esteemed whoever lives and reigns as they do; and he would have done a thing whose greatness would have surpassed all infamy, every danger, that could have proceeded from it” (I.27, 63). Machiavelli was closely associated with the government of gonfalonier Soderini, a man who wanted to appear to history as a ruler who did not prot from his political position. The segretario had started his career with the aid of Soderini; likewise, his years as a man of politics ended because of Soderini. After the disaster of Prato, the gonfalonier could not negotiate any terms with his enemies and had to abandon Florence, after securing safe-conduct to Siena. What would be the fate of his segretario? Reacting to a campaign to smear Soderini’s reputation, Machiavelli wrote with passion Ai Palleschi, and, as a result, was abruptly removed from ofce on November 7, 1512. The Ai Palleschi became his last ofcial writing. He was asked to pay a ne and was forbidden to enter the Palazzo, “to which he had to return to account for a great amount of money that he had managed for the battalions of the Ordinanza (translation mine).”33 Furthermore, by the beginning of 1513, his enemies sought retaliation for Machiavelli’s frank ways and prominent participation in the past republic. He was, thus, unjustiably accused of conspiring against the Medici and had to endure torture and exile. This dramatic chapter in Machiavelli’s life was recorded by Francesco Vettori in his Sommario della Istoria d’Italia: Agostino Capponi and Pietropaulo Boscoli conspired to kill Giuliano de’ Medici. And they were discovered because they drew up a list in which they wrote the names of those they believed, after the assassination, would be shown to be on their side . . . And they were so careless that they dropped the list, and it was found and taken to the Cardinal [Giovanni de’ Medici]; and, recognizing names of suspected men, he ordered that not only Pietropaulo and Agostino should be imprisoned, but all the others who were on the list (translation mine).34
33
Ugo Dotti, Machiavelli rivoluzionario: Vita e opera (Roma: Carocci Editori, 2003),
228. 34
Ibid., 237.
12
patricia vilches
Machiavelli’s name appeared seventh on the list of the conspirators. His arrest was imminent, but he was not found at his home, and a proclamation was issued against him. Anybody who had knowledge of his whereabouts had a duty to denounce him. Machiavelli did not hold out for too long; he reported shortly afterwards because he understood that his work in the Second Republic and his later harsh admonitions and defense of Soderini’s deposed republic in the Ai Palleschi made him a persona non grata.35 “Diplomacy’s loss was posterity’s gain” asserts Joseph V. Femia.36 With the demeanor of a spurned lover, Machiavelli, after being pardoned and freed from incarceration, became obsessed with getting back into the political arena when the Medici celebrated their rst pope, Leo X. At this point, Femia observes, “the ad hoc observations of the political participant gave way to a more general theoretical examination of the underlying realities of political action.”37 He no longer had to contend with the realities of a political career which brought him into contact with famous condottieri. That realization did not come easy for Machiavelli, though. After being freed through Vettori’s diplomatic intervention, he urgently attempted to procure himself a position in Leo X’s court. Vettori either could not or did not want to help the former segretario who, in turn, resigned himself to leave Florence to retreat to his family farm in Sant’Andrea in Percussina. Once there, he lived a double life: during the day he went about his business as a normal contadino, and in the evening he vicariously joined the company of illustrious men of the past who instructed him about how governments are led, how they succeed, and how they fail.38
35
Ibid., 238. Machiavelli Revisited (Cardiff: University of Wales Press, 2004), 5. 37 Ibid. 38 Viroli, in Machiavelli, expresses frustration at other critics’ interpretation of the intellectual relationship that Machiavelli established with the ancients: “. . . he repeated over and over again in all his words that the political wisdom of the ancients was far superior to the political ideas of the moderns, and that he wrote all his political works to persuade princes and leaders of republics to imitate the former and avoid the latter. ‘While bowing ironically to the authority of the ancients,’ Harvey C. Manseld has written, ‘Machiavelli in fact uses ancient examples to reproach ancient teaching. He returns to the ancients in order to improve on them.’ This view entirely misrepresents the nature of Machiavelli’s intellectual relationship with the ancients. He treats the ancients not as authorities to be used against other authorities, but as intellectual authorities with whom he shares the commitment and the passion for political wisdom,” 3–4. 36
the enduring power of niccolò machiavelli
13
III. Machiavelli as a Man of Letters Machiavelli was fascinated by history’s protagonists, winners and losers, and strove to make his readings both didactic and pleasurable in the classical tradition.39 For him, the element of the anecdote was an essential aspect of giving advice to a prospective ruler. For this reason, through him we learn about the intimate circumstances that make or destroy a condottiere. These could be especially dramatic, as Cesare Borgia’s case shows. Machiavelli’s exempla, Peter Bondanella afrms, are directly related to practical political activity that he analyzed from a theoretical framework shaped by his own experience and ideas; “they are rarely presented as historical personications of simple vice or virtue.”40 Life is much more complex, and people’s attitudes can have multiple shades. The segretario seems to remind us of this every time that we approach his texts. In his writings on government, Machiavelli showed a notable independence of mind, and he stood by his ideas even when, as Carlo Dionisotti asserts, he was forced to stoop to the newly installed Medici regime, “begging fruitlessly for Medici preferment.”41 Beyond The Prince and The Discourses, Machiavelli’s unique perspective and attitude are also evidenced in his creative works. Literature in Florence, at the time, mimicked political events in the republic and had come into crisis, according to Dionisotti, with Lorenzo de’ Medici’s death in 1494.42 Florence became literarily dependent on other Italian states. Venice and Rome inuenced the way in which literati developed their repertoire and brought into light “the crisis in Florentine literature.” By a sudden stroke, Lady Fortuna made Machiavelli both spectator and participant in this crisis. Dionisotti reects: “. . . born as he was for comedy, he probably enjoyed the spectacle of the writers and philosophers who, having made merry with the Medici, now hastened to beat their breasts with Savonarola, and then were left high and dry, without a clue as to
39
Peter Bondanella, Machiavelli and the Art of Renaissance History (Detroit: Wayne State University Press, 1973), 23. Bondanella emphasizes that for Machiavelli, history “is essentially an educational tool that is also a pleasurable, literary genre with its own proper style and principles of organization. Indeed it is the pleasing form of presentation that alone guarantees the impact of the moral lesson,” 24. 40 Ibid., 25. 41 “Machiavelli, Man of Letters.” Machiavelli and the Discourse of Literature. Ed. Albert Russell Ascoli and Victoria Kahn (Ithaca & London: Cornell University Press, 1993), 20. 42 Ibid., 30.
14
patricia vilches
what to do next.”43 The segretario’s literary formation emulated, then, the development of his political theories which were also an intricate part of all his ction. Unlike some of his contemporaries, Machiavelli not only concentrated on Roman Fine Arts, he also strove to depict a politically glorious Rome and developed his style away from the trend of Petrarchan love poetry, which had a decisively un-Florentine fashion.44 Times of political uncertainty beget politically engaged literati. Unlike Petrarch, who found himself in a rather privileged position and did not see t for a poet to be involved in politics,45 Machiavelli had an afnity with the strong political engagement of poetic predecessors like Dante, who in his Divine Comedy so brilliantly depicted his political enemies in the various circles of Hell. In fact, through his correspondence and in self-mockery, the segretario emulated Dante and placed himself in the roster of well-known poets by sneering at Ludovico Ariosto for not giving him credit as a poet in his Orlando Furioso: Lately I have been reading Ariosto’s Orlando Furioso; the entire poem is really ne and many passages are marvelous. If he is there with you, give him my regards and tell him that my only complaint is that in his mention of so many poets he has left me out like some prick and that he has done to me in his Orlando what I shall not do to him in my Ass.46
With a sardonic comment, Machiavelli made fun of himself as a poet and had the inventiveness to refer to Ariosto in asinine terms, while at the same time promoting his writing of Dell’Asino d’oro, based on Apuleius’s text, 43
Ibid. Ibid., 35. Dionisotti declares: “Machiavelli entered once and for all a path diverging from that of Petrarchan love poetry, which represented the mainstream of the new Italian literature in the fteenth and sixteenth centuries. Critics will reply that his path was naturally and necessarily a different one, that we could never imagine Machiavelli in the garb of a writer like Benivieni or Cei. I do not intend to answer this obvious objection fostered as it is by an awareness of exactly who the ‘one and only’ Machiavelli is. I maintain, instead, that a different method of investigation is more useful: one that considers the various possibilities that Machiavelli was offered but refused. Such a comparative method will help us to account for the unpredictable gestures, the startling inventiveness, the sudden lights, of the one and only Machiavelli.” 45 See John M. Najemy, “Machiavelli and Geta: Men of Letters,” Machiavelli and the Discourse of Literature. Ed. Albert Russell Ascoli and Victoria Kahn (Ithaca & London: Cornell University Press, 1993). Najemy brings about the political engagement of among others, Brunetto Latini and later Leonardo Bruni, intellectuals who stressed the involvement of men of letters in “the civic arena,” 54. 46 This extract is from Letter 254. “Niccolò Machiavelli to Ludovico Alamanni.” Florence, 17 December 1517. Machiavelli and his Friends: Their Personal Correspondence. Trans. and ed. James B. Atkinson and David Sices (DeKalb, IL: Northern Illinois University Press 1996), 318. 44
the enduring power of niccolò machiavelli
15
which he left incomplete. Such a stark assertion bespeaks the author’s readiness to engage in intense literary and political thought. Notwithstanding his perception of himself as a middle-rung poet, Machiavelli phrased his complaint from the dramatic point of view of one who desired membership as a literati while at the same time understanding that Ariosto’s roster of poets was not so illustrious. In his remarks regarding Ariosto, thus, we nd the sardonic and smiling author of La Mandragola, considered one of the best comedies of the Renaissance. Machiavelli included the ckle aspect of Lady Fortuna in all his works of ction. By giving humanity half responsibility for one’s actions, he presented a sense of secular dualism in individuals’ reaction to events.47 From this perspective, if we determine to make good use of what we can control, our turf, we can win even if we have pledged our soul to the devil, a humanistic devil, that is. As it is, in Belfagor, Machiavelli reverses the Christian hell and makes the city of Florence the true hell from which the fallen angel must escape. Belfagor, because of fate, is chosen to carry on with the task of reporting about the misbehavior of women on earth but cannot do his devilish duties because of an insupportable wife. Later on, he is beaten by the astute Giammateo and decides to return to Pluto rather than putting up with his former wife’s nagging or with humanity’s ways in general. With Belfagor, Machiavelli sent us the message that we should concentrate on what we have at hand rather than hope to receive help from divine intervention. If we can control half of what comes to us, we can even beat the devil. Hence, we should not be such fools as to waste our chances. After his illustrious fourteen-year service as a Florentine man of affairs, Machiavelli could never get off the wrong side of Lady Fortuna. Dismissed from his position in the Second Chancery, he was humiliated by his peers and tortured for false accusations of conspiracy. Later on, through his famous Prince, he procured some sustenance for himself and his family through a commission from the Medici to write the Florentine Histories. How could a well-known republican write a history of his beloved city in which he had to glorify despots? He followed his dicta of balancing the delicate path between intention and action: [. . .] Here in the country I have been applying myself, and continue to do so, to writing the history, and I would pay ten soldi—but no more—to have you by my side so that I might show you where I am, because, since
47
Kocis, 47.
16
patricia vilches I am about to come to certain details, I would need to learn from you whether or not I am being too offensive in my exaggerating or understating of the facts. Nevertheless, I shall continue to seek advice from myself, and I shall try to do my best to arrange it so that—still telling the truth—no one will have anything to complain about.48
As with his political treatises, Machiavelli sought to ponder and intertwine historic connections between Florence and ancient Rome. In his dedication to Clement VII, he was extremely careful in his wording and succeeded at both concealing while revealing criticism of the Medici’s historic legacy in Florence. In spite of treading in dangerous territory, he strove to write with a sense of civic duty and equity, transmitting in more adaptable fashion, the thoughts displayed in The Prince and The Discourses.49 The assumption to the Papacy in 1527 of Giuliano de’ Medici as Clement VII made the Medici tenure vulnerable in Florence. Giuliano was a strong ruler, but, in order to advance his career in Rome, he left the governing of the city to inept condottieri who were quickly deposed by the Medici’s increasing enemies. This signaled the beginning of the Third Republic in Florence. As for Machiavelli, who must have rejoiced that his beloved city was again a republic, the political development had a negative impact. Eager to get into the politics of the new republic, the segretario, tragically, was mistrusted and, once again, associated with a deposed regime. Clement VII had his own political calamity to contend with. He was not able to procure the backing of France, thus
48 Letter 285. Atkinson and Sice declare that there is no absolute evidence that Machiavelli’s assertion refers directly to the Florentine Histories. “Niccolò Machiavelli to Francesco Guicciardini,” Machiavelli and His Friends, 351. Michael White presents Machiavelli’s contemporary history as he was communicating to his friend Francesco Guicciardini: “In the world beyond his country retreat the politicians, kings and pontiffs were engaged in their usual games and shaping the events that would ll the pages of future histories. The balance of power in Europe, always a delicate thing, had been destabilized in recent years by two deaths. In 1516 Ferdinand II (also known as Ferdinand the Catholic) who had been King of Aragon, Castile, Sicily and León (as well as ruler of Naples since 1504), had died. The Holy Roman Emperor Maximilian had followed him to the grave in 1519. That year the nineteen-year-old grandson of Ferdinand and Maximilian and son of the late Philip I and Joanna of Castile became Holy Roman Emperor, as Charles V, having already been crowned King Charles I of Spain three years earlier. This union of two of the major power blocs of Europe posed an intolerable threat to France, and from 1521 it sparked a series of wars that were to drag on for a generation. Italy was inexorably drawn into these wars because of a succession of incompetent popes, beginning with Leo X (Giovanni de’ Medici), who tried to play the two ends off against the middle,” 236–237. 49 Salvatore Benso, Machiavelli italiano (Palermo & Roma: F. Cuini Editori, 1943), 187.
the enduring power of niccolò machiavelli
17
alienating Spain. The infamous Sack of Rome ordered by Charles V to destroy the alliance between France and the papacy took place in May of that same year. Machiavelli, nally being witness to a maimed papal court, died in June of 1527.
Bibliography Atkinson, James B., and David Sices., trans. and ed. Machiavelli and his Friends: Their Personal Correspondence. DeKalb, IL: Northern Illinois University Press, 1996. Baron, Hans. The Crisis of the Early Italian Renaissance: Civic Humanism and Republican Liberty in an Age of Classicism and Tyranny. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 1966. Bausi, Francesco. Machiavelli. Roma: Salerno, 2005. Benso, Salvatore. Machiavelli italiano. Palermo & Roma: F. Cuini Editori, 1943. Bondanella, Peter. Machiavelli and the Art of Renaissance History. Detroit: Wayne State University Press, 1973. ——, and Julia Bondanella. Discourses on Livy. New York: Oxford University Press, 1997. ——, and Mark Musa. The Portable Machiavelli. London: Penguin, 2005, 1979. Burckhardt, Jacob. The Civilization of the Renaissance in Italy. Trans. S. G. C. Middlemore. New York: Albert and Charles Boni, 1935. Chabod, Federico. Machiavelli and the Renaissance. Trans. David Moore. Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1960. de Grazia, Sebastian. Machiavelli in Hell. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 1989. Dionisotti, Carlo. “Machiavelli, Man of Letters.” Machiavelli and the Discourse of Literature. Ed. Albert Russell Ascoli and Victoria Kahn. Ithaca & London: Cornell University Press, 1993. Dotti, Ugo. Machiavelli rivoluzionario: Vita e opera. Roma: Carocci Editori, 2003. Femia, Joseph V. Machiavelli Revisited. Cardiff: University of Wales Press, 2004. Gilbert, Allan., ed. and trans. The Chief Works and Others. Fourth Edition. 3 vols. Durham: Duke University Press, 1965. Hale, J. R. Machiavelli and Renaissance Italy. New York: MacMillan Company, 1960. Kocis, Robert A. Machiavelli Redeemed: Retrieving His Humanist Perspectives on Equality, Power, and Glory. Bethelem: Lehigh University Press and London: Associated University Presses, 1998. Manseld, Harvey C., and Nathan Tarcov. Niccolò Machiavelli Discourses on Livy. Chicago & London: The University of Chicago Press, 1996. Najemy, John M. Between Friends: Discourses of Power and Desire in the Machiavelli-Vettori Letters of 1513–1515. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 1993. ——. “Machiavelli and Geta: Men of Letters.” Machiavelli and the Discourse of Literature. Ed. Albert Russell Ascoli and Victoria Kahn. Ithaca & London: Cornell University Press, 1993. Ridol, Roberto. The Life of Niccolò Machiavelli. Trans. Cecil Grayson. London: Routledge & Kegan Paul, 1963. Skinner, Quentin. Machiavelli. New York: Hill and Wang, 1981. Viroli, Maurizio. Machiavelli. Founders of Modern Political and Social Thought Series. Oxford & New York: Oxford University Press, 1998. ——. From Politics to Reason of State: The Acquisition and Transformation of the Language of Politics 1250–1600. Cambridge & New York: Cambridge University Press, 1992. White, Michael. Machiavelli: A Man Misunderstood. London: Abacus, 2004, 2005.
GOVERNMENT
AN INTRODUCTION TO THE PRINCE EDITED AND TRANSLATED FROM THE FRENCH BY GERALD SEAMAN1 Marie Gaille-Nikodimov
The Prince is one of history’s most frequently read, translated, and commented upon texts. Clairvoyant and awless for some, diabolical and courtesan for others, this work has caused a commotion throughout the centuries. Some readers have even become disciples of The Prince, believing that it contains proven recipes that can be applied successfully to politics, to the military, to love, and to market economics. Given this attention, it is worth noting that the original autograph text of The Prince is not extant, and that the dedicatory copy which came to Lorenzo de’ Medici (the young), and which was conserved in the Medici library until the beginning of the seventeenth century, has also been lost. Thus, although there have been many editions of The Prince, there is no automatically denitive version of the text. A letter from Machiavelli to his friend Francesco Vettori informs us of the circumstances surrounding the composition of The Prince. Removed from the Florentine Chancery on February 12, 1513; suspected of having fomented with Agostino Capponi and Pierpaolo Boscoli a plot against Cardinal Guiliano de’ Medici; tortured and condemned to life in prison; Machiavelli was nally released and conned to reside on his small estate in San Casciano. From there, on December 10, 1513, he wrote the famous Letter 224 describing his daily and evening activities. After stopping about his property, reading a poem next to a stream, talking and playing cards or other games with neighbors, he would return home and go into his room. He describes the scene as follows: On the threshold, I take off my workday clothes, covered with mud and dirt, and put on the garments of court and palace. Fitted out appropriately, I step inside the venerable courts of the ancients, where, solicitously received by them, I nourish myself on that food that alone is mine and
1 This chapter is adapted from an Introduction to The Prince published in Paris by Librairie Générale Française in 2000. It appears here by permission.
22
marie gaille-nikodimov for which I was born; where I am unashamed to converse with them and to question them about the motives for their actions, and they, out of their human kindness, answer me. And for four hours at a time I feel no boredom, I forget all my troubles, I do not dread poverty, and I am not terried by death. I absorb myself into them completely. And because Dante says that no one understands anything unless he retains what he has understood, I have jotted down what I have proted from in their conversation and composed a short study, De principatibus, in which I delve as deeply as I can into the ideas concerning this topic, discussing the denition of a princedom, the categories of princedoms, how they are acquired, how they are retained, and why they are lost.2
Relying on this letter, we cannot establish with certainty, however, that the text which we read today occupied Machiavelli’s attention only between the summer of 1513 and the 10th of December of that same year. Interpreters have proposed a variety of hypotheses for the time of composition and revision which could extend to May 1514 or even as far as 1518. Moreover, fate has left us a split textual tradition, one based on manuscripts and the other based on editions. The text was published for the rst time in 1532, ve years after Machiavelli’s death, rst in Rome (the Blado editions) and then in Florence (the Bernardo di Giunta editions). The manuscript tradition, which includes copies from years prior to 1532, is nonetheless essential to the establishment of a critical text, since the edited copies are characterized by substantial corrections and textual revisions that are written in Machiavelli’s own hand. Finally, the title itself can be open to interpretation. In the December 10, 1513, letter, Machiavelli refers to his work as De principatibus; that same title is used in a letter from Niccolò Guiccardini to his father that dates from July 29, 1517. In The Discourses on Livy, however, Machiavelli, in his own hand, refers to the work as De principe, which is also the title used in the post-1532 editions of the text. A look at the manuscript tradition does not help settle matters. The differing titles of Machiavelli’s work, then, oscillate between a focus on the prince and a focus on the principality, from instruction manual in government to a work about politics. G. Inglese chose to retain the De Principatibus title for his 1994 critical edition and used Il Principe for the paperback edition in 1995. If we decide to follow the oldest editorial tradition and favor the title 2 English translation from Machiavelli and his Friends: Their Personal Correspondence. Trans. and ed. James B. Atkinson and David Sices (DeKalb, IL: Northern Illinois University Press, 1996), 264.
an introduction to THE PRINCE
23
The Prince, it is because we are convinced that the work itself contains an irrefutable argument for doing so. Machiavelli clearly places greatest emphasis on the dialogue between himself, in a counselor’s role, and the character of the prince whom he addresses intimately on page after page of the text. From this perspective, it seems possible to sacrice the titular reference to the principality, even as we acknowledge the important place of that topic within the body of the work itself. With The Prince, Machiavelli offers us an intense reading experience, for his text has rhythm, style, and allure. We cannot deny that the literary quality of the work has played a role in its historical success. But this success is due as much to the questions and considerations that the text raises and provokes. His writing is driven by an acknowledgement of the historical instability of Florentine institutions and of the weakness of Italian city-states as they confronted powerful foreign invasions. It is lled with the urgency of war and the need to reform the city-states. In this context, Machiavelli assumes the posture of an historian during a time of crisis, as H. Arendt denes it: when present events have rendered past wisdom null and void and made following common sense irrelevant, it becomes necessary to rediscover the political sense of judgment.3 The task becomes to propose a new category and framework of analysis that will allow us to understand these events and to determine the ends and means of the actions we take. This task is exceptionally difcult to accomplish for “discerning what is new and different from what we are already accustomed to requires a particular quality of judgment.”4 Still, it is precisely with respect to this particular quality of judgment that Machiavelli’s desired role as counselor is dened and grounded. The prince, no matter how clairvoyant, cannot spare himself the cost of the effort that is necessary to understand and to determine the course of his own actions. Being thus engaged, he knows he cannot go it alone. He simply does not have that luxury, and so he is obliged to lend his ear to others. The deafness of the kings who are denounced by Raphael, the voyager in Thomas More’s Utopia, cannot be tolerated. For Machiavelli, the prince must listen to the advice of the person who is removed from action and has no stake in the decision, a person who has the time 3 Hannah Arendt, Juger: Sur la philosophie politique de Kant. Trans. M. Revault d’Allones (Paris: Seuil, 1991). 4 This citation of Arendt can be found in R. Benier, “H. Arendt et la faculté de juger.” Juger: Sur la philosophie politique de Kant, 157–158. Translated from the French.
24
marie gaille-nikodimov
for observation and discernment. Inversely, it should be said that, in Machiavelli’s eyes, the value of his counsel is due to his practical knowledge of the art of the state and, generally speaking, to the experience he acquired during his years of service to the Florentine Chancery. In the December 10, 1513, letter to Francesco Vettori, Machiavelli in effect said of his little work that: Were it to be read, it would be evident that during the fteen years I have been studying the art of the state I have neither slept nor fooled around, and anybody ought to be happy to utilize someone who has had so much experience at the expense of others.5
This experience with current events, which is made complete through an in-depth knowledge of the ancients, is a condition for providing counsel: the good counselor is the man who is able to mix practical experience with a disengagement from action. If we refer to A. Kojève’s thinking about the relationship between the philosopher and the tyrant, we can easily understand how this hybrid status of the counselor disturbs the person who chooses the contemplative life and might, on the other hand, motivate the person who wishes to participate in the life of the city. Distinguishing two conceptions of the truth, this latter person in effect underlines their implications for the way in which one leads one’s life. If one’s being is essentially immutable, then it is present to humans as an eternal and absolute truth that is discovered either through religious revelation or through one’s intellectual effort.6 If one considers the contrary position, however, that being is revealed essentially through its historical unfolding, one should, in the world of politics, avoid solitude and, like Socrates, mingle with citizens and even participate in the administration of a city’s affairs. If Machiavelli were asked to take a side in this debate, there is no doubt that he would place himself on the side of those who choose to be engaged in thinking and in acting and thus refuse the choice of retreating into a world of pure reection. An active period of experience precedes and accompanies the leisure time that is necessary for writing.
5
English translation from Machiavelli and his Friends: Their Personal Correspondence,
265. 6 Alexander Kojève, “Tyrannie et sagesse.” Leo Strauss, De la tyrannie (Paris: Gallimard, 1997), 169.
an introduction to THE PRINCE
25
Of course, Machiavelli is not out to discover the truth about being but rather is attempting to determine the conditions of action for a prince. This occurs by virtue of a discourse on the nature of things as they are, as chapter 15, with its focus on verità effettuale, makes clear. How does Machiavelli set all this up? In the text, there are a number of motifs that highlight his method. First of all, he seeks to provide counsel to the prince and is not a prisoner of his own point of view. In order to best serve the prince’s desire to acquire and to maintain power at the head of the city or province, he shows his aptitude for envisioning and describing the points of view of others. The prince cannot achieve his objective unless he is able to understand his opponents and is able to win their favor or, at least, convince them not to do him harm. Thus we can see that Machiavelli, as early as the Dedication, employs an artistic metaphor to compare his work to that of a painter: one must know the best places for observing and becoming acquainted with the nature of princes and the nature of people. Echoing fteenth-century work on perspective, we might say that Machiavelli asks the same question as Pascal: “I must do as painters do—distance myself from my subject, but not too far. How far is far enough? Guess.”7 With this question of placement of perspective, Machiavelli does not believe that there are, however, an innite number of possible points of view: there are those of the enemy, those of allies, those of the powerful, and those of the people. It is not possible to encompass all points of view in a single perspective. Rather, one must become capable of shifting from one to the next: “The work exists to help facilitate the passage from one place and one universe of words to another place and another universe of words.”8 Machiavelli does not however seek to determine the conditions for action in general. Rather, he immerses the prince in numerous analyses of individual cases by means of examples. Recourse to examples was widely used in the texts of renaissance humanists, but with Machiavelli it attained a completely original status. As a rst innovation, one discovers that Machiavelli does not use examples as a means to illustrate or introduce an argument. Rather, it is by the exposition of a given example that Machiavelli himself argues, judges, measures, weighs the pros and cons, contradicts, interrogates, and elaborates.
7 8
Blaise Pascal, Œuvres complètes (Paris: Gallimard, 1954), No. 558. Gérald Sfez, Machiavel, Le Prince sans qualities (Paris: Editions Kimé, 1998).
26
marie gaille-nikodimov
As a second innovation: the history that these examples are supposed to take into account is told in a way that advances the goals of Machiavelli’s arguments. Evidence for this can be found in his use of Herodian’s Roman History in chapter 19. Machiavelli notably softens the matter that he takes from this source. He does not take up the opposition between the emperors who had been weakened by the Orient and those who were barbaric and tyrannical but rather focuses on the problem that they all had to face: the essential role of soldiers to their power and the necessity of winning them over to their side. In order to support the idea that a prince must above all concern himself with not being hated by the people, Machiavelli disdains Herodian’s chronological ordering of the emperors so that he may evaluate the causes of their success or failure. He nds inspiration in his source and then adapts it, by omission and exaggeration, to his own argument. Thus he resumes his discussion of the causes of hatred toward Pertinax, adds to it a reason for contempt—old age—and sets aside Pertinax’s speeches to the Senate, which might have been useful to an analysis of his generosity. Throughout The Prince, one nds this kind of refashioning of textual or factual sources: historical material is segmented, even touched up; read or lived, history comes to resemble a palimpsest that the political thinker constantly reworks and in whatever way he nds suitable. Taking this kind of liberty in his writing is characteristic of Machiavelli’s œuvre. It is present in The Discourses on Livy, as A. Matucci has shown in his analysis of the two terms that Machiavelli uses to describe his work: discourse and “narration.”9 The former, according to usage that was current during the rst half of the sixteenth century, refers to an act of wit or reasoning and, since it applies to a text and not to an event, is opposed to gloss (chiosa) and commentary (comento). The Discourses, according to Matucci, mix together two words that had heretofore been distinct in Florentine historiography: the narration of history and reection on history. In the same way, the term “narration” that is used in the Dedication to The Discourses refers to a style that is equally distant from political treatises as it is from the practice of history: that is the entry to “oratio” according to the meaning Cicero gave to that term in his De oratore, that is the entry into argumentation. This liberty appears also in the fact that a single event or person is evoked by Machiavelli
9 Andrea Matucci, Machiavelli nella storiograa orentina: Per la storia di une genere letterario (Florence: L. S. Olschki, 1991).
an introduction to THE PRINCE
27
in diverse manners according to the course of his argument. It is not clear, from that, that one can pertinently criticize Machiavelli based on criteria such as the precise use of facts and the scientic use of source material, for he uses examples in a free manner. In this sense, the use of examples supports his mode of argumentation in two ways: rst, it gives him a setting for it; second, it is malleable, changing according to the author’s object. Thus, in chapters 3 and 24, Phillip of Macedonia appears. In the rst chapter, he is the embodiment of failure in the face of the Romans, never having been able to secure their friendship without being abased himself. In the second, he is praised by Machiavelli for having discovered, despite the small size of his territory, how to put up a lasting front against the Romans, and, as such a leader, he is shown as an example for the princes of Italy who have themselves been defeated by foreign armies. Third and nal innovation: far from systematically shedding light on the kinds of actions that should be imitated, Machiavelli often exposes failures and mistakes. In this case, such instances constitute counterexamples for the rules, customs, and counsel whose pertinence or universal efcacy Machiavelli wishes to challenge. Thus it is in contrast to the proverb: “Chi fonda in sul populo, fonda in sul fango” (Founding a state on the people is like founding it on mud) that Machiavelli cites the examples of the Gracchi in Rome and Giorgio Scali in Florence in chapter 9. Some examples, of course, show a clear path of action: the prince to whom Machiavelli addresses himself has predecessors, “very excellent men,” in whom he can and should nd inspiration. But, should it be a matter of simply reproducing their actions? One might draw that conclusion from a reading of Francesco Guicciardini, Machiavelli’s friend and interlocutor on affairs of state. He accuses Machiavelli of lacking discernment—discrezione—of being inattentive to the differences and peculiar qualities of different eras, all of which makes imitation impossible and invalidates the idea that lessons can be taken from history.10 Machiavelli’s argument is in reality more complicated than that, and it is difcult to clarify fully because his work accords no place to a theory of history that would take this form of desirable imitation into account. It would be wrong to create opposing identities between the
10 Francesco Guicciardini, Selected Writings. Ed. Cecil Grayson, trans. Margaret Grayson (London and New York: Oxford University Press, 1965).
28
marie gaille-nikodimov
ancient world and the modern world. Rather, Machiavelli’s text is lled with examples of events that attest to an encounter—a riscontro—between these two periods, to their resemblances and to their similarities. One can suppose, without forcing the text, that such similarities are connected to the permanence of human passions and to the presence in all political entities of the same kinds of political desires and humors that were identied in chapter 9—that one detects, in afrming this kind of permanence, an anthropological train of thought or a necessary hypothesis for whomsoever wishes to dedicate his thought to the conditions for conquest or for maintaining the power of the state. In these examples, this permanence of human passion and humors should not invite confusion with particular cases of ideal-types who should dene a prince’s mode of action. Rather, it allows the historian, following his own judgment, to move freely between time periods and, from this, to be able to develop analogies which can be used as a guide to action, identifying good and bad choices rather than determining what to do. Thus, Machiavelli is able to underline in chapter 3 the contrast between the Roman’s decisions, which led to their successes in their colonies, and the poor choices of the kings of France after they invaded Italian territory. The two series of examples that describe these good and bad choices are inscribed in a comparison that is made possible by the identication of a common goal—the conquest of a new country—and by similar conditions—the desires and passions of men, subjects or allies, and the reasons for their allegiance to a new prince. Thus we can speak of a creative form of imitation as opposed to one that simply reproduces a previous act. As paradoxical as this may seem, it does allow us to grasp how, in Machiavelli’s eyes, a prince, by his “virtù,” may enroll himself in the glorious list of “very excellent” men and, at the same time, be considered innovative. He is inspired by the excellent actions of those who have served as his examples, but he has invented his own course of action, in a context that is his own and which may be unique and hitherto unknown. From this perspective, the comparison taken up in chapter 6 between the imitator and the archer who aims higher than his target is important. Through this image, Machiavelli stresses two causes for the impossibility of reproducing past acts: one cannot borrow the same path that one seeks to imitate, and one can never equal it. In these causes, the distance from imitated to imitator is clearly indicated, and the way to innovation is opened. The set of examples and counter-examples that are at the disposal of the prince through his reading are similar, one could say, to the guide
an introduction to THE PRINCE
29
that is given to the voyager, which he can consult to evaluate a present situation in which he is required to act: the writer Machiavelli took care, as he says on many occasions, to reduce—ridurre, ridurre a memoria—to a small number the images and sentences that the prince would need to remember. By means of this reduction, Machiavelli is aiming for the most effective form of counsel: a few striking persons or events will better serve the prince than would lengthy volumes or a chronological narrative, even if it is abundant and detailed with his own personal experiences. The end of Savonarola, therefore, reminds everyone that arms are indispensable to whomsoever wishes to command a city. Evoking Soderini allows Machiavelli to incite the prince to deance and to the use of evil when necessary. Looked at only from the point of view of ancient prudence, the work of transmission, adaptation, selection, and evaluation that Machiavelli made to effect this reduction was enormous. L. Arthur Burd’s 1891 edition of The Prince shows great evidence of this. Through his work of reduction, Machiavelli shows his prince the route that his intellect must follow and does not divulge any kind of recipe for action. It is up to the prince, after having read, discussed, thought about, and made inquiries of himself, to establish analogies that will illuminate a possible course of action in a given context. Indeed, we have already noted that the prince, being engaged in action, does not have the free time necessary to dedicate to reection. This is true, with respect to his counselor, but Machiavelli takes advantage of the leisure time that is used for hunting and recommends that they use this time to think about the art of war. Chapter 14, in this sense, constitutes a tableau of what the prince should do when he is traveling about the countryside with others: like Philopoemen, prince of the Achaians, while observing the landscape he should conceive of the different possible offensive and defensive actions that he might take and discuss them with his companions. Knowledge of the landscape, and these kinds of discussions, Machiavelli emphasizes, will be useful to the prince who will later be able to rely on this knowledge when he is engaged in a real battle. The approach that Machiavelli applies and recommends takes its pertinence from the idea that The Prince expresses rules of action that are of general value. Indeed, Machiavelli himself uses the term “rule” or even “sentence.” Nonetheless, an examination of their occurrence reveals that rules, conceived as we have seen from particular cases, are relativized. After establishing them, Machiavelli outlines a possible situation where the rules might not hold or suggests that they would
30
marie gaille-nikodimov
only hold under certain conditions. In this connection, we may, after having underlined the necessity for the prince to use his intellect to imagine the possible situations and the action appropriate to each one, skip from this point in the text all the way to chapter 23. This chapter contributes to the denition of Machiavelli’s avowed prince: this prince is a prudent man, and this prudence is in fact the quality that allows the prince to apply the rules with discernment, to modulate them according to the situation, even to create new ones, by comparison or analogical transfer to the present context or the lived situation. Like the physician to whom he is often considered similar, the prince must formulate a diagnosis and determine the remedy to use in each case in a particular manner. If The Prince is not focused on prescribing general rules for action, what kind of counsel does it advocate? Machiavelli, it seems, wishes to inculcate in the prince the kinds of concerns that should draw his attention and preoccupy him. The prince himself should not be dependent on forces that could cause him harm. On the contrary, he should establish his own forces and only rely on them. The gure of Cesare Borgia, in chapter 7, exemplies this independence with respect to harmful forces. Starting from a position of dependence on the arms of others, he progressively removes himself from this dependence by reducing the forces to nothing or by cultivating alliances which prevent them from harming him and which also attach him to the people who have been conquered. Even if they do not exclude other elements, the kinds of forces that are given priority in The Prince are those that will best ensure military power. This has many implications: mercenary forces are rejected because they work for personal gain and not for a common cause of patriotism that inspires courage in the hearts of soldiers. When Machiavelli wrote The Prince, this criticism of mercenaries could be understood on two levels: Florence, like other Italian cities, had been attacked by foreign invaders, and its military weakness did not allow it to resist. In addition, the use of mercenary soldiers in defense of Italian cities had become commonplace. Machiavelli was not only opposed to the use of mercenaries, he was also opposed to military alliances that could require sharing victory with others who might later wish to conquer themselves. His critique, which The Discourses elaborate using the motif of “money is not the nerve of war,” and the counsel that the prince should establish an army of his own—a militia made up of members of the city itself—are articulated early on in Machiavelli’s writings. Before him, Bruni had developed this thought, after him
an introduction to THE PRINCE
31
Gianotti would do the same, but the vigor and clarity of Machiavelli’s defense of the necessity of having an army of one’s own made him the most convincing spokesperson for this argument. The originality of Machiavelli’s critique can be found in the concentration of criticisms that tie the project for an army of one’s own together with an analysis of the way in which the prince must join himself to the powerful and to the people. The distinction between internal and external policies is, in this context, meaningless. A prince who is hated by his subjects is made weak militarily: his subjects would be favorable to conquest by another prince or another republic, and these latter would seek only to nourish the hate that the subjects felt for their current prince. At the very least, subjects in this state would hesitate to defend their prince at all. This consideration is valid with respect to the people, for, because they are large in number, they make up the greater part of one’s army. Thus, in his examination of the emergence of civil principality (chapter 9)—which occurs when a person from the city becomes prince by virtue of the support of the powerful and of the people—Machiavelli emphasizes the necessity of attracting the favor of the people and of maintaining this favor if it is indeed the people who brought the prince to power. But the prince cannot neglect to pay attention to the powerful, though for different reasons: for them, it is not their number that matters, but the fact that they are far-sighted and that they are more clever than the people. The nature of the relationships that the prince can have with the powerful and with the people must be dened in a deeper way than this reection on the necessity of an army of one’s own permits. In every city, as Machiavelli says in chapter 9, there are two kinds of desire: for the powerful, they wish to command, to dominate, to oppress. For the people, they wish not to be commanded, dominated, or oppressed. Indeed, they wish to have a share of power. These desires vary with the history of the city. One could thus envision two opposite poles: one a city where the members are accustomed to liberty and where the people desire liberty and a share of deliberating and decision-making power. The history of the ancient roman republic and modern Florence illustrates this kind of city. The other kind of city, however, would be one that has always been administered by a monarch where the desire for liberty does not exist and where the people wish not to be oppressed but do not pretend to wish for a share in power, though their own desire to oppress the powerful is extremely great. Between these two poles, one can imagine any number of other possible congurations.
32
marie gaille-nikodimov
It is essential that we note that Machiavelli, when describing the relationships between the powerful and the people in terms of dominating or not being dominated, used the word humor—“umore”—along with the terms desire and appetite. This directs our attention immediately to the kind of Hippocratic medical terminology that was in vogue at the time and that was current in the discourse of the city. A comparison between the way in which Machiavelli used this term and the ways of Savonarola and F. Guicciardini shows how unique Machiavelli’s usage was. His was much more systematic than his contemporaries, and the term “humor” occupies a central place in Machiavelli’s thought on the fate of the city and the action of the prince. It does not appear in his political writings from the time of the Chancery but is, on the other hand, present in The Prince, The Discourses, and The History of Florence. If these desires refer to categories of citizens—the powerful and the people in this case—they are not necessarily synonyms or equivalents. These categories are evoked when Machiavelli addresses the question of the division of responsibilities in the city, whereas desires or humors appear in his analyses of change or reform of institutions or regimes. Feeding off one another, without xed limits, these humors, as they collide, are the source of an innite historical dynamic. The usage of humor as a medical term makes it all the more apparent to the reader that the city is, for Machiavelli, the place where things are mixed together and for which one must nd a correct balance. In the same way that humors combine and are balanced in the body to effect health or illness, the desires of the powerful and of the people combine in a relationship that is more or less benecial to the fate of the city. From bloody division to pacic coexistence an entire range of relationships and combinations of the desire of the powerful and the desire of the people is conceivable. When a prince, by heredity or by conquest, commands a city, he nds himself confronted by the question of the balance of humors either because, from a military perspective, he requires the favor of the people or because he wishes to avoid civil conict or a plot against his life. Yet, the prince can exercise some inuence over these humors. It is a vain hope to wish to reconcile the powerful and the people. Their respective desires, which are by denition antagonistic, make such an ambition absurd. On the other hand, he could favor a balance that neither puts the city nor his hold on power in danger. Obviously, to the extent that these desires remain piqued, the action of the prince toward them must be permanent. He cannot pretend to discover a kind of rule that
an introduction to THE PRINCE
33
would resolve the question once and for all and make a certain balance permanent. An additional difculty can be found in the fact that each context requires a different and unique method and response. Between recourse to arms, exile, assassination, and the creation of a law that would allow the powerful and the people to satiate—“sfogare”—their appetites or the creation of an institution that would regulate specic conicts between the powerful and the people—like the French parliament (chapter 19), the prince must know how to choose the means that are most appropriate to his situation and to the history of the city. The skill required for this permanent action is extreme for the prince must be able to make the powerful feel that they retain a kind of power that is commensurate with their pretensions and with the conception they have made for themselves and their rank. He must all the while act in such a way that the people do not feel oppressed by the powerful. It seems like squaring a circle. But it would be wrong to suggest that Machiavelli does not believe that a balance of the humors is possible, at least during a certain extent of time. As an example, he refers to the French kingdom in chapter 19 which follows immediately the statement on what balance should be put in place—do not make the powerful desperate lest they plot against the prince; and, satisfy the people in their desire not to be oppressed. Without this, they will not defend the prince when he is attacked by the powerful or by outside enemies. When one examines the effects that this regulation of humors has on a prince’s reputation, one nds Machiavelli describing it in terms of passions. This brings us back to the essentially affective dimension of his analysis in that these passions appear to account for the fragility or the surety of a prince’s power. Machiavelli does not embrace the idea of a transcendent foundation. He also renounces the idea of a prince whose power rests on the fact that he acts in a way that promotes the good of the people—to pursue the common good and not antagonize the powerful and all the while satisfy the people—these are two very different kinds of things. Friendship, love, hate, admiration, esteem, spite, fear—these are the words that Machiavelli uses in chapters 15–21, which are devoted to a prince’s reputation and to a critique of fortresses, to measure a prince’s power beyond the material resources that he has at his disposal. The new prince and the hereditary prince are equals in this regard. Certainly chapter 2 seems to suggest that the task of the hereditary prince is more simple, but chapter 24 contradicts that assertion. First, great deeds give the new prince a great reputation; and he can take on the appearance of a long-time former prince. But later,
34
marie gaille-nikodimov
sloth and short-sightedness can cause a prince to lose his possessions, which is seen in the defeat of the Italian princes. In opposition to the hatred of the people and the powerful, the prince must seek their favor. This is what Machiavelli recommends in the most general terms. But, a more specic analysis of the relationship of the prince to the people and the powerful is necessary because a prince can actually cause himself harm if he is excessively generous or merciful in his search for favor. In times of adversity, fear is stronger than love. For this reason, the prince should cultivate a sense of fear among his subjects, but he must do so in a way that does not transform fear into hate. Chapter 17 concludes with a denition of the combination of passions that is most likely to promote the maintenance of a prince’s power: fear without hate. As much as it provides a way to organize an army and to create bonds with the people and the powerful, The Prince also rejects resignation, fatalism, and inaction, and promotes engagement and action. This occurs in two ways. In the rst, Machiavelli denounces the effects of resignation and inaction. Maintaining an analytic tone that is nonetheless already passionate, the secretary, in chapter 24, initiates a call to liberate Italy from the barbarians and provides a one-word diagnosis of the cause for Italy’s military defeats: indolence. In another way, Machiavelli argues strongly against the omnipotence of fortune. In chapter 25, he suggests that the course of events is determined by an almost equal division of human action and fortune. It makes sense to act, and especially so since Machiavelli’s views on action are not inscribed within a frame that is governed by Providence. Chapter 11 discusses ecclesiastic principalities. Machiavelli declares that they are self-perpetuating, no matter the manner in which they are governed and no matter the mores of the prince. This surprising state of affairs, Machiavelli believes, stems from the fact that they are established and maintained by God. Conceived of in this way, as founded on a transcendent divine power, ecclesiastic principalities are of no interest to Machiavelli. He refuses to speak of them, and there is irony in Machiavelli’s perspective. He touches on the emergence of the church as a temporal power and then proceeds to talk about Alexander VI and Julius. Machiavelli situates his analyses in a temporal plane and speaks in terms of force and confrontation when he describes the conditions for the prince’s action. Alexander VI and Julius created a powerful church by the power of the sword, through ruse, and through temporary alliances. Their success was not due to a transcendent power. It can be no different for the prince, for whom this work is explicitly destined.
an introduction to THE PRINCE
35
The temporal dimension in Machiavelli is not dened exclusively in terms of its opposition to a providential dimension. It is also set in opposition to the kind of astrological thinking that was so common at the time. Although there are more astrological elements to be found in his thinking in The Discourses than in The Prince, it is nonetheless worthwhile to dedicate some attention to this issue because it will help us to understand how Machiavelli expresses the conditions for the prince’s action and, more generally, for anyone’s action. It is possible that Machiavelli had astrological beliefs, as some passages in his Discourses on Livy show. Still, we should distinguish between determinism, which Machiavelli did not favor, and another kind of belief that recognizes the inuence of the stars on the sub-lunar world without making them out to be a source or cause of events. Natural astrology sees in the movement of the stars a general cause for, but not a specic relationship to, terrestrial events. In the Proemio of The Discourses I, Machiavelli recalls this inuence as something that conditions but does not determine human action; and chapter I, 56 simply states the factual existence of celestial signs that can presage terrestrial events and which are beyond human ability to interpret. Action in the temporal dimension, therefore, is never vain, even if it is not always effective. There are good and bad choices; and there are weak and lazy acts or, by contrast, energetic and valiant ones. Machiavelli’s invitation to action opens up a realm of possibilities that is nonetheless lled with limitations. Action can never be considered outside of a context. The prince cannot act solely according to his own wishes but must determine how to act within a specied context. Beyond the particularities of each context, the prince must never think in terms of peace but must always think in terms of war. As M. Senellart has said so well: “Machiavelli does not refuse peace; but he does denounce a love of peace that would lead to repose and to a failure to remember war.”11 If a prince thinks in terms of peace, he will not be able to work with his subjects in a way that will assure that he can count on them in times of war. Thus, a prince would be mistaken to think that, in times of peace, he need no longer be concerned with inciting hatred in his subjects. If he were to despoil them, tax them heavily, or take their women, he would be betrayed at
11 Michel Senellart, Machiavélisme et raison d’État (Paris: Presses Universitaires de France, 1989).
36
marie gaille-nikodimov
the rst possible occasion. Last-minute attempts at benevolence would not compensate for how the prince treated his subjects in a time when he did not need them. Machiavelli believes that a prince must use his character to his advantage when facing difcult circumstances. This is illustrated in chapter 19, when he speaks of Marcus and Pertinax and how they, along with Alexander, shared the traits of modesty, love of justice, benevolence, and humanity. Marcus’s life and fate were happy because he was admired for his many virtues and because he inherited his empire and thus was not beholden to the people or to the army. Pertinax, by contrast, met a bad end because he was made emperor against the will of the soldiers who were accustomed to a licentious lifestyle and because he was disrespected due to his age. Using this comparison, Machiavelli shows that one condition for a prince’s success is his ability to act in a way that is appropriately adapted to the context. Although he believes that adaptation is possible, Machiavelli recognizes that some princes were born in times that made their own particular success impossible. Along with a rejection of resignation and this recognition of limits, Machiavelli also believed that the prince must be sensitive to the variations in the nature of the times and must be capable of being a good forecaster, like a doctor whose diagnosis prevents illness even before signs of it appear. The Prince is lled with reminders of the possibility of being overthrown, either by an enemy attack or by unhappy subjects. The opposition between times of peace and times of adversity is at the center of this discourse. The prince must not only be prepared for adversity to come—as the construction of dikes to protect against oods demonstrates in chapter 25—he must also adjust his action to conform to the nature of the times. This requires more than just never thinking about peace. It also requires that the prince act badly when it is necessary. To know when and how to do so is, in Machiavelli’s eyes, one of the most difcult aspects of the prince’s job. And yet, as the example of Agathocles of Sicily shows, it cannot be avoided. By being cruel at the beginning of his reign, Agathocles was able, without any civic controversy, to remain king of Syracuse and never had to commit any further acts of inhumanity (chapter 8).12
12 Gérald Sfez, Machiavel, la politique du moindre mal (Paris: Presses Universitaires de France, 1999).
an introduction to THE PRINCE
37
To engage and disengage from bad acts, to temporize or to react immediately, but also to use law or force as a weapon, and, nally, since force is an animal attribute, to use physical strength like a lion or to use cunning like a fox (chapter 18): with these alternatives, Machiavelli depicts the prince like Dante’s artist, with a trembling hand, oscillating irretrievably between humanity and inhumanity, benevolence and cruelty, and paints the portrait of a scandalous gure if one were to think in terms of political morality.13 As he does this, he also captures the relationship of the prince to fortune, hesitating between its personication—either a being or a wheel—and a negative concept—fortune being that which arises when a man does not avail himself of his own strength but resigns himself to fate and devolves into inaction. Fortune demands that the prince face up to things; it is also, at the same time, the thing that the prince must confront. Machiavelli does not only draw the prince’s attention to the temporal dimension, he also asks him to think of the affairs of his state, from conquest to maintenance, in terms of appearances. Commentators on The Prince have rightly emphasized that, from chapters 15–21, the text encourages the prince to cultivate a certain image of himself, in spite of his character. But he also asks the prince to try to go beyond appearances. For some readers, The Prince teaches a prince rst and foremost how to deceive people by providing them with an image that will impress them, seduce them, and build attachments from which the prince can draw his own personal advantages. But, in chapter 17, Machiavelli also offers this astonishing portrait of men in general: Because we can say this about men in general: They are ungrateful, changeable, simulators and dissimulators, runaways in danger, eager for gain; while you do well by them they are all yours; they offer you their blood, their property, their lives, their children, as was said above, when need is far off; but when it comes near you, they turn about.14
In the midst of men, the prince is therefore in danger—and he must remind himself constantly of this fact—and the threat cannot be removed unless the prince knows how to pierce the façade of appearances that men place before him. Machiavelli uses three metaphors, all 13 Dante Alighieri, The Divine Comedy: Paradiso, Canto XIII. Ed. and trans. Charles S. Singleton (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1975). 14 Machiavelli: The Chief Works and Others. Trans. Allan Gilbert. Vol. One (Durham, NC: Duke University Press, 1965), 62.
38
marie gaille-nikodimov
based on the senses, to describe the quality that is required for a prince to succeed in this enterprise. In one, he distinguishes between two ways of seeing—one which focuses on appearances, and another that sees beyond them and captures things better, as the powerful do or as does a good doctor. In another, he speaks of being able to detect the odor of poison in something sweet smelling. Finally, he focuses on the difference between seeing and touching, stating that those who know how to use their sense of touch can penetrate beyond appearances. If the prince is in danger, his subjects are deceived by him when, in the same way, he projects a veil of appearance. This is necessary for the prince to conquer and to maintain power. He could do neither if the people did not form an attachment to him. But, this attachment is built on the manifestation of certain qualities to which men are sensitive and which create the prince’s reputation. The effectiveness of this image is guaranteed by the fact that very few men know how to “touch”: they are simulators and dissimulators, but there are very few of them who can actually penetrate beyond appearances. Since a prince cannot possess every quality that is necessary for conquest and maintenance of power, he must cultivate for himself an image that will make it appear that he does indeed possess these qualities. Machiavelli, in this way, is asking the prince to think about his actions in terms of the kind of qualities they will demonstrate, without considering what they might hide. A prince’s actions therefore are inscribed in a realm of appearances wherein the prince must tend to the image that will give rise to his reputation. Determining what reputation is appropriate to conquest and to the maintenance of power is one of the aspects of The Prince that most clearly reveals its polemical character. In chapter 15, Machiavelli quickly divests himself of the opposition between good and bad qualities, as it has been understood in Ciceronian, Christian, or Humanist terms, in order to treat qualities exclusively from the point of view of their contribution to a prince’s ability for conquest and rule. As he does this, he introduces duration as an essential consideration. Thus, it is sometimes better to cultivate a bad reputation for parsimony, when it is the better way to maintain power, than a reputation for liberality— continuous and indiscriminate spending reduces resources and forces excessive taxation on subjects in times of war if the coffers go bare. On the other hand, parsimony allows the wealth of the principality to grow and helps the prince to avoid engendering hatred in his subjects
an introduction to THE PRINCE
39
by overly burdensome taxes. Inversely, one should not accept every possible kind of bad reputation. To be considered a prince of little religion is harmful (chapter 18), for example. Between a good reputation and a bad reputation, the prince must know how to choose prudently and variously according to circumstances. Finally, the prince must know that a reputation that is favorable to conquest and to rule is not exclusively the product of duration. It relies on great deeds and timely examples. These latter allow a prince to maintain his status, to inspire admiration and, in doing so (as Machiavelli suggests in chapter 24) to transcend the effects of the former establishment within a state. Through valiant acts, a prince attains a reputation for strength, courage, and power which mirrors the effects of the former establishment on his subjects. To focus the prince on the temporal dimension, to ask him to count only on his own strength and the strength of his state, to show him the truth of things behind their appearances while teaching him not to have faith in appearances: for what purpose has Machiavelli taken the trouble to compose these reections, which are the product of both his experiences and his study? In his eyes, beyond his desire to re-establish himself in government, writing this work was made necessary by the state of Italy. Its need for a prince is pointed out unambiguously in the nal chapter. Specically, Italy needs a prince who will know how to heal its wounds and how to build a state on a solid foundation. In other words, Italy needs a prince who is both a physician and an architect. If we spend too much time focusing on the kind of prince that is not endorsed by Machiavelli—the virtuous prince (in the moral sense of the term), God’s agent on earth, etc.—we could lose sight of the positive attributes of the Machiavellian prince. Most notably, the quality of “virtù” is attached to this prince, and Machiavelli deploys a dense array of other metaphors and comparisons that link the prince to the physician who prevents illness or cures it, to architects, and to builders. The founder of a state—whether he creates it or takes control over it at a moment when it is in ruins—is the object par excellence of Machiavellian praise. Such praise is particularly explicit in the 1520 text A Discourse on Remodeling the Government of Florence, written after the death of Lorenzo de’ Medici: “I believe the greatest honor possible for men to have is that willingly given them by their native cities; I believe the greatest good to be done and the most pleasing to God is that which one does to one’s native city. Besides this, no man is so much exalted by any act of his as are those men who have with laws and with institutions
40
marie gaille-nikodimov
remodeled republics and kingdoms.”15 Without pretending that this text is an a posteriori clarication of Machiavelli’s intentions in The Prince, we can nonetheless point out that, in chapter 26, he uses these sentiments to name such a reformer. This perspective allows us to respond to two questions of interpretation. First, what is the relationship of The Prince to The Discourses? We should reafrm that Machiavelli does not have a split personality, à la Dr. Jekyl and Mr. Hyde. His writings on principalities and The Discourses are addressing a similar question: the future of the city of Florence and the means to enact civil and military reforms in a context that has been more and more disturbed by foreign invasions, civil dissent, and the corruption of citizens. A quick look at chapter I, 18 of The Discourses may be of help in this connection. In this chapter, Machiavelli undertakes what one might call an experiment in political thinking. Here, he inquires about how a city can restore its freedom or establish it depending on its level of corruption. In a situation of extreme corruption, even a republican city will need to await the arrival of an energetic individual who is capable of violence. Becoming prince, this person could restore order to the city and clean up the sources of corruption. From this chapter, one could venture the hypothesis that Machiavelli splits off the question of how rule of the city is maintained. Machiavelli is republican so long as it is possible to safeguard a free form of government. But once the course of events makes that impossible, he focuses rst and foremost on safeguarding the city itself. In the rst case, the two meanings of “libertá”—independence with respect to a source of authority and power from outside the city, and republican form of government—are united. In the second, they are separated. One must save what can be saved; if the government can’t be saved, at least the independence of the city must be. With The Prince, we nd ourselves in the second scenario. There is no time to regret the loss of the republic and no reason to expect that a prince who has just saved the city will simply slip back into the background. In this situation, there is less concern for corruption and dissent among citizens and much more for the threat of invasion and defeat. Nonetheless, Italy’s unfortunate circumstance, which does in fact result from corruption and disunion, requires the same sort of intervention by a single man, the prince. Machiavelli believes that one man alone, who is energetic,
15
Ibid., 113–114.
an introduction to THE PRINCE
41
courageous, violent, far-sighted, and prudent, is better suited to succeeding in founding or re-founding a city than are many men together, as he makes clear in The Discourses.16 In this way, far from being in opposition, The Prince and The Discourses together complete a reection on the conditions and modalities for reforming cities and their forms of government. From this, we can see clearly Machiavelli’s desire to construct The Prince as a piece of persuasive rhetoric. Whether we can see the basis for the text’s composition in Cicero’s De inventione, the Rhetorica ad Herennium, and the works of Quintillien, as Mr. Viroli does, is an open question.17 We can certainly recognize some gures of roman style—such as the exordium in the Dedication to Lorenzo de’ Medici and the exhortatio in the nal chapter—but we do not see in the succession of chapters a traditional rhetorical structure. As we look for a structure to the work, we discover that the process that was announced at the beginning is not followed past chapter 11, after which the text is composed of sections which are relatively independent from each other. Links are made between them by recalling subject matter that was treated earlier or by repeating subject matter and treating it from a different perspective or point of view. It appears most evident that Machiavelli’s desire to persuade can be found more in the character of the text than in its structure. The Prince is, as Leo Strauss has said, “a combat text.”18 Of course, Machiavelli the writer does not nd himself in the same position as the captain orator described by Fabrizio Colonna in book IV of the Art of War: he is not addressing a crowd of soldiers to persuade them to go into battle or to incite their courage. But, he is not far from that position. His task also is to persuade a prince to go to war and to inspire in him the will to ght. Chapter 26 is explicitly addressed to leaders and not to Italy. Leaders are the ones who are failing to heed the call; courage is not what is failing Italy. That the call to liberate Italy is made in a specic chapter should not lead us to separate off the militant tone of Machiavelli’s analysis of the conditions for action. On the contrary, Machiavelli’s appeal depends on this kind of analysis. From this point of view, it is remarkable that his analysis has a polemical character. If 16
Machiavelli: The Chief Works and Others. Chapter 3, “The Power of Words.” Maurizio Viroli, Machiavelli (New York: Oxford University Press, 1998). 18 Leo Strauss, Pensées sur Machiavel (Paris: Payot, 1982). 17
42
marie gaille-nikodimov
his inquiry takes a twist or turn after an objection or a question, this is because Machiavelli shares with historians, chroniclers, retired political actors, rich merchants who worry about the future of their city, even with religious agents such as Savonarola, the same preoccupation: how to understand the events that have occurred in Italy since 1494; how to reveal the cause of the various defeats; and how to show the way out of civil and military crisis. He does not share with them, however, agreement on the means for coming to grips with these things or for creating a project of reform or re-founding.
Bibliography Atkinson, James B., and David Sices, ed. and trans. Machiavelli and his Friends: Their Personal Correspondence. DeKalb, IL: Northern Illinois University Press, 1996. Alighieri, Dante. The Divine Comedy: Paradiso. Ed. and trans. Charles S. Singleton. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1975. Arendt, Hannah. Juger: Sur la philosophie politique de Kant. Trans. M. Revault d’Allones. Paris: Seuil, 1991. Benier, R. “H. Arendt et la faculté de juger.” Juger: Sur la philosophie politique de Kant. Trans. M. Revault d’Allones. Paris: Seuil, 1991. Guicciardini, Francesco. Selected Writings. Ed. Cecil Grayson, trans. Margaret Grayson. London and New York: Oxford University Press, 1965. Kojève, Alexander. “Tyrannie et sagesse.” Leo Strauss, De la tyrannie. Paris: Gallimard, 1997. Machiavelli: The Chief Works and Others. Trans. Allan Gilbert. Vol. One. Durham, NC: Duke University Press, 1965. Matucci, Andrea. Machiavelli nella storiograa orentina: Per la storia di une genere letterario. Florence: L. S. Olschki, 1991. Pascal, Blaise. Œuvres complètes. Paris: Gallimard, 1954. Senellart, Michel. Machiavélisme et raison d’État. Paris: Presses Universitaires de France, 1989. Sfez, Gérald. Machiavel, la politique du moindre mal. Paris: Presses Universitaires de France, 1999. ——. Machiavel, Le Prince sans qualities. Paris: Editions Kimé, 1998. Strauss, Leo. Pensées sur Machiavel. Paris: Payot, 1982. Viroli, Maurizio. Machiavelli. New York: Oxford University Press, 1998.
MACHIAVELLI’S BURDEN: THE PRINCE AS LITERARY TEXT Charles D. Tarlton
Hence, if you look for a man’s burden, you will nd the principle that reveals the structure of his unburdening. . . . Kenneth Burke1 I did it my own self to gratify. John Bunyon2
Some time after The Prince had been composed and had circulated in manuscript among Machiavelli’s friends, he wrote the proem or dedicatory letter to Lorenzo de’ Medici. With the text before him, Machiavelli tried to capture for Lorenzo (and whoever else might read it) the sense and purpose of what he had written, intimating just what was most important about the little gift he was sending. When we examine this belated introduction carefully, three major and tightly interrelated moments are most conspicuous: 1) the problematic relation between political ability (knowledge and experience) and success, 2) the awkwardness, irony, and unfairness of social and political rank, and 3) fortuna’s decisive, unpredictable, and deliberate interference in human affairs. In the months of 1513, post res perditas, when he was writing The Prince, guilt and dejection over his sudden calamity lay heavily on his mind. He had fallen, in a shockingly short time, from the heights of success (as represented by the remarks of a friend, in 1509, who had praised him excessively for his militia’s brilliant showing at Pisa and compared him to Quintus Fabius Maximus),3 to become the broken and humiliated outcast who could write, in a letter in 1513, that “it is a miracle
1 Kenneth Burke, The Philosophy of Literary Form (Baton Rouge, Louisiana: Louisiana State University Press, 1941), 92. 2 John Bunyan, The Pilgrim’s Progress, Vol. XV, Part 1, The Author’s Apology for his Book. The Harvard Classics (New York: P. F. Collier & Son, 1909–14; Bartleby.com, 2001), www.bartleby.com/15/1/ [14 February 2006]. 3 James B. Atkinson and David Sices, trans. and ed., Machiavelli and His Friends, Their Personal Correspondence (DeKalb: Northern Illinois University Press, 1996), hereinafter, Correspondence, Letter 167.
44
charles d. tarlton
that I am alive, because my post was taken from me and I was about to lose my life . . . I have had to endure all sorts of other evils, both prison and other kinds.”4 In such situations, human beings need to understand what has happened to them, to give it a name, and, nearly as often, nd some means for distancing themselves from its full implications or so softening those implications that they can salvage the condence to go on. Some might sacrice themselves in suicidal attempts at revenge, or try to quiet the murmuring that dogs them by acts of mad daring. Machiavelli, however, for all his familiarity with the world of violent men, was himself much gentler—a poet, a dramatist, a writer. The world of imagination promised the best way for him to seek deliverance from his agony. How better to achieve that than by writing a pithy, eccentric, and highly personal treatise on politics, at the center of which he could situate an imaginary and upstart political innovator who thrusts himself destructively into the middle of Italian politics? Such a vehicle could serve, moreover, as a setting in which he might dream a highly symbolic drama in which the ironies that plagued his days could be re-staged, assaulted, and overcome. Poetry might let him invent just the cast of surrogates (men and actions) in terms of which he might relive and improve his political life.5 The Prince is an episodic text, a kind of Pilgrim’s Progress with this difference—the characters who rise up and drift away in The Prince can be viewed as recurrences of a single persona; let us call him Il principe. He is a fantasy political actor who, transmuting from chapter to chapter, adopts various roles and performs, as it were, in the shifting scenes at the center of each chapter. On the surface, Machiavelli uses the names of actual historical princes in crucial places, but he has also brought in the abstract idea of a prince—some prince, any 4
Correspondence, Letter 214. There is a large and growing literature that looks at Machiavelli’s The Prince from the point of view of literature rather than political science proper. Those writings that I have found most useful include in this connection are: Thomas M. Greene, “The End of Discourse in Machiavelli’s Prince,” Yale French Studies 67 (1984), 57–71; Michael McCanles, The Discourse of “Il Principe,” (Malibu: Udena, 1983); Eugene Garver, “Machiavelli’s The Prince: A Neglected Rhetorical Classic,” Philosophy and Rhetoric, 13 (1980), 99–120; Martin Coyle, ed., Niccolò Machiavelli’s “The Prince:” New Interdisciplinary Essays (Manchester (UK) and New York: Manchester University Press, 1995), especially John Parkin, “Dialogue in The Prince”; John M. Najemy, “Language and The Prince”; Andrew Mousley, “The Prince and Textual Politics”; and all of the essays in Albert Russell Ascoli and Victoria Kahn, eds., Machiavelli and the Discourse of Literature (Ithaca and London: Cornell University Press, 1993). 5
machiavelli’s burden: THE PRINCE as literary text
45
prince, or all princes—to every chapter of The Prince. They appear as the subjects of narrative fragments of varying length, the stories of Il principe’s actions which are surrounded, in turn, by maxims, rules, and sweeping theoretical statements. Everything takes on the look of a story, fable, or parable, and tucked in amidst the more obvious stories, we nd prose passages that fasten the larger and more obviously narrative parts together. Not exactly story or exposition, these passages seem to fuse theory and story in a single form; the actors, scenes, and actions have been abstracted or typied. Consider, for example: Men who become rulers by prowess similar to theirs acquire their principalities with difculty but hold them with ease. The difculties they encounter in acquiring their principalities arise partly because of the new institutions and laws they are forced to introduce in founding the state and making themselves secure (20–21).
There is plenty of drama here, albeit slowed down and smoothed over. There may be no names or specic places, no dates or times, but there is story. We can nd, of course, different possible degrees of specicity in any narrative form. The expression “we ght,” tells a story in germ. “We will have to ght,” says a little more. “We, my citizens and I, will have to ght the enemy relentlessly, in the name of God,” carries us a lot farther along. Nevertheless, action (and, by implication), actors, setting, purpose, and outcome are present in all three. The same is true for virtually all of The Prince as a text; the fragments we encounter are pieces of the symbolic action of The Prince, which, in turn, we might then re-entitle, “The picaresque adventures of Il principe,” a swashbuckler who (oddly) very seldom wins, sometimes fails utterly, but mostly achieves only a sort of begrudging-near success. Despite that, Il principe, leaping from scene to scene, is always struggling to nd his way through the labyrinth of historical examples, precepts, rules, maxims, and theories that dene his labors. Machiavelli rst introduces this princely apparition in chapter 2, hesitating even to name the menace that rose up to threaten hereditary princes, and for which no amount of protection was sufcient. He here identies Il principe, indirectly, only as “an extraordinary and inordinate force” (8). As the ‘new prince,’ Il principe appears in a succession of dramatic political situations (conquering a neighboring kingdom, liberating an enslaved people, ousting an established prince and clinging to his place, rushing about to create his military foundations “on
46
charles d. tarlton
the run,” murdering or persuading his way into power, and the like) and, in acting out the underlying motif in each, he carries on, in Machiavelli’s name, as it were, the latter’s effort to come to terms with the apprehensions underpinning his own tragic fate. In the unfolding of The Prince, we can follow Machiavelli’s symbolic encounters with such key and troubling personal questions as: how anyone with such superb political perception could nevertheless fail at a crucial juncture; how, despite that inherent superiority, he had always been required to bow and scrape; and how fortuna had vindictively burst upon the scene to turn all his accomplishments to dust. 1. His prowess was such, even when he was an ordinary citizen, that his biographer wrote: “that he required nothing to be a prince but a princedom” (22). Machiavelli deeply felt, at least half of the time, that knowledge and experience ought to lead to success. His own knowledge had failed him (and Florence), and it was just those ideas in which he had put the most faith, especially the idea of the militia, the citizen army, that had let him down most ruinously. Right across the text of The Prince, in story after story, these problems are performed and the performances minutely examined to nd alternative and exonerating explanations. Machiavelli was engrossed here in the explanation of loss (we might even think of success, in The Prince, as but the avoidance of loss). Nothing, Machiavelli wrote, was so “dear to me or that I value as much as my understanding of the deeds of great men, won by me from long acquaintance with contemporary affairs and a continuous study of the ancient world” (3). The knowledge and experience that he was offering Lorenzo was so powerful, Machiavelli implies, that he could nonchalantly promise that “if he carefully observes the rules I have given above, a new prince will appear to have been long established and will quickly become more safe and secure in his government than if he had been ruling his state for a long time” (77). Knowledge of the right action to take was the guarantee of success, and the proof of that lay in the successes of the great leaders of the past, particularly the Romans; one need only study “the actions of eminent men to see how they conducted themselves during war and to discover the reasons for their victories or their defeats, so that he can avoid the latter and imitate the former” (49). Success, on at least one level of the text of The Prince, results from political actions or policy being in accord with the times. The knowl-
machiavelli’s burden: THE PRINCE as literary text
47
edge best suited to the achieving of success, then, was knowing what action would be most suitable to the achieving of one’s goals in some particular situation. History provided examples of success and failure, models of completed actions in which the goals, the settings, the actions themselves, and their outcomes are concluded. It is clear in these examples whether the historical actor had done the right thing or not, simply because he was successful or not. In the present, you need only model your actions on those of successful past actors, who had pursued goals like yours, in circumstances like yours. “So a prudent man must always follow in the footsteps of great men,” Machiavelli wrote, “and imitate those who have been outstanding” (19). A closer reading of these and other passages, however, reveals a twist that calls such a straightforward summing into question. The emulative method, Machiavelli hints here and there, is not really so undemanding. In fact, men do naturally imitate those who have been victorious, although it is most often done, he also said, despite the fact that most men could not really reach as high or as far as those truly great. This was all right, because even when “his own prowess fails to compare with theirs, at least it has an air (odore) of greatness about it” (19). One feels something in common with the great men of the past, he seems to have said, as if comforting someone, even if that resemblance is an illusion. Had we been there to hear him say that, how could we have doubted for a second that he was talking about his own experience? His was a knowledge gained painfully, he had told us, and, in large part, “from a long acquaintance with contemporary affairs and a continuous study of the ancient world” (3). He was, perhaps, like one of those “eminent men” of the past, who, in his pursuit of historical successes to copy, studied “history so that he [could] do what eminent men have done before him: taken as their model some historical gure who has been praised and honoured; and always kept his deeds and actions before them” (49). Machiavelli doubtless had let himself fantasize in this way about the parallels between his own knowledge and ability and those of the greatest princes, both historical and contemporary. However, he had also come to realize that the distance between himself and, say, Caesar or Severus or Hiero, was too great to surmount by merely feeling the resemblance or snifng the odore. In any event, it is clear that from the outset he would both present this historical-imitative method as his own (made available, of course, in the predigested form that Machiavelli
48
charles d. tarlton
had “very diligently analyzed and pondered . . . and summarized” in his “little book” (3)) and, at the same time, hedge his bets, acknowledging that the difculty any prince “encounters in maintaining his rule is more or less serious insofar as he is more or less able” (19). In any case, the troublesome question here remains how someone who so well “knew” the mysteries of the political process (as Machiavelli claims he did) could have failed so abjectly. He remains undecided between the view that knowledge and experience are the means to success, on the one hand, and the realization, on the other, that such a connection may only be illusory, the result merely of overestimating one’s own capacities. As a result, the text strains in the effort to salvage his own ability, and to show that, if he did fail, it was not for lack of knowing what to do. Machiavelli beseeched Lorenzo to “realize the extent to which, undeservedly, I have to endure the great and unremitting malice of fortune” (3). Undeservedly, because all he had ever done, he had done for his country and to the best of his considerable ability. Il principe, having known the security of the publicly beloved hereditary princedom, whose power and security demanded only that he be “reasonably assiduous” and “not neglect the institutions founded by one’s ancestors,” is suddenly catapulted into the role of the “new prince,” where “difculties do arise” (7–8). Machiavelli focused the bulk of his attention on two new princes who failed—Louis XII, the king of France, and Cesare Borgia, the son of Pope Alexander VI. The few successful new princes who do appear—Ferdinand of Aragon, Agathocles the Syracusan, Pope Julius II, and the Roman emperor Severus—become mere caricatures, their successes attributed mainly to a kind of cunning or instinctive and violent capacity to act without caution. Louis XII and Cesare Borgia, however, stood in important, if different, relations to the rules of politics. The actions of the former illuminated those rules in the breach; the latter was an original, whose actions were so dazzling they actually brought new rules into existence. Nevertheless, they both failed. We meet Louis XII in Chapter 3, in the midst of his ill-fated foray into Lombardy and the Duchy of Milan. Louis rolled into Italy with his army, conquered Milan, helped Cesare Borgia’s campaign in the Romagna, subjugated the Kingdom of Naples with the help of Ferdinand of Aragon, was opposed by Pope Julius II and the Holy League, and was eventually driven from Italy. Already a powerful king, but eager to restore an old claim and capture a foothold in northern Italy, Louis is used by Machiavelli to demonstrate the fate of the ‘insufcient prince.’
machiavelli’s burden: THE PRINCE as literary text
49
The Prince has cast Louis’s story in a logic of contrariety, in which his actions come into view entirely in the form of mistaken strategies, rules manifested in the negative. Louis had, therefore, made these ve mistakes: he had destroyed the weaker powers; increased the power of someone already powerful in Italy; brought into that country a very powerful foreigner; stayed away from Italy himself; failed to establish settlements there. Even these mistakes, if he had lived, need not have been fatal if there had not been a sixth: his dispossessing the Venetians of their state (14).
Louis’s faltering is related with an obvious moral. The story is prefaced by commemoration of the successes of the Romans in similar kinds of invasions, from which successes Machiavelli abstracts a structure of political rules, which, inside out, Louis’s actions systematically violate. Masquerading as Louis, Il principe acts out his tragic through-line, hunting down the connection between ability and political success. Machiavelli’s message is clear. The wish to acquire more is admittedly a very natural and common thing; and when men succeed in this they are always praised rather than condemned. But when they lack the ability to do so and yet want to acquire more at all costs, they deserve condemnation for their mistakes (14).
We readily understand Machiavelli’s indignation here; in the rst place, Louis’s inexcusable failure had ultimately (if unwittingly) set in motion the series of events that led directly to Machiavelli’s own catastrophe. The French failure to impede the objectives of Ferdinand and Julius II deposited the Spanish army (and the Medici) on Florence’s doorstep. Nevertheless, Louis’s desire to acquire more was certainly understandable, and Machiavelli insists, “I do not mean to condemn the course of action taken by the king” (13). At rst, Louis only did what circumstances forced him to do. However, blame attaches to failure, in this connection, when the ambition is not rooted in a realistic expectation. France, under Louis, blindly undertook more than she had the resources to accomplish. In the actions of all men, and especially of princes, where there is no court of appeal, one judges by the result. So let a prince set about the task of conquering, and maintaining his state; his methods will always be judged honorable and will be universally praised (58).
At the same time, Machiavelli cannot let go of the obviously (and personally) expedient view that even where failure and loss are involved,
50
charles d. tarlton
something might yet be salvaged if it can be shown that the actor had the requisite knowledge and experience. Even though Louis had made mistake after mistake (ve, to begin with), Machiavelli remarked that he could have rescued himself, if he just had not made the sixth mistake (which was to “help another become powerful”).6 Louis, who already had the princedom, was, perhaps, no real prince because he squandered his magnicent advantages of wealth, power, armies, and friends, whereas Machiavelli, like Hiero, had all along had the requisite ability but languished only for the lack of stuff. As if to leave no doubt about the closeness of this episode to Machiavelli’s own heart, he intrudes himself, in the persona of the author, into the text at the end of the chapter. Repeating the central lesson: King Louis, therefore, lost Lombardy because he observed none of the rules observed by others who have seized countries and determined to hold on to them. There is nothing fantastic about this, it is very commonplace and reasonable. I had a word on this subject with Rouen, at Nantes, when Valentino (as Cesare Borgia, son of Pope Alexander, was popularly called) was occupying the Romagna (15).
The Italians knew nothing of War, the Archbishop of Rouen had said to Machiavelli, to which he had replied, as he tells us, that the French knew nothing of statecraft. They knew nothing of what Machiavelli knew so well; and, so, they lost. Cesare Borgia, on the other hand, was Machiavelli’s choice as the most imitable of princes, who nevertheless also failed. If Machiavelli traced Louis’s failure to his doing the opposite of what ought to be done, he could not do the same to Cesare Borgia. Though Borgia was, perhaps, an even more complete failure than Louis, Machiavelli insisted that he “was right in putting him forward as an example for all those who have acquired power through good fortune and the arms of others” (27). Borgia’s story is the most fully realized narrative in The Prince, and the lessons Machiavelli drew from it reveal how important that story was to his purposes in the book. The arc of Cesare’s brief political career (“having summed up all that the duke did” (27)) mirrors Machiavelli’s own concerns in The Prince, and the summary of the lessons to be learned from Borgia reads like a synopsis of the book. 6 This idea of a continuously deferrable outcome was a crucial one for Machiavelli. Its importance in the overall structure of The Prince is developed in Charles D. Tarlton, “Machiavelli’s The Prince as Memoir,” Texas Studies in Literature and Language, 46, 1 (Spring, 2004), 1–19.
machiavelli’s burden: THE PRINCE as literary text
51
So a new prince cannot nd more recent examples than those set by the duke, if he thinks it is necessary to secure himself against his enemies, win friends, conquer either by force or by stratagem, make himself both loved and feared by his subjects, followed and respected by his soldiers, if he determines to destroy those who can and will injure him, to reform ancient institutions, be severe yet loved, magnanimous and generous, and if he decides to destroy disloyal troops and create a new standing army, maintaining such relations with kings and princes that they have either to help him graciously or go carefully in doing him harm (28).
The abridgment of Borgia’s deeds epitomizes the whole of The Prince; the lessons reach back to the earliest chapters and stretch forward to the conclusions. If we would know the underlying romance of Il principe, we must see him here in Cesare Borgia’s sad shoes. Moreover, remaining alert for signs of Machiavelli’s own symbolic investment in all that happens, we can notice how very evocatively he links his own misfortunes with Borgia’s by employing parallel verbal structures to name their common fates; thus, his own grief he attributed to “una grande e continua malignità di fortuna (great and continuous misfortune), while Borgia, he said, suffered from una estraordinaria et extreme malignità di fortuna (extraordinary and extreme misfortune).”7 Because Borgia was one who made “the journey” [to political power] “as if [he] had wings,” his problems only began the moment he alighted. Being dependent on his father and the king of France for his position, he stood little chance of lasting success unless, as the current textual embodiment of Il principe, he proved to be one of those princes of “such prowess that overnight they can learn how to preserve what fortune has suddenly tossed in to their laps, and unless they can then lay foundations such as other princes would have already been building on” (22–23). For the greater part of Borgia’s short career, this proved to be quite easy; where Louis’s failure had been traceable to his ignorance of what the Romans and others before him had known so well (thus, conrming ironically Machiavelli’s linking of ability with success), Borgia’s impressive early successes are said to grow out of his instinctive grasp of what was, in virtually any circumstances, the right and necessary thing to do. Machiavelli’s Borgia neither drew on the past nor imitated anyone; he was, as it were, an originator of strategies, maneuvers that might later become maxims to guide others.
7
Niccolò Machiavelli, Il principe e Discorsi (Milano: Feltrinelli, 1960), 14, 35.
52
charles d. tarlton
Borgia was the only political actor in The Prince whose political acumen is portrayed as being on a par with the Romans. Both just somehow seemed to know what to do, and both eventually failed for the same reason. The Romans, who always “saw when troubles were coming” (12), failed, in the end, to read the consequences of hiring Goth mercenaries, and it “was the start of the downfall of the Roman empire” (47). Borgia, similarly, “had laid excellent foundations for his future power,” but (and, here, as was the case discussing Louis, Machiavelli again intrudes his own persona into the text, talking with Borgia himself ) he failed to anticipate a sudden damaging turn of events. If when Alexander died, he had been well himself, everything would have been easy for him. And he himself said to me, the day Julius II was elected, that he had thought of everything that could happen when his father died, and found a remedy for everything except that he never thought that when he did so he himself would also be at the point of death. (27)
For Machiavelli the key to the story of Il principe as Borgia, however, resides in its essential ambiguity. Borgia was both the unsuspecting victim of fortuna and someone who made a mistake that “was the cause of his ultimate ruin” (28). Machiavelli’s text remains indeterminate (I almost said ‘irresolute’) in this connection, I suspect, because he remains equally uncertain regarding his own blamelessness for his own fate. Fortuna, however compelling as an explanation, was also too convenient, too apologetic. Either both of them, he and Borgia, so skilled and knowing and so closely coupled in the text of The Prince, were responsible for what happened to them, or they were not. Fortuna, in Chapter 6 of the text, was as yet insufciently developed to bridge between the poles of this duality, and was too entirely restricted to the question of one’s opportunity; we have to wait for the penultimate chapter to encounter fortuna as caprice and vindictiveness. For the moment, we can speculate, however, that Machiavelli, having looked in the mirror and seen the reected resemblance to Cesare, had already begun to conclude that “fortune is the arbiter of half the things we do, leaving the other half or so to be controlled by ourselves” (79). No more than a fty-fty chance, regardless how well one has prepared one’s forces, are not good odds. The predicament of Il principe, as represented in the carefully wrought stories of Louis and Borgia, designates the cathartic and strategic sleight of hand by which Machiavelli tried to rise above his own sense of self-reproach. If lack of understanding could fell so powerful a king as
machiavelli’s burden: THE PRINCE as literary text
53
Louis, and if someone as clever and resourceful as Borgia, through no fault of his own, could nevertheless come to a bad end, then Machiavelli, lacking adequate resources and armed only with his clear grasp of politics might be pardoned for not saving himself. 2. In this case, he may well be given good advice, but he would not last long because the man who governs him would soon deprive him of his state (76–77). Either you are already a prince, or you are on the way to becoming one (52). Hierarchy, as Kenneth Burke reminded us, is always awkward and embarrassing. Discourse across the gulfs that dene rank is generally difcult and poignant; the very principle that elevates one over another carries in it, by implication, the suggestion and the possibility of their reversal. In his address to Lorenzo, Machiavelli was so humble, excusing in advance any inadvertent presumptuousness that might have found its way into his writing. He admitted to being a man of “low and humble status,” living in “low-lying regions,” whereas Lorenzo, he acknowledged, was a prince, living on a “lofty peak.” Between these expressions of hair-tugging deference, Machiavelli insinuates a subversive metaphor based on the tactics of map makers, who, when they “are sketching the landscape put themselves down in the plain to study the mountains and the highlands, and to study the low-lying land they put themselves high on the mountains.” Not wanting his point to be missed, he quickly explains that “to comprehend fully the nature of the people, one must be a prince, and to comprehend fully the nature of princes, one must be an ordinary citizen” (4). Each rank, the high and the low, requires the perspective of the other to recognize itself; that is an intense symbiosis. Proceeding into the text of The Prince proper, it is hard not to cast a glance back; there was something sarcastic in that display of subservience, just subtle enough not to be missed. From chapter 3 through chapter 8, Il principe stood alone; “one must urgently arrange matters so that when they [the populace] no longer believe they can be made to believe by force” (21). The distance, difference, and friction between ruler and people in those early chapters were vast and decisive. Machiavelli’s dramatizations of Il principe were quite cold-blooded and stark. The people were constrained in the narrowest roles: they invited the conqueror in, but were inevitably disappointed in the result; they clung to their old rulers and were therefore slaughtered;
54
charles d. tarlton
or they attacked and overthrew pusillanimous new princes and fell in line with wise, resolute, and resourceful ones. In every case, however, the characters played by Il principe stood diametrically opposed to the people; the rhetorical structure of hierarchy was centered on command and obedience. None of the stories point in a single direction. Over against the cold mechanistic clanking of Il principe’s arrival on the scene, there is a constant, softer, but no less steady drumbeat of egalitarian sentiment. We already know that the (all but mystical) source of political wisdom was always the Romans (of the Republic, that is); their collective and independent organization assured them wise leaders and noble policies. The idea of republics, as a general rule, constituted a kind of poison pill to Il principe: “Whoever becomes the master of a city accustomed to freedom, and does not destroy it, may expect to be destroyed himself ” (18). They remain a constant threat despite Il principe’s best efforts because “the memory of their ancient liberty does not and cannot let them rest” (19). Machiavelli’s predilection for republics is never completely absent from The Prince. Chapter 8 had narrated the crimes of two murderous princes (the one, Agathocles, successful, the other, Oliverotto da Fermo, not) and extolled the merit of expeditious cruelty, but the adventures of Il principe resume in earnest in Chapter 9, which tells the story of the principatu civili (the constitutional or civil prince, with its echoes of community), relating how an ordinary private citizen rises to the rank of prince on a wave of popular or aristocratic emotion. In the course of this prince’s circuitous ways to power, Machiavelli explores the multifarious forms of social and political rank. Machiavelli had suffered routinely from the hostility of those above him in both political authority and social status; “I was born in poverty,” he wrote to Francesco Vettori shortly after being released from jail, “and at an early age learned how to scrimp rather than to thrive.”8 Therefore, it is with some interest that we watch him deconstruct the sociological structure of domination. All states were, at the core, divided between the people and the nobles, the former and largest group wanting only not to be oppressed, and the latter seeking only to oppress. Machiavelli’s bias here is quite clear. These divisions within all cities can lead to any of three outcomes—a principality (when either the nobles or the people, out of fear of the
8
Correspondence, Letter 206.
machiavelli’s burden: THE PRINCE as literary text
55
other side, elevate one of their own and support his bid for power), a republic (when the conict is channeled into and through public institutions and laws), and anarchy (when the conict simply rages on). Machiavelli collapses the two logical princely possibilities into one; the man who becomes a prince through the encouragement of the nobles will eventually have to turn on them (because the nobles are always themselves ambitious and, therefore, dangerous) and seek the support of the people. “Moreover,” he adds, “a prince can never make himself safe against a hostile people: there are too many of them” (33). The mix is uid and risky, up and down, forever alternating. The people, fearful and disorganized, are looking only for safety; the nobles, some pusillanimous and able to be manipulated, the others ambitious and shifty, seek power and the opportunity to lord it over the populace. Il principe has to weave his way through an intricate web of competing and mutually suspicious forces. In the end, however, the greatest stability is gained by siding with the people against the nobles. Machiavelli dismisses those who decry the political imsiness of the people’s loyalty (“Let no one contradict this opinion of mine with that trite proverb, that he who builds on the people builds on mud”) (34), and takes the people’s side against the nobles. Crucially, however, the victory of the people that this chapter envisions requires a miraculous transformation of Il principe from an opportunistic political adventurer into an archetypal hero-prince. But if it is a prince who builds his power on the people, one who can command and is a man of courage, who does not despair in adversity, who does not fail to take precautions, and who wins general allegiance by his personal qualities and the institutions he establishes, he will never be let down by the people; and he will be found to have established his power securely (35).
Rank is often the goal and consequence of ambition (when it is not inherited, of course), so Machiavelli appends a little coda to his story of the popularly chosen prince. Commonly, even in the case of the paragon he has just described, Il principe is not content with a power that, like the one praised above, might have a reciprocal quality about it. Craving more than mere respect, security, and harmony, some potential princes will inevitably attempt to seize absolute power, to raise themselves above even the people’s scrutiny. They enter a morass, however, through which Machiavelli, apparently, cannot imagine a successful passage. A maelstrom of reaction, resistance, betrayal, danger, and confusion is all that awaits such immoderation.
56
charles d. tarlton
The petty motives that underpin the behavior of the upper classes and prevent the ordering of a prosperous and optimistic society (something, he will insist later on, that ought to be the goal of any proper prince) are banished by Il principe in the guise of this civil prince. Real politics carries us over and beyond small-minded purposes, Machiavelli seems to be saying, and it allows the man of virtue and skill to rise up and overturn the prevailing hierarchies. It is not difcult to see the implications for Lorenzo (and any others who might have lorded it over Machiavelli). No one, he warns, is ever permanently ensconced in their pinnacles. The Prince abruptly changes subject in Chapter 15; Machiavelli turns away from the overt violence of conquests and toward the sublimated violence of artice. Il principe moves about, trying on various masks, donning disguises, and practicing strange voices. He is a prince performing before an audience of the people because princes, we are told, “are more exposed to view . . . and are judged for various qualities which earn them either praise or condemnation” (50). Of these many vices and virtues, there are some that “everyone will agree that it would be most laudable if a prince” (50 –51) possessed them; there are others that an astute prince can never more than pretend to have. He must know the difference between ‘moral actions’ that will cost him his position, and those which, to the delight of the moralizing crowd, he can indulge to the limit. As an actor, Il principe must resist dragging his off-stage personality on to the boards; in fact, as Machiavelli insists, he probably ought not to have an off-stage personality at all, but “he should have a exible disposition, varying as fortune and circumstances dictate” (57). Il principe’s goal now is to capture the good will of the people, an objective beyond the reach of the crude tactics of war and conquest (the tools of the “lion”). He requires the wiles of the “fox” to keep himself always before the eyes of public, yet always out of sight. “Men in general judge by their eyes,” Machiavelli wrote, “rather than by their hands; because, everyone is in a position to watch, few are in a position to come in close touch with you. . . . The common people are always impressed by appearances and results. In this context, there are only common people, and there is no leeway for the few when the many are rmly sustained” (58). The hierarchal pillar at the center of politics can be seen to lean a little, showing signs of instability. The prince comes down closer to the people, closer to resembling the people, to reect back to the people the expectations they themselves have about government. There can be no success if one is hated or contemned by the populace. The stage direc-
machiavelli’s burden: THE PRINCE as literary text
57
tions for the part of Il principe increasingly require him to engineer the good will of the people; otherwise, “he must go in fear of everything and everyone” (61). “But, wait,” Il principe might say, “that’s all an illusion; behind the scene of those tricks, the prince is free to do what he wants.” One wonders, though, what could that be, that “what he wants,” if it were something that would not otherwise work on stage? Everything comes under the proscenium arch of public approval. Il principe, whose earliest roles had each required only the skills and determination of the innovator whose mind was set on conquering and maintaining a state, has by now become merely an instrument of that state, his every action now dedicated to holding its fragile constitution together. He has learned this ironic and valuable lesson in respect of hierarchy and rank: in symbiosis, there is little difference between tenant and host. It is the basis for social hope. 3. Their own indolence was to blame, because, having never imagined when times were quiet that they could change (and this is a common failing of mankind, never to anticipate a storm when the sea is calm), when adversity came their rst thoughts were of ight and not resistance (78). Il principe has arrived at a decisive moment. Behind him, amidst the now wavering certainties of the promised political mechanics, the predators are snifng and howling for his blood. Machiavelli’s general laws and maxims have come gradually to seem less and less certain; we repeatedly meet such caveats as, “it is impossible to give a nal verdict on any of these policies,” (67) and “here generalization is impossible” (69). Situations are no longer so easily categorized; as the saying goes, the devil is suddenly in the details. In front of Il principe, the quicksand of fortuna is waiting to suck him down. “I say that we see that some princes ourish one day and come to grief the next,” Machiavelli cautions, “without appearing to have changed in character or any other way” (80). What has brought this misfortune down upon our hero? The simple answer is that with all this emphasis on the past, we have been neglecting the future! “Time sweeps everything along,” Machiavelli had warned early on, foreshadowing (we now see) what was about to unfold, “and can bring good as well as evil, evil as well as good” (12). While the earliest escapades of Louis XII, Borgia, Agathocles, and the rest had gestured toward an undoubted connection between action and circumstances, the emphasis had always been on choosing the right action for whatever circumstances one happened to nd oneself.
58
charles d. tarlton
Political knowledge amounted to a kind of strategic calculus, in which knowledgeable actors plotted the vectors of cause and effect from situation to situation, comparing vital similarities and dissimilarities, for good measure, watching themselves in the historical mirror. Earlier, noting how Louis XII did none of the things that successful conquerors had done, and pressed to explain just how he knew what those rules were, Machiavelli had credited the Romans for having originated the model strategies and principles. Il principe now steps forward to ask: “How could they have always known what to do?” The answer is, weirdly, they could tell fortunes. In these instances, the Romans did what all wise rulers must: cope not only with present troubles but also with ones likely to arise in future, and assiduously forestall them. When trouble is sensed well in advance it can easily be remedied; if you wait for it to show itself any medicine will be too late because the disease will have become incurable (12).
Machiavelli, it seems, had all along been warning Il principe about the uncertainties of politics, even while uttering assurances that he knew its ins and outs. Maybe the “Romans saw when troubles were coming and always took counter-measures,” but these were more or less fantasy Romans, and Il principe and everyone else who has studied politics with any seriousness knows that nothing can safely be predicted, that no tactics are guaranteed, and that no victory is ever permanent. Still, if Machiavelli would insist that “political disorders can be quickly healed, if they are seen well in advance,” he still has to hedge his bets, and add that “only a prudent ruler has such foresight” (12). We have to wait until chapter 21, however, to nd out what Machiavelli means by prudence. Then no government should ever imagine that it can always adopt a safe course; rather, it should regard all possible courses of action as risky. This is the way things are: whenever one tries to escape one danger one runs into another. Prudence [ here it is] consists in being able to assess the nature of a particular threat and in accepting the lesser evil (73, emphasis added).
I wonder (and Il principe certainly wonders) whether we would have read very far beyond the opening passages of this book if Machiavelli had told us to begin with how little he really knew. When we eventually get to a fuller explication of fortuna in Chapter 25, the spotlight will be on Pope Julius II. The soldier pope’s success and his good fortuna were, of course, the other side of the coin from Machiavelli’s fall from grace, just as they had also canceled out Cesare Borgia’s good
machiavelli’s burden: THE PRINCE as literary text
59
luck streak. Such observations are crucial to our understanding of The Prince as a symbolic action in which Machiavelli sought to name, encompass, and transcend the calamity in his life. In the rst place, I would argue that he had set out to excuse his own failure as something utterly beyond his control. Fortuna had worked its malice on Machiavelli just as it had victimized Cesare Borgia (and all those unnamed other princes who had counted wholly on fortuna). In this view, fortuna was whimsical, a capricious goddess raising men up, as Machiavelli had put it in his “Tercets on Fortune,” only to crash them down the harder. Fortuna exists literarily to exonerate us from all responsibility. In the Proem, Machiavelli had employed another, second strategy with respect to fortuna. Within the short compass of that brief introduction, we nd, linked together in an embarrassing pairing (virtually suggesting courtship), on the one hand, the cluster of Machiavelli (knowledge of politics, bad fortuna, low status (luoghi basso), the people) and, on the other hand, the cluster of Lorenzo (needing political knowledge, good fortuna, high status (sua altezza), prince). By the end of the book, as we shall see in the afterword, he had collapsed the differences between the two clusters, allowing the gure, Machiavelli, to go forward optimistically, in tandem with Lorenzo, in the now composite and heroic Il principe, metamorphosed into the savior of Italy. Before getting to that, however, the penultimate story in our adventures of Il principe nds our political adventurer weaving his way through fortuna’s obstacle course of shifting ratios among personal dispositions, circumstances, courses of action, and endings. “I say that we see some princes ourish one day and come to grief the next,” Machiavelli said, “without appearing to have changed in character or any other way” (80). In the midst of shifting circumstances, anyone whose actions remain always the same must eventually fail. By the same token (one would have supposed), anyone whose actions were simply wild, formless, and unpredictable would also run into trouble, eventually. Consider the options available to princes in their mad scramble to conquer and hold on to states. “One man proceeds with circumspection, another impetuously; one uses violence, another stratagem; one man goes about things patiently, another does the opposite; and yet everyone, for all this diversity of method, can reach his objective” (80). There are all kinds of princes who have succeeded, yet no one can say which of them followed the wisest course of action. But, wait, there’s more. “It can also be observed,” he goes on, “that with two circumspect men, one will achieve his end, the other not; and likewise two men succeed
60
charles d. tarlton
equally well with different methods, one of them being circumspect and the other impetuous” (80). We can see why there is so much confusion and inertia among the princes; they are irresolute and passive, perhaps, just because they cannot gure out what to do. Ah, but there is an answer. “This results,” Machiavelli assures us, “from nothing else except the extent to which their methods are or are not suited to the nature of the times” (80). Is this (by now, certainly) merely tautological conclusion really meant to reassure Il principe? I do not think so; but it is, I believe, meant to stretch out the question of what to do beyond the simple considerations of immediate success or failure. One can be doing the right thing for a long time, succeeding all over the place, and then, suddenly, and without anyone seeing it come, the very next action (say, trusting our beloved militia to hold out against an angry, hungry, and vengeful Spanish army, or believing that a lifetime of public service in which one always sought only the public good would by itself keep us beyond suspicion) we fall ignominiously on our faces. “This also explains why prosperity is ephemeral,” Machiavelli announced, pregnant with implication, “because if a man behaves with patience and circumspection and the time and circumstances are such that this method is called for, he will prosper; but if time and circumstances change he will be ruined because he does not change his policy” (80). Was it a failure of judgment or of nerve? Who could not see that there had to be a connection between our actions and our setting? We must all have something like a natural instinct to create just such balances. Failure here must reect a kind of aw, a weakness of character or intellect. Machiavelli’s next move, however, is to expand the area of the unexceptionable to accommodate just such failure. “Nor do we nd any man shrewd enough to know how to adapt his policy in this way” (80). No one knows how to do it; no one could have known how to do it; how could I have known how to do it; why would you blame me? Il principe strikes a deant pose. It is all perfectly reasonable, is it not?, simply a matter of no one being able to act in contradiction to his or her basic disposition, on the one hand, or, on the other, “having always prospered by proceeding one way, he cannot persuade himself to change” (80). Not even Cesare Borgia could surmount this natural law: He was a man of great courage and high intentions, and he could not have conducted himself other than the way he did; his plans were frustrated only because Alexander’s life was cut short and because of his own sickness (27).
machiavelli’s burden: THE PRINCE as literary text
61
Moreover, even Julius II, who “was impetuous in everything . . . and found the time and circumstances so favourable to his way of proceeding that he always met with success . . . would have come to grief . . . if there had come a time when it was necessary for him to act with circumspection” (81). All of his deeds were of the same disconcerting nature, and all of them succeeded. We know, though, that he would have eventually failed (he did not, however, fail in time for it to do Machiavelli any good) because “he would never have acted other than in character” (81).9 Il principe remembers something that Machiavelli had said much earlier, namely, that the prince “should have a exible disposition” (57); he must be able to lie, kill, betray, torment, pretend, deceive, and hoard whenever his political position requires him to do so. However, this exibility seems mainly tactically moral; it is a matter of adopting whatever disguises will elicit the desired response from the populace who are always watching and commenting. It is a different thing entirely when Il principe is facing waves of previously unknown enemies coming up and into view over the horizon to attack him. Here exibility has to operate deeply within the truth of the prince’s psychology; he would have to be able to make himself over for real. What is lacking in all this talk of fortuna, therefore, is any explicit recommendation for how to act. We have heard before that Il principe “must read history, studying the actions of eminent men to see how they conducted themselves” (49), that when the ruler’s family “has been wiped out there is no one left to fear” (16–17), and that “there is no doubt that a prince’s greatness depends on his triumphing over difculties and opposition” (69). What is Machiavelli’s nal word about how to face fortuna? Just this: I conclude, therefore, that as fortune is changeable whereas men are obstinate in their ways, men prosper so long as fortune and policy are in accord, and when there is a clash they fail. I hold strongly to this: that it is better to be impetuous than circumspect; because fortune is a woman and if she is to be submissive it is necessary to beat and coerce her (81).
Audacity replaces ability against fortuna in the prescription now being written for Il principe. Machiavelli now only needed to show how he meant to use all this; turning away from the past, Il principe suddenly launches into a fantastic future.
9 Again, the idea of deferred success and failure. Time eventually brings everything.
62
charles d. tarlton
4. “As for the rest of the Italians uniting, you make me laugh; rst, there will never be any union in Italy that will do any good; even if all the leaders were united, that would be inadequate because the armies here are not worth a red cent.” 10 In Chapter 6, “Moses, Cyrus, Romulus, Theseus, and others like them,” were introduced as examples of leaders so able that they do not seem to have had from fortune anything other than opportunity. Fortune, as it were, provided the matter, but they gave it its form; without opportunity their prowess would have been extinguished, and without such prowess the opportunity would have come in vain (20).
By the time we have come to the end of The Prince, the “Exhortation to Liberate Italy from the Barbarians,” however, these images have undergone some big changes. First of all, Italy has been added to the list (linking Lorenzo with those other legendary heroes), but, more importantly, the relation between hero and people (country, situation, “opportunity,” fortuna) has been transformed. We now learn that the Israelites needed rst to have been enslaved to bring forth a Moses, the Persians had to be oppressed for there to be a Cyrus, the Athenians were scattered only in order to produce a Theseus, and Italy “had to be more enslaved than the Hebrews, more oppressed than the Persians, more widely scattered than the Athenians; leaderless, lawless, crushed, despoiled, torn, overrun; she had to have endured every kind of desolation . . . in order, therefore that Italy, after so long a time, may behold its saviour. . . .” (82, 84). Being down in the depths of ruin and despair has become, for all these peoples, merely (as it always has been, in redemption talk) the precondition for deliverance; the oppressed shall triumph by virtue of having been oppressed. Nevertheless, the people require their rescuing prince; their able, wise, and fortunate leader. The old leaders have been too weak; they have all succumbed to their own indolence and stupidity. Never thinking about the future, neglecting their armies, and failing in every category of good political leadership, they complain that their peoples have abandoned them. “[ T ]hose who are capable are not obeyed,” Machiavelli observes, “Everyone imagines he is competent, and hitherto no one has had the competence to dominate the others by his prowess and good fortune” (83). The times are, indeed, ripe for Il principe, who now combines good fortune with
10
Correspondence, Letter 219.
machiavelli’s burden: THE PRINCE as literary text
63
true ability; he transforms into Lorenzo. Only the Medici possess the good fortuna and the ability it will take to “lead Italy to her salvation” (82). All that is missing is the knowledge of what to do. “The task will not be very hard,” Machiavelli soothes, unashamedly naming himself repeatedly, “if you will call to mind the actions and lives of the men I have mentioned. . . . There is great justice in our cause . . . provided only your House will emulate the methods of those I have singled out for admiration” (82–83). Machiavelli, himself stepping now into the shoes of Il principe, has literarily hitched his wagon to the Medici star. The distance that, in the Proem, had stretched between his luoghi bassi and Lorenzo’s altezza has been bridged, verbally, at least. Before anyone can notice, he points the discussion away from images of God and redemption and onto armies. Italy’s grave situation was due to the weakness of Italian arms and armies “because the old military systems were bad and there has been no one who knew how to establish a new one” (83). A crusade had to be conducted right here, and who else to supply the knowledge and experience of creating armies better than Machiavelli himself ? Had he not once known and reveled in the glory of military success in the victory at Pisa? “If I did not think it would make you too proud,” Agostino Vespucci had written to him, in 1509, when Machiavelli’s victorious militia (whose success in defeating the Pisans everyone granted was due mainly to Machiavelli)11 was the talk of the town, “I should dare say that you with your battalions accomplished so much good work, in such a way that, not by delaying but by speeding up, you restored the affairs of Florence.”12 “And nothing brings a man greater honour,” Machiavelli himself had pronounced, “than the new laws and new institutions he establishes. When these are soundly based and bear the mark of greatness, they make him revered and admired” (83). We seem on the brink of a momentous declaration. Think of all the promises he has been making about how a courageous Il principe—who exercises prudence, who aims slightly higher than the target, who sees into the future, who keeps his own counsel, who can feign both attitude and action when necessary, and who knows how to use the knife of cruelty with compassion—will “reach the eminence that fortune and
11 Roberto Ridol, The Life of Niccolò Machiavelli (Chicago: The University of Chicago Press, 1963), 107–108. 12 Correspondence, Letter 167.
64
charles d. tarlton
your other qualities promise you” (4). We suppose that he must now be going to reveal the huge and complex project he has proposed for them, outlining the intricate plans and arrangements to be begun, but, instead, he reaches deeply into his old bag of chestnuts for this: Therefore if your illustrious House wants to emulate those eminent men who saved their countries, before all else it is essential for it, as the right basis for every campaign, to raise a citizen army; for there can be no more loyal, more true, or better troops (24).
It sounds suspiciously as if he were looking for a second chance. Perhaps we need to remind ourselves what, in his own words, had actually gone wrong. Less than a year earlier, Machiavelli had written: In the meantime, it came about that the Spanish army had appeared before Prato [garrisoned by Machiavelli’s own militia] and attacked it vigorously. Since they were unable to take it by storm, His Excellency began negotiating an agreement with the Florentine ambassador. . . . When the ambassadors arrived with this proposal [a payment from Florence to the King of Spain and his agreement not to force the Medici upon Florence] reported on the weakened condition of the Spaniards, and asserted that they might die of hunger and that Prato was going to hold out, the gonfalonier and the scores of people with whom he was consulting were inspired with such great condence that despite the advice from the wise for peace on that basis, the gonfalonier kept on postponing matters, until two days later news of Prato’s capture arrived and of how the Spaniards, having broken through some of the walls, began to force the defenders back and to terrify them. So that, after slight resistance, they all ed and the Spaniards took possession of the city, put it to sack, and massacred the city population in a pitiable spectacle of calamity.13
The Florentine Republic capitulated, then, and the Medici were restored to power. The people surrendered their liberty, Machiavelli concluded, because “everyone started to fear a sack because of the cowardice our soldiers displayed at Prato.”14 Those were his soldiers, the same ‘citizen army’ he was now ogging to Lorenzo. The two major schemes in the “exhortation,” the unication of Italy and the necessity of a citizen army seem, when judged in the harsh light of day, hopelessly improbable and unworkable. Nevertheless, here they are in the text, enthusiastically offered to Lorenzo as the chariots they might both ride into a triumphant future. Perhaps Machiavelli trusted
13 14
Correspondence, Letter 203. Correspondence, Letter 203.
machiavelli’s burden: THE PRINCE as literary text
65
that Medici inuence would, of itself, be able to make his dreams come true ( just as Hobbes would later dream of a sovereign who would transform his ‘speculations’ into ‘the utility of practice’). Nevertheless, he had to have been in a trauma-induced poetic paroxysm to concoct the fantasy that he might link up with Lorenzo and his “illustrious House, which, with its fortune and prowess [ fortuna e virtù], favoured by God and the Church, of which it is now the head, can lead Italy to her salvation” (82). This cannot be stated too bluntly: there was nothing reasonable in this appeal. As far as we know, the Medici never read or remarked on The Prince, nor, in these early years, were even the most pitiable of Machiavelli’s appeals given serious consideration. As his biographer wrote, the Medici “could not forgive the man who had done and written so much against them, the ‘puppet’ of Soderini, nor forget the coldness he had shown to them—as indeed he was obliged to do—as exiles in the courts of Rome and France.”15 What if we treat not only the ideas of a unied Italy, an invincible citizen army, and a Machiavelli restored to political importance, but all the rest of The Prince as false and illusory? The narratives of Louis XII and Cesare Borgia, Agathocles and Oliverotto, the story of the (already abstract and ctionalized) constitutional princes, the deprecation of mercenaries and the lauding of militias, the comedy of tricksters and gullible publics, the dogghts among the Roman emperors, the dubious advisers and the even cunninger ones, the reasons why Italian leaders always gave way to the French, the Spanish, the Swiss, and the Pope—none of these can any longer be considered even remotely historical. They instead arise from the needs of Machiavelli’s discourse; they bear the weight of the text’s emotional and symbolic purposes. Thus, none of those narratives is based on historical sources (no public records, no well-known chronicles, no rst-hand testimony, no memoirs carefully set out). They also largely contradict Machiavelli’s own observations is his diplomatic dispatches. So, what is their origin? I would argue that they simply grow logically and imaginatively out of the effort to create Il principe in his many juicy parts. He was the surrogate that Machiavelli intended would bear away his own burdens of failure, fall, and misfortune.
15
Ridol, 131.
66
charles d. tarlton
Think back over the crucial narratives in The Prince and the liberties taken in them. Machiavelli drastically condensed Louis XII’s fteen-year adventure in Italy into ve or six terse pivotal actions. He transformed Cesare Borgia’s complex and erratic endgame (from which, according to Machiavelli’s own dispatches from Rome in 1503, Borgia might have extricated himself at any moment by conceding to the Pope’s territorial demands in the Romagna)16 into a simple, infallible, and dreamed up axiom. More marginally, he contracted the enormous political and military signicance of Ferdinand of Aragon in Italy into a couple of passing comments in chapters focused on other things. Realizing, then, that there is something terribly unrealistic about all of it, when we come to the end, to this “exhortation,” the move into pure fantasy does not seem so radical. The generalities and self-delusions of the “exhortation” merely conrm the judgment that what we have here is decidedly not history or political science, but literary imagination. As ctions, the depicted and theorized actions of Il principe are not determined by the recognized shape and emphases of any known historical discourse (although, of course, they gesture in that direction, picking up, as Machiavelli himself might say, the odore of history). They are available, in effect, to be shaped by the needs of the work’s underlying symbolic action; they stand for the crucial incidents dening Machiavelli’s burden in 1513 (and immediately thereafter) and his effort to create a surrogate realm of political action where his ideas (well-enough known and scattered across his correspondence and poetic works), his dreams, and his deeds might lead to an ending far different than the one Time’s verdict had pronounced.
Bibliography Ascoli, Albert Russell, and Victoria Kahn, eds. Machiavelli and the Discourse of Literature. Ithaca and London: Cornell University Press, 1993. Atkinson, James B., and David Sices, trans. and ed. Machiavelli and His Friends, Their Personal Correspondence. DeKalb: Northern Illinois University Press, 1996. Berridge, G. R., ed. Machiavelli’s Legations. Allandale Online Publishing: Leicester, 2001 [reprinted from Christian A. Detmold trans., The Historical and Diplomatic Writings of Niccolò Machiavelli (1882)].
16
See Machiavelli’s dispatches from 23 November to 12 December 1503 in G. R. Berridge ed., Machiavelli’s Legations (Allandale Online Publishing: Leicester, 2001) [reprinted from Christian A. Detmold trans., The Historical and Diplomatic Writings of Niccolò Machiavelli (1882)], 242–262.
machiavelli’s burden: THE PRINCE as literary text
67
Bunyan, John. The Pilgrim’s Progress, Vol. XV, Part 1, The Author’s Apology for his Book. The Harvard Classics. New York: P. F. Collier & Son, 1909–14; Bartleby.com, 2001. www.bartleby.com/15/1/ [14 February 2006]. Burke, Kenneth. The Philosophy of Literary Form. Baton Rouge, LA: Louisiana State University Press, 1941. Coyle, Martin., ed. Niccolò Machiavelli’s “The Prince:” New Interdisciplinary Essays. Manchester (UK) and New York: Manchester University Press, 1995. Garver, Eugene. “Machiavelli’s The Prince: A Neglected Rhetorical Classic.” Philosophy and Rhetoric, 13 (1980): 99–120. Greene, Thomas M. “The End of Discourse in Machiavelli’s Prince.” Yale French Studies 67 (1984): 57–71. Machiavelli, Niccolò. Il principe e Discorsi. Giovanni Procacci and Sergio Bertelli, eds. Milano: Feltrinelli, 1960. McCanles, Michael. The Discourse of “Il Principe.” Malibu: Undena, 1983. Mousley, Andrew. “The Prince and Textual Politics.” Martin Coyle, ed. Niccolò Machiavelli’s The Prince: New Interdisciplinary Essays. Manchester (UK) and New York: Manchester University Press, 1995. Najemy, John M. “Language and The Prince.” Martin Coyle, ed. Niccolò Machiavelli’s The Prince: New Interdisciplinary Essays. Manchester (UK) and New York: Manchester University Press, 1995. Parkin, John. “Dialogue in The Prince.” Martin Coyle, ed. Niccolò Machiavelli’s The Prince: New Interdisciplinary Essays. Manchester (UK) and New York: Manchester University Press, 1995. Ridol, Roberto. The Life of Niccolò Machiavelli. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press, 1963. Tarlton, Charles D. “Machiavelli’s The Prince as Memoir.” Texas Studies in Literature and Language, 46, 1 (Spring, 2004): 1–19.
THE DISCOURSES ON LIVY: PRESERVING A FREE WAY OF LIFE Julia Conaway Bondanella
In The Discourses on Livy, Machiavelli embarks on a quest to discover both the necessary attributes of a vivere libero—a free way of life—and its effects on those who live it, revealing himself to be an experienced and enthusiastic public servant, a student of history, and a passionate proponent of free republics rather than a forerunner of the modern political scientist.1 Comparing himself to early explorers like Columbus, he embarks on an investigation of the best model of republican government.2 Although his contemporaries preferred the Venetian model, and at the time he wrote, most Italian city republics were becoming principalities, he persists in going down a path he describes as “still untrodden” (Preface to Autograph Manuscript).3 Undoubtedly he shares in the judgment of his classical models from Aristotle to Cicero, that political action is among the most glorious human activities (I. 10, 47–50)4 and that the goal of a republic is to achieve civic greatness, but he qualies this verdict with the direct claim that “governments by peoples are better than governments by princes” (I. 58, 144). In The Discourses on Livy, the primary model for a great republic is Rome, and the chief characteristics
1
Ernst Cassirer and others have depicted Machiavelli as a scientist who analyzes the forms of political life. Maurizio Viroli’s careful and convincing analysis of his rhetoric supports the view of Machiavelli as a student of the classics and passionate advocate of republican liberty rather than a “scientist.” See Viroli, Machiavelli (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1998), 73–113, or, more recently, Viroli’s introduction to Machiavelli, The Prince, trans. Peter Bondanella (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2005), vi–xxxix. All citations from this work come from this edition. 2 I prefer to translate modi e ordini nuovi as new methods and institutions. For a different view, see Harvey Manseld, Machiavelli’s New Modes and Orders (Ithaca and London: Cornell University Press, 1979). 3 Discourses on Livy, trans. and ed. Julia Conaway Bondanella and Peter Bondanella (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1997), 15. All future citations from this work come from this translation and will be listed in the text by book and chapter, as well as by the relevant page number of this edition. 4 In his Florentine Histories (I. Proem), Machiavelli says that “politics have greatness in them.” See the edition edited and translated by Laura F. Baneld and Harvey C. Manseld, Jr. (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1988).
70
julia conaway bondanella
of the vivere libero reect Roman practice: they include political liberty, devotion to the common good, equality under just laws, mixed, elective government, the active participation of the people, expansionism, open opportunities to compete for civic honors, and the avoidance of excessive self-interest, ambition, envy, tyranny, corruption, and harm. Maintaining a free way of life requires tolerating internal political conict and using new standards for judging political actions, but most of all it requires the right institutions (ordini ) and methods (modi ) as well as citizens with exceptional talents (virtù). Political action in a free republic clearly confers special worth on human life. In Machiavelli’s Discourses on Livy, only a free, republican government by the people can achieve greatness and glory. Because Athens and Venice had free beginnings and lived under their own laws, they were able “to reach the level of greatness they presently enjoy” (I. 1, 19–20). Machiavelli claims that founders of both republics and kingdoms rank second only to the founders of religion in earning glory and praise, but he warns that tyranny is an ever-present danger because human beings, including the powerful, are all too readily seduced by false goods—especially those that appeal to their own self-interest.5 He warns, reecting an essentially pessimistic Augustinian view of human nature best outlined in The Prince, that human beings, no matter how talented, are all too quickly distracted from the common good, because they are also fundamentally weak, changeable, and selsh. Only in a republic with the right institutions and values can this somewhat deplorable human readiness to indulge private appetites and interests be contained and turned toward the common good and the establishment of a free way of life. For Machiavelli, the only republic with the right institutions, values, and valor was the Roman Republic, another city with free beginnings. The necessities “imposed upon the city by Romulus, Numa, and the others” combined with “the fertility of the site, the convenience of the sea, the frequent victories, and the great size of its empire were unable to corrupt it for centuries, and these laws kept it full of as much exceptional ability [virtù] as ever adorned any other city or republic” (I. 1, 22).6
5 “Among all men who are praised, the most highly praised are those who have been leaders and founders of religions. Close afterwards come those who have founded either republics or kingdoms” (I. 10, 47). 6 Quentin Skinner discusses the theme of “grandezza” or greatness in “Machiavelli’s Discorsi and the pre-humanist origins of republican ideas,” in Machiavelli and Republican-
THE DISCOURSES ON LIVY:
preserving a free way of life
71
Livy and the Italian Republican Tradition Livy’s history of Rome, Ab urbe condita (From the Foundation of the City) and the myth of Republican Rome, occupy a key place in Italian Renaissance culture from the time of the earliest humanist, Petrarch.7 Livy’s history helped to dene a major political idiom, a language of both images and ideas embraced by Renaissance artists and thinkers, including Machiavelli, for its concrete relevance to the practical world of Italian politics.8 Machiavelli believed that classical historians, especially the ancient Romans, had laid down a number of fundamental rules for understanding human behavior, especially in the sphere of political action, in their major historical works. He adapts what he nds in Livy, partly through the juxtaposition of classical examples with those from his own times, to expound his own political and social theories.9 As Viroli demonstrates, Machiavelli abides by the conventions of classical rhetoric, especially the conviction that history is a valuable source of information and example for political oratory, the chief goal of which is to persuade.10 In The Discourses on Livy, Machiavelli exploits history to enliven his discourse and to convince his audience that a free and
ism, ed. Gisela Bock, Quentin Skinner, and Maurizio Viroli (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1990), 125–28 and 137–38, as well as in his Machiavelli: A Very Short Introduction (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2000). 7 Petrarch once asked: “what else, then, is all history, if not the praise of Rome?” in a Latin work Apologia contra cuiusdam anonymi Galli calumnias. Cited by Theodor E. Mommsen in “Petrarch’s Conception of the Dark Ages,” Medieval and Renaissance Studies, ed. Eugene F. Rice (Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 1969), 122. For a detailed account of the myth of Rome in philosophy, art, literature, and music from Petrarch to the present, see Peter Bondanella, The Eternal City: Roman Images in the Modern World (Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 1987). 8 Livy’s monumental history of republican Rome was written during the period that witnessed the transformation of its republic into an empire. It focuses upon the achievements of the Roman Republic. 9 The use of classical and modern examples is a rhetorical strategy in all of Machiavelli’s works; it seems to have been an automatic reex in his thinking and in his work as a diplomat. See the “Introduction” to Discourses on Livy, viii–ix. 10 Viroli, Machiavelli, esp. 73–113. Viroli not only surpasses earlier analyses of Machiavelli’s style in the level of detail but also offers new insights into his political thought, especially his patriotism. He convincingly demonstrates that Machiavelli follows the rules of classical rhetoric, particularly Quintillian, Cicero, and the anonymous author of the Rhetorica ad Herennium [ To Gaius Herennius: On the Theory of Public Speaking]. Viroli argues that in the composition of his political and historical works, Machiavelli’s objective is to persuade his readers that he is an expert who can provide guidance in matters of state.
72
julia conaway bondanella
independent republic on the Roman model should be the goal of political activity.11 For Machiavelli, the question of how to create, secure, and maintain a republican government that would ensure a free way of life was both a practical question, since he was employed by the Florentine government,12 as well as intensely personal, since he had been falsely accused of conspiring against the Medici after their return to power in 1513, when he was sentenced to exile on his farm in San Casciano.13 He witnessed the slow death of his beloved Florentine republic, which he recounts in his Florentine Histories. Oddly enough, after the return of the Medici, republican political theory thrived in Florentine intellectual circles, particularly in meetings at the Orti Oricellari.14 Machiavelli
11 See such passages as I. 58, 144 and I. 59, 46. Machiavelli clearly believes that a great republic promotes goodness and virtù. 12 For a discussion of Machiavelli’s work in the Florentine chancery, see Fredi Chiappelli, “Machiavelli as Secretary,” Italian Quarterly 13 (1970), 27–44; Robert Black, “Machiavelli, servant of the Florentine republic,” 71–100 and John M. Najemy, “The controversy surrounding Machiavelli’s service to the republic,” 101–118 in Bock, Skinner, and Viroli, eds., Machiavelli and Republicanism; and Douglas Biow, Doctors, Ambassadors, Secretaries: Humanism and Professions in Renaissance Italy (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2002), 155–80. 13 Machiavelli addresses these vexing issues in The Discourses on Livy, which can be and, perhaps, should be seen in the context of the political writing in his history of Florence and his handbook on the new principality. Interestingly, The Prince only appeared in print in 1532, a year after the posthumous publication of The Discourses on Livy. The readers of the time, apparently consumed by their religious and nationalistic passions that led them to condemn the author of The Prince and his book, disregarded his truly original treatment of republican politics in The Discourses on Livy. In an age of reformation and authoritarianism, The Discourses on Livy would be relegated to the background, since it ies in the face of the trends of the times by discussing politics in a secular fashion, by praising class conict as benecial to good government, and by dening the republic as the only form of the state that guarantees the good life. Early commentary on Machiavelli’s works may be traced in Sidney Anglo’s Machiavelli—The First Century: Studies in Enthusiasm, Hostility, and Irrelevance (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2005). The replacement of Livy as a historical model by Tacitus in an authoritarian era is discussed by Kenneth C. Schellhase, Tacitus in Renaissance Political Thought (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1976) and Bondanella, The Eternal City, 47–114. 14 These gardens were then located in the outskirts of Florence, a location that today is near the main city train station. Cosimo Rucellai, an aristocratic opponent of the restored Medici regime and one of the men to whom Machiavelli dedicated The Discourses on Livy, owned them. Machiavelli apparently discussed the drafts of The Discourses on Livy there. For the classic study of how these gardens contributed to the growth of Florentine political theory, see Felix Gilbert, “Bernardo Rucellai and the Orti Oricellari: a Study on the Origin of Modern Political Thought,” The Journal of the Warburg and Courtauld Institutes 12 (1949), 136–56, rpt. in Gilbert’s History: Choice and Commitment (Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1977), 215–246. Skinner, The Foundations of Modern Political Thought (I: 152–54), also discusses this topic.
THE DISCOURSES ON LIVY:
preserving a free way of life
73
beneted from his participation in this group and from his friendship with Francesco Guicciardini, a more skeptical republican thinker.15 His theory of republican government reects not only his experiences as a public ofcial and diplomat in the service of the Florentine republic, but also his deep and durable knowledge of the works of classical as well as Italian pre-humanist and humanist political theorists.16 Like them, he promotes the ideal of civic greatness founded in political liberty and supported by good institutions and customs, including a mixed constitution, elective government that is inclusive rather than exclusive, equality under just laws, opportunities open to all, and an absence of excessive wealth that corrupts. Although Venice served as the inspiration for political thinkers from at least the end of the fourteenth century,17 Machiavelli’s preference is for the Roman model of republicanism because it had far greater success in providing enduring freedom to its citizens. In The Discourses on Livy, Machiavelli’s practical purpose is to show through an analysis of the Roman model how to create and to sustain a vivere libero—a free way of life—despite a world full of forces and contingencies beyond human control. Machiavelli focuses upon how to create citizens who care more for their country than themselves through his analysis and interpretation of the institutions, customs,
15 For the relationship between Machiavelli and Guicciardini, see Felix Gilbert, Machiavelli and Guicciardini: Politics and History in Sixteenth-Century Florence (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1965); Rudolf von Albertini, Firenze dalla repubblica al principato (Turin: Einaudi, 1970); Peter Bondanella, Francesco Guicciardini (Boston: Twayne, 1976); Mark Phillips, Francesco Guicciardini: The Historian’s Craft (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1977); and especially Guicciardini’s own comments on Machiavelli’s Discourses on Livy in The Sweetness of Power: Machiavelli’s “Discourses” & Guicciardini’s “Considerations”, trans. James B. Atkinson and David Sices (DeKalb: Northern Illinois University Press, 2002). 16 In “Pre-humanist Origins of Republican Ideas,” Machiavelli and Republicanism, ed. Bock, Skinner, and Viroli, 121–141, Quentin Skinner traces some of the central concepts in The Discourses on Livy to pre-humanist thinkers, noting that Machiavelli mounts a defense of traditional republican ideals in a traditional way, including the ideas that a city must be free to attain greatness and that a city can only be free if it has a republican constitution. In The Foundations of Modern Political Thought (I: 139–89), Skinner focuses upon the ideas of the early humanists and the civic humanists who carried forward the traditional political ideology and inuenced Machiavelli’s political thought and language. 17 See Felix Gilbert, “The Venetian Constitution in Florentine Political Thought,” History, 179–214, which discusses Pier Paolo Vergerio’s De republica veneta fragmenta (Fragment on the Venetian Republic) and the political “myth” of Venice during the Italian Renaissance. Vergerio draws his conclusion from Plato’s assertion in the Laws that the mixed constitution is the most durable form of government.
74
julia conaway bondanella
and the virtù of the Roman Republic seen through the eyes of Livy. Machiavelli’s original insights into the role of religion in politics, the superiority of Rome over Venice, and the benets of social conict among different social classes enrich the republican debate. At the center of his concept of republicanism lies his prescription for well-designed institutions and just laws applied equally to all citizens, including all public ofcials. For Machiavelli, equality under the law is the essence of a free way of life, and liberty means that a state and its citizens are not dependent on others.
The Machiavellian Cosmos Although some critics have suggested that Machiavelli’s political philosophy lacks a spiritual dimension,18 he sees human political activities taking place in an arena that is home to a variety of cosmic and earthly forces, including God, or the “heavens,” as well as Fortune and cycles of time or history. In The Discourses on Livy, these constants of the Machiavellian cosmos remain more or less beyond human control, offering both opportunities and opposition to human effort. Machiavelli never systematically charts out their roles, but he constantly refers to them as he investigates the challenges of creating a republic worthy of sacrice and patriotic passion.19 The function of God or the divine remains one of inspiring great tasks of political innovation or of absolving men who display exceptional talent for using unconventional methods in moments of political necessity.20 Divine authority may benet the state by prompting men, 18
Federico Chabod, Scritti su Machiavelli (Turin: Einaudi, 1964), 80. For a lucid discussion of Machiavelli’s worldview, see Anthony J. Parel, The Machiavellian Cosmos (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1992); or a shorter discussion in Viroli, Machiavelli, 17–24. On Machiavelli’s atheism or pagan outlook, see Isaiah Berlin, “The Originality of Machiavelli,” in his Against the Current (New York: Viking Press, 1980); and Freidrich Meinecke, Machiavellism: The Doctrine of Raison d’état and Its Place in Modern History, trans. Douglas Scott (New York: Praeger, 1957). On Machiavelli’s attitude toward God and religion, see Sebastian de Grazia, Machiavelli in Hell (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1989). Even before De Grazia, Luigi Russo’s Machiavelli, 3rd edition (Bari: Laterza, 1949), 222–24, characterizes Machiavelli’s religiosity as fundamentally Christian. Most modern scholars, including all of Machiavelli’s recent biographers, consider Machiavelli anticlerical but not an atheist in spite of his bad reputation over the years. 20 See The Prince, chap. 26. In chap. 8, God appears as a friend of founders who excuses new princes who use cruelties well or when they actually contribute to the 19
THE DISCOURSES ON LIVY:
preserving a free way of life
75
in their fear of punishment, to keep oaths and to serve their country (I. 11–13, 50–58). This God differs from the traditional Christian God, who advises men to be humble and to submit to suffering, by supporting those who show exceptional abilities in the political arena and in the pursuit of worldly honor (I. 11, 50–52). In addition to God, the heavens are “lled with intelligences, who by means of natural abilities foresee future events and, having compassion for men, warn them with . . . signs so that they can prepare their defenses” (I. 56, 139). Even when the heavens send natural disasters that result in death and destruction, they may actually contribute to human welfare, like a purgation that restores a body to health (II. 5, 168–69). Machiavelli refers to the success of the Gauls’ attack on Rome as a combination of heavenly design and human error, a military disaster that paradoxically restored Roman society to its ancient values (II. 29, 234–35). Fortune may be the most prominent force in Machiavelli’s cosmos.21 In The Prince, control within the arena of human action seems roughly divided between Fortune and human virtù, with a slight advantage to Fortune.22 Nonetheless, Machiavelli’s Fortune is not blind.23 Fortune often selects men of virtù, Machiavelli says in The Discourses on Livy, because they are capable of recognizing opportunities she offers to accomplish great deeds (II. 29, 235). When Fortune wants to cause disasters, however, she may choose incompetent men to bring them about, but she may do so in order to drive a city, a group, or an individual toward even greater achievements. Machiavelli cautions, however, that “men may side with fortune, but not oppose her; they can weave her warp
common good (pp. 33–4), and in The Discourses on Livy (I. 9, 46–47), Machiavelli discusses the case of Romulus as a leader who must be “excused” even for fratricide because it ultimately contributed to the establishment of a republic. Still, he emphasizes that God may not play a role in the establishment of political institutions (I. 11, 51), in his discussion of a specically civic role for religion. As Viroli notes in Machiavelli (pp. 21–24), the idea of God as a friend of republican founders and patriots has a source in Macrobius’s “Dream of Scipio” and also appears in the works of Petrarch and Matteo Palmieri. 21 In Fortune Is a River: Leonardo da Vinci and Niccolò Machiavelli’s Magnicent Dream to Change the Course of Florentine History (New York: The Free Press, 1998), 10, Roger D. Masters equates fortune and human history in Machiavelli’s writing. I am not convinced that this equation is entirely correct, since Machiavelli tends to look at fortune as a force at work in the world along with God and the heavens. In Parel’s view (The Machiavellian Cosmos, pp. 63–67), Fortune is the mistress of chance and accident and, according to Viroli (Machiavelli, p. 20), she is quite arbitrary. 22 Machiavelli, The Prince, XXV, 84. 23 Viroli, Machiavelli, 20.
76
julia conaway bondanella
but they cannot tear it apart” (II. 29, 236). Although he admits that Fortune can be hostile to virtù (II. 16, 193), he declares that men must always take advantage of the opportunities afforded them; they “must never give up, for without knowing her goals as she moves along paths both crossed and unknown, men always have to hope” (II. 29, 236).24 Machiavelli acknowledges the control of Fortune and the heavens over human events, but he argues that virtù and prudence rather than Fortune favored the Roman people in acquiring their empire (II. 1, 152–55). Hence, he concludes that republics of his own day will succeed only when strong reformers learn from the study of antiquity how to regulate Fortune (II. 30, 239). Historical forces play a powerful role in the sphere of human activity. In both prefaces to his Discourses on Livy, Machiavelli complains that although modern men honor antiquity by imitating its art or utilizing its medicine or laws, no princes, republics, military leaders, or citizens follow ancient practice, and he argues that in failing to understand the true meaning of the ancient histories, men enjoy the incidents they recount without thinking of imitating them because they believe that imitation is impossible.25 He counters with a different understanding of the nature of history, which he views as essentially cyclical rather than progressive. If history repeatedly presents similar opportunities for human action, it is possible to learn how to take advantage of them by studying history. Machiavelli states that not only the sky, sun, and the elements, but also mankind have not “changed in their motion, order, and power from what they were in antiquity” (“Preface to Autograph Manuscript,” p. 15 and “Preface to 1531 Roman Edition,” p. 18). He concludes that imitation of the ancients in politics is clearly possible because “all the things of this world in every era have their counterparts in ancient times” (III. 43, 351). Histories from both ancient and modern times show this constant recycling of opportunities and skillful actions from which the modern reader can learn. Hence, to remedy this misunderstanding of history and the failures of modern republics, Machiavelli proposes to offer his own analysis and interpretation of Livy’s history of the Roman Republic to give modern peoples the practical knowledge to recover their right to self rule and to a free way of life: 24 See also II. 30, 239, where Machiavelli conrms his view that Fortune shows her power all the more strongly when men are weak. 25 “Preface to Autograph Manuscript” (p. 15) and “Preface to 1531 Roman Edition” (p. 17).
THE DISCOURSES ON LIVY:
preserving a free way of life
77
Anyone who studies current and ancient affairs will easily recognize that the same desires and humours exist and have always existed in all cities and among all peoples. Thus, it is an easy matter for anyone who examines past events carefully to foresee future events in every republic and to apply the remedies that the ancients employed, or if old remedies cannot be found, to think of new ones based upon the similarity of circumstances (I. 39, 105).
Along with the external or cosmic agents that affect life in the human sphere, Machiavelli explores the internal human motivations that condition political and social life in all places and among all peoples (I. 39, 105). No less challenging to the establishment of a free republic in which men are devoted to the common good is human nature with its passions. He warns that “nature has created men in such a way that they can desire everything but are unable to obtain everything, so that their desire is always greater than their power of acquisition, and discontent with what they possess and lack of satisfaction are the result” (I. 37, 99).26 The Discourses on Livy offers an analysis of human nature consistent with that in his other works,27 because republics, too, must nd ways of discouraging and limiting human wickedness. The scourge of good republics is ambition (I. 37, 101–02);28 envy, greed, and ambition are among the most destructive forces in society. Machiavelli’s analysis of the efforts of the nobility to limit the power of the plebeians after the expulsion of the Tarquins make him conclude that “men never do good except out of necessity, but where choices are abundant and unlimited freedom is the norm, everything immediately becomes confused and disorderly” (I. 3, 28). While conceding that human beings easily “become bored with the good and grieve for the bad” (III. 21, 307),
26 In I. 53. 130–31, Machiavelli notes how difcult it is for human beings to pierce the appearances to distinguish the good from the bad. Also see “Preface to Book II” (p. 151) where Machiavelli reiterates his judgment of human appetites. 27 The Prince, for example, contains many passages referring to human vices. Great leaders and good citizens face a dual challenge: they must combat their own passions as well as those of other human beings. Human wickedness encompasses a full range of vices; human beings are, he warns the new prince, “ungrateful, ckle, simulators and deceivers, avoiders of danger, and greedy for gain. While you work for their benet they are completely yours, offering you their blood, their property, their lives and their sons, as I said above, when the need to do so is far away. But when it draws nearer to you, they turn away” (XVII, p. 58). 28 Machiavelli focuses upon ambition and love of property as a key element in human nature because he believes it ultimately ruined not only the Roman Republic but his own Florentine Republic as well, since Cosimo de’ Medici and the Medici family in general were more interested in their own welfare than in the common good.
78
julia conaway bondanella
he characterizes them as unwilling to change and incapable of perceiving the truth about the evil intentions of others (I. 18, 70). Men, he says, “live as much by appearances as by realities . . .” (I. 25, 79). Interestingly, he applies his statements about human nature in The Prince to mass psychology and to the behavior of an uncontrolled multitude, while claiming that a people in a well-organized republic will become good and capable of freedom because their good laws and wise leaders have improved on human nature (I. 58). In The Discourses on Livy, Machiavelli displays greater optimism in arguing that republics by virtue of their institutions and laws may shape human character to emphasize the good rather than the evil; he regards human beings as educable and capable of engaging in great enterprises, like that of establishing a vivere libero.
The Rule of Law The rst book of The Discourses on Livy focuses upon basic institutions— government, laws, and religion—that create the conditions for this free way of life. Reecting the idea that good institutions create and sustain liberty, a key term in The Discourses on Livy is ordini, which refers to institutions and laws, or other features of a society that dene its way of life. Laws dene the fabric of civic life; they are the “nerve and life of a free government” (I. 33, 92), and the Roman people, “regulated by laws,” were “stable, prudent, and grateful” (I. 58, 142). Machiavelli envisions the political and civil life of a carefully planned republic as being grounded in a combination of good customs and good laws, which are meaningless unless obeyed. He observes that “just as good customs require laws in order to be maintained, so laws require good customs in order to be observed” (I. 18, 68). He basically argues that since “men never do good except out of necessity,” laws must dene certain limits for human behavior preventing men from damaging their fellow-citizens and the common welfare: the laws must “make them good” (I. 3, 28). In an uncorrupt republic, laws counter the worst tendencies in human nature: “it is necessary for anyone who organizes a republic and establishes laws in it to take for granted that all men are evil and that they will always act according to the wickedness of their nature . . .” (I. 3, 28). In his analysis of how power corrupted the decemvirs and their leader Appius Claudius, Machiavelli notes how easily ambition destroyed
THE DISCOURSES ON LIVY:
preserving a free way of life
79
Quintus Fabius’s good habits, arguing that lawgivers who study this example will be “more quick to restrain human appetites and to deprive people of all hope of being able to do evil with impunity” (I. 42, 113). Laws must be instituted to protect against tyranny, but they must also dene conduct that promotes the greatest good—“the common good.”29 Good laws, in The Discourses on Livy, teach men how to be good citizens, making them capable of living a free way of life. Machiavelli explains the greatness of individual Roman citizens by the power of Roman customs and laws: “Nor can one in any way reasonably call a republic disorganized where so many examples of exceptional ability occur, for good examples arise from good training, good training from good laws, and good laws from those disturbances [ between the plebeians and the nobles]” (I. 4, 30). Furthermore, he argues that the laws of a great republic must contain provisions and remedies for all eventualities so that the government can respond to them legally (I. 34, 95). The rule of law in a well-organized republic requires all members of the society to obey the laws; it also requires that laws be enforced impartially. Otherwise, the state is no more than a tyranny, like the Roman Empire under the evil emperors (I. 10, 48).30 Laws must, above all, protect liberty and provide a means of release for “the variability of those humours that agitate the republic” (I. 7, 38). In Rome, the guardianship of liberty was placed in the hands of the people, because through their tribunes and their participation in public affairs, they could counterbalance the power of the nobles. Their authority was enhanced by a law providing the power to accuse publicly any “citizens before the people or some magistrate or council when they commit any kind of offence against free government” (I. 7, 38). Such public indictments also restrained citizens from making attempts on the government. In the case of Coriolanus, this law provided a legal way for the multitude to express their anger towards him (I. 7, 38–39). Summoned by the tribunes, he could argue his case rather than being murdered by a mob. In discussing the judgment against the decimvir Appius Claudius, Machiavelli notes that it would have been inappropriate to deny him
29 When Machiavelli speaks of founders and reformers, he emphasizes that the best, such as Moses, Lycurgus, Solon, and others, were “able to create laws for the common good” (I. 9, 46). As Viroli notes in Machiavelli, pp. 116 ff., the notion of rule by law goes back to Cicero and the Italian tradition. 30 In this chapter, Machiavelli categorizes the good emperors as those “who lived under the laws.”
80
julia conaway bondanella
the right of appeal, violating established law: “I do not believe there is any worse example in a republic than to make a law and then not to observe it, and even more so when it is not observed by the person who made it” (I. 45, 116). Violations of the law are never acceptable. Although an individual citizen may have done good deeds, he must unquestionably be punished for evil acts because “no well-organized republic ever cancels the demerits of its citizens with their merits” (I. 24, 78). In giving his unconventional morality a new foundation, Machiavelli insists upon respect for the law. He argues that since ambition can turn bad, threatening law and liberty, the law must be applied without regard for the prominence of an individual or for a momentary political advantage, citing the trials and judgments against notable citizens, such as the sentences imposed on the sons of Brutus, Horatius, Manlius Capitolinus, and the Decemvirs, or charges such as those lodged against the Scipios. Horatius saved Rome by overcoming the Curiatii, but when he murdered his sister, he was put on trial for his life “despite the fact that his merits were so great and new” (I. 24, 78). Although Manlius Capitolinus had heroically saved Rome from the Gauls, his end was decidedly inglorious. Executed for sedition, Manlius “was thrown headlong without any respect whatsoever for his merits from the very Capitol he had earlier saved with such great honour” (I. 24, 79). Machiavelli envisions an uncorrupted republic in which all are treated equally under the law, and “the fear of punishment makes men better and less ambitious” (I. 29, 85–86). Recognizing that when law enforcement became lax Roman citizens became corrupt, Machiavelli views Brutus’s severity in killing his own sons as necessary to preserve liberty in Rome, and he warns that “anyone who creates a free government and does not kill the sons of Brutus, will not sustain himself for long” (III. 3, 252). The point is that punishments, too, must be imposed fairly without regard to wealth, rank, or fame. Obedience to the law and equality under the law are the vital foundation of Machiavelli’s republicanism.
Class Conict and Liberty Machiavelli’s view of lawmaking must be understood within the context of his original insights into the nature and results of turbulence in Roman political life. His striking interpretation of Livy’s history based upon his original theory that class conict gave rise to liberty in repub-
THE DISCOURSES ON LIVY:
preserving a free way of life
81
lican Rome is at odds with a tradition of classical and Italian political thinking; it troubled his fellow republican theorists, who preferred a republic with peaceful internal politcs, and it was rejected by his friend Guicciardini.31 Machiavelli observes “that those who condemn the disturbances between the nobles and the plebeians condemn those very things that were the primary cause of Roman liberty and that they give more consideration to the noises and cries arising from such disturbances than to the good effects they produced . . .” (I. 4, 29). He argues that the tension and conict between the two principal classes in Roman society produced “laws and institutions for the benet of civic liberty,” which in some way responded sufciently to the interests of both the nobility and the people that they prevented real violence. Emphasizing the positive outcomes of the conicts, he adds that they “rarely led to exile and even more rarely to bloodshed” (I. 4, 30). For Machiavelli, who had written about the armed violence that frequently disturbed his native Florence, the conict in Rome seemed salutary in comparison.32 Machiavelli steadfastly maintains that the plebeians’ protests guaranteed liberty in Rome, and he asserts that protests expressing the will of free peoples normally expand liberty because their origin lies with a group who cannot usurp power and who fear oppression. He declares that the common people most effectively check the ambitions of the powerful, drawing upon the example of Marcus Menenius and Marcus Fulvius, appointed respectively dictator and master of the horse, in order to investigate certain conspiracies or attempts to subvert free elections (I. 5, 32–33). The historical evidence shows, therefore, that an individual chosen from the common people is most capable of making disinterested inquiries. Although they may nd themselves deceived, they also have the capacity of judgment to take to heart the words of a good man and turn away from evil (I. 53–53; I. 58, 140). In Machiavelli’s republic, the power of speech and the right of free speech plays an invaluable role in public, political debate.
31 See Guicciardini’s comments on Machiavelli’s Discourses on Livy in The Sweetness of Power: Machiavelli’s “Discourses” & Guicciardini’s “Considerations”, 380–438. Guicciardini viewed Rome’s disorderly social conicts in a negative fashion and thought Rome was saved not by its strong republican institutions but, rather, by good luck and military skill. 32 See his Florentine Histories (I. 1), ed. and trans. Laura F. Baneld and Harvey C. Manseld, Jr.
82
julia conaway bondanella
Machiavelli concludes that discord between the plebeians and the senate created “a perfect republic” (I. 2, 27), by which he means a free republic. He generalizes beyond the Roman example to claim that since these two classes are typical of any society, their conicts alone will be the source of all laws that favor liberty: “in every republic there are two different tendencies, that of the people and that of the upper class, and . . . all of the laws which are passed in favour of liberty are from the rift between the two” (I. 4, 29). Cities that use their people in signicant enterprises, like the Roman Republic, must ensure that they can express their ambitions, since the “desires of free peoples are rarely harmful to liberty” (I. 4, 30). Although Rome achieved stability through institutions and laws, these institutions and laws paradoxically originated in social conict.
A Mixed Government Machiavelli never wavers in advocating a government with the participation of a large number of citizens (what his contemporaries dened as a governo largo) because he believes that such a state will benet from having many individuals who can exercise their diverse talents (virtù) in the service of their country. He asserts that “although one man alone is capable of instituting or reforming a government,” it will endure only “when it remains a matter of concern to many and when it is the task of many to maintain it” (I. 9, 45). One obvious shortcoming of a principality is that “the talent of a single man . . . disappears when he dies and will only rarely be found in his successor” (I. 11, 52), but a well-organized republic will necessarily have a succession of able leaders (I. 20, 73). He considers the Roman republic far preferable to those of Sparta and Venice because the government involved the Roman people, the plebeians, in addition to an aristocratic elite. In Machiavelli’s view, the best form of government is elective. Only a republican government with a fully representative structure can ensure a free way of life. Hence, he seeks a constitutional framework that creates a durable, stable, and free republic. Given his view of the world as a place of unavoidable change, Machiavelli accepts Polybius’s reasoning that all types of government go through an inevitable cycle of growth and decline. Of the six kinds of government, the three good forms—principality, aristocracy, and democracy—predictably devolve into three bad forms: tyranny, oligarchy and anarchy. In addition to the
THE DISCOURSES ON LIVY:
preserving a free way of life
83
fact that everything in the sublunary world has a natural tendency to decay, the good forms of government become corrupt because human beings generally fail to subordinate their own interests to the common good (I. 2, 24–25). Following tradition, Machiavelli offers practical and even hopeful advice on how best to combat corruption and change. Drawing on the ideas of Polybius and Italian political theorists, who had advocated a mixed constitution,33 he envisions a mixed type of government in which the different social groups represented produce a government with checks and balances; he even envisions such checks and balances among magistracies in a city (I. 50, 125). He cites the example of prudent founders like Lycurgus in Sparta who developed a form of government that combined the three good forms, an arrangement in which each one “keeps watch over the other” (I. 2, 24). Although Machiavelli recognizes that the mixed constitution in Venice had ensured the city’s liberty for centuries, he deviates from his contemporaries’ preference for the Venetian model because it gives far too much power to the aristocrats. Arguing that only the plebeians can serve as the guardians of liberty because they “have less of an appetite to usurp it” than the nobles, he advocates the Roman model even if it embodied the kind of social conict other republican thinkers abhorred and which they found absent in the Venetian model (I. 4, 29–30). In the case of Rome, the government became “mixed” only through an evolutionary process made possible by normally sound institutions. Romulus, the legendary founder of Rome, created a system of sharing power with the senate and well-organized laws that reected his own exceptional ability (virtù); prevented the Romans from becoming corrupt; and allowed for change.34 In Rome the agent of change was the conict between the plebeians and the senate. After consuls replaced the kings, the conict continued to produce notable benets, including the ofce of the tribunes, representing the plebeians. The addition of the tribunes to the ofces of the consuls and the senate, which represented the kingly and aristocratic authority, resulted in a mixed government.
33 Some humanists were inspired more by the example of Venice than of Rome, but Machiavelli found the number of citizens participating in that government too small and the system too inexible to defend itself in moments of change. 34 Machiavelli constantly analyzes the ways in which corruption leads to the destruction of republics, thereby offering advice on how to avoid it. See, for example, his claims (I. 16) that a corrupt people cannot enjoy its liberty.
84
julia conaway bondanella
The tribunes, Machiavelli tells us, “were established with such power and prestige that they could always thereafter act as intermediaries between the plebeians and the senate and could curb the insolence of the nobles” (I. 3, 29). Machiavelli praises the Romans who, having recognized that republics need institutions to deal with emergencies, created the dictatorship, which functioned well as long as the Roman people were incorrupt. He calls the dictatorial authority the “source of the greatness of such an empire” (I. 34, 95) because it gave the Roman government great exibility in the way it addressed pressing needs. Since the mixed authority in the state prevented one group from suppressing another, it established greater stability, security, and liberty for all citizens: “it created a perfect republic” (I. 2, 7). A reminder in book three advises that the “downfall of cities . . . arises from their failure to modify the intitutions of their republics over time” (III. 9, 282). Ultimately, in Machiavelli’s opinion, Rome became great because it could and did adapt, even though he recognizes the errors it made, such as the agrarian laws (I. 37) or establishing the decemvirs with the absolute power that corrupts.
Religion as an Integral Tool of Governing In his exploration of institutions that protect the free republic from corruption and conspiracy, Machiavelli introduces religion as a tool of the art of the state, both in creating its institutions and in reforming them. Pocock states that “Machiavelli was not free from the need to visualize the republic, or any other body politic, as originating in the realm of the sacred.”35 If Machiavelli connects his republic with the divine, it is, in part, because he recognizes the value of religion in creating beliefs and values that benet a republic. Of course, he also believes political action is, in itself, a glorious enterprise with something of the divine in it. Although Romulus did not have recourse to religion in establishing the state, Numa “pretended” to have a relationship with a nymph from whom he received counsel in order to introduce certain new institutions (I. 11, 51). Machiavelli argues that a successful republic upholds and respects its religious practices precisely because they have a crucial impact on the quality and durability of civil and political life.
35 J. G. A. Pocock, The Machiavellian Moment: Florentine Political Thought and the Atlantic Republican Tradition (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1975), 190–94.
THE DISCOURSES ON LIVY:
preserving a free way of life
85
Machiavelli takes an unorthodox view—for his times—of the function of religion in the state. When the goal of political action is to create good citizens through restraining their passions and educating them in republican values, religion becomes a reliable collaborator in the civic project. To protect the republic from tyranny and corruption, whether or not its leaders believe in God, the state must sustain and defend its religious practices and endorse religious worship; it must keep religious traditions and practices free of corruption and safeguard the people’s respect for them to remain “good and united” (I. 12, 53–54). Of course, Machiavelli would not have discerned any particular conict between religion and politics because Florentine republicans were typically Christian, and the civic humanists before him clearly championed the active life in the world, especially participation in public affairs without rejecting Christianity.36 Yet, like Dante and Boccaccio before him, Machiavelli takes a dim view of ecclesiastical behavior, which he believes has affected people’s devotion, even if his anticlericalism often expresses itself in a humorous fashion.37 He claims that there is “no greater indication of the ruin of a state than to see a disregard for its divine worship” (I. 12, 53).38 When Machiavelli argues that ancient peoples loved liberty more than modern societies, the key lies in profound differences in education and religion. Christianity falls under attack for subverting the values necessary to establishing a well-organized republic. Although Christianity “has shown us truth and the true path, it also makes us place a lower value on worldly honour, whereas the pagans, who greatly valued honour and considered it the highest good, were more ferocious in their actions” (II. 2, 158–59). In glorifying “humble and contemplative men rather than active ones,” Christianity has promulgated suffering, meekness, self-effacement, and a contempt for worldly honor and achievement, and
36 An early humanist like Petrarch felt the conict between the retired life and a life seeking worldly honor and fame, a struggle that colors not only his love poetry but his Latin writings, especially his Secretum, On the Solitary Life, On Religious Leisure, and many of his letters, including the famous “Ascent of Mount Ventoux.” By Machiavelli’s time, the issue of devoting oneself to worldly affairs was much less vexing. 37 Machiavelli’s anticlericalism resembles that of Boccaccio in The Decameron. For example, the character of Brother Timoteo in Machiavelli’s classic comedy, The Mandrake Root, presents the classic topos in medieval and Renaissance literature of the unworthy but cunning priest. 38 See De Grazia’s discussion of Machiavelli’s religion in Machiavelli in Hell (pp. 100–01, 120–21): he argues that Machiavelli compresses the duality of church and state. Yet, he does so in a way that makes religion a vital component of political action and a free way of life.
86
julia conaway bondanella
this cultivation of weakness has led to corruption and tyranny rather than to freedom and the common good (II. 2, 159). Accusing cowardly men of having misinterpreted and falsied Christianity “according to an ideal of freedom from earthly toil and not according to one of exceptional ability,” Machiavelli counters that the Christian religion actually permits citizens “to exalt and defend [their] native land” (II. 2, 159).39 Machiavelli makes religion a vital component of political action and a free way of life: To be fully virtuous, strong and good, a state needs religion because “where there is religion, arms can easily be introduced” (I. 12, 51). Religion empowers military organizations: it produces good institutions, including good armies (I. 12, 52). Religion offers an effective means of “controlling the armies, in giving courage to the plebeians, in keeping men good, and in shaming the wicked” (I. 11, 51). When education and loyalty fail to give soldiers the courage to withstand the enemy and to defend their homeland, religion becomes crucial. Fear of God can instill the necessary strength of will. Machiavelli offers the example of the great general Scipio’s behavior after Hannibal had defeated the Romans at Cannae. When a group of citizens were about to abandon their city, Scipio went to nd them “and, with his bare sword in his hand, he forced them to swear not to abandon their native land” (I. 11, 51). Their fears of divine punishment made them remain faithful to their oath because they were as yet uncorrupted (I. 13, 57–8). Machiavelli concludes that soldiers’ condence can be greatly enhanced “through religion when it is properly used” (I. 15, 61). Religion becomes important as one of the remedies for the political corruption he sees in Italy and elsewhere, which he constantly contrasts to the civil and political life in the German free cities.40 Although he concedes that Romulus did not need the authority of religion, he still ranks Numa above his predecessor, describing his introduction of religion as a crucial tool in building a society: “he turned to religion as something absolutely necessary for maintaining a civilized society” (I. 11, 50). Machiavelli never makes a negative judgment concerning Numa’s pretense about having a divine contact or the truth of Romans’ belief, 39 In Machiavelli (pp. 156–74, esp. 166), Viroli’s illuminating discussion of Machiavelli’s patriotism demonstrates that Machiavelli’s argument about Christianity and worldly glory originates in a long tradition of Florentine Christian patriotism. 40 Viroli, Machiavelli (pp. 131–43), analyzes how Machiavelli’s theory of the free republic can be studied from the angle of political corruption. He notes that Machiavelli regularly contrasts a civil and free way of living with tyranny. See for example, I. 17; I. 55; and III. 8.
THE DISCOURSES ON LIVY:
preserving a free way of life
87
especially in oracles, miracles, and auguries because, in his view, religion and its rituals played a crucial role in the development of Roman institutions and in Roman excellence (virtù) through the education of the Roman people, who “feared breaking an oath more than breaking the laws, like people who respected the power of God more than that of men . . .” (I. 11, 51).41 By creating an energizing religion, Numa adds another dimension to the founding of Rome: “the arts of peace.” Machiavelli, who never banishes God from his cosmos, makes religion a pillar of the state because it can teach the right values, while ensuring obedience to laws, customs, and traditions. Pagan religion, he observes, taught that the supreme good was “in greatness of mind, strength of body, and in all the other things apt to make men the strongest” (II. 2, 159). Underlying his argument that religion is essential in the state is Machiavelli’s assumption that men are educable. When Camillus’s soldiers become terried upon their rst sight of the size of the Etruscan army, he tells them to act in accordance with their “training and habit” (III. 31, 330). It was enough to remind them of their education and their customs to embolden them in front of their enemy.
Military Institutions: Expansionism and Freedom Besides a mixed constitution, a good legal system and salutary religious practices to support the growth of civic virtues and to shield the republic from corruption, Machiavelli advocates military discipline and power as another safeguard for a vivere libero. Like earlier theorists of free communal governments, Machiavelli conceives of armies as a legitimate and necessary means of defending liberty and of achieving civic greatness. For him, power is a path to glory and renown (II. 4, 167). Machiavelli’s commitment to strong armies and good military discipline has little to do with modern notions of imperialism or colonialism. He associates the greatness of a republic with its territorial expansion, but it is more a matter of survival and the preservation of civic values within a competitive external environment. He envisions expansion not only in terms of conquest and predation but also in terms of increasing the number of citizens, creating benecial alliances, and preserving
41
See also I. 12 and I. 14.
88
julia conaway bondanella
freedom (II. 4). For a republic in which the populace is free to participate in public debate or to protest social policies, expansion in size and power provides a release for social tension. It is in the context of Roman military exploits that Machiavelli reiterates his strong commitment to a citizen army. He had, after all, argued for a citizen militia in Florence because of his experience with incompetent mercenary troops in the 1505 siege of Pisa. Even though the Florentine troops failed in their mission, Machiavelli never gave up his faith in the citizen armies he promotes in The Prince and The Art of War as well as in The Discourses on Livy with compelling examples of Roman glory. He asserts that free soldiers are more courageous (I. 43, 114) and claims that only the Roman armies were full of both order and fury (III. 36, 340). Although he disagrees with other humanists that the Roman military ensured the success of the Republic, he clearly believed that the Roman legions played an important part in building a free way of life in the Roman Republic. In the beginning, Roman armies were composed of citizen soldiers who practiced other professions. Machiavelli’s own experience as Secretary of the Ten of Liberty and Peace in the Florentine republic, a panel that dealt with foreign affairs and war, proved to him that foreign affairs and “arms” or military operations play as signicant a role in the life of states as domestic affairs. In The Prince, Machiavelli states that good armies, along with good laws, give strong foundations to all types of states, adding that “good laws cannot exist where there are no good armies, and where good armies exist there must be good laws” (XII. 42–43). This principle remains constant in his Discourses on Livy, where the military joins the legal system and religious practices to teach the citizens the kind of virtuous discipline required to live a free way of life. By training citizens as soldiers, a city educates them to love their native land, provides for self-defense, and ensures the possibility of expansion. Machiavelli devotes most of Book II to Roman expansionism, analyzing military strategies and methods of conduct, and rejecting the claim made by critics from Plutarch to Guicciardini that Roman expansionism succeeded primarily because of Fortune’s favor.42 Machiavelli emphasizes that it was the exceptional abilities or virtù of their armies along with their prudence in the conduct of wars that brought them fortune and military success. Above all, he sees the issue in terms of
42
Plutarch makes this argument in his Moralia.
THE DISCOURSES ON LIVY:
preserving a free way of life
89
his notion that the people must be the guardians of liberty. Criticizing cities that avoid increasing the number of their inhabitants, Machiavelli contrasts the successes of Rome with the failures of Venice, Athens, and Sparta in the dangerous enterprise of expansion.43 In Venice the commoners or plebeians played no role in the defense of the city, so that the Venetian republic had to depend on mercenary troops: this fundamental constitutional choice led to Venice’s decline as a political force on the mainland. Machiavelli’s negative view of mercenaries, set out in The Prince and The Art of War, reappears in The Discourses on Livy.44 In Rome, citizens from all walks of life became soldiers; great leaders like Cincinnatus might be poor farmers, but Rome recognized their talents and utilized them (II. 25, 316–17). Only an army composed of citizen soldiers can contribute during both times of peace and war: Soldiers are also citizens, who, in times of peace, can contribute to the common good in other ways. Machiavelli prefers a republic like Rome with a growing population, even though it might be less well organized than Sparta or Athens and less peaceful than Venice because “without this abundance of men it will never succeed in becoming a great city” (II. 3, 161–63). Machiavelli views free republics with larger populations and larger armies as having an advantage within a competitive environment, but he never advocates an uncontrolled type of expansionism or empire building. For Machiavelli, conquest must have a goal other than simply increasing a state’s power; it is a means of achieving the territorial greatness that will allow it to defend itself without being dependent on the troops of others. The proper way to pursue security is through alliances and leagues; by protecting and treating subject cities with dignity; and by resorting to military force only after other prudent strategies have failed. In The Discourses on Livy, he examines the three methods of expansion used by republics. Utilized by the ancient Etruscans, the rst involves forming “a confederation of many republics in which none surpassed the others in either authority or rank; and as they acquired territory, they made the other cities their confederates, just as the Swiss have done in our own times, and as in the ancient times the Achaeans and the Aetolians did in Greece” (II. 4, 163). Characteristic of the Romans, the
43 In I. 5 and II. 3, Machiavelli analyzes the consequences when republics fail to expand. 44 See Pocock, The Machiavellian Moment, 197–201.
90
julia conaway bondanella
second and preferred method involves making alliances, while retaining leadership in a “position of command” (II. 4, 164). In describing the third method, that of creating subjects rather than allies, as did the Spartans and the Athenians, Machiavelli asserts that it “is entirely useless,” because it destroyed the republics that acquired the territories they could not hold. Rome, on the contrary, creating allies, “rose to the heights of power. And since it was the only city to live in this manner, it was also the only one to become so powerful. . . . This mode of conduct, as has been said, has been employed only by the Romans; nor can a republic wishing to expand its territory employ any other method, because experience has shown us none other more certain or more true” (II. 4, 164–65). In the way Machiavelli discusses it, the Roman method of expansion cannot be described as predatory but perhaps as exemplifying the critical quality of prudence exercised by their armies. Although the Romans sometimes used harsh methods, even when cities surrendered as subjects, the Romans “allowed the cities they did not destroy to live under their own laws” and “left no sign of Roman power,” obliging them to observe specic conditions (II. 21, 211). Although Machiavelli praises the Florentines’ benevolent policy toward Pistoia, which made that city voluntarily and willingly accept Florentine rule, he strongly criticizes their aggressive policies towards Pisa, Siena, and Lucca, because t