Seamus Heaney Searches for Answers
Eugene O’Brien
Pluto
P
Press
LONDON • DUBLIN • STERLING, VIRGINIA
First publi...
83 downloads
1598 Views
999KB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Seamus Heaney Searches for Answers
Eugene O’Brien
Pluto
P
Press
LONDON • DUBLIN • STERLING, VIRGINIA
First published 2003 by Pluto Press 345 Archway Road, London N6 5AA and 22883 Quicksilver Drive, Sterling, VA 20166–2012, USA Distributed in the Republic of Ireland and Northern Ireland by Columba Mercier Distribution, 55A Spruce Avenue, Stillorgan Industrial Park, Blackrock, Co. Dublin, Ireland. Tel: + 353 1 294 2556. Fax: + 353 1 294 2564 www.plutobooks.com Copyright © Eugene O’Brien 2003 Reprinted by permission of Faber & Faber and Farrar, Strauss & Giroux, LLC: Excerpts from ELECTRIC LIGHT by Seamus Heaney. Copyright © 2001 by Seamus Heaney. Excerpts from FINDERS KEEPERS: SELECTED PROSE 1971–2001 by Seamus Heaney. Copyright © 2002 by Seamus Heaney. Excerpts from THE GOVERNMENT OF THE TONGUE by Seamus Heaney. Copyright © 1990 by Seamus Heaney. Excerpts from THE HAW LANTERN by Seamus Heaney. Copyright © 1987 by Seamus Heaney. Excerpts from OPENED GROUND: SELECTED POEMS 1966–1996 by Seamus Heaney. Copyright © 1998 by Seamus Heaney. Excerpts from POEMS: 1965–1975 by Seamus Heaney. Copyright © 1980 by Seamus Heaney. Excerpts from PREOCCUPATIONS by Seamus Heaney. Copyright © 1980 by Seamus Heaney. Excerpts from THE REDRESS OF POETRY by Seamus Heaney. Copyright © 1995 by Seamus Heaney. Excerpts from SEEING THINGS by Seamus Heaney. Copyright © 1991 by Seamus Heaney. The right of Eugene O’Brien to be identified as the author of this work has been asserted by him in accordance with the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988. British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library ISBN 0 7453 1735 9 hardback ISBN 0 7453 1734 0 paperback Library of Congress Cataloging in Publication Data O’Brien, Eugene, 1958– Seamus Heaney : searches for answers / Eugene O’Brien. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references. ISBN 0–7453–1735–9 (hardback) –– ISBN 0–7453–1734–0 (pbk.) 1. Heaney, Seamus––Prose. 3. Northern Ireland––In literature. 3. Northern Ireland––Intellectual life. I. Title. PR6058.E2 Z799 2003 828' .91408––dc21 2003005381 10
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
Designed and produced for Pluto Press by Chase Publishing Services, Fortescue, Sidmouth, EX10 9QG, England Typeset from disk by Stanford DTP Services, Northampton, England Printed and bound in the European Union by Antony Rowe, Chippenham and Eastbourne, England
For Áine, Eoin and Dara
Contents Acknowledgements
ix
Introduction
1
1
‘Preoccupying Questions’: Heaney’s Prose
9
2
‘Continuous Adjudication’: Binary Oppositions and the Field of Force
28
3
‘Writing in the Sand’: Poetry and Transformation
60
4
‘Surviving Amphibiously’: Poetry and Politics
81
5
‘A Bright Nowhere’: The Deconstruction of Place
112
6
‘Through-Otherness’: The Deconstruction of Language
133
7
Nobel Causes: Heaney and Yeats
156
Conclusion
180
Notes Bibliography of Seamus Heaney’s Works General Bibliography Index
183 198 199 206
Acknowledgements At this juncture, I would like to record a number of debts accrued in the writing of this book. Roger van Zwanenberg at Pluto Press has been supportive of this project from the outset and for this I thank him. At an initial stage in the planning of this book, Bruce Stewart gave support and advocacy when both were needed, and for this, and for much support over the years, I thank him. My colleagues in the Department of English at Mary Immaculate College, University of Limerick have also been most helpful in easing my load through their efficiency and professionalism, thus leaving me free to complete this text, and for this, and much else, I am most grateful. Eoin Flannery took time off from his own research to read a final draft, and provided perceptive comments as well as correcting errors – I hope to do the same for him. Tony and Sinead Corbett proofread the final draft at quite short notice and enriched the text, at both the level of the signifier and the signified, with their perceptive comments and suggestions. They have read all of my previous work and I would like to thank them for their help, recommend them for their intelligence, wonder at their perseverance, and warn them that there’s more to come. I would also like to thank Tracey Day and Ray Addicott for their thorough, intelligent and painstaking reading of the typescript, and for the many suggestions and corrections they made. The book is all the better because of them. Finally, my debts to my wife Áine are many and various but I would chiefly thank her for her ongoing encouragement of this and other projects, past, present and hopefully future, her sharp proofreading, her teasing out of ideas, her frequent reality checks, and most of all, for continuing to put up with me. My two sons, Eoin and Dara were central to this project, as to so many others, and Paul and Katie continue to inspire. I would like to thank Faber & Faber and Farrar, Strauss & Giroux for permission to quote from the works of Seamus Heaney.
ix
Introduction In 1997, Seamus Heaney published a review of Roy Foster’s The Apprentice Mage, the first volume of his biography of William Butler Yeats, in The Atlantic Monthly. In this review, Heaney wrote about both biographer and subject in terms which have no small bearing on this book, and its raison d’être. To write a book about Seamus Heaney, one must, of necessity, declare one’s raison d’être from the outset as with over 30 books devoted to his work, the field is in danger of becoming over-ploughed (indeed I have already ploughed some earlier furrows myself). Any further exploration of Heaney must, de facto, suggest its relation to, and difference from, this body of critical work, if it is to justify its existence. That the majority of these studies of Heaney have been beneficial to any understanding of his work is a further problem – as this book cannot be offered as a necessary corrective to previous critical errors. However, the poet has, to date, been fortunate in his critics, therefore that avenue is also closed. So, if this book is to justify its place on the shelves, what then does it bring to Heaney studies that has been heretofore lacking? In a timehonoured manner in literary studies, and validated by the words of Shakespeare that one can ‘by indirections find directions out’ (Hamlet: II, I), I will advance my thesis via Heaney’s book review. In terms of what Heaney has to say about both Foster and Yeats, this review serves as an index to the reasons for my writing this book, as well as suggesting the critical niche which it hopes to fill. Contrary to many studies of Heaney which see him as obsessed with the past, I will be arguing that his work, both poetry and prose, is, on the contrary, oriented very much towards the future. Writing about Roy Foster, Heaney makes the following points with regard to his position within Irish historical studies in particular and Irish cultural studies in general. He notes that Foster is ‘identified as the most influential “revisionist” among contemporary Irish historians, which is to say that he, like his subject, has often been at the centre of the culture wars’. He goes on to discuss the nature of this revisionism noting that it attempts to revise the default nationalistic narrative of Irish history as a teleological emergence of the ‘Gaelic nation from foreign domination, culminating in the 1
2
Seamus Heaney
reinstatement of native government and the official recognition of the native language and majority religion after Irish independence was gained, in 1921’ (Heaney 1997). This narrative, it is argued, suppresses other strands or varieties of Irishness ‘and is therefore detrimental to any move toward a more politically workable, culturally pluralist future for the country, north and south’ (Foster 1997: 158). It is Foster’s participation in this ongoing, and sometimes fraught, process, that Heaney sees as being of value. Revisionism participates in what might be called the deconstruction of a monological historical narrative, bringing out the strains, fractures, aporias and antinomies that have been attenuated by the narrative sweep. Indeed, part of my thesis in this book will be that from a philosophical, and arguably methodological standpoint, this type of revisionism is allied to deconstruction, specifically the work of Jacques Derrida, who also focuses on neglected strands of discourses in order to bring out other narratives, histories and perspectives; as he puts it ‘marginal, fringe cases’ are important to the deconstructive project as they almost ‘always constitute the most certain and most decisive indices wherever essential conditions are to be grasped’ (Derrida 1988: 209). That Heaney should see Foster as ideally suited to write Yeats’s biography is also significant in terms of his own intellectual orientation. That he should be so affirmative of Foster’s revisionist project indicates an identification with a thinker who has engaged with the increasing complexities of socio-cultural identity that have become definitive of the situation in Northern Ireland over the past 30 years. That he should use this notion of ‘cultural pluralism’ to adequate Foster with his subject, Yeats, is highly significant in terms of Heaney’s own orientation on these issues. As Heaney points out: Nobody, therefore, was better qualified to write this book, which follows Yeats into his fiftieth year, through a period of Irish history when all the questions about national and cultural affiliation that have come so desperately to the fore again in Northern Ireland were being lived through in the rest of the country at both private and public levels and leaving their indelible mark on Irish life. But it was precisely because these crucial tensions had come to the fore that Yeats, at fifty, began to set himself up as the representative Irish poet of his times – one whose ancestors included not only a soldier who had fought for William of Orange at the Battle of the Boyne at the end of the seventeenth century but also a
Introduction
3
country scholar who was friends with the revolutionary Robert Emmet at the beginning of the nineteenth. By invoking these figures in 1914, in the introductory verses of a volume significantly titled Responsibilities, Yeats was reminding his Irish readership that he took the strain of both the major ideologies that were exacerbating Irish political life in that critically important year. (Heaney 1997: 158–9) For Heaney, then, The Apprentice Mage saw a congruence between two Irish intellectuals – Foster and Yeats – both of whom were keen to avoid a singular, monocular vision of Irishness and instead to embrace a more pluralistic and complicated construction of what it means to be Irish. Revisionism involves pluralising the narrative of history and Yeats, too, was involved in such a process. Discussing the mooted destruction of Nelson’s Pillar, in 1923, Yeats argued that the monument ‘should not be broken up’ as it represented the ‘feeling of Protestant Ireland for a man who helped to break the power of Napoleon’. Interestingly, Yeats goes on to explain his reasons for his view, noting that the ‘life and work of the people who erected it is part of our tradition’, and concluding his remarks with the telling assertion: ‘I think we should accept the whole past of this nation and not pick and choose’ (Evening Telegraph, 25 August 1923). The unravelling of different strands is again a feature of this perspective. That Heaney should be attracted by such complex and creative allegiance to a notion of a revisioned Ireland, and that he should also be attracted by the intellectual position of Foster, serves as an index of his own commitment to a similar range of ideas. Throughout his writing, in both poetry and prose, he will stress the duality and necessity for interaction and intersection of notions of selfhood and notions of alterity. As he put it elsewhere: the locating of one’s identity in ‘the ethnic and liturgical habits of one’s group’ is all very well, but for that group to ‘confine the range of one’s growth’ and ‘to have one’s sympathies determined and one’s responses programmed’ by that group, is clearly a ‘form of entrapment’ (1985: 6–7), an entrapment which defines place and identity in extremely narrow terms, and which is a polar opposite of the discourse of poetry as Heaney sees it. As Heaney puts it in The Redress of Poetry, poetry has to be ‘a working model of inclusive consciousness. It should not simplify’ (1995a: 8), and this desire to express the complexity of intersubjective relationships is the connecting thread that binds Heaney, Foster, Yeats and, I would also suggest, Derrida.
4
Seamus Heaney
All of these writers have endeavoured to avoid those ‘forms of entrapment’ of which Heaney spoke and instead, have looked for broader symbolic enunciations of individual and cultural identity, and in his Atlantic Monthly review, he stresses this admirable aspect of Yeats as icon: As a Yeats, he belonged to the respectable stratum of Protestant Irish society that owed its position and power to William of Orange’s victory and its consequences – the establishment of an Anglo-Irish ascendancy and the institution of penal laws against the Catholic population. So as a Yeats he might have been expected to support the cause of the union of Ireland with the other British nations under the English crown. But as an Irish poet who had written a manifesto aligning himself with Irish Nationalist precursors such as Thomas Davis and James Clarence Mangan, as the author of the early, inflammatory ‘rebel’ play Cathleen Ni Houlihan, as the chief inventor of the Celtic Twilight and a founding member of the Abbey Theatre, which claimed to be the country’s national theatre, Yeats had long been creating a vision of Ireland as an independent cultural entity, a state of mind as much as a nation-state, one founded on indigenous myths and attitudes and beliefs that pre-dated not only William of Orange but even Saint Patrick himself. (Heaney 1997: 159) The idea of the nation as a ‘state of mind’ is a recurring trope in contemporary cultural discourse. Heaney has made the point in his sequence ‘Squarings’ from Seeing Things, that places are always open to different naming paradigms; indeed that places are created by such paradigms: In famous poems by the sage Han Shan, Cold Mountain is a place that can also mean A state of mind. Or different states of mind At different times. (1991: 97) It is this embracing of the difference that is at the heart of the nation that further unites these writers as they all, in different ways, look to more pluralistic and complex structurations of society and culture. Not seeing nationhood or identity as either predestined or given, instead they see it as something to be created through language and
Introduction
5
imagery, and I would suggest that Heaney and Derrida follow Yeats’s idea of the importance of a dialogue between notions of selfhood and notions of alterity. Ireland as a ‘state of mind’ is a concept that is transformative of the givens of identity, in any ideological group, and it is this ongoing transformation that will take the strain of conflicting ideologies and, possibly, create new structures which will allow these ideological and cultural positions to interact, intersect and enter some form of dialogue with each other which may allow for some dissipation of the conflict. It is with this idea of taking the strain of conflicting and diverse ideological positions that I return to the question posed in the first paragraph of this introduction, as to the raison d’être of this book. I think, in the light of Heaney’s comments on Foster and Yeats, that a strand of his thinking can be traced which engages with these notions of complexity of identity, hybridity and liminality in terms of the situating of the text of selfhood within the context of one’s cultural associations and predications. His praise of the methodology used by Foster also contains the glimmerings of my own modus operandi in this book, as I will offer parallel analyses of Heaney’s poetry and prose, the latter being a glaring lacuna in what might be termed ‘Heaney studies’ over the years. Until now, I would suggest, Heaney’s prose has been generally used as a preparatory gloss on his poetry; it has never been subjected to any sustained critique in terms of its role in Heaney’s overall project. This book will redress this balance by taking specific themes in his writing, most notably concerned with issues of identity, belonging, ideology and the role of the aesthetic with respect to the political, and examine them through a sustained study of both his poetry and his prose. Finally, the connections I have made between the disciplines of historical revisionism and deconstruction presage another thematic strand of this book, namely the adequation of the ideas of Heaney and Derrida with respect to the notions of reading, writing, cultural discourse and ideology. If nothing else, this articulation has the virtue of being an unploughed part of the Heaney canon, and it also demonstrates, as I hope to show, that Heaney needs to be addressed as a cultural thinker as well as an artist in terms of his involvement in themes so seminal to the cultural narration of a contemporary form of Irishness. In both his poetry and his prose, Heaney participates in a transformative discourse which exfoliates the fixed ideological positions of Catholic-nationalist-republican and Protestant-loyalist-unionist by probing their borders, their points of
6
Seamus Heaney
limitation. By then locating these within broader and more expansive contexts, Heaney’s writing transforms points of closure into points of opening to the other. Working at the level of the individual consciousness, Heaney gradually creates the plural, complex and fluid ‘state of mind’ of an Ireland which is open to its future. At the end of his ‘Frontiers of Writing’ essay, Heaney quotes from Roy Foster’s earlier book Paddy & Mr. Punch, citing the idea that we ‘need not give up our own claims on Irishness in order to conceive of it as a flexible definition. And in an age of exclusivist jihads to east and west, the notion that people can reconcile more than one cultural identity may have much to recommend it’ (Foster 1993: xvi–xvii). It is this complexity of perspective that attracts Heaney to Yeats, and which, I will suggest, creates a strand in his work which enacts Colin Graham’s concept of deconstructing Ireland: The conclusion which this book edges towards is that ‘Ireland’ stages its own deconstruction and that at every turn the idea unravels and reforms itself, always in anticipation of the next act of definition and criticism which, like this one, will be inadequately applied to it. (Graham 2001: x) ‘Revisionism’, ‘deconstruction’, ‘different states of mind’ ‘flexibility of definition’ or pluralism: what all of these terms have in common is a desire to enunciate the complexity of Irish culture and society through the different strands of identity and to focus on the creation of this plural form of identity instead of being fixated on the givens of the past. It is this ongoing theme that will be discussed in the coming chapters. Chapter 1 deals with the theories of selfhood and alterity that run through Heaney’s prose writings. These are seen as being organised around some central questions posed in Preoccupations as to the role of poetry within society and culture. The chapter also examines the interaction and intersection of tropes of selfhood and alterity in Heaney’s writing as well as his focus on the emancipatory aspects of writing. Heaney addresses these questions, in both poetry and prose, throughout his writing. The second chapter deals with Heaney’s theory of poetry, specifically in terms of the dialectical interchange between different identitarian positions in Northern Ireland. Connections are made between his experience of internal exile and that of Derrida in Algeria, with these concrete images of travel and crossings used to extrapolate a particular strain in the work of both
Introduction
7
writers as they create plural and complex structures within which the binary oppositions can interact and inform each other, in the name of what Heaney describes as the need to accommodate ‘two opposing notions of truthfulness simultaneously’ (1985: 4). Poetry as a vehicle for the achievement of such a structure is examined in poems from The Haw Lantern, Seeing Things and The Spirit Level, as well as in essays from Preoccupations, where his notions of ‘continuous adjudication’ and a ‘field of force’ are first expressed. Chapter 3 focuses on the transformative effect which poetry can bring to reality and actuality in terms of subverting, and amplifying, the givens with which our culture presents us. This chapter discusses the effects of poetry as a dialectical structure on both writer and reader, looking at the title essay and ‘Frontiers of Writing’ in The Redress of Poetry, as well as at his Nobel lecture Crediting Poetry. Parallels between Heaney and Derrida in terms of concepts of identity, responsibility, liminality and the fluidity of borders will also be discussed. The fourth chapter examines the transformative interaction of poetry and politics, examining the creative ambiguity in the phrase ‘government of the tongue’, and then developing this analysis to examine some of his poetry and prose which attempt to transform signifiers which have a hegemonic attachment to a particular tradition into indices of plurality and complexity. Connections are made between his work and that of Derrida and Emmanuel Levinas. These include some of the placename poems from Wintering Out as well as the almost programmatic example of a poem involving the interaction of self and other: ‘The Other Side’, read in tandem with ‘The Pitchfork’ in Seeing Things. ‘The Flight Path’, from The Spirit Level, is read in terms of a transformation of the individual in terms of political allegiance. The fifth chapter deals with the deconstruction of notions of place, particularly with how placenames specifically associated with nationalist ideology, are recontextualised in order to open different paths of signification. These names are significant in terms of the Heaney canon – Toome, Mossbawn, Glanmore – and are read in terms of Derrida’s presence/absence conceit, and in terms of Heaney’s own resonant image of a creative space which stood where a chestnut tree had stood, an image traced from an essay in The Government of the Tongue, through some poems in The Haw Lantern. This reading of absence as a creative source is paralleled with Maurice Blanchot’s The Space of Literature.
8
Seamus Heaney
The sixth chapter parallels the fifth by deconstructing different aspects of language which have been associated with a particular tradition in Northern Ireland. By examining different signifiers that would seem to have a nationalist or Gaelic association, and by teasing out Heaney’s deconstruction of this aspect of their etymology as he brings the signifier into the ambit of the other tradition, his ongoing pluralisation of language is foregrounded. Specifically, the complexity of language as it is experienced in art is discussed, ranging through Heaney’s poetry and prose. Chapter 7 examines the influence and interaction of Heaney’s work with that of another Nobel Prize-winning Irish poet, one with whom he has often been compared. I refer, of course, to William Butler Yeats. Heaney has written of his debt to Yeats, and in this chapter, we will examine the ethical similarities between these writers in terms of their views on the role of the aesthetic with respect to the politic, as well as in terms of their attitude to the complexities of identity. The Nobel lectures of each writer will also be compared in terms of their attitudes to the place of writing in society. In his essay ‘Vision and Irony in Recent Irish Poetry’, published in The Place of Writing, Heaney stresses the relationship between the poet and his or her cultural context in ideal terms: ‘as poets, they comprehend both the solidarities of their own group and the need to subvert them’ (1989: 49). It is this complexity of response that will be the terminus ad quem towards which Heaney’s ongoing searches for answers will be directed.
1
‘Preoccupying Questions’: Heaney’s Prose
To say that Seamus Heaney’s work is academically popular would be an understatement. There are, to date, over 30 books completely devoted to the study and analysis of his writing, and to list the number of articles and chapters on Heaney would probably be a book-length enterprise in itself.1 Given that Heaney is a Nobel Prize winner, as well as being one of the most popular poets currently writing in English, and given that he reaches a global audience, this profusion of academic attention should come as no surprise. However, what is surprising is that, in all of these books, there is not one which is devoted to a sustained study of his prose writings, and how these writings are central to his overall project. Many critics refer to these essays and lectures in terms of providing some form of explicatory or contextual commentary on his poems. For example, Elmer Andrews, in his Icon Critical Guide (1998) to Heaney’s work, makes frequent use of his prose in order to explain the backdrop of many of the poems.2 The same is true of Neil Corcoran’s study where he sees Heaney’s second collection of essays, The Government of the Tongue, as a companion to some of the poems in The Haw Lantern, with ‘the essays sometimes fleshing out in discursive terms what the poems encode more obliquely’ (Corcoran 1986: 138). Ronald Tamplin uses a passage from the end of ‘The God in the Tree’, from Preoccupations, to enable a reading of Heaney’s poem In Gallarus Oratory (Heaney 1969: 22), noting the contrast of light and dark in the passage, and significantly commenting that this contrast can be seen ‘even more clearly in the poem’ (Tamplin 1989: 33), thus making the supplementary status of the prose explicit. Andrew Murphy uses passages from Preoccupations as a gloss in his readings of Requiem for the Croppies (Murphy 2000a: 31–2),3 while almost all of the other studies of his poetry use the prose as a supplementary point of reference. These are just a selection of examples of this usage of Heaney’s prose in academic writing: there are numerous others.4 I think it is clear, then, that the received critical wisdom here is to treat Heaney’s prose as a kind of piecemeal supplement to his poetry. 9
10
Seamus Heaney
The essays and lectures are seen to provide a privileged commentary where the poet can discuss his art in terms which will cast greater light upon it. Even in reviews or articles which purport to discuss the prose itself, the terminology and attitude is suggestive of just such an approach. Thus, in writing about the essays, Thomas Docherty feels obligated to see them as constituted by a ‘poetic’ logic (1997: 148). It is as if, were Heaney not a poet, then these essays and lectures would be of less worth: they are not ‘stand-alone’ pieces. In a similar fashion, Bernard O’Donoghue, in an article on The Government of the Tongue, makes the point that some of the best reviews of this book ‘read it enlighteningly in relation to the general political poems in The Haw Lantern’ (1994: 181).5 In a review of The Government of the Tongue, the Irish writer and critic Colm Tóibín saw the essays as underscoring this view of Heaney as poet, noting that it was ‘as though he needs to insist that he is not a critic, or a prose-writer, but a poet trying to clear space for himself’ (1988). This approach to Heaney’s prose is by now endemic, with the essays and lectures being seen as a commentary on the poetry, and also as texts which can usefully shed light on individual poems, or on biographical or thematically related detail and incident in Heaney’s own life.6 In general the readings of Heaney’s prose all seem to share this perspective. At this juncture, my own perspective needs enunciation. I see his prose as central to his developing project. Far from being a metacommentary on his poetry, it is a seminal aspect of his work, providing parallel expressions and explorations of the themes that have been ongoing in his writing. I would suggest that Edward Mendelson’s remark, about The Government of the Tongue, that the book was less miscellaneous than it appeared, could validly be applied to his prose in general (1988: 726), though the faint praise that is to be found in the phrasing of this remark further strengthens the view of the prose as very much second best in the Heaney canon. In terms of offering a reading of Heaney’s essays, I would offer his own reading practice as a useful paradigm. In The Government of the Tongue, he discusses the work of the Polish poet Zbigniew Herbert, and as befits one whose academic rite of passage was undergone when ‘practical criticism held great sway’ (Heaney 1980: 13), there is a close, in places line-by-line, examination of passages from three works by Herbert. These are Barbarian in the Garden, Selected Poems and Report from the Besieged City and Other Poems. What is interesting, in the context of our discussion, is that Barbarian in the Garden is a collection of prose writings, ‘ten meditations on art
Heaney’s Prose
11
and history which masquerade as travel writing’ (Heaney 1988: 55). Heaney does not see these essays as a metalinguistic gloss on the poetry; nor does he see them as separate, in terms of thematic concerns, from Herbert’s poetry; rather he sees them as another enunciation of the thematic, aesthetic and ethical imperatives that ground Herbert’s work. The same standards can be applied to Heaney’s own beginnings as a prose writer. In the foreword to Preoccupations, he makes the following points: I had a half-clarified desire to come to poetic terms with myself by considering the example of others, and to try to bring into focus the little I knew….I hope it is clear that the essays selected here are held together by searches for answers to central preoccupying questions: how should a poet properly live and write? What is his relationship to be to his own voice, his own place, his literary heritage and his contemporary world? (1980: 13) In this quotation, Heaney outlines the raison d’être of the essays in the book: I would argue that one could also see this quotation as outlining the raison d’être of his entire oeuvre. I would make two points about this assertion. Firstly, it demonstrates the centrality that Heaney ascribes to his prose writing, seeing it as a meditation on art and poetry, and as a coming to terms with his own voice through a consideration of other poets, what he terms, borrowing from Auden, ‘breaking bread with the dead’ (1980: 14). From the outset, this is no piecemeal series of disparate essays and reviews; instead it is a bringing ‘into focus’ of his concerns about the notion of ‘art’; it is an enunciation of, what one might tentatively term, given its early placement in the Heaney canon, an aesthetic theory. I use the term ‘theory’ advisedly, tracing its etymology from the Greek theoria, meaning ‘to look at’, and keeping in mind Heaney’s own metaphor of bringing his knowledge ‘into focus’. This new sense of looking at poetry, in terms of the study of other poets, initiates a theoretical perspective that underwrites all of his prose as opposed to just this book. In this context, the theoretical perspective that is in the process of being heuristically wrought is coterminous with the views of Christopher Norris, who describes theory as being ‘capable of providing a better, more adequate conceptual grasp of experiences that would otherwise belong to the realm of pre-reflective “commonsense” knowledge’ (1991: 13). Surely this is what Heaney
12
Seamus Heaney
is setting out to achieve in Preoccupations, and by extension in his other books. He is taking his own work, and the work of other writers who have in some way helped him to write, and is taking up ‘a critical distance from the data of first-hand subjective understanding’ (Norris 1991: 12). In this context, O’Donoghue notes, correctly in my view, that Heaney’s writing can be connected with ‘mainstream English critical theoretical tradition’ since Coleridge (1994: 148),7 and I would see this connection as a far better contextual placement of Heaney’s prose than that of Corcoran, who entitles his chapter on the prose ‘Heaney’s Literary Criticism’ (1998: 209–33).8 Secondly, this quotation attests to the teleology of his project, namely the ‘searches for answers’ to those central preoccupying questions which are cited above. This is foregrounded by the deictical glissement in the above quotation, a glissement which is thematically significant in terms of his prose. He begins using the personal pronoun, first person singular: ‘[a]ll that I really knew about the art was derived from whatever poetry I had written and from those poets who had helped me to write it. I had a half-clarified desire to come to poetic terms with myself’ [my italics]. It is clear that Heaney himself, and his work, are both the subject and object of this particular search for answers. His writing will focus on his own work, and on the work of others in terms of how they have helped him to come to poetic terms with himself. Interestingly, though, the second part of the quotation demonstrates the deictical progression from the personal to the general, with the teleological object of the searches for answers now becoming ‘the poet’, and his relationship with voice, place, literature and society: ‘how should a poet properly live and write? What is his relationship to be to his own voice, his own place, his literary heritage and his contemporary world?’ [my italics]. In this context, Heaney is being provoked by questions similar to those discussed by Derrida in terms of the form and function of literature. Pondering on his response to the question, Derrida traces his thinking as follows, as he comes back to the question: ‘What is writing in general?’ and, in the space of writing in general, to this other question which is more and other than a simple particular case: ‘What is literature?’; literature as historical institution with its conventions, rules etc., but also this institution of fiction which gives in principle the power to say everything, to break free of the rules, to displace them, and thereby to institute, to invent and even to suspect the traditional difference between
Heaney’s Prose
13
nature and institution, nature and conventional law, nature and history. Here we should ask juridical and political questions. The institution of literature in the West, in its relatively modern form, is linked to an authorization to say everything, and doubtless too to the coming about of the modern idea of democracy. (1992a: 37) The similarity between both writers in terms of their attitudes to the value and purpose of literature is striking, and further connections between their thinking will be traced in the later chapters of this work. Both writers probe the interstices between the literary and the political, Derrida examining the constitutive function of a literature which sanctions and enhances debate and discussion, while Heaney examines the relationship of the literary to notions of place, heritage and the contemporary world. No less than Derrida, he is probing the epistemological status of the literary as well as examining the interactions of the literary text with the cultural and societal context. In short, what is attempted in his various prose pieces is nothing less than a theory, or epistemology, of poetry in particular and writing in general, what Bernard O’Donoghue calls, speaking specifically of The Government of the Tongue, Heaney’s ars poetica (1994: 135). I would suggest that such a project is the result of the ‘searches for answers’ that have set in motion his prose writings in the first place. In this study, I will be focusing on what I consider to be the main prosewritings of Heaney’s career thus far: Preoccupations: Selected Prose 1968–1978 (1980); Among Schoolchildren (1983); Place and Displacement: Recent Poetry of Northern Ireland (1985); The Government of the Tongue: The 1986 T. S. Eliot Memorial Lectures and Other Critical Writings (1988); The Place of Writing (1989), The Redress of Poetry: Oxford Lectures (1995), Crediting Poetry (1995), his Nobel lecture and the most recent summative collection Finders Keepers (2002), which also includes some new material. I will trace Heaney’s ars poetica through all of these books, concentrating on his evolving discussion of how a poet should live and write, a discussion framed by the different relationships between a poet and his or her voice, place, literary heritage and society. I will also make connections between these essays and the themes of his poetry, seeing both genres as different ways of progressing his ongoing search for answers to those preoccupying questions. I will argue that the concerns and themes that various critics have discussed in his poetry are also to be found in his prose. To see what Helen Vendler terms his ‘vivid, metaphorical and intelligent prose’
14
Seamus Heaney
(1998: 5) as merely a metalinguistic commentary, or as some form of necessary background research, is to mistakenly transform generic considerations into epistemological ones. In the essays of the books cited, one finds ongoing parallel discussion of some of the central concerns of Heaney’s poetry: the nature of Irish identity; the difficulty of writing about place, given the historical and cultural baggage that always accrues; the relationship of poetry with politics; the ethical questions that are intimately connected with aesthetic enterprises; the influence of European and world perspectives on his own work, and on the whole notion of Irishness in general, the influences of other writers from different traditions on his work; the special relationship with the work of Yeats, and, finally, the attempt to set up a fluid spatial metaphor of an Irishness, which one might term negative dialectical, as it combines the multifarious traditions, cultures and ideologies that have been thrown together historically. Underwriting all of these concerns, or preoccupations, is the ongoing attempt to bring into focus some form of theorisation of the aesthetic, to take up some form of critical distance so as to better understand the mode of knowledge that is operative within art and which, by extension, is operative through poetry and prose in terms of the socio-political sphere. What emerges in these essays is a sophisticated approach to poetry, an approach which grants the internal laws of language and aesthetics which are applicable within the domain of poetry, but which at the same time demonstrates a growing awareness of the need to reconcile what he terms ‘lyric celebration’ (1988: 12), and its concomitants ‘the phrase or cadence which haunts the ear and the eager parts of the mind’ (1980: 61), with the demands of an ethical imperative which ‘the poet may find as he exercises his free gift in the presence of the unfree and the hurt’ (1988: xviii). This sophisticated aesthetic is brought about by a complex dialectical approach, which sets up what in German is termed an Auseinandersetzung, a confrontation wherein one can gain a greater understanding of each term, as well as of the relationship between them.9 It will become clear that it is on this relationship, what Andrew Murphy terms the ‘conflicting demands of Song and Suffering’ (2000a: 1), and its effect on the individual categories, that Heaney’s critical focus will be directed. For Heaney, the epistemological force of poetry is complex and multilayered, involving the granting of voice to different perspectives, as well as setting up cognitive and intellectual structures which allow for their interaction. His careful readings of other texts always
Heaney’s Prose
15
gesture towards such constructs, where the dialectical oscillation between the different perspectives creates a field of force wherein it is the relationship between the different perspectives that is the main focus of his ‘searches for answers’, and we can see this type of reading in action in an early example from Preoccupations. In an essay entitled ‘In the Country of Convention’, about a collection of English pastoral verse,10 he is critical of what he sees as an oversimplification of response on behalf of the editors to the notion of what they term ‘the pastoral vision’. Barrell and Bull see this vision as being ultimately false, because it posits a simplistic unhistorical relation between the land-owning class and the workers, which mystifies and obscures the actuality of working conditions. Heaney notes the influence of Raymond Williams on this point of view,11 and goes on to criticise this ‘sociological filleting of the convention’ as being guilty of a ‘certain attenuation of response’ which curtails the consideration of the poems as ‘made things’ as ‘self-delighting buds on the old bough of a tradition’ (1980: 174). The complexity of his position may not seem at first obvious in this essay; there is a polarity seemingly set up between what we might term intrinsic and extrinsic, or aesthetic and sociological criticism. Indeed, ‘In the Country of Convention’ does not figure in many discussions of Heaney’s work;12 nevertheless, I would argue that here, in embryo, are to be found two of the defining facets of his aesthetic epistemology, namely a fluid dialectical movement of thought, and an awareness of the complicated interaction of text and context, demands which lead writing towards a position of some complexity. So, while deploring the simplification of response, Heaney is also willing to grant the benefit of sociologically driven criticism as ‘a bracing corrective’ to what could prove an ‘over-literary savouring’ of the genre as a matter of ‘classical imitation and allusion’ (1980: 174). He is obviously not against extrinsically driven criticism per se; rather he is against any form of ‘attenuation of response’, any thinning of the plurality and complexity of the field of force which should be set up in the process of his teleological searches for answers. He sees the relationship between the internal dynamics of the poems, and their reflection, refraction, and transformation of external societal and cultural factors, as far too complex to allow the ‘Marxist broom’ to sweep aesthetic considerations aside in favour of the societal and economic. Instead, Heaney’s notion of the relationship between text and context is far more complex and fluid. It could be seen as an example
16
Seamus Heaney
of the rhetorical figure of anastomosis, as cited by J. Hillis Miller in The Ethics of Reading, in terms of notions of ‘penetration and permeation’. Miller is also speaking about the relationship between text and context, and sees this notion of context as hovering ‘uneasily’ between ‘metonymy in the sense of mere contingent adjacency and synecdoche, part for whole, with an assumption that the part is some way genuinely like the whole’ (1987: 6). It is here that he cites the trope of anastomosis, adverting to Joyce’s verbal example ‘underdarkneath’13 as well as Bakhtin’s view of language as a social philosophy which is permeated by a system of values ‘inseparable from living practice and class struggle’ (1973: 6–7).14 One could just as easily see ‘con-text’ as a similar case, with one word, ‘text’ penetrating or permeating the other, ‘context’.15 Here both words intersect and interfuse, but perform the dialectical action of remaining separate as well as blending. Heaney’s reading sets up a further contextual aspect of this dialectical structure which, far from attenuating our response, will thicken and enable it. Heaney laments the decision of the editors not to print translations of Theocritus, Virgil, Horace, Mantuan, and Marot,16 as these were the ‘informing voices that were “modified in the guts of the living”’ (1980: 175), which underwrote the pastoral poetry of Spenser, Milton, Pope and Thomson as they attempted to ‘adorn and classicise’ the native literature. He feels that such a ‘classical penumbra’ was automatic cultural capital for these writers, and thinks it a pity that the ‘ancient hinterland, the perspectives backward, are withheld’ (1980: 175). Here, the textual-contextual anastomosis becomes more intricate, as this withholding delimits our reading of the pastoral genre, and of the specific English writing of this genre, as well as the complexities inherent in the title of the book. This level of contextual cultural and linguistic complication is also to be found throughout Heaney’s poetic development. One thinks of the early placename poems ‘Broagh’ and ‘Anahorish’, where the dialectical linguistic evolution from the native Irish words ‘anach fhíor uisce’, meaning ‘place of clear water’ and ‘bruach’, meaning ‘riverbank’ is traced through their eponymous transliterations, into a form of language that is shot through with both the native Irish and the colonising English languages. In these poems, the dialectical movement between different cultural significations is instantiated in the desire to see the placename ‘Anahorish’ as translated into: ‘My “place of clear water”’ (1972: 16), and in a similar movement in the first line of ‘Broagh’ which translates the title as ‘Riverbank’ (1972:
Heaney’s Prose
17
27). Of course, no Irish or English dictionary will validate these ‘translations’ as the placenames are Anglicisations and transliterations of the original Irish words as opposed to translations. What they signify is a dialectic, a movement between languages which is creative of a new sense of English with an Irish influence. Herman Rapaport makes this point in connection with Derrida, noting that for Derrida, ‘language isn’t entirely masterable to perfection; therefore one always senses that one is, however slightly, a stranger or foreigner to it’ (2003: 31), and Heaney, in his poems dealing specifically with language, takes this position fully on board. In ‘Traditions’, one of Heaney’s ‘most discussed anthologised pieces’ (Crotty 2001: 201), the same process is to be found. The poem begins with an overt symbol of colonisation in sexual terms: Our guttural muse was bulled long ago by the alliterative tradition. (1972: 31) However, it progresses from this direct binary conflict to more nuanced notions of linguistic diffusion, as the Irish are seen to be ‘proud’ of their ‘Elizabethan English’, with some ‘cherished archaisms’ actually being ‘correct Shakespearean’ (1972: 31).17 The interaction is further complicated in the lines which speak of consonants ‘shuttling obstinately / between bawn and mossland’ (1972: 32). As will be seen later in this discussion, the two nouns of the second line are overdetermined signifiers in the Heaney canon, deriving as they do from the name of his early home, Mossbawn. Each term has a meaning in Irish and in English, and Heaney will attempt to articulate these oppositions in a manner which will create a hybrid identity. Throughout his work, Heaney does not privilege one meaning over the other. Instead, meanings interact, gesturing towards a new fusion of languages and culture, and paralleling the trope of anastomosis already discussed. In the final section of ‘Traditions’, and the plural number of this noun is significant in the light of this reading of Heaney’s work as plural in terms of its searches for answers, another linguistic and cultural tradition is grafted onto the givens of Irish identity. In answer to the most quoted question in Irish studies, MacMorris’s ‘What ish my nation?’ (Shakespeare, Henry V: II, ii, 124), Heaney cites the words of Joyce:
18
Seamus Heaney
And sensibly, though so much later, the wandering Bloom replied, ‘Ireland,’ said Bloom, ‘I was born here. Ireland.’ (Heaney 1972: 32) In this stanza, a Hungarian Jew states his claim to an Irishness that must accommodate him as he was born in Ireland. In this seemingly simple juxtaposition of Shakespeare and Joyce, Heaney is in effect setting out a paradigm of identity which is pluralistic, ethically driven and which refuses to be hidebound by hypostasised traditions and instead, remains open to the voice and language of the other who may come into contact with the self. There is a transformative imperative at work here, as the Ireland to which Bloom lays claim is in effect transformed by that very claim into a locus of plural identity. The adverb ‘sensibly’ carries a weight within this poem, as it defines an obligation to embrace change which is gradual as opposed to violent. In the appropriately entitled ‘A New Song’, Heaney seems to develop this consensual paradigm of linguistic and cultural interaction, as instead of one tradition being ‘bulled’ by another, an image of a more gentle form of sexual intercourse is posited: But now our river tongues must rise From licking deep in native haunts To flood with vowelling embrace, Demesnes staked out in consonants. (1972: 33) This new song is a paradigm of Heaney’s own developing attitude to the linguistic and cultural context that surrounds all texts. Just as the notion of English pastoral is being deconstructed in his essay, so too are the seeming simplicities of the Irish-English historical conflict offered to ongoing critique in his poetry. The language that had been foisted upon Ireland as an apparatus of colonisation is also the language through which Joyce gave voice to a new sense of Irishness, a new song in which Irishness became redefined. What is set out as The Penguin Book of English Pastoral Verse (Barrell and Bull 1975), with all the canonical, imperial, and culturally homogeneous connotations that are implied by the proper adjective ‘English’, becomes something different when placed in a dialectical relationship with the classical antecedents to which he refers. Such external influences, in this case, far from attenuating the response to
Heaney’s Prose
19
the lyrical impulse of the pastoral, thicken our reading of these works by complicating and interrogating how ‘English’ this genre actually is. This ‘perspective backwards’ is also a perspective outwards, pointing up the dependence of what is seen as the English poetic canon on generic and conventional borrowings from continental Europe. It is also a perspective inwards, as these extrinsic features have had a major influence on stylistic and thematic considerations, as well as on the aesthetic objectives of the genre. Here, the anastomosis between text and context is enacted in the permeation and intersection of the poems in the book and the poems which preceded them; of the English language and Latin and French; of Latin and French and translation; of classical pastoral convention and the English version of it and finally, of the texts that are present in the book, and those enabling translations from the classics, which are absent. Throughout Heaney’s poetry, I would argue, there is a process of ongoing recontextualisation of language at work. As his career develops, there is an increasing level of linguistic plurality to be found in his writing. Translation has become an increasingly important aspect of his canon with translations of complete texts from Polish, Anglo-Saxon, French, Latin, Greek, Italian and Irish, as well as snippets from a number of other European languages. In his latest collection of poetry, Electric Light, one finds an increasingly polyglot range of allusions. In ‘Known World’, for example, he describes his return flight from a poetry festival at Struga, in Macedonia, in a highly polylinguistic style: I kept my seat belt fastened as instructed, Smoked the minute the No Smoking sign went off And took it as my due when wine was poured By a slight de haut en bas of my headphoned head. Nema problema. Ja. All systems go. (Heaney 2001: 22–3) The ‘I’ of this poem is clearly influenced by his European context, and the linguistic and cultural anastomosis is a metaphorical enunciation of an increasingly complex sense of identity within Heaney himself. This complex interrogation of the categories of text and context calls to mind a similar interrogation in the work of Jacques Derrida who, in Limited Inc., has noted that ‘nothing exists outside context’, and that consequently, the ‘outside penetrates and thus determines the inside’ (1988: 153).18 Derrida has made a similar point in
20
Seamus Heaney
Positions, where he speaks of how each seemingly simple term is marked by the trace of other terms, so that the ‘presumed interiority of meaning’ is ‘worked on by its own exteriority. It is always already carried outside itself’ (1981a: 33). Heaney’s project will also demonstrate a view of poetry which stresses the transformative and interpenetrative mode of action through which poetry achieves its ends of breaking down opposed binary positions. Keeping these points in mind, when we return to the title, ‘In the Country of Convention’, we realise that this title is, like the essay, less simple than it might seem. Analogously, the country being described by the placenames ‘Broagh’ and ‘Anahorish’ is similarly complex: at first glance, it is an ur-Ireland, but ongoing investigation underlines the traces of the context of colonisation on both placenames, and, by extension, on English as it is spoken in Ireland. Similarly, in Preoccupations, while the country in question is England, as denoted by the proper adjective of the subtitle, ‘English Pastoral Verse’, the essay draws out the connotations of the diverse influences, literary, linguistic and political, that are present in the pastoral convention. The constituent factors of this genre are not English, but Latin and French in language, as well as in tone and theme. The ‘convention’ of the title derives from classical pastoral literature, but as translations of this literature are absent, the presentation of the ‘country’ in question is consequently attenuated. As much of the poetry shares Thomson’s notion of ‘England as an after-image of Augustan Rome’ (Heaney 1980: 178), Heaney has accurately pointed out the weakness of the book, while at the same time providing a strong reading of the genre itself through an interrogation of this absence. Thus, Heaney allows the classical context to imbricate his reading of the English texts in the book, and both present text and absent context permeate and penetrate each other in a fuller exploration in the essay than is given in the book itself. Heaney’s reading can be seen, in the terminology of Mikhail Bakhtin, as heteroglossic, in that different voices and different languages are allowed to confront each other and achieve some kind of dynamic interaction, or dialogisation (Bakhtin 1981: 263).19 Hence Heaney pluralises the title of the essay so that the ‘country of convention’ opens its borders to other countries, other languages and other literary traditions. Just as Heaney’s reading of this book sees text and context interpenetrate each other, so, by implication, the genre of English pastoral has also set text and context in a dialectical relationship, a relationship which ultimately calls into
Heaney’s Prose
21
question the separateness of the English poetic canon as such. Heaney’s reading of conventionality has become unconventional in its dislocation of the ground on which the epistemological premises of the book are based. In this reading there is an obvious similarity with a reading by Derrida of Shelley’s The Triumph of Life. Here, Derrida also questions the borderlines of a text, suggesting that a text is no longer: a finished corpus of writing, some content enclosed in a book or its margins, but a differential network, a fabric of traces referring endlessly to something other than itself, to other differential traces. Thus the text overruns all the limits assigned to it so far (not submerging or drowning them in an undifferentiated homogeneity, but rather making them more complex, dividing and multiplying strokes and lines). (1987: 84) This is precisely the process of reading undertaken by Heaney in this essay; he takes the assumptions imposed by the title and format of the book, points to the attenuations of response that the selection criteria impose, attenuations that have an analogous relationship to the Marxist broom and sociological filleting already mentioned, and proceeds to make them ‘more complex, dividing and multiplying strokes and lines’. He furthers this process towards the end of the essay by wondering whether the temporal and spatial limits imposed by the editors on poets who were included in the book are valid. He questions whether the editors’ ‘brisk dismissal’ of the further possibilities of pastoral are well-founded, and goes on to suggest valid reasons for the inclusion of other writers – Edward Thomas, Hugh MacDiarmid, David Jones, A. E. Housman – and also wonders about Louis MacNeice’s eclogues which ‘represent the form as an enabling resource’ (1980: 180). Finally, he further extends the limits of his critique by multiplying some ‘strokes and lines’ which figure as political borders, and asks whether such seminal works as Synge’s Aran Islands (pastoral),20 Kavanagh’s The Great Hunger (anti-pastoral), and Montague’s The Rough Field are ‘not to be regarded just as “occasional twitches”’ before finishing the essay with the ironic question ‘Or are these latter works held at bay in the term “frontier pastoral”?’ (1980: 180). Conceptually, this notion of a frontier has resonances of Derrida’s idea of the fluid and permeable borderlines of a text: both writers stress the value of writing in terms of breaking down rigid lines of demarcation and instead, suggesting that writing
22
Seamus Heaney
in general, and poetry in particular, exerts a deconstructive leverage over such positions of fixity. This final irony is instructive, as his earlier dialectical interpenetration of text and context demonstrated that the English pastoral had already crossed temporal, political and linguistic frontiers in appropriating Latin and French translations from classical antiquity into a specifically English landscape. However, to adopt another ‘perspective backwards’, the origin of the master trope of the pastoral was, as Barrell and Bull (1975) have noted, the Eden myth, which, together with classical dreams of a Golden Age ‘lies behind most versions of pastoral’ (Heaney 1980: 175). Here again, frontiers of language and culture have been crossed by the genre. So his question is, why stop at this particular frontier? If the genre has been sufficiently fluid to engage with the classics and the Bible, perhaps it is also capable of engaging with more modern sensibilities. The frontier, denotative of a spatial binary opposition between one notion of place and another, functions here as both a borderline of the anthology, and at the same time, as a point of possibility which will allow the ‘English’ pastoral as genre, to develop. In a further expansion of these limits, this development would necessitate an ongoing problematisation of the notion of Englishness in the title, as now, some form of ‘Irishness’ would be included. Of course, as Heaney has already noted, the final poem in the anthology is Yeats’s Ancestral Houses (Heaney 1980: 177), so there has already been a crossing of the ‘frontier pastoral’. It becomes clear, then, that his reading of the conventions of the pastoral becomes quite unconventional in its implications and in its reading practice. What we see are what Hillis Miller, in his discussion of anastomosis, terms a variety of ‘crossings, displacements, and substitutions, as inside becomes outside, outside inside, or as features on either side cross over the wall, membrane or partition dividing the sides’ (1987: 7), and I will argue that such transgressive and transgenerative crossings of frontiers are a central feature in Heaney’s epistemology of poetry.21 Indeed, Derrida, in ‘Living On: Borderlines’ probes the epistemology of the border between text and context in a broadly analogous manner, as he talks about borders in terms of permeability, noting that no context is ‘saturatable any more’, and that ‘no border is guaranteed, inside or out’ (1987: 78).22 Hence, for Heaney, the two poles of an opposition, as exemplified here by text and context, are never simply set down in isolation; nor are they placed in a dialectic which produces a definite synthesis.
Heaney’s Prose
23
Instead, his work produces readings which set up a relationship which is fluid and interactive, and in which both terms interact and reflect each other.23 This relationship is what Theodor Adorno would term a Kraftfeldt (force-field), which contains transactional and dialectical interplay of different, and sometimes opposing, forces, and which is comprised of juxtaposed clusters of changing elements that, according to Martin Jay, ‘resist reduction to a common denominator, essential core, or generative first principle’ (1984: 15). In a manner that is strikingly analogous to the thinking of Heaney, Derrida has described a similar process, in Positions, where what he terms ‘undecidables’ inhabit an opposition, ‘resisting and disorganising it, without ever constituting a third term, without ever leaving room for a solution in the form of speculative dialectics’ (1981a: 43). The answers which Heaney’s enabling searches find are often similar ‘undecidables’, which encourage us to probe the interstices of the text, and the ‘network of textual referrals to other texts’ where each term is ‘marked by the trace of another term’ (Derrida 1981a: 33). Politically, this makes Heaney’s writing highly significant as he is attempting, in both poetry and prose, to problematise simplistic concepts of identity, language and culture and instead, and by extension, to set up more fluid and complex structures where borders and limits are transformed and transgressed. Such a reading is certainly at odds with the consensus opinion of ‘famous Seamus’ whose work has been criticised for being a published form of ‘private musing’, something which is seen as far removed from any political stance (Fennell 1991: 33). However, as I will demonstrate, such readings do not take full account of the scope and complexity of Heaney’s thought and writing. To most readers, the articulation of the work of Heaney with that of Theodor Adorno, Mikhail Bakhtin and especially with that of Jacques Derrida would seem unusual, but in this study, I will show that, in terms of the central activity of Heaney’s prose, there are parallels in terms of the activity of reading. There are many similarities between Heaney’s preoccupying questions, and the complex reading and writing processes through which he conducts his searches for answers, and what has become termed as critical theory. This is particularly true of the work of Derrida, and a seminal aspect of this study will be the demonstration of the similarity between the theoretical projects of both writers. As well as an approach which breaks down static positions and oppositions into more fluid and economic dialectical structures, they each value a sense of responsi-
24
Seamus Heaney
bility to notions of alterity, and an ethical imperative towards intersubjective truth and justice. They each also stress the importance of notions of ‘play’ in any system, if that system is not to become hypostasised. Hillis Miller has made the telling assessment that deconstruction is ‘nothing more or less than good reading’ (1987: 10), and in a recent book on Derrida, Julian Wolfreys goes on to amplify this by suggesting that ‘good reading’ may well be reading which ‘never avoids its responsibility, and which never falls into reading by numbers’ (1998: 16). In his response to the issues and texts in his prose, Heaney’s plural searches for answers means that there is never any question of reading by numbers, or of forcing texts and contexts to bend to a preconceived agenda. I would suggest that for Heaney, the notion of attenuation, of making one’s response thinner, more reductive, more simple, comes close to Wolfreys’s notion of ‘reading by numbers’. Heaney’s essays always grant the heterogeneity and complexity of the issue under discussion, and in the following chapters, I will analyse his treatment of a number of important themes in his own writing, but more importantly, in terms of writing in general, or what I have already termed a theory of poetry. In his own poems, such heterogeneous notions of identity have been a feature from the very beginning. In Death of a Naturalist, such liminal intersections are to be found: Did sea define land or land the sea? Each drew new meaning from the waves’ collision. Sea broke on land to full identity. (1966: 47) It is my contention that his work is driven by just such an integrative dimension, and this is to be found in his theory of writing, his view of the relationship between poetry and politics, his teasing out of the location of the place of writing, his comments on Irish identity, and the complexity inherent in both terms, his relationship with his fellow Nobel Laureate William Butler Yeats, his views on the ethics of writing, his sense of openness to a placing of Irishness in a broader, European context and finally, his complex symbolisation, set out in The Redress of Poetry, of a shape, the quincunx, which gestures towards the fluid, reflexive and complex resolution of form and theme that may provide some of the results of his ‘searches for answers’ to those central preoccupying questions. This shape represents the combination of the dialectical interaction of different perspectives and the complexity
Heaney’s Prose
25
of perspective and understanding, which I suggest are the hallmarks of Heaney’s writing. In terms of permeation of text and context, of fluid and intersecting borders, of frontiers which are multiple and inclusive, this structure is mimetic of Heaney’s epistemology of writing in general and poetry in particular: it is his Kraftfeldt, his field of force wherein the binary oppositions that structure the parameters of identity can be contextualised and transformed. As Blanchot observes, art embodies this transformative potential: In the world things are transformed into objects in order to be grasped, utilised, made more certain in the distinct rigor of their limits and the affirmation of a homogeneous and divisible space. But in imaginary space things are transformed into that which cannot be grasped. Out of use, beyond wear, they are not in our possession but are the movement of dispossession which releases us both from them and from ourselves. (1982a: 131) Blanchot, like Heaney, sees part of the function of art as the transformation of the given perception of reality. The function of imaginary space, a concept akin to Heaney’s field of force, is the transformation of the actual, and the creation of an alternative paradigm of truth and integration. He sees poetry as a ‘source of truth and at the same time a vehicle of harmony’, and in terms of writing in Northern Ireland, this truth is achieved by being ‘true to the negative nature of the evidence’ while at the same time showing ‘an affirming flame’ (1995a: 193). The complex dialectical force of poetry is, for Heaney, a recusant one in terms of simplistic political or literary allegiance. Writing about an early poem of his own, ‘The Other Side’ (1972: 34–6), Heaney describes how a Presbyterian farmer waits until his Catholic neighbours have finished their prayers before calling in to the house. He notes that this poem was not ‘fundamentally intended as a contribution to better community relations…it was about a moment of achieved grace between people with different allegiances rather than a representation of a state of constant goodwill in the country as a whole’ (1995a: 194). Here, art attempts to redress, in its own way, the polarities of the political. As he puts it, the frontier between different forms of knowledge, or politics, or ideology ‘is for crossing’ (1995a: 203); and it is in the interstices of the weft caused by these polysemic crossings that the searches for answers are conducted. He develops this point in Finders Keepers:
26
Seamus Heaney
the poem went on to play with the notion of separation, of two sides of the march drain being like the two sides of the divided community of Northern Ireland – two sides divided by the way they pray, for example, and in little subtle but real ways…by the way they speak. The poem, however, ended up suggesting that a crossing could be attempted, that stepping stones could be placed by individuals who wanted to further things. (2002: 57) These stepping stones (and we will discuss this image at greater length in Chapter 6), served as points of liminality which allowed access to different influences; they formed a type of fluid border crossing or frontier. The notion of the frontier also figures in his collection The Haw Lantern, where a poem entitled ‘From the Frontier of Writing’ ‘evokes all the emotions entailed in the experience of oppression and also finds in that experience an analogue for the growth of conscience and consciousness’ (Tobin 1998: 231). This poem, which explores the connection ‘between the real and the written, experience and its representation’ (Molino 1994: 191), is structurally formal, with four tercets describing a physical roadblock which then becomes transposed into a metaphor for the power of writing to transform the contextual conditions that brought it into being originally. He speaks of the ‘tightness and nilness’ round the ‘space’ as the troops ‘inspect’ the ‘make and number’ of the car, and also notes that ‘everything is pure interrogation’ before he is freed to go on his way (Heaney 1987: 6). The political context of this poem, the experience of being stopped at a military roadblock is balanced by four ‘almost identical tercets’ in which ‘the poet is self-halted’ (Vendler 1998: 115) at the frontier of writing. Perhaps the most important aspect of this poem is the notion of ‘pure interrogation’, as it is only through an ongoing self-questioning of the self by the other that any form of ethical role for poetry can be fully set out. The second part of the poem features the poet self-consciously writing about the experience of the first part, and Heaney has spoken of the poem’s thematic imperative in an interview with Thomas Foster, an imperative which focuses specifically on the notions of borders and frontiers: There’s a poem called ‘From the Frontier of Writing,’ which uses an encounter at a roadblock, a kind of archetypal, Ulster, Catholic situation. It turns it into a parable for the inquisition and escape and freedom implicit in a certain kind of lyric poem. You know,
Heaney’s Prose
27
you cross the bar and you’re free into that other region. I would say that the American experience may have confirmed and assisted what I think always happens anyway as you get towards your fifties, that is a certain rethinking of yourself, a certain distance from your first self. (Foster 1989: 132–3) For Heaney, writing has become an activity which is governed by a self-questioning, a sense of recognising the context that is creative of much of the self, yet which can also be transformed by the recreated text of the self: ‘And suddenly you’re through, arraigned yet freed.’ He sees art as at least offering ‘a vision of possible order and harmony’ (Mathews 1997: 164). Interestingly, in the context of a reading of Heaney’s work predicated on his ongoing searches for answers, the trope of a journey is a strong connective between the experience of the roadblock ‘guarded unconcerned acceleration’ and the aesthetic recreation of that experience ‘the black current of a tarmac road’ (Heaney 1987: 6). As Henry Hart tellingly observes, Heaney’s ‘inclusionary strategies ultimately indict the exclusionary ones being practiced around him’ (Hart 1992: 187), and it is to these inclusionary strategies, which see frontiers or borders as liminal areas where different strands of identity can be interrogated and transformed that I now turn.
2
‘Continuous Adjudication’: Binary Oppositions and the Field of Force
If the searches for answers to Heaney’s preoccupying questions are to be posed with any degree of consistency, then the notion of poetry qua poetry must be explored. His complication of the anastomosis between ‘text’ and ‘context’, already discussed in the introduction, is a pointer towards the type of knowledge which he will see poetry as possessing and projecting. In the title essay of The Government of the Tongue, Heaney cites the critic C. K. Stead, in conjunction with Osip Mandelstam, in terms of their criticism of the ‘purveyors of ready-made meaning’, and he goes on to talk about a verse ‘like a metrical piston, designed to hammer sentiment or argument’ into its readers. Such a poetics, with a ‘strong horse-power of commonsense meaning’ (1988: 91) is not what Heaney has in mind when he is speaking about poetry, or attempting to set out some form of ars poetica. As he puts it in The Redress of Poetry, poetry has to be ‘a working model of inclusive consciousness. It should not simplify’ (1995a: 8). One can also bring into the equation the work of Maurice Blanchot in this context. Blanchot sees one of the seminal functions of literature as literature as being that of interrogation of the norm: ‘Let us suppose that literature begins at the moment when literature becomes a question’ (1981: 21), and Heaney will go on to question some of the most central givens of his culture in his ongoing search for answers. Perhaps the verb is more significant than the noun in this phrase as it is the search, the process, as opposed to the answers, the product, that will concern us. As Blanchot observes, commenting on the imperative to write, the writer must: ‘start immediately, and, whatever the circumstances without further scruples about beginning, means or end, proceed to action’ (1981: 24). This is because, like Heaney, he feels that poetry is in essence a matter of contradiction, an ‘extreme intensity of mysteries, interrogations and oppositions’ (1995: 123). Indeed simplification is the antithesis of what Heaney sees as the force of poetry, both in terms of writing and reading. If poetry is to be of value, he notes, it must avoid the ‘consensus and settlement of 28
Binary Oppositions and the Field of Force
29
a meaning which the audience fastens on like a security blanket’ (1988: 122). The problem with such a view of poetry is that the very complexity and ambiguity that are part of the force of poetry are denied and etiolated. If he is to find any answers to those initial questions in Preoccupations, dealing with how a poet should ‘properly live and write’ and analysing his relationship to ‘his own voice, his own place, his literary heritage and his contemporary world’ (1980: 13), then he must set out some theory of how poetry works. Hence, in this chapter, we will look in more detail at points already adduced in the introduction. If the ‘security blanket’ of a consensual meaning is seen as something to be avoided, perhaps the best way to proceed is not by throwing off the blanket altogether, but instead, to examine more closely the weft and weave of the textile of the blanket in order to bring out the intersections, joins and interfusions that create the blanket in question. Indeed, one is reminded of Declan Kiberd’s concluding image in Inventing Ireland, wherein he speaks of the ‘green flag’ that once had been wrapped around Cathleen Ni Houlihan being replaced by: ‘a quilt of many patches and colours, all beautiful, all distinct yet all connected too. No one element should subordinate or assimilate others: Irish or English, rural or urban, Gaelic or Anglo, each has its part in the pattern’ (Kiberd 1995: 653). This is also true of Heaney’s own writing, as in both poetry and prose, he probes the nature and epistemology of poetry itself. In Death of a Naturalist, and Door into the Dark, there are poems about ‘silent tradesmen’ which are intended as ‘models for the poet: as he celebrates them, so they in turn guide and sanction his craft’ (Morrison 1982: 31). The transforming effect of poetry on language, identity and perception is analogous to the transformations wrought by these figures in their own world. Hence in ‘The Diviner’, the moment when water is discovered is imaged in strongly verbal terms: ‘Spring water suddenly broadcasting / Through a green aerial its secret stations’ (1966: 36), while in ‘Thatcher’, as the silent thatcher puts on a new thatched roof, he is seen as ‘pinning down his world’, and stitching together the different pieces of straw into a ‘sloped honeycomb’, leaving his audience ‘gaping at his Midas touch’ (1969: 20). In ‘Churning Day’, the notion of art as transforming reality is again an important trope, as ‘gold flecks / began to dance’, and the raw materials become ‘coagulated sunlight’ (1966: 21). The poetic subtext is foregrounded by the butter being compared, in the final section of the poem, to ‘soft printed slabs’ (1966: 22).1
30
Seamus Heaney
Here, the seeming opposition between reality and representation, or between the non-literary and the literary is interrogated by the craftsmen as poetic archetypes. It is not that these are seen as ‘folksy’ but rather that they participate in the field of force within which poetry is operative. At no stage is poetry seen as in some way removed from the world; instead, its mode of operation is transformative in that it changes our perception of that world. All of the active subjects in these seemingly simple poems are operative within their environment, and responsible for significant developments and changes therein. This is a paradigm which will be further developed as Heaney’s art develops. As in his seminal poem ‘Digging’, where spade and pen become analogues of each other, a revisioning of action is at stake, and the dichotomy between physical and intellectual labour, while not subsumed, nevertheless is encompassed within a new structure where the perspective has changed, and the binarism is recontextualised within a more fluid structure, like Kiberd’s woven patchwork quilt. In terms of such a weave, the mode of its creation is that of a loom with a shuttle which moves back and forth creating the solidity of the blanket through the intermeshing of the skeins of threads. This metaphor is relevant to Heaney’s own theoretical processes as in his earlier writing, the dialectical cut and thrust of poetry is a major theme. In Preoccupations, for example, one of the main discursive strategies that Heaney undertakes in his discussion of texts or their socio-political contexts, is the uncovering of binary oppositions.2 Much of Heaney’s thought revolves around such dualisms and binarisms. Writing about different types of poetry, he speaks of masculine and feminine strains (1980: 34), and later he divides the activity up into craft and technique (1980: 47). Still later, speaking of the work of Wordsworth and Yeats, he invokes Valéry’s definition of two kinds of poetry, les vers donnés and les vers calculés (1980: 61), and he goes on to contrast the poetry of Wordsworth and Yeats in terms of the binaries of ‘complaisance’ and ‘control’ (1980: 71). Writing about Ireland, and the political situation in Ulster, he uses a similar vocabulary, seeing Ireland as associated with the feminine and England with the masculine. He also sees the tension between poetry which is ‘secret and natural’ and the world in which it must make its way ‘that is public and brutal’, and notes the opposition between the ‘old vortex of racial and religious instinct’ and ‘the mean of humane love and reason’ (1980: 34). In Heaney’s poetry, such structures also inhere: one thinks of the bipartite divisions in Wintering Out, North,
Binary Oppositions and the Field of Force
31
Seeing Things, and Electric Light; of the Greek/Trojan binarism in The Cure at Troy, of the Irish/English binarisms of Beowulf, of the pagan/Christian conflict in Sweeney Astray, of the north/south binarisms that feature in Field Work and of the general tendency to look at different sides of an issue: ‘Two buckets were easier carried than one / I grew up in between’ (1987: 5). Neil Corcoran, speaking of these, notes what he calls a ‘tendency to over-schematic or even specious binary thinking’ (1986: 230), and seems to see it as a type of defect in Heaney’s writing. Possibly because such binarisms call to mind the work of Derrida, Corcoran is inclined to see them as negative, given his placement of Heaney’s prose in the mould of New Criticism, which in turn, he sees as descending from Romanticism. In this vein, he goes on to deplore Heaney’s occasional use of terms such as ‘empowered’, ‘heuristic’ and transgressive’ seeing them as in some way a dilution of the ‘individuality of Heaney’s critical lexicon’ (1986: 228).3 For Corcoran, Heaney’s ‘critical consciousness of Wordsworth makes his basic conceptions of poetry essentially Romantic ones’ (1986: 229).4 To take this standpoint is to attenuate the complexity of Heaney’s own poetic epistemology. It is also to deny Heaney’s work as part of the theorising of literary studies that was coterminous with Heaney’s own education in literature and his writing career. The influence of structuralist and poststructuralist theory, with its overt use of examinations of cognitive, linguistic and societal structures in terms of binary oppositions, has clearly been operative in Heaney’s own mindset. Instead of locating him in terms of the new critics, it would seem more valuable to see him as participative in the theoretical project of re-envisaging the role of literature in terms of political and ethical effects. Heaney’s binarisms, far from being overschematic, instead attempt to give value to the alterity of experience, and of poetic experience in particular. Corcoran, by attempting to place Heaney’s writing in a Romantic–New Critical paradigm as opposed to a Modernist–Postmodernist one, misses the interaction of these binarisms that is so important to the structure of Heaney’s thinking. For Heaney, the notion of poetry as a mode of knowledge is one which partakes of multiple perspectives, as evidenced in his polyglossic enunciation of different voices in North.5 To write about the experience of Northern Ireland, without succumbing to sectarian atavism is, of necessity, to inhabit some form of binarism. Such binarisms however, are used dynamically and constructively, as opposed to statically, to create the complex
32
Seamus Heaney
weave of interconnections and intersections which are the results of his searches for answers. This becomes clear when we look at the primal binarisms that define Northern Ireland – Catholic and Protestant; nationalist and unionist; republican and loyalist; Irish and British; green and orange – and examine how these are treated in the Heaney aesthetic. He has given us an educative insight into the development of this type of thought-process which highlights the dynamic oscillatory structure that defines his transformative notions of dialectical knowledge. To put it another way, what Corcoran is describing may be imagined as the security blanket which was adduced earlier in our discussion; a simple covering device with little complexity attached, on first sight. However, Heaney will demonstrate that, on closer inspection, this woven material is comprised of numerous criss-crossings and intersections of threads which face in different directions, processes analogous to the complexities of dialectical thought. In Among Schoolchildren6 Heaney spoke about a great-aunt of his, Catherine Bradley, and about an example of her school needlework, from 1843. This included the following verse, embroidered on her ‘sampler’: Ireland as she ought to be Great glorious and free First flower of the earth First gem of the sea. (1983a: 6) The embroidery beneath this verse was of a shamrock, the traditional symbol of Ireland, but ‘squeezed to the right of the verse’ were the words ‘God Save the Queen’ (1983a: 6). Here the prevalence of binarisms in Heaney’s thought is embodied on a piece of Ulster linen. Is the imperative here, stressing how Ireland ‘ought’ to be, inclining to the notion of being free of British influence, as signified by the shamrock, or else of being free as part of the union between Great Britain and Ireland, as signified by the rubric ‘God Save the Queen’? Throughout this pamphlet, and in Place and Displacement, Heaney stresses the bifurcation of ideologies and identities that have marked his growth. From learning about Jane Austen, Tennyson and Lawrence and from attending sherry parties at the house of a professor in Queen’s University who hailed from Oxford,7 to acting with the Bellaghy Dramatic Society, and playing the parts of a United Irishman and Robert Emmett (1983a: 7),8 we see someone who is
Binary Oppositions and the Field of Force
33
being influenced by both the Irish and British aspects of Ulster culture. In many cases, such binarisms were expressed in antagonistic tones of self and other, or us and them. For Heaney, as he puts it, the exposure to aspects of both cultures, brought about an uncertainty in terms of cultural and ideological identification.9 The physical oscillation between weekly exposure to English literature, ‘the elegances of Oscar Wilde and the profundities of Shakespeare’ and the weekend, with its religious devotions in the chapel, and acting as fear a’ tigh at the GAA ceilidhs10 has its psychical and identificatory effect in a number of questions which are broadly coterminous with those preoccupying questions with which we began our discussion. Heaney asks: Was I two persons or one? Was I extending myself or breaking myself apart? Was I being led out or led away? Was I failing to live up to the aspiring literary intellectual effort when I was at home, was I betraying the culture of the parish when I was at the university? (1983a: 8) In this discussion, Heaney is probing the conditions of subjectivity and identity, as the ‘I’ of the poem is caught between different forces which must, of necessity, change and alter it. As Derrida has pointed out, all subjects are imbricated in this play of signification: Nothing – no present and in-different being – thus precedes différance and spacing. There is no subject who is agent, author, and master of différance, who eventually and empirically would be overtaken by différance. Subjectivity – like objectivity – is an effect of différance, an effect inscribed in a system of différance. (Derrida 1981a: 28) For Derrida, the subject is constituted in language by this ‘economy of traces’ (1981a: 29), and he goes on to say that the economic aspect of différance confirms that the speaking subject is constituted by the division from itself, through the movement of différance, in language, and to agree with Saussure that language, which consists only of differences, ‘is not a function of the speaking subject’ (Derrida 1981a: 29). Heaney, by his exposure to different linguistic and cultural discourses, feels himself pulled in different directions, and finds that the seeming core of his identity has become fractured.
34
Seamus Heaney
Given the linguistic context of this sense of fracture in subjectivity, it would seem that language can also be the vehicle where such a sense of fracture can be seen as positive, allowing for development and change within the parameters of identity. The differential aspects of language and meaning, the lack of teleology in discourse, is what is being explored by Heaney, and this locates his work within the postmodern and poststructuralist paradigms in terms of a wariness about the referentiality of language: as Jacques Lacan has observed that ‘we are forced, then, to accept the notion of an incessant sliding of the signified under the signifier’ (Lacan 1977: 154). Hence, there is strong theoretical warrant for Heaney’s musings on the different traces of his origins and modes of identity. This view of the poet as being situated within a linguistic and social matrix has important implications for textual study, implications that have been summarised by Roland Barthes when he sees texts as sites of hermeneutic intersection rather than the release of a single ‘theological’ meaning (Barthes 1979, in Lodge 1988: 170). The ‘I’ (and here, there are major implications for the lyric ‘I’), stands at the axis of signifier and signified, a split being, never able to give its position a full presence. The unconscious play with meaning is revealed, according to Freudian and Lacanian theory, in dreams, jokes and art. The subject of the enounced is never fully able to stand in for the subject of the enunciation who in turn is never able to give full, conscious expression to him or herself through language. Heaney’s interrogations of subjectivity and language are very much in keeping with this theme of the creation of subjectivity through language. The preconditions which set up this questioning are defined in terms of spatial and temporal oscillations. Temporally, he spent the weekdays of term at Queen’s University studying English literature and becoming enculturated into the middle-class, literary, cultured ethos that is signified by ‘sherry parties on the Malone Road’. At ‘weekends and during the holidays’ he was immersed in Catholic, rural, Gaelic, nationalist social and cultural mores. Spatially, he oscillated between city and country, Belfast and Bellaghy, the academy and the parish. This physical movement, constituted in time and space, serves as a paradigm for the psychical and cognitive motion of what I term Heaney’s epistemology of poetry. It informs statements which see the poet as being ‘displaced from a confidence in a single position by his disposition to be affected by all positions, negatively rather than positively capable’ (1985a: 8) as transgressive in terms of experiential knowledge and epistemological paradigm.
Binary Oppositions and the Field of Force
35
In terms of temporal and spatial movements in different directions, there is an immediate similarity between Heaney’s psychic and cultural subjective bifurcation, and Derrida’s notion (and neologism) of différance. Derrida has coined this term, substituting an ‘a’ for the second ‘e’ of ‘difference’, to explain what he sees as the deconstruction of meaning in terms of a simple self-presence. His point is that, in any system, the meaning of each individual element is neither unified nor self-present. Instead, it is created through a twin process of differentiation from other elements and a deferral until some point of closure. For example, in the practice of reading, the meaning of any one term is different from the others, and deferred until the end of a clause, or of a sentence, or of a paragraph or of a book. As Derrida puts it, ‘no element can function as a sign without referring to another element which itself is not simply present’; hence this interweaving results in each element being constituted ‘on the basis of the trace within it of the other elements of the chain or system’ (1981a: 26). The ‘a’ in différance denotes the temporal and spatial dimensions of the term which are so similar to Heaney’s oscillation, what Derrida terms ‘différance as temporisation, différance as spacing’ (1982: 9). It is obvious that such a process is analogous to what is being described by Heaney in his description of being pulled in different directions in terms of seeking cultural norms of meaning. The difference between Belfast and Bellaghy is enunciated in spatial and temporal vectors; the persona of Heaney himself is being created by the differential pulls of both, as well as by a constant process of deferral in terms of a final flash of self-present knowledge. The opposing forces were taking him in different directions, but were also setting down the parameters of a cognitive structure which comes close to that of différance. Geoffrey Bennington makes the point that différance, if thought of as a force, can only be seen in terms of the ‘tension between at least two forces’ (Bennington and Derrida 1993: 82). In Heaney’s case, it is the differential interaction between the forces signified by Belfast and Bellaghy that help to form his notions of poetry as a cognitive structure which is capable of including different forces. When we come to examine his notion of poetry as a field of force, we will see that this field is analogous to Derrida’s suggestion that when speaking of the different terms of an identity, be that of the self, or of a culture, then ‘each of the terms must appear as the différance of the other, as the other different and deferred in the economy of the same’ (1982: 17). In terms of
36
Seamus Heaney
Corcoran’s discussion of the binary oppositions in Heaney’s writing, what is becoming clear is that a deconstructive position is being introduced wherein the binary oppositions themselves are less important than the process of their interaction, an interaction that will become transformative of the context within which these oppositions exist. Such identificatory oscillations and bifurcations are also definitive in terms of Derrida’s notion of selfhood, living in Algeria, but speaking French, and, as the following passage will indicate, this constitutes a further connection between the thought of both of these writers. Derrida, while living in Algeria, learned French as his only language and yet was acutely aware that ‘all of this came from a history and a milieu that were not in a simple and primitive way mine’ (Derrida 1995: 120). Derrida’s notions of différance, and his breaking down of seeming unities and totalities, has much in common with Heaney’s view of poetry as the articulation of different forces within some form of structure which can reveal more aspects of the self to the self. In this sense, Heaney’s cultural hybridity has definite similarities with that of Derrida. Derrida’s sense of alienation from the given matrix of identity: ‘the Frenchman of France was an other’ (1995: 204) has much in common with Heaney’s view of being led out or led away. In The Other Heading, Derrida speaks of himself as someone ‘not quite European by birth’ (1992b: 7), and goes on to pose the question as to whether one is ‘more faithful to the heritage of a culture by cultivating the difference-to-oneself (with oneself) that constitutes identity’ (1992b: 11). In a passage that is remarkably similar, Heaney too speaks of feelings of strangeness and alienation in connection with place and language. Writing in Preoccupations he points out that he has maintained a notion of himself ‘as Irish in a province that insists it is British’ (1980: 35), and goes on to further underscore his sense of difference in the following statement: I speak and write in English, but do not altogether share the preoccupations and perspectives of an Englishman. I teach English literature, I publish in London, but the English tradition is not ultimately home. I live off another hump as well. (1980: 34) Here, we see the similar sense of the Unheimlich invading the seeming certainties of the Heimlich. Both writers inhabit a liminal space which
Binary Oppositions and the Field of Force
37
allows them to see difference, rather than sameness, as a criterion of definition in terms of notions of singular and communal identity. Both writers, in other words, have taken a physical progression, Heaney from County Derry to Belfast, and Derrida from Algeria to France, with its attendant cultural problematics, and transformed it into a cognitive dialectical epistemology of identity. This progression from physical movement to dialectical cognition is a feature of ‘Digging’, the opening poem of Death of a Naturalist and the first poem where he felt his ‘feelings had got into words’ (1980: 41). Here the experiential practice of digging into earth becomes transformed into an epistemological paradigm of an artesian imagination as well as of an unearthing of new experiences through the process of upturning the givens of the surface so as to create ‘opened ground’, in terms of ideas and worldviews.11 In other words, rather than seeing the act of writing as merely descriptive of the actuality of experience, both Heaney and Derrida instead see writing as creative of the contexts of that experience. This poem also signifies the importance of a particular relationship with memory in Heaney’s writing. Hence, his dialectical relationship is the defining factor in his epistemology of poetry in that it allows him to set up transformative and transgressive structures which he sees as answering his own complex position in terms of the knowledge or truth-claims of poetry. That Heaney figures his growth to maturity in this lecture through such binary oppositions does not place him as some sort of proto-deconstructionist, nor does it presage some form of ‘reading by numbers’ schematicisation of experience.12 Instead, such binarisms, as we will see, are part of a dialectical mode of thought which is ethical in its mode of operation. To be affected by all positions is to acquire some form of negative knowledge inasmuch as one can see that neither position has a monopoly on truth or right, and also that one has some form of ethical responsibility to this other; it involves a responsibility to the thought of the other. It also involves an ongoing process of critique, what John D. Caputo calls a questioning dialogue of homologia by heterologia (1993: 113).13 Ethics, in the sense of the word as used by Emmanuel Levinas, envisions a sense of responsibility to the other, to forms of alterity which are outside the self, as a primary facet of human discourse.14 Derrida has made the point, in Of Spirit, that the origin of language is responsibility (1989a: 132) in the sense that to speak is to speak to someone else, to assume a responsibility of addressing some other person. In a binary opposition, something is defined in terms of the
38
Seamus Heaney
other, and as such, can be placed in an ethical context by taking note of the differences and connections between self and other. It is what Heaney terms the notion of ‘needing to accommodate two opposing notions of truthfulness simultaneously’ (1985: 4), the very condition which has been emblematically rendered in Catherine Bradley’s embroidery sampler, where ‘two value systems, which now explode daily, are lodged like dormant munitions’ on one piece of Ulster linen (1983a: 6). I would suggest that Heaney’s writing will dislodge these positions so as to bring out the etymological senses of ‘munition’ as a fortification (‘munitio-onis’) and as ammunition, but also its cognate term ‘muniment’, meaning a document entailing rights or privileges. Two sets of fortified rights and privileges are exactly what is signified by the shamrock and the slogan on the sampler, and both have munimental designs on the notion of ‘Ulster’ in that piece of Ulster linen. By dislodging these fortifications, Heaney is, symbolically, bringing these documents into dialectical interaction. It is worth keeping in mind that the term ‘dialectic’ originates from the Greek ‘dialektos’, meaning discourse or conversation. The verb διαλεγοηαι (dialegomai) means ‘to converse’, but δια (dia) means ‘through’, or ‘against’ or ‘because of’, and λεγο (lego) means ‘to speak’, so there is another oscillation set up etymologically. The sampler is a mimetic example of this process in Heaney’s epistemology of writing, as he sets up an oscillation between the two positions found on this piece of Ulster linen, an oscillation which parallels his physical oscillation, and which will allow these sets of rights and privileges to ‘speak through’ or ‘speak against’ or ‘speak because of’ each other in a structure which embodies what we have already seen of différance. The proper adjective ‘Ulster’ is significant here. In Place and Displacement: Recent Poetry in Northern Ireland,15 delivered in 1984, Heaney makes it clear that to be a writer in Ulster is to be very much in two minds, to be ‘in two places at once’, to be aware that he or she belongs to a place ‘that is patently riven between notions of belonging to other places’ (1985: 4). This view of place as inhabited by oppositions pulling in different directions puts an obligation, or responsibility, on the writer to delineate the positions – ideological, social, political and cultural – of his or her own grouping (self), as well as that of the ‘other’, in a place where the whole population are adepts in the ‘mystery of living in two places at one time’ (1995a: 190). To define the identificatory parameters, the muniments, of each group is not as simple as it might first seem, as there are complex
Binary Oppositions and the Field of Force
39
equations and intersections which are both mutually exclusive and at the same time, mutually intertwined. These notions form parts of the weave that his dialectical mentalité will outline. Ulster, as he notes, is just such a complex series of threads in this weave. As he puts it, the nationalist will ‘wince at the Union Jack and “God Save the Queen” as tokens of his place in the world’, but for the unionist, with whom the nationalist conducts his daily life, these emblems have ‘pious and passionate force’ (1985: 4).16 Heaney goes on to demonstrate the further complex imbrications and dualities of identity in Northern Ireland: The fountainhead of the Unionist’s myth, springs in the Crown of England, but he has to hold his own in the island of Ireland. The fountainhead of the Nationalist’s myth lies in the idea of an integral Ireland, but he too lives in an exile from his ideal place. Yet while he has to concede that he is a citizen of the partitioned British state, the Nationalist can hold to the physical fact of his presence upon the Irish island, just as the Unionist can affirm the reality of political realm of the United Kingdom even as he recognises the geographical fact that Ireland is his insular home.17 (1985: 5) Here we do not see Corcoran’s notion of schematic binaries at work; instead we see the careful delineation of a complex series of oppositions which are placed in an evolving structure which attempts to set up some form of dialectical conversation between them. There is a careful weighing of the nuances of each position, seen in terms of its similarity with the other side of the equation. As Hans-Georg Gadamer puts it, the presence of the other ‘before whom we stand helps to break up our own bias and narrowness’ (1981: 26), and this can be seen as part of Heaney’s searches for answers. There is no attenuation of either position here; both sets of oppositions are placed within a structure which allows them to interrogate each other. Simon Critchley has argued that there is a ‘duty’ in Derrida’s terms, to produce a reading that commands respect insofar as it opens an ‘irreducible dimension of alterity’ (1992: 41), and I would suggest that Heaney’s thought is aimed at achieving such a respect for alterity. His binary oppositions invariably interact and intersect so as to create some form of text or structure wherein they can mutually inform each other. This is not to say that Heaney is setting out to create some post-Hegelian synthesis which will ‘lure the tribal shoals to
40
Seamus Heaney
epigram / And order’ (1975: 59). As we have already seen, in both his reading of the genre of pastorality and of the multiform notions of identity in Northern Ireland, he realises that such simplicity of synthesis is just not possible, given the many layers and levels which construct the complex weave which dialectical shuttling sets up. The many layers interact at different levels as they attempt to give figuration to the different interstices as nodal points in the delineation of the knowledge that poetry, and the reading of poetry, can bring to bear on issues of life and art. Hence, his readings of poetry and of notions of identity, share the same complex structurations, and strive to produce an epistemology of poetry which does justice to the complexity and ethicity that are central to its operation. In his poetry, this probing of the structurations of meaning has been a constitutive strand from the beginning. In ‘Alphabets’, in The Haw Lantern, Heaney has traced the progression from reality to representation in terms of a sign-producing function, beginning with his father making a shadow ‘like a rabbit’s head’ with his ‘joined hands’, and with the letters of the alphabet being compared to objects from his early known world:18 Then draws the forked stick that they call a Y. This is writing. A swan’s neck and swan’s back Make the 2 he can see now as well as say. Two rafters and a cross-tie on the slate Are the letters some call ah, some call ay. (1987: 1) The pre-given nature of these signs, the seeming naturalness of their adequation with the known world is gradually deconstructed as the poem progresses. Different writing systems – Gaelic, Latin, Greek, Merovingian – take their place within his developing consciousness, inscribing their differential structures within his sense of self, and further broadening the field of force which becomes the ‘I’ of the poem. Whereas at the beginning, systems of signification were seen in terms of the experientially familiar, by the end of the poem, the familiar objects of his home are now envisaged through the signsystems which have been part of his education: Balers drop bales like printouts where stooked sheaves Make lambdas on the stubble once at harvest And the delta face of each potato pit. (1987: 3)
Binary Oppositions and the Field of Force
41
By the end of the poem, the notion that our selfhood is predicated by our language and systems of discourse is made explicit as an astronaut is seen as looking back at the earth from space in terms of its being an ‘aqueous, singular, lucent O’ (1987: 3). Here, there is a desire to escape from the binary logic through some form of contextual framework which foregrounds the arbitrariness of language and the constructedness of reality and ideology. Historically, Heaney’s preoccupation with binaries and dualities can be traced back to formative poetic and rhythmic experiences, which he discusses in Preoccupations. In Mossbawn, he points out the different types of poetry that influenced him, beginning with rhymes from his schooldays featuring a character called Neddy McGuigan or Dirty-Faced McGuigan who ‘pissed in the Quigan / The Quigan was hot / So he pissed in the pot’, as well as more ideologically centred rhymes: ‘Up the long ladder and down the short rope / To hell with King Billy and God bless the Pope’ (the answer to this being ‘Up with King William and down with the Pope’) (1980: 25). Here, the sectarian divide is captured in what might be termed subcultural poetry, but interestingly both traditions are set down together. Indeed, the rhythmic and prosodic similarity of the two couplets sees both traditions as placed in a mutually defining, if antagonistic, structure, with King William being defined in contradistinction to the Pope, and vice versa. The same mutuality of definition is clear from the other two poems quoted, one suggesting that ‘Paypishes’ (Catholics) should be ‘cut in two’ with the answering verse suggesting that it is ‘red, white and blue’ which should be ‘torn up in two’ (1980: 25). This type of oppositional writing is also found in early stages of Heaney’s work, as in ‘Docker’, where the eponymous Protestant worker (‘The only Roman collar he tolerates / Smiles all round his sleek pint of porter’) is seen as violently opposed to his other: ‘That fist would drop a hammer on a Catholic’ (1966: 41). The same perspective is clear in ‘Orange Drums, Tyrone 1966’, where self and other are conflictually defined, with the lambeg drum, an instrument traditionally associated with Protestant celebrations of William of Orange’s victory in the Battle of the Boyne in 1690. In this poem, as in the rhymes being discussed, there is little complication or interrogation; instead the other is defined in terms redolent of evil and disease: It is the drums preside, like giant tumours. To every cocked ear, expert in its greed, His battered signature subscribes ‘No Pope’. (1972: 68)
42
Seamus Heaney
The binary perspective is writ large in this poem, with the image chain leaving no room for any interaction or intersection between selfhood and alterity. We seem to be back in the weave of Catherine Bradley’s sampler here, with the binarisms being sketched out in bold lines of difference, and the memory of the poet oscillating between them. In this case, we might, perhaps, agree with Corcoran’s criticism of the flatness of the binary opposition, and the overschematic nature of the verses. Here, there seems to be no sense of dialectical interaction between the two. This is because these rhymes are separate from the present tense of the voice of the essay. The ‘I’ describing these poems is not involved in any of them; they are remembered from a distance, and serve as signifiers of a childish sense of rhyme, which merely enunciates the sense of the group to which the rhymester belonged. There is no sense of responsibility or adjudication between the positions; each set of rhymes delineates the security blanket of each tradition. To recall an earlier comment from The Redress of Poetry, this type of poetry is not ‘a working model of inclusive consciousness’; here, this type of poetry does simplify; self is self, other is other and there can be no middle ground between them. In an essay entitled ‘Christmas, 1971’, a more complex interaction is foregrounded by the voice of the poet himself as the locus of the interaction. Writing about the role of the artist in the face of the political confrontation in Belfast in 1971,19 Heaney again sees the situation in terms of binaries, but now, we see a far more dynamic structure of thought, as well as a more ethical concern with the correctness of the choices being made. He says that he is ‘fatigued by a continuous adjudication between agony and injustice, swung at one moment by the long tail of race and resentment, at another by the more acceptable feelings of pity and terror’ (1980: 30). Here, the physicality of the original oscillation between cultural and ideological poles is restated in the verb of motion ‘swung’; the poet is struggling to control these forces of ‘race and resentment’ as opposed to those of ‘pity and terror’, as they swing him from one to the other, giving him little chance to pause in a space between. Perhaps the most important words in this passage are ‘continuous adjudication’. The interaction of active and passive voices in this passage outlines the complexity of the struggle that is ongoing within the culture, and within the poet. There are two levels involved here, both of which reflect back on each other. Firstly, he is involved in continually adjudicating between agony and injustice, and the nature
Binary Oppositions and the Field of Force
43
of the stated weariness is that while attempting to exercise the cognitive faculty of judgement, he is also (and here we see the second level) being ‘swung’ by events over which he seems to have no control, the external political and violent actions which occurred in Belfast in 1971. That the adjudication here is continuous would imply that the terms are never finally defined, in contradistinction to the perspective of ‘Docker’ or ‘Orange Drums, Tyrone 1966’. An example of the poetic exemplification of this paradigm is to be found in one of Heaney’s later translations, The Midnight Verdict. In this poem, Heaney demonstrates how differential and fluid his notions of selfhood are. Speaking about the impulse to translate, he notes: The three translations included here were all part of a single impulse. ‘Orpheus and Eurydice’ was done in June 1993, just before I began to prepare a lecture on Cúirt an Mheán Oíche (1780) for the Merriman Summer School. Then, in order to get to closer grips with the original, I started to put bits of the Irish into couplets and, in doing so, gradually came to think of the Merriman poem in relation to the story of Orpheus, and in particular the story of his death as related by Ovid. The end of The Midnight Court took on a new resonance when read within the acoustic of the classical myth, and this gave me the idea of juxtaposing the Irish poem (however drastically abridged) with the relevant passages from Ovid’s Metamorphoses. (2000a: 11) In this case, the notion of a poetry that should not simplify is the imperative behind this fluid structure. Structurally the book is a triptych, with Ovid framing the two sections from Merriman, a structure he first used in Field Work in the poem entitled ‘Triptych’, and the fluidity of the interaction between Greek and Irish myths is synecdochic of the mature Heaney’s notion of art as a field of force which can contain oppositional and parallel structures. Just as in ‘Alphabets’, different structures of signification became part of the selfhood of the ‘I’ of the poem, so now, different cultural myths serve to locate atavisms and oppositions within a broader context. The importance of this structure, highlighted by the adjective ‘continuous’ in the term ‘continuous adjudication’, is that it is fluid, dialectical and transformative. It is the relational intersubjectivity of these structures that makes them paradigmatic of Heaney’s concept of the force of writing in general, and of poetry in particular.
44
Seamus Heaney
At a further level of discourse, the atavisms which are ratified by a group consciousness, those of race and resentment, are placed in a binary opposition with those of pity and terror, terms which also have a literary resonance. The terms ‘pity’ and ‘terror’ are, of course, part of Aristotle’s definition of tragedy in his Poetics,20 but they are also to be found in James Joyce’s A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man. In the fifth chapter, Stephen tells Lynch that: ‘Aristotle has not defined pity and terror. I have.’ He goes on: Pity is the feeling which arrests the mind in the presence of whatsoever is grave and constant in human sufferings and unites it with the human sufferer. Terror is the feeling which arrests the mind in the presence of whatsoever is grave and constant in human sufferings and unites it with the secret cause. (1916: 178) Hence, Heaney’s continuous adjudication is a multiform complex process, adjudicating between different political, ideological and ethical choices, while at the same time, adjudicating between the different fields of force of ‘pity and terror’. Hence there is a question as to whether he is speaking about pity for victims and terror in the face of atrocities, or whether he is speaking about the Joycean aesthetic categories that Stephen is torturously working out, and their role within the context of Belfast in 1971? Is it possible that the ‘secret cause’ of which Stephen speaks is what Heaney, in Kinship, refers to as the ‘appetites of gravity’ (1975: 43), namely an unadjudicated yielding to the gravitational pull of the tail of race and resentment? Perhaps the terror here is that he feels the racial resentment overcoming the emotions of pity for victims who are not part of his own group. Is there here the dawning of the consciousness that, at some level, he is part of a group, of a ‘we’ or ‘us’ for whom the ‘other’ will always be a focus of our terror but never a recipient of our pity?: And you, Tacitus… report us fairly, how we slaughter for the common good and shave the heads of the notorious, how the goddess swallows our love and terror. (1975: 45)
Binary Oppositions and the Field of Force
45
For the voice of this poem, there is no process of adjudication, continuous or otherwise; here there is complete symphysis between agony, injustice, race, resentment and terror on the part of the ‘I’ of the poem, with possibly Tacitus providing some degree of pity.21 The organic figuration of these emotions, in a nexus of bloodsacrifice to a personified notion of the land, is hardly accidental, as many theories of race stem from an anthropomorphisation of characteristics and places so as to construct a mythos of the self.22 Heaney’s metaphor of being ‘swung’ by the ‘long tail’ represents the atavistic, visceral emotions that were rife in Belfast at this time. Members of Heaney’s own community were slaughtering for the ‘common good’, even as he was writing, and this internecine violence, itself both caused by, and creative of, a binary opposition, foregrounded questions about the nature and function of art. The issue under adjudication appears to be that seminal preoccupying question: ‘how should a poet properly live and write?’ in such times (1980: 13); an issue which, in its probing of the relationship between politics and aesthetics, reminds us of the earlier anastomosis between text and context. The etymology of ‘adjudicate’ helps to clarify the issue at this point. Stemming from the Latin ‘judicare’, the original composite was ‘jus’ (law) and ‘dicere’ (to say), the word highlights Heaney’s difficulty in continually attempting to ‘say the law’ of proper aesthetic, ethical and political action in the face of a violent contemporary context.23 Of necessity, such adjudication will be dialectical, it will create a locus for the enunciation of the concerns of self and other without necessarily succumbing to the atavisms of either group. As he puts it, the locating of one’s identity in ‘the ethnic and liturgical habits of one’s group’ is all very well, but for that group to ‘confine the range of one’s growth, to have one’s sympathies determined and one’s responses programmed’ by that group, is clearly a ‘form of entrapment’ (1985: 6–7), an entrapment whose consequences are enunciated clearly in the lines already cited from Kinship, and whose prevalence is clear from the ‘swung by the tail’ metaphor, as individuals become trapped in ideological atavisms. His adjudication on this issue is first spoken in an essay aptly entitled ‘Feeling into Words’, where he teases out the different roles of a poet who is attempting to ‘properly live and write’. He points to a crucial period, when the ‘original heraldic murderous encounter between Protestant yeoman and Catholic rebel’24 was ‘initiated again’ in the Summer of 1969, in Belfast.25 In this context, the epistemology
46
Seamus Heaney
of the texts of poetry became clear and consisted of becoming a ‘search for images and symbols adequate to our predicament’ (1980: 56). The performative nature of this activity, a ‘search’ as opposed to a destination, resonates with his original ‘searches for answers’, and is qualified directly in terms of what such symbols and images should not be: I do not mean liberal lamentation that citizens should feel compelled to murder one another or deploy their different military arms over the matter of nomenclatures such as British or Irish. I do not mean public celebrations or execrations of resistance or atrocity – although there is nothing necessarily unpoetic about such a celebration, if one thinks of Yeats’s ‘Easter 1916’.26 (1980: 56) The difficulty Heaney has with both of these epistemological positions is that they both demand a suspension of the faculty of adjudication, and of the notion of searches for some form of intersubjective truth. In both of the above positions, poetry is very much in the service of the actual; it functions as, at best, reportage, and at worst, as a sort of poetic licence for the barbarities of sectarian hatred. In the first of these, poetry is attenuated in that it must maintain the note of lamentation which precludes any spontaneous joy or creativity on the part of the writer. As Heaney puts it in The Government of the Tongue: ‘art does not trace the given map of a better reality but improvises an inspired sketch of it’ (1988: 94). Liberal lamentation is of necessity, post factum, it is dependent on the actual material situation of politics and violence. In this sense, it is mimetic of one of the meanings Heaney suggests for his resonant title The Government of the Tongue, where the tongue is governed by the quotidian, where one is told to govern one’s tongue, with the implication of a ‘denial of the tongue’s autonomy and permission’. Here, ironically, liberal lamentation, a lamentation that seems to achieve a position of transcendence with respect to the sectarian atavisms of race and resentment, actually allows such atavisms to dictate the nature of such liberal discourse. For a poet or writer, such an epistemology can leave poetry in a ‘relatively underprivileged situation, requiring it to take a position that is secondary to religious truth or state security or public order’ (1988: 96). As we have seen in the introduction, such simplifications of writing and reading are the very attenuations that Heaney wishes to avoid, as they in no way facilitate any complex searches after answers.
Binary Oppositions and the Field of Force
47
This attenuated view of poetry suggests that answers must be in response to events, and hence, will be dictated by those events. Similarly, such a position excludes any mythological dimension to poetry. As Heaney demonstrated in North, an exploration of the mythos that underwrites sectarian constitutions of identity can be a powerful tool in the unpacking of such identities.27 He sees the role of writing as more than such an event-driven response which must be belated with respect to actuality. The second position with which he takes issue is that of poetry as a celebration or execration of resistance or atrocity. Such a position places the poet firmly within his or her group or mythos. Here the hortatory or execratory role of the poet consists in articulating the monological vision of the tribe or group, without any notion of different perspectives or different standpoints. This monocular vision, which is at the core of Kinship, is creative of the subjectivities of the group. It is a vision which achieves the entrapment of consciousness already noted, as the growth of the individual is canalised by the ethnic and liturgical vision of the group. Such a position of immanence removes any power of critique from the writer, and also attenuates the complexity of any political or identificatory conflict. It denies any notion of dialectical complexity in terms of the relationship of the ‘I’ to the ‘we’. Writing about the poetry of Osip Mandelstam, and the memoir of his life, Hope Abandoned, written by his wife Nadezhda, Heaney cites her views on the notion of the ‘we’, the community. She notes that the relationship between the ‘we’ and the ‘I’ is dialectical and fluid: ‘[t]o find its fulfilment, the “I” needs at least two complementary dimensions: “we” and – if it is fortunate – “you”’ (1988: 76). These dimensions external to the ‘I’ yet also connected to it, define a notion of subjectivity that is central to Heaney’s notion of the function of art. This notion is complex, transformational, and plural in its mode of action. As he has put it elsewhere, for him, ‘the “I” of the poem is at the eye of the storm within the “I” of the poet’ (1985: 4), and this dialectical interaction between the seeing eye, and the subject, the ‘I’, is what rings true about the ‘inspired sketch of reality’ already mentioned as the provenance of art. The causal anastomosis between ‘eye’ and ‘I’, between vision and subjectivity, signifies an important aspect of Heaney’s poetic epistemology. To see others, whether ‘we’ or ‘you’, and to take into account our relationship with them, is to embody an ethicity of writing wherein the otherness of the other is taken into account. For Heaney, this broadening of the subject is
48
Seamus Heaney
central to how poetry should achieve its aims and goals. In Gadamerian terms, it is the presence of the other which helps to ‘break up our own bias and narrowness’ (1981: 26). The narrowness of vision already mentioned is precisely what is being critiqued here. This monocular perspective is the antithesis of Heaney’s notion of how a poet should properly live and write.28 A single perspective will produce attenuated vision with the resultant attenuated subjectivities which can see slaughtering ‘for the common good’ as a defensible position. The creation of a complex and self-aware ‘I’ which is aware of its constituent givens but which is also conscious of the role of agency, is a crucial element in Heaney’s aesthetic. The importance of this complexity and plurality of vision that Heaney associates with poetry is underlined by his return to this image of the ‘I’ and the ‘eye’ in The Redress of Poetry. In an essay entitled ‘Joy or Night: Last Things in the Poetry of W. B. Yeats and Philip Larkin’, he is writing about Yeats’s poem The Cold Heaven, and sees in this poem a ‘sense of answerability, of responsibility’ and goes on to add that ‘the “I” of the poet as a first person singular, a selfknowing consciousness, is brilliantly and concretely at one with the eye of the poet as a retina overwhelmed by the visual evidence of infinity and solitude’ (1995a: 149). Here again, the conflation of the subject with vision is central to Heaney’s aesthetic epistemology. Answerability and responsibility to the other are central to his notion of the constitutive vision of poetry. This dialectic between ‘I’ and ‘eye’ is an example of the rhetorical figure of a metalepsis, the creation of an effect through a remote cause. For Heaney this metaleptic structure allows him to express the complexity of vision that poetry can bring about. As I have already noted, such an epistemology is the very antithesis of simplistic and attenuating notions of subjectivity. To ‘see’ is to see the other, to create the ‘I’ with these objects of vision in mind is to act ethically. In this sense, Heaney’s notion of art is broadly similar to that of Emmanuel Levinas who sees art as a ‘relation with the other’ (1989: 143), a position opposed to that of speaking exclusively for one’s own group. Such monocularity of vision which, in turn, leads to a monological notion of subjectivity, suspends his notion of adjudication, and instead allows the poet to be swung by the tail of racial hatred. Hence, Heaney’s denial of the validity of these two different methods of providing ‘images and symbols adequate to our predicament’ is an example of litotes in that through describing what these images and symbols should not be, he is gesturing very much
Binary Oppositions and the Field of Force
49
in the direction of what he sees as their correct mode of being. He agrees that there is a profound relation between ‘poetic technique’ and ‘historical situation’ (1985: 7). However, he refuses to allow the former to become either dependent on, or subservient to, the latter. Heaney’s epistemology of poetry will attempt to avoid these attenuations and entrapments, and I will quote the passage at length: I mean that I felt it imperative to discover a field of force in which, without abandoning fidelity to the processes and experience of poetry as I have outlined them, it would be possible to encompass the perspectives of a humane reason and at the same time to grant the religious intensity of the violence its deplorable authenticity and complexity. And when I say religious, I am not thinking simply of the sectarian division. To some extent the enmity can be viewed as a struggle between the cults and devotees of a god and a goddess. There is an indigenous territorial numen, a tutelar of the whole island, call her Mother Ireland, Cathleen Ni Houlihan, the poor old woman, the Shan Van Vocht, whatever; and her sovereignty has been temporarily usurped or infringed by a new male cult whose founding fathers were Cromwell, William of Orange and Edward Carson, and whose godhead is incarnate in a rex or Caesar resident in a palace in London. What we have is the tail-end of a struggle in a province between territorial piety and imperial power. (1980: 56–7) The term ‘field of force’ is interesting because it signifies a fluid, mobile structure which is composed of many interacting parts, and which posits the dialectical interaction of different forces. In physics, the term defines the space through which a force, or forces, operate, and clearly for Heaney, such a space is what constitutes the epistemological force of poetry. In this space, this force-field, he will encompass these two different forces, humane reason and religious intensity, and in some way cause them to co-exist, if not in harmony, at least in some form of structure which allows them to penetrate each other in some form of anastomosis which is specific to poetry as genre. Once again, the notion of movement, of forces operating and intersecting, is crucial here. Such a force-field, or constellation, to use another term of Adorno’s, borrowed from Benjamin,29 results in a dialectical process which constantly oscillates without ever reaching any Hegelian Aufhebung. This term, best understood in terms of Benjamin’s
50
Seamus Heaney
homology ‘ideas are to objects as constellations are to stars’ (1977: 34), allows for a non self-present form of identity, which can encompass different ideas and forces, just as a constellation can encompass many different stars. Keeping in mind the plural number involved in Heaney’s searches for answers to those preoccupying questions, it becomes clear that when some answers are found, they generate other questions and so the complexity of the process is constantly regenerated. In the context of the argument being put forward in this study, it is more than interesting that Derrida, too, has made use of this term ‘field of forces’ in a broadly similar context (1985: 168) in describing the multilayered nature of a text wherein different ideologies and perspectives co-exist in a creative tension. In Blanchot’s terms, such a structure is paradigmatic of what he terms the ‘space of literature’ in that different poles of oppositions are placed in a structure which sees them ‘quitting themselves and detaining each other together outside themselves in the restless unity of their common belonging’ (1982a: 200). For Heaney, this notion of space is especially important in the political context which frames much of his work. In an essay entitled ‘Cessation 1994’, he is writing about the conditions in Northern Ireland that predated the IRA ceasefire that was called on 31 August 1994. He recalls the ‘early days of political ferment in the late sixties’ and also the ‘energy and confidence on the nationalist side’ and a concomitant ‘developing liberalism – as well as the usual obstinacy and reaction – on the unionist side’, and goes on to say that the ‘border was becoming more pervious than it had been’ (2002: 45). One of the more significant memories he recalls is his own participation in an artistic initiative, and particularly significant is the name given to this enterprise in the context of our discussion: I remember in particular feeling empowered…by a week on the road with David Hammond and Michael Longley in May 1968 when we brought a programme of songs and poems to schools and hotels and libraries in unionist and nationalist areas all over Northern Ireland. The programme was called ‘Room to Rhyme’ and I thought about it again last Wednesday. (2002: 45) Here the space of literature becomes actual in both the programme of activities and in its title. The sense of movement across Northern Ireland, through both communities, as well as the notion of this movement creating, literally, a space for literature, is highly symbolic
Binary Oppositions and the Field of Force
51
in the light of Heaney’s searches for answers to those central preoccupying questions. The creation of a space for poetry allows poetry the chance to become operative within the community and also to attempt to transform that community through its particular usage of language, at both the level of the signifier and that of the signified. What this ‘room’ managed to achieve was a place, or space, for some recognition of an Irish dimension within the official culture of Northern Ireland. There is no sense of a return of the repressed here, as was found in the ongoing IRA campaign; rather there is a sense of a more complex understanding of the dynamic that is created by the interaction of both traditions within this room to write, or the space of literature. As Heaney puts it: Which is to say that ‘diversity’ is beginning to be recognised and to find its expression long before it became a buzz word. Small changes of attitude, small rapprochements and readjustments were being made. Minimal shifts in different areas – artistic, educational, political – were beginning to effect new contacts and new concessions. The fact that I felt free to read a poem about the 1798 rebels to a rather staid audience of middle-class unionists was one such small symptom of a new tolerance. (2002: 46) The role of the arts in the creation of this more diverse climate of feeling should not be underestimated. In retrospect, Heaney can see that small changes, often at the level of the individual, are the building blocks of what can become seismic shifts, if given enough time and enough space. The activity of reading poems to diverse audiences is in no way seen as creative of the climactic moment, in 1994, when the IRA ceasefire was called. However, what was achieved in this ‘Room to Rhyme’ was the opening an opportunity for plurality and this is precisely the point made at the close of this essay: The cessation of violence is an opportunity to open a space – and not just in the political arena but in the first level of each person’s consciousness – a space where hope can grow. And I mean hope in the sense that Vaclav Havel has defined it, because it seems to me that his definition has the kind of stoical clarity that should appeal to every realist in the north, Planter or Gael, Protestant or Catholic, optimist or pessimist. Hope, according to Havel, is different from optimism. It is a state of the soul rather than a
52
Seamus Heaney
response to the evidence. It is not the expectation that things will turn out successfully but the conviction that something is worth working for, however it turns out. Its deepest roots are in the transcendental, beyond the horizon. (2002: 47) Thus, when, in The Cure at Troy, we hear that oft-quoted phrase from the chorus that: once in a lifetime The longed-for tidal wave Of justice can rise up, And hope and history rhyme. (1990: 77) It is this Havelian perspective that is being promulgated. In this context, the space of literature, the room to rhyme, the field of force, the complexity that is created by poetry, all cohere in the sense that they provide an opportunity to work for the values of humanity and understanding despite the chaos that is going on around them. The shape of his field of force, or constellation, is hinted at in his essay on Osip Mandelstam, where he cites approvingly Mandelstam’s notion of the purity of poetry as being like making Brussels lace, an activity which involves ‘real work’ but whose ‘major components, those supporting the design, are air, perforations and truancy’ (Heaney 1988: 84). Here, the dialectic of presence and absence, the importance of the shadow as well as the substance, are stressed. The similarity with Derrida’s articulation of all communication being achieved through différance and the trace is clear. Derrida sees language as functioning through an ‘economy of traces’, and in an interview with Julia Kristeva, goes on to explain his view of a ‘new concept of writing’ wherein ‘no element can function as a sign without referring to another element which itself is not simply present’. In other words, the elements of the system are structurally dependent on elements which are never ‘simply present or absent’, and are the results of an interweaving between presence and absence. It is this ‘interweaving, this textile’, which produces the ‘text’ (Derrida 1981a: 26). It is ironic that, via Derrida, we are now back in the realm of Catherine Bradley’s sampler, and the oscillatory imagery of the loom as it creates the Ulster linen of her sampler. As already noted, this is far from the security blanket of oversimplistic meaning; this weaving, this text(ile) is redolent of the original anastomosis discussed in the introduction, namely that of text and context.
Binary Oppositions and the Field of Force
53
The transformative potential of such a weaving is signalled in ‘Markings’ in Seeing Things. This poem describes a childhood football game with ‘four jackets for four goalposts’, and goes on to describe this very physical experience, with a transformative moment occurring in the second stanza of the opening section, as the light died, the children kept on playing because ‘by then they were playing in their heads’. As he notes: Some limit had been passed, There was fleetness, furtherance, untiredness In time that was extra, unforeseen and free. (Heaney 1991: 8) The interweaving of actuality and imagination is clear at this point as a physical experience is internalised and seen as a paradigm for the process of imagination. The self, in this poem, becomes that field of force of which Heaney has been speaking: All these things entered you As if they were both the door and what came through it. They marked the spot, marked time and held it open. (1991: 9) The idea of the self as being both the entrance for alterity and in a way now composed of that same alterity is crucial here. Self is now that entity wherein limits can be passed, and new aspects of identity created through the entrance of ‘all these things’. The self, as field of force open to different influences and transformed by these influences, is what is being both explored and at the same time created in this poetic text. Indeed, the similarity of Derrida’s notion of text with Heaney’s constellatory ‘field of force’ is striking. Both writers see meaning as constructed in terms of a dialectic of presence and absence, and they both conceive of a ‘text’ as constructed of a weave of differences. Derrida gives the name ‘trace’ to the part played by the radically other within the structure of difference that is language. This, Gayatri Spivak notes, can be called an economy – ‘not a reconciliation of opposites, but rather a maintaining of disjunction. Identity constituted by difference is economy’ (1976: xlii). Hence, Heaney’s appropriation of Mandelstam’s Brussels lace metaphor describes a similar economy in that what is present is supported by ‘air, perforations and truancy’. It is in the interstices of this economy, this field
54
Seamus Heaney
of force, the places where different forces intersect, that Heaney sees the force of poetry. Much of his later poetry is suffused with such imagery, and with suggestions that the epistemology of poetry is best understood in terms of its enunciation of such elements in a field of force. Hence, Heaney will attempt to create a force-field, a constellation, a textcontext anastomosis in his later poetry as he constantly strives to avoid simplification and instead offer a model of a developed consciousness. Through the use of vastly different contexts, the consciousness, the ‘I’ of the poem, gradually develops intertextually. In ‘The Golden Bough’, Heaney translates form Virgil’s Aeneid, and invokes the chants of the ‘Sibyl of Cumae’ who made the cave echo with ‘sayings where clear truths and mysteries / Were inextricably twined’ (1991: 1). The idea that truth is a construct made up of interacting texts is one which would seem to be drawn from his earlier experiences – it is a construct wherein binary oppositions are fused in a structure which concentrates on the ‘twining’ of ‘truths’ and ‘mysteries’. Similarly in ‘The Point’, there is a field of force created between the child playing football and the ball itself in his description of the game: ‘Was it you // or the ball that kept going / beyond you’ (1991: 10), as memory blurs subject and object into a complex image of process. This point is also made in ‘The Pulse’, the second poem from ‘Three Drawings’, poems about fishing, where he speaks of ‘pure duration’ to describe the ‘effortlessness / of a spinning reel’, before going on to describe the image of the fisherman in terms of a fusion of image and shadow, light and reflection, person and water: Then after all of that Runaway give, you were glad When you reeled in and found Yourself strung, heel-tip To rod-tip, into the river’s Steady purchase and thrum. (1991: 11) The third image of this triptych, itself emblematic of the concept of the field of force and structure of tension of which we have been speaking, ‘A Haul’, describes a new context for the fishing trope, reverting to the Norse mythology of North, and recalling Thor’s and Hymer’s fishing for ‘the world-serpent itself’. In this context, the escape of the serpent and the resultant loss of the ‘haul’ resulted in
Binary Oppositions and the Field of Force
55
a surprising sense of plenitude as Thor ‘felt at one with space’, and this state is seen in simile as reminiscent of ‘some fabulous highcatcher / coming down without the ball’ (1991: 12). Process and activity are seen as the desirable factors here, creating a field of force or economy where self-definition is due to the interaction with the world, as opposed to a sense of imposition of selfhood on the world. The following poem advances the fishing motif as a meta-trope on the purpose and function of poetry. Such a trope has a history in an Irish literary context, as it stems from Yeats’s programmatic poem ‘The Fisherman’, wherein the power of poetry to encapsulate different forms and emotions is central to its thematic development. Yeats concludes this poem by telling of how he will address all of his work to this imaginary audience: A man who does not exist, A man who is but a dream: And cried, ‘Before I am old I shall have written him one Poem maybe as cold And passionate as the dawn.’ (Yeats 1979: 167) Heaney is also using the technique of fishing, a casting into otherness and a tenuous connection with that which is outside the self, as an image of the fluid and transforming nature of poetry. Given our concern with the idea of binary oppositions, and with the desire to create structures which, as Derrida also implies, can alter and allow these to interact differentially within a new context, this poem is highly significant. In his poem, dedicated to another poet, Ted Hughes, Heaney speaks of different sounds which ‘took side’, clearly indicating different forces in a debate or argument. Both sides of this binary opposition are voiced in the poem, personified as fishermen with different styles of casting: one whose cast went ‘whispering’ while in the case of the other ‘a sharp ratcheting went on and on’. Both then voice conflicting opinions, with the ‘I’ of the poem torn between them, as one says ‘Watch it! Be severe’ while the other says: ‘Go with it! Give and swerve. / You are everything you feel beside the river’. Here would seem to be a locus classicus of the binary oppositions of which we have been speaking, with the subject of the poem being torn between the conflicting perspectives. However, the final stanza of the poem functions metapoetically in its creation of
56
Seamus Heaney
a fluid structure which encompasses both perspectives in a way which makes the ‘I’ of the poem more complex and thoughtful through his exposure (not a term used innocently) to the different voices: I love hushed air. I trust contrariness. Years and years go past and I do not move For I see that when one man casts, the other gathers And then vice versa, without changing sides. (1991: 13) In a manner that recalls Catherine Bradley’s sampler, the poem gestures towards that inclusivity of consciousness that Heaney has come to valorise as part of the function of the aesthetic in society. The poem creates an economy in the sense already defined by Spivak: it is a not a reconciliation of opposites, but rather a maintaining of disjunction. Identity constituted by difference is such an economy. Time and again, Heaney’s poems are creative of these fields of force wherein different strands are woven together in structures which are transformative of actuality ‘Who ever saw / The limit in the given anyhow?’ (1991: 46). This Kraftfeldt is imagined again and again in his writing as he tries to capture structures which will allow for the different aspects of opposition but which will, at the same time, transform them through dynamic interaction. So, in the aptly titled ‘Wheels within Wheels’, speaking of pedalling a ‘bike’ by hand as it was turned ‘upside down’, and specifically of the spinning wheel, he creates just such a transformative structure: I loved the disappearance of the spokes, The way the space between the hub and rim Hummed with transparency. (1991: 46) Here, through a process, the elements, brought into dynamic interaction, become altered and almost transparent. Such developments at the level of the individual consciousness, are what poetry can achieve. In ‘Weighing In’, in The Spirit Level, the same sense of oppositional interaction and a notion of flux is conveyed: ‘and everything trembled, flowed with give and take’ (1996: 17). Indeed, the very title of this volume inscribes a sense of balance and adjustment to the pulls of different forces in an attempt to maintain some form of equilibrium: ‘only as long as the balance holds’ (1996: 18). This sense that the individual who has been exposed to the aesthetic can
Binary Oppositions and the Field of Force
57
become more complex and more reactive to external forces is a constant of Heaney’s work, but especially of his later work. Thus in ‘Postscript’, he can say: ‘You are neither here not there, / A hurry through which known and strange things pass’ (1996: 70), and can make the parallel point in ‘Tollund’ that he can feel ‘footloose, at home beyond the tribe’ (1996: 67), a line which immediately complicates notions of identity and home as well as almost casually suggesting that personal identity need not be trammelled by that of the tribe or the group. He is interweaving different aspects of his heritage, language and history into a new context, a context which is also operative within his own oeuvre, as the title ‘Tollund’ refers analeptically to ‘The Tollund Man’, while the quoted line about being at home beyond the tribe, echoes one of his most emblematic early lines: ‘lost, unhappy and at home’ (1972: 48). Here, in terms of the altered context, Heaney can progress his ‘continuous adjudication’, and be both beyond the tribe and at home, a point which is almost a contradiction of the imperative that drives the voice of the tribe in ‘The Tollund Man’ where there was massive identification between the self and the group consciousness, what Sidney Burris terms the reconciliation of ‘Republican dreams with the realities of occupation’ (1990: 90). His initial connection with this bog figure was his similarity with aspects of Heaney’s personal and Irish past: ‘he looks like an ancestor’ (Haffenden 1981: 57). However, in the present poem, a totally altered context speaks, not of mythic connections which valorise some form of originary myth of presence, but instead he now sees the place as ‘hallucinatory and familiar’, and instead of foregrounding the mythic connections, now talks about ‘light traffic’ in a discourse of normalisation, a discourse which is progressed by his juxtaposition of a ‘scarecrow’ and a ‘satellite dish’. As a paradigm of his ongoing contextualisation of oppositions within new structures, this poem exemplifies how Heaney creates his differential structures. Gesturing towards the mythopoeic impulses of ‘The Tollund Man’, Heaney goes on to describe a symbol of Iron Age Denmark in ‘Tollund’ in a manner replete with postmodern irony: The scarecrow’s arms Stood open opposite the satellite
58
Seamus Heaney
Dish in the paddock, where a standing stone Had been resituated and landscaped, With tourist signs in futhark runic script In Danish and in English. Things had moved on. (1996: 69) He is writing of the present, a present in which the past has become commodified in terms of its tourist potential. Brooding mythic imagery of sacrificial bog victims, and what Peter McDonald sees as one of the seminal tropes of Northern Irish poetry, the ‘the attractions, and liabilities, of “home”’ (1997: 114) have been consigned to the past, a past which can be reified and ‘resituated’ like the ‘standing stone’ and which is no longer a driving force within the present: things had ‘moved on’. The continuous adjudication between past and present has resulted in this most fluid of poems, a poem which decentres the placename ‘Tollund’ and instead makes it more of a spectral entity, as those who walk ‘abroad’ there are like ‘ghosts’ ready to make ‘a new beginning’ (Heaney 1996: 69). In ‘The Swing’, the close of the poem embodies this dialectical interaction between the demands of history and the developing complexity of an individual response to those demands. Describing the swing which he used as a child, the poem closes as follows: We all learned one by one to go sky high. Then townlands vanished into aerodromes, Hiroshima made light of human bones, Concorde’s web migrated towards the future. So who were we to want to hang back there In spite of all? In spite of all, we sailed Beyond ourselves and over and above The rafters aching in our shoulderblades, The give and take of branches in our arms. (1996: 49) The notion of the aesthetic as a means of sailing ‘beyond ourselves’ is one which Heaney probes throughout his work. Whereas the binaries that initiated his continuous adjudication are historically contextualised, he is now able to transcend these by placing them in a constellation, and by talking on the complexities of both sides through a form of exposure of self to other and vice versa. It is
Binary Oppositions and the Field of Force
59
through the interweaving of the historical and the personal, an interweaving flagged by the anadiplosis of the lines: In spite of all? In spite of all, we sailed Beyond ourselves that this is brought about.30 Here, the semantic sequence is that of question and answer: the fact that the question is verbally identical to the answer symbolises the complexity of the issues that are at stake, when an individual interacts with the societal and historical. For Heaney, such complexity is part of the structure and function of poetry. As he puts it in ‘The Redress of Poetry’, the work of George Herbert can symbolise what he calls: ‘fully realised poetry’, a poetry where: ‘the co-ordinates of the imagined thing correspond to and allow us to contemplate the complex burden of our own existence’ (1995a: 10). The value of Herbert’s mind, for Heaney, is that he is able to take the binary oppositions of his culture, and Heaney cites a number of these: ‘creator/creature, heaven/earth, soul/body, eternity/time, life/death, Christ/man, grace/guilt, virtue/sin, divine love/courtly love’ (1995a: 10) and offer them to ‘structural animation’. As Heaney puts it: What might be called the DNA pattern of Herbert’s imagination is fundamentally a matter of up-down, criss-cross motion, reversals effected with such symmetry that they are experienced as culminations, tensions so thoroughly exercised and traced home that they return the system to relaxation, dialogues so sinuous that they end with speakers ready to start again, sometimes from diametrically opposed premises. (1995a: 10) This, I would suggest, is paradigmatic of Heaney’s structural sense: a constellation, a force-field, a dynamic and balanced process wherein the self is made more complex. In the next chapter a further dimension of his epistemology will be examined, a dimension wherein the transformative aspects of poetry become the focus of our attention.
3
‘Writing in the Sand’: Poetry and Transformation
In the title essay of The Government of the Tongue, Heaney is discussing the ‘paradox of poetry and of the imaginative arts in general’ (1988: 107) and muses on the efficacy of poetry. He says in one sense, the efficacy is ‘nil – no lyric has ever stopped a tank’; however, in another sense he sees its efficacy as ‘unlimited’ and goes on to cite the metaphor of Jesus’ writing in the sand – ‘in the face of which accusers and accused are left speechless and renewed’ – as an example of the status or force of poetry. Quoting from Chapter Eight of John’s Gospel, he cites Jesus’ writing, in the face of the scribes and Pharisees who were accusing the woman caught in adultery. He sees poetry as analogous to this writing, a ‘break with the usual life but not an absconding from it’ (1988: 108). This notion of a break brings us back to the interstices of the field of force, those airy truancies of Brussels lace which were just as important as the designs which they supported. In terms redolent of Derrida’s notions of difference and the trace, Heaney speaks of the epistemology of poetry as paralleling the writing in the sand, a process which is ephemeral in the extreme. As he puts it, poetry does not promise a solution to either ‘accusing crowd’ or ‘helpless accused’: Instead, in the rift between what is going to happen and whatever we would wish to happen, poetry holds attention for a space, functions not as distraction but as pure concentration, a focus where our power to concentrate is concentrated back on ourselves. This is what gives poetry its governing power. At its greatest moments it would attempt, in Yeats’s phrase, to hold in a single thought reality and justice. (1988: 108) Here we see different but parallel statements about the field of force. Poetry can be the space through which reality and justice can operate, not overtly in the political sphere, but in terms of influencing the writer and the reader; he goes on to describe poetry as ‘more a threshold than a path’ and sees it as one which is ‘constantly approached and constantly departed from’, and which 60
Poetry and Transformation
61
affects reader and writer by the experience of being ‘at the same time summoned and released’ (1988: 108). The oscillatory nature of this dialectical movement demonstrates the complexity of the forces acting on both reader and writer. Indeed, Bernard O’Donoghue makes the telling point that this book ‘remains intent on thresholds and crossings throughout its formally very different parts’, citing the title of the Dante translation, ‘Crossings’, as emblematic of the book itself (1994: 120). The importance of this Yeatsian example for Heaney is further underscored by its use in The Redress of Poetry.1 Once again, it features in a discussion wherein Heaney is stressing the force of poetry and its epistemological nature, and once again, this is expressed in a dialectical modus agendi. He cites the original location of this quote, the introduction to A Vision, where Yeats notes that his ‘systems’ while at times deemed by him to be ‘taken literally’, are now seen as ‘stylistic arrangements of experience’, comparable to the cubes of Wyndham Lewis and the ovoids of Brancusi which have ‘helped him to hold in a single thought reality and justice’ (Heaney 1995a: 150).2 Heaney goes on to juxtapose this with a quotation from Lady Dorothy Wellesley’s recollection of a conversation with Yeats on the topic of life after death. After a colloquy on his beliefs, she wryly commented that he seemed to be coming very close to a Roman Catholic position, whereupon Yeats’s retort was ‘a splendid laugh’ (Heaney 1995a: 150–1).3 For Heaney this laugh is an expression of a ‘frame of mind which allowed the venturesomeness of a supernatural faith to coexist with a rigorously sceptical attitude’ (1995a: 151), and he goes on to exfoliate this Yeatsian notion of poetry in a series of oscillatory metaphors. He sees the laugh as the ‘comic expression of a tragic perception’, and goes on to cite Richard Ellmann’s view that Yeats had perceived of the possibility that ‘reality was desolation and justice a figment’, a perception imaged by Ellmann in terms of life as a cornucopia being undermined by the notion of life as an empty shell.4 For Heaney it is this dialectical ability to encompass these notions of faith and scepticism, comedy and tragedy, immanence and transcendence that makes Yeats a great poet. As he puts it, it is because of Yeats’s ‘fidelity to both perceptions and his refusal to foreclose on either that we recognise in him a poet of the highest attainment’ (1995a: 151). It is the fluidity and complexity of this Yeatsian constellatory structure that Heaney admires. The possibility that the writing in
62
Seamus Heaney
the sand will last only until the next gust of wind is the necessary context out of which the text of hope and affirmation can be achieved, if only briefly. In Heaney’s own writing, we see a repetition and an invocation of this dialectical Kraftfeldt in his introductory essay to The Government of the Tongue. Writing about ‘The Interesting Case of Nero, Chekhov’s Cognac and a Knocker’,5 he demonstrates the value of his field of force in terms of its emancipatory power, and here he evinces a far more confident belief in the force of poetry as being able to achieve some form of effect on an individual consciousness. He is speaking of the ‘achievement of a poem’ which he sees as a sense of release, and of how, when the lyric achieves its ‘buoyant completion’ and the ‘timeless formal pleasure comes to fullness and exhaustion’ there occurs in the writer something which is ‘equidistant from self-justification and self-obliteration’, and this sense of release and momentary stasis is expressed in terms of the eponymous title of the collection. The ‘tongue, governed for so long in the social sphere’ (and he uses the phrase ‘by nice obeisance to one’s origin within the minority or the majority’, a phrase that has particular, though not exclusive, resonances with Northern Ireland), is ‘suddenly ungoverned’ as it gains access to a condition that is ‘unconstrained’ and while ‘not being practically effective, is not necessarily inefficacious’ (1988: xxii). In this instance, we see the mode of thought which allows Heaney, like Yeats, to hold two emotions in one cognition. The epistemology of poetry is described in terms of the oscillating binarism that we noted in Catherine Bradley’s sampler, and in the metaphor of Brussels lace, with its dialectical series of interstices and weavings. As Heaney put it in the first Yeatsian citation, poetry is more of a threshold which is constantly approached and departed from, as both reader and writer undergo the experience of being ‘at the same time summoned and released’ (1988: 108). Heaney’s epistemology of poetry focuses on the dialectical forces of space and time, presence and absence, movement and stasis, in an attempt to delineate the transgressive and transformative effects of poetry, if not on the body politic, then certainly on the body individual, the individuated consciousness which is seeking those answers to preoccupying questions. In the space created by poetry between what is going to happen and what we would like to happen, between the actual and the desired, it focuses our attention on ourselves. Ultimately, as already noted in terms of the relationship between the ‘I’, the ‘you’ and the ‘we’, poetry creates a dialectical questioning of the ‘I’ by
Poetry and Transformation
63
the ‘I’; it allows our ‘power to concentrate’, to be ‘concentrated back on ourselves’ (1988: 108). In his ‘writing in the sand’ metaphor, Heaney discusses the efficacy of such activity; on the one hand, he sees that poetry doesn’t stop tanks; on the other, it may alter the mindset that is sending in those tanks. Ironically, it is the very ephemerality of poetry, the writing in the sand, that gives it any sense of lasting force, it is ‘the imagination pressing back against the pressure of reality’ (1995a: 1). However, the force is microcosmic as opposed to macrocosmic; it has no direct effect on the political, but it has the effect of altering the individual consciousness of both writer and reader. In terms of the relationship between writing and politics, he sees the ‘purely poetic force of words’ as ‘the guarantee of a commitment which need not apologise for not taking up the cudgels since it is raising a baton to attune discords which the cudgels are creating’ (1985: 7). We have come a long way from Corcoran’s notion of overschematic or specious binary thinking. Instead we see the complicated construction of the field of force, the constellation, the economy, all of which describe the epistemology of poetry in terms of the creation of a space wherein and where through different forces can operate. This Kraftfeldt can be traced back to the spatial and temporal oscillation already adduced in this chapter: it is a cognitive transformation of a physical progression, and the notion of movement is seminal to Heaney’s epistemology of poetry. As we have seen, there is a clear relationship between poetry and reality; it is the nature of this relationship that Heaney puts in question. He is unwilling to see poetry as merely a reflection of a preordained reality as this would negate the imaginative and creative aspect of art. As he puts it: ‘when a rhyme surprises and extends the fixed relations between words, that in itself protests against necessity’ (1995a: 158). In terms of the issues under discussion in this chapter, namely the scope and nature of Heaney’s epistemology of poetry, the verbs in this phrase are telling. Rhyme is seen as a force which is transformative of the ‘fixed’ relationships between words, a point which can serve as a synecdoche of Heaney’s view of the force of poetry in general: ‘it is essential that the vision of reality that poetry offers should be transformative, more than just a printout of the given circumstances of its time and place’ (1995a: 159). Time and time again, this trope surfaces in Heaney’s writing as he describes the transformation of reality within the individual con-
64
Seamus Heaney
sciousness. When speaking of sliding on ice, he describes the sensation as being like: A farewell to surefootedness, a pitch Beyond our usual hold upon ourselves. (1991: 86) Once again, the transformation of selfhood is the key to this image, and by extension, to the imperatives underlying so much of his writing. It is through some form of transfiguration of the actual that poetry achieves it epistemological goal, and this transfiguration must occur at the level of the individual, be it reader or writer, as opposed to the societal or communal. Through the new relationships between points of fixity (once again, we are transported back to the weave of Catherine Bradley’s sampler of Ulster linen, with its oscillation between the shamrock and emblem), individuals are encouraged to reattune their consciousness, to be ‘forwarded’ within themselves. What he means by this is that in the most illuminating poetry what is at work is the mind’s capacity to ‘conceive a new plane of regard for itself, a new scope for its own activity’ (1995a: 160). This new plane has a relationship with the actual, but is in no way governed by it, and it also has the ability to encompass different forces within its field of force, and to posit answers, in some way, to the questions raised by the actual.6 In terms of these answers, we need look no further than Heaney’s specific discussion of the role of poetry as an answering, the title essay in The Redress of Poetry. Here the notion of redress encompasses the dialectical field of force which, I have argued, is the shape of Heaney’s epistemology of poetry. In the introduction to this book,7 Heaney stresses the notion of poetry as capable of encompassing different perspectives, a point which is by now a sine qua non of his view of poetry. Describing a poem by George Herbert, and one of his own works from ‘Squarings’,8 Heaney notes that both works are about ‘the way consciousness can be alive to two different and contradictory dimensions of reality and still find a way of negotiating between them’ (1995a: xiii). This notion of negotiating is precisely what is meant by his comment that rhyme ‘surprises and extends’ the fixed relationships between words, and it is with this transgressive aspect of his field of force that our discussion of his aesthetic will conclude. To revert back to Corcoran’s point, Heaney’s binary thinking necessitates some form of connection between the binarisms, and this
Poetry and Transformation
65
connection will in some way change the relationship between them, at least in the consciousness of writer and reader. In Poem VIII of ‘Lightenings’, Heaney speaks of a ship appearing in the air while the monks of the medieval monastery of Clonmacnoise were ‘at prayer’. The air seemed to be the proper element of this ship, as an anchor was dropped which ‘hooked itself into the altar rails’ (1991: 62) and paradoxically, a crewman who ‘shinnied’ down the rope was in danger of drowning in air unless he was released back to the ship. The monks duly released the anchor and the crewman ‘climbed back / Out of the marvellous as he had known it’ (1991: 62). Here notions of the marvellous and of safety are predicated on the different perspectives from which one comes; in the poem air is both marvellous and dangerous, as, by implication is water. Heaney’s aim here is to affirm that: Within our individual selves we can reconcile two orders of knowledge which we might call the practical and the poetic; to affirm also that each form of knowledge redresses the other and that the frontier between them is there for the crossing. (1995a: 203) This idea of crossings and transfers between different positions and epistemologies is also shared by Derrida who notes that texts are usually approached through the metaphor of a type of translation and goes on to speak about the ‘procession of one language into another’ and the resulting movement of this procession ‘over the border of another language, into the language of the other’ (1987: 77). I would suggest that both writers, while examining the context of binary oppositions on which much of Western thought is predicated, take the additional step of setting in motion a complex structure wherein these binary oppositions are rendered dynamic, and the focus will be on their intersubjective relationship and the dynamics of that relationship as opposed to the elements of the binary opposition seen as static polar opposites. For example, earlier we discussed Heaney’s use, in Preoccupations, of masculine and feminine as synecdoches of different types of poetry, and of different types of socio-cultural identity. However in a following essay, he strives to find an answering shape which will set up some kind of transformative dynamic between the two. He finds this in the poetry of Hopkins, whose poems were conceived as ‘the crossing of masculine strain on feminine potential’ (Heaney 1980: 95), and he also finds a shape for part of his field of force,
66
Seamus Heaney
noting that ‘the Church fathers perceived the sign of the cross in the figure of a man and woman splayed’ (1980: 97). Here, a chiasmatic pattern of reversal and transformation is the terminus ad quem towards which Heaney’s binarisms are directed, a point noted in the previous chapter with respect to the writing of Herbert, whose work contains ‘within itself the co-ordinates and contradictions of experience’ (Heaney 1995a: 12). A similar point can be made with reference to his earlier binary view of Ireland and England, as he attempts to see poetry as a constellation wherein both can be set in dialectical and transformative interchange: ‘I think of the personal and Irish pieties as vowels, and the literary awarenesses nourished on English as consonants. My hope is that the poems will be vocables adequate to my whole experience’ (1980: 37). The word ‘vocable’ usually refers to the form, as opposed to the meaning of a word, and has connotations of calling, deriving from ‘vocare’, meaning ‘to call’. Hence, he is striving for a new formal shape which can encompass the differing identities and forces with which he is dealing, and also, to initiate a calling to the other, to initiate a response to that call, and again, we are on familiar ground in terms of an adequation of the thought of Heaney and Derrida. In an interview with Richard Kearney in 1981, Derrida made the point that deconstruction is itself a ‘positive response to an alterity which necessarily calls, summons or motivates it…a response to a call’ (Derrida 1981c: 168). The ethical similarities are clear; both writers seek some forms or structures which facilitate dialogue with the other, and response to the call of the other. For Derrida, this structure is deconstruction; for Heaney it is poetry; for both, it is a structure which values the interplay of differences. Writing in ‘Structure Sign and Play in the Discourse of the Human Sciences’, Derrida stresses the double nature of deconstruction in a manner analogous to Heaney’s view of the complex structuration of poetry. Speaking about the ‘event’ that has taken place in the development of the study of structure, Derrida explains that the exterior form of this event would be ‘that of a rupture and a redoubling’ (1978: 278).9 The notion of a rupture followed by a redoubling is indicative of a more complex structure in terms of layers, as well as of the imperative to rebuild following the initial deconstruction. Heaney and Derrida both follow their interrogations of simplistic positions of identity and ideology by this very restructuration and redefinition of such positions.
Poetry and Transformation
67
Thus, in ‘Exposure’ in North, Heaney stresses, in litotes, that he is ‘neither internee nor informer’. Instead, he takes on the complex role of an ‘inner émigré’, one who is still part of his culture but existing at a physical ‘It is December in Wicklow’ (1975: 72), and existential ‘weighing / My responsible tristia’ (1975: 73) distance from it, taking on the persona of a ‘wood-kerne’, one who has crossed over from the old Gaelic order into the life of an outlaw. Embodying a movement away from simplistic identifications with singular ideological positions: ‘His gift like a slingstone / Whirled for the desperate’ (1975: 72), Heaney instead takes on a position similar to that of the earlier cited complex notion of selfhood in ‘Markings’, assuming the position of one who is capable of ‘feeling / Every wind that blows’ (1975: 73). This position is a recurring trope in his poetry, as he conflates different spatial, temporal and epistemological positions in an increasingly structured sense of selfhood: Strange how things in the offing, once they’re sensed, Convert to things foreknown; And how what’s come upon is manifest Only in light of what has been gone through. (1991: 108) He increasingly sites the ‘I’ of his poems in terms of being at a crossroads or intersection of different traditions: ‘I swim in Homer’ (1991: 36), and sees the desired role of the poetic persona as located in such points of intersection: Air and ocean known as antecedents Of each other. In apposition with Omnipresence, equilibrium, brim. (1991: 80) For Heaney, the balance and process of containing and encompassing different positions is clearly of central importance. The idea of a brim, border, margin or edge, as a teleological point is important especially in the context of the structure in which this poem appears. In Seeing Things, the second section of the book is comprised of a sequence entitled ‘Squarings’: In this sequence, each poem has the same shape: all are twelve lines long and divided into four versets of three lines each, a form which recalls the Dantean terza rima, without its interlinked rhyme
68
Seamus Heaney
scheme….There are four shorter sequences within the larger one: ‘Lightenings’, ‘Settings’, ‘Crossings’, and the concluding sequence ‘Squarings’ itself. Each of these contains twelve poems: so that the shape of the sequence as a whole is a kind of geometrical ‘squaring’: 4 x 12 x 12. (Corcoran 1986: 173–4) Hence fluidity of structure and transformative perspectives are central to this sequence, as both structurally and thematically, it embodies the notion of a field of force as envisaged by Heaney, Adorno and Derrida. Tobin suggests that the ethical function of such a sequence is clear from its insistence that ‘the created order of any world exists meaningfully only in relation to the world of the other’ (1998: 258), and it is this ongoing interfusion of differences that is at the core of this sequence, and indeed, of much of Heaney’s later work. At this juncture, I would transpose a comment of Henry Hart’s, on The Haw Lantern, where he notes that in this book, Heaney10 ‘negates age-old prejudices in order to affirm the productive interplay of differences’ (Hart 1992: 7), and sees it as more aptly applying to Heaney’s theory of poetry in general. The ‘productive interplay of differences’ is, it seems to me, Heaney’s methodology of achieving his searches for answers; to borrow a phrase from Augustine, of making truth (facere veritatem), of crossing over positions ‘out to another side’ (Heaney 1995a: xiii) so as to glean some notion of the other, in order to better inform and create one’s own sense of truth. Heaney has coined the term ‘the frontier of writing’ for this notion of poetry, and the ethical imperative that drives this idea of poetry as a crossing to the side of the other, and of being a connection as well as a point of difference between self and other, is very much in keeping with the central preoccupying question of how a poet should ‘properly’ live and write.11 The concept of borders is also stressed in Heaney’s essay ‘Something to Write Home About’, where he discusses memories of paddling in the Moyola river, and seeing an image of ‘Terminus, the god of boundaries’, and interestingly in the context of our discussion, he images this god in terms of space once again. The Romans kept an image of this god on Capitol Hill and the interesting point about this image is that ‘the roof above the image was open to the sky’: …as if to say that a god of the boundaries and borders of the earth needed to have access to the boundless, the whole unlimited height and width and depth of the heavens themselves. As if to say
Poetry and Transformation
69
that all boundaries are necessary evils and that the truly desirable condition is the feeling of being unbounded, of being king of infinite space. And it is that double capacity that we possess as human beings – the capacity to be attracted at one and the same time to the security of what is intimately known and the challenges and entrancements of what is beyond us – it is this double capacity that poetry springs from and addresses. (2002: 48) The connection of poetry with the desire to remain within our boundaries while at the same time wishing to transcend them, further strengthens his idea of the complexity that is created by poetic writing. The space of literature, in this case, is one wherein there is a lot of border traffic, and where the movement is an index of the doubleness of which he speaks. It is his way of working towards that regulative idea of an ‘infinite space’ where the bounded interacts with, and is influenced by, the unbounded, and where different traditions can mutually interrelate. Once again, there is a parallel with Derrida, who also speaks of borderlines, and notes that we: have to cross the border but not to destroy the border; that is we have to cross the border in order to understand not only their relationship to the Western tradition [he is speaking about Romanian philosophy], but also to understand what they are doing with their own background, language, traditions, we have to travel, to go in their direction. (1993: 33) In terms of crossing a border or frontier, in terms of locating the self in a relationship with the other, and in terms of seeing identity as, not fixed, but fluid, both writers are very much in concord. We have already noted Heaney’s preoccupation with justice, so too Derrida sees justice as intimately connected with notions of responsibility to the ‘absolute singularity of the other’ (1993: 25). In a lecture given in his second year in Oxford, Heaney cites a comment of Robert Pinsky’s from an aptly entitled essay called ‘Responsibilities of the Poet’12 where Pinsky makes the point that the artist requires, not so much an audience per se, as much as the ‘need to feel an answer, a promise to respond’ (1995a: xiv). This need to respond presupposes the presence of an other, of a form of alterity to which our response is addressed, and it locates poetry as a profoundly ethical discourse. Once again, there is a clear similarity
70
Seamus Heaney
between his thought and that of Derrida, who notes that it is only through the acknowledgement of the other that the self can fully come into being, as it is the ear of the other that ‘says me to me and constitutes the autos of my autobiography’ (1985: 51). For Derrida, the whole notion of identity is bound up with this dialectical oscillation between self and other, and this movement predicates what Heaney terms a concentration on the self, through the ‘need to respond’ which can achieve the ‘imaginative transformation of human life’ (1995a: xv). Derrida sees separation and dissociation as the conditions of any relationship with the other (1997b: 14). He also notes that: the identity of a culture is a way of being different from itself; a culture is different from itself; language is different from itself; the person is different from itself. Once you take into account this inner and other difference, then you pay attention to the other and you understand that fighting for your own identity is not exclusive of another identity, is open to another identity. And this prevents totalitarianism, nationalism, egocentrism and so on. (1997b: 13–14) This notion of self-differentiating identity leaves some form of gap within the self, be that self singular or communal, and it is this very gap (Derrida 1992b: 9–11), analogous I would argue to Heaney’s view of poetry as occurring in the space between what ‘has to happen and what we would like to happen’, that allows for the interaction with the other, and for this interaction to influence our notion of selfhood. It is this dialectic, this field of force, that constitutes our notions of self, and poetry has the ability to influence this. By responding to the other, we are creating the self, and it is to this relationship between the self, poetry and society that our focus, in this chapter, is finally drawn. In the title essay of The Redress of Poetry, Heaney addresses directly how poetry can be ‘of present use’.13 Citing Philip Sidney and Wallace Stephens, he fixes on Plato’s world of ideal forms as the ‘court of appeal through which poetic imagination seeks to redress whatever is wrong or exacerbating in the prevailing conditions’ (1995a: 1). Having used the term ‘redress’ in this opening paragraph, Heaney explores its etymological complexity at a later stage, and explains his differing usages of the word:
Poetry and Transformation
71
The OED has four entries for ‘redress’ as a noun, and I began by calling on the first sense which it provides: ‘Reparation of, satisfaction or compensation for, a wrong sustained or the loss resulting from this.’ For ‘redress’ as a verb the dictionary gives fifteen separate entries, all of them subdivided two or three times, and almost all of the usages noted as obsolete. I have also taken account of the first of these obsolete meanings, which is given as, ‘To set (a person or a thing) upright again; to raise again to an erect position. Also fig. To set up again, restore, re-establish.’ (1995a: 15) It is interesting that this etymological examination does not occur until late in the essay. The earlier discussions of the notion of redressal, as ‘affirming that which is denied voice’, take place under the rubric of poetry being ‘of present use’, and are seen in terms of being part of a motivated ‘field of force’. As he puts it ‘engaged parties’ will see poetry as an ‘applied art’ which can be harnessed to their own movements. He explains that they will ‘always want the redress of poetry to be an exercise of leverage on behalf of their point of view’ (1995a: 2). The use of the terms ‘field of force’, and the notion of a committed poetry, remind us of the earlier definition of the epistemology of poetry in Preoccupations (1980), but more importantly of the two initial caveats that preceded that definition, namely that poetry is neither exclusively liberal lamentation nor praise or execration of violent action; that its force is one which provides a symbolic nexus of images which enable the continuing encompassment of reason and atavism, and possible realignments of the relationship between them. Here too, Heaney will reiterate his epistemology of poetry. Rather than seeing redress as simply a one-sided answering, subsumed within political and ideological movements, he is making a space for poetry sui generis, as an independent field of force which will be related to, but not dependent on, politics and ideology. He does not, as he puts it in North, see poetry as a ‘slingstone [to be] / Whirled for the desperate’ (1975: 72). Instead, he follows the advice of Wallace Stevens, who sees poetry as creating the world to which we turn, and as giving life to the ‘supreme fictions’ without which we would have difficulty in interpreting that world (Heaney 1995a: 2).14 Heaney’s notion of redress as a parallel to the actual is clear in his expansion of these ideas. He notes that if our experience is a labyrinth, then the poet is capable of countering its impassibility by ‘imagining some equivalent of the labyrinth and presenting himself and us with a
72
Seamus Heaney
vivid experience of it’ (1995a: 2). Here, the redressal is achieved by setting up that oscillation between literature, where ‘license is given to the writer to say everything he wants to or everything he can’ (Derrida 1992a: 37) and the political and societal world. The ‘affirming of that which is denied voice’ (Heaney 1995a: 2) takes place in this oscillation, this re-vision of the ‘I’ through art as a corrective to that of the ‘I’ involved in politics. Heaney explains the interstitial connection between these aspects of his field of force by stressing that such an operation ‘does not intervene in the actual’ but offers consciousness ‘a chance to recognise its predicaments, foreknow its capacities and rehearse its comebacks’ (1995a: 2). Hence, it redresses what Simone Weil has seen as ‘the greatest sin’, namely ‘obedience to the force of gravity’ (Heaney 1995a: 3),15 with gravity seen as the pull of essentialist and atavistic intensities, what he had termed in Preoccupations ‘religious’ intensities, and which also figured in the already quoted Kinship as the ‘appetites of gravity’ (1975: 43). Weil sees the intervention of poetry or art in society as a force of counter weighting. This is not to see redress as a political tool per se, rather it is to see art as setting up a ‘conception of equilibrium’ and then being ready to change sides so as to ‘add weight to the lighter scale’, an ever-changing, dynamic process, like justice which she sees as ‘that fugitive from the camp of conquerors’ (1995a: 3).16 The value of this notion of the redress of poetry for Heaney is threefold: it is independent, it is dialectical and transgressive, and it is ethically driven in its mode of action. As he puts it: Her whole book is informed by the idea of counter weighting, of balancing out the forces, of redress – tilting the scales of reality towards some transcendent equilibrium. And in the activity of poetry too, there is a tendency to place a counter-reality in the scales – a reality which may be only imagined but which nevertheless has weight because it is imagined within the gravitational pull of the actual and can therefore hold its own and balance out against the historical situation. The redressing effect of poetry comes from its being a glimpsed alternative, a revelation of potential that is denied or constantly threatened by circumstances. (1995a: 3–4) Here we see another constituent to his field of force, an anastomosis, an interpenetration of the actual and the imagined, which parallels
Poetry and Transformation
73
that of the earlier cited text and context. This redress is temporally and spatially fragile; it seems to be constantly under threat from the forces of gravity, of actuality, and those of the political and social spheres. However, as it is imagined within the gravitational pull of the actual, it can achieve a point of balance, which is focused inwardly on the reading or writing consciousness, and which is a powerful agent for change on both. The balance can be a point of stasis, or more accurately, a balance of opposed motions which cross and recross the frontier of writing. This is clear from the final poem in ‘Settings’ where it is the relational that provides the focus: Air and ocean known as antecedents Of each other. In opposition with Omnipresence, equilibrium, brim. (1991: 80) As his work develops, it is this complexity and nuanced response to experience that has become one of the defining characteristics of Heaney’s writing. Interestingly, this is not the end of the interstitial field of force, as there is an additional dialectical oscillation in the weave that shapes his view of poetry. As I have already pointed out, Heaney’s notion of the frontier of writing is a necessary component of that Kraftfeldt, as it is by crossings and transgressions that transformations of relationships and perceptions can take place. As a further complication of the field of force, it also functions as a dividing line between the ‘actual conditions of our daily lives’ and the ‘imaginative representation of those conditions’ and, by extension, as a dividing line between the ‘world of social speech and the world of poetic language’ (1995a: xvi). As well as its ethical force of redress, poetry also sets up a force which is unique to poetry qua poetry. Citing Auden’s poetic trivium of making, judging and knowing, Heaney notes that the making faculty seems to have a ‘free pass’ which enables it ‘to range beyond the jurisdiction of the other two’, and this process, this ‘fundamentally self-delighting inventiveness’ (1995a: 5) is also a necessary aspect of his epistemology of poetry, and can be seen to involve a neglected meaning of ‘redress’: a meaning which comes in entry four of the verb, subsection (b): ‘Hunting. To bring back (the hounds or deer) to the proper course.’ In this redress there is no hint of ethical obligation, it is more a matter of finding a course for the breakaway of innate capacity, a
74
Seamus Heaney
course where something unhindered, yet directed, can sweep ahead into its full potential. (1995a: 15) In a manner analogous to his anastomosis of ‘text and context’, Heaney here allows the different meanings of the weave of the word ‘redress’ to oscillate and penetrate each other so as to more fully define his epistemological view of the meaning of poetry. The faculty of making (deriving from the Greek ‘poieín’, meaning ‘to make’), is here adduced to redress the ethical imperative by setting up what we might term an aesthetic imperative which will bring out the ‘innate capacity’ of thought and language, the ‘self-delighting inventiveness’, the joy experienced in being a ‘process of language’ (1995a: 5). These different interactive redressals are not, however, confined to the realms of theory. Both are part of the constellation which he sees as embodying the functions of poetry. On 12 May 1981 Heaney was a guest at an Oxford college dinner, on the same day that Francis Hughes, an IRA hunger striker, died in prison.17 Hughes, Heaney tells us, belonged to a neighbour’s family, and Heaney felt the contradictory emotions brought about by his place at an Oxford occasion, while imagining the funeral rites that would be taking place in his native County Derry. In this lecture, ‘Frontiers of Writing’, he discusses the role of poetry with respect to such political problems. He makes the point that the individual consciousness is torn between conflicting demands: feelings of betrayal at enjoying the hospitality of an Establishment college (1995a: 188) while at the same time not wishing to support the hunger strike overtly because this would be taken as an endorsement of the ‘violent means and programmes of the Provisional IRA’ (1995a: 187). In this very real context, where the weight of the actual is palpable, he again stresses the dialectical functions of poetry, namely to be ‘a source of truth and at the same time a vehicle of harmony’, to be capable of being both socially responsible and creatively free’ (1995a: 193). Once again, in his use of binarisms to undermine the solidity of those binarisms, Heaney is tracing out an argument that is similar to that of Derrida, who, speaking about his early neologism, différance, notes that it is ‘neither this nor that; but rather this and that (e.g. the act of differing and of deferring) without being reducible to a dialectical logic either’ (1981c: 161).18 Both writers predicate the complex interaction of elements as ultimately destructive of oversimplifications, and Heaney stresses the necessary imbrication of redress as a counterweighting political
Poetry and Transformation
75
action and redress as redress of this political involvement by veering towards the aesthetic. Heaney sees this redress as the ‘redress of poetry as poetry’, as the inception of ‘its own category’ which exerts an ‘eminence’ and a ‘pressure’ through ‘distinctly linguistic means’ (1995a: 5–6). While cognisant of the necessity for the denial of the normative linguistic or literary standards in any ‘movement of liberation’, Heaney sees part of the field of force of poetry as being independent of such political gravitational pulls. He feels that there must be a dialectical awareness that, while in some way connected with the enforcement of cultural hegemonic regimes and mindsets, nevertheless poetry cannot be attenuated into a post factum political appendage. Such attenuation of the role of poetry in the world is the very antithesis of Heaney’s view of its effect. He makes the point that its integrity should not be impugned because ‘at any given moment it happens to be a refraction of some discredited cultural or political system’ (1995a: 7). It is against such oversimplifications that much of Heaney’s writing is directed, arguing again and again for notions of poetry as a working model of ‘inclusive consciousness’; a consciousness that is susceptible to the demands of the actual, the ethical and the aesthetic, as is made very clear in his Nobel Prize lecture, Crediting Poetry. In this lecture, Heaney traces his early steps in the acquisition of language, and the manner in which different discourses awakened in him a curiosity about the wider world outside rural County Derry. He discusses his alertness to different night sounds, seeing his reception to these sounds mirrored by the delicate, concentric ripples caused in a bucket of drinking water in the family scullery by the passing of nearby trains (1995b: 11). He goes on to explain the effect of listening to the different radio stations and his ‘first encounters with the gutturals and sibilants of European speech’, stimuli which had initiated a journey ‘into the wideness of the world’. He expands this metaphor into a journey into ‘the wideness of language, a journey where each point of arrival – whether in one’s poetry or one’s life – turned out to be a stepping stone rather than a destination’ (1995b: 11). Such a set of stepping stones leads to the space of poetry where different forces can work together; where microcosm and macrocosm intersect and interact, where: Poetry can make an order as true to the impact of external reality and as sensitive to the inner laws of the poet’s being as the ripples
76
Seamus Heaney
that rippled in and rippled out across the water in that scullery bucket fifty years ago. An order where we can at last grow up to that which we stored as we grew. An order which satisfies all that is appetitive in the intelligence and prehensile in the affections. I credit poetry, in other words, both for being itself and for being a help, for making possible a fluid and restorative relationship between the mind’s centre and its circumference. (1995b: 11–12) Here, the Kraftfeldt is again explained and reinforced. Poetry sets up dialectical relationships between self and other, itself and politics, language and the mind, motion and stasis, all woven together in a textile that calls us back to the earlier images of text being permeated by context, and the differing notions of identity that co-existed and interpenetrated in the field of force that was Catherine Bradley’s linen sampler. Once again he is describing the force of writing in the sand, something which creates a reflective space between the music of what happens and that which we would like to happen. The ‘fluid relationship’ is suggestive of a force which sets up connections which interact, intersect and interpenetrate without ever becoming solidified into foundationalist positions: as Heaney puts it: ‘Who ever saw / The limit in the given anyhow?’ (1991: 46), a telling phrase in which he encompasses the dialectic between the real and the imagined. Poetry holds attention in this space, and functions, as we have already noted, ‘not as distraction but as pure concentration, a focus where our power to concentrate is concentrated back on ourselves’ (Heaney 1988: 108). To concentrate on the self is to develop new notions of the self, and of the role of the self in culture. For Heaney, this focus on the self invokes a responsibility to the other, as his notion of selfhood is defined by an interaction of different forces. He is attempting to find what Derrida has termed ‘the other in oneself already’ (1997a: 24). Here there is a correlation with the work of Levinas who says that: ‘I am defined as a subjectivity, as a singular person, as an “I”, precisely because I am exposed to the other’ (1981a: 192). For Levinas, the ethical quality of language itself involves this notion of a response to the call of the other. The ability to look from the mind’s centre to its circumference and vice versa involves an opening of ‘me to the other before saying what is said’ (1989: 183). At this point, we return to the sampler of Catherine Bradley, and the two emblems of the value systems, which explode daily in Northern Ireland, and which are lodged like ‘dormant munitions’ on the piece of Ulster linen (Heaney 1983a: 6). Heaney’s notion of
Poetry and Transformation
77
poetry will transform the violence of the term ‘munition’ into the ‘saying of the law’ that is implied in the cognate term ‘muniment’. A ‘saying’ of the rights and privileges of the other can have a similarly explosive force on entrenched attitudes and ideologies, and it is such an ethical ‘saying’ or Derridean ‘response to a call’ that Heaney has in mind here. The ripple effect may seem small, but it does have a force of its own. As already noted, poetry creates a dialectical questioning of the ‘I’ by the ‘I’; it allows our ‘power to concentrate’ to be ‘concentrated back on ourselves’ (Heaney 1988: 108). In a real sense, it presents a community with an option of looking from its own centre to its circumference so as to acknowledge its limits. However, as Derrida notes, it is possible for ‘its limit to be its opening’ (1995: 355), a point implicit in much of Heaney’s writing. Speaking of the difficulty of attempting to demonstrate how a community’s limit can also be its opening to the other, Heaney, in Crediting Poetry, recalls one of the most savage events in the long history of the violence in Northern Ireland. In 1976, a minibus full of workers was stopped at Kingsmills, near Bessbrook in County Armagh at a bogus checkpoint. The occupants were lined up at the side of the road, and were asked ‘any Catholics among you, step out here’. Heaney notes that, since the majority of the group were Protestants, with a single exception, the presumption must have been that ‘the masked men were Protestant paramilitaries about to carry out a tit-for-tat sectarian killing’ (1995b: 18).19 He goes on: It was a terrible moment for him, caught between dread and witness, but he did make a motion to step forward. Then, the story goes, in that split second of decision, and in the relative cover of the winter evening darkness, he felt the hand of the Protestant worker next to him take his hand and squeeze it in a signal that said no, don’t move, we’ll not betray you, nobody need know what faith or party you belong to. (1995b: 18) The man did step forward, but was thrown aside to watch the execution of the ten Protestant workers, murdered by ‘presumably, the Provisional IRA’ (1995b: 18).20 Heaney notes that, in the face of such atrocity, we are ‘rightly suspicious of that which gives too much consolation in these circumstances’ (1995b: 19). However, if art is to be of ‘present use’, then its redress must take account of both the hand that gripped its other, as well as those which murdered their others. Here, in this symbol of a connection between self and other,
78
Seamus Heaney
we see how the very finality of the limit of one community, its total sectarian attack on the other as other, can also function as a tiny symbol of opening, an opening upon which some type of structure of community can be built. Heaney’s field of force hopes to credit the ‘marvellous’ as well as the ‘murderous’ (1995b: 20). That he enunciates this telling point in an essay as opposed to a poem further underscores my point that his prose writing is a seminal aspect of his overall project. At the level of his own writing, his field of force also consists of an anastomosis between poetry and prose as both genres combine to produce the complexity of response which is the teleological aim of his writing. He credits poetry both for ‘being itself and for being a help’ (1995b: 11); as well as redressing the socio-political, Heaney’s searches for answers will take into account the restorative relation of poetry to the self. In terms of the dialectic with which we began, he concludes his lecture with some assertions of the nature of the field of force that is his definition of poetry. He sees poetic form as both ‘the ship and the anchor. It is at once both a buoyancy and a holding, allowing for the simultaneous gratification of whatever is centrifugal and centripetal in mind and body’ (1995b: 29). The sense of movement of opposing forces within an encompassing structure which values both in their different ways is again enunciated and is, I would suggest, at the very core of Heaney’s aesthetic. Ultimately, this aesthetic is an attempt at gratifying the twin demands that pull us in different directions, whether these are violence or humane reason, emblems on an embroidered sampler, different definitions of Ulster, the ethical or the aesthetic in terms of the function of poetry. These binarisms are not, however, overschematic or specious; instead they are ethical in the sense that self is defined on an ongoing basis against some notion of alterity or otherness. This definition is ephemeral and transitory, and constantly changing and comes from the ‘resolution and independence which the entirely realised poem sponsors’ (1995b: 28). For Heaney, the achievement of poetry, that which will always be to poetry’s credit, is ‘the power to persuade that vulnerable part of our consciousness of its own rightness in spite of the evidence of wrongness all around it’ (1995b: 29). Heaney’s searches for answers are located in this desire to vindicate the question of consciousness that is central to the formation and ongoing development of the individual as individual. These searches for answers are profoundly ethical in that they prescribe a sense of
Poetry and Transformation
79
responsibility on the part of the individual. The activity of persuading the self means that we are constantly opening to changes in that self, changes which are wrought through the form and language and generic singularity of poetry. As Derrida notes: ‘it is because I am not one with myself that I can speak with the other and address the other’, and he goes on to see such notions of selfhood as the only way to ‘take responsibility and make decisions’ (1997b: 14). Heaney’s epistemology of poetry is similarly ethically informed. It is that which reminds us that we are ‘hunters and gatherers of values, that our very solitudes and distresses are creditable, in so far as they, too, are an earnest of our veritable human being’ (Heaney 1995b: 29). Here, in a nutshell, we have Heaney’s epistemology of poetry. It credits all our emotions, sets them in dialectical oscillation, and attempts, by a process of adjudication which involves aesthetic and ethical standards, to create a space which allows the revelation of the self to the self in a way that increases our humanity, and our response to, and responsibility for, the other. We can now begin to see the shape of his field of force, a structure which allows different, opposing forces to pass through its interstices, and which, like Brussels lace, acknowledges the gaps which underlie the connections. The series of dialectical oscillations which we have traced demonstrates the fluid relationship of Heaney’s continual adjudication between different positions and perspectives that is the essence of his epistemology of poetry. His searches for answers to those preoccupying questions have led him to a threshold, or frontier from where he looks in different directions, and attempts to create a space for their interaction. For Heaney, this multiple perspective is central to the force of poetry, and his citing of the Czeslaw Milosz poem, appropriately entitled ‘Ars Poetica?’ underlines this point. Speaking in The Government of the Tongue about the necessity for poetry to ‘put poetic considerations first – expressive considerations…based upon its own genetic laws’, he nevertheless grants the equal need to ‘concede the justice’ of Milosz’s ‘rebuke to the autocracy of such romantic presumption’ (1988: 166). He goes on to cite the following lines, where the openness of the self to the other is seen as the province of poetry, and I would see these as paradigmatic of his epistemology of poetry: The purpose of poetry is to remind us How difficult it is to remain just one person, For our house is open, there are no keys in the doors, And invisible guests come in and out at will. (1988: 167)
80
Seamus Heaney
This notion of poetry as a way in which selfhood can be transformed through the entrance of new ideas, thoughts and experiences has much in common with Heaney’s own poem ‘Markings’ which, as we have seen, speaks of a similar experience where ‘All these things entered you / As if they were both the door and what came through it’ (1991: 9). The field of force image has clearly influenced his general concept of the epistemological structure of poetry; in the next chapter, his attitude to the vexed question of the role that poetry can, and should, play in terms of the political sphere will be explored. Given that in politics, especially the polarised political space of Northern Ireland, selfhood can often become attenuated into the imperatives of the tribe, the expansionist aspects of Heaney’s notion of poetry could be seen to have an important ameliorative function. However, the interrelationship of the poetic and the political is fraught with dangers, and there is a need for poetry to engage with, but retain a certain distance from, the discourse of politics. Heaney stresses the need for some form of ethical dimension to the poetic, within the individual as opposed to the group consciousness. As he puts it in ‘Weighing In’, all ‘good tidings’ amount to: This principle of bearing, bearing up, And bearing out, just having to Balance the intolerable in others Against our own. (1996: 17) The notion of balance, of redressal, of counterweighting and of a structure which accommodates selfhood and alterity will underwrite his exploration of the relationship between the poetic and the politic.
4
‘Surviving Amphibiously’: Poetry and Politics
In terms of the nexus between poetry and politics, perhaps the most opportune place to begin is with the title of his second collection of prose writings, The Government of the Tongue.1 Like much of Heaney’s writing, this phrase resounds with a productive ambiguity. He tells us that what he had in mind was the aspect of poetry as its own vindicating force. In this dispensation, the tongue (representing both a poet’s personal gift of utterance and the common resources of language itself) has been granted the right to govern. The poetic art is credited with an authority of its own. (1988: 93) This confident assertion of the power of poetry to become operative in the world of language without undue deference to political ideologies is balanced later in the essay, by a more negative interpretation: ‘Govern your tongue,’ it says, compelling me to remember that my title can also imply a denial of the tongue’s autonomy and permission….This manifests a world where the prevalent values and necessities leave poetry in a relatively underprivileged situation, requiring it to take a position that is secondary to religious truth or state security or public order….In ideal republics, Soviet republics, in the Vatican and Bible-belt, it is a common expectation that the writer will sign over his or her individual, venturesome and potentially disruptive activity into the keeping of an official doctrine, a traditional system, a party line, whatever. In such contexts, no further elaboration or exploration of the language or forms currently in place is permissible. An order has been handed down and the shape of things has been established. (1988: 96) Under the ‘whatever’ rubric of this quotation, Heaney might well have added the term ‘nationalist ideology’ to flag the felt need on his 81
82
Seamus Heaney
part, and on the part of others, that he should in some way articulate this sense of nationalist identity in Northern Ireland. This sense of a social or tribal duty has been baggage which Heaney has carried for some time during his career. Much of Heaney’s writing probes this nexus of connections between the poetic and the politic. In keeping with the epistemological structure which has already been sketched in the introduction and opening chapter, Heaney is unwilling to completely valorise one perspective over the other: instead, he will attempt to initiate a field of force wherein both senses of the government of the tongue can be teased out to their fullest extent: ‘Sea broke on land to full identity’ (1966: 47). That this identity comes from the interaction of opposing forces is significant in the light of the argument being advanced in this book. In Preoccupations, Heaney has already flagged the problematic nature of his own community: ‘if this was the country of community, it was also the realm of division’ (1980: 20), and part of his function as a poet is to voice both of these strands of identity. Perhaps the core question is whether he will take on the colourings of the given political divisions or attempt to use poetry to in some way transform these. As in all of Heaney’s work, this will not be a simple or overt project; instead, he will initiate an anastomosis between writer and context similar to that between text and context as discussed earlier. As he puts it: ‘the curtain was about to rise on the larger drama of our politics and the writers were to find themselves in a play within a play’ (1980: 30). Whether this role would be predefined or fluid is the question which this chapter attempts to probe. As early as Wintering Out, Heaney is gesturing towards his own political constituency in the epigraph to the book which introduces the themes ‘disorientation, place, history, and the collective fate’ and the routes through which those themes are enunciated ‘the drive from present to past, past to present, future to past’ (Parker 1993: 93). This poem, entitled ‘For David Hammond and Michael Longley’, sets out the grim reality of what life was like in Northern Ireland in 1972. Internment without trial had been introduced in Northern Ireland in 1971, with some 1,500 people, the vast majority of these nationalists, being interned.2 Heaney’s epigraph to Wintering Out is located firmly in this period. Indeed the book’s title refers to an Ulster term meaning to ‘survive a crisis’ (Parker 1993: 90), and it is the lineaments of this crisis that are the subject of the poem.
Poetry and Politics
83
Heaney describes driving along a ‘dewy motorway’ and seeing ‘the new camp for the internees’,3 with attendant bomb-craters and ‘machine-gun posts’. The only comparison that can be made is to Second World War films, ‘some film made / of Stalag 17’ (1972: 5); the only response that enters his head is graffiti written in a nationalist area: ‘Is there life before death? That’s chalked up / on a wall downtown’ (1972: 5).4 In the final line of the poem, there is a pronominal swerve, as the ‘I’ of the initial two quatrains becomes immersed in the ‘we’ of his community: ‘we hug our little destiny again’ (1972: 5). In this poem, and in others, Heaney feels the obligation to voice his own group’s sense of identity. In an essay entitled ‘Christmas, 1971’, he describes the contemporary situation and its effect on him as both a person and a writer.5 In a style reminiscent of the epigraph to Wintering Out, Heaney describes the ongoing political context where ‘we have to live with the army’, where ‘we survive explosions and funerals’ and where ‘soldiers with cocked guns are watching you’ (1980: 30). He goes on to describe how if ‘it is not the army, it is the vigilantes’, and details some of the slogans on the walls: ‘Keep Ulster Protestant’, ‘Keep Blacks and Fenians out of Ulster’, ‘Six into Twenty-Six won’t go’. He also poses the questions on people’s minds as to the identity of ‘the next target on the Provisional list’6 or whether the resultant reprisals ‘won’t strike where you are’ (1980: 31). The imagery of the war film in the epigraph is replicated here, with the poet caught in the middle. He also refers to his three-year-old son being brought with him to a police station near the Falls Road, and to his wife’s being ‘cornered’ by a security man in a shop because of an old clock she had in her bag which may have been a ‘timing device’ for a bomb (1980: 31). Interestingly, even in the middle of such a situation, Heaney’s attitudes attempt to transcend the givens of his ideological positioning. In the fourth paragraph from the end, he probes the ‘Ulster Protestant consciousness’ as enunciated by Louis MacNeice, W. R. Rodgers and John Hewitt who are all seen as exploring ‘in different ways’ their relationship to ‘the old sow that eats her farrow’. This gesture of an embattled consciousness towards some understanding of the voice of the other is an important node in Heaney’s developing understanding of the transformative role of poetry within culture. At an unconscious level, the binaries still structure his grasp of the situation, as he contrasts a reading of Martin Luther King’s ‘I have a Dream’ speech with an actual dream he had himself while in California: ‘I was shaving at the mirror of the bathroom when I
84
Seamus Heaney
glimpsed in the mirror a wounded man falling towards me with his bloodied hands lifted to tear at me or to implore’ (1980: 33). I would argue that these dreams symbolise the different meanings of the government of the tongue: on the one hand, the voiced dream attempts to transform the present with a vision of the future which is ameliorative – ‘free at last’ – whereas on the other, it is an image of present discord which attempts to embrace the poet. This oneiric symbolisation of the binaries could be seen as a negative index of any chance of relating the two. However, in a later essay from Preoccupations, entitled ‘Feeling into Words’, Heaney ponders the imperatives that such bifurcations place on a poet, and reaches conclusions which are potentially liberating for him and his work. Having worked through the concept of the ‘field of force’, as discussed in the opening chapter, Heaney answers the central question about the role of the poet in this situation: ‘the question, as ever, is “How with this rage shall beauty hold a plea?” And my answer is, by offering “befitting emblems of adversity”’ (1980: 57). These emblems are predicated neither on one specific meaning of the notion of the government of the tongue, nor do they valorise either specific oneiric vision of the nature of poetry. Instead, they attempt to initiate the differing parameters of that field of force of which we spoke, a structure which will grant the ‘religious intensity of the violence’ while at the same time encompassing the perspectives of ‘a humane reason’ (1980: 56–7). Hence, his work will look for symbolic expression of the many facets of the Northern Irish situation, and to see him as espousing one tradition or perspective over others is to seriously attenuate the scope and vision of his work. Hence I would argue that a critic like Elmer Andrews is only partially correct when he speaks of Heaney being ‘the voice of instinct probing the soft mulches of feeling and sensation’ (1988: 55), or when he speaks of Heaney’s accepting ‘a desolating heritage of brutality and defeat’ (1988: 97). The same is true of Blake Morrison’s assertion that North has been seen both as conflating the poetic with the politic and of being politically one-sided: ‘it ends up speaking the language of the tribe, brutal though that language may be’ (1982: 68). This is true, but only insofar as Heaney is granting the visceral intensity that allows people to kill each other in the name of a sense of identity as one of those adequate symbolic texts which will interact with the social and cultural context. The voicing of a sense of essentialist nationalist Irishness is a necessary aspect of this strand. Before the tongue can be freed to govern the contextual structures that have
Poetry and Politics
85
shaped it, it must first voice the ‘appetites of gravity’ (Heaney 1975: 43), the pull of those forces on the voice of the poet. In this interaction of text and context, Heaney’s thought parallels that of Derrida who sees such a permeation as a seminal aspect of deconstructive thought: ‘There is no outside-the-text’ signifies that one never accedes to a text without some relation to its contextual opening and that a context is not made up of what is so trivially called a text, that is, the words of a book or the more or less biodegradable paper document in a library. (Derrida 1989c: 841) He goes on to add that if one does not understand this transformation of text and context, then one understands nothing about deconstruction. I would argue that there is a thematically dominant strand of such transformation at work in Heaney’s poetry and in his writing about the purpose and function of poetry. The anastomosis that we traced in the opening chapter also applies broadly to issues of culture, language and identity. Heaney is constantly aware of the intersection of different texts and contexts and he is also at pains to tease out this interaction. Therefore, in ‘Fodder’, this sense of a personal identity being located within a broader contextual framework is encapsulated in the pronominal shift between ‘we’ and ‘I’ and in the use of the image of embracing: Fodder Or, as we said, fother, I open my arms for it again. (1972: 13) Here, the preconceived notion of language and identity of which he spoke in The Government of the Tongue exerts its force as the dialect pronunciation exerts a gravitational pull on the consciousness of the poet. The language of the ‘I’ in this stanza is predicated on the social language of the group, the ‘we’. He is aware of both the need to voice his own group identity and also of the dangers of such a project which could leave him ‘snared, swinging / an ear-ring of sharp wire’ (1972: 22). To be attenuated by the parameters of one’s own tradition is to risk being ‘sleeved in’ by ‘alluvial mud’ with ‘elvers’ tailing his
86
Seamus Heaney
hair (1972: 26). This image of immersion within a culture is echoed throughout the early part of Wintering Out, as he sees himself as ‘lobe and larynx / of the mossy places’ (1972: 28). In these poems, language as a given is a constructive, and constricting, force on the development of identity: the tongue is being governed by social and linguistic constraints, by the handed down and established order of things. Utterance has a political subtext even when the thematic material is not ostensibly political. There is a need to cross the border into the language of the other as opposed to remaining snared in the language of one’s own community. In one of his most famous early poems, ‘The Other Side’, Heaney speaks of a Protestant neighbour in a language that is very much that of binary opposition. The neighbour’s comments that a piece of ground is ‘as poor as Lazarus’ is seen as metonymic of a different way of speaking: ‘his fabulous, biblical dismissal, / that tongue of chosen people…he prophesied’ (1972: 34). The identity of the neighbour is similarly couched in the language of an established order, both in terms of his own speech, and also in terms of how Heaney envisions him and his identity: His brain was a whitewashed kitchen hung with texts, swept tidy as the body o’ the kirk. (1972: 35) This identification with the binaries of Northern Ireland becomes more politically overt in North, where the identificatory connections of Wintering Out become weighed down by political, ideological and racial ‘official doctrines’. In this poem, the personal pronoun first person plural ‘we’ is used in an exclusionary and differentiating manner: Then sometimes when the rosary was dragging Mournfully on in the kitchen We would hear his step round the gable. (1972: 35) That the discourse invoked in this quotation is that of prayer is significant as culturally and semiotically this precise form of language exercises a defining imperative in terms of what constitutes selfhood and alterity. In the opening section, the Protestant neighbour is described in a similar yet opposite religious discourse: ‘his fabulous biblical dismissal, / that tongue of chosen people’ (1972: 34), and
Poetry and Politics
87
the binary opposition is voiced from both sides, with the neighbour speaking of ‘your side of the house’ (1972: 35), referring to his Catholic neighbours.7 However, in terms of structuration, the notion of an ‘other side’ presupposes a figure where there is also a same side: the very title of the poem sees the Protestant neighbour as relationally connected to the ‘I’ of the poem. What the poem enacts is the difficulty of negotiating the borders and frontiers that block the movement between these two sides of a seminal binary opposition in Northern Ireland of Protestant/Catholic. Rather than attempt to blur these differences, created through language, religion and history, Heaney, in this poem, spells out the limits of the binary opposition which has defined the politics of Northern Ireland since its foundation. Structures which attempt to sanitise these differences are predestined to failure as they can never sufficiently engage with the ideological positions of either side.8 In this poem the discursive constitution of each side is foregrounded as opposed to being elided, and the final discursive mode of the poem is that of silence as the ‘I’ of the poem stands behind the Protestant neighbour ‘in the dark yard, in the moan of prayers’ (1972: 36). The response to the religious discourse which divides the community into two sides is silence, in which a form of connection is posited: Should I slip away, I wonder, Or go up and touch his shoulder And talk about the weather Or the price of grass-seed? (1972: 36) It is significant in this context that this conversation is optative: it does not take place. Instead, the vocal discourse of the poem is that of religion, while any real form of communication is predicated in the future. Edna Longley sees this poem as entering into the ‘idiom of the other side’ and also as spanning ‘two languages to create a third’ (1986: 201), and while this may be a little premature in terms of the poem itself, which as noted, ends not in a further language but in silence, nevertheless it is a perceptive observation in terms of Heaney’s ongoing project. The projected discourse at the end of the poem supplants the religious frame of reference with those of weather and commerce, perhaps indicating the tenor of this ‘further language’.
88
Seamus Heaney
At this juncture it is important to note that in the poem there is no sense of this type of language as having been developed: as Wells-Cole remarks, any attempt at unity here is evaded by the Protestant other (1995: 142).9 Brewster is undoubtedly correct when he notes that ‘The Other Side’ stages a ‘face-to-face’ encounter that, on the face of it, typifies the awkward proximities threaded through Northern Irish culture. Yet the poem is striking for the way it avoids facing up to the face (for Levinas the incarnation of non-violence) or envisaging the difficulties of approaching a cultural and political divide and attempting to find a shared point of access. (Brewster forthcoming 2004) Brewster’s invocation of the work of Emmanuel Levinas as a lens through which aspects of Heaney’s work can be analysed is an important dimension in contemporary cultural discourse. For my purposes, it is Levinas’s distinction between the ‘saying’ and the ‘said’ that will be of most significance. In his study of otherness, published in English in 1981 entitled Otherwise Than Being Or, Beyond Essence, Levinas make a distinction between the ‘saying’ and the ‘said’, and in an interview with Richard Kearney in the same year, he discussed this differentiation. Levinas made the point that ‘saying’ is ‘ethical sincerity in so far as it is exposition’ and as such, is irreducible ‘to the ontological definability of the said’ (1981a: 193–4).10 In other words, ‘saying’ presupposes an ‘ethical openness to the other’ (1981a: 194). The ‘said’ is ontologically definable and constitutive of fixed identities by proclaiming and establishing an ‘identification of this with that in the already said’ (1981b: 37). The ‘saying’, on the other hand, ‘states and thematises the said, but signifies it to the other, a neighbour, with a signification that has to be distinguished from that borne by words in the said’ (1981b: 46). The use of the term ‘neighbour’ is especially significant here, in the context of our discussion. As Simon Critchley summarises, the philosopher’s project is the ‘reduction of the Said to the Saying’, and he goes on to make the point that ethics, far from overcoming or abandoning ontology, actually deconstructs the latter’s limits (1992: 8). For Levinas: ‘saying makes signs to the other, but in this sign signifies the very giving of signs’. He goes on to stress the primacy of alterity in the saying, noting that it ‘opens me to the other before saying what is said’ (1989: 183). As he puts it, language as ‘saying is ethical sincerity’, it is ‘an ethical openness to the other’ (1981a: 193–4), and this is what
Poetry and Politics
89
I suggest we will find as Heaney develops his notion of the ‘other side’ in a later poem where this locution is taken and given a broader contextual framework wherein movement and interaction are more fluent and more positive. Paradoxically, however, the silence at the end of this poem is an index of the development of an ethical position towards the other and towards a form of intersubjective communication. That ‘The Other Side’ ends in silence would seem to indicate an inability to broach this ‘saying’ in terms of a relationship with the other. However, as Brewster correctly points out: silence is not necessarily testimony to an ethical failure (forthcoming 2004) and both Derrida and Levinas, in their explorations of the ethical imperative, foreground this very point. Speaking about the concepts of hope and the promise of a better future, specifically in the context of the Arab-Israeli question, Levinas describes the difference between the reality of a Jewish state, and his own conception of ‘longing for Zion’, which can be his notion of the ‘promised’ Jerusalem, of what he terms ‘the humanity of the Torah’: Our text which began with the cities of refuge, reminds us or teaches us that the longing for Zion, that Zionism, is not one more nationalism or particularism; nor is it a simple search for a place of refuge. It is the hope of a science of society, and of a society, which are wholly human. (1994: 51–2) Reading this passage, Derrida notes that the whole concept of this ‘promise’ is voiced in Levinas’s idea of the saying, but he also foregrounds the role of the recipient of this promise in terms of listening and a silence which has parallels with the openness to alterity of the ‘saying’: Can we not hear this promise? We can also receive and listen to it. We can even feel ourselves engaged by it without, however, remaining insensitive to the silence it bears at the heart of the call. This silence can also be a figure of a hiatus, that is, a mouth opened to speak and eat, but a mouth that is still silent. (1999: 113–14) Derrida goes on to speak of this silence in Levinas’s phrase ‘a hope beyond refuge’, and proceeds to read this silence as a necessary step in the inauguration of a new future:
90
Seamus Heaney
Silence is kept concerning the rules or schemas…that would procure for us better or less bad mediations: between ethics or the holiness of messianic hospitality on the one hand and the ‘peace process’, the process of political peace, on the other. (1999: 114) Derrida is speaking in the context of the Arab-Israeli conflict but interestingly, the term ‘peace process’ has come to have a discernibly Irish connotation (at least in an Anglocentric context), and one could read the silence at the end of ‘The Other Side’ precisely in terms of this moment of preparedness for some form of relation to the other, a relation which, because it has no further language, must begin in silence. In this context, the silence at the end of the poem is a necessary ethical step towards a furtherance of a willed connection between self and other. The ‘I’ of the poem is at a decisive point in determining whether he should, or should not, touch his neighbour before speaking to him. This is a necessary silence which delimits a space wherein the connection is willed but also where there is not a template or paradigm within which to sustain it. In that moment of decision as to whether he should ‘slip away’ or ‘touch’ his neighbour, a personal ethics of self and other is about to be sketched. As Derrida notes, this silence, this: non-response conditions my responsibility, there where I alone must respond. Without silence, without the hiatus, which is not the absence of rules but the necessity of a leap at the moment of ethical, political or juridical decision, we could simply unfold knowledge into a program or course of action. (1999: 117) In terms of achieving a form of intersubjective relationship with the other side of the political, religious and ideological divide that is constitutive of identity in Northern Ireland, this silence is fundamental. Indeed, it is through this trope of silence (but a silence that is contextually amplified), that Heaney will develop his appreciation of the need for connection with the ‘other side’. In ‘The Pitchfork’ in Seeing Things, Heaney is writing in the mode of the first two books, Death of a Naturalist and Door into the Dark. Here, the tools of the artisan take on a connotative signification as they symbolise aspects of the poet’s art. One is reminded of the spade in ‘Digging’; the jam-pots in ‘Death of a Naturalist’; the scythe in ‘The Barn’; pea-tins and jam-pots in ‘Blackberry-Picking’; the churns
Poetry and Politics
91
in ‘Churning Day’; the gaff and net of ‘The Salmon Fisher to the Salmon’; the anvil of ‘The Forge’; the bag of knives in ‘Thatcher’, and this is far from an exhaustive list. It is, I would argue, no coincidence that the pitchfork would be part of the discourse of ‘weather’ and ‘the price of grass-seed’ that is envisioned at the end of ‘The Other Side’. As an object, it is an index of the commonality that is at the heart of rural living: it is an implement used by both sides of the divide, and as such, should be free of ideological and sectarian baggage. Unlike the religious discursive thread which ran through ‘The Other Side’, this should be an area which stresses connection as opposed to dislocation. In this poem, the pitchfork is described in terms of both the actual and the imagined: as a descriptor, the pitchfork crosses the frontier of the real and the imagined: ‘of all implements, the pitchfork was the one / That came near to an imagined perfection’ (1991: 23), and it is this sense of an imagined reality which transcends the given one that resonates through this poem, and which connects it with the previously discussed one: And then when he thought of probes that reached the farthest, He would see the shaft of a pitchfork sailing past Evenly, imperturbably through space, Its prongs starlit and absolutely soundless – But has learned at last to follow that simple lead Past its own aim, out to an other side Where perfection – or nearness to it – is imagined Not in the aiming but the opening hand. (1991: 23) This image of the opening hand is symbolic of the Levinasian notion of the ‘saying’ as opposed to the ‘said’, inasmuch as it is a gesture which does not seek closure. Perfection, in this stanza, may never be achieved, but the idea of ‘nearness to it’ is central in that it provides an open-ended goal in terms of relation with the other. I feel that it is no accident that the same tropes of otherness and silence are revisited in this poem. It allows Heaney to reconceptualise otherness in terms of an imagined connection where a sense of openness will transfigure the relationship just as the pitchfork becomes an imagined type of space probe, which is able to go ‘past its own aim’, in a process analogous to Levinas’s ‘saying’, a process where a sense of responsibility to and for the other is important: ‘In the saying of
92
Seamus Heaney
responsibility, which is an exposure to an obligation for which no one could replace me, I am unique. Peace with the other is first of all my business’ (Levinas 1981b: 138–9). The context of an imaginary pitchfork gliding through a silent space takes the silence at the conclusion of ‘The Other Side’ and transforms it into an image of peace and hope, both of which are oriented towards the future. The contextual frameworks of both poems enact this development. In the former, the context of Heaney’s childhood home, rural County Derry, where the discourse that is operative is differential in that the Protestant neighbour speaks in biblical language and talks about the ‘book’ (the Bible) as a point of differentiation, while within the house, it is the rosary, a specifically Catholic prayer, that is heard. This sense of contextual closure is further highlighted by the inside–outside binary opposition that delimits the interaction of the protagonists in the poem. In ‘The Pitchfork’, however, there is a contextual expansion from the farm yard to the realm of space, a realm which is very much beyond that of the narrow farmyard. Here, the other side takes on a new signification: it describes a realm which is transcendent in terms of the immanent sectarian either/or choices that constrain the givens of identity in Northern Ireland. Indeed, this poem, seen in tandem with ‘The Other Side’ exemplifies Derrida’s notion of the interaction of text and context: Every sign, linguistic or non-linguistic, spoken or written…in a small or large unit, can be cited, put between quotation marks; in so doing it can break with every given context, engendering an infinity of new contexts in a manner which is absolutely illimitable. This does not imply that the mark is valid outside of a context, but on the contrary that there are only contexts without any centre or absolute anchorage. (Derrida 1988: 12) One of the shared cognitive attitudes of Heaney and Derrida is this desire to probe the givens, the seeming fixities of anchorage and to destabilise them in order to enlarge the contextual parameters that govern our discursive practices. Hence ‘The Pitchfork’ defines a new context for the term the ‘other side’, a context which is as expansive and transcendent as the initial context was narrow and circumscribed. The sense of perfection here is related to Levinas’s sense of an ethics of plurality which derives from this form of transcendence:
Poetry and Politics
93
Transcendence or goodness is produced as pluralism.…Pluralism is accomplished in goodness proceeding from me to the other....The unity of plurality is peace, and not the coherence of the elements that constitute plurality….Peace therefore cannot be identified with the end of combats that cease for want of combatants, by the defeat of some and the victory of others, that is, with cemeteries or future empires. Peace must be my peace, in a relation that starts from an I assured of the convergence of morality and reality. (Levinas 1969: 305) This sense of peace can be produced by a broadening of the contextual framework, and it is with this in mind that we should examine Heaney’s political poetry. He has often been accused of writing from within the logos and mythos of his own side. Certainly parts of Wintering Out and North have received a fair share of criticism in these terms. I have spoken elsewhere about the misreadings, as I see them, of the so-called ‘land and language’ poems of Wintering Out, specifically ‘Broagh’ and ‘Anahorish’.11 These poems have been largely read as statements of linguistic and cultural resistance to the encroachment of the British presence in Ireland. The genesis of such readings can be seen to emanate from Heaney’s own explanation of the beginnings of the poems: Mossbawn was bordered by the townlands of Broagh and Anahorish, townlands that are forgotten Gaelic music in the throat, bruach and anach fhíor uisce, the riverbank and the place of clear water. The names lead past the literary mists of a Celtic twilight into that civilization whose demise was effected by administrators like Spenser and Davies, whose lifeline was bitten through when the squared-off walls of bawn and demesne dropped on the country like the jaws of a man-trap. (1980: 36) In the light of this paragraph, the two poems have been read from a broadly anti-colonial perspective. Both poems begin with the first line seemingly translating the title – Anahorish: ‘My “place of clear water”’ (1972: 16), and Broagh: ‘Riverbank, the long rigs / ending in broad docken’ (1972: 27), and both proceed to make connections between place and the language and people who formally inhabited those places. ‘Anahorish’ speaks of the italicised word ‘Anahorish’ conjuring up visions of the earliest inhabitants ‘mound-dwellers’ who are imagined as going ‘waist-deep in mist’ (1972: 16), while
94
Seamus Heaney
‘Broagh’ speaks of a fusion of signifier and referent with the mark of a heel in the ‘garden mould’ being seen as ‘the black O // in Broagh’ (1972: 27), an identification culminating in the very name of the place being seen as an index of identity and difference: a way of dividing people into one’s own side and the other side, as the ‘shower’ of rain: ended almost suddenly, like that last gh the strangers found difficult to manage. (1972: 27) These poems would seem to be a repression of the process of contextual openness of which we have been speaking, as placenames are seen as divisive and polarising. There is no Levinasian or Derridean ethical silence at work here: the names seem to speak the ‘absolute anchorage’ of the centres of nationalist identity. Andrews reads the end of the poem in this light as exploring the ‘relationship between landscape, language and people, it ends by alerting us to the nationalistic implications of all this’ (1988: 55), while Ronald Tamplin observes that language ‘acts as a line of recognition, marking intimate from stranger’ and thus is operative ‘in political terms’ in the poem (1989: 41–2). However, keeping in mind the anastomosis with which we began this discussion of Heaney’s work, and the resultant series of interrelationships between text and context, these readings become less determined. The prose description of the genesis of these poems from Preoccupations has already been noted. However, that paragraph which speaks of the English cultural imperative in the simile of a ‘man-trap’ is followed by another one which would seem to suggest a different relationship with this ‘other side’: Yet I also looked across our fields to Grove Hill and Back Park, names that fetch the imagination in a different direction. They insist that this familiar locale is a version of pastoral….Grove is a word that I associate with translations from the classics, a sunlit treeline, a tonsured hillock approached by white-robed priests. The literary word and the earthwork sentried by Scotch firs sit ill together. My illiterate ear isn’t totally satisfied, as it is by another name, The Dirraghs, from doire as in Derry, also usually Englished as ‘oak grove’. Grove and park, they do not reach me as a fibre
Poetry and Politics
95
from a tap-root but remind me of the intricate and various foliage of history and culture that I grew up beneath. (Heaney 1980: 36) In this paragraph, that contextual exfoliation of which we spoke in terms of ‘The Other Side’ and ‘The Pitchfork’ is again foregrounded. Far from lodging the psyche in the names of his home place and in the Irish language, what we see at work here is a glissement of Gaelic, English and classical traditions, creating a context within which the communication between selfhood and alterity becomes a ‘saying’ as opposed to a ‘said’: there is an openness and an orientation towards a future ethics and politics instead of the closure that critics read in ‘Anahorish’ and ‘Broagh’. This sense of interaction is enunciated in the closing lines from this essay: If you like, I began as a poet when my roots were crossed with my reading. I think of the personal and Irish pieties as vowels, and the literary awarenesses nourished on English as consonants. My hope is that the poems will be vocables adequate to my whole experience. (1980: 37) This would indicate that Heaney’s conception of language is very much that of Levinas in terms of seeing language in general, and poetic language in particular, as a ‘saying’ which ‘presupposes an ‘ethical openness to the other’ (Levinas 1981a: 194). In the light of these contextual placements, if we revisit ‘Broagh’ and ‘Anahorish’, a different reading will become clear, one which firmly locates these poems within his broader ethical and aesthetic project. Indeed, I would see these poems as instantiating the ‘intricate and various foliage of history and culture’ of which he spoke in Preoccupations. These two signifiers are neither Gaelic nor English language terms, nor are they direct translations. The Irish word ‘bruach’ translates as ‘riverbank’, and the Irish string ‘anach fhíor uisce’ translates as ‘place of clear water’: however, the signifier ‘Broagh’ is a new term, related to both but identical with neither; similarly ‘Anahorish’ has the same structural relationship and non-relationship with both languages. To see these terms as translations in the strict sense, with the Irish-language term antedating the English one, is simply incorrect. Instead, both placenames embody the pluralities, complexities and traces of the complex interaction of Irish and English cultures in a historical context. As I have noted:
96
Seamus Heaney
Given the difficulty of the Gaelic phonetic system, as we have seen, British cartographers transliterated many such names into the British phonetic and graphological system; hence the transliteration from ‘bruach’ to ‘broagh.’ ‘Broagh’ then, like ‘Anahorish,’ is not a Gaelic word, but rather it is a transliteration of the Gaelic word ‘bruach’ by the very ‘strangers’ who are deemed to find it so ‘difficult to manage’ in the first place. The ‘strangers’ who found the original pronunciation ‘difficult’ have altered it, changing the phonetic area of difficulty into another sound that, almost by definition, they will be able to manage. (O’Brien 2003: 60) The signifiers ‘Broagh’ and ‘Anahorish’, then, are neologisms, they are vocables, in Heaney’s sense of the word, a language of ‘saying’ wherein self and other interact and intersect in a transformative manner. In this sense, they embody a more complicated concept of translation, a concept which sees it as an index of the interaction and pluralisation of languages as opposed to a simplistic exchange of meaning between one and another. Derrida makes the following connection between deconstruction and this more complex idea of translation. Deconstruction, he says, consists: only of transference, and of a thinking through of transference, in all the senses that this word acquires in more than one language, and first of all that of the transference between languages. If I had to risk a single definition of deconstruction, one as brief, elliptical and economical as a password, I would say simply and without overstatement: plus d’une langue – both more than a language and no more of a language. (Derrida 1989b: 14–15) I would argue that both ‘Broagh’ and ‘Anahorish’ enact this transference, underlining the transformative nature of the interaction, and locating themselves as sites wherein self and other may communicate. The difficulty and friction that is necessitated by such communication is in no way elided in these works, nor in the contextual passages from Preoccupations. Heaney’s sense of the two traditions ‘sitting ill together’ underlines this but nevertheless the communication is ongoing and both words transgress the borders of the simplistic self and other binary in a way which becomes ‘through-other’ a term which we will revisit later in this discussion, in Chapter 6.
Poetry and Politics
97
Ironically, little has been made of Heaney’s early efforts at creating a more inclusive and open relationship between selfhood and alterity. Indeed, in much of the criticism of his poetry of this period, the view that Heaney is speaking very much from within his own tradition, that his tongue is being governed by its constitutive ideology, has become a commonplace. Speaking about ‘Kinship’, Andrews, for example, notes that a ‘guttural cacophonous music takes over as the poet accepts his kinship not only with Romantic victim but with barbaric tribe’ (1988: 96). James Simmons notes that ‘Heaney’s affirmations and omissions suggest that he feels absolutely closer to the hopes and actions of the IRA than he does to any sort of British soldier or Ulster policeman’ (1992: 57).12 David Annwn argues that some of the bog poems suggest that ‘republican violence is the dark side of Catholicism’, it is the destructive aspect ‘of the pre-Marian goddess which have not found a “home” in Christian doctrine’ (1984: 145). Stephen Wade asserts that in poems such as ‘The Tollund Man’ and ‘Punishment’ there is an ‘emotional closeness’ in the imagery and diction (1993: 42). In North, this argument is developed in both a mythic and political sphere. In the first part of the book, Heaney has been attacked for speaking too much in the voice of the tribe, in poems like ‘Punishment’ and ‘Kinship’ where his sense of being the ‘lobe and larynx’ of his own identity becomes governed by the atavisms of that very identity: Who would connive in civilised outrage yet understand the exact and tribal, intimate revenge. (1975: 38) …report us fairly, how we slaughter for the common good and shave the heads of the notorious. (1975: 45) I have argued elsewhere that to see this as the limit of North’s thematic concerns is to grossly oversimplify one of Heaney’s most complex books. However, there is no doubt that this type of enunciation of visceral sectarianism that has been part of much of
98
Seamus Heaney
the nationalist psyche over the past 30 years, must be addressed in any complex enunciation of identity.13 David Lloyd’s critique of Heaney focuses on precisely this facet of his writing, what might be termed the governed aspect of his voice. The gradual deictic slide from ‘I’ to ‘we’ achieves its most basic expression in these mythic poems as Ireland is personified as a mother figure: Our mother ground is sour with the blood of her faithful. (Heaney 1975: 45) As Lloyd notes, these associations of Ireland with ‘Irish ground, linked as the associations are through Cathleen Ni Houlihan, the motherland, together produce the forms in which the aestheticisation of Irish politics is masked’ (1993: 17). Heaney has been accused, by many critics, of writing from within his mythos in a manner which is widely seen as wrong. Conor Cruise O’Brien calls ‘the area where literature and politics overlap’ an ‘unhealthy intersection’; because, ‘suffused with romanticism’, it breeds bad politics – fascism and nationalism (1975a, 1975b).14 But it also breeds ‘bad literature, particularly, bad poetry, which in a vicious circle breeds – or inbreeds – bad politics’ (Longley 1986: 185). However, the issue of agency is an important one here: Heaney is not espousing this type of essentialist nationalism as a credo or an ethos. He is not invoking what Derrida has termed the telos of nationalism: ‘killing the future in the name of the old frontiers’ (1994: 169). Instead, what he is doing is giving voice to that visceral aspect of his own community’s sense of self which valorises the killing of the other in the name of that very concept of such an ideology. Terry Eagleton’s assertion that ‘ideology is a function of the relation of an utterance to its social context’ (1991: 9) is significant here as the social context of Heaney’s utterance is the Northern Irish violence spread over 30 years. However, the context of the utterance of the poetry is mythical as opposed to actual. The bog people, while figures from an archetypal past, are largely from cultures other than that of Northern Ireland. The figure of Tacitus, invoked as an observer in ‘Kinship’, is fictional in the context that the Romans never came to Ireland. His presence in the poem does not describe any motivated connection between Heaney’s mythos and the land of Ireland. Similarly, many of the bog poems are set in a European as opposed to an Irish context, with the bog people themselves having no
Poetry and Politics
99
connection with Ireland – the Windeby Girl (Germany), the Tollund Man and the Grauballe Man (Denmark), while the goddess Nerthus was worshipped in Europe as opposed to Ireland. My point here is that the connection between these bog people and the matter of Northern Ireland is not one which sees Heaney subordinating the freedom of the tongue to the governing imperatives of the nationalist mythos, despite the widespread critical consensus to the contrary. These connections are literary and created by Heaney in terms of finding adequate symbols for the situation in Northern Ireland. He is attempting to universalise and distance his imagery. As he told Edward Broadbridge: There’s a kind of sectarian conflict going on. Something that was repressed and held under, but which has forced itself to the surface again, and I’ve tried to make a connection lately between things that come to the surface in bogs, in particular in Danish bogs, and the violence that was coming to the surface in the north of Ireland. (Broadbridge 1977a: 11) The connection between the Iron Age bog victims and the victims of contemporary Northern Irish violence is a willed one, and I would maintain that it is this very connection that exercises a deconstructive force on the received meaning of the governing of the utterance by the gravitational demands of Heaney’s own community. The connections between, for example, the Windeby Girl and the ‘betraying sisters / cauled in tar’ (Heaney 1975: 38) who were punished by the nationalist community for dating British soldiers are created as opposed to being in some way ‘given’; Heaney is choosing to write about material which is aesthetically, temporally and spatially distant from his own political context in order to achieve the symbolic adequation of which he spoke in Preoccupations. He is not being forced to inhabit a position inside one of the contextual binary oppositions of nationalist–unionist; republican–loyalist; Catholic–Protestant or, at a broader level, poetry–politics and the tongue being governed as opposed to being self-governing. Instead, in these poems, he is deconstructing the received relationship between the aesthetic and the political by firstly reversing the binary and secondly by reconstituting the whole structure in order to redefine the role of the poetic text within the political context. This process is emblematic of how Derrida describes the act of deconstruction. This reversal of prevailing hierarchical binary
100
Seamus Heaney
oppositions is a necessary step in a deconstructive reading. As Derrida himself notes: ‘to deconstruct the opposition, first of all, is to overturn the hierarchy at a given moment’ (1981a: 41). But this reversal is only the first step in the deconstructive project. Making the point that an opposition of metaphysical concepts is never the faceto-face of two terms, but a hierarchy and an order of subordination, Derrida goes on to say: Deconstruction cannot limit itself or proceed immediately to a neutralization: it must, by means of a double gesture, a double science, a double writing, practice an overturning of the classical opposition and a general displacement of the system. It is only on this condition that deconstruction will provide itself the means with which to intervene in the field of oppositions that it criticises, which is also a field of non-discursive forces. Each concept, moreover, belongs to a systematic chain, and itself constitutes a system of predicates. There is no metaphysical concept in and of itself. There is a work – metaphysical or not – on conceptual systems. Deconstruction does not consist in passing from one concept to another, but in overturning and displacing a conceptual order, as well as the nonconceptual order with which the conceptual order is articulated. (1982: 329) Heaney is setting up links in this systematic chain, this field of force, in order to provide for a change in the meaning of the idea of the government of the tongue. He is creating a broader contextual framework within which he can locate different aspects of his discussion of his themes. So, what is at work in the bog poems is not an atavistic expression of some form of essentialist identity; instead, it is a reformulation of experience within the generic structure of poetry. He is involved in the process of overturning the conceptual order of the received relationship between poetry and politics through this dialectical interaction of differing perspectives and symbolic structures. We have already noted his statement in ‘Squarings’, that a place can mean ‘A state of mind. Or different states of mind // At different times’ (1991: 97), and it is this sense of difference or plurality that is his most important step in overturning the binaries. The epigraph to Wintering Out has already been discussed, but it appears again, in recontextualised form, in North. In a poem which is located in modern-day Northern Ireland, ‘Whatever You Say Say
Poetry and Politics
101
Nothing’, he speaks in a contemporary voice about the situatedness of his position as a Catholic nationalist poet who is attempting to locate his art within this circumscribed political and ideological space: ‘I sit here with a pestering / Drouth for words at once both gaff and bait’ (1975: 59). In this poem he has ‘levelled his voice to the conversational, turned his anthropomorphic gaze to the ordinary ways life is lived’ (Vendler 1998: 74), and is asking questions of himself that are the core of this chapter, namely, the correct relationship between poetry and politics. He examines his desire to ‘draw the line through bigotry and sham’ (1975: 59) while at the same time feeling that ‘the liberal papist note sounds hollow // When amplified and mixed in with the bangs’ of the ongoing explosions (1975: 58). He goes on to ponder the contradiction that despite his linguistic gifts, he is ‘incapable’ of finding that ‘right line’: The famous Northern reticence, the tight gag of place And times: yes, yes. Of the ‘wee six’ I sing Where to be saved you only must save face And whatever you say, you say nothing. (1975: 59) The penultimate section of the poem compares the nationalist community to the Greeks in the wooden horse of Troy, besieged ‘within the siege, whispering morse’ (1975: 60). The final image of this section again gestures towards that silence which is a prerequisite for ethical action. Any attempt to use poetry as a direct mode of address to in some way salve the wounds of division will be patently ineffective. Heaney’s reaction in both Wintering Out and North has been far more nuanced: he has broadened the contextual framework in order to reimagine the contemporary situation. Through such a process of recontextualisation, and in essence, this is what the mythopoeic swerve in Heaney’s poetry entails, the current political and sectarian situation is complicated and thickened in order to destabilise the fixities of meaning and create a new field of force wherein differences can be discussed. This impulse, which can be traced through other works such as his translations: Sweeney Astray, Beowulf, The Midnight Verdict, The Cure at Troy and ‘Mycenae Lookout’ in The Spirit Level, is a parallel enunciation of one of the many definitions that Derrida has given of the epistemological thrust of deconstruction:
102
Seamus Heaney
One of the definitions of what is called deconstruction would be the effort to take this limitless context into account, to pay the sharpest and broadest attention possible to context and thus to an incessant movement of recontextualisation. (Derrida 1988: 136) Thus, when operating in the more contemporary and more declarative world of ‘the Irish thing’, and when using the jargon that has been established by ‘politicians and newspapermen’ who have ‘scribbled down’ the situation in their own terms: Who proved upon their pulses ‘escalate’, ‘Backlash’ and ‘crack down’, ‘the provisional wing’, ‘Polarization’ and ‘long-standing hate’, (Heaney 1975: 57) Heaney is contextually circumscribed. He is forced to operate within the given linguistic context and all transformative attempts are frustrated by a language which is locked within the conflictual paradigm, and which has no opening to alterity through which to usher in some form of dialogue. Hence, the Levinasian silence of which we have already spoken comes into play in both the title and in the conclusion of the above quotation. Interestingly, it is after this injunction to silence that another recontextualisation occurs, the repetition of the epigraph to Wintering Out. Vendler makes the point that the conversational tone of this poem stresses the lack of power of conversational discourse to encompass the sheer complexity of the situation in which Heaney finds himself. It is in this context that the epigraph beginning ‘This morning from a dewy motorway’ is repeated, and the altered perspective underlines the act that such descriptions can only give one impression of the reality that is Belfast ‘where bad news is no longer news’ (1975: 57). Desmond Fennell has taken the title of this poem as the title of a pamphlet in which he offers Heaney’s poetry and reputation to a form of interrogation. He stresses Heaney’s lack of overt statement about matters political: ‘his [Heaney’s] poetry says nothing, plainly or figuratively, about the war, about any of the three main parties to it, or about the issues at stake’ (1991: 16). However, this is to miss the point that is at issue in terms of Heaney’s developing epistemological approach to the relationship between the aesthetic and the political. Writing in The Redress of Poetry, Heaney makes a core point in relation to this relationship:
Poetry and Politics
103
Poetry, let us say, whether it belongs to an old political dispensation or aspires to express a new one, has to be a working model of inclusive consciousness. It should not simplify. Its projections and inventions should be a match for the complex reality which surrounds it and out of which it is generated….As long as the coordinates of the imagined thing correspond to those of the world that we live in and endure, poetry is fulfilling its counterweighting function. (1995a: 8) Heaney is at pains not to adopt a simplistic response to ‘the Troubles’; in the conversational discourse of ‘Whatever You Say Say Nothing’, he tells us that when so asked, he is ‘incapable’, and the recontextualised appearance of the epigraph underlines this point. The dreamlike aura and oneiric description of the camp at Long Kesh in terms of its similarity to a silent war film underline the difficulty of responding to the specific situation without falling into a simplistic and clichéd frame of reference. The anastomosis of text and context discussed earlier is at work again here as the repetition of the twelve lines (the only such repetition in the Heaney canon) stresses the problematic nature of the demand to write for the group or community. The parergonal framework traced by the repetition of these lines describes a specific facet of Heaney’s writings on poetry and politics. The epigraph introduces two books that were broadly similar in terms of structure and theme. Indeed, Heaney has told John Haffenden that he was certain that ‘up to North that that was one book’ (1981: 64). Both books offer overt and allusive responses to the political situation in Northern Ireland, and can be seen as his attempt to address this vexed issue from a broadly communitarian perspective. On seeing a volume entitled North, the horizon of expectations at the time, given that the poet himself came from County Derry, would have anticipated a book about the contemporary situation in Northern Ireland in 1975. Blake Morrison makes the point that there was a certain demand for ‘war poets’ (Morrison 1982: 55). However, I would argue that the repeated epigraph stylistically makes the point that Heaney’s probings have not really developed any further from the beginning of Wintering Out to the close of North, hence the circularity and closure of the oneiric epigraph. In this sense the framing circularity voices one connotation of the phrase the ‘government of the tongue’ which we have already discussed, namely the ‘denial of the tongue’s autonomy and permission’, with the poet
104
Seamus Heaney
having to take up a position that is ‘secondary to religious truth or state security or public order’ (Heaney 1988: 96). However, having traced some strands of the governing of the tongue in terms of the denial of the tongue’s autonomy and permission, the other strand of this particular field of force must also be investigated and, significantly, this investigation can also begin with that epigraph from Wintering Out. In ‘The Interesting Case of Nero, Chekhov’s Cognac and a Knocker’, Heaney tells that in 1972, he and David Hammond were on their way to a recording studio to assemble ‘a tape of songs and poems’ for a friend in Michigan: The tape was to be sent in memory of a party which the man from Michigan had attended some months beforehand, when tunes and staves had been uttered with great conviction. The occasion had been immensely enjoyable and the whole point of the tape was to promote that happiness and expansiveness which song, meaning both poetry and music, exists to promote in the first place. (1988: xi) However, on the way to the studio, a number of explosions occurred in Belfast, and the sound of ambulances rang through the city. These explosions were part of a campaign of terror waged by the Provisional IRA, and as such, by members of Heaney’s own Catholic, nationalist community, a point clear from his description of the ‘certain halfdirected fury’ directed at them by the loyalist BBC security man when they arrived at the studio. In the face of the explosions and the sound of ambulance sirens, both Heaney and Hammond felt that ‘the music of the guitar’ could make ‘little impression’, that the ‘very notion of beginning to sing at that moment when others were beginning to suffer seemed like an offence against their suffering’. So both men drove off ‘into the destroyed evening’ (1988: xi). Here, song is definitely seen as ‘secondary’ to the prevailing orthodoxies of sectarian identity, the tongue is definitely governed by political and ideological imperatives. The silence of the performance is an eloquent one as the sounds of discord prevail. In ways, this is the nadir of the relationship as politics silences the voice of imagination. However, the very fact that he can write about the experience is an aporetic swerve away from this position, allowing him to acknowledge the governing power of the violence and political action but at the same time, to voice a regret at allowing utterance and poetic freedom to be so governed. At the end of ‘Nero, Chekhov’s
Poetry and Politics
105
Cognac and a Knocker’, he tells us of a poem he wrote for David Hammond ‘after the event described at the beginning of this introduction’, c