SCALING IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT
INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT STUDIES Series Editors:
P. Martens, J. Rotmans International ...
50 downloads
1158 Views
6MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
SCALING IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT
INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT STUDIES Series Editors:
P. Martens, J. Rotmans International Centre for Integrative Studies, Maastricht University, Maastricht, The Netherlands
Advisory Board: M.B. Beck Environmental Informatics and Control Program, Warnell School of Forest Resources, University of Georgia, Athens, Georgia, USA J. Robinson Sustainable Development Research Institute and Department of Geography, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, Canada H.J. Schellnhuber Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research, Potsdam, Germany; Tyndall Centre for Climate Change, Research, Norwich, UK
SCALING IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT
Editors Jan Rotmans & Dale S. Rothman
PUBLISHERS LISSE
ABINGDON
EXTON (PA)
TOKYO
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Applied for
This edition published in the Taylor & Francis e-Library, 2005. “To purchase your own copy of this or any of Taylor & Francis or Routledge’s collection of thousands of eBooks please go to www.eBookstore.tandf.co.uk.” Cover design: ZWAARWATER, Esther Mosselman, Amsterdam, The Netherlands Copyright © 2003 Swets & Zeitlinger B.V., Lisse, The Netherlands All rights reserved. No part of this publication or the information contained herein may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, by photocopying, recording or otherwise, without written prior permission from the publishers. Although all care is taken to ensure the integrity and quality of this publication and the information herein, no responsibility is assumed by the publishers nor the author for any damage to property or persons as a result of operation or use of this publication and/or the information contained herein. Published by: Swets & Zeitlinger Publishers www.szp.swets.nl www.balkema.nl
ISBN 0-203-97100-0 Master e-book ISBN ISBN 90 265 1947 8 (Print Edition) ISSN 1569-299X
CONTENTS ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ........................................................................... X THE EDITORS ......................................................................................... X THE CONTRIBUTORS ............................................................................. XI FOREWORD ........................................................................................ XIII LIST OF FIGURES ...................................................................................XV LIST OF TABLES ................................................................................. XVII 1 INTRODUCTION ................................................................................... 1 INTRODUCTION ........................................................................................ 1 SETTING THE STAGE ................................................................................ 1 ABOUT THIS BOOK ................................................................................... 2 2 GEOGRAPHIC SCALING ISSUES IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENTS OF CLIMATE CHANGE........................................... 5 HOW SCALE MATTERS ............................................................................. 5 BASIC CONCEPTS ............................................................................... 6 FINDINGS TO DATE ............................................................................ 8 ELEMENTS OF A COHERENT STORY LINE ABOUT HOW SCALE MATTERS ......................................................................................... 13 OPERATIONAL ISSUES ............................................................................ 18 THE PRINCIPAL ALTERNATIVES........................................................ 18 THE PRINCIPAL CHALLENGES........................................................... 21 DIRECTIONS FOR IMPROVING OUR CAPABILITIES ................................... 27 REFERENCES .......................................................................................... 29 3 MICRO/MACRO AND SOFT/HARD: DIVERGING AND CONVERGING ISSUES IN THE PHYSICAL AND SOCIAL SCIENCES ............................................................................ 35 ABSTRACT ............................................................................................. 35 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS .......................................................................... 35 INTRODUCTION AND OVERVIEW ............................................................ 36 SCALES IN THE SOCIAL SCIENCES: MIXING LEVELS OR WHAT IS THE DIFFERENCE?......................................................................................... 37 SCALES IN THE PHYSICAL SCIENCES: THE CLIMATE SYSTEM................. 40 THERE IS NOTHING AS PRACTICAL AS A GOOD THEORY ........................ 43 THE DIFFERENCES THAT MAKE A DIFFERENCE: SCALES IN CLIMATE CHANGE AND CLIMATE IMPACT RESEARCH........................................... 45 CONCLUSIONS ........................................................................................ 46 REFERENCES .......................................................................................... 47
4 SCALE AND SCOPE IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT: LESSONS FROM TEN YEARS WITH ICAM...................................................... 51 ABSTRACT ............................................................................................. 51 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS .......................................................................... 51 INTRODUCTION ...................................................................................... 52 LESSONS FROM DEVELOPING ICAM...................................................... 54 QUESTIONS, SCOPE AND SCALE ....................................................... 56 PERCEPTIONS, IMPACTS AND ADAPTATION ...................................... 62 SEA LEVEL RISE REVISITED .............................................................. 65 ENERGY MARKETS AND TECHNOLOGICAL PROGRESS....................... 67 SCALE, THE STUDY OF CLIMATE POLICY AND ITS EVOLUTION.......... 69 CONCLUSIONS ON SCOPE AND SCALE .................................................... 71 REFERENCES .......................................................................................... 72 5 SCALING ISSUES IN THE SOCIAL SCIENCES............................... 75 ABSTRACT ............................................................................................. 75 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS .......................................................................... 75 INTRODUCTION ...................................................................................... 76 SCALING TERMINOLOGY ........................................................................ 77 CONTEXT OF SCALE ISSUES IN SOCIAL RESEARCH................................. 79 SCALE ISSUES IN SOCIAL SCIENCE DISCIPLINES..................................... 82 SCALE ISSUES IN GEOGRAPHY.......................................................... 83 SCALE ISSUES IN ECONOMICS .......................................................... 85 SCALE ISSUES IN ECOLOGICAL ECONOMICS ..................................... 86 SCALE ISSUES IN URBAN STUDIES .................................................... 87 SCALE ISSUES IN SOCIOLOGY ........................................................... 87 SCALE ISSUES IN POLITICAL SCIENCE AND POLITICAL ECONOMY ..... 89 SCALE, SOCIAL SCIENCE DATA COLLECTION, REPRESENTATION AND ANALYSIS ...................................................................................... 93 SOCIAL SCIENCES METHODS ADDRESSING SCALE ................................. 96 CONTEXTUAL ANALYSIS.................................................................. 96 MULTI-LEVEL MODELING ................................................................ 97 HIERARCHY THEORY ....................................................................... 97 MODIFIABLE AREAL UNIT PROBLEM............................................... 97 SCALE, SOCIAL SCIENCE AND INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT MODELING ... 98 CONCLUSION ....................................................................................... 100 REFERENCES ........................................................................................ 101 6 SUSTAINABILITY AND ECONOMICS: A MATTER OF SCALE? .............................................................................................. 107 ABSTRACT ........................................................................................... 107 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ........................................................................ 107 INTRODUCTION .................................................................................... 108 RETURNS TO SCALE ............................................................................. 111 INDUSTRIAL DISTRICTS IN THE WORLD ECONOMY .............................. 114 BACK TO THE FUTURE ......................................................................... 116 CONCLUSION ....................................................................................... 121 REFERENCES ........................................................................................ 122
7 SCALES IN ECONOMIC THEORY .................................................. 125 INTRODUCTION .................................................................................... 125 SCALES AND AGGREGATION ................................................................ 126 SPACE AND AGGREGATION IN ECOLOGY ............................................. 128 SPACE AND AGGREGATION IN ECONOMICS .......................................... 129 SPATIAL RESOLUTION AND EMERGING PATTERNS OF LOCATION BEHAVIOUR ......................................................................................... 131 DOES SPATIAL RESOLUTION MATTER IN SCIENTIFIC DISCIPLINES THAT DEAL WITH SPACE?............................................................... 131 GEOGRAPHY .................................................................................. 132 REGIONAL ECONOMICS .................................................................. 133 CONCLUSION ....................................................................................... 136 REFERENCES ........................................................................................ 136 8 SCALING METHODS IN REGIONAL INTEGRATED ASSESSMENTS: FROM POINTS UPWARD AND FROM GLOBAL MODELS DOWNWARDS ............................................... 139 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ........................................................................ 140 INTRODUCTION .................................................................................... 140 SCALING UP IMPACTS .......................................................................... 141 SITE-DRIVEN APPROACHES ............................................................ 141 UNIFORM GRID APPROACH............................................................. 145 SPATIALLY COMBINED: UNIFORM GRIDS WITH RELATIONAL SOILS 148 SPATIAL INTERPOLATION APPROACH ............................................. 154 STOCHASTIC SPACE APPROACH...................................................... 158 DOWNSCALING .................................................................................... 162 OVERVIEW OF METHODS ............................................................... 162 ISSUES IN SCALING METHODS.............................................................. 167 INPUT DATA ................................................................................... 167 TECHNICAL EXPERTISE .................................................................. 167 VALIDATION .................................................................................. 168 UNCERTAINTY AND RISK ............................................................... 168 STAKEHOLDER PARTICIPATION ...................................................... 169 SCALING AGENTS .......................................................................... 169 CONCLUSIONS ...................................................................................... 170 REFERENCES ........................................................................................ 170 9 STRATEGIC CYCLICAL SCALING: BRIDGING FIVE ORDERS OF MAGNITUDE SCALE GAPS IN CLIMATIC AND ECOLOGICAL STUDIES ........................................................ 179 SCALING PARADIGMS IN MODELING COUPLED SYSTEMS .................... 179 ECOLOGICAL RESPONSES TO CLIMATE CHANGES AS SCALING EXAMPLES ........................................................................................... 183 SCALING ANALYSIS OF ECOLOGICAL RESPONSES ................................ 187 INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT VIA COUPLED SOCIO-NATURAL SYSTEMS MODELS ............................................................................................... 193 CONCLUSIONS ...................................................................................... 197 REFERENCES ........................................................................................ 198
10 THE SYNDROMES APPROACH TO SCALING ............................. 205 ABSTRACT ........................................................................................... 205 DEALING WITH GLOBAL CHANGE – THE SCALING PROBLEM AS ONE CRUCIAL ASPECT OF COMPLEXITY AND UNCERTAINTY ............... 205 IDEALISTIC DEDUCTION VERSUS REALISTIC INDUCTION...................... 207 SYNDROMES II: MODELLING, SPATIAL AND FUNCTIONAL SCALE OF VALIDITY ............................................................................................. 216 QUALITATIVE DIFFERENTIAL EQUATIONS – FORMALIZING COARSE FUNCTIONAL SCALES ..................................................................... 216 GENERAL HAZARDOUS FUNCTIONAL PATTERNS AND DETAILED LOCAL CASE STUDIES ..................................................................... 221 THE EXTENDED SAHEL HFP AND SPATIAL DISTRIBUTION OF TIME BEHAVIOURS.................................................................................. 227 CONCLUDING REMARKS ...................................................................... 230 APPENDIX A: IMPORTANT TERMS OF THE SYNDROME CONCEPT ......... 232 APPENDIX B: SYMBOLS USED FOR THE GRAPHICAL REPRESENTATION OF QUALITATIVE MODELS ................................................................... 232 REFERENCES ........................................................................................ 234 11 POLYCENTRIC INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT ............................. 237 ABSTRACT ........................................................................................... 237 INTRODUCTION .................................................................................... 238 THE DECISION PERSPECTIVE ................................................................ 238 NOVEL APPROACHES TO DECISION MAKING ................................... 240 THE IMPORTANCE OF SCALES .............................................................. 243 ENVIRONMENT HUMAN INTERACTIONS ACROSS SCALES ................ 243 CLIMATE CHANGE AND WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT FROM A SCALING PERSPECTIVE IN TIME AND SPACE ................................. 245 CLIMATE CHANGE AND BEYOND ......................................................... 248 SUSTAINABLE MANAGEMENT OF WATER RESOURCES ........................ 252 SOCIETAL TRANSITIONS AND LOCK-IN EFFECTS ............................. 253 MARKET BASED INSTITUTIONS FROM LOCAL TO GLOBAL SCALES .. 255 SUMMARY AND CHALLENGES FOR INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT ............ 257 REFERENCES ........................................................................................ 259 12 EMERGENT PROPERTIES OF SCALE IN GLOBAL ENVIRONMENTAL MODELING – ARE THERE ANY?............... 263 ABSTRACT ........................................................................................... 263 SCALES IN CLIMATE CHANGE IMPACT ASSESSMENT ........................... 264 HUMAN-ENVIRONMENT SYSTEMS AS COMPLEX AND HIERARCHICAL . 267 EMERGENCE: REAL OR IMAGINED?...................................................... 269 HIERARCHICAL EMERGENCE.......................................................... 271 SELF-ORGANIZATION AS A DYNAMICAL THEORETICAL BASIS FOR SCALE-RELATED EMERGENCE ............................................................. 275 AN APPLICATION TO THE PROBLEM OF THE VULNERABILITY OF THE USA AGRICULTURAL PRODUCTION SYSTEM TO CLIMATE CHANGE…..................................................................................... 278
EMERGENT PROPERTIES, VULNERABILITY AND RESILIENCE OF LAND USE SYSTEMS WITH ENVIRONMENTAL FORCING: THE CASE OF HURRICANE MITCH AND HONDURAN AGRICULTURE ...................... 282
ARE ISSUES OF SCALE AND SURPRISE CONNECTED?............................ 285 CONCLUSION ....................................................................................... 286 REFERENCES ........................................................................................ 287 13 COMPLEXITY AND SCALES: THE CHALLENGE FOR INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT ......................................................... 293 ABSTRACT ........................................................................................... 293 ACKNOWLEDGMENTS .......................................................................... 293 INTRODUCTION – THE EPISTEMOLOGICAL DIMENSION OF COMPLEXITY ....................................................................................... 293 PART 1 – HOLARCHIES, NON-EQUIVALENT DESCRIPTIVE DOMAINS, AND NON-REDUCIBLE ASSESSMENTS .................................................. 296 SELF-ORGANIZING SYSTEMS ARE MADE OF NESTED HIERARCHIES AND THEREFORE ENTAIL NON-EQUIVALENT DESCRIPTIVE DOMAINS ....................................................................................... 296 HOLONS, HOLARCHIES AND NEAR-DECOMPOSABILITY OF HIERARCHICAL SYSTEMS ............................................................... 300 THE EPISTEMOLOGICAL PREDICAMENTS IMPLIED BY THE AMBIGUOUS IDENTITY OF HOLARCHIES ......................................... 304 BIFURCATION, EMERGENCE AND SCIENTIFIC IGNORANCE .............. 307 NON-REDUCIBILITY (MULTIPLE CAUSALITY) AND INCOMMENSURABILITY ................................................................. 312 PART 2 – IMPLICATIONS OF COMPLEXITY AND SCALES ON INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT .................................................................. 319 THE EPISTEMOLOGICAL PREDICAMENT OF SUSTAINABILITY ANALYSIS ...................................................................................... 319 A NEW CONCEPTUALIZATION OF “SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT”: MOVING FROM “SUBSTANTIAL” TO “PROCEDURAL” RATIONALITY ..... 321 CONCLUSION ....................................................................................... 323 REFERENCES ........................................................................................ 324 14 SCALING IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT: PROBLEM OR CHALLENGE?................................................................................... 329 INTRODUCTION .................................................................................... 329 WHAT IS THE PROBLEM? ...................................................................... 330 SCALING IN IA-MODELS ...................................................................... 331 GRID-CELL BASED MODELLING...................................................... 332 CELLULAR AUTOMATA MODELLING .............................................. 333 MULTIPLE-SCALE REGRESSION MODELLING .................................. 333 SCALING IN IA-SCENARIOS .................................................................. 334 AGENTS AND SCALE ............................................................................. 339 UNCERTAINTY AND SCALE ................................................................... 343 IS THERE A SOLUTION?......................................................................... 346 CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS ............................................ 350 REFERENCES ........................................................................................ 352
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Many people contributed directly or indirectly to this book. First of all, we would like to thank the authors for their efforts and patience and for the fruitful discussions we had during the original workshop. Furthermore, we would like to thank all of our colleagues at the International Centre for Integrative Studies (ICIS) at Maastricht University for their help in finalising this book; special thanks to Frank Nelissen for his tireless effort in formatting the manuscript and Caroline van Bers for her incomparable organisation of the original workshop. Finally, we thank all of our colleagues from institutes and universities world-wide who have given us feedback on earlier versions of the chapters. Jan Rotmans & Dale S. Rothman
THE EDITORS Jan Rotmans and Dale S. Rothman are at the International Centre for Integrative Studies (ICIS), Maastricht University.
THE CONTRIBUTORS M. Bindi, DISAT, University of Florence, Florence, Italy R.J. Brooks, IACR Long Ashton Research Station, University of Bristol, Bristol, UK R.E. Butterfield, Environmental Change Institute, University of Oxford, Oxford, UK T. R. Carter, Finnish Environment Institute, Helsinki, Finland R. Delécolle, INRA – Unité de Bioclimatologie, Avignon, France T.E. Downing, Environmental Change Institute, University of Oxford, Oxford, UK Hadi Dowlatabadi, Sustainable Development Research Institute, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada William E. Easterling, Department of Geography and Center for Integrated Regional Assessment, The Pennsylvania State University, United States Tom P. Evans, Department of Geography, Center for the Study of Institutions, Population and Environmental Change, Indiana University, Bloomington, United States Mario Giampietro, National Institute of Research on Food and Nutrition (INRAN), Unit of Technological Assessment, Rome, Italy Clark Gibson, Department of Political Science, University of California, San Diego, United States Z. S. Harnos, Department of Mathematics and Informatics, University of Horticulture and Food Industry, Budapest, Hungary P. A. Harrison, Environmental Change Institute, University of Oxford, Oxford, UK A. Iglesias, Escuela Tecnica Superior de Ingenieros Agronomos, Cuidad Universitaria, Madrid, Spain Carlo C. Jaeger, Department of Global Change and Social Systems, Potsdam Institute of Climate Impact Research, Potsdam, Germany Kasper Kok, International Centre for Integrative Studies, University of Maastricht, The Netherlands M.K.B. Lüdeke, Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research, Potsdam, Germany S. Moss, Centre for Policy Modelling, Manchester Metropolitan University, Manchester, UK M. New, School of Geography and the Environment, University of Oxford, Oxford, UK J.E. Olesen, Department of Crop Physiology & Soil Science, DIAS, Research Centre Foulum, Tjele, Denmark J.L. Orr, Scottish Natural Heritage, Edinburgh, Scotland Elinor Ostrom, Department of Political Science, Center for the Study of Institutions, Population and Environmental Change, Indiana University, Bloomington, United States Henriëtte Otter, University of Twente, The Netherlands
Claudia Pahl-Wostl, Interdisciplinary Institute for Environmental Systems Science, University of Osnabrück, Germany G. Petschel-Held, Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research, Potsdam, Germany J. Porter, Department of Agricultural Sciences, Royal Veterinary and Agricultural University, Taastrup, Denmark Terry L. Root, Center for Environmental Science and Policy, Institute for International Studies, Stanford University, United States Stephen H. Schneider, Department of Biological Sciences and the Institute for International Studies, Stanford University, United States H.-J. Schellnhuber, Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research, Potsdam, Germany M. A. Semenov, IACR Long Ashton Research Station, University of Bristol, Bristol, UK Nico Stehr, Kulturwissenschaftliches Institut, Essen, Germany Richard Tol, Centre for Marine and Climate Research, Hamburg University, Hamburg, Germany; Institute for Environmental Studies, Vrije Universiteit, Amsterdam, The Netherlands; Centre for Integrated Study of the Human Dimensions of Global Change, Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, United States Anne van der Veen, University of Twente, The Netherlands Hans von Storch, Institute for Coast Research, GKSS Forschungszentrum, Geesthacht, Germany Thomas J. Wilbanks, Oak Ridge National Laboratory, Oak Ridge, Tennessee, United States J. Wolf, Department of Theoretical Production Ecology, Wageningen Agricultural University, The Netherlands
FOREWORD The past decades have seen the rise of a new academic field, Integrated Assessment, in which different strands of knowledge are combined in order to better represent and analyze real world problems of interest to decision-makers. For many, if not most, of these problems this means dealing with complex issues that operate at multiple scale levels. Especially the choices made in assessment regarding the geographic scale and the time scale of the issues considered and the inherent limitations involved, require more attention than given so far. Just as addressing problems from the perspective of a single discipline or sector can result in an incomplete and often problematic picture of society and societal concerns, so can focusing on a single scale and ignoring the interactions between and across scales. The ultimate effect is that decisions will be made and actions taken that may be inappropriate and, at times, coun-terproductive. For this reason, the European Forum on Integrated Environmental Assessment (EFIEA) was pleased to host a Policy Workshop on Scaling Issues in Integrated Assessment. This workshop, held from 12-19 July 2000 in the town of Mechelen, close to Maastricht in the Netherlands, brought together European and international experts who have been addressing these issues from many different perspectives. The papers in this volume were either prepared for or grew out of this workshop. As such, they provide a reflection of the state-of-the-art in addressing the issue of scaling in Integrated Assessment. They show that whereas increased effort has been exerted in this direction, there remains much to accomplish. For example the workshop illustrated that it is not just the geographic and the time scale that influence the set-up and the outcome of an assessment, the “scale” and range of institutions considered is an issue that requires explicit attention of integrated assessment researchers and practitioners. This volume presents the broad range of scaling issues relevant in Integrated Environmental Assessment. As such, it lays the foundation of further work in this important area of Integrated Assessment. Pier Vellinga Chair of EFIEA
LIST OF FIGURES Figure 2.1: Scale-dependent distribution of impacts of climate change ......... 8 Figure 2.2: Scale domains of climate change and cosequences .................... 11 Figure 2.3: Trajectories from global-scale expert analysis to local action.... 13 Figure 2.4: Macroscale/microscale interactions in global change................. 14 Figure 2.5: The GCLP concept ..................................................................... 15 Figure 2.6: Oak Ridge Climate Impact Response (CLIR) Model ................. 18 Figure 2.7: Oak Ridge approach for scale integration................................... 26 Figure 3.1: Scales in the atmospheric dynamics. .......................................... 40 Figure 3.2: a) EBM without noise, b) with noise. ......................................... 42 Figure 4.1: A global influence diagram of the climate change problem ....... 60 Figure 4.2: Local trends in relative sea level ................................................ 66 Figure 6.1: Sum of angles in a Euclidean triangle. ..................................... 109 Figure 7.1: Processes, interactions, analytical scale and traditional hierarchy in economics. ...................................................................... 130 Figure 8.1: Approaches for representing spatial variability in models: ...... 142 Figure 8.2: Comparison of the mean duration of ........................................ 148 Figure 8.3 Change in mean water-limited wheat yield ............................... 149 Figure 8.4. Schema showing the approaches for the spatial application of crops models ................................................................................... 152 Figure 8.5: Comparison between simulated model output variables (Sim) and the observed statistical data (Obs)................................................ 158 Figure 8.6: Flow chart showing the three types of calibration undertaken for STICS-Wheat and their application (Source: Delécolle [37]). ...... 160 Figure 8.7: Simulated distributions of yield for the observed climate ........ 161 Figure 9.1: “Cliff diagram” of equilibrium THC overturning varying ....... 196 Figure 10.1: Hypothesised process of the deduction of Hazardous Functional Patterns ............................................................................ 209 Figure 10.2: Approaches to identification of Hazardous Functional Patterns............................................................................................... 211 Figure 10.3: Network of interrelations for the Sahel-Syndrome-generating functional pattern ................................................................................ 213 Figure 10.4: Structure of the algorithm for calculating the disposition towards the SAHEL Syndrome, ............................................................ 214 Figure 10.5: Disposition towards the SAHEL SYNDROME under the present climate................................................................................................. 215 Figure 10.6: Climate sensitivity of the disposition towards the SAHEL SYNDROME (1/)................................................................................. 215 Figure 10.7: Basic relation for the didactic model to explain the qualitative modelling approach............................................................................. 218 Figure 10.8: Qualitative behaviours of the simple didactic model for a general logistic growth........................................................................ 219 Figure 10.9: Core mechanism of the original version of the SAHELSYNDROME. ......................................................................................... 222 Figure 10.10: Scheme of generalisation used to formulate a class of civilisation-nature interactions............................................................ 223
XVI LIST OF FIGURES
Figure 10.11: General scheme of case study integration into a common class of causes and effects................................................................... 224 Figure 10.12: “Behaviour tree" for the original Sahel HFP of causes and effects.................................................................................................. 226 Figure 10.13: Enhancement of the simple Sahel-HFP ................................ 228 Figure 10.14: Resulting behavior tree for the enhanced Sahel HFP ........... 229 Figure 11.1: Representation of the pathways relevant for decision making ................................................................................................ 240 Figure 11.2: A generic approach to represent decision making .................. 242 Figure 11.3: Different levels in a hierarchical systems. .............................. 244 Figure 11.4: Comparison of the PSI sequence ............................................ 246 Figure 11.5:Overview of the measures catalogue included in OPTIONS... 250 Figure 11.6: Lock-in effect preventing the spread of an innovation ........... 251 Figure 11.7: Determinants for lock-in effects in urban water management. ....................................................................................... 254 Figure 11.8: Some urban-rural couplings in urban water management. ..... 255 Figure 11.9: Different areas of research in agent based modeling .............. 258 Figure 12.1: Hypothetical aggregation error by up-scaling non-linear relations between crop yield and precipitation.................................... 266 Figure 12.2: The Human-Environment System .......................................... 268 Figure 12.3: Levels of a hierarchy .............................................................. 269 Figure 12.4: Cluster (square) aggregation method...................................... 272 Figure 12.5: Linear aggregation method..................................................... 273 Figure 12.6: Complexity versus randomness. ............................................. 276 Figure 12.7: Substitution of energy for labor in American agriculture in the 20th century. ............................................................................. 279 Figure 12.8: Four land-use system functions and the flow of events between them ...................................................................................... 283 Figure 12.9: Short-term and long-term effects of hurricane Mitch on cover percentage of maize in Honduras. ............................................. 284 Figure 13.1: Non-equivalent descriptive domains needed to obtain non-equivalent pattern recognition in nested hierarchical systems..... 298 Figure 13.2: Multi-objective integrated representation of the performance of a car. .......................................................................... 317 Figure 14.1: The IPCC SRES scenarios as branches of a twodimensional tree. ................................................................................. 335 Figure 14.2: Different scale levels of agent representation......................... 342 Figure 14.3: Multiple-scale representation of an institutional agent........... 343 Figure 14.4: Typology of sources of uncertainty ........................................ 344 Figure 14.5: Four phases of the transition curve........................................ 349
LIST OF TABLES Table 4.1: Four successive generations of ICAM ......................................... 55 Table 4.2: Climate questions climate change policy..................................... 58 Table 5.1: The relationships of analytical levels of human choice and geographic domains .............................................................................. 92 Table 8.1: Modelled mean, maximum and minimum yields calculated for MAFF’s Government Office Region .................................................. 153 Table 8.2: Approaches to downscaling ...................................................... .167 Table 10.1: Syndromes of global change.................................................... 212 Table 10.2: Comparison of important features of conventional modelling with ordinary differential equations (left) and qualitative modelling (right) using QDEs.............................................................................. 220 Table 12.1: Southeastern USA simulated corn yield response to 1960–1995 observed climate and CSIRO climate change (2×CO2) at different levels and shapes of units of aggregation: yields averaged over time and aggregation units ......................................................................... .274 Table 13.1: Multiple scientific explanations for a given event ................... 315 Table 13.2: Example of an impact matrix ................................................... 318
1 Introduction DALE S. ROTHMAN International Centre for Integrative Studies, University of Maastricht, The Netherlands
Introduction From 12–19 July 2000, the European Forum on Integrated Environmental Assessment (EFIEA) hosted a Policy Workshop on Scaling Issues in Integrated Assessment in the town of Mechelen, close to Maastricht in the Netherlands. This was the second of the so-called “Matrix” workshops, which addressed specific methodological topics relevant to Integrated Environmental Assessment in the context of policy-relevant issues. In each workshop, a group of approximately 50–60 participants, including EFIEA-members and other scholars, were brought together to explore theoretical and methodological issues and to share practical experiences. The first Matrix workshop was held in July 1999 in Baden close to Vienna, where the focus was on uncertainty. In the second workshop, the focus of this volume, the emphasis was on the issue of scaling in Integrated Environmental Assessment. Thus, it is commonly referred to as the EFIEA Scaling Workshop. Setting the Stage The issue of scale, both in time, space and quantity, is of fundamental importance in the field of Integrated Assessment. By definition Integrated Assessment deals with complex issues that operate at multiple scale levels. Within the natural sciences the scale-problem has already played an important role for some time. For many social scientists the scale issue is a relatively new area of concern, although its importance is increasingly recognized. Insights from both the social and natural sciences are of crucial importance in understanding the complex relationships between humans and the natural environment. There is a growing need for interdisciplinary approaches to scaling issues: approaches that combine insights from both the natural and social sciences. These interdisciplinary approaches can pave the way for a more common understanding of the role of scale in many current societal problems.
2 INTRODUCTION
To date, no grand ‘scale theories’ or standard procedures have been developed that allow integrated assessors to deal with different and multiple spatial scales, and with the short and long term in an appropriate and qualified manner in their assessment endeavors. The aim of the workshop therefore was to address this observed need and to take a significant step towards the development of heuristics, procedures and tools to address spatial and temporal scale issues. The workshop focused on various aspects of scales in Integrated Assessment with respect to data/indicators, models and scenarios. For each of these topics, the available theories and practical methods were screened for their contribution to Integrated Assessment. The workshop format combined lectures on topical issues around scale with more applied work sessions. Ten speakers, well known in the field of integrated assessment and modeling, prepared and presented papers during morning sessions. Building on these presentations, afternoon works sessions focused on topical issues related to several key themes: crossscale interactions; up and downscaling (including aggregation and disaggregation), scaling and modeling, scaling and scenarios, and scaling and indicators/ data. Based on these sessions, scaling concepts were clarified and further refined, and a research agenda was developed for subsequent explorations in scale management. This volume represents the key tangible output of the Scaling Workshop. In addition to the ten papers prepared and later refined by the key speakers, three other papers prepared by participants at the workshop are also included here. These papers reflect the wide range of topics that were addressed during this meeting. They point to a number of unresolved issues in the field of IA and point towards important areas for further research. Unfortunately, as the attendees will certainly attest, they cannot fully capture the breadth and depth of these discussions, along with the enthusiasm of the participants.
About this Book Wilbanks sets the stage by indication why scale matters in pursuing integrated assessments (IAs). Driving forces of environmental change come from and interact across different scales. He also raises the issue of agency and structure, i.e. the ability of individuals and groups to take action, but always under constraints. He also discusses operational issues of incorporating microand macro-scale information and perspectives in Integrated Assessment Models (IAMs). He lays out several key challenges related to data availability, upscaling, downscaling, integration, and cross-scale dynamics, all of which come back in later chapters. Stehr and von Storch point out the different approaches the social and physical sciences have take to addressing scale issues. Within the social sciences, debates have focused on macro-micro and agent-structure issues. The physical sciences provide a clearer hierarchical structure in the dorm of a cascade of spatial
SCALING IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT 3
(and temporal) scales. The key element they address, thought, is the often missing link between the analytical and practical capacity of knowledge. “The distinction between analytical and practical is particularly relevant to actors who have to deal with and convert scientific knowledge claims into practical action. Thus, choices of scale not only affect what can or will be analyzed but also what can or will be done. Dowlatabadi offers us a personal journey. Most significantly he draws in the importance of scale with respect to human cognitive processes – perception and awareness, and human social organization and the associated ability to act. Similar to Stehr and von Storch, these are seen to differ fundamentally from the usual physical dimensions. He draws upon insights into the scale or participation required versus that actually seen for climate policies – mitigation, adaptation, and geo-engineering. He also talks about meeting energy needs. Evans, et al. go further in exploring in more detail the role of scale in various social sciences. Unfortunately, but perhaps to be expected, they do not find a grand solution or even a consensus on either approaches or even definitions. They do point to common areas of concern, however. Also they nicely summarize what could be the holy grail of IAMs – “spatially explicit models that elegantly handle dynamic relationships and human decision making”. Jaeger and Tol point to the need for economic analyses to more deeply address laws and patterns that govern economic processes at different spatial, temporal, and institutional scales. This goes beyond what has been done before in the areas of micro- vs. macro- and short-run vs. long-run analyses. They point, for example, to the key role of increasing returns to scale. Van der Veen and Otter also focus on the issue of scale in economics, but approach it from a different angle. Focusing more specifically on regional economics, they emphasize the difficulties in understanding spatial resolution and human behavior in a uniform construct. Like Jaeger and Tol, they also note the somewhat arbitrary divisions between micro-, meso-, and macroeconomics. Downing, et al. take us into the practical issues of scale in terms of upscaling and downscaling in studies of the impacts of climate change and variability on agriculture in Europe. They show us that there is still much to learn in this area and how current practices can introduce additional uncertainties. May be worse when add agents??? Schneider and Root propose a more general strategy for bridging gaps related to scale, in particular geographical scale. In their approach, Strategic Cyclical Scaling, “large-scale associations are used to focus small-scale investigation in order to develop valid causal mechanisms generating the large-scale relationships.” This is somewhat different from traditional upscaling or down-scaling, which attempt to bring either the higher or lower scale directly into the model. Most significant is the requirement of “the development and fostering of interdisciplinary teams, and eventually, interdisciplinary communities, capable of unbiased peer reviewing of cross-scale, cross-disciplinary analyses in which
4 INTRODUCTION
the bulk of the originality is in the integrative aspects, rather than advances in the sub-disciplines that are coupled.” Schnellnhuber, et al. introduce us to the notion of Hazardous Functional Patters (HFPs) generating non-sustainable trajectories, or Syndromes, of the human nature system. They propose the use of Qualitative Differential Equations (QDEs) to analyze these. In relation to scale, these can help to bridge variability at the local scale and changes at the global or regional scale by identifying common patterns of behavior (or potential behavior) at a more intermediate, or functional scale. They also look at the issue of non-local interactions. Pahl-Wostl brings us more directly to the question of scales other than the traditional ones of time and space. Focusing on the importance of individuals and organizations, she points to the need to pay attention to levels of social organization and points toward agent-based and participatory methodologies. Easterling and Kok take up the challenge of scale in the context of the theory of hierarchical systems. They start from the premise that the systems of interest for Integrated Assessment are inherently nested hierarchical systems, which are “too complex for analytical solution and too structured and organized for pure statistical treatment.” In doing so, they emphasize that this calls for going beyond the preoccupation with bottom-up aggregation and top-down disaggregation. Many relevant properties of a system are emergent, i.e. they are difficult if not impossible to construct or predict from the constituent parts. Similarly, behavior in system components may be constrained by processes operating at a higher scale, in ways that might not be apparent from top-down disaggregation. Thus, it is important for IAMs to try to embed hierarchical structures explicitly. Giampietro also draws from hierarchy theory in his chapter. He emphasizes the importance of perspectives, i.e. how we interact with the system. Specifically, different perspectives, which include different choices of scale, reflect different reasons for analyzing, and can provide equally valid, but non-equivalent descriptions of, the same system. In many cases of IA, it will be necessary to adopt more than a single perspective to reflect both the general complexity of the issue and the different perspectives of different stakeholders. Finally, Rotmans rounds off this volume with a general reflection on the issue of scale in Integrated Assessment. He provides an overview of the challenges, both theoretical and practical, scale issues poses for the field. He also provides recommendations for moving forward even as a wide range of practitioners make initial tentative steps into what is in many cases unknown territory.
2 Geographic Scaling Issues in Integrated Assessments of Climate Change THOMAS J. WILBANKS Oak Ridge National Laboratory, Oak Ridge, Tennessee, United States
If top-down, large-scale integrated assessments of global climate change issues were all we need – sufficient to answer most of the important intellectual and practical questions about climate change impacts and responses – then scaling would not be an important enough topic to justify organizing this workshop. We are learning, however, that answering such questions often requires atten-tion to local scales as well as global, despite very serious operational complications in figuring out how to integrate local-scale analysis into com-prehensive integrated assessment modeling. Recognizing that we are in some respects nosing into territory that, if not entirely new, is still early in a serious exploration process, this paper first reviews how geographic scale matters in integrated assessments of global climate change issues. Next, it looks at operational issues in incorporating a variety of scales and cross-scale dynamics in integrated assessment modeling (overlapping several of the other papers prepared for the workshop). It concludes with some suggestions for research to improve our capabilities in dealing with macro-microscale interactions in global change processes. The intent here is not to dig into a few particular scaling issues in depth but to sketch the landscape of scale-related issues as a contribution to the general workshop discussion, reporting a not entirely integrated assemblage of recent experience that may have some bearing on scaling issues in integrated assessment.
How Scale Matters Our understanding about how scale matters is grounded in a number of basic concepts; it is increasingly informed by ongoing integrated assessment activities; and it can be illustrated by several of these activities.
6 GEOGRAPHICAL SCALING ISSUES IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENTS OF CLIMATE CHANGE
Basic concepts Understanding relationships between macroscale and microscale processes and phenomena is one of the “grand queries” of science [1], and this great intellectual challenge extends beyond geographic scale alone. Clearly, temporal scale raises equally important issues – i.e., between the short term and the long term – and geographic scale and temporal scale are often related in processes of interest; and organizational scale can also be significant in ways not entirely captured by spatial or temporal scale [2, 3]. Considering geographic or spatial scale in this paper, our thinking is generally shaped by several basic concepts that are not always recognized explicitly. For example, we tend to take the following notions as underlying premises: ■
■
■
■
When arrayed along a scale continuum from very small to very large, most processes of interest establish a number of dominant frequencies; they show a kind of lumpiness, organizing themselves more characteristically at some scales than others (see, for instance, Klemes [4] and Holling [5]). Recognizing this lumpiness, we can concentrate on the scales that are related to particular levels of system activity – e.g., family, neighbor-hood, city, region, and country – and at any particular level subdivide space into a mosaic of “regions” in order to simplify the search for understanding. In many (perhaps most) cases, smaller scale mosaics are nested within larger-scale mosaics; therefore we can often think in terms of spatial hierarchies [5]. As we look across mosaics at different levels of scale and spatial detail, the importance of cross-border linkages increases as the scale shrinks. This generalization clearly applies to external linkages at the particular scale of interest (e.g., multipliers in regional economics). It is not so clear that the generalization applies to the importance of cross-scale linkages: more important at small scales than large? Perhaps not: see below. Place is more than an intellectual and social construct; it is a real context for communication, exchange, and decision-making. More than a decade of research by “post-modernist” scholars has established that place has meaning for local empowerment, directly related to equity, and indeed for personal happiness in the face of space-time compression (e.g., Harvey [6], Smith [7], NAS [8]). Scale is not just an operational abstraction. It has meaning for people and processes, related to forms of social organization.
It is tempting, of course, to speculate about how many generalizations about macro-microscale relationships pertaining to geographic scale might apply to other kinds of scale as well. Consider, for instance, the four concepts above as they might apply to functional scale. Based partly on such concepts, it has been suggested that geographic scale matters in seeking an integrated understanding of global change processes and that understanding linkages between scales is an important part of the search for knowledge [9, 10]. Several of the reasons have to do with how the world
SCALING IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT 7
works. First of all, the forces that drive environmental systems arise from different domains of nature and society. For example, Clark has shown that distinctive systems imbedded in global change processes operate at different geographic and temporal scales [11]. Within this universe of different domains, local and regional domains relate to global ones in two general ways: systemic and cumulative [12]. Systemic changes involve fundamental changes in the functioning of a global system, such as effects of emissions of ozone-depleting gases on the stratosphere, which may be triggered by local actions (and certainly may affect them) but which transcend simple additive relationships at a global scale. Cumulative changes result from an accumulation of localized changes, such as groundwater depletion or species extinction; the resulting systemic changes are not global, although their effects may have global significance. A second reason that scale can matter is that the scale of agency – the direct causation of actions – is often intrinsically localized, while at the same time such agency takes place in the context of structure: a set of institutions and other regularized, often formal relationships whose scale is regional, national, or global. Land use decisions are a familiar example. This kind of local-global linkage is especially important where environmental impact mitigation and adaptation actions are concerned, analogous to hazards behavior. A third reason that scale can matter is that the driving forces behind environmental change involve interactions of processes at different locations and areal extents and different time scales, with varying effects related to geographical and temporal proximity and structure. Looking only at a local scale can miss some of these interactions, as can looking only at a global scale. For instance, geographers have shown that processes of change involve patterns of spatial diffusion that can be generalized, and ecological modelers such as Holling have found that managed biomes are characterized by landscapes with lumpy geometries and lumpy temporal frequencies related to the size and speed of process interactions, shaped by the fact that processes operating at different scales tend to show faster or slower dynamics [13]. Several additional reasons have to do with how we learn about the world. One of the strongest is the argument that complex relations among environmental, economic, and social processes that underlie environmental systems are too complex to unravel at any scale beyond the local. A second reason is that a portfolio of observations at a detailed scale is almost certain to contain more variance than observations at a very general scale, and the greater variety of observed processes and relationships at a more local scale can be an opportunity for greater learning about the substantive questions being asked (e.g., Fig. 2.1). In other words, variance often contains information rather than “noise.” A third reason is that research experience in a variety of fields tells us that researchers looking at a particular issue top-down can come to dramatically different conclusions from researchers looking at that very same issue bottomup. The scale embodied in the perspective can frame the investigation and shape the results, which suggests that full learning requires attention at a variety
8 GEOGRAPHICAL SCALING ISSUES IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENTS OF CLIMATE CHANGE
Figure 2.1: Scale-dependent distribution of impacts of climate change (adapted from Environment Canada [20])
of scales. As one example, Openshaw and Taylor [14] have demon-strated that simply changing the scale at which data are gathered can change the correlation between variables virtually from +1 to 1. These reasons, of course, do not mean that global-local linkages are salient for every question being asked about global change. What they suggest is more modest: that examinations of such changes should normally take time to consider linkages between different scales, geographical and temporal, and whether or not those linkages might be important to the questions at hand. Findings to date Quite a number of recent assessments and studies have offered learning experiences about how geographic scale matters in trying to understand global change and its impacts. Examples from a U.S. perspective include the “Global Change in Local Places” (GCLP) project funded by NASA through the Association of American Geographers, 1996–2000 [1, 9]; the first U.S. National Assessment of Possible Consequences of Climate Variability and Change (NACC), 1997–2000 [15]; the recent U.S. National Academy of Sciences/National Research Council report on pathways for a “sustainability
SCALING IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT 9
transition” [16]; and a variety of other activities, including the ongoing work of the Global Environmental Assessment Project (GEA) at Harvard University (e.g., Clark and Dickson [17]), the Long-Term Ecological Research (LTER) network sponsored by the National Science Foundation in the U.S. (e.g., Redman et al. [18]), and the Land-Use/Land Cover Change project jointly sponsored by the IGBP and the International Human Dimensions Programme. Learning from these and other recent research experiences – often related to and drawn from a variety of disciplinary literatures – one can offer some tentative findings about how geographic scale matters, stated as propositions as a basis for discussion. Even (especially?) in an era of globalization, attention to the local end of the spectrum is critically important. ■
■
■
■
Integrative research on complex sustainability issues is best carried out in a place-based context. According to recent reviews of the development of earth system science and global change research in the U.S. [19], the most fundamental change in the past decade has been a recognition that integrative research must be down-scaled and placefocused. This conclusion is reported as an empirically-based finding by both the NAS/NRC sustainability transition report and the U.S. national climate change assessment. Many important global change issues are inherently regional/local rather than global or national in scale. The most salient example is vulnera-bilities to impacts of global or national-scale processes. Clearly, the interest in bottom-up perspectives, or at least in down-scaling topdown perspectives, has grown as the emphasis in global change research has shifted from better understanding atmospheric dynamics toward better understanding impacts of climate change. Figure 2.1, for example, summarizes a key finding from the Canadian climate change assessment [20], that variations in net benefits from climate change appear much more clearly at more detailed scales. Local-scale attention is essential for implementing sustainability actions. It bounds the realistic and the possible in sustainability actions, identifies a wider range of opportunities for action, and assists in establishing effective larger-scale structures [1]. In other words, it helps to make sustainability more achievable. In fact, GCLP has noted a number of undesirable unintended local consequences in the U.S. of one-size-fits-all policy actions at a national scale. Local-scale investigation facilitates assessment as a social process. It encourages and facilitates exchanges of information and understanding between investigators and stakeholders, not just disembodied organizational representatives of stakeholders, which connects the issues with local empowerment, constituency-building, and other aspects of democratic decision-making at a variety of scales.
10 GEOGRAPHICAL SCALING ISSUES IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENTS OF CLIMATE CHANGE
Sustainability science needs to be sensitive to multiple scales rather than focused on a single scale. ■
■
■
■
Selection of a single scale can frame an investigation too narrowly. Whether the scale is global or local, a single scale of attention tends to focus on issues, processes, data, and theories associated with that scale, when a full, integrated understanding calls for attention to perspectives associated with other scales as well [21] (also see Gallegher and Appenzeller [22]). Moreover, research in a wide variety of fields has shown that the results of analysis can be scale-dependent (e.g., Rosswell et al. [23] and Joao [24]) and that, indeed, the concept of “equilibrium” is inherently scale-dependent in complex systems [25]. Schneider has suggested that different scales may be amenable to different research questions related to a common line of inquiry: e.g., larger scales to seek larger associations, smaller scales to ask “why” (see chapter 9). Phenomena, processes, structures, technologies, and stresses operate at different scales. This means that observations of processes at larger scales may not reveal causal mechanisms needed either to forecast system behavior reliably or to determine appropriate actions (e.g., Jarvis [26]). Conversely, observations at smaller scales may not reveal processes responsible for larger-scale patterns – nor the possibility of “emergent properties” (see chapter 12). It seems especially likely that scale is related to uncertainty and surprises, a central issue in considering climate change. A familiar case in integrated assessment is waste emission and disposal, which often involves processes at multiple scales: from local point-source emission streams to regional emission plumes to national regulatory structures. Moreover, the scale of such factors may be subject to change through time, as in the case of the scale of agricultural production in the U.S. Phillips [27] suggests that for any divergent landscape in earth surface systems, there are at least three scale ranges where fundamental system behavior differs. A particular scale may be more or less important at different points on a single cause-consequence continuum. Figure 2.2 illustrates such a continuum schematically, suggesting that for global climate change processes most emissions and many responses are relatively local, while radiative forcing is clearly global in scale. No single scale is ideal for broad-based investigation. The GCLP project found that arbitrary use of a one degree scale has no intrinsic value (see below), and the U.S. national climate change assessment found that there was no ideal scale for investigating regional impact issues (e.g., more detailed scales were better for stakeholder interaction but demanding in terms of funding, local expertise, and management requirements). In nearly every case, valid arguments can be made for either larger or smaller scales, or for boundary modifications to include or exclude activities of interest that have particular weight and might there-fore have a significant impact on general findings. A particular problem with using a latitude/longitude-
SCALING IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT 11
Figure 2.2: Scale domains of climate change and consequences (Source: Kates et al. [1]).
12 GEOGRAPHICAL SCALING ISSUES IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENTS OF CLIMATE CHANGE
oriented scale for local studies – whether one degree, half a degree, or some other grid size – is that the scale is unlikely to approximate the scale and boundaries of any significant decision-making unit, although “gridded” approaches are common in ecology and certain other fields. As a general rule, the GCLP experience indicates that, if the intent of a study is to inform decision-making, there is merit in relating the scale of the study to the scale of decision-making units appropriate to the issues of greatest interest (also see Cash and Moser [28]). Improving the understanding of scale dimensions of sustainability calls for certain kinds of research strategies. ■
■
■
Monitoring and data-gathering are needed at multiple scales, including careful attention to appropriate indicators. NACC, the sustainability transition study, GCLP, LTER, and other recent studies have concluded that our existing monitoring systems are inadequate for understanding multiple stresses at multiple scales. Building an effective knowledge base for comprehensive integrated assessment modeling requires fully-integrated observational systems, monitoring multiple variables at multiple scales. In the meantime, the sustainability transition study found no consensus on the appropriateness of existing indicators as a basis for such monitoring approaches [16]. “Protocols” for local-scale studies would improve prospects for aggre-gating their results. One of the most common reservations about bottom-up approaches to local-scale studies is that they usually take the form of case studies that can be exceedingly difficult to aggregate. GCLP suggests that the prospects that local area studies of global change, conducted by different people at different sites, can produce comparable results would be improved by encouraging individual studies to ask similar questions, generate data in similar categories based on similar techniques for measurement or estimation, and make data available in similar formats. Guidelines for such a shared approach can be termed a “protocol.” Unfortunately, at least in the U.S., existing protocols created for analyses at a regional or national scale, such as the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency’s state workbook, are not readily transferable to a local scale. For instance, they often call for data not available at the scales of smaller area units. What is needed, GCLP indicates, is a “process protocol” which describes a process for conducting local area studies that can be followed by study teams with varying resources and other constraints. Using local experts as “gate-keepers” helps in eliciting local knowledge and communicating with local stakeholders. A relatively robust finding in studies of environmental assessment experiences worldwide is that the results of assessments are much more likely to be put to use in local areas if they are channeled through local experts (i.e., the right-hand curve in Fig. 2.3). GCLP found the same thing to be true in the opposite direction as well. Local experts are uniquely suited to assist in accessing local knowledge,
SCALING IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT 13
Figure 2.3: Trajectories from global-scale expert analysis to local action.
■
because they are repositories of so much of that knowledge and because their local contact networks – often strength-ened by the presence of former students in local institutions – usually embrace the most important of the local information infrastructures. Effective approaches are needed for integrating top-down and bottom-up perspectives. GCLP, NACC, and other studies indicate that tools for integrating perspectives across spatial scales are still limited, although this is an area of research which is showing considerable creative activity (see “Operational Issues” below). From a modeling point of view, of course, a central issue is handling such integration in scientifically-valid ways that permit replication, along with evaluations of conditionalities and uncertainties.
Elements of a coherent story line about how scale matters If “all science is storytelling,” as we hear from our social theorist colleagues, we should try to turn these individual findings into a coherent story of how the macroscale and the microscale are connected in global change processes. Unsurprisingly, in trying to cover a broad continuum of geographic scales such a story is necessarily immersed in “on the one hand…; on the other hand…” perspectives. For example, we are coming to understand that on the one hand sustainability can only be operationalized for particular places, but on the other hand every place is affected by others. We know that many key actions are local, but most key actions are shaped by broader structures. We know that many of the strongest driving forces are translocal, but we also know that (a) many of the impacts are relatively local and that (b) in a demo-cratic society many of the responses are shaped by a cumulation of local concerns.
14 GEOGRAPHICAL SCALING ISSUES IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENTS OF CLIMATE CHANGE
Figure 2.4: Macroscale/microscale interactions in global change (Source: Kates et al. [1]).
The beginning of a coherent story, capturing these kinds of complications, is depicted schematically in Figure 2.4. Shaped themselves by external driving forces, local actions have systemic or cumulative impacts on processes that operate at global, national, or large-regional scale. If those impacts are judged to be undesirable or risky, there may be institutional responses at those larger scales, leading to structures designed to assure sustainability. That process, in turn, is shaped – at least in democratic societies – by support and/or opposition at local scales. The structures then provide enablement, constraints, and/or incentives to stimulate adaptive behavior at a local scale, leading to changes in local processes and actions; and the cycle continues. This picture is only offered as a basis for discussion, but it is evocative enough to suggest certain implications. For example, it suggests that actions aimed at driving forces need a larger-scale context, while actions aimed at impact reduction/adaptation need a smaller-scale context. It suggests that sustainability is grounded in linkages between different scales of concern. Taking this logic one more step, one might suggest that an over-emphasis on top-down forces can threaten sustainability by provoking backlash from disenfranchised local stakeholders, by being insensitive to local context, and by failing to empower local creativity. At the same time, an over-emphasis on bottom-up forces can also threaten sustainability by missing the importance of larger-scale driving forces, by being insensitive to larger-scale issues (temporal as well as spatial), and by being uninformed about linkages between places and scales. This
SCALING IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT 15
indicates a need for balance and harmony in a multiscale, interrelated system for assessment and action, when in so many cases philosophies, processes, structures, and knowledge bases are lacking to assure such a balance. An illustrative example: I One example of an effort to explore such interactions is the Global Change in Local Places research project of the Association of American Geographers, funded by what was at the outset NASA’s Mission to Planet Earth program. This project was focused on the challenge of linking scales in understanding global change. Conceived and designed in 1994 and 1995, it was concerned with three aspects of global change research at that time (Fig. 2.5): ■
■ ■
Changes in human activities that alter GHG emissions and uptakes and surface albedo Driving forces for these changes Capacities of localities to mitigate and adapt to changes
Figure 2.5: The GCLP concept (Source: Wilbanks and Kates [9]).
If the project had been designed a few years later, of course, it would have included a fourth aspect as well: local impacts of global change. At the time,
16 GEOGRAPHICAL SCALING ISSUES IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENTS OF CLIMATE CHANGE
however, the capacity to forecast climate change impacts at a regional scale was still quite limited, roughly five degrees latitude-longitude; and a climate change impact dimension of a much more localized study appeared infeasible. Initially, GCLP included three local study areas defined at a scale of approximately one degree (equatorial) latitude-longitude: the Blue Ridge – Piedmont area of Western North Carolina; a portion of the Central Great Plains in Southwestern Kansas, underlain by the Ogallala aquifer; and a portion of the traditional U.S. manufacturing belt in Northwestern Ohio. A fourth study area was added later – a six-county area in the vicinity of Pennsylvania State University in Central Pennsylvania – taking advantage of a strong overlap between the aims and approaches of GCLP and research activities already underway in Penn State’s Center for Integrated Regional Assessment. As GCLP proceeded, it was linked with a number of other activities also concerned with macroscale-microscale interactions in global change processes, such as NACC, the NAS/NRC sustainability transition study, GEA, and the evolution of the LTER concept in the U.S. In particular, it joined forces with the Cities for Climate Protection (CCP) program of the International Council for Local Environmental Initiatives (ICLEI), which had developed an Internetbased approach for assessing potentials for GHG emission reductions by cities and metropolitan areas that is now in use in more than 300 cities worldwide [29]. Findings from GCLP are still emerging, such as its analysis of potentials for the local study areas to meet hypothetical emission reduction targets in 2020; but some of the tentative findings may be of interest. Simply stated, the project found that local knowledge is important, albeit not for everything. The familiar slogan “Think globally and act locally” is inadequate because global or even national knowledge averages together too many distinctive local trajectories of action and change, missing potential response opportunities and making local actions more difficult. Local knowledge, however, is also inadequate, since for the most part the locus of decisions related to climate change responses is not locally-based. In general, GCLP found that local greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions are not greatly different from national patterns; the importance of a local scale of attention lies not in the big picture of emissions but in the details, and these details are especially important in understanding both trends through time and in identifying opportunities for local action. In the four GCLP sites, GHG emission details mainly reflected five factors: the location and fuel use of electricity generation, the degree to which the local economy has a natural resource orientation, the dynamics of local economic development, changes in technology through time, and growth rates in the number of households. Driving these factors are such underlying processes as consumer demand, regulation, energy supply and price, economic organization, and social organization. Within these contexts, the potential for local action to reduce GHG emissions is considerable, if: there is a conviction based on the local context
SCALING IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT 17
that such action is a good idea, there is some local control over significant emission decisions, and the locality has access to technological and institutional means to make a difference. On the other hand, the GCLP local area studies found that the current institutional framework in the U.S. does not motivate and facilitate local action, and the portfolio of technology opportunities is often a poor fit with local emission abatement potentials. An illustrative example: II A very different kind of example is a current research project at the Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL), supported by internal discretionary research funds. Initiated in October 1999, this three-year project – labeled “Improving the Science Base for Evaluating Energy and Environmental Alternatives” – is intended to improve the tools available for comparing benefits and costs of global climate change impact avoidance (i.e., GHG emission abatement) with benefits and costs of global climate change impact adaptation. Essentially, this project includes three main components: (1) developing and characterizing a taxonomy of adaptation pathways as a basis for comparison with available characterizations of mitigation pathways (most notably US DOE [30]); (2) improving the science base for pathway analysis, emphasizing macroscale/microscale integration and portfolio optimization (rather than optimization in terms of individual pathways based on a conventional supply curve); and (3) tool development for comparative analysis (Fig. 2.6 is a preliminary indication of the general structure of the tool). Even though the project is still in its early stages, scaling issues have already emerged as central to the activity. For instance (as a broad generalization), the benefits of GHG emission abatement are spread globally through their contributions to reducing the rate of increase in carbon concentrations in the earth’s atmosphere. Benefits of most adaptation pathways, on the other hand, tend to be associated with regionally or locally specific impact vulnerabilities, and therefore to generate benefits at a relatively local scale. This suggests that the results of a comparison of avoidance and adaptation pathways will depend on the scale of the analysis: a macroscale favoring avoidance actions and a microscale favoring adaptation actions. To the degree that climate change policy depends on intra-country political processes and thus net benefits at a regional or local scale, this may hint that adaptation will be favored by some of the key national players in global change policymaking in years ahead. Such a possibility, of course, is one reason for seeking an analytical approach which will produce an optimal course of action that is portfolio-oriented, including a combination for both adaptation and avoidance pathways. Incidentally, it also appears that the temporal scale of avoidance benefits and costs is longer, perhaps considerably longer, than the temporal scale of adaptation benefits and costs. Here again, there is a need to integrate both macroscale and microscale perspectives.
18 GEOGRAPHICAL SCALING ISSUES IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENTS OF CLIMATE CHANGE
Figure 2.6: Oak Ridge Climate Impact Response (CLIR) Model (Source: Wilbanks et al. [31]).
Operational Issues As an operational question, determining how to incorporate macroscale and microscale information and perspectives into integrated assessment models depends on the conceptual approach that is adopted, but it (ideally) involves two fundamental dimensions: incorporating information from multiple scales and incorporating information about interactions between scales. The principal alternatives Although the conceptual approaches that can be considered are probably as numerous as the investigators using them, at a very general level they can be categorized in one of two ways: (a) convergence at a single “meso” or regional scale or (b) seeking a multi-scale or meta-scale synthesis of insights from a number of scales. A third alternative, of course, is to continue to model at a global scale but to make an effort to aggregate data and process understandings from smaller scales [32]. Perhaps convergence approaches imply a perspective that process representations can be considered seamless across scales, while multi-scale or meta-scale perspectives imply a rejection of that point of view [33].
SCALING IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT 19
Convergence at a single “meso” or regional scale The most common approach is to integrate scale-related information at an intermediate scale as a way to provide a transition among various scales, either by converting data to a common geographic metric, by solving separately at different scales and then iterating to convergence, or by relying on empirical information about the scale of particular regional processes of interest: Conversion to a common metric One common approach, possibly the most-often used analytical strategy at present in climate change impact/response studies, is to down-scale information about global processes (such as global climate change) and up-scale information about local processes (such as agricultural production) to meet at an intermediate scale [34]. The current frontier appears to be a scale of one-half degree latitude-longitude, or a cell of about 50 km on a side, with the principal driving factor being limits on the down-scaling of climate change forecasts. Generally, the strategy is either to focus on the smallest scale that is feasible with available data sets or to determine the appropriate scale based on statistical analyses. In trying to define the most appropriate scale, one approach has been to try to find the scale at which data related to a particular question show maximum inter-zonal variability and minimum intra-zonal variability. Another identifies the scale, which minimizes statistical error between observed and modeled phenomena [35]. Still another seeks to balance the increased information from finer spatial resolution against the increased difficulty of gathering the information and modeling the processes [36]. Examples of such work include a variety of efforts by Linda Mearns of the U.S. National Center for Atmospheric Research (NCAR) and others to explore effects of climate variability and change on agriculture in the U.S., especially in the Southeast (e.g., Mearns et al. [37]). Among the challenges noted from this experience is mismatches in the scale resolution of different data sources [38]. Iterating to convergence An alternative is to use different analytical models to derive solutions at different scales and then to iterate back and forth until the results converge. This approach has been widely practiced, at least informally and qualitatively, for much of the past quarter-century. A recent example is incorporated in IIASA’s integrated assessment model for examining energy–economy– environment interactions [39]. One component of this modeling structure couples a top-down macroeconomic model, 11R, modified from the Global 2100 model developed by Manne and Richels, with a bottom-up dynamic LP model, MESSAGE III, that selects cost-minimizing technology combinations. The model-linking approach, as described by Wene [40], is based on iterative adjustments of aspects of the two different models until harmonization of their results is achieved.
20 GEOGRAPHICAL SCALING ISSUES IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENTS OF CLIMATE CHANGE
Empirical evidence of the scale of regional processes Still another approach is to select an intermediate or mesoscale for integrative analysis on the basis of case-by-case empirical evidence and qualitative understandings of the process involved, rather than based on formal modeling conventions or statistical analyses per se (e.g., Hirschboeck [41]). Although this approach can be difficult to capture in formal modeling logic and difficult to replicate precisely, it is both intuitively and intellectually attractive and also relatively easy to explain to external audiences. Many of the most thoughtful and evocative examples of the art of regional integrated assessment in recent years can be included in this category, including the Kasperson, Kasperson, and Turner book on Regions at Risk [42] and the focus of the German Advisory Council on Global Change [43] on characteristic “syndromes” that represent the greatest threats to sustainability [44], where the relevant scale is defined by looking in detail at the functions of processes and mechanisms (see chapter 10). Seeking a multi-scale or meta-scale synthesis Alternatively, one can try to get results from asking the same question at each of several scales and, rather than iterating to convergence on a single answer, preserve the different answers and seek a higher level of understanding that derives insights from all the answers: e.g., to what degree are the answers different across scales? One example of this approach is the Susquehanna River Valley study which has been carried out over a number of years by a multidisciplinary research team at Pennsylvania State University. This team has analyzed such issues as the net cost of a national carbon tax at four different scales, finding strikingly different answers depending on the scale of attention [45]. Another example is a recent study of prospects for adaptation to global climate change in Australian agriculture, including attention to both farm-level decision-making patterns and national scale trends and structures [46]. Yet another example is work in progress at Oxford University which mixes bottom-up and top-down approaches in constructing vulnerability indicators [47]. In essence, this research accepts the results of analysis at each of several scales as all being aspects of a larger truth and looks for broader understandings that embrace and aid in understanding the variety of single-scale answers, usually seeking these understandings through qualitative judgments by assessment experts and, in some cases, stakeholders. Two examples of methodological conceptions that illustrate this perspective are “strategic cyclical scaling” and “hierarchical patch dynamics” (strategic cyclical scaling [48] will be discussed in greater detail in chapter 9 in this volume). Very briefly, it proposes a continuing cycling between upscaling and downscaling approaches, with each affecting the design of the other; and the early tests of this paradigm have been encouraging.
SCALING IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT 21
Hierarchical patch dynamics emerged from several decades of attention to pattern-process relationships in ecology, stimulated by Watt [49]. This approach proceeds from a conception of large-scale ecologies as nested hierarchies of patch mosaics, with overall ecosystem dynamics related to patch changes in time and space but moderated by metastability at a larger scales, not necessarily destabilized by the transient dynamics often characterizing local phenomena [50]. Patch dynamics are normally modeled by analyzing pattern-process relationships at several (or all) levels in the hierarchy, then examining how the findings at the different levels relate to each other (e.g., a trend from less stability at more local scales to more stability at larger scales or a relationship between scale and the speed at which component subsystems operate). In some cases, dynamic simulation modeling is employed to explore such issues as the “incorporation” of instability among hierarchical levels. Comparing the two alternatives Obviously, neither approach is clearly preferable for every conceivable purpose. Incorporating multiple scales is intellectually satisfying and may in some cases pick up inter-scale differences and interactions missed by regional synthesis, and this approach seems more promising for systems in which some scenarios converge on steady state A while others converge on B or C (Schneider, personal communication). A focus on a single region, however, when that region has some intrinsic meaning in terms of the empirical scale of a key concern or the ability to make decisions and take actions, can enable a firm grounding in reality. The main determinants are likely to be utility, operational feasibility, and the purposes of the assessment. In several important respects, the two alternatives are in fact similar. Both require some upscaling of more localized data and some downscaling of data and/or forecasts from global and other very large scales. Both are shaped by understandings derived from the general scientific literature (a kind of downscaling in which most upscaling is embedded: Root and Schneider [48]); and both are cognizant of relatively high-visibility findings from localized experience, including the investigators’ own life experiences. In addition, neither alternative necessarily addresses cross-scale dynamics, although neither excludes them. In terms of philosophical orientation, the practice of meta-scale synthesis appears to be more directly concerned with this dimension of integrated assessment. The principal challenges The challenges faced in operationalizing these approaches as ways to incorporate scaling into integrated assessment modeling range from conceptual to technical and data-based. As a very broad generalization, it can be suggested that the most fundamental challenges to regional synthesis are data-based, while the most fundamental challenges to meta-scale synthesis are conceptual.
22 GEOGRAPHICAL SCALING ISSUES IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENTS OF CLIMATE CHANGE
Regional synthesis Obviously, operating at a single mesoscale requires some combination of upscaling, downscaling, and integration. One of the richest bodies of research experience in meeting this challenge is Geographic Information System (GIS) research (e.g., Quattrochi and Goodchild [51], NCGIA [52], Turner et al. [53], Turner [54] and, for relationships with simulation modeling: Wilson and Burrough [55]), although the preoccupation of GIS research with integrating spatial patterns is an imperfect fit with the needs of integrated assessment. For instance, the very substantial GIS problem of upscaling line patterns such as rivers and highways for display at a much more general scale is not the sort of thing that worries an integrated assessment modeler. On the other hand, the challenges associated with converting data for areal units into different spatial metrics are similar, and the abler GIS practitioners share a strong interest in process understanding in order to assure that the tool is both substantively valid and socially useful. Another substantial body of experience, of course, is landscape ecology (e.g., Rastetter et al. [56], Turner et al. [57]). Upscaling Many kinds of data pertinent to macroscale issues are gathered at specific points or in small areas, ranging from meteorological observations to crop production to soil samples. In addition, if future research support follows recent conclusions that integrated assessments of complex issues should be placeoriented, often implying a small-regional scale, then building larger-scale understandings from a growing portfolio of more or less localized case studies is an upscaling challenge that will be growing. Essentially, upscaling is an aggregation challenge, and a very serious technical challenge indeed [58, 59] (see also Curran et al. [60], Butterfield et al. [61]; Smith et al. [62]). In many cases, data cannot simply be aggregated to estimate larger-scale values, such as regional agricultural production or climate processes. For instance, the data may fail to meet standards for valid sampling, or they may fail to represent stochastic and geographic variability in representing how processes work. As one example, it has been shown that an estimated response to an “average” environment can be a biased predictor of a “true” aggregate response [63]. Or aggregate totals may lose information about variability that is instructive, or the value of the aggregate may be undermined by the fact that processes operate differently at different scales (i.e., “local” is not necessarily micro-global). The challenge is especially complicated when larger-scale characterizations are being constructed from incomplete local evidence: e.g., from a small number of at least somewhat idiosyncratic case studies (regardless how sound they may be). One such problematic situation is an effort to aggregate estimates of the net economic cost of climate change impacts on small areas in order to arrive at a total global or continental net cost, which has been a
SCALING IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT 23
subject of discussion in producing the Third Assessment Report of IPCC Working Group II (Impacts, Adaptation, and Vulnerability) [64]. A number of technical alternatives for dealing with statistical problems in upscaling have been outlined by Harvey [58], including distributed point process modeling, parameterization of patch interactions, linking mechanistic models between scales, changing model resolution, and creating new models. Another approach is regional calibration: comparing aggregates of individual records with regional records. Rastetter et al. [56] identify four methods: partial transformations using a statistical expectations operator, moment expansions, partitioning based on spatial autocorrelation, and regional calibration (regarding the use of interpolation to fill gaps in upscaling, see chapter 5). Downscaling Downscaling is equally essential as an aspect of integrated assessment, because so many critical driving forces – e.g., global climate dynamics, global population growth, global economic restructuring, and global technology portfolios – operate at very large scales but shape local realities and choices. In this connection, it goes without saying that the integrated research community recognizes the limitations of top-down paradigms based on global or near-global scale modeling alone [43]. Modelers are moving toward more detailed geographic scales and topical richness, using both numerical (i.e., model-based) and empirical (i.e., data-based) approaches (for one review, see Bass and Brook [65]; for an example of the current state of the art, see Easterling et al. [66]). Challenges include limited data availability at detailed scales (at least without expensive new data-gathering), the increasing complexity of causal relationships as models become more like the real world, challenges of capturing contextual detail to approximate local reality more closely (e.g., incorporating terrain in climate change modeling), and in some cases computational capacity (although advances in computing have reduced this constraint considerably). An example of the breadth of the current downscaling research enterprise is the range of approaches being applied experimentally in Pennsylvania State University’s Susquehanna River basin study (Yarnal, personal com-munication). Four approaches have been used to date. In one approach, Jenkins and Barron [67] embedded a regional climate model in a global circulation model, showing significant improvements over precipitation projections from the GCM alone. A second approach linked a nested version of a mesoscale meteorological model to a hydrological model system, which simulates basin hydrology at relatively detailed scale [68]. A third approach employed artificial neural network analysis for empirical climate downscaling to investigate cross-scale relationships between large-scale circulation and humidity fields and local precipitation [69]. A fourth approach used more traditional synoptic climatological analysis to relate atmospheric dynamics to various scales of basin runoff, showing different characteristic responses for different basin scales [70].
24 GEOGRAPHICAL SCALING ISSUES IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENTS OF CLIMATE CHANGE
One of the forces encouraging downscaling is an interest in fostering public participation in discussions of issues being addressed by integrated assessment [71]. A frequent discovery in such a process is that, as presently constructed, models do not always produce answers to the questions being asked. This has led to consideration of “inverse” approaches to assessment modeling, beginning with relevant bottom-up questions and working back toward appropriate modeling structures. In this sense, listening to local concerns can help to catalyze a rethinking of how integrated assessment modeling is done. Integration Once all relevant data are converted to a common metric, or an algorithm for iterative convergence is specified, the integration challenge has been greatly simplified – but in some cases perhaps misleadingly so. If the aim is to attain an integrated understanding of processes, simply converting numbers to a common spatial scale does not necessarily assure conceptual integration, as contrasted with computational integration. In most cases, full integration also involves attention to interactions between processes that operate at different scales, because processes and controls that shape them, and appropriate representations of them, may not be scale-invariant. It often involves bridging between analytical styles, e.g., top-down models and bottom-up case studies, in order to understand the meaning behind the different perspectives imbedded in the source data. In addition, it is often a matter of reconciling differences in process assumptions, theoretical foundations, and perceived standards as to what constitutes the best science, sometimes rooted in different disciplinary traditions. Further, because different interacting processes may operate at different scales (e.g., between the scale of ecosystems and the scale of governmental units making decisions about them), efforts to incorporate a variety of linkages in a single analysis or action often must confront problems of “scale mismatch” [72, 28]. Among the avenues being investigated are “adaptive” approaches to analysis and assessment, which permit modifications of the scale as more is learned about the relevant processes and their interactions. What we know is that how integration is done can affect its outcomes. It is at least arguable that in many cases integration incorporates certain values of the modeler – often implicitly, sometimes without the modeler’s full awareness – and that this undermines the supposed objectivity of the process [73]. We also know that the scale at which integration is performed and results are reported can affect uses of the work (see chapter 3). Addressing cross-scale dynamics A profound general problem, because so much data collection and analysis occurs at a particular scale, large or small, is that data (and understandings)
SCALING IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT 25
are often scarce about cross-scale relationships and interactions. The challenge is to simultaneously capture driving and constraining forces at multiple scales and how they relate to each other [74]. Aside from system dynamics types of approaches, the most common strategy is to call upon hierarchy theory [75, 76, 77], which assumes that interactions between the dynamics of processes and structures at different scales shape systems at any one scale and that, therefore, hierarchies of scale-related processes define “constraint envelopes” within which systems can operate. Hierarchical perspectives can, however, be applied without necessarily relying on hierarchy theory. An example of a formal statistical approach related to this perspective, concerned with multiscale statistical inference, begins with a set of hierarchically defined partitions and then combines “data likelihoods” at each scale with a Bayesian prior probability structure [78]. One problem, of course, is that cross-scale dynamics may not always fit neatly into hierarchical structures. Still another possible source of ideas – at least for cross-scale pattern dynamics – is the literature on fractal structures [79], which suggests a predictable relationship between the scale of measurement and the measured phenomenon. Whether such relationships might also hold for non-pattern aspects of chaotic system dynamics is not so clear. A positive recent step has been efforts (e.g., by the U.S. National Science Foundation) to establish richer information infrastructures, especially regarding longitudinal data sets, although – as we all know – assuring continued financial support for really long-term data collection structures is a continuing challenge. Meta-scale synthesis On one level, it is not too difficult to outline a general approach for utilizing perspectives from multiple scales. Elements of a general strategy would include definition of a question to be answered (e.g., how much may climate change impacts be reduced by autonomous adaptation, or how much is biodiversity likely to be reduced by global climate change); conversion of the questions into operational definitions amenable to quantitative measurement and analysis, consistent with available data; selection of two or more scales, ideally perhaps three or four related to relevant conceptions of hierarchical levels in processes of interest [80], a compromise between an intellectual interest in all levels and resource limitations; calculation of an answer to the question at each of the scales; displaying the set of answers in a format that provides insights about patterns and/or relationships; and derivation of findings from that display, maybe using more or less standardized conventions. This strategy, however, only fills only a part of the need. It has the clear potential to illuminate differences among scales in functional relationships important in understanding global change, avoiding tunnel vision from looking at such relationships at only one scale. It may not, however, necessarily
26 GEOGRAPHICAL SCALING ISSUES IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENTS OF CLIMATE CHANGE
illuminate interactions between scales. Addressing cross-scale dynamics in integrated assessment seems to call for one of four approaches (or a combination of them): (a) the kind of cyclical analysis proposed by strategic cyclical scaling, with each scale iteration including specific attention to interactions with other scales, (b) use of a methodology that delivers simultaneous solutions of equations representing within-scale and cross-scale relationships, such as system dynamics approaches, (c) finding and adopting a conceptual/theoretical construct that relates the macroscale and microscale processes, such as the patch-dynamics hypothesis and/or hierarchy theory, or (d) stepping out beyond the formal integrated assessment activity to access macroscale-microscale interaction understandings from relevant literatures and/or expert judgments, inserting the resulting understandings as additional model specifications, parameters, variables, or uncertainties. One example of a possible integrative approach is outlined conceptually in Figure 2.7; note the challenge of integrating both multiscale and cross-scale understandings in a single computational system.
Figure 2.7: Oak Ridge approach for scale integration.
For these and less ambitious meta-scale integration goals, three central challenges are worth considering: Data availability GCLP found that many questions being addressed by research protocols at global, national, or large regional scales cannot be pursued readily at more
SCALING IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT 27
local scales because of a lack of availability of data at those detailed scales. For climate change studies, the most familiar example is climate change forecasts at local scales, e.g., for a major city in a developing country. But the data gap is even more critical regarding impacts of climate change at a local scale, and it is still more problematic regarding local capacities to cope, adapt, and otherwise respond to risks or realities of impacts. Meanwhile, dealing with relatively localized scales by generalizing from a few detailed case studies is also problematic. This suggests that, for many purposes, balanced multi-scale or meta-scale synthesis is fundamentally undermined by data limitations at local scales. Creating formal quantitative structures that synthesize Incorporating meta-scale synthesis into integrated assessment modeling would ideally include a model component that provides an artificial-intelligence equivalent of human integrative judgment: not only combining numbers and applying mechanical algorithms but applying some form of synthesizing “reasoning.” This appears to be a laudable goal for the long term, but the fact remains that handling synthesis formally within the structure of an integrated assessment model requires quantitative structures appropriate to the questions being asked. A pertinent question at this stage is the degree to which this process can be generalized in integrated assessment models vs. being tailored for each question, represented in the overall modeling formulation as an exogenous input to be specified on a case-by-case basis. The current state of the art seems to require identifying a manageable number of key relationships for each case. Formalizing processes for combining quantitative and qualitative analysis One of the frontiers of integrated assessment, many practitioners believe, is transcending a boundary between quantitative analysis and non-quantitative components of an assessment process. Particular challenges range from incorporating expert judgment to incorporating narrative “stories,” scenarios, and analogs along with stakeholder knowledge bases [81]. One intriguing possibility is formal qualitative modeling, where broad insights do not depend on the precise shape of curves [43]. Another direction of interest is incorporating fuzzy logic in simulation modeling [55].
Directions for Improving our Capabilities If we want to improve our ability to meet these challenges, probably not by selecting a single operational approach for all purposes but by enhancing a variety of kinds of approaches as we learn further lessons from experience with integrated assessment modeling, what are the most important cross-cutting directions for research – and for research funding? In general, it appears that the easiest pieces of the puzzle to create are the computational ones, although
28 GEOGRAPHICAL SCALING ISSUES IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENTS OF CLIMATE CHANGE
such issues as the representation of uncertainty and nonlinearities continue to be challenges that transcend scale-related questions alone. Rather than being limited by computational capabilities or the ability to model processes and relationships once we know them and have data about them, the state of the art is first of all profoundly data-limited [82, 58]. It is also still conceptually limited, not so much in representing more than one scale but in representing interscale processes and interactions. Given these realities, I would suggest the following directions as sort of a skeleton for a multidisciplinary, multi-institutional, multinational research agenda to improve our capabilities for addressing scale and scaling issues in integrated assessment: ■
■
■
■
■
Increase the availability of local or small-regional scale data, related to key issues and indicators. While this is obviously a resource-intensive process, it is an essential building block. One possible direction for exploration may be an expanded use of instrumentation for routine data-gathering; but it is important first to determine key indicators in order to assure that our modeling will be indicator-driven rather than merely data-driven. Improve longitudinal databases related to complex nature-society interactions and multiple stresses. A related need is to increase our knowledge base about interconnected phenomena and processes that crossdisciplinary boundaries, especially between nature and society, and to imbed our expanding understandings in comprehensive databases maintained over long periods of time. Identify key macroscale-microscale interaction issues and improve understanding of those key interactions. Along lines barely hinted at by Figure 2.4, we need to strengthen both theoretical and empirical understandings of the major components of cross-scale dynamics in global change processes, in order to determine how best to build this dimension into integrated assessment models. Explore tools for dynamic modeling of complex systems that are not now widely used in integrated assessment modeling. Most of our current modeling structures were built to understand process interactions at a very large scale. It is possible that structures intended to illuminate complex multi-scale system dynamics will need to use different tools, from system dynamics (or other approaches for deriving simultaneous solutions) to such alternatives as fuzzy logic, dynamic spatial simulation modeling, and applications of the science of complexity. Improve understandings of how to link analysis, assessment, deliberation, and stakeholder interaction. Finally, it seems clear that some aspects of the integrated assessment effort – especially related to upscaling from smallregional case study experiences, incorporating uncertainties in scenario construction, and involving stakeholders as experts in their own domains – will call for new paradigms for relating quantitative and non-quantitative contributions to our enterprise.
SCALING IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT 29
References 1.
2. 3.
4. 5. 6. 7. 8.
9. 10.
11. 12.
13.
14.
15.
Kates, R. W., T. J. Wilbanks, and R. Abler (eds.): Global Change in Local Places: Estimating, Understanding, and Reducing Greenhouse Gases. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Gibson, C., E. Ostrom, and T-K. Ahn, 1998. “Scaling Issues in the Social Sciences.” IHDP Working Paper no. 1. Bonn: IHDP. Gibson, C. C., E. Ostrom, T-K. and Ahn, 2000. “The Concept of Scale and the Human Dimensions of Global Change: A Survey.” Ecological Economics 32: 217–39. Klemes, V., 1983. “Conceptualization and Scale in Hydrology.” Journal of Hydrology 65: 1–23. Holling, C. S., 1992. “Cross-scale Morphology, Geometry, and Dynamics of Ecosystems.” Ecological Monographs 62: 447–502. Harvey, D., 1989. The Growth of Postmodernity. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins. Smith, N.: Homeless/Global: Scaling Places. In: J. Bird et al. (eds.). Mapping the Futures: Local Cultures, Global Change. Towards a Comprehensive Geographical Perspective on Urban Sustainability, 1999. Final Report of 1998 National Academy of Science Workshop on Urban Sustainability, New Brunswick: Rutgers – The State University of New Jersey, Center for Urban Policy Research Wilbanks, T. J., and R. W. Kates, 1999. “Global Change in Local Places.” Climatic Change 43: 601–628. Alexander, J. C., and B. Giesen, 1987. “From Reduction to Linkage: the Long View of the Micro-Macro Debate.” in: J. C. Alexander et al. (eds.). The Micro-Macro Link, Berkeley: University of California: 1–42. Clark, W. C., 1985. “Scales of Climate Impacts.” Climatic Change 7: 5–27. Turner, B. L. II, R. E. Kasperson, W. B. Meyer, K. M. Kow, D. Golding, J. X. Kasperson, R. C. Mitchell, and S. J. Ratick, 1990. “Two Types of Global Environmental Change: Definitional and Spatial Scale Issues in Their Human Dimensions.” Global Environmental Change 1: 14–22. Holling, C. S., 1995b. “What Barriers? What Bridges?” In: L. H. Gunderson, C. S. Holling, and S. S. Light (eds.). Barriers and Bridges to the Renewal of Ecosystems and Institutions. New York: Columbia University: 3–34. Openshaw, S., and P. J. Taylor, 1979. “A Million or So Correlation Coefficients: Three Experiments on the Modifiable Areal Unit Problem.” in: N. Wrigley (ed.). Statistical Applications in Spatial Science, London: Pion: 127–144. USGCRP, 2000. Climate Change and America: The Potential Consequences of Climate Variability and Change for the United States. U. S. Global Change Research Program, Washington, DC.
30 GEOGRAPHICAL SCALING ISSUES IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENTS OF CLIMATE CHANGE
16. NAS/NRC, 1999. Our Common Journey: A Transition Toward Sustainability. Board on Sustainable Development, National Research Council. Washington: National Academy Press. 17. Clark, W. C., and N. M. Dickson, 1999. “The Global Environmental Assessment Project: Learning from Efforts to Link Science and Policy in an Interdependent World.” Acclimations 8: 6–7. 18. Redman, C., J. M. Grove, and L. Kuby, 2000. “Toward a Unified Understanding of Human Ecosystems: Integrating Social Science into Long-Term Ecological Research.” Working Paper, Long Term Ecological Research (LTER) Network. 19. Corell, R., 2000. Prepared remarks at a symposium in his honor: “A Decade of Global Change Research: Accomplishments and Future Directions of Earth System Sciences.” Fairfax, VA, May 15. 20. Environment Canada, 1997. The Canada Country Study: Climate Impacts and Adaptation. Adaptation and Impacts Research Group, Downsview, Ontario. 21. Cash, D. W., and S. C. Moser, 1998. “Cross-scale Interactions in Assessments, Information Systems, and Decision-making.” In: A Critical Evaluation of Global Environmental Assessments. Global Environmental Assessment Project. Cambridge: Harvard University. 22. Gallegher, R., and T. Appenzeller, 1999. “Beyond Reductionism.” Science 284: 79. 23. Rosswell, T., R. G. Woodmansee, and P. G. Risser, 1988. Scales and Global Change, New York: Wiley. 24. Joao, E., 2000. “The Importance of Scale Issues in Environmental Impact Assessment and the Need for Scale Guidelines.” Research Papers in Environmental and Spatial Analysis, No. 62. Department of Geography and Environment, London School of Economics. 25. Malanson, G. P., 1999. “Considering Complexity.” Annals of the Association of American Geographers 89: 746–753. 26. Jarvis, P. G., 1993. “Prospects for Bottom-Up Models.” in: J. R. Ehleringer and C. B. Field, (eds.). Scaling Physiological Processes: Leaf to Globe, New York: Academic Press: 117–126. 27. Phillips, J. D., 1999. Earth Surface Systems: Order, Complexity, and Scale. Oxford: Blackwell. 28. Cash, D. W., and S. C. Moser. 2000. “Linking Global and Local Scales: Designing Dynamic Assessment and Management Processes.” Global Environmental Change 2: 109–120. 29. Kates, R. W., M. Mayfield, R. Torrie, and B. Witcher, 1998. “Methods for Estimating Greenhouse Gases from Local Places.” Local Environment 3: 279–298. 30. U.S. Department of Energy, 1997. Technology Opportunities to Reduce U.S. Greenhouse Gas Emissions, Appendix B: Technology Pathways, Washington, DC: DOE. 31. Wilbanks, T. J., P. Leiby, R. Perlack, T. Ensminger, S. Hadley, and S. Wright, 2002. Tools for an Integrated Analysis of Mitigation and
SCALING IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT 31
32.
33.
34.
35.
36. 37.
38.
39. 40. 41.
42. 43. 44. 45.
46.
Adaptation as Responses to Concerns about Impacts of Global Climate Change. ORNL Report, Oak Ridge National Laboratory. Rotmans, J., 1998. “Global Change and Sustainable Development: Towards an Integrated Conceptual Model.” In: Schellnhuber, H-J., and V. Wenzel (eds.), 1998. Earth System Science: Integrating Science for Sustainability. Berlin: Springer-Verlag: 421–453. Bauer, B. O., J. A. Winkler, and T. T. Veblen, 1999. “Methodological Diversity, Normative Fashions, and Metaphysical Unity in Physical Geography.” Annals of the Association of American Geographers 89: 771–778. Easterling, W. E., 1997. “Why Regional Studies Are Needed in the Development of Full-scale Integrated Assessment Modelling of Global Change Processes.” Global Environmental Change 7: 337–356. Easterling, W. E., A. Weiss, C. Hays and L. O. Mearns, 1998. “Spatial Scales of Climate Information for Simulating Wheat and Maize Productivity.” Agricultural and Forest Meteorology 90: 51–63. Costanza, R., and T. Maxwell, 1994. “Resolution and Predictability: An Approach to the Scaling Problem.” Landscape Ecology 9: 47–57. Mearns, L. O., 2000. “The Issue of Spatial Scale in Integrated Assessments: An Example of Agriculture in the Southeastern U.S.” paper presented at the annual meeting of the Association of American Geographers, Pittsburgh, April. Mearns, L. O., T. Mavromatis, E. Tsvetsinskaya, C. Hays, and W. Easterling, 1999. “Comparative Response of EPIC and CERES Crop Models to High and Low Spatial Resolution Climate Change Scenarios.” Journal of Geophysical Research 104: 6623–6646. Grubler, A., N. Nakicenovic, and A. MacDonald, 1998. Global Energy Perspectives. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Wene, C. O., 1996. “Energy-economy Analysis: Linking the Macroeconomic and Systems Engineering Approaches.” Energy 21: 809–824. Hirschboeck, K. K., 1999. “A Room with a View: Some Geographic Perspective” Annals of the Association of American Geographers 89: 696–706. Kasperson, R., J. Kasperson, and B. L. Turner, 1995. Regions at Risk. Tokyo: United Nations University. Schellnhuber, H-J., and V. Wenzel (eds.), 1998. Earth System Science: Integrating Science for Sustainability. Berlin: Springer-Verlag. WBGU (German Advisory Council on Global Change), 1997. World in Transition: The Research Challenge. Berlin: Springer-Verlag. Abler, D. G., J. Shortle, A. Rose, and G. Oladosu, 2000. “Characterizing Regional Economic Impacts and Responses to Climate Change.” Global and Planetary Change 25: 67–81. Risbey, J., M Kandlikar, H. Dowlatabadi, and D. Graetz, 1999. “Scale, Context, and Decision Making in Agricultural Adaptation to Climate Variability and Change.” Mitigation and Adaptation Strategies for Global Change 4: 137–165.
32 GEOGRAPHICAL SCALING ISSUES IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENTS OF CLIMATE CHANGE
47. Downing, T. E., R. Butterfield, S. Cohen, S. Huq, R. Moss, A. Rahman, Y. Sokona, and L. Stephen, 2001. “Climate Change Vulnerability: Toward a Framework for Understanding Adaptability to Climate Change Impacts.” Environmental Change Institute, Oxford University. 48. Root, T. L., and S. H. Schneider, 1995. “Ecology and Climate: Research Strategies and Implications.” Science 269: 334–341. 49. Watt, A. S., 1947. “Pattern and Process in the Plant Community.” Journal of Ecology 35: 1–22. 50. Wu, J., and O. L. Loucks, 1995. “From Balance of Nature to Hierarchichal Patch Dynamics: A Paradigm Shift in Ecology.” Quarterly Review of Biology 70: 439–466. 51. Quattrochi, D. A., and M. F. Goodchild (eds.). Scale in Remote Sensing and GIS. Boca Raton: Lewis Publishers, 1997. 52. National Center for Geographic Information and Analysis, 1997. “Scale.” White Paper No. 6. Santa Barbara, CA: University of California. 53. Turner, M. G., R. V. O’Neill, and R. H. Gardner, 1989. “Effects of Changing Spatial Scale on the Analysis of Landscape Pattern.” Landscape Ecology 3: 153–162. 54. Turner, M. G., 1990. “Spatial and Temporal Analysis of Landscape Patterns.” Landscape Ecology 4: 21–30. 55. Wilson, J. P., and P. A. Burrough, 1999. “Dynamic Modeling, Geostatistics, and Fuzzy Classification.” Annals of the Association of American Geographers 89: 736–746. 56. Rastetter, E. B., A. W. King, B. J. Cosby, G. M. Hornberger, R. V. O’Neill, and J. E. Hobbie, 1992. “Aggregating Fine-scale Ecological Knowledge to Model Coarser-scale Attributes of Ecosystems.” Ecological Applications 2: 55–70. 57. Turner, M. G., R. Constanza, and F. H. Sklar, 1989. “Methods to Compare Spatial Patterns for Landscape Modeling and Analysis.” Ecological Modelling 48: 1–18. 58. Harvey, L. D., 1997. “Upscaling in Global Change Research.” Elements of Change 1997, Aspen Global Change Institute: 14–33. 59. Harvey, L. D., 2000. “Upscaling in Global Change Research.” Climatic Change 44: 225–263. 60. van Gardingen, P. R.,G. M. Foody, and P. J. Curran (eds.). Scaling Up: From Cell to Landscape, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. 61. Butterfield, R. E., M. Bindi, R. F. Brooks, T. R. Carter, R. Delecolle, T. E. Downing, Z. Harnos, P. A. Harrison, A. Iglesias, J. E. Olesen, J. L. Orr, M. A. Semenov, and J. Wolf, 2000. “Review and Comparison of Scalingup Methods.” In: T. E. Downing et al. (eds.), 2000. Climate Change, Climatic Variability and Agriculture in Europe: An Integrated Assessment. Oxford: University of Oxford, Environmental Change Institute: 393–414.
SCALING IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT 33
62. Smith, T. M., H. H. Shugart, G. B. Bonan, and J. B. Smith, 1992. “Modeling the Potential Response of Vegetation to Global Climate Change.” In: F. I Woodward (ed.). Advances in Ecological Research: The Ecological Consequences of Global Climate Change. New York: Academic Press: 93–116. 63. Templeton, A. R., and L. R. Lawlor, 1981. “The Fallacy of the Averages in Ecological Optimization Theory.” American Naturalist 117: 390–391. 64. IPCC, 2001. Climate Change 2001: Impacts, Adaptation, and Vulnerability. Cambridge UK: Cambridge University Press. 65. Bass, B., and J. R. Brook, 1997. “Downscaling Procedures as a Tool for Integration of Multiple Air Issues.” Environmental Monitoring and Assessment 46: 152–174. 66. Easterling, W. E., L. O. Mearns, C. Hays, and D. Marx, 2001. “Comparison of Agricultural Impacts of Climate Change Calculated from High and Low Resolution Climate Change Scenarios. Part II: Accounting for Adaptation and CO2 Direct Effects.” Climatic Change 51: 173–197. 67. Jenkins, G. S., and E. J. Barron, 1997. “Global Climate Model and Coupled Regional Climate Model Simulations over the Eastern United States.” Global and Planetary Change 15: 3–32. 68. Yarnal, B., M. N. Lakhtakia, Z. Lu, R. A. White, D. Pollard, D. A. Miller, and W. M. Lapenta, 2000. “A Linked Meteorological and Hydrological Model System: The Susquehanna River Basin Experiment.” Global and Planetary Change 25: 149–161. 69. Crane, R. G., and B. C. Hewitson, 1998. “Doubled CO2 Precipitation Changes for the Susquehanna Basin: Down-scaling from the GENESIS General Circulation Model.” International Journal of Climatology 18: 65–76. 70. Yarnal, B., and B. Frakes, 1997. “Using Synoptic Climatology to Define Representative Discharge Events.” International Journal of Climatology 17: 323–341. 71. Kasemir, B., D. Schibli, S. Stoll, and C. Jaeger, 2000. “Involving the Public in Climate and Energy Decisions.” Environment 42: 32–42. 72. Wilbanks, T. J., 1994. “Sustainable Development in Geographic Context.” Annals of the Association of American Geographers 84: 541–57. 73. Schneider, S. H., 1997. “Integrated Assessment Modeling of Global Climate Change: Transparent Rational Tool for Policy Making or Opaque Screen Hiding Value Laden Assumptions?” Environmental Modeling and Assessment 2: 229–249. 74. Holling, C. S., 1995a. “Sustainability: the Cross-scale Dimension.” In: M. Munasinghe and W. Shearer (eds.). Defining and Measuring Sustainability: The Biogephysical Foundations. Washington: United Nations University/World Bank: 65–75.
34 GEOGRAPHICAL SCALING ISSUES IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENTS OF CLIMATE CHANGE
75. Pattee, H. H., (ed.), 1973. Hierarchy Theory: The Challenge of Complex Systems. New York: G. Braziller. 76. O’Neill, R. V., 1988. “Hierarchy Theory and Global Change.” In: T. Rosswall, R. G. Woodmansee, and P. G. Risser (eds.). Scales and Global Change. New York: John Wiley: 29–45. 77. O’Neill, R. V., A. R. Johson, and A. W. King, 1989. “A Hierarchical Framework for the Analysis of Scale.” Landscape Ecology 3: 193–205. 78. Kolaczyk, E. D., and H. Huang, 2001. “Multicale Statistical Models for Hierarchical Spatial Aggregation.” Geographical Analysis 33: 95–118. 79. Mandelbrot, B. B., 1977. Fractals: Form, Chance, and Dimension. San Francisco: W. H. Freeman. 80. Ahmad, A. U., M. Alam, and A. A. Rahman, 1999. “Adaptation to Climate Change in Bangladesh: Future Outlook.” In: S. Huq, Z. Karim, M. Asaduzzaman, and F. Mahtab (eds.). Vulnerability and Adaptation to Climate Change for Bangladesh. Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic. 81. Wilbanks, T. J., and R. Wilkinson, forthcoming. “Integrating Human and Natural Systems to Understand Climate Change Impacts on Cities.” Elements of Change 1999, Aspen Global Change Institute. 82. Hulme, M., E. M. Barrow, N. W. Arnell, P. A. Harrison, T. C. Johns, and T. E. Downing, 1999. “Relative Impacts of HumanInduced Climate Change and Natural Climate Variability.” Nature 397: 688–691.
3 Micro/Macro and Soft/Hard: Diverging and Converging Issues in the Physical and Social Sciences 1
2
NICO STEHR AND HANS VON STORCH 1 Kulturwissenschaftliches Institut, Essen, Germany 2 Director, Institute for Coast Research, GKSS Forschungszentrum, Geesthacht, Germany
Abstract The concept of scales is widely used in social, ecological and physical sciences, and is embedded in various ongoing philosophical debates about the nature of nature and the nature of society. The question is whether the difference between scales makes a difference and if so what difference. Multilevel approaches compete with reductionist approaches. We are tracing the highlights of the disputes as well as some of the resolutions that have been offered. Most importantly, debates about differences in scale are enmeshed in what should be distinguished, namely analytical knowledge-guiding interests and those that might be called practical knowledge-guiding interests. It is unlikely that purely analytical debates can be resolved. However, progress about the impact and relevance of scale can be achieved with respect to the practicalpolitical discursive level of knowledge claims. More specifically, scales are a crucial concept in determining the capacity for action from knowledge about the dynamics and structures of processes. For instance, in the context of climate change, knowledge claims about global and continental processes are relevant for the international political process aimed at abatement measures, whereas knowledge about regional and local effects controls decisions concerning adaptation measures. Acknowledgements We appreciate the comments and suggestions received on an earlier version of the paper by Carlo C. Jaeger, Jan Rotmans and Dale Rothman although it has not been possible for all of those to be absorbed in the present version.
36 MICRO/MACRO AND SOFT/HARD
Introduction and Overview Climate scientists share a greater common understanding of the scientific usefulness of scales1 than do social scientists2. This greater agreement among climate scientists does not necessarily enhance the practicality of the knowledge claims about the dynamics of the climate system. Social scientists have debated the relevance of different scales for a long time, and though the arguments have been rehashed and repeated many time, they have rarely led to new insights. Conflicts gave way to a search for linkages between micro and macro levels of analysis and the failure to agree on linkages reanimated conflicts (cf. Alexander and Giesen [3]). The disputes remain unresolved. We will try to reframe the issue rather than repeat claims that are invariably contested. For the purpose of further reflection, the main points we want to develop in the process of reframing the debate on scaling is that scales – or the difference between micro and micro, as many social scientists would say – are relevant not just as an analytical problem (that is, as a problem of scientific description or explanation) but as a practical problem. The disputes about scale have rarely been treated as a topic that ought to distinguish between knowledge-guiding interests that are concerned, on the one hand, with the practicality of the knowledge generated by science and, on the other hand, with optimizing certain theoretical and methodological conceptions in the process of generating knowledge claims (see Gibson et al. [2: p14]). The practicality of knowledge generated by science refers to the usefulness knowledge may have as a “capacity for action” in practical circumstances and for particular actors. Analytical attributes of knowledge refer to methodological and theoretical attributes of knowledge claims, for example, the extent to which 1
For instance, in climate science, a reference to a continental scale means that only quantities averaged over a continent are considered, whereas a scale of 1 km means that variations taking place on distances much shorter or much longer than 1 km are not regarded. Similarly, a time scale of 100 and more years mean that time variations extending over intervals of less than 100 years are disregarded. The concept of scales, and the art of “filtering” dynamical equations so that they become simpler and valid to a limited range of spatial and temporal scales, is worked out formally in textbooks on geophysical fluid (atmosphere, ocean) dynamics (see for instance Pedlosky [1]). 2 We will refrain from extensive discussions about the terminology used in social sciences; instead, we adhere to the difference between macro and micro in the social sciences. This difference does not only (or even mainly) refer to allegedly “precise” operations and conceptions along readily quantifiable (flat or hierarchical) dimensions and therefore only time and location. It would be a mistake to conflate these two approaches, as is the case in mundane reasoning. Such a conflation occurs in a report by Gibson et al. [2: p11] where small scale “refers to phenomena that are small in regard to scales of space, time, or quantity” and large scale “refers to big items, quantities, or space.”
SCALING IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT 37
propositions developed for one level can be generalized to another level or the extent to which they can be formalized. The practicality of knowledge claims, in contrast, aims to assist actors, confronted with specific conditions of action, to set something into motion and do so, of course, with the aid of knowledge. We maintain that there is not a linear relation or obvious congruence between enhancing the analytical and practical capacity of knowledge. Two examples may illustrate the point. (1) The determination that the “growing division of labor in society explains the rising divorce rates in advanced society” constitutes a prominent and eminent social science explanation. However, a nation, a region, a city, a village, or a neighborhood will hardly be able to “manipulate” the division of labor and therefore “arrest” (in the sense of effect) divorce rates within its boundaries. (2) The insight that the equilibrium global temperature of Earth would rise by, say, 2 degrees Celsius if carbon dioxide concentrations in the atmosphere double does not provide people at the regional and local level with the capacity to react skillfully, as this insight on the global scale provides no assessment for ongoing environmental change on a regional or local scale within the foreseeable future. Knowledge-guiding interests that aim to enhance the practicality of knowledge claims and knowledge claims that live up to specific analytical attributes (such as logic, truthfulness, reality-congruence, etc.) are not mutually exclusive; however, they do not necessarily lead to identical knowledge claims. The distinction between analytical and practical is particularly relevant to actors who have to deal with and convert scientific knowledge claims into practical action. Thus, choices of scale not only affect what can or will be analyzed but also what can or will be done. But first, we need to restate and summarize the social and the physical science debate about the role of scales in the analysis and the differences that are claimed on behalf of a differentiation with the help of scales. In the case of physical science, our description will focus on climate science. Scales in the Social Sciences: Mixing Levels or what is the Difference? In every living thing what we call the parts is so inseparable from the whole that the parts can only be understood in the whole, and we can neither make the parts the measure of the whole nor the whole the measure of the parts; and this is why living creatures, even the most restricted, have something about them that we cannot quite grasp and have to describe as infinite or partaking of infinity. Johann Wolfgang von Goethe (1785)
38 MICRO/MACRO AND SOFT/HARD
Goethe maintains that the understanding of parts or wholes requires the elimination of their difference. It appears that the social sciences have generally followed his advice, since a liberal mixing of levels3 or multilevel analysis is common in social science accounts. Even in approaches that are self-consciously micro or macro, linkages between levels are evident. If this is the case, then the difference between levels is unnecessary. The assertion whether a differentiation is helpful or not is based on a certain comprehension of the constitution of examined processes and therefore to specific knowledge-guiding interests internal to the scientific community. For example, the common theoretical link that sociologists obtain between the conduct of individual actors (micro level), situational factors, or the social structure typically are a particular social psychological theory (macro level). When Robert K. Merton [4] explains deviant behavior he does so not as the outcome of individual differences but as the consequence of the situation within which the actor is located. Merton argues that unattainable goals produce deviant behavior. Whether the actor in fact faces unattainable goals is determined by the situation or social structure. Situations vary, but the social psychology that links actor and situation (namely, trying to pursue legitimate goals) are the same for each individual. Hence the differences in location explain deviance. Without the social psychological premises, the account would be incomplete [5: p102–103].4 Put another way, the problem is that neither solitary perspective “pays adequate attention to the constructed nature of both individuals and groups” [9: p59]. Part and system form a whole. The mixture of different scales is argued to be constitutive for social phenomena. Paraphrasing Wittgenstein [10: p20], understanding parts of an ordinary language game requires the comprehension of a form of life or a cultural system.5 3
We use the term “level” mostly as synonymous with “scale”. However, when two different types of scales are considered, for instance, space and time, they are considered to be of the same “level” if they are found to co-exist. 4 The volatility of shifting positions, courting methodological individualism but not to the exclusion of holism (or vice versa) is also one of the characteristics of classical social theory, for example, in the work of Marx, Weber and Durkheim but also in the writings of classical contemporary social theory such as Parsons [6: p89–102, p177–196, p298–322] or in the assumptions that informed neo-classical economic discourse. By the same token, in advocating an institutionalist view, Meyer et al. [7: p13–14] do not postulate a society without people. However, they maintain that the individual is a social construction and that the linkage between institutional scripts enacted by individuals is the social psychological advocated by C. Wright Mills [8]. The institutionalist perspective corrects for excessive emphasis on the preeminent status of (individual) actors in modern economic, psychological and social theory characterized by individual socialization and internalized values. 5 Using more conventional sociological terminology, both “microscopic processes that constitute the web of interactions in society and the macroscopic frameworks that
SCALING IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT 39
As the label already indicates, the institutionalist perspective assigns explanatory priority to the macro scale: “Social processes and social change … result at least in part, from the actions and interactions among large-scale actors … Welfare systems, job markets, and cultural structures become products of organizations or sets of organizations” [7: p17]. Network analysis, rational choice theory, interaction ritual chain analysis [12] or Homans’ [13] behaviorism typically favor the micro scale. These strategies simply maintain and are linked to the theoretical premise that the realities of social structure reveal patterns of “repetitive micro-interaction” [12: p985]. What is relevant and constitutes the immediate environment for the analysis depends on prioritizing scales. Macro models – where their own internal divisions of levels are problematic – prefer resource or ecological dependency perspectives, while micro models that acknowledge the presence of levels emphasize cultural practices and conceptions as their most relevant environment. Approaches that readily acknowledge and freely mix different scales in their analysis place different emphasis on relevant scales, on how one progresses down or up the conceptual scale (aggregation, cumulation, interaction), and on how robust or recalcitrant different units of analysis happen to be. The strict limitation to certain scales, that is, the conviction that levels cannot be mixed, is based on considerations of methods or access to levels. As Scheff [14: p27–28] states in an exemplary fashion: The macroworld, “so vast and so slow moving, requires special techniques to make its regularities visible – the statistics and mathematical models now taken for granted. The study of the microworld also requires special techniques, but for the opposite reason: the movements are too small and quick to be readily observable to the unaided eye.”6 Our interpretation of the elevation of one level is one necessitated by perspective: The perspective of the observer as compared with the level of the observer. The debate about levels of analysis in the social sciences are not constrained or disciplined by commonly accepted definitions of the boundaries of disciplines and subdisciplines. However, the choice to work within the accepted confines of sub-atomic physics or cellular biology a priori limits the resolution of patterns that can legitimately be studied. Social scientists have not reconstructed the world of social phenomena in the same hierarchical fashion that is generally taken for granted in the physical sciences.
result from and condition those processes are essential levels for understanding and explaining social life” [3: p13, 11: p185]. 6 For specifically, as Scheff [14: p28] notes, “observing the microworld requires not a telescope, such as a sample survey, but a microscope – video- and audiotapes, or at least verbatim texts, which provide the data for discourse analysis.”
40 MICRO/MACRO AND SOFT/HARD
Scales in the Physical Sciences: the Climate System A characteristic of the physical climate system is the presence of processes on all spatial scales. The “scale” of a process is the extension of an area where the direct impact of the process is felt. Thus the spatial scale of the tropical trade wind system is several thousand kilometers; that of a cyclone at mid latitudes is about one thousand kilometers; a front, a few hundred kilometers; a thunderstorm, a few kilometers, and individual turbulent eddies in the atmospheric boundary layer exert an influence on scales of several meters and less (Fig. 3.1). A typical feature of this cascade of spatial scales is that it is associated with a similar cascade in temporal scales. Smaller scales exhibit shorter term variations, whereas larger scales vary on longer time scales. For instance, a cyclone with a diameter of a thousand kilometers exists for several days, whereas a thunderstorm of several kilometers diameter is dissipated after a few hours (Fig. 3.1). A similar analysis can be made for oceanic processes.
Figure 3.1: Scales in the atmospheric dynamics.
All of these processes interact. The trade wind system, as part of the Hadley Cell, helps to maintain a meridional temperature gradient at mid latitudes, so that the air flow becomes unstable and eddies form (namely, extratropical cyclones); these storms form fronts, and the strong winds blowing above the Earth surface create a turbulent boundary layer of several hundred meters
SCALING IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT 41
height. In this argument, large-scale features create environmental conditions so that smaller scale features emerge. This view is supported by an experiment with a complex climate model simulating atmospheric motion on an “aqua planet”, i.e., a globe without topography [15]. Initiated with a motionless state, driven by equator-to-pole gradients in the global ocean’s surface temperature and by solar radiation, the general circulation of the atmosphere just described emerges within a few weeks, with trade winds, extratropical storms, and turbulent boundary layers. Climate at a smaller scale appears as conditioned by the state at a larger scale [16]. However, the smaller scale is not determined by the larger scale, as demonstrated by the weather details, which may differ greatly in two very similar synoptic situations [17, 18]. But information about the conditioning large-scale state is incorporated in the statistics of small scale features. This fact is used in paleoclimatic reconstructions [19, 20], which are based entirely on “upscaling” of local information like tree ring widths or densities. Do the smaller scales affect the larger scales? They do: without the small scale eddies in the turbulent boundary layer, a cyclone would not lose its kinetic energy; without the extratropical storms, a much stronger equator-topole temperature gradient would appear and the Hadley Cell, with its trade wind system, would possibly extend to the polar regions. While the large scales condition the smaller scales, the smaller scales make the large scales more fuzzy. There is a simple intuitive arguments for this asymmetry: there are many realizations of the smaller scale process, encompassed in the area of influence of one larger scale process. The smaller scale processes represent a random sample of possible realizations, and their feedback on the large-scale process depends on the statistics of the smaller scales processes. The details of a single storm are not relevant, but the preferred area of formation, the track of the storms, and the mean intensity do influence the formation of the general atmospheric circulation. Aside from making the large scales more fuzzy, smaller scale short-term variations also cause the large-scale components to exhibit slow variations. This phenomenon, comparable with Brownian motion of macroscopic particles under the bombardment of infinitely many microscopic molecules, is demonstrated in the “stochastic climate model” of Hasselmann [21]. The short term variations are considered random, and the large-scale components integrate this random behavior. Whether the many small-scale features are really varying randomly is irrelevant; as long as these processes are strongly nonlinear, often a valid assumption, their joint effect can not be distinguished from randomly generated numbers. This effect is illustrated in Figure 3.2, showing the time evolution of a one-dimensional world characterized by a large-scale (global) temperature: solar (short-wave) radiation is intercepted by this world; part of this radiation
42 MICRO/MACRO AND SOFT/HARD
Figure 3.2: a) EBM without noise, b) with noise.
is reflected back to space; the intercepted radiation is re-emitted as thermal (long-wave) radiation proportional to the fourth power of temperature. When the proportion of reflected solar radiation (“albedo”) is such that a higher temperature is connected with lower reflectivity (less snow and ice) and lower temperature with higher reflectivity (more snow and ice), then Earth can have two different temperatures. Which of these temperatures is attained depends on where one starts (Fig. 3.2a). However, a different behavior emerges
SCALING IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT 43
when the reflectivity exhibits additional random variations, representing the variable small-scale cloud cover of Earth (Fig. 3.2b). The systems exhibits slow variations and intermittent jumps between the two preferred regimes of the system. Obviously, in this thought experiment, the small-scale, short-term variations (“noise”) are a constitutive element, causing the emergence of slow variations of large-scale temperature [22]. Time series of observed large-scale quantities, like the global mean near-surface temperature, show similar frequency behavior, even if the interesting regime shifts in Figure 3.2b are not obvious [23, 24].
There is Nothing as Practical as a Good Theory Our discussion of the macro/micro controversy in the social sciences and the accomplishments of scaling in climate science has shown that, despite their divergence, the focus in both cultures is on the analytical accomplishments. That is, scaling issues tend to be deliberated and judged in the sciences based on the internal knowledge-guiding interests. But this also implies that the scaling problem is discussed in a one-sided manner. Improvements in the analytical capacities of knowledge (or the scientificity of knowledge claims) do not always improve upon the practical efficacy of knowledge. The thesis that analytical improvements enhance the usefulness of knowledge is best captured in the maxim “there is nothing as practical as a good theory”. The emphasis clearly is on good theory, and what constitutes good theory is disputed more in the social than the physical sciences. An improvement of theory surely constitutes intellectual progress within science. But good theory does not invariably point to “elements” in a concrete situation that can be acted upon in order to accomplish a certain purpose, for example, in the sense of affecting development of a specific process – even though that process is better understood because of the good theory (and the scaling choices made in order to generate good theory). That good theory – and whatever good theory may mean in concrete terms – does not automatically mean practical knowledge can best be shown by defining knowledge as a capacity to act or as a model for reality (see Stehr [25]). Our choice of terms is inspired by Francis Bacon’s famous observation “scientia est potentia,” or, as it has often been somewhat misleadingly translated: “knowledge is power”. Bacon suggests that knowledge derives its utility from its capacity to set something in motion. The term “potentia”, or capacity, describes the power of knowing. Human knowledge represents the capacity to act, to set a process in motion, or to produce something.7 The 7
Knowledge, as a generalized capacity for action, acquires an “active” role in the course of social action only under circumstances where such action does not follow purely stereotypical patterns (Max Weber), or is not strictly regulated in some other
44 MICRO/MACRO AND SOFT/HARD
fashion. Knowledge assumes significance under conditions where social action is, for whatever reasons, based on a certain degree of freedom in the courses of action that can be chosen. Certain circumstances of the situation have to be actionable. Space does not allow us to examine all the implications of our thesis. However, this much needs to be added: the notion that constraints may be apprehended as open to action or, as more or less unalterable, should not be interpreted to mean that the apprehension of pertinent constraints of action is merely a subjective matter and an idiosyncratic component of social action. Evidently, it is not only the social definition of the nature of the situation that decides whether certain features of the context in question are fixed or not. Such a conception of situational components that are open to social action of course ignores what are often called “objective” constraints of human conduct, which facilitate social action or impose on it certain limits. Nonetheless, extraneous or structural constraints that may issue from given social contexts may be interpreted in terms of “sets of feasible options” open to individuals and groups ([26: p107]; emphasis added) because such structural constraints are ultimately the product of decisions of specific actors, though the ability of many to reproduce and effect such constraints is often severely restricted. But in the final analysis, the point is, whatever the objective constraints, they are not beyond the control of all actors. These considerations require that the consideration of features of specific social contexts as either relatively open or closed to social action should not be driven solely by a subjective definition of situational constraints, but should recognize, for example, that actors at times may be largely unaware of constraints that are “actionable” (cf. Merton [27: p173–176]). Individuals and groups may therefore need and be prepared to accept some form of enlightenment. This “critical” function could well be served by a practical social science that provides a cogent account of human agency as it is mediated by the specifics of certain social contexts. In this sense, the function of social science is to open up possibilities for social action that common sense, for example, strives to conceal or manages to close down (cf. Baumann [28: p16]). For a more detailed discussion of the various implications of our thesis, see Stehr [29]. Karl Mannheim [30] defines, in much the same sense, the range of social conduct generally, and therefore the contexts in which knowledge plays a role, as restricted to spheres of social life that have not been completely routinized and regulated. For, as he observes, “conduct, in the sense in which I use it, does not begin until we reach the area where rationalization has not yet penetrated, and where we are forced to make decisions in situations which have as yet not been subjected to regulation” [30: p102]. Concretely, “The action of a petty official who disposes of a file of documents in the prescribed manner or of a judge who finds that a case falls under the provisions of a certain paragraph in the law and disposes of it accordingly, or finally of a factory worker who produces a screw by following the prescribed technique, would not fall under our definition of ‘conduct.’ Nor for that matter would the action of a technician who, in achieving a given end, combined certain general laws of nature. All these modes of behaviour would be considered as merely ‘reproductive’ because they are executed in a rational framework, according to a definite prescription entailing no personal decision whatsoever” [30: p102].
SCALING IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT 45
success of human action can be gauged from changes that have taken place in reality or are perceived by society. The notion of knowledge as a capacity for social action has the advantage that it enables one to stress not just one dimension, but the rich, multifaceted consequences of knowledge for action. The realization of knowledge in political, everyday, economic, or business contexts is embedded in a web of social, legal, economic and political circumstances. That is, the definition of knowledge as a capacity for action strongly indicates that the realization of knowledge is dependent on specific social and intellectual contexts. Knowledge use and its practical efficacy is a function of “local” conditions and contexts. Scaling decisions can therefore be affected with respect to actionable circumstances and not merely attributes that suggest themselves because they happen to be desirable from an analytical perspective.
The Differences that Make a Difference: Scales in Climate Change and Climate Impact Research The scale problem outlined above relates to both a success and a major limitation of modern climate research in constructing plausible climate change scenarios. The computing technology available now and in the foreseeable future does not allow resolution of small-scale features in climate models. Instead, the small-scale features are not described in any detail but are parameterized, i.e., their effect on the resolved scales is described as a function of the resolved scales. In this way, the equations are closed, and the large-scale features are described realistically. The overall general circulation of the atmosphere is simulated as in the real world, extratropical storms are formed with the right life cycles and locations. Obviously, this success is not perfect and the next years will see significant improvements. Independently of the degree of success on scales of, say, 2000 km and more, global climate models fail to provide skillful assessments on scales of, say 100 and less kilometers. Therefore the contemporary discussion concentrates only on anthropogenic climate change detectable now on the global scale, and not on the regional and local scale. For political purposes, namely for emphasizing the need for abatement action of the worlds’ governments, these results valid for large scales are sufficient, as the details of expected change are less important than the perception of global risk. When we consider the alternative though not contradictory poltiical strategy to abatement measures, namely adaptation, we need regional and local assessment of anthropogenic climate change, since climate impacts people mainly on the regional scales. Regional scales as social constructs are highly variable. Storm surges happen regionally; the storm track may be shifted by a few hundred kilometers; when rain replaces snowfall, or snow melts early, a
46 MICRO/MACRO AND SOFT/HARD
catchment is affected, and so on. Such information may be derived by postprocessing the output of global climate models, by exploiting the above sketched links between the scales. For this purpose, climate scientists have designed dynamically or empirically constructed models describing the possible regional states consistent with large-scale states generated in global models. This approach is named “downscaling”, as information from larger scales is transferred to smaller scales. “Dynamical downscaling” uses models based on detailed dynamical models, or regional climate models; “empirical downscaling” operates with statistical models fitted to the observational evidence available from the recent history. While a large variety of “downscaling” techniques have been developed in the past decade, they have not yet provided climate impact research with the required robust estimates of plausible regional and local climate change scenarios, mainly because global climate models have not yet provided sufficiently converged consistent large-scale information to be processed through “downscaling” [31]. However, one might expect that this gap could be filled in within a few years, so that detailed regional and local impact studies may provide robust scenarios of changes in climatic variables like temperature, storminess and sea level. This information also has to be postprocessed further with dynamical and empirical models of climate sensitive systems, like the water balance in a catchment, the ecology of a forest, the statistics of waves on marginal seas, or the economy of agriculture. Of course, in many cases, this postprocessing is futile if other factors are considered in parallel to changing climatic conditions, such as changing social preferences, technological progress and the like. These models again suffer from scale problems. Almost all environmental modeling efforts assume that the system may separated into two subsystems, one that is explicitly described and another that is considered noise, which influences the explicitly described part statistically. The explicitly described “dynamical” part is considered to carry the essential dynamics. In climate and other physical systems, the dynamical subsystem comprises all large-scale processes while the noise subsystem comprises the small scale processes. Thus, the former contains relatively few processes and the latter, infinitely many. This convenient separation according to scales can no longer be adopted in other systems, such as ecosystems or economies.
Conclusions In the physical sciences, discussions of scale revolve around time and place. In the social sciences, discussions of micro/macro tend to concentrate on functional relationships. The concepts of macro vs. micro and of scales in the social and in the physical science are widely used, but not without problems (see Connolly [32: p10–44]). The question is whether the difference between
SCALING IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT 47
scales makes a difference, and if the scales matter, what difference they make. Not surprisingly, the intensity of the dispute varies by discursive field. In the physical sciences, in this case, climate science, the debate is less intense and manifests itself in more definitive knowledge claims about the impact of differences in scale. Well-intentioned scientists focus on the analytical qualities of the knowledge claims they generate, largely because they see it as the solution to the question of “what is to be done”, without looking at how effective and practical these accounts are going to be. This can be judged to be a form of escape from scientific labor. Effectiveness and practicality are governed by prevailing social conditions. The ability to transform prevailing contexts requires, first, an examination and identification of those contextual elements that can be altered. The mutable conditions then drive decisions about scaling.
References 83. Pedlosky, J., 1987. Geophysical Fluid Dynamics. New York: Springer. 84. Gibson, C., E. Ostrom, and T-K. Ahn, 1998. Scaling Issues in the Social Sciences. A Report for the International Human Dimensions Programme on Global Environmental Change. IHDP Working Paper 1. Bonn: IHDP. 85. Alexander, J. C., and B. Giesen, 1987. “From reduction to linkage: the long view of the micro-macro debate.” In: J. C. Alexander, B. Giesen, R. Münch, and N. J. Smelser (eds.). The Micro-Macro Link. Berkeley: University of California Press: 1–42. 86. Merton, R. K., 1938. “Social Structure and Anomie.“ American Sociological Review 3: 672–82. 87. Zelditch, M. Jr., 1991. “Levels in the logic of macro-historical explanations.” in: J. Huber (ed.). Macro-Micro Linkages in Sociology. Newbury Park, California: Sage: 101–106. 88. Parsons, T., 1954. Essays in Sociological Theory. New York: Free Press. 89. Meyer, J. W., F. O. Ramirez, and J. Boli, 1987. Ontology and rationalization in the Western cultural account. in: G. M. Thomas, J. W. Meyer, F. O. Ramirez, and J. Boli (eds.). Institutional Structure. Constituting State, Society and the Individual. Newbury Park, California: Sage: 12–37. 90. Mills, C. W., 1940. “Sitated actions and the volcabulary of motive.” American Sociological Review 5: 316–330. 91. Calhoun, C., 1991 The problem of identity in collective actions. in: J. Huber (ed.). Macro-Micro Linkages in Sociology. Newbury Park, California: Sage: 51–75. 92. Wittgenstein, L., 1953. Philosophical Investigations. New York: Macmillan.
48 MICRO/MACRO AND SOFT/HARD
93. Münch, R., and N. J. Smelser, 1987. A theory of social movements, social classes, and castes. In: J. C. Alexander, B. Giesen, R. Münch, and N. J. Smelser. (eds.). The Micro-Macro Link. Berkeley: University of California Press: 371–386 and 403–404. 94. Collins, R., 1981. “The microfoundations of macrosociology.” American Journal of Sociology 86: 984–1014. 95. Homans, G. C., 1961. Social Behavior: Its Elementary Forms. New York: Harcourt, Brace, and World. 96. Scheff, T. J., 1990. Microsociology. Discourse, Emotion and Social Structure. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. 97. Fischer, G., E. Kirk, and R. Podzun, 1991. Physikalische Diagnose eines numerischen Experiments zur Entwicklung der grossräumigen atmosphärischen Zirkulation auf einem Aquaplaneten. Meteorogische Runddschau 43: 33–42. 98. Von Storch, H., 1999. The global and regional climate system. In: H. von Storch and G. Flöser (eds.). Anthropogenic Climate Change, New York: Springer Verlag. 99. Starr, V. P., 1942. Basic principles of weather forecasting. New York: Harper. 100. Roebber, P. J., and L. F. Bosart, 1998. “The sensitivity of precipitation to circulation details. Part I: An analysis of regional analogs.” Monthly Weather Review 126, 437–455. 101. Appenzeller, C., T. F. Stocker, and M. Anklin, 1998. “North Atlantic Oscillation dynamics recorded in Greenland ice cores.” Science 282: 446–449. 102. Mann, M., R. S. Bradley, and M. K. Hughes, 1998. “Global-scale temperature patterns and climate forcing over the past six centuries.” Nature 392: 779–789. 103. Hasselmann, K., 1976. “Stochastic climate models. Part I Theory.” Tellus 28: 473–485. 104. Von Storch, H., J.-S. von Storch, and P. Müller, 2001. Noise in the Climate System – Ubiquitous, Constitutive and Concealing. In: B. Engquist and W. Schmid (eds.). Mathematics Unlimited – 2001 and Beyond. New York: Springer-Verlag: 1179–1194. 105. Hansen, A. R., and A. Sutera, 1986. On the probability density function of planetary scale atmospheric wave Amplitude. J. Atmos. Science 43: 3250–3265. 106. Nitsche, G., J. M. Wallace, and C. Kooperberg, 1994. “Is there evidence of multiple equilibria in the planetary-wave amplitude?” J. Atmos. Science 51: 314–322. 107. Stehr, N., 2002. Knowledge and Economic Conduct: The Social Foundations of the Modern Economy. Toronto: University of Toronto Press. 108. Giddens, A., 1990. R. K. Merton on structural analysis. In: J. Clark, C. Modgie, and S. Modgie (eds.). Robert K. Merton: Consensus and Controversy. London: Falmer Press: 97–110.
SCALING IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT 49
109. Merton, R. K., 1975. “Social knowledge and public policy. Sociological perspectives on four presidential commissions.” In: M. Komarovsky (ed.), Sociology and Public Policy. The Case of Presidential Commissions. New York: Elsevier: 153–177. 110. Bauman, Z., 1990. Thinking Sociologically. Oxford: Blackwell. 111. Stehr, N., 1992. Practical Knowledge. London: Sage. 112. Mannheim, K., (1929). Ideology and Utopia: An Introduction to the Sociology of Knowledge. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul. 113. Houghton, J. T., Y. Ding, D. J. Griggs, M. Noguer, P. J. van der Linden, and D. Xiaosu (eds.), 2001. Climate Change 2001: The Scientific Basis. Contribution of Working group I to the Third Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. 114. Connolly, W. E., 1983. The Terms of Political Discourse. Princeton, New Jersey: Princeton University Press.
4 Scale and Scope in Integrated Assessment: Lessons from Ten Years with ICAM HADI DOWLATABADI Sustainable Development Research Institute, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada
Abstract Scale has traditionally been thought of in terms of the spatial extent and units of observation in a field. This is an excellent convention in the study of physical processes where scale also differentiates between the dominant forces at play. For example at the scale of planetary distances gravitation is the dominant force of interaction and the only thing that matters is mass, while at the atomic level electromagnetic forces dominate and charge of the bodies is critical. In this paper I would like to offer other criteria for scale selection in studies involving the interaction of social and natural systems. In this paper the focus is on integrated assessments where we hope to understand and capture the interaction between natural and social systems. By applying the same paradigm for scale identification as before, namely factors that dominate the dynamics and landscape of the system I would like to persuade the reader that we need to define two additional scales for integrated assessments: one to capture human cognitive processes and another to capture our social organization. The rationale for wanting to add these scales is simple. Awareness of the interface between nature and us is determined by our cognitive processes and technologies invented and employed to enhance these. Our ability to act on what we would like to do about the interface is shaped by the way our societies are organized and institutions invented and maintained to enhance them.
Acknowledgements I would like to thank the organizers of the Matrix 2000 Workshop on Scale in Integrated Assessment for offering me this opportunity to think more
52 SCALE AND SCOPE IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT
systematically about scale issues. I am grateful to Dale Rothman for his comments and suggestions to improve this paper. The research reported here was made possible through support from the Center for Integrated Study of the Human Dimensions of Global Change. This Center has been created through a cooperative agreement between the National Science Foundation (SBR-9521914) and Carnegie Mellon University, and has been generously supported by grants from the Electric Power Research Institute, the ExxonMobil Corporation, the American Petroleum Institute and Resources for the Future. All views expressed herein are those of the author, and all remaining errors are a reflection of his fallibility.
Introduction Often, it is asserted that human activity is leading to environmental impacts of unprecedented scale. Here, scale presumably means phenomena that extend through space and time. I am not sure though, if such statements are helpful in analysis of our interactions with nature. In absolute terms, these impacts are more extensive today than ever before. This is because: (a) many of our activities grow ever more synthetic, (b) measurements of change in the environment are more sensitive and (c) our more sophisticated understanding of the underlying processes leads to attributions of these changes to our own actions. For example, we invented CFCs as a miracle industrial gas and fluid. No such chemical existed in nature before and for three decades we used it without any knowledge of its potential environmental impacts. During that period, our growing understanding of environmental science allowed us to speculate and later measure the impact of CFCs in the stratosphere above Antarctica! Yes, our reach is global (as we understand the term “global” today). In relative terms history is replete with episodes of human action whose impacts extended to the boundaries of the contemporaneously known universe. Today, we know a good deal more about the earth. For Paleolithic villagers, the impact may have been limited to the valley in which they had lived for generations. Cognitively, these two are not differentiable in terms of “the known interface” between humans and the environment. What matters is whether what we know influences what we do. In general, while our impact is rarely limited to the space we know, the impacts we neither see nor postulate may exist rarely, if ever, limit our actions. Furthermore, there is little doubt that our actions today have impacts beyond the space/time we know. For example, the earth is an extremely bright source of radio emissions in the sky. Our radio, TV and telephone conversations are finding their way to the farthest reaches of the universe. The earliest TV signals are already more than 60 light years away. If and when we grow sensitive to the impact of these stray emissions into the electromagnetic spectrum of deep space we may choose to control these also.
SCALING IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT 53
Meanwhile, there is nary a concern about such impacts. In summary, the decisions about our patterns of activity are taken in recognition of what we know at any given time. This is an irrefutable aspect of humanity. The scale of our knowledge about change is determined by our cognitive capacity. Even though I think the above argument is pretty persuasive, others would argue that there is a fundamental difference between then and now. Today, we are witnessing motivations for human activity that extend beyond local geographic scales and there is an imbalance between “global demands” and “local capacity to provide” in a sustainable manner. This too has historic precedent. The empires often aggrandized in history books are all about institutions that imposed control over far flung resources. Arab, Ashante, Aztec, British, Chinese, Greek, Mayan, Mogul, Persian, Portuguese, Soviet and Spanish empires conquered vast areas of the known world, extending trade networks, imposing belief systems and collecting resources. Did they consider the impact of their demands on local systems and their viability? What is the difference between these historic empires and our current concerns about the Global Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT)? Economic superpowers and global markets, even while well-meaning, embody a promise and an ill-wind that come about from mismatches in the scales of pressure and responses. The scale of human activity is determined by the characteristics of social organizations and institutions. There is no prerequisite that our knowledge of change (cognitive scale) and our knowledge of manipulation (organization scale) be spatially the same or dynamically in harmony. Scale mismatches are part and parcel of the struggle of living on earth as social beings. Exploiting these mismatches is a major determinant of heterogeneity between and within different societies. These heterogeneities are beyond those that can be explained in terms of each community’s endowments. Utilization of these resources impose different collateral effects (externalities) on individuals, households, neighborhoods, communities and regions. Forces external to the region are increasingly the determinant of demand for these resources. These tensions lead to an imbalance of pressure and response in different regions. Consequently, winners and losers emerge. These differences in outcomes are now shown to be linked to how “happiness” and “welfare” are experienced. Here again, our cognitive and perceptive functions determine how we evaluate outcomes. Happiness of individuals and communities are defined relative to outcomes for others. Thus, in these societies, happiness is essentially being a winner, relative to others, even when the world as a whole or a neighboring society may be worse off. There is a clear pathology implied in the above paragraph. It suggests that even awareness of adverse impacts on nature does not necessarily lead to wise action on the part of humans. This is not simply a restatement of a tragedy of commons problem. It is one that associates the individually important phenomenon of “winning in relative terms” with actions that can
54 SCALE AND SCOPE IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT
knowingly lead to the overall deterioration of the commons. By extension we can fuel the fire of concern about systematic collapse – socially, economically and/or ecologically. My immediate reaction to such worries is if humanity is so afflicted, then why worry about its demise. On a more positive note however, I believe catastrophic outcomes are only likely under two circumstances: (a) where the system has become so homogeneous that the same affliction can spell doom for all, (b) where the different components of the earth system are so strongly interconnected that the failure of one will lead to the collapse of all. Winners and losers (be they ecological or social) define heterogeneity within a system and hence resilience to the first type of challenge. The interacting elements of the system (society, ecology, …) lead to ever changing conditions, but it is their self-perpetuating interactions that leads to an identifiable system being created. Therefore change and heterogeneity are part and parcel of a more stable system, even though individual state variables may be transitory and unstable. In other words, while Welsh coalmining communities are a feature of our past, the villages are still there, and the people are engaged in different activities and the ecology is again flourishing in species that are sensitive to mine runoff. Interestingly enough, even though systemic collapse on a local scale is all about us, we seem to be expending more effort in projecting and forestalling such futures as opposed to doing something about them now. This could be due to a number of reasons, among them: (a) collapse being more dreadful when unknown and more easily adapted to when in progress; (b) collapse being precipitated or marginalized by institutional dynamics. These simple observations, about our cognitive and institutional capacity, have led me to be skeptical about our ability to address climate change in a substantive fashion. Climate change is the poster-child of distant and uncertain concerns. Somehow, it is hard to imagine us finding a solution there where we continue to fail in removing the familiar blights of persistent hunger and trampled human rights.
Lessons from Developing ICAM I do not claim any knowledge about how the issue of scale has been treated in the literature. This paper is about a personal journey in integrated assessment of climate change. One might suspect that a global scale is all that such an assessment would be focused on. However, the nature of the problem, a global concern with differentiated local implications has led to successive iterations in which questions to consider and what solutions to explore. Over the period in question, the problem was redefined four times. Each redefinition had implications for scale and scope of the analysis – see Table 4.1. This iterative approach to problem solving has been discussed by Root and Schneider [1]. I am now convinced that for problems like climate change, a “right scale” of analysis, based on space and time, does not exist. I believe that the cognitive and organizational aspects of our societies act locally, but their “location” is
SCALING IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT 55
not coterminous with a spatial definition of locality. I believe that today, the high degree of exchange between geographic locations has led to shared goods, services, ideas, and social norms being the defining characteristics of a “locality”.
Table 4.1: Four successive generations of ICAM ICAM 0
Problem characteristics ■ ■
■
1
■
■
2
■
■
3
■
Uncertainty in outcome Uncertainty in efficacy of control measures Subjective perspectives on costs and benefits of control Outcomes are simulated as a consequence of parametric uncertainty Regional differences in driving variables manifestation of climate change and impacts of that change Outcomes are simulated as a consequence of parametric and structural uncertainties Regional differences due to aerosols emissions and climate change that would ensue The key question is no longer what range of outcomes can happen but what institutional framework can steer us clear of pathologically bad futures. This is explored through simulation of interactions between three groups: those who worry about nature, those who worry about development and those who are entrusted with policy implementation. These simulations explore the consequence of specific institutional frameworks
■ ■
Critical factors shaping outcomes Subjective views on costs Subjective views on benefits
■
Two geographical domains (high and low latitudes) used to depict differences in demographics, economics, and market/non-market impacts of climate change
■
12 world regions whose boundaries are defined by aerosol transport Differences in energy resources Differences in pollution control Differences in land use
■ ■ ■
■
■
■
Sensitivity to control cost signals and economic disruptions Sensitivity to impacts attributed to climate change Institutions for social interactions and for monitoring and managing the interface with nature
In this paper, I plan to offer some insights about scale and integrated assessment through examples from three generations of ICAM modeling. In these examples, I will try to illustrate the added value of cognitive and organizational scales as adjuncts to the more familiar time and space scales. I will present: ■
Cognitive scale issues, including how we define the relevant questions and the scales of analysis adopted for examining different options,
56 SCALE AND SCOPE IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT
■
Organizational scale issues, including which aspects of the dynamics of the system are represented.
I conclude this paper with a plea for design of integrated assessments that reflects the different scales at which human cognition and organizations operate. I believe these to be fundamental scales at which we perceive changes in the world around us and translate our desires for its manipulation and preservation into specific actions and interventions. Questions, scope and scale It may sound trite, but in any research endeavor, it is important to have a clear question in mind. In pure research, the question is gradually crystallized as one gropes around for understanding.1 By contrast, in applied research, the objectives defined by a specific question identify the scope and scale of the analysis that should be undertaken. Often, we researchers fall between these two modes of inquiry and have difficulty defining the question appropriately. Failing to define the appropriate question often goes hand in hand with the research findings being ignored. I have tried to keep the research underlying ICAM relevant by repeatedly visiting the dual questions: What is good climate change policy? What is good policy if climate changes? The redeeming feature of these questions is that they are a constant reminder of the context in which climate change is taking place. In the examples offered below, I try to show how context dramatically changed the nature of the insights that could be gained from the study of climate change issues. However, while I thought this approach would provide the most useful information applied science could offer, it ignored whether such information was in demand by decision-makers. It also ignored whether such information would be easy to digest once demanded. Three factors distinguished integrated assessment of climate change at Carnegie Mellon University (CMU), and my experiences over the past decade. These differences were: ■ ■
■
We had little expertise in climate change science. We tried to define the relevant questions from a decision-analytic basis before starting the research program. We insisted on characterizing the uncertainties hampering informed and assured decision-making.
However, we were fortunate in having a team of colleagues who had substantial experience in developing integrated assessments starting in 1981. We 1
Just consider any thesis or research project you are familiar with. Did it start with the questions that it finally answered, or did the questions that were answered emerge from the process of doing the research? In my case, the research has always revealed questions that were unknown to me before the research was started. Furthermore, these questions needed to be answered before the initial objective could be addressed.
SCALING IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT 57
were also blessed with a strong research program on public perceptions of risk and systematic risk communication. Our department had cut its eyeteeth on problems such as acid rain [2, 3], local air pollution [4] and radon and electromagnetic fields [5, 6, 7, 8, 9]. These differences in starting points, spared our effort from a common misstep in climate change research – a narrow focus on climate change ignoring other forces of change acting on similar or shorter time scales. At first blush, a lack of domain expertise is a fatal flaw in any assessment effort. This is true under two conditions: (a) if we were shy about seeking-out expertise when needed. (b) if we were unable to identify when we needed such expertise. However, by not having experts in climate science, global economics, ecological and ocean dynamics we were not obliged to shape our effort to include a pre-existing set of models or adopt their natural scales into our integrated assessment. The advantage of not having to start with preexisting models developed to address questions that have differed in scope and scale can hardly be overstated. Of course the drawback has been that by not adopting pre-existing models we have had a more difficult time persuading the domain experts that the features of their knowledge relevant to climate change decision-making are being faithfully reflected in our integrated assessments. While an initial question capturing the challenge of climate change policy is simple to pose, its refinement into the concerns of different stake holder groups is critical to adopting an appropriate scale of analysis. This process of identifying the relevant questions involved many person-years of effort and took over six months to complete. In this exercise we explicitly identified different stakeholders and their varying ethical and political stances on climate change and climate policy (see Table 4.2). Thus, we defined the scope and scale of the problem that was not limited to dollar denominations of costs and benefits. This broader definition of variables relevant to decision-making and policy formation broadened our effort beyond reliance on economic “solutions” to the climate change problem. The next step was to figure out how different social and natural processes interacted. This was accomplished by developing influence diagrams of increasing sophistication through which we explored scale and scope issues relevant to climate change and its context. These influence diagrams were used to explore how a snapshot of interactions would vary from short-term and longterm interactions and how a diagram of regional interactions would differ from one with a global focus. Figure 4.1 reproduces an influence diagram proposed by Granger Morgan and refined by the research team late in 1991.
58 SCALE AND SCOPE IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT
Table 4.2: Climate questions climate change policy (developed during the first 6 months of the integrated assessment program)* 1. What policy issues will drive the evolution of the climate change problem? How big an issue is climate change? 1. What is the relative importance of climate change issues, compared with other issues, faced by groups around the US and the world? 2. What is the likely relative weight in US and global decision making of those groups for which climate issues are of significant importance? (the answer allows us to identify “key groups” in the climate change issue) What are the alternative responses that might be used in dealing with climate change? 3. What options exist for avoiding or limiting changes through reducing the emissions of greenhouse gases and/or reducing anthropogenic changes to albedo and standing bio-mass? 4. What options exist for geoengineering to avoid undesirable climate change while continuing current loadings? 5. What options exist for adapting to climate change? 6. What are the relative advantages and disadvantages of alternative responses and their implementation strategies to “key groups?” ■ ■ ■
■
■ ■
■
■
■
What is the ethical acceptability of each to “key groups?” How well are the economic costs and risks of each known? How well are the political, social, ecological and other non-economic costs and risks of each known? What are the prospects for reducing key uncertainties about costs and risks of each through research? How well are the economic benefits of each known? How well are the political, social, ecological and other non-economic benefits of each known? What are the prospects for reducing key uncertainties about benefits of each through research? What are the most attractive options for each “key group” if groups must act alone? What are the most attractive options for each “key group” if groups could act collectively?
What choices will and should be made? ■
■
■
What are the most likely policy responses for each “key group” given their current “decisions making culture?” What are the opportunities for improving individuals or collective outcomes through various policy interventions? If collective action is required, how is it best achieved?
SCALING IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT 59
Table 4.2: continued 2. What are the determinants of how various “key groups” value the effects of climate change and of possible policy interventions and reach decisions about them? What ethical framing does each “key group” apply in addressing these issues? What is mankind’s relations to nature, to time, etc.? ■ To what domain of issues is “economics” considered applicable? What issues ■ are framed in terms of rights, duties, etc.? What are the conflicts and contradictions between the ethical framing adopted ■ and the constraints of physical reality? What views does each “key group” hold about the nature of the climate and earth/biological system? 1. How is economic analysis done? How should it be done to be consistent with the group’s basic ethical framing? ■ ■ ■ ■
How are various things priced or otherwise valued? How should they be? How are things valued over long time periods? How should they be? How is aggregate economic performance measured? How should they be? How are large (non-incremental) changes evaluated? How should they be?
What are the mechanisms for collective decision-making and dispute resolution? How are decisions made within the group? ■ How are decisions made between groups? ■ What options exist to “improve” collective decision-making and dispute ■ resolution? 3. What are the human activities that can modify climate? What are the emissions and activities of concern? How are they distributed geographically? How much have they changed in the past? How might they change in the future (absent any intervention)? How do they compare to non-anthropogenic emissions? 4. What changes in climate will occur? What are the measures of global climate change? How do greenhouse gas emissions cause changes in these measures? What factors affect the rate of change? Has change already resulted from human activity? What magnitude of changes might result from increases in future emissions? 5. What effects will this climate change bring? What is the magnitude of sea-level rise that might occur? What is the effect on agricultural crops? What is the effect on managed and unmanaged ecosystems? What is the effect on water supplies? How do the above effects change the prospects for (a) goods and services, (b) human health, (c) how time is spent, (d) the physical environment, (e) social justice, and (f) other social interactions? * Note that in contrast to many lists of “climate questions,” this list begins with policy issues and moves on to matters of straight science only in its later stages.
60 SCALE AND SCOPE IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT
Figure 4.1: A global influence diagram of the climate change problem (see textbox for further explanation).
Finally, decision-analysis requires an understanding of the uncertainties relevant to each choice. We spent much of our first year recognizing that there were parametric and structural uncertainties in our understanding of the natural and social systems that make up life and its environment on earth. We also noted variability among different actors in how different aspects of life are valued. These uncertainties were so large that we spent the first eight months of the
SCALING IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT 61 This framework treats the problem as being divided into four broad domains. These domains are, from left to right: the setting of the climate problem, the apparatus of the human decision making and sustenance, the options available for dealing with the climate change issue; and the natural system. • The setting of the climate problem has five major components. These are: i) The stock of knowledge, science, and technology. ii) The values held about change in various elements of the human and natural system. iii) The structural of social institutions & decision processes. iv) The stock of resources, which are a "god given endowment." At any given time only a fraction of this is available to the allocation model. The size of this fraction is determined by the state of our knowledge and technology. v) Acts of god which occur in both the natural and the human systems and can be characterized as volcanic eruptions and revolutions respectively. • The human sustenance and decision making apparatus is made up of three elements. These elements are: i) Humans perceive phenomena, understand these and identify potential problems/hazards. ii) The latter initiate an enquiry which requires assessment of a value for the various consequences being pondered. iii) The valuations dictate a paradigm and (possibly a strategy) for resource allocation. • The resources available can be distributed among the various options based on the valued consequences and the current state of knowledge. The options available at any given time fall into five categories: i) Invest in more R&D and learn about the potential problem and possible solutions. ii) Continue with the use of resources and economic development. iii) Adopt a GHG and land use change abatement policy, so that the magnitude of climate change can be kept in check. iv) Adopt a strategy for adapting to climate change of a given magnitude. v) Engage in geoengineering options designed to keep climate parameters of consequence within prescribed bounds. • These actions will all have impacts on the natural system. Here this system is divided into two elements: i) The climate system. ii) The environment. Finally it should be noted that changes in the climate system and the environment are either directly or indirectly (via economic impacts of change) picked up by the human decision making and sustenance apparatus.
project wondering whether a quantitative model of climate change would serve any useful purpose when uncertainties were so large. However, we as a group felt more comfortable using quantitative rather than qualitative modes for expressing our ideas and we did build a series of models to discuss the useful and the feasible features of such models. By this stage we were ready to discuss an iterative approach to integrated assessment that would start with the simplest framing that captured the relevant features of the problem and cycled through different iterations to refine the information needed to answer specific questions [10]. Having defined the scope of our research through these questions, we had to adopt a scale at which to study them. An overwhelming feature of the questions listed in Table 4.1 is that climate change and its impacts, as well as the various response policies we may adopt (i.e., adaptation, mitigation and geoengineering) will be manifested in different
62 SCALE AND SCOPE IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT
ways in various regions of the world and perceived differently by different people. This heterogeneity in outcome and in perceptions about these outcomes has dictated the scale adopted for ICAM. Our research group’s conclusions about the scale and scope of the climate problem were first published in reaction to the analyses already in hand. The most prominent studies of climate change and policy up to 1991 featured: ■ ■ ■
■
unitary global actors, time horizons spanning a century or more, no admission of uncertainties in understanding of possible climate change processes, and, no admission of how options to abate greenhouse gas emissions, adapt to climate change impacts or engineer the climate system would be valued by different interested parties.
We were certain that it would be erroneous to start an integrated assessment with these assertions [11, 12] and hence developed a framework explicitly representing differences in subjective perspectives on costs and benefits of climate policy and uncertainties in climate science [13]. In this particular study (ICAM 0), the scale at which the problem is resolved is that of the values humans bring to climate change mitigation and climate change impacts. Perceptions, impacts and adaptation The most important driver of our evolving perspective on scale has been the issue of subjective perspectives and heterogeneity of experience. In other words, even though we are considering global climate change, different locations will experience different changes to their climate and different people will evaluate the desirability of the same change in their climate differently. The initial steps to reflect these realities in integrated assessments led to Integrated Climate Assessment Model (ICAM) 0. In this version, while climate change was globally homogenous, nine different perspectives could be entertained on climate policy costs and climate change impacts [13]. We found that subjective perspectives dominated scientific uncertainties in such analyses. Today, a decade after we first framed this question, while scientific opinion has gradually solidified around the reality of anthropogenic climate change, the policy divide has remained intractable. There are those who believe mitigation is more costly than realizable benefits, while others believe the benefits are so large that draconian controls must be undertaken immediately. There is fundamental polarity of opinion on these issues. This polarity drives the dynamics of any policy initiative regarding climate change. While our efforts have been aimed at providing higher and higher resolution scientific models of climate change, we do not know how such increased detail affects the perspectives of different individuals. What we need is a better understanding of how additional information may change the positions adopted by the different parties. In a democracy, the challenge we face is to provide credible
SCALING IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT 63
and targeted information to move the debate forward. Finer geographic scale simply leads to modeling results (regardless of relevance or accuracy) being believed more readily by the public – simply due to their realistic depiction of familiar geographic outlines. In ICAM 1 we allowed for different manifestations of climate change in a world with two regions (low latitudes and high latitudes), even though the people in each region had similar judgements about climate policy and climate change impacts [14]. Since that time, successive generations of ICAM have had finer spatial and temporal scales, primarily to increase the accuracy with which specific spatial heterogeneity is reproduced. Fundamentally however, the original insights of ICAM 0 (which had no spatial scale) prevail – people’s subjective perspectives dominate scientific uncertainties in choosing an appropriate climate policy. Beyond the insights from ICAM 0, I have come to recognize that a focus on subjective experiences should dictate a much finer scale of resolution for realistic analyses of the issues at hand. Cognitively, change will be experienced on a local level. Slow trends, may never be consciously noted and are likely to be swamped by our efforts to adapt to the large and inevitable changes we all undergo – e.g., aging. In other words, while we age, our perceptions of what what is changing in our local and more distant environment and whether that is desirable evolves through time. For example, we recall much higher snow fall from when we were children (partly because we were shorter). We also tend to grow less tolerance of cold weather as we age, and reconsider the ideal climates to live in. One of our team members, Shane Frederick [15], explored how much people think they change as they age. For example, he asked 15 year olds how similar they thought they would be to their current selves when 50, and he asked 50 year olds how similar to their current selves they were as teenagers. His findings show that people expect significant changes in their personal activities and preferences over time. Many believed that they would retain less than half of their personality traits over the span of three decades [15]. These levels of personal change are clearly far larger than environmental changes that we seek to forestall or prepare to adapt to. Therefore, it is not unreasonable to expect almost sub-conscious adaptation to environmental trends that take place more slowly than the personal changes we inevitably experience. I am not suggesting that all slow changes in environmental conditions go undetected, but some are likely to be lost in the noise. Furthermore, when the underlying factors shaping environmental conditions are complex, the interpretation of detected changes is open to misinterpreted. For example, changes in local land cover and air pollution affect local climates. In Pittsburgh, average annual temperatures fell by 3 °C from 1950 to 1970 and rose again by a similar amount from 1970 to 2000. When surveyed, the public was perhaps too young to have experienced the former cooling trend but readily noted the warming trend. Furthermore, they readily attributed this warming to
64 SCALE AND SCOPE IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT
“global climate change.” It is more likely though that the warming in Pittsburgh is due to much lower atmospheric concentrations of sulfate aerosols brought about by the demise of the local steel and coke industries and successful implementation of the Clean Air Act. Correct attribution is critical to taking appropriate actions. Today, our institutions have prepared the public to worry about climate change. Various phenomena will be tied to climate change by the public whether or not such conclusions are scientifically valid. This issue is even more pronounced for extreme events, and these leave lasting psychological impressions. Extreme events are easily detected and often attributed to phenomena that the public psyche has been primed to accept. The wrath of this or that god common in polytheistic cultures is in response to some human misdeed. Today’s sin is often assumed to be our despoiling of the environment, but the wrath remains the same: storms, floods, draughts and so on. Studies of the available evidence do not support the notion that extreme events have changed dramatically in their frequency and severity over the past century [16]. Nevertheless, over the past decade extreme events have routinely been attributed to anthropogenic climate change. Our social organizations have adopted climate change as their favorite cause for any detected changes in adverse environmental conditions. Furthermore, improved newsgathering and dissemination has allowed information about extreme weather events (which are essentially local in nature) to be broadcast worldwide. This has blurred geographic factors (which have a significant bearing on the possibility of specific extreme events occurring locally) and contributed to the sense of public dread about climate change. This provides further evidence of cognitive dimensions of the problem dominating geography. Social institutions not only play a role in our interpretation of environmental changes, but also the dominant modes of response. As noted above, there is little statistical support for the notion that extreme weather events have increased in their frequency or severity. There is little doubt that they would persist whether there is a climate treaty or not. Sadly, the global response to these events has not been a call for better warning and response measures for dealing with extreme weather events (especially in less industrialized countries), but a clarion for mitigation of climate change. Schelling [17, 18, 19] is eloquent in arguing for promotion of development as the most effective measure to address the vicissitudes of climate. However, environmental activists use the extreme events to feed the fires of our remorse for being insatiable consumers of the earth’s exhaustible bounty. Integrated Assessments are about how problems are framed and solutions explored. The scale of analysis needs to reflect who is active in proposing interventions to protect life and property and what measures they are promoting. An early warning system and response needs to be adapted to local geographical conditions and suitable for implementation using local resources. A global carbon dioxide control strategy rarely considers factors beyond large players in the energy markets.
SCALING IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT 65
Sea level rise revisited One of the more thoroughly studied impacts of “global warming” is sea level rise. Global mean sea level is expected to rise due to thermal expansion and a net release of water from glaciers worldwide. There is no doubt that rising sea level will inundate low-lying lands.2 However, there are three processes of local importance that will define our capacity to adapt to sea level rise. The scale and scope of climate change assessment must be sufficiently fine and broad to capture these processes. Otherwise, the information provided to decision-makers will be erroneous. These three processes are: ■
■
■
Factors affecting relative sea level in specific locations (physical and cognitive) Factors affecting local development of coastal areas (cognitive and institutional) Factors affecting recovery from storms (cognitive and institutional)
Figure 4.2 depicts local relative sea level for four different locations. The differences between these are staggering. The local sea level is rising 18 times faster near Bangkok than near Mumbai. The reason behind the dramatically faster local sea level rise near Bangkok is fresh water withdrawal and surface water management causing land subsidence. It is clear that in this case sea level rise due to climate change is a secondary issue. Rapidly growing demand for fresh water is not unique to Bangkok. In many low-lying islands and coastal areas the same challenge exists. The problem is local. The condition is repeated globally. Thailand is in the process of implementing programs promoting water table recharge to slow local subsidence. It is not clear that in other locations encountering the same challenges, the institutions to respond are in place. Coastal developments are another example of a local phenomenon globally repeated. Safe harbors gave shelter from storms and made it possible to have a sustained fishing effort or establish trade centers at the mouth of inland waterways. If the location was not safe it could not prosper long. Now, shorelines are being developed for leisure and housing. Many of the locations being developed today were not developed historically because of their vulnerability to storms. Unfortunately, developers rarely consider this in locating new homes and communities. Their goal is to develop property, sell it and move on. Their exposure is being hit by a storm between setting the foundation and handing the key to an unsuspecting immigrant to that location. This clearly increases exposure to extreme events on the coasts, but again, the factor that is leading to rapid increases in risk is not climate change but ill-considered location of new developments on the coast. 2
There is also no doubt in my mind that we will not implement a climate policy that will save the populations and resources at risk from sea level rise in the next few decades.
66 SCALE AND SCOPE IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT
Figure 4.2: Local trends in relative sea level Figure 4.2a shows that while the long-term trends in monthly tide-gauge data for Mumbai suggest a relative sea level rise of .7 mm per year. But the raw data suggest two periods of relative stability in relative sea level with more rapid changes in sea level during periods of transition from one level to another. In figure 4.2b we observe that tide-gauge data for Churchill, where the glacial rebound of the Canadian Shield is argued to be continuing leading to relative fall in sea level. In figure 4.2c we can observe that tide-gauge data in Kobe, Japan are recording rapid changes in relative sea level with the trend changing sharply in the wake of the massive earthquake suffered there in 1994. Figure 4.2d reflects tide-gauge data for Pom Prachum in Thailand where surface water management in Bangkok and withdrawals from the water table have influenced a much more rapid rise in local sea level in the past four decades. The rate of change in sea level here is 18.5 times faster here than in Mumbai. Data: Permanent Service for Mean Sea Level, UK
The news is not all gloomy. The ability to forecast storms and the ability to move people out of harm’s way have improved dramatically over the past century. From 1900 to 1910 more than 8000 people perished in storms pounding the coastline of the United States. During the 1990s, this number had fallen to 1/50th of 80 years earlier. Meanwhile, property damages quintupled from $4 billions in the 1930s to $20 billion in the 1990s. This is because so much more property was placed in harm’s way in coastal developments.
SCALING IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT 67
How much damage is inflicted by storms in the future is dictated by how much of our resources we place in harm’s way. This is a repeated game. Each storm brings information about places where property is at higher risk. We can reduce future exposure to this risk by not rebuilding there. This iterative process of locating our developments where they are safe from storms is key to reducing the impacts of future sea level rise. In our studies of impacts and adaptation we have learned that where it is possible to create institutions to “learn and respond to natural extremes” impacts from climate change can be significantly reduced [20]. We have learned three important lessons from this work: ■
■
■
Local development patterns determine the initial conditions and exposure to risk. There is no reason to believe that current development patterns are optimal in their reduction of risk to coastal dwellers. Local regulations governing recovery from storm damage determine the persistence and cumulative damage from storms through time. Where storms send strong signals of inappropriate development, rebuilding is unwise. If regulations limit such rebuilding, total damages from storms and sea level rise combined can be reduced by an order of magnitude over a century time-scale. If rebuilding regulations prohibit rebuilding in risky locations cumulative damages from small storms far exceeds those from large storms. Should climate change lead to more extreme storm events, the long-term impacts in coastal areas will be lower.
These insights all point to the role our perceptions play in the design of institutions created to address our concerns. We worry about households who suffer the impact of coastal storms and riverine flooding but create institutions that often help them rebuild their property in harm’s way. We worry about the impact of more severe storms, but it is the small and frequent storms that inflict the greater cumulative damage. Perceptions are critical to our ability to recognize what contributes to the risks we face and how best to reduce these. Climate change impact assessments need to be developed with a scale and scope appropriate to capturing the essential features of human perception of natural events and their impacts, and how best to limit their initial impacts and recover from their consequences. Energy markets and technological progress I would like to use energy markets and technical change to highlight the issue of co-existing and competing scales of organization as a fundamental feature of social systems. The single most important factor in determining future atmospheric concentrations of greenhouse gases is technical change. Technical change determines the pattern and extent of economic activity. Technical change determines the types and magnitude of resources we harness to meet economic needs and our expectations about lifestyles. Climate policy is our attempt to influence
68 SCALE AND SCOPE IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT
the direction of technical change so that a given level of economic activity can be achieved at lower levels of greenhouse gas emissions. Interestingly though, technical change is more often than not treated as an exogenous factor in studies of climate change [21, 22]. The inadvisability of treating technical change as an exogenous variable aside, scale plays a significant role in how technical progress evolves. In ICAM-3, technical change has been formulated as an endogenous process [23]. I am a believer in the old saying: “necessity is the mother of invention.” Therefore, I believe that purposive technical progress is brought forth to solve a perceived problem. Scale enters the picture because of the way in which I believe technical progress is diffused. For example, whenever energy prices rise, technical change is unleashed to come up with a solution. But there are at least two solutions to this challenge: a) discovery of lower cost ways to produce energy, b) search for more efficient ways of using energy. I believe that evolution of the pattern of energy use is then shaped by competition between technological innovation and diffusion on the supply side and technological innovation and diffusion on the demand side of energy markets. There are however, significant differences in organizational coherence on the two sides of this market. This, difference in organizational scale leads to a particular pattern of dynamics that needs to be taken into account when considering long-term policies affecting energy use. Energy supply is a fairly concentrated and large-scale activity. Energy costs are the primary concern of this industry and their innovative activities are unlikely to be captured by other concerns. Therefore, innovations are directly aimed at improving energy discovery and production and are rapidly adopted when needed. On the demand side however, energy is used in order to gain a large variety of services and labor savings. For the innovator and adopter, the services delivered are the primary concern and energy use is secondary. Furthermore, the scale at which technology is adopted is household-by-household and business-by-business. Therefore, adoption is a far slower process and rarely motivated by energy (or carbon) saving considerations. This leads to a particularly interesting dynamic process of technical progress and diffusion in energy markets. In the wake of a crisis that raises energy prices, there is innovative activity in both the supply and the demand technologies. However, the more rapid adoption of technical breakthroughs on the supply side lead to more plentiful supply (of a resource or its substitute) and lower energy prices. One example of such technical breakthroughs is in oil drilling and production. We are now able to direct the drilling process in any desired direction. When this capability is combined with monitoring of chemical gradients in the well, the drill can be piloted towards the smallest of reservoirs. This has permitted economic oil recovery from reservoirs previously considered too small to exploit or even include in reserve assessments. Rapid adoption of technology on the supply-side often lowers energy prices before the technologies promising better end-use energy efficiency are broadly adopted in the market. Such
SCALING IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT 69
technological progress is not lost, but is more often used to deliver a wider range of services for which energy is being used.3 Here the diffusion of technical progress may be slower, but can persist even when energy prices are low or falling. The reason for this paradox is that the technical progress in question (e.g., variable valve timing for internal combustion engines) is no longer solving the problem for which is was invented (higher fuel efficiency), but by providing more services (a broader and higher torque curve from the same engine displacement) is a weapon in the auto industry’s competition for the consumers’ pocket book. Scale, the study of climate policy and its evolution At the outset I argued that climate change is not a problem of unprecedented scale. I argued that humanity has a long history of affecting its environment to the limits of its known extent. In contrast to climate change, I believe organizational scale and persistence needed to implement an effective climate policy has no historic precedent. Greenhouse gases are long lived. The climate system responds with a lag of something between 10 and 50 years. The dynamics of terrestrial ecosystems and carbon storage are on the century time-scale and ocean processes have elements whose temporal extent can span more than a millennium. In order for us to entertain a successful solution to the climate problem, we need to recognize the required longevity of an effective policy. Such a policy needs to stabilize greenhouse gas concentrations in the atmosphere. Doing so requires century-scale persistence in control of emissions. Few human endeavors have spanned such time-scales unchanged. Political systems rarely last more than a decade. Even fundamental social movements rarely last more than half a century. For example, consider the social programs that shaped the governments of Europe in the decades following WWII. All have come to be reviewed and redefined in the closing decade of the twentieth century. Sovereign nations also seem to have a longevity that rarely exceeds a century.4 It is hard to imagine how a climate policy will be made stable over such long timescales. Even the signatories to the treaty will change over its requisite duration. The only feasible approach to making sure climate policy can survive this underlying pattern of instability is to make sure there are irreversible steps in the path to lower greenhouse gas emissions. This irreversibility would ensure continuation of reduced emissions even when the forces making climate policy desirable fail to see through their vision.
3
Take the efficiency of internal combustion engines. Today’s, average engine is twice as efficient as an equivalent engine (of similar output) 30 years ago. However, as energy prices stabilized and then fell during the 80s and 90s, the performance of engines was nudged up, almost every year, in order to attract customers. 4 Religious movements probably last the longest, but evolve considerably over time.
70 SCALE AND SCOPE IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT
Beyond unprecedented longevity, a successful climate strategy needs to involve all major emitters of greenhouse gases. Without the participation of the OECD, Former Soviet States, India and China, emission reduction efforts have little chance of assuring stabilization of greenhouse gas concentrations in the atmosphere. At present, climate change is one of the last concerns of most less-industrial countries. They face the danger of instability as they have raised the expectations of their populace with visions of plenty and wealth in the wake of liberalized markets and globalized trade. It will be difficult to meet these expectations. It may be possible to implement climate policy as a means of reducing expectations. Just as at times of war, the general public willingly adopts austerity and hardship in order to achieve a greater good. Whether this approach will or can be adopted remains to be seen. It is possible that a clever government can translate public concern about extreme events into adoption of a climate policy. Imagine a setting in which the above has been achieved and a fairly comprehensive emissions control program is in place. The public is likely to continue to associate extreme weather conditions as manifestations of climate change. How will they respond when we continue to have extreme events even after a decade or more of selfimposed austerity? I believe there will be strong local forces to break global compacts to control emission. Here again, cognitive forces dominate the dynamics of policy formation and dissolution. If a large enough party to the global climate accord steps away from the agreement, resuming a growing emissions trajectory, the burden of control for the remaining parties to the agreement can grow to the point of extreme economic discomfort and further defections. A domino effect would then take over and the mitigation policy would collapse. The mechanism and probability of such policy failures are reflected in ICAM-3 and discussed and elsewhere [24]. This is an example of how at the international level the crossscale organizational features of initiatives for climate policy implementation dominate the dynamics of their stability and success. An interesting aspect of the climate change challenge is that mitigation is not the only policy option. There is likely to be adaptation to climate change, whether or not there is a mitigation policy. This can be undertaken at different scales appropriate to representation of different aspects of climate change and its impacts. However, geoengineering of the climate system is also a possibility. A possibility that can be launched unilaterally by a nation that perceives a sufficient threat from climate change. The requisite technology is not too sophisticated, the scale of the impact can be limited to one region and the persistence of the effect can be as short as a few weeks. This policy can be launched with little prior preparation, yielding almost immediate relief from some aspects of climate change. In summary, different policies require different scales of participation and persistence. For mitigation (the policy most often talked about) to be successful requires a scale of participation that has no historic precedent.
SCALING IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT 71
Conclusions on Scope and Scale The examples I have offered suggest that even in the study of a global process such as climate change the scope should be expanded to include local phenomena, such as local changes in sea level or initial conditions for coastal developments. In other words context matters a great deal in how climate change impacts will emerge and how well we can cope with these. There is broad agreement that multiple stresses acting on the system simultaneously are where we should be focussing our attention. We are now in a better position to realize that interactions between different stresses and the remedies we adopt in dealing with these are how we change the profile of our vulnerability [25, 26]. I worry that the narrower scope of initiatives such as the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change have led to too much focus on climate issues and insufficient attention to other processes of environmental and social change. I also believe that there has been a misallocation of human capital to the study climate related issues while these other issues loom larger and more immediate. Therefore, I fear that the narrower focus on climate change, adopted by so many of us, has needlessly limited the generation and delivery of appropriate scientific information to the decision-makers responsible for shepherding local, regional and national development plans. The focus on crafting a global accord on climate change has led to a political impasse that, if ever made substantive, is unlikely to deliver a solution that will be embraced by the industrialized and non-industrialized nations alike. Meanwhile, we could have tried to craft an accord on a global effort to deliver potable water, or sanitation. We could have launched a program on mapping global natural hazards and put into place institutions that can limit our vulnerability to these. Unfortunately, by continuing to focus on Kyoto, these and other opportunities to implement good policies whether or not climate changes are being lost every day. The insight I hope to illustrate with the examples above is the importance of understanding and representing interacting processes at appropriate scale(s). All too often, the different sides of an equation (or system in dynamic tension) are represented as being at the same scale. The social sciences are an aggregation of scholarly studies at different scales from the cognitive psychologists who focus on the individual, to organizational behaviorists who study groups of people aiming to achieve a specific goal, to social and political scientists who study our interactions at higher levels of aggregation. What makes the social sciences so very difficult is that under the appropriate conditions, observed phenomena are under the influence of forces at many different scales. Unlike the natural sciences (specifically Physics) where at a given scale, one force of nature dominates interactions, in social interactions cognitive processes of the individual are affected by the culture of the society and the society’s culture can be shaped under the influence of an individual’s
72 SCALE AND SCOPE IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT
thought processes. This is not simply true for public policy, it reaches deep into our psyche and permeates how we conduct research in both what we choose to study and how we interpret available empirical evidence [27]. In a sense this can be viewed as coming back full circle. After ten years of research, I am still asking, what is good climate policy? and what is good policy if climate changes? But at least I have some idea that the problem needs to be tackled using multi-scale analyses that reflect human cognitive and organizational issues as well as the scales at which natural processes operate.
References 1.
Root, T. L., and S. H. Schneider, 1995. “Ecology and climate: Research strategies and implications.” Science 269: 331–341. 2. Rubin, E. S., 1991. “Benefit-Cost Implications of Acid Rain Controls: an evaluation of the NAPAP Integrated Assessment.” Journal of the Air & Waste Management Association 41: 914–921. 3. Rubin, E. S., M. J. Small, C. N. Bloyd, and M. Henrion, 1992. “An Integrated Assessment of Acid Deposition Effects on Lake Acidification.” Journal of Environmental Engineering, ASCE 118: 120–134. 4. Russell, A. G., H. Dowlatabadi, and A. J. Krupnick, 1992. “Electric Vehicles and the Environment.” Energy & Environment 3: 148–160. 5. Henrion, M., and M. G. Morgan, 1985. “A Computer Aid for Risk and Other Policy Analysis.” Risk Analysis 5: 195–208. 6. Morgan, M. G., M. Henrion, S. C. Morris, and D. A. L. Amaral, 1985. “Uncertainty in Risk Assessment.” Environmental Science and Technology 19: 662–667. 7. Henrion, M., M. G. Morgan, I. Nair, and C. Wiecha, 1986. “Evaluating an Information System for Policy Modeling and Uncertainty Analysis.” Journal of the American Society for Information Science 37: 319–330. 8. Bostrom, A., B. Fischhoff, and M. G. Morgan, 1992. “Characterizing Mental Models of Hazardous Processes: a methodology and an application to radon.” Journal of Social Issues 48: 85–100. 9. Morgan, M. G., B. Fischhoff, A. Bostrom, L. Lave, and C. J. Atman, 1992. “Communicating Risk to the Public: first learn what people know.” Environmental Science and Technology 26: 2048–2056. 10. Dowlatabadi, H., and M. G. Morgan, 1993a. “Integrated Assessment of Climate Change.” Science 259: 1813. 11. Lave, L. B., H. Dowlatabadi, G. J. McRae, M. G. Morgan, and E. S. Rubin, 1992. “Making Global Climate Change Research More Productive.” Nature 355: 197. 12. Dowlatabadi, H., and L. B. Lave, 1993. “Pondering Greenhouse Policy (Letter).” Science 259: 1381.
SCALING IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT 73
13. Lave, L. B., and H. Dowlatabadi, 1993. “Climate Change Policy: The Effects of Personal Beliefs and Scientific Uncertainty.” Environmental Science and Technology 27: 1962–1972. 14. Dowlatabadi, H., and M. G. Morgan, 1993b. “A Model Framework for Integrated Studies of the Climate Problem.” Energy Policy 21: 209–221. 15. Frederick, S., 1999. Time Preferences. Department of Social and Decision Sciences. Pittsburgh, PA, Carnegie Mellon University. 16. IPCC, 2001. Third Assessment Report: WGI, Cambridge University Press. 17. Schelling, T. C., 1983. Climate Change: Implications for Welfare and Policy. Changing Climate. National Research Council. Washington, D.C.: National Academy Press. 18. Schelling, T. C., 1992. “Some Economics of Global Warming.” The American Economic Review: 1–14. 19. Schelling, T. C., 1994. “Intergenerational Discounting.” Energy Policy 23: 395–402. 20. West, J. J., and H. Dowlatabadi, 1998. On assessing the economic impacts of sea level rise on developed coasts. Climate, change and risk. T. E. Downing, A. A. Olsthoorn, and R. S. J. Tol. London: Routledge. 21. Azar, C., and H. Dowlatabadi, 1999. A Review of the Treatment of Technical Change in Energy Economics Models. Annual Review of Energy and the Environment. R. Socolow. Palo Alto, California, Annual Reviews Inc. 24: 513–543. 22. Weyant, J. P., and T. Olavson, 1999. “Issues in modeling induced technological change in energy, environmental and climate policy.” Environmental Modeling and Assessment 4: 67–85. 23. Dowlatabadi, H., 1998. “Sensitivity of Climate Change Mitigation Estimates to Assumptions About Technical Change.” Energy Economics 20: 473–493. 24. Dowlatabadi, H., 2000. “Bumping against a gas ceiling.” Climatic Change 46: 391–407. 25. Graetz, D., H. Dowlatabadi, J. Risbey, and M. Kandlikar, 1997. Applying Frameworks for Assessing Agricultural Adaptation to Climate Change in Australia. Canberra, Center for Integrated Study of the Human Dimensions of Global Change. 26. Risbey, J., M. Kandlikar, D. Graetz, and H. Dowlatabadi, 1999. “Scale and Contextual Issues in Agricultural Adaptation to Climate Variability and Change.” Mitigation and Adaptation Strategies for Global Change 4: 137–165. 27. Gould, S. J., 1981. The Mismeasure of Man. New York, NY, W. W. Norton & Co.
5 Scaling Issues in the Social Sciences 1
2
3
TOM P. EVANS , ELINOR OSTROM AND CLARK GIBSON 1 Department of Geography, Center for the Study of Institutions, Population and Environmental Change, Indiana University, Bloomington, United States 2 Department of Political Science, Center for the Study of Institutions, Population and Environmental Change, Indiana University, Bloomington, United States 3 Department of Political Science, University of California, San Diego, United States
Abstract The issue of scale is critical to the understanding of data collection, data representation, data analysis and modeling in the social and biophysical sciences. Integrated assessment models must acknowledge these scale issues in order to evaluate the utility and results of these models. This awareness of scale has been widely recognized in the physical sciences and a variety of tools have been developed to address these scale issues, although there is no general consensus on what tools to apply in what situations. Scale issues have been less widely addressed in the social sciences, but recent literature suggests an increasing awareness. This paper addresses the importance of scale issues to social data as they are related to integrated assessment modeling. A review of terminology related to scale issues is presented to address the vagueness and lack of consensus in this terminology. Scientists from a variety of social disciplines have addressed scale issues from different perspectives and these are briefly reviewed. Keywords: scale; spatial analysis; social science; integrated assessment Acknowledgements Institutional support from the Center for the Study of Institutions, Population and Environmental Change (NSF; SBR 9521918) is gratefully acknowledged. Bill McConnell provided helpful comments in the construction of this paper.
76 SCALING ISSUES IN THE SOCIAL SCIENCES
Introduction The importance of scale issues is widely recognized. Methods of dealing with the effects of scale are not, however, universally accepted. Cohesive theories of scale, with a few isolated exceptions, have not yet been developed, widely applied or widely accepted. Because scale issues pervade data collection and representation efforts, spatial data modeling, including integrated assessment modeling (IAM) is dramatically affected by these scale issues [1]. Both social and natural scientists acknowledge the importance of scale effects and how relationships and processes operate differently at different scales [2, 3]. Because of the varying nature of social-biophysical interactions as a function of scale [4], many researchers have concluded that a multi-scale approach is necessary to understand the relationships between variables or the function of social and biophysical processes [2, 5]. While scale effects are widely acknowledged, a considerable amount of research in integrated assessment and global change research is still conducted at a single scale of analysis using data collected at single scales. Important conclusions are drawn about the relative impact of different factors using only household, regional or global scale analysis. This dependence on a single scale is understandable. In some cases, data availability may limit the ability to examine relationships across scales, particularly for regional and global extents. In other cases, labor resource limitations may make a multi-scale approach infeasible. A continent-scale examination of the impact of population growth on deforestation can hardly expect to use household level data as a social unit of analysis for such a large geographic extent. Yet, it is critical that researchers pursue research questions that operate at large scales where these data availability problems and resource limitations predominate. In these cases, researchers must attempt to hypothesize about the impact of different operational scales on the phenomenon they are studying. This paper explores how some social scientists have acknowledged the importance of scale issues, the various meanings of scale in different social science disciplines and the implications of scale issues to social science within the realm of IAM. The first section of this paper discusses the various terminology related to scale issues from different social science disciplines. The second section of this paper reviews how different disciplines have developed different meanings of “scale”, drawing from Gibson et al. [3]. Section three discusses the implications of scale on social data collection focusing on individual, household, community and regional levels of aggregation. The following two sections review specific methods of dealing with scale developed from the fields of the social and natural sciences. The paper closes with a discussion of how these components relate to data collection and representation for integrative assessment and integrated assessment modeling.
SCALING IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT 77
Scaling Terminology The vagueness of the terms “scale” and “level” contribute to the difficulty of developing universal theories of scale effects [6]. While the meaning of “scale” varies across (and within) disciplines, there are common threads within these different meanings. Scale can be referred to as the spatial, temporal, quantitative, or analytical dimensions used by scientists to measure and study objects and processes [3]. Levels refer to a region along a measurement dimension. For example, the terms micro, meso, and macro refer in general to regions on spatial scales referring to small, medium, and large-sized phenomena. To be precise about the concept of scale, one needs to refer to the concepts of extent and resolution. Extent refers to the magnitude of a dimension used in measuring some phenomenon. Spatially, extent may range from a meter or less, to millions of square meters or more. Temporally, extent may involve a second, an hour, a day, or even a century, a millennium, or many millennia. The extent of a scale establishes the outer boundary for what is being measured. Resolution refers to the precision used in measurement. The term “grain” is used to refer to the smallest unit of resolution along a particular scale. Social scientists use a variety of resolutions in their measurements. In regard to time, physical scientists frequently use extremely small units of time when measuring physical processes. Most social scientists, on the other hand, rarely use a resolution of less than an hour. Such a unit would only be used when timing groups of individuals performing particular tasks such as labor allocation. Many types of social science data are recorded on an annual or decadal basis. In this paper, we will use small scale to refer to phenomena that are limited in their spatial, temporal, or numerical extent and large scale to refer to big quantities or space. This is how many people understand the term in everyday usage, but it is exactly the opposite of the way the terms are used by cartographers. For integrated assessment modeling, choices about scales, levels, extent, and resolution affect what data is collected, how it is calibrated, what data can be used for validation, and what are the basic units that can be used in a model of a process. For example, a researcher must determine what the appropriate level of analysis is when examining the relationship between changes in agricultural production and climate change. In developing countries, land management decisions are often made at a household level, yet most climatechange models are focused at a regional level of analysis. It is these cross-scale issues that need to be reconciled within integrated assessment modeling. It is important to distinguish between how scale issues relate to data collection versus data representation and how scale related terminology refer to both areas in the social sciences. In terms of data collection and cartographic representation, scale implies a representative fraction related to portraying data in the real world on a map (e.g., topographic maps showing village
78 SCALING ISSUES IN THE SOCIAL SCIENCES
locations and road features) The implications of map scale are common across disciplines and well documented. For example, scale affects the representation of a road used for market accessibility in the same way scale affects the representation of a stream or contour line. In the social sciences, scale can also refer to the social unit of analysis. For example, socio-demographic data are collected at the individual, household and community level. This social unit of analysis is critical in the observation of certain processes. For example, in many rural environments, land-use decisions are made at the household level within a regional context. Individual migrant decisions are made within the context of the household. Both cases are examples of lower-level agents or actors being affected by higher-level forces or factors. While social data are commonly collected at one of the above social units of analysis, it should be noted that these terms (individual, household, community) mean different things in different areas. For example, the meaning of a household differs dramatically between cultures. Land settlement patterns and institutional regimes affect how a community is defined and what the implications of a community arrangement are for decision making and vice versa. It is also important to understand how the terms “scale-up” and “scaledown” apply to social science data. Curran et al. [6] has identified how these terms alone are vague and that specifying between what scales data are being transformed is a more precise method of description. Household level data are commonly scaled up to a regional level representation such as with census enumeration units. Household level data are also commonly scaled up to a community level. With this scaling-up, data variability is clearly lost as with any data aggregation procedure. It should also be noted that different social variables are affected by this scaling-up differently. For example, household size scales-up to the community level population totals with little impact on the precision or accuracy of those data (assuming no households are excluded in the household survey). In contrast, data on ethnic composition or religious affiliation does not scale-up well as these are nominal data attributes. In addition, scaling-up or aggregating data on labor allocation and land-use from the household to the community level loses the complex household dynamic that exists between these variables. Social science researchers also sometimes use data at a higher scale to represent a social unit at a lower scale. For example, social data at the census block or block-group level (U.S. census enumeration units analogous to groups of city blocks) can be mapped to households within those enumeration units. For example, hospitals collect address information for patients and addressmatching procedures allows these addresses to be spatially located. The socioeconomic characteristics of the census unit an address falls within, such as educational background or median family income, can be assigned to a patient as a prediction of that patient’s characteristics. However, this downscaling or disaggregation clearly risks mis-representing households because
SCALING IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT 79
the higher-scale census block-group data does not indicate the variability within the census unit. Fuzzy data techniques, for example, can be used to represent with what reliability the data can be mapped to lower-scales or the boundaries within which a data value may likely fall, but these techniques still do not provide a level of accuracy or reliability were the data initially collected at the household level. Context of Scale Issues in Social Research Following Curran et al. [6], who conducts a similar review of scale issues relating to biology and ecology, we use the following propositions to discuss how scale issues relate to social science. Here we explore a set of statements revolving around social-biophysical relationships to establish a context for scale issues in IAM. In this discussion, we address where these statements hold for different types of social data and where they break down. ■
The small things are the ones that determine the characteristics of the living world
The complexity in social and natural systems is beyond the ability of researchers to represent completely. Yet these systems can be modeled through simplifications and generalizations of these systems. All systems can be broken down into components. Researchers strive to identify the components in the living world and the relationships among these components. One of the most difficult tasks in integrated assessment modeling is how to determine what level of complexity is needed in a model and what model components need more or less complexity. Just as the landscape-scale pattern and composition of forests can be broken down into the physiological characteristics of the individual species within the forest, the economic structure of a society can be broken down into the household dynamics of labor decisions and financial management. Likewise, it is the aggregate condition and situations of the households, communities and businesses within a region that determine the regional economy of that area. All land-use decisions are affected by the individuallevel in some way. In environments where subsistence agriculture is the major mode of production this is particularly the case. But even in areas with a higher degree of economic development, agricultural landholdings (e.g., large farms practicing agriculture with high inputs) may be managed by a relatively small number of individuals. One notable exception to this rule are publicly managed lands where land management decisions are made in the context of a set of political institutions regulating how that land may be managed. But, 1) public lands comprise a relatively small proportion of the earth’s surface and 2) while many institutional regulations are not necessarily the product of individual decisions, individual-level decision making does enter into the land-use equation at other points, such as where within a forest stand to selectively cut trees. For an integrated assessment model with a
80 SCALING ISSUES IN THE SOCIAL SCIENCES
biodiversity/ecological function component these lower-level individual decisions made within the context of institutional regulations at a higher-level are important. It is these lower-level decisions create landuse/landcover outcomes that in aggregate produce higher-level patterns and processes. ■
The small things are the ones most amenable to study by the methods of science
Regional economies are characterized by a summary of statistics for the businesses and individuals in that region. The mean cost of new housing in different regions is the product of the costs in different areas composing each region. While data are often reported at coarse scales, it is fine scale measurements that allow the generation of this coarse scale reporting. This statement can be extrapolated to temporal scales of analysis as well. With the exception of dramatic changes in landcover such as that associated with colonization in the Midwest United States in the 1800’s or the Brazilian Amazon in the 1970’s, landcover changes generally operate over long periods of time. An examination of an area over the course of one or two years yields a very different process than an examination over the course of a decade or several decades. Likewise, examining an area using a monthly interval yields dynamic relationships that are not observable using a coarser time interval such as five or ten years. ■
The large things are the ones that have the most profound effect on humans
While small-scale phenomena frequently lend themselves to easier data collection, it is often larger-scale phenomena that attract major interest among global change researchers. Such large-scale phenomena include global temperature changes, acid rain, tropical deforestation, carbon sequestration, and regional-global species diversity. It is also the case that large-scale government policies have an impact over the opportunities and constraints faced by many peoples. Current patterns of extending markets to a global extent are the result of major international treaties. Similarly, restrictions on the trade of rare and endangered species have come about through national legislation as well as international treaties. For all the importance of large scale phenomena, there are many small-scale phenomena that also impact large numbers of people. The tragic consequence of the spread of the HIV virus is but one example of how many small-scale processes add up to large scale disasters. ■
There is a feeling that we should be able to use our knowledge of small things to predict and manage these large-scale phenomena
Because of the difficulty and expense of collecting detailed and compre-hensive data at the regional and global scales, researchers often rely on finer scale data to characterize social-biophysical relationships. Much of the research in human ecology, an arena where social-biophysical relationships have been studied from a systems perspective, has concentrated at local-scale relationships. Examples
SCALING IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT 81
include fallow periods in swidden agricultural systems, nutrient loss, soil erosion and other forms of environmental degradation. These observations at the local scale have widely been used to inform policy makers whose decisions affect regional and global change. Yet it is unclear to what extent local scale phenomena scale up to regional and global scale affects. Can the behavior of individuals modeled at a local scale be represented at a higher scale? Can the outcomes of the behavior of those individuals modeled at the local scale be adequately depicted by a higher scale represen-tation? Many economists would argue that a macro-scale representation can adequately represent the function of system that is composed of a set of individuals. But in terms of policy prescriptions it is important to understand what the impact of high-scale (e.g., national or regional) policies will be at lower scales. The impact of a specific policy prescription in a region with a highly homogenous ethnic composition can be quite different than the impact of that policy prescription in a region with a highly heterogeneous ethnic composition. ■
Although the small things are easier to study and understand, they are more numerous
Social data collection is expensive and time consuming whether the data is household data, demographic data, or agriculture prices from regional co-ops. While remote sensing provides the ability to characterize the landcover or meteorologic conditions of an area (at specific scales), no such method exists to rapidly assess the condition of human systems across broad spatial extents at any scale. The resources necessary to collect full data at the finest scale possible for a large spatial extent are beyond the capabilities of researchers and governments alike. Even mammoth efforts such as the U.S. Census make compromises in data collection. While every household is included in the survey, there are two different forms for data collection. A short form for the complete census and a longer form sent to approximately one-sixth of all households provides still further information for a subsample of the population. Beyond this, there are households and individuals missed by the census, such as migrant and transient populations. In addition, the questions included in national level censuses are generally broad and not focused on a specific research question. Therefore, researchers interested in focused areas of research understandably limit the spatial extent of their research and focus on specific scales of analysis. These compromises allow researchers to examine relationships that would otherwise be undiscovered or poorly understood. Yet the compromises in research design limit the researchers ability to fully document and characterize the nature of the relationships at work. ■
The large scale is likely to have at least some characteristics we cannot predict at all from a knowledge of the small scale.
One of the major intellectual breakthroughs of the 18th Century was the work of Adam Smith and his recognition that studying a single firm was not
82 SCALING ISSUES IN THE SOCIAL SCIENCES
sufficient to understand the consequences of exchange among a variety of firms in an open competitive market. Thus, most of modern economics is based on a study of the competitive dynamics among many firms rather than the internal organization and decision making of a single firm. All processes that involve some levels of competition are likely to generate phenomena at a larger scale that is not fully predictable from a focus strictly on the smaller scale. ■
The small scale is likely to have at least some characteristics we cannot predict at all from a knowledge of the large scale.
Similarly, examining some data or processes at a large scale removes considerable variation in what is happening at a smaller scale. For example, it is frequently thought that population change leads to rapid deforestation. For countries as a whole, population density does appear to be related to the amount of forested land remaining in the country. At a micro-level, however, many studies have shown that increases in population either do not affect the extent and composition of forests in a smaller region or actually lead to an enhancement [7, 8]. Thus, while some areas are adversely affected by increases in population located nearby, or in other regions of a country, other areas are able to use an increase in population to invest more labor in protecting a forest. In addition, large scale processes and relationships mask the variability that exists at smaller scales. While an overall population growth rate can be determined for an entire region, there are households with both low and high fertility within that region. The household dynamics are what will inform the researcher about what the factor are contributing to the overall level of fertility, whether they be income, education or access to contraception. ■
Scaling-up is not part of our scientific tradition
Despite the acknowledgement in both the social and physical sciences of the importance of scale effects, most theoretical progress has been made while disregarding this importance. For example, the theories about demographic transition, agricultural intensification [9], collective choice theory [10] are major contributions but do not acknowledge the operation of these theories across scales. Hierarchy theory arguably comes the closest to a conceptual framework for addressing scale issues, but this theory is not widely applied and methods of addressing this theory in research are lacking.
Scale Issues in Social Science Disciplines With this context for scale issues established, we now turn to a discussion of how scale has been approached from different social science discipline drawing on Gibson et al. [3]. The content of this earlier work is adapted and modified in the following section. This discussion demonstrates that that many social science disciplines are cognizant of scale related problems in data collection and data representation. The different approaches that different
SCALING IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT 83
disciplines adopt is partly a product of the nature of the data associated with a particular discipline and partly related to the inter-disciplinary nature of certain disciplines and the ability for ideas and techniques to cross-fertilize. Scale issues in geography A major focus of geographers is to describe and explain spatial patterns. Depending on what in a space matters to particular researchers, geography is divided into subdisciplines that parallel most of the major disciplines across natural and social sciences, e.g., physical geography includes geomorphology, biogeography, and climatology; human geography includes economic, political, and urban geography. Geographers gain their disciplinary identity is by their explicit consideration of spatial relationships. Spatial scales are thus critically important in this discipline, and span in their extent from “a single point to the entire globe” [11]. As geographers have addressed more questions related to global change, they have also been increasingly aware of linkage between spatial and temporal scales. The choice of extent and resolution that conveys relevant information most efficiently has always been the central problem of topography. Discussions of the problem of scale in a more methodological and abstract fashion did not start in physical and human geography until mid-century, when geomorphologists began to address the problem. Now, scale issues are found at the center of methodological discussions in both physical and human geography. Regional scales were used prominently during the first half of the twentieth century until new research technologies, combined with a need for a more scientific mode of explanation, led to more microlevel studies. Until recently, most geographic studies gathered data at a microlevel for the purpose, however, of contributing to larger geographic domains. Given an increasing interest in global phenomena, however, geographic studies are shifting more meso- and macroscale studies [12]. Like ecologists, geographers have found that the consideration of scale problems is fundamental to the identification of patterns and their explanation. In spite of the ongoing debate on the appropriate scale on which geographic processes should be analyzed, a widespread agreement exists that explanatory variables for a given phenomenon change as the scale of analysis changes. Behavioral geographers examine the correlation between spatial and temporal scales in individual activities. Spatial scale, temporal scale, and the degree of routinization are highly correlated in many human activities. Patterns that appear to be ordered at one level may appear random at another.1 For 1
Human migration is a phenomena that may occur at different spatial scales: within an urban area, within a region, within a nation, or across national boundaries. The patterns of intraurban migration are related to individual-level variables such as age, education, and individual family income. Intrastate migration, on the other hand, is explained mainly by aggregate variables such as “labor demand, investment, business
84 SCALING ISSUES IN THE SOCIAL SCIENCES
example, shoe stores show clumping patterns to attract more customers, but each store in a clump tries to place itself as far as possible from the others [11]. When the generalization of propositions is made across scales and levels in geography, it can result in the common inferential fallacies. These erroneous inferences have often been attributed to poor theory. In fact, they often reflect lack of data, or the limits in gathering data at multiple levels. Meentemeyer [11] suggests using data-rich, higher-level variables as theoretical constraints on lower-level processes to help predict lower-level phenomenon. The issues posed by the growing interest in globalized phenomena have led some human geographers to discuss new types of scaling issues. In postmodern interpretations of globalization, human geographers assert that the scale of the relationship between the dimension and object is important. Three types of scales involve different relationships: absolute, relative, and conceptual. An absolute scale exists independently of the objects or processes being studied. Conventional cartography, remote sensing, and the mapping sciences use absolute spatial scales, usually based on a grid system, to define an object’s location and to measure its size. An advantage of using absolute scales is that hierarchical systems can easily be created when a larger (or longer) entity contains several smaller (shorter) ones (e.g., Nation-City-DistrictNeighborhood; Century-Decade-Year-Month-Week). Geographers have paid increasing attention to relative space as they try to conceptualize the processes and mechanisms in space rather than the space itself. Relative scales are defined by, rather than define, the objects and processes under study.2 A relative concept of space regards space as “a positional quality of the world of material objects or events,” while an absolute concept of space is a “container of all material objects” [13, 14].3
climate, and income” [11: p165]. If the spatial scale or level is fixed, variables may also change according to a temporal scale. For example, different variables related to patterns of precipitation in and around mountains vary over temporal levels of hours, days, and years [11: p166]. 2 Jammer [13] first contrasted absolute and relative concepts of space in his review of the history of the concept of space in physics. In fact, the absolute concept of space is a rather modern development that accompanied Newtonian physics in which relations of objects were represented in absolute terms [14]. 3 The classical reference for geographers, [14], starts with the psychological, cultural, and the philosophical problems of understanding the concept of space, which he then connects with issues of measurement and spatial representation. For Harvey, a central question is “how concepts of space arise and how such concepts become sufficiently explicit for full formal representation to be possible” [14: p192]. The early geographers relied more on Kant and Newton and thus on absolute scales. The construction of noneuclidean geometry in the nineteenth century and the development of Einstein’s theory of relativity challenged the absolute concept of space. Since the mid-twentieth century, geographers have included more measures of relative space in their studies.
SCALING IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT 85
Relative space is particularly important in studies of behavioral geography that focus on individual perception of space. When we need to measure distance in terms of the time and energy needed for an organism to change its position from one place to another, absolute distance rarely corresponds with the relative distance. The plasticity of space is represented by the work of Forer [15] who examined both the time and the net distance that it took to reach diverse locations within New Zealand in 1947 as compared to 1970 after growth in the airline network. Finally, in addition to spatial denotations, geographers also use terms like global and local scale to stress conceptual levels. Global and local may correspond to the conceptual levels of “totality, comprehensives” and “particularity, discreteness, contextuality” [12]. As a spatial scale also implies a temporal scale in physical geography, so too does space link with conceptual scale in human geography. Scale issues in economics Economics has developed two distinct types of theories – microanalytic and macroanalytic. Microtheories tend to examine the incentives faced by producers, distributors, retailers, and consumers as they are embedded in diverse market structures. Macroeconomists study large-scale economic phenomena, such as how various economic forces affect the rate of savings and investment at a national level. Few economists attempt to link these two distinct levels of theory. Recently, Partha Dasgupta [16] addressed a concern with the problem of linking across spatial and temporal scales within economic theory. Dasgupta suggests that economics at its core tries to explain “the various pathways through which millions of decisions made by individual human beings can give rise to emergent features of communities and societies” [16: p1]. By emergent features he means “such items as the rate of inflation, productivity gains, level of national income, prices, stocks of various types of capital, cultural values, and social norms” [16: p1]. He points out that individual decisions at any particular time period are affected by these emergent features (which themselves result from very recent individual decisions). Some of the emergent features are fast-moving variables (e.g., changes in national income and rate of inflation) and some are slow-moving variables (e.g., changes in cultural values, institutions, and norms). When economists have studied short periods of time, they have simplified their analyses by taking slow-moving variables as exogenous and focused on the fast-moving variables. This has been a successful strategy for many economic questions, but Dasgupta [16] points to the repeated findings in ecology, on the other hand, that it is the interface between fast- and slow-moving variables that produces many important phenomena.
Here, space does not exist by itself but “only with reference to things and processes” [11: p164].
86 SCALING ISSUES IN THE SOCIAL SCIENCES
Scale is most overtly addressed by microeconomists interested in the question of economies of scale and optimization problems. Economies of scale refer to the phenomena in which an increase of inputs within some range results in more or less than proportional increase of outputs [17]. The quantity or magnitude of objects in both the input and output streams of a productive process represents certain levels of the process. Many propositions found in economics are expressed in terms of the relationship between the level of inputs and outputs, followed by suggestions on how to make decisions that optimize results. The law of diminishing returns refers to the diminishing amount of extra output that results when the quantity of an input factor is successively increased (while other factors are fixed). The law of increasing costs refers to the ever-increasing amount of the other good that tend to be sacrificed in order to get equal extra amount of one good [17: p25–29]. The optimal combination of inputs is a combination of input factors that minimizes the cost of a given amount of output and is achieved by equalizing marginal productivity of every input factor. The optimum population for a society is the size of population that maximizes per capita income for given resources and technology of the society [18]. The issue of generalizability is also studied in microeconomic theory. Paul Krugman [19] examines the generalizability of theoretical propositions developed at one scale of interactions to another. Theories based on competitive markets are not useful when attempting to explain the structure and behavior of firms under the conditions of monopoly and less than perfect competition. Scale issues in ecological economics Ecological economists study economic phenomena using a broader perspective than traditional economics by overtly incorporating ecological processes. Many ecological economists reject the myopic and human-centered viewpoint of mainstream neoclassical economics. They also differ with environmental economics in that the latter is seen merely as an application of neoclassical economics to environmental issues. Instead, ecological economists adopt a broader and more holistic analytical scale: conceptually larger in spatial scale and longer in terms of temporal scale [20]. Ecological economists criticize the “methodological individualism” of neoclassical economics as the theoretical expression of myopic economic thinking that treats the ecological environment only as an exogenous constraint on human economic activity. And they argue that this narrow scale of economic analysis is responsible for the disturbances of ecosystems and the overexploitation of natural resources that destroy the foundations of human existence. The quantitative dimension of economic objects is also an important scale issue in ecological economics. Ecological economists’ discussion of scale centers on “the physical volume of the throughput” [20] or “the physical dimensions of the economy relative to the ecosystem” [21]. They take the ecosystem as a relatively fixed entity and argue that the economy grows by exploiting the ecosystem. This approach shifts the focus of economic study
SCALING IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT 87
from economies of scale to the scale of the economy, i.e., the scale of “all enterprises and households in the economy” [21]. Ecological economists argue that the scale of economy should not be reduced to allocation analysis but should be addressed at the outset as a constraint on human economic activity – something that should not be determined by the price system but by a social decision that would take into account sustainability. Scale issues in urban studies In urban studies, the primary dimension of scale used is population. Scale or size of a city, unless otherwise specified, is equated to the number of people living within a given territory. Urban researchers also use alternative measures of scale such as a city’s active labor force, number of households, value added in production process within the territory, and spatial area [22]. The problem of optimal city size is central to urban studies, and is reflected in a variety of secondary research topics such as the planning of new cities, limiting the growth of existing cities, rebuilding destroyed or deteriorated cities, dispersal of cities as a measure of civilian defense, deconcentration of urban populations, and controlling the location of industry. These topics, in turn, depend on different optimization problems, such as the optimum population of a nation, the optimum ratio of urban to rural population, the optimum pattern of different sized cities, the optimum size of a principal city as the service center for its tributary region, the optimum size of residential units, and the optimum sizes of particular cities or of cities of special types [23]. While at first glance these approaches appear straightforward, urban researchers wrestle with a great deal of complexity, and extensive controversy exists concerning the mensuration and optimization of these phenomena. Urban researchers addressed the issue of optimal city size most intensively and broadly in the 1970s [24], often posed as “the problem of determining the optimal spatial distribution and hierarchy of cities of different sizes” that maximizes per capita income. Urban researchers also consider noneconomic, but no less significant, factors in their models of optimum city size, including the physical layout (accessibility to the countryside), health, public safety, education, communication, recreation, churches and voluntary associations, family life, and psychosocial characteristics. Researchers have found no general relationship between the size of city and these desired conditions [23]. Scale issues in sociology While scaling issues have always been implicit in sociology, the publication of Charles Tilly’s book in 1984, Big Structures, Large Processes, Huge Comparisons [25] put the importance of explicitly dealing with scale squarely on sociologists’ agenda. Tilly criticizes many aspects of traditional sociological theories because they address social processes in abstraction, without specifying temporal or spatial limits. His method is to specify the scale of
88 SCALING ISSUES IN THE SOCIAL SCIENCES
analysis first and then to find fundamental processes and structures within that scale (or, in our terms, level). The implication of his work is that multiple processes exist and some are more fundamental than others for a given level of spatial and temporal scales. For example, he argues that from the fifteenth through the nineteenth centuries in the Western world, the forms of production and coercion associated with the development of capitalism and nation states “dominated all other social processes and shaped all social structure” [25] including urbanization and migration. For Tilly, the proper problem of studying historical processes should start with “locating times, places, and people within those two master processes and working out the logics of the processes” [25]. If one were to accept his argument for the study of integrated assessment modeling, one would start by (1) defining the question of which temporal and spatial scale is crucial in affecting a particular environmental change process; (2) identifying fundamental processes (such as commercialization, industrialization, or population growth) that drive the process; (3) examining how these fundamental processes relate to one another; and (4) addressing how systematic, large-scale comparison would help us understand the structure and processes involved. Tilly’s [25] work also focuses on the concept of the levels of analysis – a higher level corresponds to a larger temporal and spatial scale. He argues that the crucial structures and processes vary as one changes the level of analysis. While he indicates that the number of levels between the history of a particular social relationship and the history of the world system is an arbitrary number, he proposes four levels as being useful: (1) at world-historical level, the rise and fall of empires, interaction of world systems, and changes in the mode of production are the relevant processes to investigate; (2) at world-system level, the world system itself and its main components, such as big networks of coercion and exchange, are the foci of analysis; (3) at macrohistorical level, major structure and processes of interest to historians and social scientists such as proletarianization, urbanization, capital accumulation, and bureaucratization become effective foci of investigation; and (4) at microhistorical level, the task is to make a linkage between the historical processes and the experience of individuals and groups. Coleman [26] also directly addresses the problem of analyzing multilevel social systems. Coleman critiques Weber’s [27] argument in “The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism” for using macrophenomena at one level to explain other macrophenomena at the same level. By ignoring lower-level phenomena, Weber [27] (and others who follow this method) omit how lowerlevel phenomena react to macrolevel phenomena, and then may act to change it. For Weber’s argument, this would mean that new religious doctrines affect the values of individuals, leading to changed values about economic phenomena, new patterns of interaction between individuals, and finally, a new economic system.
SCALING IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT 89
Scale issues in political science and political economy As in other sciences, scales and levels divide political science into different subdisciplines. Many political scientists focus on the actions and outcomes of aggregated units of government operating at different geographical levels: local, regional, national, and international. Levels of human aggregation also affect what political scientists study: much research concerns the political behavior of individuals (especially voting); another features the politics of groups, particularly political parties and interest groups. Most research undertaken by political scientists, however, tends to focus directly on a particular level of primary interest to the scholar without much attention to how the phenomena at that level is linked to phenomena at a higher or lower level. Two exceptions worth noting are the study of federalism, which is at its heart a theory of multilevel, linked relationships, and the Institutional Analysis and Development (IAD) framework, developed by colleagues associated with the Workshop in Political Theory and Policy Analysis at Indiana University, which focuses on nested levels of rules and arenas for choice. Although the concept of scale within the subdisciplines of political science is rarely addressed explicitly, some of the most important substantive and methodological issues addressed by political scientists relate essentially to problems of scale and level – especially the number of individuals involved. One important discussion regarding democracy concerns the differences of scale and level between the image of the original, small Greek city-states and the conditions of large, modern nation-states. In a major study of this question, Robert Dahl [28] concludes that there are major consequences of increases in the size of democratic polities, including limited participation, increased diversity in the factors relevant to political life, and increased conflict. Sartori [29] argues that democracy is still possible because competition among politicians for election and re-election more or less guarantees their responsiveness to citizens. Vincent Ostrom [30, 31], who is more cautious, sees modern democracies as being highly vulnerable precisely because of problems related to the scale of interaction among citizens.4 And Benjamin Barber [32] fears that the technocratic and bureaucratic orientations of monolithic multinational corporations seriously challenge the access of citizens to information and participation in effective decision making. Scholars in political economy, public choice, or social choice focus on the relationship between individual and group preferences, with scale and level issues at its core. The path-breaking work of Kenneth Arrow [33], which has 4
The competition for electoral office may be reduced to a media war that trivializes the discussion of public policy issues rather than clarifying important issues. Without a strong federal system and an open public economy, both of which allow for substantial self-organized provision of problem-solving capabilities, Ostrom [30, 31] views contemporary state-centered democratic systems as losing the support of their citizens, fostering rent-seeking behavior, and losing capabilities to deal with major public problems.
90 SCALING ISSUES IN THE SOCIAL SCIENCES
been followed by several thousand articles on what is now referred to as social choice theory (for a review, see Enelow [34]), proved that it was impossible to scale up from all individual preference functions to produce a group preference or “general will” or “public interest” function that satisfied what appeared to be an essential set of axioms of desirable properties of an aggregation process. Plott [35] demonstrated that when there were more than two dimensions involved in a policy choice, majority rule rarely generated a single equilibrium except when the preferences of individual members were balanced in a particularly optimal, but unlikely, manner. McKelvey [36] and Schofield [37] proved that an agenda could be constructed to include every potential outcome as a majority winner unless there was a single outcome that dominated all others. These “impossibility theorems,” combined with Arrow’s earlier impossibility theorem, have deeply challenged the core presumption that simple majority rule institutions are sufficient to translate citizen preferences into public decisions that are viewed as representative, fair, and legitimate.5 Like the Arrow paradox, the theory of collective action has also demonstrated a fundamental discontinuity between rationality at the individual and group level in the face of a social dilemma.6 Olson [10] and hundreds after him have explored the ramifications that in social dilemmas, group outcomes are worse when individuals choose their own best strategies. The relationship between scale, government, and the delivery of public goods and services has also been an important part of political science. This tradition of work starts with an awareness of market failure in regard to the provision of public goods and services. If free riding leads to an underprovision of a good through voluntary arrangements, some form of governmental provision will be necessary. Different configurations of governments may be more efficient and responsive depending upon the nature of the goods and services in question [42, 43, 44]. The work of scholars focusing on local public economies has tried to understand how local units of government cooperate on the provision and production of some goods and services while competing with one another with regard to others [45, 46]. The approach is similar to that of ecologists who study the patterns of interactions among a large number of organized units within a spatial terrain and discover emergent properties resulting from the way that individual units work together. Scholars 5
Kenneth Shepsle [38, 39] has shown how diverse kinds of institutional rules – including the allocation of particular types of decisions to committees within a legislative body – do lead to equilibria that can be thought of as institutionally induced equilibria. 6 The term “social dilemma” refers to an extremely large number of settings in which individuals make independent choices in an interdependent situation with at least one other person and in which individual incentives lead to suboptimal outcomes from the perspective of the group [40, 41]. The reason that such situations are dilemmas is that there is at least one outcome that yields higher returns for all participants, but rational participants making independent choices are predicted not to achieve this outcome. Thus, there is a conflict between individual rationality and optimal outcomes for a group.
SCALING IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT 91
have found that in many cases a multilevel, polycentric system is more efficient than one large, metropolitan-wide governmental unit or only a single layer of smaller units [47, 48]. In addition to recognizing that governmental units operating at diverse spatial levels are potentially more efficient than any single-unit operation at one level could achieve, scholars in this tradition have also recognized that there are several conceptual levels involved in any governance system. At an operational level, individuals engage in a wide diversity of activities directly impacting on the world, such as the transformation of raw materials into finished goods. There is a set of operational rules that provides structure for these day-to-day decisions made by government officials and citizens interacting in a wide diversity of operational situations (teachers in a classroom with students; welfare workers processing applications of those seeking welfare benefits; police giving a ticket to a speeding driver). These operational rules are the result of decisions made in a collective-choice arena. The structure of that collective-choice arena is itself affected by a set of collective-choice rules that specify who is eligible to make policy decisions, what aggregation rule will be used in making these decisions, and how information and payoffs will be distributed in these processes. At a still different conceptual level, collective-choice rules are the outcome of decisions made in constitutional arenas structured by constitutional rules [47, 49, 50]. Contrary to many presumptions that constitutional rules are made once and only at a national level, the constitution of all organized structures – ranging from the household all the way to international regimes – may be updated by interpretation or self-conscious choice relatively frequently. Constitutional rules change more slowly than collective-choice rules which, in turn, change more slowly than operational rules. Rules that are genuinely constitutional in nature may be contained in any of a wide diversity of documents that do not have the name “constitution” attached to them. The constitution of many local units of government is embedded in diverse kinds of state laws. Similarly, collective-choice decisions may be made by a diversity of public units, such as city and county councils, local and state courts, and the representative bodies of special authorities, as well as by a variety of private organizations that frequently participate actively in local public economies – particularly in the provision of local social services. Operational choices are made by citizens and by public officials carrying out the policies made by diverse collective-choice arrangements in both public and private organizations. In order to understand the structure, processes, and outcomes of complex polycentric governance systems in a federal system, one needs to understand the conceptual levels of decision making ranging from constitutional choice, through collective choice, to operational choices. The relationship of these conceptual and spatial levels is illustrated in Table 5.1, where the conceptual levels are shown as the columns of a matrix while the spatial levels are shown as the rows. The particular focus on
92 SCALING ISSUES IN THE SOCIAL SCIENCES
operational activities in this table relates to the use of land and forest resources – but almost any other type of CPR or public good could be used instead. Given the importance of international institutions in this realm of activities, as well as the decisions made by households, the geographic domains are arrayed at five levels. This, of course, is an oversimplified view, as there may be several geographic domains covered by community governance units as well as several at a regional level. Table 5.1: The relationships of analytical levels of human choice and geographic domains Spatial levels of political jurisdictions International
Constitutional-choice level
Collective-choice level
Operational-choice level
International treaties and charters and their interpretation National constitutions and their interpretation as well as the rules used by national legislatures and courts to organize their internal decision-making procedures State or provincial constitutions and charters of interstate bodies
Policy making by international agencies and multinational firms Policy making by national legislatures, executives, courts, commercial firms (who engage in interstate commerce), and NGOs
Community
County, city, or village charters or organic state legislation
Policy making by county, city, village authorities and local private firms and NGOs
Household
Marriage contract embedded in a shared understanding of who is in a family and what responsibilities and duties of members are
Policies made by different members of a family responsible for a sphere of action
Managing and supervising projects funded by agencies Buying and selling land and forest products, managing public property, building infrastructure, providing services monitoring and sanctioning Buying and selling land and forest products, managing public property, building infrastructure, providing services monitoring and sanctioning Buying and selling land and forest products, managing public property, building infrastructure, providing services monitoring and sanctioning Buying and selling land and forest products, managing public property, building infrastructure, providing services monitoring and sanctioning
National
Regional
Policy making by state or provincial legislatures, courts, executives, and commercial firms and NGOs with a regional focus
One can well expect different types of political behavior as one goes across rows or columns of this matrix. Paul Peterson [51], for example, argues that since local governments are under the condition of mutual competition, they pursue more developmental and allocative policies than redistributive policies. If they pursue redistributive policies too vigorously, both corporations and private citizens will move to other local governments that do not tax wealthier taxpayers for services delivered primarily to poorer residents. This suggests that redistributive policies will be pursued more often and more successfully at the national level.
SCALING IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT 93
Similar phenomena have evolved during the past two decades in regard to various kinds of environmental policies. Environmentalists seek to engage some policy questions at a strictly local level, some at a regional or national level, and still others within international regimes. At the international level, they may gain considerable public attention, but end up with written agreements that are poorly enforced. At a local or regional level, they may achieve a large number of quite different, but more enforceable agreements. Trying to understand the impact of dealing with diverse “global change phenomena” at diverse levels of organization will be one of the central tasks of institutional theorists studying global change processes.
Scale, Social Science Data Collection, Representation and Analysis Social science data is most frequently collected at one of the follow levels: individual, household, neighborhood, urban jurisdiction (e.g., cities or counties), larger political jurisdictions (e.g., states or regions of a country), or for a nation. Recently, more studies have involved data collection for more than a single country and more than a single time period. The levels at which data are collected and aggregated most frequently may not be useful to the research question at hand. This is particularly the case with secondary data such as census data and national summary data. For many purposes where the process under study does not conform to the levels described above, data must be scaled-up or down which involves the introduction of error to the analysis. Further, the operational processes in a smaller geographic domain may be simultaneously affected by several levels of analytical processes in that same domain as well as in larger domains (Table 5.1). And, as social scientists begin to address policy issues related to ecological processes, the problems of aggregating data to fit the processes under study becomes ever more important. Earlier methods of data collection and analysis frequently are not sufficient for the major environmental questions being addressed currently. Several recent studies conducted in Indiana as well as in Nepal [52, 53] have shown the usefulness of creating institutional landscapes that conform to the governance and management units of those responsible for forest resources in a particular geographic region. To understand forest change over time, for example, it is necessary to understand the legal rules that affect forests that are owned by national as well as by state governments [54], but also the internal policies adopted by a forest owner (whether a government or an individual person) toward specific stands of forests. Rarely do forests conform to any of the levels identified above. Most state and Federal forests in the U.S. cross county borders and frequently include portions of several cities. In his study of state and Federal forests, Schweik [55] identified new geographic units that represented the institutional landscapes relevant to forest property manager’s operational decision-making and activities (as a result of a study of the collective choice and constitutional levels of choice
94 SCALING ISSUES IN THE SOCIAL SCIENCES
affecting these operational level activities). He was then able to identify the institutional incentives they faced and to map the relevant geographic domains of diverse forest-stand policies and how these changed over time. Schweik then used Spectral Mixture Analysis to convert the raw digital numbers that MSS images provide to at-surface reflectance values for three time periods. This enabled Schweik to trace changes in management practices (e.g., opening areas for recreation, changing timber harvesting practices, restricting all harvesting activities) as measured by changes in the reflectance values. By conducting this kind of multi-scale analysis (from the pixel, to a stand, to a forest owner, to a region), Schweik was able to show that many of the forest stands owned by both state and national governments were showing substantial patterns of regrowth over the past twenty years, but that the difference in collective choice rules governing the two types of government-owned forests could be detected in the spectra. The stronger collective choice mandate facing state foresters to generate income from state land can be detected when comparing the spectra from federal and state forests over time. Recent studies using dynamic modeling techniques, have also enabled scholars to address problems of spatial misperceptions as they affect public policy. Wilson et al. [56] examine the domain of regulatory actions related to inshore fisheries and ask whether the spatial extent of the regulation is appropriate given the spatial differentiation in the ecological processes affecting fishery dynamics. The presumption underlying much of contemporary policy is that the domain of regulation should be as large as possible for any resource where there is some movement among local ecological niches. In this view, all members of the same species are part of a panmictic population and harvesting practices adopted in one location will eventually affect and be affected by practices adopted in other locations. If the population is indeed panmictic, then regulation at the largest level is indeed appropriate. Gilpin [57] and others have argued, however, that many fisheries are characterized by metapopulations where local populations are relative discrete. When a species is appropriately characterized as a metapopulation, a local extinction may not be re-colonized by other fish and regulation that does not take into account smaller-scale processes may lead to an unintended collapse of key segments of the larger population. By using a series of dynamic models, Wilson et al. [56], are able to identify when having regulatory regimes at a smaller level (complemented by more limited regulation at a larger level) leads to greater sustainability of a fishery. In particular, the level of variability that occurs within and across sub-systems affects the likelihood that a regulatory system organized at too large a scale will lead to extinctions of local populations and a consequent overall reduction in the sustainability of the fishery. Entwisle et al. [58] used the integration of community-level sociodemographic data and remotely sensed imagery to explore the relationship between demographic factors (fertility, migration) and the rate of deforestation in Northeast Thailand. Deforestation in Northeast Thailand is the product of
SCALING IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT 95
household level decisions made within the context of community-level institutions such as those rules imposed on a community by a village headman and group of village elders7. In order to enable this linkage, the social unit of analysis, a community, was linked to the landscape by creating a spatial partition around each community representing the area affected by the socioeconomic composition of the community. While communities did have distinct administrative boundaries associated with them, community-level land tenure patterns did not coincide with these boundaries making the administrative boundaries alone inadequate to capture the spatial extent affected by households in a particular village. In an extension of this work, Walsh et al. [4] explore how the relationship between demographic factors and forest cover changes as a function of scale and specifically the cell size used for spatial data representation. Using a set of different cell resolutions and tests of significance, it was found that the statistical results (e.g., sex-ratio and landcover composition) changed as a function of data aggregation and the cell resolution used to represent those data. In other words, the scale at which data are collected and represented affect what relationships are found between variables in subsequent analysis. This study is one of many that demonstrates the importance of not relying on a single scale of analysis. Perhaps even more fundamentally, a researcher must determine if a specific level of analysis is of relatively little importance in a social-biophysical system. For example, in some areas community-level institutions have relatively little affect on the way land is managed and household dynamics are far more important. In this case a model of landcover change may appropriately exclude a specific community-level component while still adequately capturing the key social-biophysical interactions. The difficulty lies in determining the relative importance of different levels prior to data collection. Scientific research at different scales of levels of analysis invariably yields different findings [4]. This disparity is in part due to the scale dependence of certain relationships but also the availability and representation of data at different scales. For example, Wood and Skole [59] completed a large study of deforestation in the Brazilian Amazon to examine the factors related to the rate of deforestation. This research relied on regional level census data and remotely sensed imagery and found that population density was a major factor related to deforestation rates. This regional level analysis is critical in determining the rate of deforestation over a broad spatial extent. However,
7
The study area of Nang Rong is characterized by a nuclear village settlement pattern where households are aggregated in a common area and land holdings are dispersed around the village area. The administrative areas around a village are comprised of private landholdings and community land whose management is controlled by village headmen and village elders.
96 SCALING ISSUES IN THE SOCIAL SCIENCES
the findings relating social variables to deforestation are limited to the variables available in the census data. Household level analyses of the Brazilian Amazon show a more complex set of relationships in relating socio-economic and biophysical factors to deforestation [60, 61, 62]. For example, access to credit, wage labor availability, distance to roads, topography, and soil characteristics have all been shown to be important factors at this household level of analysis. These more complex relationships are apparent because of the use of a household level survey to address the specific question of deforestation, and so this distinction between household and regional-level analysis is more a question of data availability. Yet researchers developing IA models need data to calibrate and validate their models. Furthermore, IA models typically operate at a single scale of analysis. Data availability issues might lead modelers to develop models at specific scales of analysis not because that is the proper scale at which the system should be modeled but because of the scale at which validation data are available.
Social Sciences Methods addressing Scale Much of the progress made towards understanding the nature of scale has been made in the physical sciences [3]. However, these methods developed in fields such as ecology and hydrology do not necessarily address the particular problems scale effects introduce in social science research. A variety of methods have been developed in fields such as geography, epidemiology and sociology that are well suited to addressing scale questions related to social data. Contextual analysis One of the interesting scale-related questions that political scientists face is whether there are “neighborhood” affects on individual political behavior. For example, is it the case that individuals who start out with a Democratic party identification continue to vote for Democratic Party candidates in all elections over time when they are living in a neighborhood that is predominantly Republican as contrasted to predominantly Democratic? In other words, what is the effect of the context at a neighborhood level on the voting behavior of individuals with particular political orientations. This is a question that has now been addressed by the development of a sophisticated form of data analysis referred to as contextual analysis [63, 64]. Recently scholars interested in educational performance have used contextual analysis to address questions related to the impact of classroom composition on individual student performance. Again, the question is phrased whether students who come into a classroom with an initial score on a standardized test progress more rapidly or more slowly depending on the test scores of others in the classroom or other individual attributes of students aggregated up to the classroom level. In all forms of contextual analysis, the hypothesis is that
SCALING IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT 97
the aggregation of individual characteristics that make up a relevant group affect the impact of individual characteristics on individual behavior. Multi-level modeling Socio-economic data that are collected at the individual, household and community levels are in turn aggregated to regional and then national levels of data representation. Scientists have recognized the importance of relationships that operate at only specific scales. For example, land management decisions are commonly made at the household level in the context of a regional economy. Individual migrant decisions are made by individuals in the context of a household and region. The importance of these multiple levels has been managed methodologically using multi-level modeling, where variables from multiple levels are used in empirical analyses. Much of this multi-level modeling research grew from the health sciences. In particular, epidemiologists would use multi-level modeling to look at both household and neighborhood characteristics as risk factors. Hierarchy theory One theory particularly relevant to scaling both social and biophysical data is Hierarchy theory [65, 66]. The central idea of hierarchy theory is that to understand any complex system depends on understanding the constraints at higher and lower levels of spatial-temporal resolution. The levels immediately above and below the referent level provide environmental constraints and produce a constraint ‘envelope’ in which the process or phenomenon must remain [67, 68]. For example, households are a common unit of social data analysis and in many environments are the level at which land management decisions are made. Community level institutions and characteristics provide a context within which household decisions are made as with the example from Northeast Thailand [4, 58]. The difficulty in applying this theory is that the researcher must first decide what the bounding levels with constraints are, something difficult to do without the availability of multi-scale data. However, hierarchy theory comes closest to providing a conceptual framework within which scale issues can be explicitly addressed regarding the spatial representation of social and biophysical processes and the interactions between them. Modifiable areal unit problem A common method of spatial data integration is by using simple overlays of different polygonal units representing homogenous areas for particular variables. Overlaying polygonal units from different sources (e.g., census tract polygons and watersheds) often creates polygon intersections that can change the nature of the spatial data representation. These changes occur because of the method of the somewhat arbitrary method of delineating polygonal units. This problem, referred to as the Modifiable Areal Unit Problem in Geography
98 SCALING ISSUES IN THE SOCIAL SCIENCES
[69, 70] has been well documented and a variety of researchers have presented research suggesting various solutions to this problem (see for example Green and Flowerdew [71]). However, a universal solution has not yet been forthcoming and the modifiable areal unit problem addresses only one particular manifestation of scale effects. Scale, Social Science and Integrated Assessment Modeling A central problem in integrated assessment modeling and the calibration and validation of IA models is data availability. The lack of social data (longitudinal and cross-scale) precludes the ability to perform robust time series analysis, hindering the ability to look at the dynamic nature of social and biophysical processes. For example, county or state level price data are often available in rich time series and at multiple temporal resolutions (e.g., daily, monthly, yearly) but demographic data is more commonly available at much coarser temporal resolutions (e.g., decadal, five years). Some might argue that demographic indicators are less variable then economic indicators and thus the relative intervals for data collection is thus justified. However, while fertility and mortality rates are slow to change, very dramatic changes in inmigration and out-migration rates can occur within very short periods of time. These disparities between datasets from different sources are major obstacles to model calibration and validation and no solution to this problem is evident. A core issue related to the scale dependence of social data is the need to reconcile the difference between social units of observation and spatial units of analysis. GIS techniques present a variety of methods of transforming data from one spatial data representation to another allowing these different units to be reconciled. To a large extent, the pattern of land settlement determines what data transformations are necessary to make these social spatial linkages. For example, in Altamira, Brazil, parcels are organized in the widely cited fishbone pattern. Parcels are of roughly uniform size (500 ⫻ 2000m) and with the exception of recent isolated instances of land consolidation, each parcel is allocated to a single household. This spatial arrangement lends itself to a parcel level analysis as a one-to-one linkage can be made between the social unit of analysis and a spatial unit of analysis – the parcel. A similar arrangement exists in many areas in the Midwest United States. Here land was surveyed into parcels of regular dimensions and allocated to individual landholders in the early 1800’s. In contrast to Altamira, there has been a high degree of parcel fragmentation as households split parcels and land is transitioned from agricultural uses to residential uses. It is still possible to make a one-to-one linkage between households and a discrete spatial unit of observation, but the ability to conduct longitudinal or multi-temporal analysis is complicated by the fragmentation of parcels over time. In contrast to Altamira and the Midwest United States, Northeast Thailand presents a very different pattern of land settlement that dramatically affects
SCALING IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT 99
the feasibility of making a one-to-one social-spatial linkage. In Buriram Province on the Korat Plateau of Northeast Thailand, villages are organized into a nuclear pattern of land settlement. Households are concentrated into a central area and landholdings are distributed around this central village area. Complicating the ability to link households to discrete spatial partitions on the landscape is the fact that households typically have several landholdings that are distributed in different areas around the village. In the absence of digital or hardcopy maps showing landholdings linked to landholders, the effort necessary to spatially reference the landholding of all the households for a single village is tremendous. This type of linkage would allow researchers to relate household or individual level characteristics to outcomes on the landscape with a one-to-one relationship between the social unit of analysis (household) and the spatial unit of analysis (parcel). In terms of policy prescriptions it is important to understand the impact of those policies at the household level because different households may be affected differently by the same policy. But, the resources necessary to do this for even a small number of villages makes such a household-level linkage unfeasible for large spatial extents. In this situation data transformations may be used to scale-up social data from the household to the community level. For example, radial buffers can be created around communities allowing a spatial partition to be created within which community level characteristics can be linked to biophysical data characterizing this spatial partition [58]. Community level boundaries can be used to partition the landscape, acknowledging certain inconsistencies in these boundaries such as the overlap between adjacent communities. This scaling-up has two major affects. First, some variables do not lend themselves to aggregation. The mean age of males and females can be easily computed, but variables such as ethnicity or religious affiliation are more difficult to scale-up. In addition, this scaling-up necessitates the introduction of some heterogeneity within the social unit. In some cases this heterogeneity is minimal, but in other cases it can have dramatic affects on subsequent analysis. So what developments in modeling might allow researchers to produce integrated assessment models that are more suited to crossing-scales? Many models exist which do one or two of the following things well: 1) incorporate spatial interactions [56, 72], 2) incorporate dynamic relationships [72, 73], 3) model the human decision making process [74, 75]. The primary challenge facing researchers now is to develop spatially explicit models that elegantly handle dynamic relationships and human decision making [76]. One type of modeling that shows particular promise is agent-based modeling. Agent-based models explicitly allow interactions between model actors to be represented in a dynamic framework [77]. For example, an agent based model examining landcover change can be be populated with the following types of actors: 1) residential small-holders, 2) large holder agriculturalists, 3) land developers. Interactions within these agent groups and between these agent groups allow for a more realistic environment within
100 SCALING ISSUES IN THE SOCIAL SCIENCES
which decision-making can be modeled. Furthermore, agent-based approaches present a means whereby complex social interactions can be explored such as feedbacks in systems as a result of the transfer of information between agriculturalists or equilibrium states related to crop productivity and inputs. Currently, agent-based models that examine integrated systems are lacking. However, models exist that are approaching this functionality (for example the FLORES model [74] and improvements to the Patuxent ecosystem model [72, 78]) and this linkage between agent-based and spatially explicit approaches shows particular promise for IA models. This linkage involves the reconciliation between individual based models [79] and large-scale ecosystem approaches [78]. Such a reconciliation is at the core of scale issues in social science and IA modeling.
Conclusion An integrated assessment model ideally should incorporate data at multiple scales to calibrate and validate the model. It is possible to use a single scale to observe the impact of a single relationship (e.g., prices and land use, topography and deforestation), but there are likely other factors operating at other scales that are as important and the nature of relationships change across scales. It is well established that certain phenomena are observable at some scales while unobservable at others. Beyond this, the nature of relationships changes with scale, so that even if a relationship is observable at multiple scales, the magnitude or strength of that relationship may differ across scales. A multi-scale approach will provide a more complete understanding of a system than an analysis focusing on a single scale, but researchers must still determine the individual scales composing this multi-scale approach. What would be ideal would be an analysis not at a discrete set of scales but along a scale continuum, but this is clearly not possible due to data availability issues. The realities of research and modeling dictate that a multiscale analysis is not always feasible. In these situations it is the researcher’s task to understand the situations when scale dependent relationships may be present through an understanding of the social and biophysical systems under study. If a particular relationship is not evident at one scale, the researcher may explore other scales if there is a certain confidence that relationship exists at other scales or has a different characterization at other scales. Unfortunately this does not lend itself to a rapid appraisal of systems and the impact of scale dependence within those systems. What is clear from an examination of social science literature is that there is no consensus on how to deal with scale issues in the social sciences and by extension no evident answers in terms of integrated assessment modeling. What the existing literature does provide is evidence of when scale issues are important, to what degree scale issues are important in different situations and methods (albeit not universally accepted) of dealing with scale dependence. While a consensus surrounding scale effects is missing, new developments in
SCALING IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT 101
modeling present opportunities to explore spatially explicit and complex IA models that cross from the individual to the ecosystem scales. The spatially explicit nature of these new models will allow scale relationships in complex social-biophysical systems to be more easily explored.
References 1.
Quattrochi, D. A. and M. F. Goodchild, 1997. Scale in Remote Sensing and GIS, Boca Raton: CRC Lewis Publishers. 2. Bian, L., 1997. Multiscale Nature of Spatial Data in Scaling Up Environmental Models. Scale in Remote Sensing and GIS. In: D. A. Quattrochi and M. F. Goodchild (eds.). Scale in Remote Sensing and GIS. Boca Raton, FL: Lewis Publishers. 3. Gibson, C. C., E. Ostrom, and T. K. Ahn, 2000. “The Concept of Scale and the Human Dimensions of Global Change: A Survey.” Ecological Economics, 32(2): 217–39. 4. Walsh, S. J., T. P. Evans, W. Welsh, B. Entwisle, and R. Rindfuss, 1999. “Scale-Dependent Relationships between Population and Environment in Northeast Thailand.” Photogrammetric Engineering and Remote Sensing, 65(1): 97–105. 5. Evans, T. P., G. G. Green, and L. Carlson, 2000. Multi-scale Analysis of Landcover Composition and Landscape Management of Public and Private Lands in Indiana. In: A. Millington, S. J. Walsh, and P. Osborne (eds.). GIS and Remote Sensing Applications in Biogeography and Ecology. Kluwer Press. 6. Curran, P. J., G. M. Foody, and P. R. Van Gardingen, 1997. “Scalingup.” Scaling-up: From Cell to Landscape, P. R. Van Gardingen, G. M. Foody, and P. J. Curran (eds.), Cambridge University Press: Cambridge. 7. Fox, J., 1993. “Forest Resources in a Nepali Village in 1980 and 1990: The Positive Influence of Population Growth.” Mountain Research and Development, 13(1): 89–98. 8. Fairhead, J. and M. Leach, 1996. Misreading the African Landscape. Society and Ecology in a Forest-Savanna Mosaic. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. 9. Boserup, E., 1966. The Conditions of Agricultural Growth. Chicago: Aldine Publishing. 10. Olson, M., 1965. The Logic of collective Action: Public Goods and the Theory of Groups, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. 11. Meentemeyer, V., 1989. “Geographical perspectives of space, time, and scale.” Landscape Ecology, 3(3/4): 163–173. 12. Meyer, W. B., D. B. L. T. Gregory II, and P. F. McDowell, 1992. “The Local-Global Continuum.” In: R. Abler, M. G. Marcus, and
102 SCALING ISSUES IN THE SOCIAL SCIENCES
13. 14. 15. 16.
17.
18. 19.
20.
21.
22. 23. 24. 25. 26. 27.
28. 29. 30.
J. M. Olson (eds.). Geography’s Inner Worlds. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press. Jammer, M., 1954. Concepts of Space, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. Harvey, D., 1969. Explanation in Geography, New York: St. Martin’s Press. Forer, P., 1978. “A place for plastic space?” Progress in Human Geography, 2(2): 230–267. Dasgupta, P., 1997. Notes on Slow and Fast Variables in Economics. Notes for the Resilience Network, University of Florida, Department of Zoology, Gainesville. Samuelson, P. A., 1973. “A Diagrammatic Exposition of a Theory of Public Expenditure.” Review of Economics and Statistics, 37: 360–366. McConnell, C. R., 1969. Elementary Economics: Principles, Problems, and Policies Economics, New York: McGraw-Hill. Krugman, P., 1986. Industrial Organization and International Trade. Working Paper no. 1957. Cambridge, MA: National Bureau of Economic Research. Daly, H. E., 1992. “Allocation, Distribution, and Scale: Toward an Economics that is efficient, just and sustainable.” Ecological Economics, 6: 185–193. Foy, G. and H. Daly, 1992. “Allocation, Distribution and Scale as Determinants of Environmental Degradation: Case Studies of Haiti, El Salvador and Costa Rica.” In: Environmental Economics, A. Markandya and J. Richardson (eds.). New York: St. Martin’s Press: 297–315. Reiner, T. A. and J. B. Parr, 1980. “A note on the dimensions of a National Settlement Pattern.” Urban Studies, 17: 223–230. Duncan, O. D., 1980. An Examination of the Problem of Optimum City-Size, New York: Arno Press. Hansen, N., 1975. The Challenge of Urban Growth, Lexington, MA: D. C. Heath & Co. Tilly, C., 1984. Big Structures, Large Processes, Huge Comparisons, New York: Russell Sage Foundation. Coleman, J. S., 1990. Foundations of Social Theory, Cambridge, MA.: Harvard University Press. Weber, M., 1958. “The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism.” In: H. W. G. and C. W. Mills (eds.). Essays in Sociology. Oxford: Oxford University Press: 168–178. Dahl, R., 1989. Democracy and Its Critics, New Haven: CT, Yale University Press. Sartori, G., 1987. The Theory of Democracy Revisited, Chatham, NJ: Chatham House Publishers. Ostrom, V., 1991. The Meaning of American Federalism: Constituting a Self-Governing Society, San Francisco, CA: ICS Press.
SCALING IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT 103
31. Ostrom, V., 1997. The Meaning of Democracy and the Vulnerability of Democracies: A Response to Tocqueville’s Challenge, Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press. 32. Barber, B. R., 1992. “Jihad v. McWorld.” Atlantic Monthly, 269: 59–65. 33. Arrow, K., 1951. Social Choice and Individual Values, New York: John Wiley & Sons. 34. Enelow, J. M., 1997. “Cycling and Majority Rule.” In: D. C. Mueller, (ed.). Perspectives on Public Choice. New York. Cambridge University Press: 149–162. 35. Plott, C., 1967. “A Notion of Equilibrium and its Possibility Under Majority Rule.” American Economic Review, 57(4): 787–807. 36. McKelvey, R. D., 1976. “Intransitivities in Multidimensional Voting Models and Some Implications for Agenda Control.” Journal of Economic Theory, 12: 472–482. 37. Schofield, N., 1978. “Instability of Simple Dynamic Games.” Review of Economic Studies, 45: 575–594. 38. Shepsle, K. A., 1979a. “Institutional arrangements and equilibrium in multidimensional voting models.” American Journal of Political Science 23(1): 27–59. 39. Shepsle, K. A., 1979b. The role of institutional structure in the creation of policy equilibrium. In: Rae, D. W., Eismeier, T. J. (eds.), Public Policy and Public Choice. Sage Yearbooks in Politics and Public Policy, vol. 6. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage: 249–283. 40. Dawes, R. M., 1980. “Social dilemmas.” Annual Review of Psychology, 31:169–193. 41. Hardin, R., 1982. Collective Action, Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press: pp. 248. 42. Ostrom, V., C. M. Tiebout, and R. Warren, 1961. “The Organization of government in metropolitan areas: a theoretical inquiry.” American Political Science Review, 55(4): 831–842. 43. Ostrom, V. and E. Ostrom, 1977. Public Goods and Public Choices. In: Alternatives for Delivering Public Services: Toward Imporoved Performance, E. S. Savas, (ed.), Boulder, CO: Westview Press. 44. Ostrom, E., 2000. “The Danger of Self-Evident Truths.” Political Science and Politics, 33(1): 33–44. 45. Parks, R. B. and R. J. Oakerson, 1993. “Comparative Metropolitan Organization: Service Production and Governance Structures in St. Louis (MO) and Alleghany County (PA).” Publius, 23(1): 19–39. 46. Oakerson, R. J., 1999. Governing Local Public Economies: Creating the Civic Metropolis, Oakland, CA: ICS Press. 47. McGinnis, M., 1999b. Polycentricity and Local Public Economics: Readings from the Workshop in Political Theory and Policy Analysis, Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.. 48. McGinnis, M., 1999a. Polycentric Governance and Development. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.
104 SCALING ISSUES IN THE SOCIAL SCIENCES
49. Kiser, L. L. and E. Ostrom, 1982. The Three Worlds of Action: A Metatheoretical Synthesis of Institutional Approaches In: Strategies of Political Inquiry, E. Ostrom, (ed), Beverly Hills, CA: Sage: 179– 222. 50. Ostrom, E., R. Gardner, and J. M. Walker, 1994. Rules, Games, and Common-Pool Resources, Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press. 51. Peterson, P., 1981. City Limits, Chicago: University of Chicago Press. 52. Schweik, C. M., K. R. Adhikari, and K. N. Pandit, 1997. “Land Cover Change and Forest Institutions: A Comparison of Two SubBasins in the Siwalik Hills of Nepal.” Mountain Research and Development, 17(2): 99–116. 53. Schweik, C. M. and G. M. Green, 1999. “The Use of Spectral Mixture Analysis to Study Human Incentives, Actions, and Environmental Outcomes.” Social Science Computer Review, 17(1): 40–56. 54. Koontz, T., 1997. “Difference Between State and Federal Public Forest Management: The Importance of Rules.” Publius: The Journal of Federalism, 27(1): 15–37. 55. Schweik, C. M., 1998. The Spatial and Temporal Analysis of Forest Resources and Institutions. Bloomington, Indiana: Indiana University. 56. Wilson, J., B. Low, R. Costanza, and E. Ostrom, 1999. “Scale Misperceptions and the Spatial Dynamics of a Social-Ecological System.” Ecological Economics, 31(2): 243–257. 57. Gilpin, M., 1996. Metapopulations and wildlife conservation: Approaches to Modeling Spatial Structure In: Metapopulations and Wildlife Conservation, D. R. McCullough, (ed.), Washington, D. C.: Island Press: 11–27. 58. Entwisle, B., S. J. Walsh, R. Rindfuss, and A. Chamratrithirong, 1998. “Land-Use/Land-Cover and Population Dynamics, Nang Rong, Thailand.” In: People and Pixels, E. F. M. a. P. C. S. Diana Liverman, (ed.), Washington D.C.: National Academy Press: 121–144. 59. Wood, C. H. and D. Skole, 1998. Linking Satellite, Census, and Survey Data to Study Deforestation in the Brazilian Amazon In: People and Pixels, E. F. M. a. P. C. S. Diana Liverman, (ed.), National Academy Press: 70–93. 60. Moran, E. F. and E. Brondizio, 1998. “Land-Use change after deforestation in Amazonia.” In: People and Pixels, E. F. M. a. P. C. S. Diana Liverman, (ed.), Washington D.C.: National Academy Press: 94–120. 61. Brondizio, E., S. McCracken, E. F. Moran, A. Siqueira, D. Nelson, and C. Rodiguez-Pedraza, 1999. “The Colonist Footprint: Towards a conceptual framework of deforestation trajectories among small farmers in frontier Amazonia.” In: Patterns and Processes of Land, Use and Forest Change in the Amazon, C. Wood, (ed.), Gainesville, FL: University of Florida Press. 62. Moran, E. F., E. Brondizio, and S. McCracken, 1999. “Trajectories of Land Use: Soils, Succession, and Crop Choice.” In: Patterns and
SCALING IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT 105
63. 64. 65. 66. 67. 68. 69.
70.
71.
72.
73.
74. 75.
76.
77.
78.
Processes of Land Use and Forest Change in the Amazon, C. Wood, (ed.), Gainesville, FL: University of Florida Press. Boyd, L. H. and G. R. Iverson, 1979. Contextual Analysis: Concepts and Statistical Techniques. Belmont, CA: Wadsworth. Bryk, A. S. and W. Radenbush, 1992. Hierarchical Linear Models: Applications and Data Analysis Methods. Newbury Park, CA: Sage. Simon, H. A., 1962. “The Architechture of Complexity.” Proceeedings of the American Philosophical Society, 106(6), 467–482. Allen, T. F. H. and T. B. Starr, 1982. Hierarchy: Perspectives for Ecological Complexity, Chicago: University of Chicago Press. O’Neill, R. V., A. R. Johnson, and A. W. King, 1989. “A hierarchical framework for the analysis of scale.” Landscape Ecology, 3: 193–205. Norton, B. G. and R. E. Ulanowicz, 1992. “Scale and biodiversity policy: a hierarchical approach.” Ambio, 21(3): 244–249. Openshaw, S., 1977. “A geographical solution to scale and aggregation problems in region-building, partitioning, and spatial modelling.” Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, 2: 459–72. Openshaw, S. and P. J. Taylor, 1981. “The modifiable areal unit problem.” In: Quantitative Geography: A British View, N. Wrigley and R. J. Bennett, (eds.), London: Routledge. Green, M. and R. Flowerdew, 1996. “New evidence on the modifiable areal unit problem.” In: Spatial Analysis: Modelling in a GIS Environment, P. Longley and M. Batty, (eds.), New York: John Wiley and Sons. Voinov, A., R. Costanza, L. Wainger, R. Boumans, F. Villa, T. Maxwell, and H. Voinov, 1999. “Patuxent Landscape Model: Integrated Ecological Economic Modeling of a Watershed.” Environmental Modelling & Software Journal, 14(5): 473–491. Voinov, A. and R. Costanza, 1999. “Landscape Modeling of Surface Water Flow: 2. Patuxent Case Study.” Ecological Modelling, 119: 211–230. Vanclay, J. K., 1998. “FLORES: for exploring land use options in forested landscapes.” Agroforestry Forum, 9(1): 47–52. Evans, T. P., A. Manire, F. DeCastro, E. Brondizio, and S. McCracken, 2001. “A dynamic model of household decision making and parcel level landcover change in the Eastern Amazon.” Ecological Modeling, 143: 95–113. Grove, M., C. Scweik, T. P. Evans, and G. Green, 2001. “Modeling Human-Environmental Dynamics.” In: K. C. Clarke, B. E. Parks, and M. P. Crane (eds.), Geographic Information Systems and Environmental Modeling: Prentice-Hall. Deadman, P., R. D. Brown., and H. R. Gimblett, 1993. “Modelling Rural Residential Settlement Patterns with Cellular Automata.” Journal of Environmental Management, 37: 147–160. Costanza, R., F. H. Sklar, and M. L. White, 1990. “Modelling coastal landscape dynamics.” Bioscience, 40: 91–97.
106 SCALING ISSUES IN THE SOCIAL SCIENCES
79. DeAngelis, D. L., and L. J. Gross, 1992. Individual-based Models and Approaches in Ecology: Populations, Communities, and Ecosystems, New York: Chapman & Hall.
6 Sustainability and Economics: a Matter of Scale? 1
2
CARLO C. JAEGER AND RICHARD TOL 1 Department of Global Change and Social Systems, Potsdam Institute of Climate Impact Research, Potsdam, Germany 2 Centre for Marine and Climate Research, Hamburg University, Hamburg, Germany; Institute for Environmental Studies, Vrije Universiteit, Amsterdam, The Netherlands; Centre for Integrated Study of the Human Dimensions of Global Change, Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, United States
Abstract Sustainability is a global issue concerning future generations, but steps towards sustainable development must also be taken at the spatial scales of regions and at the temporal scales of individual lives. Different scales matter in social networks and in cultural realities, too. The fact that relatively small regions can dominate global markets for products based on continuous innovation points to the accumulation of a specific social capital in these regions. This resource is a club good at the regional scale. Similar goods exist at national scales. Their development depends to a considerable extent on expectations that play a very different role in the short and in the long run. In the former, the efficient market hypothesis seems a reasonable approach. In the latter, very different approaches need to be developed. Understanding how processes at the regional, national and global level interact in the short and in the long run will be vital for a successful management of the transition towards a sustainable world economy.
Acknowledgements This paper owes much to careful comments by Tom Evans and to discussions in Harry’s club, an informal gathering of economists which originated at the EFIEA workshop on Uncertainty, held in Baden, Austria, in July 1999. The
108 SUSTAINABILITY AND ECONOMICS
Michael Otto Foundation for Environmental Protection provided financial support. The usual disclaimers apply.
Introduction Over the last decades, it has become increasingly clear that the world economy is on an unsustainable path. Is a transition to a sustainable society possible in the 21st century? In other words: can our grandchildren live in a society that would look at global environmental disruption no more as a threat to its future, but as an expierence of the past? The question is as urgent as it is difficult. A sustainability transition, if it will happen at all, will be a complex process, involving many different scales – in spatial, temporal, and institutional terms. It will take a long-lasting process of integrated assessments to develop an awareness of where we stand in relation to this challenge, and where we can – and cannot – go. These assessments will need to keep the spatial, temporal and institutional scales of everyday human life in sight if they are to be practically meaningful. These are the scales where it makes a difference whether two people talk to each other from a distance or whether they are so close as to be able to touch one another. They are the scales at which it makes a difference whether we leave home for a weekend or for a two weeks holiday, at which we make career choices, develop diet habits, go for a walk or take a nap. The sustainability transition cannot be grasped at the scales of everyday life only. Integrated assessments dealing with the sustainability transition need to take into account an “astronaut’s perspective” as well. The diet habits of billions of people are geared to changes of the whole earth system, and so are their choices about which transport systems to use, where to live, etc. Switching between different scales of analysis can result in amazing journeys, however. A simple triangle suffices to illustrate what kind of surprises can arise.1 As Figure 6.1 shows, on a Euclidean plane, summing up the angles of a triangle yields a straight line, or an angle of 180°. In the figure, lines c and c* are parallel, so that the angles  and * are equal, as are the angles ␣ and ␣*. This fact is hard to prove, however, and may rather be introduced as an axiom.2 Our experience with pencil and paper, or with rigid structures that we may lay out on the ground, shows that such axioms actually work in such settings – they lead to sound inferences and sound constructions, they help us to make accurate observations and to engage in successful actions.
1
The following argument builds on Putnam [1]. An alternative route would be to introduce as an axiom that the angles of any triangle sum up to 180° and to deduce the equality of angles ␣ and ␣*. 2
SCALING IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT 109
c* α∗ γ b
β∗ a
β
α c Figure 6.1: Sum of angles in a Euclidean triangle.
Now consider a triangle on a sphere. Here it is perfectly possible to construct triangles with three right angles. On the surface of planet earth, one may imagine a triangle with one angle at the North pole and the other two on the equator, the distance between the latter two being just one quarter of the equator. At the scale of human individuals living on the surface of the same earth, however, Euclidean geometry works perfectly well. Of course, one may be tempted to say that it works only as an approximation, but this misses the point. If a designer wants to cover the floor of a living-room with triangular tiles she cannot improve the design by making calculations with triangles whose angles sum up to a tiny little bit more than 180o. On the other hand, if trajectories of three satellites were computed on the basis of the assumption that they cannot be all orthogonal to each other, this would lead to nonsensical results. So far we have considered spatial metaphors, but the argument extends to temporal scales. When singers perform an opera, it is perfectly – not approximately – clear what it means for them to start a duet at the same time. When astronomers study two supernova explosions, they must come to terms with the fact that these explosions may be simultaneous if observed from one point in space and not simultaneous if observed from another one.3 Temporal scales are of additional interest when they relate to non-linear dynamics. Complex patterns may emerge and fade away at different scales, sometimes yielding stable structures at one temporal scale and chaotic dynamics at another one (see Christiansen and Parmentier [2], Sterman [3]).
3
This is the kind of reasoning which differentiates relativity theory from classical mechanics. It involves a further version of non-Euclidean geometry, now couched in four-dimensional “space”.
110 SUSTAINABILITY AND ECONOMICS
Scale issues are not limited to physical reality, they arise in mental structures, too. A domain of discourse may have a logical structure under which it is possible to assess for any single sentence whether it is true or false, but not for all sentences at once.4 Like a rug in the carpet, the domain of uncertainty wanders around whenever new certainties are found. Even logical laws may hold at one scale of analysis and fail at another one.5 Spatial, temporal, and logical scales interact if one considers an integrated assessment incorporating a component of demographic change. At one scale a population can be represented by fairly simple rates of fertility, mortality and net migration. At another scale, the decision of an individual to (try to) have a child is a highly complex decision, and modeling this decision-making process is incredibly difficult. In some situations, it may be perfectly sufficient to understand the net result of these complex decisions at a global scale (e.g., through aggregation and projections of national census data). However, in other cases it is important to analyze this decision-making process at an individual level in order to understand the mechanisms triggered by different policies. Different laws may hold at different scales, and one can try to establish rules for the transition between these different domains.6 Even in everyday life, such transitions are widespread, as we sometimes realize when switching from one social setting, e.g., an empty bus, to another one, e.g., a crowded baseball stadium. Of course, sometimes huge scale changes are possible without inducing any change in relevant patterns, laws, etc.: it was the great triumph of Newtonian mechanics to show that stones and stars follow the same laws of motion. But sometimes moving from one scale to another comes close to traveling between different worlds. While traveling, we may encounter a twilight zone of ambiguity. But as the distinction between day and night is perfectly sound although no clear-cut boundary separates the two, so the distinction between small and large scales may often be perfectly sound even if a gradual transition between them is possible. And of course, more than two scaling levels are relevant in many domains of inquiry. Perhaps, little more can be said about scale issues in general. Rather, it seems necessary to consider such issues case by case. In economics, there are many instances of scaling issues – the micro-macro problem is one of the big challenges of our discipline, returns to scale one of its classical topics (see Gold [5]). We consider the latter in a brief overview of orthodox economic methodology and its core assumptions about returns to scale. Then, we will 4
Such patterns are known from quantum logic. There is no reason why similar structures should not be widespread in the fabric of human knowledge. 5 This led mathematical intuitionists to argue that the logical law of the excluded middle holds for finite sets, but not necessarily for infinite ones. 6 This is a major issue in geographical research, ranging from landscape ecology to remote sensing (see Wong and Amrhein [4]).
SCALING IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT 111
focus on two particular instances of scaling issues in economics that are especially relevant for the sustainability transition: the role of innovative regional economies on global markets and the role of expectations in the short and the long run.7 We will conclude with a few remarks about the relevance of scale issues for bringing about a sustainable world economy.
Returns to Scale According to a famous definition, economics is the study of the allocation of scarce resources.8 Integrated assessment is multi-disciplinary, policy-relevant research that is typically carried out on complex environmental issues. A key problem with the environment is that what once was abundant, now is scarce. Economics is thus one of the core disciplines of integrated assessment. Economics is also a controversial discipline. This is partly because the discipline has taken a unique route in its quest for knowledge accumulation and partly because other researchers do not always take enough time to understand economics and economists are not always patient enough to explain their ways. In contrast to other social sciences, the defining methodological characteristic of orthodox economics is mathematical rigor.9 That is, an economist starts with a series of basic assumptions (treated as axioms, first principles, laws) from which higher order characteristics are deduced. Rigor is assumed to be a prerequisite for true understanding of economic phenomena. In the early days, the basic assumptions were rather limited in number and scope. The predictive power was, therefore, rather limited as well. Over the years, however, the set of basic assumptions has been extended and refined so that economists now have a clearer understanding of many observed phenomena in economies. Few non-economists are aware of the advances of orthodox economics. In fact, a lot of people have a rather outdated image. Applied economists, the ones that enter into the discussion with other disciplines, often rely on older methods, assuming perfectly competitive markets, unboundedly rational actors, full employment of labor and other resources, and so on. This is sometimes because of convenience. More often, however, this is because it was shown (in 7
Both shed some light – or perhaps twilight – on the micro-macro problem. “Economics is the science which studies human behaviour as a relationship between (given) ends and scarce means which have alternative uses.” [6: p16]. 9 This is not to deny that other social science disciplines have produced gems of mathematical rigor. A case in point is the work in linguistics inspired by the correspondences between the idea of a grammar and the concept of a Turing machine (see Martin-Vide [7]). But the community of linguists – perhaps to their advantage – has always cultivated a methodological pluralism which includes historical, interpretive and other approaches. 8
112 SUSTAINABILITY AND ECONOMICS
some paper unknown outside the economic community) that, for this particular environmental application, the older, simpler, more convenient assumptions lead to the same conclusions as do the newer, more complex, more elaborate assumptions. There is no “scale theory” in economics, in fact, scale is hardly treated as an issue in economic textbooks.10 At the same time, scale issues are pervasive, and labelled, treated and analysed in so many ways that a survey would be an enormous task. Standard economic models use production functions that have a property known as “constant returns to scale”. That is, the production function is such that if all inputs are multiplied by a factor then output is multiplied by the same factor . If output increases by less than a factor , we speak of decreasing returns to scale. If output increases by more than a factor , we speak of increasing returns to scale. The standard assumption of constant returns to scale has major implications for the influence of scale issues in economic models.11 One implication is that the structure of the economy is essentially scale-independent. This is quite convenient. It is often possible to use representative consumers and producers, because heterogeneity in size does not matter. It is possible to ignore stochasticity, because temporary size changes do not matter. Another implication of the assumption of constant returns to scale is that the modelled economy does not have a spatial structure. As size does not matter, agglomeration does not matter either. A constant returns to scale economy is an economy without cities. Finally, constant returns to scale imply that specialisation does not pay. Starting from the same initial conditions, every firm and every country produces the same, broad range of goods and services. The world of decreasing returns to scale does not differ fundamentally from the constant returns to scale world. In fact, the two go neatly together, where the assumption of decreasing returns to scale explains why inputs that are in principle substitutable (e.g., capital and labour) are in practice observed together.
10
One would find reference to “returns to scale”, which is a property of the production function rather than an issue of scale. The common assumption of “constant returns to scale” does have major scale implications, which are treated below. 11 At first sight, the economic notion of scale is one of speed: what varies is the amount of goods produced per time unit. Of course, this influences the stock of durable goods available. In chemistry, a similar distinction arises between fast and slow reactions with their effects on concentrations of different substances. In climate dynamics, atmospheric processes are fast in comparison with oceanic ones, again with implications for con-centrations of various substances like greenhouse gases. In economics, greater production often goes along with a greater extent of the market, both in financial and in geographical terms. In this sense, the economic notion of scale is more than just a temporal one.
SCALING IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT 113
The main reason why standard economic models assume constant and decreasing returns to scale is rigor. The analytical and numerical tools available to the pioneers of standard economics did not allow them to explore the consequences of alternative assumptions, particularly that of increasing returns to scale. With progress in mathematical and computer power, less restrictive assumptions have been explored, and the exact role of the original implications has been considerably clarified. The world implied by the assumption of increasing returns to scale is radically different. Increasing returns to scale invoke (often local) positive feedbacks in the economic system. This brings strong path dependence with it, as there are asymmetries between growth and shrink rates. One ignores heterogeneity and stochasticity at one’s peril with increasing returns to scale, as size – and thus random variations in size – matter if growth rates depend on initial size. Agglomeration and specialisation effects can be modelled using the assumption of increasing returns to scale. A dynamic variant of increasing returns to scale is learning-by-doing. Learning-by-doing means that experience gained with production today leads to lower average production costs tomorrow. The assumption of constant returns to scale goes hand in hand with the assumption of perfect competition. Increasing returns to scale, however, reduces the number of competitors and so leads to forms of imperfect competition. Vice versa, the profits generated in situations of imperfect competition may activate increasing returns to scale. If not, newcomers will enter the market until competition is perfect. In sum, the assumed properties of the production function (known as “returns to scale”) have a profound effect on generic scale issues in economics. If the production function has constant or decreasing returns to scale, scale does not matter. The economy looks the same through binoculars and a magnifying glass. On the other hand, if the production function has increasing returns to scale, scale matters in the economy. Standard macro-economic models – the type usually used for integrated assessment studies – assume constant and decreasing returns to scale. If one zooms in at smaller scales, research questions and methodologies change. The simplified assumptions made to make large-scale economic models work are obviously invalid at smaller scales. Full information, optimising behaviour, divisibility of goods, continuous substitutability, and flexible labour markets have no place in micro-economics, although they do in macroeconomics.12
12
For a thoughtful reflection on the complex relations between micro- and macroeconomics, see Hahn and Solow [8]. One implication of their work is that temporal scales present the bigger intellectual challenge for economic analysis than varying scales of production. We will discuss temporal scales in the section Back to the Future.
114 SUSTAINABILITY AND ECONOMICS
The question is, of course, does the detail of the small scale influence the patterns of the large scale? The answer to that question lies in the dynamics of the system. In a considerable number of cases, research has shown that there is no devil in the detail. In other cases, the jury is still out. We investigate two of those below. Industrial Districts in the World Economy Globalization is not a new stage in the development of economic life, it is the intensification of a pattern that characterizes modern society since its beginnings. At the end of the Middle Ages, the ability to transcend national boundaries and to span the whole globe set the modern economy apart from older ways of life. This ability was based on two interlocked socio-cultural arrangements: open markets and specialized professions. Of course, most actual markets are not completely open. They have entry barriers, sometimes quite high ones. But these can be overcome in perfectly legitimate ways, and this sets modern markets apart from typical structures of, say, feudal societies. And of course, economic activities are by no means always performed in a professional style. Unskilled labor plays a very important role in the history of capitalism. But without the skills provided by specialized professionals geared to a body of scientific knowledge, no global transport infrastructure and no industrial production system would have emerged, let alone a global culture sharing the music of Bach and the art of making pizza. By now, the life of most, if not all human beings is interconnected via the global economy – be it through a direct or a very distant indirect connection – and they know it. What is surprising, then, is how important local conditions remain for economic activities. Silicon valley is a remarkably small area compared with the global reach of its products, and the same holds for the Hollywood movie industry. Since several centuries, the City of London is the premier location for financial activities in Europe – technological revolutions, wars, the breakdown of the Empire, and the rise of the Dollar did not overcome this amazing local singularity. Since Marshall’s attempts at understanding the role of industrial districts in terms of localized positive external effects, many models of regional economies have been suggested and new models will now doubt be proposed in the years to come [9, 10, 11]. For our present purpose – looking at scaling issues in view of the sustainability transition – two points may be emphasized. First, successful regions in today’s global economy share some good that is neither public nor private. In economics, this distinction is usually drawn in terms of exclusiveness and rivalry: a private good is one from whose use othes can be easily excluded and whose use by one agent reduces the quantity available for use by other agents. If you put a piece of cake on your plate, it is not trivial for me to grab it; if you eat the cake, I cannot eat it anymore. On
SCALING IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT 115
the other hand, it is hard for me to exclude you from using the English language, and if you do use it, it is by no means less available for me. There is something about places like Silicon valley or the City of London that looks like a public good from inside these places: firms operating there can hardly be excluded from it, and by using it, they don’t make it less available for their competing neighbors. That something may involve a contact network, a set of procedures, an evolving body of knowledge, shared facilities for producing some kind of goods, etc. Looked at from the outside, however, it looks like a private good: outsiders are excluded from its use, and if they were not, they would impair it. The kind of social network evolving over centuries in the City of London would break down if all of a sudden it had to involve ten times as many members. This resource is a kind of club good.13 Club goods are defined as similar to public goods up to a point: use of the good is non-rival only up to a certain number of users. And the first point to note about today’s successful regional economies is that they do share some kind of regional club good. The regional scale seems due to basic features of human existence – the importance of face-to-face contacts, the changing character of conversations when more than a certain number of people is involved, the distance that can be covered in a few minutes by walking, the combinatorial explosion of possible binary relations when a social network grows in size, etc. The second point to note is that regional club goods not only can make certain activities less costly than similar activities would be elsewhere, but that they can also greatly facilitate on-going innovation processes. Taken together, these mechanisms bring about the tremendous competitive advantage that some regions can build up over time. For newcomers, it is extremely difficult to challenge such regions, because building up a similar club good elsewhere takes time, is costly and involves a serious risk of failure. The incumbent region can finance continuous investment in its own club good out of the rent that the competitive advantage allows it to collect. This can literally mean that landlords in the incumbent region fund the kind of social life that maintains the regional club good. As a result, incumbent regions are advantaged in their specialization both by Heckscher-Ohlin kind of trade based on static comparative advantages and by monopolistic competition based on dynamic innovation rents as analyzed by endogenous growth theorists. A similar analysis can be applied at the national scale, too. From a global point of view, the nation state sometimes looks more like a provider of club goods than of the pure public goods that are sometimes invoked to justify its existence. After all, there are national institutions, infrastructures, cultures and identities. In the course of history these can crystallize into shared national resources that confer competitive advantages in specific fields. From time to time nations are challenged in their economic specialization, and then their future 13
The role of clubs in the history of the City of London invites a footnote about how appropriate it is to consider club goods when studying regional economies.
116 SUSTAINABILITY AND ECONOMICS
will depend on whether they are able to either renew their existing competitive advantage or to build up another one in a new field [12]. At the global level, it is clear that so far only Western Europe, North America, Japan and Australia have been able to firmly establish a capacity to generate economic innovations – personal computers, mobile phones, weather satellites, color TV, container transport, etc. – at a sustained rate [13]. Parts of South-East Asia, the Middle East, Eastern Europe and Latin America seem able to absorb these innovations in processes of economic growth still driven more by capital accumulation than by technical progress. But the large rest of the world misses out in the fierce competition characterising todays global markets. This competition is a very different animal than classical and neoclassical perfect competition, but it certainly has little mercy with those who don’t have the regional and national club goods required to innovate at the pace it requires. With regard to the sustainability transition, this is a worrying situation. Take the global energy system.14 Currently, about 95% of all commercial energy worldwide is produced by burning fossil fuels. In the coming decades, world population is bound to increase, mainly in those parts of the world that have a hard time in generating the innovations that are driving today’s knowledge economy. At the same time, one would hope that these very parts of the global economy be the ones enjoying the fastest growth in income per head, so as to overcome the scandalous inequality of income across the globe. Sustainability is not meant to consist only in environmental constraints, it is meant to balance environmental with economic and social concerns. How then can one envisage a transition towards a more sustainable energy system under such conditions? This will be impossible unless new dynamics of economic development set in at the global, national and regional scales. Back to the Future For the purposes of integrated assessment, temporal scales of analysis are as important as spatial ones. For economics, they may actually be even more important. Economic dynamics is often analyzed in terms of a single intertemporal equilibrium path. This has been done by Ramsey [15] for a onegood world, and Nordhaus [16] has used a variant of Ramsey’s scheme to analyze optimal climate policies in the long run. Arrow and Debreu [17] have suggested an intertemporal equilibrium for a world with many goods – the intricacies of such a world, however, lead to a much less suggestive picture than the one-good case. To maintain that picture, computable general equilibrium models are usually framed in such a way as to reproduce the basic dynamics of a one-good world.15 14
See the discussion in Imboden and Jaeger [14]. Nordhaus and Yang [18] is a good example. Two main devices preserve the simple dynamics of a one-good world. First, a representation of investment which treats
15
SCALING IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT 117
In the full-blown many-goods case, intertemporal equilibrium would allocate resources over time in the same way as it allocates them among sectors at any given point in time. A myriad of own-rates of interest for different goods at different moments in time must then result.16 It takes a lot of faith (if not plain ignorance) to subscribe to the assumptions needed to blend them into an overall rate of interest ruling intertemporal capital markets. It seems much more sensible to build on the distinction between two scales well-known in economics: the short-run and the long-run. As with the triangle discussed in the introduction, very different patterns prevail at these two different scales – but now it is temporal, not spatial scale that matters. From a management point of view, short-run decisions are about how much to produce in order to serve actual demand on present markets. For the purpose of short-run decisions, production capacity and available technology are treated as given – because to modify them is a long-run process. Long-run decisions are about how to meet not actual, but expected demand. In long-run decisions, various kinds of fixed capital goods are purchased and produced in view of future demand which is not yet effective on present markets. When studying long-run economic dynamics, supply and demand for goods traded on actual markets may be assumed to operate at equilibrium levels because their adjustment via price mechanisms is much faster than the development of various kinds of fixed capital relevant for long-run economic dynamics. As a result, at each moment in time one gets a temporary general equilibrium contingent on investors’ expectations for future demand.17 Present decisions depend on expected futures, and actual futures depend on present decisions. This is the challenge of endogenous uncertainty in economics.18 Climate change is a remarkable example of the complex interplay between long and short-run developments in todays world economy. The Framework Convention on Climate Change is part of today’s international environmental diplomacy, and it fosters studies of how to develop technologies and products capital goods as some sort of homogeneous jelly which can be transformed costlessly in different kinds of infrastructure. And second, a representation of demand which eliminates income effects resulting from the production of different goods. 16 Suppose somebody sells a quantity of wheat today for whatever amount of money the market allows for. Now suppose there is a futures market for wheat and consider the quantity of tomorrow’s wheat which that amount of money can buy today. Then, the difference between these two quantities of wheat divided by the initial quantity is the wheat own-rate of interest. There is no reason why it should be equal to the own-rate of interest of, say, bricks. Otherwise, no changes in relative prices would be possible and therefore no adjustment of production patterns to demand for future products. (The analysis of ownrates of interest goes back to Sraffa’s critique of Hayek [19]). 17 A model of this kind is proposed by Morishima [20]. 18 A promising approach to the problem of endogenous uncertainty has been proposed by Kurz [21].
118 SUSTAINABILITY AND ECONOMICS
that could help reducing greenhouse gas emissions. These, in turn, are part of R&D efforts undertaken by today’s governments and businesses. The possible disruptions of the global climate system that these measures are supposed to mitigate, however, are likely to reach their climax way after the year 2100 [22]. This is due both to the time horizon over which humankind is likely to use the carbon available in the earth crust and to the time constants involved in the climate system, especially its oceanic components. Of course, some future demand is anticipated by futures markets operating in the present. But except for financial assets, futures markets exist only for a few goods and services and only for a very limited time horizon. In most cases, long-term decisions must rely on expectations that are not based on the interplay of futures markets, but on the “animal spirits” of investors [23]. For climate economics, this means that actual markets can hardly be expected to take care of climatic risks. There are no futures markets for land in Bangladesh in the year 2100 – and if there were, purchasing power disparities would give little weight to the interests of Bangladeshi people in the decision-making process. The difference between short-run and long-run economic decisions raises two major questions with regard to the role of expectations for the sustainability transition: ■
■
How do economic agents form their expectations about environmental changes that may happen in the long-run? How do such expectations influence long-run economic decisions?
As for the first question, we know at least four patterns of expectation formation that are relevant here. The first one is plain knowledge acquisition. In the case of climate change, scientific research can show that certain outcomes – say a sea level rise of 1m within 1 century – are possible as a consequence of human greenhouse gas emissions, while other events – say a sea level rise of 10 m within 10 years – are not. Usually, climate change research establishes that some event is possible or not, without attaching objective probabilities to it, although vague notions of “being likely” are often expressed by the experts from the relevant field. In some cases, the relevant knowledge is a public good available to economic agents at no cost. Where information acquisition is costly, economic agents may try to acquire as much information as needed to take a decision that they consider satisfactory both in its expected outcome and in the reliability of this expectation. This is the second pattern: satisficing behavior along the lines of bounded rationality. The third pattern is Bayesian learning [24]. If some economic agent – say a multinational oil company – considers climate change as highly unlikely on the basis of the evidence available at some point in time, that agent may change her expectation as additional evidence – say about long-term temperature trends – becomes available. The fourth pattern is pure guessing. This lies at the heart of notions of subjective probability, but also of the state-preference approach pioneered by Arrow [25] and Debreu [26]. Just
SCALING IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT 119
as human beings can prefer apples to oranges, they can prefer one uncertain situation to another one – even if they know nothing about relative frequencies. But while recent work by Becker [27] and others has begun to shed some light on the formation of preferences, so far little is known about the formation of those subjective probabilities that enter Bayesian learning as priors. As for the second question, it is far more intricate. The role of expectations for economic dynamics lies at the heart of some of the most important debates both in economic theory and policymaking. According to the efficient market hypothesis (EMH), at any moment in time current prices reflect all available information in the most accurate manner possible, taking into account different preferences and endowments in wealth.19 Current prices here include spot prices for future contracts – today’s spot price for wheat harvested one year in the future gives the expected value of the future price, discounted with today’s rate of interest. EMH is based on the idea that arbitrage will eliminate imperfections in information processing by market participants. We do not want to overemphasize the importance of EMH as such, rather we use it as a powerful way of addressing the difference between two temporal scales in economics. For policy purposes, EMH gives support to a general approach of laissez-faire and to general skepticism of discretionary – as opposed to rule-based – policies. In the case of climate policy, for example, economic agents should be given access to the best possible scientific evidence and enabled to work out its economic implications for themselves. Two objections to EMH that are relevant here.20 First, many real world markets are imperfect by the standards of the theory of competitive markets, and one may ask whether this jeopardizes the capability of economic agents to deal efficiently with the risks of climate change. The global oil market is clearly shaped by a few multinational corporations, none of which is faced with the horizontal demand function characteristic for firms operating under perfect competition. (Similar situations arise for other markets with key relevance for climate change). Bounded rationality provides ways to describe such markets without buying in to EMH. Under such descriptions, expectations are formed according to adaptive learning: economic agents observe current events and try to learn from the past. According to EMH, however, past prices provide no additional information to current prices when trying to forecast future price dynamics. Nevertheless, the fact that real oil prices are remarkably sticky since more than one hundred years is something one would not wish to ignore when studying climate policy. When oil prices underwent major shocks, these have been linked to large scale recessions, and even wars, until after a while they returned to their long-term level. 19
The origins of EMH go back to Samuelson [28]. A recent criticism of EMH relating both to the short and the long-run is to be found in Lo and MacKinlay [29]. 20
120 SUSTAINABILITY AND ECONOMICS
One answer to this experience has been provided by real business cycle theory, which argues that markets are efficient but that they take some time to work out the implications of exogenous shocks. This has been shown to be plausible even if economic agents do not form their expectations by adaptive learning, but if instead they are characterized by rational expectations.21 The latter concept provides a formalized version of Hayek’s [31] argument that no centralized authority can match the information processing capability of decentralized markets. Economic agents can know the structure of the economy at least as well as governments can. Accordingly, they can work out the implications of exogenous shocks for the system as a whole without any need for government assistance. The second objection to EMH, which may turn out to be even more important for integrated assessments regarding the sustainability transition, is based on empirical evidence concerning stock markets. In stock markets, the volume of trading and the volatility of prices are much larger than reasonable applications of EMH suggest. A possible explanation combines the absence of futures markets with adaptive learning by heterogeneous agents to understand the imperfections of actual stock markets. While this is certainly an important line of research, a more comprehensive approach is possible thanks to recent research. The Debreu-Sonnenschein-Mantel theorem ([32], see also Kurz [21]) shows that theoretically sound general equilibrium models produce not one equilibrium, but a whole set – which may be finite, countable, or uncountable – of equilibria. Only extreme assumptions can guarantee uniqueness of equilibrium. Clearly, this faces economic agents with a major coordination problem in equilibrium selection [33]. As Schelling [34] has shown, such problems may be solved by establishing some focal point of attention. They cannot be solved by utility maximization, however, because all relevant equilibria are Pareto optima in their own right. Even if endowed with rational expectations and a full suite of futures markets, therefore, economic agents would need some additional mechanism of expectation formation if they are to act at all. One such mechanism has been discussed under the label of “sunspot equilibria”, meaning the focussing of expectations by some exogenous event without additional causal impact on the economy. And while nowadays sunspots are a highly implausible candidate for such focussing, expectations of global climate change may well become a plausible one. Two more mechanisms which may be relevant for the sustainability transition deserve our attention. The first is based the role of science in today’s global society: Scientific knowledge claims may focus expectations of investors on certain technological trajectories long before the profitability of such trajectories can be assessed. While this mechanism relates to long-term investment, a completely different mechanism, namely price stickiness, helps economic agents to coordinate their expectations in the short run [35]. 21
The idea of rational expectations was introduced by Lucas [30].
SCALING IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT 121
Summing up: expectations may be formed in a variety of ways, some of which are reasonably well understood. Formation of priors and/or state preferences, however, clearly need further research. Expectations may shape the economy in two ways. First, they are essential for the way the economy digests exogenous shocks. And second, they are essential to cope with situations of endogenous uncertainty, where no single equilibrium is given. So far, economic work on expectations has been carried out mainly – but by no means only – in financial economics. Environmental economics has not yet taken advantage of this body of work. In particular, familiar models used in climate economics do not include representations of monetary phenomena. This is no big problem if one subscribes to EMH and real business cycle theory, but even then it is of course insufficient to discuss, say, the impact of carbon taxes on inflation or the role of the financial sector in shaping technical progress. It seems advisable, however, to develop models that would enable us to compare the EMH case with the one of adaptive expectations and the sunspot case. In a first step, this would mean an effort to use findings and methods available from other domains of economic research. As the role of expectations for economic dynamics is by no means settled in contemporary economic theorizing, one might also expect the study of the sustainability transition to contribute to significant advances in general theory. Policy advice referring to global environmental change may be greatly improved by explicitly addressing the role of different time scales in economic decision-making.
Conclusion Scaling issues in economics are not mainly about the up- and downscaling of models and the interpolation between discrete data points, important as these issues are in economics as elsewhere. The main issues concern deep changes in the laws and patterns that govern economic processes at different spatial, temporal and institutional scales. Much further research is warranted to deal with these issues. What should be clear by now, however, is that the role of nation states will need a thorough reappraisal in view of the sustainability transition. Are markets to take care of decisions affecting the short-run future, and governments advised by scientists to take care of long-term decisions about energy systems, urban development, and the like? This would turn Hayek’s [31] argument on its head: the most important decisions would not be taken by markets, but by governments. From the point of view of the global economy, however, nation states may be provider of club goods rather than public goods, and it is not clear whether in the long-run they will be the appropriate providers of the latter [36]. Do we need a complete set of futures markets ranging over the next centuries in order to deal with the challenge of the sustainability transition? Such markets would leave decisions over the future of humankind in the
122 SUSTAINABILITY AND ECONOMICS
hands of that tiny fraction of humans which currently is in a position to take major investment decisions, and it would greatly amplify the risks of speculative bubbles on futures markets. The thorny, if fascinating, issue of global governance calls for major institutional innovations. From an economic point of view, one may wonder whether political institutions are really the one and only kind of institutions to consider for this purpose. Perhaps, far-reaching innovations will take place in the realm of economic institutions, too.22 The sustainability transition can hardly be engineered by some more or less intelligent central agency, but at the same time it cannot take place without new structures and processes of global management. Learning to deal with scaling issues in economics will be vital in order to meet the challenge of sustainability.
References 1. 2.
Putnam, H., 1987. The Many Faces of Realism, La Salle: Open Court. Christiansen, P., and Parmentier R. (eds.), 1988. Structure, Coherence, and Chaos in Dynamical Systems. Manchester: Manchester University Press 3. Sterman, J., 2000. Business Dynamics: Systems Thinking for a Complex World. New York: Irwin/McGraw-Hill. 4. Wong, D., and C. Amrhein. (eds.), 1996. The Modifiable Areal Unit Problem. Special issue of Geographical Systems, 3: 2–3. 5. Gold, B., 1981. Changing perspectives on size, scale, and returns: an interpretive essay. Journal of Economic Literature, 19: 5–33. 6. Robbins, L., 1932. Essay on the Nature and Significance of Economic Science, New York: New York University Press. 7. Martin-Vide, C., (ed.), 1994. Current Issues in Mathematical Linguistics. Amsterdam, North-Holland. 8. Hahn, F., and R. M. Solow, 1997. A Critical Essay on Modern Macro Economic Theory, London: Blackwell. 9. Marshall, A., (1890) 1961. Principles of Economics: An Introductory Volume. London: Macmmillan. 10. Martin, R., and P. Sunley, 1996. Paul Krugman’s geographical economics and its implications for regional development theory: A critical assessment. Economic Geography, 72: 259–92. 11. Feser, E. J., 1998. Enterprises, external economies, and economic development. Journal of Planning Literature, 12: 283–302. 12. Nelson, R. R., 1993. National Innovation Systems: A Comparative Study. New York: Oxford University Press.
22
In this respect, sustainability studies may have much to gain from the seminal analysis in Drucker [37].
SCALING IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT 123
13. Sachs, J., 2000. “A New Map of the World.” The Economist, 24 June, 81–83. 14. Imboden, D. M., and C. C. Jaeger, 1999. Towards a Sustainable Energy Future. In: OECD, Energy: The Next Fifty Years, Paris: OECD. 15. Ramsey, F., 1928. “A Mathematical Theory of Saving.” Economic Journal, 38: 543–559. 16. Nordhaus, W. D, 1994. Managing the commons: The economics of climate change. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. 17. Arrow, K., and G. Debreu, 1954. “Existence of an Equilibrium for a Competitive Economy.” Econometrica, 22: 265–290. 18. Nordhaus, W. D., and Z. Yang, 1996. “A Regional Dynamic General-Equilibrium Model of Alternative Climate-Change Strategies.” American Economic Review, 86: 741–765. 19. Sraffa, P., 1932. “Dr. Hayek on Money and Capital.” Economic Journal, 42: 42–53. 20. Morishima, M., 1992. Capital and Credit. A New Formulation of General Equilibrium Theory. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. 21. Kurz, M., 1996. “Rational Beliefs and Endogenous Uncertainty.” Economic Theory, 8: 383–97. 22. Manabe, S., and R. J. Stouffer, 1993. “Century-scale effects of increased atmospheric CO2 on the ocean-atmosphere system.” Nature 364: 215–218. 23. Magill, M., and M. Quinzii, 1996. Theory of Incomplete Markets, Cambridge, Massachusetts: MIT Press. 24. Bernardo, J. M., and A. F. M. Smith, 1994. Bayesian Theory, New York: John Wiley. 25. Arrow, K. J., 1953. “Le rôle des valeurs boursières pour la repartition la meilleure des risques.” Econometrie, 40: 41–47, translated in 1964, Review of Economic Studies, Vol. 31: 91–6. 26. Debreu, G., 1959. Theory of Value: An axiomatic analysis of economic equilibrium. New Haven: Yale University Press. 27. Becker, G. S., 1996. Accounting for Tastes, Cambridge, Massachusetts: Harvard University Press. 28. Samuelson, P. A., 1965. Proof that Properly Anticipated Prices Fluctuate Randomly, Industrial Management Review, 6: 41–49. 29. Lo, A. W., and C. MacKinlay, 1999. A Non-Random Walk down Wall Street, Princeton: Princeton University Press. 30. Lucas, R. E., Jr., 1972. “Expectations and the neutrality of money.” Journal of Economic Theory, 4: 103–124. 31. Hayek, F. V., 1945. “The Use of Knowledge in Society.” American Economic Review, 35: 519–30. 32. Sonnenschein, H., 1974. “Market excess demand functions.” Econometrica, 40: 549–563. 33. Benhabib, J., and R. Farmer, 1999. Indeterminacy and Sunspots in Macroeconomics, In: J. Taylor and M. Woodford. (eds.), Handbook for Macro Economics, New York, North-Holland, vol. 1A, 387–448.
124 SUSTAINABILITY AND ECONOMICS
34. Schelling, T., 1960. The Strategy of Conflict. Cambridge, Massa-chusetts: Harvard University Press. 35. Blinder, A. S., E. R. D. Canetti, D. E. Lebow, J. R. Rudd, 1989. Asking About Prices: A New Approach to Understanding Price Stickiness. New York: Russell Sage Foundation. 36. Rodrik, D., 2000. “How Far Will International Economic Integration Go? Some wild speculation on the future of the world economy.” Journal of Economic Perspectives, 14: 177–186. 37. Drucker, P., 1976. The Unseen Revolution: How Pension Fund Socialism Arrived to America, New York: Harper & Row.
7 Scales in Economic Theory ANNE VAN DER VEEN AND HENRIËTTE OTTER University of Twente, The Netherlands
Introduction One of the underrated topics in economics is the issue of scale and aggregation. To be more precise, in regional economics spatial scale and spatial aggregation is a neglected item. This statement might sound a little bit strange in a world where transportation economics, regional economics and urban economics are well-established fields. However, it is our belief that in defining an observation set in order to understand the arrangement of spatial patterns and structures economists are poorly equipped. Economists have devoted more attention to the scale of time than to the scale of space. In addition, what has been done in the field of space is often general and abstract, not connected to an explicit observation set in time and space. Finally, it is our perception that in economic theory time scales and spatial scales are not tied, making the choice for a macro, meso or microeconomic theory a rather arbitrary process. We cannot handle these critical remarks all at the same time so we will restrict ourselves in order to illustrate our point of view. In this article, we will devote attention to the explanation of the phenomenon of emerging [1] spatial structures [2]. We will discuss the standard theories that describe the underlying processes and argue that by being more explicit about spatial scales explanatory power is added to current theoretical work. Given these introductory remarks on time, space and aggregation we will first pay attention to the choice of scales and aggregation levels in general. The issue of (spatial) aggregation as an almost insurmountable step will be discussed in some detail. Secondly, we devote a special section to ecology. We recently experienced that in ecology a discussion has taken place on exactly the same topic as we present here and we are convinced that by reviewing their findings on time and space, and especially their conclusions on aggregation, we can learn. Moreover, as an example, we will measure how location theory, as the heart of regional economic theory, is influenced by scaling. We evaluate how spatial resolution is handled in location theory and
126 SCALES IN ECONOMIC THEORY
discuss how defining the problem in terms of spatial resolution might contribute to a better understanding of the phenomenon of emerging spatial patterns. Finally, we devote a section to the consequences for government in the design of spatial policy.
Scales and Aggregation Models are abstract maps of empirical reality around us. Examples of these representations of reality are mental models, mathematical models, simulation models, physical scale models, etc. A binding element in all is that we aim to frame theories and ideas to better understand the empirical chaos. In every model, a choice has to be made on scales. Choosing a scale on which to project the objects and processes in a model refers to a quantitative and analytical dimension and to time and space [3,4]. Concerning these scales we may further discriminate between resolution and extent. For resolution in temporal and spatial scales we thus define a: ■ ■
time step (e.g., a day), and a spatial step (e.g., a grid of 100 by 100 meter).
For extent we can distinguish between: ■ ■
the extent of time (e.g., a year), and the spatial extent (e.g., a country).
As an example of the distinction above, abstract neo-classical models in economics have low temporal and spatial resolution. Moreover, they have relatively high extent in time and space. Large national-regional econometric models, on the other hand, may have a higher spatial resolution and consider a smaller extent in time. Besides quantitative and analytical dimensions and time and space, there is another concept to introduce and that is level. It is defined as the unit of analysis along a scale [3]. Economists prefer to speak about aggregation level. Level follows from systematically making choices on time and spatial scale (and thus on resolution and extent) and on quantitative and analytical dimensions. Before continuing with scales in economics, we make a remark on the aggregation process in economics. In economics, we do not have direct data at the coarse scale. Rather data at the coarse scale are aggregates used for macro or meso economic analyses. Two types of such economic aggregates can be distinguished: aggregate quantities and aggregate agents [5]. Relationships between aggregate macroeconomic quantities can be derived from [6]: ■ ■ ■
a macro theory, e.g., the Harrod and Domar model, a method based on analogies from micro behaviour, or an aggregation of micro relations based on micro characteristics.
SCALING IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT 127
A macro theory under (1) always has more or less an ad hoc character. It is based on rigorous hypotheses on relations between aggregate variables and is not related to any micro behaviour. The analogy method under (2) is followed in consumption and production theory. Studies in this field start with an elaborated theory of individual behaviour, but they are also assumed to hold for per capita data of totals. However, as Van Daal and Merkies [6] note, “Usually any argument in defence of this jump in the train of thoughts is lacking”. More firmly, Malinvaud, in Harcourt [7], states the following about the microeconomic foundations of macroeconomics: “Aggregation was hardly ever justified, except in rather narrow cases, which were not often found in fact. Most of the times our macro economic theory therefore lacked the rigorous justification that we should like to find in micro-economic analysis”. The implication of these arguments thus is that forming an observation set in mesoand macro-economics on basis of the analogy method (a representative agent) is a critical process. For (3) a consistent aggregation procedure has to be followed. This procedure is related to what in natural sciences is called up-scaling and downscaling [3]. However, as noted by Costanza et al. [4] such an aggregation procedure is far from trivial in complex, non-linear discontinuous systems. Indeed, Forni and Lippi [8] argue that macroeconomic modelling and testing would receive a new impetus if a better balance were reached between micro theory, aggregation theory, and empirical research on the distribution of the micro parameters over the population. Consequently, more importance would be given to heterogeneity on a micro level. In spatial economics, there are even more perplexing aggregation problems. Whereas census data are collected for essentially non-modifiable entities (people, households) they are reported for arbitrary and modifiable areal units (enumeration districts, local authorities etc). This is the crux of the modifiable areal unit problem: there are a large number of different spatial objects that can be defined and few, if any, non-modifiable units [9]. The conclusion from the discussion in this section on scales and aggregation is that building an observation set in time and space on a certain aggregation level is far from a simple process. More strongly, by making mistakes or misjudgements in the design of our observation set we make misjudgements in the understanding of the processes we wish to describe. Before continuing a discussion on building our observation set, we review a recent dispute in the discipline of ecology on scales. Given the definition of ecology in the next section we see a certain analogy with spatial economics. There is an identical problem in identifying aggregation levels in relation to an observation set in time and space.
128 SCALES IN ECONOMIC THEORY
Space and Aggregation in Ecology Ecology attempts to explain the relationship between living organisms and their surroundings. Ecology is about the distribution and abundance of different types of organisms over the face of the earth, and about the physical, chemical but especially the biological features and interactions that determine these distributions and abundances [10]. In ecology there are supposed to exist several dependent (bio) diversities at different aggregation (organisational) levels. Processes can, for instance, take place in the biosphere, but also on ecosystem, community, population and individual species level. (Note the analogy with micro, meso and macroeconomics.) In ecology, space and time are linked. Ecological processes that operate over large areas also tend to operate over long time scales. Modern ecology has focused mainly on those scales where local communities and short time periods are studied [11]. Thus, processes are simulated at short time scales and treated entirely as recursive; consequently high time resolution models are adopted [12]. Secondly, ecologists are interested in long time horizons and especially the long-term implication of human action [13]. Spatial dynamics are extremely important in ecology. Besides the physical flows of matter, the spatial arrangement of habitats or land cover affect all ecological processes such as species diversity, natural assimilative capacity and nutrient cycling. The spatial pattern of habitats or land cover, the landscape pattern, is thus linked with all ecological processes. Furthermore, the size and shape of the patterns themselves depend on the scale on which they are described. These notions have led to the development of hierarchy theory [14], which states that the variation that is observed in ecosystems depends on the scale over which we measure it, both in time and in space. Within such a hierarchy we observe: ■ ■ ■ ■
Processes, Flows, Interactions, and Rates (which characterise the speed of change in the system).
Variables and processes on lower level in the hierarchy are considered as noise, whereas variables on higher level act as constraints. Rates appear to be a kind of distinctive variable in relation to hierarchies. “High” levels show slow rates and “low” levels show fast rates. The notions on hierarchy and scale as presented above have been shaken somewhat by authors who discuss the relation between level and scale. An important first observation by O’Neill and King [14] is that hierarchies are less evident than they look because moving across scales the dominant processes may suddenly change and relationships may completely disappear.
SCALING IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT 129
Moreover, within an ecological observation set, processes may be located at different levels by finding breaks or discontinuities in the data. Otherwise stated, discontinuities in the ecological data may suggest a change in level of organisation. The question that is being raised is whether these levels of organisation, as extracted from empirical data, are the same as adopted in traditional biological literature: organism, population, landscape, ecosystem, etc. Significantly, ecologists admit that they have confused the words scale and level [14]. This implies, for instance, that the application of the word scale in ‘landscape scale’ is wrong. Landscape is a level of organisation. There is a relation between scale and level, but changing the scale of observation changes the observation set. Consequently, the hierarchical organisation can change or disappear. Allen [15] takes an even harder position: Landscape is a “type” as the researcher constructs it and it is thus an organisation level that is not scalar. Type-based levels of organisation contrast with scale based levels, which are rooted in observations. Higher levels of observation are materially larger, whereas levels of organisation cannot be assigned to any particular spatiotemporal size. Consequently, landscape is a model, a choice in an analytical dimension. A second observation by O’Neill and King [14] is that hierarchies, as established by ecological theory, are rather arbitrary. The authors do, however, like to keep the idea of hierarchies, but these concepts should be sustained by observations and should not be merely heuristic in the sense of explaining very special problems. From the above experiences in ecology, we firstly infer that in ecology time and spatial scales are connected. Secondly, we conclude that in ecology there is a relation between scale and aggregation level, and that changing the scale of observation also changes the observation set. More strongly, even the hierarchical organisation can change or disappear. Having gone through the general discussion on scales and through the particular application in ecology the question may arise: “How about scales in economics”? Is there a kind of hierarchy in economics sustained by observations? Or is the distinction in micro, meso and macro a type based level characterisation of organisation, which is a rather arbitrary decision, made by the scientific economic community?
Space and Aggregation in Economics Economics is concerned with human behaviour. It studies the allocation of scarce resources to different means. Producers aim to maximise profits and thus minimise costs, while choosing a certain technology, where labour and capital are combined. Consumers aim to optimise their utility given their income and the relative prices of different goods.
130 SCALES IN ECONOMIC THEORY
Economics is thus concerned with choice and value. Three main levels along the scale of analytical interest are distinguished, the micro, meso and macro level. Each level of aggregation has its own theoretical content. Microeconomics studies consumer and producer behaviour, meso-economics focuses on sectors, while macroeconomics focuses on aggregates, aggregate behaviour and government policy. Analogous to ecology, the processes, interactions, flows and rates in economics distinguish organisational levels. Higher levels have slower rates (e.g., inflation), and different levels show different interactions and processes. In Figure 7.1 we give an example of processes and interactions for three levels of analytical interest. In the figure, we bring in a traditional ‘natural’ economic order to resemble traditional thinking in micro, meso and macroeconomics. The grey part in the figure represents a dynamic area, where interactions, flows and rates are relevant. Outside the grey part processes and analytical concepts are not relevant. Above a certain organisational level information acts as constraint and below a level information is supposed to be noise. For example, on the micro level price setting formation is given. On the meso level inflation will act as a constraint whereas individual producer maximisation is noise. Horizontally seen, for sectoral agents, behaviour of individual consumers and producers is noise, whereas the behaviour of aggregate agents is given. Note that in this reasoning, there is no explicit reference to space.
Processes Macro
Inflation
Meso
Markets and price formation
Utility/Prod. Optimization
Micro Consumers & Producers
Sectors & Groups
Aggregates and representative agents
Analytical Scale
Figure 7.1: Processes, interactions, analytical scale and traditional hierarchy in economics.
Given the processes and the analytical scale domain we distinguish, what are the time and space dimensions in economics? Moreover, what is the observation set? Here we notice an important difference between economics and natural science in general and ecology in particular. Economic theory is
SCALING IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT 131
based on abstract social units. It is inter alia focussed on utility optimisation of households and price formation in markets. The consequence is that economic theory is not spatially explicit [12] in terms of spatial resolution. Economists might research yearly changes in expenditure on housing for households in the Netherlands as influenced by changes in female labour force participation over a period of ten years. Or they might investigate changes in the quantity of steel sold by industry in the year 1999 in Portugal as a function of changes in GNP in Portugal. Or changes in Gross Regional Product in a time series for states in the USA. Or yearly changes in the demand for water in the UK because of privatisation. To some degree, spatial extent and spatial resolution seem to coincide. Economic research on consumer and producer behaviour on the basis of individual data is not performed on or restricted to a local or regional level. In addition, sectoral observations can be collected at a local, regional and national level. Does this imply that space does not matter in economics? No, space does matter; however, space is generally translated into transportation costs [16], and thus into prices, by the one-dimensional concept of distance. Thus, spatial differences come back in another fashion. But, note again that the resolution of space is not important. Thus, we conclude that spatial resolution, as part of the concept of spatial scale is not taken into account in economics. Economic theory is on abstract social units. Concerning the related problem of aggregation, it is our observation that the ‘traditional’ division in micro, meso and macroeconomics does not have an explicit spatial connotation. As a corollary, the organisational division in economics in micro, meso and macro is a rather abstract distinction, a type based construct, as ecologists would call it. Spatial Resolution and Emerging Patterns of Location Behaviour Does spatial resolution matter in scientific disciplines that deal with space? Above we reached the conclusion that distance as a one-dimensional concept of space does matter, but we did not investigate two- and three-dimensional spatial issues in economics. Are there any applications in spatial sciences where spatial resolution is of importance? Of course there are; in agricultural economics crop results depend on technology as well as on soil conditions, climate and hydrology. In regional economics, inter alia, locational decisions made by households and by firms are spatially dependent. In land markets, land use and land cover change are at stake. Moreover, in (economic) geography, we are interested in differences between regions and countries and we try to understand the formation of patterns.
132 SCALES IN ECONOMIC THEORY
Yet, we are not impressed how spatial resolution is introduced in these disciplines. We will illustrate this statement by presenting standard theories on emerging spatial structures in regional economics and in geography. The evident example for emerging structures is that of location behaviour of firms and households in producing urban spatial patterns. We will evaluate how spatial resolution is handled in location theory and discuss how defining the problem in terms of spatial resolution might contribute to a better understanding of the phenomenon of emerging spatial patterns. In presenting theories on location behaviour, we will split between geography and regional economics as they approach location behaviour from different angles. Geography Geography focuses on where things are located and why [17]. Location, maps and distribution help to answer the where question. The why question is addressed by researching the ability of people to adjust to their physical environment. Scale is of utmost importance in geography. Spatial scale (resolution and extent) is recognised in geography as the main mechanism whereby patterns can be analysed and explained. Geographical Information Systems (GIS) is the essential tool to solve this why and where question [18]. It is our belief, however, that geographers aim at merely a description of the adjustment process that comes with location behaviour. This means that the choice for a certain resolution is not decisive in explaining emergent patterns. A good example is the work on land use dynamics. The high spatial resolution model of urban land-use dynamics developed by White and Engelen [19] aims to capture the spatial complexity of urban and regional areas, by making use of two basic techniques, cellular automata and GIS. Cellular automata use a set of transition rules that govern the local behaviour at each cell with respect to the cell’s neighbours and its own characteristics. It offers a means to study emergent global behaviour in systems where only local processes are understood. By applying this technique of cellular automata, GIS is converted into a dynamic tool [20, 21]. The model of White and Engelen [19] for instance distinguishes between two levels, a macro and a micro level. The macro level includes a modelling framework, which integrates several component submodels representing the natural, social and economic subsystems. The micro level is developed on a cellular array in which the land use changes are calculated through transition rules [19, 22]. However, a drawback of cellular automata in general is the fact that the transition rules are not necessarily reproducible with an objective empirical methodology. The system performance depends highly on the skill of the modeller. Secondly, transition rules do not change during the course of a simulation and hence may be of limited importance because changes of landscape rarely are constant over time. Finally, a most important drawback
SCALING IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT 133
is the difficulty of incorporating micro-economic behaviour. Geographers are relatively poor in formulating theories explaining behaviour in space. Indeed, Openshaw and Abrahart [23: p380] argue that ‘ human systems modelling is going to become an unavoidable area of considerable practical importance. People are too important to ignore. Currently, we have no good or even tolerably poor models of the behaviour of people’. Our conclusion is that geographers, although they combine high spatial resolutions with GIS, do not succeed in explaining emergent location behaviour.1 Regional economics In elucidating the role of spatial resolution in regional economics, we again discuss location theory and the appearance of spatial patterns and structures. Location theory and spatial patterns In location theory, a distinction is made between location theories of the firm, location theories of households and the interaction between the two. In the literature on location of the firm, transportation costs (as an estimate of the notion of space and distance) are central to location choice. Here we may distinguish between models that assume a demand for goods and services continuously dispersed in space and models where demand is concentrated in one point [24]. The first type of model suggests [25] geographical patterns of firm location that are hierarchical ordered, whereas the second type presents structures that are dependent on the (point) location of markets and resources. Anas et al. [26] note that defining clusters in space is not so easy. The distinction between an organized system of subcenters and apparently unorganized urban sprawl depends very much on the spatial scale of observation. Here we find one of the very few remarks economists devote to the problem of spatial resolution. For the explanation of agrarian land use the famous Von Thünen model [27] is important. The model has been criticised for the assumptions that production takes place around an isolated market and that soils are of constant fertility. Nevertheless his distance-cost relationship has become the basis of urban location theory. Some claim that Von Thünen’s approach has dominated the thinking about location exactly because of its simplicity and predictive ability [28]. In using an urban location model linked to Von Thünen’s theory, Alonso [29] developed a model that can be regarded as the basis for household location choice. Alonso’s approach is based on the principle that rents decrease outward from the centre of a city (lower revenue, higher operating costs and transportation costs). Rent gradients consist of a series of bid-rents, which compensate for falling revenue and higher operating costs. Different land uses 1
One of the reasons might be the intrinsic data problem geographers and economists have regarding the Modifiable Areal Unit Problem, as discussed above.
134 SCALES IN ECONOMIC THEORY
have different rent gradients, the use with the highest gradient prevailing. Competitive bidding (perfect information) determines patterns of rent and allocates specific sites between users to ensure that the highest and best use is obtained. Land is used in the most appropriate way and profit is maximised. Criticisms to Alonso’s model are first of all that in reality information is incomplete; thus there is an imperfect market. He also fails to take into account the distinctive nature of buildings and their use, which are not easily changed (lock-in). Other points are the heterogeneity of property, public sector land and spillover effects of other uses. The Alonso model and the literature based on it are characterised by other simplistic assumptions. Employment is centralised in the Central Business District (CBD), there is a dense radial road system and all households have the same taste [30]. Moreover, the model is static. Some of these assumptions have been removed [31, 32, 33, 34, 35], but the theories remain rather general and abstract. Note that we did not refer to spatial resolution in interpreting Alonso type urban location models. By only applying distance as the one-dimensional concept of space, the location theories of Von Thünen and Alonso are not able to explain the complex spatial structures that we encounter. Anas et al. [26] discuss this problem by referring to alternative assumptions for the Pareto equilibrium of monocentric cities that make a uniform distribution unstable. Spatial inhomogeneities, internal scale economies, external scale economies and imperfect competition create polycentric agglomerations. In regional economic theory external economies of scale, agglomeration economies, or localisation economies are used as theoretical constructs explaining why firms locate in each other’s vicinity to arrive at increasing returns to scale [36, 37]. Business firms locate in each other’s vicinity in order to gain from the attractiveness of companies of the same type activity, but also to gain from the general atmosphere in such a region. These notions are regarded as a major contribution to economic theory [1]. However, the theoretical constructs remain more or less a black box failing to explain the occurrence of spatial structures and patterns on a high level of spatial resolution. It is here that non-economic explanations have much more to offer in order to interpret the black box [2, 38]. Self-organising criticality and synergetics produce organised structures with which polycentric cities might be better explained. In these theories interactions between individual actors on a high level of spatial resolution give rise to meso and macro spatial structures. Anas et al. [26] therefore plea for an adaptation of standard economic theory. An explanation on a high level of spatial resolution is available where traditional economic theories seem to fail. Interaction between individual actors on high spatial resolution is, however, not in the heart of regional economic theory.
SCALING IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT 135
Spatial econometrics Before concluding that in traditional economics spatial scale is not taken into account, we would like to devote attention to a special branch in spatial economics that is related to special techniques caused by the features of space: spatial econometrics. In the same way as we discussed the combination of GIS and geography in the first section, it might be the case that the combination of spatial econometrics and spatial economics produces a powerful explanation for spatial behaviour. Spatial econometrics is concerned with techniques that deal with the peculiarities caused by space [39]. It deals with spatial dependencies and with spatial heterogeneity. According to Anselin and Florax [39] spatial dependency is relevant in two cases: ■
■
In case of a spatial structure underlying spatial correlation, where the main interest is the spatial interaction behind the variable of interest. Spatial dependence between ignored variables in the model as reflected in the error terms.
In neglecting these cases the estimation of an a priori specified model, based on observations for a finite set of spatial units, will cause a number of problems [40]: ■
■
■
■ ■
The modifiable areal unit problem [9], which concerns the aggregation of observations over space. Border or edge problems, pertaining to the problem that inferences are based on a finite set of observations whereas the spatial process extends to spatial units not represented in the data set. Specification of the spatial interaction structure, which is typically represented by a spatial weight matrix. Testing for spatial effects by means of spatial association or correlation. Estimation of spatial models for which adjusted estimators are needed.
The underpinning of spatial dependencies and heterogeneities in regional economics is based on the same ideas as we try to develop in this paper. Anselin and Florax [39: p5] state that there is a ‘renewed interest for the role of space and spatial interaction in social science theory. In mainstream economic theory this is reflected in the interest in the new economic geography’. It is our judgement, however, that spatial econometrics is mainly interested in the statistical and econometric problems of spatial dependencies and not so much in the extension of the theory of economic behaviour with a spatial context and component.2 It is our view that spatial complexity should acknowledge space as a context for decisions made by individual households and firms. We conclude that the combination of spatial econometrics and spatial economics does not produce an additional explanation for spatial behaviour. 2
But there are exceptions: Dubin [41] presents a wonderful paper of a logit model incorporating spatial dependencies on a GIS grid base!
136 SCALES IN ECONOMIC THEORY
Conclusion In discussing scaling and aggregation in (regional) economics, it is our first observation that the construction of an observation set may have strong limitations in relation to the spatial theoretical notions that are assumed. Secondly, the ‘traditional’ division between micro, meso and macroeconomics does not seem have an explicit spatial connotation. Thirdly, in standard economic theory spatial extent and spatial resolution seem to coincide. Considering spatial resolution and human behaviour in regional economic theory, it seems as though there is a trade-off between two topics. Certain types of models are capable of capturing the spatial complexity of urban and regional areas, for instance, by using cellular automata. These models have a high spatial resolution, but do not include choices made by individuals. On the other hand, current static and dynamic location models on the other hand do not guarantee a high spatial resolution. It is here that future researchers should concentrate their efforts.
References 1.
Krugman, P. R., 1996. The Self-Organizing Economy. Cambridge: Blackwell Publishers. 2. Otter, H. S., 2000. Complex adaptive land use system: an interdisciplinary approach with agent-based models. Uitgeverij Eburon, Delft, The Netherlands. 3. Gibson, C. C., E. Ostrom and T. K. Ahn, 2000. “The concept of scale and the human dimensions of global change: a survey.” Ecological Economics, 32: 217–239. 4. Costanza, R., L. Wainger, C. Folke and K. G. Mäler, 1993. “Modeling Complex Ecological Economic Systems.” BioScience, 43: 545–555. 5. Schlicht, E., 1985. Isolation and Aggregation in Economics. Berlin: Springer Verlag. 6. Van Daal, J., and A. H. Q. M. Merkies, 1985. Aggregation in economic research; from individual to macro relations., D. Reidel Publishing Company, Kluwer. 7. Harcourt, G. C. (ed.), 1977. The microeconomic foundations of macroeconomics, London: The Macmillan Press. 8. Forni, M., and M. Lippi, 1997. Aggregation and the Microfoundations of dynamic Macroeconomics. Oxford: Clarendon press. 9. Openshaw, S., 1983. The modifiable areal unit problem, Concepts and techniques in modern geography. Norwich: Geo Books. 10. Begon, M., J. L. Harper and C. R. Townsend, 1996. Ecology. Oxford: Blackwell Science.
SCALING IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT 137
11. Beeby, A., and A. M. Brennan, 1997. First Ecology. London: Chapman & Hall. 12. Bockstael, N., 1996. “Modeling Economics and Ecology: The Importance of a Spatial Perspective.” American Journal of Agricultural Economics, 78: 1168–1180. 13. Bockstael, N., R. Costanza, I. Strand, W. Boyton, K. Bell and L. Wainger, 1995. “Ecological Economic Modeling and Valuation of Ecosystems.” Ecological Economics 14: 143–159. 14. O’Neill, R. V., and A. W. King, 1998. Homage to St. Michael; or, why are there so many books on scale? In: Ecological scale: Theory and application. D. L. Peterson and V. Th. Parker (eds.). New York: Columbia University Press: 3–15. 15. Allen, T. F. H., 1998. The landscape is dead. In: Ecological scale: Theory and application. D. L. Peterson and V. Th. Parker (eds.). New York: Columbia University Press. 16. Krugman, P. R., 1993. “On the relationship between trade theory and location theory.” Review of International Economics, 1: 110–122. 17. Rubenstein, J. M., 1989. An introduction to Human geography. New York: MacMillan. 18. Martin, D., 1996. Geographic Information Systems: Socioeconomic Applications. London: Routledge. 19. White, R., and G. Engelen, 1993. “Cellular automata and fractal urban form: a cellular modelling approach to the evolution of urban land-use patterns.” Environment and Planning A, 25: 1175–99. 20. Tobler, W., 1979. Cellular geography In: Philosophy in Geography. S. Gale and G. Olsson (eds.). Dordrecht: D. Reidel Publishing Company: 379–86. 21. Couclelis, H., 1985. “Cellular Worlds: A Framework for Modeling Micro-Macro Dynamics.” Environment and Planning A, 17: 585–596. 22. Engelen, G., R. White, I. Uljee and P. Drazan, 1995. “Using Cellular Automata for Integrated Modelling of Socio-Environmental Systems.” Environmental Monitoring and Assessment, 34: 203–214. 23. Openshaw, S., and R. J. Abrahart, 2000. Geocomputing. London: Taylor and Francis. 24. Lloyd, P. E., and P. Dicken, 1977. Location in space. London: Harper and Row. 25. Christaller, W., 1933. Die Zentrale Orte in SüdDeutschland. Eine ökonomisch-geografische Untersuchung über die Gesatzmässigkeit der Verbreitung und Entwicklung der Siedlungen mit Städtischen Funktionen. Jena: Gustav Fischer. 26. Anas, A., R. Arnott and K. A. Small, 1998. “Urban spatial structure.” Journal of Economic Literature vol XXXVI: 1426–1464. 27. Von Thünen, J. H., 1826. Der Isolierte Staat. Used Edition: Von Thünen’s Isolated State; An English Edition of Der Isolierte Staat. P. Hall (ed.). Oxford: Pergamon Press.
138 SCALES IN ECONOMIC THEORY
28. Vickerman, R. W., 1980. The Microeconomic Foundations of Urban and Transport Economics. London: MacMillan Press. 29. Alonso, W., 1960. “A Theory of the Urban Land Market.” Papers and Proceedings of the Regional Science Association, 6: 149–157. 30. Richardson, H. W., K. J. Button, P. Nijkamp, and H. Park, 1997. Analytical Urban Economics, Modern Classics in Regional Science. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar. 31. Pines, D., 1976. Dynamic Aspects of Land Use Patterns in a Growing City In: Mathematical Land Use Theory. G. J. Papageorgiou: Lexington Books: 229–243. 32. White, M. J., 1976. “Firm Suburbanisation and Urban Subcenterss.” Journal of Urban Economics, 3: 323–343. 33. Fujita, M., 1976. “Spatial Patterns of Urban Growth: Optimum and Marke.” Journal of Urban Economics, 3: 209–241. 34. Fujita, M., 1989. Urban economic theory; Land use and city size. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. 35. Papageorgiou, Y. Y., and D. Pines, 1999. An essay on urban economic theory. Dordrecht: Kluwer. 36. Marshall, A., 1890. Principles of economics. London: MacMillan. 37. Lambooy, J. G., 1998. Agglomeratievoordelen en ruimtelijke ontwikkeling (Agglomeration advantages and spatial development). Oratie. Utrecht: Universiteit Utrecht. 38. Allen, P. M., 1997. Cities and Regions as Self-Organising Systems; Models of Complexity. Amsterdam: Gordon and Breach Science. 39. Anselin, L., and R. J. G. M. Florax, 1995. New directions in spatial econometrics. Berlin: Springer Verlag. 40. Florax, R. J. G. M., and S. Rey, 1995. The impacts of misspecified spatial interaction in linear regression models. In: New directions in spatial economterics. L. Anselin and R. J. G. M. Florax (eds.). Berlin: Springer Verlag. 41. Dubin, R., 1995. Estimating logit models with spatial dependence. In: New directions in spatial econometrics. L. Anselin and R. J. G. M. Florax (eds.). Berlin: Springer Verlag.
8 Scaling Methods in Regional Integrated Assessments: from Points Upward and from Global Models Downwards 1
1
2
T. E. DOWNING , R. E. BUTTERFIELD , M. BINDI , 3 4 5 R. J. BROOKS , T. R. CARTER , R. DELÉCOLLE , 6 1 7 8 Z. S. HARNOS , P. A. HARRISON , A. IGLESIAS , M. NEW , 9 10 11 12 S. MOSS , J. E. OLESEN , J. L.ORR , J. PORTER , 13 14 M. A. SEMENOV AND J. WOLF 1 Environmental Change Institute, University of Oxford, Oxford, UK 2 DISAT, University of Florence, Florence, Italy 3 IACR Long Ashton Research Station, University of Bristol, Bristol, UK 4 Finnish Environment Institute, Helsinki, Finland 5 INRA – Unité de Bioclimatologie, Avignon, France 6 Department of Mathematics and Informatics, University of Horticulture and Food Industry, Budapest, Hungary 7 Escuela Tecnica Superior de Ingenieros Agronomos, Cuidad Universitaria, Madrid, Spain 8 School of Geography and the Environment, University of Oxford, Oxford, UK 9 Centre for Policy Modelling, Manchester Metropolitan University, Manchester, UK 10 Department of Crop Physiology & Soil Science, DIAS, Research Centre Foulum, Tjele, Denmark 11 Scottish Natural Heritage, Edinburgh, Scotland 12 Department of Agricultural Sciences, Royal Veterinary and Agricultural University, Taastrup, Denmark 13 IACR Long Ashton Research Station, University of Bristol, Bristol, UK 14 Department of Theoretical Production Ecology, Wageningen Agricultural University, The Netherlands
140 SCALING METHODS IN REGIONAL INTEGRATED ASSESSMENTS
Acknowledgements This article draws upon the CLIVARA final report (see Butterfield et al. [1]), an EU project on climate change and agriculture (ENV4-CT95-0154).
Introduction All models contain a simplification of the spatial or temporal scale of the real system, either by averaging or aggregating small scale elements or by treating large scale changes as a constant [2, 3, 4]. Three examples illustrate the importance of scale in climate change impact assessment. First, understanding of crop-climate modelling at the site scale is far more profound than is readily captured in spatial, regional models. Yet, spatial shifts in agricultural potential, demand for water, use of fertiliser and competitiveness are more profound for agricultural systems than point estimates of changes in potential yield. Second, climate change captured in low resolution global climate models may not relate to the sensitivity of local climate impacts. Changes in extreme events, such as ground frost, persistent drought, and ocean-atmosphere anomalies, are poorly represented in existing models. Yet, such changes are likely to be more significant than gradual changes in means. Third, understanding adaptation requires a new breed of climate change impact assessment – one that portrays realistic decision making, environmental, economic and social signals, and thresholds for action [5]. Scaling between the cognition of decision agents and their broader environments will be a considerable challenge. This paper primarily focuses on methodologies required to address the first of these demands for understanding scale in integrated assessment – scaling up impacts. We also provide an entrée into the literature on downscaling climate. The discussion introduces issues in scaling agents – a critical aspect of agent-based simulation. In many respects, these issues are part of the arcane toolkit of impacts modeling. However, resolving the scale issue can make a difference (see for example Easterling et al. [6], Mearns et al. [7, 8]). The CLIVARA project undertook a European-scale assessment of climate change and potential crop production, using high resolution, multi-scale crop-climate models. On two occasions we have (subjectively) compared our results with the results from single-scale spatial models used in global assessments. We have the diverging results – the global models predict major adverse impacts of climate change whereas our process-oriented understanding shows widespread benefits and few adverse impacts on potential crop production. However, these comparisons
SCALING IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT 141
are simply visual – further comparison of impacts models remains an urgent agenda for research. Scaling Up Impacts This section provides examples of different approaches to scaling up, drawn from the experience of the Climate Change, Climatic Variability and Agriculture in Europe (CLIVARA) project [9]. The choice of scale is part of the process of formulating a model [10]. For some physical models strong spatial interactions between the principal model variables, such as air movement between neighbouring grid cells, guide the choice of an appropriate spatial scale. Such spatial interactions are limited in agriculture (e.g., competition between plants for water, pests), although scaling is still present in crop models, for example, by modelling the average conditions over a small area and by using average daily weather rather than trying to reproduce the changes throughout the day. The techniques described here apply to common methods in climate change impact assessment, specifically crop-climate modelling. The focus is on crop phenology and yield. We assume nutrients will be applied and pests controlled. Scaling up all of the factors affecting crop production (e.g., agronomic management) and agricultural systems (e.g., costs and prices) is more difficult. Methods for bridging scales range from using available climate stations to forcing all data, processes and output to a uniform gridscale and multi-level approaches that embed reduced form or emulation models (e.g., Polsky and Easterling [11]). One aspect of the scaling-up has been to determine the optimum amount of input data and model runs. that are needed to represent the responses to environmental change in a ‘region’. Several studies have discussed this issue, in particular the regional study on Central England [12] and the Danish country study [13]. Five approaches for representing variability across space are illustrated schematically in Figure 8.1 (see Downing et al. [3]). Site-driven approaches (a in Fig. 8.1) begin with station data. In contrast, raster grids for the basis for most spatial modeling (b), although much data is held in polygons rather than grids (d). The two forms can be combined in various ways (c, d and e). Site-driven approaches A common approach in determining regional yields is to identify sites and soils that can ‘represent’ that region. Such an approach is generally based on soil polygons for natural resource data. If soil units cover a large geographic region, they may be intersected with an agroclimatic index, such as aridity or agroecological zone, topography (often a proxy for temperature), or agronomic management regions e.g., known land use or irrigated areas.
142 SCALING METHODS IN REGIONAL INTEGRATED ASSESSMENTS
(a)
(d)
(b)
(c)
(e)
Figure 8.1: Approaches for representing spatial variability in models: (a) site driven (site/polygon and multiple sites in a polygon); (b) spatial uniform grids; (c) uniform grids with relational soils (spatially combined); (d) spatial interpolation; and (e) stochastic space.
Each resulting polygon is associated with representative climate data. Ideally, this would be a station within the boundaries of the polygon. If this is not available, the climate data may need to be interpolated from stations outside the polygon. Or, more simply, the nearest station is used. In either case, a single site represents the entire polygon. This is the site/polygon approach. A slightly more complex approach is the multiple site/region method. This assumes that several sites can be used to represent the spatial variability within a region. Brooks and Semenov [12] investigated how many sites were required to capture the variability in climatic and soils parameters for modelling climate change effects on winter wheat in central England. Analysis of data at numerous sites in the region indicated that it could be considered as a single climatic region with three main soil types. Empirical relationships were then derived between site predictions from a process-oriented wheat model (Sirius) and observed regional yield statistics for climate change. A different interpretation of the multiple site/region method is illustrated in Davies et al. [14] in a study on the economic response of potatoes to climate change in England and Wales. Here, site-based crop and economic models were applied to 93 meteorological stations in the region for current conditions and several climate change scenarios. Model output variables (e.g., yield, gross margins) were then spatially interpolated from the 93 sites to a 10 km grid across England and Wales. In a case study in Denmark [13], correlations using summer precipitation with 650 precipitation stations identified regions of Denmark, represented by 6 climate stations. Using the maximum correlation scheme the areas that were best correlated to each site were identified.
SCALING IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT 143
This approach has the benefit of retaining complex soils data and can readily utilise detailed climate data (e.g., 30-year daily time series of temperature, solar radiation, wind, humidity and rainfall) that would be difficult to grid for a study region. Soils are acknowledged as more important for crop suitability than local differences in climate. If soil units are large, then one climate station may not be representative and the soil units may need to be subdivided by climatic regions. A site-polygon approach was also adopted in the regional studies in Hungary [15]. The main technical drawback to site-driven approaches is the relative complexity of the modelling environment. Creating and accessing databases in different formats requires special facilities not generally provided in a Geographic Information System (GIS) or crop-climate programmes. Even with generic shells, such as AEGIS [16], considerable investment is required to set up a study area and carry out simulations. Even creating a spatial map of the length of growing period requires fully processing the crop model for each soil-climate polygon, summarising the model output, and presenting the resulting statistics for the soil-climate thematic layer in the GIS. However, the approach does preserve the original data formats and integrity. The conceptual limitations concern notions of space as an inherent variable. The model only has to be run once for each soil type and crop management group within each climate polygon. There is no a priori test for choosing the number of soil-climate spaces and the number of climate stations required to represent each polygon. To the extent that long term change alters present environmental relationships, choosing ideal polygons for the present situation does not guarantee an adequate representation of the future. The estimation of the variance of modelled regional yield requires the spatial correlation of simulated yields to be assessed. This can be done for current conditions by running a model for each database grid using observed weather data for a given period. However, climate change scenarios downscaled to sites generally are not spatially correlated and so cannot be used to investigate the future yield covariance structure. This is true for scenarios constructed using a weather generator to produce independent time series of synthetic weather data for each site (but see the spatial weather generator in Semenov and Brooks [17]). Regional climate models are another approach gaining popularity, but at some expense in terms of data handling. Central England case study A study has been conducted using the soil/polygon approach in Central England [12]. The methodology involves predicting regional yield under future climate by scaling-up output from a site-based wheat model. Limited site information is assumed to be available so that the method is applicable in most circumstances; only soil data for the region and detailed weather data at a few sites are required. The predictions of yield assume good management and the absence of pests and diseases with spatial variations in modelled yield therefore being due to differences in weather and soil conditions throughout the region.
144 SCALING METHODS IN REGIONAL INTEGRATED ASSESSMENTS
The first step was to investigate the relationships between the input and output variables of the Sirius wheat model by conducting a comprehensive sensitivity assessment. Next, a simpler model was constructed based on an analysis of the inherent relationships within the Sirius model and results from the sensitivity assessment. The model was able to reproduce the Sirius yields closely for a variety of UK conditions. Test data sets with a wide range of yields produced root mean square errors of around 800 kg ha1, compared to standard deviations in the Sirius model of some 2000 kg ha1. Correlations were above 0.90. The methodology consists of identifying the areas within the given region that have similar soil-weather characteristics. Unless the region is very large, contains major topographical features or a vast diversity of soil types, there will only be a few such soil-weather combinations. Predictions of regional yield are then made by combining site-scale Sirius predictions for each soilweather combination with predictions of the inter-site correlation pattern. The mean regional yield is simply defined as the weighted sum of the mean site yields. When data from only a few sites are available the yields across the region must be inferred using this data. In particular, areas that are considered to have similar weather and soil conditions are likely to show a similar change in yield and can be considered as one large site. It was necessary to assess the relationships between the site weather data and the site soils data. A sensitivity analysis on the full mechanistic winter wheat model and resulting simpler model showed that the single important soil variable, under non-nitrogen limiting conditions is the total available water capacity. Different soils can therefore be grouped together if their water capacities are similar. Those areas identified as having similar climates and soils are considered as a single large site in the estimation of the mean and variance of regional yield. This overcomes the need to simulate each individual farm within the region. The mean regional yield is calculated for present and future climatic conditions for each different soil-climate combination. This is undertaken using the Sirius model with synthetic weather data produced by the LARSWG stochastic weather generator (see Barrow et al. [18]). The estimation of the variance of regional yield requires the spatial correlation of the simulated yields to be assessed. The close correspondence of the weather characteristics of the sites means that they can be grouped together. Since the topography of the region is fairly homogeneous, the whole region’s weather can be represented by just one site. There is a slight temperature gradient from north to south and a precipitation gradient from west to east for the three sites. Hence, a centrally situated site would be the most representative. However, the weather database does not contain such a site with observed weather data for 1960–90 and so, instead, the site of Oxford was chosen as it has a complete record and site climate change scenarios are available.
SCALING IN INTEGRATED ASSESSMENT 145
The input parameters used for the three sites were the same and so the differences in synthetic yield are entirely due to the different weather data at the three sites. The analysis of the weather data indicated that the systematic differences were small and so the region could be considered as experiencing a single climate. Furthermore, the random differences were not sufficiently great that they needed to be modelled explicitly. The comparison of yields supports this conclusion with small differences between the sites. The sensitivity analysis showed that small random differences in weather could produce significant differences in yield and, thus, the differences in yield observed here are consistent with small random differences between the sites. The recorded regional yield data only covers the period 1974–1979 and 1983–1995 and will be influenced by a number of factors that are not included in this study, particularly the effects of pests and diseases and changes in management practices and technology. This prevents a meaningful comparison with the mean and standard deviation of yields modelled for central England. However, a limited validation can be made by examining the yield pattern across the region. Actual yields should contain a climate signal and a comparison of regional yields across Britain shows that there are strong correlations between yields of nearby regions. This is consistent with the model analysis in that yield is related to cumulative values of the climate variables and that many of the relationships are approximately linear so that the relationship of yield to climate should not have large discontinuities. The similarity of the climate across Britain means that there should not be large differences in the climate related effects on yield. The methodology produces the most accurate prediction of the regional yield variance by combining the weather generated climate scenarios and the observed climate data. However, this prevents an analysis of the distribution of regional yields or of the statistical significance of the results. An indication of the likely shape of the distribution of regional yield can be obtained from the observed data by multiplying the predicted yields for each year for the three soil types by the soil relative area values to give a simulated regional yield. The lack of data (only 30 values) and the fact that the climate change scenario does not include changes in variability limits the value of such results. The simulated regional yield distributions for the observed data and for the observed data adjusted for the two scenarios of climate change are slightly negatively skewed. The skewness probably results from several of the years being at or close to potential yield so that variations in water deficit between those years have no effect on yield. Uniform grid approach The most common approach to linking GIS and crop models is to convert all of the input data into raster grid databases with uniform pixel size and geographical co-ordinates. The original data need to be interpolated to the
146 SCALING METHODS IN REGIONAL INTEGRATED ASSESSMENTS
raster grid. Data with irregular boundaries such as soil data are forced to match the grid. The site-based crop model (or a simplified version) is then applied consecutively to each grid cell in the region. The resolution is generally chosen based on the availability of data, resulting size of database and computing resources. Ideally the resolution would reflect the sensitivity of model results to spatial variation and discontinuities as well as corresponding to the accuracy of the input data. Recent examples of this method are studies that have applied complex site crop models to relatively fine grids at national scales. Carter et al. [19] applied the CERES-Wheat and POTATOS site-based crop models to data held in a network of 3827 grid boxes at a 10 × 10 km resolution across Finland. The application of simplified and complex site models to gridded input data has been deomonstrated by Rounsevell et al. [20]. The European study in CLIVARA also used this approach by applying a simplified crop model to gridded climatological and soil data [21]. Gridded models generally require converting site models to a regional scale model and using aggregated regional inputs. Model parameters and inputs need to be scaled, by running the model throughout the region either by using interpolated inputs or by dividing the region into sub-regions with the same characteristics. At the site level, detailed crop-climate models simulate plant responses to a wide variety of environmental and management changes. These results are used to calibrate parameters in more generic, reduced-form models that run on the spatial data (e.g., EuroWheat at the European scale [21]. Brisson et al. [22] studied large scale spatial variations in maize suitability in France. The main aim was to build a crop model (GOA-Maize) with the minimum of biological detail needed to produce useful information for decision making and which is able to use readily available input data. The model was applied to climatic data on a ten-day time step at a gridded resolution of 20 km2. Brignall and Rounsevell [23] developed a simple model to assess the effects of climate change on winter wheat potential in England and Wales. This classified crop performance into well-suited, moderate, marginal or unsuited based on calculations of machinery work days and drought stress. Two reduced-form models were developed by Wolf [24, 25] and compared with output from complex site-based models under current and future climatic conditions. The POTATOS reduced-form potato model was compared with the NPOTATO site model, whilst the SOYBEANW reduced-form soya bean model was compared with the SOYGRO site model. Result