Rotation and Accretion
Powered Pulsars
WORLD SCIENTIFIC SERIES IN ASTRONOMY AND ASTROPHYSICS Editor: Jayant V. Narli...
207 downloads
1616 Views
9MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Rotation and Accretion
Powered Pulsars
WORLD SCIENTIFIC SERIES IN ASTRONOMY AND ASTROPHYSICS Editor: Jayant V. Narlikar Inter-University Centre for Astronomy and Astrophysics, Pune, India
Published: Volume 1:
Lectures on Cosmology and Action at a Distance Electrodynamics F. Hoyle and J. V. Narlikar
Volume 2:
Physics of Comets (2nd Ed.) K. S. Krishna Swamy
Volume 3:
Catastrophes and Comets* V. Clube and B. Napier
Volume 4:
From Black Clouds to Black Holes (2nd Ed.) J. V. Narlikar
Volume 5:
Solar and Interplanetary Disturbances S. K. Alurkar
Volume 6:
Fundamentals of Solar Astronomy A. Bhatnagar and W. Livingston
Volume 7:
Dust in the Universe: Similarities and Differences K. S. Krishna Swamy
Volume 8:
An Invitation to Astrophysics T. Padmanabhan
Volume 9:
Stardust from Meteorites: An Introduction to Presolar Grains M. Lugaro
Volume 11:
Find a Hotter Place!: A History of Nuclear Astrophysics L. M. Celnikier
*Publication cancelled.
Magdalene - Rotation and Accretion.pmd
2
2/13/2007, 2:10 PM
World Scientific Series in Astronomy and Astrophysics – Vol. 10
@]bObW]\O\R/QQ`SbW]\
>]eS`SR>cZaO`a Pranab Ghosh
Tata Institute of Fundamental Research, India
World Scientific NEW JERSEY
•
LONDON
•
SINGAPORE
•
BEIJING
•
SHANGHAI
•
HONG KONG
•
TA I P E I
•
CHENNAI
Published by World Scientific Publishing Co. Pte. Ltd. 5 Toh Tuck Link, Singapore 596224 USA office: 27 Warren Street, Suite 401-402, Hackensack, NJ 07601 UK office: 57 Shelton Street, Covent Garden, London WC2H 9HE
British Library Cataloguing-in-Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library.
Cover figure: Chandra X-ray image of the Crab pulsar and nebula. Reproduced with permission from CXC Education/Outreach Co-ordinator.
World Scientific Series in Astronomy and Astrophysics — Vol. 10 ROTATION AND ACCRETION POWERED PULSARS Copyright © 2007 by World Scientific Publishing Co. Pte. Ltd. All rights reserved. This book, or parts thereof, may not be reproduced in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording or any information storage and retrieval system now known or to be invented, without written permission from the Publisher.
For photocopying of material in this volume, please pay a copying fee through the Copyright Clearance Center, Inc., 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923, USA. In this case permission to photocopy is not required from the publisher.
ISBN-13 978-981-02-4744-7 ISBN-10 981-02-4744-3
Printed in Singapore.
Magdalene - Rotation and Accretion.pmd
1
2/13/2007, 2:10 PM
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
To the Memory of My Parents
Verba docent, exempla trahunt.
v
pranab
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
This page intentionally left blank
pranab
February 13, 2007
15:0
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
Preface
“The truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth,” observes a character in Aldous Huxley’s The Genius and the Goddess, “All witnesses take the same oath, and testify about the same events. The result, of course, is fifty-seven varieties of fiction.” We forget all too often that this describes not only witnesses and artists, but scientists as well. We describe what is piously believed to be objective truth, but the outcome is necessarily our view of that truth. This book grew out of my desire to communicate to a wide scientific readership in a simple, accessible way the unifying overview we have begun to achieve in recent years of rotation- and accretion-powered pulsars — the phases that rotating, magnetic neutron stars go through during their lives. The basic facts are scattered far and wide over professional scientific literature, but the manner in which I collect and present them reflects my own overview of the subject, as it must. For a long time, it has been clear that, while there were classic, pioneering text-books on rotationpowered pulsars, and excellent individual chapters on X-ray binaries within collective volumes, the unified view was not really available as an advanced text book. And yet, this overview is one of the milestones in modern highenergy astrophysics. It is my hope that this book will fill that void. It has been my pleasure and privilege to learn from many fine physicists over the years, and their gifts to my mind will be felt throughout the book. I am proud of this. Among them, the name of Prof. Frederick K. Lamb is one that I always mention with great pleasure and honor. While writing the book, I have marveled at how various branches of physics blend beautifully to give us a comprehensive description of the physics of rotating, magnetic neutron stars and their environments. While this synthesis may be found to a certain extent in many parts of astrophysics, that of rotation- and accretion-powered pulsars seems to be a remarkably strong example. vii
pranab
January 10, 2007
viii
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
pranab
Rotation and Accretion Powered Pulsars
For motivation and fruition of this project, appreciation and acknowledgment of a deep debt of gratitude go to my late parents, and to my wife Surita. That thirst for knowledge which the former propagated into me has been the ultimate motive power behind all my work. This book owes a great deal to Surita’s constant inspiration and encouragement, and to her unflinching support and endless patience while it was being written.
Pranab Ghosh 2006
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
Acknowledgments
Permissions for reproduction of previously-published figures have been obtained as follows. Permissions were obtained from sole/lead authors (and/or other authors where appropriate), the author names being given in the respective figure captions, and full references, e.g., journal/proceedings/book names, volume and page numbers, given in the Bibliography. Permissions were also obtained from the appropriate publishers/permission-granting authorities of these publications, as detailed in the following table. In case none of the authors of a publication was available or alive, only the latter permission could be obtained. We thank all such authors and publishers/permission-granting authorities for their kind permission, and display the appropriate copyright sign and/or other material in respective figure captions for those who require it as per terms and conditions. Those authors who showed further kindness by providing us with copies of their figures are much appreciated, and mentioned in the respective figure captions.
Table 1
PERMISSIONS
Figure(s)
Publisher/Permission-granting authority
Book cover
Chandra X-ray Center Education/Outreach Co-ordinator
2.1,2.4,7.13,7.15,7.16,13.4 3.1,4.18,4.19,6.1,9.1,9.12,9.13 9.23 2.3 9.7,9.8,9.22,9.18 4.9,4.10,4.11,4.14,7.19,B.1,D.1
Blackwell Publishing, Oxford Annual Reviews, Palo Alto Revista Mexicana de Astron. y Astrofis. Taylor & Francis Ltd, Oxford Astronomical Society of Japan Elsevier B.V., Amsterdam & Oxford
ix
pranab
January 10, 2007
16:24
x
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
Rotation and Accretion Powered Pulsars
Table 1
PERMISSIONS (continued)
Figure(s)
Publisher/Permission-granting authority
1.4,7.10 6.8 6.6,11.2 2.5,4.8,4.12,4.15,4.16,5.5,5.7,5.9,6.4,7.23 7.14,7.20,7.22,11.1 7.1,7.2,7.3 7.24,10.30 8.1 9.26 14.1,8.3,8.4,8.5,5.1,5.3,10.6,10.16 5.6,10.20,9.19,9.21,7.6,5.11,5.12 5.13,9.11,10.5,10.15,10.17,5.14 10.21,11.4,6.3,5.10,7.12,1.5,9.10 5.2,5.4,5.15,1.10,1.9,11.8,10.22 10.23,10.29,9.15,9.24,11.6,11.7 9.20,7.6,10.12,10.26,10.27,10.28 1.2,1.3,9.25,10.2,10.8,10.9,7.23 9.3,1.7,7.4,7.5,7.19,7.22,9.6,9.9 7.17,10.10,10.13,10.18,10.19,12.1 12.2,12.3,12.4,10.3,10.4,10.14,12.6
IEEE Astronomical Society of the Pacific International Astronomical Union American Physical society The Royal Society, London W.H. Freeman & Co., New York Societ` a Astronomica Italiana Progress of Theoretical Physics M. Sako & G. Branduardi-Raymont
American Astronomical Society
6.16 9.5,9.14,9.16,9.17,7.8,10.1,13.5,6.10 7.11
AAAS Cambridge University Press Koninklijke Nederlandse Akad. Wetensch.
6.2,6.7,6.9,6.11,6.12,6.13,9.2,8.2 10.24,11.5,10.3,10.4,10.14,12.6
Springer Science and Business Media
6.14,6.15,13.3 5.8 B.3 6.5 1.1 11.3 C.1 12.5 A.2
MacMillan Publishers Ltd H. Heiselberg M. van der Sluys K. Kifonidis The Nobel Foundation The University of Chicago ATNF Outreach Indian Acad. Sci. Princeton University Press
pranab
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
pranab
Contents
Preface
vii
Acknowledgments
ix
1. The 1.1 1.2 1.3
Discovery of Pulsars Rotation-Powered Pulsars: Radio Discovery . . Accretion-Powered Pulsars: X-Ray Discovery . . Pulsars as Neutron Stars . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.3.1 Rotation-Powered Pulsars . . . . . . . . 1.3.2 Accretion-Powered Pulsars . . . . . . . 1.4 Powering Pulsars by Rotation and Accretion . . 1.4.1 Rotation Power . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.4.2 Accretion Power . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.5 Galactic Distributions of Pulsars . . . . . . . . . 1.5.1 Rotation-Powered Pulsars . . . . . . . . 1.5.1.1 Pulsar distances . . . . . . . 1.5.1.2 Galactic electron distribution 1.5.1.3 Galactic pulsar distribution . 1.5.1.4 Selection effects . . . . . . . . 1.5.2 Accretion-Powered Pulsars . . . . . . . 1.6 Period Distributions of Pulsars . . . . . . . . . .
2. Physics of Neutron Stars — I. Degenerate 2.1 Historical Notes on Neutron Stars . 2.2 Degenerate Stars . . . . . . . . . . . 2.2.1 Degeneracy . . . . . . . . . 2.2.2 Electron Degeneracy . . . . xi
Stars . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
1 1 4 10 10 14 17 17 20 24 24 26 27 31 32 34 34
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
39 39 47 47 50
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
pranab
Rotation and Accretion Powered Pulsars
xii
2.3
2.4
2.5
2.6
2.2.3 Neutron Degeneracy . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.2.4 Complete Degeneracy . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The Landau Arguments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.3.1 Degenerate Stars: Rough Mass Limits . . . . . 2.3.2 Degenerate Stars: Mass-Radius Relations . . . White Dwarfs . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.4.1 The Stoner-Anderson Work . . . . . . . . . . . 2.4.2 Polytropes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.4.3 Chandrasekhar’s Work . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.4.4 Modern Work . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Neutron Stars . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.5.1 The Oppenheimer-Volkoff Work . . . . . . . . 2.5.2 A General-Relativistic “Toy” Neutron Star . . Landau Arguments: General-Relativistic Modifications
. . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . .
51 51 53 58 59 60 61 65 68 75 80 81 88 91
3. Physics of Neutron Stars — II. Physics of Dense Matter-1 3.1 Matter at Low Densities: Electronic Energy . . . . . . . 3.1.1 Wigner-Seitz Cells . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.1.2 The Thomas-Fermi Approximation . . . . . . . . 3.2 Dense Matter Below Neutron-Drip Density: Equilibrium Nuclei . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.2.1 Effects of Lattice Energy . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.2.2 Nuclear Shell Effects . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.3 Neutron Drip . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.4 Matter Above Neutron-Drip Density: Nuclei Surrounded by Neutrons . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.4.1 Nuclear Surface Energy: A Primer . . . . . . . . 3.4.2 BBP Results . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.4.3 More Accurate Results . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.4.4 Simple Scalings . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
97 . 97 . 98 . 101 . . . .
104 110 113 116
. . . . .
118 121 125 126 128
4. Physics of Neutron Stars — III. Physics of Dense Matter-2 4.1 Above Nuclear-Matter Density: Uniform Nuclear Matter 4.1.1 The Goldstone Expansion . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.1.2 Goldstone Diagrams . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.1.2.1 First-order diagrams . . . . . . . . . . 4.1.2.2 Second-order diagrams . . . . . . . . . 4.1.3 Brueckner’s Reaction Matrix . . . . . . . . . . . 4.1.4 Correlations and “Healing” . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
131 131 134 137 138 139 141 145
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
pranab
Contents
4.1.5 4.1.6
4.1.7
Brueckner-Bethe-Goldstone (BBG) Theory . . . The Variational Method . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.1.6.1 Cluster diagrams . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.1.6.2 Modern calculations . . . . . . . . . . Recent Developments in BBG and Variational Approaches . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.1.7.1 Relativistic effects in Brueckner theory 4.1.7.2 Relativistic effects in variational methods . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.1.7.3 Recent results . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
5. Physics of Neutron Stars — IV. Mass, Radius and Structure 5.1 Masses and Radii . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.1.1 Insensitivity of Radius to Mass . . . . . . . . . . 5.2 Internal Structure . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.2.1 Crustal Properties: Mass and Radius . . . . . . 5.3 Non-Spherical Shapes: Rods and Plates . . . . . . . . . . 5.3.1 Turning Nuclei “Inside Out” . . . . . . . . . . . 5.3.2 Physical Insights: Frustrated Fission . . . . . . . 5.3.3 Uncertainties . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.4 The Maximum Mass of Neutron Stars . . . . . . . . . . . 5.4.1 The Maximum Compactness . . . . . . . . . . . 5.4.2 The Maximum Mass . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.5 Rotating Neutron Stars . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.5.1 The Hartle-Thorne Approximation . . . . . . . . 5.5.2 Arbitrary Rotation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.5.3 Maximum and Minimum Rotation . . . . . . . . 5.5.3.1 The mass-shed limit . . . . . . . . . . 5.5.3.2 The gravitation-wave limit . . . . . . . 5.5.3.3 The r-mode . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.5.3.4 The supramassive-collapse limit . . . . 5.5.3.5 Maximum angular velocity of neutron stars . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.5.4 Hartle-Thorne Approximation: Reprise . . . . . 5.5.5 Moments of Inertia . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.5.5.1 Crustal moment of inertia . . . . . . .
xiii
. . . .
150 154 158 161
. 164 . 168 . 170 . 171
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
173 173 179 180 183 186 188 189 190 192 192 195 198 200 202 205 205 207 209 210
. . . .
212 214 215 218
6. Origin and Evolution of Neutron Stars 221 6.1 Binary Stellar Evolution . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 221
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
pranab
Rotation and Accretion Powered Pulsars
xiv
6.1.1 6.1.2
6.2
6.3
6.4
6.5
Cases A, B, and C . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Orbital Changes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.1.2.1 Conservative mass transfer . . . . . . . 6.1.2.2 Non-conservative mass transfer . . . . . 6.1.3 Stellar Evolution . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.1.3.1 Conservative evolution . . . . . . . . . . 6.1.3.2 Common-envelope (CE) evolution . . . Supernovae: Birth of Neutron Stars . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.2.1 Final Evolution of Helium Stars and Cores . . . . 6.2.2 Core Collapse: Neutron Star Formation . . . . . . 6.2.3 Core Bounce: Supernova Explosion . . . . . . . . 6.2.3.1 Explosion mechanisms . . . . . . . . . . 6.2.3.2 Orbital changes due to supernova explosions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.2.4 Evolution of Proto-Neutron Stars . . . . . . . . . . Rotation Power in Young Pulsars . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.3.1 Missing Links: Ante-Deluvian Systems . . . . . . . 6.3.2 Probes of Be-Star Outflow: PSR B1259-63 . . . . 6.3.2.1 The Shvartsman surface . . . . . . . . . 6.3.2.2 Propeller spindown . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.3.2.3 Tilted Be-star disks . . . . . . . . . . . 6.3.2.4 Recent work: further orbital dynamics . Accretion Power in Middle-Aged Pulsars . . . . . . . . . . 6.4.1 Evolution to Massive X-Ray Binaries . . . . . . . 6.4.2 Evolution to Intermediate-Mass X-Ray Binaries . 6.4.3 Evolution to Low-Mass X-Ray Binaries . . . . . . 6.4.3.1 CVs . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.4.3.2 LMXBs . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Rotation Power in Old, Recycled Pulsars . . . . . . . . . . 6.5.1 Final Evolution of HMXBs and Recycling . . . . . 6.5.1.1 Recycled pulsars: single or with degenerate companions . . . . . . . . . . 6.5.2 The Double Pulsar Binary J0737-3039 . . . . . . . 6.5.3 Final Evolution of LMXBs and Recycling . . . . . 6.5.3.1 Gravitational radiation . . . . . . . . . . 6.5.3.2 Magnetic braking . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.5.3.3 The minimum period and the period gap 6.5.3.4 Donor evolution and expansion . . . . . 6.5.3.5 Recycled pulsars from LMXBs . . . . .
222 225 225 226 228 229 231 234 235 238 239 241 244 246 250 252 252 253 255 256 258 259 260 263 264 264 266 272 274 276 280 282 287 287 289 291 294
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
pranab
Contents
6.5.4 6.5.5 6.5.6 6.5.7
Missing Links: Accreting Millisecond Pulsars Irradiation of Low-Mass Companions . . . . Missing Links: “Black Widow” Pulsars . . . Pulsars with Planets . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
xv
. . . .
7. Properties of Rotation Powered Pulsars 7.1 Pulse Properties . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.1.1 Integrated Pulse Profiles . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.1.1.1 Pulse shapes . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.1.1.2 Interpulses . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.1.1.3 Polarization . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.1.1.4 The rotating vector model . . . . . . 7.1.1.5 Frequency dependence and stability 7.1.2 Individual Pulses . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.1.2.1 Intensity variations and nulling . . . 7.1.2.2 Subpulse drifting . . . . . . . . . . . 7.1.2.3 Micropulses . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.1.2.4 Giant pulses . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.2 Timing Properties . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.2.1 Pulsar Timing . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.2.2 Secular Period Changes . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.2.2.1 Characteristic age . . . . . . . . . . 7.2.2.2 Braking index . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.2.2.3 Higher derivatives . . . . . . . . . . 7.2.3 Irregular Period Changes . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.2.3.1 Timing noise . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.2.3.2 Millisecond pulsars as stable clocks . 7.2.3.3 Limits on cosmic gravitational wave background . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.2.3.4 Glitches . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.2.3.5 Glitches: starquakes . . . . . . . . . 7.2.4 Timing Rotation Powered Pulsars in Binaries . 7.2.4.1 PSR 1913+16: historical notes . . . 7.2.4.2 Binary rotation-powered pulsars: general systematics . . . . . . . . . . 7.2.4.3 PSR 1913+16: nursery of relativistic gravity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.2.4.4 PSR 1534+12 and similar “relativity laboratories” . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . .
. . . .
296 301 302 304
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
307 307 308 308 308 310 313 313 315 315 318 319 321 323 323 328 329 331 332 333 333 336
. . . . .
. . . . .
342 344 349 354 359
. . 361 . . 365 . . 371
January 10, 2007
xvi
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
pranab
Rotation and Accretion Powered Pulsars
7.2.4.5 7.2.4.6
The double-pulsar binary as relativity laboratory . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 373 A related “fundamental” effect . . . . . 375
8. Superfluidity in Neutron Stars and Glitch Diagnostics 8.1 Superfluidity in Neutron Stars . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.1.1 Pairing . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.1.2 Gap Energy . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.1.3 Rotating Superfluids and Quantized Vortices 8.2 Post-Glitch Relaxation: Two-Component Theory . . 8.3 Glitches: Vortex Pinning . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.3.1 The Pinning Force . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.3.2 Strong and Weak Pinning . . . . . . . . . . . 8.3.3 The Magnus Force . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.4 Post-Glitch Relaxation: Vortex Creep . . . . . . . . . 8.4.1 Rotational Dynamics: Steady State . . . . . 8.4.2 Approach to Steady State . . . . . . . . . . . 8.5 Stellar Parameters from Glitch Data . . . . . . . . . . 8.6 Glitches: Recent Developments . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . .
377 377 378 380 382 386 387 389 391 394 395 398 400 405 409
9. Properties of Accretion Powered Pulsars 9.1 Binary Characteristics . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9.1.1 Displaying Binary Systematics . . . . 9.1.2 Newtonian Apsidal Motion . . . . . . 9.1.3 Orbital Period Changes . . . . . . . . 9.1.4 Neutron-Star and Companion Masses 9.2 Pulse Profiles . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9.3 Secular Period Changes . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9.4 Timing Noise . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9.4.1 Power-Density Spectra . . . . . . . . . 9.4.1.1 Observed power spectra . . 9.4.2 Time-Domain Analysis . . . . . . . . 9.5 Quasi-Periodic Oscillations (QPOs) . . . . . . 9.5.1 QPOs in LMXBs . . . . . . . . . . . . 9.5.1.1 Low-frequency QPOs . . . . 9.5.1.2 High-frequency QPOs . . . 9.5.1.3 LF QPO diagnostics . . . . 9.5.1.4 HF QPO diagnostics . . . . 9.5.2 QPOs in HMXBs . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
413 414 417 419 423 426 429 432 440 443 445 449 451 451 451 455 456 458 464
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
pranab
Contents
9.6
9.7
xvii
X-Ray 9.6.1 9.6.2 9.6.3 9.6.4
Spectra . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Continuum Emission . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Pulse-Phase Spectroscopy . . . . . . . . . . . . Cyclotron Features . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Emission Lines: Fluorescence, Recombination, Resonance . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9.6.4.1 Fluorescence . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9.6.4.2 X-ray ionization of stellar winds . . 9.6.4.3 Observations . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9.6.4.4 Recombination . . . . . . . . . . . . 9.6.4.5 Recent observations . . . . . . . . . 9.6.4.6 Wind diagnostics . . . . . . . . . . . Mutants: Anomalous X-Ray Pulsars (AXPs) . . . . . .
10. Pulsar Magnetospheres 10.1 Magnetospheres of Accretion-Powered Pulsars . . . . 10.1.1 Exterior Flow and Plasma Capture . . . . . . 10.1.1.1 Capture from stellar winds . . . . 10.1.1.2 Fluctuations in stellar winds . . . 10.1.1.3 Capture from Roche-lobe overflow 10.1.2 Formation of Magnetospheres . . . . . . . . . 10.1.2.1 Lengthscales of magnetospheres . . 10.1.3 Radial Flow . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.1.3.1 Size of the magnetosphere . . . . . 10.1.3.2 The shock . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.1.3.3 Shape of the magnetosphere . . . . 10.1.3.4 Magnetospheric boundary with accretion flow . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.1.4 Disk Flow . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.1.5 Thin Keplerian Accretion Disks . . . . . . . 10.1.5.1 One temperature disks . . . . . . . 10.1.5.2 The α-model of disk viscosity . . . 10.1.5.3 The nature of disk viscosity . . . . 10.1.5.4 The structure of α-disks . . . . . . 10.1.5.5 Two temperature disks . . . . . . . 10.1.6 The Disk-Magnetosphere Interaction . . . . . 10.1.6.1 Basic electrodynamic processes . . 10.1.6.2 Steady flow models . . . . . . . . .
. . . .
. . . .
465 466 469 471
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
474 474 477 481 482 485 489 490
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
495 495 496 497 504 505 508 511 513 515 517 518
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
524 525 525 527 529 531 534 538 542 543 548
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
pranab
Rotation and Accretion Powered Pulsars
xviii
10.1.7
Disk-Magnetosphere Boundary Layer . . . . . . 10.1.7.1 Boundary-layer behavior . . . . . . . . 10.1.7.2 Boundary-layer: nature and structure 10.1.8 Inner Edge of the Disk . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.1.9 Outer Transition Zone . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.1.10 Further Work . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.1.11 Plasma Entry into Magnetospheres: Radial Flow 10.1.11.1 Entry via Rayleigh-Taylor instability . 10.1.11.2 Cusp entry . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.1.11.3 Entry by other modes . . . . . . . . . 10.1.12 Plasma Entry into Magnetospheres: Disk Flow . 10.1.13 Accretion Flows Inside Magnetospheres . . . . . 10.1.13.1 Field-aligned flow . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.1.13.2 Flow “between” field lines . . . . . . . 10.1.14 Accretion on Stellar Surface: Stopping Mechanisms . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.1.14.1 Radiative stopping . . . . . . . . . . . 10.1.14.2 Collisional stopping . . . . . . . . . . 10.2 Magnetospheres of Rotation-Powered Pulsars . . . . . . . 10.2.1 The Goldreich-Julian Argument . . . . . . . . . 10.2.2 The Aligned Rotator . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.2.2.1 The pulsar equation . . . . . . . . . . 10.2.2.2 Convergence . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.2.2.3 Results . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.2.3 Problems with the Standard Model . . . . . . . 10.2.4 Vacuum Gaps . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.2.4.1 Ruderman-Sutherland gaps . . . . . . 10.2.5 The Oblique Rotator . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.2.6 The Double-Pulsar Binary as Magnetospheric Probe . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11. Pulsar Emission Mechanisms 11.1 Emission by Rotation-Powered Pulsars 11.1.1 Coherent Emission . . . . . . . 11.1.2 Emission by Bunches . . . . . 11.1.3 Maser Emission . . . . . . . . 11.1.4 Relativistic Plasma Emission .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . .
552 556 558 560 564 566 569 570 576 578 580 581 582 588
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
592 592 596 597 598 602 605 606 607 610 612 616 623
. 625
. . . . .
629 629 630 632 633 635
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
pranab
Contents
xix
11.2 Emission by Accretion-Powered Pulsars . . . . . . . . 11.2.1 Radiation Transport in Strongly Magnetized Plasmas . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11.2.1.1 Basic radiative processes . . . . . . 11.2.1.2 Transport calculations . . . . . . . 11.2.1.3 Results . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11.2.2 Pulse Shapes and Spectra . . . . . . . . . . . 12. Spin Evolution of Neutron Stars 12.1 Spin Evolution of Rotation-Powered Pulsars 12.1.1 Electromagnetic Spindown . . . . . 12.1.2 Propeller Spindown . . . . . . . . . 12.1.3 Other Spindown Torques . . . . . . 12.1.4 Spindown of PSR B1259-63 . . . . . 12.2 Spin Evolution of Accretion-Powered Pulsars 12.2.1 Torques on Disk-Fed Pulsars . . . . 12.2.2 Comparison with Observations . . . 12.2.3 Torques on Wind-Fed Pulsars . . . . 12.3 Pulsar Period — Magnetic Field Diagram . . 12.3.1 The Spinup Line . . . . . . . . . . . 12.3.2 Disk Diagnostics: Spinup Lines . . .
. . . 637 . . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
638 640 643 645 645
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
649 649 649 650 652 653 656 656 661 665 666 669 672
13. Neutron Star Magnetic Fields 13.1 Exotic Atoms in Strong Magnetic Fields . . . . . . . . 13.1.1 Further Exotica: Molecular Chains . . . . . . 13.2 Origin of Neutron-Star Magnetic Fields . . . . . . . . . 13.2.1 Fossil Fields . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13.2.2 Thermo-Magnetic Effects . . . . . . . . . . . . 13.2.3 Dynamos in Young Neutron Stars: Magnetars 13.3 Evolution of Neutron-Star Magnetic Fields . . . . . . . 13.3.1 Accretion-Induced Field Decay . . . . . . . . . 13.3.1.1 Ohmic decay . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13.3.2 Field Decay or Hiding/Burial? . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
675 675 679 681 681 681 682 685 686 687 690
14. Strange Stars 14.1 EOS of Strange Matter . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14.2 Structure of Strange Stars . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14.3 Search for Strange Stars . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
693 694 694 696
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
January 10, 2007
16:24
xx
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
pranab
Rotation and Accretion Powered Pulsars
Appendix A Astronomical Preliminaries A.1 Units . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A.2 Astronomical Co-Ordinate Systems . A.2.1 Equatorial Co-Ordinates . . A.2.2 Precession of Equinoxes . . . A.2.3 Galactic Co-Ordinates . . . . A.2.4 Co-Ordinate Transformation A.2.5 Time Keeping . . . . . . . . A.2.6 Stellar Classification . . . . . A.2.6.1 Color Index . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
699 699 700 700 702 703 705 705 706 706
Appendix B Binary Dynamics B.1 Binary Orbit . . . . . . . B.1.1 Orbital Elements B.1.2 Mass Function . B.1.3 Position in Orbit B.2 Roche Lobes . . . . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
709 709 709 710 711 712
Appendix C Single Star Evolution C.1 The Hertzsprung-Russell Diagram C.2 Stellar Evolution . . . . . . . . . . C.2.1 Hydrogen Burning . . . . C.2.2 Helium Burning . . . . . C.2.3 Advanced Burning Stages C.2.4 Essential Timescales . . . C.2.5 Mass-Radius Relations . . C.2.6 Brown Dwarfs . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
717 717 719 720 722 722 722 723 724
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
Appendix D The Two-Nucleon Potential 725 D.1 Skyrme Interaction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 728 Appendix E Tables of Pulsars 731 E.1 Accretion Powered Pulsars and AXPs . . . . . . . . . . . . 731 Bibliography
735
Index
761
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
Chapter 1
The Discovery of Pulsars
1.1
Rotation-Powered Pulsars: Radio Discovery
There is no doubt today that the 1967 discovery of rotation-powered pulsars at radio frequencies was the single most significant event responsible for the recognition of neutron stars as a physical reality rather than a brainchild of brilliant physicists. The idea of neutron stars was conceived in the 1930s following Chadwick’s discovery of the neutron1 , the possibility of their birth in supernovae proposed [Baade & Zwicky 1934a], and the first calculation of their masses and radii performed [Oppenheimer & Volkoff 1939]. After 1939, there was little interest in neutron stars for about two decades because (a) the original motivation for the study of neutron cores of stars as possible stellar energy sources had vanished with the acceptance of stellar thermonuclear reactions as this source of energy, and, (b) it was mistakenly thought (see Sec. 2.1) that neutron stars would not be able to form in the last stages of stellar evolution, because of a paradox which was not resolved until 1959 [Cameron 1959b]. A revival of interest in neutron stars in the 1960s was inspired largely by the discovery of discrete X-ray sources outside the solar system in 1962 [Giacconi et al. 1962], because these X-rays were thought at first to be thermal emission from newborn, hot neutron stars. Even in 1965, however, physicists writing papers on neutron stars tended to be somewhat skeptical at times, as illustrated by the following quote from Bahcall and Wolf (1965b): “In order to prevent the investigation of neutron stars from degenerating into a philosophical discussion, it is necessary to concentrate on those aspects of the theory which are at least in principle connected with observation.” 1 For
a brief historical account of neutron stars before 1967, see Sec. 2.1. 1
pranab
January 10, 2007
2
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
Rotation and Accretion Powered Pulsars
Then, in August-September 1967, a doctoral student named Jocelyn Bell at the University of Cambridge, who had just started operating a newly-constructed large dipole array (2048 dipole antennae spread over an area of 4.5 acres, operating at 81.5 MHz) for studying interplanetary scintillation of compact radio sources with her thesis supervisor Anthony Hewish, found “a bit of ‘scruff’ on the records” [Bell-Burnell 1977] of her chart recorder. Radio telescopes are extremely sensitive to man-made electromagnetic interference (from, e.g., automobile ignition or electrical farm equipment), but this did not look like interference; in addition, it came repeatedly from the same part of the sky [Bell-Burnell 1977]. On a recorder with a short response time ∼ 0.05 seconds, Bell’s “scruff” or fluctuations came out on November 28, 1967, to be a train of astounding, precisely periodic, pulses at a period of 1.337 seconds. Fig. 1.1 shows these pulses. Bell and Hewish investigated the pulses, painstakingly eliminating one possibility after another2 . The pulses were not from radar beams reflected off the moon. They were not from man-made satellites in unusual orbits, or deep space probes. In fact, since the pulses came about 4 minutes earlier
Fig. 1.1 Pulses from PSR 1919+21, the first rotation-powered pulsar, discovered in 1967. Note that this pulsar is referred to as CP 1919 in the figure, as per the customs of the time: CP stands for Cambridge pulsar. Reproduced with permission by the Nobel c 1975 The Nobel Foundation. Foundation from Hewish (1975). 2 Bell’s foresight and perseverance was instrumental to this, as the custom at the time in radio-astronomy circles was to dismiss such signals as man-made [Lyne & GrahamSmith 1990]. Bell’s own delightful account of the discovery [Bell-Burnell 1977] contains these words: “I contacted Tony Hewish who was teaching in an undergraduate laboratory in Cambridge, and his first reaction was that they must be man-made. This was a very sensible response under the circumstances, but due to a truly remarkable depth of ignorance I did not see why they could not be from a star.” We may well wonder where we would be today but for Bell’s “depth of ignorance”.
pranab
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
The Discovery of Pulsars
pranab
3
each night, i.e., kept to the sidereal time (see Appendix A), their source had to be far outside the solar system. An immediate and interesting possibility was that of communication signals deliberately sent out by an extraterrestrial civilization—the proverbial “little green men” of early science-fiction. But this alternative became improbable when careful Doppler-effect analysis of the period of the pulses revealed only our Earth’s motion around our Sun, and no trace of the further Doppler shift expected from the motion of the planet inhabited by these distant intelligent beings around their sun [Bell-Burnell 1977]. By late December, 1967, another pulsing radio source was discovered in a different part of the sky, making it clear that the phenomenon being observed was indeed natural radio emission. Studies of the dispersion of the radio signals established that the pulses were coming from within our galaxy, but outside the solar system. The first pulsar results were announced to the world in the journal Nature on February 24, 1968 [Hewish et al. 1968], and in a seminar that Hewish gave in Cambridge a few days before that. “Every astronomer in Cambridge, so it seemed, came to the seminar,” recalled Bell later, “and their interest and excitement gave me a first appreciation of the revolution we had started” [Bell-Burnell 1977]. The universal question was: what was the nature of these cosmic pulsing radio sources? Since a period ∼ 1.3 seconds was too short to be associated with the oscillations of a large, low-density, “normal” star, Hewish et al. immediately called attention to compact, high-density stars like white dwarfs and neutron stars, which are among the end-points of stellar evolution (see Chapter 6 and Appendix C), and whose frequencies of radial oscillation ran from about ten seconds to a small fraction of a second. A significant historical point, to which we come back in Sec. 2.1, is that the pulsar-discovery paper [Hewish et al. 1968] considered oscillations, not rotations, of compact stars as the probable cause of radio pulses. Radio astronomers all over the world now directed their telescopes and their attention to the discovery of more of these new pulsing radio sources, or “pulsars”, as they came to be called. New pulsars were found in profusion, in particular two fast-rotating pulsars in supernova remnants: the Crab pulsar (with a period of 33 milliseconds) and the Vela pulsar (with a period of 89 milliseconds). This opened up a new, rich field of study in astronomy and astrophysics. Identification of pulsars with rotating neutron stars, which was established within about a year and a half (see Sec. 1.3) following the seminal paper by Gold (1968), led to torrential theoretical work in the 1970s on every conceivable aspect of neutron stars: internal structure, surface properties, origin, and evolution (see Chapters
January 10, 2007
4
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
Rotation and Accretion Powered Pulsars
2 and 3). In addition, attempts to understand the properties of rotationand accretion-powered pulsars (see Chapters 7, 8 and 9) led to fundamental work on the electrodynamics and plasma (i.e., ionized gas) dynamics near rotating, magnetic, compact stars (see Chapter 10), and on theories of gravitation . In recognition of the profound impact on physics of the discovery of rotation-powered pulsars, Hewish shared3 the 1974 Nobel Prize in Physics: he was cited for “his pioneering research in radio astrophysics, particularly the discovery of pulsars”. More than 1700 rotation-powered pulsars are known today: as it is not practicable to list their essential parameters in this book, we refer the reader to the Australia Telescope National Facility (ATNF) Pulsar Catalogue, available at the website: http://www.atnf.csiro.au/research/pulsar/psrcat. A uniform way of naming rotation-powered pulsars has emerged now. Each pulsar is identified by its position on the sky in terms of two angles, right ascension and declination (see Appendix A). The sequence of numbers specifying the angles is preceded by the letters PSR (for Pulsar, obviously, replacing older prefixes like CP for Cambridge Pulsar, etc). Thus, the first pulsar discovered [Hewish et al. 1968] is PSR 1919+21, the Crab pulsar is PSR 0531+21, the (Hulse-Taylor) binary pulsar is PSR 1913+16, the first millisecond pulsar discovered is PSR 1937+21, and so on. A slight modification has arisen in recent years because of the transition from the original 1950 coordinates to the current 2000 coordinates, which is explained in Appendix A. To distinguish between the two, the letter J is appended to the prefix PSR for the 2000 coordinates, and the letter B for the old 1950 ones, the nomenclature and the transformation between the two being given in Appendix A.
1.2
Accretion-Powered Pulsars: X-Ray Discovery
X-ray astronomy is a product of the space age, as X-rays from celestial sources are absorbed by the Earth’s atmosphere, and the only way of observing them is through detectors sent above the atmosphere in space vehicles4 . The subject started in 1949 with the detection of X-ray emission from the Sun by Geiger counters flown on a V-2 rocket captured at the end of the Second World War. Solar X-ray flux was so weak, however, 3 With Ryle, who won it also for achievements in radio astrophysics which lie outside the scope of this book. 4 High-altitude balloons can also be used to detect hard X-rays.
pranab
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
The Discovery of Pulsars
pranab
5
that observable X-ray emission from sources outside the solar system was not expected, based on the assumption that sun-like stars are the dominant X-ray sources in the universe. The absurdity of this assumption may be obvious to us today, but the atmosphere of skepticism was so persuasive in 1962 that the avowed purpose of the rocket flight of Giacconi and co-workers [Giacconi et al. 1962] had to be the detection of solar X-rays bouncing off the moon, while the real purpose was a search for extrasolar X-ray sources [Rossi 1973]. That Aerobee rocket flight became history: the counters on board detected a very bright X-ray source in the constellation of Scorpius (in addition to the expected X-ray fluorescence from the moon), giving birth to extrasolar X-ray astronomy, and showing, in Rossi’s (1973) words, “the boundless wealth and complexity of nature”. Between 1962 and 1970, about 50 cosmic X-ray sources were discovered by rocket and balloon flights: most of these were inside our Galaxy, but the first extragalactic X-ray source—the giant elliptical galaxy M87 in the Virgo cluster—was also discovered in the same era. It became customary to name the galactic X-ray sources by the constellation they were in, and the order in which they were discovered. Thus the first extrasolar source ever detected was called Scorpius X-1, or Sco X-1 for short, and so on. Accretion is a word which etymologically means “the process of growth or enlargement” by various means, in particular “by external addition or accumulation, as by external parts or particles”5. This meaning is slightly adapted in astrophysics to signify the gravitational capture by a star of the matter surrounding it (either matter through which it is passing, such as the interstellar medium or moecular clouds, or matter which is flowing toward it, such as that coming from its companion in a binary system), leading to an increase in the star’s mass. Study of accretion by the Sun and similar stars during their passage through diffuse gas, in contexts which are no longer of interest to us, goes back to Eddington (1930), who mistakenly thought that the geometrical size of the star was the capture radius, inside which all particles of matter (following trajectories somewhat “focused” toward the star by its gravitational attraction) were intercepted by the star and accreted by it. Hoyle and Lyttleton (1939a,b) introduced the essential physics, namely that at all gas densities of astrophysical interest, the collisions between particles greatly reduced their transverse momenta, much enhancing the effective capture radius, which depended basically on the stellar mass M and the relative velocity v between the star and the 5 From
the Latin accretus, past participle of the verb accrescere, to increase.
January 10, 2007
6
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
Rotation and Accretion Powered Pulsars
streaming matter, scaling as GM/v 2 , and usually exceeding the stellar radius by a large factor. This radius, now called the accretion radius, is a key parameter in the theory of accretion. The effects of the thermal energy content of the streaming gas on the accretion radius were included later. The potential significance of accretion by compact stars was emphasized in 1965 by Zel’dovich and Novikov, before the discovery of either rotationor accretion-powered pulsars. They clearly expressed their appreciation of the crucial point about accretion by neutron stars as follows: “However, the main stimulus for the study of accretion lies in the energy released during accretion. Particles incident on the surface of a neutron star give up to (0.2– 0.3) c2 of energy per gram, which is much more than can be obtained from nuclear reactions.” Zel’dovich and Novikov (1965) then went on to make the prophetic remark that “Connected with the accretion phenomenon is the very possibility of observing neutron and cooled stars...” (“cooled stars” was the name these authors used for black holes). As we know today, the 1962 discovery of Sco X-1 had, in fact, been the first clear detection of a neutron star powered by accretion. But this was not realized in 1965. The 1967 discovery of radio pulsars, powered by rotation, not accretion, and their rapid identification with neutron stars led to the first acceptance of the reality of these stars (see Sec. 1.1). The 1971 discovery of binary X-ray pulsars (see below) and their identification with accreting neutron stars finally made us aware of the abundant occurrence in nature of the phenomenon that Zel’dovich and Novikov had speculated on in 1965. For objects which are candidates for being black holes, emission powered by accretion remains our best observational probe to this day. An optical counterpart for Sco X-1 was found in 1966 [Sandage et al. 1966], a faint, blue star with excess ultraviolet emission, somewhat resembling an old nova. Novae were well-known to be binary stars, with evidence for gas streams flowing between the two stars. In 1967, Shklovskii proposed that Sco X-1 “is a neutron star forming a comparatively massive component of a close binary system”, and that “a stream of gas flowing out of the second component is permanently incident on the neutron star”, X-ray emission occurring from the hot gas in the stream. This pioneering6 6 Curiously, in a brief 1966 note, Zel’dovich and Guseynov had advocated the use of known single-line spectroscopic binaries to search for black holes and neutron stars, arguing that the optically-unseen companions in some of these binaries could be such objects. They had also made a casual comment that gas moving in the strong gravitational field of black holes could show spectral features in the X-rays. But these authors had not described sources powered by accretion, emitting primarily X-rays. This is amazing in the context of the 1965 Zel’dovich-Novikov work on accretion described in the previous paragraph.
pranab
February 8, 2007
15:39
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
The Discovery of Pulsars
pranab
7
scenario contained most of the essential ingredients of what later became the standard model of compact X-ray sources and accretion-powered pulsars, namely, (1) a neutron star or a black hole forming a binary stellar system with a “normal” companion star still burning thermonuclear fuel, (2) the companion transferring mass to the compact object by one or more of several possible mechanisms, and, (3) the gravitational energy released by matter accreting onto the compact object converted into electromagnetic radiation, primarily at X-ray wavelengths. In 1969, Zel’dovich and Shakura published the first quantitative, detailed calculation of the process of spherical accretion by neutron stars, and the spectrum of the X-rays emitted in the process, neglecting the magnetic field of the star. These authors started their paper with the remarkable statement “Neutron stars were born at the tip of the theoretician’s pen over 30 years ago7 , but a convincing identification of such a star has yet to be made”, although their paper was published in Russian in March-April 1969, by which time the rotating neutron-star model of radio pulsars was becoming accepted, as we described in Sec. 1.1. Zel’dovich and Shakura considered various mechanisms for deceleration and stopping of matter near the stellar surface, showing that the emergent X-ray spectrum depended both on this mechanism and on the accretion rate. The calculated spectra, which differed considerably from the Planck spectrum of a black body (particularly when the deceleration mechanism was collective plasma oscillations), was compared by them with the X-ray spectrum of Sco X-1 known at the time, after which they stated that only through such comparisons “might one be able to ascertain whether the observed point X-ray sources are in fact neutron stars, and whether neutron stars are entitled to pass from the realm of hypothetical objects into the class of reliably identified stars”. Apparently, these authors did not believe that rotation-powered pulsars already entitled neutron stars to join “the class of reliably identified stars”; the verdict of history turned out to be exactly contrary. X-ray astronomy really came into its own in 1970 with the launch of NASA’s first astronomy satellite Uhuru8 totally dedicated to surveying the X-ray sky in the energy range 2–20 keV, obtaining accurate positions (for its time) of the X-ray sources, and studying their spectra and time-variability. Uhuru discovered some 300 X-ray sources during its twenty-seven month 7 See
footnote 1. Swahili word meaning “freedom”: the satellite was launched off the coast of Kenya, on the independence day of that country. 8A
January 10, 2007
8
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
Rotation and Accretion Powered Pulsars
life-span, establishing a new branch of astronomy which was subsequently brought to its full glory of abundance and maturity by successive generations of X-ray satellites. In January 1971, about a month into the Uhuru mission, Giacconi and his co-authors noticed that a previously known X-ray source in the constellation of Centaurus, Cen X-3, was exhibiting periodic pulses. Based on the Uhuru data obtained in Januaray and April, 1971, these authors obtained a pulse period of 4.84 seconds, and published their result in July, 1971 [Giacconi et al. 1971]. This was the discovery of the first X-ray pulsar: Fig. 1.2 shows the Cen X-3 pulses. A second X-ray pulsar, Her X-1, was discovered in the constellation of Hercules by the end of 1971: it had a period of 1.24 second, and became one of the most widely studied accretion-powered pulsars [Tananbaum et al. 1972]. The binary nature of Cen X-3 soon became clear from the X-ray data gathered by Uhuru between January and December, 1971: the source underwent “regular changes in intensity between two distinct levels with a period of 2 days”, and its pulse-period underwent sinusoidal variations with the same period, correlated with the intensity variations [Schreier et al. 1972], as shown in Fig. 1.3. Schreier et al. wrote: We interpret this effect as due to an occulting binary system. The changes in intensity are then due to occultation of the X-ray source by a large massive companion, and the sinusoidal variations in the period of the 4.8 s pulsations are due to Doppler effect. The orbital period of the X-ray source is 2.08712 ± 0.00004 days. This interpretation became the standard picture of binary X-ray pulsars. The “large massive companion” in Cen X-3 was optically identified by Krzeminski (1973) to be an evolved supergiant star of spectral class late O (see Appendix A): it is now called Krzeminski’s star, or V779 Cen. Similar results followed quickly for Her X-1, with a binary period of 1.7 days
Fig. 1.2 Pulses from Cen X-3, the first accretion-powered pulsar, discovered in 1971. Reproduced by permission of the AAS from Schreier et al. (1972): see Bibliography.
pranab
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
The Discovery of Pulsars
pranab
9
Fig. 1.3 Orbital variation of the pulse-period and intensity of Cen X-3, indicating its binary nature. Reproduced by permission of the AAS from Schreier et al. (1972): see Bibliography.
[Tananbaum et al. 1972], and a relatively low-mass evolved (spectral class late A / early F) optical companion named HZ Her. Within about a year of their discovery, the X-ray emitting stars in these binary X-ray pulsars were argued to be neutron stars (see Sec. 1.3.2 for details), largely carrying over the expertise obtained a few years earlier in debating the case of rotation-powered pulsars. The idea that they were powered by accretion onto the neutron stars also came naturally [Pringle & Rees 1972; Davidson & Ostriker 1973; Lamb et al. 1973] in the wake of the discussion of accreting neutron stars which we have summarized above, and which had existed in the scientific literature for about seven years by then. Thus, the pioneering Shklovskii (1967) scenario for Sco X-1 blossomed into a full-fledged model for accretion-powered X-ray pulsars, which has become universally accepted today. Ironically, the binary nature of Sco X-1 itself was not established until 1975, and no X-ray pulses have yet been detected from this source. About 110 accretion-powered pulsars are known now, their periods ranging from 1.7 milliseconds to 9860 seconds: some of their essential parameters are lised in Table E.1. These form a subset of binary, accretionpowered, compact X-ray sources known today from several generation of
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
Rotation and Accretion Powered Pulsars
10
X-ray satellites over the last three decades, starting with Uhuru, and coming all the way to the current satellites RXTE, BeppoSAX, Chandra, and XMM-Newton. It is no longer convenient to list them by the constellations, and the modern nomenclature system for X-ray sources closely follows that for rotation-powered pulsars (see Sec. 1.1). The position on the sky is specified by right ascension and declination, and these numbers are preceded by an abbreviation for (usually) the name of the satellite that generated the catalog of X-ray sources (and, occasionally, the version of that catalog). Thus, Cen X-3, the first accretion-powered pulsar discovered, was named 4U 1119-60 in the 4th Uhuru catalog, and the recently-discovered 2.5 ms pulsar (which we discuss later at length because of its importance as an evolutionary link; see Sec. 6.5.4) was named SAX J1808.4-3658 or XTE J1808-359 after the satellites BeppoSAX and RXTE respectively. As position determinations become more accurate with succeeding generations of satellites, the numbers change slightly, and more significant digits are added. An alternative earlier system of using galactic co-ordintes (see Appendix A), in which the numbers were galactic longitude and latitude, preceded by the letters GX, has also been largely superseded. We may use it in this book occasionally for historical reasons. In recognition of his pioneering efforts in X-ray astronomy, his monumental efforts in developing this field to its present level of advancement, and his direct involvement in many of the finest discoveries in this field (including that of accretion-powered pulsars, which we are discussing in this book), Giacconi shared9 the 2002 Nobel Prize in Physics: he was cited for “pioneering contributions to astrophysics, which have led to the discovery of cosmic X-ray sources”.
1.3
Pulsars as Neutron Stars
1.3.1
Rotation-Powered Pulsars
In a Nature paper published almost exactly three months after the Hewish et al. (1968) discovery paper of radio pulsars, Gold (1968) made the pioneering, definitive suggestion that these objects were rotating neutron stars, the pulse period being the rotation period of the neutron star10 . Over a 9 With
Davis and Koshiba, who won it for their work in neutrino astrophysics. 1967, before the discovery of pulsars, Pacini had already described the emission of electromagnetic radiation from rotating, magnetized neutron stars in a related but different context, which is discussed in Sec. 2.1. 10 In
pranab
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
The Discovery of Pulsars
pranab
11
duration of about a year, this suggestion took hold, grew in detail as more properties of radio pulsars were established, and eclipsed all other suggestions to become what is now the universally-accepted physical model of pulsars. Gold initially (1968) appealed to the extreme stability of the periods (1 in 108 ) to argue the case for a massive, compact, rotating object (as opposed to stellar vibrations, or oscillations of plasma configurations), and predicted a “slowing down of the observed repetition frequencies”, which was subsequently confirmed. The fact that the rate of loss of rotational energy of the Crab pulsar was roughly the same as that required to power the Crab nebula (essentially repeating the 1967 scenario of Pacini), as Gold argued in a subsequent (1969) paper, clinched the issue. We now summarize the arguments in favor of the rotating neutron-star model and against the competing models, as they stand today, rather than following the historical development. The crucial observational point used in these arguments are that (1) the periods of the radio pulsars are so short (∼ milliseconds to several seconds), (2) radio pulsars are exremely accurate clocks (measurements upto precisions ∼ 1 part in 1014 have been possible), and (3) the periods of radio pulsars always increase slowly and gradually, except for occasional, discontinuous decreases or “glitches” (which we treat in some detail in Chapters 7 and 8). The first point implies that rotations or vibrations of compact, dense stars, e.g., white dwarfs or neutron stars, (or orbital motions around such stars) must be involved rather than those of large, low-density, “normal” stars, which occur on much longer timescales, since all these characteristic times scale roughly as ρ−1/2 (see below), where ρ is the average density of the star. Further, since the shortest known period among radio pulsars is ∼ 1.6 ms (see Sec. (1.6)), and light travels ∼ 500 km in this time, this distance must be an upper limit to the size of the emitting region. Because of the great accuracy of the pulsar clock mechanism, we can argue that this must also be a rough upper limit to the size of the star itself, since it is basically impossible to justify such accuracy for an emitting region much smaller than the star and unrelated to the size of the latter: the two must be closely coupled. Of the various compact-star phenomena, consider first oscillations of white dwarfs or neutron stars. Periods of fundamental modes of oscillations of white dwarfs are in the range 2–10 s, and those of neutron stars are in the range 1–10 ms [Meltzer & Thorne 1966]. It is thus clear that a single class of objects will not account for the entire range of pulsar periods. White-dwarf oscillations at higher harmonics will, of course, have shorter periods than above, but it requires special circumstances to excite these
January 10, 2007
16:24
12
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
pranab
Rotation and Accretion Powered Pulsars
harmonics, and the sharpness of the pulses (one of their major observed characteristics) will then be destroyed by mode-mixing due to any small nonlinearity (always present in real stars). In any case, the periods of wellknown pulsars like Crab (33 ms) and Vela (89 ms), which lie in the “gap” between the above ranges for white dwarfs and neutron stars, are almost impossible to account for in this way. Finally, if pulses were emitted by this mechanism, the energy-loss from the oscillating system would lead to a decrease in the pulse period, the exact opposite of what is observed. Thus, oscillations are ruled out. Consider next rotating white dwarfs. The shortest period P , or the highest angular velocity Ω, at which a star of mass M and radius R can rotate without being torn apart by centrifugal forces is given by Ω2 R ∼
GM . R2
(1.1)
In terms of the average density ρ of the star, Eq. (1.1) for the breakup angular velocity can be recast in the approximate form Ω ∼ (Gρ)1/2 ,
(1.2)
which is a very useful, general result for a variety of dynamical timescales associated with a star. White dwarfs with ρ ∼ 107 –108 g cm−3 therefore have breakup rotation periods P = 2π/Ω ∼ 1–10 s, a result which rules out rotating white dwarfs. Note also the similarity between this range of periods and that given above for white-dwarf oscillations. This is a consequence of the virial theorem [Chandrasekhar 1935], according to which the period of the fundamental oscillation mode of a star is of the same order of magnitude as its breakup period11 [Gold 1968], and so given roughly by Eq. (1.2), as we anticipated above. Now consider orbital motion around compact stars, either (a) of a small object in a close orbit around the star, or, (b) of a close binary system of compact stars around each other. In the former case, balancing the centrifugal force against the gravitational attraction of the star again yields an equation like Eq. (1.1) with the orbital radius r replacing the stellar radius R, and since r ∼ R for a close orbit, we recover Eq. (1.2). In the latter case, we again get an equation of the form 1.1, with M replaced by the total mass (= 2M for two identical stars of mass M ) of the system, and 11 Elastic
restoring forces, which augment the usual gravitational restoring forces in solid or partly-solid stars like white dwarfs and neutron stars, shorten the oscillation periods somewhat, but the scaling with density in Eq. (1.2) is still roughly valid.
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
The Discovery of Pulsars
pranab
13
the orbital radius r replacing the stellar radius R as before. With r ∼ 2R for two identical stars of radius R, we again roughly recover Eq. (1.2). This further illustrates the universal significance of the dynamical timescale. The earlier arguments given for the range of periods thus roughly apply to orbital motion as well. Additional, severe difficulties arise. First, such a close binary system containing a neutron star would be a copious emitter of gravitational waves, the two objects spiralling into each other in a very short time due to energy-loss through these waves. This timescale for a binary system of two neutron stars, each of mass M , and a binary period of P is roughly Tspiral ∼ 10
−3
P 1s
8/3 yr,
(1.3)
an absurdly short lifetime. In reality, pulsar periods are observed to change typically on timescales ∼ 107 yr. Furthermore, orbit decay due to gravitational radiation would cause the period to decrease, contrary to what is observed12 . For a planet or satellite of mass M in a close orbit around a neutron star of mass M ( 1), the spiral-in timescale is again given by Eq. (1.3), but with an extra factor of −1 included in its right-hand side. Observed period-change timescales of pulsars would thus imply tiny masses ( ∼ 10−10 ) of the satellite. Even under the unlikely assumption that such an insignificant object could produce the observed radio pulses, we immediately encounter the problem that such a satellite would be pulverized by the enormous tidal forces in the strong gravitational field close to a neutron star. The high radiation field of the pulsar only adds to the difficulty, as it would tend to melt or evaporate the satellite13 . This rules out orbital periods. Finally, consider rotation periods of neutron stars. As applications of Eq. (1.2) show, neutron stars with ρ ∼ 1014 g cm−3 have breakup rotation periods ∼ 1 ms. Thus, rotation periods > ∼ 1 ms are all possible for neutron stars; indeed, the shortest pulse period ∼ 1.6 ms known for radio pulsars is rather close to (but, of course, longer than) the numerical 12 Double neutron-star binaries are known, of course, the classic example being PSR 1913+16, the famous Hulse-Taylor pulsar discovered in 1974. The pulse period of this pulsar is P ≈ 59 ms, the orbital period is Porb ≈ 7.7 hours, and the rate of decrease of the latter due to gravitational radiation has been measured accurately. See Sec. 7.2.4 for a full discussion. 13 Indeed, the radiation field of the binary pulsar PSR 1957+20, the so-called “black widow” pulsar, is believed to be slowly evaporating its low-mass white dwarf companion. See Sec. 6.5.5 for details.
January 10, 2007
16:24
14
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
Rotation and Accretion Powered Pulsars
value of the breakup period calculated from detailed neutron-star models. All the other objections against the alternative scenarios detailed above also do not apply to the rotating neutron-star scenario. Thus the rotating neutron-star model survives as the only viable scenario. The accuracy of the pulsar clock relates well to the rotation of a massive, compact star with a solid surface, the lengthening of the pulse period to the slowing down of the rotation (or spindown, as it is called) due to loss of rotational energy through electromagnetic emission at the rate expected for canonical magnetic fields (∼ 1012 G) of neutron stars, and the above energy loss-rate to the (apparent) energy supply-rate to canonical supernova remnants like the Crab nebula. Many details of the observed features of pulsars, which we describe in later chapters, have generally found satisfactory explanations in the rotating neutron-star model, although our understanding of the pulseformation mechanism is still not as good as it could be (see Chapter 11). Because of the universal agreement today that the pulsars originally (and still being) discovered at radio frequencies are powered by the rotational energy of neutron stars, we shall refer to these as rotation-powered pulsars throughout the rest of the book. As these pulsars sometimes have emission in other wavebands (optical, X-ray, γ-ray,...) as well, a categorization which is more meaningful physically is in terms of their source of energy, which sets them apart from the other class of pulsars with which we are concerned in this book. 1.3.2
Accretion-Powered Pulsars
Let us summarize the arguments identifying binary X-ray pulsars as rotating, accreting neutron stars, again as they would stand today, rather than historically. Arguments favoring rotating neutron stars follow much the same route as those used for rotation-powered pulsars, using the observational facts that (1) the pulse periods range from ∼ 2 milliseconds to ∼ 104 seconds, and, (2) the periods are quite stable after correction for the Doppler effect due to binary motion [Davidson & Ostriker 1973]. The first point implies that, again, the only kind of stars capable of having dynamical phenomena over this whole range of periods are compact stars—white dwarfs, neutron stars, and black holes—and, of these, the only single class able to account for the entire range is that of neutron stars. This follows from the arguments about dynamical timescales in terms of the average stellar density ρ summarized in the previous subsection, particularly Eq. (1.2). Rotating black holes are ruled out because non-axisymmetric
pranab
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
The Discovery of Pulsars
pranab
15
black holes, such as would be required for producing pulses, can have only a transient existence, if any. For neutron stars, only rotation can cover this entire range of periods, oscillation periods being far too limited in range (∼ 1–10 ms), as explained in the previous subsection. The second point, the stability of the pulses, also argues in favor of rotations rather than oscillations as the basic cause of modulation at the pulse period. Again, the argument is that the rotation of a compact, massive body, isolated except for the gravitational influence of its binary companion, is far stabler by nature than a train of oscillations excited by any conceivable mechanism. By the same argument, plasma oscillations are ruled out even more strongly. Finally, orbital periods around neutron stars are untenable because (a) the range of observed periods cannot be accounted for, and, (b) such periods would change on absurdly short timescales due to emission of gravitational radiation (see Eq. (1.3)). Thus, we are left with rotation periods of neutron stars as the only viable model. That the source of power for the X-ray emission from binary X-ray pulsars could not be the rotational energy of the neutron stars was clear from the beginning, since the typical observed X-ray luminosities of these sources (∼ 1037 erg s−1 ) were far too high to be accounted for in this manner, even if we assumed, for the sake of argument, that these sources were all spinning down. This is easily seen by noting that the slowingdown time of a binary X-ray pulsar of period P and luminosity L is [Lamb et al. 1973]: Tslow ∼ Erot /L ∼ 60I45
P 1s
−2
L−1 37 yr,
(1.4)
where Erot = 12 IΩ2 is the rotational energy of the neutron star, I being its moment of inertia. In Eq. (1.4), L37 is L in units of 1037 erg s−1 , and I45 is I in units of 1045 gm cm2 : this convention of expressing a physical variable in units of its typical order of magnitude in a given problem is standard in astrophysics, and we shall be using it throughout this book. This timescale is absurdly small for the vast majority of the sources with periods in the range 1–1000 seconds. Actually, periods of binary X-ray pulsars show a complex behavior with time, consisting of (a) a secular component which is spinup (i.e., P decreasing with time) for some pulsars, spindown (i.e., P increasing with time) for some, and and no significant change for yet others, superposed on (b) a fluctuating “noise” component.
January 10, 2007
16:24
16
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
Rotation and Accretion Powered Pulsars
So the spindown argument is irrelevant to these pulsars as a general class14 . Accretion remains the only viable source of power to the class of binary X-ray pulsars as a whole [Pringle & Rees 1972; Davidson & Ostriker 1973; Lamb et al. 1973]. The vast quantity of energy released by matter falling into the deep gravitational potential wells of neutron stars of radii R ∼ 106 cm and masses M ∼ M , amounting to = GM/R ∼ 1020 ergs per gram of accreted matter, i.e., about a tenth of its rest-mass energy (∼ 0.1c2 ), makes accretion an ideal source of power, as was recognized by Zel’dovich and coauthors long ago [Zel’dovich & Novikov 1965; Zel’dovich & Shakura 1969]. To generate X-ray luminosities ∼ 1037 erg s−1 typical of bright, binary Xray pulsars, accretion rates ∼ 1017 gm s−1 ∼ 10−9 M yr−1 are therefore required. The binary companion of the neutron star is a natural, and more than adequate, source of supply of the matter to be accreted, as stars lose mass through a variety of processes during the course of their evolution, particularly if they are in binary systems. Massive, young, O and B stars drive sizable outflows of matter called “stellar winds”, and rapidly-rotating Be stars shed, in addition, rings of matter from time to time. At several stages of their thermonuclear evolution, stars expand by large factors to become “giants” or “supergiants” (see Appendix C): if they are in close binaries, they lose mass copiously during these stages as they attempt to expand beyond their limiting gravitational equipotentials, which are called Roche lobes (see Appendix B). Finally, the X-rays emitted by the neutron star can heat the companion’s surface, causing mass loss in a so-called “selfexcited wind”. All this matter is available for accretion by the neutron star, which the latter can do through several types of accretion flows, ranging from spherical inflow (for matter with negligible angular momentum relative to the neutron star) to inflow through an accretion disk (for matter with so much angular momentum that it can go into orbits around the neutron star obeying Kepler’s laws). We discuss these processes in detail in later chapters. 14 Historically,
the prototype binary X-ray pulsars Her X-1 and Cen X-3, which were used to start building models for these pulsars, were soon found to have secular spinup, at which point rotation-power for emission became irrelevant and was forgotten. In the last few years, this chapter has been reopened for a small subclass of X-ray pulsars with periods ∼ 5–12 seconds: these show secular spindown, and their binary nature has never been really established. The idea that these Anomalous X-ray Pulsars (AXPs) could be rotating neutron stars with unusually, but not impossibly, high magnetic fields, and that the observed spindown is by the same electromagnetic torques that brake rotationpowered pulsars, is being explored. We return to AXPs in Chapter 9.
pranab
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
The Discovery of Pulsars
pranab
17
There is universal agreement today that binary X-ray pulsars are powered by accretion. Additional supporting evidence has accumulated over the years, for example from rates of secular spinup of binary X-ray pulsars [Lamb et al. 1973; Rappaprt & Joss 1977], and from strong evidence for the presence of accretion disks in these and similar binaries through probes at other wavelengths, e.g., optical. In close analogy with what we described for the radio pulsars in the previous subsection, all major details of the properties of binary X-ray pulsars have found satisfactory explanation in the framework of the accreting neutron-star model. A particular triumph of this model has been the natural explanation of the evolutionary link between young, high magnetic-field, rotation-powered pulsars (e.g., the Crab pulsar) and old, low magnetic-field, “recycled” rotation-powered pulsars spun up to millisecond periods, whose discovery started in 1982 with the ∼ 1.6 millisecond pulsar PSR 1937+21. As this is a dominant theme of this book, we shall return to evolutionary questions repeatedly, particularly in Chapter 6. Finally, in analogy with the nomenclature introduced in the previous subsection, we shall refer to binary X-ray pulsars as accretionpowered pulsars throughout the rest of the book, despite the fact that they were, and are still being, discovered by X-ray satellites. The reason, again, is that they have emission at other wavelengths—optical, UV, IR, radio, and the like—and studies at some of the other wavelengths is often crucial (such as optical studies for the clarification of binary properties), whereas their source of energy is their key physical feature distinguishing them from the rotation-powered pulsars described earlier.
1.4 1.4.1
Powering Pulsars by Rotation and Accretion Rotation Power
Consider a neutron star of moment of inertia I, rotating with an angular velocity Ω, so that its rotational energy is given by Erot =
1 2 IΩ ≈ 2 × 1046 I45 P −2 (s) erg, 2
(1.5)
where I45 is I in units of 1045 g cm2 , as before, and P = 2π/Ω is the ˙ its rotational rotation period. If the star’s spin is changing at a rate Ω, energy is changing at a rate ˙ 2 ≈ IΩΩ˙ = −4 × 1032 I45 P −3 (s)P˙−14 erg s−1 . ˙ + 1 IΩ E˙ rot = IΩΩ 2
(1.6)
January 10, 2007
18
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
pranab
Rotation and Accretion Powered Pulsars
Here, I˙ is the rate of change, if any, of the star’s moment of inertia during the spin-change process, due to a variety of possible reasons we discuss later, and the approximate version of the right-hand side of Eq. (1.6) is obtained by neglecting the inertia-change term, which we shall be using most frequently. Loss of rotational energy is then inferred from spindown, ˙ < 0, or, equivalently, P˙ > 0, as is the case for rotation-powered pulsars. Ω In Eq. (1.6), P˙−14 is P˙ in units of 10−14 second per second (s s−1 ), a typical order of magnitude for rotation-powered pulsars, roughly comparable to a nanosecond per day (ns d−1 ), which is also used as a unit for P˙ . How does such a pulsar convert its rotational energy into electromagnetic energy and radiate it? This was the problem addressed by Pacini (1967) and Gold (1969). Young neutron stars have very large magnetic 12 fields (B > ∼ 10 G), the origins of which we discuss in Chapter 13. As a first approximation, we can represent this field by that of a magnetic dipole, since any magnetic field configuration in the star can be represented by a combination of magnetic multipoles (see, e.g., Jackson 1975), as seen by an outside observer, and the dipole component is dominant when the observer is sufficiently far away from the star. Consider a neutron star of magnetic dipole moment µ oriented at an angle α with respect to its rotation axis. (The magnetic field at the stellar surface of radius R is given roughly by Bs ∼ µ/R3 , and the field at either of the magnetic poles is given exactly by Bp = 2µ/R3, so that typical orders of magnitude for young pulsars are Bs ∼ 1012 G and µ ∼ 1030 G cm3 .) This rotating oblique dipole appears as a time-varying one from the point of view of a distant observer [Jackson 1975], and so radiates energy at a rate 2µ2 Ω4 sin2 α 2 E˙ mdr = ≈ 1031 B12 R66 P −4 (s) sin2 α erg s−1 , 3c3
(1.7)
as magnetic dipole radiation at a frequency Ω. Here, B12 is the polar field Bp in units of 1012 G, and R6 is R in units of 106 cm. A comparison of Eqs. (1.6) and (1.7) shows how readily magnetic dipole radiation accounts for the spindown rates of rotation-powered pulsars. In fact, the observed spindown rate of a given pulsar can be used to estimate its magnetic field through the relation we obtain by combining Eqs. (1.6) and (1.7), namely,
B12 ≈ 6
I45 P˙−14 P (s) R63 sin α
,
(1.8)
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
The Discovery of Pulsars
pranab
19
and is the standard method for doing so. The angle of obliquity α is, of course, not known from the spindown observations alone, but we can either (a) set sin α = 1 in Eq. (1.8), and interpret the result as the magnetic field due to that component of the magnetic moment which is perpendicular to the rotation axis, or, (b) use a statistically averaged value of sin α expected for a collection of pulsars, unless we have clues to the value of α from other observation, e.g., that of polarization. Note that the magnetic field ˙ strength inferred in this way scales as P P . Thus, because of its short period (P ≈ 33 ms) and high spindown rate (P˙−14 ≈ 42), the Crab pulsar has a higher energy, Erot ≈ 2 × 1049 erg, and higher energy-loss rate, E˙ rot ≈ −5 × 1038 erg s−1 , than the canonical values appearing in Eqs. (1.5) and (1.6), but the inferred magnetic field strength, B12 ≈ 7, is canonical, since the factor of increase in P˙ largely cancels the factor of decrease in P . In this argument, we have used the canonical estimate ∼ 1 for I45 and R6 , as we shall do throughout this book. It was the remarkable agreement between the above estimate of E˙ rot for the Crab pulsar and the inferred energy requirements of the Crab nebula that proved instrumental for identifying rotation-powered pulsars with neutron stars [Gold 1969]. Although E˙ rot is the rate of loss of rotational energy from the neutron star, sometimes called the spindown power, only a small fraction of it appears in the radio pulses. For example, the fraction of the above spindown power for the Crab pulsar that goes into radio pulses is ∼ 10−7 , i.e., absolutely tiny, as is the typical value ∼ 10−5 characteristic of the known population of rotation-powered pulsars. Where does the bulk of the energy go? It is generally thought that much of this energy goes into accelerating charged particles15 to high energies, which then deposit their energy in the surrounding nebula (supernova remnant) in the case of young pulsars like the Crab pulsar to make the nebula a strong emitter of electromagnetic radiation (radio, optical, X-ray...). Note also that the magnetic dipole radiation we discussed above is clearly not what we observe as pulses from the pulsars, since this radiation is emitted at the stellar rotation frequency (ν ≡ Ω/2π ∼ 1–1000 Hz), and has an approximately sinusoidal pulse shape. The observed pulses are modulations at radio frequencies (ν ∼ 10 MHz— 10 GHz), or even higher frequencies of electromagnetic radiation, and their shapes resemble narrow spikes, covering a small fraction (∼ 10−2 –10−1) of the total pulse period (see Chapetr 7). Thus, the magnetic dipole radiation is merely a process that taps the reservoir of the neutron star’s rotational 15 γ-ray pulses, which have been detected from a small number of rotation-powered pulsars so far, have been observed to carry upto ∼ 0.3 of the spindown power.
January 10, 2007
16:24
20
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
Rotation and Accretion Powered Pulsars
energy; the pulse-generation process is far more complex, to which we return in Chapter 11. Whatever this process is, it must be clear that it is very strongly tied to the stellar rotation, since the pulses come with such stable periodicity, and it produces electromagnetic radiation in extremely sharp, narrow beams (unlike magnetic dipole radiation). Charged particles moving along the stellar magnetic field lines, which are corotating with the star, are therefore an essential ingredient of any such process, as we shall see. In the universally-accepted model of rotation-powered pulsars, such a process generates a very narrow beam of radiation rotating with the star, as shown schematically in Fig. 1.4, and when this beam sweeps by the earth, rather like a lighthouse beam, we see the pulses. 1.4.2
Accretion Power
Consider a neutron star of mass M and radius R accreting mass at a rate M˙ . Since each unit of accreted mass releases an amount of gravitational potential energy GM/R on reaching the stellar surface, the lumnosity (i.e., energy per unit time) generated by the accretion process is given by [Zel’dovich & Shakura 1969]
Fig. 1.4 Basic model of rotation-powered pulsars. Reproduced by permission of IEEE c 1991 IEEE. from Taylor (1991), Proc. IEEE, 79, 1054.
pranab
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
The Discovery of Pulsars
L=
GM M˙ ≈ 1.3 × 1037 M˙ 17 (M/M )R6−1 erg s−1 , R
pranab
21
(1.9)
where M˙ 17 is M˙ in units of 1017 g s−1 . Thus, accretion rates of bright accretion-powered pulsars with L ∼ 1037 erg s−1 are ∼ 1017 g s−1 ∼ 10−9 M yr−1 , as we mentioned before, and the accreted mass comes from the binary companion of the neutron star. How, again, is this energy converted into electromagnetic radiation— primarily X-rays—that we see in the pulses? The basic process is thermal emission from the heated stellar surface and the hot plasma (ionized matter) close to it, the source of heat being the gravitational potential energy released as described above, as the accreting matter falling towards the stellar surface is brought to a halt by a variety of dissipative processes. As a first approximation, we can treat this as blackbody emission (complexities due to radiative transfer in the presence of intense neutron-star magnetic fields are discussed in Chapter 11) at an effective temperature T from that part of the stellar surface which receives the accreting matter, and whose area is A. By Stefan’s law, the luminosity is then L = σAT 4 ,
(1.10)
which must equal that given by Eq. (1.9) in a steady state. Here, σ is the Stefan-Boltzmann constant. What is the accretion area A on the neutron star? Note first that if we equated this to the entire stellar surface area, As = 4πR2 , we would obtain the case of spherical accretion onto the neutron star, such as was considered by Zel’dovich and Shakura (1969). While interesting in its own right, such a situation does not produce pulses (as must be obvious since the stellar rotation produces no modulation in the outgoing radiation) and so is irrelevant for accretionpowered pulsars, in which the intense magnetic field of the neutron star channels the flow of the accreting matter (which, being completely ionized, must move along the magnetic field lines, a situation which is called “flux-frozen” flow; see, e.g., Jackson 1975) towards the magnetic poles of the star [Davidson & Ostriker 1973; Lamb et al. 1973]. Matter thus accretes on two polar caps at the stellar surface, producing two “hot spots” which emit radiation, as shown in Fig. 1.5: matter raining down on a hot spot forms a column-like structure called “accretion column”16 . If the magnetic axis of the star is oblique with respect to its rotation axis 16 Also
called “accretion funnel” because of its shape on a larger scale: see Fig. 1.5.
January 10, 2007
22
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
Rotation and Accretion Powered Pulsars
Fig. 1.5 Basic model of accretion-powered pulsars. Reproduced by permission of the AAS from Lamb et al. (1973): see Bibliography.
(as for rotation-powered pulsars), this is a natural mechanism for modulating the emitted radiation at the stellar rotation frequency, as observed. The area of these polar caps, which is what enters into Eq. (1.10), can be estimated by the following method [Davidson & Ostriker 1973; Lamb et al. 1973]. Far away from the neutron star, the flow of the accreting matter is not influenced by the stellar magnetic field, and is determined, rather, by the details of how it is lost by the companion star, and by the dynamics of the binary system (see Chapter 10). Close to the neutron star, on the other hand, the flow is completely dominated by the stellar magnetic field, matter falling onto the star along the field lines: this region is called the magnetosphere of the neutron star. Of crucial importance is the transition boundary between the magnetospneric flow and the outer flow: its location can be calculated from various physical arguments involving the accreting matter and the magnetic field, which we discuss in Chapter 10. All these arguments give a boundary radius rm which depends basically on the accretion rate M˙ and the surface magnetic field Bs of the neutron star, as may
pranab
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
The Discovery of Pulsars
pranab
23
be expected: for typical values appropriate for bright accretion-powered pulsars (M˙ 17 ∼ 1, B12 ∼ 1), rm ∼ 108 cm (see Chapter 10 for detailed expressions for various estimates of rm ). The size of the polar cap is then roughly estimated by the simple, but useful, geometrical argument that the field lines passing through the outer edge of this cap must be the the outermost stellar field lines that can possibly close within rm (see Fig. 1.5). As a first approximation, we assume a dipolar magnetic field for the star (as we did for rotation-powered pulsars, and as we shall do throughout this book): the equation for the field lines of a magnetic dipole in polar coordinates is [Jackson 1975] r = r0 sin2 θ,
(1.11)
where r0 is a field line ‘label’, identifying the particular field line by its value of r on the equatorial plane of the dipole (θ = π/2). Since r0 = rm for the outermost field line we are concerned with here, the value of θ for the footpoint of this field line on the stellar surface (r = R) given from Eq. (1.11) by θa ≈ (R/rm )1/2 , which is also the semi-angle subtended by the polar cap at the center of the star (see Fig. 1.5). Thus the total area of the two polar caps (one at each pole of the star) is given by Ap ≈ 2πR2 θa2 = 2πR3 /rm ≈ 6R63 (rm /108 cm)−1 km2 ,
(1.12)
which is much smaller than (in fact, only about 0.5 % of) the total surface area, As ≈ 1260 R62 km2 , of the neutron star. Note that even if the stellar field configuration was a perfect dipole to begin with, the accretion process itself is likely to distort it, so that the above picture is only approximate. Nevertheless, this simple geometrical estimate, which can be regarded as an upper limit to the size of the hot spots, makes a good beginning, which can be improved upon by detailed considerations of the accretion flow pattern (see Chapter 10). The blackbody emission temperature of the hot spots can now be obtained by combining Eqs. (1.9), (1.10), and (1.12). The result, 1/4 T ≈ 4 × 107 M˙ 17 (M/M )1/4 R6−1 (rm /108 cm)1/4 K,
(1.13)
readily shows why the bulk of the emission is in the X-rays, since the mean energy of the photons emitted by a blackbody of this temperature is ¯ ≈ 2.7kT ≈ 9 keV for canonical values of the parameters in Eq. (1.13), k being
January 10, 2007
16:24
24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
Rotation and Accretion Powered Pulsars
Boltzmann’s constant17 . Furthermore, since the blackbody temperature is only a lower bound on the actual emission temperature, the latter may be higher. In chapter 11, we discuss how additional effects may modify the shape of the emergent spectrum of an accretion-powered pulsar from that of a blackbody. While a rotating hot spot does generate periodic modulations due to a varying angle of viewing, further complications are introduced into the anisotropy of the emergent radiation due to the stellar magnetic field, since the opacity of matter in such fields is highly energy-dependent. The study of the latter effect was pioneered by Lamb et al. (1973), who identified three regimes of magnetic effects, depending on whether the stellar magnetic field was above, below, or comparable to a critical field strength ∼ 2 × 1011 G. Far below the critical value, the magnetic field has little effect on the opacity of the matter. Since the integrated density of matter, and so its opacity, is much greater along the accretion column than across it, the radiation emerges preferentially through the sides of the column, producing a fanshaped beam. Far above this value, the magnetic field drastically reduces the opacity of matter, essentially making the accretion column transparent, so that the viewing-angle effect mentioned above produces the modulation. Finally, when the magnetic field is comparable to the critical value, interesting opacity effects are possible, leading to complex pulse shapes. We discuss radiative transfer and pulse-shaping in accretion-powered pulsars in Chapter 8. Note that the observed pulse profiles of accretion-powered pulsars (see Chapter 9) are generally much smoother—covering most or all of the pulse period—than those of rotation-powered pulsars. This is entirely consistent with the fact that the above modulation mechanisms tend to produce smooth, gradual variations, and shows that pulse-shaping mechanisms in rotation-powered pulsars must be very different indeed.
1.5 1.5.1
Galactic Distributions of Pulsars Rotation-Powered Pulsars
Fig. 1.6 shows the positions of ∼ 1500 rotation-powered pulsars in the sky, in galactic coordinates (i.e., galactic latitude and longitude; see Appendix A). The concentration of pulsars towards the galactic plane which is 17 Here, keV stands for kilo-electron volts, an electron volt being the energy gained by an electron in a potential difference of 1 volt, which is approximately 1.6 × 10−12 erg. A handy relation between energy E in electron volts (eV) and temperature T in degrees K is T (K)≈ 1.16 × 104 E(eV), which follows directly from E = kT .
pranab
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
The Discovery of Pulsars
pranab
25
Fig. 1.6 Distribution of rotation-powered pulsars in galactic coordinates (see Appendix A), using a Hammer-Aitoff (equal-area) projection. Shown are the 1509 pulsars known roughly as of December 2004: more have been discovered since. Note that the figure includes rotation-powered pulsars, as well as AXPs and SGRs (see Chapter 9). Categories of rotation-powered pulsars as indicated. Reproduced by permission of the AAS from Manchester et al. (2005): see Bibliography.
apparent from the figure is a real effect: pulsars are galactic objects. There is also a real tendency for pulsars to be concentrated in the longitude quadrant toward the galactic center, which suggests that the density of pulsars increases radially towrads the galactic center, at least in the vicinity of the sun, since most of the observed pulsars lie in this neighborhood (because of the difficulty in detecting pulsars far away from us due to their faintness, which is an example of selection effects discussed later). In addition to these two angles, we need to know a distance, say that of the pulsar from the galactic center, r, projected onto the galactic plane, in order to completely specify the position of the pulsar in the galaxy. Actually, the galactic distribution of pulsars is usually quoted in terms of the two cylindrical coordinates r and z, the former being the projected radius just defined, and the latter the vertical distance from the galactic plane. Azimuthal symmetry is assumed. The distances r and z cannot be measured directly, of course. What we can estimate by various methods is the distance d of the pulsar from us, which is also its distance from the Sun for all practical purposes. In terms of d, the galactic longitude l, and the galactic latitude b, the required distances are then given by the trigonometric relations: 2 + d2 cos2 b − 2r d cos b cos l, z = d sin b. (1.14) r = r
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
pranab
Rotation and Accretion Powered Pulsars
26
Here, r ≈ 8.5 kiloparsec (kpc) is the distance of the Sun from the galactic center (parsec is a unit of distance defined in Appendix A). 1.5.1.1
Pulsar distances
But how do we measure d? Foremost among the methods for doing this is that of dispersion measure, which makes use of the dispersion of the radio pulses during propagation through the ionized interstellar medium, because of which pulses from a given pulsar arrive slightly later at lower frequencies than at higher frequencies. The group velocity vg of propagation of electromagnetic waves of frequency ν through a plasma with electron density ne is given (see, e.g., Krall & Trivelpiece 1973) by:
νp2 vg = c 1 − 2 ν
1/2 .
(1.15)
Here, νp ≡ ne e2 /πme is the plasma frequency of the medium, e and me being respectively the charge and the mass of the electron. Since the time of travel d of a pulse of frequency ν from a pulsar at a distance d to us is ta ≡ 0 dl/vg , the dispersion in ta , i.e., the difference ∆ta between the times of arrival of pulses at two frequencies around ν differing by ∆ν is found from Eq. (1.15) to be ∆ta = −
∆ν ν
e2 πme cν 2
d
ne dl = − 0
∆ν ν
DM (cm−3 pc) 2 120.5νGHz
(1.16)
d correct to the first order in νp2 /ν 2 . Here, DM ≡ 0 ne dl is called the dispersion measure of the pulsar, which is the integrated density (or column density, as it is called in astrophysics) of electrons along the line of sight to the pulsar, conventionally expressed in the hybrid unit of cm−3 pc. In Eq. (1.16), ∆ta is in seconds, and νGHz is ν in GHz. Now, since
d
ne dl = ne d,
DM =
(1.17)
0
in terms of the average electron density ne in the direction of the pulsar, we can find d if we know ne , or the electron-density distribution, in the galaxy. The latter is usually obtained from dispersion measurements of pulsars whose distances are independently known by one of the following methods.
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
The Discovery of Pulsars
pranab
27
First, for very nearby pulsars (within about 1 kpc from the Sun), it is possible to measure distances from observations of the annual parallax (i.e., the apparent annual cyclic movement of position due to the Earth’s orbital motion around the Sun), as is done for nearby stars. For pulsars, this is achieved through very long baseline radio interferometry (VLBI). However, the number of such extremely close pulsars is very small. Secondly, when pulsars at low galactic latitudes are observed through the spiral arms of the galaxy, their spectra show marked absorption at the famous 21-cm line of neutral hydrogen (HI). The velocity of the HI cloud can be determined from the Doppler shift in the absorption line, which yields its distance with the aid of our knowledge of the rotation velocity of matter as a function of distance from the center of the galaxy, which is called the rotation curve of the galaxy. This method is by far the most widely applicable one for pulsar distance determination independent of dispersion measure [Manchester & Taylor 1977]. Finally, when a pulsar is associated with a supernova remnant (e.g., the Crab and Vela pulsars) or a globular cluster (e.g., pulsars in 47 Tuc), the distances to which are known from optical observations, we have an independent distance measure: this method is also applicable to only a relatively small number of pulsars. Distances inferred by these methods generally range from ∼ 40 pc to ∼ 20 kpc, and the average electron densities ne so obtained are in the range 0.02–0.07 cm−3 , a typical value ∼ 0.03 cm−3 being representative of much of our galaxy. Corresponding values of DM are in the range 3–800 cm−3 pc. 1.5.1.2
Galactic electron distribution
The above procedure gives a first, rough map of the distribution of ne in various directions in the galaxy, which is used for a first determination of distances to those pulsars for which only the dispersion-measure method is possible. This model of electron-density distribution is then refined from the pulsar measurements themselves, using an iterative scheme. Starting with the model of Manchester and Taylor (1981), successive refinements by Lyne et al. (1985), Taylor and Cordes (1993), and Lazio and Cordes (1998) have now yielded an electron-density distribution capable of providing pulsar distances accurate to ∼ 25% or better. Galactic ne -distribution models consist of the following components. The first is a smooth, axisymmetric component representing the smooth distribution of ionized hydrogen (HII) in the galactic disk. This consists of two parts, representing the inner and the outer disk. The second is a large HII region close to the Sun known as
January 10, 2007
28
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
pranab
Rotation and Accretion Powered Pulsars
the Gum Nebula, which is located at galactic longitude l = 260◦ and latitude b = 0◦ . Because of its close proximity (d ≈ 500 pc) and large angular diameter (∼ 40◦ ), the effects of the nebula are prominent on the dispersion measures of a significant number of pulsars located behind it. The third contribution comes from the four spiral arms of the galaxy, each of which has prominent HII regions (around newborn, massive OB stars) lined along it [Taylor & Cordes 1993], which particularly affect the dispersion measures of pulsars seen by us along tangent directions to these spiral arms. In order to convey the flavor of typical ne -distribution models used in modern work on rotation-powered pulsars, we now summarize the distribution advocated by Taylor and Cordes (1993). Each of the smooth, axisymmetric components is assumed to factorize, or be separable, in the coordinates r and z defined earlier. This is reminiscent of the separable nature the galactic distribution of pulsars (see below), which is supported by the observed lack of correlations between r and z in that distribution. The outer-galaxy component is (r, z) = 0.02 nouter e
sech2 (r/20) sech2 (z/0.88) cm−3 sech2 (r /20)
(1.18)
Here, r and z are in units of kpc, and r ≈ 8.5 kpc is the distance of the Sun from the galactic center, as before. The distribution in Eq. (1.18) has been so normalized as to reproduce the known electron density, ne ≈ 0.02 cm−3 near the Sun. The choice of the squared hyperbolic secant [sechz ≡ 1/ cosh z ≡ 2/{exp(z) + exp(−z)}] is not unique, but plausible and convenient. Its use in the z-direction is prompted by the facts that (a) it is more appropriate than the exponential distribution exp(−|z|) used earlier for vertical distributions, since it has the physically expected zero derivative at z = 0, and (b) the density profile of an isothermal gas layer is expected to have this functional form [Spitzer 1942]. Extension to r and other coordinates is largely by analogy. The inner-galaxy component is (r, z) = 0.1 exp{−[(r − 3.5)/1.8]2}sech2 (z/0.15) cm−3 . ninner e
(1.19)
The radial part of this distribution is an annulus with the maximum density at a radius 3.5 kpc and a Gaussian half-width of 1.8 kpc. This ring-like structure is prompted by a similar structure seen in molecular line observations [Burton 1988], which suggest enhanced star formation and consequent creation of HII regions within such a ring.
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
The Discovery of Pulsars
The Gum Nebula contribution is modeled as 1, u ≤ 0.13 GN −3 ne = 0.25 cm exp{−[(u − 0.13)/0.05]2}, u > 0.13
pranab
29
(1.20)
where u is the distance in kpc from the center of the Gum Nebula to the point at which ne is being evaluated. The nebula’s contribution is constant = 0.25 cm−3 out to a distance of 130 pc from its center, and its at nGN e edges have been “softened” as a Gaussian fall-off with a 50 pc length scale. Finally, the contribution from each of the four spiral arms is again modeled by a factorisable, or separable, distribution of the form = 0.08sech2 (z/0.3) exp[−(s/0.3)2 ]gspine(t) cm−3 . nspiral e
(1.21)
The first distribution factor on the right-hand side of Eq. (1.21) is the standard Taylor-Cordes sech2 -distribution in the z-direction, i.e., perpendicular to the galactic plane. Within the plane, the distribution is described naturally in terms of two following coordinates. Imagine a curved line following a spiral arm along its central and densest parts (see Fig. 1.7), which we can call the “spine” of that spiral arm18 . Then a (curvilinear) coordinate t following the spine, and a coordinate s transverse to t specify the planar distribution completely. The transverse s-distribution is taken as a Gaussian with a scale length of 0.3 kpc, as Eq. (1.21) shows. What about the t-distribution along the spine, gspine(t)? Taylor and Cordes approximated it as follows. The spine can, of course, be described as a curve in the galactic plane in terms of the galactocentric radius r and a galactocentric angle θ measured, say, counterclockwise from galactic longitude l = 0. These authors took gspine = f (θ)R(r), using simple functions for f and R. For the radial distribution they took a constant value inside a cutoff radius of 8.5 kpc, and a fall-off outside this following a sech2 -law with a scale length of 2 kpc, in order to roughly account for the observed number densities of H II regions. The θ-distribution they kept as simple as possible, using a constant value unless the observed distribution of H II regions along the spine showed large variations in some angular region of the spiral arm, in which case that was accounted for in a simple way. We refer the reader to the original paper for further details. 18 We deliberately avoid using the word “axis” in this context [Taylor & Cordes 1993], as it often means something entirely different for spiral structures, namely an axis perpendicular to the plane of the spiral, passing through the central point of the whole spiral.
January 10, 2007
30
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
Rotation and Accretion Powered Pulsars
Fig. 1.7 Electron distribution in the galactic plane (z = 0) in gray-scale representation. The electron density is roughly maximum, ne ∼ 0.25 cm−3 , near the center of the Gum Nebula, shown by the large dark spot. For comparison, ne ∼ 0.019 cm−3 at the position of the Sun. Reproduced by permission of the AAS from Taylor & Cordes (1993): see Bibliography.
The Taylor-Cordes ne -distribution in the galactic plane (z = 0) is shown in Fig. 1.7. The largest electron densities are found in the outer parts of spiral arm 2 and in the Gum Nebula (ne ∼ 0.2 cm−3 ), the density in the solar neighborhood being only a tenth of this. Further refinements have recently been added to the model by Lazio and Cordes (1998) in the treatment of the outer galaxy, by including such effects as flaring (i.e., scale height increasing with r) and warping (i.e., the disk not being strictly planar) of the galactic disk, and investigating whether the radial distribution is better described by the sech2 -distribution of Eq. (1.18) or by a disk truncated at about 15 kpc.
pranab
February 8, 2007
15:39
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
The Discovery of Pulsars
1.5.1.3
pranab
31
Galactic pulsar distribution
We can now discuss the distribution of rotation-powered pulsars in terms of the galactic coordinates r and z, and the pulsar luminosity L. This distribution ρ(r, z, L) is taken to be separable in r, z, and L, because of the lack of correlations between these variables demonstrated in the early work on pulsars [Manchester & Taylor 1977], so that ρ(r, z, L)drdzdL = ρr (r)drρz (z)dzΦ(L)
dL . L
(1.22)
Note that the L-distribution is defined to be that over a unit logarithmic interval. Consider the galactic distribution first. The distribution perpendicular to the galactic plane is usually described in terms of an exponential, ρz (z) ∝ exp(−|z|/h), with a scale height of h. Recent estimates of h are in the range 400–500 pc [Lyne & Graham-Smith 1990; McLaughlin & Cordes 2000]. In view of the discussion in the previous subsection, it must be clear that a sech2 -distribution can also be used. Note that the scale height for pulsars is much higher than that of galactic Population I objects (massive OB stars which produce neutron stars through supernovae; see Appendices A and C, and Chapter 6) which is ∼ 50–100 pc. This is understood in terms of the high pulsar velocities: it is believed that they have traveled away from the galactic plane, their birthplace, due to such velocities received as “kicks” at their births in supernova explosions. The luminosity distribution is described over a considerable range (∼ 3 decades) by a power-law, Φ(L) ∝ L−n , with n ≈ 1. Note that, for rotation-powered pulsars, the “luminosity” is often defined by L = S400 d2 , where S400 is the mean flux density at 400 MHz. Since S is measured in units of milliJansky or mJy (1 Jansky ≡ 10−23 erg s−1 cm−2 Hz−1 ), and d in kpc, the units of L are then mJy kpc2 . To convert this into the more conventional units of erg s−1 (which are used for accretion-powered pulsars), we need to integrate over the bandwidth of radio frequency and the solid angle of the pulsar beam. Assuming a bandwidth of 400 MHz and a conical beam of width 10◦ , 1 mJy kpc2 translates into 3.4×1025 erg s−1 [Manchester & Taylor 1977]. Limiting sensitivities of pulsar surveys are typically ∼ 0.1–0.3 mJy kpc2 , which are sufficient to show clearly that the distribution at very low luminosities falls well below that predicted by the above power-law. This is as expected, since a distribution ∝ L−2 dL at arbitrarily low luminosities would give a divergent total population upon integration.
January 10, 2007
16:24
32
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
pranab
Rotation and Accretion Powered Pulsars
The distribution in r (galactocentric radius projected onto the galactic plane) shows a monotonic decrease outward from r ∼ 4 kpc, with very few pulsars detected beyond 15 kpc. Inside 4 kpc, the distribution is poorly determined. It is not entirely clear if (a) there is really a large inward drop in the pulsar density from this radius, or, (b) if pulsars are harder to detect in this direction because the limiting flux at which they can be detected increases inward due to (i) the higher noise-level in a radio telescope looking towrad the galactic center because of a high level of background radiation, and (ii) much stronger interstellar scattering in the innermost parts of the galaxy, which disperses the pulses more and makes them harder to detect. In reality, all of these effects could act simultaneously. In any case, there is some indication that the pulsar density does actually decrease inward inside ∼ 4 kpc. A simple distribution used in recent work [McLaughlin & Cordes 2000] is a superposition of two Gaussians, ρ(r) ∝ exp[−(r/6)2 ] + 0.25 exp[{−(r − 4)/1.5}2],
(1.23)
the first a disk of radial scale length 6 kpc, and the second an annulus at 4 kpc with a width of scale 1.5 kpc. This will remind the reader of the radial distribution of galactic electron density described in the previous subsection. Indeed, the annular distribution is inspired by the molecular ring mentioned there. Integration over the above distributions gives an estimate of ∼ 5 × 104 − −1 × 105 for the total number of observable pulsars in the galaxy above a threshold luminosity corresponding to the typical limiting sensitivity quoted earlier. To obtain the total of number of active pulsars in this luminosity range, we have to correct this by a beam-width factor, yielding a number ∼ a few times 105 . The fact that the r-distribution is poorly determined at small radii (r < 4 kpc) does not have a large effect on this estimate, since the integration over area is weighted as rdr, and the area inside the above limiting radius is not a large fraction of the total area (r ≤ 15 kpc, say) of the effective disk [Manchester & Taylor 1977]. The surface density of observable pulsars in the galactic disk in the vicinity of the Sun (above the same luminosity threshold) is estimated to be ∼ 70 pulsars per square kpc. 1.5.1.4
Selection effects
Selection effects are observational biases of various kinds introduced by limitations or discriminatory choices inherent in our detection procedures.
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
The Discovery of Pulsars
pranab
33
A universal, and almost trivial, example is luminosity bias. All detection equipment has a limiting sensitivity, so that our observations are necessarily cut off at that limit: if we were to conclude from this that no sources exist below that luminosity, we would be completely wrong. Like other astronomical observations, pulsar observations are plagued by several selection effects, of which we give a few examples here. The classic example is that of the distribution of pulsars projected onto the plane of our galaxy (i.e., a distribution in r and θ, in terms of the coordinates defined earlier). This shows a huge concentration of pulsars around the Sun [see, e.g., Fig. 8.2 in Lyne & Graham-Smith 1990], which is, of course, not real: it merely reflects the fact that pulsars are harder to detect when they are farther away from us, since the flux detected at Earth goes down as the inverse square, d−2 , of the pulsar’s distance from us. Indeed, the observed pulsars represent only that small minority of the galactic population of pulsars which have very high luminosity and so are detectable from the Earth. Conversely, although only a small percentage of the pulsars discovered by our radio telescopes have low luminosities (∼ 0.3– 3 mJy kpc2 , say), they represent the overwhelming majority of the galactic population [Lyne & Graham-Smith 1990]. In order to determine the true distribution, this selection effect has to be taken into account. Another well-known example can be seen in Fig. 1.6, namely the apparent concentration of pulsars near the galactic longitude l = 50◦ . This is also not real, but only reflects the fact that the famous Arecibo survey of pulsars was very deep (i.e., went down to very low limiting fluxes), but covered only this region of the sky, so that it preferentially detected a large number of pulsars only in this region. A diagnostic use of the cumulative number of pulsars N (d) with distances ≤ d serves as a further example. The reader can easily show that, if the pulsars were distributed uniformly through a galactic disk of half-thickness h, then N should scale as d3 for d < h, and as d2 for d > h. The observed N (d) vs. d distribution [Manchester & Taylor 1977; Beskin et al. 1993] roughly follows this scaling upto a limiting distance dl , at which point the curve drops below the d2 -line. This only means that a significant fraction of pulsars begins to become undetectable beyond dl due to the limiting sensitivity. Entirely as expected, dl is found to be larger for pulsar surveys which are more sensitive (i.e., which have lower thresholds of detection): Beskin et al. (1993) illustrate this point with the fact that the Jodrell Bank I survey, with a threshold flux density ∼ 15 mJy, had
January 10, 2007
16:24
34
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
Rotation and Accretion Powered Pulsars
dl ∼ 1 kpc, while the more sensitive Massacusetts-Arecibo I survey, with a tenfold lower threshold, had dl ∼ 5 kpc. 1.5.2
Accretion-Powered Pulsars
Of the ∼ 110 known accretion-powered pulsars today, ∼ 2 are in our neighboring Andromeda galaxy (M31), ∼ 1 in M33, ∼ 32 are in the Small Magellanic Cloud (SMC), ∼ 6 in the Large Magellanic Cloud (LMC), and ∼ 68 in our Milky Way. Thus, some ∼ 40 such pulsars have been found in the Magellanic Clouds: these pulsars have been discovered in profusion only in the last few years, before which there were only about 3 such known [Nagase 2001], although the discovery of the first such source, SMC X-1, goes back to 1976, i.e., relatively early days of X-ray astronomy. Some essential parameters of these pulsars are listed in Table E.1 in Appendix A. Note that the SMC/LMC pulsars, and a few well-known individual pulsars like Her X-1 and X Per, are significantly away from the galactic plane, but the majority of the accretion-powered pulsars are in, or close to, the galactic plane. Actually, it is the Massive (or High-Mass) X-ray Binaries (HMXBs for short; see Chapter 9), which follow the disk population of massive stars in our galaxy, since these are their progenitors. The LowMass X-ray Binaries (LMXBs for short; see Chapter 9) are largely a bulge population, following the distribution of old, low-mass stars in the bulge of our galaxy. Since HMXBs are, by far, the dominant population among accretion-powered pulsars, the whole population also roughly follows the galactic disk. The distribution of accretion-powered pulsars in galactic coordinates is shown in Fig. 1.8.
1.6
Period Distributions of Pulsars
The distribution of the pulse periods of rotation-powered pulsars is shown in Fig. 1.9 [Manchester et al. 2005]. As these authors point out, the distribution is clearly bimodal, with a dichotomy between “normal” pulsars in the period range of about 0.1 second to 10 seconds, and recycled “millisecond” pulsars in the period range of about 1 to 10 milliseconds. Evolutionary origins of this, and related phenomena, will occupy us over much of this book. Further, as these authors also stress, binary rotation-powered pulsars have pulse periods predominantly in the millisecond range, a major key to the
pranab
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
The Discovery of Pulsars
pranab
35
Accretion Powered Pulsars
Her X-1
LMC
SMC
Fig. 1.8 Distribution of accretion-powered pulsars in the Galaxy, in the Small Magellanic Cloud (SMC), and in the Large Magellanic Cloud (LMC) in galactic co-ordinates (see Appendix A), using a Hammer-Aitoff (equal-area) projection. Asterisks: pulsars in HMXBs. Diamonds: pulsars in LMXBs (including systems like Her X-1; see Chapter 9). Squares: pulsars in binaries whose natures are not certain yet (see Table E.1). Labeled are some sources significantly off the galactic plane: Her X-1, SMC, and LMC. The numerous pulsars in SMC appear as a cluster, and similarly for LMC. Accretion-powered millisecond pulsars (see Chapter 6) form a cluster around the galactic center, and some have been omitted for clarity. Not shown are AXPs (see Chapter 9), and pulsars in M31 and M33. Data partly from Nagase (2003).
idea of recycling, which we discuss in Chapter 6, and elsewhere in the book. Expected rotation periods of nascent neutron stars are considered in the discussion in Chapter 6 of the birth of neutron stars in supernovae. The distribution of the pulse periods of accretion-powered pulsars is shown in Fig. 1.10 [Laycock et al. 2005], wherein pulsars in the Galaxy, SMC, and LMC are included, as indicated. Barring one or two very short and long-period pulsars, the whole distribution runs from about half a second to several thousand seconds. The galactic pulsar population appears skewed toward longer periods compared to the SMC population, which could be a selection effect, but is not really clear at present, as discussed by these authors. Evolutionary and dynamical origins of the pulse periods
January 10, 2007
36
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
Rotation and Accretion Powered Pulsars
observed in accretion-powered pulsars are discussed in Chapters 6, 9, and 12. One of the major consequences of the recycling scenario, as discussed in Chapter 6 and further elaborated on in Chapter 12, is a comprehensive account of how a spinning neutron star in a binary functions first as a rotation-powered pulsar somewhere in the right-hand part of the distribution of Fig. 1.9, then as an accretion-powered pulsar somwhere in the distribution of Fig. 1.10, and finally, after recycling, again as a rotationpowered pulsar, but now somewhere in the left-hand part of Fig. 1.9. This is, undoubtedly, a major road-marker in today’s high-energy astrophysics.
Fig. 1.9 Distribution of the pulse periods of rotation-powered pulsars and AXPs (see Chapter 9). Reproduced by permission of the AAS from Manchester et al. (2005): see Bibliography.
pranab
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
The Discovery of Pulsars
pranab
37
Fig. 1.10 Distribution of the pulse periods of accretion-powered pulsars in the Galaxy, the Small Magellanic Cloud (SMC) and the Large Magellanic Cloud (LMC), as indicated. Reproduced by permission of the AAS from Laycock et al. (2005): see Bibliography.
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
This page intentionally left blank
pranab
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
Chapter 2
Physics of Neutron Stars — I Degenerate Stars
2.1
Historical Notes on Neutron Stars
While reminiscing at a Solvay Conference in 1973 a few months before his death, Rosenfeld (1974) recalled a lively discussion in Bohr’s institute on that day in 1932 when the news of Chadwick’s discovery of the neutron reached from Cambridge to Copenhagen. During this discussion, Landau, who was visiting the institute, proposed the idea of Unheimliche Sterne (Strange1 Stars), which Rosenfeld identified with neutron stars. Landau thought that these stars would normally be invisible, showing their existence only by causing explosions when they collided with normal stars, and that these explosions could be supernovae. It is unclear if Landau was really thinking about what we call neutron stars today. According to Rosenfeld, Landau then published a paper in which he mentioned neutron stars and (mistakenly) thought that they were systems “to which quantum mechanics would not be applicable”. Actually, the Landau (1932) paper to which Rosenfeld was apparently referring does not mention neutron stars at all. It is essentially a re-derivation of Chandrasekhar’s (1931a,b,c) celebrated result on the maximum mass (∼ 1.4M) of white dwarfs (i.e., stars which have exhausted their nuclear fuel and are supported by the pressure of degenerate electrons; see Sec. 2.4), the Chandrasekhar limit, above which white dwarfs cannot exist, and matter collapses further (see below). Landau’s arguments, which we summarize in Sec. 2.3, were brilliant in their intuitive appeal, and provided the first physical explanation of the mass 1 The
adjective unheimlich normally translates as “weird” or “sinister”: Rosenfeld chose the first meaning. In the neutron-star context, a more suitable adjective would have been “strange” or “exotic”, whose German equivalent would be closer to unheim. Why Landau applied a negative connotation is unknown, assuming that the Rosenfeld quotation is accurate. 39
pranab
January 10, 2007
40
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
Rotation and Accretion Powered Pulsars
limit to white dwarf stars which is now named after Chandrasekhar. However, there appears to be no mention of neutronized matter in stars in the papers of either Landau2 or Chandrasekhar until about 1938. The name “neutron star” was coined by Baade and Zwicky in 1934 while attempting a connection between the intensity of cosmic rays observed on the Earth, and the energy released in supernova3 explosions of stars, whose study they had pioneered. They made the following, justifiably famous, statement: “With all reserve we advance the view that supernovae represent the transitions from ordinary stars into neutron stars, which in their final stages consist of extremely closely packed neutrons.”, which has been called “prescient” [Shapiro & Teukolsky 1983]. Indeed, it appears today that the statement did not come from an understanding of what we believe now to be the correct supernova mechanism (see below and Chapter 6). Due to a gross overestimate of the energy output of supernovae, these authors came to the (incorrect) conclusion that “in the supernova process mass in bulk is annihilated” (Baade & Zwicky 1934a,b,c) and converted into the energy of supernova explosions, and went on to suggest that the remainder of the star’s mass would become a neutron star. Further, it also seems that Baade and Zwicky had no inkling of the physical reason why stellar matter must consist mostly of neutrons at extremely high densities4 . Ironically, the fundamental physics that makes the process of neutronization inevitable at very high densities of stellar (or other) matter, namely, that it is then energetically favorable for electrons to combine with the protons in the nuclei to produce neutrons (a process called inverse β-decay), had already been discovered in 1933 by Sterne, but not appreciated fully. Sterne (1933) constructed a statistical theory of the equilibrium nuclear abundances in stellar matter, based on the properties of nuclei and the 2 Landau did state in his 1932 paper that “all stars heavier than 1.5M certainly pos sess regions in which laws of quantum mechanics (and therefore of quantum statistics) are violated”, and did suggest that this might “occur when the density of matter becomes so great that atomic nuclei come in close contact, forming one gigantic nucleus”. However, this had nothing to do with neutronized matter. While writing his 1932 paper (which was done before Chadwick’s discovery of the neutron in the same year), Landau, like most physicists of his time, still thought that atomic nuclei were composed of protons and electrons, as a glance at his paper will show. Perhaps we should take Landau’s speculations metaphorically, not literally. 3 The name “supernova” was also coined by Baade & Zwicky. 4 In fact, Baade and Zwicky (1934c) made such statements as: “If neutrons are produced on the surface of an ordinary star they will “rain” down towards the center...”.
pranab
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
Degenerate Stars
pranab
41
neutron known at the time. He expressed one “conclusion of a simple nature” from the graphical display of his results, reproduced in Fig. 2.1, as: “At these high densities, matter at low temperatures would be literally squeezed together into the form of neutrons.”, which, in retrospect, we can only call profound: it was not speculative, but the result of quantitative calculations. Naturally, Sterne’s estimate of the lower bound on the density above which matter would be extremely 10 −3 neutron-rich (ρ > ∼ 2.3 × 10 g cm ) is roughly consistent with the results of modern calculations (see Sec. (3.3)). Even his words for describing the neutronization process, as quoted above, were so accurately picturesque that Gamow (1939) later adopted them almost verbatim to write “electrons are, so to speak, squeezed into the nuclei”, an imagery we continue to use to this day. But the profound astrophysical implications of this result were lost on Sterne himself. In his excellent 1936 review entitled “Matter under very high pressures and temperatures”, Hund gave a thorough discussion of Sterne’s results, and displayed, in a pioneering fashion, the equation of state (i.e., the pressure vs. density relation) of high-density matter, complete with the “kink” in it that accompanies neutronization. Hund also coined the term Dichte
Fig. 2.1 Equilibrium nuclear abundance calculated by Sterne (1933). Shown are the “abundance lines” for various species. x is a rough measure of the density, and −y a rough measure of the abundance in completely degenerate (T → 0) matter. Since the line for neutrons has the highest slope, it follows that neutrons will dominate the matter at sufficiently high densities. Reproduced by permission of Blackwell Publishing from Sterne (1933): see Bibliography.
January 10, 2007
42
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
Rotation and Accretion Powered Pulsars
Sterne, which roughly translates as “Compact Stars” – a name which is universally used today for degenerate stars, and he discussed the significance of the Landau mass scale (see Sec. 2.3) and the gravitational radius associated with it. Ironically, again, Hund failed to recognize the possibility of a new kind of stars supported by the pressure of degenerate neutrons, considering neutronization only as a perturbation in the dense regions of white dwarfs, and discussing the collapse of more massive stars into black holes (see below). It remained for Gamow (1936) to make the brilliant astrophysical connection, suggesting in the following words that neutron cores would be formed at the centers of sufficiently massive stars after exhaustion of their nuclear fuel: “For still higher densities electrons will probably be absorbed by the nuclei (an inverse β-decay process) and the mixture will tend to a state which can be described very roughly as a gas of neutrons. For densities of the order of magnitude ρ ∼ 1012 gm/cm3 (average density of atomic nuclei) nuclear exchange forces between the gas particles will come into play and the conditions in the ‘gas’ will become analogous to the conditions inside an atomic nucleus. Such an extreme state of matter we shall call the ‘nuclear state’ and the region of the star occupied by such nuclear matter the ‘stellar nucleus’.” In 1938, Landau considered neutron cores of stars, estimating the minimum mass above which neutronized matter would be more stable than “normal” matter consisting of nuclei and electrons, and stating that he had in 1932 “already shown that the formation of a core must certainly take place in a body with mass greater than 1.5M ”. Today, Landau’s 1938 statement could be dubbed fanciful (see above), were it not for the crucial historical fact that it inspired Oppenheimer and Volkoff (1939) to do their seminal work on neutron stars, which has since served as the point of departure for all modern work. Still thinking of neutron cores rather than neutron stars, Oppenheimer and Volkoff scrutinized the ∼ 1.5M Landau limit in the light of the most accurate treatment of the essential physics possible at the time. They noted first the minor point that the Landau limit should really be ∼ 5.7M for neutrons, and not the ∼ 1.4M value relevant for white dwarfs (Gamow had made the same error in 1936), since the limit goes as the inverse square of the “mass per particle obtained by spreading out the total mass over only those particles which essentially determine the pressure of the Fermi gas”: this mass is approximately twice the nucleon mass for white dwarfs (since, on the average, there are roughly
pranab
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
Degenerate Stars
pranab
43
two nucleons per electron in white dwarf matter, and degenerate electrons supply the pressure), but equal to the nucleon mass for neutron stars (since their matter is mostly neutrons, which themselves supply the pressure). But it was the masterly handling of two major points of the physics of neutron stars by Oppenheimer and Volkoff that made their paper a milestone. These were: (1) that at the enormous densities of neutron stars, Newtonian gravitational theory was not adequate, and general relativistic effects must be included, and, (2) that the neutrons, because of their large mass, would be non-relativistically degenerate, in contrast to the relativistically degenerate electrons (see Sec. (2.4)) in white dwarfs, and the correct equation of state must be used. The inclusion of these effects (actually, Oppenheimer and Volkoff used an equation of state valid for both non-relativistic and relativistic regimes) brought the above limit down to ∼ 0.7M: above this mass, no equilibrium configuration would be possible, and the core would continue to collapse indefinitely. Below this limit, which now bears the name of Oppenheimer and Volkoff, their quantitative calculations of the masses and radii of neutron stars—the first ever done—stood for twenty years before they were improved upon. These improvements came from one crucial point of physics that was still missing from their treatment, namely, the interaction between the neutrons: by assuming a Fermi gas of free neutrons, Oppenheimer and Volkoff had neglected this completely. In an era when children learn in school that stars produce energy by converting hydrogen to helium through thermonuclear reactions (see Appendix C), it may be difficult for us to believe that the main motivation behind the original interest of Landau, Gamow (1936), and others in neutron cores was their possible role as stellar energy source. In the period 1937-39, however, the stellar-energy problem was satisfactorily solved by the pioneering and classic works of von Weizs¨ acker, Bethe, and others on stellar thermonuclear reactions. After this, the above motivation vanished, and, with it, most of the interest in neutron stars. More disastrous was the fact that Oppenheimer, who, by 1939, had accepted the central role of thermonuclear energy generation in stars, and was studying neutron cores for exploring their role in stellar evolution after the exhaustion of nuclear fuel, himself came to the (manifestly incorrect) conclusion that “it seems unlikely that static neutron cores can play any great part in stellar evolution” [Oppenheimer & Volkoff 1939], and never returned to the subject. This conclusion was based on the fact that the Oppenheimer-Volkoff limit, as calculated by these authors themselves (∼ 0.7M), was considerably lower than the Chandrasekhar limit (∼ 1.5M ). Since the latter limit had to be
January 10, 2007
44
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
Rotation and Accretion Powered Pulsars
exceeded before the collapse could proceed further towards the formation of a neutron core, and since such a neutron core would be unstable because it was above the former limit, it was not clear how neutron cores would ever be produced in nature. It was to be two decades before this paradox would be resolved by the inclusion of neutron-neutron interactions (see below), which showed that the Oppenheimer-Volkoff limit was, in fact, above the Chandrasekhar limit, so that there was no problem in forming neutron cores or stars. Indeed, we are well aware today of the key roles played by neutron cores and neutron stars in the late stages of stellar evolution, without which there would be no need to write this book. Physicists will be thankful today for Zwicky’s missionary service for the cause of neutron stars, but for which there was little mention of these Unheimliche Sterne anywhere until the late 1950s. When progress did come to the field in 1958, it was actually as a sidelight of a “resurvey” of the basic aspects of gravitational collapse by Harrison, Wakano, and Wheeler (1958), in which they attempted to “connect up” (for purposes of completeness) the Chandrasekhar limit and the Oppenheimer-Volkoff limit. However, the resulting construction of the equation of state of matter from ordinary to super-nuclear densities (spanning about twenty orders of magnitude) was pioneering, as were the computations of the masses and radii of collapsed objects over this entire range of densities (also see Harrison, Thorne, Wakano, and Wheeler 1965, henceforth HTWW, and Wheeler 1966). These partly inspired the next stage of development, and the detailed work on neutron stars in the post-pulsar “modern” era (see below) has often used these early models as reference points. In 1959, Cameron took the crucial next step of introducing neutronneutron interactions into neutron-star calculations (also see Ambartsumyan and Saakyan 1960). Using the effective nuclear potential (then newly) proposed by Skyrme (1959), Cameron (1959b) showed that the OppenheimerVolkoff limit was raised to ∼ 2M , i.e., above the Chandrasekhar limit, aptly calling the result “very gratifying”, since it solved the Oppenheimer paradox5. Cameron (correctly) speculated that the latter result would be a general one, and consequently that there would be no difficulty in forming neutron stars in supernovae: modern calculations have borne this out. Further, confirming the visionary comments of Gamow (1939), Cameron described the basic scenarios (1959a) for (a) the chain of nuclear reactions in the stellar core preceding a supernova, (b) the collapse of the neutron 5 After Saakyan (1963) corrected an error in Cameron’s treatment of energy density, the limit came down to ∼ 1.7M , but still remained above the Chandrasekhar limit.
pranab
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
Degenerate Stars
pranab
45
core, and, (c) the expulsion of the rest of the star by the energy released in the collapse. These appear to be the seeds from which the subsequent, detailed, computational scenarios for the birth of neutron stars in supernova explosions and core collapses, such as those pioneered by Colgate and co-authors in the 1960s [Colgate & White 1966], have grown. Research on neutron-star models was continued in the mid-1960s by Tsuruta and Cameron (1965), who used the more elaborate Levinger-Simmons nuclear potential, by Saakyan and co-authors [Saakyan & Vartanyan 1964], who used their own nuclear potential, and by Salpeter and co-authors [Hamada & Salpeter 1961]. It was primarily the discovery of cosmic X-ray sources outside the solar system [Giacconi et al. 1962], a major event in high energy astrophysics (see Sec. 1.2), that sustained practical interest6 in neutron stars during the above era. The principal motivation at the time was the possibility that the observed X-rays from the discrete X-ray sources could be thermal radiation from young, hot neutron stars, which prompted calculations of the cooling rates of such neutron stars [Bahcall & Wolf 1965a; Tsuruta & Cameron 1965]. As we know today, the X-ray sources discovered in this era were largely powered by either (a) the release of gravitational energy during accretion onto neutron stars, for point-like sources, or, (b) thermal and nonthermal emission from hot plasmas containing magnetic fields in supernova remnants (like the Crab nebula), for extended sources. However, these cooling calculations did prove useful later. Another major event, namely, Schmidt’s 1963 discovery of quasars, also spurred brief interest in neutron stars, because of a mistaken belief. It was thought at first that the large redshifts of quasar spectral lines could be of general-relativistic origin, arising in the strong gravity on the surfaces of neutron stars, similar to what Zwicky had (also mistakenly) proposed in the 1930s as the cause of the line-shifts in the spectra of supernovae. This idea was soon abandoned as it became clear that the largest quasar redshift observed by then (small compared to the largest value known today) already exceeded the maximum redshift possible from neutron-star surfaces. It remained for the discovery of rotation-powered pulsars in 1967 and their rapid identification with neutron stars (see Chapter 1) to finally catalyze an era of intense research on the physics of neutron stars: this can be called the “modern” era of neutron-star research. An historical irony regarding the identification of neutron stars with pulsars is famous: this 6 See
the Bahcall-Wolf comment quoted in Sec. 1.1.
January 10, 2007
46
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
Rotation and Accretion Powered Pulsars
concerns Pacini’s classic 1967 paper, which had appeared about two weeks before Bell detected the first pulses from a radio pulsar (see Sec. 1.1). Pacini (1967) had, in this paper, estimated the rate of emission of electromagnetic radiation from a rotating neutron star with a dipolar magnetic field. Yet, his paper was unknown not only to the radio-astronomers who discovered the first pulsars [Hewish et al. 1968], and did not even consider the possibility in their discovery paper that the rotation of neutron stars could be the cause of the pulses, but also to Gold (1968), who did make the definitive connection between pulsars and rotating neutron stars in his seminal paper. At first, this may sound unbelievable, since all of the above scientists published their works in the same journal (Nature) within a period of about seven months, and further since Pacini and Gold were apparently at the same academic institution at the time [Lyne & Graham-Smith 1990]. However, we must not forget that no one was expecting observable periodic pulses of electromagnetic radiation from neutron stars in 1967. Pacini (1967) was only interested in the consequences of the absorption of electromagnetic radiation from neutron stars by their supernova remnants, such as the Crab Nebula. Intrigued by an earlier suggestion that vibrations of a magnetized neutron star could be this source of electromagnetic radiation, Pacini was actually looking for an alternative source because the original suggestion had been found to be untenable by then, and found this in the magnetic dipole radiation from a rotating neutron star. Radio astronomers have explored possible causes for why pulsars had not been discovered before 1967, although radio telescopes capable of doing so had existed since the 1950s [Manchester & Taylor 1977; Lyne & Graham-Smith 1990]. A similar attempt to explore possible causes of the inadequacy of human imagination, which had failed to predict that periodic electromagnetic pulses from neutron stars could reach our detectors on (or near) the Earth before such pulses were actually discovered, would be futile. The fact remains that these clock-like pulses across the electromagnetic spectrum, from radio to γ-rays, are the best signature for identifying neutron stars today: these pulses tell us the rotation periods of neutron stars, and the changes in the periods of the pulses give us valuable information on the magnetic field and internal structure of neutron stars, and on the flow of matter around these stars when they occur in accreting binary systems. The pulses are, of course, the origin of the name “pulsar”, which has now become almost synonymous with the words “neutron star”.
pranab
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
Degenerate Stars
2.2
pranab
47
Degenerate Stars
A normal star like the Sun generates thermal energy through thermonuclear reactions in its interior. Its size is determined by a balance between the selfgravitational attraction of the stellar mass, which tends to contract the star to its center, and the thermal pressure, which tends to expand it outward. When its nuclear fuel is exhausted completely, the star has no further source of energy. It turns colder and contracts, converting gravitational potential energy released in the infall into thermal energy, and radiating it away (see Appendix C). But the star cannot go on contracting indefinitely in this manner, extracting its own gravitational potential energy and shrinking to arbitrarily small radii. At sufficiently high densities, stellar matter becomes degenerate7 , following quantum statistics (i.e., Fermi-Dirac statistics for particles with half-integral spin, called fermions, which the stellar matter is composed of) instead of the classical Maxwell-Boltzmann statistics.
2.2.1
Degeneracy
In statistical mechanics, the volume in the six-dimensional phase space (i.e., the space of coordinates and momenta) available to structureless particles of mass m with momenta between p and p + dp is 4πV p2 dp, where V is the physical volume occupied by the particles. For fermions with spin 12 , such as electrons, protons, and neutrons, this expression is multiplied by a factor 2, corresponding to the two possible orientations of such a spin. According 7 The use of the word ‘degenerate’ here is in its original etymological sense of “deviant from the ideal situation” (with an implied derogatory connotation), the ‘ideal’ in this case being the classical Maxwell-Boltzmann statistics. There is nothing ‘ideal’ about Maxwell-Boltzmann statistics, of course; it is only a useful limiting case. Further, there is an unfortunate confusion between this usage and that of the same word ‘degenerate’ for a wholly different quantum-mechanical phenomenon, in which the eigenvalues corresponding to two or more distinct eigenstates are identical. This confusion arose from an indiscriminate use of the words ‘degenerate’ and ‘degeneracy’ (actually, their German equivalents entartet and entartung respectively, as much of the original work on both quantum statistics and quantum mechanics was published in German) in both contexts in the early days of quantum mechanics. The usage in quantum statistics was apparently pioneered by Fermi (1926), and continued extensively by Sommerfeld (1928) in his classic study of degenerate electrons in metals. The usage in quantum mechanics, itself more emotive than scientific, can be clearly seen in the pioneering work of Born, Heisenberg and Jordan (1926) on quantum-mechanical perturbation theory. In his famous book on quantum mechanics, Dirac (1958) remarked about this latter usage that “these words are not very appropriate from the modern point of view”, but no one apparently took heed.
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
pranab
Rotation and Accretion Powered Pulsars
48
to the simple description of quantum statistics pioneered by Einstein8 , the phase space can be pictured as being divided into ‘cells’ of volume h3 , h being Planck’s constant, and the three factors of h corresponding to the three translational degrees of freedom, since each such degree yields dpdq ∼ h according to quantum mechanics. The number a of cells available to particles in this energy range is thus a = 4πV p2 dp(2/h3 ), and the problem of distributing s such particles into these cells becomes a combinatorial one, the result of which depends on what rules we follow about how many particles can go into a given cell. Two situations arise naturally, viz., (1) there is no limit to the number of particles that a cell can contain, so that each cell can have 0, 1, 2, ... s particles, or, (2) a cell can contain no more than one particle (Pauli’s exclusion principle), so that each cell can only have 0 or 1 particle. The former situation leads to Bose-Einstein statistics, applicable to particles with zero or integral spin, e.g., photons (which are described by symmetric quantum-mechanical wave functions), and the latter situation to Fermi-Dirac statistics, applicable to particles with half-integral spin, e.g., electrons, protons, and neutrons (which are described by antisymmetric wave functions). The classical Maxwell-Boltzmann statistics is the limit of a s: both Bose-Einstein and Fermi-Dirac statistics then reduce to the classical one, since the above rules for putting particles into cells make little difference in this limit, as must be clear on a little reflection. For a given statistics, the distribution function f is the average occupation number of a cell (i.e., the average number of particles in it), as defined above, in that statistics. The distribution function is normally expressed in terms of the kinetic energy E ≡ p2 c2 + m2 c4 − mc2 rather than the momentum p. In the non-relativistic (NR) r´egime, where p mc, E reduces to E ≈ p2 /2m, while in the extremely relativsitic (ER) r´egime, where p mc, E is approximately given by E ≈ pc. For the classical Maxwell-Boltzmann case, the distribution function has the form fMB (E) ∝ exp(−E/kT ), where k is Boltzmann’s constant, and T is the temperature of the system. In Fermi-Dirac statistics, f (E) is given by fFD (E) ≡
1 A
exp
1
E kT
+1
,
(2.1)
where A is the degeneracy parameter introduced by Fermi (1926) and Sommerfeld (1928) to facilitate comparison with the classical MaxwellBoltzmann statistics. For A 1, if we multiply the numerator and the 8A
more rigorous approach is through the Schr¨ odinger equation; see Fowler 1927.
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
Degenerate Stars
pranab
49
denominator of the right-hand side of Eq. (2.1) by A and neglect higher powers of A, we recover the classical statistics: fMB (E) = A exp[−E/kT ].
(2.2)
Small values of A thus correspond to classical, or non-degenerate, behavior, and large values of A to highly degenerate behavior. The boundary between the two r´egimes is approximately determined by the condition A = 1. The degeneracy parameter is often recast in terms of a reference potential µ as A ≡ exp(µ/kT ), µ being called the chemical potential, and the Fermi-Dirac distribution written in the standard form fFD (E) ≡
1 1 + exp
E−µ kT
.
(2.3)
The functional form on the right-hand side of Eq. (2.3) is now called the Fermi function; it is also useful in other contexts in physics, as we shall see later in the book. Classical behavior then corresponds to large negative chemical potentials, and highly degenerate behavior to large positive ones, the transition region being given by | µ | kT . The degeneracy parameter A is a function of the mass m and the number density n of the particles, and of the temperature T . The value of A can be determined by noting that the total number, N = nV , of the particles in the volume V is obtained by multiplying the number of phase-space cells a in the momentum range p to p+dp, as given above, by the distribution function f given in the previous paragraph, and integrating over all momenta. For the classical distribution (given by Eq. [2.2]) in the NR r´egime, this yields A=
nh3 . 2(2πmkT )3/2
(2.4)
Strictly speaking, this equation is valid only in the limit A 1 and in the NR r´egime, but it often serves as an excellent estimate of A for deciding whether a given system is degenerate or not9 . If A, as calculated from Eq. (2.4), is 1, the system is non-degenerate; if it is 1, the system is degenerate. It is clear from Eq. (2.4) that systems at low densities and high temperatures are non-degenerate, while those at high densities and 9 The exact value of A for the Fermi-Dirac distribution of Eq. (2.1) can, of course, be determined by numerical integration. For the NR r´egime, Sommerfeld (1928) has given an analytic series solution for A 1. The corresponding result for the ER r´egime has been given by Chandrasekhar (1931c).
January 10, 2007
16:24
50
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
pranab
Rotation and Accretion Powered Pulsars
low temperatures are degenerate. Further, at the same number density and temperature, lighter particles are more degenerate than heavier ones. 2.2.2
Electron Degeneracy
The classic use of the above degeneracy criterion is the 1928 demonstration by Sommerfeld that the electron gas in metals is highly degenerate even at normal temperatures, because of the smallness of the electron mass. This follows immediately from Eq. (2.4) on substituting the electron mass for m: we get A ≈ 2 × 10−16ne T −3/2 , where ne is the number density of electrons. If we approximate the number density of conduction electrons by that of the metal atoms, nM = ρNA /A, where ρ is the metal’s density in g cm−3 , A is its atomic weight, and NA is Avogadro’s number, we get ne ≈ 6 × 1022 cm−3 for silver with ρAg = 10.5 and AAg = 107.9. Thus, at T = 300 K, the degeneracy criterion for silver stands at AAg ≈ 2.4 × 103 , so that the conduction electrons in it are very degenerate indeed. What about the degeneracy of electrons in stars? Consider a spherical star of total mass M and radius R in hydrostatic equilibrium, the condition for which in the radial direction is: Gm(r) dP (r) = −ρ(r) . dr r2
(2.5)
Here, P is the total pressure, ρ is the density, and m(r) is the mass contained within a radius r from the center of the star, all of which are functions of r in general. From Eq. (10.35), which is a local equation valid at every point inside the star, we can obtain a global condition which is approximately valid for the star as a whole. This very useful estimate, which is widely used in astrophysics, proceeds as follows. We replace the local variables P and ρ by their average values P¯ and ρ¯ ≡ 3M/4πR3 over the whole star, and the derivative d/dr by a dimensional estimate ∼ 1/R of its average value. If, further, we consider a star whose pressure is dominated by that of its gas content, we can write P¯ ∼ 2¯ nk T¯ , and Eq. (10.35) yields k T¯ ∼
GM mp . 2R
(2.6)
Here, n ¯ = ρ¯/mp is the average number density of protons, mp being the proton mass, and we are considering for simplicity a gas consisting predominantly of hydrogen. Eq. (2.6) is the useful dimensional estimate of the average stellar temperature we were seeking. We now return to Eq. (2.4), which gives the degeneracy parameter for electrons with m = me , n = ne ,
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
Degenerate Stars
pranab
51
and T = Te . Using ne ≈ n ¯ and Te ≈ T¯ as given by Eq. (2.6), we obtain an estimate of the average electron-degeneracy parameter of the star: 1/2 −1 ρ¯ M (3ρ¯)1/2 h3 A∗ ∼ ∼ . (2.7) 5/2 3/2 2 × 104 g cm−3 M 2π 2 G3/2 M mp me The crucial role of stellar density in deciding electron degeneracy in stellar matter is evident from Eq. (2.7). A normal star like the Sun with ρ¯ ∼ 1 g cm−3 has A∗ ∼ 10−2 , and so is non-degenerate, as expected. A white dwarf star with ρ¯ ∼ 106 g cm−3 (see below) and mass comparable to that of the Sun has A∗ ∼ 10, so that the electrons in it are degenerate. Indeed, it is the pressure of the degenerate electrons that balances the self-gravitational attraction of matter in a white dwarf, leading to an equilibrium stellar configuration, as we shall see in detail in Sec. (2.2.3). The transition from non-degenerate to degenerate electrons, roughly given by A∗ ∼ 1, occurs at an average stellar density ∼ 2 × 104 g cm−3 for solar-mass stars. 2.2.3
Neutron Degeneracy
Sidestepping, for the moment, the details of the circumstances under which stellar matter may come to consist mostly of neutrons (to which we return in later sections), we can now ask the question: can such neutronized stellar matter become degenerate, and, if so, at what densities? Eq. (2.4) readily provides a crude but useful answer. Setting m = mn in it, where mn is the mass of the neutron, and following a procedure otherwise identical to that used above for electron degeneracy, we obtain the following estimate of the average neutron-degeneracy parameter: 1/2 −1 ρ¯ M (3ρ¯)1/2 h3 ∼ . (2.8) A∗ ∼ 2 3/2 1014 g cm−3 M 2π G M m4n It is clear from Eq. (2.8) that neutronized stellar matter becomes degenerate 14 −3 at ρ¯ > ∼ 10 g cm , which are just the typical average densities of neutron stars (see below). Thus, neutron-star matter is expected to be degenerate. 2.2.4
Complete Degeneracy
The extreme case of strong degeneracy occurs in the limit T → 0, which is called complete degeneracy. It is clear from Eq. (2.4) that, for given values of n and m, the degeneracy parameter becomes arbitrarily large in this limit. What happens to the Fermi-Dirac distribution then? To see this,
January 10, 2007
52
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
pranab
Rotation and Accretion Powered Pulsars
note first that the chemical potential µ, defined above by A ≡ exp(µ/kT ), remains finite in this limit, while A → ∞, of course. Call this limiting value µ0 . Note next that the Fermi-Dirac distribution, as given by Eq. (2.3) becomes very simple in the limit T → 0. If E < µ0 , fF D = 1, and if E > µ0 , fF D = 0. Thus, µ0 is the limiting kinetic energy of the fermions in this limit, and so of key importance. It is customary to define a limiting momentum, called pF , corresponding to µ0 by the the Fermi momentum 2 2 2 2 4 relation µ0 = pF c + m c − mc , to write the Fermi-Dirac distribution as fF D =
1 , p < pF , 0 , p > pF
(2.9)
and to state that all momentum states upto pF are completely filled, and all states above pF are completely empty. It is also customary to define a total 2 energy (i.e., including the rest energy mc of the fermion) corresponding 2 2 2 to pF by the relation EF ≡ pF c + m c4 , and call it the Fermi energy. All states of total energy upto the Fermi energy are then fully occupied in the limit of complete degeneracy, and all states above this energy are completely empty. We shall be using the complete-degeneracy limit throughout the next few sections while describing the basic properties of degenerate stars, not only because they were first calculated in this limit, but also because this limit contains the essence of the basic physics of degenerate stars, the finitetemperature effects being largely corrective factors, most important near the (low-density) surface layers of these stars, where matter passes from degenerate to non-degenerate state. In these T → 0 calculations, a relation between the Fermi momentum pF and the number density n that will be constantly useful is n=
8πp3F . 3h3
(2.10)
Equation (2.10) follows from the fact that n is the obtained by multiplying the number of phase-space cells a in the momentum range p to p + dp, as given earlier, by the Fermi-Dirac distribution in the complete-degeneracy limit, as given by Eq. (2.9), and integrating over all momenta. The Fermi momentum, or Fermi energy, is thus a direct measure of the number density of the completely degenerate fermions.
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
Degenerate Stars
2.3
pranab
53
The Landau Arguments
A key property of degenerate matter is that its kinetic energy and pressure do not vanish in the T → 0 or complete-degeneracy limit, in sharp contrast to the situation for non-degenerate matter following classical statistics. The residual values at T = 0, which are called zero-point energy and zero-point pressure (nullpunktsenergie and nullpunktsdruck respectively in the original German; see Fermi 1926 and Sommerfeld 1928), are crucial for determining the essential physics of degenerate stars like white dwarfs and neutron stars. It is this nullpunktsdruck that balances the self-gravitational attraction in these ‘dead’ stars, which have ceased to generate energy inside them by thermonuclear reactions, and makes equilibrium stellar configurations possible even for arbitrarily cold stellar matter. For a non-relativistic (NR) gas of fermions like electrons or neutrons, the zero-point kinetic energy Enull per particle and the zero-point pressure Pnull can be calculated from the completely degenerate Fermi-Dirac distribution of Eq. (2.9), and are given by [Fermi10 1926, Sommerfeld 1928]: Enull
3 = 40
2/3 2 2/3 3 h n , π m
Pnull
1 = 20
2/3 2 5/3 3 h n . π m
(2.11)
Here, n is the number density of the fermions and m is the fermion mass. For a highly relativistic (ER) fermion gas, on the other hand, the expressions for zero-point kinetic energy per particle and zero-point pressure are [Stoner 1930; Chandrasekhar 1931b,c]: Enull =
3 8
1/3 3 hcn1/3 , π
Pnull =
1 8
1/3 3 hcn4/3 , π
(2.12)
showing that these quantities are independent of the fermion mass in this limit. We shall derive the exact, general expression for zero-point kinetic energy per particle in Sec. 2.4.1, and that for zero-point pressure in Sec. 2.4.3: these expressions will be valid all the way from the NR to the ER r´egime. Consider now that the self-gravitational energy of a star of mass M and radius R, which is negative and of the form: Egrav = −αGM 2 /R,
(2.13)
where α is a structure factor depending on the density profile of the star. For a uniform density, ρ = ρ¯, we have R = (3M/4π ρ¯)1/3 , and α = 3/5, so 10 The
spin factor 2−2/3 was missing in Fermi’s original expressions.
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
pranab
Rotation and Accretion Powered Pulsars
54
that Egrav = −γGM 5/3 (¯ ρ)1/3 , where γ = (3/5)(4π/3)1/3 . For other density profiles, the form of Egrav remains the same with different values11 for the numbers α and γ, with ρ¯ signifying the average density of the star. Let the star be supported against self-gravity by the zero-point pressure of fermions whose total number is N , and whose number density is n. To relate these to M and ρ¯, we now define µ as the number of pressure-supporting fermions per nucleon in the star. This variable µ is of central importance in the subject: we shall use it constantly in this chapter, and elsewhere in the book. For white dwarfs, these fermions are the electrons, and the stellar matter consists of nucleons and electrons with µ ≈ 1/2, since most elements contain about two nucleons per electron. For neutron stars, on the other hand, these fermions are the neutrons, and since the stellar matter consists almost wholly of these neutrons themselves, µ ≈ 1. In general, we have N = M µ/mN and n = ρµ/mN . We can now define a self-gravitational energy per pressure-supporting fermion, Egrav = Egrav /N , which is given by n)1/3 , Egrav = −γ(mN /µ)4/3 GM 2/3 (¯
(2.14)
where n ¯ is the average value of n. For brevity, we shall henceforth omit the bars on n and ρ throughout the rest of this section. The scaling of the energies Egrav and Enull (in both the r´egimes described above) with the number density n can thus be expressed as: Egrav = −agrav n1/3 ,
NR 2/3 Enull = aNR , null n
ER 1/3 Enull = aER , null n
(2.15)
where the superscripts NR and ER respectively signify the non-relativistic and extreme-relativistic r´egimes, as before. The coefficients are given by: 4/3 2/3 2 1/3 mN h 3 3 3 3 ER , a GM 2/3 , aNR = = hc. agrav = γ null µ 40 π m null 8 π (2.16) These scalings had already been described by Stoner in 1930. But it remained for Landau to make use of them in 1932 to give a set of simple and brilliant arguments which showed that the mass of a self-gravitating star consisting of zero-temperature fermions could not exceed a limit which depended essentially only on the fundamental constants G, c, h, and the mass mN of a nucleon, quite independent of the details of how a degenerate star is put together. The heart of the Landau argument is a study of the behavior of the total energy, E = Egrav + Enull , per pressure-supporting fermion 11 For
a polytrope (see Sec. 2.2.3.2) of index s, α = 3/(5 − s).
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
Degenerate Stars
pranab
55
in the star. (Considering the behavior of the total energy of the whole star, i.e., E = EN , would give the same results, since the total number N of these fermions remains constant during all of the variational processes we might consider.) This gives us the existence and character of possible equilibrium configurations of the star, as we now show. Consider non-relativistic fermions first. The total energy E is given by 2/3 − agrav n1/3 , E NR = aNR null n
(2.17)
so that E NR is negative at small densities and scales as n1/3 , while it is positive at large densities and scales as n2/3 . As the reader can easily verify by sketching E NR as a function of n, as given by Eq. (2.17), there must always be a minimum in E NR , which is the (stable) equilibrium configuration of the star. The density at which this occurs is obtained by setting the derivative ∂E NR /∂n to zero, which gives 3 n = (agrav /2aNR null ) .
(2.18)
Thus, a stable equilibrium is always possible between the inward gravitational force and the outward zero-point pressure of degenerate nonrelativistic fermions: the star merely expands or contracts to achieve this equilibrium density, given by Eq. (2.18). Next consider extremely relativistic fermions. E is now given by 1/3 , E ER = (aER null − agrav )n
(2.19)
and the situation is completely different, since the monotonic variation of E ER with n makes any extremum impossible: the magnitude of the total energy always increases with density as n1/3 . This means that, if aER null > agrav , E ER is positive, and the star tries to minimize its energy by expanding ER is indefinitely to lower and lower densities. Conversely, if aER null < agrav , E negative, and the star tries to minimize its energy by collapsing indefinitely to higher and higher densities. Thus, no equilibrium is possible for extremerelativistic fermions in either of the above two cases. The transition between ER = 0 at all the two cases occurs when aER null = agrav , in which case E densities, and there is a neutral equilibrium. In reality, the fermions change from the NR to the ER r´egime at sufficiently high densities, the transition density nrel being given by the condition that the Fermi momentum (see above) of the degenerate fermions is comparable to mc, m being the fermion mass (so that the relativity
January 10, 2007
56
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
Rotation and Accretion Powered Pulsars
parameter x ≡ pF /mc becomes ∼ 1), or equivalently by the condition that NR ER and Enull , as given by Eq. (2.15), are comparable, which yields: Enull 3 5 1 mc 3 nrel = . (2.20) 4 3π 2 This corresponds to an average stellar mass density ρrel ∼ 2 × 106 g cm−3 when the fermions are electrons, and ρrel ∼ 1 × 1016 g cm−3 when the fermions are neutrons, as can be seen by substituting the appropriate fermion mass in Eq. (2.20). For stars of average densities ρrel , the pressure-supporting fermions are non-relativistic, while for stellar densities ρrel , they are highly relativistic. Thus, the electrons in white dwarfs of average density ρ ∼ 106 g cm−3 are mildly relativistic, while the neutrons in neutron stars of average density ρ ∼ 1014 g cm−3 are non-relativistic [Oppenheimer & Volkoff 1939], as we mentioned in §2.1. In an actual star, therefore, an appropriate combination of the above NR and ER results applies, as Landau argued. If aER null > agrav , the star expands until its density falls below nrel , at which point NR results apply, and the star achieves equilibrium, as described above. On the other hand, if aER null < agrav , the star keeps on collapsing without limit, reaching higher and higher densities, and making the fermions more and more ER: an equilibrium is never possible. Stars supported against self-gravity by the zero-point pressure of degenerate fermions can only exist, therefore, if aER null ≥ agrav . Use of Eq. (2.16) turns this condition into an upper limit on the stellar mass: 3/2 c 1 ML ≡ . (2.21) M ≤ Mc ≡ µL ML , G m2N Here, ML is the Landau mass scale, which depends only on universal constants and has a numerical value ≈ 3.69 × 1033 g ≈ 1.85M, and µL ≡ (9π/8)γ −3/2 µ2 is a number ∼ 1 whose value depends on the density profile of the star through γ. For the uniform-density case considered above, µL ≈ 3.72µ2 . With the aid of the exact expression for the zero-point kinetic energy given in Sec. 2.4.1, we display in Fig. 2.2 the variation of the total energy E with density (or, equivalently, with the relativity parameter x), extending from the NR to the ER r´egime, for a range of stellar masses M . For M < Mc , there is always a minimum in the energy corresponding to a stable equilibrium configuration, which is the actual configuration of the degenerate star of mass M . As M approaches Mc , this energy-minimum
pranab
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
pranab
Degenerate Stars
Total Energy (ε)
1.0
57
Landau arguments Newtonian
0.1
0.5
0.5
0.9
0.0 -0.5 -1.0 0.01
5.0 1.5
1.1
0.10 1.00 10.00 Relativity Parameter (x)
1.0
100.00
Fig. 2.2 Original Landau arguments for Newtonian gravity. Shown is the total energy per pressure-supporting fermion (E) in units of this fermion’s rest-mass energy for a uniform-density degenerate star vs. its relativity parameter x, the latter being a measure of its density (see text). Curves are given for various values of M/Mc , each curve labeled by its value of M/Mc . Dashed line: critical curve corresponding to M/Mc = 1, where the minima in the curves disappear. Curves corresponding to higher masses have no extrema, so that no equilibria are possible.
moves to higher and higher densities, i.e., higher and higher values of x, which simply means that higher stellar masses require higher densities for stable degenerate stars. In the limit M → Mc , this minimum occurs at arbitrarily high densities. For M > Mc , no minimum (indeed, no extremum of any kind) appears in the energy, and no equilibrium is possible. The total energy is then always negative, and its magnitude increases monotonically as density increases, indicating a collapse to arbitrarily high densities. Thus, degenerate stars supported by the zero-point pressure of a given kind of fermions (electrons, say) have a mass limit Mc they cannot exceed. A configuration of higher mass will not be supported by these fermions, and so will collapse, either indefinitely or until degenerate fermions of another kind (neutrons, say) can supply adequate zero-point pressure at sufficiently higher densities, if the latter situation is possible. To give a specific example, white dwarfs, which are supported by degenerate electrons, cannot exceed a mass limit named after Chandrsekhar (1931a,b,c). Masses above
January 10, 2007
16:24
58
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
Rotation and Accretion Powered Pulsars
the Chandrasekhar limit collapse until neutrons become degenerate at sufficiently high densities (see Sec. 2.1.2), and supply zero-point pressure. Then, if the mass does not exceed the limit which corresponds to degenerate neutrons and which is named after Oppenheimer and Volkoff (1939), a neutron star forms. Masses above the Oppenheimer-Volkoff limit collapse without limit, into a black hole. The wonderful thing about the Landau arguments is that they are quite general, equally applicable to electrons, neutrons, and any other degenerate fermions one can think of, although Landau himself did not stress this in his 1932 paper. The only feature missing in them is general relativity (since Landau used Newtonian theory of gravitation throughout his work), to which we shall return at the end of this chapter. Even in their Newtonian form, however, Landau’s arguments readily suggest a deeply significant feature of the maximum mass Mc of degenerate stars, namely that this mass is, crudely speaking, independent of the nature of the degenerate fermions providing the pressure support. This is so because the Landau mass scale ML depends only on the fundamental constants G, c, h, and mN , and so is independent of the details, e.g., the mass, of the pressure-supporting fermions. This, in turn, is a direct consequence of the fact that the zeropoint pressure of ER degenerate fermions is independent of their mass (see Eq. (2.12) and the discussion below it). The fermionic details enter only through the factor µ2 occurring in µL (see above): µ being the number of pressure-supporting fermions per nucleon introduced earlier. For different fermions, µ will be somewhat different in general (e.g., µ ≈ 1/2 for electrons, and µ ≈ 1 for neutrons; see above), but it is ∼ 1 within a factor of about 2 in all situations of practical interest, so that Mc for different fermions would be the same within a factor of about 4 (we shall see later that general-relativistic effects considerably reduce this factor of difference). This fundamental property of Mc seems not to have been appreciated by Stoner (1930) and Chandrasekhar (1931b) when they gave their derivations of the mass limit of white dwarfs: the clue came undoubtedly from Landau’s 1932 work, and was fully appreciated by 1938-39 [Landau 1938; Oppenheimer & Volkoff 1939]. 2.3.1
Degenerate Stars: Rough Mass Limits
The simple arguments summarized above would give Mc ≈ 1.72M and ≈ 6.89M for white dwarfs and neutron stars respectively. Refinements can now be incorporated. First, instead of the uniform-density approxi-
pranab
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
Degenerate Stars
pranab
59
mation, we can use a polytropic approximation (see Sec. 2.2.3.2), in which the equation of state has the power-law form P ∝ nΓ , Γ being the polytropic exponent. As Eqs. (2.11) and (2.12) show, the polytropic approximation holds accurately in both NR and ER limits, with ΓNR = 5/3 and ΓER = 4/3. We can then use Emden’s (1907) extensive results on polytropic gas spheres, as Chandrasekhar (1931a,b,c) and Landau (1932) did. The resultant changes are twofold: (1) the gravitational-energy structure factor γ in Eq. (2.14) changes appropriately from the uniform-density value given above, and, (2) the simple condition aER null = agrav for neutral equilibrium changes to an outer boundary condition on the polytrope for the existence of well-behaved solutions of the polytropic equation (see below, Sec. 2.2.3, for details of polytropes) in the ER case. The final result in Landau’s treatment of the problem is that the constant of proportionality between µL and µ2 changes from the value ≈ 3.7 in the simple case given above to a value ≈ 3.1 [Landau 1932]. This gives Mc ≈ 1.4M for white dwarfs [Landau 1932], and Mc ≈ 5.7M for neutron stars [Oppenheimer & Volkoff 1939]. In later sections, we shall describe some of the next refinements to the calculations, which are the inclusions of (a) the exact equation of state for degenerate fermions, as opposed to polytropic approximations, (b) the effects of the general theory of relativity, where appropriate, and, (c) the interaction between the fermions. Inclusion of the first two effects (of which the general-relativistic effect is by far the dominant one) lowers the mass limit of neutron stars to ≈ 0.7M (see Sec. 2.1 and Oppenheimer and Volkoff 1939), but has only a small effect on that of white dwarfs. The third effect raises the neutron-star mass limit to ≈ 2M , which proved historically crucial for resolving the Oppenheimer paradox, as we explained in Sec. 2.1. 2.3.2
Degenerate Stars: Mass-Radius Relations
To show the power and beauty of the Landau arguments, we now calculate the radii of degenerate stars from the simple estimates for uniformdensity stars given above. For a given stellar mass M < Mc , there is only one possible configuration in stable equilibrium, whose density n is given by Eq. (2.18). Its radius R is therefore given by the relation R = (3M µ/4πnmN )1/3 , which, upon substitution of Eqs. (2.18) and (2.16), yields the following mass-radius relation for degenerate stars:
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
pranab
Rotation and Accretion Powered Pulsars
60
M ML
1/3 R = µR RG (ML )
m mN
−1
≈ 10.1µ5/3
m mN
−1 km,
(2.22)
where µR ≡ (9π/4)2/3 µ5/3 ≈ 3.7µ5/3 , and RG (ML ) ≡ GML /c2 is the gravitational radius corresponding to the Landau mass scale defined earlier (see Eq. (2.21)). The gravitational radius is a length of central importance in the general theory of relativity, to which we shall return repeatedly in this book. The nice thing about this mass-radius relation is, again, its generality. It holds for all pressure-supporting fermions, the transparent scaling R ∝ m−1 with the fermion mass m showing that, unlike the mass limits, the radii are strongly influenced by m, the radius of a neutron star being ∼ 10−3 of that of a white dwarf of the same mass. Further, as before, the use of polytropic models would leave the form of Eq. (2.22) unaltered, changing only the numerical constant in the relation between µR and µ. Substituting into this equation the numerical value of ML from Eq. (2.21), we obtain
M M
1/3
R ≈ 12µ
5/3
m mN
−1 km ≈
7.1 × 103 km, white dwarfs . 12 km, neutron stars (2.23)
In subsequent sections, we shall compare the radii given by Eq. (2.23) with those obtained from (a) the uniform-density calculations of Stoner (1929) and the polytropic calculations of Chandrasekhar (1931a) for white dwarfs, and, (b) the numerical calculations of Oppenheimer and Volkoff (1939) for neutron stars to emphasize the value of these simple estimates.
2.4
White Dwarfs
Observationally, white dwarfs had been known as stars with masses comparable to that of the Sun (inferred from, e.g., binary dynamics for Sirius B, the binary companion to the prominent optical star Sirius: for the basics of binary dynamics, see Appendix B), but with radii much smaller than those of Sun-like stars, as inferred from Stefan’s law of blackbody emission, L = 4πR2 σT 4 (see Eq. (1.10) and Appendix A), the effective surface temperature T being obtained from spectral measurements. Their discovery goes back to 1910, when Russell, Pickering, and Fleming (see Russell 1944) found that the faint star 40 Eridani B had a spectral class A (see Appendix
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
Degenerate Stars
pranab
61
A), i.e., an unusually high temperature, or a very “white” color, for such low-luminosity stars, which normally have a spectral class M (i.e., a low temperature and a “red” color), and so are called M- or red-dwarfs (the reader will immediately see from Stefan’s law that low luminosities and high temperatures imply small radii). By the mid-1920s, it was established from the early, rough determinations of masses and radii of white dwarfs like Sirius B and 40 Eridani B that the average densities of these stars 4 5 −3 were > ∼ 5 × 10 − 10 g cm . This prompted Eddington (1926) to argue in his classic book The Internal Constitution of the Stars that such dense, ionized matter would exhibit paradoxical behavior at low temperatures if it followed classical statistics, since, after having radiated away a sufficient amount of its thermal energy, it would reach a state where its energy content would be less than that of the same matter in the form ordinary unionized atoms at zero temperature, and it was not clear how the former state would “cool down” to the latter, as it was expected to do according to the laws of physics. The answer came from Fowler: the pioneering papers of Fermi (1926) and Dirac (1926) on Fermi-Dirac statistics had just been published, and Fowler (1926) made the first application of their results to astrophysics, proposing the profound idea that the properties of stellar matter at such high densities as expected in white dwarfs would be governed by quantum, not classical, statistics. “This discovery,” Chandrasekhar was to write in his 1945 obituary of Fowler, “which must be certainly counted among the more important of the astronomical discoveries of our time, could not have been made except by one whose grasp of the theories both of physics and of astrophysics was of the highest.” This not only solved the Eddington paradox readily, since high-density degenerate matter obeying Fermi-Dirac statistics has a large energy-density even at zero temperature (this is the nullpunktsenergie we discussed in Sec. 2.2.2), but also introduced the very concept of the degenerate stars that we discuss in this book. 2.4.1
The Stoner-Anderson Work
The pioneering application of Fowler’s idea to white dwarfs was made in 1929-30 by Stoner, who investigated uniform-density model stars, using energy arguments essentially identical to those which we have given in Sec. 2.2.2. Stoner (1929) first considered stars pressure-supported by NR degenerate electron gas, obtaining the equilibrium density from Eq. (2.18), NR )/∂n = 0 which gives rise to this and describing the condition ∂(Egrav + Enull equation (see Sec. 2.2.2) in the picturesque and physically apt words “the
January 10, 2007
16:24
62
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
pranab
Rotation and Accretion Powered Pulsars
gravitational energy released just supplies the energy required to squeeze the electrons together”. Stoner gave the result not as a mass-radius relation (see Sec. 2.2.2.2), but as a density-mass relation, which is easily obtained from Eq. (2.23) by using R = (3M/4πρ)1/3 , and is12 ρ ≈ 4.12 × 104 µ−5
M M
2
g cm−3 ≈ 1.32 × 106
M M
2
g cm−3 . (2.24)
Relations like Eq. (2.24) first established the correct scale of white-dwarf densities, ρ ∼ 106 g cm−3 , showing these to be considerably higher than thought before. In a now-forgotten critique of the Stoner’s above work, Anderson (1929) made the first attempt to include relativistic effects in the theory of degenerate stars by incorporating these effects into the calculation of Enull . √ Whereas the NR theory gives M ∝ ρ (see Eq. [2.24]), Anderson found that the relativistic effects reduced the mass at a given density below the value given by the NR relation, the deviation so increasing with increasing density that M attained a limiting constant value at very high densities. This last result, which apparently went unnoticed by Anderson himself although the density-mass tables in his 1929 paper clearly showed it, was the first appearance of that mass limit to white dwarfs which we call the Chandrasekhar limit today. Unfortunately, Anderson’s approximate treatment of relativity was unacceptable: Stoner immediately recognized this, as also the existence of the mass limit. In his reply to Anderson’s critique, Stoner (1930) gave the pioneering exact derivation of Enull for a degenerate Fermi gas valid for all momenta of the fermions, and used it to obtain a densitymass relation for uniform-density model white dwarfs that was valid all the way from the NR to the ER r´egime. We obtain Enull by averaging the exact, general expression for the kinetic energy per fermion over the Fermi-Dirac distribution in the completedegeneracy limit (Eq. [2.9]): 1 pF 2 2 2 [ p c + m2 c4 − mc2 ] 3 4πp2 dp, (2.25) Enull = n 0 h 12 Stoner’s original number in the second expression on the right-hand side of Eq. (2.24) was somewhat different, viz., ≈ 4×106 (M/M )2 g cm−3 , because he had used µ = 1/2.5, as did Chandrasekhar after him in the 1930s, as per the custom of the time. The custom goes back to Jeans (1928), and this value of µ, which is representative of heavy elements in the periodic table around lead, is only an historical curiosity now. As we know today, and as we describe in later subsections, µ ≈ 1/2 gives an excellent representation of the elements that the bulk of the white-dwarf matter is thought to be composed of, e.g., C, O, Ne, and Mg.
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
Degenerate Stars
pranab
63
where pF is the Fermi momentum introduced earlier, and n = 8πp3F /3h3 is the number density of the fermions (see Sec. 2.2.4). The integral in Eq. (2.25) is performed by defining the dimensionless momenta x ≡ pF /mc (x is called the relativity parameter; see Sec. 2.3) and y ≡ p/mc, the result being conveniently expressed in units of the rest-mass energy, mc2 , of the fermion as: Enull = mc2 fE (x),
fE (x) ≡
3 fS (x) − 1, 8x3
where fS (x) is the Stoner (1930, 1932) function, defined by x fS (x) ≡ 8 1 + y 2 y 2 dy = x 1 + x2 (1 + 2x2 ) − sinh−1 x.
(2.26)
(2.27)
0
We leave it as an exercise for the reader to show that the energy function fE is given by
3 fE (x) = 3 x 1 + x2 (1 + 2x2 ) − sinh−1 x − 1, (2.28) 8x that the NR (x 1) limit of this function is13 fENR =
3 2 3 x − x4 · · · , 10 56
and that its ER (x 1) limit is14 3 1 fEER = x + · · · − 1. 4 x
(2.29)
(2.30)
The reader will also see that, on substituting the value of x in terms of n, i.e., using the relation 8π mc 3 3 n= x , (2.31) 3 h NR (as given by the leading terms in fENR and fEER above readily yield Enull ER Eq. [2.11]) and Enull (as given by Eq. [2.12]) respectively, as they should. 13 Note the difference with the corresponding result in Shapiro and Teukolsky [1983], even after conversion from their energy-density to our energy per particle. The reason for this is that the Shapiro-Teukolsky expressions are for the total energy, i.e., that including the rest-mass energy of the fermions, while ours are for the kinetic energy, i.e., that excluding the rest-mass energy. Our choice makes the differences from classical statistics more transparent. 14 We neglect here the logarithmic term, −(3/8x3 ) ln(2x), which arises from the x 1 √ limit of the function sinh−1 x = ln(x + 1 + x2 ), as its contribution is unimportant.
January 10, 2007
64
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
pranab
Rotation and Accretion Powered Pulsars
Using this exact Enull in the energy-extremum condition given earlier, Stoner (1930) obtained the exact mass-density relation for uniform-density white dwarfs shown in Fig. 2.3, where the Anderson (1929) result is also shown. The asymptotic approach to a limiting maximum mass is clear in the ER r´egime at high densities, this limiting mass MS of Stoner being exactly equal to the mass limit Mc given by Eq. (2.21), i.e., MS = Mc ≡ µL ML ,
µL ≡ (15/8)3/2 (2π/3)1/2 µ2 ≈ 3.72µ2 ,
(2.32)
Fig. 2.3 Stoner’s mass-density relation for uniform-density white dwarfs (solid line). Shown also are Anderson’s results (dashed line). Notice the asymptotic approach to a limiting maximum mass. Positions of a few well-known white dwarfs are also indicated. Reproduced with permission by Taylor & Francis Ltd (http://www.tandf.co.uk/journals) from Stoner (1930): see Bibliography.
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
Degenerate Stars
pranab
65
where ML is the Landau mass scale defined in Sec. 2.2.2. Hence, for µ ≈ 1/2, as we adopt for electrons, MS ≈ 1.72M , while Stoner (1930) himself obtained a value15 MS ≈ 1.10M using the customary value µ ≈ 1/2.5 of his time, as explained above. At first sight, the equality of the two results may not be surprising, since we used uniform-density model stars throughout our simple calculations of Sec. 2.2.2. But the reader should appreciate that Stoner’s (1930) mass limit was given without the benefit of Landau’s (1932) arguments on the deep significance of a natural limit to masses of degenerate stars. Stoner (1930) apparently had no inkling of the special case of neutral equilibrium for aER null = agrav (see Sec. 2.2.2), ER (both going as n1/3 ) and interpreted the similar scaling of Egrav and Enull as implying that “there will obviously be no equilibrium” in the ER limit, totally unperturbed by the fact that he was obtaining an equilibrium solution in this limit, namely his mass limit. What was actually happening is clear to us today: if we assume that the energy-extremum condition ∂(Egrav + Enull )/∂n = 0 always gives us an equilibrium solution, and look for this solution, we shall get a solution for n (e.g., Eq.[2.18] in the NR limit) as long as Egrav and Enull have different scalings with n. But when Egrav and Enull have identical scalings with n, as the n1/3 scaling in the ER limit, the only possible solution will simply be the condition that the coefficient of n1/3 is zero, i.e., that aER null = agrav , which just gives the mass limit on degenerate stars, as we saw above. This is what Stoner (1930) did. In reality, white dwarf stars have a radial variation in density, and so in pressure and in the zero-point energy Enull per electron. A quantitative theory of white dwarfs must take this variation into account. Chandrasekhar did this in the period 1931-35, treating the NR and ER limits in the polytropic approximation in a series of papers in 1931 before attempting a general numerical calculation valid for all r´egimes in 1935. We summarize below the essential properties of polytropes before describing Chandrasekhar’s work. 2.4.2
Polytropes
We introduced polytropes in Sec. 2.2.2.1 as those systems for which pressure and density are connected by a relation of the form: P = KρΓ ,
(2.33)
15 Anderson’s (1929) mass limit, obtained from his approximate treatment of relativistic effects, was ≈ 0.69M .
January 10, 2007
66
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
pranab
Rotation and Accretion Powered Pulsars
K and Γ being constants. It is customary to write the exponent Γ in the form: 1 Γ≡1+ , s
(2.34)
and call s the polytropic index. As explained in Sec. 2.2.2.1, a degenerate Fermi gas has Γ = 5/3 when it is non-relativistic, and Γ = 4/3 when it is extremely relativsitic. The corresponding values of the polytropic index s are sNR = 3/2 and sER = 3 respectively. In the early years of the twentieth century, polytropes were thoroughly studied for obtaining the first indications of the internal structures of stars. Apart from its computational convenience (see below), the polytropic form has the significance that numerous limiting physical situations of basic importance in stars lead to a pressure-density relation of this form: this is why its use has survived to this day. For example, the (non-degenerate) matter in normal stars obeys a polytropic relation with s = 3/2 if the star is fully convective and its pressure is dominated by the gas pressure. On the other hand, a normal star in which the ratio of gas pressure to radiation pressure is constant throughout the star, and the energy-transport is primarily by radiative transfer (i.e., the so-called standard model), is closely represented by a polytrope with s = 3. For degenerate stars, the polytropic form applies in both NR and ER limits, as indicated above. The structure of a polytropic gas sphere in hydrostatic equilibrium is determined by first combining Eq. (10.35) for hydrostatic equilibrium with an equation satisfied by the mass m(r) contained within a radius r from the center of a spherically symmetric distribution, namely, dm(r)/dr = 4πr2 ρ(r). This yields: 1 d r2 dP = −4πGρ. (2.35) r2 dr ρ dr In combining Eq. (2.35) with the polytropic relation (Eqs. (2.33) and (2.34)) to obtain the polytrope-structure equation, it is convenient to define two dimensionless variables. The first is a density-related variable θ, obtained by scaling in terms of the central density ρc of the polytrope: ρ = ρc θ s ,
(2.36)
the choice of the exponent refelecting the fact that ρ ∝ T s (T is the temperature) in a polytrope of index s obeying classical statistics, which the reader can readily demonstrate by combining the classical equation of state,
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
Degenerate Stars
pranab
67
P ∝ ρT , with Eqs. (2.33) and (2.34). Thus, θ is a temperature-like variable. The second is a dimensionless radial co-ordinate ξ:
( 1 −1)
(s + 1)Kρc s a≡ 4πG
r = aξ,
12 .
(2.37)
In terms of ξ and θ, the polytrope-structure equation reduces to a simple, ordinary differential equation called the Lane-Emden equation, given by: 1 d 2 dθ (2.38) ξ = −θs , ξ 2 dξ dξ and its solution with appropriate boundary conditions is called the LaneEmden function of index s. These boundary conditions are: θ = 1 and θ = 0 at ξ = 0, where θ ≡ dθ/dξ. The first condition follows when we consider Eq. (2.36) at the center of the polytrope. The second comes from a consideration of Eq. (10.35) in the neighborhood of r = 0: approximating ρ by ρc and m(r) by 4πρc r3 /3 in this neighborhood, we see that dP/dr ∝ r, so that dP/dr → 0 as r → 0, and so do dρ/dr and dθ/dξ. The Lane-Emden equation is simple, but nonlinear except in the special cases s = 0 and 1, so that the vast array of analytical techniques available for solving linear differential equations is inapplicable to it in general. Indeed, numerical techniques have to be used for all cases except s = 0, 1, and 5, integrating Eq. (2.38) outward from ξ = 0, subject to the two boundary conditions described above. For all values of s less than 5, one finds that θ(ξ) decreases outward monotonically, vanishing at a finite radius ξ = ξ1 , which must, therefore, correspond to the surface of the polytropic star, since p = 0 = ρ there. The physical radius of the star follows from Eq. (2.37) as:
(s + 1)K R = aξ1 = 4πG
12
1−s
ρc 2s ξ1 .
(2.39)
R The mass of the polytropic star, M ≡ 0 4πr2 ρdr, is obtained by substituting Eq. (2.36) in the integrand and making use of Eq. (2.38), yielding:
(s + 1)K M = 4π 4πG
32
3−s
ρc2s ξ12 | θ (ξ1 ) | .
(2.40)
Elimination of ρc between Eqs. (2.39) and (2.40) yields the mass-radius relation for polytropic stars:
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
pranab
Rotation and Accretion Powered Pulsars
68
3−s
M R s−1 = 4π
(s + 1)K 4πG
s s−1
s+1
ξ1s−1 | θ (ξ1 ) |,
(2.41)
which shows that the scale for this relation is set by the constant K occurring in the polytropic relation (which is determined by the character of the stellar matter; for degenerate matter, K depends on the fundamental constants h, c, mN , and also on the mass m of the pressure-supplying fermion in the NR case: see Sec. 2.2.2) and, of course, by the gravitational constant G. The detailed numbers on the right-hand side of Eq. (2.41) depend on the numbers ξ1 and | θ (ξ1 ) | for the particular polytropic index s we are interested in: these are obtained from a numerical solution of the LaneEmden equation, and have been tabulated16 extensively by Emden (1907) and Chandrasekhar (1939). 2.4.3
Chandrasekhar’s Work
Chandrasekhar’s (1931a,b,c) application of the theory of polytropic gas spheres [Emden 1907] to degenerate stars, undoubtedly inspired both by Eddingtion’s (1926) earlier application of this theory to normal stars and by Sommerfeld’s classic (1928) work17 on electron degeneracy in metals (see Sec. 2.2.1.1), stands in scientific history as the first construction of a quantitative theory of white dwarfs. The first result Chandrasekhar (1931a) gave was for the NR degenerate electron gas, which corresponds to a polytropic index s = 3/2. The constant K is then obtained from Eq. (2.11) as K
NR
1 = 20
5/3 2/3 2 µ 3 h , π me mN
(2.42)
and Eq. (2.41) reduces to M R3 = (4π)−2 (5K NR /2G)3 η1 in this particular case, where η1 ≡ [ξ15 | θ (ξ1 ) |]3/2 , the subscript 3/2 on the square brackets indicating that solution of the Lane-Emden equation for the s = 3/2 case is to be used. The mass-radius relation then becomes M R3 =
16 Actually,
6 9π 2 µ5 η1 . 3 128 G m3e m5N
(2.43)
it is customary to tabulate ξ12 | θ (ξ1 ) | instead of | θ (ξ1 ) |. recalled in 1989 the inspiring personal interaction with Sommerfeld in 1928: see Chandrasekhar (1989), p. xii. 17 Chandrasekhar
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
Degenerate Stars
pranab
69
In order to calculate η1 , we use the tables in Chandrasekhar’s (1939) classic text An Introduction to the Study of Stellar Structure, which give ξ1 ≈ 3.654 and ξ12 | θ (ξ1 ) |≈ 2.714 for s = 3/2, which yield η1 ≈ 132.4. The massradius relation finally becomes M 3 R = 2.161 × 1028 µ5 cm3 , M
(2.44)
which is essentially identical to Chandrasekhar’s (1931a) corresponding result18 , the slight difference in the number on the right-hand side being due to the fact that, in his 1931 works, Chandrasekhar used the older tables in Emden’s (1907) classic book Gaskugeln. The corresponding relation between mass and average density ρ¯ is 2 2 M M g cm−3 ≈ 0.70 × 106 g cm−3 , (2.45) ρ¯ ≈ 2.20 × 104 µ−5 M M where we have used µ ≈ 1/2 in the second relation. Note that Chandrasekhar, like Stoner before him, used µ ≈ 1/2.5 throughout his 1931 work, as was customary then (see Sec. 2.2.3.1). It is instructive to compare these results with those of Stoner (see Sec. 2.2.3.1), particularly Eq. (2.45) with Eq. (2.24). We can also compare the above results with those of Sec. 2.2.2.2 by combining Eq. (2.43) with the definitions of the Landau mass scale ML and the gravitational radius RG (ML ) corresponding to ML , given in Secs. 2.2.2 and 2.2.2.2 respectively. These yield: 2 1/3 1/3 −1 9π η1 me M 5/3 R= µ RG (ML ) (2.46) ML 128 mN −1 me km, (2.47) ≈ 12.4µ5/3 mN which is to be compared with Eq. (2.22). The closeness of numerical values with those given in Eq. (2.23) is clear when we rewrite the above as:
M M
1/3
R ≈ 15µ
5/3
me mN
−1 km ≈ 8.7 × 103 km,
(2.48)
where we have substituted µ ≈ 1/2 for white dwarfs, as before (see Sec. 2.2.2). This is remarkable in view of the simplicity of our estimates of Sec. 2.2.2.2, and shows that the essential physics of the equilibria of white 18 Note
that Chandrasekhar (1931a) defined his µ to be the reciprocal of ours.
January 10, 2007
70
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
pranab
Rotation and Accretion Powered Pulsars
dwarfs, as contained in the Landau (1932) arguments, had been already brought out almost entirely in Stoner’s (1929) uniform-density calculations. Chandrasekhar’s next result (1931b) was on the ER degenerate electron gas, which corresponds to a polytropic index s = 3. The constant K in this case is seen from Eq. (2.12) to be K ER =
1 8
4/3 1/3 µ 3 hc , π mN
(2.49)
and Eq. (2.41) then gives the remarkable result that the mass of the star is in this case independent of its radius (and, therefore, of its density), being given simply by M = (4π)(K ER /πG)3/2 χ1 , where χ1 ≡ [ξ12 | θ (ξ1 ) |]3 , the subscript 3 on the square brackets indicating that solution of the LaneEmden equation for the s = 3 case is to be used. This unique value of the mass, given by √ 3/2 3π c 1 2 µ χ1 , (2.50) MCh = 2 G m2N was immediately identified by Chandrasekhar (1931b) as the polytropic analogue of the white-dwarf mass limit described earlier by Stoner (1930) for uniform-density white dwarfs. It is called the Chandrasekhar limit today. The occurrence of the Landau mass scale in Eq. (2.50) is obvious: we can recast it as MCh ≈ 3.1µ2 ML ≈ 1.4M ,
(2.51)
using χ1 ≈ 2.018 from Chandrasekhar’s (1939) tables. The first form of Eq. (2.51) is exactly that which was given by Landau (1932) in his rederivation of the Chandrasekhar limit. The final numerical value originally obtained by Chandrasekhar (1931b), MCh ≈ 0.9M, was somewhat different from ours, again because he used µ ≈ 1/2.5 (see above). The reader can compare Eq. (2.51) with the Stoner limit, MS ≈ 3.7µ2 ML ≈ 1.7M , which is identical to the results summarized in Sec. 2.2.2. Like Stoner (1930) before him, Chandrasekhar (1931b) also did not explain why there should be a limit to the mass of white dwarfs: the explanation came from Landau in 1932. In 1935, Chandrasekhar took the next logical step of generalizing the polytropic approach to calculate the equilibrium properties of white dwarfs all the way from the NR to the ER r´egime. For this purpose, he used the exact, general equation of state of a degenerate Fermi gas, valid for all
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
Degenerate Stars
pranab
71
momenta of the fermions, derived19 earlier by Stoner (1932). We obtain this equation of state by noting that the usual NR kinetic-theory result that the average transfer of momentum for a particle of velocity v andmomentum p is vp/3 generalizes in the relativistic case to βcp/3 = p2 c2 /3 p2 c2 + m2 c4 (Stoner 1932), so that the pressure of degenerate fermions is obtained by integrating this over the Fermi-Dirac distribution: 1 P = 3
pF
0
p 2 c2 2 4πp2 dp, 2 2 2 4 h p c +m c 3
(2.52)
The integral in Eq. (2.52) is performed, as before, by defining the dimensionless momenta x ≡ pF /mc and y ≡ p/mc, the result being conveniently expressed in units of P0 ≡ (8π/3)(m4 c5 /h3 ) as: P = P0 fP (x),
fP (x) ≡ x3
3 1 + x2 − fS (x), 8
(2.53)
where fS (x) is the Stoner function defined by Eq. (2.27). Note that the reference pressure P0 does indeed have the dimensions of pressure (which are the same as those of energy density), since it can be expressed as P0 = n0 mc2 , where n0 ≡ (8π/3)(mc/h)3 is a reference number density. (This becomes clear on comparing the expression for n0 with the relation between the fermion number density and Fermi momentum, n = (8π/3)(pF /h)3 , given in Sec. 2.2.3.1. Indeed, n0 for electrons can be alternatively expressed as ne0 = 1/3π 2 λ3e , where λe ≡ /me c is the electron Compton wavelength.) We again leave it as an exercise for the reader to show that the pressure function fP is given by 3 2x2 −1 2 fP (x) = − 1) + sinh x , x 1+x ( 8 3
(2.54)
that the NR (x 1) limit of this function is fPNR =
x7 x5 − ···, 5 14
(2.55)
19 Chandrasekhar (1935) gave a re-derivation of the general equation of state of a degenerate Fermi gas, in which there is an error in the ER limit corresponding to Eq. (2.56), which was repeated in Schatzman’s (1958) book White Dwarfs. The correct expression is given here, in Stoner (1932), and in Shapiro and Teukolsky (1983).
January 10, 2007
72
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
pranab
Rotation and Accretion Powered Pulsars
and that its ER (x 1) limit is20 fPER =
x2 x4 − ···. 4 4
(2.56)
Once again, the reader will see that, on substituting the value of x in terms of n (i.e., using Eq. [2.31]), the leading terms in fPNR and fPER above NR ER (as given by Eq. [2.11]) and Pnull (as given by Eq. [2.12]) readily yield Pnull respectively, as they must. Equations (2.53) and (2.54), together with the relation between x and the density ρ (which readily follows from Eq. [2.31]), namely, 8π mc 3 mN 3 x , (2.57) ρ= 3 h µ constitute a parametric form of the general equation of state of a completely degenerate Fermi gas, which we shall henceforth call the StonerChandrasekhar equation of state. In order to obtain the general equilibria of white dwarfs, Chandrasekhar (1935) combined the equation of hydrostatic equilibrium, Eq. (2.35), with the above general equation of state, instead of the earlier polytropic relations. With characteristic mathematical skill, he cast the resultant structure equation, the Chandrasekhar equation, into a Lane-Emden-like form 1 d 2 dθ (2.58) ξ = −(θ2 − ζc2 )3/2 , ξ 2 dξ dξ which made its connections with the NR and ER polytropic limits transparent. In Eq. (2.58), the variable θ is now the Fermi energy, EF = p2F c2 + m2 c4 , of the electrons at any radius, scaled in terms of the Fermi energy, EFc , of the electrons at the center of the star, i.e., at r = 0, and the constant ζc is the reciprocal of EFc in units of the electron rest-mass energy: θ ≡ EF /EFc ,
ζc ≡ me c2 /EFc .
(2.59)
The dimensionless radial variable ξ is still defined by r ≡ aξ, as before, with the scale a now being given by: −1 me 3π a≡ RG (ML ) ≈ 7.72 × 103 µζc km. (2.60) µζc 4 mN 20 Again, we neglect here the logarithmic term, (3/8) ln(2x), which arises from the large-x limit of sinh−1 x.
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
Degenerate Stars
pranab
73
The reader will immediately recognize this scale as being essentially that occurring in Eqs. (2.22) and (2.23), execpt for the factor ζc , which shows the basic importance of this lengthscale, as we indicated earlier. The NR limit (EFc → me c2 ) corresponds to ζc → 1, and the ER limit c (EF me c2 ), to ζc → 0, so that the entire collection of degenerate stars from the one limit to the other is described by the range of values 0 ≤ ζc ≤ 1. It is straightforward to show that the Chandrasekhar equation does, indeed, reduce to the appropriate polytropic Lane-Emden equations in these two limits, i.e., to a polytrope of index s = 3/2 in the ζc → 1 limit, and to a polytrope with s = 3 in the ζc → 0 limit21 . The stellar radius R is defined, as before, as the point where the density vanishes, i.e., where n = 0 = pF , so that EF = me c2 , and θ = ζc (see Eqs. [2.59] and [2.31]). If this happens at ξ = ξ1 , then R = aξ1 . The stellar mass is calculated in a way entirely analogous to that which was used in Sec. 2.2.3.2 for polytropes, i.e., by integrating over the density profile and utilizing Eq. (2.58). This yields √ 3π ML µ2 ξ12 | θ (ξ1 ) | , M= 2
(2.61)
showing, as expected, the fundamental significance of the Landau mass scale ML . The reader will notice that Eqs. (2.61) and (2.50) look identical, and should not interpret this to mean that they really are so. The Chandrasekhar limit of Eq. (2.50) only applies in the ER limit, corresponding to the polytrope with s = 3, and it gives a constant mass. On the other hand, Eq. (2.61) is a general result valid for all white dwarfs, and it does not give a constant mass except in the ER limit. The complications are all hidden in the boundary-value quantity ξ12 | θ (ξ1 ) |, which in Eq. (2.61) depends on ζc , and so on EFc and the central density (since the Chandrasekhar equation, Eq. [2.58], involves ζc ), and is no longer a simple number charcteristic of a polytrope of a given index s. As noticed by Chandrasekhar (1935), this destroys the homology property of polytropes, which is that, independent of their masses, all polytropes of a given index have the same density profile (i.e., the same relative density in units of the central density at the same relative radius in units of the stellar radius). Each chosen value of the central density ρc now gives a distinct density profile, a distinct value of ξ12 | θ (ξ1 ) |, and so distinct values for both M and R on integrating the Chandrasekhar equation numerically. 21 The ER limit is trivial. The NR limit is obtained by noting that both θ and ζ then c have Taylor-series expansions around unity, and rewriting the Chandrsekhar equation in terms of modified definitions of θ and ξ. For details, see Chandrasekhar (1935).
January 10, 2007
74
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
Rotation and Accretion Powered Pulsars
Fig. 2.4 Chandrasekhar’s mass-radius relation for white dwarfs. The mass M3 is the Chandrasekhar limit, obtained when the density becomes arbitrarily large, and the radius approaches zero. Reproduced with permission by Blackwell Publishing from Chandrasekhar (1935): see Bibliography.
This is what Chandrasekhar (1935) did: the result was a mass-radius relation for white dwarfs (or, alternatively, one between their masses and average densities ρ¯, defined as before), which is shown in Fig. 2.4, and a comparison with Fig. 2.3 again makes it quite obvious how much of the basic physics was already contained in the simple, uniform-density, StonerAnderson results. In the ER (high ρ) limit, M approaches the constant value which is, of course, the Chandrasekhar limit, and in the NR (low ρ) limit, the relation reduces to the M − ρ¯ relation for a polytrope22 of index of index s = 3/2, i.e., Eq. (2.45). 22 The reader may be surprised by this, as the boundary-value quantity ξ 2 | θ (ξ ) | 1 1 should then reduce to a constant number characteristic of a polytrope of index 3/2, and Eq. [2.61] should imply a constant mass, instead of a mass-radius relation. This is not so because of the way in which the Chandrasekhar equation reduces to the Lane-Emden equation in the NR limit, as explained in the previous footnote. The modified function θ1 which satisfies the Lane-Emden equation does not obey the standard central boundary condition θ c = 1 at ξ = 0. Rather, its central value θ1c depends on the central density in such a way that the boundary-value quantity ξ12 | θ (ξ1 ) |, which occurs in Eq. [2.61] and which involves the original θ, exactly reproduces Eq.[2.40] for the mass of a polytrope of index s = 3/2. See Chandrasekhar (1935) for a more detailed explanation of this point.
pranab
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
Degenerate Stars
pranab
75
We close this account of our foundations of the understanding of white dwarfs with two brief historical points. First, it took quite a while for the ER limit of degenerate-matter physics, which we have described above, to be fully understood and accepted by astrophysicists, since the conclusion that it logically led to, namely, that stars above a limiting mass would go into indefinite collapse, and produce what we call black holes now, was somewhat challenging philosophically at the time. Today, of course, we accept the idea of black holes and look for their observational signatures, and we regard the above idea of relativistic degeneracy and the consequent mass limit on degenerate stars as one of the cornerstones of modern astrophysics, together with Fowler’s brilliant, pioneering suggestion that dense stars should be degenerate. Second, for his achievements in astrophysics, Chandrasekhar shared23 the 1983 Nobel Prize in Physics, being cited for “his theoretical studies of the physical processes of importance to the structure and evolution of the stars”.
2.4.4
Modern Work
Even in the limit of complete degeneracy, i.e., without considering finitetemperature effects, stellar matter is subject to a variety of physical effects of electrostatic and nuclear origin which were not included in the early works described above, and which began to be investigated in the 1950s. In 1961, Salpeter published a comprehensive treatment of these effects which has become the point of departure for modern work. Consider first the effects of electrostatic or Coulomb interactions between the electrons and nuclei in the fully-ionized degenerate matter obtained from an element of atomic number Z and mass number A. Foremost among these is the attractive interaction between the nuclei and the electrons: at the densities of interest in white dwarfs, the nuclei of charge Ze form a lattice immersed in a sea of electrons, and this attraction wins over the mutual repulsion between the electrons, causing a decrease in the outward pressure. Thus, this effect reduces the zero-point energy and zero-point pressure of degenerate matter, yielding a smaller radius and higher density for a white dwarf of given mass, as compared to those given by the Chandrasekhar model. The 23 With W. A. Fowler (not R. H. Fowler, whose pioneering contributions to the physics of degenerate stars we have discussed above, and who had passed away in 1944: see Chandrasekhar’s obituary of Fowler referred to in Sec. 2.4), who won it for his work in nucleosynthesis.
January 10, 2007
76
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
pranab
Rotation and Accretion Powered Pulsars
calculation of the Coulomb effects proceeds by first making the WignerSeitz approximation, in which each lattice cell is replaced by a uniform negatively-charged sphere of total charge −Ze (representing the electrons) with a nucleus of positive charge Ze at its center: we describe this calculation in Sec. 3.1. The “classical” Coulomb energy so calculated is, in fact, the largest electrostatic correction by far: (smaller) modifications made to it take into account (a) the non-uniform distribution of the negative electronic charge, which is done according to the Thomas-Fermi prescription (see Sec. 3.1), (b) the energy of quantum-mechanical exchange interactions, which occur because of the antisymmetric wave function of the electrons, and, (c) even smaller, higher-order corrections to the electron-electron interaction energy. In contrast to the situation for non-degenerate matter, the Coulomb corrections decrease with increasing density for degenerate matter (see Sec. 3.1), and so are the most important for the lightest white dwarfs, which have the smallest density. Consider now the effects of inverse β-decay, which become important at high densities, and cause a qualitative change from the Chandrasekhar results, as opposed to the detailed, quantitative changes due to Coulomb interactions described above. At sufficiently high densities, the nuclei of the element (or elements) that the degenerate white-dwarf matter is composed of undergo inverse β-decay, in which protons in these nuclei capture elctrons to produce neutrons: p + e− → n + ν .
(2.62)
This is the process of neutronization, which is crucial for eventually producing neutron stars at very high densities, and which we shall discuss further in later sections of this chapter. Note first that inverse β-decay is energetically possible whenever an electron has more total energy than the difference between the rest-mass energies of the neutron and the proton, (mn − mp )c2 ≈ 1.29 MeV, but the process is effective only when the reverse process, i.e., the β-decay of neutrons into protons, n → p + e− + ν¯ ,
(2.63)
which is always energetically possible by itself, is blocked because all the possible electronic energy states in which the electron of Eq. (2.63) may be emitted are fully occupied in the degenerate electron plasma (see Sec. 2.2.1.3). This happens when the Fermi energy EF exceeds the total
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
Degenerate Stars
pranab
77
energy of the highest energy-state that the electron can be emitted into, which, in turn, happens only at sufficiently high densities, as a glance at Eq. (2.10) shows. Each individual inverse β-decay converts a nucleus (Z, A) (i.e., atomic number Z, mass number A) into a nucleus (Z − 1, A). The resulting phase transition from one nuclear species to another “softens” the stellar matter, i.e., increases its compressibility ( the technical words used in the subject are that it softens the equation of state). This is so because compression and consequent density increase do not now increase the pressure and the Fermi energy as they normally would, but, rather, cause nuclear phase transition. The polytropic exponent Γ (see 2.2.3.2), which was already close to 4/3 because the electrons are highly relativistic in this density range, now falls below 4/3, which makes the situation unstable, and the star subject to gravitational collapse. The density at which this happens first is, therefore, the maximum density that a white dwarf can have: this density depends on the chemical composition of the white-dwarf matter, as we describe below. Thus, for a given composition (Z, A), the sequence of possible white dwarfs on the density vs. mass plot does not go to arbitrarily high densities and the Chandrasekhar limit, but terminates at a finite, maximum density ρmax and a corresponding maximum mass Mmax , which is less than the Chandrasekhar mass MCh for this composition. This is the qualitative difference from the Chandrasekhar result we referred to above. Computationally, it appears in the following way. If we compute the masses and radii of equilibrium white dwarf configurations after including the effects of inverse β-decay, we find that, while M increases with increasing ρ at low and moderately high densities, it reaches a maximum Mmax at a very high density ρmax , after which M falls with increasing ρ. It is this falling branch that contains the unstable white dwarfs with Γ < 4/3, stars which cannot occur in nature. This phenomenon was clearly noticed in 1958 both by Schatzman and by Harrison, Wakano, and Wheeler. In 1961, Hamada and Salpeter gave a detailed computation of the effect, which we summarize next. If the white-dwarf matter were pure hydrogen, so that the nuclei in question were just protons, the criterion for the onset of inverse β-decay would be EF ≥ (mn − mp )c2 , which corresponds to a density threshold of 7 −3 ρ> ∼ 1.2 × 10 g cm . But, of course, the matter in real white-dwarf stars is predominantly not hydrogen: in the process of their evolution through thermonuclear reactions (see Appendix C), normal stars convert most of
January 10, 2007
78
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
Rotation and Accretion Powered Pulsars
their hydrogen into heavier elements, so that the white dwarfs produced at the end of this evolution have cores (which contain most of the dwarf’s mass) made of the heavier elements, surrounded by lighter, outer envelopes that contain the remnant hydrogen, if any. Which elements dominate the chemical composition of the white-dwarf core depends on the initial mass of the star that produced the white dwarf (see below). Consider, for simplicity, a white-dwarf core made entirely of degenerate electrons and the nuclei (Z, A), as above, which undergo inverse β-decay into (Z − 1, A) when the electron Fermi energy satisfies EF > Z , where Z is the elctron-emission β-decay energy of nucleus (Z − 1, A) (see above). Now, since nuclei with both an even number of protons and an even number of neutrons (called even-even nuclei), and therefore with both Z and A even are generally more stable than odd-odd nuclei, the original (Z, A) nuclei are likely to be even24 28 56 even ones, possiblities24 being 126 C, 168 O, 20 10 Ne, 12 Mg, 14 Si, . . . 26 Fe. Note that the number of electrons per nucleon µ = Z/A for all of these elements upto Si is exactly µ = 1/2, while that for Fe is µ = 26/56 ≈ 1/2.154. When such an even-even nucleus (Z, A) becomes an odd-odd nucleus (Z − 1, A) by an inverse β-decay, it generally turns out that the elctronemission β-decay energy Z−1 of the next even-even nucleus (Z − 2, A) is less than Z and therefore less than EF . Hence (Z − 1, A) immediately undergoes another inverse β-decay into (Z − 2, A), which means that, in effect, an even-even nucleus undergoes a rapid double β-decay into the next even-even nucleus with the same A. Examples are 126 C → 125 B → 12 24 24 24 4 Be, and 12 Mg → 11 Na → 10 Ne. Generally, this next even-even nucleus is stable against further inverse β-decay until a considerably higher density and higher Fermi energy is reached. The density thresholds for inverse βdecay for the nuclei listed above are in the range ∼ 1 × 109 – 4 × 1010 g cm−3 , the corresponding Fermi energies are in the range ∼ 4 – 14 MeV, and the corresponding values of the relativity parameter x are in the range ∼ 8 – 28, showing that the elctrons are extremely relativistic at this point. Hamada and Salpeter (1961) computed white-dwarf models for the pure (initial) compositions listed above, including all the Coulomb and inverse β-decay effects just described. Figure 2.3(b) shows their results for 126 C, 24 28 56 12 Mg, 14 Si, and 26 Fe white dwarfs: in each case, the reader can clearly see 24 Of these, iron is the most tightly bound nucleus, the standard endpoint of the chain of complete thermonuclear burning in stars, which does not mean, of course, that whitedwarf matter can necessarily reach this endpoint. Indeed, we believe today that it does not: see next page.
pranab
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
pranab
Degenerate Stars
79
the occurrence of a maximum mass Mmax below MCh and the unstable stellar models beyond this maximum density on the falling branch of the curve. Modern calculations of stellar evolution indicate that most white dwarfs form from progenitor stars of original mass ∼ 1 – 10 M . After the completion of helium burning in the stellar core, such a star “climbs” the Asymptotic Giant Branch (AGB) in the Hertzsprung-Russell diagram, with increasing luminosity and decreasing temperature (see Appendix C). At this stage, the star consists of a degenerate core composed of C and O (and also Ne and Mg for the heaviest progenitors), surrounded by thin shells where thermonuclear burning of H and He is still going on (see Iben 1991). The degenerate core contains a mass ∼ 0.5 – 1.4 M in a region of the size of the Earth: this is what will eventually become the white dwarf. The rest of the stellar mass lies in a cool, hugely extended envelope (radius several hundred times that of the Sun) of very weak gravitational binding, which is expelled during the AGB evolution, particularly due to large energy inputs from periodic pulsations in the burning shells due to thermonuclear runaway (the so-called “shell flashes”). The degenerate core thus exposed is a white-hot dwarf star—the white dwarf—which then cools slowly to oblivion (unless the white dwarf is in a mass-transfer binary, and emits radiation due to accretion of matter from its companion, as we describe in Chapter 6). For progenitors of initial mass ∼ 1–8 M , the cores consist of C and O, and the resulting degenerate stars are called CO white dwarfs, while for progenitors of mass ∼ 8–10 M , the cores consist principally of O, Ne, and Mg, and we get ONeMg white dwarfs. CO white dwarfs range in mass from ∼ 0.5M to ∼ 1.3M (scaling roughly linearly with the original progenitor mass; see Iben and Truran 1978), and ONeMg white dwarfs have a narrow range of masses around ∼ 1.35M (Nomoto 1984). It thus appears that µ = 1/2 should provide an excellent description of the matter in white-dwarf cores. Eggleton (1982) has given a simple analytic approximation to the results of numerical calculations of the mass-radius relation for white dwarfs (see Truran and Livio 1986),
M M
1/3
R ≈ 9.6 × 10 km 1 − 3
M MCh
4/3 ,
(2.64)
which is very useful in modern work for a variety of rapid estimates, and which can be compared with the mass-radius relations given earlier.
January 10, 2007
80
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
Rotation and Accretion Powered Pulsars
As this is not a book on white dwarfs, we conclude our account of these degenerate stars here, and return to these in later sections or chapters only with reference to neutron stars. For the reader interested in further study of white dwarfs, there is Schatzman’s (1958) pioneering book White Dwarfs, many excellent review articles, e.g., those by Weidemann (1968, 1990) and Liebert (1980), and numerous conference proceedings, all of which have references to the original papers. Evolution and structure of white dwarfs, their luminosity function, their cooling and crystallization, their atmospheres, and their magnetic fields have all blossomed into important specific areas of research, as has the study of their pulsations through novel techniques devised recently. The reader can get a feel for the progress made in these areas in the last ten to fifteen years from the proceedings of such conferences as White Dwarfs: IAU Colloquium 114 (Wegner 1989), or White Dwarfs: 9th European Workshop (Koester and Werner 1995). Binary stellar systems containing white dwarfs is a rich field of study to which we shall return at appropriate points in this book, as it will be of direct interest to us.
2.5
Neutron Stars
After inverse β-decay makes white dwarfs unstable, cold degenerate matter continues to collapse, and becomes more and more neutronized through a set of transformations which form the subject of the next sections. Long before they were fully appreciated, however, it was correctly guessed that matter would consist mostly of neutrons at sufficiently high densities (see Sec. 2.1), that these neutrons would become degenerate (see Sec. 2.2.1.2), and that the zero-point pressure of this cold, degenerate neutron gas would again be able to balance its own self-gravitational attraction in a stable fashion, producing a new kind of degenerate star, viz., the neutron star. It was on this basis that Oppenheimer and Volkoff (1939) performed their pioneering calculation of the masses and radii of neutron stars. The main concern of these authors was the correct mass limit for neutron stars—the analogue of the Chandrasekhar limit for white dwarfs—above which the cold, degenerate neutrons cannot support a stable configuration. Not satisfied with the simple-minded scaling of the Chandrasekhar mass limit to µ = 1 for neutrons (see Sec. 2.2.2), which gives Mc ≈ 5.7M (see Sec. 2.2.2.1) for neutron-star mass limit, Oppenheimer and Volkoff correctly anticipated that the neglect of general-relativistic effects, as done quite justifiably for
pranab
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
Degenerate Stars
pranab
81
white dwarfs, would not be justified at all at the enormous densities of neutron stars. The inclusion of these effects changed the results grossly, bearing out this anticipation fully. We summarize the Oppenheimer-Volkoff work below, before describing more modern and more detailed understanding of neutron-star matter in the next chapters. 2.5.1
The Oppenheimer-Volkoff Work
What essential changes enter into the description of a degenerate star when we include the effects of general relativity? First of all, mass-density ρ in our intuitive, Newtonian sense ceases to be the most basic quantity: rather, it is generalized to a total energy-density divided by c2 , ρ ≡ /c2 , of which our usual mass-density is the Newtonian limit. Here, includes the rest-mass energy of the particles involved, as well as all other forms of energy they have, since all forms of energy are are equivalent to mass according to the theory of relativity. For a completely degenerate Fermi gas, we can express in terms of the zero-point kinetic energy Enull per particle, introduced in Sec. 2.2.2, as = n(Enull + mc2 ) ,
(2.65)
m being the fermion mass, and n the number density of the fermions, as before. Of course, m means the neutron mass mn in all discussions of neutron stars. What happens to the Stoner-Chandrasekhar equation of state for completely degenerate matter (see Sec. 2.2.3.3) because of this? Nothing of substance, except that we have to re-express the pressure P (x) parametrically in terms of the energy density (x) now, x ≡ pF /mc being the relativity parameter introduced earlier. This is easy, since the pressure is already given in this form by Eqs. (2.53) and (2.54), and the energy density is readily obtained by combining Eq. (2.65) with Eqs. (2.26) and (2.27), which gives: =
3 P0 fS (x) , 8
(2.66)
where fS (x) is the Stoner function, and P0 ≡ (8π/3)(m4 c5 /h3 ) is the reference pressure, or energy-density, introduced earlier. Actually, Oppenheimer and Volkoff (1939) introduced a modified relativity parameter t related to the usual one x by the transformation x = sinh(t/4), in terms of which they expressed their results as:
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
pranab
Rotation and Accretion Powered Pulsars
82
P =
t P0 (sinh t − 8 sinh + 3t) , 32 2
≡ ρc2 =
3P0 (sinh t − t) . 32
(2.67)
The algebra leading from Eqs. (2.53), (2.54), (2.66), and (2.27) to Eq. (2.67) is straightforward, which we leave to the reader as an exercise. The most significant changes enter in the description of the hydrostatic equilibrium of the degenerate star, as one might expect, since it involves the self-gravitational field of the star, and general relativity is a relativistic theory of gravitation, as opposed to Newton’s theory, which we have been using so far in this book. How is Eq. (10.35) modified by general relativity? Newtonian theory, or, equivalently, Poisson’s equation relating the second derivative of the Newtonian gravitational potential to the usual mass-density, is now replaced by Einstein’s equation relating the curvature tensor (which involves the derivatives of the co-ordinate metric; see,e.g., Weinberg 1972) to the energy-momentum tensor. For a spherically symmetric star in hydrostatic equilibrium, the gravitational field outside the star is given by the exterior Schwarzschild solution, and at every radius r inside the star, the condition for hydrostatic equilibrium becomes √ dP (r)/dr = (ρ(r) + P (r)/c2 )(−d ln −gtt /dr), i.e., (ρ + P/c2 ) replaces the √ mass-density in Eq. (10.35), and ln −gtt replaces the Newtonian gravitational potential. Here, gtt is the “time-time” part of the metric inside the star. Using the Einstein equations (see Weinberg 1972), we can eliminate the derivative of the metric in the above hydrostatic-equilibrium condition, and so obtain the equation describing the internal structure of spherically symmetric, static stars in general relativity, the Tolman-OppenheimerVolkoff (TOV) equation25 , as
P (r) 4πr 3 P (r) dP (r) Gm(r) 1 + ρ(r)c2 1 + m(r)c2
= −ρ(r) . dr r2 1 − 2Gm(r) rc2
(2.68)
Here, m(r), defined either by the differential equation dm(r)/dr = 4πr2 ρ(r) ,
(2.69)
25 Tolman not only laid the foundations of this field through his influential (1934) book Relativity, Thermodynamics and Cosmology, but also discussed various analytic solutions of TOV equations, and associated matter distributions, in a paper (1939) accompanying the Oppenheimer-Volkoff paper.
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
Degenerate Stars
pranab
83
r or, equivalently, by the integral m(r) ≡ 0 4πr2 ρ(r)dr, is the total massenergy inside radius r, including the gravitational self-energy. This is a crucial point, which needs to be fully appreciated by the reader before proceedR ing further. The mass of the star, defined by M ≡ m(R) ≡ 0 4πr2 ρ(r)dr, contains both the matter-energy (which includes the rest-mass energy and the zero-point kinetic energy, both of which have been counted already in our general-relativistic definition of ρ given above, as well as thermal energy, if we are considering non-zero temperatures) and the energy of the self-gravitational field of the star. This mass M is what is measured by a distant observer as the star’s mass, as inferred from its external gravitational field. (In more technical words, M is what describes the exterior Schwarzschild solution: see Weinberg 1972.) Thismay seem paradoxical to R the reader, since the simple-looking integral M = 0 4πr2 ρ(r)dr appears to be only a sum over the matter (or material) energy, and yet we are claiming that it includes both material and gravitational energy. However, it is the appearance which is wrong here, because the proper volume element dv in general relativity is not simply 4πr2 dr, but involves the space-time metric, and is (1 − 2Gm(r)/c2 )−1/2 4πr2 dr in this case, so that M , as defined by the above expression, is not an integral simply over the element of material energy ρdv. As a matter of fact, M does include both material and selfgravitational energy. It is the superficial similarity of Eq. (2.69) with the corresponding Newtonian equation (see Sec. 2.2.3.2) that tends to mislead us. In the TOV equation, the general-relativistic modifications can be seen as the factors within square brackets26 . The origins of these modifications are clear from the discussion given above Eq. (2.68): the first square bracket in the numerator comes from the fact that (ρ + P/c2 ) now replaces the mass-density of the Newtonian formulation, representing the components of the energy-momentum tensor (remember that ρ is now the energy-density, ρ ≡ /c2 , as explained earlier). The rest of the brackets are the effects of the metric, the Schwarzschild metric in this case. We expect, therefore, that when the relevant metric changes, e.g., for describing a rotating neutron star, the latter two factors will change, while the former will remain the same. 26 In
general relativity, it is convenient to use natural or geometrized units, in which c = G = 1. However, since we are introducing general-relativistic effects at this point, we have displayed the TOV equation in conventional units, to familiarize the reader with the way in which factors of c and G enter. Later, we shall use the geometrized units when appropriate.
January 10, 2007
84
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
Rotation and Accretion Powered Pulsars
Oppenheimer and Volkoff integrated Eqs. (2.67), (2.68) and (2.69) to obtain the masses and radii of neutron stars. The integration had to be numerical, of course, since even the Newtonian limit of these equations, which were combined by Chandrasekhar into Eq. (2.58), had to be integrated numerically, and, indeed, even the Lane-Emden equation, of which the Chandrasekhar equation can be thought of as a generalization, has to be so integrated except for very special values of the polytropic index s (which lie outside the range of s-values relevant for degenerate stars; see Sec. 2.2.3.2). It should come as no surprise to the reader, therefore, that all subsequent work on neutron-star masses and radii, which incorporated a variety of further physical effects into the equation of state and which we shall describe in the next chapters, necessarily involved numerical integration of the TOV equation. This is a standard procedure today, indeed rather easy for modern computers. We choose a central density (in the above generalized sense) ρc , and start integrating the above equations from the center, r = 0, where the other boundary condition is m(0) = 0. At each step, the equation of state relates the value of P to that of ρ: for the more complete, modern equations of state, the P –ρ relation becomes so complicated that it is customary to store it as a numerical P vs. ρ table in the computer, instead of the analytic relation given by Eq. (2.67). We stop the outward integration where P = 0: this is the surface of the neutron star, so that corresponding value r = R is the stellar radius, and m(R) = M is the stellar mass. Actually, Oppenheimer and Volkoff chose to work in terms of their modified realtivity parameter t rather than the density ρ (the relation between the two is, of course, Eqs. [2.67]), and so displayed their results, shown in Fig. 2.5, not as a relation between M and ρc , but as one between M and t0 , where t0 = tc ≡ t (r = 0) is the central value of t. (From the definition of t given earlier, the reader can easily show that t0 is closely related to the relativity parameter, and so to the Fermi energy and momentum, at the stellar center: xc = sinh[t0 /4], pcF = mcxc and EFc = mc2 cosh[t0 /4].) The stellar mass increases at first with increasing t0 (and therefore increasing ρc and xc ), representing stable neutron stars, until t0 ≈ 3 is reached, corresponding to xc ≈ 0.82 and ρc ≈ 4 × 1015 g cm−3 , where M passes through a maximum value Mmax = MOV ≈ 0.71M, the Oppenheimer-Volkoff mass limit. After this, M decreases with increasing ρc , xc , and t0 , representing unstable neutron stars which cannot occur in nature. The limiting stable configuration with mass MOV had a radius R ≈ 9.5 km according to the Oppenheimer-Volkoff calculation, which can be compared with the radius given by the simple estimate of Eqn. (2.23).
pranab
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
Degenerate Stars
pranab
85
Fig. 2.5 The Oppenheimer-Volkoff relation between a neutron star’s mass and the parameter t0 . The latter is a measure of its central density: see text. Reprinted with perc 1939 mission by the APS from Oppenheimer & Volkoff (1939), Phys. Rev., 55, 374. American Physical Society.
Note well that the physical origin of the Oppenheimer-Volkoff maximum in the neutron-star mass in Fig. 2.5 is different from that of the Chandrasekhar limit (1931b,c; 1935) for white dwarfs or its equivalent for neutron stars proposed by Landau (1938). Chandrasekhar and Landau worked entirely within the domain of the Newtonian theory of gravitation, and the Chandrasekhar-Landau limit comes from a physical cause which was first identified by Landau (1932), and which we have discussed earlier. It is that extremely relativistic degenerate fermions cannot provide an equilibrium stellar configuration by balancing the star’s self-gravitation with their zero-point pressure, if the star’s mass exceeds the Chandrasekhar-Landau limit. This limit does not appear as a maximum mass in the density-mass (or mass-radius) relation, but, rather, is appraoched asymptotically as the stellar density becomes very high, and the fermions become extremely relativistic, as we saw earlier. By contrast, Oppenheimer and Volkoff worked in a fully general-relativistic theory of gravitation, where new pieces of essential physics are added, as described above. As the density of the neutron star increases, general-relativsitic effects become important long before the neutrons are extremely relativistic and the Landau limit for neutrons has any relevance. These effects make the neutron star unstable to perturbations beyond a finite critical density (corresponding to a relativity
January 10, 2007
86
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
Rotation and Accretion Powered Pulsars
parameter x ≈ 1 for neutrons: see below), and so terminate the sequence of physically viable neutron stars at this point. This is the OppenheimerVolkoff limit, where the stellar mass passes through a maximum. Beyond this limit, equilibrium configurations are still possible (on the falling branch of the curve in Fig. 2.5, where stellar mass decreases with increasing density), but they are unstable and so do not occur in nature. There is, thus, a basic difference between the characters of the two limits. We illustrate the basic features of the Oppenheimer-Volkoff limit with the aid of a simple, but general-relativistic, “toy” model of neutron stars at the end of this chapter. We give there the essential variations in energy with density (or, equivalently, the relativity parameter x), i.e., the generalized Landau arguments for the general-relativistic case. As we shall see there, general relativity introduces two extrema in the energy curves as opposed to the one seen in Fig. 2.2 — a minimum corresponding to the Newtonian one already described earlier, and a maximum which is entirely general-realtivistic. The former is a stable equilibrium where the star is actually found, while the latter is an unstable equilibrium (corresponding to the falling branch in Fig. 2.5) which cannot occur in nature. As the stellar mass M increases, the two extrema approach each other, and coalesce at an inflection point for a maximum mass Mmax , which is the Oppenheimer-Volkoff limit (see Fig.2.7). At higher masses, there are no extrema, and no equilibria are possible. In this sense, then, we could think of a formal similarity between the Newtonian and the general-relativistic case, but it is only formal. The physical reasons for the disappearance of the extrema in the two cases are quite different: in the Newtonian case, it happens because the fermions become extremely relativsitic (ER) in their zero-point motion, as explained earlier, while in the GR case, it happens because of general-relativistic effects at high densities, which have no Newtonian analogue, and which occur, indeed, at densities where the zero-point motion of the neutrons is still only mildly relativistic (x < ∼ 1). Thus, the Chandrasekhar-Landau limit is completely Newtonian, while there appears to be no Newtonian analogue of the Oppenheimer-Volkoff limit. The reader will remember that we described earlier that white-dwarf masses also pass through a maximum value at a finite density when the effects of inverse β-decay are taken into account, terminating the sequence of physically viable white dwarfs at this maximum mass, since white dwarfs at higher densities are unstable, lying on a branch of the curve where stellar mass decreases with increasing stellar density. Naturally, the reader might wonder what connection there is between this phenomenon and the
pranab
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
Degenerate Stars
pranab
87
Oppenheimer-Volkoff limit. The answer, of course, is: none whatever. The white-dwarf maximum mass at a finite density occurs because of the detailed nuclear physics of white-dwarf matter, i.e., inverse β-decay of a given nuclear species above a density threshold, while the Oppenheimer-Volkoff maximum mass is a basic result of general relativity, completely independent of the details of neutron-star matter. The former occurs when electrons are extremely relativistic, with the relativity parameter at the stellar center xec ≡ peF /me c ∼ 10 – 30 (see Sec. 2.4.4), while the latter occurs when the neutrons are just becoming relativistic, with xnc ≡ pnF /mn c < ∼ 1, as we saw above. In fact, the Oppenheimer-Volkoff (1939) treatment of neutron stars is exactly at the same level of detail as the Chandrasekhar (1935) treatment of white dwarfs as far as the description of the stellar matter is concerned: each neglects the interactions between the fermions concerned, and each uses an exact, completely degenerate, equation of state for these non-interacting fermions. Modifications of the asymptotic approach to the Chandrasekhar limit enter only at the next higher level of detail, as we described in Sec. 2.4.4, when we put in the nuclear interactions. We stress this point particularly because there is a tendency in scientific literature to apply the name “Chandrasekhar limit” to the above maximum mass of white dwarfs at a finite density, which can cause confusion about the underlying physics. The correct analogue for neutron stars of the inverse β-decay effects on the white-dwarf mass would be the effects of any further nuclear transformations in neutronized matter at extremely high densities, e.g., production of muons and then a variety of hyperons, which we summarize later in the book. The other natural question, of course, is if there is an analogue of the Oppenheimer-Volkoff limit for white dwarfs at all. In other words, if we included general relativity in our description of stars supported by the zero-point pressure of degenerate electrons and neglected all other corrections to the Stoner-Chandrasekhar equation of state that we described in Sec. 2.4.4, would there be a point where the general-relativistic effects alone are sufficient to make the star unstable, and where the density is not yet high enough to make the neutrons degenerate? The answer is yes [Chandrasekhar 1964]: the onset of general-relativistic instability in white dwarfs occurs at a density ∼ 2.6 × 1010 gm cm−3 when its constituent elements have µ = 1/2, as is the case for C, O, Ne, Mg — the elements we now believe to be the principal constituents of white dwarfs existing in nature (see Sec. 2.4.4). This density is either greater than or comparable to that for the onset of inverse β-decay of these elements (see Sec. 2.4.4).
January 10, 2007
16:24
88
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
pranab
Rotation and Accretion Powered Pulsars
Thus, depending on the elemental composition, the point where the whitedwarf sequence terminates is determined entirely by the nuclear properties of its constituents, or by a combination of these and general-realtivistic effects, which are difficult to disentangle in practice. It appears at this time, therefore, that the effects of general relativity on white-dwarf stars are of secondary importance for practical purposes. 2.5.2
A General-Relativistic “Toy” Neutron Star
In order to clarify the essential effect of general relativity on the masses of neutron stars without the complication of numerical work (which sometimes tends to obscure the physics involved), we now present a simple, analytic, “toy” model of a neutron star which still retains general relativity in full, and so displays its effect transparently. The “toy” neutron star has a uniform density, in much the same spirit as our Newtonian uniform-density models of degenerate stars of Sec. 2.3, and Stoner’s white-dwarf models of Sec. 2.4.1. Amazing as it may seem, the TOV equation then has a simple, analytic solution, which was discovered by Schwarzschild in 1916 in his famous application of Einstein’s general-relativity theory to uniform spheres, and which we return to in Chapter 5. The reader can easily obtain the Schwarzschild (1916) solution by writing m(r) = (4/3)πr3 ρ in Eq. (2.68) and changing the radial variable from r to (1 − 8πGρr2 /3c2 ). The solution is P (r) 2 = −1 , 1−8πGρr 2 /3c2 ρc2 3− 1−2GM/Rc2
(2.70)
where M ≡ m(R) = (4/3)πR3 ρ is the stellar mass, R being the stellar radius. In terms of the central pressure Pc ≡ P (0), the stellar radius (where P (R) = 0) is given by R= and the stellar mass by M=
3Pc 2πρ2 G
6 π
1/2 1/2 1 + 2Pc /ρc2 , (1 + 3Pc /ρc2 )
Pc Gρ4/3
3/2 3/2 1 + 2Pc /ρc2 . (1 + 3Pc /ρc2 )3
(2.71)
(2.72)
We emphasize that, by setting ρ to a constant value independent of the radial coordinate, we are not claiming that the stellar matter is perfectly
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
Degenerate Stars
pranab
89
incompressible, in which case the equation of state for degenerate matter (Eq. [2.67]) would not apply. Rather, we are crudely mimicking the actual situation for neutron stars, particularly the heavier ones, where the density is nearly constant over most of the star (which accounts for almost all of the stellar mass), before falling off rapidly in the outermost layers, as we shall see later. While this simple approach is not strictly self-consistent, since P varies with r in Eqn. (2.72) but ρ does not, the results will, hopefully, display the essential features: this is the idea of a “toy” model. We now need to relate the central pressure to the central density, using an appropriate equation of state. Again in the spirit of the toy model, and remembering that neutrons in neutron stars are non-relativistic or mildly relativistic, we use the non-relativistic equation of state Pc = K NR ρ5/3 ,
(2.73)
where the constant K NR for the neutrons (compare with Eq. [2.42]) is given by K
NR
1 ≈ 20
2/3 2 3 h . 8/3 π mN
(2.74)
Combining Eqs. (2.72), (2.73), and (2.74), we obtain the mass vs. density relation for our toy neutron stars. We can now use the Landau mass scale ML ≡ (c/G)3/2 /m2N ≈ 1.85M and the Landau length scale RL ≡ RG (ML ) = GML /c2 defined in Sec. 2.2.2, as they are the natural units for the problem, and furthermore define a Landau density scale ρL 3 by the relation ρL ≡ ML /[(4/3)πRL ] ≈ 4.29 × 1016 g cm−3 . In these units, the density-mass relation is: M 9π = √ ML 5 10
ρ ρL
3/2 1/2 1 + 2β (ρ/ρ )2/3 L
3 , 2/3 1 + 3β (ρ/ρL )
(2.75)
where β ≡ (9π/4)2/3 /5 ≈ 0.737. If we neglect the deviation of the quantities within square brackets in Eq. (2.75) from unity, we recover the familiar √ density-mass relation (M ∝ ρ) for a non-relatvistic degenerate Fermi gas of neutrons (a polytrope with s = 3/2) in Newtonian gravity. Thus, the general-relativistic effects are contained entirely (and transparently) in the square brackets, the strength of these effects being measured by the parameter (Pc /ρc2 ) = β(ρ/ρL )2/3 . It must be clear to the reader that, as ρ
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
pranab
Rotation and Accretion Powered Pulsars
90
increases and so does this parameter, M given by Eq. (2.75) passes through a maximum, and declines at still higher densities. Actually, it is instructive to rewrite our results in terms of the relativity parameter xnc for the neutrons at the stellar center introduced above, which we shall abbreviate as x in further discussions of this toy model. x is, of course, a measure of the importance of the effects of special relativity, by definition. Note, however, that we can express it as 1/3 1/3 1/3 ρ ρ 9π ≈ 1.92 , (2.76) x= 4 ρL ρL with the aid of Eq. (2.57), so that we can rewrite the general-relativity parameter introduced above as: 2/3 1 ρ Pc =β = x2 . (2.77) ρc2 ρL 5 This shows that x is also a measure of the general-relativistic effects: we shall display our final results in trems of x, for ease of comparison with those of Oppenheimer-Volkoff and others. We rewrite Eq. (2.75) as 6 M = ML 5
π 3/2 x g(x) , 10
g(x) ≡
3/2 1 + 2x2 /5 (1 + 3x2 /5)3
,
(2.78)
and display the toy neutron-star’s mass as a function of x in Fig. 2.6. The reader can easily show that the maximum mass is Mmax ≈ 0.51M, that it occurs at x ≈ 1.07, and that the corresponding value of the density is ρ ≈ 7.4 × 1015 g cm−3 . These values can be compared with the corresponding Oppenheimer-Volkoff values given earlier. Rather than investigating the details of the deviations of the toy-star properties from those of the numerical Oppenheimer-Volkoff models, we should note the remarkable similarity between the two despite the simplifying assumptions that went into the former, and ask ourselves how this happened. The answer is clear: the uniform-density profile is close enough to the actual profiles of numerically calculated neutron-star models, and the NR approximation is adequate enough for the equation of state of neutrons in range of densities relevant for stable neutron stars (although not so, of course, for x 1), that no gross errors were made on the stable branch of the density-mass relation. The toy model is very useful because it shows us directly where and how the general-relativistic effects come in, viz., through the quantities in square brackets in Eq. (2.75). Each of these
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
Mass/Msun
Degenerate Stars
0.6 0.5 0.4
pranab
91
Uniform Density "Toy"
Neutron Star Mass
0.3 0.2 0.1 0.0 0.01
0.10 1.00 Relativity Parameter (x)
Fig. 2.6 Mass of our uniform-density “toy” neutron star vs. its relativity parameter x, the latter being a measure of its density (see text). Note the similarities with the Oppenheimer-Volkoff results shown in Fig. 2.5.
arises from a mixture of the two effects we described in Sec. 2.5.1: (a) the replacement of ρ by ρ + P/c2 , and, (b) the deviation of the metric gtt from its flat spacetime value.
2.6
Landau Arguments: General-Relativistic Modifications
Beautiful as they are, the Landau arguments as given in Sec. 2.3 still lack one essential piece of physics, since they use Newtonian theory of gravity, and so miss the general-relativistic effects. We have already seen in the last section what happens to the hydrostatic equlibrium and the densitymass relation of degenerate stars when the Newtonian theory is replaced by the general theory of relativity. What happens to Landau’s energy arguments under this replacement is also highly interesting, as we describe now: the modified Landau arguments immediately show the existence of the branch of unstable equilibria in a transparent way, again underscoring their inherent power. The essential modifications to the Landau arguments are entirely in the self-gravitational energy Egrav , the Newtonian expression for which,
January 10, 2007
92
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
pranab
Rotation and Accretion Powered Pulsars
as given by Eq. (2.13), must now be replaced by an appropriate generalrelativistic expression. By comparison, the slight modification in the zeropoint energy is only formal, involving merely a re-definition of the massenergy as explained above, and of little consequence. Even then, we shall include it in the explicit calculations presented below. These calculations are done for a slightly more sophisticated version of the uniform-density toy neutron star introduced above, in which we use the exact equation of state for the degenerate neutrons instead of its NR limit as we did in the last section. This makes the comparison with the Newtonian Landau arguments presented in Sec. 2.3 more transparent. Of course, this slightly more sophisticated toy has properties which are slightly different from those of the simple toy of last section. For example, the maximum mass now occurs at Mmax ≈ 0.85M, as we shall see. We calculate the self-gravitational energy Egrav of our toy star by noting that it is the difference, Egrav = (M − M0 )c2 , between the toR tal “gravitational” mass of the star, M ≡ 0 4πr2 ρ(r)dr, as seen by a distant observer, and the total matter-content (including both restmass energy) of the star, which is the integral M0 ≡ R and zero-point 2 −1/2 4πr2 ρdr, as explained in Sec. 2.5.1. Using m(r) = 0 (1 − 2Gm(r)/c ) 3 (4/3)πr ρ and M = (4/3)πR3 ρ for our toy star, we get Egrav = −G(a), M c2
G(a) ≡ 3 0
1
y 2 dy −1 , 1 − ay 2
(2.79)
where a ≡ (2GM/Rc2 ) is called the compactness parameter of the star, and sometimes also its redshift parameter, since it is closely connected to the general-relativistic redshift of the radiation emitted from the stellar surface, as we shall see later in the book. The integral in Eq. (2.79) is elementary and yields G(a) =
3 −1 √ sin a − a(1 − a) −1 . 2a3/2
(2.80)
The reader can easily work out the Newtonian (a 1) limit of G(a), viz., G(a) =
9 3 a + a2 · · · , 10 56
(2.81)
which shows that we recover the Newtonian result Egrav = −(3/5)GM 2 /R from the leading term in Eq. (2.81), as we must.
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
Degenerate Stars
pranab
93
Consider now the modified definition of density, ρ ≡ n(mN +Enull /c2 ) as explained above, n being the number density of the neutrons, and note that the total number N of neutrons in the star is related to its total mattercontent M0 introduced above as M0 = N (mN + Enull /c2 ) = M mN [1 + fE (x)], where we have used Eq. (2.26) in the last step. Accordingly, the self-gravitational energy per neutron, Egrav ≡ Egrav /N , can be expressed as Egrav G(a) [1 + fE (x)] , =− m N c2 1 + G(a)
(2.82)
and the total energy per neutron, E ≡ Egrav + Enull can therefore be written, using Enull = mN c2 fE (x), as: E mN
c2
=
fE (x) − G(a) . 1 + G(a)
(2.83)
Observe next that the compactness parameter, which can be written as a = 2(4π/3)1/3 GM 2/3 ρ1/3 /c2 for a uniform-density star, can be expressed in terms of the relativity parameter x with the aid of the expression for the modified mass-density ρ given in the last paragraph, and Eq. (2.31). The result is most conveniently expressed in terms of the Newtonian mass limit Mc we introduced in Sec. 2.3 (see Eq.[2.21]), identical to Stoner’s mass limit MS discussed in Sec. 2.4.1 (see Eq.[2.32]), and is given by a=
5 2
M Mc
2/3 x[1 + fE (x)]1/3 .
(2.84)
For neutron stars, Mc = MS ≈ 6.89M corresponding to µ ≈ 1, as explained before. The quantitative energy results of our general-relativistic toy neutron star are contained in Eqs. (2.83) and (2.84). Before discussing them, however, we extract their Newtonian limit, which we used in Sec. 2.3 for the Newtonian energy curves shown there. This is the limit a 1, in which we use the appropriate limit given by Eq. (2.80), and the usual Newtonian definition of density, and so obtain 3 ENewton = fE (x) − 2 mN c 4
M Mc
2/3 x,
(2.85)
which can, of course, be directly obtained from the Newtonian expressions for energy given in earlier sections.
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
Rotation and Accretion Powered Pulsars
94
Total Energy (ε)
0.10
Landau arguments General Relativistic
0.07
0.05
0.085
0.00
0.1
-0.05 -0.10 0.01
0.13 0.8
0.4
0.2
0.10 1.00 Relativity Parameter (x)
Fig. 2.7 Generalized Landau arguments including general relativity. Shown is the total energy per neutron (E) in units of the neutron’s rest-mass energy for a uniform-density general relativistic “toy” neutron star vs. its relativity parameter x, the latter being a measure of its density (see text). Curves are given for various values of M/Mc , each curve labeled by its value of M/Mc . Dashed line: critical curve corresponding to M/Mc ≈ 0.13 (or the maximum mass M ≈ 0.89M possible for this toy neutron star; see text), where the maxima and minima in the curves coalesce into an inflection point. Curves corresponding to higher masses have no extrema, so that no equlibria are possible. Note the difference from the Newtonian case shown in Fig. 2.2.
Consider, finally, the variation of the general-relativistic energy with density or relativity parmeter x, as given by Eqs. (2.83) and (2.84), and as displayed in Fig. 2.7. The essential new feature is clear: in addition to the minimum in the energy, as in the Newtonian case, there is now also a maximum at higher densities, corresponding to an unstable equilibrium of a stellar configuration of the same mass. This corresponds to the falling, unstable branch in Fig. 2.6. The physical cause of this maximum is clear from a glance at Eqs. (2.80) and (2.81). General-relativistic effects increase the magnitude of the gravitational binding energy of a star, i.e., the selfgravitational energy of a star of a given mass and radius is more negative when these effects are included. At sufficiently high densities, this effect is so large that, even for those stellar masses where the (positive) zeropoint energy dominated at high densities in the Newtonian case, so that E was increasing monotonically there after passing through a minimum,
pranab
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
Degenerate Stars
pranab
95
the energy is now dominated by the (negative) gravitational component at very high densities, which stops the above increase in energy and reverses it, producing a maximum. Thus, for a given stellar mass M , there are two possible equilibria—one stable and one unstable—corresponding to the two extrema, and only the stable one occurs in nature. As M increases, the two extrema approach each other, and at a maximum mass Mmax , they merge at an inflection point, corresponding to the maximum mass seen in the mass-density plots. For M > Mmax , there are no extrema in the energy, and no equilibrium configuration is possible, the situation leading to gravitaional collapse. For our “sophisticated” toy neutron star of this section, Mmax ≈ 0.89M, and the corresponding value of x is x ≈ 0.63. These values can be compared with the corresponding ones for either (a) the numerical models of Oppenheimer and Volkoff or (b) the simple, analytical toy considered above. The energy arguments thus show their power once again, displaying in an elementary and transparent way how the character of the equilibria of degenerate stars changes due to the “stronger” gravitational forces (or, strong field effects, as they are often called) that apply when general relativity is invoked. We emphasize that the above differences in energy variation from the Newtonian case are qualitative and therefore essential, not just a matter of detail. Further discussion on this point has been given in Sec. 2.5.1.
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
This page intentionally left blank
pranab
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
Chapter 3
Physics of Neutron Stars — II Physics of Dense Matter-1
The essence of more realistic calculations of the basic properties of degenerate stars is the recognition that the matter in them is actually far more complicated than the simple, non-interacting, completely degenerate matter discussed in the last chapter. The complications come from the electromagnetic, weak, and strong interactions between the constituent particles (electrons, protons, neutrons, and a variety of mesons and hyperons produced at very high densities, and possibly quark matter at even higher densities), and we now consider the basic physics of dense matter when these interactions are included. It is essential to understand this physics well, since this is what determines how the equation of state (henceforth abbreviated as EOS) of matter changes as its density increases, which, in turn, determines the internal structure, the mass-radius relation, and the maximum mass of degenerate stars, particularly neutron stars. We have already introduced some of these effects (particularly those which are important at the relatively low densities found in white dwarfs) qualitatively in Sec. 2.4.4. In this and the next chapter, we give a comprehensive discussion of the essential physics of dense matter, keeping in mind that our main concern in this book is with neutron stars, and therefore with matter at very high densities.
3.1
Matter at Low Densities: Electronic Energy
At low densities of matter, the most stable nucleus is iron in the form of 56 26 Fe, as we stated in Sec. 2.4.4. Consider the physical reasons for this. If the only force between the protons and neutrons in a nucleus were the strong nuclear forces, which are attractive (except at extremely short distances), nuclei would grow to unlimited size, i.e., to aggregates of nucleons with 97
pranab
January 10, 2007
16:24
98
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
Rotation and Accretion Powered Pulsars
arbitrarily large mass numbers A. The Coulomb force of repulsion between the protons prevents this from happening, since very large nuclei would undergo spontaneous fission into smaller fragments due to the repulsive Coulomb forces. The point of stable equilibrium between these opposing forces, which occurs at the minimum of the total energy, determines the mass number A and the atomic number Z of the stable nucleus. At relatively low densities, by which we mean all the way from terrestrial densities to those at which inverse β-decay starts in the cores of white dwarfs (See Sec. 2.4.4), the most stable, i.e., the most tightly bound, nucleus is 56 26 Fe. The ground state of cold matter in nuclear equilibrium at these densities would, therefore, be expected to be a lattice of such iron nuclei immersed in an electron ‘sea’ or fluid1 . At very low densities, the behavior of cold, crystalline matter is determined by solid-state forces which depend on the properties of the (strongly interacting) electron fluid. Calculation of electronic energies is the most difficult at the lowest densities of this range [Pethick and Ravenhall 1991], due to complicated effects of the electronic shell-structure in atoms, but the problem becomes easier with increasing density, as (a) the relative importance of elctronic Coulomb interactions decreases (see below), and, (b) a statistical treatment of the atomic electrons by the Thomas-Fermi method (see below) becomes possible. 3.1.1
Wigner-Seitz Cells
Consider the basics of Coulomb interactions of electrons with nuclei and electrons in matter composed of nuclei of atomic number Z, mass number A, and number density nN , immersed in a fluid of electrons with number density ne : clearly, ne = ZnN by the requirement of overall charge neu1 This does not mean, of course, that terrestrial, planetary, or white-dwarf matter really consists wholly of iron, but rather that the lowest-possible equilibrium state of cold matter at their densities would be obtained for iron. The actual composition of an object which is not cold and not in nuclear equilibrium depends on its formation history and thermal structure. Planets (which are generally not cold systems) are believed to have formed from left-over material in accretion disks after stellar formation, and their matter, which is not in nuclear equilibrium, contains a wide variety of elements. Even the cores of cold white dwarfs, whose elemental compositions are determined by the history of thermonuclear burning in their progenitors, are now believed to consist of elements much lighter than Fe, e.g., C, O, Ne, Mg (See Sec. 2.4.4). However, it is essential for our purposes here to clarify the nature of the ground state of cold matter at these densities before discussing that of matter at much higher densities in the interiors of neutron stars, since an understanding of the progression of the essential physics with rising density is crucial.
pranab
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
Physics of Dense Matter-1
pranab
99
trality of matter. It is useful to define a length rc such that the volume per nucleus is equal to that of a sphere of radius rc . This length is given by nN =
1 . 4πrc3 /3
(3.1)
The physical picture we have in mind is the Wigner-Seitz approximation (see Sec. 2.4.4), in which each nucleus is surrounded by Z electrons, producing a neutral sphere of radius rc . In this simple, pioneering view of solids, which goes back to the 1930s, the lattice of ions immersed in the electron fluid is roughly approximated by an arrangement of these spherical Wigner-Seitz “cell”s. Of course, rc is a measure of the lattice spacing. In a similar way, we can define a length re for the electrons by the relation ne = 1/(4πre3 /3). The length re , which is a measure of the average distance between the electrons, is seen to be related to rc as rc = Z 1/3 re on using the above relation between nN and ne . The total Coulomb energy of interaction between all the electrons and ions, which determines the properties of matter and so its EOS at these densities, is easy to calculate in the Wigner-Seitz approximation, as each of the above spherical cells is neutral, so that interactions between the cells can be neglected in a first approximation, and we need only calculate the Coulomb energy of a single cell, followed by a sum over all cells. To make a simple estimate of this, imagine that the total charge −Ze of the Z electrons in a Wigner-Seitz cell is uniformly distributed over the volume of the sphere of radius rc , surrounding the nucleus of charge Ze, regarded as a point charge at the center of the sphere. Then the Coulomb energy of mutual repulsion of the electrons is just the elctrostatic self-energy of the sphere excluding the nucleus, wee =
3 Z 2 e2 , 5 rc
(3.2)
while that of the attraction between the nucleus and the electrons is given by: 3 Z 2 e2 ρe d3 r =− , (3.3) wei = Ze r 2 rc where ρe ≡ −Ze/(4πrc3 /3) is the electronic charge density. Note that wei and wee are generally of the same order, but the magnitude of the former always exceeds that of the latter, yielding an overall negative Coulomb energy per cell,
January 10, 2007
100
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
pranab
Rotation and Accretion Powered Pulsars
wc = wee + wei = −
9 Z 2 e2 , 10 rc
(3.4)
as expected. It is a well-known, remarkable fact that the Coulomb energy per electron, Ec ≡ wc /Z = −(9/10)(4π/3)1/3Z 2/3 e2 n1/3 e ,
(3.5)
obtained in this simple way is very close (within 1%) to the results of the actual calculations for body-centered, face-centered, or simple cubic lattices, which implies, of course, that Ec depends little on the details of the lattice structure. Indeed, the energy is close to the above value even if the ions form a cold liquid, i.e., one whose thermal energy is small compared to the above energy [Pethick and Ravenhall 1991]. As the density rises, so does the kinetic energy of an electron, and when it much exceeds the magnitude of the above Coulomb energy, the electrons behave essentially as free electrons, i.e., unaffected by the Coulomb interactions described above. With the aid of Eq. (2.11) for the kinetic energy per electron, Enull , of cold electrons, this criterion, namely, Enull | Ec |, yields the condition ne (4/π 3 )(Z 2 /a30 ) on the electron density, where a0 ≡ 2 /me e2 is the Bohr radius. The corresponding condition on the matter density, ρ = Amb ne /Z, is then ρ ρfree ≡
4 mN AZ 3 ≈ 1.4 AZ g cm−3 , π3 a0
(3.6)
showing the natural density scale of the problem to be mb /a30 ≈ 11 g cm−3 . Here, mb is the mass of a nucleon (baryon). For hydrogen, ρfree ∼ 1 g cm−3 , 4 −3 and for iron it is ∼ 2 × 103 g cm−3 . At densities ρ > ∼ 10 g cm , we thus expect the Coulomb corrections to the EOS to be insignificant, and the Stoner-Chandrasekhar EOS for degenerate electrons, described in detail in the previous chapter, to be a sufficiently accurate description, until other physical effects enter at much higher densities. Note that electrons are still non-relativistic at densities where Coulomb corrections are significant (ρ < ∼ ρfree ), as explained in Sec. 2.3 (see discussion below Eq. (2.20)): they 6 −3 become relativistic only at ρ > ∼ 10 g cm ρfree . At densities below ρfree , then, there is a significant contribution to the total energy per electron, E = Enull + Ec , from the electronic Coulomb energy Ec , which reduces it from its zero-point value, since Ec < 0. The corresponding pressure can be obtained from the general relation
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
Physics of Dense Matter-1
P = n2b
∂(u/nb ) , ∂nb
pranab
101
(3.7)
where nb is the number density of baryons and u is the total energy density: we shall use this relation repeatedly in this chapter, and throughout the book. In this case, using E = (u/nb )(A/Z) and nb = ne (A/Z), we can write P = n2e (∂E/∂ne ), which, together with Eqs. (2.11) and (3.6), yields 1/3 ρfree P = Pnull 1 − , (3.8) 8ρ showing that the pressure is reduced by the Coulomb interactions, as expected. Indeed, Eq. (3.8) would imply that the pressure vanishes at a density ρ = ρfree /8 ≈ 0.18 AZ g cm−3 . Although this result is not surprising in view of the above way in which we estimated the pressure reduction, the crudeness of that estimate becomes evident from the following considerations, first given by Salpeter (1961). Consider solid iron, 56 26 Fe. If we argue that the equilibrium state of this solid in terrestrial laboratories is roughly the point at which the (outward) zero-point pressure and the (inward) overall Coulomb self-attraction balance, i.e., where the pressure given by Eq. (3.8) vanishes, we would get a density ρ ≈ 260 g cm−3 , to be contrasted with the actual terrestrial density of iron, ρ ≈ 7.9 g cm−3 ! 3.1.2
The Thomas-Fermi Approximation
The major piece of missing physics in the above estimate is the nonuniformity of the electron density in the Wigner-Seitz cell, whose effects simply cannot be ignored at low densities. While these effects are extremely complicated at terrestrial densities, a statistical description of the electronic orbits becomes viable at somewhat higher densities, e.g., at ρ > ∼ 15 g cm−3 for iron. This is the Thomas-Fermi approximation, in which one improves on the assumption of constant electron density ne inside a Wigner-Seitz spherical cell of radius rc by approximating it with a spherically symmetric function of radius, ne (r). This radially-varying electron density is determined by assuming that, inside each Wigner-Seitz cell, the electrons ‘see’ only a slowly-varying, spherically symmetric potential φ(r), and relating φ(r) to ne (r) through Poisson’s equation, as we summarize below. The assumption of a slowly-varying φ(r) is crucial, because it implies that the (electrostatic) forces, −dφ(r)/dr, generated from it are relatively
January 10, 2007
102
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
pranab
Rotation and Accretion Powered Pulsars
small, which means that we can apply the usual Fermi-Dirac statistics. It also shows the inherent limitation of the Thomas-Fermi approximation: it is basically a perturbation theory, and will not work when Coulomb interaction energy is comparable to zero-point energy, i.e., at very low densities. The Fermi energy EF , defined in Sec. 2.2.4, now needs to be modified by the inclusion of the potential energy −eφ(r), and it is this total EF which determines the statistical properties of electrons in a Wigner-Seitz cell. In complete degeneracy, all energy-states upto EF are occupied, and all those above it empty. Note that this total EF must be constant over a cell, for if it had different values at two radii, electrons would move from the higher value to the lower value. However, both ne and φ do vary with radius over the extent of a cell: in fact, they do so in roughly similar ways (see below), so as to keep EF constant. The Thomas-Fermi calculation is straightforward, although requiring (a small amount of) numerical work. Noting that EF = me c2 + p2F (r)/2me − eφ(r) for non-relativistic electrons, we choose the kinetic energy Ek (r) = p2F (r)/2me = EF − me c2 + eφ(r) as the variable used for the computation, rewriting Eq. (2.10) as ne (r) = (8π/3h3 )(2me Ek (r))3/2 . Poisson’s equation relating φ(r) to the charge-density in the Wigner-Seitz cell, i.e., ∇2 φ(r) = 4πene (r) − 4πZeδ(r), where the second term on the right-hand side represents the point-like nucleus of charge Ze, reduces to 32π 2 e2 1 d2 [rE (r)] = [2me Ek (r)]3/2 k r dr2 3h3
(3.9)
everywhere outside the nucleus, eliminating φ(r) with the aid of the above relation between it and Ek (r). Equation (3.9) is to be solved subject to the boundary conditions (a) that the potential must correctly reduce to that due to the nucleus as r → 0, i.e., [rφ(r)]r→0 = Ze, and (b) that the electrostatic forces must vanish at the cell boundary, r = rc , since each cell is electrically neutral, i.e., (dφ/dr)rc = 0. Equation (3.9) can be readily cast in the standard, dimensionless, Thomas-Fermi form by identifying the natural scales for length and energy in this problem, the former being the Fermi length λ≡
9π 2 128Z
1/3 a0 ,
(3.10)
and the latter being the reference Coulomb energy Ze2 /r. In Eq. (3.10), a0 ≡ 2 /me e2 is the Bohr radius, as before. Introducing the dimensionless
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
Physics of Dense Matter-1
pranab
103
energy ψ ≡ rEk /Ze2 and Fermi’s dimensionless radial co-ordinate x ≡ r/λ, we obtain from Eq. (3.9) the Thomas-Fermi equation: ψ 3/2 d2 ψ = 1/2 , 2 dx x
(3.11)
and similarly translate the above boundary conditions on φ into the following ones on ψ: (a) ψ(0) = 1, and (b) (dψ/dx)xc = ψ(xc )/xc . Equation (3.11) is simple but nonlinear, and has to be solved numerically: this was done by Feynman, Metropolis and Teller in 1949 in order to obtain the modified EOS. The cell boundary xc is obtained from the numerical integration as the radius where the second boundary condition is satisfied2 . We then calculate the resultant pressure of the system by noting that it is the electron pressure Pc at the cell boundary which balances the external pressure on the system, since electrostatic forces vanish at that boundary by definition, and there are no interaction between cells. Therefore, the observed pressure is this Pc , given by Eq. (2.11), with the relevant electron density now being nce ≡ ne (xc ), i.e., that at the cell boundary. This pressure can be compared with that obtained earlier for a uniform electron distribution and no Coulomb effects, which we denoted above by Pnull : this is given by Eq. (2.11) with an electron density related to the observed matter density ρ by ρ = AmN ne /Z, as discussed above. We drop the subscript c on P henceforth, and express the ratio of the pressures, P/Pnull = (nce /ne )5/3 , in terms of the solution of the Thomas-Fermi equation by the following method. The local relation between ne and Ek (given above Eq. [3.9]) holds everywhere: by applying it to the cell boundary, and combining the result with the value at this boundary of the dimensionless energy introduced earlier, Ekc = Ze2 ψc /λxc , the reader can show with the aid of Eq. (3.10) that nce /ne = (ψc xc )3/2 /3, where ψc ≡ ψ(xc ). This yields the “pressure correction factor” of Feynman, Metropolis and Teller (1949): 1 P = 5/3 (ψc xc )5/2 , Pnull 3
(3.12)
and so their EOS, which is generally adequate for this low-density r´egime upto ρ ≈ 104 g cm−3 . At the latter density, the pressure correction factor 2 The original Thomas-Fermi model had the defect that the zero-pressure case, corresponding to free atoms, yielded xc → ∞, indicating an infinitely large radius for such atoms. This defect was remedied by including the Dirac exchange term . In this Thomas-Fermi-Dirac model, the right-hand side of Eq. (3.11) acquires an extra factor of (1 + x/ψ)3 , and that of Eq. (3.12) an extra factor (1 + xc /ψc )5 [1 − (5/4)( + ψc /xc )−1 ]. Calculation of the exchange energy is mentioned in the text in brief.
January 10, 2007
104
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
Rotation and Accretion Powered Pulsars
of Eq. (3.12) becomes essentially unity, corresponding to the fact that the elctronic Coulomb contributions to the total pressure become insignificant at and above this density, as discussed earlier. Thus, the direct influence of 4 the electronic, or lattice, energy on the EOS becomes negligible for ρ > ∼ 10 −3 g cm . However, it retains a significant indirect role in determining the nature of dense matter (through its role in determining equilibrium nuclides after the onset of inverse β-decay) upto much higher densities, as we shall see in Sec. 3.2. An alternative approach was adopted by Salpeter (1961), who calculated the Thomas-Fermi corrections to the energy, ETF , in a manifestly perturbative, linearized theory, arguing that the energies Enull , Ec , and ETF were successive terms in a perturbation expansion at the densities of interest. By contrast, the above Feynman et al. approach calculates the total energy at one go, in a nonlinear theory. Salpeter (1961) also calculated the (smaller) exchange energy Eex (see footnote), which takes account of the antisymmetric wave functions of the electrons, and also the (even smaller) correlation energy, all within his perturbative approach. In the non-relativsitic limit, only the simplest, Coulomb exchange interaction survives, yielding the re1/3 NR = −(3/4)(9/π 2)1/3 Z 1/3 e2 /rc = −(3/4)(3/π)1/3 e2 ne . In practisult Eex cal calculations, the above two approaches yield essentially identical results, and the Feynman-Metropolis-Teller EOS is often used for densities 10 g 4 −3 cm−3 < ∼ρ< ∼ 10 g cm . Above this upper limit, the Stoner-Chandrasekhar EOS (see Sec. 2.4.3 and Eq. [2.53]) with the simple Coulomb correction represented by Eq. (3.4) is adequate until the equilibrium nuclides start changing at ρ ≈ 8 × 106 g cm−3 (see Sec. 3.2).
3.2
Dense Matter Below Neutron-Drip Density: Equilibrium Nuclei
6 −3 (see After the electrons become relativistic at densities ρ > ∼ 10 g cm Sec. 2.3), their kinetic energies go into the MeV range, making inverse β-decay possible by blocking its reverse reaction, i.e., β-decay, as we explained in Sec. 2.4.4. Although the actual density thresholds for inverse β-decay of the nuclei of interest are typically in the range ρ ∼ 109 – 1010 g cm−3 (see Sec. 2.4.4), the presence of highly energetic electrons changes the properties of matter long before such densities are reached. This occurs because the weak interactions, which determine the balance between the protons and neutrons in the nuclei and the electrons surrounding them, play a crucial role in determining the equilibrium state of the nuclei, in
pranab
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
Physics of Dense Matter-1
pranab
105
addition to that played by the strong interactions between the nucleons in the nuclei. Equilibrium with respect to weak interactions determines the neutron/proton ratio in the nuclei, and the MeV-scale energy of electrons at these densities has a profound effect on this ratio. As we shall see below, the equilibrium condition is that the difference between the neutron chemical potential and the proton chemical potential equals the electron chemical potential (µn − µp = µe ), which physically means that it costs no energy to convert an electron and a proton into a neutron, or vice versa. With rising density, µe rises, leading to an increase in µn − µp , which means an increase in the neutron/proton ratio, or neutron richness, of the nuclei. For calculating the equilibrium nuclides, one borrows from the earlier, extensive research in nuclear physics on the semi-empirical mass formula for nuclei, the origins of which go back to the classic work of von Weizs¨acker (1935). This is a simple, liquid-drop model of the nucleus, in which the energy of an isolated nucleus (A, Z), including the rest-masses of its constituent protons (mp ) and neutrons (mn ), is given by [Pethick and Ravenhall 1991]: E(A, Z) = Evol + Esurf + ECoul ,
(3.13)
where Evol = (A − Z)mn c2 + Zmp c2 − Eb A + Es (1 − 2xp )2 A,
(3.14)
is the bulk energy, and the surface energy Esurf and Coulomb energy ECoul are given by Esurf = Eσ A2/3
,
ECoul = Ec x2p A5/3 .
(3.15)
Here, xp ≡ Z/A is the proton fraction, Eb is the bulk binding energy per nucleon, Es is the symmetry energy coefficient, and Eσ and Ec are the coefficients for surface and Coulomb energy respectively. Note that another very useful parameter related to the proton fraction is the neutron excess δ ≡ (N − Z)/(N + Z) = 1 − 2xp , in terms of which the symmetry energy has a quadratic form Es δ 2 A: this form is characteristic of laboratory nuclei with low to moderate neutron excess. We shall see later that the form may be inadequate for very neutron-rich nuclei, i.e., those with large values of δ. The physical origins for the scalings of the surface and Coulomb energies with A and xp become clear when we write these in their usual forms, i.e., Esurf = σS, and ECoul = (3/5)Z 2 e2 /rN , where σ is the surface tension,
January 10, 2007
16:24
106
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
pranab
Rotation and Accretion Powered Pulsars
2 S = 4πrN is the surface area, and we have assumed, for simplicity, spherical nuclei of radius rN (thus improving on the point-nucleus assumption which we made while calculating the lattice energy in Sec. 3.1), with the protonic charges Ze distributed uniformly through this sphere. Since the expected, obvious scaling rN ≈ r0 A1/3 (i.e., nuclear volume ∝ A) is borne out by actual size measurements of nuclei, the above scalings follow, with Eσ = 4πσr02 and Ec = (3/5)e2 /r0 . Here, r0 ≈ 1.14 fm is the standard nuclear scale size, in terms of the unit of length 1 fm ≡ 10−13 cm named after Fermi and used universally3 in nuclear physics. Similarly, if we wish to bring out the scaling of the bulk energy Evol , we can express it as Evol = Eb A, in terms of the energy per nucleon (baryon) of uniform matter, Eb , and express the latter as
Eb = mn c2 − Eb − xp (mn − mp )c2 + Es (1 − 2xp )2 .
(3.16)
Note that σ depends on the proton fraction xp (or neutron excess δ), and Eb on both xp and the number density of nucleons (baryons) nb . The total energy per unit volume of the matter is, therefore, given by utot = nN E(A, Z) + ne Ee = nb (Eb + Eσ A−1/3 + Ec x2p A2/3 + xp Ee ), (3.17) where the energy per electron Ee includes (a) the rest mass me , (b) the zero-point kinetic energy (see Sec. 2.3), and (c) the complete Coulomb energy, including electron-nucleus and electron-electron contributions (see Sec. 3.1). At a given density, the equilibrium nuclide (A, Z) is that which minimizes utot with respect to both A and Z. It is convenient to minimize first with respect to A and then with respect to xp ≡ Z/A, and this two-step procedure has important physical significances, as stressed by Pethick and Ravenhall (1995). The first step is really an optimization with respect to the strong interaction process, which conserves not only the total number of baryons, but also protons and neutrons separately, and so also the number of electrons. Consequently, nb and xp remain unchanged under this process (and therefore Eb (nb , xp )), as does Ee . The minimization with respect to A then simply finds that value of A for which the nucleus has a minimum 3 Note
also that 1 fm = 10−15 m, which is called a femtometer. This unit, which is relevant for nuclear physics, is not to be confused, of course, with the much larger unit of length λ (given by Eq. [3.10]) which Fermi introduced in the Thomas-Fermi theory of the atom, and which we discussed in Sec. 3.1. λ is comparable to atomic sizes, and measured in units of the Bohr radius a0 ≈ 0.5 × 10−8 cm.
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
Physics of Dense Matter-1
pranab
107
value of (surface + Coulomb) energy. Straightforward differentiation of Eq. (3.17) yields A=
Eσ , 2Ec x2p
(3.18)
which means Eσ A2/3 = 2Ec x2p A5/3 , or, Esurf = 2ECoul
(3.19)
This simple and classic result, namely that the surface energy equals twice the Coulomb energy for a nucleus at equilibrium under strong interactions, is as expected, since the bulk (including symmetry) properties of nuclear matter drop out of this equilibration process, as explained above, leaving only those effects which depend on the actual size of the nuclei, i.e., the finite-size effects. It is very instructive, and indeed essential for later usage, to compare Eq. (3.19) with another classic finite-size effect of crucial importance in nuclear physics, namely the Bohr-Wheeler (1939) criterion for nuclear fission. The latter criterion states that an isolated nucleus undergoes spontaneous quadrupolar deformation and fission into smaller pieces if its Coulomb energy exceeds twice its surface energy, 0 0 ≥ 2Esurf , ECoul
(3.20)
where the superscript 0 stresses the fact that the nucleus is isolated. As 0 0 long as Esurf ≈ Esurf and ECoul ≈ ECoul , i.e., we can neglect the changes in these energies due to the presence of other nuclei, and of electrons (and also neutrons at sufficiently high densities, as we shall see below) surrounding the nuclei, we can infer that the equilibrium condition (3.19) guarrantees stability against sponatneous fission by a large margin. However, this is true only at low densities: we shall see later how drastically this may change at sufficiently high densities. Consider now the second step, which, in a similar vein, is really an optimization with respect to the weak interaction process, which conserves the total baryon number but changes the proton/neutron ratio. Specifically, the minimization with respect to Z is the condition of stability against both β-decay and inverse β-decay: the former raises Z while the latter lowers it, and this condition ensures that it would cost energy to do either. Note that, since changes in Z change the number of electrons, the electronicenergy term in Eq. (3.17) plays an essential role in the optimization process
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
pranab
Rotation and Accretion Powered Pulsars
108
now. Operationally, in order to minimize utot with respect to xp , we first substitute the value of A from Eq. (3.18) into Eq. (3.17), which turns the sum of the surface- and Coulomb-energy terms in the latter equation into 2/3 the form (3/2)(2Eσ2 Ec )1/3 xp , and then differentiate with respect to xp . The resulting relation, , Ee = (mn − mp )c2 + 4Es (1 − 2xp ) − (2Eσ2 Ec )1/3 x−1/3 p
(3.21)
is really a statement of thermodynamic equilibrium, i.e., a condition of balance between the chemical potentials of electrons, protons, and neutrons: µe + µp = µn .
(3.22)
These chemical potentials, or Fermi energies, are calculated from the standard definition µi ≡ ∂utot /∂ni (where i = e, p, n), and include the restmass energy of the respective particle in the convention adopted henceforth. Physically, Eq. (3.22) means that, exactly at the equilibrium point, it costs no energy to convert an electron and a proton into a neutron, or vice versa. (The neutrinos that are emitted in these electron-capture and neutrondecay processes are assumed to leave with essentially zero energy, and so do not enter explicitly into the equilibrium condition.) We leave it as an exercise for the reader to explicitly calculate the chemical potentials from Eqs. (3.17) and (3.16) with the aid of the definition given above4, and show that these are given by: µe = Ee ,
(3.23)
1 µn = mn c2 − Eb + Es (1 − 4x2p ) + (2Eσ2 Ec )1/3 x2/3 p , 2 µp = mp c2 − Eb − Es (1 − 2xp )(3 − 2xp ) + 1 1 + (2Eσ2 Ec )1/3 x2/3 . p 2 xp
(3.24)
(3.25)
It can then be seen that Eqs. (3.21) and (3.22) are entirely equivalent. An immediate consequence of the above chemical-potential balance condition is that the proton fraction xp decreases, and so the nuclei become increasingly neutron-rich, as the density of matter rises. This is easily seen by noting first that the chemical potential of the electrons: µe = (3π 2 ne )1/3 c ∝ ρ1/3 ,
(3.26)
4 Note that u tot in Eq. (3.17) must be expressed entirely in terms of nn , np , and ne (using xp = np /nb and nb = nn + np ) before taking the partial derivatives.
January 10, 2007
16:24
WSPC/Book Trim Size for 9in x 6in
Physics of Dense Matter-1
pranab
109
increases with increasing density for the relativistic electrons considered here, and then that an increasing Ee = µe in Eq. (3.21) implies a decreasing xp . The second point becomes clear when we recognize that the variation of the right-hand side of Eq. (3.21) is controlled by the symmetry-energy term for all values of the proton fraction xp of practical interest, and this term obviously increases with decreasing xp . This happens because, among the coefficients of symmetry, surface, and Coulomb enrgies, i.e., Es , Eσ , Ec , the first is the largest, typical values being Es ≈ 24 MeV, Eσ ≈ 17 MeV, and Ec ≈ 0.7 MeV [Bohr and Mottelson 1969]. These numbers readily show that the coefficient of the second term on the right-hand side of Eq. (3.21) is 4Es ≈ 96 MeV, larger by far than that of the third term (2Eσ2 Ec )1/3 ≈ 7.4 MeV5 . Physically, this means that, as the electron chemical potential rises with rising density and the weak-interaction equibrium condition (Eq. [3.21]) requires that the neutron-proton chemical potential difference rise in step with it, the way this occurs is by increasing the asymmetry between the neutron and proton numbers (i.e., moving away from the symmetric situation xp ≈ 1/2 which obtains for the very stable nuclei at low densities): a dropping proton fraction raises the neutron chemical potential and lowers the proton chemical potential (see Eqs. [3.25] and [3.25]), thus raising the difference between them. This decreasing proton fraction with rising density leads to another immediate conclusion from Eq. (3.18), namely that the mass number A of the equilibrium nuclide increases as the density increases, i.e., the nuclei get progressively heavier, larger, and richer in neutrons. This is as expected physically, since a decreasing proton fraction means a smaller (repulsive) proton-proton Coulomb force per nucleus, which shifts the balance in favor of the (attractive) nuclear forces, leading to a larger number of nucleons per nucleus. The numerical estimate obtained from Eq. (3.18) with the aid of the above numerical values of Eσ and Ec , A≈
12 , x2p
(3.27)
is very instructive [Pethick and Ravenhall 1995]. Consider first terrestrial laboratory conditions, under which stable nuclei have xp ≈ 1/2 (roughly equal number of protons and neutrons):