RILEM_Connections_between_Steel_COncrete_Stutgart_2001
0_Preface by R. Eligehausen 1_Where structural steel and concre...
401 downloads
2795 Views
31MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
RILEM_Connections_between_Steel_COncrete_Stutgart_2001
0_Preface by R. Eligehausen 1_Where structural steel and concrete meet by J.W.B. Stark, D.A. Hordijk 10_Study on standard test methods for post-installed anchors by Y. Hosokawa, K. Nakano, Y. Oohaga, S. Usami, K. Imai 100_Experimental investigations on the bahaviour of strip shear connectors with powder actuated fasteners by M. Fontana, H. Beck, R. Bärtschi 101_Design concept of nailed shear connections in composite tube columns by G. Hanswille, H. Beck, T. Neubauer 102_An experimental study on shear characteristics of perfobond strip and its rational strength equations by U. Yoshitaka, H. Tetsuya, M. Kaoru 103_Behavior of lying shear studs in reinforced concrete slabs by U. Kuhlmann, K. Kürschner 104_Composite bridge with compression joint connection concrete end slab to steel girder finite element method by M.V. Lammens 105_Perfo-bond connection and tests by S. Poot 106_Development and application of saw-tooth connections for composite structures by J. Schlaich 107_Geometry, behaviour and design of high capacity saw-tooth connections by V. Schmid 108_Composite bridge with compression joint - Connection concrete end slab to steel girder - Dowels divided in groups by D. Tuinstra 109_TH~1 11_Static behavior of anchors under combinations of tension and shear loading by D. Lotze, R.E. Klingner, H.L. Graves, III 110_Influence of fatigue loads in tension on short cast-in-place anchors in concrete by E. Cadoni 111_A test proposal for fatigue experimental studies on stud shear connectors by G. Natalino, E. Giuriani 112_Innovative interface systems for steel-girders-concrete-deck connection by M.K. Tadros S.S. Badie, A.M. Girgis 113_Non-linear analyssis of steel-concrete composite beams a finite element model by C. Faella E. Martinelli E. Nigro 114_Connections between prestressed concrete bridge decks and composite bridge decks - Hybrid construction by D. Jankowski, O. Fischer, M. Matthes 115_Anchorage behavior of 90-degree hooked beam bars in reinforced concrete wall-beam intersections by O. Joh, Y. Goto, A. Kitano 116_Embedded steel bearings instead of concrete NIBS by M.R. Kintscher 117_Anchorage zone in a steel-concrete composite slab with unbonded tendons by H. Koukkari 118_Connections for continuous framing in precast concrete structures by G. Krummel 119_Standoff screws as shear connectors for composite trusses push-out test results and analysis by J.R.U. Mujagic W.S. Easterling T.M. Murray 12_Improved structural model for channel bars with more than 2 anchors by J. Kraus, J. Ozbolt, R. Eligehausen 120_EX~1 122_Design and construction of a concrete-filled steel tube joint by S.P. Schneider, D.R. Kramer, D.L. Sarkkinen 123_Friction slipping behavior between concrete and steel - Aiming the development of bolted friction-slipping joint by T. Yoshioka, M. Ohkubo 124_AN~1 125_Low-cycle fatigue behaviour of pull-push specimens with headed stud shear connectors by S. Erlicher, O.S. Bursi, R. Zandonini 126_Static tests on various types of shear connectors for composite structures by H.C. Galjaard, J.C. Walraven 127_Structural monitoring of hybrid specimens at early age using fibre optic sensors by B. Glisic, D. Inaudi 128_Development of innovative composite system- Between steel and concrete members by K. Kitagawa, H. Watanabe, Y. Tachibana, H. Hiragi, A. Kurita 129_An experimental study on the bond-slip relationship between the concrete and steel with stud by K. Konno, A. Farghaly, T. Ueda 13_Anchors in low and high strength concrete by J. Kunz, Y. Yamamoto, M. Berra 130_The behavior of beam-to-box column connection of CFT with air cavity by M.-J. Lee, M.-S. Choi, J.-H. Kim, S.-W. Jun 131_Sheet reinforcement by O. Matthaei, H.-P. Andrä, N.V. Tue 132_Composite girders of reduced height by U. Khulmann, J. Fries, A. Rieg 133_Innovative development of light steel composites in buildings by R.M. Lawson, S.O. Popo-Ola, D.N. Varley 134_Intentional and unintentional shear connections in shallow floor composite structures by M.V. Leskelä 14_Development of common uniform regulations in Europe for the assessment of metal anchors by K. Laternser 15_Behavior of multiple-anchor fastenings subjected to combined tension_shear loads and bending moment by L. Li, R. Eligehausen 16_Load bearing capacity of torque-controlled expansion anchors by L. Li 17_Behaviour and design of anchors close to an edge under torsion by R. Mallée 18_Fixing new anchors concerning relevant base plate thickness by R. Mallée, F. Burkhardt 19_Installation verification of mechanical and adhesive anchors by L. Mattis 2_Fastening technique - Current status and future trends by R. Eligehausen, I. Hofacker, S. Lettow 20_Steel capacity of headed studs loaded in shear by N.S. Anderson, D.F. Meinheit
21_The analysis of fastener strength using the limit state approach by J.J. Melcher, M. Karmazínová 22_Behavior of shear anchors in concrete stastical analysis and design recommendations by H. Muratli, R.E. Klingner, H.L. Graves, III 23_Study on shear transfer of joint steel bar and concrete shear key in concrete connections by K. Nakano, Y. Matsuzaki 24_Performance of undercut anchors in comparison to cast-in-place headed studs by P. Pusill-Wachtsmuth 25_Shear anchoring in concrete close to edge by N. Randl, M. John 26_Behavior of tensile anchors in concrete statistical analysis and design recommendations by M. Shirvani, R.E. Klingner, H.L. Graves, III 27_Performance of single anchors near an edge under varying angles of loading by R.E. Wollmershauser, U. Nestler, V. Smith 28_The prequalification of anchors in the united states of america past, present and future by R.E. Wollmershauser 29_On the ratio of plate thickness to stud diameters for steel concrete stud shear connectors by H.D. Wright, A. Elbadawy, R. Cairns 3_Anchoring to concrete_the new ACI approach by J.E. Breen, E.-M. Eichinger, W. Fuchs 30_INC~1 31_Corrosion behavior of materials in fixing applications by N. Arnold 32_Behaviour of post-installed anchors in case of fire by K. Bergmeister, A. Rieder 33_Durability of galvanized, post-installed fasteners to concrete by K. Menzel, B. Hagmayer 34_Durability of stainless steel connections with respect to corrosion by U. Nürnberger 35_Fibre resistance of steel anchors in concrete by M. Reick 36_Anchoring with bonded fasteners by R.A. Cook, R.C. Konz 37_Experimental study on performance of bonded anchors in the low strength reinforced concrete by T. Akiyama, Y. Yamamoto, S. Ichihashi, T. Katagiri 38_Behavior of grouted anchors by R.A. Cook, N.A. Zamora, R.C. Konz 39_Long time load-carrying capacity of bonded anchors by L. Elfgren, G. Danielsson, I. Holm, G. Söderlind 4_Evolution of fastening design methods in Europe by W. Fuchs 40_Transmission of shear loads with post-installed rebars by J. Kunz 41_Design of anchorages with bonded anchors tension load by B. Lehr, R. Eligehausen 42_Load bearing bahavior and design of single adhesive anchors by J. Meszaros, R. Eligehausen 43_Rebar anchorage in concrete with injections adhesive by M. Reuter, T. Greppmeir, F. Münger 44_Investigations on bonding behaviour of the reinforcements in historic masonry by M. Raupach, J. Brockmann, A. Domink, M. Schürholz 45_Actual trends in chemical fixings from capsule to injection systems by J. Schätzle 46_PER~1 47_Study on the performance evaluation of the new capsule typed bonded anchor by M. Yonetani, A. Fukuoka, Y. Matsuzaki 48_Seismic behavior of connections between steel and concrete by J.O. Jirsa 49_Test on connectors for seismic retrofitting of concrete and masonry structures in Mexico by S.M. Alcocer, L. Flores 5_Probabilistic calibration of design methods by W. Fuchs 50_Design and construction of heavy industrial anchorage for power-plants by P.J. Carrato, W.F. Brittle 51_Dynamic behavior of single and double near-edge anchors loaded in shear by J.H. Gross, R.E. Klingner, H.L. Graves, III 52_Post-installed rebar connections under seismic loading by I. Hofacker, R. Eligehausen 53_An evaluation of tensile capacity of anchor system in NPPS by actual model tests by J. Jung-Bum, W. Sang-Kyun, S. Yong-Pyo, L. Jong-Rim 54_Structural behavior of SRC column - RC beam joint under monotonic and cyclic load by S.-H. Lee, Y.-K. Ju, S.-C. Chun, D.-Y. Kim 55_Dynamic behavior of tensile anchors to concrete by M. Rodriguez, D. Lotze, J. Hallowell Gross, Y.-G. Zhang, R.E. Klingner, H.L. Graves, III 56_Test methods for seismic qualification of post-installed anchors by J.F. Silva 57_Safety concept for fastenings in nuclear power plants by T.M. Sippel, J. Asmus, R. Eligehausen 58_Experimental study on seismic performance of beam members connected with post-installed anchors by R. Tanaka, K. Oba 59_Shallow shear anchor bolts for structural seismic strengthening of columns with wing wall by Y. Yamamoto, Y. Hattori, T. Koh, M. Kato 6_Current status of post-installed anchor application in Japan by R. Tanaka 60_Seismic response of multiple-anchor connections to concrete by Z. Yong-gang, R.E. Klingner, H.L. Graves, III 61_Smeared fracture Finite Element (FE) - Analysis of reinforced concrete structures - Theory and examples by J. Ozblot_ 62_Numerical and experimental investigations of the splitting failure mode of fastenings by J. Asmus, J. Ozbolt 63_Three dimensional modeling of an anchorage to concrete using metal anchor bolts by H. Boussa, G. Mounajed, B. Mesureur, J.-V. Heck 64_Influence of bending compressive stresses on the concrete cone capacity by M. Bruckner, R. Eligehausen, J. Ozbolt 65_ATENA - An advanced tool for engineering analysis of connections by V. Cervenka, J. Cervenka, R. Pukl 66_A computational model for double-head studs by A. Haufe, E. Ramm 67_Behavior and design of fastenings with headed anchors at the edge under arbitrary loading direction by J. Hoffmann, J. Ozbolt, R. Eligehausen 68_Evaluation of a bridge deck strengthening with shear connectors finite element analysis and experimental results by A.J. Leite 69_Numerical analysis of group effect in bonded anchors with different bond strengths by Y.-J. Li, R. Eligehausen
7_Design method for splitting failure mode of fastenings by J. Asmus, R. Eligehausen 70_Simulation of fastening systems utilizing chemical and mechanical anchors by J. Nienstedt, R. Mattner, U. Nestler, C. Song 71_Headed stud anchor - Cyclic loading and creep-cracking interaction of concrete by J. Ozbolt, J. Hofmann, R. Eligehausen 72_Numerical investigations of headed studs with inclined shoulder by P. Pivonka, R. Lackner, H.A. Mang 73_Simulating investigations of headed studs with inclined shoulder by R. Pukl, J. Cervenka, V. Cervenka 74_Non-supported crash barriers - Proof of the concrete resistances according to the concrete-capacity-method by J. Buhler 75_Reconstruction of multi-layer-walls by E. Dereser, J. Buhler 76_Load carrying capacity of fasteners in concrete railay sleepers by H. Thun, S. Utsi, L. Elfgren, P. Nilsson, B. Paulsson 77_Anchorage with headed bars with exterior beam-column joints by J. Hegger, W. Roeser 78_Halfen HDB-S bars as shear reinforcement in slabs and beams by J. Hegger, K. Fröhlich, R. Beutel, W. Roeser 79_Behaviour of fasteners in concrete with coarse recycled concrete and masonry aggregates by D.A. Hordijk, R. van der pluijm 8_Behaviour and design of fastenings of shear lugs in concrete by H. Michler, M. Curbach 80_Regarding strength of anchor bolts used for PCa Curtain wall fasteners by H. Kawamura, T. Otobe, S. Oka 81_New method of reconstruction - Strengthening of old buildings by M. Marjanishvili, T. Zuzadze, D. Ramishvili, A. Lebanidze 82_Fastening in masonry by A. Meyer, T. Pregartner 83_Study on design method of joint panels for hybrid railway rigid-frame bridges by H. Nishida, K. Murata, T. Takayama 84_Tension stiffening model based on bond by M.A. Polak, K. Blackwell 85_OVE~1 86_Redundant structures fixed with concrete fasteners by M. Rößle, R. Eligehausen 87_Numerical and experimental analysis of post-installed rebars spliced with cast-in-place rebars by H.A. Spieth, J. Ozbolt, R. Eligehausen, J. Appl 88_Dowel action of titanium bars connecting marble elements by E. Vintzileou, K. Papadopoulos 89_Case study - Application of high strength post-tensioned rods for anchoring aerial tram structures to rock by G.P. Wheatley 9_Safety relevant aspects for torque controlled expansion anchors by H. Gassner, E. Wisser 90_Behaviour and design of fastenings with concrete screws by J.H.R. Küenzlen, T.M. Sippel 91_Behaviour and design of anchors for lifting and handling in precast concrete elements by D. Lotze 92_Behaviour of plastic anchors in cracked and uncracked concrete by T. Pregartner, R. Eligehausen 93_TES~1 94_A new step forward for composite bridges - The Bras de la Plaine Bridge by E. Barlet, G. Causse, J.-P. Viallon 95_Anchorage of the steel elements to the concrete piers at the specific pipe bridges over a Danube-bay in Budapest by B. Csiki 96_BEH~1 97_Recent developments and chances of composite structures by U. Kuhlmann 98_Design of lying studs with longitudinal shear force by U. Breuninger 99_STU~1
Preface Anchorage by fasteners and composite structures of steel and concrete have seen dramatic progress in research, technology and application over the past decade. The understanding of the fundamental principles underlying both disciplines has significantly improved. Concurrently, there has been rapid growth in the development of sophisticated new products and the establishment of international directives and codes to ensure their safe and economical use in a wide range of engineered structures.
Although they deal with very similar problems, the two disciplines have developed independently from each other. To optimize the use of composite structures and fastenings to concrete, however, it is necessary to have knowledge of both: the local behavior of the fastening system and the global behavior of the structure. It became apparent that a forum offering the opportunity to expand and to exchange experience in the field of connecting steel and concrete would benefit all involved. Furthermore this forum would aid in the rapid dissemination of new ideas, technologies and solutions as well as explore new areas of research.
To meet these objectives the first symposium on 'Connections between Steel and Concrete' was conducted in Stuttgart, Germany from September 9 to 12, 2001 organized under the auspices of RILEM, the International Union of Testing and Research Laboratories for Materials and Structures and the University of Stuttgart. The event was cosponsored by the American Concrete Institute (ACI), the International Federation for Structural Concrete (fib) and the International Association for Bridge and Structural Engineering (IABSE). Experts from all facets of the research, design, construction and anchor manufacturing community from around the world were invited to present papers covering the topics of testing, behavior and design, durability, exceptional applications, strengthening and structures as well as related topics such as anchorage to masonry.
Regrettably, due to the limitation on the number of papers, dictated by the time frame of the symposium, not all worthy papers proposed for presentation could be accepted. 134 authors were invited by the scientific committee to address the topic of connections between steel and concrete at the symposium. Their papers are gathered in this volume. I hope this volume will significantly contribute to knowledge in the field of connecting steel and concrete, related design methods, code specifications and new applications.
I wish to thank the authors for their excellent contributions and the scientific committee for the useful technical advice. I would like to express particular thanks to Mr. Stefan Fichtner and Werner Fuchs for their essential assistance in the local organization of the symposium and the preparation of the present volume.
Rolf Eligehausen Stuttgart, September 2001
WHERE STRUCTURAL STEEL AND CONCRETE MEET J.W.B. Stark*, D.A. Hordijk** *Delft University of Technology CiTG, The Netherlands **Adviesbureau ir. J.G. Hageman B.V., The Netherlands
Abstract Traditionally "steel structures" and "concrete structures" formed more or less two different worlds in structural engineering. However, fortunately this situation is changing rapidly. It is now recognised that each of the two materials have advantages and disadvantages and that often an optimal solution is found by combining both materials in for example a "Composite steel-concrete construction" or a "Mixed construction". It is important that the design rules for the two materials are consistent, especially for those components connecting both materials. However, in the past the design standards and recommendations for concrete and steel have been developed separately. So evidently at this moment there are still considerable differences in design assumptions and treatment of various aspects. During drafting of the Eurocodes and the conversion of the ENV's into EN's these inconsistencies became apparent. As the Eurocodes, additional to level national differences, also aim at harmonisation over the materials, it is now urgent to trace inconsistencies and find solutions for improvement. In this paper situations in modern buildings are described where steel and concrete meet. On the basis of an overview of the historic situation in education and practice, differences in approaches for concrete and steel design can be explained. Then for some aspects of steel-concrete-connections the present approaches will be discussed and compared with emphasis on inconsistencies, gaps and possibilities for harmonisation of design rules.
1. Introduction In the past for the design of a building the choice was normally between a concrete structure or a steel structure. Looking at recent practice in Europe there is an evident tendency that designers also consider the combined use of concrete and steel in the form of composite or mixed structures as a serious alternative. Use of composite elements in
1
the form of beams, columns and composite slabs is already common practice in many countries (see Figure 1). Composite slab
Composite beam Composite column
Fig. 1: Composite elements Applications are supported by accepted National Standards or Recommendations, including rules for the design and verification of the connection between the concrete and steel parts. These National Standards will be replaced by a Harmonised European Standard: EN 1994 - Eurocode 4 [1], now being in a final stage of completion. However, this supporting material is not available for mixed constructions where (reinforced or prestressed) concrete elements and structural steel elements are used in combination. The elements itself are covered by the respective design standards for concrete and steel. But in many cases the joints where the elements meet form a black spot as far as Design Standards and information is concerned. So the designer has to develop design models based on a creative interpretation of methods and rules in use for concrete and steel. It is of course a complication when these design methods for the different materials are not consistent. In the past the Design Standards and Recommendations for concrete and steel have been developed separately. So evidently at this moment there are still considerable differences in design assumptions and treatment of various aspects. Some examples of these differences will be illustrated in this paper. That this situation exists is understandable from the historic perspective where separation existed for education and design practice between concrete and steel. At Universities students were (are) separately educated by professors specialised in concrete or steel. Each had (have) separate academic chairs and departments. Also in practice often difference is made between concrete designers and steel designers rather than structural engineers. This is also caused by the fact that for concrete most often the complete design is made by the design consultant while for steel the task of the design consultant is limited to the overall structural design. Detailing for steel structures, inclusive connection design, is often carried out by the fabricator or a specialised design office. Also professional organisations act separately. In Germany, for example, “Betonverein” and “DAST” and on an international level CEB and FIP (now merged to fib) and ECCS act respectively for the concrete and the steel society. Incidentally there are examples of co-operation between these organisations as for example in the “Joint
2
Committee on Structural Safety” and the “Joint Committee for Composite Structures”. It would be useful to form a similar Joint Co-operation for connections between concrete and steel (and possibly other materials).
2. Typology Many different details exist depending on the type of members to be connected, the actions to be transferred and the performance requirements. An exhaustive treatment of all possible details is not possible in the context of this paper. Just to give an idea an arbitrary selection is made. 2.1 Column bases This is one of the most commonly used details. The steel column is connected to a base plate, which is attached to the concrete foundation by some form of so-called “holding down” assembly. A typical detail is shown in Figure 2. The system of column, base plate and holding down assembly is known as a column base. The holding down assembly comprises two, but more commonly four (or more) holding down bolts (anchors). These may be cast-in-place, or post-installed to the completed foundation. Cast-in-place bolts sometimes have some form of tubular or conical sleeve, so that the top of the bolts are free to move laterally, to allow the base plate to be accurately located.
base plate
anchor grout
Fig. 2: Typical detail of a column base
Base plates for cast-in assemblies are usually provided with oversized holes and thick washer plates to permit translation of the column base. Anchor plates or similar embedded arrangements can be attached to the embedded end of the anchor assembly to resist pull-out. Post-installed anchors may be used, being positioned accurately in the hardened concrete. Post-installed assemblies include, for instance, torque-controlled expansion anchors, under-cut anchors and bonded anchors (see also [2]).
3
2.2 Connections of steel beams to concrete walls or columns A stiff concrete core often provides the stability of a multi-storey steel frame. The steel beams of the floors are connected to the wall of the concrete core (see Figure 3a). To provide sufficient fire resistance sometimes (prefabricated) concrete columns are used instead of steel columns with fire protection. In Figure 3b a connection is shown as used in a refurbishment project where new steel floor beams are connected to existing concrete columns by means of an extended end plate connection.
concrete core
anchor
a
b
Fig. 3 Connection composite beam-concrete core (a) ; steel beam-concrete column (b). A great number of different forms of connection details are possible for these types of connection. The choice of the most appropriate solution is dependent of the following aspects of consideration: • Sequence of construction • Method of fabrication of the core or column. • Tolerances of both concrete and steel • Type of action effects (shear, tension or compression, moment) • Static or variable loading • Reversal of loading • Support conditions (degrees of freedom) • Required static properties (resistance, stiffness and deformation capacity) • Behaviour under elevated temperature caused by fire 2.3 Outrigger in a high rise building In some structures taylor-made solutions have to be invented by the designer. As an example in Figure 4 an outrigger structure in a high rise building is shown. The steel outrigger had to be connected to a concrete core and to a composite column.
4
Outrigger
Composite column
Concrete core
Fig. 4: Outrigger in a high rise building
3 Standards and Recommendations The European Standards Organisation (CEN) has planned to develop a complete set of Harmonized European Building Standards. This set includes Standards for concrete, steel and composite steel-concrete buildings and bridges. The Eurocodes, being the Design Standards, form part of this total system of European Standards, together with Standards for fabrication and erection and Product Standards. After a period of experimental use of the ENV(European Pre Standard)-versions of the Eurocodes, a start has been made with the conversion to EN’s (European Standards). At the time of the conference, draft prEN versions of the relevant parts covering – "General Rules and Rules for Buildings" will have been completed [1,3,4]. The Eurocode-programme is aiming at a two dimensional harmonization: 1) Harmonization across the borders of the European Countries; 2) Harmonization between different construction materials, construction methods, types of building and civil engineering works to achieve full consistency and compatibility of the various Codes with each other and to obtain comparable safety levels. Especially the 2nd item is relevant for the topic of this paper. The designer of a “mixed structure” is concerned with the Eurocodes listed in Table 1. A check of the present drafts shows that he will find not many detailed rules specific for the design of joints between concrete and steel elements. Table 1: Eurocodes relevant to “mixed” structures Standard Subject Material General EN 1990 Basis of Design “ EN 1991-1 Actions on structures Concrete EN 1992-1-1 Concrete - General & Buildings Steel EN 1993-1-1 Steel - Common rules “ EN 1993-1-8 Steel – Design of joints “ EN 1993-3 Steel – Buildings Composite EN 1994-1-1 Composite steel & concrete – General & buildings
5
•
•
•
prEN 1992-1-1 (Eurocode 2 – 2nd Draft Jan. 2001) [3] In Eurocode 2 no specific section for the design of connections is included. This situation will change since recently within CEN/TC250/SC2 a new Working Group ‘Design of fastenings’ started their activities. prEN 1993-1-8 (Eurocode 3 – 2nd Draft Dec. 2000) [4] Eurocode 3 has a separate part for the design of steel joints. The present draft contains design rules for fasteners (bolts, rivets and welds) but also principles and application rules for the design of joints. The principles are so general that they apply globally to ”mixed” joints as well. For example clause 2.5 states: “2.5 Design assumptions (1)P Joints shall be designed by distributing the internal forces and moments to fulfill the following criteria: (a) the assumed internal forces and moments are in equilibrium with the applied forces and moments; (b) each element in the joint is capable of resisting the forces or stresses assumed in the analysis; (c) the deformations implied by this distribution are within the deformation capacity of the fasteners or welds and of the connected parts, and (d) the deformations assumed in any design model based on yield lines are based on rigid body rotations (and in-plane deformations) which are physically possible. (2)P In addition, the assumed distribution of internal forces shall be realistic with regard to relative stiffnesses within the joint.” The design method for joints in EN1993-1-8 is based on the so-called “component method”. The advantage being that the rules for “all steel” joints can easily be extended to ”mixed” joints. Detailed rules are given for the application of the component method for typical steel joints but also for column bases. prEN 1994-1-1 (Eurocode 4 – 3rd Draft April 2001) [1] Composite joints in frames for buildings are covered in Section 8 (and Annex A) of prEN1994-1-1. This Section is consistent with prEN 1993-1-8. A great advantage is that the design method in EN1993-1-8 is based on the component method so only rules for properties of specific composite components had to be given in EN19941-1. The proposed EN provisions therefore deal only with what is peculiar to composite joints. It is assumed that the user of EN1994 will be familiar with EN 1993-1-8. Design moment resistance and rotational stiffness are each to be “determined in a manner analogous to that for steel joints”. No attempt is made to present detailed modifications to the provisions of the Steel Code.
So far Design Standards as covered by the Eurocodes. Other groups also produce design guidance. A CEB Task Group (since the merging of CEB and FIP in 1998 now a fib Group) prepared a Design Guide for fastenings in concrete [5]. It only covers the load transfer into the concrete. For the design of the fixture (f.e. a base plate) the designer is referred
6
to “the appropriate code of practice”. In [5] so far only rules for cast-in-place headed anchors and post-installed expansion and undercut anchors are given. Work is in progress for other types of anchor, like bonded anchors and channel bars. Many types of anchor are special products. The determination of the characteristic properties is not covered in the Eurocodes. They either refer to Harmonized Product Standards or ETA‘s (European Technical Approvals). For ETA‘s, guidelines (ETAG’s) are being produced by the European Organisation for Technical Approvals (EOTA). In the ETAG for “Metal anchors for use in concrete” [6] a Design Guide is given in an Annex. The motivation for including design rules was the fact that there is a relation between the anchor properties and the design and that a Design Guide was not yet provided by CEN. With the new Working Group of CEN/TC250/SC2, as mentioned before, this situation will change. The elastic design approach in the ETAG Design Guide [6] is similar to the CEB guideline [5]. However the CEB document is more comprehensive than the ETAG design guideline, since also a plastic design approach is included, while cast-in-place anchors are also covered. As a result of a joint project of ECCS/TWG10.2 “Semi-rigid connections” and COST/C1/WG2 a publication [7] was issued. This publication gives details of a design method for column bases. It covers the calculation of characteristic values for the resistance and rotational stiffness. An evaluation of the CEB Design Guide model is included.
3. Comparison of some fastener aspects in different Codes 3.1 General As mentioned before, in Eurocode 2 connections are not treated. Therefore, for some aspects the rules in Eurocode 3 are compared with the CEB/EOTA Design Guidelines. In Section 3.2 rules for the resistance of the steel part of a single anchor fastening are compared. In Section 3.3 some aspects related to a base plate connection are discussed. 3.2 Anchor strength In table 2 resistances for the steel part of a single anchor according EC3 and EOTA/CEB are compared. Values are given for the design tension resistance Ft.Rd (NRd.s) and the design shear resistance Fv.Rd (VRd.s). For some cases there are significant differences. The design shear strength according to EC 3 is always greater than that according to CEB and EOTA. It should be noted that in case of shear there is a difference between a bolt connecting two steel parts and an anchor connecting a steel component to concrete. The design resistance to combined tension and shear load is according CEB [5] and EOTA [6] to be determined with the following interaction equation:
N N Sd VSd + ≤ 1,2 but Sd ≤ 1 and N Rd VRd N Rd
VSd ≤1 VRd
(1)
It is noted that this yields conservative results for steel failure and that when NRd and VRd are governed by steel failure more accurate results are obtained by:
7
2
2
N Sd VSd + ≤ 1 N Rd VRd
(2)
For bolts subjected to combined tension and shear Eurocode 3 [4] gives the following interaction equation :
Fv.Sd Ft .Sd + ≤ 1,0 but Fv.Rd 1,4 ⋅ Ft .Rd
Ft .Sd ≤1 Ft .Rd
(3)
The resistance functions in Eurocode 3 have been developed by statistical evaluation of a international collection of test results evaluated in accordance with the procedure given in Annex D of prEN1990 : “Basis of Design” Table 2 Comparison of the design resistance of the steel part of a single anchor according to Eurocode 3 [4] and the CEB/EOTA [4,5] Design Guidelines. tension ‘Code’ ‘original equation’ 4.6 5.8 8.8 10.9 EC 3 Ft.Rd = 0,9⋅fub⋅As / γMb = 0,72⋅As⋅fuk 288⋅As 360⋅As 576⋅As 720⋅As CEB/EOTA NRd,s= As⋅fyk / γMs = 0,83⋅As⋅fyk 200⋅As 333⋅As 533⋅As 750⋅As Note: fyk = characteristic steel yield strength (nominal value) fuk = characteristic steel ultimate tensile strength (nominal value) The ‘original equation’ differs between CEB and EOTA, but the result is, except for 10.9 anchors, equal; CEB result is shown. shear ‘Code’ ‘original equation’ 4.6 5.8 8.8 10.9 EC 3 384⋅As Fv.Rd= 0,6⋅fub⋅As / γMb = 0,48⋅As⋅fuk 192⋅As 200⋅As 400⋅As Fv.Rd= 0,5⋅fub⋅As / γMb = 0,40⋅As⋅fuk CEB/EOTA VRd,s= 0,6⋅As⋅fyk / γMs = 0,5⋅As⋅fyk 120⋅As 150⋅As 320⋅As 360⋅As Note: CEB/EOTA: for 10.9 anchors γMs=1,5 instead of 1,2 for lower classes. In the CEB and EOTA Design Guidelines steel failure under a shear load with a lever arm (causing combined shear and bending stresses in the anchor) is treated separately. This is not covered by Eurocode 3. 3.4 Base plate connection Probably the most common connection between concrete and steel is the base plate connection of a column (see Figure 2). Quite a lot of steel research into the structural behaviour was carried out in the past. These research activities mainly focussed on the strength and stiffness of the steel base plate, while for the behaviour of concrete under concentrated loads use was made of knowledge provided by the‘concrete-colleagues’. For tensile loading “holding down bolts” have to be used, as they are named in the
8
normative Annex L of Eurocode 3 [4]. For the anchorage of these bolts reference is made to Eurocode 2. This means that the anchorage should be such that steel yielding governs anchorage failure. One could speak of an anchorage according to the reinforced concrete technique. With the fastener technique relative shorter anchorages with other governing failures modes (break out of concrete cone, pull-out and concrete splitting), are introduced. The length of short anchors is normally about 10 times their diameter, while for anchorages of reinforcing steel according to the concrete codes lengths of 20d to 30d, depending on cover and concrete strength, are required. Now two items from the CEB Design Guide will be discussed more in detail. These items were selected because the authors expect that a combined effort of experts from the steel and fastener groups shall lead to improvement of the design rules . Base plate stiffness and load distribution over the anchors. In the CEB Design Guide [4] distinction is made between an elastic design approach and a plastic design approach. The plastic approach is only acceptable when the anchor has sufficient deformation capacity. For short anchors with a high steel strength this is often not the case. Furthermore, in many situations the resistance of the concrete is reduced by edge effects of the concrete element. This may also cause that the requirement for the plastic approach is not fulfilled. For an elastic approach it is required that the fixture does not deform under the design actions. It may be assumed that this is valid when the base plate is rigid and in full contact with the concrete or with a layer of mortar. Furthermore, the base plate may be assumed to be rigid when the maximum steel stress under the design actions does not exceed fyk/γMs with γMs = 1,1. It is expected that in practice this requirement will sometimes not be fulfilled and/or even not checked in many cases. The guidance in [5] on this aspect is rather limited, which can be understood since the document mainly deals with the load transfer into the concrete. According the CEB Design Guide the use of flexible end plates is permitted, provided that the non-linear load distribution over the anchors and the associated prying forces are taken into account. Shear strength and contribution of friction According the CEB Design Guide for base plates with a grout layer thicker than 3 mm plastic design is not allowed, friction forces underneath the base plate should be neglected and the shear capacity has to be calculated for the mechanism ‘shear load with lever arm’. For column bases usually a grout layer with a thickness greater than 3 mm is used. Though it is realised that there may be uncertainties about the strength and quality of the grout layer, the CEB method will be very conservative in many practical cases. This was confirmed by COST/WG2 [7] that compared design values with test results for column bases loaded in shear and with a varying thickness of the grout layer [8]. In particular in case of low strength bolts and a thick grout layer (60 mm) the experimentally obtained maximum shear load was many times (between 10 and 25 !!) greater than the calculated characteristic shear strength of the connection.
9
5. Concluding remarks In daily practice the two main structural materials concrete and steel are often used in combination. When steel is fully incorporated in the concrete, as is the case with reinforcement the interaction between these two materials is treated properly. This also applies to composite elements. However, when concrete and steel elements are used in combination in a mixed structure the designer is not supported with sufficient design guidance. Significant improvement can still be achieved as far as Codes, engineering practice and education is concerned. Though things are changing rapidly in a positive direction, to some extent there are still two separate “worlds”. As far as the joint is concerned, both “worlds” tackle the aspects related to their one material in detail and look a little bit over the border to the other world. Since at the joint the interaction between the two worlds play an essential role, it is of prime importance that the treatment on both sides of the border is consistent. This is not the case yet. As a result of the “two-world-situation” inconsistencies in Codes still exist and properties of connections may not be fully utilised. Some examples have been given. The authors of this paper, one with a steel and the other with a concrete background, are of the opinion that with joint co-operation for several aspects of steel-concrete connections improvement can be achieved. In that respect, this symposium is a perfect initiative and may be a bases for new combined activities.
6. References 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6.
7. 8.
prEN 1994-1-1, ‘Eurocode 4: Design of composite steel and concrete structures – Part 1: General rules and rules for buildings’, CEN, 3rd Draft, April 2001. CEB ’Fastenings to concrete and masonry structures – State-of-the-art’ CEBbulletin no. 216, Thomas Telford, July 1994. prEN 1992-1, ‘Eurocode 2: Design of concrete structures – Part 1: General rules and rules for buildings’, CEN, 2nd draft, January 2001. ENV 1993-1-1: 1992, ‘Eurocode 3: Design of steel structures – Part 1-1: General rules and rules for buildings’, CEN, April 1992. CEB, ‘Design of Fastenings in Concrete. CEB Guide - Part 1 to 3’ CEB-bulletin no. 233, Thomas Telford, January 1997. Guideline for European Technical Approval of Anchors (metal anchors) for use in concrete. Part 1, 2 en 3 and Annexes A, B en C (Final Draft). EOTA, Brussels, February 1997. COST C1, ‘Column bases in steel building frames’, ECCS Technical Working Group 10.2 ‘Semi-rigid connections’ and COST C1 WG 2, February 1999. Bouwman, L.P., Gresnigt, A.M. and Romeijn, A., Research into the connection of steel base plates to concrete foundations, Stevin report 25.6.89.05/c6, 1989 (in Dutch).
10
FASTENING TECHNIQUE – CURRENT STATUS AND FUTURE TRENDS Rolf Eligehausen, Isabelle Hofacker and Steffen Lettow Institute of Construction Materials, University of Stuttgart, Germany
Abstract In the paper the current status and future trends of modern fastening technique are described. Fastening technique is used in a wide range of the construction industry. By cooperation between industry and research more economical and safe fastening systems have been and will be developed, which work well in cracked and uncracked concrete. Engineers use special software for the selection of fastening systems and the design of fastenings according to the CC-method. For the installation of anchors technicians are more and more supported by manufacturers with descriptive technical manuals and in some cases with training courses. This will lead to an expanding field of application of modern fastening technique.
1. Introduction Modern fastening systems are becoming more important in civil engineering constructions. In Figure 1 on basis of a simple graph an overview of the wide area of applications of fastenings is given. Fastenings are used in all types of constructions. Because the failure of a fastening may lead to an endangerment of human life or major economic consequences, reliable fastenings are necessary. To ensure reliable fastenings a good co-operation of producer, engineer and user is needed (Figure 2). The producer has to supply efficient and well functioning fastening systems, the engineer must choose the optimal fastening system for the application in question and proof the adequate safety of the fastening by accurate design methods and the user has to ensure a correct installation of the fasteners.
11
Figure 1. Examples of the field of application of fastenings
Figure 2. Requirements to ensure reliable fastenings
2. Fastening Systems The fastening systems currently in use in concrete structures may be classified in cast-inplace installations and post-installed installations for applications (Figure 3). Cast-inplace systems are typically positioned in the formwork before the concrete is cast and thus may also be used in members with dense reinforcement. Post-installed systems may either be installed into drilled holes (drill installation) or be driven into the base material with impact energy (direct installation). They are very flexible in application. For tension loading the load-transfer mechanisms employed by the fasteners may be identified by three different types: friction, mechanical interlock and bond (Figure 4).
Figure 3. Fastening methods in concrete
Figure 4. Load transfer mechanisms
12
Cast-in-place systems like headed anchors (Figure 5a) and channel bars (Figure 5b) transfer tension load mainly by mechanical interlock to the concrete. Typical postinstalled fasteners based on the above mentioned load-transfer mechanisms are shown in Figure 6. In case of expansion anchors (Figure 6a), the load is transferred to the concrete mainly by friction. The frictional resistance depends on the expansion force generated by the expansion of the anchor. Undercut anchors (Figure 6b) transfer tension load to the concrete principally through mechanical interlock between a local undercut and the expansion element which results in locally high bearing stresses. The load transfer of bonded anchors (Figure 6c) is ensured by bond stresses between threaded rod and mortar and mortar and concrete along the embedment length. Often fastenings systems employ a combination of load transfer mechanisms, e.g. bonded expansion anchors for use in cracked concrete. During the last decade many innovative and well functioning fastening systems have been developed by the industry often in close contact with research institutes which cover almost all applications encountered in practice (e.g. fastenings in noncracked and cracked concrete as well as fastenings in different types of masonry under static and cyclic loading).
(a)
(b)
Figure 5. Typical cast-in-place anchors
(a)
(b)
(c)
Figure 6. Typical types of post-installed anchors
13
A survey at about 50 German engineering offices revealed that engineers consider the availability of detailed technical data (e.g. Technical Approval) on anchors as the most important criteria for anchor selection (Figure 7). Furthermore they ask for fastening systems that can be used in a large variety of appli- Figure 7. Selection criteria of fastenings cations. In contrast to the general believe the low price of a fastening system seems not to be an important selection criteria.
3. Testing of Fasteners Fasteners must function properly in the application in question. To ensure this prequalification testing is necessary. During the last years test programs to check the suitability of anchors and to evaluate allowable conditions of use have been worked out by EOTA (1997) and ACI (1985). They will be explained in detail during the conference. In the suitability tests the behavior of fasteners under unfavorable conditions that may occur during installation or the service life of the fastening (e.g. behavior in a wide crack with w=0.5 mm) is checked. In Europe anchors that have passed the approval tests which are mainly performed by an independent testing institute receive an European Technical Approval (ETA) which is required for the use of anchors in safety related applications.
4. Design of Fastenings Fastenings may be loaded by tension-, shear-, or combined tension and shear loads and bending moments. The loads may be static or dynamic. Fastenings may fail in several different modes.
14
Under tension loading mechanical fasteners may be pulled out of the hole (Figure 9e), whereby the concrete at the surface may be damaged. This failure mode will occur only if with expansion anchors the expansion force and with headed and undercut anchors the bearing area is too small. The most common failure mode is the pulling of a concrete cone (Figure 9b + d). For anchor groups the individual cones may overlap (Figure 9b) and for fastenings at the edge the cone is truncated by the edge (Figure 9d). With fastenings close to an edge or in a thin concrete member splitting of the concrete Figure 8. Load directions and failure modes might occur (Figure 9a) and headed anchors very close to an edge may generate a local blow-out failure (Figure 9f). The maximum capacity of the fastening is governed by steel failure (Figure 9c). Fastenings with a sufficiently large edge distance and embedment depth loaded in shear will fail by a local concrete spall in front of the anchor followed by steel rupture (Figure 10a). If the embedment depth is not large enough, the concrete behind the anchor will fail (pry-out failure, Figure 10b). Fastenings close to an edge often fail by a brittle edge failure (Figure 10c, d + e).
Figure 9. Failure modes under tension loading
Figure 10. Failure modes under shear loading
15
While in reinforced concrete constructions in general tensile forces are taken up by reinforcement this is often not possible with fastenings. Therefore fastenings without special reinforcement utilize the concrete tensile capacity which – in case of concrete failure governs the failure load. This must be taken into account in the safety considerations. In the design it must be shown that in the serviceability limit state the displacements of the fasteners are smaller than allowable values and that in the ultimate limit state the load acting on the fastening can be safely transmitted into the concrete. Furthermore the fasteners must be durable during the expected service life. The design of fastenings – as the design of structures – is based on the concept of partial safety factors. It must be demonstrated that the design actions Sd are not larger than the design resistance Rd (Equ. (4.1)). Formelabschnitt 4
S d ≤ Rd
(4.1)
The design actions are distinguished between permanent or variable actions and actions induced by restraint of imposed deformations (e.g. by temperature variations). In the simplest case with one variable load Qk acting in the same direction as the permanent load Gk we get
S d = γ G ⋅ Gk + γ Q ⋅ Qk
(4.2)
The partial safety factors γG for permanent loads and γQ for variable loads are independent of the material or failure mode. They may be different in different countries. In Europe γG = 1.35 and γQ= 1.50 are used. The design resistance is equal to the characteristic resistance (5%-quantile) divided by the material safety factor γM (Equ. (4.3))
Rd ≤ Rk γ M
(4.3)
The partial safety factor γM depends on the accepted probability of failure. It is influenced by the failure mode (ductile steel failure or brittle concrete failure). In case of concrete failure the value of γMc should reflect the utilization of the concrete tensile capacity. Furthermore it should take into account the sensitivity of a fastening system to installation inaccuracies often observed in practice and to unfavorable conditions (e.g. hole drilled with drill but with a diameter of the cutting edge at the upper tolerance limit). In Europe values γMc = 1.80 (fastener with high installation safety) to γMc = 2.50 (fastener with low installation safety) are used.
16
To calculate characteristic resistances for different load directions and failure modes sound engineering models should be available that are sufficient accurate and generally accepted. A comprehensive design method has been published by ACI 349 (1985). It is based on the 45° cone model and assumes a constant tensile stress ( k1 ⋅
f c0.5 ) over the failure
surface ( k2 ⋅ hef ) (Equ. (4.4)). 2
N u ,c = k1 ⋅ f c0.5 ⋅ k2 ⋅ hef2
(4.4)
Intensive research has shown that in case of concrete structures failing in tension the failure load should not be based on the theory of plasticity. But on fracture mechanics to account for the size effect (Bažant (1984)). According to the size effect the failure load of geometrical similar specimens will increase less than proportional with increasing member size. Because of the very high strain gradient in the region of the load transfer area the size effect is very pronounced in fastening technique (Eligehausen/Sawade (1989), Eligehausen/Ožbolt (1990)). It can be taken into account by multiplying 0.5
Equ. (4.4) with the factor ( k5 / hef ) (Equ. (4.5)).
N u ,c = k3 ⋅ f c0.5 ⋅ k4 ⋅ hef2 ⋅ k5 / hef0.5 = k ⋅ f c0.5 ⋅ hef1.5 with:
(4.5)
k1 - k5 = constants fc = concrete compressive strength hef = embedment depth
Figure 11 shows the concrete cone failure loads measured in tests can be predicted with sufficient accuracy by Equ. (4.5). In contrast to that the failure loads are underestimated by Equ. (4.4) for small embedment depths and are overestimated for large embedment depths. Furthermore the angle between the failure cone and the concrete surface is not 45° but approximately 35° (Figure 12). Therefore assuming α = 45° the failure load of anchor groups or fastenings at the edge may be overestimated.
17
3.0 Eligehausen et al. (1992/1) and (1992/2)
Failure load [MN]
2.5
CC-method ACI-349 (1985)
2.0 1.5 1.0 0.5 0.0 0.0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
Embedment depth [m]
Figure 11. Concrete cone failure loads of headed Figure 12. Angle of the failure cone as a anchors under tensile load as a function of the function of the embedment depth (Fuchs, embedment depth (fcc=33 MPa), (Eligehausen et al. Eligehausen, Breen (1995/2) (1992/1), (1992/2))
The above described and other research results have been incorporated into the κ-method for the design of fastenings which is described in the CEB State-of-the-Art-Report (1994). In this method the influence of different parameters on the failure load (as edge distance, spacing, eccentricity of the resultant force, surface reinforcement, cracked concrete) is taken into account by κ−factors. Fuchs/Eligehausen/Breen (1995/1) developed the CC-method, which is based on the same mechanical models as the κ-method. The CC-method visualizes the κ-factors of the κ−method. Furthermore, more recent research results (e.g. Fuchs (1990), Eligehausen/Furche (1991), Lehmann (1993), Zhao (1993), Furche (1994), Asmus (1999)) have been taken into account to cover all failure modes. The CC-method is very user friendly and in most cases gives sufficiently accurate results. The CC-method has been incorporated in several design guides in Europe ((DIBt (1993), EOTA (1997), CUR (2000) and SIA (1998)) and the USA ((IBC (2000) and ACI 318 (2001)) and is currently discussed in China. It is described in several papers of this conference and open problems are discussed. Recent research results (e.g. Cook et al. (1998), Meszaros (2001) and Lehr (2001)) demonstrate that for fastenings with bonded anchors a modification of the CC-method is needed to cover their load transfer mechanism. These modifications will also be discussed during this conference.
5. Cracked Concrete In concrete structures often cracks will occur due to a variety of reasons (Beeby (1991)). The most important are tensile stresses due to loads and due to restraint of imposed
18
deformations (e.g. caused by shrinkage, creep, temperature variations or support settlements). Therefore according to codes for structural concrete in the serviceability limit state the width of cracks must be limited to acceptable values by reinforcement. Extensive measurements in practice demonstrate that under quasi-permanent load the characteristic crack width is wk ≈ 0.3 mm (Bergmeister (1988), Eligehausen/Bozenhardt (1989)), which agrees with the value generally accepted by codes.
Figure 13. Crack pattern at service load. The anchors were installed in uncracked concrete, after Lotze (1987)
There is a high probability that fasteners installed in uncracked concrete will be located in a crack if the concrete cracks (Figure 13), because high tensile stresses are caused in the region of the fastening by prestressing and loading of anchors and the notch effect. The influence of concrete cracking on anchor behavior depends on the type of anchor. The failure load of anchors transferring tensile loads by mechanical interlock (e.g. headed and undercut anchors) and failing by breaking a concrete cone is reduced by about 25 % by a crack with a width w ≈ 0.3 mm (Figure 14) due to the disturbance of the distribution of the tensile stresses around the anchor by the crack. A slightly larger reduction must be expected for torque controlled expansion anchors that function well in cracked concrete (Figure 15).
19
Figure 14. Load-displacement curves of headed Figure 15. Load-displacement curves of anchors in cracked and uncracked concrete torque controlled expansion anchors de(Furche, Dieterle (1986)) signed for use in cracked concrete in cracked and uncracked concrete (Dieterle, Bozenhardt, Hirth, Opitz (1990))
Figure 16. Load-displacement curves of torque controlled expansion anchors designed for use in non-cracked concrete in cracked and uncracked concrete (Dieterle, Bozenhardt, Hirth, Opitz (1990))
20
Figure 17. Load-displacement curves of fully expanded displacement controlled expansion anchors in cracked and uncracked concrete (Dieterle, Opitz (1988))
However torque controlled expansion anchors that are designed for use in uncracked concrete may not function at all if anchored in a crack (Figure 16). With deformation controlled expansion anchors the failure load in cracked concrete (w = 0.3 mm) is on average only 50 % of the value valid for non-cracked concrete (Figure 17). The reduction of the failure load is even more pronounced if – as often in practice – the anchors are partly expanded only.
Figure 18. Interference of bond between mortar Figure 19. Influence of cracks on the and concrete caused by a crack failure load of capsule-type bonded anchors under tension loading (Meszaros (2001))
With bonded anchors the bond between mortar and concrete is partly destroyed by a crack (Figure 18) which results in rather low failure loads and a large scatter (Figure 19). With bonded expansion anchors expansion forces are generated by pulling the cone into the mortar after crack opening (Figure 20). Therefore the failure load is only reduced by about 30 % compared to non-cracked concrete (Figure 21). If fastenings must be installed in reinforced concrete that may crack only fasteners with a predictable behavior in cracked concrete (demonstrated in pre-qualification tests) should be used and the influence of cracks on the failure load should be taken into account in the design. Whether in a certain application the concrete may be considered as cracked or non-cracked over the expected service life of the fastening should be decided by the designer based on the rules for reinforced concrete.
21
Figure 20. Interference of bond between Figure 21. Load-displacement curves of bonded mortar and concrete caused by a crack and expansion anchors in cracked and uncracked load transfer mechanism of a bonded expan- concrete (schematically) sion anchor
6. Installation of Fasteners Fasteners must be installed correctly according to the design specifications and the installation instructions of the manufacturer. To reach this goal the installation instructions - preferably in form of pictograms - should be detailed and clear and the installer should be well trained. The mistakes may not always be as severe as shown in Figure 22. However, even smaller mistakes (e.g. use of improper drill bit, no or too little cleaning of the hole, too small installation torque, improper compaction of the concrete in the region of a cast-in-place fastening) may influence the anchor behavior significantly. During the last decade especially manufacturers have done a lot to improve the situation by distributing adequate installation instructions. However the biggest problem is that many fasteners are installed by untrained workers. According to a recent survey in Germany, 45% of the
Figure 22. Fastening of column. According to the design the fastening should be installed directly on the concrete surface, after Steiner (2000)
22
polled engineers believe that fastenings are installed by inexperienced personal resulting in an incorrect installation in about 50% of all applications (Schade (2001)). In other countries the situation is probably not much better. According to the authors opinion the situation will only improve significantly if only workers with proper training are allowed to install safety related fastenings. And if this is checked by supervision the proper training should be demonstrated by a certificate that is issued after passing a corresponding test. Very good experiences have been made in Germany with this approach for the post-installation of rebars.
7. Open Problems and Future Trends With the CC-method fastenings under arbitrary loading can be designed. However, in some applications (e.g. fastenings close to an edge and loaded in shear parallel to or away from the edge) the design models are rather conservative and should be improved. Furthermore the influence of special reinforcement on the strength and ductility of fastenings should be taken into account by improved design models. Until now most of the research has been done for monotonic loading including sustained and fatigue loading. However, much less research has been performed to study the behavior of fastenings under seismic excitations. The results until about 1990 are summarized in the CEB State-of-the-Art Report (1994) and the results of a recently finished extensive study are given in Klingner et al. (1998). It should be clarified if the test procedures and evaluation criteria for post-installed anchors and the design models valid for monotonic loading are adequate in case of seismic loadings, especially if fastenings are installed in regions where very wide cracks must be expected in the structure. Fastenings may be subjected to fire. While some results have been published (e.g. Reick (2001)), more research is needed in this area. In many regions of the world a large number of existing structures must be strengthened to resist future earthquakes. Modern fastening technique will play an important role in this work. However, more research is needed to develop new strengthening techniques and rational design models for the actions on and the resistance of fastenings. During the last two decades many new types of anchors have been developed (e.g. undercut anchors, bonded expansion anchors, concrete screws) to cope with new requirements (e.g. cracked concrete, fatigue and seismic loading). In the future more systems will be developed by combining different working principals to reach more economical solutions, better performance or both satisfy new demands by the user.
23
Figure 23. Procedures used in praxis for the design of fastenings, after Schade (2001)
According to a recent survey in Germany about 70% of the polled engineers design fastenings according to the CC-method by using software provided by manufacturers and in only 20% of applications a hand calculation is done according to a simplified design method (Figure 23). In the future the design of fastenings with the help of a computer will be common all over the world.
Several committees all around the world work on test procedures and evaluation criteria for fasteners and on design methods for fastenings. The authors hope that because of modern information technologies, communication between the acting persons and – last but not least – conferences like this one the provisions will be harmonized world wide. The knowledge on fastening technique has increased significantly over the last two decades which is demonstrated by an increasing number of papers, reports, text books and conferences. However, the subject is often not taught in engineering schools. The authors believe that this will change in the future when more design guides are published by code committees.
8. Summary Modern fastening technique is increasingly used in the building industry. New and innovative fastening systems have been developed by the industry and reliable design methods have been incorporated in design guides. This will go on in the future. However, the training of designers and installers should be improved. Currently fastenings to concrete structures with cast-in-place or post-installed fastening systems are often not used in practice with the same confidence as other connections (e.g. welding or screwing in steel structures). It is hoped that this will change in the future, thereby expanding the field of application of modern fastening technique.
24
9. References 1. American Concrete Institute, ACI Committee 318: Proposed Canges to Building Code Reqiurements for Structural Concrete. Appendix D – Anchoring to Concrete, scheduled to be published in edition of Concrete International, June 2001. 2. American Concrete Institute, ACI Standard 349-85: Code Requirements for Nuclear Safety Related Concrete Structures, Appendix B – Steel Embedments, 1985 3. Asmus, J.: Verhalten von Befestigungen bei der Versagensart Spalten des Betons. Dissertation, Institut für Werkstoffe im Bauwesen, Universität Stuttgart, 1999. 4. Bažant, Z.P.: Size Effect in Blunt Fracture: Concrete, Rock, Metal. Journal of Engineering Mechanics, ASCE, 110, No. 4, S. 518-535, April 1984. 5. Bergmeister, K.: Stochastik in der Befestigungstechnik mit realistischen Einflußgrößen. Dissertation, Universität Innsbruck, 1988. 6. Civieltechnisch Centrum Uitvoering Research en Regelgeving (CUR): Aanbeveking 25, Korte Ankers in Beton; berekening en uitvoering. Redactionale Bijlage bij Cement 4/2000. 7. Comité Euro-International du Béton (CEB): Design of Fastenings in Concrete. Bulletin D’Information No. 226, Lausanne. Thomas Telford, London 1995. 8. Comité Euro-International du Béton (CEB): Fastenings to Concrete and Masonry Structures. State-of-the-Art-Report, Bulletin D’Information No. 216, Lausanne. Thomas Telford, London 1994. 9. Cook, R.A.; Bishop, M.C.; Hagedoorn, H.S.; Sikes, D.; Richardson, D.S.; Adams, T.L.; De Zee, C.T.: Adhesive Bonded Anchors: Bond Properties and Effects of InService and Installation Conditions. Bericht Nr. 94-2A, University of Florida, Department of Civil Engineering, Collage of Engineering, Gainsville 1994. 10. Cook, R.A.; Kunz, J.; Fuchs, W.; Konz, R.C.: Behavior and Design of Single Adhesive Anchors under Tensile Load in Uncracked Concrete. ACI Structural Journal, V. 95, No. 1, 1998, S. 9-26. 11. Deutsches Institut für Bautechnik (DIBt): Bemessungsverfahren für Dübel zur Verankerung in Beton (Anhang zum Zulassungsbescheid). Berlin, Ausgabe Juni 1993. 12. Dieterle, H.; Bozenhardt, A.; Hirth, W.; Opitz, V.: Tragverhalten von Dübeln in Parallelrissen unter Schrägzugbeanspruchung. Bericht Nr. 1/45-89/19 (nicht veröffentlicht). Institut für Werkstoffe im Bauwesen. Universität Stuttgart, 1990. 13. Dieterle, H.; Opitz, V.: Tragverhalten von nicht generell zugzonentauglichen Dübeln, Teil 1: Verhalten in Parallelrissen. Bericht Nr. 1/34-88/21 (nicht veröffentlicht). Institut für Werkstoffe im Bauwesen, Universität Stuttgart, 1988. 14. Eligehausen, R.; Bouska, P.; Cervenka, V.; Pukl, R.: Size Effect of the Concrete Cone Failure Load of Anchor Bolts. In Bažant, Z.P. (Herausgeber), Fracture Mechanics of Concrete Structures. S. 517-525, Elsevier Applied Science, London, New York, 1992/2. 15. Eligehausen, R.; Bozenhardt, A.: Crack Widths as Measured in Actual Structures and Conclusions for the Testing of Fastening Elements. Bericht Nr. 1/42-89/9, Institut für Werkstoffe im Bauwesen, Universität Stuttgart, 1989.
25
16. Eligehausen, R.; Fuchs, W.; Ick, U.; Mallée, R.; Reuter, M.; Schimmelpfennig, K.; Schmal, B.: Tragverhalten von Kopfbolzenverankerungen bei zentrischer Zugbeanspruchung. Bauingenieur 67, S. 183-196, 1992/1. 17. Eligehausen, R.; Mallée, R.: Befestigungstechnik im Beton- und Mauerwerkbau. Bauingenieur-Praxis. Ernst & Sohn, Berlin 2000. 18. Eligehausen, R.; Ožbolt, J.: Size Effect in Anchorage Behavior. Proceedings, ECF8, Fracture Behavior and Design of Materials and Structures, Turin, 1990. 19. Eligehausen, R.; Sawade, G.: A Fracture Mechanics based Description of the PullOut Behavior of Headed Studs embedded in Concrete. Fracture Mechanics of Concrete Structures, From Theory to Application. S. 281-299. Herausgeber: Elfgren, L. Chapmann and Hall, London, New York, 1989. 20. European Organization for Technical Approvals (EOTA): Guideline for European Technical Approval of Metal Anchors for Use in Concrete. Part 1, 2, 3 & 4, Brüssel, 1997. 21. Fuchs, W.: Tragverhalten von Befestigungen unter Querlast im ungerissenen Beton. Dissertation, Institut für Werkstoffe im Bauwesen, Universität Stuttgart, 1990. 22. Fuchs, W.; Eligehausen, R.; Breen, J.E.: Concrete Capacity Design (CCD) Approach for Fastening to Concrete. ACI Structural Journal, Vol. 92, No. 1, S. 73-94, 1995/1. 23. Fuchs, W.; Eligehausen, R.; Breen, J.E.: Concrete Capacity Design (CCD) Approach for Fastening to Concrete, Authors’ Closure to Discussion. ACI Structural Journal, Vol. 92, No. 6, S. 794-802, 1995/2. 24. Furche, J.: Zum Trag- und Verschiebungsverhalten von Kopfbolzen bei zentrischem Zug. Dissertation, Institut für Werkstoffe im Bauwesen, Universität Stuttgart, 1994. 25. Furche, J.; Dieterle, H.: Ausziehversuche an Kopfbolzen mit unterschiedlichen Kopfformen bei Verankerungen in ungerissenem Beton und Parallelrissen. Bericht Nr. 9/1-86/9 (nicht veröffentlicht), Institut für Werkstoffe im Bauwesen. Universität Stuttgart, 1986. 26. Furche, J.; Eligehausen, R.: Lateral Blow-out Failure of Headed Studs Near the Free Edge. In: Senkiw, G.A.; Lancelot, H.B. (Herausgeber), SP-130, Anchors in Concrete, Design and Behavior. American Concrete Institute, S. 235-252, Detroit, 1991. 27. International Building Code (IBC): International Code Council. Fall Church, Virginia, March 2000. 28. Klingner, R.E.; Hallowell, J.M.; Lotze, D.; Park, H.-G.; Rodriguez, M.; Zhang, Y.G.: Anchor Bolt Behavior and Strength During Earthquakes. Report No. NUREC/CR-5434. The University of Texas at Austin, 1998. 29. Lehmann, R.: Tragverhalten von Metallspreizdübeln in ungerissenem und gerissenem Beton bei der Versagensart Herausziehen. Dissertation, Institut für Werkstoffe im Bauwesen, Universität Stuttgart, 1993. 30. Lehr, B.: Bemessung von Befestigungen mit Verbunddübeln. Dissertation, Institut für Werkstoffe im Bauwesen, Universität Stuttgart, 2001. 31. Lehr, B.; Eligehausen, R.: Vorschlag eines Bemessungskonzeptes für Verbundanker. Bericht Nr. 20/25-98/6, (nicht veröffentlicht). Institut für Werkstoffe im Bauwesen, Universität Stuttgart, 1998.
26
32. Lotze, D.: Untersuchungen zur Frage der Wahrscheinlichkeit, mit der Dübel in Rissen liegen – Einfluß der Querbewehrung. Bericht Nr. 1/24-87/6 (nicht veröffentlicht), Institut für Werkstoffe im Bauwesen, Universität Stuttgart, 1987. 33. Meszaros, J.: Tragverhalten von Einzelverbunddübeln unter zentrischer Kurzzeitbelastung. Dissertation, Institut für Werkstoffe im Bauwesen, Universität Stuttgart, 2001. 34. Ministry of Construction of People’s Repuplic of China: Anchors for Use in Concrete (Draft). China, 2000. 35. Rehm, G.; Eligehausen, R.; Mallée, R.: Befestigungstechnik. Betonkalender 1988, Teil II, Verlag Wilhelm Ernst & Sohn, Berlin 1988, S. 569-663. 36. Rehm, G.; Lehmann, R.: Untersuchungen mit Metallspreizdübeln in der gerissenen Zugzone von Stahlbetonteilen. Forschungsbericht, Forschungs- und Materialprüfungsanstalt Baden-Württemberg, Stuttgart 1982. 37. Reick, M.: Brandverhalten von Befestigungen in Beton bei zentrischer Zugbeanspruchung. Dissertation, Institut für Werkstoffe im Bauwesen, Universität Stuttgart, 2001. 38. Schade, P.: Stand der Befestigungstechnik in der Praxis. Diplomarbeit am Institut für Werkstoffe im Bauwesen, Universität Stuttgart, 2001. 39. Schweizerischer Ingenieur- und Architekten-Verein (SIA): SIA 179, Befestigungen in Beton- und Mauerwerk. Zürich, 1998. 40. Steiner, J.: Vermeidbare Qualitätseinbuße – Erfahrungen mit der Planung und der Ausführung von Verankerungen mit Dübeln. IBK-Bau-Fachtagung, Dübel- und Befestigungstechnik, Darmstadt 2000. 41. Studiengemeinschaft für Fertigbau e.V.: Verankerungen am Bau. Technisches Merkblatt der Arbeitskreise “Dübel” und “Verankerungen am Bau”. Wiesbaden 2000. 42. Zhao, G.: Tragverhalten von randfernen Kopfbolzenverankerungen bei Betonbruch. Dissertation, Institut für Werkstoffe im Bauwesen, Universität Stuttgart, 1993.
27
ANCHORING TO CONCRETE: THE NEW ACI APPROACH John E. Breen*, Eva-Maria Eichinger** and Werner Fuchs*** *Ferguson Structural Engineering Laboratory, The University of Texas at Austin, USA **Institute for Structural Concrete, Technical University of Vienna, Austria ***Institute for Construction Materials, University of Stuttgart, Germany
Abstract This paper outlines the general approach of a new appendix for design of anchoring to concrete in the American Concrete Institute (ACI) Building Code. It covers cast-in-situ anchors and mechanical post-installed anchors. ACI 318 and the ACI Technical Activities Committee have approved this proposal, and it is being published for public comment as part of the ACI 318-2001 revision. The proposed design procedures are in general harmony with provisions being developed by fib.
1. Foreword It is a great privilege to participate in this Symposium. It is fitting that it is being held at the University of Stuttgart where Professors Gallus Rehm, Rolf Eligehausen and their coworkers, established the extensive scientific basis for modern approaches to Anchoring to Concrete. While ACI has long had recommendations for the design of anchors when used in nuclear related structures (ACI 349) the ACI 318 Building Code has been silent on this subject. In 1970, ACI Committee 355, Anchorage to Concrete, was established to report on performance and recommend design and construction practices for anchorage to concrete. Because of trade conflicts, no design related code recommendations ever came to ACI 318. In 1989 ACI 318 Sub B formed a task force to develop anchoring to concrete design provisions. Anchor qualification provisions were left to ACI 355 and ASTM. The design approach adopted by ACI 318 stems directly from the interaction with Dr. Fuchs as a DFG post-doctoral fellow at The University of Texas in 1990-1991. His visit resulted in major integration of the European and North American test data on cast-in-place and post-installed anchors reported in comparison studies of Reference 1. Detailed discussions led to adaptation of the previously proposed Stuttgart κ method to
31
make it more “designer friendly,” a most important factor in subsequent adoption by ACI 318. Now, twelve years later that challenge is virtually done, at least in its first phase. This paper describes where ACI 318 is and its general approach. But, in structural concrete, doors never truly close. While the new recommendations cover much and represent a great improvement, they are still only first steps. The search is just beginning for similar design provisions for adhesive and grouted anchors.
2. Introduction In 1995 when setting the goals for the 2001 ACI 318 Building Code, the membership voted overwhelmingly to add specific design provisions for anchoring to concrete. This reflects the increased demand for such design guidance by code users, the considerable research and design development stimulated by ACI Committees 349 and 355, and the increased cooperation with CEB (now fib). Main decisions in the ACI 318 approach were based on the unanimous technical advice from Committee 355. The approach had to be compatible with the load and resistance factor format of the present code. The nominal resistance expressions should be consistent with the observed accuracy of the design formulae or values from comprehensive tests. A design approach should be found that accommodates brittle failure as well as ductile failure modes. The design provisions that envision brittle failure should use load and resistance factors appropriate for brittle failure modes. The nominal resistance design formulae should account for the effects of the type of anchor, anchor material, anchor diameter, edge distance, spacing, concrete strength, embedment depth and for the effects of cracking. An alternate approach using site specific testing to determine design values should be included. The basic approach of the ACI 318 Building Code provisions is to express all possible modes of failure for the anchors, to require the use of conservative design provisions based on the 5 percent fractile, and to provide some limited spacings, edge distance minimums and minimum thicknesses for the concrete member. Then, while the user is allowed to choose any design models or design by test values that meet these general requirements, for practical use a “deemed to satisfy” procedure is included. This latter procedure for steel failures is based on the method of AISC LRFD [2] while for concrete failures, it is based on the Concrete Capacity Design (CCD) procedure [1,3] that is accurate, designer friendly and in good agreement with tests. Special provisions for seismic applications and enhanced ductility through use of supplementary reinforcement are included. The ACI 318 Building Code provisions are applicable in scope to cast-in-place headed studs and headed or hooked bolts as well as a variety of post-installed anchors such as expansion anchors and undercut anchors [See Fig. 1]. Committee 318 plans to include provisions for adhesive anchors in a future code revision. A key element in the design philosophy is that the post-installed anchors must be prequalified by acceptance testing
32
using performance standards developed by ASTM or ACI 355 (ACI 355.2-00) [4]. This testing differentiates between post-installed anchors according to their installation sensitivity, behavior in oversize holes, low and high strength concrete, or with partial torque or expansion in cracked or uncracked concrete. These standards are similar to European EOTA (ETAG) requirements but adapted to American certification procedures. The anchors are placed in one of three categories according to their performance in tests. The ACI Code gives reduced resistance factors (φ) for the poorer performing categories. Designers may specify allowable categories to be used according to their safety requirements. The ACI 318 Appendix passed all voting procedures of Committee 318 and was approved by the ACI Technical Activities Committee pending final approval of the reference testing standard. A version for cast-in-place anchors that does not require such acceptance testing was adopted and included in the International Building Code 2000 [9]. An almost identical version has been adopted by ACI 349B for cast-in and post-installed anchors for nuclear-related structures. Since the Nuclear Regulatory Commission prescribes test procedures for fastening acceptance, the ACI 349B-1999 version did not have to wait for completion of the reference acceptance testing standard. Thus, ACI has now replaced the traditional 45º cone approach of ACI 349B with the new CCD procedures. The overall approach has also been adopted by the Fastening to Concrete committee of NEHRP (National Earthquake Hazard Reduction Program) for inclusion in NEHRP 2000 [10].
hef
hef (a) post-installed anchors
(b) cast-in-place anchors
Figure 1 – Types of anchors The proposed Appendix provides design requirements for structural anchors used to transmit structural loads from attachments into concrete members by means of tension, shear, or a combination of tension and shear. Several failure types of fasteners can be differentiated [See Figs. 2 and 3]. Strength design of structural anchors is based on the computation or test evaluation of the steel tensile and shear strengths of the anchor and the attachment, the concrete breakout tensile and shear strengths, the tensile pullout strength of the anchor, the side-face blowout strength, the concrete pryout strength and required edge distances, spacing and member thickness to preclude splitting failure. The minimum of these strengths is taken as the nominal strength of the anchor for each load condition. Regardless of the mode which governs for a given anchor at a given embedment depth, the suitability of post-installed anchors for use in concrete must be demonstrated by the prequalification tests of ACI 355.2 [4].
33
Many possible design approaches exist and the user is always permitted to “design by test” as long as sufficient data are available to verify the model. If test results are used these must be evaluated on an equivalent statistical basis to that used to select the values for the concrete breakout method in the “deemed to satisfy” provisions. The basic capacity shall not be taken greater than the 5 percent fractile. When the failure of an anchor group is due to breakage of the concrete, the behavior is brittle and there is limited redistribution of the forces between the highly stressed and less stressed anchors. In such a case the theory of elasticity must be used for determining the force on the anchor, assuming the attachment that distributes loads to the anchors is sufficiently stiff. The forces in the anchors are considered to be proportional to the external load and its distance from the neutral axis of the anchor group.
Nn
Nn
(a) Steel Failure
Nn
Nn
(b) Pullout
Nn
(c) Concrete Breakout
Nn
Nn
Nn
Nn
(e) Concrete Splitting (d) Side-Face Blowout
Figure 2 — Failure modes for fasteners under tensile loading
34
Vn
Vn
(b) Concrete Pryout for Fasteners Far From a Free Edge
(a) Steel Failure Preceded by Concrete Spall Vn
Vn
Vn Vn
Vn Vn
Vn
(c) Concrete Breakout
Figure 3 — Failure modes for fasteners under shear loading If an anchor failure is governed by ductile failure of the anchor steel, significant redistribution of anchor forces may occur. In such a case, analysis assuming the theory of elasticity will be conservative. A non-linear analysis, using theory of plasticity, is allowed for the determination of the ultimate loading conditions of ductile anchor groups. The levels of safety defined by the combinations of load factors and resistance factors (φ) are appropriate for structural applications. The designer may use lower levels of safety in design for non-structural applications and may wish to use more demanding safety levels for particularly sensitive structural connections. The safety levels are not intended for handling and construction conditions. The φ factors proposed for use with the current load factors given in the 1995 ACI Code Section 9.2 are given in Table 1. Condition A applies where the potential concrete failure surfaces are crossed by supplementary reinforcement proportioned to tie the potential concrete failure prism into the structural member. Condition B applies where such supplementary reinforcement is not provided or where pullout or pryout strength governs. Higher φ factors are given for anchors that have supplementary reinforcement in the direction of the load to increase overall ductility, i.e. Condition A [See Fig. 4].
35
Table 1: φ factors a) Anchor governed by tensile or shear strength of a ductile steel element .................... 0.90 b) Anchor governed by tensile or shear strength of a brittle steel element...................... 0.75 c) Anchor governed by concrete breakout, blowout, pullout or pryout strength Condition A Condition B i) Shear Loads ...................................................................... 0.85 0.75 ii) Tension Loads Cast-in headed studs, headed bolts, or hooked bolts ........ 0.85 0.75 Post-installed anchors with category as determined from ACI 355.2 Category 1 (Low sensitivity to installation and high reliability) ...................................................................... 0.85 0.75 Category 2 (Medium sensitivity to installation and medium reliability) ........................................................ 0.75 0.65 Category 3 (High sensitivity to installation and lower reliability) ...................................................................... 0.65 0.55
Figure 4 – Influence of reinforcement on the load-displacement behavior of headed anchors loaded in shear (from Ref.5)
36
For a post-installed anchor to be acceptable in seismic loading situations, the system must be proven to have adequate ductility. The anchor must demonstrate the capacity to undergo large displacements through several cycles as specified in the seismic simulation of the ACI 355.2 prequalification tests. If the anchor cannot meet these requirements or if substantially reduced design loads are being applied which assume substantial ductility in the structure, then the attachment must yield at a load well below the anchor capacity.
3. Steel Based Resistance For the calculation of steel failure, an approach based on the AISC LRFD [1] approach was “deemed to satisfy” (See Reference 6). In case of steel failure the shear and tensile strength of an anchor are evaluated based on the properties of the anchor material and the dimensions of the anchor. Values based on the 5 percent fractile of test results may also be used.
4. Concrete Based Resistance The basic design concrete capacities for any anchor or group of anchors must be based on design models which result in predictions of strength in substantial agreement with results of comprehensive tests and which account for the size effect. They are to be based on the 5 percent fractile of the basic individual anchor capacity, with modifications made for the number of anchors, the effects of close spacing of anchors, proximity to edges, depth of the concrete member, eccentric loading of anchor groups, and presence or absence of cracking. Limits on edge distances and anchor spacing in the design models shall be consistent with the tests that have verified the model. The “deemed to satisfy” design method used for the calculation of the concrete breakout capacities under tensile or shear loading was developed from the Concrete Capacity Design (CCD) Method [1,3], which was an adaptation of the κ method [7,8] and is considered to be accurate, relatively easy to apply, and can be extended to irregular layouts. For single anchors, it assumes a breakout prism angle of about 35 degrees [Figs. 5, 6]. Both the CCD and the κ methods include fracture mechanics theory, which indicates that in the case of brittle concrete failure the failure load increases at a rate less than the increase in the available surface and that the nominal stress at failure (peak load divided by failure area) decreases with increasing member size. The method predicts the load-bearing capacity of an anchor or group of anchors by using one basic equation for a single anchor in cracked concrete, and multiplying by factors which account for the number of anchors, edge distance, spacing, eccentricity and absence of cracking [1,6]. A very important attribute of the CCD approach is that it is reasonably “transparent” and hence designer friendly. Rather than working with the complex intersection of 45º cones as previously required by the ACI 349B approach, the CCD method when applied to groups uses values of AN/ANo or AV/AVo that are based on projected areas of
37
quadrilaterals. These areas are illustrated in Figure 7 for tension loads and in Figure 8 for shear loads.
The critical edge distance for headed studs, headed bolts, expansion fasteners, and undercut fasteners is 1.5hef . 1.5 hef
1.5hef
1.5 hef
1.5hef
≈ 35° h ef
1.5hef
1.5hef
Section through failure cone Plan view
A No = 2 * 1.5 h ef × 2 * 1.5 h ef = 3 h ef × 3 h ef = 9 h ef2
Figure 5 – CCD concrete cone breakout model for tensile loading
1.5c1
≈35o
Vn Center of fastener where it crosses the free surface
1.5c1
The critical edge distance for headed studs, headed bolts, expansion fasteners, and undercut fasteners is 1.5c1
1.5c1
c1
Edge of concrete
1.5c1
Plan view
Vn
1.5c1
hef
Side section
A Vo = 2 ∗ 1.5c 1 × 1.5c 1 = 3c1 × 1.5c 1 = 4.5c 12 Front view
Figure 6 – CCD concrete cone breakout model for shear loading
38
c1 1.5 hef 1.5 hef 1.5 hef
AN AN = (c1 + 1.5hef) (2 x 1.5hef) if c1 < 1.5hef
s1 1.5 hef
1.5 hef 1.5 hef
c1
AN AN = (c1 + s1 + 1.5hef) (2 x 1.5hef) if c1 < 1.5hef and s1 < 3hef
s1 1.5 hef
c2
s2 1.5 hef
c1
AN AN = (c1 + s1 + 1.5hef) (c2 + s2 + 1.5hef) if c1 and c2 < 1.5hef and s1 and s2 < 3hef
Figure 7 – Projected areas for single anchors and groups of anchors for tension loads
5. Other Design Concepts A comparison with the extensive test database indicated that the CCD method gave good results over the full range of applications [Figs. 9, 10]. While the ACI 349-85 procedure had very much the equivalent accuracy in some ranges, it was very unconservative in other ranges, particularly with group effects, and the geometry of intersecting circles was much more complex in group applications [Fig. 11]. However, recognizing that widely accepted procedures such as the earlier ACI 349-85 model as well as the PCI model can give satisfactory results in certain ranges, the proposed ACI 318 Appendix allows any “design models which result in substantial agreement with results of comprehensive tests” to be used. This generalized wording
39
allows previous procedures like the ACI 349 or PCI techniques to be used in applicable ranges if desired.
if h < 1.5c1
if h < 1.5c1
Vn/2
Vn Av
Av
c1
h
Vn/2 c1
h 1.5c1 1.5c1
1.5c1 1.5c1
AV = 2 x 1.5c1 x h
AV = 2 x 1.5c1 x h Note:One One assumption of the Note: assumption of the distribution forces indicates distribution of of forces indicates that that half half thewould shear be would be on critical the shear critical front on front anchor its projected fastener and its and projected area. area.
if c2 < 1.5c1 Vn Av
c1
1.5c1
if h < 1.5c1 Vn
c2 1.5c1 Av
AV = 1.5c1 (1.5c1 + c2)
c1
h 1.5c1
if h < 1.5c1 and s1 < 3c1
Av = 2 x 1.5c1 x h
Vn Av
Note:Another Another assumption of the Note: assumption of the distribution forces applies distribution of of forces thatthat applies onlyonly where anchorsare arerigidly rigidly connected where fasteners connected to to theattachment attachment indicates the total the indicates thatthat the total shear would critical on the shear would be be critical on the rearrear anchor and itsand projected area. area. fastener its projected
c1
h 1.5c1
s1
1.5c1
1.5c1
AV = (2 x 1.5c1 + s1) x h
Figure 8 – Projected areas for single anchors and groups of anchors for shear loads
Typical cast-in-place headed studs, headed anchor bolts and hooked anchors have been tested and have proven to behave predictably, so calculated pullout values are acceptable.
40
Post-installed anchors do not have predictable pullout failure loads, therefore they must be tested. The pullout strength of headed studs or headed anchor bolts can be increased by provision of confining reinforcement such as closely spaced spirals throughout the head region. This increase can be demonstrated by tests. The tensile and shear capacity can be increased by provision of supplementary reinforcement with resisting components in the direction of the applied force [See Fig. 4] [5].
a) Equation vs Tension Test Results for Post-Installed Anchors
b) Equation vs Tension Test Results for Headed Studs and Anchor Bolts
in uncracked concrete, and not affected by edges or spacing
in uncracked concrete, and not affected by edges or spacing
Mean CCD Equation for tension on post-installed anchors in uncracked concrete
Mean CCD equation for tension on headed studs and anchor bolts in uncracked concrete
1000
Failure Load, kN
Failure Load, kN
300
200
500
100
Design equation for anchors in uncracked concrete
Design equation for anchors in uncracked concrete 0 0
50
100
150
200
0
250
0
125
250
375
500
Effective Embedment Depth, hef, mm
Effective Embedment Depth, hef, mm
Figure 9 – Mean and design CCD equations for anchors in uncracked concrete compared to test data for a) post-installed anchors and b) headed anchors
41
625
Equation vs. Shear Test Results for single anchors in deep uncracked members (European Tests)
Failure Load, kN
150
Mean CCD equation for shear in uncracked concrete
100
50
0
Design equation for shear in uncracked concrete
0
75
150
225
300
Edge Distance in Direction of Shear, c1, mm
Figure 10 – Mean and design CCD shear equations for uncracked concrete compared to test data
N [kN] 3000
Symbol
1 4 16 36
Si
+ I3 AC
85 49-
fcc′ = 25 N/mm2 hef = 185 mm n = 1-36 headed studs
St
2000
n
hod Met CCD
1000
200
400
600
800
+
Mean value of a series
1000 Si [mm]
Figure 11 – Comparison of ACI 349-85 and CCD design equations for anchor groups
42
Interaction of tensile and shear loads is considered in the design using an interaction expression which results in predictions of strength in substantial agreement with results of comprehensive tests [See Ref. 6 and Fig. 12]. The values used for the tension part of the interaction equation shall be the smallest of the anchor steel strength, concrete breakout strength, sideface blowout strength, or pullout strength. For the shear part, the smaller of the steel strength, the concrete pryout strength or the concrete breakout strength shall be used.
Nu Nu φ Nn
φ Nn
5
3
+ Vu φ Vn
5
3
=1
Trilinear Interaction Approach
0.2 φ Nn φ Vn
0.2φ Vn
Vu
Figure 12 – Shear and tensile load interaction equation
6. Status In North America, a task force of ACI 318 Subcommittee B developed and refined the current proposals that have been approved by ACI Committee 318. ACI 355 recently completed the post-installed anchor acceptance test standard [4], but it has been subject to procedural and legal challenges by one anchor manufacturer. Assuming resolution of this challenge, comprehensive design provisions will be in ACI 318-2001. Even if the challenge provides further delay in adoption of the provisions for post-installed fasteners, the new ACI 349B expressions will be widely used and cast-in anchors will be governed by the recently adopted IBC 2000 provisions. These are identical to the ACI 318 provisions given herein but are limited to cast-in applications. The proposed new Appendix to the ACI 318 Building Code is a very important step in harmonizing several existing design procedures. The user is allowed to choose any design models or design by test values that meet the general requirements. A design procedure based on the CCD design method is “deemed to satisfy.” The harmonization with the CEB task force leads to the hope that future fib recommendations and Eurocodes will be in close agreement with the new ACI approach.
43
7. References 1. Fuchs, W., Eligehausen, R., and Breen, J., Concrete Capacity Design (CCD) Approach for Fastening to Concrete. ACI Structural Journal, 92(1), Jan.-Feb., 1995, pp. 73-93. 2. American Institute of Steel Construction (1986). Manual of Steel Construction – Load and Resistance Factor Design. 3. Eligehausen, R., and Balogh, T., Behavior of Fasteners Loaded in Tension in Cracked Reinforced Concrete, ACI Structural Journal, 92(3), May-June 1995, pp. 365-379. 4. ACI Committee 355, ACI Provisional Standard 355.2-00, Evaluating the Performance of Post-Installed Mechanical Anchors in Concrete, American Concrete Institute, Detroit, MI. 5. Comité Euro-International du Béton (1994). Fastenings to Concrete and Masonry Structures – State of the Art Report. Thomas Telford Services Ltd., London. 6. ACI Committee 318, Proposed Changes to Building Code Requirements for Structural Concrete, scheduled to be published in June 2001 edition of Concrete International. 7. Eligehausen, R., Fuchs, W., and Mayer, B., Load Bearing Behavior of Anchor Fastenings in Tension. Betonwerk + Fertigteiltechnik, 12(87), pp. 826-832, and 1/88, pp. 29-35. 8. Eligehausen, R., and Fuchs, W., Load Bearing Behavior of Anchor Fastenings under Shear, Combined Tension and Shear or Flexural Loadings. Betonwerk + Fertigteiltechnik, 2(88), pp. 48-56. 9. International Code Council, International Building Code 2000, Falls Church, Virginia, March 2000. 10. Proposed year 2000 revisions to the 1997 edition of the NEHRP (National Earthquake Hazards Reduction Program) Recommended Provisions for Seismic Regulations for New Buildings and Other Structures, Federal Emergency Management Agency 302, Building Seismic Safety Council, Washington, DC, 1997.
44
EVOLUTION OF FASTENING DESIGN METHODS IN EUROPE Werner Fuchs Institute of Construction Materials, University of Stuttgart, Germany
Abstract Since antiquity there has been a demand for more flexibility in the planning, design and strengthening of concrete structures in Europe. Although a wide variety of fastening systems have been invented over the years to help achieve this goal, our understanding of the behavior of these systems and the corresponding development of design provisions has only in the past three decades made significant advances. This paper gives a brief overview of the evolution of fastener design. Emphasis is placed on the importance of understanding the physics behind these problems and the need for a unified design approach throughout Europe.
1. Foreword Stability, durability and aesthetics have always been primary concerns for buildings. These requirements have been equally important for fastening technology. In the 1st century B.C., Vitruvius described in his 10 books on architecture practical solutions for fastening applications. It can be assumed that fasteners played an important role in the construction of the Colosseum in Rome as evidenced by the ruins (Fig. 1). At many other excavation sites in Europe traces similar fastening devices have been found. At the beginning of the 20th century, the common thinking of the master builder with regard to fastening technology was: "leave well-enough alone". That is to say, use what has been proven to work. Consequently, fastening technology was restricted for many centuries to grouting or cast-in situ installation of steel parts. This dogma was thrown into turmoil as new construction methods were developed such as mixed constructions from concrete and steel or concrete and wood which placed higher demands on fastening technology. For the fulfillment of these tasks, new solutions in the fastening technology such as post-installed fasteners were provided.
45
Figure 1: Colosseum, Rome The diversity of products increased with the number of possible applications of fastening devices. For the user in the practice, it became difficult to find the correct fastening solution and to design safe connections. It became apparent that guidelines to aid in the design of structures using fastening systems was necessary.
2. Introduction The push over the last two decades to reduce construction duration has brought about increased use of fasteners for the transfer of concentrated loads in concrete structures. Various types of fastenings, such as cast-in-place headed anchors, as well as postinstalled mechanical and chemical fastening systems, are available to meet a wide range of strength and application requirements. Furthermore, installation techniques have been developed for certain fastening systems, which have features that can be tailored to fit special construction situations and offer added constructability and productivity advantages. These advances have been brought about through extensive scientific work and today myriad prequalified, quality controlled products with demonstrated repeatable performance characteristics meet the ever increasing demand for safe and secure fastening products in a wide field of applications. This paper surveys fastener design techniques from past to present. It illustrates how fastenings were historically used to meet project demands and the progress of products for new applications. Some developments in building design codes are also highlighted. The review focuses primarily on developments in Europe, however, similar trends can be observed in other parts of the world.
46
3. Basic principles Plutarch (45-125 A.D.) reported that the building contractors who promise quality construction and fast execution, with the lowest costs, will receive the contract for the erection of a building. The trade-offs between quality, costs and deadlines have apparently existed for millenniums and are still valid today for the discipline of structural fastening technology. As the use of fasteners has increased in recent years, so has the need to ensure their correct use on site. Faced with a bewildering multitude of fastening systems, the first question one must ask one's self is: 'Which kind of fastening type is most appropriate for my application?'. The second question is: 'How do I use it to achieve its maximum effect?'. This work is the domain of the engineer. The best design method and the most careful design by engineer, however, are of no use if the fastening device specified by the designer does not function reliably or is not installed properly. The factors influencing the successful design of connections are illustrated in Figure 2. reliable fastening systems
satisfying design provisions
designer (accurate design)
installer (proper installation)
safe, economical, aesthetically pleasing connection
Figure 2: Success factors for connections It goes without saying that connections for safety relevant applications where fastening devices are used, should be planned and designed by experienced personnel. Reproducible calculations and drawings must be done. The fastening installation has to be carried out by properly trained workers. Reliable connections based on reliable fasteners and appropriate design procedures may be ensured only by cooperation of both: the designer and the installer. One should never lose sight of the fact that proper connection design and application are vital for the overall performance of a structure.
47
4. Evolution of fastening systems As the development of new and innovative products in fastening technology has gained pace, design provisions have become considerably more accurate, more transparent and unfortunately, more time consuming. In Figure 3 the load-bearing principles of three commonly used fasteners are shown. Load transfer through mechanical interlock by anchor heads (Fig. 3a)) and grouting or glueing of steel parts to the base material (Fig. 3c)) are very old techniques. In the past the design of such fastening elements was based mainly on trial and error. Failure was to be avoided at all costs and it was for this reason that the fasteners were overdesigned in most applications. This poor engineering was due to a lack of understanding of the behavior of fasteners.
N
a)
N
N
N
b)
c)
Fig. 3: Load-bearing principles of fastening elements a) mechanical interlock (direct) b) expansion (friction) c) grouting, glueing (bond, shear) In 1920 a new era in fastening technique began, when John Rawlings applied a time tested scientific principle as a means of making fasteners. Namely, he used the principle of expansion (Fig. 3b)) to develop the first expansion anchors (Fig. 4). When a screw was turned into a threaded plug, the product expanded and tightly griped the side of the hole that had been made for it. The result was that the plug and screw become securely fixed. This invention immediately gained public favor for small fastener dimensions. It was not until the 1960's, however, that the real break-through for post-installed fasteners occurred: This was when the first electric compact hammer-drill tools were launched to the construction market. It became possible to drill large holes into concrete in a reasonable period of time. At about the same time the first post-installed glass-capsule
48
type adhesive anchors became available to the construction market and increased the range of applications for post-installed fastening systems. The use of post-installed anchors for structural applications began to soar, and today a big variety of fastening systems classified in cast-in situ fasteners and post-installed fasteners with different load-bearing principles are known and used in virtually every country of the world. The need for reliable design provisions taking into account the load-bearing principles is evident.
Fig. 4: One of the first expansion anchors
5. Development of design concepts Fastener design provisions must account for several influencing factors. For example they must consider the type of fastener, its load-bearing mechanism, fastener material, fastener diameter, edge distance, anchor spacing, concrete strength, embedment depth, as well as for the conditions of the base material (cracked or non-cracked concrete), the type of loading and the loading direction. Early on there was little known about the parameters mentioned above. The designer, liable for his work with his fortune and perhaps even his life, had to design according to experience and gut feeling. Therefore, he may have used lower levels of safety in design for non-structural applications and more demanding safety levels for particularly sensitive structural connections. With the development of post-installed fasteners this situation changed. It was necessary to promote new products and to convince the engineering community of their performance. The design of early post-installed fasteners was primarily based on test results. Tensile loading was thought to be the most critical application. Therefore, values obtained from static, short-duration tests with single fastenings under tensile loading were published as technical data in most manufacturers' product information brochures. The producers recommended to apply a global safety factor 4 ≤ γ ≤ 5 to the mean ultimate load of the tests to account for variations e.g. in concrete, steel and fastening reliability. For non-standard applications the designer had to refer to his own experience and limited common knowledge. Until about 1970, no guidelines or standards for fastener testing and evaluation were available. Testing was conducted based on an individual laboratories' experience or
49
according to the manufacturers' recommendations. It became apparent that depending on the testing laboratory, the same product could end up with different load-bearing behavior, ultimate capacity and consequently, a different recommended allowable load. The need for harmonization of testing and evaluation procedures became obvious. In response to several, in part severe accidents mainly due to improper use and installation of post-installed fasteners, an expert committee 'Channel bars and dowels' was set up in Berlin, Germany in 1972 to refine the application of fasteners to allow for greater safety and durability. Thus began the first true research work in fastening technology with the goal of understanding the influence of the test methods on the fastening systems. The focus was on the most common case of predominantly static loading. The investigations yielded testing guidelines. The experimental program included tensile tests and shear tests far away from edges. Furthermore, the experience from a large number of fastener tests showed that the load-bearing capacity of the fasteners approximates a normal Gaussian probability density function. This allowed for the use of statistical evaluation techniques, which could relate the allowable load to the reliability of the connection. Thus, design could be defined based on the 5%-fractile with a global safety factor γ = 3 for concrete failure and γ =1.75 for steel failure. The minimum strength after evaluation was taken as the allowable load for each load condition: tension, shear and combined tension and shear loading. Acceptable quality levels were defined and the era of approved fastening systems began. The design was founded on experimental results, corresponding evaluation method and allowable loads for certain applications. In addition it became necessary to the manufacturer to shown by internal (plant) and external quality control (testing agency), that the product samples used in the approval tests are conform with of the products marketed. Only fastening systems which were approved were permitted for use in safety relevant applications. In 1975 the first approvals for post-installed expansion and bonded anchors as single fastenings with large edge distances and anchor spacings for applications in non-cracked concrete were released. Both the admissible loads and the fields of application were limited, however, and not in accordance with practical requirements. This is illustrated by the technical data of a sleeve type expansion anchor M 12 with an embedment depth hef = 80 mm: The allowable load in non-cracked concrete C20/25 was 5.7 kN at a minimum edge distance c1 = 130 mm, a minimum distance to the corner c1 = c2 = 180 mm and the minimum anchor spacing s = 450 mm. As our knowledge of the behavior of structural fasteners increased the range of applications regulated by German approvals was extended. Approvals were granted for double fastenings with post-installed anchors in non-cracked concrete (1978) and for single fasteners with expansion anchors in cracked concrete (1979). Then, the allowable load for an expansion anchor M 12 situated in cracked concrete was just 1.5 kN.
50
In the mid 1970's, the headed stud industry in the United States intensified testing and supported the development of the first design methods for applications in non-cracked concrete only [9]. The nominal tensile capacity of an anchor governed by concrete failure was assumed to be computed by the maximum concrete tensile strength acting equally distributed on the surface of an idealized truncated conical failure surface (Fig. 5). The inclination of the concrete break.-out surface was assumed to 45 degrees. The design of fastenings under shear loads was based on similar assumptions of the failure mechanism. Because this design approach was conceptually simple and in satisfactory agreement with the limited test results available at this time, it was adopted by ACI 349 [10]. Due to the lack of design aids for cast-in parts, the ACI 349 design method was often used by designers in Europe.
Fig. 5: Concrete tensile capacity of a headed stud [10] In the beginning of the '80s, comprehensive research in fastening technology started in Germany. The first physical models explaining the behavior and failure of different fastening systems were developed [4]. These models lead to the so-called κ-method for the design of fastenings (Fig. 6). The main research focus was on the load-bearing principles of mechanical interlock and the mechanics of anchor expansion (Fig. 3a, b). In 1983, the first approval incorporating the κ-method was published for cast-in-place headed studs in non-cracked and cracked concrete. In 1985 followed approvals, also based on the κ-method, for mechanical post-installed anchorage systems for use as fastenings in the tensile and compressive zones of slab-type and beam-type concrete and reinforced concrete structural members. Fasteners were placed in load classes according to their anchorage depth (Fig. 7). Fastening in the tensile zone (i.e. cracked concrete)
51
was regarded as the normal case. The permissible load in the compression zone (noncracked concrete) was about 1.33 times the value in the tension zone. The higher allowable loads in the compression zone could be used for design, if in each individual case it was shown, that the anchors were installed in a concrete member, which is under compression over the full embedment depth of the fastener. Then, for the example of an expansion anchor M12, installed to concrete C20/25, the admissible load in cracked concrete might be 6 kN (compare to 1.5 kN in 1979), in non-cracked concrete 9 kN (compare to 5.7 kN in 1975), the minimum edge distance c1 = 120 mm, a minimum distance to the corner c1 = c2 = 120 mm and the minimum anchor spacing s = 80 mm.
Fig. 6: κ-method for fastenings according to German approvals [6] The κ-method represented a significant advance in the design methods given in approval documents up until this point, which – with a few exceptions – were applicable only to single anchors in the compressive zone with large anchor spacing and edge distances. The κ-method permitted to determine the admissible load of a single anchor and of an anchor in a double or quadruple fastening far from and close to an edge. The admissible load for a fixture is calculated from the admissible load of an individual anchor located at considerable distance from other anchors and from an edge of a structural member by multiplication with coefficients κ (Fig. 6). The values for the admissible load of the individual anchor, the critical anchor spacings and edge distances, that prevent adjacent anchors from interacting with each other as well as the minimum spacings and distances were stated in the approval documents. However the κ-method of the German approvals still had the disadvantage, that the minimum of the capacities under shear and tensile
52
loading evaluated from test results regardless of the mode of failure was taken as the admissible load of the fastener for each load direction, i.e. the admissible load represented the most unfavorable case.
Fig. 7: Load classes for mechanical anchors in cracked concrete [6] In the mid '80s, approvals for mechanical expansion anchors were released by SOCOTEC in France, which allowed higher loads and a wider range of applications than given in the German approvals. The basematerial used to establish these approvals, however, was non-cracked concrete. The admissible loads for each product were derived directly from experimental results. Since the French system did not use load classes, allowable anchor loads were dependent on scatter of concrete strength and on the testing methods of the testing institute, where proof testing was performed. In other countries where no approval system existed the designer had to rely on information provided by the manufacturers. Most of these published data were based on fastener testing. The manufacturers believed that determining the ultimate or allowable loads for fasteners from 'theoretical (i.e. calculation) methods' e.g. the κ-method would not give satisfactory results because of the interrelationships of the many variables involved e.g. material strength, friction coefficients, etc.. Hilti developed a design concept very similar to the κ-method also taking into account product specific characteristics. In some cases even different sizes of a single product had different tuning factors. Furthermore, the Hilti design method distinguished between load
53
directions and in this respect was superior to the κ-method of the German approvals at this time. The various efforts to develop new design provisions reflected the increased need and demand to design reliable connections with cast-in-place and post-installed anchors at reasonable costs. Further improvements were necessary. The German design concept of one admissible load for all directions could be presented in a very simple form, however, it resulted in many cases in a considerable underestimation of the load-carrying capacity of the fastening. For reasons of economy, it was desired to optimally utilize the capacity of anchor-type fastenings in most applications. Thus it was necessary to develop a more application oriented approach. The first steps in this direction are documented in [6, 7 and 8]. In these documents expanded κmethods for the computation of concrete break-out failure of post-installed mechanical expansion and undercut anchors as well as cast-in-place headed studs under tension, shear and combined tension and shear loading fracture mechanics theory are explained in detail. Fracture mechanics indicated that the failure load increases less than the available concrete break-out failure surface. That means the nominal stress at failure (peak load divided by failure area) decreases. Furthermore, corresponding to widespread observations in tests, the κ-method is based on 35 degrees concrete break-out cones. Note, these are major differences to the ACI 349 design approach. It was determined that an improved design method should distinguish between different directions of loading, modes of failure and condition of the base material (cracked or non-cracked). In addition, modern design recommendations should consider all available test data and differences among already existing recommendations should be analyzed and reconciled. This task was performed at the University of Stuttgart and during the visit of the author to the Structural Engineering Laboratory at the University of Texas, Austin in 1990-1991. During his visit the European and North American test data for cast-in-place and post-installed mechanical fasteners were assembled and integrated into a database to facilitate comparison studies with different design approaches. Furthermore, the κ-method to predict concrete capacity was adapted to make the design process more transparent and user friendly by implementing a rectangular prism model (Fig. 8). The combination of the accuracy of the κ-method and the transparency analogous to the ACI 349 cone model yielded the Concrete Capacitymethod (CC-method). The CC-method not only improved computation for design with fasteners, it also helped to increase the accuracy of the computed fastener capacity in comparison to design provisions using test results. Detailed results of the comprehensive studies leading to the development of the CC-method are given in [11]. A summary is published in [1].
54
The critical edge distance for headed studs, headed bolts, expansion anchors, and undercut anchors is 1.5hef . 1.5 hef
1.5hef
1.5 hef
1.5hef
≈ 35° h ef
1.5hef
1.5hef
Section through failure cone Plan view
A No = 2 * 1.5 h ef × 2 * 1.5 h ef = 3 h ef × 3 h ef = 9 h ef2
Fig. 8: Concrete cone surface idealized by a 35° prism, according to CC-method [11] To predict the capacity of other failure modes, such as steel failure, additional design models may be used. The pull-out capacity for typical cast-in-place headed studs has proven to be predictabe by calculation. Post-installed anchors on the other hand do not have predictable pullout failure loads and therefore they must be tested. Tests are also necessary to determine the minimum concrete member dimensions, minimum spacing and edge distances of fasteners to avoid a splitting failure. These values are characteristic of a product and are given in approvals or technical data sheets of the manufacturers. In 1987, in order to improve the design methods, the general knowledge and the awareness of the engineering profession in this area, the formation of Task Group III/5 (TG III/5) with members from academia, practice and producers from Asia, Europe and North America was authorized by the Comité Euro-International du Béton (CEB, now fib). One of the TG III/5's first major tasks was providing test data to support the author in the construction of a data base of European fastener tests at the University of Stuttgart. Until 1991, the group produced a state-of-the-art report on fastenings to concrete and masonry, first published as CEB Bulletins 206 and 207. A revised hardcover edition was published in 1994 [5]. Therein the revised safety concept for the design of fastenings based on partial safety factors was introduced to Europe.
55
In the new safety concept it has to be shown that the value of the design actions Sd does not exceed the value of the design resistance Rd. (1)
Sd < Rd Sd Rd
= =
value of design action value of design resistance
The partial safety factors for the actions depend on the type of loading and shall be calculated according to Eurocode 2 or Eurocode 3. The partial safety factors for the resistances cover steel failure, concrete cone failure, splitting failure and pull-out failure. Furthermore, the partial safety factor γ2, which indicates the sensitivity of a fastening system to installation inaccuracy, was introduced. It is determined as part of the proof testing in so-called suitability tests and may not be changed because it describes a characteristic of the fastening system. The partial safety factors can be found in the relevant approvals. In 1993, stimulated by these results, DIBt (Deutsches Institut für Bautechnik) replaced the traditional κ-method with the new CC-method and the new safety concept for postinstalled mechanical fasteners [12]. Cracked concrete still was assumed the normal state of the base material. In 1995 in Germany the first approvals based on this new design concept were released for headed studs and mechanical post-installed fasteners suitable for applications in cracked concrete. Compared to 1985, with regard to tensile loading nothing has changed. However, now the admissible shear load in cracked concrete C20/25 is 14,9 kN (compare to 6 kN in 1985). At the same time throughout Europe harmonized test regimes were developed to create data necessary to fit the new design concept and to prequalify the products for safety relevant applications. In 1995, the CEB TG III/5 published a comprehensive design method for cast-in-place headed anchors and mechanical post-installed fasteners in concrete based on the CC-method in CEB Bulletin No. 226, released as a revised hardcover edition in 1997 [13]. This approach to the design of mechanical anchors forms the basis for current design codes in Europe and the United States. It was adopted by EOTA in ETAG 001, Appendix C [14] in 1997. According to ETAG the design resistance is based on the performance of a specific product demonstrated in prequalification tests following the ETAG directive [14]. Corresponding to the type and number of tests, three different design methods are proposed. The relation between the design methods and the required tests is given in Table 1. The design method to be applied is given in the relevant European Technical Approval (ETA) of the product concerned. In design method A the characteristic resistance is calculated for all load directions and failure modes. It must be shown that Equation (1) is satisfied for all loading directions
56
(tension, shear, combined tension and shear), as well as all failure modes (steel failure, pull-out failure and concrete failure). To design the anchorage the loads acting on each anchor shall be calculated, taking into account partial safety factors.
Table 1: Design methods and required tests according to ETAG [14] Design method
cracked and noncracked concrete
A
x x
non-cracked concrete only
characteristic resistance for C 20/25 only
x x x
B
x x
x x
x x x x
C
C 20/25 to C 50/60 x
x x
x x
x x x x
x x
tests according ETAG Annex B, Option 1 2 7 8 3 4 9 10 5 6 11 12
Design method B is based on a simplified approach in which the design value of the characteristic resistance is considered to be independent of the loading direction and the mode of failure. In the case of anchor groups, the design is performed for the most highly stressed anchor. Design method C is based on a simplified approach in which only one value for the design resistance FRd is given, independent of loading direction and mode of failure. The actual spacing and edge distance must be equal to or larger than the characteristic values given in the relevant ETA specifications. With this combination of testing guidelines and design models EOTA was able to publish approvals for mechanical fasteners that are valid in the whole European community. This means that for a product with an ETA there are uniform technical data for Europe. This is a significant improvement from the old situation, where different national approvals and manufacturers' recommendations showed different technical data and fields of application for the same product. Furthermore, it is now easier to compare similar products. Trade barriers have been removed and since establishment of the first ETA in 1998, engineers can now design with fastenings almost without problems Europe wide. Today about 30 ETAs for different types of mechanical post-installed fasteners exist.
57
In accordance with European agreement after a transition period of 33 months after the publication of an ETAG , national approvals in the areas covered by an ETAG, are not allowed. For the first ETAGs the transition period takes longer i.e. for the ETAGs P.1 to P. 4 the deadline is June 2002. Since the establishment of the new design recommendations for mechanical anchors, in the mid 1990's the efforts of the CEB TG III/5 have been directed to channel bars and adhesive anchors. Channel bar and adhesive anchor design is still based mainly on knowledge from the 1980's. It is performed according to national regulations and recommendations of the manufacturers. It is hoped that design methods compatible with the CC-method can be formulated for these systems as well in the future. Work in this direction have already begun. It is under discussion in the now fib Task Group and is expected to be finalized within the next year. In 2000, the new Working Group of CEN/TC250/SC2 'Design of Fastenings' was given the task of coming up with a new Eurocode covering 'Design of Fastenings for Use in Concrete'. The Working Group plans to include the existing design provisions for mechanical anchors and the soon to be completed design provisions for adhesive anchors and channel bars under static and fatigue loading [15]. Earthquake loading will not be covered in this document due to lack of published research. A key element in the design philosophy will be that fasteners and fastening systems must be prequalified using performance criteria described in ETAG, stated by a European Technical Approval (ETA) or relevant Eurocode (EN).
6. Conclusion The first documentation of the use of fastenings to concrete was provided by Vitruvius over 2000 years ago. Up until the mid 20th Century, engineers were still designing fastening systems according to experience and gut feeling – often with huge safety factors thrown in for good measure. This situation changed dramatically with the development of hammer-drill tools and innovative post-installed fastening systems. The urgent need for the detailed understanding of the working principles of fasteners increased. In the last two decades very comprehensive research programs were undertaken to consolidate existing knowledge and significantly extend the general knowledge in the field of fastening technology. The efforts allowed the design of fastenings to be based on physical understanding. This allowed for the development of universal design models and their international application. Optimal utilization of anchor capacity in all applications under static loading using castin headed studs and mechanical metal anchors is possible by the existing CC-method. More recently, research efforts have been directed towards the design of grouted and
58
bonded (adhesive) anchors. A design method compatible with the CC-method can be formulated for these systems and is under consideration in Europe. Additionally, the design of cast-in-place channel bars following the principles of the CC-method, has been undertaken and is nearly finalized. The design of anchors for earthquake loading continues to be a focus of research and will hopefully be addressed in future codes. It is known that the load-bearing behavior of fasteners can be enhanced by properly detailed local reinforcement. Such enhancement can be included in future design provisions a s well as the resistance of fasteners under seismic load. To conclude, today fastening systems are reliable, economical and satisfy many needs in construction practice. However, it is important to keep in mind that even the most expensive fastenings form a nearly negligible part of the total cost of a building, and a failure can damage property and endanger lives. Connections - their accurate design and correct application - are vital to the performance of the building!
7. Acknowledgements The author wishes to express special thanks to Dr. Schätzle (fischerwerke), Dr. Arndt and Dr. Pusill-Wachtsmuth (Hilti), Mr. Tschositsch (Unibautechnik) as well as Mr. Frischmann and Mr. Zimmermann (UPAT) who provided brochures, technical data and product information that were needed to give a historical background. Special thanks are also accorded to Matthew Hoehler who spent many hours in reviewing the paper.
8. References 1.
2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7.
Fuchs, W., Eligehausen, R., and Breen, J.E., Concrete Capacity Design (CCD) Approach for Fastening to Concrete. ACI Structural Journal, 92(1), Jan.-Feb., 1995, pp. 73-93. Marsh, P., Fixings, Fasteners and Adhesives, Site Practice Series, Construction Press, London, New York, 1984. Maass, G., Bauwerksdübel, Werner-Verlag, Düsseldorf, 1987. Eligehausen, R., Pusill-Wachtsmuth, P., Stand der Befestigungstechnik im Stahlbetonbau. IVBH Bericht S-19/82, IVBH-Periodica 1/1982, Februar 1982. Comité Euro-International du Béton. Fastenings to Concrete and Masonry Structures – State of the Art Report. Thomas Telford Services Ltd., London, 1994. Eligehausen, R., Design of Fastenings with Steel Anchors – Future Concept. Betonwerk + Fertigteiltechnik, 5(88), pp. 88-100. Eligehausen, R., Fuchs, W., and Mayer, B., Load Bearing Behavior of Anchor Fastenings in Tension. Betonwerk + Fertigteiltechnik, 12(87), pp. 826-832, and 1/88, pp. 29-35.
59
8.
9. 10. 11.
12. 13. 14.
15.
Eligehausen, R., and Fuchs, W., Load Bearing Behavior of Anchor Fastenings under Shear, Combined Tension and Shear or Flexural Loadings. Betonwerk + Fertigteiltechnik, 2(88), pp. 48-56. Cannon, R.W., Burdette, E.G., Funk, R.R., Anchorage to Concrete, Tennessee Valley Authority, Knoxville, Dec. 1975. ACI 349-76, Code Requirements for Nuclear Safety Related Concrete Structures, American Concrete Institute, Detroit, 1976. Fuchs, W., Entwicklung eines Vorschlags für die Bemessung von Befestigungen (Development of a Proposal for the Design of Fastenings to Concrete), Report to the DFG, Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft, Bonn, February 1991. Deutsches Institut für Bautechnik (DIBt), Bemessungsverfahren für Dübel zur Verankerung in Beton, DIBt, Berlin, 1993. Comité Euro-International du Béton. Design of Fastenings to Concrete. Thomas Telford Services Ltd., London, 1997. European Organisation for Technical Approvals (EOTA), ETAG, Guideline for European Technical Approval of Metal Anchors for Use in Concrete, P. 1: Anchors in General, P. 2: Torque-controlled Expansion Anchors, P. 3: Undercut Anchors, P. 4: Deformation-controlled Expansion Anchors, P. 5: Bonded Anchors, Annex A: Details of Tests, Annex B: Tests for Admissible Service Conditions – Detailed Information, Annex C: Design Methods for Anchorages, European Organisation for Technical Approvals, Brussels, 1997-2001. CEN/TC 250/SC/WG 2 'Design of Fastenings', Design of Fastenings for Use in Concrete, 1st Draft, Brussels, 2001.
60
PROBABILISTIC CALIBRATION OF DESIGN METHODS Richard E. Klingner Dept. of Civil Engineering, The University of Texas at Austin, USA
Abstract In this paper, basic steps in the probabilistic calibration of design methods are identified. These include identification and evaluation of test data; comparison of design models with test data; evaluation of safety in the context of an overall design approach; and final development of code language. Challenges to the success of each step are described, and means of overcoming those challenges are suggested. Finally, calibration is shown to be an ongoing process, one of whose benefits is to suggest areas in which additional research would be particularly cost-effective.
1. Introduction This Symposium, had it been held a decade earlier, would have been quite different. At that time, many of the world’s researchers on anchor behavior were divided into two camps, which, if not opposing, certainly had different perspectives on how to design anchorage to concrete. Those different perspectives had been developed by technical committees of the Comité Euro-International du Beton in Europe, and the American Concrete Institute in the USA. In Europe, a broad-based and reasonably coordinated technical community, tied on many levels to the University of Stuttgart, was convinced of the reality of cracked concrete, and of the need to address concrete cracking in anchorage design. They were equally convinced of the potential weaknesses of traditional design methods for anchors, and of the need to develop and adopt new design methods. In the USA, an equally broad-based but much less coordinated technical community was beginning to examine these same issues. Instead of a single Eurocode, though, we had a bewildering array of manufacturers’ recommendations, consensus resource documents,
61
and model codes, which agreed with each other only on the broadest issues, and were sometimes in direct conflict. The past 10 years have witnessed a remarkable convergence of technical understanding among Europe, the USA, and other countries around the world with respect to design of anchorage to concrete. Most modern design provisions for anchors admit the possibility of cracked concrete, and require that anchor designs have reasonably consistent levels of safety. In a most important sense, this convergence is the result of tremendous work by individuals who believed that a connection to concrete should behave in the same manner whether it is designed and built (for example) in Austin, Texas, or in Stuttgart, Germany. Several key steps in that convergence depended on the successful probabilistic calibration of design methods. That is the subject of this paper.
1. Basic Steps in the Probabilistic Calibration of Design Methods The probabilistic calibration of design methods can be discussed in terms of the following steps: o o o o
identification and evaluation of test data; comparison of design models with test data; evaluation of safety in the context of an overall design approach; and final development of code language.
In the remainder of this paper, each step is described, and is illustrated by specific examples from technical committee work in the anchorage area over the past decade. Challenges to the success of each step are described, and means of overcoming those challenges are suggested, again with reference to one specific example: tensile breakout capacity.
2. Background for Specific Examples Design codes are not intended to predict behavior. Rather, they are intended to enable practicing engineers to produce designs that are sufficiently safe. Nevertheless, if design codes are to be more than empirical expressions of what has worked before, their design equations must be linked to engineering mechanics and physical reality. The first linkage occurs through rational design models; the second, through comparison with test data. Let us first discuss design models, using the specific example of tensile breakout capacity. A decade ago, one particular area of controversy existed with respect to predicting the tensile breakout capacity of anchors in concrete. Many designers in the USA and elsewhere used the 45-Degree Cone Method, a traditional way of computing that capacity. A growing number of designers in Europe used what has now evolved into the CC Method.
62
The 45-Degree Cone Method assumes that a constant tensile stress of 4 f c′ acts on the projected area of a 45-degree cone radiating towards the free surface from the bearing edge of the anchor (Figure 1). T
2hef+dh
45º
dh
Figure 1
Tensile breakout cone as idealized by 45-degree Cone Method
For a single tensile anchor far from edges, the mean cone breakout capacity is determined by:
(
To = 0.96 f c′ π hef2 1 + d h hef where: To f c′ dh hef
= = = =
)
N
(1)
tensile breakout capacity (kN); specified concrete compressive cylinder strength (MPa); diameter of anchor head (mm); and effective embedment (mm).
Breakout capacity is reduced by edges or adjacent anchors as a function of the reduction in area of the projection of the breakout cone on the free surface. The CC Method [1] computes the mean concrete breakout capacity of a single tensile anchor far from edges as:
To = k fc′ hef1.5
(3)
where: To = tensile breakout capacity (kN); k = constant; equal to 13.48 for expansion and sleeve anchors, 15 for undercut and headed anchors, in SI units; f′c = specified concrete compressive strength (6 in. × 12 in. cylinder) (MPa);
63
hef = effective embedment depth (mm). In the CC Method, the breakout body is in effect idealized as a pyramid with an inclination of about 35 degrees between the failure surface and the concrete member surface (Figure 2). Breakout capacity is reduced by edges or adjacent anchors as a function of the reduction in area of the projection of the breakout pyramid on the free surface. Other modification factors are used as well. 3hef 3hef
h
ef
35º
Figure 2
Tensile breakout body as idealized by CC Method
3. Identification and Evaluation of Test Data A decade ago, technical discussion of the relative merits of the 45-Degree Cone Method and the CC Method for predicting tensile breakout was complicated by the fact that there was no consensus database of test results that could be used as a standard. Proponents of each method referred to separate sets of test data. To cut through that Gordian knot, Dr. Werner Fuchs, during a stay as a Visiting Researcher at The University of Texas at Austin, began to assemble such a database. He identified original test reports from all over the world; he placed each tensile test in a common framework of units (both US customary and SI); and most important, he began the process of evaluating each test result to distinguish those tests governed by steel failure, from those governed by pullout, and from those governed by concrete breakout. His original work was done in DOS. Since then, the database that he began has been converted into Excel, has been expanded to include many more tests, and has been even more extensively studied [2, 3, 4]. It is in the public domain, and is maintained by ACI Committee 349 (Subcommittee 3) and ACI Committee 355. The database for tensile breakout behavior in uncracked concrete under static load now numbers almost 1600 tests, partitioned into shallow and deep embedment, absence or presence of edge effects, and absence or presence of adjacent anchors. For cracked
64
concrete, dynamic loading, or combinations of these, statistically significant number of tests (for example, 50 to 200) are available in several categories.
4. Comparison of Design Models with Test Data The next step is to evaluate each design model with respect to the consensus database of tensile breakout results. In the case of models for predicting tensile breakout capacity, the required steps are as follows: 1) For each failure mode, ratios of tested capacity to that predicted by the design provisions are computed. The ratios are plotted as a function of embedment depth. 2) The resulting plots are evaluated, using the criteria that an ideal design method should have: a) no systematic error (that is, no variation in ratios with changes in embedment depth); b) high precision (that is, little scatter of data); and c) appropriate conservatism, achieved by a combination of normalizing criteria for the design equation (mean versus lower fractile), load factors, and φ-factors. Examples of those plots are given in Figure 3 and Figure 4, for single tensile anchors with shallower embedments, for the CC Method and the 45-Degree Cone method respectively. Both methods have been normalized so that they predict approximately the mean capacity from test results. The implications of this normalization are discussed in more detail later in this paper. Comparison of those figures shows that the CC Method has little systematic error (that is, almost zero slope), high precision (that is, relatively low dispersion), and appropriate conservatism (mean values close to unity for this normalization). In contrast, the 45-Degree Cone Method, while at least as conservative, has high systematic error and lower precision.
65
RATIOS OF OBSERVED TO PREDICTED CAPACITIES, CC METHOD, SHALLOWER EMBEDMENTS 3.5 y = 0.0009x + 0.9097
Mean = 0.981 COV = 0.197
3
(Nobs/Npre)
2.5 2 1.5 1 0.5 0 0
50
100
150
200
Effective Embedment, mm
Figure 3
Ratios of observed to predicted tensile breakout capacities, CC Method, single anchors with shallow embedment RATIOS OF OBSERVED TO PREDICTED CAPACITIES, 45-DEGREE CONE METHOD, SHALLOWER EMBEDMENTS, NO EDGE EFFECTS
3.5 3
Mean = 1.356 COV = 0.266
(Nobs/Npre)
2.5 2 1.5 1 0.5
y = -0.0059x + 1.8074 0 0
50
100
150
200
Effective Embedment, mm
Figure 4
Ratios of observed to predicted concrete tensile breakout capacities, 45Degree Cone Method, single anchors with shallow embedment
66
Plots such as these immediately indicate how to improve a given design method. Downward-trending systematic error, as in the case of the 45-Degree Cone Method, indicates that as embedments increase, the ratios of observed to predicted capacity tend to decrease. This means that as embedments increase, predicted capacities are too high, and it implies that the exponent of the embedment (equal to 2.0 in the case of the 45Degree Cone Method) should be reduced to a value between 1.5 and 1.6.
5. Evaluation of Safety in the Context of an Overall Design Approach The next step is to compare the safety that will result from the use of different design models, in the context of a particular overall design approach. For example, as in the work of Farrow et al. [2, 3] and Shirvani [4], using each tensile breakout method, and a probabilistic analysis based on the design framework of ACI 349-90 Appendix B [5], the probabilities of failure under known loads, and the probabilities of brittle failure independent of load, are evaluated for each method. Any probabilistic evaluation of safety faces several daunting challenges: o o
many design professionals are suspicious of probabilities; and many design professionals are unfamiliar with probabilistic tools.
For example, referring to Figure 3 and Figure 4, many design professionals, while recognizing that the 45-Degree Cone Method has greater dispersion than the CC Method for shallow embedments, would intuitively think that this greater dispersion would be compensated for by the former’s higher ratios of observed to predicted capacity, leading to approximately equivalent levels of safety for each method. This in fact is not the case. In spite of the higher conservatism of the 45-Degree Cone Method, its greater dispersion makes it less safe than the CC Method. Experience has demonstrated that while very few technical committee members (including this author) have the formal mathematical background to compute probabilities of failure in closed form, most feel reasonably comfortable with approximating probabilities of failure by Monte Carlo analysis, for which tools such as Schneider [6] are readily available and reasonably user-friendly. Monte Carlo analysis has the additional advantage of being practical when a design method involves complex logic with many possible branches. Using an assumed statistical distribution of loads, and known distributions of the ratios between observed and predicted strengths as governed by steel yield and fracture, and by tensile breakout, it is possible within the context of a given overall design approach, such as that of ACI 349-90 [5], to predict the probabilities of failure under given loads, or the probabilities of brittle failure independent of loads. Results of typical statistical analyses for known loads are summarized in Table 1. Higher values of β indicate lower probabilities of failure. The table shows that in most anchor categories, anchors
67
designed using the 45-Degree Cone Method to predict concrete breakout capacity, have a much higher probability of failure than if the CC Method were used. This is particularly evident for anchors with edge and group effects. Table 2 shows corresponding probabilities of brittle failure independent of load. These probabilities are essentially the probability of brittle failure if the load increases beyond the value used in design. For design against earthquakes or loads that are similarly difficult to predict, it is important to reduce the probability of brittle failure (“capacity design”). The 45-Degree Cone Method has much higher probabilities of brittle failure, than the CC Method. Table 1
Probability of failure under known loads for different categories of tensile anchors, ductile design approach, static loading, uncracked concrete CC METHOD ANCHOR CATEGORY
single anchors, shallower embedments single anchors, deeper embedments single anchors, shallower embedments, edge effects single anchors, deeper embedments, edge effects 2- and 4-anchor groups, shallower anchors, no edge effects 4-anchor groups, deeper embedments, no edge effects
45-DEG CONE METHOD Probability β of Failure 8.56E-04 3.14 1.99E-03 2.88
Probability of Failure 5.46E-05 1.39E-05
3.87 4.19
1.92E-03
2.89
1.00E-03
3.09
1.70E-06
4.65
9.87E-04
3.09
2.23E-05
4.08
1.79E-03
2.91
5.23E-04
3.28
5.08E-04
3.29
68
β
Table 2
Probabilities of brittle failure independent of load for different categories of tensile anchors, ductile design approach, static loading, uncracked concrete CC METHOD ANCHOR CATEGORY
Probability of Brittle Failure single anchors, shallower embedments 0.178 single anchors, deeper embedments 0.088 single anchors, shallower embedments, 0.206 edge effects single anchors, deeper embedments, 0.0405 edge effects 2- and 4-anchor groups, shallower 0.107 anchors, no edge effects 4-anchor groups, deeper embedments, 0.0621 no edge effects
β
0.922 1.36 0.821
45-DEG CONE METHOD Probability β of Brittle Failure 0.066 1.51 0.369 0.335 0.198 0.848
1.75
0.717
0.573
1.24
0.125
1.15
1.54
0.273
0.603
6. Final Development of Code Language Once a design method has been agreed upon, it is necessary to decide how that method should be expressed in code language. The following questions are relevant: o o
How should the design method be normalized? How should appropriate load factors and understrength factors be derived?
Design methods can be normalized so that they predict either mean values, or some lower fractile (such as 5%). Provided that ratios of observed to predicted capacities are reasonably consistent from case to case, either normalization technique can produce equivalent levels of safety. Nevertheless, because the scatter of observed to predicted capacities varies from case to case, it is probably preferable to normalize design methods to a lower fractile of the expected capacity. It is simple to convert design models normalized on mean values, to models normalized on lower fractiles. For example, if a 5% fractile value is about 75% of the mean for the tensile breakout database, then design methods normalized to mean values can simply be multiplied by 0.75 to give the corresponding design methods normalized to 5% fractiles. For example, the leading coefficient k in the CC Method (normalized to mean values) for tensile breakout is 15 for cast-in-place and undercut anchors. If it is desired to normalize to the 5% fractile of test results, then the leading coefficient k would be 15 multiplied by that same factor of 0.75, or 11.25.
69
Probabilities of failure such as those presented in Table 1 depend on the load and understrength factors used in the overall design framework. To keep the probability of failure the same, if the load factor is increased by 10%, the understrength factor should be decreased by 10%, without any need to run additional probabilistic studies. In most cases, load factors are prescribed uniformly for all materials, and are beyond the control of those developing anchor design provisions. In such cases, it is necessary to arrive at suitable understrength factors by trial and error. In some cases, understrength factors will be constrained by practical limitations, such as being less than unity, or less than that corresponding so some other failure mode. If both load factors and understrength factors are constrained, the only possible adjustments may be in the fractile against which the design method is normalized. Finally, it is necessary to modify design methods to account for effects such as dynamic loading and cracked concrete. Modification factors for such cases are most appropriately arrived at by comparing the results of tests in which everything is held constant, except for the loading rate, or the presence of cracks.
7. Summary, Conclusions and Recommendations In this paper, essential steps in the probabilistic calibration of design methods have been identified, and examples of how challenges to those steps were successfully overcome, with reference to the particular issue of methods for predicting tensile breakout capacity. Those steps, and the methodology behind them, need to be checked against new data and new design criteria. Finally, while more research is not always needed, the methodology outlined here can be used to indicate areas in which additional research information would be particularly cost-effective.
8. References 1.
Fuchs, W., Eligehausen and R. and Breen, J. E., “Concrete Capacity Design (CCD) Approach for Fastening to Concrete”, ACI Structural Journal, Vol. 92, No. 1, January-February, 1995, pp. 73-94.
2.
Farrow, C. Ben and Klingner, R. E., “Tensile Capacity of Anchors with Partial or Overlapping Failure Surfaces: Evaluation of Existing Formulas on an LRFD Basis,” ACI Structures Journal, Vol. 92, No. 6, November-December 1995, pp. 698710.
3.
Farrow, C. Ben, Frigui, Imed and Klingner, R. E., “Tensile Capacity of Single Anchors in Concrete: Evaluation of Existing Formulas on an LRFD Basis,” ACI Structures Journal, Vol. 93, No. 1, January-February 1996.
70
4.
Shirvani, Mansour, “Behavior of Tensile Anchors in Concrete: Statistical Analysis and Design Recommendations,” M.S. Thesis, The University of Texas at Austin, May 1998.
5.
ACI Committee 349, “Code Requirements for Nuclear Safety Related Concrete Structures,” American Concrete Institute, Detroit, 1990.
6.
Schneider, Jörg, “VaP version 1.6,” Institute of Structural Engineering, Zurich, Switzerland.
71
CURRENT STATUS OF POST-INSTALLED ANCHOR APPLICATION IN JAPAN Reiji Tanaka, Faculty of Eng., Tohoku Institute of Technology, Japan
Abstract Currently about 450 million pcs. of post-installed anchors are being used annually in Japan. This report introduces the outline where and how these post-installed anchors are utilized. Japan Construction Anchor Association (JCAA) is now producing an approval system and design guide of post-installed anchors. This outline is also presented. This report aims for the comprehensive study on current status and overall picture in the near future concerning post-installed anchor application in Japan.
1. Post-installed Anchor Products Construction Anchor Association
Approval
Project
by
Japan
Japan Construction Anchor Association (JCAA) is preparing for the approval of post-installed anchors. Target products are confined to ones manufactured or sold exclusively by JCAA members. Foreign products sold by JCAA members are qualified to get approval. The initial application was accepted in January, 2001. 1.1 Product approval procedure Product approval procedure is shown in the flow chart of Table 1. 1.2 Approval Committee Approval Committee members are composed of more than 10 experts. Present chairman is Prof. Reiji Tanaka, Tohoku Institute of Technology.
72
1.3 Overall plan of product approval Followings are the outline of product approval project. Applicants Application Application receipt Receipt judgement
Notification of acceptance
Approval
Approval committee
Decision Yes/No
Notification of Yes/No
To sign the agreement
Issue of certificate
Renewal Table 1 Procedure of product approval
73
a) Target products All products which applicants wish to apply. But the secretariat will check in advance whether these products are qualified for JCAA approval. z Post-installed anchors consist of metal anchors, bonded anchors and other anchor group. z Applicants can freely select which category their products belong to. z Basically every product can be acceptable by establishing the category of other anchor group and also their criteria can be specified by self-declaration. z But at least they should have shape and form of post-installed anchors. b) Approved products 1) Approved products consist of standard type and special type. Special type is composed of Type 1 and Type 2. Standard type Approved products Type 1 Special type Type 2 The structure of approved products is shown below for metal anchor, bonded anchor and other anchor group respectively. z
Metal anchors Standard type Approved products
Type 1 Special type Type 2
z
Bonded anchors Standard type Approved products
Type 1 Special type Type 2
z
Other anchor group Type 1 Approved products
Special type Type 2
74
2) Standard type Similar to JIS standard, acceptance criteria is already available and only those that pass this criteria can be approved. Standard type has the self-regulatory feature, and has an advantage of clear quality contents for the public such as JIS standard. Also users receive the merit of exchangeability of products. This type is very important in order to show the consensus of JCAA to the public society. Some standard testing methods are available to confirm the performance in the acceptance criteria. Approval shall be given to depending on the experimental results of those testing methods. 3) Special type It is also necessary to cope with the technical development and originality of each manufacturer. The acceptance criteria of those products are self-declared by applicants. After the reliability of the self declared contents has been confirmed, approval will be granted. Though the contents of evaluation items are self-declared, the evaluation process is the same as standard type, and therefore the approval level is never damaged. Plenty of products are considered in special type, and they are classified into type 1 and type 2. It is up to the applicant to which category he wish to apply. The evaluation items should include specific ones in addition to the standard type items. These specific items are also self-declared. Type 1 is supposed to those anchors designed by the JCAA Design Guide. On the other hand, type 2 is supposed to be designed in very simple form or used without any engineering approach. Its evaluation items and evaluation methods are self-declared. For example, evaluation items can be several ones like shape, material quality, strength, etc. But the minimum information for anchor performance is necessary. Though the quantity of evaluation items may be small. their contents are carefully investigated like standard type and therefore the approval level is never damaged. As for specific evaluation items for special type, some standard testing methods will become necessary. At this time nobody knows which specific items will appear in the future, and we can not prepare all standard testing methods. But for the time being we estimate following ones: cyclic loading test (tension and shear), crack test(tension and shear), thermal effect test for bonded anchors. The name of above mentioned “standard testing method” is tentative. When some new specific items appear, we will have to consider additional standard testing methods to cope with them. For both metal anchors and bonded anchors, the next table is applied for standard type as well as specific type. For other anchor group, the rule of special type is applied.
75
Standard type Evaluation item 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15
approval standard
Approval standard is available
Special type Type 1 Type 2 Evaluation approval Evaluation approval item standard item standard 1 ** 2 ** Self3 ** declaration 4 ** 5 6 Self7 declaration 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 Specific items Selfdeclaration
z
Quality level of standard type and special type (Type 1 , Type 2) is as follows. Special type 1 > Standard type > Special type 2 z Specific items are declared by applicants. Foe example, we consider strength effect, rigidity effect, cyclic loading effect, crack effect, and thermal effect as specific items for the time being. z Evaluation items 1 through 15 of special type 1 are same as standard type. But the approval standard of special type is self-declared. z The evaluation items of special type 2 shall be selected from the counterparts of standard type 1 through 15 and self-declared. Approval standard is also self-declared. z Those anchors designed by JCAA Design Guide should belong to the category of at least standard type 4) Evaluation items and acceptance criteria Product approval is evaluated by next items. Evaluation items for metal anchors and bonded anchors are shown in Fig.2 and Fig.3 respectively.
76
Table 2 Approval items of metal anchors Approval items
1) Shape, size and tolerance of anchor parts. 2) Material of parts. 3) Strength of parts 4) Hardness and ductility of parts 5) Thread class, appearance and surface finish 2 Subjects concerning quality 6) Shape, size and tolerance before and after “set” condition. and performance of anchor 7) Drill bit diameter, drilling depth and tolerance products. 8) Product strength 9) Hardness and ductility of products 10)Base material type 11)Scope of base material design strength 12)Tensile resistance 13)Tensile rigidity 14)Shear resistance 15)Shear rigidity Table 3 Approval items of bonded anchors 1
Subjects concerning quality and performance of anchor parts.
1
Subjects concerning quality and performance of anchor parts.
2
Subjects concerning quality and performance of anchor products.
Approval items
1) Shape, size and tolerance of capsule 2) Material and strength of adhesive 3) Property of adhesive 4) Type, shape and appearance of anchor bolts 5) Material and surface finish of anchor bolts 6) Strength and thread class of anchor bolts 7) Drill bit size and tolerance 8) Drilling depth and tolerance 9) Base material type 10)Scope of design strength of base material 11)Environmental conditions 12)Tensile resistance 13)Tensile rigidity 14)Shear resistance 15)Shear rigidity
For the evaluation of approval items in Table2 and Table3, the acceptance criteria on quality/performance are given in Table4 and Table5.
77
Table 4 Quality/performance criteria of metal anchors Criteria 1 Shape, size and tolerance of anchor parts. Criteria 2 Material of parts. Criteria 3 Nominal yield strength and tensile strength of parts Criteria 4 Hardness and ductility of parts Criteria 5 Thread class, appearance and surface finish Criteria 6 Shape, size and tolerance before and after “set” condition Criteria 7 Drill bit diameter and drilling depth Criteria 8 Product material: nominal yield strength, tensile strength Criteria 9 Product material: Hardness, ductility Criteria 10 Base material type Criteria 11 Scope of design strength of base material Criteria 12 Tensile resistance Criteria 13 Tensile rigidity Criteria 14 Shear strength Criteria 15 Shear rigidity Table 5 Quality/performance criteria of bonded anchors Criteria 1 Shape, size and tolerance of capsule. Criteria 2 Material and strength of adhesive. Criteria 3 Mechanical property of adhesive Criteria 4 Type, shape and appearance of anchor bolts Criteria 5 Material and surface finish of anchor bolt Criteria 6 Strength and thread class of anchor bolts Criteria 7 Drill bit diameter and drilling depth Criteria 8 Drilling depth and tolerance Criteria 9 Base material type Criteria 10 Scope of design strength of base material Criteria 11 Environmental condition Criteria 12 Tensile resistance Criteria 13 Tensile rigidity Criteria 14 Shear strength Criteria 15 Shear rigidity 2.JCAA “Post-installed Anchor Design Guide” JCAA is now working on their original “Post-installed Anchor Design Guide (draft)”. Its working activities are nearly finished. Design Committee consists of eight members with chairman Prof. Reiji Tanaka, Tohoku Institute of Technology. I will give just the content of this guide below.
78
Post-installed Anchor Design Guide and its Commentary (Draft) Contents 1. General rules 1.1 Scope of application 1.2 Post-installed anchors 1.3 Base material 1.4 Operation of post-installed anchors 1.5 Terminology 2. Design of post-installed anchors 2.1 Security of structural performance 2.2 Safety factor 2.3 Characteristic values of materials 2.4 Design load and design deformation 2.5 Design resistance and design deformation limit 2.6 Serviceability limit state design 2.7 Ultimate limit state design 3. Resistance and rigidity formula 3.1 Resistance and rigidity formula of metal anchors 3.2 Resistance and rigidity formula of bonded anchors 4. Structural specification Design example 1 Design example 2 Design example 3 Design example 4 Design example 5 Design example 6 Design example 6 Design example 7
Equipments fixed on floors (Underground) Equipments fixed on floors (High importance case) Equipments fixed on floors (Rooftop) Suspension Sign board (fixed on wall) Metal handrail Seismic reinforcing (added shear wall) Deformation design
79
DESIGN METHOD FOR SPLITTING FAILURE MODE OF FASTENINGS Jörg Asmus*, Rolf Eligehausen** *Ingenieurbüro Eligehausen und Sippel, Stuttgart, Germany **Institute of Construction Materials, University of Stuttgart, Germany
Abstract The failure of a fastening is often caused by a rupture of steel, anchor pullout or by a concrete-cone failure. In the past these failure modes have been intensively investigated and the associated failure loads can be calculated with sufficient accuracy [1]. For the failure mode splitting there exists no general equation to calculate the failure load. Therefore, theoretical and experimental investigations have been performed [2]. Splitting of a concrete member can be expected if the member dimensions are relatively small or in large concrete specimens if the fasteners are installed near to an edge or corner. The splitting failure load depends on dimensions and on material properties of the concrete member. Moreover, the design and load-bearing area of the fastener influence the failure load as well. In the present paper the results of experimental and numerical investigations in case of splitting are discussed and a design method to calculate the splitting failure load is proposed. Details of the design method are given to illustrate how installation parameters (dimension of concrete member and material properties) and the type of the fastener (headed anchor and undercut anchor) influence the splitting resistance.
1. Introduction For fastenings loaded under tension concrete-cone failure, bursting failure, steel failure or pull-out failure are the most common failure modes (Fig. 1a-d). For these failure modes design methods are available [1]. However, fastenings in concrete can also fail by splitting (Fig. 1e). The corresponding failure load may be smaller than the concrete cone failure load. Therefore, the failure mode splitting has to be considered in the design of fastenings. The mechanism of splitting failure is not well understood and the ultimate load associated with it is not easily predictable. Currently splitting is prevented in Technical Approvals by prescribing minimum edge distances and spacing. These parameters have
80
to be determined in tests. However, to design safer and more economical fastenings for any geometry a realistic design method which accounts for splitting failure is needed.
a) concrete-cone failure
b) bursting failure
c) steel failure
d) pull-out failure
e) splitting failure
Fig. 1 Failure modes of fastening systems Splitting is especially relevant for anchor systems which transfer loads by high local stresses into the base material. These stresses are present for systems with mechanical interlock as well as for expansion systems. Therefore, a design method for the failure mode splitting valid for headed anchors, undercut anchors and torque controlled expansion anchors has been proposed [2]. In this paper the design model for headed anchors and undercut anchors is presented (Fig. 2). A1
F
αΗead
Drilling pin a) Mechanical interlock b) Headed anchor c) Undercut anchor Fig. 2 Fastening systems with load-transfer mechanism mechanical interlock
81
2. Splitting failure mechanism 2.1. Numerical investigations To study the splitting failure mechanism numerical non-linear calculations using a realistic material model for concrete have been performed. In a three-dimensional (3D) finite element analysis the splitting of a concrete block caused by a concentrated internal pressure has been investigated. The results show that the ultimate pressure at splitting failure depends mainly on the size and geometry of the specimen as well as on the size of the load-bearing area. When the structure geometry and the load-bearing area are scaled proportionally, the ultimate load increases approximately proportionally as well, i.e. no significant size effect on the splitting failure load is observed. However, if the structure size is scaled proportionally but the size of the load-bearing area is kept constant, there is a strong size effect on the ultimate load. The reason is the localisation of damage and consequently a decrease of the peak resistance by an increase of the size. The numerical results are in good agreement with the experimental observations [2] as well as with theoretical and experimental studies for concrete members loaded by locally applied compressive forces [2]. The numerical investigations are explained in detail in [12]. 2.2. Model When modeling the splitting failure mode it must be taken into account that anchors transfer high loads on a relatively small area compared to the size of the concrete member. The concentrated load causes highly concentrated stresses which are several times higher than the uniaxial compressive strength. In literature several cases have been studied in which small areas are loaded by concentrated compression forces [4], [5], [6]. On the basis of theoretical and experimental investigations the pressure σu under the loaded area A1 is assumed to be proportional to the square root of the ratio between loaded area Ao and load transfer area A1 σu ∼ (Ao/A1)0,5. The investigations in [10] show that the square root relationship is valid for a range of Ao/A1 ≤ 950 which covers the range valid for fasteners. Assuming the tensile capacity of concrete as proportional to fcc0,5 the following equation for splitting resistance is recommended in [10]: Nu,sp = 4,65 ⋅ A10,5 ⋅ Ao0,5 ⋅ fcc0,5
(1)
When loading a small concrete area on the surface of a concrete member by a rigid disk the typical failure mechanism shown in Fig. 3a) is observed. First, a local failure on the concrete surface occurs, which is associated with radial cracking and spalling around the disk. If the ratio A1/Ao is high below the disk a sheared compressed cone with an angle between 25° to 40° is observed. Fig. 3a) shows a typical schematic cross section of a concrete specimen loaded by a stiff disk. With increasing load splitting failure may occur due to the wedging action.
82
In case of headed or undercut anchors the concrete around the load bearing area is confined. Therefore no spalling is possible. As shown in numerical investigations [12] the loading zone is high compressed in all directions. Under the compressed volume zone high tensile strains localize in the radial as well as in the splitting direction and failure is caused by splitting. The failure mechanism is very similar to the failure mechanism shown in Fig. 3a). Therefore in principle, Equation (1) is also valid for headed anchors. However, certain modifications must be taken into account. While the loaded area Ao can easily be calculated the definition of the area A1 needs some considerations (see section 3.1).
Fastening by mechanical interlock
Loading plate member surface
h LE
h LE
αB
sheared compressed concrete
αB
Concrete member Sheared compressed concrete
a) Partial loading on a concrete surface
b) Loading by a headed anchor in a concrete member
Fig. 3 Load-transfer mechanism Based on the Mohr-Coulomb-law and a friction angle of concrete φ of about 36° [11] an angle of the compressed cone αB = 27° is determined [2]. This angle, α deduced by theoretical considerations, φ N agrees well with angles observed in α tension pull-out tests with headed anchors RES F [8]. In tension tests with headed anchors a shearing of the concrete in front of the R (α+φ) anchor head with an angle of about 25° is observed. Because the sheared compressed F Fig. 4 Forces in the load bearing area of cone in front of a headed anchor has angle αB = 27°, a similar behavior for headed a headed anchor anchors with a head angle (see Fig. 2b) between αHead= 27° to 90° is to be expected. For a head angle αB < 27° the splitting and bursting forces increase significantly. Therefore, the higher splitting forces of fasteners with mechanical interlock with a head angle αB < 27° have to be taken into account when calculating the splitting failure load. From the mechanical model shown in Fig. 4 a factor kα is introduced in Equation (2) to consider a head angle αB < 27°. z
SP
83
3. Calculation of the Average Failure Load for Splitting 3.1. General In [2] it is shown that a substitution of the loaded area Ao by the fracture area Acrack is needed. The fracture area depends on member size and edge distance. The fracture area for anchors installed in the middle of a narrow concrete member is defined by the member width b and the member height h. Numerical and experimental investigations with anchors installed in a large specimen near the corner or edge the typical splitting failure mode as shown in Fig. 5b is observed. The splitting crack appears at a specific angle β to the edge. In Fig. 6 the angles as observed in tests are plotted as a function of the edge distance. Besides the results of tension pull-out tests also results of tests with a shear load to the edge [7] are evaluated in Fig. 6. The test results can be approximated by Equation (6), which is represented by the line in Fig. 6. A similar result have been found for fasteners at the corner Equation (7). Equation (6) and (7) are valid for an edge distance c ≥ 40 mm. Furthermore, the splitting area must be restricted to a member height h ≤ 2hef (hef = embedment depth) because the concrete at a distance larger than hef is not stressed significantly [2]. Therefore, the member height in the calculation is limited by h ≤ 2hef (compare Equations (4) and (5)). Equations (2) to (7) give the average splitting failure load of a single fastener with mechanical interlock. In [2] equations for calculating the failure load of double and quadruple fastenings are given. Furthermore, an equation valid for torque controlled expansion anchor is proposed as well. Nu,sp = 4,65 ⋅ kα ⋅ A10,5 ⋅ Acrack0,5 ⋅ fcc0,5 kα = 0,51⋅tan (αB + 36°) = 1 fastening
for αHead < 27° for αHead ≥ 27°
(3)
member h
fracture area Acrack
h
fracture area Acrack
c3
bb
(2)
c1
c1
a)
c2
Fastener installed in the middle of b) Fastener installed at the edge or a narrow concrete member corner (5) h ≤ 2 hef ACrack = rCrack ⋅ h h ≤ 2 hef (4) ACrack = b ⋅ h Fig. 5 Failure area in a concrete member loaded by a fastener
84
Angle of crack ß [°]
60
50
40
30
20
ß
ß
c1
rcrack/2
10
0 0
50
100
150
200
250
Edge distance [mm] h = 120 mm h = 240 mm Shear load to edge (scatter range)
Fig. 6
h = 160 mm tension, Blow-out sin (21 + 0,15c)
Splitting of a single fastener located at the edge; angle of crack as a function of the edge distance
rcrack,edge =
2 ⋅ c1 sin (21 + 0,15 ⋅ c1 )
(c1 ≤ 40 mm: r = 4,4c; c1 ≥ 160 mm: r = 2,8c)
(6)
2 ⋅ c1 sin (61 − 0,1 ⋅ c1 )
(c1 ≤ 40 mm: r = 2,4c; c1 ≥ 160 mm: r = 2,8c)
(7)
rcrack,corner =
3.2. Undercut Anchors Headed anchors are cast-in-place systems, while undercut anchors are systems installed in hardened concrete (post-installed systems). Undercut anchors transfer tension loads to the concrete primarily through mechanical interlock. Nevertheless, there are some differences between headed anchors and undercut anchors. Fig. 7 shows details of the load-bearing area of an undercut anchor. The annular gap between the anchor sleeve and the wall of the drilled hole and gaps between the elements of the expansion sleeve reduce the load-bearing area. Furthermore, with some types of undercut anchors with increasing tension load the cone is drawn further into the expansion sleeves. Due to this follow-up expansion the expansion forces are increased. Furthermore, the concrete surrounding an undercut anchor is affected by the drilling process. The aggregate granules may split when drilling the hole or when generating the undercut.
85
To consider these differences to headed anchors for the calculation of the splitting failure load of undercut anchors a factor kp is introduced in Equation (2): Nu,sp,undercutanchor
= kP ⋅ Nu,sp
(8)
hLE Drilling pin
kP ≤ 1 product factor
Undercut elements
The factor kp is product dependent. For headed anchors it is kp = 1.0. For undercut anchor it must be evaluated by tests. For typical undercut anchors values kp = 0.8 to 1.0 have been found.
Sleeve Space Threaded rod Load bearing area b d1
d2
Fig. 7
Expansion zone of an undercut anchor
4. Comparison with experimental data To evaluate the proposed design method, numerous tests with undercut anchors (see Fig. 2c) were carried out. In these tests several influencing factors were investigated. According to Equation (2) the splitting failure load of systems with mechanical interlock depends on the member width or edge distance, member height and other parameters of the fastening system (embedment depth hef, load-bearing area A1). Fig. 8 a) to d) shows the ratio of the measured and calculated splitting failure load in narrow concrete member (compare Fig. 5a) plotted as a function of edge distance (c = b/2), member height, embedment depth and load-bearing area. The splitting failure load is calculated with a factor kp = 1, i.e. for a headed anchor. The head angle of the undercut anchor is 18°. An optimal agreement between measured and calculated splitting failure loads corresponds to Fu,test/Fu,calc = 1. The comparison shows a good agreement between the proposed formula and the experimental data. Furthermore, a histogram for the ratio of measured to calculated splitting failure loads is shown in Fig. 9. The diagram is based on the results of 164 tests with single fasteners in narrow concrete members. The coefficient of variation is approximately 20%. The scatter is not significantly larger than that of the measured concrete tensile strength. The design formula visualises the effect of influencing parameters and it predicts the splitting failure load obtained in the experiments with sufficient accuracy.
86
Nu,s p,tes t/Nu,s p,calculation
2,00 1,80 1,60 1,40 1,20 1,00 0,80 0,60 0,40 0,20 0,00 0
100
200
300 400 Edge dis tance [cm]
500
0
100
200
300
500
2,00 Nu,s p,tes t/Nu,s p,calculation
1,80 1,60 1,40 1,20 1,00 0,80 0,60 0,40 0,20 0,00 400
M ember height h [cm] 2,00
Nu,s p,tes t/Nu,s p,calculation
1,80 1,60 1,40 1,20 1,00 0,80 0,60 0,40 0,20 0,00 0
50
100
150 Embedment depth h ef [mm]
0
100
200 300 Load-bearing area A 1 [mm²]
200
2,00
Nu,s p,tes t/Nu,s p,calculation
1,80
Fig. 8
1,60 1,40 1,20 1,00 0,80 0,60 0,40 0,20 0,00 400
Single fastenings with undercut anchors in narrow members; Ratio of the measured to the calculated splitting failure load as a function of (1 = optimal agreement): a) edge distance with c = b/2 b) member height c) embedment depth c) load-bearing area
87
50
n = 164 x = 1,08 v = 21,6 %
45 40 35
Number
30 25 20 15 10 5 0 0,0
0,5
1,0
1,5
2,0
Splitting failure load Test/Calculation
Fig. 9
Comparison of measured to calculated splitting failure loads; Single fastenings (undercut anchors) in narrow concrete members
In [2] more details are given related to the influence of the bending and the spacing of multiple fastenings on the splitting failure load. Furthermore, a design method for calculating the splitting failure load of torque controlled expansion anchors is proposed as well.
5. Summary Splitting of concrete occurs when the dimensions of the structural member are too small or the anchors are located too close to the edge or are spaced too closely. The failure load is normally less than in the case of concrete cone failure. Therefore, the failure mode splitting has to be considered in the design of fastenings. In the present paper the results of experimental and numerical investigations are discussed and a design method to calculate the splitting failure load is proposed. Details of the design method are discussed to illustrate how installation parameters (dimension of concrete member; material properties) and type of fastener (headed anchors or undercut anchors) influence the splitting failure load. To demonstrate the validity of the proposed design method, numerous tests with undercut anchors were performed. The calculated and experimentally obtained failure loads agree with sufficient accuracy.
88
6. References [1]
[2] [3]
[4]
[5]
[6] [7] [8]
[9]
[10]
[11] [12]
[13]
European Organisation for Technical Approvals (EOTA) (1994): Guideline for European Technical Approval of Anchors (Metal Anchors) for Use in Concrete, Final Draft, Sept. 1994. Asmus, J., „Bemessung von zugbeanspruchten Befestigungen bei der Versagensart Spalten des Betons”, Dissertation, Universität Stuttgart, 1999. Eligehausen, R.; Mallee, R.: Befestigungstechnik im Beton- und Mauerwerksbau, Ernst & Sohn Verlag für Architektur und technische Wissenschaften GmbH, Berlin, 2000. Lächler, W.: „Beitrag zum Problem der Teilflächenpressung bei Beton am Beispiel der Pfahlkopfanschlüsse.“, Dissertation, Institut für für Grundbau und Bodenmechanik der Universität Stuttgart, 1977. Spieth, H.P: Das Verhalten von Beton unter hoher örtlicher Pressung und Teilbelastung unter besonderer Berücksichtigung von Spannbetonverankerungen. Dissertation TH Stuttgart, 1959. Niyogi, S. K.: The Bearing Strength of Concrete-Geometric Variations; ASCE, Journal of the Structural Division No. 99, July 1973. Fuchs, W.: Tragverhalten von Befestigungen unter Querlast in ungerissenem Beton, Deutscher Ausschuß für Stahlbeton, Heft 424, Beuth-Verlag, 1992. Furche, J.: Zum Trag- und Verschiebungsverhalten von Kopfbolzen bei zentrischem Zug, Dissertation, Institut für Werkstoffe im Bauwesen der Universität Stuttgart, 1994. Furche, J.; Eligehausen, R.: „Lateral Blow-Out Failure of Headed Studs Near a Free Edge“, In: Senkiw, G. A.; Lancelot, H. B. (Herausgeber), SP-130, Anchors in Concrete, Design and Behaviour. American Concrete Institute, Detroit, 1991, S. 235 - 252. Lieberum, K.-H.: Das Tragverhalten von Beton bei extremer Teilflächenbelastung. Dissertation an der Technischen Hochschule Darmstadt, 1978. Szabo, G.: Über die Berechnung der Bruchlast örtlich belasteter Stahlbetonkörper, Betonstein-Zeitung, Heft 2/1963. Asmus, J.; Ozbolt, J.: Numerical and experimental investigations of the failure mode splitting of fastenings, Symposium on connections between steel and concrete, University Stuttgart 2001 Furche, J.: „Spalten des Ankergrundes Beton infolge zentrisch belasteter formschlüssiger Befestigungsmittel“; Nachtrag zur Diplomarbeit Bohner (1988), Bericht Nr. 9/7 - 88/20, Institut für Werkstoffe im Bauwesen der Universität Stuttgart, 1988.
89
BEHAVIOUR AND DESIGN OF FASTENINGS OF SHEAR LUGS IN CONCRETE Harald Michler, Manfred Curbach Dresden University of Technology, Germany
Abstract Research on special structures with shear lugs to transmit high values of shear load to fixed ground has been carried out. An additional loading with normal force and bending moment is possible, but the shear load will be the main loading. In this case the base will be concrete and the fitting will be made of steel. The fixing is built into the green concrete. The advantage of the fittings with shear lug is reasonable in the splitting of the load transfer. The special components of the load especially the shear load is transmitted by highly specialized structural parts. The behaviour and capacity of these structures will be shown.
1. Introduction An experimental and theoretical analysis of the bearing behaviour of complex shear loaded fixtures with shear lugs has been carried out at Dresden University of Technology, which was supported by the DFG. As part of the working group ”Design of Fastenings in Concrete (Design Guide of fib)”, fastenings are examined for the transfer of great surface parallel shear loads into the concrete structure [1] [2] [3]. The experiments discussed later are an extension of work done at the Bechtel Power Corporation in Ann Arbor, Michigan and at the former Institute of Reinforced Concrete in Dresden. The earlier experiments in Dresden are the basis for this examination [4] [5]. The analysed units are different from systems based on friction or prestressed units. And they do not need any normal pressure, which is a usual feature of a steel pillar feet. The analysis has turned the attention to a major shear force load combined with small normal forces either in tension or compression and also a bending moment or not. The basic idea of the new components is the construction from highly sophisticated and specialised modules.
90
The fixings mentioned can be used F for any kind of concentrated load fixture transmission or assembly joints M fitting between structural concrete (steel) V components, steel/wooden structures or other concrete elements loaded base plate parallel to the surface. Possible fields abutting of application of the new components padding will be all cases that match to the face principle of corbel load introduction. tie bar shear lug The strengthening of existing = round bolt concrete structures using additional headed Ø14 steel structures, fixing facade anchor bolt elements on the main construction Figure 1 Schema of fixing, main parts part or supporting girders using a corbel may be some examples for future applications. As shown in Figure 1, the component always consists of three main parts: the base plate, the shear lug and the tie bar. The base plate parallel to the surface is the interconnection between the load and the actual anchoring components, the shear lug and the tie bar. The design of the shear lug is supposed to deliver an optimal transmission of the shear force into the concrete component and the tie bar is designed only for the transfer of tension forces. Because the shear lug has a rectangular cross section with flat surfaces, the load transmission is more effective than the load transmission of the tie bar. Even it is possible to easily built a stress distribution at fixing systems much greater cross section than the circular cross • bending stiff • rigid joint section of a traditional anchor bolt of shear lug round anchor bolt. So the tie h e bar has only been a b considered as transmission of tension forces either from R2 h e external load or resulting from the eccentricity of the shear force V (see Figure 2). Normal compression forces R1 are transmitted directly R1 using the base plate. For this loading no further special cross section cross section elements are needed. So the of anchor bolt: of shear lug: specified construction is most ideal for great shear Figure 2 Comparison of stress distribution, anchor forces in combination with bolt and lug
V
l/2
V
l/2
91
lower normal forces or bending moments. A design concept for this shear anchorage will be presented here. The concept is based on numerous tests, and a numerical description will be discussed. The resistance will be explained in dependence on different stiffness conditions, especially the geometry and material of the lug, various depths of embedment of the lug and the tie bar, different strength of the concrete ground and, of course, different load combinations. In addition to the failure modes and the capacity, the ductility of the construction will be described.
F M
V eV
eS
RS
eD
RA
eA/2
eA/2
FA
RD shear lug
Figure 3
Forces at the fixture
2. Testing The tests have been carried out at the OTTO MOHR LABORATORY at the INSTITUTE OF STRUCTURES AND MATERIALS IN DRESDEN. The fittings are designed in the style of experiments carried out before. But, the double symmetric design of these former experiments is given up for the benefit of a directional layout. In this manner the individual elements can be specialized more consequently. In Figure 1, a schematic profile view is presented. It is easy to see that the shear force V is only suitable in one direction, according to the design. Consequently there is only one headed anchor bolt placed behind the shear lug, the tie bar. Its task is to take the tension part from the equilibrium moment and introduce it into the anchor ground. In front of the lug a weaker pressure-anchor is placed. Between these elements the shear lug itself is placed. It serves to transfer the shear load to the concrete base. The shear lug is supported by the base plate. The front end face of this base plate also transfers a part of the shear load to the ground. The experiments are designed to make the concrete failure in front of the lug decisive. A possible breaking of the tie bar bolt due to shear load is prevented by padding the bolt shaft directly below the base plate. By this coating, the concrete in this area is not connected to the tie bar shaft and no shear load can be transmitted. This will be the theory until there is a moving of approximately 2 mm. Therefore, the tie bar is only loaded by a tensile normal force, according to plan. There are three mechanisms which may lead to a breakdown of these fittings. These are: 1) concrete failure; shear failure of the concrete part in front of the lug and/or the base plate, or rather crushing 2) steel failure of the shear lug, shear failure or plastification and rotation 3) breaking down of the tie bar a) concrete cone failure or pull-out failure b) steel failure
92
The concrete failure aspect should be examined mainly. A failure according to 2) and 3) is not planned, however, it represents important limiting conditions for failures according to 1). This mutual susceptibility can be shown if we look at the reaction forces RD, see Figure 3. The quantity of RD represents the main part of the shear force. But the eccentricity, say eD, of it sets the loading of the shear lug by the bending moment and of Figure 4 Fixings with rigid block lugs course the load of the tie bar FA according to the equilibrium moment. But this eccentricity itself is influenced by the vertical movement of the tie bar – theory of 2nd order. RD is based on the multiaxial compressive stress in front of the shear lug, and this stress itself is dependent on the tie bar extension. The whole tests are divided into three parts, to investigate the essential experimental parameters. The mean parameters are: concrete strength, lug stiffness, anchoring depth of the lug and the tie bar, and of course the load carrying capacity of the tie bar. Its influence on the shear load capacity of the shear lug will also be of interest. Figure 4 shows the fittings of a series of experiments of the 1st group. We see the stiff box lugs, composed from two channel sections, with stepping of 0 cm, 4 cm and 8 cm anchoring depth. By the first group the influence of the concrete strength is investigated, also the lug stiffness and the anchoring depth of the lug are varied. The lug stiffness is achieved by two different lug designs. On the one hand, flat lugs made from steel plates - 2 cm thickness. They will be called soft lugs. On the other hand, inflexible box lugs composed from two welded channel sections, which are the stiff ones. The cell composed from them is filled by concrete, too. All these lugs are tested with anchoring depths of 4 cm and 8 cm. So the building relevant sizes are covered. In each series fittings also are tested without lugs at all, so the anchoring depth will be 0 cm. In this case only the base plate will transmit the shear load to the ground. The tie bars are varying at 20 and 30 cm. Hereby the swapping stress state in front of the shear lug is tested. It is influenced by the volume belonging to the pull-out failure of the tie bar, and the stress in front of the shear lug itself. In the second group, the concrete strength is then held unchangeable and the load combination is varied. Only the soft flat-sheet lugs are applied with 4 and 8 cm anchoring depth. Besides an additional eccentricity of the shear force V, an unchangeable tensile or compression normal force F is applied. The tie bar anchoring depth itself is unchangeably 30 cm. In the third group, the experimental body is changed, first the location of the base plate is bonded in the concrete and, second on top of the concrete. Only soft 4 cm and 8 cm lugs are used. The solid experimental body, measuring 120·120·90 cm, of the first two groups is changed in the last group. Here a narrow rectangular reinforced column measuring
93
45·45 cm is used. The effect of a placing of the fittings close to the edge should be examined hereby, and of course the influence of reinforcement. All experiments are designed to expect a failure of the concrete in front of the load transmitting faces. Only if higher strength classes of concrete and the stiff box lug are used, pull-out-failure or steel failure of the tie bar is to be expected.
3. Crushing mechanics and behaviours
V
v5 v4 v3
F
The failure case ”exhaustion of lug load-carrying v 1 v2 v6 v7 w4 capacity” is used for the assessment of lug effects and ability. This failure is characterized by w6 shearing a wedge-shaped concrete volume in front of the base plate, in general (Vks failure). With beginning loss of the pressure transmitting in front of the base plate the shear force itself is V 3 increasingly relocated to the shear lug and finally onto the bolt of the tie bar itself. This will 1 2 4 6 7 happen if the bolt will crush onto the concrete face after the padded path around the tie bar is used. The ability of the tie bar to pick up these 5 additional loads and to transmit them to the concrete decides whether it comes to an immediate Figure 5 Measuring points with breaking of fixing or a stable balance can still shift direction appear in the deformed state in spite of damage. The exact description and explanation of the damage process is of decisive importance. From the first crack to the crack propagation and the final crushing down, the whole procedure of damage is to be observed to do a valid description of the cause to fracture and the evaluation of a calculation model. Special attention must be given to the special cause that will release the final breaking down. The failure of the concrete can be traced back to four basic cases. These can occur both in a pure form and in combination: a) Loss of the stress transmission in front of the base plate by shearing a wedge sized concrete volume in front of the base plate face or damage of concrete in this area. The shear force is shifted onto the shear lug and possibly the anchor bolt of the tie bar. b) Shearing of an wedge sized concrete volume according to a) with immediately following breaking down of the tie bar near the base plate due to combined tensile shear load. c) Tie bar outbreak due to the load attacking at the tie bar head, with an outbreak of a cone behind the base plate. (pull-out failure) d) Complete destruction of the experimental concrete body. Cracking starting at the shear lug will reach up to the component edges. A more detailed description of these basic cases is done in [8] [9] and [10].
94
4. Structural behaviour and load-bearing capacity
total failure load V [kN]
Figure 6 presents a first view of all achieved ultimate loads. All experiments are plotted on one graph and the load is shown over the concrete compressive strength. It should be noted that all tested parameters are shown. Therefore the achieved loads need some comments, because different load applications, different forms of fittings and, of course, reasons of crushing are presented. Obviously the three classes of concrete compressive strength can be recognized clearly. Please note the fittings have two different shear transfer faces with quite a varying bearing behaviour. The base plate, embedded in the concrete, which will transmit important parts of the shear loading into the concrete at its front face. But only 2 cm are embedded in the concrete, and the result is an edge compression. The free surface does not allow the concrete to establish a multiaxial compressive state of stress, in the sense of partial load pressure. And the shear lug itself that transmits decisive parts of the shear load V. The concrete body in front of this shear lug is enclosed in concrete and steel. On the top it is protected by the lateral cantilever of the base plate and all the rest is enclosed in concrete, too. So the differB15 B25 B45 -> concrete strength ent conditions make it clear 0 cm 4 cm flat 4 cm box -> lug anchoring that the failure mechanism 8 cm flat 8 cm box depth and sort for the final crushing canD, e = 0 cm Z, e = 0 cm -> additional load . D, e = 10 cm Z, e = 10 cm e = 10 cm tension/compression not automatically be the same for the experiments V eccentricity F bewehrt, bewehrt without lugs and for the mit Stirn ohne Stirn e experiments with lugs present. 1200 Consequently, the consideration of a summary lug face AC [8], cannot allow a 1000 general estimation of ultimate load. Also it is not 800 possible to transfer the results to a more general layout of fittings. So the 600 failure of the base plate end face (Vks) is to view separately from the total failure 400 (Vges). Here Vks designates the shear load step that 200 brings the breaking out of the concrete in front of the 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 55 base plate front side. Vges f c [N/mm²] whereas is the maximum shear load achieved in the Figure 6 Total failure load of all tests experiment.
95
4.1.
Concrete failure in front of the base plate, Vks e 1000 The dependence of concrete failure on the existing uniaxil or multiaxial stress 800 state is confirmed by the experiments. In certain 600 experiments, the concrete in front of the base plate is crushed and is shifted out without dowel 400 4 cm rigid dowel without a total failure oc4 cm soft dowel curring. Even this case of 8 cm rigid dowel 8 cm soft dowel 200 events often is difficult to e = 10 cm compressiv F discover in the load-distensile F placement diagrams be0 cause there is no sudden 100 300 500 700 900 relocation of the load failure load V ks [kN] transmitted in the base plate contact surface to the lug Figure 7 Possible increasing of load Vks to Vges surface. This failure load Vks due to concrete failure in front of the base plate only indicates that the complete shear load V is now transferred by the shear lug itself. It is still possible to increase the load after the concrete destruction on the end face of the base plate. This is shown by Figure 7. For the experiments without special shear lugs (black points), the load must be relocated to the tie bar if the Vks-failure occurs. The bolt of the tie bar will now act as a dowel and will be shear loaded, like the lug. It looks similar in the experiments with flat sheet lugs (triangles). The load increasing ability is smaller in the case of the experiments with 4 cm lugs and greater in the case of the experiments with 8 cm lugs. For the experiments with the stiff block lugs the load is not increased after the Vks-failure has occurred. In this case the load due to the Vks-failure is greater than or equal to the load of final breaking, but this will happen on a quite higher load step. The same also occurs in all experiments with enlarged eccentric load attack eV, and in experiments with additional tensile normal force. Merely in the case of the experiments with pressing normal force an appreciable load increase can be found in turn.
V
increase of load Vks to Vges [kN]
F
4.2. Concrete failure in front of the lug – final failure Vges The concrete failure in front of the base plate brings a clear announcement of the breaking, but it will not automatically introduce it. Regardless of whether it is a question of block or flat lugs, in the fracture state the experiments show a concrete stress of 4.5 to 6.0 times fc for all the 4 cm lugs. The adequate values of the 8 cm lugs then range between 2.5 and 4.0 times fc, where the values of the block lugs fall out down. However,
96
F-compression
load V [kN]
load V [kN]
for these block lugs no concrete failure is the final reason for breaking down. If the theoretical anchoring depth of all flat 8 cm lugs is reduced to 6 cm in general, the values will join the values of the F=0 4 cm lugs, too. By a pure F-tension shear load all the 4 cm lugs alone (flat and block) 0,2 0,6 1,0 1,4 1,8 give a concrete ultimate displacement v 4 [mm] stress of 5.2·fc. An additional pressure load increases this value to 800 7.1·fc, an additional tensile F-compression 700 normal force will reduce 600 the value to 4.1·fc. A 500 similar behaviour is to be 400 observed for an additional 300 eccentric load 200 F=0 introduction. A look at the 100 F-tension displacement values v4 and 0 w4 at the fracture state will show that an additional -0,2 0,2 0,6 1,0 1,4 1,8 normal force increases the displacement w 4 [mm] displacement considerably F v4 during failure. An Figure 8 Behaviour with tension w4 additional eccentric load and compression introduction with normal V force or without normal hD = 4/8 force then leads to lower values of the displacement value of w4 in the fracture state. Looking at the load displacements in Figure 8, the displacements v4 und w4 show the behaviour as it is described above. Figure 8 shows the displacements for 4 cm and 8 cm flat lugs without additional eccentric load introduction. The grouping of the lines is to be seen clearly. For an additional compressive normal load we get a very stiff behaviour, and the 8 cm lugs do not behave differently to the 4 cm lugs. The behaviour of both is much stiffer than in the case of pure shear load or shear load with additional tensile normal force. These experiments also react far more brittle than those with additional eccentricity of the load introduction. Arriving the maximal load the deformation will increase. Of course the load will go down hereby due to decreasing oil pressure, and the fitting in general is cut by shear force at the tie bar bolt.
800 700 600 500 400 300 200 100 0 -0,2
97
This is the reaction to fact that the concrete also has broken down in front of the lug. And the steel fitting glides up, on a wedgeshaped body of concrete that was formed in the corner between the base plate and the lug front face. Finally tests with additional tensile normal force show a much more brittle behaviour with a more sudden breaking down. Again, in principle it is not important whether 4 cm- or 8 cm flat lugs are used. Only the ultimate load is higher in the case of the latter. However, the principle of failure is not changed at all. It can be seen that the additional pressing normal force constitutes a kind of initial preloading on the tie bar. The preloading will help the tie bar and is to be directly subtracted from the rest of the tie bar load. The additional tensile normal load then is a preloading with additional load. Especially noteworthy is that the load displacement lines for v4 are identical for all of the experiments with compressive normal force without additional eccentric load. Here all the lugs with 4 cm and 8 cm act quite identically at any rate up to Vks-failure. However, the fact must be considered that the experiments with compressing and compressing eccentric load show a considerably more good-natured post-break behaviour than the experiments with tension and tensioneccentric load. This will effect the dimensioning of this fittings, by the possible choice of permissible stresses in front of the shear lugs. There will be a necessary differentiation according to load combinations, especially load combinations with tension. 4.3. Other failure modes Steel failure in the lug can occur in two variants. On the one hand, the lug can be cut by shear load in the place of the maximal stress. Both will happen as reaction to the situation of the concrete stresses in front of the lug. The type of distribution of these concrete stresses over the lug height is to be assumed here. These cannot be measured in the experiments and is examined by means of an FEM-model. The tie bar works like a normal force loaded headed anchor bolt, and will crash like that. (steel failure, concrete cone failure or pull-out failure.
5. Model of design Finally, a simple model of dimensioning for these fittings should be presented. This must consider the three basic failure mechanisms separately (See Testing) Even if the different failure mechanism must not be considered completely independent, it is helpful for the checking process to do this. Within the framework of a simple and presumably rough dimensioning it is precise enough to isolate the failure mechanisms and to estimate deformations not at all. The key to the numerical dimensioning of the fittings is the concrete failure in front of the lug and/or the load transmitting face of the base plate. The knowledge of the resulting forces RS and RD will develop the loading of the tie bar, and all forces that will be transmitted in the fitting are known (see Figure 3). To know the location of the forces always a constant stress is assumed in front of the load transmitting surfaces. As shown, a concrete failure in front of the base plate can be distinguished clearly from a total failure. Furthermore, the dimensioning equations will be given for both, a permissible stress σm,AC and a permissible stress σm,AD. The stress of σm,AC will be combined with the available summary lug face AC, and no concrete out-
98
break in front of the base plate is to be expected. On the other hand, the pure lug face AD may be applied to the stress of σm,AD. This is the part of lug face in front of which a multiaxial stress state may develop. The load step of VAC may be considered by a concrete breakout in front of the base plate, but it will not matter. This will occur if the value VAD is greater than the value VAC. The consideration of these two values will also offer the possibility to dimension fittings without a base plate embedded in the concrete, too. 5.1. General verification equation With consideration of all available experiments, the equations (1) can be developed. Hereby hD is replaced, so it is more easy to handle the equation. The value hD is to be calculated directly from the total shear load and the permissible stress σm, because the stress σm does not depend on hD furthermore. Also reprocessing of e'V (e'V is the value from the test protocols) to eV is done.
σm, AC fC
σm, AD fC
F − 0,005 ∗ eV − 0,002 ∗ fC FA F = 9,175 − 2,270 ∗ − 0,0150 ∗ eV − 0,100 ∗ fC FA
= 2,475 − 0,570 ∗
a) (1) b)
Units [N] and [mm]; eV ≥ 25 mm FA = FuE = 15,5 ∗ hr1,5 ∗ β w [N]
(2)
A post processing of the experiments based on these relationships gives a good agreement with the experimental values. Naturally, for the experiments without lug only Vksfailure can be calculated. Here the final failure is characterized by a bolt shear fracture of the tie bar, and the yielding mechanisms can be found in the literature due to headed tie bars [6], [7]. For each of AC and AD, the possible value of shear load is calculated, and of course the depended value of FA, the normal force at the tie bar. The greater value indicates the permissible shear load Vges and indicates simultaneously whether a concrete outbreak is possible in front of the base plate or not. Of course, the tie bar has to be able to serve the dependent value of FA. Otherwise the permissible shear load is to be reduced. It should be noted that the tie bar can break down with a steel failure or a pull-out failure. In practice, the tie bar will be a headed bolt, and so the load carrying capacity is known (see equation (2)). In this equation the value of hr gives the anchoring depth of the tie bar. The tie bar diameter has no effect on the concrete-pull-out loading.
5.2. Model For dimensioning the fittings, the following model can be used. This model is used to get the test results by calculation and therefore it works with mean values. It is valid to all fittings which strongly separate shear load transmission from normal force transmission. Even the normal force component of the balance moment is served by the separate tie
99
bar. Using equation (1) to get the absorbable mean concrete compressive stress, the experimental total failure loads are reached sufficiently precise. Only the 8 cm lugs show a greater deviation in the results. This behaviour can be traced back to the approximation of the model itself. Naturally the effects on deformation will not allow a rectangular stress distribution in front of the lug over the hole anchoring depth. The effects of this state of affairs are more closely described in [11]and would go beyond the scope of this simple model. In detail, the procedure has to be carried out as shown in Figure 9: On the basis of the input variables, the absorbable mean concrete compressive stresses in front of the lug are determined. From these stresses the absorbable shear load is to be calculated. This total load is based, on the one hand, on the summary lug face area AC, and, on the other hand, on the pure lug face area AD. Notice that area AD will be only that contact surface which can develop a multiaxial stress status in front of itself. The bigger value of these two approaches indicates the absorbable shear load level - henceforth called V. If the shear load VAC is less than the shear load VAD, it is to be expected that the concrete will break out in front of the linked base plate, but still there will be a reserve available up to the total shear failure load given: searched: that will be V = VAD. The planned use and the secushear load V eccentricity eQ [mm] rity concept will decide normal force N [N] whether V as working AC tie bar load capacity F [N] A load may be exceeded or concrete strength fc [N/mm²] not. The form and stiffness of the lugs are still unimportant in this step. permissible stress / load Furthermore, the failure σm,AC -> tolerable VAC = σm,AC × AC of the single components is tested and they will be σm,AD -> tolerable VAD = σm,AD × AD dimensioned or the absorbable shear load V is load carrying fitness for use to be reduced to the capacity weakest part. In this step VAC ≥ VAD sudden crash it will be practically choultimate load VAC < VAD concrete breaks out in sen by which component tol VAC front of the linked base the final failure will be max =V tol VAD plate, but still load inintroduced. It is adviscrease to VAD possible able, to prove the tie bar first. Its load will be clearly given by the exdimensioning / verification ternal loading and the at the fixture (local) rectangular stress distribution in front of the base plate and the shear lug. Figure 9 Schema of verification The tie bar is to be veri-
100
fied with respect to steel failure as well as to concrete outbreak. At last the lug itself should be proved. The proofing is to be done in a separate manner for a shear failure, and bending failure that will result in plastic flow with rotation. The last one is not to be allowed, because no deformations are expected in this model. In this form the proving has the advantage that not a reduced anchoring depth of the shear lug has to be used. As a result, the shear load component in the lug is reduced by static system alternations and the applied concrete compressive stress state will remain unchangeable. Using this lug dimensioning model will result in great deformations of the fitting, and therefore the concrete will break in front of the base plate. In the case of very big values of lug anchoring depth combined with a very small value of the lug bending stiffness this dimensioning model should not be used because it does not consider the real deformations in the fitting. So the local load introduction is done. Of course, a secure load transmission to the supports is to be ensured, too. The investigation of a possible punching of the fitting is also to be made. This case is not so erroneous at mass components with low reinforcement. The test with stiff lugs and high values of concrete strength does show this.
Bibliographic references [1] Fastenings to Reinforced Concrete and Masonry Structures, State-of-the-Art Report, Part I and Part II, CEB-Bulletin d’Information Nr. 206/7, Lausanne 1991 [2] Fastenings to Concrete and Masonry Structures, State-of-the-Art Report, CEBBulletin d’Information Nr. 216, Lausanne 1994 [3] Design of Fastenings in Concrete, Draft CEB Guide Part 1 to 3; Fastenings to Seismic Retrofitting, State-of-the-Art Report on Design and Application, CEB-Bulletin d’Information Nr. 226, Lausanne 1995 [4] Rotz, J.V.; Reifschneider, M: Combined Axial and Shear Load Capacity of Steel Embedments in Concrete, Report Bechtel Power Corporation, 1991 [5] Körner, C; Schweigel, P: Nachweis der Betontragfähigkeit im Verankerungsbereich von Stahleinbauteilen, Betontechnik H. 1, 1986 [6] Rehm, G.; Eligehausen, R.; Mallée, R.: Befestigungstechnik, published in Betonkalender 1988, (Teil II-D, 609-753; 1997) and other following [7] Eligehausen, R. and other; Tragverhalten von Kopfbolzenverankerungen bei zentrischer Zugbeanspruchungen, Bauingenieur 67 (1992) pp.183-196 [8] Körner, C.: Verankerung schwerer Lasten mit Schubdübeln, 34. Forschungskolloquium des DAfStb am 9./10. Oktober 1997 an der TU Dresden [9] Curbach, M.; Körner, C.; Michler, H.: Tragfähigkeit von Befestigungen mit Schubdübeln im Betonbau zur Übertragung großer Schubkräfte. Abschlussberichtzum Forschungsvorhaben DFG Cu-37/3-1, TU Dresden, Institut für Tragwerke und Baustoffe, Lehrstuhl für Massivbau, Dresden 2001 [10] Michler, H: Load Capacity of shear loaded anchorages. International PHD Symposium in Civil Engineering, Wien 2000 [11] Michler, H: Dissertation, Lehrstuhl für Massivbau, TU Dresden (in progress)
101
SAFETY RELEVANT ASPECTS FOR TORQUE CONTROLLED EXPANSION ANCHORS Helmut Gassner, Erich Wisser Hilti AG, Schaan, Liechtenstein
Abstract For an assessment of expansion anchors, it is necessary to know, which parameters have to be considered. To investigate safety relevant aspects for Torque Controlled Expansion Anchors fife different types of anchors have been tested. The products were examined onto appearance, behaviour at setting and under static loading in tension and shear direction. The tests have been shown, that a lot of parameters have to be considered to compare the behaviour of different anchors, especially under difficult conditions on construction site. In addition to the ultimate pull-out and shear load, the setting procedure and the tightening torque moment are very important parameters.
1. Introduction To investigate safety relevant aspects for Torque Controlled Expansion Anchors fife different types of anchors have been tested. The dimensions and embedment depth are nearly identical. The products were examined onto appearance, behaviour at setting and under static loading in tension and shear direction. Basic data for concrete capacity C25/30 and drill hole were evaluated. All anchors of same size were set with same embedment depth obeying the setting instructions of the respective manual.
2. Test Setup Static pull-out test All pull-out tests were carried out with a testing system of 250 kN maximum load and a
102
chosen displacement speed of 6 mm/min. The tests were performed with and without tightening torque moments to check the reliability at wrong application. Static shear tests The shear tests were carried out with a servohydraulic test cylinder of an nominal capacity of 250 kN. The displacement speed of the piston was 16 mm/min. Clamping of gaps between concrete and attaching part Often only after installing the torque moment there is realized that the attaching part shows a gap to the substrate. So in the test a steel padding of 6 mm was placed between concrete surface and loading plate. The full torque moment was installed, then released and the padding removed. If after installing the torque moment again the loading plate could be clamped onto concrete surface, the clamping test was assessed positive. With the Anchor Type E one test was performed only with a low torque moment. Then the pads were taken out and the full torque moment applied for simulating a flexible footing.
Load F [kN]
3. Behavior under Tensile and Shear 70 A; M12 with Md A; M12 without Md B; M12 with Md B; M12 without Md C; M12 with Md C; M12 without Md D; 5/8" with Md * D; 5/8" without Md * E; M12 with Md E; M12 without Md
60
50
40
30
20
10
0 0
5
10
15
Fig. 1 Load Displacement behaviour - Pull-Out Tests
103
20
25 30 Displacement s [mm]
In Figure 1 the results at static pull-out tests for all anchor types are shown, black curves with tightening torque moment, red curves without. All tested samples of Anchor Type A were conform to the anticipated behaviour. The follow-up expansion worked well. At pull-out test the very small scattering in the load displacement behaviour up to ultimate load is significant. But the clamping force of the attaching part is comparatively low with 15 kN. Also in shear the system works as requested. With high ductility the ultimate shear load is achieved at a displacement of about 28 mm. The claming function is ensured up to a gap of 8 mm. The results at static pull-out test of Anchor Type B shows, that at in minimum two of five anchors the expansion sleeve cracked radially and moved onto the upper cone. This causes a high number of turnings for the torque moment. So the conversion of torque to pre-load is undefined and within a wide variation of deviation. At prescribed torque moment pre-stressing forces twice of Anchor Type A were achieved. At the static pullout tests the system acted brittle and without any follow-up expansion effect. At four of five anchors the cones were pulled through. The concrete failed but no concrete cone broke out. The average ultimate load was only at 63% of the Anchor Type A value. In shear the system works - due to the failure mode bending-tension of bolt - ductile but the maximum loads were achieved after already 5-12 mm displacement (Anchor Type A only after 28 mm). For the Anchor Type C, the transmission of the torque moment varied in a wide range as with Anchor Type B. To the customer this generates a dubious feeling. However prestressing forces of 120 to 200 % of the Anchor Type A values are realised. The loaddisplacement behaviour, the ultimate loads and the failure mode were equal to that of the Anchor Type A. Nevertheless at the pullout test without a torque moment the tested anchors failed without increasing of load. Also in shear loading the ductility of the tested Anchor Type C is about 30% below the ductility of the Anchor Type A. The average of the ultimate shear capacity is 18% less however with small standard deviation - below the Anchor Type A value. The results at static pull-out of Anchor Type D are described as follow. A high number of strokes was needed for setting the anchor. At two of five anchors the plastic ring broke so that the expansion sleeve did not touch the cone. At the attempt to install the torque moment the screw got stuck at the front of the slotted and compressed cone and the cone was not pulled into the expansion sleeve. In the drill hole the cone turned through. One of these two anchors was pulled out with only 4 kN ultimate load. The average ultimate load of the other anchors for pull-out amounted only 69% of the Anchor Type A value. Without torque moment both tested anchors were pulled out without load.
104
The tested Anchor Type D System works very unsafe concerning the setting and pull-out behaviour. In shear the ductility of this anchor is comparable to Anchor Type A. The ultimate force is 17% below the Anchor Type A value because of the thin rolled sheet sleeve. The expansion cone of Anchor Type E differs from all other tested anchors in the twofold expansion angle. First an angle of 7º and 6 mm long followed by an angle of 15º and 7 mm long. At Anchor Type A the angle is 8º with a length of 12 mm. This may cause the high pre-stressing force, more than twice that of Anchor Type A. Sleeve and washer are equal to Type A parts. The torque moment was reached only after 4 1/2 to 6 turnings because 5 mm displacement are necessary that the front of the sleeve contacts the cone. Ultimate tensile load and its variation are equal to Anchor A. The follow-up expansion works well also the plastic deformation of the expansion sleeve to a tulip shape. Also without a torque moment the safety of this anchor at tensile loads is given. The shear capacity of Anchor Type E makes 73% of Type A value. But the threaded rod version of Type E has 27% reduced stress area. The ductility is much lower as with anchor A. The dimensions of the sleeve are equal to Anchor A.
4. Rest Results at Cclamping of Gaps At Anchor Type E the functions of the plastic collapsible section are integrated into the expansion sleeve made of sheet metal. These consist of 3 folded expansion parts of 1.2 mm thickness. The rips as crumble zone should prevent internal pretension when a gap between concrete surface and attaching part has to be closed. The thickness of the sleeve is 20% less than that of Anchor Type A. To assess the function of gap clamping two tests were performed. At the first one the total torque moment was installed using steel pads between concrete surface and attaching part, then released and the pads were removed. Now no clamping of attaching parts to concrete surface could be achieved with torque moment. At the second test after a small torque moment the pads were removed and the torque moment was increased to the prescribed value now producing a clamping force. The drilled out anchors show the insufficient function of the crumble zone. To get more information for the functioning at “gap clamping” a more detailed examination is proposed.
5. Setting Behavior In Table 1 is shown a synopsis of test results to setting behaviour. Most of anchors needs 1 to 2 hammer strokes for setting into the drill hole, but Anchor Type D significantly more. The mounting overhead can be made without falling out of the anchors and the antirotation device works at all anchors, too.
105
The clamping test with a gap of 6mm worked more or less at all anchors. At Anchor Type B broke the expansion sleeve and was pushed over the conic part. At Anchor Type C the plastic section collapsed as defined, at Anchor D as undefined. Anchor Type E managed the clamping test only at facilitated conditions. The tightening with torque moment occurred at Anchor Type A with only 1 1/2 to 1 3/4 turns. The others partially needed much more turns as you see in the table. All anchors could be removed flush to the concrete surface.
type of anchor
number of mounting strokes at with 500g overhead hammer
antirotation device
clamping test (6 mm gap)
o.k. o.k., expansion sleeve broken o.k., defined collapse of plastic section o.k., undefined collapse of plastic section o.k., only at facilitated conditions
A B
1 2
o.k. o.k.
o.k. o.k.
C
1
o.k.
o.k.
D
12-17
o.k.
o.k.
E
2-3
o.k.
o.k.
needed removable turns for flush to the tightening concrete with torque surface moment 1 ½ -1 3/4 o.k. o.k. 4 ½ -10 1¾-4
o.k.
2-2½
o.k.
4½-6
o.k.
Table 1 setting behaviour
6. Behavior at Loading In the synopsis of test results to the behaviour at loading it is recognisable that the prestressing force of Anchor B, C and E is distinctly higher than at Anchor Type A. The pre-stressing force of Anchor Type D varies between 0 and 14 kN. The ultimate load at static pull-out of Type C is the highest one with the smallest standard deviation, followed by Anchor A. The follow-up expansion did not work at all anchors of Anchor Type B, 3 of 5 anchors of Anchor Type D.
106
type of pre-stressing ultimate pull- follow-up ultimate pull-out ultimate shear anchor force out load, expansion load without load, standard standard tightening torque deviation, n=4 deviation, n=5 moment, n=2 A ~ 15 kN Fu,m = 61,9 kN o.k. Fu,m = 55,2 kN Vu,m = 100,6 kN v = 9,1 % Fu,m = 57,3 kN with v = 8,8 % follow-up expansion B ~ 32 - 40 kN Fu,m = 39,4 kN no follow- Fu,m = 37,0 kN Vu,m = 87,2 kN v = 11,6 % up Fu,m = 38,0 kN with v = 1,4 % expansion follow-up expansion C ~ 20 - 30 kN Fu,m = 63,9 kN o.k. Fu,m = 0,8 kN Vu,m = 82,3 kN v = 4,2 % Fu,m = 1,1 kN pull v = 3,2 % out by hand D ~ 0 - 14 kN Fu,m = 42,6 kN 3 of 5 Vu,m = 83,2 kN Fu,m = 2,0 kN v = 16,6 % without Fu,m = 2,0 kN no v = 4,6 % follow-up follow-up expansion expansion E ~ 35 - 40 kN Fu,m = 60,3 kN o.k. Fu,m = 45,4 kN Vu,m = 73,7 kN v = 9,3 % Fu,m = 59,6 kN with v = 1,3 % follow-up expansion Table 2 load behaviour The pull-out test without tightening torque moment simulates, that because of confined place a tightening with full torque moment is not or only partially possible. Here Anchor Type A, B and E demonstrated follow-up expansion and high pull-out forces. Anchor Type C and D exhibited no follow-up expansion and therefore low loads. The ultimate static shear load of Anchor A was the highest, this time followed by Type B.
7. Conclusion The tests of different expansion anchors demonstrates, that the Anchor Type A impresses with the clear and save function of the plastic collapsible section. The system is well calculable because of the small standard deviation of the results. All components are optimally adjusted to the setting procedure, pull-out and shear load. It has been shown, that a lot of parameters have to be considered to compare the behaviour of different anchors, especially under difficult conditions on construction site.
107
STUDY ON STANDARD TEST METHODS FOR POSTINSTALLED ANCHORS Yoji Hosokawa*, Katuhiko Nakano**, Yoshiki Oohaga***, Shigeru Usami****, Kiyoshi Imai***** * Technical Development Group, Maeda Corporation, Japan ** Institute for Structural Concrete, Science University of Tokyo, Japan *** Institute for Structural Concrete, Tohoku Institute of Technology, Japan **** Institute for Structural Engineering, Kajima Corporation, Japan ***** Institute for Post-Installed Anchor, KFC Corporation, Japan
Abstract The present paper reports the test methods and test results of Bonded anchors and Metal Anchors. So far, in Japan, Post-installed Anchors cannot be used for a newly-built building, but can be used to reinforce an existing building for earthquake resistance strengthening. There for, standards test methods are important to meet the requirement of appraisal system.
1. Introduction About 4 hundred millions of Post-installed Anchors are used for fitting up machineries and reinforcing earthquake resistant structures. In common, the performances of Post-installed Anchors are determined by the makers, and there is not a unified standard to evaluate the performances of such anchors. In order to guarantee the quality and performances of Post-installed Anchors, Japan Construction Anchor Association makes an Approval System for the technical appraisals. The present paper reports the standard mechanical test methods, by which the necessary data of strength and stiffness are determined for the Approval of Post-installed Anchors. So far, three test methods were developed, which are the Set test, Tensile strength test and Shear test. The Set test is a performance test for a constructed anchor, in which strength test for the base material and adhesive strength is necessary for metal anchors and bonded anchors respectively. While, the Tensile test and Shear test are carried out by measuring the strengths and displacements due to tension and shear forces act on test anchors, which was supposed that the test anchors were constructed anchors fixed in concrete.
108
2. Set Test Method 2.1 Set test for metal anchors 2.1.1 Introduction In common, Metal anchors are cold formed, and the properties of its material are changed during the products process. Stress concentration always happens at the expansion head of an anchor, due to the beating and pressing during construction. So, it is very important for the quality control to confirm the performance and its quality by the Set test before the products leave the factory. 2.1.2 Method of the Set test The Testing equipment is Fig. 2.1 shown in Fig. 2.1. The equipment is composed by Reaction plate, Oil jack and Deflection Transducer. The test anchors are Nail-in, Internal cone, Out Cone, the diameter of the test anchor is M10—M20. 150
2.1.3 Test results Fig. 2.2 shows the loaddisplacement curve of the tests. The displacement
No1M10 No2M10 No3M12 No4M12 No5M20 No6M20 No7M20
125
Tensile Load (KN)
The test anchor is set between a tension rod and a jig fixed onto the equipment, and then the jack applies the tension force on to the set. Just like the real construction, the jig is filled with nonshrink mortar (compressive strength: 30N/mm2). The jig is made by steel, and its inner shape is a cone.
M20 100 M12
75
P M10
50
l
δ2
l=50mm δ = (δ 1 +δ 2 ) / 2
25
0 0
δ1
2.5
5
7.5
10
12.5
15
Displacement (mm) Fig. Fig.2.2 Relationship of Tensile Load and Displacement (Outer Cone Type Anchor)
109
measuring points are 50mm and 100mm below the concrete surface for Out Cone and Nail-in type respectively. The broken locations are at the thread part for the cone anchor and Internal cone, minimum section or thread part for Nail-in type. 2.2 Set test for Bonded Anchor 2.2.1 Introduction By the Set test for bonded anchor, we measured the limited value of the bond strength of the anchors, and make a standard value for quality control of bonded anchors. Hence, the bonding surface of the anchor should be very homogenous. Steel jig and mortar filled steel jig are discussed, and then mortar filled steel jig are selected as a part of the testing equipment. Event for the test using old resin, we have not found the influence of aggregate in the steel jig. 2.2.2 The test method Fig. 2.3 shows the testing equipment and the jig. The jig is a steel pipe (89.1mm in diameter and 80mm in length) filled with non-shrink mortar. The test anchor is a bolt of M16 hammered into a bored hole in the jig. In such a bonding strength test, the object anchor was set on the tension rod, and tensile force was applied with a speed of 20N/mm2 per second by the oil jack till the anchor was pulled out of the jig. 3. The Tension test method 3.1 Introduction For this test, there is not a specification for the shape of the loading equipment. But, we set the inner dimension of the reaction plate food as shown in Table 3.1, considering the support position of the reaction plates have influence on the measures results of tension Fig. 2.3 performance of the anchor.
110
Table 3.1 Minimum Inner dimension of the reaction plate Broken Type of the anchors Metal anchors Cone broken type 3.5 h Not cone broken type 2.0 h
Bonded Anchors 2.0 h 1.5 h
Fig. 3.1 3.2 Testing equipment Fig.3.1 shows the testing equipment and its Deflection Transducer. There is not a specification for the dimension of the concrete object. We used common concrete, and its minimum thickness is double of the insert depth of the anchor in the concrete body, or the biggest value of the double of the insert depth and the depth plus 10cm (same as the Shear test). The tolerance of the load cell is less than 1.5%, and the maximum tension load acted on the load cell is 1/20 (5%) of its capability. The tolerance of the Deflection Transducer is less than 0.02mm. As showing in Fig. 3.1, three Deflection Transducers were set around the test anchor, which are 15mm from the concrete surface. The reference fix points are in a distance from the anchor, double of the insert depth of the anchor in the concrete body, and are set at the top and lateral surfaces where the influence due to the bending displacement of concrete can be considered as small enough.
111
3.3 The Test method For this test, a pre-load acted on the test anchor was introduced. The value of the pre-load is 5% of the maximum of a presumed load and smaller than 2.0KN. The load was acted at a loading speed smaller than 20N/mm2 per second. The measuring of load and displacements were continued till the anchor was broken. 3.4 Confirm the Test method In the present paper, the influence of pre-load and loading speed were discussed based on the tests for checking the validity of the test methods. Table 3.2 shows the types of the anchors and the out line of the test anchors. Table 3.2 Outline of Test Anchors Effective Effective Minimum Embedded Bolt Horizontal Calculated Embedded Anchor Type Nominal Diameter Section Length Length Project Aria Strength Ac (cm) Tc(kN) Diameter de (mm) (mm2) h (mm) Le(mm) Nail-in 16.0 119 60 44.0 82.9 130 M 16 Metal Internal Cone 20.0 127 60 40.0 75.4 119 M 16 Anchor Outer Cone 21.4 157 63 41.6 82.3 129 M 16 Type Hard Sleeve 21.7 157 60 38.3 72.2 114 M 16 Bonded Vinyl 16.0 157 125 109.0 427.8 506 M 16 Anchor Urethane Calculated Strength with Shear Cone Failure・ Tc=√ óB・ Ac( Metal Type) ・ Tc=0.75√ ó B・ Ac( Bonded Type) Here, óB: Concrete Strength at Test( 26N/mm2) Ac: Effective Horizontal Project Aria( c㎡) Le: Effective Embedded Length( cm) =h-de
The pre-load was applied with 3 load levels, which were a determined load level, 0% and 200% of the determined load level. And then, 3 loading speeds were used, which were a determined speed, 50% and 150% of the determined speed. The tests were carried out with an anchor hammered into concrete block (110cm
180cm
30cm, Fc = 21N/mm2) and set onto the testing equipment . 3.4.1 Influence of pre-load Fig. 3.2 shows the relationship between the pre-load and the capability. In this diagram, the average value of 3 test pieces with different levels is shown as folded line. The influence of pre-load is obvious for anchors of Hard Sleeve, and there is not obvious influence for other types of anchors.
112
4. Shear test 4.1 Introduction For this test, we set the test anchor at a certain distance from the concrete edge, so that the edge part the concrete would not break.
80 Hard Sleeve Type 60 40 80 Outer Cone Type Maxuium Load (KN)
3.4.2 Influence of loading speed Fig 3.3 shows that the capability increased proportionally to the loading speed for a bonded anchor. But, a little influence of loading speed was measured for Nail-in anchors, and almost no influence was measured for other types of anchors.
40
40 20
0 (0%)
1.96 3.92 (Stndard) (200%) Pre-force of Bolt Pre-load of Bolt (KN)(KN)
Fig. Pre-force Fig. 3.2 Relationship relationship ofofPre-load and Maximum Strength And Maximum strength 120 100 Maxuium Load (KN)
Tests were carried out for different types of anchors, with different lengths of setting-plate, and different material of shearing surfaces. The anchor types used for the tests are Internal cone, Hard Sleeve, Out Cone, Nail-in and bonded anchors. Lengths of setting-plate are 7.5 and 15.0 times of the diameter of the anchor. The Pre-load are shown in Table 4.1. The shearing surface is thin steel sheet, and Teflon sheet.
40 60 Internal Cone Type
20 60 Nail-in Type
4.2 The testing equipment Fig. 4.1 shows the loading equipment. The loading equipment is composed with a setting-plate for supplying shear forces onto the anchor, a tension rod, an oil jack and a load cell. 4.3 Tests for confirming the equipment The tests were carried out by the equipment shown in Fig. 4.1, with different lengths of setting-plate and shearing surface, different levels of pre-load and different types of anchors. The concrete strength used for the tests is Fc = 32.7KN/mm2, and the diameter of the anchor is 16mm.
60
Bonded Anchor Type
80 80 60
Hard Sleeve Type
40 60 40 20
Nail-in Type 9.8 19.6 29.4 (50%) (Upper Limit of Stndard) (150%) 2 Loading Speed N/mm ( N/mm2/sec /sec ) )
Fig. 3.3 Relationship of Loading Speed and Maximum Strength
113
Reaction Frame H-200x200
Teflon sheet Reaction Frame Tension Rod Setting Plate
Swivel Load Cell Jack
S p ec ime n Anchor Plate
M1 6 A n ch o r Reaction Pedestal
Spring Fastening Anchor Bolt
Fig.4.1 Equipment of Shear Laoding Test Table 4.1 indicates the types of anchors and other items for the test. In the test procedure, the concrete close to the anchor was broke first by its bearing stress, and then the anchor broke lately, which is the common phenomenon of the tests.
Table4.1 List of Shear Tsets Table Se tting P late To r que B o undary C o nditio n Le ngth Anc ho r Type N o n 120 240 ・ ・ SS T mm mm 0 kN N o te 1 N o te 2 SS +T M A1 ~ 4 M A1 M A2 M A3 M A4 ○ ○ M A5 ~ 8 M A5 M A6 M A7 M A8 ○ ○ H ar d Sle e ve M A9 ~ 1 2 M A9 M A1 0 M A1 1 M A1 2 ○ ○ M A1 3 ~ 1 6 M A1 3 M A1 4 M A1 5 M A1 6 ○ ○ M B1~ 2 O ute r Co ne M B1 M B2 ○ ○ M C1 Inte rnal C o ne ○ ○ ○ M D1 N ail-in ○ ○ ○ B o nde d Anc ho r B A1 ~ 3 B A1 B A2 ,3 ○ ○ N o te 1 : To rque= M in. [ 6 0 % o f Yie ld Stre ngth, 4 0 % o f Shear-C o rn failure Stre ngth, 4 0 % o f B o nd Stre ngth ] , The To rque is c o ntro lle d by the 0 .2 to rque c o e f fic ie nt. H ar d Slee ve : To r que Value 2 3 5 N ・ m m (Axis fo rc e 7 .3 5 K N ) O ute r Co ne : To rque Value 2 2 5 N ・ m m (Axis fo rc e 7 .0 5 K N ) Bo nde d Anco r: To rque Value 2 2 5 N ・ m m (Axle Fo rc e 7 .0 5 K N ) BA2 : To rque Value 6 5 6 N ・ m m (Axle Fo rc e 2 0 .4 8 K N ) B A3 N o te 2 : Bo undary C o nditio n: N o n-she e t SS is Ste el She e t. T is Te flo n She e t. Metal Anchor
Spe cim e n N am e
114
60
Shear Load Q (KN)
50
MA2-2(Steel Sheet)
MA1-1(Non-Sheet)
40 30 20 MA4-2(Steel + Teflon Sheet)
10 0 -2
MA3-2(Teflon Sheet)
0
2
4
6
8
10
Shear Deflectionδ (mm) Fig. Fig.4.2 Relationship Example of Shear Load and Displacement (Boundary Condition)
[1] Influence of concrete surface situation and setting-plate: The test anchor is Hard Sleeve, and take setting-plate (120mm in length) and 4 types of concrete surface situation as the items of the test. The test result are shown in Fig.4.2. The concrete surface situation (1) Bare concrete surface (2) Concrete surface covered by steel sheet (3) Concrete surface covered by Teflon sheet of 2mm in thickness (4) The composing of (2) and (3) Fig. 4.2 shows the difference of stiffness and capability depend on the situation of the concrete surface. Fig. 4.3 shows the result with different lengths of setting-plate, and that the capability and stiffness are increased with the increasing of the setting-plate lengths. [2] The influence of the pre-load Fig 4.4 shows the displacement-strength cure of Hard Sleeve due to torques of “0” and 235N・mm respectively. By this diagram, we found that there was not influence of the torque.
115
60
MA1-1(120mm)
MA9-3(240mm)
Shear Load Q (KN)
50 40 30 20
MA1-1(240mm)
10
MA3-2(120mm)
0 -2
0
2
4
6
8
10
Shear Deflectionδ (mm) Fig. Fig.4.3 Relationship Example of Shear Load and Displacement (Setting Plate Length)
60
Shear Load Q (KN)
50
M A 7-2 (3 .5K N )
40 30 20 M A 3-2(A xis For c e 0K N )
10 0 -2
0
2
4
6
8
10
Sh ear D e flection δ (m m ) Fig. F ig.4.4 R elations hip E xa m ple of S hear Loa d a nd D is pla cem e nt (A xis Fo rc e)
Fig. 4.5 shows the test results of bonded anchor, which is a comparison between three torques, “0”, 225N・mm and 656N・mm. The maximum of stiffness increased with the increasing of the pre-load.
116
60 BA2-1(3.5KN)
Shear Load Q (KN)
50 40
BA1-1(0 KN)
30 20
BA3-1(10.3KN)
10 0 -2
0
2
4
6
8
10
Shear Deflectionδ (mm) Fig. 4.5 Relationship Example of Shear Load and Displacement Fig. (Axis Force)
5. Conclusion 1. 2. 3. 4.
We demonstrated that it is possible to confirm the performances of metal anchors and bonded anchors by set test method before the products leave the factories. For the tension tests, the influence of pre-load is very small besides the test for Hard Sleeve anchors. Besides the Nail-in anchors, almost no influence of loading speed on the capability was found. Henceforth, we will study the in situ test methods for the anchors.
Acknowledgement I am grateful to Dr. R. Tanaka (Tohoku Institute of Technology), Dr. Y. Matsuzaki (Science University of Tokyo) and JCAA for their good cooperation throughout the research. And then, I would like to thank Dr. Pei Shan Chen (Meada Co.) for his help with composing this paper.
117
STATIC BEHAVIOR OF ANCHORS UNDER COMBINATIONS OF TENSION AND SHEAR LOADING Dieter Lotze*, Richard E. Klingner** and Herman L. Graves, III*** *Director of Research, Halfen GmbH & Co., Wiernsheim, Germany. Former, The University of Texas at Austin. **Phil M. Ferguson, The University of Texas at Austin, Texas, USA ***Office of Nuclear Regulatory Research, US Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Washington, DC, USA.
Abstract Under the sponsorship of the US Nuclear Regulatory Commission, a research program was carried out on the dynamic behavior of anchors (fasteners) to concrete. This paper deals with the static behavior of single and multiple undercut and sleeve anchors, placed in uncracked concrete and loaded by combinations of tension and shear. The results are used to draw conclusions regarding force and displacement interaction diagrams for single anchors, and regarding the applicability of elastic and plastic theory to the design of multiple-anchor connections to concrete.
1. Introduction Under the sponsorship of the US Nuclear Regulatory Commission, a research program has recently been completed, whose objective was to obtain technical information to determine how the seismic behavior and strength of anchors (cast-in-place, expansion, and undercut) and their supporting concrete differ from the static behavior. The research program comprised four tasks: 1) 2) 3) 4)
Static and Dynamic Behavior of Single Tensile Anchors (250 tests); Static and Dynamic Behavior of Multiple Tensile Anchors (179 tests); Static and Dynamic Behavior of Near-Edge Anchors (150 tests); and Static and Dynamic Behavior of Multiple-Anchor Connections (16 tests).
This paper deals with part of Task 2, concerning the static behavior of single and multiple undercut and sleeve anchors, placed in uncracked concrete and loaded by combinations of tension and shear. The results are used to draw conclusions regarding force and displacement interaction diagrams for single anchors, and regarding the applicability of elastic and plastic theory to the design of multiple-anchor connections to concrete.
118
2. Background The behavior of anchors (fasteners) to concrete is discussed at length in Reference 1. The work of Fuchs [2] provides some useful information regarding shear behavior. As discussed in Reference 3, mean concrete breakout capacity in tension or shear is well predicted by the CC Method. Tensile capacity as governed by steel failure is given by the product of the ultimate tensile strength and the cross-sectional area of the anchor shank. For a uniform cross-section, the ratio of shear to tensile capacity is about 0.6 [4]. If the anchor sleeve goes through the baseplate, steel capacity in shear is increased, by an amount that depends on the degree of interaction between the anchor shank and sleeve, and the material of each component. Figure 1 shows different models for the interaction of tension and shear capacities. 1.2 1 Elliptical (5/3)
N/No
0.8 0.6
Tri-linear
0.4
Linear
0.2 0 0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
1.2
V/Vo
Figure 1
Tension – shear force interaction for anchors
For failure by steel fracture, an elliptical interaction is used: p
p
N V + = 1 N 0 V0
(1)
The exponent p varies between 5/3 [5] and 2.0 [6]. For failure by concrete breakout, Johnson and Lew [7] propose a linear interaction as a lower bound (Figure 1). Bode and Roik [8] propose a tri-linear interaction (Equations 2a through 2c):
N = 1 N0
119
(2a)
V = 1 V0 N V + = 1 N 0 V0
(2b)
(2c)
The elliptical interaction of Equation 2 has been proposed for concrete failure as well, using an exponent p equal to 4/3 [9], 5/3 [4], or 2.0 [6]. Displacement interaction has not been widely investigated [10], and is in theory not required for the elastic design procedure, in which no redistribution of anchor forces is assumed. If redistribution of anchor forces is assumed, as in the plastic design approach, then knowledge of displacement interaction is necessary.
3. Anchors, Test Setups and Procedures Based on surveys of existing anchors in nuclear applications, tests described here involved one undercut anchor (“UC1”) and a heavy-duty, sleeve-type, single-cone expansion anchor (“Sleeve Anchor”). Based on current use in nuclear applications, it was decided to test anchors ranging in diameter from 3/8 to 1 in. (9.2 to 25.4 mm), with emphasis on the 3/4 in. (19.1 mm) diameter. The Sleeve Anchor tested throughout this study is a single-cone, sleeve-type expansion anchor with follow-up expansion capability, shown in Figure 2. expansion sleeve structurally funished surface cone
D
lef
Figure 2
D2
plastic crushable leg
D1
spacer sleeve
lc
Key dimensions of Sleeve Anchor
The Undercut Anchor 1 (UC1) opens conventionally, and is shown in Figure 3.
120
extension sleeve
expansion sleeve
D
lef
Figure 3
D2
cone
D1
threaded shank
lc
Key dimensions of Undercut Anchor 1
Embedment depths in Task 2 were varied according to whether steel failure or concrete breakout failure was desired. The embedments used are described when each set of test results is discussed. The target concrete compressive strength for this testing program was 4700 lb/in.2 (32.4 MPa), with a permissible tolerance of ±500 lb/in.2 (±3.45 MPa) at the time of testing. For these tests, a porous limestone aggregate was used. The typical test specimen was a concrete block 39.5 in. (1 m) wide, 24 in. (0.6 m) deep, and 87.5 in. (2.2 m) long. Seven #6 (32 mm) longitudinal reinforcing bars were placed in the middle of each block to provide safety when the block was moved. This reinforcement was placed at the mid-height of the block to permit testing anchors on both the top and bottom surfaces, while precluding interference with anchor behavior. Four lifting loops were located at the mid-height of the blocks, permitting transport by overhead crane. For loading anchors under combinations of tension and shear, the test setup consisted of a structural steel framework holding a center-hole actuator at a variable angle (Figure 4). Load was applied through a special loading shoe, shown in Figure 5. For eccentric shear tests on two-anchor attachments, the loading fixture consisted of a special baseplate with two high-strength steel inserts, two tension rods, and two compression bars (Figure 6). The inside thickness of these inserts was counter-bored to 3/4 in. (19 mm), the same as the diameter of the anchor bolts. The diameter of the baseplate holes was 13/16 in. (20.6 mm). The overall test setup is shown in Figure 7.
121
actuator angle varies
steel frame
anchor
Figure 4
Test setup for anchors loaded at different orientations hole for mounting pin
30 deg
60 deg welded side plate baseplate screwed-in insert made of high-strength steel
Figure 5
Special loading shoe for tests at different orientations
122
External Load Strain Gages
Compression Bars
Tension Rods
Inserts Strain Gages 5 deg Plan view of base plate Elevation
Figure 6
Loading fixture for eccentric shear tests on two-anchor attachments
Loading Attachment
Load DCDT Cell
Hydraulic Actuator
Clamping Beams Concrete Specimen
Restraint Tubes
Rollers Reaction Frame
Additional W12 Beams
Figure 7
--- Lab Floor ---
Tie-Down Rods On Floor
Setup for eccentric shear tests on two-anchor attachments
The axial force and bending moment in the baseplate were calculated from strain measurements from two sets of three strain gauges each, evenly spaced on the top and bottom of the center section of the baseplate. Based on the geometry of the loading apparatus, the force in the tension rods is 1.2 times the external shear load, and the tension force on the back anchor can be calculated by equilibrium of moments about the center of the baseplate. The shear force on the back anchor equals the measured tension force in the baseplate. External load on the connection was measured with a load cell, using a spherical bearing to eliminate error due to angular deviation. The tension forces
123
on each anchor were measured with force washers placed between the normal washers and the baseplate. Baseplate slip was measured with a potentiometer placed against the back of the baseplate. The horizontal displacement of the loaded point 12 in. (305 mm) from the surface was also measured. The vertical displacement of the baseplate, δv, was measured at the centerline of the baseplate. Rotation of the attachment was calculated from the difference between the transverse displacements measured at the level of the baseplate and at 12 in. (305 mm) above the concrete surface.
4. Test Results Results for Single Anchors Loaded at Different Orientations (Series 2.3 and 2.4) Figure 8 shows the mean force interaction diagrams for Sleeve and Expansion anchors in Series 2.3 [11]. In that series, anchor failure was intended to be governed by yield and fracture of anchor steel, so deep embedments were used. Interaction of Load, Series 23 140
Series 23H64, Exp. = 1.8 Series 23M53 / 54, Exp. = 1.8
Vertical Load Component [ kN ]
120
Series 23M74 / 23H74, Exp. = 1.8 Series 23M34, Exp. = 1.67
100 80 60 40 20 0 0
50
100
150
200
Horizontal Load Component [ kN ]
Figure 8
Interaction curves for actions (Test Series 2.3, [11])
Mean displacement interaction curves for all sub-series in Series 2.3 and 2.4 are compared in Figure 9. That figure shows large displacements in Series 23M53 under tension, approaching the values achieved in higher strength concrete with increased load angle or increased shear. It also shows good agreement between the values for UC1 and the Sleeve Anchor. Differences are evident, however, due to installation method (through-sleeve versus flush-sleeve). Under pure tension, displacements are identical. Under oblique loading, anchors installed with flush sleeves generated smaller shell-
124
shaped concrete spalling in the loading direction in front of anchors, than did otherwise identical anchors with through sleeves. For this reason, they failed under shear and oblique tension by shear fracture of the anchor shank at a comparatively small shearing deformation. With lower concrete strength, larger displacements were achieved at maximum load under tension. These approach the displacements in higher-strength concrete with increasing shear. Tests with 3/8 in. anchors showed smaller displacements, and no concrete spalling in front of the anchors under shear and oblique tension.
Vertical Displacement at Maximum Load (mm)
45 23H64, EAII, M16, flush-sleeve installation 23H74, EAII, M16, through-sleeve installation 23M54, UC1, 5/8 in., flush-sleeve installation 23M74, UC1, 5/8 in., through-sleeve installation 23M53, UC1, 5/8 in., flush-sleeve installation 23M34, UC1, 3/8 in., flush-sleeve installation
40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5 0 0
5
10
15
20
25
30
Horizontal Displacement at Maximum Load (mm)
Figure 9
Interaction curves for displacements (Series 2.3 and 2.4, [11])
Discussion of Results for Eccentric Shear Loading on Two-Anchor Attachments Despite the differences in gaps between anchors and baseplates among specimens, failure loads showed only slight scatter. In contrast, considerable scatter was observed in displacements, without any obvious correlation with the measured gaps. The gaps, however, did significantly affect the failure mode. In tests with an eccentricity of 18 in. (457 mm), failure always occurred by fracture at the outermost tension anchor. In tests with an eccentricity of 12 in. (305 mm) the shear anchors also fractured. The tension anchor fractured only with maximum gaps of the shear anchors. Normal force and bending moment in the baseplate were calculated from the results of the strain measurement. Strains are approximately constant over the width of the baseplate, due to its configuration. The bending moments and axial forces in the baseplate can be calculated from those strains. Axial force in the baseplate (equal to the
125
shear in the tension anchor) increases with the applied load. After the gap at the shear anchor is overcome, this increase slows, and the axial force even decreases near ultimate. When the shear anchor fractures, the axial normal force increases abruptly, because the applied shear must then be resisted entirely by the tension anchor. The hogging bending moment in the baseplate (tensile stresses on top) decreases with increasing external load, changing finally to a reversed moment caused by a combination of the diagonal compression (at the height of the axis of the shear anchor) and the support reaction from the concrete (at the compression edge of the baseplate). The fracture of the shear anchors causes an additional negative moment from the additional normal force of the tension anchor, applied eccentrically to the bottom edge of the baseplate. Observed versus Predicted Capacities for Two-Anchor Attachments with Eccentric Shear Loading The loading eccentricity used for these attachments was such that the tension anchors were required to resist combined shear and tension. Under these conditions, their load capacity could be limited either by load, or by deformation. Ratios of observed capacities to those predicted by elastic theory ranged from 0.954 to 1.154. Ratios of observed capacities to those predicted by plastic theory [4] ranged from 0.892 to 1.05.
5. Conclusions Tests on Single Anchors Loaded at Different Orientations 1) Force interaction is well described by an elliptical interaction relationship (Equation 1), with an exponent of 1.67 to 1.80 for steel failure and 1.6 for concrete breakout. 2) The displacement interaction diagram for steel fracture is bulb-shaped; that is, the shearing displacement at failure under oblique tension is larger than under pure shear. This is due to larger spalling under oblique tension in the direction of the shear, in front of the anchor. 3) Failure by steel fracture and ductile behavior of the steel of anchor shank do not by themselves guarantee ductile connection behavior. Brittle fracture of the anchor shank can still occur. Low steel strength, small anchor diameters, flush-sleeve installation, and high-strength concrete lead to small deformation capacity, particularly if shear dominates. 4) Ductile fractures will be achieved, in principle, if the maximum possible steel strength of the anchor is reached. Therefore, connections with large edge distance, high-strength yet ductile steels, and through-sleeve installation (sleeve extending to the top surface of baseplate) are recommended. Eccentric Shear Tests on Two-Anchor Connections 1) For large eccentricity in shear (capacity governed by fracture of the tension anchor), plastic theory accurately predicts connection behavior and capacity.
126
2) At lower eccentricities of applied shear, the bulb-shaped interaction curve for displacements causes a failure transition from the tension anchor to the shear anchor. At this point both shear anchors and tension anchors are fully utilized, and the assumptions of plastic theory agree with the actual behavior of the connection. 3) At still lower eccentricities of applied shear, the transverse displacement of the tension anchor cannot exceed the transverse displacement of the shear anchor. For that reason, the tension anchors of a multiple-anchor connection cannot reach the fracture states in the “belly” of the displacement interaction curve. Contrary to the assumptions of plastic theory, this causes the strength of the tension anchor to be under-utilized at small loading eccentricities. Depending on how pronounced the “belly” of the interaction curve is, the calculated capacity of the group can be considerably overestimated by plastic theory, or even by elastic theory. Lotze [11] proposes that this problem be corrected by assuming an even distribution of shear to all anchors.
6. Acknowledgment and Disclaimer This paper presents partial results of a research program supported by the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) (NUREG/CR-5434, “Anchor Bolt Behavior and Strength during Earthquakes”). The technical contact is Herman L Graves, III, whose support is gratefully acknowledged. The conclusions in this paper are those of the authors only, and are not NRC policy or recommendations.
7. References 1.
CEB, “Fastenings to Reinforced Concrete and Masonry Structures: State-of-the-Art Report, Part 1,” Euro-International Concrete Committee (CEB), August 1991.
2.
Fuchs, W., “Tragverhalten von Befestigungen unter Querlast in ungerissenem Beton,” Dissertation, Universität Stuttgart, 1990.
3.
Fuchs, W., Eligehausen and R. and Breen, J. E., “Concrete Capacity Design (CCD) Approach for Fastening to Concrete,” ACI Structural Journal, Vol. 92, No. 1, January-February, 1995, pp. 73-94.
4.
Cook, R. A. and Klingner, R. E. “Ductile Multiple-Anchor Steel-to-Concrete Connections,” Journal of Structural Engineering, Vol. 118, No. 6, June 1992, pp. 1645-1665.
5.
McMackin, P. J., Slutter, R. G. and Fishere, J. W., “Headed Steel Anchor under Combined Loading,” Engineering Journal, AISC, Vol. 10, No. 2, April, 1973.
6.
Shaikh, A. and Whayong, Y., “In-place Strength of Welded Headed Studs,” Journal of the Prestressed Concrete Institute, 1985 pp. 56-81.
127
7.
Johnson, M. and Lew, H., “Experimental Study of Post-Installed Anchors under Combined Shear and Tension Loading,” Anchorage to Concrete, SP-103, American Concrete Institute, Detroit, Michigan, 1987.
8.
Bode, H. and Roik, K., “Headed Studs Embedded in Concrete and Loaded in Tension,” Anchorage to Concrete, SP-103, American Concrete Institute, Detroit, Michigan, 1987, pp. 61-88.
9.
PCI Design Handbook - Precast and Prestressed Concrete, 3rd Edition, Prestressed Concrete Institute, Chicago, 1985.
10. Dieterle, H., Bozenhardt, A., Hirth, W. and Opitz V., “ Tragverhalten von nicht generell zugzonentauglichen Dübeln, Teil 4: Verhalten im unbewegten Parallelriß unter Schrägzugbelastung,” Bericht Nr. 1/45 - 89/19, Institut für Werkstoffe im Bauwesen, Universität Stuttgart, 1989. 11. Lotze, D. and Klingner, R. E., “Behavior of Multiple-Anchor Connections to Concrete From the Perspective of Plastic Theory,” PMFSEL Report No. 96-4, The University of Texas at Austin, March 1997.
128
IMPROVED STRUCTURAL MODEL FOR CHANNEL BARS WITH MORE THAN 2 ANCHORS Josef Kraus, Joško Ožbolt, Rolf Eligehausen Institute of Construction Materials, University of Stuttgart, Germany
Abstract At present, no model is available to describe concrete failure of channel bars with several anchor distances and for the general position of tensile loads. To examine this problem, an Finite Element-analysis of channel bars (profil 50/30) with several anchor distances has been carried out with various load positionings. Based on the results of the numerical study, a new design model for channel bars with more than two anchors, is proposed.
1. Introduction In current engineering practice, no design code for fastening elements exists. Consequently, the conditions for the use of channel bars are controlled by general building authority approvals. In these approvals, the limit values of the edge distances in concrete elements, the application of loads and the minimal member sizes are recommended. The regulations do not offer a possibility for a general design of channel bars. They reflect a structural framework of demands, which limit the variability of possible applications and often leads to not very efficient and economical solutions. Therefore, there is an obvious need for design rules, which should account for the specific geometrical and loading conditions. These rules have to assure safer and more economical fastenings. With channel bars there are principal two different kinds of failure modes: (1) concrete failure and (2) steel failure. The steel failure is to a large extent clarified. However, to better understand the concrete failure mechanism of channel bars with 3 or more anchors, additional investigations are needed. Therefore, a new model should be developed, in which the critical anchor is obtained on a system of a single-span beams. So, the influence on the single anchors can be determined and compared with the characteristical resistance of the considered anchor. The resistance of the anchor is calculated
129
based on the concept of the influencing area. Depending on the system, loads can be transferred from the considered anchor, due to the stiffness and degree of constraint of the channel, to the neighbour anchor with respecting their loading condition. For better understanding the failure of channel bars, Finite Element studies have been carried out. The analysis is useful to predict the structural behaviour of channel bars with any loading conditions (e.g. load distribution on the anchors, influenced area of each anchor). Based on the results of the parametric study, a new design model for channel bars with more than two anchors is proposed.
2. Channel Bars In engineering practice channel bars are used for fastening of facing masonry, at the mounting of claddings, for fastening of pipe systems, for the ground fastening engines and other applications.
Figure 2.1: Channel bar with bolt anchors Channel bars are made in cold-rolled or hot-rolled U-shaped steel. They are filled up with foaming agent, fixed in the formwork and casted into concrete. After removing the formwork and the foaming agent the construction members can be fixed with special hammer- or by hook bolts.
Figure 2.2: Hook bolt with channel bar The advantage of this method for fixing is, that the point of loading in direction of the channel bar, must not been known before. Consequently the system is very flexible. The
130
disadvantage of the system is, that the insertion of the channel bar has to be planned exactly. The screw can freely be moved along the channel bar and the load can be so transmitted to the channel bar. At the lower side of the channel bar headed studs are welded and they are responsible for the transmission of the load into the concrete. Several versions are available: welded I-shaped anchors clench anchors swaged headed studs The single bolts are connected by the U-shaped profile. The anchor rail itself cannot transfer loads into the concrete. The load can only be transferred to concrete by the anchors. A general topic to be discussed is, how the geometrical parameters and position of load influence the structural behaviour. The main parameters are the spacing of the anchors, the edge distance, the position of the load, the angle of load, the embedment depth and the size of the channel bar.
3. Concrete failure 3.1 Design method (CCD-method) When the steel strength is high enough, most fasteners lead under axial tension load to a concrete cone failure of a specimen. The inclination of the cone surface is between 30° and 40° measured to the direction of load. With increasing embedment depth the inclination of angle increases up to approximately 45°. The tensile resistance under the load is distributed differentially over the concrete cone. At the point of origin of the concrete cone, directly at the head of the anchor, the tensile strains are maximal and they decrease by reaching the surface of concrete. Based on a number of tests, the failure load of headed studs with large edge distances and large spacing of the anchors, can be calculated as:
N 0u ,c = 15,5 ⋅ h 1ef,5 ⋅ β w
(1)
with: hef = embedment depth [mm] βw = concrete compressive strength [N/mm2] The resistance calculated by equation (1) can only be achieved, if there is a sufficient concrete surface for each fastener. If the fastener is put close to the edge of the structural member or if a neighbour fastener is too close, the cones are overlapping. The characteristic spacing for an anchor group is s = 3 ⋅ hef. To transfere the maximum load of a fastener, the minimum edge distance must be at least 1,5 ⋅ hef. To estimate the concrete capacity of anchor groups and fastenings close to the edge of the building component, the mentioned influences are considered in the CCD-Method (Concrete Capacity De-
131
sign). In this method, the concrete cone is idealized as a rectangular projection of the concrete cone, on the concrete surface. By groups of anchors within the CCD-Method it is assumed that the anchor plate is sufficient stiff, to distribute the loads uniformly on all anchors. The group effect is taken into account by the formula.
N u ,c = with: Ac,n0
A c,N A
0 c,N
⋅ ψ s, N ⋅ N u0 , c
(2)
projected area of each single fastener with large edge distance and spacing. The concrete cone is idealized as a pyramide with the height hef and a length of the basis scr,n = 3 ⋅ hef .
Ac,n
actual projected area of the concrete cone on the concrete surface. The limits of the area are the overlapping of the single cones of the next fasteners and the edges.
ψs,n
= 0,7 + 0,3 ⋅ c/ccr,N edge distances c of a fastener; ccr,N edge distances required, to guarantee that a complete concrete cone can be developed, and so the tension of equation (1) with ccr,N = 1,5 ⋅ hef can be transmitted.
Nu,c0
resistance of a single anchor (1)
The ratio Ac,n/A0c,n considers the geometrical influence of the edge and further fasteners next to the calculated fastening group. An additional reduction of the concrete capacity is given by the factor ψs,n. It considers the disturbance of the radial-symmetric stress distribution. For fastenings without edge influence (c ≥ 1,5 hef) the factor is ψs,n = 1,0. This means that there is no disturbing influence of the radial-symmetric stress distribution. 3.2 Application of the CCD-method for channel bars By the calculation of the capacity of the anchor ground with a channel bar it is assumed, that by designing of each single anchor the design rules of headed studs can be used [1]. According to the method, the capacity of the anchor ground of channel bars with more than 2 anchors with any positions of single loads, is designed as follows. Each span of the channel bar can be considered as a single span beam (Figure 3.1).
132
s
s
s
s
Figure 3.1: Channel bar as a system of single span beams The model should be used for spacings s of the anchors. The resistance is for each anchor calculated with respect of the actual influencing area i.e. according to (2). Ac,N 3 hef
s/2 + 1,5 hef
s
s
s
s/2 + 1,5 hef
Figure 3.2: Determination of the characteristical anchor resistances with respect of the influencing area. The above model is for channel bar only realisable, if the bar is stiff or the spacing of anchors relatively small. Therefore the model need to be improved.
4. Modelling of a specimen with channel bar 4.1 General To better understand the failure of channel bars a FE-analysis with the program MASA has been carried out. The FE-program MASA has been developed at the Institute of Construction Materials, University of Stuttgart and is aimed to be used for three dimensional linear and non-linear analysis structures of quasi-brittle materials, especially of concrete. The concrete is discretisized with 8-node solid elements. The channel bar is also discretisized by volume elements with steel material parameters. To discretisize the contact between channel bar and concrete, special contact elements are used which transfer only compressive forces. The load is applied incrementally by displacement control. For the graphical analysis mesh generation and analysis of the results, the pre- and postprocessor FEMAP® is used. Former investigations showed, that the symmetric part of the specimen can be used (Figure 4.1) to reduce the number of elements, what leads to a shorter calculation time.
133
modelled area
Figure 4.1: Channel bar with 5 anchors and the modelled area 4.2 Modelling The concrete and steel are modelled separately. The mesh of the concrete and the steel elements has to be similar, to be able to connect both. Figure 4.2 shows a concrete member with the size length 1800 mm, edge distance c = 75 mm and spacing of the anchors of s = 300 mm with using the double symmetrie of the system. In the concrete member an acavity for the channel bar of the profile 50/30 with 5 anchors can be seen. The steel is although modelled with 5 anchors, the elementation is similar to the concrete.
position of load
Z Y X
Figure 4.2: Specimen for 5 anchors (¼ of the specimen)
Figure 4.3: FE-model of a channel bar profile 50/30 with 5 anchors (¼ of the bar)
The load is applicated in direction of the z-axis and it’s position is at the top of the channel. The load, which is applied as a displacement onto the channel bar, is first transferred to the anchors. From the anchors the tensile force is transferred into the concrete. The transmission occurs at the head of the anchor, where the elements of steel and concrete are connected to each other.
load transfer nodes (channel bar - concrete) Z
Figure 4.4: Back view of a channel bar with bolt and the load transfer nodes
134
The rest of the nodes of the bolt are not connected to the concrete. They have a distance of 0,1 mm to the concrete nodes. To avoid load transfer, the vertical nodes of the channel bar, are also at the distance of 0,1 mm measured from the surface of the concrete member. Under load the channel lifts from the concrete surface. At some positions between channel bar and concrete, pressure caused by bending of the channel, can be transferred. To model the real contact between channel bar and concrete, special contact elements are used. The mesh of these elements is similar to the concrete and channel elements. The tensile stress which can be transferred from steel to concrete is very low (tensile strength of interface elements is close to zero). The thickness of the contact elements is 2 mm.
Figure 4.5: Contact between steel and concrete concrete channel bar
Z
contact elements
Y X
anchor
Figure 4.6: FE-model of a specimen
5. Numerical investigations of channel bars with 5 anchors 5.1 General The aim of the calculations is, to investigate the concrete failure of a channel bar for different loading positions. Totally predict 22 Finite-Element-Calculations with spacings of the anchors of s = 100 mm and s = 300 mm are carried out. The profile 50/30 (width, height of the channel) with an embedment depth of hef = 85 mm was analysed. The diameter of the bolt was d1 = 16 mm, the diameter of the head of the bolt was d2 = 24 mm. The protrusion of the channel in direction of the channel length was u = 300 mm. With the chosen protrusion of the channel, the corner influence should be avoided. At the calculations with a spacing of the anchors of s = 300 mm ≥ 3 ⋅ hef = 255 mm, there is no interaction between the anchors to be expected. At a spacing of s = 100 mm = 1,18 ⋅ hef there is a strong influence between the anchors,
135
with respect to the transmission of load. In all calculations the edge distance on both sides was choosed c2 = c3 = 75 mm. The concrete properties are summarised in table 1. Concrete compressive strength Fc,cube200 [N/mm²] 29,4
Concrete compressive strength Fc,cylinder [N/mm²] 25,0
Concrete tensile strength ft [N/mm²]
Fracture energy GF
E-Modulus
[N/mm]
[N/mm²]
2,0
0,08
28000
Table 1: Concrete parameters The material model of the steel of the channel bar is supposed as linear elastic with an E-modulus of 210000 N/mm². I.e. in all cases concrete failure causes the system failure. The load on the channel bar is always symmetric to the middle anchor with 2 single loads (Figure 5.1). The distance of the single load to the middle anchor is signed with x. The position of load was varied between x = 0 mm (over the middle anchor A) and x = 100 mm respectively x = 300 mm (over the anchor B). x
C (le.)
B (le.)
s
s
x
A
B (ri.) s
C (ri.)
s
Figure 5.1: Designation of the anchors The supports in z-direction were placed at the concrete surface. The displacement was applied incrementally on the channel bar. The increment size was 0,05 mm. 5.2 Results of the calculations for spacing s = 300 mm Different load positions are investigated for a spacing of the anchors of s = 300 mm, and the maximum loads of the anchors are compared with each other. The anchor load B is shown only once, but it actually acts 2 times in the system, caused by the symmetry. The difference between the sum of the anchor loads and the system load, is a result of the minimum tensile capacity of the contact elements. Figures 5.2a and b show crack development at the maximum load of the first broken anchor. The failure is caused by a horizontal crack to the edge of the concrete member. As can be seen from the crack development for load position x = 0 mm, only the middle anchor A is activated. For load position x = 200 mm both anchors (A and B) are activated.
136
0.01 0.00833 0.00667 0.005 0.00333 0.00167 0. Z
Z
Y
Y
X Output Set: MASA3 A10073 Contour: Avrg.Ez stra.
X Output Set: MASA3 A1096 Contour: Avrg.Ez stra.
Figure 5.2a: Cracks pattern, x = 0 mm
Figure 5.2b: Cracks pattern, x = 200 mm
40
40
35
35
Anchor load A, B [kN]
Anchor load A, B [kN]
In the Figures 5.3a and b the load distribution on the single anchors is shown. At load position x = 0 mm only anchor A is activated, then at about 75 % of the maximal anchor load, the anchors B are also activated. The load of the anchors B can nearly be neglected. The system failure is caused by failure of anchor A. In comparison with load position x = 200 mm from the beginning, the middle anchor A and the anchors B are activated. At maximum load of the system the anchors A and B take up almost the same load. The failure of the system is caused by concrete failure of the anchors A and B (ri./ le.).
30 25 20 anchor load A anchor load B
15 10
30 25 20 15 anchor load A anchor load B
10 5
5
0
0 0
10
20
30
40
50
0
60
Figure 5.3a: Anchor loads, x = 0 mm
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
Systemload [kN]
Systemload [kN]
Figure 5.3b: Anchor loads, x = 200 mm
Figure 5.4 shows, that by loading above position x = 0 mm the ultimate load of the system is nearly the same, as the ultimate load of a single anchor. Load position x = 200 mm shows, that the systemload is 3-times the load of the anchor acting at x = 0 mm. At the load positions from x = 0 mm to x = 50 mm the middle anchor carries about 97 % of the total load. The neighbour anchors get only 3 % of the total load. Beginning at position x = 150 mm the load in the system is better distributed. The anchors B take up at load position x = 150 mm 63,5 % of the maximum load and the middle anchor only 36,5 %. This tendency maintains up to load position x = 200 mm. At position x = 200 mm the anchors A and B are activated at the same size. From load position x = 200 mm on, activation of anchor A is decreasing. As a result between x = 200 mm and 300 mm the
137
systemload becomes lower. 140
Systemload [kN]
120 100 80 systemload anchor load A anchor load B
60 40 20 0 0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
Distance of loading point from middle anchor [mm]
Figure 5.4: Anchor loads and maximum load for different load positions At position x = 300 mm the systemload is 2 times higher than the load from position x = 0 mm. The results show, that for s = 300 mm when load is applied directly over an anchor, only that anchor can be activated. Generally can be seen, that the maximum anchor load of a single anchor is reached at 32 kN. This gives a maximal (optional) resistance if all anchors are directly loaded. This shows a good agreement between the calculated loads and the CCD-method. The analysis shows, that for s = 300 mm there is no interaction between the anchors. The results are in good agreement with the CCDmethod (34 kN), only if the load is applied directly over the anchor. 5.3 Results of the calculations for spacing s = 100 mm The representation of the results of the calculations with different load positions and spacing of the anchors of s = 100 mm is corresponding to section 5.2. The Figures 5.5a and b show crack development at the maximum. The maximum load is controlled by a horizontal crack in direction to the edge of the concrete member and a connecting crack between the heads of the anchors. From the crack development it can be seen, that at load position x = 0 mm the anchors A and B are activated and for the load position x = 75 mm the anchor C is activated as well. After peek load the anchors will break by concrete cone failure.
138
0.01 0.00833 0.00667 0.005 0.00333 0.00167 0. Z
Z
Y
Y
X Output Set: MASA3 C7055 Contour: Avrg.Ez stra.
X Output Set: MASA3 C1053 Contour: Avrg.Ez stra.
Figure 5.5a: Crack pattern, x = 0 mm
Figure 5.5b: Crack pattern, x = 75 mm
In the Figures 5.6a and b the load distribution of the individual anchors is shown. At load position x = 0 mm anchor A carries the highest part of the acting load. In comparison with the channel bar with large spacing of the anchors the anchors B and C are activated as well (see Figure 5.3). Up to 50 % of the maximum load the activation of anchor B and C is nearly the same. From 50 % of the maximum load anchor B is activated more strongly. The system failure is caused by concrete failure of the anchors A and B. Compared with the load position x = 75 mm, both anchors A and B are activated from beginning of loading. At maximum load the loads are nearly the same. The anchor C is activated from beginning of loading as well. Extremely strong is the activation close by the maximum of the system load. The failure is caused by concrete failure of all 5 anchors. 40
Anchor load A, B, C [kN]
Anchor load A, B, C [kN]
40
anchor load A anchor load B anchor load C
30
20
10
0
30
anchor load A anchor load B anchor load C
20
10
0 0
10
20
30
40
50
60
0
Systemload [kN]
Figure 5.6a: Anchor loads, x = 0 mm
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
Systemload [kN]
Figure 5.6b: Anchor loads, x = 75 mm
Figure 5.7 shows, that for s = 100 mm the influence of the position of the load on the maximum load of the system is not so strong as for s = 300 mm. Nevertheless, the maximum load is growing up in dependence on the load position from x = 0 mm to x = 100 mm. At the load position x = 62,5 mm the ratio of activation of the anchors A and B is the same. From load position x = 62,5 mm to x = 100 mm anchor C is better activated. In the CCD-method mutual influence of the anchors by spacing of s = 100 mm with an embedment depth of hef = 85 mm is taken to account on the failure of a single anchor. In
139
the FE-analyses the same influence can be seen. Especially it is shown in the activation of the single anchors at different load positions. Up to position x = 50 mm 3 anchors will break out, over x = 50 mm 5 anchors will break out. Generally it is shown, that the highest loaded single anchor has a failure load of about 20 kN. At load position x = 0 mm the failure load of anchor A is about 25 kN. This could be restored, because activated area of anchor A is low influenced by the anchors B and C. An indication therefore is the lower anchor load of the anchors B and C, compared with all other load positions at maximum load. 120
Systemload [KN]
100
80
60 systemload anchor load A
40
anchor load B anchor load C
20
0 0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
Distance of loading point from middle anchor [mm]
Figure 5.7: Anchor loads and maximum load for different load positions By designing anchor groups using the CCD-Method it is assumed, that the anchor plate, which connects the anchors is sufficiently stiff. Figure 5.7 shows, that the anchors close to the loading point (anchor B and A) are both activated almost the same. However the ratio of activation of anchor C is lower than for the anchors A and B. Obviously by small spacing of the anchors, the CCD-method can be used only conditional, since the load distribution on all anchors is not the same.
6. Conclusions Presently no model is available to describe concrete failure of channel bars with more than two anchors and for different positions of loads. To investigate this problem a FEanalysis of channel bars (profil 50/30) with several anchor distances and for different load positions has been carried out. The results of the calculations are compared with the CCD-method for fasteners. By designing anchor groups with the CCD-method it is assumed, that the anchor plate which connects the anchors, is sufficiently stiff. Consequently, according to the model the load is uniformly distributed over all anchors. The numerical analyse shows, that for small spacing of the anchors, the channel bar can be viewed approximately as a stiff. Therefore the CCD-method can be used. However,
140
the results show, that for large spacing of the anchors, it is reasonable to assume the channel bar as a system of single span beams. Therefore, in the new model for design of channel bars the critical anchor is obtained on a system of single span beams. The resistance of each anchor is calculated based on a concept of the influencing area. The cases studied in the present numerical investigations are two extreme cases. To formulate a more general design model, which should account for the transition from the approach with the stiff channel bar (CCD-method) to the system of a single span beams, further numerical and experimental work is needed.
7. Acknowledgements This work was supported by the following companies: Halfen and Deutsche Kahneisen. The support is very much appreciated.
8. References [1] Wohlfahrt, R.: Tragverhalten von Ankerschienen ohne Rückhängebewehrung, Stuttgart: Institut für Werkstoffe im Bauwesen, Mitteilung 1996(4). [2] Ozbolt, J.: „MASA- Macoscopic Space Analysis“, Stuttgart: Institut für Werkstoffe im Bauwesen, Internal report 1999. [3] Halfen GmbH & Co. KG: Zulassungsbescheid Halfen-Ankerschiene HTA (Z-21.434), Berlin: Deutsches Institut für Bautechnik (1998).
141
ANCHORS IN LOW AND HIGH STRENGTH CONCRETE Jakob Kunz*, Yasutoshi Yamamoto**, Mario Berra***, Pietro Bianchi* *Hilti AG, Corporate Research, Liechtenstein **Shibaura Institute, Tokyo, Japan ***Enel.Hydro, Milan, Italy
Abstract Standard anchor design rules apply to normal strength concrete in a range of about 20 to 50 MPa compressive strength. However, we often encounter low strength concrete when retrofitting old buildings. On the other hand, the evolution in concrete technology leads to always higher compressive strengths in new concrete construction. A research commissioned by Hilti Corporate Research and carried out under the direction of Professor Yamamoto at Shibaura Institute of Technology in Japan investigated the transfer capability of anchors by conducting a systematic series of more than 500 shear and tension tests in low strength concrete. The behavior of anchors in high strength concrete has been investigated in the European project ANCHR. This paper puts together comparable results from both research programs and draws conclusions for the design of anchorage in low and high strength concrete. This leads to the conclusion that standard design rules can be applied for shear transmission, but that for tension load, the concrete strength has to be taken into account as proposed by structural concrete codes when designing anchorage for concrete capacity in low or high strength concrete.
1. Introduction Standard anchor design rules apply to normal strength concrete in a range of about 20 to 50 MPa compressive strength. The failure of the concrete capacity is usually associated with the concrete strength to the power of 0.5. Thus the concrete capacity design method (CCD, [1], [2]) gives the concrete cone failure caused by an anchor as:
N u ,m = k ⋅ hef1.5 ⋅ f c
142
(1) with: Nu,m k hef fc
mean ultimate concrete cone pullout load [N] constant, =13.5 for metal anchors; =15.5 for headed studs and some undercut anchors [-] effective embedment depth [mm] concrete compressive strength [MPa]
and for shear loads:
Vc ,u ,m
hef = 0.9 ⋅ d ⋅ d
with: Vc,u,m d c Vs,u,m
0.2
⋅ c1.5 ⋅ f c ≤ Vs ,u ,m
(2)
ultimate load for concrete cone failure in shear [N] anchor diameter [mm] distance from axis of anchor to concrete edge [mm] maximum shear load for steel failure [N]
The value of the concrete compressive strength to the power of 0.5 is to represent the concrete tensile strength. This results in a good representation of the cone pullout strength for concrete strengths from 20 to 50 MPa. However, Neville [3] suggests, that probably the best fit to represent tensile strength of concrete ft is
f t ≅ 0.3 ⋅ f c2 / 3
(3)
In fact, Eurocode 2 [4] also uses this formula. In this study, tests for concrete failure with compressive strengths below and above the range of 20 to 50 MPa have been compared to both representations of the concrete tensile strength. The tests in low strength concrete have been taken from a research program carried out at the Shibaura institute of Technology, Tokyo under the direction of Professor Y. Yamamoto and the tests in high strength concrete are taken from the Brite-Euram Project ANCHR which investigated the anchor behavior in normal and high strength concrete under static load and under high strain rates. Another set of tests with undercut anchors in normal strength concrete from the Hilti testing laboratory is considered as well.
2. Tensile Load Capacity of Undercut Systems The tensile load capacity was evaluated with headed studs and undercut anchors. A total of 97 tests representing concrete compressive strengths from 5 to 120 MPa has been analyzed. The embedment depths range from 36mm to 135mm. The measured failure loads Fu,test have been “normalized” to an embedment depth of 100mm. Since the ultimate load depends on the embedment depth hef to the power of 1.5 (1), the normalized ultimate load Fu,norm is obtained as:
143
Fu ,norm
100 = Fu ,test ⋅ h ef
1.5
(4)
Figure 1 shows the normalized measured ultimate loads with two calculated curves. The first curve represents formula (1), where the factor k for the considered sample was 17.2. Thus, curve (1) represents the dependence of the ultimate load on the square root of the concrete compressive. The second curve represents formula (5), i.e. the dependence of the ultimate load on the concrete strength to the power of 2/3.
N u ,m = 10.3 ⋅ hef1.5 ⋅ β w2 / 3
(5)
conrete cone failure load [kN]
350 300 250
formula (1) formula (5) tests Shibaura tests ENEL tests Hilti
200 150 100 failure loads normalized for hef = 100mm
50 0 0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
concrete strength [N/mm2]
Figure 1: Tests with undercutting systems Figure 1 clearly shows that both formulae yield the same results with compressive strengths in the range of 20 to 50 MPa, but that for lower and especially for higher compressive strengths the differences are considerable. For low strength concrete, the test results are lower than the results of both formulae, but formula (5) is somewhat closer than formula (1). For a compressive strength of 120 MPa, formula (1) clearly underestimates the test results, while formula (5) gives a good prediction of the average test result. A thorough analysis of the test data has shown, that the quality of a predictive formula can be further increased by taking into account the undercutting area A.
N u ,m = 8.1 ⋅ (hef + 0.9 ⋅ A0.5 ) ⋅ f c2 / 3 1.5
(6)
144
with: A undercutting area projected to a plane perpendicular to the axis of the anchor The ratio of measured to predicted ultimate load has been evaluated for all 97 tests with formulae (1), (5) and (6). The coefficient of variation obtained with the prediction formula (1) is 17.7% which corresponds to the values given in [1]. Considering formula (5), the coefficient of variation is reduced to 13.1% and with formula (6) even to 11.6%.
3. Tensile Load Capacity of Adhesive Bonded Systems a) Bond Strength As shown earlier[5], [6], the pullout resistance of bonded anchorage systems is mainly dependent on the product specific bond strength τb and the anchor surface. The influence of the compressive strength of the concrete depends on the product. In the considered tests, the dependence varied from none to proportional to the square root of the concrete compressive strength.
N u ,m ,b
f = τ b ⋅ φ ⋅ π ⋅ hef ⋅ c f c ,ref
n
(7)
with: Nu,m,b mean ultimate maximum load for pullout failure [N] τb product specific bond strength [MPa] φ diameter of anchor [mm] fc,ref reference concrete strength, corresponds to tb [MPa] n product dependent exponent, 0.0 < n < 0.5 This statement has been confirmed by both presented test series in low and in high strength concrete. b) Splitting Bond Failure If the anchor is set near the edge and therefore the concrete cover is small, the bond strength τb may not be reached before splitting of the concrete cover. Splitting failure has been tested in normal and high strength concrete. Cylindrical concrete specimens with a diameter of 100mm. High strength reinforcement bars with a diameter of 20mm were pulled out of the concrete cylinders. Thus the concrete cover around the reinforcement bars was 40mm or 2 times the bar diameter. From the measured maximum loads, the splitting bond stress τu,sp was evaluated by dividing the maximum load by the anchor surface, i.e:
145
τ u ,sp =
Fu ,m
(8)
φ ⋅ π ⋅ hef
Figure 2 shows the splitting bond stresses evaluated from tests with cast-in and with post-installed bars against the concrete strength. Two curves show the best fit equations for predictions supposing that the splitting bond stress is proportional to the concrete strength to the power of 0.5, or to the power of 2/3, respectively.
splitting bond stress [MPa]
curve1 : τ u ,sp = 1.69 ⋅ f c0.5 ;
curve 2 : τ u ,sp = 0.81 ⋅ f c2 / 3
40.0 35.0 30.0 25.0 20.0 15.0 10.0 5.0 0.0
(9)
curve 1 curve 2 tests postinstalled tests cast in place
0
100
200
300
concrete strength [MPa] Figure 2: splitting bond tests with bonded systems The comparison of tests and prediction (figure 2) shows that the assumption that the splitting failure is proportional to the concrete strength to the power of 2/3 (curve 2) gives better results for very high and very low concrete strengths. When comparing the ratios of measured to predicted values, curve 1 yields a coefficient of variation of 38% while curve 2 yields a coefficient of variation of 29% for the considered sample of 30 tests. Nevertheless these results must be considered as preliminary, since the coefficient of variation is rather high in both cases.
4. Shear Load Capacity without Edge Influence in Low Strength Concrete In the test program at Shibaura Institute of Technology the shear capacity of single anchors and of groups of 3 anchors has been measured in low strength concrete specimens. The concrete base material was cast as 1.2m long concrete blocks with compressive strengths of 5 to 15 MPa. Monotonic shear loading tests on post-installed reinforcement bars were conducted in order to measure strength, displacement and failure modes that are basic characteristics of post-installed anchors.
146
The number of cracks in the base material (existing member) decreased, as the concrete strength increased, since the mode of failure shifted from concrete bearing pressure to steel shear failure. Structural concrete design codes show how to calculate the strength of shear bolts. Eurocode 4 proposes the following formulae for the characteristic resistance PRk (sect. 6.3.2.1 [7]):
PRk = 0.8 f u
steel shear failure: concrete bearing pressure:
E cm = 9500( f ck + 8)
1/ 3
(E
π ⋅d 2
(10)
4 2 PRk = 0.29d f ck ⋅ Ecm cm
, f ck [kN / mm 2 ], EC2, sect. 3.1.2.5.2 )
(11)
normalized shear strength 2 2 Fu/(n*d ) [kN/mm ]
ultimate strength of steel with: fu fck characteristic compressive strength of