Universitext
Universitext Series Editors: Sheldon Axler San Francisco State University Vincenzo Capasso Università degli Studi di Milano Carles Casacuberta Universitat de Barcelona Angus J. MacIntyre Queen Mary, University of London Kenneth Ribet University of California, Berkeley Claude Sabbah CNRS, École Polytechnique Endre Süli University of Oxford Wojbor A. Woyczynski Case Western Reserve University
Universitext is a series of textbooks that presents material from a wide variety of mathematical disciplines at master’s level and beyond. The books, often well class-tested by their author, may have an informal, personal even experimental approach to their subject matter. Some of the most successful and established books in the series have evolved through several editions, always following the evolution of teaching curricula, to very polished texts. Thus as research topics trickle down into graduate-level teaching, first textbooks written for new, cutting-edge courses may make their way into Universitext.
For further volumes: www.springer.com/series/223
Jürgen Jost
Riemannian Geometry and Geometric Analysis
123
Jürgen Jost Max Planck Institute for Mathematics in the Sciences Inselstr. 22 04103 Leipzig Germany
[email protected]
ISBN 978-3-642-21297-0 e-ISBN 978-3-642-21298-7 DOI 10.1007/978-3-642-21298-7 Springer Heidelberg Dordrecht London New York Library of Congress Control Number: 2011932682 Mathematics Subject Classification (2010): 53B21, 53L20, 32C17, 35I60, 49-XX, 58E20, 57R15 © Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2011 This work is subject to copyright. All rights are reserved, whether the whole or part of the material is concerned, specifically the rights of translation, reprinting, reuse of illustrations, recitation, broadcasting, reproduction on microfilm or in any other way, and storage in data banks. Duplication of this publication or parts thereof is permitted only under the provisions of the German Copyright Law of September 9, 1965, in its current version, and permission for use must always be obtained from Springer. Violations are liable to prosecution under the German Copyright Law. The use of general descriptive names, registered names, trademarks, etc. in this publication does not imply, even in the absence of a specific statement, that such names are exempt from the relevant protective laws and regulations and therefore free for general use. Cover design: deblik, Berlin Printed on acid-free paper Springer is part of Springer Science+Business Media (www.springer.com)
Dedicated to Shing-Tung Yau, for so many discussions about mathematics and Chinese culture
•
Preface
Riemannian geometry is characterized, and research is oriented towards and shaped by concepts (geodesics, connections, curvature, . . . ) and objectives, in particular to understand certain classes of (compact) Riemannian manifolds defined by curvature conditions (constant or positive or negative curvature, . . . ). By way of contrast, geometric analysis is a perhaps somewhat less systematic collection of techniques, for solving extremal problems naturally arising in geometry and for investigating and characterizing their solutions. It turns out that the two fields complement each other very well; geometric analysis offers tools for solving difficult problems in geometry, and Riemannian geometry stimulates progress in geometric analysis by setting ambitious goals. It is the aim of this book to be a systematic and comprehensive introduction to Riemannian geometry and a representative introduction to the methods of geometric analysis. It attempts a synthesis of geometric and analytic methods in the study of Riemannian manifolds. The present work is the sixth edition of my textbook on Riemannian geometry and geometric analysis. It has developed on the basis of several graduate courses I taught at the Ruhr-University Bochum and the University of Leipzig. The main new feature of the present edition is a systematic presentation of the spectrum of the Laplace operator and its relation with the geometry of the underlying Riemannian manifold. Naturally, I have also included several smaller additions and minor corrections (for which I am grateful to several readers). Moreover, the organization of the chapters has been systematically rearranged. Let me now briefly describe the contents: In the first chapter, we introduce the basic geometric concepts of Riemannian geometry. We then begin the treatment of one of the fundamental objects and tools of Riemannian geometry, the so-called geodesics which are defined as locally shortest curves. Geodesics will reappear prominently in several later chapters. Here, we treat the existence of geodesics with two different methods, both of which are quite important in geometric analysis in general. Thus, the reader has the opportunity to understand the basic ideas of those methods in an elementary context before moving on to more difficult versions in subsequent chapters. The first method is based on the local existence and uniqueness of geodesics and will be applied again in Chapter 9 for two-dimensional harmonic maps. The second method is the heat flow method
viii
Preface
that gained prominence through Perelman’s solution of the Poincar´e conjecture by the Ricci flow method. The second chapter introduces another fundamental concept, the one of a vector bundle. Besides the most basic one, the tangent bundle of a Riemannian manifold, many other vector bundles will appear in this book. The structure group of a vector bundle is a Lie group, and we shall therefore use this opportunity to also discuss Lie groups and their infinitesimal versions, the Lie algebras. The third chapter then introduces basic concepts and methods from analysis. In particular, the Laplace-Beltrami operator is a fundamental object in Riemannian geometry. We show the essential properties of its spectrum and discuss relationships with the underlying geometry. We then turn to the operation of the Laplace operator on differential forms. We introduce de Rham cohomology groups and the essential tools from elliptic PDE for treating these groups. We prove the existence of harmonic forms representing cohomology classes both by a variational method, thereby introducing another of the basic schemes of geometric analysis, and by the heat flow method. The linear setting of cohomology classes allows us to understand some key ideas without the technical difficulties of nonlinear problems. We also discuss the spectrum of the Laplacian on differential forms. The important observation that the spectra for forms of different degrees are systematically related I learned from Johannes Rauh, whom I should like to thank for this. The fourth chapter begins with fundamental geometric concepts. It treats the general theory of connections and curvature. We also introduce important functionals like the Yang-Mills functional and its properties, as well as minimal submanifolds. The Bochner method is applied to the first eigenvalue of the Laplacian and harmonic 1forms on manifolds of positive Ricci curvature, as an example of the interplay between geometry and analysis. We also describe the method of Li and Yau for obtaining eigenvalue estimates through gradient bounds for eigenfunctions. In the fifth chapter, we introduce Jacobi fields, prove the Rauch comparison theorems for Jacobi fields and apply these results to geodesics. We also develop the global geometry of spaces of nonpositive curvature. These first five chapters treat the more elementary and basic aspects of the subject. Their results will be used in the remaining, more advanced chapters. The sixth chapter treats K¨ ahler manifolds and symmetric spaces as important examples of Riemannian manifolds in detail. The seventh chapter is devoted to Morse theory and Floer homology. In the eighth chapter, we treat harmonic maps between Riemannian manifolds. We prove several existence theorems and apply them to Riemannian geometry. The treatment uses an abstract approach based on convexity that should bring out the fundamental structures. We also display a representative sample of techniques from geometric analysis. In the ninth chapter, we treat harmonic maps from Riemann surfaces. We encounter here the phenomenon of conformal invariance which makes this twodimensional case distinctively different from the higher dimensional one. Riemannian geometry has become the mathematical language of theoretical physics, whereas the rigorous demonstration of many results in theoretical physics
Preface
ix
requires deep tools from nonlinear analysis. Therefore, the tenth chapter explores some connections between physics, geometry and analysis. It treats variational problems from quantum field theory, in particular the Ginzburg–Landau and Seiberg– Witten equations, and a mathematical version of the nonlinear supersymmetric sigma model. In mathematical terms, the two-dimensional harmonic map problem is coupled with a Dirac field. The background material on spin geometry and Dirac operators is already developed in earlier chapters. The connections between geometry and physics are developed in more generality in my monograph [164]. A guiding principle for this textbook was that the material in the main body should be self-contained. The essential exception is that we use material about Sobolev spaces and linear elliptic and parabolic PDEs without giving proofs. This material is collected in Appendix A. Appendix B collects some elementary topological results about fundamental groups and covering spaces. Also, in certain places in Chapter 7, we do not present all technical details, but rather explain some points in a more informal manner, in order to keep the size of that chapter within reasonable limits and not to lose the patience of the readers. We employ both coordinate-free intrinsic notations and tensor notations depending on local coordinates. We usually develop a concept in both notations while we sometimes alternate in the proofs. Besides the fact that i am not a methodological purist, reasons for often preferring the tensor calculus to the more elegant and concise intrinsic one are the following. For the analytic aspects, one often has to employ results about (elliptic) partial differential equations (PDEs), and in order to check that the relevant assumptions like ellipticity hold and in order to make contact with the notations usually employed in PDE theory, one has to write down the differential equation in local coordinates. Also, manifold and important connections have been established between theoretical physics and our subject. In the physical literature, usually the tensor notation is employed, and therefore, familiarity with that notation is necessary for exploring those connections that have been found to be stimulating for the development of mathematics, or promise to be so in the future. As appendices to most of the sections, we have written paragraphs with the title “Perspectives”. The aim of those paragraphs is to place the material in a broader context and explain further results and directions without detailed proofs. The material of these Perspectives will not be used in the main body of the text. Similarly, after Chapter 5, we have inserted a section entitled “A short survey on curvature and topology” that presents an account of many global results of Riemannian geometry not covered in the main text. At the end of each chapter, some exercises for the reader are given. We trust the reader to be of sufficient perspicacity to understand our system of numbering and cross-references without further explanation. I thank Miroslav Baˇcak and the copy editor for valuable corrections. I am grateful to the European Research Council for supporting my work with the Advanced Grant FP7-267087. The development of the mathematical subject of Geometric Analysis, namely the investigation of analytical questions arising from a geometric context and in turn
x
Preface
the application of analytical techniques to geometric problems, is to a large extent due to the work and the influence of Shing-Tung Yau. This book, like its previous editions, is dedicated to him.
J¨ urgen Jost
Contents 1 Riemannian Manifolds 1.1 Manifolds and Differentiable Manifolds . . . . . 1.2 Tangent Spaces . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.3 Submanifolds . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.4 Riemannian Metrics . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.5 Existence of Geodesics on Compact Manifolds . 1.6 The Heat Flow and the Existence of Geodesics 1.7 Existence of Geodesics on Complete Manifolds Exercises for Chapter 1 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
1 1 6 10 13 28 31 35 37
2 Lie Groups and Vector Bundles 2.1 Vector Bundles . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.2 Integral Curves of Vector Fields. Lie Algebras 2.3 Lie Groups . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.4 Spin Structures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Exercises for Chapter 2 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
41 41 51 61 67 87
3 The Laplace Operator and Harmonic Differential Forms 3.1 The Laplace Operator on Functions . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.2 The Spectrum of the Laplace Operator . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.3 The Laplace Operator on Forms . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.4 Representing Cohomology Classes by Harmonic Forms . . . 3.5 Generalizations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.6 The Heat Flow and Harmonic Forms . . . . . . . . . . . . . Exercises for Chapter 3 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
89 89 94 102 113 122 123 129
4
. . . . .
Connections and Curvature 4.1 Connections in Vector Bundles . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.2 Metric Connections. The Yang–Mills Functional . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.3 The Levi-Civita Connection . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.4 Connections for Spin Structures and the Dirac Operator 4.5 The Bochner Method . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
133 . . . . . . . . 133 . . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
144 160 175 182
Contentss
xii
. . . .
. . . .
187 191 196 203
5 Geodesics and Jacobi Fields 5.1 First and second Variation of Arc Length and Energy . . . . . . . . 5.2 Jacobi Fields . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.3 Conjugate Points and Distance Minimizing Geodesics . . . . . . . . 5.4 Riemannian Manifolds of Constant Curvature . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.5 The Rauch Comparison Theorems and Other Jacobi Field Estimates 5.6 Geometric Applications of Jacobi Field Estimates . . . . . . . . . . . 5.7 Approximate Fundamental Solutions and Representation Formulas . 5.8 The Geometry of Manifolds of Nonpositive Sectional Curvature . . . Exercises for Chapter 5 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
205 205 211 219 227 229 234 239 241 258
4.6 Eigenvalue Estimates by the Method of Li–Yau 4.7 The Geometry of Submanifolds . . . . . . . . . 4.8 Minimal Submanifolds . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Exercises for Chapter 4 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
A Short Survey on Curvature and Topology
261
6 Symmetric Spaces and K¨ ahler Manifolds 6.1 Complex Projective Space . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.2 K¨ahler Manifolds . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.3 The Geometry of Symmetric Spaces . . . . . . . . . . . 6.4 Some Results about the Structure of Symmetric Spaces 6.5 The Space Sl(n, R)/SO(n, R) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.6 Symmetric Spaces of Noncompact Type . . . . . . . . . Exercises for Chapter 6 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
269 269 275 285 296 303 320 325
7 Morse Theory and Floer Homology 7.1 Preliminaries: Aims of Morse Theory . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.2 The Palais–Smale Condition, Existence of Saddle Points . . . . . . 7.3 Local Analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.4 Limits of Trajectories of the Gradient Flow . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.5 Floer Condition, Transversality and Z2 -Cohomology . . . . . . . . 7.6 Orientations and Z-homology . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.7 Homotopies . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.8 Graph flows . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.9 Orientations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.10 The Morse Inequalities . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.11 The Palais–Smale Condition and the Existence of Closed Geodesics Exercises for Chapter 7 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
327 327 332 334 350 358 364 368 372 376 392 403 416
8 Harmonic Maps between Riemannian Manifolds 8.1 Definitions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.2 Formulas for Harmonic Maps. The Bochner Technique 8.3 The Energy Integral and Weakly Harmonic Maps . . . 8.4 Higher Regularity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . .
. . . .
419 419 426 438 448
. . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . .
. . . .
Contents
xiii
8.5 Existence of Harmonic Maps for Nonpositive Curvature 8.6 Regularity of Harmonic Maps for Nonpositive Curvature 8.7 Harmonic Map Uniqueness and Applications . . . . . . Exercises for Chapter 8 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
459 466 485 492
9 Harmonic Maps from Riemann Surfaces 9.1 Two-dimensional Harmonic Mappings . . . . . . . . . 9.2 The Existence of Harmonic Maps in Two Dimensions . 9.3 Regularity Results . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Exercises for Chapter 9 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
495 495 509 530 544
10 Variational Problems from Quantum 10.1 The Ginzburg–Landau Functional . 10.2 The Seiberg–Witten Functional . . . 10.3 Dirac-harmonic Maps . . . . . . . . Exercises for Chapter 10 . . . . . . . . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
547 547 555 562 569
A Linear Elliptic Partial Differential A.1 Sobolev Spaces . . . . . . . . . . A.2 Linear Elliptic Equations . . . . A.3 Linear Parabolic Equations . . .
Field Theory . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . .
Equations 571 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 571 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 576 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 580
B Fundamental Groups and Covering Spaces
583
Bibliography
587
Index
605
•
Chapter 1
Riemannian Manifolds
1.1
Manifolds and Differentiable Manifolds
A topological space is a set M together with a family O of subsets of M satisfying the following properties: (i) Ω1 , Ω2 ∈ O ⇒ Ω1 ∩ Ω2 ∈ O, (ii) for any index set A : (Ωα )α∈A ⊂ O ⇒
α∈A
Ωα ∈ O,
(iii) ∅, M ∈ O. The sets from O are called open. A topological space is called Hausdorff if for any two distinct points p1 , p2 ∈ M there exist open sets Ω1 , Ω2 ∈ O with p1 ∈ Ω1 , p2 ∈ Ω2 , Ω1 ∩ Ω2 = ∅. A covering (Ωα )α∈A (A an arbitrary index set) is called locally finite if each p ∈ M has a neighborhood that intersects only finitely many Ωα . M is called paracompact if any open covering possesses a locally finite refinement. This means that for any open covering (Ωα )α∈A there exists a locally finite open covering (Ωβ )β∈B with ∀ β ∈ B ∃ α ∈ A : Ωβ ⊂ Ωα . The condition of paracompactness ensures the existence of an important technical tool, the so-called partition of unity, see Lemma 1.1.1 below. A map between topological spaces is called continuous if the preimage of any open set is again open. A bijective map which is continuous in both directions is called a homeomorphism.
J. Jost, Riemannian Geometry and Geometric Analysis, Universitext, c Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2011 DOI 10.1007/978-3-642-21298-7 1,
2
Chapter 1 Riemannian Manifolds
Definition 1.1.1. A manifold M of dimension d is a connected paracompact Hausdorff space for which every point has a neighborhood U that is homeomorphic to an open subset Ω of Rd . Such a homeomorphism x:U →Ω is called a (coordinate) chart. An atlas is a family {Uα , xα } of charts for which the Uα constitute an open covering of M. Remarks. 1. A point p ∈ Uα is determined by xα (p); hence it is often identified with xα (p). Often, also the index α is omitted, and the components of x(p) ∈ Rd are called local coordinates of p. 2. It is customary to write the Euclidean coordinates of Rd as x = (x1 , . . . , xd ),
(1.1.1)
and these then are considered as local coordinates on our manifold M when x : U → Ω is a chart. As we shall see, local coordinates yield a systematic method for locally representing a manifold in such a manner that computations can be carried out. We shall now describe a concept that will allow us to utilize the framework of linear algebra for local computations as will be explored in §1.2 and beyond. Definition 1.1.2. An atlas {Uα , xα } on a manifold is called differentiable if all chart transitions xβ ◦ x−1 α : xα (Uα ∩ Uβ ) → xβ (Uα ∩ Uβ ) are differentiable of class C ∞ (in case Uα ∩ Uβ = ∅). A maximal differentiable atlas is called a differentiable structure, and a differentiable manifold of dimension d is a manifold of dimension d with a differentiable structure. From now on, all atlases are supposed to be differentiable. Two atlases are called compatible if their union is again an atlas. In general, a chart is called compatible with an atlas if adding the chart to the atlas yields again an atlas. An atlas is called maximal if any chart compatible with it is already contained in it. Remarks. 1. One could also require a weaker differentiability property than C ∞ , for instance C k , i.e., that all chart transitions be k times continuously differentiable, for some k ∈ N. C ∞ is convenient as one never needs to worry about the order of differentiability. The spaces C k for k ∈ N, on the other hand, offer the advantage of being Banach spaces.
1.1 Manifolds and Differentiable Manifolds
3
−1 2. Since the inverse of xβ ◦ x−1 α is xα ◦ xβ , chart transitions are differentiable in both directions, i.e. diffeomorphisms. In particular, their Jacobian (functional determinant) is never 0.
3. It is therefore easy to show that the dimension of a differentiable manifold is uniquely determined. For a general, not differentiable manifold, this is much harder. 4. Since any differentiable atlas is contained in a maximal differentiable one, it suffices to exhibit some differentiable atlas if one wants to construct a differentiable manifold. Definition 1.1.3. An atlas for a differentiable manifold is called oriented if all chart transitions have positive functional determinant. A differentiable manifold is called orientable if it possesses an oriented atlas. Examples.
n+1 i 2 1. The sphere S n := {(x1 , . . . , xn+1 ) ∈ Rn+1 : = 1} is a i=1 (x ) differentiable manifold of dimension n. Charts can be given as follows: On U1 := S n \{(0, . . . , 0, 1)} we put f1 (x1 , . . . , xn+1 ) := (f11 (x1 , . . . , xn+1 ), . . . , f1n (x1 , . . . , xn+1 )) xn x1 , . . . , := 1 − xn+1 1 − xn+1 and on U2 := S n \{(0, . . . , 0, −1)} f2 (x1 , . . . , xn+1 ) := (f21 (x1 , . . . , xn+1 ), . . . , f2n (x1 , . . . , xn+1 )) xn x1 , . . . , := . 1 + xn+1 1 + xn+1
2. Let w1 , w2 , . . . , wn ∈ Rn be linearly independent. We consider z1 , z2 ∈ Rn as equivalent if there are m1 , m2 , . . . , mn ∈ Z with z1 − z2 =
n
m i wi .
i=1
Let π be the projection mapping z ∈ Rn to its equivalence class. The torus T n := π(Rn ) can then be made a differentiable manifold (of dimension n) as follows: Suppose Δα is open and does not contain any pair of equivalent points. We put Uα := π(Δα ), zα := (π|Δα )−1 .
4
Chapter 1 Riemannian Manifolds 3. The preceding examples are compact. Of course, there exist also noncompact manifolds. The simplest example is Rd . In general, any open subset of a (differentiable) manifold is again a (differentiable) manifold. 4. If M and N are differentiable manifolds, the Cartesian product M × N also naturally carries the structure of a differentiable manifold. Namely, if {Uα , xα }α∈A and {Vβ , yβ }β∈B are atlases for M and N , resp., then {Uα × Vβ , (xα , yβ )}(α,β)∈A×B is an atlas for M ×N with differentiable chart transitions.
Definition 1.1.4. A map h : M → M between differentiable manifolds M and M with charts {Uα , xα } and {Uα , xα } is called differentiable if all maps xβ ◦ h ◦ x−1 α are differentiable (of class C ∞ , as always) where defined. Such a map is called a diffeomorphism if bijective and differentiable in both directions. For purposes of differentiation, a differentiable manifold locally has the structure of Euclidean space. Thus, the differentiability of a map can be tested in local coordinates. The diffeomorphism requirement for the chart transitions then guarantees that differentiability defined in this manner is a consistent notion, i.e. independent of the choice of a chart. Remark. We want to point out that in the context of the preceding definitions, one cannot distinguish between two homeomorphic manifolds nor between two diffeomorphic differentiable manifolds. When looking at Definitions 1.1.2 and 1.1.3, one may see a general pattern emerging. Namely, one can put any type of restriction on the chart transitions, for example, require them to be affine, algebraic, real analytic, conformal, Euclidean volume preserving, . . . , and thereby define a class of manifolds with that particular structure. Perhaps the most important example is the notion of a complex manifold. We shall need this, however, only at certain places in this book, namely in §6.1 and §6.2. Definition 1.1.5. A complex manifold of complex dimension d (dimC M = d) is a differentiable manifold of (real) dimension 2d (dimR M = 2d) whose charts take values in open subsets of Cd with holomorphic chart transitions. In the case of a complex manifold, it is customary to write the coordinates of Cd as z = (z 1 , . . . , z d ), with z j = xj + iy j (1.1.2) √ 1 1 d d 2d with i := −1, that is, use (x , y , . . . , x , y ) as Euclidean coordinates on R . We then also put ¯ z j := xj − iyj . The requirement that the chart transitions zβ ◦ zα−1 : zα (Uα ∩ Uβ ) → zβ (Uα ∩ Uβ ) be holomorphic then is expressed as ∂zβj =0 (1.1.3) ∂zαk¯
1.1 Manifolds and Differentiable Manifolds for all j, k where 1 ∂ ¯ = k 2 ∂z
∂ ∂ ¯ +i k ∂x ∂yk¯
5 .
(1.1.4)
We also observe that a complex manifold is always orientable because holomorphic maps always have a positive functional determinant. We conclude this section with a useful technical result. Lemma 1.1.1. Let M be a differentiable manifold, (Uα )α∈A an open covering. Then there exists a partition of unity, subordinate to (Uα ). This means that there exists a locally finite refinement (Vβ )β∈B of (Uα ) and C0∞ (i.e. C ∞ functions ϕβ with {x ∈ M : ϕβ (x) = 0} having compact closure) functions ϕβ : M → R with (i) supp ϕβ ⊂ Vβ for all β ∈ B, (ii) 0 ≤ ϕβ (x) ≤ 1 for all x ∈ M, β ∈ B, (iii) β∈B ϕβ (x) = 1 for all x ∈ M . Note that in (iii), there are only finitely many nonvanishing summands at each point since only finitely many ϕβ are nonzero at any given point because the covering (Vβ ) is locally finite. Proof. See any advanced textbook on Analysis, e.g. J. Jost, Postmodern Analysis, 3rd edn, Springer, 2005. ¨ Perspectives. Bernhard Riemann’s habilitation address “Uber die Hypothesen, welche der Geometrie zugrunde liegen”, reprinted in [299], laid the foundations for most concepts of what is now called Riemannian geometry. In particular, Riemann was the first mathematician with the concept of a (differentiable) manifold. This notion was then formally developed by H. Weyl[297] and others. The only one-dimensional manifolds are the real line and the unit circle S 1 , the latter being the only compact one. Two-dimensional compact manifolds are classified by their genus and orientability character. In three dimensions, Thurston[287,288] had proposed a program for the possible classification of compact three-dimensional manifolds. This was recently resolved by Perel’man with techniques from geometric analysis (that were rather different from those that Thurston had developed); see the Survey on Curvature and Topology in the middle of this book for references. In higher dimensions, the plethora of compact manifolds makes a classification useless and impossible. In dimension at most three, each manifold carries a unique differentiable structure, and so here the classifications of manifolds and differentiable manifolds coincide. This is no longer so in higher dimensions. Milnor[215,216] discovered exotic 7-spheres, i.e. differentiable structures on the manifold S 7 that are not diffeomorphic to the standard differentiable
6
Chapter 1 Riemannian Manifolds
structure exhibited in our example. Exotic spheres likewise exist in higher dimensions. Kervaire[186] found an example of a manifold carrying no differentiable structure at all. In dimension 4, the understanding of differentiable structures owes important progress to the work of Donaldson, see the monograph [82] for a systematic treatment of the theory and its subsequent developments. Donaldson defined invariants of a differentiable 4-manifold M from the space of selfdual connections on principal bundles over it. These concepts will be discussed in more detail in §4.2. In particular, there exist exotic structures on R4 . A description can e.g. be found in [103].
1.2
Tangent Spaces
Let x = (x1 , . . . , xd ) be Euclidean coordinates of Rd , Ω ⊂ Rd open, x0 ∈ Ω. The tangent space of Ω at the point x0 , Tx 0 Ω is the space {x0 } × E, where E is the d-dimensional vector space spanned by the basis ∂x∂ 1 , . . . , ∂x∂ d . Here, ∂x∂ 1 , . . . , ∂x∂ d are the partial derivatives at the point x0 . If Ω ⊂ Rd , Ω ⊂ Rc are open, and f : Ω → Ω is differentiable, we define the derivative df (x0 ) for x0 ∈ Ω as the induced linear map between the tangent spaces df (x0 ) : Tx0 Ω → Tf(x0 ) Ω , v = vi
∂ ∂f j ∂ → v i i (x0 ) j . i ∂x ∂x ∂f
Here and in the sequel, we use the Einstein summation convention: An index occurring ∂ twice in a product is to be summed from 1 up to the space dimension. Thus, vi ∂x i is an abbreviation for d ∂ vi i , ∂x i=1
j
∂ v i ∂f ∂xi ∂f j
stands for c d i=1 j=1
vi
∂f j ∂ . ∂xi ∂f j
In the previous notations, we put T Ω := Ω × E ∼ = Ω × Rd . Thus, T Ω is an open subset of Rd × Rd , hence in particular a differentiable manifold. π : T Ω → Ω, (x, v) → x
(projection onto the first factor)
1.2 Tangent Spaces
7
is called a tangent bundle of Ω. T Ω is called the total space of the tangent bundle. Likewise, we define df : T Ω → T Ω , ∂ ∂ ∂f j x, v i i → f (x), v i i (x) j . ∂x ∂x ∂f Instead of df (x, v) we write df (x)(v). ∂ If in particular, f : Ω → R is a differentiable function, we have for v = v i ∂x i
df (x)(v) = v i
∂f (x) ∈ Tf(x) R ∼ = R. ∂xi
In this case, we often write v(f )(x) in place of df (x)(v) when we want to express that the tangent vector v operates by differentiation on the function f . Let now M be a differentiable manifold of dimension d, and p ∈ M. We want to define the tangent space of M at the point p. Let x : U → Rd be a chart with p ∈ U , U open in M . We say that the tangent space Tp M is represented in the chart x by Tx(p) x(U ). Let x : U → Rd be another chart with p ∈ U , U open in M. Ω := x(U ), Ω := x (U ). The transition map x ◦ x−1 : x(U ∩ U ) → x (U ∩ U ) induces a vector space isomorphism L := d(x ◦ x−1 )(x(p)) : Tx(p) Ω → Tx (p) Ω . We say that v ∈ Tx(p) Ω and L(v) ∈ Tx (p) Ω represent the same tangent vector in Tp M . Thus, a tangent vector in Tp M is given by the family of its coordinate representations. This is motivated as follows: Let f : M → R be a differentiable function. We then want to define df (p) as a linear map from Tp M to R. In the chart x, let w ∈ Tp M be ∂ represented by v = v i ∂x i ∈ Tx(p) x(U ). We then say that df (p)(w) in this chart is represented by d(f ◦ x−1 )(x(p))(v). Now d(f ◦ x−1 )(x(p))(v) = d(f ◦ x−1 ◦ x ◦ x−1 )(x(p))(v) = d(f ◦ x−1 )(x (p))(L(v)) by the chain rule = d(f ◦ x−1 )(x (p)) ◦ d(x ◦ x−1 )(x(p))(v).
8
Chapter 1 Riemannian Manifolds
Thus, in the chart x , w is represented by L(v). Here, a fundamental idea emerges that will be essential for the understanding of the sequel. Tp M is a vector space of dimension d, hence isomorphic to Rd . This isomorphism, however, is not canonical, but depends on the choice of a chart. A change of charts changes the isomorphism, namely at the point p by the linear transformation L = d(x ◦x−1 )(x(p)). Under a change of charts, also other objects then are correspondingly transformed, for example derivatives of functions, or more generally of maps. In other words, a chart yields local representations for tangent vectors, derivatives, etc., and under a change of charts, these local representations need to be correctly transformed. Or in still other words: We know how to differentiate (differentiable) functions that are defined on open subsets of Rd . If now a function is given on a manifold, we pull it back by a chart, to an open subset of Rd and then differentiate the pulled back function. In order to obtain an object that does not depend on the choice of chart, we have to know in addition the transformation behavior under chart changes. A tangent vector thus is determined by how it operates on functions by differentiation. Likewise, for a differentiable map F : M → N between differentiable manifolds, dF is represented in local charts x : U ⊂ M → Rd , y : V ⊂ N → Rc by d(y ◦ F ◦ x−1 ). In the sequel, in our notation, we shall frequently drop reference to the charts and write instead of d(y ◦ F ◦ x−1 ) simply dF, provided the choice of charts or at least the fact that charts have been chosen is obvious from the context. We can achieve this most simply as follows: Let the local coordinates on U be (x1 , . . . , xd ), and those on V be (F 1 , . . . , F c ). We then consider F (x) as abbreviation for (F 1 (x1 , . . . , xd ), . . . , F c (x1 , . . . , xd )). dF now induces a linear map dF : Tx M → TF (x) N, which in our coordinates is represented by the matrix α ∂F . ∂xi α=1,...,c i=1,...,d
A change of charts leads to a base change of the tangent spaces, and the transformation behavior is determined by the chain rule. If (x1 , . . . , xd ) → (ξ 1 , . . . , ξ d ) and (F 1 , . . . , F c ) → (Φ1 , . . . , Φc )
1.2 Tangent Spaces
9
are coordinate changes, then dF is represented in the new coordinates by β β ∂Φ ∂Φ ∂F α ∂xi = . ∂ξ j ∂F α ∂xi ∂ξ j Note that the functional matrix of the coordinate change of the image N , but the inverse of the functional matrix of the coordinate change of the domain M appears here. We also remark that for a function ϕ : N → R and a v ∈ Tx M , (dF (v)(ϕ))(F (x)) := dϕ(dF (v))(F (x)) by definition of the application of dF (v) ∈ TF (x) N to ϕ : N → R, = d(ϕ ◦ F )(v)(x) by the chain rule = v(ϕ ◦ F )(x) by definition of the application of v ∈ Tx M to ϕ ◦ F : M → R. Instead of applying the tangent vector dF (v) to the function, one may also apply the tangent vector v to the “pulled back” function ϕ ◦ F . We want to collect the previous considerations in a formal definition: Definition 1.2.1. Let p ∈ M. On {(x, v) : x : U → Ω chart with p ∈ U, v ∈ Tx(p) Ω} (x, v) ∼ (y, w) : ⇐⇒ w = d(y ◦ x−1 )v. The space of equivalence classes is called the tangent space to M at the point p, and it is denoted by Tp M. Tp M naturally carries the structure of a vector space: The equivalence class of λ1 (x, v1 )+ λ2 (x, v2 ) (λ1 , λ2 ∈ R) is the one of (x, λ1 v1 + λ2 v2 ). We now want to define the tangent bundle of a differentiable manifold of dimension d. T M is the disjoint union of the tangent spaces Tp M, p ∈ M, equipped with the following structure of a differentiable manifold: First let π : T M → M with π(w) = p for w ∈ Tp M be the projection onto the “base point”. If x : U → Rd is a chart for M, we let T U be the disjoint union of the Tp M with p ∈ U and define the chart Tp M ) dx : T U → T x(U ), ( := p∈x(U )
where T x(U ) carries the differentiable structure of x(U ) × Rd w → dx(π(w))(w) ∈ Tx(π(w))x(U ). The transition maps
dx ◦ (dx)−1 = d(x ◦ x−1 )
then are differentiable. π is locally represented by x ◦ π ◦ dx−1 and this map maps (x0 , v) ∈ T x(U ) to x0 .
10
Chapter 1 Riemannian Manifolds
Definition 1.2.2. The triple (T M, π, M ) is called the tangent bundle of M, and T M is called the total space of the tangent bundle. Finally, we briefly discuss the case of a complex manifold M , to have it at our disposal in §6.2. With the previous constructions and conventions in the real case understood, we let z j = xj + iyj again be local holomorphic coordinates near z ∈ M , as at the end of §1.1. TzR M := Tz M is the ordinary (real) tangent space of M at z, and TzC M := TzR M ⊗R C is the complexified tangent space which we then decompose as TzC M = C{
∂ ∂ , } =: Tz M ⊕ Tz M, ∂z j ∂z¯j
where Tz M = C{ ∂z∂ j } is the holomorphic and Tz M = C{ ∂z∂ ¯j } the antiholomorphic tangent space. In TzC M , we have a conjugation, mapping ∂z∂ j to ∂z∂ ¯j , and so, Tz M = Tz M . The projection TzR M → TzC M → Tz M is an R-linear isomorphism. Perspectives. Other definitions of the tangent space of a differentiable manifold M are possible that are more elegant and less easy to compute with. A germ of a function at x ∈ M is an equivalence class of smooth functions defined on neighborhoods of x, where two such functions are equivalent if they coincide on some neighborhood of x. A tangent vector at x may then be defined as a linear operator δ on the function germs at x satisfying the Leibniz rule δ(f · g)(x) = (δf (x))g(x) + f (x)δg(x). This definition has the obvious advantage that it does not involve local coordinates.
1.3
Submanifolds
A differentiable map f : M → N is called an immersion, if for any x ∈ M df : Tx M → Tf(x) N is injective. In particular, in this case m := dim M ≤ n := dim N . If an immersion f : M → N maps M homeomorphically onto its image in N , f is called a differentiable embedding. The following lemma shows that locally, any immersion is a differentiable embedding: Lemma 1.3.1. Let f : M → N be an immersion, dim M = m, dim N = n, x ∈ M. Then there exist a neighborhood U of x and a chart (V, y) on N with f (x) ∈ V, such that
1.3 Submanifolds
11
(i) f|U is a differentiable embedding, and (ii) y m+1 (p) = . . . = y n (p) = 0 for all p ∈ f (U ) ∩ V. Proof. This follows from the implicit function theorem. In local coordinates (z 1 , . . . , z n ) on N, (x1 , . . . , xm ) on M let, w.l.o.g. (since df (x) is injective) α ∂z (f (x)) ∂xi i,α=1,...,m be nonsingular. We consider
F (z, x) := (z 1 − f 1 (x), . . . , z n − f n (x)),
which has maximal rank in x1 , . . . , xm , z m+1 , . . . , z n . theorem, there locally exists a map
By the implicit function
(z 1 , . . . , z m ) → (ϕ1 (z 1 , . . . , z m ), . . . , ϕn (z 1 , . . . , z m )) with F (z, x) = 0 ⇐⇒ x1 = ϕ1 (z 1 , . . . , z m ), . . . , xm = ϕm (z 1 , . . . , z m ), z m+1 = ϕm+1 (z 1 , . . . , z m ), . . . , z n = ϕn (z 1 , . . . , z m ), i
∂ϕ for which ( ∂z α )α,i=1,...,m has maximal rank.
As new coordinates, we now choose (y1 , . . . , y n ) = (ϕ1 (z 1 , . . . , z m ), . . . , ϕm (z 1 , . . . , z m ), z m+1 − ϕm+1 (z 1 , . . . , z m ), . . . , z n − ϕn (z 1 , . . . , z m )). Then z = f (x) ⇔ F (z, x) = 0 ⇔ (y 1 , . . . , y n ) = (x1 , . . . , xm , 0, . . . , 0), and the claim follows. If f : M → N is a differentiable embedding, f (M ) is called a differentiable submanifold of N . A subset N of N , equipped with the relative topology, thus is a differentiable submanifold of N , if N is a manifold and the inclusion is a differentiable embedding. Charts on N then are simply given by restrictions of charts of N to N , and Lemma 1.3.1 shows that one may here always find a particularly convenient structure of the charts. Similarly, the implicit function theorem implies
12
Chapter 1 Riemannian Manifolds
Lemma 1.3.2. Let f : M → N be a differentiable map, dim M = m, dim N = n, m ≥ n, p ∈ N. Let df (x) have rank n for all x ∈ M with f (x) = p. Then f −1 (p) is a union of differentiable submanifolds of M of dimension m − n. Proof. We again represent the situation in local coordinates around x ∈ M and p = f (x) ∈ N. Of course, in these coordinates df (x) still has rank n. By the implicit function theorem, there exist an open neighborhood U of x and a differentiable map g(xn+1 , . . . , xm ) : U2 ⊂ Rm−n → U1 ⊂ Rn with U = U 1 × U2 and
f (x) = p ⇐⇒ (x1 , . . . , xn ) = g(xn+1 , . . . , xm ).
With y α = xα − g(xn+1 , . . . , xm ) y s = xs
for α = 1, . . . , n, for s = n + 1, . . . , m,
we then get coordinates for which f (x) = p ⇐⇒ yα = 0
for α = 1, . . . , n.
(y n+1 , . . . , y m ) thus yield local coordinates for {f (x) = p } and this implies that in some neighborhood of x {f (x) = p } is a submanifold of M of dimension m − n. Let M be a differentiable submanifold of N, and let i : M → N be the inclusion. For p ∈ M, Tp M can then be considered as subspace of Tp N, namely as the image di(Tp M ). The standard example is the sphere S n = {x ∈ Rn+1 : |x| = 1} ⊂ Rn+1 . By Lemma 1.3.2, S n is a submanifold of Rn+1 . Lemma 1.3.3. In the situation of Lemma 1.3.2, we have for the submanifold X = f −1 (p) and q ∈ X Tq X = ker df (q) ⊂ Tq M. Proof. Let v ∈ Tq X, (ϕ, U ) a chart on X with q ∈ U. Let γ be any smooth curve in d γ(t)|t=0 = dϕ(v), for example, γ(t) = ϕ(q)+tdϕ(v). ϕ(U ) with γ(0) = ϕ(q), γ(0) ˙ := dt −1 ˙ = v. Because of X = f −1 (p), c := ϕ (γ) then is a curve in X with c(0) f ◦ c(t) = p ∀t,
1.4 Riemannian Metrics
13
hence df (q) ◦ c(0) ˙ = 0, and consequently v = c(0) ˙ ∈ ker df (q). Since also Tq X = dim ker df (q) = m − n, the claim follows. For our example S n , we may choose f : Rn+1 → R, f (x) = |x|2 . Then Tx S n = ker df (x) = {v ∈ Rn+1 : x · v(= xi v i ) = 0}. Perspectives. H. Whitney (1936) showed that any d-dimensional differentiable manifold can be embedded into R2d+1 . Thus, the class of abstract differentiable manifolds is the same as the class of submanifolds of Euclidean space. Nevertheless, the abstract and intrinsic point of view offers great conceptual and technical advantages over the approach of submanifold geometry of Euclidean spaces.
1.4
Riemannian Metrics
We now want to introduce metric structures on differentiable manifolds. Again, we shall start from infinitesimal considerations. We would like to be able to measure the lengths of and the angles between tangent vectors. Then, one may, for example, obtain the length of a differentiable curve by integration. In a vector space such a notion of measurement is usually given by a scalar product. We thus define Definition 1.4.1. A Riemannian metric on a differentiable manifold M is given by a scalar product on each tangent space Tp M which depends smoothly on the base point p. A Riemannian manifold is a differentiable manifold, equipped with a Riemannian metric. In order to understand the concept of a Riemannian metric, we again need to study local coordinate representations and the transformation behavior of these expressions. Thus, let x = (x1 , . . . , xd ) be local coordinates. In these coordinates, a metric is represented by a positive definite, symmetric matrix (gij (x))i,j=1,...,d (i.e. gij = gji for all i, j, gij ξ i ξ j > 0 for all ξ = (ξ 1 , . . . , ξ d ) = 0), where the coefficients depend smoothly on x. The transformation formula (1.4.5) below will imply that this smoothness does not depend on the choice of coordinates. Therefore, smooth dependence on the base point as required in Definition 1.4.1 can be expressed in local coordinates.
14
Chapter 1 Riemannian Manifolds
The product of two tangent vectors v, w ∈ Tp M with coordinate representations ∂ j ∂ (v 1 , . . . , v d ) and (w1 , . . . , wd ) (i.e. v = v i ∂x i , w = w ∂xj ) then is v, w := gij (x(p))v i wj .
(1.4.1)
∂ ∂ In particular, ∂x i , ∂xj = gij . Similarly, the length of v is given by 1
v := v, v 2 . Finally, we have the volume factor √ g := det(gi j)
(1.4.2)
used for the integration of functions F : M → R, F (x) g(x)dx1 . . . dxd .
(1.4.3)
M
The linear algebra behind this will be clarified in Section 3.3. We now want to study the transformation behavior. Let y = f (x) define different local coordinates. In these coordinates, v and w have representations (˜ v 1 , . . . , v˜d ) and j j 1 d j i ∂f j i ∂f ˜ = w ∂xi . (w ˜ , . . . , w˜ ) with v˜ = v ∂xi , w Let the metric in the new coordinates be given by hk (y). It follows that hk (f (x))˜ vk w ˜ = v, w = gij (x)v i wj ,
(1.4.4)
hence
∂f k ∂f i j v w = gij (x)v i wj , ∂xi ∂xj and since this holds for all tangent vectors v, w, hk (f (x))
hk (f (x))
∂f k ∂f = gij (x). ∂xi ∂xj
(1.4.5)
Formula (1.4.5) gives the transformation behavior of a metric under coordinate changes. Likewise, the integral (1.4.6) of a function Φ is invariant, 1 d Φ(f (x)) g(x)dx . . . dx = Φ(y) h(y)dy 1 . . . dyd . M
M
The simplest example of a Riemannian metric of course is the Euclidean one. For v = (v 1 , . . . , v d ), w = (w1 , . . . , w d ) ∈ Tx Rd , the Euclidean scalar product is simply δij v i wj = v i wi ,
where δij = is the standard Kronecker symbol.
1 0
for i = j for i = j
1.4 Riemannian Metrics
15
Theorem 1.4.1. Each differentiable manifold may be equipped with a Riemannian metric. Proof. Let {(xα , Uα ) : α ∈ A} be an atlas, (ϕα )α∈A a partition of unity subordinate to (Uα )α∈A , see Lemma 1.1.1 (for simplicity of notation, we use the same index set for (ϕα ) and (Uα ); this may be justified by replacing the original covering (Uα ) by a locally finite refinement). For v, w ∈ Tp M and α ∈ A with p ∈ Uα let the coordinate representations be (vα1 , . . . , vαd ) and (wα1 , . . . , wαd ). Then we put ϕα (p)vαi wαi . v, w := α∈A with p∈Uα
This defines a Riemannian metric. (The metric is simply obtained by piecing the Euclidean metrics of the coordinate images together with the help of a partition of unity.) Let now [a, b] be a closed interval in R, γ : [a, b] → M a smooth curve, where “smooth”, as always, means “of class C ∞ ”. The length of γ then is defined as a
and the energy of γ as E(γ) :=
1 2
dγ (t)dt dt
(1.4.6)
dγ 2 (t) dt. dt
(1.4.7)
b
L(γ) :=
b a
(In physics, E(γ) is usually called the “action of γ” where γ is considered as the orbit of a mass point.) Of course, these expressions can be computed in local coordinates. Working with the coordinates (x1 (γ(t)), . . . , xd (γ(t))) we use the abbreviation x˙ i (t) := Then
b
L(γ) =
d i (x (γ(t))). dt
gij (x(γ(t)))x˙ i (t)x˙ j (t)dt
(1.4.8)
a
and E(γ) =
1 2
b
gij (x(γ(t)))x˙ i (t)x˙ j (t)dt.
(1.4.9)
a
We also remark for later technical purposes that the length of a (continuous and) piecewise smooth curve may be defined as the sum of the lengths of the smooth pieces, and the same holds for the energy.
16
Chapter 1 Riemannian Manifolds
On a Riemannian manifold M, the distance between two points p, q can be defined: d(p, q) := inf{L(γ) : γ : [a, b] → M piecewise smooth curve with γ(a) = p, γ(b) = q}. We first remark that any two points p, q ∈ M can be connected by a piecewise smooth curve, and d(p, q) therefore is always defined. Namely, let Ep := {q ∈ M : p and q can be connected by a piecewise smooth curve}. With the help of local coordinates one sees that Ep is open. But then also M \Ep = q ∈E / p Eq is open. Since M is connected and Ep = ∅ (p ∈ Ep ), we conclude M = Ep . The distance function satisfies the usual axioms: Lemma 1.4.1. (i) d(p, q) ≥ 0 for all p, q, and d(p, q) > 0 for all p = q, (ii) d(p, q) = d(q, p), (iii) d(p, q) ≤ d(p, r) + d(r, q) (triangle inequality) for all points p, q, r ∈ M . Proof. (ii) and (iii) are obvious. For (i), we only have to show d(p, q) > 0 for p = q. For this purpose, let x : U → Rd be a chart with p ∈ U. Then there exists ε > 0 with Dε (x(p)) := {y ∈ Rd : |y − x(p)| ≤ ε} ⊂ x(U ) (the bars denote the Euclidean absolute value) and q∈ / x−1 (Dε (x(p))).
(1.4.10)
Let the metric be represented by (gij (x)) in our chart. Since (gij (x)) is positive definite and smooth, hence continuous in x and Dε (x(p)) is compact, there exists λ > 0 with gij (y)ξ i ξ j ≥ λ|ξ|2 (1.4.11) for all y ∈ Dε (x(p)), ξ = (ξ 1 , . . . , ξ d ) ∈ Rd . Therefore, for any curve γ : [a, b] → M with γ(a) = p, γ(b) = q L(γ) ≥ L(γ ∩ x−1 (Dε (x(p)))) ≥ λε > 0,
(1.4.12)
because x(γ) by (1.4.10) has to contain a point z ∈ ∂Dε (x(p)), i.e. a point whose Euclidean distance from x(p) is ε. By (1.4.11), z then has distance from x(p) at least λε w.r.t. the metric (gij ).
1.4 Riemannian Metrics
17
Corollary 1.4.1. The topology on M induced by the distance function d coincides with the original manifold topology of M. Proof. It suffices to show that in each chart the topology induced by d coincides with the one of Rd , i.e. the one induced by the Euclidean distance function. Now for every x in some chart, there exists ε > 0 for which Dε (x) is contained in the same chart, and positive constants λ, μ with λ2 |ξ|2 ≤ gij (y)ξ i ξ j ≤ μ2 |ξ|2
for all y ∈ Dε (x), ξ ∈ Rd .
Thus λ|y − x| ≤ d(y, x) ≤ μ|y − x|
for all y ∈ Dε (x),
and thus each Euclidean distance ball contains a distance ball for d, and vice versa (with B(z, δ) := {y ∈ M : d(z, y) ≤ δ} we have
◦
◦
◦
Dλδ (x) ⊂ B (x, δ) ⊂ D μδ (x), if μδ ≤ ε). We now return to the length and energy functionals. Lemma 1.4.2. For each smooth curve γ : [a, b] → M L(γ)2 ≤ 2(b − a)E(γ),
(1.4.13)
and equality holds if and only if dγ ≡ const. dt Proof. By H¨older’s inequality
12 b b 2 dγ 1 dt ≤ (b − a) 2 dγ dt dt dt a a with equality precisely if dγ dt ≡ const. Lemma 1.4.3. If γ : [a, b] → M is a smooth curve, and ψ : [α, β] → [a, b] is a change of parameter, then L(γ ◦ ψ) = L(γ). Proof. Let t = ψ(τ ).
18
Chapter 1 Riemannian Manifolds
By the chain rule, L(γ ◦ ψ) =
β dψ 2 12 dτ gij x(γ(ψ(τ ))) x˙ i (ψ(τ )) x˙ j (ψ(τ )) dτ α
and by a change of variables, = L(γ).
Lemma 1.4.4. The Euler–Lagrange equations for the energy E are x ¨i (t) + Γijk (x(t))x˙ j (t)x˙ k (t) = 0, with Γijk = where
(1.4.14)
1 i g (gj,k + gk,j − gjk, ), 2
(g ij )i,j=1,...,d = (gij )−1
and
i = 1, . . . , d
(i.e. gi gj = δij )
∂ gj . ∂xk are called Christoffel symbols. gj,k =
The expressions Γijk
Proof. The Euler–Lagrange equations of a functional b I(x) = f (t, x(t), x(t))dt ˙ a
are given by d ∂f ∂f − i = 0, dt ∂ x˙ i ∂x In our case, recalling E(γ) =
1 2
i = 1, . . . , d.
gjk (x(t))x˙ j x˙ k dt,
we get
d gik (x(t))x˙ k (t) + gji (x(t))x˙ j (t) − gjk,i (x(t))x˙ j (t)x˙ k (t) = 0, dt for i = 1, . . . , d, hence ¨k + gji x ¨j + gik, x˙ x˙ k + gji, x˙ x˙ j − gjk,i x˙ j x˙ k = 0. gik x Renaming some indices and using the symmetry gik = gki , we get ¨m + (gk,j + gj,k − gjk, )x˙ j x˙ k = 0, 2gm x
= 1, . . . , d,
(1.4.15)
1.4 Riemannian Metrics
19
and from this 1 g i gm x¨m + gi (gk,j + gj,k − gjk, )x˙ j x˙ k = 0, i = 1, . . . , d. 2 Because of gi gm = δim , and thus gi gm x ¨m = x¨i , we obtain (1.4.14) from this. Definition 1.4.2. A smooth curve γ = [a, b] → M, which satisfies (with x˙ i (t) = d i x (γ(t)) etc.) dt x ¨i (t) + Γijk (x(t))x˙ j (t)x˙ k (t) = 0, for i = 1, . . . , d
(1.4.16)
is called a geodesic. Thus, geodesics are the critical points of the energy functional. By Lemma 1.4.3, the length functional is invariant under parameter changes. As in the Euclidean case, one easily sees that regular curves can be parametrized by arc length. We shall attempt to minimize the length within the class of regular smooth curves, and we shall succeed and complete the program in Corollary 1.4.2 below. The length is invariant under reparametrization by Lemma 1.4.3, therefore, if one seeks curves of shortest length, it suffices to consider curves that are parametrized by arc length. For such curves, by Lemma 1.4.2 one may minimize energy instead of length. Conversely, every critical point of the energy functional, i.e. each solution of (1.4.14), i.e. each geodesic, is parametrized proportionally to arc length. Namely, for a solution of (1.4.14) d d x, ˙ x ˙ = (gij (x(t))x˙ i (t)x˙ j (t)) dt dt ¨i x˙ j + gij x˙ i x ¨j + gij,k x˙ i x˙ j x˙ k = gij x = −(gjk, + gj,k − gk,j )x˙ x˙ k x˙ j + gj,k x˙ k x˙ x˙ j by formula (1.4.15), which is equivalent to (1.4.14) =0 since gjk, x˙ x˙ k x˙ j = gk,j x˙ x˙ k x˙ j by interchanging the indices j and .
Consequently x, ˙ x ˙ ≡ const, and hence the curve is parametrized proportionally to arc length. We have shown Lemma 1.4.5. Each geodesic is parametrized proportionally to arc length.
20
Chapter 1 Riemannian Manifolds
Theorem 1.4.2. Let M be a Riemannian manifold, p ∈ M, v ∈ Tp M. Then there exist ε > 0 and precisely one geodesic c : [0, ε] → M with c(0) = p, c(0) ˙ = v. In addition, c depends smoothly on p and v. Proof. (1.4.14) is a system of second order ODEs, and the Picard–Lindel¨of theorem yields the local existence and uniqueness of a solution with prescribed initial values and derivatives, and this solution depends smoothly on the data. We note that if x(t) is a solution of (1.4.14), so is x(λt) for any constant λ ∈ R. Denoting the geodesic of Theorem 1.4.2 with c(0) = p, c(0) ˙ = v by cv , we obtain cv (t) = cλv ( λt ) for λ > 0, t ∈ [0, ε]. In particular, cλv is defined on [0, λε ]. Since cv depends smoothly on v, and {v ∈ Tp M : v = 1} is compact, there exists ε0 > 0 with the property that for v = 1, cv is defined at least on [0, ε0 ]. Therefore, for any w ∈ Tp M with w ≤ ε0 , cw is defined at least on [0, 1]. Definition 1.4.3. Let M be a Riemannian manifold, p ∈ M, Vp :={v ∈ Tp M : cv is defined on [0, 1]} expp :Vp → M v → cv (1) is called the exponential map of M at p. By the preceding considerations, the domain of definition of the exponential map always at least contains a small neighborhood of 0 ∈ Tp M. In general, however, Vp is not all of Tp M, as is already seen in the example of a proper, open subset of Rd , equipped with the Euclidean metric. Nevertheless, we shall see in Theorem 1.5.2 below that for a compact Riemannian manifold, expp can be defined on all of Tp M. Theorem 1.4.3. The exponential map expp maps a neighborhood of 0 ∈ Tp M diffeomorphically onto a neighborhood of p ∈ M. Proof. Since Tp M is a vector space, we may identify T0 Tp M, the tangent space of Tp M at 0 ∈ Tp M, with Tp M itself. The derivative of expp at 0 then becomes a map from Tp M onto itself: d expp (0) : Tp M → Tp M. With this identification of T0 Tp M and Tp M, for v ∈ Tp M
1.4 Riemannian Metrics
21 d ctv (1)|t=0 dt d = cv (t)|t=0 dt = c˙ v (0) = v.
d expp (0)(v) =
Hence d expp (0) = id|Tp M .
(1.4.17)
In particular, d expp (0) has maximal rank, and by the inverse function theorem, there exists a neighborhood of 0 ∈ Tp M which is mapped diffeomorphically onto a neighborhood of p ∈ M. Let now e1 , e2 , . . . , ed (d = dim M ) be a basis of Tp M which is orthonormal w.r.t. the scalar product on Tp M defined by the Riemannian metric. Writing for each vector v ∈ Tp M its components w.r.t. this basis, we obtain a map Φ : Tp M → Rd v = v i ei → (v 1 , . . . , v d ). For the subsequent construction, we identify Tp M with Rd via Φ. By Theorem 1.4.3, there exists a neighborhood U of p which is mapped by exp−1 p diffeomorphically onto a neighborhood of 0 ∈ Tp M, hence, with our identification Tp M ∼ = Rd , diffeomorphically onto a neighborhood Ω of 0 ∈ Rd . In particular, p is mapped to 0. Definition 1.4.4. The local coordinates defined by the chart (exp−1 p , U ) are called (Riemannian) normal coordinates with center p. Theorem 1.4.4. In normal coordinates, we have for the Riemannian metric gij (0) = δij , Γijk (0)
= 0, (and also gij,k (0) = 0) for all i, j, k.
(1.4.18) (1.4.19)
Proof. (1.4.18) directly follows from the fact that the above identification Φ : Tp M ∼ = Rd maps an orthonormal basis of Tp M w.r.t. the Riemannian metric onto an Euclidean orthonormal basis of Rd . For (1.4.19), we note that in normal coordinates, the straight lines through the origin of Rd (or, more precisely, their portions contained in the chart image) are geodesic. Namely, the line tv, t ∈ R, v ∈ Rd , is mapped (for sufficiently small t) onto ctv (1) = cv (t), where cv (t) is the geodesic, parametrized by arc length, with c˙v (0) = v.
22
Chapter 1 Riemannian Manifolds
Inserting now x(t) = tv into the geodesic equation (1.4.14), we obtain because of x ¨(t) = 0 Γijk (tv)v j v k = 0, for i = 1, . . . , d. (1.4.20) In particular at 0, i.e. for t = 0, Γijk (0)v j v k = 0 for all v ∈ Rd , i = 1, . . . , d.
(1.4.21)
We put v = 12 (e + em ) and obtain because of the symmetry Γijk = Γikj Γim (0) = 0 for all i. Since this holds for all , m, all Γijk (0) vanish. By definition of Γijk , we obtain at 0 ∈ Rd g i (gj,k + gk,j − gjk, ) = 0 ∀ i, j, k, hence also gjm,k + gkm,j − gjk,m = 0 ∀ j, k, m. Adding now the relation (obtained by cyclic permutation of the indices) gkj,m + gmj,k − gkm,j = 0, we obtain (with gkj = gjk ) gjm,k (0) = 0, for all j, k, m.
Later on (in Chapter 4), we shall see that in general the second derivatives of the metric cannot be made to vanish at a given point by a suitable choice of local coordinates. The obstruction will be given by the curvature tensor. Further properties of Riemannian normal coordinates may best be seen by using polar coordinates, instead of the Euclidean ones (obtained from the map Φ). We therefore introduce on Rd the standard polar coordinates (r, ϕ1 , . . . , ϕd−1 ), where ϕ = (ϕ1 , . . . , ϕd−1 ) parametrizes the unit sphere S d−1 (the precise formula for ϕ will be irrelevant for our purposes), and we then obtain polar coordinates on Tp M via Φ again. We express the metric in polar coordinates and write grr instead of g11 , because of the special role of r. We also write grϕ instead of g1 , ∈ {2, . . . , d}, and gϕϕ as abbreviation for (gk )k,=2,...,d . In particular, in these coordinates at 0 ∈ Tp M (this point corresponds to p ∈ M ) grr (0) = 1, grϕ (0) = 0 by (1.4.18) and since this holds for Euclidean polar coordinates.
(1.4.22)
1.4 Riemannian Metrics
23
After these preparations, we return to the analysis of the geodesic equation (1.4.14). The lines ϕ ≡ const. are geodesic when parametrized by arc length. They are given by x(t) = (t, ϕ0 ), ϕ0 fixed, and from (1.4.14) Γirr = 0 for all i (we have written Γirr instead of Γi11 ), hence gi (2gr,r − grr, ) = 0, for all i, thus 2gr,r − grr, = 0, for all .
(1.4.23)
For = r, we conclude grr,r = 0, and with (1.4.22) then grr ≡ 1.
(1.4.24)
Inserting this in (1.4.23), we get grϕ,r = 0, and then again with (1.4.22) grϕ ≡ 0.
(1.4.25)
We have shown Theorem 1.4.5. For the polar coordinates, obtained by transforming the Euclidean coordinates of Rd , on which the normal coordinates with center p are based, into polar coordinates, we have ⎛ ⎞ 1 0 ··· 0 ⎜0 ⎟ ⎜ ⎟ gij = ⎜ . ⎟, ⎝ .. ⎠ g (r, ϕ) ϕϕ
0 where gϕϕ (r, ϕ) is the (d − 1) × (d − 1) matrix of the components of the metric w.r.t. angular variables (ϕ1 , . . . , ϕd−1 ) ∈ S d−1 . The polar coordinates of Theorem 1.4.5 are often called Riemannian polar coordinates. The situation is the same as for Euclidean polar coordinates: For example in polar coordinates on R2 , the Euclidean metric is given by 10 r02 . We point out once more that in contrast to Theorem 1.4.4, Theorem 1.4.5 holds not only at the origin 0 ∈ Tp M, but in the whole chart. Corollary 1.4.2. For any p ∈ M, there exists ρ > 0 such that Riemannian polar coordinates may be introduced on B(p, ρ) := {q ∈ M : d(p, q) ≤ ρ}. For any such ρ and any q ∈ ∂B(p, ρ), there is precisely one geodesic of shortest length (= ρ) from p to q, and in polar coordinates, this geodesic is given by the straight line x(t) = (t, ϕ0 ), 0 ≤ t ≤ ρ, where q is represented by the coordinates (ρ, ϕ0 ), ϕ0 ∈ S d−1 . Here, “of shortest length” means that the curve is the shortest one among all curves in M from p to q.
24
Chapter 1 Riemannian Manifolds
Proof. The first claim follows from Corollary 1.4.1 (and its proof) and Theorem 1.4.3. For the second claim, let c(t) = (r(t), ϕ(t)), 0 ≤ t ≤ T, be an arbitrary curve from p to q. c(t) need not be entirely contained in B(p, ρ) and may leave our coordinate neighborhood. Let t0 := inf{t ≤ T : d(c(t), p) ≥ ρ}. Then t0 ≤ T, and the curve c|[0,t0 ] is entirely contained in B(p, ρ). We shall show L(c|[0,t0 ] ) ≥ ρ with equality only for a straight line in our polar coordinates. This will then imply the second claim. The proof of this inequality goes as follows: t0 1 L(c|[0,t0 ] ) = (gij (c(t))c˙i c˙j ) 2 dt 0 t0 1 (grr (c(t))r˙ r) ˙ 2 dt ≥ 0
by (1.4.25) and since gϕϕ is positive definite = 0
t0
|r|dt ˙ ≥
t0
rdt ˙ by (1.4.24) 0
= r(t0 ) = ρ by definition of t0 , and equality holds precisely if gϕϕ ϕ˙ ϕ˙ ≡ 0, in which case ϕ(t) is constant and r˙ ≥ 0 and c(t) thus is a straight line through the origin. In particular, under the assumptions of Corollary 1.4.2, the Euclidean ball dρ (0) := {y ∈ Rd : |y| ≤ ρ} ⊂ Tp M is mapped under expp diffeomorphically onto the Riemannian ball with the same radius, B(p, ρ). Corollary 1.4.3. Let M be a compact Riemannian manifold. Then there exists ρ0 > 0 with the property that for any p ∈ M, Riemannian polar coordinates may be introduced on B(p, ρ0 ). Proof. By Corollary 1.4.2, for any p ∈ M, there exists ρ > 0 with those properties. By Theorem 1.4.2, expp is smooth in p. If thus expp is injective and of maximal rank on a closed ball with radius ρ in Tp M, there exists a neighborhood U of p such that for all q ∈ U, expq is injective and of maximal rank on the closed ball with radius ρ in Tq M. Since M is compact, it can be covered by finitely many such neighborhoods and we choose ρ0 as the smallest such ρ.
1.4 Riemannian Metrics
25
Corollary 1.4.4. Let M be a compact Riemannian manifold. Then there exists ρ0 > 0 with the property that any two points p, q ∈ M with d(p, q) ≤ ρ0 can be connected by precisely one geodesic of shortest length. This geodesic depends continuously on p and q. Proof. ρ0 from Corollary 1.4.3 satisfies the first claim by Corollary 1.4.2. Moreover, by the last claim of Corollary 1.4.2, the shortest geodesic from p to q ∈ B(p, ρ0 ) depends continuously on p. Exchanging the roles of p and q yields the continuous dependence on p as well. We explicitly point out that for any compact Riemannian manifold there is always more than one geodesic connection between any two points. (This will be discussed in Chapter 7.) Only the shortest geodesic is unique, provided p and q are sufficiently close. Let now M be a differentiable submanifold of the Riemannian manifold N. The Riemannian metric of N then induces a Riemannian metric on M, by restricting the former one to Tp M ⊂ Tp N for p ∈ N. Thus, M also becomes a Riemannian manifold. In particular, S n ⊂ Rn+1 obtains a Riemannian metric. We want to compute this metric in the local chart of §1.1, namely x1 xn for xn+1 = 1 , . . . , f (x1 , . . . , xn+1 ) = 1 − xn+1 1 − xn+1 =: (y1 , . . . , y n ) ∈ Rn . In the sequel, a Latin index occurring twice in a product has to be summed from 1 to n + 1, a Greek one from 1 to n. We compute 1 = xi xi = yα yα (1 − xn+1 )2 + xn+1 xn+1 hence xn+1 = and then xi =
yα y α − 1 yα y α + 1
2y i 1 + yα yα
(i = 1, . . . , n).
For g := f −1 then 2δjk 4y j y k ∂g j = − ∂y k 1 + yα yα (1 + yα y α )2 ∂g n+1 4y k = . k ∂y (1 + yα yα )2
for j = 1, . . . , n, k = 1, . . . , n
26
Chapter 1 Riemannian Manifolds
Let a tangent vector to S n be represented by w = (w 1 , . . . , wn ) in our chart. Then w, w = dg(w) · dg(w), where the point denotes the Euclidean
=
1 (1 +
y α y α )4
scalar product of Rn+1 4(1 + y α yα )2 wβ wβ − 16(1 + y α yα )yβ wβ yγ wγ + 16y β yβ yγ wγ yδ wδ + 16yβ wβ yγ wγ
=
4
2w
(1 + y α y α )
β
wβ .
Thus, the metric in our chart is given by gij (y) =
4 (1 + |y|2 )
2 δij .
Definition 1.4.5. A diffeomorphism h : M → N between Riemannian manifolds is an isometry if it preserves the Riemannian metric. Thus, for p ∈ M, v, w ∈ Tp M, and if ·, ·M and ·, ·N denotes the scalar products in Tp M and Th(p) N, resp., we have v, wM = dh(v), dh(w)N . A differentiable map h : M → N is a local isometry if for every p ∈ M there exists a neighborhood U for which h|U : U → h(U ) is an isometry, and h(U ) is open in N. If (gij (p)) and (γαβ (h(p))) are the coordinate representations of the metric, an isometry has to satisfy gij (p) = γαβ (h(p))
∂hα (p) ∂hβ (p) . ∂xi ∂xj
A local isometry thus has the same effect as a coordinate change. Isometries leave the lengths of tangent vectors and therefore also the lengths and energies of curves invariant. Thus, critical points, i.e. geodesics, are mapped to geodesics. With this remark, we may easily determine the geodesics of S n . The orthogonal group O(n + 1) operates isometrically on Rn+1 , and since it maps S n into S n , it also operates isometrically on S n . Let now p ∈ S n , v ∈ Tp S n . Let E be the two-dimensional plane through the origin of Rn+1 , containing v. We claim that the geodesic cv through p with tangent vector v is nothing but the great circle through p with tangent vector v (parametrized proportionally to arc length), i.e. the intersection of S n with E. For this, let S ∈ O(n + 1) be the reflection across that E. Together with cv , Scv is also a geodesic through p with tangent vector v. The uniqueness result of Theorem 1.4.2 implies cv = Scv , and thus the image of cv is the great circle, as claimed. As another example, we consider the torus T 2 introduced in §1.1. We introduce a metric on T 2 by letting the projection π be a local isometry. For each chart of the form (U, (π|U )−1 ), we use the Euclidean metric on π −1 (U ). Since the translations z → z + m1 w1 + m2 w2
(m1 , m2 ∈ Z)
1.4 Riemannian Metrics
27
are Euclidean isometries, the Euclidean metrics on the different components of π −1 (U ) (which are obtained from each other by such translations) yield the same metric on U. Hence, the Riemannian metric on T 2 is well defined. Since π is a local isometry, Euclidean geodesics of R2 are mapped onto geodesics 2 of T . The global behavior of geodesics on such a torus is most easily studied in the case where T 2 is generated by the two unit vectors w1 = (1, 0) and w2 = (0, 1): A straight line in R2 which is parallel to one of the coordinate axes then becomes a geodesic on T 2 that closes up after going around once. More generally, a straight line with rational slope becomes a closed, hence periodic geodesic on T 2 , while the image of one with irrational slope lies dense in T 2 . Before ending this section, we want to introduce the following important notion: Definition 1.4.6. Let M be a Riemannian manifold, p ∈ M. The injectivity radius of p is i(p) := sup{ρ > 0 : expp is defined on dρ (0) ⊂ Tp M and injective}. The injectivity radius of M is i(M ) := inf i(p). p∈M
For example, the injectivity radius of the sphere S n is π, since the exponential map of any point p maps the open ball of radius π in Tp M injectively onto the complement of the antipodal point of p. The injectivity radius of the torus just discussed is 12 , since here the exponential map is injective on the interior of a square with center 0 ∈ Tp M and side length 1. Perspectives. As the name suggests, the concept of a Riemannian metric was introduced by Bernhard Riemann, in his habilitation address [299]. He also suggested to consider more generally metrics obtained by taking metrics on the tangent spaces that are not induced by a scalar product. Such metrics were first systematically investigated by Finsler and are therefore called Finsler metrics. For a general metric space, a geodesic is defined as a curve which realizes the shortest distance between any two sufficiently close points lying on it. Those metric spaces that satisfy the conclusion of the Hopf–Rinow theorem (proved below) that any two points can be connected by a shortest geodesic are called geodesic length spaces, and they are amenable to geometric constructions as demonstrated by the school of Alexandrov. See e.g. [231], [18]. A Lorentz metric on a differentiable manifold of dimension d + 1 is given by an inner product of signature (1, d) on each tangent space Tp M depending smoothly on p. A Lorentz manifold is a differentiable manifold with a Lorentz metric. The prototype is Minkowski space, namely Rd+1 equipped with the inner product x, y = −x0 y 0 + x1 y 1 + . . . + xd y d for x = (x0 , x1 , . . . , xd ), y = (y 0 , y 1, . . . , y d ). Lorentz manifolds are the spaces occurring in general relativity. Let us briefly discuss some concepts. Tangent vectors V with negative,
28
Chapter 1 Riemannian Manifolds
positive, vanishing V 2 = V, V are called time-like, space-like, and light-like, resp. Length and energy of a curve may be defined formally as in the Riemannian case, and we again obtain geodesic equations. Geodesics whose tangent vectors all have norm zero are called null geodesics. They describe the paths of light rays. (Note that in our above description of the Minkowski metric, the conventions have been chosen so that the speed of light is 1.) Submanifolds of Lorentz manifolds whose tangent vectors are all space-like are ordinary Riemannian manifolds w.r.t. the induced metric. For treatments of Lorentzian geometry, an introduction is [248]. Deeper aspects are treated in Hawking and Ellis[141]. J. Nash proved that every Riemannian manifold M can be isometrically embedded into some Euclidean space Rk . For the proof of this result, he developed an implicit function theorem in Fr´echet spaces and an iteration technique that have found other important applications. A simpler proof was found by G¨ unther[135]. Although on a conceptual level, Nash’s theorem reduces the study of Riemannian manifolds to the study of submanifolds of Euclidean spaces, in practice the intrinsic point of view has proved to be preferable (see Perspectives on §1.3). In our presentation, we only consider finite dimensional Riemannian manifolds. It is also possible, and often very useful, to introduce infinite dimensional Riemannian manifolds. Those are locally modeled on Hilbert spaces instead of Euclidean ones. The lack of local compactness leads to certain technical complications, but most ideas and constructions of Riemannian geometry pertain to the infinite dimensional case. Such infinite dimensional manifolds arise for example naturally as certain spaces of curves on finite dimensional Riemannian manifolds. A thorough treatment is given in [190].
1.5
Existence of Geodesics on Compact Manifolds
In the preceding section, we have derived the local existence and uniqueness of geodesics on Riemannian manifolds. In this section, we address the global issue and show the existence of shortest (geodesic) connections between any two points of arbitrary distance on a given compact Riemannian manifold. In fact, we shall be able to produce a geodesic in any given homotopy class of curves with fixed endpoints, as well as in any homotopy class of closed curves. We recall the notion of homotopy between curves (see Appendix B): Definition 1.5.1. Two curves γ0 , γ1 on a manifold M with common initial and end points p and q, i.e. two continuous maps γ0 , γ1 : I = [0, 1] → M with γ0 (0) = γ1 (0) = p, γ0 (1) = γ1 (1) = q, are called homotopic if there exists a continuous map Γ: I ×I →M with Γ(0, s) = p, Γ(1, s) = q Γ(t, 0) = γ0 (t),
Γ(t, 1) = γ1 (t)
for all s ∈ I for all t ∈ I.
1.5 Existence of Geodesics on Compact Manifolds
29
Two closed curves c0 , c1 in M, i.e. two continuous maps c0 , c1 : S 1 → M, are called homotopic if there exists a continuous map c : S1 × I → M with c(t, 0) = c0 (t), c(t, 1) = c1 (t)
for all t ∈ S 1
(S 1 , as usual, is the unit circle parametrized by [0, 2π)). Lemma 1.5.1. The concept of homotopy defines an equivalence relation on the set of all curves in M with fixed initial and end points as well as on the set of all closed curves in M. The proof is elementary. With the help of this concept, we now want to show the existence of geodesics: Theorem 1.5.1. Let M be a compact Riemannian manifold, p, q ∈ M. Then there exists a geodesic in every homotopy class of curves from p to q, and this geodesic may be chosen as a shortest curve in its homotopy class. Likewise, every homotopy class of closed curves in M contains a curve which is shortest and geodesic. Since the proof is the same in both cases, we shall only consider the case of closed curves. As a preparation, we shall first show Lemma 1.5.2. Let M be a compact Riemannian manifold, ρ0 > 0 as in Corollary 1.4.4. Let γ0 , γ1 : S 1 → M be curves with d(γ0 (t), γ1 (t)) ≤ ρ0
for all t ∈ S 1 .
Then γ0 and γ1 are homotopic. Proof. For any t ∈ S 1 let ct (s) : I → M be the unique shortest geodesic from γ0 (t) to γ1 (t) (Corollary 1.4.4), as usual parametrized proportionally to arc length. Since ct depends continuously on its end points by Corollary 1.4.4, hence on t, Γ(t, s) := ct (s) is continuous and yields the desired homotopy.
Proof of Theorem 1.5.1. Let (γn )n∈N be a minimizing sequence for arc length in the given homotopy class. Here and in the sequel, all curves are parametrized
30
Chapter 1 Riemannian Manifolds
proportionally to arc length. We may assume w.l.o.g. that the curves γn are piecewise geodesic; namely, for each curve, we may find t0 = 0 < t1 < t2 < . . . < tm < tm+1 = 2π with the property that L(γn|[tj−1 ,tj ] ) ≤ ρ0 /2 (ρ0 as in Corollary 1.4.4), for j = 1, . . . , m + 1 with tm+1 := 2π. Replacing γn|[tj−1 ,tj ] by the shortest geodesic arc between γn (tj−1 ) and γn (tj ), we obtain a curve which is homotopic to and not longer than γn (the same argument also shows that each homotopy class does contain curves of finite length). We may thus assume that for any γn there exist points p0,n , . . . , pm,n for which d(pj−1,n , pj,n ) ≤ ρ0 (pm+1,n := p0,n , j = 1, . . . , m + 1) and for which γn contains the shortest geodesic arc between pj−1,n and pj,n . Since the lengths of the γn are bounded as they constitute a minimizing sequence, we may also assume that m is independent of n. After selection of a subsequence, by the compactness of M, the points p0,n , . . . , pm,n converge to points p0 , . . . , pm , for n → ∞. The segment of γn between pj−1,n and pj,n then converges to the shortest geodesic arc between pj−1 and pj , for example by Corollary 1.4.4. The union of these geodesic segments yields a curve γ. By Lemma 1.5.2, γ is homotopic to the γn , and L(γ) = lim L(γn ), n→∞
and since the curves γn are a minimizing sequence for the length in their homotopy class, γ is a shortest curve in this class. Therefore, γ has to be geodesic. Namely, otherwise, there would exist points p and q on γ for which one of the two segments of γ between p and q would have length at most ρ0 , but would not be geodesic. By Corollary 1.4.4, γ could then be shortened by replacing this segment by the shortest geodesic arc between p and q. By the argument of Lemma 1.5.2, this does not change the homotopy class, and we obtain a contradiction to the minimizing property of γ. γ thus is the desired closed geodesic. Corollary 1.5.1. On any compact Riemannian manifold M1 , any two points p, q can be connected by a curve of shortest length, and this curve is geodesic. Proof. Minimize over all curves between p and q (and not only over those in a fixed homotopy class) as in the proof of Theorem 1.5.1. We also show Theorem 1.5.2. Let M be a compact Riemannian manifold. Then for any p ∈ M, the exponential map expp is defined on all of Tp M, and any geodesic may be extended indefinitely in each direction. Proof. For v ∈ Tp M, let Λ := {t ∈ R+ : cv is defined on [−t, t]},
1.6 The Heat Flow and the Existence of Geodesics
31
where cv is, as usual, the geodesic with cv (0) = p, c˙v (0) = v. It follows from cv (−t) = c−v (t) that cv may also be defined for negative t, at the moment at least for those with sufficiently small absolute value. Theorem 1.4.2 implies Λ = ∅. The compactness of M implies the closedness of Λ. We shall now show openness of Λ : Let cv be defined on [−t, t]; for example c˙v (t) = w ∈ Tcv (t) M. By Theorem 1.4.2 there exists a geodesic γw (s) with γw (0) = cv (t), γ˙ w (0) = c˙v (t), for s ∈ [0, ε] and ε > 0. Putting cv (t+ s) = γw (s) for s ∈ [0, ε], we have extended cv to [−t, t+ ε]. Analogously, cv may be extended in the direction of negative t. This implies openness of Λ, hence Λ = R+ . The claims follow easily. Perspectives. For an axiomatic approach to the construction of closed geodesics on the basis of local existence and uniqueness, see [174].
1.6
The Heat Flow and the Existence of Geodesics
In the preceding section, we have derived the global existence of geodesics from the local existence and uniqueness of geodesic connections between points. In this section, we shall present an alternative method that uses methods from partial differential equations instead. This section thus serves as a first introduction to methods of geometric analysis. A reader who wishes to understand the geometry first may therefore skip this section. Conversely, for a reader interested in analytical methods, this section should be a good starting point. Our scheme developed here will use parabolic partial differential equations. The idea is to start with some curve (in the homotopy class under consideration) and let it evolve according to a partial differential equation that decreases its energy until the curve becomes geodesic in the limit of “time” going to infinity (in fact, this will constitute some gradient descent for the energy in an (infinite dimensional) space of curves). This is the so-called heat flow method. The methods we are going to present here can naturally prove all the statements of Theorem 1.5.1. Since we do not wish to be repetitive, however, we shall confine ourselves here to the existence of closed geodesics. Theorem 1.6.1. Let M be a compact Riemannian manifold. Then every homotopy class of closed curves in M contains a geodesic. Proof. In order to conform to conventions in the theory of partial differential equations, we need to slightly change our preceding notation. The parameter on a curve c : [0, 1] → M will now be called s, that is, the points on the curve are c(s), because we
32
Chapter 1 Riemannian Manifolds
need t for the time parameter of the evolution that we now introduce. For technical convenience, we also parametrize our closed curves on the unit circle S 1 instead of on the interval [0, 1] because we do not have to stipulate the closedness as an additional condition (c(0) = c(1) in the preceding sections). We consider mappings u : S 1 × [0, ∞) → M with arguments s ∈ S 1 , 0 ≤ t
(1.6.1)
and impose the partial differential equation ∂2 ∂ ∂ ∂ i u (s, t) = 2 ui (s, t) + Γijk (u(s, t)) uj (s, t) uk (s, t) for s ∈ S 1 , t ≥ 0 (1.6.2) ∂t ∂s ∂s ∂s (1.6.3) u(s, 0) = γ(s) for s ∈ S 1 for some smooth curve γ : S 1 → M in the given homotopy class. (1.6.2) can also be abbreviated in obvious notation for partial derivatives as uit = uiss + Γijk ujs uks .
(1.6.4)
The proof will then consist of several steps: 1. A solution of (1.6.2) exists at least on some short time interval [0, t0 ) for some t0 > 0. This implies more generally that the maximal interval of existence of a solution is nonempty and open. 2. For a solution u(s, t), the “spatial” derivative dently of t). We may then rewrite (1.6.4) as uit − uiss = f
∂ u(s, t) ∂s
stays bounded (indepen-
(1.6.5)
with some bounded function f and may apply the regularity theory for linear parabolic differential equations as presented in §A.3 to obtain a timeindependent control of higher derivatives. 3. Therefore, when a solution exists on [0, T ), for t → T , u(s, t) will converge to a smooth curve u(s, T ). This curve can then be taken as new initial values to continue the solution beyond T . This implies that the maximal existence interval is also closed. Consequently, the solution will exist for all time t > 0. d E(u(·, t)) = − S 1 ut (s, t)2 ds. 4. E(u(·, t)) is a decreasing function of t, in fact dt Since this quantity is also bounded from below, because nonnegative, we can find a sequence tn → ∞ for which u(·, tn ) will converge to a curve with uiss + Γijk ujs uks = 0, that is, a geodesic. 5. A convexity argument shows that this convergence not only takes place for some sequence tn → ∞, but generally for t → ∞. Step 1 is a general result from the theory of partial differential equations which follows by linearizing the equation at t = 0 and applying the implicit function theorem in
1.6 The Heat Flow and the Existence of Geodesics
33
Banach spaces, see §A.3. Therefore, we shall not discuss this here any further. For step 2, we compute, using the symmetry gij = gji repeatedly, ∂ ∂2 − )(gij (u(s, t))uis (s, t)ujs (s, t)) (1.6.6) ∂s2 ∂t = 2gij uiss ujss + 2gij (uisss − uist )ujs + 4gij,k uks ujs uiss − gij,k ukt uis ujs + gij,kl uks uls uis ujs .
(
From (1.6.4), we obtain uisss − uist = −Γijk,l uls ujs uks − 2Γijk ujss uks
(1.6.7)
which we can insert into (1.6.6). In order to simplify our computations, it is natural to use normal coordinates at the point under consideration so that all first derivatives of the metric gij and the Christoffel symbols Γijk vanish. Moreover, we then have Γijk,l =
1 (gij,kl + gik,jl − gjk,il ). 2
(1.6.8)
Inserting this as well, we obtain altogether (
∂ ∂2 − )(gij uis ujs ) = 2gij uiss ujss ∂s2 ∂t
(1.6.9)
because the terms with the second derivatives of gij cancel.1 This implies (
∂2 ∂ − )(gij uis ujs ) ≥ 0, ∂s2 ∂t
(1.6.10)
that is, gij uis ujs is a subsolution of the heat equation. principle (Theorem A.3.1) then implies that
The parabolic maximum
sup gij (u(s, t))uis (s, t)ujs (s, t)
(1.6.11)
s∈S 1
is a nonincreasing function of t. In particular, gij (u(s, t))uis (s, t)ujs (s, t) ≤ K
(1.6.12)
for some constant that does not depend on t and s. Thus, we have (1.6.5) with some bounded function f . We also note that since M is assumed compact, our solution u will automatically stay bounded. We may therefore apply the estimates of Theorem A.3.2.2 1 We shall see a deeper geometric interpretation of the computation leading to (1.6.9) in §8.2B below. 2 These estimates are local estimates on the domain, and therefore, we have to make sure that for suitable regions Ω × (t1 , t2 ) in S 1 × [0, ∞), the image of u on such a region stays in the same coordinate chart in which we write our equation (1.6.4). First of all, since we already have derived a bound on us , in particular u is uniformly continuous w.r.t. s. As a solution of the heat equation, u is also continuous w.r.t. t so that we may apply the estimates locally in time. The uniform continuity w.r.t. t will be derived shortly.
34
Chapter 1 Riemannian Manifolds
By the first estimate in Theorem A.3.2, u(s, t) therefore has H¨ older continuous first derivatives with respect to s. Since f is given in terms of such first derivatives, f then is also H¨older continuous. By the second estimate in Theorem A.3.2, we then get higher estimates. In fact, this procedure can be iterated. Higher order estimates on u from the linear theory imply a corresponding control on f which in turn then yields even higher estimates from the linear theory. (This is the so-called bootstrapping method.) This completes step 2. Step 3 is self-explanatory, and so we may now turn to step 4. The computation to follow is a consequence of (1.6.9), but as it is easier than the derivation of that formula, we do it directly. d 1 ∂ E(u(·, t)) = gij (u(s, t))uis (s, t)ujs (s, t) dt 2 ∂t S 1 1 (2gij uist ujs + gij,k ukt uis ujs ) = 2 S1 1 (−2gij uiss ujt − 2gij,k uks uit ujs + gij,k ukt uis ujs ) (integrating by parts) = 2 S1 gij uit ujt by (1.6.4). (1.6.13) =− S1
Since E is nonnegative and the integrand also satisfies pointwise estimates by step 2, we obtain the conclusion of step 4. Finally, we find by similar computations as above (again in normal coordinates) from (1.6.13) ∂ d2 E(u(·, t)) = − gij uit ujt dt2 ∂t S 1 =− 2gij uitt ujt 1 S =− 2gij uisst ujt S1 = 2gij uist ujst ≥ 0. (1.6.14) S1
Thus, the energy E(u(·, t)) is a convex function of t, and since we already know that d d E(u(·, tn )) → 0 for some sequence tn → ∞, we conclude that dt E(u(·, t)) → 0 for dt t → ∞. Thus, again invoking our pointwise estimates, ut (s, t) → 0 for t → ∞. This implies that u(s) = limt→∞ u(s, t) exists and is geodesic. This completes the proof. We remark that the closed geodesic produced by the heat flow method need not be the shortest curve in its homotopy class. The reason is simple: When the initial curve γ for the heat flow (1.6.2) happens to be a closed geodesic already, the heat flow will stay there, that is u(s, t) = γ(s) for all t ≥ 0. In particular, if γ is a closed geodesic that is not the shortest one in its homotopy class, the heat flow with those initial values will fail to produce a shortest one.
1.7 Existence of Geodesics on Complete Manifolds
1.7
35
Existence of Geodesics on Complete Manifolds
In this section, we want to address the question whether the results of Theorem 1.5.2 continue to hold for a more general class of Riemannian manifolds than the compact ones. Obviously, they do hold for Euclidean space which is not compact, but they do not hold for any proper open subset of Euclidean space, essentially since such a set is not complete. It will turn out that completeness will be the right condition for extending Theorem 1.5.2. Definition 1.7.1. A Riemannian manifold M is geodesically complete if for all p ∈ M, the exponential map expp is defined on all of Tp M, or, in other words, if any geodesic c(t) with c(0) = p is defined for all t ∈ R. We can now state the Theorem of Hopf–Rinow. Theorem 1.7.1. Let M be a Riemannian manifold. The following statements are equivalent: (i) M is complete as a metric space (or equivalently, it is complete as a topological space w.r.t. its underlying topology, see Corollary 1.4.1). (ii) The closed and bounded subsets of M are compact. (iii) There exists p ∈ M for which expp is defined on all of Tp M. (iv) M is geodesically complete, i.e. for every p ∈ M, expp is defined on all of Tp M. Furthermore, each of the statements (i) – (iv) implies (v) Any two points p, q ∈ M can be joined by a geodesic of length d(p, q), i.e. by a geodesic of shortest length. Proof. We shall first prove that if expp is defined on all of Tp M, then any q ∈ M can be connected with p by a shortest geodesic. In particular, this will show the implication (iv) ⇒ (v). For this purpose, let r := d(p, q), and let ρ > 0 be given by Corollary 1.4.2, let p0 ∈ ∂B(p, ρ) be a point where the continuous function d(q, ·) attains its minimum on the compact set ∂B(p, ρ). Then p0 = expp ρV, for some V ∈ Tp M. We consider the geodesic c(t) := expp tV, and we want to show that c(r) = q. c|[0,r] will then be a shortest geodesic from p to q.
(1.7.1)
36
Chapter 1 Riemannian Manifolds For this purpose, let I := {t ∈ [0, r] : d(c(t), q) = r − t}.
(1.7.1) means r ∈ I, and we shall show I = [0, r] for that purpose. I is not empty, as it contains 0 by definition of r, and it is closed for continuity reasons. I = [0, r] will therefore follow if we can show openness of I. Let t0 ∈ I. Let ρ1 > 0 be the radius of Corollary 1.4.2 corresponding to the point c(t0 ) ∈ M. W.l.o.g. ρ1 ≤ r − t0 . Let p1 ∈ ∂B(c(t0 ), ρ1 ) be a point where the continuous function d(q, ·) assumes its minimum on the compact set ∂B(c(t0 ), ρ1 ). Then (1.7.2) d(p, p1 ) ≥ d(p, q) − d(q, p1 ). Now for every curve γ from c(t0 ) to q, there exists some γ(t) ∈ ∂B(c(t0 ), ρ1 ). Hence L(γ) ≥ d(c(t0 ), γ(t)) + d(γ(t), q) = ρ1 + d(γ(t), q) ≥ ρ1 + d(p1 , q)
because of the minimizing property of p1 .
Hence also d(q, c(t0 )) ≥ ρ1 + d(p1 , q)
(1.7.3)
and by the triangle inequality, we then actually must have equality. Inserting (1.7.3) into (1.7.2) and recalling d(q, c(t0 )) = r − t0 gives d(p, p1 ) ≥ r − (r − t0 − ρ1 ) = t0 + ρ1 . On the other hand, there exists a curve from p to p1 of length t0 + ρ1 ; namely one goes from p to c(t0 ) along c and then takes the geodesic from c(t0 ) to p1 of length ρ1 . That curve thus is shortest and therefore has to be geodesic as shown in the proof of Theorem 1.5.1. By uniqueness of geodesics with given initial values, it has to coincide with c, and then p1 = c(t0 + ρ1 ). Since we observed that equality has to hold in (1.7.3), we get d(q, c(t0 + ρ1 )) = r − (t0 + ρ1 ), hence t0 + ρ1 ∈ I, and openness of I follows, proving our claim. It is now easy to complete the proof of Theorem 1.7.1: (iv) ⇒ (iii) is trivial.
Exercises for Chapter 1
37
(iii) ⇒ (ii) Let K ⊂ M be closed and bounded. Since bounded, K ⊂ B(p, r) for some r > 0. By what we have shown in the beginning, any point in B(p, r) can be connected with p by a geodesic (of length ≤ r). Hence, B(p, r) is the image of the compact ball in Tp M of radius r under the continuous map expp . Hence, B(p, r) is compact itself. Since K is assumed to be closed and shown to be contained in a compact set, it must be compact itself. (ii) ⇒ (i) Let (pn )n∈N ⊂ M be a Cauchy sequence. It then is bounded, and, by (ii), its closure is compact. It therefore contains a convergent subsequence, and being Cauchy, it has to converge itself. This shows completeness of M. (i) ⇒ (iv) Let c be a geodesic in M, parametrized by arc length, and being defined on a maximal interval I. I then is nonempty, and by Theorem 1.4.2, it is also open. To show closedness, let (tn )n∈N ⊂ I converge to t. Since d(c(tn ), c(tm )) ≤ |tn − tm | as c is parametrized by arc length, c(tn ) is a Cauchy sequence, hence has a limit p ∈ M, because we assume M to be complete. Let ρ > 0 be as in Corollary 1.4.2. Then B(p, ρ) is compact, being the image of the compact ball of radius r in Tp M under the continuous map expp . Therefore, the argument of Corollary 1.4.3 and Corollary 1.4.4 applies to show that there exists ρ0 > 0 with the property that for any point q ∈ B(p, ρ) any geodesic starting from q can be extended at least up to length ρ0 . Since c(tn ) converges to p, for all sufficiently large m, n d(c(tn ), c(tm )) ≤ |tn − tm | ≤ ρ0 /2 and d(c(tn ), p), d(c(tm ), p) ≤ ρ0 . Therefore, the shortest geodesic from c(tn ) to c(tm ) can be defined at least on the interval [−ρ0 , ρ0 ]. This shortest geodesic, however, has to be a subarc of c, and c thus can be defined up to the parameter value tn + ρ0 , in particular for t, showing closedness of I.
Exercises for Chapter 1 1. Give five more examples of differentiable manifolds besides those discussed in the text. 2. Determine the tangent space of S n . (Give a concrete description of the tangent bundle of S n as a submanifold of S n × Rn+1 .)
38
Chapter 1 Riemannian Manifolds 3. Let M be a differentiable manifold, τ : M → M an involution without fixed points, i.e. τ ◦ τ = id, τ (x) = x for all x ∈ M. We call points x and y in M equivalent if y = τ (x). Show that the space M/τ of equivalence classes possesses a unique differentiable structure for which the projection M → M/τ is a local diffeomorphism. Discuss the example M = S n ⊂ Rn+1 , τ (x) = −x. M/τ is real projective space RPn . 4.
a: Let N be a differentiable manifold, f : M → N a homeomorphism. Introduce a structure of a differentiable manifold on M such that f becomes a diffeomorphism. Show that such a differentiable structure is unique. b: Can the boundary of a cube, i.e. the set {x ∈ Rn ; max{|xi | : i = 1, . . . , n} = 1} be equipped with a structure of a differentiable manifold?
5. We equip Rn+1 with the inner product x, y := −x0 y 0 + x1 y 1 + . . . + xn yn for x = (x0 , x1 , . . . , xn ), y = (y 0 , y1 , . . . , y n ). We put H n := {x ∈ Rn+1 : x, x = −1, x0 > 0}. Show that ·, · induces a Riemannian metric on the tangent spaces Tp H n ⊂ Tp Rn+1 for p ∈ H n . H n is called hyperbolic space. 6. In the notations of Exercise 5, let s = (−1, 0, . . . , 0) ∈ Rn+1 f (x) := s −
2(x − s) . x − s, x − s
Show that f : H n → {ξ ∈ Rn : |ξ| < 1} is a diffeomorphism (here, Rn = {(0, x1 , . . . , xn )} ⊂ Rn+1 ). Show that in this chart, the metric assumes the form 4 dξ i ⊗ dξ i . (1 − |ξ|2 )2 7. Determine the geodesics of H n in the chart given in Exercise 6. (The geodesics through 0 are the easiest ones.) Hint for Exercises 5, 6, 7: Consult §5.4. 8. Determine the exponential map of the sphere S n , for example at the north pole p. Write down normal coordinates. Compute the supremum of the radii of balls in Tp S n on which expp is injective. Where does expp have maximal rank?
Exercises for Chapter 1
39
9. Same as Exercise 8 for the flat torus generated by (1, 0) and (0, 1) ∈ R2 . 10. Let c0 , c1 : [0, 1] → M be smooth curves in a Riemannian manifold. Show the following: If d(c0 (t), c1 (t)) < i(c0 (t)) for all t, there exists a smooth map c : [0, 1] × [0, 1] → M with c(t, 0) = c0 (t), c(t, 1) = c1 (t) for which the curves c(t, ·) are geodesics for all t. 11. Consider the surface S of revolution obtained by rotating the curve (x, y = ex , z = 0) in the plane, i.e. the graph of the exponential function, about the x-axis in Euclidean 3-space, equipped with the induced Riemannian metric from that Euclidean space. Show that X is complete and compute its injectivity radius. 12. Let M be a differentiable submanifold of the Riemannian manifold N. M then receives an induced Riemannian metric, and this metric defines a distance function and a topology on M, as explained in §1.4. Show that this topology coincides with the topology on M that is induced from the topology of N. 13. Prove Corollaries 5.2.3 and 5.2.4 below with the arguments used in the proofs of Theorem 1.4.5 and Corollary 1.4.2.
•
Chapter 2
Lie Groups and Vector Bundles
2.1
Vector Bundles
Definition 2.1.1. A (differentiable) vector bundle of rank n consists of a total space E, a base M, and a projection π : E → M, where E and M are differentiable manifolds, π is differentiable, each “fiber” Ex := π −1 (x) for x ∈ M, carries the structure of an n-dimensional (real) vector space, and the following local triviality requirement is satisfied: For each x ∈ M, there exist a neighborhood U and a diffeomorphism ϕ : π −1 (U ) → U × Rn with the property that for every y ∈ U ϕy := ϕ|Ey : Ey → {y} × Rn is a vector space isomorphism, i.e. a bijective linear map. Such a pair (ϕ, U ) is called a bundle chart. In the sequel, we shall omit the word “differentiable” for a vector bundle. Often, a vector bundle will simply be denoted by its total space. It is important to point out that a vector bundle is by definition locally, but not necessarily globally, a product of base and fiber. A vector bundle which is isomorphic to M × Rn (n = rank) is called trivial. A vector bundle may be considered as a family of vector spaces (all isomorphic to a fixed model Rn ) parametrized (in a locally trivial manner) by a manifold.
J. Jost, Riemannian Geometry and Geometric Analysis, Universitext, c Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2011 DOI 10.1007/978-3-642-21298-7 2,
42
Chapter 2 Lie Groups and Vector Bundles
Let now (E, π, M ) be a vector bundle of rank n, (Uα )α∈A a covering of M by open sets over which the bundle is trivial, and ϕα : π −1 (Uα ) → Uα × Rn be the corresponding local trivializations. For nonempty Uα ∩ Uβ , we obtain transition maps ϕβα : Uα ∩ Uβ → Gl (n, R) by
ϕβ ◦ ϕ−1 α (x, v) = (x, ϕβα (x)v)
for x ∈ Uα ∩ Uβ , v ∈ Rn ,
(2.1.1)
where Gl(n, R) is the general linear group of bijective linear selfmaps of Rn . The transition maps express the transformation behavior of a vector in the fiber under a change of local trivialization. The transition maps satisfy ϕαα (x) = idRn ϕαβ (x)ϕβα (x) = idRn ϕαγ (x)ϕγβ (x)ϕβα (x) = idRn
for x ∈ Uα
(2.1.2)
for x ∈ Uα ∩ Uβ
(2.1.3)
for x ∈ Uα ∩ Uβ ∩ Uγ .
(2.1.4)
These properties are direct consequences of (2.1.1). A vector bundle can be reconstructed from its transition maps. Theorem 2.1.1. E=
Uα × Rn / ∼ ,
α∈A
where denotes disjoint union, and the equivalence relation ∼ is defined by (x, v) ∼ (y, w) : ⇐⇒ x = y and w = ϕβα (x)v
(x ∈ Uα , y ∈ Uβ , v, w ∈ Rn ).
Proof. This is a straightforward verification of the properties required in Definition 2.1.1. A reader who does not want to carry this out him/herself may consult [150]. Definition 2.1.2. Let G be a subgroup of Gl(n, R), for example O(n) or SO(n), the orthogonal or special orthogonal group. We say that a vector bundle has the structure group G if there exists an atlas of bundle charts for which all transition maps have their values in G. Definition 2.1.3. Let (E, π, M ) be a vector bundle. A section of E is a differentiable map s : M → E with π ◦ s = idM . The space of sections of E is denoted by Γ(E). We have already seen an example of a vector bundle above, namely the tangent bundle T M of a differentiable manifold M. Definition 2.1.4. A section of the tangent bundle T M of M is called a vector field on M. Let now f : M → N be a differentiable map, (E, π, N ) a vector bundle over N. We want to pull back the bundle via f, i.e. construct a bundle f ∗ E, for which the fiber over x ∈ M is Ef(x) , the fiber over the image of x.
2.1 Vector Bundles
43
Definition 2.1.5. The pulled back bundle f ∗ E is the bundle over M with bundle charts (ϕ ◦ f, f −1 (U )), where (ϕ, U ) are bundle charts of E. We now want to extend some algebraic concepts and constructions from vector spaces to vector bundles by performing them fiberwise. For example: Definition 2.1.6. Let (E1 , π1 , M ) and (E2 , π2 , M ) be vector bundles over M. Let the differentiable map f : E1 → E2 be fiber preserving, i.e. π2 ◦ f = π1 , and let the fiber maps fx : E1,x → E2,x be linear, i.e. vector space homomorphisms. Then f is called a bundle homomorphism. Definition 2.1.7. Let (E, π, M ) be a vector bundle of rank n. Let E ⊂ E, and suppose that for any x ∈ M there exists a bundle chart (ϕ, U ) with x ∈ U and ϕ(π −1 (U ) ∩ E ) = U × Rm (⊂ U × Rn , m ≤ n). The resulting vector bundle (E , π|E , M ) is called a subbundle of E of rank m. Let us discuss an example: S 1 = {x ∈ R2 : |x|2 = 1} is a submanifold of R2 . If we restrict the tangent bundle T R2 of R2 to S 1 , we obtain a bundle E over S 1 that is isomorphic to S 1 × R2 . The tangent bundle of S 1 has fiber Tx S 1 = {y ∈ R2 : x · y = 0} ⊂ R2 (where the dot · denotes the Euclidean scalar product). T S 1 is a subbundle of T R2 |S 1 ; the reader is invited to write down explicit bundle charts. Definition 2.1.8. Let (E1 , π1 , M ) and (E2 , π2 , M ) be vector bundles over M. The Cartesian product of E1 and E2 is the vector bundle over M with fiber E1,x × E2,x and bundle charts (ϕα × ψβ , Uα ∩ Vβ ), where (ϕα , Uα ) and (ψβ , Vβ ) are bundle charts for E1 and E2 resp., and (ϕα × ψβ )(x, (v, w)) := (ϕα (x, v), ψβ (x, w))
(v ∈ E1,x , w ∈ E2,x ).
Thus, the product bundle is simply the bundle with fiber over x ∈ M being the product of the fibers of E1 and E2 over x. By this pattern, all constructions for vector spaces can be extended to vector bundles. Of particular importance for us will be dual space, exterior and tensor product. Let us briefly recall the definition of the latter: Let V and W be vector spaces (as always over R) of dimension m and n, resp., and let (e1 , . . . , em ) and (f1 , . . . , fn ) be bases. Then V ⊗ W is the vector space of dimension mn spanned by the basis (ei ⊗ fj ) i=1,...,m . There exists a canonical bilinear j=1,...,n map L: V ×W →V ⊗W mapping (ai ei , bj fj ) onto ai bj ei ⊗ fj One may then also define the tensor product of more than two vector spaces in an associative manner.
44
Chapter 2 Lie Groups and Vector Bundles
Definition 2.1.9. Let M be a differentiable manifold, x ∈ M. The vector space dual to the tangent space Tx M is called the cotangent space of M at the point x and denoted by Tx∗ M. The vector bundle over M whose fibers are the cotangent spaces of M is called the cotangent bundle of M and denoted by T ∗ M. Elements of T ∗ M are called cotangent vectors, sections of T ∗ M are 1-forms. We now want to study the transformation behavior of cotangent vectors. Let (ei )i=1,...,d be a basis of Tx M and (ωj )j=1,...,d the dual basis of Tx∗ M, i.e. 1 for i = j, j j ω (ei ) = δi = 0 for i = j. Moreover, let v = v i ei ∈ Tx M, η = ηj ω j ∈ Tx∗ M. We have η(v) = ηi v i . Let the bases (ei ) and (ω j ) be given by local coordinates, i.e. ei =
∂ , ∂xi
ω j = dxj .
Let now f be a coordinate change. v is transformed to f∗ (v) := v i
∂f α ∂ . ∂xi ∂f α
η then has to be transformed to f ∗ (η) := ηj
∂xj β df ∂f β
because in this case f ∗ (η)(f∗ (v)) = ηj
∂xj i ∂f α v = ηi v i = η(v). ∂f α ∂xi
Thus a tangent vector transforms with the functional matrix of the coordinate change whereas a cotangent vector transforms with the transposed inverse of this matrix. This different transformation behavior is expressed by the following definition: Definition 2.1.10. A p times contravariant and q times covariant tensor on a differentiable manifold M is a section of T .. ⊗ TM M ⊗ . p times
⊗
∗ . . ⊗ T ∗M . T M ⊗ . q times
Actually, one should speak of a tensor field, because “tensor” often also means an element of the corresponding fibers, in the same manner as a (tangent) vector is an element of Tx M and a vector field a section of T M. If f is a coordinate change, a p times contravariant and q times covariant tensor is transformed p times by the matrix (df ) and q times by the matrix (df −1 )t .
2.1 Vector Bundles
45
Lemma 2.1.1. A Riemannian metric on a differentiable manifold M is a two times covariant (and symmetric and positive definite) tensor on M. Proof. From the formula (1.4.5) for the transformation behavior of a Riemannian metric. A Riemannian metric thus is a section of T ∗ M ⊗ T ∗ M. We consequently write the metric in local coordinates as gij (x)dxi ⊗ dxj . Theorem 2.1.2. The tangent bundle of a Riemannian manifold M of dimension d has structure group O(d). Proof. Let (f, U ) be a bundle chart for T M, f : π −1 (U ) → U × Rd . Let e1 , . . . , ed be the canonical basis vectors of Rd , and let v1 , . . . , vd be the sections of π −1 (U ) with f (vi ) = ei , i = 1, . . . , d. Applying the Gram–Schmidt orthogonalization procedure to v1 (x), . . . , vd (x) for each x ∈ U we obtain sections w1 , . . . , wd of π −1 (U ) for which w1 (x), . . . , wd (x) are an orthonormal basis w.r.t. the Riemannian metric on Tx M, for each x ∈ U. By f : π −1 (U ) → U × Rd λi wi (x) → (x, λ1 , . . . , λd ) we then get a bundle chart which maps the basis w1 (x), . . . , wd (x), i.e. an orthonormal basis w.r.t. the Riemannian metric, for each x ∈ U onto an Euclidean orthonormal basis of Rd . We apply this orthonormalization process for each bundle chart and obtain a new bundle atlas whose transition maps always map an Euclidean orthonormal basis of Rd into another such basis, and are hence in O(d). We want to point out, however, that in general there do not exist local ∂ coordinates for which wi (x) = ∂x i for i = 1, . . . , d. Corollary 2.1.1. The tangent bundle of an oriented Riemannian manifold of dimension d has structure group SO(d). Proof. The orientation allows to select an atlas for which all transition maps have positive functional determinant. From this, one sees that we also may obtain transition functions for the tangent bundle with positive determinant. The orthonormalization process of Theorem 2.1.2 preserves the positivity of the determinant, and thus, in the oriented case, we obtain a new bundle atlas with transition maps in SO(d).
46
Chapter 2 Lie Groups and Vector Bundles
Definition 2.1.11. Let (E, π, M ) be a a vector bundle. A bundle metric is given by a family of scalar products on the fibers Ex , depending smoothly on x ∈ M. In the same manner as Theorem 2.1.2, one shows Theorem 2.1.3. Each vector bundle (E, π, M ) of rank n with a bundle metric has structure group O(n). In particular, there exist bundle charts (f, U ), f : π −1 (U ) → U × Rn , for which for all x ∈ U, f −1 (x, (e1 , . . . , en )) is an orthonormal basis of Ex (e1 , . . . , en is an orthonormal basis of Rn ). Definition 2.1.12. The bundle charts of Theorem 2.1.3 are called metric. In the same manner as Theorem 1.4.1, one shows Theorem 2.1.4. Each vector bundle can be equipped with a bundle metric. It will be more important for us, however, that a Riemannian metric automatically induces bundle metrics on all tensor bundles over M. The metric of the cotangent bundle is given in local coordinates by ω, η = gij ωi ηj
for ω = ωi dxi , η = ηi dxi .
(2.1.5)
(We recall that (g ij ) is the matrix inverse to (gij ).) Namely, this expression has the correct transformation behavior under coordinate changes: If w → x(w) is a coordinate change, we get ωi dxi = ωi
∂xi dwα =: ω ˜α dwα , ∂w α
while g ij is transformed into hαβ = gij
∂wα ∂w β , ∂xi ∂xj
and ˜ α η˜β = gij ωi ηj . hαβ ω Moreover, we get ω(x) = sup{ω(x)(v) : v ∈ Tx M, v = 1}. A Riemannian metric also induces an identification between T M and T ∗ M : v = vi
∂ corresponds to ω = ωj dxj ∂xi with or
(2.1.5) may also be justified as follows:
ωj = gij v i v i = gij ωj .
2.1 Vector Bundles
47
Under this identification, to v ∈ Tx M there corresponds a 1-form ω ∈ Tx∗ M via ω(w) := v, w
for all w
and (2.1.5) means then that ω = v. For example, on T M ⊗ T M, the metric is given by v ⊗ w, ξ ⊗ η = gij v i ξ j gk wk η l
(2.1.6)
∂ (v = v i ∂x i etc. in local coordinates).
Definition 2.1.13. A local orthonormal basis of Tx M of the type obtained in Theorem 2.1.3 is called an (orthonormal) frame field. We put Λp (Tx∗ M ) := Tx∗ M ∧ . . . ∧ Tx∗ M
(exterior product).
p times
On Λp (Tx∗ M ), we have two important operations: First, the exterior product by η ∈ Tx∗ M = Λ1 (Tx∗ M ) : Λp (Tx∗ M ) → Λp+1 (Tx∗ M ) ω −→ (η)ω := η ∧ ω. Second, the interior product or contraction by an element v ∈ Tx M : Λp (Tx∗ M ) → Λp−1 (Tx∗ M ) ω −→ ι(v)ω with ι(v)ω(v1 , . . . , vp−1 ) := ω(v, v1 , . . . , vp−1 ) for v, v1 , . . . , vp−1 ∈ Tx M. In fact, such constructions may be carried out with any vector space W and its dual W ∗ in place of Tx∗ M and Tx M . This will be relevant in §2.4. The vector bundle over M with fiber Λp (Tx∗ M ) over x is then denoted by Λp (M ). Definition 2.1.14. The space of sections of Λp (M ) is denoted by Ωp (M ), i.e. Ωp (M ) = Γ(Λp (M )). Elements of Ωp (M ) are called (exterior) p-forms. A p-form thus is a sum of terms of the form ω(x) = η(x)dxi1 ∧ . . . ∧ dxip where η(x) is a smooth function and (x1 , . . . , xd ) are local coordinates.
48
Chapter 2 Lie Groups and Vector Bundles
Definition 2.1.15. The exterior derivative d : Ωp (M ) → Ωp+1 (M ) (p = 0, 1, . . . , dim M ) is defined through the formula d(η(x)dxi1 ∧ . . . ∧ dxip ) =
∂η(x) j dx ∧ dxi1 ∧ . . . ∧ dxip ∂xj
and extended by linearity to all of Ωp (M ). Lemma 2.1.2. If ω ∈ Ωp (M ), ϑ ∈ Ωq (M ), then d(ω ∧ ϑ) = dω ∧ ϑ + (−1)p ω ∧ dϑ. Proof. This easily follows from the formula ω ∧ ϑ = (−1)pq ϑ ∧ ω and the definition of d. Let f : M → N be a differentiable map, ω(z) = η(z)dz i1 ∧ . . . ∧ dz ip ∈ Ωp (N ). We then define f ∗ (ω)(x) = η(f (x))
∂f i1 α1 ∂f ip αp dx ∧ . . . ∧ dx . α ∂x 1 ∂xαp
This obviously is the correct transformation formula for p-forms. Lemma 2.1.3.
d(f ∗ (ω)) = f ∗ (dω).
Proof. This easily follows from the transformation invariance ∂η(z) j ∂η(f (x)) ∂f j α ∂η(f (x)) α dz = dx = dx . ∂z j ∂z j ∂xα ∂xα
Corollary 2.1.2. d is independent of the choice of coordinates. Proof. Apply Lemma 2.1.3 to a coordinate transformation f. Theorem 2.1.5.
d ◦ d = 0.
Proof. By linearity of d, it suffices to check the asserted identity on forms of the type ω(x) = f (x)dxi1 ∧ . . . ∧ dxip .
2.1 Vector Bundles Now
49
∂f j i1 ip dx ∧ dx ∧ . . . ∧ dx ∂xj ∂2 f dxk ∧ dxj ∧ dxi1 ∧ . . . ∧ dxip = ∂xj ∂xk = 0,
d ◦ d(ω(x)) = d
since
∂2 f ∂xj ∂xk
=
∂2 f ∂xk ∂xj
(f is assumed to be smooth) and dxj ∧ dxk = −dxk ∧ dxj .
Let now M be a differentiable submanifold of the Riemannian manifold N ; dim M = m, dim N = n. We saw already that M then also carries a Riemannian metric. For x ∈ M, we define Tx⊥ M ⊂ Tx N by
Tx⊥ M := {v ∈ Tx N : ∀ w ∈ Tx M : v, w = 0},
where ., ., as usual, is the scalar product given by the Riemannian metric. The spaces Tx⊥ M are the fibers of a vector bundle T ⊥ M over M, and T M and T ⊥ M are both subbundles of T N|M , the restriction of T N to M (in a more complicated manner: T N|M = i∗ T N, where i : M → N is the differentiable embedding of M as a submanifold of N ). In order to see this, one may choose the first m basis vectors v1 , . . . , vm of T N|M in the orthonormalization procedure of the proof of Theorem 2.1.2 in such a manner that they locally span T M. Then T M is also locally spanned by w1 , . . . , wm (notation as in the proof of Theorem 2.1.2), and the remaining basis vectors then span T ⊥ M, and we have wi , wα = 0 for i = 1, . . . , m, α = m + 1, . . . , n. Thus, T ⊥ M is the orthogonal complement of T M in T N|M . Definition 2.1.16. T ⊥ M is called the normal bundle of M in N. For our example of the submanifold S 1 of R2 , T ⊥ S 1 is the subbundle of T R2|S 1 , the restriction of T R2 to S 1 , with fiber Tx⊥ S 1 = {λx : λ ∈ R} ⊂ R2 . We conclude this section with a consideration of the complex case – again, we remind the reader that is needed only in particular places, like §6.2. Definition 2.1.17. A vector bundle E over a differentiable manifold M is called a complex vector bundle if each fiber Ez = π −1 (z) is a complex vector space, i.e., isomorphic to z × Ck , and if that complex structure varies smoothly, that is, the local trivializations are of the form ϕ : π−1 (U ) → U × Ck .
50
Chapter 2 Lie Groups and Vector Bundles We thus have transition maps ϕβα : Uα ∩ Uβ → Gl (k, C).
Here, in contrast to the Definition 1.1.5 of a complex manifold, we neither require that the base M be complex nor that these transition maps be holomorphic. If, however, these conditions are satisfied, that is, M is a complex manifold and the transition maps are holomorphic, then we have a holomorphic vector bundle. On a complex manifold M , in local holomorphic coordinates, we have the 1-forms ¯
dz j := dxj + idy j , dz k := dxj − idyj (recall (1.1.2)). We can then decompose the space Ωk of k-forms into subspaces Ωp,q with p + q = k. Namely, Ωp,q is locally spanned by forms of the type ¯
¯
ω(z) = η(z)dz i1 ∧ . . . ∧ dz ip ∧ dz j1 ∧ . . . ∧ dz jq . Thus Ωk (M ) =
Ωp,q (M ).
(2.1.7)
p+q=k
We can then let the differential operators ∂ 1 ∂ 1 ∂ ∂ j j ¯ − i j (dx + idy ) and ∂ = + i j (dxj − idyj ) (2.1.8) ∂= 2 ∂xj ∂y 2 ∂xj ∂y operate on such a form by ∂ω = and
∂η i ¯ ¯ dz ∧ dz i1 ∧ . . . ∧ dz ip ∧ dz j1 ∧ . . . ∧ dz jq ∂z i
(2.1.9)
¯ = ∂η dz¯j ∧ dz i1 ∧ . . . ∧ dz ip ∧ dz¯j1 ∧ . . . ∧ dz¯jq . ∂ω (2.1.10) ∂z¯j The following important relations link them with the exterior derivative d:
Lemma 2.1.4. The exterior derivative d satisfies ¯ d = ∂ + ∂.
(2.1.11)
∂∂ = 0, ∂¯∂¯ = 0, ¯ . ∂ ∂¯ = −∂∂
(2.1.12)
Moreover,
Proof. We have
(2.1.13)
∂ ∂ ∂ 1 ∂ j j (dx (dxj − idy j ) − i + idy ) + + i ∂xj ∂yj 2 ∂xj ∂y j ∂ ∂ dxj + j dy j = d. = ∂xj ∂y
1 ∂ + ∂¯ = 2
2.2 Integral Curves of Vector Fields. Lie Algebras
51
Therefore, ¯ ¯ = ∂ 2 + ∂ ∂¯ + ∂∂ ¯ + ∂¯2 0 = d2 = (∂ + ∂)(∂ + ∂) and decomposing this into types yields (2.1.12) and (2.1.13). One may verify these relations also by direct computation, e.g. ∂ ∂¯ =
2.2
∂2 ∂2 ¯ ¯ k j ¯ dz ∧ dz = − dz k ∧ dz j = −∂∂. ¯ ∂z j ∂z k ∂z k¯ ∂z j
Integral Curves of Vector Fields. Lie Algebras
Let M be a differentiable manifold, X a vector field on M, i.e. a (smooth) section of the tangent bundle T M. X then defines a first order differential equation (or, more precisely, if dim M > 1, a system of differential equations): c˙ = X(c).
(2.2.1)
This means the following: For each p ∈ M, one wants to find an open interval I = Ip around 0 ∈ R and a solution of the following differential equation for c : I → M dc (t) = X(c(t)) for t ∈ I dt c(0) = p .
(2.2.2)
One checks in local coordinates that this is indeed a system of differential equations: in such coordinates, let c(t) be given by (c1 (t), . . . , cd (t))
(d = dim M )
and let X be represented by Xi
∂ . ∂xi
Then (2.2.2) becomes dci (t) = X i (c(t)) dt
for i = 1, . . . , d.
(2.2.3)
Since (2.2.3) has a unique solution for given initial value c(0) = p by the Picard– Lindel¨of theorem, we obtain
52
Chapter 2 Lie Groups and Vector Bundles
Lemma 2.2.1. For each p ∈ M, there exist an open interval Ip ⊂ R with 0 ∈ Ip and a smooth curve cp : Ip → M with dcp (t) = X(cp (t)) dt cp (0) = p.
Since the solution also depends smoothly on the initial point p by the theory of ODEs, we furthermore obtain Lemma 2.2.2. For each p ∈ M, there exist an open neighborhood U of p and an open interval I with 0 ∈ I, with the property that for all q ∈ U, the curve cq (c˙q (t) = X(cq (t)), cq (0) = q) is defined on I. The map (t, q) → cq (t) from I × U to M is smooth. Definition 2.2.1. The map (t, q) → cq (t) is called the local flow of the vector field X. The curve cq is called the integral curve of X through q. For fixed q, one thus seeks a curve through q whose tangent vector at each point coincides with the value of X at this point, i.e. a curve which is always tangent to the vector field X. Now, however, we want to fix t and vary q; we put ϕt (q) := cq (t). Theorem 2.2.1. We have ϕt ◦ ϕs (q) = ϕt+s (q),
if s, t, t + s ∈ Iq ,
(2.2.4)
and if ϕt is defined on U ⊂ M, it maps U diffeomorphically onto its image. Proof. We have c˙q (t + s) = X(cq (t + s)), hence cq (t + s) = ccq (s) (t). Starting from q, at time s one reaches the point cq (s), and if one proceeds a time t further, one reaches cq (t + s). One therefore reaches the same point if one walks from q on the integral curve for a time t + s, or if one walks a time t from cq (s). This shows (2.2.4). Inserting t = −s into (2.2.4) for s ∈ Iq , we obtain ϕ−s ◦ ϕs (q) = ϕ0 (q) = q. Thus, the map ϕ−s is the inverse of ϕs , and the diffeomorphism property follows.
2.2 Integral Curves of Vector Fields. Lie Algebras
53
Corollary 2.2.1. Each point in M is contained in precisely one integral curve for (2.2.1). Proof. Let p ∈ M . Then p = cp (0), and so it is trivially contained in an integral curve. Assume now that p = cq (t). Then, by Theorem 2.2.1, q = cp (−t). Thus, any point whose flow line passes through p is contained in the same flow line, namely the one starting at p. Therefore, there is precisely one flow line going through p. We point out, however, that flow lines can reduce to single points; this happens for those points for which X(p) = 0. Also, flow lines in general are not closed even if the flow exists for all t ∈ R. Namely, the points limt→±∞ cp (t) (assuming that these limits exist) need not be contained in the flow line through p. Definition 2.2.2. A family (ϕt )t∈I (I open interval with 0 ∈ I) of diffeomorphisms from M to M satisfying (2.2.4) is called a local 1-parameter group of diffeomorphisms. In general, a local 1-parameter group need not be extendable to a group, since the maximal interval of definition Iq of cq need not be all of R. This is already seen by d , i.e. c(t) ˙ = c2 (t) as differential equation. easy examples, e.g. M = R, X(τ ) = τ 2 dτ However Theorem 2.2.2. Let X be a vector field on M with compact support. Then the corresponding flow is defined for all q ∈ M and all t ∈ R, and the local 1-parameter group becomes a group of diffeomorphisms. Proof. By Lemma 2.2.2, for every p ∈ M there exist a neighborhood U and ε > 0 such that for all q ∈ U, the curve cq is defined on (−ε, ε). Let now supp X ⊂ K, K compact. K can then be covered by finitely many such neighborhoods, and we choose ε0 as the smallest such ε. Since for q ∈ K, X(q) = 0, ϕt (q) = cq (t) is defined on (−ε0 , ε0 ) × M, and for |s|, |t| < ε0 /2, we have the semigroup property (2.2.4). Since the interval of existence (−ε0 , ε0 ) may be chosen uniformly for all q, one may iteratively extend the flow to all of R. For this purpose, we write t ∈ R as t=m
ε0 + ρ with m ∈ Z, 0 ≤ ρ < ε0 /2 2
and put ϕt := (ϕε0 /2 )m ◦ ϕρ . (ϕt )t∈R then is the desired 1-parameter group.
54
Chapter 2 Lie Groups and Vector Bundles
Corollary 2.2.2. On a compact differentiable manifold, any vector field generates a 1-parameter group of diffeomorphisms. The preceding is a geometric interpretation of systems of first order ODEs on manifolds. However, also higher order systems of ODEs may be reduced to first order systems by introducing additional independent variables. As an example, we want to study the system for geodesics, i.e. in local coordinates x ¨i (t) + Γijk (x(t))x˙ j (t)x˙ k (t) = 0,
i = 1, . . . , d.
(2.2.5)
We want to transform this second order system into a first order system on the cotangent bundle T ∗ M. As usual, we locally trivialize T ∗ M by a chart T ∗ M|U U × Rd with coordinates (x1 , . . . , xd , p1 , . . . , pd ). We also put H(x, p) =
1 ij g (x)pi pj 2
(g ij (x)gjk (x) = δki ) .
(2.2.6)
(The transformation behavior of g ij and pk implies that H does not depend on the choice of coordinates.) Theorem 2.2.3. (2.2.5) is equivalent to the following system on T ∗ M : ∂H = gij (x)pj ∂pi ∂H 1 p˙ i = − i = − gjk ,i (x)pj pk ∂x 2 x˙ i =
(gjk ,i :=
∂ jk g ). ∂xi
Proof. From the first equation x ¨i = gij (x)p˙j + g ij ,k (x)x˙ k pj = gij p˙ j + g ij ,k x˙ k gj x˙ and with the second equation then 1 x ¨i = − g ij g k ,j p pk + gij ,k gj x˙ k x˙ , 2 1 ij m = g g gmn,j g nk gr x˙ r gks x˙ s − g im gmn,k g nj gj x˙ k x˙ 2
(2.2.7)
2.2 Integral Curves of Vector Fields. Lie Algebras
55
using g ij , = −gim gmn, g nj (which follows from gij gjk = δki ), 1 ij g gmn,j x˙ m x˙ n − g im gmn,k x˙ k x˙ n 2 1 = gij (gmn,j − gjn,m − gjm,n )x˙ m x˙ n 2 =
since gmn,k x˙ k x˙ n = 12 gmn,k x˙ k x˙ n + 12 gmk,n x˙ k x˙ n and after renumbering some indices, = −Γimn x˙ m x˙ n . Definition 2.2.3. The flow determined by (2.2.7) is called the cogeodesic flow. The geodesic flow on T M is obtained from the cogeodesic flow by the first equation of (2.2.7). Thus, the geodesic lines are the projections of the integral curves of the geodesic flow onto M. The reason for considering the cogeodesic instead of the geodesic flow is that the former is a Hamiltonian flow for the Hamiltonian H from (2.2.6). We remark that by (2.2.7), we have along the integral curves dH = Hxi x˙ i + Hpi p˙ i = −p˙ i x˙ i + x˙ i p˙ i = 0. dt Thus, the cogeodesic flow maps the set Ex := {(x, p) ∈ T ∗ M : H(x, p) = λ} onto itself for every λ ≥ 0. If M is compact, so are all Eλ . Hence, by Corollary 2.2.2, the geodesic flow is defined on all of Eλ , for every λ. Since M = ∪λ≥0 Eλ , Theorem 2.2.3 yields a new proof of Theorem 1.5.2. If ψ : M → N is a diffeomorphism between differentiable manifolds, and if X is a vector field on M, we define a vector field Y = ψ∗ X on N by
Y (p) = dψ(X(ψ −1 (p))).
(2.2.8)
Then Lemma 2.2.3. For any differentiable function f : N → R (ψ∗ X)(f )(p) = X(f ◦ ψ)(ψ −1 (p)) . Proof. (ψ∗ X)(f )(p) = (dψ ◦ X)(f )(p) = (df ◦ dψ ◦ X)(ψ −1 (p)) = X(f ◦ ψ)(ψ −1 (p)).
(2.2.9)
56
Chapter 2 Lie Groups and Vector Bundles If ϕ : N → P is another diffeomorphism, obviously (ϕ ◦ ψ)∗ X = ϕ∗ (ψ∗ (X)).
(2.2.10)
Lemma 2.2.4. Let X be a vector field on M, ψ : M → N a diffeomorphism. If the local 1-parameter group generated by X is given by ϕt , the local group generated by ψ∗ X is ψ ◦ ϕt ◦ ψ −1 . Proof. ψ ◦ ϕt ◦ ψ −1 is a local 1-parameter group, and therefore, by uniqueness of solutions of ODEs, it suffices to show the claim near t = 0. Now d d (ψ ◦ ϕt ◦ ψ−1 (p))|t=0 = dψ ϕt ◦ ψ−1 (p)|t=0 dt dt (where dψ is evaluated at ϕ0 ◦ ψ −1 (p) = ψ−1 (p)) = dψX(ψ−1 (p)) = ψ∗ X(p).
Definition 2.2.4. For vector fields X, Y on M, the Lie bracket [X, Y ] is defined as the vector field Xj
i ∂Y i ∂ ∂ j ∂X − Y ∂xj ∂xi ∂xj ∂xi
(X = X i
∂ ∂ , Y = Y i i ). ∂xi ∂x
We say that the vector fields X and Y commute, if [X, Y ] = 0. Lemma 2.2.5. [X, Y ] is linear (over R) in X and Y. For a differentiable function f : M → R, we have [X, Y ]f = X(Y (f )) − Y (X(f )). Furthermore, the Jacobi identity holds: [[X, Y ], Z] + [[Y, Z], X] + [[Z, X], Y ] = 0 for any three vector fields X, Y, Z. ∂ i ∂ Proof. In local coordinates with X = X i ∂x i , Y = Y ∂xi , we have
[X, Y ]f = X j
∂Y i ∂f ∂X i ∂f −Yj j = X(Y (f )) − Y (X(f )) j i ∂x ∂x ∂x ∂xi
(2.2.11)
and this is linear in f, X, Y. This implies the first two claims. The Jacobi identity follows by direct computation.
2.2 Integral Curves of Vector Fields. Lie Algebras
57
Definition 2.2.5. A Lie algebra (over R) is a real vector space V equipped with a bilinear map [·, ·] : V × V → V, the Lie bracket, satisfying: (i) [X, X] = 0
for all X ∈ V.
(ii) [X, [Y, Z]] + [Y, [Z, X]] + [Z, [X, Y ]] = 0
for all X, Y, Z ∈ V.
Corollary 2.2.3. The space of vector fields on M, equipped with the Lie bracket, is a Lie algebra. Lemma 2.2.6. Let ψ : M → N be a diffeomorphism, X, Y vector fields on M. Then [ψ∗ X, ψ∗ Y ] = ψ∗ [X, Y ].
(2.2.12)
Thus, ψ∗ induces a Lie algebra isomorphism. Proof. Directly from Lemma 2.2.3. We now want to investigate how one might differentiate tensor fields. A function f : M → R, if smooth, may simply be differentiated at a point x by comparing its values at x with those at neighboring points. For a tensor field S, this is not possible any more, because the values of S at different points lie in different spaces, and it is not clear how to compare elements of different fibers. For this purpose, however, one might use a map F of one fiber onto another one, and an element v of the first fiber may then be compared with an element w of the second fiber by comparing F (v) and w. One possibility to obtain such a map at least between neighboring fibers (which is sufficient for purposes of differentiation) is to use a local 1-parameter group ∂ (ψt )t∈I of diffeomorphisms. If for example X = X i ∂x i is a vector field, we consider (ψ−t )∗ X(ψt (x)). This yields a curve Xt in Tx M (for t ∈ I), and such a curve may be differentiated. In particular, (ψ−t )∗
k ∂ψ−t ∂ ∂ (ψt (x)) = (evaluated at ψt (x)). i ∂x ∂xi ∂xk
(2.2.13)
k
∂ϕ ∂ ∂ (In general, one has for ϕ : M → N, ϕ∗ ∂x i = ∂xi ∂ϕk , but in case M = N and x and ϕ(x) are contained in the same coordinate neighborhood, of course ∂ϕ∂ k = ∂x∂ k .) If ω = ωi dxi is a 1-form, we may simply consider
(ψt∗ )(ω)(x) = ωi (ψt (x))
∂ψti k dx , ∂xk
(2.2.14)
which is a curve in Tx∗ M. In general for a smooth map ϕ : M → N and a 1-form ω = ωi dz i on N, ϕ∗ ω := ωi (ϕ(x))
∂z i k dx ; ∂xk
note that ϕ need not be a diffeomorphism here.
(2.2.15)
58
Chapter 2 Lie Groups and Vector Bundles Analogously, for a section h = hij dz i ⊗ dz j , of T ∗ N ⊗ T ∗ N (ϕ∗ )h = hij
∂z i ∂z j k dx ⊗ dx . ∂xk ∂x
(2.2.16)
Finally, for a function f : N → R of course ϕ∗ f = f ◦ ϕ.
(2.2.17)
If ϕ : M → N is a diffeomorphism, and Y is a vector field on N, we put ϕ∗ Y := (ϕ−1 )∗ Y
(2.2.18)
in order to unify our notation. ϕ∗ is then defined analogously for other contravariant tensors. In particular, for a vector field X on M and a local group (ψt )t∈I as above: (ψt∗ )X = (ψ−t )∗ X.
(2.2.19)
Definition 2.2.6. Let X be a vector field with a local 1-parameter group (ψt )t∈I of local diffeomorphisms, S a tensor field on M. The Lie derivative of S in the direction X is defined as d LX S := (ψt∗ S)|t=0 . dt Theorem 2.2.4. (i) Let f : M → R be a (differentiable) function. Then LX (f ) = df (X) = X(f ). (ii) Let Y be a vector field on M. Then LX Y = [X, Y ]. ∂ (iii) Let ω = ωj dxj be a 1-form on M. Then for X = X i ∂x i
LX ω =
∂ωj i ∂X i X + ωi dxj . ∂xi ∂xj
Proof. (i) LX (f ) =
d ∗ dt ψt f|t=0
=
d dt f
◦ ψt|t=0 =
∂f i ∂xi X
= X(f ) (cf. (2.2.17)).
2.2 Integral Curves of Vector Fields. Lie Algebras
59
∂ (ii) Y = Y i ∂x i.
d ∗ i ∂ ψ (Y ) dt t ∂xi |t=0 d ∂ = (ψ−t )∗ (Y i i )|t=0 by (2.2.19) dt ∂x j ∂ψ−t d i ∂ = (Y (ψt ) ) by (2.2.13), Lemma 2.2.3 dt ∂xi ∂xj |t=0 ∂X j ∂ d ∂Y i k j ∂ X δi j + Y i (− i ) j , since ψ0 = id, ψ−t|t=0 = −X = k ∂x ∂x ∂x ∂x dt j j ∂ k ∂Y k ∂X = (X −Y ) ∂xk ∂xk ∂xj = [X, Y ].
LX Y =
(iii) d ∗ (ψ ω) dt t |t=0 d ∂ψj = (ωj (ψt ) kt dxk )|t=0 by (2.2.14) dt ∂x ∂ω j i j k ∂X j k d = X δk dx + ωj dx , since ψ0 = id, ψt|t=0 = X i ∂x ∂xk dt ∂ωj ∂X i = ( i Xi + ωi )dxj . ∂x ∂xj
LX ω =
In this manner, also Lie derivatives of arbitrary tensor fields may be computed. For example for h = hij dxi ⊗ dxj ∂X i k ∂X j i j dx ⊗ dx + h dx ⊗ dxk ij ∂xk ∂xk ∂X k ∂X k = (hij,k X k + hkj + hik )dxi ⊗ dxj . i ∂x ∂xj
LX h = hij,k X k dxi ⊗ dxj + hij
(2.2.20)
Remark. For vector fields X, Y, Z and ψ = ψt , the local flow of X, Lemma 2.2.6 yields by differentiation at t = 0 LX [Y, Z] = [LX Y, Z] + [Y, LX Z], and with Theorem 2.2.4 (ii), we then obtain the Jacobi identity [X, [Y, Z]] = [[X, Y ], Z] + [Y, [X, Z]] = −[Z, [X, Y ]] − [Y, [Z, X]].
60
Chapter 2 Lie Groups and Vector Bundles
Definition 2.2.7. Let M carry a Riemannian metric g = gij dxi ⊗ dxj . A vector field X on M is called a Killing field or an infinitesimal isometry if LX (g) = 0.
(2.2.21)
Lemma 2.2.7. A vector field X on a Riemannian manifold M is a Killing field if and only if the local 1-parameter group generated by X consists of local isometries. Proof. From (2.2.21) d ∗ (ψ g) = 0. dt t |t=0 Since this holds for every point of M, we obtain ψt∗ g = g
(2.2.22)
for all t ∈ I.
Therefore, the diffeomorphisms ψt are isometries. Conversely, if the ψt are isometries, (2.2.22) holds, hence also (2.2.21). Lemma 2.2.8. The Killing fields of a Riemannian manifold constitute a Lie algebra. Proof. The space of all vector fields on a differentiable manifold constitute a Lie algebra by Corollary 2.2.3. The claim then follows if we show that the space of Killing fields is closed under the Lie bracket [., .], i.e. that for any two Killing fields X and Y, [X, Y ] is again a Killing field. This, however, follows from the following identity which was derived in the proof of Theorem 2.2.4 (ii): [X, Y ] = LX Y =
d dψ−t Y (ψt )|t=0 , dt
where (ψt )t∈I is the local group of isometries generated by X. Namely, for any fixed t, ψ−t ◦ ϕs ◦ ψt , is the local group for dψ−t Y (ψt ), where (ϕs )s∈I is the local group generated by Y. Since ψt and ϕs are isometries, so are ψ−t ◦ ϕs ◦ ψt . It follows that L[X,Y ] g =
∂2 (ψ−t ϕs ψt )∗ g|s=t=0 = 0. ∂s∂t
Thus, [X, Y ] indeed is a Killing field.
2.3 Lie Groups
2.3
61
Lie Groups
Definition 2.3.1. A Lie group is a group G carrying the structure of a differentiable manifold or, more generally, of a disjoint union of finitely many differentiable manifolds for which the following maps are differentiable: G × G → G (multiplication) (g, h) → g · h and G→G g → g
−1
(inverse) .
We say that G acts on a differentiable manifold M from the left if there is a differentiable map G×M →M (g, x) → gx that respects the Lie group structure of G in the sense that g(hx) = (g · h)x
for all g, h ∈ G, x ∈ M.
An action from the right is defined analogously. The Lie groups we shall encounter will mostly be linear algebraic groups. In order to describe the most important ones, let V be a vector space over R of dimension n. We put Gl(V ) := {A : V → V linear and bijective}, the vector space isomorphisms of V . If V is equipped with a scalar product ·, ·, we put O(V ) := {A ∈ Gl(V ) : Av, Av = v, v for all v ∈ V } and SO(V ) := {A ∈ O(V ) : the matrix Aei , ej i,j=1,...,n has positive determinant for some (and hence any) basis e1 , . . . , en of V }. (In the terminology of §3.3 below, one might express the last condition as: A transforms positive bases into positive bases.) Clearly SO(V ) ⊂ O(V ). Gl(V ), SO(V ) and O(V ) become Lie groups w.r.t. composition of linear maps. Since bijectivity is an open condition, the tangent space to Gl(V ), for example at the identity linear map, i.e. the Lie algebra of Gl(V ), can be identified with gl(V ) := {X : V → V linear},
62
Chapter 2 Lie Groups and Vector Bundles
the space of endomorphisms of V . The Lie algebra bracket is simply given by [X, Y ] = XY − Y X. The Lie algebra of SO(V ) then is obtained by differentiating the relation Av, Aw = v, w, i.e. as so(V ) := {X ∈ gl(V ) : Xv, w + v, Xw = 0 for all v, w ∈ V }, the skew symmetric endomorphisms of V . (Of course, this is also the Lie algebra of O(V ), and therefore in the sequel, we shall sometimes write o(V ) in place of so(V ).) The relation between a Lie algebra and its Lie group is given by the exponential map which in the present case is simply 1 1 eX = Id + X + X 2 + X 3 + · · · 2 3! For t ∈ R, we have
t2 2 X + ... 2 As the ordinary exponential map converges, this series converges for all t ∈ R, and etX is continuous in t. For s, t ∈ R, we have e(s+t)X = esX etX . etX = Id + tX +
In particular
eX e−X = Id.
Therefore, eX is always invertible, i.e. in Gl(V ), with inverse given by e−X . Thus, for each X ∈ gl(V ), t −→ etX yields a group homomorphism from R to Gl(V ). We assume that ·, · is nondegenerate. Every X ∈ gl(V ) then has an adjoint X ∗ characterized by the relation Xv, w = v, X ∗ w With this notation
for all v, w ∈ V .
X ∈ so(V ) ⇐⇒ X = −X ∗ .
For X ∈ so(V ), then
hence eX ∈ SO(V ).
eX
∗
1 = Id + X ∗ + (X ∗ )2 + . . . 2 1 2 = Id − X + X − . . . = e−X = (eX )−1 , 2
2.3 Lie Groups
63
In fact, the exponential map maps so(V ) onto SO(V ). However, the exponential map from gl(V ) is not surjective; its image does not even contain all elements of Gl+ (V ), the subgroup of automorphisms of V with positive determinant (w.r.t. some basis). Typically, (V, ·, ·) will be the Euclidean space of dimension n, i.e. Rn with its standard Euclidean scalar product. For that purpose, we shall often use the notation Gl(n, R) in place of Gl(V ), gl(n), O(n), SO(n), o(n), so(n) in place of gl(V ), O(V ), SO(V ), o(V ), so(V ) etc. Sometimes, we shall also need complex vector spaces. Let VC be a vector space over C of complex dimension m. We put Gl(VC ) := {A : VC → VC complex linear and bijective}. If VC is equipped with a Hermitian product ·, ·, we put U(VC )(:= U(VC , ·, ·)) := {A ∈ Gl(VC ) : Av, Aw = v, w for all v, w ∈ VC } SU(VC ) := {A ∈ U(VC ) : det A = 1}. The associated Lie algebras are gl(VC ) := {X : VC → VC complex linear} u(VC ) := {X ∈ gl(VC ) : Xv, w + v, Xw = 0 for all v, w ∈ VC } (the skew Hermitian endomorphisms of VC ), and su(VC ) := {X ∈ u(VC ) : tr X = 0} (the skew Hermitian endomorphisms with vanishing trace), where the trace tr is defined using a unitary basis e1 , . . . , em of VC , i.e. ei , ej = δij . If V is Cm with its standard Hermitian product, we write Gl(m, C), U(m), SU(m) etc. in place of Gl(VC ), U(VC ), SU(VC ) etc. For A, B ∈ Gl(V ), we have the conjugation by A: Int (A)B = ABA−1 .
(2.3.1)
For X ∈ gl(V ), then the induced action of A is given by (Ad A)X = AXA−1 , and for Y ∈ gl(V ), we obtain the infinitesimal version (ad Y )X = Y X − XY = [Y, X] as follows by writing B = etX , A = esY and differentiating (2.3.1) w.r.t. t and s and s = t = 0. Thus, Ad and ad associate to each element in Gl(V ) resp. gl(V ) a linear endomorphism of the vector space gl(V ). Thus, Ad and ad yield representations
64
Chapter 2 Lie Groups and Vector Bundles
of the Lie group Gl(V ) and the Lie algebra gl(V ), resp., on the vector space gl(V ). These representations are called adjoint representations. The unit element of a Lie group G will be denoted by e. For g ∈ G, we have the left translation Lg : G → G h → gh and the right translation Rg : G → G h → hg. Lg and Rg are diffeomorphisms of G, (Lg )−1 = Lg−1 . A vector field X on G is called left invariant if for all g, h ∈ G Lg∗ X(h) = X(gh) (see (2.2.8) for the definition of Lg∗ ; note that we should write (Lg )∗ for Lg∗ ), i.e. Lg∗ X = X ◦ Lg . (2.3.2) Theorem 2.3.1. Let G be a Lie group. For every V ∈ Te G, X(g) := Lg∗ V
(2.3.3)
defines a left invariant vector field on G, and we thus obtain an isomorphism between Te G and the space of left invariant vector fields on G. Proof. X(gh) = L(gh)∗ V = Lg∗ Lh∗ V = Lg∗ X(h) which is left invariance. Since a left invariant vector field is determined by its value at any point of G, for example at e, we obtain an isomorphism between Te G and the space of left invariant vector fields. By Lemma 2.2.6, for g ∈ G and vector fields X, Y [Lg∗ X, Lg∗ Y ] = Lg∗ [X, Y ].
(2.3.4)
Consequently, the Lie bracket of left invariant vector fields is left invariant itself, and the space of left invariant vector fields is closed under the Lie bracket and hence forms a Lie subalgebra of the Lie algebra of all vector fields on G (cf. Corollary 2.2.3). From Theorem 2.3.1, we obtain
2.3 Lie Groups
65
Corollary 2.3.1. Te G carries the structure of a Lie algebra. Definition 2.3.2. The Lie algebra g of G is the vector space Te G equipped with the Lie algebra structure of Corollary 2.3.1. We may easily construct so-called left invariant Riemannian metrics on a Lie group G by the following procedure: We select a scalar product ·, · on the Lie algebra Te G. For h ∈ G, V ∈ Th G, there exists a unique Ve ∈ Te G with V = Lh∗ Ve ,
(2.3.5)
since Lh is a diffeomorphism. We then put for V, W ∈ Th G V, W := Ve , We .
(2.3.6)
This defines a Riemannian metric on G which is left invariant. In analogy to the definition of a vector bundle (Definition 2.1.1) where the fiber is a vector space we now define a principal bundle as one where the fiber is a Lie group. Definition 2.3.3. Let G be a Lie group. A principal G-bundle consists of a base M, which is a differentiable manifold, and a differentiable manifold P, the total space of the bundle, and a differentiable projection π : P → M, with an action of G on P satisfying: (i) G acts freely on P from the right: (q, g) ∈ P × G is mapped to qg ∈ P, and qg = q for g = e. The G-action then defines an equivalence relation on P : p ∼ q : ⇐⇒ ∃g ∈ G : p = qg. (ii) M is the quotient of P by this equivalence relation, and π : P → M maps q ∈ P to its equivalence class. By (i), each fiber π−1 (x) can then be identified with G. (iii) P is locally trivial in the following sense: For each x ∈ M, there exist a neighborhood U of x and a diffeomorphism ϕ : π−1 (U ) → U × G of the form ϕ(p) = (π(p), ψ(p)) which is G-equivariant, i.e. (π(p), ψ(p)g) for all g ∈ G.
ϕ(pg) =
As in Definition 2.1.2, a subgroup H of G is called the structure group of the bundle P if all transition maps take their values in H. Here, the structure group operates on G by left translations. The notions of vector and principal bundle are closely associated with each other as we now want to explain briefly. Given a principal G-bundle P → M and a vector space V on which G acts from the left, we construct the associated vector bundle E → M with fiber V as follows:
66
Chapter 2 Lie Groups and Vector Bundles
We have a free action of G on P × V from the right: P ×V ×G →P ×V (p, v) · g = (p · g, g−1 v) . If we divide out this G-action, i.e. identify (p, v) and (p, v)·g, the fibers of (P ×V )/G → P/G become vector spaces isomorphic to V, and E := P ×G V := (P × V )/G → M is a vector bundle with fiber G ×G V := (G × V )/G = V and structure group G. The transition functions for P also give transition functions for E via the left action of G on V. Conversely, given a vector bundle E with structure group G, we construct a principal G-bundle as Uα × G/ ∼ α
with (xα , gα ) ∼ (xβ , gβ ) : ⇐⇒ xα = xβ ∈ Uα ∩ Uβ
and gβ = ϕβα (x)gα
where {Uα } is a local trivialization of E with transition functions ϕβα , as in Theorem 2.1.1. P can be considered as the bundle of admissible bases of E. In a local trivialization, each fiber of E is identified with Rn , and each admissible basis is represented by a matrix contained in G. The transition functions describe a base change. For example, if we have an SO(n) vector bundle E, i.e. a vector bundle with structure group SO(n), then the associated principal SO(n) bundle is the bundle of oriented orthonormal bases (frames) for the fibers of E. Perspectives. Lie groups, while only treated relatively briefly in the present book, form a central object of mathematical study. An introduction to their geometry and classification may be found in [144]. As symmetry groups of physical systems, they also play an important role in modern physics, in particular in quantum mechanics and quantum field theory. We shall encounter Lie groups again in Chapter 6 as isometry groups of symmetric spaces. A theorem of Myers–Steenrod says that the isometry group of a Riemannian manifold is a Lie group. For a generic Riemannian manifold, the isometry group is discrete or even trivial. A homogeneous space is a Riemannian manifold with a transitive group G of isometries. It may thus be represented as G/H where H := {g ∈ G : gx0 = x0 } is the isotropy group of an arbitrarily selected x0 ∈ M. Homogeneous spaces form important examples of Riemannian manifolds and include the symmetric spaces discussed in Chapter 6.
2.4 Spin Structures
2.4
67
Spin Structures
For the definition of the Dirac operator in §4.4 and its applications in Chapter 10, we need a compact Lie group, Spin (n), which is not a subgroup of Gl(n, R), but rather a two-fold covering of SO(n) for n ≥ 3. The case n = 4 will be particularly important for our applications. In order to define Spin (n), we start by introducing Clifford algebras. We let V be a vector space of dimension n over R, equipped with a positive 1 definite inner product ·, ·. We put v := v, v 2 , for every v ∈ V . For a substantial part of the algebraic constructions to follow, in fact a not necessarily nondegenerate quadratic form on V would suffice, but here we have no need to investigate the most general possible construction. On the contrary, for our purposes it suffices to take Rn with its standard Euclidean scalar product. An orthonormal basis will be denoted by e1 , . . . , en . Definition 2.4.1. The Clifford algebra Cl(V ), also denoted Cl(n), is the quotient of V ⊗ . . . ⊗ V generated by V by the two-sided ideal generated the tensor algebra k≥0
by all elements of the form v ⊗ v + v2 for v ∈ V . Thus, the multiplication rule for the Clifford algebra Cl(V ) is vw + wv = −2v, w.
(2.4.1)
In particular, in terms of our orthonormal basis e1 , . . . , en , we have ei 2 = −1 and ei ej = −ei ej for i = j.
(2.4.2)
From this, one easily sees that a basis of Cl(V ) as a real vector space is given by e0 := 1,
eα := eα1 eα2 . . . eαk
with α = {α1 , . . . , αk } ⊂ {1, . . . , n} and α1 < α2 . . . < αk . For such an α, we shall put |α| := k in the sequel. Thus, as a vector space, Cl(V ) is isomorphic to Λ∗ (V ) (as algebras, these two spaces are of course different). In particular, the dimension of Cl(V ) as a vector space is 2n . Also, declaring this basis as being orthonormal, we obtain a scalar product on Cl(V ) extending the one on V . We define the degree of eα as being |α|. The eα of degree k generate the subset Clk (V ) of elements of degree k. We have Cl0 = R Cl1 = V. Finally, we let Clev (V ) and Clodd (V ) be the subspaces of elements of even, resp. odd degree. The former is a subalgebra of Cl(V ), but not the latter. Lemma 2.4.1. The center of Cl(V ) consists of those elements that commute with all v ∈ Cl1 (V ) = V . For n even, the center is Cl0 (V ), while for n odd, it is Cl0 (V ) ⊕ Cln (V ).
68
Chapter 2 Lie Groups and Vector Bundles
Proof. It suffices to consider basis vectors eα = eα1 . . . eαk as above. For j ∈ α, we have eα ej = (−1)|α| ej eα , and thus |α| has to be even for eα to commute with ej , while eα eαj = (−1)|α|−1 eαj eα , so that |α| needs to be odd for a commutation. The conclusion follows easily for monomials and with a little algebra also in the general case. We next observe that Cl2 =: spin(V )
(or simply spin(n))
is a Lie algebra with the bracket [a, b] = ab − ba.
(2.4.3)
For that, note that [a, b] ∈ Cl2 (V ) if a, b ∈ Cl2 (V ) as an easy consequence of (2.4.2). To verify this, let us first consider the case a = ei ej ,
b = ek el
with the indices i, j, k, l all different. In this case ei ej ek el − ek el ei ej = ei ek el ej − ek el ei ej = ek el ei ej − ek el ei ej = 0
by (2.4.2).
Another case is a = ei ej ,
b = ej ek .
Then, using (2.4.2) ei ej ej ek − ej ek ei ej = −ei ek − ej ej ek ei = −ei ek + ek ei = −2ei ek ∈ Cl2 (V ). From these two cases, the general pattern should be clear. In a similar manner, the bracket defines an action τ of Cl2 (V ) on Cl1 (V ) = V : τ (a)v := [a, v] := av − va. Again, by (2.4.2) [a, v] ∈ Cl1 (V ) if a ∈ Cl2 (V ), v ∈ Cl1 (V ). Let us consider the two typical cases as before, first a = ei ej ,
v = ek ,
(2.4.4)
2.4 Spin Structures
69
with i, j, k all different. Then ei ej ek − ek ei ej = ei ej ek − ei ej ek = 0. The second case is a = ei ej ,
v = ei .
Then ei ej ei − ei ei ej = −ei ei ej − ei ei ej = 2ej ∈ Cl1 (V ). Lemma 2.4.2. τ defines a Lie algebra isomorphism between spin(V ) and so(V ). Proof. Since, as noted, τ (a) preserves V , and since one readily checks that τ [a, b] = [τ (a), τ (b)], τ defines a Lie algebra homomorphism from spin(V ) = Cl2 (V ) to gl(V ). For a ∈ Cl2 (V ), 1 1 τ (a)v, w + v, τ (a)w = − [[a, v], w] − [v, [a, w]] 2 2 = 0,
by (2.4.1)
(2.4.5)
as one easily checks by employing (2.4.2), after the same pattern as above. Therefore, τ (a) ∈ so(V ) for all a ∈ Cl2 (V ). It follows from Lemma 2.4.1 that τ is injective on Cl2 (V ). Since Cl2 (V ) and so both are vector spaces of dimension n(n−1) , and τ is an injective linear map between them, τ in fact has to be bijective. 2 In the Clifford algebra Cl(V ), one can now define an exponential series as in gl(V ), and one may define the group Spin (V ) as the exponential image of the Lie algebra spin(V ). Spin (V ) then becomes a Lie group. This follows from general properties of the exponential map. Here, however, we rather wish to define Spin (v) directly, as this may be more instructive from a geometric point of view. For that purpose, let us first introduce an anti-automorphism a → at of Cl(V ), defined on a basis vector eα1 eα2 . . . eαk as above by (eα1 eα2 . . . eαk )t = eαk . . . eα2 eα1 (= (−1) In particular
t
eα1 eα2 . . . eαk (eα1 . . . eαk ) = Also, for all a, b ∈ Cl(V )
k(k−1) 2
eα1 eα2 . . . eαk ).
1, if k is even −1, if k is odd.
(ab)t = bt at .
(2.4.6)
(2.4.7)
(2.4.8)
Definition 2.4.2. Pin(V ) is the group of elements of Cl(V ) of the form a = a1 . . . ak with ai ∈ V, ai = 1 for i = 1, . . . , k. Spin (V ) is the group Pin(V ) ∩ Clev (V ), i.e. the group of elements of Cl(v) of the form a = a1 . . . a2m with ai ∈ V, ai = 1 for i = 1, . . . , 2m (m ∈ N). We shall often write Pin(n), Spin (n) in place of Pin(Rn ), Spin (Rn ), resp.
70
Chapter 2 Lie Groups and Vector Bundles From (2.4.7), we see that Spin (V ) is the group of all elements a ∈ Pin(V ) with aat = 1.
Theorem 2.4.1. Putting
(2.4.9)
ρ(a)v := avat
defines a surjective homomorphism ρ : Pin(V ) → O(V ) with ρ(Spin (V )) = SO(V ). In particular, Pin(V ) ⊂ Cl(V ) acts on V . This is the so-called vector representation, not to be confused with the spinor representation introduced below. Proof. We start with a ∈ V , a = 1. In that case, every v ∈ V decomposes as v = λa + a⊥ , with a, a⊥ = 0, λ ∈ R. Then, since a = at for a ∈ V ρ(a)v = a(λa + a⊥ )a = −λa − aaa⊥ ,
since aa = aat = −1 ⊥
⊥
and a a + aa = 0
by (2.4.7) by (2.4.2)
⊥
= −λa + a . Consequently ρ(a) is the reflection across the hyperplane orthogonal to a. This is an element of O(V ). Then also for a general a = a1 . . . ak ∈ Pin(V ), ρ(a) is a product of reflections across hyperplanes, hence in O(V ). The preceding construction also shows that all reflections across hyperplanes are contained in the image of ρ(Pin(V )). Since every element in O(V ) can be represented as a product of such reflections,1 it follows that ρ(Pin(V )) = O(V ). If now a ∈ Spin (V ), then ρ(a) is a product of an even number of reflections, hence in SO(V ). Since every element SO(V ) can conversely be represented as a product of an even number of reflections, it follows that ρ(Spin (V )) = SO(V ). From (2.4.8), it is clear that ρ(ab) = ρ(a)ρ(b), and so ρ defines a homomorphism. Let us now determine the kernel of ρ : Spin (V ) → SO(V ). If a ∈ ker ρ, then ρ(a)v = v for all v ∈ V . From the definition of ρ and aat = 1 for a ∈ Spin (V ), we obtain that this is equivalent to av = va for all v ∈ V, 1 Every rotation of a plane is a product of two reflections, and the normal form of an orthogonal matrix shows that it can be represented as a product of rotations and reflections in mutually orthogonal planes.
2.4 Spin Structures
71
i.e. a commutes with all elements of V . Since all elements in Spin (V ) are even, Lemma 2.4.1 implies a ∈ R. Since aat = 1, we conclude that a = ±1. We next claim that Spin (V ) is connected for dimR V ≥ 2. Let a = a1 . . . a2m ∈ Spin (V ), with ai in the unit sphere of V .
(2.4.10)
Since that sphere is connected, we may connect every ai by a path ai (t) to e1 . Hence, a can be connected to e1 . . . e1 (2m times), which is ±1. Thus we need to connect 1 and −1. We use the path π π π π γ(t) = cos t e1 + sin t e2 cos t e1 − sin t e2 2 2 2 2 π π π π = − cos2 t + sin2 t − 2 sin t cos t e1 e2 , 2 2 2 2 since e1 e1 = e2 e2 = −1. This path is contained in Spin (V ) and satisfies γ(0) = −1, γ(1) = 1, and we have shown connectedness of Spin (V ) for dimR V ≥ 2. (2.4.10) also easily implies that Spin (V ) is compact. If we finally use the information that π1 (SO(V )) = Z2 for n = dimR V ≥ 3, we obtain altogether Theorem 2.4.2. ρ : Spin (V ) → SO(V ) is a nontrivial double covering. Spin (V ) is compact and connected, and for dimR V ≥ 3, it is also simply connected. Thus, for dimR V ≥ 3, Spin (V ) is the universal cover of SO(V ). Let us briefly return to the relation between spin(V ) and Spin (V ). differentiate the relation characterizing Spin (V ), i.e. aat = 1
If we
and avat ∈ V for all v ∈ V ,
(differentiating means that we consider a = 1 + b + O(2 ) and take the derivative w.r.t. at = 0), we obtain the infinitesimal relations b + bt = 0
and bv + vbt = bv − vb for all v ∈ V ,
which were the relations satisfied by elements of spin(V ) = Cl2 (V ). Since the preceding implies that Spin (V ) and spin(V ) have the same dimension, namely the , spin(V ) indeed turns out to be the Lie algebra one of SO(V ) and so(V ), i.e. n(n−1) 2 of the Lie group Spin (V ). Let us also discuss the induced homomorphism dρ : spin(V ) → so(V ), the infinitesimal version of ρ. The preceding discussion implies that dρ coincides with the Lie algebra isomorphism τ of Lemma 2.4.2. In order to obtain a more explicit
72
Chapter 2 Lie Groups and Vector Bundles
relation, we observe that a basis for so(n), the Lie algebra of skew symmetric n × nmatrices is given by the matrices ei ∧ ej , 1 ≤ i < j ≤ n (denoting the skew symmetric matrix that has −1 at the intersection of the ith row and the j th column, +1 at the intersection of the j th row and the ith column, and 0 entries elsewhere).2 ei ∧ ej is the tangent vector at the identity of SO(n) for the one-parameter subgroup of rotations through an angle ϑ in the ei ej plane from ei towards ej . In Spin (n), we may consider the one-parameter subgroup ϑ → ei (− cos(ϑ)ei + sin(ϑ)ej ) = cos(ϑ) + sin(ϑ)ei ej . Its tangent vector at 1, i.e. at ϑ = 0, is ei ej . Lemma 2.4.3.
dρ(ei ej ) = 2(ei ∧ ej ).
Proof. We have seen in the proof of Theorem 2.4.1 that ρ(a) is the reflection across the hyperplane perpendicular to a, for a unit vector a ∈ Rn . Thus, ρ(cos(ϑ) + sin(ϑ)ei ej ) is the reflection across the hyperplane orthogonal to − cos(ϑ)ei + sin(ϑ)ej followed by the one across the hyperplane orthogonal to ei . This, however, is the rotation in the ei , ej plane through an angle of 2ϑ from ei towards ej . Examples. 1. From its definition, the Clifford algebra Cl(R) is R[x]/(x2 + 1), the algebra generated by x with the relation x2 = −1. In order to make contact with our previous notation, we should write e1 in place of x. Of course this algebra can be identified with C, and we identify the basis vector e1 with i. Clev (R) = Cl0 (R) then are the reals, while Clodd (R) = Cl1 (R) is identified with the purely imaginary complex numbers. Pin(R) then is the subgroup of C generated by ±i, and Spin (R) is the group with elements ±1. 2. Cl(R2 ) is the algebra generated by x and y with the relations x2 = −1,
y2 = −1,
xy = −yx.
Again, we write e1 , e2 in place of x, y. This algebra can be identified with the quaternion algebra H, by putting i = e1 ,
j = e2 ,
k = e1 e2 .
Since i2 = j 2 = k 2 = −1, ij + ji = ik + ki = jk + kj = 0 the relations (2.4.2) are indeed satisfied. In fact, we have a natural linear embedding γ : H → C2×2 2 For
(2 by 2 matrices with complex coefficients)
the sake of the present discussion, we identify V with Rn (n = dimR V ).
(2.4.11)
2.4 Spin Structures
73
by writing w ∈ H as w = (w0 + kw1 ) − i(w2 + kw3 ) = ω − iψ with w0 , w1 , w2 , w3 ∈ R while we consider ω and ψ as elements of C, and putting ω −ψ w −→ . ψ ω
Then γ(i) =
0 1 , −1 0
γ(j) =
0 i
i , 0
γ(k) =
i 0
0 . −i
These matrices satisfy the same commutation relations as i, j, k, and γ(ww ) = γ(w)γ(w ),
γ(w) = γ(w)∗
for all w, w ∈ H. Thus, γ is an algebra homomorphism. The subalgebra Clev (R2 ) is generated by k, and thus it is isomorphic to C ⊂ H, where the purely imaginary complex numbers correspond to multiples of k. 2×2 Under the embedding γ, it corresponds to the diagonal elements in C , that ω 0 , i.e. those with ψ = 0. is, the ones of the form w −→ 0 ω Pin(R2 ) is generated by the circle cos(ϑ)i + sin(ϑ)j through i and j (ϑ ∈ S 1 ). Spin (R2 ) then is the group consisting of products (cos(ϑ1 )i+sin(ϑ1 )j)(cos(ϑ2 )i+ sin(ϑ2 )j) (ϑ1 , ϑ2 ∈ S 1 ) = − cos ϑ1 cos ϑ2 − sin ϑ1 sin ϑ2 + (cos ϑ1 sin ϑ2 − cos ϑ2 sin ϑ1 )k, i.e. the unit circle in the above subspace C ⊂ H. (So, while Pin(V ) is generated by 1, i, j, k, Spin (V ) is generated by 1, k. i and j act on R2 by reflection while k acts as a rotation.) Thus, Spin (R2 ) is isomorphic to U(1) ∼ = S 1 . We should note, however, that it is a double cover of SO(2) as ±1 both are mapped to the trivial element of SO(2). 3. Similarly, we identify Cl(R3 ) with H ⊕ H by putting e0 = (1, 1),
e1 = (i, −i),
e2 = (j, −j),
e3 = (k, −k).
Then e1 e2 = (k, k),
e2 e3 = (i, i),
e3 e1 = (j, j),
and Cl (R ) is identified with the diagonal embedding of H into H ⊕ H. Since Cl1 (R3 ) = R3 is identified with the pairs (α, −α) of purely imaginary quaternions α, Pin(R3 ) is generated by such elements of length 1. Spin (R3 ) then is the group of pairs (β, β) of unit quaternions β, as every such pair can be obtained as a product (α1 , −α1 )(α2 , −α2 ) where α1 , α2 are purely imaginary unit quaternions themselves. Thus, Spin (R3 ) is isomorphic to the group Sp(1) of unit quaternions in H. One also knows that this group is isomorphic to SU(2). The above embedding γ : H → C2×2 (2.4.11) induces an isomorphism between Sp(1) and SU(2). ev
3
74
Chapter 2 Lie Groups and Vector Bundles 4. Cl(R4 ) is identified with H2×2 , the space of two by two matrices with quaternionic coefficients, by putting 1 0 0 1 0 i e0 = , e1 = , e2 = , 0 1 −1 0 i 0 0 j 0 k , e4 = . e3 = j 0 k 0 Pin(R4 ) is generated by the unit sphere in Cl1 (R4 ) = R4 , i.e. in our identification by all linear combinations of e1 , e2 , e3 , e4 of unit length. Spin (R4 ) then is the group of products of two such elements, i.e. the group of all elements of the form α0 β0 where α and β are unit quaternions. Thus, Spin (R4 ) is homeomorphic to S 3 × S 3 ∼ = SU(2) × SU(2). From Theorem = Sp(1) × Sp(1) ∼ 2.4.2, we then infer that SO(4) ∼ = Spin (4)/Z2 ∼ = (SU(2) × SU(2))/Z2 .
In the sequel, we shall also need the complex Clifford algebra and the corresponding spin group. For V as before, we denote the complexified Clifford algebra by ClC (V ) = Cl(V ) ⊗R C. Thus, the eα again form a basis, and the only difference is that we now admit complex coefficients. For the sequel, we need to choose an orientation of V , i.e. select an (orthonormal) basis e1 , . . . , en of V being positive. (Any other basis of V obtained from this particular one by an element of SO(V ) then is also called positive.) Definition 2.4.3. Let e1 , . . . , en be a positive orthonormal basis of V . The chirality operator is Γ = im e1 , . . . , en ∈ ClC (V ) with m =
n 2
for even n, m =
n+1 2
for odd n.
It is easy to check that Γ is independent of the chosen positive orthonormal basis. To see the mechanism, let us just consider the case n = 2, and the new basis f1 = cos ϑe1 + sin ϑe2 , f2 = − sin ϑe1 + cos ϑe2 . Then f1 f2 = − sin ϑ cos ϑe1 e1 + sin ϑ cos ϑe2 e2 + cos2 ϑe1 e2 − sin2 ϑe2 e1 = e1 e2 by (2.4.2). Lemma 2.4.4. Γ2 = 1. For odd n,
Γv = vΓ,
for all v ∈ V.
For even n,
Γv = −vΓ,
for all v ∈ V.
2.4 Spin Structures
75
Proof. A simple computation based on (2.4.2). Thus, we may use Γ to obtain a decomposition ClC (V )± of ClC (V ) into the eigenspaces with eigenvalue ±1 under multiplication by Γ. This is particularly interesting for even n, because we have vClC (V )± = ClC (V )∓
for every v ∈ V \ {0},
(2.4.12)
i.e. Clifford multiplication by v interchanges these eigenspaces. This is a simple consequence of Lemma 2.4.4, namely if e.g. Γa = a then Γva = −vΓa = −va. Definition 2.4.4. Spinc (V ) is the subgroup of the multiplicative group of units of ClC (V ) = Cl(V ) ⊗ C generated by Spin (V ) and the unit circle in C. Lemma 2.4.5. Spinc (V ) is isomorphic to Spin V ×Z2 S 1 , where the Z2 action identifies (a, z) with (−a, −z). Proof. By Lemma 2.4.1, the unit complex scalars are in the center of ClC (V ), and hence commute with Spin (V ). Therefore, we obtain a map Spin (V ) × S 1 → Spinc (V ),
(2.4.13)
which is surjective. The kernel of this mapping are the elements (a, z) with az = 1, which means a = z −1 ∈ Spin (V ) ∩ S 1 . We have already seen in the preparations for Theorem 2.4.2 that this latter set consists precisely of ±1. By Lemma 2.4.5, changing (a, z) to (−a, z) amounts to the same as changing (a, z) to (a, −z), and thus we obtain an action of Z2 on Spinc (V ). The quotient of Spinc (V ) by this action yields a double covering Spinc (V ) → SO(V ) × S 1
(2.4.14)
that is nontrivial on both factors. The maps given in (2.4.13), (2.4.14) allow to determine the fundamental group π1 (Spinc (V )). Namely, a homotopically nontrivial loop γ in S 1 induces a loop in Spinc (V ) that is mapped to the loop 2γ in S 1 by (2.4.14) (2γ means the loop γ traversed twice) which again is nontrivial. Thus, π1 (Spinc (V )) contains π1 (S 1 ) = Z as a subgroup. On the other hand, if we have a loop in Spinc (V ) that is mapped to a homotopically trivial one in S 1 when we compose (2.4.14) with the projection on the second factor, it is homotopic to a loop in the kernel of that composition. That kernel can be identified with Spin (V ) by (2.4.13), and since Spin (V ) is simply connected by Theorem 2.4.2 for dim V ≥ 3, such a loop is homotopically trivial for dim V ≥ 3. Thus
76
Chapter 2 Lie Groups and Vector Bundles
Theorem 2.4.3. For dim V ≥ 3 π1 (Spinc (V )) = Z.
Examples. The treatment here will be based on the above discussion of examples in the real case. 1. ClC (R) = Cl(R) ⊗R C = C ⊕ C, and Spinc (R) ∼ = S 1 sits diagonally in this space. 2. ClC (R2 ) = Cl(R2 ) ⊗R C = H ⊗R C. We want to identify ClC (R2 ) with C2×2 , the space of two by two matrices with complex coefficients. We consider the above homomorphism of algebras H → C2×2 , and extending scalars, we obtain an isomorphism of C-algebras H ⊗ C → C2×2 . Thus, we identify ClC (R2 ) with C2×2 . Under this identification, Spin (R2 ) corresponds to the elements α 0 with α ∈ S 1 = U(1) ⊂ C. 0 α Spinc (R2 ) then consists of the unitary diagonal matrices, i.e. Spinc (R2 ) = U(1) × U(1) = S 1 × S 1 . 3. Clc (R3 ) = Cl(R3 )⊗C = (H⊕H)⊗C = C2×2 ⊕C2×2 from the preceding example. We have identified Spin (R3 ) with SU(2), and so Spinc (R3 ) ∼ = eiϑ U : ϑ ∈ R, U ∈ SU(2) = U(2). 4. Similarly, Clc (R4 ) = Cl(R3 ) ⊗R C = H2×2 ⊗ C = C4×4 . We have identified Spin (R4 ) with SU(2) × SU(2), and so Spinc (R4 ) = Spin (R4 ) ×Z2 S 1 ∼ {(U, V ) ∈ U(2) × U(2) : det U = det V }. = In order to describe the isomorphism Clc (R4 ) ∼ = C4×4 more explicitly, we recall the homomorphism γ : H → C2×2 from the description of Cl(R3 ). We define Γ : H → C4×4
via Γ(w) =
0 −γ(w)∗
γ(w) . 0
2.4 Spin Structures We recall
77
1 0 γ(1) = , 0 1 0 −1 γ(j) = , 1 0
0 γ(i) = i i γ(k) = 0
i , 0 0 . −i
We identify R4 with H, putting e1 = 1, e2 = i, e3 = j, e4 = k. Then ⎞ ⎛ 0 i ⎟ ⎜i 0 ⎟ = − Γ(e2 )Γ(e1 ), Γ(e1 )Γ(e2 ) = ⎜ ⎝ 0 −i⎠ −i 0 ⎞ ⎛ 0 −1 ⎟ ⎜1 0 ⎟ = − Γ(e3 )Γ(e1 ), Γ(e1 )Γ(e3 ) =⎜ ⎝ 0 −1⎠ 1 0 ⎞ ⎛ i 0 ⎟ ⎜0 −i ⎟ = − Γ(e4 )Γ(e1 ), Γ(e1 )Γ(e4 ) = ⎜ ⎝ −i 0⎠ 0 i ⎞ ⎛ i 0 ⎟ ⎜0 −i ⎟ = − Γ(e3 )Γ(e2 ), Γ(e2 )Γ(e3 ) = ⎜ ⎝ i 0⎠ 0 −i ⎞ ⎛ 0 1 ⎟ ⎜−1 0 ⎟ = − Γ(e4 )Γ(e2 ), Γ(e2 )Γ(e4 ) =⎜ ⎝ 0 1⎠ −1 0 ⎞ ⎛ 0 i ⎟ ⎜i 0 ⎟ = − Γ(e4 )Γ(e3 ) Γ(e3 )Γ(e4 ) = ⎜ ⎝ 0 −i⎠ −i 0 (always with 0’s in the off-diagonal blocks). One also easily checks that Γ(eα )Γ(eα ) = −Id,
for α = 1, 2, 3, 4.
Thus, Γ preserves the relations in the Clifford algebra, and it is not hard to verify that Γ in fact extends to the desired isomorphism between ClC (R4 ) and C4×4 . The preceding examples seem to indicate a general pattern that we now wish to demonstrate by induction on the basis of
78
Chapter 2 Lie Groups and Vector Bundles
Lemma 2.4.6. For any vector space V as above ClC (V ⊕ R2 ) ∼ = ClC (V ) ⊗C ClC (R2 ). Proof. We choose orthonormal bases v1 , . . . , vn of V and e1 , e2 of R2 . In order to define a map that is linear over R, l : V ⊕ R2 → ClC (V ) ⊗C ClC (R2 ) we put l(vj ) := ivj ⊗ e1 e2 ,
for j = 1, . . . , n,
l(eα ) := 1 ⊗ eα ,
for α = 1, 2.
Since for example l(vj vk + vk vj ) = (−vj vk − vk vj ) ⊗ e1 e2 e1 e2 = vj vk + vk vj ⊗ 1 l(vj eα + eα vj ) = ivj ⊗ (e1 e2 eα + eα e1 e2 ) = 0 for α = 1, 2 we have an extension of l as an algebra homomorphism l : Cl(V ⊕ R2 ) → ClC (V ) ⊗C ClC (R2 ). Extending scalars from R to C, we obtain an algebra homomorphism l : ClC (V ⊕ R2 ) → ClC (V ) ⊗C ClC (R2 ). Now l has become a homomorphism between two algebras of the same dimension, and it is injective (and surjective) on the generators, hence an isomorphism. Corollary 2.4.1. (i) If dimR V = 2n,
ClC (V ) ∼ = C2
n
×2n
(ii) If dimR V = 2n + 1,
ClC (V ) ∼ = C2
n
n
×2
, ⊕ C2
n
×2n
.
∼ C2×2 , and the proof follows from Lemma 2.4.6 by Proof. By Example 2, ClC (R2 ) = induction, starting with Example 2 in the even and Example 1 in the odd dimensional case, and using Cm×m ⊗C C2×2 ∼ = C2m×2m .
We now wish to identify ClC (V ) for even dimensional V as the algebra of endomorphisms of some other vector space in a more explicit manner than in Corollary
2.4 Spin Structures
79
2.4.1. We thus assume that n = dimR V is even, n = 2m. We also choose an orientation of V , i.e. select a positive orthonormal basis e1 , . . . , en . In V ⊗ C, we consider the subspace W spanned by the basis vectors 1 ηj := √ (e2j−1 − ie2j ), 2
j = 1, . . . , m.
(2.4.15)
If we extend the scalar product ·, · to V ⊗ C by complex linearity, we have ηi , ηj C = 0
for all j,
(2.4.16)
hence w, wC = 0 for all w ∈ W .
(2.4.17)
(One expresses this by saying that W is isotropic w.r.t. ·, ·C .) We have V ⊗ C = W ⊕ W, with W spanned by the vectors ηj = ∗
√1 (e2j−1 2
+ ie2j ), j = 1, . . . , m. Because of
(2.4.17), W is the dual space W of W w.r.t. ·, ·C , i.e. for every w ∈ W \ {0}, there exists a unique w ∈ W with w = 1 and w, w C = w. Definition 2.4.5. The spinor space S is defined as the exterior algebra ΛW of W . If we want to emphasize the dimension n of V , we write Sn in place of S. We may then identify ClC (V ) as End C (S) as follows: We write v ∈ V ⊗ C as v = w + w
with w ∈ W, w ∈ W ,
and for s ∈ S = ΛW , we put √ √ (= 2w ∧ s, as denotes the exterior product) ρ(w)s := 2(w)s √ ρ(w )s := − 2ι(w )s (where ι(w ) denotes the interior product; note that we identify W with the dual space W ∗ of W , c.f. §2.1). ρ obviously extends to all of ClC (V ) by the rule ρ(vw) = ρ(v)ρ(w). We have the following explicit rules for (w) and ι(w ): If s = ηj1 ∧ . . . ∧ ηjk , with 1 ≤ j1 < . . . < jk ≤ m, then (ηj )s = ηj ∧ ηj1 ∧ . . . ∧ ηjk and
ι(η j )s =
(= 0 if j ∈ {j1 , . . . , jk }),
0 (−1)μ−1 ηj1 ∧ . . . ∧ η jµ ∧ . . . ∧ η j k
if j ∈ / {j1 , . . . , jk }, if j = jμ .
(2.4.18)
(2.4.19)
80
Chapter 2 Lie Groups and Vector Bundles
In particular
(ηj )iι(ηj )s = ι(η j )(ηj )s =
0 if j ∈ / {j1 , . . . , jk }, s if j ∈ {j1 , . . . , jk }.
(2.4.20)
s if j ∈ / {j1 , . . . , jk }, 0 if j ∈ {j1 , . . . , jk }.
(2.4.21)
Thus, we have for all s and all j ((ηj )ι(η j ) + ι(η j )(ηj ))s = s.
(2.4.22)
For subsequent use in §6.2, we also record that in the same manner, one sees that ((ηj )ι(η ) + ι(η )(ηj ))s = 0 for j = .
(2.4.23)
In order to verify that the claimed identification is possible, we need to check first that ρ preserves the relations in the Clifford algebra. The following examples will bring out the general pattern:
1 1 1 1 √ (η1 ) − √ ι(η 1 ) ρ e1 2 = 2 √ (η1 ) − √ ι(η1 ) 2 2 2 2 2 = −((η1 )ι(η 1 ) + ι(η 1 )(η1 )) since (η1 ) = 0 = ι(η 1 )2 = −1 by (2.4.22), and ρ(e1 e2 ) + ρ(e2 e1 ) = ((η1 ) − ι(η1 ))i((η1 ) + ι(η 1 )) + i((η1 ) + ι(η 1 ))((η1 ) − ι(η 1 )) = 0, ρ(e1 e3 ) + ρ(e3 e1 ) = ((η1 ) − ι(η1 ))((η2 ) − ι(η 2 )) + ((η2 ) − ι(η 2 ))((η1 ) − ι(η 1 )) = ((η1 )(η2 ) + (η2 )(η1 )) + (ι(η 1 )ι(η 2 ) + ι(η 2 )ι(η 1 )) − ((η1 )ι(η 2 ) + ι(η 2 )(η1 )) − ((η2 )ι(η 1 ) + ι(η 1 )(η2 )) = 0, since the (η1 ), . . . , ι(η 2 ) all anticommute, e.g. (η1 )ι(η 2 )η2 ∧ η3 =
(η1 )η3 =
η1 ∧ η3 ,
ι(η 2 )(η1 )η2 ∧ η3 = ι(η 2 )η1 ∧ η2 ∧ η3 = − η1 ∧ η3 . Now dimC ClC (V ) = 2n = (dimC (ΛW ))2 = dimC (End C (S)), and since ρ has nontrivial kernel, we conclude
2.4 Spin Structures
81
Theorem 2.4.4. If n = dimR V is even, ClC (V ) is isomorphic to the algebra of complex linear endomorphisms of the spinor space S. (Later on, we shall omit the symbol ρ and simply say that ClC (V ) operates on the spinor space S via Clifford multiplication, denoted by “·”.) Now since ηj η j − η j ηj = 2ie2j−1 e2j , we have
Γ = 2−m (η1 η 1 − η 1 η1 ) . . . (ηm η m − η m ηm )
and so Γ acts on the spinor space S = ΛW via ρ(Γ) = (−1)m ((η1 )ι(η 1 ) − ι(η 1 )(η1 )) . . . ((ηm )ι(η m ) − ι(η m )(ηm )), and for the same reasons as in the computation of ρ(e1 2 ), we see that ρ(Γ) equals (−1)k on Λk W . As above, any representation of ClC (V ), in particular ρ, decomposes into the eigenspaces of Γ for the eigenvalues ±1, and so in the present case we have the decomposition S ± := Λ± W where the + (−) sign on the right-hand side denotes elements of even (odd) degree. Since Spin (V ) sits in Cl(V ), hence in ClC (V ), any representation of the Clifford algebra ClC (V ) restricts to a representation of Spin (V ), and we thus have a representation ρ : Spin (V ) → End C (S). Since Spin (V ) ⊂ Cl+ (V ), Spin (V ) leaves the spaces S + and S − invariant, and thus the representation is not irreducible, but decomposes into the ones on S + and S − . (The latter are in fact irreducible.) As in (2.4.12), multiplication by an element of Cl− (V ), in particular by a vector v ∈ V , exchanges S + and S − . Definition 2.4.6. The above representation ρ of Spin (V ) on the spinor space S is called the spinor representation, and the representations on S + and S − are called half spinor representations. Note that the spinor space S = ΛW is different from the Clifford space Cl(V ) (= Λ∗ (V ) as a vector space). Cl(V ), and therefore also V , acts on both of them by Clifford multiplication. We now want to extend the representation of Spin (V ) to Spinc (V ). Lemma 2.4.7. Let σ : Spin (V ) → End C (T ) be a complex representation of Spin (V ) on some vector space T , satisfying σ(−1) = −1. Then σ extends in a unique manner to a representation σ : Spinc (V ) → End C (T ).
82
Chapter 2 Lie Groups and Vector Bundles
Proof. Since σ is complex linear, it commutes with multiplication by complex scalars, in particular with those of unit length. Thus, σ extends to σ : Spin (V ) × S 1 → End C (T ). Since σ(−1) = −1, it descends to Spinc (V ). Corollary 2.4.2. The spinor and half spinor representations of Spin (V ) possess unique extensions to Spinc (V ). Of course, this is also clear from the fact that these representations of Spin (V ) come from ClC (V ). For Clc (R2 ), the spinor space is isomorphic to C2 and generated by v1 := 1 and v2 := η1 = √12 (e1 − ie2 ), see (2.4.15). Since e1 = √12 (η1 + η¯1 ) and e2 = √i2 (η1 − η¯1 ), we have e1 v1 = v2 , e1 v2 = −v1 , e2 v1 = iv2 , e2 v2 = iv1 , that is, the action of Clc (R2 ) on its spinor space is given by the above representation (2.4.11) of H as C2×2 acting on C2 . Let us also discuss the example of Clc (R4 ) once more. We recall the isomorphism Γ : Clc (R4 ) → C4×4 . Γ in fact is the representation described in Theorem 2.4.4, and C4 is isomorphic to S4 . The formulas given above for the products Γ(eα )Γ(eβ ) also show that the representation admits a decomposition into two copies of C2 that is preserved by the elements of even order of Clc (R4 ). In fact, these yield the half spinor representations S4± in dimension 4. In the above formulas, the upper left block corresponds to S + , the lower right one to S − . In dimension 4, we also have a decomposition Λ2 = Λ2,+ ⊕ Λ2,−
(Λ2 = Λ2 V ∗ , dim V = 4)
of exterior two forms. Namely, we have the Hodge ∗ operator (to be discussed in §3.3 for arbitrary dimensions) determined by ∗(e1 ∧ e2 ) =
e3 ∧ e4 ,
∗(e1 ∧ e3 ) = −e2 ∧ e4 , ∗(e1 ∧ e4 ) =
e2 ∧ e3 ,
∗(e2 ∧ e3 ) =
e1 ∧ e4 ,
∗(e2 ∧ e4 ) = −e1 ∧ e3 , ∗(e3 ∧ e4 ) =
e1 ∧ e2
and linear extensions, where e1 , . . . , e4 is an orthonormal frame in V ∗ . We have ∗∗ = 1, and ∗ thus has eigenvalues ±1, and Λ2,± then are defined as the corresponding eigenspaces. Both these spaces are three dimensional. Λ2,+ is spanned by e1 ∧ e2 +
2.4 Spin Structures
83
e3 ∧ e4 , e1 ∧ e3 − e2 ∧ e4 , e1 ∧ e4 + e2 ∧ e3 , while Λ2,− is spanned by e1 ∧ e2 − e3 ∧ e4 , e1 ∧ e3 + e2 ∧ e4 , e1 ∧ e4 − e2 ∧ e3 . Elements of Λ2,+ are called selfdual, those of Λ2,− antiselfdual. We have a bijective linear map ΛV ∗ → Cl2 (V ), given by ei ∧ ej → ei · ej (where i e is the orthonormal frame in V ∗ dual to the frame ei in V ). Therefore, Γ induces a map Γ1 : Λ2 V ∗ → End (C4 ). In the above decomposition of the representation of Clc,ev (R4 ), the selfdual forms then act only on C2 ⊕ {0}, while the antiselfdual ones act only on {0} ⊕ C2 , as one directly sees from the formulas for Γ(eα )Γ(eβ ) and the description of the bases of Λ2,± . Finally, let us briefly summarize the situation in the odd dimensional case. Here, according to Corollary 2.4.1, ClC (V ) is a sum of two endomorphism algebras, and we therefore obtain two representations of ClC (V ). When restricted to Spin (V ), these representations become isomorphic and irreducible. This yields the spinor representation in the odd dimensional case. We omit the details. We also observe that the spinor representation is a unitary representation in a natural manner. For that purpose, we now extend the scalar product ·, · from V to V ⊗ C as a Hermitian product, i.e. n
αi ei ,
i=1
n
j=1
n
βj ej = α i βi
for α1 , . . . , αn , β1 , . . . , βn ∈ C.
i=1
Note that this is different from the above complex linear extensions ·, ·C . This product extends to ΛV by letting the monomials ei1 ∧ . . . ∧ eik , 1 ≤ i1 < . . . ik ≤ n, constitute an orthonormal basis. From the above computations for the ρ(ej ), one checks that each ρ(ej ) preserves ·, ·, i.e. ρ(ej )s, ρ(ej )s = s, s
for all s, s ∈ ΛW.
Of course, this then holds more generally for every v ∈ V with v = 1, and then also for products v1 . . . vk with vj = 1 for j = 1, . . . , k. This implies Corollary 2.4.3. The induced representation of Pin(V ) and Spin (V ) on End C (S) preserves the Hermitian product ·, ·. Corollary 2.4.4. ρ(v)s, s = −s, ρ(v)s
for all s, s ∈ ΛW, v ∈ V.
Proof. We may assume v = 1. Then ρ(v)2 = −1, hence ρ(v)s, s = −ρ(v)s, ρ(v)ρ(v)s = −s, ρ(v)s
by Corollary 2.4.3.
After these algebraic preparations, we may now define spin structures on an oriented Riemannian manifold M . At each point x ∈ M , we may take the tangent
84
Chapter 2 Lie Groups and Vector Bundles
space Tx M as the vector space V for the definition of the Clifford algebra Cl(V ), and we want to to construct vector bundles with fibers carrying the above constructions of spin groups and spinors. We let T M be the tangent bundle of M . The Riemannian metric allows to reduce the structure group of T M to SO(n) (n = dim M ), and we obtain an associated principal bundle P over M with fiber SO(n), the so-called frame bundle of M . Definition 2.4.7. A spin structure on M is a principal bundle P over M with fiber Spin (n) for which the quotient of each fiber by the center ±1 is isomorphic to the above frame bundle of M . A Riemannian manifold with a fixed spin structure is called a spin manifold. In other words, we require that the following diagram commutes, P
r
π
P π M
where π denotes the projection onto the base point, and ρ is the nontrivial double covering ρ : Spin (n) → SO(n) on each fiber as described in Theorem 2.4.2. This is also expressed by saying that the frame bundle is lifted to a Spin (n) bundle. It is important to note that such a lift need not always be possible. One way to realize this is by considering the corresponding transition functions. We recall from §2.1 that the frame bundle P for each trivializing covering (Uα )α∈A of M induces transition functions ϕβα : Uα ∩ Uβ → SO(n) satisfying ϕαα (x) = id ϕαβ (x)ϕβα = id ϕαγ (x)ϕγβ (x)ϕβα (x) = id
for x ∈ Uα for x ∈ Uα ∩ Uβ for x ∈ Uα ∩ Uβ ∩ Uγ .
Lifting the frame bundle to a Spin (n) bundle then requires finding transition functions ϕ βα : Uα ∩ Uβ → Spin (n) with ρ (ϕ βα ) = ϕβα
for all β, α
(2.4.24)
and satisfying the same relations as the ϕβα . By making the Uα sufficiently small, in βα satisfying (2.4.24), is no problem, particular simply connected, lifting the ϕβα to ϕ but the problem arises with the third relation, i.e. ϕ αβ (x)ϕ βγ (x)ϕ γα (x) = id for x ∈ Uα ∩ Uβ ∩ Uγ .
(2.4.25)
βγ (x) and ϕ γα (x) differ by the nontrivial deck Namely, it may happen that ϕ αβ (x)ϕ transformation of the covering ρ : Spin (n) → SO(n).
2.4 Spin Structures
85
In fact, the existence of a spin structure, i.e. the possibility of such a lift, depends on a topological condition, the vanishing of the so-called Stiefel–Whitney class w2 (M ) ∈ H 2 (M, Z2 ). Here, however, we cannot define these topological concepts. Furthermore, if a spin structure exists, it need not to be unique. For example, a compact oriented two-dimensional Riemannian manifold of genus3 g carries 22g different spin structures. In particular, the two-dimensional sphere S 2 has genus 0 and hence carries a unique spin structure. Let us assume that M possesses a spin structure P → M . Since the fiber Spin (n) of P operates on the spinor space Sn and for even n also on the half spinor spaces Sn± via the (half) spinor representations, we obtain associated vector bundles Sn , S± n over M with structure group Spin (n), Sn := P ×Spin (n) Sn , with
− Sn = S + n ⊕ Sn
± S± n := P ×Spin (n) Sn ,
for even n.
Definition 2.4.8. Sn is called the spinor bundle, S± n the half spinor bundles associated with the spin structure P. Sections are called (half ) spinor fields. From Corollary 2.4.3, we infer that these bundles carry Hermitian products that are invariant under the action of Spin (n), and even of Pin(n), on each fiber. In particular, Clifford multiplication by a unit vector in Rn ⊂ Cl(Rn ) is an isometry on each fiber. We may also consider Spinc (n) in place of of Spin (n) and ask for a lift of the frame bundle P over M to a principal Spinc (n) bundle Pc . Of course, the requirement here is that the map from a fiber of Pc to the corresponding one of P is given by the homomorphism Spinc (n) → SO(n) obtained from (2.4.14) by projecting onto the first factor. Definition 2.4.9. Such a principal Spinc (n) bundle P c (if it exists) is called a spinc structure on M . An oriented Riemannian manifold M equipped with a fixed spinc structure is called a spinc manifold. Again, the existence of a spinc structure depends on a topological condition, namely that w2 (M ) lifts to an integral class in H 2 (M, Z2 ). Again, however, we cannot explain this here any further. We point out, however, that the required condition is satisfied for all oriented Riemannian manifolds of dimension 4. Thus, each oriented four-manifold possesses a spinc structure. Given a spinc structure, we may also consider the homomorphism Spinc (n) → S 1 3 The genus is a basic topological invariant of a compact surface. There are several different ways of defining or characterizing it, see [168]. For instance, it equals the first Betti number b1 , the dimension of the first cohomology, that will be defined in the next chapter.
86
Chapter 2 Lie Groups and Vector Bundles
obtained from (2.4.14) by projecting on the second factor. Identifying S 1 with U(1), we see that a spinc structure induces a set of transition functions for a vector bundle L with fiber C, a so-called (complex) line bundle. Definition 2.4.10. The line bundle L is called the determinant line bundle of the spinc structure. As in the case of a spin structure, a spinc structure induces (half) spinor bundles cf. Corollary 2.4.2. We return to the frame bundle P over M with fiber SO(n). SO(n) acts on Cl(Rn ) and Clc (Rn ) simply by extending the action of SO(n) on Rn . Thus, P induces bundles
S± n,
Cl(P ) = P ×SO(n) Cl(Rn ) ClC (P ) = P ×SO(n) ClC (Rn ) of Clifford algebras. Definition 2.4.11. The bundles Cl(P ) and ClC (P ) are called the Clifford bundles. Again, these Clifford bundles can be decomposed into bundles of elements of even and of odd degree. The chirality operator Γ (cf. Definition 2.4.3) is invariant under the action of SO(n), and it therefore defines a section of ClC (P ) of norm 1. The definition of the Clifford bundles did not need a spin or spinc structure on M . But suppose now that we do have such a structure, a spin structure, say. Spin (n) acts on ClC (Rn ) by conjugation: ρ(a)v = ava−1
for a ∈ Spin (n), v ∈ ClC (Rn )
(2.4.26)
(cf. Theorem 2.4.1 (note that at = a−1 for a ∈ Spin (n) by (2.4.9)) for the action of Spin (n) on Rn , and extend this action to ClC (Rn ); this is of course induced by the above action of SO(n) on ClC (Rn )). This action commutes with the action of Spin (n) on ClC (Rn ) given by (2.4.26) and the action of Spin (n) on Sn ; namely for a ∈ Spin (n), v ∈ ClC (Rn ), s ∈ Sn (ava−1 )(as) = a(vs).
(2.4.27)
This compatibility with the Spin (n) actions ensures that we get a global action ClC (Rn ) × Sn → Sn ,
(2.4.28)
which is the above action by Clifford multiplication on each fiber. Recalling that the space Rn here is a tangent space Tx M , we thus can Clifford multiply a tangent vector v ∈ Tx M at x with a spinor s ∈ Sn,x at x. In fact, since a vector is an odd element in the Clifford algebra, we have the action ∓ Tx M × S± n,x → Sn,x .
(2.4.29)
Exercises for Chapter 2
87
According to Corollary 2.4.4, this Clifford multiplication is skew-symmetric w.r.t. the Hermitian product on Sn,x , that is, vs, s = −s, vs
for all s, s ∈ Sn,x , v ∈ Tx M.
(2.4.30)
Perspectives. References for this section are [8], [198], [305], [22], [251], [223].
Exercises for Chapter 2 1. What is the transformation behavior of the Christoffel symbols under coordinate changes? Do they define a tensor? 2. Show that the structure group of the tangent bundle of an oriented ddimensional Riemannian manifold can be reduced to SO(d). 3. Can one define the normal bundle of a differentiable submanifold of a differentiable manifold in a meaningful manner without introducing a Riemannian metric? 4. We consider the constant vector field X(x) = a for all x ∈ Rn+1 . We obtain a ˜ vector field X(x) on S n by projecting X(x) onto Tx S n for x ∈ S n . Determine the corresponding flow on S n . 5. Let T be the flat torus generated by (1, 0) and (0, 1) ∈ R2 , with projection π : R2 → T. For which vector fields X on R2 can one define a vector field π∗ X on T in a meaningful way? Determine the flow of π∗ X on T for a constant vector field X. 6. Compute a formula for the Lie derivative (in the direction of a vector field) for a p-times contravariant and q-times covariant tensor. 7. Show that for arbitrary vector fields X, Y, the Lie derivative satisfies LX ◦ LY − LY ◦ LX = L[X,Y ] .
•
Chapter 3
The Laplace Operator and Harmonic Differential Forms
3.1
The Laplace Operator on Functions
A fundamental topic in geometric analysis and an important tool for studying Riemannian manifolds is given by harmonic objects. Such objects are defined as the minimizers, or more generally, the critical points of some action or energy functional. We have already seen one instance, the energy functional for curves in a Riemannian manifold, see (1.4.7), (1.4.9), whose critical points were the geodesics, see (1.4.14). In this chapter, however, we shall not look at maps into a Riemannian manifold, but at functions and differential forms defined on such a manifold. (These two themes, maps into a manifold and functions on a manifold, will be unified in Chapter 8 below.) In this section, which is of an introductory nature, we consider harmonic functions on Riemannian manifolds. More generally, we discuss the energy functional, the Dirichlet integral, and the operator, the Laplace–Beltrami operator, in terms of which harmonic functions are defined. This functional and operator will play an important role at many places in this book. Since the emphasis in this section will be on introducing concepts, we shall not go into the analytical details. Those will be presented in Appendices A.1 and A.2. We begin with the situation in Euclidean space, that is, on Rd equipped with its Euclidean metric ., .. Let f : Rd → R be a differentiable function. The gradient of f is defined as the vector field ∇f := grad f :=
d ∂f ∂ . i ∂xi ∂x i=1
J. Jost, Riemannian Geometry and Geometric Analysis, Universitext, c Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2011 DOI 10.1007/978-3-642-21298-7 3,
(3.1.1)
90
Chapter 3 The Laplace Operator and Harmonic Differential Forms
We also have the 1-form df =
d ∂f i dx . i ∂x i=1
(3.1.2)
These two objects are dual to each other in the sense that df (X) = grad f, X
(3.1.3)
for every (smooth) vector field X. d ∂ d Finally, for a (smooth) vector field Z = i=1 Z i ∂x i on R , we define its divergence as d ∂Z i . (3.1.4) div Z := ∂xi i=1 d Also, for a 1-form ϕ = i=1 ϕi dxi , we define d∗ ϕ := −
d ∂ϕi i=1
∂xi
= − div ϕ.
(3.1.5)
In fact, this is only a preliminary definition. In Section 3.3, we shall define the operator d∗ on forms of any degree, in such a manner that for the special case of 1-forms in Euclidean space, (3.1.5) comes out. The idea is that d∗ is an L2 -adjoint of the exterior derivative d. This is justified by integration by parts, where we need to assume that ϕ has compact support in Rd ,
d ∂f ϕ dx1 ∧ . . . ∧ dxd i i Rd i=1 ∂x d ∂ϕi =− f i dx1 ∧ . . . ∧ dxd , since ϕ is compactly supported. Rd i=1 ∂x
(df, ϕ) =
It remains to clarify the duality between vector fields and 1-forms that allows us to define the divergence for either type of object. This again will emerge when we consider a general Riemannian metric in place of the Euclidean one. The operator Δ that operates on (smooth) functions f via Δf = −
d ∂2f = −div (grad f ) (∂xi )2 i=1
(3.1.6)
then is called the Laplace operator. This Laplace operator differs from the usual one on Rd , as defined in calculus, by a minus sign. The reason is that, with our conventions, Δ is a positive operator (for instance in the sense of having positive eigenvalues), and a special case of the Hodge–de Rham Laplacian defined below in Section 3.3. For two smooth functions f, g, we then have (Δf, g) = (df, dg) = (f, Δg).
(3.1.7)
3.1 The Laplace Operator on Functions
91
Finally, for a function f : Rd → R, we consider the Dirichlet integral (whose subsequent generalizations will be called “energy”, hence the symbol E) 1 E(f ) : = grad f, grad f dx1 ∧ . . . ∧ dxd (3.1.8) 2 1 df, df dx1 ∧ . . . ∧ dxd = 2 d 1 ∂f 2 1 = ( i ) dx ∧ . . . ∧ dxd 2 ∂x i=1 where in the first integral, ., . is the Euclidean product on vector fields, and in the second integral, the one on 1-forms. In the Euclidean case, we do not really see the difference between the two, but this will be different in the Riemannian case. More generally, for an open Ω ⊂ Rd , we consider 1 E(f, Ω) := grad f, grad f dx1 ∧ . . . ∧ dxd . (3.1.9) 2 Ω Of course, the Dirichlet integral of f need not be finite, but for a smooth f with compact support, E(f ) < ∞. Similarly, E(f, Ω) is finite under appropriate conditions. The question about the appropriate space of functions on which the Dirichlet integral is well defined will be answered in Appendix A.1. We now assume that f is a minimum of E(f, Ω) in the sense that E(f, Ω) ≤ E(g, Ω) (3.1.10) for all g : Ω → R with the same boundary conditions, that is, g(y) = f (y) for all y ∈ ∂Ω.
(3.1.11)
E(f, Ω) ≤ E(f + tη, Ω)
(3.1.12)
This implies that for all η : Ω → R with η(y) = 0 for all y ∈ ∂Ω and all t ∈ R. Therefore, when that derivative exists (see Appendix A.1 for the relevant technical conditions), we have d E(f + tη, Ω)|t=0 = 0 (3.1.13) dt for all such η. Computing formally, we have d E(f + tη, Ω)|t=0 = grad f, grad ηdx1 ∧ . . . dxd ∧ dt Ω d ∂f ∂η 1 dx ∧ . . . dxd ∧ = i ∂xi ∂x Ω i=1 d ∂2f = (− η)dx1 ∧ . . . since η = 0 on ∂Ω ∧ dxd i )2 (∂x Ω i=1 = Δf ηdx1 ∧ . . . ∧ dxd , (3.1.14) Ω
92
Chapter 3 The Laplace Operator and Harmonic Differential Forms
the important step being the integration by parts. Therefore, according to Theorem A.1.5, a necessary condition for (3.1.13) is that Δf = 0 in Ω.
(3.1.15)
An f : Ω → R satisfying (3.1.15) is called a harmonic function. We summarize these heuristic considerations by stating that a minimizer of the Dirichlet integral with fixed boundary conditions on an open set Ω has to be a harmonic function.
We now extend these considerations to the Riemannian case. Let M be a Riemannian manifold of dimension d, with metric tensor gij in some local coordinates x1 , . . . , xd . According to the Einstein summation convention introduced in Section 1.2, we shall leave out the summation signs from now on. Let f : M → R be a function on M , and X a vector field. We want to define the gradient of f so that (3.1.3) continues to hold, that is, grad f, X = X(f ) = df (X).
(3.1.16)
Since grad f, X = gij (grad f )i X j , this leads to ∇f := grad f := gij
∂f ∂ . ∂xi ∂xj
(3.1.17)
As a consistency check, we have ∇f 2 = gj g ij
∂f k ∂f ∂f ∂f g = gij i j = df 2 , i k ∂x ∂x ∂x ∂x
(3.1.18)
that is, when taking norms, we can switch readily between ∇f and df . ∂ Also, the appropriate extension of (3.1.4) for the divergence of a vector field Z = Z i ∂x i is ∂ 1 ∂ √ ij 1 ∂ √ j (3.1.19) ( gZ ) = √ gg Z, i . div Z := √ j j g ∂x g ∂x ∂x We then have the Laplace–Beltrami operator 1 ∂ √ ij ∂f Δf := −div grad f = − √ gg . g ∂xj ∂xi
(3.1.20)
As in (3.1.7), it satisfies, for smooth functions f, g, (Δf, g) = (df, dg) = (f, Δg). Note how the volume factor
√
(3.1.21)
g comes out correctly in the verification of this formula.
3.1 The Laplace Operator on Functions
93
Finally, we define the energy of a differentiable function f : M → R as (using √ the abbreviation g := det(gij ) for the volume factor (as in (1.4.6)), a quantity to be explained in Section 3.3) √ df, df gdx1 . . . dxd (3.1.22) E(f ) : = M ∂f ∂f √ g ij i j gdx1 . . . dxd . = ∂x ∂x M In this formula, ., . denotes the induced Riemannian metric on 1-forms. When we consider the vector field grad f in place of the 1-form and use the Riemannian metric on tangent vectors, we can also write √ E(f ) = grad f, grad f gdx1 . . . dxd (3.1.23) M ∂f ∂f √ g ij i j gdx1 . . . dxd , = ∂x ∂x M using of course (3.1.17). In this way, everything fits together as in the Euclidean case. We assume that f is a critical point of E(f ) in the sense that d E(f + tη)|t=0 = 0 dt
(3.1.24)
for all η : M → R. In order to avoid boundary terms when integrating by parts, we might simply assume that M is a compact Riemannian manifold so that there is no boundary to worry about. This, however, would lead to a somewhat trivial situation below (a solution f would have to be constant then), and so we may prefer to assume instead that (3.1.24) holds for all η with compact support. We may then compute ∂f d 1 ∂η ∂f ∂η √ 0= g ij (x) + t + t gdx1 . . . dxd |t=0 dt 2 M ∂xi ∂xi ∂xj ∂xj ∂f ∂η √ = g ij i j gdx1 . . . dxd using the symmetry gij = gji ∂x ∂x M ∂ √ ij ∂f =− gg ηdx1 . . . dxd j ∂xi M ∂x √ = Δf η gdx1 . . . dxd . M
When this holds for all η, Theorem A.1.5 then implies Δf = 0.
(3.1.25)
In the terminology of the calculus of variations, (3.1.25) then is the Euler–Lagrange equation for the Dirichlet integral E. A function satisfying Δf = 0 is called harmonic. We formulate this result as
94
Chapter 3 The Laplace Operator and Harmonic Differential Forms
Lemma 3.1.1. A smooth critical point f of the energy integral E in the sense that d E(f + tη)|t=0 = 0 dt
(3.1.26)
for all η : M → R with compact support in M is harmonic, i.e., Δf = 0. When we formally perform the preceding computation with differential forms, we get d 1 √ g ij (x)df + tdη, df + tdη gdx1 . . . dxd |t=0 0= dt 2 M √ = g ij df, dη gdx1 . . . dxd M √ = d∗ df, η gdx1 . . . dxd , M
where we have introduced the formal adjoint d∗ of the exterior derivative d. From this, we see that, as in the Euclidean case (cf. (3.1.4), (3.1.5)), this adjoint d∗ as operating on 1-forms is dual to the divergence operating on vector fields (3.1.19), and that we can write the Laplace–Beltrami operator Δ as Δ = d∗ d.
(3.1.27)
This aspect will be clarified in Section 3.3.
3.2
The Spectrum of the Laplace Operator
In this section, we wish to show that every L2 function on a compact Riemannian manifold M can be expanded in terms of eigenfunctions of the Laplace–Beltrami operator Δ on M . The essential tool will be Rellich’s embedding theorem (Theorem A.1.4). Thus, the function space that is appropriate for our purposes is the Sobolev space H := H 1,2 (M ), see Appendix A.1. An eigenfunction of Δ is a function f ∈ H 1,2 (M ), f ≡ / 0, that satisfies Δf (x) = λf (x)
for all x ∈ Ω
for some real λ. A λ for which such an f exists is called an eigenvalue of Δ. The set of all eigenvalues is called the spectrum of Δ. From (3.1.21), we obtain λ(f, f ) = (Δf, f ) = (df, df ) ≥ 0, so that all eigenvalues λ are nonnegative. In fact, for every constant function c, we have Δc ≡ 0,
3.2 The Spectrum of the Laplace Operator
95
so that λ0 := 0 is always an eigenvalue. We shall easily see in a moment that the constant functions are the only ones satisfying Δf = 0 so that the eigenvalue 0 has the multiplicity 1. All other eigenvalues will be positive. We shall use the L2 -product (f, g) :=
√ f (x)g(x) gdx1 . . . dxd M
for f, g ∈ L2 (M ), and further 1
f := f L2 (M ) = (f, f ) 2 . Δ is symmetric in the sense that, for instance for smooth functions ϕ, ψ, we recall (3.1.21), (Δϕ, ψ) = −(dϕ, dψ) = (ϕ, Δψ). We now define λ1 :=
inf
f∈H, M f=0
(df, df ) . (f, f )
(3.2.1)
From the Poincar´e inequality (Corollary A.1.2) it follows that λ1 > 0.
(3.2.2)
Now let (fn )n∈N in the space H0 := {f ∈ H : M f = 0} be a minimizing sequence, so that (dfn , dfn ) lim = λ1 . n→∞ (fn , fn ) Here, we may assume that fn = 1
for all n
(3.2.3)
and, since we have a minimizing sequence for the quotient in (3.2.1), also dfn ≤ K
for all n.
(3.2.4)
By Theorem A.1.3, after a choice of a subsequence, the sequence (fn )n∈N converges weakly in the Hilbert space H to some v1 ∈ H, and by the Rellich compactness theorem (Theorem A.1.4) (fn )n∈N then also converges strongly in L2 (M ) to v1 ; by (3.2.3) it follows that v1 = 1. Furthermore, it follows, because of lower semicontinuity of df L2 for weak convergence in H (Theorem A.1.9; notice that by the Poincar´e inequality df L2 defines a norm in H0 ), and the definition of λ1 that λ1 ≤ (dv1 , dv1 ) ≤ lim (dfn , dfn ) = λ1 , n→∞
so
(dv1 , dv1 ) = λ1 . (v1 , v1 )
96
Chapter 3 The Laplace Operator and Harmonic Differential Forms
Now assume that (λ1 , v1 ), . . . , (λm−1 , vm−1 ) have already been determined iteratively, with λ1 ≤ λ2 ≤ · · · ≤ λm−1 , Δvi = λi vi , and (vi , vj ) = δij
for i, j = 1, . . . , m − 1.
(3.2.5)
We set Hm := {f ∈ H : (f, vi ) = 0 for i = 1, . . . , m − 1} and λm :=
inf
f∈Hm \{0}
(df, df ) . (f, f )
Remarks. 1. λm ≥ λm−1 ,
as Hm ⊂ Hm−1 .
(3.2.6)
2. Hm , being the orthogonal complement of a finite dimensional subspace, is closed (if (fn )n∈N ⊂ Hm converges to f then, as (fn , vi ) = 0 for all n ∈ N, (f, vi ) = 0 for i = 1, . . . , m, so f ∈ Hm ) and therefore it is also a Hilbert space. With the same argument as before we now find a vm ∈ Hm with vm = 1 and λm = (dvm , dvm ) =
(dvm , dvm ) . (vm , vm )
(3.2.7)
Now we claim that Δvm = λm vm .
(3.2.8)
For a proof we observe that for all ϕ ∈ Hm , t ∈ R, (d(vm + tϕ), d(vm + tϕ)) ≥ λm (vm + tϕ, vm + tϕ) and this expression is differentiable in t (this is seen as in the derivation of the Euler– Lagrange equations for the Dirichlet integral E) and has a minimum at t = 0; so d (d(vm + tϕ), d(vm + tϕ)) 0= dt (vm + tϕ, vm + tϕ) t=0
(dvm , dϕ) (dvm , dvm ) (vm , ϕ) − =2 (vm , vm ) (vm , vm ) (vm , vm ) = 2 ((dvm , dϕ) − λm (vm , ϕ)) for all ϕ ∈ Hm . However, for i = 1, . . . , m − 1 (vm , vi ) = 0
3.2 The Spectrum of the Laplace Operator
97
and (dvm , dvi ) = (dvi , dvm ) = λi (vi , vm ) = 0. It follows that (dvm , dϕ) − λm (vm , ϕ) = 0 even for all ϕ ∈ H. This means that vm is a solution of √ dvm (x)dϕ(x) gdx1 . . . dxd = λm M
(3.2.9)
√ vm (x)ϕ(x) gdx1 . . . dxd ,
M
for all ϕ ∈ H 1,2 . By Corollary A.2.2, vm ∈ C ∞ (M ) and Δvm = λm vm .
(3.2.10)
Lemma 3.2.1. limm→∞ λm = ∞. Proof. Otherwise, by (3.2.7), we would have dvm ≤ K
for all m ∈ N.
By the Rellich compactness theorem (Theorem A.1.4), the sequence (vm )m∈N , after choosing a subsequence, would converge in L2 , say to the limit v. Thus lim vm − v = 0. m→∞
However, this is not compatible with the fact that, using (3.2.5), i.e. (v , vm ) = δm , v − vm 2 = (v , v ) − 2(v , vm ) + (vm , vm ) = 2
for = m,
which violates the Cauchy property. This contradiction proves the lemma. Theorem 3.2.1. Let M be a compact Riemannian manifold. Then the eigenvalue problem Δf = λf, f ∈ H 1,2 has countably many eigenvalues with pairwise orthonormal vectors vm , also (vm , v ) = δm ,
(3.2.11)
Δvm = λm vm , (dvm , dv ) = λm δm .
(3.2.12)
Except for the eigenvalue λ0 = 0 realized for a constant as its eigenfunction, all eigenvalues are positive and lim λm = ∞. m→∞
98
Chapter 3 The Laplace Operator and Harmonic Differential Forms
For f ∈ L2 (M ), we have f=
∞ (f, vi )vi ,
(3.2.13)
i=0
where this series converges in L2 and if f ∈ H 1,2 (M ), we also have (df, df ) =
∞
λi (f, vi )2 .
(3.2.14)
i=1
Remark. Equation (3.2.13) means that the eigenvectors form a complete orthonormal basis in L2 (M ).
Proof. First we notice that (3.2.12) follows from (3.2.9) and (3.2.11). It remains to show (3.2.13) and (3.2.14). We set for f ∈ H as abbreviation αi := (f, vi )
for i ∈ N
and fm :=
m
α i vi ,
i=1
ϕm := f − fm . ϕm is thus the orthogonal projection of f onto Hm+1 , the subspace of H orthogonal to v1 , . . . , vm . Hence (ϕm , vi ) = 0 for i = 1, . . . , m (3.2.15) and by definition of λm+1 , (dϕm , dϕm ) ≥ λm+1 (ϕm , ϕm ).
(3.2.16)
By (3.2.9) and (3.2.15) we also have (dϕm , dvi ) = 0
for i = 1, . . . , m.
(3.2.17)
From (3.2.15), we obtain (ϕm , ϕm ) = (f, f − fm , fm ),
(3.2.18)
(dϕm , dϕm ) = (df, df ) − (dfm , dfm ).
(3.2.19)
and from (3.2.17) Now (3.2.16) and (3.2.17) give (ϕm , ϕm ) ≤
1 (df, df ) λm+1
3.2 The Spectrum of the Laplace Operator
99
and using now Lemma 3.2.1, ϕm has to converge to 0 in L2 . This means that f = lim fm = m→∞
∞ (f, vi )vi
in L2 (M ),
i=1
hence (3.2.13). Furthermore, dfm =
m
αi dvi ,
i=1
so by (3.2.12), (dfm , dfm ) =
m
α2i (dvi , dvi )
i=1
=
m
(3.2.20) λi α2i .
i=1
Now, as by (3.2.19), (dfm , dfm ) ≤ (df, df ) and all the λi are positive, the series ∞
λi α2i
i=1
converges. Now for m ≤ n, (dϕm − dϕn , dϕm − dϕn ) = (dfn − dfm , dfn − dfm ) =
n
λi α2i .
i=m+1
Therefore, not only (ϕm ) but also (dϕm ) is a Cauchy sequence in L2 and ϕm therefore converges in H to 0, with respect to the H 1,2 norm. Hence by (3.2.19), (df, df ) = lim (dfm , dfm ) = m→∞
∞
λi α2i
(cf. (3.2.20)).
i=1
We finally want to verify that we have found all the eigenvalues and that all the eigenvectors are linear combinations of the vi . First, the eigenvectors corresponding to different eigenvalues are L2 -orthogonal: Namely, if for v, w = 0, Δv = λv, Δw = μw, then for all ϕ ∈ H, (dv, dϕ) = λ(v, ϕ), (dw, dϕ) = μ(w, ϕ),
100
Chapter 3 The Laplace Operator and Harmonic Differential Forms
and therefore, λ(v, w) = (dv, dw) = (dw, dv) = μ(w, v), and so, if λ = μ, we must have (v, w) = 0. Now if there were an eigenvalue λ not contained in {λm }, say with an eigenvector v = 0 that is linearly independent of all the vi , then (v, vi ) would be 0 for all i and therefore by (3.2.13), v = 0, a contradiction.
Remark. The presentation of the eigenvalue expansions follows the one in [167]. The method originated in Courant–Hilbert [71]. The eigenvalues and eigenfunctions of the Laplace–Beltrami operator of a Riemannian manifold M determine its Green function and heat kernel. We have 1 Γ(x, y) = vj (x)vj (y) (3.2.21) λj j≥1
and p(x, y, t) =
e−λj t vj (x)vj (y).
(3.2.22)
j≥1
The eigenvalues of the Laplace–Beltrami operator of a Riemannian manifold M encode its geometric features, and conversely, these eigenvalues can be estimated in terms of geometric quantities. We now discuss some instances. 1. Weyl’s estimate relates the asymptotics of the spectrum to the volume Vol (M ) of M (see (3.3.9) below): Let N (λ) be the number of eigenvalues (as always, counted with multiplicity) that are ≤ λ. Then for λ → ∞ N (λ) ∼
ωd Vol (M )λd/2 (2π)d
(3.2.23)
where ωd is the volume of the unit ball in Rd , and ∼ means that the remainder term is of order lower than d/2 (the asymptotics of the remainder term can be made more precise in terms of geometric quantities). Reformulated in terms of the eigenvalues, this means that (λj )d/2 ∼
(2π)d jVol (M ). ωd
(3.2.24)
2. The Cheeger estimate controls the first eigenvalue in terms of a global quantity, the cohesion of the manifold. More precisely, we consider h(M ) := inf
Vol d−1 (S) min(Vol d (M1 ), Vol d (M2 ))
(3.2.25)
3.2 The Spectrum of the Laplace Operator
101
where the infimum is taken over all (d − 1)-dimensional submanifolds S of M that divide M into two pieces M1 , M2 , and Vol d−1 refers to the induced of the (d − 1)-dimensional submanifold S. This quantity becomes small when M can be divided into two pieces M1 and M2 of large volume by cutting M along a small hypersurface S, that is, when it is easy to cut M into two large pieces. We then have Cheeger’s estimate h(M )2 . (3.2.26) 4 The argument is essentially the following: We consider an eigenfunction u1 for the eigenvalue λ1 . Since M u1 = 0, according to the definition (3.2.1), M consists of two pieces M1 , M2 with u|M1 < 0, u|M2 > 0; w.l.o.g., let M1 be the one of smaller volume. We then have λ1 ≥
Δu1 = λ1 u1 in M1 ,
u1 = 0 on ∂M1 .
(3.2.27)
We multiply (3.2.27) by u1 and integrate by parts over M1 (there is the issue about the regularity of the boundary of M1 permitting such an integration by parts, but we suppress the technical details here), to obtain
du1 , du1
1 λ1 = M . (3.2.28) u1 , u1 M1 We now consider the function φ := (u1 )2 (= u1 , u1 ). Since d(u1 )2 = 2u1 du1 , we have from the Cauchy–Schwarz inequality dφ ≤ 4( du1 , du1 )( u1 , u1 ), (3.2.29) M1
M1
hence 1 λ1 ≥ 4
M1
M1
dφ
M1
φ
2 .
(3.2.30)
We now recall Federer’s coarea formula (see e.g. [171] for a proof). Theorem. For every open Ω ⊂ M and every smooth function φ on Ω, we
have
Ω
dφ =
∞
−∞
Vol d−1 (φ−1 (t) ∩ Ω)dt,
(3.2.31)
where Vol d−1 indicates the (d − 1)-dimensional volume of a hypersurface. We then obtain
dφ M1
∞
Vol d−1 (φ−1 (t) ∩ M1 )dt ∞ Vol d ({φ ≥ t} ∩ M1 )dt ≥ h(M ) 0 = h(M ) φ. =
−∞
M1
(3.2.32) (3.2.33)
102
Chapter 3 The Laplace Operator and Harmonic Differential Forms For (3.2.32), note that for t > 0, φ−1 (t) is a closed hypersurface in the interior of M1 as φ vanishes on ∂M1 . And since the volume of M1 was assumed to be smaller than the one of M2 and {φ ≥ t} is a subset of M1 , its volume is the smaller one of the two parts into which φ−1 (t) dissects M . This inequality (3.2.33), combined with (3.2.30) yields (3.2.26). Thus, when the first eigenvalue gets smaller and smaller, it becomes easier and easier to break up M into two pieces. In the limiting case where λ1 becomes 0, M becomes disconnected, that is, consists of more than one connected component (which, however, we have excluded by our general assumption that all manifolds be connected). The definition of h(M ) can be considered as a variational problem for a hypersurface S of minimal (d − 1)-dimensional volume enclosing a given ddimensional volume, say the one of M1 . When this infimum is achieved by a smooth hypersurface S, then S should have constant mean curvature. The problem is, however, that in general a minimizing hypersurface will not be smooth, but have singularities. These issues are treated in geometric measure theory. We do not enter into the details here, but simply quote the foundational [97].
3. λ1 can also be controlled from below in terms of a local quantity, the Ricci curvature of M , a concept to be introduced in Chapter 4. This estimate will be derived in Section 4.5 below. Perspectives. Cheeger’s estimate is found in [55]. The estimate of eigenvalues in terms of curvature bounds has been developed by S.T.Yau and P.Li, see for instance [201, 202, 310]. This method will be treated in detail below in Section 4.6. Some books devoted to eigenvalue estimates are [21, 52].
3.3
The Laplace Operator on Forms
In this section, we shall extend the Laplace–Beltrami operator from functions, that is, from 0-forms, to differential forms of arbitrary degree. We need some preparations from linear algebra. Let V be a real vector space with a scalar product ·, ·, and let Λp V be the p-fold exterior product of V. We then obtain a scalar product on Λp V by v1 ∧ . . . ∧ vp , w1 ∧ . . . ∧ wp = det(vi , wj )
(3.3.1)
and bilinear extension to Λp (V ). If e1 , . . . , ed is an orthonormal basis of V, ei1 ∧ . . . ∧ eip
with 1 ≤ i1 < i2 < . . . < ip ≤ d
constitute an orthonormal basis of Λp V.
(3.3.2)
3.3 The Laplace Operator on Forms
103
An orientation on V is obtained by distinguishing a basis of V as positive. Any other basis that is obtained from this basis by a base change with positive determinant then is likewise called positive, and the remaining bases are called negative. Let now V carry an orientation. We define the linear star operator ∗ : Λp (V ) → Λd−p (V ) (0 ≤ p ≤ d) by ∗ (ei1 ∧ . . . ∧ eip ) = ej1 ∧ . . . ∧ ejd−p ,
(3.3.3)
where j1 , . . . , jd−p is selected such that ei1 , . . . , eip , ej1 , . . . , ejd−p is a positive basis of V. Since the star operator is supposed to be linear, it is determined by its values on some basis (3.3.3). In particular, ∗(1) = e1 ∧ . . . ∧ ed
(3.3.4)
∗(e1 ∧ . . . ∧ ed ) = 1,
(3.3.5)
if e1 , . . . , ed is a positive basis. From the rules of multilinear algebra, it easily follows that if A is a d × d-matrix, and if f1 , . . . , fp ∈ V , then ∗(Af1 ∧ . . . ∧ Afp ) = (det A) ∗ (f1 ∧ . . . ∧ fp ). In particular, this implies that the star operator does not depend on the choice of positive orthonormal basis in V , as any two such bases are related by a linear transformation with determinant 1. For a negative basis instead of a positive one, one gets a minus sign on the right-hand sides of (3.3.3), (3.3.4), (3.3.5). Lemma 3.3.1. ∗∗ = (−1)p(d−p) : Λp (V ) → Λp (V ). Proof. ∗∗ maps Λp (V ) onto itself. Suppose ∗(ei1 ∧ . . . ∧ eip ) = ej1 ∧ . . . ∧ ejd−p
(cf. (3.3.3)).
Then ∗ ∗ (ei1 ∧ . . . ∧ eip ) = ±ei1 ∧ . . . ∧ eip , depending on whether ej1 , . . . , ejd−p , ei1 , . . . , eip is a positive or negative basis of V. Now ei1 ∧ . . . ∧ eip ∧ ej1 ∧ . . . ∧ ejd−p = (−1)p(d−p) ej1 ∧ . . . ∧ ejd−p ∧ ei1 ∧ . . . ∧ eip , and (−1)p(d−p) thus is the determinant of the base change from ei1 , . . . , ejd−p to ej1 , . . . , eip .
104
Chapter 3 The Laplace Operator and Harmonic Differential Forms
Lemma 3.3.2. For v, w ∈ Λp (V ) v, w = ∗(w ∧ ∗v) = ∗(v ∧ ∗w).
(3.3.6)
Proof. It suffices to show (3.3.6) for elements of the basis (3.3.2). For any two different such basis vectors, w ∧ ∗v = 0, whereas ∗(ei1 ∧ . . . ∧ eip ∧ ∗(ei1 ∧ . . . ∧ eip )) = ∗(e1 ∧ . . . ∧ ed ), where e1 , . . . , ed is an orthonormal basis (3.3.3) =1
by (3.3.5),
and the claim follows. Remark. We may consider ·, · as a scalar product on d
Λ(V ) := ⊕ Λp (V ) p=0
with Λp (V ) and Λq (V ) being orthogonal for p = q. Lemma 3.3.3. Let v1 , . . . , vd be an arbitrary positive basis of V. Then 1 v1 ∧ . . . ∧ vd . ∗ (1) = det(vi , vj )
(3.3.7)
Proof. Let e1 , . . . , ed be a positive orthonormal basis as before. Then 1
v1 ∧ . . . ∧ vd = (det(vi , vj )) 2 e1 ∧ . . . ∧ ed , and the claim follows from (3.3.4). Let now M be an oriented Riemannian manifold of dimension d. Since M is oriented, we may select an orientation on all tangent spaces Tx M, hence also on all cotangent spaces Tx∗ M in a consistent manner. We simply choose the Euclidean orthonormal basis ∂x∂ 1 , . . . , ∂x∂ d of Rd as being positive. Since all chart transitions of an oriented manifold have positive functional determinant, calling the basis dϕ−1 ( ∂x∂ 1 ), . . . , dϕ−1 ( ∂x∂ d ) of Tx M positive, will not depend on the choice of the chart. Since M carries a Riemannian structure, we have a scalar product on each Tx∗ M. We thus obtain a star operator ∗ : Λp (Tx∗ M ) → Λd−p (Tx∗ M ),
3.3 The Laplace Operator on Forms
105
i.e. a base point preserving operator ∗ : Ωp (M ) → Ωd−p (M )
(Ωp (M ) = Γ(Λp (M ))).
We recall that the metric on Tx∗ M is given by (gij (x)) = (gij (x))−1 . Therefore, by Lemma 3.3.3 we have in local coordinates (3.3.8) ∗ (1) = det(gij )dx1 ∧ . . . ∧ dxd . This expression is called the volume form. In particular Vol (M ) :=
∗(1)
(3.3.9)
M
(provided this is finite). For α, β ∈ Ωp (M ) with compact support, we define the L2 -product as α, β ∗ (1) (α, β) : = M = α ∧ ∗β by Lemma 3.3.2 . M p
This product on Ω (M ) is obviously bilinear and positive definite. We shall also use the L2 -norm α := (α, α)1/2 .
(3.3.10)
(In §3.4 below, we shall also introduce another norm, the Sobolov norm · H 1,2 .) So far, we have considered only smooth sections of vector bundles, in particular only smooth p-forms. For later purposes, we shall also need Lp - and Sobolev spaces of sections of vector bundles. For this aim, from now on, we deviate from Definition 2.1.3 and don’t require sections to be smooth anymore. We let E be a vector bundle over M, s : M → E a section of E with compact support. We say that s is contained in the Sobolev space H k,r (E), if for any bundle atlas with the property that on compact sets all coordinate changes and all their derivatives are bounded (it is not difficult to obtain such an atlas, by making coordinate neighborhoods smaller if necessary), and for any bundle chart from such an atlas, ϕ : E|U → U × Rn we have that ϕ ◦ s|U is contained in H k,r (U ). We note the following consistency property: If ϕ1 : E|U1 → U1 × Rn , ϕ2 : E|U2 → U2 × Rn are two such bundle charts, then ϕ1 ◦ s|U1 ∩U2 is contained in H k,r (U1 ∩ U2 ) if and only if ϕ2 ◦ s|U1 ∩U2 is contained ∞ in this space. The reason is that the coordinate change ϕ2 ◦ ϕ−1 1 is of class C , and all derivatives are bounded on the support of s which was assumed to be compact. We can extend our product (·, ·) to L2 (Ωp (M )). It remains bilinear, and also positive definite, because as usual, in the definition of L2 , functions that differ only on a set of measure zero are identified. We now make the assumption that M is compact, in order not to always have to restrict our considerations to compactly supported forms.
106
Chapter 3 The Laplace Operator and Harmonic Differential Forms d
Definition 3.3.1. d∗ is the operator which is (formally) adjoint to d on ⊕ Ωp (M ) w.r.t. (·, ·). This means that for α ∈ Ωp−1 (M ), β ∈ Ωp (M ) (dα, β) = (α, d∗ β);
p=0
(3.3.11)
d∗ therefore maps Ωp (M ) to Ωp−1 (M ). Lemma 3.3.4. d∗ : Ωp (M ) → Ωp−1 (M ) satisfies d∗ = (−1)d(p+1)+1 ∗ d ∗ .
(3.3.12)
Proof. For α ∈ Ωp−1 (M ), β ∈ Ωp (M ) d(α ∧ ∗β) = dα ∧ ∗β + (−1)p−1 α ∧ d ∗ β = dα ∧ ∗β + (−1)p−1 (−1)(p−1)(d−p+1) α ∧ ∗ ∗ (d ∗ β) by Lemma 3.3.1 (d ∗ β is a (d − p + 1)-form) = dα ∧ ∗β − (−1)d(p+1)+1 α ∧ ∗ ∗ d ∗ β = ± ∗ (dα, β − (−1)d(p+1)+1 α, ∗d ∗ β). We integrate this formula. By Stokes’ theorem, the integral of the left-hand side vanishes, and the claim results. Definition 3.3.2. The Laplace(–Beltrami) operator on Ωp (M ) is Δ = dd∗ + d∗ d : Ωp (M ) → Ωp (M ). ω ∈ Ωp (M ) is called harmonic if Δω = 0 . Remark. Since two stars appear on the right-hand side of (3.3.12), d∗ and hence also Δ may also be defined by (3.3.12) on nonorientable Riemannian manifolds. We just define it locally, hence globally up to a choice of sign which then cancels in (3.3.12). Similarly, the L2 -product can be defined on nonorientable Riemannian manifolds, because the ambiguity of sign of the ∗ involved cancels with the one coming from the integration. More precisely, one should write dp : Ωp (M ) → Ωp+1 (M ) d∗p : Ωp+1 (M ) → Ωp (M ). Then
Δp = dp−1 d∗p−1 + d∗p dp : Ωp (M ) → Ωp (M ).
Nevertheless, we shall usually omit the index p.
3.3 The Laplace Operator on Forms
107
Corollary 3.3.1. Δ is (formally) selfadjoint, i.e. (Δα, β) = (α, Δβ)
for α, β ∈ Ωp (M ).
Proof. Directly from the definition of Δ. Lemma 3.3.5. (Δα, α) = (dd∗ α, α) + (d∗ dα, α) = (d∗ α, d∗ α) + (dα, dα) ≥ 0.
(3.3.13)
In particular, Δ is nonnegative, and Δα = 0 iff dα = 0 and d∗ α = 0.
(3.3.14)
Proof. (3.3.13) follows from the definitions of Δ, d∗ , (., .). Since both terms on the right-hand side of (3.3.13) are nonnegative and vanish only if dα = 0 = d∗ α, Δα = 0 is equivalent to dα = 0 = d∗ α, indeed. Corollary 3.3.2. On a compact Riemannian manifold, every harmonic function is constant. Lemma 3.3.6. ∗Δ = Δ ∗ . Proof. Direct computation. Before we embark on a number of computations that compare the Laplacian Δ as defined here with the one operating on functions as introduced in Section 3.1 and that express our quantities in local coordinates, it might be useful to summarize the key points that will be important for the sequel: We have the exterior derivative d : Ωp (M ) → Ωp+1 (M ). This operator needs only the differentiable structure of M , but no Riemannian metric. When we do have a metric, we have an L2 -product (., .) on p-forms, and we can then define the adjoint d∗ : Ωp+1 (M ) → Ωp (M ) of d w.r.t. this product, that is, (dω, η) = (ω, d∗ eta) for every p-form ω and every (p+1)-form η. With the help of this adjoint, we define the Laplacian Δ = d∗ d + dd∗ : Ωp (M ) → Ωp (M ). This operator is positive and formally selfadjoint, as we see from (Δω, ν) = (dω, dν) + (d∗ ω, d∗ ν) = (ω, Δν) for all ω, ν.
(3.3.15)
When we put ω = ν in this formula, we see that ω is harmonic, i.e., Δω = 0 precisely if dω = 0 and d∗ ω = 0. Of course, the essential point behind this was that on a compact M , integration by parts does not produce any boundary terms. Thus, the second order differential equation Δω = 0 is seen to be equivalent to two first order equations, dω = 0 and d∗ ω = 0. First order differential equations in general are much
108
Chapter 3 The Laplace Operator and Harmonic Differential Forms
more rigid than second order ones, and therefore we can expect that the harmonicity of a form ω will yield strong consequences. So much for the summary. In Section 3.4 below (see Corollary 3.4.2), we shall show that the Hilbert space L2p (M ) admits the orthogonal decomposition L2p (M ) = Bp ⊕ Bp∗ ⊕ Hp
(3.3.16)
where Bp is the L2 -closure of {dα : α ∈ Ωp−1 (M )}, Bp∗ is the L2 -closure of {d∗ β : β ∈ Ωp+1 (M )}, and Hp = Bp⊥ ∩ Bp∗ ⊥ is the space of harmonic p-forms, that is, of (smooth) forms ω satisfying dω = 0 and d∗ ω = 0.
(3.3.17)
Anticipating that result, we shall now briefly discuss the spectrum of the Laplace operator Δ = Δp on p-forms (we shall address the issue of extending the results of Section 3.2 to the present situation of the Laplace operator on p-forms only briefly; more details will be taken care of in one of the exercises to this chapter). Thus, we consider those λ, the eigenvalues of Δp , for which there exists a nontrivial solution ν, the corresponding eigenform, of Δp ν = λν. (3.3.18) As before, since Δp is symmetric w.r.t. the L2 -product (Corollary 3.3.1) and nonnegative (Lemma 3.3.5), all eigenvalues of Δp are real and nonnegative. Also, by elliptic regularity theory (see the details in Section 3.4 below), all eigenforms are smooth. When (3.3.18) holds, we have (dν, dη) + (d∗ ν, d∗ η) = (Δν, η) = λ(ν, η) for all η ∈ Ωp (M ).
(3.3.19)
From this, we see as in Section 3.2 (see (3.2.11)) that eigenforms for different eigenvalues are orthogonal w.r.t. (., .). When λ = 0 in (3.3.18), ν is harmonic. We now look at the case where λ = 0, hence > 0. A corresponding eigenform ν then is contained in Bp ⊕ Bp∗ , according to (3.3.16). We can thus decompose ν = ν1 + ν2 with ν1 ∈ Bp , ν2 ∈ Bp∗ .
(3.3.20)
Since then dν1 = 0 = d∗ ν2 by the definitions of Bp , Bp∗ and d2 = 0 = (d∗ )2 , we have λ(ν1 + ν2 ) = Δν = (dd∗ + d∗ d)(ν1 + ν2 ) = dd∗ ν1 + d∗ dν2 .
(3.3.21)
Since then also dd∗ ν1 ∈ Bp , d∗ dν2 ∈ Bp∗ and these spaces are orthogonal, we conclude Dp ν1 := dp−1 d∗p−1 ν1 = λν1 and Dp ν2 := d∗p dp ν2 = λν2 ,
(3.3.22)
that is, ν1 is an eigenform for Dp and ν2 one for Dp . We write σ(D) for the spectrum, that is, the collection of eigenvalues of a (differential) operator D.
3.3 The Laplace Operator on Forms
109
Since, conversely, when ν1 ∈ Bp , then Dp ν1 = 0, and when ν2 ∈ Bp∗ , then Dp ν2 = 0, we conclude that σ(Δp )\{0} = σ(Dp )\{0} ∪ σ(Dp )\{0}. (3.3.23) Since for any two linear operators A, B σ(AB)\{0} = σ(BA)\{0}
(3.3.24)
(when, for φ = 0, ABφ = λφ, then also BA(Bφ) = λBφ, and Bφ = 0 when λ = 0), we also have )\{0} (3.3.25) σ(Dp )\{0} = σ(Dp−1 (recall Dp = dp−1 d∗p−1 , Dp−1 = d∗p−1 dp−1 ). (3.3.23) and (3.3.25) then imply
Theorem 3.3.1. σ(Δp )\{0} = σ(Dp−1 )\{0} ∪ σ(Dp )\{0}.
(3.3.26)
In particular, the operators Δp and Δp−1 share the part σ(Dp−1 )\{0} of their spectrum while the operators Δp and Δp+1 share σ(Dp )\{0}. In particular:
Corollary 3.3.3. When we know the spectra of Δp−1 and Δp+1 , then we also know the one of Δp , except for the multiplicity of the eigenvalue 0, that is, the number of linearly independent harmonic forms. Thus, all the spectral information of the Laplacian, except for the number of harmonic forms, is already contained in the spaces of differential forms of even degree. The harmonic forms will be the object of Section 3.4.
Before ending this section, we wish to check that the Laplace operator as defined here coincides with the one introduced in Section 3.1 on functions. We begin with the Euclidean case. Let f : Rd → R be a differentiable function. We have df =
∂f i dx ∂xi
d i ∧ and for ϕ = ϕi dxi with compact support, and ∗ϕ = σi=1 (−1)i−1 ϕi dx1 ∧ . . . ∧ dx d . . . ∧ dx ∂f (df, ϕ) = ϕ dx1 ∧ . . . ∧ dxd i i ∂x d R ∂ϕi =− f i dx1 ∧ . . . ∧ dxd , since ϕ is compactly supported. Rd ∂x i
It follows that (see (3.1.5)) d∗ ϕ = − ∂ϕ ∂xi = − div ϕ, and Δf = d∗ df = −
d ∂2f = −div (grad f ). (∂xi )2 i=1
110
Chapter 3 The Laplace Operator and Harmonic Differential Forms
This agrees with (3.1.6). More generally, for a differentiable function f : M → R, we recall the Laplace– Beltrami operator (3.1.20) 1 ∂ √ ij ∂f gg , (3.3.27) Δf = − √ g ∂xj ∂xi with g := det(gij ). Again, we wish to verify that this coincides with our Laplacian d∗ df . We proceed as follows: Since for functions, i.e. 0-forms, we have d∗ = 0, we get for ϕ : M → R (differentiable with compact support) √ d∗ df · ϕ gdx1 ∧ . . . ∧ dxd = (d∗ df, ϕ) = (df, dϕ) = df, dϕ ∗ (1) ∂f ∂ϕ √ = g ij i j gdx1 . . . dxd ∂x ∂x
1 ∂ √ ij ∂f √ ϕ gdx1 . . . dxd , =− √ gg g ∂xj ∂xi and since this holds for all ϕ ∈ C0∞ (M, R), it follows that (3.3.27) yields the Laplacian d∗ d, indeed. In (3.1.17), we have defined the gradient of a function f as ∂f ∂ , ∂xi ∂xj
(3.3.28)
grad f, X = X(f ) = df (X).
(3.3.29)
∇f := grad f := g ij in order to have for any vector field X
∂ Also, in (3.1.19), the divergence of a vector field Z = Z i ∂x i has been defined as
1 ∂ √ ij 1 ∂ √ j ∂ ( gZ ) = gg div Z := √ Z, . √ g ∂xj g ∂xj ∂xi
(3.3.30)
(3.3.27) then is, see (3.1.20), Δf = −div grad f.
(3.3.31)
In particular, if M is compact, and f : M → R is a smooth function, then as a consequence of (3.3.31) and (3.3.30) or (3.3.27) and the Gauss theorem, we have Δf ∗ (1) = 0. (3.3.32) M
We now want to compute the Euclidean Laplace operator for p-forms. It is denoted by Δe ; likewise, the star operator w.r.t. the Euclidean metric is denoted by ∗e , and d∗ is the operator adjoint to d w.r.t. the Euclidean scalar product.
3.3 The Laplace Operator on Forms
111
Let now ω = ωi1 ...ip dxi1 ∧ . . . ∧ dxip be a p-form on an open subset of Rd , as usual with an increasing p-tuple 1 ≤ i1 < i2 < . . . < ip ≤ d. We choose j1 , . . . , jd−p such that ∂x∂i1 , . . . , ∂x∂ip , ∂x∂j1 , . . . , ∂xi∂d−p is a positive orthonormal basis of Rd . In the sequel always ∈ {1, . . . , p}, k ∈ {1, . . . , d − p}. Now ∂ωi1 ...ip d−p
dω =
∂xjk
k=1
dxjk ∧ dxi1 ∧ . . . ∧ dxip
d−p
∗e dω =
(−1)p+k−1
k=1 d−p
d ∗e dω =
(−1)p+k−1
k=1
+
∂ωi1 ...ip j1 jk ∧ . . . ∧ dxjd−p dx ∧ . . . ∧ dx ∂xjk
(3.3.33)
∂ 2 ωi1 ...ip jk jk ∧ . . . ∧ dxid−p dx ∧ dxj1 ∧ . . . ∧ dx (∂xjk )2
d−p p
(−1)p+k−1
k=1 =1
∂ 2 ωi1 ...ip i jk ∧ ... ∧ dxid−p dx ∧dxj1 ∧ . . . ∧ dx ∂xjk ∂xi (3.3.34)
d−p
∗e d ∗e dω =
(−1)p+p(d−p)
k=1
+
p d−p
∂ 2 ωi1 ...ip i1 dx ∧ . . . ∧ dxip (∂xjk )2
(−1)pd+
k=1 =1
∂ 2 ωi1 ...ip jk i ∧ . . . ∧ dxip . dx ∧ dxi1 ∧ . . . ∧ dx ∂xjk ∂xi (3.3.35)
Hence with (3.3.12) d∗ dω =
d−p
(−1)
k=1
+
∂ 2 ωi1 ...ip i1 dx ∧ . . . ∧ dxip (∂xjk )2
p d−p k=1 =1
(−1)+1
∂ 2 ωi1 ...ip jk i ∧. . .∧dxip . dx ∧ dxi1 ∧. . .∧ dx ∂xjk ∂xi
(3.3.36)
112
Chapter 3 The Laplace Operator and Harmonic Differential Forms
Analogously ∗e ω = ωi1 ...ip dxj1 ∧ . . . ∧ dxjd−p d ∗e ω =
p ∂ωi1 ...ip =1 p
∗e d ∗e ω = d ∗e d ∗e ω =
=1 p
∂xi
dxi ∧ dxj1 ∧ . . . ∧ dxid−p
(3.3.38)
(−1)p(d−p)+d−p+−1
∂ωi1 ...ip i1 i ∧ . . . ∧ dxip dx ∧ . . . ∧ dx ∂xi
(−1)p(d−p)+d−p+−1
∂ 2 ωi1 ...ip i i ∧ . . . ∧ dxip dx ∧ dxi1 ∧ . . . ∧ dx (∂xi )2
=1
+
(3.3.37)
(3.3.39)
p d−p ∂ 2 ωi ...i i ∧ . . . ∧ dxip, (−1)p(d−p)+d−p+−1 i 1 jp dxjk∧ dxi1 ∧ . . . ∧ dx ∂x ∂x k =1 k=1
(3.3.40) hence with (3.3.39) dd∗ ω =
p =1
+
(−1)
∂ 2 ωi1 ...ip i1 dx ∧ . . . ∧ dxip (∂xi )2
p d−p ∂ 2 ωi ...i i ∧ . . . ∧ dxip . (−1) i 1 jp dxjk ∧ dxi1 ∧ . . . ∧ dx ∂x ∂x k
(3.3.41)
=1 k=1
(3.3.36) and (3.3.41) yield Δe ω = d∗ dω + dd∗ ω = (−1)
d ∂ 2 ωi1 ...ip i1 dx ∧ . . . ∧ dxip . m )2 (∂x m=1
(3.3.42)
Some more formulas: We write η :=
√ gdx1 ∧ . . . ∧ dxd =: ηi1 ...id dxi1 ∧ . . . ∧ dxid .
(3.3.43)
For β = βj1 ...jp dxj1 ∧ . . . ∧ dxjp β i1 ...ip := gi1 j1 g i2 j2 . . . gip jp βj1 ...jp .
(3.3.44)
With these conventions, for α = αi1 ...ip dxi1 ∧ . . . ∧ dxip (∗α)ip+1 ...id = and (d∗ α)i1 ...ip−1 = −gk
1 ηi ...i αi1 ...ip p! 1 p
∂αki1 ...ip−1 − Γjk αji1 ...ip−1 . ∂x
(3.3.45)
(3.3.46)
3.4 Representing Cohomology Classes by Harmonic Forms
113
Further (α, β) = αi1 ...ip β i1 ...ip ∂αi1 ...ip ∂βj1 ...jp k i1 j1 g g . . . g ip jp (dα, dβ) = k ∂x ∂x ∂αki1 ...ip−1 − Γjk αji1 ...ip−1 ei1 ∧. . .∧eip−1 , (d∗ α, d∗ β) = g k ∂x
∂β mj1 ...jp−1 r e − Γ β ∧. . .∧e gmn rj ...j j j mn 1 p−1 1 p−1 ∂xn ∂αki1 ...ip−1 ∂βmj1 ...jp−1 k mn i1 j1 = g g g . . . g ip−1 jp−1 ∂x ∂xn ∂αki1 ...ip−1 i − Γmn βij1 ...jp−1 g k . . . gip−1 jp−1 ∂x ∂βmj1 ...jp−1 j − Γmn αji1 ...ip−1 g k g mn g i1 j1 . . . g ip−1 jp−1 . ∂xn
(3.3.47) (3.3.48)
(3.3.49)
Formula (3.3.45) is clear. (3.3.46) may be verified by a straightforward, but somewhat lengthy computation. We shall see a different proof in §4.3 as a consequence of Lemma 4.3.4. The remaining formulas then are clear again.
3.4
Representing Cohomology Classes by Harmonic Forms
We first recall the definition of the de Rham cohomology groups. Let M be a differentiable manifold. The operator d : Ωp (M ) → Ωp+1 (M ) satisfies (Theorem 2.1.5) d ◦ d = 0 (d ◦ d : Ωp (M ) → Ωp+2 (M )). (3.4.1) α ∈ Ωp (M ) is called closed if dα = 0, exact, if there exists η ∈ Ωp−1 (M ) with dη = α. Because of (3.4.1), exact forms are always closed. Two closed forms α, β ∈ Ωp (M ) are called cohomologous if α − β is exact. This property determines an equivalence relation on the space of closed forms in Ωp (M ), and the set of equivalence classes is a vector space over R, called the p-th de Rham cohomology group and denoted by p (M, R). HdR
Usually, however, we shall simply write H p (M ). In this section, we want to show the following fundamental result:
114
Chapter 3 The Laplace Operator and Harmonic Differential Forms
Theorem 3.4.1 (Hodge). Let M be a compact Riemannian manifold. Then every cohomology class in H p (M ) (0 ≤ p ≤ d = dim M ) contains precisely one harmonic form. The general idea is to select a specific representative of a class of geometric objects, here a cohomology class, by imposing a suitable differential equation, or equivalently, as we shall see, by minimizing a certain functional within that class. The differential equation imposed in the present case is d∗ η = 0 which in addition to the equation dη = 0 satisfied by any cohomology class yields the harmonic equation Δη = 0. The general strategy exemplified here by the Hodge theorem is fundamental in geometric analysis. Here, we shall demonstrate the Hodge theorem by a variational method. As in Section 3.2, the key technical tool will be Rellich’s embedding theorem (Theorem A.1.4), to be recalled below in the specific form needed here in Lemma 3.4.2. An alternative proof, by the heat flow method, as well as some important extensions, will be given in Section 3.6 below. Proof. Uniqueness is easy: Let ω1 , ω2 ∈ Ωp (M ) be cohomologous and both harmonic. Then either p = 0 (in which case ω1 = ω2 anyway) or (ω1 − ω2 , ω1 − ω2 ) = (ω1 − ω2 , dη) for some η ∈ Ωp−1 (M ), since ω1 and ω2 are cohomologous = (d∗ (ω1 − ω2 ), η) = 0, since ω1 and ω2 are harmonic, hence satisfy d∗ ω1 = 0 = d∗ ω2 . Since (·, ·) is positive definite, we conclude ω1 = ω2 , hence uniqueness. For the proof of existence, which is much harder, we shall use Dirichlet’s principle. Let ω0 be a (closed) differential form, representing the given cohomology class in H p (M ). All forms cohomologous to ω0 then are of the form ω = ω0 + dα
(α ∈ Ωp−1 (M )).
We now minimize the L2 -norm D(ω) := (ω, ω) in the class of all such forms. The essential step consists in showing that the infimum is achieved by a smooth form η. Such an η then has to satisfy the Euler–Lagrange equations for D, i.e.
3.4 Representing Cohomology Classes by Harmonic Forms
115
d (η + tdβ, η + tdβ)|t=0 dt = 2(η, dβ)
0=
∗
for all β ∈ Ω
= 2(d η, β)
(3.4.2)
p−1
(M ).
This implies d∗ η = 0. Since dη = 0 anyway, η is harmonic. In order to make Dirichlet’s principle precise, we shall need some results and constructions from the calculus of variations. Some of them will be merely sketched (see §§A.1, A.2 of the Appendices), and for details, we refer to our textbook [167]. First of all, we have to work with the space of L2 -forms instead of the one of C ∞ forms, since we want to minimize the L2 -norm and therefore certainly need a space that is complete w.r.t. L2 -convergence. For technical purposes, we shall also need Sobolev spaces which we now want to define in the present context (see also §A.1). On Ωp (M ), we introduce a new scalar product ((ω, ω)) := (dω, dω) + (d∗ ω, d∗ ω) + (ω, ω) and put
(3.4.3)
1
ωH 1,2 (M ) := ((ω, ω)) 2 .
(3.4.4)
2
(This norm is to be distinguished from the L -norm of (3.3.10).) We complete the space Ωp (M ) of smooth p-forms w.r.t. the · H 1,2 (M) -norm. The resulting Hilbert space will be denoted by Hp1,2 (M ) or simply by H 1,2 (M ),1 if the index p is clear from the context. Let now V ⊂ Rd be open. For a smooth map f : V → Rn , the Euclidean Sobolev norm is given by f H 1,2
eucl. (V
)
f ·f +
:= V
V
∂f ∂f · ∂xi ∂xi
12 ,
the dot · denoting the Euclidean scalar product. With the help of charts for M and bundle charts for Λp (M ) for every x0 ∈ M, there exist an open neighborhood U and a diffeomorphism ϕ : Λp (M )|U → V × Rn where V is open in Rd , n = dp is the dimension of the fibers of Λp (M ), and the fiber over x ∈ U is mapped to a fiber {π(ϕ(x))} × Rn , where π : V × Rn → V is the projection onto the first factor. Lemma 3.4.1. On any U U , the norms ωH 1,2 (U )
and
ϕ(ω)H 1,2
eucl.
(V )
(with V := π(ϕ(U ))) are equivalent. do not confuse the H of the Sobolev space Hp1,2 (M ) (which may stand for Hilbert) with the H of the cohomology group H p (which stands for “homology”). 1 Please
116
Chapter 3 The Laplace Operator and Harmonic Differential Forms
Proof. As long as we restrict ourselves to relatively compact subsets of U, all coordinate changes lead to equivalent norms. Furthermore, by a covering argument, it suffices to find for every x in the closure of U a neighborhood U on which the claimed equivalence of norms holds. After these remarks, we may assume that first of all π ◦ϕ is the map onto normal coordinates with center x0 , and that secondly for the metric in our neighborhood of x0 , we have |gij (x) − δij | < ε and |Γijk (x)| < ε for i, j, k = 1, . . . , d.
(3.4.5)
The formulas (3.3.47) – (3.3.49) then imply that the claim holds for sufficiently small ¯ ⊂ U is compact by ε > 0, i.e. for a sufficiently small neighborhood of x0 . Since U assumption, the claim for U follows by a covering argument. Lemma 3.4.1 implies that the Sobolev spaces defined by the norms · H 1,2 (M) and · H 1,2 coincide. Hence all results for Sobolev spaces in the Euclidean setting eucl. may be carried over to the Riemannian situation. In particular, we have Rellich’s theorem (cf. Theorem A.1.8): Lemma 3.4.2. Let (ωn )n∈N ⊂ Hp1,2 (M ) be bounded, i.e. ωn H 1,2 (M ) ≤ K. Then a subsequence of (ωn ) converges w.r.t. the L2 -norm 1
ωL2 (M ) := (ω, ω) 2 to some ω ∈ Hp1,2 (M ). Corollary 3.4.1. There exists a constant c, depending only on the Riemannian metric of M, with the property that for all closed forms β that are orthogonal to the kernel of d∗ , (β, β) ≤ c(d∗ β, d∗ β). (3.4.6) Proof. Otherwise, there would exist a sequence of closed forms βn orthogonal to the kernel of d∗ , with (βn , βn ) ≥ n(d∗ βn , d∗ βn ). (3.4.7) We put Then
1
λn := (βn , βn )− 2 . 1 = (λn βn , λn βn ) ≥ n(d∗ (λn βn ), d∗ (λn βn )).
Since dβn = 0, we have λn βn H 1,2 ≤ 1 +
1 . n
(3.4.8)
3.4 Representing Cohomology Classes by Harmonic Forms
117
By Lemma 3.4.2, after selection of a subsequence, λn βn converges in L2 to some form ψ. By (3.4.8), d∗ (λn βn ) converges to 0 in L2 . Hence d∗ ψ = 0; this is seen as follows: For all ϕ 0 = lim (d∗ (λn βn ), ϕ) = lim(λn βn , dϕ) n→∞
= (ψ, dϕ) = (d∗ ψ, ϕ) and hence d∗ ψ = 0. (With the same argument, dβn = 0 for all n implies dψ = 0.) Now, since d∗ ψ = 0 and βn is orthogonal to the kernel of d∗ , (ψ, λn βn ) = 0.
(3.4.9)
On the other hand, (λn βn , λn βn ) = 1 and the L2 -convergence of λn βn to ψ imply lim (ψ, λn βn ) = 1.
n→∞
This is a contradiction, and (3.4.7) is impossible. We can now complete the proof of Theorem 3.4.1: Let (ωn )n∈N be a minimizing sequence for D(ω) in the given cohomology class, i.e. ωn = ω0 + dαn D(ωn ) →
inf
ω=ω0 +dα
D(ω) =: κ.
(3.4.10)
By (3.4.10), w.l.o.g. (ωn , ωn ) = D(ωn ) ≤ κ + 1.
(3.4.11)
As with Dirichlet’s principle in Rd , ωn converges weakly to some ω, after selection of a subsequence. We have (ω − ω0 , ϕ) = 0 for all ϕ ∈ Ωp (M ) with d∗ ϕ = 0, (3.4.12) because
(ωn − ω0 , ϕ) = (dαn , ϕ) = (αn , d∗ ϕ) = 0 for all such ϕ.
(3.4.12) means that ω − ω0 is weakly exact. We want to study this condition more closely and put η := ω − ω0 . We define a linear functional on d∗ (Ωp (M )) by (δϕ) := (η, ϕ); is well defined; namely if d∗ ϕ1 = d∗ ϕ2 , then (η, ϕ1 − ϕ2 ) = 0 by (3.4.12).
(3.4.13)
118
Chapter 3 The Laplace Operator and Harmonic Differential Forms
For ϕ ∈ Ωp (M ) let π(ϕ) be the orthogonal projection onto the kernel of d∗ , and ψ := ϕ − π(ϕ); in particular d∗ ψ = d∗ ϕ. Then (3.4.14) (d∗ ϕ) = (d∗ ψ) = (η, ψ). Since ψ is orthogonal to the kernel of δ, by Corollary 3.4.1, ψL2 ≤ cd∗ ψL2 = cd∗ ϕL2 .
(3.4.15)
(3.4.14) and (3.4.15) imply |(d∗ ϕ)| ≤ cηL2 d∗ ϕL2 . Therefore, the function on d∗ (Ωp (M )) is bounded and can be extended to the L2 -closure of d∗ (Ωp (M )). By the Riesz representation theorem, any bounded linear functional on a Hilbert space is representable as the scalar product with an element of the space itself. Consequently, there exists α with (α, d∗ ϕ) = (η, ϕ)
(3.4.16)
dα = η.
(3.4.17)
for all ϕ ∈ Ωp (M ). Thus, we have weakly Therefore, ω = ω0 + η is contained in the closure of the considered class. Instead of minimizing among the ω cohomologous to ω0 , we could have minimized as well in the closure of this class, i.e., in the space of all ω for which there exists some α with (α, d∗ ϕ) = (ω − ω0 , ϕ) for all ϕ ∈ Ωp (M ). Then ω, as weak limit of a minimizing sequence, is contained in this class. Namely, suppose ωn = ω0 + dαn weakly, i.e. n (d∗ ϕ) := (αn , d∗ ϕ) = (ωn − ω0 , ϕ) ∀ ϕ ∈ Ωp (M ). By the same estimate as above, the linear functionals n converge to some functional , again represented by some α. Since D also is weakly lower semicontinuous w.r.t. weak convergence, it follows that κ ≤ D(ω) ≤ lim inf D(ωn ) = κ, n→∞
hence D(ω) = κ. Furthermore, by (3.4.2), 0 = (ω, dβ) for all β ∈ Ωp−1 (M ). In this sense, ω is weakly harmonic.
(3.4.18)
3.4 Representing Cohomology Classes by Harmonic Forms
119
We still need the regularity theorem implying that solutions of (3.4.18) are smooth. This can be carried out as in the Euclidean case. If one were allowed to insert β = d∗ ω in (3.4.18) and integrate by parts, it would follow that 0 = (d∗ ω, d∗ ω), i.e. d∗ ω = 0. Iteratively, also higher derivatives would vanish, and the Sobolev embedding theorem would imply regularity. However, we cannot yet insert β = d∗ ω, since we do not know yet whether dd∗ ω exists. This difficulty, however, may be overcome as usual by replacing derivatives by difference quotients (see §A.2 of the Appendix). In this manner, one obtains regularity and completes the proof. Corollary 3.4.2 (Hodge). Let Bp be the L2 -closure of {dα : α ∈ Ωp−1 (M )}, and Bp∗ be the L2 -closure of {d∗ β : β ∈ Ωp+1 (M )}. Then the Hilbert space L2p (M ) of square integrable p-forms admits the orthogonal decomposition L2p (M ) = Bp ⊕ Bp∗ ⊕ Hp (3.4.19) where Hp = Bp⊥ ∩ Bp∗ ⊥ is the space of harmonic p-forms. Proof. Since (dα, d∗ β) = (d2 α, β) = 0 since d2 = 0, the spaces Bp and Bp∗ are orthogonal to each other. Therefore, we obtain the orthogonal decomposition L2p (M ) = Bp ⊕ Bp∗ ⊕ (Bp⊥ ∩ Bp∗ ⊥ ). Moreover, since for a smooth ω, (ω, dα) = (d∗ ω, α), we have that ω ∈ Ωp (M ) is in Bp ⊥ iff d∗ ω = 0. Similarly, ω ∈ Ωp (M ) is in Bp∗ ⊥ iff dω = 0. Thus, ω ∈ Ωp (M ) is contained in Bp⊥ ∩ Bp∗ ⊥ iff it is harmonic. This is for smooth ω, but the fundamental point of the proof of Theorem 3.4.1 was that when (ω, dα) = 0 = (ω, d∗ β) for ω ∈ L2 (M ) and all (smooth) α, β, then ω is itself smooth and harmonic. This completes the proof. Corollary 3.4.3. Let M be a compact, oriented, differentiable manifold. Then all p cohomology groups HdR (M, R) (0 ≤ p ≤ d := dim M ) are finite dimensional. Proof. By Theorem 1.4.1, a Riemannian metric may be introduced on M. By Theorem 3.4.1 any cohomology class may be represented by a form which is harmonic w.r.t.
120
Chapter 3 The Laplace Operator and Harmonic Differential Forms
this metric. We now assume that H p (M ) is infinite dimensional. Then, there exists an orthonormal sequence of harmonic forms (ηn )n∈N ⊂ H p (M ), i.e. (ηn , ηm ) = δnm for n, m ∈ N.
(3.4.20)
Since the ηn are harmonic, d∗ ηn = 0, and dηn = 0. By Rellich’s theorem (Lemma 3.4.2), after selection of a subsequence, (ηn ) converges in L2 to some η. This, however, is not compatible with (3.4.20), because (3.4.20) implies ηn − ηm L2 ≥ 1 for n = m, so that (ηn ) cannot be a Cauchy sequence in L2 . This contradiction proves the finite dimensionality. Let now M be a compact, oriented, differentiable manifold of dimension d. We define a bilinear map p d−p (M, R) × HdR (M, R) → R HdR by
(ω, η) →
ω∧η
(3.4.21)
M
for representatives ω, η of the cohomology classes considered. It remains to show that (3.4.21) depends only on the cohomology classes of ω and η, in order that the map is indeed defined on the cohomology groups. If, however, ω and ω are cohomologous, there exists a (p − 1)-form α with ω = ω + dα, and ω ∧ η = (ω + dα) ∧ η M M ω∧η+ d(α ∧ η) since η is closed = M M ω ∧ η by Stokes’ theorem. = M
Therefore, (3.4.21) indeed depends only on the cohomology class of ω, and likewise only on the cohomology class of η. Let us now recall a simple result of linear algebra. Let V and W be finite dimensional real vector spaces, and let (·, ·) : V × W → R be bilinear and nondegenerate in the sense that for any v ∈ V, v = 0, there exists w ∈ W with (v, w) = 0, and conversely. Then V can be identified with the dual space W ∗ of W, and W may be identified with V ∗ . Namely, i1 : V → W ∗
with i1 (v)(w) := (v, w),
i2 : W → V ∗
with i2 (w)(v) := (v, w),
are two injective linear maps. Then V and W must be of the same dimension, and i1 and i2 are isomorphisms.
3.4 Representing Cohomology Classes by Harmonic Forms
121
Theorem 3.4.2. Let M be a compact, oriented, differentiable manifold of dimension p d. The bilinear form (3.4.21) is nondegenerate, and hence HdR (M, R) is isomorphic d−p ∗ to (HdR (M, R)) . Proof. For each nontrivial cohomology class in H p (M ), represented by some ω (i.e. dω = 0, but not ω = dα for any (p − 1)-form α), we have to find some cohomology class in H d−p (M ) represented by some η, such that ω ∧ η = 0. M
For this purpose, we introduce a Riemannian metric on M which is possible by Theorem 1.4.1. By Theorem 3.4.1, we may assume that ω is harmonic (w.r.t. this metric). By Lemma 3.3.6 Δ ∗ ω = ∗Δω, and therefore, ∗ω is harmonic together with ω. Now ω ∧ ∗ω = (ω, ω) = 0, since ω does not vanish identically. M
Therefore, ∗ω represents a cohomology class in H d−p (M ) with the desired property. Thus the bilinear form is nondegenerate, and the claim follows. Definition 3.4.1. The p-th homology group Hp (M, R) of a compact, differentiable p (M, R))∗ . The p-th Betti number of M is bp (M ) := manifold M is defined to be (HdR p dim H (M, R). With this definition, Theorem 3.4.2 becomes d−p Hp (M, R) ∼ = HdR (M, R).
(3.4.22)
This statement is called Poincar´e duality. Corollary 3.4.4. Let M be a compact, oriented, differentiable manifold of dimension d. Then d (3.4.23) (M, R) ∼ HdR =R and bp (M ) = bd−p (M )
for
0 ≤ p ≤ d.
(3.4.24)
0 (M, R) ∼ Proof. HdR = R. This follows e.g. from Corollary 3.3.2 and Theorem 3.4.1, but can also be seen in an elementary fashion. Theorem 3.4.2 then implies (3.4.23), as well as (3.4.24).
122
Chapter 3 The Laplace Operator and Harmonic Differential Forms
As an example, let us consider an n-dimensional torus T n . As shown in §1.4, it can be equipped with a Euclidean metric for which the covering π : Rn → T n is a local isometry. By (3.3.42), we have for the Laplace operator of the Euclidean metric Δ(ωi1 ,...,ip dxi1 ∧ . . . ∧ dxip ) = (−1)
n ∂ 2 ωi1 ...ip i1 dx ∧ . . . ∧ dxip m )2 (∂x m=1
(x1 , . . . , xn Euclidean coordinates of Rn ). Thus, a p-form is harmonic if and only if all coefficients w.r.t. the basis dxi1 ∧ . . . ∧ dxip are harmonic. Since T n is compact, by Corollary 3.3.2, they then have to be constant. Consequently n n p n p n bp (T ) = dim H (T ) = dim Λ (R ) = (0 ≤ p ≤ n). p Perspectives. The results of this section were found in the 1940s by Weyl, Hodge, de Rham and Kodaira.
3.5
Generalizations
The constructions of this chapter may easily be generalized. Here, we only want to indicate some such generalizations. Let E and F be vector bundles over the compact, oriented, differentiable manifold M. Let Γ(E) and Γ(F ) be the spaces of differentiable sections. Sobolev spaces of sections can be defined with the help of bundle charts: Let (f, U ) be a bundle chart for E, f then identifies E|U with U × Rn . A section s of E is then contained in the Sobolev space H k,p (E) if for any such bundle chart and any U U, we have p2 ◦ f ◦ s|U ∈ H k,p (U , Rn ), where p2 : U × Rn → Rn is the projection onto the second factor. A linear map L : Γ(E) → Γ(F ) is called a (linear) differential operator of order from E to F if in any bundle chart, L defines such an operator. For the Laplace operator, of course E = F = Λp (T ∗ M ), = 2. In a bundle chart, we write L as L = P (D) + . . . + P0 (D), where each Pj (D) is an (m × n)-matrix (m, n = fiber dimensions of E and F , resp.), whose components are differential operators of the form aα (x)D α |α|=j
3.6 The Heat Flow and Harmonic Forms
123
where α is a multi-index, and Dα is a homogeneous differential operator of degree |α| = j. Let us assume that the aα (x) are differentiable. For ξ = (ξ 1 , . . . , ξ m ) ∈ Rm , let Pj (ξ) be the matrix obtained for Pj (D) by replacing D α by ξ α . Pj (ξ) thus has components aα (x)ξ α . |α|=j
L is called elliptic at the point x, if P (ξ) ( = degree of L) is nonsingular at x for all ξ ∈ Rm \{0}. Note that in this case necessarily n = m. L is called elliptic if it is elliptic at every point. Let now ·, ·E and ·, ·F be bundle metrics on E and F, resp. (those always exist by Theorem 2.1.3), let M carry a Riemannian metric (existing by Theorem 1.4.1) and an orientation. Integrating the bundle metrics, for example (·, ·)E := ·, ·E dVol g (dVol g = det(gij )dx1 ∧ . . . ∧ dxd ), M
we obtain L2 -metrics on Γ(E) and Γ(F ). Let L∗ be the operator formally adjoint to L, i.e. (Lv, w)F = (v, L∗ w)E for v ∈ Γ(E), w ∈ Γ(F ). L is elliptic if L∗ is. The importance of the ellipticity condition rests on the fact that solutions of elliptic differential equations are regular, and the space of solutions has finite dimension. Here, however, this shall not be pursued any further.
3.6
The Heat Flow and Harmonic Forms
In this section, we shall present an alternative proof of Theorem 3.4.1. This proof will procede by solving a parabolic equation, the so-called heat flow. The idea is to let the objects involved, here p-forms, depend not only on the position x in the manifold M , but also on another variable, the “time” t ∈ [0, ∞), and to replace the elliptic equation that one wishes to solve by a parabolic equation that one can solve for given starting values at time t = 0. In our case of differential forms, this heat equation is ∂β(x, t) + Δβ(x, t) = 0 ∂t β(x, 0) = β0 (x) where β0 is a p-form in the cohomology class that we wish to study.
(3.6.1) (3.6.2)
124
Chapter 3 The Laplace Operator and Harmonic Differential Forms
We recall from Section 3.4 that Δ is the Euler–Lagrange operator for the functional (β, β) that we wish to minimize, that is, Δ is some kind of gradient for our functional (in a sense that will not be made precise here). Thus, the idea of the parabolic flow (3.6.1) is to flow in the direction of the negative gradient of the functional to be minimized, expecting that this will bring us towards a minimum as t → ∞. The strategy then consists in showing that (3.6.1) can be uniquely solved for all positive t (this is called global or long time existence) and that, as t → ∞, the solution β(x, t) converges to a harmonic p-form in the same cohomology class. (3.6.1) is a linear parabolic differential equation (or more precisely, a system of linear differential equations since the dimension of the fibers Λp is larger than 1 except for trivial cases). Therefore, the global existence and existence of solutions follows from the general theory of linear parabolic differential equations. Since we consider this equation as a prototype of other, typically nonlinear, parabolic differential equations arising in geometric analysis, we shall only use the short time existence here (which also holds for nonlinear equations by linearization) and deduce the long time existence from differential inequalities for the geometric objects involved. The short time existence is contained in Lemma 3.6.1. Let β0 ∈ Ωp be of class C 2,α for some 0 < α < 1. Then, for some 0 < , (3.6.1) has a solution β(x, t) for 0 ≤ t < , and this solution is also of class C 2,α . In order to procede to the global existence, we shall consider the L2 -norm 2 β(·, t) = (β, β) = β(x, t) ∧ ∗β(x, t) (3.6.3) M
and the energy E(β(·, t)) :=
1 1 1 1 dβ(·, t)2 + d∗ β(·, t)2 = (dβ, dβ) + (d∗ β, d∗ β). 2 2 2 2
(3.6.4)
(Note that (β(·, t)2 + 2E(β(·, t)))1/2 is the Sobolev norm of β(·, t) as introduced in (3.4.4).) Lemma 3.6.2. d β(·, t)2 ≤ 0 dt d2 β(·, t)2 ≥ 0 dt2 d E(β(·, t)) ≤ 0. dt
(3.6.5) (3.6.6) (3.6.7)
The lemma tells us that β(·, t)2 is a decreasing and convex function of the flow parameter t.
3.6 The Heat Flow and Harmonic Forms
125
Proof. d ∂ β(·, t)2 = 2( β(·, t), β(·, t)) dt ∂t = −2(Δβ(·, t), β(·, t)) = −2(dβ(·, t), dβ(·, t)) − 2(d∗ β(·, t), d∗ β(·, t)) = −4E(β(·, t))
(3.6.8)
≤0 which shows (3.6.5). Next d ∂ ∂ E(β(·, t)) = (d β(·, t), dβ(·, t)) + (d∗ β(·, t), d∗ β(·, t)) dt ∂t ∂t ∂ = ( β(·, t), Δβ(·, t)) ∂t ∂ ∂ = −( β(·, t), β(·, t)) ∂t ∂t ≤0 which shows (3.6.7). (3.6.6) follows from this and (3.6.8). Analyzing the proof, (3.6.5) is a direct consequence of the differential equation (3.6.1). In fact, one can apply the same kind of strategy to any functional, that is, to decrease its value by flowing with some associated parabolic equation. (3.6.6), in contrast, is a more special result that expresses an important convexity property of the functional that we are investigating here. This aspect will also play a fundamental role in our considerations in Chapter 8. In particular, when β(x, 0) ≡ 0, then, by (3.6.5), β(x, t) ≡ 0 for all t for which the solution exists. From this, we deduce Corollary 3.6.1. Solutions of (3.6.1) are unique (if β1 (x, t) and β2 (x, t) are solutions of (3.6.1) for 0 ≤ t ≤ T with the same initial values, i.e., β1 (x, 0) = β2 (x, 0), then they also coincide for 0 ≤ t ≤ T ) and satisfy a semigroup property (if β(·, t) solves (3.6.1), then β(·, t + s) = βs (·, t) where βs (·, t) is the solution of (3.6.1) with initial values βs (·, 0) = β(·, s)). In fact, we have a more general stability result Corollary 3.6.2. For a family β(x, t, s) of solutions of (3.6.1) that depends differentiably on the parameter s ∈ R, d ∂ β(·, t, s)2 ≤ 0. dt ∂s
(3.6.9)
∂ Proof. ∂s β(x, t, s) also solves (3.6.1), and (3.6.9) therefore follows from (3.6.5). We now need some a priori estimates:
126
Chapter 3 The Laplace Operator and Harmonic Differential Forms
Lemma 3.6.3. A solution β(x, t) of (3.6.1) defined for 0 ≤ t ≤ T with initial values β0 (x) ∈ L2 satisfies for τ ≤ t ≤ T , for any τ > 0, estimates of the form β(·, t)C 2,α (M ) +
∂ β(·, t)C α (M) ≤ c1 ∂t
(3.6.10)
with a constant c1 depending only on β0 L2 (M ) , τ and the geometry of M (but not on the particular solution β(x, t)). Remark. An important consequence of this lemma that we shall use repeatedly in the sequel is that from the estimates we can infer convergence results. In fact, the Arzela–Ascoli theorem implies that any sequence (fn ) that is bounded in the H¨ older space C α (M ) for some 0 < α < 1 contains a subsequence that converges in C α (M ), for any α < α. See [167] for details. Proof. From (3.6.5), β(·, t)L2 (M ) ≤ β0 L2 (M) .
(3.6.11)
∂ From (3.6.9) with s = t, we see that ∂t β(·, t)L2 (M) is nonincreasing in time. The regularity results then follow from Theorem A.3.2 of the Appendix.
We can now deduce the global existence of solutions of (3.6.1): Corollary 3.6.3. Let β0 ∈ C 2,α for some 0 < α < 1. Then the solution β(x, t) of (3.6.1) with those initial values exists for all t ≥ 0. Proof. By local existence (Lemma 3.6.1), the solution exists on some positive time interval 0 ≤ t < . Whenever it exists on some interval 0 ≤ t ≤ T , for t → T , by Lemma 3.6.3, β(x, t) converges to some form beta(x, T ) in C 2,α for 0 < α < α. Applying the semigroup property (Corollary 3.6.1) and local existence (Lemma 3.6.1) again, the solution can be continued to some time interval beyond T , that is, it exists for 0 ≤ t < T + . Thus, the existence interval is open and closed and nonempty and therefore consists of the entire positive real line. The final step in the program is the asymptotic behavior of solutions as t → ∞. With this, we shall complete the proof of Theorem 3.6.1 (Milgram–Rosenbloom). Given a p-form β0 (x) on M of class C 2,α , for some 0 < α < 1, there exists a unique solution of ∂β(x, t) + Δβ(x, t) = 0 for all 0 ≤ t < ∞ ∂t with β(x, 0) = β0 (x).
(3.6.12) (3.6.13)
As t → ∞, β(·, t) converges in C 2,α to a harmonic form Hβ. dβ(·, t) = 0. If β0 is closed, i.e., dβ0 = 0, then all the forms β(·, t) are closed as well,
Also, in this case, if ω is a coclosed (d − p)-form, i.e. d∗ ω = 0, then M β(x, t) ∧ ω(x) does not depend on t, and we have M Hβ(x) ∧ ω(x) = M β0 (x) ∧ ω(x).
3.6 The Heat Flow and Harmonic Forms
127
This result obviously contains the Hodge theorem (Theorem 3.4.1) and provides an alternative proof of it. Proof. Since E(β(·, t)) ≥ 0, (3.6.5) implies that there exists at least some sequence tn → ∞ for which ∂ β(·, tn ) → 0. (3.6.14) ∂t The control of the higher norms of β(·, tn ) of Lemma 3.6.3 then implies that ∂ β(·, tn ) converges to 0 in some H¨older space C 2,α , that is, β(·, tn ) Δβ(·, tn ) = − ∂t converges in C 2,α to a harmonic form Hβ. The difference β1 (x, t) := β(x, t) − Hβ(x) then also solves (3.6.12). Using (3.6.14) and (3.6.5) once more, we see that β(·, t) − Hβ(·) → 0 as t → ∞, and by Lemma 3.6.3, β(x, t) converges to Hβ(x) in C 2,α . Uniqueness was already deduced in Corollary 3.6.1. Since the exterior derivative d commutes with the Laplacian Δ as is clear from the ∂ definition of the latter and obviously also with ∂t , if β(x, t) solves (3.6.12), then so does dβ(x, t). Thus, using e.g. (3.6.5) again, if dβ0 = 0, then also dβ(·, t) = 0. Finally, if also d∗ ω = 0, then ∂ β(x, t) ∧ ω(x) = − Δβ(x, t) ∧ ω(x) ∂t M M dd∗ β(x, t) ∧ ω(x) = − d∗ β(x, t) ∧ d∗ ω(x) = 0. =− M
M
The heat flow method can also conveniently deduce some refinements of this theorem. We observe Lemma 3.6.4. Under the assumptions of Theorem 3.6.1, the solution β(x, t) of (3.6.1) converges exponentially towards the harmonic form Hβ0 (x), that is, β(·, t) − Hβ0 (·) ≤ ce−λt
(3.6.15)
for some positive constants c, λ. Here, λ is independent of β. Proof. Given t > 0, we seek β with β = 1 and Hβ = 0 for which for the solution β(x, t) of (3.6.1) with initial values β(x, 0) = β(x), β(·, t) is maximal. Since, by Lemma 3.6.3, the C 1,α -norm of β(·, t) is bounded in terms of β(·, 0), this maximum is attained. Let this maximal value be b(t). Since Hβ = 0,
128
Chapter 3 The Laplace Operator and Harmonic Differential Forms
(3.6.5) must be strictly negative. This implies b(t) < 1. The semigroup property of Corollary 3.6.1 then implies b(nt) ≤ b(t)n for n ∈ N, from which
b(t) ≤ e−λt for some λ > 0.
Therefore, for general β(x, 0) ∈ L2 , we obtain (3.6.15). We can then show Corollary 3.6.4. The equation Δν = η
(3.6.16)
2
for a p-form η of class L is solvable iff (η, ω) = 0 for all ω with Δω = 0.
(3.6.17)
This solution then is unique up to addition of a harmonic form. Therefore, the space of p-forms of class L2 admits the decomposition ΩpL2 (M ) = ker Δ ⊕ image Δ
(3.6.18)
(note that the first summand, the kernel of Δ, is finite dimensional). Proof. We consider ∂ μ + Δμ = γ ∂t μ(·, t) = μ0 .
(3.6.19)
We put Tt μ0 = β(·, t) for the solution of ∂ β + Δβ = 0 ∂t β(·, t) = μ0 .
(3.6.20)
We then have μ(x, t) = Tt μ0 (x) + as γ does not depend on t. By (3.6.15), we have
0
t
Tt−s γ(x)ds = Tt μ0 (x) +
Ts γ − Hγ ≤ e−λs
0
t
Ts γ(x)ds
(3.6.21)
Exercises for Chapter 3
129
whence
μ − tHγ − Tt μ0 ≤
t
e−λs ds.
0
We conclude that ν(x) := lim (μ(x, t) − tHγ(x)) t→∞
2
exists, in L and then also in C (
2,α
, by the estimates. Since ΔHγ = 0, we have
∂ + Δ)(μ(x, t) − tHγ(x)) = η(x) − Hη(x). ∂t
Therefore, Δν = η − Hη. This implies the solvability of (3.6.16) under the condition (3.6.17) because η − Hη is the projection onto the L2 -orthogonal complement of the kernel of Δ.
Exercises for Chapter 3 1. Compute the Laplace operator of S n on p-forms (0 ≤ p ≤ n) in the coordinates given in §1.1. 2. Let ω ∈ Ω1 (S 2 ) be a 1-form on S 2 . Suppose ϕ∗ ω = ω for all ϕ ∈ SO(3). Show that ω ≡ 0. Formulate and prove a general result for invariant differential forms on S n . 3. Give a detailed proof of the formula ∗Δ = Δ ∗ . 4. Let M be a two-dimensional Riemannian manifold. Let the metric be given by gij (x)dxi ⊗ dxj in local coordinates (x1 , x2 ). Compute the Laplace operator on 1-forms in these coordinates. Discuss the case where gij (x) = λ2 (x)δij with a positive function λ2 (x). 5. Suppose that α ∈ Hp1,2 (M ) satisfies (d∗ α, d∗ ϕ) + (dα, dϕ) = (η, ϕ)
for all ϕ ∈ Ωp (M ),
with some given η ∈ Ωp (M ). Show α ∈ Ωp (M ), i.e. smoothness of α.
130
Chapter 3 The Laplace Operator and Harmonic Differential Forms
6. Compute a relation between the Laplace operators on functions on Rn+1 and the one on S n ⊂ Rn+1 . 7. The considerations of the spectrum of the Laplace–Beltrami operator on functions as given in Section 3.2 can be extended to differential forms, as briefly described and utilized in Section 3.3. The present exercise leads you to the systematic derivation of these results. Thus, let M be a compact oriented Riemannian manifold, and let Δ be the Laplace operator on Ωp (M ). λ ∈ R is called an eigenvalue if there exists some u ∈ Ωp (M ), u = 0, with Δu = λu. Such a u is called an eigenform or an eigenvector corresponding to λ. The vector space spanned by the eigenforms for λ is denoted by Vλ and called the eigenspace for λ. Show: a: All eigenvalues of Δ are nonnegative. b: All eigenspaces are finite dimensional. c: The eigenvalues have no finite accumulation point. d: Eigenvectors for different eigenvalues are orthogonal. As in Section 3.2, the next results need a little more analysis (cf. e.g. [167]). e: There exist infinitely many eigenvalues λ1 ≤ λ2 ≤ . . . ≤ λn ≤ . . . f: All eigenvectors of Δ are smooth. g: The eigenvectors of Δ constitute an L2 -orthonormal basis for the space of p-forms of class L2 . 8. Here is another long exercise: Let M be a compact oriented Riemannian manifold with boundary ∂M = ∅. For x ∈ ∂M, V ∈ Tx M is called tangential if it is contained in Tx ∂M ⊂ Tx M and W ∈ Tx M is called normal if V, W = 0 for all tangential
V.
An arbitrary Z ∈ Tx M can then be decomposed into a tangential and a normal component: Z = Ztan + Znor . Analogously, η ∈ Γp (T x , M ) can be decomposed into η = ηtan + ηnor
Exercises for Chapter 3
131
where ηtan operates on tangential p-vectors and ηnor on normal ones. For p-forms ω on M, we may impose the so-called absolute boundary conditions ωtan (δω)nor
= 0, = 0,
on ∂M,
= 0, = 0,
on ∂M.
or the relative boundary conditions ωnor (dω)nor
(These two boundary conditions are interchanged by the ∗-operator.) Develop a Hodge theory under either set of boundary conditions.
•
Chapter 4
Connections and Curvature
4.1
Connections in Vector Bundles
Let X be a vector field on Rd , V a vector at x0 ∈ Rd . We want to analyze how one takes the derivative of X at x0 in the direction V. For this derivative, one forms lim
t→0
X(x0 + tV ) − X(x0 ) . t
Thus, one first adds the vector tV to the point x0 . Next, one compares the vector X(x0 + tV ) at the point x0 + tV and the vector X(x0 ) at x0 ; more precisely, one subtracts the second vector from the first one. Division by t and taking the limit then are obvious steps. A vector field on Rd is a section of the tangent bundle T (Rd ). Thus, X(x0 + tV ) lies in Tx0 +tV (Rd ), while X(x0 ) lies in Tx0 (Rd ). The two vectors are contained in different spaces, and in order to subtract the second one from the first one, one needs to identify these spaces. In Rd , this is easy. Namely, for each x ∈ Rd , Tx Rd can be canonically identified with T0 Rd ∼ = Rd . For this, one uses Euclidean coordinates ∂ ∂ and identifies the tangent vector ∂xi at x with ∂x i at 0. This identification is even expressed by the notation. The reason why it is canonical is simply that the Euclidean coordinates of Rd can be obtained in a geometric manner. For this, let c(t) = tx, t ∈ [0, 1] be the straight line joining 0 and x. For a vector X1 at x, let Xt be the vector at c(t) parallel to X1 ; in particular, Xt has the same length as X1 and forms the same angle with c. ˙ X0 then is the vector at 0 that gets identified with X1 . The advantage of the preceding geometric description lies in the fact that X1 and X0 are connected through a continuous geometric process. Again, this process in Rd has to be considered as canonical.
J. Jost, Riemannian Geometry and Geometric Analysis, Universitext, c Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2011 DOI 10.1007/978-3-642-21298-7 4,
134
Chapter 4
Connections and Curvature
On a manifold, in general there is no canonical method anymore for identifying tangent spaces at different points, or, more generally fibers of a vector bundle at different points. For example, on a general manifold, we don’t have canonical coordinates. Thus, we have to expect that a notion of derivative for sections of a vector bundle, for example for vector fields, has to depend on certain choices. Definition 4.1.1. Let M be a differentiable manifold, E a vector bundle over M. A covariant derivative, or equivalently, a (linear) connection is a map D : Γ(E) → Γ(E) ⊗ Γ(T ∗ M ) with the properties subsequently listed: By property (i) below, we may also consider D as a map from Γ(T M ) ⊗ Γ(E) to Γ(E) and write for σ ∈ Γ(E), V ∈ Tx M Dσ(V ) =: DV σ. We then require: (i) D is tensorial in V : for V, W ∈ Tx M, σ ∈ Γ(E),
DV +W σ = DV σ + DW σ DfV σ = f DV σ
∞
(4.1.1)
for f ∈ C (M, R), V ∈ Γ(T M ).
(4.1.2)
for V ∈ Tx M, σ, τ ∈ Γ(E)
(4.1.3)
(ii) D is R-linear in σ : DV (σ + τ ) = DV σ + DV τ
and it satisfies the following product rule: DV (f σ) = V (f ) · σ + f DV σ
for f ∈ C ∞ (M, R).
(4.1.4)
Of course, all these properties are satisfied for the differentiation of a vector field in Rd as described; in that case, we have DV X = dX(V ). Let x0 ∈ M, and let U be an open neighborhood of x0 such that a chart for M and a bundle chart for E are defined on U. We thus obtain coordinate vector fields ∂ ∂ ∂x1 , . . . , ∂xd , and through the identification E|U ∼ = U × Rn
(n = fiber dimension of E),
a basis of Rn yields a basis μ1 , . . . , μn of sections of E|U . For a connection D, we define the so-called Christoffel symbols Γkij (j, k = 1, . . . , n, i = 1, . . . , d) by D
∂ ∂xi
μj =: Γkij μk .
(4.1.5)
We shall see below that the Christoffel symbols as defined here are a generalization of those introduced in §1.4.
4.1 Connections in Vector Bundles
135
Let now μ ∈ Γ(E); locally, we write μ(y) = ak (y)μk (y). Also let c(t) be a smooth curve in U. Putting μ(t) := μ(c(t)), we define a section of E along c. Furthermore, let d ∂ V (t) = c(t)(:= ˙ c(t)) = c˙i (t) ∂x i. dt Then by (4.1.1) – (4.1.5) DV (t) μ(t) = a˙ k (t)μk (c(t)) + c˙i (t)ak (t)D k
i
= a˙ (t)μk (c(t)) + c˙ (t)a
k
∂ ∂xi
μk
(t)Γjik (c(t))μj (c(t)).
(4.1.6)
˙ = X, (In particular, DX μ depends only on the values of μ along a curve c with c(0) and not on all the values of μ in a neighborhood of the base point of X.) DV (t) μ(t) = 0 thus represents a linear system of first order ODEs for the coefficients a1 (t), . . . , an (t) of μ(t). Therefore, for given initial values μ(0) ∈ Ec(0) , there exists a unique solution of DV (t) μ(t) = 0 .
(4.1.7)
Definition 4.1.2. The solution μ(t) of (4.1.7) is called the parallel transport of μ(0) along the curve c. Thus, if x0 and x1 are points in M, the fibers of E above x0 and x1 , Ex0 and Ex1 , resp., can be identified by choosing a curve c from x0 to x1 (x0 = c(0), x1 = c(1)) and moving each μ0 ∈ Ex0 along c to Ex1 by parallel transport. This identification depends only on the choice of the curve c. One might now try to select geodesics w.r.t. a Riemannian metric as canonical curves, but those are in general not uniquely determined by their endpoints. From parallel transport on a Riemannian manifold, i.e. the identification of the fibers of a vector bundle along curves, one may obtain a notion of covariant derivative. For this purpose, given V ∈ Tx M, let c be a curve in M with c(0) = x, c(0) ˙ = V. For μ ∈ Γ(E), we then put DV μ := lim
t→0
Pc,t (μ(c(t))) − μ(c(0)) , t
where Pc,t : Ec(t) → Ec(0) is the identification by parallel transport along c. In order to see that the two processes of covariant derivative and parallel transport are equivalent, we select a basis of parallel sections μ1 (t), . . . , μn (t) of E along c, i.e. Dc(t) ˙ μj (t) = 0
for j = 1, . . . , n.
(4.1.8)
An arbitrary section μ of E along c is then written as μ(t) = ak (t)μk (t), and for X = c(0), ˙ we have DX μ(t) = a˙ k (t)μk (t)
by (4.1.6), (4.1.8)
(4.1.9)
136
Chapter 4
Connections and Curvature
and consequently, ak (t) − ak (0) μk (0) t→0 t Pc,t (μ(t)) − μ(0) . = lim t→0 t
(DX μ)(c(0)) = lim
It is important to remark that this does not depend on the choice of the curve c, as long as c(0) ˙ = X. We want to explain the term “connection”. We consider the tangent space at the point ψ to the total space E of a vector bundle, Tψ E. Inside Tψ E, there is a distinguished subspace, namely the tangent space to the fiber Ex containing ψ (x = π(ψ)). This space is called vertical space Vψ . However, there is no distinguished “horizontal space” Hψ complementary to Vψ , i.e. satisfying Tψ E = Vψ ⊕ Hψ . If we have a covariant derivative D, however, we can parallely transport ψ for each X ∈ Tx M along a curve c(t) with c(0) = x, c(0) ˙ = X. Thus, for each X, we obtain a curve ψ(t) in E. The subspace of Tψ E spanned by all tangent vectors to E at ψ of the form d ψ(t)|t=0 dt then is the horizontal space Hψ . In this manner, one obtains a rule for how the fibers in neighboring points are “connected” with each other. We return to (4.1.6), i.e. Dc˙i (t)
∂ ∂xi
(aj (t)μj (c(t)))
= a˙ j (t)μj (c(t)) + c˙i (t)aj (t)Γkij (c(t))μk (c(t)).
(4.1.10)
Here, ∂aj (c(t)). (4.1.11) ∂xi This part thus is completely independent of D. Γkij now has indices j and k, running from 1 to n, and an index running from ∂ 1 to d. The index i describes the application of the tangent vector c˙i (t) ∂x i . We thus k consider (Γij )i,j,k as an (n × n)-matrix valued 1-form on U : a˙ j (t) = c˙i (t)
(Γkij )i,j,k ∈ Γ(gl(n, R) ⊗ T ∗ M|U ).
(4.1.12)
(Here, gl(n, R) is the space of (n × n)-matrices with real coefficients.) In a more abstract manner, we now write on U D = d + A,
(4.1.13)
where d is an exterior derivative and A ∈ Γ(gl(n, R) ⊗ T ∗ M|U ). Of course, A can also be considered as an (n × n)-matrix with values in sections of the cotangent bundle ∂ k of M ; A, applied to the tangent vector ∂x i , becomes (Γij )j,k=1,...,n . By (4.1.10), the j application of A to a μj is given by ordinary matrix multiplication. Once more: D(aj μj ) = d(aj )μj + aj Aμj ,
(4.1.14)
4.1 Connections in Vector Bundles
137
where A is a matrix with values in T ∗ M. We now want to study the transformation behavior of A. As in §2.1, let (Uα )α∈A be a covering of M by open sets over which the bundle is trivial, with transition maps ϕβα : Uα ∩ Uβ → Gl (n, R). D then defines a T ∗ M -valued matrix Aα on Uα . Let the section μ be represented by μα on Uα . Here, a Greek index is not a coordinate index, but refers to the chosen covering (Uα ). Thus, (4.1.15) μβ = ϕβα μα on Uα ∩ Uβ . But then we must also have ϕβα (d + Aα )μα = (d + Aβ )μβ on Uα ∩ Uβ ;
(4.1.16)
on the left-hand side we have first computed Dμ in the trivialization defined by the Uα and then transformed the result to the trivialization defined by Uβ , while on the right-hand side, we have directly expressed Dμ in the latter trivialization. We obtain −1 Aα = ϕ−1 (4.1.17) βα dϕβα + ϕβα Aβ ϕβα . This formula gives the desired transformation behavior. Thus, Aα does not transform as a tensor (see the discussion following Definition 2.1.10), because of the term ϕ−1 βα dϕβα . However, the difference of two connections transforms as a tensor. The space of all connections on a given vector bundle E thus is an affine space. The difference of two connections D1 , D2 is a gl(n, R)-valued 1-form, i.e. D1 − D2 ∈ Γ(End E ⊗ T ∗ M ), considering gl(n, R) as the space of linear endomorphisms of the fibers. We return to our fixed neighborhood U and thus drop the index α. We want to extend D from E to other bundles associated with E, in particular to E ∗ and End(E) = E ⊗ E ∗ . We now write Aμj = Akj μk , (4.1.18) where each Akj now is a 1-form, Akj = Γkij dxi . Let μ∗1 , . . . , μ∗n be the basis dual to μ1 , . . . , μn on the bundle E ∗ dual to E, i.e. (μi , μ∗j ) = δij ,
(4.1.19)
where (·, ·) : E ⊗ E ∗ → R is the bilinear pairing between E and E ∗ . Definition 4.1.3. Let D be a connection on E. The connection D∗ dual to D on the dual bundle E ∗ is defined by the requirement d(μ, ν ∗ ) = (Dμ, ν ∗ ) + (μ, D ∗ ν ∗ )
(4.1.20)
for any μ ∈ Γ(E), ν ∗ ∈ Γ(E ∗ ). (Dμ ∈ Γ(E ⊗ T ∗ M ), and (Dμ, ν ∗ ) pairs the E-factor of Dμ with ν ∗ . Thus (Dμ, ν ∗ ), and similarly (μ, D∗ ν ∗ ), is a 1-form.)
138
Chapter 4
Connections and Curvature
As usual, we write D = d + A on U and compute ∗ 0 = d(μi , μ∗j ) = (Aki μk , μ∗j ) + (μi , A∗ j μ )
= Aji + A∗i j
by (4.1.19),
i.e.
Recalling (4.1.5), we get
A∗ = −At .
(4.1.21)
D∗ ∂ μ∗j = −Γjik μ∗k .
(4.1.22)
∂xi
Definition 4.1.4. Let E1 , E2 be vector bundles over M with connections D1 , D2 , resp. The induced connection D on E := E1 ⊗ E2 is defined by the requirement D(μ1 ⊗ μ2 ) = D1 μ1 ⊗ μ2 + μ1 ⊗ D2 μ2
(4.1.23)
for μi ∈ Γ(Ei ), i = 1, 2. In particular, we obtain an induced connection on End (E) = E ⊗ E ∗ , again denoted by D. Let σ = σji μi ⊗ μ∗j be a section of End (E). We compute D(σji μi ⊗ μ∗j ) = dσji μi ⊗ μ∗j + σji Aki μk ⊗ μ∗j − σji Ajk μi ⊗ μ∗k = dσ + [A, σ].
(4.1.24)
The induced connection on End (E) thus operates by taking the Lie bracket. We next want to extend the operation of a connection D from Γ(E) to Γ(E) ⊗ Ωp (M ) (0 ≤ p ≤ d). Since, on Ωp (M ), we have the exterior derivative d, we define in analogy with Definition 4.1.4 for μ ∈ Γ(E), ω ∈ Ωp (M ) D(μ ⊗ ω) = Dμ ∧ ω + μ ⊗ dω.
(4.1.25)
(Here, we have employed a wedge product of forms with values in vector bundles, as Dμ is an element of Γ(E) ⊗ Ω1 (M ): If σ ∈ Γ(E), ω1 ∈ Ω1 (M ), ω2 ∈ Ωp (M ), then (σ ⊗ ω1 ) ∧ ω2 := σ ⊗ (ω1 ∧ ω2 ), and the general case is defined by linear extension.) As an abbreviation, we write Ωp (E) := Γ(E) ⊗ Ωp (M ),
Ωp := Ωp (M ).
Thus D : Ωp (E) → Ωp+1 (E),
0 ≤ p ≤ d.
We want to compare this with the exterior derivative d : Ωp → Ωp+1 . Here, we have d ◦ d = 0. Such a relation, however, in general does not hold anymore for D.
4.1 Connections in Vector Bundles
139
Definition 4.1.5. The curvature of a connection D is the operator F := D ◦ D : Ω0 (E) → Ω2 (E). The connection is called flat, if its curvature satisfies F = 0. The exterior derivative d thus yields a flat connection on the trivial bundle M × R. We compute for μ ∈ Γ(E) F (μ) = (d + A) ◦ (d + A)μ = (d + A)(dμ + Aμ) = (dA)μ − Adμ + Adμ + A ∧ Aμ (the minus sign occurs because A is a 1-form). Thus F = dA + A ∧ A. If we write A = Aj dxj , (4.1.25) becomes ∂Aj dxi ∧ dxj + A A F = i j ∂xi 1 ∂Aj ∂Ai = − + [Ai , Aj ] dxi ∧ dxj 2 ∂xi ∂xj (note that each Aj is an (n × n)-matrix). We now want to compute DF. F is a map from Ω0 (E) to Ω2 (E), i.e. F ∈ Ω2 (E) ⊗ (Ω0 (E))∗ = Ω2 (End E). We thus consider F as a 2-form with values in End E. By (4.1.24) then DF = dF + [A, F ] = dA ∧ A − A ∧ dA + [A, dA + A ∧ A] by (4.1.24) = dA ∧ A − A ∧ dA + A ∧ dA − dA ∧ A + [A, A ∧ A] = [A, A ∧ A] = [Ai dxi , Aj dxj ∧ Ak dxk ] = Ai Aj Ak (dxi ∧ dxj ∧ dxk − dxj ∧ dxk ∧ dxi ) = 0. This is the so-called second Bianchi identity. Theorem 4.1.1. The curvature F of a connection D satisfies DF = 0.
(4.1.26)
(4.1.27)
140
Chapter 4
Connections and Curvature
We now want to study the transformation behavior of F. We use the same covering (Uα )α∈A as above, and on Uα , we write again D = d + Aα , Aα = Aα,i dxi . F then has the corresponding representation 1 ∂Aα,j ∂Aα,i − + [A , A ] dxi ∧ dxj (4.1.28) Fα = α,i α,j 2 ∂xi ∂xj by (4.1.27). Using the transformation formula (4.1.16) for Aα , we see that in the transformation formula for Fα , all derivatives of ϕβα cancel, and we have Fα = ϕ−1 βα Fβ ϕβα .
(4.1.29)
Thus, in contrast to A, F transforms as a tensor. We now want to express F in terms of the Christoffel symbols. In order to make contact with the classical notation, we denote the curvature operator, considered as an element of Ω2 (End E) by R : F : Ω0 (E) → Ω2 (E) μ → R(·, ·)μ, k by and we define the components Rij
R
∂ ∂ , ∂xi ∂xj
k μ = Rij μk
(4.1.30)
(k, ∈ {1, . . . , n}, i, j ∈ {1, . . . , d}). By (4.1.27) R(·, ·)μ = F μ 1 ∂Γkj ∂Γki k m k m = − + Γim Γj − Γjm Γi dxi ∧ dxj ⊗ μk , 2 ∂xi ∂xj
(4.1.31)
i.e. k Rij =
∂Γkj ∂Γki k m − + Γkim Γm j − Γjm Γi . i ∂x ∂xj
(4.1.32)
Theorem 4.1.2. The curvature tensor R of a connection D satisfies R(X, Y )μ = DX DY μ − DY DX μ − D[X,Y ] μ
(4.1.33)
for all vector fields X, Y on M, and all μ ∈ Γ(E). Proof. A direct computation is possible. However, one may also argue more abstractly ∂ ∂ as follows: First, (4.1.33) holds for X = ∂x i , Y = ∂xj . Namely, in this case [X, Y ] = 0, and (4.1.33) follows from (4.1.27).
4.1 Connections in Vector Bundles
141
We have seen already that R transforms as a tensor (the tensorial transformation behavior w.r.t. X, Y also follows from (4.1.27), for example), and thus the value of R(X, Y )μ at the point x depends only on the values of X and Y at x. Now for ∂ j ∂ X = ξ i ∂x i , Y = η ∂xj DX DY μ − DY DX μ = ξ i
∂η j ∂ξ i D ∂ j μ − ηj j D ∂ i μ i ∂x ∂x ∂x ∂x
+ ξiηj D
∂ ∂xi
D
∂ ∂xj
−D
∂ ∂xj
D
∂ ∂xi
μ
and D[X,Y ] μ = D(ξi ∂ηj
∂ ∂xi ∂xj
hence
−η j
DX DY μ − DY DX μ − D[X,Y ] μ = ξ i η j D
∂ξi ∂ ∂xj ∂xi
∂ ∂xi
D
)
μ,
∂ ∂xj
−D
∂ ∂xj
D
∂ ∂xi
μ,
and this has the desired tensorial form. In order to develop the geometric intuition for the curvature tensor, we want ∂ ∂ to consider vector fields X, Y with [X, Y ] = 0, e.g. coordinate vector fields ∂x i , ∂xj . Then R(X, Y ) = DX DY − DY DX . When forming DX DY μ, we first move μ by infinitesimal parallel transport in the direction Y and then in the direction X; when forming DY DX μ, the order is reversed. R(X, Y )μ then expresses the difference in the results of these two operations, or, in other words, the dependence of parallel transport on the chosen path. Corollary 4.1.1. We have R(X, Y ) = −R(Y, X).
(4.1.34)
Proof. From (4.1.33). Corollary 4.1.2.
k k Rij = −Rji ∀ i, j, k, .
Proof. This reformulation of (4.1.34) also follows from (4.1.31). Connections on the tangent bundle T M are particularly important. For such a connection ∇ on T M , the Christoffel symbols are given by ∂ ∂ = Γkij k . (4.1.35) j ∂x ∂x According to Definition 4.1.3, the connection ∇ also induces a connection on the cotangent bundle T M which we again denote by ∇, and which satisfies, by (4.1.22), ∇
∇
∂ ∂xi
∂ ∂xi
dxj = −Γjik dxk .
(4.1.36)
142
Chapter 4
Connections and Curvature
Definition 4.1.6. Let ∇ be a connection on the tangent bundle T M of a differentiable manifold M. A curve c : I → M is called autoparallel or geodesic w.r.t. ∇ if ∇c˙ c˙ ≡ 0,
(4.1.37)
i.e. if the tangent field of c is parallel along c. ∂ In local coordinates, c˙ = c˙ i ∂x i , and
ck + Γkij c˙i c˙ j ) ∇c˙ c˙ = (¨
∂ , ∂xk
(4.1.38)
and the equation for geodesics has the same form as the one in §1.4. The difference is that the Christoffel symbols now have been defined differently. We shall clarify the relation between these two definitions below in §4.3. According to (4.1.38), (4.1.37) is a system of second order ODEs, and thus, as in §1.4, for each x ∈ M, X ∈ Tx M, there exist a maximal interval I = IX ⊂ R with 0 ∈ IX and a geodesic c = cX c:I →M with c(0) = x, c(0) ˙ = X. C := {X ∈ T M : 1 ∈ IX } is a star-shaped neighborhood of the zero section of T M, and as in §1.4, we define an exponential map by exp : C → M X → cX (1). If X ∈ C, 0 ≤ t ≤ 1, then exp(tX) = cX (t). Definition 4.1.7. The torsion tensor of a connection ∇ on T M is defined as T (X, Y ) := T∇ (X, Y ) := ∇X Y − ∇Y X − [X, Y ] ∇ is called torsion free if
T ≡ 0.
(X, Y ∈ Γ(T M )).
(4.1.39) (4.1.40)
Remark. It is not difficult to verify that T is indeed a tensor, i.e. that the value of T (X, Y )(x) only depends on the values of X and Y at the point x. In terms of our local coordinates, the components of the torsion tensor T are given by ∂ ∂ ∂ ∂ ∂ Tij = T = ∇ ∂i , − ∇ ∂j = (Γkij − Γkji ) k . (4.1.41) ∂x ∂xj ∂x ∂xi ∂xi ∂xj ∂x We conclude
4.1 Connections in Vector Bundles
143
Lemma 4.1.1. The connection ∇ on T M is torsion free if and only if Γkij = Γkji
for all i, j, k.
(4.1.42)
Definition 4.1.8. A connection ∇ on T M is called flat if each point in M possesses a neighborhood U with local coordinates for which all the coordinate vector fields ∂y∂ i are parallel, that is, ∂ ∇ i = 0. (4.1.43) ∂y Theorem 4.1.3. A connection ∇ on T M is flat if and only if its curvature and torsion vanish identically. Proof. When the connection is flat, all ∇
∂ ∂xi
∂ ∂xj
= 0, and so, all Christoffel symbols
Γkij = 0, and therefore, also T and R vanish, as they can be expressed in terms of the Γkij . For the converse direction, we shall find local coordinates y for which ∇dy = 0.
(4.1.44)
For such coordinates, the coordinate vector fields
∂ ∂y i
then are covariantly constant,
i.e., satisfy (4.1.43), because (dy , = hence 0 = d(dy j , ∂y∂ i ) = (∇dyj , ∂y∂ i ) + ∂ j j (dy , ∇ ∂yi ) by (4.1.20) and ∇dy = 0 by (4.1.46). j
∂ ∂y i )
δij ,
∂y i For given coordinates, we have dy = ∂x i dx . We shall proceed in two steps. We first construct a covariantly constant (vector valued) 1-form μi dxi , and then show that ∂y the μi can be represented as derivatives, μi = ∂x i . For the first step, we shall use the vanishing of the curvature, and for the second, the vanishing of the torsion. In both steps, the decisive ingredient will be the theorem of Frobenius. The equation for the first step, ∇μi dxi = 0 (4.1.45)
by (4.1.36) is equivalent to the system ∂ μi + Γkji μk = 0 ∂xj
for all i, j.
(4.1.46)
In vector notation, this becomes ∂ μ + Γj μ = 0, ∂xj
(4.1.47)
and by the theorem of Frobenius, this can be solved if and only if the integrability condition ∂ ∂ Γi = 0 (4.1.48) [Γi , Γj ] + i Γj − ∂x ∂xj
144
Chapter 4
Connections and Curvature
holds for all i, j. With indices, this is ∂Γkj ∂Γki k m − + Γkim Γm j − Γjm Γi = 0 ∂xi ∂xj
for all i, j,
(4.1.49)
which by equation (4.1.32) means that the curvature tensor vanishes. We can thus solve (4.1.46) for the μi . ∂y For the second step, i.e., to check that these μi are derivatives ∂x i , the necessary and sufficient condition (again, by the theorem of Frobenius) is ∂ ∂ μj = μi ∂xi ∂xj
for all i, j,
(4.1.50)
which by (4.1.46) in turn is equivalent to the condition Γkij = Γkji for all i, j, k, that is, by Lemma 4.1.1, the vanishing of the torsion T . This completes the proof. Perspectives. Ehresmann was the first to arrive at the correct concept of a connection in a vector bundle. Equivalently, the concept may also be introduced in a principal bundle (see the discussion at the end of §2.3). The theory of connections is systematically explored in [191, 192]. The curvature tensor introduced here generalizes the Riemann curvature tensor derived from a Riemannian metric in §4.3 below. The Bianchi identity (Theorem 4.1.1) may be derived in a more conceptual way as the infinitesimal version of the equivariance of the curvature form F with respect to certain transformations in horizontal directions, see [253]. For a more detailed and elementary discussion of integrability conditions and the Frobenius theorem, we refer to [93].
4.2
Metric Connections. The Yang–Mills Functional
Definition 4.2.1. Let E be a vector bundle on the differentiable manifold M with bundle metric ·, ·. A connection D on E is called metric if dμ, ν = Dμ, ν + μ, Dν for all μ, ν ∈ Γ(E).
(4.2.1)
A metric connection thus has to respect an additional structure, namely the metric. We want to interpret condition (4.2.1). Let X ∈ Tx M ; (4.2.1) then means Xμ, ν = DX μ, ν + μ, DX ν.
(4.2.2)
Let now c : I → M be a smooth curve, and let μ(t) and ν(t) be parallel along c, i.e. Dc˙ μ = 0 = Dc˙ ν. Then from (4.2.2) d μ(t), ν(t) = 0. dt This can be interpreted as follows:
(4.2.3)
4.2 Metric Connections. The Yang–Mills Functional
145
Lemma 4.2.1. The parallel transport induced by a metric connection on a vector bundle preserves the bundle metric in the sense that parallel transport constitutes an isometry of the corresponding fibers. Namely, (4.2.3) means that the scalar product is preserved under parallel transport. Lemma 4.2.2. Let D be a metric connection on the vector bundle E with bundle metric ·, ·. Assume that w.r.t. a metric bundle chart (cf. Definition 2.1.12 and Theorem 2.1.3), we have the decomposition D = d + A. Then for any X ∈ T M, the matrix A(X) is skew symmetric, i.e. A(X) ∈ o(n)
(= Lie algebra of O(n))
(n = rank of E).
Proof. As described in Theorem 2.1.3, a metric bundle chart (f, U ) generates sections μ1 , . . . , μn on U that form an orthonormal basis of the fiber Ex at each x ∈ U , i.e. μi (x), μj (x) = δij . Moreover, since the μi are constant in the bundle chart, we have for the exterior derivative d defined by the chart dμi ≡ 0
(i = 1, . . . , n).
Let now X ∈ Tx M, x ∈ U. It follows that 0 = Xμi , μj = A(X)μi , μj + μi , A(X)μj = A(X)ki μk , μj + μi , A(X)kj μk = A(X)ji + A(X)ij .
By Ωp (Ad E), we denote the space of those elements of Ωp (End E) for which the endomorphism of each fiber is skew symmetric. Thus, if D = d + A is a metric connection, we have A ∈ Ω1 (Ad E). We define
D∗ : Ωp (Ad E) → Ωp−1 (Ad E)
146
Chapter 4
Connections and Curvature
as the operator dual to D : Ωp−1 (Ad E) → Ωp (Ad E) w.r.t. (·, ·); thus (D∗ ν, μ) = (ν, Dμ)
for all μ ∈ Ωp−1 (Ad E), ν ∈ Ωp (Ad E).
(4.2.4)
This is in complete analogy with the definition of d∗ in §3.3. Indeed, for D = d+A (A ∈ Ω1 (Ad E)), A = Ai dxi (ν, dμ + Ai dxi ∧ μ) = (d