Richard Titmuss Welfare and Society Second Edition
David Reisman
Richard Titmuss
Also by David Reisman ADAM SMITH’S...
35 downloads
1209 Views
788KB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Richard Titmuss Welfare and Society Second Edition
David Reisman
Richard Titmuss
Also by David Reisman ADAM SMITH’S SOCIOLOGICAL ECONOMICS ALFRED MARSHALL: Progress and Politics ALFRED MARSHALL’S MISSION ANTHONY CROSLAND: The Mixed Economy CONSERVATIVE CAPITALISM: The Social Economy CROSLAND’S FUTURE: Opportunity and Outcome THE ECONOMICS OF ALFRED MARSHALL GALBRAITH AND MARKET CAPITALISM MARKET AND HEALTH THE POLITICAL ECONOMY OF HEALTH CARE THE POLITICAL ECONOMY OF JAMES BUCHANAN STATE AND WELFARE: Tawney, Galbraith and Adam Smith THEORIES OF COLLECTIVE ACTION: Downs, Olson and Hirsch
Richard Titmuss Welfare and Society David Reisman
Second Edition
© David Reisman 1977, 2001 All rights reserved. No reproduction, copy or transmission of this publication may be made without written permission. No paragraph of this publication may be reproduced, copied or transmitted save with written permission or in accordance with the provisions of the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988, or under the terms of any licence permitting limited copying issued by the Copyright Licensing Agency, 90 Tottenham Court Road, London W1P 0LP. Any person who does any unauthorised act in relation to this publication may be liable to criminal prosecution and civil claims for damages. The author has asserted his right to be identified as the author of this work in accordance with the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988. First edition published 1977 by Heinemann Educational Books Second edition published 2001 by PALGRAVE Houndmills, Basingstoke, Hampshire RG21 6XS and 175 Fifth Avenue, New York, N. Y. 10010 Companies and representatives throughout the world PALGRAVE is the new global academic imprint of St. Martin’s Press LLC Scholarly and Reference Division and Palgrave Publishers Ltd (formerly Macmillan Press Ltd). ISBN 0–333–80050–8 This book is printed on paper suitable for recycling and made from fully managed and sustained forest sources. A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Reisman, David A. Richard Titmuss : welfare and society / David Reisman.—2nd ed. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 0–333–80050–8 1. Social policy. 2. Public welfare. 3. Welfare state. 4. Titmuss, Richard Morris, 1907–1973. I. Title. HN16 .R44 2001 361.6’1—dc21 2001021633 10 10
9 09
8 08
7 07
6 06
5 05
4 04
3 03
Printed and bound in Great Britain by Antony Rowe Ltd, Chippenham, Wiltshire
2 02
1 01
Contents Acknowledgements 1
vii
Introduction
1
PART ONE: The Status of Social Policy 2
The Definition of Social Policy
29
3
Some Methodological Considerations
43
4
Part One: Evaluations and Extensions
52
(a) The Sub-Division of Welfare (b) The Origins of Welfare
53 72
PART TWO: Selectivity 5
Stigma
91
6
Part Two: Evaluations and Extensions
98
PART THREE: Universalism 7
Universalism I: Social Costs and Social Benefits
113
8
Universalism II: Integration and Involvement
123
9
Universalism III: Planned Redistribution
137
10
Part Three: Evaluations and Extensions
158
(a) (b) (c) (d)
159 174 181 189
Externalities Blood Community Legitimation
PART FOUR: The Failure of the Market 11
The Failure of the Market I: Quality
203
12
The Failure of the Market II: Choice
217
13
The Failure of the Market III: Quantity
230
v
vi
Contents
14
The Failure of the Market IV: Price
237
15
Part Four: Evaluations and Extensions
241
(a) (b) (c) (d)
243 246 253 261
16
Scarcity Choice Growth Pattern Maintenance
Conclusion
269
(a) Social Science and Social Philosophy (b) The Importance of Social Theory
270 273
Abbreviations of Books by R.M. Titmuss
277
Notes
278
Index
300
Acknowledgements The author and publishers are grateful to Ann Oakley for permission to quote from the publications and unpublished papers of Richard Titmuss. They would also like to thank the staff of the Archives Section of the British Library of Political and Economic Science for their assistance.
vii
This page intentionally left blank
1 Introduction
Richard Morris Titmuss was appointed Professor of Social Administration at the London School of Economics in 1950. He was not the architect of the modern British social services state, but he soon made himself its ideologue, although as much its critic as its advocate. His impact on the intellectual underpinnings of welfare and society in the complacent and consensual Britain that came in with Attlee and Bevan and went out with the Thatcherites and the Monetarists simply cannot be underestimated. In the words of Ann Oakley: The post-war period was a brave new world to many. It was one with which Richard Titmuss was intimately associated. He influenced the manner in which the welfare state evolved and was understood, not only in Britain, but as a model to be emulated and improved on by other countries. The Labour Party in the 1950s, ’60s and ’70s, particularly its social security and pension plans, would not have been the same without him.1 Nor, as Robert Pinker states, would the academic discipline of social policy: ‘Few scholars have so dominated the development of an academic subject over so long a period . . . He was one of those rare thinkers who are able to shift the whole focus of debate in a field of study.’2 David Donnison, drawing the balance both of the socialism and of the scholarship, was right to return the following verdict at the time of Titmuss’s early death: ‘For years to come, political parties and governments in many parts of the world will find themselves using his ideas or responding to the prodding of his disciples.’3 That is also the verdict of the present book. 1
2
Richard Titmuss
The Eleanor Rathbone Memorial Lecture of 1955 contained the manifesto. In ‘The Social Division of Welfare’ (published in 1956 and best known from the 1958 Essays) Titmuss sought to widen the discussion of social welfare by situating public services in cash and kind in the framework of a general matrix of privileges (not least fiscal and occupational welfare) and values (most of all, community, integration and equality). Brian Abel-Smith and Kay Titmuss called it ‘perhaps the most influential piece he ever wrote’.4 Pinker has this to say about the 1955 milestone and the work that was to come: ‘In his seminal essay, “The Social Division of Welfare”, Titmuss broke through the then conventional and narrow definitions of social policy . . . By focusing upon aims rather than administrative procedures, he brought a new analytical dimension to his subject.’5 It was an analytic that was to impart a remarkable consistency of outlook to the books and papers that he produced while a professor at the LSE. His main publications in the years in which his thinking solidified into his mature analytic were Essays on ‘The Welfare State’ (1958) (republished in 1963 to include a revised version of his 1959 Fabian Tract on The Irresponsible Society), Income Distribution and Social Change (1962), Commitment to Welfare (1968), The Gift Relationship (1970) and Social Policy (1974). The last-named is a posthumously published set of lecture notes, edited by Brian AbelSmith and Kay Titmuss, which he had used in the University of London. Titmuss was also the co-author of three influential studies of more specialised interest: The Cost of the National Health Service in England and Wales (1956) (with Brian Abel-Smith), Social Policies and Population Growth in Mauritius (1961) (with Brian Abel-Smith and Tony Lynes) and The Health Services of Tanganyika (1964) (with Brian Abel-Smith, George Macdonald, Arthur Williams and Christopher Ward). All of this was foreshadowed by his monumental Problems of Social Policy (1950) – his panoramic study of the human costs of war and the unified nationhood that the bombing, the evacuation and the homelessness had produced – that Pinker with good reason describes as ‘still his masterpiece’.6 Titmuss’s analytic reached its maturity in the LSE quarter-century of ‘you’ve never had it so good’, Keynesian full employment, partypolitical Butskellism and the National Health. His formative years, however, had been those of inter-war unemployment, the Jarrow marches, the exhaustion of benefits, the public-spending cuts of Sir Eric Geddes which in 1922 had put macroeconomics before ‘homes fit for heroes’, the Public Assistance administrators (replacing the
Introduction
3
Poor Law guardians in 1929) who regularly means-tested the hungry by asking them how they had found the money for a new coat. No one understands Titmuss who forgets the Depression or who fails to read the books and papers which, antedating the Problems of Social Policy by a decade and more, give a clear picture of a Toynbee-like quester driven by his conscience to harness empiricism in the service of compassion. Of particular importance are Poverty and Population (1938), Our Food Problem (1939) (with F. Le Gros Clark), Parents Revolt (1942) (with Kay Titmuss), Birth, Poverty and Wealth (1943) and Report on Luton (1945) (with F. Grundy). These early books are hardly the contributions that Hilary Rose had in mind when she refers to Titmuss as a ‘central figure’ in policy studies, a thinker ‘whose work was to dominate social policy until his premature death in 1973’.7 What these early books do reveal is, however, the inception of a lifetime search to combine Tawney-like moral passion with the careful scientific research which the Webbs had made the precondition for social reform. The Problems and ‘The Social Division’ were to herald the emergence of a more sophisticated analytic. Even so, the Titmuss of 1938 is recognisably the same Toynbee-like quester as the Titmuss of 1970. The continuity comes as no surprise – since there is little in Titmuss’s considerable body of work that is not, as Wilding points out, deeply embedded in his own moral values: ‘They are implicit in nearly all he wrote, and they remain remarkably constant and consistent.’8 Titmuss’s moral values prescribed the track and the direction. One consequence is an intellectual system which was built to last. Titmuss was a systemic thinker who, in Wilding’s words, sought to generalise from the particular and to apply the all-embracing: In all he wrote, Titmuss was concerned with direct and immediate social policy issues. At the same time, he was also concerned with fundamental questions – the nature of the good society, the nature of social obligation, and the nature of social policy. His concerns and his ideas ranged widely as he moved from the particular to the general and from the general to the particular.9 Wilding in 1995 was able to recognise the macrosocial frame of reference which unifies the body of Titmuss’s work. In 1976, interestingly, he himself had denied its existence: ‘Titmuss was not a theorist . . . He was suspicious of attempts to construct broad, general theories of social policy development or the roles and functions
4
Richard Titmuss
of social services.’10 Mishra implicitly makes the same point when he complains that the theorists of the middle ground have allowed themselves to become stranded in a morass of piecemealism, pragmatism and eclecticism which in effect leaves them without a compass or a map to release them from the tyranny of the reactive ad hoc: ‘It is indeed something of a paradox that over three decades of successful welfare statism has not produced a “Centrist” theory of the mixed system comparable to the analytical perspectives of the market liberals and the Marxists.’11 While a word like ‘comparable’ must inevitably open the door to debate, this much at least is beyond dispute: Richard Titmuss developed a valuable intellectual system and is well deserving of the credit that is due to a genuinely innovative mind. It is appreciation of a kind that he has not always received. Richard Titmuss was an original, creative and sensitive thinker whose work has not always won the understanding it deserves. Titmuss is a difficult author, partly because he was more likely to write essays than book-length monographs (even a major book like Commitment to Welfare turns out to be a collection of separate essays), partly because so many of his occasional papers were the response to invitations (often to speak at international conferences on topics chosen for him by the organisers), partly because he never saw the need to make his underlying system fully explicit (in the obvious sense that he never set out to write a textbook, coherent and comprehensive). Abel-Smith and Kay Titmuss conjecture that he might later have wanted to produce his magisterial synthesis on Principles: ‘Perhaps, if he had lived longer, he would have brought it together in a different way. But sadly he did not.’ 12 One purpose of the present book is to reconstruct the system, to reassemble the pieces of the puzzle; and thus to demonstrate that the Titmussian world-view is a unified whole made one by an ambitious attempt to restore the study of welfare to its proper place in the study of society. A second purpose of the present book is to evaluate the system and to note its essential paradox: Titmuss most stressed integration but left certain aspects of his own model incomplete and unintegrated. To some extent, however, such imprecision is bound to be the fate of all those who attempt a science of society. It was not only for himself that Titmuss was speaking when he confessed: ‘The more I try to understand the role of welfare and the human condition the more untidy it all becomes.’13
Introduction
5
Richard Titmuss was born on 16 October 1907, the son of a Bedfordshire small farmer. The farm, near Luton, was broken up under Lloyd George’s scheme for distributing land to soldiers returning from the World War; and in 1918 the family moved to London where Morris Titmuss (first using horses and then lorries) established a small haulage business. The bankruptcy of that business, a sense of personal failure, a resentful wife and a tendency to drink all contributed to his death in 1926, aged only 53. Richard left school in 1921 when he was 14. He attended a sixmonth course in bookkeeping at a local commercial college and then became an office-boy in Standard Telephones and Cables Ltd. After his father’s death he entered the County Fire Insurance Office as a clerk. The contact was made by his mother. Richard, the family breadwinner at the age of 19, came to understand at first hand the burden of dependency: not only did he find himself responsible for an older sister and a younger brother, there was also the problem of the ‘desolate, incapable widow’,14 ‘intensely impractical and nervous’,15 whom Ann Oakley describes with no evident warmth as ‘a fat, self-indulgent, hypochondriachal woman with cow-like brown eyes and limitless demands’.16 Maude Titmuss (née Farr) had married young, and into a less affluent farming family. She never fully reconciled herself to the fact that her husband was only a small farmer become an alcoholic bankrupt. The consequence was that she was both financially and emotionally dependent on her son from 1926 until her death (aged 89) in 1972, only one year before Richard’s own. The financial strain at least was slightly eased when she won a football pool after the Second World War. Within the insurance company, Titmuss rose rapidly to become a London Inspector in 1939 at the early age of 32. He learned about the dependent both as statistics and as case histories, and also acquired an insight into the way in which institutional investors deploy their funds. Moreover, when he finally left County Fire in 1942, he personally fell victim to the exercise of power without responsibility through the loss of 16 years of occupational pension rights. Meanwhile, Richard Titmuss met Kathleen (Kay) Miller in 1934 while on a fortnight’s rambling holiday in North Wales. Middleclass, the daughter of a south London cutlery salesman, she had had more formal education than Richard. Having done a secretarial course, she was able to type his letters and (although there is no evidence of research work as well) the manuscripts of his first four
6
Richard Titmuss
books. When they met she was doing low-paid, untrained social work in London clubs for the unemployed. Distributing clothes and books, mending worn-out jackets, arranging breaks in the country, she was seeing for herself what life without work meant for men and their families. In the Preface to his first book Titmuss wrote as follows about the contribution his helpmate and discussion-partner had made to the development of his social and political awareness: ‘It is my wife, Kay – not only by her part in the publication of this book, but through her work among the unemployed and forgotten men and women of London – who has helped me to visualise the human significance, and often the human tragedy, hidden behind each fact.’ 17 Richard and Kay were married in 1937. He was 29 and she was 33. Both still lived at home. They had one daughter, Ann (Oakley), born in 1944. Later she was to be Professor of Sociology and Social Policy in the University of London, with a special interest in health, education and gender studies. Her books include The Sociology of Housework, Social Support and Motherhood and Housewife, but also novels like The Men’s Room and The Secret Lives of Eleanor Jenkinson. In Taking it like a Woman – ‘a sort of autobiography’18 – and Man and Wife: Richard and Kay Titmuss she has made a valuable contribution to the understanding of her remarkable parents. Ann Oakley, looking back, was struck by the fact that Kay at marriage withdrew from her work in the unemployment centres (the only real job she is known to have had) and to have made Richard’s career her life: ‘Kay and Richard Titmuss were . . . only one couple among many; millions of men were freed for full participation in the world outside the home through the unpaid services of women within it.’19 Throughout their long life together (Kay outlived Richard by 14 years, dying in 1987), Kay was a source of strength and understanding. As Margaret Gowing says in her British Academy essay on Titmuss: ‘He could support the great weight of work and maintain his inner calm because of his happiness at home with Kay. Looking after Richard was her life work.’20 Ann Oakley’s impression of Kay’s self-defined mission is a similar one: ‘Almost the whole of her energy and passion was brought to bear on the task of supporting the idea of her husband as a great man.’21 Acknowledging the intellectual stimulation that the relationship must have meant, the high-powered social circles (from Lord Horder and Tawney to the Archbishop of Canterbury), the garden parties at Buckingham Palace, Ann Oakley none the less expresses the opinion
Introduction
7
that the traditional division of labour left her mother at the end of the day with a certain sense of personal frustration: ‘The fact that he became her work was something she was proud of; but it didn’t give her the same satisfaction as the work she once had which was her own.’22 The rivalry with the neurotic and possessive Maude for Richard’s affections cannot have done much to lift her spirits: at one point she labelled a photograph of Maude in the family album ‘The Evil One’. Nor should it be forgotten that even a dependent woman can be resentful of a controlling husband. However happy the home, however great the love on both sides, the fact is that Richard could be controlling.
The Vancouver Sun in 1966 called Kay a Pied Piper for her husband. Kay herself had a private vision ‘that Richard was her discovery’.23 While there is bound to be some truth in the contention that Richard was ‘Kay-made’24 even as he was self-made – Kay was convinced (others were less confident) that they discussed everything together – it is important to remember that even in the 1930s Richard appears to have been more politically alert than was Kay. A letter from 1935 reveals that Kay had little respect for the political leaders of the time: ‘I thought that if they could have the Christian Gospel in the background as an ideal and work towards that ideal a number of the present difficulties in this country and in fact the world would be more easily solved.’25 Richard, on the other hand, was already convinced that the mixed economy and social reform – neither Marxian class consciousness and revolution nor libertarian laissez-faire and unemployment – were inevitable and that the lead had to be a political one. In that sense he would have been in broad agreement with the two great classics of moderate interventionism that were published while he was at County Fire: Keynes’s General Theory (1936) and Macmillan’s Middle Way (1938). The intellectual high ground seemed to be the preserve of the reforming Liberals. Richard Titmuss joined the Hendon Young Liberals as early as 1932 – welcoming him, the Honorary Secretary observed that ‘liberals are few and far between in Hendon’26 – and was obviously not excessively discouraged by the fact that there had not been a Liberal Government for many years. He also began to attend the Fleet Street Parliament, a debating society meeting every Monday evening at St Bride’s Institute to obtain practice in public speaking. He was critical of County Fire, once calling it
8
Richard Titmuss
‘Inefficiency Limited’.27 He did not hesitate to put his powers of persuasion to good use by campaigning bravely for higher salaries for the County staff. Before Kay as well as after Kay, in other words, Titmuss was looking to leadership and to argumentation for the impulse that would bring into being the Good Society. To that extent the Fabianism was there from the start. So long as Shaw was being photographed with Gorky and the Webbs were writing of Soviet Communism: A New Civilisation, it is clear that Titmuss, social reformer but not economic planner, could not have contemplated a closer association. Publication had to be the next step. In 1936 Titmuss wrote Crime and Tragedy. Its subject was errors in British foreign policy since the Treaty of Versailles; rearmament in Germany and the possibility of war; Hitler’s aggressiveness and the scope for the League of Nations. Because of his position in County Fire, Titmuss used the pseudonym Richard Caston. Kay supplied the pseudonym (Caston, her mother’s maiden name, was her middle name) and an unspecified amount of typing, correcting and rewriting. She need not have bothered. The manuscript was never published. The tone was judged polemical and the author was unknown. Then, however, came Poverty and Population and with it the attention of reformers and statisticians around the world.
Titmuss joined the Eugenics Society in 1937. He was still a member at the time of his death. Most of the contacts which were instrumental in getting his early writings into print or in securing him his posts in the Cabinet Office and later at the LSE were made through his involvement in the Eugenics Society. Titmuss published in (and, in the early 1940s, edited) its journal, the Eugenics Review. He was active in the war in selecting eugenically promising children for evacuation to Canada. He served on the Council of the Society. Francis Galton, cousin of Charles Darwin, had been the first to coin the term eugenics. Studying twins, he found that they remained similar in character even when separated in space. This led him in 1883 to declare that ‘nature prevails enormously over nurture’,28 and that there was little that a change in environment could do. The subject of genetic inheritance (and of selective breeding to upgrade the qualities of the stock) was widely debated in the 1930s. Not least was it debated because of Hitler’s policies on race, and because of British doctors’ curiosity to discover how far mental illness
Introduction
9
was an intergenerational gift. Eugenics in the 1930s was a mainstream topic in socio-political debate. Senior figures in national life were drawn to the Society and Titmuss had a chance to meet them. Personal impressions were important as Titmuss, largely self-educated, had no paper qualifications. Poverty and Population, Titmuss’s first published book, was his contribution to the debate on the who and the which of selection and survival. It was published in 1938 by Macmillan (Harold Macmillan, MP for Stockton-on-Tees, taking a personal interest in anything that could alleviate the absolute deprivation he saw in his constituency) and came with a Preface written by the physician to the Royal Family (Lord Horder, then President of the Eugenics Society: David Glass appears to have interested him in the project). Its subtitle was ‘A Factual Study of Contemporary Social Waste’. By factual, Titmuss meant that he was proposing to rely on statistics, both national and disaggregated. By waste, Titmuss meant that he could document the annual loss of 50 000 British lives that could otherwise have been spared. Titmuss’s book was published at a time when unemployment had hovered around the 2 million mark for almost 20 years – ‘and there is every indication that heavy unemployment is now a permanent feature of our civilisation’.29 In spite of that surplus Titmuss made clear that the 50 000 remained a cause for concern. One reason was the widespread fear in the 1930s that the British population was not only declining but declining too fast. A typical statement would be that of Beveridge in 1937: ‘In twenty-five years we shall be in a panic about the population of this country . . . The centre of the social sciences is going to be the problem of population.’30 A further reason was the possibility of war. In 1936 the rejection rate for military service in the Home Counties was 32 per cent; for England and Wales as a whole it was 48 per cent.31 This not only meant fewer recruits but also, as Titmuss writes, a selective bias in favour of the fitter south: ‘War is always dysgenic; that means to say it always kills the best types from amongst the biologically important age groups.’32 The population total was moving from surplus into deficit. Up to a half of Britain’s would-be soldiers were unfit for service. A future war would take a discriminatory toll of Britain’s best-quality breeders. Considerations such as these led Titmuss to document carefully the differentials in preventable illness and premature death as a preliminary to making recommendations that would protect the human stock.
10
Richard Titmuss
Titmuss in his book is approaching the human stock from the perspective of innate potential. What he is saying, however, is that in certain circumstances nurture is the key that unlocks the hidden potential and empowers it to reach the level that nature made possible. The relationship between nutrition and intelligence is a case in point: ‘Many a child classed as dull or backward should have been recorded as deficient in vitamin A . . . There are substantial reasons for thinking that dietetically balanced meals increase mental output.’33 Environment cannot do what the endowment rules out – in that he is at one with Galton. Changes in conditions, on the other hand, can at least allow that which is already in successfully to get out: ‘Satisfactory diet allows valuable hereditary qualities to assert themselves.’34 Satisfactory diet allows it. Malnutrition and deprivation stunt it. Thus it was that Titmuss, specifically addressing the need to make the most of a genetically bounded scarce resource, began to put forward social reforms that would allow the nation to exploit limited ability to the full. Gifted children cannot make full use of educational opportunities if their drinking-water is polluted and their sustenance impoverished – but an answer is to be found in school milk and meals (including breakfast), medical services to contain infection and an improvement in the housing stock. In 1928–34 the maternal death-rate in the five principal coal-mining counties was 41 per cent higher, the infantile death-rate 51 per cent higher, than that prevailing in Middlesex and Essex35 – but the surplus in deaths could be significantly reduced if measures could be taken to break the vicious circle that linked low wages and high unemployment to family poverty and thence to disease, defect and underperformance. In all of this the proximate subject is diphtheria and tuberculosis, overcrowded slums and inadequate ventilation, but the real cause is lack of money. Poverty is the principal problem facing the poor. All those who believed with Galton in the upgrading of the race should turn to social reform for a meaningful answer to the inequality of outcomes handed on intergenerationally through fertility and reproduction. The poor breed more. That in itself is a sound enough reason for an economical nation to make the poor less poor over time.
Titmuss’s second book, Our Food Problem (written with F. Le Gros Clark and published in 1939), continued the discussion of
Introduction
11
malnutrition and stratification. It proved both influential and controversial: some 30 000 copies were sold as a Penguin Special before the outbreak of war. The book is in two parts. The first, ‘Britain’s Food Supplies in War’, was written entirely by Clark. It dealt with the minutiae of storage, blockade, rationing, state trading in food and the optimal siting of stocks. The second, entitled ‘Stamina of the British People’, was a collaborative effort of the two authors. It began by stating the obvious, that in war as in peace Britain had need of a ‘lively and vigorous population’,36 energetic and purposeful. It then evoked the sociological evidence Titmuss had previously collected on economic deprivation and preventable mortality to demonstrate that poverty was a threat to physical stamina – and inequality a threat to ‘social stamina’ which is the cause and effect of equity and sharing: When folk like the British . . . cease to believe that society is organically constructed to serve the common good of all, they begin from that moment to lose their morale . . . There is a sickness of the soul as well as of the body; and if we are to persuade our people to fight for their world, it must be a world that is patently providing them with the first essentials of life . . . If there is one thing few men can stomach to-day, it is the growing divergence of interests between rich and poor and the suspected inequality of sacrifice.37 Diet by itself is only a part of the problem. As much as the deprived need to increase their intake of fresh vegetables, fruit, milk, eggs and fish, there is something more that is required – Tawney’s ‘common tradition’, Tawney’s ‘common culture’, Tawney’s ‘equality of environment, of access to education and the means of civilization, of security and independence, and of the social consideration which equality in these matters usually carries with it’.38 Clark and Titmuss built on Tawney’s Equality. They did so in order to argue that folk like the British would be especially motivated to fight the giants from abroad if the giants on their doorstep could also be put to rout. It was in this spirit that Clark and Titmuss called for a planned food policy that would include subsidisation of the staples most needed by those most in need. Schoolchildren should be given free school meals, an apple and a pint of milk. Pregnant and nursing mothers should be assisted to correct deficiencies of calcium and
12
Richard Titmuss
phosphorous before they passed on to their children the free gift of dental caries. What all of this adds up to is the political lead: ‘A government which exerts itself to feed the people will be also a truly democratic government.’39 Only a year later, in July 1940, the milk and the meals had become a fact; and so had the immunisation against diphtheria of what was to be 7 million schoolchildren by the end of the war. It would be wrong to say that Our Food Problem was the cause. What is clear, however, is that it said what many were thinking – not least Sir Richard Acland, who used his position as Liberal MP to collect information for the book by means of Parliamentary questions – and that it did so with the mix of commitment and data that Titmuss was to make his trademark.
In 1942 came Parents Revolt. It is the only book jointly authored (although Richard appears to have written almost the whole of the text by himself) by Richard and Kay. There had been a significant decline in the birth-rate and, with it, in the population in a number of countries. The list included France, Germany and the United Kingdom. In the decade in which Keynes had written so persuasively about macroeconomic failure, a further debate had emerged on the possibility of a socio-biological failing that could prove in the long run to be just as much a cause for concern. The decline had been the subject of The Twilight of Parenthood (1934) by Enid Charles, Crisis in the Population Question (1934) by Alva and Gunnar Myrdal (published in Swedish only), The Struggle for Population (1936) by David Glass; and, of course, of Titmuss’s own Poverty and Population. In 1942 (the same year – the authors could not have known this – as the revival in birth-rates began) the Titmusses resumed the discussion. The decline in the birth-rate, they said, was ‘of even more vital importance to the destiny of man than the tragedy of war’.40 Still childless after five years of marriage, Richard and Kay must have known that they themselves formed part of the Parents Revolt that was the title of their book. Their only child (born when Kay was 39 and provisionally called Adrian in advance) must have been conceived at the same time as many reviews and a BBC discussion (headed ‘Too Few Babies?’) were making Richard’s name ever better known. Central to the debate are, of course, the aggregates. The net British reproduction rate in the 1930s, the authors reported, was 0.74–0.78. The British population was evidently not replacing itself. One consequence was the rise in the average age of the
Introduction
13
population and therewith in the burden of late-life dependency. In 1876, 5 per cent of the British population was aged 65 or above. In the early 1940s the figure stood at 9 per cent.41 Not only were the numbers of Britons contracting but those who were working were becoming responsible for an expanding cohort of those who were not. Premature deaths as well as prevented births can be a cause of falling numbers. Here once again it might be economic deprivation that was draining Britain of its strength: ‘War kills people, and poverty results in premature death.’42 Social reform in such circumstances could conceptually put right the aggregates. Eugenics, however, seriously complicates the choices. The strict adaptationist, sorry to lose superior specimens but less tolerant of the chronically unfitted, would be sorely tempted to say that a quantitative fall could simultaneously be a qualitative betterment where it was primarily the dysgenic and the maladaptive who were tending to die young. Titmuss (who in this period was in sympathy with voluntary sterilisation for the chronically unsuited) knew that premature deaths could be an indicator of natural selection: the ‘gloomy view’ of Galton is ‘exaggerated’, Parents Revolt declares, but ‘it does contain some truth’.43 The real problem is to separate the dysgenic from the merely disadvantaged. Nurture being so unequal and so capricious, the Titmusses argued, the fact is that nature itself is not visible but hid in night: The harmful effects of malnutrition, overcrowding, industrial working conditions, inadequate education and insufficient air, sun and leisure on physical and mental health so complicate the issues that . . . until there is far greater social and economic equality we shall not be able to point out particular groups whose fertility is harmful to the community.44 As things stand, we simply do not know. Given the lack of knowledge, common sense points to an equalisation of opportunity such as at the very least is likely to deliver an improvement in the population total. Birth-control makes possible the conscious choice of family size. Birth-control in that way makes endogenous and attitudinal the very survival – or extinction – of the British people. The middle classes have taken the lead in refusing to supply new Britons in quantities adequate to serve their nation’s need: ‘If the common people had restricted the size of their families in the same way as the well-to-do, Hitler’s Wehrmacht might by now be goose-stepping
14
Richard Titmuss
down Whitehall.’45 Not enough soldiers, not enough producers, not enough consumers, not enough ‘folk like the British’ – national decline was just down the road, and the reason was the capitalist economy: ‘Capitalism is a biological failure.’46 Marx’s Capital argues that the free-enterprise system contains the seeds of its own destruction. Parents Revolt makes the same telling assessment: ‘The age of economic man – of competitive, acquisitive goals, is breaking down . . . Nothing shows this more completely than the fact that man is refusing to reproduce himself.’47 The middle classes already on strike, the working classes likely soon to emulate them, it was the message of Parents Revolt that the population problem would not and could not be resolved so long as ‘Will it pay?’ took precedence over ‘Is it right?’ in an economic order that depended on selfishness and greed. The sub-title of Parents Revolt – ‘a study of the declining birthrate in acquisitive societies’ – gave a warning that the book was not just about how many and which but about a why that, as with Marx, was the internal contradiction of possessive individualism. Beatrice Webb, asked by Richard to contribute a Preface, saw precisely what the book was about. On the one hand, she wrote, it was about the ‘public danger . . . threatening the survival of the white race’.48 On the other hand, she continued, it was about the rule of ‘Every man for himself and devil take the hindmost’ that was causing parents in capitalist societies to make excessive use of family planning. The ‘new civilisation’, Beatrice Webb observed pointedly, was setting a better example. The population of the Soviet Union, where public-spiritedness had replaced the man-made evil of narrow gain-seeking, was increasing rapidly: ‘By the end of this century, its population may be some three hundred millions of well educated and healthy human beings.’49 The Soviets had wisely begun with the economic basis. Because they had had a proletarian revolution there was no need for a parents’ revolt. The Titmusses (who showed no interest either in the Soviet Union or in the proletarian revolution) were absolutely clear that the birthrate had fallen because of the imperatives of the economic basis: ‘The combative nature of the economic system itself determined the choice. Children went out of fashion because they had no place in the scheme of things.’50 People in an acquisitive society judge themselves by what they can buy: clearly, children must be an ‘expensive liability’51 where esteem and standing are so much the results of outward display and conspicuous consumption. People,
Introduction
15
moreover, experience a perennial insecurity in a competitive economy: unstable employment, recurring unemployment, a shortage of living space, all militate against new responsibilities so long as poverty remains an ever-present possibility. Where altruism is expressed, it is in such conditions prudently confined to the members of the immediate family. Parents practise family planning in order to give a smaller number of offspring a better start in life. Conscientious as this might seem to some, it is also a selfish and an irresponsible action when seen from the perspective of a Britain becoming inexorably less Great over time. Possessive individualism is the cause. The transcendence of isolated ambition is the cure: ‘We have got to progressively eradicate the profit motive from society; we have to go forward to a real economic democracy based on co-operative values and we must offer something more compelling than the goal of economic prosperity.’52 Parents will simply not see the need to contribute sufficient children to the national pool so long as they lack the sensation of felt citizenship and purposeful integration that alone can make the cell use its freedom to choose the whole: A decisive attitude on the part of the majority to the population problem can only come about on the basis of a kind of identification of the individual with the people. The individual must not only feel but know that he is working and living not for himself alone but for the community . . . He must know that his children will be welcomed by the community as free contributions to the public good. He must begin to trust – and not distrust – the community.53 Lonely separateness leads to contraception as it does to suicide. Unity and neighbourliness, ‘a feeling of nationality, a sense of belonging to a national group’, is, on the other hand, ‘a prophylactic’54 – against both. The message of Parents Revolt is evidently a recommendation not just for more wanted children but for ‘the right viewpoint’: ‘We must look at things in terms of men and women, and not in terms of money.’55 This is not to underestimate the contribution of welfare reforms like family allowances, only to assert that ‘money is not the answer’56 and that income transfers superimposed upon economic values would do little to fill the moral vacuum of the times. As Titmuss had declared in the New Statesman in the year preceding the publication of Parents Revolt:
16
Richard Titmuss
Man’s desire to serve the community – and one way in which he can best do this is by consciously and deliberately desiring the continuance of his own kind – has been increasingly negatived by a society which tells him to seek his own interest, individually and nationally; to regard wealth as an index of biological success . . . For a century we have preached the value of morals and practised the immorality of acquisitiveness.57 Greatly influenced as he was by Tawney’s Equality, it is clear that Titmuss had absorbed the lesson of Tawney’s Acquisitive Society as well – that ‘if society is to be healthy, men must regard themselves, not primarily as the owners of rights, but as trustees for the discharge of functions and the instruments of a social purpose’.58 It was precisely this stewardship that the capitalist economy was normatively incapable of delivering. Titmuss at approximately the same time as the publication of Parents Revolt switched his allegiance from the Liberal to the Labour Party. This was a more radical choice then than it would have been a decade later. Parents Revolt uses the birth-rate as a sensitive social indicator in the same way that The Gift Relationship was much later to use the donation of blood. Both books introduce a microsociological discrimination (middle-class fertility in the former case, Skid Row ‘ooze for booze’ in the latter) alongside the quantitative totals. Both books address the ‘free-rider’ temptation that imperils the supply of the textbook economist’s ‘public goods’ – Britons in 1942, transfusions in 1970 – through an appeal to altruism, commitment, community and duty. Both books contend that market capitalism can act to repress the freedom of choice, can be incompatible with ‘biological need’ and ‘biological success’, can be a cause of social division and personal emptiness. The Gift Relationship is rightly regarded as a classic at the interface between social science and social philosophy. Parents Revolt deserves to be more widely read as the early attempt of the same original thinker to explain the coordination of millions of individual decisions by means not of prices but of attachments and of norms.
Between 1939 and 1942, still employed at County Fire, Titmuss worked on German vital and medical statistics, advising the Ministry of Economic Warfare after 1941 on the impact of the war on the health status of the Germans. He showed that mortality indices
Introduction
17
in Germany had actually risen since 1933. This was in contrast to Nazi propaganda, which had made much of the effectiveness of German social policies. From 1939 to 1941, also in his spare time, Titmuss was continuing his research on demography and eugenics. His research was supported by a small grant from the Leverhulme Trust. The outcome of his investigations was Birth, Poverty and Wealth, published in 1943. As before in his work, Titmuss took for granted the reality and the significance of the genetic constitution. As before in his work, Titmuss refused to assert that the British experience confirmed the weeding out of bad genes and the beneficial selection of good: ‘In all the major causes of death in this country there is little or no evidence of important hereditary factors.’59 Nature can be the cause of schizophrenia and epilepsy. Nurture, however, can lie at the root of tuberculosis and influenza. Trapped between the biology and the sociology, Titmuss in 1943 reported that his earlier assessment of unequal opportunity still appeared to him sound: ‘Inherited intelligence has not the full opportunities for development in an evil environment or when nutrition is inadequate.’60 In Birth, Poverty and Wealth Titmuss used statistical data from many sources to show that premature death was most likely in the lowest occupational groups, least likely in the highest: ‘On the basis of the latest available social class mortality data we see that the mortality of Class V exceeds that of Class I by 161 per cent.’61 As with the occupational gradient, so with the North–South divide upon which it was superimposed: ‘Looking at the regional extremes we see that while Class V mortality exceeded that of Class I in the South-East by 63 per cent and the South-West by 67 per cent, in North 1 the excess was 166 per cent and in North 4 it was 198 per cent.’62 The differentials as measured by the Registrar-General’s five broad categories (work function here serving as a proxy for income group and social status) and by the standard geographical circumscriptions – themselves an indicator of ‘the much more depressed economic conditions of the poor in the North’63 – could, of course, have been the consequence of innate differences in physical and mental fitness alone. They could, on the other hand, have been the result of slum density, insanitary sewers, threadbare clothing, insufficient food, inaccessible doctoring – of poverty, in other words, such as condemns the deprived to high infant mortality and to wasteful underperformance: ‘Wealth opens the door of opportunity while poverty keeps it closed from the cradle to the grave.’64
18
Richard Titmuss
Titmuss knew that the evidence did not allow him to be dogmatic about the relative importance of heredity and environment. He also knew that his unique position as a eugenicist and a socialist, a statistician and a philosopher, made it indispensable for him not to dwell too long on the fence. It is possible that his conclusion was too confident. It was, however, the only conclusion that a follower of Tawney and a contemporary of Stockton could reasonably have reached: ‘The fact that for every eleven infants of the economically favoured groups who die from preventable causes, 90 children of the poor die from similar causes summarises, as a matter of life or death, the power of environment and economics.’65 And not, apparently, of genes. Even so, the Eugenics Society was prepared to support publication of Birth, Poverty and Wealth through a grant of £100. Macmillan turned down the proposal (they had decided to concentrate on commercially attractive manuscripts for the duration of the war) and Titmuss’s fourth book moved on to Hamish Hamilton – his fourth publisher. Titmuss’s book (soon supported by three papers written with J.N. Morris on the social origins of mortality from rheumatic heart disease and from stomach ulcers) looks forward to the mature analytic of his later work. It also looks backward to his earlier concern with a declining population. In Birth, Poverty and Wealth Titmuss showed that social inequalities as measured by the disparity in infant deathrates between the most and the least privileged social classes was ‘as high as, if not higher than, before the 1914–18 war’. 66 He calculated that if all classes had had the same infant death-rates in 1930–32 as did social class I, then 90 000 infants would not have died. Even after allowing for the welcome fall in the absolute levels, a loss of 90 000 lives in consequence of a reducible gap must be regarded as a topic in collective survival and not just in individual fitness at a time when Hitler’s Wehrmacht was already contemplating its goose-stepping down Whitehall. Tawney in his path-breaking Ratan Tata lecture had in 1913 proclaimed deprivation another name for maldistribution: ‘What thoughtful rich people call the problem of poverty, thoughtful poor people call with equal justice the problem of riches.’67 Titmuss, at the time when Birth, Poverty and Wealth marked the end of his apprenticeship years, had, like Tawney, come to see poverty as the obverse of wealth – and as an economic failing which a sensible society would do well to correct. In the free-market past, self-centred, ostentation-chasing, money-worshipping, poverty had been seen as
Introduction
19
a ‘part of the landscape’: ‘To most, poverty, or the inequal distribution of wealth, was quite natural in an age when every man was taught to promote his own self-interest.’68 That was the past. The future was yet to come.
At the outbreak of war Titmuss had been deferred from conscription because his occupation of Insurance Inspector and Surveyor had been made a reserved one. Titmuss was involved in war-risks and war-damage insurance. In that capacity he made visits to bombedout premises and talked to people who had lost their homes. The Cabinet Office was assembling a team of historians to write the civil history of the Second World War. Unusually for an official record, the events were to be monitored as they unfolded and not simply reconstructed in tranquil hindsight later. The leader of the group was to be W. Keith (later Sir Keith) Hancock, an economic historian at Birmingham University. Eventually some thirty volumes were to appear. Titmuss was by no means unknown. There had been the articles in The Times, The Lancet, The Spectator, The Insurance Record, The New Statesman; the editorship of the Eugenics Review; the four booklength investigations into neediness and numbers which had demonstrated such scrupulous attention to detail. Titmuss was a Fellow of the Royal Statistical Society and the Royal Economic Society. He was on the Council of the Eugenics Society. He had been approached in the war by the Ministry of Food and the Ministry of Information. On the other hand, he had left school at 14 and had no formal qualifications. Hancock had heard of Titmuss from Eva Hubback, Principal of Morley College and a Council member of the Eugenics Society. Hancock was impressed by the self-taught enthusiast and not deterred by the lack of public-school – or even state-school – credentials. Perhaps the fact that Hancock was Australian made him more open to merit and more resistant to the Oxbridge self-presentation of the career civil servant. His decision to invite Titmuss to join the team showed courage but also remarkable prescience in the light of the use that Titmuss was to make of this piece of good luck. County Fire refused to give him unpaid leave and, signing the Official Secrets Act, he resigned. Titmuss joined Hancock’s group in 1942. He was to be concerned with social services (ranging from the evacuation and billeting of
20
Richard Titmuss
mothers and children to health, social security and the care of the homeless). The project was to occupy him until 1949. The war years must have been especially exhausting. Doing his research in the daytime, he and Hancock spent one night a week as firewatchers at St Paul’s. Looking back on the rum consumed in an unconsecrated corner, the bath and breakfast at the Cabinet Office before doing a day’s work, Hancock later wrote: ‘Even during the war, I think that the crypt of St Paul’s on Wednesday nights was the best club in London.’69 Titmuss was one of many British people who found in unpaid activities such as firewatching the camaraderie, the equality of respect, the sense of belonging which for them was the essence of the One Nation ideal. Just as the Depression had shown how social forces could generate vast unrelieved states of dependency, so the war was proving that men and women in society could work together in pursuit of a common aim. As the Queen said when a bomb shattered the windows of Buckingham Palace: ‘It makes me feel I can look the East End in the face.’ Richard and Kay must have felt much the same way when their own small home in Pimlico was bombed out in the Blitz. Titmuss’s contribution to the series, Problems of Social Policy, was published in 1950. Because the failures as well as the successes were impartially depicted, Hancock had to threaten to resign for the Ministries to withdraw their objection to the volume. In his book Titmuss showed mastery of vast quantities of material, some from official publications but much or most collected directly from government departments and a wide range of welfare institutions. Unlike many historical works, Problems of Social Policy was sensitive at all times to moral dilemmas, value choices and the human dimension. Insightful and well written, it ultimately sold more copies than any other volume in Hancock’s series. R.H. Tawney regarded it as little short of brilliant: Sociology, like history, is a department of knowledge which requires that facts should be counted and weighed, but which, if it omits to make allowance for the imponderables, is unlikely to weigh or even to count them right. Mr. Titmus [sic] is a humane scientist who does not succumb to the temptation to ‘measure the universe by rule and line’. His subtlety and insight in interpreting his evidence are as impressive as the meticulous scrupulousness with which he has collected and sifted it.70
Introduction
21
In 1945 Titmuss found time for the Report on Luton. It was prepared for the Luton Borough Council and written in collaboration with Dr Fred Grundy, the local Medical Officer of Health (who happened to be a qualified barrister as well). For their Report the authors conducted a statistical survey of Luton’s population (sampling one household in every ten). In that way they built up a picture of social life and social conditions – housing, health, education, migration patterns, age structure – which they rightly regarded as the factual basis upon which any policy infrastructure would have to build. Titmuss’s unique contribution is visible in a number of places. Not the least of these is the section on the finance of social services. There, discussing the ‘function of money in society’, the Report concludes that the budget can never be more than ‘a means to an end’: ‘Policy should not be determined mainly according to money resources. It may, indeed, be argued that if we cannot afford these services we must have them; if we could easily afford them, many would be unnecessary.’71 Written in the year when Labour’s victory heralded the cradle-to-grave security that had been eagerly awaited since Social Insurance and Allied Services in 1942, those words reiterate the core pledge of Titmuss’s commitment to care – that no citizen should ever be denied a decent lifestyle simply because his community is too mean to pay. The civil service period at an end, from 1949 Titmuss was free to devote himself full-time to research projects like the Report. In 1949–50 he served as the Deputy Director of the Social Medicine Research Unit of the Medical Research Council. He also explored (with Hancock’s help) the possibility of an academic appointment at All Souls’ or Nuffield. The prospect was one which he contemplated with some trepidation. Titmuss was acutely aware that he was deficient in social location and university culture. His feelings of inferiority, his moods of self-doubt, are well illustrated by a letter written to Jerry Morris not long before the Report: I have had the ‘glooms’ lately and badly . . . My particular worry is, broadly, education. It gets a bit tiresome, you know, to be constantly meeting people who will talk about things on which you know literally nothing. I am always being reminded about this ‘educational inferiority’. It applies to literature, history, ‘the arts’, and, nearer home, to statistics. It sometimes makes me despair of getting, and holding, a worthwhile job after the war.72
22
Richard Titmuss
Ann Oakley suggests that there may even be a link between Titmuss’s own second-bestness, self-perceived, and the deep sympathy he felt for society’s outcasts and also-rans: In discovering the huge disparities in life chances between those at the bottom and those at the top of the social scale, he was at the same time commenting on his own lack of fortune in not being born at the top. Awareness of class was central to his intellectual perception of society. But it was also constantly felt as an aspect of his own life.73 Titmuss need not have worried about getting, and holding, a worthwhile job after the Problems. New professorships in social policy were being created in London and Birmingham in response to the expansion in the social services. Titmuss was approached for both. The result was that, in 1950, he was appointed to the new Chair of Social Administration at the London School of Economics. T.H. Marshall had tried even before publication of the Problems to secure him for the School and Hancock wrote an enthusiastic recommendation. The Director of the School, Sir Alexander Carr-Saunders, knew Titmuss through the Eugenics Society. He was sympathetic to the appointment despite Titmuss’s lack of a university degree. Given the nature of the post and the small number of reputable investigators in 1950 with an interest in social policy, Titmuss is unlikely to have been in competition with any very strong rivals. The Chair was Titmuss’s first (and only) academic post. Much of the freshness of his work may indeed be due to the fact that he never had to conform to the rigidity of departmental conventional wisdom in order to secure a job or win a promotion. Titmuss was a maverick and an outsider. According to Ann Oakley, he derived great satisfaction from the freedom to trespass which his self-selected multidisciplinarity was able to offer him: ‘His work was always difficult to classify (a fact of which he himself was obstinately proud), and, since he had no professional academic training, he persisted in calling himself a student of society. He always began with a problem and worked outwards to an analysis of it.’74 Just as Titmuss was fortunate that he had no strong rivals for the Chair, so he was in luck that research assessment exercises and audit by peer-refereed publication did not yet exist to constrain innovation within the time-worn grooves. In 1950 the London School of Economics, although formally a
Introduction
23
part of the University of London, had no natural scientists and few arts staff. It was almost entirely a social science college. The continuous debates on the issues of the day must have been a source of considerable stimulus – and benefit – to a newly enfranchised autodidact who found even multiple regression a new discovery. The lack of a degree proved no obstacle to recognition in the long run. Titmuss eventually received five honorary doctorates – from the University of Wales (1959), Edinburgh (1962), Toronto (1964), Chicago (1970), Brunel (1971) – and was about to receive a sixth (from Brandeis) at the time of his death. He was made a Commander of the Order of the Dannebrog (in Denmark) in 1965 and a Fellow of the British Academy in 1972. In 1966 he was awarded the CBE. Later he was offered, also by Harold Wilson, a life peerage. Like Tawney before him, he declined. Always refusing to travel first class on the railways, he presumably believed that it would isolate him too much from his fellow citizens. Kay was disappointed, observing late in life that ‘there’s only one thing I regret, that I wasn’t Lady Titmuss’.75 Interestingly, their daughter Ann was educated from 11 to 16 in the private sector at a grant-aided school (she herself had a state-funded place but one-third of the pupils were fee-paying) and later at Oxford. Looking back, Ann had this to say about a man who had a love–hate relationship with some parts at least of Britain’s historic Establishment: ‘You didn’t have to be a detective to discern my father’s concealed adulation of certain unsocialist institutions.’76 In 1950 Titmuss inherited from T.H. Marshall a strong department of 13 members. Most were trained social workers, looked down upon in the School to such an extent that as late as 1949 they were paid on a lower salary scale. Titmuss, of course, was not a social worker; and his brand of administration, as opposed to casework, undeniably brought him into conflict with some of his more task-centred colleagues. The conflict was to some extent resolved when it was realised that his interest in policies and politics was accompanied by a real commitment to vocational social-work education. He also won admiration from many of his associates for the institution of reforms such as the admission of older students without formal educational qualifications. At the London School of Economics, supported by core ‘Titmice’ like Brian Abel-Smith and Peter Townsend, Titmuss moulded the new subject of Social Policy and Administration and demonstrated that it could be both academically and intellectually respectable.
24
Richard Titmuss
Rose is right to say that ‘the growth of social administration over the fifties and sixties was paralleled by the spread of the paradigm and the people from the Titmuss school’.77 Not only did the LSE Department train a disproportionate number of practitioners, British and foreign, but the acknowledged vanguard was called upon with disproportionate frequency to advise other departments on the Chairs they should select: ‘Kingmaking within the newly developing departments of social policy took place actively.’78 Peter Townsend was appointed to the first Chair of Sociology at the new University of Essex. Brian Abel-Smith, David Donnison and Della Nevitt were given Chairs at the LSE. Roy Parker became Professor at Bristol, John Greve at Southampton. The inference to Rose is clear enough: ‘At its height the Titmuss school reigned unchallenged over the construction of social policy.’79 The downside of the hegemony is, however, a self-reinforcing complacency which is never very beneficial for the health of a field of study. Pinker writes as follows of Titmuss and the respect which his authority could command: ‘During his lifetime his work was only very rarely subjected to reappraisal by other scholars within the discipline.’80 Titmuss is not to be blamed for the zeal of his disciples. It must, however, be conceded that a commanding figure in any subject must always be a threat to diversification and to change. At the LSE Titmuss had a high profile on committees and boards. He was noteworthy for his approachability, his modesty and his simplicity. Although very hard-working, he was never too busy to comment on or discuss the work of others. Violence and disorder were, however, always anathema to him. In the troubled years of 1966–68 he joined forces with right-wing economists like Lionel Robbins in opposing New Left activists such as Robin Blackburn (who was dismissed from his lectureship) and student radicals who failed to recognise that democratic socialism could have no worthwhile future save in the historic context of tolerance and respect, debate and persuasion, hierarchy and discipline. Titmuss was more than just an academic. While the main lines of the modern British Welfare State were laid down before he became influential, he acted, while a professor at the London School of Economics, as adviser to the Labour Party on policy issues such as pensions. He was bitterly disappointed when Labour’s new national superannuation scheme was lost in 1970. Had the election of that year which ended six years of Labour government been called only a few months later, the Bill would have become an Act.
Introduction
25
Outside party politics, Titmuss sat on a number of government committees. These included the National Insurance Advisory Committee, the Royal Commission on Medical Education, and the One Parent Family (Finer) Committee. Titmuss and his close associates, partly because there was not much challenge, institutional or intellectual, were strongly represented in the preparation of policyrelated reports throughout the period of their leadership. Titmuss demonstrated his interest in race relations by serving on the Community Relations Commission (from 1965 to 1971) and in the problem of poverty by acting as the Deputy Chairman of the Supplementary Benefits Commission (from 1966 to 1973). This last post is a surprise as supplementary benefits were means-tested and Titmuss was a vociferous enemy of the means test. Perhaps, however, as Margaret Gowing believes, ‘he saw the Commission’s work as one way of exercising the positive discrimination in favour of the underprivileged which was necessary on top of universalist benefits’.81 Titmuss was interested in the problems of poor countries and set up at the LSE the first course in Britain in development administration. In his writings he stressed that developing countries, in their quest for economic growth, should not neglect the indicators of social growth as well. He repeated this point in the recommendations he made to the governments of Tanganyika (where he and Julius Nyerere found that they shared a common vision of equality and nation-building) and Mauritius.
Titmuss did not live to be ‘eccentric in old age’ as he had hoped. He died of cancer in a national health hospital – the Central Middlesex, near his home at 32 Twyford Avenue, Acton – on 6 April 1973. He was 65. Over one thousand people attended a memorial service for him at St Martin-in-the-Fields on 6 June. The speakers were Richard Crossman (previously Secretary of State for Social Services in the United Kingdom), Wilbur Cohen (previously Secretary at the Department of Health, Education and Welfare in the United States) and the Rt Reverend Trevor Huddleston, socialist Bishop of Stepney. Julius Nyerere sent a message of condolence. So did Sir Keith Joseph. Trevor Huddleston called Titmuss ‘anima naturaliter Christiana’ and said that he exemplified the true Christian values. Richard Crossman paid tribute to his commitment to welfare: ‘Richard Titmuss was not like other men. His eyes and his conversation shone with a
26
Richard Titmuss
moral force.’82 It is indeed that moral force which more than anything else characterises the intellectual system that is analysed in the chapters of this book. As Paul Wilding has put it so well: Titmuss’ work put moral and philosophical issues at the heart of debates about the welfare state, and gave them a central place in the academic study of social policy. Social policy could, very easily, have become preoccupied with the study of the nuts and bolts required to achieve certain ends. Titmuss’ legacy ensured that this would not happen.83
Part One: The Status of Social Policy
This page intentionally left blank
2 The Definition of Social Policy
All policy means choice involving change. Policy by its very nature implies that we ‘believe we can affect change in some form or another. We do not have policies about the weather because, as yet, we are powerless to do anything about the weather.’1 Yet, precisely because it cannot escape the constraint of choice involving change, precisely because it is action-oriented and problem-oriented, no policy can escape from values, ideologies and images of what constitutes the ‘good society’. Titmuss stressed that human values cannot be ignored in any meaningful discussion of social policy. Since in the last analysis, ‘social policy is all about social purposes and choices between them’,2 it was obvious to him that it could never be ‘value-free’: We all have our values and our prejudices; we all have our rights and duties as citizens, and our rights and duties as teachers and students. At the very least, we have a responsibility for making our values clear; and we have a special duty to do so when we are discussing such a subject as social policy which, quite clearly, has no meaning at all if it is considered to be neutral in terms of values.3 Social policy has its origins in the values of a particular society. It ‘cannot be discussed or even conceptualised in a social vacuum’.4 Welfare systems tend to ‘reflect the dominant cultural and political characteristics of their societies’.5 They must be seen ‘in the context of a particular set of circumstances, a given society and culture, and a more or less specified period of historical time’.6 Social policy, in short, is social because and where needs are defined to be social: ‘All collectively provided services are deliberately designed to meet 29
30
The Status of Social Policy
certain socially recognized “needs”; they are manifestations, first, of society’s will to survive as an organic whole and, secondly, of the expressed wish of all the people to assist the survival of some people.’7 This is an important statement. There are two crucial points to note. First, social policy is concerned with those needs which must be satisfied if the existing social matrix is to continue in existence. It is thus group policy not just in its origins but in its functions as well, since it has a deeply integrative and communitarian objective. Hence the primary areas of unifying interest for social policy ‘are centred in those social institutions that foster integration and discourage alienation’.8 Its model is the gift or unilateral transfer rather than the exchange of equivalents or the quid pro quo. Titmuss believed that social policy is ‘profoundly concerned with questions of personal identity whereas economic policy centres round exchange or bilateral transfer’.9 He went still further to assert that, save in terms of its aims, objectives and ends, there is no consistent definition of social policy.10 It is not, in short, particular institutions themselves that make up social welfare but their functions within the social structure: ‘The definition, for most purposes, of what is a “social service” should take its stand on aims; not on the administrative methods and institutional devices employed to achieve them.’11 Second, social policy is concerned with those states of dependency which are generally recognised by the collectivity to be collective responsibilities: ‘These “states of dependency” arise for the vast majority of the population whenever they are not in a position to “earn life” for themselves and their families; they are then dependent people.’12 The reasons for the dependency might be related to the life cycle (as in the case of the very young or the very old), the mind (as in the case of the psychologically ill), the economy (as in the case of unemployment created by regional policies). The dependent person might not even recognise all the social needs that are being met. An urban black, for example, might desire medical attention which has the manifest function of making him well, and yet find that care in an integrated ward where the same universalist benefits are available to all will also make him feel happily integrated, a latent function which he did not anticipate. Such integration is an example of a benefit to the community in its own right. It is conceptually independent of any benefit that may accrue to the individual. Other social needs affecting the community as a whole might be for the probation services, law and order, or the prevention of infectious diseases. The need for equality itself,
The Definition of Social Policy
31
in Titmuss’s view, comes into this category. The justification for equality is to be sought in ‘the will of society to move towards a more equal society’, and its extent is to be governed by the rule ‘to each according to our needs’.13 The needs, work, merit or worth of the individual are relevant only to the extent that they are refracted through the whole. Both points that have just been considered suggest that the amount and nature of assistance offered under the heading of social policy will depend ‘on prevailing notions of what constitutes a “need”’14 (and on how far the group as a whole is to be held responsible for satisfying it). Historically and comparatively, ‘no consistent principle seems to obtain in the definition of what is a “social service”’.15 For modern Britain, however, we may induce the following from experience. In modern Britain the discipline called ‘Social Policy and Administration’ is concerned with identifying social needs and with the structure of administration necessary to satisfy them. It studies the nature and distribution of social benefits and social costs; the rights and duties of the citizen both as contributor to and consumer of the social services; the interaction between the three systems of welfare that constitute collective intervention to meet selected needs (social welfare, occupational welfare and fiscal welfare); and the command-over-resources-over-time. It identifies the present-day social services as involving state education, local authority housing, social security, the National Health Service (both in its preventive and its curative role), and other directly administered services and transfer payments. The benefits can be in cash (for example, old age pensions or unemployment benefits) or in kind (for example, hospital services), but in all cases the government and not the economic market is the allocating agent for rights, duties and collective consumption and the objectives are wherever possible emerging as the following: ‘Social policy in Britain in the personal health, welfare and education fields is moving toward integrated community services, preventive in outlook and of high quality for all citizens in all areas irrespective of means, social class, occupation or ethnic group.’16
This is the state of affairs in modern Britain. Yet, because values and priorities are pre-eminently social facts, it is understandable that the scope for collective provision is elastic and that the role of social policy in practical terms varies from period to period and place to place.
32
The Status of Social Policy
Consider first variation over time in the sort of policies that should be ‘social’. Here Titmuss records a change both in the underlying nature of social reality and in popular attitudes: ‘The Britain of the 1950’s is a very different society from the Britain of the 1900’s. Not only are the “needs” and “situations” different but they are differently seen.’17 Naturally, ideas go deep into the past (witness the vestigial influence of the Poor Laws, or of the crude utilitarianism of Economic Man), and in that sense ‘reality starts with history’.18 Yet, despite the fact that ‘we all drag about with us the chains of history’,19 changes in phenomena and perception do take place. Such changes in the field of welfare have been brought about by both intellectual and material forces. An example of the former would be the influence of Marx, Freud or democratic socialists such as Tawney. An example of the latter would be the technological revolution or the revolution of rising expectations. As is well known, ‘rising standards of living and of education have shifted the emphasis in social services from quantity to quality’.20 This process has been accelerated by the inclusion of the middle classes in the Welfare State, stridently demanding services of the standard to which they would like to be accustomed and thereby generating a bonus for the lower classes. This illustrates how the definition of adequacy and the specification of priorities are still in a process of evolution and are being shaped by social factors. Titmuss believed that social thinking on matters of welfare in the twentieth century had been considerably influenced by war. In the Second World War, for example, the evacuation of mothers and children led to reports of lice, skin diseases, undernourishment, poor clothing, and exposed the extent of bad housing and poverty: ‘The shock to public opinion over the condition of some of the evacuees rivalled the outcry after the Boer War with its disclosures of sickness and low physical standards.’21 Again, the cooperation of the masses and social integration in wartime are only possible if marked differences in the population (say, in the ability to afford luxury entertainment) are reduced: ‘The waging of modern war presupposes and imposes a great increase in social discipline; moreover, this discipline is only tolerable if – and only if – social inequalities are not intolerable.’22 Then, too, war shifted the emphasis away from ‘a philosophy which regarded individual distress as a mark of social incapacity’23 and towards a more altruistic approach according to which new forms of assistance were to be offered without social discrimination to all groups in the population on the basis
The Definition of Social Policy
33
of ‘the pooling of national resources and the sharing of risks’.24 Hitler’s bombs succeeded where the Depression of the 1930s had failed, in imposing a de facto structure of universalism in a multitude of welfare benefits. After all, the diswelfare costs were demonstrably universal as well: ‘That all were engaged in war whereas only some were afflicted with poverty and disease had much to do with the less constraining, less discriminating scope and quality of the war-time social services. Damage to homes and injuries to persons were not less likely among the rich than the poor.’25 Nor, incidentally, was the need for adequate widows’ pensions or the use of rehabilitation centres. This too, presumably, meant greater tolerance by the rich of adequate rent subsidies for the poor. Such subsidies covered the same sort of socially imposed costs as the benefits which the rich themselves had begun to receive. The drift into tolerance was further stimulated by the highly desirable sense of community that came about as a result of wartime setbacks, bombing, and a clearly defined sense of common purpose. Titmuss, like many others of his generation, welcomed the changes in social values and social policy that were induced by the spirit of Dunkirk. He argued that in the summer of 1940 ‘the mood of the people changed and, in sympathetic response, values changed as well. If dangers were to be shared, then resources should also be shared.’26 Dunkirk was a milestone in the history of the social services since it unleashed a flood of critical debate and national introspection. It caused even The Times to call in a Leader on l July for tighter social organisation, better economic planning, and more equitable conditions of income distribution: If we speak of democracy, we do not mean a democracy which maintains the right to vote but forgets the right to work and the right to live. If we speak of freedom, we do not mean a rugged individualism which excludes social organisation and economic planning. If we speak of equality, we do not mean a political equality nullified by social and economic privilege. If we speak of economic reconstruction, we think less of maximum production (though this too will be required) than of equitable distribution.27 The Times, writing of the preconditions for justice in wartime, seemed to be formulating a theory of the just peace as well.
34
The Status of Social Policy
In July 1940 the Treasury took steps to improve the number and quality of school meals and to ensure that more milk be provided for expectant and nursing mothers and young children. It is significant that this decision was taken only five days after the Dunkirk evacuation, and that these early steps were followed by numerous other measures. These included the provision of cheap or free supplies of orange juice and cod liver oil and a nationwide campaign to immunise children against diphtheria. All of this is evidence to support Titmuss’s view on the Dunkirk evacuation: ‘The long, dispiriting years of hard work that followed these dramatic events on the home front served only to reinforce the war-warmed impulse of people for a more generous society.’28 The Second World War was immediately responsible for the Beveridge Report of 1942, the Education Act of 1944 and even the National Health Service in 1946. Titmuss, like Tawney, had a ‘historian’s eye to the future’.29 He was convinced that he had learnt a vital lesson from Britain’s wartime experience: people, once aware of the common situation which they share with their fellow citizens, will opt for non-discriminatory benefits available to all members of the crew, for services which will themselves increase still further the sense of belonging and integration. In this way the recognition of social duty, the perception of common humanity and the awareness of citizenship rights become cumulative over time. They are in turn fostered by the atmosphere of planning that results.
This chapter has been considering variations over time in the sort of policies that are regarded as being properly ‘social’. It will be useful now to consider variations from place to place. There is, after all, no absolute definition of what constitutes a social ‘need’. All that can be known is spotlighted by the specific standards that are shaped by a given society. The use of the comparative method reveals important differences in attitudes from one culture to another. Titmuss rejected those theories common in the 1950s and 1960s which postulated the death of ideology (in a world increasingly based on economic and technological rationality) and the imminence of convergence as between advanced industrial societies (due to similarities in technology and the exploitation of mass-consumption markets). The fact is that countries are not tending to become more and more alike ‘in terms of their dominant value systems and political
The Definition of Social Policy
35
ideologies’, as Titmuss’s own study of paid and unpaid blood donorship indicates: ‘This study throws doubt on such theories. There is no indication of convergence over the last twenty years in the pattern of blood donor gift-relationships when comparisons are made between the United States and Britain.’30 Blood-donorship patterns may be regarded as a useful index of social benefits and values. Titmuss uses an eight-point scale ranging from the paid donor at one extreme (motivated solely by the promise of cash compensation) to the voluntary community donor at the other (motivated by the altruistic desire to give to strangers regardless of what is offered in return) to make international comparisons of attitudes and ideas. His conclusions are unambiguous: ‘Different social and political structures and value systems strongly determine the typology distributions.’31 The differences between, say, Britain, Russia, the United States and Japan in blood-donorship patterns cannot be explained simply in terms of administrative and organizational structures of blood supply systems and patterns of medical care services. The causal factors are more fundamental than that; ultimately, explanations – and, admittedly, explanations that can never be more than partial – have to be sought in the history, the values and the political ideas of each society.32 The fact that there is not a unique developmental path to which all countries must willy-nilly conform is a source of freedom: ‘The sense of freedom and self-respect, implicit in the notion of purposive control over man’s secular affairs, can be diminished if it is believed that political choice has been narrowed to considerations of technique and administration.’33 Where there are no radical choices to be made, ‘political democracy becomes a device for choosing between different leaders but not between different social objectives’,34 and people’s ability to shape their own future is sadly diminished. The ‘end of ideology’ in the sense of Daniel Bell and of Galbraith is hence a most lamentable state of affairs. It reduces the range of choices open to a country to express its unique value-orientation, or to change its institutions as that value-orientation alters. Were ideology to drop out of the social welfare equation, the social policy-maker would be left with techniques but not values. Yet, since ‘policy, any policy, to be effective must choose an objective and must face dilemmas of choice’,35 social decision-makers
36
The Status of Social Policy
are bound to feel confused without an ideological map capable of focusing their attention. Thus, ‘social policy models . . . with all their apparent remoteness from reality, can serve a purpose in providing us with an ideological framework which may stimulate us to ask the significant questions and to expose the significant choices’.36 Social policy presupposes social choices which presuppose social values. It must evolve from widely held attitudes rather than be imposed from above by a power élite. Societies, like individuals, must make choices. In a democracy these choices must be made collectively. Suppose, for example, that the decision-maker is confronted with a choice between equity and equality, between selectivity and universalism, between cost-effectiveness and social justice, between individual liberty and collective responsibility, or between the principle of charity and that of compensation. Suppose, in a concrete case, that he or she must decide whether an income maintenance scheme should be associated with compulsory retraining and rehabilitation (or, alternatively, be extended indefinitely to an alcoholic or an addict who refuses to bend his way of life to the consensual norm); or whether poor parents should receive cash supplementation (rather than payments in kind or in vouchers tied to specific purposes such as schooling or transport); or whether to means-test applicants for supplementary benefits (instead of providing these benefits as of right). In all of these cases science provides no more than a spectrum of choices and a unique answer can only be found by consulting the social matrix. The solution then depends ‘on the relative importance we accord to economic growth and social growth, and on how the scales are weighted between the rights of the individual and the rights of society’.37 Even the allocation of scarce resources by the market mechanism, to be legitimate, must be legitimated by social choice. It is therefore eminently plausible that the market will on occasion be rejected in favour of other social mechanisms of allocation, either because it undermines social integration or because it simply fails to meet ‘publicly acknowledged needs’.38
Social policy, as has been seen, is conservative in nature in so far as it is concerned with those needs which must be satisfied if the existing social matrix is to continue in existence. Yet it is also radical because of the wide range of choices (choices concerning both ends and means) that is open to a society in the shaping of its own
The Definition of Social Policy
37
future. Titmuss believed that social policy ought to be active rather than passive. It must, he said, function as the instrument of a ‘modern democratic society’ in achieving its collective goals: ‘Social security has to be seen as an agent of structural change; not as a system reflecting and legitimating the status quo.’39 A good example of the active social engineering role that Titmuss intended for welfare may be found in the advice he gave to the Government of Mauritius. The problem in Mauritius was an alarmingly rapid rise in population after the Second World War, caused by a sudden fall in mortality rates (following the virtual eradication of malaria and tuberculosis) and by an extremely high birth-rate. The latter was a social fact due partly to the low status of women (who married young since they were not expected to take jobs nor found it easy to obtain them) and partly to the social insurance function of a large family in a country without comprehensive pension provision. The result of the rise in population was unemployment, underemployment, pressure on state services such as education, and falling standards of living (measured in terms of gross national product per capita). When Titmuss went to Mauritius in 1960, the country had one of the most rapidly expanding populations in the world. Employment opportunities were not increasing at the same rate as the number of potential workers. Naturally Titmuss could not recommend an increase in mortality rates; and an increase in jobs, while desirable, was both a longterm measure and inadequate by itself if the population continued to increase so rapidly. Hence Titmuss’s solution was to reduce fertility. His proposals fall into two groups. First, he called for voluntary birth-control and recommended a nationwide campaign to provide free facilities and information. He advised that every cinema and newspaper should include an advertisement at least once a week on the benefits of the three-child family and bringing out the fact that family planning is essential for social progress. Showing considerable tolerance, however, he recognised the validity of religious objections to contraception and proposed that the new services should neither be compulsory nor prohibited: The right of any individual on religious or any other ground to refuse to use these services or any particular method of family limitation must be safeguarded. The right of those who wish to know and who wish to use the services must equally be upheld.
38
The Status of Social Policy
The tolerances and courtesies of a liberal society must be practised by all. The illiberalities of some must not thrive on the courtesies of others.40 In their report to the Government of Tanganyika four years later he and his colleagues adopted an identical position. The State, they recommended, should help disseminate information about family planning (thereby giving the citizenry a legitimate choice by showing them how far births can be controlled), but it should not make the small family compulsory: ‘It is for the people of Tanganyika to say whether they would prefer to have fewer and stronger children than large numbers of undersized and sickly children . . . These are questions which parents must decide. They cannot be the subject of legislation or any form of regulation.’41 Secondly, Titmuss proposed the creative manipulation of the pattern of social benefits to help bring about an immediate change-over to the small-sized three-child family system that he regarded as essential to contain the Malthusian momentum. Thus he recommended that there should be a ‘Small Family Pension Benefit’ of an extra 15 rupees per month. This would be payable to a woman of 65 or over who had given birth to not more than three live-born children and thus helped to solve the community’s most pressing social problem. The proviso was that she was still married at age 65 and had married before she was 45.42 Again, a maternity benefit was to be provided to no woman who had borne a child (living or dead) within the 24 months before the expected date of the birth for which she was claiming. This would encourage the spacing of children. Some of the proposals were even more microscopic and targeted. No woman, for instance, was to receive maternity benefit if she was under 21 (to encourage a later start to families), or if she already had three living children (to keep down the size of families), or if her husband had in the previous year been assessed for income tax (to skew the benefits towards the poor), or if she could not prove she had access to information on family planning at an antenatal clinic (even if she did not in fact make use of contraceptive techniques).43 Titmuss also recommended a system of family allowances aimed at discouraging the large family. A benefit of 15 rupees per month was to be paid to each family with three dependent children under the age of 14. There was, however, to be no increase in benefit if the family had more than three children and no payment at all if
The Definition of Social Policy
39
there were less than three (the idea being that, in the absence of financial aid for their first or second child, would-be parents would postpone starting a family until later when they were richer).44 The system was to be non-contributory (so as to reach even the poorest members of the community). It was to replace tax allowances for children. These, because income taxes in Mauritius were progressive, were of greater value to the rich than to the poor.45 Titmuss went still further in harnessing social welfare in the service of society. He recommended that a non-contributory benefit of 50 rupees should on the occasion of a marriage be paid to the father of the bride where both bride and groom were 21 years of age or older and provided the woman had had no previous children.46 He suggested that the minimum age for marriage should for women be raised from 15 to 18.47 Both measures would encourage later marriage and reduce the period available for child-bearing. At the same time Mauritian doctors should be induced to work in Mauritius. Here again the Welfare State could help. Student grants should, Titmuss advised, be awarded increasingly for Mauritians to study in countries like Australia rather than Britain or France, for the simple reason that – Australia then showing a preference for white immigrants – they were less likely to settle permanently in Australia.48 Similarly, a definite quota of scholarships for study abroad should be reserved for women: quite apart from improving career prospects for women, such a stratagem would help to increase the pool of professionals on the island, since women students are more likely than their male counterparts to return home after qualifying.49 In this way, too, social welfare has an active role to play in helping to mould and structure the nature of Mauritian society.
It was because he believed that the ‘integrated community services’ of the modern Welfare State should be active rather than passive that Titmuss opposed those thinkers in Britain and the United States who, he felt, were fighting a rearguard action against collective progress by arguing for the privatisation or reprivatisation of welfare services. His reasoning was that, if the expansion of social services has a positive influence on the national health, then their contraction and their replacement by private provision is bound to have a negative influence. An example is the move ‘to set people free from the conscience of obligation’50 by establishing private markets for blood, eyes, kidneys
40
The Status of Social Policy
and other human tissues and organs (while still accepting that a market to buy and sell the whole living human being is immoral). This movement is dangerous since a substantial social cost arises whenever voluntary gifts are replaced by commercialism: ‘It is likely that a decline in the spirit of altruism in one sphere of human activities will be accompanied by similar changes in attitudes, motives and relationships in other spheres.’51 Clearly, ‘if dollars or pounds exchange for blood then it may be morally acceptable for a myriad of other human activities and relationships also to exchange for dollars or pounds. Economists may fragment systems and values; other people do not.’52 The observer of the social scene must be sensitised to its dynamic as well as to its static properties. Specifically, he must recognise the fact that an erosion of the sense of community is likely to result from an extension of the role of market transfers in social life: Once man begins to say, as he sees that dollars exchange for blood supplies from Skid Row and a poor and often coloured population of sellers, ‘I need no longer experience (or suffer from) a sense of responsibility (or sin) in not giving to my neighbour’ then the consequences are likely to be socially pervasive. There is nothing permanent about the expression of reciprocity. If the bonds of community giving are broken the result is not a state of value neutralism. The vacuum is likely to be filled by hostility and social conflict.53 The ideologists of free enterprise capitalism tend to neglect the social costs that result from the narrowing of social choices to those alternatives associated with the market mechanism. They tend to obscure the spectrum of potential choices that in fact exists. Such an attitude means that a very large number of economists in practice, and despite their oath of value-neutrality, ‘perform as missionaries in the social welfare field and often give the impression of possessively owning a hot line to God’.54 Although naïve rather than malicious, such libertarians none the less are dangerous once it is recognised that ‘the myth of maximizing economic growth can supplant the growth of social relations’.55 Market economists are insensitive to such relations. The reason is that they are imbued with an outdated methodological individualism, with abstractions lingering on from the nineteenth century and ‘wrapped round the
The Definition of Social Policy
41
concept of individual man acting outside the matrix of his particular society’.56 The possessive individualism of market capitalism is unacceptable in the social-policy field. To begin with, it favours economic growth and neglects other welfare needs and objectives of the social group. Yet increasingly ‘we have begun to recognise that social growth – the need for integration, the need for more equality of opportunity, the need for freedom from want – deserves as much attention, intellectually as well as in terms of political action, as economic growth’.57 Then, too, market-oriented theories stress the bilateral transfer and neglect the ethical superiority of the gift. This is the direct opposite of Titmuss’s own view that altruism in giving to a stranger does not begin and end with blood donations, and that as often as possible people should be put in situations where they can get in the habit of making gifts rather than bargaining contracts. In the last analysis, therefore, social policy is not simply about therapy for the dependent but about how people interact. It ought most of all to focus ‘on processes, transactions and institutions which promote an individual’s sense of identity, participation and community and allow him more freedom of choice for the expression of altruism and which, simultaneously, discourage a sense of individual alienation’.58
Social policy focuses on integration and involvement. So does what Titmuss believed to be socialism: ‘Socialism is about community as well as equality. It is about what we contribute without price to the community and how we act and live as socialists.’59 Socialism is not simply about levelling, about how much of the rich person’s property the poor person can expect to enjoy, for ‘socialism is also about giving’.60 The fact is that the paradigm of good social policy coincides with that of the good society as conceived by the good socialist, and is the stranger-gift in blood donation. Perhaps it is true that the term social policy itself ‘does not imply allegiance to any political party or ideology’.61 It is no less true, however, that social policy as conceived of by Titmuss can hardly be divorced from what he defined to be socialism. Both make a value-judgement stressing integration, redistribution, community and altruism. Both recognise the social significance of individual needs. As Titmuss puts it, ‘socialist social policies are, in my view, totally different in their purposes, philosophy and attitudes to people from Conservative
42
The Status of Social Policy
social policies. They are (or should be) pre-eminently about equality, freedom and social integration.’62 His comparison between the Labour Party’s National Superannuation Bill (lost in 1970) and the Conservatives’ Social Security Bill led him to conclude that ‘choice in this particular area of social policy is not just a matter of detail – of marginal differences in administrative organisation and social engineering. At bottom, the real choice consists of two fundamental contrasting views of the objectives of social policy and different interpretations of the nature of man.’63 Here, as always, choice involves ideology and values. Here, as always, Titmuss makes clear where his own sympathies lie. Titmuss believed that man must continue to ‘reach out for the politically impossible’, and ought not simply to ‘busy himself with the resurrection of utilitarian theory’ or (no less deplorable) to ‘cultivate the new stoicism of affluence’.64 He had reason, moreover, to be optimistic about the future. By opting in Titmuss’s own time for the new Welfare State, the electorate had made a value-judgement in favour of social justice and the community. In such circumstances a socialist might truly be tempted to conclude that what is is rapidly becoming what ought to be.
3 Some Methodological Considerations
Social policy exists in a social context. Social scientists have a unique opportunity to be of service to the group. Hence the methodological importance of four interrelated concepts: generalism, humanism, relevance and scepticism.
First, generalism. Titmuss believed that ‘the study of social policy cannot be isolated from the study of society as a whole in all its varied social, economic and political aspects’.1 In discussing social policy, it is not possible to abstract from the complex changes taking place in a complex society (changes, for example, in population, the position of women, the family, social stratification, race, mobility, urbanisation, industrialisation, the work ethic). Nor is it sensible to brush aside the multiplicity of human needs, which make any policy discussion many-sided, multidisciplinary and interdisciplinary. The discipline of Social Policy and Administration ‘does not claim to be a distinctive, separate discipline’2 or a ‘self-contained specialism’.3 Rather, it is dependent on ‘the methods, techniques and insights of the historian, the economist, the statistician, the sociologist or, on occasion, some of the perspectives of the philosopher’.4 Indeed, the subject is ‘the concern of all who live in an industrial, urban country’.5 The discipline itself has an integrative function. Infringing ‘the unwritten rules of academic trespass’,6 it is able as a result to offer the ‘imaginative excitements of unifying perspectives and principles’.7 The student of social policy must therefore be sensitised both to the fact that social policy exists in the broader context of society itself and to the complexity of human beings. Unfortunately, the 43
44
The Status of Social Policy
extensive and often excessive division of labour in scientific research is a force operating in the opposite direction. Nowadays, Titmuss wrote, many social scientists are no longer able to see the whole human being: ‘Industrial psychologists and sociologists . . . seem to be falling into much the same trap as some economists. Hence they observe only a part and a steadily smaller part of man’s life in highly industrialized societies.’8 It is a sad fact that professionals (including the ‘less gifted and less perceptive research worker’9) do like to retreat to some small allotment of skill and specialised knowledge where they feel secure. It also consolidates their social status if their role and function are clearly defined and well known. It should not be forgotten, Titmuss said, that ‘professional people, whether they be doctors, social workers or teachers, are pre-eminently people with status problems’.10 Nowadays, ‘most professions . . . may sometimes be regarded as associations for spreading the gospel of self-importance’.11 Excessive compartmentalism is an occupational hazard of excessive professionalism. In the socialpolicy field at least, the specialist must overcome his fear of trespass and recognise the need to be to some extent a generalist.
Second, humanism. One of the reasons why Titmuss so strongly advocated generalism was his belief that a citizen must be seen in his fullness and richness, as an actor who plays many parts (a worker perhaps, but also a father or a mother, a member of a community, and so on). He believed that narrow scientism and the tendency to regard people as numbers in a table was the enemy of humanism. He warned of the danger ‘that concern for the value and uniqueness of the individual human being may be diminished if the scientific outlook spreads to embrace more and more of human affairs’.12 Titmuss recognised that statistical tools are a considerable help to the scholar as they enable the investigator to recreate human situations. He made a point, however, of looking behind the figures in order to reconstruct the real individuals who were hidden there. The following discussion of why a mother might have wanted to return from wartime evacuation to the dangers of an urban community is a good illustration of his tendency to personalise and of his sensitivity to real people: There were the savings clubs and the sickness associations which bound contributors to a particular voluntary hospital or firm of
Some Methodological Considerations
45
doctors; the well-known school treatment clinic or ‘welfare’ where you could get different forms of help from people who understood your trouble; the friendly society, insurance agent or co-operative, upon one of which you were relying for a small sum to buy new blankets or an extra bed; the medical officer to whom you could look for cod-liver oil for the baby, or advice about Mary’s ear trouble; the health visitor – an old friend – who had done so much when Jimmy was ill and had seen him grow up and leave school; the midwife who had made arrangements for a friend to look after Jane when the last baby arrived; the lady at the Charity Organisation Society who had helped when father had all his teeth out; the school nurse, the teacher, the lady at the hospital, the assistance man and, finally, the serried ranks of check traders, secondhand dealers, hire-purchase firms and club roundsmen. These were the people who were known, liked, disliked or tolerated. They fitted into a part of life that had meaning. They were the people who helped to stop the leaks, who patched and repaired and encouraged in the cycle of birth, marriage, illness, death and all the ‘rude inelegance of poverty’.13 In this passage Titmuss demonstrates (apart from his evident admiration for the seamless web of the working-class community) a novelist’s capacity to write lyrical prose coupled with a novelist’s ability to get inside the minds of other people. Nor is this passage an isolated instance. As another example of his ability to empathise with people’s detailed perceptions of their own lives, consider his discussion of those unfortunate city-dwellers who ‘trekked’ in wartime from the towns in order to spend each night in the country: The fact that many people chose to trudge off into the country each evening did not, by itself, imply a deterioration in morale. These people were afraid of the bombs; of dark hours of wakefulness, of listening, sometimes tense and sometimes nodding, for the drawn-out whine, and then the rumbling murmur of a house collapsing in the blackness. Above all, they wanted sleep; for sleep was forgetfulness and rest.14 Such passages must not be written off as obiter dictum sentimentality. They show that real understanding of the human condition which Titmuss envisaged as an essential complement to statistical tabulation.
46
The Status of Social Policy
Third, relevance. Social policy has the power both to observe facts and to create them, but the social scientist ought not to prescribe ends for the community and should accept the values it evolves. The scientist can attempt to persuade the community that its aims are incompatible or even undesirable. Academia, however, must in the last analysis accept that there is a premium on social relevance and that the search for knowledge must be in the service of society. Because of his stress on relevance, Titmuss had occasion to warn the universities that they ought not to be ‘abstracted from society and wholly unresponsive to the needs of their times’:15 ‘No university can be free to establish, say, a faculty of veterinary medicine; to buy as many computers as it thinks fit; to concentrate its resources on teaching students from other countries; or to ignore completely the needs of society.’16 Titmuss reminded the universities that they are financed by the group and must show ‘responsiveness to the welfare objectives of that society’.17 They must meet ‘the trained manpower needs of their age’18 and plan ahead to ensure that their nation will have adequate trained personnel with requisite skills at some date in the future. They must not forget that their obligation is ‘to serve the needs of others and society at large’19 as well as to attend to the aspirations of their staff. The output of a university comprises the twin products of teaching and research. In the case of teaching, a student’s education ought to embody both ‘practical usefulness’ and ‘intellectual excitement’.20 This means, on the one hand, that education ought to help students to acquire specific skills and prepare for a socially useful career: there is a need, as Titmuss puts it, ‘for education which furthers the abilities of men and women to reason and act effectively in a variety of vocational situations’. 21 It also means, on the other hand, that education ought to help students to think independently. While rejecting as élitist the claim that ‘learning to think’ is an end in itself, and while insisting that people must be able to act as well as reflect, Titmuss none the less deplored the promotion through education of excessive specialisation: Consider the growing substitution of specialization for general education. What education for democracy is there in much of the professionalized, sectionalized diet served up today to students in most universities, technical colleges, teachers’ training courses and other places of instruction? Are we not, indeed, witnessing a triumph of technique over purpose? What, in fact, are we
Some Methodological Considerations
47
offering to a majority of the young beside material success, the social graces, vocational techniques and, in particular, professional salvation?22 Titmuss rejected cost–benefit studies made of the effects of education on the grounds that a high rate of return on investment in training might reflect precisely that economic progress which is purchased at the cost of social growth: ‘The current obsession which sees education as capital investment for the purpose of “keeping up in the economic race” suggests that our values are being distorted.’23 He also warned against excessive credentialism, ‘the ultimate absurdity of which might be that no public gardener would be allowed to grow roses without a Ph.D. in Horticulture’.24 In the social policy field, education can play a vital role in helping to train humane and enlightened social workers and other personnel, and to challenge knee-jerk attitudes and conventions which impede an improvement in service. Such improvement is not just a question of quantity of resources. It is also a question of quality of staff: We know now from experience in Britain that we did not abolish the spirit of the old and hated poor law by enacting new legislation in 1948. The same people – the same administrators and workers – still had to run the hospitals, public assistance offices and welfare services. They poured into the new social service bottles the old wine of discrimination and prejudice.25 The second product of the university is research. It too should be relevant to the needs of society. Research must be the servant, not the master, and must be aimed at helping people to acquire better control over their environment so that they have more freedom to develop their personality. Again, personal contact of students with lecturers is, like personal contact of patients with doctors, vital to prevent alienation; and hence lecturers should avoid a flight into research where it means the neglect of teaching. Combining these two points, it would be true to say that a lecturer who does research on non-relevant subjects and simultaneously treats his teaching as a burden is attempting to secure his individual self-advancement at the expense of the group. In the domain of social policy, research has the important social function of helping the community to get at the facts of the social
48
The Status of Social Policy
situation. In that way it enables the society to make intelligent choices on the basis of hard evidence rather than in that intellectual darkness where myth and prejudice thrive. Titmuss had ‘a strong belief that one of the purposes of the university in the modern world is to help society to make informed political choices about economic growth, about social growth and about educational growth’.26 Seeking the facts, the scholar is also serving his nation. Hence the academic should recognise that his primary duty is to the truth, not to professional success nor even to political ideology. He cannot, of course, escape his ideology, but he ought at least to indicate where his evidence stops and his bias begins: Our first and last duty is to the truth. It is because I am sceptical of the claims that are sometimes made for a value-free social science that I restate this fundamental allegiance. The values that we hold should be clear to our students; the evidence on all sides should also be clear. It is part of our responsibilities to expose more clearly the value choices that confront societies in the arena of social welfare.27 Social policies are likely to be more effective if they are ‘grounded in a basis of fact about reality’;28 and clearly, ‘social diagnosis is needed as well as individual therapy’.29 If the dependent are to be helped, they must first be identified and information about their condition must be made available to policy-makers. Similarly, any action to deal with the distribution of income and wealth or the burden on the health services is more likely to succeed if assertions can be avoided which ‘do not rest on any firm basis of fact’.30 The Welfare State has not always benefited most those whose needs are the greatest. Part of the reason has been inadequate comprehension of user-patterns and latent wants: ‘Only now are we coming to see that we need much sharper tools of social study and measurement; more precise social analysis of conditions, needs and the actual functioning of services; more attempts at social planning in alliance with economic planning.’31 In short, research in social policy, like teaching, has a dual function. It is enlightening and even exhilarating in its own right in so far as it advances ‘our knowledge of human behaviour in situations of change’.32 It is socially useful in so far as it is instrumental in bringing about a change in situations. Social policies must be formulated on the basis of observations and forecasts. Titmuss was understandably critical of the lack of
Some Methodological Considerations
49
intellectual preparedness in Britain on the eve of the Second World War: No Cabinet committee maintained a continuous watch over the social services. No research was conducted into the effects of bombing on the apparatus of civilian life. No comprehensive study was made of the social consequences that might flow from the kind of war that the Government expected. Inadequate factual knowledge and an inadequate endeavour to acquire it, a deep ignorance of social relationships and a shallow interest in social research – these things were later to handicap the work of Government Departments.33 Fourth, scepticism. Titmuss believed, as has been seen, that the facts are, regardless of one’s value-orientation, the prerequisite for reasoned argument. He warned that ‘if English social history is any guide, confusion has often been the mother of complacency’.34 He also believed, however, that the academic should recognise the limits put upon his evidence by the unavoidable truth that in the human sciences not all variables are measurable, even through proxies and indicators. The fact is that the world of social welfare does not usually lend itself to precise quantification: ‘We cannot easily measure the effects of particular delivery systems in the satisfaction of education, medical care, child guidance, adoption procedures, cash transfer payments and so forth.’35 It is difficult to compare the value of two years of nursery education to a three-year-old child with the benefit accruing from two years of postgraduate education to a student reading for a Ph.D.; or to know what money value to assign to a human life saved in hospital; or to estimate the costs of urban slums in terms of resentment and bitterness, racial tension and felt discrimination; or to know the extent to which altruism, by diminishing alienation, reduces the incidence of dishonesty and violence in social life; or to calculate the distress caused by the maiming, death or mental breakdown of a loved one in time of war. In general terms, we may conclude that there are few quantifiable indices of costs and benefits basically qualitative in nature: There are few criteria of success (though there are negative ones in the form of failure) in assessing the performance of social service systems. What is, for example, success for the Director of
50
The Status of Social Policy
a Social Services Department, the Manager of a Supplementary Benefits or public assistance office, a general practitioner, a probation officer, a hostel manager for homeless people or discharged manic depressives?36 In such cases success indicators may be impossible to calculate and society may have no choice but to rely on the informed assessment and professional ethic of people who are expert in the field. Value-judgements are inescapable, crude fact-gathering therefore insufficient. Success in making husbands pay maintenance to wives, for example, could mean a data-bank society and with it the failure to preserve individual privacy. There is no scientific means of ascertaining whether the transfers would outweigh the invasiveness.37 Again, while universities ought as recipients of social funds to be cost-conscious, they ought also to recognise that their objectives are social as well as economic. They are for that reason obliged to reject the ‘narrow world of the accountant or the sillier notions of “productivity” as applied to higher education’.38 In the last analysis, ‘human welfare is an ethical concept’.39 In any case, a study of success and failure in social policy would be a complex exercise were it to take into account (as it should) all present and future social costs and benefits by using a generalised sociological approach. It would be necessary to know, for instance, the percentage of the cost of a patient’s stay in hospital that should be assigned to teaching and research done on him (and thus what economic ‘price’ should be the doctor’s imputed payment to the patient for the right to use him as an input); or the opportunity cost of the voluntary blood donor’s time (remembering that the data are not precise: ‘For women donors the value of housewives’ services cannot be measured’40); or the specific value of the integration and altruism that are engendered over time by universalism in place of the market. The difficulties imposed by the temporal factor should not be underestimated. A mental patient discharged may represent success for the mental hospital (since the client is then ‘off the books’), but this success may also mean the demand for a place in a hostel for the single homeless, for unemployment benefits, possibly even for police services, prisons and research to explain a subsequent increase in crime. Here, when the case is followed up, it becomes apparent that a narrow cost–benefit study of the hospital alone would ignore many highly relevant costs and
Some Methodological Considerations
51
benefits throughout society. It also becomes apparent that a broader cost–benefit study would be virtually impossible to carry out. It is significant that Titmuss makes no attempt to use such an approach in his study of blood-banking systems. The social scientist must face the fact that much of the knowledge of how socialised beings live together in groups is vague, imprecise, impressionistic, collected in situational contexts which are themselves diverse, intricate and changing. The student of social policy must recognise that the mechanistic method (involving ‘a questionnaire, a random sample of delinquents, and a computer’41) is not a substitute for the test of the intellect; and that the field of social policy offers no quantifiable indices comparable to the engineer’s measurement of efficiency or the economist’s estimation of managerial success in terms of profits. The student of social policy must come to see that, compared with the more prestigious natural sciences, we cannot so easily measure the complex sicknesses of a complex society; the prevalence of the stress diseases of modern civilization, the instabilities of family relationships or the extent of mental ill-health in the community. Difficulties of accurate measurement should not prevent us, however, from seeking to extend our knowledge of the causes at work.42
52
The Status of Social Policy
4 Part One: Evaluations and Extensions
Social policy is concerned with social values and collectively defined needs. The consensus is at once the conservative consequence of past occurrences and the radical cause of future departures. Welfare policies vary with ideology in time and space rather than converging to equilibrium along a unique developmental trajectory. Privatisation would threaten the self-perpetuating community by legitimating the divisiveness of the Hobbesian bellum. Socialism would reinforce the bonds of belonging by putting in place integrative institutions which reaffirm the common and the shared. The social scientist, a social actor like his fellows, cannot afford to neglect the methodological importance of multidisciplinarity, understanding, a sensitivity to social purpose and an acceptance that there are limits beyond which the statistics will never go. What it all adds up to is this, that ‘social administration as a subject is not a messy conglomeration of the technical ad hoc’1 but instead a focus for the ‘imaginative excitements of unifying perspectives and principles’.2 The driving force is the overlapping ethic. The embedding context is the interdependent matrix. On the one hand there is the pursuit of the ideal. On the other hand there is the preservation of the organic. It is the task of this chapter to evaluate Titmuss’s vision of the status of social policy and to explore the ways in which it might be extended to meet the needs of a world that Titmuss never knew. Titmuss would have welcomed the search, arguing as he always did that to fossilise an answer is to deprive it of sense: Choices have continually to be made in the modern democratic state. We cannot make them for all time – either about the kind of services people need or the ways in which services are organised, administered 52
Evaluations and Extensions
53
and paid for. Continually to rely on the solutions of yesterday – whether they were reached through the accidents and the forces of history or by the deliberate decisions of men – is eventually to leave society without a sense of social direction. Nor can it be found by forgetting the past in a single-minded search for more material wealth.3 Social policy must move on if it is not to be left behind. Whether Titmuss would have been in broad agreement with the precise evaluations, with the specific extensions that form the subject of the two sections of this chapter can, needless to say, only be a matter for conjecture and debate.
(a) The sub-division of welfare Titmuss states that human blood is not a ‘trading commodity, a market good like aspirins or cars’, but rather a ‘service rendered by the community for the community’.4 The still photograph of the British status quo is clear enough. The analytical dividing-line between trading commodities like aspirins and cars in the one lane, community-confirming services like blood for transfusions in the other is, however, more of a problem. It is never easy to prescribe just how much social policy a responsibly mixed economy ought to select, just how much private enterprise it ought to include in its portfolio. Concerned that is-ness is being left de facto the sole test of ought-ness by a democratic consensualist reluctant to take a lead, the reader may object that Titmuss’s theories provide insufficient guidance as to the proper location of the boundary between the freely given and the paid-for through exchange. Titmuss consistently stressed the need for clarity – for a cast-iron grip on ‘the rationale of the social services; the roles they are playing in society, and the ends to which, separately and in combination, they are directed’.5 As an empiricist who was also a philosopher, he believed that phenomena had evolved so rapidly in the area of social policy that conceptualisation and understanding had regrettably been left behind: The social services are the product of the 20th century and the rapidity of their development has not been accompanied by a parallel development in theoretical analysis . . . Most of the textbooks on the subject are confined to straightforward, descriptive accounts of organisation and statutory provision.6
54
The Status of Social Policy
Titmuss knew that there was an explanation gap in the subject area. Importantly, he also went out of his way to say that there were limits to what he could do. The reader who objects that Titmuss is excessively vague as to the ideal boundary between the welfare sector and the market should be reminded that Titmuss himself experienced a similar frustration at being unable to identify the precise boundaries of his camp. Thus Titmuss in 1967 was telling Greeks that his was an ‘immense field . . . Definition like beauty . . . what is and what is not a Social Service? A political definition, a sociological definition, or an economic one?’7 In 1964 he was informing Israelis that he was not in a position to name the optimum: ‘I am no expert. Welfare is concerned with social values and human relations. It may be the embodiment, carrier and expression of a philosophy of everyman’s place in society. There is no authoritarian role here for the expert.’8 In the 1950s he was admitting to Scots that only a decade after Beveridge he was already without a compass: ‘I come to tell you that the maps most of us use are out-of-date; that Beveridge is a better guide to the 1930s than the 1950s; and that the social service world, as a separate, autonomous entity, does not exist.’9 Titmuss knew that the precondition for the study of the caring sector was an unambiguous specification of what the black box contained. He also knew that he himself could not supply the checklist that was so much in demand. A lecture from the 1950s – its sub-title is ‘An Essay in Confusion’ – reveals his own frustration at being forced to start from here when the here in question had for him no intrinsic appeal: ‘Even a superficial analysis will show that it is almost accidental whether a particular need, when met, is or is not regarded as a social service.’10 The Health Service is in. Marriage guidance is out. School meals are subsidised welfare. Works canteens are a fringe benefit. Shakespeare read in a classroom is the gift relationship. Shakespeare seen in a theatre is a commercial transaction. Titmuss was sharply critical of the complacent conventionalism that made yesterday’s accidents into today’s ‘done thing’ in cases such as these: ‘There is little that is rational about this classification.’11 Titmuss made a diagnosis of an inescapable ‘confusion which surrounds the concept of what constitutes a social service’.12 Valuable as is the way in which he elucidated the categories (by showing, say, that private pensions in common with state pensions are in receipt of fiscal support), the fact remains that Titmuss, aware as he was of the
Evaluations and Extensions
55
boundary-line problem, was in the last analysis unprepared to be precise about the activities that belong to sharing, the activities that can be delegated to Mammon with some benefit.
The ambiguity is a source of especial difficulty in the case of those goods and services which are actively in supply on both sides of the public–private divide. Human blood must be procured and distributed on a community-confirming basis if it is not to pass on the stranger gifts of hepatitis and conflict. Aspirins and cars are satisfactorily supplied through profit-seeking capitalism that requires neither nationalisation nor planning to deliver with efficiency. The either/ors are clear enough. What is less clear in Titmuss’s work is the legitimacy of coexisting provision in areas such as health, education and insurance where both welfare and exchange had a significant presence. Titmuss was in favour of equality of opportunity and community of experience. He also believed that state services performed better than commercial in mixed industries where direct comparisons could be made. For those two reasons one would have expected him to recommend the suppression of crude economism and market competition in those welfare activities which had ill-advisedly settled where they did not belong. One would have been wrong. Titmuss defended the availability of pay beds in state hospitals and the existence of a parallel system of private medicine. In respect of the educational head start, he knew what the public schools meant in terms of facilities and contacts but only once directly recommended their incorporation into the state system. That uncharacteristic call to end the mixed educational economy was made in the Introduction Titmuss wrote for the 1964 reprint of Tawney’s Equality. The demand was not repeated. Titmuss had nothing to say about the nationalisation of the British pharmaceutical industry (despite the symbiotic links it maintained and maintains with its dominant customer, the National Health, links so intimate as to recall the American military–industrial complex). Nor did he consider the social ownership of the private insurance corporations (companies seen to be socially divisive to the extent that they perpetuate economic inequalities into states of dependency; and within which, Titmuss believed, non-accountable managers combine maximal power with minimal social responsibility). Tawney had recommended the state ownership of the banking sector
56
The Status of Social Policy
– ‘for it determines the economic weather more directly than any other’.13 Titmuss was unprepared to prescribe the same medicine for the private insurance corporations – although he was clear in his own mind that private bureaucracies were depriving the nation both of the integration and of the performance that state bureaucracies were in a strong position to deliver. Titmuss advises a pragmatic and open-minded assessment of the options: ‘The alternative to public policies to-day in respect to many social needs for most people is not “free enterprise” . . . The real choice is between one “bigness” and another “bigness”.’14 His assessment completed, Titmuss is then strangely silent on the extent to which the norm of altruism, good business and good moral philosophy in the social welfare sector, should be liberated for progress in the capitalist market economy which retains a high profile in welfare-replicating commodities like insurance. In the case of insurance, Titmuss was at least prepared to advocate greater state regulation. Noting, for example, that insurance companies in five of the original six Common Market countries were obliged by law to invest a substantial part of their funds in government stock, he advised that the British Government take similar measures to compel such loans.15 Otherwise, he accepted that the dual system in insurance (like the dual system in health and education) was to be regarded as a fact of life. Private insurance in that way acquired the status of a ‘trading commodity’ (on the model of aspirins and cars) – while state insurance, of course, remained resolutely a ‘service rendered by the community for the community’ (as if blood donated to help unnamed strangers or aid to poorer countries under threat from a drought). Yet insurance is insurance, just as blood is blood. Titmuss’s accommodating tolerance in the face of a dual system that was also a dual standard, of Apartheid-like structures that segregated the wealthy from their less prosperous team-mates, would seem to be at variance with the citizenship-based ideal of upgrading ‘from working-class standards to m/c standards’: ‘The objective [is] to abolish two standards of medical care, education, housing, social security and welfare generally.’16 It is possible that Titmuss was too timid – too moderate – in respect of the welfare-replicating sector that was a de facto obstacle to equality and integration. In Titmuss’s defence, however, it must be emphasised that Fabians make haste slowly and that Titmuss saw no need for an instantaneous unification. Titmuss indisputably regarded the state system
Evaluations and Extensions
57
as potentially a comprehensive one, but he also knew that democratic consensus was the sine qua non. A believer in persuasion and choice rather than regimentation and force, he probably reasoned to himself that the separation between public and private would one day be transcended; that the dual system would ultimately become one; and that the key to universality by consent lay in the last analysis in the demonstration effect of that which is not only free and accessible but provides a better service as well. Such an interpretation, filling in the gaps in what Titmuss wrote, is an extension of his model that retains the ideal of the gift of blood as the paradigm for good social policy but also accepts that compromise is necessary if other people (including wealthy people) are to be treated with respect.
Titmuss was always resistant to the term ‘Welfare State’ – ‘Do not know what it means’17 is a characteristic reaction – but appears to have defined it as the embodiment of two interrelated aspirations, two sets of objectives which together point unreservedly to ‘an enlargement of social responsibility’.18 The first element is well represented in his published books and articles. The second element, regrettably, is discussed only in unpublished lectures and notes. The consequence of the imbalance is a failure to appreciate the significance of what might be called ‘macroeconomic welfare’ in the socio-economic system of Richard Titmuss. The first of the two elements is the familiar objective of inclusion and levelling up, ‘the transformation in aims of limited, public assistance social policies to comprehensive, citizenship policies’.19 Thence come the services in kind of housing and social work, together with the well-financed empowerment that makes a reality of ‘equal opportunities to education and health’.20 Thence come the payments in cash that make child benefits, disability allowances and old-age pensions a means of affirming ‘collective responsibility for minimum subsistence for all citizens . . . in times of adversity and non-earning’.21 Titmuss was perceptive enough to recognise that alongside state welfare there existed the parallel systems of occupational welfare (an example would be company pensions) and fiscal welfare (consider tax relief for mortgage interest) that satisfied the same need for society’s most fundamental services. The second of the two elements makes the ‘Welfare State’ quite explicitly a macroeconomic State in the sense that the government
58
The Status of Social Policy
is obliged to take upon itself the ‘Collective responsibility for Full Employment. The Right to Work. Control and Supervision of the economy. The Keynesian Revolution. The avoidance of mass unemployment.’ 22 Titmuss said that it was one of the defining characteristics of the commitment to welfare that there would have to be ‘a more positive policy of State management of the economy – adoption of full employment as a policy – deliberate selection of priorities (housing before cinemas, etc.) – and a greater use of fiscal, monetary and physical instruments to achieve certain ends’.23 Titmuss’s published work gives the impression that he took full employment as background economics and not as a topic in social policy. Titmuss’s unpublished work demonstrates that for him an interventionist macroeconomics could be a characteristic of the ‘Welfare State’ too. Keynes in the General Theory had in 1936 continued his earlier theme of ‘The End of Laissez-Faire’ by arguing strongly that market homeostasis could not be relied upon either to ensure fair shares or to eliminate excess capacity: ‘The outstanding faults of the economic society in which we live are its failure to provide for full employment and its arbitrary and inequitable distribution of wealth and incomes.’24 The duality of Keynes’s critique of the invisible hand – social injustice combined with macroeconomic slack – looks forward not just to Titmuss on the ‘Welfare State’ but also to Beveridge and the reforming Liberalism that Titmuss had imbibed in Hendon before he came into contact with the Webbs. Thus Beveridge in the mould-making White Paper of 1942 had made the management of total demand a necessary condition for the relief of residual dependency: ‘A satisfactory scheme of social insurance assumes the maintenance of employment and the prevention of mass unemployment.’25 Social Insurance and Allied Services identifies a warfare State under threat from five ‘giants’. Four of those giants (Want, Disease, Ignorance and Squalor) can be neutralised by means of Titmuss-type social service policies. The fifth, however, is Idleness – a waste of human resources ‘which destroys wealth and corrupts men’26 – and here Beveridge argued that nothing short of a discretionary macroeconomics would be sufficient to correct the twin deficiencies of resourcing and of self-respect: The economic problem is that of doing deliberately in peace that which we are forced to do in war – of creating a community in which men and women have value . . . If full employment is to be
Evaluations and Extensions
59
attained, the target for peace must be such as to set up effective demand for the products of labour constantly exceeding the supply.27 Beveridge, like Keynes, looked to the visible hand both for equity in the balance of endstates and for the opportunity to earn life without which income maintenance, however generous, must still stigmatise and shame: ‘Bread and health are not all that a citizen needs. Idleness even with bread demoralizes.’28 Titmuss, like Beveridge, looked to the ‘Welfare State’ for the prudent demand management that married the right to a social wage to the right to a decent job. Writing after 1944 (when Cmd. 6527 on Employment Policy made a promise that the defeat of the Germans would not be the victory of the dole), writing after 1948 (when full employment was established and underemployment equilibrium crowded out by Beveridge’s utopia of ‘more vacant jobs than unemployed men’29), dying before 1976 (when James Callaghan reassured the International Monetary Fund that price inflation would be contained even if marginal labour had to manage without work), dying before 1979 (when Thatcherite monetarism, accusing welfarism of pushing up the ‘natural rate’, called for supply-side economics to price people back into jobs), Titmuss presumably saw little need to state the obvious or reiterate the accepted in respect of Keynesian macroeconomics as an element in the ‘Welfare State’. That he was prepared where necessary to stand on the shoulders of giants is, however, absolutely clear, if clear almost entirely from his unpublished lectures and hardly at all from his books. Thus Titmuss, speaking in Copenhagen on the British experience of social growth, stated without reservation that it was macroeconomic welfare that had done most to deliver the gains: ‘Improved health, better nutrition, lessening of class consciousness, the reduction of gross poverty, fewer inequalities – owe more to Full Employment than anything else or all the Social Services.’30 Addressing the British Council in London, he made the same point about paid employment and the social revolution: ‘The greatest change since 1939. Full employment. The right to work fulfilled. Cannot emphasise this and its social implications too much.’31 The State’s guarantee of a high level of demand meant not the Marxian reserve army, hungry and anxious, but rather a Smith-like competition on the part of employers to attract and retain. Seen from the perspective of the less advantaged, Titmuss left no doubt, in the notes he made for the British Council talk, that ceiling operation was a fundamental cause of welfare:
60
The Status of Social Policy
‘Security and regularity of income – effects on living standards – more families able to plan ahead. Most important consequence: health and vitality of children – more important than social services.’32 Titmuss is not saying that Keynesianism is a substitute for casework, income support or the Health Service. What he is saying is that the guarantee of a tight market for labour has proved more beneficial in total than have the welfare institutions created since Attlee to relieve distress: Full employment has done more than any or all of these services not only to raise standards of living but to give millions of people a greater sense of self-respect and independence. But of course these social services have contributed – they have had some effects (difficult as they are to measure) on health, productivity, standards of education, family life and other patterns of behaviour in British society.33 That statement, taken from a BBC talk in July 1958 to mark the tenth anniversary of the NHS, is a useful reminder that for Titmuss the ‘Welfare State’ went beyond the caring services to bring in macroeconomic welfare as well.
Macroeconomic welfare is an integral part of the system. Microeconomic welfare, on the other hand, is a domain that Titmuss seldom if ever chose to visit. The omission is a curious one. The market economist will defend laissez-faire with arguments relating to allocational and dynamic efficiency. The classical liberal will see in supply and demand the free and spontaneous contracting of discrete individuals with unique preference patterns. Thinkers whose maximand is growth or autonomy will understandably resist any attempt to make the regulation of business activity a topic in social policy. Titmuss, however, was a consensualist and a welfarist, a man of principle whose priority was not affluence or initiative but instead ‘a more civilized, humane and compassionate society . . . a fairer distribution of wealth and command-over-resources . . . higher standards of social justice for the under-privileged and deprived; more generous treatment for the victims of social change’.34 Given that aid to others ranks so highly in his pantheon of values, it is a curious omission indeed that economic organisations, whether as sellers or as employers, are not to be invited to provide
Evaluations and Extensions
61
microeconomic welfare in acknowledgement of the citizen’s contract with the All. William Temple, with Zimmern in 1934 and Schuster in 1937 among the first (in 1941) to speak of a ‘Welfare State’, wrote eloquently in the year of Beveridge about the need to make the economy the servant and not the master of the ethical and the just: We all recognize that in fact the exploitation of the poor, especially of workhouse children, in the early days of power-factories was an abomination not to be excused by any economic advantage thereby secured; but we fail to recognize that such an admission in a particular instance carries with it the principle that economics are properly subject to a non-economic criterion.35 The Archbishop of Canterbury had learned well the lesson preached by his Rugby contemporary, Tawney: ‘The individual has no absolute rights: they are relative to the function which he performs in the community of which he is a member.’36 Temple and Tawney had no reservations about the sensible deployment of microeconomic welfare such as might serve for particular groups of potential dependants the same function as the macrosocial services. Titmuss chose not to emulate their quasi-Keynesian interventionism. Had he wished to do so, however, there is much he could have prescribed for organisations, both as sellers and employers. The price of goods has an obvious impact on consumers’ wellbeing. Income support and shopping vouchers are the social-welfare response to real wages made intolerably low by the high cost of necessities. Positive as their contribution may be to the enhanced market power of the targeted buyer, it must not be forgotten that state inducements and state directives can fulfil precisely the same value-driven function of bending the buyer–seller relationship to the dictates of a social consensus that will not allow outcomes to lie where they fall. The fact that microeconomic welfare assists the buyer through action taken specifically to circumscribe the seller must inevitably make it especially attractive to the interventionist who is not just a reformer but a socialist as well. Taxes and subsidies are the policy instruments recommended by the middle-ground economists Marshall and Pigou when they address the problem of social benefits underproduced by an uninstructed interest. Applied to the price of goods, what this could mean is the exemption from indirect taxation of welfare commodities like
62
The Status of Social Policy
children’s clothing and basic foodstuffs, the subsidisation on a generous scale of vital infrastructure like public transport, fuel and water. Taxes and subsidies have the attraction to the middle-ground mind that they work through demand and supply rather than requiring the suppression through directive of the gain-seeking mechanism itself. Although Titmuss does not say so, it is probable that microeconomic welfare proceeding by means of fiscal inducements such as these can be incorporated without difficulty into the familiar category of fiscal welfare which Titmuss normally reserves for social-service cases alone. There would not seem to be a world of difference between tax reliefs for the purchase of private health insurance, tax holidays for the construction of low-cost housing (a targeted benefit on the model of cold-weather payments) or even public subsidies for the conversion to lead-free petrol and the fluoridation of domestic drinking water (a universalist benefit which, like the NHS itself, is available to all classes on the sole basis of personal need). Directives to control the price of goods are more difficult to situate within the framework of Titmuss’s established categories. A ceiling price for nutritional staples is a way of ensuring that the shopkeepers do not pocket the windfalls of a famine. A usury law may restrict the supply of savings but at least it keeps the money-lenders at bay. The lessons of the medieval ‘just price’ and of Aquinas on the ethically informed economy look forward not only to Papal Encyclicals like Rerum Novarum in 1891 and Quadrogesimo Anno in 1931 but also to rent control in Titmuss’s own Britain which, it may safely be assumed, Titmuss saw no need to replace with ‘whatever the traffic will bear’. In that case at least, he is likely to have implied not only the legitimacy of directives but also the possibility that the controlled market could have the function of welfare. Inducements and directives subordinate the organisation to the collectivity in respect of the sale of output. Microeconomics constrained is, conceptually speaking, no less a source of welfare enhanced in the case of the employment of labour. Socialist authors like Owen and Marx had made economic exploitation the irreducible cause of social disharmony. Union leaders in the Britain of ‘you’ve never had it so good’ had not hesitated to use the strike weapon because Henry Dubb had been cost-benefited as input and deeply resented the slight. Market remuneration unacceptable, the market mechanism divisive – there is a tradition in British socialism which says with Tawney ‘One can’t look a gift cherub in the mouth’37 and
Evaluations and Extensions
63
which is deeply sceptical of any labour contract save one which embeds the economics in a surrounding package of welfare. A tax on labour-saving technology is an inducement to businesses not to drive out semi-skilled workers who would in consequence become dependent on benefits. A subsidy to an ailing giant in a development area is a guarantor of jobs, homes, traditional communities, informal networks that would all be put at risk by mobility forced upon labour by the bankruptcy of a dominant employer. A national minimum wage (rescuing the low-paid from the stigma of means-tested income supplementation) transfers to the firm from the State the economic burden of the poor-in-work. A statutory apprentice scheme requires employers to provide on-the-job training for manpower that would otherwise have been an external economy from the schools. Works clinics and health and safety regulations give businesses a statutory involvement in preventive and curative medicine that would otherwise have been passed to a Welfare State prepared non-judgementally to pick up the pieces of shattered people. Equal opportunity laws and counter-discriminatory quotas might integrate women and blacks at work to at least the same extent as the mental hospital (reinforced in due course by the Supplementary Benefits Commission) integrates them through the comprehensive school of social welfare once their professional frustration has taken its toll. Incomes policies flatten the pay pyramid to the benefit of the lower-paid, contain inflation which is itself a cause of poverty for pensioners on fixed incomes, and obviate the need for deflations and austerity measures that would cause the expendable to lose their jobs. It will be the task of Chapter 15 to consider the social dysfunctionalities and the economic costs that tariff walls, part-timers’ rights and mid-career leaves can represent. The present task is simply to show that microeconomic welfare, conceptually speaking, is as much a part of the welfare complex as are social welfare, fiscal welfare, and occupational welfare, on which Titmuss prefers to concentrate his attention. Accompanying his division of ‘all collective interventions to meet certain needs of the individual and/or to serve the wider interests of society’ into the ‘three major categories of welfare’ with which his name is associated, Titmuss offers the following specification of the realm: ‘The definition, for most purposes, of what is a “social service” should take its stand on aims; not on the administrative methods and institutional devices employed to achieve them.’38 There is no obvious reason why microeconomic welfare should be excluded
64
The Status of Social Policy
from such a specification, built as it is around functional equivalence and not around legalistic convention. The fact remains, however, that Titmuss himself preferred to treat microeconomic welfare as something outside and beyond. His study was the dependent. It was not the world of work before the victims became a charge upon the State. There is a final point to make about regulation. It concerns deregulation. Titmuss followed Mill, as Tawney had done, in stressing the importance of the open road as well as the equal start. Lecture notes dating from 1954 show that he associated personal fulfilment with freedom from as well as with the gift relationship when a nation moves into modernity: The family more mixed up with society, more dependent on what society has to offer in terms of education, work, social relations and so forth. If these are blocked by restrictions, closed shops of all kinds, class privileges and professional in-breeding then social frustration is bound to accumulate.39 Eton and the old-boy network put up barriers against an able interloper like Titmuss himself. So too, by inference, do union constraints, outdated demarcations, seniority rules and professional bodies that ration access to supra-normal remuneration to the detriment of new entry that cannot pay for the obstacle course. It would in the circumstances make sense to include in the broad category of microeconomic welfare the anti-monopoly policies that are needed to keep the private sector competitive and open.
Titmuss, in a letter written in 1959, acknowledges the ongoing importance of the voluntary bodies: ‘The modern state needs, in addition to collective public services, a variety and diffusion of genuine voluntary agencies.’40 It is a recognition of voluntarism and the gift of labour which is no more than one would expect from a committed communitarian. Titmuss’s ideal was not the passivity of mealtimes in the workhouse but rather the activity of parents who donate children, voters who donate taxes, citizens who donate blood precisely because welfare is as much about St Anthony as it is about the beggar with whom he shared his cloak. Titmuss was a theorist of giving and not just of taking. He was also a welfarist who stated that getting involved was at the cutting edge, that the quid without
Evaluations and Extensions
65
the quo was increasingly a necessity and not merely the icing on the cake: ‘Modern societies now require more rather than less freedom of choice for the expression of altruism in the daily life of all social groups.’41 Given the emphasis on social responsibility and the promise of an outlet for compassion, Titmuss, it might be presumed, would have been quick to have made community-based services, self-help groups, consumer cooperatives and mutual aid societies into a further category – after the social, the occupational and the fiscal, to say nothing of the macroeconomic and the microeconomic – in his taxonomy of care and help. It is a matter of record that he did not do so. Titmuss was a believer in voluntarism and in getting involved. In his publications and in his lectures, however, the duty to others of Toynbee Hall and the willing selfsacrifice of the Charity Organisation Societies are overshadowed into insignificance by the concentrated power of the State. Beveridge in 1948 had warned against the route: ‘The State is or can be master of money, but in a free society it is master of very little else. The making of a good society depends not on the State but on the citizens, acting individually or in free association with one another.’42 Writing when the Welfare State was already a fait accompli, he continued to look back to providential associations like the friendly societies (then already in decline) for the model of mutuality and belonging which he welcomed as a corrective of market failure without the need for top–down shepherding. Economic self-interest, Beveridge warned, is a necessary but not a sufficient condition for social well-being: ‘The business motive is a good servant but a bad master . . . A society which gives itself up to the dominance of the business motive is a bad society. We do not put first things first in putting ourselves first.’43 State intervention, Beveridge continued, must be judged by the same pragmatic standard of benefits and costs. In respect of spending, the State can serve well the nation, both in the field of income maintenance (‘The State alone can ensure that at all times unsatisfied needs are clothed with purchasing power’44) and through its well-informed practice of macroeconomic fine-tuning (‘The State alone, by its management of money, can prevent there being at one and the same time in a community unsatisfied needs, and idle men and machinery by whose employment those needs could be met’45). In respect of commodities and delivery systems, however, the beneficence of the good servant is less easy to establish – and the dominance of the bad master most likely to stifle the autonomy and the dignity
66
The Status of Social Policy
that, means as well as ends, are the reliable source of the socially sensitive response: In a totalitarian State or in a field already made into a State monopoly, those dissatisfied with the institutions that they find can seek a remedy only by seeking to change the Government of the country. In a free society and a free field they have a different remedy; discontented individuals with new ideas can make a new institution to meet their needs. The field is open to experiment and success or failure; secession is the midwife of invention.46 Beveridge, always more favourable than was his distinguished LSE colleague Hayek to welfarism and to Keynes, had clearly absorbed the lessons both of the road to serfdom that could lead to Hitler and of the information-deficient society that necessitated a decentralised discovery process. Voluntary action could be a part of that process, a corrective of its shortcomings without the need for the State. Beveridge believed that the case for ‘private enterprise, not in business but in the service of mankind, not for gain but under the driving power of social conscience . . . is beyond debate’.47 Reasoning precisely as Titmuss did, Beveridge looked to ‘mankind in brotherhood’,48 to community and to membership, for a stream of returns which ethical capital alone was in a position to produce: ‘There are some things – not goods but services – which often cannot be bought with money, but may be rendered from sense of duty.’49 The scope for gifts agreed, the paths then diverged and diverged quite significantly. Beveridge looked to ‘private enterprise’, solidarity by subscription, philanthropy by consent – to voluntary action, in short – for a valuable empowerment that would allow free individuals to turn their conscience to material as well as to moral advantage: ‘So at last human society may become a friendly society – an Affiliated Order of branches . . . each linked to all the rest by common purpose and by bonds to serve that purpose.’50 Titmuss, on the other hand, was as slow to make the voluntary sector a meaningful part of his theory of welfare as he was quick to recognise in its uncoerced communalism a moral manifestation of good neighbourliness, honest civility and of a fellowship that cares. Titmuss admired voluntarism but had a preference for the State. His relative neglect of intermediate corporations is not an oversight
Evaluations and Extensions
67
but rather a consequence of his logic. Microeconomic welfare can arguably be added on to an existing system. The voluntary sector will be more of a problem. One reason is the nation-building objective. Tawney had assigned a very high priority to the overlap in experience: ‘What a community requires, as the word itself suggests, is a common culture, because, without it, it is not a community at all.’51 Titmuss shared with Tawney the ideal of unifying assumptions, the endstate of Eliza and Higgins integrated into Englishness by a single set of symbols. Voluntarism, like Eton, injects supermarket pluralism into the citizenship fundamentals. Different parent–teacher associations press for different kinds of curriculum. Different medical charities provide different standards of care. On the fringes of welfare, such differentiation is precisely what is needed to cater for a variety of non-standard circumstances: consider the intentionally narrow remit of Alcoholics Anonymous, the ‘school run’, the support group organised by and for chemotherapy patients. At the centre of welfare, however, it is in the nature of the service that without bunching around the mean the product will lose much of the socialising function that so strongly recommends it to the advocate of cohesion. A second reason why Titmuss has so little say about the voluntary sector has to do with the fulfilment of promise. Titmuss, deriving his conviction from the value-consensus, argues that the citizen, where dependent, has a right to his service. Voluntarism, however, is by its very nature discretionary. A charity might lack resources or volunteers. It might ration provision by means of stigma that is at variance with rights. It might opt for second-rate quality that distances Eliza still further from the snobbish Professor. A mutualaid society, again, might turn away the needy who have not paid their contributions. It might refuse to admit as members those citizens likely to impose an abnormal burden. It might undersupply scarce welfare because it is too small for economies of size. Titmuss must have seen that the consumer’s right to welfare must always be a fragile craft where there is not also a producer’s duty to supply. The voluntary sector cannot convincingly take on such an obligation. The state sector can do so. The fact that the nation as a whole shares in the financial commitment offers not just the guarantee of the Exchequer grant but also the knowledge that one citizen is cross-subsidising another within the framework of a club that is as all-encompassing as the national family itself. A third and final reason has to do with the involvement of experts
68
The Status of Social Policy
and professionals. Peter Townsend has correctly observed that ‘if you have gargantuan departments of state then you are implying that there is some great repository of knowledge about what is good for society in its administration’.52 Pluralism, syndicalism, multiple possibilities have a certain attraction in the open-ended agnosticism of Ivan Illich – in a looking-glass world where teachers impede learning, surgeons cross-infect and where, outcomes aside, ‘any kind of dependence soon turns into an obstacle to autonomous mutual care, coping, adapting, and healing’.53 The gargantuan department of state, on the other hand, is the unhesitating choice of the welldrilled therapist whose professional response it is to select the best possible from the state-of-the-art. In the words of Lord Horder, physician to five monarchs and author of the Preface to Titmuss’s first book: ‘Only the doctor knows what good doctoring is.’54 Titmuss was in the camp of the single right strategy and of the big ministries that universalise the big tasks. Of course he recognised that the well-drilled could end up schooled down to size and blinkered into passive rubber-stamping – he said as much in an LSE lecture in 1965: ‘Expertise has a certain caste-spirit about it, so that experts tend to neglect all the evidence which does not come from those who belong to their own ranks . . . The one thing an expert requires is humility before all the facts.’55 On balance, however, Titmuss was in favour of the expert judgement made a citizenship entitlement through the State. The voluntary sector in that respect simply could not compete.
Social, occupational and fiscal welfare are always to be included in the definition of social policy. Macroeconomic welfare is explicit in the notes and implicit in the publications. Microeconomic welfare may be implicit in the publications and a useful extension to the theory. The voluntary sector is yesterday’s welfare in the theory, an optional add-on but no longer the substance. Ending the list of the welfare-providers is the first – the family. Titmuss, Rose writes, was ‘within the ideology of the family’.56 A sociologist as well as a socialist, he identified in the stable family unit the original welfare pool, the original locus of care, education and support. A disabled child, a convalescent spouse, an aged parent, where cared for in the home, is a burden that does not have to be shouldered by the State. De facto counselling is provided to a relative suffering from stress. De facto nursing is provided to a partner
Evaluations and Extensions
69
whose dressing must be changed. In ways such as these the family supplies the functional equivalent of social services and promotes an overall enhancement in welfare. Were it not to do so – were it to abstain (as in the case of the absentee father or the latch-key mother), were it, still worse, to cause intergenerational harm (consider child abuse or, more subtly, parents ‘unsecure and ambivalent’ who pass on to their offspring ‘a diminished sense of purpose and authority’57) – then the economic and social cost of its dysfunctions would have to be borne by the community. Negatively as well as positively, in short, the family unit is a social fact: ‘For good or ill, the healthy and harmonious working of the family is now the business of society. The failures – as well as the successes – are our concern, for society has decided that it should take care of the individual consequences of such failures.’58 Titmuss believed that the family (nuclear or extended) was the irreducible welfare pool. He also believed that the institution was a social fact that was at once a public concern: ‘We no longer regard family life as being a purely private, possessive affair.’59 Given his description of the family as a semi-socialised undertaking, it is of significance that he did not take the obvious (if also pedantic) next step of making ‘familial welfare’ a sub-system in his social division. It is of significance because it is so indicative of his sensitivity to common usage. Most people regard their loved ones as their own loved ones and not as their nation’s loved ones. To call it ‘familial welfare’ when a parent takes a sick child to the clinic would be as refractory to the median understanding as it would be to speak of ‘individual welfare’ whenever a citizen eats an apple a day, teaches himself a new language or puts money aside in case of chronic ill-health. Titmuss knew that a line would have to be drawn somewhere if the definition of social policy was not to become a tautology or even a joke. In the case of the family, he decided upon a compromise that would satisfy the sociologists without alienating the Dubbs. What Titmuss does is to describe the family de facto as a welfare sub-system but not to give it an official name that would label it as anything other than private. The status of the family requires no more than a clarification. The status of the wife within the family is more of a problem. An unspoken assumption in Titmuss’s theory of welfare provision is that the man is a full-time breadwinner in lifelong employment while the woman adopts the unwaged role of homemaker and domestic carer. Less likely to be a part of the formal, monetised economy,
70
The Status of Social Policy
she is less likely to have earned income of her own (culminating in an occupational pension in the retirement phase) and more likely to be dependent on her partner for (largely discretionary) support. Titmuss does not question this gendered division of labour. Nor does he reflect critically on the extent to which the Welfare State itself enjoys a hidden subsidy from low-cost carers such as nurses and social workers. Tacit is the background belief that women have a strong sense of duty; that their work is only a stop-gap until the children come along; and that the man’s wage is effectively the main source of income for the household. Titmuss, at the end of his Millicent Fawcett Lecture of 1952 on ‘The Position of Women’, acknowledged that four million families in Britain were enjoying a higher standard of living because women were going out to work.60 In 1958, lecturing at a conference on the first decade of the Welfare State, he managed to link women’s employment to full employment and both together to the downward trend in deprivation: ‘The fundamental reason for the relative absence of poverty, hardship and bad health among the workingclasses since 1948 is the fact of full employment and (we must certainly add) the great increase since 1948 in the paid employment of wives and mothers.’61 What passages such as these confirm is that Titmuss neither ignored the rising participation rate of women in the economy nor believed that the reproducers should remain in the kitchen so that the producers can get on with the job. Even so, there is a complacency in his view of women which is a reminder to the reader that God is a father, paternalism one stop before patriarchy and brotherhood – ‘fraternity’ – a universalism that excludes. Titmuss’s life at home with Kay (‘It was a perfect division of labour – exactly what families exist for’62) must have contributed to his vision of a biology-based order in which the woman’s career will normally be subordinated to her role as wife and mother. The economic base of post-Marxian socialism, as Ann Oakley perceptively points out, tends in itself to subordinate gender issues to the real issues: ‘Ideas about equality were primarily ideas about men defined in traditional occupational-class terms. The welfare state was about reducing class inequality. What it might or should do about women’s unequal chances compared to men’s was marginal to the main agenda, if, indeed, it was there at all.’63 Whatever the reasons for his tacit acceptance of ‘women welfare’ as a taken-forgranted sub-system in his theory, the fact remains that he was too complacent about the different social experiences of men and women,
Evaluations and Extensions
71
less than sensitive to the constructive use that could be made of welfare policy to resolve the specific problems that must have been uppermost in the minds of his students and his colleagues (the majority of them women) when they filtered his lectures through their own conflict of loyalties. Titmuss’s welfarism must evidently be extended if it is to provide an adequate response both to long-standing feelings of exclusion and exploitation and to the changes in economy and society that have had so great an impact on women’s life chances and expectations. As the two-career, two-income household becomes the norm, as divorce or desertion throws up a significant number of one-parent families, as part-time opportunities (often at low rates of pay) liberate women from the home but offer them neither job security nor occupational welfare, so there is a need for public policy to be able to satisfy new demands at the same time as it responds to the unhappiness of long-ignored aspirations. Thus social welfare could ensure the provision of nurseries and affordable childcare so that women can take jobs outside the home. It could protect women-only hospitals despite the lack of scale economies and guarantee hostels for battered wives when family life goes wrong. It could upgrade state pensions in line with earnings (de facto discrimination in favour of women because of their longer life-span) and ensure that child benefits are generous (many single parents live on or near the poverty line). Social welfare, more imaginatively, could even pay a social wage to housewives and carers for the quasi-social service which they provide. There is much that social welfare can do to respond to changes in the traditional sex roles. Importantly, however, economic welfare will have a contribution to make as well. A buoyant labour market protects part-timers, late entrants and the semi-skilled from the safety-valve function which has so often been women’s unique contribution to labour-market flexibility: ‘Mothers and wives’, Titmuss writes, ‘are likely to be affected first by any rise in unemployment.’64 Regulatory intervention reduces discrimination in hiring and promotions policy, guarantees paid maternity leave with the right to return, permits reasonable absenteeism where a family member such as a child is ill. Since the Welfare State (although disproportionately an employer of female labour) has itself left women underrepresented in senior positions, it is to be inferred that public service as well as private commerce could well stand to reap a welfare gain from control.
72
The Status of Social Policy
(b) The origins of welfare Titmuss always emphasised that welfare is by definition in flux. Speaking in Denmark on policy, it was the crux of his message that no agenda can ever be permanent, unalterable, sacrosanct, oncefor-all: ‘Asked to talk about “The Welfare State”. Personal dislike of the term . . . Implies a static approach to society. A state of completion. A kind of welfare conservatism and welfare Marxism. Insufficiently dynamic. Contradicts “society in process”.’65 Things change, perceptions change, and open-mindedness is all. Continuously, pragmatically, ‘we need to revise existing concepts of what constitutes a social service’.66 New challenges (atomic energy, insecticides, ‘the effects on water-supplies and sanitation of the scientific development of detergents’) must perpetually give rise to new services: ‘In a multitude of devious and indirect ways, the social services are assuming a host of new responsibilities and costs as a result of advances in knowledge which benefit the whole of society.’67 Extinct volcanoes, although Titmuss does not say so, must presumably be made subject to an analogous process of review in order that resources might be transferred into areas of sunrise deficiency. The precise, named services will – and must – come and go. There is, however, one thing which is not open to renegotiation. That irreducible constant is necessarily the selective standard by means of which the social sector is properly to be singled out: Whatever our ‘angle of vision’ may be we shall eventually have to take account of two elements in any definition of ‘social policy’, the ‘welfare state’, and so on. The first is the extent to which any society identifies and recognises ‘needs’ – needs for food, housing, education, income maintenance, medical care and so forth. The second is the extent to which these socially recognised needs are met in the interests of the individual and/or of society through the provision of collectively organised services – in cash or in kind.68 The first element relates to fundamental needs that must not be conflated with self-perceived wants. Neoclassical economics makes the calculus of choice an emanation from subjective individualism, from tastes and preferences. Social policy, on the other hand, must take a more detached, a more objective view on the prerequisites
Evaluations and Extensions
73
for socio-biological survival. Wants in the real world – consider the final demand for food or shelter, the intermediate demand for skillformation to earn access to the spendable income – will often produce the same choices as will needs. In the words of Doyal and Gough: ‘You can need what you want, and want or not want what you need. What you cannot consistently do is not need what is required in order to avoid serious harm – whatever you may want.’69 The choices will often converge. The causal explanations, however, will never do so. A want is a surface perception. A need is an underlying condition. They are not interchangeable and not the same. The first element in Titmuss’s selective standard relates to the specification of the need that is not – just – a want. The second element brings in the State. In referring to ‘the provision of collectively organised services’, Titmuss is associating social policy with a politicisation of cash and kind such as distinguishes his subject from informal transfers between family members or the private charity with an agenda of its own. The second characteristic of a social service in the sense of Titmuss is quite explicitly ‘public provision to meet specific needs’.70 If the ‘specific needs’ in question were already being met through demand and supply, there would be no need for ‘public provision’ to correct a market failure. In that sense, and as a matter of simple logic, ‘a redistributive element is present; it is the result of a public recognition of a specific need, and takes the form of a transfer from the whole (or part) of the population to a particular group composed of heterogeneous income categories but having in common a specific characteristic of need’.71 Social policy is always and everywhere about the redistribution of opportunities and endstates – from the old to the young, from the healthy to the sick, from the productive to the unemployed, from the urban to the rural, from the past to the present, from the present to the future. Seen in that light, the well-publicised redistribution from the rich to the poor turns out to be only one form of social engineering among many: ‘All forms of public intervention in the life of the community do not, in their total effect, suggest a one-track one-way stream of traffic for ever converging on a proletarian terminus. On the contrary, I am reminded of Crewe junction; of flows of traffic coming from and going to all stations.’72 The welfarist State exists to meet specific needs wherever they arise on the social map. Social policy is not – just – the corrective of the top-down divide: ‘To prefer the simplicity of the single-line proletarian track to the complex dynamics of Crewe is to fall into the outstretched
74
The Status of Social Policy
arms of uncomplicated Marxian dialectic.’73 The truth is the whole. It cannot be the part.
Titmuss defined social policy in terms of uncorrected need and of political intervention – and, most of all, in terms of the collective consensus upon which both elements were fundamentally dependent for their ethical legitimation. Titmuss carefully chooses phrases like ‘society identifies and recognises’ and ‘socially recognised needs’ in order to leave no doubt as to the nature of the imperative: ‘It is the public recognition and agreement to provide for a common characteristic of need that is important; not redistribution as an aim or effect.’74 Primary is the perception – ‘of society’s will to survive as an organic whole’, ‘of the expressed wish of all the people to assist the survival of some people’75 – and not the meaningless tautology that limited resources can always be reallocated and then reallocated once more: ‘It does not appear . . . that the criteria of redistribution . . . is of any value in defining a social service.’ 76 The precise beneficiaries (‘some people’) will only be known once the social consensus (‘all the people’) has arrived at its choice. The social consensus, in other words, is the sole agency with a map and an itinerary at Crewe. The simple opportunity to intervene and to assist can never be more than a necessary condition. Without the goahead from the group it must always remain insufficient. Titmuss saw the social consensus not as a sociological abstraction but as a social fact. Consider health policy in Tanganyika – where everyone wanted medical care to be improved. Consider population policy in Mauritius – where no one wanted living standards to fall. Consider the National Health Service in Britain – where unanimity of consent made it inevitable that citizenship pooling and free-on-demand delivery should become the norm. Cases such as these illustrate the general principle, that because we agree, therefore welfare is. Agreement, not the Bible, the Social Welfare Function or the General Will is the ultimate source of ought-ness in respect of the definition of a social service. James Buchanan, writing from the free-market ideological camp, was able to defend his own constitutionalism through an appeal to the same democratic contract: ‘Values are widely acknowledged to be derived from individuals, and there are not absolutes. God has been dead for a century, and attempts to revive him are likely to founder.’77 Titmuss expected agreement among
Evaluations and Extensions
75
fellow-citizens with common values. Buchanan, predicting diversity and welcoming pluralism, was less confident that conformity and compromise would steer a modern nation in the direction of the Golden Mean. In the one case as in the other, however, agreement is freedom – and disagreement creates a vacuum. Titmuss, unlike Buchanan, can hardly be called a misanthropic Hobbesian. The bias in Titmuss’s case is more likely to be in the opposite direction. Introducing dissensus, acknowledging disagreement, the modifications that would have to be made to the real-world role of social policy could leave it far less effective as a watchdog than is envisaged in Titmuss’s positive proposals. Thus the nature of a need with an objective existence might not appear the same to all members of the community. Titmuss, although he does not spell out in detail what it means to be a part of homo sapiens, would probably have favoured a broad definition such as that provided by Abraham Maslow when, not limiting himself to the gratification of the bodily needs like shelter and nutrition, that much-read humanitarian proceeds sequentially to the satisfaction of higher, socio-psychological needs such as safety and security, integration and rootedness, esteem and purposiveness, self-realisation and self-actualisation.78 Others, unimpressed by so universal and so categorical a vision, will favour the narrower definition of the physiological standard while leaving it to each individual to choose his own becoming (in the sense of Green) or his own fixation (in the sense of Freud) in his own unique way. Given the potential dissensus as to the nature of ego’s need, given the potential dissensus as to the extent to which ego’s need is a collective concern, the possibility must be recognised that a need with an objective existence as defined by Titmuss might have to be left unmet because subjective rankings legitimate only residual support for the homeless sleeping rough, for unemployed alcoholics with a history of petty theft, for traumatised refugees who need a skill, for unmarried mothers with nowhere to go. Titmuss did not anticipate that fundamental needs might not be labelled as fundamental needs by a median citizen with little tolerance of weakness or failure – and, still less, that the social consensus might not care about others at all. The legitimate non-fulfilment of basic human needs is one problem which arises once value-dissensus is admitted into the Titmuss model. Ambiguity and dissatisfaction within the agreed-upon welfare package is another. Titmuss, attacking vertical differentiation,
76
The Status of Social Policy
expressed his support for ‘one publicly approved standard of service, irrespective of income, class or race’.79 Titmuss, defending horizontal differentiation, came down strongly in favour of ‘a respect for the unique value of each individual and his or her need for self-respect, independence and dignity as a citizen in work and old age, in childhood and adolescence, in sickness and disability’: ‘Cultural diversity in the instruments of welfare is a precious asset in a world of more and more standardised products.’80 On the one hand the same restaurant, on the other hand a choice of dishes – Titmuss clearly believed that the heterogeneous could be accommodated within the homogeneous in an umbrella consensus where the common culture does not presuppose that everyone should wear a uniform and that even Muslims should eat pork. On the one hand the consensus accepts the need ‘to provide a strong enough basis for the common life to enable people to cope with their inequalities in such a way that they do not fall into envy, malice and the denial of charity’.81 On the other hand the consensus is the party of freedom and the champion of taste: ‘The spread of conformity means injustice.’82 Titmuss may have underestimated the extent to which the differentiation of preferences can prove a threat to common-culture welfare in a mobile and a competitive society. Thus parent A will want comprehensive education (to minimise stigma) while parent B will want streaming (to maximise accomplishment): even the suppression of non-state schooling will not resolve the win–lose dissensus that divides A from B. C believes that local authority tenants should be charged economic rents, D that there should be means-tested rents differentiated by the ability to pay, E that the citizenship option is flat-rate subsidised rents that treat like as equal: building more estates will not resolve intrawelfare disagreements such as these. There is no single public opinion on the provision of social security to the deprived families of men on strike (whose action may cause thousands of others to lose their livelihood and be forced themselves on to benefits); nor as to whether the irresponsibly large families of careless people (often of another confession and therefore doubly suspect) should be bailed out of self-imposed misery; nor as to whether a woman cohabiting with a man not her husband should be denied a widow’s pension. Dissensus in instances such as these cannot be resolved simply by pointing to consensus on the need for the State. Welfare in place, that can be when the bitterest of the value-conflicts begin. The point is that value-differences often reflect fundamental
Evaluations and Extensions
77
cleavages in society, and that, where they do, social policy might be quite unable to reach a compromise on the basis of a unique social will. There may, for example, be value-conflict between those citizens who demand free contraception for the under-aged and abortion as of right on the National Health, and those who disapprove of scarce social resources being utilised in this way: here, to choose one policy based on one morality is to alienate the sympathies of those who want an alternative policy based on an alternative morality. Again, to take a second example, there may be value-conflict as a consequence of value-divergence in the case of governmentally mixed communities: where one view is that the privileged should be allowed to exclude the non-privileged by price and another view is that the neighbourhood should be made a cross-section of the nation, bargaining will be out of the question and one set of aspirations will have at the end of the day to be scrapped. Titmuss says little about the resentment of pensioners sentenced to death because their demand for a transplant is called a want and not a need by the Service. Nor does he acknowledge the sadness of savers prevented by death duties from passing on to their children the full fruits of a lifetime of labour. Where there is a conflict of values, universalism will always be at risk from the threat within. The imposition on one group of another group’s values is as likely to deepen social division as it is to foster social integration. Titmuss shows little interest in value-conflict and the divisiveness it can produce. The reason is almost certainly his propensity to treat welfare at a high level of generality (health policy: everyone wants to be well) and not at a low level of specificity (organ bigotry: the donor will give only if the beneficiary is white). One consequence is that there is little in his work about the tyranny of the majority: it was to ‘the poor and the coloured population’ (and not to middle-class parents denied fast-track education because gifted high-flyers discourage the mean) that Titmuss was referring when he wrote that ‘one crucial test of the degree of accepted social responsibility in a community lies in its treatment of minorities’.83 Another consequence is that there is no real account in his writings of the techniques that decision-makers should employ to capture the sense of the social will – and the degree of dispersion that separates the tails from the median that has salience but not necessarily philosophy on its side. Social consensus and social dissensus are by their very nature imprecise. Titmuss, assuming convergence and expecting agreement,
78
The Status of Social Policy
was content to rely on impressions since common perceptions are not difficult to access. He does not say how states of dependency or welfare projects could be ranked at the margin in terms of quantifiable indices derived from subjective sensations. He cites few case histories of particular programmes where governments successfully determined the content of the collective consciousness as the first step towards reaching the targets that it prescribed. While his theoretical bent is a welcome antidote to the trivialities of the short-story approach to social policy, the fact that he does not explain how public opinion can be turned to good use in setting priorities and adjudicating disputes between services means that the exact nature of the link between social intelligence and social welfare must remain a focus for conjecture. Titmuss, not strong on the reconstruction of the representative, finds no room in his world-view for two discovery mechanisms which might, conceptually, give an insight into the consumer-citizen’s concealed valuations. One of these is the market: success indicators like profit and utility indicators like price have no place in an intellectual system which is resistant to the use of money as a index of achievement. The other is direct consumer consultation. Gunnar Myrdal gives a sense of citizen involvement as one of the main reasons in Sweden for citizen satisfaction with the Welfare State. His argument is that the dependent, like other people, want not just income-sharing but power-sharing as well: When participation is on a low level, we should expect people to be more apt to feel that the regulations are imposed upon them from above and that they are being pushed around by ‘them’ – the bosses, the bureaucrats and the oligarchies in the organisations, the strange and distant forces in Wall Street and Washington. This might breed feelings of resentment, and will anyhow frustrate people’s feelings of solidarity and identification with the purposes of the regulations.84 Middle-class owner-occupiers shop around for the fitted kitchen and the loft conversion that help them to make their dreams into a lifestyle. The deprived family must accept the high-rise flat at some distance from the children’s playground and the parents’ place of work that the welfare professionals deign to put at their disposal. Consultation in such circumstances would moderate the unequal distribution of the power cake that would otherwise make
Evaluations and Extensions
79
welfare itself a locus of social distance. Crucially, it would also make clients’ tastes and consumers’ preferences known to the administrators and the planners before they made expert opinion the sole determinant of the welfare package. Titmuss was sensitive to cultural stratification and sub-cultural segmentation. Non-judgementalism to him meant that equal humanity was deserving of equal respect. Speaking of the lower classes (more likely than social workers to smoke, less likely than case officers to save), he advised that gift cherubs should not too frequently be asked to bake biscuits for a Women’s Institute fête: ‘There is the danger of assuming that the norms of one class are relevant to the needs of another.’85 Speaking of black immigrants (abnormally exposed to a conflict of perceptions, abnormally prone to feelings of exclusion), he insisted that it is forever cricket to back different teams within the broad church of a single sport: ‘By integration I do not mean assimilation; the purpose is not to turn these neighbours of ours into “good little Englishers”. By integration I mean equality of opportunity and the fostering of multiple loyalties.’86 Sensitive to variation, in favour of acceptance, it would in the circumstances have made sense for Titmuss to have included community involvement and democratic consultation in a system which is expressly legitimated bottom–up. Autocracy and passivity being the undesirable by-products of ‘outer rather than inner observation’,87 there is clearly a case for Titmuss’s system to be extended in such a way as to incorporate grassroots sensibilities alongside the objective needs that are the province of the professionals. In practice, grassroots sensibilities in the welfare sector are often made the private capital of pressure groups. Titmuss could usefully have said more about the associations, charities and unions which lobby on behalf of claimants, children, addicts, students, social workers, probation officers and other actors in the welfare drama. Pressure groups represent the interests of the pools for which they speak. Whether they do so with any real authority is less obvious. The representation is typically indirect (with the implicit threat that the organisations will not fully mirror the sentiments of their members), often undemocratic (as where the groups are the self-appointed spokesmen for constituents who do not know of their existence, or where an unelected leadership is unaccountable to the rank-andfile), usually arbitrary (as in an attempt by town-planners to redeem an urban disaster area, where problems are multiple, criteria complex, and it is not clear whom to consult), and always unequal (since
80
The Status of Social Policy
not all pressure groups enjoy pressure parity, making a dispute between the representatives of the long-term mentally ill and the representatives of the consultant psychiatrists into an all-but-certain victory for supplier sovereignty). The relationship between pressure groups and client values is self-evidently a problematic one. Filling in the gaps in Titmuss’s model, it would be a useful contribution to show how power and militancy act to defend interests and convictions which in an ideal world may be refracted through the groups but will none the less take their origin in perceptions from below.
Titmuss, like Tawney, proceeds consensually, bottom–up. The Webbs, like Keynes, proceed expeditiously, top–down. The former standard relies upon Henry Dubb to reveal what he prefers. The latter standard relies upon the skilled dentist to select a suitable drill. Both standards are present in the hyphenated welfarism of the prudent T.H. Marshall. T.H. Marshall, like Tawney, derived his model of ‘mutual aid on the basis of common citizenship’88 from overall agreement in the society as a whole: ‘Without a foundation of near-consensus, no general social welfare policy would be possible.’89 Without such a foundation, ‘there could be no welfare state’.90 Marshall, philosophically a welfarist himself, was therefore pleased to report that, in modern Britain at least, ‘a very high degree of consensus exists about the aims of the welfare services’.91 Yet T.H. Marshall, like the Webbs, was also prepared to countenance democratic leaderliness where popular choices left the fabric exposed. Thus the government should not hesitate to frustrate expectations where the requests articulated were of a low order of importance: ‘Although it must take careful note of expressed desires, it does not simply react to or obey them. Its responsibility is to satisfy needs, which is a different undertaking.’92 Besides that, the government must make itself the guardian of productive efficiency and economies of scale even as it seeks to guarantee to the consumers of welfare the right to demand-led supply: ‘You cannot make the optimum use of scarce skills and resources in a nationwide service open to all if you allow every applicant for its help to pick and choose as he pleases.’93 T.H. Marshall was normally prepared, like Tawney, to make Henry Dubb the architect of welfare. Sometimes, however, he believed that he had to look to the politicians and the bureaucrats to take a lead.
Evaluations and Extensions
81
In his theory of welfare Titmuss was closer to Marshall on consensus than he was to Marshall on supply-side initiative. It is interesting, and indicative, that he cites few if any constructive contributions that were made to social policy by ‘Great Men’ like Barbara Castle (in respect of pensions), or philosopher-rulers like Anthony Crosland (in respect of schools). Even the personal impact of Aneurin Bevan on the Health Service, hardly acknowledged at all, is treated implicitly as if the input of a public servant and not that of a visionary engineer. Both in terms of explaining what has gone before and of recommending how public policies ought to come to the surface in the future, it is possible that Titmuss was actually too modest and not too ambitious in the role that he assigned to the lead. There is, of course, another view that can be taken of Titmuss on the State – that by being so complacent about the sensitivity of politicians, the seemliness of bureaucrats, he unintentionally concealed the perversion of democracy and the suppression of voice that can be the creeping consequences of ‘the road to serfdom’ in conspiracy with ‘the new despotism’. Tawney writes that the State in a mature democracy can safely be treated as a ‘serviceable drudge’ and not a ‘bloodthirsty Leviathan’: ‘We, in England, have repeatedly re-made the State, and are re-making it now, and shall re-make it again. Why, in heaven’s name, should we be afraid of it?’94 The critics of peaceable statists like Tawney and Titmuss have never been reluctant to provide an answer to the question. Consider first politicians. Anthony Downs has developed an economic theory of the political market according to which elected officers, self-interested and calculatively rational, sell policies (their ‘products’) in order to maximise votes (their ‘profits’). Such cynical opportunism, unfamiliar though the vision of principle-less commercialism will normally be in developed democracies that frown on bribes, at least implies that the merchants will have to please the voters in order to retain their seats. The popularity-chasing, sadly, can have a displeasing under-side as well. Because of the need to score a five-yearly victory in a general election contested on a bundle of issues, the leaders might target public spending on high-profile projects and marginal constituencies while underfunding the controversial, the unglamorous and the boringly obscure. By the same short-horizoned logic, and recognising with O’Connor that ‘every economic and social class and group wants government to spend more and more money on more and more things . . . but no one wants to pay new taxes’,95 they might
82
The Status of Social Policy
offer too many free gifts relative to what the voters are prepared to support in the knowledge that deficit-finance can make future cohorts the sponsors of the present day’s consumables. Also, as Downs makes clear, the economic reality that voters normally earn in one market but always spend in many makes legislation disproportionately favourable to the producer precisely because the consumer does not find it cost-effective to become informed: ‘Rational ignorance among the citizenry leads governments to omit certain specific types of expenditures from their budgets which would be there if citizens were not ignorant.’96 Marx and Engels, taking the view that ‘the executive of the modern state is but a committee for managing the common affairs of the whole bourgeoisie’,97 predicted government failure as a direct consequence of the market economy. So, interestingly, does Anthony Downs – who for that reason sees a case for the mixed economy to become more skewed towards exchange. Politicians can be popularity-chasers. They can also be manipulative Machiavellians with ideological objectives of their own. Not the passive servants of widely held social values but conviction zealots who are certain they know best, the possibility is real that they will proclaim social policy from above without awaiting instructions from the vagueness of a consensus in which they have no strong faith. As Buchanan puts it: ‘Within what he treats as his feasible set, the politician will choose that alternative or option which maximizes his own, not his constituents’, utility.’98 The brainwashing and the refamiliarisation come first in the causal sequence. The new consensus and the self-validating acceptance need not for all that lag far behind. Thus a sense of community might be the result and not the cause of mixed neighbourhoods; while population movements into the new housing estates might in any case alter the electoral bias of the locality in such a way as to ensure the vote-winning potential of geographical comprehensivisation in the future. Critics of centralised power have traditionally complained that there is a genuine threat to individual liberty in political initiatives such as these. Devolution is one answer – since local government is that much closer to public opinion on the spot. Privatisation is another – since ‘economic strength’, as Milton Friedman explains it, would then be in a position ‘to be a check to political power rather than a reinforcement’.99 Titmuss believed that political power can be a vital corrective to economic power, a locus of countervailing power in a society that had known abuse and neglect. What he was unprepared to accept
Evaluations and Extensions
83
is that political power can be a cause of new grievances in itself. The possibility of coercion is of especial concern in the field of welfare, since there the public sector arrogates to itself not simply the right to regulate but the power to provide. Titmuss, writing of the government’s wartime efforts to convince parents of the need to evacuate schoolchildren from the cities, records the following fact: ‘The art of democratic persuasion, of making people feel confidence in the Government’s plans, had to be practised.’100 Here he seems content that plan should antedate persuasion, just as it does in the mature corporation of Galbraith’s New Industrial State. Presumably this is because he is arguing to himself that no parents, understanding the issues, would really want their children to be exposed to the Blitz. If, however, ‘the art of democratic persuasion’ is truly a powerful weapon, then it is not clear why politicians should ever turn first to the elusive collective consciousness when it is in their power to make a change and only afterwards to mould consensual attitudes into the image desired. The temptation for the sensible to take a lead must have been a strong one for a man of principle like Richard Titmuss. Giving a talk at Balliol College three years after the publication of Downs’s Economic Theory of Democracy, he left his listeners in no doubt that politics for him was not just another name for buying and selling: To me, the business of socialists is to change society in accordance with socialist ethics. It is not, first and foremost, to achieve power. To put power first must mean ‘studying the market’ today; an impressionistic market research view of what the new working-classes are demanding. This may well be – in the next 20 years – reactionary – e.g. materialism; capital punishment; homosexuality; inequality etc. We have not educated them. It is easy to criticise the T.U.s for manual workers; but we have to try and understand the reasons for their narrow view.101 Their view is ‘narrow’. Socialists have not ‘educated them’. Leaders must not put ‘power first’ where the price is their ‘socialist ethics’. Unpublished notes for a talk at Balliol College cannot be taken as proof positive that Titmuss was at heart a moulder and not a follower of consensus. What they do show is that a man of principle who is also an unwavering democrat will inevitably face the same conflict of interest as does the doctor when employed by his customer to supply cocaine.
84
The Status of Social Policy
Tawney, unafraid of the State, denied that politicians were necessarily doomed to sink into the role of despots: ‘It is as possible to plan for freedom as for tyranny.’102 Titmuss, sharing his confidence, also saw that Tawney’s rejection of minimax was a direct reflection of Tawney’s own way of life, ‘a realisation in action of his own high principles’: ‘The severest criticism of Equality as a social theory is that it would be easier to realise in practice if all men were Tawneys.’103 Titmuss was a pragmatist and a man of caution. Referring to politicians, however, he tended none the less to write as if ‘all men were Tawneys’ – and they were not. As with politicians, so with bureaucrats. Max Weber treated the civil servant as compliant, faceless, powerless, obedient: ‘In the great majority of cases, he is only a single cog in an ever-moving mechanism, which prescribes to him an essentially fixed route of march. The official is entrusted with specialized tasks and normally the mechanism cannot be put into motion or arrested by him.’104 Titmuss shared the vision of the civil servant as an instruction-follower and a function in a structure. Passive and reactive, accountable to his nation because he is responsive to his superiors, the civil servant is always our servant and never a self-interested entrepreneur with goals and purposes of his own. Anthony Downs sees the survival of sharp elbows as a reason why good Weberians tend to be pushed aside by social deviants with little interest in the social consensus: ‘Men who enter bureaus and consistently evidence statesmanlike behavior are rarely promoted . . . It is our ironic conclusion that bureaucracies have few places for officials who are loyal to society as a whole.’105 Titmuss, on the other hand, never doubts, with Weber, that office-holders on balance take professional pride in doing what their principals demand. Titmuss recognised that salaried managers of private corporations could have behavioural goals of their own, purposes quite different from those of the profit-seekers who were in law their masters. He was, however, more reluctant to accept that administrators in government departments and parastatal bodies could themselves be blinkered by interest or exposed to temptation. The fact that civil servants seldom take bribes and show no overriding obsession with money seems to have convinced him that the ministries cannot realistically be regarded as a major locus of non-consensual or counterconsensual conduct. He would have been more concerned had he been more open to the personal and private objectives, not directly pecuniary though these may be, which can divert the officeholder from his Weberian duty.
Evaluations and Extensions
85
Prominent among these organisational goals will presumably be job satisfaction (which may induce a service to undertake highly specialised research for which there is no objective need and of which the consensus would never approve were it in a position to penetrate the jargon of boffinism), security (which may prevent a service from winding itself up when it has served its purpose or decisively failed to do so), autonomy (which may cause a service to flee from the audit and the publicity of the interdepartmental committee into the protected secrecy of the parallel hierarchy) and growth (which may stimulate a service to expand, irrespective of the rationalisation it provides to itself and others, principally in order to generate more opportunities for promotion and more fiefdoms of power in a world of intra-mural empire-building). In order to retain the freedom to pursue microsociological objectives such as these, a service will want to impress with its successes and to avoid embarrassing failures that could cause questions to be asked. Its incentive structure is such that it will be led by its own self-interest to divert marginal resources from slow learners and confirmed recidivists in order to concentrate help on the ‘good-risk’ dependent most likely to make spectacular progress at minimum cost. Such a policy of playing safe is, needless to say, the opposite of what Titmuss intended when he called for selective discrimination. The problem of organisational goals is compounded by that of organisational aggregation. Given self-interest, what can emerge is an aimless proliferation of schemes essentially because each group wants to be at the centre of one project or another. The resultant tangle (combined with the inflexible demarcations of professionalism itself) need not represent either an efficacious response to need or a comprehensive and coordinated structure of services. In the real world, what passes for planning is often no more than the weary compromise ground out by the deal-making and the negotiating of supply-side coalitions. Power-rating may sway the balance (although strength is not the same as wisdom); and so might the practice of settling disputes through an appeal to precedent. Caution and myopia can be a significant cause of waste and delay. They can also mean that there might be inadequate opportunities for a self-correcting response to originate within the social service matrix itself. The perpetuation of established patterns can be at variance with the attainment of wider social goals. Titmuss, stressing the evolving nature of the Welfare State, observed that the inability to recognise
86
The Status of Social Policy
the ‘all-pervasive character of social change’ had in the past ‘prevented us from understanding that all legislation is experimental and that a social service is a dynamic process – not a finished article’.106 He called for flexibility and sensitivity in order to ensure that the social services change in accordance with changing social needs: The forces of the past in terms of how we live together in society create new situations; if the structure and functions of the social services cling too closely to the needs of the age when they originated, and if the interests which resist change become too powerful, these services will not meet the needs of the new situations. We shall not achieve a better balance between the needs of today and the resources of today by living-out the destinies of tradition.107 Titmuss recognised that inertia resulting from the vested interests and the professional conventions of the Welfare Establishment itself could be a cause of retarded adaptation and the perpetuation of the status quo. What he denied was that the nightmare scenario must necessarily be the normal one. His followers will no doubt add that organisational redesign (in the State as in the corporate sector) can contribute much to the improvement of performance – and that even competition between state schools, between state hospitals, will prove more attractive to the social consensus than would the privatisation that the critics of bureaucracy so often cite as the solution. Titmuss could usefully have said more about the organisational obstacles to consensus-led welfare. Writing as a sociologist, he obviously did not regard the obstacles as especially serious ones. Writing as a reformer, interestingly, he seems to have found the prevalence of Weberian self-abnegation the greater cause of concern: Bureaucrats and ‘professionalized’ people, whether employed by large-scale private or public organisations, have one attribute in common: a self-image of political neutrality. This rests on the belief that administration can be wholly rational . . . These and other forces encourage rather than discourage a climate of opinion which is detached about injustice, inequality and the position of minorities. There is a truce about values. There is a demand to take health and social welfare ‘out of politics’.108
Evaluations and Extensions
87
A philosopher, a socialist, a policy-maker, Titmuss pointed with unease to developments in society which were ‘tending to enlarge the area of power of forces which are openly or tacitly hostile to research topics which carry – or seem to carry – overt political implications’ – developments such as the Weberian blandness of the organisational revolution: ‘The growth of bureaucracy, in public or private structures, as a consequence of large-scale organisation, is one such force.’109 The nation needs wide-ranging new research, not least into neglected areas where the facts can present a challenge to complacency. Civil servants, however, precisely because they are self-effacing Weberians, try to filter out the controversial lest it prove an embarrassment to their political heads. Research into widows’ benefits, Titmuss reports, was just such a case of a potential upset identified and defused: ‘Any shrewd administrator worth his salt to the Treasury, was bound to be struck with the thought that the findings of research on this aspect of the inquiry were unlikely to recommend a reduction in benefits.’110 Harmonious functional integration in the non-market sector presupposes continual review and revision of policies in combination with impassioned struggle for justice and inclusion. Civil servants, however, precisely because they are the self-effacing servants of an easily embarrassed Cabinet, tend to have an independent impact on the welfare that is supplied. Social policy in the sociology of Richard Titmuss must bubble up from the social consensus. Social policy that originates on the side of supply must in the circumstances always stand out as a cause of concern.
This page intentionally left blank
Part Two: Selectivity
This page intentionally left blank
5 Stigma
Titmuss believed that the State should provide a range of free welfare services. He also knew that resources are limited and that there is a need to ration supply.1 Clearly, and even if resources are not to be rationed by price for all comers, there is at least a case for a dual system whereby those who can afford to pay for welfare rely on private provision, and the State (rather than providing welfare benefits indiscriminately) concentrates its help where the need is greatest and the ability to pay least. Titmuss, however, rejected such selectivity. Partly this was because of his belief (the subject of Part Four) that private enterprise in the field of welfare is a mixed blessing even for those who can pay. Partly it was because he was convinced that a dual system involves stigma. Stigma means a loss of self-respect and personal dignity, a sense of guilt, of shame, of personal fault or failure. It means the sensation of second-class citizenship that results from discrimination. It means what Goffman calls ‘spoiled identity’,2 since discrimination so easily becomes self-discrimination. To begin with this operates at the level of perception: ‘If men and women come to think of (and feel) themselves as inferior persons, subordinated persons, then in part they stigmatise themselves, and in part they are reflecting what other people think or say about them.’3 Later, however, the process of self-stigmatisation seeps through to the level of action: ‘If men are treated as a burden to others – if this is the role expected of them – then, in time, they will behave as a burden.’4 Whether at the level of perception or at the level of action, such psychological damage is undesirable. It arises in a selective system in three ways.
91
92
Selectivity
First, there is the stage of trying to obtain private insurance or private treatment and failing because one is an actuarial bad risk. It would be uneconomic for the private market not to exclude those who cannot pay or are likely to make excessive demands on resources. It would also be unfair to the shareholders were private enterprise to redistribute the national income by, say, undertaking to charge non-weighted insurance premiums to patients with aboveaverage medical needs. At the same time, however, this leaves the disadvantaged in a state of neglect. It may be that people ought to stand on their own feet and spend according to the dictates of their own conscience and purse. Yet they cannot be expected to buy services which the vendor is unprepared to sell. The fact is that the private market does not provide adequate welfare services for such groups, potentially at risk, as the deprived child, the single parent, the woman over 40 entering the labour force, the widow, the educationally deprived, the unemployed, the mentally handicapped, the mentally ill, the physically handicapped (such as the deaf or the blind), the bedridden. It often neglects the non-white immigrant, the striker, the unsupported wife, the worker on a work permit, the intermittently employed agricultural worker, the ‘elderly isolates and desolates’5 of society. It does not provide treatment for the drug addict, the indigent, the impoverished schizophrenic newly discharged from hospital. In America the whole of the urban ghetto is often declared an uninsurable risk. It must be remembered too that, in an increasingly mobile society, a number of those rejected by the private market will not have families on which to fall back.6 It is possible that many of these potential losers apply for private insurance or treatment and are rejected without right of appeal. Not only is this a denial of freedom of choice to large groups of would-be consumers, but lack of access to essential facilities leaves the felt and experienced need among such vulnerable groups without proper remedy. It also leaves the dependent with the bitter taste of rejection, exclusion, powerlessness and indignity. In some way, whether on grounds of race, poverty, mental fitness or some other judgemental yardstick, society is seen to have expressed its disapproval and selected them out. Such stigmatisation is the order of the day for many groups in modern society. It is, however, largely invisible: the insurance companies collect no statistics on ‘the psychological and social harm they do to people’7 in rejecting them or rating them as sub-standard. It is hard to see in any case how a sense of stigma could be precisely quantified.
Stigma
93
It has been argued that affluence and full employment will cause this first kind of stigma to disappear over time. The aim of state provision of social services, so the argument goes, should be selfliquidation as more and more people become eligible for privately provided welfare: ‘Such pockets of poverty and residual distress as still prevail will in time automatically and gracefully succumb to the determinism of growth. This will be achieved by a natural process of market levitation; all classes and groups will stand expectantly on the political right as the escalator of growth moves them up.’8 The fallacy here is the assumption that the increase in command over resources will be evenly and proportionately distributed between spending units. Titmuss quotes American evidence for 1966 (one child in four and three elderly persons in ten living below the poverty line, a move towards greater inequalities in income and wealth) to support his contention that economic progress need not naturally lead to social progress without redistributive intervention by the State. The ‘invisible resource allocation of the market’9 in a dynamic economy will not solve the problem of poverty and thus of stigma associated with the rejection of application for private provision. Embourgeoisement is not the answer, the way out.
Second, there is the stigma associated with the means test that is administered to applicants for state welfare in order to guard the gate of state-provided cash transfers and free services against those who can afford to pay for private support. The aim being to reach the desperate directly, they must first be separated out from a population which includes sheep as well as goats, non-poor as well as poor. The means test is a deterrent to abuse. It aims to help the poor by sparing them the need to share scarce welfare resources with all and sundry. Unfortunately, however, welfare provided on a discriminatory, means-tested basis has a tendency to ‘foster both the sense of personal failure and the stigma of a public burden’. Clearly, ‘the fundamental objective of all such tests of eligibility is to keep people out; not to let them in. They must, therefore, be treated as applicants or supplicants; not beneficiaries or consumers.’10 Yet ‘it is a regrettable but human fact that money (and the lack of it) is linked to personal and family self-respect’.11 No poor person wants to stand up and define or identify himself as poor, for to do so would be ‘to declare, in effect “I am an unequal person”’.12 Such a punitive
94
Selectivity
process of selection, because it means a ‘humiliating loss of status, dignity or self-respect’,13 is too great an insult to be tolerable in a society that wants to protect the sense of self-worth. Quite apart from the indignities involved, means-testing is undesirable because of the administrative problem. Any test that acknowledges the fundamental truth that ‘there are no standard families with standard or uniform requirements’14 becomes an administrative nightmare due to the multiplicity of variables that must be taken into account. These variables, moreover, do not remain constant. Circumstances are in a continual state of flux caused by births, adoption, children leaving school, marriage and remarriage, desertion, separation, divorce, illness, disablement, retirement, death, fires and disasters, unemployment, a new job (possibly with a pay increase only just keeping pace with inflation), a new house (with a different rent), boarders, inheritance, institutional care for aged parents, capital appreciation, windfalls, and numerous other factors influencing the resources and responsibilities of spending units. Even if meaningful means-testing of families could be carried out, the results are likely very quickly to become out of date. Means-testing also makes it difficult to deal with urgent needs. In the case of, say, an evicted family with an unemployed father where an individual experiences a spell of sickness, the emergency must be dealt with immediately, and without the delay imposed by administrative intricacies. In any case, these formalities are bound heavily to penalise the most ignorant (who may well be the most needy). There are a multitude of different means tests (at least 1500 are administered by local authorities in England and Wales in welfarerelated areas alone). In the past the academics and the administrators have ‘overestimated the potentialities of the poor, without help, to understand and manipulate an increasingly complex ad hoc society’.15 The poor are not only stigmatised by welfare but may be excluded from it (not least where they have multiple needs necessitating multiple tests): ‘Who helps them, I wonder, to fill up all those forms?’16 A negative income tax operated through the Pay As You Earn network would help remove this administrative burden from the dependent by making benefits (albeit in the form of money, not services) automatically available, and based on a computerised code number. It would, however, face the same insuperable difficulties as any other test in attempting to estimate resources and shortfalls, to keep track of changes over time, or to respond quickly to
Stigma
95
urgent needs. It simply does not make sense to deal with this year’s emergency by applying a code number derived from last year’s data, based on a P.60 which may be seriously out of date.17 Naturally, employers could be asked to provide the Inland Revenue not with annual data but with weekly or monthly data, so as to keep the tax code up to date in a non-static world. The data could then be married on a continuous basis with other relevant data (as where, for example, husband and wife are assessed separately for income tax). All of this, however, is a waste of administrative resources (including the resources of private employers) and might not even be feasible (due to the multitude and complexity of ever-changing variables). As Titmuss says: ‘What I find frightening is the extraordinary administrative naivety of those who argue in such terms for “selectivity”.’18 Not only is any means test bound to be administratively unwieldy, but it is not able to deal mechanistically with the mass of difficult value-judgements that must be made at all stages in defining the criteria for eligibility. The basic decision is, of course, to specify in what financial circumstances an individual qualifies for income supplementation by the State. Yet this in turn raises other important questions and ultimately involves complicated social values. For example: should people who do not work be better off than people who do (the wage-stop)? Should a distinction be made between earned and unearned incomes? Should the test include a wealth test or ‘should income tests and charges disregard capital assets, house property, discretionary trusts, education covenants, insurance policies, reversionary interests, fringe benefits, tax-free lump sums, share options, occupational benefits in kind and suchlike?’19 Should wives be encouraged to go out to work? Should one distinguish qualitatively as to the cause of dependency (the same zero income, for example, might be earned by a striker, a layabout, a disabled war hero, or a student in the process of acquiring socially useful skills)? Naturally, once considerations of ethics and equity are brought in, ‘computers cannot answer these questions’.20 There is no escape from the human decision-maker.
Third, there is the stigma attached to separate provision, partly because the special facilities provided are clearly earmarked for failures and inadequates, partly because residual provision is invariably inferior provision. The truth is that ‘separate discriminatory services for poor people have always tended to be poor quality services’,21
96
Selectivity
second-class services aimed at second-class consumers excluded from the middle-class world of welfare and conscious of that exclusion. The inferiority of public compared with privately provided services is to some extent a question of finance: ‘Insofar as they are able to recruit at all for education, medical care and other services, they tend to recruit the worst rather than the best teachers, doctors, nurses, administrators and other categories of staff upon whom the quality of service so much depends.’22 As far as the poor are concerned, however, ‘if the quality of personal service is low, there will be less freedom of choice and more felt discrimination’.23 Such felt discrimination is not an unintended outcome but a part of the system. Its roots may be found historically in a past society which attempted to reconcile compassion with individualism by treating the poor as the indigent, a public burden for whom a safety net had to be provided, but subject to the expression of disapproval. Rationing by shame and inferior quality of services provided is, however, no longer acceptable as a deterrent in the way that it was acceptable at the time of the New Poor Law of 1834. Then, ‘shame was needed to make the system work’.24 Nowadays, the collectivity is more likely to feel that the dependent should not be sanctioned with stigma, and that those who provide welfare should not see it as their duty to stigmatise the recipient for some supposed dereliction or failing on his part. To avoid the cumulative and demoralising effects of rejection on the individual, Titmuss therefore decided that social welfare services had to be provided free of charge, as of right, to all citizens, dependent on their needs alone and not on their means. In place of a selectivist system, where the State withers away until it performs merely a residual function, Titmuss believed that a universalist structure of services had to be made available to all, since liberation from state intervention was bound to increase the incidence of experienced disapprobation in society. The great majority of people using the National Health Service do not feel stigmatised, and the reason is that the Service is known and felt to be universalist in scope.25 The same infrastructure of facilities is used by the nonpoor and the poor alike (i.e. by those who could pay for private attention as well as those who could not). Selection is avoided and the dependent keep their self-respect. In Britain, just as a cat can look at a king, so an unskilled labourer can share a ward with a Professor of Social Administration. The avoidance of stigma is secured by opening social welfare services
Stigma
97
to all, regardless of class, colour or income. Naturally this great benefit substantially raises the cost of provision. But against that cost must be set the fact that universalism not only negates a previous negation but also constitutes a definite affirmation by making a constructive contribution to social growth in three important ways. These are the covering of social costs by social provision, the furtherance of a heightened sense of social integration, and the creation of a framework within which to plan the redistribution of life chances. These social benefits will be examined in Part Three.
98
Selectivity
6 Part Two: Evaluations and Extensions
Dependent people are people with needs. People with needs should be treated with respect. The Good Samaritan applied no means test when he proffered relief to a stranger in distress. The Welfare State should take pride in the same non-judgemental compassion when it provides a guarantee not just of cash and kind but of self-worth and self-esteem as well. No one but a scoundrel kicks a beggar in the teeth. The welfare services in the sense of Richard Titmuss were a reaffirmation of community and identity, not just a soup-kitchen for failures and misfits: To me, the social services are not simply a means by which purchasing power may be redistributed, although that is – and will remain – a vitally important role for the social services. They are also concerned – and, in my view, should increasingly be concerned – with the quality of civilised living, with the condition of our physical environment, with our attitudes and values towards minority groups, the deprived and the poor, and with the diffusion of power and the multiplication of loyalties.1 The welfare services are not just alms-houses and Maundy money. They are also the non-calculative response of a national family that instinctively shares to the distress and unhappiness of all of its sons and daughters who stand in need of its love. That being the case, there can be no justification for looking the Prodigal Son shrewdly in the mouth or colour-coding the black sheep for blackness of fleece: ‘To be responsible for others means the acceptance of duties or obligations towards others without discrimination.’2 Dependent 98
Evaluations and Extensions
99
people are people with needs. They are not natural deviants who deserve to be hurt. Acceptance without stigma is absolutely central to Titmuss’s vision of the socialist alternative. Capitalism ranks – and the result is ‘pain and stress’: ‘The corollary for any society which invests many of its values and virtues in the promotion of the individual is individual failure and individual consciousness of failure.’3 Welfarism assists – since physical or psychological suffering can never be good: ‘Pain, nature-made or man-made, can be unmade or prevented by man; that is the lesson that is being taught. And it is being learnt if I interpret correctly the popularity of the National Health Service.’4 The witness to the mass rejection of Depression unemployment, the son of a father whose business had not made the grade, himself an outsider professor without deep roots in academic privilege, Titmuss had first-hand knowledge of second-rate status and had not liked what he had seen. The mixed economy which he endorses is intended by him as a safe environment in which a sensitive person can make his way without loss of dignity or fear of humiliation. Whether the middle ground can indeed provide a guarantee of acceptance without stigma is, however, by no means certain. Perhaps nothing can. Market values are a hard task-master. They are, potentially at least, a much greater cause of spoiled identity than the need to submit to a means test as the price of entry into welfare. The low-paid have behind them a sad history of relative failure in areas ranging from competitive schooling to competitive status. They will in an acquisitive society be aware of comparative deprivation in the selfdefining activities of earning and spending. They will have little familiarity with employee consultation, security of tenure and the meaningful use of ‘please’. They will return to the world of those unable to pay for the median lifestyle once their ulcers (caused by repeated rejection in the market sector) have been patched up (through the free-on-demand universalism of the National Health). Continuous winnowing can wear down the ego. It is by no means certain that a person marked down since school by commerce will actually experience a significant increment in stigma if asked to pass (in the sense of fail) an income test as the precondition for a rent rebate or an exemption from the prescription charge. Titmuss in his published work never directly addresses the issue of market-sector stigma. His unpublished lectures, on the other hand, reveal a profound sympathy with those who registered for the ‘good
100
Selectivity
life’ and ended up as clients of the Welfare State instead. The following is especially evocative of what it means to be ‘the man or woman who is “too old at 40”’, ‘the people who are retired from work in the interests of promoting success for other people’, ‘the applicant without the “right” trade union ticket’, ‘the boy who has been to an approved school’, even ‘the girl who is unpresentable’ in a marriage market that values looks: The price of increasing specificity in selection – at school and in work – is the creation of more and more social ‘ineffectives’ – people who are rejected and who know that they have been rejected. The risk of their becoming dependent people requiring income-maintenance, medical care, psychological help and other services, increases as they become aware of their ‘ineffectiveness’ and the reasons for it.5 Here, clearly, it is non-welfare costings that inflict the stigma, the welfare services that arrive post festum to do good. The man or woman who will never work again at 40 will presumably not welcome a personal means test prior to receiving long-term benefits. The pinprick is pain and pain is bad. Even so, the ‘ineffectives’ and the rejects will almost certainly think that is the market test and not the welfare test that has done the most to make them feel deficient.
The market can cause stigma. So too can the consumption of welfare. The means test is not the only way in which the social services can make the dependent feel that an approach to the State is an admission of defeat. Society values people who can look after their own. People value themselves because they can cope without help. Pushed by neighbourhood sanctions and pulled by the conscience within, people will often feel that there is something shameful about having a child taken into care, or being on the dole, or having to ask for a cold-weather supplement where the alternative is hypothermia or malnutrition. Dependency rather than equivalency is for most responsible adults a psychological diswelfare at the best of times. The lower occupational groups, Peter Townsend observes, are especially sensitive to the implication that handouts are the symbol of default: ‘There’s much more inclination among the working class to have individualistic explanations for poverty and to imagine that
Evaluations and Extensions
101
people are poor because of personal mismanagement rather than the institutional structures of society.’6 The subjective perceptions are not those that Titmuss himself would have been able to validate. Even so, if the vulnerable do in fact feel damaged by failure and humiliated by dependency, then that is the attitudinal capital that the middle-class sociologist must acknowledge to be their own. Ann Davis, probing into the actual attitudes that exist in a mixed society where welfare speaks Latin while commerce speaks Greek, reaches the conclusion that contact with the caring services can ‘undermine self-esteem and confidence. It can reinforce the oppression experienced by the poor in our society’.7 Welfare alleviates stigma – since the lot of the poor would have been even more disgracing had they remained unable to pay for a socially acceptable standard of housing, food and clothing. Welfare also imposes stigma – since people socialised to rank themselves by what they have achieved can feel that the nexus is a sub-normal one where no return gift is expected or made: Exchanges of this kind take place in a society in which success, status and reward are represented as the fruits of individual effort and responsibility. Standing on one’s own two feet and looking after oneself and one’s dependants is portrayed as the way in which the responsible citizen behaves. Contact with a social work agency is a public declaration of failure to make the grade as a citizen. To look to a state service to supplement or substitute for one’s own efforts is to be branded as an inadequate.8 The socialist will postulate a right to welfare and the Fabian will table facts on occupation and need. At the end of the day, however, it must be the clients who make sense of the labels. If Davis is right in her contention that the poor feel second-rate because of access, then the fact must be recognised that the receipt of welfare as well as the lack of money can in their eyes be a benefit that is also a cost. The problem, as Robert Pinker points out, is that one central value-system will find it difficult to reconcile the two contradictory sub-systems of the quid pro quo on the one hand, the unilateral gift provided free of charge on the other. Pinker presents his argument in the language of learning and development:
102
Selectivity
As we grow up, the most authentic rights we acquire and exercise are those we use in the roles of buyers and sellers in the market-place. We do not have to be persuaded that we have rights to what we buy. The idea of paying through taxes or holding authentic claims by virtue of citizenship remains largely an intellectual conceit of the social scientist and the socialist. For the majority the idea of participant citizenship in distributive processes outside the market-place has very little meaning. Consequently most applicants for social services remain paupers at heart.9 On the one hand business, on the other hand support – Pinker does not regard the two contestants as equally matched and has no doubt as to the sub-system that will engender the dominant response. Where applicants, ‘paupers at heart’, are unconvinced as to their inalienable rights and unaware that citizenship alone has given them an unquestionable entitlement, there would seem to be a strong case for an education in welfare. As applicants discover that all social classes are including themselves in state-provided benefits, as applicants find out that they are de facto the innocent victims of social costs borne by the few so that the many can prosper, the hope would be that the social services would lose their association with stigma and sanction. Titmuss (who had little sympathy with propaganda of any kind) would probably have had mixed feelings about formal lessons in community and fellowship that could all too easily degenerate into a gerrymandering of consensus. Learning from experience was, however, a different matter. Universalist services like the NHS were the supply that reinforced the demand that had created them. They were the comprehensive schools that made men and women progressively more comprehensive over time. A socialisation into socialism can challenge the sensation of stigma. So, importantly, can the quid pro quo. The Beveridge Report in 1942 had implied that the dependent would always feel neglected and undersupplied as long as the link between welfare contributions and welfare entitlements was not made transparent to them: ‘The citizens as insured parties should realise that they cannot get more than certain benefits for certain contributions [and] . . . should not be taught to regard the State as the dispenser of gifts for which no one needs to pay.’10 The Beveridge Report had also maintained that citizens, taking pride in their ability to earn life for their own,
Evaluations and Extensions
103
would actually welcome the opportunity to buy a right: ‘The insured persons themselves can pay and like to pay, and would rather pay than not do so.’11 Disappointment stigmatises. Something for nothing stigmatises. Welfare is good, the Report had said; but still the unspoiled self-image could usefully be protected by a pragmatic appeal to the in-state quid pro quo. Titmuss had read the Report and thought deeply about guilt. The following statement from 1969 shows that, in respect at least of superannuation, he could write as if a prudent shopper and not a new immigrant or an abandoned wife: ‘People do not want to be given rights to pensions, but . . . want to earn them by their contributions.’12 Titmuss tended as a general rule to ignore the possibility that unilateral transfers may themselves come to represent stigma. If, however, his 1969 declaration is a good description of people’s psychology, then there may in fact be a socialist case for hypothecated taxes, contributions-records and user charges precisely in order to signal to welfare applicants that they are more than might-havebeens begging to be let in. Titmuss’s core position on universalism and overlap effectively rules out the privatisation of the welfare services. Titmuss’s high valuation of equal self-respect, on the other hand, arguably leaves the door open to the in-state compromises of league tables, internal markets and welfare vouchers. Accent, demeanour, dress, selfconfidence all deter Henry Dubb from seeing the hospital consultant as a family friend, from standing up to the headmaster who says he knows best. Economic sanctions will not resolve the cultural gap. What they might do, however, is to attenuate the stigma that is the free gift of passivity without a contract. The private shopper buys in a second Harley Street opinion and transfers his business from Eton to Harrow. The welfare client has no analogous opportunity to establish a right to a service by virtue of the payment that he makes. A socialisation into socialism might help over time to combat the sense of personal failure that is experienced by Pinker’s ‘paupers at heart’ when they take without giving. So, however, might a greater reliance on the in-state freedom to choose.
Welfare per se can be a stigmatising encounter. Individual services themselves can be a further cause of lowered self-esteem. Thus social work can be perceived as a disempowering intrusion where a
104
Selectivity
meddlesome outsider feels a worn overcoat to determine if it warrants replacement, scans the sideboard for expensive drinks and inspects the children for signs of physical or sexual abuse. Strangers decide in secret on the nature of ego’s need. Large-scale bureaucracies appear inflexible, oppressive, impersonal, unresponsive. Practice variance and intrinsic discretion make the client vulnerable to the whims of a single named paternalist. Disputes and adversarial relationships are a cause of anger, apathy, hopelessness, rejection. Media references to ‘dysfunctional families’, ‘unmarried mothers’, ‘welfare scroungers’ reinforce the feeling that the social worker would not be visiting if the client were able to lead a normal life. Social work can make a valuable contribution to the welfare of the at-risk. The present point is not, however, a point about contribution but a point about stigma. Social workers ask questions about life style. At least the means test only asks questions about means. Council housing too can be perceived as marginalising welfare, as welfare that provides a roof but also, in Crosland’s words, ‘a taint’ – ‘a whiff of the welfare, of subsidization, of huge uniform estates, and generally of second-class citizenship’.13 The middle classes can escape the ‘taint’. The less privileged find it more difficult to ‘go private’. Surrounded by neighbours who are themselves less privileged, told they cannot keep pets or choose their own colour scheme, the separateness and the difference can easily inculcate in them a sense of lower self-worth. This, as Crosland stressed, is difficult to reconcile with the socialist objective of levelling through services: ‘Judged in this wider sense of social status, the council tenant and the owner-occupier are by no means equal.’14 Miller writes as follows about stigma within the framework of welfare: ‘Stigma threatens the person stigmatized, the programme, and the society which condones stigmatization . . . A stigmatized clientele stigmatizes a programme: a stigmatized programme stigmatizes its clientele.’15 A means-tested university scholarship would not be a good illustration of the self debased through association with service. A council flat offered to a candidate on supplementary benefits would be a better illustration of Miller’s vision of the less-glamorous tarnished by the less-prestigious. Where problem families make a rough development a no-go area at night, where only problem families are desperate enough to brave the drug-dealing and the vandalism, it will not be the entry barrier of the means test but rather the place of residence that will have the more
Evaluations and Extensions
105
stigmatising properties at the parents’ evening or when applying for a job. Education is a further area of welfare that can damage and depress. Titmuss, leaving school early, had at least escaped the rank in the year, the struggle to score well, the class of degree – and, of course, the ever-present anxiety that the young person will be found to be academically ungifted: ‘I was not forced to learn through a system of book-memorisation for examinations. In fact, I have never sat an examination in my life. So I was never conscious of being selected or rejected for a class of élites or professional experts. I escaped – at any rate at this stage in my life – the sense of being a failure; of being a second-class citizen.’16 So vivid is this evocation of stigma through schooling that the reader confidently expects Titmuss to make common cause with Crosland in attacking the 11-plus streaming system that was in use in his adult years to separate the intelligent from the duffers. Titmuss as it happens seems never to have made up his mind on this vital topic in British social policy. On the one hand he knew that testing could be a cause of second-bestness, self-perceived, at an impressionably early age: ‘Apart from the problem of education as the road to success there is the danger here of creating more rejects. The unfulfilled promise of child justice. Disappointed parents. The sense of inferiority in the mind of the child. Labelling children as failures.’17 On the other hand he knew that the social consensus wanted the high living standards that were made possible by meritocracy and accomplishment, and that nepotism and favouritism would be even less acceptable than credentials and ratings: ‘Of course, in the world in which we live we have to have some relatively objective tests for selection and promotion . . . But is it inevitable that examinations of the formal, traditional, written type should come to dominate our whole education system and our lives?’18 Titmuss never answered his own question. Nor did he make himself the champion of the comprehensive school with the argument that the alternative could only be an unwarranted incidence of spoiled self-esteem. Significantly, however, he did recognise that schools, like markets, are filtering mechanisms which screen out the losers before handing out the prizes. Schools to that extent are most definitely a part of the Welfare State that possesses the power to stigmatise. They can do so even in the absence of the personal means test that figures so prominently in Titmuss’s theory of welfare without clients getting hurt.
106
Selectivity
The case for positive discrimination rests on the theory of spoiled identity. Positive discrimination means the direction of resources without stigma towards a particular group or area. Here the question is not (as it is with a means test) of whom to exclude but (within the common structure of universalism) of whom to include more intensively. Whether this can be done without stigma is another matter. Some categories might feel stigmatised precisely because they have been selected: there is no a priori reason to think that the residents in Plowden’s Educational Priority Areas do not experience a collective sense of shame when they read in the newspapers that they have been branded as especially deficient. There may also be a conflict between economic necessity and the welfarist ethos where teachers and doctors in deprived areas must be paid a ‘dirty jobs’ differential to attract them away from comfortable areas rich in articulate professionals. Such differentials, necessary though they may be to secure and retain scarce welfare staffs, can be a source of profound discouragement to the local consumers should they learn the percentage value of their perceived inferiority. Again, just as some groups may feel stigmatised by being admitted, so other groups might feel stigmatised by being turned down. If a university discriminates in favour of blacks and browns, it is by definition discriminating against yellows and whites; and those latter trait-bearers, statistically good performers, might deeply resent the inference that their colour or social background is an