RELIGIOUS LITERACY What Every American Needs to Know—and Doesn’t Stephen Prothero
To my daughters, Molly and Lucy Pro...
86 downloads
1695 Views
3MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
RELIGIOUS LITERACY What Every American Needs to Know—and Doesn’t Stephen Prothero
To my daughters, Molly and Lucy Prothero
Contents
Introduction
1
Part 1 The Problem ONE
A Nation of Religious Illiterates
21
TWO
Religion Matters
39
Part 2 The Past THREE FOUR
Eden (What We Once Knew)
59
The Fall (How We Forgot)
87
Part 3 The Proposal FIVE SIX APPENDIX
Redemption (What to Do?)
125
A Dictionary of Religious Literacy
149
Religious Literacy Quiz
235
Contents
iv
Further Reading
241
Acknowledgments
243
Notes
245
Index
281
About the Author Credits Cover Copyright About the Publisher
Introduction
A
few years ago I was standing around the photocopier in Boston University’s Department of Religion when a visiting professor from Austria offered a passing observation about American undergraduates. They are very religious, he told me, but they know next to nothing about religion. Thanks to compulsory religious education (which in Austria begins in elementary schools), European students can name the twelve apostles and the Seven Deadly Sins, but they wouldn’t be caught dead going to church or synagogue themselves. American students are just the opposite. Here faith without understanding is the standard; here religious ignorance is bliss. The religious differences between Europe and the United States are typically described in terms of beliefs and practices: Europeans are far less likely than Americans to join and attend houses of worship or to believe in heaven and hell. This book, however, focuses on religious knowledge. It begins with a paradox I had been wrestling with for some time when my Austrian colleague helped to clarify it for me. That paradox is this: Americans are both deeply religious and profoundly ignorant about religion. They are Protestants who can’t name the four Gospels, Catholics who can’t name the seven sacraments, and Jews who can’t name the five books of Moses. Atheists may be as rare in America as Jesus-loving politicians are in Europe, but here faith is almost entirely devoid of content. One of the most religious countries on earth is also a nation of religious illiterates.1 Bible Babble
The civic implications of this paradox began to dawn on me on February 25, 1993, the day the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, and Firearms (BATF)
2
Introduction
raided the Waco, Texas, compound of an obscure religious sect called the Branch Davidians. I was at the time the proud owner of a freshly minted PhD trying to hold onto my first teaching job. My specialty was (and is) American religions, but I had no real expertise in new religious movements, and certainly no close encounters of the apocalyptic kind. Still, as I watched television coverage of the raid (which left six Branch Davidians and four BATF officials dead) and followed subsequent events in the media, I felt I knew how it was going to go down. The FBI, which took over the case from the BATF after the botched raid, thought it was calling the shots. But as I saw it, the Branch Davidians’ leader, David Koresh, was luring FBI agents into playing roles he had assigned to them in an end game of his own imagining—an end game whose logic derived not so much from FBI profiles or SWAT team tactics as from Koresh’s own idiosyncratic interpretation of the biblical book of Revelation. “It’s going to burn,” I told myself, and I remember thinking that I should pick up the phone and call the FBI, tell them what Koresh must be thinking, tell them to give him the time he had requested to unlock the cryptic meanings of the book of Revelation’s Seven Seals, show them how perfectly, how eerily, they were playing the parts he had assigned to them, let them know that, if they persisted, the whole thing would end in fire. But how do you call the FBI? (Do they have an 800 number?) And why would they listen to a thirty-something like me? I did not call. I hoped instead. I hoped that the federal government knew what it was doing—that President Bill Clinton and Attorney General Janet Reno were getting good advice from people far more knowledgeable than I about end times theology. Unfortunately, no such counsel was forthcoming. And so the siege did end in fire. As the FBI attacked the compound with tear gas and combat vehicles on April 19, 1993, flames engulfed the buildings, and Koresh and about seventy-five followers (including twenty-one children) perished. Waco was a case of death by religious ignorance. Perhaps the outcome was fated; perhaps the Branch Davidians were, as many believed, an incendiary cult and Koresh a megalomaniac hell-bent on death and destruction. Still, it might have ended differently if there had been someone, anyone, in the White House or the FBI who knew something, anything, about apocalyptic Christianity, if federal officials had not blithely dismissed Koresh’s theology as “Bible babble” unworthy of engagement.2 Religious ignorance proved deadly again in the aftermath of September 11, 2001, when an Indian American man was shot and killed at an Arizona gas station by a vigilante who believed the man’s turban marked
Introduction
3
him as a Muslim (and therefore for assassination). But what killed Balbir Singh Sodhi, who was actually a Sikh, was not simply bigotry. It was ignorance: the vigilante’s inability to distinguish a Muslim from a Sikh. The moral of this story is not just that we need more tolerance. It is that we need better education—and not because it is nice to be multicultural but because the world’s religions, no longer quarantined in the nations of their birth, now live and move among us: yoga in our church halls, nirvana in our dictionaries, and Sikhs at our gas stations. Religious ignorance was also rife after 9/11 in Washington DC, where, I soon learned to my dismay, hardly anyone spoke Arabic or understood the basics of Islam. And so the nation was treated for months to theology by sound bite. “Islam is peace,” President Bush stated repeatedly, as if that mantra were all Americans needed to know about the Islamic tradition. Meanwhile, the televangelist Jerry Falwell denounced Muhammad as “a terrorist,” and Paul Weyrich and William Lind, prominent voices in American conservatism, called Islam “a religion of war.”3 Who was right? Unfortunately, Americans had no way to judge, because, when it comes to understanding the Islamic tradition, most Americans are kindergarteners at best. Cultural Literacy Cultural literacy has been hotly debated ever since E. D. Hirsch’s best seller of that name injected the term into the culture wars in 1987. In Cultural Literacy, Hirsch, a University of Virginia English professor, argued that much of our common cultural coin had been drastically devalued. (“Remember the Alamo”? Um, not really.) Hirsch traced this problem to John Dewey and other Progressive-era education reformers, who gave up in the early twentieth century on content-based learning in favor of a skills-based strategy that scorned “the piling up of information.” This new educational model produced, according to Hirsch, “a gradual disintegration of cultural memory,” which caused in turn “a gradual decline in our ability to communicate.” Hirsch rightly understood that there are civic implications of this descent into cultural ignorance, particularly in a democracy that assumes an informed citizenry. “Having the right to vote is meaningless,” he observed, “if a citizen is disenfranchised by illiteracy or semiliteracy.” So Hirsch called for a return in America’s schools to “core knowledge,” beginning with his book’s appendix of five thousand or so names, dates, concepts, and phrases essential in his view to cultural literacy.4
4
Introduction
When I first began teaching in the early 1990s I was a follower of Dewey and the Progressives. In high school I had come to see the subject of history as nothing more than the mindless accumulation of names and dates, and I vowed upon entering college in the late 1970s that I would study every subject I could manage except history. Happily, I came across a professor who taught me that the vocation of history is not about memorizing names and dates but about forming judgments and contributing to debates about what happened in the past. So when I finished graduate school and became a professor myself, I told students that I didn’t care about facts. I cared about having challenging conversations, and I offered my quiz-free classrooms as places to do just that. I soon found, however, that the challenging conversations I coveted were not possible without some common knowledge—common knowledge my students plainly lacked. And so, quite against my prior inclinations, I began testing them on simple terms. In my world religions classes I told my students that before we could discuss in any detail the great religious traditions of the world, we would need to have some shared vocabulary in each, some basic religious literacy. In this way I became, like Hirsch, a traditionalist about content, not because I had come to see facts as the end of education but because I had come to see them as necessary means to understanding. Today religious illiteracy is at least as pervasive as cultural illiteracy, and certainly more dangerous. Religious illiteracy is more dangerous because religion is the most volatile constituent of culture, because religion has been, in addition to one of the greatest forces for good in world history, one of the greatest forces for evil. Whereas ignorance of the term Achilles’ heel may cause us to be confused about the outcome of a Super Bowl game or a statewide election, ignorance about Christian crusades and Muslim martyrdom can be literally lethal. When Madeleine Albright was secretary of state in the Clinton administration, she had an “entire bureau of economic experts” at her disposal but only one adviser with any expertise in religion. In The Mighty and the Almighty (2006) she notes that currently US ambassadors to Muslim-majority countries don’t have to have any training in Islam. That is not only foolhardy, it is dangerous. The same goes for ambassadors to India who don’t know anything about Hinduism or to China who don’t know anything about Confucianism.5 Religion has always been a major factor in US politics and international affairs. Neither the American Revolution nor the Civil War is comprehensible in a religion vacuum. The same goes for social reform movements such as abolitionism, temperance, women’s rights, civil
Introduction
5
rights, and environmentalism—and, of course, for contemporary debates about abortion, stem cell research, capital punishment, animal rights, global warming, intelligent design, state lotteries, birth control, euthanasia, gay marriage, welfare policy, military policy, and foreign policy. To be sure, the political, cultural, social, and economic force of religious ideas and institutions has not always been recognized. For much of the twentieth century, most American intellectuals dreamed of a public square empty of religious actors and religious arguments, and many imagined that this not-so-noble dream had become a reality—that religion had been quarantined to its rightful realm of the purely private and politics had been inoculated against the dangers of faith. Advocating for a politics stripped entirely of religious reasons—what the Catholic critic Richard John Neuhaus decried in the mid-1980s as a “naked public square”6—made sense as long as intellectuals were convinced, as they had been for the prior two decades, that religion was fading away. According to the prevailing secularization thesis, modernity and faith were antagonists in a zero-sum game; as modernity advanced, faith would retreat. But then came the deluge: the election of Jimmy Carter, the Iranian Revolution, the rise of the Moral Majority, the Reagan Revolution, 9/11, and the faith-based presidential election of 2004. Today far too many thinkers, on both the left and the right, cling to the illusion that we live in a “post-Christian” country and a secular world. But evidence of the public power of religion is overwhelming, particularly in the United States. As Boston University law professor Jay Wexler has observed, “A great many Americans rely on religious reasons when thinking and talking about public issues. Ninety percent of the members of Congress, by one report, consult their religious beliefs when voting on legislation. A majority of Americans believe that religious organizations should publicly express their views on political issues, and an even stronger majority believe it is important for a President to have strong religious beliefs.” All this is to say that the “naked public square” has been, as Wexler puts it, “substantially clothed with religion.” At least in the United States, religion matters. In fact, religion is now emerging alongside race, gender, and ethnicity as one of the key identity markers of the twenty-first century.7 “A Nation of Biblical Illiterates” If religion is this important, we ought to know something about it, particularly in a democracy, in which political power is vested in voters. But
6
Introduction
the average voter knows embarrassingly little about Christianity and other religions. Evangelical pollsters have lamented for some time the disparity between Americans’ veneration of the Bible and their understanding of it, painting a picture of a nation that believes God has spoken in scripture but can’t be bothered to listen to what God has to say. The Democratic presidential aspirant Howard Dean, when asked to name his favorite New Testament book, mistakenly cited an Old Testament text (Job) instead. But such confusion is not restricted to Dean’s home state of Vermont. According to recent polls, most American adults cannot name one of the four Gospels, and many high school seniors think that Sodom and Gomorrah were husband and wife. A few years ago no one in Jay Leno’s Tonight Show audience could name any of Jesus’ twelve apostles, but everyone, it seemed, was able to list the four Beatles. No wonder pollster George Gallup has called the United States “a nation of biblical illiterates.”8 One might imagine that ignorance of Christianity and the Bible is restricted to non-Christians or at least to non-evangelicals. But born-again Christians do only moderately better than other Americans on surveys of religious literacy. In a 2004 study of Bible literacy among high school students, most evangelical participants were not able to identify “Blessed are the poor in spirit” as a quote from the Sermon on the Mount.9 When it comes to religions other than Christianity, Americans fare far worse. One might hope that US citizens would know the most basic formulas of the world’s religions: the Five Pillars of Islam, for example, or Buddhism’s Four Noble Truths. But most Americans have difficulty even naming these religions. In a recent survey of American teenagers, barely half were able to come up with Buddhism and less than half with Judaism when asked to list the world’s five “major religions.” Far fewer could name Islam or Hinduism. According to Harvard religious studies professor Diana Eck, “Christians in the United States are pretty abysmally ignorant about the religious traditions of the rest of the world.”10 Religion as a Chain of Memory In The Man Who Mistook His Wife for a Hat (1987), neurologist Oliver Sacks wrote about patients with Korsakov’s syndrome, a neurological illness characterized by profound amnesia. Not knowing in any given moment what they are doing or why, these patients wander around in a state of profound disorientation; in losing their memory, they have lost
Introduction
7
themselves. Societies suffer from similar syndromes. The French sociologist Danièle Hervieu-Léger has written eloquently about the loss of faith in Europe as a sort of amnesia. The rise of secularism in Europe, she contends, is rooted not so much in doubt as in forgetting. Religion is a “chain of memory,” she argues, and Europeans have broken the chain.11 Faith is more robust in the United States, but Americans are forgetters too. Catholics have forgotten the words of the Baltimore Catechism their parents and grandparents once knew by heart. Protestants have forgotten the key plot points in the Exodus story, which beckoned New England’s colonists to a New World Zion. Methodists have forgotten what distinguishes them from Baptists. And whatever Americans once knew about Islam and Asian religions, well, they have forgotten most of that too. Many of the institutions that once forged the “chain of memory” that is religion are now some of its weakest links. Because of grave misunderstandings about the First Amendment and the separation of church and state, the subject of religion is taboo in many public schools. Moreover, churches, synagogues, and other religious congregations, which once inculcated “the Fourth R” effectively (though doubtless in their own manner) are now doing so ineffectively, or not at all.12 Basic religious literacy is lacking even in seminaries, where many ministers-in-the-making are unable to describe the distinguishing marks of the denominations they are training to serve. Half a century ago, in Protestant-Catholic-Jew (1955), sociologist Will Herberg wrote that “the religion which actually prevails among Americans today has lost much of its authentic Christian (or Jewish) content.” The postwar religious revival, which saw church membership and attendance rates rocket to all-time highs, came according to Herberg at a cost. And the cost was religious content. In conforming themselves to American culture, Protestantism, Catholicism, and Judaism had become little more than parallel paths up the mountain of the American dream. Instead of quaking in the presence of the Almighty, Herberg observed, Americans blithely pledged their allegiance to “religion that makes religion its own object.” In the process Protestantism, Catholicism, and Judaism became, at least in their American incarnations, “so empty and contentless, so conformist, so utilitarian, so sentimental, so individualistic, and so self-righteous.”13 Today what Herberg decried as “the growing ‘religious illiteracy’ of the American people” remains a major challenge to believers hoping to keep their children in the faith or to bring up the next generation of ministers, priests, rabbis, and imams.14 Catholic leaders lament how quickly and
8
Introduction
deeply their youth descended into Catholic illiteracy after the reforms of the Second Vatican Council (1962–65) did away with rote memorization of the Baltimore Catechism. Evangelicals mourn the passing of biblical literacy at the hands of television, video games, and the Internet. Jews worry about what Jewish illiteracy portends for their community’s survival. Religious literacy also troubles educators, who know how much our appreciation of literature, music, and art depends on our knowledge of the Bible—how difficult it is to understand the musical compositions of J. S. Bach and the paintings of El Greco as long as we are deaf and blind to artists’ spiritual impulses and religious idioms. In 2002 the official magazine of the National Association of Independent Schools decried “a high level of religious illiteracy” even in the nation’s elite private schools.15 But broken links in the chain of memory that sustains faith through the generations should not be of interest solely to believers or educators. Americans’ inability to think clearly and speak confidently about Christianity and other religions should concern anyone who cares about American public life. A Civic Problem I am by training a professor of religious studies. That means, among other things, that just about every time I step onto a plane or attend a party I have to explain to someone that, no, I am not a minister, no, I do not teach theology, and, no, I do not work in a divinity school. Theology and religious studies, I often say, are two very different things—as different as art and art history. While theologians do religion, religious studies scholars study religion. Rather than ruminating on God, practitioners of religious studies explore how other human beings (theologians included) ruminate on sacred things. Scholars of religion can be religious, of course, but being religious is not our job. Our job is to try to understand what religious people say, believe, know, feel, and experience. And we try to do this work as fairly and objectively as possible. Working as a religious studies professor also means being committed to seeing the study of religion as an indispensable part of a liberal education—to viewing religious literacy as a key component, perhaps the key component, of what Hirsch called cultural literacy. So I share with philosopher Warren Nord the conviction that our current inattention to religion in secondary and higher education today is a failure of the highest order—that “current American education is profoundly illiberal in its refusal to take religion seriously.”16 In this book, however, I write more as
Introduction
9
a citizen than as an educator. I am convinced that one needs to know something about the world’s religions in order to be truly educated. And I will admit to a sneaking suspicion, likely rooted in my Episcopal upbringing, that faith without knowledge is dead. However, the argument of this book is neither that liberal education needs religious studies nor that real faith requires religious knowledge. The argument is that you need religious literacy in order to be an effective citizen. When antebellum Americans weighed the pros and cons of slavery— almost exclusively on the basis of the Bible—most citizens could make sense of that debate’s references to the runaway slave in the New Testament book of Philemon and to the year of the Jubilee (when slaves could be freed) in the Old Testament book of Leviticus. When the Seneca Falls convention of 1848 put female suffrage on the national agenda, most citizens knew that suffragettes would have to contend with the injunctions in 1 Timothy and 1 Corinthians (two New Testament letters attributed to the apostle Paul) that women should keep silent in the churches and submit to male authority. Today it is a rare American who can follow with any degree of confidence biblically inflected debates about abortion or gay marriage. Or, for that matter, about the economy, since the most widely quoted Bible verse in the United States—“God helps those who help themselves”—is not actually in the Bible.17 Religious illiteracy makes it difficult for Americans to make sense of a world in which people kill and make peace in the name of Christ or Allah. How are we to understand protests against the Vietnam War, which compelled Catholic priests to burn draft records in Maryland and Buddhist monks to set fire to themselves in Vietnam, without knowing something about Catholic just war theory and the Buddhist principles of no-self and compassion? How are we to understand international conflicts in the Middle East and Sri Lanka without reckoning with the role of Jerusalem in the sacred geography of the Abrahamic faiths and with the differences between Hinduism and Buddhism in Southeast Asia? Closer to home, how are we to understand faith-based electioneering if the “reds” on the Religious Right and the “blues” on the Secular Left continue to stereotype one another as distinct species? Is it possible to weigh the merits of Supreme Court rulings on religious liberty if we are unaware of the legacies of antiCatholicism, anti-Semitism, anti-Mormonism, and anti-fundamentalism in American life?18 From the time of the nation’s founding, the success of the American experiment in republican government was rightly understood to rest on an educated citizenry. If suffrage was to be extended first to white males
10
Introduction
with property and eventually to men and women of all races, then it would be essential for all Americans to understand the issues on which they were voting. How could we act responsibly as citizens if we did not know how to read, if we did not know something about politics and history and science and economics? Today, when religion is implicated in virtually every issue of national and international import (not least the nomination of Supreme Court justices), US citizens need to know something about religion too. In an era in which the public square is, rightly or wrongly, awash in religious reasons, can one really participate fully in public life without knowing something about Christianity and the world’s religions? Without basic religious literacy? How to decide whether intelligent design is “religious” or “scientific” without some knowledge of both science and religion? How to determine whether the effort to yoke Christianity and “family values” makes sense without knowing what sort of “family man” Jesus was? How to adjudicate the debate between President Bush’s description of Islam as a religion of peace and the conviction of many televangelists that Islam is a religion of war without some basic information about Muhammad and the Quran? How to determine whether the current Supreme Court’s First Amendment jurisprudence discriminates against minority religions without knowing what Sikhs and Buddhists hold dear? Unfortunately, US citizens today lack this religious literacy. As a result, they are too easily swayed by demagogues on the left or the right. Few Americans are able to challenge claims made by politicians or pundits about Islam’s place in the war on terrorism or what the Bible says about homosexuality. This ignorance imperils our public life, putting citizens in the thrall of talking heads and effectively transferring power from the third estate (the people) to the fourth (the press). The Roots of Religious Illiteracy How did this happen? And what can we do about it? In order to answer these questions, we need to understand how one of the most religious countries in the world slipped into religious amnesia. When did we forget what we once knew about the Bible, the Apostles’ Creed, the Westminster Confession, the Ten Commandments, the Exodus story, and the crucifixion? How was the chain of memory that once transmitted religious knowledge from parents to children, priests to parishioners, and schoolteachers to students severed?
Introduction
11
This book answers these questions by going back, first, to an Eden of sorts in which basic literacy and religious literacy (at least of the Protestant sort) went hand in hand—when young people learned to read by learning to read the Bible, and Christian doctrines and stories were part of the mental furniture of virtually all adults. It then locates a moment in US history—call it the Fall—when religious faith and religious knowledge went their separate ways. Observers of today’s culture wars might imagine that my account of the decline of religious literacy will turn on the events of the 1960s, notably the 1962 and 1963 US Supreme Court rulings that banned school prayer and Bible reading in the public schools. After all, the justices behind Engel v. Vitale (1962) and Abington v. Schempp (1963) have long been the whipping boys of the Religious Right, which itself emerged out of the rancor these rulings unleashed.19 But public schools are not the only places where religious literacy has been cultivated (or ignored), and religion ceased to be a topic of instruction in these schools generations before the hippies became hip. The historical portion of this book focuses instead on two religious revivals: the Second Great Awakening of the first third of the nineteenth century and the postwar revival of the 1940s and 1950s. In each case the villains were not activist judges or ACLU-style secularists hell-bent on hounding religion out of the public square but well-meaning religious folks intent on doing just the opposite. In one of the great ironies of American religious history, it was the nation’s most fervent people of faith who steered Americans down the road to religious illiteracy. Just how that happened is one of the stories this book has to tell. Defining Religious Literacy After making a historical diagnosis of religious illiteracy, this book goes on to prescribe a remedy. Given a problem like ignorance, the solution is obviously going to be knowledge. But what kind of knowledge do we need? And what sort of education will deliver it? Before answering these questions, we must define more precisely what religious literacy is and what it is not. Like the term cultural literacy, religious literacy is obviously a metaphor of sorts. On its home ground in linguistics, literacy refers to the ability to use a language—to read and perhaps to write it, to manipulate its vocabulary, grammar, and syntax. In this sense religious literacy refers to the ability to understand and use in one’s day-to-day life the basic building blocks of religious traditions—their
12
Introduction
key terms, symbols, doctrines, practices, sayings, characters, metaphors, and narratives. Like languages, however, religions are particular creatures. Just as it is not possible to speak language in general (one must choose to speak one particular language), religious literacy in the abstract is an impossibility. (One cannot be literate in every religion; neither is there one generic religion to “speak.”) It would probably be most precise, therefore, to refer to specific religious literacies: Protestant literacy, Buddhist literacy, Islamic literacy (or, even more accurately, Methodist literacy, Zen literacy, Sunni literacy, and so on). In this context Protestant literacy might refer to knowing the basic history of the Protestant Reformation, the core beliefs of the Christian creeds, and the basic symbols, heroes, and stories of the King James Bible, while Islamic literacy might refer to knowing basic Islamic history, the key practices of the Five Pillars of Islam, and the basic symbols, heroes, and stories of the Quran. Religious literacy might also be divided into a variety of functional capacities; for example, ritual literacy (knowing how to cross yourself during the Catholic Mass or how to perform ablutions before Muslim prayers); confessional literacy (knowing what Christians affirm in the Apostles’ Creed or what Muslims affirm in the Shahadah); denominational literacy (knowing salient differences between Episcopalians and Catholics or between Reform and Conservative Jews); and narrative literacy (knowing what Adam and Eve are said to have done in the Garden of Eden or how the Buddha came to abandon his palace for the life of a wandering ascetic). It might even be useful to refer, as has Professor Francis Clooney of the Harvard Divinity School, to “interreligious literacy.”20 But all this specificity can get unwieldy at times, so this book will refer to religious literacy in general as a shorthand for one or more of these particular religious literacies. In the United States today the most important of these particular literacies is Christian literacy. Inside the academic study of religion it is decidedly out of fashion to emphasize Christianity over other religions. In fact, many a college course in American religion devotes more time to Vodou than it does to Methodism. The point of this multicultural approach to American religion is to underscore the fact that the United States is one of the most religiously diverse nations on earth. But the United States is also the world’s most Christian country. With a Christian population of about 250 million, there are more Christians in the United States today than there have been in any other country in the history of the world. Christianity’s dominance, moreover, swells as you enter the corridors of power. Of all the members of the 109th Congress, 92 percent were Chris-
Introduction
13
tians, as were 100 percent of fifty state governors in 2000. Among this elite group of state and national politicians, there were zero Muslims, zero Buddhists, and zero Hindus.21 So it should be obvious that Christian literacy is more important than other religious literacies when it comes to understanding US politics. A quick search of the Congressional Record (the official source for Senate and House debates) reveals in excess of a thousand usages of the Golden Rule and more than five hundred invocations of the Good Samaritan over the last two decades. This same search yields hundreds of references to the Promised Land, Armageddon, and the Apocalypse. In a nationally televised address on September 11, 2001, President George W. Bush quoted from the Twenty-third Psalm. One year later, on the first anniversary of the 9/11 attacks, he concluded with a reference to John 1:5 (“The light shines in the darkness, but the darkness has not understood it”).22 You may be a Hare Krishna, a Jain, or an atheist yourself, but to be religiously literate in contemporary America you need to be familiar with Bible characters such David and Goliath, Bible stories such as the trial and crucifixion of Jesus, and Bible phrases such as “an eye for an eye” and “the love of money is the root of all evil.” Christian literacy is not enough, however. To understand foreign policy on Tibet, for example, one needs to know something about Buddhist monasticism and the Dalai Lama. To follow the ramifications of the “under God” language in the Pledge of Allegiance, one needs to know something about the nuances of both atheism and polytheism. And to fully engage in debates about the war in Iraq, one needs to be informed about jihad and the Islamic tradition of martyrdom (a tradition, it might be noted, that Muslims adapted from Christians and Jews). The war on terrorism is to a great extent—a far greater extent than most American politicians recognize—a war of ideas. To wage that war, one needs to be equipped with ideas—to understand, among other things, the religious underpinnings of Osama bin Laden’s strategy to engage “the crusaderZionist alliance” in a clash of civilizations.23 Religious Literacy in Practice In this book religious literacy refers to the ability to understand and use the religious terms, symbols, images, beliefs, practices, scriptures, heroes, themes, and stories that are employed in American public life. Some of this is factual information, which might be learned, as students often learn vocabulary words, by simple memorization. So this book’s proposals are open to the criticisms of “rote learning” that descended upon Hirsch
14
Introduction
when he published his controversial list of “what every American needs to know.” But religious literacy is not just the accumulation of facts. Tempting as it is to define this book’s core concept entirely in terms of doctrine—as the ability to work with such Christian teachings as the atonement or such basic practices as baptism—religious literacy cannot and should not be reduced to memorizing and regurgitating dogma. To return again to the Christian example, surely religious literacy also includes knowing the key characters, images, and stories in the scriptures, rites, and history of the church. And so, in addition to doctrine, this book’s definition of religious literacy includes narrative. To be religiously literate today is to be familiar with the creation story in Genesis and the apocalyptic horrors of Revelation. It is to know that David triumphed over Goliath, even though David was small and Goliath was big, perhaps to know as well that David felled the giant with a stone. Religious literacy, in short, is both doctrinal and narrative; it is conveyed through creeds and catechisms, yes, but also through creation accounts and stories of the last days.24 Like other forms of literacy, religious literacy is more a fluid practice than a fixed condition.25 It is the ability to participate in our ongoing conversation about the private and public powers of religions. But that ability itself depends on knowing basic information about Christianity and other religions, and that basic information changes over time. Certain religious terms that were widely employed in American public life in 1776—Socianism, to take just one example—are no longer in circulation today. And terms, such as Wahhabism, that were not noteworthy as recently as the 1990s now circulate widely. Because of the rapid rise of religious diversity in the United States since Congress opened up immigration from Asia in 1965, understanding the basics of Islam, Buddhism, and Hinduism is far more important than it was a half century ago. Nonetheless, understanding Christianity and the Bible must remain the core task of religious literacy education, if only because Christian and biblical terms are most prevalent on our radios and televisions, and on the lips of our legislators, judges, and presidents. There are many uses to which religious literacy can be put. Religious literacy can be used to firm up the faith of young people raised in the Lutheran Church–Missouri Synod or Reform Judaism. It might be seen, in other words, as a way to keep teenagers on the straight and narrow, to convince young adults to marry inside the faith, or to give adults the courage to share their deepest convictions with their friends. Some read-
Introduction
15
ers might assume that this is my agenda. After all, many who speak out on religion in public life have theological axes to grind; they are out to promote Roman Catholicism or to ridicule fundamentalism or to turn the United States into a theocracy of this or that sort. But my agenda is not religious. It is civic and secular. I was raised an Episcopalian and, if pressed, will fess up to being a Christian. I prefer, however, to describe myself as religiously confused. Like many Americans, I find far more questions than answers in the world’s religious traditions, and my attitude toward people who possess firmer faith than my own is awe rather than fear. Regardless of the measure of my faith (and doubt), however, I write here not as a believer (or unbeliever) but as a citizen. My purpose is not to foster faith or to denigrate it. Neither is it to advance the liberal arts or to boost high school students’ SAT scores (though these are both laudable educational ends to which religious literacy might be put). My goal is to help citizens participate fully in social, political, and economic life in a nation and a world in which religion counts. To put this goal in more personal terms, my hope is that readers will come away from this book empowered to talk about religion in their homes, at work, in houses of worship, and in the rough-and-tumble of local and national politics. I hope that readers will be emboldened to ask questions about their own faiths and to learn about the religious traditions of others. A neighbor of mine—a conservative Catholic—told me recently that she and many of her Catholic friends go mum whenever the topic of religion comes up in everyday conversations out of a fear that, if they speak up, their ignorance will be quickly found out (presumably by biblically literate Protestants). At least one study supports this anecdotal evidence, reporting that many Catholics harbor “feelings of inadequacy” in the face of conservative Protestants “better versed in Bible knowledge.” Catholics may find it reassuring to learn that the average American Protestant knows very little about the Bible. I find it troubling, however, that members of America’s largest religious group (Roman Catholicism) feel that they cannot discuss religion even with their friends, not because of qualms about mixing religion and politics but because of fears about making fools of themselves. I doubt, moreover, that such anxieties are confined to Catholics. This book aims to allay these anxieties and quiet these fears by offering readers of all faiths (and none at all) the confidence they need to participate in religious discussions.26
16
Introduction
What to Do? So much for what religious literacy is and does. How might we cultivate it? One way of course is for individuals to read the Bible or the Quran, or both. Individuals can also peruse the Dictionary of Religious Literacy in chapter 6 of this book. This dictionary defines key terms from Christianity and other religions, focusing on the religious symbols, beliefs, rituals, holidays, scriptures, people, places, and historical events employed in public life for political purposes. It also refers in many cases to specific instances in which these terms have been used—references to Adam and Eve and Sodom and Gomorrah in the gay marriage debate, for example, or President George W. Bush’s description of the war on terrorism as a crusade, or Senator Hillary Clinton’s characterization of restrictive immigration legislation as contrary to the spirit of the Good Samaritan. This dictionary delivers, in other words, the basic vocabulary one needs to become a religiously literate US citizen, and to allay anxieties about discussing religion over the water cooler or in the living room. In addition to empowering individual readers with the basic building blocks of religious literacy, this book suggests how religious literacy might be cultivated in our collective lives. Churches, synagogues, mosques, and temples can do much to address our collective ignorance— to follow the commandment to “remember” made repeatedly in the Hebrew Bible. Religious leaders can preach from their scriptures more plainly and more regularly. Religious congregations can go “back to basics” in their Sunday schools and religious camps. But even if America’s religious congregations were to step up and start teaching effectively the faiths of their fathers and mothers, that would affect only regular attenders. And even they would come to know only their own religious tradition (and from one particular perspective). The media could help too. Since 9/11 mainstream print and broadcast media have gotten religion. Many major newspapers have religion beat writers, and it is no longer rare to see an intelligent program on religion broadcast on national television. But it no longer appears to be the media’s vocation to educate the public—entertainment is the new god— and even if it were, the media’s own plague of religious illiteracy would prevent them from doing much good. The most effective way forward, therefore, is to focus on secondary schools and colleges. America’s private and public educational institutions need to get religion, to start seeing teaching about religion not as a
Introduction
17
third rail but as the “Fourth R.” Two barriers currently stand in the way: misinformation about the constitutionality of teaching about religion in schools, and a misguided approach to religious studies in colleges and universities. Each of these barriers can be overcome if American citizens come to understand what the US Supreme Court has actually said about religion in the public schools, and if religious studies experts stop preaching the gospel of religious relativism. This book argues for both the constitutionality and the necessity of teaching about religion in public schools and higher education. In this respect its proposals might be understood as advocating “civic education,” which one group defines as the inculcation of the knowledge, skills, dispositions, and virtues necessary for “self-government” in our “constitutional democracy.”27 And my proposals do engage the “civic education” debate. This book shares with the writings of Professors Eck and Wexler the conviction that teaching about religion is first and foremost a civic enterprise. However, unlike others who have advanced civic arguments for the study of religion in our schools, I focus on spreading knowledge rather than inculcating virtues. Today many are not so sure that morality needs religion as a prop or that religion’s first order of business should be performing such a role. Scores of books have been written about America’s moral decline. This book addresses a different problem: our descent into religious ignorance. My argument concerning the academic study of religion in secondary and higher education is threefold: first, that teaching about religion is an essential task for our educational institutions; second, that the primary purpose of such teaching should be civic; and third, that this civic purpose should be to produce citizens who know enough about Christianity and the world’s religions to participate meaningfully—on both the left and the right—in religiously inflected public debates. High school and college graduates who have not taken a single course about religion cannot be said to be truly educated. Like the scene in The Wizard of Oz in which Dorothy opens the door to a Technicolor munchkin land, many key chapters in US and world history leap from black-and-white to color once you realize the role religion played in them—how the Inner Light of Quakers shaped the abolitionist movement, how biblical criticism lent the women’s rights movement much of its early brio, and how the theological mouthful of “dispensational premillennialism” fed the bottom line of software firms during the months before Y2K. The same is true of the stories that appear in the morning paper and on the nightly news. Suicide bombings in the Middle
18
Introduction
East, the enduring popularity of The Da Vinci Code, the latest diet fad, the Yankees–Red Sox morality play, and the ritual cycles of presidential elections all make far more sense (and are far more intriguing) if these tales are not stripped of the coat of many colors that is religion. But more intriguing is not the whole story here, since in addition to making the world more interesting, religious literacy also makes it less dangerous. Of course, getting past religious ignorance is not the panacea some advocates of interreligious dialogue imagine it to be. (People sometimes kill their enemies not because they do not understand them but precisely because they do.) Still, it is hard to avoid the conclusion that some of the bloodletting in such places as Waco and Afghanistan and Iraq might have been avoided if we had understood a bit better our own religions traditions, and those of others.
Part 1
The Problem
One
A Nation of Religious Illiterates
B
oth the Religious Right and the Secular Left feel besieged. In the Left Behind novels popular in conservative Christian circles, true believers are “raptured” into heaven at the end of times; everyone else is “left behind.” Today secularists are attesting to a Last Days scenario of another sort, in which the old order of reason, rights, and the separation of church and state is being replaced by a new medievalism in which the president and his acolytes answer to God rather than to the American people. This disquiet can be heard in port cities across the country, but it is particularly palpable in Manhattan, the mecca of the Secular Left, where many report that their island is starting to feel, well, like an island again, cut off from the heartland by (among other things) its cosmopolitanism. At least for New Yorkers, it is as if the iconic Saul Steinberg cartoon of the United States according to Manhattan—an image that looks west across Ninth Avenue and the Hudson River and New Jersey to a Kansas City the size of a yellow cab and a Los Angeles no bigger than a courier’s bicycle—is eerily mutating into a Grant Wood landscape, its bucolic foreground anchored not by yellow cabs but by the corn rows and church spires of Kansas, with nary a skyscraper on the horizon. “I feel assaulted,” one New Yorker told me. “I feel like these Christians are hiding a crucifix in their shoe. Any minute they’ll pull it out and gut you.”28 Bill O’Reilly of The O’Reilly Factor on Fox News feels assaulted too. Whereas secularists are sure that the Religious Right has taken over US politics, he is morally certain that “secular progressives” are winning the culture wars. Christmas is “under siege,” O’Reilly says. An “anti-Christian jihad” is banishing Christmas trees from holiday parades, Christmas carols from public school pageants, and Christmas greetings from department
22
RELIGIOUS LITERACY
stores. In the world according to O’Reilly, the ultimate aim of these criminalizers of Christmas is nothing less than banishing religion from the public square and thereby clearing the way for “secular progressive programs like legalization of narcotics, euthanasia, abortion at will, gay marriage.” Televangelist Jerry Falwell also believes that “radical secularists” are “aggressively attempting to redefine America in their own Godless image,” and religious broadcaster Pat Buchanan complains about “hate crimes against Christianity.” The mission of the Secular Left, concludes Buchanan, is “to expunge from the public life of the West all reminders that ours was once a Christian civilization and America once a Christian country.”29 The emotions on both sides of this question are understandable, though the irony of the situation—in which each camp sees itself as a victim and believes that the other is seizing control of the country—seems lost on everyone concerned. The fact of the matter is that, in the American marketplace of ideas, neither faith nor faithlessness is close to either bankruptcy or monopoly. Though O’Reilly may rage, Christmas (which remains a national holiday) is not fading into that good night. And theocracy—in the true sense of church-run government—is not even a twinkle in the Bush administration’s eye. Much ink has been spilled, and many megabytes expended, trying to pigeonhole the nation into either “secular America” or “Christian America.” It has always been both. The United States is by law a secular country. God is not mentioned in the Constitution, and the First Amendment’s establishment clause forbids the state from getting into the church business. However, that same amendment also includes a free exercise clause safeguarding religious liberty, and Americans have long exercised this liberty by praying to God, donating to religious congregations, and hoping for heaven. So there is logic not only to President John Adams’s affirmation in the Treaty of Tripoli in 1796 that “the government of the United States of America is not in any sense founded on the Christian religion” but also to the Supreme Court’s 1892 observation that “this is a Christian nation.” In short, the long-standing debate about whether the United States is secular or religious is fundamentally confused. Thanks to the establishment clause, the US government is secular by law; thanks to the free exercise clause, American society is religious by choice.30 Ever since George Washington put his hand on a Bible and swore to uphold a godless Constitution, the United States has been both staunchly secular and resolutely religious. Church and state have never been completely separated in the United States; religion and politics were bedfel-
A Nation of Religious Illiterates
23
lows from the start. Traditional liberals such as the political philosopher John Rawls insist that religion restrict itself to the individual heart, the pious home, and the religious congregation; religion is a private matter that will contaminate civil society if not quarantined from public life. Because religion is a “conversation stopper,” political discourse must be conducted entirely in terms of “public reason,” which by definition excludes religious reasons. According to this strict separationist perspective, the wall between church and state is supposed to form, as one nineteenth-century activist once put it, “a barrier high and eternal as the Andes.” The only alternative is “politics as holy war.”31 George W. Bush caught a lot of flak for disrespecting this church-state divide at his 2001 inauguration, which included one prayer offered by the Reverend Franklin Graham (Billy’s son) in the name of “the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit” and another offered by the United Methodist minister Kirbyjon Caldwell “in the name that’s above all other names, Jesus, the Christ.” But Bush’s sin was also committed, in flagrante delicto, by Bill Clinton, whose inaugurations were unabashedly Christian affairs. Clinton’s 1997 fete included a trinitarian prayer by Billy Graham, a benediction by a black Baptist preacher, and songs by no fewer than three gospel groups (one called the Resurrection Choir). Plainly, the celebrated wall of separation between church and state has never been particularly wide or sturdy. Breached nearly as often as it has been respected, this wall resembles a rickety picket fence far more than the eternal Andes. Washington and Madison, Reagan and Clinton all declared national days of prayer or thanksgiving, and the Supreme Court still opens its sessions with “God save the United States and this Honorable Court.” As G. K. Chesterton once put it, the United States has long been “a nation with the soul of a church.”32 Churched and Unchurched Believers The contrast with Europe could not be sharper. Many theological doctrines that Europeans now dismiss as fables—heaven and hell, angels and the devil—are enthusiastically affirmed by the vast majority of Americans. Out of every ten adults in the United States, more than nine believe in God, more than eight say that religion is important to them personally, and more than seven report praying daily. Believers here also put their money where their faith is; annual giving to houses of worship—about $88 billion—is larger than the gross domestic product of many nations. What the apostle Paul once said to the Athenians—“I see that in every
24
RELIGIOUS LITERACY
way you are very religious” (Acts 17:22, NIV)—applies to Americans too.33 Conservatives often claim that “secular humanism” is running amok in America—that the United States has become “post-Christian.” But that is simply not the case. The kind of hard-nosed secularism that is common in Europe—“Eurosecularity,” in the neologism of sociologist Peter Berger—is hard to find even in the bluest boroughs of America’s bluest states. Some surveys show that the portion of “Nones” (those who claim no religious preference) is rising in the United States—doubling by one account over the course of the 1990s from 7 percent to 14 percent. But those who have distanced themselves from organized religion have done nothing of the sort when it comes to God or spirituality. In a recent survey of US adolescents, sociologist Christian Smith found that, of the teenagers who claimed “no religion,” fewer than one out of five rejected the possibility of life after death. In a recent study of American adults, nine out of ten of the “no religion” respondents told researchers that they pray. These “Nones,” in short, are about as irreligious as your average nun. Few are Euro-style atheists or agnostics; the vast majority are “unchurched believers”—spiritual people who for one reason or another avoid religious congregations.34 Of America’s religions, the most popular of course is Christianity. Half of Americans describe themselves as Protestants, one-quarter as Catholics, and 10 percent as Christians of some other stripe. This makes the US population more Christian than Israel is Jewish or Utah is Mormon. Moreover, members of this Christian majority are extraordinarily observant. About two-thirds of Americans are church members, and two-fifths report attending a religious congregation either weekly or almost every week.35 Inside American Christianity, evangelical or “born-again” Protestantism is particularly robust. Forty percent of Americans call themselves born-again Christians, and nearly half report a born-again experience. When it comes to biblical literalists—those who say they believe that the Bible is the literal word of God—only the Philippines (54 percent) and Poland (37 percent) rank higher than the United States (34 percent).36 America’s buoyant religiosity repeatedly flows beyond the rivers of our private domains onto the banks of our public life. The land of Thomas Jefferson and church-state separation is now the land of The Passion of the Christ and the passions of born-again politicians. Candidates for elected office call Jesus not only their Savior but also their favorite political philosopher. National news magazines repeatedly put Jesus and Mary on
A Nation of Religious Illiterates
25
their covers, not least because such magazines race off the shelves. In the world of entertainment, Christian music sales exceed $1 billion annually, and songs such as “Jesus Take the Wheel” by American Idol winner Carrie Underwood top the charts. Although conservative radio and television commentators rail against the exile of Christianity from American public life, their own ratings belie the huffing and puffing. Even heated debates about the proper role of religion in the public square—court cases about posting the Ten Commandments on public property or about accommodating God in the Pledge of Allegiance—attest to the power of the Christian majority to put such matters on the national agenda.37 A Nation of Religions If the United States is both secular and religious, it is also both Christian and pluralistic. Christianity dominates, but this nation of immigrants is also “a nation of religions.”38 Los Angeles, the most religiously heterogeneous city in the country, boasts more than three hundred Buddhist temples and is likely home to more Buddhist schools than Tokyo. According to a recent study, one in every eight Americans, including many Christians and Jews, say that Buddhism has influenced their religious lives. There are only about a million Hindus in the United States, but many of the largest companies in the Silicon Valley are run by them. And yoga, which began in ancient India as a technique for spiritual liberation from the cycle of life, death, and rebirth, is now a Main Street phenomenon, practiced in community centers and churches alike. Taoism is present too—in thousands of martial arts academies scattered in cities and small towns across the United States. Islam is even more visible. Now represented in over 1,200 mosques nationwide, it will soon outrun Judaism as America’s second largest religion (that is, if it hasn’t already). Harvard’s Diana Eck exaggerates when she calls the United States “the most religiously diverse nation on earth.” With a Christian majority of roughly 85 percent, the United States is far more homogeneous than dozens of countries with no religious majority. (For every hundred people in Singapore, for example, there are forty-two Buddhists, fifteen Muslims, fifteen Christians, eight Taoists, and four Hindus.) Still, Eck is right that the United States offers its citizens one of the world’s largest menus of spiritual options. The fare is mind-boggling in Flushing, New York, which religious studies scholar R. Scott Hanson has described as “perhaps the most extreme case of religious pluralism in the world.” Over two hundred houses of worship, including six different Hindu temples and one
26
RELIGIOUS LITERACY
hundred Korean churches, are crammed into this small community of a few square miles. There are buildings for Buddhists, Sikhs, Muslims, Taoists, Mormons, and Protestants. Jews can choose among Reform, Conservative, and Orthodox synagogues.39 Given America’s religious diversity, it should not be surprising that Jesus and Mary have company in the public square. Kanye West may not be rapping about the Dalai Lama, but the spiritual and political leader of the Tibetan people has become an American icon, celebrated on billboards for Apple computers as someone who “thinks different.” A gaggle of celebrities, not least the actor Richard Gere, has championed the cause for Tibetan independence. Perfumes have been named after such Hindu concepts as om (a sacred sound), samsara (the cycle of life, death, and rebirth), and karma (the law of actions and their consequences). American Hindus Against Defamation, a pressure group modeled after the Anti-Defamation League, is working hard to combat negative stereotypes of Hindus. More than any of these religious newcomers to American society, however, Islam has pushed powerfully into politics. Thanks to groups such as the Council on American-Islamic Relations and the Muslim Public Affairs Council, Muslims were quite active in both the 2000 and 2004 presidential elections. (They voted overwhelmingly for Bush in the former and for Kerry in the latter.) In Dearborn, Michigan, Muslims constitute a potent political force. All this is to say that both the private and the public lives of Americans are “awash in a sea of faith.” Unfortunately, however, Americans’ knowledge of religion runs as shallow as Americans’ commitment to religion runs deep. Many cannot recognize the phrase “Hail, Mary” except as the name of a football play; many are unaware that the pop singer Madonna was actually named after someone. In fact, most Americans lack the most basic understanding of their own religious traditions. Americans, writes historian R. Laurence Moore, “are stupefyingly dumb about what they are supposed to believe.”40 Religious Literacy Quiz Over a century and a half ago Henry David Thoreau complained in Walden (1854) about the religious ignorance of his neighbors in Concord, Massachusetts. “As for the sacred Scriptures, or Bibles of mankind, who in this town can tell me even their titles?” he asked. “Most men do not know that any nation but the Hebrews have had a scripture.” Things are a bit better today. Most major bookstores carry translations of such scrip-
A Nation of Religious Illiterates
27
tures as the Bhagavad Gita and the Quran. After the Bible itself, Lao Tzu’s Taoist classic, the Tao Te Ching, is likely the most widely translated book in the United States. Still, one wonders who is actually reading these sacred texts, and with what sort of care. In Thoreau’s time the Unitarian minister turned Transcendentalist sage, Ralph Waldo Emerson, mistook the Bhagavad Gita to be “the much renowned book of Buddhism.” Closer to our time justices for the United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit made a similar mistake. While considering in 1982 whether the International Society for Krishna Consciousness (the Hare Krishnas) is a religion, they said that the Bhagavad Gita (which is a Hindu scripture) is “as important in the Buddhist religions [sic] as the Bible is to Christians and Jews.” Today most Americans are no better prepared to distinguish between Hinduism and Buddhism. Only a tiny minority can name a single scripture from any Asian religion. In a recent book on religious diversity in the United States, sociologist Robert Wuthnow discovered that American Hindus, Buddhists, and Muslims don’t just want to be tolerated, they “wish to be understood.” If so, that wish is going unfulfilled.41 In an effort to determine just how far we are from this goal of interreligious understanding, I gave a religious literacy quiz to my Boston University students at the start of an introductory course I was teaching in the spring of 2006 called “Death and Immortality.” Before I parse the results, readers might like to take the test for themselves. (The answers appear in the appendix.) Religious Literacy Quiz 1. Name the four Gospels. List as many as you can. 2. Name a sacred text of Hinduism. 3. What is the name of the holy book of Islam? 4. Where according to the Bible was Jesus born? 5. President George W. Bush spoke in his first inaugural address of the Jericho road. What Bible story was he invoking? 6. What are the first five books of the Hebrew Bible or the Christian Old Testament? 7. What is the Golden Rule?
28
RELIGIOUS LITERACY
8. “God helps those who help themselves”: Is this in the Bible? If so, where? 9. “Blessed are the poor in spirit, for theirs is the kingdom of God”: Does this appear in the Bible? If so, where? 10. Name the Ten Commandments. List as many as you can. 11. Name the Four Noble Truths of Buddhism. 12. What are the seven sacraments of Catholicism? List as many as you can. 13. The First Amendment says two things about religion, each in its own “clause.” What are the two religion clauses of the First Amendment? 14. What is Ramadan? In what religion is it celebrated? 15. Match the Bible characters with the stories in which they appear. Draw a line from one to the other. Hint: Some characters may be matched with more than one story or vice versa. Adam and Eve
Exodus
Paul
Binding of Isaac
Moses
Olive Branch
Noah
Garden of Eden
Jesus
Parting of the Red Sea
Abraham
Road to Damascus
Serpent
Garden of Gethsemane
Most of my students flunked this exam. The results, however, were not entirely discouraging. Almost everyone was able to associate “Adam and Eve” with the “Garden of Eden,” and nearly nine out of ten knew that the holy book of Islam was the Quran. But most students could not list the four Gospels, only one out of eight could name the first five books of the Hebrew Bible or Old Testament, and only one in four could name a single Hindu scripture. National surveys have shown that most Americans cannot name five of the Ten Commandments; my students averaged four. They were equally unfamiliar with what may be the most important piece of oratory in Western civilization; only one in six knew
A Nation of Religious Illiterates
29
that “Blessed are the poor in spirit” is a quote from the Sermon on the Mount.42 My class also fared poorly on the exercise that required them to match Bible heroes with Bible stories. In their creative retellings, the most basic elements of the most influential Bible narratives were shuffled and reshuffled like so many cards at a poker table. In their imaginations Paul bound Isaac, Noah led the Exodus of the Israelites out of Babylon, Moses was the recipient of the dove’s olive branch, Abraham was blinded on the road to Damascus, and Jesus was nearly as likely to be born in Jerusalem or Nazareth as in Bethlehem. Ben Franklin once proposed that the United States adopt as its national seal a depiction of Moses leading the Israelites across the Red Sea. Some of my students thought that this was Jesus’ job. On these quizzes Gospels were credited to such scriveners as Isaac, James, Michael, Simon, Peter, and Paul. In fact, 10 percent of my class thought that Paul was one of the four Gospels. Perhaps most disturbingly, the vast majority of my students did not know that the First Amendment both guarantees religious freedom (the free exercise clause) and prohibits the government from endorsing religion (the establishment clause). In fact, only one in six of my students knew both of the First Amendment’s religion clauses. Joan of Arc If things are this bad at Boston University—and in fairness to my students I should note that professors at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill and Wheaton College (Illinois) have reported equally dispiriting results on similar quizzes—how is it elsewhere in the country? Unfortunately, there is not much data on Americans’ religious knowledge. Experts can tell you how many American Baptists there are in the United States and what portion of the population in Maine’s Aroostook County belongs to that denomination’s churches. We know that Catholicism is the largest religious group in thirty-six states, that Southern Baptists dominate in ten, and Mormons in two (Utah and Idaho). We know that women are more likely than men to believe in angels and witches, that liberals are more likely than conservatives to believe in haunted houses, that 20 percent of evangelicals believe in reincarnation, that the vast majority of Americans support the rights of women to act as clergy, and that only a small minority concur with the apostle Paul’s view that wives should submit to their husbands. Unfortunately, researchers have devoted far less attention to what Americans know about their own
30
RELIGIOUS LITERACY
religions or the religions of their neighbors. Some polling data is instructive, however. And both the current situation and the trends are alarming.43 Biblical illiteracy has been fairly well documented. In fact, according to the Gallup Organization, which has tracked trends in US religion for over fifty years, Bible reading has declined since the 1980s and “basic Bible knowledge is at a record low.” Virtually every American home has at least one Bible, publishers sell about twenty million Bibles annually, and Gideons International gives away a new Bible every second of every day. Moreover, nearly two-thirds of Americans believe that the Bible holds the answers to all or most of life’s basic questions, and a majority claims that it reads that book at least twice a month. If so, Americans are not reading particularly carefully.44 The Gospel of John instructs Christians to “search the scriptures” (John 5:39), but little searching, and even less finding, is being done. In 1997 Tonight Show host Jay Leno took to the streets of New York to find out how much average Americans know about the Bible. Interviewees told him that God created Eve from an apple, that Jacob gave his son Joseph a new car, and that Matthew was swallowed by a whale.45 But biblical illiteracy is not limited to Manhattan. Consider these sobering facts gleaned from more scientific surveys: • Only half of American adults can name even one of the four Gospels.46 • Most Americans cannot name the first book of the Bible.47 • Only one-third know that Jesus (no, not Billy Graham) delivered the Sermon on the Mount.48 • A majority of Americans wrongly believe that the Bible says that Jesus was born in Jerusalem.49 • When asked whether the New Testament book of Acts is in the Old Testament, one quarter of Americans say yes. More than a third say that they don’t know.50 • Most Americans don’t know that Jonah is a book in the Bible.51 • Ten percent of Americans believed that Joan of Arc was Noah’s wife.52 In 2005 an enterprising journalist called up the ten cosponsors of an Alabama bill that sought to protect public displays of the Ten Command-
A Nation of Religious Illiterates
31
ments. Just one of those cosponsors could name all ten. But journalists are just as religiously ignorant as politicians. After President George W. Bush referred to the Good Samaritan story in his first inaugural address in 2001, Dick Meyer of CBS News confessed that that portion of the speech left him stumped. “There were a few phrases in the speech I just didn’t get,” he said. “One was, ‘When we see that wounded traveler on the road to Jericho, we will not pass to the other side.’” Meyer later added, “I hope there’s not a quiz.”53 Mount Cyanide One might hope that we are at a nadir here—that the only way out is up. But as pollster George Barna has observed, “The younger a person is, the less they understand about the Christian faith.” A recent Gallup poll found that “Bible illiteracy is common” among US high school students. (Fully 8 percent of the teen respondents thought that Moses was one of the twelve apostles.) And teachers are five times more likely to say that Bible knowledge is decreasing than to say that it is increasing.54 One of this Gallup poll’s most intriguing findings is that born-again Christians are only marginally better informed about the Bible than other students. Only 44 percent of born-again respondents correctly identified “Blessed are the poor in spirit, for theirs is the kingdom of heaven” as a quote from the Sermon on the Mount, versus 37 percent of the broader group. And while born-again students did better than the general population in identifying Cain as the person who said, “Am I my brother’s keeper?” and in knowing that the apostle Paul was blinded by a vision on the road to Damascus, private school students did better than evangelicals on both questions.55 In an early study of Americans’ biblical knowledge, dating to 1968, conservative Protestants did better than liberal Protestants and far better than Catholics. For example, when asked whether “Blessed are the strong: for they shall be the sword of God” appears in the Bible (it does not), only 20 percent of the Southern Baptists (a theologically conservative group) were fooled compared with 28 percent of the Congregationalists (a liberal Protestant group) and 41 percent of the Catholics. On some recent surveys, however, evangelicals actually display less biblical knowledge than other religious adherents. For example, when asked whether the Bible locates Jesus’ birth in Jerusalem (it does not), only 51 percent of the Jews surveyed were fooled, while 60 percent of evangelical Protestants got the answer wrong.56
32
RELIGIOUS LITERACY
America’s youth—evangelical or otherwise—are not learning the Bible at home or in religious congregations. But they are not learning about it in school either. In a 1997 study on “The Place of Bible Literature in Public High School English Classes,” only 9 percent of the high school English teachers surveyed said that they taught either a course or a unit on the Bible. And in 2005 only 8 percent of public school teens reported that their school offered an elective Bible course.57 Perhaps the most damning data to come out of studies on teenagers and the Bible is that there is hardly any difference in Bible knowledge between younger teens (seventh to ninth graders) and older teens (tenth to twelfth graders). This means that students are learning almost nothing about the Bible during high school—that schools (at least public schools) are failing to function as “chains of memory.” There is a humorous list of biblical bloopers, supposedly drawn from actual student papers and exams, that used to circulate fairly widely among teachers. For example (from the Hebrew Bible or Old Testament): • “Moses led the Jews to the Red Sea where they made unleavened bread which is bread without any ingredients.” • “The Egyptians were all drowned in the dessert. Afterwards, Moses went up to Mount Cyanide to get the Ten Commandments.” • “Moses died before he ever reached Canada. Then Joshua led the Hebrews in the Battle of Geritol.” And, from the New Testament: • “Jesus enunciated the Golden Rule, which says to do one to others before they do one to you. He also explained, ‘A man doth not live by sweat alone.’” • “The epistles were the wives of the apostles.” • “St. Paul cavorted to Christianity. He preached holy acrimony, which is another name for marriage.” These bloopers don’t pop up as often as they used to. That may be because to get the humor you have to know something about Judaism, Christianity, and the Bible—that God gave Moses the Ten Commandments on Mount Sinai, that Joshua led the Battle of Jericho, and that Jesus said, “Man shall not live by bread alone” (Matthew 4:4; Luke 4:4).
A Nation of Religious Illiterates
33
Religiously Befuddled Broader Christian literacy is also hard to find. Many a proponent of interreligious dialogue assumes that Christians know their own religious traditions. In fact, interreligious dialogue assumes basic knowledge on both sides of the religious divide that the discussion is designed to bridge. But this assumption is hollow, at least in the United States. Many American Christians here do not know that Easter commemorates the resurrection of Jesus or that the Trinity comprises the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit. Many Baptists cannot tell you how their denomination understands its signature rite of adult baptism. Many Methodists will simply shrug if you ask them about their denomination’s distinctive doctrine of sanctification. And many Lutherans have no idea who Martin Luther is. A professor at a prestigious seminary in the South reports that she spends considerable time in her church history courses on what might be called “Denominations for Dummies,” basic information that in the past would have been covered in the elementary grades of Sunday schools (or public schools) but is lost on her ministers-in-training today. Over the last few presidential election cycles, evangelicals have emerged as key players in American politics. In 2005 “The 25 Most Influential Evangelicals in America” merited the cover of Time. Still, many Americans confuse evangelicals with fundamentalists, and twothirds of Americans report that they have no clue what evangelicalism means. Church members routinely report that they are happy with the religious education their congregations offer, but there is little evidence that offerings such as the Catholics’ ubiquitous CCD (Confraternity of Christian Doctrine) courses or Lutheran and Episcopalian confirmation classes are accomplishing much, except perhaps as social events.58 Broader religious literacy—understanding of non-Christian religions— is far more difficult to gauge, largely because polling organizations rarely ask about it. In one of the earliest efforts to quantify this sort of religious knowledge, a 1954 Gallup poll asked Americans to name the founder of any religion other than Christianity. Only about a third were able to do so. In a more recent study the overwhelming majority of Americans freely admit that they are not at all familiar with the basic teachings of Islam, Buddhism, or Hinduism. One reason for this may be that most Americans do not know a Muslim, Buddhist, or Hindu. A surprisingly high portion of the Boston University students who took my religious literacy quiz (nearly nine out of ten) knew that the Quran was the Muslims’ holy book, but fewer than a quarter were able to name a single Hindu scripture, and
34
RELIGIOUS LITERACY
only one student was able to list Buddhism’s Four Noble Truths. No wonder sociologist Christian Smith has concluded that young Americans are “remarkably inarticulate and befuddled about religion.”59 Is the Pope Catholic? Religious groups in the United States have long lamented declines of religious knowledge in their ranks. The US Catholic hierarchy has fretted for decades about a yawning knowledge gap between Catholics who came of age before the Second Vatican Council of the early 1960s and those who did so after its reforms rocked the church. In the Golden Age of Catholic education, students in CCD classes memorized the Baltimore Catechism by heart; virtually all Catholic school students were Catholics, and nearly all the teachers were priests and nuns. Today Catholic school courses are taught almost exclusively by laity, and non-Catholic students are a surging presence. Moreover, efforts to update catechetical training have replaced time-honored instruction about church traditions with touchyfeely conversations about one’s personal values. “The problem is that somehow the doctrines got lost and we were left with only our desires, hopes, fears, and dreams, together with broad-stroke connections to a few marquee items like Jesus, God (the relation between them left fuzzy), the Spirit,” writes John C. Cavadini of Notre Dame’s Department of Theology. “Most other items were left behind in a penumbra of distinguished but cozy irrelevance.” As a result, nearly half of American Catholics say that they “often feel that [they] cannot explain [their] faith to others.”60 A 2001 book called Young Adult Catholics found among US Catholic youth “a low level of knowledge of the Catholic tradition and a limited command of Catholic cultural symbols,” which the authors attributed to (among other things) a shift in emphasis from participating in the sacraments to loving Jesus and a growing tendency to reduce the sum of religion to moral behavior. What others have called cafeteria Catholicism these researchers refer to as “selective Catholicism,” and what these “selective Catholics” are choosing to discard are the narratives, doctrines, and symbols of the church. The most striking finding in Young Adult Catholics, however, is that CCD attendance does not correlate in any way with knowledge about Catholicism. Nearly two-thirds of American Catholic youth attend after-school CCD classes, but they aren’t learning much there. “We got God loves you but not much else,” one interviewee told the authors of Young Adult Catholics. Other participants were equally critical:
A Nation of Religious Illiterates
35
“Nothing in depth, just Jesus is love.” “No content; touchy-feely.” “I was confirmed and had no idea of what was going on.”61 A Catholic friend of mine told me that CCD is “lame and useless.” When I asked Catholic students in my 2006 “Death and Immortality” course what they did in CCD, the first answer I got was: “Color!” A less flip response was that these classes focus almost exclusively on social service projects. Either way, Catholic youth are not being taught much about their tradition. One Catholic theologian, noting that “the religious illiteracy of so many otherwise well-educated young Catholics” may be “too familiar to bear mentioning again,” refers to Catholic ignorance of Catholicism as akin to a “retinal detachment” in which “a whole field of vision” is “pulling inexorably away toward blindness.” The fear is that, as American Catholics are losing sight of what is distinctive about being Catholic, they are becoming indistinguishable from Americans in general. Responding to this troubling situation, Catholic leaders have called for stern measures to address the “crisis in religious literacy” among young Catholics, including attempts to effect the “conversion of Catholics to Catholicism.” Meanwhile, theologians in Notre Dame’s Department of Theology have called for “a renewed pedagogy of the basics,” bishops have made fostering Catholic literacy a high priority, and a Web site called Catholics Read is trying “to encourage Catholics to read the Bible and related books.” Not to be outdone, entrepreneurs have come up with innovative ways to catechize wayward Catholics, such as Trivial Pursuit–style board games called Catechic and Is the Pope Catholic?62 The Greatest Story Never Read Evangelicals also lament a “tragedy of religious illiteracy” in their ranks. Mark Noll, a Notre Dame history professor and an evangelical himself, opened his book The Scandal of the Evangelical Mind (1994) by arguing that “the scandal of the evangelical mind is that there is not much of an evangelical mind.” Os Guinness, an evangelical writer, put it equally starkly: “Most evangelicals simply don’t think.” While evangelicals once followed Jonathan Edwards, John Wesley, and others in affirming both heartfelt experience and hard-won education, evangelicalism today has become, as another born-again Christian wrote, “less a matter of learning than it is a matter of experiencing.” Pop psychology has elbowed biblical exegesis out of many born-again pulpits (including some of the most
36
RELIGIOUS LITERACY
successful megachurches), self-help books outsell theological works in most Christian bookstores, and loving Jesus has replaced affirming the Westminster Confession as the soul of evangelical piety. Despite their conviction that the Bible is the Word of God, evangelicals show scant interest in learning what scripture has to say or wrestling with what it might mean. “I have watched with growing disbelief as the evangelical church has cheerfully plunged into astounding theological illiteracy,” writes evangelical theologian David E. Wells. Even in the Bible Belt, the Good Book is fast becoming, as another evangelical puts it, “The Greatest Story Never Read.”63 In an effort to get evangelical youth to read that unread story, Christian publisher Thomas Nelson initiated in 2003 a series of “Biblezines,” which reprint the entire New Testament in a format guaranteed to attract American teens. The glossy magazine Revolve (for teen girls) looks like a Christian Seventeen, complete with beauty secrets, a feature called “Are You Dating a Godly Guy?” and fashion tips (“Just make sure you look like a child of God”). Refuel (for guys) has the frenetic feel of ESPN: The Magazine and offers tips on such “practical” matters as wrestling an alligator and handling a jalapeño. (“Man, it’s like dealing with the burning problem of sin. You need to grab the right solution. Get Jesus.”) Real— for hip-hoppers—offers “Dope Christian Rhymes” and a series of articles by ex-cons called “Jail Ain’t No Joke.” The concept here is simple: young people don’t read the Bible because it’s too imposing, too hard to understand, too square; but if you put it in a friendly format they’ll eat it up. This concept has been a huge commercial success. Thomas Nelson claims that Revolve “became America’s #1 selling Bible in less than 3 months after it was originally released” in July 2003. It is doubtful, however, that these godly glossies are doing much to wipe out biblical ignorance among American youth. When I assigned Refuel one week to students in a seminar on the Bible in American culture, many admitted that they skipped entirely over the New Testament text, reading instead the “extreme” sidebars, which gyrated around the edges of each page, demanding attention like a hyperactive child. One student was convinced that Refuel was an Onion-style parody. In either case the biblical message was literally lost in translation.64 Jews also fret about a lack of basic understanding of Judaism among Jewish youth. “At a time when Jewish life in the United States is flourishing, Jewish ignorance is too,” writes one rabbi. “Tens, if not hundreds of thousands of teenage and adult Jews are seeking Jewish involvements— even Jewish leadership positions—all the while hoping no one will find
A Nation of Religious Illiterates
37
out their unhappy little secret: They are Jewishly illiterate.” Convinced that ignorance of Judaism and the problem of out-marriage are inextricably intertwined, groups such as the Jewish Literacy Foundation have dedicated themselves to addressing the problem of “uneducated” and “unaffiliated” Jews.65 Even atheists and agnostics have a religious illiteracy rant. The Weststar Institute, the think tank behind the notorious Jesus Seminar (which took it upon itself in the 1980s and 1990s to decide what Jesus really said and did), describes itself as “an educational institute dedicated to the advancement of religious literacy.” Its Web site contends that “religious literacy is essential” to (among other things) “liberation from religious bullies” and “inoculation against fanaticism.” Other freethinkers promote teaching about religion on the theory that the more you know about religion, the less likely you are to be suckered by one of its elaborate cons.66 An Eye for an Eye What these diverse constituencies share is a rhetoric of lament, and tucked inside that rhetoric is a certainty that not so long ago in a place not so far away things used to be much, much better. In the 1790s, or the 1890s for that matter, how might eleven average Americans have responded to a fellow juror who cited the Old Testament book of Leviticus in a 1995 murder trial in Colorado? During jury deliberations a juror pulled out a Bible and referred to the “eye for an eye, a tooth for tooth” passage in Leviticus 24:20–21, which concludes: “He that killeth a man, he shall be put to death.” The juror in question then reportedly urged his colleagues to go home to their own Bibles and prayerfully ponder this passage for themselves. The next day the jury returned a unanimous decision for the death penalty. In 2005, after a long appeals process, the Colorado Supreme Court, in a 3–2 decision, ruled that the jurors were not permitted to consult the Bible (which it referred to as “extraneous prejudicial material”) and ordered a new trial. In the ensuing hue and cry, conservative Christians, drawing on time-honored culture wars rhetoric, denounced the decision. “Today’s ruling further confirms that the judicial branch of our government is nearly bereft of any moral foundation,” said a spokesperson for Focus on the Family, a Colorado-based evangelical group. “It is a sad day when the Bible is banned from a jury room.” Colorado Governor Bill Owens also decried the decision as “demeaning to people of faith.” Few noticed, however, just how impoverished were the exegetical skills of the jury.67
38
RELIGIOUS LITERACY
There are very few passages from the Hebrew Bible that are explicitly rejected in the New Testament, but Leviticus 24:20–21 (which is echoed in Exodus 21:23–25 and Deuteronomy 19:21) is one of them, since in Matthew 5:38–39 Jesus says, “Ye have heard that it hath been said, An eye for an eye, and a tooth for a tooth: But I say unto you, That ye resist not evil: but whosoever shall smite thee on thy right cheek, turn to him the other also.” The purpose of citing this passage is neither to provide divine sanction for nonviolence nor to forestall a reading of the Bible in favor of capital punishment, but simply to offer yet another case study in the dangers of religious illiteracy. Were any jurors aware of Jesus’ refutation of “an eye for an eye”—his invocation of a new morality of “turn the other cheek”? Might this defendant have been spared a decade on death row if they had been? At least for me, the moral of this story is neither (as the Colorado Supreme Court ruled) that Americans should not bring Bibles into the jury box nor (as Focus on the Family argued) that they should. The moral is rather that if jurors are going to consult scripture— and, court rulings aside, they doubtless are—then those jurors should at least have the decency (and the piety) to try to get the Bible right.
Two
Religion Matters
I
n 1966 Time magazine asked, on a stark, black cover reminiscent of a Victorian funeral card, “Is God Dead?” Today, when books on spirituality crowd the best-seller lists, God is a recurring character on television, and Jesus is big at the box office, this question seems, well, a little European. “Is Secularism Dead?” seems the pertinent question. Whereas redstate believers once felt marooned in a sea of secularists, now unbelievers in the blue states feel adrift in a sea of patriotic piety. The challenge is not to decide whether it is time to pay our last respects to the Almighty but to figure out how anyone ever could have imagined that God was anything other than alive and well and living in America. Was there really a time when people actually believed that the world was outgrowing religion? As the 1966 Time cover indicates, the answer to that question is yes. Social theorists of such stature as Auguste Comte in the nineteenth century and Max Weber in the twentieth were convinced that wherever modernity advanced, religion would fade. Their acolytes multiplied in the early 1960s, as the religious revival that followed the Second World War was fading into the countercultural camp meeting of the late 1960s and early 1970s. At the height of this flirtation with secularity, theologians weren’t just predicting the eclipse of God, they were bragging about doing God in. To be clear, these “Death of God” theologians were not saying that God was literally deceased; many of them didn’t believe that God had ever been literally alive in the first place. What they were saying was that God was as good as dead—that divinity had ceased to matter in the modern world. The academic culture that produced “secularization theory,” as the social-scientific species of this prognosticating is called, is a curiously parochial enclave, by no sights as cosmopolitan as its natives imagine,
40
RELIGIOUS LITERACY
and by no means representative of modern societies. Among academia’s curiosities is the persistent skepticism of its inhabitants, their tendency to dismiss faith as fanaticism. Theorists who postulated the death of religion under modernity’s crush (or, at a minimum, its retreat into the closet of the private) often based their predictions on nothing more substantial than the vague air of skepticism they detected at the dean’s sherry hour; if academia was marching away from God—or so the logic went—the rest of the modern world would surely follow. So it seemed safe for social scientists to ignore religion as a force in the modern world. Religion, after all, had no force over them. When it came to truly important matters such as politics, economy, and society, religion must be as vestigial as the appendix; whether you had one or not didn’t matter a whit (though having one might make you deathly ill). Or so went the conventional wisdom. Pop Goes Jesus That such wisdom now begs for an adjective as dismissive as conventional owes much to the vitality of religion in American popular culture, which is indebted in turn to the collective decision of evangelicals—made around the time the novel was still a scandal and no self-respecting church would cotton to an organ—to join modernity rather than fight it. Since that time religion and modernity have become fast friends, with evangelicals borrowing (and sanctifying) virtually every accoutrement of modern life: theater, radio, rock music, marketing, advertising, television, and the Internet, to say nothing of individualism and consumer capitalism. We now know that prophecies of God’s death, however passionately or poetically argued, were but fingers in the wind, measuring little more than the climate of faith in, say, Sigmund Freud’s Vienna, Jean-Paul Sartre’s Paris, or the environs of Harvard Square. Secularization theory has run aground, as grand theories often do, on the shoals of historical facts. Today the hard-core atheist, once a stock figure in American life, has gone the way of the freak show. The best-seller lists, long obsessed with sex, lies, and other virtues, are now salted with titles ripped from the hymnals. Sales of The Purpose-Driven Life (2002) by the megachurch pastor Rick Warren and Tim LaHaye’s and Jerry B. Jenkins’s apocalyptic Left Behind novels are sufficient (20 and 60 million, respectively) to turn even John Grisham green. On the other side of the spirituality spectrum Dan Brown’s The Da Vinci Code (2003) and Ron Howard’s 2006 movie of the
Religion Matters
41
same name combine a caustic critique of Catholicism with a provocative retelling of the life of Jesus. Spirituality and religion, angels and vampires, the Son of God and the supernatural suffuse all sorts of television shows. And on the radio, supposedly secular artists now invoke the Jword with impunity—all the way to the bank. “If I talk about God my record won’t get played, Huh?” Kanye West raps in “Jesus Walks.” Not exactly. The song won a Grammy. It was politics rather than pop culture, however, that drove a stake into the heart of the assumption that modernity was sucking the vitality out of religion. The story of the recent rediscovery of the force of faith— that is to say, the story of the shipwreck of secularization theory—begins with the US Supreme Court, which outlawed prayer and devotional Bible reading in the public schools in 1962 and 1963 and upheld abortion in 1973 in Roe v. Wade. Democrats defended these rulings (and the freedoms of the counterculture) in the name of Thomas Jefferson, individual rights, public reason, and the First Amendment. Republicans decried the same rulings (and the licentiousness of the counterculture) in the name of God, family values, revelation, and the Judeo-Christian tradition. In this way religion became a player once again in American political life. The first beneficiary of this rechristening of US politics was of course the peanut farmer and Sunday school teacher from Plains, Georgia, Jimmy Carter. Before Carter it was possible to see the United States as a secular nation with a citizenry that, while individually religious, had nevertheless agreed to quarantine religion from the public square. The White House had been dominated until Carter’s 1977 inauguration by a New England ethos that viewed public professions of religion as bad manners or bad faith (or both). Senator John Kennedy, while campaigning for the presidency in 1960, felt obliged to pledge to make policy on subjects such as birth control, gambling, and education without any regard to his Catholicism. Carter, however, in keeping with the emergent southern style in US politics, spoke repeatedly and unabashedly about his piety (not least in Playboy, where he famously confessed to lusting in his heart). Governor Ronald Reagan was swept to victory on the wings of the Moral Majority, which from its founding in 1979 had urged the nation to repent of its godlessness and amorality and return to its ostensibly Judeo-Christian roots. President Reagan’s speeches repeatedly invoked themes from the biblical commonwealth of New England’s Puritans, notably Governor John Winthrop’s metaphor of the Massachusetts Bay Colony as a “city upon a hill” (an image that Winthrop himself borrowed from Matthew 5:14: “Ye are the light of the world. A city that is set on a hill cannot be hid”).
42
RELIGIOUS LITERACY
By the mid-1980s the line between religion and politics had become exceedingly fuzzy, and the Supreme Court was flummoxed about where to draw it. As the ranks of born-again Christians swelled to over onethird of the population and preachers strutted their stuff (and their favorite political candidates) on Christian radio and television stations, religion became more conservative, more public, and more political. (It was during this decade that George W. Bush repented of his alcohol use—and his father’s liberal Episcopalianism—and accepted Jesus as his Savior and Lord.) In the early 1990s a double-digit “God gap” opened up among frequent worshippers between the Democrats (now understood as the secular party) and the Republicans (the “faith-based” alternative). During the 1960s and 1970s there had been no discernible party preference among religious practitioners; religious affiliation was politically irrelevant. In 1992, however, frequent worshippers (those who attend religious congregations at least once a week) preferred Bush the Elder over Bill Clinton by 14 percentage points. That gap widened to 20 percent in the 2000 Bush-Gore and the 2004 Bush-Kerry elections, dwarfing the proverbial gender gap. Gore and Kerry, of course, did better among those who never darken the door of a religious congregation, but such voters constitute a much smaller portion of the electorate than frequent attendees do. After the Republicans triumphed in the 2004 election, there was considerable debate about whether “values voters” really turned the election. That remains questionable. Not in doubt is the fact that regular attendance at religious services is now one of the best predictors of political affiliation and voting behavior.68 Jesus-Loving Politicians The sociologist Peter Berger once remarked that, if India is the world’s most religious country and Sweden the least, then the United States is a nation of Indians ruled by Swedes. Not exactly. Like citizens of India, US citizens are extraordinarily religious. But so are their leaders. Since Jimmy Carter, born-again bona fides seems to have become a requirement for the Oval Office, and Jesus-loving politicians are as thick on the ground in Washington DC as Bush haters in Paris. Berger’s observation, in short, is now as wet as it once was dry: the United States is plainly a nation of believers ruled by the same. All this is to say that the old wishful thinking about religion’s death at the hands of modernity is starting to look delusional, at least in the
Religion Matters
43
American instance. Some still label the United States “post-Christian,” but smart sociologists and historians have admitted the errors of their ways. Berger, one of the star secularization theorists of the 1960s, confessed in a book called The Desecularization of the World (1999) that secularization theory is bunk, at least as a general proposition. “The world today, with some exceptions . . . is as furiously religious as it ever was, and in some places more so than ever,” Berger wrote. “This means that a whole body of literature by historians and social scientists loosely labeled ‘secularization theory’ is essentially mistaken.”69 International events also had a hand in overturning the secularization myth. The Iranian Revolution of 1979, which saw Mohammad Reza Shah Pahlavi and his US-backed secularists displaced by Muslim clerics, demonstrated that the old “realist” strategy of conducting foreign policy as if religion didn’t matter was not so realistic after all. The rise to power of the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) in India in the late 1990s showed that right-wing political activism was not unknown even to the Hindu faith. And 9/11 brought home as never before the public power of religious ideologies. After the horrors of that day we knew not only that piety could elect presidents and overturn governments but also that it could hijack jets, attack the Pentagon, and take down two of the world’s largest buildings. Since 9/11 events in Afghanistan, Iraq, and Iran have brought home to Americans, perhaps as never before, the relevance of religion to world affairs. Observers disagree about whether we have entered into a “clash of civilizations” pitting the Judeo-Christian West against the Muslim world. But there is little doubt that groups such as the Wahhabis—virtually unknown to the average American politician just a decade ago—will play a role in shaping the next world order.70 One response to these events might be to imagine that religion emerged as a historical force with the rise to power of the Iranian cleric Ayatollah Khomeini in the late 1970s or of the televangelist turned politician Pat Robertson in the early 1980s. That response would be misguided since religion has always mattered, not least in American public life. Today what needs explaining is not the persistence of religion in modern societies but the emergence of unbelief in Europe and among American leaders in media, law, and higher education. If there is any general rule to follow regarding the place of religion in modern life, that rule is that God is alive and well and shaking things up in places as distinct as California and Utah, Zimbabwe and Brazil, India and Pakistan, Israel and Tibet.
44
RELIGIOUS LITERACY
Textbook Ignorance (American Style) High school textbooks blatantly disregard this rule, following instead Emily Post’s dictum not to discuss religion in polite company. So US high school students learn virtually nothing about the powerful historical and contemporary effects of religious beliefs, religious practices, religious people, and religious institutions. When religion is mentioned in US history schoolbooks, it is all too often an afterthought or an embarrassment (or both) and clearly a diversion from what is presumed throughout to be a secular story. Historian Jon Butler has called this the jack-in-the-box approach: Religious characters pop up here and there, typically with all of the color and substance of a circus clown, but their appearances—prosecuting witches in Salem in the 1690s or making monkeys of themselves at the Scopes Trial in Dayton, Tennessee, in the 1920s—are always a surprise (or a scare), and, happily, they go back into hiding as quickly as they emerge. Readers of American history textbooks might learn something about the religious bigotry of the Puritans and the quaint customs of Native Americans of bygone days. And when the Civil War rolls around there may be a brief discussion of the Quakers’ abolitionist sentiments. But after President Abraham Lincoln is buried, religion typically goes underground too, leaving students with the distinct impression that, insofar as religion has had any historical effects, those effects are now safely behind us. In fact, according to one study of US history textbooks, there is typically more discussion of railroads than of religion in the postbellum period.71 Secularists love to chuckle at evangelicals for their quaint take on American history—for forcibly converting the Founding Fathers to Christianity and for reading the godless Constitution as part of God’s divine plan for “Christian America.” But secularists have their foibles too, including their own odd take on American history—an interpretation enshrined, unfortunately, in all too many history textbooks. According to this view—call it the secular myth of America—American civilization is on the march from religion to reason, superstition to science. True, religion intrudes occasionally to retard this advance, but zealots always retreat dutifully into the backwaters from whence they came. A thirst for freedom sends the Pilgrims to the New World, but when they get here all they want to do is catch cod, and when Thanksgiving rolls around they give thanks not to God but to the Indians, or to the land itself. The revivals of the early nineteenth century send Americans scurrying to the pews (and away from bars and brothels), but their real purpose is to dupe fac-
Religion Matters
45
tory workers into thinking that “God” loves a happy laborer. According to one major study of thirty-one history textbooks up for adoption in Texas, “The treatment of religion as a force in US history continues to receive short shrift.”72 A Very Short History of Religion in US History The tendency of textbook authors and publishers to reduce religion, as one critic has put it, to “either a quaint relic or a chronic source of strife” cannot erase the fact that what sociologist Gerhard Lenski called “the religious factor” has been a major factor in US history—and not always on the Dark Side.73 In fact, none of the classic events in American history—the Revolution, the Civil War, the New Deal, the Reagan Revolution—can be understood without some knowledge of the religious motivations of the generals, soldiers, thinkers, politicians, and voters who made them happen. As the following very short history indicates, religion has always mattered in American society. Religion mattered in North America’s English colonies. As Alexis de Tocqueville observed in Democracy in America (1835), “It must never be forgotten that religion gave birth to Anglo-American society.”74 The Puritans came here at least in part to worship God as they saw fit. In virtually everything they thought and did (fishing and farming included), they understood themselves to be in a covenantal relationship with God. According to the terms of this conditional covenant, God would bless them if they acted well and curse them if they did otherwise. In this way every aspect of life among the Puritans, including their economics and their politics, was brought under the sacred canopy of their faith. In The Protestant Ethic and the Rise of Capitalism (1904–1905), Max Weber argued that religious ideas give rise to economic realities (not, as Karl Marx had argued, the other way around). More specifically, Weber contended that the “Protestant ethic” of the Puritans birthed capitalism—by providing a divine mandate for hard work, savings, and other essentials of a capitalist economy. That may or may not be the case. It is indisputable, however, that Puritanism in colonial New England profoundly influenced the course of American literature, art, economics, society, and politics.75 Puritanism also affected the founding of Rhode Island, which Roger Williams established as a haven for Baptists and other religious dissenters from Puritan orthodoxy. Anglicanism mattered in the founding of Virginia, and Roman Catholicism in the founding of Maryland. And Quaker
46
RELIGIOUS LITERACY
William Penn established Pennsylvania as a “holy experiment” in religious liberty. Religion mattered in the encounters of British, French, and Spanish colonists with the Indians, and of these colonists with one another. These encounters have often been understood chiefly in military, economic, technological, and even biological terms (since so many Indians died of European diseases), but they were also religious exchanges. Colonists converted Indians to Protestantism and Catholicism, and some colonists taken captive by Indians took up Indian religious practices. Spanish missions included both forts and churches. The French traded furs with the Mohawks, but they also preached to them the Catholic Christ. Later in US history, Native Americans responded to efforts to “civilize” and “Christianize” them with new religious movements such as the Ghost Dance, which played a major role in the Wounded Knee Massacre of 1890. Religion mattered in the American Revolution too, which proceeded very differently from France’s more secular revolt. The Great Awakening of the 1730s and 1740s, a grand revival that stretched up and down the eastern seaboard, helped to knit the colonists into one people and in so doing paved the way for a rebellion against the British Crown that many understood theologically—as a quest to make good in the political realm on the liberty they had already found in the spiritual. The revolution may not have been, as historian J. C. D. Clark has argued, “the last great war of religion in the western world,” but it was motivated in part by religious dissenters who saw Anglicanism and monarchy as parts of a single tyrannical force and termed their rebellion “the cause of heaven against hell.” As this rhetoric intimates, Americans in the making were careful to direct their revolt against the British monarchy rather than Christianity. Those who drafted the Constitution and the Bill of Rights were influenced far more by Deism than by anticlericalism. The early republic experienced, as historian Henry May has observed, a moderate, pro-Christian Enlightenment as opposed to the more radical, anti-Christian Enlightenment of the French.76 This moderate Enlightenment transformed American religion, chiefly by making Protestantism more egalitarian. Having cast off George III, Americans became chary of the tyranny of Calvin’s capricious God. In the spiritual marketplace brought on by the First Amendment, “populist preachers” and the “sovereign audience” reigned. Ordinary people took control of their churches just as they had taken control of their government. In the process the God-fearing faith of Calvinism yielded to the
Religion Matters
47
Jesus-loving faith of evangelicalism, and American religion became less intellectual and more enthusiastic. Americans, the Baptist firebrand Elias Smith proclaimed in 1809, must be “wholly free to examine for ourselves what is truth, without being bound to a catechism, creed, confession of faith, discipline or any rule excepting the scriptures.”77 Religion mattered as well during the early nineteenth century, when a series of social reforms swept the country. The movements to abolish slavery, reform the prison system, prohibit alcohol consumption, care for the insane, bring education to the masses, and win for women the right to vote were all led by evangelical Protestants and justified on biblical grounds. (Abolitionist William Lloyd Garrison put Jesus on the masthead of his newspaper, The Liberator.) Moreover, these social reformers drew the resources required to fight these fights from a deeply theological well of postmillennial optimism. They pushed to free slaves and to shut down saloons because they believed that such reforms would usher in the kingdom of God, which in turn would bring on Christ’s Second Coming. And if these efforts also preserved the Protestant character of the nation in the face of the Catholic hordes washing ashore from Europe, well, so much the better. Religion mattered in the Civil War also. This defining moment in American history was of course a battle over slavery and state’s rights. But it was also a holy war in which, as President Abraham Lincoln famously observed, both sides “read the same Bible and pray to the same God.” The Presbyterian Church of the Confederate States of America argued that slavery was “a gracious Providence” sanctioned in the Bible, while Frederick Douglass, disgusted over Christendom’s complicity in the sin of slavery, divided Christianity into two irreconcilable factions: “the corrupt, slaveholding, woman-whipping, cradle-plundering, partial and hypocritical Christianity of this land” and “the pure, peaceable, and impartial Christianity of Christ.” When the war ended, both sides saw it as an Armageddon of sorts. Southerners fastened onto the Myth of the Lost Cause, which embraced Confederate soldiers as martyrs and the South as something of a resurrected Christ, while Northerners anointed Lincoln, who was assassinated on Good Friday, as a Christ of their own who shed his blood to atone for the sins of the nation.78 After the Civil War Americans debated the pros and cons of capitalism with much of the theological passion they had devoted to the slavery question. Steel magnate and philanthropist Andrew Carnegie promulgated a “gospel of wealth,” which understood getting rich as a religious obligation. This theology was later popularized by the Baptist minister
48
RELIGIOUS LITERACY
and Temple University president Russell Conwell, who contended in “Acres of Diamonds,” a sermon he reportedly preached six thousand times to 13 million people, that “to make money honestly is to preach the gospel.” Progressive proponents of the Social Gospel, by contrast, saw capitalism as a sin. The novel In His Steps (1897) by the Congregationalist minister Charles M. Sheldon is remembered today for bequeathing to us the query “What would Jesus do?” but its original purpose was to drive home the point that if Jesus were out and about in Victorian America he would be caring for slum dwellers, not selling steel.79 Religion mattered as the United States expanded its empire overseas in the late nineteenth century. Earlier, the doctrine of Manifest Destiny had propelled Americans west into the frontier on the theory that it was God’s will for them to civilize and Protestantize the continent. After bumping up against the Pacific, Americans looked farther afield, forcibly opening Japan to trade in 1853, and annexing Hawaii and waging war in Cuba and the Philippines in 1898. This expansion, which would soon extend to Haiti, Nicaragua, and many other Latin American countries, was motivated and justified by commercial and military interests, to be sure, but also by a desire to missionize the “heathen.” Religion mattered during World War II, when the federal government packed virtually every Japanese American Buddhist in the country off to an internment camp, in part because government officials confused Buddhism with Shinto (in which the Japanese emperor was worshipped as a god). As in the Civil War, Americans again gave theological reasons both for supporting and opposing this war. Partisans of “muscular Christianity,” recalling that Jesus “came not to send peace, but a sword” (Matthew 10:34), contended that their “manly Redeemer” would want them to fight for what is right. Christian pacifists, who worshipped a “sweet Savior,” countered with the story of Jesus rebuking followers after they drew blood from his captors in the Garden of Gethsemane (Matthew 26:51–52).80 During the Cold War, of course, religious considerations were paramount. In this era “reds” were atheists, Americans were monotheists, and the Cold War was spiritual warfare that, in an era of nuclear weapons, carried portents of the Apocalypse. Religion mattered too in the civil rights movement, which as one historian has written was “led by ministers, fortified by Scripture, exhorted in massive church meetings, and buoyed by gospel music.”81 And it mattered as a thousand freedoms bloomed during the Beat movement of the 1950s and the counterculture of the 1960s and 1970s, which were fueled not only by jazz, rock ’n’ roll, and marijuana but
Religion Matters
49
also by Zen, Transcendental Meditation, and Jesus piety. Religion mattered as well in each of America’s great waves of immigration since, in addition to hopes and dreams, pilgrims from Ireland and Germany, Japan and India brought to America their religious traditions. Catholicism arrived in force with the Irish in the 1830s and Judaism with Eastern Europeans in the 1880s. After the passage of new immigration legislation in 1965 Buddhists, Hindus, Sikhs, and Muslims came in numbers too. Each of these immigration waves set off nativist opposition, on the one hand, and renewed calls for tolerance and pluralism, on the other. It was largely through the force of immigration that Americans came to debate whether the United States is a secular or a Christian country and (more recently) whether it is Judeo-Christian, Judeo-Christian-Islamic, or multireligious. Finally, religion mattered in the culture wars of the 1980s and beyond, which were set off by Supreme Court decisions banning school prayer and upholding abortion, and by a little-known 1978 IRS ruling that eliminated the tax-exempt status of segregated Christian schools. These events in turn catapulted evangelicals back into US politics, something they had remained aloof from since their embarrassment at the Scopes “Monkey Trial” in 1925. Presidential Piety President George W. Bush has been criticized for seeking to transform the United States into a theocracy. But the public display of religion is nothing new in the White House. In fact, it is older than the White House building itself. When George Washington became the country’s first president in 1789, he placed his hand upon a Bible and punctuated his official oath of office with “So help me God.” In his inaugural address, he asked “the benign Parent of the Human Race” for “His divine blessing.” Since that time, no president has failed to invoke “the Infinite Power,” as Jefferson once called God. In fact, presidents have long used their bully pulpit to hold forth on such matters as military chaplains, school prayer, state aid to religious schools, faith-based social services, and creationism. James Garfield, “the Preacher President,” was a Disciples of Christ revivalist who occasionally mounted a real pulpit during his years as commander-in-chief. James Polk forbade liquor and dancing in the White House and refused to conduct official business on the Sabbath. Benjamin Harrison, who like John Adams considered going into the ministry, may have been the most active churchman, serving as a deacon and an elder in his Presbyterian church, teaching Sunday school, organizing
50
RELIGIOUS LITERACY
Bible studies, and participating actively in the YMCA.82 When it comes to American history, religion is, as historian Edwin Gaustad once argued, “a datum and point of reference as omnipresent and inescapable as the rivers and the mountains, the laws and the courts, the trade routes and the labor unions, the political parties and the national presidents.” That datum is inescapable today in the Supreme Court, which every year or so must decide how to define religion, if only to keep the government out of its hair (and vice versa). Religion is omnipresent in congressional elections, where some Democrats are making an effort to learn the vocabulary of faith and speak it with a native twang. It matters in public debates over environmentalism (which most evangelicals wholeheartedly support) and stem-cell research (which they generally oppose), and whenever and wherever born-again Christians try to apply the “What would Jesus do?” test to public policy—to tax rates in Alabama, the ethics of gas-guzzling SUVs, and the war in Iraq. It matters too in presidential elections since, like it or not, there is a religion test for the presidency. When New York governor Al Smith ran on the Democratic ticket in 1928 he lost in part because he was Catholic. Today you might not have to be a Protestant or even a Christian to earn the Oval Office—92 percent of Americans say they would vote for a Jew—but you do have to be a person of faith. Only 49 percent of Americans say they would even consider making an atheist commander-in-chief.83 Textbook Ignorance (Global Style) The influence of religion is by no means confined to American history. World events have been shaped by Confucian ritual, Jewish law, Christian love, and Buddhist compassion. Chinese history was influenced by Confucian conceptions of family and society, which influenced in turn both Japanese and Korean life. Jain concepts of nonviolence inspired Gandhi’s campaign for Indian independence and the US civil rights movement. The Bible inspired (and the Roman Catholic Church funded) Michelangelo’s work on the Sistine Chapel. Slogans such as sola scriptura (“Bible alone”) and “the priesthood of all believers” led Protestant reformers to redraw the map of Europe. Jerusalem has long been a flash point because Jews, Christians, and Muslims alike see it as holy ground. Catholic condemnations of scientists, most famously in the case of Galileo’s heliocentric theory of the solar system, retarded the scientific revolution, yet virtually every early scientific pioneer was a believer who was convinced that he was uncovering the secrets of the Creator’s Book of Nature. Most of the
Religion Matters
51
great conflicts in world history—between Protestants and Catholics in early modern Europe, between Communists and Buddhists in contemporary Tibet, and among Christians, Jews, and Muslims in fifteenthcentury Spain—have been largely or partly religious. And some contemporary nation-states, including Israel and Pakistan, emerged out of such conflicts. Atheists and agnostics, pointing to such horrors as the Holocaust, routinely claim that religion has been the most powerful force for evil in world history. That is probably true. But religion has likely been the world’s most powerful force for good too. While it is plausible to claim that religion no longer counts for much in Sweden, Holland, and France, religious beliefs and practices continue to have undeniable impacts on social, economic, and political life in virtually every other country in the world. Religion matters today in hot spots such as the Balkans, northern Ireland, Kashmir, Sri Lanka, and the Middle East. But it also affects Indian tourism (since some high-caste Hindus consider traveling outside of India polluting), AIDS in Africa (where the Roman Catholic Church forbids artificial birth control), and banking throughout the Muslim world (since Islamic law prohibits the giving and receiving of interest). You wouldn’t know any of this by reading high school world history textbooks, however. Hinduism, Buddhism, Judaism, Christianity, and Islam all fare a bit better in these sources than they do in US history schoolbooks. Most world history textbooks offer quick-and-easy accounts of the origins of these religions and, in some cases, of the key beliefs and practices of contemporary adherents. But despite strongly worded calls for teaching about religion in state and national standards for world history, these accounts rarely extend beyond a few pages, and here too religion disappears with the rush of modernity—in this case around 1750. Once again students are led to believe that religion somehow belongs to the past; the present (and, presumably, the future) belongs to secularity. As philosopher Warren Nord has observed, in the case of Islam, the typical textbook teaches students a bit about Islam’s origins in the seventh century only to see the tradition disappear for more than a millennium before popping up, quite unexpectedly, in the form of the Iranian hostage crisis of the 1970s. “Religion remains,” Gaustad writes, “a classroom pariah.”84 While one US history text describes Christmas as nothing more than “a warm time for special foods,” these world history texts may actually skip altogether the life of Jesus, the Protestant Reformation, and even the Holocaust—all on the theory that religion is too hot to handle in the public
52
RELIGIOUS LITERACY
schools. The result, according to a report released by the Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development, is “massive ignorance of any faith beside one’s own (and sometimes even of one’s own).”85 Textbook authors are probably not actively trying to disrespect religion. They are likely just attempting to avoid controversy. Textbook publishers are notoriously allergic to controversy, and religion has a way of stirring up controversy in a country where so many people have invested so much in so many different faiths. Simple prudence might suggest it is best to steer clear of this minefield of potential parental protests. But ignoring religion can be explosive too. During the 1980s textbook controversies broke out in Tennessee and Alabama when parents charged that schoolbooks that ignored religion were violating the Constitution by preaching the religions of “secular humanism” and the “New Age.” These cases brought to light a history textbook that identified the Pilgrims as “people who make long trips” and a home economics text whose teacher’s guide listed Jesus and Martin Luther as examples of a hyperreligious “irrational-conscientious” personality type whose “repressed hostility makes them far too literal-minded and rigid in their righteousness.”86 The current booms in homeschooling and evangelical private schooling can be credited in part to a widespread perception among conservative Christian parents that public schools have gone over to the secular side. Recently some conservative Christians have called for what might be termed a “second disestablishment” of the public schools. Whereas the first disestablishment, effected over the course of the nineteenth century, got rid of a sectarian bias toward Protestantism in public schools, this second disestablishment takes aim at sectarian bias toward “secular humanism.” Turning the tables on liberal critics of fundamentalists’ efforts to censor such books as Catch-22 and Heather Has Two Mommies, conservative Christian critics contend that secular humanists are now effectively censoring schoolbooks and, through them, the public schools themselves. In this way complaints about the exclusion of religion from schoolbooks have become part of a broader protest against the erasure of religion from American public life—yet another case of antireligious bias.87 In 1985, while the cultural conservative William Bennett was overseeing the Department of Education, the DOE’s National Institute of Education commissioned a study on the role of religion in some sixty grade school and high school textbooks. In Censorship: Evidence of Bias in our Children’s Textbooks (1986), the study’s principal investigator, Paul Vitz, called attention to the scandal of the excision of religion from elementary and high school textbooks and, by extension, elementary and secondary
Religion Matters
53
schools: “Are public school textbooks biased? Are they censored? The answer to both is yes. And the nature of the bias is clear: Religion, traditional family values, and conservative political and economic positions have been reliably excluded from children’s textbooks.” A few years later historian Timothy Smith accused the authors and publishers of the thirteen high school US history textbooks he reviewed of “ignoring or distorting the place of religion in American history.”88 Many of these textbook watchers are evangelicals, and as Vitz’s comments about “traditional family values” and “conservative political and economic positions” suggest, some are concerned about more than just religion. But conservative Republicans are not the only constituency scandalized by the trivialization of religion in the public schools. Liberals and libertarians are angry too, though their focus is typically on the religion clauses of the First Amendment and America’s heritage of religious diversity. While Vitz and those on the right are more likely to be worried about a lack of attention to Puritan New England, critics on the left want to give Roger Williams, William Penn, and other scions of religious liberty their due. A textbook review published by People for the American Way said, “While history textbooks talk about the existence of religious diversity in America, they do not show it: Jews exist only as the objects of discrimination; Catholics exist to be discriminated against and to ask for government money for their own schools; there is no reflection of the diversity within American Protestantism. . . . The Quakers are shown giving us religious freedom and abolition, and then apparently disappear off the face of the earth.”89 This muzzling of religion is not only unfair, it is likely unconstitutional. As a series of recent Supreme Court rulings has made plain, the First Amendment requires that the public schools be neutral with respect to religion. That means not taking sides among the religions, not favoring Christianity over Buddhism, for example, or the Baptists over the Lutherans. But it also means not taking sides between religion and irreligion. As Justice Tom Clark wrote in Abington v. Schempp (1963), public schools may not preach the “religion of secularism.” But pretending that you can understand the world without reckoning with one of the most influential forces in world history comes perilously close to doing just that. One elementary school teacher told researchers that she had celebrated Christmas with her students for twenty-three years and had never mentioned Jesus even once. Is that fair to Christianity? Is it neutral? Does it make educational sense to study American poetry without attending to the Psalms? Or world literature without reading the words of Confucius
54
RELIGIOUS LITERACY
and Jesus? As Nord noted, “For some time now, people have rightly argued that ignoring black history and women’s literature (as texts and curricula have traditionally done) has been anything but neutral. Rather, it betrays a prejudice; it is discriminatory. And so it is with religion.”90 Reasons for Neglect Many reasons have been offered for this not-so-benign neglect of religion in US and world history textbooks, which appears to have begun in the 1960s and 1970s. A desire to steer clear of controversy has already been mentioned. Another reason is confusion about Supreme Court decisions on religion and public education. Many teachers, parents, principals, superintendents, curriculum committees, textbook authors, textbook publishers, and members of textbook selection boards are simply unaware that the Court has repeatedly and explicitly given a constitutional seal of approval to teaching about religion “when presented objectively as part of a secular program of education.”91 In fact, many teachers wrongly believe that any mention of religion is unconstitutional. A related reason for the silence on religion in public schools is confusion about the crucial distinction between theology and religious studies—between what the Supreme Court Justice Arthur Goldberg called “the teaching of religion” (which is unconstitutional) and “the teaching about religion” (which is not).92 Religion has been neglected because of demands for coverage of other “new” subjects—from women and blacks to Native Americans and Latinos. Religion has also been squeezed out by the “back to basics” movement, by the mania for testing (such as Massachusetts’s high-stakes MCAS examinations), and by President Bush’s “No Child Left Behind” initiative. In each of these cases an emphasis on so-called essentials has pushed to the sidelines supposed inessentials, such as the study of religion. Schoolbooks also tend to trivialize religion because of the secular biases of those who write and publish them. Eurosecularity is rampant in both higher education and the media, textbook publishing’s two homes. The former answers to the Enlightenment and the latter to Romanticism, but neither takes religion as seriously as the American public does. Many authors and publishers are as a result convinced that religion just doesn’t matter, except perhaps to the ancient past. In other words, while historians and sociologists are finally coming around to repudiating secularization theory, that theory continues to animate, consciously or unconsciously, the writing and editing of high school textbooks. So perhaps Peter Berger is not all wrong; perhaps those who lord over
Religion Matters
55
this country still have a bit of Sweden’s secularity in them. The United States is ruled, to be sure, from the White House, the Capitol, and the Supreme Court, and none of these institutions is in danger of going over to the secular side any time soon. But knowledge is power too, and textbooks have long functioned in the United States as the scriptures of our schools, which are themselves, as Frances Fitzgerald once put it, “Ministries of Truth for children.”93 Schoolbooks tell us what we need to know and what we ought to value. They tell us what matters and what can be ignored, what is worth dying for and what (or who) is to be shunned. They tell us what America is, both as an ideal and as a reality, and they interpret the wider world—the beaker in which the American experiment is forever bubbling up. This is no small power: telling children what to think about themselves, their country, and the world—telling them as well what to think of Islam and Christianity and Judaism or whether to think of religion at all. At least for the time being the gospel that these ministries are peddling is that religion is moribund—that God is dead. Things were not always so. Not long ago high school textbooks were filled with references to the living God and the resurrected Christ. They quoted freely from the Gospel of Matthew and the five books of Moses. The truths these schoolbooks told were religious to the core: that the United States was a chosen nation, that good boys and girls would go to heaven, and that cleanliness was next to godliness. You may not agree with these messages, but there is no gainsaying the fact that this sort of education cultivated religious literacy, at least of the Protestant sort. In fact, in the colonies and the early republic, basic literacy and religious literacy were intimately intertwined. It was impossible to learn how to read without learning basic facts about the Christian tradition. To understand how we fell into the predicament we find ourselves in today, we need to go back to this educational Eden and see how teachers and students in that time heeded the biblical commandment to “remember.”
Part 2
The Past
Three
Eden (What We Once Knew)
O
nce upon a time, Americans were a people of the book. Colonists did not just believe in the Bible, they knew what it said. They carried with them on their New World pilgrimages not only a thirst for adventure but also Psalters, New Testaments, and Bibles, which they read and memorized, cited and recited, searched for meaning and quoted for authority. They named their children after Bible heroes: Sarah, Hannah, and Mary; Joseph, Samuel, and David. And when these colonists’ descendants became patriots and then citizens, they found themselves in a world animated not only by Adams and Washington and Jefferson but also by Adam and Moses and Jeremiah. They called their towns Eden and Bethlehem, Mount Ararat and Canaan, Shiloh and Jericho, and they knew the Bible stories these place names evoked. Sayings from the Gospels salted their everyday speech, as surely as knowing references to the exploits of the Israelites flavored their presidents’ speeches. Among those presidents, Thomas Jefferson likely had the least conventional theology, but when prompted to propose a seal for the new nation, he suggested a biblical image: the people of Israel being led through the wilderness by a pillar of cloud and fire. In the colonies and the early republic, biblical wisdom was literally in the air.94 That wisdom had taken flight in sixteenth-century Europe, where Martin Luther, John Calvin, and other renegades had gotten up a religious revolution on the theory that ordinary folks should be able to read the Bible in their own languages and interpret it for themselves. During the Protestant Reformation, as that revolution came to be called, the focus of Christianity shifted—at least for the Reformers—from sacraments to scripture, from the idolatry of images to the veracity of words. Sola scriptura (“Bible alone”) was the new rallying cry; God’s grace now flowed not just through baptism and the Lord’s Supper but also, and
60
RELIGIOUS LITERACY
more importantly, through God’s Word. And so clergy became first and foremost interpreters and teachers of that Word, the printing press became a gift from God, the translator became a new saint, and reading became a means of grace. To receive this grace, however, to free oneself from the tyranny of priestly mediation and papal bulls, one had to be able to read. So teaching reading became an act of nearly unparalleled piety, and acquiring basic literacy a religious duty. The Protestants who peopled the North American colonies in the seventeenth century were heirs of this religious revolution, so among them too the fates of reading and religion were closely tied. But more than salvation hung on the colonists’ ability to read; the success of the New World experiment itself depended on the profusion of basic literacy. In both Europe and North America it had long been understood that social order depended on morality, and morality on religion. As early as 1516 the Spanish crown had instructed its explorers that every New World village “was to have its own school and church, and it was the duty of missionaries to see that each individual was taught and instructed . . . in the Catholic faith.” Among New World Protestants, it was an article of faith that church and state alike depended on a populace able to read and understand the Word of God. Bible reading would foster faith, which would foster ethical behavior, which would sustain social order, even (God willing) in the wilds of this new wilderness. Or so the theory went. The point is that the effort to teach colonial children to read was a high-stakes project. On its success hung not merely the job prospects and spiritual destinies of individual children but the fate of the New World experiment itself. No wonder the colonists passed a series of laws in the seventeenth century requiring apprentices and children to “attain at least so much, as to be able duly to read the Scriptures, and other good and profitable printed Books in the English tongue.”95 “The Most Literate Place on Earth” With the American Revolution came a new rationale for basic literacy, and a new aim. Whereas the revolution of Luther and Calvin had provided a theological justification for reading, the revolution of Washington and Adams provided a civic one. Now children needed to read not only to be good Protestants but also to be good citizens—to free themselves from the tyranny of popes as well as kings. The theory here was simple, and it was rooted in a shared sense of the fragility of democratic government. Unlike European monarchies, which saw educated citizens as a bother at
Eden (What We Once Knew)
61
best, the American experiment in republican government, which vested sovereignty in the people and, by the 1820s, extended suffrage without regard to economic means (though, it must be noted, still in regard to race and sex), depended for its survival on an informed citizenry. Or, as James Madison put it, “A people who mean to be their own Governors, must arm themselves with the power which knowledge gives.”96 And so two potent justifications for literacy developed side by side. Children would learn to read both to free themselves from sin and to liberate themselves from monarchs—both to save their souls and to save the republic. These two impulses—one religious and one secular—would eventually conspire to produce the public school system we have today. In the shorter term they produced literacy rates unparalleled in Europe, leading John Adams to write (in 1765) that “a Native of America, especially of New England, who cannot read and wright is as rare a Phenomenon as a Comet.” That was hyperbole. Nonetheless, historian David Paul Nord’s characterization of seventeenth- and eighteenth-century New England as “perhaps the most literate place on earth” seems warranted. “There is scarcely an adult individual in all New England,” Philadelphia’s Analectic Magazine reported in 1817, “who cannot read, and write, and keep accounts.”97 Literacy came more slowly to African Americans and Indians. For African Americans the main barrier was a concern among slaveholders that, if slaves learned to read the Bible (including Galatians 3:28, ASV: “there is neither slave nor free . . . in Christ Jesus”) they would demand freedom in this world as well as the next. According to W. E. B. DuBois, only 5 percent of African Americans could read on the eve of the Civil War. Of course, many did learn to read, through the instruction of ministers or privately funded schools for black children. Some Massachusett Indians acquired literacy through the efforts of Congregationalist missionary John Eliot, who wrote both an Indian Grammar (1666) and an Indian Primer (1669), the latter promising to train its users “in the good Knowledge of God, in the Knowledge of the Scriptures, and in an ability to Reade.” An Indian school in the “Praying Town” of Natick (one of fourteen such settlements) taught Massachusett-speaking Indians to read; the Reverend Cotton Mather of Boston’s North Church oversaw an evening school for both Indians and blacks; and Harvard College enrolled Native Americans in its Indian College. Still, literacy was hard to find among these groups.98 Among whites, reading literacy was not as common in the southern and middle colonies, where scattered settlements made schools less feasible
62
RELIGIOUS LITERACY
than they were in New England’s towns and where Puritanism’s power was muted by a preponderance of Anglicans, Quakers, and Lutherans. Still overall literacy rates for whites were higher—for both men and women—in the colonies than on the Continent.99 “Scripture Learnt” Colonists and early Americans used this literacy first and foremost to read the Bible, which throughout American history has been both the bestselling book and the most influential cultural artifact. There may have been Bibles in as many as nine out of ten homes in the early republic, and the Bible was the book for reading in households and schools well into the nineteenth century. Many children read the Bible cover to cover multiple times before adulthood, and families gathered regularly in the morning or evening (or both) to pray, sing hymns, and read the scriptures, which they received as “a manual of law, literature, history, and warfare, as well as a primer for reading and, of course, religion.” In fact, the controversial traditions of prayer, hymn singing, and Bible reading in public schools likely developed out of these domestic rituals.100 Early Americans’ knowledge of religious matters was by no means confined to scripture, however. A few renegades understood the Reformation’s sola scriptura imperative to mean that they should interpret the Bible solely by the light of individual conscience, without regard to creed, clergy, or catechism. But most Protestants understood that ordinary folk would need some assistance if their society was to avoid lapsing into a Babel of competing Bible interpretations. So Americans imported, published, purchased, read, and memorized countless catechisms—“no less than five hundred” by 1679, according to Puritan divine Increase Mather. The Westminster’s Assembly’s Shorter Catechism (1647) was the most popular in New England, and the Anglican catechism predominated in New York and such southern colonies as Maryland, Virginia, and the Carolinas. In 1717 a teacher in Rye, New York, reported that his school, sponsored by the Anglican Society for the Propagation of the Gospel, boasted twenty-one boys and fifteen girls who had memorized the entire Anglican catechism.101 Seventeenth- and eighteenth-century Americans (undistracted by such technological graces as radio, television, and the Internet) also heeded lengthy sermons on the Incarnation, the crucifixion, and the Trinity. According to church historian Harry Stout, “The average weekly churchgoer in New England . . . listened to something like seven thousand ser-
Eden (What We Once Knew)
63
mons in a lifetime, totaling somewhere around fifteen thousand hours of concentrated listening”—roughly ten times the listening load of a fouryear college student today. Many of these churchgoers, moreover, returned in print to sermons they had heard in church, making the sermon “the central ritual” in colonial New England and its dominant mode of “public communication.” New England laypeople, moreover, were expected to offer their own sermon of sorts as a condition of admission to full membership in their Congregational churches. These “relations,” which were delivered in public before the entire congregation, typically included a narrative about the candidates’ conversion and a “heavily doctrinal” synopsis of Calvinist theology.102 While novels were the most popular books in some European countries in the late eighteenth century, religious books predominated in the colonies and the early republic. In fact, books on religion were far better sellers than books on politics, science, medicine, or law. Full Bibles and New Testaments were the most popular works retained in family libraries, and ministers were the most popular authors—the J. K. Rowlings of their time. Roughly half of the books printed in the British colonies between 1639 and 1689 were religious tomes. During and after the Revolution, political works increased in popularity, as did books that aimed simply to amuse, but religious works predominated; as late as the early nineteenth century roughly two-fifths of the books in family libraries in rural New England were devoted to sacred subjects. Among early America’s “steady sellers” (a term coined by historian David D. Hall to denote popular volumes that stayed in print for decades, even centuries) were Philip Doddridge’s The Rise and Progress of Religion in the Soul, Richard Baxter’s The Saints Everlasting Rest, and John Bunyan’s Pilgrim’s Progress.103 Religion mattered more in New England than in other areas, but religious knowledge was widespread in Virginia too. Like colonial New Englanders, colonial Virginians were a people of the book, convinced that God had “Caused all holy Scriptures to be written for our learning.” They supplemented the Bible, however, with the Anglican Book of Common Prayer. As a result, their literacy was liturgical as much as scriptural. “The entire drama of the faith, an explanation of the meaning of existence, a rule of conduct, and an apprehension of the spiritual,” writes historian John Nelson, “were laid out for worshippers in the weekly recitation of confession, creed, collects, responses, Psalms, canticles, Old Testament, Gospel, and Epistle lessons.” Priests and parents alike catechized youth, and courts instructed parents to teach their children to read
64
RELIGIOUS LITERACY
the Bible. African American slaves did not convert in Virginia in large numbers, but those who did were catechized on Sundays and generally attended church services with whites.104 In the wider Chesapeake region in the seventeenth century, the Bible was far and away the most popular book, followed by Lewis Bayly’s Protestant steady seller, The Practice of Piety, making Protestantism “something of a common denominator” even in Jefferson’s Virginia and once-Catholic Maryland. Like the Bible itself, devotional books such as Bayly’s were typically read intensively rather than casually—for knowledge more than entertainment—at least through the early nineteenth century. In other words, they were read and reread, studied and pondered, memorized and recited. In the process, the wisdom shared in these texts became part of the common culture on which colonists and early Americans of all social classes and regions drew. This common culture was not lost on visitors. After a brief sojourn in Connecticut, an Englishwoman wrote in 1775, “They are all politicians, and all Scripture learnt.”105 All this is to say that, in colonial and early national America, basic literacy and religious literacy were one. Americans acquired, as they learned to read, at least the rudiments of a Protestant worldview, which (because of widespread literacy) was by no means confined to elites or, for that matter, to Protestants. To put it another way, it was not possible to learn how to read without learning biblical idioms; with basic literacy came religious literacy of the Protestant sort. If the early nineteenth century was, as orator and statesman Daniel Webster noted, an “age of knowledge,” and the early republic was, as historian William Gilmore argued, a “republic of knowledge,” then religious knowledge was one of the grand achievements of that age, and of that republic.106 This religious literacy, it should be emphasized, was limited to Christianity. More specifically, it was limited to Protestantism, since anti-Catholicism was one of its key components. Neither the colonists nor early Americans knew much about Judaism or Mohammedanism (as Islam was then called). And only the most sophisticated scholar or well-traveled sea captain knew anything at all about such Asian religions as Buddhism, Hinduism, or Sikhism. When Benjamin Franklin observed in his Autobiography that his father’s library “consisted chiefly of books in polemic divinity,” he was not talking about Islamic divinity.107 The religious literacy that early Americans possessed was Protestant literacy of a sectarian sort. What they knew were the basic teachings, core practices, key values, and Bible stories of Protestant Christianity as their particular denominations understood it.
Eden (What We Once Knew)
65
Household Historians once imagined that education was confined to the formal instruction offered in schools. We now know that education occurs whenever human beings teach and learn—that the province of education extends to homes and religious congregations, newspapers and almanacs, publishers and booksellers, libraries and museums, theological tracts and political pamphlets, camp meetings and revivals, social reform organizations and religious denominations, Sunday schools and workplaces.108 In the colonies and the early republic, all these sites functioned as links in the chain of memory passing religious knowledge down from generation to generation. Newspapers printed not only news stories but also sermons, while almanacs included the positions of the planets alongside quotations from the Psalms. Six venues, however, were particularly important in delivering to early Americans the religious information so many of us have now forgotten. These six venues were: homes, churches, schools, Sunday schools, Bible and tract societies, and colleges, which together warded off, at least through the early nineteenth century, the sort of religious amnesia now rampant among America’s faithful. In the colonies and the early republic, instruction in both reading and religion took place first and foremost in the home, which served as the primary institution of social organization and cultural transmission. Today homeschooling is a countercultural activity, but in seventeenth- and eighteenth-century America it was the norm. In 1642 the Massachusetts Bay Colony passed legislation requiring families to teach their children “to read and understand the principles of religion.” Connecticut followed suit in 1650 with a law mandating that children and servants be taught to read and catechized weekly. New Haven, New York, Plymouth, Pennsylvania, and Virginia later passed similar laws.109 In early American households children learned to read and write on the laps of their parents. Writing, which was understood as a skill for the counting house, the government office, and the pulpit, was typically restricted to boys. But reading, understood as a religious skill (preparation for God’s grace), was taught to girls as well, particularly after the onset of “republican motherhood,” which charged eighteenth-century mothers with the task of turning their sons into patriotic citizens.110 This was an era of oral reading, which means not only that people read aloud in groups but also that children learned to read via the ears and the mouth as much as the eyes—through both recitation and memorization. In this era the Bible was the core text, and many children
66
RELIGIOUS LITERACY
imbibed Bible stories by listening to parents and siblings long before they themselves learned to read. In many homes religious instruction was a daily task, and children as young as four or five were drilled repeatedly in the 107 questions and answers of the Westminster Assembly’s Shorter Catechism (or in some suitable substitute, such as the 64 questions and answers of Spiritual Milk for Babes: Drawn out of the Breasts of Both Testaments by Puritan divine John Cotton). As Cotton’s title implies, religious education was to the Puritans as essential as mother’s milk, and it too was delivered by mothers to children, who memorized the Ten Commandments and learned of sin, salvation, and sanctification long before they could read. Cotton Mather, another Puritan divine, admonished mothers to drill their children in the catechism “continually,” adding that nothing less than the eternal state of their souls hung in the balance: The Souls of your Children made a Cry in your Ears, O parents; . . . They are Born Children of Wrath; and when they grow up, you have no way to Save them from the dreadful Wrath of God, if you do not Catechise them in the Way of Salvation. They cry to you; O our dear Parents; Acquaint us with the Great God, and His Glorious Christ, that so Good may come unto us! Let us not go from your Tender Knees, down to the Place of Dragons. . . . What, but more cruel than the Sea-Monsters are the Parents, who will not be moved by such Thoughts as these, to Draw out the Breasts of the Catechism, unto their Young Ones!111 Household religious instruction did not end with British rule. According to his 1852 memoir, newspaper editor Joseph Buckingham (who was born in 1779) read at least one Bible chapter daily for years, completing the entire work (“with no other omissions than the jaw-breaking chapters of the Chronicles”) at least a dozen times before the age of sixteen. In the process, “the incidents and the language became almost as familiar as the grace . . . said before and after meals.” But Buckingham was nearly as intimate with popular devotional works. “In her devotional exercises,” Buckingham remembered, “my mother often introduced passages from Watts and Doddridge.” Eventually Buckingham “could recite Watts’s version of the Psalms from beginning to end, together with many of his Hymns and Lyric Poems.”112
Eden (What We Once Knew)
67
Church Early Americans also learned about religion in the church, which since the time of Jesus’ Great Commission has been mandated to go forth not only to baptize but also to “teach all nations” (Matthew 28:19). Meetinghouse attendance was required by law as early as 1635 in Massachusetts, and on the eve of the Revolution there were religious establishments in nine of the thirteen colonies. Puritans, in keeping with their emphasis on religious knowledge, recognized not one clerical office but two. Each congregation was to have, in addition to a pastor, a teacher, whose job was to deliver sermons and catechize and tutor youth. Puritanism was the reigning theology in the colonies, and Puritan sermons were arranged in a four-part scheme of text, doctrine, reasons, and uses. The niceties of this method, which goes back to The Arte of Prophecying (1592) by the English Puritan William Perkins, can be left to experts. The important point here is that sermons emphasized scripture—reading it, understanding it, and applying it. Particularly in New England, preachers rarely colored their sermons with tales from their own lives or the lives of their parishioners. They did biblical exegesis in the plain style, often for as long as two hours at a stretch, typically from notes or a complete manuscript. Anglican preaching, popular in Virginia, South Carolina, Georgia, and Maryland, where the Church of England was established, was more essay than exegesis, but Anglican clergy too steered clear of commonplace tales to focus on the Bible. If, as Augustine wrote, preaching is about teaching, delighting, and persuading, early American preachers focused on the first and third desiderata. The Great Awakening of the mideighteenth century injected into the popular sermon a wider emotional range, including overt appeals to the horrors of hell, chiefly because such appeals induced conversions. Some Great Awakening preachers spoke extemporaneously, and a few waited on the Holy Spirit to inspire whatever they might say that day. But for the most part colonial and early American sermons remained rigorously theological. Most ministers were educated, and biblical preaching was the rule. Lessons learned from the pulpit were supplemented with individual and group instruction. In Virginia a 1631 law required each minister to “examine, catechize, and instruct the youth and ignorant persons of his parish in the Ten Commandments, the Articles of the Belief and the Lord’s Prayer.” New England ministers took the duty to transmit basic religious literacy to the next generation at least as seriously. According to
68
RELIGIOUS LITERACY
Cotton Mather, “Few pastors of mankind ever took such pains at catechising, as have been taken by our New-English divines.” Even the traveling evangelist George Whitefield was committed to catechesis. Though he spent most of his seven sojourns to America in the 1730s and 1740s preaching and otherwise stirring up the Great Awakening, he also catechized youth and established a school in Savannah, Georgia.113 To be sure, not every colonist attended church or submitted to catechesis. Even in New England eighteenth-century ministers “complained of ignorant children who knew nothing of their catechisms, parents who failed to present infants for baptism, and brash Sabbath profaners who mocked their sermons, took the Lord’s name in vain, or spoke lightly of the Devil.”114 But when it came to religion, a mixture of piety and knowledge was the rule. Both of these ingredients were enhanced by the ratification in 1791 of the First Amendment, which outlawed any federal religious establishment. Though state establishments lingered until the demise of the Congregational standing order in Massachusetts in 1833, the American preference for persuasion over coercion in all things religious was firmly in place before the end of the eighteenth century. Many feared that religious freedom would weaken the churches, but instead Christianity sprang to life, thanks largely to the Baptists and the Methodists, the two great revivalist denominations that by the midnineteenth century had trounced such old colonial standbys as the Congregationalists and the Episcopalians (as the Anglicans were renamed after the Revolution). In time, the vast spiritual marketplace brought on by the First Amendment would provide virtually all Americans with a religious option they could call their own. So church attendance boomed, and religious congregations became even more effective transmitters of religious knowledge. Ministers also labored to convert and catechize Indians and African Americans. John Eliot, who has been called “perhaps the quintessential minister-educator of the seventeenth-century colonies,” worked with the Indian Job Nesutan to translate the Bible into Massachusett (an Algonquian language) in 1663. The first book Eliot produced for Indians, however, was a catechism, and he drilled his native students in it relentlessly, teaching them the Ten Commandments and the basic outlines of the Christian story: God’s creation, humanity’s fall, Christ’s redemption. The family of Thomas Mayhew did similar work among Wampanoags on the islands of Martha’s Vineyard and Nantucket, though unlike Eliot the Mayhews did not insist that the Indians cut their hair, wear English clothing, and congregate in “Praying Towns.” Outside Puritan New England, Angli-
Eden (What We Once Knew)
69
cans, Lutherans, Roman Catholics, and the Dutch Reformed conducted Native American missions too. One of the most successful, perhaps because it followed the example of the Mayhews in confining its work to Christianizing (as opposed to “civilizing”), was conducted among Mohawks in what is now upstate New York by Anglicans in the Society for the Propagation of the Gospel. Some Indian converts demonstrated exceptional religious literacy. Elisha Paaonut, a Wampanoag preacher from Martha’s Vineyard, was said to know the Bible nearly by heart, and the Iroquoian leader T’hayendanegea (Joseph Brant), perhaps the bestknown Indian of the Revolutionary period, translated the Gospel of Mark into Mohawk.115 African Americans converted to Christianity in far greater numbers, first in the Great Awakening of the early eighteenth century and especially in the revivals of the early nineteenth century. Some slaves acquired basic literacy, but most got their Protestantism orally: through masterapproved white preachers, who often confined their sermons to such fare as Ephesians 6:5 and Colossians 3:22: “Slaves, obey your masters”; through black preachers partial to biblical narratives such as the Exodus story (in which God delivers his chosen people from slavery to freedom); and, perhaps most important, through spirituals that celebrated Jesus as a Moses figure who promises both salvation from sins and liberation from slavery. The Reverend William Sturgeon, an Anglican minister who taught African Americans at the Negro Charity School in Philadelphia, reported in the 1750s that many of his students could recite the Lord’s Prayer, a creed, and some of the catechism.116 School The United States was the first country to take universal free education as an ideal and the first to transform that ideal into a reality. This transformation began as early as 1647, when Massachusetts Bay Colony legislators passed a law intended to ward off the efforts of “that old deluder, Satan, to keep men from the knowledge of the Scriptures.”117 This law instructed towns of fifty households to appoint teachers of reading and writing, and towns of one hundred households to establish grammar schools. Virginia passed similar legislation during the same decade, and by the 1670s every New England colony except Rhode Island had such a law. Over the course of the seventeenth century much of the burden of education passed from homes to schools. This happened quickest in New
70
RELIGIOUS LITERACY
England, where a population gathered in towns made schooling efficient. But even a settlement as scattered as Virginia had eleven schools by 1689 (to New England’s twenty-three). Schools were as multiform as local conditions, ranging from “dame schools” run out of housewives’ kitchens to “grammar schools,” which taught Hebrew and Greek grammar to aid in the reading of the Bible, to private academies, “petty schools,” and evening schools. These were variously funded: by parents, communities, employers, patrons, or churches. Education was catch-as-catch-can in most southern colonies, which did not mandate education the way New Englanders did. In New York, New Jersey, and Pennsylvania, denominational schools—for Quakers, Mennonites, Lutherans, and so on—were the standard. In them children learned denominational doctrines alongside Bible stories. But across the colonies and then the early United States, teachers relied on similar textbooks. As historian Lawrence Cremin argued, “There is every reason to believe that the curriculum was fairly standard.” And from the start this curriculum emphasized religion in a manner that doubtless would be ruled unconstitutional today. Children learned their ABC’s from scripture-saturated schoolbooks or from the Good Book itself. And they aimed to read not so much to get rich as to get right with God. According to historian Jennifer Monaghan, early literacy education amounted in essence to “a course in Christianity.” “If there was an overriding purpose to American colonial education,” adds philosopher Warren Nord, “it was to nurture and sustain a Christian civilization.”118 This notion of the pious schoolhouse endured well into the nineteenth century, notably in common schools (as public schools were then called). The publicly funded common school emerged in the 1820s in response to such developments as the rise of the “common man,” aborning nationalism, the end of property requirements for voting, and, above all, fears about Roman Catholic immigration—the “great danger,” as one nativist put it, posed by “the dark and stolid infidelity and vicious radicalism of a large portion of the foreign immigrating population.” The goal of these schools, which by 1850 were instructing over 90 percent of the nation’s white students, was to Americanize the school population—to make “of many, one.” Beginning shortly after the Revolution, that population included girls, who were finally incorporated into the ideal of “universal education” between the 1780s and the 1830s. It embraced Southerners during the Reconstruction era of the late 1860s and 1870s, which finally saw public education take root south of the Mason-Dixon line.119
Eden (What We Once Knew)
71
One of the myths of American education is that once upon a time (that is, before the Religious Right started to muck around in the public schools) public education was secular. This is simply not so. From their early-nineteenth-century beginnings, common schools were very much a part of an unofficial yet powerful Protestant establishment, which included the leading Protestant denominations and a “Benevolent Empire” of nondenominational voluntary associations dedicated to improving the world through peace, temperance, abolitionism, and other social reforms. These “little nurseries of piety and religion” preached this informal establishment’s gospel of Protestant republicanism, teaching students to revere George Washington as a saint and Jesus as the Christ. They were religious in their leadership, faculty, curricula, and aims. Their textbooks called the Bible the Word of God, and their teachers endeavored to turn out not just good citizens but good Protestants.120 The New England Primer Good Protestants were made during the colonial period through a process that English John Locke once referred to as the “ordinary Road” from illiteracy to learning. The first stop on this “ordinary Road” was the hornbook, a one-page lesson pasted onto a paddle-shaped board and laminated by transparent animal horn. This primitive primer, European in origin, was used in schools, homes, and churches—wherever colonists were taught to read. It came in a variety of forms, though it typically included the alphabet (in upper and lower case), followed by lists of vowels and a syllabary of common two-letter combinations. But the bulk of its limited space was given to religious matters: a cross in the upper lefthand corner, the Lord’s Prayer, and a short invocation of the Trinity—“In the Name of the Father, & of the Son, & of the Holy Ghost. Amen.”— sometimes called “The Exorcism” because of its alleged capacity to ward off evil.121 As printed books came to the colonies, publishers and booksellers became key links in the chain of memory that transmitted religious knowledge to early Americans, and the hornbook yielded to a series of best-selling schoolbooks, each of which combined lessons on spelling and syllabification with scripture readings and catechisms. The first great example was the New England Primer. It is tempting to describe the New England Primer as the Bible of early American education. That is not quite right, since the Bible itself was the Bible of early American education. Many young colonists took the Bible
72
RELIGIOUS LITERACY
as their first reader, laboring to decode in the letters, syllables, and words of the Gospel of Matthew the sounds of the Sermon on the Mount they had memorized as children. But after the Bible the New England Primer was the best-selling book in colonial and early America, and far and away the most important American schoolbook for over a century. Probably first published around 1690 (though the earliest extant edition dates to 1727), the New England Primer was printed, and plagiarized, by many publishers in hundreds of varying editions under a variety of different names—these were precopyright days—and was ubiquitous in both New England and the middle colonies. Print run estimates vary from two to eight million, but because schoolbooks were so highly prized, these copies were handed around to millions more. According to one historian, the New England Primer “influenced, probably more than any other elementary book for children, the character and creed of many leading actors in our country’s history,” including many of the nation’s founders. It was, another historian wrote, “for a hundred years, beyond any other, the principal text of American schools.”122 The purpose of any primer would seem to be to teach children to read. But like the hornbook, the New England Primer was first and foremost a primer on religion. Its 1777 edition, published in the midst of the American Revolution, championed not Enlightenment virtues so much as Calvinist truths. It began with “A Divine Song of Praise to God, for a Child,” followed by a child’s morning prayer and a child’s evening prayer. Only then did it move on to letters, syllables, and words. Its word lists were shot through with religious terminology: one-syllable words such as saint and vice, two-syllable words such as Ba-bel and Ja-cob. Then, for more advanced readers (and theologians), dam-ni-fy, ho-li-ness, be-a-ti-tude, bene-dic-ti-on, for-ni-ca-ti-on, and a-bo-mi-na-ti-on.123 The heart of the New England Primer, however, was its series of rhyming couplets and accompanying woodcuts, which offered children a simple way to memorize the alphabet. In almost every case these couplets drew on a Bible story (more often the Old Testament than the New). The lesson began (again in 1777): A In Adam’s Fall We sinned all. B Heaven to find; The Bible Mind. C Christ crucify’d For sinners dy’d.
Eden (What We Once Knew)
73
By the time students got to Z and Zacchaeus, they had been introduced to the Flood, Judgment Day, the Exodus, Peter’s denial of Christ, Elijah, Job, Esther, Ruth, Samuel, Obadias, David, and many more Bible stories and heroes. It has been widely remarked that the New England Primer taught the Calvinist theology of New England’s Puritans, including its fear of God, its morbid preoccupation with sin and death, and its dread in the face of everlasting judgment. In addition to preaching Reformed truths, however, the book offered a wealth of basic information about the Christian tradition. Following immediately on its doggerel of the ABC’s was a onepage catechism of the Old and New Testaments, which began: Who was the first man? Who was the first woman? Who was the first Murderer? Who was the first Martyr?
Adam Eve Cain Abel
This catechism went on to teach schoolchildren about the oldest man (Methuselah), the strongest man (Sampson), and the wisest man (Solomon). It told readers who built the Ark (Noah), who led Israel into Canaan (Joshua), who saves lost souls (Jesus Christ), who betrayed his Master (Judas), and who was the first Christian martyr (Stephen). Later versions Americanized this list, asking: “Who saved America?”: “George Washington”; and “Who betrayed America?”: “Benedict Arnold.”124 The New England Primer also included the Lord’s Prayer and the Apostles’ Creed, Bible quotations, lists of biblical names, “A Dialogue Between Christ, Youth, and the Devil,” an account (accompanied by a gruesome woodcut) of the martyrdom of the Protestant minister Mr. John Rogers at the hands of Queen Mary, and a shorter version of the Westminster Confession, which educated its readers about such matters as monotheism, original sin, and the virgin birth. Finally, the New England Primer contained this famous prayer (which seems to have first appeared in this formulation in the 1737 edition): Now I lay me down to sleep I pray the Lord my soul to keep If I should die before I wake I pray the Lord my soul to take. Today we often think of public schools as religion-free zones, as if the First Amendment guarantees not freedom of religion but freedom from
74
RELIGIOUS LITERACY
it. In early America, however, religion permeated the classroom. Children learned both to conduct business and to get right with God. The primers they consulted were, as other historians have noted, “denominational texts,” which focused as much on the Fourth R as the first. Or, to put it more precisely, religion was their first R, since in their hierarchy of knowledge theology towered above reading, writing, and arithmetic. Children who learned from the New England Primer would have acquired not only basic literacy in English but also basic literacy in Calvinism. From an early age they would have been conversant with the foundational beliefs, practices, stories, and heroes of their parents’ faith.125 Noah Webster’s Speller The New England Primer dominated eighteenth-century education and was used sporadically into the early twentieth century, but its sales were minuscule when compared with the first great best seller in American history, Noah Webster’s speller. Webster is best known for his efforts to standardize the writing and speaking of American English—by taking the u out of honour and the k out of musick—notably in his American Dictionary of the English Language of 1828 and his “American” translation of the Bible of 1833. But Webster’s most popular creation was The American Spelling Book, which first appeared in 1783 (under the infelicitous title of Grammatical Institute of the English Language, Part I) and later came to be known, because of its vivid blue covers, as the “blue-back speller.” At a time when sales of a few thousand units qualified a book as an unqualified success, Webster’s speller was shipped to dry-goods stores in crates of seventy-two dozen. The editions came fast and furious; publishers in Vermont alone produced some twenty-seven editions between 1787 and 1820. Webster estimated that ten million copies had come off printing presses by 1829, and by midcentury Americans were reportedly buying copies at a rate of a million per year (though sales spiked to over a million and a half copies in 1866, when newly freed slaves turned to Webster to grab the brass ring of literacy). Aggregate sales estimates converge in the range of seventy million, making Webster’s speller one of the best-selling books of all time, behind only the Bible and perhaps Quotations from Chairman Mao Tse-tung.126 Given these figures, it is difficult to overestimate the influence of Webster’s speller. Historian Henry Steele Commager, however, came close. “It established its sovereignty in the East; it went west with the Conestoga wagon, and in the knapsacks of countless itinerant peda-
Eden (What We Once Knew)
75
gogues; it leaped the mountains and established its empire on the Pacific coast; it even invaded the South,” Commager wrote. “No other secular book had ever spread so wide, penetrated so deep, lasted so long. . . . Under its benign guidance generations of young Americans learned the same words, the same spelling, the same pronunciations; read the same stories; absorbed the same moral lessons.”127 But young Americans absorbed far more than morality from Webster, as this was no secular book. In fact, Webster’s speller was chock-full of Bible quotations and other religious fare. Webster once criticized his most eminent predecessor, Thomas Dilworth, for never missing an opportunity to insert God into his popular speller, A New Guide to the English Tongue (1740). “Nothing has a greater tendency to lessen the reverence which mankind ought to have for the Supreme Being,” Webster remarked acidly, “than a careless repetition of his name upon every trifling occasion.” But Webster’s speller, while doubtless more circumspect when it came to naming Names, hallowed God too. Its first reading lesson—the very words on which millions of American children began to read—begins with these pious lines: No man may put off the law of God. My joy is in his law all the day. O may I not go in the way of sin! Let me not go in the way of ill men. This lesson goes on to discuss—in simple vocabulary that somehow manages to respect Webster’s self-imposed limit of three letters (and one syllable) per word—such matters as repentance, the Golden Rule, loving one’s enemies, salvation, the atonement, churchgoing, everlasting life, cursing, swearing, stealing, lying, and hell.128 Subsequent lessons, also intended (in keeping with pedagogical customs of the day) to be committed to memory and spoken aloud, quote from the Bible repeatedly, but Webster’s speller emphasizes morality as much as theology. Webster called his narratives “Lessons of easy Words, to teach children to read, and to know their duty,” and they echo the virtue and vice catalogs in Paul’s Epistles. Repeatedly the man whom conservative Christians now laud as the “Father of American Christian Education” reminded his readers that both their fates and the fate of the nation hung on their moral scruples. His “Moral Catechism,” printed near the back of the book, commends to readers lives of humility, mercy, peacemaking, purity of heart, justice, generosity, gratitude, charity, frugality, industry,
76
RELIGIOUS LITERACY
and cheerfulness while steering them away from pride, cruelty, anger, revenge, deceit, laziness, drunkenness, wastefulness, and avarice. “God’s word, contained in the Bible,” this catechism proclaims, “has furnished all necessary rules to direct our conduct.”129 Webster then tells his readers the words they need to read the Bible. He prints lists of hundreds of names of biblical characters, each parsed into syllables and with detailed notations on pronunciation. He includes a narrative of the creation of the world, which begins, “In six days God made the world, and all things that are in it.” He prints various sayings of Jesus. His list of homophones—pray and prey, rite and right, prophet and profit—includes many words important to church history, and his lists of abbreviations cover more than a dozen biblical books.130 Webster’s speller is a bit more secular and much less sectarian than the unapologetically Calvinist New England Primer. The New England Primer reads like a sacred text with some reading lessons thrown in, whereas Webster’s speller is plainly a reading book with religious lessons interspersed. Nonetheless, by one account, one-third to one-half of the content of Webster’s early spellers was religious fare.131 McGuffey’s Readers Both the New England Primer and Webster’s American Spelling Book had lives of Old Testament proportions. In fact, each enjoyed a revival among evangelical homeschoolers in the 1980s and 1990s and remained in print in the early twenty-first century. In the 1830s, however, these two classics gave way to the hugely popular McGuffey readers, which like their predecessors conveyed to American youth considerable religious knowledge. The McGuffey readers, which debuted in 1836, have been called “the most influential volumes ever published in America.” Although more popular in the Midwest and the South than in New England, and in rural than urban America, they became by 1890 the standard school readers in some thirty-seven states. Over their long life they sold roughly 120 million copies, making them, along with the Bible, Webster’s spellers, and the Harry Potter series, the most popular books in American history. Individual copies of these readers were almost certainly read by more people than the average Bible, however, since these volumes (which often remained in a schoolhouse for a dozen years) were, like the New England Primer and Webster’s speller, read to rags. Their influence, moreover, extended well beyond schoolhouse walls since ministers, writers, and
Eden (What We Once Knew)
77
other culture brokers who memorized their contents as children went on to quote liberally from them as adults.132 The McGuffey readers were the brainchild of William Holmes McGuffey, a Scotch-Irish Presbyterian preacher and professor of ancient languages at Miami University in Oxford, Ohio, who became upon their publication the “Schoolmaster of the Nation.” (His brother, Alexander Hamilton McGuffey, later assisted with the franchise.) These readers succeeded commercially because they told gripping stories about children to children, and in that sense anticipated and contributed to the midcentury mania for child-centered education. Today we owe to these volumes our collective memory of such ditties as “Twinkle, Twinkle, Little Star” and such sayings as “Where there’s a will, there’s a way.” Scholars have criticized the McGuffey readers for presenting a romantic image of rural and small-town life—a happy heartland free of racial, ethnic, religious, and class conflict. They have lamented the absence of blacks, Native Americans, Catholics, and Jews in these texts. And they have noted the readers’ social conservativism—their middle-class morality of frugality, hard work, and self-control. At least as noteworthy, however, is the theology of these volumes. One biographer wrote that “two passions consumed McGuffey—educating the young mind and preaching the gospel.” His popular readers did both. Many of the entries were written by notable American ministers; others came from the Bible itself. Early readers were saturated with the sort of Calvinist content that McGuffey would have gotten from the Westminster Confession during his Presbyterian childhood. God was these books’ leading character, piety their cardinal virtue, and the Bible their ultimate source of wisdom. According to church historian George Marsden, the earliest editions of these readers taught “God’s creation and Providence, the insignificance of the world, the sinfulness of humans, the primacy of salvation through Christ for the next life, and the necessity of righteousness and piety in this life.”133 One of the problems faced by compilers of any nineteenth-century reader was which Bible translations to use. If you used the Protestants’ beloved King James, Catholics would cry foul. But if you went with the Catholics’ authoritative Douay-Rheims translation, Protestants would protest. McGuffey solved this problem ingeniously—by offering folksy translations of key passages. His readers rendered the Ten Commandments in rhyme: Thou no gods shall have but me. Before no idol bend the knee.
78
RELIGIOUS LITERACY
Take not the name of God in vain. Dare not the sabbath day profane. Give to thy parents honor due. Take heed that thou no murder do. Abstain from words and deeds unclean. Steal not, for thou by God art seen. Tell not a willful lie, nor love it. What is thy neighbor’s do not covet.134 And they delivered the Lord’s Prayer too in an accessible (though cloying) rhyming format: Our Father in heaven, We hallow thy name; May thy kingdom holy On earth be the same; Oh, give to us daily Our portion of bread; It is from thy bounty, That all must be fed. Forgive our transgressions, And teach us to know The humble compassion That pardons each foe; Keep us from temptation, From weakness and sin, And thine be the glory Forever! Amen!135 As popular schoolbooks evolved from the New England Primer through Webster’s spellers and McGuffey’s readers, things changed but much remained the same. These classic schoolbooks equipped generations of American schoolchildren not only with basic literacy but also with cultural literacy—what historian Elliot Gorn has called “a lingua franca . . . that went beyond common readings to a shared set of morals, aesthetics, and beliefs.” More important for present purposes, these textbooks provided a shared set of religious information. Though the moralism characteristic of Victorian America undeniably accreted in the McGuffey readers over time—“Pure and undefiled religion is,” one later reader said, “to do good”—key Protestant doctrines and stories were nonetheless plainly
Eden (What We Once Knew)
79
conveyed. Students reared on these schoolbooks typically learned the Ten Commandments and the Lord’s Prayer by heart. They were familiar with the Sermon on the Mount and the Exodus story. They understood the rudiments of church history and the creeds. To put the matter more in civic terms, they were capable of understanding biblically inflected debates on such matters as slavery, temperance, women’s rights, war, and poverty. They knew the religious heritage out of which these debates grew and without which they would have sounded bewildering.136 Other Pious Schoolbooks Neither the New England Primer nor Webster’s speller nor the McGuffey readers enjoyed a monopoly over the minds of American schoolchildren. According to one historian, the quantity of schoolbooks circulating in the early republic was so large as to be “almost beyond belief.” But competing books also stressed the Fourth R alongside reading, writing, and arithmetic. There were spellers for Quakers and Lutherans, and primers and catechisms for Anglicans. Dilworth’s hugely popular New Guide was even more theological than Webster’s speller, and as a rule textbooks published in New England accented divinity more than the Cincinnatibased McGuffey franchise. Readers by Charles Sanders, which in some years outsold the McGuffey readers, included, in addition to lessons on “The Bears and the Bees” and “The Cat and the Lobster,” such fare as “God Made All Things” and “The Child’s Prayer.” “The Bible” was the first lesson in Samuel Goodrich’s popular reader. The Franklin Family Primer (1807) included numerous illustrations of Bible scenes, including “Noah’s Ark,” “Moses in the Bullrushes,” and “Moses Smiting the Rock.” And The First Dixie Reader (1868) somehow squeezed into a lesson called “The Frog” not only the fact that it is bad for boys to kill frogs but also this tidbit: that “God made [the frog’s] tongue with glue on it, so he could thus get his food.”137 Among these alternatives to Webster and McGuffey, Richard Gilmour’s Catholic readers are particularly important. Widely used in parochial schools, these readers contained, in addition to such McGuffey staples as “Rip Van Winkle,” such articles as “The Power of the Blessed Sacrament.” Alongside requisite moral lessons on industry, honesty, and prudence, they included more specifically Catholic fare, including teachings on the evils of avarice and the importance of charity to the poor. Popes and saints—Mary the first among them—figured prominently, as did monks, missionaries, and martyrs.138
80
RELIGIOUS LITERACY
These examples, which could be multiplied a hundredfold, lend force to historian Ruth Miller Elson’s claim that “a religious tone is evidence throughout the century” in American primers, spellers, and readers. Even arithmetic texts, she observes in her history of nineteenth-century schoolbooks, taught religious facts—for example, by asking students to calculate how many days had passed “since the birth of Our Savior.” From these schoolbooks children learned that there is one God who created, ruled, and judged the world, and that Americans are God’s chosen people. They also learned that Protestantism was the one true religion and that Roman Catholicism was an antidemocratic invitation to ignorance, immorality, and tyranny. (Catholic schoolbooks had their own prejudices, such as the claim in Sadler’s Excelsior Geography (1878) that Catholicism is the “one true religion.”)139 Sunday School These pious schoolbooks were used in schools, households, and churches. They were also employed in another link in the chain of memory that helped to ward off religious amnesia, namely, the Sunday school, which according to one historian served as “the primary tool of Protestant religious education in the nineteenth century.”140 Today Christian Sunday schools and Jewish Sabbath schools are places where children of congregation members are raised in a given faith. When the Sunday school movement migrated from England to the United States in the 1790s, however, Sunday schools had a very different purpose: teaching working-class children (including many African Americans) how to read. In the 1820s this British model gave way to the modern Sunday school under the auspices of the American Sunday School Union (ASSU), which was founded in Philadelphia in 1824. Now the children of church members made up the student body, and cultivating religious literacy was the mission. This new model, which focused on learning “the leading doctrines of the Bible” through rote memorization and recitation, was an immediate success. By 1832, 8 percent of the nation’s Sunday school age children were enrolled in ASSU-affiliated schools, with much higher numbers in some urban centers (28 percent in Philadelphia), and by 1837 there were roughly one million students in sixteen thousand Sunday schools across the country. One reason for these impressive numbers was the willingness of Sunday schools to enroll female students. Whereas common schools were initially largely for boys, girls constituted the majority of students in
Eden (What We Once Knew)
81
early Sunday schools. Sunday schools were less pluralistic when it came to region, however. Although today’s Bible Belt is in the South, Sunday schools were initially concentrated in the North.141 Sunday schools fostered religious literacy by publishing and distributing religious tracts and by constructing a vast network of libraries, which just before the Civil War accounted for most of the nation’s total libraries and nearly half its total library volumes. The ASSU’s main emphasis, however, was Sunday school instruction. Initially, Sunday school teachers tried to spark a sudden conversion in each student. By midcentury, however, the emphasis shifted to a more gradual process that liberal Protestant theologian Horace Bushnell called “Christian nurture.” Around this same time teachers started downplaying rote memorization of Bible sayings, focusing instead on grasping the meanings of Bible stories. Lessons for Every Sunday in the Year (1864), a popular Sunday school text published by the Methodist Episcopal Sunday School Union (but by no means confined to that denomination) guided students through fifty-two lessons on the Old and New Testaments. This book and its imitators prompted Sunday school book publishers to agree on a uniform lesson plan, which cycled through the same Bible passages each week for seven years, ensuring that Baptists in Texas and Methodists in Iowa were reading the same texts each weekend (though not through the same interpretive lenses). In this way Sunday schools became “a primary avenue for socializing the rising generations into evangelical culture.”142 The growth of common schools in the 1820s and 1830s gave a huge boost to the Sunday school movement. In fact, these two types of schools settled almost immediately into a symbiotic relationship of separate spheres. As common schools and Sunday schools spread, the former focused on basic literacy while the latter emphasized religious literacy. This partnership would eventually have a double effect: divesting Sunday schools of their original mission of teaching literacy to the poor and underprivileged, and divesting common schools of their charge to make good Protestants. In the process, parents and ministers concerned about the religious education of their youth came to see the value added of the Sunday school. Some restorationists (Protestants who wanted the modern church to mimic the New Testament church in all particulars) rejected Sunday schools as, to quote Disciples of Christ founder Alexander Campbell, “hobbies of modern times” and “inventions of men.” But the Disciples of Christ eventually got on the Sunday school bandwagon, and denominations with proud histories of catechesis—notably, Episcopalians and
82
RELIGIOUS LITERACY
Methodists—were big Sunday school supporters from the start. In time, virtually every church in the country would offer Sunday classes to members’ children, and Sunday schools would come to rival common schools as vehicles for cultural transmission.143 Like common schools, Sunday schools taught middle-class morality. They also delivered basic knowledge of evangelical Protestant theology (human depravity, Christ’s atonement, and so on) as well as the distinctive beliefs, practices, and histories of their own Protestant denominations. (Though nonsectarian itself, the ASSU allowed individual Sunday schools to affiliate with particular denominational groups.) In this way Sunday schools became, in the judgment of Anne Boylan, the ASSU’s foremost historian, “the primary locale—outside of the family—for religious indoctrination of Protestant youth.” “A child who had spent any appreciable time in a Sunday school,” Boylan concludes, “would be well equipped to participate in American public life, where references to Bible characters and events were commonplace.”144 Bible and Tract Societies The literacy fostered by Sunday schools and common schools was by no means evenly distributed across the United States. On the western frontier a scattered population made churches and schools scarce and libraries almost nonexistent. Missionaries to the frontier met illiterate pioneers whose encounters with Christianity were rare and fleeting, prompting one missionary to lament in 1815 “the dreadful famine of the written, as well as the preached word of God.” Other evangelists were appalled to find families in Kentucky who “seem as stupid on the subject of religion as the stones of the street,” a Virginia woman who mistook a biography of Washington for a Bible, and a group of young toughs who threw stones at the scriptures for target practice. This famine was particularly worrying in light of the feast of secular novels and other “vicious literature” available on the frontier. Pioneers seemed to expend the limited reading skills they possessed on literature that amused rather than edified. As a result, the masses on the frontier were left “in the grossest darkness and spiritual ignorance,” “destitute” of both learning and religious books.145 Or so went the missionaries’ literature of lament. Some suspicion is warranted here, however, since these lamentations were used to win support for a vast enterprise of evangelical organizations dedicated to bringing true religion to all Americans—to imploring readers on the frontier to “put down that novel!” and study the Bible.146
Eden (What We Once Knew)
83
Beginning in the nation’s first generation, hundreds of nonprofit Bible, tract, and missionary societies sprang up at the local, state, and national levels, each intent on imprinting the stamp of evangelicalism on American civilization. The earliest were local, starting with the Boston-based Society for Propagating the Gospel among the Indians and Others in North-America (SPGNA), which became in 1787 the first missionary society established in the United States. Many were denominational efforts, such as the General Baptist Tract Society. The most enduring and successful, however, were interdenominational associations with national reach—groups such as the American Bible Society (established 1816), the American Tract Society (established 1825), and, as already noted, the American Sunday School Union. As their names imply, these voluntary organizations had different missions. Each was founded, however, on the proposition that faith without knowledge is dead, and all grew into ambitious publishers with vast distribution networks. Together these organizations produced Bibles of all shapes and sizes, tracts that aped the salacious styles of the popular literature of the day, and spiritual literature for children. They collected these volumes in free libraries devoted to stamping out religious ignorance. And they cast them across the continent through a vast distribution network of preachers doubling as itinerant book distributors. In the first decade after its founding the SPGNA distributed an impressive inventory of books: 1566 primers, 969 spellers, 768 New Testaments, 634 Psalters, and 310 Bibles. The Massachusetts Society for Promoting Christian Knowledge, which upon its founding in 1803 became the first US voluntary association devoted to religious publishing, had by 1815 distributed 30,350 tracts and 8,224 books. By the 1830s, however, such societies were counting their output in the millions. The American Tract Society, for example, was pumping out five million tracts annually, leading some enthusiasts to dream of placing a tract in the hands of each and every American. This would prove to be an impossible dream, but America’s Bible and tract societies did create, as historian David Paul Nord argued, “the first genuine mass media in America.”147 College The last of the six links in the chain of memory that fostered religious literacy in the colonial and early national eras was the college. Among the generation of immigrants that arrived in New England before 1646 were one hundred men with Cambridge degrees and thirty-two with degrees
84
RELIGIOUS LITERACY
from Oxford. Of these men, ninety-eight served as ministers. So it should not be surprising either that New Englanders valued higher education or that they understood the college to be, in the words of Jonathan Edwards (who would later serve as Princeton’s president), “nurseries of piety.”148 America’s first three colleges—Harvard (established 1636), William and Mary (1693), and Yale (1701)—were all founded primarily to educate clergy, and each emphasized the Fourth R. Yale was dedicated to the “upholding and propagating of the Christian Protestant religion,” and William and Mary was at its founding “a seminary of ministers of the gospel.” At Harvard, where the vast majority of the library’s titles were works in divinity, faculty taught students not only “to know God and Jesus Christ” but also to understand Jesus as “the only foundation of all sound knowledge and learning.” Recipients of Harvard’s AB degree had to be “able to read extempore the Pentateuch, and the New Testament in Latin out of the Original Tongues”—a good thing since most Harvard graduates through the late seventeenth century went on to become Protestant ministers.149 By the Revolution, there were nine degree-granting colleges (not counting various academies offering similar instruction), and none of them even contemplated education as a secular endeavor. Instruction in these colleges stressed, according to historian Lawrence Veysey, “discipline and piety,” and religious concerns remained paramount in American higher education well into the nineteenth century.150 Most colleges had denominational ties, and their courses inculcated without apology the specific theological and liturgical commitments of their particular denominations. Students were required to attend chapel services, and campus revivals were often stirred up by college presidents, who were typically Protestant ministers themselves. Faculty (also top-heavy with Protestant clergy) offered a fixed curriculum focused on what we now call Classics. Following Noah Webster, who understood the goal of education to be “the preservation and transmission of the wisdom of the ages,” faculty at these denominational colleges sought less to create new knowledge than to pass down the sacred truths bequeathed to them from antiquity.151 In addition to Latin, professors taught Hebrew and Greek, with an eye to equipping students to read the Old and New Testaments in their original languages. The standard curriculum culminated in a yearlong course in moral philosophy typically taught by the college president. This course, which often included “evidences of Christianity,” aimed to gather the disparate knowledge accumulated in prior college courses into a coherent theological vision. Its
Eden (What We Once Knew)
85
ultimate goal—and that of higher education generally—was to make learned Protestants. Education reformers challenged this denominational college model throughout the 1820s, arguing (among other things) that some theological and philological instruction needed to give way to new subjects and that a preoccupation with something akin to theological correctness was impeding advances in science. But Protestant theology remained a staple of higher education long after it was run out of public schools. The old college paradigm, which favored teaching over research and Greek and Latin over geology and geography, triumphed in the influential Yale Report of 1828, which argued for the retention of classical language training on the basis of “an imperative obligation to read and know the Scriptures in their original simplicity and purity.” The ministry remained the most popular career choice for college graduates into the late 1830s, and well beyond the Civil War private colleges continued to exude a Protestant ethos. Public colleges and universities did too. In fact, as historians Jon Roberts and James Turner have observed, state institutions were if anything more explicitly theological than their private counterparts “since they answered to electorates deeply suspicious even of Catholics, much more of outright unbelievers.” As late as 1905 a study of religion at state universities would conclude that these institutions were “more intensely and genuinely Christian than the average community.”152 Toward a New Religion In this brief history of how households and churches, schools and Sunday schools, spellers and primers, voluntary associations and colleges conspired to plant religious knowledge in Americans, we see both the flowering of religious literacy and the seeds of its demise. Children who read, memorized, and recited passages in the New England Primer, Webster’s spellers, and the McGuffey readers learned much about the basic beliefs and practices, stories and heroes of Protestant Christianity. But by the early nineteenth century the acids of nondenominationalism were starting to erode religious content. Sectarian Protestantism (most conspicuously of the Calvinist variety) was starting to give way to nonsectarian Protestantism. With this shift came a tendency to emphasize morality since it was in the domain of ethics that Protestants of different denominations could agree. As it became imperative to get along (at least with other Protestants), theology started giving ground to morality. If the point of the New England Primer was to teach children that they were sinners and that Jesus
86
RELIGIOUS LITERACY
died to save them from their sins, the point of the later McGuffey readers was to teach children that God wanted them to work hard, save their money, tell the truth, and avoid alcohol. Their core text was not Paul’s “for by grace are ye saved through faith” (Ephesians 2:8) but the Ten Commandments. Already Americans were inaugurating a new form of religion—less sectarian, less doctrinal, more emotional, and more moralistic. “Little children, you must seek,” one reader put it, “rather to be good than wise.”153 In other words, we had already taken one giant step toward the contemporary era in which morality is the essence of religion and the term Christian connotes opposition to abortion and gay marriage rather than faith in the incarnation and the redemption—an era in which having a relationship with Jesus is more important than knowing what he actually did, in which believing in the Bible matters more than knowing what the Bible has to say. More than the forces of secularism, it was this sort of religion that would do religious literacy in.
Four
The Fall (How We Forgot)
H
istorian Martin Marty tells a story about a heated debate at an early Methodist convention concerning whether Methodists should build seminaries to educate clergy. Rising to oppose the idea, one bishop said that faith was strongest in a soul unfettered by book learning. If pressed, the bishop added, he would opt any day for a preacher without education over a preacher without passion. A critic then asked the bishop whether he was thankful for his own ignorance, to which the bishop unabashedly answered yes. “Whereupon,” Marty writes, “the critic moved that the convention sing a Te Deum, since the good bishop had so much for which to be thankful.”154 This story encapsulates the nineteenth-century battle inside American Christianity between piety and learning—a battle that learning lost. In Marty’s telling the bishop plays the fool. But for many American Christians, then and today, willingness to be a fool for Christ is a mark of true faith. Christianity is about loving Jesus; it does not require knowing much of anything at all. How did this happen? How did religious ignorance become a sign—perhaps the sign—of genuine piety? And what lessons might this story of our fall into religious illiteracy hold for Americans today? Answers to these questions must begin with the fact that the divorce of piety and learning is nothing new. In the early 1950s Dean O. R. Sellers of Chicago’s McCormick Theological Seminary was lamenting that demand for such practical subjects as home economics, shorthand, and shop had edged Bible courses out of high schools. College professors used to be able to presume the average incoming student would possess “an elementary acquaintance with the Book of Books,” Sellers complained. “He would have learned the books of the Bible in order, the Lord’s Prayer, the Twenty-Third Psalm, and the Ten Commandments. . . . He would
88
RELIGIOUS LITERACY
have heard about Adam and Eve, Cain and Abel, David and Goliath, Joseph and Mary, Peter and Paul. At Christmas and Easter he would have learned about the birth, crucifixion, and resurrection of Jesus. . . . he would know that Moses led the children of Israel from Egypt, that Daniel was put into the den of lions, and that there were twelve apostles.” But then a “great wave of secularism” washed away our collective memories of these Bible heroes and their exploits.155 When did that wave wash over America? And what seismic shocks caused it to crest and to crash? The conventional wisdom is that the Supreme Court broke the chain of memory that is religion when it banned prayer and devotional Bible reading in the public schools in the early 1960s. This has long been the complaint of leaders of the Moral Majority and the Christian Coalition, pressure groups that owe their genesis in large measure to the one-two punch of Engel v. Vitale (1962) and Abington v. Schempp (1963). But Sellers wrote his lamentations in 1951, and at least as early as the turn of the century a push by progressive reformers for greater attention to vocational education, athletics, and “life adjustment” skills had edged religion and many other traditional academic subjects out of public school curricula. As has been noted, religious faith and religious knowledge were inseparable in the colonies and the early republic. America was, as the Great Awakening’s grand itinerant George Whitefield once put it, “an excellent school to learn Christ in.” But early Americans didn’t just know Jesus; they knew the Sermon on the Mount (often by heart). They believed, as the Reverend John Lathrop of Boston’s Second Church wrote, that “the connexion between knowledge and faith, is such, that the latter cannot exist without the former.” And they were convinced, as historian David Paul Nord put it, that “genuine religion was not about miracles, enthusiasm, direct revelation, human will, or even uninformed faith; it was about knowledge, learning, and reading the word.” All that changed, however, with the rise to public power in the early nineteenth century of a new form of Protestantism called evangelicalism. By the end of that century a lack of elementary knowledge of Christianity would constitute evidence of authentic faith. What for generations had been shameful—religious illiteracy—would become a badge of honor in a nation besotted with the self-made man and the spirit-filled preacher.156 Long-term trends are always the products of multiple causes, so it is often difficult to track their genesis with any precision. The story of the decline of religious literacy is particularly difficult to reconstruct. Even today we do not routinely survey Americans on their religious IQs. And
The Fall (How We Forgot)
89
we certainly did not do so in the colonial, antebellum, or Progressive eras. Historians of American religion know much about the rise and fall of particular denominations, theological debates, and practices such as preaching and hymn singing, but we know very little about the rise and fall of religious knowledge—what Americans knew and when they knew it. Still, many of the causes of our collective Fall into religious illiteracy are plain, as are some of the villains. And here the evildoers were not, as one might expect, diabolical secularists conspiring to banish religion from the public square. Rather, they were well-meaning Protestants, Catholics, and Jews intent on rescuing religion from the acids of modernity. This story—a tale of the demise of religious knowledge at the hands of people of faith—begins with a catalytic event in American religious, cultural, and social history called the Second Great Awakening. The Second Great Awakening Like the Great Awakening of the 1730s and 1740s, the Second Great Awakening was a widespread religious renewal that produced powerful individual conversions, explosive church growth, and epochal cultural changes. It began at the turn of the nineteenth century with a series of revivals that burned hottest on the southern and western frontiers, most notably at a camp meeting held in 1801 in Cane Ridge, Kentucky—an event that Methodist evangelist Peter Cartwright later termed the greatest outpouring of the Holy Spirit since the biblical day of Pentecost. In these revivals the Puritans’ harsh insistence that God had predestined each of us before birth to either heaven or hell gave way to the gentler Arminian conviction (named after John Calvin’s Dutch critic Jacobus Arminius) that all are free to accept or reject the saving grace of Jesus and so to play a part in determining their eternal destinies. Equally important, the genteel revival style of colonial New Englanders (heartfelt but orderly) capitulated in these revivals to orgies of sobbing, shrieking, shouting, and other spiritual ecstasies. (“When I see a man preach,” Abraham Lincoln once said, “I like to see him act as if he were fighting bees.”) Out of the egalitarian impulses of Jacksonian America—an America in which someone as woodsy as Andrew Jackson could grow up to be president—the irreverent reverend was born, and he quickly learned to offer his audiences (and audiences they were) the potent mix of religion and entertainment we would later come to associate with American revivalism. Thanks to the efforts of Charles Grandison Finney, the lawyer turned evangelist who argued the case for Christ (and lent to US revivalism a
90
RELIGIOUS LITERACY
variety of potent “new measures”), America’s Pentecost spread like wildfire in urban areas of upper New York State beginning in the 1820s, prompting observers to refer to these areas as the “Burned-Over District.” Not until the great revival in Rochester, New York, in the winter of 1830–31 did this spiritual fire consume its fuel.157 By the end of the 1830s America’s religious landscape had assumed its current shape. The population had been rapidly Christianized, but Christianity itself had become extraordinarily diverse. Evangelicalism had supplanted Puritanism as the dominant religious impulse, thanks in no small measure to the willingness of evangelicals to mix the ways and means of revivalism with those of republicanism. Methodists and Baptists—both prorevival groups—had displaced such eighteenth-century stalwarts as Congregationalists and Anglicans atop the denominational pecking order. With the disestablishment in Connecticut and Massachusetts of Congregationalism—“protestant popedom,” Thomas Jefferson called it—in 1817 and 1833, respectively, the free-exercise promise of the First Amendment had been extended to citizens within their respective states. And as Roman Catholic immigration rose and a dizzying array of new religious options (including spiritualism, Adventism, Mormonism) fueled the “antebellum spiritual hothouse,” religious competition became fierce, not just among the Protestant denominations but between Protestants and Catholics too.158 As the nation became both Christian and religiously plural, the links in the chain of memory that once bound the minds of Americans to the truths of the Christian tradition began to fracture. Ironically, the United States became a nation of forgetters at the same time it became a nation of evangelicals. And more than any other single event, the Second Great Awakening aided and abetted our national amnesia. True, revivalism made Christians. In fact, it made converts by the millions. Church membership rates more than doubled from roughly 17 percent of Americans at the start of the Revolution to 34 percent in 1850. And for the first time the Christian story traveled deep into the heart of the African American population. Earlier efforts, chiefly by Anglicans, to convert slaves through “a lengthy process of learning, memorization, and moral testing” had largely failed, probably because the religion slaves were being asked to adopt bore almost no resemblance to West African religious traditions. Now, however, God could be known in spirit as well as in truth—in sudden conversions, in ecstatic worship, in call-and-response preaching, and in shouting and song.159 Many of those who came to Jesus during the Second Great Awakening went on to learn the basics of the Christian faith. Religious literacy
The Fall (How We Forgot)
91
expanded among African Americans, who came to see the story of Israel’s exodus from bondage to freedom as their own story and to praise Jesus for taking onto the cross both the world’s sins and their own suffering. Presbyterians and Congregationalists remained faithful not only to Jesus but also to their traditions of learning. But for the most part the Christians made during and after in the Second Great Awakening were Christians of a very different sort from those who populated colonial and early America, since during the early nineteenth century religious faith and religious knowledge began for the first time to march to different drummers. A revolution in print technology spurred explosive growth in sectarian religious periodicals such as Calvinist Magazine and Arminian Magazine, which fomented bitter religious controversies—between Calvinists and Arminians over salvation, between Unitarians and Trinitarians over Jesus, and between Mormons and their angry opponents over ongoing revelation—which in turn kept Christian teachings on the minds of ordinary Americans. These new technologies also put inexpensive denominational tracts, not least a massive Baptist Library, into the hands of the masses. As they read and debated these magazines and tracts, Americans learned much about the beliefs and practices of their denominations and of Christianity itself. But gradually nondenominational uniformity eroded the particularities of denominational life. What church historian Nathan Hatch described as the “the most centrifugal epoch in American church history” succumbed to centripetal pressures.160 Among these pressures was the vast network of nondenominational voluntary associations constituting the Benevolent Empire. One of the key features of American denominations had long been their neighborliness: their willingness to see other denominations less as rivalrous sects (the European model) than as friendly competitors. In the wake of the Second Great Awakening, this denominational ideal gave birth to the allied notion of nondenominationalism, which accented not so much competition as cooperation. Now Presbyterians and Methodists, Baptists and Congregationalists joined hands to form a united evangelical front dedicated to transforming the United States into a Christian civilization and to stamping the imprint of that civilization on the wider world. Most of these organizations—the American Anti-Slavery Society, the American Temperance Society, the American Bible Society, the American Tract Society, the American Sunday School Union, the American Home Missionary Society, and so on—foreswore any denominational affiliation. In order to accomplish their goals, the Protestants who staffed and led these groups
92
RELIGIOUS LITERACY
agreed to disagree when it came to doctrine. Why argue about infant baptism when there were drunks to sober up and “heathens” to save? So the American Bible Society published scripture “without note or comment,” and the literature distributed by the American Tract Society and the American Sunday School Union steered around such contentious matters as the Trinity, Holy Communion, and Judgment Day. Hymns also reinforced a nondenominational Protestant identity by stressing the shared experience of Jesus, a common morality, and what church historian Stephen Marini termed a “core of consensus beliefs”—a core, it might be noted, that seemed to be shrinking by the day.161 For the first half of the nineteenth century, the pendulum of American Christianity swung back and forth between denominational specificity and nondenominational vagueness—between the thirty-three-volume Baptist Library and the more irenic forty-five-volume Evangelical Family Library. After the Civil War, however, many Americans grew tired of theological controversies. Desperate for union in church as well as state, they gravitated—in churches, schools, and colleges—toward a lowestcommon-denominator faith. If the measure of such developments is growth, then this one is to be applauded, since over the course of the century American Protestantism boomed and missionaries expanded its footprint worldwide. But this growth came at a cost, and once again the cost was religious literacy. Dimensions of the Sacred Philosopher Ninian Smart argued that the world’s great religions exhibit at least six important family resemblances, which he terms “dimensions of the sacred.” These dimensions are: the doctrinal/philosophical, the narrative/mythic, the ritual/practical, the experiential/emotional, the ethical/ legal, and the social/institutional. Different religions exhibit these dimensions in varying degrees. In fact, the inclination of believers to emphasize some dimensions while downplaying others—Confucianism’s focus on ritual, for example, or Orthodox Judaism’s on law—is one way to tell religions apart. As we have seen, Puritanism celebrated the doctrinal and experiential dimensions of religion. Puritans emphasized both experiencing the “new birth” and learning true doctrine. Jonathan Edwards, the grand synthesizer of Puritan thought, saw the Christian life as a dance of the head and the heart, the intellect and the emotions.162 Historians disagree about the nature of the relationship between Puritanism, which dominated the American religious landscape in the seven-
The Fall (How We Forgot)
93
teenth and eighteenth centuries, and evangelicalism, which dominated from the early nineteenth century forward. These two religious impulses certainly share much, not least a reverence for the Bible and an emphasis on conversion. But when it comes to the intellect and education, Puritanism and evangelicalism are nearly polar opposites. If, as Smart suggested, you can differentiate one member of the religion family from another by the religious dimensions it most comfortably occupies, Puritanism and evangelicalism are distant relatives. Puritans went to great lengths to spread religious literacy. So did the evangelicals who populated the Bible, tract, and Sunday school organizations of the Benevolent Empire. But over the course of the nineteenth century evangelicals learned to ignore religious learning. Evangelicals did more than that, however. In the name of heartfelt faith, unmediated experience, and Jesus himself, they actively discouraged religious learning. To evangelicalism, therefore, we owe both the vitality of religion in contemporary America and our impoverished understanding of it. Here evangelicalism was assisted, however, by liberal Protestantism, a movement that sought to accommodate Christianity to modern circumstances. Although liberal Protestants disagreed with evangelicals on such matters as the inspiration of the Bible, they shared with their antagonists an emphasis on morality and experience that also tended to shut doctrine out. There are many ways to tell this story of Americans’ descent into pious ignorance. Here I focus, first, on schools and colleges and, second, on churches. Between the Second Great Awakening and World War I, schools and colleges learned to forget about religion. As educational institutions secularized their curricula, the burden of disseminating knowledge about religion fell on the churches. But this burden shifted just as American Protestants were moving away from Christianity’s doctrinal dimension, emphasizing experience and ethics instead. Nonsectarianism and the Public Schools Today Americans often think of public schools as bereft of religious influences. But when public schools spread throughout New England during the late eighteenth century and across the nation over the course of the nineteenth, religion was a daily presence. Dutch Reformed schools in New York, Presbyterian schools in the Carolinas, and Quaker and Lutheran schools in Pennsylvania were religious through and through; the Bible was their core text. But public schools emphasized faith too. Early superintendents were typically Protestant ministers, as were many pioneering
94
RELIGIOUS LITERACY
advocates of public education. Their schools promulgated, in the words of historian Lawrence Cremin, “a Christian paideia that united the symbols of Protestantism, the values of the Old and New Testaments, Poor Richard’s Almanack, and the Federalist papers.”163 From the beginning, however, reformers struggled over how to make “common schools” truly common in a country that was so religiously diverse. The goal of public education was to produce good citizens. Because it was widely believed that morality depended on religion, it was assumed that the schoolhouse would have to stand on a religious foundation to accomplish this aim. But what might such a foundation look like in a nation with so many different kinds of Protestants, to say nothing of a burgeoning Catholic population? How to inculcate religion without dividing religious groups against one another and thereby undermining the unifying purpose of these “common schools,” their charge to transform children of all religions and ethnicities into Americans—to make e pluribus unum, “out of many, one”? The solution that emerged, early in Massachusetts and Ohio and eventually nationwide, centered on the concept of generic religion, which was variously described as “nonsectarianism” or “nondenominationalism.” This solution, which is now widely (and erroneously) used in Supreme Court decisions, rests on one core conceit, namely, that lurking inside the particular expressions of different religious groups was what education reformer John Dewey would later call a “common faith.” Drawing on this concept, public school advocates argued that though the First Amendment prevented them from preaching any particular form of Protestantism—Methodism, for example, or the Calvinism of the New England Primer—it did not prohibit them from inculcating Protestantism in general. As long as the schoolhouse faith they were preaching was “nonsectarian,” public school teachers could preach it unimpeded. This ideal first became a reality in 1827, when Massachusetts passed a law prohibiting use of public funds to buy any schoolbooks “which are calculated to favour any particular religious sect or tenet.” This law was the nation’s first to restrict public support for sectarian religious instruction, and it was intended, it should be emphasized, not to kill the teaching of religion in public schools but to preserve it.164 Two contradictory impulses fueled this nonsectarian ideal. The first was tolerance, more specifically the desire of Protestants of competing denominations to get along with one another in order to pursue common projects. As has been noted, most of the voluntary associations of the Benevolent Empire were not affiliated with any one denomination. Inside
The Fall (How We Forgot)
95
these interdenominational groups, Protestants downplayed doctrinal differences in order to work together for abolitionism or temperance or missions. Tolerance, in short, would get things done. The second impulse behind the nonsectarian ideal was intolerance, since the comity in these circles was by no means extended to Roman Catholics. In fact, one of the main motivations underlying the evangelicals’ nondenominational efforts was the desire to present a united front against what many saw as a worrying wave of Roman Catholic immigration. Protestant leaders routinely described Catholicism as a form of brainwashing incompatible with liberty, insisting that the Vatican’s refusal to allow Catholics to interpret the Bible and church teachings for themselves amounted to spiritual tyranny. How better to do battle with the Catholic menace and uphold the principle of freedom of conscience than to speak in one voice against the “malignant, social, anti-Christian poison” that was popery?165 The key figure behind the nondenominational or nonsectarian solution to the problem of religion in public education was Horace Mann, the education reformer (and, not coincidentally, Unitarian) who served as the secretary of the Massachusetts Board of Education from its founding in 1837 until 1848. More than anyone else, Mann determined the role religion would play in the nation’s public schools. Mann’s approach to universal education (which now included girls as well as boys) focused on the common school—the “sacred temple of education,” as he called it—and featured five interlocking elements. The first was to teach piety, which in his view was necessary for cultivating virtue, which was in turn necessary for preserving social order and safeguarding democracy. The second was to limit religious education to those doctrines on which all Christians could agree, “leaving to the family, the pulpit, and the Sabbath School, that more full doctrinal instruction which parents may desire.” This meant excluding from public schools texts that took a specific position on controversial theological questions. “In every course of studies, all the practical and perceptive parts of the Gospel should be sacredly included,” Mann wrote, “and all dogmatical theology and sectarianism sacredly excluded.” The third was to locate this classroom piety in the moral (as opposed to the doctrinal) truths of the Christian tradition— to teach what sociologist Nancy Ammerman would later describe as “Golden Rule Christianity.” The fourth was to ground this shared morality in the King James Bible, which was to be read in public schools (as it had been published by the American Bible Society) “without note or comment.” The fifth was to provide some cover for what might otherwise
96
RELIGIOUS LITERACY
be seen as secular drift by allowing for three religious rituals in the public schools: prayer, hymn singing, and devotional Bible reading.166 Some of the problems with this approach will be immediately apparent to twenty-first-century readers. The most obvious is that this ostensibly generic schoolhouse faith is nothing of the sort. What Mann called “the religion of heaven” and “the religion of the Bible” is plainly Christian.167 Teachers taught the Bible, after all, not the Quran or the Tao Te Ching. So this supposedly common faith excluded on the face of it Muslims, Hindus, and Buddhists, to say nothing of agnostics and atheists. Another problem, apparent to many nineteenth-century observers, was that Mann-style nonsectarianism also excluded Roman Catholics and Jews and, as we shall see, many evangelicals too. Bible Wars Roman Catholic opposition to this schoolhouse piety took many forms, including protests against the anti-Catholic diatribes printed in many popular schoolbooks. But Catholic protests homed in on the Bible. The article the here is instructive, since Mann’s approach assumed that there was one Bible rather than many (or that Christians could at least agree on which one their children should read). Neither assumption was true. By the 1830s there were already many Protestant Bibles, though popular devotion to the King James Version largely masked that problem. The real rub was that Catholics had their own version, the Douay-Rheims, which was based not on ancient Hebrew and Greek manuscripts (as Protestant Bibles were) but on the Latin Vulgate translation of the fourth and fifth centuries. Catholics also maintained, then as today, that scripture must be read communally—in the light of church traditions. So their translation included doctrinal guidance in the form of footnotes and commentaries. No wonder Catholics viewed the insistence that the Bible be read “without note or comment” as anything but neutral. These tensions simmered before exploding in the Bible wars of the midnineteenth century. The most visible battlefield in these early culture wars was Philadelphia, where Protestant-Catholic riots over whose Bible would be read in public schools left over a dozen people dead and Catholic churches burned to the ground in 1844. But some of the best arguments on both sides of the question came from New York City’s public school controversy of the early 1840s.168 There a privately run, nondenominational Protestant organization called the Public School Society ruled the roost, doling out public funds and, in keeping with its mandate
The Fall (How We Forgot)
97
“to inculcate the sublime truths of religion and morality contained in the Holy Scriptures,” seeing to it that students in its city’s schools were reading a Protestant Bible, reciting Protestant prayers, and singing Protestant hymns.169 Buoyed by a call from Governor William Seward for the “establishment of schools in which [children] may be instructed by teachers speaking the same language with themselves and professing the same faith,” Catholics requested funds from the Public School Society for precisely that purpose. After their request was denied, Catholic bishop John Hughes argued that the city’s supposedly nonsectarian schools were actually Protestant and anti-Catholic. According to Hughes, the King James Bible used as a reader in these schools was a sectarian book, and popular history textbooks slandered Catholicism as tyrannical. The American Bible Society responded with a petition insisting that the Bible “is a book peculiarly appropriate for use in common schools, and cannot be excluded from them without hazard both to our civil and religious liberties.” American Protestant Vindicator, a nativist newspaper, found the Catholic position preposterous. Catholics, it editorialized, “demand of republicans to give them funds to train up their children to worship a ghostly monarchy of vicars, bishops, archbishops, cardinals, and Popes!”170 After it became plain that public funds for Roman Catholic parochial schools would not be forthcoming—to do so, the Public School Society determined, would create an “unholy alliance” between church and state—Hughes changed his tack, arguing (with the support of New York City’s Jewish leaders) for legislation that would mandate completely secular, Bible-free public education.171 Soon many evangelical Protestants were sailing the same course. While Catholics attacked “nonsectarian” religion in the schools as too specific, these Protestants saw Mann-style faith as too generic—the sort of watered-down religion “that infidels might believe, and sensualists applaud.” The best plan was to teach children the one true faith, but if that was not legally permissible or politically feasible then it was better to secularize the public schools than to let Mann’s Unitarianism prevail. In this way, as legal scholar Philip Hamburger argued, “the idea of separation of church and state first attracted widespread support and even national attention.”172 The real mistake Mann and his supporters made was assuming that religion could be made generic. It cannot. Just as it is not possible to speak language in general (at any given moment, you have to pick one), it is not possible to inculcate religion in general. That is because religion
98
RELIGIOUS LITERACY
in general does not exist; all that we have are specific religious expressions. To put the matter more concretely, those who want to teach about religion have to decide which scripture(s), if any, students are going to read, in which translation(s), and with (or without) which commentary. Mann’s Catholic critics understood this. So did many Protestants. In fact, some of Mann’s angriest opponents were evangelicals who saw no difference between Mann’s Unitarianism and his ostensibly generic schoolhouse faith. What sort of Christianity, one critic asked, does not teach the “supernatural scheme of salvation,” including “the doctrines of election and predestination” and the “perseverance of the saints”? Or, as another put it, religious instruction in the public schools was being reduced under Mann to “the vague transcendentalism of our poetical moralists.” You cannot simultaneously keep real religion in the public schools, these critics argued, and keep sectarianism out of it.173 In 1869 and 1870 Cincinnati’s board of education voted to outlaw hymn singing, Bible reading, and religious education from its public schools. By this time Roman Catholics were America’s largest denomination, and once again high dudgeon ensued. Most Protestants argued the old saw of a common religion for the common schools; in a Harper’s Weekly cartoon dated March 19, 1870, Thomas Nast depicted Pope Pius and his Catholic clerics firing an “ecclesiastical canon” at a public school. Meanwhile, a coalition of Jews, freethinkers, Catholics, and a few evangelicals insisted (as Hughes had earlier) that nonsectarian religion was a chimera—that, in a city as diverse as this commercial hub of the West, inculcating religion in public school students could only undermine the public schools’ mission to unify the populace.174 In the end the Cincinnati school board withdrew the King James Bible from the curriculum and the secular model triumphed. Godless Schools Bible wars in Philadelphia, New York, Cincinnati, and other cities produced four important results. The first was that it became nearly impossible to discuss religion in most public schools. Increasingly, superintendents and school committees came under pressure to cede the topic of religion to Sunday schools, and increasingly teachers and administrators succumbed to that pressure. As early as the 1840s the General Assembly of the Presbyterian Church was reporting that “the common school system is rapidly assuming not a mere negative, but a positively
The Fall (How We Forgot)
99
anti-Christian character.” By the start of the Civil War public schools were not quite “as godless as a steam engine” (as one wag in Cincinnati quipped), but the subject of religion had largely vanished from public school curricula.175 In 1875 James Blaine, a Republican congressman from Maine, inspired by an 1855 Massachusetts law banning state support for sectarian (read: Roman Catholic) schools, introduced a constitutional amendment to outlaw the flow of tax dollars to schools “under the control of any religious sect.”176 The Blaine Amendment, as it came to be called, was a stealth attempt to preserve Protestantism in the public schools. It passed overwhelmingly in the House but lost by a few votes in the Senate. It lived on, however, in the laws and constitutions of dozens of other states, which passed Blaine-style language banning state funding for sectarian textbooks, sectarian instruction, and sectarian schools. Some schoolbooks, such as the popular McGuffey readers, continued to reprint Bible passages, but schoolbooks for the most part lost their theological swagger. References to animals and children, eagles and flags displaced references to Old Testament prophets and New Testament evangelists. Coverage of such subjects as bookkeeping, sewing, and science edged out theology, which when it did survive became vaguer and vaguer. Later editions of Webster’s speller dropped its famous first lesson (“No man may put off the law of God . . .”). The McGuffey readers were secularized too, bowing to the new gods of patriotism and practicality. While about a third of the lessons in McGuffey’s fourth reader in the late 1830s and early 1840s were religious, little religious content remained after 1850, and the 1879 editions featured only two Bible passages: the Lord’s Prayer and the Sermon on the Mount. By the late nineteenth century a new Catholic archbishop, John Ireland of St. Paul, Minnesota, was lamenting that intramural squabbles between Catholics and Protestants had placed “the nursery of thought,” that is, the public schools, “into the hands of unbelievers and secularists.” And by the early twentieth century historians were writing books with such titles as The Secularization of American Education (1912), which concluded that “a gradual but widespread elimination of religious and church influences from public education” had been afoot “for somewhat over a century.”177 Compensating for this loss was the second outcome of the Bible wars of the midnineteenth century: the consolidation in the public schools of largely vestigial civic rites—hymn singing, praying, Bible reading—that under the newly nonsectarian public school regime had the trappings of religious significance with little actual piety. Because these empty
100
RELIGIOUS LITERACY
ceremonials were typically performed before the start of the school day, they were, as historian R. Laurence Moore observed, literally “extracurricular.”178 And they were intended not so much to transmit religious knowledge as to foster religious feeling. In all likelihood, however, these formalities did little of either. They amounted to little more than a fig leaf covering collective embarrassment over a system that was abandoning religion as a subject of instruction. The third outcome of these Bible controversies was the substitution of morality for religion. At least in the nineteenth century, educators did not give up explicitly on the long-standing conviction that morality needed to stand on the rock of religion in order to be secure. But Americans gradually confused religion with morality and subsumed the former into the latter. The lowest-common-denominator Protestantism once preached in public schools morphed into generic Christianity, then into generic moralism. Shortly after the Civil War the Congregational minister Henry Ward Beecher, the most popular liberal Protestant preacher of his era, said that public schools no longer needed to preach “technical” religion; preaching “morality and true virtue” and “fellowship and common feeling” would suffice. In postbellum McGuffey readers, the Calvinist theology of sin and salvation that pervaded early editions gave way to bland lessons on “a morality of industry, self-denial, sobriety, thrift, propriety, persistence, modesty, punctuality, conformity, and submission to authority.” And such virtues were said to beget not so much salvation as prosperity. Other schoolbooks dumped theology too. “As systematized theology,” historian Ruth Miller Elson wrote in her exhaustive survey of nineteenth-century schoolbooks, “religion almost disappears from the later books, but it always maintains a prominent place with regard to man’s moral behavior. It has become a religion of ethics rather than one of theology.”179 A fourth outcome of the Bible wars was rapid growth in parochial education among Catholics, who continued to insist, first, that education was a parental obligation rather than a state prerogative and, second, that Catholic parents who sent children to public schools were abrogating their sacred duty to raise their children in the one true church. In 1884 a gathering of American Catholic bishops decreed that every Catholic parish support at least one parochial school. By 1895 over 750,000 Catholics were enrolled in some four thousand Catholic schools.180 All this happened during the heyday of the public school movement, as public schooling was migrating out of New England toward the South and the Midwest, and as nationwide enrollment rates were skyrocket-
The Fall (How We Forgot)
101
ing—from just 38 percent of all white children in 1840 to close to 61 percent in 1870. It happened while what education reformer Booker T. Washington called a “veritable fever” for learning was seizing African Americans after the Civil War. To put it another way, just as America’s current system of nationwide public schooling was replacing a patchwork of privately funded dame schools, charity schools, parochial schools, and academies, the focus of education shifted from teaching religious doctrines to inculcating moral character. The great exodus of religion from the minds of American citizens was under way.181 The effects of this exodus remain with us today, notably in our collapsing of religion into “values” and “values” into sexual morality, which in turn functions via an odd sort of circular reasoning as a proxy for religiosity. At least in popular parlance, what makes religious folks religious today is not so much that they believe in Jesus’ divinity or Buddhism’s Four Noble Truths but that they hold certain moral positions on bedroom issues such as premarital sex, homosexuality, and abortion. Nonsectarianism and Higher Education Also contributing to religious illiteracy were developments in higher education that paralleled those in public schools. Here too the nondenominational ideal and the fiction of generic religion chipped away at religious literacy. Here too teaching doctrine yielded to inculcating character. And once again the culprits were not secularists but believers. Higher education resisted secularization longer than the public schools, however, since here the key transformation occurred at the end rather than in the middle of the nineteenth century. In fact, this transformation was not complete until the early twentieth century, when faculty and administrators finally became convinced that it was possible to teach morality quite apart from religion. Historians of higher education have often interpreted these changes as a revolution in which the secular university overthrew the denominational college. For present purposes, however, the site of this shift matters less than its inner workings, which saw (in colleges and universities alike) such values as utility, research, specialization, and professionalization trump the pious preoccupations of the prior model—“its traditionalism, authoritarianism, paternalism.” Perhaps the most important innovation of the new paradigm was the idea that knowledge was something to create rather than something to preserve—that scholarship was about “searching” rather than “conserving.”182
102
RELIGIOUS LITERACY
As early as the 1820s critics of the colleges’ fixed curriculum were arguing that courses of study top-heavy in Latin, Greek, and Hebrew had to make room for such subjects as the natural sciences, history, engineering, and agriculture. Real change on this score waited, however, until the passage of the Morrill Act of 1862 provided financial incentives for higher education in agriculture and other practical subjects, and the Civil War made palpable the importance of science and technology. Initially, college presidents shuffled these subjects off to new schools of their own (agricultural schools, schools of engineering, and so on), but in the last decades of the nineteenth century new topics stampeded into college curricula as electives, and the dusty fixed curriculum was no more. Over the course of the late nineteenth century, faculty fiat gave way to student choice, and the old emphasis on learning content (covering it all) yielded to acquiring certain skills. Some have argued that during this postbellum era, which also saw research emerge as a key mission of the university and specialization as a key characteristic of that mission, science displaced theology as the central discipline in most American universities. According to this view, as freedom of thought became the sine qua non of university life and religious orthodoxy came to be seen as an enemy of that freedom, the study of religion receded so science could proceed. This narrative is not quite right, since character building remained a key aim of American universities and religion remained character’s prerequisite. What really happened on the religion front was a shift from denominational to nondenominational Protestantism; higher education had its Horace Manns too. One such Mann was Charles Eliot, who served as the president of Harvard from 1869 until 1909. Eliot, also a committed Unitarian, instituted a wide-ranging elective system for Harvard undergraduates, which he described as both “an outcome of the spirit of the Protestant Reformation” and “an outcome of the spirit of political liberty.” Eliot believed that “the whole work of a university is uplifting, refining, and spiritualizing,” but he wanted to accomplish that spiritual uplift through electives in literature, science, and the arts rather than mandatory theological instruction.183 Eliot changed Harvard’s motto from In Christi Gloriam (“To the Glory of Christ”) to Veritas (“Truth”) in 1884 and put an end to compulsory chapel in 1886—two reasons evangelist Billy Sunday called him “so lowdown he would need an aeroplane to get into hell.” But Eliot ought to be remembered not for trying to kill religion at Harvard but for trying to save it. Like Mann, he was a liberal Protestant rather than a secularist. “A
The Fall (How We Forgot)
103
university cannot be built upon a sect,” he once wrote, and, according to historian Julie Reuben, “Eliot’s notion of the unsectarian university triumphed” nationwide. “Unsectarianism” became, according to Cornell University’s first president, Andrew Dickson White, the “guiding idea” of higher education reform. During the late nineteenth century Johns Hopkins and Stanford were established on an “unsectarian” basis, and all the great public Midwestern universities—Michigan, Wisconsin, Indiana, Illinois, among them—also began as nonsectarian Protestant institutions. Many colleges founded to train ministers farmed out theological instruction to separate divinity schools and then, in the name of tolerance and pluralism, wriggled away from their roots in Episcopalianism or Congregationalism. Required courses in natural theology and evidences of Christianity were retired. Mandatory chapel services showcased singing over sermonizing before becoming electives themselves. A particularly hard blow to denominational particularity in higher education came in the form of a 1906 decision by the Carnegie Foundation to restrict a generous pension program for faculty to nondenominational institutions. Within a few years of that decision, the denominational college paradigm was dead.184 Establishing Unbelief The modern secular university did not entirely neglect religion as a subject of inquiry; it just turned that subject into one specialization among many—a field that would come to be known as religious studies. As early as the 1850s Bible courses were popping up at American colleges, and they were commonplace by century’s end. This may seem to be a positive trend for partisans of religious literacy, but Bible courses multiplied only because religion was being banished from virtually every other discipline. Under the earlier one-size-fits-all curriculum, all manner of courses with religious content were required of every student. To get a college degree, it was agreed, you needed to be religiously literate. But with the rise of the electives system after the Civil War, learning about the Bible became a take-it-or-leave-it proposition. By the start of the twentieth century the term humanities had acquired its current sense as the home of such humane disciplines as philosophy, art history, classics, and literature (though, it should be noted, not the study of religion). In the process the humanities, which previously had referred more narrowly to the study of Latin and Greek, acquired a new burden: inculcating character in college students. The old capstone courses on
104
RELIGIOUS LITERACY
moral philosophy gave way to introductory courses in Western civilization, literature replaced classics as the “backbone of the humanities,” and the humanities themselves were increasingly described in quasi-religious terms—as carriers of common moral and spiritual sensibilities from generation to generation.185 Whereas the rise of the humanities helped to collapse religion into what we now call spirituality, the key development in this era of the emergent university was the collapse of religion into morality. This had happened earlier in the public schools, when Mann and his minions, determined to make a place for religion in the curriculum, decided that the only religion the common school could abide was a vaguely spiritual morality. In the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries the lords of higher education came to the same conclusion. As enrollments skyrocketed and the United States became a “land of colleges,” far more Catholics and Jews matriculated than ever before, and higher education was confronted with the challenge of religious diversity. Presidents responded to this challenge as school superintendents had decades before—not by banishing religion from their environs but by trying to make it generic. College chaplains jet