Reconfiguring Public Relations
“Conversations constitute realities and reconfiguring PR means changing its conversatio...
53 downloads
1384 Views
899KB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Reconfiguring Public Relations
“Conversations constitute realities and reconfiguring PR means changing its conversations” say McKie and Munshi in this new book, arguing that PR must engage more appropriately with the changing world of the twenty-first century. The authors set out innovative ideas for equipping public relations to respond and to reimagine itself in the light of current major forecasts and trends for uncertain business, environment, and social conditions. Indeed this is the first PR book of its kind to address environmental questions within the context of global business. McKie and Munshi’s project is to situate a transformed PR within the new global economy, offering ethical value beyond the limits of the excellence project. The authors draw from postmodern and postcolonial approaches to reframe cultural relations, PR education, futures, history and professionalism to suggest how PR might be moved from its current insularity and begin contributing to increased environmental responsibility, social justice and global enterprise. This book will be of considerable interest to postgraduate students of public relations and communication management in Europe, Canada, the US, and Asia. It would also be of topical interest to academics, professionals, and strategists in public relations. Dr David McKie is Professor of Management Communication at the Waikato Management School at the University of Waikato in New Zealand. Dr Debashish Munshi is Associate Professor of Management Communication at the Waikato Management School at the University of Waikato in New Zealand. Both have published widely on the subject of public relations.
Routledge advances in management and business studies
1 Middle Managers in Europe Yves Frédéric Livian and John G. Burgoyne
7 HRM, Technical Workers and the Multinational Corporation Patrick McGovern
2 Marketing Apocalypse Eschatology, escapology and the illusion of the end Edited by Stephen Brown, Jim Bell and David Carson
8 The Internationalization of Small to Medium Enterprises The interstratos project Edited by Rik Donckels, Antti Haahti and Graham Hall
3 Relationship Marketing in Professional Services A study of agency–client dynamics in the advertising sector Aino Halinen
9 Neo-Industrial Organising Renewal by action and knowledge formation in a project-intensive economy Rolf A. Lundin, Hans Wirdenius, Eskil Ekstedt and Anders Soderholm
4 Job Design and Technology Taylorism vs anti-Taylorism Hans D. Pruijt 5 Regulation and Organisations International perspectives Edited by Glenn Morgan and Lars Engwall 6 Information Technology, Organisations and People Transformations in the UK retail financial services sector Jeff Watkins
10 Perspectives on Public Relations Research Edited by Danny Moss, Dejan Vercic and Gary Warnaby 11 Resources, Technology and Strategy Edited by Nicolai J. Foss and Paul L. Robertson 12 Telecommunications Regulation Culture, chaos and interdependence inside the regulatory process Clare Hall, Colin Scott and Christopher Hood
13 Organisational Learning in the Automotive Sector Penny West 14 Marketing, Morality and the Natural Environment Andrew Crane 15 The Management of Intangibles The organization’s most valuable assets A. Bounfour 16 Power and Influence in the Boardroom James Kelly and John Gennard 17 Public–Private Partnerships Theory and practice in international perspective Stephen Osborne 18 Work and Unseen Chronic Illness Silent voices Margaret Vickers 19 Measuring Business Excellence Gopal K. Kanji 20 Innovation as Strategic Reflexivity Edited by Jon Sundbo and Lars Fuglsang 21 The Foundations of Management Knowledge Edited by Paul Jeffcutt 22 Gender and the Public Sector Professionals and managerial change Edited by Jim Barry, Mike Dent and Maggie O’Neill
23 Managing Technological Development Hakan Hakansson and Alexandra Waluszewski 24 Human Resource Management and Occupational Health and Safety Carol Boyd 25 Business, Government and Sustainable Development Gerard Keijzers 26 Strategic Management and Online Selling Creating competitive advantage with intangible web goods Susanne Royer 27 Female Entrepreneurship Implications for education, training and policy Edited by Nancy M. Carter, Colette Henry, Barra Ó Cinnéide and Kate Johnston 28 Managerial Competence within the Hospitality and Tourism Service Industries Global cultural contextual analysis John Saee 29 Innovation Diffusion in the New Economy The tacit component Barbara Jones and Bob Miller 30 Technological Communities and Networks International, national and regional perspectives Dimitris G. Assimakopoulos
31 Narrating the Management Guru In search of Tom Peters David Collins 32 Development on the Ground Clusters, networks, and regions in emerging economies Edited by Allen J. Scott and Gioacchino Garofoli
33 Reconfiguring Public Relations Ecology, equity, and enterprise David McKie and Debashish Munshi
Reconfiguring Public Relations Ecology, equity, and enterprise
David McKie and Debashish Munshi
First published 2007 by Routledge 2 Park Square, Milton Park, Abingdon, Oxon OX14 4RN Simultaneously published in the USA and Canada by Routledge 270 Madison Ave, New York, NY 10016 Routledge is an imprint of the Taylor & Francis Group, an informa business This edition published in the Taylor & Francis e-Library, 2007. “To purchase your own copy of this or any of Taylor & Francis or Routledge’s collection of thousands of eBooks please go to www.eBookstore.tandf.co.uk.” © 2007 David McKie and Debashish Munshi All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reprinted or reproduced or utilised in any form or by any electronic, mechanical, or other means, now known or hereafter invented, including photocopying and recording, or in any information storage or retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publishers. British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library Library of Congress Cataloging in Publication Data A catalog record for this book has been requested ISBN 0-203-95663-X Master e-book ISBN ISBN10: 0-415-39408-2 (hbk) ISBN10: 0-203-95663-X (ebk) ISBN13: 978-0-415-39408-6 (hbk) ISBN13: 978-0-203-95663-2 (ebk)
Contents
Acknowledgements 1 Locating the project, the personal, and the geo-politics of publishing Informing situations: space and time from Waikato to Downing Street 2 The personal is political: how do we fit into the reconfiguration project? 5 Locating publication: political economy, theory geography, and edge interventions 8 Limiting textbooks: the case of the creeping fox terrier clone 10 Enlarging the field: on status, textbooks, and terminology 11 Acknowledging antecedents, entertaining ideas, and net gains 13 Postscript that could have been a preface: acknowledging contradictions 15 Progressing the conversation: a brief outline plan of the chapters 17 2 Signs of the times: assessing the present and revisiting the past Vital signs (1): stormy weather and the ecological case for reconfiguration 21 Vital signs (2): equity, democracy, and global (im)balances 24 Vital signs (3): enterprise, markets, and corporate choices 26 Shifting signs: pluralisation and context-relevant PR 28 From pessimism to lines of flight: emotional matters, public diplomacy, and propaganda for peace 31 3 Pluralising theory: academic empires, excellence, and global implications Interpreting symmetry 36
xi
1
19
34
viii
Contents Testing symmetry in two locations: can’t live without it (in PR) and don’t notice it (outside PR) 40 US primacy and the reach of the global 43 Strategic amnesia and empiricism’s empire 44 Beyond the parochial: empires, knowledge, and pluralism 45
4 Moving the settings: multiple diversities and requisite varieties Focusing on the core: photographic metaphors and ethnocentric lenses 49 Controlling the settings: trapped in the time warp of mechanistic models 51 Underexposed films: PR and the phobia of the other 54 The state of the art as a grainy picture: global PR theory and inherent inequalities 56 Freedom beyond Freedom House: towards new flowering democracies 57 Relocating knowledge in PR 59 5 Not enough Said: decolonising PR through postcolonial frameworks The new S-curve: an overview of postcolonial perspectives in communication from Said and Spivak 63 Colonising illusions: an “other” look at Bhopal 66 Continuing the S-curve: insights from Shiva to Shome and Hegde 67 Correcting myopia: diversifying publics and enlarging visions 68 Global relations: emerging situations and changing status 70 Metaphoric lines of flight: trees, tubers, India Shining, and Western PR in the dark 73 6 What’s next (1)? Empowering differences, learning from leadership, and equity in management after In Search of Excellence Leading change after modernity: heretical heroes of the post 77 Downsizing In Search of Excellence (1): metaphor banks, restricted credit, and reality checks 79 Downsizing In Search of Excellence (2): fashionable dismissals and corporate games 82 Exposing excellence: crossover culture and business science 83 Re-fashioning In Search of Excellence: interdisciplinary intertexts Ltd 84
48
61
76
Contents
ix
Non-Western searches: Eastern exposures, continuing contradictions, and the metaphor spectrum 86 Less than excellent: postscript on methodologies and what’s next in leadership 88 Uncertain times: leadership with more emotion and newer science 89 7 What’s next (2)? Accounting for value and returns on the real Accounting for the bottom line (1): discipline, demand, and building value propositions 92 Accounting for the bottom line (2): temptations and transparency costs 96 Accounting for activists: deviant dolls and online culture 97 Environment matters: tilting at windmills and returns on the real 99 8 Questioning professionalism: cover stories, disciplines, and identities Residing metaphors: limited hospitality and ideal homes for professional people 103 Testing identity: marketing ACID for PR 104 Communicated identity: from born in the USA to a Polish pope in Ireland 105 Planning futures: ACID dreams and university premises 107 Marketing matters: intimations of integration, demarcation disputes, and marketing after modernism 109 Competing disciplines: marketing offensives and partial colonisation 112 Community halls and social marketing 114 9 PR history (Ltd): postmodernising empiricism, selling stories, and telling tales Back to the “new” history: from innocence to interests 119 Metaphoric titles: (in)visible imaging, sensuousness, and ventriloquist voicing 120 (Dis)owning the creation myth: determining Darwinism, evolving ethics, and intelligent design 122 Other histories: researching without the US as prototype 126 Inclusive historiography: herstories and voices from below 129
91
102
118
x
Contents
10 Back to futures: losing control and cultivating foresight Deploying foresight: from forecasts to future informed insight 133 Futuring in PR and an economic 9/11? 134 Global opportunities and a brief history of managing alternative futures 136 Imagined projections: catching the currents of change 137 Waving or drowning? Generation MM, poetry, and business 140 Enterprising solutions: the creative class and PR 142 Afterword: context, foresight, and conclusion 144 Bibliography Index
132
146 173
Acknowledgements
It has taken more than seven years for this book to take shape and evolve. More than anything else, it was nurtured by conversations not only between us but also with many other people. These were the conversations that catalysed the aim of reconfiguring public relations to meet the needs of an increasingly diverse and interconnected world and also to be more fun. It would be impossible to acknowledge the contribution of every individual or institution to our project but we are grateful to the Waikato Management School (WMS) for not only providing us with an intellectually stimulating working environment but also supporting us with research funds and wonderfully supportive colleagues. More specifically, in the Management Communication Department (MCom), we have had engaging conversations and raucous laughter with all our fellow MComrades, and acknowledge the department’s talented chairpersons at different times of our project, Ted Zorn and Juliet Roper. We recognise many of our departmental colleagues through our citations to their work in the book. We also thank the many activists and decent organisation communicators who have informed our work as well as our students from whom we have learnt so much. In terms of logistical support, we thank Terry Clague and his team at Routledge for working so efficiently and diligently with us on the production of this book. We also thank the department of Management Communication administrator, Jean Beaton; the computer staff of the Waikato Management School, especially Monica van Oostrom for her help with formatting; and Moira Neho for her assistance in cross-checking references. Among those who have inspired us in many different ways, we specifically acknowledge George Cheney and Bob Heath and also Kirsten Broadfoot, Lars Christensen, David Dozier, Susan Hafen, Vince Hazleton Jnr, Suzanne Holmström, Astrid Kersten, Martha Launzem, Jacquie L’Etang, Steve Mackey, Frances Nelson, Sally Planalp, Nancy Snow, Krishnamurthy Sriramesh, Cynthia Stohl, Gaye Synnott, James Taylor, Gael Walker, Stefan Wehmeier, and Elizabeth van Every. We also gratefully record our thanks to supportive editors Ray Hiebert, James Chesebro, Ted Zorn, and, especially Roslyn Petelin for her belief in our work and providing us with an education in editing.
xii
Acknowledgements
At a personal level: David Above all I gratefully acknowledge my partner, colleague, font of practitioner wisdom, seeker out of innovative new ideas in PR, and sometime writing companion, Margalit, for her support and for accepting the time taken away from other joys, especially in Tel Aviv. My much missed father and mother, James and Winifred, my daughter Anna, granddaughters Abbie and Mhairi Charters, and friends who have all tolerated my frequent absences on this, and other work projects, for years. Also my co-writers: Tom Cockburn, Marie Louise Hunt, Chris Galloway, Kelly Robertson, Vikram Murthy, and Kay Weaver (with special thanks to them for letting me publish some co-authored material under my name), and those who gave exceptional assistance as I was travelling: Kevin Moloney, Alenka Elena, Dejan Vercˇicˇ (also for creating the phenomenon that is BledCom), Israeli academics and friends, Tamar and Jakob Katriel, Nurit Zeitman, Nurit Guttman, Alaya Malach-Pines, Yoram and Pnina Peri, Danny and Michal Arazi, Shlomo and Mena Inbar, Zveika and the Gareen Oz, and my extended Israeli family Doria, Yonathan, Galit, Nimrod, Gilad, Illana, Dana, Ilan, and the kids. Debashish My greatest source of strength and inspiration has been my friend, partner, and colleague, Priya Kurian, who made my transition from a journalist to an academic a smooth and hiccup-free one. I thank her for letting me use her amazing mind as an anvil to shape my ideas on. I also thank my daughters, Akanksha Khwaish and Alya Laaeqa, for their unbridled joy, companionship, and delight in everything I do. A special word of gratitude to my late father, Promil Kumar Munshi, who knew my strengths and weaknesses more than I do myself and who inspired me to follow my instincts; my late mother Aruna Munshi and my late grandmother Latika Munshi for making me who I am; all my uncles, aunts, and members of my dear families in India, both in the Munshi and Kurian clans, for believing in me and standing by me at all times. I am also grateful for the institutional support I have received at different times from the Centre for Aboriginal Economic Policy Research at the Australian National University; the Department of Linguistics and Modern English Language in Lancaster University; the Women, Culture, Development Program at the University of California at Santa Barbara; The Indian Institute of Technology (Madras) and the Chennai Mathematical Institute. For their intellectual support, I thank my colleagues from both journalism and academia, and countless other friends, fellow thinkers, activists, and scholars in not only India and New Zealand but also in Australia, China, France, Germany, Iran, Japan, Pakistan, Palestine, Singapore, Sri Lanka, the UK, and the US. Given the iconoclastic nature of the work, the rider that none of those mentioned in the acknowledgements are responsible for any of the contents applies even more than usual although they may have immensely assisted in the book’s positive features. Some of the chapters in the book are extensive revisions of material pub-
Acknowledgements
xiii
lished previously while some include excerpts of articles we have co-authored individually or jointly with each other or with others. We would like to thank the following publishers for graciously allowing us to reproduce, excerpt, or adapt material, authored or co-authored by us. Elsevier Publishers and Ray Hiebert for drawing on or excerpting from the following articles: McKie, D. and Munshi, D. (2005). Tracking trends: peripheral visions and public relations, Public Relations Review, 31(4), 453–457; Schoenberger-Orgad, M. and McKie, D. (2005). Sustaining edges: CSR, postmodern play, and SMEs, Public Relations Review, 31(4), 578–583; Munshi, D. and Kurian, P. (2005). Imperializing spin cycles: a postcolonial look at public relations, greenwashing, and the separation of publics, Public Relations Review, 31(4), 513–520; and from the following reviews: McKie, D. (2005). Review essay: Globalizing public relations: old wine, new bottles, and good years, Public Relations Review, 31(1), 149–152; McKie, D. (2006). Review of R. Lawniczak (ed.). Introducing market economy institutions and instruments: the role of public relations in transition economies, Public Relations Review, 32(3), 317–318; McKie, D. (2003). L.E.A. liberating expansive authorship or licensing editorial abdication? Review of Thomas J. Mickey, Deconstructing public relations: public relations criticism, Public Relations Review, 29(2), 215–219. The Asia Pacific Public Relations Journal for the following articles: Munshi, D. (1999). Requisitioning variety: photographic metaphors, ethnocentric lenses, and the divided colours of public relations, Asia Pacific Public Relations Journal, 1(1), 39–52; McKie, D. and Hunt, M. L. (2000). Staking claims: marketing, public relations and territories, Asia Pacific Public Relations Journal, 1(2), 43–58. The Australian Journal of Communication and Ros Petelin for drawing on or using excerpts from several articles, including the following: McKie, D., Motion, J., and Munshi, D. (2004). Envisioning communication from the edge, Australian Journal of Communication, 31(3), 1–11; Munshi, D. and McKie, D. (2001). Different bodies of knowledge: diversity and diversification in public relations, Australian Journal of Communication, 28(3), 11–22; McKie, D. (2005). Public relations in Britain: a history of professional practice in the twentieth century, Australian Journal of Communication, 32(2), 127–130. BledCom and Dejan Vercˇicˇ for drawing on and excerpting from a number of papers, including McKie, D. and Weaver, K. (1999). Sheltering public relations: business houses, family homes, and external environments (pp. 50–54). In Vercˇicˇ, D., White, J., and Moss, D. (eds), Public Relations, Public Affairs and Corporate Communications in the New Millennium: The Future. Ljubljana, Slovenia: Pristop Communications and Toledano, M. and McKie, D. (2006). Promoting social integration: a study of media, democracy and public relations over an extended time frame, BledCom 2006, 18–29.
1
Locating the project, the personal, and the geo-politics of publishing
The Muppets dream, aspire, attempt and fail – and they do so unbitterly, humorously, endearingly. We (whose lives and aspirations are not so dissimilar) can both stand the comparison and take heart from their example. (Alan Coren, Editor, Punch magazine, cited in Wedemeyer and Jue, 2002, p. xv)
We certainly see ourselves and, to an extent, people on the planet and in public relations (PR), as having kinship with Coren’s view of the Muppets’ process. There is much that is absurd in the project of this book. First, our ambition is to reconfigure PR to fit with contemporary conditions in ways that can globally catalyse human enterprise and equity. This involves attempting to convey an assessment of the characteristics, challenges, opportunities, tendencies, and potential of the international situation even as it changes day by day (and as knowledge about it expands exponentially). One example of the complexities can be illustrated through our teaching of students from China in a Western academic location. Faced with an everchanging world, these students are forced to negotiate the constant state of flux they find themselves in. Many students go back to China after a year’s study to find their rapidly globalising homeland virtually unrecognisable. Similarly, those who return to study at our university management school find that institution different as Chinese students have rapidly grown to be over one-third of its student population. The academic world is slowly adjusting to these profound changes. In China itself, students are studying PR through US textbooks “translated verbatim into local languages such as Mandarin, without any attempt to align the contents with local environmental contexts” (Sriramesh, 2002, p. 56). PR scholarship and teaching needs to take into account the changing conditions of Chinese students and the changed conditions they are creating. Only a few years ago it was impossible to have an open discussion of Chairman Mao even in International MBA executive classes. Then students would break down in class as they told moving stories of how their parents and grandparents had been devastated by the dictates of the Cultural Revolution. Now such traumatic moments are rare. Currently, more common discussions, relevant to this book, concern the likely usefulness, or not, of Western media and management practices to a
2
Locating the project
nation with a significantly larger growth rate, more authoritarian structures, more government intervention (especially in all forms of media), and extensive ecological degradation. The complexities of globalisation, which we discuss as part of the warp and woof of contemporary life, bring these students into contact with us and with Western PR. The ensuing dialogues help teachers and students alike to learn and to experiment despite their dramatically different frames of what constitutes PR, let alone a civil society. In conditions of such uncertainty and flux, our desire for comprehension can seem like a distant academic echo of the Muppet cycle of dream followed by failure. Although we intend it to have utility, and we make specific suggestions, this book is not intended as any kind of “how to” manual. As in communicating with our students, it is often from the breadth, depth, and diversity of the strategic conversations – to adapt a term from Kees van der Heijden’s (1996) Scenarios: The Art of Strategic Conversation – that realities emerge. That is to say conversations constitute realities, and reconfiguring PR means changing its conversations. For that reason we frequently challenge the content, ideas, and thinkers of the discussions currently forming the field, and introduce fresh subject matter, different theories, and previously unheard voices. In order to create space for these, we contest the tendency for talk in the field to revolve around the gravitational pull of the “Grunigian paradigm” (Moloney, 2006, p. x), although it means taking a few more orbits for the purpose of justifying our case. Deriving the name from its chief originator, James Grunig, the Grunigian paradigm (aka the two-way symmetry movement, or excellence study, or excellence project) has been an overriding voice in PR research, especially since the large International Association of Business Communicators (IABC) grant from 1985, and the subsequent publishing of its results (e.g. Dozier et al., 1995; J. Grunig, 1992a; L. Grunig et al., 2002). Our ambition to enlarge conversations about PR extends beyond the academic. Corporate and government PR can also be made more transparent and accountable, especially when they act in support of ecological degradation, ethnic bias, anti-democratic movements, and unjust business practices. Reconfiguring Public Relations, which emerges from our position as part of a management school committed to sustainability, resituates PR as part of a wider movement towards more regionally and internationally inclusive enterprise foregrounding equity concerns, and environmental and social sustainability. Paradoxically, this will require PR to be more in touch with both the new currents in business globalisation and with the activist and critical voices that challenge that globalisation.
Informing situations: space and time from Waikato to Downing Street In reforming the conversation, a further Muppet-like feature involves location since the heartland of PR is the US. We enact our aspirations in a place far from
Locating the project
3
that action, and, indeed, other major global centres, at Waikato Management School in Hamilton, a small town at the geographical edge of the world in Aotearoa/New Zealand. The peripheral situation brings strengths as well as weaknesses. Nonetheless, Hamilton, a town in the Waikato region, best known for farming and innovation around agriculture, would not be the obvious first choice of a place to produce a book aiming to reframe, reorient, and reconfigure the field in global business terms. In our defence, research confirms the utility of learning from edges in science and elsewhere (Boettcher, 2001). We trust that the local can coalesce with the international to stimulate multiple twigs of growth rather than fixed branches of disciplinary knowledge. We take heart from the disproportionate consequences inherent in the butterfly effect identified in chaos theory. After all, to draw an analogy from Lorenz’ famous meteorological example, if a butterfly flapping its wings in Brazil can cause a tornado off Texas, then words from Waikato might also perturb PR across the other side of the world. A further trajectory of possible absurdity involves both space and time. For the former, we talk as much, if not more, of what is missing, and what might develop, in PR, rather than what is actually there. For the latter, our focus is on future potential, or what Derrida (1994), in relation to democracy, terms “the tocome . . . of an alterity that cannot be anticipated” (p. 65). Because we see the field as intellectually insular and out of touch with advances in other disciplines, we propose ways, sometimes highly speculative, to redress that, and, hopefully, to initiate more interesting conversations on the “to-come” of PR. The field’s insularity is particularly disabling in relation to current global conditions, and so we foreground particular clusters of knowledge that are not common in PR and where we risk exposing our lack of expertise. The aim is not to rush to expose our ignorance but to encourage others, who are better informed, to expand on the knowledge to advance the field. Desirable outcomes would encompass enlarged dialogues between PR insiders and outsiders on the possibilities for practice and research in, say, advances in cognitive neuroscience, or the philosophy of Deleuze and Guattari. Only too aware of our own limitations, we welcome other contributions to identifying important knowledge gaps and to suggesting how to fill them. Another absurdity, or perhaps contradiction, is to try to reconfigure PR as a field to further a more ecologically aware, and socially egalitarian, world through sustainable enterprise. Usual assessments are akin to the view of Jones et al. (2005) on business ethics, that is, it “holds great promise . . . but at the same time it seems compromised to its core” (p. 2). Inside the field, many would question whether PR should intervene with such an agenda; outside the field many would simply laugh and point to the frequent examples of unethical PR practice from global warming, to politics, and tobacco promotion (see Lubbers, 2002). We share such doubts and, as partial response, include activist practice, research, and thinking as major contributors to the conversation. Moloney (2006) talks of a “great Niagara of PR” (p. x) that is too large to be ignored and we extend his metaphor of fluid range to an expanding field of oceanic scale
4
Locating the project
with significant countercurrents. PR is too important to be left to corporate and government practitioners (and academics taking their primary role as serving them); and global publics and other disciplines are too important not to be made aware of what Cutlip’s (1994) still-relevant book title called PR’s Unseen Power. There are already indicators of increased visibility in Britain as public dissatisfaction pushes political communication towards greater transparency. It is visible in the changing agenda of Tony Blair’s early PR adviser turned politician, Peter Mandelson, in his book The Blair Revolution (Mandelson and Liddle, 1996) and his introduction (Mandelson, 2002) to its re-publication six years later. In the first edition, the seven indexed references to public, which ranged from “public appointments”, through “public spending” to “public-private partnerships” (Mandelson and Liddle, 1996, p. 267), excluded PR. Nor had the index any reference to “spin” or “sleaze”. This was not the case in Mandelson’s (2002) introduction to the reprint, The Blair Revolution Revisited (Mandelson and Liddle, 2002): he first reaffirms the central importance of PR, “To succeed, New Labour has to become new New Labour, not because the project and its goals are in dispute, but because in modern politics, maintaining connection with the public is a constant challenge” (Mandelson, 2002, p. xiii). He then responds, in a section ambiguously entitled “Killing ‘spin’ ” (p. xliii), to criticisms of his party’s abuse of PR: The idea of “spin”, that the government simply makes things up or hides the truth is being peddled aggressively by New Labour’s critics. As a result, unjustifiably, ministers are often not believed and the government as a whole is not always trusted. If a politician opens his or her mouth, he or she is accused of “spinning”. Answer a simple question and this is “spin”. Facts are “spin”. Anyone who works for a politician or a minister is a “spin doctor”. Journalists regularly discuss policy in terms of how they are “spun”. (pp. xliii–xliv) We think he protests too much. Nevertheless, while sometimes “more spinned against than spinning” (Cockerell, 2006, p. 52) by the media, Mandelson’s (2002) rueful conclusion on the New Labour project, that “Too much of what the government is doing fails to make an impact because its words are dismissed as spin” (p. xlv), signals the need for higher standards from PR once its unseen power rightly becomes publicly visible and openly debated. The PR-influenced language of the New Labour government also sparked academic criticism from discourse theory that our field would do well to heed. Fairclough (2000) recommends that New Labour move to a greater “honesty” and “away from designing its language quite so much on the basis of market research and focus groups, [and] away from its preoccupation with ‘spin’ and how to say things in ways that will win support” (p. 160). He concludes that “Long term trust cannot be built on this basis”, which, on the contrary, “results
Locating the project
5
in contempt for politics” (p. 160). Held in at least as much contempt as New Labour, PR also needs to rebuild trust through greater honesty and openness. This means greater transparency, and resisting the pull to secrecy from its past when, as late as the 1990s, one of its founding fathers, Edward Bernays, still “sermonized on the invisibility with which public relations experts must, ideally, perform their handiwork” (Ewen, 1996, p. 15).
The personal is political: how do we fit into the reconfiguration project? In advocating greater transparency, we are obliged to practice what we preach. Accordingly, in this book, rather than attempting any “spurious neutrality” (Fairclough, 1989, p. 5), we similarly declare influences shaping our thinking: investigation of social matters is perfectly compatible with committed and “opinionated” investigators (there are no others!), and being committed does not excuse you from arguing rationally or producing evidence for your statements. (p. 5) The life stories of authors are often suppressed in academic books (but see May and Mumby, 2005a), yet the history of every scholar’s personal development – cultural backgrounds, ideological predilections, places of study, theoretical preferences, and life trajectories – impacts on their research projects. Our own trajectories could not have been more different; yet the knowledge gained from these different cultures, educations, and experiences sparked the writing of this book. Accordingly, to acknowledge our interestedness, we offer the following brief backgrounds. David No one in my family attended school beyond the age of 15. This was not that unusual in the children of working class Scots in that era. In retrospect, the catalyst for my academic career came from an unsympathetic schoolteacher. The woman in question pronounced in class to the effect that McKie would never go to university. Inadvertently, she introduced the possibility of university study into my consciousness – albeit more through my stubborn attempt to refute her opinion of me as unfit for advanced study, than for any career or scholarly ambitions. Anyway, I left school to escape such teaching but returned to study as a mature student via night classes and then a postgraduate scholarship. I have now spent around 35 years from student to professor with teaching posts across four continents. Through it all I have retained a critical stance to official educational establishments and a keen desire to assist others who are in similar positions of doubt about their abilities, to still go forward and learn anyway. I remain suspicious of self-elected gatekeepers to knowledge whose pronouncements follow a
6
Locating the project
pattern of excluding or marginalising people unlike themselves. In travelling across Europe while writing this book, I have been gratified by younger scholars who came and thanked me for publishing a piece on the new science and PR (McKie, 2001), which they said helped them resist narrowly positive teachers and supervisors. In seeking a disciplinary home that would make a practical difference to inequality, I have moved across many disciplines, from literature and cultural studies to media and leadership. Rather surprisingly, since most would see its contribution as increasing inequality, I found a publication home in PR. As well as promotional activities for universities, I have been involved outside academia in small scale, or cottage, PR for much of my life in assisting local causes, political organisations, authors, artists, and small businesspeople to make their voices heard in crowded media spaces. I also run an international consultancy based in New Zealand, where my clients include its leading corporations, with a four year development programme with the talented employees of Telecom New Zealand, and five years working on leadership with stimulating Maori health workers as well as assisting responsiveness to Maori in the New Zealand police. The main areas of my business involve action inquiry and research, change management, emotional intelligence, entrepreneurship, leadership, and strategic communication. All of these also inform the writing here, provide some professional background, and help shape my thinking on business. As a former activist I retain sympathy for many of their projects and any examination of history reveals human dissent as one of humanity’s major resources of progressive change and future hope. I have lived long enough to see formerly reviled radicals, including Nelson Mandela, proved right and becoming inspirational world leaders in going against the mainstream until greater justice was attained. For me activists, often engaged in local campaigns that gathered momentum and resulted in significant social change, from the misunderstood Luddites, through the feminist movement, to the Greens of today, have been the dynamo of life-affirming change. I also believe activist PR is not only vital PR but has repeatedly shown itself to be innovative PR. Much of this book draws from activists’ experiences, often gained through considerable personal sacrifice. I salute their efforts and gratefully acknowledge their input (and the liveliness of their writings). Again let us stress that we do not make any claim to be writing a disinterested piece. In fact many of our disagreements with PR work is that it presents itself as impartial, scientific, and universal, rather than influenced by its origins and originators. While generalisations about large nations are dangerous, we know of no US university under the legally embedded guidance “to act as the conscience of society” that covers all New Zealand universities. So, for example, when, in the aftermath of 9/11, Argenti and Forman (2002) express their conscience it can be unashamedly the conscience of American capitalism rather than the American people: Taking a retrospective glance, we could see the foreshadowing of the violence in the increasing verbal attacks on corporate America, especially the
Locating the project
7
anticorporate jamming that floods the Internet and the envy of our freedom and prosperity as seen in the worldwide media. (p. 5) While Adbusters (see www.adbusters.org), and other cyberjammers can be accused of excesses, the allegation that they, and books such as Canadian author Naomi Klein’s No Logo (2000), foreshadowed the violence of Al Qaeda’s World Trade Center attack is unjustified. It is often accompanied by a narrowing of the rest of the world’s disagreements with the US to the simplistic result of “envy” of American freedom and prosperity. Although I taught in Australia for ten years, Britain for six years, Libya for one year, and the US for one year, and neither of us was born here, we are proud to be New Zealand-based academics. That background not only colours our point of view but, as the book goes on to show, it also influences our intellectual allegiances and attitude to power, both within and outside of the academy. Debashish In the scholarly pursuit of research in PR, I have always seen myself as an outsider. Having been a journalist for much of my adult life, I was never entirely at home in either the academy in general or in the discipline of PR in particular. To me, academics were those who worked in their ivory towers, far removed from the issues that confronted “real” people. I also believed that they were largely self-centred beings who wrote treatises for themselves and a small group of people in their inner circles. As far as PR was concerned, I had no doubt that it was all about spinning the truth and obfuscating facts for strategic organisational gain. When David asked me, in the late 1990s, if I would consider doing a paper on PR for an upcoming International Communication Association conference, I looked at him in utter disbelief. “You must be crazy!” I told him. “Well, I am”, he responded and went on to talk me into exploring the discussion of “requisite variety” in mainstream PR literature. Neither of us was clear on the extent of disciplinary coverage of the subject but knew that PR tended to gloss over issues of diversity. My journalistic instincts told me that there was a “story” in this and I jumped headlong into doing the research for the paper. In some ways, being an outsider helps me research and write on issues of diversity. As a Third World academic working in a Western setting, I have come face to face with the physical, emotional, and professional challenges of being what postcolonial scholars call the “other” (see Munshi, 2005a). An acknowledgement of my own status as an “other” has helped me sharpen my focus on perspectives and practices that lie on the margins of established discourse in not just PR, but also communication management in general. It has given me a chance to think about, and draw on, theoretical approaches such as postcolonialism, which had never been applied to these fields of study. My background as a journalist, and my ongoing negotiations with otherness, have together helped me
8
Locating the project
to redefine the notion of publics in PR and reach out to listen to the voices of people who are not even considered publics in PR textbooks. Such people, most notably the poor in the Third World, are bearing the onslaught of so-called development projects but are not in the line of vision of either academics or practitioners in PR. Working on collaborative projects with colleagues in fields as diverse as Engineering, Environmental Studies, Indigenous Studies, Organisational Studies, Political Science, Physics, Public Policy, and Sociology has helped me step out of the sequestered comfort zone of mainstream management discourses. These projects have opened my eyes to the many different realities of people who have to negotiate the undercurrents of power embedded in the dominant discourses of modernisation, be it in the realm of development or science and technology. During my field trips to India, for example, I have been able to see globalisation in its myriad facets. Under the discursive spotlight of the country’s economic progress (see, for example, Ohmae, 2005; Friedman, 2006), the upwardly mobile middle class is choking the roads with late-model cars and traipsing in and out of multi-storey steel and glass malls. Yet the infrastructure has not kept pace with the booming economy and the rising expectations of the people. Far worse, the divide between the rich and the poor has sharply widened even as the safety net that once characterised India is yanked away (see, for example, Sainath, 2006; Hallinan, 2006). While the PR machinery of international corporations, strategically aided by Western journalists, continues to wield the power of representation on behalf of the elites, the poor seem to be getting pushed to the margins. As Cockburn (2005) says, “Even as Friedman hailed India’s Tiger Economy, the country slipped to rank 127 in the UN’s Human Development Index of 2003” (p. 10). Ultimately, for me, if the profitability and success of the PR enterprise depends on the dehumanising or invisibilising of the Third World publics, then the very notion of an ethical PR would be unattainable. Creating PR with a conscience requires Western practitioners, journalists, and academics to work with their non-Western colleagues for a just, equitable, and sustainable world. This book gives us a chance to think through how this can be achieved.
Locating publication: political economy, theory geography, and edge interventions Recently, we were invited by the Review of Communication to undertake a review essay, for which we gratefully acknowledge the generous editorial and intellectual assistance of James Chesebro, on recent PR books in Australia, New Zealand, and the US (McKie and Munshi, 2004). In a mad Muppet moment, we knew it was both impossible to do, and, for the two of us (keen to learn from the comparison and contrast), impossible to resist. The survey foregrounded the major shaping role of the political economy of publishing in theory generation. Put simply, different emphases emerged from different geographies. The US
Locating the project
9
offered “a relative abundance of choice and diversity with specialist books, textbooks, theoretical books, and ‘how-to’ or ‘practical’ manuals” (McKie and Munshi, 2004, p. 279). In sharp contrast, outside of North America, PR-specific scholarship usually, albeit with such exceptions as German language PR publishing, struggles for a niche market let alone a spread of genres and a range of special interests. The publication possibilities for writers for whom English is not a native language are especially restricted. Lauf’s (2005) empirical analysis shows that “the dominance of the U.S. in communication journals has been much greater than in journals of other disciplines” (p. 148). Finding “indications that non-U.S. authors are disadvantaged”, Lauf further speculates that “the review process discriminates against international manuscripts”. He suggests that “U.S. editors might overrate minor mistakes in U.S. citation systems . . . lack of English proficiency, missing U.S. literature, and so on” (2005, p. 148). These findings resonate strongly with our own impressions of mainstream PR scholarship. Indeed, as a form of counterbalance, we co-edited a special issue of Public Relations Review (McKie and Munshi, 2005a) on “Global Public Relations: A Different Perspective”, for which we take the chance to publicly thank the editor, Ray Hiebert, for granting us editorial freedom for radical content. Our initiative arose out of the sense that exclusion was a widespread feeling outside the US core. Accordingly we called for papers asking for authors to send us their idea of edge-happening PR. That special issue gave us an opportunity to provide scholars in the field with an “exposure to the ‘other’ ” (Slack, 2005, p. 6) and opened up the field to a number of controversial aspects. Israeli practitioner turned academic, Toledano (2005), for example, provided an account of the rarely considered, at least outside of Israel and the Jewish diaspora, history of Zionism as a PR challenge. Articles (Kersten, 2005; Kersten and Sidky, 2005) from two US-based academics (although the former was born in Holland and the latter in Afghanistan) courageously considered the controversy surrounding Iraqi prisoner abuse and resituated it as a crisis of dysfunctional leadership best analysed as systemic neurosis through frameworks developed in leadership. Petelin (2005) introduced the first application of Deleuze and Guattari’s rhizome theory into the field. In a number of ways the articles illustrate how contestations become most evident at the edges. Each edge is “like a tectonic plate that grinds against another and forms multiple layers of complex formulations” (McKie and Munshi, 2005b, p. 456) that simultaneously rupture old concepts and burst forth with new material. These disruptions, as Slack (2005) points out, “permeate – more accurately, characterize – the world around us; they are already of substantial symbolic and material consequence” (p. 6). As we had over 30 submissions in a relatively short time frame from the call for papers to the submission date, we realised that a significant number of writers, from all over the world, saw themselves as, at best, edgy or marginalised, or, at worst, excluded. Occasionally, the marginalisation tended towards self-affirming exclusion in as much as submissions ignored the usual length
10
Locating the project
conventions and submitted papers without any attention to Public Relations Review’s style or referencing protocols. It is worth reflecting that many others who failed to submit may have lacked the confidence or even the willingness to attempt submission to a US-based journal. Despite our global call, we failed to attract any submissions from Asia. Although a major region in twenty-first century business, Asia remains massively underrepresented with few publications in English, and practically none outside of US-educated and excellence study-influenced graduates. Otherwise it has been virtually “a silent continent when it comes to public relations pedagogy even though public relations is said to have been practiced in Asia since pre-biblical times” (Sriramesh, 2004b, p. 2). Sriramesh (2004a) himself, has begun to redress the balance with both a soloedited collection, Public Relations in Asia: an Anthology, and a co-edited global anthology covering Asia and beyond (Sriramesh and Vercˇicˇ, 2003a). Unfortunately, the publishers, Thomson Learning in Singapore, do not promote the Asian collection through their other international offices (Sriramesh, 2006). As a result a vital collection that fills a gap, and is fascinating in its own right, has additional barriers to cross to participate in the mainstream discourse. Our book also aims to redress what we see as a debilitating US-centric dominance that extends selective experiences from that part of the world into unquestioned universals elsewhere. However, we too acknowledge having been shaped by this mould, writing as we do in the English language, and drawing on works largely published in Europe and the US. In contesting existing attempts to codify a body of PR knowledge (PRSA Task Force, 1988; McElreath and Blamphin, 1994), our idea is to mark free space for new entrants who are locally informed and capable of shaping the future field that is likely to be predominantly Asian. Our personal preferences, in that we both received Western educations, with a European bias, lead us towards European thought, and European-influenced Third World writing, and specific theorists, whose work is often not available in PR publications in English. Similarly, we acknowledge that, although strongly influenced by feminist writing, we deal with wider issues of equity and diversity that mitigate against giving women the focused attention that they merit. In this book, we seek to clear the path for shifting the paradigm in PR research in the largely English-speaking part of the Euro-American world by using theories from within it, but not in PR, and from outside of it (Vervoorn, 2002). Accordingly, we draw from the tradition of many postcolonial theorists (Chakrabarty, 2000; Said, 1978; Spivak, 1999), who work in the Euro-American centre but are strongly critical of the ideology of the West (and do not see any necessary contradiction between the two), and we highlight distortions in PR research brought about by a limited engagement with diverse theories.
Limiting textbooks: the case of the creeping fox terrier clone The largest and easily the most read PR books, because they are prescribed on educational syllabi internationally, are textbooks. However the preponderance of textbooks, and particularly, current US textbooks, can distort the dissemination
Locating the project
11
of knowledge. This can occur by assuming a universal experience undervaluing the contributions of different cultures and histories, and by targeting undergraduate US students as customers more than as learners. This can limit the theoretical range, discursive scope, and cultural width, especially when being used internationally by students with different educational levels and intellectual traditions than their US counterparts. A discipline that is highly textbook centred, is also more prone to perpetuating error as illustrated by Stephen Gould’s (1991) seminal chapter on “The case of the creeping fox terrier clone”. The case arose through Gould’s desire to find if there was evidence of creationist interference in introductory accounts of evolution and his resulting analysis of major high-school science textbooks. Finding some creationist appeasement, he was more startled to discover that evolution sections were “virtually cloned” (Gould, 1991, p. 156) in moving from one to the next and to find confirmation for this cloning phenomena in the field of psychology in “Diane B. Paul’s fascinating article ‘The Nine Lives of Discredited Data’ (The Sciences, May 1987)” (p. 156). Gould’s (1991) miniresearch supported: first, Paul’s inference that careless copying of errors arise “because authors of textbooks copy from other texts and do not read original sources”; second, her argument “that the increasing commercialization of textbooks has engendered this virtual cloning of contents”; and, third, her acceptance that with future textbooks the “quality of marketing will make the difference” (pp. 157–158) in sales. Gould (1991) draws ironic attention to the “conspicuous absence of any mention whatsoever about the quality of the text itself” (p. 158). For PR our caution arises directly out of Gould’s (1991) further observations on a case “that may seem tiny and peripheral in import” but because, “perhaps paradoxically, such cases provide our best evidence for thoughtless copying” for “when a quirky little senseless item attains the status of the proverbial bad penny, copying from text to text is the only reasonable explanation” (p. 158). His example is from the fossil record and “an animal informally called Eohippus (the dawn horse), or more properly, Hyracotherium” (p. 158), which a large majority of the texts describe as being “ ‘like a fox terrier’ in size” (p. 159). After a scholarly detour of the evidence of comparative sizes, Gould (1991) cites less dated research as making the comparative animal much too small. While we do not wish to chase down detailed error in PR textbooks, we do examine the larger issues around cloned frameworks, and check the applicability of Gould’s (1991) conclusion that “Thoughtlessly cloned eternal verities are often false” (p. 167) to contemporary PR theory.
Enlarging the field: on status, textbooks, and terminology In society and in the academy alike, reputation does matter. We believe the field’s low status in both arenas requires action at a number of levels. Gould’s (1991) case highlights some problems with textbook prominence but there are others. As a field aspiring to be what Hebdige (1990) calls a YUMDie, or
12
Locating the project
“young upwardly mobile discipline” (p. ix), PR may not be unusual in having textbooks as a formative force, but it is still celebrating that as a strategy in the twenty-first century. In organisation studies, for example, Scott (2006) observes that while “it is also recognized that a thoughtful and well-written text can exert enormous influence on an academic field”, it “is well known that authors of texts are the ‘Rodney Dangerfields’ of the academic world: writing texts is not the route to scholarly respect” (p. 889). In PR the textbook tradition started, as L. Grunig and J. Grunig (2003) note, with Edward Bernays, who also “began what has become the noble tradition of using his own textbook (in this case Crystallizing Public Opinion [Bernays, 1923]) in the class” (p. 344). While there are pros (e.g. familiarity, knowledge, tailored relevance, and royalties) and cons (e.g. restricting diversity and student access to alternative points of view) in prescribing one’s own textbook, we wonder what makes the action “noble”. For a discipline desperately seeking respect from other disciplines, the less noble tradition of theory books may be, as Scott’s (2006) dismissive “Rodney Dangerfields” (p. 889) comment indicates, a better route. Undoubtedly, however, the seminal text of contemporary PR is J. Grunig and Hunt’s 1984 book, Managing Public Relations. This was written and published as a textbook, yet contains seeds of the two-way symmetrical theory that germinated into the excellence study and has subsequently expanded, we will argue, to the extent of threatening the space for growth of other perspectives in the field. One specific target of artificial cloning that originates in the J. Grunig and Hunt (1984) textbook is their formative four-stage evolution of PR that appears without challenge in so many current and recent textbooks. In Chapter 9, in critically examining its origin and spread, we will, like Gould (1991), suggest what “the textbook tradition of endless and thoughtless copying has done to retard the spread of original ideas” (p. 159). As with many in the field we plead guilty to using the single term PR to signify a variety of realities and not always being clear on the particular reality that is being invoked. On the whole our major topic is PR as an academic or educational project. However, that project cannot always be simply distinguished from the practice, since many academics are practitioners and practitioner perspectives form the core of many academic programmes. Moreover, theory and practice also have an indivisible fusion that is only split artificially for analytical convenience. Nevertheless, whenever possible we try to specify points where differences matter by referring independently to theory, to practice, or, where appropriate, to both theory and practice. That confusion is compounded by the many incarnations of PR. The major referent for PR outside the academy is the profession practiced in and by corporations and governments (and agencies, who serve mainly corporations and governments). These muster the largest resources and employ the majority of PR people. While acknowledging this preponderance of a profession devoted to activities for the already powerful, we explicitly reject definitions, which would restrict it solely to a management function as though that marks its beginning and end. Strong environmental opponents acknowledge its importance: “Public
Locating the project
13
relations, not physics – or even ecology – is the paradigm science of the modern age” (Athanasiou, 1996, p. 228), but they position its role as entirely negative because it is perceived as corporate or government communication. Considerable evidence supports this perception of negative impact, but we write in the hope that it can increasingly make a positive difference in its corporate and government expressions as well as outside of them. It is a fact that much of what Amnesty International, Greenpeace, Martin Luther King, and many NGO activist groups have done, and some continue to do, is also PR. From such instigators it plays a conscious role, not just in maintaining a diversity of opinion, but also in social cohesion, maintenance of values, and influencing progressive change. Reiterations that PR is a management function uphold a fallacy that has political and practice consequences. Huge corporations and tiny activist groups alike practice PR even if the former employ paid professionals and the latter, although not always, untrained and enthusiastic amateurs. This fuller spectrum of what constitutes PR activities exists whether or not it is loaded in terms of a massive imbalance of both communication and material resources. Moreover, the rise of the Internet has shifted positions on the spectrum between established communication power and its opponents in favour of the latter. Corporate and government PR are making adjustments proactively and reactively. Proactive examples include Cockerell (2006) acknowledging New Labour’s former PR pivot Alistair Campbell as the instigator of previously restricted Lobby briefings being made available “on the Number 10 website” (p. 56); reactive examples include the same Alistair Campbell’s resignation after the public furore concerning the exaggeration of Iraq’s weapons of mass destruction. PR has also had a significant non-corporate and non-government history. PR, from the distant past to the online present, operates outside of, as well as inside of, the management function. In the first half of the twentieth century, as Ewen’s (1996) PR! A Social History of Spin copiously illustrates, many of the techniques of US PR were pioneered by social movements before being adapted by corporate communicators. At the end of the twentieth century Coombs (1998) wrote on the effectiveness of the Flaming Ford activist Internet site, which mobilised consumers against a life threatening design flaw in the company’s cars, its negative impact on Ford’s corporate reputation, and its positive pressure to reduce driver danger. In addition, many small groups, from reading circles to cancer support organisations, also practice PR. The emphasis on corporations marginalises small to medium enterprises (SMEs), which form a huge part of the world economy. Although these will not be our focus, it remains important that the concentration on corporate and government communication management does not ignore the fact of their existence, and, therefore a range of PR practices that are often socially beneficial (Schoenberger-Orgad and McKie, 2005).
Acknowledging antecedents, entertaining ideas, and net gains Play has an importance not acknowledged in PR. It is, in many of its forms, a valuable economic commodity in its own right as Orbanes (2004) records in The
14
Locating the project
Game Makers: The Story of Parker Brothers from Tiddledy Winks to Trivial Pursuits. As well as bringing in serious money it underpins innovation through Serious Play: How the World’s Best Companies Simulate to Innovate (Schrage, 2000). In Wolf’s (1999) account of The Entertainment Economy: How MegaMedia Forces Are Transforming Our Lives, the blurring of boundaries between business and entertainment has made the latter a differentiating factor in what we buy, the depth of penetration, and the scale of profitability so that: “Entertainment – not autos, not steel, not financial services – is fast becoming the driving wheel of the new world economy [italics in original]” (p. 4). The field’s residual Puritanism, heavily influenced by its lower North American power base, matters in this lack of acknowledgement. Prior to PR members having the numbers to make the transition from an interest group to a division at the International Communication Association (ICA), its acronym was PRIG (Public Relations Interest Group) and a certain priggishness and undue seriousness continues to permeate the field. In pluralising its ideas, we import theoreticians talking of desire, emotions, and sex. These concerns, like play, matter to a fully alive field. In his discussion of IRC, the net’s pioneering multi-user chat system, Rheingold (2000) helpfully reminds us that neither due scholarly diligence, nor the Protestant work ethic, was what created the net as we know it or what powered many of its subsequently valuable transformations: IRC is . . . “the great good place” of the Net . . . scientists and scholars began to get the word that IRC was a way to convene informal discussions among geographically distant colleagues, but the continuing popularity of IRC seems to be primarily a function of its appeal as a psychological and intellectual playground. Why should taxpayers support anyone’s playground? It’s a good question, and it goes to the heart of the current debate over privatization of the Net. It pays to keep in mind a bit of history when addressing the question, however, because playgrounds have played a critically important role in the evolution of computer technology. The very earliest creators of interactive computing also created the enormously popular Spacewar game in the early 1960s, which turned expensive research computers into powerful versions of what would come to be known in the 1970s as video games [. . .] The government-sponsored researchers who built the first ARPANET started using government resources to exchange e-mail about science fiction. ARPA administrators wisely invested in building even more powerful CMC systems when the SF-LOVERS list began to eat up more and more of the communication capacity of the systems. In computer technology, playgrounds often are where real innovations emerge. (pp. 184–185) We willingly acknowledge that we follow others in seeking change and gratefully build on their efforts. There are a number we particularly acknowledge.
Locating the project
15
Robert Heath, especially through the breadth of his rhetorical sources, enriches the field intellectually and practically. In a discipline notable for restrictive gatekeeping, Heath has consistently opened up paths to publication for many in the US and for many, in much greater need, outside of its borders with an admirable generosity of spirit and openness to critical viewpoints. Heath’s (2001a) Handbook of Public Relations brought diverse writers from all round the world, with diverse perspectives, into the mainstream of PR alongside established US theorists, in a way that made a statement that the discipline was global and open to global and critical inputs. Although only intermittently in the field, George Cheney’s multiple inputs, more recently with Lars Christensen (Cheney and Christensen, 2001b, 2006), have contributed significantly to making PR a more democratically sensitive, inclusive, informed, and thoughtful discipline. Kevin Moloney (2006) provides democratic directions for progressing the profession and parallels work by L’Etang (2004) and L’Etang and Piezcka (1996a, 2006a), who have also gone boldly beyond to create critical escape routes. Our colleagues in the Waikato Management School introduced and developed Foucauldian and Faircloughian Critical Discourse in PR (Henderson, 2005; Motion and Leitch, 1996; Weaver et al., 2006); pioneered innovative interdisciplinary work from politics (Roper, 2004; Schoenberger-Orgad, 2002); and are shifting paradigms on PR and sustainability (Roper and Toledano, 2005), corporate social responsibility (Ganesh, in press; May et al., in press; Munshi and Kurian, 2005; Munshi and Kurian, in press; Zorn, in press), social enterprise PR in SMEs (Schoenberger-Orgad and McKie, 2005), and social entrepreneurship in corporate governance (Roper and Cheney, 2005).
Postscript that could have been a preface: acknowledging contradictions Discursively we acknowledge that our language is shot through with contradictions. We seek to have people entertain our ideas so, despite the academic theory content, we use intertextual links with popular culture, including songs and movie titles, to increase accessibility, import energy, and generally try to live up to Hampden-Turner and Trompenaars’ (2000) description of their own writing as “Serious Humor” (p. 10). As suggested above, entertainment is a vital part of business, and is also central to the promotional culture, which includes PR, and is a defining characteristic of the contemporary condition (Wernick, 1991). Academic writing ought similarly to be more open to attracting larger interested audiences as well as captive student audiences. In addressing such concerns, hybrid high culture–low culture forms have found favour in marketing. Stephen Brown’s (1995) Postmodern Marketing, for example, uses lines from films to spice up theoretical discussion and his Postmodern Marketing Two: Telling Tales (Brown, 1998) adapts, and puns (badly) on, pop song lines in similar fashion to provide chapter titles such as “Bakhtin the US, Bakhtin the US, Bakhtin the USSR” (p. 127) to track the disparate influences of the Russian
16
Locating the project
theoretician of dialogue in the US, invoking Bruce Springstein’s song in the process. In Tsoukas and Knudsen’s (2003) The Oxford Handbook of Organization Theory, Czarniawska (2003) devotes a complete chapter on “The styles and the stylists of organization theory”. She not only proposes that “the rapprochement between organization theory and cultural anthropology that happened under the guise of ‘organizational culture’ studies was most likely given an impulse by people who wanted to study poetry that pretends to be scientific” (p. 246), but cites as support Karl Weick’s use of a humorous quotation from Kurt Vonnegut: My advisor smiled, “How would you like to study poetry which pretends to be scientific?” he asked me. “Is such a thing possible?” I said. He shook my hand. “Welcome to the field of social and cultural anthropology,” he said. (Weick, 1979, p. 234, cited in Czarniawska, 2003, p. 246) In marked contrast to PR, while simultaneously explaining why this is so, Czarniawska (2003) celebrates the fact that “organization theory has many excellent stylists, probably due to its much lamented plurality [italics not in original]” (p. 238) and, for the rest of the chapter, she looks at the rich interplay of style and meaning and how they help generate fresh theory. In line with Czarniawska’s (2003) argument, and the qualitative research tradition that classifies writing as a legitimate “Method of Inquiry” (Richardson and St. Pierre, 2005, p. 959), we experiment stylistically to assist thought exploration. That is why we warmly welcome the publication of Hobsbawm’s (2006a) collection, Where the Truth Lies: Trust and Morality in PR and Journalism, since many of her contributors, if thin on academic theory, live up to the serious fun of the title in engaging with vital issues with insight. We also play seriously with titles (and subtitles, and phrases) to alert readers to the instability of language, which through puns, such as that on entertaining ideas, enable us to simultaneously suggest amusing thoughts, inviting attention, and being open to fresh theory. In this we are weak followers of Derrida, who contends that verbal texts rely on the assumption that language is merely the vehicle for transmitting thoughts and so deploys deconstruction to overturn that assumption of verbal “centring”. That centring, for Derrida, is also a “censoring” of meaning by positioning human experience around a hierarchical and illegitimate equation of word and thing. In working to overturn such assumptions one deconstructionist trademark is playing “meaningfully” with words to destabilise the seeming solidity of their associated concepts. Derrida, and other deconstructionists, frequently emphasise textual instabilities by means of punning, or by writing concepts under erasure (that is with a line, or lines, scored through them to denote their dubious relationship to material phenomena). Sometimes words can be broken down to show component parts to expose their “constructedness” and their potential to house
Locating the project
17
other meanings so that the word “MAN-AGE-MENT”, as well as the practice, is exposed with the word “man” as its verbal opening in a way that would evade semantics and considerations of non-sexist language (see McKie, 2001, pp. 76–77, for a deconstruction of excellence). Ironically, this kind of tight focus, and creative play, on small variations on letters, language, and meaning has drawn corporate attention online via “gripe sites”, which are both “an embarrassingly public forum for trivial customer or employee complaints . . . [and] an established tool for serious issues-led activism” (John and Thompson, 2003, p. 129). They advise corporations on limiting their “reputational liability” to gripe and rogue sites “by applying a thorough planning process to domain registration”, and by taking “care to register all likely permutations and easy misspellings of their corporate and product brands, as well as appending or prefixing their brands with common derogatory descriptors (e.g. ‘sucks’)” (p. 130). PETA (People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals), for example, ran successful campaigns to force McDonald’s and Burger King (identified online as Murder King) to implement a more humane way of killing the animals that they used for meat. As we write this, PETA are currently reworking KFC as Kentucky Fried Cruelty at (www.kentuckyfriedcruelty.com) with the help of a downloadable video featuring Pamela Anderson. Our wordplays in this book lack such celebrity support and are partly a mild homage to Derridean practice, though we fall far short of Derrida’s punning in more than one language, etymological scope, and creative use of typography. Our playfulness often sits uncomfortably alongside a certain moralistic tone. Ironically, despite frequent deployment of language such as “needs to”, “requires”, and “must”, our invocations, although in the imperative and demanding change as a matter of urgency, sit alongside a genuine tentativeness in exploring possible options. While we spend considerable energy in unsettling the Grunigian paradigm, we have no desire to replace it with one of our own. We simply want to decrease the concern with whether or not new developments fit, or do not fit, with two-way symmetry and to focus instead on whether they advance the field professionally and socially. In short, we hope the book entertains enough broader, inclusive, and innovative ideas to enliven and expand the field and to encourage others, especially those currently in the margins, on more emancipatory lines of flight that engage with ecology, equity, and enterprise.
Progressing the conversation: a brief outline plan of the chapters The opening word of our book title is “Reconfiguring” because this is a large task and a work in progress. We focus our attention on making a case for reconfiguration both externally, through the present state of the physical and social environment in the second chapter’s reading of the signs of the times (especially environmental ones), and internally, through the present state of PR in Chapter 3. Chapters 4 and 5 focus on equity and globalisation with an emphasis on postcolonial and decolonising points of view while Chapter 6 looks at learning from
18
Locating the project
leadership and the past history of excellence in the business field. Chapter 7 considers economic questions and searches for value propositions for PR after the crisis in the new economy, and those concerns carry over into Chapter 8’s reinterpretation of the field’s perennial concerns with professionalism. Finally, in concluding the case for reconfiguration, we explore beyond the present in two directions: back to the history and historiography of the field in Chapter 9; and forward through future methodologies and future studies in Chapter 10.
2
Signs of the times Assessing the present and revisiting the past
PR needs to be sensitive to change and to be aware of the shifting contexts within which it has to function. This chapter sets out our view of contemporary conditions in the midst of transformative change: “Every few hundred years in Western history, there occurs a sharp transformation” in which “society rearranges itself – its worldview; its basic values; its social and political structure; its arts; its key institutions” (Drucker, 1993, p. 1). While we agree with Drucker that transformation is underway, we disagree that it is restricted to Western history. In fact, a distinctive feature, and driving force, of this transformative change is its global scope, and its insertion of all history into world history. Currently PR is unprepared for engagement with the globally transforming environment of the early twenty-first century. Indeed as a vastly expanded electronic capacity collects and communicates a wider world opinion to more people, more quickly than ever before, the ongoing US leadership in global commerce, politics, and PR has been called into doubt. In Global Outrage, Stearns (2005) records the huge international rallies and large opinion polls of people opposed to the 2003 US invasion of Iraq as a key moment in his pioneering concept of world opinion history. Historically, for Stearns (2005), this “was world opinion, unprecedented in the strength of its opposition to a great power, unusually coordinated thanks both to the passion involved and to high-speed technologies”. Even “governments, as in France and Germany, saw their own policies constrained, partially guided, by the sentiments of the public”. In the end though “this was also world opinion aborted”: “The United States government, despite some bows to the United Nations, largely ignored the world . . . went to war, and encountered few immediate adverse consequences” (p. 4). At the same time global leadership is less in the hands of governments. Just as 400 years ago, “social responsibility shifted from the church to the state, as government replaced religious institutions as society’s predominant force”, now, at the start of the twenty-first century, “business appears the next likely candidate to carry this mantle” (Joel Makower and Business for Social Responsibility, 1994, p. 33). This perception captures a consensus on the central role of business in contemporary global life that covers both those who fear the consequences of a coming time, When Corporations Rule the World
20
Signs of the times
(Korten, 1996), and those for whom it signals the advent of an emerging planetary civilisation (Hart, 2005). To map this present context for PR, we first revisit accounts of earlier large scale business change that has been categorised as transformative (if more national than international in its early stage). Summarising historical retrospectives on the early twentieth century, Raucher (1968) observes, in his book Public Relations and Business: 1900–1929, how business apologists for that 30-year period “have claimed that the ‘transformation of capitalism’ has meant that the fundamental outlook and motivation of business managers have morally improved in comparison with the late nineteenth century” (p. 152). On the other hand, Raucher (1968) also notes how business critics “have argued that business changed its methods to meet the countervailing forces of external opposition from government, labor unions, and other sources without yielding basic profit motives” (p. 152). Finally, he comes down on the side of the critics because PR as a “defensive political device . . . appears to have been very much a sophisticated response to external pressures”, and, while it cannot be known if “such ‘enlightened’ policies” would have been created without such external pressure, “the history of PR suggests not” (Raucher, 1968, pp. 152–153). That history, as Cleveland (1946) notes, involves the substantial PR role played by the National Association of Manufacturers (NAM), which, from “1895 to the present time . . . has vigorously (and often militantly) sought to further the interests of industrialists . . . Much of this opposition has taken the form of extensive propaganda designed to influence the electorate” (pp. 1–2, cited in Cutlip, 1995, pp. 259–260). Raucher’s (1968) account and, more strongly, Ewen’s (1996) pro-activist version act as strong correctives to Hiebert’s (1966) interpretation of the same early phase of capitalist transformation in Courtier to the Crowd: the Story of Ivy Lee and the Development of Public Relations. Hiebert’s (1966) account has been seminal, in shaping subsequent PR interpretation of the events covered in Raucher, by framing the period as a triumph for Lee and his business employers: For a time during the second half of the nineteenth century, industrial leaders turned to monopoly as a solution to their economic problems. By the turn of the century, however, a reversal was taking place, largely as the result of a new kind of communication that appealed to mass man: “yellow journalism” with its practice of “muckraking.” This gave to such antiindustrial groups as the agrarians and grangers, populists, labor unions, and progressives a new power over public opinion that allowed them to counterbalance the might of the industrial captains, for a while even threatening the continued existence of their power by bringing into question the basic idea of free enterprise. Ivy Lee arrived on the scene at a moment when capitalistic forces no longer seemed to have the upper hand in the struggle for public opinion. (pp. x–xi)
Signs of the times
21
Then, as now, media expansion and increased public access – although higher up the social scale than the net and shorter in numbers than today’s international mass communication audiences – played a major role in the change: “Nourishing a trend toward middle-class spectatorship, a new and increasingly disembodied public sphere was being spawned by the dramatic growth of mass-circulation media between the early 1880s and the First World War” (Ewen, 1996, p. 52). In this earlier hinge of history, PR obviously played a role, but a largely reactive one of less significance than that its own historians claim for it. Today, in the midst of a comparable capitalist transformation that Kelly (2005) characterises as Powerful Times, we follow his subtitle’s call for Rising to the Challenge of Our Uncertain World by adopting “a powerful orientation toward learning, experimentation, and discovery that will require us to acknowledge uncertainty and embrace ambiguity – even as our impulse is to seek comfort in certainty and adhere to a set of familiar convictions, assumptions and beliefs” (p. xx). This time around we see the opportunity for PR to be proactive and in the vanguard of positive change. However, Kelly’s (2005) call points to features currently absent in PR, which rarely satisfies the demand for a learning orientation, for experimentation, for discovery, for acknowledging uncertainty, and for embracing ambiguity. Accordingly, as well as experimenting (with approach, language, style, and theory), we seek to admit uncertainty, and to manage with – at least as much in the sense of “coping with”, as in the sense of “controlling” – ambiguity. In dealing with ambiguity we pay heed to Kelly’s (2005) advice to avoid an “ ‘either/or’ mindset”, and join his search “for recurring themes and patterns” (pp. 18–19) by concentrating on our three selected themes of ecology, equity, and enterprise (without ignoring their interactions and without giving any one of them precedence over any of the others).
Vital signs (1): stormy weather and the ecological case for reconfiguration The Worldwatch Institute’s (2005) Vital Signs: The Trends That Are Shaping Our Future 2000–2006 provides a snapshot of the state of the planet with “upto-the-minute information on global warming, population growth, military spending, HIV/AIDS, economic equity, the trade in drugs and a whole range of other environmental, developmental, social, political, and economic trends” (blurb). One outstanding feature, which has been a prominent part of many people’s experience (and massive media coverage), is the increase in weatherrelated disasters: “In 2004, weather-related natural disasters caused nearly $105 billion in economic losses” almost twice as much as 2003, became “only the second time that recorded losses have topped $100 billion”, and followed a general increase “over the last 25 years” (p. 50). As these figures illustrate, environment and economy are strongly connected. Other contemporary accounts consistently confirm the interconnection. This is supported by the contents, as well as the title, of probably the single
22
Signs of the times
most authoritative recent report on the state of the planet: the Millennium Ecosystem Assessment’s [MEA] (2005) Living Beyond Our Means: Natural Assets and Human Well-being. Produced by the board governing the Millennium Assessment process, the MEA’s members included “representatives from U.N. organizations, governments through a number of international conventions, nongovernmental organizations, academia, business, and indigenous peoples”. It reads the weather signs as a warning and identifies “the growing threat to ecosystems from climate change and nutrient pollution” (MEA, 2005). The MEA findings concur with other research such as: 1 2
3
the frightening question in cosmologist Martin Rees’ (2003) book title: Our Final Century: Will the Human Race Survive the Twenty-First Century?; the equally disturbing summation of recent climatology findings in the alarming title of science journalist John Cox’s (2005) Climate Crash: Abrupt Climate Change and What It Means For Our Future; the first-hand observations of ecological change that lead Mark Lynas (2005) to conclude “that all the impacts described are just the first whispers of the hurricane of future climate change which is now bearing down on us” (p. 298).
If PR is to respond to the material challenges of the contemporary world, it has to engage with the implications of the growing body of evidence of physical eco-degradation. The signs so far are not good. During the last quarter of a century, scientists internationally have reached a consensus on the dangers of global warming (see, for example, the US National Academy of Sciences reports (National Research Council, 1983, 2001) and the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) assessment reports (1990, 1995, 2001)). They all support the MEA (2005) assessment of high risk. Unfortunately, PR is more visible in opposition than in support of tackling the problem. In fact, eminent scientists and scientific bodies are attacking the PR activities of a contrarian movement, which denies that there is convincing evidence of global warming. In analysing this powerful countermovement, McCright and Dunlap (2000) identify the role of the American political conservatives and their “industry allies” (p. 518) as working to de-legitimise climate change as a significant “problem” (p. 499). British scientists similarly perceive this countermovement as an alliance of corporate-funded PR practitioners and scientists. Ex-President of the Royal Society, and former chief scientific adviser to the British Government, Lord May (2005) of Oxford, targeted what he calls a US oil industry funded “climate change denial lobby” into Britain: On the one hand, we have the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, the rest of the world’s major scientific organisations and the Government’s Chief Scientific Advisor all pointing to the need to cut emissions. On the other hand, we have a small band of sceptics, including lobbyists funded by the US oil industry, a sci-fi writer (in the shape of Michael Crichton) and the Daily Mail who deny the scientists are right.
Signs of the times
23
May (2005) goes on to draw parallels with “the tobacco lobby’s attempts to persuade us that smoking does not cause lung cancer”, and describes its media influence as “poisonous”. At this point in planetary history, PR has expanded to a significant global role which brings with it increased responsibilities. At present, the major existing bodies are too self-interested, and not self-reflexive enough to take up the challenge. The Global Alliance (n.d.), for example, seeks to be “the authoritative global voice on PR matters”, while simultaneously claiming to work “in the public interest for the benefit of the profession”. We argue that to meet Kelly’s (2005) challenge, especially on the environmental front, PR will need to develop a more reflective metaview, with a less selfinterested global dimension, and: to construct new globally-oriented public relations fora to deal with the expansion of megacatastrophic planetary risks. These fora would parallel, and learn from, a range of other existing examples: the Global Environment Facility, which is an independent organization that gives grants for projects that benefit the global environment and sustainability; and the Forest Stewardship Council, which issues a consumer label to wood products constructed from sustainably-managed forests; and, especially, the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, a group of international scientists who gather to assess the state of knowledge and give advise to the Framework on Climate Change (see Simmons and Jonge Oudraat, 2001). In the absence of emergent, globally-concerned, and environmentally-aware public relations fora, or massively improved linkages between such existing institutional sites as conferences, professional bodies, and universities, practitioners will lack an overview perspective to guide them to informed choices . . . Moreover, since anti-environmental forces currently have more resources, a public relations profession without that reflective element, is economically structured to support the high-risk acceleration of global warming and other ecological degradation. (McKie and Galloway, forthcoming) This will be a preparatory step to establishing transnational institutions – for example, see Ruggie’s (1998) Constructing the World Polity: Essays on International Institutionalization – to translate the findings into action. Without such moves, PR risks deepening the growing opprobrium it has gathered for practitioner and consultancy support of anti-environmentalism identified at an international level by Beder’s (2000) book, Global Spin: The Corporate Assault on Environmentalism, by Lubbers’ (2002) Battling Big Business: Countering Greenwash, Infiltration and Other Forms of Corporate Bullying, and, at a local level, by Hager and Burton’s (1999) Secrets and Lies: The Anatomy of an Anti-Environmental PR Campaign in New Zealand. As with the earlier “transformation of capitalism”, PR is not solely accountable, but the taint of the tobacco lobby still stains the profession. Over time that may seem insignificant in comparison to the current practice of building countermovements designed to
24
Signs of the times
obstruct attempts at avoiding planetary degradation and eco-disasters. Accordingly, this narrower economic-centred view may put both the economy and the environment at risk since the former is dependent on the latter. Historical change cannot avoid being ecological change, economic change, and egalitarian change. PR has to engage with all three.
Vital signs (2): equity, democracy, and global (im)balances Sriramesh (2003a) analyses linkages between globalisation, democracy, market democracy, and PR, but elsewhere the literature tends to present the simultaneous spread of economic globalisation, and global PR along with it, as unreservedly positive. Seitel (2004) is typical in portraying the twenty-first century as holding the promise of being “the golden age of public relations” because, with the influence of “Economic globalization”, the practice “has become a growth industry round the world” (p. 510). The only downside he refers to is “Global jealousies, fueling terrorism and anti-Western feelings” (p. 510). The field’s treatment of equity issues resembles its engagement with ecological issues. In this sphere too, it requires a similarly self-reflective disciplinary overview with a global dimension. Although he writes pre-9/11, and pre-Iraq War, Derrida’s (1994) analysis remains accurate: never have violence, inequality, exclusion, famine, and thus economic oppression affected as many human beings in the history of the earth and of humanity. Instead of singing the advent of the ideal of liberal democracy and capitalist market in the euphoria of the end of history, instead of celebrating the “end of ideologies” and the end of the great emancipatory discourses, let us never neglect this obvious macroscopic fact, made up of innumerable singular sites of suffering: no degree of progress allows one to ignore that never before, in absolute figures, never have so many men, women and children been subjugated, starved or exterminated on the earth. (p. 85) The French philosopher’s analysis is confirmed by economist Stiglitz’s (2003) comments, in Globalization and Its Discontents, that “globalization has not succeeded in reducing poverty, neither has it succeeded in ensuring stability” as crises “in Asia and in Latin America have threatened the economies and stability of all developing countries . . . [with] fears of financial contagion spreading around the world, [so] that the collapse of one emerging market currency will mean that others fall as well” (p. 6). Anthropologist Arjun Appadurai (2006) also examines the dark side of globalisation to ask why the spread of free market liberal democracy has been accompanied by extreme violence in such forms as indiscriminate attacks on civilian populations and systemic ethnic cleansing in disparate locations across the globe. These analyses underpin the urgency in our concern with equity, and the lack of it, in the changing business context. We use the term equity, and the
Signs of the times
25
absence of equity, in a broad sense to encompass issues of diversity, democracy, politics, and justice, as well as their antonyms from ethnocentrism to injustice, and substantial sections of the spectrum between polarities in “the shifting world in which we live: tourists, immigrants, refugees, exiles, guest workers and other moving groups” and the re-wired “global configuration of technology” crisscrossing “previously impervious boundaries” (Appadurai, 1990, p. 297) at ever increasing speeds. The changing technological landscape is tilting other status quos. In Smart Mobs: The Next Social Revolution, Rheingold (2002) charts business and social manifestions of the uptake of new technology in society. Categorising the January 2001 overthrow of President Joseph Estrada of the Philippines as “the first head of state in history to lose power to a smart mob” (Rheingold, 2002, p. 157), he recounts how over one million people in Manila, “mobilized and coordinated by waves of text messages, assembled at the site of the 1986 ‘People Power’ peaceful demonstrations that had toppled the Marcos regime” (Rheingold, 2002, p. 157) and how thousands of them “converged on Epifanio de los Santas Avenue, known as ‘Edsa’, within an hour of the first text message volleys: ‘Go 2EDSA, Wear blck’ (p. 158). Rheingold (2002) concludes that: “Over four days, more than a million citizens showed up, mostly dressed in black. Estrada fell. The legend of ‘Generation Txt’ was born” (p. 158). Rheingold’s (2000) sensitivity to differences in culture also offers unusual ways of assessing the present and its links to the future. In tracking research into an online community using Fujitsu’s “Habitat” system – a combination of “a cartoonland graphical representation of participants and their environment with a synchronous chat system” (Rheingold, 2000, p. 184) – he describes the phenomenon of “Kansei” or the “invisible and perhaps partially ineffable component of Japanese spoken communication . . . which can be only loosely translated as an intuitive, partially aesthetic, sense of rightness about the contextual elements in a conversation” (p. 203). His findings have wider implications for communication and e-commerce in general, and PR online and multiculturalism in particular: Kansei might turn out to be an important term all over the Net, as an aid to evaluating the advantages and disadvantages of each Net tool in different situations. The Net is increasingly a multicultural forum – the only multicultural forum of any scope. To focus on developments in the United States is wise because that is where the Net began, and where many technical and social innovations continue to emerge. But to do so exclusively is to miss the big picture: the Net is happening to the whole world. Because of the sharp focus on communications and information technologies at the highest levels of Japan’s industrial policymakers, the question of Japan and the Net is perhaps the most important critical uncertainty in the shaping of tomorrow’s Worldnet. (Rheingold, 2000, p. 203)
26
Signs of the times
PR would do well to keep the changing cultural and technological landscapes in mind to free innovation, to promote competition, and to maintain democracy. They may prove useful as people in business communities and world institutions alike call for a rethinking of issues of equity in relation to issues of enterprise and ecology, or what Porritt (2005) calls Capitalism As If the World Mattered.
Vital signs (3): enterprise, markets, and corporate choices To the financially influential audience at a World Economic Forum meeting in Switzerland’s Davos, UN Secretary-General Kofi Annan (1999) suggested countering critics of global capitalism by launching a global initiative to institutionalise good corporate citizen behaviour and by choosing “to unite the power of markets with the authority of universal ideals”. That initiative was developed into the Global Compact as an essential part of ensuring “that the global market is embedded in broadly shared values and practices that reflect global social needs and that all the world’s people share the benefits of globalization” (Annan, cited in Rowe, 2005, p. 130). At a less lofty level H. F. Johnson (2005), Chairman and CEO of S. C. Johnson & Son, Inc., sets out two opposing sides of the dynamic tension surrounding enterprise and market economics. He acknowledges that by “improving the lives of workers in one country while degrading the environment in another”, business has fuelled “the growing anti-globalization outcry”; but asserts that “the corporate sector can be the catalyst for a truly sustainable force in the global development for all on the planet” (p. xxxi). Stuart Hart’s (2005) Capitalism At the Crossroads expands on the polar opposites first with a more muted form of Derrida’s (1994) summation of “a decade of economic globalization, privatization, and free trade” in relation to business and enterprise, as producing, at best, mixed outcomes: “Whereas the wealthy in developed countries have grown richer, the vast majority of nations and people in the world have yet to benefit from the apparent triumph of capitalism and liberal democracy” (p. xxxvii). However, more optimistically, Hart (2005) also ushers in what the subtitle of his book calls “The Unlimited Business Opportunities in Solving the World’s Most Difficult Problems”. He indicates ways for business to rise to the challenge of sustainable development along the lines of the World Commission on Environment and Development’s (WCED) (1987) definition, as “development that meets the needs of the present without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs” (p. 8), by: creating a new, more inclusive brand of capitalism, one that incorporates previously excluded voices, concerns, and interests, the corporate sector could become the catalyst for a truly sustainable form of global development – and prosper in the process. To succeed, however, corporations must learn to open up to the world: Strategies need to take account the entire
Signs of the times
27
human community of 6.5 billion, as well as the host of other species with which we share the planet. (Hart, 2005, p. xli) Business PR practices have long been implicated in a modernisation project colonised by dominant Western perspectives, and narrowly logical thinking that might sometimes be classed as economic fundamentalism. As a consequence they see offshore populations as additional consumer numbers, minority publics as a problem to be managed, workforces as requiring control, and nature as a realm to be mastered and exploited. Current strategic thinking (Prahalad, 2005), in line with demographic trends and other global shifts, repositions the billions at the bottom of the economic pyramid as customer relationship opportunities and talent pools (Mahajan and Banga, 2005), and environmental sensitivity as a source of profit rather than an obstacle to it (Hart, 2005). Current scriptwriters of the PR field still reinforce elitist control over a changing world by “promoting a synthetic equality that ignores the lopsidedness of actual power structures” (Munshi, 2005a, p. 53). They ignore the power of emerging markets (and their populations) and support anti-environmentalist movements that retard the implementation of measures to respond to threats such as global warming. The shift in relation to nature should be modelled more in terms of what Giblett (2004) terms mutuality rather than mastery. Forging a worldview akin to Kofi Annan’s idea of a global compact, which is more representative of an increasingly complex, diverse, and uncertain world, will require changes in the field. It will need to move towards an actively multicultural theatre. Increasingly obsolete theories of management such as command-and-control will make room for more, and more flexible, theories to enable inclusive and collective engagements with issues of difference. Within corporate PR this side of the debate on the new capitalism is neglected. Although progress has been made (see Chapter 5), the conversations have still to become more polyphonic or many-voiced. Significantly, clear positive consequences – not just for reducing poverty and for expanding global enterprise, but for gender equity, and contributing to world peace – through enlarging input by people from developing nations, and by spreading their innovations, have been acknowledged by the award of the 2006 Nobel Peace Prize to Muhammad Yunus and his Grameen Bank: for their efforts to create economic and social development from below. Lasting peace cannot be achieved unless large population groups find ways in which to break out of poverty. Micro-credit is one such means. Development from below also serves to advance democracy and human rights. Muhammad Yunus has shown himself to be a leader who has managed to translate visions into practical action for the benefit of millions of people, not only in Bangladesh, but also in many other countries. Loans to poor people without any financial security had appeared to be an impossible idea. [. . .]
28
Signs of the times Yunus and Grameen Bank have shown that even the poorest of the poor can work to bring about their own development. Micro-credit has proved to be an important liberating force in societies where women in particular have to struggle against repressive social and economic conditions. Economic growth and political democracy cannot achieve their full potential unless the female half of humanity participates on an equal footing with the male. (BBC News Online, 2006)
Shifting signs: pluralisation and context-relevant PR Pluralism in PR theory is not expanding along with these new directions in business and global change. Almost any innovation has to fight for space against the inertia exerted by the dominance of the excellence tradition. For followers of two-way symmetry, the final theory has been found. The remaining tasks are augmentation within its parameters, defence against its detractors, and extension of its global grip. Nevertheless, from small beginnings (Botan and Hazleton, 1989), through the 1990s (Toth and Heath, 1992; L’Etang and Pieczka, 1996a), other perspectives have gradually become more visible. We survey the current contours of conceptualisation, and issue prioritisation, through four significant 2006 book publications: Botan and Hazleton (2006a); L’Etang and Pieczka (2006a); Moloney (2006); and Hobsbawm (2006a). Three of these four books are augmentations of earlier projects and so demonstrate durability and gathering momentum for multiple approaches. Botan and Hazleton’s (2006a) Public Relations Theory II looks back to the collection’s predecessor, Public Relations Theory (Botan and Hazleton, 1989), which was a milestone publication in introducing theory to the field. Retrospectively, they recognise more changes than continuities with the earlier period. They note, for example, the rise in practitioner remuneration, the massive globalisation of the field in practice so that “several large [US] firms . . . each have client lists with a dozen or more national governments on them”, and the huge expansion of higher education so that in 2005 “GradSchools.com lists 64 graduate programs in public relations in the United States and 31 more internationally, although known programs in Germany, Brazil, and elsewhere had been left off that list”, so that “demand for qualified faculty” (Botan and Hazleton, 2006b, p. 2) has also continued to grow. Nevertheless they conclude that their focus is PR theory rather than economics or education. In that theory area Botan and Hazleton (2006b) acknowledge a shift that is in tune with global shifts in other areas: while “the United States is the birthplace of public relations theory and has been dominant in public relations research in recent years” (p. 13), perhaps the most important development “is that this U.S. dominance is fading” (p. 13). They identify at “least two other centers [Europe and Australasia] for theory work . . . emerging in the world with, possibly, two more [Brazil and China and Southeast Asia] starting to develop” (Botan and Hazleton, 2006b, p. 13). While their earlier book “set out to argue the need for more theory in PR” (Botan and Hazleton, 2006b, p. 4), they see this one as
Signs of the times
29
“engaged in the new task of giving voice to the need for diversity and competition between theories in public relations” and “believe that the field cannot develop further without such a contest of ideas”, which they term “a paradigm struggle” (p. 4). Although we will dispute the basis for their accompanying assertion that the Grunigian paradigm is the only paradigm in town, it is heartening to find these pioneers calling for increased pluralism and exemplifying it in practice with the inclusion of international contributions. At the same time they follow their introduction with J. Grunig et al.’s (2006) chapter on “The excellence theory”. On the opening page, the excellence study authors implicitly dismiss the editors’ opening call for a contest of ideas by classifying it as a mark of a field’s immaturity: “In mature sciences, scholars generally agree on common theories. In immature sciences, however, everyone seems to have his or her own theory, and debate rages among the competing camps about which theories are preferable” (J. Grunig et al., 2006, p. 21). Indeed, contemporaneous with the growth of plural perspectives, attempts to solidify and extend the Grunigian paradigm beyond the present continue. The latest is Toth’s (2006) 656-page collection, The Future of Excellence in Public Relations and Communication Management, in which, according to the publisher’s promotional blurb, the contributors “consider the indelible theory building” of J. Grunig and L. Grunig and “present research that advances excellence theories, adds new dimensions and directions to the excellence theories, and shows how the excellence study has moved to the global stage” (Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, 2006). Since Toth’s (2006) collection was unavailable as we were writing, we can only note the blurb’s claims and observe that the title, in selecting “excellence” rather than “excellence theory” or “excellence research”, operates semantically in pulling all that is excellent into the two-way symmetry movement’s ambit as if any other kind of PR lacks a future that may claim to be excellent. Directions more consistently diverging from excellence theory than Botan and Hazleton (2006a) can be found in L’Etang and Pieczka (2006a). Public Relations: Critical Debates and Contemporary Practice (L’Etang and Pieczka, 2006a) strengthens its predecessor’s core, Critical Perspectives in Public Relations (L’Etang and Pieczka, 1996a), with more iconoclastic chapters on accepted beliefs in mainstream PR in, for example, professionalism, systems theory, and postmodern writing, and augments them with newer fields such as sport and tourism. Although many of its contributors are still linked to the one institution, Stirling University in Scotland, the new edition acknowledges globalisation and pluralisation by widening its contributor base with non-institutionally aligned Australasian and European authored chapters. Consistent with its critical theory lineage, Public Relations: Critical Debates and Contemporary Practice (L’Etang and Pieczka, 2006a) has a more philosophical, and less PR-centred, bibliography than most literature in the discipline – authors cited at some length include US network theorist Manuel Castells, French poststructuralist Michel Foucault, and British sociologist, Bryan Turner, all of whom are used for conceptual updating that acknowledges aspects of the new context.
30
Signs of the times
Among the important commonalities between both of these collections are their casts of academic contributors and their orientation, albeit less sustained in the former, towards moving the field beyond two-way symmetry. The academic focus, the attempt to open new directions acknowledging the change in media conditions, and the reworking of a previous volume, are all common to the third of these 2006 books, Moloney’s (2006) Rethinking PR: PR Propaganda and Democracy. While published as a second edition of his earlier Rethinking PR: The Spin and the Substance (Moloney, 2000), this book, as we will show in Chapter 3, significantly extends that earlier work, notably on the Grunigian paradigm. Our fourth selection, Where the Truth Lies: Trust and Morality in PR and Journalism (Hobsbawm, 2006a), is very different from the others. The contributors, who are largely journalists and PR practitioners, completely ignore the Grunigian paradigm and touch only briefly on other academic PR theory. They foreground a different agenda, in a context heavily marked by contemporary, mainly British, conditions. And they are much more direct in naming, and engaging with, such current issues as: lack of public reputation and trust, insularity, interactions with journalism, the political economy, implications of new technologies, transparency of media and PR, and even global financial literacy in Anna Schiffrin’s (2006) “PR in developing countries”, which provides a model for non-exploitative relationships that should be a template for new PR initiatives in the area. Eschewing simplistic generalities, editor Hobsbawm’s (2006b) introduction does not pretend that the issues are easy. Nevertheless, she notes with approval the crucial shift in emphasis from the unseen to the seen, declares herself “in favour of continuing the trend of making PR’s role more public” (Hobsbawm, 2006b, p. 2) despite difficulties in knowing “how truth is interpreted, and the different truths of those telling it, and on whose behalf” (p. 11). All of these introduce complications into notions of mutual communication exchanges as a permanent answer and she does not rest at either idealism or hopelessness. Hobsbawm’s (2006c) own individual chapter puts many of us academics to shame in setting out specific proposals for improving ethics practically and for educating publics through increased visibility for both professions. She cites David Michie’s (1998) observation that “ ‘a fascinating picture would emerge if newspapers were required to print the names of PR consultants providing them with materials for each issue, in the same way that foodstuffs manufacturers have to give details of their products’ contents on the packaging’ ” (cited in Hobsbawm, 2006c, p. 123). She then goes on to extend this new transparency and label it “ ‘Inside Out Information’ or IOI” (Hobsbawm, 2006c, p. 122). Taking advantage of Internet possibilities, she proposes providing websites with inside information on the connections, sources, and creators of media stories and lists of PR clients “something along the lines of the academic model of citations, so that the audience for a story can really track and trace its origins . . . and understand much more fully the basis on which that story has reached them” (Hobsbawm, 2006c, p. 124). Specific suggestions include asking the BBC to consider
Signs of the times
31
offering “a continuous Big Brother-style broadcast of the newsgathering teams making their choice of stories” and the “best PR agencies” allowing “webcams to cover media relations activity” (Hobsbawm, 2006c, p. 125). In addition, because it is “irrefutable that the practices of PR and journalism are inexorably linked”, she opposes their educational segregation and while she does “not think that providing academic-based courses in either discipline can work without being done in tandem with direct experience, neither can learning about one practice work properly without learning fully about the other” (p. 126). As we discuss in Chapter 8, professional jurisdictions have a major impact on the creation and maintenance of a profession, so this suggestion to shift from competition to cooperation may help ensure PR’s survival. Along similar survival through cooperation strategy lines, Hobsbawm (2006c) contends that there is a need to widen the current watchdog regime since “there is no single trade body or legally defined group that currently has at its heart the twin practices and ethical considerations of journalism and public relations” (p. 127). To address the absence, she proposes establishing a Media Commission to deal “with the practical and interconnected issues between PR and journalism and broadcasting” (Hobsbawm, 2006c, p. 128). Hobsbawm’s (2006c) own firm practices what she calls “Integrity PR” (by matching its principles with its client list) and has succeeded “despite suspicion of the idea by an industry that took some time to accept that to believe in your client (or the cause you espouse) is essential if you are to be believed by the media you inform and lobby” (p. 126). Nor is Hobsbawm unaware of the economic pressures against integrity in PR and for accepting socially dubious clients. Borkowski’s (2006) sometimes tongue-in-cheek chapter, “Is honesty the best policy?”, makes plain the pressures, the temptations, and the professional challenges: Whatever ethical position you take, it’s extremely difficult when times are hard and your loyal employees are banging their begging bowls on your door to turn down income from drug companies, arms manufacturers, GM crop researchers, cosmetic firms with a taste for guinea pig testing, gasguzzling 4 4 makers, political parties, hell, even tobacco manufacturers . . . They all need good PR desperately, and no one is prepared to pay more than them for a slice of your time and a turn on the media roundabout. The organized pre-planned use of lies to create column inches and TV coverage is at its most cunning and electrifying when employed by companies or individuals with plenty to hide. (pp. 36–37)
From pessimism to lines of flight: emotional matters, public diplomacy, and propaganda for peace Within US PR, one significant voice strongly suggests that all is not well in how post-excellence study PR intersects with its context. Educator, practitioner, textbook author, and leading historian of the field, Scott Cutlip’s (1995) final
32
Signs of the times
historical book ends with a lament for the state of the nation and for PR’s contribution to that lamentable state: This is my last work in a career that has spanned 62 years in newswork, public relations, and education of two generations of public relations practitioners. As I pass the baton to the present generation of journalists, practitioners, and educators, I do so with a sense of deep concern for the vitality and integrity of the nation’s public information system, the public information system on which we must depend to govern ourselves and do the nation’s business. America’s public relations practitioners, some 150,000 strong, wield a major influence in that system by providing nearly half of the mainstream media’s daily content. Their effort is to put a favorable spin on the news in the interest of the client, not the public’s interest. (pp. 282–283) Cutlip’s (1995) assessment is salutary and it is noteworthy that it appears in print over a decade after J. Grunig and Hunt’s (1984) reshaping of the field and three years after the publication of the first large excellence study collection (J. Grunig, 1992a). If Cutlip had believed that excellence study research and theory had begun to transform the field, surely he would have been less pessimistic. We end this chapter with an intermittently recurring feature: a brief exposition of what, adapting Deleuze and Guattari (1972, 1987), we term a “line of flight”. Our pathways are less expansive than those French philosophical sources: each is simply designed to offer ways of escaping the current iron cage of a narrowly rational positivism inhibiting an intellectually insular field. We found reading Cutlip’s (1995) deeply-felt lament for the negative role of PR despite a lifetime of commitment to the field, to be a moving experience. The time has come to recognise that PR is not only cognitive. Emotion and desire have been undervalued and have been slow to emerge in academic PR (but see Yeomans, 2006), yet emotional matters have received considerable attention in business (Goleman, 1998; Goleman et al., 2002). That shift in attention has been powered by the growing impact of insights from the new field of cognitive neuroscience developed since the 1970s. Gazzaniga et al. (2002) describe the field as “a hybrid of disciplines . . . [with] roots in neurology, neuroscience, and cognitive science” (p. 7). Their book also tracks the rapid progress in the field through technological advances that enable the physical tracking of feelings in the brain. They quote Joseph LeDoux (1998), a leading authority on The Emotional Brain, who concludes that “the brain did evolve to deal with danger and other so-called emotional situations without cognition and consciousness . . . and I’m taking a chance and assuming that invertebrates are not consciously aware of their emotional reactions” (cited in Gazzaniga et al., 2002, p. 543). In parallel neurological research, Antonio Damasio (1994) has identified the associated mistake as “Descartes’ Error” whereby excessively logical behaviour can cause us to make irrational decisions. Damasio (1994) suggests that a more
Signs of the times
33
consciously emotional response is justified because of the residual and erroneous Cartesian hangover of a disembodied mind. In fact he continues: “Versions of Descartes’ error obscure the roots of the human mind in a biologically complex but fragile, finite, and unique organism” and, as a result of failing “to see the inherent tragedy of conscious existence”, people “feel far less called upon to do something about minimizing it, and may have less respect for the value of life” (p. 250). We think the emotional underpinnings to the dire situation described by Cutlip deserve much further scrutiny. However let us end with an instance of what happens when emotions are consciously mobilised in a way that pushes through one of the excellence study shibboleths, US propaganda. To do so we quote at length from a telling tale in the public domain from a former insider. Nancy Snow’s (2004b) book chapter, “From bombs and bullets to hearts and minds: U.S. public diplomacy in an age of propaganda” is powered by personal feeling and suggests what is possible if the spectre haunting PR, propaganda, is acknowledged and addressed directly. Between 1992 and 1994, Snow (2004b) worked (although she acknowledges this was not in the official job description) as what she terms “a government propagandist by the U.S. Information Agency (USIA) and the State Department in Washington, D.C.” whose “euphemism was public diplomacy” (p. 17). They aimed to “ ‘tell America’s story to the world’ ” (Snow, 2004b, p. 17) and she goes on to record how after September 11, it became “clear that the propaganda war was underway” (p. 17) and the US was participating by disseminating US propaganda even if it still preferred the euphemism of public diplomacy. Her conclusion is refreshingly honest and partisan in openly pushing for propaganda for peace: Right now, every night, as we sleep, the war propagandists, both state and stateless actors, are dominating the media landscape. This should come as no surprise, because war is viewed by many as an efficient means of carving up centralized zones of power – the power to control, the power to dominate, both through message and force. Peace propaganda needs the same amount of diligence and hard work. If we spend too much time worrying about using propaganda for peace, we will continue to subject ourselves to governments and other interest groups who are more than willing and able to utilize propaganda methods for their own violent causes. If your cause is the cause of peace, then utilize communications responsibly, truthfully, and effectively. This is a call to arms, to arm ourselves with knowledge, content, and context generated from open and diverse channels of communication. White House news conferences, CNN, and Al-Jazeera should not be watched in a vacuum, separated from the world’s people. If so, then the world will remain in the hands of the war propagandists. (Snow, 2004b, p. 2)
3
Pluralising theory Academic empires, excellence, and global implications
As Pimlott (1951) observed in the middle of the last century: “Public relations is not a peculiarly American phenomenon, but it has nowhere flourished as in the United States. Nowhere else is it so widely practiced, so lucrative, so pretentious, so respectable and disreputable, so widely suspected and so extravagantly extolled” (p. 3). As well her advocacy of propaganda’s positive possibilities, Snow (1998, 2004a, 2004b) is unusual in her multiple accounts of contemporary US propaganda. Post 9/11, however, she is part of a growing trend in the US that both acknowledges PR as part of the same family of activities as propaganda, albeit as “its ‘black sheep’ cousin” (Carden, 2005, p. 614), and that exhorts the field to engage with it. Following Jowett and O’Donnell’s (1992) muted admission that “propaganda is not necessarily an evil thing” (p. 271), Burton St. John III (2006), for example, urges PR practitioners and scholars alike to “move beyond the 80-year-old progressive stance that refuses to acknowledge an ethical role for propaganda” (p. 227). According to Moloney (2006), the intervention of Grunigian theory during “the Cold War between capitalism and communism in economics, and between liberal democracy and dictatorship in politics”, positioned PR as taking “a progressive journey towards betterment, if not perfection” through “an intellectual route map that in its stages distanced PR from propaganda, and made public relations intellectually respectable, decently practicable, and legitimately teachable at public expense in the ideological and geopolitical circumstances of the 1980s” (p. 3). To reach their two-way symmetric destination, PR practice first travels from one-way asymmetrical communication, “with complete truth not essential”, through one-way symmetrical with “truth important”, and two-way asymmetric, whose purpose was “Scientific persuasion” with “imbalanced effects” (J. Grunig and Hunt, 1984, p. 22). In effect, by situating two-way symmetrical communication as a theoretically ideal, already practised, and widely attainable, form of PR, J. Grunig and Hunt’s (1984) model severed the connection between public relations and propaganda. In what is, retrospectively, a breathtaking break with time-bending implications (see Chapter 9), they relegate propaganda almost entirely to the province of propagandists as a different breed of communicators. The engineered gap between PR and propaganda allows “PR teachers and students [to] glide over the state-
Pluralising theory
35
ment that three parts of the Grunigian typology are pathologies of the fourth and not much practiced part (two-way symmetrical)” (Moloney, 2006, p. 168). In effect, by “exposure and repetition the ‘ought’ of the fourth has become the ‘is’ of the other three” with “an implied judgement that PR has become two-way respectful dialogue with others – or that it soon will” (Moloney, 2006, p. 168). Before the declaration of the break, (i.e. in the period before two-way symmetry was explicitly executable), pre-excellence study PR belonged to an almost prehistoric period of asymmetry and so evaded moral evaluations. In the contemporary world only poor practice, which fails to live up to, or does not aspire to, the Grunigian standards, has a link to propaganda. And this is irrespective of how infrequently two-way symmetrical practice occurs. Logically, once its existence has been confirmed, it can be diminishing, or need never actually recur again, for the same theoretical effect to be achieved. The resulting dismissal of existing asymmetrical practices as anachronistic, apart from specific circumstances (and sectors, such as entertainment), shifts attention away from engaging with actual flawed practice (other than to say it should follow excellence research principles). The excellence team cite Moloney’s earlier version of the British pedagogic consequences at some length: For university teachers seeking to found their work on an academically respectable basis, his [J. Grunig’s] and Hunt’s work were welcome to staff competing on campuses for resources against teachers of older and more established disciplines. The Grunigian paradigm gave them academic status. More emotionally, it met internalized needs of UK public relations teachers who had to convince themselves that they were worth a place on higher education campuses. Whatever the explanations, the outcome in the lecture theatre has too often been: “Public relations is a good thing called symmetrical communications” rather than “Maybe it should be that but the data seem not to fit”. (Moloney, 1997, p. 140, cited in J. Grunig et al., 2002, p. 319) L. Grunig et al. (2002) frame this account as a “naive utopian portrayal of the two-way symmetrical model”, go on to quote Moloney (1997) further on “distortions by disciples” (p. 319), and use his words that the “normative aspect of symmetrical communication has, so to speak, been over-stamped on its minority existence” (p. 140) to illustrate “that it is a mistake to believe that a normative theory describes all positive practice” (p. 319). When Moloney (2006) returns to the theme nine years later, he comments that “Grunigians can be read as though they regret the popularity of asymmetrical PR”, but it “is the natural outcome of PR practice in its drive for communicative self-advantage, and it is an outcome that is sought after” (p. 167).
36
Pluralising theory
Interpreting symmetry Accordingly, the Grunigian map acts as distorted projection in glossing over the “drive for communicative self-advantage” and remains content to have the collateral benefits of grateful educators and practitioners rather then address power directly. Along with the most critical (see, for example, Cheney and Christensen, 2001b; Gandy, 1982; Kersten, 1994; Kunczik, 1994; Leitch and Neilson, 2001; L’Etang, July, 1995; L’Etang, 1996; Pieczka, 1995, 1996; Stauber and Rampton, 1995; Weaver et al., 2006) and other dissenting, theorists (see, for example, Cancel et al., 1999; Coombs, 1993; Heath, 1992; Karlberg, 1996; Leichty and Springston, 1993; Miller, 1989; Murphy and Dee, 1996; Vasquez, 1996), we continue to perceive the two-way symmetrical form as one, or all, of the following: flawed, largely normative at best (and, at worst, misleading in its promise of equality of exchange amid realities of uneven power), very restricted in practice, and, to date, structured in support of socially exclusionary practices (Dozier and Lauzen, 1998). The list is by no means exhaustive. In fact, it is extracted from just those authors selected for a re-education class in two-way symmetry in one excellence publication (L. Grunig et al., 2002, pp. 310–327). Nor is it just opponents that J. Grunig finds in naive error: “Both the disciples of the symmetrical theory and critical scholars who debunk it seem to have reconstructed the theory inaccurately in their minds – to the extent that the theory appears to be ridiculous” (J. Grunig, 2001, p. 18). The track record of symmetry development, rather than “numerous revisions of the theory we have made over the years as a result of research” (Grunig, 2001, p. 17), looks more like a series of gradual adjustments to external criticism. The process follows a pattern of points being met with silence, or denial, then slow uptake, then incorporation. Examples include Murphy’s (1991) piece on Game Theory, which went on to earn entry into the Grunigian canon for the previously excluded concept of mixed motives: “In actuality, I never viewed the two-way symmetrical model as one of pure cooperation or total accommodation . . . Therefore, Murphy’s mixed-motive model actually described the two-way symmetrical model as . . . originally conceptualized” (J. Grunig, 2001, p. 12). Similarly, Dozier and Lauzen’s (1998) critique of the limits of symmetry in relation to disadvantaged groups was initially rejected before it was reinstated as the acceptable face of critical theory. We perceive the same pattern in philosophical issues. So while L. Grunig et al. (2002) write that some critical scholars “have asserted that our theories of public relations are ‘modernist’ – that is, based on a belief in rational, linear, and positivist scientific thought”, the excellence theorists themselves “believe the symmetrical model and the theory of strategic management . . . are decidedly postmodern” (p. 328). While symmetrists have been fiddling with making external views fit their theory, and helping educationists to feel good about teaching PR, the field has been burning with unaddressed issues and lack of academic and social status. In relation to both, postmodernism goes beyond instrumental rationality to engage with the limits of reason, epistemology, the representation
Pluralising theory
37
of the world, the nature of contemporary power, and the relativity of power/knowledge configurations. Symmetry has no substantive engagement with these issues. At this stage let us be clear that, although we have multiple doubts about its methodology, its intellectual depth, its standards of proof, and its implementation, we have no problem with the idealism of two-way symmetry. To us it is common sense that, for long term relationships, you treat your partners and prospective partners with respect as to what they say and what they seek and discuss ways to resolve differences. The real difficulties come with how to do that. The “symmetrists”, to use Brown’s (2006, p. 206) commendably brief collective term for excellence study adherents, draw little from dialogue research that pays attention to specifics (see Kent and Taylor, 2002) and have not used their ascendancy to pioneer replicable dialogue-building techniques. Two-way symmetry may serve a purpose in reassuring some educators, and building disciplinary self-esteem, but the reassurance lacks substance. Meantime, in acting as a weapon of mass distraction it diverts discussions from what one practitioner/scholar termed the “dirty realities” of PR that will have to be addressed if the discipline is to earn a good name. In addition, the symmetrists often behave in decidedly asymmetrical fashion. Their research is firmly organisation-centric, rather than from the publics’ perspective, and more from the top of the organisation at that – see the appendices on “Questionnaires for Heads of Public Relations Departments” (L. Grunig et al., 2002, pp. 563–600) and on “Questionnaire for CEO or Other Member of the Dominant Coalition” (pp. 601–609). The asymmetrical absence of data from disadvantaged publics leaves symmetrists’ claims to mutual benefit as one-sided assertions. Certainly evidence from activists suggests a deeply asymmetrical situation usefully summarised in the foreword to Lubbers’ (2002) collection on Battling Big Business by Naomi Klein (2002): this book does not tell the story of corporations defending themselves against public concern and criticism with facts, arguments and improved practices. It tells the story of a few very powerful multinationals using, in Eveline Lubbers’ words, “a bag of dirty tricks” against their critics, from setting up fake activist organizations, to sending in spies to infiltrate meetings, to pressuring the state to treat legitimate activists like terrorists . . . for those who don’t identify as activists, but believe in the principles of open debate and free expression, this book should serve as a warning. PostSeptember 11, many of the strategies used to silence anti-corporate activists are being used against much broader segments of the population. (pp. 8–10) Instead, the excellence study constantly speaks for those on the other side of symmetry from the organisational perspective. This is clear in their adoption of the agency’s perspective in one of their own examples. Vercˇicˇ et al. (1996) describe a context where many organisations do not have experience of activist
38
Pluralising theory
pressure to “incorporate the demands of activists into strategic planning, therefore, Pristop [the leading Slovenian agency involved] organizes the opposition to communicate with its client” (pp. 59–60). As a result, according to a partner of the firm, “for maybe four or five of the disputes it was not the activist group that organized themselves” (cited in Vercˇicˇ et al., 1996, p. 60). Moreover, Pristop continued to persevere with these tactics despite knowing some other “major players would take advantage because the activists have no tradition of organizing themselves” (cited, p. 60). However, the explanation for Pristop’s move was not to improve democracy, but for the system to work properly for their client organisation: We have organized the activists so that management gets the other side organized to talk with. Because the basic problem at the beginning is who is representing whom? If you have several hundred people on the other side, say in some local community, you’ve got to talk. We help organize the other side so that at least you can engage in negotiations. Otherwise, there is no one with whom you can negotiate. (cited in Vercˇicˇ et al., 1996, p. 60) This is an isolated but welcome example of specific difficulties that bring an outside public into the account. It raises central issues about who is representing whom. These have to be fully examined from the activist group side before twoway symmetrists can claim win-win situations. Amongst environmentalists, the fiercer debate concerns whether spokespeople for environmental causes should take any paying position at all with corporates that have bad environmental records. Monbiot’s (2002) “The Greens get eaten”, for example, is scathingly dismissive of leading figures in eco-movements who go on to work with “companies whose practices they once contested” (p. 53). He sees the environmental movement at risk “of being swallowed by the corporate leviathan” (Monbiot, 2002, p. 55) and that no one “threatens its survival as much as greens who have taken the company shilling” (p. 55). In her treatment of activism L. Grunig’s (1992) organisation-centred attitude is captured in her chapter title “Activism: how it limits the effectivism of organizations and how excellent public relations departments respond” and her nine assumptions about activism assume nothing positive about activists despite claiming that instead of “trying to dominate their environment, practitioners of this model [two-way symmetry] want to understand and to cooperate with their relevant external publics” (pp. 513–514) and noting that activist pressure creates an opportunity for communicators to gain more organisational power and status. The results of the neglect of the nonorganisational side of symmetry was noted in as late as Karagianni and Cornelissen’s (2006) “Anti-corporate movements and public relations”, which accurately observed: “the public relations literature (as an important source of knowledge for practitioners) is very much in its infancy and does not offer the theoretical and conceptual tools to analyze and understand this emerging movement” (p. 168).
Pluralising theory
39
That neglect of research by the excellence study could be compensated by drawing on data and fieldwork from other disciplines. In the field of organisational communication, such communication research is more widespread with diverse organisations and communities, such as Cheney’s (1999) Values at Work: Employee Participation Meets Market Pressure at Mondragón in a workers’ cooperative. Indeed the author of that study has, from the 1980s, been among the area research leaders. Cheney and Christensen (2001b) did in fact comment that the two-way symmetrical model was idealistic and recommended the precaution of not taking “managerial accounts and self-reports, such as the ones presented in J. Grunig’s chapter [J. Grunig, 2001, pp. 11–30], at face value” (p. 180), because, where ideas such as symmetry “have become almost sacred terms . . . it should be no surprise to find these notions often used and represented by decision makers in their descriptions of organizational practice” (p. 180). This comment drew the following rather asymmetric response from L. Grunig et al. (2002): Such a claim is the ultimate put-down of both quantitative and qualitative approaches to social science and, if accepted, would discredit all of the research evidence that we have painstakingly gathered and interpreted in this book. Cheney and Christensen (2001) would have us believe that the participants in our research were deluding themselves or lying to us. (p. 320) However, as Cheney and Christensen’s writing testifies, the social world is not naturally equal so symmetrical strategies and tactics, have to acknowledge inequalities and find ways of equalising communication power. Moloney (2006) provides practical strategies for addressing equity in communication and PR. Noting a positive social shift in how more “marginal, resource-poor groups are lobbying now than forty years ago”, he suggests that their access to policy-makers would increase with more measures (private and public subsidy) to produce PR communicative equality” and that, without such measures, lobbying is “a concern for democrats because it mostly mobilises bias in favour of powerful and dominant organisations and groups” (p. 12). Following British precedents, Moloney (2006) focuses thinking on PR equity provisions, akin to already existing legal aid provisions, for resource-poor groups through a series of questions: “Could voluntary service councils subsidise PR agencies to offer free PR advice, as legal aid centres support lawyers offering legal advice? Could legal aid centres have PR advice sections in them? Could citizens’ advice bureaux offer PR advice?” (p. 81). Observing that PR “resource equalisation is already on the agenda of the voluntary sector”, he argues for significant extensions in order that: it be systematised and expanded into a communicative equality to promote social justice. Such equality need not be focused exclusively on the social disadvantaged. Poor communications resourcing is not uncommon in other
40
Pluralising theory sectors, and non-commercial groups wanting a PR “voice” for new technologies (e.g. nanotechnology), environmental practices (e.g. renewable energy sources) or lifestyles (e.g. trans-sexuals) could be given a communications subsidy. The media also has a training role vis-à-vis resource-poor groups . . . The UK media takes up that role via the Media Trust, sponsored and supported by media organisations and PR firms. Its purpose is “to help charities communicate” and it trains them in PR. (Moloney, 2006, p. 81)
This is a thoughtful proposal with an agenda to move beyond idealism to practice. It comes from someone who writes from within PR, who has been a practitioner for a significant part of his career, and who comes to a credibly nuanced conclusion that “the positive effects of PR still outweigh the negative ones – just” (Moloney, 2006, p. 176). It offers tangible defence against external criticism and offers a way to engage with the low public standing of the profession. The low academic standing of the discipline is another question.
Testing symmetry in two locations: can’t live without it (in PR) and don’t notice it (outside PR) Henry Mintzberg (2004), in his iconoclastic attack on MBA education, suggested the bottom line for measuring MBA results was performance in the top positions in the business world after graduation. Accordingly, Harvard Business School’s achievement in placing their MBA graduates in CEO positions mattered less than what those CEOs subsequently achieved for their organisations (Mintzberg, 2004, pp. 112–116). Building on that useful line of thinking, we examined two-way symmetry’s achievement through the extent to which it is not only picked up, but operationalised, in congruent disciplinary fields. As a rough test, we sought out any references to the Grunigian two-way symmetrical communication model by authors publishing in recent authoritative handbooks or collections in adjacent fields between 2002 (18 years after the publication of Managing Public Relations and ten years after the 1992 Excellence volume – and therefore time enough for impact and influence to permeate) and 2006. The oldest, Carlsnaes et al. (2002) Handbook of International Relations, a substantial 571-page volume with 28 individual chapters involving 34 different authors, makes no mention of either J. Grunig or two-way symmetrical communication. We were unable to find a handbook of political communication so we took two different texts to act as substitutes. The first, Esser and Pfetsch’s (2004) book, Comparing Political Communication: Theories, Cases, and Challenges, contained 17 chapters, 21 contributing authors, and 418 pages, and had a rough comparability with a handbook. It did not yield a single reference to J. Grunig or two-way symmetry either. In fairness, both cases may be linked to disciplinary divisions, as neither field interacts much with PR. Nonetheless, if two-way symmetry were useful to understanding public interactions, it would be reasonable to expect citation.
Pluralising theory
41
Our second substitute for a handbook of political communication was Kaid’s (2004) Handbook of Political Communication Research, which features 540 pages, with 19 chapters and 30 contributing authors. It does register influence in an interesting way: one of the 19 chapters devotes most of a page to the relevance of two-way symmetry in improving Internet democracy (Tedesco, 2004, p. 524). This application seems unjustly neglected, and offers an arena for possible use for symmetrical, or at least some of the less asymmetrical, exchanges on the net. Although without any attribution, Holtz’s (2002) Public Relations on the Net seems to build explicitly from the two-way symmetry concept: “The best public relations efforts are not only two-way but also symmetrical – that is, they afford both the company and the strategic audience equal opportunities to participate in the discussion and – even more important – equal opportunities to achieve their objectives” (p. xiv). Our final two fields lie closer to PR and have a record of interaction with it. Indeed some of their authors and editors have demonstrated considerable facility in, as well as familiarity with, the discipline. In Harris and Fleisher’s (2005) Handbook of Public Affairs, for example, both editors are knowledgeable about, and have published on, PR. Nevertheless, in that volume (with 579 pages, 29 chapters, and 31 contributing authors), the only reference to the Grunigian canon is a one page mention of J. Grunig and Hunt (1984), and that is in relation to lobbying and not symmetry. Jablin and Putnam’s (2001) The New Handbook of Organizational Communication offers a distinctive exception to the other evidence of omission. It has the healthiest representation with 27 citations of J. Grunig and nine referring to two-way symmetry. However, two-way symmetry appears less influential than its nine citations suggest because all appear within only two of the volume’s 20 chapters, one of which, Sutcliffe (2001), is concerned with “Organizational environments and organizational information processing”, where it would be hard to ignore PR. At present it is difficult to write on PR and ignore two-way symmetry. The other chapter that addresses two-way symmetry (Cheney and Christensen, 2001a) considers the relationship between internal and external communication. Despite a generous acknowledgement of the normative value of the two-way symmetrical model “as an important communication ideal or beacon in today’s society” (p. 261), Cheney and Christensen (2001a) suggest that in practice this model may function to embed inequity: the analyst interested in ethical and democratic issues should pay attention to the possibility that the communication systems being developed these days – though avowedly to satisfy the general public’s demand for insight and participation – are too closed around organizations and their active and resource rich publics and stakeholders . . . What appear, to some observers, as symmetrical systems of communication may, in other words, turn out to be “corporatist” systems organized around specific issues with only limited access to the non-organized stakeholders . . . Such a pattern of communication by and among well-established and resource-rich entities can exacerbate
42
Pluralising theory the problem of dominance of the “free speech” arena by corporate and other large organizational interests. (p. 261)
So overall, the picture is of a continuing lack of significant uptake for symmetrical theory in other important disciplinary sites. That is of concern to a field seeking respectability. It is not a concern with regard to rhetoric in PR, which has never sought such ascendancy or uniqueness and is comfortable sitting alongside other approaches within PR, as in Toth and Heath’s (1992) Rhetorical and Critical Approaches to Public Relations, or alongside other perspectives on common topics of interest such as O’Hair et al.’s (forthcoming) Terrorism: Communication and Rhetorical Perspectives and permeate other disciplines as in the Handbook of Risk and Crisis Communication (O’Hair and Heath, forthcoming). The excellence study has taken a more exclusive route. If, as Botan and Hazleton (2006b) claim, two-way symmetry is the first dominant paradigm in PR: why are congruent fields so uninterested? And why are those who do register any interest so doubtful of its value in practice? Moloney’s (2006) insight on the prevalence of the Grunigian paradigm having more to do with comforting PR teachers in the specific educational, political, and social conditions of the late twentieth century provides one logical answer. Whatever the answer, we see good reasons to resist both the push of US PR to become more dominant internationally and the symmetrists’ reach for global primacy, in both the geographical and the universal senses. In Kelly’s (2005) challenging times of swiftly-altering environments, and considerable uncertainty, we see canonisation attempts and claims for global applicability as out of step with the context. Knowledge is better dispersed among plural knowledge traditions, which are often locally influenced, increasingly decentralised, and changing quickly. Knowledge configurations need to attune to learning from criticisms and to gather from diverse sources to adapt to new circumstances. The negative chorus of voices not only comes from outside the field. Even before the deception employed to launch the invasion of Iraq, Cutlip’s (1995) discussion of what he calls the “sense of deep concern for the vitality and integrity of the nation’s public information system”, is eloquently pessimistic: “The U.S. Military’s control of the news of the Gulf War with Iraq in 1991 was a perfect example of how news sources, guided by public relations officials, can control and shape the news with truth a casualty” (p. 283): Propagandist, press agent, public information officer, public relations or public affairs officer, political campaign specialists, trade association lobbyists – all are protected in our democratic system by the same First Amendment rights that journalists enjoy, enabling them to play a far more important opinion-making role that the public perceives, or that journalists (who themselves are only some 130,000 strong) are willing to admit. It is safe to say that more than 40% of today’s media content originates in the
Pluralising theory
43
word processors and fax machines of public relations specialists. The thrust of their work is always the same – to mobilize public opinion in the interest of the paying client. Their hope is to set the public agenda in their favor. These professional case-pleaders play to win. And usually do. The some 100 million dollars the insurance, medical, and health industries spent to kill President Clinton’s proposal for health reform in 1993–1994 is a case in point. (p. 283)
US primacy and the reach of the global Despite these failings, only five years later, leading excellence theorists asserted that “the American concept of public relations is the only global concept of public relations available currently” (Vercˇicˇ and J. Grunig, 2000, p. 12). Far from reflecting reality, we argue that the statement serves instead to self-validate US PR in general, and the excellence tradition in particular. Because of their status in the field, and the scope of the claim, which they themselves make, their justification requires consideration. It also opens up issues around certain terms – global (or universal), concept, and theory – with methodological and political dimensions. Vercˇicˇ and J. Grunig’s (2000) use of global, in “global concept” (p. 12), implies the meaning universal, as well as the geographical sense of global, at a time when PR as a practice has been spreading across the globe. This spread has mainly been from the developed to the developing world and several large US firms “each have client lists with a dozen or more national governments on them” (Botan and Hazleton, 2006b, p. 2). Furthermore, Montenegro (2004) extracts the revealing statistic from 2001 data that “the largest public relations firms, such as Fleishman-Hillard, Weber Shandwick Worldwide, Hill and Knowlton, and Burson-Marsteller earn about half of the fees abroad” (p. 102). It is in this climate that Vercˇicˇ and J. Grunig (2000) suggest that there is only one PR theory, which then clearly has universal aspirations to uniformity. This is somewhat at odds with the geographical sense of global that informs a steadily expanding, and clearly diverse, globalisation process. In Ritzer’s (2004) analysis, its impact and significance “is to be seen virtually everywhere . . . most visibly in the now-commonplace protests that accompany high-level meetings of such key global organizations as the World Trade Organization (WTO), the International Monetary Fund (IMF), and the World Bank” (p. 71). Despite noting “the level of protest against them” (p. 71), he foresees the globalisation process as leading to “the death of the local [italics in original]” (p. xiii). In this context where local ideas, as well as local practices, struggle to survive, we see no reason to stack the cards further in favour of the powerful by accepting that the US conception of PR is the only universal concept of public relations. If that were accepted, then, according to Vercˇicˇ and J. Grunig (2000), any conceptual criticism of PR would have to be criticism of the US conceptualisation of PR not because “other conceptualizations are not possible or even emerging” but as
44
Pluralising theory
“a simple but accurate statement that other conceptualizations have not yet been developed to a level that allows disciplined criticism” (p. 12). Within the next few years, Vercˇicˇ (2003) himself admitted the situation had changed and listed work “initiated on alternative conceptualizations, primarily in Europe . . . with reflections from Africa (Rensburg, 2002), Asia (Sriramesh, 2002) and Latin America (Ferrari, 2002)” (p. 478 fn). This acknowledgement, however, leaves the imperial reach of US methodology intact. In re-labelling what others termed “a new wave of Asian research” as “a series of small tributaries of American positivism”, Chris Ryan (2006), a leading international authority on tourism, captures the continuing methodological colonisation as so many US-educated Asian scholars return home with their implanted American conceptual equipment intact.
Strategic amnesia and empiricism’s empire PR, as numerous writers define it, is a management, or managerial function. Actually, only part of it is, and while that part may be the largest by far, the exclusion of non-management PR serves to foreground US PR as the prototype, when British (L’Etang, 2004), Israeli (Toledano, forthcoming), and even postcommunist Russian (Guth, 2000) PR, did not emerge primarily from business and the market sector. Moreover, the US emphasis, on big business and organisation-centred approaches, downplays PR as a means by which groups through the ages have argued their case and sought to achieve their aims. That said, modern management, like PR, did develop primarily in the US, but it has been open to other theoretical input, sometimes from other disciplines (Weber, 1964), as well as from theories and practices in other nations. The results have not always been universally appreciated as Clarke (2005) observes: The spread of management has been assisted by processes of naturalization. In the broadest sense, the specific formation of management as a social and organizational cadre is aided by the incontrovertible view that “wellmanaged organizations” are desirable. The blurring of general and specific in the word “management” has enabled the flourishing of a particular form of management (which is cost-conscious, power-hungry, anti-democratic, and tends toward a messianic view of its own importance). (p. 203) In the PR literature, Wakefield (1996) points out how Hampden-Turner and Trompenaars’ (1995) Seven Cultures of Capitalism raises alarm bells about the implications of cultural differences for American business in an environment of constant change. Summarising Hampden-Turner and Trompenaars’ work, Wakefield (1996) says that in a world where business and economic activity consists not of one universal model but seven different cultures of that one capitalist model, “the American value set is causing its organizations to lose ground in the emerging global marketplace” (p. 23). The subsequent rise of the
Pluralising theory
45
Chinese and Indian economies lends weight to Hampden-Turner and Trompenaars’ (1995) contentions and recalls earlier Japanese business success. That success is acknowledged in what one chapter in the excellence collection (J. Grunig, 1992a), called the “meteoric rise of Japan as an industrial and economic power . . . [that] spawned a plethora of books and journal articles about Japanese industry and management styles” (Sriramesh et al., 1992, p. 578). Admittedly, in relation to Japan, rather than management theory, the words used are cultural, economic, industrial, and management (often associated with styles rather than theoretical substance). At one point J. Grunig (1992b) concedes that the US is not the best place to practice excellence because: “Excellent management and excellent public relations, in essence, can flourish only in collaborative participative cultures”, a conclusion supporting the position that “symmetrical public relations cannot function without a major change in US culture and political structures” (p. 247). Perhaps there may be parallels with knowledge.
Beyond the parochial: empires, knowledge, and pluralism Abbott’s (2001) Chaos of Disciplines illustrates both how knowledge growth is neither so geographically linear nor so incontestable as PR theorists may desire. He attacks axiomatic foundations for universal knowing, and links a lineage of contested knowledge from the early Roman Empire to the present day: the larger, universal framework for social science is by no means the standard, often-parodied axiomatic structure. Rather it resembles what the Romans called the law of peoples (ius gentium), a law that they applied to diverse groups at the edges of empire and that they distinguished from the formalized civil law (ius civile) that applied specifically to Roman citizens. There is no universal social scientific knowledge of the latter kind – systematic, axiomatic, universal in a contentless sense. There is only universal knowledge of the former kind, a universal knowledge emerging from accommodation and conflict rather than from axioms, a universal knowledge that provides tentative bridges between local knowledges rather than systematic maps that deny them, a universal knowledge that aims, like the ius gentium, at allowing interchange among people who differ fundamentally. (p. 5) The concept of a conflict-free knowledge has similarly been deconstructed in organisation theory. Shenhav (2003) has convincingly argued that the “conflictladen history of management and organizations was edited out of the canon” and proposes a more reflexive approach, which, rather than accepting instrumental rationality, proposes reformulating it “as a cultural system [mainly constructed in America]” in order to undercut “the assumption that instrumental rationality is a universal ontological feature of nature and society” (p. 203). Shenhav (2003)
46
Pluralising theory
further notes the growing body of literature along these lines in the field and the associated establishment of “an alternative epistemological position . . . [with] a new critical outlet Organization . . . established mainly by European entrepreneurs-academics to give voice to heterogeneous views” (p. 203). These heterogeneous challenges to the imperial reach of universalising American organisational theory are equally relevant to PR. They may, perhaps, give pause for thought to those who hold that instrumental rationality is an ultimate measure. Two examples spring to mind. The first is Toth’s (2002) functionalist, “Show me the money”-style demand for postmodern PR: “I would be uncomfortable if it didn’t help the field become more effective. There is a need for practicality in a good theory . . . postmodernism must have a cash value for modern public relations” (p. 243). The second is L. Grunig et al.’s (2002) expression of disdain for Pieczka (1996) because “like many critical scholars, [she] expressed more interest in criticizing the symmetrical theory than constructing a replacement” (p. 318) and is adversely contrasted with “Dozier and Lauzen’s (2000) call for marrying public relations theory and critical theory for the betterment of public relations practice” (p. 318). L. Grunig et al.’s (2002) dismissals of critical theory sit alongside our second interpretation of “undisciplined” theory as theory not governed by methodological positivism. Again, in other fields, these debates are history in the sense of being passé. In his chapter in the collection entitled International Theory: Positivism and Beyond (Smith et al., 1996), Smith (1996) describes the decadeold controversy in international theory: “For the last forty years the academic discipline of International Relations has been dominated by positivism” that “has involved a commitment to a unified view of science, and the adoption of methodologies of the natural sciences to explain the social world” (p. 11). This resulted in a tendency to “accept implicitly a rather simple and crucially, an uncontested set of positivist assumptions which have fundamentally stifled debate over both what the world is like and how we might explain it” (p. 11). Although he admits this was not true of the field’s critical scholars “because these writers never bought into the positivist assumptions that dominated the discipline”, Smith concluded that it was “the dominance of positivism that has accounted for both the character, and more importantly, the content of central debates in international theory” (p. 11). It is little wonder that in PR, the Grunigians and critical theorists disagree dramatically – see Roper’s (2005) insightfully provocative “Symmetrical communication: excellent public relations or a strategy for hegemony”. Moreover, one study that set out to test US excellence findings in the field in South Africa did not just fail to replicate them, but concluded that the whole replication enterprise risked distorting international research. Holtzhausen et al. (2003) “Exploding the myth of the symmetrical/asymmetrical dichotomy: public relations models in the new South Africa”, concluded: Based on our findings in this study, we challenge the application of the four historical U.S. models to international research settings. Research has long
Pluralising theory
47
ignored the statistical unreliability of these models, lending credence to the belief that it is typical for U.S. standards of practice to be artificially enforced in international settings. It also points to the way in which models are reified and, therefore, accepted unconditionally. The research literature suggests that such thinking prevents nations from developing their own models of practice because they continually seek to emulate U.S. practices. [. . .] We would encourage international practitioners to trust their own instincts and develop culture- and country-specific practice based on the economic, social, and political realities of their countries, using research methods that best suit their cultural environments. (p. 338) These findings come together with what is emerging, in 2006, as a critical mass of dissonant voices. Over ten years ago, international relations similarly rejected positivist bids to close out the field. Smith (1996) records one particular attempt by Robert Keohane, who used his Presidential Address to the International Studies Association in 1988 to speak of evaluating rival research paradigms “in terms of the ‘testable theories’, without which they ‘will remain in the margins of the field . . . [since] . . . it will be impossible to evaluate their research program’ ” (Keohane, 1989, pp. 173–174, cited in Smith, 1996, p. 13). As Smith (1996) goes on to observe: “this form of response reveals the dominance of positivism, since Keohane issues the challenge on grounds that are themselves positivist” (p. 13). Ten years on, Botan and Hazleton (2006b) similarly position two-way symmetry as PR’s only paradigmatic theory for two sets of reasons. The first, that “the field has failed to see enough merit in what they [critics of ‘the Symmetrical/Excellence approach’] have said to develop their work into alternative paradigms” is a valid point that leads Botan and Hazleton to identify a “need to encourage the development of additional and different theories of public relations” as a “primary goal” (p. 9).The second set of reasons, that critics of the symmetrists “have limited their remarks to critiques and failed to conduct affirmative research” (p. 9) tends towards a restrictive model of empirical testing and therefore positivist proof. Karl Weick (1989), in “Theory construction as disciplined imagination”, was of the opinion that “theorists often write trivial theories because their process of theory construction is hemmed in by methodological strictures that favor validation over usefulness” (p. 517). In international relations, within two years of their closure, Waever (1998) looked back on the field’s great debates and came to the mature conclusion that the last debate, between positivists and their critics, should be “seen not as a debate to be won, but a pluralism to work with” (p. 155). Organisation theory and international relations as fields escape the imperial bids of empiricists and it is time for PR to make more space for postpositivist traditions.
4
Moving the settings Multiple diversities and requisite varieties
It is only by making room for post-positivist traditions that we can look meaningfully at issues of equity in PR. Building on our macro view in the previous chapter about the overwhelmingly organisation-centric character of PR, we zoom into a micro examination of equity, in particular relation to diversity, in action in PR. We carry out this examination through a detailed critique of the field’s deployment of the concept of requisite variety. While PR theorists have sought to use requisite variety to introduce multiculturalism to a field slow to engage with cultural diversity, we argue that the deployment of the concept does not go far enough to engage with contemporary issues revolving around diversity. On the surface, the concept of requisite variety seems equitable enough: “Diversity or requisite variety is the characteristic that helps organizations identify all . . . groups and foster relationships with each” (Hon and Brunner, 2000, p. 313). What remains understated in this conceptualisation is the centrality of organisational control. This is evident from Hon and Brunner’s (2000) conviction that “the organization is most effective when it is diverse enough to deal with and capitalize on the diversity in its external environment” (p. 313). In such a formulation, “the diversity of ideas and viewpoints within a manager’s self-regulating system should equal diversity of the environment” (Culbertson et al., 1993, p. 23). As this quotation indicates, the emphasis clearly rests on the manager’s “self-regulating system” and requisite variety is, therefore, reduced to a mechanism of control. As theorised by the British psychiatrist W. Ross Ashby (1956/1963), the Law of Requisite Variety is a complex one. At its core, the law endorses the need for plurality and diversity because only variety can foster harmony in complex mechanisms whether they are biological, mechanical, or societal. Yet, ironically, the law of requisite variety is also about control. In fact, the law is laid out in Ashby’s (1956/1963) introduction to cybernetics, a field of study defined by the mathematician Norbert Wiener (1948/1961) as “the Science Of Control And Communication” (p. x). Despite the rhetoric about diversity, the law of requisite variety tends to see variety as “disturbances” that need to be managed by a calculated integration of variety by the regulator (read manager). Ashby (1956/1963), for instance, says that the:
Moving the settings
49
law of Requisite Variety enables us to apply a measure to regulation . . . There is first a set of disturbances D, that start in the world outside the organism, often far from it, and that threaten, if the regulator R does nothing, to drive the essential variables E outside their proper range of values. (p. 209) The essence of Ashby’s (1956/1963) formula is that the unlimited range of variety in the external world (designated as T in his formula) could disturb the equilibrium in an organism (or organisation) and so this variety would need to be strategically controlled by the incorporation of some variety in the process of regulation.
Focusing on the core: photographic metaphors and ethnocentric lenses This logic of regulation and management of variety is central to Karl Weick’s (1979) The Social Psychology of Organizing, which is the principal reference point for PR theorists working with the idea of requisite variety. Providing an example of requisite variety, Weick (1979) says that if a photographer has to photograph 20 subjects at different distances from his camera, he has to have at least 20 distinct settings to bring all the negatives to a uniform density and sharpness. As Weick (1979) points out, a camera with less than 20 settings “lacks requisite variety and will not register with sufficient detail enough of that environment so that control can be maintained over it” [italics not in original] (p. 189). As it moves from photography to management, this notion needs to be contextualised as it is significantly reframed through Hamel and Prahalad’s (1994) notion of “managerial frames”, which are acquired “through business schools and other educational experiences and from consultants and management gurus, absorbed from peers and the business press, and formed out of career experiences” (p. 54). These managerial frames are the “corporate equivalent of genetic coding” and “limit management’s perception to a particular slice of reality” (p. 54). We argue that it is this exercise of control, by what Hamel and Prahalad (1994) call a “dominant managerial frame” (p. 54) of organisational leaders that we see as slanted in favour of the West, which has kept the balance of power in the hands of a Western cultural elite and impeded the progress of multiculturalism in the area of PR. As the relative balance of managerial numbers shifts away from the West in favour of the rise of an Eastern managerial elite with global power, this frame needs to reflect a less ethnocentric reality. To date, however, multiculturalism, even as a concept, has been slow to emerge in PR literature. Until the 1980s, the theoretical moorings of PR were anchored largely in systems theory (e.g. J. Grunig and Hunt, 1984) and communication theory (e.g. Botan and Hazleton, 1989). The first references to requisite variety began to surface at the beginning of the
50
Moving the settings
1990s (Culbertson et al., 1993; Dozier et al., 1995; J. Grunig, 1992a; L. Grunig et al., 1992), more than a decade after Karl Weick (1979) talked about the concept in the context of making organisations effective. Even these references were limited in their scope because the need for diversity in PR was seen primarily from the point of view of the management. Without requisite variety, as some PR scholars have pointed out, “senior managers of organisations interact awkwardly with constituents different from themselves” (Dozier et al., 1995, p. 151), which in turn leads to difficulties in communication and misunderstandings. This obvious focus on managerial and organisational control was subsumed under the rhetoric of the theoretical formulation of the two-way symmetrical model of PR (J. Grunig and Hunt, 1984) that we critique in the previous chapter. Despite its professed democratic aspirations, this model “does not address the asymmetries inherent in discourse practices weighted in favour of one of the discourse participants” (Leitch and Neilson, 1997, p. 19), and does not look critically at PR in an environment of social inequality with lopsided power equations. Such an unequal environment frequently characterises relations between the Western organisational core and the other. This narrow focus on organisational or corporate control based on self-interest has not disappeared in the twenty-first century. Continuity of such control is evident in more recent PR research that still endorses the two-way symmetry model and its relationship with requisite variety (Hon and Brunner, 2000; Pompper, 2004). While this research does highlight the importance of acknowledging the importance of diversity in organisations, it does not point to a balance of power away from an overt (or sometimes covert) dominant managerial bias. The refusal to see the dynamics of power in PR is rather naive in relation to other fields. Rihani (2005), for example, points out: To control a system with a given level of variety, one is confronted by two choices: either reduce the variety of the system to be controlled, or give the controlling system at least as much variety as the system to be controlled. Traffic management provides a good illustration. The authorities could either reduce variety (by means of rules such as driving on one side of the road and giving way) or recruit a traffic policeman/woman for each and every driver on the road. They naturally choose the first alternative. Rihani’s (2005) example illustrates how the default setting in the concept of requisite variety is always designed to suit the strategic interests of the manager. Attempts by PR theory to draw on the concept, therefore, reflect the field’s inherent need to legitimise and consolidate the power of the dominant core. This core is embodied in what Banks (2000), in a book devoted to Multicultural Public Relations, calls “organizational leaders” (p. 122). Banks (2000) does bring multiculturalism in PR under the spotlight by describing PR as “a cultural activity” (p. 30) and talking about how the “cultural aspects of public relations communication indicate that intercultural communication theory must be sensi-
Moving the settings
51
tive to both interaction that creates and displays identities among cultural groups and communication as a culturally coded system of expressing identity” (p. 31). However, in prescribing a plan for the future of multicultural PR, Banks (2000) highlights the central position of organisational leaders by asserting that a “genuine dialogue with relevant publics will occur only when organisational leaders personally demonstrate that they ground their own communication in solidarity and mindfulness” (p. 122). He omits saying who these “organisational leaders” are. The question, therefore, remains: is multicultural PR only about the leaders of an organisation having equitable relations with a requisite variety of diverse publics, or is it about the organisation itself acquiring a multicultural character? By ignoring such questions, Banks (2000), along with other theorists in the field, ends up reducing requisite variety to tokenism. Shorn of the egalitarian veneer, requisite variety in PR literature only bolsters the image of an other that is markedly different from the dominant mainstream of an organisation represented by “organisational leaders” (Banks, 2000, p. 122) and “senior managers” (Dozier et al., 1995, p. 151). The leaders and the managers are classified into a distinct group that excludes the other. This is an elite group that manages diversity.
Controlling the settings: trapped in the time warp of mechanistic models The notion of managerial control of diversity is institutionalised in PR textbooks. Far from integrating issues of cultural diversity into the core concepts of PR, many textbooks contain only token sections on cultural diversity, multiculturalism, and minority publics. While Lattimore et al. (2004) quote the wellknown PR figure, J. Donald Turk, as saying that “diversity will be characteristic of the work force and customer mix, as well as one in which diversity will be valued and even required to be a successful business” (p. 363), their 390-page book devotes just over two pages to a sub-section on “Diversity” in a chapter on corporate PR. In many other books too, despite well-meaning attempts to acknowledge the importance of issues of cultural diversity, these topics are often described as “issues of ethnicity and other cultural problems” [italics not in original] (Newsom et al., 1996, p. 74). Advertising commercial and film-maker Spike Lee recently observed that “there is much more diversity in the film industry than the advertising industry, and there is hardly any diversity in the film industry!” (Lee, 2000). His observations, and his follow up claims that “if we want to reach consumers, our agencies should look like the consumers, at least to some extent” and that “it’s not just about what color you are, but about your whole perspective on life” (Lee, 2000, p. 68). In another popular textbook on PR, Wilcox et al. (1998) talk of the emergence of a major “target audience” of ethnic minorities who “differ from the traditional mainstream citizenry in race, language, and customs” (p. 235). In considering ethnic minorities, these authors see only a “target audience” or a market that needs to be developed. In such a setting, organisational interests are
52
Moving the settings
evidently the prerogative of the “traditional mainstream citizenry”. Ironically, in the very sections devoted to different diverse cultures, the phrase becomes no more than a euphemism for the dominant Western worldview. This parallels the approaches of organisational strategic thinking. In most large organisations, it is the “dominant managerial frame” (Hamel and Prahalad, 1994, p. 54) that puts into place an administrative system that reinforces “certain perspectives and biases” (p. 55) at the cost of others. It is this managerial frame that controls the organisation and, by extension, its various internal and external publics. The discussion of the concept of requisite variety in PR literature makes little or no attempt to give the dominant managerial frame a truly multicultural character. PR as technique is part of a systemic view of the organisation. Such a view remains conceptually trapped in the mechanistic model of communication outlined in the information model in Shannon and Weaver’s (1949) The Mathematical Theory of Communication. In their model, communication is essentially linear and moves from a source to a receiver and, as the originator of the communication process, the source is all powerful while the receiver remains passive. Such a transmission model has no room for political, social, economic, or cultural contexts. Its primary goal is to get the message from the source over to the recipients. The primacy of the source is what legitimises the communication plans of organisations: “Driven by the ‘logic of profit and competition’ ”, large corporations aim “to get their product to the largest number of consumers” (Morley and Robins, 1995, p. 11). The construction of a large market space is facilitated by the incorporation of smaller cultural spaces into the larger organisational culture defined by Western cultural norms, concepts, and ideologies. This dominant culture administered by “senior managers” (Dozier et al., 1995, p. 151), as part of the Western mainstream, then goes about controlling the large market space by carrying the non-Western “other” along. Multinational fast-food chains, for instance, devise PR campaigns that emphasise their attempts to incorporate local tastes, but ignore the fact that the genre of fast food itself is essentially Western and could be alien to some cultures. Coca-Cola is one example of a “global product bottling a blend of Western, American and ‘international’ values almost as hard to separate as the drink’s ingredients” (Moore, 1996, p. 68). This cultural control of the other by the dominant economic and social system fits neatly with other conceptualisations of PR. According to Miller (1989), for example, PR “serves as a definitional label for the process of attempting to exert symbolic control over the evaluative predispositions (‘attitudes,’ ‘images,’ etc.) and subsequent behaviors of relevant publics or clienteles” (p. 47). He goes on to suggest that “whenever control of the environment hinges on the attitudes and behaviors of others, attempts to control these attitudes and behaviors are inevitable” (p. 47). This organisational perspective, built around Western notions of organisational success and excellence, positions PR as an active tool of the organisation that “must contribute to achieving the profit goal of business in a competitive
Moving the settings
53
environment” (Cutlip et al., 1994, p. 437). There is obviously not much room for theories of cultural diversity in an environment geared towards profit-making by an elite group that runs the organisation without recognising the importance of diverse cultures to organisational well-being and growth. As acknowledgement of these cultures’ importance is beginning to win consent (see Hart, 2005; Mahajan and Banga, 2005; Prahalad, 2005), so, too, is the strength of the business case for more multicultural awareness, more multicultural organisations, and more multicultural leaders. Traditionally, as J. Grunig and Hunt (1984) express it, PR has been oriented to “the management of communication between an organisation and publics” (p. 8). In other words, the organisation is the sun around which the planet of PR revolves. As the organisational policy is essentially constructed by elite (mainly Western) policy-makers, PR practice ends up mirroring the interests of dominant groups. As a result, even when PR theorists advocate an engagement with other voices, they do not let go the primacy of the dominant core of the organisation. J. Grunig (2001) is typical in suggesting that “simultaneous fusion with the Other while retaining the uniqueness of one’s self-interest seems to describe well the challenge of symmetrical public relations” (p. 28). This emphasis on the centrality of organisational policy, reflected in the core aim of protecting “one’s self-interest”, restricts the role of the average PR practitioner. The symmetrists align their proposals with diversity but to date that is not happening in significant numbers in nations such as Britain (Edwards, 2006) and the US (Pompper, 2004). The symmetrists underpin the diversity axiom in two main ways. The first is economic – the need for requisite variety to fit market demands. This is condensed in the two sentence cover of The Public Relations Strategist’s “Special Diversity Issue” (PRSA, 2005): “The buying power of blacks, Asians and Native Americans will exceed $1.7 trillion by 2010, an increase of 268 percent from 1990. Are you ready?” This approach has already been taken up by several companies. Bush (2006), for example, talks about two separate PR campaigns by General Mills that specifically target AfricanAmerican and Hispanic communities. One campaign called “The Serving Up Soul Initiative” is geared towards increasing “awareness of General Mills’ products among African-American mothers”, while the other, titled the “Que Rica Vida” campaign, targets Hispanic mothers. What is interesting is the way the campaigns tap into the cultural reserves of minority communities to spread the way of life of dominant communities in a process that commodifies ethnicity. A part of the campaign aimed at the African-American community includes a competition to find a woman who can serve soul food in a creative way (Bush, 2006). The second way is moral – to do the right thing. Both these ways have their own values. However, a further, and more compellingly egalitarian argument, is how actively cultivating diversity increases creativity and grows the bottom line through developing employees with a range of diversities. Hampden-Turner and Trompenaars (2000) observe “More than we might expect, immigrants, refugees, outsiders, and diverse religious and ethnic groups within cultures have so often been successful at wealth
54
Moving the settings
creation that it cannot be a coincidence” (p. 6) and provide reasons in the rest of their book. That multiculturalism is good enterprise also informs Prahalad’s (2005) vision of the Third World as not only an untapped market but an untapped talent pool that can shape its own destiny without interference from the control processes and mechanisms of Western management practices.
Underexposed films: PR and the phobia of the other In following the voice of the dominant managerial frame of the organisation that employs him or her, the average practitioner is often left to see PR as an organisational activity rather than a public activity. And, in viewing PR primarily as an organisational activity, PR professionals, steeped as they are in unidimensional notions of efficiency, productivity, and persuasiveness, are unable to see the complexities of race, culture, and ethnicity. Even when they do recognise cultural differences, they tend to assume that every cultural group is homogenous. The lack of an awareness of the diversity within each such group inevitably leads to stereotyping of the other which, in turn, becomes a barrier in the way of establishing meaningful relationships at a public level. The disjuncture between organisational and public activities is best illustrated by a contemporary conceptualisation of PR in New Zealand, a country defined by the bi-cultural goals of the Treaty of Waitangi (signed between the British Crown and Maori chiefs in 1840). As both “Pakeha and Maori cultures (in all their diverse modes of expression) belong in New Zealand”, organisations need to “understand the importance of both cultures as part of their broader cultural environment” (Tremaine, 1997, pp. 287–288). Despite this context, The New Zealand Public Relations Handbook (Peart and Macnamara, 1996), the only textbook devoted to PR in New Zealand, makes no mention of issues of cultural diversity. Instead the book defines and describes the nature of PR from one perspective: the perspective of the dominant managerial frame. “It has been said”, Peart and Macnamara (1996) note, “that a company or organisation today without an active public relations programme soon finds itself ignored by the media, threatened by hysterical minorities and faced with political and economic neglect” (p. 20). There is clearly no positive place in this perspective for the other, which, it is implied, is not only hysterical but a threat as well. Yet, such perspectives are often dictated by current mindsets rather than a careful study of the environment. They seem to unquestioningly follow Ashby’s (1956/1963) conception of variety as disturbances that might threaten organisational equilibrium and therefore would need to be managed. Half a century after Ashby’s formulation, PR scholars’ few attempts to look at issues of diversity continue to revolve around the need to manage groups of people who may have the potential to disrupt the perceived stability of organisations based on monocultural values and norms. Sha’s (2006) important contemporary work on the significance of intercultural PR, for example, eventually falls in line with the usual thinking when it calls for a “refined version” of situational theory with “efficient measures of cultural identity” to help “multinational corporations in
Moving the settings
55
the management of grassroots activist groups” (p. 61). While Sha’s (2006) study does well to acknowledge the importance of the variables of race and ethnicity in PR research, she does not in any way shake the fundamental will to control in PR. This notion of organisational control is what prompts PR to see any expression of alternative points of view as activism that needs curbing. As Sha (2006) says, a situational theory infused with cultural variables: would help organizations determine which stakeholder groups are likely to become active publics. With this ability to predict active communication behavior, public relations practitioners could plan communication programs to prevent or hinder the rise of activist publics or to encourage groups likely to become active in support of the organization, particularly in situations dealing with cultural issues. (p. 61) Despite the efforts to acknowledge the variables of race and ethnicity, such a reformulation of situational theory remains unmindful of the often invisible influence the dominant core wields. It assumes that sound PR is something that will persuade ethnic or cultural publics to support the organisation or prevent them from becoming activists. The assumption is based around an unchallenged conception of the organisation as race, gender, or class neutral. It does not, for instance, see that “the ways in which we routinely frame race preserve the Whiteness of the field, even as we claim to do otherwise” (Ashcraft and Allen, 2003, p. 6). These organisational communication scholars call upon all researchers working in the larger area of communication to explore the notion that organisations are fundamentally “raced” and that “we are also raced beings, instead of conflating race with people of color in general” (Ashcraft and Allen, 2003, p. 31). Such an exploration would allow us to see widely accepted theory and practice as “raced” rather than taken for granted as universal. That PR scholars and practitioners have continued to follow the practice of positioning minority groups as the other has subsequently been recognised by Macnamara (2004), who, in a self-reflexive piece, talks about how his “own previous texts in Australia, New Zealand, and Asia have been criticised for Western myopia and lack of focus on multicultural and cross-cultural issues in communication” (p. 325). In emphasising the need to incorporate issues of culture and diversity into PR research, Macnamara (2004) specifically acknowledges the critique of taken-for-granted views and perspectives in an earlier version of parts of this chapter published in the Asia Pacific Public Relations Journal (Munshi, 1999). This positive impact of our arguments on the field is encouraging, and illustrates what we are trying to achieve. Unfortunately, the kind of self-reflexivity demonstrated by Macnamara (2004) is still extremely rare in PR. Many mainstream scholars and practitioners need to reflect much more on their field and work towards actively changing the lens through which they view PR to make the field more equitable.
56
Moving the settings
The state of the art as a grainy picture: global PR theory and inherent inequalities PR is making strides towards a global approach. For example, Sriramesh and Vercˇicˇ’s (2003a) edited collection, The Global Public Relations Handbook: Theory, Research and Practice, raises the bar for the future significantly in terms of new standards for aligning with changing demographics; range, scope, and depth of coverage; and cultivation of new authors, especially from underrepresented areas. In addition to their unprecedented geographic scope, Sriramesh and Vercˇicˇ (2003a) introduce content and theory that add new breadth to the field. Significant innovations include Pratt’s (2003) chapter, “Managing sustainable development in sub-Saharan Africa: a communication ethic for the global corporation” which is unique in introducing an ecological area as a focus of interest for PR. He foregrounds ethical communication as vital in sustainable development that, as a matter of life or death, urgently needs to be pioneered in his selected region. It can also provide prototype solutions for problems increasingly likely to confront the developed world, sooner rather than later, as oil runs out. Vercˇicˇ (2003) himself supports his assertion that PR is “a managerial function” with one of the few serious considerations of the role of transnational corporations as the “movers and shakers” (p. 478) of globalisation with input from critics of capitalism (Hertz, 2001; Klein, 2000). He also deploys Dicken’s (1998) Global Shift to give a thicker texture, a less celebratory tone, and a more complex account of phenomena that connect PR to globalisation. Moreover, as co-editor, he partially contradicts his definition of PR as exclusively managerial, or at least business managerial, by including a chapter adjacent to his own where Tkalac and Pavicic (2003) perform the overdue task of setting NGOs and PR into a global context that provides a platform for future work. Nevertheless, having acknowledged a few of the many innovative and valuable contributions that Sriramesh and Vercˇicˇ’s (2003a) Global Handbook makes, we critique certain aspects of it as being stuck in the old mould. Even this collection exemplifies the tendencies of insular conceptualisations and ignoring, or downplaying, of the power asymmetries found in US PR. In short, despite its global aspirations and achievements, its good intentions and partial realisation, and the encouraging geographical spread of its international authors, we consider The Global Public Relations Handbook as symptomatic of some problems as well as the beginning of solutions. In addition to identifying problems with, and deconstructing, existing theorisations, the rest of this chapter offers theoretical augmentations by relevant contributors to global diversity from outside of the field. One example is Vervoorn’s (2002) Re Orient: Change in Asian Societies, which offers challenges to existing disciplinary models in what may be the Asian century. After revisiting Starck and Kruckeberg’s (1991) query whether there would be a “Europeanization of education and scholarship?” (p. 25), we suggest that a more urgent question was whether there should be an Asianisation
Moving the settings
57
of PR education and scholarship (Munshi and McKie, 2001). This is built on combining pre-2000 observations on the rise of China and Asia (Burstein and De Keijzer, 1998; Naisbitt, 1997a, 1997b) with other estimations of the shifting balance of economic power: “Wealth increasingly depends upon market demand rather than supplier pressure, and – with more than 90 per cent of the world’s population – the Third World will become the main economic driver of the Third Millennium” (Mercer, 1998, p. 15).
Freedom beyond Freedom House: towards new flowering democracies Enterprise links with equity and democracy and democracy with PR. Sriramesh (2003a) rightly celebrates how the “democratization of the world, especially in the latter half of the 20th century, has forced organizations of all types in many regions of the world to consider giving greater importance to public relations and communication management” (p. xxvi). However, he leaves unanswered Beck’s (1994) earlier key post-communism questions: “whether the historical symbiosis between capitalism and democracy that characterized the West can be generalized on a global scale without exhausting its physical, cultural and social foundations”; and whether we should “see the return of nationalism and racism in Europe precisely as a reaction to the processes of global unification?” (p. 1). Sriramesh’s (2003a) further comments overlook that question, and whether liberal democracy might have a use-by date in the globalising world. In PR this has practical implications as illustrated by Huang and Chen’s (2005) writing on China, when, for example, they use Freedom House statistics, and perspectives, to gauge media freedom and even observe in a footnote that “The Freedom House is a non-profit, non-partisan organization founded by Eleanor Roosevelt, Wendell Willkie, and other Americans nearly 60 years ago” (p. 59). They do so without displaying any knowledge of Freedom House’s partisan role in anticommunist, and, in places such as Nicaragua, anti-democratic, activities against elected governments. Sims’ (1992) fuller account of Freedom House notes that, despite its promotion as “a documentation center and clearing house on human and civil rights”, it should be reclassified as a “neoconservative heavyweight in the global war for ideas”, which, after the Second World War, provided “exhaustive ‘documentation’ of human rights abuses by Soviet and leftist governments, while downplaying and under-reporting abuses in U.S.-allied countries” (p. 47). As Google learned in its dispute over revealing activist net addresses to the Chinese government, global realities involve dynamic tensions between equity, in terms of human rights, and enterprise, in terms of business priorities. In considering more expansive senses of freedom and democracy in politics we turn to Beck’s (1994) critique of the limits of already existing democracy whereby the “West is confronted by questions that challenge the fundamental premises of its own social and political system” (p. 1) and Giddens’ (1994) discussions of how to widen traditional democratic processes. In a self-reflexive
58
Moving the settings
critique of the work of himself and his co-authors in Beck et al.’s (1994) Reflexive Modernization: Politics, Traditions and Aesthetics in the Modern Social Order, Giddens (1994) interprets an alternative order of democratisation around a botanical metaphor. In what he terms “the fragile-flower theory”, democracy is a tender plant that requires careful tending and nurturing “over a long period through the long-term development of a civic culture” (p. 191). He directly critiques Fukuyama’s position that “democratic forms of government” involve a “necessarily protracted process” that essentially involves “allowing the retarded countries to catch up with their more advanced counterparts where liberal democracy is already firmly established” with “deep roots” (p. 191). Against that he prefers what he terms “the sturdy-plant view” (Giddens, 1994, p. 192), which “does not equate democracy solely with liberal democracy within the nation state” and sees democracy as an ongoing work in progress so that: Processes of democratization stimulate the emergence of liberal democracy where it did not previously exist, yet at the same time also expose its limitations. Democracy in this broader sense is a hardy growth that can develop shoots even in quite infertile ground . . . it suggests that there are profound social changes occurring in the current era that do not occur mainly at the level of the state. (p. 192) We present the following summary of Giddens’ four key non-state social contexts because they seem to us to present a clear agenda of areas where PR might act to broaden democracy and foster more inclusive social cohesion both inside, and outside of, national boundaries. First, he suggests “ ‘emotional democracy’ in the domains of sexual relations, parent-child relations and friendship” so that “a relation of equals, organized through emotional communication coupled to self-understanding, becomes possible” and develops a kind of emotional democracy that “promises a great deal for the reconstruction of civic ethics” (Giddens, 1994, p. 193). This development is lent further weight by the growth of knowledge into emotions where further research may uncover further means of implementing such emotional democracy. Second, he advocates “the replacing of bureaucratic hierarchies by more flexible and decentralized systems of authority” taking care to acknowledge that “flexibility for some groups, in some contexts, may signal increasing constraint or oppression for others” (p. 193). For his third context, Giddens (1994) identifies the “development of social movements and self-help groups” and notes how, in certain circumstances, “such movements and groups set themselves up against existing ‘authorities’, whether these be state officials, professionals [NB authors’ note: who may include PR professionals] or others” (pp. 193–194). He continues that, “apart from the issues they pursue”, such groups can, if they are not always so in practice, also be “democratizing as modes of social association” (p. 194). Giddens’ (1994) fourth and final example is “at more global levels of devel-
Moving the settings
59
opment” (p. 194) and combine what he classes as a “superpolitical” level that interacts with the other three, which he follows Beck in classing as “sub-political” (p. 193). Without consciously including such dimensions into discussions of actual and potential social cohesion, PR is likely to keep addressing symptoms. It would do better to abandon the universalising limitation of its one size fits all view, and contribute to longer term in-process solutions for different regions in different circumstances.
Relocating knowledge in PR Sriramesh’s (2003a) introduction to The Global Public Relations Handbook, applauds the fact that the “scholarly body of knowledge of public relations has grown significantly in the last 25 years”, but laments the “lopsided” growth of this knowledge “because the focus of theory building has been confined predominantly to the United States and a few Western European countries” (p. xxv). We hoped this accurate perception signalled a welcome weighing in to tip the scales away from the West. We took the scholar’s shortcut of checking the index to see what theorist had been mobilised to redress the balance. Sadly, in the multiple entries chapters we found the usual suspects: Grunig, J. (48), Grunig, L. (47), and the old (i.e. Glen) Broom (21) rather than any new brooms. In fact the only non-PR specific theorist with multiple citations is Hofstede (38), and it is not a coincidence that he is the only European philosopher cited frequently by J. Grunig and his colleagues. Sriramesh and Vercˇicˇ’s (2003b) acronyms, assumptions, and timelines reveal similarly slanted treatments. While the chapter by L. Grunig and J. Grunig (2003) is focused on the US and modestly acknowledges that it “may be early to celebrate the implications of the Excellence theory”, they go on to observe that it already “serves as the organization framework for this book” (p. 327). Such extensions of the excellence tradition are doing little to tackle the international theoretical–political divide. Certain temporal consequences of US-centricity emerge on the first page of Sriramesh’s (2003a) preface, which identifies the 1990s as “the decade of globalization because of the founding of the World Trade Organization and the formation of many regional and trans-region blocs such as NAFTA, the European Union, Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC, founded in 1989)” (p. xxiii). In the quotation it is noticeable that NAFTA does not have its acronym spelled out, presumably on the assumption that what it stands for will be understood outside of North America, while APEC, although involving more nations and significantly larger populations, is not similarly trusted to be understood. More importantly, in temporal terms, the exclusion of the preceding pre-1990s centuries of globalisation through, mainly Western, empire building, exhibits a longer term strategic amnesia. It ignores, within the covers of the same book, Kunczik’s (2003) Saidian perspective of the importance of the image of the “Orient” as “almost a European invention” (p. 420) cemented in place by sustained economic and military interventions into the Middle East. Kunczik (2003) observes that such “stereotypes are extremely difficult to change by using public
60
Moving the settings
relations” (p. 420). As he is alone in the collection in tackling such systematic stereotyping, or ethnic profiling, the field is less likely to make any attempt to do so. The tensions between local–global have an important knowledge dimension. Increasingly, as Plumwood (1993) pointed out over a decade ago, assumptions regarding the universality of knowledge are being undermined; in her case from an environmental and feminist perspective. From a similar angle this questioning has been carried over in relation to economic, political, and social development (see Kurian, 2000). In relation to Asia, Vervoorn (2002) has questioned the neutrality of Western “scientific” knowledge and his critique can be usefully transferred to the US body of PR knowledge. European scholars have contested various limbs of the body, but, in a formulation akin to Abbott’s (2001) comments on Roman knowledge, Vervoorn (2002) perceptively alerts us to the dangers of having any singular universal body of knowledge with local variants: “The real test of knowledge is not leaving all that is local or particular behind, but recognising the ways in which it is local or particular, how it may fit into patterns not visible to a parochial observer” (p. 285). The potential for parochialism exists in the Washington Beltway and the Public Relations Society of America as well as in New Zealand and Singapore. One of our concerns is that Sriramesh and Vercˇicˇ’s (2003a) book, in line with current US orthodoxies, may be reluctant to acknowledge already existing power imbalances, in economics, in images, and in histories. Clearly differential power is manifested in communication processes. Describing the “management of communication” as one of the “sovereign prerogatives” of the present age, Hardt and Negri (2000) say that “communication is the form of capitalist production in which capital has succeeded in submitting society entirely and globally to its regime, suppressing all alternative paths” (pp. 346–347). Clearly, while colonialism’s ambitious quest for physical territory has receded into the background, its will to exercise political and economic power continues. PR is no exception.
5
Not enough Said Decolonising PR through postcolonial frameworks
Much is lost by the field’s current insularity to theory from different parts of the globe, and from different disciplines. Rather than seeking to validate the neocolonial universality of a relatively narrow stream of US theory, we recommend that PR generates different epistemic maps. Our first example of the cost of such absences features one of the most influential thinkers on global relations, Edward Said. As Patrick Williams (2004) observes in his academic obituary of Edward Said (1935–2003): If it is unusual for the death of an academic to constitute much of a media event, then it is altogether rare for such a death to be a media event on a global scale, as was the case with Edward Said. That this should be so is perhaps no more than fitting for someone who not only did so much to rehabilitate the categories of the public intellectual and the intellectual engagé, both in his academic work and in his daily life, but did so precisely globally. (p. 169) Despite this being one of many acknowledgements of his importance in a global role, PR has yet to begin to come to terms with Said’s (1978) seminal book on Orientalism more than a quarter of a century after its publication. In the intervening years other disciplines have considered post-Orientalist, and postOccidentalist, concepts. In partial defence of the chapter title’s pun on Said’s surname, we signal not only PR’s lack of engagement with Said’s legacy in PR but also its neglect of the historical forces that have forged globalisation, and which continue to threaten equity and to retard sustainable societies. The almost total absence of Said’s contribution (but see Kunczik, 2003), and the debates he engendered, captures a critical gap in contemporary discussions of the global within the discipline. While communication studies in general has kept pace with postcolonial perspectives by documenting the “growing awareness of the limitations and parochialism of theory so steeped in Eurocentrism” (Shome and Hegde, 2002, p. 260), PR has not. Tied, as it is in some ways, to the apron strings of corporate communication and tangled in outmoded positivism, PR has been unable to feel
62
Not enough Said
the pulse of people around the world who have been influenced by Said’s “critical insights into ideology, history, power relations” (Hussein, 2002, p. 230). Indeed, as Bayoumi and Rubin (2000) point out, the: desire to engage with Said – by Indonesians and Parisians, from the Irish to the Iroquois – is perhaps felt even more so today, as bland pronouncements of globalization often mean little more than extending the military and economic reach of the United States, and the confusing reactions to global power fall prey to simple “us” versus “them” dichotomies. (p. xvi) Postcolonialism has been late to arrive in the field but a greater mainstream recognition of other perspectives has been enabled by the publication of the Handbook of PR (Heath, 2001a). This collection leveraged its status as a handbook to cast a broad international net. Instead of taking PR as US PR, Heath (2001a) featured authors from outside the US and writings by non-US theorists, which included some engaging with issues of power and contesting two-way symmetry (Leitch and Neilson, 2001). The collection integrated the field’s historical interests, from crisis and rhetoric to symmetry and strategy, with a substantial section on “Globalizing PR” (Heath, 2001a) that considered globalisation as “The frontier of multiculturalism and global diversity” (Heath, 2001c, pp. 625–628) and another on “PR in cyberspace” (Heath, 2001a, pp. 579–623). In a format variation unique among the now-extensive list of Sage Handbooks, Heath (2001a) concluded the 11 essays “Defining the discipline” (pp. 1–166) with a twelfth, entitled “PR as contested terrain: a critical response” (Cheney and Christensen, 2001b, pp. 167–182). This opening up of the mainstream field – as plural, globally diverse, open to debate, and receptive to outside critique – has been a watershed moment. Heath (2005) has subsequently followed up with a two volume Encyclopedia of PR, which included entries on critical theory (McKie, 2005) and postcolonialism (Munshi, 2005b). Viewed through postcolonial optics, the managerial bias of PR, as shown in the use of the concept of requisite variety, is an extension of old colonialist strategies. Just as powerful Western nations have sought to incorporate requisite varieties of other countries in the interest of expanding political influence, powerful Western businesses have tried to incorporate the other in the global marketplace in the interest of enlarging profitability. Understanding the link between old colonialist agendas and modern-day neo-colonialist strategies is central to the process of decolonising PR. To map out the structure of decolonisation, we draw on the perspectives of the postcolonial and the subaltern – defined as a “general attribute of subordination . . . expressed in terms of class, caste, gender and office” (Guha, 1988, p. 35). The project of subaltern studies, and of many aligned postcolonial scholars, is to view the world from the perspective of historically and epistemologically subordinated groups. As part of the decolonising project, such scholars challenge the homogeneous internationalism of dominant elites. They call into ques-
Not enough Said 63 tion how generations of Western thinkers, who may lack any knowledge of nonWestern cultures, have constructed theories that are supposed to apply to all of humanity (Chakrabarty, 1996). In such theory-building enterprises, incorporating and subsuming a homogeneous category of the other represents “the surface manifestations of a latent economic and cultural colonization of the ‘nonwestern’ world” (Mohanty, 1991, p.192). A major task of subaltern studies’ historiography, for example, has been “to retrieve some trace of the voice” (Bhabha, 1996, pp. 14–15) of the subaltern from the ventriloquism of the colonisers. In retrieving these voices, the subaltern collective has attempted to rewrite the histories of colonialism and nationalism from the perspective of the colonised. The field of PR however, has, as yet, had little engagement with decolonising projects. As a consequence, while the voice of the other might incidentally be heard, his or her words are not deliberately sought out, and will still be in virtual parentheses to the amplified speech of Western organisational leaders. In attempting to move beyond the symmetry model, Roth et al. (1996) took a unique step, in PR, by drawing from, or at least dipping into, postcolonial theory. Their brief immersion allowed them to argue in favour of ethical principles based on a critical assessment of issues of relative power. However, their reading of postcolonial work is limited: first, because of the merely cursory reference to Said’s (1978) classic book; and, second, because they see neither the centrality of the dominant Western managerial framework nor the homogenising tendency of the process of setting up a universal code. As a result, their approach aligns with the fake universalism of Eurocentrism and their central question – “Can’t we all just get along?” (Roth et al., 1996, p. 151) – avoids addressing power asymmetries. Instead Roth et al. (1996) look at how equitable their proposed incorporation of cultural variables are to the “development of mutually agreed upon principles to guide global practice” (p. 60). The idea that “we” need to “get along” seems admirable but cannot be taken out of the context of the ethnically narrow composition of the “we” and the logic of the neo-colonial market. Cultural diversity, from the perspective of that logic, becomes the means to a greater share of a market controlled largely by expansionist Western businesses.
The new S-curve: an overview of postcolonial perspectives in communication from Said and Spivak Postcolonialism offers radical new ways of understanding the world. It challenges both overt and covert forms of economic, social, and cultural imperialism. Interdisciplinary postcolonial approaches have been used extensively in art history, literary criticism, and cultural studies to critique the taken-for-granted worldviews of mainstream Euro-American writers, scholars, and thinkers. While Roth et al. (1996) do cite Said (1978), they have been unable to grasp the significant impact his works have made in challenging universalised Western assumptions about the world. As is well-known in literary and political circles, Said’s (1978) Orientalism showed how systematically exaggerated, exoticised,
64
Not enough Said
and erroneous images of the non-West in mainstream Western texts – novels, films, and other mass-circulated texts – perpetuated the myth of a superior West. This strategy helped colonisers to justify their disproportionate power. Novelists and film-makers, wilfully or otherwise, became part of a PR exercise that sought to engineer the image of the Western colonisers as benevolent rulers whose objective was to “develop” the world in their own superior image. From very early on, there are massive disparities in discourse and image circulation in terms of Fairclough’s (1995) conceptualisation of power “both in terms of asymmetries between participants in discourse events and in terms of unequal capacity to control how texts are produced, distributed, and consumed (and hence the shapes of texts) in particular sociocultural contexts” (pp. 1–2) Said’s ground-breaking work has left behind a rich legacy of postcolonial criticism which continues to scrutinise the way in which Western imperialist attitudes had paved the way for the justification of colonisation. It may not have been called PR when he first published in 1923, but Tallens’ (1955) The Projection of England displays a commercial sensitivity to early supply chain management as well as prototypical public diplomacy. Other empire promoters and the commercial exporters exhibit similar integration. Anne McClintock (1995) describes how in the era of colonisation, “colonial heroes and colonial scenes were emblazoned on a host of domestic commodities, from milk cartons to sauce bottles . . . toffee boxes to baking powder” and how: in the flickering magic lantern of imperial desire, teas, biscuits, tobaccos, Bovril, tins of cocoa and, above all, soaps beach themselves on far-flung shores, tramp through jungles, quell uprisings, restore order and write the inevitable legend of commercial progress across the colonial landscape. (p. 219) McClintock’s (1995) portrayal of colonial era representations of the Western civilising mission is not much different from, for example, Cook’s (2003) description of Enron’s PR-managed CSR report as being “sprinkled with images of sunlit foliage and smiling ethnic faces” (p. 40) and narratives of how the company “conserved trees in Bolivia and told the security men at its Indian subsidiary to stop beating people up” (p. 40). What is common to the colonial and neo-colonial communication strategies of powerful institutions, whether empires or corporate giants, is the core emphasis on promoting Western business and/or political interests but concealing their selfish goals under a gloss of universal good and benevolence. It will require reflexivity, and attention to developments in other fields, for PR to rise above this superficial gloss. No matter what economic benefits imperial strategies may bestow on the other, the hierarchies of power cannot be ignored. As the postcolonial scholar, Gayatri Spivak (1999) says: My generation in India, born before Independence, realizes only too well that many of the functionaries of the civilizing mission of imperialism were
Not enough Said 65 well-meaning. The point here is not personal accusations. And in fact what these functionaries gave was often what I call an enabling violation – a rape that produces a healthy child, whose existence cannot be advanced as a justification for the rape. Imperialism cannot be justified by the fact that India has railways and I speak English well. Many of the functionaries of the civilizing mission were well-meaning; but alas, you can do good with contempt or paternal-maternal-sororal benevolence in your heart. And today, you can knife the poor nation in the back and offer band-aids for a photo opportunity. (p. 371) In fact, PR, “by and large, spends the bulk of its energies on such photo opportunities for leaders of big business houses and multinational corporations (MNCs), overlooking the traumas of publics at the lower end of the pecking order, especially those in the Third World” (Munshi and Kurian, 2005, p. 516). Structurally, the dominant organisational core “manages” its image through an imperialist PR paradigm that creates and perpetuates an asymmetric hierarchy of publics: (1) the predominantly Western shareholders; (2) the Western consumer public/the global middle-class consumer; (3) the Western activist public; (4) the vast numbers of Third World workers who produce the goods for consumption by others; and (5) the even greater numbers of Third World citizens too poor to consume. The first is obsessive about profits and share values, the second consumes blindly, and the third provides resistance from within the West, while the last two fall below the corporate radar. Corporate PR efforts, therefore, focus on undercutting the protests of the third public to appease the second public and directly benefit the first public. Its agenda has no place for the colonised fourth and fifth publics. (Munshi and Kurian, 2005, p. 514) Effectively, this hierarchy creates impermeable boundaries between two halves of the world – one the so-called “developed” world with its obsession with bottom-lines and Western notions of economic clout and the other the so-called “developing” world which is deemed to live in the shadows of the developed world. If there is any communicative interaction between these two worlds at all, it is asymmetrical. An example of this asymmetry is in the PR-driven messages of corporate social responsibility and sustainable development produced by major global corporations. These messages constitute a well-designed “magic formula with which the world system of production pretends to solve the problems that it itself has created” (Boff, 2003). Central to this formula is the belief that image building revolves around keeping key publics at the higher end of the hierarchy happy. The formula thrives on a universalised conception of effective PR that is limited primarily to the concerns of publics in the developed world. Postcolonial perspectives enable us to unwrap the shiny packaging of
66
Not enough Said
persuasive messages of sustainable development drawn up by dominant coalitions. So, while such dominant coalitions use ecological narratives to show their desire to save the Earth, in practice they can be exposed as endorsing the continued exploitation of the Third World. In fact, even some mainstream environmental organisations have sometimes been co-opted by PR firms to support organisations involved in environmental degradation – see Burton (2002) on the “WWF’s role in sustaining cyanide use”. Furthermore, many underprivileged communities, including indigenous ones, in the developing world “are generally the victims of environmental degradation mostly caused by resource extractive operations of MNCs in the name of global development” (Adeola, 2001, p. 41). That popular PR practice, as well as scholarship in the field, is aligned in overlooking the case of the other is exemplified by how the tragedy of Bhopal continues to be treated in mainstream PR texts. It shows how, at its worst, PR actually recolonises.
Colonising illusions: an “other” look at Bhopal The gas leak in a Union Carbide factory in Bhopal, India, which claimed several thousand lives and left hundreds of thousands injured in 1984 (see, for example, Sen and Egelhoff, 1991; Lapierre and Moro, 2002), was one of the worst industrial disasters the world has known. It remains relevant today because it continues to be cited in PR literature as a landmark case. Bhopal illustrates both how a corporation dealt with non-Western constituents in what might be seen as a discriminatory fashion and how PR theory continues, retrospectively, to endorse that action. In a clear case of aligning with Western corporate bodies rather than human Indian bodies, the Union Carbide PR response to the disaster’s aftermath “dealt with the scientific, rather than the human, sides of the leak’s effects” (Ice, 1991, p. 358). The spotlight on Bhopal was guided by Western self-interest in that the tragedy involved “a U.S. firm that was manufacturing the same lethal chemical” (Heath, 1998b, p. 296) in America. The public outrage in the West had less to do with the actual dead and maimed Indian bodies than with the imagined Western injuries that might be inflicted by the threat of a similar accident in the US. Although this “was a financial differentiation” (Ice, 1991, p. 358) based on bookkeeping, Union Carbide used it to distance itself from its Indian subsidiary immediately after the Bhopal leak by differentiating between the US-based headquarters and the subsidiary in India. Even in the post-Bhopal phase, Carbide focused primarily on “maintaining its image with financial investors and the developed world” (Sen and Egelhoff, 1991, p. 77). The company’s distorted field of vision has since been approximated by the PR field’s vision. Both viewed the Bhopal tragedy almost entirely through the eyes of Union Carbide, the Western chemical industry, and its corporate wellbeing. One introductory textbook illustrates the convergence succinctly: “Following the Bhopal disaster and a resultant out-of-court settlement, Union Carbide found itself on the receiving end of a takeover bid. The bid was foiled
Not enough Said 67 as the result of better communications with appropriate publics and an increased share value” (Kitchen, 1997, p. 30). Other PR considerations similarly concentrate on that kind of balance sheet in the way those protagonists dealt with the crisis. As in colonial historiography, this concentration omits the perspective of the subaltern. Bhopal’s Indian victims are obviously not seen by mainstream PR as “appropriate publics”. Effectively, in the discourses of crisis communication, the bodies of these victims approximate to silent experimental subjects for the “science” of PR. Moreover, the Bhopal research findings have subsequently been deployed to chart new strategies for the profession and for its Western corporate clients. Dozier et al.’s (1995) discussion of how the Bhopal tragedy pushes all chemical manufacturers to change and be more open to the public, for example, refers to the public in the West. At the height of the crisis in Bhopal (where the human need was obviously highest), Union Carbide “distanced itself from the press in India” (Sen and Egelhoff, 1991, p. 77) but continued to communicate with the US media through official releases. After-the-event PR research publications continue to treat Bhopal as a source of data to help frame guidelines for Western centres, without much concern for the fate of the victims of the tragedy. Klein (2000), in documenting the way many multinational companies are creating “another kind of global village, where the economic divide is widening”, points out how, in the minds of global corporations, the Third World has “existed for the comfort of the First” (p. xviii). In fact it is evident that, just as with Bhopal, any “major changes” in work practices concern the reputation of Western corporate bodies in the West, rather than the condition of employees in the Third World where, for example, “Nike workers are still forced to work excessive hours in high pressure work environments, and not paid enough to meet the basic needs of their children, and are subject to harassment, dismissal and violent intimidation if they try to form unions or tell journalists about labor abuses in their factories” (Connor, 2001). Lipschutz and Rowe’s (2005) “Doing well by doing it? Social regulation and the transnational apparel industry” concludes negatively that in the corporate’s subcontractor factories “Few of Nike’s efforts have been rewarded with a clean bill of health from campaigners. According to various reports, surveys, and studies undertaken by outside observers and critics, none of the steps taken by Nike has fundamentally altered conditions” (p. 85).
Continuing the S-curve: insights from Shiva to Shome and Hegde Issues relating to diversity in the business world correlate with similar issues in the natural world, in which postcolonial scientist Vandana Shiva (1993) has condemned the Western world’s use of the Biodiversity Convention “to ‘globalise’ the control, management and ownership of biological diversity” (p. 151). In order to nurture diversity, Shiva (1997) says that “dominant groups of nations
68
Not enough Said
and humans” who impose their ways of life on other peoples and species need to give up “the will to control” (p. 120). Already Western seed companies have capitalised on patents of crops bred in the developing world to create profits and put farmers in the Third World out of business. Following Shiva’s (1993) insight that “biodiversity cannot be preserved until diversity is made the logic of production” (p. 146), global management is similarly unlikely to be sustainable until human diversity informs the logic of capitalism. Requisite variety cannot function fully until organisations become wholly multicultural and the other is not restricted to a “numerical, additive category” (Shiva, 1993, p. 87). In the light of Shiva’s (1993) insight, contemporary PR scholarship needs to be re-examined. Despite the desire to promote and celebrate diversity, research continues to look at issues of diversity as a strategic means to help “the PR function contribute to the bottom line” (Hon and Brunner, 2000, p. 336). Such research goes on endorsing the two-way symmetrical model as a model that “best facilitates excellence” (Pompper, 2004, p. 270), and highlights the “benefits of requisite variety” (Hon and Brunner, 2000, pp. 314, 335). The key issue of control is conveniently ignored. Pompper’s (2004) study on AfricanAmerican PR practitioners brings issues of diversity into PR literature. However, in framing them as “a conduit between senior-level management and key publics”, she excludes minority practitioners from a place in the “senior management” (Pompper, 2004, p. 290). Pompper’s study overlooks the power dimension despite the fact that her flow chart “offers organizational power holders an enhanced decision model that incorporates diversity [italics not in original]” (p. 290). The incorporation of diversity has an in-built power equation that PR continues to ignore. Communication scholars outside PR are already exploring the way power is wielded by implicit notions of universalised notions of management and communication. In a special issue of Communication Theory on “Postcolonial approaches to communication”, for instance, Raka Shome and Radha Hegde (2002) point out: “Denaturalizing communication (to use Grossberg’s words) and problematizing culture from a postcolonial perspective allows us to go beyond the descriptive and account for ways in which the Western realities have spread across the world as the universal condition” (p. 261). It is this unquestioned allegiance to the universal condition, manifested most prominently in the overwhelming legitimacy given to the voice of the dominant organisational core, which casts PR in a colonialist mould.
Correcting myopia: diversifying publics and enlarging visions The work of the postcolonial historian Dipesh Chakrabarty (2000) opens the way for PR to see beyond the usual Eurocentric ways of determining strategic stakeholders for organisations. In a landmark book, Provincializing Europe: Postcolonial Thought and Historical Difference, Chakrabarty (2000) seeks to
Not enough Said 69 decentre the universalised notion of Europe, “an imaginary figure that remains deeply embedded in clichéd and shorthand forms in some everyday habits of thought” (p. 4). Challenging the classic liberal theorists’ idea that history belonged to Europe, Chakrabarty (2000) focuses instead on the alternative histories of subordinate social groups in India. He is critical of the Western pursuit of historicism, which presumes that history is shaped by an organic chain of events and developments over time. Historicist accounts, he points out, chart the development of modernity and claim that Europe was intellectually ahead of other regions, an ideology that allowed John Stuart Mill to write foundational essays which “proclaimed self-rule as the highest form of government and yet argued against giving Indians or Africans self-rule on grounds that were indeed historicist . . . Indians or Africans were not yet civilized enough to rule themselves” (Chakrabarty, 2000, p. 8). Indians and Africans did indeed, as did other colonised peoples, fight for and get self-rule and, in doing so, upset the historicists’ Eurocentric logic (Chakrabarty, 2000). In addition to importing contextual insights from postcolonialism, PR can draw from other fields to expose spurious claims to universalism. These importations can open up understandings of benefit to organisations who seek to cultivate diverse others as leaders, outsourcers, and partners, as well as customers. Feminist scholar Nancy Fraser (1997), for instance, deconstructs the key photographic metaphor of requisite variety as “tantamount to filtering diverse rhetorical and stylistic norms through a single overarching lens” (p. 83) and notes accurately that, because there is “no such lens that is genuinely culturally neutral, it would effectively privilege the expressive norms of one cultural group over those of others” (p. 84). To resist that further privileging of the already powerful, Fraser records how groups, such as women, workers, people of colour, and gays and lesbians, have often constituted what she calls “subaltern counterpublics . . . to formulate oppositional interpretations of their identities, interests, and needs” (Fraser, 1997, p. 81). Examples of such alternative publics include feminist journals and bookstores, gay and lesbian conventions, and ethnic minority forms and fora. The concurrent moves in PR have been less diverse with less opportunity for dialogue. Instead prominent PR practitioners have been arguing that centralised sites of control should simply incorporate the leading institutionalised opposition bodies. One case in point was when the then Director-General of the British Nuclear Industry Forum advocated bringing organised oppositional groups, such as Greenpeace, “into the tent” (Haywood, 1997) – a phrase that itself connotes negotiations with “natives” under an imperial canvas. The same phrase was used by the Director of Operations of Queensland Mining Council in the title of a talk to a national PR convention in Australia in 1998 (Mathias, 1998). Others, including IBM’s environmental director, have also argued for the inclusion of such “opinion formers” as a key “upstream” part of environment consultations (ten Brink et al., 1996). These attempts at inclusion remain open to the same charges of unequal
70
Not enough Said
incorporation already levelled against Roth et al. (1996). They do not begin to encompass such complex counterpublics as the First National People of Color Environmental Leadership Summit and the Third World Network. Nevertheless, attention to a meaningful requisite variety (i.e. one that would include significant power sharing and attention to the voice and issues of diverse cultural others) earlier in the process could pay dividends. Just as intelligent, and inclusive, issues management can avoid the need for crisis management, so intelligent, and culturally inclusive, requisite variety can avert the need for divisive confrontations. This in turn reduces investment of resources into reactive media interventions, protracted negotiation, and reputation protection. The costs of such actions can be particularly heavy in relation to disputes over ethnicity where the ramifications are often both internal and international. With specific regard to ethnicity, the field needs to heed its own general advice that “relationships are long term rather than short term; that hazardous firefighting activities may be better accomplished in the light of such relationships” (Kitchen, 1997, p. 27). We contend that such longer-term relationship building needs to take into account the discursive complexities and desires of different ethnicities and counterpublics. Otherwise the homogenised worldview of PR maintains old colonial legacies that support neo-colonial economic interests. In PR texts these interests are entrenched in neatly demarcated, and often well-meaning, sections on multiculturalism. Typically, such sections emphasise the need to communicate effectively with selected other groups, such as Latinos, African-Americans, and Asians, but do not acknowledge how the power to set the communication agenda remains in Western hands.
Global relations: emerging situations and changing status In effect, by hailing globalisation without reservations, the field neglects accounts of how the process developed, the historical forces that forged it, and the resulting continuation of power inequities. This can be illustrated in recent collections on international PR. Tilson and Alozie’s (2004) Toward the Common Good: Perspectives in International PR, for instance, follows the pioneering model of Culbertson and Chen’s (1996) International PR: A Comparative Analysis. That is to say it assigns many regions to US authors better qualified in PR knowledge than local knowledge – although in fairness it has to be said that this is a difficult task and Tilson and Alozie are to be commended for succeeding in introducing some new authors and covering some new regions and periods. However, the continuities are more marked than the innovations. Tilson and Alozie’s (2004) Toward the Common Good: Perspectives in International PR contradicts its title’s claim, to be moving in the direction of the common good, by opening with an unreflective declaration of self-interest. Tim Traverse-Healy’s (2004) “Foreword” sets the book’s agenda as filling the scholarly gap in “coverage accorded the affairs of developing countries” and meeting the globalisation-fostered need for practitioners (presumably from developed
Not enough Said 71 countries), who “are fast entering the realms of developing countries” (p. xi). Such practitioners “want access to authoritative information describing the nature and the state of the craft in areas, territories, and countries with which they are not immediately professionally familiar but in which they can suddenly find themselves having to initiate operations” (Traverse-Healy, 2004, p. xi). As with Friedman’s (2006) account of how Reuters restricts high level journalism jobs to Western journalists at the expense of Indian journalists, Traverse-Healy is similarly open in seeking good PR jobs for Western outsiders in developing countries and continuing an international division of labour that has long favoured the West. By putting this upfront, Tilson and Alozie (2004) endorse that self-centred perspective rather than following their title’s stated aspiration of moving “Toward the common good”. It is confirmed empirically in Montenegro’s (2004) chapter in the book where her key point is that “multinational PR firms must adapt their practices” to gain work in the Latin American region although large US PR firms already “earn about half of the fees abroad” (p. 102). One chapter with a globalising title in Tilson and Alozie’s (2004) collection does exhibit a measure of reflexivity, as well as a rationale, both for foregrounding PR in the US and for reflecting on its claims to universality. US authors Melvin Sharpe and Betty Pritchard’s (2004) “The historical empowerment of public opinion and its relationship to the emergence of PR as a profession” is unusual in acknowledging that its perspective, materials, and history, are grounded in US developments. Not only that but they go on to justify that national grounding for the following reasons: “the documentation available from scholars and library resources”; “the democratic model is more closely identified with the United States than with any other country”; and “the PR profession in the United States is larger and more developed than in any other country” (Sharpe and Pritchard, 2004, p. 15). Their reasoning has strong empirical support. Sharpe and Pritchard (2004) go on to account for the field’s development in a similarly material-based fashion: “A convergence of three factors contributed to the emergence of PR as a profession: a growth in the global acceptance of democratic principles, growing global social interdependence, and the emergence of direct instantaneous communication abilities” (p. 15). Significantly, in addition to the shifting of business and, gradually, the growing number of professionals who work outside of the US, each of these factors is mutating in the present environment in ways that impact negatively on US moral and practical leadership. The first, the increasingly wide “acceptance of democratic principles” has come at a time when the US, and parts of Europe, instead of leading world opinion (see Stearns, 2005), are defying international law, arguing for the legalisation of torture and being brought to book for fabricating the weapons of mass destruction excuse to invade Iraq. Change for the US is equally evident on a number of other international fronts: in finance, where “the appreciation of the euro and of sterling versus the dollar . . . suggests a nascent challenge to the role of the dollar as the sole global
72
Not enough Said
reserve currency”; in politics, where the US, “though it still wields substantial influence, cannot claim the overwhelming power it once had to shape global alliances to its own purposes” and has to handle potentially huge volatility when unpredictable “disruptions in unstable states – such as Pakistan and Saudi Arabia – could easily spill over into major global disruptions”; and, in markets, where the “emergence of a tactical coalition led by China, India, South Africa, and Brazil . . . confronting Europe, the US, and Japan about agricultural subsidies opens a new front in international bargaining” (Harvey, 2003, pp. 230–231). In fact, Harvey concludes “India, Brazil, Russia, and China could together rewrite the economic geography of the world along much fairer lines in the twenty-first century”, and this “could well signal the emergence of an ‘antineo-liberal’ power bloc in the world” (p. 231). Sharpe and Pritchard’s (2004) second formative factor, “growing global social interdependence”, further loosens US leadership as, under the second Bush administration, the US increasingly tries to go it alone. It has manifest difficulties in relation to not ratifying environmental treaties, let alone, unlike the first Gulf War, putting together a coalition of the willing for war in Iraq. Unless this trend is reversed, the increasing isolation of the US in the global national community is likely to threaten its influence on future interdependence movements, especially if its economic position worsened. And finally, the emergence of direct instantaneous communication abilities and the resultant death of distance, again removes the platform for US supremacy as more and more of the globe catches on to the communications revolution. Ironically, the configurations around Sharpe and Pritchard’s (2004) three formative factors may be reforming to reduce, and perhaps replace, the leading international role of US PR. In these shifting market relations, the continuation of the will to maintain ethnocentric and national control threatens sustainable profitability. People make up markets and non-Western populations will tend to react negatively to organisations that marginalise them or, in extreme cases, ignore their humanity. In the case of Bhopal the other was dealt with as a numerical sum in market arithmetic. The Western multinational company’s “scientific and financial focus resulted in ‘looking beyond Bhopal,’ past the suffering of the victims toward the future of the company itself” (Ice, 1991, p. 358). Union Carbide’s visual reach encompassed the short term US future of the company but did not extend to a longer term view of how it would look to India and other large Asian economies. In PR in Asia: An Anthology (Sriramesh, 2004a), Sriramesh’s “Epilogue” concludes the anthology with a set of proposals for a more genuinely multicultural PR, which he hopes “will pave the way for the PR profession around the world to become more truly strategic as a result of becoming more multicultural [italics in original]” (p. 337). While strongly supporting the sentiment, we are concerned that it may be underpinned with excellence study assumptions (see White and Mazur, 1995), that PR does not serve vested interests, and that strategic goals and power are transparently shared. Our view, that the use of the term strategy in PR means different things to
Not enough Said 73 different people, finds support in Botan’s (2006) distinction between “strategy”, which “is a property of campaigns and is about planning and the maneuvering and allocation of resources” and “grand strategy”, which “is the policy-level decisions an organization makes about goals, alignments, ethics, and relationship with publics and other forces in the environment” (p. 225). Botan’s (2006) distinction, and his associated insight that although “grand strategies occur at a much higher level than do campaign strategies, what is most important is that they constrain or limit strategies” (p. 226), forms a foundation for an expanded view of strategy. Building on it, we suggest that PR as a field also has a grand strategy that limits, but that, as a field, it has not developed it as consciously as an organisation. This is to be expected since an organisation has to take many more collective, coordinated actions more often, and with clearer lines of authority. Accordingly much of the field’s grand strategy is unconscious. We see a pro-Western power interest embedded in the grand strategy of PR that may be a vital retarding feature in the frustratingly slow progress towards genuine multiculturalism. Power, profit, and ethnicity need to be explicitly brought into consideration as part of building social cohesion, locally, nationally, and globally. The field needs to overcome its consistent omission, or marginalisation of the perspective of the subaltern. Such marginalisation effectively keeps in place processes of neo-colonisation and an uneven international division of labour. Citing data from business bank Goldman Sachs on twenty-first century superpowers, Bakas (2006) names the top six as “the United States . . . Japan, and the so-called BRIC countries – Brazil, Russia, India and China” and notes that half of them will be in Asia which “will mean that that the twenty-first century will be characterized as the ‘Asian century’ ” (p. 31). Accordingly, the longer term, more equitable relationship building required for sustainable social cohesion, already needs to be taking account of the alternative subaltern forms and fora (Fraser, 1997), and those who theorise their value, as well as what they represent: some of the discursive complexities and desires, of people of different ethnicities and economic backgrounds, who in other countries, and globally, are majorities not minorities.
Metaphoric lines of flight: trees, tubers, India Shining, and Western PR in the dark Alongside their emancipatory lines of flight, Deleuze and Guattari (1972; 1987) offer multiple sources of new beginnings through their conceptualisation of the rhizome. In its botanical sense a rhizome is an underground tuber that ramifies and diversifies, producing new buds from anywhere in the system, and so having no apparent beginning or end. As such it opposes what Deleuze and Guattari call arboric systems of knowledge, based on the model of a tree, which solidify in visible and immovable forms, and which have clearly located areas of origin. Their rhizome is therefore both dispersed and mobile as a network of connections across which things flow and disperse. By having no centre and no steadily solid structure, rhizomes signal ongoing states of disarray. In this sense, they are
74
Not enough Said
perpetually in the stage of becoming. Rhizomes oscillate between the lines established by the arboric systems, and as such occupy the zone of fuzzy logic rather than conventional logic or simple aggregation. Although we make no claim to be Deleuzian scholars, we are excited by how Deleuze and Guattari offer a kind of metaphysics of process that acknowledges a fluidity, which is more representative of the ongoing flow of material conditions in making space for conditions of disarray than existing PR theory. Such metaphysics undercuts complacent conceptions of the fixed structures and underdeveloped body of theory that dominates the field. Deleuze and Guattari’s work engages with perceiving processes of change in what has been described as a “becoming ontology” (Chia, 1999, p. 222), which “offers a lifeline for the alternative conceptualization of organizational change that cannot be hijacked by the systematic reductionism of modernist thought” (p. 222). We recommend reaching for that lifeline by getting PR to shake off some of its conventional lines of thinking. Conventional worldviews of mainstream PR often maintain old colonial legacies in supporting neo-colonial economic interests. This was evident in the ambitious, multi-million dollar “India Shining” campaign run by a multinational PR and advertising agency, on behalf of the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) government in India, towards the end of 2003 (see, for example, Verma, 2003; Luce, 2003). The target publics for the media-centred campaign were clearly the upwardly mobile middle-class Indians as it focused on the achievements of the IT sector, the outsourcing contracts, and the building of entertainment complexes. The campaign did not reflect the realities of the poor. As Sainath (2004) points out, the irony of it all was that while the focus was on the lifestyles of the elite, not much was said about the increasing poverty, the crumbling public health system, or the destitution of landless villagers. The PR blitz did not help the BJP at all as the party crashed to a defeat in the general elections in 2004. Yet, after the election results were announced, a significant section of the mainstream media in the West appeared to be taken so much by surprise that some chose to call it a “stunning political upset” (see “The upset in India”, 2004, p. A 24; “India shifts course”, 2004, p. A 24). But was it really an upset? It was, after all, a verdict delivered by a huge majority of the country’s voters. What the election results did show yet again was that PR needs to acknowledge multiple and diverse publics rather than be subservient to a few elite ones. This is especially true when they comprise the vast majority as is the case in India and the world as a whole. Millions of impoverished Indian rural voters, marginalised in the age of globalisation and corporatisation, and ignored by the PR machinery, had their say in the world’s largest democracy. The Indian experience provides material proof of the possible falsifying of Fukuyama’s (1992) famous thesis, which he summarises in The End of History and the Last Man: What I had suggested had come to an end was not the occurrence of events, even large and grave events, but History: that is, history understood as a
Not enough Said 75 single, coherent, evolutionary process, when taking into account the experience of all peoples in all times. This understanding of History . . . is implicit in our use of words like “primitive” or “advanced,” “traditional” or “modern,” when referring to different types of human societies . . . This evolutionary process was neither random nor unintelligible, even if it did not proceed in a straight line, and even if it was possible to question whether man (sic) was happier or better off as a result of historical “progress”. (p. xii) Fukuyama (1992) placed his own end point in the “remarkable consensus concerning the legitimacy of liberal democracy as a system of government” that may constitute the “end point of mankind’s ideological evolution” and the “final form of human government” and, therefore, “the end of history” (p. xi). As we discuss in Chapter 9, J. Grunig and Hunt (1984) presented their description of two-way symmetrical communication as the evolutionary epitome of PR history five years prior to Fukuyama’s first 1989 National Interest article on his end of history. Events have led Fukuyama to reconsider his position, but before we reconsider PR history per se we want to track the past of excellence and its intertwining with leadership.
6
What’s next (1)? Empowering differences, learning from leadership, and equity in management after In Search of Excellence