Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
Re-O...
118 downloads
2229 Views
4MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
Re-Orienting Whiteness
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
This page intentionally left blank
Edited by
Leigh Boucher, Jane Carey, and Katherine Ellinghaus
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
Re-Orienting Whiteness
RE- ORIENTING WHITENESS
Copyright © Leigh Boucher, Jane Carey, and Katherine Ellinghaus, 2009. All rights reserved.
Photo Credits: Cover image: “Naked for Dinner.” Published in the Lone Hand, September 2, 1907. Figure 14.1: “A Gin and Piccaninny,” reproduced from the Rex Van Kivell Collection, NK10389, Courtesy of the National Library of Australia; Figure 14.2: “Portrait of an Aboriginal Mother and Child, Canning Stock Route, Western Australia, 1942,” reproduced from the National Library of Australia, nla.pic-vn4463084, with the kind permission of Roslyn Poignant; Figure 14.3: “Earthly Mother,” William Ricketts Sanctuary reprinted with the permission of Parks Victoria; Figure 14.4: “An Old Woman,” in Savage Life and Scenes in Australia and New Zealand, George French Angus, courtesy of the State Library of Victoria; Figure 14.5: “A Curiosity in Her Own Country,” cartoon by Phil May reprinted from the Bulletin, 1888. First published in 2009 by PALGRAVE MACMILLAN® in the United States—a division of St. Martin’s Press LLC, 175 Fifth Avenue, New York, NY 10010. Where this book is distributed in the UK, Europe and the rest of the world, this is by Palgrave Macmillan, a division of Macmillan Publishers Limited, registered in England, company number 785998, of Houndmills, Basingstoke, Hampshire RG21 6XS. Palgrave Macmillan is the global academic imprint of the above companies and has companies and representatives throughout the world. Palgrave® and Macmillan® are registered trademarks in the United States, the United Kingdom, Europe and other countries. ISBN: 978–0–230–61885–5 Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data is available from the Library of Congress. A catalogue record of the book is available from the British Library. Design by Newgen Imaging Systems (P) Ltd., Chennai, India. First edition: November 2009 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 Printed in the United States of America.
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
Chapter 10 is a slightly revised version of “Making Tasmania Home,” Frontiers: A Journal of Women Studies 28, nos 1 and 2 (2007): 1–17, published by the University of Nebraska Press. Copyright © 2007 by Frontiers Editorial Collective, Inc.
Acknowledgments 1
Re-Orienting Whiteness: A New Agenda for the Field Jane Carey, Leigh Boucher, and Katherine Ellinghaus Part I
vii 1
Historians Approaching the Study of Whiteness
2
Whiteness and “the Imperial Turn” Angela Woollacott
3
The Strange Career of Whiteness: Miscegenation, Assimilation, Abdication Louise Newman
31
“Whiteness,” Geopolitical Reconfiguration, and the Settler Empire in Nineteenth-Century Victorian Politics Leigh Boucher
45
4
Part II
Whiteness as a Transnational Colonial Production
5
Traveling White Warwick Anderson
6
The Question of Miscegenation in the Politics of English-Speaking Countries in the Early Twentieth Century Henry Reynolds
7
8
17
“Being Thankful for their Birth in a Christian Land”: Interrogating Intersections between Whiteness and Child Rescue Shurlee Swain, Margot Hillel, and Belinda Sweeney “I Followed England Round the World”: The Rise of Trans-Imperial Anglo-Saxon Exceptionalism, and the Spatial Narratives of Nineteenth-Century British Settler Colonies of the Pacific Rim Penelope Edmonds
65
73
83
99
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
Contents
vi
●
Contents
9
10
11
12
White is Wonderful: Emotional Conversion and Subjective Formation Marilyn Lake
119
The Fabrication of White Homemaking: Louisa Meredith in Colonial Tasmania Patricia Grimshaw and Ann Standish
135
Reading the Shadows of Whiteness: A Case of Racial Clarity on Queensland’s Colonial Borderlands, 1880–1900 Tracey Banivanua Mar
149
The Deluded White Woman and the Expatriation of the White Child Margaret Allen
165
Part IV 13
14
15
16
Whiteness and the Imagining/Managing of Colonial Populations
“Women’s Objective—A Perfect Race”: Whiteness, Eugenics, and the Articulation of Race Jane Carey
183
“Born and Nurtured in Darkest Ignorance”: White Imaginings of Aboriginal Maternity Liz Conor
199
Rethinking “Squaw Men” and “Pakeha-Maori”: Legislating White Masculinity in New Zealand and Canada, 1840–1900 Angela Wanhalla Into the White Man’s Kingdom: Whiteness and Indigenous Assimilation Policies in the United States and Australia, 1880s–1960s Katherine Ellinghaus Part V
17
219
235
Conclusion
Epilogue Jane Carey, Leigh Boucher, and Katherine Ellinghaus
253
Notes on Contributors
259
Index
263
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
Part III Whiteness as a Settler-Colonial Identity
T
his volume would not have been possible without the input of many people. We would like to thank all the participants of the Historicizing Whiteness conference, held at the University of Melbourne in 2006. The essays in this collection are much stronger for having been delivered in such a collegial and rigorous environment, and the School of Historical Studies at the University of Melbourne provided essential institutional and financial support to make that meeting of minds possible. We are grateful to all the contributors for their patience and engagement with the project, and to Lindi Todd, Roger Knight, Vera Mackie, and David Goodman for their support (both intellectual and otherwise). When our enthusiasm for the task of historicizing whiteness f lagged we had only to turn to the work of these fine scholars to be reinspired. Sarah Pinto was a skilled, professional copy editor who went above and beyond the call of duty to smooth the edges of these many authorial voices. The editors at Palgrave are also due our gratitude for their enthusiasm and support for the project. All three editors of this volume were the product of the postgraduate school at the University of Melbourne between the mid-1990s and 2006. The friendships among fellow postgraduates and junior staff that we found there were unquestionably important to our development as scholars, and we were also fortunate to come into contact with a remarkable group of senior academics whose intellectual generosity shaped our own perspectives. We are better historians for being exposed to this rich environment at the early stages of our careers.
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
Acknowledgments
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
This page intentionally left blank
Re-Orienting Whiteness: A New Agenda for the Field Jane Carey, Leigh Boucher, and Katherine Ellinghaus
S
ince whiteness studies made its dramatic entrance into the U.S. academy in the early 1990s it has generated tremendous scholarly output. Monographs and edited collections have proliferated across and between numerous disciplines. Amongst all this intellectual activity, however, the question of whiteness and colonialism remains a significant and curious absence.1 As its Saidian-inspired title signals, Re-Orienting Whiteness emerges from our desire to address this gap by pushing “whiteness studies” toward a more sustained engagement with critical postcolonial thought and the history of colonialism. Despite their many obvious synergies, there has been remarkably little cross-fertilization between these approaches to understanding the modalities of race, past and present. 2 There is a clear need for this radical separation to be addressed. This collection offers an explicit challenge both to work on race in the United States (which has tended to elide the foundational significance of its settler- colonial origins), and to historical scholarship on British empirebuilding (which remains deeply conf licted over the significance of race)3. Our work is based on the conviction that the construction of whiteness and the phenomena of European colonialism are fundamentally interconnected, and that whiteness studies must be “Re-Oriented” to take this into account. Equally, a greater and more rigorous focus on whiteness as a racial category has much to offer to our understandings of the historical operations of colonialism and its ongoing effects. The essays presented here perform precisely these tasks. Most had their origins in a conference on “Historicising Whiteness” held in Melbourne, Australia, in late 2006.4 This gathering deliberately set out to move beyond the North
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
CHAPTER 1
●
Carey, Boucher, and Ellinghaus
American focus that has shaped studies of whiteness. As conveners, we were taken aback by the level of interest it generated. While we were and are convinced that whiteness studies opened productive new avenues for historians interested in racialization broadly and colonialism specifically, we were caught unawares by the number of scholars who shared this view. This was close to a decade after the first major scholarly whiteness conference, the (in)famous Berkeley gathering of 1997, generated so much attention in and out of the U.S. academy.5 And the intervening years had witnessed many a dismissal of the field’s utility, particularly for historians. We wondered, at first, if the energy might have dissipated and we were simply caught in a time-lag. The depth and breadth of the work that appeared soon assuaged any such fears. This is not to say that this collection is united by an unfaltering commitment to whiteness studies. It is equally shaped by a uneasiness with the field tendencies toward ahistoricity, reification, and universalization; its ill-defined analytic vocabulary; and especially its potential simply to reinscribe white people at the center of historical narratives. And we are acutely aware that, since its emergence, the field has proven “a lightning rod for critics.”6 Indeed, alongside its rapid growth, the apparently deserved death of the field has been simultaneously announced as the latest headstone in a graveyard of academic fads.7 A key development that argues these dismissive predictions, however, is the degree to which the terms “white” and “whiteness” have already been adopted by historians, particularly those writing about European colonialism. These categories have recently been inserted alongside class, gender, and various “others.” 8 This book functions in some ways simply to highlight the significance of this quite startling analytic uptake. But it also registers a profound discomfort with the ways that whiteness has snuck through the backdoor into the historian’s toolkit, often with little definition or explanation. Its meanings are often taken for granted, as if they were self-evident. The nuanced, historically grounded, and theoretically broad-ranging approaches in this collection suggest a number of ways forward for scholars. As Matt Wray has recently observed, “whiteness studies has left childhood and is now enduring adolescence. It’s having its identity crisis right on time.”9 The time is ripe for a major reassessment of the field. In approaching this task, we wish to foreground the limitations that have resulted from the U.S.-centered nature of most whiteness scholarship. This is clearly problematic for a field that makes broad, even universal, claims to explaining the operations of “race.” Whiteness, obviously, has had far wider geographic purchase.10 We seek to decenter the United States in the area of whiteness studies, and in some ways to recognize that it was never central to begin with. So too, the isolationist tendencies of U.S. whiteness scholarship have produced its lack of engagement with work on race in other contexts, particularly the analytic frames that have emerged through attempts to theorize European colonialism. We contend that this nationally and theoretically limited approach represents in fact the major weakness of the field.11 In other words, whiteness needs to be reconciled with the major intellectual currents that have shaped research on race outside the United States.
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
2
●
3
Re-Orienting Whiteness brings together historians of the United States, Canada, Australia, New Zealand, and Europe to historicize constructions of whiteness across the times and spaces of empire. “Transnationalizing” whiteness studies—and thus bringing it into contact with colonial history—re-orients the frames of whiteness for U.S. and non-U.S. scholars alike.12 Confronting the power and privilege inherent in the structured normativity and invisibility of contemporary whiteness requires that the historical roots of that power be interrogated, and the history of European colonialism is of more than passing significance to this project. If, as many scholars have argued, the very idea of race emerged through the colonial encounter, the seeming failure of whiteness studies to take this into account is both insufficient and unsustainable. While the colonial underpinnings of U.S. “structures of race” have frequently been elided,13 this collection functions to read the colonial back into whiteness.
The Rise of Whiteness and Its Discontents: U.S. Origins and Debates Despite its much longer tradition in black American writing,14 whiteness studies has its origins in the spate of foundational works of the early 1990s, which continue to mark and define the field.15 Where previously race had only been deployed to refer to “non-whites,” this scholarship firmly established whiteness too as a racial category and one in urgent need of interrogation. The key features of whiteness that emerged—and that do not need repetition here—were its inherent association with power and privilege, and its structural, invisible location as “the norm.” The exponential growth of whiteness studies since this time has been accompanied by almost equally numerous overviews of the field, some highly negative.16 Assessing the utility of whiteness specifically for U.S. historians in 2001, Eric Arnesen contended that it had “proven to be an inadequate tool of historical analysis.”17 Methodological weaknesses and definitional looseness, he argued, rendered it practically worthless. Indeed, he accused some whiteness scholars of providing little empirical evidence for their claims, suggesting instead they “put words into their subjects’ mouths . . . disregarded scholarly standards [and] employed sloppy methodology.” “Arbitrary and inconsistent definitions,” he concluded, meant “whiteness has become a blank screen onto which those who claim to analyze it can project their own meanings.”18 Arneson was not alone, as the flurry of similarly dissatisfied reviews indicated.19 Although not as scathing, Peter Kolchin, for example, also expressed uneasiness at the “elusive, undefined nature of whiteness,” the lack of “historical grounding” of many contemporary studies, and the “over-reliance on whiteness in explaining the American past.” 20 In assigning such overarching explanatory power to whiteness, he suggested, the field is prone to overstatement and overgeneralization, coming close to “portraying race as a ubiquitous and unchanging transhistorical force rather than a shifting and contingent ‘construction.’ ” 21 Kolchin also briefly observed that one of the “most striking features” of whiteness
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
Re-Orienting Whiteness
●
Carey, Boucher, and Ellinghaus
studies is the “assumption—sometimes asserted and sometimes unspoken—that the racism they describe is uniquely American and that American whiteness can be understood in isolation.” 22 The most influential U.S. scholarship, particularly that by labor historians, locates the creation of white identity entirely within historical circumstances quite specific to the United States, namely black chattel slavery and, later, mass immigration. 23 While this narrow national focus has not emerged as a prominent concern within existing critiques of the field, we argue that it is in fact of central importance. Much historical work on whiteness is even more narrowly positioned. As John Munro has outlined, it largely represents another in the series of U.S. labor history projects that have sought to answer the question Werner Sombart posed in 1906, “Why is there no socialism in the United States?,” and is primarily concerned with finding “a usable past upon which an anti-capitalist and antiracist future can be envisioned.” 24 This in part explains why it has largely ignored wider scholarship that does not share these, very particular, interests, and why many objections to whiteness studies have simply joined the long history of attempts to assert the primacy of class over race. 25 Despite pretensions to an almost universal applicability, distinct U.S. academic debates, as well as specific political projects and disavowals (particularly of the settler-colonial underpinnings of the United States), silently orient the field. In many ways, debates about whiteness have primarily ref lected a turf war over leadership in the field of labor history in the United States. The issues at stake are far too important to allow them to be subsumed within such parochial concerns.
Provincializing America: Putting the Colonial Back into Whiteness and Whiteness into the Colonial Unmooring whiteness from its foundations in U.S. pasts and presents promises to overcome many of the field’s conceptual blind spots. By foregrounding the importance of colonialism, our approach addresses the transnational dimensions of the historical trajectories of whiteness. 26 Until recently, history-writing has tended to contain the past within contemporary national borders. But the unstable fiction of race was and is always generated by processes that refuse to be enclosed within such territorial boundaries, and the global reach of whiteness cannot be explained by the simple application of U.S.-centered studies. Whiteness studies must pay far greater attention to the transnational as a field of power. As Angela Woollacott’s early work on transcolonial voyages so potently demonstrated, whiteness travelled, both discursively and materially, and its meaning was always reconfigured in these circulations. 27 As Frederick Cooper argues, the study of the pre–World War II world is often transnational precisely because empires encourage border crossings. 28 This collection explores the genealogy of whiteness once we put the transnational in, and shows how historical analysis can bring local, temporal, and spatial specificity to this project. As we are faced by a “new world” of globalized cultural, economic, and social exchange, an effective history of the ways in
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
4
●
5
which whiteness—as a figuration of identity and power—has been transnationally molded could not be more needed. Comprehending the strategies and dynamics of racialization requires a transnational analytic frame—if only to comprehend the contexts in which local specificities were generated. Conversely, understanding global whiteness can only be achieved by simultaneously paying attention to these local specificities. Historians of the outposts of European empires are often acutely aware of the ways in which local conditions are always imbricated in transnational networks of exchange. The broad scope of this collection clearly demonstrates the far-reaching, if divergent, global currency of whiteness. Indeed, the characterization of whiteness studies as a predominantly U.S. phenomenon is somewhat misleading. It ref lects in part a tendency among U.S. scholars not to read outside of their own national historiography, or even, in the case of labor history, outside of their particular specialist area. Overviews of the field have largely failed to take note of how whiteness is being addressed in broader historical scholarship. But we suggest that some of the most productive work on whiteness has been taking place outside of the small group of scholars specifically identified with the field, particularly by those engaged in studies of colonialism and its continuing effects. Dynamics of racialization have often been maintained via the unbearable discursive weight of Othering. Like the field of whiteness studies, we seek to reverse this strategy by attending to whiteness as the sovereign—if sometimes silent—social, legal, cultural, and experiential category that the very idea of race essentially functions to privilege. Reading whiteness into the colonial in this way may prove enormously productive. Postcolonial scholarship might also benefit from whiteness studies’ explicit focus on race and racial privilege, which is, paradoxically, not necessarily central to this approach. Aileen MoretonRobinson’s pioneering work on contemporary Australian feminism was among the first to integrate insights of both whiteness and postcolonial studies and clearly established the need for such a dialogue. 29 Historians are well-placed to continue this project by showing the importance of imperial networks and processes to the operation of white power. Indeed, since the publication of Edward Said’s Orientalism in 1978, countless historical works have explored how “white identity” was contrapuntally forged through the colonial encounter, although their terminology has been quite different. Equally, reading the colonial back into whiteness has significant implications for U.S. historiography.30 The effacement of the “colonial” in U.S. history, a reluctance to see the United States as a site of empire (whether as metropole or periphery), and the isolationist tendencies of U.S. historiography have enabled a rejection (if only via a lack of interest) of the possibilities of postcolonial theory to contribute to discussions of whiteness. As MoretonRobinson has observed, U.S. scholars have located whiteness in relation to slavery and immigration, but not the dispossession of Native American peoples. 31 This disjunction has been further fueled by the open hostility of many U.S. labor historians toward postcolonialism. By contrast, Warwick Anderson’s
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
Re-Orienting Whiteness
●
Carey, Boucher, and Ellinghaus
work on American rule in the Philippines strongly argues the significance of colonial contexts for constructions of American whiteness, as do Ann Stoler’s recent ref lections on the salience of postcolonial theory for approaching U.S. history.32 Moreover, although this is rarely acknowledged, many whiteness scholars do in fact draw heavily on frameworks first proposed by postcolonial theory, particularly the concept of “Othering” and its exclusionary functions. Both fields view white/European identity as a largely “empty” category, defined solely in relation to and against that which it is not (whether “savages” or slaves). With these synergies in mind, our approach attempts to resolve the hostilities and locate the many sympathies between the work of U.S. labor scholars of whiteness and scholars who approach race through the lens of colonialism.
Historians Approaching the Study of Colonial Whiteness The historians in this collection read the surprisingly discrete fields of postcolonial and whiteness studies’ together to think about how having a “colored conversation” about whiteness might be “re-oriented” and thus invigorated.33 As David Roediger has acknowledged, “the most inf luential [whiteness] studies from the early 1990s were not specialized ones that could later be deployed to create a broader narrative: Instead, studies that staked out broad claims across time and space came first.”34 The diverse array of studies presented here, with their firm empirical grounding and definitional clarity, refute Eric Arnesen’s suggestion that whiteness is nothing more than a product of some historians’ imagination. They demonstrate how we might go about exploring the particularities of whiteness in certain contexts, while incorporating the wider, global phenomena that shaped it. By exploring the specific forms of whiteness produced in colonial, and particularly settler-colonial, contexts, they foreground the impact of colonial regimes of whiteness on Indigenous peoples, offering a much-needed corrective to existing U.S. scholarship. Some suggest that addressing colonialism will redefine current formulations of the emergence of white identity. Quite simply, read together, they indicate the possibility of a history of whiteness as a globalizing force. The opening methodological and historiographical papers suggest a suite of analytic tools that are useful for historians of whiteness in U.S. and non-U.S. contexts alike. And each, in different ways, questions the usefulness of the concept. They contribute much to our understanding of how whiteness resonates with the concerns and foci of colonial/postcolonial history. Identifying the “myth of white racial purity” as foundational to constructions of whiteness, Louise Newman charts the subtle shifts in racial dynamics across time in the United States, focusing on miscegenation, assimilation, and abdication as “three distinct practices, or strategies [employed by] European settlers, immigrants and their descendants,” which paradoxically revealed “the fluidity of racial boundaries, as much as they were intended to solidify them.” She urges us “to find ways to historicize whiteness so that we come to appreciate how whiteness is a matter of place and context.” Avoiding the reifying “shorthand of speaking
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
6
●
7
of white people,” Angela Woollacott focuses on the “specific forms of whiteness” produced in settler-colonial contexts, arguing that these have been “key sites” in the historical trajectory of this racial category. She explores the implications of acknowledging the whiteness of settler colonialism, since “in white-settler colonies, there have been specific regimes in which whiteness itself accrued legislative, regulatory and cultural substance.” Thus what is required is “grounded and contextualized analyses of the emergence and evolution of whiteness.” Noting the “lack of specificity about the racial status of the colonizer population” in mid-nineteenth-century Victoria (who were “variously termed ‘Anglo-Saxon,’ ‘English,’ ‘British,’ ‘colonist,’ or, very, very rarely, ‘white’ ”), Leigh Boucher urges us to pay closer attention to specific dynamics of racialization. He suggests a need to distinguish between whiteness as an analytic category that we apply to historical analysis and an empirical category that appears within the contexts we are studying. Such a distinction is needed because the differences between these modalities of racialization have substantive impacts on the possibilities of political inclusion and exclusion for whites and nonwhite alike. The following sections present a range of different frameworks that demonstrate how utilizing whiteness can provide significant new insights into the historical operations of race in colonial contexts. The next group of essays considers whiteness as both a transnational and a colonial product. By interrogating how whiteness and the politics of racial difference more broadly were necessarily implicated in the transnational projects of empire building, they forge a new path toward historicizing whiteness. Warwick Anderson thus proposes extremely pertinent questions when he asks “How did whiteness travel? What did it do when it arrived? And what was it not able to do?” Indeed, his chapter suggests that the geographic and political contours of the imperial project provided precisely the generative conditions for the emergence of whiteness as a marker of identity. So too, Henry Reynolds’ study of the politics of miscegenation—a “problem” all too frequently solved by local legislation—reveals how these politics relied on a transnational exchange of ideas about the white race. This exchange, moreover, followed the routes of the Anglophone empire and suggests a much wider dynamic of fear and anxiety about miscegenation. As Reynolds argues “there was a very broad consensus in the English speaking world during the first part of the twentieth century” about its dangers. The routes of empire, without question, fostered the circulation of these fears and forged specific routes and networks of exchange that shaped whiteness, as Penelope Edmonds compellingly demonstrates. Examining Charles Wentworth Dilke’s account of his tour of “Greater Britain,” she alerts us to the “spatiality of whiteness,” and reveals how practices of transcolonial travel fostered a discourse of “transimperial Anglo-Saxon exceptionalism” in the nineteenth century. This discourse, she argues, prefigured and “later intertwined and competed with discourses of whiteness and Britishness,” creating globalizing histories and identities with decidedly local impacts; the “implications” of the Anglo-Saxons’ apparently unique capacity for colonization and rule for “the expropriated Indigenous peoples of British settler colonies were profound.” So too, Shurlee Swain, Margot Hillel, and Belinda Sweeney’s account of the imperial project of “child rescue” and philanthropic tourism interrogates a body of
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
Re-Orienting Whiteness
●
Carey, Boucher, and Ellinghaus
literature “repeated and expanded in denominational and secular journals published across the Empire” as well as in children’s books, which was centrally “engaged in constructing and consolidating whiteness in both Britain and its settler colonies.” By propagating understandings of the innate civilization and modernity of the English, the racial narratives embedded in this literature enervated notions of whiteness across the breadth of empire. In the next section, historians interrogate whiteness specifically in the settlercolonial context, examining the complex ways in which the formation of individual identity was bound up with the project of settler-colonial expansion. Patricia Grimshaw and Ann Standish explore Louisa Meredith’s account of establishing her “home” in Tasmania as reflecting a “broader claiming of the colony as a British possession, a home for all English people,” suggesting “a wider understanding of the ways the ‘private’ could be manipulated for colonialist ends.” They demonstrate how the personal was necessarily implicated in the politics of the colonial: individual domesticity was significant in “normalizing white people’s presence and domination in the colony . . . Meredith is all the more interesting precisely because her books both adhered to expectations of appropriate female traits and fulfilled a colonizing function.” Margaret Allen’s chapter similarly interrogates how one interracial “family drama,” caught up in the implementation of the restrictive immigration regime of White Australia, can reveal the “precarious and mutable nature . . . of race, whiteness and nation.” By focusing on the individual (and, in this case, the intimate) Allen is able to reveal the ways in which notions of whiteness were always underwritten by localized dynamics of power and cross-hatched by other axes of differentiation. Whiteness, more often than not, was a strategy to differentiate people, and peopling our histories must form a crucial element of this analytic project. In part, this concern underpins Marilyn Lake’s insightful reading of the work of W. E. B. Du Bois. Sitting at the intersection of the global and the local, Lake, whose work has been among the first to locate whiteness within a transnational frame, suggests the need to account for the subjective and emotional components of whiteness by paying more attention to “the emergence of whiteness as both a personal identity and global politics.” This is significant not least if, as Lake argues, by the early twentieth century a global identity of “self-styled white men” was consolidated and asserted “its dominion over the earth, if not always for ever and ever, certainly for the foreseeable future.” So too, Tracey Banivanua Mar demonstrates the importance of grounding our analytics of race in specific times and places. Examining the “Bunya Terror” in late-nineteenth-century colonial Queensland, she suggests twin dynamics of white power, “first, as the identification system for settler-society in relation to the defense of the colony from both external and internal threats; and second as the logic for an emerging structural formation of settler-society.” But she strongly urges the need to “go beyond” charting the emergence of “an articulated white identity . . . [to] a deeper analysis of the way race defined power, particularly at the structural level where privilege and disadvantage were historically embedded.” The essays in the final section move our analytic gaze once more, this time to the ways in which entire populations were rendered comprehensible—and thus manageable—by the rhetorics of whiteness. Ideas about racial difference
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
8
●
9
are historically malleable, not only because they change over time, but because they are deployed in surprising ways to respond to the demands of maintaining particular structures of privilege and power. Understandings of whiteness and racial difference could be enacted to surprising ends or in unexpected ways. These case studies reveal the f luidity and contingency of racialization, providing intriguing examples of the tensions between the transnational and the local. Thus, Katherine Ellinghaus’s examination of legal definitions of white/ Indigenous identity in Australia and the United States reveals instances where whiteness was sometimes both unobtainable and not a privilege at all. Comparing Indigenous assimilation policies in Australia and the United States, she argues that, despite significant contextual differences, in both cases, although the rhetoric of assimilation “promised acceptance, blending in, and economic, political and social equality,” in reality “Aborigines and Native Americans were never imagined as full participants in the societies that they were supposed to be assimilating into”; they were still excluded from the “white man’s kingdom.” Angela Wanhalla similarly explores the surprising legislation enacted in New Zealand and Canada to protect the racial status of white men who “went native” by marrying Indigenous women. This contrasts with the United States, where “men on reserves forfeited their whiteness.” She argues that whiteness was nevertheless “at the heart” of the interracial marriage laws that, by preserving white male racial status, “recast [them] as potential agents of assimilation.” Liz Conor, conversely, asks how the bodies of Aboriginal women operated as potential transmitters of white identity as they gave birth to mixed descent children: “white imaginings of [Australian] Aboriginal maternity that informed the paradoxical state demands on women’s procreative capacities to expire their own race while reproducing another.” She foregrounds “the irrational premise that Aboriginal mothers could be recruited as bearers of the white race,” which was critical to the development and enforcement of the policies of biological absorption and assimilation. Jane Carey explores very different terrain—Australian women’s eugenically inspired campaigning around “white racial health.” These, she argues, reveal how “propagating a large and healthy white population” was central to “the settler-colonial project of White Australia.” Complicating understandings of whiteness as an invisible, empty category, Carey observes that “the ‘whiteness’ of Australian national identity was continually and explicitly proclaimed.” Thus, she suggests, “The relational nature of race . . . may not necessarily mean that racial beliefs are only articulated in explicit discussions of ‘others.’ Anxieties internal to whiteness were also present and . . . [sometimes] formed the major field of racial discourse.” While this collection speaks to the broad connections between whiteness and the colonizing project, most of the studies are based in British settler-colonial contexts. It thus particularly furthers our understandings of how whiteness was produced by, operated within, drove, and structured this specific manifestation of European imperialism. Indeed, we suggest that these settler colonies, and the racial discourses that were deployed to justify and support them, were critical
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
Re-Orienting Whiteness
●
Carey, Boucher, and Ellinghaus
sites for the historical emergence of whiteness and its later trajectories. It was these colonies that had the greatest impact on Indigenous peoples, and where racial beliefs about the capacities and entitlements of white settlers were so crucial to validating the scale of this violent expropriation. Settler colonialism was fundamentally driven by a racial politics of population—the “elimination of the native” and the propagation of a white population to replace them. It was thus structured around protecting the privileges of whiteness. Removing the Indigenous presence through violent conflict and rendering the survivors invisible or at least “harmless” to the assertion of white sovereignty was essential to this. It took considerable discursive and legislative work to inscribe settler colonies as “white spaces.” And strident assertions of whiteness were a significant component of settler colonies’ transition into autonomous nation-states. The Australian case, which several essays address, has much to offer to wider understandings of the changing historical constructions of colonial whiteness.35 Antipodean historians such as Angela Woollacott and Warwick Anderson have been drawing on the insights of both postcolonial and whiteness studies for some time. Australia’s settler-colonial origins have made postcolonial and empire studies central to understandings of this history. The Australian nation, anxious because of its distance from the northern hemisphere, has undergone countless twists and turns in its effort to sustain and claim its white identity, and enforce white sovereignty. Australia may well prove to be paradigmatic.
*
*
*
Whiteness studies has had a dramatic impact and arguably has already fundamentally altered the entire field of racial research. The basic proposition that whiteness too is a racial category that needs to be interrogated has been broadly accepted. This shift is unlikely to simply dissipate. Nevertheless, it seems likely the field will be radically transformed through a broader perspective and greater integration with other approaches, particularly those developed by scholars of colonialism. Indeed, we suggest such a transformation is necessary for the potential of the field to be realized. The global reach of whiteness was and is enabled by the ways in which European empire-building necessarily transgressed national boundaries. Moreover, whiteness didn’t simply sail around the imperial globe. Rather, it was challenged and reinscribed by the exigencies and ambivalences of local contexts. This collection reveals how whiteness was differently constituted under colonial regimes, particularly settler colonies where the claiming of Indigenous lands was central, and in this process addresses how whiteness studies might be modified by critical postcolonial theory. The studies of settler colonialism, including those that firmly reposition the United States within this frame, explore how both land and labor were critical to the construction of whiteness. Indeed, since slavery too was a product of European imperial expansion, we can thus begin to see how the production of whiteness was a transnational phenomenon rooted in the histories of both colonial slavery and settler colonialism.36
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
10
●
11
Most importantly, though, this collection reminds us that investigating whiteness is, and should be, a political contestation of what Robert Young terms the “ruthless whiteness [that leaves] so many blank spaces” in historical scholarship. The importance of taking account of the colonial dimensions of whiteness, how it was forged through the dispossession of Indigenous lands and labor, and, in settler colonies, the elimination of their very existence both bodily and discursively cannot be overstated. Such investigations are essential not only for understanding racialization in the past but also its continuing effects in the present. To borrow a phrase from Ann Stoler, the world as we know it remains “haunted” by the shadows of imperialism. Using the past to know “ourselves,” to truly understand where white power and privilege has come from, is a powerful motivation for the scholarship you will find in these pages. The charge that whiteness studies simply reinscribes white people at the center of historical narratives remains potent. Thinking whiteness without thinking Otherness (whether imagined or experienced) is a strategy destined for political and methodological vapidity. Grafting this awareness onto a field that foundationalizes one category in the ruthless play of race is an important task. Critical studies of whiteness can only be warranted if the oppression and violence it creates, its effects on those who lost the most from its operations, remains clearly and explicitly at the center of such endeavors. Re-orienting whiteness will ensure it stays on the political straight and narrow.
Notes Our thanks to an anonymous reviewer of an earlier version of this chapter for most helpful suggestions. 1. There are some significant exceptions, particularly in the works of many of the authors included in this collection. Ann Laura Stoler explores some of these interconnections in Race and the Education of Desire: Foucault’s History of Sexuality and the Colonial Order of Things (Durham, NC: Duke University Press, 1995), 46–7, 99–100, 149–64, and 177–83. 2. This point is also made in Alfred Lopez, ed., Postcolonial Whiteness: A Critical Reader on Race and Empire (Albany: State University of New York Press, 2005). This collection, however, is focused on literary and cultural studies of the “postcolonial world.” 3. Our thanks to an anonymous reviewer of an earlier version of this chapter for most helpful suggestions. In particular, we thank the reviewer for encouraging us to make this challenge explicit. 4. Leigh Boucher, Jane Carey, and Katherine Ellinghaus, eds., Historicising Whiteness: Transnational Perspectives on the Construction of an Identity (Melbourne: RMIT Publishing, 2007). 5. Birgit Rasmussen et al., eds., The Making and Unmaking of Whiteness (Durham, NC: Duke University Press, 2001). 6. David Roediger, “Whiteness and Its Complications,” The Chronicle of Higher Education 52, no. 45 (July 14, 2006); available from http://chronicle.com/subscribe/ login?url=/weekly/v52/i45/45b00601.htm; accessed September 24, 2007.
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
Re-Orienting Whiteness
●
Carey, Boucher, and Ellinghaus
7. David Stowe, e.g., asserted that the “fad” of whiteness studies would soon begin to disappear. “Book Review,” Journal of American History 86, no. 3 (1999): 1358–9. See also Andrew Hartman, “The Rise and Fall of Whiteness Studies,” Race and Class 46, no. 2 (2004): 22–38. 8. This is evident in the work of some of the key historians of the British Empire, e.g., Catherine Hall, Civilising Subjects: Metropole and Colony in the English Imagination 1830–1867 (Cambridge: Polity, 2002); Philippa Levine, ed., Gender and Empire: The Oxford History of the British Empire, vol. 6 (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2004). 9. Matt Wray, Not Quite White: White Trash and the Boundaries of Whiteness (Durham/ London: Duke University Press, 2006), 6. 10. See, e.g.: Alistair Bonnett, White Identities: Historical and International Perspectives (Harlow/New York: Prentice Hall, 2000); Aileen Moreton-Robinson, Maryrose Casey, and Fiona Nicoll, eds., Transnational Whiteness Matters (Lanham: Lexington Books, 2008); Warwick Anderson, The Cultivation of Whiteness: Science, Health and Racial Destiny in Australia (Melbourne: Melbourne University Press, 2002); Angela Woollacott, “ ‘All this is Empire I Told Myself’: Australia Women’s Voyages ‘Home’ and the Articulation of Colonial Whiteness,” American Historical Review 102, no. 4 (1997): 1003–29; Marilyn Lake, “White Man’s Country: The Trans-National History of a National Project,” Australian Historical Studies 34, no. 122 (2003): 346–63; Marilyn Lake and Henry Reynolds, Drawing the Global Colour Line: White Men’s Countries and the Question of Racial Equality (Melbourne: Melbourne University Press, 2008). 11. While Ruth Frankenberg’s foundational work included “A Note on Colonial Discourses,” this was an aside to her main analysis and has been largely ignored by subsequent American scholarship. White Women, Race Matters: The Social Construction of Whiteness (Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 1993), 16–18. 12. For an earlier discussion of some of the issues raised in this introduction, including an expanded discussion of American debates and historiography, see Jane Carey, Leigh Boucher, and Katherine Ellinghaus, “Historicising Whiteness: Towards a New Research Agenda,” in Historicising Whiteness, vi–xxiii. 13. This point is forcefully made by Aileen Moreton-Robinson in her “Preface,” to Whitening Race: Essays in Social and Cultural Criticism, ed. Aileen MoretonRobinson (Canberra: Aboriginal Studies Press, 2004), viii. The phrase “structures of race” is taken from Patrick Wolfe’s now seminal article arguing for attention to how dynamics of racialization are “structured” by localized material demands: “Land, Labor and Difference: Elementary Structures of Race,” American Historical Review 106, no. 3 (June 2001): 866–905. 14. For example, the work of W. E. B. Du Bois and James Baldwin. On this tradition, see bell hooks, “Representations of Whiteness in the Literary Imagination,” in her Black Looks: Race and Representation (Boston: South End Press, 1992), 165–9; John Munro, “Roots of Whiteness,” Labor/Le Travail no. 54 (2004); available from http:// www.historycooperative.org/journals/llt/54/munro.html; accessed September 20, 2007; and David Roediger, “Critical Studies of Whiteness, USA: Origins and Arguments,” Theoria 98 (December 2001): 74–6. 15. Particularly David Roediger, The Wages of Whiteness: Race and the Making of the American Working Class (London/New York: Verso, 1991); hooks, “Representations of Whiteness in the Literary Imagination”; Toni Morrison, Playing in the Dark: Whiteness and the Literary Imagination (New York: Vintage: Random House, 1992); Frankenberg, “A Note on Colonial Discourses”; Cheryl I. Harris, “Whiteness as Property,” Harvard Law Review 106, no. 8 (June 1993): 1707–91. In the American labor history context, see also Alexander Saxton, The Rise and Fall of the White
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
12
16.
17.
18.
19.
20.
21. 22.
23.
24. 25. 26.
●
13
Republic Class Politics and Mass Culture in Nineteenth-Century America (London/ New York: Verso, 1990). For some of these overviews, not all of them negative, see, e.g.: David W. Stowe, “Uncolored People: The Rise of Whiteness Studies,” Lingua Franca 6, no. 6 (September/October 1996): 68–77; Robyn Wiegman, “Whiteness Studies and the Paradox of Particularity,” Boundary 2 (1999): 115–50; Catherine Hall, “White Identities,” New Left Review 1, no. 193 (May–June 1992): 114–19; Homi Bhabha, “The White Stuff,” Artforum 36 (1998): 21–4; Sara Ahmed, “A Phenomenology of Whiteness,” Feminist Studies 8, no. 2 (2007): 149–68. See also works by Kolchin, Munro, Hartman, Kaufmann, and Roediger cited earlier and later. Eric Arnesen, “Whiteness and the Historians Imagination,” International Labor and Working-Class History no. 60 (2001): 6. Arnesen suggests “whiteness is, variously, a metaphor for power, a proxy for racially distributed material benefits, a synonym for ‘white supremacy,’ an epistemological stance defined by power, a position of invisibility or ignorance, and a set of beliefs about racial ‘Others’ and oneself ” (9). Ibid., 5 and 3. This aspect of Arnesen’s critique focuses on David Roediger’s claim that, in nineteenth-century America, the Irish were perceived as “not white,” and his use of psychoanalytic methods to explain why white workers came to identify with white supremacy. See note 15 earlier and the whiteness studies issue of International Labor and WorkingClass History 60 (Fall 2001), which contained several highly negative assessments aside from Arnesen’s, including Barbara J. Fields, “Whiteness, Racism, and Identity,” International Labor and Working-Class History 60 (Fall 2001): 48–56. Peter Kolchin, “Whiteness Studies: The New History of Race in America,” Journal of American History 89, no. 1 (2002): 157. For example, in relation to the Irish, Jews, and poor whites, he suggests: “Americans have had many ways of looking down on people without questioning their whiteness” (165). Ibid., 159 and 161. Ibid., 170–1. Some of the debate between Eric Kaufmann and David Roediger in a 2006 issue of Ethnicities revolved around the question of whether the paradigms developed in American scholarship could or should be applied to other contexts: Eric Kaufmann, “The Dominant Ethnic Moment: Towards the Abolition of ‘Whiteness’?” and “Whiteness—Too Blunt an Instrument? A Reply to David Roediger,” Ethnicities 6, no. 2 (2006): 231–53 and 263–6; David Roediger, “A Reply to Eric Kaufmann,” Ethnicities 6, no. 2 (2006): 254–62. Roediger’s most recent book argues that immigrants “learnt” specifically American formations of race and whiteness after their arrival: Working Toward Whiteness: How America’s Immigrants Became White (New York: Basic Books, 2005), especially 92, 104, 110–16, and 129. See also Noel Ignatiev, How the Irish Became White (New York: Routledge, 1995); Karen Brodkin, How Jews Became White Folks and What That Says About Race in America (New Brunswick: Rutgers University Press, 1998); and Matthew Frye Jacobson, Whiteness of a Different Color: European Immigrants and the Alchemy of Race (Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1998). Munro, “Roots of Whiteness.” Stowe made a similar point in his much earlier “Uncolored People.” See, e.g., Hartman, “The Rise and Fall of Whiteness Studies,” who argues for more sophisticated materially based class analysis. Two works that have begun to explore the transnational dimensions of whiteness are Moreton-Robinson et al., eds., Transnational Whiteness Matters; and Lake and Reynolds, Drawing the Global Colour Line.
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
Re-Orienting Whiteness
●
Carey, Boucher, and Ellinghaus
27. Woollacott, “All this is Empire,” and To Try Her Fortune in London: Australian Women, Colonialism, and Modernity (New York: Oxford University Press, 2001). 28. Frederick Cooper, Colonialism in Question: Theory, Knowledge, History (Berkeley: University of California Press, 2005). See also Philippa Levine, Kevin Grant, and Frank Trentmann, eds., Beyond Sovereignty: Britain, Empire and Transnationalism, 1860–1950 (Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan, 2007). 29. Aileen Moreton-Robinson, Talkin’ Up to the White Woman: Aboriginal Women and Feminism (Brisbane: University of Queensland Press, 2000). Her more recent work has focused on the construction of “patriarchal white sovereignty” as providing the legitimation of settler-colonial rule in Australia: “Writing off Indigenous Sovereignty: The Discourse of Security and Patriarchal White Sovereignty,” in Sovereign Subjects: Indigenous Sovereignty Matters, ed. Aileen Moreton-Robinson (Sydney: Allen & Unwin, 2007), 86–102. 30. For work that repositions American history within a colonial frame, see, e.g.: Ann Laura Stoler, ed., Haunted by Empire: Geographies of Intimacy in North American History (Durham, NC: Duke University Press, 2006); C. Richard King, ed., Postcolonial America (Chicago: University of Illinois Press, 2000); and Katherine Ellinghaus, Taking Assimilation to Heart: Marriages of White Women and Indigenous Men in the United States and Australia, 1887–1937 (Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press, 2006). 31. Aileen Moreton-Robinson, “Preface,” in Whitening Race, viii. 32. Warwick Anderson, Colonial Pathologies: American Tropical Medicine, Race, and Hygiene in the Philippines (Durham: Duke University Press, 2006); Stoler, “Intimidations of Empire: Predicaments of the Tactile and Unseen,” in Haunted by Empire, 1–67. 33. The phrase “colored conversation” is taken from Michelle Fine et al., “Preface,” in Off White: Readings in Power, Privilege and Resistance, ed. Michelle Fine et al., second edn (New York and London: Routledge, 2004), vii–xii. 34. Roediger, “Whiteness and Its Complications.” 35. Largely due to the inf luence of Aileen Moreton-Robinson, Australian scholars have also produced the largest bodies of contemporary whiteness scholarship outside of the United States. See, e.g., The Australian Critical Race and Whiteness Studies Association Journal. 36. We thank Clare Midgley for making this suggestion.
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
14
Historians Approaching the Study of Whiteness
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
PART I
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
This page intentionally left blank
Whiteness and “the Imperial Turn” Angela Woollacott
T
he study of whiteness as a racial category emerged roughly at the same time as historians became interested in postcolonial theory and subaltern studies, and forged what became known as “the new imperial history.” Yet the two areas had different scholarly roots. Whiteness studies grew from labor history, sociology, cultural studies, and feminist theory, among other fields. Here I consider some connections between whiteness studies and the new imperial history as they have evolved, and a few of their implications for each other. Recent work has emphasized the global circulation of racial thinking, and historians of empire have located whiteness as a racial category in diverse colonial sites. Arguably, since the seventeenth century, if not before, the white settler colonies have been key sites. Relevant questions, I think, include: Has white settler colonialism been the breeding ground of specific forms of whiteness? How has the whiteness created by white settler colonialism been connected to the whiteness constructed by slavery and post-slavery societies—or that of societies shaped by both slavery and settler colonialism? How has Australian history, in particular, contributed to broader understanding of changing historical constructions of whiteness? And how might analyses of whiteness contribute to future work in Australian history? All of which, arguably, begs the question: How can we analyze and subvert whiteness without reifying it—through our seemingly inescapable shorthand of speaking of white people? Perhaps we should speak of “whitened” people? I begin with a few notes on the emergence of whiteness studies, before similarly considering the appearance of “the imperial turn,” and then moving on to the category of “settler colonialism.” I will then offer a few thoughts on how Australian history has contributed to broader understandings of historical constructions of whiteness, and conclude with a bit of speculation about how
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
CHAPTER 2
18
●
Angela Woollacott
analyses of whiteness, including work on other settler colonies, might help to shape our understanding of the nineteenth century in Australia.
One of the first and most inf luential historians to study whiteness was the American labor historian David Roediger. Roediger’s insightful work on whiteness, the first book of which was published in 1991, has been founded on his passionate commitment to radical politics and activism, specifically to the possibility of workers uniting across racial barriers. Through detailed research into the labor movement in late nineteenth-century America, Roediger argues that race and class were constructed together in a way that divided workers by privileging some workers through the category of whiteness. The social rewards of whiteness were sufficient to split the American working class and thus make it more tractable for employers, especially in the crucial decades following the Civil War and the abolition of slavery. In his close study of the 1877 General Strike in St Louis, for example, Roediger identified a moment of cross-racial protest that was quashed by a coalition of interests between the Europeandescended class of skilled workers, the local elite, and municipal authorities. In opting to close ranks with the local elite, skilled workers allowed racism to set limits on the potential for the labor movement to improve conditions for all workers.1 Roediger’s work was inf luential because of its detailed historical specificity and his appealing insistence that racism was not inevitable or immutable, but contingent and shifting. It is germane to recall the crucial role of David Roediger’s work for American history as we grapple with our current role as historians within whiteness studies. In Australia the field of whiteness studies was boosted in 2003 with the launching of the Australian Critical Race and Whiteness Studies Association (ACR AWSA). This interdisciplinary association is linked to cultural studies, anthropology, sociology, and other fields. Internationally, whiteness studies has had such interdisciplinary roots. Ruth Frankenberg’s 1993 study White Women, Race Matters: The Social Construction of Whiteness made clear how valuable a sociological approach could be for the United States. Frankenberg used detailed interviews with a small cohort of women to show variation in individual awareness of white racial privileges, as well as the operation of those privileges in specific demographic and cultural contexts. 2 Sociological and contemporary cultural criticism have also played a significant role in analyzing specific factors in the construction of whiteness in Australia. Aileen Moreton-Robinson’s substantial contributions to the field have included one of the few edited volumes on the subject, as well as a powerful critique of racism within Australian feminism. 3 Due to recent critical work, not only has the historical phenomenon of “White Australia” received valuable renewed scrutiny, but the term “whitefella” has become newly resonant. Whitefella still does not have the currency and therefore the ref lexive potency of the ubiquitous term “Pakeha” in Aotearoa/New Zealand, but it is gaining
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
The Emergence of Whiteness Studies
●
19
usage and served as the theme for a provocative look at late-twentieth-century Australian race relations.4 Disciplinary wellsprings for the study of whiteness have also included literary criticism and psychoanalytic theory, to plumb what, according to Jennifer Rutherford, are the roles of fantasy and aggression in white Australian identity.5 Tanya Dalziell’s study of settler romance fiction and gender (particularly “the Australian girl”) in the late nineteenth century explores the way whiteness was shaped in adventure stories often set in the bush. 6 In the United States, where the study of whiteness was first taken seriously, other historians quickly followed Roediger’s lead. The field soon boasted wonderful titles such as Noel Ignatiev’s How the Irish Became White (1995); Karen Brodkin’s How Jews Became White Folks and What that Says About Race in America (1998); Matthew Frye Jacobson’s Whiteness of a Different Color: European Immigrants and the Alchemy of Race (1998), and so forth.7 Whiteness studies also spawned in other disciplines. From its first emergence, the study of whiteness was applied to literature (not least by Toni Morrison8), film, and other areas of cultural production. It encompassed critical legal theory, and soon boasted not only at least one reader in whiteness studies, but from 1992 a journal titled Race Traitor edited by Noel Ignatiev and John Garvey, with the motto “Treason to whiteness is loyalty to humanity.” 9 The first feminist works to reveal complicity between feminists, racism, and imperialism did not use the term “whiteness” per se, even though their work— such as Vron Ware’s inf luential 1992 study Beyond the Pale: White Women, Racism and History—raised crucial questions about what Antoinette Burton termed feminists’ peculiar Burdens of History, that is, the contemporary legacies of racism in first-wave feminist thought and activism.10 Louise Newman’s work has been very important in raising these questions about the American women’s rights movement of the late nineteenth century. Through a detailed analysis of American feminist thought from 1870 to 1920, Newman demonstrates the central role of racism and evolutionary thought in underpinning middle-class women’s claims to expanded public roles based on their supposed white cultural superiority and moral work as civilizing agents.11 It is a real boon to Australian historiography that Jane Carey has taken up these issues in relation to the Australian women’s movement, with her current research on eugenics, whiteness, and feminism in the early twentieth century.12 So, we might well ask, what is the role of history? If some commentators worried aloud that whiteness studies was a re-privileging of the white subject (just as some also worried much the same thing about the rise of masculinity studies and the universal male subject), for many historians around the world interested in race relations, identifying white as a constructed racial category was a productive step. As Richard Dyer contends, whiteness has been constituted through dominance: “The point of seeing the racing of whites is to dislodge them/us from the position of power, with all the inequities, oppression, privileges and sufferings in its train, dislodging them/us by undercutting the authority with which they/we speak and act in and on the world.”13 Historians
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
Whiteness and “the Imperial Turn”
20
●
Angela Woollacott
can, quite specifically, shed light on how whiteness has been constructed as a dominant and normative racial category, in specific times and cultural contexts, and therefore have a crucial role to play in whiteness studies.
In Britain, the field of cultural studies was central to the rise of critical race theory, while many historians were far more conservative. Inf luenced by Marxism, Edward Said, Homi Bhabha, Michel Foucault, and the subaltern studies group—such as Gayatri Chakravorty Spivak’s critiques of history, imperialism, and representation—from the 1980s cultural studies scholars developed a critical appraisal of colonialism in the modern period, its depredations in the colonies themselves, and its implication in knowledge production and the writing of history. This academic enterprise had clear contemporary political dimensions in Britain because of what Robert Young has termed “the demonstration of the relation of structures of colonialism to contemporary forms of imperialism, neocolonialism and racism.”14 Crucial to the development of this field in Britain was the Birmingham Centre for Contemporary Cultural Studies, and the work in critical race theory by Stuart Hall and his student Paul Gilroy.15 It was no coincidence that one of the first British historians to use the term whiteness was Catherine Hall, Stuart Hall’s partner. In a 1992 essay, Catherine Hall referred to the varying meanings of whiteness as constructed by British missionaries in the West Indies in the 1830s and 1840s, such as one discursive rendering of it to mean “order, civilization, Christianity, separate spheres and domesticity, rationality, modernity and industry.” Equating whiteness also with the behavior of British colonizers, Hall goes on to suggest that in the same moment it could also mean “when white Anglican clergymen and planters, some dressed up as women, joined forces to burn down chapels and mission stations and lynch, tar and feather missionaries themselves.”16 Hall thus drew attention to the variability of whiteness, as well as the historical specificity of its meanings. There has been a strong school of historical thought in Britain that resists postcolonialism, the critical study of Orientalism, whiteness studies, and the new imperial history—especially the notion that the empire shaped the metropole itself. Those who defend the idea of metropolitan imperviousness to sullying by the empire, and a conceptual division between the British Isles and the colonies have been accused of imperial nostalgia. Such defenders point to the popularity of Raj nostalgia (and thus by implication the memory of the empire) among the British public, and see the new imperial history as the work of “some revisionist historians, principally across the Atlantic.”17 The eminent historian David Cannadine has specifically sought to counter the centrality of racial analysis in postcolonial histories by turning the discussion back toward class, the central category of analysis in older British social histories. Class, ritual, ceremony, and collaboration between local elites and British rulers constituted the main structure of the empire, according to Cannadine, in the book he titled
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
“The Imperial Turn”
●
21
Ornamentalism (2001) to signal its refutation of Said.18 Yet, against the weight of such resistance, there has been a growing school of British historians insisting on studying British imperialism around the globe and its ramifications. Arguably, slavery and its abolition have been foundational topics, through the work of historians such as James Walvin and Clare Midgley; so too has imperial propaganda and its presence in popular culture been a major theme, particularly in the work of John MacKenzie.19 It ought to be said, however, that there is still not a great deal of work on the historical construction of whiteness in Britain itself. Over the last fifteen years, there has been an explosion of work on the empire, with the profusion of feminist and postcolonial approaches applied to British colonialism in South Asia, Africa, the Caribbean, and, more recently, the white settler dominions. Playing on the epithet “the linguistic turn” used to denote the arrival of poststructuralism and deconstruction on the shores of the historical discipline, Antoinette Burton has defined the imperial turn in historical scholarship as: “accelerated attention to the impact of histories of imperialism on metropolitan societies in the wake of decolonization, pre- and post-1968 racial struggle and feminism in the last quarter century.” Further, she contends that it has not been a turn toward empire so much as a critical return to the connections between metropole and colony, race and nation, which imperial apologists and dissenters have appreciated at least since the nineteenth century, if not before. In the context of Euro-American colonial histories, then, what we might properly call the return to empire is one symptom of the pressure of postcolonial social, political, and demographic realities on the production of modern knowledge. 20 Burton’s focus was on the impact of postcolonial approaches on the study of the European and other metropoles. Yet we can also perceive an “imperial turn” in historical work on the colonies themselves, and connections across imperial locations. In relation to the history of the Antipodes, the phrase “the imperial turn” may at first glance seem nonsensical. A nonspecialist might imagine that Australian and New Zealand histories have always been necessarily contextualized through their location within the British Empire. Historians in these fields, of course, know that has not been the case. Increasingly, in fact, there has been a recent “return to empire” that has challenged the nationalist framework dominant in recent decades. Tony Ballantyne, in his study of the circulating and contingent ideology of Aryanism and connections between New Zealand and India in the nineteenth century, uses what he calls “the disruptive power of empire” and its “cross-cultural engagements.” Thus he refutes historiographical adherence to national boundaries in favor of studying “the cultural and intellectual transformations enacted by colonialism both in the colonies and in Europe itself.” 21
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
Whiteness and “the Imperial Turn”
●
Angela Woollacott
For Australian history, this development is especially significant because of a powerful nationalist historiographical paradigm, built on both radical nationalism and other variants. In the 1950s and 1960s, a left-leaning nationalist framework became ascendant in Australian historiography through inf luential works such as Vance Palmer’s The Legend of the Nineties (1954) and Russel Ward’s The Australian Legend (1958), followed by the somewhat different nationalist interpretations of Manning Clark. 22 While there were variations within this paradigm, and political differences between the radical nationalists of the post–World War II period, and the New Left of the Vietnam War years, the nationalist framework became firmly entrenched in Australian historiography. Its entrenching was linked to a rejection of both conservative, pro-empire political views and an older historiography that considered Australia within its relationship to Britain. Federation became a major focus of historical scholarship, ref lecting the emphasis on severing ties with Britain and the desire to see Australia only within its own shores. Significantly, the nationalist framework shaped the feminist and labor histories of the 1970s and 1980s, such that critical perspectives also stayed within national frames. Even the emergent field of Aboriginal history largely accepted the same boundaries. Historical research sought to consider Australian subjects on their own terms, rather than as broader global phenomena, and especially not as produced through the historical relationship with Britain—with the obvious exception of Australia’s convict origins, which was the subject of much work in this period. The imperial turn has included new attention to the historical relationship between metropole and colonies, and metropole and dominion, but it has also meant raising new questions about race relations and colonialism within our shores. Becoming more aware of the empire, then, has returned our gaze not just outward but insistently inward, with new questions about the continuing structures of colonialism. For us, Ania Loomba’s warnings have had particular pertinence. Loomba has pointed out that the “post” in “postcolonialism” does not mean that colonialism has been supplanted, and that “it is premature to proclaim the demise of colonialism.” Rather, she says, we need to see postcolonialism as “the contestation of colonial domination and the legacies of colonialism.”23 Thus, in the Australian context, the new imperial history has broached the territory mapped out by the field of Aboriginal history since the 1970s. In so doing, it is much indebted to and has joined forces with historians of Indigenous people in their critical approach to the history of Australian race relations. At the same time, it has brought some slightly different or renewed emphases to the historical study of race in Australia. For example, while the term “settler” has been used in Aboriginal history since the 1970s, there is now a reinvigorated interest in the meanings and workings of white settler colonialism here.
The Category of “Settler Colonialism” The very interesting recent collection on Settler Colonialism in the Twentieth Century (2005) edited by Caroline Elkins and Susan Pedersen suggests
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
22
●
23
commonalities and differences among states that have not, to my knowledge, previously been compared. They look at Korea and Manchuria under the Japanese, the Jewish settlement of Palestine, Angola and Mozambique under the Portuguese, German settlers in occupied Poland, and the French in Algeria, South Africa, Kenya, and Rhodesia, all as case studies of twentieth-century settler colonialism. Elkins and Pedersen posit differences between these twentieth-century cases and what they term “new world states” such as America and Australia. The differences include that in the twentieth-century cases the settlers mostly did not become majority populations; and the metropole continued to wield more power, including military power. 24 The book is very useful in its broadening of the category of settler colonialism beyond the white settler colonies of the European empires. A basic question then is: Is white settler colonialism categorically different from other settler colonialisms? I think the answer must be no. Penny Edwards, in her work comparing anti-miscegenation policies and child removal in Western Australia, Burma, and Cambodia, argues against distinctions between crown colonies and settler colonies. 25 Colonialism, its racial hierarchies and their intersections with other categories, and its regulatory and discursive regimes operated in ways directly comparable across such typologies. Yet there are specificities to white settler colonial histories that offer us insights into the contingent construction of whiteness as the superordinate racial category. In white settler colonies, there have been specific regimes in which whiteness itself accrued legislative, regulatory, and cultural substance. This is where linking whiteness and settler colonialism can provide us with telling insights. Needless to say, although my focus is on the British Empire, Algeria and other non-British examples of white settler colonialism are in the same frame. And Katherine Ellinghaus’s work makes clear the value of comparing Australia and the United States in the modern period when the latter was no longer part of the British Empire. 26 As the editors of this volume argue in their introduction, whiteness studies will benefit both from being “unmoored” from its tethering to American labor and migration history, and at the same time locating its operations there as stemming from America’s settler-colonial origins. 27 While Elkins and Pedersen draw distinctions between what they call “new world settler states” and their twentieth-century case studies, it was largely in the twentieth century that whiteness was overtly enshrined and empowered. In South Africa, of course, the Apartheid regime from 1948 to 1994 articulated white racial privilege in a myriad of legal, economic, political, and social forms. The twentieth century also produced the full emergence of a legislatively entrenched White Australia, although, as Leigh Boucher argues in his essay in this section, the 1870s and 1880s were the formative imperial historical moment when “[p]olitical entitlement and competence . . . were explicitly designated as white.” 28 There is much historical reason to suggest that we should look more closely at connections between South Africa and Australia. As Fiona Paisley has
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
Whiteness and “the Imperial Turn”
24
●
Angela Woollacott
national history cannot be so directly read as signaling “separation” from empire. In the Australian case, post-federation nationalism emerged hand-in-hand with, and not in opposition to, empire. In fact loyalty to the British Empire increased in the first decades of nationhood as strengthened race ideology provided for both a White and an Imperial Australia. 29 As Paisley suggests, contrary to what has been at least implicit in some nationalist histories, Australians’ identification with the British Empire, and the concomitant articulation of whiteness, may in fact have been most overt and marked in the first half of the twentieth century. A new book by Marilyn Lake and Henry Reynolds locates Australia as one of several “white men’s countries” that in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries together shaped a “global colour line.”30
Australian History and Historical Constructions of Whiteness Twelve years ago I sought to grapple with the historically specific construction of whiteness in the Australian colonies-dominion in my article on “Australian Women’s Voyages ‘Home’ and the Articulation of Colonial Whiteness.” One problem I sought to work through in writing that piece was the complexities of Australians’ positioning in imperial hierarchies of the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries: their simultaneous status as colonials and colonizers. I suggested that: “Occupying an in-between ranking in imperial hierarchy, Australian women sought to elide the inferiority inherent in their colonialness by emphasizing their whiteness and their economic and cultural privileging.” My focus was on the sea voyage Australian women and men took en route to England, and their status as white colonials in the imperial metropolis. It seemed to me that “while whiteness may have been so normative as to be partly invisible in Australia itself, exposure to different colonial racial structures [at the ports of call] at times compelled women to articulate notions of themselves as white that were integral to developing Australian national identity but usually tacit.” My reading of women’s records from the period—such as their accounts of their visits to Colombo, Bombay, Durban, and other ports— suggested that: “during the decades in which Australians established and first interpreted national Australian identity, the whiteness that was crucial to that identity was premised on a shared British heritage . . . , on notions of England as ‘home,’ and on belonging to the stratum of imperial rulers.”31 My own focus is now turning to the articulation of whiteness and settler colonialism within Australia’s shores, and I am excited by, and learning a great deal from, the work that has been done on that subject in recent years—as essays in this volume demonstrate. I am finding particularly useful and
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
argued, Australian history shows the complex relationship between colonialism, nationalism, and empire, such that
●
25
stimulating the work that looks carefully at historically specific constructions of whiteness, racial power, and privilege in the settler-colonial context. Leigh Boucher’s work brings together careful archival research, a biographical approach, and discourse analysis. His analysis of settler-colonial men, their “othering” of Chinese and Indigenous subjects, and their construction of their own privilege and entitlements is a wonderful model of empirically grounded, specifically contextualized work on whiteness.32 Also, Penelope Edmonds’s work on nineteenth-century expressions of Anglo-Saxonism raises very interesting questions about whiteness and settler colonialism.33 Through such detailed work, we are gradually accruing informed insights into the operation and evolution of settler colonialism here in Australia, and elsewhere. A relevant question is: Can a study allow insight into whiteness without using the term? And I think the answer must be “yes.” I have in mind two studies in particular. I have greatly enjoyed reading Julie Evans’s book on Edward Eyre, race, and colonial governance. With detailed attention to the contexts of each stage of his career, and his own actions, as well as careful analysis of his writings, Evans mounts an argument that Eyre’s ultimate repressiveness in Jamaica was the product of colonialism itself. Evans traces the evolution of Eyre’s thinking and policies toward colonized peoples, and the ways in which he responded to the specific circumstances of each of his positions and the exigencies pertaining to the different colonies. This in turn builds her argument about his ultimately repressive policies being the systemic results of colonialism, that is, of the intractable opposition of imperial interests and the rights and interests of colonized peoples. Without specifically addressing whiteness, she helps us to see the contingent operations of colonial rule that directly contributed to ideas of white racial superiority and authority. 34 Like Penny Edwards’s work, Evans’s study cuts across typologies of colonies with its focus on historical specificity and organic interconnections. Another book that speaks to whiteness studies, though it does not use exactly that term, is Victoria Haskins’s One Bright Spot (2005).35 By telling the story of her great-grandmother as an employer of indentured Aboriginal domestic servants under the Aborigines Protection Board of New South Wales in the early twentieth century, Haskins presents us with a richly detailed story of individual women, their lives intertwined across racial and class boundaries. She shows in vivid detail how white women’s social and racial positioning was created through this government-run system of exploitation, and discusses the complex politics surrounding the system at the time, as well as its historical legacies. These studies and a number of others have contributed recently to our understanding of white racial privileges, power, and identities in Australian history—and by extension to the history of settler colonialism and whiteness transnationally.
Analyses of Whiteness and the Nineteenth Century in Australia The essays in this collection show that work on whiteness is providing new insights into Australian history, across a range of time periods and topics, as
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
Whiteness and “the Imperial Turn”
●
Angela Woollacott
well as other national and transnational histories. As historians, we know that racial categories including whiteness have been to a large extent historically contingent, and that we must look freshly at different periods. Scholars of whiteness in the early modern period are providing really intriguing and valuable lessons for those of us who are modernists, about the quite different meanings attached to skin color at earlier moments. Roxann Wheeler’s study of racial understandings in eighteenth-century Britain reveals changing conceptions and uncertainty about racial categories. She argues that skin color, or complexion, was not the only determinant of racial status; rather, it was one determinant, but judgments also depended on a subject’s status in relation to religion (Christianity being an important component of whiteness), education, and consumerism. Colonialism itself, Wheeler contends, became an important force in changing understandings of racial hierarchies.36 In her essay in this section, Louise Newman shows how f luid ideas of whiteness were in the American colonies from the seventeenth century onward, how they varied by time and place, and how in fact the current racial category of “white” is the product of centuries of racial mixing.37 I am currently trying to educate myself about the mid-nineteenth century. For someone whose work has not much ventured earlier than the 1870s, this is a fascinating challenge. I find I am learning both from those who have focused on the Australian colonies, and those who have pursued connections and comparisons with other colonies—such as Julie Evans, and also Kirsten McKenzie in her evocative work on status, respectability, and class in New South Wales and the Cape Colony.38 As we seek to understand the construction of whiteness in Australia in the mid-nineteenth century, I suspect that work on other imperial locations— particularly, and perhaps only, other white settler colonies—will prove valuable. For example, in exploring how whiteness may have shaped social and legal hierarchies in the period following the end of convict transportation, that is, from the 1840s, Pamela Scully’s work on the period of and after slave emancipation in the western Cape Colony may offer clues. In Australia, whiteness may well have been invoked to leverage the social status of emancipated convicts, as they struggled against material challenges and social prejudice. From Scully’s work, we know that racial categories were reimagined after the emancipation of the enslaved in the 1830s, and as social and legal categories were rearticulated in conjunction with new patterns of labor and landholding. Conceptions of gender, respectability, and the family were all newly articulated to shore up a system of continuing racial hierarchy and oppression that needed new underpinnings to reflect the new legal realities. Scully shows powerfully how discourses of race and sexuality intertwined, such that, for women, “virtue” became synonymous with whiteness in a continuing subordination of black women.39 For the Australian context, similar questions could be applied to the effects of the ending of convict transportation on the linked categories of race, morality, and sexuality. Several scholars are conducting research that shows the significance of connections between, and the circulation of ideas around, the white settler colonies
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
26
●
27
of the empire. In her study of the 1835–36 Select Committee on Aborigines, Elizabeth Elbourne argues that “debates about virtue were inf luenced by cross-cutting transnational discourses in the British world about religion, economics and gender, despite enormous variations in particular local contexts and in the local political implications of such discourses.”40 Considering New South Wales and the Cape Colony in one frame, Elbourne analyzes discussion of the virtue or otherwise of the British settler, and official plans to increase metropolitan oversight of settlers’ treatment of Indigenous peoples. Such plans envisaged elevating the morals and behavior of white settlers at the same time as bringing Indigenous people into the fold of Christianity. Metropolitan perceptions of white settlers, at least, encompassed widely separated colonies within the same discursive frame.41 Alan Lester’s work on the eastern Cape Colony in the nineteenth century emphasizes imperial connectedness. “British colonial discourses,” Lester contends, “were made and remade, rather than simply transferred or imposed . . . between Britain and settler colonies like the Cape.”42 Lester suggests that, just as the empire’s material base consisted of an articulated worldwide trade in commodities, imperial production of knowledge also f lowed between colonies and metropole and globally around the empire. “Settler newspapers and letters, . . . official dispatches and travellers’ reports,” parliamentary commissions, their “minutes of evidence” and reports, all circulated among the colonies, not least via the metropolitan and colonial presses.43 Lester finds these imperial networks illuminating for his study of the colonization of the Xhosa in the mid-nineteenth century because: During moments of imperial crisis in particular, colonial representations of the Xhosa were considered in the light of Australian settlers’ images of the Aborigine, New Zealand colonists’ constructions of the Maori, Indian officials’ notions of the “Hindoo,” West Indian planters’ portrayals of former slaves and not least, British bourgeois ideas of the labouring classes and other domestic “subaltern” groups. This circulating compendium of racialized images, Lester contends, shaped metropolitan racial discourse and images as much as those of the colonies.44 While Lester does not himself speak of whiteness, here, I think, we have important insight into the connections between settler colonialism and whiteness. A racial lexicon forged in multiple colonial sites, especially the confrontational and violent sites of settler colonialism, shaped British and hence EuroAmerican conceptions of racial hierarchy, even before the rise of so-called scientific racism. The violent struggles over land and for colonial control were narrated by the winners in multiple kinds of records that would become the colonial archive so inf luential in the later writing of histories. At the time of the creation of this circulating imperial discourse, the racial hierarchies it forged were crowned by the stratum of imperial rulers: the white settlers, colonial officials, and all who claimed British identity and status. Justifications for
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
Whiteness and “the Imperial Turn”
●
Angela Woollacott
dispossession of Indigenous peoples, for colonial rule and violence, were articulated in specific ideas of white settler racial and cultural superiority. The whiteness of settler colonialism has been forged in multiple and importantly diverse sites and times. Of course, it must not be seen as any monolith, or more significant than definitions of whiteness constructed in other sites. What it illustrates is the globally circulating nature of this toxic racial fiction, its plasticity, and its historical reach. Gail B. Griffin has suggested that the work of scholars includes “the relentless destruction of innocence” about privilege and its workings in “oppressive discourses and institutions”—a destruction that meets “quite natural resistance to this ultimate loss of innocence.”45 Exploring whiteness as a constructed racial category, and the specificities of its historical links to settler colonialism, can perhaps further the work of disrupting the “innocence” of racial hierarchies, their legacies, and the continuing effects of colonialism. In such a project, whiteness studies and postcolonial studies seem likely allies. The new imperial history, while perhaps not so new as it used to be, still holds much promise for exploring the historical workings of colonialism, and has potential to develop. It can continue to learn from whiteness studies, and in turn contribute substantially to it through providing grounded and contextualized analyses of the emergence and evolution of whiteness.
Notes 1. David Roediger, Towards the Abolition of Whiteness (London: Verso, 1994), especially chapter 7. Roediger’s first book on the subject was The Wages of Whiteness: Race and the Making of the American Working Class (London: Verso, 1991). 2. Ruth Frankenberg, White Women, Race Matters: The Social Construction of Whiteness (Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 1993). 3. Aileen Moreton-Robinson, ed., Whitening Race: Essays in Social and Cultural Criticism (Canberra: Aboriginal Studies Press, 2004); Talkin’ Up to the White Woman: Aboriginal Women and Feminism (Brisbane: University of Queensland Press, 2000). 4. Duncan Graham, ed., Being Whitefella (Fremantle: Fremantle Arts Centre Press, 1994). 5. Jennifer Rutherford, The Gauche Intruder: Freud, Lacan and the White Australian Fantasy (Melbourne: Melbourne University Press, 2000). 6. Tanya Dalziell, Settler Romances and the Australian Girl (Perth: University of Western Australia Press, 2004). 7. Noel Ignatiev, How the Irish Became White (New York: Routledge, 1995); Karen Brodkin, How Jews Became White Folks and What That Says about Race in America (New Brunswick: Rutgers University Press, 1998); Matthew Frye Jacobson, Whiteness of a Different Color: European Immigrants and the Alchemy of Race (Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1998). 8. Toni Morrison, Playing in the Dark: Whiteness and the Literary Imagination (Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1992). See also Valerie Babb, Whiteness Visible: The Meaning of Whiteness in American Literature and Culture (New York: New York University Press, 1998).
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
28
●
29
9. Ian Haney-Lopez, White By Law: The Legal Construction of Race (New York: New York University Press, 1996); Mike Hill, ed., Whiteness: A Critical Reader (New York: New York University Press, 1997); David W. Stowe, “Uncolored People: The Rise of Whiteness Studies,” Lingua Franca no. 6 (September–October 1996): 74. 10. Vron Ware, Beyond the Pale: White Women, Racism and History (London: Verso, 1992); Antoinette Burton, Burdens of History: British Feminists, Indian Women, and Imperial Culture 1865–1915 (Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 1994). 11. Louise Newman, White Women’s Rights: The Racial Origins of Feminism in the United States (New York: Oxford University Press, 1999). 12. Jane Carey, chapter thirteen in this collection. 13. Richard Dyer, White (London: Routledge, 1997), 2. 14. Robert Young, White Mythologies: Writing History and the West (London: Routledge, 1990), 174. 15. See Kuan-Hsing Chan and David Morley, eds., Stuart Hall: Critical Dialogues in Cultural Studies (London: Routledge, 1996). 16. Catherine Hall, White, Male and Middle Class: Explorations in Feminism and History (New York: Routledge, 1992), 212. 17. Geoffrey Moorhouse, “The Old Scenes Shall Rise Again . . . ,” Review section, The Guardian, October 1, 2005, 9. 18. David Cannadine, Ornamentalism: How the British Saw their Empire (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2001). 19. See, e.g., James Walvin, England, Slaves and Freedom, 1776–1838 (Basingstoke: Macmillan, 1986); Clare Midgley, Women Against Slavery: The British Campaigns, 1780–1870 (London: Routledge, 1992); John M. MacKenzie, Propaganda and Empire: The Manipulation of British Public Opinion, 1880–1960 (Manchester: Manchester University Press, 1984). 20. Antoinette Burton, After the Imperial Turn: Thinking with and through the Nation (Durham: Duke University Press, 2003), 2; emphasis in the original. 21. Tony Ballantyne, Orientalism and Race: Aryanism in the British Empire (Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan, 2002), 3–4. 22. Vance Palmer, The Legend of the Nineties (Melbourne: Melbourne University Press, 1954); Russel Ward, The Australian Legend (Melbourne: Oxford University Press, 1958). On Manning Clark, see John Docker, In a Critical Condition: Reading Australian Literature (Melbourne: Penguin Books, 1984), 110–17. 23. Ania Loomba, Colonialism/Postcolonialism (London: Routledge, 1998), 7, 12. 24. Caroline Elkins and Susan Pedersen, eds., Settler Colonialism in the Twentieth Century (New York: Routledge, 2005), 3–4. 25. Penny Edwards, “On Home Ground: Settling Land and Domesticating Difference in the ‘Non-Settler’ Colonies of Burma and Cambodia,” Journal of Colonialism and Colonial History 4, no. 3 (2003). http://muse.jhu.edu/journals/journal_of_ colonialism_and_colonial_history/v004/4.3edwards.html 26. See Katherine Ellinghaus, Taking Assimilation to Heart: Marriages of White Women and Indigenous Men in the United States and Australia, 1887–1937 (Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press, 2006); and chapter sixteen in this collection. 27. Jane Carey, Leigh Boucher, and Katherine Ellinghaus, chapter one in this collection. 28. Leigh Boucher, chapter four in this collection. 29. Fiona Paisley, “Introduction: White Settler Colonialisms and the Colonial Turn: An Australian Perspective,” Journal of Colonialism and Colonial History 4, no. 3 (2003).
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
Whiteness and “the Imperial Turn”
30.
31.
32.
33. 34. 35. 36. 37. 38. 39.
40.
41.
42. 43. 44. 45.
●
Angela Woollacott
http://muse.jhu.edu/journals/journal_of_colonialism_and_colonial_histor y/ v004/4.3intro.html Marilyn Lake and Henry Reynolds, Drawing the Global Colour Line: White Men’s Countries and the International Challenge of Racial Equality (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2008). Angela Woollacott, “ ‘All this is the Empire, I Told Myself ’: Australian Women’s Voyages ‘Home’ and the Articulation of Colonial Whiteness,” The American Historical Review 102, no. 4 (October 1997): 1006–8. See Leigh Boucher, “Masculinity Gone Mad: Settler Colonialism, Masculinity and the White Body in Late Nineteenth Century Victoria,” Lilith 13 (2004): 51–67; as well as chapter four in this collection. Penelope Edmonds, chapter eight in this collection. Julie Evans, Edward Eyre, Race and Colonial Governance (Dunedin: University of Otago Press, 2005). Victoria Haskins, One Bright Spot (Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan, 2005). Roxann Wheeler, The Complexion of Race: Categories of Difference in EighteenthCentury British Culture (Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 2000). Louise Newman, chapter three in this collection. Kirsten McKenzie, Scandal in the Colonies: Sydney and Cape Town, 1800–1850 (Melbourne: Melbourne University Press, 2004). Pamela Scully, Liberating the Family? Gender and British Slave Emancipation in the Rural Western Cape, South Africa, 1823–1853 (Portsmouth, NH: Heinemann, 1997), 175. Elizabeth Elbourne, “The Sin of the Settler: The 1835–36 Select Committee on Aborigines and Debates over Virtue and Conquest in the Early Nineteenth-Century British White Settler Empire,” Journal of Colonialism and Colonial History 4, no. 3 (2003). http://muse.jhu.edu/journals/journal_of_colonialism_and_colonial_history/ v004/4.3elbourne.html Other scholars who are embarking on research projects linking the white settler colonies include Ann Curthoys, who holds an Australian Research Council Professorial Fellowship for her project on “Indigenous Peoples, the British Empire, and self-government for the Australian colonies”; and also my own ARC-funded research project on “Settler Society in the Australian Colonies: The Cultural and Political Changes of the 1830s to 1860s in Imperial Context.” Alan Lester, Imperial Networks: Creating identities in nineteenth-century South Africa and Britain (London: Routledge, 2001), 5. Ibid., 7. Ibid., 189. Gail B. Griffin, “Speaking of Whiteness: Disrupting White Innocence,” MMLA: The Journal of the Midwest Modern Language Association 31, no. 3 (Spring 1998): 3.
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
30
The Strange Career of Whiteness: Miscegenation, Assimilation, Abdication Louise Newman
T
he title of this chapter is taken from the title of a book written in 1955 by C. Vann Woodward, a renowned historian of race from the United States. Woodward’s book, The Strange Career of Jim Crow, appeared just one year after the Supreme Court’s famous ruling in Brown v. Board of Education (1954), which declared unconstitutional the principle of separate but equal that underlay segregation ever since the court’s upholding of that principle in Plessy v. Ferguson (1896). Woodward, in tracing the history of racial segregation in the South, was especially taken with the various ironies in this history. Although most Americans—then and now—associated Jim Crow laws with the South, Woodward pointed out that it was a system that had first emerged in northern states in the antebellum period and was only infused into southern law several decades after the end of the Civil War (not immediately afterward as many believed). Woodward also took comfort in the fact that Jim Crow seemed to be an overlay onto southern culture, not something intrinsic to the region’s history or deeply embedded in southern social custom. In other words, Woodward argued that Jim Crow as a social, political, and legal institution was of very recent vintage and from the vantage point of 1955, was vulnerable and under attack.1 Thus, in Woodward’s view, Jim Crow in the South had had a very strange career indeed, with its seemingly abrupt emergence at the end of the nineteenth century and its equally sudden demise in the middle of the twentieth century. Of course, from today’s perspective, the supposed challenge to the legal basis for Jim Crow that took place in 1954 may seem less significant to us than it appeared to Woodward’s generation. Nonetheless, a major accomplishment of
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
CHAPTER 3
●
Louise Newman
Woodward’s book, and the reason I have adapted his title for this chapter, is to remind us that the history of whiteness in the United States has had its own strange career (Jim Crow being just one of its manifestations) and is full of its own vagaries, nuances, and ironies. This essay attempts to grapple with some of the questions that Angela Woollacott, in the preceding chapter of this collection, encourages us to think about: “Has white settler colonialism been the breeding ground of specific forms of whiteness?” 2 The answer, it seems to me, is clearly yes, but white settler colonialism was different in different parts of the world, and the U.S. example is particularly revealing in that different groups of white settlers inhabited different parts of the country. The earliest among the European settlers (British, French, Dutch, German, and Spanish, among others) perhaps shared a belief in European superiority, but nonetheless had very different attitudes concerning those they considered their racial inferiors. For example, French Canadians who settled in Louisiana had different notions about race and racial difference than, say, the English who settled in Virginia. This is a complex history and I will touch on a few of these differences later in my chapter. Moreover, Woollacott encourages us to also consider “how . . . whiteness created by white settler colonialism [was] connected to the whiteness constructed by slavery and post-slavery societies—or that of societies shaped by both slavery and settler colonialism.” The United States is an example of the latter—a society shaped by both settler colonialism and slavery, with the two coexisting for several hundred years. In the United States, racialized slavery (of Africans) evolved out of and in contrast to indentured servitude (of European settlers) and took part in the forging of new understandings of whiteness and blackness. My subtitle, “Miscegenation, Assimilation, Abdication,” is an attempt to distill from this complex history three distinct practices, or strategies, that European settlers and their descendants in North America employed in their interactions with peoples of other races. Certainly I could have chosen other practices: segregation, sterilization, and lynching come immediately to mind. But the terms I have chosen appealed to me because they were practices that revealed the f luidity and merging of racial categories, as much as they were intended to solidify the boundaries between different races. On the one hand, these strategies could be and were employed by European whites in progressive ways; for example, to extend the political and legal privileges of whiteness (freedom, citizenship, property, and the franchise) to individuals who were culturally considered to be, or legally categorized as, nonwhite. For example, in some instances, assimilation offered a way to redefine as white individuals those who had been excluded from the category on biological or cultural grounds. Even today education and/or wealth can be used to anoint particular individuals as honorary whites and historians have shown how assimilation has brought about a racial re-categorization of whole “races,” as in the case of the Irish and Jews. At the same time, assimilation and miscegenation were also used to delineate and exclude from the white race those individuals and peoples
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
32
●
33
who did not conform—in biological, cultural, religious, or gender terms—to emerging ideals and norms of whiteness. Once I settled on these analytical terms, however, it became immediately evident that my ordering of these terms was arbitrary. Beginning with miscegenation—or rather, the arguments over whether interracial marriage should be legal or not—would allow me to ref lect on the historical imperatives and choices facing European male settlers, suggesting that for them, the first order of business was to secure a progeny. But what if I adopted the perspective of a different group of historical subjects, say European women: the meanings of my terms would need to be rethought. How frequently did European women in the seventeenth century, either as freeborn women or as indentured servants, have sex with or marry indigenous peoples or indentured servants from Africa? And why would a European woman make such a choice, if presumably there were European men available to her? In the case of English indentured servant women, there is some evidence to suggest that interracial marriage could help them avoid sexual advances by their European masters. Moreover, historians know that such intermarriages took place, even after indentured servitude for Africans evolved into lifelong slavery, and even when, as was the case in Maryland, the decision of a European woman to marry an enslaved African meant that she would have to assume the slave status of her husband so long as he was alive. Consider the famous case of Irish Nell. In this instance, Nell’s children were racialized as black and enslaved for life (as were their descendants). Intermarriage for Irish Nell thus required an abdication of her previously unchallenged whiteness: the formerly free white woman was forced to relinquish her own freedom and that of all her descendants upon her marriage to an African man. 3 For other Euro/British settlers, abdication of whiteness may have begun involuntarily. I am thinking of the British-descended men and women taken captive by Indians in white-Indian warfare, who were then construed by their former compatriots as “lost to the race,” even though, according to historian Gary Nash, many of these captives often chose to remain in Indian societies.4 Or if I shift perspectives once again, this time from European women to indigenous peoples, how might miscegenation, assimilation, and abdication appear to them? From the perspective of indigenous peoples, interracial sex and marriage had one set of meanings upon initial contact, when indigenous peoples outnumbered European settlers by the hundreds of thousands, and when their own political sovereignty was unthreatened. But interracial marriage and assimilation carried very different meanings in the nineteenth century, once native peoples were relegated to reservations and denied U.S. citizenship, which was only offered to them on the condition that they relinquish their own forms of government, labor, and religion and agree to adopt white forms of gendered labor and marital/sexual relations. In characterizing the history of the United States in the twentieth century, historians often use the term assimilation to connote a voluntary process of foreign-born immigrants learning English, adopting “American” forms of culture, and becoming naturalized American
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
The Strange Career of Whiteness
●
Louise Newman
citizens. But for Native Americans, assimilation could be seen as the finishing touch on the physical genocide that they experienced at the hands of European immigrants and their descendants.5 Regardless of my ordering of these terms, might it make sense to try to place these various strategies in relation to one another, as either alternatives or prerequisites, synchronous or sequential in time? For example, did Euro Americans demand a certain degree of assimilation on the part of Indians or Africans before intermarriage could be envisioned as part of an acculturation program? Or was the opposite the case: did whites believe in assimilations programs only after a certain amount of racial mixing had occurred? Were amalgamation and assimilation at odds with one another or different means to the same end? In the second half of the nineteenth century, when the lines between biology and culture were not as firmly drawn as they are today, the prevailing belief among white elites was that individuals (and thus whole races) inherited not just physical racial traits such as skin color, but cultural practices as well. These beliefs led to pressing political questions that were often articulated in socialDarwinian terms: was Christian civilization passed on from white father to white son, white mother to white daughter, along with skin color and intelligence or virtue? Might attempts to assimilate non-Christian, non-civilized “others” have the unintended effect of causing (white) civilization to regress even if it did result in the “progress” of so-called primitive (nonwhite) races? Ref lecting on these questions, I found it unhelpful to think of these as separate or discrete processes: interracial marriage, miscegenation outside marriage, efforts to assimilate nonwhite peoples into U.S. “civilization,” and abdication of whiteness (whites becoming Indianized or whites choosing to have black children) often coexisted in time, although not always comfortably. These, then, are some of the complexities that emerged as I tried to envision what it might mean to historicize whiteness in the context of U.S. history. I want now to turn to the first of my themes, miscegenation. What one legal historian has called the “anti-miscegenation regime” extended for three hundred years, from 1664 through to 1967.6 The year 1664 represents the date of the first law banning interracial marriage (in Maryland; Virginia’s first law was 1691); 1967 is the year that the Supreme Court declared such laws unconstitutional in Loving v. Virginia. But, as historians know well, despite the laws that forbade it, miscegenation has been an integral part of U.S. history. How then did a notion of white racial purity emerge out of a history that has been thoroughly saturated with racial mixing? When, how, and for whom did whiteness emerge as a racial category on the American continent? How did its meanings change over time? Let me begin with the moment of initial contact between European settlers and indigenous peoples. Some historians have treated miscegenation as a strategy employed by European male settlers to facilitate their own survival in places where European women were scarce, and in some instances, to produce descendants. Spanish conquistadors, in particular, mixed with indigenous women throughout North and South America. Such mixing was facilitated by an economic system called
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
34
●
35
repartimento, by which Indian peoples were made subject to Spanish conquerors and brought into close contact as tribute laborers. In sixteenth-century Cuzco, Peru, as historian Kathryn Burns has shown, interracial liaisons were common among the first generation of Spanish conquistadors, and the mixed-raced offspring were racialized in different ways: depending not just on physical appearance and skin color, but equally significantly on sex. Mestizo sons were racialized as non-European because they were construed as competitors with European/Spanish men, for both women and land, while the mestiza daughters could be “Europeanized” in a variety of ways. One of the more intriguing of these was by cloistering them in a monastery until they were of marriageable age, with the goal of making them suitable wives for other European/Spanish settlers. By 1650, mestizos and mestisas outnumbered Spaniards in New Spain and were to play a large role in later stages of colonization and conquest.7 In North America, each colonial settlement had its own attitudes toward interracial sex in its various forms—concubinage, prostitution, or marriage— depending on demographic and economic factors, as well as on the cultural beliefs of the particular European settlers and indigenous peoples. As historian Jennifer Spear has demonstrated, colonial administrators and missionaries in French Louisiana during the seventeenth century expressed concerned about the extensive concubinage occurring between French Canadian men and Indian women, believing that such relationships encouraged licentiousness among both partners and “retarded the growth” of the colony by discouraging European men from settling down in monogamous relationships and becoming farmers. 8 The French perceived Indian women as more sexual, more promiscuous, and more independent than European women (this must have been part of the allure). Thus, the French construction of Indian women’s sexuality conf licted with their beliefs about how to create a stable society, which was fundamentally dependent upon women’s sexual subordination and obedience to husbands. Moreover, French secular officials and religious leaders disagreed with one another over whether marriage to Indians was a desirable alternative to concubinage. French missionaries felt that mixed-race marriages could serve as a “ ‘civilising’ vehicle” leading to the “cultural colonisation” of Indian women and their children.9 Secular French officials, by contrast, did not know which form of metissage—concubinage or interracial marriage—was worse. Concubinage encouraged licentious behavior, but interracial marriage entailed the risk of losing French male inhabitants to an Indian way of life altogether. They feared that marriage to Indians would Indianize the French colonists, not Europeanize the Indians.10 As a solution to this problem, both secular administrators and religious officials in Louisiana agreed on the desirability of importing more women from France and expected that the resulting marriages would bring stability and morality to the colony. Ironically, although French officials obliged, the desired moral social order did not materialize. Between 1662 and 1673 French
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
The Strange Career of Whiteness
●
Louise Newman
authorities sent more than 700 young women—most of them illiterate orphans from the Hospital General du Paris, which served as a house of detention and correction for prostitutes and vagrants—and between 1718 and 1721 another 1,215 French women emigrated. Nonetheless, by the end of the 1720s, FrenchLouisiana officials were still complaining that many of the French women were “useless and . . . do nothing but cause disorder.”11 Virginia is a convenient focus for the next part of my discussion because an analysis of its history enables us to explore how whiteness came to be associated with freedom in contrast to blackness, which became associated with enslavement. In Virginia, in contrast to Louisiana, the issues of miscegenation and interracial marriage revolved primarily around white-black liaisons, as opposed to white-Indian liaisons. Despite a shortage of English women, white-Indian marriages were a rare occurrence in Virginia, as well as in other early English settlements (North and South Carolina). Richard Godbeer attributes the rarity of such marriages to a number of factors: English sense of cultural superiority and their disdain for Indians’ “barbaric” way of life; biblical injunctions against marriage to non-Christians; English fear that Indians might use intermarriage as a means to infiltrate colonial settlements; and, conversely, English apprehension that Indian men might be jealous and resentful and so wage war on settlements in which intermarriages had occurred.12 Those among the English who valued premarital chastity were shocked by Indians’ seemingly permissive attitudes toward sex; those without such scruples worried about the alleged prevalence of syphilis. In short, English colonists feared that marriage to native women would endanger their own mores, safety, and health.13 Nonetheless, as Godbeer points out, such cultural beliefs did not prevent English colonists from having sex with Indian women, leading to sexual interactions that could be characterized as either embodying “the violence of colonial appropriation” or the “mutual and successful accommodation of different peoples.”14 As historians have pointed out, the peoples of European descent who inhabited Virginia in the seventeenth century noticed and remarked upon differences of color and often expressed a preference for lightness/whiteness, associating it with beauty and morality. Virginia planter William Byrd, writing in the early 1700s, took note of the male settlers’ “squeamish” opposition to Anglo-Indian marriages, arguing that it was due to their “aversion to the copper complexion of the natives.” Byrd himself found this view “unreasonable” and pointed out that the progeny of interracial marriages became whiter with each passing generation: “if a Moor may be washed white in three generations,” Byrd wrote, “surely an Indian might have been blanched in two.”15 But as Kathleen Brown’s study Good Wives, Nasty Wenches and Anxious Patriarchs (1996) reminds us, American colonists for the most part did not think of race, as we do today, in terms of color. It took over 150 years (from 1600 to 1785 or so) for racialized categories to solidify in Virginia and, as racial categories emerged, they fused together ideas of national ancestry, religion, color, gender, sexual division of labor, freedom, and slavery. As Brown describes this process, gender distinctions between “good” and “wanton” women eventually
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
36
●
37
hardened into and overlapped with racial distinctions as we have come to understand them: virtuous women (good wives) became identified with freeborn women of English descent (known for their domestic labor, obedience, chastity, and submission) and this group of women eventually became distinguishable from women of African descent, with the implication of wantonness and enslavement.16 Many historians, Brown included, have commented on the crucial importance that legislation played in this process of racialization. In 1662, the Virginian legislature made enslavement inheritable, establishing the principle that the status of the child would follow that of the mother. Historian Kathleen Wilson has pointed out that this legislation contravened usual patriarchal practices,17 but Martha Hodes has done a great job in speculating why legislators might have chosen to do so. Perhaps “the most compelling reasons,” Hodes writes: are the question of who could care for the enslaved children of a free white woman; the fact that paternity was too often difficult . . . to prove; the fact that [having the child follow the status of the father] might encourage masters to coerce white women into sex with enslaved men . . . to produce more slaves; or perhaps such laws would have left too little distinction between white women and black women if either one could produce enslaved offspring.18 The legislation of 1662 was intended to clarify the relationship between English men and their mixed-race offspring, making those children their property rather than their heirs. But the legislation also led to the creation of two different groups of mixed-race offspring (legally speaking): the free children of European women who had children with black men; and the enslaved children of European men and black women. Thus, the legislation had the undesirable effect (undesirable from the perspective of ruling whites) of destabilizing the system of racialized slavery that was slowly evolving; by producing mixed-raced people who were free, but indistinguishable in color and appearance from mixed-race people who were enslaved. To address these consequences, the Virginia legislature passed a new law in 1691, noting that it found sexual liaisons between white mothers and black men “spurious,” even the more so if these relationships were sanctioned by marriage.19 Although the 1691 law condemned all marriages between whites and nonwhites (not just those between white women and black men) its main intent was to target and punish white women (not white or black men). If the white woman was unmarried and her child illegitimate, the woman was fined for giving birth to the mixed-race child; and if she could not pay the fine, the church wardens were to auction her off as an indentured servant for five years. If she were already an indentured servant, her sale was to take place after she had completed her current indenture so as not to deprive her current master of her labor. There was no punishment for the black father, but the mixed-race child
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
The Strange Career of Whiteness
●
Louise Newman
was taken by the church wardens and bound out as a servant until thirty years of age. If the white woman had married the nonwhite father (a free black or Indian man; enslaved blacks could not marry) then she was banished from the colony, along with her husband and child. Because of the banishment provision, there was now a severe disincentive for white men to marry free black women, but there was nothing to discourage white men from continuing to have sexual relations with enslaved black women. Any mixed-race offspring from the latter liaisons would continue to follow the status of the enslaved mother, just as it had previously under the 1662 law. The principles behind these rules persisted up through the Civil War with one notable change: in 1785 the Virginian legislature, perhaps inf luenced by the struggle for freedom embodied in the American revolution, expanded the category of whiteness, rather than further restricting it, by making it possible for someone who had less than one-quarter African ancestry to be considered white. (The fraction previously had been set at one-eighth African ancestry). 20 By the end of the eighteenth century in Virginia, the transition from indentured servitude to racialized slavery was complete. The presumption now was that white people were free and black people were enslaved, even though there were exceptions in both cases: there were black people who were free (because they descended from free blacks who had arrived as indentured servants, finished their contracts, and had freeborn offspring; and because some white slaveholders manumitted black slaves). There were also white people who were enslaved. This fact is much less widely appreciated but historians know of it because descendants of white women (who had less than a quarter Negro blood) petitioned for their freedom—not on the grounds that they were white—but on the grounds that their status should be changed to follow the status of their freeborn white female ancestor. Moreover, in Maryland, white female ancestry was not sufficient to prevent “white” people from being held in slavery: again historians cite the famous case of Irish Nell, a woman legally recognized as white, who had had to assume the slave status of her African husband in the seventeenth century, and whose eighteenth-century descendants petitioned for their freedom on the basis that their Irish great-grandmother was born a free white woman. Under slavery in the United States, miscegenation proliferated in the south, most notably between white men and enslaved African women. One of the vagaries of this strange career of whiteness, then, is that miscegenation between white men and nonwhite women, which in the seventeenth century had occurred in the context of the scarcity or absence of white women, was occurring in the eighteenth century not as a substitute for but in conjunction with marriage to white women. For white men, miscegenation became one of the privileges that stemmed from their race and sex; that is, one aspect of their control over the sexuality of all the women in their household: wives, servants, slaves, daughters. In the south, miscegenation was enmeshed in attitudes about white men’s right to sexually control all their female dependents, but also stemmed from their beliefs about slave women’s wantonness and promiscuity.
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
38
●
39
Another nuance worth noting is that miscegenation between white women and black men continued to occur under slavery as well; but when found out, white women found both their sexual and racial purity impugned. That is, they were stigmatized and ostracized in ways that white men were not—forced to abdicate their whiteness, if you will. At other times, white women relinquished their white privilege voluntarily by continuing to have sex with black men, sometimes leaving white husbands to reside in the slave quarters with their mixed-race children. Although these instances were rare, they are extremely intriguing, in particular for what they imply about white women’s willingness to abdicate their whiteness. Sometimes these reasons had to do with sexual desire; young white women left older white husbands to reside and sleep with younger and more attractive slaves. Finally, the history of Virginia enables us to consider how whiteness became, in the words of Peter Wallenstein, “a far more exclusive property by 1930 than it had been a half century before.” 21 As we have already seen, Virginia first used one-eighth but later adopted one-quarter as the fraction to be used to determine the boundary between black and white; that is, people were considered to be legally black (no matter how white they looked or behaved) if one of their grandparents was black. However, by 1910, Virginia was using the fraction of one-sixteenth to set the boundary between white and black (now if one had one great-great-grandparent who was black, then one was also designated as black); and by 1924, the state legislature went all the way, adopting what is now called the “one-drop rule,” which had the intended effect of re-categorizing as black, white people who had any black ancestry at all. This narrowing of the category of whiteness, along with the fact that laws banning interracial sex and marriage were much less harsh on blacks before the Civil War than they were to become afterward, does not mean that Virginia became more racist after the Civil War than it had been before. Rather it shows how the mechanisms delineating the boundary between whiteness and nonwhiteness differed in these two eras; how after slavery was abolished, law had to be increasingly employed to define whiteness and set the racial boundaries between who was white and who was not, punishing behavior that threatened that boundary. Historians have pointed out how varied and arbitrary such definitions of whiteness were, how individuals could be defined as white and live among whites in one State, but find themselves reclassified as black should they move to another. Clearly many white-looking people with black (or other nonwhite) ancestry passed into whiteness without authorities noticing or revoking their whiteness. However, in other instances, white people of mixed-raced ancestry (who thought of themselves as white) could find themselves disinherited if relatives saw fit to challenge their racial status. The history of whiteness becomes even more complicated when we examine how other States in other regions of the country—California or Texas, for example—constructed whiteness: anti-miscegenation legislation in western states banned marriages between white peoples and certain racial groups but
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
The Strange Career of Whiteness
●
Louise Newman
not others. 22 But rather than try to make sense of why certain intermarriages were permitted and others not, I want to stress a different, albeit related point: whiteness was a f luid, racially hybrid category from the very beginning of U.S. history. Yet, by the mid-nineteenth century, that historical reality was being forgotten: whiteness and mixed-raceness had become antithetical terms. By 1924, as the one-drop rule indicated, whiteness was formally declared to be a category of racial purity (no mixing whatsoever). Let me now skip forward to the twentieth and twenty-first centuries in an attempt to deal with the last of my themes: abdication. In the introduction to his book Colored White: Transcending the Racial Past (2002), historian David Roediger speculates about the future, wondering “whether and how nonwhiteness is possible, both for those currently identified as white and for those who may be . . . coerced into whiteness in the future.” 23 And in his conclusion, Roediger seems to suggest that one possibility is to continue on a path set by the twentieth century’s expansion of the category. As Roediger cautiously ref lects, there “is a temptation to regard the opening up of whiteness in the twentieth century as on balance a positive thing, certainly as preferable to continuing anti-immigrant racism against Greeks, Italians, Jews, Poles and others.” 24 While I think few scholars would dispute the point that expanding the category of whiteness to include certain European ethnicities under the term “Caucasian” is preferable to further restricting the category, two problems still persist: first, whiteness, even if more encompassing, continues to exclude those deemed to be outside its boundaries; second, and more significantly, expanding the category does not weaken the racist assumptions that lies behind the ideology of white supremacy, nor does it dismantle the system of racial inequality that currently exists. One obvious alternative—to abdicate whiteness or to become a “race traitor” 25 —is also problematic, if only because abdication for any particular individual isn’t really possible unless the white person is fully committed to passing in reverse. How does one shed one’s whiteness as one walks down the street, hails a taxi, goes into a grocery store, buys a house, or applies for a job? The call to individuals to abdicate their whiteness strikes me as premature, even disingenuous—a way for white people to have their cake and eat it too, to be white when it is advantageous to be white, and to be something else when there is something to be gained from not being white. Another alternative is to somehow abolish the category of whiteness altogether—empty it of its current meanings and remove the economic, political, and social advantages that it conveys. 26 This approach requires radical reforms in law, culture, politics, and the economy, to eliminate what Cheryl Harris has termed the “property of whiteness.” 27 Where to start? How can we, as historians, work to facilitate this goal? 28 Ironically, to abolish the category we must fully focus our attention on it. To allow whiteness to remain an unmarked norm makes it difficult, if not impossible, to develop truly effective antiracist forms of white identity. So, let us study how white peoples have been
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
40
●
41
seen by peoples of color. 29 Let us analyze, in great historical detail, the ways in which whiteness operates, along with other categories, such as gender, class, and religious affiliation, to empower particular groups and individuals and to disempower others.30 Let us continue to train ourselves to see whiteness as a category that imbues its subject with particular freedoms and privileges. Let us be willing to consider how white peoples, even well meaning ones, are complicit in sustaining a system of racial inequality. Let us understand why so much of white liberal discourse about race during the twentieth century has been “color blind”—that is, has espoused universalist ideals of racial equality (of the “all men are created equal” variety) and understand how this discourse has contributed to the strengthening of a political, economic, and social status quo grounded in racial inequities.31 A second step toward deconstructing whiteness has involved emphasizing ethnic or class differences among whites, in order to undermine any notion that white identity is a singular, or unifying, locus of privilege and power. For example, scholars such as Annalee Newitz and Matt Wray, who have studied the discourse of “white trash,” have argued that the term “is a way of naming actually existing white people who occupy the economic and social margins of American life, and it is a set of myths and stereotypes that justify their continued marginalization.”32 These recent theoretical and historical analyses of white trash have been extremely useful because they permitted the articulation of racial disempowerment and whiteness together. But again we need to be careful not to overextend this insight. Just because poor whites face economic discrimination and political ostracism in ways that middle-class whites do not, it does not mean that they do not also benefit from the privileges and freedoms that accompany whiteness in ways that poor blacks do not. Nor should we permit these analyses to undermine multiculturalist agendas such as affirmative action and social welfare programs in the mistaken belief that addressing class discrimination will also take care of racial discrimination. We know that whiteness needs to be understood as a social construction—a set of social meanings that are attributed to particular peoples at particular moments of time. Historicizing whiteness can help us understand better how that process of social construction took place—and keep our attention on the strangest element of this history: how race-mixing, a fundamental reality of the peopling of the United States, could be so forgotten, so marginalized, so stigmatized that it is not now widely known. For after all, the history of whiteness in the United States has been a history about how folks of different ethnic/ national origins have gone about forging a racial commonality. In sum, I encourage all of us working in the field today to find ways to historicize whiteness so that whiteness can no longer be taken for granted as an unmarked norm. I encourage us to find ways to historicize whiteness so that we come to appreciate how whiteness is a matter of place and context: an individual (or a group) can be more white, or less white than another individual or group, white in certain circumstances and not in others. I encourage us to find
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
The Strange Career of Whiteness
●
Louise Newman
ways to historicize whiteness so that we come to recognize the privileges that accompany whiteness, even while we remember that not all people designated as whites enjoy these privileges. Most of all, I encourage us to find ways to historicize whiteness so that we might work to change our perspective and our language and begin to speak of white peoples, all white peoples, as a mixed race; a product of miscegenation and assimilation, as indeed our history shows. To do otherwise is to perpetuate the myth that whiteness entails racial purity. Once it is well understood that white peoples in the United States are a mixed race, the category of whiteness will cease to have the meanings it now carries, and the abolition of whiteness—that utopian desire to abdicate whiteness— may then become possible. At that historical juncture, perhaps, we may be able to say with pride, along with Jane Lazarre, author of Beyond the Whiteness of Whiteness: Memoir of a White Mother of Black Sons (1996), “I am no longer white. However I may appear to others, I am a person of color now.”33
Notes 1. C. Vann Woodward, The Strange Career of Jim Crow (New York: Oxford University Press, third edition, 1974 [1955]). 2. Angela Woollacott, chapter two in this collection. 3. Irish Nell is well known to historians of this period. See Martha Hodes, White Women, Black Men: Illicit Sex in the Nineteenth Century South (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1997). 4. Gary B. Nash, “The Hidden History of Mestizo America,” in Sex, Love, Race: Crossing Boundaries in North American History, ed. Martha Hodes (New York and London: New York University Press, 1999), 20–21. 5. David Wallace Adams, Education for Extinction: American Indians and the Boarding School Experience, 1875–1928 (Lawrence, University of Kansas, 1995). 6. Peter Wallenstein, Tell the Court I Love My Wife: Race, Marriage and Law—An American History (New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2002). 7. Kathryn Burns, Colonial Habits: Convents and the Spiritual Economy of Cuzco, Peru (Durham: Duke University Press, 1999), 7 and 15–18. 8. Jennifer M. Spear, “ ‘They Need Wives’: Metissage and the Regulation of Sexuality in French Louisiana, 1699–1730,” in Hodes (ed.) Sex, Love, Race, 35–59. 9. Ibid., 40. 10. Ibid, 41–2. 11. Ibid., 50. 12. Richard Godbeer, “Eroticizing the Middle Ground: Anglo-Indian Sexual Relations Along the Eighteenth-Century Frontier,” in Hodes (ed.) Sex, Love, Race, 91–111. 13. Ibid., 92. 14. Ibid. 15. Quoted in ibid., 94. 16. Kathleen M. Brown, Good Wives, Nasty Wenches and Anxious Patriarchs: Gender, Race and Power in Colonial Virginia (Chapel Hill and London: University of North Carolina Press, 1996). 17. Kathleen Wilson, “Gender, Empire and Modernity in the Eighteenth Century,” in Gender and Empire: The Oxford History of the British Empire, ed. Philippa Levine (Oxford University Press, 2004), 14–45.
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
42
18. 19. 20. 21. 22.
23. 24. 25. 26. 27. 28.
29.
30.
31.
32.
33.
●
43
Hodes, White Women, Black Men, 30. Wallenstein, Tell the Court I Love My Wife, 16. Ibid., 19. Ibid., 4. Peggy Pascoe has made the intriguing suggestion that laws were applied most stringently to groups like the Chinese, Japanese, and Filipinos, whose men were thought likely to marry white women and applied less stringently to groups like Native Americans and Hispanics whose women were historically likely to marry white men. See Peggy Pascoe, “Race, Gender and Intercultural Relations: The Case of Interracial Marriage,” Frontiers 12, no. 1 (1991): 7. David R. Roediger, Colored White: Transcending the Racial Past (Berkeley, Los Angeles, and London: University of California Press, 2002), 26. Ibid., 240. Noel Ignatiev, “Abolish the White Race by any Means Necessary,” Race Traitor 1 (Winter 1993), http://racetraitor.org/abolish.html. Noel Ignatiev was among the first to propose this solution. Cheryl I. Harris, “Whiteness as Property,” Harvard Law Review 10, no. 8 (June 1993): 1707–91. The best discussion of abolishing whiteness that I have found is David Roediger’s “Introduction: From the Social Construction of Race to the Abolition of Whiteness,” in Towards the Abolition of Whiteness: Essays on Race, Politics, and Working Class History, ed. David Roediger (London: Verso, 1994), 1–17. There are hundreds of works, but David Roediger has edited an extremely useful anthology titled Black on White: Black Writers on What it Means to Be White (New York: Schocken Books, 1998), and this collection is a good place to begin. Hazel Carby’s Reconstruction of Womanhood, published in 1987, reminded white scholars that white people were also raced individuals: Hazel Carby, Reconstruction of Womanhood: The Emergence of the Afro-American Woman Novelist (New York: Oxford University Press, 1987). See Peggy Pascoe’s brilliant article, “Miscegenation Law, Court Cases and Ideologies of ‘Race’ in Twentieth-Century America,” Journal of American History 83, no. 1 (June 1996): 44–69. Annalee Newitz and Matthew Wray, “What is ‘White Trash’? Stereotypes and Economic Conditions of Poor Whites in the United States,” in Whiteness: A Critical Reader, ed. Mike Hill (New York/London: New York University Press, 1997), 172. Historical dictionaries ascribe the origin of the term “white trash” to black slaves; it originated as a black-on-white labeling practice of the early nineteenth century and was quickly appropriated by upper-class whites (by 1855). The terms white trash and poor white trash remained in use by blacks and whites throughout the nineteenth century. Today, the term white trash seems more widespread and is often used to denote an explicitly economic as well as racial identity. Jane Lazarre, Beyond the Whiteness of Whiteness: Memoir of a White Mother of Black Sons (Durham and London: Duke University Press, 1996), 135.
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
The Strange Career of Whiteness
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
This page intentionally left blank
“Whiteness,” Geopolitical Reconfiguration, and the Settler Empire in Nineteenth-Century Victorian Politics Leigh Boucher
I
n 1858, Victorian liberal parliamentarian Thomas McCombie published his History of the Colony of Victoria.1 This colony, in twenty years of startling historical change, had progressed from functioning as an administrative satellite of New South Wales to self-governing “independence” with complete (white) manhood suffrage. To describe a geopolity territorialized as a self- governing British colony only two decades after formal colonization began, McCombie deployed a narrative of manly liberal development to explain how “the bureaucratic style of government [had] been thrown aside and an entirely new order of things had developed. [Victoria had] passed from a perfect despotism . . . to the opposite point of extreme democracy.” 2 If, as James Levine argues, ideas about manhood provided the bedrock for dynamics of political incorporation in nineteenth-century British liberal thought, it should come as no surprise that McCombie’s historical “colonists” embodied a suite of manly and respectable political competencies.3 Furthermore, for McCombie, the Victorian colonist was discursively cohered via a spectral contrast with the “helpless aborigine [who] wasn’t fit to have a political existence”; as Uday Mehta so compellingly describes, access to the (hu)man rights and entitlements of liberal thought in the nineteenth century was always modulated by the idea of race. McCombie’s History thus mobilized ideas about racialized political competency to both concretize a particular ordering of territory and governance and to organize political entitlements within this colonial state.
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
CHAPTER 4
●
Leigh Boucher
Just under four decades later, George Turner, liberal premier of Victoria, attended the Colonial Conference in London. The contradictory rights of British subjects within the wider imperial polity cast a particular hue over this meeting. As the published proceedings obliquely expressed it, the various premiers and imperial administrators engaged in a “full exchange of views” about both colored immigration and practices of naturalization across empire.4 This was another episode in debates about the territorial purchase of an apparently racially unspecified imperial citizenship, the racial specificities of intra- colonial immigration regulations, and the relationship between territory and governance in the settler-colonial empire. For Turner, the unique racial arithmetic of the dominions’ colonies signified their status as “white man’s countries,” and the apparently racially unspecified entitlements of imperial subjecthood wouldn’t stop these colonies pursuing an immigration policy to maintain this racial congeniality.5 The liberality of the Australian colonies—and their inevitable federation—was enabled by the shared racial heritage of this Greater British world. Adding color to the white body politic would only serve to halt, if not reverse, their apparent progress. In the turn to transnational models of historical analysis, many historians have convincingly suggested that grammars of racial difference were constantly (re)constituted by their articulation across myriad imperial and international borders. Unsurprisingly, McCombie’s and Turner’s racial arithmetics necessarily “braided together” knowledge from across the settler empire. 6 If, as Marilyn Lake and Henry Reynolds suggest, a specifically “white” identity emerged as a global/transnational signifier in the late nineteenth century, it is also important to remember the types of borders this signifier crossed and the variegated transterritorial geopolitical communities it animated.7 At both these moments certain types of borders mattered, both materially and imaginatively. So too, historians of the British settler empire more broadly have recently begun to analytically entangle the histories of immigration and colonialism through the deployment of “whiteness” as a category of analysis in colonial contexts. In part, then, this chapter is an attempt to think through the different conceptual vocabularies of whiteness studies and postcolonial theory, and consider the implications of these distinct genealogies of theoretical knowledge. While paying attention to the constitution of the figure at the apex of racialized hierarchies of political and social entitlements is important, I propose an analytic distinction between the different discursive strategies that maintain these always-uncertain relations of power. The following discussion, then, is rather sharply divided. In the first sections, I consider how settler-colonial historians might engage in a project of writing a “transnational” history of whiteness that attends to different strategies of racialization and acknowledges both the historical contingency and importance of specific geopolitical configurations. In the concluding section, I will attempt to analyze the two historical moments that opened this chapter with these sets of theoretical, historiographical, and political concerns in mind. This historical analysis is animated by a central set of questions: how were
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
46
“Whiteness,” Geopolitics, and the Settler Empire
●
47
Whiteness and Postcolonial Studies: Correspondent Conceptual Models? Whiteness and postcolonial studies would seem to make happy bedfellows precisely because these fields share a commitment to denaturalizing dynamics of racialization and the relationships of power they enable. These two analytic domains have, however, developed as largely discrete conceptual endeavors with largely distinct genealogies of contestation and development. However, the category of whiteness offers historians interested in the relationship between settler-colonial rule, systems of racial difference, and settler identity tempting bounty; might it be a perfect analytic fit to the settler-colonial encounter? In fact, the “fit” between postcolonial analytics and settler-colonial contexts is not straightforward. As Antoinette Burton points out, the bulk of postcolonial “metatheory” has been produced about the African and South Asian contexts;8 the accepted genealogy of postcolonial thought, from anticolonial discourses in Africa and Asia to Said via psychoanalysis and Foucault, is oriented by a particular historical narrative of imperial expansion, control, contestation, and departure in those contexts. Perhaps equally emblematically, Ranajit Guha suggests the way around our understanding of empire as a “sort of machine” is to remember the “scale . . . of unimaginable and uncomfortable . . . immensities” that greeted the colonizers gaze.9 For Guha, and for much postcolonial theory, these immensities are as much corporeal as they are spatial; in the postcolonial theoretical imaginary, colonized bodies outnumber the colonizers. However, nineteenth-century settler colonies were gripped by anxieties directed toward an(Other) population. If the Manichean binary of colonizer/colonized was always and already racially coded as white/nonwhite, the specter of the nonwhite colonizer demanded a reconfiguration of strategies of racialization. Partha Chatterjee’s “rule of colonial difference” offers little insight into perhaps the most prominent racial problem of the late-nineteenth-century settler empire, namely, the nonEuropean immigrant.10 Perhaps because settler contexts are equally (if not more) characterized by anxieties about a mass of nonwhite colonizers as they are by anxieties about a mass of politically disruptive colonized subjects, or because the numerical relationship between white-settler and Indigenous bodies orients the scales of discursive attention in different ways, a body of Australian scholars have grafted whiteness studies onto a corpus of postcolonial knowledge. Precisely because whiteness studies gives analytic weight to the sovereign category of racialized power relations (much like the numerical relations of settler colonies) and often assumes a “gallery of racial others’ ” rather than a constitutive colonial binary
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
different geopolitical communities racialized within political debate, how did these dynamics of racialization modulate political and territorial entitlements, and what kinds of borders were energized and transgressed in these discursive eruptions?
●
Leigh Boucher
(which offers a way to consider how debates about nonwhite immigration and strategies of colonial racialization were mutually encoding), whiteness studies seems to offer a useful corrective to the limitations produced by the historicopolitical genealogy of postcolonial knowledge.11 One of the fundamental assumptions of this emergent analytic field— generated, perhaps, by its U.S. lineage—is that white racial power maintains its legitimacy through a ruthless absence of color and meaning. Precisely because, as Richard Dyer and others argue, whiteness maintains its privilege and power through a cultivated absence of color, culture, and ethnic specificity, the central analytic strategy of whiteness studies turns on an attempt to conceptualize a form of racialized identity that disavows any racial designation.12 Unsurprisingly, in Australia, the specter of the White Australia Policy looms large over the field of whiteness studies. There is, however, a dramatic analytic inconsistency within this analytic application; the production of a “white Australia” at the turn of the nineteenth century wasn’t characterized by an absence of color. Indeed, the whiteness of Australia was made coherent by a set of discourses that explicitly specified the Australian nation as a white political community. Jane Durie argues that scholars need to conceptualize “whiteness as a signifier of dominance.”13 I am suggesting, however, that we need to clarify whether this is a signifier generated by our conceptual vocabulary or by the contexts we are examining. If we analytically deploy the category of whiteness into contexts where it is designationally absent, who or what historical designation are we talking about? Drawing a clear distinction between whiteness as an empiricallyoccurring designation or as an analytic category might offer different ways of conceptualizing racialized privilege. There is no question that in certain times and places, political communities (minority or otherwise) have explicitly imagined themselves in a rhetoric of whiteness as a means of securing political incorporation.14 In contrast, however, political entitlements—particularly in the liberal tradition—have often been articulated in the universalizing tropes of western modernity. In this historically persistent modality of racialized thought, exclusion occurs via a racialized attribution of incompetence. Precisely because, as Judith Butler describes, “the human is understood differentially” on the basis of race, gender, sexuality, and class, “certain humans are recognized as less than human” and thus less able to access so-called human political rights.15 Whiteness in these contexts is most certainly an absence: it is the empty signifier “man.” Historical accounts of racialization might usefully distinguish between these strategies of specified privilege (which would necessarily incorporate a genealogy of the “white race” as an empirically occurring designation) and the moments when racialized hierarchies of political entitlement are maintained via “strategies of exclusion.”16 On the one hand, then, studies of empirical whiteness would interrogate its emergence as a specific designation with attendant specifying functions, whereby the attribution of whiteness explicitly legitimates specific privileges. On the other, studies of analytic whiteness would seek to bring to the surface the operation of power that operates via
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
48
●
49
racialized exclusions from political, emotional, or social norms. This is not to suggest, however, that I am arguing for naïve empiricism in the project of historicizing whiteness. Rather, I am asking for some historical specificity about the strategies and imperatives of racially coded power relations. Perhaps the different historiographic utilities of whiteness studies and postcolonial theory have been produced by their particular historical and political contexts. In the settler empire, however, perhaps neither/both of these frameworks “fit.”
Transnational Histories and Geopolitical Specificity Historians are, of course, interested in both the temporal and spatial specificities of their analytic domains; in one sense transnational histories are a corrective response to the historico-spatial limitations of the “narrative contract” between twentieth-century historical writing and the nation-state.17 For transnationally oriented historians, “bundles of relationships” and the complex f low of bodies, ideas, and capital across the globe have been fundamental to the production of particular economic, social, and cultural situations, national or otherwise.18 Indeed, as discourses about late-twentieth-century globalization have reverberated throughout the western academe, historians have sought to analyze a much longer genealogy of globalized change and exchange. Many historians, in an attempt to dislodge dominant narratives of U.S. exceptionalism, for example, have undermined the opacity of U.S. historical borders.19 Historians of the British Empire in particular have leapt aboard the “global” and transnational bandwagons to provide accounts of the British Empire as a globalizing force for transcolonial and transnational circulations of people, ideas, and capital.20 Catherine Hall and Sonya Rose, among others, argue that British “national and local [contexts] were imbricated in a world system fashioned by imperialism and colonialism.”21 Indeed, apparently “exceptional” British and U.S. national historiographies have been seriously challenged by transnational scholars who disrupt the assumption that Europe (and, for some, the United States) is always and already the birthplace of knowledge, culture, and power. Indeed, Dipesh Chakrabarty’s call to “provincialise Europe” was, in one sense, a call for a transnational history of modernity’s origin.22 These are important political and historiographical projects; they attend to the capacity of historical processes to unfold across and between national boundaries. Ironically, however, these nation-centered critiques tend to stabilize the very borders they are attempting to fracture. The “dance of flows and fragments,” to paraphrase Frederick Cooper,23 that many globally and transnationally oriented historians depict are conceptually stabilized by a critique of national analytic geographies. It is worth remembering, however, that the national-borders that transnational historians are incohering are relatively recent phenomena; this is a project determined to unmake the connection between historical writing and twentieth-century nation-states. At a fundamental level, histories of nineteenth-century empires challenge the nation-state
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
“Whiteness,” Geopolitics, and the Settler Empire
●
Leigh Boucher
both because of their unevenly “globalized” circulations of capital and culture, and because their constitutive borders weren’t always national ones. So too, the imagined and governed borders of these empires and colonies didn’t necessarily correlate with the boundaries of twentieth-century nation-states.24 Sometimes histories of colonialism aren’t transnational, they are simply imperial. As Duncan Bell argues, various modalities of political thought in the second half of the nineteenth century attempted to grapple with the present and future shape of the global order. 25 The territorial boundaries of the British Empire, both internally and externally, were a problem to be politically managed rather than a stable organizer of political, economic, and cultural exchange. Politicians in the metropole and the peripheries asked: what was the relationship between different forms of colonies? Which colonies should be geopolitically connected, and what form should this connection take? Which spaces of empire were to be “self-governed”? And who was the “self ” imagined as the constituency deserving of home rule? While twentieth-century discourses of national sovereignty have tended to animate notions of national imperviousness and autonomy (precisely the tropes transnational historians are arguing against), the borders of the nineteenth-century imperial world were managed by a recognition of their intra-imperial infirmity and undermined by their inter-imperial ambiguities. 26 These questions constituted an unstable ground upon which forms of political membership, belonging, and entitlement were managed by equally unstable grammars of racial difference. A transnational history of whiteness rightly decenters the nation, but also needs to attend to the ways in which the graduated sovereignties of intra-imperial borders both fostered certain networks of cultural circulation and forged discrete transterritorial communities that deployed racialized rhetorics to solidify certain boundaries whilst transgressing others. An important element of the transnational historical project, then, must include an attempt to think through how non-national (rather than transnational) forms of geopolitical management and exchange generated historical change. At particular moments specific kinds of borders did territorialize political possibilities in particular ways, even while, perhaps, drawing on circuits of knowledge production that stretched beyond them. While the tremendous political and intellectual purchase of transnational historical writing opens out the capacity to connect previously isolated historiographies, it is worthwhile to consider how geopolitical borders were imagined and policed. At certain moments nation-states certainly didn’t matter, not because their boundaries were transgressed, but because their borders didn’t exist or were understood differently. Questions about the relationships between race, territory, and forms of governance shaped the political careers of Thomas McCombie and George Turner. McCombie (in the 1840s and 1850s) and Turner (in the 1890s) were politicians crucially involved in the machinations of geopolitical reconfiguration in the nineteenth-century British Empire. While these two points of solidification seem to constitute a narrative of teleological political development—from
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
50
●
51
settlement to colony to nation—the outcomes of these debates were far from certain; the simple fact that campaigns were required to achieve them should unsettle any whiggish narrative of inevitable reform. Moreover, these colonial, imperial, and national territories and populations were, of course, continuously reimagined in the changing grammars of racial difference that reverberated through the empire throughout the nineteenth century. At a local level, the racial constituency of the Victorian population was both a figurative problem to be managed and a concrete policy to be developed; at the same time as McCombie and Turner described the Victorian body politic in transnationally produced grammars of race, they justified their respective racialized polices of political and territorial inclusion and exclusion. In the context of these globalized grammars of difference and their local articulations, McCombie and Turner also animated particular transterritorial political communities: communities that, inevitably, recast the racialized geographies of empire and the borders that managed its coherence. While McCombie was primarily concerned with the internal problem of Indigenous presence, for Turner the specter of the non-European immigrant threatened to unmake the racialized logics of territorial and political entitlement. It is to their respective contestations of geopolitical structure, their variegated imaginings of territorially bounded political communities, and their management of territorial and political entitlements that I now turn with the hope of paying attention to how their political projects were shaped by specific dynamics of racial specification or exclusion.
Racialization, Whiteness, and Imperial Geopolitics in Nineteenth-Century Victoria By the 1850s, McCombie was well known in Victorian political life. As the editor and primary contributor to one of the first Victorian daily newspapers in the 1840s, McCombie’s mode of Scottish liberalism cast a particular hue over the representational life of the colony. Together with a group of “Scots radicals,” who, as Cliff Cumming points out, were so crucial to the political machinations of early-colonial Victoria, McCombie earned a degree of infamy by mischievously nominating colonial secretary Lord Grey as the sole Melbourne representative to the Sydney based colonial government to demonstrate the apparent need for local self-rule. 27 The single other “problem” to occupy as much space in McCombie’s voluminous published and political output was an explicitly racialized one. Unlike his discussions of the character and political entitlements of the Victorian population, which displayed an apparent lack of racial specificity—but more on that in a moment—McCombie was an enthusiastic contributor to the construction of ethnographic knowledge about and policy regarding the so-called Aboriginal problem in colonial Victoria. As a perhaps largely forgettable parliamentarian, McCombie’s ambivalently recognized political significance in the reconfigured colony was produced by his continued attempts to obtain what he termed a “measure of justice” for the
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
“Whiteness,” Geopolitics, and the Settler Empire
●
Leigh Boucher
Indigenous population; he chaired the 1859 Select Committee appointed by the Victorian parliament to enquire into the condition and racial character of Victorian Indigenous population. 28 Eventually, his recommendations provided the framework for the first “protection” act in Victoria, an act that solidified their social exclusion and legislative discrimination in the colony. McCombie’s political and literary career, then, embodied the intersections between the constitution of racial knowledge, the management of racialized hierarchies of political entitlement, and the organization of territory within empire. Indeed, McCombie mobilized notions of humanitarian obligation that had a transterritorial heritage and orientation. In McCombie’s political rhetoric, temporally and geographically removed audiences provided support for his attempts to prompt the disbursement of “British duty.” McCombie reminded his fellow colonists that these audiences would judge the treatment of the Indigenous populations as a crucial indicator of the colony’s “character”; he had “been in correspondence with gentlemen of high attainment and from British societies in reference to it.” 29 However, McCombie was, in fact, in regular contact with the British Association for the Advancement of Science (BA AS), perhaps characterized by a much less “benevolent” set of concerns. McCombie had been a key correspondent for the BA AS in Victoria since the mid-1840s, and as editor of the Port Phillip Gazette published their ethnographic survey in an attempt to collect information about the “aboriginal race of Victoria.”30 McCombie would finally secure this ethnographic information in his role as select committee chair in the late-1850s and his ethnographic imagining of the “Victorian Aborigine” and “his” political (in)capacities circulated to other locations in the settler empire.31 The analytic connection so crucial to postcolonial theoretical vocabularies— namely between the production of myriad knowledges about colonized subjects and the maintenance of racially coded hierarchies of territorial and political entitlement—is not purely an analytic one. Indeed, McCombie himself represented the collection of ethnographic information about his racialized objects as a crucial project to assess the political capabilities of his Indigenous charges. Alongside his involvement with the Merri Creek School for Aboriginal Children, the collection of information about the local population provided him with the rhetorical means to “ascertain whether they [were] fit to have a political existence.” 32 The “experiment” of a small school for Indigenous children removed from their communities, in combination with this body of empirical knowledge about their racial character, would for McCombie “answer the long disputed question—is it possible to civilize the Aboriginal population of this continent?”33 The apparent failure of the school and McCombie’s ethnographic portraits suggested that even though “we have no reason to believe them incapable of learning . . . they must go through gradations before they can be placed on political equality . . . [they are not] a race capable of caring for themselves [at present].”34 In the 1850s, the apparent helplessness of the indigene provided even more rhetorical support for McCombie’s attempts to produce some kind of legislative
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
52
●
53
response to the Aboriginal problem. The colonists, with their recently acquired knowledge of Indigenous political (in)capacities, were newly obligated to figure out the best “means of alleviating their absolute wants.” 35 Furthermore, a fundamental indicator of their “social and moral progress towards . . . becoming a great and civilized” colony would be the treatment of the Indigenous population.36 Indeed, between the late 1840s and 1860, the internal management of political entitlement and the external geopolitical orientation of the colony of Victoria was drastically reorganized. Not only was the colony itself constituted as a coherent unit within the imperial geopolity—with a specific modality of sovereignty—but the hierarchy of political entitlement and enfranchisement within this polity was reordered. After the initial liberal reforms of the early1850s (with an already wider reaching franchise than “home”), the combination of the gold rush rebellion (and the subsequent extension of limited voting rights to the mining population) and the inf lation in land prices (with a unintentional effect of bringing the ten-pound franchise into the grasp of a previously excluded population), 37 the Victorian colony was characterized, according to McCombie, by an “early and extreme state of freedom.”38 The need for colonial self-rule had been a running theme through McCombie’s contributions to the Edinburgh Simmond’s Colonial Magazine throughout the late 1840s. His “sketches” of the colonial situation for the “pleasure of the readers at home” were littered with references to the “manly . . . respectability” of the colonists in Port Phillip.39 Indeed, in a context where the extension of the franchise in the metropole had been crucially modulated by racialized notions of middle-class respectability and political competence, McCombie mobilized precisely these tropes in order to argue for Victorian separation and independence.40 In his various arguments for a “new system of representation and government for the colonies,”41 McCombie stridently argued that these colonists were “ready for the duties of citizenship.”42 He continued, “the colonists see themselves as born for no higher aim than to till the soil, and this is that most honorable of callings.”43 In this way, McCombie engaged in a project of imagining the responsible character of the local population. The language he used to do so, however, was remarkable malleable. The population itself could be either “Anglo-Saxon,” “English,” “British,” “colonial,” or, very rarely, “white”, demonstrating a surprising lack of specificity about the racial status of the colonizer population. While Stoler has suggested that campaigns for colonial political reform “cultivated and clarified notions of whiteness” that were specific to the colonizers’ political rhetoric,44 in Victoria in the 1850s this clarification occurred, for the most part, via the attribution of racial characteristics to Other populations. When read in counterpoint to his representation of Indigenous political incapacities, there is little question that McCombie’s arguments for self-government hung upon a racialized conception of manly political competence. McCombie, then, was a Victorian politician whose dominant political concerns—namely, the relationship between the imperial center and its colonial periphery, and the treatment of the Indigenous population at that
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
“Whiteness,” Geopolitics, and the Settler Empire
●
Leigh Boucher
periphery— forced him to consider the ways in which these territorially bounded “populations” should be governed and geopolitically organized. Furthermore, the political rhetoric he deployed to agitate for a reorganization of the policies that managed these problems was, unsurprisingly, constituted by and constitutive of understandings of racial difference. There is no question that McCombie’s understandings of racial difference, geopolitical organization, and individual political entitlement were modulated by transcolonial and intra-imperial forms of knowledge and exchange; the genealogy of his ideas stretched elastically across various nodal points of empire. Most obviously, McCombie’s unwillingness to racially specify the “rights and duties of citizenship” in the colonies echoed the traditions of liberal practice in Britain and its tendency to disavow the racial specificity of their application; in the imperial polity, there was little space for the admission that British subjecthood was hierarchically modulated by race.45 However, the exigencies of settler-colonial rule demanded the brutal exclusion of specific populations from territorial and political entitlements; just as settler colonialism was organized by an exclusive claim to territory by the colonizer population and a subsequent denial of Indigenous sovereignty, so too, these racialized grammars of difference expelled the Indigenous populations from the rights and duties of citizenship within the liberal body politic. In a powerful combination of developmental theories of racial difference and hierarchies of political competence, McCombie endlessly deferred the prospect of Indigenous political inclusion. Equally importantly, however, McCombie deployed these ideas to argue for specific types of territorial integrity and autonomy. While the parameters of racial thinking and political recognition might have crossed borders, they were used, at least by McCombie, to reterritorialize empire and imagine populations within it. The granting of responsible government to the southeastern Australian colonies might have momentarily stabilized coterminous forms of sovereignty in this region (as self-governing colonies), but territorial reorganization continued to de/restabilize the imperial polity in the thirty years that followed. Geopolitical structure, political incorporation, and competing strategies of racialization formed an unstable figurative triad within which political debate about and across empire took place. Debates about the racialized reach of imperial citizenship and the possibilities of imperial/national federations reverberated in the political landscapes of empire throughout the nineteenth century. Indeed, public debate about Australasian federation began to gain momentum in the 1880s and the discussions of imperial federation that had reverberated at the edges of imperial policy making since the 1830s gained increasing support in the metropole and settler periphery from the 1870s.46 Debates about the reach and implicit racial codings of imperial citizenship similarly refused to disappear from the metropolitan political landscape.47 In a similar way, debates about irreconcilable strategies of immigration restriction and citizenship in the various colonial peripheries indicated the inevitable reconfiguration of imperial conceptions of political membership. This was precisely the nexus of political instabilities that shaped the debates of the colonial conferences in the 1890s and 1900s. George Turner, then
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
54
●
55
premier of Victoria, attended the colonial conference in 1897 uncertain of precisely the outcomes he could expect. Like McCombie he was centrally involved in the racially encoded debates about geopolitical structure and political inclusion over the course of his career as a liberal politician in Victoria (and Australia) between 1880 and the 1900s. And like McCombie, Turner was a figure whose political identity centered around notions of respectable, responsible liberal manhood; according to Alfred Deakin, “in dress, manner and habits [he was] exactly on the same level as the shopkeepers and prosperous artisans . . . [so too] in his uprightness, straightforwardness, domestic happiness and regularity of habits.”48 Importantly, Turner’s Victorian government recrafted the immigration laws of the colony in order to maintain the racial constituency of the body politic, and, like most representatives to the first Australian parliament in 1901, he firmly supported the exclusion of troubling racial others from the newly territorialized Australian nation-state. These imperial conferences must be understood, at least in part, as a response to increasingly “independent” forms of governance in the settlercolonial periphery. In one sense, however, they also drew on a language of imperial commonality and unity to draw colonial politicians back into the imperial fold. Turner, like most colonial politicians of the late nineteenth century, expressed a firm commitment to the continued (if not increased) unity of empire. Turrner’s major reservation was, unsurprisingly, that the geopolitical reconfiguration of the Australian colonies currently underway—namely, Australian federation—needed to be completed first.49 The overtures of Turner (and the colonial conference more broadly) toward closer imperial ties were crucially supported by a modality of racial thought that specified an Anglo-Saxon empire as a discrete cultural and geopolitical unit. Whether in pro-imperialist declarations of expansionist pride in the metropole, or explicitly racialized declarations of trans-territorial racial commonality in the colonies, the dominion empire garnered potent cultural and political purchase in the late nineteenth century. The solidification of the dominion empire as a coherent cultural and political figuration was made possible by figures such as Charles Dilke and John Seeley in the 1880s who, in specific ways, argued that the “expansion of England” into the settler colonies represented a fundamental expansion of the English state rather than the control of external territory by that nation. As Penelope Edmonds argues in this collection, Anglo-Saxonism provided a powerful connection between the settler colonies. As Robinson remarked at the Royal Colonial Institute in 1875 in his discussion of Natal, the settler colonies were, in their “political and social character . . . emphatically Anglo-Saxon [because they demonstrated] a love of manly work and responsibilities.”50 The AngloSaxonist specificity of British political and social life was crucial to Turner’s imagining of the Victorian population. While eschewing the works of liberal philosophy, he nonetheless carried the works of James Bryce—an ardent AngloSaxonist—with him to Victorian parliament. So too, his solution to the 1890s depression in Victoria was to create Anglo-Saxon “village-communities” in rural Victoria.51
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
“Whiteness,” Geopolitics, and the Settler Empire
●
Leigh Boucher
The alignment between settler and metropolitan political concerns was, however, less smooth than the descriptions of a great Anglo-Saxon settler empire might have implied. Moreover, political debates between the Australian colonies regularly demonstrated how a commonality of racial stock was no guarantee of political unity. However, there was one concern common to most institutions of devolved governance in the settler-colonial periphery, namely, how to maintain the racial integrity of the territorially bounded populations to which they apparently referred. As Robert Huttenback describes, politicians across the empire communicated with each other about this problem of racial constituency and various legislative solutions circulated around the imperial polity.52 At the colonial conference in London in 1897, the settler-colonial premiers almost uniformly asserted a commitment to keeping the dominions white. Indeed, in this forum—as in the local colonial debates—the subtleties and contradictions of Anglo-Saxonist thought were molded into that potent appellation of racial specificity. Like the emergent discourses of explicitly designated whiteness that had emerged in local colonial debates from the 1880s, the settler empire was politically imagined as a racially united set of territories and populations. As the premier of New Zealand expressed it in 1907, the settler empire was a “white man’s country” and the local governments would enact legislation to ensure they remained so.53 These assertions in 1907 were certainly not new; at the 1897 conference New South Wales premier George Reid and Turner affirmed that “we are sternly resolved there shall be a white Australia, and we feel the sooner we put up this barrier the better for all parties.”54 The discussions about immigration policies and restrictions at the colonial conference took place against the backdrop of a wider discussion of the ambiguities of citizenship legislation across empire. Indeed, Chamberlain had placed these items on the agenda precisely because the explicit racialization of political entitlements and immigration policies at the settler-colonial peripheries contradicted the myth of an unraced British subjecthood. Chamberlain proposed a simple solution to the problem: to adopt the “Natal formula” currently in operation in the South African colonies. As Turner assured his fellow Victorian parliamentarians upon his return in 1898, the language test would “only be applied to colored people . . . [there was] no need to apply the test to whites.”55 Turner’s confidence that territorial entitlement in Victoria should and would be specified by whiteness was echoed across the settler-colonial empire. Indeed, the legislative strategy for keeping the colonies white was, like the commitment to a white man’s country, passed along a trans-territorial network of politicians and officials. This community of colonizers was, however, both a network of discursive exchange and a political figuration in nineteenth-century imperial politics. In the context of a geopolitical structure constantly under revision, the dominion colonies were united by their racialized designations. The white man’s empire of the late nineteenth century, then, specified its racial privilege. Whether as Anglo-Saxon or white, colonial politicians mobilized discourses of racial specificity to manage the racial constituency of their
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
56
●
57
populations. This marked a significant shift for the dynamics of racialization in the settler-colonial polity. Rather than excluding specific races from political entitlement according to their apparent civilizational and political incompetency, the recognition of whiteness became a key modulator of territorial and political entitlement. Even while legislation apparently effaced racial specificity, the cultural purchase of discourses of whiteness made the racial exclusivity of territorial and political entitlements all too apparent.
Coda Whiteness studies and transnational historical analysis represent two of the more productive analytic developments in the historical interrogation of settler colonies in recent years. At the start of this chapter, I tried to suggest that there were concrete historical, political, and methodological reasons for this analytic purchase that, contrary to accusations of faddism or academic opportunism, offer historians of the settler colony important ways to orient their discussions of racialized hierarchies of power and entitlement. I have tried to suggest that the interventions of transnational models of historical analysis shouldn’t only apply to moments when national borders were crossed, but should also pay attention to the different kinds of borders that structured political debate, contestation, and imagination. While we might think that understanding the network of trans-territorial exchange in the nineteenth century requires attention to the ways in which borders were crossed, for many nineteenth-century politicians an interlocking and malleable system of coterminous sovereignties meant that some borders were more important than others; particular territories were bound together (and thus bordered) by the invocation of particular racial commonalities and by forms of imperial governance and sovereignty. We don’t need to “read against the grain” to understand how the southeastern Australian colonies were connected to other nodal points in the empire; these connections were fostered by a body of knowledge that asserted trans-colonial commonality. While whiteness studies asks us to pay attention to the silent and invisible category at the apex of racialized hierarchies of power, it is also important to remember that at specific moments, racialized entitlement operates via the specification of privilege rather than the exclusion of difference. Indeed, precisely because designations of whiteness emerge at particular times, this demands a more robust historicization of the dynamics of racialization.56 As Louise Newman’s chapter in this collection suggests, incorporations into and expulsions from the category of whiteness are complex processes. These forms of racialized hierarchy and entitlement differently managed the racial constituency of particular territorially bounded populations. Paying attention to these different strategies of racialization is important because they opened out different boundaries of inclusion and exclusion. When Thomas McCombie negated the possibility of Indigenous political inclusion in the 1850s, the dynamics of racialization he employed functioned
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
“Whiteness,” Geopolitics, and the Settler Empire
●
Leigh Boucher
to defer rather than reject Indigenous political rights. Precisely because the rhetorics of racialization he deployed were developmental and exclusionary, according to the logic (if not the intent) of his political rhetoric the Indigenous population of Victoria might, one day, have found a niche to move the system. This was precisely the niche that Indigenous political activists sought in the late 1870s. When the residents of Coranderrk mission station in Victoria engaged in a sustained protest at their treatment by the colonial state, a petition to the chief secretary from the Kulin argued that “we are not children for the board to do with as they like any longer.”57 These Indigenous petitioners thus demanded political and, indeed, existential entitlements in precisely the language of liberal inclusion and exclusion that marked out the category of settler in McCombie’s writings; they spoke as politically mature and civilizationally competent fellow humans. Because the racialized exclusions of settler-colonial entitlement had been written in a language of universally attainable competencies, Indigenous protestors could make concrete claims on these entitlements in precisely the language that had originally justified their exclusion. When political competency was designationally ambiguous, Indigenous peoples could make a claim upon it. However, the 1870s and 1880s were also the decades when the racially designated settler empire emerged as a coherent (although contested) geopolitical unit and potent figurative referent. In the face of a troubling population of non-European colonizers, colonial politicians mobilized emergent discourses of whiteness to manage settler-colonial populations. Political entitlement and competence—at least at this moment—were explicitly designated as white. It should come as no surprise, then, that when female suffragists argued for political incorporation, they deployed a rhetoric of racial specificity to do so; as they earned the right to vote it was simultaneously reconfigured as racially exclusive, and thus incompatible with Indigenous racial membership.58 Perhaps this explains that the Kulin claims weren’t recognized. I don’t raise these decidedly “local” examples of the politics of whiteness to undermine the trans-territorial imagination of whiteness I previously outlined. Rather, perhaps the most important task a history of undesignated racial privilege and/or specified whiteness can fulfill is to consider the implications these strategies of racialization had on local populations; lest we forget, the most productive critical maneuvers in historical writing have been generated by precisely those voices that white knowledge functions to silence.
Notes Thanks to Sarah Pinto, Steven Angelides, and Jane Carey for their insightful comments on earlier versions of this chapter. Vital research was made possible by a fellowship at the Centre for Research in History and Theory at Roehampton University. Thanks to John Tosh and the Centre for providing this invaluable opportunity. 1. Thomas McCombie, The History of the Colony of Victoria from Its Settlement to the Death of Sir Charles Hotham (Melbourne: Sands and Kenny, 1858). 2. McCombie, History, 1.
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
58
●
59
3. John Vincent, The Formation of the Liberal Party, 1857–1868 (London: Constable, 1966). 4. Maurice Ollivier, The Colonial and Imperial Conferences from 1887 to 1937 (Ottawa: Queens Printer, 1954). 5. “Report of a Conference between the Right Hon. Joseph Chamberlain, M.P. (Her Majesty’s Secretary of State for the Colonies) and the Premiers of the Self-Governing Colonies of the Empire, at the Colonial Office, Downing Street, London, S.W., in June and July 1897; with Appendices,” in Records of the Colonial Office, Commonwealth and Foreign and Commonwealth Offices, Empire Marketing Board, and Related Bodies (London: National Archives, 1897). 6. The phrase “braided together” is from Tony Ballantyne, Orientalism and Race (New York: Palgrave, 2006). 7. Marilyn Lake and Henry Reynolds, Drawing the Global Colour Line (Melbourne: Melbourne University Publishing, 2008), 1–15. 8. Antoinette Burton, At the Heart of the Empire: Indians and the Colonial Encounter in Late-Victorian Britain (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1998). 9. Ranajit Guha, “Not at Home in Empire,” Critical Inquiry 23, no. 3 (1997): 348. 10. Partha Chatterjee, The Nation and Its Fragments: Colonial and Postcolonial Histories (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1993). 11. The phrase “gallery of racial others” is from George Lipsitz, “The Possessive Investment in Whiteness: Racialized Social Democracy and the White Problem in American Studies,” American Quarterly 47, no. 3 (1995): 374. 12. For a discussion, see Ross Chambers, “The Unexamined,” in Whiteness: A Critical Reader, ed. Mike Hill (New York: New York University Press, 1997): 187–203. 13. Jane Durie, “Speaking the Silence of Whiteness,” Journal of Australian Studies 79 (2003): 138. 14. See, e.g., Theodore Allen, The Invention of the White Race (London; New York: Verso, 1994). 15. Judith Butler, Undoing Gender (New York: Routledge, 2004); emphasis in the original. 16. Uday Mehta, Liberalism and Empire (Chicago: Chicago University Press, 2003), 1–19. 17. The phrase “narrative contract” is quoted by Antoinette Burton, “Introduction: On the Inadequacy and the Indispensability of the Nation,” in After the Imperial Turn: Thinking with and through the Nation, ed. Antoinette Burton (Durham and London: Duke University Press, 2003): 1–25. 18. Eric Wolfe’s “bundles” are discussed in Ballantyne, Orientalism and Race. 19. Perhaps the best example of this kind of work in recent years is the collection of essays in Ann Laura Stoler, Haunted by Empire: Geographies of Intimacy in North American History (Durham: Duke University Press, 2000). 20. Phillippa Levine, Kevin Grant, and Frank Trentmann, Beyond Sovereignty: Britain, Empire and Transnationalism, 1860–1950 (Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan, 2007). 21. Sonya O. Rose and Catherine Hall, “Introduction,” in At Home with the Empire (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2006): 1–31. 22. Dipesh Chakrabarty, Provincializing Europe: Postcolonial Thought and Historical Difference (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2000). 23. Frederick Cooper, Colonialism in Question: Theory, Knowledge, History (Berkeley: University of California Press, 2005). 24. As Donald Denoon argues, the Australian colonies were often imagined as part of a wider pacific community that incorporated New Zealand. Donald Denoon, Settler Capitalism (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1983).
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
“Whiteness,” Geopolitics, and the Settler Empire
●
Leigh Boucher
25. Duncan Bell, Victorian Visions of Global Order (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2007). 26. For a discussion of the complexities surrounding economic treaties between European nations and their empires, see Luke Trainor, “The British Government and British Imperial Unity,” The Historical Journal 13, no. 1 (1970): 68–84. 27. Cliff Cumming, Port Phillip Presbyterians: The Continuing Scottish Connection (London: Australian Studies Centre, Institute for Commonwealth Studies, 1993), 8. 28. Select Committee Appointed to Enquire into the Condition of the Aborigines of Victoria (Melbourne: George Fairfax, 1858). 29. The Victorian Hansard Containing the Debates and Proceedings of the Legislative Council and Assembly of the Colony of Victoria: Volume 4 (Melbourne: W. Fairfax, 1856–1865). 30. Port Phillip Gazette, April 4, 1845. 31. For a discussion of this distribution, see Liz Conor, chapter fourteen in this collection. 32. Port Phillip Gazette, February 17, 1847. 33. Select Committee, 20. On civilization and Christianisation, see Port Phillip Gazette, May 25, 1847. 34. Port Phillip Gazette, December 18, 1849. 35. Select Committee, 1858, ii. 36. Quoted in The Argus, August 11, 1856, 5. 37. There is an extensive historiography that discusses the development of colonial democracy in Victoria. Usually, however, this material is much more concerned with the agitations of miners according the central concerns of Chartism: Paul A. Pickering, “A Wider Field in a New Country: Chartism in Colonial Australia,” in Elections: Full, Free and Fair, ed. Marian Sawer (Sydney: The Federation Press, 2001): 28–45; Marian Sawyer, “Peacemakers,” in Elections, 1–26. 38. McCombie, History. 39. Thomas McCombie, “A New System of Government and Representation for the Colonies,” Simmond’s Colonial Magazine and Foreign Miscellany (1845), 269; “Australian Sketches: No V—the Scenery and Society of New South Wales,” Simmond’s Colonial Magazine and Foreign Miscellany (1846), 326. 40. On the complex discourses of racialized middle-class respectability in the metropole in the 1830s, see Catherine Hall, “The Rule of Difference: Gender, Class and Empire in the Making of the 1832 Reform Act,” in Gender Nations: Nationalisms and the Gender Order in the Long Nineteenth Century, ed. Ida Blom, Karen Hagemann, and Catherine Hall (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2000): 107–35. 41. Thomas McCombie, “The Port Phillip Colonists and Their Superintendant,” Simmond’s Colonial Magazine and Foreign Miscellany (1849), 33. 42. Thomas McCombie, “Emigration and Prison Discipline Considered,” Simmond’s Colonial Magazine and Foreign Miscellany (1847), 462. 43. McCombie, “The Port Phillip Colonists and Their Superintendant,” 35. 44. Ann Laura Stoler, Carnal Knowledge and Imperial Power (Berkeley: University of California Press, 2002). 45. Sonya O. Rose and Keith McClelland, “Imperial Citizenship,” in At Home with the Empire, passim. 46. For a discussion of the various proposals for Imperial Federation, see Ronald Hyam and Ged Martin, eds., Reappraisals in British Imperial History (London: Macmillan, 1975).
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
60
●
61
47. Pat Thane, “The British Imperial State and the Construction of National Identities,” in Borderlines: Gender and Identities in War and Peace, ed. Billie Melman (London: Routledge, 1998): 29–45. 48. Alfred Deakin, The Federal Story (Melbourne: Robertson and Mullins, 1944), 49. 49. Ollivier, The Colonial and Imperial Conferences, 132. 50. J. Robinson, “The Relations of the Colonies to the Mother Country,” Proceedings of the Royal Colonial Institute 6 (1875): 59. 51. The Victorian Hansard Containing the Debates and Proceedings of the Legislative Council and Assembly of the Colony of Victoria: Volume 35 (Melbourne: John Ferris, 1866–1958): 423. 52. Robert Huttenback, Racism and Empire: White Settler and Colored Immigrants in Britain’s Self-Governing Colonies, 1830–1910 (London: Cornell University Press, 1976). 53. “Confidential Papers Printed in Connection with the Colonial Conference, 1907” from Records of the Dominions Division (Colonial Office, Dominions Division, 1907–1925) Series 1 National Archives, Kew, CO 885/18. 54. “Report of a Conference between the Right Hon. Joseph Chamberlain, M.P. (Her Majesty’s Secretary of State for the Colonies) and the Premiers of the Self-Governing Colonies of the Empire.” 55. The Victorian Hansard Containing the Debates and Proceedings of the Legislative Council and Assembly of the Colony of Victoria: Volume 37 (Melbourne: John Ferris, 1866–1958): 395. 56. The historical narrative that is emerging about “whiteness” in much scholarship— namely, that the “white race” solidified in some kind of global context in the late nineteenth century—certainly seems to fit with broader understandings of the “hardening” of racial categories of the course of the nineteenth century. What remains to be interrogated, however, is the relationship between these two developments. Did whiteness emerge in the context of this hardening, or, as a response to it? 57. Quoted in Diane Barwick, Rebellion at Coranderrk (Canberra: Aboriginal History Inc., 1998), 67. 58. See Patricia Grimshaw, “A White Woman’s Suffrage,” in A Woman’s Constitution? Gender and History in the Australian Commonwealth, ed. Helen Irving (Sydney: Hale and Iremonger, 1996): 179–85.
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
“Whiteness,” Geopolitics, and the Settler Empire
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
This page intentionally left blank
Whiteness as a Transnational Colonial Production
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
PART II
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
This page intentionally left blank
Traveling White Warwick Anderson
W
riting at the start of the twentieth century, the African American scholar W. E. B. DuBois seems deftly to have anticipated the current interest in imperial dimensions of racial formation and emergent strategies of whiteness. Soon after the annexation of the Philippines and Puerto Rico doubled the “colored” population under the sovereignty of the United States, DuBois observed: “This is for us and the nation the greatest event since the Civil War and demands attention and action on our part. What is to be our action toward these new lands and toward the masses of dark men and women who inhabit them?” If the problem of the coming twentieth century was the “problem of the color line,” then surely it would trace these imperial contours.1 It is within the setting of the American empire, then, that we must view DuBois’s comments some ten years later, when he discerned that the “world in sudden emotional conversion, has discovered that it is white, and by that token, wonderful.” The souls of these assertive, cosmopolitan white folks puzzled him—“not, mind you, the souls of them that are white, but the souls of them that have become painfully conscious of their whiteness; those in whose minds the paleness of their bodily skins is fraught with tremendous and eternal significance.” 2 What concerned him most were the souls of those whose proclamation of whiteness would come to etch more deeply the national and imperial color lines. DuBois was pointing to the emergent white man as a boundary subject, as a position for negotiating or asserting affinity and difference, as a point on the color line where respectability and disreputability could be determined. At the end of the twentieth century, Homi K. Bhabha echoed DuBois when he argued that whiteness was more a “strategy of authority” than any “authentic or essential ‘identity.’ ”3 James Baldwin also suggested as much when he wrote “there is, in fact, no white community”—rather there are specific ethnic communities, whether English, French,
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
CHAPTER 5
●
Warwick Anderson
German, or some European blend. “The people who, as they claim, ‘settled’ the country became white,” Baldwin continued, “because of the necessity of denying the Black presence, and justifying the Black subjection.”4 Although Matt Wray in Not Quite White urges us to examine the shifting boundaries of whiteness, he implies that they delimit some hinterland of an experienced or imagined white social category—when in fact the boundary might constitute the sum of it.5 It may be worth considering further the white man as a remarkably adaptable boundary subject, a livelier version of what so ciologists call “boundary objects.” According to Susan Leigh Star and James R. Griesemer, such “boundary objects are both plastic enough to adapt to local needs and constraints of the several parties employing them, yet robust enough to maintain a common identity across sites. They are weakly structured in common use, and become strongly structured in individual-site use.”6 The figure of the white man therefore might mark the color line at any number of national and imperial sites. At certain points, some folks can strategically deploy their whiteness without always living it. The concept of a “boundary subject” may help to explain how whiteness can so often seem invisible, or an empty signifier—even though, at unsettling sites and moments of anxiety, it will be asserted stridently or forcefully rebuffed.7 Whiteness can make boundaries work around the world (it is, after all, the color line), though it may make surprisingly little happen within them. It is thus strategically and analytically distinct from those other racial identifiers that have sometimes appeared synonymous, such as British and Anglo-Saxon. Neither of these figurations has proven quite so adaptable to places of racial conf lict and stress, neither is as robust and inclusive, nor possesses such a conveniently loose structure, as whiteness. Fixed more securely and less mobile, “British” and “Anglo-Saxon” in contrast have proven perhaps more powerful in framing ordinary subjectivity, organizing ethnic affiliation, and setting political agenda—at apparently bounded and comfortable sites, at least. To be sure, “white” can do all these things too, but mostly on the fraught margins of European advance. Accordingly, whiteness has been the most sensitive marker or tracer of social stress and anxiety in settler nations and colonies. 8 Within the boundary, behind the color line, it is generally invisible and sometimes even inoperable. What I want to do in this essay—in a very brief and tentative fashion—is explore the historical operations of whiteness, distinguishing its functionality from that of related categories such as British and Anglo-Saxon.9 How did whiteness travel? What did it do when it arrived? And what was it not able to do? At this stage, it is impossible to answer these questions fully. The best I can manage here is to sketch out some issues that might be addressed less abstractly and in more detail by future studies of whiteness as a boundary strategy.
*
*
*
We should begin by asking when and where “white” became such a telling point of distinction. For example, in the Australian colonies during most of the
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
66
●
67
nineteenth century, British was the preferred designation for the new settlers in the southeast of the continent, though recourse to white was not impossible. The colonizers found even cultivable territories and temperate climates could test British fiber and sensibility from time to time, though never really imperil them. Moreover, the native peoples seemed to be withering away with contact. Southern Australia thus appeared a proper place for British bodies and mentality. It was not until the 1880s, when the settlers came to feel serious competition from Asians and experience profound discomfort and unease in the tropical north of the country, that their whiteness was asserted far and wide. “White Australia” was a proclamation of possession in adverse circumstances, an extension of foreign bodies into liminal spaces, in conf lict with colored peoples. Additionally, the designation had the advantage of mobilizing the Irish and other Europeans on the frontiers of settlement. While not a properly British territory (with its very specific environmental furnishings), the Australian tropics might become subject to white control and occupation. In the insulated salons of Melbourne and Sydney, however, British and even Anglo-Saxon continued to command respect, as they implied for many a more complete way of life and form of government.10 Where did the white man emerge? His genealogy remains surprisingly obscure, but Theodore Allen suggests white identity served as a mark of social distinction, and a means of excluding African Americans, in colonial Virginia as early as the beginning of the eighteenth century. During the rest of that century, when Virginians ventured out to the frontier, they usually went as whites.11 Yet Alexander Saxton argues it was not until the early nineteenth century, with the rise of Jacksonian Democrats in the United States, that “white racism moved to center stage in Democracy’s legitimating synthesis”—to constitute the boundaries of the “white republic.”12 Certainly after the 1830s, “white” became a remarkably common self-representation in the southern United States and the Caribbean. It was a time of heightened racial conf lict in an environment that felt especially inhospitable to settlers of European ancestry. In tracing the origins of “white trash” to the southern states during this period, Wray might actually have located the beginnings of white as a popular identifier and positive self-marker.13 For centuries used as an adjective, white began to surface more commonly then as a noun connoting membership of a collective, or as a corporate type. By the 1850s, talk of the white vote and white blood abounded. Perhaps it was from the southern United States that whiteness spread like an invasive species. Marilyn Lake and Henry Reynolds have already documented the passage of one of the key technologies for differentiating whiteness, the dictation test, from Mississippi to South Africa and Australia during the latenineteenth century.14 It is likely that other racial ideas and practices followed similar routes. As DuBois suggested, many settler societies discovered and asserted their whiteness toward the end of the nineteenth century. Australia and South Africa were among the more prominent of the new ecological niches in which whiteness took root and f lourished. This white proliferation took place just as racial
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
Traveling White
●
Warwick Anderson
competition sharpened, as Asians and Africans increasingly resisted European colonialism, and as Europeans moved to occupy the tropics, a place once regarded as inimical to their type. At racial borderlands, the white man represented a pragmatically mutable and negotiable character. He became a boundary subject that generated speculation and discussion, literary, scientific, and popular. What sort of man was the white man? What were his capacities and limits? What did the white man want? For multiple parties, the white man proved good to think with.15 What whiteness offered in flexibility, it could withhold in definition and validation. Although whiteness was frequently conjugated with capacity for civilization, it did not usually imply any particular political program, in contrast to Anglo-Saxonism. For nineteenth-century literary travelers such as Charles Dilke, chasing “Greater Britain” around the globe, Anglo-Saxon heritage was a distinct package of hereditary propensities, institutions of government, and cultural forms, altogether readily differentiated from French or German styles.16 For President Theodore Roosevelt of the United States, Anglo-Saxons were inevitably vigorous, self-governing people, independent in character, and republican in sentiment.17 Anglo-Saxonism evidently exerted its own transnational attraction early in the twentieth century, as Paul Kramer and Marilyn Lake have argued so convincingly.18 Yet the appeal of this fairly standard assemblage in the United States and Australia rarely extended far beyond political circles in Boston, New York, Washington, and Melbourne. Anglo-Saxon worked less well in tropical Australia, or in colonies like the Philippines and Puerto Rico—in these places, white types were generically triumphant, so it seemed. Indeed, the same person might be robustly white in Darwin or Manila, and proudly Anglo-Saxon in Melbourne or New York—when necessary, of course, one could proclaim whiteness in these “civilized” cities too, but no one, so far as I can tell, ever tried the AngloSaxon gambit on racial borderlands. Whiteness functioned at sites of corporeal unease and conf lict with others to consolidate and justify claims of privilege and possession. It was a maneuver along perceived borders that betrayed anxiety, even as it displayed pride or confidence or solidarity. Whiteness became linked intimately to estimates of civic status, intellectual achievement, and moral standards. A form of registration and communicability, it was additionally a measure of sovereignty and a proxy for self-government. In this sense, the category worked as a gate-keeping mechanism, as a means of assessing and surveying white and nonwhite populations. Just as Anglo-Saxon recognized civic attainment, white implied certain broad embodied capacities and potential cultural trajectories, all available for political agitation, literary speculation, and scientific investigation. Whiteness allowed gradations of sovereignty, and provided an entry point for the disciplines required for the eventual achievement, or maintenance, of self- government. In thus summoning up and projecting subjectivity, it operated as a differentiated strategy for mobilizing and managing populations—white and other—across the world in the early twentieth century. Whiteness, in other words, emerged as an inherently biopolitical formation, organized around the discipline of individual bodies and the surveillance and regulation
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
68
●
69
of populations. Unlike other more expressive filiations such as Anglo-Saxon and Briton, whiteness operated most effectively through personal hygiene, restriction of contact, and control of sex and reproduction.19 These operations were adaptable enough to allow the production of probationary whites, liminal whites, degenerate whites, deferred whites, and part whites—they offered a precisely adjustable mechanism of sliding scales and thresholds. In some circumstances, southern Europeans or others from the Mediterranean littoral might be classed as whites; at other points, they could be excluded. Sometimes, women, children, the elderly, the poor, homosexuals, and others on the social margins might seem dubiously white, at risk of heading off course, threatening white prestige. In settler states like Australia, plans were made to absorb biologically the indigenous people into the white population, making them whites with a “dark strain” running through them.20 In other settings, absorption was rejected in favor of segregation, and miscegenation was officially forbidden.
*
*
*
The emerging white man often seems a melancholy or nostalgic character. Frequently a troubled soul, he could be more an itinerant than cosmopolitan, a figure of pathos as much as hubris. Emerging at sites of environmental stress and group conf lict, he appears always in f lux, always becoming, imperiled, anxious, messing up, and breaking down. Prone to outbursts of anger and frustration,and often full of self-pity and nervousness, the white man rarely presented a compelling model of self-possession and control. Few diasporic whites would have recognized as their own the commanding, hardy white bodies and mentalities that politicians and scientists were busily constructing and mobilizing. Take, for example, the “tropical white man,” invented in tropical medicine circa 1910. Scientists in laboratories in places like Manila and Townsville examined men of European descent, recording their body temperatures, testing their blood, assessing perspiration and metabolism and other physiological functions, to determine if whites would degenerate in conditions of moist heat. Physicians studied them working hard on the Townsville waterfront and performing drills on the Philippine parade grounds. Marshaled in hundreds of scientific papers, the scientific data proved for the first time that white male bodies were robust and resilient enough to thrive anywhere, even in supposedly “unnatural” and unsuitable places like the tropics. The white male body, usually belonging to some colonial functionary or nation-builder, was thus biologically projected across the globe around 1910. Yet few white men seem to have experienced any sense of durability and insulation, and fewer still would have recognized the masses of scientific data as representing their own frail bodies. Instead, most whites in the tropics continued to feel uncomfortable and vulnerable. They frequently succumbed to “tropical neurasthenia,” or went “troppo”, becoming nervy and unmanned in stressful circumstances. The tropical white body—to say nothing of its soul—was not one to be easily inhabited. 21
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
Traveling White
●
Warwick Anderson
The “sovereign” white subject found himself still longing for old attachments and familiar objects. Whiteness often proved a poor substitute for more homely connections and complex identifications. Melancholy, as Sigmund Freud suggested in the early twentieth century, is a pathological condition where the subject cannot accept a substitution for the loss of an object, leading to self-reproach, the expectation of punishment, and the impoverishment of ego.22 For all his assertion and pride, the white subject remained prone to nostalgia, dissatisfaction, and ambivalence—painfully conscious of his whiteness, as DuBois observed. Perhaps in gaining a world the white man might even lose his soul.
*
*
*
This essay is merely a preliminary reconnoiter of some of the English-language terms used to describe people of European ancestry in the late-nineteenth and twentieth centuries. It is an exercise in tracing what Leigh Boucher calls “empirical” whiteness in the “British world,” not in assembling its analytic framework. 23 As such, it demands attention to self-markers and self-images, and requires sensitivity to distinctions between cognate representations such as Anglo-Saxon and British. It argues, in an admittedly sketchy fashion, that the emergent white man might profitably be regarded as a f lexible, biopolitical boundary subject, as a disciplinary formation on racial borderlands—or, as Baldwin and Bhabha noted, a strategy of authority, not an essential identity. As racial formation, visible whiteness is a piquant example of what Edward W. Said called “late style.” Questioning the “accepted notion of age and wisdom in some last works . . . ref lect[ing] a special maturity, a new spirit of reconciliation and serenity [or] a miraculous transfiguration of common reality,” Said wondered: “What of artistic lateness not as harmony and resolution but as intransigence, difficulty, and unresolved contradiction?” 24 Whiteness proliferated late, after almost a century of the fabrication of different forms of racial classification and racialized practice; it began to fall apart within fifty years, in the senescence of race science; and to the historian it continues to demonstrate “intransigence, difficulty, and unresolved contradiction.” Of course, DuBois was saying all that as long ago as 1910.
Notes 1. W. E. B. DuBois, “The Present Outlook for the Dark Races of Mankind,” AME Church Review 17 (October 1900): 95–110, 95. 2. W. E. B. DuBois, “The Souls of White Folk,” Independent (August 18, 1910), 339. For an extended analysis of this article, see Marilyn Lake and Henry Reynolds, Drawing the Global Colour Line: White Men’s Countries and the Question of Racial Equality (Melbourne: Melbourne University Press, 2008). 3. Homi K. Bhabha, “The White Stuff,” Art Forum 36 (May 1998): 21. 4. James Baldwin, “On Being ‘White’ . . . and Other Lies” [1984], in Black on White: Black Writers on What it Means to be White, ed. David R. Roediger (New York: Schoken, 1998), 177–80, 178.
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
70
●
71
5. Matt Wray, Not Quite White: White Trash and the Boundaries of Whiteness (Durham, NC: Duke University Press, 2006). 6. Susan Leigh Star and James R. Griesemer, “Institutional Ecology, ‘Translations,’ and Boundary Objects: Amateurs and Professionals in Berkeley’s Museum of Vertebrate Zoology, 1907–39,” Social Studies of Science 19 (1989): 387–420. 7. On the invisibility of whiteness, see Richard Dyer, “White,” Screen 29 (1988): 44–64; and Ruth Frankenberg, White Women, Race Matters: The Social Construction of Whiteness (Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 1993). On the emptiness of whiteness, see Noel Ignatiev and John Garvey, eds, Race Traitor (New York: Routledge, 1996); and David Roediger, Towards the Abolition of Whiteness: Essays on Race, Politics, and Working Class History (New York: Verso, 1994). 8. Ann Laura Stoler, Race and the Education of Desire: Foucault’s History of Sexuality and the Colonial Order of Things (Durham, NC: Duke University Press, 1995); Anne McClintock, Imperial Leather: Race, Gender and Sexuality in the Colonial Conquest (New York: Routledge, 1995); and Radhika Mohanram, Imperial White: Race, Diaspora, and the British Empire (Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 2007). 9. The resort to “Caucasian” in the United States during the twentieth century adds further complications: see Matthew Frye Jacobson, Whiteness of a Different Color: European Immigrants and the Alchemy of Race (Cambridge MA: Harvard University Press, 1999); and Bruce Baum, The Rise and Fall of the Caucasian Race: A Political History of Racial Identity (New York: New York University Press, 2006). 10. Warwick Anderson, The Cultivation of Whiteness: Science, Health and Racial Destiny in Australia (Melbourne: Melbourne University Press, 2002). On Britishness, see Neville Meaney, “Britishness and Australian Identity,” Australian Historical Studies 32 (2001): 76–90; and Carl Bridge and K. Fedorowich, eds, The British World: Diaspora, Culture and Identity (London: Routledge, 2003). 11. Theodore W. Allen, The Invention of the White Race. Volume 2: The Origin of Racial Oppression in Anglo-America (London and New York: Verso, 1997). Winthrop D. Jordan (White Over Black: American Attitudes Toward the Negro, 1550–1812 [Chapel Hill, NC: University of North Carolina Press, 1968]) offers a similar chronology, but a different explanation. 12. Alexander Saxton, The Rise and Fall of the White Republic: Class Politics and Mass Culture in Nineteenth-Century America (London and New York: Verso, 1990), 386. Thus James Fenimore Cooper refers to red-skins and whites in The Last of the Mohicans (1826), which takes place near Lake Champlain, not the South. 13. Wray, Not Quite White. 14. Lake and Reynolds, Drawing the Global Colour Line. 15. This remains the case in recently independent countries such as Papua New Guinea, once an Australian territory. See Ira Bashkow, The Meaning of Whitemen: Race and Identity in the Orokaiva Cultural World (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2006); and Warwick Anderson, The Collectors of Lost Souls: Turning Kuru Scientists into Whitemen (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 2008). 16. Charles W. Dilke, Greater Britain: A Record of Travel in English-Speaking Countries During 1866 and 1867, 2 vols (London: Macmillan and Co., 1869). See also Penelope Edmonds, “White Spaces? Racialised Geographies, Anglo-Saxon Exceptionalism and the Location of Empire in Britain’s Nineteenth-Century Pacific Rim Colonies,” in Historicising Whiteness: Transnational Perspective on the Construction of an Identity, eds Leigh Boucher, Jane Carey, and Katherine Ellinghaus (Melbourne: School of Historical Studies, University of Melbourne, 2007), 363–74.
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
Traveling White
●
Warwick Anderson
17. Reginald Horsman, Race and Manifest Destiny: The Origins of American Racial Anglo-Saxonism (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1981); and Allen J. Frantzen and John D. Niles, eds, Anglo-Saxonism and the Construction of Social Identity (Gainesville: University Press of Florida, 1997). For Australia, see Peter Cochrane, “Anglo-Saxonness: Ancestors and Identity,” in Communal/Plural: An Inquiry into the State of Anglo-Saxonness within the Nation, eds, Ghassan Hage, Justine Lloyd, and Lesley Johnson (Kingswood, NSW: University of Western Sydney-Nepean, 1994): 1–16. 18. Paul Kramer, The Blood of Government: Race, Empire, the United States & the Philippines (Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 2006); and Marilyn Lake, “Whiteman’s Country: The Transnational History of a National Project,” Australian Historical Studies 122 (October 2003): 346–81. See also Lake and Reynolds, Drawing the Global Colour Line. 19. Stoler, Race and the Education of Desire. 20. Russell McGregor, Imagined Destinies: Aboriginal Australians and the Doomed Race Theory (Melbourne: Melbourne University Press, 1997); and Anderson, Cultivation of Whiteness. 21. Anderson, Cultivation of Whiteness; and Warwick Anderson, Colonial Pathologies: American Tropical Medicine, Race, and Hygiene in the Philippines (Durham, NC: Duke University Press, 2006). 22. Sigmund Freud, “Mourning and Melancholia” (1917) in Standard Edition of the Complete Works of Sigmund Freud, vol. 14, trans. and ed. James Strachey (London: The Hogarth Press, 1957). 23. Leigh Boucher, “ ‘Whiteness’ Before ‘White Australia’?,” in Boucher, Carey, and Ellinghaus (ed.), Historicising Whiteness, 16–25. 24. Edward W. Said, On Late Style: Music and Literature against the Grain (New York: Pantheon, 2006), 7.
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
72
The Question of Miscegenation in the Politics of English-Speaking Countries in the Early Twentieth Century Henry Reynolds
I
n 1902 James Bryce delivered the prestigious Romanes lecture in Oxford. He was a man of many talents—historian, jurist, and politician; world traveler and author of the magisterial study The American Commonwealth. Bryce’s lecture “The Relations of the Advanced and the Backward Races of Mankind” was inimitably global in its sweep and sober in its song. Bryce had, for many years, been considering the social consequences of the revolution in communications brought by the trains, steam ships, and the telegraph, and by the contemporaneous expansion of the great European empires. The situation was unprecedented. All parts of the world had been explored and all the races of mankind were in contact. The early twentieth century stood “eminent and peculiar in this” because it marked the completion of a process by which all the races had been effected, and all the backward ones placed in a more or less complete dependence on the more advanced. The new and radical closeness of contact—“so much closer and more widespread than ever in the past”—had created a unique situation. The, by now, inescapable contact between the races had created a “crisis in the history of the world,” which would “profoundly effect the destiny of mankind.”1 What Bryce feared was that there would be extensive intermarriage or “race fusion” of the kind already seen in the Ottoman Empire and the South American republics. He had no doubt that miscegenation was bad in principle and perilous in practice. The mixture of whites with “negroes” and “hindus” seldom showed “good results.” The two general conclusions from global experience were that when “races of
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
CHAPTER 6
74
●
Henry Reynolds
The matter ought to be regarded from the side neither of the white race nor of the black, but of the future of mankind at large. Now for the future of mankind nothing is more vital than that some races should be maintained at the highest level of efficiency, because the work they can do for thought and art and letters, for scientific discovery, and for raising the standard of conduct will determine the general progress of humanity. If therefore we were to suppose the blood of the races which are now most advanced to be diluted, so to speak, by that of the most backward, not only would more be lost by the former than would be gained by the latter, but there would be a loss, possibly an irreparable loss, to the world at large. Given the universal importance of the matter of racial mixture Bryce concluded that it might be doubted “whether any further mixture of Advanced and Backward races is to be desired.” 2 Bryce’s lecture was seen as a masterful statement of widely shared views and was cited many times over during the following twenty years. As an American admirer phrased it, the Englishman had put his finger on the complex problem of how to facilitate global cooperation without promoting “the mongrelisation of the world’s people.” 3 There was a very broad consensus in the Englishspeaking world during the first part of the twentieth century about the danger of miscegenation linking scholars in many disciplines—biology, geography, sociology, anthropology, and political science. The power of this conviction can be illustrated by the difficulties faced by the proponents of racial equality when attempting to counter the charge that their views implied that interracial marriage would necessarily follow.4 Gustav Spiller was the driving force behind the Universal Races Congress in London in 1911 and delivered a paper entitled “The Problem of Racial Equality.” Having taken what for the time was a radical stand if favor of equality, he felt obliged to provide a preemptive answer to presumed critics, observing: Is it, then, to be inferred, we may be asked in astonishment, that we should encourage indiscriminate miscegenation, free intermarriage between white, black and yellow races? The inference need not be drawn, since we may say that, just as in parts of Europe, for instance, Protestants, Catholics and Jews live together amicably while yet intermarrying very rarely, so the equality of the human races might be universally acknowledged, and yet intermarriage not take place.5 The English colonial administrator and explorer Sir Harry Johnston reacted in a similar way in an article, “Race Problems in the New Africa,” published in
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
marked physical dissimilarity” intermarried the average offspring was apt to be “physically inferior to the average of either parent stock” and far below the mental level of the “superior.” Bryce believed that he had identified a question that had implications for the future of civilization itself, declaring that:
●
75
Foreign Affairs in 1924. Having proposed a series of liberal reforms for the continent, he too felt the need to address expected criticism, writing: “Then comes the crucial question: ‘So you approve of miscegenation?’ Well, no I cannot say I approve of our losing our pink and white Complexions and our position as the highest race.”6 So great was the fear of miscegenation that reformers who wanted to liberalize racial policies felt it necessary to disown any suggestion that they favored intermarriage. This was well illustrated in the case of the liberal South African scholar R. F. A. Hoernle. In an article “Race Mixture and Native Policy” published in 1934, he explained how fear of miscegenation lay at the heart of his country’s policies of segregation. Their proponents, he observed, argued that: If we civilize the native and let him acquire skill, if we let him enter the learned professions, we cannot in the end refuse him political equality if we grant him political equality, we cannot deny him social equality; if we grant him social equality, we cannot in the end avoid race-mixture. Fear of race mixture, Hoernle observed, was at the heart of South African racial policies. But in order to break down the structure of segregation the “barrier against race mixture” was “worth maintaining,” because while the visceral fear of intermarriage persisted no change was possible.7 The Canadian scholar T. H. Boggs adopted a similar position. While wishing to advance the position of “Orientals” in British Columbia and grant them all the rights of citizenship, he was convinced that this could only be done if there was “rigid exclusion of all Oriental immigration, even to the total future exclusion of all Asiatics.” Boggs believed that exclusion was essential “so long as racial assimilation through intermarriage is not feasible.”8 Another telling illustration of the persistence of fears of intermarriage between “races” considered “widely separated” can be found in the caution adopted in the 1930s by some of the leading advocates of racial tolerance. In their celebrated book We Europeans, published in 1935, J. S. Huxley and A. C. Haddon attacked the vast “pseudo-science” of racial biology associated with the rise of Nazi Germany. They declared that “for existing populations, the word ‘race’ should be banished.” But the two crusaders were not so sure about “very wide crosses” that they feared might give: “biologically ‘disharmonious’ results in later generations, by producing ill-assorted combinations of characters. Characters may be unduly exaggerated by the coming together of unfamiliar genes, or characters adapted to one environment may be forced to co-exist with those adapted to another.” 9 J. B. S. Haldane was another prominent and outspoken opponent of German racial policies who continued to be doubtful about the wisdom of “racial crosses,” writing in 1938: I would urge the extraordinary importance of a study of the effects of race crossing for the future of the British Commonwealth. Until such a
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
Miscegenation in English-Speaking Countries
76
●
Henry Reynolds
Hostility to miscegenation was most pronounced in the United States and reached a peak of intensity in the early twentieth century. By the early 1930s twenty-nine of the forty-eight states had legislated to prohibit the marriage of whites and Afro-Americans. Many of the western states also banned marriages between Europeans and Asians. These laws were enforced with punitive jail sentences. The prominent American scholar E. B. Reuter observed in 1931 that popular opposition to miscegenation was equally strong in those states without specific legislation. He reported the comments of a senior Massachusetts official who observed that interracial marriages were rare “chief ly because of the violent opposition of the public” toward them.11 The Swedish sociologist Gunnar Myrdal found that white opposition to miscegenation was almost universal. It was held “commonly, absolutely, and intensely.” During his travels around the country he found that “nine out of ten liberal minded, cosmopolitan northerners were opposed to amalgamation” even in the future, fearing it as producing an “inevitable deterioration.”12 South Africa developed its own homegrown policies against miscegenation. Prime Minister Jan Smuts declared in 1917 that there must be “no intermixture of blood between the two colors.”13 His political rival, J. B. Herzog, was equally determined to prevent the emergence of a “mixed race by miscegenation.”14 In 1927 Herzog’s government passed The Immorality Act that banned sexual contact across the color line. In Australia a series of Protection Acts passed in the different states between 1897 and 1916 gave government officials power to control Aboriginal marriages. The detail of policies differed but there was a general understanding that controls should be exercised in such a way that would protect White Australia. Immigration restriction, introduced in Australia, Canada, New Zealand, and the United States between 1901 and 1924, was motivated by fear of miscegenation, expressed volubly and insistently by members in all the relevant legislatures. When the Immigration Restriction Act was introduced in the first session of the new Australian federal parliament in 1901, it inspired speeches from almost all the members and senators. Many of them spoke of the dangers of racial mixture, of their horror of “piebald populations,” of “mongrels,” and corruption of the blood. A typical comment was made by G. B. Edwards who declared that: Racial contamination would proceed from the lowest strata of society and filter up until it comes to the highest, permeating the whole nation. That is what we have to fear. I do not fear that my people or my friends will mix with the inferior races, but I do fear that my descendants, in
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
study has been accomplished, and it is a study that will take generations to complete, we are not, I think, justified in any dogmatism as to the effect of race crossing. It may not be desirable to forbid it, but there can be very little reason, I think, to encourage it as between the widely different races of mankind.10
Miscegenation in English-Speaking Countries
●
77
A colleague observed that nothing good ever came from “hybridization,” which resulted in offspring that reproduced the “vices of both parents with the virtues of neither.” It was essential to preserve “our civilization intact and uncontaminated” safe from a “mongrel breed.”16 Immigration restriction legislation in the sister Dominions, New Zealand and Canada, was greeted with similar sentiments and comparable rhetoric. There was little opposition in either parliament, the consensus being that miscegenation presented a grave danger to both race and nation. New Zealander E. Kellett explained in 1920 that the evil of the “mixed breed” could be seen on nearby Pacific islands and “it was time we stopped it absolutely.” J. Q. Young declared that amalgamation tended to weakness, a fact verified by “half-breed raced all over the world.” His colleague J. A. Hannan argued that any racial intermarriage would inevitably lead to a “sad deterioration of the race.”17 In May 1922 members from British Columbia moved a motion in the Canadian House of Commons calling for the exclusion of all “oriental Aliens.” In providing his justification W. G. McQuarrie explained that Chinese and Japanese migrants could never be assimilated because it could only be accomplished with intermarriage. But the differences between the races made that objective unthinkable: it was unnatural and had never produced anything but degradation for both parties.18 Following the debate on McQuarrie’s motion the House passed legislation that virtually closed Canada to non-European migration. The U.S. Immigration Act of 1924 was more complicated than earlier legislation in Canada and New Zealand and was constructed around a quota system. But the sentiments and the rhetoric were familiar. In a paper prepared for the House Committee on Immigration, the New York lawyer John Trevor argued that non-European migrants presented an insoluble problem for the Republic. Either they would form separate colonies within the nation or there would be assimilation by way of miscegenation, which was a perversion of the natural law and therefore an “unthinkable solution to the problem.”19 All the evidence we have suggests that politicians in the United States and the British Dominions were ref lecting public opinion in their intense hostility to miscegenation. This was certainly the conclusion reached by two American scholars who carried out extensive interviews in California in 1913 at the height of the crisis brought about by the decision of the State legislature to prohibit the purchase of land by Japanese migrants. H. A. Millis, professor of economics at the University of Kansas, carried out a survey of opinion in the state addressing public meetings and conducting extensive private interviews. He found that the primary objection to the Japanese was the conviction that they could never be assimilated and that any suggestion of intermarriage was totally unacceptable. 20 The other survey was conducted by the missionary-scholar Sidney Gulick. He too found that the question of land ownership was secondary to the
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
future days of the Commonwealth, may be largely contaminated with them.15
●
Henry Reynolds
matter of miscegenation. After conducting many interviews he concluded that the strongest cause of white hostility was the fear of intermarriage and the production of “mongrel offspring.” Any thought of miscegenation was “utterly obnoxious.” In his many conversations the clinching argument was invariably the retort: “Would you let your daughter marry a Jap?” This, Gulick observed, was the” storm-centre of our problem.” 21 The way in which the land question in California was entwined with the problem of intermarriage was well illustrated by evidence given to a state government enquiry into Japanese ownership of farms. The most inf luential and much quoted testimony was provided by a local white farmer Ralph Newman, who declared: Near my home is an eighty-acre tract of as fine land as there is in California. On that land lives a Japanese. With that Japanese lives a white woman. In that woman’s arms is a baby. What is that baby? It isn’t white. I’ll tell you what that is. It is the germ of the mightiest problem ever faced in this state; a problem that will make the black problem of the south look white. All about us the Asiatics are gaining a foothold. They are setting up Asiatic standards. From whole communities the whites are moving out. Already the blood is intermingling. 22 When they were talking about domestic politics for local audiences the politicians in the English-speaking countries were both frank and emphatic about their fear of miscegenation. But when it came to international relations matters were much more complicated. At the very time that racial fears grew the public avowal of them became more problematic. The sudden and unexpected rise of Japan, emphasized by the treaty with Britain in 1902 and the defeat of Russia in 1905, made it very difficult to talk openly about racial inferiority. The same was true with the rise of colonial nationalism and particularly in India. With racial inferiority out of reach as a justification for immigration restriction in international exchanges the argument became one of the danger of mixture itself even among “ races” equal in every other way. The peoples of Asia and Europe should mix but they must not mingle. Rudyard Kipling’s famous lines “East is east and west is west and never the twain shall meet” were quoted, and indeed misquoted, many times over. In his 1912 book Empires of the Far East Lancelot Lawton noted that the famous lines were brought forth “a thousand times” to support the view that the mingling of the “races of East and West and a fusion of their blood is neither possible or desirable.” 23 American politicians faced the problem of dealing with the international consequences of domestic racism at the time of the Californian schools crisis in 1906. Relations with Japan were tested when the San Francisco city authorities banned Japanese children from local schools. President Theodore Roosevelt was anxious to maintain good relations with the Japanese and he was shocked by the vulgarity of West Coast rhetoric. But he came to appreciate the fears and
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
78
●
79
sentiments of the Californians. In his autobiography he declared that it was “eminently undesirable that Japanese and Americans should attempt to live together in masses.” They should keep from “mass contact and intermingling.” 24 Prominent members of the American foreign policy establishment were more open in their views about miscegenation. A. C. Coolidge was a distinguished Harvard scholar and founder of the prestigious journal Foreign Affairs. A series of lectures delivered at the Sorbonne was collected and published in 1908 as The United States as a World Power. In a chapter on “Race Questions” he dealt with the problem of intermarriage, which had been thrown into sharp relief by the new international status of the Japanese who had shown themselves to be “virtually one of the white peoples.” But despite that the “instinct of aversion” was always there. Coolidge was by no means sure that the children of parents “racially far apart” would be “satisfactory.” He argued that the popular view that people of mixed descent inherited the worst characteristics of both parent races had much to commend it and drew on the experience of breeding dogs. “May not something of the same sort hold true of human beings,” he asked, rhetorically? 25 Australian leaders, suffering from a perpetual sense of both isolation and vulnerability, were even more anxious than their American counterparts about the threat of miscegenation. W. M. Hughes told an American audience in 1924 that “east and west could not meet and live together as one people.” It was, he explained: “our thought as it is plainly yours that they must only mingle, if they must, and not blend, for blending would spell disaster to our race, disaster, grim and irretrievable.” 26 At the time Hughes was out of office with greater freedom to voice his fears and anxieties. But such concerns were expressed in a vital meeting between Australian and Japanese officials in 1919. Major E . L. Piesse, director of the Pacific Branch in the prime minister’s department, met with senior officials of the Japanese Foreign Office on Christmas Day. Although arranged by the British Embassy it was one of the most important meetings in Australian diplomatic history. Among a number of issues discussed Piesse referred to the “racial aspect” of the bilateral relations, while wondering if perhaps it was “impertinent even to mention this aspect.” There was, he observed, “no question about the relative superiority of races.” Few Australians would presume to say they were justified in thinking that the “white race was superior to the coloured races of the Far East.” However there were differences and Australians thought that at the present state of the world it would be better if the two peoples did not mix racially. In justifying the White Australia policy Piesse explained: If the Japanese came to Australia in large numbers, they would either marry with their own women, or they would inter-marry with us. If they inter-married, we do not know what the racial result would be. It might be an improvement on either side of the racial stock or it might not and the results are so doubtful we prefer not to try the experiment. 27
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
Miscegenation in English-Speaking Countries
●
Henry Reynolds
The British officials who accompanied Piesse were taken aback by his frankness. They had long realized that the racial composition of the Empire required them to proclaim that the common law and British administration was color blind, however, much practice gave the lie to these protestations. In private it was a different matter. In 1908 at a time when the future of South Africa was being discussed the outgoing secretary of state for the colonies, Lord Elgin, wrote a private letter to his successor, the Earl of Crewe. Referring to the question of race Elgin remarked that it was often argued that the native subjects of the king “had a right to same treatment as all others” But he doubted whether “nature itself so permits.” He observed that Britain had absorbed many European migrant communities and their descendants had “become as ourselves.” But, he wondered: is that conceivable in the case of coloured races? So far as I know, there is no historical foundation for any such proposition. I do not venture to propound any scientific theories, but the half-caste (certainly the Eurasian in India in my experience) does not hold out much expectation of favorable results. 28 Far more extreme views were embodied in a Foreign Office memo on the subject of “Racial Discrimination and Immigration” written in 1921. While some economic issues were involved, in essence the question was a racial one, the official F. Ashton-Gwatkin declared: The white and coloured races cannot and will not amalgamate. One or the other must be the ruling caste; and countries where the white population is in power have determined from a sure instinct for self preservation that they will never open their doors to the inf lux of a coloured race, which might eventually become dominant. 29 Such discussion of questions of race and miscegenation was commonplace in the English-speaking world in the first forty years of the twentieth century, fortified by both expert commentary and popular prejudice. There is no doubt the fear of racial mixture influenced domestic legislation and foreign policy decision making. But by the 1940s it became increasingly difficult to publicly promote such ideas. The example of Nazi Germany was a stark warning to any public figure still using the racial rhetoric of the 1920s and the rapid de-colonizing of the non-European world presented a definitive challenge to lingering ideas of white supremacy. It is much harder to determine when ideas have become discredited or outmoded than when they are in the ascendancy. Often they simply slip almost unnoticed out of public discourse. Those who cling to them are increasingly less likely to publicly express ideas that have manifestly become unfashionable. They are likely to be kept for diaries or confidential correspondence. This was true of Henry Stimson, the U.S. secretary for war, who wrote in his diary in
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
80
Miscegenation in English-Speaking Countries
●
81
Notes 1. Bryce was responding to the same developments in the work of Charles Dilke and his old friend and contemporary Charles Pearson that Penelope Edmonds discusses in chapter eight of this collection. 2. James Bryce, The Relations of the Advanced and Backward Races of Mankind (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1902), 26. 3. Ulysses G. Weatherly, “Race and Marriage,” The American Journal of Sociology 15, no. 4 (January 1910): 450. 4. Warwick Anderson shows in chapter five of this collection that there was considerable critical debate on the question in the 1920s and 1930s. But expert opinion was one thing, political discourse quite another. 5. Gustav Spiller, “The Problems of Race Equality,” in Papers on Inter-Racial Problems: Communicated to the First Universal Races Congress (London: P. S. King, 1911), 30. 6. Harry H. Johnston, “Race Problems in the New Africa,” Foreign Affairs 2, no. 4 (June 1924): 611–12. 7. R. F. Alfred Hoernle, “Race-Mixture and Native Policy in South Africa,” in Western Civilization and the Natives of South Africa, ed. I. Schapera (London: Routledge, 1934), 264–5. 8. Theodore H. Boggs, “The Oriental on the Pacific Coast,” Queens Quarterly 33, no. 2 (1926): 320. 9. Julian S. Huxley and Alfred C. Haddon, We Europeans (London: Cape, 1935), 281. 10. J. B. S. Haldane, Heredity and Politics (London: Allen & Unwin, 1938), 172. 11. Edward Byron Reuter, Race Mixture: Studies in Intermarriage and Miscegenation (New York: McGraw-Hill, 1931), 101. 12. Gunnar Myrdal, An American Dilemma, second edn (New York: Harper & Row, 1962), 57. 13. W. K. Hancock, Smuts: The Fields of Force 1919–1950 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1968), 113. 14. L. E. Neame The History of Apartheid: The Story of the Color War in South Africa (London: Pall Mall Press, 1962), 40. 15. Commonwealth Parliamentary Debates, vol. 4 (1901), 5922. 16. Ibid., 5140. 17. New Zealand Parliamentary Debates, vol. 187 (1920), 905–24. 18. Canadian Parliamentary Debates (1922–3), 497 and 1509. 19. John Bond Trevor, “Japanese Exclusion: A Study of the Policy and the Law,” in The Reference Shelf, comp. Julia Emily Johnson, 111, no. 4 (New York: The H. W. Wilson Company, 1925), 125–6. 20. Harry Alvin Millis, The Japanese Problem in the United States (New York: Macmillan, 1915), 251–2. 21. Sidney L. Gulick, The American Japanese Problem: A Study of the Racial Relations Problem of the East and West (New York: Scribners, 1914), 118.
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
1942 that social equality was unattainable because of the “impossibility of race mixture through marriage.”30 Sir Allen Lascelles, principal private secretary to King George VI, noted in his diary at much the same time that: “No white man can endure the thought of mixed marriages; and nature herself condemns such marriages by the almost invariably inferior quality of their fruits.” 31
●
Henry Reynolds
22. Elk Grove Citizen, April 10, 1913, in E. P Penrose, Californian Nativism: Organized Opposition to the Japanese, 1890–1913 (San Jose: R & E Associates, 1973), 93. 23. Lancelot Lawton, Empires of the Far East, 2 vols (London: Grant Richards, 1912), 2: 748. 24. Thoedore Roosevelt, Theodore Roosevelt: An Autobiography (London: Macmillan, 1913), 414. 25. Archibald Gary Coolidge, The United States as a World Power (New York: Macmillan, 1908), 64–6. 26. The Los Angeles Examiner, June 1, 1924. 27. Edmund Leolin Piesse. Papers. Australian National Library. MSS 882/5/41, 49–50. 28. Ronald Hyam, Elgin and Churchill at the Colonial Office, 1905–08 (London: Macmillan 1968), 377. 29. Foreign Office. MS 371/6684, October 10, 1892. British National Archives 4212/223/23. 30. Christopher G. Thorne, Allies of a Kind: The United States, Britain, and the War Against Japan, 1941–1945 (London: Hamish Hamilton, 1978), 6. 31. Quoted in Richard Davenport-Hines, “Marques Mes Mots,” Times Literary Supplement, February 9, 2007, 24.
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
82
“Being Thankful for their Birth in a Christian Land”: Interrogating Intersections between Whiteness and Child Rescue Shurlee Swain, Margot Hillel, and Belinda Sweeney
“
R
eading whiteness into texts that are not overtly about race,” Ruth Frankenberg writes, “is essential if we are to disrupt whiteness as the unchallenged racial norm.”1 The sources that provide the basis for this chapter, the literary and journalistic output of the nineteenth-century child rescue movement, were certainly not overtly about race. They were, however, engaged in constructing and consolidating whiteness in both Britain and its settler colonies. It is the central role of such literature in the imperial dissemination of ideas about whiteness that we aim to investigate. Thomas Barnardo (1854–1905), founder of Dr Barnardo’s Homes (1868), Thomas Bowman Stephenson (1838–1912), founder of the Wesleyan National Children’s Homes (1869), Edward de Montjoie Rudolf (1852–1933), founder of the Anglican Waifs and Strays Society (1881), and Benjamin Waugh (1839–1908), secretary of the National Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Children (1889) constitute a distinct subset of the much larger group of English “slummers” identified by Seth Koven. 2 They were supported in their literary effort by an array of writers, artists, and poets who incorporated the genre of child rescue in their work. Their poignant tales were published alongside the regular offerings of staff writers and contributors, and filled the pages of the journals month after month.
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
CHAPTER 7
●
Swain, Hillel, and Sweeney
Designed primarily to guarantee continuing financial support, Barnardo’s Night and Day and Young Helpers’ League Magazine, Stephenson’s Children’s Advocate, Highways and Hedges, and Our Boys and Girls, Rudolf ’s Our Waifs and Strays and Brothers and Sisters, and Waugh’s The Child’s Guardian and the Children’s League of Pity Paper also functioned to alter national sensibilities in relation to poverty and race. Hence they constitute a rich archive for scholars interested in the concept of whiteness. The message that they propagated was repeated and expanded in denominational and secular journals published across the Empire, and a range of books written for children around the child rescue theme. With titles such as The Little Orange-Sellers, Lost! Stolen! or Strayed!, or Froggy’s Little Brother, these books and the articles and poems found in the magazines were intended to cultivate pity and charity in their child readers. Much has been written in recent years about the role of the ref lexive relationship between empire and metropole in the shaping of English identity. Nineteenth-century missionary organizations played a key role in this process. The reading material they circulated to an increasingly literate public and the rallies they organized constituted a popular form of amusement.3 Their inf luence, however, spread well beyond the realm of entertainment and disseminated representations of foreign peoples to a substantial proportion of the population. “Religious belief provided a vocabulary of right,” Catherine Hall has argued, “the right to know and to speak that knowledge, with the moral power that was attached to the speaking of God’s word. One of the issues on which they spoke was what it meant to be English.”4 In this discourse race was foundational.5 Moving freely between the self and the other, missionaries had an inf luence “at home” equally significant to that which they had in the countries to which they were sent. 6 Their literary production was critical in shaping ideas about race, constituting “a significant part of the popular material, which helped shape and sustained imperial mythologies well into the twentieth century.” 7 Narratives of the conversion of “the sons and daughters of the heathen” served also, Frank Prochaska has argued, to convert “the sons and daughters of England . . . to an imperial Christianity.”8 Metaphors derived from foreign missions provided a vocabulary that could be readily transferred to the endeavors of missionaries at home.9 To Victorian Evangelicals, Susan Thorne has argued, home and foreign missions were not separate undertakings but “two fronts of the same war, separated by geographic happenstance and little more.”10 By constituting the residents of the inner city as a foreign, heathen other, urban missionaries increased the attractiveness of their endeavor while undermining any radical potential it might have had. In the process, they rendered “evangelical religious practice a principal site at which conceptions of race emanating from the colonies entered metropolitan social discourse.”11 The child rescue movement was located within this larger missionary enterprise, its leaders active participants in “the competition for bodies and souls” both at home and abroad.12 Despite a primary concern with conversion and salvation, their literary output also functioned to ref lect and
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
84
●
85
refract developing discourses around poverty and race. The images of otherness derived from the foreign missions were readily applied to the children of the poor.13 The cultural practices of the other constituted by child rescuers—such characteristics as starved, emaciated bodies, speech, and physicality—operated also to affirm the Empire, and the privilege implicit in whiteness. This privileging of whiteness is particularly apparent in much of the children’s literature of the time, which reinforced notions of the “might and right” of the British Empire while exhibiting a fascination with the other.14 Juvenile literature operated as a critical adjunct to the British imperial enterprise. Nationalist and imperial thinkers privileged the “ideological incorporation of boys and girls over the incorporation of the adult citizenry.” The literature that they produced offered working-class youth a valued place in imperial England while simultaneously constructing social and political limits to such service.15 And yet, central to such literature was the representation of the other. In her analysis of colonial children’s literature, Kathryn Castle contends that imperial subjects constituted the “ ‘supporting cast’ in the story of Empire,” the depiction of which gave substance to assumptions about class hierarchy in the metropole.16 Thus while missionary literature constructed Englishness for adult and child readers, children’s literature offered to young readers ways of relating to the imperial world. R.M. Ballantyne, an occasional contributor to Our Waifs and Strays, is best known for his book The Coral Island (1911), a work in which images of indigenous people are used to justify imperialism and missionary endeavor. Indeed, the subtitle, Views of Missionary Endeavour, makes Ballantyne’s intentions clear. The English travelers, young men and boys, are portrayed as heroes and rescuers, civilized and manly in contrast with the “savages.” After being told that the practice of the sacrifice of babies in the south sea islands ceases when missionaries arrive, one of the protagonists declares “God bless the missionaries . . . God bless and prosper the missionaries till they get a footing in every island of the sea.”17 Harry’s Trip to India (n.d.), written by the Rev. W. J. Wilkins, is less a boy’s own adventure than Ballantyne’s work, but shares a call to young men to become missionaries. Here, the non-Christian other is represented to young British readers as misguided, contemptible, often risible, and at times unredeemable. Much is made of the sacrifices many Indians, frequently children, have made in order to embrace Christianity, sacrifices that move Harry “to yield up heart and life to his Saviour and Lord.”18 As a missionary, Harry plays his part in rescuing the heathen in far-f lung parts of the British Empire. The rescue is constructed as both spiritual and corporal, with orphaned Hindu children a particular target. “Hinduism finds it easier to allow a child of unknown caste to die than to provide it with a home,” the reader is informed. “And so it happens that little helpless children are left to perish until the police find them, and hand them over to Christians to care for. In this way, many have been rescued from death, and have early learnt of a loving father in Heaven.”19
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
Whiteness and Child Rescue
●
Swain, Hillel, and Sweeney
Bessie Marchant, a prolific and popular writer with a larger female audience than either Ballantyne or Wilkins, was widely read in all English-speaking countries. Richard Phillips argues that Marchant “challenged constructions of ‘women’s place’ in order to challenge the male domination of emigration to British colonies and dominions.” 20 However, like other British evangelical writers, she does not contest notions of white superiority, or the importance of bringing Christianity to the heathen. In her books, white immigrant children are depicted as inherently superior to the “natives.” In The Black Cockatoo (1910), the white children scare a group of Western Australian Aboriginal men away from the “cultivated land” on the “plantation” belonging to the children’s parents. 21 White settlement and this sense of ownership are justified by “using” land neglected by the Aborigines. Adult Aborigines are infantilized both as an inherent part of, and support for, the dominant white ideology. The book also contains a strong message about the desirability of “rescuing” indigenous children. When the two white children are captured by “cannibal blacks,” they are helped to freedom by an Aboriginal girl who, as she already speaks some English, is seen as a redeemable other. She receives what the Religious Tract Society clearly constructs as the ultimate reward and is Christianized, allowing her to make the final rejection of her culture and her people. She is, we are told, “quick to respond to the teaching she received,” thus justifying the generosity of the gift bestowed on her. 22 The mixture of dread and fascination with the “other” was a feature of “imperial” literature. Fear of white capture and enslavement by natives were prominent themes, pointing to persistent anxieties about the inversion of the “natural order.”
Barnardo and the Beni-Zou-Zougs “Who is Hadj Ali Ben Mahomet, and what has he or his Troupe to do with US this happy Christmas Day?” 23 So began the feature article in the December issue of the Barnardo magazine Night and Day in 1881. The story, “as bad as any of African slavery,” was set “in the City of Constantinople itself,” where the British consul-general and an English barrister had discovered “a number of London boys in the care of an Arab acrobat, who treated them as though they were really his slaves” and called upon Barnardo for help. Readers were promised a thrilling story of the rescue from “heathenism and misery” of “these innocent little fellows . . . through the all-powerful influence which England exercises.” The boys, Night and Day alleged, were “living in a state of slavery,” “isolated from the world.” “They were ill-treated,” “not allowed to speak their native language, which most of them had consequently totally forgotten,” “had no regular communication with their parents,” “received no sort of education,” and “had never been inside a Church or a Mosque,” nor ever “received wages.” 24 Legally indentured by their parents, they had been touring for some time, but their situation was constituted as abusive because it reversed established racial hierarchies. “The Arabs do hardly anything but domestic work . . . The English boys did all the rest.” The celebratory tone of the article is undiminished by its ending, even
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
86
●
87
though only eight of the fourteen boys agreed to be “rescued” and they included “a half-caste, dark skin and curly black hair aged 13 ½,” and “a fair-haired boy and an unmistakable cockney . . . the most backward of the lot.”25 Why was the story of the Beni-Zou-Zougs so important to Barnardo and his supporters? The answer lies in consideration of the concept of whiteness, and in particular the performance of whiteness, the means by which “white dominance is rationalized, legitimized, and made ostensibly normal and natural.” 26 Whiteness, Ruth Frankenberg argues, has three elements: “a location of structural advantage, of race privilege . . . a place from which white people look at ourselves, at others, and at society . . . [and] a set of cultural practices that are usually unmarked and unnamed.” 27 Mission literature consistently encoded the practice of whiteness, designating non-European societies as “primitive” in order to reinforce the superiority of the colonizing nation.28 Nevertheless, the comparisons that missionaries drew between the urban poor and the “tribes” and “savages” of foreign lands did not undermine the implicit advantages of whiteness that the former enjoyed. 29 It was the threat posed to white privilege by urban degeneracy, rather than the denial of privilege, that such comparisons signified. “Whiteness,” Catherine Hall writes, “should mean order, civilization, Christianity, separate spheres and domesticity, rationality, modernity and industry. Those moments when whiteness meant something quite other were terrifying.”30 Hall’s understanding of whiteness offers a theoretical approach to the multiple problems of the Beni-Zou-Zogs. Their status as the slaves of a nonwhite man, performing rather than issuing orders, threatened to undermine whiteness generally; a threat only partially erased by the fact that they had not been reduced to doing the domestic work, a role consigned to Hadj Ali Ben Mahomet’s Arab employees.31 Susan Thorne has argued that shared whiteness within missionary organizations operated against concern for the English poor. The “characteristics that the poor had in common with the missionary middle classes—their race or national heritage—constituted benefits whose apparent waste served merely to indict more fully their possessor.”32 However, for children, it was this shared whiteness that rendered them salvageable. The English poor, it was argued, were less vicious than the poor of other nations. Redemption, however, was dependent on removal. English children, depicted as victims of “bad or unfortunate parentage,” could be reformed by traveling to an improved environment where the advantages attached to whiteness could once again f lourish. 33 Even the somewhat ambiguous Beni-Zou-Zougs, safely ensconced in Barnardo’s East End shelter, could be transformed into sturdy British laborers.34
Travel Narratives In the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, the increasing facility of travel collapsed the physical and imagined space between metropole and colony. The leaders of the child rescue movement took advantage of this new mobility, blending travel with fund-raising as a way of spreading their message throughout the Empire. In turn, their reports refracted images of Empire to
10.1057/9780230101289 - Re-Orienting Whiteness, Edited by Katherine Ellinghaus, Jane Carey and Leigh Boucher
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Feng Chia University - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-04
Whiteness and Child Rescue
●
Swain, Hillel, and Sweeney
their supporters at home. In recent years, postcolonial scholars have explored the ways in which travel writing functioned both to assert the moral superiority of Englishness and to construct an English ethnic identity. 35 Such writing, Mary Louise Pratt argues, “treats the relations among colonizers and colonized, or travelers and ‘travelees,’ not in terms of separateness or apartheid, but in terms of copresence, interaction, interlocking understandings and practices, often within radically asymmetrical relations of power.” 36 But the “otherness of colonized persons was neither inherent nor stable; his or her difference had to be defined and maintained.”37 Travel writers joined missionaries in this gatekeeper function, encoding the inferiority of the other “through the filter of a set of assumptions . . . which seesawed on the ambivalence of racial difference.” 38 Such discourses provided a readily accessible vocabulary for both urban missionaries and social investigators seeking to develop new understandings of the rapidly changing inner cities at home. “The valorization of the black other�